{"id": "2d0fbc6f-spread-n25-k3-t0.92-s0", "instance": {"stops": ["S01", "S02", "S03", "S04", "S05", "S06", "S07", "S08", "S09", "S10", "S11", "S12", "S13", "S14", "S15", "S16", "S17", "S18", "S19", "S20", "S21", "S22", "S23", "S24", "S25"], "parcels": [{"id": "P01", "stop": "S01", "volume_dl": 23}, {"id": "P02", "stop": "S01", "volume_dl": 30}, {"id": "P03", "stop": "S02", "volume_dl": 58}, {"id": "P04", "stop": "S02", "volume_dl": 259}, {"id": "P05", "stop": "S03", "volume_dl": 9}, {"id": "P06", "stop": "S04", "volume_dl": 8}, {"id": "P07", "stop": "S05", "volume_dl": 92}, {"id": "P08", "stop": "S05", "volume_dl": 39}, {"id": "P09", "stop": "S06", "volume_dl": 5}, {"id": "P10", "stop": "S07", "volume_dl": 10}, {"id": "P11", "stop": "S07", "volume_dl": 95}, {"id": "P12", "stop": "S07", "volume_dl": 46}, {"id": "P13", "stop": "S07", "volume_dl": 179}, {"id": "P14", "stop": "S08", "volume_dl": 21}, {"id": "P15", "stop": "S09", "volume_dl": 179}, {"id": "P16", "stop": "S10", "volume_dl": 53}, {"id": "P17", "stop": "S11", "volume_dl": 179}, {"id": "P18", "stop": "S12", "volume_dl": 79}, {"id": "P19", "stop": "S13", "volume_dl": 14}, {"id": "P20", "stop": "S14", "volume_dl": 57}, {"id": "P21", "stop": "S15", "volume_dl": 95}, {"id": "P22", "stop": "S15", "volume_dl": 179}, {"id": "P23", "stop": "S16", "volume_dl": 104}, {"id": "P24", "stop": "S16", "volume_dl": 6}, {"id": "P25", "stop": "S17", "volume_dl": 157}, {"id": "P26", "stop": "S17", "volume_dl": 157}, {"id": "P27", "stop": "S18", "volume_dl": 9}, {"id": "P28", "stop": "S18", "volume_dl": 19}, {"id": "P29", "stop": "S19", "volume_dl": 5}, {"id": "P30", "stop": "S20", "volume_dl": 133}, {"id": "P31", "stop": "S21", "volume_dl": 37}, {"id": "P32", "stop": "S22", "volume_dl": 133}, {"id": "P33", "stop": "S23", "volume_dl": 133}, {"id": "P34", "stop": "S23", "volume_dl": 79}, {"id": "P35", "stop": "S24", "volume_dl": 26}, {"id": "P36", "stop": "S25", "volume_dl": 57}, {"id": "P37", "stop": "S25", "volume_dl": 57}], "vans": 3, "capacity_dl": 1023, "travel_s": [[0, 2115, 2174, 2182, 2043, 2031, 2252, 2193, 2357, 2143, 2005, 2102, 2180, 2044, 2055, 2081, 2388, 2047, 2002, 2100, 2314, 2000, 2009, 2282, 2063, 2137], [2165, 0, 265, 148, 137, 261, 263, 154, 368, 249, 140, 90, 191, 256, 163, 172, 406, 65, 187, 206, 325, 154, 226, 296, 169, 240], [2231, 298, 0, 290, 286, 333, 64, 298, 169, 238, 206, 248, 226, 322, 312, 253, 200, 193, 256, 91, 142, 303, 375, 161, 148, 213], [2249, 155, 290, 0, 195, 319, 288, 81, 394, 349, 240, 191, 200, 319, 221, 269, 455, 165, 290, 306, 351, 212, 284, 318, 269, 321], [2193, 133, 271, 200, 0, 205, 269, 211, 375, 391, 238, 218, 198, 205, 106, 268, 406, 164, 241, 362, 332, 97, 169, 299, 268, 302], [2112, 254, 390, 318, 179, 0, 388, 329, 493, 306, 110, 336, 316, 54, 109, 247, 530, 283, 143, 263, 450, 107, 154, 418, 226, 299], [2297, 277, 66, 271, 267, 392, 0, 282, 105, 304, 272, 314, 207, 388, 293, 319, 137, 260, 322, 157, 78, 284, 356, 97, 214, 228], [2265, 170, 306, 65, 211, 338, 307, 0, 409, 364, 259, 209, 218, 338, 236, 290, 473, 181, 306, 322, 369, 227, 299, 337, 284, 337], [2411, 390, 180, 385, 381, 505, 114, 393, 0, 418, 386, 428, 321, 502, 407, 433, 117, 373, 436, 271, 105, 398, 469, 189, 328, 342], [2243, 265, 248, 338, 353, 344, 312, 346, 417, 0, 218, 242, 354, 334, 347, 173, 449, 187, 268, 171, 390, 348, 401, 351, 134, 194], [2056, 280, 227, 251, 208, 127, 291, 259, 396, 196, 0, 154, 345, 116, 129, 134, 428, 100, 56, 153, 369, 161, 212, 350, 116, 190], [2174, 131, 266, 176, 223, 276, 264, 184, 369, 258, 149, 0, 192, 265, 249, 178, 401, 74, 199, 215, 326, 240, 311, 294, 178, 297], [2342, 216, 239, 201, 207, 331, 238, 210, 343, 359, 270, 300, 0, 331, 232, 298, 375, 195, 320, 331, 300, 223, 295, 268, 261, 270], [2127, 252, 390, 319, 180, 77, 389, 330, 494, 298, 102, 337, 317, 0, 101, 236, 526, 283, 135, 255, 451, 122, 169, 419, 218, 292], [2115, 151, 289, 218, 79, 109, 287, 226, 393, 328, 132, 236, 216, 98, 0, 286, 424, 182, 163, 285, 350, 76, 173, 317, 248, 320], [2163, 182, 256, 259, 273, 264, 346, 273, 452, 136, 138, 162, 275, 254, 267, 0, 489, 108, 188, 179, 409, 268, 368, 376, 141, 219], [2427, 420, 213, 412, 408, 528, 141, 426, 92, 439, 402, 444, 348, 518, 434, 452, 0, 396, 458, 287, 133, 425, 497, 216, 355, 369], [2100, 74, 241, 151, 166, 202, 239, 162, 344, 184, 75, 54, 167, 191, 204, 107, 382, 0, 125, 141, 301, 205, 256, 269, 104, 178], [2063, 288, 277, 301, 213, 137, 422, 312, 527, 246, 76, 204, 350, 150, 160, 187, 564, 150, 0, 203, 484, 141, 206, 452, 166, 240], [2156, 196, 157, 270, 284, 258, 221, 281, 326, 166, 131, 173, 261, 247, 260, 178, 358, 118, 181, 0, 291, 261, 312, 259, 68, 130], [2379, 352, 148, 346, 343, 467, 82, 354, 80, 386, 354, 396, 282, 467, 368, 401, 112, 342, 404, 239, 0, 360, 431, 147, 294, 303], [2096, 144, 282, 211, 72, 107, 281, 219, 386, 337, 176, 229, 209, 120, 83, 279, 418, 176, 144, 374, 343, 0, 120, 311, 257, 313], [2071, 234, 372, 300, 161, 141, 370, 309, 475, 362, 210, 318, 299, 154, 174, 300, 507, 265, 196, 319, 432, 118, 0, 400, 282, 356], [2337, 289, 134, 284, 280, 404, 68, 292, 172, 330, 312, 354, 220, 404, 306, 372, 209, 268, 362, 226, 144, 297, 368, 0, 231, 241], [2195, 235, 111, 309, 398, 297, 175, 317, 280, 217, 170, 212, 337, 286, 299, 312, 312, 158, 220, 37, 253, 300, 351, 272, 0, 169], [2202, 242, 212, 315, 326, 303, 233, 323, 339, 193, 176, 218, 265, 292, 305, 226, 376, 164, 226, 169, 296, 307, 357, 263, 131, 0]]}, "reference": {"optimum_s": 15185, "optimality": "best_found", "lower_bound_s": 13775, "floor_s": 12168, "solve_s": 41.19, "ffd_s": 17020, "stop_aware_best_s": 16053, "stop_aware_mean_s": 16267.6, "route_id": "RouteID_2d0fbc6f-c0b7-4bb1-ae6e-27242292b446", "plans": {"optimum": [{"route": ["S21", "S04", "S07", "S03", "S01", "S11", "S17"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S22", "S05", "S13", "S10", "S15", "S09", "S25", "S18"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S24", "S19", "S02", "S06", "S20", "S16", "S08", "S23", "S12", "S14"], "parcels": []}], "ffd": [{"route": ["S15", "S09", "S02", "S07", "S11"], "parcels": ["P04", "P12", "P13", "P22"]}, {"route": ["S13", "S15", "S17", "S20", "S16", "S23", "S07", "S22"], "parcels": ["P11", "P21", "P23", "P33"]}, {"route": ["S05", "S14", "S21", "S04", "S01", "S07", "S03", "S12", "S23", "S06", "S16", "S08", "S02", "S24", "S19", "S25", "S10", "S18"], "parcels": ["P03", "P10", "P24", "P34"]}], "stop_aware_best": [{"route": ["S15", "S02", "S16", "S23", "S12", "S18"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S22", "S05", "S21", "S01", "S17", "S24", "S06", "S20", "S08", "S19", "S25"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S09", "S11", "S07", "S03", "S04", "S14", "S13", "S10"], "parcels": []}]}}, "meta": {"route_id": "RouteID_2d0fbc6f-c0b7-4bb1-ae6e-27242292b446", "split": "train", "stops": 25, "vans": 3, "tightness": 0.92, "station": "DLA7", "city": "DLA", "date": "2018-07-21", "seconds": 91.8, "stop_aware_best_reward": 0.6584, "optimality": "best_found"}}
{"id": "53983e24-spread-n40-k4-t0.9-s0", "instance": {"stops": ["S01", "S02", "S03", "S04", "S05", "S06", "S07", "S08", "S09", "S10", "S11", "S12", "S13", "S14", "S15", "S16", "S17", "S18", "S19", "S20", "S21", "S22", "S23", "S24", "S25", "S26", "S27", "S28", "S29", "S30", "S31", "S32", "S33", "S34", "S35", "S36", "S37", "S38", "S39", "S40"], "parcels": [{"id": "P01", "stop": "S01", "volume_dl": 34}, {"id": "P02", "stop": "S02", "volume_dl": 11}, {"id": "P03", "stop": "S02", "volume_dl": 7}, {"id": "P04", "stop": "S02", "volume_dl": 92}, {"id": "P05", "stop": "S02", "volume_dl": 57}, {"id": "P06", "stop": "S02", "volume_dl": 54}, {"id": "P07", "stop": "S03", "volume_dl": 41}, {"id": "P08", "stop": "S03", "volume_dl": 63}, {"id": "P09", "stop": "S04", "volume_dl": 309}, {"id": "P10", "stop": "S05", "volume_dl": 55}, {"id": "P11", "stop": "S06", "volume_dl": 9}, {"id": "P12", "stop": "S06", "volume_dl": 5}, {"id": "P13", "stop": "S06", "volume_dl": 60}, {"id": "P14", "stop": "S07", "volume_dl": 92}, {"id": "P15", "stop": "S08", "volume_dl": 25}, {"id": "P16", "stop": "S08", "volume_dl": 429}, {"id": "P17", "stop": "S09", "volume_dl": 23}, {"id": "P18", "stop": "S10", "volume_dl": 9}, {"id": "P19", "stop": "S11", "volume_dl": 53}, {"id": "P20", "stop": "S11", "volume_dl": 28}, {"id": "P21", "stop": "S11", "volume_dl": 20}, {"id": "P22", "stop": "S11", "volume_dl": 6}, {"id": "P23", "stop": "S12", "volume_dl": 157}, {"id": "P24", "stop": "S13", "volume_dl": 57}, {"id": "P25", "stop": "S14", "volume_dl": 104}, {"id": "P26", "stop": "S15", "volume_dl": 95}, {"id": "P27", "stop": "S15", "volume_dl": 95}, {"id": "P28", "stop": "S16", "volume_dl": 477}, {"id": "P29", "stop": "S17", "volume_dl": 19}, {"id": "P30", "stop": "S18", "volume_dl": 27}, {"id": "P31", "stop": "S19", "volume_dl": 840}, {"id": "P32", "stop": "S20", "volume_dl": 26}, {"id": "P33", "stop": "S20", "volume_dl": 59}, {"id": "P34", "stop": "S20", "volume_dl": 133}, {"id": "P35", "stop": "S20", "volume_dl": 18}, {"id": "P36", "stop": "S20", "volume_dl": 34}, {"id": "P37", "stop": "S21", "volume_dl": 95}, {"id": "P38", "stop": "S22", "volume_dl": 11}, {"id": "P39", "stop": "S23", "volume_dl": 7}, {"id": "P40", "stop": "S24", "volume_dl": 92}, {"id": "P41", "stop": "S25", "volume_dl": 92}, {"id": "P42", "stop": "S25", "volume_dl": 63}, {"id": "P43", "stop": "S26", "volume_dl": 259}, {"id": "P44", "stop": "S26", "volume_dl": 28}, {"id": "P45", "stop": "S26", "volume_dl": 57}, {"id": "P46", "stop": "S27", "volume_dl": 60}, {"id": "P47", "stop": "S27", "volume_dl": 20}, {"id": "P48", "stop": "S28", "volume_dl": 133}, {"id": "P49", "stop": "S29", "volume_dl": 11}, {"id": "P50", "stop": "S30", "volume_dl": 232}, {"id": "P51", "stop": "S31", "volume_dl": 34}, {"id": "P52", "stop": "S32", "volume_dl": 157}, {"id": "P53", "stop": "S33", "volume_dl": 92}, {"id": "P54", "stop": "S34", "volume_dl": 104}, {"id": "P55", "stop": "S34", "volume_dl": 840}, {"id": "P56", "stop": "S34", "volume_dl": 104}, {"id": "P57", "stop": "S35", "volume_dl": 23}, {"id": "P58", "stop": "S35", "volume_dl": 29}, {"id": "P59", "stop": "S36", "volume_dl": 28}, {"id": "P60", "stop": "S37", "volume_dl": 157}, {"id": "P61", "stop": "S37", "volume_dl": 242}, {"id": "P62", "stop": "S38", "volume_dl": 179}, {"id": "P63", "stop": "S39", "volume_dl": 14}, {"id": "P64", "stop": "S39", "volume_dl": 133}, {"id": "P65", "stop": "S40", "volume_dl": 179}], "vans": 4, "capacity_dl": 1972, "travel_s": [[0, 1652, 1669, 1780, 1680, 1618, 1734, 1584, 1634, 1670, 1686, 1781, 1752, 1719, 1686, 1708, 1683, 1682, 1752, 1734, 1693, 1530, 1659, 1696, 1738, 1680, 1640, 1637, 1583, 1637, 1644, 1711, 1781, 1686, 1694, 1542, 1511, 1680, 1741, 1664, 1602], [1820, 0, 189, 280, 198, 56, 252, 80, 157, 96, 272, 195, 270, 318, 186, 205, 201, 200, 270, 245, 231, 141, 181, 78, 256, 345, 34, 200, 80, 155, 144, 229, 281, 61, 194, 350, 157, 180, 155, 261, 120], [1885, 187, 0, 174, 61, 240, 174, 242, 70, 179, 222, 193, 136, 244, 144, 142, 68, 106, 190, 121, 181, 282, 46, 152, 148, 258, 229, 140, 220, 34, 94, 121, 167, 181, 73, 387, 297, 96, 148, 206, 81], [1961, 272, 157, 0, 135, 325, 190, 327, 136, 288, 179, 264, 143, 145, 92, 198, 96, 167, 200, 64, 138, 366, 150, 255, 154, 161, 306, 149, 305, 155, 116, 128, 76, 266, 115, 326, 382, 119, 247, 168, 192], [1892, 212, 78, 152, 0, 258, 110, 250, 146, 187, 232, 169, 118, 223, 146, 103, 49, 45, 128, 100, 191, 307, 119, 152, 86, 239, 236, 202, 246, 42, 159, 60, 154, 188, 118, 400, 323, 132, 152, 222, 89], [1800, 66, 250, 340, 252, 0, 305, 24, 204, 129, 255, 240, 323, 379, 246, 250, 255, 253, 323, 305, 262, 87, 228, 143, 309, 405, 22, 206, 59, 209, 204, 282, 342, 122, 255, 329, 107, 241, 199, 233, 173], [1936, 256, 192, 219, 114, 302, 0, 294, 244, 215, 298, 133, 123, 254, 212, 98, 117, 83, 60, 166, 257, 351, 220, 196, 37, 250, 280, 269, 290, 156, 226, 63, 220, 233, 184, 446, 367, 198, 173, 288, 133], [1762, 103, 240, 328, 251, 34, 304, 0, 187, 145, 238, 256, 323, 366, 234, 266, 254, 253, 322, 293, 246, 63, 212, 170, 308, 282, 56, 190, 35, 208, 192, 282, 330, 138, 243, 292, 83, 229, 216, 216, 173], [1856, 159, 87, 168, 134, 212, 240, 196, 0, 208, 158, 228, 195, 204, 72, 212, 140, 178, 253, 129, 117, 253, 25, 180, 206, 229, 199, 68, 192, 106, 30, 180, 168, 153, 81, 306, 269, 67, 205, 134, 114], [1888, 94, 167, 283, 178, 129, 238, 153, 214, 0, 330, 110, 248, 353, 243, 121, 179, 178, 256, 230, 289, 153, 208, 25, 233, 369, 128, 257, 112, 135, 201, 206, 284, 140, 236, 418, 189, 238, 70, 319, 114], [1893, 276, 220, 219, 268, 255, 326, 239, 134, 337, 0, 375, 282, 231, 115, 337, 235, 306, 340, 184, 62, 303, 159, 310, 293, 257, 264, 126, 274, 241, 139, 267, 220, 274, 186, 258, 322, 172, 335, 92, 244], [1934, 195, 194, 266, 174, 238, 162, 262, 260, 109, 346, 0, 231, 336, 259, 73, 162, 174, 193, 213, 304, 262, 236, 126, 199, 350, 235, 320, 221, 174, 254, 216, 268, 231, 225, 464, 298, 250, 40, 341, 131], [1958, 298, 173, 180, 117, 343, 108, 336, 207, 270, 259, 244, 0, 131, 173, 180, 77, 88, 121, 126, 218, 393, 180, 237, 75, 129, 321, 229, 331, 137, 186, 49, 174, 274, 145, 323, 408, 159, 229, 237, 174], [1858, 331, 234, 123, 204, 303, 256, 288, 195, 357, 212, 333, 181, 0, 122, 267, 164, 236, 269, 133, 168, 351, 219, 324, 222, 29, 325, 182, 322, 224, 175, 196, 110, 325, 184, 223, 370, 179, 316, 137, 261], [1889, 209, 141, 103, 159, 262, 211, 264, 73, 258, 86, 288, 167, 132, 0, 222, 120, 191, 224, 68, 45, 303, 98, 230, 178, 159, 243, 56, 242, 173, 53, 152, 105, 203, 70, 254, 319, 56, 256, 76, 165], [1900, 203, 132, 197, 105, 246, 120, 258, 209, 117, 277, 67, 162, 267, 190, 0, 93, 110, 135, 144, 235, 271, 182, 134, 130, 281, 243, 247, 229, 104, 204, 147, 199, 196, 162, 429, 306, 176, 76, 266, 96], [1900, 220, 95, 104, 40, 266, 113, 258, 131, 193, 183, 169, 69, 174, 97, 102, 0, 84, 126, 51, 142, 315, 104, 160, 80, 190, 244, 153, 254, 59, 110, 54, 105, 197, 69, 351, 331, 83, 151, 173, 97], [1894, 214, 113, 185, 34, 260, 89, 252, 181, 187, 264, 160, 89, 220, 178, 101, 83, 0, 102, 132, 223, 309, 154, 154, 56, 218, 238, 235, 248, 76, 192, 29, 186, 191, 150, 424, 325, 164, 145, 254, 91], [1952, 272, 208, 232, 129, 317, 37, 309, 259, 230, 312, 157, 136, 267, 225, 113, 130, 96, 0, 179, 271, 367, 233, 211, 70, 265, 295, 282, 305, 171, 239, 76, 234, 248, 198, 460, 382, 212, 189, 301, 148], [1942, 254, 128, 61, 99, 307, 151, 309, 118, 252, 160, 228, 106, 131, 74, 162, 59, 131, 164, 0, 119, 348, 114, 219, 118, 147, 288, 131, 287, 119, 98, 92, 63, 248, 78, 307, 364, 93, 210, 150, 156], [1844, 264, 205, 158, 214, 274, 269, 258, 125, 313, 63, 337, 222, 170, 55, 277, 175, 246, 280, 123, 0, 322, 150, 286, 233, 195, 281, 66, 293, 229, 108, 207, 160, 258, 126, 209, 341, 112, 311, 36, 220], [1689, 126, 289, 379, 305, 88, 358, 54, 241, 140, 293, 251, 377, 418, 285, 261, 308, 307, 376, 344, 300, 0, 266, 166, 362, 336, 110, 244, 58, 262, 243, 336, 381, 160, 294, 346, 26, 280, 211, 271, 227], [1883, 185, 72, 157, 109, 238, 215, 223, 27, 235, 185, 236, 170, 227, 99, 190, 116, 154, 228, 104, 144, 280, 0, 192, 181, 243, 219, 95, 219, 82, 57, 155, 159, 180, 65, 333, 296, 80, 196, 167, 141], [1863, 69, 142, 260, 153, 125, 206, 149, 189, 35, 305, 118, 225, 330, 218, 128, 156, 154, 224, 207, 264, 191, 183, 0, 210, 346, 103, 232, 121, 110, 176, 183, 261, 122, 210, 392, 197, 213, 77, 294, 74], [1940, 260, 164, 182, 86, 305, 33, 298, 209, 244, 261, 169, 86, 217, 175, 127, 80, 46, 69, 129, 220, 355, 183, 199, 0, 215, 284, 232, 294, 128, 189, 26, 184, 236, 147, 409, 370, 161, 202, 251, 137], [1829, 334, 257, 147, 230, 274, 280, 259, 233, 383, 199, 377, 169, 39, 159, 290, 190, 257, 291, 159, 139, 322, 245, 350, 244, 0, 290, 205, 294, 250, 211, 218, 136, 327, 209, 194, 342, 212, 341, 103, 287], [1822, 46, 217, 330, 232, 20, 288, 44, 203, 131, 277, 241, 304, 364, 232, 248, 235, 234, 304, 291, 280, 107, 227, 124, 290, 391, 0, 224, 75, 189, 190, 263, 327, 107, 240, 351, 126, 224, 199, 255, 154], [1870, 212, 144, 180, 193, 225, 290, 210, 59, 262, 97, 306, 243, 192, 76, 273, 196, 237, 301, 145, 56, 273, 83, 234, 254, 217, 233, 0, 245, 165, 64, 228, 181, 206, 114, 265, 293, 100, 259, 92, 168], [1811, 68, 231, 322, 240, 54, 294, 49, 199, 110, 293, 221, 312, 360, 228, 231, 243, 242, 312, 287, 273, 61, 223, 136, 298, 387, 78, 242, 0, 197, 186, 271, 323, 103, 236, 341, 77, 222, 181, 271, 162], [1850, 170, 32, 153, 43, 216, 153, 208, 100, 145, 233, 154, 118, 224, 146, 124, 49, 88, 171, 100, 192, 265, 73, 110, 129, 239, 194, 168, 204, 0, 126, 103, 155, 147, 101, 380, 281, 115, 114, 222, 47], [1854, 156, 88, 136, 154, 209, 231, 211, 20, 205, 128, 243, 187, 174, 42, 217, 140, 192, 244, 101, 87, 250, 45, 178, 198, 201, 190, 83, 189, 120, 0, 172, 138, 150, 50, 296, 266, 36, 203, 118, 112], [1933, 254, 149, 156, 80, 299, 59, 291, 183, 226, 235, 195, 60, 191, 149, 153, 54, 39, 73, 103, 194, 348, 157, 193, 26, 189, 277, 206, 287, 113, 163, 0, 158, 230, 121, 383, 364, 135, 184, 225, 130], [1950, 275, 168, 58, 139, 328, 190, 331, 140, 292, 182, 268, 146, 134, 96, 201, 99, 170, 204, 68, 141, 370, 154, 259, 157, 150, 309, 152, 309, 158, 119, 131, 0, 269, 118, 315, 385, 123, 250, 172, 196], [1807, 82, 173, 298, 184, 135, 238, 159, 175, 131, 290, 242, 256, 336, 204, 212, 187, 186, 256, 238, 249, 176, 200, 131, 242, 363, 116, 218, 115, 141, 162, 215, 300, 0, 213, 336, 192, 199, 201, 258, 106], [1895, 197, 93, 123, 129, 250, 183, 253, 64, 247, 157, 258, 136, 193, 70, 191, 89, 160, 194, 70, 116, 292, 86, 219, 147, 209, 233, 125, 231, 111, 41, 121, 124, 191, 0, 324, 308, 14, 225, 152, 153], [1776, 372, 416, 350, 427, 331, 483, 316, 321, 452, 370, 462, 370, 240, 360, 454, 392, 429, 498, 360, 239, 379, 343, 417, 445, 203, 347, 321, 351, 384, 324, 419, 338, 366, 374, 0, 379, 360, 440, 203, 349], [1680, 141, 303, 394, 313, 104, 366, 70, 271, 156, 308, 267, 384, 432, 300, 277, 316, 314, 384, 359, 316, 16, 296, 181, 370, 352, 125, 260, 72, 270, 258, 343, 396, 175, 308, 356, 0, 294, 226, 286, 234], [1881, 183, 107, 137, 143, 236, 198, 239, 50, 233, 143, 272, 150, 189, 56, 205, 103, 174, 208, 84, 102, 278, 72, 205, 161, 213, 217, 110, 217, 125, 27, 135, 139, 177, 14, 310, 293, 0, 230, 138, 139], [1894, 154, 154, 259, 165, 197, 205, 221, 222, 68, 339, 40, 224, 330, 252, 97, 155, 154, 232, 206, 298, 222, 195, 85, 210, 345, 188, 270, 180, 122, 214, 183, 261, 190, 223, 424, 257, 237, 0, 328, 91], [1813, 265, 225, 195, 245, 243, 300, 228, 125, 326, 83, 346, 253, 198, 86, 313, 206, 277, 310, 154, 36, 291, 147, 298, 264, 222, 247, 97, 263, 229, 128, 238, 191, 262, 162, 178, 311, 148, 323, 0, 232], [1803, 124, 67, 185, 78, 169, 132, 161, 135, 98, 264, 131, 150, 255, 178, 105, 81, 80, 150, 132, 223, 218, 108, 63, 136, 271, 147, 179, 157, 35, 123, 109, 187, 100, 136, 333, 234, 150, 91, 254, 0]]}, "reference": {"optimum_s": 15888, "optimality": "best_found", "lower_bound_s": 14357, "floor_s": 12764, "solve_s": 66.56, "ffd_s": 17562, "stop_aware_best_s": 17299, "stop_aware_mean_s": 17397.4, "route_id": "RouteID_53983e24-47d6-48e5-9218-cb359a96c8ad", "plans": {"optimum": [{"route": ["S27", "S37", "S34", "S33", "S01", "S28", "S21"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S02", "S04", "S17", "S31", "S12", "S24", "S18", "S06", "S15", "S11", "S38", "S09", "S23", "S26", "S05", "S07", "S36"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S35", "S25", "S13", "S32", "S03", "S19", "S16"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S40", "S29", "S22", "S08", "S30", "S14", "S10", "S20", "S39"], "parcels": []}], "ffd": [{"route": ["S26", "S34", "S19", "S35"], "parcels": ["P43", "P55", "P58"]}, {"route": ["S08", "S30", "S14", "S37", "S16", "S04", "S38"], "parcels": ["P16", "P61"]}, {"route": ["S25", "S32", "S12", "S24", "S06", "S15", "S40", "S02", "S34", "S37", "S20", "S39", "S07", "S28", "S21"], "parcels": ["P04", "P13", "P34", "P41", "P54", "P56", "P60", "P64"]}, {"route": ["S35", "S25", "S13", "S03", "S10", "S39", "S20", "S27", "S08", "S22", "S02", "S29", "S17", "S31", "S18", "S06", "S11", "S09", "S23", "S33", "S01", "S26", "S05", "S36"], "parcels": ["P02", "P03", "P05", "P06", "P11", "P12", "P15", "P32", "P33", "P35", "P36", "P42", "P44", "P45", "P57", "P63"]}], "stop_aware_best": [{"route": ["S36", "S07", "S26", "S29", "S02", "S04", "S16", "S32", "S14", "S27", "S35"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S28", "S33", "S38", "S11", "S18", "S06", "S17", "S19", "S03", "S25"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S13", "S39", "S10", "S30", "S08", "S22", "S24", "S15", "S40", "S23", "S05", "S21"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S01", "S09", "S31", "S12", "S34", "S37", "S20"], "parcels": []}]}}, "meta": {"route_id": "RouteID_53983e24-47d6-48e5-9218-cb359a96c8ad", "split": "train", "stops": 40, "vans": 4, "tightness": 0.9, "station": "DLA8", "city": "DLA", "date": "2018-08-05", "seconds": 127.2, "stop_aware_best_reward": 0.5334, "optimality": "best_found"}}
{"id": "3df50218-spread-n25-k3-t0.92-s0", "instance": {"stops": ["S01", "S02", "S03", "S04", "S05", "S06", "S07", "S08", "S09", "S10", "S11", "S12", "S13", "S14", "S15", "S16", "S17", "S18", "S19", "S20", "S21", "S22", "S23", "S24", "S25"], "parcels": [{"id": "P01", "stop": "S01", "volume_dl": 368}, {"id": "P02", "stop": "S01", "volume_dl": 179}, {"id": "P03", "stop": "S02", "volume_dl": 34}, {"id": "P04", "stop": "S02", "volume_dl": 59}, {"id": "P05", "stop": "S03", "volume_dl": 322}, {"id": "P06", "stop": "S03", "volume_dl": 34}, {"id": "P07", "stop": "S04", "volume_dl": 34}, {"id": "P08", "stop": "S05", "volume_dl": 18}, {"id": "P09", "stop": "S06", "volume_dl": 11}, {"id": "P10", "stop": "S07", "volume_dl": 157}, {"id": "P11", "stop": "S08", "volume_dl": 179}, {"id": "P12", "stop": "S08", "volume_dl": 92}, {"id": "P13", "stop": "S08", "volume_dl": 95}, {"id": "P14", "stop": "S09", "volume_dl": 53}, {"id": "P15", "stop": "S10", "volume_dl": 157}, {"id": "P16", "stop": "S11", "volume_dl": 427}, {"id": "P17", "stop": "S11", "volume_dl": 95}, {"id": "P18", "stop": "S11", "volume_dl": 427}, {"id": "P19", "stop": "S11", "volume_dl": 324}, {"id": "P20", "stop": "S11", "volume_dl": 427}, {"id": "P21", "stop": "S11", "volume_dl": 542}, {"id": "P22", "stop": "S11", "volume_dl": 427}, {"id": "P23", "stop": "S11", "volume_dl": 427}, {"id": "P24", "stop": "S11", "volume_dl": 427}, {"id": "P25", "stop": "S12", "volume_dl": 63}, {"id": "P26", "stop": "S12", "volume_dl": 508}, {"id": "P27", "stop": "S12", "volume_dl": 133}, {"id": "P28", "stop": "S12", "volume_dl": 25}, {"id": "P29", "stop": "S13", "volume_dl": 21}, {"id": "P30", "stop": "S14", "volume_dl": 15}, {"id": "P31", "stop": "S15", "volume_dl": 140}, {"id": "P32", "stop": "S16", "volume_dl": 16}, {"id": "P33", "stop": "S16", "volume_dl": 57}, {"id": "P34", "stop": "S17", "volume_dl": 42}, {"id": "P35", "stop": "S18", "volume_dl": 5}, {"id": "P36", "stop": "S19", "volume_dl": 322}, {"id": "P37", "stop": "S20", "volume_dl": 97}, {"id": "P38", "stop": "S21", "volume_dl": 146}, {"id": "P39", "stop": "S21", "volume_dl": 146}, {"id": "P40", "stop": "S22", "volume_dl": 11}, {"id": "P41", "stop": "S23", "volume_dl": 53}, {"id": "P42", "stop": "S24", "volume_dl": 322}, {"id": "P43", "stop": "S24", "volume_dl": 322}, {"id": "P44", "stop": "S25", "volume_dl": 133}], "vans": 3, "capacity_dl": 2860, "travel_s": [[0, 1202, 1078, 1083, 1229, 1424, 1160, 1147, 1107, 1132, 1638, 1104, 1112, 947, 1130, 1080, 1059, 1398, 1027, 1148, 1272, 1155, 1212, 1191, 1106, 1414], [1105, 0, 376, 428, 488, 899, 524, 500, 483, 473, 980, 480, 496, 292, 494, 338, 330, 872, 241, 406, 530, 426, 565, 544, 489, 672], [997, 386, 0, 321, 161, 698, 299, 230, 323, 203, 780, 320, 376, 185, 286, 44, 155, 672, 198, 206, 329, 213, 295, 274, 370, 471], [979, 441, 343, 0, 455, 866, 380, 368, 327, 353, 948, 324, 95, 173, 350, 306, 261, 840, 253, 374, 498, 357, 432, 411, 90, 640], [1123, 499, 165, 473, 0, 863, 425, 356, 426, 329, 945, 424, 502, 311, 411, 209, 267, 837, 324, 371, 495, 378, 421, 399, 495, 636], [1339, 891, 652, 865, 813, 0, 911, 842, 881, 815, 311, 878, 894, 703, 897, 608, 645, 30, 716, 456, 360, 449, 907, 885, 887, 218], [1050, 553, 284, 416, 435, 822, 0, 183, 201, 96, 1022, 198, 445, 298, 40, 328, 339, 795, 378, 448, 572, 455, 248, 227, 438, 714], [1039, 547, 260, 404, 411, 747, 204, 0, 189, 131, 961, 187, 433, 286, 174, 304, 315, 721, 372, 424, 548, 431, 64, 42, 427, 690], [966, 481, 291, 305, 442, 762, 190, 177, 0, 162, 988, 54, 361, 214, 159, 335, 346, 736, 294, 414, 538, 422, 242, 220, 354, 680], [1026, 483, 196, 400, 347, 734, 96, 114, 184, 0, 934, 182, 429, 294, 88, 240, 251, 707, 308, 360, 484, 367, 179, 158, 422, 625], [1533, 993, 754, 967, 915, 311, 1013, 944, 983, 916, 0, 980, 996, 804, 999, 710, 747, 285, 818, 558, 462, 551, 1008, 987, 989, 319], [963, 466, 340, 328, 452, 771, 199, 186, 54, 172, 985, 0, 357, 210, 169, 343, 322, 745, 290, 411, 535, 418, 251, 230, 351, 677], [1024, 474, 388, 88, 500, 911, 426, 413, 372, 398, 993, 370, 0, 219, 395, 351, 330, 885, 299, 419, 543, 426, 478, 456, 87, 685], [857, 280, 156, 207, 307, 718, 277, 264, 223, 249, 800, 221, 236, 0, 246, 158, 137, 692, 105, 226, 349, 233, 329, 307, 230, 491], [1010, 513, 258, 376, 409, 786, 30, 144, 161, 98, 995, 158, 405, 258, 0, 301, 313, 760, 338, 422, 545, 429, 208, 187, 398, 687], [981, 357, 44, 330, 205, 654, 343, 274, 344, 247, 736, 342, 360, 168, 330, 0, 111, 628, 182, 162, 286, 169, 339, 318, 353, 427], [954, 330, 136, 277, 288, 695, 373, 300, 319, 273, 776, 317, 333, 141, 342, 135, 0, 669, 155, 203, 326, 210, 365, 344, 326, 468], [1333, 886, 647, 860, 808, 31, 906, 836, 875, 809, 305, 873, 889, 697, 892, 603, 640, 0, 711, 451, 355, 444, 901, 880, 882, 212], [955, 246, 187, 305, 338, 749, 374, 351, 321, 324, 831, 319, 334, 143, 344, 189, 168, 723, 0, 257, 381, 264, 416, 394, 328, 523], [1059, 435, 196, 409, 357, 492, 455, 385, 424, 358, 574, 422, 438, 246, 441, 152, 189, 466, 260, 0, 124, 7, 450, 429, 431, 266], [1204, 580, 341, 554, 502, 393, 600, 530, 570, 503, 475, 567, 583, 391, 586, 297, 334, 367, 405, 145, 0, 138, 595, 574, 576, 142], [1066, 442, 224, 389, 364, 485, 462, 393, 432, 366, 566, 429, 445, 254, 448, 159, 196, 459, 267, 7, 116, 0, 458, 436, 438, 258], [1084, 592, 305, 449, 456, 792, 249, 44, 234, 176, 1006, 232, 478, 331, 219, 349, 360, 766, 417, 469, 592, 476, 0, 23, 472, 734], [1088, 596, 309, 453, 460, 796, 254, 48, 238, 180, 1010, 236, 482, 336, 223, 353, 364, 770, 421, 473, 597, 480, 29, 0, 476, 739], [1012, 473, 336, 91, 488, 899, 413, 400, 359, 385, 980, 357, 92, 206, 382, 338, 318, 872, 286, 406, 530, 414, 465, 444, 0, 672], [1348, 724, 485, 698, 646, 254, 744, 675, 714, 648, 335, 712, 727, 536, 730, 441, 478, 227, 549, 289, 144, 282, 740, 718, 721, 0]]}, "reference": {"optimum_s": 9776, "optimality": "best_found", "lower_bound_s": 7763, "floor_s": 5412, "solve_s": 39.17, "ffd_s": 12658, "stop_aware_best_s": 11528, "stop_aware_mean_s": 12233, "route_id": "RouteID_3df50218-258c-45cf-804d-79accb01c249", "plans": {"optimum": [{"route": ["S24", "S12", "S03", "S13", "S18", "S01"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S11"], "parcels": ["P16", "P17", "P20", "P21", "P22", "P23", "P24"]}, {"route": ["S17", "S05", "S10", "S25", "S20", "S21", "S19", "S16", "S15", "S02", "S04", "S07", "S23", "S22", "S09", "S06", "S14", "S11", "S08"], "parcels": ["P18", "P19"]}], "ffd": [{"route": ["S12", "S18", "S20", "S11"], "parcels": ["P16", "P18", "P20", "P21", "P22", "P26"]}, {"route": ["S01", "S19", "S24", "S12", "S03", "S11"], "parcels": ["P01", "P05", "P19", "P23", "P24", "P28"]}, {"route": ["S17", "S05", "S10", "S25", "S21", "S15", "S02", "S04", "S16", "S01", "S13", "S12", "S03", "S14", "S06", "S09", "S07", "S23", "S22", "S08", "S11"], "parcels": ["P02", "P06", "P17", "P25", "P27"]}], "stop_aware_best": [{"route": ["S13", "S18", "S20", "S15", "S02", "S04", "S07", "S11"], "parcels": ["P16", "P17", "P18", "P22", "P23", "P24"]}, {"route": ["S01", "S16", "S24", "S06", "S11"], "parcels": ["P19", "P20", "P21"]}, {"route": ["S17", "S05", "S10", "S25", "S21", "S19", "S23", "S22", "S09", "S14", "S08", "S03", "S12"], "parcels": []}]}}, "meta": {"route_id": "RouteID_3df50218-258c-45cf-804d-79accb01c249", "split": "train", "stops": 25, "vans": 3, "tightness": 0.92, "station": "DSE4", "city": "DSE", "date": "2018-08-09", "seconds": 92.7, "stop_aware_best_reward": 0.5649, "optimality": "best_found"}}
{"id": "23f737be-spread-n40-k4-t0.91-s0", "instance": {"stops": ["S01", "S02", "S03", "S04", "S05", "S06", "S07", "S08", "S09", "S10", "S11", "S12", "S13", "S14", "S15", "S16", "S17", "S18", "S19", "S20", "S21", "S22", "S23", "S24", "S25", "S26", "S27", "S28", "S29", "S30", "S31", "S32", "S33", "S34", "S35", "S36", "S37", "S38", "S39", "S40"], "parcels": [{"id": "P01", "stop": "S01", "volume_dl": 95}, {"id": "P02", "stop": "S02", "volume_dl": 277}, {"id": "P03", "stop": "S03", "volume_dl": 30}, {"id": "P04", "stop": "S03", "volume_dl": 60}, {"id": "P05", "stop": "S04", "volume_dl": 39}, {"id": "P06", "stop": "S05", "volume_dl": 322}, {"id": "P07", "stop": "S06", "volume_dl": 27}, {"id": "P08", "stop": "S07", "volume_dl": 18}, {"id": "P09", "stop": "S07", "volume_dl": 34}, {"id": "P10", "stop": "S08", "volume_dl": 34}, {"id": "P11", "stop": "S09", "volume_dl": 21}, {"id": "P12", "stop": "S10", "volume_dl": 134}, {"id": "P13", "stop": "S11", "volume_dl": 242}, {"id": "P14", "stop": "S11", "volume_dl": 179}, {"id": "P15", "stop": "S12", "volume_dl": 179}, {"id": "P16", "stop": "S13", "volume_dl": 39}, {"id": "P17", "stop": "S14", "volume_dl": 41}, {"id": "P18", "stop": "S15", "volume_dl": 60}, {"id": "P19", "stop": "S15", "volume_dl": 10}, {"id": "P20", "stop": "S16", "volume_dl": 57}, {"id": "P21", "stop": "S17", "volume_dl": 34}, {"id": "P22", "stop": "S18", "volume_dl": 104}, {"id": "P23", "stop": "S18", "volume_dl": 27}, {"id": "P24", "stop": "S18", "volume_dl": 179}, {"id": "P25", "stop": "S18", "volume_dl": 133}, {"id": "P26", "stop": "S18", "volume_dl": 28}, {"id": "P27", "stop": "S18", "volume_dl": 28}, {"id": "P28", "stop": "S18", "volume_dl": 34}, {"id": "P29", "stop": "S18", "volume_dl": 34}, {"id": "P30", "stop": "S18", "volume_dl": 25}, {"id": "P31", "stop": "S18", "volume_dl": 13}, {"id": "P32", "stop": "S18", "volume_dl": 59}, {"id": "P33", "stop": "S18", "volume_dl": 29}, {"id": "P34", "stop": "S18", "volume_dl": 60}, {"id": "P35", "stop": "S18", "volume_dl": 38}, {"id": "P36", "stop": "S18", "volume_dl": 6}, {"id": "P37", "stop": "S18", "volume_dl": 34}, {"id": "P38", "stop": "S18", "volume_dl": 63}, {"id": "P39", "stop": "S18", "volume_dl": 57}, {"id": "P40", "stop": "S18", "volume_dl": 321}, {"id": "P41", "stop": "S18", "volume_dl": 30}, {"id": "P42", "stop": "S18", "volume_dl": 104}, {"id": "P43", "stop": "S18", "volume_dl": 23}, {"id": "P44", "stop": "S18", "volume_dl": 92}, {"id": "P45", "stop": "S18", "volume_dl": 21}, {"id": "P46", "stop": "S19", "volume_dl": 34}, {"id": "P47", "stop": "S20", "volume_dl": 12}, {"id": "P48", "stop": "S21", "volume_dl": 277}, {"id": "P49", "stop": "S22", "volume_dl": 92}, {"id": "P50", "stop": "S23", "volume_dl": 57}, {"id": "P51", "stop": "S24", "volume_dl": 157}, {"id": "P52", "stop": "S24", "volume_dl": 34}, {"id": "P53", "stop": "S24", "volume_dl": 36}, {"id": "P54", "stop": "S24", "volume_dl": 157}, {"id": "P55", "stop": "S25", "volume_dl": 104}, {"id": "P56", "stop": "S26", "volume_dl": 6}, {"id": "P57", "stop": "S27", "volume_dl": 37}, {"id": "P58", "stop": "S28", "volume_dl": 179}, {"id": "P59", "stop": "S29", "volume_dl": 23}, {"id": "P60", "stop": "S30", "volume_dl": 242}, {"id": "P61", "stop": "S31", "volume_dl": 57}, {"id": "P62", "stop": "S31", "volume_dl": 57}, {"id": "P63", "stop": "S32", "volume_dl": 242}, {"id": "P64", "stop": "S32", "volume_dl": 179}, {"id": "P65", "stop": "S32", "volume_dl": 133}, {"id": "P66", "stop": "S33", "volume_dl": 104}, {"id": "P67", "stop": "S34", "volume_dl": 34}, {"id": "P68", "stop": "S35", "volume_dl": 226}, {"id": "P69", "stop": "S36", "volume_dl": 92}, {"id": "P70", "stop": "S36", "volume_dl": 840}, {"id": "P71", "stop": "S36", "volume_dl": 134}, {"id": "P72", "stop": "S37", "volume_dl": 9}, {"id": "P73", "stop": "S37", "volume_dl": 34}, {"id": "P74", "stop": "S38", "volume_dl": 59}, {"id": "P75", "stop": "S39", "volume_dl": 45}, {"id": "P76", "stop": "S40", "volume_dl": 77}], "vans": 4, "capacity_dl": 1991, "travel_s": [[0, 2415, 2504, 2499, 2440, 2538, 2483, 2368, 2397, 2434, 2487, 2583, 2551, 2546, 2478, 2461, 2370, 2582, 2522, 2458, 2481, 2551, 2478, 2533, 2607, 2452, 2566, 2607, 2540, 2474, 2444, 2471, 2444, 2471, 2582, 2490, 2514, 2406, 2458, 2449, 2427], [2321, 0, 311, 84, 96, 506, 210, 105, 150, 207, 294, 390, 358, 425, 135, 268, 177, 389, 329, 146, 332, 358, 63, 340, 411, 78, 374, 414, 468, 282, 230, 163, 251, 109, 389, 176, 593, 75, 77, 182, 235], [2378, 284, 0, 302, 312, 316, 274, 239, 244, 349, 108, 148, 119, 185, 409, 83, 95, 149, 122, 351, 217, 153, 347, 150, 171, 321, 129, 169, 229, 83, 446, 440, 186, 395, 149, 450, 302, 275, 330, 314, 171], [2286, 94, 338, 0, 96, 533, 273, 184, 213, 270, 321, 417, 385, 452, 141, 287, 204, 416, 356, 210, 359, 385, 86, 367, 438, 78, 401, 441, 495, 309, 212, 169, 278, 134, 416, 181, 613, 128, 85, 233, 262], [2224, 82, 376, 98, 0, 571, 206, 153, 146, 203, 360, 420, 361, 470, 71, 334, 242, 427, 350, 133, 351, 424, 94, 406, 476, 92, 401, 446, 526, 305, 142, 99, 240, 64, 427, 111, 546, 129, 48, 169, 223], [2334, 520, 286, 539, 552, 0, 376, 537, 425, 400, 401, 160, 223, 90, 512, 375, 331, 161, 287, 502, 287, 141, 644, 188, 165, 642, 174, 199, 122, 370, 478, 505, 338, 566, 162, 524, 210, 511, 598, 483, 360], [2335, 220, 265, 270, 200, 368, 0, 184, 104, 116, 293, 298, 205, 280, 209, 283, 176, 270, 197, 171, 145, 314, 267, 339, 271, 248, 290, 290, 316, 186, 214, 210, 117, 250, 270, 203, 384, 211, 220, 132, 112], [2239, 102, 271, 170, 156, 466, 177, 0, 117, 174, 254, 350, 318, 385, 220, 228, 137, 349, 289, 179, 292, 318, 165, 300, 371, 103, 334, 374, 428, 242, 272, 231, 211, 188, 349, 260, 517, 57, 146, 170, 194], [2246, 150, 237, 200, 130, 424, 101, 115, 0, 111, 259, 295, 246, 336, 165, 233, 143, 304, 205, 116, 192, 278, 197, 307, 314, 179, 254, 306, 372, 158, 237, 196, 119, 151, 304, 206, 440, 141, 150, 118, 77], [2247, 278, 330, 295, 243, 393, 100, 194, 114, 0, 384, 364, 282, 303, 160, 358, 223, 341, 246, 149, 198, 392, 292, 386, 308, 289, 368, 346, 344, 272, 98, 153, 184, 210, 341, 182, 371, 299, 245, 111, 190], [2384, 344, 167, 358, 372, 356, 315, 300, 267, 386, 0, 245, 214, 364, 432, 73, 155, 271, 201, 369, 270, 213, 407, 191, 266, 382, 228, 270, 396, 154, 483, 463, 204, 418, 272, 473, 447, 335, 390, 367, 194], [2374, 425, 150, 419, 405, 203, 300, 391, 294, 362, 239, 0, 130, 162, 428, 214, 212, 61, 208, 349, 256, 75, 472, 95, 153, 454, 51, 101, 203, 234, 460, 439, 184, 440, 62, 480, 244, 416, 425, 368, 220], [2311, 366, 101, 369, 346, 208, 206, 330, 244, 277, 175, 125, 0, 119, 341, 149, 161, 65, 104, 310, 160, 143, 412, 180, 105, 394, 119, 85, 162, 212, 375, 360, 146, 383, 65, 388, 236, 356, 366, 256, 161], [2262, 482, 196, 465, 462, 88, 285, 446, 334, 310, 311, 170, 132, 0, 422, 285, 257, 143, 197, 411, 196, 203, 554, 240, 93, 551, 179, 121, 63, 279, 387, 415, 248, 476, 143, 434, 190, 473, 507, 392, 270], [2248, 119, 416, 135, 83, 512, 220, 208, 179, 159, 414, 421, 348, 462, 0, 388, 296, 413, 351, 74, 339, 457, 132, 460, 462, 129, 433, 447, 503, 337, 71, 28, 241, 54, 413, 40, 494, 179, 85, 92, 256], [2361, 321, 156, 285, 349, 361, 273, 276, 253, 348, 58, 250, 204, 271, 430, 0, 132, 276, 172, 348, 241, 218, 372, 196, 256, 359, 234, 260, 314, 125, 445, 449, 176, 404, 277, 459, 452, 312, 367, 345, 165], [2228, 189, 134, 207, 217, 329, 160, 144, 141, 230, 117, 214, 181, 248, 280, 91, 0, 212, 152, 235, 221, 181, 252, 163, 234, 226, 197, 237, 291, 105, 328, 308, 155, 248, 212, 321, 416, 180, 234, 225, 145], [2346, 434, 150, 419, 414, 170, 275, 399, 300, 334, 244, 61, 69, 150, 410, 218, 212, 0, 173, 372, 229, 108, 481, 137, 110, 463, 84, 58, 167, 234, 432, 429, 207, 451, 0, 457, 254, 425, 434, 325, 227], [2394, 366, 130, 355, 346, 277, 174, 331, 244, 269, 173, 180, 82, 189, 342, 147, 148, 147, 0, 311, 132, 210, 413, 237, 187, 395, 186, 167, 234, 145, 366, 361, 146, 384, 147, 378, 324, 357, 366, 257, 162], [2303, 159, 345, 188, 136, 497, 166, 209, 117, 148, 358, 346, 310, 409, 79, 361, 267, 370, 276, 0, 265, 395, 185, 430, 387, 182, 371, 372, 445, 266, 144, 103, 166, 91, 370, 130, 490, 180, 138, 60, 194], [2344, 405, 159, 455, 385, 264, 216, 370, 266, 206, 206, 205, 114, 184, 366, 180, 259, 178, 68, 337, 0, 237, 452, 274, 126, 434, 213, 172, 219, 178, 304, 359, 190, 416, 178, 388, 275, 396, 405, 317, 196], [2400, 379, 182, 397, 438, 191, 322, 422, 326, 368, 220, 32, 127, 152, 469, 196, 190, 58, 216, 381, 280, 0, 442, 47, 160, 416, 32, 117, 183, 266, 466, 484, 217, 472, 59, 512, 234, 370, 458, 384, 253], [2299, 55, 366, 88, 74, 560, 265, 160, 205, 262, 349, 445, 413, 480, 119, 323, 232, 444, 384, 200, 387, 413, 0, 395, 466, 82, 429, 469, 523, 336, 190, 147, 306, 113, 444, 160, 647, 130, 64, 212, 289], [2386, 403, 196, 422, 432, 165, 342, 359, 304, 417, 245, 77, 191, 209, 470, 220, 215, 122, 269, 420, 320, 76, 466, 0, 226, 441, 55, 175, 278, 272, 514, 500, 261, 455, 122, 510, 291, 394, 449, 423, 231], [2348, 518, 231, 500, 498, 158, 320, 482, 377, 318, 328, 113, 165, 101, 478, 302, 292, 97, 214, 451, 230, 105, 565, 189, 0, 546, 135, 112, 114, 314, 416, 472, 286, 528, 96, 500, 224, 509, 518, 421, 304], [2324, 58, 348, 67, 99, 543, 248, 106, 188, 245, 332, 428, 396, 463, 144, 306, 214, 427, 367, 170, 370, 396, 90, 378, 448, 0, 412, 452, 506, 319, 215, 172, 289, 134, 426, 185, 630, 50, 102, 206, 272], [2380, 400, 142, 398, 380, 200, 287, 364, 250, 362, 216, 56, 121, 176, 415, 190, 190, 82, 214, 366, 265, 24, 447, 112, 172, 428, 0, 120, 207, 217, 460, 445, 210, 400, 82, 456, 258, 391, 400, 368, 176], [2336, 404, 154, 423, 430, 216, 267, 414, 302, 335, 258, 80, 89, 126, 430, 232, 216, 38, 160, 374, 224, 125, 497, 169, 86, 478, 101, 0, 182, 238, 432, 449, 209, 453, 38, 470, 279, 395, 450, 345, 229], [2256, 478, 228, 497, 511, 124, 336, 496, 366, 320, 333, 202, 164, 82, 461, 307, 289, 175, 237, 445, 242, 235, 593, 272, 141, 590, 211, 195, 0, 311, 426, 454, 280, 515, 175, 473, 150, 469, 546, 421, 293], [2355, 311, 79, 361, 291, 353, 191, 276, 161, 265, 139, 227, 198, 264, 326, 114, 140, 228, 139, 268, 208, 232, 358, 226, 250, 339, 208, 248, 308, 0, 363, 357, 103, 312, 228, 367, 381, 302, 311, 262, 88], [2261, 182, 418, 197, 145, 481, 188, 271, 241, 88, 472, 483, 389, 391, 62, 446, 311, 454, 381, 137, 286, 520, 194, 474, 396, 191, 496, 474, 432, 400, 0, 55, 303, 116, 454, 74, 459, 242, 147, 134, 318], [2251, 138, 434, 153, 101, 555, 210, 226, 197, 162, 432, 440, 345, 466, 18, 406, 315, 410, 337, 93, 323, 475, 150, 478, 449, 147, 451, 430, 503, 356, 74, 0, 259, 72, 410, 44, 498, 197, 103, 89, 274], [2387, 241, 178, 291, 221, 324, 115, 206, 118, 183, 192, 181, 145, 235, 244, 166, 104, 204, 110, 164, 123, 236, 288, 268, 221, 269, 212, 206, 320, 99, 280, 267, 0, 255, 204, 295, 352, 232, 241, 184, 41], [2292, 104, 395, 120, 68, 583, 252, 191, 158, 233, 398, 436, 380, 494, 66, 372, 281, 446, 363, 89, 350, 436, 117, 444, 472, 114, 412, 462, 530, 316, 136, 93, 256, 0, 446, 106, 560, 162, 70, 125, 235], [2346, 434, 150, 419, 414, 170, 274, 399, 300, 334, 243, 61, 69, 150, 410, 218, 211, 0, 173, 371, 228, 108, 481, 137, 110, 463, 84, 58, 167, 233, 431, 429, 207, 451, 0, 457, 254, 425, 434, 325, 227], [2248, 168, 465, 184, 132, 512, 204, 257, 227, 159, 463, 472, 382, 462, 49, 437, 345, 448, 375, 126, 349, 506, 181, 509, 475, 178, 482, 468, 504, 386, 71, 42, 292, 103, 448, 0, 495, 228, 134, 127, 304], [2267, 607, 318, 672, 587, 196, 426, 572, 457, 410, 423, 293, 255, 172, 536, 397, 380, 266, 320, 535, 356, 250, 668, 297, 233, 666, 301, 286, 136, 402, 502, 530, 370, 591, 266, 548, 0, 598, 622, 480, 384], [2424, 166, 326, 250, 192, 521, 208, 119, 148, 205, 310, 405, 363, 472, 255, 284, 192, 405, 345, 210, 352, 374, 229, 356, 426, 204, 389, 430, 528, 297, 302, 266, 242, 222, 404, 295, 547, 0, 209, 200, 225], [2280, 59, 370, 74, 55, 565, 233, 147, 173, 230, 353, 449, 417, 484, 100, 327, 236, 448, 388, 156, 391, 417, 71, 399, 470, 68, 433, 473, 527, 341, 171, 128, 267, 119, 448, 141, 572, 116, 0, 191, 250], [2264, 194, 336, 220, 168, 466, 127, 186, 118, 115, 361, 366, 255, 377, 85, 355, 215, 321, 248, 75, 233, 397, 217, 378, 360, 214, 373, 341, 414, 257, 145, 104, 186, 126, 320, 131, 458, 216, 170, 0, 195], [2300, 223, 160, 273, 203, 377, 111, 188, 73, 186, 182, 218, 170, 251, 238, 192, 85, 227, 128, 189, 148, 201, 270, 248, 237, 252, 177, 229, 294, 82, 283, 269, 54, 224, 227, 279, 368, 214, 223, 192, 0]]}, "reference": {"optimum_s": 21767, "optimality": "best_found", "lower_bound_s": 20494, "floor_s": 18368, "solve_s": 118.52, "ffd_s": 24129, "stop_aware_best_s": 23309, "stop_aware_mean_s": 23602.4, "route_id": "RouteID_23f737be-6f72-41f1-9045-a0ab0e93e641", "plans": {"optimum": [{"route": ["S01", "S37", "S08", "S40", "S20", "S18", "S12"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S16", "S29", "S02", "S15", "S10", "S23", "S26", "S21", "S11", "S17", "S34", "S27", "S24", "S28"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S07", "S25", "S03", "S22", "S38", "S04", "S33", "S14", "S31", "S35", "S30", "S09", "S06", "S32", "S19", "S39"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S36", "S05", "S13"], "parcels": []}], "ffd": [{"route": ["S36", "S05", "S02", "S18", "S35"], "parcels": ["P40", "P70"]}, {"route": ["S30", "S32", "S18", "S12", "S21", "S11", "S28"], "parcels": ["P24", "P44", "P63", "P64"]}, {"route": ["S01", "S22", "S38", "S25", "S03", "S33", "S40", "S32", "S18", "S15", "S10", "S24", "S36"], "parcels": ["P04", "P22", "P25", "P32", "P34", "P38", "P42", "P51", "P54", "P65", "P69", "P71"]}, {"route": ["S07", "S37", "S08", "S03", "S04", "S31", "S14", "S19", "S39", "S09", "S06", "S20", "S18", "S29", "S16", "S23", "S26", "S17", "S34", "S27", "S24", "S13"], "parcels": ["P03", "P23", "P26", "P27", "P28", "P29", "P30", "P31", "P33", "P35", "P36", "P37", "P39", "P41", "P43", "P45", "P52", "P53"]}], "stop_aware_best": [{"route": ["S07", "S01", "S33", "S14", "S19", "S32", "S29", "S11", "S12"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S37", "S16", "S02", "S23", "S26", "S27", "S34", "S05", "S36"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S25", "S22", "S38", "S04", "S35", "S30", "S06", "S40", "S15", "S10", "S21", "S24", "S13", "S28"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S08", "S03", "S31", "S39", "S09", "S20", "S18", "S17"], "parcels": []}]}}, "meta": {"route_id": "RouteID_23f737be-6f72-41f1-9045-a0ab0e93e641", "split": "train", "stops": 40, "vans": 4, "tightness": 0.91, "station": "DSE5", "city": "DSE", "date": "2018-08-09", "seconds": 179.2, "stop_aware_best_reward": 0.5314, "optimality": "best_found"}}
{"id": "60b304da-spread-n40-k4-t0.85-s0", "instance": {"stops": ["S01", "S02", "S03", "S04", "S05", "S06", "S07", "S08", "S09", "S10", "S11", "S12", "S13", "S14", "S15", "S16", "S17", "S18", "S19", "S20", "S21", "S22", "S23", "S24", "S25", "S26", "S27", "S28", "S29", "S30", "S31", "S32", "S33", "S34", "S35", "S36", "S37", "S38", "S39", "S40"], "parcels": [{"id": "P01", "stop": "S01", "volume_dl": 57}, {"id": "P02", "stop": "S02", "volume_dl": 21}, {"id": "P03", "stop": "S03", "volume_dl": 92}, {"id": "P04", "stop": "S04", "volume_dl": 322}, {"id": "P05", "stop": "S05", "volume_dl": 44}, {"id": "P06", "stop": "S06", "volume_dl": 25}, {"id": "P07", "stop": "S06", "volume_dl": 288}, {"id": "P08", "stop": "S07", "volume_dl": 542}, {"id": "P09", "stop": "S08", "volume_dl": 16}, {"id": "P10", "stop": "S09", "volume_dl": 57}, {"id": "P11", "stop": "S10", "volume_dl": 289}, {"id": "P12", "stop": "S10", "volume_dl": 133}, {"id": "P13", "stop": "S11", "volume_dl": 133}, {"id": "P14", "stop": "S12", "volume_dl": 43}, {"id": "P15", "stop": "S13", "volume_dl": 11}, {"id": "P16", "stop": "S13", "volume_dl": 21}, {"id": "P17", "stop": "S13", "volume_dl": 25}, {"id": "P18", "stop": "S14", "volume_dl": 22}, {"id": "P19", "stop": "S14", "volume_dl": 34}, {"id": "P20", "stop": "S15", "volume_dl": 42}, {"id": "P21", "stop": "S15", "volume_dl": 157}, {"id": "P22", "stop": "S16", "volume_dl": 5}, {"id": "P23", "stop": "S17", "volume_dl": 26}, {"id": "P24", "stop": "S18", "volume_dl": 57}, {"id": "P25", "stop": "S19", "volume_dl": 57}, {"id": "P26", "stop": "S19", "volume_dl": 57}, {"id": "P27", "stop": "S20", "volume_dl": 13}, {"id": "P28", "stop": "S21", "volume_dl": 226}, {"id": "P29", "stop": "S22", "volume_dl": 133}, {"id": "P30", "stop": "S23", "volume_dl": 259}, {"id": "P31", "stop": "S24", "volume_dl": 25}, {"id": "P32", "stop": "S24", "volume_dl": 37}, {"id": "P33", "stop": "S24", "volume_dl": 21}, {"id": "P34", "stop": "S25", "volume_dl": 34}, {"id": "P35", "stop": "S25", "volume_dl": 10}, {"id": "P36", "stop": "S26", "volume_dl": 21}, {"id": "P37", "stop": "S26", "volume_dl": 34}, {"id": "P38", "stop": "S27", "volume_dl": 3}, {"id": "P39", "stop": "S28", "volume_dl": 59}, {"id": "P40", "stop": "S29", "volume_dl": 242}, {"id": "P41", "stop": "S30", "volume_dl": 133}, {"id": "P42", "stop": "S30", "volume_dl": 14}, {"id": "P43", "stop": "S31", "volume_dl": 179}, {"id": "P44", "stop": "S31", "volume_dl": 157}, {"id": "P45", "stop": "S32", "volume_dl": 95}, {"id": "P46", "stop": "S33", "volume_dl": 57}, {"id": "P47", "stop": "S34", "volume_dl": 59}, {"id": "P48", "stop": "S35", "volume_dl": 95}, {"id": "P49", "stop": "S36", "volume_dl": 53}, {"id": "P50", "stop": "S37", "volume_dl": 102}, {"id": "P51", "stop": "S38", "volume_dl": 12}, {"id": "P52", "stop": "S39", "volume_dl": 28}, {"id": "P53", "stop": "S40", "volume_dl": 95}, {"id": "P54", "stop": "S40", "volume_dl": 133}], "vans": 4, "capacity_dl": 1445, "travel_s": [[0, 1291, 1695, 1778, 1426, 1267, 1650, 1412, 1322, 1697, 1781, 1309, 1306, 1548, 1737, 1316, 1288, 1864, 1161, 1713, 1685, 1761, 1728, 1365, 1092, 1671, 1680, 1782, 1675, 1539, 1386, 1401, 1436, 1705, 1150, 1773, 1243, 1383, 1476, 1273, 1393], [1291, 0, 679, 658, 289, 372, 633, 275, 405, 680, 765, 395, 480, 458, 675, 425, 566, 848, 400, 651, 623, 689, 712, 168, 256, 655, 664, 766, 613, 603, 249, 521, 299, 688, 366, 756, 330, 150, 339, 342, 256], [1746, 670, 0, 268, 682, 765, 140, 668, 545, 187, 271, 788, 843, 479, 317, 558, 929, 354, 830, 268, 245, 252, 55, 537, 741, 180, 170, 273, 255, 687, 642, 704, 692, 195, 759, 77, 624, 599, 732, 689, 649], [1688, 610, 287, 0, 736, 819, 162, 722, 520, 163, 251, 842, 877, 297, 101, 533, 963, 334, 753, 96, 31, 129, 311, 477, 664, 306, 187, 180, 39, 496, 696, 626, 746, 162, 813, 364, 512, 495, 786, 611, 703], [1300, 248, 613, 695, 0, 239, 567, 104, 494, 614, 699, 262, 379, 546, 705, 514, 465, 782, 458, 695, 672, 679, 646, 301, 491, 589, 598, 700, 643, 691, 116, 610, 21, 622, 252, 690, 516, 318, 207, 577, 124], [1265, 345, 710, 792, 234, 0, 664, 219, 591, 711, 796, 42, 189, 644, 802, 610, 275, 879, 423, 792, 769, 776, 743, 398, 354, 686, 694, 797, 740, 788, 152, 707, 243, 720, 234, 787, 505, 415, 214, 535, 106], [1706, 660, 125, 128, 642, 725, 0, 628, 504, 103, 132, 748, 803, 354, 177, 518, 889, 214, 802, 128, 105, 112, 149, 526, 713, 90, 86, 140, 115, 549, 601, 655, 652, 111, 719, 202, 561, 544, 692, 660, 609], [1294, 242, 607, 689, 92, 233, 561, 0, 488, 608, 692, 256, 373, 540, 699, 507, 459, 776, 452, 689, 666, 673, 640, 294, 484, 583, 591, 694, 637, 685, 110, 604, 102, 616, 245, 684, 510, 312, 200, 570, 117], [1335, 403, 545, 496, 530, 573, 499, 516, 0, 558, 646, 615, 524, 324, 513, 32, 610, 568, 400, 489, 461, 527, 578, 271, 311, 521, 530, 575, 451, 257, 490, 173, 540, 557, 456, 622, 79, 289, 580, 258, 497], [1793, 716, 193, 148, 710, 792, 68, 695, 590, 0, 188, 815, 870, 375, 183, 604, 956, 271, 858, 156, 125, 114, 217, 583, 769, 157, 39, 94, 135, 574, 670, 704, 719, 64, 786, 270, 618, 600, 760, 716, 676], [1750, 673, 253, 234, 798, 881, 128, 784, 548, 188, 0, 904, 940, 459, 283, 561, 1026, 162, 815, 234, 210, 217, 278, 540, 726, 218, 171, 245, 220, 562, 758, 668, 808, 196, 876, 331, 574, 557, 849, 673, 766], [1297, 378, 743, 825, 266, 32, 697, 252, 624, 744, 829, 0, 221, 676, 835, 643, 307, 912, 455, 825, 802, 809, 776, 430, 386, 719, 727, 830, 773, 821, 185, 740, 276, 752, 266, 820, 537, 448, 246, 567, 139], [1177, 465, 849, 894, 373, 170, 804, 359, 497, 851, 935, 212, 0, 722, 911, 490, 148, 1018, 335, 887, 859, 925, 882, 499, 266, 825, 834, 936, 849, 714, 292, 576, 383, 859, 146, 927, 417, 482, 335, 447, 255], [1522, 445, 498, 324, 570, 653, 385, 556, 319, 386, 474, 676, 712, 0, 341, 333, 798, 556, 587, 315, 289, 355, 531, 312, 498, 474, 410, 403, 279, 462, 530, 440, 580, 385, 647, 575, 346, 329, 620, 445, 537], [1739, 662, 320, 116, 788, 870, 195, 773, 571, 186, 280, 893, 929, 345, 0, 584, 1015, 366, 804, 71, 81, 72, 344, 529, 715, 360, 210, 202, 72, 548, 747, 674, 797, 184, 864, 397, 564, 546, 838, 662, 754], [1329, 396, 548, 500, 550, 566, 502, 535, 42, 562, 649, 608, 518, 344, 516, 0, 604, 587, 393, 490, 464, 530, 581, 291, 304, 524, 533, 578, 454, 250, 509, 167, 559, 560, 450, 626, 73, 308, 600, 252, 516], [1246, 570, 945, 999, 468, 265, 899, 454, 601, 946, 1031, 307, 171, 826, 1016, 594, 0, 1114, 439, 992, 963, 1011, 978, 631, 370, 921, 930, 1032, 953, 818, 387, 680, 478, 954, 250, 1022, 522, 586, 431, 551, 350], [1746, 668, 345, 325, 794, 877, 220, 780, 543, 280, 149, 900, 935, 454, 437, 556, 1021, 0, 811, 413, 302, 309, 369, 535, 722, 310, 263, 337, 374, 558, 754, 664, 804, 288, 871, 423, 570, 553, 844, 669, 761], [1163, 337, 815, 767, 604, 400, 769, 589, 369, 828, 916, 442, 352, 594, 783, 362, 438, 838, 0, 760, 731, 798, 848, 372, 120, 791, 800, 845, 721, 586, 522, 448, 613, 827, 284, 893, 289, 354, 566, 319, 485], [1705, 628, 261, 112, 754, 836, 133, 739, 537, 137, 224, 859, 895, 314, 52, 548, 981, 308, 770, 0, 77, 45, 285, 495, 681, 227, 161, 154, 68, 514, 713, 641, 763, 136, 830, 338, 530, 512, 804, 628, 720], [1657, 580, 258, 35, 705, 788, 132, 691, 489, 134, 221, 811, 846, 266, 71, 502, 932, 304, 722, 65, 0, 98, 282, 446, 633, 276, 158, 151, 8, 466, 665, 595, 715, 133, 782, 335, 481, 464, 755, 580, 672], [1747, 669, 256, 131, 772, 855, 130, 758, 579, 114, 219, 878, 933, 355, 68, 592, 1019, 302, 811, 41, 96, 0, 280, 536, 722, 220, 138, 131, 88, 555, 732, 685, 782, 113, 850, 333, 571, 554, 823, 670, 740], [1775, 699, 66, 282, 711, 794, 154, 697, 574, 201, 285, 817, 872, 508, 331, 587, 958, 368, 859, 282, 259, 266, 0, 566, 770, 158, 184, 287, 269, 716, 671, 733, 721, 209, 788, 141, 653, 628, 761, 718, 678], [1327, 170, 602, 539, 363, 446, 556, 349, 267, 601, 688, 469, 516, 320, 556, 287, 602, 612, 436, 532, 504, 570, 635, 0, 292, 578, 587, 618, 494, 465, 323, 383, 373, 600, 440, 680, 289, 18, 413, 378, 330], [1096, 269, 769, 720, 537, 334, 723, 523, 323, 782, 870, 376, 286, 548, 737, 316, 372, 792, 143, 713, 685, 751, 802, 303, 0, 745, 754, 799, 675, 540, 455, 401, 547, 781, 217, 846, 243, 285, 499, 312, 419], [1740, 741, 176, 210, 676, 759, 82, 662, 538, 129, 213, 782, 837, 436, 262, 554, 923, 296, 884, 208, 186, 193, 165, 608, 794, 0, 112, 215, 196, 630, 635, 737, 686, 137, 753, 227, 643, 626, 726, 742, 643], [1787, 709, 186, 162, 703, 786, 61, 688, 584, 29, 181, 808, 864, 388, 197, 597, 950, 264, 851, 169, 139, 128, 210, 576, 762, 152, 0, 102, 149, 588, 662, 704, 712, 25, 780, 263, 611, 594, 753, 710, 670], [1776, 698, 271, 158, 788, 871, 146, 774, 607, 107, 266, 894, 949, 384, 192, 621, 1035, 349, 840, 165, 135, 124, 295, 565, 751, 236, 85, 0, 145, 584, 748, 714, 798, 60, 865, 348, 600, 583, 838, 698, 755], [1667, 589, 247, 44, 715, 798, 122, 701, 499, 124, 211, 821, 856, 276, 62, 512, 942, 294, 732, 54, 8, 90, 272, 456, 642, 285, 147, 140, 0, 476, 675, 605, 725, 122, 792, 325, 491, 474, 765, 590, 682], [1576, 607, 694, 520, 733, 920, 580, 719, 264, 582, 669, 962, 872, 454, 537, 277, 958, 606, 641, 513, 484, 551, 727, 474, 552, 670, 606, 599, 474, 0, 693, 357, 743, 581, 803, 771, 329, 492, 783, 661, 700], [1256, 224, 588, 671, 112, 174, 542, 98, 469, 590, 674, 196, 291, 521, 684, 488, 377, 757, 414, 668, 647, 654, 621, 276, 345, 566, 572, 676, 618, 667, 0, 585, 122, 598, 207, 666, 492, 294, 141, 552, 57], [1414, 482, 661, 613, 646, 672, 616, 632, 154, 675, 762, 714, 624, 440, 633, 147, 710, 684, 479, 604, 578, 644, 694, 388, 390, 637, 646, 692, 568, 357, 606, 0, 656, 674, 556, 739, 159, 405, 696, 404, 613], [1299, 247, 611, 694, 30, 238, 566, 103, 492, 613, 697, 261, 378, 545, 704, 512, 464, 780, 457, 694, 670, 677, 644, 299, 489, 587, 596, 699, 642, 690, 115, 608, 0, 621, 250, 689, 515, 317, 205, 575, 122], [1755, 677, 211, 137, 728, 811, 86, 713, 587, 54, 206, 834, 888, 364, 172, 600, 974, 289, 820, 144, 114, 103, 235, 544, 730, 175, 25, 77, 124, 563, 688, 693, 737, 0, 805, 288, 579, 562, 778, 678, 695], [1148, 436, 933, 866, 457, 254, 888, 443, 468, 935, 1015, 296, 206, 693, 882, 461, 292, 937, 306, 858, 830, 896, 966, 470, 237, 909, 918, 944, 820, 685, 376, 546, 467, 926, 0, 1011, 388, 453, 419, 418, 339], [1812, 736, 66, 333, 748, 831, 205, 734, 611, 253, 337, 854, 909, 544, 382, 624, 995, 420, 896, 334, 310, 317, 121, 603, 807, 243, 236, 338, 320, 753, 708, 770, 758, 261, 825, 0, 690, 665, 798, 754, 715], [1256, 323, 547, 498, 506, 493, 501, 492, 79, 560, 648, 535, 445, 326, 515, 73, 531, 569, 320, 491, 463, 529, 580, 247, 231, 523, 531, 577, 453, 313, 466, 158, 516, 559, 377, 624, 0, 340, 556, 179, 473], [1309, 152, 620, 557, 345, 428, 574, 331, 285, 618, 706, 451, 499, 337, 573, 304, 585, 630, 418, 550, 521, 588, 653, 18, 275, 596, 604, 635, 511, 482, 305, 401, 355, 617, 422, 697, 307, 0, 396, 361, 312], [1341, 309, 674, 756, 197, 190, 628, 183, 555, 675, 759, 213, 312, 607, 766, 574, 398, 842, 499, 756, 733, 740, 706, 361, 430, 650, 658, 761, 704, 752, 116, 671, 207, 683, 292, 751, 577, 379, 0, 637, 74], [1289, 348, 683, 635, 624, 562, 638, 610, 237, 697, 784, 604, 514, 462, 652, 230, 600, 706, 354, 628, 599, 666, 716, 382, 265, 659, 668, 714, 589, 454, 584, 316, 634, 696, 445, 761, 158, 365, 674, 0, 591], [1272, 239, 604, 686, 128, 116, 558, 113, 485, 605, 690, 139, 260, 538, 696, 505, 346, 773, 430, 684, 663, 670, 637, 292, 360, 580, 589, 691, 634, 682, 46, 601, 137, 614, 223, 681, 507, 309, 108, 568, 0]]}, "reference": {"optimum_s": 16301, "optimality": "best_found", "lower_bound_s": 11931, "floor_s": 8752, "solve_s": 68.28, "ffd_s": 19837, "stop_aware_best_s": 18842, "stop_aware_mean_s": 19554.6, "route_id": "RouteID_60b304da-3402-4791-b06b-3b52321199da", "plans": {"optimum": [{"route": ["S02", "S35", "S22", "S25", "S10", "S17", "S23", "S37", "S01", "S24"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S18", "S39", "S36", "S31", "S15", "S08", "S30", "S38", "S40", "S11", "S05", "S12", "S16"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S29", "S28", "S19", "S14", "S21", "S27", "S33", "S26", "S09", "S06", "S03", "S20", "S13"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S07", "S04", "S32", "S34"], "parcels": []}], "ffd": [{"route": ["S10", "S27", "S06", "S07", "S04"], "parcels": ["P07", "P11"]}, {"route": ["S31", "S15", "S29", "S03", "S21", "S10", "S23"], "parcels": ["P12", "P21"]}, {"route": ["S18", "S36", "S35", "S22", "S09", "S33", "S19", "S28", "S20", "S37", "S01", "S32", "S30", "S40", "S11", "S34"], "parcels": ["P41"]}, {"route": ["S16", "S12", "S05", "S38", "S30", "S02", "S25", "S06", "S17", "S26", "S14", "S13", "S08", "S15", "S39", "S24"], "parcels": ["P06", "P20", "P42"]}], "stop_aware_best": [{"route": ["S31", "S13", "S28", "S19", "S17", "S10", "S02", "S34"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S24", "S15", "S29", "S03", "S14", "S27", "S33", "S25", "S35", "S38", "S12", "S16"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S18", "S08", "S22", "S06", "S26", "S09", "S21", "S20", "S37", "S32", "S40", "S30"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S39", "S36", "S23", "S01", "S07", "S04", "S11", "S05"], "parcels": []}]}}, "meta": {"route_id": "RouteID_60b304da-3402-4791-b06b-3b52321199da", "split": "train", "stops": 40, "vans": 4, "tightness": 0.85, "station": "DCH4", "city": "DCH", "date": "2018-08-15", "seconds": 129.0, "stop_aware_best_reward": 0.6117, "optimality": "best_found"}}
{"id": "d590d67c-spread-n20-k3-t0.93-s0", "instance": {"stops": ["S01", "S02", "S03", "S04", "S05", "S06", "S07", "S08", "S09", "S10", "S11", "S12", "S13", "S14", "S15", "S16", "S17", "S18", "S19", "S20"], "parcels": [{"id": "P01", "stop": "S01", "volume_dl": 242}, {"id": "P02", "stop": "S02", "volume_dl": 59}, {"id": "P03", "stop": "S03", "volume_dl": 179}, {"id": "P04", "stop": "S04", "volume_dl": 28}, {"id": "P05", "stop": "S05", "volume_dl": 44}, {"id": "P06", "stop": "S06", "volume_dl": 57}, {"id": "P07", "stop": "S07", "volume_dl": 39}, {"id": "P08", "stop": "S08", "volume_dl": 429}, {"id": "P09", "stop": "S08", "volume_dl": 34}, {"id": "P10", "stop": "S09", "volume_dl": 429}, {"id": "P11", "stop": "S09", "volume_dl": 8}, {"id": "P12", "stop": "S09", "volume_dl": 57}, {"id": "P13", "stop": "S09", "volume_dl": 28}, {"id": "P14", "stop": "S10", "volume_dl": 57}, {"id": "P15", "stop": "S11", "volume_dl": 14}, {"id": "P16", "stop": "S12", "volume_dl": 47}, {"id": "P17", "stop": "S13", "volume_dl": 16}, {"id": "P18", "stop": "S13", "volume_dl": 259}, {"id": "P19", "stop": "S14", "volume_dl": 39}, {"id": "P20", "stop": "S15", "volume_dl": 157}, {"id": "P21", "stop": "S16", "volume_dl": 63}, {"id": "P22", "stop": "S16", "volume_dl": 5}, {"id": "P23", "stop": "S17", "volume_dl": 42}, {"id": "P24", "stop": "S17", "volume_dl": 226}, {"id": "P25", "stop": "S18", "volume_dl": 34}, {"id": "P26", "stop": "S19", "volume_dl": 157}, {"id": "P27", "stop": "S20", "volume_dl": 95}], "vans": 3, "capacity_dl": 1021, "travel_s": [[0, 1990, 2031, 2035, 2377, 2252, 1989, 2428, 2104, 2166, 2063, 2059, 2013, 2454, 1887, 2193, 1984, 2383, 2051, 2056, 1865], [1826, 0, 372, 116, 805, 662, 276, 856, 392, 586, 117, 403, 129, 882, 153, 613, 325, 811, 356, 402, 232], [1999, 356, 0, 278, 614, 490, 125, 665, 47, 325, 454, 709, 318, 692, 459, 353, 48, 620, 662, 52, 537], [1903, 128, 283, 0, 734, 592, 187, 785, 303, 515, 226, 481, 81, 812, 231, 543, 236, 740, 434, 313, 309], [2367, 863, 592, 801, 0, 176, 717, 176, 629, 353, 961, 1216, 842, 96, 966, 484, 639, 90, 1169, 643, 1044], [2223, 687, 447, 625, 212, 0, 572, 285, 485, 208, 785, 1040, 666, 289, 790, 340, 495, 222, 993, 499, 868], [1958, 261, 159, 182, 772, 630, 0, 823, 116, 452, 359, 614, 222, 850, 363, 480, 108, 778, 566, 164, 442], [2398, 880, 622, 818, 183, 352, 748, 0, 660, 384, 978, 1124, 859, 178, 983, 515, 670, 116, 1077, 674, 1061], [2084, 379, 43, 300, 657, 532, 118, 708, 0, 373, 477, 732, 340, 733, 482, 396, 89, 661, 685, 85, 560], [2118, 606, 336, 543, 319, 194, 462, 369, 373, 0, 704, 958, 584, 394, 708, 229, 384, 322, 911, 388, 787], [1897, 117, 468, 213, 902, 759, 373, 945, 489, 682, 0, 330, 220, 979, 225, 710, 422, 949, 282, 499, 303], [1865, 431, 719, 464, 1078, 1010, 623, 1074, 739, 933, 314, 0, 442, 1212, 340, 961, 673, 1078, 70, 749, 332], [1864, 89, 324, 69, 758, 615, 229, 809, 345, 538, 213, 442, 0, 835, 192, 566, 278, 764, 395, 355, 270], [2426, 908, 650, 846, 104, 280, 776, 176, 688, 406, 1006, 1261, 887, 0, 1011, 543, 698, 132, 1214, 702, 1089], [1727, 177, 478, 222, 912, 769, 382, 962, 498, 692, 335, 338, 201, 989, 0, 720, 432, 917, 291, 508, 133], [2172, 633, 364, 570, 498, 373, 489, 548, 401, 208, 731, 986, 611, 575, 736, 0, 411, 503, 938, 415, 814], [1994, 308, 46, 230, 661, 536, 77, 711, 108, 376, 407, 661, 270, 738, 411, 399, 0, 666, 614, 76, 490], [2388, 891, 612, 829, 92, 272, 737, 101, 648, 368, 990, 1091, 870, 134, 994, 504, 660, 0, 1044, 664, 1072], [1871, 391, 679, 423, 1038, 970, 583, 1034, 699, 893, 274, 55, 402, 1172, 300, 920, 632, 1038, 0, 709, 395], [2030, 425, 54, 347, 669, 544, 165, 720, 85, 380, 524, 778, 387, 746, 528, 407, 81, 674, 731, 0, 606], [1714, 265, 566, 310, 999, 857, 470, 1050, 586, 780, 400, 356, 289, 1077, 162, 808, 520, 1005, 348, 596, 0]]}, "reference": {"optimum_s": 15252, "optimality": "best_found", "lower_bound_s": 12797, "floor_s": 10737, "solve_s": 44.18, "ffd_s": 16736, "stop_aware_best_s": 17008, "stop_aware_mean_s": 17212.2, "route_id": "RouteID_d590d67c-a64b-4eff-88c6-9c7d51cf0c4d", "plans": {"optimum": [{"route": ["S09", "S02", "S16", "S12", "S01", "S10", "S18", "S11"], "parcels": ["P10"]}, {"route": ["S15", "S09", "S17", "S07", "S13", "S04", "S05"], "parcels": ["P11", "P12", "P13"]}, {"route": ["S19", "S08", "S06", "S03", "S14", "S20"], "parcels": []}], "ffd": [{"route": ["S16", "S08", "S15", "S09"], "parcels": ["P08", "P10", "P22"]}, {"route": ["S17", "S13", "S03", "S01", "S20"], "parcels": ["P24"]}, {"route": ["S07", "S17", "S04", "S05", "S09", "S08", "S02", "S19", "S16", "S06", "S12", "S10", "S18", "S11", "S14"], "parcels": ["P09", "P11", "P12", "P13", "P21", "P23"]}], "stop_aware_best": [{"route": ["S05", "S07", "S02", "S08", "S01", "S14", "S20", "S11"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S17", "S13", "S04", "S15", "S06", "S03", "S12"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S09", "S19", "S16", "S10", "S18"], "parcels": []}]}}, "meta": {"route_id": "RouteID_d590d67c-a64b-4eff-88c6-9c7d51cf0c4d", "split": "train", "stops": 20, "vans": 3, "tightness": 0.93, "station": "DCH3", "city": "DCH", "date": "2018-08-10", "seconds": 65.4, "stop_aware_best_reward": 0.5738, "optimality": "best_found"}}
{"id": "4e6f9dd3-spread-n40-k4-t0.94-s0", "instance": {"stops": ["S01", "S02", "S03", "S04", "S05", "S06", "S07", "S08", "S09", "S10", "S11", "S12", "S13", "S14", "S15", "S16", "S17", "S18", "S19", "S20", "S21", "S22", "S23", "S24", "S25", "S26", "S27", "S28", "S29", "S30", "S31", "S32", "S33", "S34", "S35", "S36", "S37", "S38", "S39", "S40"], "parcels": [{"id": "P001", "stop": "S01", "volume_dl": 6}, {"id": "P002", "stop": "S01", "volume_dl": 51}, {"id": "P003", "stop": "S02", "volume_dl": 20}, {"id": "P004", "stop": "S03", "volume_dl": 33}, {"id": "P005", "stop": "S04", "volume_dl": 133}, {"id": "P006", "stop": "S04", "volume_dl": 39}, {"id": "P007", "stop": "S04", "volume_dl": 6}, {"id": "P008", "stop": "S04", "volume_dl": 57}, {"id": "P009", "stop": "S04", "volume_dl": 12}, {"id": "P010", "stop": "S04", "volume_dl": 95}, {"id": "P011", "stop": "S05", "volume_dl": 63}, {"id": "P012", "stop": "S06", "volume_dl": 27}, {"id": "P013", "stop": "S06", "volume_dl": 95}, {"id": "P014", "stop": "S06", "volume_dl": 57}, {"id": "P015", "stop": "S06", "volume_dl": 133}, {"id": "P016", "stop": "S07", "volume_dl": 60}, {"id": "P017", "stop": "S07", "volume_dl": 157}, {"id": "P018", "stop": "S07", "volume_dl": 30}, {"id": "P019", "stop": "S07", "volume_dl": 7}, {"id": "P020", "stop": "S08", "volume_dl": 36}, {"id": "P021", "stop": "S09", "volume_dl": 6}, {"id": "P022", "stop": "S10", "volume_dl": 28}, {"id": "P023", "stop": "S10", "volume_dl": 34}, {"id": "P024", "stop": "S11", "volume_dl": 20}, {"id": "P025", "stop": "S12", "volume_dl": 14}, {"id": "P026", "stop": "S13", "volume_dl": 242}, {"id": "P027", "stop": "S13", "volume_dl": 57}, {"id": "P028", "stop": "S13", "volume_dl": 179}, {"id": "P029", "stop": "S13", "volume_dl": 104}, {"id": "P030", "stop": "S14", "volume_dl": 57}, {"id": "P031", "stop": "S14", "volume_dl": 102}, {"id": "P032", "stop": "S15", "volume_dl": 134}, {"id": "P033", "stop": "S15", "volume_dl": 157}, {"id": "P034", "stop": "S15", "volume_dl": 157}, {"id": "P035", "stop": "S15", "volume_dl": 12}, {"id": "P036", "stop": "S15", "volume_dl": 45}, {"id": "P037", "stop": "S16", "volume_dl": 133}, {"id": "P038", "stop": "S17", "volume_dl": 4}, {"id": "P039", "stop": "S18", "volume_dl": 57}, {"id": "P040", "stop": "S18", "volume_dl": 779}, {"id": "P041", "stop": "S18", "volume_dl": 179}, {"id": "P042", "stop": "S19", "volume_dl": 57}, {"id": "P043", "stop": "S19", "volume_dl": 429}, {"id": "P044", "stop": "S20", "volume_dl": 15}, {"id": "P045", "stop": "S20", "volume_dl": 25}, {"id": "P046", "stop": "S20", "volume_dl": 322}, {"id": "P047", "stop": "S21", "volume_dl": 23}, {"id": "P048", "stop": "S22", "volume_dl": 104}, {"id": "P049", "stop": "S22", "volume_dl": 23}, {"id": "P050", "stop": "S22", "volume_dl": 133}, {"id": "P051", "stop": "S23", "volume_dl": 134}, {"id": "P052", "stop": "S24", "volume_dl": 95}, {"id": "P053", "stop": "S25", "volume_dl": 3}, {"id": "P054", "stop": "S26", "volume_dl": 134}, {"id": "P055", "stop": "S26", "volume_dl": 242}, {"id": "P056", "stop": "S26", "volume_dl": 92}, {"id": "P057", "stop": "S27", "volume_dl": 38}, {"id": "P058", "stop": "S28", "volume_dl": 277}, {"id": "P059", "stop": "S29", "volume_dl": 179}, {"id": "P060", "stop": "S29", "volume_dl": 57}, {"id": "P061", "stop": "S29", "volume_dl": 133}, {"id": "P062", "stop": "S29", "volume_dl": 57}, {"id": "P063", "stop": "S29", "volume_dl": 46}, {"id": "P064", "stop": "S29", "volume_dl": 36}, {"id": "P065", "stop": "S29", "volume_dl": 41}, {"id": "P066", "stop": "S29", "volume_dl": 552}, {"id": "P067", "stop": "S29", "volume_dl": 32}, {"id": "P068", "stop": "S29", "volume_dl": 133}, {"id": "P069", "stop": "S29", "volume_dl": 259}, {"id": "P070", "stop": "S29", "volume_dl": 21}, {"id": "P071", "stop": "S29", "volume_dl": 372}, {"id": "P072", "stop": "S29", "volume_dl": 34}, {"id": "P073", "stop": "S29", "volume_dl": 25}, {"id": "P074", "stop": "S29", "volume_dl": 92}, {"id": "P075", "stop": "S29", "volume_dl": 133}, {"id": "P076", "stop": "S29", "volume_dl": 63}, {"id": "P077", "stop": "S29", "volume_dl": 5}, {"id": "P078", "stop": "S29", "volume_dl": 322}, {"id": "P079", "stop": "S29", "volume_dl": 133}, {"id": "P080", "stop": "S29", "volume_dl": 95}, {"id": "P081", "stop": "S30", "volume_dl": 30}, {"id": "P082", "stop": "S30", "volume_dl": 13}, {"id": "P083", "stop": "S30", "volume_dl": 277}, {"id": "P084", "stop": "S30", "volume_dl": 34}, {"id": "P085", "stop": "S30", "volume_dl": 35}, {"id": "P086", "stop": "S30", "volume_dl": 11}, {"id": "P087", "stop": "S30", "volume_dl": 41}, {"id": "P088", "stop": "S30", "volume_dl": 59}, {"id": "P089", "stop": "S30", "volume_dl": 599}, {"id": "P090", "stop": "S30", "volume_dl": 92}, {"id": "P091", "stop": "S31", "volume_dl": 53}, {"id": "P092", "stop": "S32", "volume_dl": 15}, {"id": "P093", "stop": "S33", "volume_dl": 34}, {"id": "P094", "stop": "S34", "volume_dl": 57}, {"id": "P095", "stop": "S34", "volume_dl": 24}, {"id": "P096", "stop": "S34", "volume_dl": 57}, {"id": "P097", "stop": "S34", "volume_dl": 95}, {"id": "P098", "stop": "S34", "volume_dl": 242}, {"id": "P099", "stop": "S34", "volume_dl": 40}, {"id": "P100", "stop": "S34", "volume_dl": 14}, {"id": "P101", "stop": "S34", "volume_dl": 179}, {"id": "P102", "stop": "S35", "volume_dl": 95}, {"id": "P103", "stop": "S35", "volume_dl": 47}, {"id": "P104", "stop": "S36", "volume_dl": 104}, {"id": "P105", "stop": "S36", "volume_dl": 294}, {"id": "P106", "stop": "S37", "volume_dl": 40}, {"id": "P107", "stop": "S38", "volume_dl": 32}, {"id": "P108", "stop": "S38", "volume_dl": 88}, {"id": "P109", "stop": "S38", "volume_dl": 21}, {"id": "P110", "stop": "S38", "volume_dl": 57}, {"id": "P111", "stop": "S38", "volume_dl": 24}, {"id": "P112", "stop": "S38", "volume_dl": 289}, {"id": "P113", "stop": "S38", "volume_dl": 26}, {"id": "P114", "stop": "S38", "volume_dl": 63}, {"id": "P115", "stop": "S38", "volume_dl": 95}, {"id": "P116", "stop": "S38", "volume_dl": 36}, {"id": "P117", "stop": "S39", "volume_dl": 157}, {"id": "P118", "stop": "S39", "volume_dl": 134}, {"id": "P119", "stop": "S39", "volume_dl": 79}, {"id": "P120", "stop": "S39", "volume_dl": 34}, {"id": "P121", "stop": "S40", "volume_dl": 104}], "vans": 4, "capacity_dl": 3301, "travel_s": [[0, 2809, 2574, 2635, 2728, 2751, 2848, 2743, 2780, 2792, 2746, 2651, 2774, 2633, 2758, 2695, 2824, 2804, 2798, 2869, 2581, 2674, 2647, 2783, 2774, 2753, 2602, 2578, 2607, 2860, 2574, 2610, 2753, 2731, 2656, 2831, 2775, 2580, 2906, 2824, 2810], [3152, 0, 237, 254, 202, 223, 65, 112, 76, 111, 217, 269, 153, 237, 106, 297, 136, 153, 270, 331, 230, 297, 248, 134, 332, 224, 292, 288, 305, 236, 307, 301, 145, 224, 214, 155, 209, 230, 368, 15, 93], [2916, 235, 0, 62, 155, 177, 274, 169, 206, 219, 172, 77, 201, 60, 185, 128, 250, 230, 224, 295, 8, 111, 88, 209, 192, 179, 56, 51, 68, 286, 70, 64, 180, 158, 82, 257, 201, 6, 332, 250, 237], [2957, 252, 42, 0, 172, 194, 291, 186, 223, 236, 189, 16, 218, 76, 202, 137, 267, 247, 241, 312, 34, 44, 104, 226, 201, 196, 97, 93, 110, 303, 112, 106, 196, 174, 188, 274, 218, 35, 349, 267, 254], [3109, 168, 194, 210, 0, 108, 120, 144, 155, 118, 106, 226, 46, 193, 93, 253, 110, 98, 155, 226, 186, 254, 205, 73, 288, 110, 249, 245, 261, 154, 264, 258, 89, 180, 170, 124, 68, 187, 263, 170, 82], [3082, 230, 166, 183, 140, 0, 210, 164, 227, 190, 38, 198, 182, 166, 202, 230, 186, 155, 46, 116, 159, 227, 178, 165, 261, 45, 222, 217, 234, 172, 237, 230, 198, 152, 143, 182, 126, 160, 153, 245, 172], [3201, 48, 285, 302, 125, 233, 0, 160, 124, 159, 228, 317, 149, 285, 154, 345, 185, 93, 229, 271, 277, 346, 296, 182, 380, 182, 346, 329, 353, 176, 363, 335, 193, 304, 262, 101, 149, 278, 308, 50, 40], [3160, 184, 244, 261, 90, 230, 210, 0, 162, 126, 224, 276, 82, 244, 69, 304, 103, 223, 274, 316, 236, 305, 256, 62, 339, 232, 300, 295, 312, 279, 314, 308, 33, 231, 221, 250, 194, 238, 353, 199, 172], [3122, 90, 206, 223, 172, 192, 153, 82, 0, 68, 187, 239, 111, 206, 76, 270, 94, 196, 239, 289, 199, 267, 218, 93, 301, 194, 262, 258, 274, 252, 277, 271, 114, 194, 183, 222, 166, 200, 326, 104, 172], [3141, 136, 226, 242, 150, 212, 180, 101, 95, 0, 206, 258, 81, 226, 95, 289, 65, 167, 218, 260, 218, 286, 237, 64, 320, 213, 281, 277, 294, 223, 296, 290, 97, 213, 202, 193, 137, 219, 297, 151, 143], [3091, 252, 175, 192, 122, 33, 194, 186, 212, 175, 0, 208, 167, 175, 184, 235, 171, 122, 84, 154, 167, 236, 187, 150, 270, 7, 235, 226, 243, 211, 250, 239, 183, 161, 152, 146, 90, 169, 187, 267, 172], [2968, 262, 52, 10, 182, 204, 301, 196, 233, 246, 199, 0, 228, 87, 212, 122, 277, 258, 251, 322, 44, 28, 115, 236, 185, 206, 108, 103, 120, 314, 122, 116, 207, 185, 173, 284, 228, 45, 359, 277, 264], [3138, 162, 222, 239, 96, 208, 140, 98, 127, 91, 203, 255, 0, 222, 47, 286, 68, 188, 239, 281, 215, 283, 234, 27, 317, 210, 278, 274, 290, 244, 293, 287, 43, 210, 199, 215, 159, 216, 318, 190, 102], [2973, 253, 57, 74, 172, 195, 292, 187, 223, 236, 192, 89, 218, 0, 202, 190, 267, 248, 242, 312, 50, 118, 144, 226, 144, 196, 113, 108, 125, 304, 128, 121, 197, 175, 72, 274, 218, 51, 349, 267, 254], [3091, 115, 175, 192, 103, 161, 188, 50, 86, 91, 156, 208, 48, 175, 0, 235, 68, 188, 208, 279, 168, 236, 187, 28, 270, 163, 231, 226, 243, 244, 246, 240, 50, 162, 152, 215, 159, 169, 316, 130, 150], [3037, 303, 146, 131, 222, 245, 342, 237, 274, 286, 240, 121, 268, 89, 252, 0, 318, 298, 292, 363, 138, 102, 150, 277, 77, 247, 159, 191, 160, 354, 192, 168, 247, 225, 78, 325, 269, 139, 400, 318, 305], [3166, 160, 250, 267, 126, 236, 140, 125, 120, 83, 174, 282, 58, 250, 77, 314, 0, 161, 212, 254, 242, 310, 261, 40, 345, 165, 306, 301, 318, 217, 320, 314, 73, 237, 227, 187, 131, 243, 291, 175, 102], [3145, 138, 230, 246, 135, 136, 86, 206, 170, 205, 103, 262, 155, 229, 200, 293, 159, 0, 159, 201, 222, 290, 241, 138, 324, 94, 285, 281, 298, 83, 300, 294, 171, 248, 206, 26, 27, 223, 238, 153, 50], [3126, 274, 211, 227, 178, 43, 247, 208, 245, 228, 82, 243, 220, 210, 224, 270, 224, 273, 0, 70, 203, 271, 222, 203, 305, 90, 266, 262, 278, 210, 281, 275, 219, 197, 187, 247, 163, 204, 108, 289, 210], [3210, 360, 295, 311, 233, 127, 302, 324, 319, 283, 241, 327, 275, 294, 295, 355, 278, 250, 84, 0, 287, 355, 306, 258, 390, 231, 350, 346, 363, 265, 365, 359, 291, 281, 271, 224, 218, 288, 37, 375, 264], [2923, 228, 8, 54, 147, 170, 267, 162, 198, 211, 164, 111, 193, 52, 177, 140, 242, 223, 217, 288, 0, 93, 80, 201, 192, 171, 64, 59, 76, 279, 78, 72, 172, 150, 74, 249, 193, 1, 324, 242, 229], [2986, 281, 71, 29, 201, 223, 320, 215, 252, 265, 218, 19, 247, 156, 231, 93, 296, 276, 270, 341, 63, 0, 134, 255, 157, 225, 153, 122, 139, 332, 141, 161, 225, 203, 145, 303, 247, 64, 378, 296, 283], [3072, 259, 138, 200, 178, 201, 298, 193, 230, 242, 196, 215, 224, 149, 208, 268, 274, 254, 248, 319, 146, 247, 0, 233, 224, 203, 110, 92, 179, 310, 126, 98, 203, 181, 106, 281, 225, 145, 356, 274, 260], [3128, 140, 212, 229, 86, 198, 157, 87, 99, 63, 193, 245, 17, 212, 37, 276, 41, 161, 212, 254, 205, 273, 224, 0, 307, 200, 268, 264, 280, 217, 283, 276, 33, 200, 189, 187, 131, 206, 291, 155, 120], [3096, 362, 205, 190, 282, 304, 401, 296, 333, 346, 299, 180, 328, 148, 312, 85, 377, 357, 351, 422, 197, 161, 210, 336, 0, 306, 218, 250, 219, 413, 251, 227, 306, 284, 137, 384, 328, 198, 459, 377, 364], [3101, 248, 185, 202, 118, 42, 187, 182, 204, 168, 10, 217, 160, 185, 180, 249, 164, 115, 89, 160, 177, 246, 196, 143, 280, 0, 241, 236, 253, 171, 255, 249, 176, 171, 162, 141, 85, 178, 197, 263, 165], [2960, 286, 51, 113, 206, 229, 326, 221, 257, 270, 226, 156, 252, 111, 236, 158, 301, 282, 276, 346, 59, 137, 125, 260, 218, 230, 0, 32, 155, 338, 104, 8, 231, 209, 133, 308, 252, 58, 383, 301, 288], [2935, 281, 46, 107, 200, 223, 320, 215, 252, 264, 218, 123, 246, 105, 230, 201, 296, 276, 270, 341, 53, 184, 119, 255, 246, 225, 46, 0, 87, 332, 82, 35, 225, 203, 128, 303, 247, 52, 378, 296, 283], [2947, 321, 86, 188, 241, 263, 360, 255, 292, 305, 258, 178, 287, 146, 271, 176, 336, 316, 310, 381, 94, 159, 159, 295, 240, 265, 156, 90, 0, 372, 101, 164, 265, 243, 228, 343, 287, 92, 418, 336, 323], [3203, 243, 287, 304, 171, 194, 191, 262, 257, 221, 161, 319, 213, 287, 233, 347, 216, 124, 216, 258, 280, 348, 299, 196, 382, 151, 343, 338, 355, 0, 358, 351, 229, 306, 264, 131, 85, 281, 296, 258, 155], [2926, 295, 60, 121, 214, 237, 334, 229, 265, 278, 234, 137, 260, 119, 244, 184, 310, 290, 284, 354, 67, 160, 133, 269, 260, 239, 88, 64, 93, 346, 0, 96, 239, 217, 142, 317, 261, 66, 392, 310, 296], [2958, 298, 62, 124, 217, 240, 337, 232, 268, 281, 234, 167, 263, 122, 247, 165, 312, 293, 287, 357, 70, 148, 136, 271, 229, 241, 11, 23, 110, 349, 96, 0, 242, 220, 144, 319, 263, 69, 394, 312, 299], [3127, 151, 211, 228, 53, 152, 172, 86, 129, 93, 147, 243, 50, 211, 36, 275, 70, 190, 241, 283, 204, 272, 223, 29, 306, 154, 267, 262, 279, 246, 282, 275, 0, 198, 188, 217, 161, 205, 320, 166, 135], [3149, 173, 233, 250, 79, 219, 199, 108, 151, 115, 214, 265, 72, 233, 58, 297, 92, 212, 263, 305, 226, 294, 245, 51, 328, 221, 289, 284, 301, 268, 304, 297, 22, 0, 210, 239, 183, 227, 342, 188, 161], [2991, 225, 75, 92, 145, 167, 264, 159, 196, 209, 162, 107, 191, 75, 175, 83, 240, 220, 214, 285, 67, 136, 73, 199, 118, 169, 154, 136, 143, 276, 171, 143, 170, 148, 0, 247, 191, 69, 322, 240, 227], [3172, 115, 256, 272, 163, 162, 67, 219, 182, 190, 130, 288, 182, 256, 201, 316, 185, 26, 185, 227, 248, 316, 267, 164, 351, 120, 312, 307, 324, 109, 326, 320, 198, 274, 232, 0, 53, 249, 264, 117, 78], [3118, 168, 202, 219, 86, 109, 116, 178, 199, 136, 72, 235, 128, 202, 148, 262, 132, 29, 132, 174, 195, 263, 214, 111, 297, 67, 258, 254, 270, 85, 273, 267, 144, 221, 179, 56, 0, 196, 211, 183, 80], [2922, 229, 6, 55, 148, 171, 268, 163, 199, 212, 165, 110, 194, 53, 178, 135, 243, 224, 218, 288, 1, 92, 81, 202, 193, 172, 62, 58, 74, 280, 77, 71, 173, 151, 75, 250, 194, 0, 325, 243, 230], [3254, 324, 338, 354, 276, 170, 254, 368, 362, 326, 284, 370, 318, 338, 338, 398, 322, 213, 127, 43, 330, 398, 349, 301, 433, 274, 394, 389, 406, 296, 408, 402, 334, 324, 314, 187, 240, 331, 0, 309, 259], [3168, 15, 252, 268, 217, 238, 60, 127, 91, 126, 232, 284, 168, 252, 121, 312, 152, 168, 285, 346, 244, 312, 263, 149, 347, 240, 342, 325, 320, 251, 359, 331, 160, 239, 228, 170, 224, 245, 383, 0, 97], [3194, 86, 278, 295, 84, 193, 37, 175, 139, 174, 187, 310, 109, 278, 169, 342, 113, 138, 189, 231, 270, 338, 289, 127, 373, 142, 334, 366, 346, 194, 348, 373, 152, 264, 255, 82, 108, 271, 268, 88, 0]]}, "reference": {"optimum_s": 25522, "optimality": "best_found", "lower_bound_s": 23067, "floor_s": 21960, "solve_s": 94.85, "ffd_s": 28635, "stop_aware_best_s": 26505, "stop_aware_mean_s": 26741.8, "route_id": "RouteID_4e6f9dd3-7949-45ed-aa93-d1bb033dc649", "plans": {"optimum": [{"route": ["S27", "S31", "S26", "S02", "S18", "S19", "S38", "S35", "S17", "S40", "S06", "S39", "S01", "S08", "S20"], "parcels": ["P041", "P045"]}, {"route": ["S20", "S36", "S29"], "parcels": ["P044"]}, {"route": ["S30", "S20", "S10", "S25", "S18", "S05", "S13"], "parcels": ["P039", "P040", "P046"]}, {"route": ["S22", "S33", "S23", "S09", "S16", "S12", "S14", "S07", "S32", "S04", "S34", "S24", "S15", "S21", "S11", "S03", "S37", "S28"], "parcels": []}], "ffd": [{"route": ["S30", "S20", "S01", "S29", "S19", "S18", "S13"], "parcels": ["P001", "P026", "P040", "P043", "P046", "P066", "P071", "P089"]}, {"route": ["S30", "S26", "S07", "S04", "S36", "S29", "S38", "S18", "S05", "S34", "S15", "S13", "S28"], "parcels": ["P007", "P017", "P028", "P033", "P041", "P055", "P059", "P069", "P078", "P083", "P098", "P101", "P105", "P112"]}, {"route": ["S26", "S22", "S04", "S36", "S29", "S38", "S35", "S40", "S06", "S39", "S16", "S23", "S14", "S34", "S24", "S15", "S13", "S02"], "parcels": ["P005", "P010", "P013", "P015", "P029", "P031", "P032", "P034", "P048", "P050", "P054", "P056", "P061", "P068", "P074", "P075", "P079", "P080", "P097", "P102", "P104", "P115", "P117", "P118"]}, {"route": ["S30", "S37", "S20", "S13", "S03", "S11", "S21", "S15", "S34", "S33", "S12", "S14", "S07", "S32", "S04", "S17", "S29", "S25", "S10", "S18", "S19", "S38", "S35", "S06", "S39", "S01", "S08", "S09", "S22", "S31", "S27"], "parcels": ["P002", "P006", "P008", "P009", "P012", "P014", "P016", "P018", "P019", "P027", "P030", "P035", "P036", "P039", "P042", "P044", "P045", "P049", "P060", "P062", "P063", "P064", "P065", "P067", "P070", "P072", "P073", "P076", "P077", "P081", "P082", "P084", "P085", "P086", "P087", "P088", "P090", "P094", "P095", "P096", "P099", "P100", "P103", "P107", "P108", "P109", "P110", "P111", "P113", "P114", "P116", "P119", "P120"]}], "stop_aware_best": [{"route": ["S20", "S13", "S24", "S21", "S03", "S19", "S38", "S36", "S12", "S14", "S22", "S31", "S27"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S08", "S09", "S29", "S25", "S10", "S05", "S28"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S30", "S26", "S02", "S07", "S32", "S16", "S17", "S35", "S06", "S40", "S04", "S11", "S37"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S33", "S23", "S39", "S01", "S18", "S34", "S15"], "parcels": []}]}}, "meta": {"route_id": "RouteID_4e6f9dd3-7949-45ed-aa93-d1bb033dc649", "split": "train", "stops": 40, "vans": 4, "tightness": 0.94, "station": "DBO3", "city": "DBO", "date": "2018-07-23", "seconds": 159.4, "stop_aware_best_reward": 0.6677, "optimality": "best_found"}}
{"id": "83c8fc14-spread-n30-k4-t0.91-s0", "instance": {"stops": ["S01", "S02", "S03", "S04", "S05", "S06", "S07", "S08", "S09", "S10", "S11", "S12", "S13", "S14", "S15", "S16", "S17", "S18", "S19", "S20", "S21", "S22", "S23", "S24", "S25", "S26", "S27", "S28", "S29", "S30"], "parcels": [{"id": "P01", "stop": "S01", "volume_dl": 57}, {"id": "P02", "stop": "S02", "volume_dl": 242}, {"id": "P03", "stop": "S03", "volume_dl": 9}, {"id": "P04", "stop": "S03", "volume_dl": 134}, {"id": "P05", "stop": "S04", "volume_dl": 57}, {"id": "P06", "stop": "S05", "volume_dl": 57}, {"id": "P07", "stop": "S06", "volume_dl": 34}, {"id": "P08", "stop": "S07", "volume_dl": 34}, {"id": "P09", "stop": "S07", "volume_dl": 599}, {"id": "P10", "stop": "S07", "volume_dl": 10}, {"id": "P11", "stop": "S07", "volume_dl": 226}, {"id": "P12", "stop": "S08", "volume_dl": 413}, {"id": "P13", "stop": "S09", "volume_dl": 23}, {"id": "P14", "stop": "S10", "volume_dl": 261}, {"id": "P15", "stop": "S11", "volume_dl": 43}, {"id": "P16", "stop": "S11", "volume_dl": 2}, {"id": "P17", "stop": "S12", "volume_dl": 89}, {"id": "P18", "stop": "S13", "volume_dl": 28}, {"id": "P19", "stop": "S14", "volume_dl": 45}, {"id": "P20", "stop": "S15", "volume_dl": 104}, {"id": "P21", "stop": "S16", "volume_dl": 21}, {"id": "P22", "stop": "S17", "volume_dl": 57}, {"id": "P23", "stop": "S18", "volume_dl": 248}, {"id": "P24", "stop": "S19", "volume_dl": 19}, {"id": "P25", "stop": "S20", "volume_dl": 34}, {"id": "P26", "stop": "S21", "volume_dl": 133}, {"id": "P27", "stop": "S22", "volume_dl": 56}, {"id": "P28", "stop": "S23", "volume_dl": 368}, {"id": "P29", "stop": "S23", "volume_dl": 355}, {"id": "P30", "stop": "S23", "volume_dl": 57}, {"id": "P31", "stop": "S24", "volume_dl": 27}, {"id": "P32", "stop": "S25", "volume_dl": 11}, {"id": "P33", "stop": "S26", "volume_dl": 57}, {"id": "P34", "stop": "S27", "volume_dl": 44}, {"id": "P35", "stop": "S28", "volume_dl": 57}, {"id": "P36", "stop": "S29", "volume_dl": 134}, {"id": "P37", "stop": "S29", "volume_dl": 54}, {"id": "P38", "stop": "S30", "volume_dl": 133}, {"id": "P39", "stop": "S30", "volume_dl": 104}, {"id": "P40", "stop": "S30", "volume_dl": 13}], "vans": 4, "capacity_dl": 1224, "travel_s": [[0, 1814, 1743, 1914, 1967, 1922, 2020, 2076, 1831, 1957, 1997, 1860, 1920, 1961, 1875, 1767, 1903, 1904, 1947, 1914, 2005, 1978, 1987, 1890, 2005, 1866, 1836, 1835, 1844, 1981, 1998], [1966, 0, 289, 549, 564, 302, 566, 629, 568, 503, 736, 264, 657, 699, 163, 504, 283, 88, 801, 549, 458, 171, 297, 197, 519, 153, 573, 417, 489, 291, 852], [1952, 271, 0, 311, 327, 250, 278, 395, 331, 214, 447, 188, 420, 461, 435, 267, 231, 305, 563, 311, 262, 307, 316, 237, 262, 194, 336, 257, 297, 337, 614], [2077, 529, 397, 0, 7, 508, 149, 80, 254, 209, 196, 446, 120, 103, 693, 240, 488, 563, 380, 0, 451, 564, 648, 495, 452, 452, 294, 480, 350, 526, 430], [2108, 527, 407, 10, 0, 506, 160, 90, 252, 219, 206, 444, 113, 95, 691, 238, 487, 561, 390, 10, 462, 563, 572, 493, 462, 450, 287, 478, 342, 537, 441], [2116, 304, 215, 475, 491, 0, 493, 555, 495, 430, 662, 110, 584, 625, 468, 431, 19, 338, 727, 475, 392, 339, 231, 288, 478, 245, 500, 339, 461, 225, 778], [2190, 563, 292, 154, 161, 588, 0, 142, 408, 104, 194, 549, 274, 257, 728, 394, 568, 598, 378, 154, 347, 599, 544, 530, 347, 486, 448, 550, 504, 422, 429], [2198, 606, 403, 78, 85, 585, 155, 0, 332, 215, 202, 524, 198, 181, 771, 318, 566, 641, 368, 78, 457, 642, 654, 573, 458, 529, 372, 558, 428, 532, 418], [1945, 523, 323, 266, 345, 502, 415, 346, 0, 475, 462, 440, 297, 339, 687, 134, 483, 557, 641, 266, 585, 559, 568, 489, 586, 446, 213, 474, 218, 561, 692], [2178, 497, 226, 210, 218, 521, 81, 198, 464, 0, 251, 483, 331, 313, 661, 493, 502, 531, 435, 210, 280, 533, 477, 463, 281, 420, 505, 483, 523, 355, 486], [2110, 713, 446, 184, 192, 742, 198, 173, 438, 258, 0, 703, 305, 287, 878, 424, 722, 748, 298, 184, 500, 749, 697, 680, 501, 636, 479, 669, 534, 575, 348], [2064, 276, 163, 424, 439, 140, 441, 504, 443, 378, 611, 0, 532, 573, 440, 379, 121, 310, 675, 424, 364, 311, 203, 260, 426, 216, 448, 287, 409, 197, 726], [2003, 634, 434, 125, 114, 613, 274, 205, 286, 334, 321, 551, 0, 116, 798, 206, 594, 668, 505, 125, 576, 670, 678, 600, 577, 557, 220, 526, 276, 651, 556], [2055, 633, 513, 116, 106, 612, 265, 196, 358, 325, 312, 550, 106, 0, 797, 344, 593, 667, 496, 116, 568, 668, 677, 599, 568, 556, 272, 584, 328, 643, 547], [2039, 175, 465, 725, 740, 478, 742, 805, 744, 679, 912, 440, 833, 875, 0, 680, 459, 264, 977, 725, 634, 347, 473, 372, 695, 329, 749, 574, 646, 467, 1027], [1879, 518, 318, 273, 263, 497, 422, 353, 123, 482, 469, 435, 215, 257, 682, 0, 478, 552, 576, 273, 580, 554, 563, 484, 581, 441, 131, 402, 152, 557, 626], [2096, 285, 196, 456, 471, 19, 474, 536, 475, 410, 643, 91, 564, 606, 449, 412, 0, 319, 708, 456, 373, 320, 212, 269, 458, 226, 480, 320, 442, 206, 759], [2067, 113, 328, 588, 603, 341, 605, 668, 607, 542, 775, 303, 696, 738, 277, 543, 322, 0, 840, 588, 497, 210, 336, 235, 558, 192, 612, 470, 604, 330, 890], [2079, 746, 546, 387, 395, 725, 401, 376, 544, 461, 296, 663, 508, 490, 910, 480, 706, 780, 0, 387, 703, 782, 791, 712, 704, 669, 549, 638, 511, 704, 51], [2077, 529, 397, 0, 7, 508, 149, 80, 254, 209, 196, 446, 120, 103, 693, 240, 488, 563, 380, 0, 451, 564, 648, 495, 452, 452, 294, 480, 350, 526, 430], [2219, 441, 267, 446, 454, 354, 317, 434, 598, 254, 486, 315, 567, 549, 605, 534, 334, 475, 671, 446, 0, 476, 309, 425, 124, 382, 602, 544, 564, 187, 721], [2095, 145, 318, 579, 594, 332, 596, 659, 598, 533, 766, 293, 687, 729, 309, 534, 312, 179, 830, 579, 488, 0, 326, 226, 549, 183, 603, 460, 635, 320, 881], [2213, 307, 286, 546, 562, 219, 501, 618, 566, 437, 670, 181, 655, 696, 471, 502, 200, 341, 798, 546, 316, 342, 0, 291, 378, 248, 570, 410, 532, 149, 849], [2046, 215, 229, 489, 504, 284, 506, 569, 508, 443, 676, 260, 597, 639, 379, 444, 265, 249, 741, 489, 440, 250, 279, 0, 491, 66, 513, 370, 475, 273, 791], [2203, 484, 251, 430, 438, 397, 301, 418, 582, 238, 471, 358, 551, 533, 648, 518, 378, 518, 655, 430, 86, 520, 352, 468, 0, 425, 587, 508, 548, 230, 706], [1980, 171, 185, 445, 460, 241, 462, 525, 464, 399, 632, 216, 553, 595, 335, 400, 221, 205, 697, 445, 397, 206, 235, 46, 447, 0, 469, 327, 431, 229, 748], [1918, 548, 348, 297, 287, 528, 446, 377, 201, 506, 493, 466, 239, 281, 713, 120, 508, 583, 614, 297, 611, 584, 593, 515, 611, 472, 0, 440, 190, 587, 665], [2045, 403, 275, 496, 560, 370, 552, 576, 424, 489, 722, 308, 513, 554, 568, 360, 351, 438, 656, 496, 537, 439, 433, 370, 537, 326, 428, 0, 390, 427, 707], [1833, 464, 264, 343, 333, 443, 492, 423, 196, 479, 539, 381, 285, 327, 628, 132, 424, 498, 530, 343, 526, 500, 509, 430, 527, 387, 201, 356, 0, 503, 581], [2191, 311, 291, 518, 526, 224, 389, 507, 570, 326, 559, 186, 659, 701, 476, 506, 205, 346, 704, 518, 205, 347, 180, 296, 266, 252, 575, 414, 537, 0, 755], [2119, 786, 586, 428, 435, 765, 441, 416, 584, 501, 337, 704, 548, 531, 951, 520, 746, 821, 40, 428, 744, 822, 831, 753, 744, 709, 589, 678, 551, 744, 0]]}, "reference": {"optimum_s": 19674, "optimality": "best_found", "lower_bound_s": 17542, "floor_s": 14304, "solve_s": 72.29, "ffd_s": 22803, "stop_aware_best_s": 21497, "stop_aware_mean_s": 22179.6, "route_id": "RouteID_83c8fc14-4dc3-49c0-8592-9f401cc0648d", "plans": {"optimum": [{"route": ["S14", "S01", "S17", "S21", "S16", "S05", "S11", "S22", "S29", "S20", "S24", "S09", "S06", "S03", "S04", "S13", "S12", "S26", "S28"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S27", "S25", "S23", "S02"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S30", "S18", "S15", "S08"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S19", "S07", "S10"], "parcels": []}], "ffd": [{"route": ["S01", "S16", "S03", "S07", "S08"], "parcels": ["P04", "P09"]}, {"route": ["S30", "S10", "S07", "S23"], "parcels": ["P11", "P28", "P29", "P40"]}, {"route": ["S21", "S29", "S11", "S02", "S15", "S12", "S06", "S30", "S18"], "parcels": ["P16", "P36", "P38", "P39"]}, {"route": ["S14", "S17", "S25", "S23", "S27", "S11", "S05", "S22", "S29", "S20", "S24", "S09", "S07", "S19", "S03", "S04", "S13", "S26", "S28"], "parcels": ["P03", "P08", "P10", "P15", "P30", "P37"]}], "stop_aware_best": [{"route": ["S14", "S16", "S27", "S15", "S04", "S10", "S30", "S18"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S11", "S05", "S22", "S29", "S24", "S09", "S06", "S03", "S19", "S08", "S26"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S01", "S21", "S20", "S07", "S13", "S28"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S17", "S25", "S23", "S02", "S12"], "parcels": []}]}}, "meta": {"route_id": "RouteID_83c8fc14-4dc3-49c0-8592-9f401cc0648d", "split": "train", "stops": 30, "vans": 4, "tightness": 0.91, "station": "DBO3", "city": "DBO", "date": "2018-07-25", "seconds": 122.9, "stop_aware_best_reward": 0.6108, "optimality": "best_found"}}
{"id": "3de71d89-spread-n25-k3-t0.94-s0", "instance": {"stops": ["S01", "S02", "S03", "S04", "S05", "S06", "S07", "S08", "S09", "S10", "S11", "S12", "S13", "S14", "S15", "S16", "S17", "S18", "S19", "S20", "S21", "S22", "S23", "S24", "S25"], "parcels": [{"id": "P01", "stop": "S01", "volume_dl": 104}, {"id": "P02", "stop": "S02", "volume_dl": 49}, {"id": "P03", "stop": "S02", "volume_dl": 79}, {"id": "P04", "stop": "S03", "volume_dl": 34}, {"id": "P05", "stop": "S03", "volume_dl": 17}, {"id": "P06", "stop": "S04", "volume_dl": 57}, {"id": "P07", "stop": "S05", "volume_dl": 133}, {"id": "P08", "stop": "S06", "volume_dl": 259}, {"id": "P09", "stop": "S07", "volume_dl": 25}, {"id": "P10", "stop": "S08", "volume_dl": 12}, {"id": "P11", "stop": "S08", "volume_dl": 104}, {"id": "P12", "stop": "S08", "volume_dl": 14}, {"id": "P13", "stop": "S09", "volume_dl": 13}, {"id": "P14", "stop": "S10", "volume_dl": 104}, {"id": "P15", "stop": "S11", "volume_dl": 19}, {"id": "P16", "stop": "S11", "volume_dl": 53}, {"id": "P17", "stop": "S11", "volume_dl": 6}, {"id": "P18", "stop": "S12", "volume_dl": 9}, {"id": "P19", "stop": "S13", "volume_dl": 133}, {"id": "P20", "stop": "S13", "volume_dl": 322}, {"id": "P21", "stop": "S14", "volume_dl": 31}, {"id": "P22", "stop": "S14", "volume_dl": 322}, {"id": "P23", "stop": "S15", "volume_dl": 133}, {"id": "P24", "stop": "S15", "volume_dl": 26}, {"id": "P25", "stop": "S16", "volume_dl": 4}, {"id": "P26", "stop": "S17", "volume_dl": 44}, {"id": "P27", "stop": "S17", "volume_dl": 4}, {"id": "P28", "stop": "S18", "volume_dl": 13}, {"id": "P29", "stop": "S19", "volume_dl": 9}, {"id": "P30", "stop": "S20", "volume_dl": 53}, {"id": "P31", "stop": "S21", "volume_dl": 4}, {"id": "P32", "stop": "S22", "volume_dl": 63}, {"id": "P33", "stop": "S22", "volume_dl": 63}, {"id": "P34", "stop": "S23", "volume_dl": 599}, {"id": "P35", "stop": "S23", "volume_dl": 59}, {"id": "P36", "stop": "S23", "volume_dl": 59}, {"id": "P37", "stop": "S24", "volume_dl": 478}, {"id": "P38", "stop": "S24", "volume_dl": 29}, {"id": "P39", "stop": "S25", "volume_dl": 23}, {"id": "P40", "stop": "S25", "volume_dl": 59}, {"id": "P41", "stop": "S25", "volume_dl": 95}, {"id": "P42", "stop": "S25", "volume_dl": 242}], "vans": 3, "capacity_dl": 1405, "travel_s": [[0, 1579, 1593, 1503, 1426, 1617, 1543, 1524, 1462, 1658, 1479, 1546, 1493, 1494, 1434, 1575, 1433, 1642, 1459, 1452, 1473, 1607, 1394, 1616, 1463, 1475], [1650, 0, 134, 348, 522, 508, 192, 482, 557, 549, 316, 99, 480, 297, 331, 202, 367, 183, 365, 254, 337, 192, 408, 360, 397, 490], [1625, 141, 0, 354, 496, 483, 166, 420, 531, 523, 223, 54, 455, 324, 236, 177, 292, 67, 243, 282, 232, 219, 383, 345, 270, 464], [1412, 360, 339, 0, 247, 186, 294, 123, 282, 227, 384, 330, 242, 249, 333, 238, 316, 396, 368, 325, 389, 437, 156, 153, 346, 190], [1321, 530, 510, 252, 0, 310, 466, 164, 35, 351, 534, 501, 312, 421, 489, 410, 488, 566, 514, 497, 528, 608, 171, 320, 518, 134], [1477, 535, 514, 227, 385, 0, 470, 246, 420, 79, 559, 506, 417, 440, 508, 429, 491, 571, 544, 516, 564, 612, 317, 313, 521, 313], [1544, 189, 169, 294, 452, 439, 0, 376, 488, 480, 187, 160, 444, 372, 207, 209, 253, 235, 191, 330, 163, 267, 371, 346, 223, 442], [1439, 444, 424, 137, 153, 195, 421, 0, 188, 236, 468, 415, 253, 417, 418, 381, 401, 480, 453, 452, 474, 522, 112, 205, 430, 88], [1370, 580, 559, 302, 50, 360, 515, 214, 0, 401, 584, 551, 361, 505, 536, 460, 538, 616, 564, 547, 578, 657, 220, 370, 568, 176], [1537, 595, 574, 287, 445, 79, 530, 306, 480, 0, 619, 566, 477, 500, 569, 489, 551, 631, 604, 576, 624, 672, 377, 373, 581, 373], [1506, 359, 274, 419, 539, 533, 233, 470, 574, 574, 0, 334, 518, 519, 116, 360, 77, 276, 66, 477, 141, 436, 446, 518, 47, 536], [1611, 101, 59, 332, 474, 461, 145, 398, 510, 502, 268, 0, 454, 297, 281, 175, 320, 127, 318, 229, 289, 166, 381, 333, 349, 464], [1388, 557, 536, 297, 249, 398, 492, 262, 285, 438, 560, 528, 0, 392, 516, 381, 461, 592, 541, 468, 554, 634, 132, 418, 491, 213], [1527, 283, 254, 226, 389, 386, 302, 323, 424, 427, 407, 280, 358, 0, 420, 164, 446, 321, 427, 189, 456, 370, 302, 269, 476, 376], [1437, 381, 265, 442, 470, 477, 210, 414, 505, 517, 95, 323, 462, 536, 0, 351, 92, 264, 49, 468, 69, 458, 387, 494, 81, 480], [1521, 212, 183, 219, 383, 380, 230, 353, 418, 421, 336, 192, 351, 230, 349, 0, 406, 250, 355, 362, 345, 299, 279, 231, 383, 361], [1434, 439, 325, 342, 488, 456, 268, 393, 523, 497, 68, 386, 442, 570, 103, 411, 0, 327, 52, 528, 127, 516, 369, 551, 30, 460], [1621, 174, 71, 386, 528, 515, 198, 452, 564, 556, 249, 125, 505, 357, 265, 227, 318, 0, 268, 314, 258, 251, 433, 385, 296, 518], [1465, 386, 272, 447, 498, 503, 215, 440, 533, 544, 46, 333, 488, 518, 50, 359, 62, 274, 0, 475, 75, 464, 416, 499, 32, 506], [1486, 242, 213, 185, 348, 345, 260, 282, 383, 386, 366, 223, 316, 43, 422, 123, 404, 280, 386, 0, 414, 329, 244, 214, 434, 326], [1477, 357, 260, 418, 510, 517, 186, 454, 545, 558, 100, 327, 502, 506, 69, 376, 115, 262, 54, 463, 0, 434, 430, 469, 85, 520], [1734, 196, 210, 455, 597, 584, 267, 520, 632, 624, 391, 162, 583, 309, 406, 298, 442, 258, 440, 266, 412, 0, 511, 456, 472, 592], [1328, 409, 380, 166, 157, 266, 364, 130, 192, 307, 438, 385, 141, 301, 388, 290, 370, 447, 423, 378, 444, 492, 0, 297, 400, 82], [1543, 353, 336, 160, 324, 276, 333, 199, 359, 317, 478, 333, 374, 283, 492, 246, 462, 403, 482, 339, 454, 440, 283, 0, 505, 258], [1488, 409, 295, 372, 521, 486, 238, 423, 556, 527, 38, 356, 471, 541, 73, 381, 30, 297, 23, 498, 97, 486, 399, 521, 0, 489], [1410, 489, 462, 181, 140, 232, 465, 93, 168, 280, 513, 453, 223, 376, 465, 372, 445, 529, 498, 460, 518, 566, 82, 260, 475, 0]]}, "reference": {"optimum_s": 11625, "optimality": "best_found", "lower_bound_s": 9902, "floor_s": 8145, "solve_s": 37.14, "ffd_s": 13904, "stop_aware_best_s": 12533, "stop_aware_mean_s": 12966.8, "route_id": "RouteID_3de71d89-7ebe-40c9-b5c1-d617f6608833", "plans": {"optimum": [{"route": ["S19", "S13", "S15", "S01", "S21", "S11", "S02", "S17", "S06"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S14", "S20", "S18", "S10", "S24", "S16", "S12", "S22", "S04", "S08"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S25", "S07", "S23", "S03", "S09", "S05"], "parcels": []}], "ffd": [{"route": ["S24", "S11", "S13", "S23"], "parcels": ["P17", "P20", "P34", "P37"]}, {"route": ["S14", "S06", "S01", "S02", "S15", "S13", "S25", "S05"], "parcels": ["P03", "P19", "P22", "P23", "P42"]}, {"route": ["S16", "S24", "S10", "S18", "S14", "S20", "S17", "S02", "S11", "S21", "S19", "S15", "S23", "S03", "S09", "S07", "S25", "S22", "S12", "S04", "S08"], "parcels": ["P02", "P15", "P16", "P21", "P24", "P35", "P36", "P38", "P39", "P40", "P41"]}], "stop_aware_best": [{"route": ["S16", "S24", "S10", "S18", "S20", "S21", "S19", "S13", "S08"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S14", "S17", "S02", "S11", "S15", "S03", "S07", "S25", "S12", "S04"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S06", "S01", "S23", "S09", "S05", "S22"], "parcels": []}]}}, "meta": {"route_id": "RouteID_3de71d89-7ebe-40c9-b5c1-d617f6608833", "split": "train", "stops": 25, "vans": 3, "tightness": 0.94, "station": "DLA9", "city": "DLA", "date": "2018-08-01", "seconds": 97.6, "stop_aware_best_reward": 0.6817, "optimality": "best_found"}}
{"id": "73646c01-spread-n20-k3-t0.88-s0", "instance": {"stops": ["S01", "S02", "S03", "S04", "S05", "S06", "S07", "S08", "S09", "S10", "S11", "S12", "S13", "S14", "S15", "S16", "S17", "S18", "S19", "S20"], "parcels": [{"id": "P01", "stop": "S01", "volume_dl": 39}, {"id": "P02", "stop": "S02", "volume_dl": 29}, {"id": "P03", "stop": "S03", "volume_dl": 157}, {"id": "P04", "stop": "S03", "volume_dl": 60}, {"id": "P05", "stop": "S03", "volume_dl": 31}, {"id": "P06", "stop": "S04", "volume_dl": 368}, {"id": "P07", "stop": "S05", "volume_dl": 36}, {"id": "P08", "stop": "S05", "volume_dl": 40}, {"id": "P09", "stop": "S06", "volume_dl": 179}, {"id": "P10", "stop": "S07", "volume_dl": 57}, {"id": "P11", "stop": "S08", "volume_dl": 358}, {"id": "P12", "stop": "S09", "volume_dl": 20}, {"id": "P13", "stop": "S10", "volume_dl": 134}, {"id": "P14", "stop": "S11", "volume_dl": 53}, {"id": "P15", "stop": "S12", "volume_dl": 34}, {"id": "P16", "stop": "S12", "volume_dl": 13}, {"id": "P17", "stop": "S13", "volume_dl": 277}, {"id": "P18", "stop": "S13", "volume_dl": 157}, {"id": "P19", "stop": "S14", "volume_dl": 273}, {"id": "P20", "stop": "S15", "volume_dl": 95}, {"id": "P21", "stop": "S16", "volume_dl": 242}, {"id": "P22", "stop": "S17", "volume_dl": 13}, {"id": "P23", "stop": "S18", "volume_dl": 1}, {"id": "P24", "stop": "S19", "volume_dl": 226}, {"id": "P25", "stop": "S19", "volume_dl": 18}, {"id": "P26", "stop": "S20", "volume_dl": 35}], "vans": 3, "capacity_dl": 1116, "travel_s": [[0, 1905, 1886, 1679, 1821, 1898, 1773, 1589, 1671, 1530, 1625, 1821, 1785, 1741, 1534, 1785, 1666, 1670, 1944, 1825, 1989], [1760, 0, 267, 514, 243, 74, 316, 361, 257, 477, 491, 335, 315, 228, 468, 174, 305, 316, 250, 263, 296], [1728, 256, 0, 437, 230, 249, 119, 278, 308, 400, 513, 152, 111, 127, 423, 184, 232, 353, 338, 34, 383], [1566, 525, 542, 0, 441, 516, 393, 285, 451, 168, 280, 441, 404, 361, 190, 452, 286, 406, 606, 445, 651], [1724, 258, 211, 424, 0, 250, 190, 325, 221, 387, 499, 278, 184, 70, 409, 128, 269, 279, 339, 198, 384], [1775, 90, 254, 499, 258, 0, 268, 377, 273, 464, 485, 356, 261, 240, 487, 190, 320, 331, 222, 251, 267], [1654, 281, 92, 364, 198, 274, 0, 204, 189, 326, 439, 82, 192, 118, 349, 207, 159, 247, 362, 126, 408], [1489, 339, 282, 295, 255, 332, 207, 0, 219, 196, 290, 255, 219, 175, 200, 266, 99, 219, 420, 259, 465], [1502, 342, 375, 491, 298, 342, 283, 243, 0, 439, 534, 422, 318, 342, 444, 275, 205, 180, 467, 358, 512], [1417, 488, 413, 188, 404, 480, 356, 203, 413, 0, 152, 404, 368, 324, 61, 415, 248, 368, 569, 408, 614], [1526, 482, 364, 315, 438, 475, 386, 312, 533, 146, 0, 419, 437, 441, 99, 392, 375, 488, 564, 398, 609], [1716, 350, 144, 426, 306, 343, 88, 266, 277, 388, 501, 0, 244, 220, 411, 259, 221, 341, 431, 179, 477], [1696, 269, 100, 405, 234, 259, 171, 246, 254, 368, 481, 259, 0, 132, 391, 187, 200, 312, 350, 77, 395], [1668, 188, 141, 354, 80, 178, 120, 269, 165, 317, 429, 208, 114, 0, 339, 115, 213, 223, 268, 131, 314], [1427, 470, 352, 216, 426, 463, 374, 213, 432, 47, 90, 407, 425, 429, 0, 379, 276, 388, 551, 386, 597], [1707, 179, 170, 438, 109, 172, 204, 308, 205, 401, 404, 248, 199, 113, 381, 0, 252, 263, 260, 188, 306], [1608, 300, 243, 285, 216, 293, 168, 143, 170, 248, 361, 216, 180, 136, 271, 227, 0, 120, 381, 220, 426], [1603, 305, 338, 406, 261, 306, 246, 194, 150, 369, 484, 337, 281, 257, 394, 238, 121, 0, 430, 321, 476], [1852, 235, 312, 559, 293, 211, 325, 399, 370, 522, 543, 413, 319, 249, 544, 287, 354, 428, 0, 308, 197], [1717, 274, 23, 426, 238, 264, 142, 266, 274, 389, 501, 175, 77, 137, 411, 192, 221, 332, 354, 0, 400], [1934, 318, 394, 642, 376, 293, 408, 482, 453, 604, 625, 496, 402, 332, 627, 370, 437, 511, 214, 391, 0]]}, "reference": {"optimum_s": 12283, "optimality": "best_found", "lower_bound_s": 10596, "floor_s": 8841, "solve_s": 38.16, "ffd_s": 13691, "stop_aware_best_s": 13054, "stop_aware_mean_s": 13263.2, "route_id": "RouteID_73646c01-b671-4b17-972f-9f572ef9209e", "plans": {"optimum": [{"route": ["S20", "S18", "S05", "S01", "S15", "S04", "S13"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S07", "S12", "S19", "S02", "S11", "S06", "S08"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S17", "S16", "S03", "S14", "S10", "S09"], "parcels": []}], "ffd": [{"route": ["S19", "S15", "S04", "S13", "S08"], "parcels": ["P17", "P25"]}, {"route": ["S16", "S01", "S19", "S06", "S03", "S14"], "parcels": ["P03", "P24"]}, {"route": ["S17", "S05", "S20", "S18", "S13", "S12", "S02", "S11", "S07", "S03", "S10", "S09"], "parcels": ["P04", "P05", "P18"]}], "stop_aware_best": [{"route": ["S07", "S11", "S19", "S15", "S08"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S17", "S16", "S12", "S02", "S20", "S18", "S13", "S03", "S09"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S14", "S10", "S05", "S01", "S04", "S06"], "parcels": []}]}}, "meta": {"route_id": "RouteID_73646c01-b671-4b17-972f-9f572ef9209e", "split": "train", "stops": 20, "vans": 3, "tightness": 0.88, "station": "DSE4", "city": "DSE", "date": "2018-08-05", "seconds": 40.9, "stop_aware_best_reward": 0.7176, "optimality": "best_found"}}
{"id": "557f0993-spread-n30-k4-t0.89-s0", "instance": {"stops": ["S01", "S02", "S03", "S04", "S05", "S06", "S07", "S08", "S09", "S10", "S11", "S12", "S13", "S14", "S15", "S16", "S17", "S18", "S19", "S20", "S21", "S22", "S23", "S24", "S25", "S26", "S27", "S28", "S29", "S30"], "parcels": [{"id": "P01", "stop": "S01", "volume_dl": 11}, {"id": "P02", "stop": "S02", "volume_dl": 242}, {"id": "P03", "stop": "S03", "volume_dl": 10}, {"id": "P04", "stop": "S04", "volume_dl": 38}, {"id": "P05", "stop": "S04", "volume_dl": 324}, {"id": "P06", "stop": "S04", "volume_dl": 63}, {"id": "P07", "stop": "S04", "volume_dl": 149}, {"id": "P08", "stop": "S04", "volume_dl": 57}, {"id": "P09", "stop": "S05", "volume_dl": 51}, {"id": "P10", "stop": "S05", "volume_dl": 79}, {"id": "P11", "stop": "S06", "volume_dl": 51}, {"id": "P12", "stop": "S06", "volume_dl": 133}, {"id": "P13", "stop": "S06", "volume_dl": 107}, {"id": "P14", "stop": "S06", "volume_dl": 62}, {"id": "P15", "stop": "S06", "volume_dl": 92}, {"id": "P16", "stop": "S07", "volume_dl": 92}, {"id": "P17", "stop": "S07", "volume_dl": 45}, {"id": "P18", "stop": "S07", "volume_dl": 134}, {"id": "P19", "stop": "S08", "volume_dl": 104}, {"id": "P20", "stop": "S08", "volume_dl": 63}, {"id": "P21", "stop": "S09", "volume_dl": 18}, {"id": "P22", "stop": "S10", "volume_dl": 19}, {"id": "P23", "stop": "S10", "volume_dl": 3}, {"id": "P24", "stop": "S10", "volume_dl": 57}, {"id": "P25", "stop": "S11", "volume_dl": 34}, {"id": "P26", "stop": "S11", "volume_dl": 13}, {"id": "P27", "stop": "S12", "volume_dl": 57}, {"id": "P28", "stop": "S13", "volume_dl": 30}, {"id": "P29", "stop": "S14", "volume_dl": 29}, {"id": "P30", "stop": "S15", "volume_dl": 19}, {"id": "P31", "stop": "S16", "volume_dl": 2}, {"id": "P32", "stop": "S16", "volume_dl": 57}, {"id": "P33", "stop": "S17", "volume_dl": 104}, {"id": "P34", "stop": "S18", "volume_dl": 26}, {"id": "P35", "stop": "S18", "volume_dl": 26}, {"id": "P36", "stop": "S18", "volume_dl": 26}, {"id": "P37", "stop": "S18", "volume_dl": 43}, {"id": "P38", "stop": "S19", "volume_dl": 157}, {"id": "P39", "stop": "S20", "volume_dl": 133}, {"id": "P40", "stop": "S21", "volume_dl": 34}, {"id": "P41", "stop": "S22", "volume_dl": 157}, {"id": "P42", "stop": "S23", "volume_dl": 133}, {"id": "P43", "stop": "S23", "volume_dl": 29}, {"id": "P44", "stop": "S23", "volume_dl": 12}, {"id": "P45", "stop": "S24", "volume_dl": 27}, {"id": "P46", "stop": "S25", "volume_dl": 34}, {"id": "P47", "stop": "S26", "volume_dl": 13}, {"id": "P48", "stop": "S27", "volume_dl": 133}, {"id": "P49", "stop": "S28", "volume_dl": 79}, {"id": "P50", "stop": "S28", "volume_dl": 242}, {"id": "P51", "stop": "S28", "volume_dl": 63}, {"id": "P52", "stop": "S29", "volume_dl": 368}, {"id": "P53", "stop": "S30", "volume_dl": 104}, {"id": "P54", "stop": "S30", "volume_dl": 157}], "vans": 4, "capacity_dl": 1222, "travel_s": [[0, 2466, 2424, 2384, 2344, 2460, 2324, 2500, 2297, 2512, 2396, 2433, 2445, 2491, 2393, 2454, 2443, 2347, 2360, 2293, 2356, 2299, 2294, 2355, 2296, 2226, 2245, 2196, 2218, 2403, 2446], [2497, 0, 358, 287, 286, 230, 365, 96, 307, 430, 250, 45, 299, 409, 386, 356, 21, 338, 298, 319, 114, 288, 167, 101, 238, 276, 211, 314, 352, 338, 95], [2545, 350, 0, 91, 313, 187, 223, 312, 307, 449, 410, 333, 152, 428, 204, 368, 358, 142, 101, 302, 321, 294, 300, 270, 346, 383, 300, 403, 440, 182, 380], [2454, 264, 98, 0, 226, 95, 172, 226, 216, 365, 323, 247, 60, 344, 113, 284, 272, 52, 114, 199, 235, 190, 214, 184, 259, 297, 213, 316, 354, 91, 294], [2412, 279, 302, 208, 0, 161, 308, 266, 132, 525, 335, 261, 180, 504, 211, 450, 264, 200, 243, 123, 229, 114, 226, 178, 36, 136, 202, 207, 224, 164, 287], [2467, 214, 176, 97, 145, 0, 248, 200, 152, 444, 291, 200, 68, 422, 230, 362, 236, 149, 192, 141, 202, 132, 181, 186, 181, 250, 181, 284, 321, 182, 247], [2442, 350, 200, 160, 306, 236, 0, 337, 312, 353, 409, 333, 221, 332, 273, 295, 356, 212, 136, 302, 321, 294, 300, 270, 345, 383, 300, 402, 440, 251, 380], [2539, 87, 320, 249, 272, 202, 327, 0, 246, 402, 291, 69, 270, 381, 357, 328, 107, 301, 260, 269, 177, 260, 191, 194, 301, 338, 236, 338, 376, 310, 119], [2338, 282, 309, 211, 109, 162, 311, 243, 0, 528, 359, 264, 173, 506, 152, 453, 304, 150, 245, 50, 270, 42, 249, 220, 145, 160, 226, 230, 247, 165, 314], [2568, 414, 405, 334, 517, 440, 311, 375, 516, 0, 544, 396, 395, 31, 447, 165, 429, 386, 348, 506, 459, 498, 444, 446, 538, 575, 488, 591, 629, 425, 411], [2419, 240, 394, 323, 350, 294, 400, 326, 370, 547, 0, 219, 362, 526, 449, 480, 217, 375, 334, 343, 142, 353, 101, 140, 292, 329, 146, 249, 286, 402, 239], [2471, 61, 334, 263, 291, 217, 354, 107, 297, 416, 218, 0, 284, 395, 371, 341, 76, 314, 288, 282, 108, 274, 122, 126, 232, 270, 166, 269, 306, 323, 53], [2469, 282, 162, 93, 192, 68, 236, 243, 181, 429, 359, 265, 0, 408, 192, 348, 303, 114, 177, 172, 271, 163, 250, 220, 222, 281, 249, 335, 352, 145, 315], [2589, 404, 396, 325, 507, 430, 332, 366, 507, 21, 535, 387, 386, 0, 438, 157, 420, 377, 369, 497, 450, 488, 434, 437, 528, 566, 479, 582, 619, 416, 402], [2442, 367, 210, 112, 202, 206, 284, 329, 136, 477, 435, 350, 171, 456, 0, 396, 383, 96, 225, 162, 347, 154, 326, 296, 231, 272, 325, 342, 359, 66, 400], [2562, 352, 340, 268, 439, 362, 365, 314, 438, 114, 500, 335, 330, 145, 381, 0, 379, 320, 298, 429, 409, 420, 400, 397, 472, 509, 426, 529, 567, 360, 362], [2476, 23, 337, 266, 274, 238, 342, 144, 313, 454, 228, 72, 305, 432, 392, 379, 0, 318, 276, 298, 93, 308, 146, 111, 217, 255, 190, 293, 329, 344, 105], [2403, 317, 150, 52, 192, 147, 224, 278, 181, 418, 376, 299, 112, 397, 78, 336, 324, 0, 166, 171, 288, 163, 266, 237, 222, 281, 266, 335, 351, 56, 346], [2525, 289, 84, 99, 245, 176, 161, 250, 251, 395, 348, 276, 160, 374, 212, 336, 297, 151, 0, 241, 260, 232, 239, 209, 284, 322, 238, 341, 379, 190, 318], [2365, 272, 289, 191, 107, 153, 303, 234, 71, 518, 350, 255, 164, 497, 179, 444, 293, 158, 236, 0, 261, 10, 240, 210, 136, 109, 203, 207, 224, 147, 305], [2402, 116, 320, 249, 249, 220, 327, 201, 296, 479, 153, 120, 289, 458, 375, 430, 93, 301, 261, 281, 0, 291, 53, 64, 201, 238, 97, 200, 238, 328, 115], [2349, 263, 280, 182, 97, 144, 293, 224, 61, 509, 340, 245, 154, 488, 169, 434, 284, 149, 226, 9, 251, 0, 230, 201, 126, 118, 207, 211, 228, 137, 295], [2349, 182, 284, 212, 233, 184, 291, 220, 260, 467, 101, 139, 252, 446, 339, 400, 159, 264, 224, 242, 62, 252, 0, 72, 184, 216, 44, 147, 185, 291, 152], [2398, 111, 259, 188, 195, 159, 263, 218, 232, 474, 145, 111, 228, 452, 314, 396, 84, 240, 197, 220, 51, 230, 68, 0, 140, 177, 112, 215, 256, 267, 106], [2376, 253, 356, 267, 48, 218, 364, 299, 182, 583, 299, 257, 239, 562, 270, 494, 230, 270, 297, 143, 193, 153, 190, 142, 0, 100, 166, 171, 188, 222, 252], [2310, 293, 352, 254, 171, 262, 411, 342, 152, 617, 339, 297, 272, 596, 248, 538, 270, 201, 337, 109, 233, 118, 225, 182, 123, 0, 176, 181, 148, 257, 292], [2353, 222, 307, 236, 193, 208, 314, 264, 236, 516, 150, 188, 276, 495, 344, 449, 199, 288, 248, 197, 110, 207, 49, 111, 145, 172, 0, 103, 140, 296, 201], [2243, 311, 396, 334, 224, 296, 403, 352, 232, 605, 239, 277, 323, 584, 328, 538, 288, 281, 337, 208, 199, 217, 138, 200, 175, 161, 89, 0, 98, 306, 290], [2354, 355, 446, 348, 244, 332, 466, 412, 246, 676, 310, 354, 342, 654, 342, 608, 331, 296, 400, 227, 296, 237, 209, 248, 185, 137, 160, 111, 0, 326, 354], [2440, 328, 196, 98, 162, 193, 270, 290, 152, 463, 405, 311, 152, 442, 94, 382, 349, 82, 212, 142, 317, 133, 296, 266, 192, 251, 296, 305, 322, 0, 361], [2492, 104, 354, 283, 293, 256, 361, 158, 331, 438, 242, 77, 323, 417, 410, 374, 79, 335, 294, 316, 111, 326, 142, 128, 235, 272, 187, 290, 327, 362, 0]]}, "reference": {"optimum_s": 21214, "optimality": "best_found", "lower_bound_s": 19248, "floor_s": 17756, "solve_s": 93.36, "ffd_s": 24620, "stop_aware_best_s": 22816, "stop_aware_mean_s": 23172.8, "route_id": "RouteID_557f0993-75be-4d5a-afe8-d9c978803865", "plans": {"optimum": [{"route": ["S26", "S23", "S16", "S01", "S07", "S11", "S30", "S20", "S22", "S10"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S06", "S18", "S02", "S03", "S15", "S09", "S13"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S25", "S19", "S21", "S05", "S12", "S17", "S29", "S14", "S08"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S28", "S24", "S04", "S27"], "parcels": []}], "ffd": [{"route": ["S28", "S04", "S07", "S02", "S29"], "parcels": ["P05", "P17", "P50"]}, {"route": ["S06", "S04", "S19", "S07", "S30", "S16", "S23", "S20", "S22", "S10"], "parcels": ["P06", "P07", "P12", "P18", "P23", "P31", "P42", "P54"]}, {"route": ["S06", "S18", "S17", "S08", "S04", "S05", "S07", "S30", "S10", "S28", "S27"], "parcels": ["P08", "P10", "P13", "P14", "P15", "P16", "P24", "P34", "P49", "P51", "P53"]}, {"route": ["S26", "S10", "S23", "S16", "S01", "S11", "S15", "S09", "S13", "S06", "S18", "S03", "S14", "S12", "S05", "S21", "S04", "S24", "S25"], "parcels": ["P04", "P09", "P11", "P22", "P32", "P35", "P36", "P37", "P43", "P44"]}], "stop_aware_best": [{"route": ["S06", "S15", "S09", "S13", "S20", "S25", "S19", "S08"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S21", "S12", "S17", "S03", "S18", "S07", "S30", "S23", "S27"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S04", "S05", "S01", "S11", "S22", "S10"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S28", "S26", "S16", "S02", "S14", "S29", "S24"], "parcels": []}]}}, "meta": {"route_id": "RouteID_557f0993-75be-4d5a-afe8-d9c978803865", "split": "train", "stops": 30, "vans": 4, "tightness": 0.89, "station": "DLA7", "city": "DLA", "date": "2018-07-22", "seconds": 153.7, "stop_aware_best_reward": 0.5251, "optimality": "best_found"}}
{"id": "149f5b35-spread-n25-k3-t0.9-s0", "instance": {"stops": ["S01", "S02", "S03", "S04", "S05", "S06", "S07", "S08", "S09", "S10", "S11", "S12", "S13", "S14", "S15", "S16", "S17", "S18", "S19", "S20", "S21", "S22", "S23", "S24", "S25"], "parcels": [{"id": "P01", "stop": "S01", "volume_dl": 542}, {"id": "P02", "stop": "S01", "volume_dl": 779}, {"id": "P03", "stop": "S02", "volume_dl": 57}, {"id": "P04", "stop": "S03", "volume_dl": 63}, {"id": "P05", "stop": "S04", "volume_dl": 226}, {"id": "P06", "stop": "S05", "volume_dl": 54}, {"id": "P07", "stop": "S06", "volume_dl": 6}, {"id": "P08", "stop": "S07", "volume_dl": 157}, {"id": "P09", "stop": "S07", "volume_dl": 104}, {"id": "P10", "stop": "S08", "volume_dl": 179}, {"id": "P11", "stop": "S09", "volume_dl": 57}, {"id": "P12", "stop": "S10", "volume_dl": 59}, {"id": "P13", "stop": "S11", "volume_dl": 36}, {"id": "P14", "stop": "S12", "volume_dl": 36}, {"id": "P15", "stop": "S13", "volume_dl": 8}, {"id": "P16", "stop": "S13", "volume_dl": 133}, {"id": "P17", "stop": "S14", "volume_dl": 34}, {"id": "P18", "stop": "S15", "volume_dl": 133}, {"id": "P19", "stop": "S16", "volume_dl": 95}, {"id": "P20", "stop": "S16", "volume_dl": 47}, {"id": "P21", "stop": "S17", "volume_dl": 104}, {"id": "P22", "stop": "S18", "volume_dl": 57}, {"id": "P23", "stop": "S19", "volume_dl": 57}, {"id": "P24", "stop": "S20", "volume_dl": 242}, {"id": "P25", "stop": "S21", "volume_dl": 42}, {"id": "P26", "stop": "S22", "volume_dl": 63}, {"id": "P27", "stop": "S22", "volume_dl": 157}, {"id": "P28", "stop": "S23", "volume_dl": 57}, {"id": "P29", "stop": "S24", "volume_dl": 28}, {"id": "P30", "stop": "S24", "volume_dl": 57}, {"id": "P31", "stop": "S25", "volume_dl": 21}], "vans": 3, "capacity_dl": 1369, "travel_s": [[0, 2212, 2568, 2146, 2491, 2234, 2364, 2510, 2204, 2300, 2167, 2358, 2245, 2180, 2423, 2184, 2441, 2266, 2378, 2516, 2496, 2590, 2338, 2515, 2460, 2544], [2206, 0, 684, 263, 608, 22, 481, 648, 321, 417, 304, 475, 362, 176, 584, 301, 554, 54, 886, 632, 613, 734, 454, 732, 576, 761], [2550, 746, 0, 447, 119, 768, 525, 249, 589, 413, 630, 264, 585, 662, 457, 524, 447, 799, 448, 130, 70, 50, 366, 129, 217, 198], [2150, 293, 448, 0, 372, 316, 245, 412, 189, 181, 230, 239, 184, 261, 348, 123, 322, 347, 650, 396, 376, 498, 218, 496, 340, 524], [2475, 619, 115, 372, 0, 641, 450, 281, 514, 338, 555, 189, 510, 587, 382, 449, 372, 672, 519, 115, 95, 170, 292, 249, 142, 316], [2227, 22, 706, 285, 630, 0, 503, 670, 343, 439, 325, 497, 384, 198, 606, 322, 580, 31, 908, 654, 634, 756, 476, 754, 598, 782], [2377, 513, 561, 328, 484, 536, 0, 525, 416, 218, 457, 351, 412, 489, 413, 351, 144, 567, 762, 509, 489, 611, 198, 608, 453, 637], [2517, 700, 239, 414, 352, 723, 502, 0, 556, 380, 597, 231, 552, 628, 424, 490, 424, 754, 346, 369, 310, 223, 320, 148, 271, 177], [2234, 378, 617, 196, 541, 400, 414, 581, 0, 350, 314, 408, 295, 346, 517, 234, 491, 432, 819, 565, 546, 667, 387, 665, 509, 694], [2310, 454, 420, 208, 344, 476, 237, 384, 350, 0, 390, 211, 345, 422, 314, 284, 294, 507, 622, 368, 348, 470, 190, 468, 312, 496], [2189, 312, 650, 229, 574, 335, 446, 614, 286, 383, 0, 441, 327, 280, 549, 266, 524, 366, 851, 598, 578, 700, 420, 697, 542, 726], [2339, 482, 282, 236, 206, 505, 324, 246, 378, 202, 419, 0, 373, 450, 246, 312, 246, 536, 484, 230, 210, 332, 142, 330, 174, 358], [2217, 360, 594, 173, 518, 383, 391, 558, 256, 327, 297, 385, 0, 328, 529, 121, 468, 414, 796, 542, 522, 644, 364, 642, 486, 670], [2174, 197, 653, 232, 577, 219, 450, 617, 290, 386, 272, 444, 331, 0, 553, 270, 523, 250, 855, 601, 582, 703, 423, 701, 545, 730], [2411, 554, 444, 308, 368, 576, 378, 408, 450, 273, 491, 235, 445, 522, 0, 384, 300, 608, 616, 392, 372, 494, 196, 492, 336, 520], [2154, 298, 532, 110, 456, 320, 328, 496, 194, 264, 234, 322, 126, 266, 471, 0, 406, 352, 733, 480, 460, 582, 302, 579, 424, 608], [2443, 499, 452, 394, 376, 525, 144, 412, 482, 284, 523, 243, 478, 642, 328, 416, 0, 556, 653, 400, 380, 502, 113, 499, 340, 528], [2259, 53, 738, 316, 661, 31, 534, 702, 374, 470, 357, 528, 415, 229, 637, 354, 611, 0, 939, 686, 666, 788, 507, 785, 630, 814], [2418, 900, 470, 661, 550, 922, 749, 374, 803, 626, 844, 478, 798, 875, 671, 737, 671, 954, 0, 574, 540, 454, 567, 379, 518, 408], [2521, 738, 133, 418, 116, 761, 484, 327, 560, 384, 601, 235, 555, 632, 428, 494, 406, 792, 564, 0, 61, 183, 337, 262, 188, 328], [2480, 623, 72, 377, 75, 646, 455, 286, 519, 342, 560, 194, 514, 591, 387, 453, 376, 677, 523, 60, 0, 122, 296, 200, 147, 267], [2611, 720, 61, 508, 174, 743, 586, 224, 651, 474, 691, 325, 646, 723, 518, 585, 508, 774, 423, 191, 132, 0, 428, 104, 279, 173], [2326, 472, 339, 223, 263, 494, 182, 303, 365, 188, 406, 130, 360, 437, 215, 299, 100, 526, 540, 287, 267, 389, 0, 386, 231, 415], [2542, 645, 139, 495, 251, 667, 698, 148, 637, 460, 678, 312, 632, 784, 505, 571, 585, 698, 347, 269, 209, 122, 505, 0, 356, 94], [2464, 607, 259, 361, 182, 629, 468, 270, 503, 326, 544, 177, 498, 575, 371, 437, 386, 660, 507, 207, 187, 309, 309, 353, 0, 382], [2605, 644, 184, 559, 292, 667, 698, 212, 701, 524, 742, 375, 696, 784, 569, 635, 589, 698, 411, 303, 243, 168, 540, 112, 390, 0]]}, "reference": {"optimum_s": 17400, "optimality": "best_found", "lower_bound_s": 15604, "floor_s": 12888, "solve_s": 35.12, "ffd_s": 19208, "stop_aware_best_s": 18628, "stop_aware_mean_s": 19021, "route_id": "RouteID_149f5b35-b668-43db-aae3-7a2bbd4f89e9", "plans": {"optimum": [{"route": ["S01", "S08", "S03", "S06", "S16", "S22", "S14", "S09"], "parcels": ["P01"]}, {"route": ["S10", "S01", "S05", "S17", "S13"], "parcels": ["P02"]}, {"route": ["S18", "S07", "S23", "S25", "S21", "S02", "S20", "S19", "S04", "S24", "S11", "S12", "S15"], "parcels": []}], "ffd": [{"route": ["S16", "S01"], "parcels": ["P20"]}, {"route": ["S13", "S08", "S22", "S20", "S04", "S07", "S11", "S15"], "parcels": ["P16", "P27"]}, {"route": ["S18", "S23", "S25", "S21", "S02", "S19", "S24", "S14", "S22", "S16", "S06", "S09", "S03", "S12", "S10", "S05", "S17", "S13"], "parcels": ["P15", "P19", "P26"]}], "stop_aware_best": [{"route": ["S01"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S05", "S13", "S15", "S03", "S06", "S16", "S14", "S19", "S20", "S02", "S25", "S07", "S18"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S10", "S08", "S12", "S09", "S22", "S11", "S24", "S04", "S21", "S23", "S17"], "parcels": []}]}}, "meta": {"route_id": "RouteID_149f5b35-b668-43db-aae3-7a2bbd4f89e9", "split": "train", "stops": 25, "vans": 3, "tightness": 0.9, "station": "DCH4", "city": "DCH", "date": "2018-08-08", "seconds": 85.6, "stop_aware_best_reward": 0.6697, "optimality": "best_found"}}
{"id": "96cd0efc-spread-n30-k4-t0.9-s0", "instance": {"stops": ["S01", "S02", "S03", "S04", "S05", "S06", "S07", "S08", "S09", "S10", "S11", "S12", "S13", "S14", "S15", "S16", "S17", "S18", "S19", "S20", "S21", "S22", "S23", "S24", "S25", "S26", "S27", "S28", "S29", "S30"], "parcels": [{"id": "P01", "stop": "S01", "volume_dl": 259}, {"id": "P02", "stop": "S02", "volume_dl": 12}, {"id": "P03", "stop": "S02", "volume_dl": 14}, {"id": "P04", "stop": "S02", "volume_dl": 104}, {"id": "P05", "stop": "S02", "volume_dl": 59}, {"id": "P06", "stop": "S03", "volume_dl": 53}, {"id": "P07", "stop": "S04", "volume_dl": 477}, {"id": "P08", "stop": "S04", "volume_dl": 95}, {"id": "P09", "stop": "S04", "volume_dl": 44}, {"id": "P10", "stop": "S05", "volume_dl": 92}, {"id": "P11", "stop": "S06", "volume_dl": 259}, {"id": "P12", "stop": "S07", "volume_dl": 42}, {"id": "P13", "stop": "S07", "volume_dl": 22}, {"id": "P14", "stop": "S08", "volume_dl": 14}, {"id": "P15", "stop": "S09", "volume_dl": 34}, {"id": "P16", "stop": "S10", "volume_dl": 9}, {"id": "P17", "stop": "S11", "volume_dl": 5}, {"id": "P18", "stop": "S12", "volume_dl": 12}, {"id": "P19", "stop": "S13", "volume_dl": 30}, {"id": "P20", "stop": "S14", "volume_dl": 40}, {"id": "P21", "stop": "S14", "volume_dl": 104}, {"id": "P22", "stop": "S14", "volume_dl": 46}, {"id": "P23", "stop": "S14", "volume_dl": 36}, {"id": "P24", "stop": "S15", "volume_dl": 322}, {"id": "P25", "stop": "S16", "volume_dl": 72}, {"id": "P26", "stop": "S17", "volume_dl": 21}, {"id": "P27", "stop": "S17", "volume_dl": 63}, {"id": "P28", "stop": "S17", "volume_dl": 28}, {"id": "P29", "stop": "S17", "volume_dl": 104}, {"id": "P30", "stop": "S18", "volume_dl": 30}, {"id": "P31", "stop": "S19", "volume_dl": 54}, {"id": "P32", "stop": "S20", "volume_dl": 32}, {"id": "P33", "stop": "S21", "volume_dl": 57}, {"id": "P34", "stop": "S22", "volume_dl": 133}, {"id": "P35", "stop": "S22", "volume_dl": 242}, {"id": "P36", "stop": "S22", "volume_dl": 242}, {"id": "P37", "stop": "S23", "volume_dl": 19}, {"id": "P38", "stop": "S24", "volume_dl": 44}, {"id": "P39", "stop": "S25", "volume_dl": 92}, {"id": "P40", "stop": "S25", "volume_dl": 57}, {"id": "P41", "stop": "S25", "volume_dl": 34}, {"id": "P42", "stop": "S25", "volume_dl": 46}, {"id": "P43", "stop": "S25", "volume_dl": 124}, {"id": "P44", "stop": "S26", "volume_dl": 63}, {"id": "P45", "stop": "S27", "volume_dl": 12}, {"id": "P46", "stop": "S27", "volume_dl": 179}, {"id": "P47", "stop": "S28", "volume_dl": 22}, {"id": "P48", "stop": "S29", "volume_dl": 1428}, {"id": "P49", "stop": "S30", "volume_dl": 226}], "vans": 4, "capacity_dl": 1559, "travel_s": [[0, 1279, 1268, 1560, 1272, 1412, 1673, 1430, 1456, 1380, 1370, 1361, 1400, 1452, 1279, 1370, 1297, 1539, 1239, 1484, 1450, 1571, 1383, 1510, 1514, 1318, 1690, 1388, 1566, 1721, 1554], [1275, 0, 144, 641, 235, 263, 699, 281, 307, 231, 332, 323, 257, 304, 156, 842, 174, 391, 202, 630, 412, 831, 346, 362, 366, 195, 758, 240, 417, 571, 545], [1292, 153, 0, 658, 252, 285, 721, 307, 329, 254, 349, 340, 256, 326, 11, 859, 30, 413, 219, 652, 429, 773, 362, 384, 388, 76, 780, 262, 440, 593, 568], [1587, 637, 656, 0, 600, 872, 499, 854, 633, 585, 522, 362, 609, 826, 668, 288, 686, 722, 471, 191, 362, 285, 502, 790, 861, 708, 582, 594, 750, 420, 262], [1288, 274, 262, 592, 0, 407, 870, 425, 450, 375, 284, 274, 395, 447, 274, 785, 292, 534, 153, 689, 364, 782, 297, 505, 509, 305, 930, 384, 561, 743, 759], [1433, 269, 302, 799, 393, 0, 788, 18, 220, 272, 490, 466, 365, 94, 314, 891, 332, 196, 360, 720, 570, 841, 504, 101, 278, 353, 848, 330, 198, 661, 635], [1796, 631, 665, 464, 755, 781, 0, 763, 627, 580, 734, 574, 604, 735, 676, 465, 694, 630, 683, 294, 745, 414, 714, 699, 769, 716, 257, 588, 658, 264, 407], [1451, 287, 320, 816, 411, 18, 806, 0, 237, 290, 508, 484, 383, 112, 331, 909, 350, 186, 378, 738, 588, 858, 521, 83, 288, 366, 866, 348, 180, 679, 653], [1440, 276, 309, 786, 400, 210, 684, 228, 0, 128, 497, 362, 272, 188, 321, 787, 338, 290, 366, 616, 577, 736, 510, 311, 395, 360, 744, 204, 301, 557, 531], [1380, 216, 335, 713, 340, 271, 611, 289, 156, 0, 437, 289, 170, 249, 346, 714, 364, 351, 306, 543, 517, 663, 450, 372, 411, 386, 671, 121, 362, 484, 458], [1364, 350, 338, 532, 282, 483, 810, 501, 522, 474, 0, 214, 498, 523, 350, 725, 368, 610, 153, 628, 303, 722, 237, 581, 585, 389, 870, 482, 637, 683, 699], [1378, 390, 353, 396, 297, 494, 675, 512, 386, 338, 218, 0, 362, 495, 365, 589, 383, 597, 168, 493, 168, 586, 198, 593, 597, 404, 734, 347, 570, 547, 563], [1407, 243, 276, 772, 367, 398, 658, 416, 283, 173, 464, 336, 0, 376, 287, 761, 305, 478, 334, 590, 544, 710, 477, 499, 450, 326, 718, 181, 489, 531, 505], [1460, 296, 329, 826, 420, 115, 750, 133, 198, 251, 518, 478, 394, 0, 341, 902, 359, 102, 387, 731, 597, 852, 531, 198, 305, 380, 860, 326, 114, 672, 647], [1303, 164, 11, 669, 263, 297, 732, 318, 341, 265, 361, 351, 267, 337, 0, 871, 18, 424, 230, 664, 441, 785, 374, 396, 399, 80, 792, 274, 451, 605, 579], [1406, 731, 765, 276, 855, 881, 516, 863, 727, 680, 717, 557, 704, 835, 776, 0, 794, 730, 667, 200, 557, 287, 697, 799, 869, 816, 532, 688, 758, 428, 271], [1322, 182, 30, 687, 281, 315, 750, 333, 359, 283, 379, 370, 286, 355, 18, 889, 0, 442, 248, 682, 459, 803, 392, 414, 418, 54, 810, 292, 469, 623, 597], [1520, 355, 389, 732, 479, 191, 655, 169, 303, 356, 577, 553, 452, 105, 400, 732, 418, 0, 446, 561, 657, 682, 590, 131, 248, 431, 738, 416, 92, 576, 722], [1238, 224, 213, 486, 156, 357, 765, 375, 401, 325, 178, 169, 346, 397, 224, 680, 242, 484, 0, 583, 258, 676, 192, 456, 460, 264, 825, 334, 511, 638, 654], [1516, 556, 590, 216, 680, 706, 333, 688, 552, 505, 659, 499, 529, 660, 601, 216, 620, 556, 608, 0, 497, 166, 639, 624, 694, 641, 416, 513, 584, 254, 159], [1456, 412, 431, 345, 375, 516, 749, 534, 408, 360, 296, 136, 384, 517, 443, 538, 461, 619, 246, 442, 0, 535, 276, 615, 619, 482, 832, 369, 592, 569, 512], [1569, 713, 747, 287, 837, 862, 489, 845, 709, 662, 728, 568, 685, 817, 758, 270, 776, 712, 677, 182, 568, 0, 708, 781, 851, 798, 573, 670, 740, 410, 278], [1412, 497, 387, 502, 330, 531, 781, 552, 492, 445, 252, 185, 469, 602, 398, 696, 416, 704, 202, 599, 274, 692, 0, 629, 634, 429, 841, 453, 677, 654, 670], [1480, 316, 349, 846, 440, 98, 713, 80, 318, 365, 538, 513, 412, 193, 361, 790, 379, 141, 407, 619, 617, 740, 551, 0, 208, 400, 796, 377, 168, 634, 682], [1390, 383, 416, 913, 507, 269, 784, 287, 424, 432, 605, 580, 479, 310, 428, 862, 446, 275, 474, 691, 684, 812, 618, 246, 0, 467, 868, 444, 358, 706, 749], [1328, 189, 90, 694, 288, 322, 757, 339, 365, 290, 386, 376, 292, 362, 81, 895, 63, 449, 255, 688, 465, 809, 399, 420, 424, 0, 817, 299, 476, 629, 604], [1593, 714, 747, 547, 838, 863, 231, 845, 710, 662, 816, 656, 686, 818, 759, 420, 777, 713, 766, 376, 828, 497, 796, 781, 852, 798, 0, 671, 741, 245, 490], [1388, 224, 343, 721, 348, 326, 619, 347, 211, 101, 445, 297, 178, 304, 355, 722, 372, 406, 315, 551, 525, 672, 458, 427, 466, 385, 679, 0, 417, 492, 466], [1555, 391, 424, 733, 515, 174, 656, 156, 293, 346, 613, 556, 489, 95, 436, 734, 454, 102, 482, 563, 692, 683, 626, 180, 349, 475, 740, 421, 0, 577, 688], [1742, 578, 611, 474, 702, 682, 300, 727, 574, 526, 680, 520, 550, 683, 623, 474, 641, 595, 630, 303, 754, 424, 660, 664, 734, 662, 284, 535, 623, 0, 416], [1592, 536, 569, 292, 660, 640, 452, 658, 532, 484, 638, 478, 508, 641, 581, 292, 599, 674, 588, 144, 573, 268, 618, 743, 743, 620, 535, 493, 702, 373, 0]]}, "reference": {"optimum_s": 16094, "optimality": "best_found", "lower_bound_s": 14016, "floor_s": 9908, "solve_s": 80.29, "ffd_s": 20149, "stop_aware_best_s": 18326, "stop_aware_mean_s": 18733.4, "route_id": "RouteID_96cd0efc-5bdf-417f-bf15-fab124b420d2", "plans": {"optimum": [{"route": ["S02", "S14", "S16", "S25", "S12", "S27", "S09", "S08", "S01"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S15", "S03", "S30", "S19", "S06", "S17", "S28", "S13", "S05", "S07", "S23", "S24"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S21", "S29", "S26"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S04", "S22", "S20", "S11", "S10", "S18"], "parcels": []}], "ffd": [{"route": ["S25", "S29", "S11"], "parcels": ["P43"]}, {"route": ["S15", "S06", "S01", "S04", "S22"], "parcels": ["P07", "P35"]}, {"route": ["S04", "S22", "S03", "S30", "S27", "S17", "S05", "S02", "S14", "S16", "S25"], "parcels": ["P04", "P08", "P21", "P27", "P29", "P34", "P36", "P39", "P46"]}, {"route": ["S26", "S19", "S21", "S20", "S10", "S18", "S04", "S02", "S14", "S25", "S12", "S27", "S09", "S08", "S13", "S17", "S28", "S07", "S23", "S24"], "parcels": ["P02", "P03", "P05", "P09", "P20", "P22", "P23", "P26", "P28", "P40", "P41", "P42", "P45"]}], "stop_aware_best": [{"route": ["S04", "S25", "S12", "S27", "S13", "S23", "S24"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S15", "S03", "S26", "S06", "S17", "S07", "S05", "S01", "S16"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S02", "S14", "S09", "S30", "S19", "S21", "S11", "S22"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S18", "S10", "S20", "S29", "S28", "S08"], "parcels": []}]}}, "meta": {"route_id": "RouteID_96cd0efc-5bdf-417f-bf15-fab124b420d2", "split": "train", "stops": 30, "vans": 4, "tightness": 0.9, "station": "DCH4", "city": "DCH", "date": "2018-07-31", "seconds": 136.7, "stop_aware_best_reward": 0.5933, "optimality": "best_found"}}
{"id": "cd3bb014-spread-n20-k3-t0.92-s0", "instance": {"stops": ["S01", "S02", "S03", "S04", "S05", "S06", "S07", "S08", "S09", "S10", "S11", "S12", "S13", "S14", "S15", "S16", "S17", "S18", "S19", "S20"], "parcels": [{"id": "P01", "stop": "S01", "volume_dl": 179}, {"id": "P02", "stop": "S02", "volume_dl": 10}, {"id": "P03", "stop": "S03", "volume_dl": 25}, {"id": "P04", "stop": "S04", "volume_dl": 48}, {"id": "P05", "stop": "S05", "volume_dl": 322}, {"id": "P06", "stop": "S05", "volume_dl": 36}, {"id": "P07", "stop": "S05", "volume_dl": 179}, {"id": "P08", "stop": "S06", "volume_dl": 10}, {"id": "P09", "stop": "S07", "volume_dl": 46}, {"id": "P10", "stop": "S08", "volume_dl": 33}, {"id": "P11", "stop": "S09", "volume_dl": 38}, {"id": "P12", "stop": "S10", "volume_dl": 25}, {"id": "P13", "stop": "S11", "volume_dl": 106}, {"id": "P14", "stop": "S12", "volume_dl": 56}, {"id": "P15", "stop": "S13", "volume_dl": 12}, {"id": "P16", "stop": "S14", "volume_dl": 50}, {"id": "P17", "stop": "S15", "volume_dl": 23}, {"id": "P18", "stop": "S15", "volume_dl": 57}, {"id": "P19", "stop": "S16", "volume_dl": 63}, {"id": "P20", "stop": "S17", "volume_dl": 21}, {"id": "P21", "stop": "S18", "volume_dl": 157}, {"id": "P22", "stop": "S19", "volume_dl": 289}, {"id": "P23", "stop": "S20", "volume_dl": 9}], "vans": 3, "capacity_dl": 651, "travel_s": [[0, 951, 1587, 1430, 963, 1520, 1469, 1376, 1565, 870, 1604, 1634, 1383, 904, 1625, 1438, 1652, 1618, 1733, 1141, 1689], [956, 0, 1052, 770, 180, 860, 809, 716, 782, 226, 791, 1099, 601, 64, 965, 655, 968, 1082, 1198, 497, 942], [1651, 1064, 0, 473, 906, 563, 412, 615, 837, 1054, 834, 170, 834, 1016, 256, 787, 255, 174, 572, 1325, 149], [1439, 737, 529, 0, 580, 191, 193, 164, 364, 727, 361, 558, 383, 690, 361, 337, 376, 481, 915, 998, 338], [971, 162, 965, 615, 0, 705, 654, 639, 602, 241, 610, 994, 420, 115, 810, 474, 812, 918, 1212, 512, 787], [1551, 848, 640, 188, 692, 0, 304, 353, 553, 839, 550, 670, 572, 801, 473, 525, 488, 593, 1027, 1110, 450], [1474, 772, 414, 181, 615, 271, 0, 324, 545, 762, 542, 444, 543, 725, 372, 496, 262, 367, 846, 1033, 286], [1379, 677, 652, 154, 520, 345, 341, 0, 299, 667, 504, 682, 219, 630, 514, 172, 500, 605, 1069, 938, 492], [1573, 765, 874, 346, 602, 537, 538, 301, 0, 843, 426, 904, 163, 718, 707, 119, 722, 827, 1261, 1114, 684], [916, 246, 1011, 744, 259, 834, 783, 690, 860, 0, 869, 1058, 679, 199, 939, 733, 941, 1042, 1157, 271, 916], [1618, 809, 919, 390, 647, 620, 583, 523, 444, 888, 0, 948, 501, 762, 751, 555, 766, 871, 1296, 1159, 728], [1682, 1143, 173, 567, 986, 657, 457, 695, 945, 1156, 929, 0, 914, 1096, 382, 867, 346, 186, 387, 1427, 275], [1410, 602, 872, 373, 440, 564, 561, 219, 181, 680, 477, 901, 0, 555, 734, 54, 719, 824, 1288, 951, 711], [929, 64, 1024, 743, 153, 833, 782, 689, 755, 199, 764, 1072, 574, 0, 938, 628, 940, 1055, 1171, 470, 915], [1635, 933, 280, 342, 776, 432, 282, 485, 706, 923, 704, 383, 704, 886, 0, 657, 118, 382, 786, 1194, 107], [1454, 646, 835, 336, 484, 527, 524, 182, 127, 725, 522, 864, 44, 599, 697, 0, 682, 787, 1252, 996, 674], [1678, 976, 312, 416, 818, 507, 289, 527, 781, 966, 778, 341, 746, 928, 110, 699, 0, 264, 743, 1237, 181], [1683, 1084, 145, 508, 926, 598, 397, 635, 886, 1074, 869, 183, 854, 1036, 355, 807, 287, 0, 586, 1345, 248], [1927, 1361, 548, 907, 1204, 997, 846, 1049, 1271, 1351, 1268, 375, 1268, 1314, 735, 1222, 722, 561, 0, 1622, 651], [1184, 517, 1281, 1014, 529, 1104, 1053, 960, 1131, 270, 1140, 1328, 949, 470, 1209, 1004, 1212, 1312, 1428, 0, 1186], [1633, 931, 173, 340, 774, 430, 279, 482, 704, 921, 701, 276, 701, 884, 107, 654, 169, 280, 679, 1192, 0]]}, "reference": {"optimum_s": 11615, "optimality": "best_found", "lower_bound_s": 9501, "floor_s": 5358, "solve_s": 40.28, "ffd_s": 14006, "stop_aware_best_s": 13935, "stop_aware_mean_s": 14286.6, "route_id": "RouteID_cd3bb014-746f-4c73-9199-ee94c3b611f4", "plans": {"optimum": [{"route": ["S19", "S09", "S13", "S01"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S18", "S11", "S17", "S02", "S20", "S14", "S16", "S06", "S07", "S15", "S08", "S12"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S05", "S03", "S10", "S04"], "parcels": []}], "ffd": [{"route": ["S19", "S09", "S05"], "parcels": ["P05"]}, {"route": ["S18", "S11", "S05", "S03", "S01"], "parcels": ["P07"]}, {"route": ["S17", "S02", "S20", "S14", "S16", "S06", "S05", "S07", "S15", "S12", "S08", "S10", "S04", "S13"], "parcels": ["P06"]}], "stop_aware_best": [{"route": ["S09", "S19", "S12", "S15", "S08", "S03", "S14"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S18", "S11", "S16", "S07", "S04", "S01"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S17", "S02", "S20", "S06", "S05", "S10", "S13"], "parcels": []}]}}, "meta": {"route_id": "RouteID_cd3bb014-746f-4c73-9199-ee94c3b611f4", "split": "train", "stops": 20, "vans": 3, "tightness": 0.92, "station": "DBO3", "city": "DBO", "date": "2018-07-23", "seconds": 48.1, "stop_aware_best_reward": 0.5856, "optimality": "best_found"}}
{"id": "a960e907-spread-n25-k3-t0.88-s0", "instance": {"stops": ["S01", "S02", "S03", "S04", "S05", "S06", "S07", "S08", "S09", "S10", "S11", "S12", "S13", "S14", "S15", "S16", "S17", "S18", "S19", "S20", "S21", "S22", "S23", "S24", "S25"], "parcels": [{"id": "P01", "stop": "S01", "volume_dl": 53}, {"id": "P02", "stop": "S01", "volume_dl": 57}, {"id": "P03", "stop": "S01", "volume_dl": 30}, {"id": "P04", "stop": "S02", "volume_dl": 26}, {"id": "P05", "stop": "S03", "volume_dl": 57}, {"id": "P06", "stop": "S03", "volume_dl": 48}, {"id": "P07", "stop": "S03", "volume_dl": 28}, {"id": "P08", "stop": "S04", "volume_dl": 179}, {"id": "P09", "stop": "S04", "volume_dl": 23}, {"id": "P10", "stop": "S04", "volume_dl": 50}, {"id": "P11", "stop": "S04", "volume_dl": 50}, {"id": "P12", "stop": "S05", "volume_dl": 57}, {"id": "P13", "stop": "S06", "volume_dl": 95}, {"id": "P14", "stop": "S07", "volume_dl": 157}, {"id": "P15", "stop": "S07", "volume_dl": 117}, {"id": "P16", "stop": "S08", "volume_dl": 50}, {"id": "P17", "stop": "S09", "volume_dl": 34}, {"id": "P18", "stop": "S10", "volume_dl": 8}, {"id": "P19", "stop": "S11", "volume_dl": 179}, {"id": "P20", "stop": "S12", "volume_dl": 104}, {"id": "P21", "stop": "S13", "volume_dl": 134}, {"id": "P22", "stop": "S14", "volume_dl": 14}, {"id": "P23", "stop": "S15", "volume_dl": 104}, {"id": "P24", "stop": "S16", "volume_dl": 322}, {"id": "P25", "stop": "S17", "volume_dl": 8}, {"id": "P26", "stop": "S18", "volume_dl": 63}, {"id": "P27", "stop": "S19", "volume_dl": 26}, {"id": "P28", "stop": "S20", "volume_dl": 6}, {"id": "P29", "stop": "S21", "volume_dl": 226}, {"id": "P30", "stop": "S22", "volume_dl": 8}, {"id": "P31", "stop": "S23", "volume_dl": 92}, {"id": "P32", "stop": "S23", "volume_dl": 95}, {"id": "P33", "stop": "S24", "volume_dl": 322}, {"id": "P34", "stop": "S25", "volume_dl": 95}], "vans": 3, "capacity_dl": 1105, "travel_s": [[0, 1401, 1189, 1260, 1438, 1465, 1366, 1370, 1383, 1394, 1358, 1380, 1356, 1350, 1375, 1358, 1452, 1235, 1289, 1465, 1369, 1328, 1280, 1339, 1308, 1419], [1359, 0, 432, 265, 243, 347, 58, 132, 26, 162, 209, 262, 334, 244, 269, 126, 205, 478, 208, 270, 374, 126, 140, 110, 313, 200], [1253, 412, 0, 386, 442, 469, 370, 373, 386, 498, 461, 384, 456, 451, 476, 461, 541, 70, 391, 605, 495, 461, 475, 342, 434, 519], [1217, 256, 422, 0, 351, 133, 215, 218, 231, 293, 256, 201, 96, 177, 202, 256, 336, 468, 116, 400, 109, 256, 270, 186, 104, 318], [1501, 224, 454, 350, 0, 432, 194, 275, 236, 230, 153, 347, 419, 393, 418, 207, 287, 500, 354, 351, 459, 246, 260, 253, 398, 117], [1364, 313, 479, 146, 408, 0, 272, 275, 288, 399, 363, 166, 89, 305, 330, 363, 442, 525, 245, 507, 189, 363, 376, 244, 158, 424], [1364, 68, 380, 213, 203, 295, 0, 81, 42, 263, 186, 210, 282, 219, 244, 163, 243, 426, 183, 307, 322, 163, 177, 60, 261, 176], [1358, 134, 375, 207, 303, 289, 92, 0, 108, 219, 183, 205, 277, 226, 251, 183, 262, 421, 203, 327, 316, 183, 197, 64, 255, 244], [1390, 26, 406, 239, 235, 321, 32, 107, 0, 188, 218, 237, 309, 245, 270, 151, 231, 452, 209, 296, 348, 152, 165, 86, 287, 208], [1359, 148, 498, 286, 328, 413, 169, 198, 174, 0, 93, 328, 383, 272, 297, 93, 172, 544, 236, 237, 395, 126, 139, 177, 334, 154], [1326, 116, 465, 254, 146, 380, 137, 166, 142, 77, 0, 296, 350, 240, 265, 54, 133, 511, 204, 198, 363, 93, 107, 145, 302, 61], [1331, 252, 418, 180, 347, 169, 211, 214, 227, 338, 302, 0, 140, 244, 269, 302, 381, 464, 184, 446, 240, 302, 316, 183, 225, 363], [1317, 332, 497, 100, 426, 100, 290, 293, 306, 393, 356, 170, 0, 277, 302, 356, 436, 543, 216, 500, 100, 356, 370, 262, 111, 418], [1333, 241, 472, 182, 401, 316, 200, 214, 216, 263, 227, 252, 278, 0, 47, 227, 306, 518, 132, 371, 291, 227, 241, 183, 230, 288], [1366, 274, 505, 215, 434, 348, 232, 246, 249, 296, 260, 284, 311, 34, 0, 260, 339, 551, 165, 404, 324, 260, 273, 216, 263, 321], [1330, 119, 469, 257, 184, 383, 140, 169, 145, 80, 37, 299, 353, 243, 268, 0, 80, 515, 207, 144, 366, 96, 110, 148, 305, 98], [1390, 180, 529, 318, 244, 444, 201, 230, 206, 141, 98, 359, 414, 304, 328, 60, 0, 575, 268, 190, 427, 157, 170, 209, 366, 159], [1309, 468, 80, 442, 498, 525, 426, 429, 442, 554, 517, 440, 512, 507, 532, 517, 597, 0, 447, 661, 551, 517, 531, 398, 490, 575], [1269, 203, 409, 118, 337, 251, 161, 190, 177, 225, 189, 188, 214, 110, 134, 188, 268, 455, 0, 332, 227, 189, 202, 162, 166, 250], [1476, 265, 615, 403, 330, 530, 286, 315, 291, 226, 184, 445, 500, 389, 414, 146, 191, 661, 353, 0, 512, 243, 256, 294, 451, 245], [1318, 357, 522, 100, 451, 197, 315, 318, 331, 393, 357, 200, 97, 278, 302, 356, 436, 568, 216, 500, 0, 357, 370, 287, 190, 418], [1292, 146, 489, 278, 255, 404, 161, 190, 172, 145, 108, 319, 374, 264, 288, 108, 188, 535, 228, 252, 387, 0, 72, 169, 326, 170], [1247, 168, 518, 394, 272, 527, 189, 218, 194, 162, 125, 348, 490, 292, 317, 125, 205, 564, 256, 269, 503, 121, 0, 197, 442, 186], [1365, 93, 366, 212, 256, 347, 53, 65, 69, 180, 144, 196, 310, 200, 224, 144, 224, 412, 164, 288, 323, 144, 158, 0, 262, 205], [1272, 311, 476, 76, 405, 138, 269, 272, 285, 347, 311, 222, 101, 232, 256, 310, 390, 522, 170, 454, 185, 311, 324, 241, 0, 372], [1409, 198, 545, 336, 111, 463, 202, 248, 224, 160, 82, 378, 433, 322, 347, 136, 216, 591, 286, 280, 445, 176, 189, 227, 384, 0]]}, "reference": {"optimum_s": 10400, "optimality": "best_found", "lower_bound_s": 9335, "floor_s": 7218, "solve_s": 82.48, "ffd_s": 12176, "stop_aware_best_s": 11564, "stop_aware_mean_s": 11792.2, "route_id": "RouteID_a960e907-674b-48f9-9e49-47c46e90c342", "plans": {"optimum": [{"route": ["S18", "S14", "S13", "S07", "S23", "S06", "S08", "S01", "S09"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S19", "S16", "S15", "S10", "S25", "S04", "S21", "S22"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S17", "S02", "S11", "S05", "S12", "S20", "S03", "S24"], "parcels": []}], "ffd": [{"route": ["S21", "S16", "S04", "S01", "S24"], "parcels": ["P01", "P08"]}, {"route": ["S13", "S15", "S25", "S04", "S06", "S23", "S07", "S11", "S12"], "parcels": ["P09", "P32"]}, {"route": ["S17", "S02", "S05", "S20", "S03", "S18", "S14", "S23", "S08", "S01", "S04", "S10", "S19", "S09", "S22"], "parcels": ["P02", "P03", "P10", "P11", "P31"]}], "stop_aware_best": [{"route": ["S17", "S02", "S12", "S20", "S13", "S23", "S04", "S25", "S21", "S22"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S18", "S14", "S16", "S15", "S10", "S09", "S08", "S07", "S05", "S03"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S19", "S01", "S06", "S11", "S24"], "parcels": []}]}}, "meta": {"route_id": "RouteID_a960e907-674b-48f9-9e49-47c46e90c342", "split": "train", "stops": 25, "vans": 3, "tightness": 0.88, "station": "DBO2", "city": "DBO", "date": "2018-07-24", "seconds": 127.7, "stop_aware_best_reward": 0.5936, "optimality": "best_found"}}
{"id": "2c320a42-spread-n25-k3-t0.85-s0", "instance": {"stops": ["S01", "S02", "S03", "S04", "S05", "S06", "S07", "S08", "S09", "S10", "S11", "S12", "S13", "S14", "S15", "S16", "S17", "S18", "S19", "S20", "S21", "S22", "S23", "S24", "S25"], "parcels": [{"id": "P01", "stop": "S01", "volume_dl": 14}, {"id": "P02", "stop": "S02", "volume_dl": 179}, {"id": "P03", "stop": "S03", "volume_dl": 41}, {"id": "P04", "stop": "S04", "volume_dl": 179}, {"id": "P05", "stop": "S05", "volume_dl": 57}, {"id": "P06", "stop": "S05", "volume_dl": 60}, {"id": "P07", "stop": "S06", "volume_dl": 63}, {"id": "P08", "stop": "S06", "volume_dl": 542}, {"id": "P09", "stop": "S06", "volume_dl": 157}, {"id": "P10", "stop": "S06", "volume_dl": 840}, {"id": "P11", "stop": "S07", "volume_dl": 36}, {"id": "P12", "stop": "S08", "volume_dl": 19}, {"id": "P13", "stop": "S09", "volume_dl": 59}, {"id": "P14", "stop": "S10", "volume_dl": 134}, {"id": "P15", "stop": "S10", "volume_dl": 242}, {"id": "P16", "stop": "S10", "volume_dl": 104}, {"id": "P17", "stop": "S11", "volume_dl": 57}, {"id": "P18", "stop": "S11", "volume_dl": 63}, {"id": "P19", "stop": "S11", "volume_dl": 57}, {"id": "P20", "stop": "S11", "volume_dl": 42}, {"id": "P21", "stop": "S12", "volume_dl": 104}, {"id": "P22", "stop": "S13", "volume_dl": 157}, {"id": "P23", "stop": "S14", "volume_dl": 9}, {"id": "P24", "stop": "S14", "volume_dl": 40}, {"id": "P25", "stop": "S14", "volume_dl": 95}, {"id": "P26", "stop": "S14", "volume_dl": 134}, {"id": "P27", "stop": "S14", "volume_dl": 134}, {"id": "P28", "stop": "S15", "volume_dl": 622}, {"id": "P29", "stop": "S15", "volume_dl": 104}, {"id": "P30", "stop": "S15", "volume_dl": 59}, {"id": "P31", "stop": "S16", "volume_dl": 34}, {"id": "P32", "stop": "S16", "volume_dl": 242}, {"id": "P33", "stop": "S16", "volume_dl": 20}, {"id": "P34", "stop": "S16", "volume_dl": 20}, {"id": "P35", "stop": "S16", "volume_dl": 337}, {"id": "P36", "stop": "S16", "volume_dl": 30}, {"id": "P37", "stop": "S17", "volume_dl": 25}, {"id": "P38", "stop": "S18", "volume_dl": 381}, {"id": "P39", "stop": "S19", "volume_dl": 58}, {"id": "P40", "stop": "S19", "volume_dl": 86}, {"id": "P41", "stop": "S19", "volume_dl": 42}, {"id": "P42", "stop": "S19", "volume_dl": 26}, {"id": "P43", "stop": "S19", "volume_dl": 133}, {"id": "P44", "stop": "S19", "volume_dl": 31}, {"id": "P45", "stop": "S19", "volume_dl": 157}, {"id": "P46", "stop": "S20", "volume_dl": 41}, {"id": "P47", "stop": "S20", "volume_dl": 226}, {"id": "P48", "stop": "S21", "volume_dl": 34}, {"id": "P49", "stop": "S21", "volume_dl": 259}, {"id": "P50", "stop": "S22", "volume_dl": 95}, {"id": "P51", "stop": "S22", "volume_dl": 34}, {"id": "P52", "stop": "S22", "volume_dl": 63}, {"id": "P53", "stop": "S23", "volume_dl": 140}, {"id": "P54", "stop": "S23", "volume_dl": 429}, {"id": "P55", "stop": "S24", "volume_dl": 14}, {"id": "P56", "stop": "S24", "volume_dl": 9}, {"id": "P57", "stop": "S24", "volume_dl": 34}, {"id": "P58", "stop": "S25", "volume_dl": 133}], "vans": 3, "capacity_dl": 2957, "travel_s": [[0, 2459, 2564, 2395, 2334, 2244, 2373, 2321, 2411, 2261, 2318, 2357, 2525, 2246, 2239, 2346, 2310, 2323, 2140, 2257, 2355, 2439, 2362, 2209, 2388, 2363], [2588, 0, 230, 436, 587, 411, 184, 432, 266, 579, 158, 398, 190, 637, 259, 129, 414, 200, 530, 575, 437, 137, 610, 527, 430, 175], [2715, 229, 0, 627, 652, 476, 309, 560, 336, 707, 292, 589, 59, 702, 324, 253, 479, 266, 596, 703, 565, 202, 751, 654, 620, 299], [2588, 454, 564, 0, 338, 254, 367, 424, 459, 558, 312, 149, 524, 538, 326, 340, 397, 406, 431, 554, 360, 467, 437, 506, 120, 358], [2360, 514, 624, 336, 0, 258, 427, 237, 502, 318, 372, 299, 585, 542, 330, 400, 401, 415, 435, 314, 265, 528, 197, 265, 330, 418], [2424, 346, 456, 221, 246, 0, 260, 333, 335, 467, 208, 184, 417, 374, 175, 241, 234, 247, 268, 463, 276, 360, 346, 415, 240, 250], [2564, 98, 212, 412, 493, 317, 0, 408, 249, 555, 138, 375, 173, 620, 228, 120, 397, 183, 513, 551, 420, 120, 586, 503, 431, 158], [2354, 447, 558, 328, 212, 319, 361, 0, 453, 312, 306, 290, 518, 582, 371, 334, 442, 400, 476, 308, 200, 461, 240, 260, 321, 351], [2655, 172, 218, 557, 582, 407, 249, 500, 0, 647, 235, 519, 179, 632, 254, 196, 362, 196, 526, 643, 505, 43, 682, 594, 550, 239], [2276, 629, 739, 509, 327, 501, 542, 347, 634, 0, 487, 471, 700, 764, 552, 515, 623, 582, 657, 20, 382, 643, 356, 149, 503, 533], [2472, 164, 278, 320, 401, 225, 96, 316, 188, 463, 0, 282, 239, 553, 161, 77, 348, 106, 447, 459, 328, 186, 494, 411, 339, 86], [2518, 384, 494, 138, 268, 185, 298, 354, 390, 489, 245, 0, 455, 468, 269, 278, 328, 337, 362, 485, 291, 398, 367, 436, 101, 288], [2656, 170, 39, 568, 593, 417, 250, 500, 277, 648, 233, 530, 0, 643, 265, 194, 420, 206, 536, 644, 506, 143, 692, 595, 561, 240], [2426, 562, 667, 497, 522, 347, 475, 608, 513, 743, 420, 459, 627, 0, 341, 448, 412, 425, 172, 739, 545, 541, 622, 690, 491, 466], [2442, 267, 313, 317, 342, 166, 200, 428, 198, 562, 161, 279, 274, 392, 0, 171, 198, 72, 286, 558, 364, 206, 441, 510, 336, 191], [2564, 238, 330, 455, 480, 304, 139, 408, 240, 555, 95, 417, 291, 530, 138, 0, 336, 75, 424, 551, 420, 238, 579, 503, 474, 130], [2653, 487, 533, 527, 552, 377, 429, 639, 330, 773, 427, 490, 494, 603, 340, 399, 0, 333, 496, 769, 582, 358, 652, 721, 546, 420], [2506, 204, 273, 380, 405, 230, 139, 407, 166, 626, 98, 342, 234, 456, 77, 118, 261, 0, 349, 622, 428, 174, 505, 573, 374, 130], [2351, 487, 592, 422, 448, 272, 400, 534, 438, 668, 345, 385, 553, 184, 266, 373, 337, 350, 0, 664, 470, 466, 547, 616, 416, 391], [2260, 613, 723, 493, 311, 485, 526, 331, 619, 27, 474, 456, 684, 748, 549, 507, 607, 566, 641, 0, 372, 627, 340, 133, 512, 517], [2366, 427, 537, 308, 266, 305, 347, 241, 433, 392, 288, 270, 498, 562, 363, 322, 428, 380, 456, 394, 0, 441, 316, 346, 333, 331], [2597, 128, 174, 472, 497, 321, 206, 456, 148, 604, 195, 434, 135, 547, 197, 161, 276, 152, 440, 600, 526, 0, 596, 551, 490, 196], [2380, 610, 721, 427, 168, 349, 524, 257, 593, 338, 472, 389, 681, 632, 434, 505, 492, 505, 526, 334, 307, 624, 0, 285, 446, 514], [2235, 580, 690, 461, 286, 452, 494, 299, 586, 144, 441, 423, 651, 715, 516, 474, 574, 533, 608, 140, 340, 594, 314, 0, 480, 484], [2587, 452, 563, 146, 337, 253, 366, 423, 458, 557, 314, 83, 523, 537, 338, 347, 396, 405, 430, 553, 366, 466, 436, 505, 0, 356], [2573, 108, 222, 422, 502, 327, 10, 418, 259, 565, 144, 384, 183, 629, 251, 122, 406, 193, 523, 561, 423, 130, 595, 512, 415, 0]]}, "reference": {"optimum_s": 17466, "optimality": "best_found", "lower_bound_s": 15090, "floor_s": 13125, "solve_s": 61.24, "ffd_s": 19969, "stop_aware_best_s": 18827, "stop_aware_mean_s": 19049.8, "route_id": "RouteID_2c320a42-0447-4527-a4da-3ad2708b4ea6", "plans": {"optimum": [{"route": ["S16", "S08", "S21", "S02", "S12", "S01", "S15", "S17", "S14"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S10", "S25", "S06", "S07", "S20"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S18", "S13", "S05", "S03", "S24", "S11", "S04", "S22", "S23", "S09", "S19"], "parcels": []}], "ffd": [{"route": ["S18", "S15", "S06", "S23"], "parcels": ["P08", "P10", "P28"]}, {"route": ["S13", "S14", "S10", "S25", "S06", "S02", "S21", "S16", "S11", "S20", "S04", "S19"], "parcels": ["P09", "P20", "P26", "P27", "P32", "P35", "P43", "P45", "P47", "P49"]}, {"route": ["S16", "S08", "S21", "S12", "S01", "S06", "S15", "S17", "S14", "S05", "S03", "S24", "S11", "S20", "S07", "S22", "S09", "S19"], "parcels": ["P07", "P17", "P18", "P19", "P23", "P24", "P25", "P29", "P30", "P31", "P33", "P34", "P36", "P39", "P40", "P41", "P42", "P44", "P46", "P48"]}], "stop_aware_best": [{"route": ["S17", "S06", "S21", "S01", "S20", "S23"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S13", "S15", "S10", "S05", "S03", "S24", "S04"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S18", "S14", "S16", "S08", "S02", "S12", "S25", "S11", "S07", "S22", "S09", "S19"], "parcels": []}]}}, "meta": {"route_id": "RouteID_2c320a42-0447-4527-a4da-3ad2708b4ea6", "split": "train", "stops": 25, "vans": 3, "tightness": 0.85, "station": "DSE5", "city": "DSE", "date": "2018-08-09", "seconds": 121.6, "stop_aware_best_reward": 0.6334, "optimality": "best_found"}}
{"id": "c91c698c-spread-n30-k4-t0.88-s0", "instance": {"stops": ["S01", "S02", "S03", "S04", "S05", "S06", "S07", "S08", "S09", "S10", "S11", "S12", "S13", "S14", "S15", "S16", "S17", "S18", "S19", "S20", "S21", "S22", "S23", "S24", "S25", "S26", "S27", "S28", "S29", "S30"], "parcels": [{"id": "P01", "stop": "S01", "volume_dl": 53}, {"id": "P02", "stop": "S01", "volume_dl": 127}, {"id": "P03", "stop": "S02", "volume_dl": 58}, {"id": "P04", "stop": "S03", "volume_dl": 21}, {"id": "P05", "stop": "S04", "volume_dl": 34}, {"id": "P06", "stop": "S04", "volume_dl": 63}, {"id": "P07", "stop": "S05", "volume_dl": 18}, {"id": "P08", "stop": "S06", "volume_dl": 95}, {"id": "P09", "stop": "S07", "volume_dl": 26}, {"id": "P10", "stop": "S08", "volume_dl": 63}, {"id": "P11", "stop": "S08", "volume_dl": 34}, {"id": "P12", "stop": "S09", "volume_dl": 27}, {"id": "P13", "stop": "S09", "volume_dl": 57}, {"id": "P14", "stop": "S10", "volume_dl": 58}, {"id": "P15", "stop": "S11", "volume_dl": 18}, {"id": "P16", "stop": "S12", "volume_dl": 542}, {"id": "P17", "stop": "S13", "volume_dl": 110}, {"id": "P18", "stop": "S14", "volume_dl": 141}, {"id": "P19", "stop": "S15", "volume_dl": 53}, {"id": "P20", "stop": "S16", "volume_dl": 36}, {"id": "P21", "stop": "S17", "volume_dl": 226}, {"id": "P22", "stop": "S17", "volume_dl": 242}, {"id": "P23", "stop": "S18", "volume_dl": 179}, {"id": "P24", "stop": "S18", "volume_dl": 63}, {"id": "P25", "stop": "S18", "volume_dl": 92}, {"id": "P26", "stop": "S19", "volume_dl": 30}, {"id": "P27", "stop": "S20", "volume_dl": 57}, {"id": "P28", "stop": "S21", "volume_dl": 29}, {"id": "P29", "stop": "S22", "volume_dl": 259}, {"id": "P30", "stop": "S22", "volume_dl": 46}, {"id": "P31", "stop": "S23", "volume_dl": 46}, {"id": "P32", "stop": "S24", "volume_dl": 53}, {"id": "P33", "stop": "S25", "volume_dl": 60}, {"id": "P34", "stop": "S26", "volume_dl": 57}, {"id": "P35", "stop": "S26", "volume_dl": 104}, {"id": "P36", "stop": "S27", "volume_dl": 89}, {"id": "P37", "stop": "S28", "volume_dl": 652}, {"id": "P38", "stop": "S29", "volume_dl": 9}, {"id": "P39", "stop": "S30", "volume_dl": 36}], "vans": 4, "capacity_dl": 1127, "travel_s": [[0, 2532, 2726, 2606, 2569, 2449, 2593, 2561, 2675, 2463, 2570, 2560, 2374, 2537, 2818, 2497, 2367, 2785, 2743, 2486, 2593, 2580, 2742, 2582, 2642, 2799, 2701, 2482, 2477, 2445, 2820], [2451, 0, 605, 645, 608, 488, 632, 600, 555, 305, 609, 599, 374, 576, 698, 535, 218, 665, 652, 279, 61, 48, 627, 621, 522, 679, 740, 344, 516, 252, 699], [2651, 661, 0, 184, 313, 403, 205, 384, 172, 533, 237, 247, 519, 330, 155, 392, 620, 169, 80, 511, 675, 662, 101, 287, 140, 117, 329, 478, 489, 484, 138], [2505, 639, 201, 0, 148, 239, 41, 220, 330, 461, 72, 82, 355, 166, 285, 228, 474, 326, 176, 485, 685, 673, 259, 123, 297, 298, 165, 426, 325, 443, 319], [2466, 601, 329, 167, 0, 201, 154, 182, 457, 428, 132, 122, 317, 127, 413, 157, 435, 454, 309, 447, 647, 634, 386, 143, 424, 426, 262, 388, 287, 405, 446], [2385, 519, 418, 256, 219, 0, 243, 211, 542, 342, 221, 211, 236, 187, 502, 147, 354, 543, 393, 365, 566, 553, 476, 232, 509, 515, 351, 307, 206, 324, 535], [2492, 626, 222, 61, 136, 226, 0, 207, 351, 448, 60, 70, 342, 153, 307, 215, 461, 348, 198, 472, 672, 660, 280, 110, 318, 320, 152, 413, 312, 430, 340], [2500, 634, 402, 240, 203, 235, 228, 0, 530, 457, 205, 195, 351, 88, 486, 224, 469, 527, 377, 480, 681, 668, 460, 174, 497, 499, 335, 422, 321, 439, 520], [2577, 586, 168, 324, 452, 537, 345, 523, 0, 458, 376, 386, 423, 469, 261, 531, 546, 212, 215, 436, 600, 587, 184, 418, 47, 242, 469, 403, 566, 410, 262], [2336, 307, 496, 483, 451, 326, 470, 438, 450, 0, 448, 438, 212, 414, 589, 374, 204, 556, 547, 100, 296, 283, 518, 459, 413, 570, 578, 235, 354, 58, 590], [2487, 622, 252, 91, 131, 222, 78, 202, 381, 444, 0, 10, 338, 148, 336, 210, 456, 378, 228, 468, 668, 655, 310, 107, 348, 349, 186, 409, 308, 426, 370], [2477, 612, 262, 101, 121, 212, 88, 192, 391, 434, 10, 0, 328, 138, 346, 200, 446, 388, 238, 458, 658, 645, 320, 117, 358, 359, 196, 399, 298, 416, 380], [2245, 379, 434, 361, 324, 204, 348, 316, 384, 200, 326, 316, 0, 292, 527, 252, 214, 494, 486, 224, 408, 395, 451, 337, 351, 508, 456, 191, 232, 182, 529], [2455, 589, 324, 162, 126, 189, 150, 88, 452, 412, 127, 117, 306, 0, 408, 178, 424, 449, 299, 435, 636, 623, 382, 138, 419, 421, 257, 377, 276, 394, 442], [2734, 744, 165, 294, 451, 542, 316, 512, 256, 616, 347, 357, 581, 468, 0, 531, 703, 253, 190, 594, 758, 745, 185, 338, 223, 219, 439, 561, 628, 568, 239], [2408, 542, 422, 260, 139, 142, 248, 216, 564, 364, 225, 215, 258, 191, 506, 0, 377, 547, 397, 388, 589, 576, 480, 236, 532, 519, 355, 330, 228, 347, 540], [2282, 222, 613, 549, 512, 392, 537, 505, 563, 154, 514, 504, 278, 480, 706, 440, 0, 672, 664, 236, 279, 266, 629, 525, 530, 686, 644, 371, 421, 195, 707], [2675, 684, 129, 284, 413, 504, 306, 484, 196, 560, 337, 347, 521, 430, 222, 492, 644, 0, 176, 534, 698, 685, 89, 378, 163, 162, 430, 501, 590, 508, 182], [2645, 712, 95, 161, 289, 380, 182, 360, 223, 602, 213, 223, 496, 306, 179, 368, 614, 220, 0, 562, 726, 713, 153, 264, 190, 192, 306, 567, 466, 535, 213], [2359, 258, 474, 507, 470, 350, 494, 462, 424, 80, 471, 461, 235, 438, 567, 397, 227, 534, 526, 0, 247, 234, 490, 482, 391, 548, 601, 213, 378, 31, 568], [2466, 57, 629, 668, 631, 511, 656, 624, 578, 324, 633, 623, 397, 599, 722, 559, 223, 688, 680, 302, 0, 13, 645, 644, 546, 702, 763, 367, 540, 276, 723], [2453, 44, 615, 655, 618, 498, 642, 610, 565, 311, 619, 609, 384, 586, 708, 545, 210, 675, 667, 289, 13, 0, 632, 631, 532, 689, 750, 354, 526, 262, 710], [2643, 659, 80, 264, 392, 482, 285, 463, 170, 529, 316, 326, 490, 409, 190, 471, 612, 105, 155, 503, 667, 654, 0, 347, 132, 100, 409, 470, 569, 476, 121], [2504, 638, 288, 127, 148, 238, 114, 174, 409, 461, 112, 118, 355, 165, 372, 227, 473, 406, 264, 484, 685, 672, 338, 0, 376, 385, 222, 426, 325, 443, 406], [2530, 540, 122, 277, 405, 491, 298, 477, 33, 411, 329, 339, 376, 422, 214, 485, 499, 181, 173, 390, 553, 541, 138, 371, 0, 195, 422, 356, 519, 363, 216], [2682, 692, 94, 278, 407, 497, 300, 478, 203, 563, 331, 341, 528, 424, 205, 486, 651, 156, 174, 542, 705, 692, 79, 362, 170, 0, 424, 508, 584, 515, 21], [2583, 717, 330, 169, 227, 317, 156, 298, 459, 544, 151, 161, 434, 244, 415, 306, 552, 456, 311, 563, 764, 751, 388, 202, 426, 427, 0, 505, 404, 522, 448], [2377, 369, 427, 453, 416, 296, 440, 408, 376, 241, 418, 408, 233, 384, 520, 344, 346, 486, 478, 219, 383, 370, 443, 429, 344, 500, 548, 0, 324, 192, 521], [2359, 493, 490, 328, 292, 172, 316, 284, 516, 316, 293, 283, 210, 259, 574, 219, 328, 626, 465, 339, 540, 527, 548, 304, 483, 587, 423, 281, 0, 298, 608], [2328, 290, 438, 475, 438, 318, 462, 430, 387, 48, 440, 430, 204, 406, 530, 366, 196, 497, 489, 41, 279, 266, 454, 451, 354, 511, 570, 176, 347, 0, 532], [2700, 709, 112, 296, 425, 515, 318, 496, 221, 581, 349, 359, 546, 442, 223, 504, 669, 174, 192, 559, 723, 710, 97, 380, 188, 18, 442, 526, 602, 533, 0]]}, "reference": {"optimum_s": 23473, "optimality": "best_found", "lower_bound_s": 20355, "floor_s": 18448, "solve_s": 44.21, "ffd_s": 26430, "stop_aware_best_s": 24909, "stop_aware_mean_s": 25616, "route_id": "RouteID_c91c698c-f263-400d-92a3-804df1817d0f", "plans": {"optimum": [{"route": ["S07", "S13", "S11", "S10", "S03", "S18", "S02", "S24", "S09", "S29", "S19", "S21", "S20", "S01", "S16"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S05", "S15", "S04", "S23", "S06", "S26", "S28"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S14", "S30", "S25", "S22", "S17", "S08"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S12", "S27"], "parcels": []}], "ffd": [{"route": ["S22", "S18", "S28", "S16"], "parcels": ["P23", "P29"]}, {"route": ["S13", "S17", "S12"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S01", "S20", "S09", "S27", "S08", "S14", "S25", "S02", "S18", "S06", "S26", "S10", "S04"], "parcels": ["P02", "P06", "P10", "P13", "P24", "P25", "P35"]}, {"route": ["S05", "S15", "S04", "S07", "S23", "S11", "S26", "S03", "S30", "S22", "S24", "S08", "S09", "S29", "S19", "S21", "S01"], "parcels": ["P01", "P05", "P11", "P12", "P30", "P34"]}], "stop_aware_best": [{"route": ["S11", "S18", "S30", "S08", "S12"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S16", "S29", "S24", "S17", "S25", "S02", "S26", "S10", "S23", "S15", "S05"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S01", "S20", "S21", "S27", "S07", "S28"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S13", "S04", "S06", "S03", "S14", "S22", "S19", "S09"], "parcels": []}]}}, "meta": {"route_id": "RouteID_c91c698c-f263-400d-92a3-804df1817d0f", "split": "train", "stops": 30, "vans": 4, "tightness": 0.88, "station": "DSE5", "city": "DSE", "date": "2018-07-26", "seconds": 99.3, "stop_aware_best_reward": 0.6568, "optimality": "best_found"}}
{"id": "b6f25e23-spread-n20-k3-t0.93-s0", "instance": {"stops": ["S01", "S02", "S03", "S04", "S05", "S06", "S07", "S08", "S09", "S10", "S11", "S12", "S13", "S14", "S15", "S16", "S17", "S18", "S19", "S20"], "parcels": [{"id": "P01", "stop": "S01", "volume_dl": 57}, {"id": "P02", "stop": "S01", "volume_dl": 133}, {"id": "P03", "stop": "S01", "volume_dl": 242}, {"id": "P04", "stop": "S02", "volume_dl": 34}, {"id": "P05", "stop": "S02", "volume_dl": 157}, {"id": "P06", "stop": "S02", "volume_dl": 95}, {"id": "P07", "stop": "S03", "volume_dl": 36}, {"id": "P08", "stop": "S04", "volume_dl": 63}, {"id": "P09", "stop": "S05", "volume_dl": 13}, {"id": "P10", "stop": "S05", "volume_dl": 18}, {"id": "P11", "stop": "S06", "volume_dl": 95}, {"id": "P12", "stop": "S06", "volume_dl": 179}, {"id": "P13", "stop": "S07", "volume_dl": 95}, {"id": "P14", "stop": "S07", "volume_dl": 104}, {"id": "P15", "stop": "S07", "volume_dl": 12}, {"id": "P16", "stop": "S08", "volume_dl": 34}, {"id": "P17", "stop": "S09", "volume_dl": 40}, {"id": "P18", "stop": "S10", "volume_dl": 79}, {"id": "P19", "stop": "S10", "volume_dl": 57}, {"id": "P20", "stop": "S11", "volume_dl": 5}, {"id": "P21", "stop": "S12", "volume_dl": 358}, {"id": "P22", "stop": "S13", "volume_dl": 358}, {"id": "P23", "stop": "S14", "volume_dl": 224}, {"id": "P24", "stop": "S15", "volume_dl": 79}, {"id": "P25", "stop": "S16", "volume_dl": 59}, {"id": "P26", "stop": "S17", "volume_dl": 15}, {"id": "P27", "stop": "S18", "volume_dl": 59}, {"id": "P28", "stop": "S18", "volume_dl": 57}, {"id": "P29", "stop": "S19", "volume_dl": 63}, {"id": "P30", "stop": "S19", "volume_dl": 21}, {"id": "P31", "stop": "S20", "volume_dl": 95}], "vans": 3, "capacity_dl": 1054, "travel_s": [[0, 2042, 2018, 2033, 1802, 1970, 1966, 1918, 1995, 1996, 1889, 1901, 2056, 1965, 1911, 2055, 1992, 1851, 2101, 1946, 1829], [2081, 0, 565, 377, 509, 482, 310, 427, 352, 709, 274, 157, 433, 658, 136, 555, 371, 384, 478, 94, 294], [2002, 564, 0, 324, 408, 161, 322, 312, 438, 176, 466, 423, 293, 125, 433, 192, 282, 388, 276, 468, 406], [2054, 337, 295, 0, 418, 212, 79, 308, 210, 439, 246, 196, 175, 388, 206, 279, 120, 367, 202, 241, 250], [1845, 522, 427, 434, 0, 411, 367, 341, 504, 458, 369, 381, 489, 407, 392, 406, 428, 252, 534, 427, 309], [2024, 458, 145, 221, 423, 0, 219, 275, 335, 286, 360, 320, 200, 235, 330, 202, 179, 346, 213, 362, 303], [2004, 288, 310, 142, 368, 227, 0, 258, 160, 454, 196, 146, 172, 403, 157, 294, 110, 317, 217, 192, 200], [1982, 410, 313, 307, 335, 258, 240, 0, 264, 457, 318, 268, 343, 406, 279, 278, 279, 210, 388, 314, 286], [2042, 329, 434, 246, 463, 351, 179, 278, 0, 578, 238, 187, 302, 527, 198, 424, 240, 358, 347, 233, 242], [1998, 689, 176, 448, 452, 286, 446, 437, 563, 0, 591, 547, 417, 51, 558, 243, 406, 487, 400, 593, 531], [1911, 276, 443, 255, 340, 360, 188, 305, 230, 587, 0, 122, 311, 536, 161, 433, 249, 215, 356, 167, 127], [1956, 141, 430, 242, 384, 347, 175, 292, 217, 574, 138, 0, 298, 523, 50, 419, 236, 259, 343, 45, 159], [2084, 397, 266, 140, 477, 194, 138, 339, 269, 410, 306, 255, 0, 359, 266, 261, 160, 426, 145, 301, 310], [1978, 646, 134, 406, 431, 243, 404, 394, 520, 51, 548, 504, 374, 0, 515, 200, 363, 444, 357, 550, 488], [1956, 132, 429, 241, 384, 347, 175, 292, 217, 573, 138, 60, 297, 523, 0, 419, 236, 259, 342, 82, 159], [2097, 522, 127, 265, 397, 173, 263, 248, 394, 271, 426, 380, 244, 220, 391, 0, 223, 324, 289, 426, 366], [2041, 360, 267, 128, 440, 184, 102, 295, 233, 411, 269, 219, 184, 360, 229, 251, 0, 363, 229, 264, 273], [1912, 392, 365, 384, 226, 338, 317, 207, 359, 509, 239, 251, 423, 458, 261, 331, 359, 0, 468, 296, 179], [2144, 457, 257, 200, 537, 215, 192, 392, 329, 407, 365, 315, 139, 357, 326, 321, 219, 486, 0, 361, 370], [2019, 96, 493, 305, 447, 410, 238, 355, 280, 637, 202, 63, 361, 586, 108, 482, 299, 322, 406, 0, 222], [1884, 293, 404, 278, 312, 321, 211, 305, 253, 548, 140, 152, 333, 498, 162, 446, 272, 187, 378, 197, 0]]}, "reference": {"optimum_s": 14033, "optimality": "best_found", "lower_bound_s": 12608, "floor_s": 10941, "solve_s": 40.2, "ffd_s": 16295, "stop_aware_best_s": 14976, "stop_aware_mean_s": 15169.2, "route_id": "RouteID_b6f25e23-d167-4eff-be7f-559c14f19bfb", "plans": {"optimum": [{"route": ["S20", "S11", "S19", "S01", "S14", "S10"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S05", "S18", "S12", "S03", "S16", "S06", "S08"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S04", "S17", "S07", "S15", "S02", "S13", "S09"], "parcels": []}], "ffd": [{"route": ["S01", "S12", "S02", "S13"], "parcels": ["P03", "P06"]}, {"route": ["S04", "S07", "S02", "S06", "S14", "S01"], "parcels": ["P02", "P05", "P13", "P14"]}, {"route": ["S20", "S10", "S11", "S19", "S01", "S08", "S16", "S03", "S18", "S05", "S02", "S09", "S15", "S07", "S17"], "parcels": ["P01", "P04", "P15"]}], "stop_aware_best": [{"route": ["S09", "S13", "S15", "S05", "S16", "S03", "S06", "S08", "S20"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S12", "S01", "S10"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S11", "S19", "S14", "S18", "S02", "S07", "S17", "S04"], "parcels": []}]}}, "meta": {"route_id": "RouteID_b6f25e23-d167-4eff-be7f-559c14f19bfb", "split": "train", "stops": 20, "vans": 3, "tightness": 0.93, "station": "DLA5", "city": "DLA", "date": "2018-08-11", "seconds": 88.4, "stop_aware_best_reward": 0.6431, "optimality": "best_found"}}
{"id": "53f8ef36-spread-n25-k3-t0.85-s0", "instance": {"stops": ["S01", "S02", "S03", "S04", "S05", "S06", "S07", "S08", "S09", "S10", "S11", "S12", "S13", "S14", "S15", "S16", "S17", "S18", "S19", "S20", "S21", "S22", "S23", "S24", "S25"], "parcels": [{"id": "P01", "stop": "S01", "volume_dl": 9}, {"id": "P02", "stop": "S02", "volume_dl": 13}, {"id": "P03", "stop": "S03", "volume_dl": 134}, {"id": "P04", "stop": "S04", "volume_dl": 13}, {"id": "P05", "stop": "S04", "volume_dl": 133}, {"id": "P06", "stop": "S05", "volume_dl": 104}, {"id": "P07", "stop": "S05", "volume_dl": 16}, {"id": "P08", "stop": "S06", "volume_dl": 79}, {"id": "P09", "stop": "S07", "volume_dl": 6}, {"id": "P10", "stop": "S08", "volume_dl": 57}, {"id": "P11", "stop": "S09", "volume_dl": 12}, {"id": "P12", "stop": "S09", "volume_dl": 179}, {"id": "P13", "stop": "S09", "volume_dl": 11}, {"id": "P14", "stop": "S10", "volume_dl": 63}, {"id": "P15", "stop": "S11", "volume_dl": 62}, {"id": "P16", "stop": "S12", "volume_dl": 13}, {"id": "P17", "stop": "S13", "volume_dl": 54}, {"id": "P18", "stop": "S13", "volume_dl": 57}, {"id": "P19", "stop": "S14", "volume_dl": 36}, {"id": "P20", "stop": "S14", "volume_dl": 57}, {"id": "P21", "stop": "S14", "volume_dl": 36}, {"id": "P22", "stop": "S15", "volume_dl": 63}, {"id": "P23", "stop": "S16", "volume_dl": 928}, {"id": "P24", "stop": "S16", "volume_dl": 5}, {"id": "P25", "stop": "S16", "volume_dl": 8}, {"id": "P26", "stop": "S17", "volume_dl": 57}, {"id": "P27", "stop": "S18", "volume_dl": 104}, {"id": "P28", "stop": "S19", "volume_dl": 133}, {"id": "P29", "stop": "S19", "volume_dl": 57}, {"id": "P30", "stop": "S19", "volume_dl": 57}, {"id": "P31", "stop": "S20", "volume_dl": 39}, {"id": "P32", "stop": "S21", "volume_dl": 134}, {"id": "P33", "stop": "S22", "volume_dl": 92}, {"id": "P34", "stop": "S23", "volume_dl": 10}, {"id": "P35", "stop": "S24", "volume_dl": 133}, {"id": "P36", "stop": "S24", "volume_dl": 57}, {"id": "P37", "stop": "S24", "volume_dl": 542}, {"id": "P38", "stop": "S25", "volume_dl": 18}], "vans": 3, "capacity_dl": 1406, "travel_s": [[0, 1458, 1391, 1448, 1412, 1488, 1541, 1606, 1431, 1427, 1332, 1328, 1486, 1374, 1504, 1633, 1423, 1536, 1460, 1448, 1468, 1534, 1401, 1503, 1329, 1559], [1557, 0, 364, 127, 267, 91, 229, 279, 136, 340, 210, 290, 262, 381, 161, 143, 233, 82, 140, 285, 156, 413, 339, 193, 333, 438], [1401, 375, 0, 375, 180, 400, 469, 483, 413, 243, 358, 424, 313, 185, 345, 385, 190, 304, 228, 251, 395, 286, 50, 304, 339, 311], [1483, 132, 377, 0, 398, 175, 115, 316, 152, 462, 188, 256, 299, 360, 198, 180, 271, 166, 178, 323, 42, 450, 387, 230, 370, 475], [1464, 279, 194, 279, 0, 306, 373, 387, 381, 241, 386, 453, 286, 240, 256, 288, 132, 208, 132, 248, 299, 315, 204, 217, 333, 339], [1527, 92, 408, 192, 310, 0, 294, 238, 134, 417, 276, 310, 336, 439, 234, 187, 283, 89, 185, 360, 221, 457, 383, 268, 378, 482], [1543, 172, 437, 101, 458, 251, 0, 391, 212, 522, 248, 315, 374, 419, 273, 255, 346, 248, 253, 398, 49, 525, 447, 305, 445, 550], [1626, 320, 539, 350, 470, 256, 444, 0, 342, 439, 519, 462, 360, 670, 213, 360, 409, 249, 316, 384, 370, 589, 515, 292, 352, 614], [1460, 159, 401, 178, 422, 136, 271, 339, 0, 486, 240, 185, 383, 384, 282, 264, 354, 194, 261, 406, 198, 534, 411, 314, 454, 559], [1513, 315, 243, 340, 251, 360, 433, 322, 423, 0, 446, 513, 156, 297, 220, 349, 155, 324, 289, 94, 360, 311, 254, 157, 204, 336], [1395, 178, 364, 168, 385, 244, 262, 398, 203, 449, 0, 67, 380, 347, 280, 262, 352, 237, 259, 404, 189, 532, 374, 312, 452, 557], [1349, 235, 421, 225, 442, 301, 319, 455, 188, 506, 57, 0, 438, 404, 337, 319, 409, 294, 316, 461, 246, 589, 431, 369, 509, 614], [1577, 280, 323, 304, 291, 354, 397, 295, 387, 146, 410, 477, 0, 377, 168, 313, 234, 258, 178, 91, 324, 425, 333, 91, 286, 450], [1415, 408, 191, 408, 211, 434, 501, 516, 510, 276, 371, 438, 345, 0, 378, 417, 228, 336, 260, 276, 428, 363, 201, 337, 369, 388], [1587, 162, 342, 186, 257, 242, 280, 218, 270, 226, 293, 360, 148, 456, 0, 196, 193, 146, 136, 171, 206, 407, 333, 79, 364, 432], [1566, 140, 459, 164, 318, 185, 258, 330, 248, 391, 271, 338, 312, 442, 211, 0, 284, 168, 191, 336, 185, 464, 470, 244, 383, 488], [1451, 262, 181, 297, 133, 289, 391, 399, 364, 137, 404, 471, 207, 235, 186, 307, 0, 191, 115, 145, 318, 231, 157, 146, 230, 256], [1582, 71, 328, 170, 316, 96, 272, 234, 194, 326, 264, 348, 247, 435, 144, 167, 197, 0, 104, 271, 199, 377, 303, 178, 324, 402], [1492, 147, 223, 147, 126, 172, 241, 255, 249, 203, 254, 321, 151, 277, 134, 157, 93, 76, 0, 175, 168, 273, 198, 82, 299, 297], [1521, 288, 252, 312, 305, 369, 406, 294, 396, 74, 419, 486, 101, 305, 182, 322, 241, 271, 191, 0, 332, 319, 262, 104, 212, 344], [1494, 122, 387, 52, 409, 202, 73, 342, 162, 472, 199, 266, 324, 370, 224, 206, 296, 199, 203, 348, 0, 476, 398, 256, 396, 501], [1523, 442, 264, 442, 312, 467, 536, 550, 545, 328, 533, 600, 398, 361, 424, 452, 251, 371, 295, 336, 463, 0, 213, 372, 546, 23], [1433, 353, 51, 354, 211, 378, 447, 461, 456, 275, 389, 456, 344, 217, 377, 363, 162, 282, 206, 282, 374, 236, 0, 283, 370, 261], [1554, 188, 284, 213, 200, 263, 306, 279, 296, 147, 319, 386, 69, 338, 77, 222, 143, 167, 87, 92, 233, 334, 260, 0, 288, 359], [1433, 310, 284, 335, 292, 355, 428, 317, 418, 138, 441, 508, 197, 337, 215, 344, 195, 281, 284, 159, 355, 351, 294, 213, 0, 376], [1548, 466, 288, 467, 336, 492, 560, 574, 569, 353, 557, 624, 422, 385, 448, 476, 276, 396, 320, 360, 487, 23, 237, 396, 570, 0]]}, "reference": {"optimum_s": 11283, "optimality": "best_found", "lower_bound_s": 9709, "floor_s": 8031, "solve_s": 80.37, "ffd_s": 13109, "stop_aware_best_s": 12226, "stop_aware_mean_s": 12602.4, "route_id": "RouteID_53f8ef36-f8f0-481f-b48c-3f199f2aae5f", "plans": {"optimum": [{"route": ["S13", "S04", "S18", "S17", "S05", "S01", "S15", "S03", "S20", "S06", "S10", "S11"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S16", "S21", "S25", "S22", "S02"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S24", "S09", "S19", "S12", "S23", "S14", "S07", "S08"], "parcels": []}], "ffd": [{"route": ["S03", "S16", "S09", "S21", "S25", "S02"], "parcels": ["P12", "P23"]}, {"route": ["S24", "S19", "S22", "S04", "S18", "S07", "S05", "S06", "S10"], "parcels": ["P05", "P28", "P35", "P37"]}, {"route": ["S13", "S04", "S16", "S24", "S09", "S19", "S12", "S23", "S14", "S17", "S01", "S15", "S20", "S08", "S11"], "parcels": ["P04", "P11", "P13", "P24", "P25", "P29", "P30", "P36"]}], "stop_aware_best": [{"route": ["S24", "S14", "S20", "S01", "S05", "S18", "S21", "S25", "S13"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S04", "S19", "S12", "S23", "S15", "S03", "S06", "S10", "S11"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S02", "S22", "S16", "S09", "S07", "S17", "S08"], "parcels": []}]}}, "meta": {"route_id": "RouteID_53f8ef36-f8f0-481f-b48c-3f199f2aae5f", "split": "train", "stops": 25, "vans": 3, "tightness": 0.85, "station": "DLA8", "city": "DLA", "date": "2018-07-25", "seconds": 131.2, "stop_aware_best_reward": 0.6558, "optimality": "best_found"}}
{"id": "1bc5771b-spread-n30-k4-t0.89-s0", "instance": {"stops": ["S01", "S02", "S03", "S04", "S05", "S06", "S07", "S08", "S09", "S10", "S11", "S12", "S13", "S14", "S15", "S16", "S17", "S18", "S19", "S20", "S21", "S22", "S23", "S24", "S25", "S26", "S27", "S28", "S29", "S30"], "parcels": [{"id": "P01", "stop": "S01", "volume_dl": 29}, {"id": "P02", "stop": "S02", "volume_dl": 45}, {"id": "P03", "stop": "S03", "volume_dl": 19}, {"id": "P04", "stop": "S04", "volume_dl": 16}, {"id": "P05", "stop": "S05", "volume_dl": 6}, {"id": "P06", "stop": "S05", "volume_dl": 104}, {"id": "P07", "stop": "S06", "volume_dl": 35}, {"id": "P08", "stop": "S07", "volume_dl": 36}, {"id": "P09", "stop": "S08", "volume_dl": 46}, {"id": "P10", "stop": "S09", "volume_dl": 41}, {"id": "P11", "stop": "S10", "volume_dl": 95}, {"id": "P12", "stop": "S10", "volume_dl": 3}, {"id": "P13", "stop": "S11", "volume_dl": 9}, {"id": "P14", "stop": "S11", "volume_dl": 13}, {"id": "P15", "stop": "S12", "volume_dl": 79}, {"id": "P16", "stop": "S12", "volume_dl": 59}, {"id": "P17", "stop": "S13", "volume_dl": 157}, {"id": "P18", "stop": "S14", "volume_dl": 95}, {"id": "P19", "stop": "S15", "volume_dl": 49}, {"id": "P20", "stop": "S16", "volume_dl": 157}, {"id": "P21", "stop": "S16", "volume_dl": 38}, {"id": "P22", "stop": "S17", "volume_dl": 134}, {"id": "P23", "stop": "S18", "volume_dl": 57}, {"id": "P24", "stop": "S18", "volume_dl": 67}, {"id": "P25", "stop": "S19", "volume_dl": 12}, {"id": "P26", "stop": "S19", "volume_dl": 179}, {"id": "P27", "stop": "S20", "volume_dl": 104}, {"id": "P28", "stop": "S20", "volume_dl": 6}, {"id": "P29", "stop": "S21", "volume_dl": 133}, {"id": "P30", "stop": "S22", "volume_dl": 42}, {"id": "P31", "stop": "S23", "volume_dl": 43}, {"id": "P32", "stop": "S24", "volume_dl": 95}, {"id": "P33", "stop": "S24", "volume_dl": 59}, {"id": "P34", "stop": "S25", "volume_dl": 309}, {"id": "P35", "stop": "S26", "volume_dl": 25}, {"id": "P36", "stop": "S27", "volume_dl": 11}, {"id": "P37", "stop": "S28", "volume_dl": 57}, {"id": "P38", "stop": "S29", "volume_dl": 12}, {"id": "P39", "stop": "S29", "volume_dl": 11}, {"id": "P40", "stop": "S29", "volume_dl": 16}, {"id": "P41", "stop": "S29", "volume_dl": 242}, {"id": "P42", "stop": "S30", "volume_dl": 57}], "vans": 4, "capacity_dl": 788, "travel_s": [[0, 2204, 2190, 2298, 2243, 2349, 2206, 2275, 2289, 2413, 2397, 2118, 2357, 2193, 2185, 2446, 2226, 2170, 2200, 2247, 2158, 2258, 2182, 2273, 2318, 2391, 2290, 2170, 2275, 2354, 2208], [2189, 0, 102, 284, 172, 208, 447, 142, 223, 244, 265, 114, 313, 266, 370, 334, 155, 223, 148, 176, 470, 124, 31, 140, 185, 376, 156, 100, 142, 340, 3], [2196, 106, 0, 390, 279, 314, 568, 248, 330, 351, 371, 90, 420, 385, 377, 440, 262, 192, 223, 283, 476, 231, 137, 246, 291, 482, 263, 206, 249, 446, 110], [2356, 267, 370, 0, 410, 130, 322, 268, 166, 289, 271, 351, 88, 172, 248, 596, 392, 441, 385, 414, 302, 184, 286, 231, 298, 92, 248, 337, 234, 56, 264], [2256, 159, 252, 393, 0, 317, 557, 251, 333, 354, 374, 181, 422, 375, 437, 243, 31, 270, 180, 139, 536, 234, 158, 249, 294, 485, 266, 105, 252, 449, 157], [2362, 203, 305, 128, 345, 0, 352, 220, 142, 242, 292, 295, 140, 185, 261, 506, 331, 376, 320, 362, 322, 119, 221, 167, 244, 235, 183, 272, 169, 198, 200], [2257, 460, 562, 327, 602, 378, 0, 515, 413, 537, 425, 544, 386, 420, 484, 751, 585, 651, 578, 606, 168, 430, 478, 435, 545, 419, 418, 529, 432, 383, 457], [2280, 120, 223, 278, 263, 219, 502, 0, 218, 122, 343, 204, 308, 260, 336, 424, 246, 294, 238, 267, 481, 192, 139, 239, 43, 371, 256, 190, 242, 334, 118], [2364, 205, 308, 183, 348, 149, 407, 205, 0, 227, 312, 289, 213, 165, 242, 509, 330, 379, 323, 351, 386, 122, 224, 169, 236, 276, 186, 275, 171, 240, 202], [2386, 227, 329, 288, 369, 229, 511, 110, 228, 0, 392, 311, 318, 270, 346, 531, 352, 400, 345, 373, 491, 202, 245, 249, 98, 381, 266, 296, 252, 344, 224], [2420, 228, 330, 230, 370, 257, 356, 306, 273, 372, 0, 311, 289, 315, 391, 518, 353, 401, 345, 386, 335, 198, 246, 202, 349, 322, 186, 297, 200, 286, 225], [2149, 108, 94, 392, 218, 316, 521, 250, 434, 353, 374, 0, 422, 338, 330, 421, 201, 145, 176, 235, 429, 233, 139, 249, 293, 485, 265, 145, 251, 448, 112], [2364, 275, 377, 96, 417, 111, 359, 275, 173, 297, 308, 359, 0, 180, 256, 579, 404, 448, 393, 434, 339, 192, 294, 239, 305, 188, 255, 344, 241, 152, 272], [2218, 252, 355, 195, 394, 196, 408, 252, 150, 274, 367, 336, 225, 0, 110, 556, 377, 421, 370, 398, 316, 169, 271, 216, 282, 288, 233, 322, 218, 251, 249], [2243, 321, 423, 264, 463, 265, 432, 321, 219, 343, 436, 405, 293, 123, 0, 625, 446, 413, 439, 467, 341, 238, 340, 285, 351, 356, 302, 391, 287, 320, 318], [2400, 303, 396, 537, 228, 461, 700, 395, 476, 497, 518, 324, 566, 519, 605, 0, 238, 414, 324, 282, 705, 377, 302, 393, 438, 629, 410, 249, 395, 593, 300], [2251, 154, 247, 388, 31, 320, 552, 246, 328, 348, 369, 179, 417, 370, 432, 254, 0, 265, 178, 182, 531, 228, 153, 244, 282, 480, 261, 100, 246, 444, 152], [2224, 218, 203, 448, 274, 372, 596, 306, 388, 409, 430, 132, 478, 413, 405, 477, 257, 0, 232, 278, 504, 289, 248, 305, 349, 541, 321, 202, 307, 504, 221], [2242, 170, 238, 404, 208, 336, 567, 262, 344, 364, 385, 167, 433, 386, 423, 351, 195, 256, 0, 225, 523, 244, 169, 260, 305, 496, 277, 80, 262, 460, 167], [2272, 175, 267, 408, 130, 341, 572, 267, 348, 369, 390, 196, 448, 390, 523, 292, 158, 286, 196, 0, 610, 249, 174, 265, 303, 501, 282, 120, 267, 465, 172], [2220, 377, 480, 244, 519, 295, 138, 432, 330, 454, 343, 461, 303, 337, 316, 668, 506, 483, 495, 536, 0, 348, 396, 352, 456, 336, 335, 447, 350, 300, 374], [2273, 114, 216, 191, 256, 115, 414, 193, 131, 230, 221, 198, 220, 173, 249, 418, 239, 287, 232, 260, 394, 0, 133, 78, 236, 283, 94, 184, 80, 247, 111], [2219, 42, 144, 293, 202, 217, 457, 151, 233, 254, 274, 162, 323, 275, 351, 364, 185, 265, 178, 206, 436, 134, 0, 150, 194, 386, 166, 129, 152, 349, 39], [2301, 142, 244, 229, 284, 153, 411, 246, 169, 268, 229, 226, 259, 211, 287, 470, 267, 315, 260, 288, 391, 89, 160, 0, 277, 322, 16, 211, 2, 285, 139], [2313, 154, 256, 312, 296, 262, 535, 33, 252, 79, 369, 237, 342, 294, 370, 457, 282, 327, 265, 312, 515, 226, 172, 273, 0, 404, 290, 223, 275, 368, 151], [2448, 358, 461, 91, 501, 221, 413, 359, 257, 380, 362, 442, 179, 263, 339, 688, 484, 532, 476, 505, 393, 275, 377, 322, 389, 0, 339, 428, 325, 69, 356], [2317, 158, 261, 246, 301, 170, 400, 263, 186, 285, 218, 242, 275, 228, 304, 454, 283, 332, 276, 304, 380, 106, 177, 16, 293, 338, 0, 228, 14, 302, 155], [2187, 90, 183, 324, 129, 248, 488, 182, 264, 285, 305, 112, 354, 306, 368, 371, 111, 201, 75, 132, 467, 165, 89, 180, 225, 416, 197, 0, 183, 380, 88], [2303, 144, 246, 232, 286, 156, 413, 249, 171, 270, 231, 228, 261, 214, 290, 468, 269, 317, 262, 290, 393, 91, 163, 2, 279, 324, 14, 214, 0, 288, 141], [2401, 312, 414, 45, 454, 166, 367, 312, 210, 334, 316, 396, 132, 217, 293, 641, 441, 486, 430, 458, 346, 229, 331, 276, 342, 89, 293, 382, 278, 0, 309], [2186, 3, 105, 280, 169, 204, 444, 138, 220, 241, 262, 110, 310, 262, 367, 330, 152, 226, 144, 173, 466, 121, 27, 136, 181, 372, 153, 96, 139, 336, 0]]}, "reference": {"optimum_s": 21173, "optimality": "best_found", "lower_bound_s": 19076, "floor_s": 17068, "solve_s": 55.5, "ffd_s": 23899, "stop_aware_best_s": 22784, "stop_aware_mean_s": 23035.8, "route_id": "RouteID_1bc5771b-4d0f-4b2d-99c7-0bad1a189e2a", "plans": {"optimum": [{"route": ["S14", "S13", "S08", "S09", "S24", "S07", "S22", "S30", "S01", "S02", "S11"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S06", "S20", "S10", "S26", "S28", "S23", "S05", "S21"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S03", "S25", "S29", "S12"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S17", "S19", "S15", "S04", "S16", "S27", "S18"], "parcels": []}], "ffd": [{"route": ["S25", "S29", "S19", "S18"], "parcels": ["P23", "P26", "P41"]}, {"route": ["S17", "S16", "S10", "S21", "S05", "S13"], "parcels": ["P11", "P20"]}, {"route": ["S20", "S03", "S12", "S14", "S08", "S28", "S24", "S30", "S18", "S15"], "parcels": ["P24", "P27"]}, {"route": ["S06", "S20", "S29", "S10", "S26", "S23", "S09", "S07", "S19", "S04", "S16", "S27", "S22", "S01", "S02", "S11"], "parcels": ["P12", "P21", "P25", "P28", "P38", "P39", "P40"]}], "stop_aware_best": [{"route": ["S17", "S15", "S28", "S08", "S29", "S14"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S18", "S19", "S10", "S05", "S21", "S30", "S01", "S02"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S16", "S04", "S27", "S07", "S03", "S25", "S13"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S06", "S20", "S12", "S26", "S23", "S09", "S24", "S22", "S11"], "parcels": []}]}}, "meta": {"route_id": "RouteID_1bc5771b-4d0f-4b2d-99c7-0bad1a189e2a", "split": "train", "stops": 30, "vans": 4, "tightness": 0.89, "station": "DCH4", "city": "DCH", "date": "2018-08-17", "seconds": 115.9, "stop_aware_best_reward": 0.5718, "optimality": "best_found"}}
{"id": "21e13e3e-spread-n40-k4-t0.93-s0", "instance": {"stops": ["S01", "S02", "S03", "S04", "S05", "S06", "S07", "S08", "S09", "S10", "S11", "S12", "S13", "S14", "S15", "S16", "S17", "S18", "S19", "S20", "S21", "S22", "S23", "S24", "S25", "S26", "S27", "S28", "S29", "S30", "S31", "S32", "S33", "S34", "S35", "S36", "S37", "S38", "S39", "S40"], "parcels": [{"id": "P01", "stop": "S01", "volume_dl": 36}, {"id": "P02", "stop": "S01", "volume_dl": 201}, {"id": "P03", "stop": "S01", "volume_dl": 515}, {"id": "P04", "stop": "S02", "volume_dl": 640}, {"id": "P05", "stop": "S02", "volume_dl": 104}, {"id": "P06", "stop": "S02", "volume_dl": 57}, {"id": "P07", "stop": "S02", "volume_dl": 196}, {"id": "P08", "stop": "S03", "volume_dl": 29}, {"id": "P09", "stop": "S03", "volume_dl": 179}, {"id": "P10", "stop": "S04", "volume_dl": 11}, {"id": "P11", "stop": "S05", "volume_dl": 28}, {"id": "P12", "stop": "S06", "volume_dl": 242}, {"id": "P13", "stop": "S06", "volume_dl": 133}, {"id": "P14", "stop": "S07", "volume_dl": 57}, {"id": "P15", "stop": "S08", "volume_dl": 14}, {"id": "P16", "stop": "S09", "volume_dl": 95}, {"id": "P17", "stop": "S10", "volume_dl": 134}, {"id": "P18", "stop": "S10", "volume_dl": 104}, {"id": "P19", "stop": "S10", "volume_dl": 45}, {"id": "P20", "stop": "S10", "volume_dl": 104}, {"id": "P21", "stop": "S11", "volume_dl": 242}, {"id": "P22", "stop": "S12", "volume_dl": 322}, {"id": "P23", "stop": "S13", "volume_dl": 157}, {"id": "P24", "stop": "S14", "volume_dl": 552}, {"id": "P25", "stop": "S14", "volume_dl": 9}, {"id": "P26", "stop": "S14", "volume_dl": 95}, {"id": "P27", "stop": "S14", "volume_dl": 134}, {"id": "P28", "stop": "S15", "volume_dl": 50}, {"id": "P29", "stop": "S16", "volume_dl": 133}, {"id": "P30", "stop": "S17", "volume_dl": 34}, {"id": "P31", "stop": "S18", "volume_dl": 179}, {"id": "P32", "stop": "S19", "volume_dl": 11}, {"id": "P33", "stop": "S19", "volume_dl": 104}, {"id": "P34", "stop": "S20", "volume_dl": 542}, {"id": "P35", "stop": "S20", "volume_dl": 95}, {"id": "P36", "stop": "S21", "volume_dl": 10}, {"id": "P37", "stop": "S21", "volume_dl": 34}, {"id": "P38", "stop": "S22", "volume_dl": 34}, {"id": "P39", "stop": "S22", "volume_dl": 157}, {"id": "P40", "stop": "S23", "volume_dl": 95}, {"id": "P41", "stop": "S23", "volume_dl": 179}, {"id": "P42", "stop": "S23", "volume_dl": 2}, {"id": "P43", "stop": "S23", "volume_dl": 36}, {"id": "P44", "stop": "S23", "volume_dl": 133}, {"id": "P45", "stop": "S23", "volume_dl": 44}, {"id": "P46", "stop": "S24", "volume_dl": 28}, {"id": "P47", "stop": "S24", "volume_dl": 59}, {"id": "P48", "stop": "S25", "volume_dl": 55}, {"id": "P49", "stop": "S26", "volume_dl": 226}, {"id": "P50", "stop": "S26", "volume_dl": 322}, {"id": "P51", "stop": "S27", "volume_dl": 57}, {"id": "P52", "stop": "S28", "volume_dl": 133}, {"id": "P53", "stop": "S28", "volume_dl": 340}, {"id": "P54", "stop": "S29", "volume_dl": 60}, {"id": "P55", "stop": "S29", "volume_dl": 92}, {"id": "P56", "stop": "S30", "volume_dl": 104}, {"id": "P57", "stop": "S30", "volume_dl": 25}, {"id": "P58", "stop": "S31", "volume_dl": 26}, {"id": "P59", "stop": "S32", "volume_dl": 13}, {"id": "P60", "stop": "S32", "volume_dl": 41}, {"id": "P61", "stop": "S32", "volume_dl": 31}, {"id": "P62", "stop": "S33", "volume_dl": 133}, {"id": "P63", "stop": "S33", "volume_dl": 34}, {"id": "P64", "stop": "S34", "volume_dl": 29}, {"id": "P65", "stop": "S35", "volume_dl": 17}, {"id": "P66", "stop": "S35", "volume_dl": 41}, {"id": "P67", "stop": "S35", "volume_dl": 18}, {"id": "P68", "stop": "S36", "volume_dl": 34}, {"id": "P69", "stop": "S37", "volume_dl": 26}, {"id": "P70", "stop": "S37", "volume_dl": 15}, {"id": "P71", "stop": "S37", "volume_dl": 51}, {"id": "P72", "stop": "S38", "volume_dl": 8}, {"id": "P73", "stop": "S39", "volume_dl": 104}, {"id": "P74", "stop": "S40", "volume_dl": 57}], "vans": 4, "capacity_dl": 2283, "travel_s": [[0, 1328, 1403, 1023, 1385, 1130, 970, 1239, 1381, 1312, 1131, 1220, 1142, 1339, 1332, 1388, 1218, 1077, 1394, 1275, 1191, 1196, 1165, 1097, 993, 1292, 1357, 1213, 1388, 1347, 1291, 1205, 1367, 999, 1399, 1077, 1402, 1353, 1266, 1060, 1244], [1408, 0, 384, 541, 342, 393, 467, 426, 124, 278, 369, 224, 392, 160, 399, 280, 239, 517, 62, 203, 355, 243, 331, 344, 491, 114, 160, 259, 76, 20, 168, 296, 257, 462, 162, 360, 276, 310, 452, 579, 335], [1394, 276, 0, 359, 142, 266, 451, 299, 170, 101, 349, 199, 265, 205, 230, 168, 167, 390, 246, 75, 335, 230, 311, 329, 476, 160, 283, 246, 220, 295, 228, 170, 153, 392, 306, 290, 23, 110, 325, 432, 167], [1061, 497, 424, 0, 406, 146, 181, 249, 391, 322, 228, 362, 180, 426, 342, 398, 330, 69, 467, 284, 286, 356, 261, 280, 143, 381, 504, 373, 441, 516, 449, 238, 383, 96, 527, 245, 412, 374, 276, 158, 276], [1455, 295, 166, 419, 0, 327, 489, 359, 162, 152, 392, 246, 326, 169, 325, 25, 228, 451, 224, 136, 379, 265, 353, 367, 515, 133, 257, 282, 218, 314, 186, 230, 119, 485, 299, 344, 135, 193, 386, 493, 261], [1193, 411, 338, 152, 320, 0, 195, 161, 305, 236, 204, 276, 82, 340, 254, 312, 244, 219, 381, 199, 264, 333, 238, 257, 216, 295, 421, 350, 357, 431, 359, 152, 291, 126, 441, 215, 326, 288, 187, 239, 190], [1004, 516, 468, 182, 453, 199, 0, 349, 494, 424, 190, 284, 213, 394, 392, 478, 283, 260, 449, 387, 252, 257, 227, 162, 120, 348, 414, 277, 441, 539, 350, 290, 474, 97, 459, 153, 494, 417, 376, 208, 329], [1260, 366, 241, 276, 223, 184, 378, 0, 260, 191, 209, 231, 182, 295, 146, 248, 199, 307, 336, 154, 249, 314, 223, 260, 367, 250, 376, 331, 312, 386, 314, 53, 246, 307, 396, 182, 264, 191, 26, 350, 82], [1355, 232, 283, 507, 277, 312, 433, 344, 0, 210, 335, 190, 310, 113, 317, 179, 172, 435, 168, 120, 323, 209, 297, 310, 459, 77, 200, 225, 178, 252, 130, 215, 158, 428, 262, 334, 175, 245, 370, 545, 253], [1292, 229, 247, 430, 228, 297, 356, 329, 192, 0, 256, 108, 295, 104, 334, 205, 91, 502, 159, 126, 243, 129, 217, 234, 382, 86, 193, 146, 153, 249, 123, 200, 185, 349, 235, 257, 219, 196, 356, 468, 271], [1136, 442, 384, 203, 366, 185, 188, 320, 369, 300, 0, 157, 164, 317, 260, 391, 195, 281, 372, 263, 107, 177, 82, 101, 192, 270, 326, 194, 363, 462, 258, 158, 352, 121, 371, 66, 407, 334, 346, 278, 196], [1211, 288, 230, 348, 212, 330, 275, 313, 215, 146, 162, 0, 309, 163, 278, 237, 42, 421, 218, 109, 154, 106, 128, 153, 301, 120, 171, 122, 212, 308, 101, 176, 201, 266, 213, 176, 253, 180, 340, 387, 215], [1210, 406, 333, 166, 315, 61, 211, 156, 300, 231, 184, 271, 0, 335, 249, 307, 239, 232, 376, 194, 244, 313, 218, 237, 233, 290, 416, 330, 352, 426, 354, 147, 286, 141, 436, 195, 321, 283, 182, 252, 185], [1401, 125, 354, 510, 346, 383, 436, 415, 134, 248, 339, 194, 381, 0, 388, 250, 209, 582, 55, 191, 327, 213, 301, 314, 462, 84, 112, 229, 48, 145, 148, 286, 229, 432, 155, 337, 246, 314, 441, 548, 324], [1348, 473, 258, 312, 240, 220, 407, 131, 367, 298, 320, 350, 219, 409, 0, 265, 317, 344, 464, 260, 361, 433, 334, 372, 387, 373, 496, 449, 417, 492, 426, 165, 356, 346, 503, 320, 281, 208, 157, 386, 128], [1505, 345, 140, 469, 140, 377, 539, 409, 212, 202, 442, 292, 376, 220, 280, 0, 260, 501, 274, 186, 429, 315, 403, 417, 565, 184, 307, 332, 268, 364, 237, 280, 169, 535, 349, 394, 163, 168, 436, 543, 278], [1220, 247, 188, 358, 170, 239, 284, 271, 173, 104, 182, 32, 318, 121, 276, 195, 0, 430, 176, 67, 170, 115, 144, 162, 310, 103, 198, 132, 170, 266, 128, 142, 159, 275, 240, 185, 211, 138, 298, 396, 212], [1098, 549, 476, 72, 458, 199, 254, 299, 443, 374, 299, 414, 235, 478, 399, 450, 382, 0, 519, 337, 359, 428, 333, 302, 125, 433, 559, 445, 495, 569, 497, 290, 429, 168, 579, 310, 464, 426, 325, 88, 328], [1346, 70, 455, 593, 413, 464, 519, 496, 194, 348, 440, 294, 462, 231, 469, 350, 309, 665, 0, 273, 427, 313, 401, 396, 545, 184, 169, 330, 149, 90, 254, 367, 329, 532, 100, 420, 346, 381, 522, 631, 406], [1319, 212, 158, 336, 140, 191, 378, 223, 106, 37, 234, 144, 190, 141, 196, 112, 128, 315, 182, 0, 279, 166, 253, 270, 359, 96, 219, 182, 156, 232, 164, 94, 90, 316, 242, 214, 126, 108, 250, 357, 133], [1096, 467, 388, 238, 369, 233, 157, 337, 361, 292, 103, 207, 218, 347, 292, 395, 226, 306, 402, 255, 0, 209, 112, 38, 185, 300, 371, 224, 394, 488, 307, 190, 345, 173, 415, 53, 410, 337, 363, 272, 228], [1272, 272, 272, 409, 253, 391, 336, 338, 208, 139, 228, 66, 370, 147, 345, 215, 83, 483, 201, 150, 219, 0, 194, 214, 361, 129, 170, 16, 193, 291, 100, 242, 192, 327, 212, 229, 229, 221, 365, 448, 281], [1122, 494, 414, 264, 395, 259, 183, 363, 387, 318, 129, 233, 244, 373, 319, 421, 252, 332, 428, 281, 25, 233, 0, 64, 211, 326, 397, 250, 420, 513, 333, 216, 372, 199, 441, 79, 436, 364, 389, 298, 254], [1101, 429, 371, 243, 353, 237, 162, 339, 356, 287, 107, 172, 223, 304, 294, 378, 183, 311, 359, 249, 94, 164, 69, 0, 190, 257, 330, 181, 353, 449, 264, 192, 340, 178, 372, 72, 394, 321, 365, 277, 230], [1019, 601, 527, 138, 508, 222, 116, 336, 493, 424, 242, 328, 233, 438, 428, 500, 326, 131, 569, 387, 300, 304, 275, 204, 0, 392, 458, 321, 543, 619, 394, 340, 477, 112, 503, 197, 514, 476, 362, 95, 379], [1278, 172, 270, 430, 262, 299, 356, 331, 113, 164, 258, 113, 297, 47, 304, 166, 130, 502, 102, 107, 246, 132, 220, 233, 382, 0, 123, 148, 95, 192, 53, 202, 145, 351, 165, 257, 162, 230, 357, 468, 240], [1307, 241, 486, 557, 478, 551, 475, 534, 232, 379, 421, 294, 536, 262, 507, 381, 311, 625, 170, 311, 396, 284, 371, 356, 503, 216, 0, 300, 203, 260, 218, 405, 361, 491, 42, 372, 377, 448, 560, 591, 443], [1256, 255, 255, 393, 237, 375, 320, 322, 192, 122, 211, 50, 354, 130, 328, 198, 66, 466, 185, 134, 204, 107, 178, 197, 346, 112, 153, 0, 179, 275, 83, 226, 177, 311, 196, 221, 212, 205, 348, 432, 264], [1310, 209, 306, 465, 298, 334, 385, 366, 148, 199, 291, 146, 332, 82, 340, 201, 160, 458, 137, 143, 277, 164, 252, 266, 413, 35, 153, 181, 0, 227, 90, 237, 178, 386, 198, 281, 197, 266, 393, 500, 276], [1388, 113, 365, 522, 323, 374, 444, 406, 104, 258, 350, 204, 372, 141, 379, 260, 219, 498, 42, 183, 337, 223, 310, 325, 473, 94, 138, 240, 57, 0, 144, 277, 237, 443, 143, 354, 256, 291, 432, 559, 316], [1377, 200, 391, 490, 388, 484, 408, 456, 192, 289, 315, 204, 469, 172, 425, 291, 220, 558, 130, 233, 306, 193, 280, 289, 436, 125, 68, 210, 162, 220, 0, 327, 268, 424, 112, 305, 287, 356, 482, 524, 365], [1206, 313, 198, 223, 180, 130, 324, 163, 207, 138, 155, 178, 129, 242, 102, 205, 146, 254, 283, 101, 196, 261, 170, 207, 314, 197, 322, 277, 259, 332, 261, 0, 193, 254, 343, 129, 221, 148, 189, 296, 39], [1471, 310, 163, 435, 163, 343, 505, 375, 177, 168, 407, 262, 341, 185, 341, 23, 243, 466, 240, 152, 394, 281, 369, 382, 529, 149, 272, 297, 234, 330, 202, 246, 0, 500, 315, 359, 151, 191, 401, 509, 277], [1039, 525, 467, 82, 449, 137, 84, 298, 440, 371, 131, 277, 150, 400, 391, 474, 278, 159, 455, 334, 190, 260, 165, 184, 120, 353, 426, 277, 448, 545, 356, 260, 424, 0, 468, 169, 490, 417, 325, 119, 299], [1264, 226, 459, 582, 440, 580, 508, 524, 283, 431, 450, 346, 565, 314, 497, 433, 362, 654, 222, 300, 449, 348, 423, 385, 534, 267, 180, 364, 256, 245, 266, 394, 412, 520, 0, 409, 429, 408, 550, 620, 433], [1077, 406, 326, 248, 316, 231, 174, 284, 308, 239, 101, 154, 214, 294, 231, 342, 173, 305, 349, 210, 93, 162, 67, 78, 200, 247, 327, 171, 350, 434, 257, 137, 292, 171, 362, 0, 357, 292, 310, 271, 175], [1372, 253, 211, 336, 193, 244, 434, 276, 147, 78, 287, 169, 242, 182, 249, 218, 137, 368, 223, 52, 302, 207, 276, 298, 410, 137, 263, 224, 199, 272, 201, 147, 133, 370, 283, 260, 0, 161, 302, 410, 186], [1445, 327, 50, 409, 32, 317, 498, 349, 194, 151, 400, 250, 315, 201, 281, 57, 217, 441, 256, 126, 386, 297, 360, 379, 526, 165, 289, 314, 250, 346, 218, 220, 148, 443, 331, 360, 73, 0, 376, 483, 217], [1233, 340, 215, 249, 196, 157, 351, 189, 234, 165, 182, 205, 156, 269, 119, 222, 172, 281, 310, 128, 223, 288, 197, 234, 341, 224, 349, 304, 286, 359, 288, 27, 220, 281, 370, 156, 238, 164, 0, 323, 56], [1065, 618, 545, 158, 526, 249, 197, 347, 512, 443, 253, 398, 260, 547, 439, 518, 400, 105, 588, 406, 313, 382, 287, 283, 86, 502, 547, 398, 564, 637, 477, 358, 498, 121, 590, 264, 532, 494, 373, 0, 397], [1243, 350, 159, 260, 141, 168, 361, 120, 244, 175, 192, 251, 166, 279, 64, 166, 219, 291, 320, 138, 233, 334, 207, 244, 351, 274, 360, 350, 296, 370, 327, 37, 260, 291, 380, 166, 182, 109, 146, 333, 0]]}, "reference": {"optimum_s": 11899, "optimality": "best_found", "lower_bound_s": 9663, "floor_s": 7896, "solve_s": 112.5, "ffd_s": 15554, "stop_aware_best_s": 13669, "stop_aware_mean_s": 14176.6, "route_id": "RouteID_21e13e3e-ea4a-4556-8b7f-3ddd7c20b1a9", "plans": {"optimum": [{"route": ["S21", "S27", "S11", "S16", "S08", "S13", "S18", "S01", "S29", "S28", "S25"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S40", "S37", "S04", "S32", "S15", "S02", "S36", "S19", "S09", "S30", "S26", "S34"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S06", "S35", "S14", "S07", "S38", "S31", "S12", "S05", "S03", "S17", "S39", "S24"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S33", "S10", "S22", "S20", "S23"], "parcels": []}], "ffd": [{"route": ["S17", "S14", "S02", "S01", "S20"], "parcels": ["P03", "P04", "P24", "P34"]}, {"route": ["S06", "S11", "S26", "S01", "S28", "S32", "S02", "S12", "S03"], "parcels": ["P02", "P07", "P09", "P12", "P53", "P59"]}, {"route": ["S39", "S33", "S10", "S14", "S37", "S02", "S19", "S13", "S18", "S28", "S30", "S16", "S22", "S23", "S06"], "parcels": ["P05", "P13", "P17", "P18", "P20", "P27", "P33", "P39", "P41", "P42", "P44", "P52", "P56", "P62", "P71"]}, {"route": ["S24", "S33", "S03", "S05", "S07", "S38", "S31", "S40", "S14", "S37", "S04", "S32", "S15", "S02", "S36", "S19", "S09", "S21", "S27", "S30", "S34", "S01", "S29", "S08", "S25", "S22", "S20", "S23", "S10", "S35"], "parcels": ["P01", "P06", "P08", "P19", "P25", "P26", "P32", "P35", "P38", "P40", "P43", "P45", "P57", "P60", "P61", "P63", "P69", "P70"]}], "stop_aware_best": [{"route": ["S24", "S03", "S07", "S19", "S18", "S01", "S29", "S08", "S20"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S12", "S38", "S37", "S30", "S26", "S34", "S28", "S16", "S22", "S35"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S06", "S10", "S31", "S40", "S02", "S36", "S32", "S09", "S13", "S25"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S23", "S21", "S27", "S11", "S04", "S15", "S14", "S05", "S33", "S17", "S39"], "parcels": []}]}}, "meta": {"route_id": "RouteID_21e13e3e-ea4a-4556-8b7f-3ddd7c20b1a9", "split": "train", "stops": 40, "vans": 4, "tightness": 0.93, "station": "DCH2", "city": "DCH", "date": "2018-08-14", "seconds": 173.4, "stop_aware_best_reward": 0.5376, "optimality": "best_found"}}
{"id": "e0b5d521-spread-n25-k3-t0.91-s0", "instance": {"stops": ["S01", "S02", "S03", "S04", "S05", "S06", "S07", "S08", "S09", "S10", "S11", "S12", "S13", "S14", "S15", "S16", "S17", "S18", "S19", "S20", "S21", "S22", "S23", "S24", "S25"], "parcels": [{"id": "P01", "stop": "S01", "volume_dl": 157}, {"id": "P02", "stop": "S01", "volume_dl": 376}, {"id": "P03", "stop": "S02", "volume_dl": 5}, {"id": "P04", "stop": "S03", "volume_dl": 244}, {"id": "P05", "stop": "S04", "volume_dl": 57}, {"id": "P06", "stop": "S05", "volume_dl": 6}, {"id": "P07", "stop": "S06", "volume_dl": 322}, {"id": "P08", "stop": "S07", "volume_dl": 60}, {"id": "P09", "stop": "S08", "volume_dl": 280}, {"id": "P10", "stop": "S08", "volume_dl": 322}, {"id": "P11", "stop": "S08", "volume_dl": 41}, {"id": "P12", "stop": "S09", "volume_dl": 133}, {"id": "P13", "stop": "S09", "volume_dl": 134}, {"id": "P14", "stop": "S10", "volume_dl": 55}, {"id": "P15", "stop": "S10", "volume_dl": 95}, {"id": "P16", "stop": "S11", "volume_dl": 104}, {"id": "P17", "stop": "S11", "volume_dl": 368}, {"id": "P18", "stop": "S12", "volume_dl": 179}, {"id": "P19", "stop": "S12", "volume_dl": 157}, {"id": "P20", "stop": "S12", "volume_dl": 59}, {"id": "P21", "stop": "S13", "volume_dl": 552}, {"id": "P22", "stop": "S13", "volume_dl": 104}, {"id": "P23", "stop": "S14", "volume_dl": 9}, {"id": "P24", "stop": "S15", "volume_dl": 599}, {"id": "P25", "stop": "S16", "volume_dl": 57}, {"id": "P26", "stop": "S17", "volume_dl": 36}, {"id": "P27", "stop": "S17", "volume_dl": 26}, {"id": "P28", "stop": "S18", "volume_dl": 198}, {"id": "P29", "stop": "S18", "volume_dl": 57}, {"id": "P30", "stop": "S19", "volume_dl": 95}, {"id": "P31", "stop": "S20", "volume_dl": 95}, {"id": "P32", "stop": "S20", "volume_dl": 104}, {"id": "P33", "stop": "S21", "volume_dl": 259}, {"id": "P34", "stop": "S22", "volume_dl": 322}, {"id": "P35", "stop": "S22", "volume_dl": 303}, {"id": "P36", "stop": "S22", "volume_dl": 1428}, {"id": "P37", "stop": "S23", "volume_dl": 57}, {"id": "P38", "stop": "S24", "volume_dl": 30}, {"id": "P39", "stop": "S25", "volume_dl": 16}], "vans": 3, "capacity_dl": 2749, "travel_s": [[0, 2655, 2695, 2737, 2883, 2818, 2701, 2585, 2973, 2600, 2901, 2569, 2804, 2834, 2597, 2623, 2850, 2876, 2557, 2684, 2851, 2532, 2597, 2867, 2603, 2737], [2556, 0, 550, 519, 460, 395, 279, 298, 550, 220, 482, 259, 381, 412, 174, 318, 428, 453, 214, 668, 435, 292, 220, 548, 316, 543], [2439, 570, 0, 42, 660, 595, 496, 417, 117, 579, 678, 648, 340, 612, 490, 658, 627, 653, 603, 148, 628, 632, 605, 146, 400, 50], [2470, 528, 31, 0, 618, 553, 454, 375, 75, 537, 636, 606, 368, 570, 448, 616, 585, 611, 561, 179, 586, 590, 563, 104, 358, 52], [2805, 430, 630, 599, 0, 365, 377, 529, 630, 483, 18, 508, 479, 345, 339, 581, 34, 414, 463, 770, 389, 555, 465, 628, 512, 651], [2732, 357, 557, 526, 322, 0, 230, 456, 557, 410, 341, 435, 333, 97, 277, 508, 290, 155, 390, 697, 121, 482, 392, 554, 438, 578], [2716, 341, 444, 437, 390, 240, 0, 399, 471, 394, 409, 419, 134, 257, 261, 492, 358, 298, 374, 513, 274, 465, 376, 468, 381, 388], [2514, 292, 390, 359, 562, 497, 374, 0, 390, 162, 580, 354, 293, 514, 270, 241, 529, 555, 336, 442, 530, 214, 375, 387, 18, 411], [2534, 568, 95, 64, 658, 594, 495, 416, 0, 578, 680, 646, 408, 610, 489, 657, 626, 652, 602, 244, 633, 630, 603, 145, 398, 116], [2546, 219, 572, 542, 483, 418, 301, 188, 573, 0, 505, 318, 404, 434, 197, 207, 450, 476, 272, 690, 457, 181, 262, 570, 205, 565], [2825, 449, 649, 618, 19, 384, 396, 548, 650, 505, 0, 531, 499, 364, 359, 600, 53, 433, 484, 789, 414, 574, 488, 647, 531, 670], [2457, 313, 630, 600, 541, 476, 359, 316, 631, 306, 563, 0, 462, 493, 255, 354, 508, 534, 84, 748, 515, 263, 124, 628, 334, 624], [2682, 401, 339, 332, 495, 364, 123, 277, 396, 437, 514, 479, 0, 380, 322, 518, 463, 421, 435, 408, 403, 492, 440, 393, 259, 283], [2779, 403, 603, 572, 342, 106, 277, 502, 604, 456, 360, 481, 379, 0, 324, 554, 309, 262, 437, 743, 233, 528, 442, 601, 485, 624], [2541, 165, 520, 489, 353, 305, 210, 297, 521, 219, 372, 243, 313, 321, 0, 316, 321, 363, 199, 599, 338, 290, 200, 518, 314, 474], [2618, 330, 594, 563, 594, 529, 412, 204, 594, 200, 612, 392, 515, 546, 308, 0, 561, 587, 374, 645, 562, 121, 413, 591, 221, 614], [2771, 396, 596, 565, 32, 331, 343, 495, 596, 449, 51, 474, 445, 311, 305, 547, 0, 380, 429, 736, 355, 521, 431, 594, 478, 617], [2803, 428, 627, 597, 393, 148, 301, 527, 628, 481, 412, 506, 404, 213, 348, 579, 361, 0, 462, 768, 132, 552, 466, 625, 509, 648], [2497, 273, 590, 559, 500, 436, 319, 324, 590, 267, 522, 68, 421, 453, 214, 362, 468, 493, 0, 708, 475, 286, 35, 588, 341, 583], [2454, 717, 169, 208, 770, 706, 607, 425, 240, 587, 789, 779, 520, 722, 601, 666, 738, 764, 714, 0, 739, 640, 715, 183, 408, 211], [2765, 395, 590, 559, 355, 100, 263, 489, 596, 445, 377, 473, 371, 145, 310, 541, 323, 145, 424, 730, 0, 514, 428, 587, 471, 610], [2492, 299, 544, 513, 562, 498, 381, 154, 545, 169, 581, 267, 484, 514, 277, 117, 530, 556, 264, 596, 531, 0, 304, 542, 172, 565], [2541, 259, 576, 545, 486, 421, 305, 329, 577, 252, 505, 106, 407, 434, 200, 349, 454, 479, 38, 694, 455, 325, 0, 574, 347, 569], [2570, 572, 130, 100, 662, 597, 499, 419, 131, 581, 681, 650, 412, 614, 492, 660, 630, 655, 605, 197, 631, 634, 607, 0, 402, 151], [2497, 310, 372, 341, 544, 480, 392, 18, 373, 180, 563, 371, 276, 496, 287, 258, 512, 537, 353, 424, 513, 232, 392, 370, 0, 393], [2426, 577, 57, 49, 667, 602, 398, 424, 124, 586, 686, 655, 289, 619, 497, 665, 634, 660, 610, 152, 636, 639, 612, 153, 407, 0]]}, "reference": {"optimum_s": 18610, "optimality": "best_found", "lower_bound_s": 16565, "floor_s": 14874, "solve_s": 80.46, "ffd_s": 20935, "stop_aware_best_s": 20462, "stop_aware_mean_s": 20963.6, "route_id": "RouteID_e0b5d521-b877-4765-9fcf-2375873d73c6", "plans": {"optimum": [{"route": ["S12", "S06", "S17", "S20", "S05", "S13", "S10", "S04", "S16", "S14", "S01", "S18"], "parcels": ["P29"]}, {"route": ["S18", "S22", "S11"], "parcels": ["P28"]}, {"route": ["S21", "S15", "S09", "S07", "S24", "S23", "S08", "S03", "S02", "S25", "S19"], "parcels": []}], "ffd": [{"route": ["S15", "S14", "S13", "S01", "S22"], "parcels": ["P01", "P21", "P36"]}, {"route": ["S21", "S11", "S22", "S01", "S06", "S12", "S08", "S25"], "parcels": ["P02", "P09", "P10", "P17", "P18", "P34", "P35"]}, {"route": ["S11", "S18", "S09", "S07", "S24", "S12", "S17", "S20", "S05", "S13", "S16", "S04", "S10", "S23", "S08", "S03", "S02", "S19"], "parcels": ["P11", "P16", "P19", "P20", "P22"]}], "stop_aware_best": [{"route": ["S15", "S06", "S17", "S20", "S13", "S16", "S23", "S08", "S02"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S11", "S21", "S09", "S01", "S12", "S25", "S03"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S18", "S22", "S14", "S05", "S04", "S10", "S07", "S24", "S19"], "parcels": []}]}}, "meta": {"route_id": "RouteID_e0b5d521-b877-4765-9fcf-2375873d73c6", "split": "train", "stops": 25, "vans": 3, "tightness": 0.91, "station": "DBO2", "city": "DBO", "date": "2018-07-31", "seconds": 142.8, "stop_aware_best_reward": 0.5046, "optimality": "best_found"}}
{"id": "378cb728-spread-n25-k3-t0.94-s0", "instance": {"stops": ["S01", "S02", "S03", "S04", "S05", "S06", "S07", "S08", "S09", "S10", "S11", "S12", "S13", "S14", "S15", "S16", "S17", "S18", "S19", "S20", "S21", "S22", "S23", "S24", "S25"], "parcels": [{"id": "P01", "stop": "S01", "volume_dl": 29}, {"id": "P02", "stop": "S01", "volume_dl": 63}, {"id": "P03", "stop": "S02", "volume_dl": 104}, {"id": "P04", "stop": "S03", "volume_dl": 34}, {"id": "P05", "stop": "S04", "volume_dl": 32}, {"id": "P06", "stop": "S05", "volume_dl": 59}, {"id": "P07", "stop": "S06", "volume_dl": 242}, {"id": "P08", "stop": "S06", "volume_dl": 192}, {"id": "P09", "stop": "S07", "volume_dl": 134}, {"id": "P10", "stop": "S08", "volume_dl": 179}, {"id": "P11", "stop": "S09", "volume_dl": 429}, {"id": "P12", "stop": "S10", "volume_dl": 57}, {"id": "P13", "stop": "S11", "volume_dl": 95}, {"id": "P14", "stop": "S12", "volume_dl": 30}, {"id": "P15", "stop": "S13", "volume_dl": 149}, {"id": "P16", "stop": "S14", "volume_dl": 30}, {"id": "P17", "stop": "S15", "volume_dl": 95}, {"id": "P18", "stop": "S16", "volume_dl": 63}, {"id": "P19", "stop": "S16", "volume_dl": 542}, {"id": "P20", "stop": "S16", "volume_dl": 34}, {"id": "P21", "stop": "S17", "volume_dl": 57}, {"id": "P22", "stop": "S18", "volume_dl": 104}, {"id": "P23", "stop": "S19", "volume_dl": 39}, {"id": "P24", "stop": "S20", "volume_dl": 242}, {"id": "P25", "stop": "S21", "volume_dl": 429}, {"id": "P26", "stop": "S22", "volume_dl": 6}, {"id": "P27", "stop": "S22", "volume_dl": 53}, {"id": "P28", "stop": "S23", "volume_dl": 133}, {"id": "P29", "stop": "S24", "volume_dl": 16}, {"id": "P30", "stop": "S25", "volume_dl": 57}, {"id": "P31", "stop": "S25", "volume_dl": 104}], "vans": 3, "capacity_dl": 1361, "travel_s": [[0, 3176, 3441, 3301, 3366, 3278, 3038, 2988, 3166, 3094, 3106, 2950, 3025, 3384, 3087, 3339, 3330, 3396, 3286, 3439, 3141, 2999, 3124, 3272, 3342, 3084], [3261, 0, 534, 177, 250, 154, 212, 341, 170, 338, 242, 505, 412, 481, 283, 337, 207, 287, 179, 263, 102, 372, 296, 97, 235, 183], [3598, 521, 0, 526, 287, 503, 704, 833, 664, 830, 734, 996, 906, 47, 777, 291, 469, 317, 377, 516, 494, 866, 788, 562, 370, 675], [3414, 177, 515, 0, 231, 21, 389, 519, 347, 516, 419, 682, 589, 501, 461, 372, 361, 267, 160, 341, 162, 532, 474, 218, 215, 361], [3459, 222, 284, 238, 0, 216, 434, 564, 392, 560, 464, 727, 634, 270, 506, 142, 292, 36, 90, 386, 207, 576, 518, 262, 83, 406], [3393, 156, 493, 22, 209, 0, 368, 497, 326, 494, 398, 660, 568, 480, 439, 351, 339, 246, 138, 320, 140, 510, 452, 196, 194, 339], [3117, 226, 744, 403, 460, 380, 0, 197, 216, 194, 156, 361, 415, 707, 286, 510, 380, 496, 388, 489, 328, 375, 174, 322, 444, 134], [3068, 335, 853, 512, 569, 490, 197, 0, 326, 254, 266, 228, 345, 816, 396, 619, 489, 606, 498, 598, 437, 352, 283, 432, 553, 244], [3304, 164, 670, 341, 398, 318, 255, 384, 0, 305, 270, 385, 242, 657, 114, 430, 300, 434, 327, 427, 266, 202, 189, 261, 382, 264], [3212, 298, 816, 475, 532, 452, 182, 292, 289, 0, 109, 480, 337, 780, 209, 582, 452, 568, 461, 561, 400, 297, 96, 395, 516, 177], [3200, 245, 762, 421, 478, 399, 150, 280, 235, 119, 0, 469, 326, 726, 198, 529, 398, 515, 407, 508, 346, 286, 115, 341, 463, 68], [3062, 512, 1013, 672, 729, 650, 373, 230, 406, 430, 442, 0, 187, 993, 284, 796, 665, 766, 658, 775, 513, 194, 401, 540, 714, 420], [3136, 428, 934, 614, 671, 592, 449, 306, 264, 375, 340, 166, 0, 921, 141, 694, 564, 708, 600, 691, 455, 85, 258, 482, 656, 334], [3551, 474, 57, 532, 269, 509, 686, 816, 646, 812, 716, 979, 888, 0, 760, 273, 452, 300, 359, 469, 476, 848, 770, 515, 353, 658], [3212, 287, 793, 464, 521, 441, 295, 411, 123, 234, 198, 271, 128, 780, 0, 553, 423, 557, 450, 550, 389, 88, 117, 384, 505, 193], [3510, 364, 308, 380, 142, 358, 460, 590, 420, 587, 490, 753, 662, 294, 534, 0, 226, 172, 232, 528, 348, 622, 544, 404, 225, 432], [3392, 228, 459, 393, 293, 371, 343, 473, 303, 470, 373, 636, 545, 446, 417, 219, 0, 324, 266, 491, 361, 505, 427, 324, 321, 315], [3505, 268, 304, 285, 46, 262, 480, 610, 438, 606, 510, 773, 680, 290, 552, 162, 338, 0, 136, 432, 253, 623, 564, 309, 129, 452], [3409, 172, 365, 188, 81, 166, 383, 513, 341, 510, 413, 676, 583, 351, 455, 222, 241, 117, 0, 336, 156, 526, 468, 212, 65, 355], [3521, 260, 550, 318, 375, 295, 472, 602, 430, 598, 502, 765, 672, 493, 544, 516, 467, 411, 303, 0, 263, 627, 556, 300, 359, 444], [3252, 120, 500, 159, 216, 137, 332, 461, 290, 458, 362, 515, 461, 487, 458, 358, 346, 253, 145, 264, 0, 370, 416, 220, 201, 303], [3123, 375, 881, 529, 586, 507, 383, 341, 211, 322, 286, 201, 92, 868, 88, 641, 510, 623, 515, 638, 370, 0, 205, 397, 571, 280], [3228, 294, 812, 471, 528, 449, 178, 308, 213, 116, 105, 384, 241, 776, 113, 578, 448, 565, 457, 558, 396, 201, 0, 391, 513, 173], [3374, 96, 538, 197, 254, 174, 308, 438, 266, 434, 338, 539, 486, 501, 380, 395, 303, 290, 182, 283, 122, 394, 392, 0, 238, 280], [3457, 220, 360, 236, 76, 214, 431, 561, 389, 558, 462, 724, 632, 347, 503, 218, 289, 113, 88, 384, 204, 574, 516, 260, 0, 403], [3183, 176, 694, 353, 410, 331, 133, 263, 167, 177, 58, 426, 330, 658, 202, 460, 330, 447, 339, 440, 278, 290, 173, 273, 394, 0]]}, "reference": {"optimum_s": 22132, "optimality": "best_found", "lower_bound_s": 20120, "floor_s": 18036, "solve_s": 63.28, "ffd_s": 24129, "stop_aware_best_s": 23569, "stop_aware_mean_s": 23911.2, "route_id": "RouteID_378cb728-680a-4aef-8673-59d53d936fc7", "plans": {"optimum": [{"route": ["S11", "S12", "S21", "S14", "S08", "S01", "S23", "S19", "S20"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S09", "S22", "S10", "S25", "S06", "S07"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S05", "S03", "S18", "S24", "S04", "S17", "S02", "S13", "S15", "S16"], "parcels": []}], "ffd": [{"route": ["S09", "S22", "S16", "S06", "S07"], "parcels": ["P07", "P19", "P26"]}, {"route": ["S21", "S08", "S23", "S20", "S03", "S13", "S06"], "parcels": ["P08"]}, {"route": ["S01", "S19", "S05", "S18", "S24", "S04", "S17", "S02", "S15", "S16", "S25", "S10", "S22", "S14", "S12", "S11"], "parcels": ["P18", "P20", "P27"]}], "stop_aware_best": [{"route": ["S09", "S25", "S03", "S24", "S08", "S21"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S20", "S05", "S18", "S04", "S17", "S15", "S02", "S13", "S19", "S23", "S10", "S22", "S14", "S12", "S07"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S11", "S01", "S16", "S06"], "parcels": []}]}}, "meta": {"route_id": "RouteID_378cb728-680a-4aef-8673-59d53d936fc7", "split": "train", "stops": 25, "vans": 3, "tightness": 0.94, "station": "DBO3", "city": "DBO", "date": "2018-08-16", "seconds": 88.2, "stop_aware_best_reward": 0.6033, "optimality": "best_found"}}
{"id": "eeab1b30-spread-n20-k3-t0.86-s0", "instance": {"stops": ["S01", "S02", "S03", "S04", "S05", "S06", "S07", "S08", "S09", "S10", "S11", "S12", "S13", "S14", "S15", "S16", "S17", "S18", "S19", "S20"], "parcels": [{"id": "P01", "stop": "S01", "volume_dl": 179}, {"id": "P02", "stop": "S01", "volume_dl": 60}, {"id": "P03", "stop": "S02", "volume_dl": 92}, {"id": "P04", "stop": "S02", "volume_dl": 41}, {"id": "P05", "stop": "S02", "volume_dl": 18}, {"id": "P06", "stop": "S03", "volume_dl": 429}, {"id": "P07", "stop": "S04", "volume_dl": 133}, {"id": "P08", "stop": "S04", "volume_dl": 104}, {"id": "P09", "stop": "S04", "volume_dl": 157}, {"id": "P10", "stop": "S04", "volume_dl": 5}, {"id": "P11", "stop": "S05", "volume_dl": 59}, {"id": "P12", "stop": "S06", "volume_dl": 46}, {"id": "P13", "stop": "S07", "volume_dl": 4}, {"id": "P14", "stop": "S08", "volume_dl": 16}, {"id": "P15", "stop": "S09", "volume_dl": 31}, {"id": "P16", "stop": "S10", "volume_dl": 16}, {"id": "P17", "stop": "S11", "volume_dl": 46}, {"id": "P18", "stop": "S12", "volume_dl": 133}, {"id": "P19", "stop": "S12", "volume_dl": 34}, {"id": "P20", "stop": "S13", "volume_dl": 40}, {"id": "P21", "stop": "S14", "volume_dl": 17}, {"id": "P22", "stop": "S14", "volume_dl": 17}, {"id": "P23", "stop": "S15", "volume_dl": 4}, {"id": "P24", "stop": "S16", "volume_dl": 242}, {"id": "P25", "stop": "S16", "volume_dl": 226}, {"id": "P26", "stop": "S16", "volume_dl": 259}, {"id": "P27", "stop": "S16", "volume_dl": 79}, {"id": "P28", "stop": "S17", "volume_dl": 179}, {"id": "P29", "stop": "S18", "volume_dl": 20}, {"id": "P30", "stop": "S19", "volume_dl": 104}, {"id": "P31", "stop": "S19", "volume_dl": 95}, {"id": "P32", "stop": "S20", "volume_dl": 63}], "vans": 3, "capacity_dl": 1144, "travel_s": [[0, 2064, 2161, 2103, 2078, 2101, 2171, 2151, 2234, 2044, 2124, 2105, 2061, 2123, 2229, 2064, 2078, 2111, 2185, 2128, 2174], [2078, 0, 348, 165, 130, 165, 305, 286, 169, 97, 242, 237, 166, 209, 164, 185, 149, 232, 320, 172, 160], [2111, 346, 0, 320, 418, 232, 124, 96, 515, 380, 426, 300, 261, 307, 510, 299, 295, 346, 131, 330, 471], [2124, 156, 336, 0, 223, 151, 291, 271, 322, 190, 128, 222, 149, 195, 318, 170, 36, 217, 305, 50, 263], [2072, 160, 520, 286, 0, 286, 426, 407, 219, 80, 376, 358, 285, 330, 214, 306, 272, 182, 441, 275, 209], [2029, 173, 224, 148, 216, 0, 180, 160, 342, 207, 254, 72, 83, 98, 338, 187, 122, 183, 194, 184, 299], [2148, 322, 148, 297, 331, 280, 0, 64, 492, 395, 403, 213, 285, 303, 487, 302, 272, 298, 52, 334, 448], [2128, 303, 109, 277, 321, 262, 71, 0, 472, 337, 383, 203, 270, 285, 467, 292, 252, 288, 34, 314, 428], [2176, 172, 541, 305, 246, 356, 496, 476, 0, 184, 327, 428, 354, 400, 50, 375, 308, 347, 510, 281, 111], [1991, 78, 440, 205, 62, 206, 346, 326, 199, 0, 258, 278, 205, 250, 194, 226, 192, 199, 361, 211, 190], [2146, 246, 451, 137, 296, 265, 405, 385, 333, 262, 0, 340, 263, 309, 306, 299, 140, 346, 419, 146, 274], [2091, 241, 292, 215, 144, 68, 247, 228, 363, 208, 321, 0, 93, 108, 358, 115, 190, 111, 235, 252, 354], [2059, 163, 248, 140, 193, 63, 203, 183, 335, 200, 246, 94, 0, 58, 330, 164, 115, 160, 218, 150, 292], [2031, 180, 314, 155, 225, 94, 234, 214, 350, 214, 261, 108, 38, 0, 345, 92, 130, 138, 248, 192, 306], [2189, 186, 536, 347, 260, 351, 491, 472, 42, 198, 332, 423, 350, 395, 0, 371, 350, 361, 506, 323, 125], [2056, 259, 339, 180, 120, 119, 259, 239, 339, 183, 286, 137, 93, 83, 334, 0, 155, 69, 274, 217, 329], [2104, 139, 310, 56, 209, 125, 265, 245, 325, 176, 131, 197, 124, 169, 306, 144, 0, 191, 280, 106, 266], [2103, 253, 386, 227, 114, 166, 306, 286, 334, 178, 332, 118, 140, 130, 329, 89, 202, 0, 274, 264, 324], [2190, 327, 143, 301, 313, 228, 61, 47, 532, 376, 407, 195, 236, 250, 527, 283, 276, 280, 0, 338, 522], [2142, 177, 332, 57, 225, 175, 315, 295, 292, 214, 131, 247, 175, 219, 297, 194, 91, 241, 329, 0, 233], [2167, 140, 457, 221, 219, 272, 412, 392, 119, 186, 244, 344, 271, 316, 140, 292, 224, 339, 427, 198, 0]]}, "reference": {"optimum_s": 14187, "optimality": "best_found", "lower_bound_s": 13265, "floor_s": 12105, "solve_s": 78.29, "ffd_s": 15142, "stop_aware_best_s": 15177, "stop_aware_mean_s": 15463.8, "route_id": "RouteID_eeab1b30-30cd-42f5-a27f-e93aafc0a303", "plans": {"optimum": [{"route": ["S01", "S14", "S08", "S20", "S19", "S03", "S10"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S16", "S05", "S06", "S18", "S07", "S02"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S15", "S13", "S12", "S11", "S17", "S04", "S09"], "parcels": []}], "ffd": [{"route": ["S01", "S03", "S16", "S12"], "parcels": ["P01", "P19", "P24", "P26"]}, {"route": ["S12", "S07", "S19", "S16", "S15", "S17", "S04"], "parcels": ["P18", "P25"]}, {"route": ["S02", "S06", "S18", "S11", "S05", "S13", "S16", "S10", "S14", "S08", "S20", "S01", "S09"], "parcels": ["P02", "P27"]}], "stop_aware_best": [{"route": ["S01", "S08", "S20", "S19", "S11", "S04"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S02", "S18", "S13", "S12", "S03", "S10", "S14", "S09"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S16", "S15", "S17", "S05", "S06", "S07"], "parcels": []}]}}, "meta": {"route_id": "RouteID_eeab1b30-30cd-42f5-a27f-e93aafc0a303", "split": "train", "stops": 20, "vans": 3, "tightness": 0.86, "station": "DSE4", "city": "DSE", "date": "2018-08-04", "seconds": 118.7, "stop_aware_best_reward": 0.5228, "optimality": "best_found"}}
{"id": "d6718a27-spread-n25-k3-t0.93-s0", "instance": {"stops": ["S01", "S02", "S03", "S04", "S05", "S06", "S07", "S08", "S09", "S10", "S11", "S12", "S13", "S14", "S15", "S16", "S17", "S18", "S19", "S20", "S21", "S22", "S23", "S24", "S25"], "parcels": [{"id": "P01", "stop": "S01", "volume_dl": 12}, {"id": "P02", "stop": "S01", "volume_dl": 599}, {"id": "P03", "stop": "S02", "volume_dl": 242}, {"id": "P04", "stop": "S03", "volume_dl": 14}, {"id": "P05", "stop": "S04", "volume_dl": 368}, {"id": "P06", "stop": "S05", "volume_dl": 55}, {"id": "P07", "stop": "S06", "volume_dl": 11}, {"id": "P08", "stop": "S07", "volume_dl": 539}, {"id": "P09", "stop": "S07", "volume_dl": 8}, {"id": "P10", "stop": "S08", "volume_dl": 5}, {"id": "P11", "stop": "S08", "volume_dl": 324}, {"id": "P12", "stop": "S08", "volume_dl": 38}, {"id": "P13", "stop": "S08", "volume_dl": 34}, {"id": "P14", "stop": "S08", "volume_dl": 2}, {"id": "P15", "stop": "S09", "volume_dl": 312}, {"id": "P16", "stop": "S10", "volume_dl": 132}, {"id": "P17", "stop": "S11", "volume_dl": 63}, {"id": "P18", "stop": "S12", "volume_dl": 58}, {"id": "P19", "stop": "S12", "volume_dl": 21}, {"id": "P20", "stop": "S13", "volume_dl": 477}, {"id": "P21", "stop": "S14", "volume_dl": 322}, {"id": "P22", "stop": "S14", "volume_dl": 12}, {"id": "P23", "stop": "S15", "volume_dl": 6}, {"id": "P24", "stop": "S16", "volume_dl": 8}, {"id": "P25", "stop": "S16", "volume_dl": 21}, {"id": "P26", "stop": "S17", "volume_dl": 179}, {"id": "P27", "stop": "S17", "volume_dl": 13}, {"id": "P28", "stop": "S17", "volume_dl": 34}, {"id": "P29", "stop": "S17", "volume_dl": 226}, {"id": "P30", "stop": "S17", "volume_dl": 26}, {"id": "P31", "stop": "S17", "volume_dl": 57}, {"id": "P32", "stop": "S17", "volume_dl": 17}, {"id": "P33", "stop": "S17", "volume_dl": 13}, {"id": "P34", "stop": "S17", "volume_dl": 40}, {"id": "P35", "stop": "S17", "volume_dl": 226}, {"id": "P36", "stop": "S18", "volume_dl": 34}, {"id": "P37", "stop": "S18", "volume_dl": 11}, {"id": "P38", "stop": "S19", "volume_dl": 157}, {"id": "P39", "stop": "S20", "volume_dl": 92}, {"id": "P40", "stop": "S21", "volume_dl": 28}, {"id": "P41", "stop": "S22", "volume_dl": 95}, {"id": "P42", "stop": "S23", "volume_dl": 35}, {"id": "P43", "stop": "S24", "volume_dl": 840}, {"id": "P44", "stop": "S24", "volume_dl": 324}, {"id": "P45", "stop": "S24", "volume_dl": 14}, {"id": "P46", "stop": "S25", "volume_dl": 779}, {"id": "P47", "stop": "S25", "volume_dl": 57}], "vans": 3, "capacity_dl": 2502, "travel_s": [[0, 1290, 1085, 1318, 1128, 1110, 1388, 1394, 1327, 1158, 1309, 1106, 1301, 1206, 1274, 1232, 1332, 1085, 1271, 967, 1088, 1374, 1341, 1157, 1311, 1390], [1187, 0, 512, 322, 128, 268, 359, 300, 327, 87, 299, 265, 343, 499, 323, 264, 176, 348, 266, 614, 256, 218, 267, 319, 237, 422], [1154, 552, 0, 681, 452, 346, 654, 659, 651, 483, 717, 290, 625, 112, 598, 556, 595, 410, 596, 146, 371, 636, 607, 235, 576, 747], [1278, 320, 603, 0, 219, 451, 212, 69, 214, 224, 130, 448, 105, 640, 79, 270, 219, 438, 159, 704, 347, 276, 181, 502, 188, 152], [1096, 144, 421, 207, 0, 269, 340, 256, 216, 48, 198, 266, 190, 447, 163, 121, 133, 256, 161, 522, 165, 198, 276, 320, 245, 279], [1129, 257, 340, 445, 218, 0, 482, 424, 417, 249, 422, 58, 466, 364, 447, 322, 300, 289, 362, 456, 114, 341, 390, 111, 360, 545], [1413, 375, 629, 196, 354, 490, 0, 146, 350, 359, 266, 486, 241, 626, 214, 405, 311, 574, 288, 745, 483, 353, 166, 541, 120, 153], [1324, 318, 621, 89, 265, 433, 153, 0, 265, 270, 176, 430, 153, 619, 141, 316, 271, 484, 205, 738, 393, 323, 121, 484, 158, 185], [1280, 323, 605, 187, 221, 453, 320, 236, 0, 226, 195, 450, 170, 631, 160, 216, 231, 440, 119, 707, 350, 296, 288, 504, 325, 265], [1120, 97, 445, 245, 61, 293, 390, 331, 254, 0, 237, 290, 228, 471, 201, 159, 207, 280, 199, 546, 189, 249, 298, 344, 268, 318], [1265, 294, 590, 130, 206, 409, 262, 178, 201, 211, 0, 406, 44, 616, 42, 209, 159, 426, 146, 692, 334, 216, 231, 460, 267, 202], [1134, 262, 284, 450, 224, 66, 488, 429, 422, 254, 427, 0, 471, 308, 452, 328, 305, 294, 367, 400, 119, 346, 396, 54, 365, 550], [1239, 282, 564, 104, 180, 412, 236, 152, 181, 185, 63, 409, 0, 590, 49, 197, 196, 400, 120, 666, 309, 255, 205, 463, 241, 176], [1224, 558, 92, 660, 454, 352, 633, 638, 653, 485, 723, 296, 627, 0, 600, 558, 601, 502, 598, 179, 350, 642, 586, 241, 555, 726], [1223, 266, 548, 88, 164, 396, 221, 136, 165, 169, 51, 393, 49, 574, 0, 182, 180, 409, 104, 650, 293, 239, 189, 448, 226, 186], [1201, 270, 526, 250, 142, 384, 368, 298, 224, 147, 199, 381, 243, 552, 224, 0, 134, 362, 179, 628, 271, 199, 276, 435, 246, 322], [1214, 188, 539, 239, 155, 297, 281, 221, 313, 160, 189, 293, 233, 528, 230, 154, 0, 380, 218, 640, 283, 112, 189, 348, 165, 337], [1041, 352, 366, 414, 224, 293, 545, 461, 428, 255, 406, 289, 397, 478, 370, 328, 346, 0, 368, 468, 224, 404, 453, 344, 423, 512], [1237, 280, 562, 145, 178, 410, 268, 193, 157, 183, 152, 407, 127, 588, 101, 196, 194, 398, 0, 664, 307, 253, 246, 462, 282, 181], [1045, 657, 154, 786, 553, 452, 759, 765, 752, 584, 822, 395, 726, 218, 699, 657, 700, 511, 697, 0, 477, 742, 712, 340, 682, 853], [1066, 259, 391, 346, 156, 140, 484, 426, 355, 186, 337, 137, 329, 353, 302, 260, 302, 227, 299, 493, 0, 343, 392, 191, 362, 418], [1271, 256, 596, 279, 212, 370, 354, 296, 365, 217, 228, 367, 272, 601, 253, 211, 124, 431, 269, 698, 340, 0, 263, 421, 232, 351], [1328, 296, 579, 153, 312, 411, 163, 103, 307, 316, 223, 407, 198, 577, 171, 320, 232, 489, 249, 696, 398, 274, 0, 462, 36, 195], [1189, 317, 229, 505, 279, 111, 543, 484, 478, 309, 482, 55, 526, 254, 507, 382, 360, 350, 422, 346, 174, 402, 451, 0, 420, 605], [1288, 256, 539, 194, 280, 370, 126, 144, 353, 299, 264, 367, 240, 536, 213, 279, 198, 448, 290, 655, 358, 233, 46, 421, 0, 189], [1334, 377, 660, 132, 276, 508, 149, 150, 262, 281, 203, 504, 178, 696, 168, 293, 291, 503, 186, 761, 404, 349, 191, 559, 209, 0]]}, "reference": {"optimum_s": 9825, "optimality": "best_found", "lower_bound_s": 7980, "floor_s": 6024, "solve_s": 72.31, "ffd_s": 12324, "stop_aware_best_s": 10968, "stop_aware_mean_s": 11061.6, "route_id": "RouteID_d6718a27-cdee-4c93-9630-e5cadd22d50a", "plans": {"optimum": [{"route": ["S09", "S01", "S21", "S16", "S22", "S24"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S15", "S08", "S18", "S25", "S06", "S07", "S03", "S14", "S10", "S12"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S19", "S02", "S13", "S23", "S11", "S05", "S20", "S04", "S17"], "parcels": []}], "ffd": [{"route": ["S02", "S01", "S24", "S25", "S08", "S17"], "parcels": ["P02", "P14", "P34", "P43", "P46"]}, {"route": ["S13", "S24", "S07", "S03", "S14", "S10", "S08", "S04"], "parcels": ["P08", "P11", "P21", "P44"]}, {"route": ["S19", "S23", "S11", "S05", "S20", "S15", "S08", "S18", "S14", "S12", "S25", "S06", "S07", "S22", "S24", "S21", "S16", "S01", "S09", "S17"], "parcels": ["P01", "P09", "P10", "P12", "P13", "P22", "P26", "P27", "P28", "P29", "P30", "P31", "P32", "P33", "P35", "P45", "P47"]}], "stop_aware_best": [{"route": ["S19", "S02", "S13", "S24", "S03", "S14", "S16"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S17", "S15", "S18", "S10", "S07", "S06", "S22", "S01"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S11", "S23", "S05", "S20", "S04", "S08", "S12", "S25", "S21", "S09"], "parcels": []}]}}, "meta": {"route_id": "RouteID_d6718a27-cdee-4c93-9630-e5cadd22d50a", "split": "train", "stops": 25, "vans": 3, "tightness": 0.93, "station": "DSE5", "city": "DSE", "date": "2018-08-10", "seconds": 125.2, "stop_aware_best_reward": 0.6452, "optimality": "best_found"}}
{"id": "2f76393e-spread-n25-k3-t0.89-s0", "instance": {"stops": ["S01", "S02", "S03", "S04", "S05", "S06", "S07", "S08", "S09", "S10", "S11", "S12", "S13", "S14", "S15", "S16", "S17", "S18", "S19", "S20", "S21", "S22", "S23", "S24", "S25"], "parcels": [{"id": "P01", "stop": "S01", "volume_dl": 133}, {"id": "P02", "stop": "S02", "volume_dl": 57}, {"id": "P03", "stop": "S03", "volume_dl": 92}, {"id": "P04", "stop": "S04", "volume_dl": 24}, {"id": "P05", "stop": "S04", "volume_dl": 6}, {"id": "P06", "stop": "S05", "volume_dl": 22}, {"id": "P07", "stop": "S05", "volume_dl": 26}, {"id": "P08", "stop": "S06", "volume_dl": 840}, {"id": "P09", "stop": "S06", "volume_dl": 242}, {"id": "P10", "stop": "S06", "volume_dl": 528}, {"id": "P11", "stop": "S06", "volume_dl": 11}, {"id": "P12", "stop": "S07", "volume_dl": 57}, {"id": "P13", "stop": "S07", "volume_dl": 57}, {"id": "P14", "stop": "S08", "volume_dl": 95}, {"id": "P15", "stop": "S09", "volume_dl": 133}, {"id": "P16", "stop": "S10", "volume_dl": 29}, {"id": "P17", "stop": "S11", "volume_dl": 104}, {"id": "P18", "stop": "S12", "volume_dl": 6}, {"id": "P19", "stop": "S13", "volume_dl": 259}, {"id": "P20", "stop": "S14", "volume_dl": 34}, {"id": "P21", "stop": "S14", "volume_dl": 104}, {"id": "P22", "stop": "S14", "volume_dl": 18}, {"id": "P23", "stop": "S14", "volume_dl": 13}, {"id": "P24", "stop": "S15", "volume_dl": 47}, {"id": "P25", "stop": "S15", "volume_dl": 3}, {"id": "P26", "stop": "S16", "volume_dl": 18}, {"id": "P27", "stop": "S17", "volume_dl": 95}, {"id": "P28", "stop": "S18", "volume_dl": 179}, {"id": "P29", "stop": "S19", "volume_dl": 102}, {"id": "P30", "stop": "S20", "volume_dl": 133}, {"id": "P31", "stop": "S21", "volume_dl": 63}, {"id": "P32", "stop": "S21", "volume_dl": 21}, {"id": "P33", "stop": "S22", "volume_dl": 134}, {"id": "P34", "stop": "S22", "volume_dl": 25}, {"id": "P35", "stop": "S23", "volume_dl": 26}, {"id": "P36", "stop": "S24", "volume_dl": 179}, {"id": "P37", "stop": "S25", "volume_dl": 92}, {"id": "P38", "stop": "S25", "volume_dl": 6}, {"id": "P39", "stop": "S25", "volume_dl": 95}], "vans": 3, "capacity_dl": 1540, "travel_s": [[0, 1261, 1161, 1333, 1058, 1039, 1153, 1340, 1146, 1218, 1153, 1148, 1186, 1411, 1221, 1135, 1179, 1215, 1413, 1319, 1339, 1378, 1230, 1188, 1176, 1319], [1519, 0, 424, 111, 356, 412, 202, 118, 290, 168, 463, 389, 472, 196, 135, 438, 239, 456, 190, 96, 78, 216, 145, 230, 443, 78], [1352, 359, 0, 396, 121, 241, 281, 417, 175, 249, 140, 104, 112, 471, 320, 129, 232, 108, 490, 396, 396, 436, 329, 286, 124, 378], [1550, 112, 404, 0, 336, 393, 270, 96, 270, 149, 443, 369, 452, 118, 116, 418, 220, 436, 137, 86, 42, 138, 108, 211, 424, 68], [1301, 238, 104, 310, 0, 91, 160, 321, 124, 196, 230, 110, 188, 389, 198, 201, 156, 184, 390, 296, 316, 356, 211, 165, 196, 280], [1317, 268, 158, 341, 65, 0, 161, 348, 127, 226, 210, 136, 219, 419, 228, 185, 184, 203, 421, 326, 346, 386, 242, 195, 191, 310], [1409, 225, 262, 298, 158, 249, 0, 305, 166, 183, 308, 269, 346, 376, 186, 283, 144, 342, 378, 284, 304, 343, 195, 152, 289, 267], [1579, 112, 433, 86, 369, 426, 281, 0, 299, 178, 472, 398, 481, 121, 145, 449, 249, 465, 73, 21, 78, 146, 158, 240, 453, 42], [1344, 250, 180, 274, 88, 118, 143, 295, 0, 127, 237, 162, 246, 349, 210, 212, 57, 229, 368, 274, 274, 314, 220, 177, 217, 256], [1401, 173, 255, 147, 187, 244, 152, 168, 121, 0, 294, 220, 303, 222, 86, 269, 70, 287, 241, 147, 147, 187, 176, 96, 275, 129], [1306, 407, 114, 418, 204, 185, 300, 439, 213, 270, 0, 95, 52, 492, 368, 26, 266, 59, 512, 418, 417, 458, 377, 334, 22, 400], [1248, 385, 113, 359, 131, 137, 286, 380, 154, 212, 128, 0, 83, 434, 299, 114, 208, 67, 453, 359, 359, 399, 363, 308, 109, 341], [1333, 454, 107, 444, 195, 222, 346, 466, 240, 297, 45, 85, 0, 519, 414, 72, 293, 107, 538, 444, 444, 485, 424, 381, 68, 426], [1623, 185, 477, 96, 409, 466, 328, 120, 343, 222, 516, 442, 525, 0, 174, 491, 292, 509, 106, 141, 119, 74, 180, 284, 497, 141], [1479, 101, 333, 126, 259, 288, 154, 185, 170, 78, 372, 298, 381, 178, 0, 347, 113, 365, 201, 160, 125, 144, 74, 108, 353, 143], [1280, 381, 101, 392, 178, 160, 274, 416, 186, 244, 25, 69, 87, 466, 342, 0, 240, 33, 485, 391, 391, 433, 354, 308, 6, 387], [1395, 207, 237, 218, 146, 175, 133, 239, 57, 71, 288, 214, 297, 293, 168, 263, 0, 281, 312, 218, 218, 258, 177, 120, 269, 200], [1314, 422, 99, 426, 219, 200, 315, 447, 221, 278, 80, 66, 85, 500, 383, 55, 274, 0, 520, 425, 425, 466, 392, 349, 61, 407], [1652, 185, 506, 144, 438, 495, 354, 73, 372, 251, 545, 471, 554, 86, 206, 520, 322, 538, 0, 94, 139, 80, 227, 313, 526, 115], [1558, 91, 412, 108, 344, 400, 259, 21, 278, 157, 451, 377, 460, 142, 124, 426, 227, 444, 94, 0, 85, 167, 133, 219, 432, 21], [1558, 72, 412, 32, 344, 400, 275, 86, 278, 157, 451, 377, 460, 118, 123, 426, 227, 444, 137, 65, 0, 161, 133, 219, 432, 47], [1598, 211, 452, 132, 384, 441, 304, 153, 318, 197, 491, 417, 500, 74, 149, 466, 268, 484, 80, 174, 170, 0, 209, 259, 472, 181], [1600, 30, 454, 141, 386, 442, 202, 114, 320, 199, 493, 419, 502, 226, 162, 469, 269, 486, 183, 88, 108, 243, 0, 261, 474, 68], [1472, 172, 321, 216, 175, 269, 132, 237, 151, 82, 366, 292, 374, 290, 132, 341, 94, 358, 310, 216, 216, 256, 141, 0, 346, 198], [1285, 386, 106, 396, 183, 164, 278, 417, 191, 249, 19, 73, 92, 471, 346, 4, 245, 38, 490, 396, 396, 436, 356, 313, 0, 378], [1534, 66, 388, 90, 320, 376, 243, 42, 254, 133, 427, 353, 436, 159, 99, 402, 203, 420, 111, 17, 60, 181, 113, 195, 408, 0]]}, "reference": {"optimum_s": 9264, "optimality": "best_found", "lower_bound_s": 8348, "floor_s": 6861, "solve_s": 41.16, "ffd_s": 10377, "stop_aware_best_s": 10279, "stop_aware_mean_s": 10425.4, "route_id": "RouteID_2f76393e-948c-4fd3-94d8-3b0179aca9a4", "plans": {"optimum": [{"route": ["S22", "S01", "S20", "S03", "S13", "S21", "S18", "S07", "S19", "S25"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S06", "S23", "S14", "S09", "S16", "S08", "S04", "S02", "S12", "S10", "S24", "S15", "S17", "S11"], "parcels": ["P10"]}, {"route": ["S05", "S06"], "parcels": ["P08", "P09", "P11"]}], "ffd": [{"route": ["S14", "S22", "S06", "S15"], "parcels": ["P08", "P10", "P20", "P25", "P33"]}, {"route": ["S06", "S01", "S20", "S18", "S13", "S21", "S14", "S09", "S24", "S11"], "parcels": ["P09", "P11", "P21", "P31"]}, {"route": ["S05", "S22", "S25", "S19", "S07", "S03", "S21", "S14", "S23", "S16", "S08", "S04", "S02", "S12", "S10", "S15", "S17"], "parcels": ["P22", "P23", "P24", "P32", "P34"]}], "stop_aware_best": [{"route": ["S06", "S19", "S25", "S20", "S13", "S21", "S24"], "parcels": ["P10", "P11"]}, {"route": ["S05", "S14", "S18", "S07", "S03", "S09", "S16", "S08", "S04", "S02", "S12", "S10", "S15", "S11"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S23", "S22", "S01", "S06", "S17"], "parcels": ["P08", "P09"]}]}}, "meta": {"route_id": "RouteID_2f76393e-948c-4fd3-94d8-3b0179aca9a4", "split": "train", "stops": 25, "vans": 3, "tightness": 0.89, "station": "DLA8", "city": "DLA", "date": "2018-08-16", "seconds": 92.0, "stop_aware_best_reward": 0.5555, "optimality": "best_found"}}
{"id": "4929e984-spread-n30-k4-t0.85-s0", "instance": {"stops": ["S01", "S02", "S03", "S04", "S05", "S06", "S07", "S08", "S09", "S10", "S11", "S12", "S13", "S14", "S15", "S16", "S17", "S18", "S19", "S20", "S21", "S22", "S23", "S24", "S25", "S26", "S27", "S28", "S29", "S30"], "parcels": [{"id": "P01", "stop": "S01", "volume_dl": 179}, {"id": "P02", "stop": "S01", "volume_dl": 34}, {"id": "P03", "stop": "S02", "volume_dl": 179}, {"id": "P04", "stop": "S03", "volume_dl": 824}, {"id": "P05", "stop": "S04", "volume_dl": 56}, {"id": "P06", "stop": "S05", "volume_dl": 39}, {"id": "P07", "stop": "S06", "volume_dl": 3}, {"id": "P08", "stop": "S07", "volume_dl": 134}, {"id": "P09", "stop": "S08", "volume_dl": 79}, {"id": "P10", "stop": "S09", "volume_dl": 322}, {"id": "P11", "stop": "S10", "volume_dl": 43}, {"id": "P12", "stop": "S11", "volume_dl": 90}, {"id": "P13", "stop": "S12", "volume_dl": 26}, {"id": "P14", "stop": "S12", "volume_dl": 59}, {"id": "P15", "stop": "S13", "volume_dl": 58}, {"id": "P16", "stop": "S14", "volume_dl": 599}, {"id": "P17", "stop": "S15", "volume_dl": 95}, {"id": "P18", "stop": "S16", "volume_dl": 136}, {"id": "P19", "stop": "S17", "volume_dl": 104}, {"id": "P20", "stop": "S18", "volume_dl": 42}, {"id": "P21", "stop": "S19", "volume_dl": 57}, {"id": "P22", "stop": "S20", "volume_dl": 6}, {"id": "P23", "stop": "S21", "volume_dl": 34}, {"id": "P24", "stop": "S21", "volume_dl": 366}, {"id": "P25", "stop": "S22", "volume_dl": 133}, {"id": "P26", "stop": "S23", "volume_dl": 95}, {"id": "P27", "stop": "S24", "volume_dl": 41}, {"id": "P28", "stop": "S25", "volume_dl": 53}, {"id": "P29", "stop": "S26", "volume_dl": 133}, {"id": "P30", "stop": "S27", "volume_dl": 39}, {"id": "P31", "stop": "S28", "volume_dl": 134}, {"id": "P32", "stop": "S29", "volume_dl": 179}, {"id": "P33", "stop": "S30", "volume_dl": 8}], "vans": 4, "capacity_dl": 1288, "travel_s": [[0, 2903, 2908, 3021, 2934, 2890, 3038, 3070, 3117, 2969, 2782, 2936, 2956, 3031, 2931, 2926, 2923, 2999, 2884, 2956, 2849, 2937, 2909, 2878, 3028, 3034, 3051, 2814, 2993, 2784, 3013], [2869, 0, 742, 870, 682, 274, 857, 868, 916, 803, 348, 770, 776, 849, 269, 673, 671, 798, 632, 486, 596, 685, 656, 636, 312, 832, 798, 343, 842, 350, 511], [2899, 847, 0, 296, 386, 825, 325, 411, 458, 96, 930, 151, 311, 372, 874, 378, 395, 340, 288, 764, 373, 428, 361, 831, 863, 375, 395, 622, 268, 932, 542], [2985, 904, 297, 0, 378, 878, 334, 403, 450, 320, 982, 264, 289, 364, 931, 370, 387, 332, 280, 807, 365, 420, 353, 826, 902, 367, 387, 665, 201, 984, 610], [2886, 703, 371, 386, 0, 677, 303, 354, 401, 394, 781, 337, 222, 315, 730, 8, 168, 283, 147, 606, 172, 201, 25, 625, 701, 318, 338, 464, 357, 783, 551], [2841, 269, 736, 878, 689, 0, 865, 874, 922, 886, 320, 830, 783, 855, 333, 681, 678, 804, 639, 380, 604, 692, 664, 530, 264, 838, 804, 238, 850, 322, 540], [3012, 891, 322, 355, 295, 864, 0, 232, 280, 345, 969, 289, 89, 78, 918, 287, 356, 162, 307, 794, 360, 388, 270, 813, 888, 196, 235, 652, 327, 971, 637], [3021, 918, 395, 410, 323, 892, 221, 0, 47, 418, 996, 362, 150, 143, 945, 314, 383, 80, 316, 821, 388, 416, 298, 840, 916, 66, 150, 679, 382, 998, 646], [3079, 976, 454, 468, 381, 950, 279, 58, 0, 476, 1055, 420, 209, 202, 1004, 373, 442, 135, 374, 880, 446, 474, 356, 898, 974, 124, 209, 737, 440, 1057, 704], [2961, 908, 96, 315, 405, 886, 344, 430, 477, 0, 1009, 170, 330, 391, 936, 397, 414, 359, 307, 834, 392, 447, 380, 893, 924, 394, 414, 692, 287, 1011, 604], [2716, 360, 839, 967, 779, 324, 954, 965, 1013, 900, 0, 867, 873, 946, 365, 770, 768, 895, 729, 508, 693, 782, 754, 659, 500, 929, 895, 366, 939, 25, 608], [2918, 865, 162, 230, 339, 839, 278, 364, 411, 185, 943, 0, 263, 325, 893, 331, 348, 293, 241, 768, 326, 381, 314, 850, 863, 328, 348, 626, 202, 945, 571], [2940, 819, 318, 329, 224, 793, 119, 172, 219, 341, 897, 285, 0, 107, 846, 216, 284, 101, 235, 722, 289, 317, 199, 741, 817, 136, 174, 580, 301, 899, 565], [3014, 911, 400, 403, 316, 885, 78, 155, 202, 423, 989, 367, 117, 0, 938, 307, 376, 84, 309, 814, 380, 409, 290, 833, 909, 119, 157, 672, 375, 991, 639], [2884, 280, 798, 925, 737, 337, 912, 924, 971, 858, 384, 825, 831, 905, 0, 728, 726, 853, 687, 521, 652, 740, 712, 672, 518, 888, 853, 379, 897, 386, 566], [2878, 695, 362, 377, 8, 668, 295, 345, 393, 385, 773, 329, 213, 306, 722, 0, 160, 275, 139, 598, 164, 192, 17, 617, 692, 309, 329, 456, 349, 775, 543], [2951, 748, 396, 411, 204, 722, 380, 430, 478, 419, 826, 363, 298, 391, 776, 196, 0, 359, 139, 651, 131, 60, 179, 670, 746, 394, 414, 509, 383, 828, 576], [2970, 867, 344, 359, 271, 840, 169, 84, 132, 367, 945, 311, 99, 92, 894, 263, 332, 0, 265, 770, 336, 364, 246, 789, 864, 48, 117, 628, 331, 947, 595], [2825, 696, 270, 284, 170, 670, 301, 333, 380, 293, 774, 236, 219, 294, 723, 161, 138, 262, 0, 599, 156, 170, 145, 618, 694, 297, 317, 457, 256, 776, 450], [3004, 492, 811, 826, 638, 379, 813, 823, 870, 834, 483, 778, 732, 804, 497, 629, 627, 752, 588, 0, 552, 641, 612, 440, 403, 787, 752, 126, 798, 485, 488], [2829, 646, 346, 360, 172, 620, 347, 398, 445, 368, 724, 312, 266, 359, 673, 164, 130, 327, 122, 549, 0, 113, 147, 568, 644, 362, 382, 407, 332, 726, 526], [2974, 733, 418, 433, 227, 706, 402, 453, 500, 441, 810, 385, 321, 414, 760, 218, 70, 382, 162, 635, 108, 0, 202, 654, 730, 417, 437, 493, 405, 812, 599], [2861, 678, 346, 360, 25, 652, 278, 328, 376, 368, 756, 312, 196, 290, 705, 17, 143, 258, 122, 581, 147, 176, 0, 600, 676, 292, 313, 439, 332, 758, 526], [2885, 625, 736, 856, 667, 494, 843, 852, 900, 796, 599, 808, 761, 834, 613, 659, 657, 782, 618, 424, 582, 670, 642, 0, 518, 816, 782, 282, 828, 601, 500], [2975, 318, 784, 947, 758, 254, 934, 944, 991, 845, 541, 899, 852, 925, 504, 750, 748, 873, 709, 449, 673, 762, 733, 561, 0, 908, 873, 307, 919, 543, 553], [3004, 901, 378, 393, 306, 875, 204, 65, 113, 401, 979, 345, 133, 126, 928, 298, 366, 68, 299, 804, 371, 399, 281, 823, 899, 0, 134, 662, 365, 981, 629], [3046, 866, 420, 435, 348, 843, 228, 173, 220, 443, 944, 387, 193, 186, 893, 340, 408, 120, 341, 769, 413, 441, 323, 788, 864, 137, 0, 627, 407, 946, 671], [2878, 366, 686, 700, 512, 253, 687, 697, 744, 708, 357, 652, 606, 678, 371, 504, 501, 626, 462, 142, 426, 515, 487, 315, 277, 661, 626, 0, 672, 359, 363], [3075, 994, 388, 223, 468, 968, 425, 493, 540, 410, 1073, 354, 379, 454, 1022, 460, 478, 422, 370, 898, 455, 510, 443, 916, 992, 457, 477, 755, 0, 1075, 700], [2708, 352, 831, 959, 771, 316, 946, 957, 1005, 892, 35, 859, 865, 938, 357, 762, 760, 887, 721, 500, 685, 774, 746, 651, 492, 921, 887, 358, 931, 0, 600], [2851, 572, 522, 650, 461, 550, 637, 648, 695, 582, 655, 550, 555, 629, 600, 453, 450, 577, 411, 519, 376, 464, 436, 520, 588, 612, 578, 376, 622, 657, 0]]}, "reference": {"optimum_s": 27661, "optimality": "best_found", "lower_bound_s": 25808, "floor_s": 21960, "solve_s": 36.18, "ffd_s": 30938, "stop_aware_best_s": 30408, "stop_aware_mean_s": 30926.8, "route_id": "RouteID_4929e984-b062-4f4f-9513-c1f7cefea730", "plans": {"optimum": [{"route": ["S14", "S01", "S24", "S05", "S10", "S29"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S28", "S03"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S02", "S09", "S11", "S26", "S25", "S07", "S08", "S17", "S13", "S06", "S12"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S23", "S27", "S19", "S30", "S20", "S21", "S16", "S22", "S15", "S04", "S18"], "parcels": []}], "ffd": [{"route": ["S21", "S15", "S06", "S03"], "parcels": ["P24"]}, {"route": ["S14", "S01", "S30", "S09", "S02"], "parcels": ["P01"]}, {"route": ["S11", "S28", "S26", "S07", "S08", "S17", "S12", "S22", "S16", "S20", "S23", "S29"], "parcels": ["P14"]}, {"route": ["S12", "S13", "S25", "S04", "S18", "S21", "S27", "S19", "S24", "S05", "S01", "S10"], "parcels": ["P02", "P13", "P23"]}], "stop_aware_best": [{"route": ["S24", "S30", "S22", "S25", "S08", "S28", "S03"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S20", "S21", "S18", "S12", "S07", "S26", "S19", "S27", "S05", "S10"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S02", "S09", "S11", "S06", "S13", "S17", "S16", "S23"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S29", "S14", "S01", "S15", "S04"], "parcels": []}]}}, "meta": {"route_id": "RouteID_4929e984-b062-4f4f-9513-c1f7cefea730", "split": "train", "stops": 30, "vans": 4, "tightness": 0.85, "station": "DCH4", "city": "DCH", "date": "2018-08-17", "seconds": 39.5, "stop_aware_best_reward": 0.5103, "optimality": "best_found"}}
{"id": "83e31c32-spread-n20-k3-t0.93-s0", "instance": {"stops": ["S01", "S02", "S03", "S04", "S05", "S06", "S07", "S08", "S09", "S10", "S11", "S12", "S13", "S14", "S15", "S16", "S17", "S18", "S19", "S20"], "parcels": [{"id": "P01", "stop": "S01", "volume_dl": 133}, {"id": "P02", "stop": "S02", "volume_dl": 57}, {"id": "P03", "stop": "S03", "volume_dl": 34}, {"id": "P04", "stop": "S03", "volume_dl": 57}, {"id": "P05", "stop": "S04", "volume_dl": 8}, {"id": "P06", "stop": "S04", "volume_dl": 38}, {"id": "P07", "stop": "S05", "volume_dl": 95}, {"id": "P08", "stop": "S05", "volume_dl": 5}, {"id": "P09", "stop": "S06", "volume_dl": 6}, {"id": "P10", "stop": "S07", "volume_dl": 21}, {"id": "P11", "stop": "S08", "volume_dl": 173}, {"id": "P12", "stop": "S09", "volume_dl": 41}, {"id": "P13", "stop": "S09", "volume_dl": 59}, {"id": "P14", "stop": "S09", "volume_dl": 59}, {"id": "P15", "stop": "S10", "volume_dl": 13}, {"id": "P16", "stop": "S10", "volume_dl": 2}, {"id": "P17", "stop": "S11", "volume_dl": 59}, {"id": "P18", "stop": "S12", "volume_dl": 79}, {"id": "P19", "stop": "S13", "volume_dl": 57}, {"id": "P20", "stop": "S13", "volume_dl": 4}, {"id": "P21", "stop": "S14", "volume_dl": 5}, {"id": "P22", "stop": "S15", "volume_dl": 95}, {"id": "P23", "stop": "S15", "volume_dl": 30}, {"id": "P24", "stop": "S15", "volume_dl": 26}, {"id": "P25", "stop": "S16", "volume_dl": 17}, {"id": "P26", "stop": "S17", "volume_dl": 95}, {"id": "P27", "stop": "S17", "volume_dl": 13}, {"id": "P28", "stop": "S18", "volume_dl": 79}, {"id": "P29", "stop": "S18", "volume_dl": 34}, {"id": "P30", "stop": "S19", "volume_dl": 322}, {"id": "P31", "stop": "S20", "volume_dl": 60}, {"id": "P32", "stop": "S20", "volume_dl": 157}, {"id": "P33", "stop": "S20", "volume_dl": 36}], "vans": 3, "capacity_dl": 708, "travel_s": [[0, 1253, 1427, 1193, 1439, 1081, 1378, 1366, 1427, 1404, 1318, 1304, 1350, 1240, 1470, 1337, 1367, 1401, 1449, 1371, 1334], [1227, 0, 315, 182, 427, 234, 198, 172, 262, 362, 93, 174, 288, 68, 428, 100, 362, 247, 437, 215, 119], [1342, 328, 0, 368, 215, 511, 144, 172, 67, 84, 260, 205, 120, 365, 111, 216, 224, 97, 205, 126, 218], [1352, 173, 315, 0, 432, 307, 216, 204, 265, 348, 178, 142, 315, 170, 379, 170, 205, 237, 444, 209, 180], [1362, 432, 173, 498, 0, 578, 268, 296, 224, 150, 387, 330, 188, 445, 142, 342, 348, 259, 10, 251, 336], [1102, 241, 511, 260, 576, 0, 382, 357, 497, 528, 306, 336, 490, 225, 611, 338, 437, 429, 586, 441, 330], [1368, 204, 143, 206, 264, 378, 0, 28, 93, 179, 164, 86, 144, 225, 235, 105, 155, 50, 274, 17, 171], [1312, 176, 169, 178, 289, 350, 25, 0, 130, 204, 136, 61, 149, 197, 260, 77, 180, 75, 299, 42, 156], [1388, 275, 87, 303, 268, 474, 98, 126, 0, 134, 234, 161, 163, 313, 164, 176, 172, 44, 258, 81, 236], [1320, 379, 65, 368, 188, 523, 180, 208, 116, 0, 314, 251, 82, 413, 66, 235, 260, 146, 178, 163, 259], [1235, 93, 251, 168, 378, 302, 169, 144, 273, 298, 0, 145, 223, 132, 363, 85, 349, 216, 388, 186, 62], [1310, 174, 200, 154, 320, 325, 79, 67, 150, 235, 133, 0, 186, 189, 314, 74, 186, 129, 330, 94, 127], [1282, 297, 114, 286, 177, 484, 146, 154, 151, 74, 232, 169, 0, 331, 140, 153, 238, 151, 187, 163, 178], [1258, 59, 349, 189, 458, 218, 232, 207, 311, 396, 132, 200, 321, 0, 462, 149, 376, 282, 468, 249, 153], [1348, 413, 131, 434, 122, 550, 246, 274, 182, 66, 373, 317, 148, 426, 0, 301, 296, 211, 112, 229, 326], [1273, 99, 198, 157, 337, 329, 97, 72, 162, 230, 84, 74, 156, 148, 296, 0, 252, 145, 347, 114, 82], [1495, 362, 215, 286, 385, 439, 158, 186, 163, 262, 361, 195, 247, 394, 281, 263, 0, 141, 375, 141, 307], [1385, 257, 96, 262, 253, 432, 53, 81, 44, 146, 217, 139, 161, 276, 185, 156, 151, 0, 262, 36, 216], [1372, 442, 183, 508, 10, 588, 278, 306, 234, 160, 397, 340, 198, 454, 132, 352, 358, 269, 0, 261, 338], [1351, 221, 126, 224, 246, 395, 17, 45, 76, 162, 181, 103, 127, 242, 218, 122, 137, 32, 256, 0, 186], [1226, 120, 195, 183, 322, 318, 162, 123, 217, 242, 68, 124, 167, 153, 308, 81, 294, 212, 332, 179, 0]]}, "reference": {"optimum_s": 9022, "optimality": "best_found", "lower_bound_s": 7837, "floor_s": 6549, "solve_s": 69.27, "ffd_s": 10393, "stop_aware_best_s": 9600, "stop_aware_mean_s": 9761.6, "route_id": "RouteID_83e31c32-08e9-4d45-82ee-93feda7bd57a", "plans": {"optimum": [{"route": ["S05", "S13", "S01", "S10", "S20"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S11", "S17", "S08", "S02", "S09", "S14", "S18", "S04", "S12"], "parcels": ["P27"]}, {"route": ["S03", "S16", "S17", "S19", "S06", "S07", "S15"], "parcels": ["P26"]}], "ffd": [{"route": ["S09", "S08", "S19", "S10", "S20"], "parcels": ["P12", "P32"]}, {"route": ["S05", "S01", "S20", "S15", "S17", "S12", "S09", "S18"], "parcels": ["P07", "P13", "P22", "P28", "P31"]}, {"route": ["S03", "S16", "S02", "S09", "S14", "S18", "S04", "S06", "S07", "S11", "S15", "S20", "S13", "S05"], "parcels": ["P08", "P14", "P23", "P24", "P29", "P33"]}], "stop_aware_best": [{"route": ["S05", "S03", "S16", "S08", "S12", "S07", "S11", "S15", "S10"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S13", "S01", "S06", "S17", "S20"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S19", "S02", "S09", "S14", "S18", "S04"], "parcels": []}]}}, "meta": {"route_id": "RouteID_83e31c32-08e9-4d45-82ee-93feda7bd57a", "split": "train", "stops": 20, "vans": 3, "tightness": 0.93, "station": "DLA8", "city": "DLA", "date": "2018-07-27", "seconds": 101.3, "stop_aware_best_reward": 0.7105, "optimality": "best_found"}}
{"id": "20630d1a-spread-n20-k3-t0.85-s0", "instance": {"stops": ["S01", "S02", "S03", "S04", "S05", "S06", "S07", "S08", "S09", "S10", "S11", "S12", "S13", "S14", "S15", "S16", "S17", "S18", "S19", "S20"], "parcels": [{"id": "P01", "stop": "S01", "volume_dl": 43}, {"id": "P02", "stop": "S02", "volume_dl": 34}, {"id": "P03", "stop": "S02", "volume_dl": 30}, {"id": "P04", "stop": "S03", "volume_dl": 133}, {"id": "P05", "stop": "S03", "volume_dl": 322}, {"id": "P06", "stop": "S04", "volume_dl": 133}, {"id": "P07", "stop": "S05", "volume_dl": 54}, {"id": "P08", "stop": "S06", "volume_dl": 12}, {"id": "P09", "stop": "S07", "volume_dl": 92}, {"id": "P10", "stop": "S07", "volume_dl": 26}, {"id": "P11", "stop": "S08", "volume_dl": 26}, {"id": "P12", "stop": "S08", "volume_dl": 57}, {"id": "P13", "stop": "S08", "volume_dl": 277}, {"id": "P14", "stop": "S09", "volume_dl": 259}, {"id": "P15", "stop": "S09", "volume_dl": 20}, {"id": "P16", "stop": "S10", "volume_dl": 57}, {"id": "P17", "stop": "S11", "volume_dl": 95}, {"id": "P18", "stop": "S12", "volume_dl": 518}, {"id": "P19", "stop": "S13", "volume_dl": 57}, {"id": "P20", "stop": "S13", "volume_dl": 368}, {"id": "P21", "stop": "S14", "volume_dl": 429}, {"id": "P22", "stop": "S15", "volume_dl": 12}, {"id": "P23", "stop": "S15", "volume_dl": 179}, {"id": "P24", "stop": "S15", "volume_dl": 133}, {"id": "P25", "stop": "S16", "volume_dl": 18}, {"id": "P26", "stop": "S17", "volume_dl": 58}, {"id": "P27", "stop": "S18", "volume_dl": 1414}, {"id": "P28", "stop": "S19", "volume_dl": 92}, {"id": "P29", "stop": "S19", "volume_dl": 60}, {"id": "P30", "stop": "S20", "volume_dl": 45}], "vans": 3, "capacity_dl": 1981, "travel_s": [[0, 1104, 1288, 1236, 1387, 1413, 1154, 1179, 1394, 1248, 1051, 1136, 1203, 1205, 1277, 1176, 1250, 1311, 1209, 1431, 1302], [1104, 0, 206, 232, 410, 331, 109, 171, 378, 166, 88, 104, 319, 289, 195, 99, 246, 282, 347, 447, 308], [1266, 226, 0, 97, 481, 143, 293, 280, 449, 72, 265, 219, 171, 141, 37, 232, 365, 353, 159, 521, 372], [1196, 255, 97, 0, 486, 237, 322, 285, 454, 121, 294, 224, 170, 238, 132, 243, 370, 358, 212, 522, 377], [1337, 412, 490, 501, 0, 616, 414, 362, 148, 451, 368, 329, 604, 587, 480, 453, 399, 212, 632, 150, 260], [1259, 320, 114, 212, 595, 0, 387, 406, 564, 139, 359, 354, 214, 220, 96, 347, 480, 468, 160, 586, 487], [1110, 92, 276, 302, 417, 401, 0, 101, 424, 236, 95, 143, 389, 359, 265, 169, 176, 299, 417, 461, 247], [1115, 115, 285, 292, 400, 434, 89, 0, 332, 267, 99, 60, 422, 390, 298, 193, 111, 216, 449, 444, 154], [1353, 381, 459, 470, 168, 585, 384, 330, 0, 419, 338, 298, 573, 543, 449, 422, 321, 159, 601, 223, 207], [1245, 185, 78, 117, 448, 189, 252, 270, 417, 0, 224, 219, 206, 123, 53, 240, 360, 320, 205, 449, 340], [1016, 53, 237, 263, 387, 362, 104, 128, 356, 197, 0, 85, 350, 320, 226, 126, 199, 260, 378, 424, 236], [1128, 144, 222, 234, 340, 374, 152, 62, 326, 209, 112, 0, 362, 332, 238, 186, 151, 208, 390, 377, 216], [1125, 355, 167, 184, 618, 216, 422, 441, 586, 202, 394, 389, 0, 248, 204, 412, 530, 490, 100, 650, 509], [1165, 337, 147, 244, 600, 225, 404, 422, 568, 153, 376, 371, 220, 0, 147, 380, 512, 472, 188, 549, 492], [1276, 224, 28, 126, 487, 136, 291, 310, 455, 43, 263, 258, 206, 154, 0, 261, 399, 359, 152, 490, 379], [1111, 73, 226, 238, 394, 337, 143, 158, 363, 171, 96, 92, 325, 295, 201, 0, 234, 267, 353, 431, 313], [1186, 186, 371, 382, 402, 516, 161, 88, 343, 351, 170, 149, 504, 474, 380, 266, 0, 226, 532, 457, 206], [1262, 290, 368, 379, 243, 494, 292, 240, 184, 329, 247, 207, 482, 452, 358, 331, 208, 0, 510, 298, 94], [1099, 380, 175, 222, 656, 161, 447, 467, 624, 199, 419, 415, 81, 193, 156, 434, 540, 528, 0, 647, 547], [1389, 451, 529, 540, 140, 656, 454, 400, 224, 508, 408, 369, 678, 500, 520, 493, 438, 288, 646, 0, 336], [1212, 211, 384, 395, 277, 531, 242, 164, 218, 366, 196, 174, 519, 489, 395, 348, 174, 100, 546, 332, 0]]}, "reference": {"optimum_s": 8979, "optimality": "best_found", "lower_bound_s": 7767, "floor_s": 6201, "solve_s": 33.12, "ffd_s": 10846, "stop_aware_best_s": 10040, "stop_aware_mean_s": 10138.8, "route_id": "RouteID_20630d1a-2ecb-4b41-8c96-1e29e4d7b7d9", "plans": {"optimum": [{"route": ["S10", "S01", "S15", "S11", "S19", "S04", "S08", "S17", "S20", "S16", "S07", "S06"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S03", "S02", "S05", "S14", "S09", "S13"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S12", "S18"], "parcels": []}], "ffd": [{"route": ["S18", "S12", "S20"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S13", "S14", "S09", "S03", "S15", "S08", "S06"], "parcels": ["P13", "P14", "P20", "P23"]}, {"route": ["S13", "S05", "S02", "S09", "S19", "S04", "S08", "S17", "S16", "S07", "S11", "S01", "S15", "S10"], "parcels": ["P11", "P12", "P15", "P19", "P22", "P24"]}], "stop_aware_best": [{"route": ["S11", "S06", "S01", "S05", "S18"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S10", "S15", "S19", "S04", "S09", "S03", "S12"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S13", "S14", "S02", "S08", "S17", "S20", "S16", "S07"], "parcels": []}]}}, "meta": {"route_id": "RouteID_20630d1a-2ecb-4b41-8c96-1e29e4d7b7d9", "split": "train", "stops": 20, "vans": 3, "tightness": 0.85, "station": "DBO2", "city": "DBO", "date": "2018-08-01", "seconds": 74.0, "stop_aware_best_reward": 0.5827, "optimality": "best_found"}}
{"id": "7e992840-spread-n25-k3-t0.92-s0", "instance": {"stops": ["S01", "S02", "S03", "S04", "S05", "S06", "S07", "S08", "S09", "S10", "S11", "S12", "S13", "S14", "S15", "S16", "S17", "S18", "S19", "S20", "S21", "S22", "S23", "S24", "S25"], "parcels": [{"id": "P01", "stop": "S01", "volume_dl": 57}, {"id": "P02", "stop": "S02", "volume_dl": 576}, {"id": "P03", "stop": "S02", "volume_dl": 104}, {"id": "P04", "stop": "S03", "volume_dl": 63}, {"id": "P05", "stop": "S04", "volume_dl": 157}, {"id": "P06", "stop": "S05", "volume_dl": 141}, {"id": "P07", "stop": "S05", "volume_dl": 329}, {"id": "P08", "stop": "S06", "volume_dl": 133}, {"id": "P09", "stop": "S06", "volume_dl": 34}, {"id": "P10", "stop": "S07", "volume_dl": 226}, {"id": "P11", "stop": "S08", "volume_dl": 55}, {"id": "P12", "stop": "S08", "volume_dl": 44}, {"id": "P13", "stop": "S09", "volume_dl": 6}, {"id": "P14", "stop": "S09", "volume_dl": 104}, {"id": "P15", "stop": "S10", "volume_dl": 1907}, {"id": "P16", "stop": "S11", "volume_dl": 20}, {"id": "P17", "stop": "S12", "volume_dl": 30}, {"id": "P18", "stop": "S13", "volume_dl": 57}, {"id": "P19", "stop": "S14", "volume_dl": 157}, {"id": "P20", "stop": "S15", "volume_dl": 104}, {"id": "P21", "stop": "S15", "volume_dl": 242}, {"id": "P22", "stop": "S15", "volume_dl": 95}, {"id": "P23", "stop": "S16", "volume_dl": 43}, {"id": "P24", "stop": "S17", "volume_dl": 95}, {"id": "P25", "stop": "S17", "volume_dl": 23}, {"id": "P26", "stop": "S18", "volume_dl": 157}, {"id": "P27", "stop": "S19", "volume_dl": 242}, {"id": "P28", "stop": "S20", "volume_dl": 39}, {"id": "P29", "stop": "S21", "volume_dl": 45}, {"id": "P30", "stop": "S22", "volume_dl": 840}, {"id": "P31", "stop": "S23", "volume_dl": 104}, {"id": "P32", "stop": "S24", "volume_dl": 126}, {"id": "P33", "stop": "S25", "volume_dl": 13}], "vans": 3, "capacity_dl": 2308, "travel_s": [[0, 456, 1107, 1090, 1108, 1056, 573, 888, 919, 678, 764, 731, 1115, 891, 510, 894, 843, 903, 1138, 1183, 942, 1065, 455, 1141, 1031, 851], [512, 0, 651, 846, 947, 652, 188, 675, 463, 442, 395, 405, 712, 655, 198, 396, 345, 670, 735, 727, 443, 609, 144, 685, 857, 353], [1171, 659, 0, 423, 370, 228, 743, 361, 374, 513, 638, 688, 136, 673, 856, 409, 369, 687, 346, 150, 393, 341, 804, 371, 543, 460], [1130, 823, 424, 0, 312, 299, 854, 213, 538, 665, 790, 814, 359, 744, 946, 562, 521, 731, 272, 286, 545, 360, 890, 273, 247, 612], [1152, 914, 354, 316, 0, 381, 1031, 437, 674, 784, 969, 837, 290, 766, 968, 710, 669, 753, 392, 216, 693, 495, 912, 496, 484, 760], [1100, 664, 222, 308, 372, 0, 696, 183, 379, 507, 631, 682, 87, 667, 810, 403, 362, 701, 137, 152, 387, 161, 809, 193, 365, 453], [655, 224, 707, 846, 1003, 653, 0, 676, 398, 395, 340, 358, 713, 608, 204, 344, 298, 622, 736, 783, 396, 610, 288, 686, 858, 306], [916, 678, 350, 203, 412, 168, 795, 0, 406, 548, 659, 601, 228, 530, 732, 431, 390, 517, 250, 292, 414, 229, 676, 134, 169, 481], [966, 455, 380, 574, 676, 381, 402, 404, 0, 434, 338, 347, 441, 594, 516, 146, 158, 608, 464, 456, 257, 338, 600, 414, 586, 167], [807, 475, 504, 684, 797, 491, 419, 514, 384, 0, 307, 175, 550, 213, 536, 333, 287, 228, 573, 577, 386, 447, 619, 523, 695, 295], [834, 402, 624, 807, 920, 614, 308, 636, 359, 305, 0, 268, 673, 518, 361, 309, 258, 532, 696, 700, 357, 570, 467, 646, 818, 266], [931, 419, 598, 780, 893, 587, 366, 610, 332, 176, 252, 0, 647, 390, 480, 282, 231, 404, 670, 673, 330, 543, 564, 619, 792, 239], [1144, 709, 135, 338, 285, 91, 740, 228, 423, 551, 676, 726, 0, 711, 854, 448, 407, 745, 210, 65, 431, 205, 854, 237, 409, 498], [1018, 686, 640, 822, 828, 629, 634, 652, 599, 212, 519, 387, 689, 0, 747, 508, 467, 13, 712, 715, 492, 585, 831, 661, 751, 506], [590, 159, 810, 958, 1106, 765, 182, 788, 510, 506, 360, 470, 825, 720, 0, 460, 409, 734, 847, 886, 508, 721, 223, 797, 969, 417], [947, 436, 426, 608, 721, 415, 379, 438, 160, 377, 318, 328, 475, 538, 496, 0, 45, 553, 498, 501, 158, 372, 580, 448, 620, 140], [897, 385, 365, 548, 661, 355, 332, 378, 170, 317, 268, 278, 414, 477, 446, 36, 0, 491, 437, 441, 98, 311, 530, 387, 559, 90], [1032, 700, 653, 836, 814, 643, 647, 666, 613, 225, 532, 400, 702, 13, 761, 521, 481, 0, 725, 729, 505, 599, 845, 675, 738, 520], [1184, 749, 343, 232, 369, 138, 780, 268, 464, 591, 716, 766, 208, 751, 894, 488, 447, 785, 0, 211, 471, 227, 894, 277, 401, 538], [1254, 743, 138, 273, 220, 165, 826, 301, 457, 596, 721, 772, 74, 757, 940, 494, 452, 771, 221, 0, 477, 279, 887, 311, 442, 543], [995, 483, 368, 551, 664, 358, 430, 381, 267, 320, 366, 375, 418, 480, 544, 138, 97, 495, 440, 444, 0, 314, 628, 390, 562, 187], [1106, 595, 253, 387, 497, 152, 626, 218, 309, 437, 562, 612, 212, 597, 740, 334, 293, 611, 217, 277, 317, 0, 739, 228, 400, 384], [383, 233, 884, 907, 924, 886, 350, 704, 696, 494, 541, 547, 946, 708, 288, 629, 578, 720, 968, 960, 676, 842, 0, 918, 847, 586], [1045, 716, 374, 290, 499, 192, 748, 129, 431, 558, 683, 730, 252, 659, 861, 455, 414, 646, 274, 317, 438, 253, 806, 0, 301, 505], [1062, 824, 502, 238, 461, 320, 875, 152, 558, 686, 811, 747, 380, 676, 878, 583, 542, 664, 402, 444, 566, 381, 822, 286, 0, 633], [890, 378, 421, 603, 716, 410, 325, 433, 162, 372, 261, 270, 470, 532, 439, 106, 54, 547, 493, 496, 153, 366, 523, 442, 615, 0]]}, "reference": {"optimum_s": 8602, "optimality": "best_found", "lower_bound_s": 5690, "floor_s": 2514, "solve_s": 55.2, "ffd_s": 11637, "stop_aware_best_s": 10373, "stop_aware_mean_s": 10719.6, "route_id": "RouteID_7e992840-21cc-4cbe-919b-ea2263cd69a6", "plans": {"optimum": [{"route": ["S17", "S13", "S09", "S11", "S25", "S20", "S16", "S15", "S08", "S01", "S22"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S24", "S03", "S04", "S19", "S02", "S12", "S05", "S18", "S21", "S23", "S07"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S14", "S10", "S06"], "parcels": []}], "ffd": [{"route": ["S10", "S09", "S05", "S03"], "parcels": ["P07", "P13"]}, {"route": ["S17", "S07", "S04", "S19", "S02", "S15", "S22"], "parcels": ["P02", "P21", "P25"]}, {"route": ["S14", "S06", "S25", "S08", "S15", "S16", "S20", "S02", "S12", "S05", "S18", "S21", "S23", "S24", "S17", "S13", "S09", "S11", "S01"], "parcels": ["P03", "P06", "P14", "P20", "P22", "P24"]}], "stop_aware_best": [{"route": ["S10", "S23", "S03", "S07"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S17", "S13", "S09", "S11", "S08", "S15", "S16", "S20", "S21", "S18", "S12", "S04", "S22"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S24", "S05", "S19", "S02", "S25", "S06", "S14", "S01"], "parcels": []}]}}, "meta": {"route_id": "RouteID_7e992840-21cc-4cbe-919b-ea2263cd69a6", "split": "train", "stops": 25, "vans": 3, "tightness": 0.92, "station": "DBO3", "city": "DBO", "date": "2018-08-14", "seconds": 89.5, "stop_aware_best_reward": 0.6513, "optimality": "best_found"}}
{"id": "04982ba3-spread-n30-k4-t0.92-s0", "instance": {"stops": ["S01", "S02", "S03", "S04", "S05", "S06", "S07", "S08", "S09", "S10", "S11", "S12", "S13", "S14", "S15", "S16", "S17", "S18", "S19", "S20", "S21", "S22", "S23", "S24", "S25", "S26", "S27", "S28", "S29", "S30"], "parcels": [{"id": "P01", "stop": "S01", "volume_dl": 104}, {"id": "P02", "stop": "S01", "volume_dl": 157}, {"id": "P03", "stop": "S02", "volume_dl": 63}, {"id": "P04", "stop": "S02", "volume_dl": 133}, {"id": "P05", "stop": "S02", "volume_dl": 30}, {"id": "P06", "stop": "S03", "volume_dl": 104}, {"id": "P07", "stop": "S03", "volume_dl": 21}, {"id": "P08", "stop": "S04", "volume_dl": 22}, {"id": "P09", "stop": "S05", "volume_dl": 37}, {"id": "P10", "stop": "S06", "volume_dl": 43}, {"id": "P11", "stop": "S07", "volume_dl": 92}, {"id": "P12", "stop": "S08", "volume_dl": 13}, {"id": "P13", "stop": "S08", "volume_dl": 840}, {"id": "P14", "stop": "S08", "volume_dl": 322}, {"id": "P15", "stop": "S08", "volume_dl": 11}, {"id": "P16", "stop": "S08", "volume_dl": 63}, {"id": "P17", "stop": "S08", "volume_dl": 133}, {"id": "P18", "stop": "S09", "volume_dl": 148}, {"id": "P19", "stop": "S10", "volume_dl": 14}, {"id": "P20", "stop": "S11", "volume_dl": 34}, {"id": "P21", "stop": "S11", "volume_dl": 133}, {"id": "P22", "stop": "S11", "volume_dl": 57}, {"id": "P23", "stop": "S12", "volume_dl": 59}, {"id": "P24", "stop": "S12", "volume_dl": 95}, {"id": "P25", "stop": "S12", "volume_dl": 26}, {"id": "P26", "stop": "S12", "volume_dl": 9}, {"id": "P27", "stop": "S13", "volume_dl": 43}, {"id": "P28", "stop": "S14", "volume_dl": 133}, {"id": "P29", "stop": "S15", "volume_dl": 34}, {"id": "P30", "stop": "S16", "volume_dl": 37}, {"id": "P31", "stop": "S16", "volume_dl": 37}, {"id": "P32", "stop": "S17", "volume_dl": 43}, {"id": "P33", "stop": "S18", "volume_dl": 27}, {"id": "P34", "stop": "S18", "volume_dl": 9}, {"id": "P35", "stop": "S19", "volume_dl": 16}, {"id": "P36", "stop": "S19", "volume_dl": 57}, {"id": "P37", "stop": "S19", "volume_dl": 8}, {"id": "P38", "stop": "S20", "volume_dl": 20}, {"id": "P39", "stop": "S21", "volume_dl": 30}, {"id": "P40", "stop": "S21", "volume_dl": 57}, {"id": "P41", "stop": "S22", "volume_dl": 13}, {"id": "P42", "stop": "S22", "volume_dl": 57}, {"id": "P43", "stop": "S23", "volume_dl": 45}, {"id": "P44", "stop": "S24", "volume_dl": 242}, {"id": "P45", "stop": "S25", "volume_dl": 133}, {"id": "P46", "stop": "S26", "volume_dl": 30}, {"id": "P47", "stop": "S27", "volume_dl": 104}, {"id": "P48", "stop": "S28", "volume_dl": 157}, {"id": "P49", "stop": "S29", "volume_dl": 26}, {"id": "P50", "stop": "S29", "volume_dl": 44}, {"id": "P51", "stop": "S29", "volume_dl": 134}, {"id": "P52", "stop": "S29", "volume_dl": 542}, {"id": "P53", "stop": "S29", "volume_dl": 15}, {"id": "P54", "stop": "S30", "volume_dl": 322}], "vans": 4, "capacity_dl": 1408, "travel_s": [[0, 1458, 1335, 1224, 1312, 1282, 1317, 1370, 1433, 1445, 1516, 1222, 1329, 1361, 1414, 1348, 1314, 1502, 1398, 1355, 1396, 1507, 1518, 1476, 1381, 1254, 1490, 1138, 1404, 1247, 1107], [1366, 0, 579, 408, 382, 477, 447, 538, 494, 63, 396, 631, 619, 219, 295, 509, 632, 119, 445, 241, 509, 124, 136, 94, 221, 335, 108, 689, 118, 330, 623], [1183, 588, 0, 296, 495, 331, 366, 190, 356, 575, 374, 122, 40, 444, 271, 231, 54, 632, 321, 558, 216, 637, 648, 606, 418, 437, 620, 180, 549, 316, 239], [1090, 416, 305, 0, 240, 105, 140, 199, 267, 407, 340, 289, 305, 289, 357, 170, 321, 464, 228, 283, 171, 470, 480, 438, 310, 182, 453, 350, 317, 156, 410], [1231, 404, 490, 273, 0, 342, 311, 384, 360, 390, 434, 502, 496, 306, 400, 355, 506, 447, 326, 300, 356, 452, 464, 422, 326, 121, 436, 535, 350, 174, 594], [1084, 487, 344, 94, 307, 0, 70, 238, 305, 474, 378, 356, 348, 356, 395, 209, 359, 530, 270, 350, 210, 536, 547, 505, 376, 249, 519, 389, 384, 195, 448], [1084, 512, 368, 119, 332, 81, 0, 263, 330, 499, 403, 380, 373, 381, 420, 234, 384, 555, 295, 375, 234, 560, 572, 530, 401, 274, 544, 414, 408, 220, 473], [1252, 582, 203, 188, 382, 218, 253, 0, 243, 569, 317, 215, 209, 451, 333, 118, 218, 625, 208, 445, 103, 630, 642, 600, 459, 324, 614, 248, 478, 205, 307], [1321, 495, 321, 253, 355, 282, 317, 215, 0, 482, 182, 309, 326, 422, 199, 187, 337, 539, 74, 416, 187, 544, 556, 514, 325, 298, 528, 366, 456, 177, 426], [1355, 85, 568, 398, 371, 466, 436, 527, 483, 0, 386, 645, 608, 208, 284, 498, 622, 104, 434, 231, 499, 103, 115, 78, 210, 324, 87, 678, 107, 317, 613], [1419, 423, 420, 351, 453, 381, 416, 314, 187, 410, 0, 432, 426, 349, 127, 285, 435, 466, 138, 410, 286, 472, 483, 441, 252, 396, 455, 465, 383, 276, 455], [1060, 682, 142, 283, 482, 318, 353, 177, 343, 669, 417, 0, 133, 545, 371, 218, 120, 725, 308, 545, 203, 730, 742, 700, 518, 424, 714, 57, 578, 304, 116], [1184, 618, 32, 312, 509, 345, 380, 204, 370, 605, 404, 124, 0, 474, 301, 246, 54, 662, 338, 572, 232, 669, 680, 636, 450, 451, 650, 179, 579, 331, 240], [1274, 244, 438, 316, 326, 385, 354, 445, 422, 231, 322, 562, 480, 0, 220, 416, 492, 287, 387, 242, 417, 293, 304, 262, 147, 268, 276, 548, 204, 236, 483], [1287, 317, 284, 364, 417, 393, 446, 326, 200, 304, 103, 407, 324, 223, 0, 298, 338, 361, 151, 337, 298, 366, 377, 335, 147, 359, 350, 394, 278, 289, 328], [1231, 561, 212, 168, 361, 197, 232, 106, 222, 548, 296, 224, 217, 430, 312, 0, 228, 604, 187, 424, 82, 610, 621, 579, 438, 303, 593, 258, 458, 184, 317], [1170, 632, 44, 322, 521, 357, 392, 216, 382, 619, 417, 109, 62, 488, 314, 257, 0, 675, 347, 583, 242, 680, 692, 650, 461, 463, 664, 166, 592, 342, 226], [1395, 124, 607, 437, 411, 506, 475, 566, 522, 106, 425, 684, 650, 248, 323, 537, 661, 0, 474, 270, 538, 108, 97, 47, 250, 363, 123, 717, 147, 356, 652], [1298, 458, 298, 224, 332, 259, 294, 192, 66, 445, 145, 286, 304, 384, 162, 163, 314, 501, 0, 393, 164, 507, 518, 476, 287, 274, 490, 343, 418, 153, 402], [1240, 244, 518, 283, 314, 351, 321, 412, 388, 231, 382, 505, 522, 195, 313, 383, 533, 288, 353, 0, 384, 294, 304, 262, 215, 266, 277, 563, 141, 204, 592], [1230, 560, 235, 167, 360, 197, 232, 130, 222, 547, 295, 247, 242, 430, 312, 101, 251, 604, 187, 423, 0, 609, 621, 578, 438, 303, 593, 281, 457, 183, 340], [1393, 122, 605, 430, 409, 504, 474, 564, 520, 99, 423, 659, 649, 246, 322, 535, 659, 118, 473, 269, 536, 0, 10, 116, 248, 361, 14, 715, 145, 357, 650], [1404, 134, 617, 441, 420, 515, 485, 575, 532, 110, 434, 669, 657, 257, 333, 547, 670, 106, 483, 279, 547, 10, 0, 111, 259, 373, 26, 726, 156, 368, 661], [1379, 108, 591, 421, 394, 490, 459, 550, 506, 90, 409, 668, 633, 232, 307, 521, 645, 36, 457, 254, 522, 120, 109, 0, 234, 347, 134, 701, 130, 340, 636], [1290, 242, 409, 332, 342, 401, 371, 462, 324, 229, 227, 533, 449, 163, 125, 433, 463, 286, 276, 259, 433, 291, 303, 260, 0, 285, 275, 519, 203, 252, 454], [1184, 322, 443, 315, 109, 295, 265, 337, 314, 308, 387, 455, 450, 260, 353, 308, 459, 365, 279, 253, 309, 370, 382, 340, 280, 0, 354, 488, 218, 128, 548], [1378, 108, 591, 421, 394, 489, 459, 550, 506, 84, 408, 668, 633, 231, 307, 521, 644, 126, 457, 254, 522, 16, 28, 101, 233, 347, 0, 701, 130, 340, 636], [1003, 683, 198, 345, 538, 374, 409, 233, 399, 670, 469, 85, 189, 540, 366, 275, 176, 727, 364, 601, 259, 732, 743, 701, 513, 480, 716, 0, 634, 361, 59], [1292, 103, 544, 342, 264, 400, 373, 494, 469, 90, 362, 612, 604, 185, 261, 465, 616, 147, 434, 123, 466, 152, 164, 121, 187, 217, 136, 645, 0, 283, 589], [1144, 343, 313, 186, 178, 198, 225, 207, 184, 330, 257, 301, 318, 246, 274, 178, 329, 386, 149, 239, 179, 393, 403, 361, 266, 120, 375, 358, 289, 0, 418], [957, 623, 229, 409, 602, 438, 473, 297, 464, 610, 408, 149, 269, 479, 306, 339, 241, 666, 429, 643, 323, 672, 683, 641, 452, 544, 655, 64, 584, 425, 0]]}, "reference": {"optimum_s": 12996, "optimality": "best_found", "lower_bound_s": 10386, "floor_s": 8256, "solve_s": 46.25, "ffd_s": 15652, "stop_aware_best_s": 14631, "stop_aware_mean_s": 14771.6, "route_id": "RouteID_04982ba3-19ee-4a8e-86f4-942a3ad2c4de", "plans": {"optimum": [{"route": ["S13", "S01", "S09", "S23", "S17", "S22", "S21", "S26", "S28", "S19", "S06", "S05"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S25", "S04", "S29", "S15", "S07", "S30"], "parcels": ["P49", "P50", "P51", "P52"]}, {"route": ["S24", "S14", "S10", "S18", "S08", "S12", "S02", "S16", "S11", "S27"], "parcels": ["P15", "P17"]}, {"route": ["S29", "S08", "S20", "S03"], "parcels": ["P12", "P13", "P14", "P16", "P53"]}], "ffd": [{"route": ["S29", "S08", "S12"], "parcels": ["P13", "P25", "P52"]}, {"route": ["S28", "S01", "S09", "S24", "S08", "S12", "S30"], "parcels": ["P02", "P14", "P23"]}, {"route": ["S03", "S29", "S25", "S01", "S23", "S14", "S08", "S07", "S12", "S02", "S11", "S27"], "parcels": ["P01", "P03", "P04", "P06", "P17", "P21", "P24", "P51"]}, {"route": ["S03", "S05", "S06", "S29", "S04", "S19", "S17", "S22", "S21", "S26", "S13", "S10", "S18", "S08", "S20", "S15", "S12", "S02", "S16", "S11"], "parcels": ["P05", "P07", "P12", "P15", "P16", "P20", "P22", "P26", "P49", "P50", "P53"]}], "stop_aware_best": [{"route": ["S08"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S28", "S09", "S17", "S21", "S26", "S10", "S18", "S20", "S07", "S16", "S11", "S30"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S05", "S06", "S03", "S25", "S01", "S22", "S13", "S24", "S14", "S15", "S27"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S19", "S23", "S04", "S29", "S12", "S02"], "parcels": []}]}}, "meta": {"route_id": "RouteID_04982ba3-19ee-4a8e-86f4-942a3ad2c4de", "split": "train", "stops": 30, "vans": 4, "tightness": 0.92, "station": "DSE4", "city": "DSE", "date": "2018-08-03", "seconds": 108.0, "stop_aware_best_reward": 0.6071, "optimality": "best_found"}}
{"id": "deb986b1-spread-n25-k3-t0.88-s0", "instance": {"stops": ["S01", "S02", "S03", "S04", "S05", "S06", "S07", "S08", "S09", "S10", "S11", "S12", "S13", "S14", "S15", "S16", "S17", "S18", "S19", "S20", "S21", "S22", "S23", "S24", "S25"], "parcels": [{"id": "P01", "stop": "S01", "volume_dl": 25}, {"id": "P02", "stop": "S02", "volume_dl": 157}, {"id": "P03", "stop": "S03", "volume_dl": 104}, {"id": "P04", "stop": "S04", "volume_dl": 779}, {"id": "P05", "stop": "S05", "volume_dl": 18}, {"id": "P06", "stop": "S06", "volume_dl": 49}, {"id": "P07", "stop": "S07", "volume_dl": 62}, {"id": "P08", "stop": "S07", "volume_dl": 63}, {"id": "P09", "stop": "S08", "volume_dl": 429}, {"id": "P10", "stop": "S08", "volume_dl": 59}, {"id": "P11", "stop": "S09", "volume_dl": 8}, {"id": "P12", "stop": "S10", "volume_dl": 34}, {"id": "P13", "stop": "S11", "volume_dl": 179}, {"id": "P14", "stop": "S12", "volume_dl": 9}, {"id": "P15", "stop": "S13", "volume_dl": 34}, {"id": "P16", "stop": "S13", "volume_dl": 92}, {"id": "P17", "stop": "S14", "volume_dl": 179}, {"id": "P18", "stop": "S15", "volume_dl": 56}, {"id": "P19", "stop": "S15", "volume_dl": 25}, {"id": "P20", "stop": "S15", "volume_dl": 37}, {"id": "P21", "stop": "S16", "volume_dl": 29}, {"id": "P22", "stop": "S17", "volume_dl": 36}, {"id": "P23", "stop": "S18", "volume_dl": 57}, {"id": "P24", "stop": "S19", "volume_dl": 289}, {"id": "P25", "stop": "S19", "volume_dl": 1072}, {"id": "P26", "stop": "S20", "volume_dl": 42}, {"id": "P27", "stop": "S20", "volume_dl": 31}, {"id": "P28", "stop": "S20", "volume_dl": 26}, {"id": "P29", "stop": "S21", "volume_dl": 43}, {"id": "P30", "stop": "S22", "volume_dl": 36}, {"id": "P31", "stop": "S23", "volume_dl": 429}, {"id": "P32", "stop": "S24", "volume_dl": 157}, {"id": "P33", "stop": "S25", "volume_dl": 259}], "vans": 3, "capacity_dl": 1859, "travel_s": [[0, 1455, 1198, 1354, 1282, 1271, 1218, 1262, 1395, 1467, 1371, 1396, 1322, 1489, 1754, 1244, 1414, 1426, 1753, 1208, 1273, 1502, 1142, 1636, 1279, 1170], [1480, 0, 448, 442, 345, 408, 274, 454, 484, 210, 403, 97, 287, 364, 590, 283, 337, 344, 329, 460, 288, 142, 453, 441, 555, 338], [1238, 444, 0, 346, 156, 309, 252, 358, 388, 457, 409, 386, 197, 616, 880, 261, 453, 416, 662, 104, 147, 492, 97, 763, 299, 209], [1322, 429, 336, 0, 372, 221, 192, 175, 221, 441, 321, 370, 315, 528, 792, 218, 365, 400, 646, 346, 316, 476, 280, 675, 397, 251], [1326, 344, 156, 405, 0, 396, 236, 416, 446, 356, 371, 285, 170, 596, 822, 246, 415, 315, 561, 191, 54, 392, 184, 672, 386, 296], [1270, 410, 284, 210, 353, 0, 202, 262, 292, 422, 152, 351, 296, 425, 689, 146, 195, 381, 565, 294, 297, 517, 228, 572, 345, 199], [1236, 286, 248, 198, 230, 179, 0, 210, 240, 299, 279, 228, 172, 486, 750, 76, 323, 258, 504, 260, 174, 334, 194, 633, 311, 116], [1264, 464, 349, 208, 408, 298, 228, 0, 260, 476, 398, 406, 350, 605, 869, 254, 442, 436, 681, 360, 351, 512, 293, 752, 410, 293], [1315, 444, 329, 225, 388, 278, 207, 254, 0, 456, 378, 386, 330, 584, 849, 234, 422, 416, 661, 339, 331, 492, 273, 732, 390, 273], [1502, 199, 470, 464, 366, 429, 295, 475, 505, 0, 430, 141, 308, 451, 677, 304, 424, 365, 416, 481, 309, 247, 474, 528, 576, 360], [1361, 399, 383, 300, 344, 122, 193, 373, 403, 413, 0, 364, 287, 516, 780, 137, 56, 372, 475, 395, 288, 427, 319, 587, 436, 262], [1428, 83, 397, 391, 293, 356, 222, 402, 432, 158, 357, 0, 235, 336, 562, 231, 308, 292, 300, 408, 236, 131, 401, 412, 503, 287], [1349, 309, 202, 345, 173, 326, 176, 356, 386, 321, 336, 250, 0, 561, 787, 186, 380, 280, 526, 214, 116, 356, 207, 637, 409, 319], [1509, 336, 652, 544, 549, 534, 478, 658, 688, 414, 466, 301, 491, 0, 386, 487, 400, 548, 382, 664, 492, 364, 563, 237, 679, 542], [1751, 576, 861, 787, 788, 773, 717, 838, 869, 653, 705, 540, 731, 380, 0, 727, 639, 668, 643, 871, 732, 604, 805, 181, 922, 782], [1263, 296, 258, 225, 240, 158, 56, 236, 266, 308, 158, 238, 182, 512, 777, 0, 202, 268, 513, 269, 183, 344, 262, 660, 338, 125], [1402, 343, 424, 341, 385, 163, 234, 414, 444, 421, 66, 308, 328, 556, 680, 178, 0, 413, 419, 436, 329, 371, 360, 531, 477, 303], [1446, 318, 414, 408, 310, 374, 239, 419, 449, 330, 374, 260, 253, 570, 796, 249, 418, 0, 374, 426, 254, 366, 418, 647, 521, 304], [1692, 344, 660, 654, 556, 541, 486, 665, 696, 422, 474, 309, 499, 406, 631, 495, 407, 361, 0, 672, 500, 372, 665, 482, 767, 550], [1231, 478, 106, 339, 190, 302, 249, 350, 380, 491, 402, 420, 231, 608, 873, 276, 446, 450, 696, 0, 181, 526, 66, 756, 292, 202], [1307, 297, 161, 358, 64, 324, 190, 370, 400, 309, 324, 239, 124, 550, 775, 199, 368, 269, 514, 172, 0, 345, 165, 626, 368, 277], [1510, 144, 478, 472, 374, 438, 303, 483, 513, 239, 438, 126, 316, 414, 640, 313, 386, 374, 379, 490, 318, 0, 482, 490, 585, 368], [1165, 420, 99, 273, 183, 236, 183, 284, 314, 432, 336, 361, 224, 542, 807, 209, 380, 391, 637, 66, 174, 468, 0, 690, 226, 135], [1652, 458, 775, 687, 671, 656, 600, 739, 769, 536, 588, 423, 613, 263, 193, 610, 522, 643, 618, 786, 614, 486, 706, 0, 822, 665], [1282, 556, 282, 410, 365, 373, 320, 421, 451, 569, 473, 498, 406, 679, 944, 346, 516, 528, 774, 292, 357, 604, 226, 826, 0, 272], [1188, 327, 289, 234, 271, 197, 112, 245, 276, 339, 297, 269, 213, 504, 768, 121, 341, 299, 544, 300, 214, 375, 146, 651, 262, 0]]}, "reference": {"optimum_s": 11939, "optimality": "best_found", "lower_bound_s": 10112, "floor_s": 6921, "solve_s": 43.18, "ffd_s": 13895, "stop_aware_best_s": 13597, "stop_aware_mean_s": 13849.6, "route_id": "RouteID_deb986b1-e2de-44bf-a9f6-dbb1258ee124", "plans": {"optimum": [{"route": ["S25", "S17", "S09", "S11", "S01", "S21", "S18", "S23", "S14", "S13", "S16", "S10", "S05"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S02", "S19", "S22", "S24"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S04", "S20", "S12", "S15", "S06", "S08", "S03", "S07"], "parcels": []}], "ffd": [{"route": ["S09", "S04", "S19"], "parcels": ["P25"]}, {"route": ["S19", "S25", "S08", "S11", "S23", "S14", "S13"], "parcels": ["P09", "P16", "P24"]}, {"route": ["S24", "S22", "S02", "S20", "S12", "S17", "S18", "S13", "S21", "S01", "S16", "S10", "S05", "S15", "S06", "S08", "S03", "S07"], "parcels": ["P10", "P15"]}], "stop_aware_best": [{"route": ["S04", "S17", "S16", "S03", "S25"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S24", "S22", "S19", "S12", "S09", "S21", "S01", "S18", "S10", "S07"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S15", "S06", "S08", "S05", "S13", "S23", "S14", "S11", "S20", "S02"], "parcels": []}]}}, "meta": {"route_id": "RouteID_deb986b1-e2de-44bf-a9f6-dbb1258ee124", "split": "train", "stops": 25, "vans": 3, "tightness": 0.88, "station": "DCH4", "city": "DCH", "date": "2018-08-03", "seconds": 85.3, "stop_aware_best_reward": 0.6185, "optimality": "best_found"}}
{"id": "ec5308eb-spread-n40-k4-t0.91-s0", "instance": {"stops": ["S01", "S02", "S03", "S04", "S05", "S06", "S07", "S08", "S09", "S10", "S11", "S12", "S13", "S14", "S15", "S16", "S17", "S18", "S19", "S20", "S21", "S22", "S23", "S24", "S25", "S26", "S27", "S28", "S29", "S30", "S31", "S32", "S33", "S34", "S35", "S36", "S37", "S38", "S39", "S40"], "parcels": [{"id": "P01", "stop": "S01", "volume_dl": 36}, {"id": "P02", "stop": "S02", "volume_dl": 41}, {"id": "P03", "stop": "S03", "volume_dl": 37}, {"id": "P04", "stop": "S04", "volume_dl": 40}, {"id": "P05", "stop": "S04", "volume_dl": 86}, {"id": "P06", "stop": "S05", "volume_dl": 542}, {"id": "P07", "stop": "S05", "volume_dl": 242}, {"id": "P08", "stop": "S06", "volume_dl": 20}, {"id": "P09", "stop": "S07", "volume_dl": 55}, {"id": "P10", "stop": "S07", "volume_dl": 35}, {"id": "P11", "stop": "S08", "volume_dl": 12}, {"id": "P12", "stop": "S09", "volume_dl": 57}, {"id": "P13", "stop": "S10", "volume_dl": 95}, {"id": "P14", "stop": "S10", "volume_dl": 9}, {"id": "P15", "stop": "S11", "volume_dl": 60}, {"id": "P16", "stop": "S12", "volume_dl": 9}, {"id": "P17", "stop": "S12", "volume_dl": 179}, {"id": "P18", "stop": "S13", "volume_dl": 52}, {"id": "P19", "stop": "S13", "volume_dl": 67}, {"id": "P20", "stop": "S13", "volume_dl": 92}, {"id": "P21", "stop": "S13", "volume_dl": 95}, {"id": "P22", "stop": "S14", "volume_dl": 52}, {"id": "P23", "stop": "S14", "volume_dl": 57}, {"id": "P24", "stop": "S15", "volume_dl": 134}, {"id": "P25", "stop": "S15", "volume_dl": 363}, {"id": "P26", "stop": "S16", "volume_dl": 26}, {"id": "P27", "stop": "S16", "volume_dl": 11}, {"id": "P28", "stop": "S16", "volume_dl": 133}, {"id": "P29", "stop": "S17", "volume_dl": 95}, {"id": "P30", "stop": "S17", "volume_dl": 19}, {"id": "P31", "stop": "S18", "volume_dl": 13}, {"id": "P32", "stop": "S19", "volume_dl": 133}, {"id": "P33", "stop": "S20", "volume_dl": 179}, {"id": "P34", "stop": "S20", "volume_dl": 179}, {"id": "P35", "stop": "S21", "volume_dl": 322}, {"id": "P36", "stop": "S22", "volume_dl": 226}, {"id": "P37", "stop": "S23", "volume_dl": 23}, {"id": "P38", "stop": "S24", "volume_dl": 92}, {"id": "P39", "stop": "S25", "volume_dl": 226}, {"id": "P40", "stop": "S26", "volume_dl": 226}, {"id": "P41", "stop": "S27", "volume_dl": 542}, {"id": "P42", "stop": "S28", "volume_dl": 57}, {"id": "P43", "stop": "S29", "volume_dl": 16}, {"id": "P44", "stop": "S30", "volume_dl": 429}, {"id": "P45", "stop": "S30", "volume_dl": 95}, {"id": "P46", "stop": "S31", "volume_dl": 63}, {"id": "P47", "stop": "S32", "volume_dl": 226}, {"id": "P48", "stop": "S32", "volume_dl": 36}, {"id": "P49", "stop": "S33", "volume_dl": 322}, {"id": "P50", "stop": "S33", "volume_dl": 95}, {"id": "P51", "stop": "S34", "volume_dl": 57}, {"id": "P52", "stop": "S35", "volume_dl": 57}, {"id": "P53", "stop": "S36", "volume_dl": 56}, {"id": "P54", "stop": "S36", "volume_dl": 63}, {"id": "P55", "stop": "S36", "volume_dl": 289}, {"id": "P56", "stop": "S36", "volume_dl": 10}, {"id": "P57", "stop": "S36", "volume_dl": 57}, {"id": "P58", "stop": "S36", "volume_dl": 43}, {"id": "P59", "stop": "S37", "volume_dl": 33}, {"id": "P60", "stop": "S37", "volume_dl": 179}, {"id": "P61", "stop": "S38", "volume_dl": 57}, {"id": "P62", "stop": "S38", "volume_dl": 157}, {"id": "P63", "stop": "S39", "volume_dl": 179}, {"id": "P64", "stop": "S39", "volume_dl": 322}, {"id": "P65", "stop": "S39", "volume_dl": 40}, {"id": "P66", "stop": "S39", "volume_dl": 11}, {"id": "P67", "stop": "S40", "volume_dl": 157}], "vans": 4, "capacity_dl": 2204, "travel_s": [[0, 2379, 2398, 2406, 2342, 2447, 2456, 2391, 2305, 2201, 2345, 2386, 2424, 2370, 2180, 2339, 2436, 2473, 2370, 2298, 2367, 2377, 2310, 2321, 2469, 2500, 2380, 2388, 2312, 2400, 2305, 2323, 2310, 2299, 2206, 2329, 2412, 2430, 2413, 2348, 2212], [2413, 0, 428, 404, 341, 143, 151, 79, 303, 390, 344, 312, 101, 204, 369, 401, 108, 110, 134, 100, 188, 15, 224, 455, 146, 313, 306, 168, 164, 206, 318, 457, 308, 215, 382, 180, 89, 115, 90, 432, 261], [2401, 432, 0, 67, 149, 519, 527, 443, 116, 280, 84, 431, 477, 579, 259, 121, 489, 526, 510, 351, 564, 430, 600, 151, 522, 689, 425, 544, 540, 582, 344, 153, 210, 591, 172, 556, 465, 491, 465, 152, 301], [2428, 427, 65, 0, 176, 514, 522, 439, 112, 306, 79, 458, 472, 570, 286, 148, 484, 521, 506, 346, 559, 425, 595, 178, 517, 684, 452, 539, 535, 577, 339, 180, 205, 586, 199, 551, 460, 486, 461, 179, 296], [2339, 325, 161, 170, 0, 412, 420, 336, 86, 313, 127, 464, 370, 472, 298, 154, 385, 419, 404, 244, 457, 323, 493, 135, 415, 582, 458, 437, 433, 475, 237, 138, 103, 484, 206, 449, 358, 384, 358, 185, 194], [2472, 198, 561, 538, 474, 0, 17, 226, 437, 524, 510, 446, 61, 193, 509, 524, 113, 172, 104, 233, 178, 182, 196, 589, 106, 302, 440, 121, 154, 163, 452, 591, 442, 187, 516, 157, 123, 74, 77, 566, 395], [2455, 215, 544, 521, 457, 17, 0, 243, 420, 507, 460, 428, 78, 176, 486, 517, 128, 189, 87, 216, 160, 200, 179, 572, 123, 285, 422, 104, 137, 154, 434, 574, 424, 170, 498, 140, 140, 57, 95, 549, 378], [2415, 89, 429, 406, 342, 206, 214, 0, 305, 392, 345, 313, 163, 266, 376, 402, 123, 129, 197, 101, 251, 74, 287, 456, 182, 376, 307, 231, 227, 269, 319, 459, 309, 278, 383, 243, 142, 178, 152, 434, 263], [2329, 315, 124, 101, 94, 403, 411, 327, 0, 284, 40, 435, 360, 458, 263, 125, 372, 409, 394, 234, 447, 314, 484, 156, 405, 572, 429, 427, 423, 465, 227, 158, 93, 475, 177, 439, 349, 374, 349, 157, 185], [2233, 396, 288, 297, 289, 484, 492, 408, 276, 0, 314, 276, 441, 539, 21, 230, 453, 490, 475, 315, 528, 394, 564, 211, 486, 653, 270, 508, 504, 546, 455, 214, 322, 556, 97, 520, 430, 455, 430, 239, 413], [2362, 348, 84, 61, 160, 436, 444, 392, 33, 317, 0, 468, 379, 528, 302, 148, 407, 442, 427, 268, 482, 346, 517, 189, 438, 605, 462, 460, 456, 498, 260, 191, 126, 508, 210, 472, 382, 412, 382, 190, 218], [2419, 319, 481, 510, 447, 406, 414, 330, 409, 297, 450, 0, 364, 466, 276, 422, 376, 412, 397, 238, 451, 317, 487, 404, 408, 576, 109, 431, 427, 469, 424, 406, 414, 478, 289, 443, 352, 378, 352, 431, 367], [2474, 161, 527, 504, 440, 56, 78, 180, 403, 490, 476, 412, 0, 194, 475, 490, 76, 126, 125, 199, 181, 146, 215, 555, 45, 304, 406, 159, 155, 197, 418, 557, 398, 220, 482, 169, 77, 110, 55, 522, 361], [2371, 322, 585, 562, 498, 139, 148, 346, 465, 552, 506, 474, 185, 0, 537, 552, 231, 291, 100, 257, 34, 306, 169, 617, 225, 154, 468, 99, 67, 67, 475, 619, 466, 160, 540, 138, 242, 143, 201, 594, 419], [2212, 375, 268, 276, 274, 468, 471, 392, 255, 21, 328, 255, 406, 528, 0, 198, 434, 474, 454, 294, 509, 374, 544, 190, 465, 632, 249, 487, 483, 525, 440, 193, 306, 540, 76, 499, 409, 439, 410, 218, 392], [2360, 413, 158, 166, 146, 488, 508, 424, 146, 238, 218, 389, 444, 560, 222, 0, 472, 507, 492, 332, 547, 411, 581, 109, 503, 670, 383, 525, 521, 563, 313, 112, 179, 560, 131, 537, 434, 476, 447, 40, 282], [2528, 85, 542, 519, 457, 113, 130, 113, 418, 505, 457, 426, 72, 232, 482, 514, 0, 57, 169, 214, 224, 70, 258, 570, 58, 347, 420, 202, 198, 240, 432, 572, 424, 248, 496, 214, 87, 151, 53, 545, 376], [2554, 111, 568, 545, 482, 174, 191, 140, 444, 531, 485, 453, 131, 299, 516, 531, 60, 0, 230, 240, 283, 96, 320, 596, 119, 408, 447, 263, 259, 301, 459, 598, 449, 311, 523, 275, 114, 210, 113, 573, 402], [2377, 285, 512, 489, 425, 102, 87, 241, 388, 475, 428, 396, 148, 96, 454, 485, 198, 259, 0, 184, 97, 270, 92, 539, 193, 198, 390, 53, 73, 115, 402, 542, 392, 83, 466, 65, 210, 60, 156, 516, 346], [2314, 81, 328, 305, 241, 168, 176, 92, 204, 291, 244, 212, 125, 228, 270, 301, 138, 174, 159, 0, 213, 79, 249, 356, 170, 338, 206, 193, 189, 231, 218, 358, 208, 240, 282, 205, 114, 140, 114, 333, 162], [2351, 359, 587, 564, 498, 174, 185, 315, 463, 550, 536, 472, 207, 41, 535, 550, 274, 331, 132, 259, 0, 343, 150, 615, 266, 195, 466, 131, 55, 74, 476, 617, 466, 193, 542, 154, 282, 172, 238, 590, 421], [2428, 15, 443, 420, 356, 158, 167, 64, 318, 406, 359, 327, 116, 219, 385, 416, 92, 95, 150, 115, 203, 0, 240, 470, 149, 328, 321, 183, 179, 221, 333, 473, 323, 231, 397, 195, 105, 130, 105, 447, 276], [2308, 252, 529, 506, 443, 192, 177, 259, 405, 492, 446, 414, 200, 161, 471, 503, 264, 325, 90, 201, 162, 250, 0, 557, 244, 286, 408, 142, 108, 164, 420, 559, 410, 63, 484, 49, 212, 150, 216, 534, 363], [2355, 417, 162, 170, 115, 504, 512, 428, 150, 233, 187, 384, 462, 560, 212, 103, 474, 511, 496, 336, 549, 415, 585, 0, 507, 674, 378, 529, 525, 567, 329, 2, 195, 576, 126, 541, 450, 476, 450, 112, 286], [2521, 165, 575, 552, 488, 108, 125, 194, 450, 537, 491, 459, 47, 242, 516, 548, 79, 139, 173, 247, 226, 150, 262, 602, 0, 351, 453, 206, 202, 244, 465, 604, 455, 254, 529, 216, 148, 153, 97, 579, 408], [2498, 455, 717, 694, 630, 272, 281, 483, 593, 680, 633, 601, 318, 164, 659, 690, 368, 429, 227, 389, 199, 440, 297, 744, 363, 0, 595, 226, 194, 155, 607, 747, 597, 288, 671, 270, 380, 281, 335, 722, 551], [2405, 305, 467, 496, 433, 392, 401, 317, 395, 284, 436, 122, 350, 448, 263, 408, 362, 399, 384, 224, 437, 303, 474, 390, 395, 562, 0, 417, 413, 455, 410, 392, 400, 465, 275, 429, 339, 364, 339, 417, 353], [2393, 300, 548, 525, 461, 116, 104, 277, 424, 511, 464, 432, 162, 98, 490, 521, 213, 274, 60, 220, 117, 284, 145, 575, 207, 200, 426, 0, 76, 135, 438, 578, 428, 136, 502, 118, 225, 72, 174, 552, 382], [2317, 317, 550, 527, 463, 134, 144, 279, 426, 513, 466, 434, 180, 51, 492, 523, 231, 291, 77, 222, 52, 302, 113, 578, 225, 188, 428, 76, 0, 66, 440, 580, 430, 138, 504, 120, 242, 121, 198, 555, 384], [2343, 323, 599, 576, 512, 140, 150, 351, 475, 562, 515, 483, 186, 67, 541, 572, 237, 297, 120, 271, 48, 308, 162, 627, 231, 160, 477, 112, 67, 0, 489, 629, 479, 181, 553, 164, 248, 149, 204, 604, 433], [2338, 272, 310, 287, 223, 360, 368, 284, 186, 442, 226, 391, 317, 420, 427, 272, 329, 366, 351, 191, 404, 270, 440, 337, 362, 529, 385, 384, 380, 422, 0, 340, 190, 432, 335, 396, 306, 331, 306, 314, 162], [2357, 419, 164, 173, 117, 507, 515, 431, 152, 236, 189, 387, 464, 562, 215, 105, 476, 513, 498, 338, 551, 418, 588, 2, 509, 676, 381, 531, 527, 569, 331, 0, 197, 579, 128, 543, 453, 478, 453, 114, 289], [2326, 312, 230, 207, 143, 399, 407, 324, 106, 362, 146, 513, 357, 460, 347, 192, 369, 406, 390, 231, 444, 310, 480, 233, 402, 569, 507, 424, 420, 462, 224, 236, 0, 471, 255, 436, 345, 371, 346, 234, 181], [2294, 262, 540, 516, 453, 183, 168, 269, 415, 502, 488, 424, 209, 171, 481, 513, 273, 334, 81, 212, 182, 260, 63, 567, 254, 278, 418, 133, 145, 200, 430, 569, 420, 0, 494, 58, 222, 137, 225, 544, 373], [2229, 378, 192, 200, 192, 466, 474, 390, 179, 107, 217, 258, 423, 521, 86, 133, 436, 472, 457, 298, 510, 376, 547, 115, 468, 635, 252, 490, 486, 528, 359, 117, 225, 538, 0, 502, 412, 437, 412, 142, 316], [2338, 231, 509, 486, 422, 155, 140, 238, 384, 472, 425, 393, 151, 148, 451, 482, 215, 276, 53, 181, 154, 229, 59, 536, 196, 250, 387, 105, 102, 158, 399, 539, 389, 68, 463, 0, 231, 113, 167, 513, 342], [2491, 107, 564, 541, 477, 121, 138, 135, 440, 527, 480, 448, 65, 212, 506, 537, 91, 117, 143, 236, 196, 91, 232, 592, 123, 321, 442, 176, 172, 214, 454, 594, 444, 224, 518, 188, 0, 123, 77, 569, 398], [2399, 274, 516, 493, 425, 76, 59, 242, 392, 479, 465, 401, 122, 124, 464, 479, 189, 243, 50, 188, 106, 258, 140, 544, 181, 229, 395, 84, 80, 122, 402, 546, 392, 131, 471, 112, 194, 0, 147, 521, 350], [2465, 135, 486, 462, 399, 96, 90, 162, 361, 448, 434, 370, 40, 186, 433, 448, 50, 108, 117, 158, 172, 120, 207, 513, 93, 295, 364, 150, 146, 188, 377, 515, 366, 198, 440, 162, 77, 102, 0, 490, 319], [2367, 443, 188, 196, 188, 530, 538, 454, 176, 246, 248, 397, 474, 586, 225, 59, 500, 537, 522, 362, 577, 441, 611, 117, 533, 700, 391, 555, 551, 593, 355, 120, 221, 602, 139, 567, 476, 506, 476, 0, 312], [2232, 267, 322, 299, 236, 354, 362, 278, 198, 464, 239, 386, 312, 410, 443, 296, 324, 361, 346, 186, 399, 265, 435, 350, 357, 524, 380, 379, 375, 417, 193, 352, 203, 426, 348, 391, 300, 326, 300, 327, 0]]}, "reference": {"optimum_s": 21680, "optimality": "best_found", "lower_bound_s": 19094, "floor_s": 17568, "solve_s": 124.47, "ffd_s": 25427, "stop_aware_best_s": 23933, "stop_aware_mean_s": 24072.6, "route_id": "RouteID_ec5308eb-e52f-429f-b9f3-fecaab91a23d", "plans": {"optimum": [{"route": ["S40", "S30", "S19", "S38", "S36", "S21", "S01", "S11", "S26"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S14", "S09", "S23", "S31", "S04", "S32", "S08", "S10", "S03", "S02", "S15", "S39", "S34"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S22", "S35", "S18", "S27", "S28", "S20", "S13", "S25", "S29"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S07", "S17", "S16", "S24", "S12", "S05", "S06", "S37", "S33"], "parcels": []}], "ffd": [{"route": ["S15", "S30", "S21", "S05", "S27"], "parcels": ["P06", "P25", "P44"]}, {"route": ["S32", "S10", "S39", "S26", "S36", "S16", "S05", "S25", "S22", "S33"], "parcels": ["P07", "P13", "P26", "P47", "P49", "P55", "P64"]}, {"route": ["S23", "S39", "S15", "S30", "S40", "S19", "S17", "S16", "S24", "S12", "S38", "S37", "S20", "S13", "S33"], "parcels": ["P17", "P20", "P21", "P24", "P28", "P29", "P45", "P50", "P60", "P62", "P63"]}, {"route": ["S14", "S09", "S31", "S04", "S32", "S08", "S10", "S03", "S02", "S39", "S34", "S11", "S07", "S01", "S36", "S17", "S16", "S38", "S12", "S06", "S37", "S18", "S35", "S28", "S13", "S29"], "parcels": ["P14", "P16", "P18", "P19", "P27", "P30", "P48", "P53", "P54", "P56", "P57", "P58", "P59", "P61", "P65", "P66"]}], "stop_aware_best": [{"route": ["S08", "S02", "S15", "S39", "S14", "S09", "S11", "S25", "S29"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S40", "S03", "S31", "S34", "S26", "S19", "S38", "S24", "S37", "S18", "S13", "S20", "S22"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S32", "S30", "S07", "S16", "S36", "S27", "S35"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S23", "S04", "S10", "S01", "S21", "S17", "S12", "S05", "S06", "S28", "S33"], "parcels": []}]}}, "meta": {"route_id": "RouteID_ec5308eb-e52f-429f-b9f3-fecaab91a23d", "split": "train", "stops": 40, "vans": 4, "tightness": 0.91, "station": "DSE4", "city": "DSE", "date": "2018-08-16", "seconds": 187.8, "stop_aware_best_reward": 0.4745, "optimality": "best_found"}}
{"id": "58a6906b-spread-n30-k4-t0.89-s0", "instance": {"stops": ["S01", "S02", "S03", "S04", "S05", "S06", "S07", "S08", "S09", "S10", "S11", "S12", "S13", "S14", "S15", "S16", "S17", "S18", "S19", "S20", "S21", "S22", "S23", "S24", "S25", "S26", "S27", "S28", "S29", "S30"], "parcels": [{"id": "P01", "stop": "S01", "volume_dl": 34}, {"id": "P02", "stop": "S01", "volume_dl": 52}, {"id": "P03", "stop": "S02", "volume_dl": 40}, {"id": "P04", "stop": "S03", "volume_dl": 30}, {"id": "P05", "stop": "S04", "volume_dl": 57}, {"id": "P06", "stop": "S04", "volume_dl": 16}, {"id": "P07", "stop": "S05", "volume_dl": 28}, {"id": "P08", "stop": "S06", "volume_dl": 552}, {"id": "P09", "stop": "S07", "volume_dl": 134}, {"id": "P10", "stop": "S08", "volume_dl": 133}, {"id": "P11", "stop": "S09", "volume_dl": 104}, {"id": "P12", "stop": "S10", "volume_dl": 165}, {"id": "P13", "stop": "S11", "volume_dl": 582}, {"id": "P14", "stop": "S12", "volume_dl": 127}, {"id": "P15", "stop": "S13", "volume_dl": 63}, {"id": "P16", "stop": "S14", "volume_dl": 36}, {"id": "P17", "stop": "S15", "volume_dl": 322}, {"id": "P18", "stop": "S15", "volume_dl": 57}, {"id": "P19", "stop": "S16", "volume_dl": 477}, {"id": "P20", "stop": "S17", "volume_dl": 23}, {"id": "P21", "stop": "S18", "volume_dl": 20}, {"id": "P22", "stop": "S18", "volume_dl": 19}, {"id": "P23", "stop": "S18", "volume_dl": 95}, {"id": "P24", "stop": "S18", "volume_dl": 779}, {"id": "P25", "stop": "S18", "volume_dl": 21}, {"id": "P26", "stop": "S18", "volume_dl": 133}, {"id": "P27", "stop": "S19", "volume_dl": 29}, {"id": "P28", "stop": "S19", "volume_dl": 57}, {"id": "P29", "stop": "S19", "volume_dl": 25}, {"id": "P30", "stop": "S19", "volume_dl": 50}, {"id": "P31", "stop": "S20", "volume_dl": 191}, {"id": "P32", "stop": "S21", "volume_dl": 133}, {"id": "P33", "stop": "S22", "volume_dl": 57}, {"id": "P34", "stop": "S22", "volume_dl": 104}, {"id": "P35", "stop": "S23", "volume_dl": 57}, {"id": "P36", "stop": "S24", "volume_dl": 24}, {"id": "P37", "stop": "S25", "volume_dl": 57}, {"id": "P38", "stop": "S26", "volume_dl": 35}, {"id": "P39", "stop": "S26", "volume_dl": 34}, {"id": "P40", "stop": "S26", "volume_dl": 34}, {"id": "P41", "stop": "S26", "volume_dl": 21}, {"id": "P42", "stop": "S27", "volume_dl": 133}, {"id": "P43", "stop": "S28", "volume_dl": 242}, {"id": "P44", "stop": "S28", "volume_dl": 8}, {"id": "P45", "stop": "S29", "volume_dl": 31}, {"id": "P46", "stop": "S30", "volume_dl": 8}, {"id": "P47", "stop": "S30", "volume_dl": 63}], "vans": 4, "capacity_dl": 1545, "travel_s": [[0, 1795, 1780, 1855, 1815, 1777, 1814, 1799, 1742, 1821, 1923, 1914, 1799, 1957, 1724, 1817, 1772, 1860, 1853, 1759, 1870, 1982, 1863, 1787, 1811, 1739, 1840, 1895, 1828, 1836, 1831], [1968, 0, 501, 228, 225, 248, 425, 411, 354, 233, 514, 547, 210, 515, 195, 229, 184, 272, 387, 371, 472, 572, 420, 160, 184, 350, 451, 306, 240, 394, 243], [2051, 479, 0, 539, 480, 461, 425, 410, 353, 486, 151, 162, 483, 322, 408, 536, 457, 510, 282, 370, 117, 210, 291, 471, 496, 350, 451, 502, 493, 265, 405], [2020, 200, 553, 0, 279, 300, 478, 463, 406, 285, 566, 599, 263, 567, 247, 281, 236, 324, 439, 423, 524, 625, 473, 117, 76, 403, 504, 359, 292, 446, 295], [1990, 248, 457, 309, 0, 270, 306, 285, 228, 39, 470, 502, 150, 471, 217, 219, 123, 147, 340, 272, 428, 528, 376, 240, 265, 254, 324, 139, 113, 350, 73], [1995, 244, 612, 304, 264, 0, 453, 438, 381, 270, 695, 706, 248, 542, 63, 266, 221, 309, 414, 398, 662, 754, 448, 236, 260, 378, 479, 344, 277, 421, 280], [1976, 396, 405, 456, 313, 418, 0, 29, 85, 319, 418, 451, 333, 419, 365, 369, 306, 343, 291, 96, 376, 476, 324, 388, 413, 129, 38, 335, 326, 298, 238], [1981, 372, 410, 432, 288, 394, 21, 0, 56, 295, 423, 456, 308, 424, 341, 345, 282, 318, 296, 116, 381, 482, 330, 364, 388, 150, 40, 311, 302, 303, 214], [1926, 316, 355, 377, 233, 338, 78, 57, 0, 239, 367, 400, 253, 369, 285, 290, 226, 263, 240, 173, 326, 426, 274, 308, 333, 207, 97, 256, 246, 248, 158], [1995, 254, 471, 314, 27, 275, 321, 300, 243, 0, 484, 517, 146, 485, 222, 227, 120, 143, 357, 289, 442, 543, 391, 246, 270, 268, 340, 153, 111, 364, 90], [2036, 464, 160, 524, 465, 446, 409, 395, 338, 471, 0, 124, 468, 224, 393, 521, 441, 495, 266, 355, 49, 84, 205, 456, 480, 334, 435, 487, 478, 179, 390], [2066, 494, 149, 554, 494, 476, 439, 425, 368, 501, 101, 0, 498, 254, 422, 551, 471, 524, 296, 385, 48, 160, 235, 486, 510, 364, 465, 517, 508, 208, 420], [1974, 233, 500, 293, 166, 255, 350, 329, 272, 157, 513, 546, 0, 514, 202, 206, 31, 168, 386, 318, 471, 572, 420, 225, 249, 298, 369, 245, 136, 393, 182], [2033, 461, 316, 522, 462, 443, 407, 392, 335, 468, 247, 280, 465, 0, 390, 519, 439, 492, 264, 352, 205, 305, 202, 453, 478, 332, 433, 485, 476, 176, 387], [1937, 186, 548, 246, 206, 63, 395, 380, 324, 213, 632, 642, 190, 660, 0, 209, 164, 252, 356, 341, 598, 690, 390, 178, 202, 320, 421, 286, 220, 364, 222], [1948, 207, 481, 267, 196, 228, 406, 391, 334, 204, 494, 527, 181, 495, 175, 0, 154, 242, 367, 351, 452, 553, 401, 199, 223, 331, 432, 277, 210, 374, 213], [1936, 195, 463, 255, 128, 217, 312, 291, 234, 119, 475, 508, 40, 477, 164, 168, 0, 130, 348, 280, 434, 534, 382, 187, 212, 260, 332, 208, 98, 356, 144], [2016, 274, 522, 335, 146, 296, 372, 351, 294, 134, 535, 568, 167, 536, 243, 248, 141, 0, 408, 340, 493, 594, 442, 266, 291, 320, 391, 160, 23, 415, 188], [1885, 313, 322, 373, 314, 295, 258, 244, 187, 320, 335, 368, 317, 336, 242, 370, 290, 344, 0, 204, 294, 394, 242, 305, 329, 183, 284, 336, 327, 216, 239], [1951, 371, 380, 431, 286, 393, 95, 124, 161, 294, 393, 426, 307, 394, 340, 344, 281, 318, 266, 0, 351, 451, 299, 363, 388, 104, 133, 310, 301, 273, 213], [2017, 445, 110, 505, 446, 427, 390, 376, 319, 452, 52, 74, 449, 205, 374, 502, 422, 476, 248, 336, 0, 111, 186, 437, 461, 315, 416, 468, 459, 160, 371], [2077, 504, 201, 565, 505, 486, 450, 435, 379, 512, 86, 165, 508, 265, 433, 562, 482, 535, 307, 396, 90, 0, 246, 496, 521, 375, 476, 528, 519, 219, 430], [2020, 447, 371, 508, 448, 429, 393, 378, 322, 454, 302, 335, 451, 303, 376, 505, 425, 478, 250, 338, 260, 360, 0, 439, 464, 318, 419, 471, 462, 121, 373], [1950, 130, 483, 135, 209, 230, 407, 393, 336, 215, 496, 529, 192, 497, 177, 211, 166, 254, 369, 353, 454, 554, 402, 0, 91, 332, 433, 288, 222, 376, 225], [1996, 176, 529, 76, 255, 276, 453, 439, 382, 261, 542, 574, 238, 543, 223, 257, 212, 300, 415, 399, 500, 600, 448, 93, 0, 378, 479, 334, 268, 422, 271], [1927, 347, 356, 407, 263, 369, 135, 164, 137, 270, 368, 401, 283, 370, 316, 320, 257, 293, 242, 80, 327, 427, 275, 339, 363, 0, 173, 286, 277, 249, 188], [2033, 424, 462, 484, 339, 446, 62, 52, 108, 347, 475, 508, 360, 476, 393, 397, 334, 370, 348, 157, 433, 534, 382, 416, 440, 190, 0, 363, 354, 355, 266], [2040, 299, 480, 359, 130, 321, 329, 308, 252, 136, 493, 526, 267, 494, 268, 272, 241, 141, 366, 298, 451, 551, 399, 291, 316, 277, 349, 0, 125, 373, 100], [1993, 251, 495, 312, 121, 273, 344, 323, 266, 111, 508, 540, 144, 509, 220, 224, 118, 32, 381, 313, 466, 566, 414, 243, 268, 292, 364, 133, 0, 388, 165], [1919, 346, 270, 407, 347, 328, 292, 277, 221, 354, 201, 234, 350, 202, 275, 404, 324, 377, 149, 238, 159, 260, 66, 338, 363, 217, 318, 370, 361, 0, 272], [1985, 244, 409, 304, 73, 266, 258, 237, 180, 81, 422, 454, 212, 423, 213, 217, 186, 154, 294, 226, 380, 480, 328, 236, 260, 206, 278, 128, 137, 302, 0]]}, "reference": {"optimum_s": 17759, "optimality": "best_found", "lower_bound_s": 16422, "floor_s": 14436, "solve_s": 51.24, "ffd_s": 20938, "stop_aware_best_s": 19470, "stop_aware_mean_s": 20140.2, "route_id": "RouteID_58a6906b-aa93-4225-941e-8512c1e15aec", "plans": {"optimum": [{"route": ["S05", "S14", "S24", "S03", "S23", "S01", "S12", "S16", "S17", "S28", "S27", "S30", "S09", "S04"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S18"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S02", "S11", "S20", "S10", "S21", "S13", "S22", "S29"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S25", "S19", "S06", "S26", "S07", "S08", "S15"], "parcels": []}], "ffd": [{"route": ["S11", "S10", "S18"], "parcels": ["P22", "P24"]}, {"route": ["S15", "S16", "S06", "S20"], "parcels": ["P17"]}, {"route": ["S24", "S12", "S28", "S27", "S09", "S04", "S30", "S07", "S08", "S21", "S13", "S22", "S18"], "parcels": ["P05", "P23", "P26", "P34", "P43", "P47"]}, {"route": ["S02", "S22", "S29", "S18", "S25", "S19", "S26", "S30", "S04", "S28", "S17", "S15", "S05", "S14", "S03", "S23", "S01"], "parcels": ["P06", "P18", "P21", "P25", "P33", "P44", "P46"]}], "stop_aware_best": [{"route": ["S25", "S19", "S26", "S30", "S04", "S09", "S17", "S12", "S16"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S02", "S11", "S20", "S13", "S22", "S27", "S28", "S05", "S14", "S24", "S03"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S08", "S07", "S06", "S10", "S23", "S01", "S15"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S21", "S29", "S18"], "parcels": []}]}}, "meta": {"route_id": "RouteID_58a6906b-aa93-4225-941e-8512c1e15aec", "split": "train", "stops": 30, "vans": 4, "tightness": 0.89, "station": "DLA7", "city": "DLA", "date": "2018-08-17", "seconds": 111.7, "stop_aware_best_reward": 0.4944, "optimality": "best_found"}}
{"id": "d04d1db8-spread-n25-k3-t0.87-s0", "instance": {"stops": ["S01", "S02", "S03", "S04", "S05", "S06", "S07", "S08", "S09", "S10", "S11", "S12", "S13", "S14", "S15", "S16", "S17", "S18", "S19", "S20", "S21", "S22", "S23", "S24", "S25"], "parcels": [{"id": "P01", "stop": "S01", "volume_dl": 57}, {"id": "P02", "stop": "S01", "volume_dl": 23}, {"id": "P03", "stop": "S01", "volume_dl": 57}, {"id": "P04", "stop": "S01", "volume_dl": 9}, {"id": "P05", "stop": "S01", "volume_dl": 95}, {"id": "P06", "stop": "S01", "volume_dl": 43}, {"id": "P07", "stop": "S01", "volume_dl": 134}, {"id": "P08", "stop": "S01", "volume_dl": 63}, {"id": "P09", "stop": "S01", "volume_dl": 157}, {"id": "P10", "stop": "S01", "volume_dl": 25}, {"id": "P11", "stop": "S01", "volume_dl": 3}, {"id": "P12", "stop": "S01", "volume_dl": 7}, {"id": "P13", "stop": "S01", "volume_dl": 16}, {"id": "P14", "stop": "S01", "volume_dl": 57}, {"id": "P15", "stop": "S01", "volume_dl": 30}, {"id": "P16", "stop": "S01", "volume_dl": 53}, {"id": "P17", "stop": "S01", "volume_dl": 42}, {"id": "P18", "stop": "S01", "volume_dl": 179}, {"id": "P19", "stop": "S01", "volume_dl": 133}, {"id": "P20", "stop": "S01", "volume_dl": 14}, {"id": "P21", "stop": "S01", "volume_dl": 134}, {"id": "P22", "stop": "S01", "volume_dl": 179}, {"id": "P23", "stop": "S01", "volume_dl": 104}, {"id": "P24", "stop": "S01", "volume_dl": 10}, {"id": "P25", "stop": "S01", "volume_dl": 133}, {"id": "P26", "stop": "S01", "volume_dl": 34}, {"id": "P27", "stop": "S02", "volume_dl": 157}, {"id": "P28", "stop": "S02", "volume_dl": 322}, {"id": "P29", "stop": "S03", "volume_dl": 63}, {"id": "P30", "stop": "S04", "volume_dl": 57}, {"id": "P31", "stop": "S04", "volume_dl": 157}, {"id": "P32", "stop": "S04", "volume_dl": 34}, {"id": "P33", "stop": "S05", "volume_dl": 16}, {"id": "P34", "stop": "S06", "volume_dl": 599}, {"id": "P35", "stop": "S07", "volume_dl": 92}, {"id": "P36", "stop": "S08", "volume_dl": 15}, {"id": "P37", "stop": "S09", "volume_dl": 368}, {"id": "P38", "stop": "S10", "volume_dl": 34}, {"id": "P39", "stop": "S11", "volume_dl": 34}, {"id": "P40", "stop": "S12", "volume_dl": 13}, {"id": "P41", "stop": "S12", "volume_dl": 63}, {"id": "P42", "stop": "S12", "volume_dl": 133}, {"id": "P43", "stop": "S13", "volume_dl": 226}, {"id": "P44", "stop": "S13", "volume_dl": 322}, {"id": "P45", "stop": "S14", "volume_dl": 20}, {"id": "P46", "stop": "S14", "volume_dl": 57}, {"id": "P47", "stop": "S15", "volume_dl": 36}, {"id": "P48", "stop": "S16", "volume_dl": 10}, {"id": "P49", "stop": "S16", "volume_dl": 63}, {"id": "P50", "stop": "S17", "volume_dl": 215}, {"id": "P51", "stop": "S18", "volume_dl": 57}, {"id": "P52", "stop": "S18", "volume_dl": 54}, {"id": "P53", "stop": "S19", "volume_dl": 779}, {"id": "P54", "stop": "S19", "volume_dl": 779}, {"id": "P55", "stop": "S20", "volume_dl": 34}, {"id": "P56", "stop": "S21", "volume_dl": 429}, {"id": "P57", "stop": "S22", "volume_dl": 20}, {"id": "P58", "stop": "S23", "volume_dl": 29}, {"id": "P59", "stop": "S24", "volume_dl": 11}, {"id": "P60", "stop": "S25", "volume_dl": 45}], "vans": 3, "capacity_dl": 2735, "travel_s": [[0, 1422, 1384, 1686, 1639, 1358, 1438, 1450, 1528, 1376, 1476, 1419, 1536, 1510, 1482, 1355, 1559, 1573, 1561, 1548, 1552, 1529, 1572, 1639, 1546, 1567], [1615, 0, 98, 486, 420, 179, 206, 222, 286, 305, 244, 43, 290, 278, 449, 302, 552, 420, 447, 291, 310, 284, 330, 401, 517, 333], [1550, 102, 0, 434, 381, 79, 186, 123, 220, 239, 223, 66, 224, 257, 398, 236, 501, 320, 395, 240, 244, 221, 264, 349, 465, 268], [1751, 468, 447, 0, 198, 438, 308, 401, 400, 581, 299, 464, 367, 280, 345, 554, 448, 460, 287, 341, 350, 381, 327, 240, 412, 502], [1740, 392, 394, 186, 0, 391, 251, 354, 252, 432, 243, 393, 233, 192, 295, 407, 408, 399, 286, 306, 203, 354, 179, 228, 362, 467], [1618, 157, 88, 428, 372, 0, 171, 91, 309, 328, 209, 132, 317, 243, 368, 325, 444, 288, 408, 281, 333, 309, 353, 361, 431, 356], [1646, 190, 193, 310, 225, 184, 0, 148, 288, 396, 62, 187, 299, 96, 274, 392, 377, 334, 272, 134, 282, 215, 259, 225, 341, 336], [1646, 161, 92, 456, 399, 83, 199, 0, 313, 332, 236, 136, 321, 271, 395, 329, 472, 316, 436, 333, 337, 314, 357, 389, 459, 361], [1679, 293, 255, 396, 236, 299, 328, 343, 0, 286, 319, 290, 33, 269, 501, 271, 604, 616, 492, 388, 49, 420, 84, 445, 568, 207], [1508, 330, 291, 563, 403, 336, 408, 379, 284, 0, 407, 326, 292, 436, 561, 152, 664, 576, 559, 402, 308, 383, 300, 512, 628, 286], [1673, 218, 220, 292, 206, 211, 72, 175, 269, 423, 0, 214, 280, 78, 255, 420, 358, 370, 254, 114, 264, 197, 240, 207, 323, 317], [1572, 36, 55, 455, 390, 136, 175, 179, 243, 262, 213, 0, 250, 247, 419, 259, 522, 376, 417, 260, 267, 243, 287, 370, 486, 290], [1703, 445, 279, 367, 207, 323, 299, 402, 29, 310, 290, 441, 0, 240, 472, 295, 575, 587, 462, 359, 20, 390, 55, 416, 539, 231], [1695, 239, 242, 300, 197, 233, 93, 197, 258, 385, 85, 236, 262, 0, 264, 357, 367, 383, 261, 154, 282, 185, 217, 215, 331, 306], [1497, 438, 369, 291, 325, 360, 366, 324, 440, 610, 285, 413, 444, 266, 0, 606, 103, 115, 78, 326, 464, 367, 433, 90, 64, 487], [1570, 298, 260, 544, 384, 304, 389, 348, 265, 224, 388, 295, 272, 416, 541, 0, 644, 545, 539, 383, 289, 364, 281, 493, 608, 266], [1572, 513, 444, 372, 385, 435, 374, 399, 521, 684, 366, 488, 525, 347, 81, 620, 0, 190, 160, 408, 545, 448, 514, 171, 145, 568], [1510, 357, 288, 348, 356, 279, 286, 243, 509, 529, 323, 333, 517, 357, 133, 526, 210, 0, 212, 396, 534, 442, 474, 281, 197, 557], [1632, 450, 452, 302, 336, 443, 304, 407, 450, 578, 295, 446, 453, 276, 112, 550, 214, 227, 0, 336, 475, 378, 439, 101, 176, 498], [1710, 255, 258, 345, 296, 249, 109, 212, 283, 460, 101, 251, 287, 154, 308, 457, 411, 423, 306, 0, 308, 211, 316, 260, 376, 331], [1724, 424, 427, 346, 187, 344, 278, 382, 49, 330, 270, 421, 16, 219, 452, 316, 554, 566, 442, 339, 0, 370, 34, 395, 519, 251], [1655, 248, 230, 396, 382, 274, 207, 311, 235, 362, 206, 244, 243, 286, 360, 335, 463, 475, 358, 202, 260, 0, 280, 311, 427, 283], [1747, 390, 392, 312, 152, 383, 244, 347, 73, 354, 235, 386, 40, 185, 417, 339, 520, 532, 408, 304, 24, 336, 0, 361, 484, 275], [1572, 395, 444, 247, 255, 435, 249, 399, 396, 523, 241, 392, 403, 222, 75, 495, 178, 190, 73, 282, 420, 323, 384, 0, 142, 443], [1580, 521, 452, 354, 367, 443, 356, 407, 503, 630, 348, 497, 511, 329, 83, 602, 186, 198, 212, 390, 527, 430, 496, 153, 0, 551], [1739, 353, 314, 499, 340, 359, 431, 402, 193, 299, 423, 349, 200, 372, 604, 274, 707, 599, 521, 365, 217, 346, 237, 474, 672, 0]]}, "reference": {"optimum_s": 11755, "optimality": "best_found", "lower_bound_s": 10662, "floor_s": 8556, "solve_s": 64.25, "ffd_s": 13287, "stop_aware_best_s": 12910, "stop_aware_mean_s": 13055.2, "route_id": "RouteID_d04d1db8-25aa-4ede-bfa9-f9fa0684190b", "plans": {"optimum": [{"route": ["S05", "S07", "S02", "S01", "S11"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S06", "S10", "S19", "S21"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S09", "S15", "S25", "S08", "S12", "S20", "S22", "S13", "S04", "S03", "S23", "S18", "S14", "S24", "S16", "S17"], "parcels": []}], "ffd": [{"route": ["S01", "S06", "S19", "S21", "S08"], "parcels": ["P07"]}, {"route": ["S09", "S04", "S13", "S01", "S02", "S17"], "parcels": ["P09", "P16", "P18", "P19", "P21", "P22", "P25", "P31"]}, {"route": ["S15", "S25", "S12", "S20", "S22", "S04", "S03", "S23", "S16", "S24", "S14", "S18", "S10", "S07", "S05", "S01", "S11"], "parcels": ["P01", "P02", "P03", "P04", "P05", "P06", "P08", "P10", "P11", "P12", "P13", "P14", "P15", "P17", "P20", "P23", "P24", "P26", "P30", "P32"]}], "stop_aware_best": [{"route": ["S01", "S02", "S07", "S04", "S03"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S09", "S15", "S25", "S13", "S21", "S11", "S05", "S17", "S16", "S14"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S08", "S12", "S20", "S22", "S06", "S10", "S19", "S23", "S18", "S24"], "parcels": []}]}}, "meta": {"route_id": "RouteID_d04d1db8-25aa-4ede-bfa9-f9fa0684190b", "split": "train", "stops": 25, "vans": 3, "tightness": 0.87, "station": "DLA9", "city": "DLA", "date": "2018-08-13", "seconds": 115.1, "stop_aware_best_reward": 0.5972, "optimality": "best_found"}}
{"id": "a5b39b89-spread-n30-k4-t0.89-s0", "instance": {"stops": ["S01", "S02", "S03", "S04", "S05", "S06", "S07", "S08", "S09", "S10", "S11", "S12", "S13", "S14", "S15", "S16", "S17", "S18", "S19", "S20", "S21", "S22", "S23", "S24", "S25", "S26", "S27", "S28", "S29", "S30"], "parcels": [{"id": "P001", "stop": "S01", "volume_dl": 31}, {"id": "P002", "stop": "S01", "volume_dl": 38}, {"id": "P003", "stop": "S01", "volume_dl": 104}, {"id": "P004", "stop": "S01", "volume_dl": 226}, {"id": "P005", "stop": "S01", "volume_dl": 134}, {"id": "P006", "stop": "S01", "volume_dl": 32}, {"id": "P007", "stop": "S01", "volume_dl": 104}, {"id": "P008", "stop": "S01", "volume_dl": 144}, {"id": "P009", "stop": "S01", "volume_dl": 54}, {"id": "P010", "stop": "S01", "volume_dl": 63}, {"id": "P011", "stop": "S01", "volume_dl": 104}, {"id": "P012", "stop": "S01", "volume_dl": 133}, {"id": "P013", "stop": "S01", "volume_dl": 31}, {"id": "P014", "stop": "S01", "volume_dl": 40}, {"id": "P015", "stop": "S01", "volume_dl": 13}, {"id": "P016", "stop": "S02", "volume_dl": 7}, {"id": "P017", "stop": "S02", "volume_dl": 57}, {"id": "P018", "stop": "S02", "volume_dl": 30}, {"id": "P019", "stop": "S03", "volume_dl": 57}, {"id": "P020", "stop": "S03", "volume_dl": 53}, {"id": "P021", "stop": "S03", "volume_dl": 79}, {"id": "P022", "stop": "S03", "volume_dl": 53}, {"id": "P023", "stop": "S03", "volume_dl": 9}, {"id": "P024", "stop": "S03", "volume_dl": 34}, {"id": "P025", "stop": "S04", "volume_dl": 34}, {"id": "P026", "stop": "S04", "volume_dl": 244}, {"id": "P027", "stop": "S04", "volume_dl": 478}, {"id": "P028", "stop": "S04", "volume_dl": 779}, {"id": "P029", "stop": "S04", "volume_dl": 34}, {"id": "P030", "stop": "S04", "volume_dl": 36}, {"id": "P031", "stop": "S04", "volume_dl": 157}, {"id": "P032", "stop": "S04", "volume_dl": 34}, {"id": "P033", "stop": "S04", "volume_dl": 19}, {"id": "P034", "stop": "S04", "volume_dl": 95}, {"id": "P035", "stop": "S05", "volume_dl": 14}, {"id": "P036", "stop": "S06", "volume_dl": 133}, {"id": "P037", "stop": "S06", "volume_dl": 57}, {"id": "P038", "stop": "S06", "volume_dl": 95}, {"id": "P039", "stop": "S06", "volume_dl": 368}, {"id": "P040", "stop": "S07", "volume_dl": 133}, {"id": "P041", "stop": "S07", "volume_dl": 59}, {"id": "P042", "stop": "S08", "volume_dl": 259}, {"id": "P043", "stop": "S09", "volume_dl": 133}, {"id": "P044", "stop": "S09", "volume_dl": 55}, {"id": "P045", "stop": "S09", "volume_dl": 21}, {"id": "P046", "stop": "S09", "volume_dl": 5}, {"id": "P047", "stop": "S10", "volume_dl": 23}, {"id": "P048", "stop": "S10", "volume_dl": 157}, {"id": "P049", "stop": "S10", "volume_dl": 10}, {"id": "P050", "stop": "S11", "volume_dl": 34}, {"id": "P051", "stop": "S12", "volume_dl": 21}, {"id": "P052", "stop": "S12", "volume_dl": 92}, {"id": "P053", "stop": "S12", "volume_dl": 14}, {"id": "P054", "stop": "S12", "volume_dl": 322}, {"id": "P055", "stop": "S12", "volume_dl": 16}, {"id": "P056", "stop": "S12", "volume_dl": 179}, {"id": "P057", "stop": "S12", "volume_dl": 134}, {"id": "P058", "stop": "S12", "volume_dl": 11}, {"id": "P059", "stop": "S13", "volume_dl": 179}, {"id": "P060", "stop": "S14", "volume_dl": 429}, {"id": "P061", "stop": "S14", "volume_dl": 599}, {"id": "P062", "stop": "S14", "volume_dl": 34}, {"id": "P063", "stop": "S14", "volume_dl": 840}, {"id": "P064", "stop": "S14", "volume_dl": 14}, {"id": "P065", "stop": "S14", "volume_dl": 179}, {"id": "P066", "stop": "S14", "volume_dl": 51}, {"id": "P067", "stop": "S15", "volume_dl": 57}, {"id": "P068", "stop": "S16", "volume_dl": 59}, {"id": "P069", "stop": "S16", "volume_dl": 104}, {"id": "P070", "stop": "S17", "volume_dl": 92}, {"id": "P071", "stop": "S18", "volume_dl": 51}, {"id": "P072", "stop": "S18", "volume_dl": 27}, {"id": "P073", "stop": "S19", "volume_dl": 226}, {"id": "P074", "stop": "S19", "volume_dl": 92}, {"id": "P075", "stop": "S20", "volume_dl": 134}, {"id": "P076", "stop": "S20", "volume_dl": 104}, {"id": "P077", "stop": "S20", "volume_dl": 92}, {"id": "P078", "stop": "S20", "volume_dl": 104}, {"id": "P079", "stop": "S20", "volume_dl": 48}, {"id": "P080", "stop": "S20", "volume_dl": 240}, {"id": "P081", "stop": "S20", "volume_dl": 57}, {"id": "P082", "stop": "S20", "volume_dl": 104}, {"id": "P083", "stop": "S20", "volume_dl": 16}, {"id": "P084", "stop": "S20", "volume_dl": 34}, {"id": "P085", "stop": "S20", "volume_dl": 6}, {"id": "P086", "stop": "S20", "volume_dl": 36}, {"id": "P087", "stop": "S20", "volume_dl": 29}, {"id": "P088", "stop": "S20", "volume_dl": 79}, {"id": "P089", "stop": "S20", "volume_dl": 179}, {"id": "P090", "stop": "S20", "volume_dl": 133}, {"id": "P091", "stop": "S20", "volume_dl": 363}, {"id": "P092", "stop": "S20", "volume_dl": 21}, {"id": "P093", "stop": "S20", "volume_dl": 179}, {"id": "P094", "stop": "S20", "volume_dl": 157}, {"id": "P095", "stop": "S20", "volume_dl": 779}, {"id": "P096", "stop": "S20", "volume_dl": 12}, {"id": "P097", "stop": "S20", "volume_dl": 55}, {"id": "P098", "stop": "S20", "volume_dl": 133}, {"id": "P099", "stop": "S20", "volume_dl": 92}, {"id": "P100", "stop": "S20", "volume_dl": 134}, {"id": "P101", "stop": "S20", "volume_dl": 95}, {"id": "P102", "stop": "S20", "volume_dl": 134}, {"id": "P103", "stop": "S20", "volume_dl": 324}, {"id": "P104", "stop": "S20", "volume_dl": 80}, {"id": "P105", "stop": "S20", "volume_dl": 134}, {"id": "P106", "stop": "S20", "volume_dl": 43}, {"id": "P107", "stop": "S20", "volume_dl": 322}, {"id": "P108", "stop": "S20", "volume_dl": 63}, {"id": "P109", "stop": "S20", "volume_dl": 20}, {"id": "P110", "stop": "S20", "volume_dl": 36}, {"id": "P111", "stop": "S20", "volume_dl": 45}, {"id": "P112", "stop": "S20", "volume_dl": 10}, {"id": "P113", "stop": "S20", "volume_dl": 368}, {"id": "P114", "stop": "S20", "volume_dl": 57}, {"id": "P115", "stop": "S20", "volume_dl": 59}, {"id": "P116", "stop": "S20", "volume_dl": 63}, {"id": "P117", "stop": "S20", "volume_dl": 91}, {"id": "P118", "stop": "S20", "volume_dl": 60}, {"id": "P119", "stop": "S20", "volume_dl": 63}, {"id": "P120", "stop": "S21", "volume_dl": 242}, {"id": "P121", "stop": "S21", "volume_dl": 63}, {"id": "P122", "stop": "S22", "volume_dl": 16}, {"id": "P123", "stop": "S23", "volume_dl": 79}, {"id": "P124", "stop": "S23", "volume_dl": 133}, {"id": "P125", "stop": "S24", "volume_dl": 92}, {"id": "P126", "stop": "S25", "volume_dl": 133}, {"id": "P127", "stop": "S25", "volume_dl": 188}, {"id": "P128", "stop": "S25", "volume_dl": 57}, {"id": "P129", "stop": "S25", "volume_dl": 57}, {"id": "P130", "stop": "S25", "volume_dl": 179}, {"id": "P131", "stop": "S25", "volume_dl": 57}, {"id": "P132", "stop": "S25", "volume_dl": 44}, {"id": "P133", "stop": "S26", "volume_dl": 34}, {"id": "P134", "stop": "S27", "volume_dl": 724}, {"id": "P135", "stop": "S27", "volume_dl": 133}, {"id": "P136", "stop": "S27", "volume_dl": 133}, {"id": "P137", "stop": "S27", "volume_dl": 57}, {"id": "P138", "stop": "S27", "volume_dl": 104}, {"id": "P139", "stop": "S27", "volume_dl": 157}, {"id": "P140", "stop": "S27", "volume_dl": 34}, {"id": "P141", "stop": "S27", "volume_dl": 57}, {"id": "P142", "stop": "S27", "volume_dl": 34}, {"id": "P143", "stop": "S27", "volume_dl": 134}, {"id": "P144", "stop": "S28", "volume_dl": 104}, {"id": "P145", "stop": "S28", "volume_dl": 43}, {"id": "P146", "stop": "S28", "volume_dl": 542}, {"id": "P147", "stop": "S29", "volume_dl": 57}, {"id": "P148", "stop": "S29", "volume_dl": 12}, {"id": "P149", "stop": "S30", "volume_dl": 11}, {"id": "P150", "stop": "S30", "volume_dl": 57}, {"id": "P151", "stop": "S30", "volume_dl": 95}, {"id": "P152", "stop": "S30", "volume_dl": 34}, {"id": "P153", "stop": "S30", "volume_dl": 259}, {"id": "P154", "stop": "S30", "volume_dl": 7}, {"id": "P155", "stop": "S30", "volume_dl": 104}], "vans": 4, "capacity_dl": 5221, "travel_s": [[0, 2087, 2176, 2078, 2189, 2085, 2191, 2161, 2128, 2185, 2038, 2142, 2101, 2020, 2134, 2140, 2139, 2170, 2149, 2062, 2120, 2238, 2213, 2176, 2235, 2056, 2124, 2114, 2054, 2202, 2146], [1935, 0, 141, 149, 67, 121, 210, 291, 101, 312, 193, 270, 89, 174, 197, 86, 53, 303, 160, 216, 133, 258, 329, 304, 358, 226, 98, 102, 143, 225, 332], [1998, 65, 0, 78, 131, 58, 102, 139, 94, 163, 82, 120, 152, 65, 60, 151, 121, 148, 35, 35, 151, 148, 191, 154, 213, 116, 90, 165, 32, 112, 180], [2038, 101, 116, 0, 175, 97, 125, 118, 139, 136, 52, 47, 194, 69, 127, 190, 154, 127, 89, 99, 166, 138, 171, 81, 193, 83, 136, 204, 122, 107, 46], [2003, 72, 90, 148, 0, 50, 172, 255, 32, 280, 167, 230, 154, 149, 133, 113, 123, 263, 121, 128, 112, 216, 288, 264, 320, 201, 26, 170, 121, 183, 293], [1953, 15, 70, 96, 87, 0, 164, 249, 42, 273, 117, 130, 105, 99, 128, 104, 74, 258, 84, 98, 96, 210, 283, 164, 312, 151, 39, 118, 90, 174, 129], [2058, 176, 109, 116, 228, 172, 0, 84, 189, 102, 168, 61, 288, 185, 68, 179, 178, 94, 205, 121, 252, 41, 119, 97, 148, 199, 185, 299, 161, 11, 121], [2150, 229, 237, 217, 296, 218, 222, 0, 260, 18, 240, 162, 313, 258, 224, 312, 276, 9, 214, 196, 288, 177, 138, 180, 74, 272, 257, 326, 208, 203, 167], [2057, 122, 59, 137, 193, 117, 161, 198, 0, 222, 141, 179, 211, 124, 119, 210, 180, 207, 251, 99, 228, 207, 250, 213, 272, 176, 156, 224, 91, 171, 239], [2126, 198, 212, 193, 269, 194, 198, 128, 236, 0, 216, 138, 288, 234, 199, 288, 252, 137, 190, 172, 264, 153, 114, 156, 50, 247, 233, 301, 183, 179, 143], [1990, 104, 118, 62, 175, 99, 140, 177, 141, 201, 0, 109, 193, 17, 98, 192, 162, 186, 184, 73, 162, 186, 188, 145, 252, 34, 138, 206, 70, 154, 108], [2053, 116, 130, 55, 190, 111, 78, 71, 153, 95, 107, 0, 205, 124, 80, 204, 174, 80, 202, 60, 215, 96, 124, 34, 146, 138, 150, 218, 100, 60, 60], [2035, 104, 148, 154, 172, 78, 242, 281, 120, 299, 101, 210, 0, 84, 206, 186, 203, 290, 129, 138, 50, 289, 289, 244, 356, 136, 117, 10, 136, 256, 209], [1973, 86, 101, 77, 160, 82, 123, 160, 124, 184, 17, 126, 176, 0, 81, 175, 145, 169, 167, 61, 143, 169, 205, 160, 234, 52, 121, 189, 53, 134, 125], [2032, 144, 41, 158, 180, 129, 42, 126, 127, 151, 209, 102, 238, 106, 0, 110, 127, 135, 76, 163, 191, 88, 161, 137, 190, 241, 124, 243, 73, 52, 163], [1993, 231, 198, 252, 163, 216, 213, 298, 196, 322, 332, 274, 239, 315, 204, 0, 150, 307, 299, 334, 230, 260, 332, 308, 361, 367, 192, 252, 247, 224, 334], [1973, 118, 148, 161, 44, 102, 153, 238, 82, 256, 211, 214, 102, 194, 134, 30, 0, 247, 142, 157, 157, 194, 273, 250, 302, 240, 79, 115, 161, 167, 274], [2141, 214, 228, 208, 288, 209, 213, 143, 252, 15, 232, 153, 304, 249, 215, 303, 272, 0, 300, 195, 313, 152, 129, 169, 65, 263, 248, 317, 199, 196, 158], [1967, 66, 80, 56, 137, 153, 102, 213, 195, 230, 33, 142, 192, 16, 61, 261, 153, 222, 0, 70, 139, 178, 221, 178, 287, 67, 192, 169, 33, 150, 140], [2052, 196, 82, 135, 154, 191, 65, 98, 233, 116, 187, 80, 288, 204, 20, 192, 196, 108, 224, 0, 260, 103, 151, 116, 173, 218, 230, 298, 180, 75, 140], [1988, 128, 136, 116, 196, 174, 158, 234, 217, 258, 54, 163, 210, 37, 117, 282, 175, 243, 22, 92, 0, 199, 242, 197, 309, 89, 213, 225, 89, 169, 162], [2112, 238, 252, 232, 249, 170, 236, 38, 213, 56, 203, 96, 327, 221, 159, 240, 228, 47, 166, 130, 302, 0, 73, 115, 113, 235, 210, 278, 160, 42, 120], [2076, 139, 154, 79, 211, 134, 102, 95, 177, 119, 130, 24, 229, 148, 86, 228, 198, 104, 226, 66, 238, 120, 0, 40, 169, 162, 174, 242, 124, 84, 84], [2078, 224, 106, 161, 291, 217, 86, 125, 259, 143, 211, 106, 309, 230, 44, 218, 222, 134, 251, 18, 284, 129, 178, 0, 200, 242, 256, 322, 204, 102, 164], [2076, 218, 233, 176, 290, 213, 234, 164, 256, 188, 250, 174, 308, 268, 231, 307, 276, 173, 304, 211, 317, 173, 150, 190, 0, 282, 252, 321, 203, 217, 163], [1998, 150, 164, 85, 221, 145, 186, 203, 187, 227, 46, 132, 239, 63, 144, 238, 202, 212, 231, 119, 209, 215, 211, 166, 277, 0, 184, 252, 116, 192, 130], [2060, 125, 63, 140, 196, 120, 164, 201, 3, 225, 144, 182, 214, 127, 122, 214, 183, 210, 254, 102, 231, 210, 253, 216, 275, 179, 0, 227, 94, 175, 242], [2025, 93, 137, 143, 162, 68, 232, 271, 110, 288, 91, 199, 182, 73, 196, 176, 193, 280, 118, 128, 36, 278, 279, 234, 345, 125, 107, 0, 125, 242, 198], [2060, 204, 90, 143, 275, 199, 70, 107, 241, 131, 195, 88, 293, 212, 28, 200, 204, 116, 232, 3, 268, 116, 159, 122, 181, 226, 238, 306, 0, 80, 148], [2074, 189, 128, 124, 249, 180, 16, 74, 205, 92, 178, 69, 305, 193, 84, 196, 200, 83, 213, 120, 269, 30, 108, 105, 137, 207, 202, 315, 169, 0, 129], [1993, 56, 70, 89, 127, 51, 110, 147, 93, 172, 93, 128, 145, 76, 68, 144, 108, 156, 142, 43, 120, 156, 200, 162, 222, 128, 90, 158, 40, 124, 0]]}, "reference": {"optimum_s": 17395, "optimality": "best_found", "lower_bound_s": 16648, "floor_s": 15820, "solve_s": 80.37, "ffd_s": 19447, "stop_aware_best_s": 18623, "stop_aware_mean_s": 18734.8, "route_id": "RouteID_a5b39b89-d8b8-4a83-a501-fb5aa0167346", "plans": {"optimum": [{"route": ["S20", "S18", "S01", "S04", "S26", "S08", "S02"], "parcels": ["P001", "P081", "P082", "P084", "P087", "P088", "P089", "P090", "P092", "P095", "P096", "P097", "P098", "P101", "P103", "P104", "P107", "P114", "P118", "P119"]}, {"route": ["S13", "S10", "S25", "S03", "S30", "S05", "S01", "S16", "S15"], "parcels": ["P002", "P003", "P004", "P005", "P006", "P007", "P008", "P009", "P010", "P011", "P012", "P013", "P014", "P015"]}, {"route": ["S28", "S14", "S06", "S29", "S21", "S07", "S17", "S09", "S24", "S22", "S11", "S23", "S19"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S12", "S27", "S20"], "parcels": ["P075", "P076", "P077", "P078", "P079", "P080", "P083", "P085", "P086", "P091", "P093", "P094", "P099", "P100", "P102", "P105", "P106", "P108", "P109", "P110", "P111", "P112", "P113", "P115", "P116", "P117"]}], "ffd": [{"route": ["S27", "S20", "S28", "S14", "S04"], "parcels": ["P027", "P028", "P060", "P061", "P063", "P066", "P095", "P134", "P146"]}, {"route": ["S19", "S14", "S06", "S21", "S30", "S01", "S04", "S08", "S12", "S20", "S13", "S25"], "parcels": ["P002", "P004", "P026", "P031", "P039", "P054", "P056", "P065", "P073", "P080", "P089", "P091", "P093", "P103", "P107", "P113", "P120", "P127", "P130", "P153"]}, {"route": ["S28", "S06", "S23", "S19", "S07", "S17", "S09", "S24", "S03", "S30", "S01", "S16", "S04", "S12", "S27", "S20", "S10", "S25"], "parcels": ["P003", "P005", "P007", "P008", "P011", "P012", "P021", "P030", "P034", "P036", "P038", "P040", "P043", "P048", "P052", "P057", "P069", "P074", "P075", "P076", "P077", "P078", "P082", "P088", "P090", "P094", "P098", "P099", "P100", "P101", "P102", "P104", "P105", "P117", "P124", "P126", "P135", "P136", "P138", "P139", "P143", "P144", "P151", "P155"]}, {"route": ["S12", "S27", "S20", "S18", "S10", "S25", "S03", "S30", "S05", "S01", "S16", "S04", "S26", "S02", "S28", "S06", "S29", "S21", "S07", "S09", "S22", "S11", "S23", "S14", "S15"], "parcels": ["P001", "P006", "P009", "P010", "P013", "P014", "P015", "P019", "P020", "P022", "P023", "P024", "P025", "P029", "P032", "P033", "P037", "P041", "P044", "P045", "P046", "P047", "P049", "P051", "P053", "P055", "P058", "P062", "P064", "P068", "P079", "P081", "P083", "P084", "P085", "P086", "P087", "P092", "P096", "P097", "P106", "P108", "P109", "P110", "P111", "P112", "P114", "P115", "P116", "P118", "P119", "P121", "P123", "P128", "P129", "P131", "P132", "P137", "P140", "P141", "P142", "P145", "P149", "P150", "P152", "P154"]}], "stop_aware_best": [{"route": ["S19", "S06", "S17", "S09", "S24", "S22", "S14", "S18"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S25", "S23", "S29", "S30", "S01", "S04", "S08", "S15"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S13", "S10", "S03", "S11", "S02", "S16", "S27", "S20"], "parcels": ["P075", "P078", "P081", "P082", "P083", "P085", "P089", "P091", "P093", "P094", "P098", "P101", "P102", "P104", "P110", "P112", "P113", "P114", "P115", "P116", "P118"]}, {"route": ["S12", "S20", "S28", "S21", "S07", "S05", "S26"], "parcels": ["P076", "P077", "P079", "P080", "P084", "P086", "P087", "P088", "P090", "P092", "P095", "P096", "P097", "P099", "P100", "P103", "P105", "P106", "P107", "P108", "P109", "P111", "P117", "P119"]}]}}, "meta": {"route_id": "RouteID_a5b39b89-d8b8-4a83-a501-fb5aa0167346", "split": "train", "stops": 30, "vans": 4, "tightness": 0.89, "station": "DCH1", "city": "DCH", "date": "2018-08-08", "seconds": 140.7, "stop_aware_best_reward": 0.3846, "optimality": "best_found"}}
{"id": "f13b27b8-spread-n40-k4-t0.86-s0", "instance": {"stops": ["S01", "S02", "S03", "S04", "S05", "S06", "S07", "S08", "S09", "S10", "S11", "S12", "S13", "S14", "S15", "S16", "S17", "S18", "S19", "S20", "S21", "S22", "S23", "S24", "S25", "S26", "S27", "S28", "S29", "S30", "S31", "S32", "S33", "S34", "S35", "S36", "S37", "S38", "S39", "S40"], "parcels": [{"id": "P01", "stop": "S01", "volume_dl": 324}, {"id": "P02", "stop": "S02", "volume_dl": 63}, {"id": "P03", "stop": "S03", "volume_dl": 133}, {"id": "P04", "stop": "S04", "volume_dl": 157}, {"id": "P05", "stop": "S04", "volume_dl": 779}, {"id": "P06", "stop": "S05", "volume_dl": 179}, {"id": "P07", "stop": "S06", "volume_dl": 57}, {"id": "P08", "stop": "S07", "volume_dl": 133}, {"id": "P09", "stop": "S08", "volume_dl": 104}, {"id": "P10", "stop": "S09", "volume_dl": 57}, {"id": "P11", "stop": "S09", "volume_dl": 429}, {"id": "P12", "stop": "S10", "volume_dl": 17}, {"id": "P13", "stop": "S10", "volume_dl": 242}, {"id": "P14", "stop": "S11", "volume_dl": 45}, {"id": "P15", "stop": "S12", "volume_dl": 429}, {"id": "P16", "stop": "S13", "volume_dl": 133}, {"id": "P17", "stop": "S14", "volume_dl": 477}, {"id": "P18", "stop": "S14", "volume_dl": 95}, {"id": "P19", "stop": "S14", "volume_dl": 6}, {"id": "P20", "stop": "S15", "volume_dl": 133}, {"id": "P21", "stop": "S15", "volume_dl": 157}, {"id": "P22", "stop": "S16", "volume_dl": 226}, {"id": "P23", "stop": "S17", "volume_dl": 28}, {"id": "P24", "stop": "S17", "volume_dl": 31}, {"id": "P25", "stop": "S18", "volume_dl": 133}, {"id": "P26", "stop": "S19", "volume_dl": 34}, {"id": "P27", "stop": "S19", "volume_dl": 10}, {"id": "P28", "stop": "S19", "volume_dl": 30}, {"id": "P29", "stop": "S20", "volume_dl": 63}, {"id": "P30", "stop": "S20", "volume_dl": 179}, {"id": "P31", "stop": "S20", "volume_dl": 133}, {"id": "P32", "stop": "S21", "volume_dl": 49}, {"id": "P33", "stop": "S22", "volume_dl": 13}, {"id": "P34", "stop": "S23", "volume_dl": 63}, {"id": "P35", "stop": "S24", "volume_dl": 57}, {"id": "P36", "stop": "S25", "volume_dl": 179}, {"id": "P37", "stop": "S25", "volume_dl": 179}, {"id": "P38", "stop": "S26", "volume_dl": 322}, {"id": "P39", "stop": "S27", "volume_dl": 166}, {"id": "P40", "stop": "S27", "volume_dl": 12}, {"id": "P41", "stop": "S27", "volume_dl": 57}, {"id": "P42", "stop": "S27", "volume_dl": 120}, {"id": "P43", "stop": "S27", "volume_dl": 104}, {"id": "P44", "stop": "S28", "volume_dl": 133}, {"id": "P45", "stop": "S28", "volume_dl": 9}, {"id": "P46", "stop": "S29", "volume_dl": 92}, {"id": "P47", "stop": "S29", "volume_dl": 157}, {"id": "P48", "stop": "S29", "volume_dl": 95}, {"id": "P49", "stop": "S29", "volume_dl": 74}, {"id": "P50", "stop": "S30", "volume_dl": 95}, {"id": "P51", "stop": "S30", "volume_dl": 59}, {"id": "P52", "stop": "S31", "volume_dl": 259}, {"id": "P53", "stop": "S31", "volume_dl": 157}, {"id": "P54", "stop": "S32", "volume_dl": 57}, {"id": "P55", "stop": "S33", "volume_dl": 57}, {"id": "P56", "stop": "S34", "volume_dl": 59}, {"id": "P57", "stop": "S35", "volume_dl": 11}, {"id": "P58", "stop": "S36", "volume_dl": 36}, {"id": "P59", "stop": "S37", "volume_dl": 157}, {"id": "P60", "stop": "S37", "volume_dl": 242}, {"id": "P61", "stop": "S38", "volume_dl": 134}, {"id": "P62", "stop": "S38", "volume_dl": 104}, {"id": "P63", "stop": "S39", "volume_dl": 11}, {"id": "P64", "stop": "S40", "volume_dl": 104}, {"id": "P65", "stop": "S40", "volume_dl": 133}, {"id": "P66", "stop": "S40", "volume_dl": 20}], "vans": 4, "capacity_dl": 2500, "travel_s": [[0, 1931, 2053, 2012, 2011, 1918, 1946, 2051, 1936, 1947, 2004, 2005, 1865, 1857, 1984, 2002, 1913, 1984, 1923, 1898, 2034, 1993, 1848, 1852, 1871, 2003, 1916, 1851, 1804, 1937, 1804, 1920, 1957, 1974, 1965, 1856, 1976, 1939, 1898, 2054, 1956], [1854, 0, 144, 270, 122, 217, 226, 309, 263, 192, 309, 192, 182, 244, 231, 259, 348, 296, 299, 149, 110, 312, 199, 189, 304, 226, 141, 209, 148, 184, 334, 342, 235, 76, 209, 378, 289, 292, 183, 162, 81], [1983, 199, 0, 152, 64, 170, 108, 191, 145, 291, 406, 74, 220, 360, 328, 141, 465, 436, 425, 246, 34, 409, 237, 316, 192, 108, 134, 335, 264, 299, 444, 468, 366, 214, 374, 471, 417, 201, 309, 18, 155], [1956, 264, 141, 0, 175, 210, 37, 39, 165, 397, 512, 93, 276, 400, 434, 6, 505, 488, 466, 352, 176, 492, 293, 379, 121, 91, 215, 398, 305, 408, 495, 511, 456, 320, 470, 522, 480, 221, 373, 142, 218], [1921, 138, 74, 177, 0, 106, 134, 216, 170, 270, 384, 99, 174, 314, 305, 167, 419, 362, 363, 224, 42, 366, 191, 253, 218, 152, 90, 273, 231, 280, 402, 403, 345, 193, 345, 431, 355, 222, 240, 93, 106], [1859, 200, 190, 240, 120, 0, 197, 279, 77, 370, 423, 126, 77, 242, 407, 229, 347, 390, 307, 324, 161, 400, 94, 257, 173, 196, 75, 236, 147, 370, 306, 353, 364, 264, 368, 333, 389, 115, 278, 191, 154], [1919, 230, 107, 67, 141, 176, 0, 106, 131, 360, 475, 59, 242, 366, 397, 56, 471, 454, 432, 315, 142, 458, 259, 345, 84, 57, 181, 364, 271, 368, 461, 477, 435, 283, 436, 488, 446, 187, 339, 108, 184], [1977, 285, 163, 21, 196, 232, 58, 0, 186, 419, 534, 115, 297, 422, 456, 27, 527, 509, 487, 374, 197, 513, 314, 400, 143, 112, 236, 420, 326, 427, 517, 532, 477, 341, 492, 543, 502, 242, 394, 164, 239], [1884, 254, 131, 181, 165, 77, 138, 220, 0, 405, 476, 67, 110, 295, 442, 170, 399, 443, 360, 360, 166, 452, 127, 310, 117, 137, 128, 288, 199, 413, 330, 405, 417, 310, 460, 357, 441, 70, 330, 132, 208], [1889, 196, 298, 444, 291, 391, 401, 483, 438, 0, 171, 366, 356, 204, 94, 434, 236, 169, 179, 174, 265, 174, 374, 149, 485, 420, 315, 167, 238, 8, 290, 219, 110, 150, 84, 264, 164, 486, 102, 316, 232], [1925, 314, 416, 537, 389, 451, 493, 576, 503, 163, 0, 459, 432, 229, 121, 526, 171, 79, 145, 293, 383, 33, 444, 239, 553, 512, 416, 270, 304, 154, 305, 90, 85, 268, 140, 252, 36, 541, 201, 434, 354], [1955, 187, 64, 114, 98, 117, 70, 153, 71, 337, 452, 0, 183, 307, 374, 103, 412, 410, 372, 292, 98, 414, 200, 301, 140, 70, 138, 321, 212, 345, 402, 418, 378, 242, 393, 428, 403, 128, 295, 65, 141], [1806, 181, 234, 293, 176, 77, 249, 332, 130, 349, 404, 179, 0, 223, 386, 282, 328, 371, 288, 304, 201, 381, 17, 238, 199, 249, 88, 217, 128, 345, 253, 334, 345, 236, 374, 280, 370, 151, 259, 244, 117], [1811, 240, 365, 415, 320, 260, 371, 454, 312, 204, 199, 301, 242, 0, 196, 404, 123, 166, 83, 226, 344, 176, 258, 100, 362, 371, 226, 79, 114, 193, 90, 129, 140, 257, 195, 141, 165, 365, 94, 366, 266], [1969, 237, 339, 483, 331, 408, 439, 522, 460, 88, 121, 405, 395, 185, 0, 472, 196, 138, 139, 226, 304, 132, 412, 188, 510, 439, 354, 205, 261, 75, 278, 184, 70, 191, 63, 212, 124, 498, 147, 357, 282], [1950, 258, 135, 11, 169, 204, 31, 50, 159, 393, 506, 87, 270, 394, 429, 0, 499, 482, 460, 346, 168, 486, 287, 373, 115, 104, 209, 392, 300, 400, 487, 522, 450, 314, 464, 516, 474, 215, 360, 136, 225], [1851, 353, 477, 527, 432, 373, 484, 566, 434, 248, 169, 413, 357, 158, 214, 516, 0, 94, 70, 338, 456, 146, 340, 213, 475, 483, 338, 192, 226, 237, 190, 70, 135, 358, 244, 148, 128, 447, 207, 478, 378], [1897, 304, 438, 519, 372, 399, 476, 558, 450, 185, 75, 439, 380, 176, 145, 508, 92, 0, 97, 308, 405, 52, 396, 191, 501, 475, 364, 217, 252, 179, 257, 82, 68, 290, 162, 204, 34, 488, 177, 446, 330], [1830, 294, 435, 485, 361, 331, 442, 524, 393, 178, 124, 371, 316, 111, 144, 474, 65, 91, 0, 296, 402, 100, 299, 171, 453, 441, 296, 150, 184, 169, 160, 71, 65, 288, 174, 106, 89, 405, 154, 436, 320], [1834, 159, 261, 386, 239, 291, 343, 425, 343, 97, 212, 308, 272, 218, 132, 376, 299, 242, 241, 0, 228, 215, 298, 246, 393, 362, 256, 266, 144, 105, 296, 281, 172, 113, 180, 344, 226, 381, 205, 279, 194], [1952, 170, 32, 184, 31, 137, 141, 223, 178, 269, 384, 106, 187, 327, 306, 174, 431, 393, 394, 224, 0, 387, 204, 284, 225, 140, 101, 304, 232, 280, 409, 434, 344, 192, 353, 438, 386, 234, 272, 51, 132], [1933, 281, 383, 514, 366, 425, 470, 552, 477, 132, 23, 436, 406, 203, 100, 503, 155, 63, 122, 260, 349, 0, 421, 216, 527, 470, 390, 235, 278, 121, 282, 116, 53, 235, 107, 229, 60, 528, 178, 401, 324], [1789, 198, 251, 303, 193, 94, 256, 342, 122, 366, 421, 189, 17, 240, 403, 292, 345, 388, 305, 321, 218, 398, 0, 255, 182, 259, 103, 234, 145, 362, 236, 351, 362, 254, 391, 263, 387, 134, 276, 254, 134], [1814, 191, 332, 406, 258, 254, 362, 445, 305, 149, 227, 294, 234, 98, 203, 395, 203, 196, 163, 176, 299, 204, 252, 0, 356, 362, 219, 20, 107, 138, 198, 210, 168, 185, 184, 224, 193, 343, 60, 333, 217], [1834, 304, 182, 141, 215, 159, 74, 180, 132, 399, 514, 134, 217, 349, 436, 130, 454, 498, 415, 354, 216, 517, 234, 364, 0, 131, 182, 343, 254, 410, 439, 460, 474, 322, 483, 472, 496, 130, 385, 182, 258], [2013, 231, 108, 82, 142, 177, 38, 120, 131, 383, 496, 60, 243, 367, 419, 71, 472, 455, 432, 336, 150, 458, 260, 345, 122, 0, 182, 365, 272, 392, 459, 495, 422, 287, 437, 488, 447, 188, 333, 109, 198], [1860, 133, 141, 228, 85, 78, 184, 267, 131, 294, 384, 114, 86, 226, 331, 217, 331, 357, 291, 249, 107, 360, 104, 248, 176, 184, 0, 220, 130, 297, 311, 337, 325, 189, 339, 337, 349, 169, 242, 160, 87], [1795, 212, 338, 388, 280, 234, 344, 427, 285, 168, 248, 274, 215, 78, 224, 378, 183, 217, 144, 197, 318, 225, 232, 21, 336, 363, 199, 0, 86, 162, 175, 200, 189, 206, 205, 212, 214, 324, 81, 339, 238], [1730, 126, 251, 301, 207, 147, 258, 340, 198, 202, 276, 187, 128, 95, 252, 291, 200, 243, 160, 154, 232, 253, 145, 110, 249, 276, 112, 89, 0, 193, 183, 208, 217, 200, 221, 218, 242, 237, 138, 252, 165], [1881, 185, 290, 433, 282, 380, 392, 472, 427, 8, 180, 355, 346, 193, 90, 425, 225, 160, 170, 164, 257, 185, 363, 138, 474, 409, 304, 161, 227, 0, 281, 208, 99, 139, 73, 253, 153, 477, 97, 305, 225], [1738, 333, 458, 508, 410, 316, 478, 547, 340, 296, 281, 394, 263, 93, 275, 497, 194, 248, 158, 323, 435, 258, 246, 204, 404, 483, 319, 180, 206, 290, 0, 224, 222, 361, 295, 102, 247, 352, 195, 459, 372], [1833, 338, 463, 513, 418, 359, 469, 552, 410, 221, 88, 399, 340, 136, 194, 502, 70, 77, 73, 324, 443, 121, 372, 198, 461, 488, 324, 177, 211, 209, 219, 0, 110, 333, 231, 178, 78, 448, 199, 464, 377], [1900, 245, 386, 461, 313, 372, 417, 500, 424, 129, 59, 383, 353, 150, 79, 450, 127, 61, 69, 250, 354, 36, 368, 162, 474, 417, 338, 182, 225, 121, 229, 112, 0, 240, 126, 176, 54, 474, 125, 387, 271], [1828, 77, 179, 327, 173, 274, 284, 366, 320, 140, 255, 249, 239, 212, 177, 316, 336, 285, 278, 95, 145, 258, 256, 185, 368, 283, 198, 204, 138, 148, 293, 322, 209, 0, 183, 320, 263, 370, 178, 197, 126], [1967, 274, 376, 528, 371, 475, 484, 567, 521, 125, 255, 450, 441, 244, 167, 517, 280, 215, 223, 254, 342, 238, 458, 233, 567, 484, 399, 253, 319, 114, 341, 266, 154, 228, 0, 312, 208, 568, 192, 394, 323], [1820, 381, 494, 545, 449, 340, 498, 583, 364, 265, 235, 431, 287, 144, 229, 534, 147, 202, 112, 338, 468, 212, 270, 237, 424, 501, 345, 216, 243, 257, 133, 180, 176, 373, 245, 0, 201, 376, 221, 496, 407], [1900, 285, 426, 500, 353, 412, 457, 539, 464, 169, 47, 422, 393, 189, 128, 489, 135, 42, 109, 290, 394, 51, 408, 202, 514, 456, 377, 222, 265, 161, 269, 73, 49, 279, 160, 215, 0, 514, 164, 427, 311], [1896, 293, 188, 227, 221, 115, 160, 266, 55, 461, 516, 124, 148, 334, 496, 216, 439, 483, 400, 416, 221, 492, 154, 349, 86, 194, 168, 328, 240, 469, 340, 445, 456, 366, 460, 370, 481, 0, 377, 188, 259], [1838, 186, 327, 401, 254, 277, 358, 440, 328, 107, 187, 317, 258, 95, 142, 391, 200, 161, 161, 184, 289, 164, 275, 59, 379, 376, 242, 79, 130, 98, 181, 201, 128, 180, 144, 218, 153, 373, 0, 328, 225], [1994, 180, 29, 143, 93, 182, 100, 182, 136, 272, 387, 65, 247, 372, 309, 132, 474, 418, 417, 227, 63, 390, 264, 326, 184, 99, 162, 346, 277, 280, 467, 460, 348, 196, 356, 494, 401, 193, 320, 0, 162], [1889, 62, 109, 232, 90, 164, 189, 271, 226, 224, 339, 154, 127, 278, 261, 222, 382, 332, 334, 174, 72, 337, 144, 224, 266, 188, 104, 235, 182, 224, 376, 377, 275, 116, 249, 402, 324, 254, 218, 128, 0]]}, "reference": {"optimum_s": 17524, "optimality": "best_found", "lower_bound_s": 15662, "floor_s": 14136, "solve_s": 77.33, "ffd_s": 20231, "stop_aware_best_s": 19305, "stop_aware_mean_s": 19442.4, "route_id": "RouteID_f13b27b8-c37c-44c0-8615-7361411a8776", "plans": {"optimum": [{"route": ["S19", "S01", "S40", "S20", "S04", "S05", "S08", "S37"], "parcels": ["P29", "P31"]}, {"route": ["S35", "S16", "S31", "S17", "S36", "S10", "S21", "S34", "S33", "S20", "S02", "S39", "S11", "S25", "S07", "S03", "S15", "S06", "S24"], "parcels": ["P30"]}, {"route": ["S23", "S27", "S28", "S26", "S12", "S22"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S30", "S13", "S18", "S32", "S14", "S29", "S09", "S38"], "parcels": []}], "ffd": [{"route": ["S30", "S14", "S09", "S01", "S04", "S12"], "parcels": ["P05", "P11", "P17", "P51"]}, {"route": ["S22", "S05", "S37", "S25", "S15", "S20", "S04", "S26", "S27", "S10", "S31", "S16"], "parcels": ["P04", "P13", "P21", "P30", "P39", "P52", "P60"]}, {"route": ["S30", "S13", "S31", "S18", "S14", "S29", "S38", "S27", "S28", "S19", "S40", "S20", "S07", "S03", "S15", "S08", "S37"], "parcels": ["P18", "P20", "P27", "P31", "P42", "P43", "P44", "P47", "P48", "P50", "P53", "P59", "P64", "P65"]}, {"route": ["S24", "S06", "S11", "S39", "S02", "S20", "S40", "S33", "S19", "S09", "S29", "S14", "S34", "S32", "S21", "S10", "S36", "S17", "S35", "S23", "S27", "S28"], "parcels": ["P10", "P12", "P19", "P26", "P28", "P29", "P40", "P41", "P45", "P46", "P49", "P66"]}], "stop_aware_best": [{"route": ["S22", "S08", "S11", "S39", "S02", "S04", "S19", "S29", "S18", "S35", "S27", "S28"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S37", "S25", "S07", "S15", "S20", "S10", "S36", "S31", "S16"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S12", "S05", "S26", "S03", "S06", "S33", "S09", "S14", "S30"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S24", "S40", "S01", "S34", "S32", "S21", "S17", "S13", "S38", "S23"], "parcels": []}]}}, "meta": {"route_id": "RouteID_f13b27b8-c37c-44c0-8615-7361411a8776", "split": "train", "stops": 40, "vans": 4, "tightness": 0.86, "station": "DCH1", "city": "DCH", "date": "2018-07-20", "seconds": 138.5, "stop_aware_best_reward": 0.4881, "optimality": "best_found"}}
{"id": "0670d3ac-spread-n20-k3-t0.92-s0", "instance": {"stops": ["S01", "S02", "S03", "S04", "S05", "S06", "S07", "S08", "S09", "S10", "S11", "S12", "S13", "S14", "S15", "S16", "S17", "S18", "S19", "S20"], "parcels": [{"id": "P01", "stop": "S01", "volume_dl": 26}, {"id": "P02", "stop": "S02", "volume_dl": 157}, {"id": "P03", "stop": "S03", "volume_dl": 14}, {"id": "P04", "stop": "S04", "volume_dl": 29}, {"id": "P05", "stop": "S05", "volume_dl": 27}, {"id": "P06", "stop": "S05", "volume_dl": 19}, {"id": "P07", "stop": "S06", "volume_dl": 37}, {"id": "P08", "stop": "S07", "volume_dl": 368}, {"id": "P09", "stop": "S08", "volume_dl": 133}, {"id": "P10", "stop": "S08", "volume_dl": 28}, {"id": "P11", "stop": "S09", "volume_dl": 226}, {"id": "P12", "stop": "S09", "volume_dl": 32}, {"id": "P13", "stop": "S10", "volume_dl": 30}, {"id": "P14", "stop": "S11", "volume_dl": 9}, {"id": "P15", "stop": "S12", "volume_dl": 12}, {"id": "P16", "stop": "S13", "volume_dl": 179}, {"id": "P17", "stop": "S14", "volume_dl": 157}, {"id": "P18", "stop": "S15", "volume_dl": 63}, {"id": "P19", "stop": "S16", "volume_dl": 42}, {"id": "P20", "stop": "S17", "volume_dl": 542}, {"id": "P21", "stop": "S18", "volume_dl": 104}, {"id": "P22", "stop": "S19", "volume_dl": 15}, {"id": "P23", "stop": "S20", "volume_dl": 34}], "vans": 3, "capacity_dl": 827, "travel_s": [[0, 2677, 2909, 2887, 2794, 2790, 2795, 2912, 2812, 2843, 2980, 2650, 3016, 2940, 2826, 2811, 2805, 3095, 2696, 2716, 2725], [2762, 0, 434, 397, 322, 237, 323, 430, 340, 416, 602, 149, 589, 514, 336, 322, 333, 568, 142, 226, 235], [3069, 434, 0, 267, 633, 548, 634, 741, 651, 463, 325, 277, 518, 502, 109, 80, 644, 291, 453, 239, 249], [3185, 550, 287, 0, 777, 622, 749, 778, 767, 491, 473, 392, 666, 588, 204, 190, 788, 438, 569, 228, 238], [2887, 302, 628, 606, 0, 278, 136, 212, 121, 520, 657, 369, 693, 617, 545, 530, 27, 772, 216, 435, 444], [2906, 235, 566, 529, 288, 0, 326, 289, 344, 548, 734, 281, 720, 645, 467, 453, 300, 700, 95, 358, 367], [2900, 314, 640, 618, 129, 310, 0, 294, 17, 532, 670, 381, 705, 630, 557, 543, 157, 785, 228, 448, 456], [3078, 438, 794, 772, 204, 288, 289, 0, 306, 686, 823, 483, 858, 783, 710, 696, 215, 938, 297, 601, 610], [2915, 330, 656, 634, 112, 326, 15, 324, 0, 547, 685, 396, 720, 645, 572, 558, 139, 800, 243, 463, 471], [2989, 405, 344, 459, 525, 519, 526, 642, 543, 0, 138, 247, 173, 98, 301, 272, 536, 253, 424, 431, 441], [3127, 543, 329, 463, 663, 657, 664, 781, 681, 138, 0, 386, 193, 177, 393, 362, 674, 115, 562, 435, 445], [2792, 158, 284, 381, 356, 271, 357, 464, 374, 267, 453, 0, 439, 364, 242, 212, 367, 419, 176, 210, 219], [3161, 577, 501, 632, 697, 691, 698, 815, 715, 172, 172, 420, 0, 211, 473, 444, 708, 287, 596, 603, 613], [3097, 513, 452, 567, 633, 627, 634, 751, 651, 108, 167, 356, 202, 0, 409, 380, 644, 282, 532, 539, 549], [3014, 380, 117, 212, 578, 493, 579, 686, 596, 320, 390, 222, 493, 418, 0, 19, 589, 356, 398, 183, 194], [2995, 360, 98, 187, 559, 474, 560, 667, 577, 301, 366, 203, 474, 399, 29, 0, 570, 332, 379, 159, 169], [2908, 323, 649, 627, 17, 299, 154, 234, 138, 541, 679, 390, 714, 639, 566, 552, 0, 794, 237, 456, 465], [3242, 658, 294, 428, 777, 772, 778, 895, 796, 253, 114, 500, 308, 292, 358, 328, 789, 0, 677, 400, 410], [2798, 140, 471, 434, 213, 95, 214, 288, 232, 453, 639, 186, 626, 550, 372, 358, 224, 605, 0, 263, 272], [3041, 406, 240, 218, 604, 520, 605, 691, 623, 443, 425, 248, 618, 541, 156, 142, 616, 391, 425, 0, 77], [3107, 472, 259, 237, 671, 553, 672, 709, 689, 463, 444, 315, 638, 560, 176, 161, 682, 410, 491, 66, 0]]}, "reference": {"optimum_s": 19837, "optimality": "best_found", "lower_bound_s": 18476, "floor_s": 16236, "solve_s": 38.24, "ffd_s": 21993, "stop_aware_best_s": 21381, "stop_aware_mean_s": 21687.8, "route_id": "RouteID_0670d3ac-1ad6-4d1a-8f91-07d7b3077b5e", "plans": {"optimum": [{"route": ["S06", "S08", "S16", "S04", "S07", "S05", "S18", "S01"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S09", "S02", "S15", "S14", "S11"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S20", "S19", "S03", "S17", "S10", "S12", "S13"], "parcels": []}], "ffd": [{"route": ["S19", "S17", "S09", "S16"], "parcels": ["P11"]}, {"route": ["S13", "S02", "S18", "S05", "S07"], "parcels": ["P06"]}, {"route": ["S20", "S03", "S14", "S15", "S10", "S12", "S09", "S11", "S01", "S05", "S04", "S08", "S06"], "parcels": ["P05", "P12"]}], "stop_aware_best": [{"route": ["S09", "S07", "S04", "S08"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S20", "S19", "S14", "S15", "S02", "S12", "S13", "S11", "S05", "S18"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S03", "S17", "S10", "S16", "S06", "S01"], "parcels": []}]}}, "meta": {"route_id": "RouteID_0670d3ac-1ad6-4d1a-8f91-07d7b3077b5e", "split": "train", "stops": 20, "vans": 3, "tightness": 0.92, "station": "DBO3", "city": "DBO", "date": "2018-08-03", "seconds": 48.6, "stop_aware_best_reward": 0.5473, "optimality": "best_found"}}
{"id": "a78947fa-spread-n25-k3-t0.94-s0", "instance": {"stops": ["S01", "S02", "S03", "S04", "S05", "S06", "S07", "S08", "S09", "S10", "S11", "S12", "S13", "S14", "S15", "S16", "S17", "S18", "S19", "S20", "S21", "S22", "S23", "S24", "S25"], "parcels": [{"id": "P01", "stop": "S01", "volume_dl": 92}, {"id": "P02", "stop": "S02", "volume_dl": 416}, {"id": "P03", "stop": "S02", "volume_dl": 34}, {"id": "P04", "stop": "S03", "volume_dl": 133}, {"id": "P05", "stop": "S04", "volume_dl": 104}, {"id": "P06", "stop": "S05", "volume_dl": 34}, {"id": "P07", "stop": "S06", "volume_dl": 134}, {"id": "P08", "stop": "S07", "volume_dl": 149}, {"id": "P09", "stop": "S08", "volume_dl": 186}, {"id": "P10", "stop": "S09", "volume_dl": 46}, {"id": "P11", "stop": "S10", "volume_dl": 5}, {"id": "P12", "stop": "S11", "volume_dl": 11}, {"id": "P13", "stop": "S12", "volume_dl": 15}, {"id": "P14", "stop": "S13", "volume_dl": 25}, {"id": "P15", "stop": "S14", "volume_dl": 18}, {"id": "P16", "stop": "S15", "volume_dl": 133}, {"id": "P17", "stop": "S16", "volume_dl": 14}, {"id": "P18", "stop": "S16", "volume_dl": 63}, {"id": "P19", "stop": "S17", "volume_dl": 34}, {"id": "P20", "stop": "S18", "volume_dl": 28}, {"id": "P21", "stop": "S19", "volume_dl": 542}, {"id": "P22", "stop": "S20", "volume_dl": 17}, {"id": "P23", "stop": "S21", "volume_dl": 10}, {"id": "P24", "stop": "S22", "volume_dl": 57}, {"id": "P25", "stop": "S23", "volume_dl": 57}, {"id": "P26", "stop": "S24", "volume_dl": 57}, {"id": "P27", "stop": "S25", "volume_dl": 27}], "vans": 3, "capacity_dl": 866, "travel_s": [[0, 1758, 1467, 1658, 1588, 1323, 1713, 1664, 1614, 1842, 1739, 1232, 1306, 1883, 1388, 1305, 1532, 1401, 1140, 1613, 1246, 1614, 1767, 1509, 1537, 1661], [1852, 0, 580, 221, 240, 1120, 349, 595, 704, 326, 558, 926, 1104, 309, 1185, 1102, 241, 742, 1061, 600, 1044, 265, 586, 706, 644, 591], [1527, 538, 0, 336, 357, 564, 282, 198, 148, 376, 273, 369, 548, 561, 629, 546, 366, 218, 504, 183, 488, 292, 300, 182, 70, 194], [1730, 202, 359, 0, 175, 881, 128, 374, 507, 279, 511, 686, 864, 225, 946, 862, 199, 521, 821, 379, 804, 44, 538, 484, 429, 370], [1690, 222, 370, 177, 0, 892, 276, 385, 518, 415, 647, 697, 875, 361, 957, 874, 96, 532, 832, 390, 815, 192, 675, 496, 441, 382], [1382, 1083, 581, 881, 902, 0, 827, 779, 552, 784, 752, 248, 239, 960, 220, 259, 911, 417, 255, 728, 201, 836, 779, 525, 651, 775], [1753, 324, 282, 122, 275, 804, 0, 297, 430, 400, 632, 609, 787, 346, 869, 786, 284, 444, 744, 302, 727, 115, 660, 408, 353, 294], [1712, 570, 185, 367, 388, 698, 314, 0, 282, 483, 380, 504, 682, 592, 763, 680, 398, 403, 639, 284, 622, 323, 408, 367, 117, 4], [1575, 700, 162, 498, 519, 508, 444, 299, 0, 414, 311, 313, 491, 589, 573, 490, 528, 295, 448, 345, 431, 454, 338, 403, 171, 295], [1862, 350, 345, 304, 439, 794, 433, 445, 378, 0, 232, 600, 778, 175, 859, 776, 440, 581, 735, 528, 718, 349, 260, 526, 318, 441], [1767, 610, 250, 565, 607, 700, 532, 350, 283, 260, 0, 505, 683, 436, 765, 681, 616, 486, 640, 433, 623, 542, 27, 432, 223, 347], [1332, 884, 382, 682, 703, 264, 628, 580, 353, 586, 553, 0, 248, 761, 329, 246, 712, 218, 204, 529, 188, 638, 580, 327, 452, 576], [1373, 1074, 572, 872, 893, 228, 818, 770, 544, 776, 743, 240, 0, 951, 173, 251, 902, 409, 246, 719, 192, 828, 771, 517, 643, 766], [1982, 298, 502, 252, 387, 952, 380, 602, 535, 157, 389, 757, 935, 0, 1017, 933, 388, 738, 892, 631, 875, 296, 417, 684, 475, 599], [1467, 1168, 666, 966, 987, 220, 912, 864, 637, 869, 837, 333, 167, 1045, 0, 344, 996, 502, 340, 813, 286, 921, 864, 610, 736, 860], [1398, 1077, 575, 874, 896, 273, 821, 772, 546, 778, 745, 264, 257, 954, 338, 0, 905, 411, 270, 721, 57, 830, 773, 519, 645, 769], [1611, 232, 396, 217, 93, 918, 317, 411, 544, 424, 657, 723, 901, 370, 983, 899, 0, 558, 858, 416, 841, 233, 684, 522, 466, 407], [1484, 703, 201, 501, 522, 417, 447, 399, 349, 577, 474, 222, 400, 752, 482, 398, 531, 0, 357, 348, 340, 457, 501, 145, 271, 395], [1232, 1011, 510, 809, 830, 268, 756, 707, 481, 713, 680, 177, 251, 888, 333, 249, 839, 346, 0, 656, 191, 765, 708, 454, 580, 704], [1646, 567, 176, 365, 386, 697, 311, 257, 323, 551, 448, 502, 680, 589, 762, 679, 395, 338, 637, 0, 620, 320, 476, 301, 246, 253], [1341, 1080, 578, 877, 898, 216, 824, 775, 549, 781, 748, 207, 200, 957, 281, 58, 908, 414, 214, 724, 0, 833, 776, 522, 648, 772], [1686, 246, 315, 44, 160, 836, 101, 330, 462, 323, 555, 642, 820, 269, 901, 818, 169, 477, 776, 334, 760, 0, 582, 440, 385, 326], [1787, 642, 270, 597, 627, 720, 552, 370, 303, 292, 41, 525, 703, 468, 784, 701, 636, 506, 660, 453, 643, 562, 0, 452, 242, 366], [1582, 668, 167, 466, 487, 527, 413, 364, 314, 542, 439, 332, 510, 718, 592, 509, 496, 168, 467, 313, 450, 422, 467, 0, 237, 361], [1594, 606, 67, 404, 425, 581, 350, 127, 164, 366, 263, 386, 564, 541, 646, 562, 434, 286, 521, 251, 504, 359, 290, 249, 0, 124], [1708, 566, 181, 364, 385, 695, 310, 4, 278, 480, 377, 500, 678, 588, 760, 676, 394, 400, 635, 280, 618, 320, 404, 363, 114, 0]]}, "reference": {"optimum_s": 12891, "optimality": "best_found", "lower_bound_s": 10240, "floor_s": 7116, "solve_s": 41.15, "ffd_s": 14249, "stop_aware_best_s": 14602, "stop_aware_mean_s": 14795.4, "route_id": "RouteID_a78947fa-f071-44b5-83c3-0f63d9236bda", "plans": {"optimum": [{"route": ["S16", "S04", "S21", "S06", "S03", "S01", "S13", "S09", "S10", "S22", "S11", "S18"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S02", "S08", "S20", "S15", "S12", "S14", "S05"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S17", "S23", "S19", "S25", "S07", "S24"], "parcels": []}], "ffd": [{"route": ["S06", "S19", "S08"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S03", "S07", "S02", "S15"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S16", "S04", "S21", "S01", "S13", "S09", "S10", "S22", "S24", "S25", "S23", "S17", "S11", "S20", "S12", "S14", "S05", "S18"], "parcels": []}], "stop_aware_best": [{"route": ["S23", "S25", "S06", "S16", "S13", "S09", "S10", "S22", "S08", "S20", "S15"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S01", "S03", "S19", "S17", "S12"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S18", "S14", "S05", "S11", "S02", "S24", "S07", "S21", "S04"], "parcels": []}]}}, "meta": {"route_id": "RouteID_a78947fa-f071-44b5-83c3-0f63d9236bda", "split": "train", "stops": 25, "vans": 3, "tightness": 0.94, "station": "DBO3", "city": "DBO", "date": "2018-08-11", "seconds": 43.0, "stop_aware_best_reward": 0.6468, "optimality": "best_found"}}
{"id": "5f5de232-spread-n30-k4-t0.87-s0", "instance": {"stops": ["S01", "S02", "S03", "S04", "S05", "S06", "S07", "S08", "S09", "S10", "S11", "S12", "S13", "S14", "S15", "S16", "S17", "S18", "S19", "S20", "S21", "S22", "S23", "S24", "S25", "S26", "S27", "S28", "S29", "S30"], "parcels": [{"id": "P01", "stop": "S01", "volume_dl": 157}, {"id": "P02", "stop": "S01", "volume_dl": 29}, {"id": "P03", "stop": "S01", "volume_dl": 133}, {"id": "P04", "stop": "S02", "volume_dl": 46}, {"id": "P05", "stop": "S03", "volume_dl": 69}, {"id": "P06", "stop": "S04", "volume_dl": 12}, {"id": "P07", "stop": "S04", "volume_dl": 57}, {"id": "P08", "stop": "S05", "volume_dl": 18}, {"id": "P09", "stop": "S06", "volume_dl": 104}, {"id": "P10", "stop": "S07", "volume_dl": 25}, {"id": "P11", "stop": "S08", "volume_dl": 157}, {"id": "P12", "stop": "S08", "volume_dl": 95}, {"id": "P13", "stop": "S08", "volume_dl": 63}, {"id": "P14", "stop": "S08", "volume_dl": 95}, {"id": "P15", "stop": "S08", "volume_dl": 157}, {"id": "P16", "stop": "S09", "volume_dl": 226}, {"id": "P17", "stop": "S10", "volume_dl": 63}, {"id": "P18", "stop": "S11", "volume_dl": 13}, {"id": "P19", "stop": "S12", "volume_dl": 22}, {"id": "P20", "stop": "S12", "volume_dl": 552}, {"id": "P21", "stop": "S13", "volume_dl": 20}, {"id": "P22", "stop": "S14", "volume_dl": 60}, {"id": "P23", "stop": "S14", "volume_dl": 57}, {"id": "P24", "stop": "S15", "volume_dl": 36}, {"id": "P25", "stop": "S15", "volume_dl": 134}, {"id": "P26", "stop": "S16", "volume_dl": 26}, {"id": "P27", "stop": "S17", "volume_dl": 21}, {"id": "P28", "stop": "S17", "volume_dl": 23}, {"id": "P29", "stop": "S18", "volume_dl": 54}, {"id": "P30", "stop": "S19", "volume_dl": 22}, {"id": "P31", "stop": "S20", "volume_dl": 104}, {"id": "P32", "stop": "S21", "volume_dl": 31}, {"id": "P33", "stop": "S22", "volume_dl": 12}, {"id": "P34", "stop": "S23", "volume_dl": 133}, {"id": "P35", "stop": "S23", "volume_dl": 429}, {"id": "P36", "stop": "S23", "volume_dl": 12}, {"id": "P37", "stop": "S24", "volume_dl": 10}, {"id": "P38", "stop": "S25", "volume_dl": 41}, {"id": "P39", "stop": "S26", "volume_dl": 42}, {"id": "P40", "stop": "S26", "volume_dl": 43}, {"id": "P41", "stop": "S27", "volume_dl": 13}, {"id": "P42", "stop": "S27", "volume_dl": 90}, {"id": "P43", "stop": "S28", "volume_dl": 12}, {"id": "P44", "stop": "S28", "volume_dl": 42}, {"id": "P45", "stop": "S28", "volume_dl": 350}, {"id": "P46", "stop": "S28", "volume_dl": 133}, {"id": "P47", "stop": "S28", "volume_dl": 477}, {"id": "P48", "stop": "S29", "volume_dl": 104}, {"id": "P49", "stop": "S30", "volume_dl": 9}], "vans": 4, "capacity_dl": 1332, "travel_s": [[0, 1754, 1643, 1869, 1784, 1787, 1588, 1764, 1758, 1850, 1549, 1773, 1821, 1902, 1933, 1515, 1915, 1519, 1799, 1602, 1570, 1795, 1748, 1912, 1772, 1985, 1905, 1802, 1940, 1778, 1773], [1785, 0, 547, 220, 135, 138, 613, 354, 127, 218, 560, 81, 172, 253, 282, 532, 265, 544, 94, 613, 595, 146, 389, 346, 303, 338, 256, 153, 309, 147, 334], [1521, 538, 0, 632, 548, 550, 310, 242, 403, 364, 319, 557, 584, 665, 656, 285, 678, 241, 583, 327, 292, 559, 238, 588, 290, 711, 668, 566, 617, 384, 264], [1868, 207, 649, 0, 80, 150, 716, 456, 229, 321, 662, 226, 155, 74, 287, 628, 64, 646, 252, 715, 698, 158, 491, 352, 405, 342, 110, 156, 358, 249, 436], [1788, 127, 570, 84, 0, 70, 636, 376, 149, 241, 582, 147, 76, 117, 205, 554, 130, 567, 173, 636, 618, 78, 412, 269, 325, 262, 120, 76, 278, 169, 357], [1778, 118, 560, 162, 78, 0, 627, 367, 140, 232, 573, 137, 114, 195, 227, 539, 208, 558, 164, 626, 609, 8, 402, 292, 316, 281, 198, 96, 298, 160, 348], [1486, 573, 318, 668, 583, 586, 0, 297, 439, 419, 209, 592, 620, 701, 692, 175, 714, 83, 618, 217, 18, 594, 293, 624, 317, 746, 704, 601, 652, 419, 319], [1640, 369, 227, 463, 379, 382, 293, 0, 234, 195, 302, 388, 415, 496, 487, 268, 509, 224, 414, 310, 275, 390, 202, 420, 284, 542, 499, 397, 448, 215, 222], [1708, 134, 420, 229, 144, 147, 487, 227, 0, 92, 433, 153, 181, 262, 251, 405, 275, 418, 179, 486, 469, 155, 262, 182, 176, 307, 265, 162, 214, 20, 208], [1782, 234, 369, 328, 244, 247, 435, 176, 100, 0, 444, 253, 280, 362, 352, 410, 374, 366, 279, 460, 417, 255, 211, 285, 149, 407, 365, 262, 313, 80, 156], [1411, 543, 326, 637, 553, 556, 188, 305, 408, 426, 0, 562, 589, 670, 661, 23, 683, 118, 588, 155, 170, 564, 300, 594, 325, 716, 674, 571, 622, 389, 326], [1812, 93, 574, 246, 162, 165, 640, 380, 153, 245, 587, 0, 198, 279, 311, 553, 292, 571, 103, 640, 622, 173, 416, 376, 329, 365, 282, 180, 336, 174, 361], [1834, 174, 616, 157, 78, 116, 682, 422, 195, 287, 628, 193, 0, 138, 220, 600, 203, 613, 219, 682, 664, 124, 458, 284, 371, 276, 109, 73, 293, 215, 403], [1898, 238, 680, 60, 111, 180, 747, 487, 260, 352, 693, 257, 144, 0, 318, 659, 124, 678, 284, 746, 729, 189, 522, 383, 436, 372, 36, 187, 389, 280, 468], [1927, 264, 669, 262, 177, 209, 735, 476, 249, 340, 682, 286, 180, 295, 0, 654, 308, 664, 312, 735, 718, 217, 511, 169, 425, 130, 266, 182, 176, 269, 456], [1388, 527, 302, 614, 529, 532, 164, 281, 392, 403, 34, 538, 573, 647, 636, 0, 660, 102, 564, 131, 146, 540, 277, 575, 301, 692, 657, 555, 599, 365, 302], [1878, 218, 660, 49, 91, 160, 727, 467, 240, 332, 673, 237, 166, 124, 298, 639, 0, 658, 264, 726, 709, 169, 502, 363, 416, 352, 146, 167, 369, 260, 448], [1404, 490, 236, 585, 500, 503, 69, 214, 356, 336, 126, 509, 537, 618, 609, 98, 631, 0, 535, 134, 51, 511, 210, 538, 234, 663, 621, 518, 570, 336, 236], [1819, 82, 581, 253, 169, 171, 647, 387, 160, 252, 594, 104, 205, 286, 318, 560, 299, 578, 0, 647, 629, 180, 423, 382, 336, 372, 289, 187, 343, 180, 368], [1467, 552, 297, 646, 562, 564, 159, 276, 417, 397, 138, 571, 598, 679, 670, 104, 692, 90, 597, 0, 141, 573, 272, 602, 296, 725, 682, 580, 631, 398, 297], [1468, 555, 300, 649, 565, 567, 18, 279, 420, 400, 191, 574, 601, 682, 673, 157, 695, 64, 600, 199, 0, 576, 275, 605, 299, 728, 685, 583, 634, 400, 300], [1786, 126, 568, 170, 86, 8, 634, 375, 148, 240, 581, 145, 122, 203, 235, 547, 216, 565, 171, 634, 617, 0, 410, 299, 324, 289, 206, 104, 306, 168, 355], [1602, 390, 232, 484, 400, 402, 298, 191, 255, 216, 307, 409, 436, 517, 508, 273, 530, 229, 435, 315, 280, 411, 0, 440, 305, 563, 520, 418, 469, 236, 116], [1911, 269, 606, 363, 279, 282, 672, 412, 185, 277, 619, 288, 315, 396, 194, 585, 409, 603, 314, 672, 654, 290, 448, 0, 361, 250, 399, 297, 157, 206, 393], [1646, 309, 302, 404, 319, 322, 341, 281, 175, 160, 350, 328, 356, 437, 428, 316, 450, 272, 354, 358, 323, 330, 277, 360, 0, 482, 440, 337, 388, 155, 302], [1988, 328, 730, 323, 238, 270, 796, 537, 310, 402, 743, 347, 243, 356, 116, 709, 369, 727, 373, 796, 778, 278, 572, 232, 486, 0, 329, 245, 239, 330, 517], [1906, 246, 688, 90, 118, 188, 754, 495, 268, 359, 701, 265, 109, 30, 316, 672, 154, 685, 291, 754, 736, 196, 530, 380, 444, 372, 0, 169, 389, 288, 475], [1826, 166, 608, 161, 77, 108, 674, 414, 187, 279, 621, 185, 63, 179, 192, 592, 207, 605, 211, 674, 656, 116, 450, 256, 363, 248, 149, 0, 265, 208, 395], [1950, 308, 645, 358, 274, 305, 711, 452, 224, 316, 658, 327, 278, 391, 181, 624, 404, 642, 353, 711, 693, 313, 487, 144, 400, 237, 364, 280, 0, 245, 432], [1688, 154, 400, 249, 164, 167, 466, 207, 20, 72, 413, 173, 200, 282, 273, 379, 294, 397, 199, 466, 449, 175, 242, 205, 156, 327, 285, 182, 233, 0, 187], [1655, 322, 284, 416, 332, 334, 351, 214, 187, 148, 360, 341, 368, 449, 440, 326, 462, 282, 367, 368, 333, 343, 123, 372, 237, 495, 452, 350, 401, 168, 0]]}, "reference": {"optimum_s": 17000, "optimality": "best_found", "lower_bound_s": 13635, "floor_s": 11612, "solve_s": 50.2, "ffd_s": 19770, "stop_aware_best_s": 18375, "stop_aware_mean_s": 18712.8, "route_id": "RouteID_5f5de232-3d54-411a-95cf-004f691dc9bc", "plans": {"optimum": [{"route": ["S11", "S18", "S01", "S08", "S29", "S09", "S30", "S22", "S02"], "parcels": ["P12", "P15"]}, {"route": ["S25", "S14", "S23", "S08", "S07", "S06", "S20", "S17"], "parcels": ["P11", "P13", "P14"]}, {"route": ["S27", "S12", "S26", "S13", "S03", "S16", "S04", "S05", "S21"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S28", "S24", "S19", "S10", "S15"], "parcels": []}], "ffd": [{"route": ["S03", "S12", "S28", "S09"], "parcels": ["P20", "P47"]}, {"route": ["S01", "S05", "S28", "S23", "S08"], "parcels": ["P01", "P11", "P13", "P15", "P35", "P45"]}, {"route": ["S01", "S04", "S16", "S27", "S14", "S28", "S23", "S08", "S29", "S10", "S15", "S06", "S20"], "parcels": ["P03", "P07", "P12", "P14", "P22", "P25", "P34", "P42", "P46"]}, {"route": ["S15", "S19", "S17", "S24", "S23", "S28", "S25", "S14", "S27", "S12", "S26", "S13", "S04", "S21", "S11", "S18", "S01", "S30", "S22", "S07", "S02"], "parcels": ["P02", "P06", "P19", "P23", "P24", "P36", "P41", "P43", "P44"]}], "stop_aware_best": [{"route": ["S27", "S12", "S26", "S13", "S03", "S25", "S14", "S24", "S19"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S04", "S08", "S29", "S09", "S22", "S02", "S20"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S01", "S11", "S05", "S16", "S23", "S07", "S06", "S15"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S18", "S21", "S28", "S30", "S17", "S10"], "parcels": []}]}}, "meta": {"route_id": "RouteID_5f5de232-3d54-411a-95cf-004f691dc9bc", "split": "train", "stops": 30, "vans": 4, "tightness": 0.87, "station": "DSE4", "city": "DSE", "date": "2018-08-12", "seconds": 112.9, "stop_aware_best_reward": 0.6847, "optimality": "best_found"}}
{"id": "76f22159-spread-n20-k3-t0.85-s0", "instance": {"stops": ["S01", "S02", "S03", "S04", "S05", "S06", "S07", "S08", "S09", "S10", "S11", "S12", "S13", "S14", "S15", "S16", "S17", "S18", "S19", "S20"], "parcels": [{"id": "P01", "stop": "S01", "volume_dl": 32}, {"id": "P02", "stop": "S01", "volume_dl": 34}, {"id": "P03", "stop": "S01", "volume_dl": 45}, {"id": "P04", "stop": "S02", "volume_dl": 45}, {"id": "P05", "stop": "S02", "volume_dl": 8}, {"id": "P06", "stop": "S02", "volume_dl": 30}, {"id": "P07", "stop": "S02", "volume_dl": 9}, {"id": "P08", "stop": "S02", "volume_dl": 63}, {"id": "P09", "stop": "S03", "volume_dl": 59}, {"id": "P10", "stop": "S04", "volume_dl": 34}, {"id": "P11", "stop": "S04", "volume_dl": 157}, {"id": "P12", "stop": "S05", "volume_dl": 36}, {"id": "P13", "stop": "S06", "volume_dl": 104}, {"id": "P14", "stop": "S06", "volume_dl": 157}, {"id": "P15", "stop": "S06", "volume_dl": 552}, {"id": "P16", "stop": "S06", "volume_dl": 59}, {"id": "P17", "stop": "S07", "volume_dl": 22}, {"id": "P18", "stop": "S08", "volume_dl": 95}, {"id": "P19", "stop": "S08", "volume_dl": 92}, {"id": "P20", "stop": "S09", "volume_dl": 49}, {"id": "P21", "stop": "S10", "volume_dl": 21}, {"id": "P22", "stop": "S10", "volume_dl": 63}, {"id": "P23", "stop": "S10", "volume_dl": 9}, {"id": "P24", "stop": "S11", "volume_dl": 95}, {"id": "P25", "stop": "S12", "volume_dl": 59}, {"id": "P26", "stop": "S13", "volume_dl": 14}, {"id": "P27", "stop": "S14", "volume_dl": 134}, {"id": "P28", "stop": "S15", "volume_dl": 322}, {"id": "P29", "stop": "S16", "volume_dl": 12}, {"id": "P30", "stop": "S16", "volume_dl": 34}, {"id": "P31", "stop": "S16", "volume_dl": 79}, {"id": "P32", "stop": "S17", "volume_dl": 277}, {"id": "P33", "stop": "S18", "volume_dl": 226}, {"id": "P34", "stop": "S19", "volume_dl": 5}, {"id": "P35", "stop": "S19", "volume_dl": 38}, {"id": "P36", "stop": "S20", "volume_dl": 92}, {"id": "P37", "stop": "S20", "volume_dl": 95}, {"id": "P38", "stop": "S20", "volume_dl": 57}, {"id": "P39", "stop": "S20", "volume_dl": 34}], "vans": 3, "capacity_dl": 1315, "travel_s": [[0, 2891, 2861, 2881, 2795, 2850, 2925, 2920, 2977, 2963, 2864, 2933, 3001, 2898, 2995, 2921, 2836, 2812, 2870, 2879, 2863], [2707, 0, 329, 185, 281, 344, 256, 208, 142, 141, 425, 341, 285, 200, 272, 342, 112, 257, 228, 69, 346], [2674, 324, 0, 187, 95, 67, 189, 178, 291, 236, 273, 265, 349, 310, 253, 369, 233, 104, 126, 324, 80], [2713, 198, 191, 0, 152, 216, 161, 111, 172, 153, 312, 254, 328, 194, 232, 334, 95, 119, 82, 186, 203], [2620, 305, 77, 149, 0, 97, 173, 151, 281, 227, 274, 266, 339, 301, 243, 345, 214, 66, 75, 304, 110], [2671, 364, 88, 212, 116, 0, 132, 206, 319, 264, 227, 209, 367, 339, 310, 313, 261, 133, 147, 352, 13], [2742, 270, 170, 152, 171, 142, 0, 110, 236, 182, 169, 93, 251, 243, 178, 197, 195, 172, 122, 267, 129], [2760, 234, 174, 101, 141, 195, 129, 0, 182, 165, 298, 222, 285, 206, 189, 291, 144, 160, 65, 220, 200], [2787, 140, 286, 178, 297, 306, 211, 170, 0, 45, 369, 246, 206, 74, 152, 246, 177, 267, 221, 80, 303], [2780, 117, 240, 146, 241, 260, 165, 146, 55, 0, 335, 200, 213, 78, 131, 201, 160, 262, 207, 105, 258], [2888, 339, 296, 298, 320, 252, 137, 256, 274, 220, 0, 98, 189, 252, 191, 86, 333, 319, 268, 321, 230], [2854, 295, 270, 263, 282, 217, 112, 222, 233, 178, 211, 0, 180, 245, 157, 126, 307, 284, 233, 283, 204], [2845, 268, 327, 309, 328, 348, 246, 257, 188, 206, 377, 207, 0, 138, 109, 226, 317, 330, 279, 207, 344], [2774, 166, 294, 197, 295, 315, 219, 197, 74, 68, 389, 252, 155, 0, 119, 261, 216, 313, 259, 105, 312], [2809, 249, 237, 219, 238, 258, 162, 167, 154, 132, 332, 177, 116, 142, 0, 189, 263, 240, 189, 210, 255], [2768, 315, 336, 318, 337, 300, 195, 266, 253, 198, 295, 125, 218, 261, 183, 0, 358, 338, 288, 303, 288], [2665, 134, 230, 95, 214, 250, 185, 135, 164, 154, 354, 278, 351, 196, 255, 355, 0, 194, 139, 133, 247], [2638, 273, 102, 116, 53, 122, 186, 171, 267, 240, 312, 279, 352, 311, 256, 358, 190, 0, 96, 261, 135], [2695, 241, 124, 82, 75, 148, 132, 75, 215, 186, 244, 239, 299, 255, 203, 305, 138, 95, 0, 229, 135], [2706, 76, 328, 184, 280, 343, 249, 207, 96, 95, 418, 296, 216, 117, 209, 296, 110, 256, 227, 0, 345], [2684, 340, 78, 200, 118, 13, 119, 193, 306, 252, 202, 196, 354, 326, 298, 300, 248, 120, 134, 339, 0]]}, "reference": {"optimum_s": 18120, "optimality": "best_found", "lower_bound_s": 17331, "floor_s": 16245, "solve_s": 33.15, "ffd_s": 19711, "stop_aware_best_s": 18743, "stop_aware_mean_s": 18959.4, "route_id": "RouteID_76f22159-a7b6-43d5-b424-fe21033d7784", "plans": {"optimum": [{"route": ["S10", "S15", "S11", "S14", "S12", "S13", "S09", "S08", "S19", "S01"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S06", "S07", "S18", "S03", "S16"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S17", "S04", "S02", "S05", "S20"], "parcels": []}], "ffd": [{"route": ["S19", "S15", "S06", "S17", "S04"], "parcels": ["P11", "P15", "P34"]}, {"route": ["S10", "S11", "S14", "S13", "S08", "S16", "S18", "S06", "S20", "S02"], "parcels": ["P08", "P13", "P14", "P22", "P31", "P36", "P37"]}, {"route": ["S10", "S12", "S09", "S19", "S01", "S16", "S03", "S07", "S06", "S20", "S05", "S02", "S04"], "parcels": ["P04", "P05", "P06", "P07", "P10", "P16", "P21", "P23", "P29", "P30", "P35", "P38", "P39"]}], "stop_aware_best": [{"route": ["S10", "S15", "S11", "S18", "S02"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S12", "S19", "S01", "S16", "S03", "S17", "S04", "S20", "S05"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S13", "S08", "S09", "S14", "S06", "S07"], "parcels": []}]}}, "meta": {"route_id": "RouteID_76f22159-a7b6-43d5-b424-fe21033d7784", "split": "train", "stops": 20, "vans": 3, "tightness": 0.85, "station": "DSE5", "city": "DSE", "date": "2018-07-28", "seconds": 84.2, "stop_aware_best_reward": 0.6257, "optimality": "best_found"}}
{"id": "aeec28bc-spread-n20-k3-t0.93-s0", "instance": {"stops": ["S01", "S02", "S03", "S04", "S05", "S06", "S07", "S08", "S09", "S10", "S11", "S12", "S13", "S14", "S15", "S16", "S17", "S18", "S19", "S20"], "parcels": [{"id": "P01", "stop": "S01", "volume_dl": 57}, {"id": "P02", "stop": "S01", "volume_dl": 133}, {"id": "P03", "stop": "S02", "volume_dl": 242}, {"id": "P04", "stop": "S03", "volume_dl": 226}, {"id": "P05", "stop": "S03", "volume_dl": 133}, {"id": "P06", "stop": "S04", "volume_dl": 42}, {"id": "P07", "stop": "S05", "volume_dl": 13}, {"id": "P08", "stop": "S06", "volume_dl": 5}, {"id": "P09", "stop": "S06", "volume_dl": 134}, {"id": "P10", "stop": "S06", "volume_dl": 63}, {"id": "P11", "stop": "S06", "volume_dl": 20}, {"id": "P12", "stop": "S07", "volume_dl": 104}, {"id": "P13", "stop": "S08", "volume_dl": 30}, {"id": "P14", "stop": "S08", "volume_dl": 429}, {"id": "P15", "stop": "S09", "volume_dl": 179}, {"id": "P16", "stop": "S10", "volume_dl": 252}, {"id": "P17", "stop": "S11", "volume_dl": 12}, {"id": "P18", "stop": "S12", "volume_dl": 57}, {"id": "P19", "stop": "S13", "volume_dl": 63}, {"id": "P20", "stop": "S14", "volume_dl": 322}, {"id": "P21", "stop": "S14", "volume_dl": 57}, {"id": "P22", "stop": "S14", "volume_dl": 43}, {"id": "P23", "stop": "S15", "volume_dl": 55}, {"id": "P24", "stop": "S15", "volume_dl": 30}, {"id": "P25", "stop": "S15", "volume_dl": 57}, {"id": "P26", "stop": "S16", "volume_dl": 57}, {"id": "P27", "stop": "S17", "volume_dl": 289}, {"id": "P28", "stop": "S17", "volume_dl": 42}, {"id": "P29", "stop": "S18", "volume_dl": 928}, {"id": "P30", "stop": "S19", "volume_dl": 55}, {"id": "P31", "stop": "S20", "volume_dl": 64}, {"id": "P32", "stop": "S20", "volume_dl": 57}, {"id": "P33", "stop": "S20", "volume_dl": 36}], "vans": 3, "capacity_dl": 1537, "travel_s": [[0, 1874, 1900, 1892, 1843, 1843, 1858, 1798, 1944, 1904, 1956, 1925, 1982, 1863, 1963, 1849, 1817, 1850, 1893, 1836, 1928], [1881, 0, 208, 333, 300, 191, 225, 206, 164, 212, 305, 184, 318, 171, 218, 187, 373, 298, 201, 208, 291], [1938, 219, 0, 238, 167, 286, 286, 208, 289, 122, 174, 225, 184, 124, 180, 278, 254, 188, 110, 265, 325], [1930, 352, 196, 0, 85, 431, 432, 132, 426, 103, 198, 271, 100, 257, 243, 423, 90, 103, 185, 410, 134], [1877, 303, 240, 94, 0, 377, 378, 79, 373, 98, 227, 252, 129, 204, 231, 370, 184, 34, 180, 357, 201], [1868, 181, 278, 390, 360, 0, 124, 282, 178, 283, 363, 242, 376, 242, 266, 8, 431, 393, 271, 104, 486], [1848, 221, 257, 353, 324, 124, 0, 286, 214, 262, 399, 278, 339, 222, 307, 116, 394, 369, 250, 21, 340], [1815, 233, 161, 171, 92, 265, 265, 0, 257, 165, 218, 172, 157, 124, 224, 257, 211, 93, 154, 244, 229], [1941, 154, 267, 370, 340, 133, 180, 262, 0, 307, 332, 169, 356, 242, 229, 125, 410, 357, 260, 160, 350], [1944, 230, 138, 116, 120, 296, 297, 167, 319, 0, 189, 168, 124, 171, 134, 289, 206, 141, 82, 276, 296], [1979, 259, 178, 164, 250, 326, 326, 230, 329, 185, 0, 214, 112, 164, 164, 318, 180, 252, 65, 306, 220], [1955, 172, 213, 270, 280, 220, 268, 192, 202, 160, 210, 0, 250, 153, 52, 212, 286, 300, 189, 247, 375], [1986, 353, 246, 168, 254, 419, 420, 288, 412, 171, 168, 327, 0, 279, 344, 412, 200, 224, 260, 399, 71], [1887, 168, 109, 230, 216, 234, 235, 138, 237, 114, 225, 156, 232, 0, 188, 226, 246, 236, 102, 214, 317], [2008, 220, 207, 212, 270, 268, 315, 248, 249, 150, 152, 56, 192, 193, 0, 260, 228, 302, 131, 294, 171], [1860, 177, 271, 383, 353, 8, 117, 275, 171, 275, 355, 235, 369, 234, 264, 0, 423, 385, 264, 96, 354], [1862, 351, 233, 83, 149, 418, 419, 182, 421, 158, 187, 291, 89, 256, 241, 410, 0, 119, 157, 397, 203], [1843, 314, 196, 90, 30, 390, 392, 94, 386, 132, 257, 267, 159, 219, 270, 382, 125, 0, 214, 369, 209], [1914, 194, 112, 128, 213, 261, 261, 165, 264, 77, 64, 150, 107, 99, 116, 253, 144, 215, 0, 240, 214], [1826, 196, 236, 332, 302, 102, 21, 266, 193, 241, 378, 257, 318, 200, 280, 95, 373, 351, 230, 0, 444], [2059, 288, 225, 126, 211, 359, 360, 258, 362, 150, 68, 232, 77, 197, 176, 351, 142, 216, 98, 338, 0]]}, "reference": {"optimum_s": 12709, "optimality": "best_found", "lower_bound_s": 11915, "floor_s": 10839, "solve_s": 40.15, "ffd_s": 13920, "stop_aware_best_s": 13361, "stop_aware_mean_s": 13445.4, "route_id": "RouteID_aeec28bc-213f-4f03-aef0-a5d1be549960", "plans": {"optimum": [{"route": ["S01", "S14", "S11", "S08", "S15", "S05", "S06", "S19"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S16", "S12", "S20", "S10", "S18"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S07", "S13", "S02", "S09", "S03", "S04", "S17"], "parcels": []}], "ffd": [{"route": ["S09", "S18", "S08"], "parcels": ["P14"]}, {"route": ["S06", "S02", "S14", "S20", "S10", "S03", "S17"], "parcels": ["P04", "P08", "P09", "P20", "P27", "P31"]}, {"route": ["S07", "S04", "S17", "S03", "S16", "S12", "S20", "S14", "S11", "S13", "S01", "S08", "S15", "S05", "S06", "S19"], "parcels": ["P05", "P10", "P11", "P13", "P21", "P22", "P28", "P32", "P33"]}], "stop_aware_best": [{"route": ["S02", "S12", "S10", "S14", "S11", "S15", "S05", "S06"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S03", "S20", "S18", "S13"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S07", "S04", "S17", "S16", "S09", "S01", "S08", "S19"], "parcels": []}]}}, "meta": {"route_id": "RouteID_aeec28bc-213f-4f03-aef0-a5d1be549960", "split": "train", "stops": 20, "vans": 3, "tightness": 0.93, "station": "DLA4", "city": "DLA", "date": "2018-07-20", "seconds": 90.7, "stop_aware_best_reward": 0.6127, "optimality": "best_found"}}
{"id": "f69917e2-spread-n25-k3-t0.88-s0", "instance": {"stops": ["S01", "S02", "S03", "S04", "S05", "S06", "S07", "S08", "S09", "S10", "S11", "S12", "S13", "S14", "S15", "S16", "S17", "S18", "S19", "S20", "S21", "S22", "S23", "S24", "S25"], "parcels": [{"id": "P01", "stop": "S01", "volume_dl": 59}, {"id": "P02", "stop": "S02", "volume_dl": 133}, {"id": "P03", "stop": "S02", "volume_dl": 32}, {"id": "P04", "stop": "S02", "volume_dl": 259}, {"id": "P05", "stop": "S03", "volume_dl": 34}, {"id": "P06", "stop": "S04", "volume_dl": 44}, {"id": "P07", "stop": "S05", "volume_dl": 34}, {"id": "P08", "stop": "S06", "volume_dl": 57}, {"id": "P09", "stop": "S06", "volume_dl": 477}, {"id": "P10", "stop": "S07", "volume_dl": 95}, {"id": "P11", "stop": "S08", "volume_dl": 27}, {"id": "P12", "stop": "S09", "volume_dl": 14}, {"id": "P13", "stop": "S10", "volume_dl": 134}, {"id": "P14", "stop": "S11", "volume_dl": 59}, {"id": "P15", "stop": "S11", "volume_dl": 57}, {"id": "P16", "stop": "S11", "volume_dl": 57}, {"id": "P17", "stop": "S12", "volume_dl": 41}, {"id": "P18", "stop": "S12", "volume_dl": 63}, {"id": "P19", "stop": "S12", "volume_dl": 179}, {"id": "P20", "stop": "S12", "volume_dl": 92}, {"id": "P21", "stop": "S12", "volume_dl": 34}, {"id": "P22", "stop": "S12", "volume_dl": 37}, {"id": "P23", "stop": "S13", "volume_dl": 26}, {"id": "P24", "stop": "S13", "volume_dl": 340}, {"id": "P25", "stop": "S13", "volume_dl": 157}, {"id": "P26", "stop": "S14", "volume_dl": 56}, {"id": "P27", "stop": "S14", "volume_dl": 3}, {"id": "P28", "stop": "S14", "volume_dl": 63}, {"id": "P29", "stop": "S14", "volume_dl": 179}, {"id": "P30", "stop": "S14", "volume_dl": 9}, {"id": "P31", "stop": "S15", "volume_dl": 34}, {"id": "P32", "stop": "S16", "volume_dl": 242}, {"id": "P33", "stop": "S16", "volume_dl": 29}, {"id": "P34", "stop": "S17", "volume_dl": 23}, {"id": "P35", "stop": "S18", "volume_dl": 179}, {"id": "P36", "stop": "S19", "volume_dl": 779}, {"id": "P37", "stop": "S19", "volume_dl": 276}, {"id": "P38", "stop": "S19", "volume_dl": 779}, {"id": "P39", "stop": "S19", "volume_dl": 242}, {"id": "P40", "stop": "S20", "volume_dl": 109}, {"id": "P41", "stop": "S20", "volume_dl": 32}, {"id": "P42", "stop": "S20", "volume_dl": 53}, {"id": "P43", "stop": "S21", "volume_dl": 104}, {"id": "P44", "stop": "S21", "volume_dl": 13}, {"id": "P45", "stop": "S22", "volume_dl": 157}, {"id": "P46", "stop": "S22", "volume_dl": 133}, {"id": "P47", "stop": "S23", "volume_dl": 20}, {"id": "P48", "stop": "S23", "volume_dl": 104}, {"id": "P49", "stop": "S24", "volume_dl": 12}, {"id": "P50", "stop": "S25", "volume_dl": 95}, {"id": "P51", "stop": "S25", "volume_dl": 429}], "vans": 3, "capacity_dl": 2538, "travel_s": [[0, 1257, 1331, 1434, 1314, 1336, 1474, 1304, 1421, 1369, 1396, 1550, 1285, 1276, 1266, 1372, 1323, 1248, 1334, 1136, 1336, 1300, 1385, 1496, 1500, 1365], [1118, 0, 170, 274, 411, 59, 365, 235, 261, 209, 235, 390, 264, 115, 300, 212, 398, 7, 234, 462, 243, 254, 241, 336, 453, 379], [1223, 331, 0, 185, 322, 167, 276, 288, 172, 120, 147, 302, 295, 103, 192, 124, 305, 322, 113, 495, 175, 305, 162, 247, 365, 272], [1312, 420, 215, 0, 202, 280, 156, 401, 13, 165, 157, 206, 384, 220, 337, 97, 189, 411, 234, 630, 279, 396, 275, 138, 269, 187], [1164, 271, 226, 192, 0, 311, 219, 252, 204, 224, 250, 385, 234, 299, 189, 207, 42, 262, 191, 453, 241, 248, 313, 202, 332, 83], [1142, 64, 167, 270, 408, 0, 362, 170, 258, 206, 232, 387, 199, 82, 297, 209, 395, 54, 231, 485, 178, 189, 243, 333, 450, 376], [1310, 418, 290, 133, 200, 356, 0, 399, 146, 240, 233, 298, 384, 291, 335, 149, 204, 409, 337, 604, 388, 392, 353, 42, 197, 202], [1145, 233, 212, 316, 270, 154, 407, 0, 303, 251, 277, 432, 104, 127, 222, 254, 279, 224, 234, 506, 86, 93, 288, 378, 495, 362], [1325, 433, 202, 13, 215, 267, 169, 414, 0, 152, 144, 193, 397, 207, 350, 110, 202, 424, 222, 616, 266, 409, 262, 139, 256, 200], [1256, 290, 146, 140, 277, 211, 231, 292, 127, 0, 102, 257, 320, 151, 227, 79, 265, 281, 165, 529, 209, 311, 205, 202, 320, 263], [1273, 306, 162, 123, 260, 228, 214, 309, 110, 112, 0, 239, 337, 168, 244, 61, 248, 297, 182, 546, 226, 328, 222, 185, 302, 245], [1441, 456, 312, 206, 386, 377, 267, 530, 193, 262, 254, 0, 504, 313, 467, 177, 394, 447, 331, 700, 375, 523, 371, 237, 125, 414], [1123, 232, 232, 340, 248, 178, 427, 80, 328, 276, 297, 457, 0, 151, 195, 274, 257, 217, 259, 484, 112, 68, 312, 402, 521, 386], [1216, 143, 82, 185, 322, 64, 276, 146, 172, 120, 146, 301, 167, 0, 210, 123, 305, 134, 146, 513, 154, 162, 157, 247, 364, 290], [1130, 238, 213, 276, 178, 278, 367, 219, 263, 212, 237, 393, 194, 262, 0, 214, 182, 230, 178, 376, 229, 212, 300, 338, 364, 228], [1244, 278, 133, 60, 211, 199, 153, 280, 48, 84, 76, 177, 310, 139, 215, 0, 198, 268, 153, 517, 197, 299, 193, 123, 240, 196], [1174, 282, 237, 181, 64, 322, 212, 263, 194, 235, 261, 369, 232, 306, 194, 197, 0, 273, 202, 464, 252, 256, 324, 186, 322, 73], [1112, 9, 164, 267, 404, 53, 358, 228, 254, 202, 229, 383, 249, 108, 293, 205, 392, 0, 228, 455, 236, 247, 234, 329, 446, 372], [1197, 305, 103, 183, 320, 213, 274, 262, 170, 118, 144, 299, 267, 153, 167, 121, 308, 296, 0, 469, 149, 281, 207, 245, 362, 246], [1104, 435, 489, 552, 452, 474, 642, 544, 538, 487, 513, 668, 481, 459, 369, 490, 460, 426, 454, 0, 504, 493, 589, 568, 626, 544], [1183, 247, 184, 246, 258, 168, 337, 113, 233, 181, 207, 362, 142, 145, 195, 184, 267, 238, 148, 498, 0, 130, 302, 308, 425, 275], [1138, 245, 227, 332, 263, 170, 426, 71, 319, 267, 294, 448, 96, 145, 213, 270, 267, 236, 251, 497, 101, 0, 302, 392, 511, 377], [1231, 283, 146, 249, 386, 204, 340, 286, 236, 184, 211, 366, 313, 140, 274, 188, 369, 274, 210, 574, 294, 305, 0, 311, 429, 355], [1279, 387, 342, 127, 194, 426, 34, 368, 140, 234, 226, 256, 351, 285, 304, 142, 202, 378, 306, 565, 357, 361, 344, 0, 157, 193], [1409, 517, 366, 281, 332, 431, 184, 498, 294, 316, 308, 123, 472, 371, 434, 231, 341, 508, 436, 694, 486, 493, 426, 154, 0, 332], [1204, 312, 267, 207, 94, 351, 217, 293, 220, 265, 291, 401, 276, 336, 229, 223, 81, 303, 232, 494, 282, 288, 354, 200, 330, 0]]}, "reference": {"optimum_s": 9279, "optimality": "best_found", "lower_bound_s": 7851, "floor_s": 6720, "solve_s": 39.15, "ffd_s": 12045, "stop_aware_best_s": 10702, "stop_aware_mean_s": 10997.6, "route_id": "RouteID_f69917e2-b7c9-40de-b0a9-2b79071319e0", "plans": {"optimum": [{"route": ["S12", "S21", "S07", "S20", "S18", "S02", "S22", "S13", "S05", "S17", "S01"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S19"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S14", "S09", "S10", "S15", "S03", "S08", "S11", "S24", "S23", "S06", "S25", "S16", "S04"], "parcels": []}], "ffd": [{"route": ["S19", "S14", "S25", "S06", "S12"], "parcels": ["P09", "P18", "P30", "P36", "P38", "P51"]}, {"route": ["S19", "S01", "S13", "S22", "S02", "S18", "S10", "S16", "S14", "S12"], "parcels": ["P02", "P04", "P19", "P24", "P25", "P29", "P32", "P37", "P39", "P45"]}, {"route": ["S12", "S21", "S07", "S20", "S05", "S17", "S13", "S22", "S02", "S09", "S15", "S03", "S08", "S11", "S24", "S23", "S06", "S25", "S04", "S16", "S14"], "parcels": ["P03", "P08", "P17", "P20", "P21", "P22", "P23", "P26", "P27", "P28", "P33", "P46", "P50"]}], "stop_aware_best": [{"route": ["S17", "S02", "S10", "S25", "S16", "S12", "S21", "S07"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S14", "S18", "S09", "S08", "S23", "S06", "S15", "S22", "S13", "S05", "S01"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S19", "S04", "S24", "S11", "S03", "S20"], "parcels": []}]}}, "meta": {"route_id": "RouteID_f69917e2-b7c9-40de-b0a9-2b79071319e0", "split": "train", "stops": 25, "vans": 3, "tightness": 0.88, "station": "DLA9", "city": "DLA", "date": "2018-08-15", "seconds": 99.7, "stop_aware_best_reward": 0.4743, "optimality": "best_found"}}
{"id": "43dffcb4-spread-n20-k3-t0.89-s0", "instance": {"stops": ["S01", "S02", "S03", "S04", "S05", "S06", "S07", "S08", "S09", "S10", "S11", "S12", "S13", "S14", "S15", "S16", "S17", "S18", "S19", "S20"], "parcels": [{"id": "P01", "stop": "S01", "volume_dl": 22}, {"id": "P02", "stop": "S02", "volume_dl": 6}, {"id": "P03", "stop": "S03", "volume_dl": 92}, {"id": "P04", "stop": "S03", "volume_dl": 134}, {"id": "P05", "stop": "S03", "volume_dl": 95}, {"id": "P06", "stop": "S04", "volume_dl": 180}, {"id": "P07", "stop": "S05", "volume_dl": 60}, {"id": "P08", "stop": "S06", "volume_dl": 57}, {"id": "P09", "stop": "S07", "volume_dl": 8}, {"id": "P10", "stop": "S08", "volume_dl": 34}, {"id": "P11", "stop": "S09", "volume_dl": 6}, {"id": "P12", "stop": "S09", "volume_dl": 157}, {"id": "P13", "stop": "S10", "volume_dl": 13}, {"id": "P14", "stop": "S11", "volume_dl": 57}, {"id": "P15", "stop": "S11", "volume_dl": 57}, {"id": "P16", "stop": "S11", "volume_dl": 57}, {"id": "P17", "stop": "S12", "volume_dl": 14}, {"id": "P18", "stop": "S12", "volume_dl": 8}, {"id": "P19", "stop": "S13", "volume_dl": 34}, {"id": "P20", "stop": "S14", "volume_dl": 133}, {"id": "P21", "stop": "S14", "volume_dl": 97}, {"id": "P22", "stop": "S14", "volume_dl": 92}, {"id": "P23", "stop": "S15", "volume_dl": 35}, {"id": "P24", "stop": "S16", "volume_dl": 34}, {"id": "P25", "stop": "S17", "volume_dl": 429}, {"id": "P26", "stop": "S18", "volume_dl": 38}, {"id": "P27", "stop": "S19", "volume_dl": 95}, {"id": "P28", "stop": "S20", "volume_dl": 21}, {"id": "P29", "stop": "S20", "volume_dl": 43}, {"id": "P30", "stop": "S20", "volume_dl": 80}], "vans": 3, "capacity_dl": 820, "travel_s": [[0, 862, 1323, 922, 1074, 1400, 1149, 1321, 1444, 1465, 888, 1025, 1198, 1426, 1429, 1354, 1381, 850, 853, 1185, 1161], [906, 0, 567, 296, 470, 698, 393, 695, 738, 829, 262, 270, 572, 719, 868, 598, 675, 308, 227, 514, 535], [1288, 576, 0, 704, 872, 266, 570, 516, 250, 341, 705, 535, 606, 232, 381, 166, 187, 752, 671, 958, 674], [930, 299, 795, 0, 250, 761, 359, 514, 792, 658, 193, 342, 391, 774, 622, 802, 768, 394, 178, 292, 354], [1044, 414, 825, 241, 0, 790, 389, 543, 822, 687, 307, 388, 420, 803, 652, 832, 798, 508, 293, 205, 384], [1379, 667, 166, 795, 963, 0, 661, 468, 202, 294, 796, 626, 550, 184, 333, 239, 122, 843, 762, 872, 618], [1221, 393, 624, 365, 418, 730, 0, 483, 699, 564, 475, 125, 340, 680, 592, 709, 738, 569, 488, 442, 324], [1354, 724, 481, 526, 573, 446, 534, 0, 464, 283, 617, 516, 372, 445, 374, 580, 454, 818, 603, 598, 344], [1446, 734, 234, 822, 822, 199, 608, 451, 0, 277, 864, 572, 524, 16, 316, 333, 267, 910, 829, 846, 592], [1551, 812, 338, 688, 662, 304, 597, 275, 322, 0, 706, 580, 392, 303, 91, 438, 312, 907, 691, 686, 432], [901, 270, 731, 218, 371, 864, 452, 617, 896, 761, 0, 374, 494, 877, 726, 762, 838, 365, 132, 443, 458], [1150, 285, 553, 271, 440, 564, 136, 481, 572, 562, 383, 0, 338, 553, 589, 582, 618, 461, 380, 482, 321], [1251, 584, 577, 460, 471, 535, 369, 366, 543, 408, 515, 351, 0, 524, 499, 553, 588, 716, 500, 495, 240], [1430, 718, 218, 805, 806, 183, 592, 435, 18, 260, 848, 556, 508, 0, 300, 317, 251, 894, 813, 830, 576], [1428, 797, 355, 601, 647, 321, 607, 271, 338, 85, 691, 590, 427, 320, 0, 454, 328, 892, 676, 671, 416], [1335, 589, 164, 718, 885, 219, 584, 617, 368, 442, 719, 548, 555, 349, 482, 0, 272, 765, 684, 971, 623], [1399, 687, 187, 816, 866, 134, 634, 462, 196, 288, 817, 598, 550, 178, 327, 279, 0, 863, 782, 890, 636], [829, 314, 774, 385, 538, 905, 600, 784, 945, 928, 351, 477, 661, 926, 892, 805, 882, 0, 316, 603, 625], [861, 230, 691, 158, 311, 804, 392, 557, 836, 701, 106, 314, 434, 817, 666, 722, 812, 325, 0, 376, 398], [1101, 470, 863, 267, 239, 829, 427, 582, 860, 726, 364, 410, 459, 842, 690, 870, 836, 565, 349, 0, 422], [1167, 536, 618, 342, 386, 583, 346, 336, 591, 420, 430, 329, 213, 572, 444, 601, 591, 631, 415, 410, 0]]}, "reference": {"optimum_s": 9955, "optimality": "best_found", "lower_bound_s": 7190, "floor_s": 5037, "solve_s": 33.19, "ffd_s": 12098, "stop_aware_best_s": 11763, "stop_aware_mean_s": 12032.4, "route_id": "RouteID_43dffcb4-b327-4a81-8a1f-41487dd84876", "plans": {"optimum": [{"route": ["S01", "S02", "S15", "S05", "S16", "S08", "S13", "S09", "S14", "S07"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S11", "S06", "S12", "S20", "S04", "S19"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S18", "S03", "S10", "S17"], "parcels": []}], "ffd": [{"route": ["S07", "S09", "S20", "S04", "S17"], "parcels": ["P12", "P29"]}, {"route": ["S14", "S20", "S19", "S03"], "parcels": ["P30"]}, {"route": ["S01", "S02", "S15", "S05", "S16", "S08", "S13", "S09", "S12", "S20", "S06", "S11", "S10", "S18"], "parcels": ["P11", "P28"]}], "stop_aware_best": [{"route": ["S14", "S20", "S03"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S01", "S06", "S07", "S09", "S05", "S02", "S15", "S17"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S11", "S16", "S08", "S13", "S12", "S04", "S19", "S18", "S10"], "parcels": []}]}}, "meta": {"route_id": "RouteID_43dffcb4-b327-4a81-8a1f-41487dd84876", "split": "train", "stops": 20, "vans": 3, "tightness": 0.89, "station": "DCH4", "city": "DCH", "date": "2018-07-28", "seconds": 69.8, "stop_aware_best_reward": 0.5892, "optimality": "best_found"}}
{"id": "7cd46dde-spread-n20-k3-t0.89-s0", "instance": {"stops": ["S01", "S02", "S03", "S04", "S05", "S06", "S07", "S08", "S09", "S10", "S11", "S12", "S13", "S14", "S15", "S16", "S17", "S18", "S19", "S20"], "parcels": [{"id": "P01", "stop": "S01", "volume_dl": 3}, {"id": "P02", "stop": "S02", "volume_dl": 44}, {"id": "P03", "stop": "S02", "volume_dl": 57}, {"id": "P04", "stop": "S03", "volume_dl": 34}, {"id": "P05", "stop": "S03", "volume_dl": 13}, {"id": "P06", "stop": "S03", "volume_dl": 34}, {"id": "P07", "stop": "S03", "volume_dl": 289}, {"id": "P08", "stop": "S03", "volume_dl": 97}, {"id": "P09", "stop": "S03", "volume_dl": 179}, {"id": "P10", "stop": "S04", "volume_dl": 12}, {"id": "P11", "stop": "S04", "volume_dl": 36}, {"id": "P12", "stop": "S04", "volume_dl": 134}, {"id": "P13", "stop": "S05", "volume_dl": 104}, {"id": "P14", "stop": "S06", "volume_dl": 309}, {"id": "P15", "stop": "S07", "volume_dl": 57}, {"id": "P16", "stop": "S07", "volume_dl": 104}, {"id": "P17", "stop": "S08", "volume_dl": 53}, {"id": "P18", "stop": "S09", "volume_dl": 57}, {"id": "P19", "stop": "S10", "volume_dl": 16}, {"id": "P20", "stop": "S10", "volume_dl": 429}, {"id": "P21", "stop": "S11", "volume_dl": 9}, {"id": "P22", "stop": "S12", "volume_dl": 542}, {"id": "P23", "stop": "S12", "volume_dl": 95}, {"id": "P24", "stop": "S13", "volume_dl": 92}, {"id": "P25", "stop": "S13", "volume_dl": 259}, {"id": "P26", "stop": "S13", "volume_dl": 25}, {"id": "P27", "stop": "S13", "volume_dl": 6}, {"id": "P28", "stop": "S13", "volume_dl": 57}, {"id": "P29", "stop": "S13", "volume_dl": 477}, {"id": "P30", "stop": "S14", "volume_dl": 10}, {"id": "P31", "stop": "S15", "volume_dl": 134}, {"id": "P32", "stop": "S15", "volume_dl": 6}, {"id": "P33", "stop": "S16", "volume_dl": 11}, {"id": "P34", "stop": "S16", "volume_dl": 16}, {"id": "P35", "stop": "S17", "volume_dl": 59}, {"id": "P36", "stop": "S17", "volume_dl": 17}, {"id": "P37", "stop": "S17", "volume_dl": 104}, {"id": "P38", "stop": "S17", "volume_dl": 10}, {"id": "P39", "stop": "S17", "volume_dl": 4}, {"id": "P40", "stop": "S17", "volume_dl": 14}, {"id": "P41", "stop": "S17", "volume_dl": 2}, {"id": "P42", "stop": "S17", "volume_dl": 32}, {"id": "P43", "stop": "S17", "volume_dl": 468}, {"id": "P44", "stop": "S17", "volume_dl": 20}, {"id": "P45", "stop": "S17", "volume_dl": 73}, {"id": "P46", "stop": "S17", "volume_dl": 60}, {"id": "P47", "stop": "S17", "volume_dl": 446}, {"id": "P48", "stop": "S17", "volume_dl": 133}, {"id": "P49", "stop": "S17", "volume_dl": 33}, {"id": "P50", "stop": "S17", "volume_dl": 133}, {"id": "P51", "stop": "S17", "volume_dl": 36}, {"id": "P52", "stop": "S18", "volume_dl": 157}, {"id": "P53", "stop": "S18", "volume_dl": 17}, {"id": "P54", "stop": "S19", "volume_dl": 60}, {"id": "P55", "stop": "S19", "volume_dl": 175}, {"id": "P56", "stop": "S20", "volume_dl": 15}], "vans": 3, "capacity_dl": 2200, "travel_s": [[0, 745, 778, 832, 792, 884, 757, 752, 799, 836, 794, 709, 770, 814, 712, 844, 842, 844, 655, 879, 820], [697, 0, 174, 183, 124, 252, 90, 102, 218, 192, 144, 230, 112, 147, 167, 176, 175, 314, 175, 305, 152], [750, 210, 0, 219, 147, 151, 114, 224, 342, 205, 263, 161, 158, 128, 67, 158, 170, 186, 128, 208, 133], [817, 202, 262, 0, 161, 178, 200, 209, 298, 146, 181, 353, 258, 122, 259, 123, 108, 222, 331, 245, 112], [708, 93, 158, 84, 0, 255, 91, 124, 219, 70, 128, 244, 181, 83, 150, 112, 125, 318, 221, 241, 88], [858, 290, 164, 347, 237, 0, 179, 306, 419, 287, 321, 272, 266, 152, 191, 92, 182, 106, 239, 67, 200], [709, 93, 96, 116, 34, 162, 0, 156, 251, 102, 160, 193, 87, 57, 88, 86, 85, 224, 150, 215, 62], [728, 91, 242, 82, 128, 262, 134, 0, 116, 87, 42, 224, 160, 191, 248, 207, 192, 306, 238, 283, 196], [759, 122, 275, 101, 133, 279, 164, 38, 0, 104, 80, 255, 191, 223, 279, 224, 195, 323, 270, 346, 213], [788, 145, 209, 60, 75, 238, 112, 60, 149, 0, 58, 284, 221, 138, 201, 168, 166, 283, 299, 305, 143], [769, 132, 285, 125, 146, 303, 175, 41, 144, 87, 0, 265, 202, 232, 290, 248, 233, 348, 280, 370, 237], [670, 211, 150, 311, 229, 261, 224, 278, 321, 297, 320, 0, 142, 238, 84, 267, 266, 270, 75, 292, 243], [766, 160, 84, 206, 132, 176, 127, 174, 292, 191, 217, 187, 0, 141, 88, 171, 183, 238, 135, 215, 146], [776, 160, 144, 156, 120, 140, 64, 176, 291, 142, 200, 257, 151, 0, 153, 46, 28, 204, 213, 175, 71], [694, 182, 66, 227, 145, 188, 151, 197, 313, 213, 239, 105, 148, 166, 0, 195, 193, 197, 72, 220, 170], [797, 180, 168, 193, 120, 90, 87, 216, 328, 179, 236, 281, 174, 60, 176, 0, 102, 156, 236, 133, 131], [748, 133, 217, 128, 92, 169, 131, 147, 263, 114, 172, 284, 220, 32, 190, 74, 0, 232, 261, 208, 43], [834, 323, 185, 380, 282, 96, 214, 337, 453, 320, 354, 267, 300, 187, 194, 149, 215, 0, 234, 71, 233], [639, 182, 137, 291, 218, 251, 213, 218, 319, 277, 261, 78, 114, 227, 74, 258, 270, 259, 0, 236, 233], [899, 282, 212, 367, 269, 48, 189, 317, 429, 280, 338, 320, 276, 162, 239, 101, 225, 15, 286, 0, 248], [738, 123, 188, 119, 71, 174, 121, 139, 254, 104, 162, 274, 211, 50, 180, 79, 77, 237, 252, 208, 0]]}, "reference": {"optimum_s": 5705, "optimality": "best_found", "lower_bound_s": 4717, "floor_s": 3882, "solve_s": 34.16, "ffd_s": 6957, "stop_aware_best_s": 6232, "stop_aware_mean_s": 6321.4, "route_id": "RouteID_7cd46dde-c440-4097-a897-3eba5870a8df", "plans": {"optimum": [{"route": ["S18", "S12", "S13", "S16", "S20", "S01"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S11", "S14", "S02", "S05", "S19", "S17"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S08", "S07", "S10", "S09", "S03", "S15", "S06", "S04"], "parcels": []}], "ffd": [{"route": ["S17", "S13", "S12"], "parcels": ["P22", "P25", "P27", "P29", "P41", "P43", "P47"]}, {"route": ["S06", "S04", "S10", "S03", "S15", "S05", "S19", "S17", "S18"], "parcels": ["P07", "P09", "P12", "P20", "P31", "P39", "P44", "P48", "P50", "P52", "P55"]}, {"route": ["S08", "S07", "S10", "S09", "S03", "S17", "S19", "S15", "S13", "S16", "S20", "S04", "S01", "S12", "S02", "S14", "S11", "S18"], "parcels": ["P04", "P05", "P06", "P08", "P10", "P11", "P19", "P23", "P24", "P26", "P28", "P32", "P35", "P36", "P37", "P38", "P40", "P42", "P45", "P46", "P49", "P51", "P53", "P54"]}], "stop_aware_best": [{"route": ["S14", "S19", "S17", "S20", "S04"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S08", "S09", "S13", "S06", "S12", "S18", "S11"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S01", "S10", "S07", "S03", "S16", "S15", "S05", "S02"], "parcels": []}]}}, "meta": {"route_id": "RouteID_7cd46dde-c440-4097-a897-3eba5870a8df", "split": "train", "stops": 20, "vans": 3, "tightness": 0.89, "station": "DCH1", "city": "DCH", "date": "2018-08-05", "seconds": 94.3, "stop_aware_best_reward": 0.6624, "optimality": "best_found"}}
{"id": "a44f5e58-spread-n30-k4-t0.85-s0", "instance": {"stops": ["S01", "S02", "S03", "S04", "S05", "S06", "S07", "S08", "S09", "S10", "S11", "S12", "S13", "S14", "S15", "S16", "S17", "S18", "S19", "S20", "S21", "S22", "S23", "S24", "S25", "S26", "S27", "S28", "S29", "S30"], "parcels": [{"id": "P01", "stop": "S01", "volume_dl": 92}, {"id": "P02", "stop": "S02", "volume_dl": 133}, {"id": "P03", "stop": "S03", "volume_dl": 63}, {"id": "P04", "stop": "S04", "volume_dl": 13}, {"id": "P05", "stop": "S05", "volume_dl": 242}, {"id": "P06", "stop": "S06", "volume_dl": 59}, {"id": "P07", "stop": "S07", "volume_dl": 30}, {"id": "P08", "stop": "S08", "volume_dl": 275}, {"id": "P09", "stop": "S09", "volume_dl": 133}, {"id": "P10", "stop": "S09", "volume_dl": 284}, {"id": "P11", "stop": "S10", "volume_dl": 43}, {"id": "P12", "stop": "S11", "volume_dl": 21}, {"id": "P13", "stop": "S12", "volume_dl": 57}, {"id": "P14", "stop": "S12", "volume_dl": 58}, {"id": "P15", "stop": "S13", "volume_dl": 32}, {"id": "P16", "stop": "S14", "volume_dl": 15}, {"id": "P17", "stop": "S14", "volume_dl": 36}, {"id": "P18", "stop": "S14", "volume_dl": 57}, {"id": "P19", "stop": "S14", "volume_dl": 30}, {"id": "P20", "stop": "S15", "volume_dl": 23}, {"id": "P21", "stop": "S16", "volume_dl": 277}, {"id": "P22", "stop": "S17", "volume_dl": 12}, {"id": "P23", "stop": "S18", "volume_dl": 39}, {"id": "P24", "stop": "S19", "volume_dl": 31}, {"id": "P25", "stop": "S20", "volume_dl": 322}, {"id": "P26", "stop": "S21", "volume_dl": 134}, {"id": "P27", "stop": "S22", "volume_dl": 104}, {"id": "P28", "stop": "S22", "volume_dl": 26}, {"id": "P29", "stop": "S22", "volume_dl": 322}, {"id": "P30", "stop": "S23", "volume_dl": 259}, {"id": "P31", "stop": "S24", "volume_dl": 34}, {"id": "P32", "stop": "S24", "volume_dl": 226}, {"id": "P33", "stop": "S24", "volume_dl": 12}, {"id": "P34", "stop": "S25", "volume_dl": 12}, {"id": "P35", "stop": "S26", "volume_dl": 7}, {"id": "P36", "stop": "S27", "volume_dl": 11}, {"id": "P37", "stop": "S27", "volume_dl": 95}, {"id": "P38", "stop": "S27", "volume_dl": 57}, {"id": "P39", "stop": "S28", "volume_dl": 259}, {"id": "P40", "stop": "S28", "volume_dl": 63}, {"id": "P41", "stop": "S29", "volume_dl": 63}, {"id": "P42", "stop": "S30", "volume_dl": 21}], "vans": 4, "capacity_dl": 1201, "travel_s": [[0, 578, 890, 811, 711, 394, 1160, 1178, 763, 1326, 587, 1188, 739, 719, 570, 502, 608, 716, 590, 694, 566, 651, 465, 503, 870, 684, 1470, 955, 595, 785, 613], [582, 0, 732, 303, 203, 353, 888, 875, 255, 954, 62, 925, 214, 252, 412, 224, 83, 169, 65, 536, 58, 390, 187, 363, 712, 526, 1046, 797, 82, 260, 107], [968, 675, 0, 716, 734, 710, 590, 603, 766, 836, 684, 617, 707, 668, 386, 535, 705, 664, 688, 206, 663, 451, 544, 720, 247, 366, 1014, 180, 692, 753, 712], [835, 310, 703, 0, 146, 606, 711, 698, 142, 846, 258, 748, 103, 168, 380, 317, 238, 171, 290, 506, 322, 357, 440, 615, 682, 496, 937, 767, 321, 116, 247], [783, 222, 698, 140, 0, 474, 794, 781, 83, 881, 171, 831, 51, 90, 421, 272, 150, 83, 202, 501, 234, 296, 308, 483, 677, 491, 972, 762, 233, 97, 159], [437, 341, 654, 575, 474, 0, 924, 942, 527, 1090, 350, 952, 503, 482, 333, 266, 371, 479, 354, 457, 330, 414, 228, 167, 634, 448, 1181, 718, 359, 549, 379], [1082, 866, 597, 688, 779, 943, 0, 13, 810, 246, 814, 84, 752, 712, 618, 757, 794, 709, 845, 553, 878, 531, 776, 952, 463, 598, 403, 548, 877, 798, 787], [1096, 879, 610, 701, 792, 956, 13, 0, 823, 233, 827, 70, 765, 725, 633, 770, 807, 722, 859, 566, 891, 545, 790, 965, 476, 611, 390, 561, 890, 811, 800], [839, 269, 748, 152, 104, 529, 845, 832, 0, 893, 217, 881, 61, 111, 425, 325, 196, 129, 248, 551, 280, 346, 363, 539, 728, 541, 984, 812, 280, 108, 206], [1195, 1018, 822, 840, 930, 1100, 225, 212, 962, 0, 966, 250, 901, 864, 800, 908, 945, 860, 997, 735, 1029, 683, 934, 1109, 688, 780, 228, 773, 1032, 949, 939], [588, 52, 714, 242, 179, 359, 826, 813, 211, 991, 0, 863, 152, 190, 393, 205, 21, 127, 31, 517, 64, 328, 193, 369, 693, 507, 1082, 778, 63, 198, 108], [1111, 894, 625, 717, 807, 971, 94, 81, 839, 273, 843, 0, 780, 740, 648, 785, 822, 737, 874, 581, 906, 560, 805, 980, 492, 626, 430, 576, 905, 826, 816], [826, 207, 690, 89, 43, 555, 787, 774, 58, 922, 155, 823, 0, 67, 411, 267, 135, 68, 187, 493, 219, 289, 387, 565, 663, 484, 1014, 752, 222, 46, 144], [731, 251, 636, 156, 78, 502, 733, 720, 110, 868, 199, 770, 69, 0, 313, 213, 179, 94, 230, 440, 263, 235, 336, 511, 616, 430, 959, 701, 262, 115, 188], [587, 322, 376, 364, 382, 358, 672, 659, 413, 809, 331, 709, 352, 315, 0, 182, 352, 313, 336, 179, 312, 131, 193, 369, 356, 170, 898, 440, 345, 401, 361], [518, 237, 509, 309, 272, 288, 785, 772, 315, 919, 208, 806, 256, 216, 188, 0, 229, 213, 207, 312, 242, 286, 122, 298, 488, 302, 1011, 573, 216, 302, 225], [609, 72, 708, 221, 158, 380, 805, 792, 190, 940, 20, 842, 131, 169, 385, 219, 0, 106, 52, 512, 84, 307, 214, 389, 688, 502, 1031, 773, 83, 177, 87], [730, 170, 635, 165, 90, 500, 732, 719, 134, 866, 118, 768, 76, 96, 358, 212, 98, 0, 150, 438, 176, 234, 334, 510, 615, 428, 958, 699, 181, 122, 101], [601, 64, 709, 262, 200, 372, 847, 834, 231, 1018, 20, 883, 173, 211, 388, 200, 41, 148, 0, 512, 91, 349, 206, 381, 689, 503, 1110, 773, 76, 219, 128], [733, 469, 196, 510, 528, 504, 561, 574, 560, 807, 478, 588, 501, 461, 179, 328, 499, 458, 481, 0, 457, 244, 338, 513, 270, 159, 971, 328, 486, 547, 506], [570, 50, 664, 282, 176, 341, 894, 881, 228, 927, 72, 931, 224, 262, 345, 263, 93, 170, 90, 467, 0, 400, 174, 350, 643, 457, 1019, 728, 121, 270, 80], [646, 382, 468, 360, 316, 417, 541, 528, 348, 675, 391, 577, 289, 249, 124, 225, 331, 246, 394, 271, 370, 0, 251, 426, 448, 261, 767, 532, 399, 335, 325], [419, 237, 549, 470, 370, 190, 820, 837, 422, 985, 246, 847, 396, 378, 228, 161, 267, 375, 249, 353, 225, 310, 0, 199, 529, 343, 1077, 614, 258, 444, 274], [484, 319, 632, 552, 452, 143, 902, 920, 504, 1067, 328, 929, 480, 460, 313, 243, 349, 457, 331, 435, 307, 392, 206, 0, 611, 425, 1159, 696, 336, 526, 356], [818, 628, 278, 670, 688, 664, 467, 480, 719, 714, 637, 495, 661, 621, 329, 488, 658, 618, 641, 274, 617, 404, 498, 673, 0, 319, 864, 230, 646, 707, 666], [687, 422, 293, 464, 482, 458, 564, 577, 513, 810, 431, 591, 454, 415, 133, 282, 452, 412, 435, 97, 410, 226, 291, 467, 273, 0, 973, 358, 440, 500, 460], [1303, 1087, 933, 909, 1000, 1170, 379, 366, 1031, 214, 1035, 357, 973, 933, 908, 978, 1015, 930, 1066, 842, 1049, 752, 1004, 1179, 799, 887, 0, 884, 1098, 1019, 1008], [928, 724, 210, 766, 784, 760, 551, 564, 815, 797, 733, 578, 755, 717, 435, 584, 754, 714, 737, 348, 713, 500, 594, 769, 201, 415, 975, 0, 745, 803, 762], [607, 82, 732, 294, 232, 378, 879, 866, 264, 1033, 53, 916, 203, 243, 417, 223, 74, 180, 56, 535, 123, 381, 211, 387, 705, 525, 1125, 796, 0, 251, 160], [902, 283, 766, 112, 119, 632, 824, 810, 116, 980, 232, 860, 76, 144, 489, 343, 211, 144, 263, 570, 295, 365, 465, 641, 746, 560, 1071, 830, 294, 0, 220], [661, 114, 714, 243, 168, 401, 810, 797, 220, 919, 101, 847, 154, 192, 437, 224, 80, 97, 132, 517, 116, 312, 235, 410, 693, 507, 1010, 778, 164, 200, 0]]}, "reference": {"optimum_s": 9002, "optimality": "best_found", "lower_bound_s": 6128, "floor_s": 3252, "solve_s": 39.18, "ffd_s": 13460, "stop_aware_best_s": 12288, "stop_aware_mean_s": 13055.2, "route_id": "RouteID_a44f5e58-8c62-47c8-b2b8-65385f068dca", "plans": {"optimum": [{"route": ["S01", "S30", "S17", "S21", "S14", "S25", "S19", "S02", "S27", "S24"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S28", "S18", "S16", "S10", "S20"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S15", "S13", "S04", "S08", "S12", "S29", "S03", "S26", "S09", "S06", "S07", "S11"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S05", "S23", "S22"], "parcels": []}], "ffd": [{"route": ["S23", "S22", "S20", "S04", "S09"], "parcels": ["P10", "P29"]}, {"route": ["S05", "S28", "S16", "S08", "S17", "S21"], "parcels": ["P39"]}, {"route": ["S02", "S27", "S24", "S06", "S09", "S03", "S29", "S12", "S10", "S28", "S01", "S22"], "parcels": ["P09", "P27", "P32", "P33", "P37", "P40"]}, {"route": ["S14", "S25", "S19", "S27", "S24", "S11", "S07", "S26", "S13", "S30", "S18", "S15", "S22"], "parcels": ["P28", "P31", "P36", "P38"]}], "stop_aware_best": [{"route": ["S05", "S27", "S14", "S17", "S16", "S28"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S02", "S11", "S29", "S30", "S10", "S18", "S01", "S20", "S22"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S19", "S21", "S13", "S04", "S08", "S03", "S15"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S23", "S12", "S26", "S09", "S07", "S06", "S24", "S25"], "parcels": []}]}}, "meta": {"route_id": "RouteID_a44f5e58-8c62-47c8-b2b8-65385f068dca", "split": "train", "stops": 30, "vans": 4, "tightness": 0.85, "station": "DBO2", "city": "DBO", "date": "2018-07-30", "seconds": 91.6, "stop_aware_best_reward": 0.4601, "optimality": "best_found"}}
{"id": "32b0c699-spread-n25-k3-t0.94-s0", "instance": {"stops": ["S01", "S02", "S03", "S04", "S05", "S06", "S07", "S08", "S09", "S10", "S11", "S12", "S13", "S14", "S15", "S16", "S17", "S18", "S19", "S20", "S21", "S22", "S23", "S24", "S25"], "parcels": [{"id": "P01", "stop": "S01", "volume_dl": 10}, {"id": "P02", "stop": "S02", "volume_dl": 429}, {"id": "P03", "stop": "S02", "volume_dl": 133}, {"id": "P04", "stop": "S02", "volume_dl": 104}, {"id": "P05", "stop": "S03", "volume_dl": 242}, {"id": "P06", "stop": "S04", "volume_dl": 18}, {"id": "P07", "stop": "S05", "volume_dl": 104}, {"id": "P08", "stop": "S06", "volume_dl": 36}, {"id": "P09", "stop": "S07", "volume_dl": 104}, {"id": "P10", "stop": "S08", "volume_dl": 57}, {"id": "P11", "stop": "S09", "volume_dl": 95}, {"id": "P12", "stop": "S10", "volume_dl": 157}, {"id": "P13", "stop": "S10", "volume_dl": 57}, {"id": "P14", "stop": "S11", "volume_dl": 190}, {"id": "P15", "stop": "S12", "volume_dl": 133}, {"id": "P16", "stop": "S13", "volume_dl": 259}, {"id": "P17", "stop": "S14", "volume_dl": 51}, {"id": "P18", "stop": "S15", "volume_dl": 32}, {"id": "P19", "stop": "S16", "volume_dl": 35}, {"id": "P20", "stop": "S17", "volume_dl": 133}, {"id": "P21", "stop": "S18", "volume_dl": 11}, {"id": "P22", "stop": "S19", "volume_dl": 134}, {"id": "P23", "stop": "S20", "volume_dl": 92}, {"id": "P24", "stop": "S21", "volume_dl": 34}, {"id": "P25", "stop": "S21", "volume_dl": 57}, {"id": "P26", "stop": "S21", "volume_dl": 41}, {"id": "P27", "stop": "S22", "volume_dl": 34}, {"id": "P28", "stop": "S23", "volume_dl": 32}, {"id": "P29", "stop": "S24", "volume_dl": 19}, {"id": "P30", "stop": "S25", "volume_dl": 63}, {"id": "P31", "stop": "S25", "volume_dl": 322}, {"id": "P32", "stop": "S25", "volume_dl": 518}], "vans": 3, "capacity_dl": 1326, "travel_s": [[0, 2535, 2721, 2698, 2711, 2497, 2854, 2528, 2732, 2600, 2709, 2447, 2720, 2579, 2617, 2486, 2530, 2659, 2818, 2615, 2473, 2851, 2706, 2437, 2592, 2687], [2832, 0, 501, 419, 407, 145, 568, 61, 512, 140, 404, 216, 416, 112, 224, 256, 276, 355, 514, 92, 242, 564, 385, 206, 68, 467], [3170, 473, 0, 338, 232, 420, 511, 413, 199, 460, 323, 555, 224, 405, 417, 594, 385, 407, 432, 451, 581, 483, 236, 545, 460, 154], [2829, 417, 377, 0, 203, 483, 188, 357, 406, 458, 24, 565, 212, 350, 431, 604, 509, 100, 134, 404, 591, 184, 373, 555, 405, 361], [2889, 399, 226, 154, 0, 388, 282, 339, 255, 428, 140, 523, 7, 331, 338, 562, 358, 255, 249, 372, 549, 300, 222, 513, 386, 210], [2966, 172, 356, 424, 319, 0, 552, 155, 367, 192, 410, 277, 311, 206, 226, 316, 139, 448, 519, 258, 303, 570, 341, 267, 253, 322], [2956, 566, 504, 199, 294, 629, 0, 506, 436, 607, 167, 764, 300, 498, 530, 803, 599, 300, 168, 553, 790, 66, 463, 754, 554, 391], [2771, 60, 482, 358, 346, 126, 506, 0, 493, 101, 343, 208, 354, 51, 136, 247, 230, 293, 452, 71, 234, 503, 323, 198, 47, 448], [3124, 570, 248, 379, 291, 391, 447, 511, 0, 430, 364, 526, 284, 503, 515, 565, 361, 448, 473, 549, 551, 494, 334, 516, 558, 135], [3013, 152, 410, 478, 372, 159, 605, 116, 421, 0, 463, 259, 365, 237, 112, 298, 153, 410, 572, 102, 284, 623, 394, 249, 97, 376], [2861, 395, 363, 32, 136, 461, 163, 335, 392, 424, 0, 543, 143, 328, 334, 582, 415, 132, 109, 368, 569, 160, 359, 533, 383, 347], [2980, 210, 425, 493, 388, 201, 621, 203, 436, 259, 479, 0, 380, 254, 321, 44, 234, 497, 588, 290, 31, 639, 410, 19, 266, 391], [2879, 388, 219, 162, 8, 381, 290, 328, 248, 421, 147, 516, 0, 321, 327, 555, 352, 262, 257, 361, 542, 307, 216, 506, 376, 203], [2777, 104, 428, 345, 401, 170, 494, 44, 457, 145, 330, 252, 393, 0, 141, 291, 274, 293, 439, 91, 278, 490, 327, 242, 92, 412], [2865, 181, 416, 363, 379, 240, 512, 114, 428, 111, 349, 321, 372, 142, 0, 360, 160, 311, 458, 104, 347, 509, 347, 312, 127, 382], [3023, 253, 468, 536, 431, 244, 664, 246, 479, 302, 522, 43, 423, 297, 364, 0, 277, 540, 631, 333, 12, 682, 453, 62, 309, 434], [3068, 264, 316, 384, 279, 151, 512, 297, 327, 165, 369, 391, 271, 289, 182, 430, 0, 370, 479, 214, 417, 529, 301, 381, 209, 282], [2789, 356, 363, 115, 190, 423, 302, 297, 392, 398, 139, 504, 199, 289, 393, 544, 496, 0, 222, 344, 530, 299, 360, 495, 344, 347], [2919, 534, 469, 148, 243, 600, 170, 474, 515, 575, 105, 682, 250, 466, 439, 721, 520, 217, 0, 521, 708, 166, 466, 672, 522, 470], [2829, 78, 448, 407, 411, 162, 556, 78, 460, 101, 393, 244, 404, 135, 138, 283, 192, 352, 502, 0, 269, 553, 391, 234, 23, 414], [3011, 240, 456, 524, 419, 231, 651, 234, 467, 289, 509, 30, 411, 284, 352, 13, 264, 527, 618, 320, 0, 669, 441, 50, 297, 422], [2970, 579, 557, 213, 318, 645, 62, 520, 488, 621, 185, 727, 325, 512, 514, 766, 652, 313, 181, 567, 753, 0, 516, 717, 567, 444], [2976, 348, 234, 311, 206, 414, 439, 289, 263, 383, 296, 496, 198, 281, 293, 536, 260, 381, 406, 327, 522, 457, 0, 486, 336, 218], [2961, 190, 405, 474, 368, 181, 601, 183, 417, 239, 459, 30, 361, 234, 301, 74, 214, 477, 568, 270, 60, 619, 390, 0, 246, 372], [2827, 55, 464, 414, 427, 139, 562, 56, 475, 114, 399, 221, 419, 159, 156, 260, 208, 349, 508, 24, 246, 559, 414, 211, 0, 430], [3169, 616, 293, 424, 336, 436, 492, 556, 45, 475, 409, 570, 329, 548, 560, 610, 406, 493, 518, 594, 596, 539, 379, 561, 603, 0]]}, "reference": {"optimum_s": 19040, "optimality": "best_found", "lower_bound_s": 17827, "floor_s": 15624, "solve_s": 46.17, "ffd_s": 20584, "stop_aware_best_s": 20104, "stop_aware_mean_s": 20318.6, "route_id": "RouteID_32b0c699-8410-4a25-8912-77e4f86b67fb", "plans": {"optimum": [{"route": ["S25", "S08", "S16", "S09", "S14", "S19", "S24", "S01"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S05", "S02", "S22", "S13", "S07"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S15", "S20", "S11", "S23", "S12", "S04", "S06", "S21", "S18", "S10", "S03", "S17"], "parcels": []}], "ffd": [{"route": ["S02", "S25", "S08"], "parcels": ["P02", "P31", "P32"]}, {"route": ["S11", "S13", "S19", "S02", "S25", "S12", "S03", "S10", "S18"], "parcels": ["P03", "P12", "P30"]}, {"route": ["S15", "S20", "S23", "S05", "S01", "S07", "S24", "S09", "S14", "S16", "S02", "S22", "S04", "S21", "S06", "S10", "S17"], "parcels": ["P04", "P13"]}], "stop_aware_best": [{"route": ["S23", "S24", "S09", "S25", "S08", "S17"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S15", "S20", "S11", "S07", "S14", "S12", "S04", "S03", "S10", "S18", "S21"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S13", "S19", "S01", "S05", "S16", "S02", "S22", "S06"], "parcels": []}]}}, "meta": {"route_id": "RouteID_32b0c699-8410-4a25-8912-77e4f86b67fb", "split": "train", "stops": 25, "vans": 3, "tightness": 0.94, "station": "DBO3", "city": "DBO", "date": "2018-08-09", "seconds": 86.8, "stop_aware_best_reward": 0.6368, "optimality": "best_found"}}
{"id": "85bc6e80-spread-n20-k3-t0.88-s0", "instance": {"stops": ["S01", "S02", "S03", "S04", "S05", "S06", "S07", "S08", "S09", "S10", "S11", "S12", "S13", "S14", "S15", "S16", "S17", "S18", "S19", "S20"], "parcels": [{"id": "P01", "stop": "S01", "volume_dl": 30}, {"id": "P02", "stop": "S02", "volume_dl": 79}, {"id": "P03", "stop": "S03", "volume_dl": 104}, {"id": "P04", "stop": "S04", "volume_dl": 46}, {"id": "P05", "stop": "S05", "volume_dl": 104}, {"id": "P06", "stop": "S05", "volume_dl": 57}, {"id": "P07", "stop": "S05", "volume_dl": 18}, {"id": "P08", "stop": "S06", "volume_dl": 34}, {"id": "P09", "stop": "S07", "volume_dl": 92}, {"id": "P10", "stop": "S08", "volume_dl": 5}, {"id": "P11", "stop": "S09", "volume_dl": 40}, {"id": "P12", "stop": "S10", "volume_dl": 322}, {"id": "P13", "stop": "S11", "volume_dl": 196}, {"id": "P14", "stop": "S12", "volume_dl": 35}, {"id": "P15", "stop": "S13", "volume_dl": 16}, {"id": "P16", "stop": "S14", "volume_dl": 60}, {"id": "P17", "stop": "S15", "volume_dl": 133}, {"id": "P18", "stop": "S16", "volume_dl": 157}, {"id": "P19", "stop": "S16", "volume_dl": 104}, {"id": "P20", "stop": "S17", "volume_dl": 179}, {"id": "P21", "stop": "S18", "volume_dl": 13}, {"id": "P22", "stop": "S18", "volume_dl": 48}, {"id": "P23", "stop": "S18", "volume_dl": 134}, {"id": "P24", "stop": "S18", "volume_dl": 51}, {"id": "P25", "stop": "S18", "volume_dl": 34}, {"id": "P26", "stop": "S19", "volume_dl": 37}, {"id": "P27", "stop": "S19", "volume_dl": 133}, {"id": "P28", "stop": "S19", "volume_dl": 21}, {"id": "P29", "stop": "S20", "volume_dl": 27}], "vans": 3, "capacity_dl": 875, "travel_s": [[0, 3041, 3191, 3026, 3389, 3006, 3101, 3142, 3138, 3124, 3357, 3086, 3188, 3175, 3158, 2997, 3054, 3072, 3083, 3039, 3252], [2870, 0, 307, 146, 455, 127, 119, 284, 155, 274, 444, 104, 316, 193, 365, 94, 261, 234, 224, 353, 318], [2968, 288, 0, 183, 453, 244, 181, 325, 259, 46, 443, 275, 60, 188, 296, 296, 239, 127, 117, 331, 252], [2815, 154, 190, 0, 474, 61, 147, 303, 175, 134, 464, 132, 198, 231, 253, 113, 149, 134, 124, 241, 337], [3230, 441, 476, 473, 0, 528, 464, 332, 448, 522, 240, 386, 536, 434, 692, 496, 587, 571, 561, 679, 228], [2802, 128, 216, 26, 501, 0, 174, 330, 202, 160, 491, 159, 225, 257, 280, 87, 175, 161, 149, 267, 364], [2904, 122, 208, 137, 456, 176, 0, 285, 157, 158, 446, 114, 216, 132, 294, 140, 190, 135, 125, 282, 319], [2990, 269, 352, 301, 339, 356, 291, 0, 276, 356, 338, 213, 399, 262, 520, 318, 415, 398, 388, 507, 202], [2957, 145, 271, 177, 432, 233, 193, 261, 0, 212, 422, 72, 289, 61, 409, 200, 291, 233, 223, 383, 294], [2921, 242, 56, 136, 501, 197, 135, 330, 229, 0, 491, 229, 74, 159, 257, 250, 192, 81, 71, 284, 308], [3188, 399, 419, 431, 278, 486, 421, 290, 406, 465, 0, 343, 480, 392, 650, 454, 545, 528, 518, 637, 189], [2888, 76, 281, 108, 383, 164, 99, 212, 65, 225, 372, 0, 290, 126, 327, 131, 222, 206, 196, 314, 245], [2988, 308, 53, 203, 506, 264, 202, 356, 289, 76, 496, 296, 0, 219, 314, 317, 259, 148, 138, 351, 305], [3007, 175, 210, 225, 404, 281, 132, 233, 70, 151, 394, 142, 228, 0, 348, 230, 283, 172, 162, 375, 267], [2963, 354, 289, 254, 674, 313, 294, 503, 375, 242, 664, 332, 306, 341, 0, 324, 210, 168, 179, 302, 537], [2787, 104, 294, 124, 490, 115, 133, 305, 191, 244, 480, 139, 302, 228, 329, 0, 224, 221, 211, 316, 353], [2866, 258, 231, 158, 578, 184, 197, 407, 278, 186, 568, 236, 250, 285, 198, 227, 0, 112, 124, 172, 441], [2864, 238, 130, 150, 567, 215, 138, 396, 243, 74, 557, 225, 138, 173, 176, 225, 112, 0, 11, 204, 382], [2876, 225, 117, 138, 555, 164, 126, 384, 231, 62, 545, 213, 126, 160, 188, 237, 123, 11, 0, 215, 370], [2834, 336, 309, 236, 656, 263, 276, 485, 357, 264, 646, 314, 329, 363, 277, 306, 139, 190, 203, 0, 519], [3100, 311, 255, 343, 215, 398, 333, 202, 318, 301, 208, 255, 316, 304, 551, 366, 457, 382, 372, 549, 0]]}, "reference": {"optimum_s": 20087, "optimality": "best_found", "lower_bound_s": 19303, "floor_s": 17352, "solve_s": 34.16, "ffd_s": 21822, "stop_aware_best_s": 21102, "stop_aware_mean_s": 21261.8, "route_id": "RouteID_85bc6e80-13cb-41e0-9c82-74ea8ab966c7", "plans": {"optimum": [{"route": ["S05", "S03", "S06", "S13", "S08", "S11", "S01", "S15"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S07", "S04", "S10", "S20", "S02", "S12", "S09", "S17"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S19", "S16", "S14", "S18"], "parcels": []}], "ffd": [{"route": ["S10", "S11", "S17", "S16", "S19"], "parcels": ["P18", "P28"]}, {"route": ["S19", "S16", "S14", "S18", "S08", "S07", "S03", "S05", "S15"], "parcels": ["P05", "P19", "P23", "P27"]}, {"route": ["S19", "S18", "S09", "S12", "S02", "S20", "S04", "S13", "S06", "S01", "S05"], "parcels": ["P06", "P07", "P21", "P22", "P24", "P25", "P26"]}], "stop_aware_best": [{"route": ["S04", "S03", "S18", "S17", "S16"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S14", "S09", "S12", "S02", "S20", "S10", "S07", "S06", "S01"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S05", "S15", "S11", "S08", "S13", "S19"], "parcels": []}]}}, "meta": {"route_id": "RouteID_85bc6e80-13cb-41e0-9c82-74ea8ab966c7", "split": "train", "stops": 20, "vans": 3, "tightness": 0.88, "station": "DSE5", "city": "DSE", "date": "2018-08-17", "seconds": 76.7, "stop_aware_best_reward": 0.5909, "optimality": "best_found"}}
{"id": "fa717416-spread-n20-k3-t0.89-s0", "instance": {"stops": ["S01", "S02", "S03", "S04", "S05", "S06", "S07", "S08", "S09", "S10", "S11", "S12", "S13", "S14", "S15", "S16", "S17", "S18", "S19", "S20"], "parcels": [{"id": "P01", "stop": "S01", "volume_dl": 322}, {"id": "P02", "stop": "S01", "volume_dl": 242}, {"id": "P03", "stop": "S02", "volume_dl": 133}, {"id": "P04", "stop": "S03", "volume_dl": 57}, {"id": "P05", "stop": "S04", "volume_dl": 542}, {"id": "P06", "stop": "S04", "volume_dl": 34}, {"id": "P07", "stop": "S04", "volume_dl": 429}, {"id": "P08", "stop": "S04", "volume_dl": 92}, {"id": "P09", "stop": "S04", "volume_dl": 284}, {"id": "P10", "stop": "S04", "volume_dl": 840}, {"id": "P11", "stop": "S05", "volume_dl": 57}, {"id": "P12", "stop": "S06", "volume_dl": 368}, {"id": "P13", "stop": "S07", "volume_dl": 179}, {"id": "P14", "stop": "S08", "volume_dl": 18}, {"id": "P15", "stop": "S08", "volume_dl": 27}, {"id": "P16", "stop": "S09", "volume_dl": 12}, {"id": "P17", "stop": "S09", "volume_dl": 9}, {"id": "P18", "stop": "S09", "volume_dl": 413}, {"id": "P19", "stop": "S10", "volume_dl": 53}, {"id": "P20", "stop": "S11", "volume_dl": 92}, {"id": "P21", "stop": "S11", "volume_dl": 13}, {"id": "P22", "stop": "S11", "volume_dl": 34}, {"id": "P23", "stop": "S12", "volume_dl": 60}, {"id": "P24", "stop": "S13", "volume_dl": 599}, {"id": "P25", "stop": "S13", "volume_dl": 46}, {"id": "P26", "stop": "S13", "volume_dl": 179}, {"id": "P27", "stop": "S13", "volume_dl": 114}, {"id": "P28", "stop": "S14", "volume_dl": 2}, {"id": "P29", "stop": "S14", "volume_dl": 42}, {"id": "P30", "stop": "S14", "volume_dl": 95}, {"id": "P31", "stop": "S14", "volume_dl": 2}, {"id": "P32", "stop": "S14", "volume_dl": 63}, {"id": "P33", "stop": "S15", "volume_dl": 34}, {"id": "P34", "stop": "S16", "volume_dl": 133}, {"id": "P35", "stop": "S17", "volume_dl": 92}, {"id": "P36", "stop": "S18", "volume_dl": 31}, {"id": "P37", "stop": "S18", "volume_dl": 34}, {"id": "P38", "stop": "S19", "volume_dl": 31}, {"id": "P39", "stop": "S20", "volume_dl": 277}], "vans": 3, "capacity_dl": 2278, "travel_s": [[0, 2095, 2034, 2317, 2163, 2137, 2085, 2125, 2305, 2137, 2194, 2284, 2302, 2289, 2234, 2280, 2283, 2062, 2178, 2182, 2181], [1974, 0, 78, 491, 246, 182, 129, 169, 469, 182, 276, 458, 476, 463, 520, 454, 457, 106, 260, 226, 263], [1912, 98, 0, 429, 167, 103, 51, 91, 417, 103, 197, 396, 414, 401, 462, 392, 395, 28, 182, 148, 185], [2202, 448, 425, 0, 455, 471, 377, 378, 170, 442, 485, 32, 133, 203, 181, 194, 149, 410, 470, 487, 472], [2048, 289, 190, 443, 0, 260, 129, 96, 422, 232, 54, 411, 429, 416, 442, 407, 410, 162, 81, 277, 41], [2047, 232, 134, 458, 240, 0, 138, 164, 446, 46, 271, 426, 444, 431, 491, 422, 424, 115, 255, 107, 258], [1974, 160, 62, 372, 116, 150, 0, 40, 360, 122, 147, 339, 357, 344, 405, 335, 338, 34, 131, 166, 134], [2006, 192, 94, 407, 76, 164, 32, 0, 396, 136, 107, 375, 393, 380, 441, 371, 374, 66, 91, 180, 94], [2220, 466, 443, 176, 473, 489, 395, 397, 0, 461, 504, 136, 161, 221, 198, 212, 71, 429, 483, 506, 491], [2038, 224, 126, 430, 212, 59, 130, 136, 408, 0, 242, 397, 415, 402, 460, 393, 396, 107, 227, 61, 230], [2059, 299, 201, 454, 54, 271, 139, 107, 442, 243, 0, 421, 439, 426, 487, 417, 420, 173, 96, 287, 50], [2170, 415, 392, 32, 422, 438, 344, 346, 128, 410, 453, 0, 100, 170, 145, 161, 116, 378, 432, 455, 440], [2204, 466, 443, 140, 473, 489, 395, 397, 189, 461, 503, 108, 0, 221, 142, 212, 167, 429, 488, 505, 491], [2148, 408, 385, 219, 415, 431, 337, 338, 197, 402, 445, 186, 204, 0, 248, 9, 185, 370, 425, 447, 432], [2141, 441, 418, 115, 491, 507, 369, 371, 163, 435, 478, 82, 92, 196, 0, 186, 185, 403, 458, 480, 465], [2139, 399, 376, 210, 406, 422, 328, 329, 198, 394, 436, 177, 195, 9, 243, 0, 176, 361, 421, 438, 424], [2200, 446, 423, 155, 453, 468, 374, 376, 53, 440, 483, 122, 140, 201, 188, 192, 0, 408, 467, 485, 470], [1940, 126, 28, 395, 140, 104, 23, 63, 383, 104, 170, 362, 380, 367, 428, 358, 361, 0, 154, 149, 157], [2043, 283, 185, 438, 81, 255, 123, 91, 417, 227, 116, 401, 424, 411, 463, 402, 404, 157, 0, 272, 103], [2049, 235, 137, 441, 223, 106, 141, 146, 429, 47, 253, 408, 426, 413, 474, 404, 407, 118, 238, 0, 241], [2058, 298, 200, 453, 53, 270, 138, 106, 441, 242, 42, 420, 438, 426, 486, 416, 419, 172, 95, 286, 0]]}, "reference": {"optimum_s": 14086, "optimality": "best_found", "lower_bound_s": 12828, "floor_s": 11838, "solve_s": 34.12, "ffd_s": 16105, "stop_aware_best_s": 15016, "stop_aware_mean_s": 15453, "route_id": "RouteID_fa717416-921d-42a9-9719-81b9a7ec3491", "plans": {"optimum": [{"route": ["S01", "S02", "S05", "S09", "S19", "S17", "S06", "S07", "S20", "S10", "S18"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S04"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S14", "S12", "S03", "S11", "S16", "S08", "S15", "S13"], "parcels": []}], "ffd": [{"route": ["S04", "S11", "S13"], "parcels": ["P05", "P09", "P10", "P21", "P24"]}, {"route": ["S14", "S13", "S07", "S04", "S20", "S06", "S09", "S01"], "parcels": ["P07", "P18", "P25", "P28"]}, {"route": ["S14", "S12", "S03", "S11", "S16", "S08", "S15", "S13", "S04", "S10", "S18", "S17", "S05", "S09", "S19", "S02"], "parcels": ["P06", "P08", "P16", "P17", "P20", "P22", "P26", "P27", "P29", "P30", "P31", "P32"]}], "stop_aware_best": [{"route": ["S04", "S10"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S14", "S11", "S03", "S16", "S08", "S13", "S09", "S02"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S01", "S05", "S19", "S17", "S06", "S07", "S20", "S18", "S12", "S15"], "parcels": []}]}}, "meta": {"route_id": "RouteID_fa717416-921d-42a9-9719-81b9a7ec3491", "split": "train", "stops": 20, "vans": 3, "tightness": 0.89, "station": "DLA9", "city": "DLA", "date": "2018-07-21", "seconds": 85.4, "stop_aware_best_reward": 0.5623, "optimality": "best_found"}}
{"id": "bc0a758f-spread-n40-k4-t0.95-s0", "instance": {"stops": ["S01", "S02", "S03", "S04", "S05", "S06", "S07", "S08", "S09", "S10", "S11", "S12", "S13", "S14", "S15", "S16", "S17", "S18", "S19", "S20", "S21", "S22", "S23", "S24", "S25", "S26", "S27", "S28", "S29", "S30", "S31", "S32", "S33", "S34", "S35", "S36", "S37", "S38", "S39", "S40"], "parcels": [{"id": "P01", "stop": "S01", "volume_dl": 104}, {"id": "P02", "stop": "S02", "volume_dl": 54}, {"id": "P03", "stop": "S03", "volume_dl": 13}, {"id": "P04", "stop": "S04", "volume_dl": 34}, {"id": "P05", "stop": "S04", "volume_dl": 5}, {"id": "P06", "stop": "S05", "volume_dl": 42}, {"id": "P07", "stop": "S05", "volume_dl": 34}, {"id": "P08", "stop": "S05", "volume_dl": 133}, {"id": "P09", "stop": "S05", "volume_dl": 92}, {"id": "P10", "stop": "S06", "volume_dl": 34}, {"id": "P11", "stop": "S06", "volume_dl": 20}, {"id": "P12", "stop": "S06", "volume_dl": 8}, {"id": "P13", "stop": "S07", "volume_dl": 34}, {"id": "P14", "stop": "S07", "volume_dl": 29}, {"id": "P15", "stop": "S07", "volume_dl": 41}, {"id": "P16", "stop": "S08", "volume_dl": 322}, {"id": "P17", "stop": "S09", "volume_dl": 4}, {"id": "P18", "stop": "S10", "volume_dl": 104}, {"id": "P19", "stop": "S11", "volume_dl": 41}, {"id": "P20", "stop": "S12", "volume_dl": 36}, {"id": "P21", "stop": "S13", "volume_dl": 57}, {"id": "P22", "stop": "S13", "volume_dl": 157}, {"id": "P23", "stop": "S14", "volume_dl": 133}, {"id": "P24", "stop": "S15", "volume_dl": 289}, {"id": "P25", "stop": "S15", "volume_dl": 277}, {"id": "P26", "stop": "S15", "volume_dl": 57}, {"id": "P27", "stop": "S16", "volume_dl": 30}, {"id": "P28", "stop": "S17", "volume_dl": 58}, {"id": "P29", "stop": "S17", "volume_dl": 322}, {"id": "P30", "stop": "S17", "volume_dl": 133}, {"id": "P31", "stop": "S18", "volume_dl": 14}, {"id": "P32", "stop": "S18", "volume_dl": 79}, {"id": "P33", "stop": "S19", "volume_dl": 21}, {"id": "P34", "stop": "S19", "volume_dl": 21}, {"id": "P35", "stop": "S20", "volume_dl": 429}, {"id": "P36", "stop": "S20", "volume_dl": 542}, {"id": "P37", "stop": "S20", "volume_dl": 13}, {"id": "P38", "stop": "S20", "volume_dl": 37}, {"id": "P39", "stop": "S20", "volume_dl": 33}, {"id": "P40", "stop": "S20", "volume_dl": 57}, {"id": "P41", "stop": "S20", "volume_dl": 429}, {"id": "P42", "stop": "S20", "volume_dl": 322}, {"id": "P43", "stop": "S21", "volume_dl": 18}, {"id": "P44", "stop": "S21", "volume_dl": 51}, {"id": "P45", "stop": "S21", "volume_dl": 133}, {"id": "P46", "stop": "S22", "volume_dl": 92}, {"id": "P47", "stop": "S22", "volume_dl": 134}, {"id": "P48", "stop": "S22", "volume_dl": 104}, {"id": "P49", "stop": "S23", "volume_dl": 104}, {"id": "P50", "stop": "S24", "volume_dl": 95}, {"id": "P51", "stop": "S25", "volume_dl": 133}, {"id": "P52", "stop": "S26", "volume_dl": 63}, {"id": "P53", "stop": "S26", "volume_dl": 179}, {"id": "P54", "stop": "S27", "volume_dl": 21}, {"id": "P55", "stop": "S28", "volume_dl": 30}, {"id": "P56", "stop": "S29", "volume_dl": 14}, {"id": "P57", "stop": "S30", "volume_dl": 43}, {"id": "P58", "stop": "S30", "volume_dl": 59}, {"id": "P59", "stop": "S30", "volume_dl": 20}, {"id": "P60", "stop": "S31", "volume_dl": 157}, {"id": "P61", "stop": "S32", "volume_dl": 27}, {"id": "P62", "stop": "S33", "volume_dl": 21}, {"id": "P63", "stop": "S34", "volume_dl": 25}, {"id": "P64", "stop": "S35", "volume_dl": 14}, {"id": "P65", "stop": "S36", "volume_dl": 11}, {"id": "P66", "stop": "S36", "volume_dl": 22}, {"id": "P67", "stop": "S37", "volume_dl": 63}, {"id": "P68", "stop": "S38", "volume_dl": 37}, {"id": "P69", "stop": "S39", "volume_dl": 19}, {"id": "P70", "stop": "S40", "volume_dl": 104}], "vans": 4, "capacity_dl": 1708, "travel_s": [[0, 2509, 2352, 2430, 2608, 2314, 2412, 2388, 2247, 2310, 2347, 2529, 2497, 2434, 2296, 2338, 2293, 2339, 2382, 2316, 2349, 2391, 2359, 2321, 2300, 2262, 2423, 2389, 2396, 2339, 2508, 2366, 2627, 2406, 2355, 2234, 2298, 2388, 2539, 2554, 2371], [2493, 0, 516, 642, 198, 555, 330, 193, 331, 543, 461, 119, 12, 146, 288, 575, 290, 567, 610, 529, 561, 309, 597, 549, 505, 599, 340, 188, 313, 550, 117, 603, 217, 204, 182, 442, 506, 551, 30, 119, 169], [2536, 544, 0, 315, 644, 203, 407, 385, 237, 100, 198, 565, 533, 451, 291, 223, 288, 171, 242, 202, 234, 386, 244, 181, 61, 260, 417, 384, 390, 79, 525, 251, 662, 401, 352, 318, 381, 33, 575, 590, 365], [2618, 703, 299, 0, 802, 179, 565, 543, 395, 258, 325, 723, 691, 609, 449, 203, 446, 319, 486, 127, 170, 544, 225, 425, 247, 342, 576, 542, 548, 326, 683, 231, 821, 559, 510, 561, 624, 335, 733, 748, 523], [2569, 182, 591, 718, 0, 625, 406, 275, 406, 619, 536, 93, 183, 225, 363, 651, 366, 632, 686, 604, 631, 371, 672, 624, 580, 675, 403, 264, 389, 626, 240, 679, 18, 281, 257, 518, 579, 627, 157, 170, 245], [2514, 579, 200, 171, 674, 0, 441, 417, 266, 155, 201, 594, 562, 481, 321, 19, 322, 191, 387, 58, 86, 420, 76, 322, 144, 227, 434, 418, 424, 227, 560, 92, 697, 435, 386, 458, 521, 236, 609, 619, 395], [2436, 349, 458, 621, 449, 531, 0, 248, 274, 486, 383, 369, 337, 274, 230, 553, 233, 500, 552, 508, 541, 90, 576, 491, 447, 542, 44, 230, 143, 451, 353, 583, 467, 247, 265, 385, 448, 494, 380, 394, 211], [2394, 195, 416, 542, 295, 450, 233, 0, 231, 443, 322, 215, 183, 102, 191, 475, 194, 470, 528, 429, 459, 202, 495, 464, 405, 499, 244, 73, 217, 412, 179, 504, 313, 110, 44, 318, 381, 452, 225, 240, 48], [2262, 333, 284, 411, 433, 320, 237, 212, 0, 312, 239, 354, 322, 258, 121, 344, 118, 399, 442, 298, 330, 216, 366, 380, 273, 368, 247, 214, 220, 328, 332, 372, 451, 231, 180, 211, 274, 320, 364, 378, 195], [2494, 572, 80, 274, 671, 161, 434, 412, 264, 0, 225, 592, 560, 478, 318, 181, 315, 144, 268, 160, 193, 413, 203, 207, 28, 219, 445, 411, 418, 106, 552, 210, 690, 428, 379, 344, 407, 115, 602, 617, 393], [2342, 469, 212, 307, 568, 216, 352, 309, 186, 239, 0, 489, 457, 376, 236, 240, 231, 354, 397, 194, 226, 331, 262, 336, 201, 264, 362, 371, 335, 205, 449, 268, 587, 346, 276, 291, 354, 248, 499, 514, 352], [2503, 129, 526, 652, 86, 562, 340, 204, 341, 553, 471, 0, 117, 157, 298, 585, 300, 577, 620, 539, 571, 319, 607, 559, 515, 609, 350, 198, 323, 560, 174, 614, 105, 215, 192, 453, 516, 561, 113, 126, 179], [2481, 12, 504, 630, 186, 540, 318, 182, 319, 531, 449, 107, 0, 134, 276, 563, 278, 555, 598, 517, 549, 297, 585, 537, 493, 587, 328, 176, 301, 538, 105, 592, 205, 192, 170, 431, 494, 539, 42, 131, 157], [2431, 135, 453, 579, 240, 489, 265, 118, 268, 480, 380, 167, 123, 0, 225, 513, 227, 530, 580, 466, 496, 232, 533, 522, 442, 536, 265, 125, 250, 469, 82, 541, 265, 58, 101, 376, 436, 489, 165, 192, 106], [2294, 286, 332, 458, 386, 371, 190, 226, 131, 359, 237, 306, 274, 211, 0, 391, 35, 397, 440, 345, 377, 169, 413, 379, 320, 415, 200, 167, 173, 327, 285, 419, 404, 184, 193, 243, 306, 367, 317, 332, 148], [2543, 603, 225, 196, 701, 33, 466, 447, 295, 184, 225, 623, 591, 508, 350, 0, 346, 229, 410, 81, 113, 440, 109, 350, 173, 256, 474, 442, 449, 252, 588, 117, 721, 460, 411, 487, 548, 260, 633, 648, 424], [2308, 351, 297, 423, 450, 336, 233, 191, 146, 324, 202, 371, 339, 257, 108, 356, 0, 363, 405, 310, 342, 212, 378, 344, 286, 380, 244, 253, 217, 292, 331, 384, 469, 227, 158, 266, 330, 332, 381, 396, 234], [2336, 559, 152, 299, 652, 187, 463, 461, 297, 139, 322, 580, 548, 525, 347, 205, 344, 0, 192, 185, 218, 429, 227, 130, 115, 244, 473, 440, 446, 129, 607, 235, 677, 457, 428, 267, 330, 188, 590, 604, 421], [2376, 600, 220, 458, 699, 346, 503, 507, 338, 247, 362, 620, 588, 566, 387, 366, 384, 159, 0, 345, 377, 482, 386, 81, 208, 403, 514, 480, 486, 185, 647, 394, 718, 497, 469, 307, 370, 255, 630, 645, 461], [2490, 575, 172, 113, 668, 52, 438, 421, 268, 130, 197, 595, 563, 480, 322, 76, 318, 166, 358, 0, 43, 403, 97, 297, 120, 214, 436, 415, 421, 198, 561, 104, 693, 432, 383, 434, 494, 207, 606, 620, 396], [2511, 596, 193, 165, 689, 73, 459, 437, 289, 151, 219, 616, 584, 501, 343, 97, 340, 188, 380, 52, 0, 425, 114, 318, 141, 236, 457, 436, 442, 219, 583, 125, 714, 453, 404, 455, 516, 228, 627, 642, 417], [2403, 317, 426, 589, 416, 521, 71, 218, 241, 453, 350, 337, 305, 241, 198, 522, 200, 490, 520, 476, 531, 0, 543, 459, 415, 509, 82, 197, 111, 418, 321, 550, 435, 214, 233, 353, 416, 461, 347, 362, 178], [2575, 635, 256, 227, 732, 97, 514, 479, 327, 215, 257, 655, 623, 540, 381, 100, 378, 268, 441, 112, 163, 474, 0, 382, 205, 287, 506, 474, 480, 283, 619, 37, 753, 491, 442, 518, 580, 292, 665, 680, 455], [2346, 570, 190, 428, 670, 312, 474, 472, 308, 217, 332, 590, 558, 538, 358, 336, 354, 140, 93, 315, 347, 452, 358, 0, 179, 373, 484, 450, 457, 155, 612, 364, 688, 468, 439, 278, 341, 226, 600, 615, 432], [2474, 544, 52, 253, 643, 137, 406, 384, 236, 38, 197, 564, 532, 450, 290, 161, 287, 137, 240, 140, 172, 385, 183, 179, 0, 198, 416, 383, 389, 78, 524, 189, 662, 400, 351, 315, 378, 87, 574, 589, 364], [2451, 622, 245, 323, 721, 211, 484, 462, 314, 204, 244, 642, 610, 528, 368, 231, 365, 265, 432, 210, 242, 463, 253, 371, 194, 0, 495, 461, 468, 272, 602, 259, 740, 478, 429, 419, 482, 281, 652, 667, 442], [2424, 337, 446, 609, 430, 523, 51, 234, 262, 474, 371, 357, 325, 260, 218, 543, 221, 481, 540, 496, 522, 78, 563, 479, 435, 530, 0, 218, 131, 439, 341, 571, 455, 235, 253, 373, 434, 482, 368, 382, 199], [2378, 212, 400, 526, 311, 436, 214, 56, 215, 427, 325, 232, 200, 136, 172, 460, 174, 452, 494, 413, 446, 193, 481, 433, 389, 483, 225, 0, 198, 393, 210, 488, 330, 91, 97, 327, 390, 436, 242, 257, 29], [2417, 330, 439, 602, 430, 516, 121, 232, 254, 467, 364, 350, 318, 255, 211, 536, 214, 491, 534, 489, 522, 100, 557, 472, 428, 523, 131, 210, 0, 432, 329, 564, 448, 228, 246, 366, 429, 475, 360, 375, 192], [2342, 560, 89, 331, 660, 219, 443, 400, 240, 116, 201, 580, 548, 467, 327, 239, 322, 140, 198, 218, 250, 422, 261, 136, 78, 276, 453, 462, 426, 0, 541, 267, 678, 437, 368, 273, 336, 124, 590, 605, 444], [2489, 121, 512, 638, 232, 548, 326, 182, 327, 539, 449, 160, 109, 69, 284, 572, 286, 553, 606, 525, 557, 292, 588, 545, 501, 595, 336, 184, 309, 539, 0, 600, 258, 127, 170, 439, 502, 547, 151, 185, 165], [2555, 615, 236, 207, 714, 56, 477, 455, 307, 195, 237, 635, 603, 521, 361, 80, 358, 256, 423, 94, 127, 456, 70, 362, 185, 267, 488, 454, 460, 263, 595, 0, 733, 471, 422, 498, 562, 272, 645, 660, 435], [2585, 198, 607, 733, 16, 643, 421, 285, 422, 634, 552, 109, 198, 238, 379, 667, 381, 658, 701, 620, 652, 400, 688, 640, 596, 690, 432, 279, 404, 641, 255, 695, 0, 296, 273, 534, 597, 643, 172, 186, 260], [2405, 180, 428, 554, 291, 467, 242, 104, 243, 455, 352, 212, 168, 45, 200, 487, 202, 479, 522, 441, 473, 221, 509, 461, 417, 511, 252, 82, 225, 420, 118, 515, 310, 0, 129, 354, 418, 463, 210, 237, 63], [2350, 192, 372, 499, 292, 408, 237, 33, 187, 400, 279, 212, 180, 99, 194, 432, 197, 439, 482, 385, 418, 216, 454, 420, 361, 456, 247, 95, 220, 368, 173, 460, 310, 120, 0, 275, 338, 408, 223, 238, 76], [2237, 491, 344, 505, 590, 418, 384, 331, 219, 371, 334, 511, 479, 398, 268, 438, 265, 293, 336, 392, 424, 364, 460, 275, 332, 462, 395, 393, 368, 293, 471, 466, 609, 419, 298, 0, 91, 379, 521, 536, 374], [2282, 535, 388, 550, 628, 456, 426, 381, 263, 415, 379, 555, 523, 440, 313, 483, 310, 325, 378, 436, 466, 394, 504, 319, 377, 506, 427, 438, 412, 337, 522, 511, 653, 463, 343, 92, 0, 424, 566, 580, 419], [2574, 582, 55, 353, 682, 241, 445, 423, 275, 138, 236, 603, 571, 489, 329, 261, 326, 209, 280, 240, 272, 424, 282, 219, 99, 298, 455, 422, 428, 117, 563, 289, 700, 439, 390, 356, 419, 0, 613, 628, 403], [2519, 25, 541, 667, 184, 577, 355, 219, 356, 568, 486, 126, 37, 172, 313, 601, 315, 592, 635, 554, 586, 334, 622, 574, 530, 624, 366, 213, 338, 575, 142, 629, 202, 230, 207, 468, 531, 577, 0, 89, 194], [2527, 99, 549, 676, 162, 585, 364, 227, 364, 576, 494, 105, 111, 180, 321, 609, 324, 601, 643, 562, 595, 342, 631, 582, 538, 633, 374, 221, 347, 584, 198, 637, 181, 238, 215, 476, 539, 585, 74, 0, 203], [2349, 183, 371, 497, 282, 411, 185, 40, 186, 398, 296, 203, 171, 107, 143, 431, 145, 422, 465, 384, 416, 164, 452, 404, 360, 454, 196, 18, 168, 364, 181, 459, 301, 62, 82, 298, 361, 407, 213, 228, 0]]}, "reference": {"optimum_s": 22631, "optimality": "best_found", "lower_bound_s": 20041, "floor_s": 17884, "solve_s": 90.36, "ffd_s": 26068, "stop_aware_best_s": 25630, "stop_aware_mean_s": 25893.2, "route_id": "RouteID_bc0a758f-a028-4a73-88dd-c67dafdabf8d", "plans": {"optimum": [{"route": ["S08", "S28", "S21", "S06", "S26", "S33", "S13", "S30", "S12", "S01", "S38", "S39", "S04", "S32", "S11"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S25", "S03", "S19", "S20", "S09", "S24", "S02", "S37", "S29", "S23", "S18"], "parcels": ["P35", "P37", "P38", "P40", "P41"]}, {"route": ["S05", "S20", "S17", "S35", "S36"], "parcels": ["P08", "P09", "P36", "P39", "P42"]}, {"route": ["S22", "S31", "S05", "S15", "S10", "S34", "S07", "S40", "S27", "S14", "S16"], "parcels": ["P06", "P07"]}], "ffd": [{"route": ["S15", "S20", "S39"], "parcels": ["P24", "P35", "P36", "P41"]}, {"route": ["S15", "S20", "S17", "S08", "S26", "S13", "S01", "S34"], "parcels": ["P22", "P25", "P29", "P42", "P53"]}, {"route": ["S25", "S24", "S23", "S17", "S22", "S31", "S05", "S10", "S14", "S21", "S13", "S40"], "parcels": ["P08", "P09", "P21", "P30", "P45"]}, {"route": ["S28", "S21", "S06", "S26", "S11", "S04", "S32", "S38", "S12", "S30", "S33", "S27", "S07", "S16", "S03", "S19", "S20", "S05", "S15", "S09", "S02", "S37", "S29", "S18", "S17", "S35", "S36"], "parcels": ["P06", "P07", "P26", "P28", "P37", "P38", "P39", "P40", "P43", "P44", "P52"]}], "stop_aware_best": [{"route": ["S31", "S20", "S17", "S12", "S11", "S32", "S36"], "parcels": ["P37", "P38", "P39", "P40", "P41", "P42"]}, {"route": ["S22", "S19", "S03", "S29", "S08", "S14", "S16", "S34", "S07", "S30", "S38", "S39", "S04", "S06", "S26"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S05", "S20", "S24", "S10", "S01", "S40", "S35"], "parcels": ["P35", "P36"]}, {"route": ["S25", "S15", "S09", "S02", "S37", "S23", "S18", "S28", "S21", "S13", "S33", "S27"], "parcels": []}]}}, "meta": {"route_id": "RouteID_bc0a758f-a028-4a73-88dd-c67dafdabf8d", "split": "train", "stops": 40, "vans": 4, "tightness": 0.95, "station": "DSE5", "city": "DSE", "date": "2018-07-23", "seconds": 153.8, "stop_aware_best_reward": 0.4321, "optimality": "best_found"}}
{"id": "1364e982-spread-n20-k3-t0.88-s0", "instance": {"stops": ["S01", "S02", "S03", "S04", "S05", "S06", "S07", "S08", "S09", "S10", "S11", "S12", "S13", "S14", "S15", "S16", "S17", "S18", "S19", "S20"], "parcels": [{"id": "P01", "stop": "S01", "volume_dl": 57}, {"id": "P02", "stop": "S01", "volume_dl": 23}, {"id": "P03", "stop": "S02", "volume_dl": 60}, {"id": "P04", "stop": "S03", "volume_dl": 7}, {"id": "P05", "stop": "S03", "volume_dl": 57}, {"id": "P06", "stop": "S04", "volume_dl": 57}, {"id": "P07", "stop": "S04", "volume_dl": 8}, {"id": "P08", "stop": "S05", "volume_dl": 95}, {"id": "P09", "stop": "S06", "volume_dl": 45}, {"id": "P10", "stop": "S06", "volume_dl": 34}, {"id": "P11", "stop": "S07", "volume_dl": 133}, {"id": "P12", "stop": "S08", "volume_dl": 95}, {"id": "P13", "stop": "S09", "volume_dl": 21}, {"id": "P14", "stop": "S09", "volume_dl": 157}, {"id": "P15", "stop": "S09", "volume_dl": 134}, {"id": "P16", "stop": "S09", "volume_dl": 20}, {"id": "P17", "stop": "S10", "volume_dl": 104}, {"id": "P18", "stop": "S10", "volume_dl": 95}, {"id": "P19", "stop": "S11", "volume_dl": 57}, {"id": "P20", "stop": "S11", "volume_dl": 95}, {"id": "P21", "stop": "S12", "volume_dl": 1014}, {"id": "P22", "stop": "S13", "volume_dl": 58}, {"id": "P23", "stop": "S14", "volume_dl": 79}, {"id": "P24", "stop": "S15", "volume_dl": 40}, {"id": "P25", "stop": "S15", "volume_dl": 104}, {"id": "P26", "stop": "S16", "volume_dl": 37}, {"id": "P27", "stop": "S16", "volume_dl": 104}, {"id": "P28", "stop": "S16", "volume_dl": 41}, {"id": "P29", "stop": "S17", "volume_dl": 34}, {"id": "P30", "stop": "S18", "volume_dl": 133}, {"id": "P31", "stop": "S19", "volume_dl": 157}, {"id": "P32", "stop": "S20", "volume_dl": 57}], "vans": 3, "capacity_dl": 1219, "travel_s": [[0, 2397, 2310, 2420, 2376, 2226, 2363, 2302, 2397, 2331, 2136, 2362, 2373, 2324, 2426, 2150, 2218, 2432, 2252, 2448, 2414], [2495, 0, 404, 265, 266, 446, 411, 617, 534, 252, 378, 362, 276, 372, 278, 392, 460, 264, 373, 597, 167], [2543, 335, 0, 497, 315, 388, 142, 561, 279, 297, 450, 142, 153, 103, 305, 465, 532, 463, 189, 538, 399], [2553, 222, 484, 0, 192, 374, 529, 544, 576, 289, 435, 497, 399, 490, 225, 450, 521, 172, 519, 524, 122], [2461, 241, 347, 225, 0, 252, 398, 422, 445, 156, 440, 304, 237, 358, 70, 452, 531, 147, 417, 402, 175], [2293, 417, 404, 387, 253, 0, 448, 267, 495, 208, 566, 423, 319, 409, 303, 580, 648, 310, 523, 212, 337], [2531, 412, 145, 580, 384, 416, 0, 589, 326, 265, 529, 181, 194, 36, 373, 541, 608, 452, 265, 566, 482], [2379, 557, 559, 544, 409, 260, 604, 0, 635, 348, 706, 596, 459, 564, 463, 720, 788, 466, 678, 146, 494], [2467, 514, 295, 598, 457, 484, 348, 667, 0, 333, 644, 348, 359, 309, 447, 658, 726, 520, 230, 634, 574], [2409, 208, 224, 317, 139, 199, 268, 383, 315, 0, 386, 241, 139, 229, 129, 400, 468, 286, 343, 350, 219], [2254, 371, 284, 434, 441, 582, 337, 755, 371, 434, 0, 334, 347, 298, 442, 61, 130, 420, 226, 732, 447], [2598, 344, 148, 480, 284, 403, 204, 586, 394, 266, 464, 0, 97, 167, 276, 474, 554, 434, 268, 553, 384], [2519, 296, 147, 434, 238, 324, 205, 507, 314, 220, 412, 104, 0, 166, 227, 426, 493, 385, 266, 474, 336], [2495, 376, 110, 544, 348, 380, 39, 553, 290, 229, 491, 147, 158, 0, 338, 505, 573, 417, 229, 530, 446], [2510, 233, 338, 257, 92, 300, 389, 475, 436, 147, 430, 296, 229, 350, 0, 444, 511, 180, 408, 451, 207], [2266, 383, 296, 446, 453, 594, 349, 767, 383, 446, 57, 346, 359, 310, 454, 0, 96, 432, 238, 744, 459], [2324, 441, 354, 504, 508, 652, 404, 825, 441, 504, 127, 406, 417, 368, 512, 113, 0, 490, 296, 802, 517], [2477, 252, 436, 181, 145, 326, 481, 496, 528, 241, 407, 449, 352, 442, 177, 421, 488, 0, 480, 476, 151], [2487, 393, 216, 552, 439, 514, 269, 688, 222, 364, 524, 268, 280, 230, 428, 538, 605, 552, 0, 665, 454], [2472, 547, 534, 517, 383, 191, 578, 158, 626, 338, 696, 554, 449, 539, 433, 711, 778, 440, 653, 0, 467], [2563, 142, 451, 159, 160, 341, 476, 511, 543, 256, 445, 424, 342, 437, 192, 459, 527, 159, 438, 491, 0]]}, "reference": {"optimum_s": 16854, "optimality": "best_found", "lower_bound_s": 15096, "floor_s": 13170, "solve_s": 34.13, "ffd_s": 17932, "stop_aware_best_s": 17635, "stop_aware_mean_s": 17945.2, "route_id": "RouteID_1364e982-c768-4248-818f-cefad0f4b136", "plans": {"optimum": [{"route": ["S07", "S19", "S05", "S09", "S14", "S04", "S17", "S03", "S20", "S01"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S11", "S12"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S10", "S15", "S16", "S06", "S13", "S02", "S18", "S08"], "parcels": []}], "ffd": [{"route": ["S06", "S12", "S09"], "parcels": ["P09", "P14"]}, {"route": ["S10", "S15", "S16", "S02", "S18", "S08", "S09", "S05", "S19", "S07"], "parcels": ["P15", "P25", "P27"]}, {"route": ["S15", "S16", "S06", "S13", "S11", "S09", "S14", "S04", "S17", "S03", "S20", "S01"], "parcels": ["P10", "P13", "P16", "P24", "P26", "P28"]}], "stop_aware_best": [{"route": ["S15", "S10", "S13", "S06", "S02", "S20", "S17", "S19", "S07"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S11", "S12"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S16", "S18", "S08", "S09", "S01", "S03", "S04", "S14", "S05"], "parcels": []}]}}, "meta": {"route_id": "RouteID_1364e982-c768-4248-818f-cefad0f4b136", "split": "train", "stops": 20, "vans": 3, "tightness": 0.88, "station": "DCH4", "city": "DCH", "date": "2018-08-15", "seconds": 72.2, "stop_aware_best_reward": 0.7294, "optimality": "best_found"}}
{"id": "3862d269-spread-n40-k4-t0.87-s0", "instance": {"stops": ["S01", "S02", "S03", "S04", "S05", "S06", "S07", "S08", "S09", "S10", "S11", "S12", "S13", "S14", "S15", "S16", "S17", "S18", "S19", "S20", "S21", "S22", "S23", "S24", "S25", "S26", "S27", "S28", "S29", "S30", "S31", "S32", "S33", "S34", "S35", "S36", "S37", "S38", "S39", "S40"], "parcels": [{"id": "P01", "stop": "S01", "volume_dl": 10}, {"id": "P02", "stop": "S01", "volume_dl": 133}, {"id": "P03", "stop": "S02", "volume_dl": 43}, {"id": "P04", "stop": "S03", "volume_dl": 27}, {"id": "P05", "stop": "S03", "volume_dl": 56}, {"id": "P06", "stop": "S03", "volume_dl": 45}, {"id": "P07", "stop": "S03", "volume_dl": 34}, {"id": "P08", "stop": "S03", "volume_dl": 133}, {"id": "P09", "stop": "S03", "volume_dl": 23}, {"id": "P10", "stop": "S03", "volume_dl": 27}, {"id": "P11", "stop": "S03", "volume_dl": 179}, {"id": "P12", "stop": "S03", "volume_dl": 79}, {"id": "P13", "stop": "S03", "volume_dl": 9}, {"id": "P14", "stop": "S04", "volume_dl": 41}, {"id": "P15", "stop": "S05", "volume_dl": 57}, {"id": "P16", "stop": "S06", "volume_dl": 220}, {"id": "P17", "stop": "S07", "volume_dl": 36}, {"id": "P18", "stop": "S08", "volume_dl": 31}, {"id": "P19", "stop": "S08", "volume_dl": 104}, {"id": "P20", "stop": "S09", "volume_dl": 599}, {"id": "P21", "stop": "S10", "volume_dl": 104}, {"id": "P22", "stop": "S11", "volume_dl": 326}, {"id": "P23", "stop": "S11", "volume_dl": 133}, {"id": "P24", "stop": "S12", "volume_dl": 34}, {"id": "P25", "stop": "S13", "volume_dl": 12}, {"id": "P26", "stop": "S14", "volume_dl": 133}, {"id": "P27", "stop": "S15", "volume_dl": 242}, {"id": "P28", "stop": "S15", "volume_dl": 226}, {"id": "P29", "stop": "S16", "volume_dl": 157}, {"id": "P30", "stop": "S17", "volume_dl": 34}, {"id": "P31", "stop": "S18", "volume_dl": 60}, {"id": "P32", "stop": "S18", "volume_dl": 242}, {"id": "P33", "stop": "S19", "volume_dl": 259}, {"id": "P34", "stop": "S19", "volume_dl": 30}, {"id": "P35", "stop": "S19", "volume_dl": 95}, {"id": "P36", "stop": "S19", "volume_dl": 57}, {"id": "P37", "stop": "S19", "volume_dl": 60}, {"id": "P38", "stop": "S19", "volume_dl": 21}, {"id": "P39", "stop": "S19", "volume_dl": 259}, {"id": "P40", "stop": "S19", "volume_dl": 392}, {"id": "P41", "stop": "S19", "volume_dl": 133}, {"id": "P42", "stop": "S20", "volume_dl": 133}, {"id": "P43", "stop": "S20", "volume_dl": 477}, {"id": "P44", "stop": "S20", "volume_dl": 63}, {"id": "P45", "stop": "S20", "volume_dl": 95}, {"id": "P46", "stop": "S21", "volume_dl": 104}, {"id": "P47", "stop": "S22", "volume_dl": 57}, {"id": "P48", "stop": "S23", "volume_dl": 12}, {"id": "P49", "stop": "S24", "volume_dl": 134}, {"id": "P50", "stop": "S25", "volume_dl": 179}, {"id": "P51", "stop": "S25", "volume_dl": 21}, {"id": "P52", "stop": "S26", "volume_dl": 12}, {"id": "P53", "stop": "S27", "volume_dl": 104}, {"id": "P54", "stop": "S27", "volume_dl": 9}, {"id": "P55", "stop": "S28", "volume_dl": 40}, {"id": "P56", "stop": "S29", "volume_dl": 242}, {"id": "P57", "stop": "S29", "volume_dl": 104}, {"id": "P58", "stop": "S29", "volume_dl": 157}, {"id": "P59", "stop": "S30", "volume_dl": 11}, {"id": "P60", "stop": "S31", "volume_dl": 104}, {"id": "P61", "stop": "S32", "volume_dl": 6}, {"id": "P62", "stop": "S32", "volume_dl": 42}, {"id": "P63", "stop": "S32", "volume_dl": 133}, {"id": "P64", "stop": "S32", "volume_dl": 63}, {"id": "P65", "stop": "S33", "volume_dl": 226}, {"id": "P66", "stop": "S33", "volume_dl": 86}, {"id": "P67", "stop": "S34", "volume_dl": 133}, {"id": "P68", "stop": "S35", "volume_dl": 34}, {"id": "P69", "stop": "S36", "volume_dl": 57}, {"id": "P70", "stop": "S36", "volume_dl": 14}, {"id": "P71", "stop": "S37", "volume_dl": 55}, {"id": "P72", "stop": "S38", "volume_dl": 133}, {"id": "P73", "stop": "S38", "volume_dl": 95}, {"id": "P74", "stop": "S39", "volume_dl": 289}, {"id": "P75", "stop": "S40", "volume_dl": 43}], "vans": 4, "capacity_dl": 2405, "travel_s": [[0, 2380, 2754, 2408, 2917, 2534, 2432, 2694, 2595, 2607, 2515, 2640, 2714, 2376, 2558, 2686, 2467, 2594, 2384, 2462, 2661, 2614, 2686, 2642, 2629, 2495, 2503, 2525, 2654, 2674, 2831, 2471, 2597, 2716, 2615, 2576, 2527, 2538, 2481, 2579, 2479], [2347, 0, 545, 92, 642, 219, 116, 378, 284, 292, 199, 329, 421, 60, 243, 376, 122, 278, 48, 184, 386, 298, 370, 326, 347, 180, 187, 232, 339, 384, 515, 135, 280, 396, 330, 260, 209, 223, 162, 264, 154], [2805, 502, 0, 493, 193, 420, 459, 191, 283, 237, 422, 268, 184, 490, 266, 454, 512, 255, 499, 439, 247, 279, 232, 184, 270, 387, 416, 376, 391, 315, 328, 492, 253, 485, 462, 344, 340, 314, 362, 348, 516], [2395, 96, 535, 0, 626, 203, 100, 362, 263, 276, 183, 308, 382, 53, 227, 360, 129, 262, 106, 144, 330, 282, 354, 310, 297, 164, 171, 193, 323, 342, 499, 142, 266, 385, 284, 244, 193, 207, 146, 248, 136], [2890, 588, 185, 578, 0, 505, 544, 217, 368, 322, 508, 319, 278, 575, 351, 540, 598, 340, 584, 524, 332, 364, 328, 269, 356, 472, 502, 462, 476, 400, 463, 577, 338, 570, 548, 430, 426, 399, 448, 433, 602], [2509, 206, 427, 211, 562, 0, 142, 299, 200, 213, 20, 245, 272, 194, 163, 291, 223, 199, 260, 143, 233, 219, 291, 247, 198, 108, 66, 138, 259, 240, 436, 201, 202, 322, 202, 181, 132, 143, 94, 184, 218], [2431, 128, 481, 133, 592, 152, 0, 329, 230, 242, 132, 275, 326, 116, 193, 321, 138, 229, 211, 97, 296, 249, 321, 277, 264, 108, 138, 106, 289, 285, 466, 118, 232, 351, 250, 211, 162, 173, 94, 214, 142], [2674, 371, 210, 362, 263, 288, 328, 0, 151, 106, 291, 102, 77, 358, 134, 323, 381, 124, 367, 308, 115, 148, 112, 52, 139, 255, 285, 245, 259, 184, 425, 360, 121, 354, 331, 213, 209, 182, 231, 216, 385], [2584, 281, 298, 286, 421, 250, 290, 158, 0, 36, 253, 157, 144, 268, 76, 270, 291, 53, 329, 232, 93, 131, 155, 154, 88, 217, 247, 213, 181, 133, 346, 270, 26, 300, 241, 154, 116, 54, 193, 157, 295], [2601, 299, 263, 288, 385, 215, 254, 122, 46, 0, 217, 160, 108, 295, 78, 266, 309, 50, 294, 235, 69, 134, 125, 85, 65, 181, 211, 171, 183, 103, 349, 317, 10, 302, 280, 156, 210, 100, 157, 160, 334], [2490, 187, 446, 191, 558, 20, 122, 294, 195, 208, 0, 240, 292, 174, 159, 286, 204, 194, 241, 124, 262, 214, 286, 242, 229, 89, 46, 118, 255, 259, 431, 181, 192, 317, 222, 176, 128, 139, 75, 180, 198], [2613, 314, 308, 315, 361, 241, 269, 98, 147, 182, 254, 0, 153, 298, 74, 269, 321, 200, 332, 261, 192, 87, 142, 129, 215, 332, 238, 322, 199, 260, 365, 300, 192, 289, 271, 153, 146, 119, 258, 156, 324], [2680, 377, 193, 368, 319, 295, 334, 77, 158, 112, 297, 143, 0, 365, 140, 329, 387, 130, 374, 314, 159, 154, 135, 59, 145, 262, 291, 251, 266, 231, 431, 367, 122, 360, 338, 219, 216, 189, 237, 223, 391], [2361, 58, 523, 40, 608, 185, 82, 344, 245, 258, 165, 290, 364, 0, 209, 336, 117, 244, 89, 112, 312, 264, 336, 292, 279, 146, 153, 175, 305, 324, 481, 122, 242, 367, 266, 226, 178, 189, 132, 230, 124], [2539, 236, 314, 241, 399, 168, 195, 136, 78, 108, 180, 82, 160, 224, 0, 189, 247, 130, 261, 173, 103, 56, 127, 84, 144, 199, 164, 251, 125, 185, 291, 226, 98, 220, 197, 79, 75, 45, 184, 82, 251], [2644, 345, 482, 352, 645, 272, 300, 322, 235, 241, 285, 274, 349, 329, 186, 0, 352, 222, 362, 292, 323, 242, 314, 270, 257, 310, 269, 340, 137, 344, 347, 331, 225, 46, 302, 108, 177, 166, 286, 139, 356], [2440, 122, 506, 142, 669, 226, 132, 395, 296, 308, 206, 341, 412, 125, 259, 386, 0, 295, 173, 111, 373, 315, 386, 343, 338, 194, 203, 223, 355, 371, 531, 73, 298, 417, 242, 276, 228, 239, 179, 280, 49], [2588, 285, 282, 276, 404, 202, 242, 141, 41, 77, 205, 175, 127, 283, 94, 286, 295, 0, 281, 222, 88, 149, 146, 104, 35, 169, 199, 159, 203, 80, 368, 305, 67, 322, 268, 176, 198, 58, 145, 179, 322], [2372, 55, 525, 97, 646, 223, 121, 383, 281, 296, 204, 329, 370, 65, 247, 381, 173, 283, 0, 162, 331, 303, 375, 331, 296, 184, 192, 181, 343, 329, 520, 186, 280, 401, 304, 265, 213, 227, 166, 268, 205], [2439, 136, 539, 141, 589, 166, 95, 326, 226, 239, 146, 272, 384, 124, 190, 323, 140, 226, 161, 0, 293, 246, 317, 274, 260, 166, 134, 195, 286, 343, 462, 99, 229, 348, 254, 207, 156, 170, 148, 211, 124], [2659, 388, 254, 327, 376, 254, 293, 113, 101, 70, 256, 204, 99, 334, 152, 340, 378, 89, 332, 307, 0, 154, 62, 119, 77, 220, 250, 210, 257, 82, 423, 356, 81, 371, 319, 230, 246, 156, 196, 234, 373], [2595, 292, 328, 297, 433, 223, 251, 169, 129, 141, 236, 116, 173, 280, 56, 245, 303, 157, 317, 229, 158, 0, 161, 117, 191, 255, 220, 284, 181, 236, 347, 282, 131, 275, 253, 135, 131, 101, 240, 138, 306], [2678, 376, 252, 380, 384, 320, 347, 121, 156, 118, 310, 142, 98, 363, 139, 328, 386, 136, 387, 312, 54, 153, 0, 57, 104, 275, 316, 264, 264, 108, 430, 365, 128, 359, 336, 218, 214, 195, 250, 221, 390], [2621, 318, 210, 323, 351, 249, 289, 88, 112, 66, 252, 84, 56, 306, 82, 271, 329, 85, 328, 255, 76, 95, 44, 0, 100, 216, 246, 206, 207, 152, 373, 308, 82, 301, 279, 161, 157, 143, 192, 164, 332], [2621, 345, 274, 289, 397, 215, 255, 134, 74, 64, 218, 182, 120, 296, 126, 319, 340, 33, 294, 255, 81, 182, 111, 97, 0, 182, 212, 172, 235, 45, 401, 318, 74, 354, 281, 209, 211, 91, 158, 212, 335], [2474, 171, 418, 175, 540, 85, 95, 277, 213, 225, 66, 258, 263, 158, 176, 309, 188, 212, 202, 122, 224, 232, 269, 260, 189, 0, 100, 86, 272, 222, 448, 165, 209, 329, 254, 193, 145, 156, 32, 197, 182], [2482, 179, 433, 184, 546, 72, 157, 282, 183, 196, 66, 228, 279, 167, 147, 274, 190, 182, 276, 116, 250, 202, 274, 230, 217, 124, 0, 153, 242, 246, 419, 169, 186, 305, 209, 164, 116, 127, 110, 167, 193], [2498, 209, 402, 156, 524, 142, 96, 261, 219, 191, 123, 309, 247, 155, 233, 367, 232, 178, 157, 179, 208, 289, 253, 224, 173, 98, 158, 0, 329, 214, 506, 245, 201, 386, 295, 250, 199, 213, 81, 254, 238], [2628, 326, 345, 330, 508, 257, 284, 282, 148, 160, 270, 207, 268, 313, 125, 126, 336, 201, 350, 262, 236, 181, 285, 209, 236, 342, 253, 332, 0, 263, 210, 315, 144, 142, 286, 107, 164, 134, 318, 111, 340], [2696, 377, 338, 316, 500, 240, 282, 237, 140, 124, 259, 258, 183, 323, 192, 384, 368, 98, 322, 313, 102, 248, 116, 174, 66, 210, 236, 206, 301, 0, 467, 345, 140, 420, 305, 274, 232, 157, 185, 278, 362], [2765, 462, 244, 467, 407, 393, 421, 405, 284, 297, 406, 344, 405, 450, 262, 287, 472, 338, 487, 399, 372, 317, 422, 345, 372, 478, 390, 468, 161, 400, 0, 452, 281, 273, 423, 244, 301, 271, 454, 247, 476], [2447, 135, 530, 149, 692, 204, 114, 403, 277, 290, 184, 322, 390, 132, 241, 368, 66, 276, 186, 88, 351, 296, 396, 324, 315, 171, 185, 201, 337, 349, 513, 0, 274, 399, 234, 258, 210, 221, 157, 262, 24], [2586, 288, 273, 298, 401, 225, 270, 138, 36, 10, 233, 144, 124, 305, 68, 256, 299, 66, 313, 234, 98, 124, 141, 146, 81, 197, 227, 193, 173, 113, 339, 272, 0, 282, 290, 146, 121, 90, 176, 150, 297], [2677, 378, 467, 379, 629, 305, 333, 355, 270, 283, 318, 296, 391, 362, 219, 36, 384, 255, 395, 320, 358, 275, 347, 303, 290, 336, 302, 372, 144, 330, 331, 364, 273, 0, 335, 150, 210, 199, 319, 172, 388], [2590, 287, 510, 292, 632, 200, 246, 369, 247, 260, 219, 292, 355, 274, 210, 338, 244, 246, 311, 217, 316, 266, 361, 294, 281, 284, 196, 274, 306, 323, 483, 236, 250, 368, 0, 228, 179, 190, 260, 231, 212], [2536, 234, 420, 238, 477, 164, 192, 214, 121, 133, 177, 160, 241, 221, 78, 110, 244, 114, 258, 170, 209, 134, 206, 162, 149, 196, 161, 225, 119, 236, 285, 223, 123, 152, 194, 0, 72, 58, 182, 117, 248], [2518, 219, 376, 217, 463, 146, 174, 200, 98, 114, 159, 146, 222, 203, 64, 198, 225, 100, 236, 163, 165, 120, 192, 148, 135, 267, 142, 266, 160, 177, 337, 205, 98, 218, 175, 82, 0, 44, 248, 85, 229], [2529, 227, 337, 231, 434, 158, 185, 171, 59, 84, 170, 117, 183, 214, 35, 227, 237, 56, 337, 163, 138, 91, 163, 119, 90, 225, 154, 215, 144, 135, 310, 216, 74, 263, 187, 117, 65, 0, 201, 121, 241], [2468, 169, 387, 160, 510, 79, 89, 246, 204, 176, 60, 249, 232, 168, 170, 304, 182, 163, 170, 113, 194, 226, 238, 254, 158, 24, 95, 50, 266, 195, 442, 160, 200, 324, 248, 188, 136, 150, 0, 191, 177], [2540, 237, 423, 242, 481, 168, 196, 218, 124, 136, 181, 164, 245, 224, 82, 130, 247, 118, 261, 174, 212, 138, 209, 166, 152, 199, 164, 229, 122, 240, 288, 227, 121, 172, 197, 123, 75, 62, 185, 0, 251], [2471, 159, 505, 173, 668, 204, 139, 404, 289, 302, 184, 334, 390, 156, 253, 380, 69, 288, 210, 111, 351, 308, 396, 336, 316, 172, 219, 201, 349, 349, 525, 24, 292, 411, 210, 270, 222, 233, 158, 274, 0]]}, "reference": {"optimum_s": 23310, "optimality": "best_found", "lower_bound_s": 21129, "floor_s": 18892, "solve_s": 85.41, "ffd_s": 25949, "stop_aware_best_s": 24966, "stop_aware_mean_s": 25194.4, "route_id": "RouteID_3862d269-d228-46a4-901c-befb74d11581", "plans": {"optimum": [{"route": ["S36", "S28", "S30", "S02", "S04", "S07", "S12", "S23", "S22", "S20", "S29", "S24", "S17", "S27", "S06", "S01"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S13", "S03", "S37", "S08", "S09", "S32", "S11", "S21", "S14"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S18", "S19"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S38", "S25", "S05", "S10", "S26", "S39", "S33", "S15", "S35", "S34", "S40", "S31", "S16"], "parcels": []}], "ffd": [{"route": ["S09", "S20", "S11", "S39", "S19"], "parcels": ["P22", "P33", "P40", "P43", "P44"]}, {"route": ["S18", "S13", "S03", "S16", "S19", "S33", "S15", "S32", "S29", "S25", "S06"], "parcels": ["P11", "P32", "P39", "P50", "P56", "P58", "P64", "P65"]}, {"route": ["S03", "S10", "S38", "S27", "S24", "S29", "S20", "S08", "S32", "S11", "S21", "S14", "S33", "S34", "S19", "S31", "S01"], "parcels": ["P02", "P08", "P12", "P19", "P23", "P35", "P41", "P42", "P45", "P53", "P57", "P63", "P66"]}, {"route": ["S03", "S40", "S19", "S36", "S35", "S28", "S30", "S02", "S04", "S07", "S12", "S23", "S22", "S32", "S08", "S17", "S37", "S26", "S05", "S25", "S27", "S18", "S01"], "parcels": ["P01", "P04", "P05", "P06", "P07", "P09", "P10", "P13", "P18", "P31", "P34", "P36", "P37", "P38", "P51", "P54", "P61", "P62"]}], "stop_aware_best": [{"route": ["S39", "S33", "S30", "S02", "S04", "S11", "S21", "S32", "S09", "S17", "S10", "S31"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S06", "S05", "S35", "S37", "S23", "S20", "S29", "S27", "S03"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S13", "S40", "S19", "S36", "S14", "S08", "S38", "S01"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S18", "S25", "S26", "S24", "S22", "S12", "S07", "S28", "S15", "S34", "S16"], "parcels": []}]}}, "meta": {"route_id": "RouteID_3862d269-d228-46a4-901c-befb74d11581", "split": "train", "stops": 40, "vans": 4, "tightness": 0.87, "station": "DSE4", "city": "DSE", "date": "2018-08-23", "seconds": 147.9, "stop_aware_best_reward": 0.5843, "optimality": "best_found"}}
{"id": "0157f4f0-spread-n20-k3-t0.91-s0", "instance": {"stops": ["S01", "S02", "S03", "S04", "S05", "S06", "S07", "S08", "S09", "S10", "S11", "S12", "S13", "S14", "S15", "S16", "S17", "S18", "S19", "S20"], "parcels": [{"id": "P01", "stop": "S01", "volume_dl": 16}, {"id": "P02", "stop": "S01", "volume_dl": 179}, {"id": "P03", "stop": "S01", "volume_dl": 79}, {"id": "P04", "stop": "S02", "volume_dl": 104}, {"id": "P05", "stop": "S02", "volume_dl": 30}, {"id": "P06", "stop": "S02", "volume_dl": 104}, {"id": "P07", "stop": "S03", "volume_dl": 30}, {"id": "P08", "stop": "S03", "volume_dl": 34}, {"id": "P09", "stop": "S03", "volume_dl": 12}, {"id": "P10", "stop": "S03", "volume_dl": 840}, {"id": "P11", "stop": "S03", "volume_dl": 157}, {"id": "P12", "stop": "S03", "volume_dl": 49}, {"id": "P13", "stop": "S03", "volume_dl": 12}, {"id": "P14", "stop": "S04", "volume_dl": 63}, {"id": "P15", "stop": "S04", "volume_dl": 7}, {"id": "P16", "stop": "S04", "volume_dl": 259}, {"id": "P17", "stop": "S04", "volume_dl": 34}, {"id": "P18", "stop": "S05", "volume_dl": 517}, {"id": "P19", "stop": "S05", "volume_dl": 58}, {"id": "P20", "stop": "S06", "volume_dl": 14}, {"id": "P21", "stop": "S07", "volume_dl": 133}, {"id": "P22", "stop": "S08", "volume_dl": 63}, {"id": "P23", "stop": "S08", "volume_dl": 57}, {"id": "P24", "stop": "S09", "volume_dl": 9}, {"id": "P25", "stop": "S09", "volume_dl": 21}, {"id": "P26", "stop": "S09", "volume_dl": 3}, {"id": "P27", "stop": "S09", "volume_dl": 133}, {"id": "P28", "stop": "S09", "volume_dl": 30}, {"id": "P29", "stop": "S09", "volume_dl": 157}, {"id": "P30", "stop": "S09", "volume_dl": 30}, {"id": "P31", "stop": "S09", "volume_dl": 259}, {"id": "P32", "stop": "S09", "volume_dl": 34}, {"id": "P33", "stop": "S09", "volume_dl": 9}, {"id": "P34", "stop": "S09", "volume_dl": 28}, {"id": "P35", "stop": "S09", "volume_dl": 39}, {"id": "P36", "stop": "S10", "volume_dl": 16}, {"id": "P37", "stop": "S10", "volume_dl": 20}, {"id": "P38", "stop": "S10", "volume_dl": 41}, {"id": "P39", "stop": "S10", "volume_dl": 226}, {"id": "P40", "stop": "S10", "volume_dl": 188}, {"id": "P41", "stop": "S11", "volume_dl": 9}, {"id": "P42", "stop": "S11", "volume_dl": 178}, {"id": "P43", "stop": "S11", "volume_dl": 98}, {"id": "P44", "stop": "S11", "volume_dl": 17}, {"id": "P45", "stop": "S11", "volume_dl": 63}, {"id": "P46", "stop": "S11", "volume_dl": 95}, {"id": "P47", "stop": "S11", "volume_dl": 552}, {"id": "P48", "stop": "S11", "volume_dl": 104}, {"id": "P49", "stop": "S11", "volume_dl": 157}, {"id": "P50", "stop": "S11", "volume_dl": 95}, {"id": "P51", "stop": "S11", "volume_dl": 18}, {"id": "P52", "stop": "S11", "volume_dl": 19}, {"id": "P53", "stop": "S11", "volume_dl": 95}, {"id": "P54", "stop": "S11", "volume_dl": 11}, {"id": "P55", "stop": "S11", "volume_dl": 34}, {"id": "P56", "stop": "S11", "volume_dl": 26}, {"id": "P57", "stop": "S11", "volume_dl": 57}, {"id": "P58", "stop": "S11", "volume_dl": 11}, {"id": "P59", "stop": "S12", "volume_dl": 27}, {"id": "P60", "stop": "S12", "volume_dl": 25}, {"id": "P61", "stop": "S13", "volume_dl": 134}, {"id": "P62", "stop": "S13", "volume_dl": 34}, {"id": "P63", "stop": "S13", "volume_dl": 26}, {"id": "P64", "stop": "S13", "volume_dl": 104}, {"id": "P65", "stop": "S13", "volume_dl": 29}, {"id": "P66", "stop": "S14", "volume_dl": 568}, {"id": "P67", "stop": "S14", "volume_dl": 133}, {"id": "P68", "stop": "S15", "volume_dl": 104}, {"id": "P69", "stop": "S15", "volume_dl": 28}, {"id": "P70", "stop": "S15", "volume_dl": 23}, {"id": "P71", "stop": "S15", "volume_dl": 92}, {"id": "P72", "stop": "S16", "volume_dl": 58}, {"id": "P73", "stop": "S17", "volume_dl": 157}, {"id": "P74", "stop": "S17", "volume_dl": 8}, {"id": "P75", "stop": "S18", "volume_dl": 104}, {"id": "P76", "stop": "S18", "volume_dl": 104}, {"id": "P77", "stop": "S18", "volume_dl": 322}, {"id": "P78", "stop": "S19", "volume_dl": 259}, {"id": "P79", "stop": "S20", "volume_dl": 41}, {"id": "P80", "stop": "S20", "volume_dl": 226}], "vans": 3, "capacity_dl": 3057, "travel_s": [[0, 2056, 2369, 2384, 2119, 2324, 2384, 2294, 2044, 2263, 2158, 2066, 2293, 2182, 2119, 2074, 2137, 2196, 2095, 2166, 2241], [1869, 0, 727, 763, 275, 704, 762, 620, 200, 576, 392, 239, 578, 416, 152, 312, 168, 203, 251, 323, 428], [2314, 611, 0, 168, 646, 105, 166, 146, 571, 217, 910, 711, 130, 934, 656, 826, 696, 576, 622, 693, 373], [2281, 611, 226, 0, 646, 160, 221, 143, 571, 230, 910, 711, 128, 934, 656, 826, 695, 575, 621, 692, 357], [2066, 200, 719, 755, 0, 692, 753, 586, 129, 565, 591, 458, 570, 614, 259, 507, 270, 166, 142, 47, 420], [2387, 700, 89, 86, 703, 0, 84, 203, 628, 274, 964, 768, 187, 987, 714, 880, 784, 684, 679, 750, 430], [2283, 616, 207, 0, 648, 162, 0, 145, 573, 232, 912, 713, 129, 935, 658, 828, 697, 577, 623, 694, 359], [2208, 575, 245, 260, 607, 199, 260, 0, 532, 153, 871, 672, 51, 895, 618, 787, 657, 537, 583, 654, 318], [1995, 123, 824, 860, 121, 801, 861, 720, 0, 673, 516, 363, 675, 540, 204, 432, 226, 290, 266, 171, 545], [2186, 499, 340, 354, 578, 345, 352, 192, 506, 0, 763, 616, 173, 787, 591, 679, 584, 464, 523, 625, 260], [2082, 353, 786, 821, 545, 759, 820, 652, 474, 622, 0, 226, 652, 89, 419, 128, 437, 473, 521, 592, 714], [2044, 322, 752, 788, 512, 725, 786, 619, 440, 588, 339, 0, 618, 363, 385, 255, 404, 439, 488, 559, 665], [2211, 528, 201, 216, 559, 215, 214, 16, 484, 102, 823, 624, 0, 847, 570, 739, 609, 489, 535, 606, 270], [2154, 424, 858, 893, 617, 831, 891, 724, 546, 693, 88, 297, 723, 0, 490, 200, 509, 545, 593, 664, 770], [2014, 154, 638, 674, 197, 611, 672, 504, 81, 483, 567, 368, 489, 591, 0, 483, 180, 75, 96, 244, 379], [2119, 392, 822, 858, 582, 796, 856, 689, 507, 658, 84, 262, 688, 108, 455, 0, 474, 510, 558, 629, 751], [1873, 91, 751, 766, 280, 705, 766, 624, 205, 578, 398, 244, 583, 422, 154, 314, 0, 208, 256, 327, 434], [2068, 186, 706, 742, 225, 679, 740, 592, 113, 561, 575, 376, 557, 599, 195, 491, 207, 0, 124, 272, 423], [1924, 60, 750, 786, 298, 723, 784, 642, 227, 595, 449, 295, 601, 472, 129, 365, 148, 184, 0, 345, 451], [2019, 158, 691, 706, 195, 645, 706, 539, 79, 518, 544, 412, 523, 568, 212, 460, 224, 119, 95, 0, 374], [2064, 378, 416, 452, 397, 373, 450, 283, 341, 246, 660, 462, 267, 684, 407, 592, 462, 326, 372, 460, 0]]}, "reference": {"optimum_s": 14847, "optimality": "best_found", "lower_bound_s": 12390, "floor_s": 11739, "solve_s": 70.27, "ffd_s": 19354, "stop_aware_best_s": 17014, "stop_aware_mean_s": 17562.6, "route_id": "RouteID_0157f4f0-2c0d-4d24-82a8-71230416bf1c", "plans": {"optimum": [{"route": ["S15", "S13", "S10", "S11", "S01"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S02", "S05", "S06", "S03", "S07", "S12", "S09"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S20", "S14", "S17", "S08", "S04", "S19", "S18", "S16"], "parcels": []}], "ffd": [{"route": ["S10", "S11", "S02", "S05", "S03", "S14", "S18"], "parcels": ["P05", "P10", "P18", "P39", "P47", "P66", "P77"]}, {"route": ["S13", "S10", "S11", "S02", "S03", "S07", "S09", "S20", "S04", "S19", "S17", "S14", "S01"], "parcels": ["P02", "P04", "P06", "P08", "P11", "P16", "P27", "P29", "P31", "P40", "P42", "P48", "P49", "P61", "P67", "P73", "P80"]}, {"route": ["S15", "S13", "S10", "S11", "S05", "S06", "S03", "S12", "S09", "S20", "S17", "S08", "S04", "S18", "S01", "S16"], "parcels": ["P01", "P03", "P07", "P09", "P12", "P13", "P14", "P15", "P17", "P19", "P24", "P25", "P26", "P28", "P30", "P32", "P33", "P34", "P35", "P36", "P37", "P38", "P41", "P43", "P44", "P45", "P46", "P50", "P51", "P52", "P53", "P54", "P55", "P56", "P57", "P58", "P62", "P63", "P64", "P65", "P74", "P75", "P76", "P79"]}], "stop_aware_best": [{"route": ["S10", "S11", "S08", "S18", "S01"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S13", "S02", "S05", "S06", "S07", "S20", "S04", "S19", "S16"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S15", "S14", "S17", "S03", "S12", "S09"], "parcels": []}]}}, "meta": {"route_id": "RouteID_0157f4f0-2c0d-4d24-82a8-71230416bf1c", "split": "train", "stops": 20, "vans": 3, "tightness": 0.91, "station": "DBO2", "city": "DBO", "date": "2018-07-21", "seconds": 130.5, "stop_aware_best_reward": 0.4072, "optimality": "best_found"}}
{"id": "388fac5d-spread-n40-k4-t0.93-s0", "instance": {"stops": ["S01", "S02", "S03", "S04", "S05", "S06", "S07", "S08", "S09", "S10", "S11", "S12", "S13", "S14", "S15", "S16", "S17", "S18", "S19", "S20", "S21", "S22", "S23", "S24", "S25", "S26", "S27", "S28", "S29", "S30", "S31", "S32", "S33", "S34", "S35", "S36", "S37", "S38", "S39", "S40"], "parcels": [{"id": "P01", "stop": "S01", "volume_dl": 41}, {"id": "P02", "stop": "S02", "volume_dl": 27}, {"id": "P03", "stop": "S02", "volume_dl": 14}, {"id": "P04", "stop": "S03", "volume_dl": 57}, {"id": "P05", "stop": "S03", "volume_dl": 34}, {"id": "P06", "stop": "S04", "volume_dl": 63}, {"id": "P07", "stop": "S04", "volume_dl": 63}, {"id": "P08", "stop": "S05", "volume_dl": 14}, {"id": "P09", "stop": "S06", "volume_dl": 39}, {"id": "P10", "stop": "S07", "volume_dl": 179}, {"id": "P11", "stop": "S08", "volume_dl": 30}, {"id": "P12", "stop": "S09", "volume_dl": 34}, {"id": "P13", "stop": "S10", "volume_dl": 242}, {"id": "P14", "stop": "S11", "volume_dl": 45}, {"id": "P15", "stop": "S11", "volume_dl": 34}, {"id": "P16", "stop": "S12", "volume_dl": 92}, {"id": "P17", "stop": "S13", "volume_dl": 322}, {"id": "P18", "stop": "S14", "volume_dl": 104}, {"id": "P19", "stop": "S14", "volume_dl": 12}, {"id": "P20", "stop": "S14", "volume_dl": 34}, {"id": "P21", "stop": "S14", "volume_dl": 429}, {"id": "P22", "stop": "S15", "volume_dl": 57}, {"id": "P23", "stop": "S16", "volume_dl": 57}, {"id": "P24", "stop": "S17", "volume_dl": 12}, {"id": "P25", "stop": "S18", "volume_dl": 10}, {"id": "P26", "stop": "S19", "volume_dl": 57}, {"id": "P27", "stop": "S20", "volume_dl": 25}, {"id": "P28", "stop": "S21", "volume_dl": 95}, {"id": "P29", "stop": "S22", "volume_dl": 92}, {"id": "P30", "stop": "S23", "volume_dl": 44}, {"id": "P31", "stop": "S24", "volume_dl": 15}, {"id": "P32", "stop": "S24", "volume_dl": 157}, {"id": "P33", "stop": "S25", "volume_dl": 57}, {"id": "P34", "stop": "S26", "volume_dl": 104}, {"id": "P35", "stop": "S27", "volume_dl": 34}, {"id": "P36", "stop": "S28", "volume_dl": 14}, {"id": "P37", "stop": "S28", "volume_dl": 42}, {"id": "P38", "stop": "S29", "volume_dl": 59}, {"id": "P39", "stop": "S29", "volume_dl": 31}, {"id": "P40", "stop": "S30", "volume_dl": 35}, {"id": "P41", "stop": "S30", "volume_dl": 179}, {"id": "P42", "stop": "S31", "volume_dl": 10}, {"id": "P43", "stop": "S32", "volume_dl": 57}, {"id": "P44", "stop": "S33", "volume_dl": 29}, {"id": "P45", "stop": "S34", "volume_dl": 157}, {"id": "P46", "stop": "S35", "volume_dl": 95}, {"id": "P47", "stop": "S36", "volume_dl": 322}, {"id": "P48", "stop": "S37", "volume_dl": 42}, {"id": "P49", "stop": "S38", "volume_dl": 322}, {"id": "P50", "stop": "S39", "volume_dl": 368}, {"id": "P51", "stop": "S39", "volume_dl": 322}, {"id": "P52", "stop": "S40", "volume_dl": 242}], "vans": 4, "capacity_dl": 1358, "travel_s": [[0, 1704, 1957, 1808, 1712, 1779, 1844, 1876, 1984, 1764, 1821, 1876, 1859, 1594, 1728, 2064, 1911, 1791, 1734, 1773, 1558, 1942, 1717, 1871, 2011, 1888, 1926, 1830, 1784, 1935, 1900, 1959, 1790, 1882, 1680, 1736, 1691, 1980, 1956, 1634, 1802], [1859, 0, 267, 472, 376, 461, 265, 630, 490, 112, 124, 629, 287, 368, 72, 492, 433, 544, 82, 526, 333, 363, 89, 220, 438, 558, 350, 494, 382, 359, 328, 584, 472, 636, 201, 77, 190, 408, 494, 456, 401], [2093, 271, 0, 381, 285, 398, 350, 539, 399, 277, 137, 538, 196, 516, 323, 401, 342, 453, 210, 436, 480, 434, 340, 129, 348, 452, 259, 404, 291, 268, 237, 493, 517, 545, 348, 225, 338, 316, 403, 365, 310], [2016, 464, 350, 0, 105, 262, 445, 338, 469, 447, 330, 338, 252, 709, 516, 256, 304, 253, 404, 235, 674, 503, 533, 264, 243, 316, 337, 22, 177, 346, 293, 150, 314, 344, 542, 418, 531, 228, 148, 164, 195], [1931, 360, 245, 96, 0, 179, 340, 253, 350, 342, 225, 253, 147, 605, 412, 352, 199, 168, 299, 150, 569, 385, 428, 159, 299, 233, 232, 118, 67, 242, 188, 247, 231, 259, 437, 313, 426, 268, 244, 79, 90], [2010, 471, 356, 279, 183, 0, 452, 401, 447, 454, 336, 401, 266, 716, 523, 449, 298, 316, 410, 298, 680, 481, 540, 271, 395, 97, 344, 301, 106, 353, 298, 429, 52, 407, 548, 425, 538, 364, 427, 181, 87], [1992, 238, 345, 417, 321, 434, 0, 574, 190, 201, 269, 574, 274, 533, 311, 479, 434, 489, 230, 471, 497, 148, 327, 214, 426, 488, 248, 439, 327, 257, 315, 568, 486, 580, 366, 315, 377, 395, 481, 400, 345], [2072, 620, 505, 370, 260, 382, 601, 0, 611, 603, 485, 146, 408, 865, 672, 548, 459, 154, 559, 205, 829, 645, 689, 420, 535, 436, 492, 348, 332, 502, 448, 443, 435, 6, 697, 574, 687, 520, 440, 220, 351], [2089, 335, 442, 462, 366, 460, 127, 619, 0, 298, 366, 619, 238, 630, 408, 342, 342, 534, 327, 516, 594, 67, 424, 311, 289, 514, 345, 474, 353, 354, 271, 434, 512, 625, 463, 412, 474, 258, 344, 445, 372], [1914, 116, 273, 478, 382, 451, 228, 636, 368, 0, 132, 635, 293, 454, 189, 498, 439, 550, 68, 532, 419, 326, 206, 226, 444, 548, 309, 500, 388, 319, 334, 590, 462, 642, 288, 188, 299, 414, 500, 462, 407], [1973, 134, 144, 348, 252, 369, 317, 506, 366, 141, 0, 506, 163, 379, 186, 368, 309, 420, 91, 403, 344, 401, 203, 96, 315, 466, 226, 371, 258, 236, 204, 460, 380, 512, 212, 88, 201, 284, 370, 332, 277], [2083, 631, 516, 367, 271, 393, 612, 137, 622, 614, 496, 0, 418, 876, 683, 686, 470, 165, 570, 216, 840, 656, 700, 430, 570, 447, 503, 485, 338, 513, 459, 580, 446, 143, 708, 585, 698, 539, 578, 231, 362], [2068, 307, 192, 233, 137, 264, 297, 390, 203, 313, 173, 390, 0, 552, 359, 205, 146, 305, 246, 287, 516, 237, 376, 107, 151, 318, 198, 255, 157, 207, 40, 297, 316, 396, 384, 261, 374, 120, 207, 216, 176], [1772, 349, 513, 718, 622, 706, 546, 875, 686, 458, 369, 875, 532, 0, 373, 738, 678, 790, 408, 772, 34, 644, 361, 465, 684, 804, 595, 740, 628, 605, 573, 830, 718, 881, 255, 284, 266, 653, 740, 701, 646], [1902, 73, 340, 545, 449, 533, 338, 702, 563, 186, 196, 702, 360, 383, 0, 565, 505, 617, 155, 599, 348, 436, 17, 292, 511, 631, 422, 567, 449, 441, 400, 657, 544, 708, 215, 137, 204, 480, 567, 528, 473], [2255, 504, 389, 282, 324, 419, 413, 577, 319, 510, 370, 577, 197, 749, 556, 0, 300, 492, 443, 474, 713, 353, 573, 304, 126, 472, 395, 260, 312, 404, 229, 220, 471, 583, 581, 458, 571, 96, 130, 403, 330], [2120, 461, 346, 285, 189, 284, 429, 442, 335, 467, 326, 442, 153, 706, 513, 336, 0, 357, 400, 339, 670, 369, 530, 260, 283, 337, 351, 307, 177, 361, 186, 435, 336, 448, 538, 414, 528, 252, 338, 268, 195], [1999, 546, 431, 283, 186, 309, 527, 146, 537, 529, 412, 146, 334, 791, 598, 539, 385, 0, 486, 143, 756, 571, 615, 346, 485, 362, 419, 305, 258, 428, 374, 433, 361, 152, 624, 500, 613, 454, 431, 147, 277], [1882, 69, 205, 410, 314, 405, 247, 567, 428, 76, 86, 567, 224, 423, 142, 430, 370, 482, 0, 464, 387, 345, 158, 157, 376, 502, 287, 432, 320, 297, 265, 522, 416, 573, 256, 146, 263, 345, 432, 393, 338], [1968, 515, 400, 251, 155, 278, 496, 206, 506, 498, 380, 206, 303, 760, 567, 508, 354, 151, 454, 0, 724, 540, 584, 315, 454, 331, 388, 274, 227, 397, 343, 402, 330, 212, 592, 469, 582, 423, 400, 116, 246], [1737, 314, 478, 683, 587, 672, 512, 841, 651, 424, 335, 840, 498, 36, 338, 703, 644, 755, 374, 738, 0, 610, 327, 431, 650, 769, 561, 706, 593, 570, 539, 795, 683, 847, 220, 249, 231, 618, 705, 667, 612], [2022, 268, 374, 447, 351, 464, 60, 604, 78, 231, 299, 604, 264, 563, 340, 368, 367, 519, 260, 501, 527, 0, 357, 243, 314, 517, 278, 469, 356, 287, 296, 460, 516, 610, 396, 345, 407, 283, 370, 430, 375], [1882, 102, 346, 551, 455, 540, 366, 709, 569, 214, 203, 708, 366, 364, 28, 571, 512, 623, 184, 606, 328, 464, 0, 299, 518, 637, 429, 574, 461, 438, 407, 663, 551, 715, 195, 117, 184, 486, 573, 535, 480], [2028, 273, 131, 278, 182, 295, 221, 435, 296, 237, 111, 435, 92, 491, 298, 298, 238, 350, 185, 332, 455, 330, 314, 0, 244, 348, 155, 300, 188, 165, 133, 390, 347, 441, 323, 199, 312, 213, 300, 261, 206], [2222, 471, 356, 248, 290, 385, 380, 544, 286, 477, 336, 544, 164, 716, 523, 127, 267, 458, 410, 441, 680, 320, 540, 270, 0, 439, 361, 225, 273, 371, 196, 185, 438, 550, 548, 425, 538, 44, 95, 370, 297], [2110, 508, 393, 316, 220, 101, 489, 438, 484, 491, 374, 438, 303, 753, 560, 486, 335, 353, 447, 335, 717, 518, 577, 308, 432, 0, 381, 338, 143, 390, 335, 466, 153, 444, 585, 462, 575, 401, 464, 282, 124], [2091, 336, 274, 339, 243, 356, 298, 496, 399, 300, 254, 496, 196, 632, 409, 401, 355, 411, 328, 393, 596, 434, 426, 190, 348, 409, 0, 361, 249, 55, 237, 489, 408, 502, 465, 342, 455, 317, 403, 322, 267], [2038, 487, 372, 22, 127, 284, 541, 360, 447, 469, 352, 360, 325, 732, 539, 234, 326, 275, 426, 257, 696, 481, 555, 286, 221, 338, 359, 0, 199, 369, 357, 128, 336, 366, 564, 440, 554, 205, 126, 186, 218], [2028, 365, 250, 193, 97, 107, 346, 350, 341, 348, 231, 344, 160, 610, 417, 343, 192, 265, 304, 247, 574, 375, 434, 165, 289, 161, 238, 215, 0, 256, 192, 344, 159, 357, 442, 319, 432, 258, 345, 176, 18], [2082, 328, 265, 330, 234, 347, 289, 488, 391, 291, 245, 498, 188, 623, 401, 393, 347, 402, 319, 384, 587, 425, 417, 150, 339, 401, 57, 352, 235, 0, 228, 481, 399, 494, 456, 334, 447, 308, 395, 314, 259], [2122, 361, 246, 286, 190, 289, 322, 444, 228, 367, 226, 444, 53, 606, 412, 230, 171, 358, 300, 341, 570, 262, 429, 160, 176, 342, 251, 309, 176, 270, 0, 322, 341, 450, 438, 314, 428, 145, 232, 270, 200], [2164, 588, 473, 148, 252, 410, 497, 429, 402, 594, 453, 486, 280, 832, 640, 189, 384, 400, 527, 383, 797, 437, 656, 387, 176, 464, 478, 126, 324, 488, 312, 0, 462, 423, 665, 541, 654, 161, 82, 312, 343], [2031, 513, 398, 321, 225, 42, 494, 443, 489, 496, 379, 443, 308, 758, 565, 491, 340, 358, 452, 340, 722, 523, 582, 313, 437, 139, 386, 343, 148, 395, 340, 471, 0, 449, 590, 467, 580, 406, 469, 203, 129], [2079, 626, 511, 364, 266, 389, 607, 6, 617, 609, 492, 152, 414, 871, 678, 542, 465, 160, 565, 211, 835, 651, 695, 426, 529, 442, 498, 342, 338, 508, 454, 436, 441, 0, 703, 580, 693, 514, 434, 227, 357], [1836, 190, 354, 559, 463, 548, 440, 716, 577, 299, 210, 716, 374, 268, 210, 579, 520, 631, 250, 613, 232, 611, 198, 306, 525, 645, 436, 581, 469, 446, 414, 671, 559, 722, 0, 125, 11, 494, 581, 542, 487], [1924, 65, 229, 434, 338, 422, 330, 591, 452, 174, 85, 591, 249, 291, 117, 454, 394, 506, 124, 488, 255, 486, 134, 181, 400, 520, 311, 456, 344, 321, 289, 546, 434, 597, 123, 0, 113, 369, 456, 417, 362], [1846, 179, 343, 548, 452, 537, 429, 705, 566, 288, 200, 705, 363, 278, 199, 568, 509, 620, 239, 602, 242, 600, 187, 296, 514, 634, 426, 570, 458, 435, 403, 660, 548, 712, 10, 114, 0, 483, 570, 531, 476], [2178, 426, 312, 239, 246, 341, 336, 500, 241, 433, 292, 499, 119, 671, 478, 82, 223, 414, 366, 396, 636, 276, 495, 226, 31, 395, 317, 216, 234, 326, 151, 176, 393, 506, 504, 380, 493, 0, 86, 326, 253], [2168, 506, 391, 152, 257, 420, 415, 433, 320, 512, 371, 490, 198, 751, 558, 108, 302, 405, 445, 387, 715, 355, 574, 305, 95, 474, 396, 130, 313, 406, 230, 90, 472, 427, 583, 459, 572, 79, 0, 316, 332], [1852, 437, 322, 174, 78, 200, 418, 242, 428, 420, 303, 241, 225, 682, 489, 430, 276, 156, 376, 139, 646, 462, 506, 237, 376, 254, 310, 196, 144, 328, 265, 324, 252, 248, 514, 391, 504, 345, 322, 0, 168], [2047, 384, 269, 212, 153, 88, 364, 369, 359, 366, 249, 369, 178, 629, 436, 361, 210, 284, 323, 266, 593, 394, 452, 183, 308, 142, 256, 234, 18, 266, 210, 362, 140, 375, 461, 337, 450, 277, 363, 195, 0]]}, "reference": {"optimum_s": 18606, "optimality": "best_found", "lower_bound_s": 15948, "floor_s": 13180, "solve_s": 70.34, "ffd_s": 22570, "stop_aware_best_s": 21606, "stop_aware_mean_s": 21815.4, "route_id": "RouteID_388fac5d-ab51-4faa-9d56-1504f6f2e0d0", "plans": {"optimum": [{"route": ["S32", "S05", "S25", "S40", "S28", "S16", "S30", "S12", "S02", "S10", "S09", "S18", "S01"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S20", "S13", "S23", "S26", "S29", "S17", "S11", "S07", "S33", "S19", "S39"], "parcels": ["P50"]}, {"route": ["S39", "S04", "S03", "S27", "S31", "S38", "S15", "S24", "S37", "S08", "S21", "S06"], "parcels": ["P51"]}, {"route": ["S34", "S36", "S35", "S14", "S22"], "parcels": []}], "ffd": [{"route": ["S39", "S07", "S29", "S14", "S13"], "parcels": ["P21", "P38", "P50"]}, {"route": ["S36", "S14", "S10", "S38", "S11", "S39"], "parcels": ["P14", "P18", "P51"]}, {"route": ["S04", "S40", "S26", "S12", "S30", "S24", "S21", "S22", "S35", "S34"], "parcels": ["P41"]}, {"route": ["S32", "S05", "S25", "S28", "S17", "S11", "S33", "S19", "S03", "S27", "S31", "S15", "S37", "S16", "S30", "S08", "S06", "S29", "S23", "S02", "S18", "S09", "S01", "S14", "S20"], "parcels": ["P15", "P19", "P20", "P39", "P40"]}], "stop_aware_best": [{"route": ["S39", "S11", "S33", "S16", "S08", "S21", "S26", "S29", "S23", "S02", "S35"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S32", "S25", "S40", "S28", "S17", "S04", "S03", "S31", "S37", "S12", "S10", "S20"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S19", "S07", "S27", "S05", "S30", "S06", "S09", "S18", "S01", "S14", "S34"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S38", "S15", "S24", "S22", "S36", "S13"], "parcels": []}]}}, "meta": {"route_id": "RouteID_388fac5d-ab51-4faa-9d56-1504f6f2e0d0", "split": "train", "stops": 40, "vans": 4, "tightness": 0.93, "station": "DBO3", "city": "DBO", "date": "2018-08-12", "seconds": 132.2, "stop_aware_best_reward": 0.4701, "optimality": "best_found"}}
{"id": "a7935df4-spread-n20-k3-t0.9-s0", "instance": {"stops": ["S01", "S02", "S03", "S04", "S05", "S06", "S07", "S08", "S09", "S10", "S11", "S12", "S13", "S14", "S15", "S16", "S17", "S18", "S19", "S20"], "parcels": [{"id": "P01", "stop": "S01", "volume_dl": 226}, {"id": "P02", "stop": "S01", "volume_dl": 157}, {"id": "P03", "stop": "S02", "volume_dl": 259}, {"id": "P04", "stop": "S03", "volume_dl": 157}, {"id": "P05", "stop": "S03", "volume_dl": 34}, {"id": "P06", "stop": "S03", "volume_dl": 12}, {"id": "P07", "stop": "S04", "volume_dl": 205}, {"id": "P08", "stop": "S04", "volume_dl": 157}, {"id": "P09", "stop": "S05", "volume_dl": 104}, {"id": "P10", "stop": "S05", "volume_dl": 95}, {"id": "P11", "stop": "S05", "volume_dl": 54}, {"id": "P12", "stop": "S05", "volume_dl": 95}, {"id": "P13", "stop": "S05", "volume_dl": 8}, {"id": "P14", "stop": "S05", "volume_dl": 242}, {"id": "P15", "stop": "S06", "volume_dl": 23}, {"id": "P16", "stop": "S07", "volume_dl": 95}, {"id": "P17", "stop": "S08", "volume_dl": 32}, {"id": "P18", "stop": "S08", "volume_dl": 60}, {"id": "P19", "stop": "S09", "volume_dl": 55}, {"id": "P20", "stop": "S09", "volume_dl": 104}, {"id": "P21", "stop": "S09", "volume_dl": 2}, {"id": "P22", "stop": "S09", "volume_dl": 134}, {"id": "P23", "stop": "S10", "volume_dl": 42}, {"id": "P24", "stop": "S11", "volume_dl": 55}, {"id": "P25", "stop": "S12", "volume_dl": 137}, {"id": "P26", "stop": "S12", "volume_dl": 134}, {"id": "P27", "stop": "S13", "volume_dl": 60}, {"id": "P28", "stop": "S13", "volume_dl": 23}, {"id": "P29", "stop": "S14", "volume_dl": 57}, {"id": "P30", "stop": "S15", "volume_dl": 15}, {"id": "P31", "stop": "S16", "volume_dl": 179}, {"id": "P32", "stop": "S16", "volume_dl": 19}, {"id": "P33", "stop": "S16", "volume_dl": 21}, {"id": "P34", "stop": "S16", "volume_dl": 95}, {"id": "P35", "stop": "S16", "volume_dl": 3}, {"id": "P36", "stop": "S17", "volume_dl": 157}, {"id": "P37", "stop": "S17", "volume_dl": 928}, {"id": "P38", "stop": "S18", "volume_dl": 133}, {"id": "P39", "stop": "S18", "volume_dl": 34}, {"id": "P40", "stop": "S19", "volume_dl": 21}, {"id": "P41", "stop": "S19", "volume_dl": 95}, {"id": "P42", "stop": "S19", "volume_dl": 60}, {"id": "P43", "stop": "S20", "volume_dl": 429}, {"id": "P44", "stop": "S20", "volume_dl": 25}, {"id": "P45", "stop": "S20", "volume_dl": 19}], "vans": 3, "capacity_dl": 1872, "travel_s": [[0, 1555, 1646, 1657, 1781, 1678, 1554, 1545, 1622, 1692, 1670, 1677, 1645, 1689, 1808, 1597, 1692, 1770, 1608, 1828, 1524], [1739, 0, 422, 398, 566, 400, 27, 356, 376, 434, 411, 399, 367, 431, 531, 82, 447, 500, 423, 596, 392], [1896, 384, 0, 97, 154, 100, 411, 235, 169, 132, 110, 123, 111, 84, 162, 374, 212, 124, 107, 184, 296], [1844, 417, 155, 0, 155, 109, 444, 313, 247, 35, 13, 112, 142, 112, 172, 383, 282, 187, 116, 185, 374], [1939, 544, 170, 166, 0, 253, 572, 284, 218, 128, 152, 230, 268, 135, 105, 511, 215, 120, 279, 105, 345], [1826, 376, 123, 151, 271, 0, 404, 255, 248, 186, 164, 82, 24, 179, 285, 343, 291, 247, 76, 224, 340], [1727, 20, 442, 414, 581, 421, 0, 372, 392, 449, 427, 419, 387, 446, 546, 102, 462, 515, 443, 611, 408], [1745, 376, 244, 275, 257, 289, 403, 0, 91, 282, 288, 292, 315, 239, 280, 342, 199, 242, 227, 287, 61], [1885, 385, 171, 246, 184, 216, 412, 104, 0, 208, 232, 287, 241, 166, 207, 351, 126, 169, 242, 217, 165], [1882, 455, 120, 38, 120, 147, 482, 278, 212, 0, 24, 117, 180, 81, 137, 421, 247, 152, 154, 150, 339], [1858, 431, 142, 14, 142, 123, 458, 300, 234, 22, 0, 111, 156, 99, 159, 397, 269, 178, 131, 172, 361], [1862, 358, 140, 86, 218, 101, 385, 292, 290, 116, 99, 0, 67, 140, 253, 379, 333, 262, 113, 252, 377], [1850, 336, 98, 126, 253, 34, 364, 279, 267, 161, 139, 58, 0, 154, 260, 367, 311, 226, 56, 202, 364], [1917, 453, 69, 117, 127, 154, 480, 241, 175, 90, 105, 145, 169, 0, 162, 421, 218, 146, 181, 162, 302], [1957, 517, 162, 191, 115, 262, 544, 279, 213, 153, 177, 270, 273, 175, 0, 483, 110, 44, 289, 171, 340], [1715, 85, 331, 342, 510, 312, 112, 300, 321, 378, 355, 391, 370, 375, 475, 0, 391, 444, 294, 540, 337], [1899, 459, 225, 295, 233, 271, 486, 216, 150, 264, 287, 342, 296, 221, 118, 425, 0, 162, 247, 269, 278], [1939, 499, 118, 211, 148, 218, 526, 248, 186, 173, 197, 241, 233, 131, 38, 465, 144, 0, 248, 151, 313], [1794, 345, 142, 113, 275, 60, 372, 223, 179, 148, 126, 101, 44, 145, 301, 311, 295, 267, 0, 305, 308], [1874, 483, 236, 89, 186, 169, 507, 393, 330, 192, 213, 171, 201, 201, 270, 446, 370, 288, 176, 0, 454], [1809, 393, 295, 306, 317, 275, 420, 60, 151, 342, 319, 323, 301, 300, 340, 359, 260, 306, 258, 330, 0]]}, "reference": {"optimum_s": 11832, "optimality": "best_found", "lower_bound_s": 10283, "floor_s": 9717, "solve_s": 36.17, "ffd_s": 13255, "stop_aware_best_s": 12569, "stop_aware_mean_s": 12690.2, "route_id": "RouteID_a7935df4-5114-41e1-871a-e31fcea8b07e", "plans": {"optimum": [{"route": ["S06", "S01", "S15", "S05", "S12", "S18"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S02", "S13", "S17", "S14", "S16"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S20", "S07", "S08", "S04", "S19", "S03", "S10", "S09", "S11"], "parcels": []}], "ffd": [{"route": ["S20", "S17", "S02", "S03", "S09", "S05"], "parcels": ["P06", "P14", "P21", "P37", "P43"]}, {"route": ["S18", "S05", "S12", "S03", "S09", "S04", "S17", "S16", "S01"], "parcels": ["P04", "P10", "P22", "P31", "P36", "P38"]}, {"route": ["S20", "S07", "S08", "S16", "S14", "S19", "S03", "S10", "S09", "S13", "S11", "S05", "S18", "S15", "S06"], "parcels": ["P05", "P09", "P11", "P12", "P13", "P19", "P20", "P32", "P33", "P34", "P35", "P39", "P44", "P45"]}], "stop_aware_best": [{"route": ["S20", "S14", "S09", "S03", "S13", "S02", "S18"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S10", "S04", "S17", "S16", "S15"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S07", "S08", "S19", "S05", "S12", "S11", "S01", "S06"], "parcels": []}]}}, "meta": {"route_id": "RouteID_a7935df4-5114-41e1-871a-e31fcea8b07e", "split": "train", "stops": 20, "vans": 3, "tightness": 0.9, "station": "DLA8", "city": "DLA", "date": "2018-08-05", "seconds": 96.3, "stop_aware_best_reward": 0.6112, "optimality": "best_found"}}
{"id": "149a586b-spread-n40-k4-t0.86-s0", "instance": {"stops": ["S01", "S02", "S03", "S04", "S05", "S06", "S07", "S08", "S09", "S10", "S11", "S12", "S13", "S14", "S15", "S16", "S17", "S18", "S19", "S20", "S21", "S22", "S23", "S24", "S25", "S26", "S27", "S28", "S29", "S30", "S31", "S32", "S33", "S34", "S35", "S36", "S37", "S38", "S39", "S40"], "parcels": [{"id": "P01", "stop": "S01", "volume_dl": 36}, {"id": "P02", "stop": "S02", "volume_dl": 63}, {"id": "P03", "stop": "S03", "volume_dl": 15}, {"id": "P04", "stop": "S04", "volume_dl": 157}, {"id": "P05", "stop": "S05", "volume_dl": 542}, {"id": "P06", "stop": "S06", "volume_dl": 57}, {"id": "P07", "stop": "S06", "volume_dl": 9}, {"id": "P08", "stop": "S07", "volume_dl": 14}, {"id": "P09", "stop": "S07", "volume_dl": 599}, {"id": "P10", "stop": "S08", "volume_dl": 133}, {"id": "P11", "stop": "S09", "volume_dl": 95}, {"id": "P12", "stop": "S09", "volume_dl": 104}, {"id": "P13", "stop": "S09", "volume_dl": 79}, {"id": "P14", "stop": "S10", "volume_dl": 57}, {"id": "P15", "stop": "S10", "volume_dl": 277}, {"id": "P16", "stop": "S11", "volume_dl": 58}, {"id": "P17", "stop": "S12", "volume_dl": 8}, {"id": "P18", "stop": "S13", "volume_dl": 4}, {"id": "P19", "stop": "S13", "volume_dl": 552}, {"id": "P20", "stop": "S14", "volume_dl": 59}, {"id": "P21", "stop": "S14", "volume_dl": 42}, {"id": "P22", "stop": "S15", "volume_dl": 34}, {"id": "P23", "stop": "S15", "volume_dl": 7}, {"id": "P24", "stop": "S15", "volume_dl": 63}, {"id": "P25", "stop": "S16", "volume_dl": 30}, {"id": "P26", "stop": "S17", "volume_dl": 46}, {"id": "P27", "stop": "S18", "volume_dl": 57}, {"id": "P28", "stop": "S19", "volume_dl": 63}, {"id": "P29", "stop": "S20", "volume_dl": 7}, {"id": "P30", "stop": "S21", "volume_dl": 179}, {"id": "P31", "stop": "S21", "volume_dl": 599}, {"id": "P32", "stop": "S22", "volume_dl": 8}, {"id": "P33", "stop": "S22", "volume_dl": 34}, {"id": "P34", "stop": "S22", "volume_dl": 429}, {"id": "P35", "stop": "S23", "volume_dl": 30}, {"id": "P36", "stop": "S23", "volume_dl": 12}, {"id": "P37", "stop": "S24", "volume_dl": 179}, {"id": "P38", "stop": "S24", "volume_dl": 57}, {"id": "P39", "stop": "S25", "volume_dl": 7}, {"id": "P40", "stop": "S25", "volume_dl": 29}, {"id": "P41", "stop": "S25", "volume_dl": 104}, {"id": "P42", "stop": "S25", "volume_dl": 104}, {"id": "P43", "stop": "S25", "volume_dl": 20}, {"id": "P44", "stop": "S26", "volume_dl": 5}, {"id": "P45", "stop": "S27", "volume_dl": 179}, {"id": "P46", "stop": "S28", "volume_dl": 63}, {"id": "P47", "stop": "S29", "volume_dl": 57}, {"id": "P48", "stop": "S29", "volume_dl": 57}, {"id": "P49", "stop": "S30", "volume_dl": 32}, {"id": "P50", "stop": "S31", "volume_dl": 928}, {"id": "P51", "stop": "S31", "volume_dl": 104}, {"id": "P52", "stop": "S32", "volume_dl": 179}, {"id": "P53", "stop": "S32", "volume_dl": 54}, {"id": "P54", "stop": "S33", "volume_dl": 35}, {"id": "P55", "stop": "S34", "volume_dl": 134}, {"id": "P56", "stop": "S34", "volume_dl": 840}, {"id": "P57", "stop": "S34", "volume_dl": 8}, {"id": "P58", "stop": "S34", "volume_dl": 134}, {"id": "P59", "stop": "S34", "volume_dl": 165}, {"id": "P60", "stop": "S35", "volume_dl": 59}, {"id": "P61", "stop": "S36", "volume_dl": 11}, {"id": "P62", "stop": "S36", "volume_dl": 34}, {"id": "P63", "stop": "S36", "volume_dl": 13}, {"id": "P64", "stop": "S36", "volume_dl": 34}, {"id": "P65", "stop": "S37", "volume_dl": 52}, {"id": "P66", "stop": "S38", "volume_dl": 57}, {"id": "P67", "stop": "S39", "volume_dl": 31}, {"id": "P68", "stop": "S39", "volume_dl": 15}, {"id": "P69", "stop": "S40", "volume_dl": 16}, {"id": "P70", "stop": "S40", "volume_dl": 39}], "vans": 4, "capacity_dl": 2441, "travel_s": [[0, 1372, 1266, 1388, 1312, 1362, 1408, 1319, 1372, 1380, 1329, 1188, 1241, 1322, 1375, 1418, 1405, 1324, 1340, 1351, 1377, 1368, 1408, 1433, 1316, 1436, 1320, 1175, 1376, 1398, 1360, 1311, 1235, 1182, 1214, 1435, 1198, 1384, 1434, 1327, 1217], [1293, 0, 244, 203, 275, 293, 295, 282, 211, 43, 152, 320, 372, 329, 198, 377, 270, 284, 303, 315, 244, 245, 231, 256, 501, 259, 283, 322, 306, 357, 23, 274, 366, 287, 318, 97, 302, 207, 257, 261, 348], [1144, 370, 0, 239, 149, 200, 259, 156, 223, 378, 220, 320, 373, 83, 232, 269, 256, 175, 177, 188, 228, 219, 315, 341, 447, 343, 157, 173, 213, 249, 358, 148, 367, 138, 168, 432, 133, 292, 292, 73, 349], [1375, 260, 326, 0, 357, 352, 338, 364, 221, 268, 162, 353, 406, 411, 208, 348, 335, 254, 386, 397, 307, 255, 209, 145, 535, 237, 365, 404, 365, 328, 248, 356, 400, 369, 401, 322, 385, 185, 66, 343, 382], [1185, 341, 134, 210, 0, 62, 230, 72, 194, 349, 192, 361, 414, 217, 204, 240, 228, 147, 111, 104, 199, 191, 286, 312, 488, 314, 73, 214, 76, 220, 329, 11, 408, 179, 211, 403, 194, 263, 264, 135, 390], [1230, 386, 179, 255, 61, 0, 275, 135, 239, 394, 237, 406, 459, 262, 249, 285, 273, 192, 174, 168, 244, 236, 332, 357, 534, 360, 136, 259, 52, 265, 374, 50, 453, 224, 256, 448, 240, 308, 309, 180, 435], [1315, 301, 266, 233, 297, 348, 0, 308, 217, 324, 204, 376, 429, 366, 227, 131, 89, 92, 325, 337, 60, 212, 327, 350, 591, 353, 305, 344, 361, 79, 289, 296, 429, 309, 356, 363, 340, 286, 287, 286, 410], [1221, 377, 170, 246, 74, 125, 277, 0, 230, 385, 217, 397, 450, 256, 243, 282, 263, 182, 106, 106, 235, 225, 324, 348, 557, 354, 75, 250, 138, 259, 365, 73, 449, 215, 250, 439, 234, 299, 299, 174, 431], [1276, 226, 228, 134, 259, 309, 239, 266, 0, 234, 59, 320, 373, 312, 36, 249, 237, 156, 287, 298, 208, 80, 154, 179, 502, 182, 267, 305, 323, 229, 214, 258, 367, 270, 302, 289, 286, 130, 180, 244, 349], [1309, 32, 261, 220, 292, 310, 323, 299, 228, 0, 169, 336, 389, 346, 215, 400, 287, 300, 320, 331, 261, 260, 249, 273, 551, 281, 300, 338, 323, 374, 20, 291, 389, 304, 335, 54, 319, 224, 274, 281, 370], [1252, 168, 203, 86, 234, 285, 226, 245, 59, 186, 0, 261, 314, 288, 46, 221, 212, 131, 262, 274, 184, 91, 97, 120, 476, 128, 242, 281, 298, 195, 156, 233, 314, 246, 268, 230, 252, 72, 121, 224, 295], [1115, 295, 326, 303, 357, 375, 376, 364, 311, 303, 252, 0, 73, 410, 298, 405, 352, 312, 385, 396, 326, 344, 330, 356, 322, 358, 365, 403, 388, 385, 283, 356, 46, 369, 400, 357, 384, 307, 357, 342, 49], [1129, 309, 340, 317, 371, 389, 390, 378, 325, 317, 266, 61, 0, 424, 312, 419, 366, 326, 399, 410, 340, 358, 344, 370, 336, 372, 379, 417, 402, 399, 297, 370, 108, 383, 414, 371, 398, 321, 371, 356, 46], [1187, 418, 61, 286, 210, 261, 307, 217, 270, 426, 258, 363, 416, 0, 280, 323, 304, 223, 238, 250, 276, 265, 365, 388, 490, 396, 218, 216, 274, 296, 406, 209, 410, 144, 158, 480, 123, 340, 340, 137, 397], [1278, 214, 229, 122, 260, 311, 241, 267, 57, 222, 36, 307, 360, 314, 0, 258, 238, 158, 289, 300, 210, 89, 143, 167, 489, 169, 268, 307, 324, 231, 202, 260, 354, 272, 304, 276, 288, 118, 168, 250, 336], [1342, 346, 293, 260, 324, 375, 139, 331, 244, 354, 242, 421, 474, 378, 254, 0, 65, 119, 352, 364, 106, 241, 338, 362, 636, 365, 332, 371, 388, 140, 334, 323, 474, 336, 368, 408, 351, 313, 314, 313, 450], [1270, 276, 221, 231, 252, 303, 69, 259, 215, 284, 202, 352, 405, 306, 224, 47, 0, 90, 280, 292, 36, 211, 281, 306, 534, 309, 260, 298, 316, 70, 264, 251, 399, 264, 295, 339, 279, 258, 284, 238, 381], [1222, 272, 174, 141, 205, 255, 84, 212, 125, 280, 122, 398, 451, 258, 134, 93, 81, 0, 233, 244, 52, 121, 217, 243, 504, 245, 213, 251, 269, 73, 260, 204, 445, 216, 248, 334, 232, 194, 194, 190, 427], [1282, 439, 232, 308, 136, 164, 328, 136, 292, 447, 289, 458, 511, 315, 301, 338, 325, 244, 0, 150, 297, 288, 384, 409, 586, 412, 119, 311, 178, 318, 427, 135, 505, 277, 308, 501, 292, 361, 361, 232, 487], [1262, 418, 211, 287, 115, 166, 307, 95, 271, 426, 268, 438, 490, 294, 280, 317, 304, 223, 129, 0, 276, 267, 363, 388, 565, 391, 44, 290, 179, 297, 406, 114, 484, 256, 287, 480, 271, 340, 340, 212, 466], [1234, 240, 185, 206, 216, 267, 50, 223, 190, 248, 166, 316, 369, 270, 212, 88, 26, 71, 244, 256, 0, 187, 245, 270, 498, 273, 224, 262, 280, 60, 228, 215, 363, 228, 259, 303, 243, 222, 260, 202, 345], [1234, 261, 185, 143, 216, 267, 208, 227, 61, 268, 83, 410, 463, 269, 70, 212, 194, 113, 244, 256, 166, 0, 189, 213, 549, 215, 224, 263, 280, 186, 249, 214, 462, 228, 258, 323, 242, 165, 214, 205, 444], [1276, 207, 280, 150, 311, 299, 291, 322, 135, 215, 86, 301, 354, 364, 122, 308, 289, 208, 339, 350, 260, 169, 0, 130, 482, 68, 319, 357, 312, 281, 195, 310, 348, 323, 354, 270, 338, 15, 138, 296, 330], [1334, 266, 338, 154, 369, 357, 361, 380, 193, 274, 144, 359, 412, 423, 180, 366, 347, 266, 397, 408, 318, 225, 144, 0, 541, 170, 377, 415, 371, 339, 254, 368, 411, 381, 412, 328, 396, 119, 113, 355, 393], [1148, 445, 475, 452, 506, 524, 537, 517, 460, 453, 412, 260, 313, 560, 480, 561, 501, 461, 534, 546, 475, 492, 482, 505, 0, 513, 514, 364, 538, 534, 433, 505, 313, 371, 403, 507, 387, 457, 506, 496, 294], [1305, 232, 304, 180, 340, 329, 321, 342, 165, 240, 101, 330, 378, 394, 147, 332, 313, 232, 368, 380, 290, 194, 50, 154, 512, 0, 348, 387, 337, 306, 225, 339, 377, 352, 379, 299, 363, 45, 162, 321, 354], [1254, 410, 203, 279, 107, 158, 299, 87, 263, 418, 260, 430, 483, 286, 273, 309, 297, 216, 121, 48, 268, 260, 355, 381, 557, 383, 0, 283, 171, 289, 398, 106, 477, 248, 280, 472, 263, 332, 332, 204, 459], [1115, 343, 90, 212, 136, 187, 233, 143, 196, 351, 194, 291, 344, 175, 206, 242, 230, 149, 164, 176, 202, 193, 289, 314, 419, 317, 144, 0, 200, 222, 331, 135, 338, 110, 141, 406, 125, 266, 266, 151, 320], [1249, 405, 198, 274, 80, 53, 294, 154, 258, 413, 255, 425, 478, 281, 268, 304, 292, 211, 193, 186, 263, 255, 350, 376, 552, 378, 155, 278, 0, 284, 393, 69, 472, 243, 274, 467, 258, 327, 327, 199, 454], [1279, 286, 230, 238, 261, 312, 58, 272, 222, 294, 212, 361, 414, 315, 232, 136, 74, 97, 290, 301, 45, 217, 292, 316, 576, 324, 269, 308, 325, 0, 274, 260, 408, 273, 305, 348, 289, 267, 292, 250, 395], [1290, 12, 241, 200, 272, 290, 292, 279, 208, 20, 149, 316, 370, 326, 195, 374, 267, 281, 300, 312, 241, 242, 228, 253, 498, 256, 280, 319, 303, 354, 0, 271, 364, 284, 315, 74, 299, 204, 254, 258, 345], [1204, 360, 154, 229, 11, 52, 250, 91, 213, 368, 200, 380, 433, 237, 223, 266, 247, 166, 130, 124, 218, 208, 308, 331, 508, 339, 92, 233, 65, 239, 348, 0, 433, 198, 230, 422, 214, 282, 283, 154, 409], [1166, 346, 376, 354, 408, 425, 438, 418, 362, 354, 313, 50, 124, 466, 353, 467, 402, 362, 436, 447, 377, 394, 387, 411, 405, 419, 416, 454, 439, 436, 334, 411, 0, 419, 451, 408, 435, 358, 408, 397, 105], [1060, 420, 164, 301, 225, 276, 321, 232, 285, 428, 282, 236, 289, 156, 295, 331, 319, 238, 253, 265, 290, 282, 378, 403, 363, 406, 233, 89, 289, 311, 408, 224, 283, 0, 28, 482, 32, 354, 354, 221, 265], [1092, 452, 178, 333, 257, 308, 353, 264, 317, 460, 304, 268, 321, 170, 327, 370, 351, 270, 285, 297, 322, 312, 411, 435, 395, 438, 265, 121, 321, 343, 440, 256, 320, 49, 0, 514, 46, 386, 386, 232, 297], [1350, 72, 302, 261, 333, 350, 352, 340, 269, 41, 210, 377, 430, 386, 256, 435, 328, 341, 361, 372, 302, 302, 288, 314, 559, 316, 341, 379, 364, 415, 60, 332, 424, 344, 376, 0, 360, 265, 315, 318, 406], [1084, 444, 131, 325, 249, 300, 346, 256, 309, 452, 297, 260, 313, 124, 319, 362, 343, 262, 278, 289, 314, 304, 404, 427, 388, 435, 257, 113, 313, 335, 432, 248, 313, 21, 35, 506, 0, 378, 379, 186, 289], [1261, 192, 264, 135, 296, 284, 276, 303, 120, 200, 61, 286, 339, 349, 107, 286, 274, 193, 324, 335, 245, 154, 23, 115, 467, 51, 304, 342, 297, 266, 180, 295, 333, 308, 339, 254, 323, 0, 122, 281, 314], [1304, 236, 289, 93, 320, 328, 301, 327, 172, 244, 113, 330, 382, 374, 159, 310, 298, 217, 348, 360, 270, 206, 136, 79, 511, 164, 328, 367, 341, 290, 224, 319, 376, 332, 364, 298, 347, 113, 0, 306, 358], [1195, 380, 62, 249, 159, 210, 281, 170, 233, 388, 220, 371, 424, 145, 243, 289, 267, 186, 187, 199, 238, 228, 330, 354, 531, 354, 167, 224, 223, 259, 368, 161, 423, 189, 220, 442, 196, 302, 303, 0, 405], [1106, 286, 316, 294, 348, 366, 378, 359, 302, 298, 253, 38, 67, 401, 289, 403, 343, 302, 376, 387, 317, 334, 323, 347, 345, 354, 356, 394, 379, 380, 274, 347, 90, 360, 396, 348, 379, 298, 348, 337, 0]]}, "reference": {"optimum_s": 13147, "optimality": "best_found", "lower_bound_s": 10334, "floor_s": 8940, "solve_s": 67.25, "ffd_s": 16090, "stop_aware_best_s": 15591, "stop_aware_mean_s": 15883.8, "route_id": "RouteID_149a586b-6e2e-4a13-ade9-4437e4021e3d", "plans": {"optimum": [{"route": ["S27", "S13", "S02", "S39", "S04", "S29", "S06", "S20", "S16", "S15", "S17", "S08", "S14", "S10", "S30", "S09", "S35", "S01", "S24"], "parcels": ["P14"]}, {"route": ["S32", "S11", "S12", "S40", "S03", "S38", "S23", "S25", "S22", "S37", "S10", "S21"], "parcels": ["P15"]}, {"route": ["S36", "S33", "S34"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S18", "S26", "S19", "S07", "S31", "S28", "S05"], "parcels": []}], "ffd": [{"route": ["S07", "S31", "S02", "S36", "S34"], "parcels": ["P09", "P50", "P56", "P61"]}, {"route": ["S13", "S05", "S21", "S14", "S10", "S22"], "parcels": ["P15", "P19", "P21", "P31", "P34"]}, {"route": ["S34", "S27", "S19", "S04", "S31", "S28", "S15", "S17", "S21", "S08", "S14", "S25", "S09", "S35", "S32", "S11", "S24"], "parcels": ["P20", "P24", "P30", "P37", "P41", "P42", "P51", "P52", "P55", "P58", "P59"]}, {"route": ["S24", "S32", "S12", "S40", "S30", "S01", "S03", "S38", "S23", "S25", "S22", "S37", "S10", "S15", "S16", "S29", "S06", "S20", "S18", "S26", "S07", "S39", "S13", "S36", "S33", "S34"], "parcels": ["P08", "P14", "P18", "P22", "P23", "P32", "P33", "P38", "P39", "P40", "P43", "P53", "P57", "P62", "P63", "P64"]}], "stop_aware_best": [{"route": ["S18", "S19", "S04", "S29", "S16", "S38", "S30", "S02", "S36", "S34"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S32", "S40", "S35", "S09", "S14", "S21", "S15", "S20", "S07", "S28", "S33"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S27", "S13", "S39", "S17", "S06", "S08", "S10", "S03", "S37", "S25", "S24"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S11", "S12", "S23", "S22", "S01", "S26", "S31", "S05"], "parcels": []}]}}, "meta": {"route_id": "RouteID_149a586b-6e2e-4a13-ade9-4437e4021e3d", "split": "train", "stops": 40, "vans": 4, "tightness": 0.86, "station": "DLA9", "city": "DLA", "date": "2018-08-18", "seconds": 130.1, "stop_aware_best_reward": 0.4572, "optimality": "best_found"}}
{"id": "3a4fb973-spread-n30-k4-t0.89-s0", "instance": {"stops": ["S01", "S02", "S03", "S04", "S05", "S06", "S07", "S08", "S09", "S10", "S11", "S12", "S13", "S14", "S15", "S16", "S17", "S18", "S19", "S20", "S21", "S22", "S23", "S24", "S25", "S26", "S27", "S28", "S29", "S30"], "parcels": [{"id": "P01", "stop": "S01", "volume_dl": 21}, {"id": "P02", "stop": "S01", "volume_dl": 226}, {"id": "P03", "stop": "S02", "volume_dl": 36}, {"id": "P04", "stop": "S03", "volume_dl": 63}, {"id": "P05", "stop": "S04", "volume_dl": 5}, {"id": "P06", "stop": "S05", "volume_dl": 104}, {"id": "P07", "stop": "S05", "volume_dl": 63}, {"id": "P08", "stop": "S06", "volume_dl": 57}, {"id": "P09", "stop": "S07", "volume_dl": 179}, {"id": "P10", "stop": "S07", "volume_dl": 95}, {"id": "P11", "stop": "S08", "volume_dl": 57}, {"id": "P12", "stop": "S09", "volume_dl": 179}, {"id": "P13", "stop": "S10", "volume_dl": 79}, {"id": "P14", "stop": "S11", "volume_dl": 26}, {"id": "P15", "stop": "S12", "volume_dl": 226}, {"id": "P16", "stop": "S12", "volume_dl": 46}, {"id": "P17", "stop": "S12", "volume_dl": 25}, {"id": "P18", "stop": "S13", "volume_dl": 242}, {"id": "P19", "stop": "S14", "volume_dl": 153}, {"id": "P20", "stop": "S15", "volume_dl": 26}, {"id": "P21", "stop": "S16", "volume_dl": 32}, {"id": "P22", "stop": "S17", "volume_dl": 3}, {"id": "P23", "stop": "S17", "volume_dl": 21}, {"id": "P24", "stop": "S17", "volume_dl": 35}, {"id": "P25", "stop": "S18", "volume_dl": 9}, {"id": "P26", "stop": "S19", "volume_dl": 34}, {"id": "P27", "stop": "S20", "volume_dl": 133}, {"id": "P28", "stop": "S21", "volume_dl": 21}, {"id": "P29", "stop": "S22", "volume_dl": 34}, {"id": "P30", "stop": "S22", "volume_dl": 92}, {"id": "P31", "stop": "S23", "volume_dl": 5}, {"id": "P32", "stop": "S24", "volume_dl": 34}, {"id": "P33", "stop": "S25", "volume_dl": 104}, {"id": "P34", "stop": "S26", "volume_dl": 20}, {"id": "P35", "stop": "S27", "volume_dl": 21}, {"id": "P36", "stop": "S28", "volume_dl": 63}, {"id": "P37", "stop": "S28", "volume_dl": 17}, {"id": "P38", "stop": "S29", "volume_dl": 542}, {"id": "P39", "stop": "S30", "volume_dl": 63}], "vans": 4, "capacity_dl": 898, "travel_s": [[0, 2766, 2606, 2642, 2769, 2442, 2778, 2778, 2661, 2709, 2308, 2664, 2274, 2870, 2464, 2288, 2648, 2884, 2556, 2593, 2851, 2801, 2469, 2584, 2615, 2633, 2546, 2483, 2720, 2583, 2736], [2852, 0, 389, 325, 86, 506, 481, 508, 179, 372, 792, 573, 795, 533, 642, 811, 357, 545, 216, 515, 514, 119, 533, 387, 361, 338, 328, 661, 346, 305, 196], [2677, 393, 0, 378, 396, 536, 445, 474, 464, 336, 756, 423, 764, 497, 730, 778, 322, 512, 184, 365, 478, 429, 563, 194, 449, 260, 72, 749, 347, 210, 364], [2746, 352, 377, 0, 329, 325, 311, 340, 162, 95, 609, 586, 614, 363, 460, 628, 110, 377, 274, 514, 344, 301, 352, 375, 178, 316, 316, 478, 241, 293, 193], [2905, 75, 400, 318, 0, 485, 484, 514, 156, 375, 769, 584, 774, 536, 619, 788, 361, 551, 226, 525, 518, 96, 512, 398, 338, 342, 339, 638, 347, 316, 199], [2572, 549, 541, 342, 528, 0, 525, 512, 361, 407, 378, 355, 386, 577, 433, 400, 347, 592, 452, 284, 559, 500, 27, 371, 315, 529, 480, 451, 538, 479, 485], [2863, 483, 415, 305, 487, 499, 0, 48, 451, 308, 767, 600, 732, 297, 468, 746, 248, 312, 312, 541, 279, 590, 526, 414, 404, 355, 355, 486, 346, 332, 383], [2834, 523, 457, 403, 589, 471, 41, 0, 422, 349, 739, 732, 703, 339, 440, 717, 290, 354, 354, 660, 320, 561, 498, 455, 376, 396, 396, 458, 388, 373, 425], [2749, 190, 444, 162, 167, 329, 381, 410, 0, 257, 612, 590, 618, 433, 463, 632, 203, 447, 310, 518, 414, 139, 356, 442, 182, 384, 383, 482, 307, 360, 137], [2803, 393, 330, 82, 396, 383, 306, 335, 244, 0, 667, 514, 672, 358, 517, 686, 87, 373, 227, 456, 340, 383, 410, 328, 236, 269, 269, 536, 194, 246, 222], [2426, 822, 753, 613, 799, 346, 797, 783, 632, 678, 0, 568, 128, 848, 484, 114, 619, 863, 665, 496, 830, 771, 372, 583, 586, 741, 693, 503, 828, 691, 756], [2766, 539, 418, 524, 543, 352, 591, 620, 610, 482, 572, 0, 580, 643, 656, 594, 468, 658, 330, 52, 625, 575, 379, 248, 595, 406, 358, 674, 493, 356, 510], [2356, 846, 779, 639, 825, 372, 823, 748, 658, 704, 138, 594, 0, 874, 435, 52, 645, 889, 691, 522, 856, 797, 398, 609, 612, 767, 719, 453, 854, 717, 782], [2925, 530, 462, 352, 534, 570, 313, 342, 438, 355, 854, 647, 859, 0, 675, 873, 295, 213, 359, 588, 180, 566, 596, 461, 423, 402, 402, 694, 393, 379, 430], [2544, 625, 662, 415, 602, 387, 443, 442, 435, 480, 448, 609, 412, 648, 0, 426, 421, 662, 559, 537, 629, 574, 414, 624, 388, 602, 601, 60, 608, 579, 558], [2371, 839, 770, 630, 816, 362, 814, 800, 649, 695, 125, 584, 73, 865, 450, 0, 636, 880, 682, 513, 847, 788, 389, 600, 603, 758, 710, 468, 845, 708, 773], [2751, 389, 318, 104, 366, 331, 254, 283, 199, 74, 615, 592, 620, 306, 465, 634, 0, 321, 215, 520, 288, 338, 358, 316, 184, 257, 257, 484, 202, 234, 229], [2925, 530, 462, 351, 533, 569, 312, 341, 437, 354, 853, 646, 858, 228, 675, 872, 295, 0, 359, 588, 54, 565, 596, 460, 422, 401, 401, 693, 392, 378, 430], [2636, 209, 173, 245, 213, 462, 312, 341, 306, 203, 746, 357, 752, 364, 597, 766, 188, 378, 0, 299, 345, 245, 489, 171, 315, 140, 112, 615, 213, 90, 217], [2713, 486, 366, 472, 490, 300, 539, 568, 557, 430, 519, 72, 527, 591, 603, 541, 415, 605, 277, 0, 572, 522, 327, 196, 542, 354, 305, 621, 440, 304, 457], [2914, 519, 451, 341, 523, 558, 301, 330, 426, 344, 842, 635, 848, 217, 664, 862, 284, 57, 348, 577, 0, 555, 585, 449, 411, 391, 390, 682, 382, 368, 419], [2877, 106, 432, 290, 94, 457, 517, 546, 128, 385, 741, 718, 746, 569, 591, 760, 331, 583, 258, 646, 550, 0, 484, 430, 310, 374, 371, 610, 379, 348, 227], [2600, 576, 569, 369, 556, 28, 553, 540, 389, 434, 406, 383, 414, 605, 461, 428, 375, 619, 480, 311, 586, 528, 0, 398, 342, 557, 508, 479, 562, 507, 512], [2674, 371, 194, 356, 374, 386, 423, 452, 441, 314, 605, 273, 613, 475, 689, 627, 299, 489, 161, 214, 456, 406, 413, 0, 427, 238, 133, 707, 325, 188, 341], [2704, 393, 430, 184, 370, 283, 367, 396, 203, 249, 567, 544, 573, 419, 418, 586, 189, 434, 327, 473, 400, 342, 310, 429, 0, 370, 370, 436, 376, 347, 326], [2712, 344, 250, 311, 347, 528, 378, 407, 396, 269, 766, 434, 774, 430, 663, 788, 254, 444, 148, 375, 411, 379, 555, 248, 381, 0, 189, 681, 279, 63, 296], [2605, 321, 61, 306, 325, 465, 374, 403, 392, 264, 684, 352, 692, 426, 659, 706, 250, 440, 112, 293, 407, 357, 492, 122, 377, 188, 0, 677, 275, 139, 292], [2584, 665, 702, 456, 642, 427, 483, 482, 475, 521, 488, 649, 453, 688, 62, 466, 461, 703, 599, 577, 670, 614, 454, 665, 428, 642, 642, 0, 648, 619, 598], [2833, 331, 371, 247, 337, 530, 380, 409, 309, 204, 814, 555, 819, 432, 665, 833, 239, 450, 332, 496, 413, 369, 561, 369, 383, 310, 310, 683, 0, 287, 162], [2649, 305, 186, 290, 309, 483, 358, 387, 376, 248, 703, 370, 711, 410, 643, 725, 234, 424, 96, 312, 391, 341, 510, 184, 361, 50, 125, 661, 259, 0, 276], [2812, 214, 349, 152, 217, 466, 395, 424, 147, 212, 749, 533, 755, 447, 600, 769, 214, 462, 213, 475, 428, 212, 492, 347, 319, 289, 288, 618, 170, 266, 0]]}, "reference": {"optimum_s": 24878, "optimality": "best_found", "lower_bound_s": 21058, "floor_s": 18520, "solve_s": 36.14, "ffd_s": 28950, "stop_aware_best_s": 27899, "stop_aware_mean_s": 28112.6, "route_id": "RouteID_3a4fb973-fd42-43f8-a8de-73ed099d6723", "plans": {"optimum": [{"route": ["S05", "S03", "S09", "S28", "S30", "S08", "S21", "S04", "S01", "S18"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S22", "S11", "S19", "S23", "S25", "S29", "S02", "S26"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S27", "S14", "S10", "S15", "S12"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S07", "S06", "S13", "S20", "S17", "S16", "S24"], "parcels": []}], "ffd": [{"route": ["S05", "S13", "S18", "S29"], "parcels": ["P06"]}, {"route": ["S04", "S01", "S09", "S17", "S07", "S10", "S12"], "parcels": ["P02", "P09", "P15", "P22"]}, {"route": ["S05", "S22", "S23", "S25", "S28", "S30", "S03", "S20", "S06", "S07", "S14"], "parcels": ["P07", "P10", "P30", "P36"]}, {"route": ["S12", "S15", "S22", "S11", "S19", "S26", "S02", "S17", "S16", "S28", "S01", "S21", "S08", "S24", "S27"], "parcels": ["P01", "P16", "P17", "P23", "P24", "P29", "P37"]}], "stop_aware_best": [{"route": ["S29", "S28", "S21", "S14", "S10"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S18", "S01", "S04", "S08", "S09", "S13", "S20"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S12", "S15", "S19", "S30", "S03", "S06", "S17", "S02"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S05", "S22", "S11", "S23", "S26", "S25", "S16", "S24", "S07", "S27"], "parcels": []}]}}, "meta": {"route_id": "RouteID_3a4fb973-fd42-43f8-a8de-73ed099d6723", "split": "train", "stops": 30, "vans": 4, "tightness": 0.89, "station": "DCH3", "city": "DCH", "date": "2018-08-07", "seconds": 88.4, "stop_aware_best_reward": 0.5139, "optimality": "best_found"}}
{"id": "d013ae5e-spread-n25-k3-t0.93-s0", "instance": {"stops": ["S01", "S02", "S03", "S04", "S05", "S06", "S07", "S08", "S09", "S10", "S11", "S12", "S13", "S14", "S15", "S16", "S17", "S18", "S19", "S20", "S21", "S22", "S23", "S24", "S25"], "parcels": [{"id": "P01", "stop": "S01", "volume_dl": 133}, {"id": "P02", "stop": "S01", "volume_dl": 226}, {"id": "P03", "stop": "S02", "volume_dl": 13}, {"id": "P04", "stop": "S03", "volume_dl": 57}, {"id": "P05", "stop": "S03", "volume_dl": 277}, {"id": "P06", "stop": "S03", "volume_dl": 59}, {"id": "P07", "stop": "S03", "volume_dl": 7}, {"id": "P08", "stop": "S04", "volume_dl": 32}, {"id": "P09", "stop": "S04", "volume_dl": 824}, {"id": "P10", "stop": "S04", "volume_dl": 22}, {"id": "P11", "stop": "S05", "volume_dl": 15}, {"id": "P12", "stop": "S06", "volume_dl": 24}, {"id": "P13", "stop": "S07", "volume_dl": 179}, {"id": "P14", "stop": "S07", "volume_dl": 9}, {"id": "P15", "stop": "S08", "volume_dl": 104}, {"id": "P16", "stop": "S08", "volume_dl": 27}, {"id": "P17", "stop": "S09", "volume_dl": 31}, {"id": "P18", "stop": "S10", "volume_dl": 322}, {"id": "P19", "stop": "S11", "volume_dl": 42}, {"id": "P20", "stop": "S12", "volume_dl": 322}, {"id": "P21", "stop": "S13", "volume_dl": 19}, {"id": "P22", "stop": "S14", "volume_dl": 57}, {"id": "P23", "stop": "S15", "volume_dl": 24}, {"id": "P24", "stop": "S16", "volume_dl": 58}, {"id": "P25", "stop": "S17", "volume_dl": 57}, {"id": "P26", "stop": "S17", "volume_dl": 9}, {"id": "P27", "stop": "S18", "volume_dl": 277}, {"id": "P28", "stop": "S19", "volume_dl": 57}, {"id": "P29", "stop": "S19", "volume_dl": 149}, {"id": "P30", "stop": "S19", "volume_dl": 16}, {"id": "P31", "stop": "S19", "volume_dl": 22}, {"id": "P32", "stop": "S20", "volume_dl": 60}, {"id": "P33", "stop": "S21", "volume_dl": 59}, {"id": "P34", "stop": "S22", "volume_dl": 36}, {"id": "P35", "stop": "S22", "volume_dl": 59}, {"id": "P36", "stop": "S22", "volume_dl": 104}, {"id": "P37", "stop": "S22", "volume_dl": 27}, {"id": "P38", "stop": "S22", "volume_dl": 104}, {"id": "P39", "stop": "S23", "volume_dl": 41}, {"id": "P40", "stop": "S24", "volume_dl": 57}, {"id": "P41", "stop": "S24", "volume_dl": 30}, {"id": "P42", "stop": "S24", "volume_dl": 34}, {"id": "P43", "stop": "S25", "volume_dl": 34}], "vans": 3, "capacity_dl": 1476, "travel_s": [[0, 1296, 1316, 1428, 1451, 1455, 1416, 1756, 1364, 1603, 1365, 1351, 1407, 1324, 1698, 1454, 1512, 1694, 1373, 1530, 1384, 1443, 1440, 1514, 1486, 1412], [1288, 0, 198, 328, 322, 206, 348, 636, 240, 460, 116, 234, 262, 328, 555, 296, 412, 576, 274, 381, 266, 343, 323, 415, 337, 312], [1346, 211, 0, 370, 221, 370, 175, 509, 73, 338, 280, 163, 162, 130, 434, 196, 402, 455, 316, 242, 145, 322, 150, 328, 198, 260], [1447, 330, 373, 0, 326, 489, 522, 430, 415, 254, 399, 268, 268, 503, 350, 315, 163, 440, 48, 225, 350, 94, 498, 166, 346, 123], [1442, 307, 214, 316, 0, 466, 363, 608, 262, 438, 376, 149, 72, 343, 534, 89, 347, 624, 261, 307, 266, 266, 338, 350, 262, 204], [1425, 205, 336, 466, 460, 0, 485, 767, 384, 597, 104, 371, 400, 465, 693, 434, 550, 714, 411, 519, 404, 481, 460, 552, 474, 450], [1437, 330, 164, 490, 341, 489, 0, 628, 133, 458, 399, 282, 281, 213, 554, 315, 522, 574, 435, 361, 257, 441, 25, 447, 317, 379], [1699, 617, 541, 404, 612, 776, 690, 0, 583, 158, 686, 462, 547, 670, 153, 594, 291, 323, 384, 306, 469, 345, 666, 299, 465, 402], [1368, 259, 93, 418, 269, 418, 123, 563, 0, 386, 327, 211, 210, 144, 482, 244, 450, 497, 364, 290, 193, 369, 105, 376, 245, 308], [1628, 459, 382, 240, 447, 618, 532, 170, 430, 0, 528, 304, 389, 512, 96, 436, 133, 186, 225, 142, 311, 186, 507, 140, 307, 244], [1358, 137, 268, 398, 392, 105, 417, 700, 316, 529, 0, 303, 332, 398, 625, 366, 482, 646, 343, 451, 336, 413, 393, 485, 406, 382], [1364, 229, 137, 260, 139, 388, 287, 467, 185, 297, 298, 0, 79, 267, 392, 113, 292, 482, 205, 158, 118, 211, 262, 295, 114, 149], [1383, 248, 154, 265, 82, 407, 304, 550, 202, 380, 316, 89, 0, 284, 476, 64, 289, 566, 218, 248, 207, 208, 279, 292, 203, 146], [1315, 278, 150, 410, 371, 437, 203, 659, 164, 488, 347, 313, 312, 0, 584, 346, 493, 605, 355, 392, 331, 425, 185, 496, 347, 393], [1724, 558, 482, 339, 547, 718, 632, 133, 530, 100, 627, 404, 488, 612, 0, 535, 232, 284, 325, 242, 411, 286, 607, 240, 407, 343], [1396, 261, 168, 292, 79, 421, 318, 577, 216, 407, 330, 103, 64, 298, 502, 0, 316, 592, 244, 261, 221, 235, 293, 318, 217, 173], [1548, 413, 336, 161, 397, 572, 486, 295, 384, 125, 481, 258, 337, 466, 221, 371, 0, 311, 146, 96, 265, 107, 461, 61, 261, 165], [1683, 541, 427, 421, 551, 700, 576, 304, 475, 181, 610, 463, 492, 557, 256, 526, 314, 0, 406, 323, 421, 368, 552, 322, 493, 425], [1403, 285, 348, 63, 302, 445, 498, 400, 396, 230, 354, 243, 244, 478, 325, 290, 138, 415, 0, 200, 325, 70, 473, 141, 321, 98], [1468, 332, 240, 268, 301, 492, 390, 315, 288, 138, 401, 162, 242, 370, 234, 275, 120, 324, 253, 0, 169, 214, 365, 128, 165, 259], [1374, 239, 125, 345, 250, 399, 258, 474, 173, 304, 308, 138, 190, 255, 399, 224, 341, 489, 290, 165, 0, 296, 234, 344, 72, 234], [1484, 367, 318, 92, 272, 527, 468, 348, 366, 178, 436, 213, 214, 448, 274, 260, 87, 364, 77, 149, 274, 0, 443, 90, 270, 68], [1419, 306, 140, 465, 316, 465, 25, 610, 121, 433, 374, 258, 257, 195, 529, 290, 497, 550, 411, 337, 233, 416, 0, 422, 292, 354], [1537, 445, 369, 149, 356, 605, 518, 328, 417, 158, 514, 291, 298, 499, 254, 345, 67, 343, 134, 129, 298, 96, 494, 0, 294, 153], [1467, 332, 213, 342, 273, 491, 351, 477, 261, 301, 401, 134, 214, 343, 396, 248, 338, 486, 288, 162, 93, 293, 326, 341, 0, 231], [1416, 299, 250, 119, 203, 458, 399, 404, 298, 234, 368, 145, 145, 380, 330, 192, 142, 419, 104, 204, 230, 62, 375, 146, 226, 0]]}, "reference": {"optimum_s": 11066, "optimality": "best_found", "lower_bound_s": 9089, "floor_s": 7752, "solve_s": 36.16, "ffd_s": 13301, "stop_aware_best_s": 12608, "stop_aware_mean_s": 12860.4, "route_id": "RouteID_d013ae5e-569f-4a70-9b32-5edd2aded496", "plans": {"optimum": [{"route": ["S01", "S10", "S05", "S02", "S08", "S06", "S22", "S13"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S20", "S24", "S11", "S12", "S04", "S15"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S18", "S03", "S25", "S21", "S23", "S16", "S17", "S14", "S07", "S09", "S19"], "parcels": []}], "ffd": [{"route": ["S03", "S04", "S12", "S10"], "parcels": ["P07", "P09"]}, {"route": ["S08", "S22", "S19", "S07", "S03", "S18", "S01"], "parcels": ["P05", "P13", "P29", "P36"]}, {"route": ["S13", "S06", "S22", "S02", "S20", "S24", "S19", "S17", "S14", "S07", "S09", "S16", "S23", "S21", "S03", "S25", "S04", "S15", "S11", "S05"], "parcels": ["P04", "P06", "P08", "P10", "P14", "P28", "P30", "P31", "P34", "P35", "P37", "P38"]}], "stop_aware_best": [{"route": ["S18", "S16", "S09", "S14", "S17", "S20", "S02", "S08", "S22", "S10", "S05"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S23", "S21", "S25", "S04", "S11", "S01"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S13", "S06", "S12", "S15", "S24", "S19", "S07", "S03"], "parcels": []}]}}, "meta": {"route_id": "RouteID_d013ae5e-569f-4a70-9b32-5edd2aded496", "split": "train", "stops": 25, "vans": 3, "tightness": 0.93, "station": "DCH4", "city": "DCH", "date": "2018-08-15", "seconds": 88.6, "stop_aware_best_reward": 0.5242, "optimality": "best_found"}}
{"id": "9e86806b-spread-n20-k3-t0.9-s0", "instance": {"stops": ["S01", "S02", "S03", "S04", "S05", "S06", "S07", "S08", "S09", "S10", "S11", "S12", "S13", "S14", "S15", "S16", "S17", "S18", "S19", "S20"], "parcels": [{"id": "P01", "stop": "S01", "volume_dl": 79}, {"id": "P02", "stop": "S01", "volume_dl": 30}, {"id": "P03", "stop": "S02", "volume_dl": 34}, {"id": "P04", "stop": "S02", "volume_dl": 477}, {"id": "P05", "stop": "S02", "volume_dl": 63}, {"id": "P06", "stop": "S02", "volume_dl": 402}, {"id": "P07", "stop": "S02", "volume_dl": 36}, {"id": "P08", "stop": "S02", "volume_dl": 104}, {"id": "P09", "stop": "S03", "volume_dl": 57}, {"id": "P10", "stop": "S04", "volume_dl": 179}, {"id": "P11", "stop": "S05", "volume_dl": 242}, {"id": "P12", "stop": "S05", "volume_dl": 104}, {"id": "P13", "stop": "S06", "volume_dl": 242}, {"id": "P14", "stop": "S07", "volume_dl": 95}, {"id": "P15", "stop": "S07", "volume_dl": 53}, {"id": "P16", "stop": "S08", "volume_dl": 179}, {"id": "P17", "stop": "S08", "volume_dl": 59}, {"id": "P18", "stop": "S09", "volume_dl": 552}, {"id": "P19", "stop": "S09", "volume_dl": 34}, {"id": "P20", "stop": "S09", "volume_dl": 226}, {"id": "P21", "stop": "S09", "volume_dl": 226}, {"id": "P22", "stop": "S10", "volume_dl": 57}, {"id": "P23", "stop": "S11", "volume_dl": 46}, {"id": "P24", "stop": "S11", "volume_dl": 133}, {"id": "P25", "stop": "S11", "volume_dl": 60}, {"id": "P26", "stop": "S11", "volume_dl": 32}, {"id": "P27", "stop": "S11", "volume_dl": 37}, {"id": "P28", "stop": "S11", "volume_dl": 56}, {"id": "P29", "stop": "S11", "volume_dl": 79}, {"id": "P30", "stop": "S12", "volume_dl": 28}, {"id": "P31", "stop": "S13", "volume_dl": 43}, {"id": "P32", "stop": "S13", "volume_dl": 5}, {"id": "P33", "stop": "S14", "volume_dl": 259}, {"id": "P34", "stop": "S14", "volume_dl": 34}, {"id": "P35", "stop": "S14", "volume_dl": 26}, {"id": "P36", "stop": "S15", "volume_dl": 95}, {"id": "P37", "stop": "S16", "volume_dl": 429}, {"id": "P38", "stop": "S17", "volume_dl": 28}, {"id": "P39", "stop": "S17", "volume_dl": 309}, {"id": "P40", "stop": "S18", "volume_dl": 30}, {"id": "P41", "stop": "S19", "volume_dl": 265}, {"id": "P42", "stop": "S20", "volume_dl": 179}], "vans": 3, "capacity_dl": 2114, "travel_s": [[0, 1284, 1386, 1130, 1295, 1215, 1066, 1324, 1302, 1264, 1362, 1264, 1353, 1076, 1299, 1369, 1288, 1337, 1262, 1335, 1093], [1344, 0, 122, 306, 112, 246, 262, 66, 65, 170, 199, 165, 143, 334, 126, 138, 68, 163, 190, 598, 252], [1388, 106, 0, 401, 257, 249, 357, 132, 176, 115, 119, 173, 71, 427, 258, 58, 136, 303, 189, 693, 347], [1256, 305, 446, 0, 365, 212, 62, 345, 323, 324, 466, 438, 415, 139, 384, 404, 309, 424, 296, 402, 58], [1308, 116, 255, 390, 0, 329, 345, 148, 56, 254, 266, 195, 238, 415, 40, 205, 171, 81, 274, 682, 335], [1388, 239, 268, 210, 317, 0, 198, 338, 270, 143, 348, 368, 234, 298, 331, 287, 268, 369, 115, 535, 188], [1226, 275, 377, 52, 335, 264, 0, 315, 293, 254, 498, 470, 344, 113, 354, 435, 279, 394, 328, 372, 110], [1397, 59, 122, 353, 141, 292, 308, 0, 106, 217, 168, 164, 148, 379, 137, 107, 70, 209, 237, 645, 299], [1274, 33, 156, 328, 56, 268, 283, 72, 0, 192, 196, 129, 177, 356, 85, 136, 109, 93, 212, 620, 274], [1473, 210, 125, 286, 260, 132, 241, 218, 213, 0, 205, 259, 91, 311, 272, 144, 180, 312, 74, 577, 231], [1340, 244, 126, 518, 278, 355, 474, 194, 190, 222, 0, 131, 178, 544, 227, 76, 249, 266, 296, 747, 464], [1276, 166, 169, 440, 200, 379, 396, 161, 112, 305, 112, 0, 253, 466, 154, 119, 222, 173, 324, 732, 386], [1418, 148, 70, 357, 287, 232, 312, 160, 206, 100, 149, 180, 0, 382, 288, 88, 90, 340, 174, 649, 302], [1255, 304, 426, 146, 381, 250, 116, 361, 334, 301, 505, 468, 390, 0, 395, 444, 325, 433, 299, 406, 146], [1293, 117, 241, 394, 46, 330, 349, 139, 58, 258, 252, 159, 272, 417, 0, 192, 204, 79, 278, 686, 340], [1330, 154, 50, 432, 219, 278, 387, 118, 182, 146, 61, 92, 101, 457, 219, 0, 172, 252, 219, 723, 377], [1402, 62, 145, 298, 211, 237, 254, 70, 128, 162, 227, 223, 78, 324, 212, 166, 0, 228, 182, 590, 244], [1286, 151, 281, 446, 158, 386, 401, 198, 123, 310, 227, 156, 294, 474, 127, 253, 227, 0, 330, 738, 391], [1414, 275, 199, 269, 262, 102, 224, 283, 220, 74, 278, 310, 164, 294, 281, 217, 213, 321, 0, 560, 214], [1075, 415, 517, 285, 475, 345, 196, 455, 433, 394, 598, 557, 484, 206, 494, 538, 419, 534, 393, 0, 223], [1256, 268, 446, 64, 328, 177, 66, 308, 286, 320, 468, 441, 411, 146, 347, 406, 272, 387, 292, 402, 0]]}, "reference": {"optimum_s": 9316, "optimality": "best_found", "lower_bound_s": 7752, "floor_s": 6423, "solve_s": 35.16, "ffd_s": 10481, "stop_aware_best_s": 9767, "stop_aware_mean_s": 9979.6, "route_id": "RouteID_9e86806b-f7ef-4bdb-8b0c-370f0c91883c", "plans": {"optimum": [{"route": ["S13", "S01", "S07", "S16", "S12", "S09", "S18", "S05", "S20", "S03", "S06", "S19"], "parcels": ["P21"]}, {"route": ["S11", "S08", "S04", "S14", "S17"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S09", "S02", "S15", "S10"], "parcels": ["P18", "P19", "P20"]}], "ffd": [{"route": ["S13", "S05", "S09", "S02", "S16"], "parcels": ["P04", "P06", "P11", "P18", "P32"]}, {"route": ["S11", "S17", "S14", "S04", "S08", "S09", "S20", "S06", "S19"], "parcels": ["P16", "P20", "P21", "P23", "P33", "P39"]}, {"route": ["S13", "S03", "S05", "S18", "S09", "S12", "S02", "S15", "S10", "S11", "S08", "S01", "S07", "S14", "S17"], "parcels": ["P03", "P05", "P07", "P08", "P12", "P17", "P19", "P24", "P25", "P26", "P27", "P28", "P29", "P31", "P34", "P35", "P38"]}], "stop_aware_best": [{"route": ["S13", "S08", "S01", "S02", "S20", "S19"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S09", "S16", "S07", "S10"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S06", "S03", "S05", "S18", "S12", "S15", "S11", "S14", "S04", "S17"], "parcels": []}]}}, "meta": {"route_id": "RouteID_9e86806b-f7ef-4bdb-8b0c-370f0c91883c", "split": "train", "stops": 20, "vans": 3, "tightness": 0.9, "station": "DSE2", "city": "DSE", "date": "2018-07-31", "seconds": 87.3, "stop_aware_best_reward": 0.7918, "optimality": "best_found"}}
{"id": "fa5e36ae-spread-n30-k4-t0.92-s0", "instance": {"stops": ["S01", "S02", "S03", "S04", "S05", "S06", "S07", "S08", "S09", "S10", "S11", "S12", "S13", "S14", "S15", "S16", "S17", "S18", "S19", "S20", "S21", "S22", "S23", "S24", "S25", "S26", "S27", "S28", "S29", "S30"], "parcels": [{"id": "P01", "stop": "S01", "volume_dl": 224}, {"id": "P02", "stop": "S01", "volume_dl": 599}, {"id": "P03", "stop": "S01", "volume_dl": 12}, {"id": "P04", "stop": "S01", "volume_dl": 136}, {"id": "P05", "stop": "S02", "volume_dl": 12}, {"id": "P06", "stop": "S03", "volume_dl": 34}, {"id": "P07", "stop": "S04", "volume_dl": 34}, {"id": "P08", "stop": "S04", "volume_dl": 134}, {"id": "P09", "stop": "S05", "volume_dl": 34}, {"id": "P10", "stop": "S05", "volume_dl": 10}, {"id": "P11", "stop": "S05", "volume_dl": 60}, {"id": "P12", "stop": "S05", "volume_dl": 242}, {"id": "P13", "stop": "S06", "volume_dl": 9}, {"id": "P14", "stop": "S06", "volume_dl": 57}, {"id": "P15", "stop": "S06", "volume_dl": 41}, {"id": "P16", "stop": "S06", "volume_dl": 104}, {"id": "P17", "stop": "S06", "volume_dl": 133}, {"id": "P18", "stop": "S06", "volume_dl": 179}, {"id": "P19", "stop": "S07", "volume_dl": 94}, {"id": "P20", "stop": "S08", "volume_dl": 104}, {"id": "P21", "stop": "S08", "volume_dl": 44}, {"id": "P22", "stop": "S09", "volume_dl": 38}, {"id": "P23", "stop": "S10", "volume_dl": 179}, {"id": "P24", "stop": "S11", "volume_dl": 57}, {"id": "P25", "stop": "S11", "volume_dl": 57}, {"id": "P26", "stop": "S12", "volume_dl": 44}, {"id": "P27", "stop": "S13", "volume_dl": 259}, {"id": "P28", "stop": "S14", "volume_dl": 95}, {"id": "P29", "stop": "S15", "volume_dl": 5}, {"id": "P30", "stop": "S16", "volume_dl": 34}, {"id": "P31", "stop": "S17", "volume_dl": 95}, {"id": "P32", "stop": "S18", "volume_dl": 14}, {"id": "P33", "stop": "S18", "volume_dl": 23}, {"id": "P34", "stop": "S19", "volume_dl": 60}, {"id": "P35", "stop": "S20", "volume_dl": 242}, {"id": "P36", "stop": "S20", "volume_dl": 57}, {"id": "P37", "stop": "S21", "volume_dl": 157}, {"id": "P38", "stop": "S21", "volume_dl": 226}, {"id": "P39", "stop": "S22", "volume_dl": 57}, {"id": "P40", "stop": "S22", "volume_dl": 134}, {"id": "P41", "stop": "S23", "volume_dl": 15}, {"id": "P42", "stop": "S24", "volume_dl": 40}, {"id": "P43", "stop": "S25", "volume_dl": 48}, {"id": "P44", "stop": "S26", "volume_dl": 133}, {"id": "P45", "stop": "S27", "volume_dl": 408}, {"id": "P46", "stop": "S28", "volume_dl": 34}, {"id": "P47", "stop": "S29", "volume_dl": 104}, {"id": "P48", "stop": "S30", "volume_dl": 157}], "vans": 4, "capacity_dl": 1379, "travel_s": [[0, 1556, 1210, 1336, 1206, 1232, 1310, 1420, 1305, 1335, 1247, 1403, 1330, 1294, 1401, 1350, 1303, 1233, 1254, 1425, 1353, 1387, 1485, 1454, 1485, 1320, 1346, 1380, 1442, 1314, 1483], [1441, 0, 692, 572, 440, 422, 449, 539, 423, 397, 711, 438, 566, 739, 317, 678, 449, 670, 705, 341, 550, 302, 489, 510, 61, 302, 588, 161, 448, 708, 70], [1075, 763, 0, 158, 308, 387, 465, 638, 459, 509, 37, 559, 185, 84, 451, 140, 457, 23, 44, 395, 143, 525, 473, 610, 692, 494, 136, 554, 336, 104, 691], [1224, 651, 145, 0, 196, 274, 353, 526, 347, 397, 161, 447, 73, 208, 380, 110, 345, 123, 168, 324, 31, 454, 370, 498, 580, 382, 42, 442, 224, 188, 578], [1084, 452, 298, 179, 0, 129, 229, 375, 201, 232, 314, 296, 173, 361, 298, 263, 200, 276, 321, 322, 156, 283, 382, 347, 381, 217, 195, 276, 296, 341, 380], [1194, 496, 428, 309, 193, 0, 160, 338, 132, 275, 444, 237, 303, 491, 341, 393, 131, 406, 451, 365, 286, 327, 425, 309, 425, 260, 325, 320, 335, 471, 423], [1196, 515, 428, 308, 163, 134, 0, 343, 130, 246, 444, 291, 303, 491, 312, 393, 27, 406, 418, 336, 318, 290, 398, 314, 395, 231, 324, 290, 335, 471, 394], [1366, 532, 612, 493, 339, 343, 378, 0, 345, 548, 628, 112, 487, 675, 576, 577, 370, 590, 635, 600, 470, 562, 698, 195, 545, 495, 509, 467, 610, 655, 460], [1223, 421, 455, 336, 275, 112, 169, 299, 0, 273, 471, 198, 330, 518, 339, 420, 139, 433, 478, 363, 313, 324, 425, 270, 350, 258, 352, 271, 362, 498, 348], [1234, 435, 484, 364, 233, 206, 285, 484, 279, 0, 499, 383, 359, 546, 283, 448, 277, 462, 506, 227, 342, 234, 197, 455, 364, 168, 380, 228, 254, 527, 362], [1102, 733, 27, 183, 334, 412, 490, 664, 484, 538, 0, 584, 211, 47, 414, 166, 483, 49, 7, 358, 169, 488, 436, 636, 662, 521, 162, 557, 362, 67, 660], [1411, 420, 574, 455, 342, 231, 258, 101, 233, 378, 590, 0, 449, 637, 453, 539, 258, 552, 597, 477, 432, 438, 530, 83, 375, 377, 471, 297, 481, 617, 348], [1216, 644, 170, 51, 189, 267, 345, 518, 339, 390, 186, 439, 0, 233, 372, 135, 338, 148, 193, 316, 28, 446, 362, 490, 573, 375, 67, 434, 217, 213, 571], [1164, 754, 88, 245, 395, 474, 552, 725, 546, 560, 61, 646, 272, 0, 435, 227, 544, 110, 54, 379, 230, 509, 458, 697, 684, 542, 223, 579, 419, 135, 682], [1310, 360, 442, 358, 309, 283, 361, 560, 355, 239, 415, 460, 353, 442, 0, 382, 354, 427, 408, 44, 336, 114, 191, 531, 289, 171, 374, 184, 152, 411, 287], [1204, 714, 129, 131, 282, 360, 438, 611, 432, 519, 145, 532, 158, 192, 395, 0, 431, 107, 151, 339, 117, 469, 417, 583, 643, 502, 109, 538, 310, 172, 641], [1220, 490, 452, 332, 219, 109, 38, 366, 161, 270, 468, 266, 327, 514, 336, 417, 0, 430, 474, 360, 310, 321, 420, 337, 419, 255, 348, 314, 359, 495, 418], [1097, 740, 22, 134, 285, 363, 441, 615, 436, 486, 38, 535, 162, 84, 432, 117, 434, 0, 44, 376, 120, 506, 455, 587, 669, 471, 112, 530, 313, 105, 667], [1109, 726, 34, 190, 341, 419, 519, 670, 491, 531, 7, 591, 217, 40, 407, 173, 490, 56, 0, 351, 176, 481, 430, 642, 655, 514, 168, 550, 390, 80, 653], [1325, 375, 398, 314, 324, 298, 376, 576, 371, 255, 371, 475, 308, 398, 56, 337, 369, 382, 364, 0, 292, 130, 146, 547, 304, 186, 330, 199, 107, 367, 302], [1192, 620, 142, 22, 165, 243, 321, 495, 315, 366, 158, 415, 42, 204, 348, 107, 314, 120, 164, 292, 0, 422, 339, 466, 549, 351, 38, 410, 193, 185, 547], [1288, 337, 509, 418, 287, 261, 361, 538, 333, 217, 482, 437, 413, 509, 87, 448, 331, 493, 475, 111, 396, 0, 257, 509, 266, 148, 434, 162, 218, 478, 265], [1374, 493, 466, 350, 374, 347, 448, 625, 420, 208, 439, 524, 344, 466, 172, 406, 418, 451, 432, 116, 329, 248, 0, 596, 420, 302, 366, 316, 144, 435, 419], [1333, 529, 588, 468, 315, 315, 349, 176, 316, 461, 604, 75, 463, 651, 536, 553, 342, 566, 611, 560, 446, 521, 611, 0, 458, 464, 485, 380, 586, 631, 456], [1386, 78, 636, 517, 385, 366, 401, 480, 368, 342, 656, 379, 511, 684, 262, 623, 394, 614, 649, 285, 494, 247, 432, 451, 0, 247, 533, 106, 393, 652, 133], [1203, 315, 453, 333, 202, 176, 254, 454, 248, 132, 469, 353, 328, 516, 161, 418, 246, 431, 476, 185, 311, 146, 282, 424, 244, 0, 350, 140, 360, 496, 243], [1221, 648, 144, 42, 193, 272, 350, 523, 344, 394, 160, 444, 70, 207, 377, 109, 342, 122, 167, 321, 28, 451, 367, 495, 577, 379, 0, 439, 221, 187, 576], [1280, 176, 531, 411, 280, 267, 302, 381, 269, 242, 550, 280, 406, 578, 156, 517, 294, 509, 544, 180, 389, 141, 326, 352, 105, 141, 427, 0, 287, 547, 103], [1353, 475, 326, 206, 320, 308, 386, 585, 380, 247, 342, 484, 201, 389, 155, 291, 378, 304, 348, 99, 184, 229, 146, 556, 404, 286, 222, 299, 0, 369, 402], [1170, 729, 94, 212, 363, 442, 520, 693, 514, 534, 67, 614, 240, 101, 410, 195, 512, 111, 60, 354, 198, 484, 433, 665, 658, 517, 191, 554, 394, 0, 657], [1372, 72, 622, 502, 371, 352, 386, 469, 354, 327, 642, 368, 497, 669, 247, 608, 379, 600, 635, 271, 480, 232, 418, 440, 103, 232, 518, 91, 378, 638, 0]]}, "reference": {"optimum_s": 12954, "optimality": "best_found", "lower_bound_s": 11129, "floor_s": 9124, "solve_s": 43.15, "ffd_s": 16977, "stop_aware_best_s": 14848, "stop_aware_mean_s": 15091.8, "route_id": "RouteID_fa5e36ae-708e-43be-ac00-c25d110c8131", "plans": {"optimum": [{"route": ["S07", "S23", "S11", "S01", "S24", "S25"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S30", "S27", "S21", "S14", "S19", "S28", "S22", "S09"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S04", "S12", "S20", "S03", "S26", "S15", "S17", "S10", "S29", "S18", "S13", "S02"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S05", "S08", "S16", "S06"], "parcels": []}], "ffd": [{"route": ["S27", "S01", "S06", "S13"], "parcels": ["P02", "P13", "P16"]}, {"route": ["S05", "S06", "S21", "S01", "S20", "S18", "S10"], "parcels": ["P01", "P11", "P12", "P18", "P33", "P35", "P38"]}, {"route": ["S04", "S06", "S08", "S23", "S30", "S01", "S21", "S14", "S19", "S22", "S26", "S29", "S18"], "parcels": ["P04", "P08", "P17", "P20", "P32", "P37", "P40"]}, {"route": ["S04", "S05", "S16", "S06", "S08", "S11", "S07", "S01", "S24", "S25", "S09", "S22", "S28", "S12", "S20", "S03", "S15", "S17", "S02"], "parcels": ["P03", "P07", "P09", "P10", "P14", "P15", "P21", "P36", "P39"]}], "stop_aware_best": [{"route": ["S09", "S22", "S28", "S14", "S21", "S27", "S07"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S05", "S23", "S11", "S24", "S04", "S26", "S15", "S10", "S13", "S02"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S08", "S30", "S01", "S25", "S12"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S16", "S06", "S19", "S20", "S03", "S17", "S29", "S18"], "parcels": []}]}}, "meta": {"route_id": "RouteID_fa5e36ae-708e-43be-ac00-c25d110c8131", "split": "train", "stops": 30, "vans": 4, "tightness": 0.92, "station": "DSE4", "city": "DSE", "date": "2018-08-24", "seconds": 103.5, "stop_aware_best_reward": 0.5051, "optimality": "best_found"}}
{"id": "0809e036-spread-n25-k3-t0.86-s0", "instance": {"stops": ["S01", "S02", "S03", "S04", "S05", "S06", "S07", "S08", "S09", "S10", "S11", "S12", "S13", "S14", "S15", "S16", "S17", "S18", "S19", "S20", "S21", "S22", "S23", "S24", "S25"], "parcels": [{"id": "P01", "stop": "S01", "volume_dl": 413}, {"id": "P02", "stop": "S01", "volume_dl": 11}, {"id": "P03", "stop": "S02", "volume_dl": 53}, {"id": "P04", "stop": "S02", "volume_dl": 59}, {"id": "P05", "stop": "S03", "volume_dl": 29}, {"id": "P06", "stop": "S03", "volume_dl": 121}, {"id": "P07", "stop": "S03", "volume_dl": 259}, {"id": "P08", "stop": "S04", "volume_dl": 322}, {"id": "P09", "stop": "S04", "volume_dl": 157}, {"id": "P10", "stop": "S04", "volume_dl": 322}, {"id": "P11", "stop": "S05", "volume_dl": 21}, {"id": "P12", "stop": "S06", "volume_dl": 7}, {"id": "P13", "stop": "S07", "volume_dl": 57}, {"id": "P14", "stop": "S08", "volume_dl": 840}, {"id": "P15", "stop": "S09", "volume_dl": 37}, {"id": "P16", "stop": "S09", "volume_dl": 134}, {"id": "P17", "stop": "S09", "volume_dl": 12}, {"id": "P18", "stop": "S10", "volume_dl": 35}, {"id": "P19", "stop": "S11", "volume_dl": 57}, {"id": "P20", "stop": "S12", "volume_dl": 21}, {"id": "P21", "stop": "S13", "volume_dl": 20}, {"id": "P22", "stop": "S14", "volume_dl": 42}, {"id": "P23", "stop": "S15", "volume_dl": 36}, {"id": "P24", "stop": "S15", "volume_dl": 309}, {"id": "P25", "stop": "S16", "volume_dl": 542}, {"id": "P26", "stop": "S16", "volume_dl": 542}, {"id": "P27", "stop": "S16", "volume_dl": 322}, {"id": "P28", "stop": "S17", "volume_dl": 11}, {"id": "P29", "stop": "S18", "volume_dl": 57}, {"id": "P30", "stop": "S19", "volume_dl": 57}, {"id": "P31", "stop": "S20", "volume_dl": 242}, {"id": "P32", "stop": "S20", "volume_dl": 95}, {"id": "P33", "stop": "S21", "volume_dl": 79}, {"id": "P34", "stop": "S21", "volume_dl": 259}, {"id": "P35", "stop": "S21", "volume_dl": 26}, {"id": "P36", "stop": "S22", "volume_dl": 35}, {"id": "P37", "stop": "S22", "volume_dl": 226}, {"id": "P38", "stop": "S22", "volume_dl": 79}, {"id": "P39", "stop": "S23", "volume_dl": 20}, {"id": "P40", "stop": "S23", "volume_dl": 22}, {"id": "P41", "stop": "S23", "volume_dl": 34}, {"id": "P42", "stop": "S24", "volume_dl": 104}, {"id": "P43", "stop": "S24", "volume_dl": 4}, {"id": "P44", "stop": "S25", "volume_dl": 25}, {"id": "P45", "stop": "S25", "volume_dl": 36}, {"id": "P46", "stop": "S25", "volume_dl": 46}, {"id": "P47", "stop": "S25", "volume_dl": 450}], "vans": 3, "capacity_dl": 2593, "travel_s": [[0, 2506, 2370, 2485, 2320, 2470, 2594, 2529, 2326, 2518, 2653, 2230, 2394, 2492, 2405, 2563, 2618, 2509, 2604, 2638, 2625, 2632, 2373, 2462, 2494, 2458], [2465, 0, 305, 606, 356, 564, 458, 280, 395, 334, 428, 474, 289, 532, 410, 514, 203, 301, 249, 283, 447, 497, 497, 254, 604, 657], [2216, 353, 0, 461, 51, 358, 251, 265, 89, 236, 283, 168, 24, 387, 104, 369, 260, 286, 190, 224, 332, 352, 229, 110, 298, 778], [2437, 568, 424, 0, 475, 676, 569, 501, 513, 310, 228, 592, 400, 233, 528, 132, 601, 522, 402, 436, 312, 207, 608, 473, 722, 945], [2166, 360, 50, 511, 0, 274, 301, 315, 38, 286, 333, 117, 74, 437, 85, 419, 268, 335, 240, 274, 382, 402, 178, 140, 247, 828], [2334, 568, 309, 697, 259, 0, 174, 501, 261, 472, 519, 200, 333, 623, 344, 605, 527, 522, 427, 461, 569, 588, 87, 401, 398, 992], [2463, 464, 258, 593, 309, 194, 0, 397, 347, 368, 415, 328, 234, 519, 362, 501, 435, 417, 322, 356, 464, 484, 216, 309, 527, 906], [2440, 309, 285, 578, 336, 536, 430, 0, 374, 280, 400, 453, 261, 504, 389, 486, 462, 21, 221, 255, 420, 469, 470, 336, 627, 627], [2176, 402, 112, 573, 62, 271, 364, 377, 0, 349, 395, 113, 136, 499, 148, 482, 309, 398, 303, 337, 445, 464, 174, 217, 229, 819], [2399, 326, 183, 335, 234, 434, 328, 260, 272, 0, 157, 351, 159, 251, 287, 243, 360, 280, 86, 120, 186, 226, 367, 232, 481, 635], [2462, 389, 245, 247, 296, 496, 390, 322, 334, 131, 0, 413, 221, 173, 349, 156, 422, 343, 222, 256, 133, 138, 430, 296, 543, 770], [2106, 486, 175, 636, 125, 203, 327, 440, 128, 412, 458, 0, 199, 562, 210, 544, 394, 461, 366, 400, 508, 527, 107, 267, 283, 872], [2240, 293, 23, 437, 74, 334, 227, 241, 113, 212, 259, 192, 0, 363, 128, 345, 201, 262, 166, 200, 308, 328, 267, 74, 322, 754], [2455, 509, 365, 261, 416, 616, 510, 442, 454, 251, 169, 533, 341, 0, 469, 169, 542, 463, 342, 376, 182, 140, 549, 416, 663, 809], [2271, 414, 103, 564, 126, 461, 355, 368, 144, 340, 386, 222, 127, 490, 0, 473, 322, 389, 294, 328, 436, 455, 283, 196, 353, 881], [2514, 496, 352, 132, 403, 604, 498, 430, 442, 238, 157, 520, 329, 161, 456, 0, 529, 450, 330, 364, 240, 128, 536, 401, 650, 873], [2448, 181, 232, 672, 283, 568, 462, 390, 321, 444, 494, 400, 235, 598, 336, 580, 0, 411, 359, 393, 557, 563, 461, 159, 530, 762], [2420, 330, 306, 599, 356, 557, 451, 21, 395, 260, 421, 474, 282, 525, 410, 507, 483, 0, 242, 276, 440, 490, 490, 356, 607, 611], [2392, 242, 175, 417, 226, 427, 320, 175, 264, 106, 240, 343, 152, 320, 279, 326, 352, 195, 0, 34, 219, 308, 360, 226, 474, 684], [2416, 266, 200, 442, 250, 451, 345, 199, 289, 131, 264, 368, 176, 345, 304, 350, 377, 220, 24, 0, 244, 333, 384, 250, 498, 712], [2547, 448, 305, 348, 356, 556, 450, 381, 394, 143, 170, 473, 281, 153, 409, 256, 482, 402, 208, 241, 0, 292, 489, 353, 603, 738], [2576, 503, 359, 216, 410, 611, 504, 436, 448, 245, 164, 527, 336, 153, 463, 124, 536, 457, 337, 371, 247, 0, 544, 408, 658, 880], [2248, 533, 222, 656, 172, 96, 220, 461, 174, 432, 479, 113, 246, 583, 257, 565, 440, 481, 386, 420, 528, 548, 0, 312, 312, 906], [2291, 242, 74, 514, 125, 411, 305, 318, 164, 290, 336, 242, 77, 440, 179, 422, 150, 339, 264, 298, 386, 405, 304, 0, 373, 753], [2284, 505, 220, 681, 170, 379, 472, 485, 108, 457, 504, 222, 244, 607, 256, 590, 412, 506, 411, 445, 553, 572, 283, 318, 0, 731], [2369, 610, 729, 963, 780, 971, 881, 633, 705, 618, 779, 818, 712, 794, 833, 865, 722, 609, 672, 706, 729, 843, 875, 691, 714, 0]]}, "reference": {"optimum_s": 17376, "optimality": "best_found", "lower_bound_s": 14755, "floor_s": 13008, "solve_s": 37.14, "ffd_s": 19969, "stop_aware_best_s": 18909, "stop_aware_mean_s": 19389.4, "route_id": "RouteID_0809e036-d621-4169-a08b-8d4b78aa41ca", "plans": {"optimum": [{"route": ["S01", "S16", "S23", "S02", "S12", "S06", "S05", "S22", "S11"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S24", "S08", "S04", "S14"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S03", "S15", "S21", "S13", "S10", "S20", "S09", "S19", "S18", "S07", "S17", "S25"], "parcels": []}], "ffd": [{"route": ["S25", "S16", "S02", "S04", "S08"], "parcels": ["P04", "P09", "P25", "P26", "P47"]}, {"route": ["S03", "S15", "S21", "S20", "S09", "S01", "S16", "S04"], "parcels": ["P07", "P08", "P10", "P16", "P24", "P27", "P31", "P34"]}, {"route": ["S25", "S17", "S07", "S19", "S18", "S20", "S13", "S21", "S15", "S03", "S10", "S09", "S23", "S02", "S14", "S12", "S06", "S05", "S22", "S24", "S11"], "parcels": ["P03", "P05", "P06", "P15", "P17", "P23", "P32", "P33", "P35", "P44", "P45", "P46"]}], "stop_aware_best": [{"route": ["S25", "S17", "S21", "S15", "S13", "S10", "S12", "S02", "S14"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S11", "S22", "S05", "S06", "S19", "S18", "S20", "S23", "S04", "S08"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S03", "S09", "S07", "S01", "S16", "S24"], "parcels": []}]}}, "meta": {"route_id": "RouteID_0809e036-d621-4169-a08b-8d4b78aa41ca", "split": "train", "stops": 25, "vans": 3, "tightness": 0.86, "station": "DBO2", "city": "DBO", "date": "2018-08-17", "seconds": 98.3, "stop_aware_best_reward": 0.6028, "optimality": "best_found"}}
{"id": "633673ab-spread-n40-k4-t0.91-s0", "instance": {"stops": ["S01", "S02", "S03", "S04", "S05", "S06", "S07", "S08", "S09", "S10", "S11", "S12", "S13", "S14", "S15", "S16", "S17", "S18", "S19", "S20", "S21", "S22", "S23", "S24", "S25", "S26", "S27", "S28", "S29", "S30", "S31", "S32", "S33", "S34", "S35", "S36", "S37", "S38", "S39", "S40"], "parcels": [{"id": "P01", "stop": "S01", "volume_dl": 35}, {"id": "P02", "stop": "S02", "volume_dl": 179}, {"id": "P03", "stop": "S02", "volume_dl": 79}, {"id": "P04", "stop": "S03", "volume_dl": 5}, {"id": "P05", "stop": "S04", "volume_dl": 34}, {"id": "P06", "stop": "S05", "volume_dl": 21}, {"id": "P07", "stop": "S06", "volume_dl": 92}, {"id": "P08", "stop": "S06", "volume_dl": 63}, {"id": "P09", "stop": "S07", "volume_dl": 104}, {"id": "P10", "stop": "S07", "volume_dl": 463}, {"id": "P11", "stop": "S07", "volume_dl": 23}, {"id": "P12", "stop": "S08", "volume_dl": 9}, {"id": "P13", "stop": "S08", "volume_dl": 133}, {"id": "P14", "stop": "S09", "volume_dl": 59}, {"id": "P15", "stop": "S10", "volume_dl": 39}, {"id": "P16", "stop": "S11", "volume_dl": 1095}, {"id": "P17", "stop": "S11", "volume_dl": 63}, {"id": "P18", "stop": "S12", "volume_dl": 552}, {"id": "P19", "stop": "S13", "volume_dl": 57}, {"id": "P20", "stop": "S14", "volume_dl": 57}, {"id": "P21", "stop": "S14", "volume_dl": 34}, {"id": "P22", "stop": "S15", "volume_dl": 8}, {"id": "P23", "stop": "S16", "volume_dl": 134}, {"id": "P24", "stop": "S17", "volume_dl": 23}, {"id": "P25", "stop": "S18", "volume_dl": 63}, {"id": "P26", "stop": "S19", "volume_dl": 41}, {"id": "P27", "stop": "S20", "volume_dl": 79}, {"id": "P28", "stop": "S21", "volume_dl": 57}, {"id": "P29", "stop": "S22", "volume_dl": 79}, {"id": "P30", "stop": "S23", "volume_dl": 14}, {"id": "P31", "stop": "S24", "volume_dl": 39}, {"id": "P32", "stop": "S25", "volume_dl": 20}, {"id": "P33", "stop": "S25", "volume_dl": 59}, {"id": "P34", "stop": "S25", "volume_dl": 21}, {"id": "P35", "stop": "S25", "volume_dl": 92}, {"id": "P36", "stop": "S26", "volume_dl": 429}, {"id": "P37", "stop": "S26", "volume_dl": 57}, {"id": "P38", "stop": "S27", "volume_dl": 30}, {"id": "P39", "stop": "S28", "volume_dl": 3}, {"id": "P40", "stop": "S29", "volume_dl": 57}, {"id": "P41", "stop": "S30", "volume_dl": 34}, {"id": "P42", "stop": "S30", "volume_dl": 30}, {"id": "P43", "stop": "S30", "volume_dl": 28}, {"id": "P44", "stop": "S31", "volume_dl": 30}, {"id": "P45", "stop": "S32", "volume_dl": 16}, {"id": "P46", "stop": "S33", "volume_dl": 95}, {"id": "P47", "stop": "S34", "volume_dl": 2}, {"id": "P48", "stop": "S35", "volume_dl": 41}, {"id": "P49", "stop": "S36", "volume_dl": 553}, {"id": "P50", "stop": "S37", "volume_dl": 10}, {"id": "P51", "stop": "S38", "volume_dl": 55}, {"id": "P52", "stop": "S39", "volume_dl": 277}, {"id": "P53", "stop": "S40", "volume_dl": 133}, {"id": "P54", "stop": "S40", "volume_dl": 14}], "vans": 4, "capacity_dl": 1600, "travel_s": [[0, 2885, 2923, 2949, 2968, 2885, 3081, 3024, 2963, 2842, 3138, 2857, 2927, 2876, 2930, 2927, 2756, 3219, 2932, 2993, 3021, 2672, 3052, 3198, 2885, 2961, 2713, 3032, 2935, 2872, 2908, 2810, 2665, 3008, 2931, 3015, 3039, 2858, 2954, 3123, 2686], [3033, 0, 604, 64, 197, 71, 302, 158, 614, 640, 360, 518, 577, 279, 517, 435, 677, 371, 627, 173, 155, 842, 186, 350, 544, 627, 805, 145, 126, 484, 176, 615, 861, 169, 235, 475, 173, 142, 184, 338, 846], [2911, 535, 0, 490, 481, 516, 350, 452, 67, 100, 447, 225, 68, 645, 184, 253, 356, 391, 56, 524, 415, 325, 449, 370, 171, 43, 365, 414, 553, 244, 475, 98, 344, 418, 450, 198, 398, 652, 493, 449, 329], [3110, 62, 552, 0, 87, 89, 235, 109, 562, 587, 296, 466, 525, 313, 465, 383, 625, 322, 575, 88, 106, 790, 137, 301, 492, 570, 753, 78, 62, 432, 58, 563, 809, 103, 82, 423, 124, 218, 99, 282, 794], [3036, 125, 556, 81, 0, 170, 239, 166, 566, 592, 377, 470, 530, 267, 469, 387, 630, 358, 579, 92, 180, 794, 147, 337, 497, 579, 757, 82, 143, 436, 60, 567, 814, 107, 92, 427, 198, 195, 12, 362, 798], [3049, 67, 595, 131, 212, 0, 337, 182, 604, 630, 252, 508, 568, 294, 508, 425, 616, 362, 618, 221, 178, 832, 209, 341, 535, 617, 795, 240, 93, 474, 191, 605, 852, 264, 250, 465, 197, 158, 199, 238, 836], [3271, 290, 406, 279, 236, 295, 0, 230, 424, 450, 225, 328, 388, 400, 328, 245, 488, 181, 438, 302, 193, 652, 227, 160, 355, 432, 618, 169, 338, 294, 225, 425, 672, 173, 205, 285, 176, 464, 248, 227, 656], [3180, 146, 471, 99, 167, 214, 236, 0, 489, 515, 207, 393, 453, 368, 392, 310, 553, 246, 502, 106, 69, 717, 27, 226, 420, 497, 680, 125, 141, 359, 161, 490, 737, 95, 136, 350, 88, 288, 179, 180, 721], [2971, 565, 68, 521, 512, 547, 389, 482, 0, 176, 477, 224, 57, 675, 217, 253, 334, 422, 88, 554, 445, 384, 479, 401, 171, 99, 425, 445, 583, 243, 505, 158, 404, 449, 480, 228, 428, 682, 523, 479, 388], [2835, 576, 105, 532, 523, 558, 400, 493, 181, 0, 488, 267, 174, 686, 226, 304, 280, 432, 145, 565, 456, 249, 490, 412, 222, 148, 286, 456, 594, 311, 511, 34, 268, 460, 491, 239, 439, 693, 534, 490, 252], [3248, 284, 455, 222, 310, 238, 197, 192, 464, 490, 0, 368, 428, 497, 368, 285, 528, 222, 478, 298, 170, 692, 189, 201, 395, 473, 655, 300, 237, 334, 280, 465, 712, 230, 298, 325, 153, 396, 321, 90, 696], [2927, 495, 197, 451, 441, 476, 319, 412, 224, 251, 407, 0, 229, 605, 144, 97, 169, 351, 168, 484, 375, 314, 409, 330, 74, 206, 290, 374, 513, 88, 435, 284, 334, 378, 410, 203, 358, 612, 453, 409, 310], [2938, 533, 74, 489, 479, 514, 357, 450, 42, 150, 445, 224, 0, 643, 183, 261, 383, 389, 96, 522, 413, 352, 447, 368, 179, 96, 390, 412, 551, 252, 468, 125, 372, 416, 448, 196, 396, 650, 491, 447, 356], [3025, 287, 708, 317, 278, 287, 391, 376, 718, 744, 540, 622, 682, 0, 621, 539, 782, 510, 731, 303, 412, 946, 358, 489, 649, 731, 909, 342, 380, 588, 297, 719, 966, 346, 241, 579, 431, 160, 264, 525, 950], [3005, 458, 172, 413, 404, 439, 282, 375, 190, 215, 370, 127, 153, 568, 0, 155, 288, 314, 177, 447, 338, 392, 372, 293, 49, 211, 376, 337, 476, 146, 393, 191, 412, 341, 373, 68, 321, 575, 416, 372, 396], [3013, 398, 263, 354, 344, 380, 222, 315, 272, 298, 310, 83, 236, 508, 176, 0, 242, 254, 211, 387, 278, 400, 312, 233, 116, 281, 370, 277, 416, 49, 333, 274, 420, 281, 313, 133, 261, 515, 356, 312, 404], [2876, 627, 301, 582, 573, 608, 450, 544, 320, 272, 538, 174, 324, 736, 262, 229, 0, 483, 264, 616, 506, 263, 541, 462, 248, 297, 149, 506, 645, 174, 562, 240, 214, 510, 542, 330, 490, 744, 585, 547, 267], [3223, 359, 399, 296, 340, 311, 154, 247, 409, 434, 242, 313, 372, 504, 312, 230, 472, 0, 422, 319, 210, 637, 244, 21, 339, 417, 600, 273, 354, 279, 329, 410, 656, 287, 309, 270, 193, 481, 352, 244, 640], [2963, 558, 62, 513, 504, 539, 382, 475, 87, 155, 470, 179, 91, 668, 180, 216, 297, 414, 0, 547, 438, 377, 472, 393, 134, 33, 414, 437, 576, 206, 493, 150, 396, 441, 473, 221, 421, 675, 516, 472, 381], [3126, 147, 507, 125, 90, 187, 189, 112, 516, 542, 308, 420, 480, 290, 420, 337, 580, 308, 530, 0, 109, 744, 97, 287, 447, 529, 707, 32, 167, 386, 78, 517, 764, 57, 58, 377, 128, 260, 101, 275, 748], [3152, 149, 449, 102, 190, 217, 192, 56, 459, 485, 186, 363, 422, 428, 362, 280, 522, 216, 472, 109, 0, 687, 83, 195, 390, 472, 650, 128, 144, 329, 160, 460, 706, 151, 167, 320, 18, 291, 201, 157, 691], [2758, 756, 326, 711, 702, 737, 579, 672, 367, 246, 667, 306, 330, 865, 405, 376, 264, 612, 379, 745, 635, 0, 670, 591, 334, 369, 186, 635, 774, 321, 691, 214, 66, 639, 671, 419, 618, 873, 714, 670, 40], [3198, 164, 488, 118, 140, 233, 209, 18, 497, 523, 215, 401, 461, 340, 401, 318, 561, 254, 511, 124, 88, 725, 0, 234, 428, 506, 688, 73, 160, 367, 129, 498, 745, 77, 108, 358, 106, 307, 152, 195, 729], [3202, 338, 378, 275, 319, 291, 133, 226, 388, 414, 221, 292, 352, 483, 291, 209, 452, 21, 401, 298, 189, 616, 223, 0, 319, 401, 579, 252, 333, 258, 308, 389, 636, 266, 288, 249, 172, 460, 331, 223, 620], [2963, 483, 165, 438, 429, 464, 306, 400, 184, 210, 395, 69, 173, 592, 62, 106, 238, 339, 128, 472, 363, 350, 397, 318, 0, 161, 356, 362, 501, 96, 418, 210, 370, 366, 398, 129, 346, 600, 441, 397, 354], [2944, 563, 33, 523, 514, 544, 386, 484, 106, 128, 474, 211, 96, 672, 204, 234, 320, 419, 19, 556, 442, 353, 482, 403, 152, 0, 390, 442, 586, 225, 498, 131, 377, 451, 482, 226, 426, 685, 521, 481, 362], [2854, 806, 386, 762, 753, 788, 633, 723, 418, 297, 718, 301, 381, 916, 456, 407, 150, 663, 430, 796, 686, 174, 720, 642, 384, 423, 0, 686, 824, 324, 746, 265, 167, 690, 722, 470, 669, 924, 764, 697, 188], [3103, 121, 474, 76, 67, 165, 157, 83, 484, 510, 276, 388, 447, 267, 387, 305, 547, 276, 497, 107, 153, 712, 65, 255, 414, 497, 675, 0, 139, 354, 56, 485, 731, 25, 36, 345, 171, 238, 79, 243, 716], [3108, 126, 576, 68, 155, 73, 345, 130, 586, 612, 280, 490, 549, 354, 489, 407, 644, 343, 599, 170, 127, 814, 158, 322, 516, 594, 777, 188, 0, 456, 126, 587, 833, 213, 150, 447, 145, 217, 167, 266, 818], [2964, 453, 225, 408, 399, 434, 276, 370, 243, 270, 364, 59, 248, 562, 155, 55, 229, 309, 187, 442, 332, 351, 367, 288, 93, 216, 346, 332, 471, 0, 388, 303, 371, 336, 368, 188, 316, 570, 411, 367, 355], [3070, 94, 544, 50, 95, 138, 226, 152, 553, 579, 346, 457, 517, 308, 457, 374, 617, 345, 567, 80, 149, 781, 134, 324, 484, 558, 744, 69, 112, 423, 0, 554, 801, 94, 132, 414, 167, 177, 81, 331, 785], [2813, 542, 112, 497, 488, 523, 365, 458, 153, 24, 454, 274, 116, 651, 191, 328, 258, 398, 170, 531, 422, 227, 456, 377, 218, 155, 264, 421, 560, 289, 477, 0, 246, 425, 457, 205, 404, 659, 500, 456, 231], [2798, 764, 335, 720, 711, 746, 588, 681, 376, 254, 676, 298, 339, 874, 414, 368, 237, 620, 388, 753, 644, 66, 678, 600, 326, 378, 158, 644, 782, 313, 700, 223, 0, 648, 679, 427, 627, 882, 722, 678, 79], [3139, 156, 470, 112, 103, 201, 152, 85, 479, 505, 251, 383, 443, 303, 382, 300, 543, 271, 492, 192, 155, 707, 70, 250, 410, 492, 670, 36, 175, 349, 92, 480, 727, 0, 72, 340, 173, 274, 115, 218, 711], [3093, 120, 526, 76, 66, 164, 208, 135, 535, 561, 372, 439, 499, 232, 439, 356, 599, 327, 549, 62, 171, 763, 116, 306, 466, 548, 726, 51, 138, 405, 55, 536, 783, 76, 0, 396, 189, 234, 78, 294, 767], [3013, 416, 189, 372, 362, 398, 240, 333, 198, 224, 328, 198, 162, 526, 82, 160, 367, 272, 212, 405, 296, 426, 330, 251, 129, 211, 464, 295, 434, 209, 351, 199, 446, 300, 331, 0, 279, 533, 374, 330, 430], [3134, 166, 431, 119, 207, 158, 173, 72, 441, 466, 168, 344, 404, 461, 344, 262, 504, 198, 454, 126, 17, 668, 100, 177, 371, 449, 632, 145, 161, 310, 177, 442, 688, 168, 184, 301, 0, 328, 218, 138, 672], [3013, 163, 758, 214, 190, 163, 374, 302, 768, 793, 416, 671, 731, 187, 671, 588, 779, 525, 781, 244, 299, 995, 298, 504, 698, 780, 958, 234, 213, 637, 168, 768, 1015, 258, 227, 628, 317, 0, 176, 401, 999], [3025, 138, 570, 94, 13, 183, 252, 179, 580, 605, 390, 483, 543, 255, 483, 400, 643, 371, 593, 106, 193, 807, 160, 350, 510, 592, 770, 96, 156, 449, 74, 580, 827, 120, 80, 440, 212, 184, 0, 376, 811], [3226, 277, 455, 215, 302, 231, 197, 179, 465, 490, 80, 368, 428, 497, 368, 286, 528, 222, 478, 285, 148, 692, 184, 201, 395, 473, 656, 243, 230, 334, 273, 466, 712, 207, 279, 325, 131, 420, 314, 0, 696], [2762, 759, 330, 715, 706, 741, 583, 676, 371, 250, 671, 301, 334, 869, 409, 379, 278, 616, 383, 748, 639, 60, 674, 595, 338, 368, 202, 639, 778, 325, 699, 218, 79, 643, 674, 422, 622, 877, 718, 673, 0]]}, "reference": {"optimum_s": 26404, "optimality": "best_found", "lower_bound_s": 23655, "floor_s": 21692, "solve_s": 65.22, "ffd_s": 29192, "stop_aware_best_s": 28469, "stop_aware_mean_s": 28838.4, "route_id": "RouteID_633673ab-92da-4233-ad75-b5a4ed3228b6", "plans": {"optimum": [{"route": ["S01", "S03", "S30", "S19", "S27", "S33", "S39", "S10", "S06", "S23", "S17", "S15", "S29", "S26", "S32", "S21", "S40"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S24", "S14", "S35", "S12", "S08", "S18", "S25", "S02", "S09", "S31"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S16", "S11"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S13", "S37", "S05", "S28", "S20", "S36", "S07", "S22", "S34", "S04", "S38"], "parcels": []}], "ffd": [{"route": ["S19", "S07", "S11"], "parcels": ["P10", "P16"]}, {"route": ["S28", "S36", "S06", "S12", "S26"], "parcels": ["P08", "P36"]}, {"route": ["S16", "S11", "S06", "S34", "S33", "S22", "S07", "S20", "S39", "S08", "S25", "S02", "S09", "S40"], "parcels": ["P07", "P09", "P13", "P17", "P35", "P53"]}, {"route": ["S13", "S37", "S05", "S01", "S03", "S30", "S38", "S04", "S27", "S07", "S10", "S23", "S17", "S15", "S29", "S24", "S14", "S35", "S08", "S18", "S25", "S31", "S26", "S32", "S21", "S40"], "parcels": ["P11", "P12", "P32", "P33", "P34", "P37", "P54"]}], "stop_aware_best": [{"route": ["S16", "S11", "S18", "S10", "S28"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S13", "S38", "S27", "S33", "S39", "S06", "S15", "S29", "S24", "S14", "S35", "S25", "S02", "S09"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S26", "S32", "S21", "S40", "S31", "S17", "S20", "S07", "S22", "S34", "S05", "S37"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S01", "S03", "S04", "S30", "S19", "S36", "S23", "S12", "S08"], "parcels": []}]}}, "meta": {"route_id": "RouteID_633673ab-92da-4233-ad75-b5a4ed3228b6", "split": "train", "stops": 40, "vans": 4, "tightness": 0.91, "station": "DBO3", "city": "DBO", "date": "2018-08-07", "seconds": 126.1, "stop_aware_best_reward": 0.5391, "optimality": "best_found"}}
{"id": "ee1fad58-spread-n30-k4-t0.92-s0", "instance": {"stops": ["S01", "S02", "S03", "S04", "S05", "S06", "S07", "S08", "S09", "S10", "S11", "S12", "S13", "S14", "S15", "S16", "S17", "S18", "S19", "S20", "S21", "S22", "S23", "S24", "S25", "S26", "S27", "S28", "S29", "S30"], "parcels": [{"id": "P01", "stop": "S01", "volume_dl": 34}, {"id": "P02", "stop": "S01", "volume_dl": 57}, {"id": "P03", "stop": "S01", "volume_dl": 40}, {"id": "P04", "stop": "S02", "volume_dl": 37}, {"id": "P05", "stop": "S03", "volume_dl": 3}, {"id": "P06", "stop": "S04", "volume_dl": 95}, {"id": "P07", "stop": "S05", "volume_dl": 63}, {"id": "P08", "stop": "S06", "volume_dl": 15}, {"id": "P09", "stop": "S07", "volume_dl": 47}, {"id": "P10", "stop": "S08", "volume_dl": 133}, {"id": "P11", "stop": "S08", "volume_dl": 23}, {"id": "P12", "stop": "S08", "volume_dl": 104}, {"id": "P13", "stop": "S08", "volume_dl": 28}, {"id": "P14", "stop": "S08", "volume_dl": 11}, {"id": "P15", "stop": "S09", "volume_dl": 552}, {"id": "P16", "stop": "S10", "volume_dl": 30}, {"id": "P17", "stop": "S10", "volume_dl": 27}, {"id": "P18", "stop": "S11", "volume_dl": 179}, {"id": "P19", "stop": "S12", "volume_dl": 29}, {"id": "P20", "stop": "S13", "volume_dl": 26}, {"id": "P21", "stop": "S14", "volume_dl": 34}, {"id": "P22", "stop": "S15", "volume_dl": 57}, {"id": "P23", "stop": "S16", "volume_dl": 47}, {"id": "P24", "stop": "S17", "volume_dl": 7}, {"id": "P25", "stop": "S17", "volume_dl": 11}, {"id": "P26", "stop": "S18", "volume_dl": 30}, {"id": "P27", "stop": "S19", "volume_dl": 29}, {"id": "P28", "stop": "S20", "volume_dl": 92}, {"id": "P29", "stop": "S21", "volume_dl": 322}, {"id": "P30", "stop": "S21", "volume_dl": 7}, {"id": "P31", "stop": "S22", "volume_dl": 63}, {"id": "P32", "stop": "S23", "volume_dl": 329}, {"id": "P33", "stop": "S24", "volume_dl": 9}, {"id": "P34", "stop": "S25", "volume_dl": 133}, {"id": "P35", "stop": "S25", "volume_dl": 34}, {"id": "P36", "stop": "S26", "volume_dl": 12}, {"id": "P37", "stop": "S26", "volume_dl": 53}, {"id": "P38", "stop": "S27", "volume_dl": 133}, {"id": "P39", "stop": "S28", "volume_dl": 429}, {"id": "P40", "stop": "S29", "volume_dl": 95}, {"id": "P41", "stop": "S30", "volume_dl": 95}], "vans": 4, "capacity_dl": 966, "travel_s": [[0, 778, 779, 807, 967, 870, 884, 920, 934, 870, 775, 941, 829, 850, 775, 803, 763, 838, 798, 847, 866, 691, 928, 968, 898, 1001, 916, 812, 874, 822, 1142], [940, 0, 362, 396, 240, 269, 301, 251, 293, 298, 168, 268, 114, 260, 200, 311, 570, 267, 193, 269, 88, 446, 182, 231, 251, 274, 361, 321, 224, 267, 415], [890, 386, 0, 56, 335, 288, 174, 211, 204, 370, 443, 250, 279, 384, 380, 124, 272, 378, 464, 403, 474, 221, 370, 435, 219, 540, 224, 133, 310, 443, 482], [917, 418, 67, 0, 392, 314, 224, 268, 231, 396, 470, 307, 306, 411, 407, 151, 299, 405, 491, 430, 506, 248, 413, 462, 246, 597, 281, 160, 337, 470, 527], [1189, 256, 328, 363, 0, 303, 321, 245, 269, 385, 414, 149, 202, 347, 351, 318, 510, 354, 435, 356, 344, 397, 165, 221, 216, 368, 237, 327, 326, 396, 337], [1055, 272, 280, 309, 345, 0, 268, 220, 163, 141, 291, 260, 172, 156, 189, 191, 380, 137, 314, 196, 360, 256, 279, 328, 127, 475, 370, 201, 191, 217, 430], [1005, 299, 162, 196, 303, 278, 0, 124, 194, 360, 433, 202, 244, 374, 370, 169, 361, 368, 454, 393, 387, 248, 283, 341, 209, 481, 225, 164, 300, 433, 395], [1035, 255, 192, 227, 259, 215, 132, 0, 113, 297, 370, 172, 206, 311, 307, 159, 392, 305, 391, 330, 343, 279, 239, 297, 146, 438, 228, 195, 237, 370, 351], [1011, 311, 221, 250, 302, 177, 208, 143, 0, 240, 360, 265, 199, 267, 296, 132, 342, 244, 384, 302, 399, 218, 306, 355, 139, 500, 321, 141, 230, 324, 420], [1074, 323, 369, 398, 364, 134, 357, 311, 234, 0, 310, 345, 191, 85, 208, 280, 414, 156, 333, 130, 411, 290, 298, 347, 214, 494, 434, 290, 255, 203, 515], [924, 185, 440, 469, 374, 281, 428, 381, 329, 281, 0, 403, 218, 261, 186, 351, 571, 250, 21, 259, 271, 450, 325, 374, 287, 406, 496, 361, 264, 234, 550], [1075, 259, 243, 278, 129, 252, 236, 160, 243, 334, 405, 0, 192, 338, 342, 233, 425, 344, 425, 346, 347, 312, 151, 210, 166, 353, 153, 242, 275, 386, 266], [998, 132, 304, 339, 173, 160, 244, 194, 174, 184, 213, 201, 0, 146, 150, 202, 451, 152, 234, 154, 220, 327, 107, 156, 138, 302, 290, 212, 114, 194, 363], [1038, 268, 377, 406, 309, 159, 365, 330, 260, 95, 273, 338, 136, 0, 172, 288, 458, 114, 296, 45, 357, 334, 244, 292, 224, 439, 426, 298, 200, 118, 499], [946, 203, 392, 420, 353, 195, 379, 332, 275, 195, 182, 382, 180, 175, 0, 302, 484, 164, 205, 172, 291, 360, 288, 336, 239, 426, 470, 312, 215, 116, 586], [929, 297, 139, 168, 288, 194, 138, 147, 110, 276, 349, 237, 185, 290, 286, 0, 299, 284, 370, 309, 385, 175, 292, 341, 125, 488, 229, 10, 216, 349, 406], [870, 535, 256, 285, 492, 359, 349, 385, 324, 422, 579, 406, 423, 449, 477, 268, 0, 425, 602, 484, 624, 255, 513, 572, 352, 696, 381, 278, 455, 506, 628], [1046, 294, 381, 410, 335, 139, 368, 325, 257, 139, 281, 360, 162, 86, 180, 292, 428, 0, 304, 131, 383, 304, 270, 318, 228, 465, 448, 301, 226, 204, 530], [937, 216, 471, 500, 405, 294, 458, 411, 354, 294, 31, 434, 248, 274, 199, 382, 584, 263, 0, 272, 302, 460, 356, 404, 318, 439, 522, 391, 294, 247, 580], [1042, 298, 414, 443, 347, 206, 402, 368, 298, 148, 277, 375, 174, 53, 175, 325, 496, 167, 300, 0, 386, 372, 281, 330, 261, 476, 464, 335, 238, 107, 536], [1016, 93, 455, 489, 333, 345, 394, 344, 360, 391, 248, 361, 208, 353, 276, 387, 637, 360, 269, 362, 0, 513, 275, 324, 324, 367, 450, 397, 300, 343, 508], [808, 406, 228, 257, 411, 256, 268, 318, 230, 319, 403, 326, 358, 347, 375, 188, 274, 323, 426, 381, 494, 0, 465, 514, 249, 635, 305, 197, 379, 403, 550], [1120, 194, 350, 385, 142, 281, 290, 240, 296, 305, 334, 171, 122, 267, 271, 340, 532, 274, 355, 276, 282, 419, 0, 180, 238, 326, 259, 349, 236, 316, 359], [1159, 232, 438, 473, 216, 320, 364, 315, 334, 344, 373, 244, 160, 306, 310, 362, 620, 312, 394, 315, 321, 507, 189, 0, 324, 218, 346, 372, 274, 355, 279], [1012, 246, 222, 251, 235, 139, 200, 150, 106, 202, 298, 184, 134, 229, 257, 133, 352, 205, 319, 263, 334, 228, 241, 290, 0, 441, 273, 143, 165, 285, 354], [1193, 276, 541, 575, 356, 461, 534, 456, 482, 485, 422, 385, 301, 447, 451, 530, 723, 451, 446, 456, 366, 609, 330, 233, 426, 0, 481, 540, 415, 496, 381], [1060, 361, 228, 263, 229, 351, 222, 227, 322, 434, 500, 144, 291, 437, 441, 218, 410, 443, 525, 446, 446, 297, 250, 309, 265, 440, 0, 228, 374, 486, 356], [940, 308, 173, 208, 299, 205, 149, 158, 121, 287, 360, 248, 196, 302, 297, 11, 310, 295, 381, 320, 396, 186, 303, 352, 136, 499, 236, 0, 228, 360, 417], [1072, 235, 311, 340, 295, 179, 298, 251, 194, 220, 287, 291, 122, 235, 224, 222, 471, 229, 308, 247, 323, 347, 230, 278, 158, 425, 401, 231, 0, 309, 461], [1009, 266, 438, 467, 370, 212, 426, 392, 321, 204, 245, 399, 198, 109, 125, 349, 502, 181, 268, 110, 354, 378, 305, 354, 285, 489, 487, 359, 262, 0, 603], [1193, 460, 407, 442, 317, 422, 400, 354, 388, 504, 578, 377, 380, 531, 514, 397, 589, 508, 598, 534, 548, 476, 339, 289, 336, 357, 351, 406, 445, 588, 0]]}, "reference": {"optimum_s": 10893, "optimality": "best_found", "lower_bound_s": 8775, "floor_s": 5996, "solve_s": 51.18, "ffd_s": 13404, "stop_aware_best_s": 12184, "stop_aware_mean_s": 12424, "route_id": "RouteID_ee1fad58-4e9a-4363-9225-4542363ff9f2", "plans": {"optimum": [{"route": ["S20", "S01", "S25", "S23", "S30", "S07", "S06", "S02", "S03"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S28", "S12", "S22", "S04", "S11", "S26", "S16"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S27", "S15", "S24", "S08", "S21"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S17", "S05", "S09", "S13", "S19", "S29", "S14", "S10", "S18"], "parcels": []}], "ffd": [{"route": ["S17", "S09", "S05", "S23", "S06"], "parcels": ["P24"]}, {"route": ["S01", "S28", "S11", "S21"], "parcels": ["P01", "P29"]}, {"route": ["S29", "S20", "S25", "S30", "S22", "S04", "S08", "S27"], "parcels": ["P10", "P11", "P12", "P34"]}, {"route": ["S16", "S03", "S02", "S26", "S25", "S01", "S10", "S18", "S14", "S17", "S13", "S19", "S12", "S24", "S07", "S08", "S15", "S21"], "parcels": ["P02", "P03", "P13", "P14", "P25", "P30", "P35"]}], "stop_aware_best": [{"route": ["S14", "S28", "S21", "S16"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S01", "S22", "S23", "S12", "S29", "S13", "S05", "S24", "S27", "S15"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S20", "S25", "S30", "S04", "S26", "S07", "S08", "S17", "S19"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S10", "S18", "S09", "S11", "S06", "S02", "S03"], "parcels": []}]}}, "meta": {"route_id": "RouteID_ee1fad58-4e9a-4363-9225-4542363ff9f2", "split": "train", "stops": 30, "vans": 4, "tightness": 0.92, "station": "DLA5", "city": "DLA", "date": "2018-08-16", "seconds": 103.9, "stop_aware_best_reward": 0.6772, "optimality": "best_found"}}
{"id": "c88494db-spread-n40-k4-t0.92-s0", "instance": {"stops": ["S01", "S02", "S03", "S04", "S05", "S06", "S07", "S08", "S09", "S10", "S11", "S12", "S13", "S14", "S15", "S16", "S17", "S18", "S19", "S20", "S21", "S22", "S23", "S24", "S25", "S26", "S27", "S28", "S29", "S30", "S31", "S32", "S33", "S34", "S35", "S36", "S37", "S38", "S39", "S40"], "parcels": [{"id": "P01", "stop": "S01", "volume_dl": 4}, {"id": "P02", "stop": "S02", "volume_dl": 133}, {"id": "P03", "stop": "S03", "volume_dl": 59}, {"id": "P04", "stop": "S04", "volume_dl": 157}, {"id": "P05", "stop": "S04", "volume_dl": 29}, {"id": "P06", "stop": "S04", "volume_dl": 309}, {"id": "P07", "stop": "S05", "volume_dl": 27}, {"id": "P08", "stop": "S05", "volume_dl": 36}, {"id": "P09", "stop": "S06", "volume_dl": 40}, {"id": "P10", "stop": "S07", "volume_dl": 53}, {"id": "P11", "stop": "S07", "volume_dl": 59}, {"id": "P12", "stop": "S07", "volume_dl": 13}, {"id": "P13", "stop": "S07", "volume_dl": 26}, {"id": "P14", "stop": "S08", "volume_dl": 63}, {"id": "P15", "stop": "S09", "volume_dl": 55}, {"id": "P16", "stop": "S10", "volume_dl": 34}, {"id": "P17", "stop": "S11", "volume_dl": 60}, {"id": "P18", "stop": "S12", "volume_dl": 21}, {"id": "P19", "stop": "S13", "volume_dl": 133}, {"id": "P20", "stop": "S13", "volume_dl": 259}, {"id": "P21", "stop": "S13", "volume_dl": 134}, {"id": "P22", "stop": "S13", "volume_dl": 63}, {"id": "P23", "stop": "S13", "volume_dl": 179}, {"id": "P24", "stop": "S13", "volume_dl": 259}, {"id": "P25", "stop": "S13", "volume_dl": 259}, {"id": "P26", "stop": "S14", "volume_dl": 20}, {"id": "P27", "stop": "S15", "volume_dl": 133}, {"id": "P28", "stop": "S16", "volume_dl": 40}, {"id": "P29", "stop": "S17", "volume_dl": 157}, {"id": "P30", "stop": "S18", "volume_dl": 179}, {"id": "P31", "stop": "S18", "volume_dl": 157}, {"id": "P32", "stop": "S19", "volume_dl": 53}, {"id": "P33", "stop": "S20", "volume_dl": 259}, {"id": "P34", "stop": "S21", "volume_dl": 34}, {"id": "P35", "stop": "S22", "volume_dl": 13}, {"id": "P36", "stop": "S23", "volume_dl": 36}, {"id": "P37", "stop": "S23", "volume_dl": 42}, {"id": "P38", "stop": "S24", "volume_dl": 35}, {"id": "P39", "stop": "S25", "volume_dl": 242}, {"id": "P40", "stop": "S26", "volume_dl": 104}, {"id": "P41", "stop": "S27", "volume_dl": 133}, {"id": "P42", "stop": "S27", "volume_dl": 3}, {"id": "P43", "stop": "S28", "volume_dl": 30}, {"id": "P44", "stop": "S29", "volume_dl": 34}, {"id": "P45", "stop": "S30", "volume_dl": 79}, {"id": "P46", "stop": "S31", "volume_dl": 57}, {"id": "P47", "stop": "S31", "volume_dl": 13}, {"id": "P48", "stop": "S32", "volume_dl": 133}, {"id": "P49", "stop": "S33", "volume_dl": 19}, {"id": "P50", "stop": "S34", "volume_dl": 381}, {"id": "P51", "stop": "S35", "volume_dl": 34}, {"id": "P52", "stop": "S35", "volume_dl": 57}, {"id": "P53", "stop": "S36", "volume_dl": 5}, {"id": "P54", "stop": "S37", "volume_dl": 13}, {"id": "P55", "stop": "S38", "volume_dl": 23}, {"id": "P56", "stop": "S39", "volume_dl": 90}, {"id": "P57", "stop": "S40", "volume_dl": 133}], "vans": 4, "capacity_dl": 1416, "travel_s": [[0, 1907, 1832, 1763, 1729, 1864, 1804, 1756, 1794, 1803, 1792, 1682, 1783, 1786, 1699, 1849, 1979, 1785, 1833, 1926, 1863, 1860, 1783, 1902, 1839, 1847, 1892, 1763, 1916, 1728, 1659, 1972, 1816, 1856, 1940, 1792, 1908, 1805, 1674, 1674, 1755], [2019, 0, 321, 268, 301, 355, 415, 472, 161, 261, 402, 422, 270, 247, 377, 282, 234, 502, 191, 215, 159, 288, 546, 198, 301, 275, 280, 252, 280, 320, 306, 240, 244, 230, 184, 251, 203, 265, 306, 390, 366], [1893, 328, 0, 119, 242, 44, 240, 302, 194, 159, 227, 296, 210, 243, 216, 225, 400, 332, 189, 381, 219, 292, 420, 258, 296, 279, 276, 114, 292, 105, 224, 406, 172, 226, 350, 173, 263, 187, 238, 243, 191], [1899, 234, 125, 0, 268, 159, 247, 309, 130, 64, 234, 303, 236, 177, 223, 117, 306, 339, 95, 286, 125, 226, 427, 164, 231, 213, 210, 140, 184, 91, 273, 312, 78, 160, 256, 199, 169, 213, 245, 250, 198], [1805, 315, 217, 247, 0, 257, 307, 258, 179, 286, 294, 209, 93, 250, 164, 364, 387, 288, 269, 368, 237, 293, 333, 276, 298, 280, 277, 149, 358, 287, 93, 393, 300, 227, 337, 177, 281, 191, 93, 177, 258], [1936, 351, 53, 143, 275, 0, 283, 346, 227, 182, 270, 340, 244, 272, 260, 260, 424, 376, 217, 404, 243, 315, 464, 282, 320, 302, 299, 147, 301, 148, 268, 422, 196, 249, 374, 209, 287, 221, 282, 286, 234], [1930, 414, 293, 206, 331, 306, 0, 340, 268, 245, 121, 333, 354, 315, 254, 291, 486, 370, 276, 467, 306, 364, 492, 345, 369, 351, 348, 296, 358, 171, 262, 492, 259, 298, 437, 337, 350, 351, 276, 280, 154], [1890, 489, 368, 281, 291, 387, 322, 0, 344, 320, 309, 293, 313, 396, 229, 366, 562, 82, 351, 542, 381, 439, 418, 420, 444, 426, 423, 325, 434, 246, 221, 560, 334, 374, 512, 353, 425, 367, 235, 133, 273], [1904, 153, 206, 184, 187, 240, 301, 357, 0, 177, 288, 308, 156, 133, 263, 199, 226, 387, 108, 206, 76, 182, 432, 114, 186, 168, 166, 138, 197, 206, 192, 231, 160, 116, 176, 136, 120, 150, 192, 276, 252], [1934, 226, 160, 89, 302, 194, 281, 343, 164, 0, 268, 337, 270, 211, 257, 179, 298, 373, 88, 279, 118, 260, 462, 156, 265, 247, 244, 174, 176, 179, 307, 304, 71, 194, 248, 233, 162, 247, 279, 284, 232], [1967, 451, 329, 242, 368, 343, 149, 376, 305, 282, 0, 370, 390, 352, 290, 328, 523, 406, 312, 504, 342, 401, 507, 381, 406, 388, 385, 333, 395, 207, 298, 529, 296, 335, 473, 374, 387, 388, 312, 317, 43], [1803, 427, 330, 261, 227, 362, 302, 253, 292, 300, 289, 0, 249, 371, 197, 346, 499, 283, 331, 480, 361, 419, 190, 400, 424, 406, 404, 261, 414, 226, 157, 505, 314, 354, 450, 289, 405, 303, 171, 172, 253], [1845, 283, 186, 216, 93, 220, 351, 298, 148, 255, 338, 248, 0, 213, 204, 333, 356, 328, 238, 336, 206, 262, 373, 244, 267, 249, 246, 117, 327, 256, 133, 361, 269, 196, 306, 146, 250, 159, 133, 217, 302], [1938, 268, 214, 168, 221, 247, 317, 379, 132, 208, 304, 342, 189, 0, 293, 285, 298, 409, 238, 216, 190, 150, 466, 229, 48, 136, 158, 172, 311, 222, 226, 262, 221, 109, 230, 170, 234, 184, 226, 310, 268], [1792, 390, 293, 206, 189, 326, 248, 214, 255, 246, 235, 195, 212, 320, 0, 292, 462, 244, 276, 443, 312, 368, 320, 351, 373, 355, 352, 224, 433, 171, 123, 468, 260, 303, 412, 252, 356, 266, 134, 142, 198], [2008, 267, 233, 107, 367, 263, 355, 418, 237, 172, 342, 411, 335, 284, 332, 0, 339, 448, 117, 320, 158, 333, 536, 197, 338, 320, 317, 247, 156, 127, 340, 345, 185, 267, 289, 306, 203, 320, 354, 358, 306], [2034, 204, 336, 283, 317, 370, 431, 487, 177, 277, 418, 438, 285, 263, 393, 298, 0, 517, 207, 138, 175, 211, 562, 214, 316, 198, 243, 268, 296, 336, 322, 163, 260, 246, 63, 266, 219, 280, 322, 406, 382], [1909, 509, 387, 301, 310, 401, 342, 92, 363, 340, 329, 313, 333, 410, 249, 386, 581, 0, 370, 562, 401, 459, 437, 439, 464, 446, 443, 345, 453, 265, 241, 587, 354, 393, 532, 373, 445, 387, 255, 152, 293], [1967, 149, 199, 136, 249, 233, 320, 420, 109, 122, 308, 370, 218, 201, 325, 91, 222, 450, 0, 202, 41, 244, 495, 80, 249, 231, 228, 214, 88, 155, 254, 227, 105, 178, 172, 201, 85, 213, 254, 338, 271], [2044, 214, 347, 293, 327, 381, 441, 498, 187, 287, 428, 448, 296, 249, 403, 308, 141, 527, 217, 0, 185, 159, 572, 224, 302, 146, 190, 278, 306, 346, 332, 105, 270, 221, 73, 277, 229, 291, 332, 416, 392], [1949, 132, 228, 157, 232, 262, 345, 402, 91, 150, 332, 352, 200, 177, 308, 172, 204, 432, 80, 184, 0, 226, 477, 39, 231, 213, 210, 182, 121, 247, 237, 210, 133, 160, 154, 181, 44, 195, 236, 321, 296], [2003, 322, 278, 233, 286, 312, 381, 444, 197, 272, 368, 406, 254, 163, 358, 350, 249, 474, 325, 168, 293, 0, 531, 332, 216, 16, 76, 236, 414, 286, 290, 213, 286, 106, 181, 235, 337, 249, 290, 374, 332], [1905, 554, 457, 388, 354, 489, 430, 380, 419, 428, 416, 175, 377, 498, 324, 474, 627, 410, 458, 607, 488, 547, 0, 527, 552, 534, 531, 388, 541, 353, 284, 632, 442, 481, 577, 416, 532, 430, 299, 299, 380], [1988, 170, 266, 195, 270, 306, 384, 440, 130, 189, 371, 391, 239, 222, 346, 169, 242, 470, 102, 223, 38, 265, 515, 0, 270, 252, 249, 221, 82, 233, 275, 248, 172, 199, 193, 220, 34, 234, 275, 359, 335], [1974, 303, 249, 204, 256, 283, 352, 415, 168, 243, 339, 377, 225, 41, 329, 321, 333, 445, 274, 252, 225, 185, 502, 264, 0, 172, 194, 207, 346, 257, 261, 297, 257, 144, 266, 206, 269, 220, 261, 345, 303], [1987, 306, 263, 217, 270, 296, 366, 428, 181, 257, 353, 391, 238, 147, 342, 334, 234, 458, 310, 152, 278, 13, 515, 316, 201, 0, 61, 221, 399, 271, 275, 198, 270, 91, 166, 220, 322, 233, 275, 359, 317], [1978, 345, 253, 208, 261, 287, 356, 419, 172, 247, 344, 381, 229, 138, 333, 325, 272, 449, 278, 190, 230, 88, 506, 268, 191, 74, 0, 212, 351, 261, 266, 236, 261, 82, 204, 210, 274, 224, 266, 350, 307], [1894, 264, 98, 128, 177, 137, 294, 356, 129, 167, 281, 298, 145, 200, 270, 244, 337, 386, 197, 317, 187, 243, 422, 225, 248, 230, 227, 0, 286, 175, 182, 342, 181, 177, 287, 108, 231, 122, 182, 266, 245], [2033, 215, 265, 177, 315, 299, 386, 486, 175, 188, 374, 436, 284, 261, 391, 133, 288, 516, 66, 268, 107, 310, 561, 126, 315, 297, 294, 280, 0, 197, 320, 293, 171, 244, 238, 265, 151, 279, 320, 404, 337], [1881, 299, 122, 95, 282, 136, 228, 291, 158, 134, 216, 285, 245, 204, 205, 120, 371, 321, 149, 356, 190, 253, 409, 229, 258, 240, 237, 198, 188, 0, 213, 377, 148, 188, 321, 258, 235, 272, 227, 231, 179], [1753, 327, 230, 259, 126, 263, 255, 206, 192, 299, 242, 156, 149, 256, 126, 299, 399, 236, 281, 380, 249, 305, 281, 288, 310, 292, 289, 161, 370, 179, 0, 405, 312, 240, 349, 189, 293, 203, 71, 125, 206], [2046, 215, 348, 295, 329, 387, 442, 499, 188, 288, 429, 449, 297, 273, 404, 310, 143, 529, 218, 108, 187, 180, 574, 225, 324, 167, 212, 276, 308, 347, 334, 0, 271, 257, 75, 281, 231, 292, 333, 418, 393], [1942, 204, 168, 97, 304, 202, 289, 352, 173, 91, 276, 346, 273, 220, 266, 157, 276, 382, 66, 257, 96, 269, 470, 135, 274, 256, 253, 182, 154, 188, 309, 282, 0, 203, 227, 242, 140, 256, 309, 292, 240], [1962, 362, 238, 192, 245, 272, 341, 404, 156, 232, 328, 366, 214, 122, 318, 309, 290, 433, 262, 208, 214, 105, 490, 253, 176, 92, 89, 196, 335, 246, 250, 254, 246, 0, 222, 195, 258, 209, 250, 334, 292], [1971, 140, 273, 220, 254, 307, 368, 424, 113, 214, 354, 374, 222, 200, 330, 235, 164, 454, 144, 145, 112, 217, 499, 150, 253, 204, 232, 204, 233, 272, 259, 170, 196, 182, 0, 203, 156, 217, 258, 343, 318], [1883, 283, 167, 197, 168, 207, 364, 336, 147, 236, 351, 287, 134, 200, 242, 314, 355, 366, 267, 336, 205, 273, 411, 244, 247, 260, 255, 99, 326, 244, 171, 353, 250, 206, 305, 0, 249, 65, 171, 255, 315], [2003, 186, 282, 211, 286, 316, 400, 456, 145, 204, 386, 406, 254, 232, 362, 193, 258, 486, 126, 239, 54, 280, 531, 24, 285, 267, 264, 236, 106, 257, 291, 264, 187, 214, 208, 235, 0, 249, 290, 375, 350], [1896, 296, 180, 210, 179, 214, 377, 349, 160, 249, 364, 300, 147, 201, 255, 327, 368, 379, 280, 348, 218, 280, 424, 257, 254, 267, 262, 112, 339, 257, 184, 374, 263, 212, 318, 44, 262, 0, 184, 268, 328], [1783, 301, 203, 233, 100, 237, 285, 236, 165, 272, 272, 186, 123, 230, 141, 350, 373, 266, 255, 354, 223, 279, 310, 262, 284, 266, 263, 135, 344, 273, 70, 379, 286, 213, 323, 163, 267, 177, 0, 154, 236], [1803, 405, 303, 216, 204, 317, 257, 148, 270, 255, 244, 207, 227, 326, 152, 301, 477, 178, 286, 477, 316, 374, 331, 355, 379, 361, 358, 239, 369, 181, 135, 483, 269, 309, 427, 267, 360, 281, 149, 0, 208], [1923, 408, 286, 199, 324, 300, 171, 333, 262, 238, 53, 327, 347, 309, 247, 284, 480, 363, 269, 460, 299, 357, 486, 338, 362, 344, 342, 289, 352, 164, 255, 486, 252, 292, 430, 330, 343, 344, 269, 273, 0]]}, "reference": {"optimum_s": 18633, "optimality": "best_found", "lower_bound_s": 16785, "floor_s": 13648, "solve_s": 77.32, "ffd_s": 21080, "stop_aware_best_s": 20318, "stop_aware_mean_s": 20504.2, "route_id": "RouteID_c88494db-cbdd-4a35-8ecc-3ad9eb508097", "plans": {"optimum": [{"route": ["S29", "S15", "S28", "S18", "S20", "S01", "S19", "S31", "S16", "S34", "S08"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S40", "S10", "S06", "S03", "S09", "S32", "S36", "S23", "S33", "S25", "S21", "S26", "S37", "S35", "S27", "S02", "S05", "S14"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S13", "S24", "S12"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S22", "S11", "S07", "S17", "S39", "S38", "S04", "S30"], "parcels": []}], "ffd": [{"route": ["S13", "S34", "S04"], "parcels": ["P05", "P06", "P20", "P23", "P24"]}, {"route": ["S17", "S18", "S20", "S36", "S25", "S13", "S04"], "parcels": ["P04", "P25"]}, {"route": ["S11", "S39", "S40", "S15", "S32", "S02", "S27", "S08", "S26", "S13", "S38", "S30"], "parcels": ["P19", "P21", "P22", "P41"]}, {"route": ["S22", "S07", "S10", "S06", "S29", "S05", "S03", "S09", "S23", "S28", "S01", "S16", "S19", "S31", "S21", "S33", "S24", "S27", "S37", "S35", "S12", "S14"], "parcels": ["P42"]}], "stop_aware_best": [{"route": ["S40", "S06", "S02", "S32", "S15", "S28", "S31", "S16", "S08", "S33", "S04", "S30"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S07", "S17", "S18", "S36", "S23", "S34", "S37", "S27", "S05"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S14", "S03", "S13", "S12", "S38"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S22", "S11", "S39", "S10", "S29", "S09", "S20", "S01", "S19", "S25", "S21", "S26", "S24", "S35"], "parcels": []}]}}, "meta": {"route_id": "RouteID_c88494db-cbdd-4a35-8ecc-3ad9eb508097", "split": "train", "stops": 40, "vans": 4, "tightness": 0.92, "station": "DLA7", "city": "DLA", "date": "2018-08-08", "seconds": 138.0, "stop_aware_best_reward": 0.6124, "optimality": "best_found"}}
{"id": "2838e580-spread-n30-k4-t0.88-s0", "instance": {"stops": ["S01", "S02", "S03", "S04", "S05", "S06", "S07", "S08", "S09", "S10", "S11", "S12", "S13", "S14", "S15", "S16", "S17", "S18", "S19", "S20", "S21", "S22", "S23", "S24", "S25", "S26", "S27", "S28", "S29", "S30"], "parcels": [{"id": "P01", "stop": "S01", "volume_dl": 324}, {"id": "P02", "stop": "S02", "volume_dl": 219}, {"id": "P03", "stop": "S02", "volume_dl": 226}, {"id": "P04", "stop": "S02", "volume_dl": 133}, {"id": "P05", "stop": "S03", "volume_dl": 157}, {"id": "P06", "stop": "S04", "volume_dl": 57}, {"id": "P07", "stop": "S05", "volume_dl": 242}, {"id": "P08", "stop": "S06", "volume_dl": 6}, {"id": "P09", "stop": "S07", "volume_dl": 57}, {"id": "P10", "stop": "S07", "volume_dl": 28}, {"id": "P11", "stop": "S08", "volume_dl": 277}, {"id": "P12", "stop": "S08", "volume_dl": 57}, {"id": "P13", "stop": "S08", "volume_dl": 63}, {"id": "P14", "stop": "S09", "volume_dl": 104}, {"id": "P15", "stop": "S10", "volume_dl": 57}, {"id": "P16", "stop": "S11", "volume_dl": 67}, {"id": "P17", "stop": "S12", "volume_dl": 322}, {"id": "P18", "stop": "S13", "volume_dl": 24}, {"id": "P19", "stop": "S13", "volume_dl": 60}, {"id": "P20", "stop": "S13", "volume_dl": 13}, {"id": "P21", "stop": "S14", "volume_dl": 104}, {"id": "P22", "stop": "S15", "volume_dl": 28}, {"id": "P23", "stop": "S15", "volume_dl": 21}, {"id": "P24", "stop": "S16", "volume_dl": 368}, {"id": "P25", "stop": "S16", "volume_dl": 63}, {"id": "P26", "stop": "S17", "volume_dl": 9}, {"id": "P27", "stop": "S18", "volume_dl": 34}, {"id": "P28", "stop": "S19", "volume_dl": 542}, {"id": "P29", "stop": "S20", "volume_dl": 599}, {"id": "P30", "stop": "S20", "volume_dl": 104}, {"id": "P31", "stop": "S21", "volume_dl": 477}, {"id": "P32", "stop": "S21", "volume_dl": 57}, {"id": "P33", "stop": "S21", "volume_dl": 34}, {"id": "P34", "stop": "S21", "volume_dl": 34}, {"id": "P35", "stop": "S21", "volume_dl": 63}, {"id": "P36", "stop": "S21", "volume_dl": 57}, {"id": "P37", "stop": "S22", "volume_dl": 133}, {"id": "P38", "stop": "S22", "volume_dl": 259}, {"id": "P39", "stop": "S23", "volume_dl": 133}, {"id": "P40", "stop": "S24", "volume_dl": 57}, {"id": "P41", "stop": "S24", "volume_dl": 157}, {"id": "P42", "stop": "S24", "volume_dl": 59}, {"id": "P43", "stop": "S25", "volume_dl": 46}, {"id": "P44", "stop": "S26", "volume_dl": 57}, {"id": "P45", "stop": "S27", "volume_dl": 41}, {"id": "P46", "stop": "S27", "volume_dl": 9}, {"id": "P47", "stop": "S28", "volume_dl": 34}, {"id": "P48", "stop": "S29", "volume_dl": 310}, {"id": "P49", "stop": "S29", "volume_dl": 30}, {"id": "P50", "stop": "S30", "volume_dl": 13}], "vans": 4, "capacity_dl": 1827, "travel_s": [[0, 913, 852, 1035, 1064, 1206, 1083, 1098, 1248, 1175, 1138, 964, 1189, 1106, 944, 930, 949, 1184, 1107, 1078, 908, 1116, 1259, 1074, 1257, 1123, 922, 1033, 1107, 1268, 1192], [847, 0, 88, 387, 247, 388, 254, 269, 430, 345, 309, 206, 476, 458, 268, 202, 296, 378, 277, 376, 308, 413, 556, 245, 444, 294, 271, 385, 404, 450, 374], [901, 60, 0, 387, 264, 404, 271, 291, 449, 363, 327, 239, 486, 457, 163, 208, 191, 396, 295, 376, 209, 413, 554, 262, 441, 294, 184, 384, 404, 481, 390], [1012, 413, 410, 0, 495, 430, 518, 484, 507, 411, 448, 539, 375, 151, 573, 535, 601, 483, 523, 264, 619, 301, 445, 509, 511, 418, 594, 78, 292, 414, 414], [1077, 253, 268, 484, 0, 141, 160, 166, 183, 146, 129, 160, 229, 554, 235, 191, 230, 131, 115, 254, 274, 428, 317, 151, 188, 321, 267, 481, 227, 203, 127], [1189, 418, 415, 378, 197, 0, 269, 236, 145, 163, 200, 357, 207, 449, 441, 341, 429, 196, 226, 149, 424, 323, 294, 260, 150, 338, 461, 376, 147, 162, 108], [1122, 298, 344, 454, 156, 185, 0, 92, 210, 92, 55, 219, 273, 524, 297, 197, 285, 170, 23, 224, 280, 398, 361, 116, 214, 267, 317, 451, 222, 238, 172], [1030, 207, 217, 502, 167, 308, 174, 0, 352, 266, 229, 127, 396, 575, 206, 111, 194, 298, 197, 398, 188, 521, 482, 165, 368, 343, 225, 506, 394, 375, 295], [1251, 428, 401, 568, 174, 223, 293, 262, 0, 149, 224, 334, 251, 640, 409, 367, 403, 51, 210, 338, 448, 512, 319, 284, 211, 325, 485, 567, 311, 248, 224], [1103, 280, 295, 448, 138, 251, 106, 73, 294, 0, 37, 200, 339, 519, 279, 178, 267, 241, 130, 330, 261, 505, 427, 97, 307, 289, 298, 446, 337, 313, 238], [1066, 243, 258, 523, 101, 214, 69, 36, 257, 161, 0, 163, 302, 594, 242, 141, 230, 204, 93, 293, 224, 468, 390, 60, 270, 337, 261, 521, 300, 276, 201], [1030, 206, 221, 533, 171, 310, 147, 239, 357, 239, 203, 0, 398, 604, 132, 52, 123, 300, 171, 371, 132, 546, 486, 138, 361, 415, 164, 531, 396, 385, 297], [1150, 484, 454, 339, 230, 120, 367, 334, 197, 250, 298, 390, 0, 410, 465, 421, 460, 241, 284, 110, 504, 331, 153, 358, 201, 426, 497, 337, 82, 109, 104], [1084, 485, 482, 172, 567, 502, 590, 557, 578, 484, 520, 611, 447, 0, 645, 607, 673, 555, 595, 336, 689, 371, 517, 581, 585, 490, 666, 74, 364, 486, 486], [1019, 196, 211, 522, 285, 426, 281, 288, 468, 372, 336, 133, 514, 593, 0, 102, 52, 416, 304, 505, 53, 548, 602, 272, 484, 472, 32, 520, 512, 488, 412], [1026, 203, 224, 530, 202, 343, 196, 245, 387, 288, 252, 68, 431, 603, 100, 0, 93, 333, 220, 420, 83, 595, 516, 187, 410, 425, 120, 534, 429, 410, 329], [976, 205, 220, 532, 272, 414, 267, 273, 457, 359, 322, 125, 502, 602, 64, 94, 0, 404, 290, 491, 30, 558, 587, 258, 474, 458, 45, 530, 499, 480, 400], [1197, 374, 407, 504, 120, 161, 249, 222, 161, 155, 186, 280, 249, 574, 355, 312, 351, 0, 172, 274, 395, 448, 326, 240, 148, 330, 387, 501, 247, 186, 148], [1147, 323, 320, 430, 206, 162, 174, 141, 186, 68, 105, 268, 250, 501, 347, 246, 335, 146, 0, 200, 330, 375, 338, 166, 190, 244, 367, 428, 198, 214, 148], [1040, 347, 344, 229, 276, 166, 351, 318, 242, 245, 282, 445, 111, 300, 507, 423, 535, 287, 330, 0, 506, 174, 180, 342, 247, 352, 528, 227, 28, 150, 149], [960, 245, 260, 572, 271, 413, 264, 267, 456, 356, 320, 117, 501, 643, 63, 73, 40, 391, 288, 488, 0, 598, 565, 255, 468, 448, 37, 570, 498, 474, 399], [1091, 398, 395, 280, 444, 334, 503, 470, 409, 397, 434, 524, 279, 353, 558, 520, 586, 455, 498, 168, 604, 0, 346, 494, 419, 403, 579, 278, 196, 323, 318], [1141, 448, 445, 330, 239, 129, 376, 347, 167, 259, 307, 399, 94, 403, 474, 436, 470, 216, 293, 101, 513, 275, 0, 367, 177, 452, 506, 334, 74, 123, 112], [1131, 307, 353, 462, 166, 194, 9, 100, 218, 101, 64, 228, 282, 533, 306, 206, 294, 179, 32, 233, 289, 407, 370, 0, 223, 276, 326, 460, 231, 247, 181], [1202, 508, 506, 391, 300, 182, 437, 408, 161, 312, 367, 460, 154, 461, 535, 497, 530, 213, 354, 161, 574, 336, 177, 428, 0, 513, 567, 394, 134, 34, 173], [1104, 280, 277, 380, 321, 317, 344, 311, 363, 238, 275, 406, 405, 450, 440, 402, 468, 310, 350, 393, 486, 406, 492, 335, 350, 0, 461, 378, 402, 388, 303], [969, 218, 232, 544, 307, 448, 301, 300, 490, 393, 357, 154, 536, 615, 22, 110, 36, 438, 325, 526, 37, 570, 605, 292, 501, 485, 0, 542, 534, 510, 434], [1009, 411, 413, 98, 492, 428, 515, 487, 506, 409, 446, 537, 372, 75, 570, 539, 604, 481, 521, 262, 616, 299, 440, 506, 513, 415, 592, 0, 290, 416, 411], [1066, 373, 370, 255, 247, 137, 377, 344, 213, 271, 308, 407, 82, 326, 533, 449, 561, 258, 300, 26, 532, 200, 151, 368, 218, 378, 554, 253, 0, 120, 120], [1168, 474, 466, 357, 266, 156, 403, 374, 234, 285, 333, 426, 120, 430, 500, 463, 496, 276, 319, 127, 540, 296, 143, 394, 240, 479, 532, 360, 100, 0, 139], [1167, 380, 395, 356, 126, 14, 264, 230, 93, 146, 194, 286, 102, 427, 361, 318, 357, 137, 180, 126, 401, 301, 190, 254, 98, 322, 393, 354, 99, 76, 0]]}, "reference": {"optimum_s": 10650, "optimality": "best_found", "lower_bound_s": 8631, "floor_s": 6796, "solve_s": 87.32, "ffd_s": 13637, "stop_aware_best_s": 12226, "stop_aware_mean_s": 12543, "route_id": "RouteID_2838e580-84d0-414b-b931-acbc9159af6f", "plans": {"optimum": [{"route": ["S15", "S04", "S12", "S30", "S05", "S08", "S17", "S09", "S10", "S07", "S01"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S02", "S25", "S21", "S03", "S13", "S27"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S11", "S23", "S06", "S18", "S24", "S29", "S22", "S28", "S19"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S26", "S14", "S16", "S20"], "parcels": []}], "ffd": [{"route": ["S20", "S06", "S25", "S21", "S19", "S03"], "parcels": ["P29", "P31"]}, {"route": ["S16", "S29", "S12", "S08", "S02", "S01"], "parcels": ["P03", "P11", "P24", "P48"]}, {"route": ["S02", "S14", "S16", "S20", "S11", "S23", "S09", "S05", "S08", "S24", "S22", "S27"], "parcels": ["P02", "P04", "P13", "P25", "P30", "P41", "P45"]}, {"route": ["S26", "S15", "S18", "S10", "S07", "S04", "S30", "S08", "S17", "S24", "S29", "S28", "S21", "S13", "S27"], "parcels": ["P12", "P32", "P33", "P34", "P35", "P36", "P40", "P42", "P46", "P49"]}], "stop_aware_best": [{"route": ["S23", "S22", "S19", "S03", "S13", "S27"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S26", "S16", "S18", "S05", "S24", "S08", "S04", "S01"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S15", "S06", "S10", "S17", "S29", "S12", "S30", "S25", "S02"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S21", "S28", "S09", "S07", "S11", "S14", "S20"], "parcels": []}]}}, "meta": {"route_id": "RouteID_2838e580-84d0-414b-b931-acbc9159af6f", "split": "train", "stops": 30, "vans": 4, "tightness": 0.88, "station": "DCH2", "city": "DCH", "date": "2018-07-20", "seconds": 147.6, "stop_aware_best_reward": 0.5605, "optimality": "best_found"}}
{"id": "0446eb68-spread-n40-k4-t0.86-s0", "instance": {"stops": ["S01", "S02", "S03", "S04", "S05", "S06", "S07", "S08", "S09", "S10", "S11", "S12", "S13", "S14", "S15", "S16", "S17", "S18", "S19", "S20", "S21", "S22", "S23", "S24", "S25", "S26", "S27", "S28", "S29", "S30", "S31", "S32", "S33", "S34", "S35", "S36", "S37", "S38", "S39", "S40"], "parcels": [{"id": "P01", "stop": "S01", "volume_dl": 381}, {"id": "P02", "stop": "S02", "volume_dl": 3}, {"id": "P03", "stop": "S02", "volume_dl": 57}, {"id": "P04", "stop": "S03", "volume_dl": 26}, {"id": "P05", "stop": "S04", "volume_dl": 242}, {"id": "P06", "stop": "S04", "volume_dl": 55}, {"id": "P07", "stop": "S04", "volume_dl": 46}, {"id": "P08", "stop": "S04", "volume_dl": 7}, {"id": "P09", "stop": "S04", "volume_dl": 63}, {"id": "P10", "stop": "S05", "volume_dl": 552}, {"id": "P11", "stop": "S06", "volume_dl": 104}, {"id": "P12", "stop": "S07", "volume_dl": 21}, {"id": "P13", "stop": "S08", "volume_dl": 79}, {"id": "P14", "stop": "S09", "volume_dl": 31}, {"id": "P15", "stop": "S10", "volume_dl": 23}, {"id": "P16", "stop": "S11", "volume_dl": 87}, {"id": "P17", "stop": "S11", "volume_dl": 59}, {"id": "P18", "stop": "S12", "volume_dl": 28}, {"id": "P19", "stop": "S13", "volume_dl": 92}, {"id": "P20", "stop": "S14", "volume_dl": 4}, {"id": "P21", "stop": "S14", "volume_dl": 59}, {"id": "P22", "stop": "S14", "volume_dl": 18}, {"id": "P23", "stop": "S14", "volume_dl": 10}, {"id": "P24", "stop": "S15", "volume_dl": 30}, {"id": "P25", "stop": "S16", "volume_dl": 8}, {"id": "P26", "stop": "S17", "volume_dl": 32}, {"id": "P27", "stop": "S18", "volume_dl": 30}, {"id": "P28", "stop": "S19", "volume_dl": 104}, {"id": "P29", "stop": "S19", "volume_dl": 27}, {"id": "P30", "stop": "S20", "volume_dl": 309}, {"id": "P31", "stop": "S21", "volume_dl": 23}, {"id": "P32", "stop": "S22", "volume_dl": 32}, {"id": "P33", "stop": "S23", "volume_dl": 32}, {"id": "P34", "stop": "S24", "volume_dl": 179}, {"id": "P35", "stop": "S25", "volume_dl": 134}, {"id": "P36", "stop": "S26", "volume_dl": 13}, {"id": "P37", "stop": "S27", "volume_dl": 179}, {"id": "P38", "stop": "S27", "volume_dl": 63}, {"id": "P39", "stop": "S28", "volume_dl": 179}, {"id": "P40", "stop": "S28", "volume_dl": 322}, {"id": "P41", "stop": "S29", "volume_dl": 133}, {"id": "P42", "stop": "S29", "volume_dl": 9}, {"id": "P43", "stop": "S30", "volume_dl": 26}, {"id": "P44", "stop": "S30", "volume_dl": 44}, {"id": "P45", "stop": "S31", "volume_dl": 37}, {"id": "P46", "stop": "S32", "volume_dl": 1017}, {"id": "P47", "stop": "S33", "volume_dl": 242}, {"id": "P48", "stop": "S34", "volume_dl": 104}, {"id": "P49", "stop": "S34", "volume_dl": 19}, {"id": "P50", "stop": "S35", "volume_dl": 242}, {"id": "P51", "stop": "S35", "volume_dl": 29}, {"id": "P52", "stop": "S36", "volume_dl": 23}, {"id": "P53", "stop": "S37", "volume_dl": 29}, {"id": "P54", "stop": "S38", "volume_dl": 34}, {"id": "P55", "stop": "S39", "volume_dl": 134}, {"id": "P56", "stop": "S40", "volume_dl": 54}, {"id": "P57", "stop": "S40", "volume_dl": 32}], "vans": 4, "capacity_dl": 1730, "travel_s": [[0, 1376, 1389, 1331, 1301, 1497, 1513, 1325, 1462, 1473, 1347, 1414, 1512, 1527, 1286, 1460, 1334, 1304, 1327, 1372, 1504, 1544, 1417, 1469, 1453, 1345, 1475, 1366, 1375, 1525, 1241, 1446, 1467, 1435, 1473, 1312, 1591, 1349, 1363, 1438, 1315], [1317, 0, 313, 270, 366, 313, 347, 390, 297, 306, 412, 246, 249, 290, 267, 418, 399, 176, 373, 436, 190, 374, 180, 376, 190, 410, 291, 74, 439, 288, 200, 443, 300, 382, 160, 377, 279, 348, 287, 270, 380], [1370, 313, 0, 247, 238, 333, 264, 263, 213, 469, 222, 410, 263, 314, 410, 225, 273, 388, 132, 310, 460, 430, 278, 161, 203, 283, 311, 364, 186, 312, 329, 250, 464, 128, 241, 250, 342, 155, 58, 434, 253], [1338, 305, 242, 0, 306, 350, 366, 329, 315, 548, 307, 489, 365, 416, 207, 293, 339, 185, 148, 376, 433, 532, 380, 272, 306, 349, 327, 296, 271, 414, 123, 317, 543, 238, 343, 316, 444, 223, 216, 513, 319], [1282, 350, 265, 307, 0, 373, 389, 24, 338, 593, 241, 534, 388, 440, 260, 296, 53, 278, 203, 71, 477, 555, 403, 313, 329, 134, 351, 340, 269, 437, 219, 320, 587, 280, 356, 102, 467, 225, 239, 558, 71], [1495, 331, 245, 362, 365, 0, 300, 388, 249, 519, 350, 460, 281, 350, 503, 351, 398, 412, 257, 435, 403, 466, 314, 247, 221, 409, 48, 382, 347, 348, 436, 375, 513, 314, 259, 376, 378, 280, 219, 484, 378], [1537, 391, 287, 404, 407, 305, 0, 430, 146, 455, 392, 396, 341, 300, 515, 393, 440, 532, 299, 477, 445, 415, 263, 389, 281, 451, 283, 483, 389, 297, 482, 417, 449, 356, 319, 418, 327, 322, 261, 420, 420], [1307, 376, 291, 333, 25, 399, 415, 0, 364, 619, 267, 559, 414, 465, 286, 322, 79, 304, 229, 47, 503, 581, 429, 339, 355, 160, 377, 366, 295, 463, 241, 346, 613, 305, 392, 128, 493, 251, 265, 583, 71], [1495, 349, 245, 362, 365, 263, 135, 388, 0, 413, 350, 354, 299, 258, 473, 351, 398, 490, 257, 435, 403, 373, 221, 347, 239, 409, 241, 441, 347, 255, 440, 375, 407, 314, 277, 376, 285, 280, 219, 378, 378], [1434, 316, 492, 504, 600, 504, 538, 624, 488, 0, 597, 137, 440, 298, 501, 598, 633, 410, 505, 670, 323, 308, 187, 568, 381, 644, 482, 361, 594, 296, 434, 622, 170, 561, 351, 611, 286, 527, 466, 25, 613], [1372, 451, 188, 301, 260, 343, 401, 283, 350, 607, 0, 547, 400, 451, 350, 128, 293, 442, 197, 330, 597, 567, 415, 145, 341, 304, 321, 430, 51, 449, 380, 130, 601, 111, 378, 271, 479, 89, 228, 571, 273], [1395, 277, 453, 465, 559, 464, 499, 584, 448, 136, 557, 0, 400, 258, 461, 558, 593, 370, 465, 630, 283, 269, 147, 528, 341, 604, 442, 322, 554, 256, 394, 582, 113, 521, 301, 571, 246, 488, 426, 101, 574], [1513, 270, 263, 380, 383, 263, 298, 406, 247, 457, 368, 398, 0, 348, 441, 369, 416, 351, 275, 453, 342, 464, 312, 327, 83, 427, 241, 321, 365, 346, 375, 393, 452, 332, 155, 394, 376, 298, 237, 422, 396], [1487, 285, 320, 472, 440, 338, 302, 464, 252, 301, 425, 242, 408, 0, 469, 426, 473, 378, 333, 510, 291, 169, 110, 423, 349, 484, 316, 330, 422, 75, 402, 450, 295, 389, 319, 451, 174, 355, 294, 266, 454], [1301, 231, 345, 206, 256, 453, 469, 281, 419, 474, 303, 415, 418, 459, 0, 416, 291, 111, 283, 328, 359, 543, 349, 425, 358, 301, 431, 222, 331, 457, 83, 403, 469, 391, 328, 268, 448, 306, 319, 439, 271], [1422, 441, 269, 310, 292, 424, 391, 316, 341, 597, 129, 538, 391, 442, 400, 0, 326, 451, 205, 363, 587, 557, 406, 226, 331, 336, 401, 492, 180, 440, 388, 24, 591, 192, 368, 303, 470, 105, 309, 562, 306], [1316, 384, 300, 342, 74, 407, 424, 98, 373, 627, 276, 568, 423, 474, 294, 330, 0, 312, 238, 137, 512, 590, 438, 348, 363, 169, 385, 374, 303, 472, 249, 355, 622, 314, 401, 136, 502, 260, 274, 592, 114], [1338, 151, 413, 195, 306, 402, 436, 330, 386, 394, 352, 335, 338, 379, 142, 465, 340, 0, 297, 377, 279, 463, 269, 442, 278, 350, 380, 142, 380, 377, 75, 452, 389, 409, 249, 317, 368, 354, 386, 359, 320], [1358, 336, 162, 152, 228, 270, 286, 251, 235, 492, 227, 432, 285, 336, 293, 213, 261, 271, 0, 298, 482, 452, 300, 192, 226, 271, 248, 382, 191, 334, 209, 238, 486, 158, 263, 238, 364, 143, 136, 456, 241], [1364, 432, 348, 390, 83, 456, 472, 57, 421, 675, 324, 616, 471, 522, 342, 378, 136, 360, 286, 0, 560, 638, 486, 396, 412, 217, 433, 423, 353, 520, 298, 403, 670, 362, 449, 184, 550, 308, 322, 640, 128], [1523, 239, 395, 396, 491, 395, 430, 515, 379, 350, 537, 290, 331, 334, 392, 501, 524, 301, 408, 561, 0, 418, 224, 459, 272, 535, 373, 252, 497, 332, 325, 525, 344, 464, 242, 502, 323, 430, 369, 314, 504], [1533, 373, 421, 561, 540, 439, 403, 564, 352, 316, 525, 257, 497, 158, 557, 526, 574, 466, 433, 611, 379, 0, 244, 523, 437, 584, 417, 418, 522, 92, 490, 550, 310, 489, 407, 551, 274, 456, 395, 281, 554], [1376, 174, 304, 362, 424, 362, 286, 447, 235, 190, 409, 131, 298, 109, 358, 410, 457, 268, 316, 494, 180, 201, 0, 406, 238, 468, 340, 219, 406, 107, 292, 434, 185, 373, 208, 435, 98, 339, 278, 155, 437], [1452, 396, 141, 300, 322, 228, 364, 345, 313, 583, 159, 524, 345, 414, 464, 226, 355, 442, 196, 392, 468, 530, 378, 0, 286, 366, 206, 447, 123, 412, 379, 250, 578, 44, 323, 333, 442, 138, 181, 548, 335], [1485, 242, 236, 352, 355, 236, 270, 379, 219, 430, 340, 370, 95, 320, 414, 341, 389, 323, 248, 426, 314, 436, 284, 299, 0, 399, 214, 293, 337, 318, 347, 365, 424, 304, 72, 366, 348, 270, 210, 394, 369], [1308, 377, 292, 334, 138, 400, 416, 161, 365, 620, 268, 560, 415, 466, 286, 323, 167, 304, 230, 208, 504, 582, 430, 340, 356, 0, 378, 367, 296, 464, 242, 347, 614, 306, 393, 34, 494, 252, 266, 584, 151], [1468, 304, 218, 334, 338, 63, 272, 361, 222, 492, 323, 432, 254, 323, 476, 323, 371, 385, 230, 408, 376, 438, 287, 220, 194, 381, 0, 355, 319, 321, 409, 348, 486, 286, 231, 349, 351, 253, 192, 456, 351], [1306, 66, 373, 277, 373, 373, 407, 396, 357, 367, 418, 308, 309, 352, 348, 478, 406, 206, 379, 443, 269, 436, 242, 436, 249, 416, 351, 0, 448, 350, 279, 518, 362, 441, 210, 384, 341, 408, 347, 332, 386], [1404, 420, 157, 271, 283, 312, 370, 307, 320, 576, 75, 517, 370, 421, 434, 154, 317, 412, 166, 354, 566, 536, 385, 114, 310, 327, 290, 523, 0, 419, 353, 178, 570, 80, 338, 296, 449, 58, 198, 541, 297], [1495, 292, 328, 480, 447, 346, 310, 472, 260, 338, 433, 279, 416, 65, 477, 434, 481, 386, 340, 518, 299, 93, 152, 430, 357, 492, 324, 337, 430, 0, 410, 458, 332, 397, 317, 459, 181, 363, 302, 303, 462], [1265, 182, 337, 119, 235, 433, 461, 256, 410, 425, 278, 363, 369, 410, 81, 388, 266, 63, 221, 306, 310, 494, 300, 367, 309, 276, 411, 174, 307, 408, 0, 378, 420, 333, 270, 244, 399, 318, 311, 390, 249], [1447, 465, 293, 334, 317, 448, 416, 340, 365, 621, 130, 562, 415, 466, 425, 24, 350, 475, 230, 387, 611, 582, 430, 250, 355, 360, 426, 516, 181, 464, 412, 0, 616, 216, 393, 327, 494, 130, 334, 586, 330], [1402, 284, 460, 472, 567, 472, 506, 591, 455, 163, 564, 86, 408, 265, 468, 565, 601, 378, 472, 638, 290, 276, 155, 535, 348, 611, 450, 329, 561, 263, 402, 590, 0, 528, 318, 578, 254, 495, 434, 128, 581], [1408, 429, 118, 257, 278, 262, 356, 302, 306, 562, 115, 503, 379, 407, 420, 182, 311, 398, 153, 348, 502, 522, 371, 34, 319, 322, 240, 480, 80, 405, 335, 206, 557, 0, 357, 289, 435, 95, 159, 527, 292], [1512, 209, 260, 384, 378, 269, 304, 413, 253, 396, 374, 337, 164, 354, 371, 375, 422, 290, 282, 450, 281, 470, 318, 333, 80, 433, 247, 261, 372, 342, 311, 399, 391, 338, 0, 390, 382, 304, 243, 361, 393], [1274, 342, 258, 300, 103, 366, 382, 127, 331, 586, 234, 526, 381, 432, 252, 289, 133, 270, 196, 174, 470, 548, 396, 306, 322, 33, 344, 333, 262, 430, 211, 313, 580, 272, 349, 0, 460, 218, 232, 550, 117], [1449, 246, 362, 434, 481, 434, 468, 505, 418, 263, 466, 204, 370, 167, 431, 467, 514, 340, 374, 552, 253, 258, 71, 498, 311, 525, 412, 291, 463, 165, 364, 491, 257, 430, 281, 492, 0, 396, 335, 228, 495], [1362, 380, 171, 285, 232, 326, 331, 255, 280, 536, 94, 477, 330, 381, 340, 95, 265, 426, 181, 302, 526, 497, 345, 128, 270, 275, 304, 432, 78, 379, 363, 120, 531, 95, 308, 243, 409, 0, 212, 501, 245], [1363, 307, 57, 241, 233, 354, 257, 257, 207, 463, 218, 404, 257, 308, 404, 219, 266, 382, 126, 304, 453, 423, 272, 181, 197, 277, 332, 358, 207, 306, 319, 243, 457, 148, 234, 244, 336, 148, 0, 428, 247], [1409, 291, 467, 479, 575, 479, 513, 598, 463, 35, 572, 109, 415, 272, 476, 573, 608, 385, 479, 645, 298, 283, 162, 542, 355, 618, 457, 336, 569, 270, 409, 597, 145, 536, 326, 586, 261, 502, 441, 0, 588], [1306, 375, 290, 332, 70, 398, 414, 61, 363, 618, 266, 558, 413, 464, 284, 321, 104, 302, 228, 108, 502, 580, 428, 338, 354, 159, 376, 365, 294, 462, 244, 345, 612, 304, 381, 127, 492, 250, 264, 582, 0]]}, "reference": {"optimum_s": 15159, "optimality": "best_found", "lower_bound_s": 5361, "floor_s": 10024, "solve_s": 55.21, "ffd_s": 18858, "stop_aware_best_s": 17987, "stop_aware_mean_s": 18191, "route_id": "RouteID_0446eb68-1fe0-40f3-b82e-2cbddd0433d3", "plans": {"optimum": [{"route": ["S40", "S19", "S07", "S04", "S16", "S35", "S25", "S27", "S01"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S37", "S15", "S31", "S10", "S28", "S33", "S23", "S02", "S38"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S11", "S39", "S09", "S32", "S21", "S29", "S13", "S36", "S22"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S14", "S30", "S17", "S20", "S34", "S24", "S12", "S08", "S06", "S05", "S26", "S18", "S03"], "parcels": []}], "ffd": [{"route": ["S32", "S05", "S19", "S25"], "parcels": ["P29"]}, {"route": ["S01", "S20", "S24", "S33", "S28", "S04"], "parcels": ["P05", "P06", "P40"]}, {"route": ["S14", "S04", "S19", "S35", "S28", "S02", "S08", "S06", "S29", "S13", "S11", "S39", "S34", "S27"], "parcels": ["P02", "P07", "P09", "P21", "P28", "P39", "P41", "P48", "P50"]}, {"route": ["S09", "S21", "S29", "S36", "S22", "S34", "S12", "S26", "S37", "S15", "S31", "S10", "S23", "S02", "S38", "S18", "S03", "S30", "S17", "S14", "S40", "S07", "S04", "S16", "S35"], "parcels": ["P03", "P08", "P20", "P22", "P23", "P42", "P49", "P51"]}], "stop_aware_best": [{"route": ["S30", "S07", "S16", "S10", "S28", "S33", "S06", "S39"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S14", "S27", "S22", "S09", "S32", "S21", "S13", "S38", "S02", "S23"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S40", "S19", "S35", "S37", "S15", "S31", "S18", "S05", "S26", "S24", "S34", "S29", "S36"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S03", "S17", "S01", "S11", "S20", "S12", "S08", "S04", "S25"], "parcels": []}]}}, "meta": {"route_id": "RouteID_0446eb68-1fe0-40f3-b82e-2cbddd0433d3", "split": "train", "stops": 40, "vans": 4, "tightness": 0.86, "station": "DCH4", "city": "DCH", "date": "2018-08-03", "seconds": 118.6, "stop_aware_best_reward": 0.4716, "optimality": "best_found"}}
{"id": "59a577b4-spread-n40-k4-t0.93-s0", "instance": {"stops": ["S01", "S02", "S03", "S04", "S05", "S06", "S07", "S08", "S09", "S10", "S11", "S12", "S13", "S14", "S15", "S16", "S17", "S18", "S19", "S20", "S21", "S22", "S23", "S24", "S25", "S26", "S27", "S28", "S29", "S30", "S31", "S32", "S33", "S34", "S35", "S36", "S37", "S38", "S39", "S40"], "parcels": [{"id": "P01", "stop": "S01", "volume_dl": 133}, {"id": "P02", "stop": "S02", "volume_dl": 79}, {"id": "P03", "stop": "S02", "volume_dl": 59}, {"id": "P04", "stop": "S03", "volume_dl": 312}, {"id": "P05", "stop": "S04", "volume_dl": 57}, {"id": "P06", "stop": "S05", "volume_dl": 20}, {"id": "P07", "stop": "S06", "volume_dl": 59}, {"id": "P08", "stop": "S07", "volume_dl": 133}, {"id": "P09", "stop": "S07", "volume_dl": 9}, {"id": "P10", "stop": "S08", "volume_dl": 133}, {"id": "P11", "stop": "S08", "volume_dl": 37}, {"id": "P12", "stop": "S08", "volume_dl": 46}, {"id": "P13", "stop": "S09", "volume_dl": 21}, {"id": "P14", "stop": "S10", "volume_dl": 31}, {"id": "P15", "stop": "S11", "volume_dl": 104}, {"id": "P16", "stop": "S11", "volume_dl": 59}, {"id": "P17", "stop": "S12", "volume_dl": 11}, {"id": "P18", "stop": "S13", "volume_dl": 38}, {"id": "P19", "stop": "S14", "volume_dl": 39}, {"id": "P20", "stop": "S15", "volume_dl": 18}, {"id": "P21", "stop": "S16", "volume_dl": 34}, {"id": "P22", "stop": "S17", "volume_dl": 92}, {"id": "P23", "stop": "S18", "volume_dl": 477}, {"id": "P24", "stop": "S19", "volume_dl": 24}, {"id": "P25", "stop": "S19", "volume_dl": 12}, {"id": "P26", "stop": "S20", "volume_dl": 20}, {"id": "P27", "stop": "S21", "volume_dl": 469}, {"id": "P28", "stop": "S22", "volume_dl": 44}, {"id": "P29", "stop": "S22", "volume_dl": 157}, {"id": "P30", "stop": "S23", "volume_dl": 27}, {"id": "P31", "stop": "S24", "volume_dl": 8}, {"id": "P32", "stop": "S24", "volume_dl": 157}, {"id": "P33", "stop": "S24", "volume_dl": 34}, {"id": "P34", "stop": "S25", "volume_dl": 34}, {"id": "P35", "stop": "S26", "volume_dl": 289}, {"id": "P36", "stop": "S26", "volume_dl": 13}, {"id": "P37", "stop": "S26", "volume_dl": 6}, {"id": "P38", "stop": "S27", "volume_dl": 37}, {"id": "P39", "stop": "S27", "volume_dl": 11}, {"id": "P40", "stop": "S27", "volume_dl": 23}, {"id": "P41", "stop": "S28", "volume_dl": 22}, {"id": "P42", "stop": "S29", "volume_dl": 133}, {"id": "P43", "stop": "S30", "volume_dl": 133}, {"id": "P44", "stop": "S31", "volume_dl": 329}, {"id": "P45", "stop": "S32", "volume_dl": 59}, {"id": "P46", "stop": "S33", "volume_dl": 157}, {"id": "P47", "stop": "S34", "volume_dl": 26}, {"id": "P48", "stop": "S35", "volume_dl": 92}, {"id": "P49", "stop": "S36", "volume_dl": 59}, {"id": "P50", "stop": "S37", "volume_dl": 133}, {"id": "P51", "stop": "S38", "volume_dl": 34}, {"id": "P52", "stop": "S38", "volume_dl": 63}, {"id": "P53", "stop": "S39", "volume_dl": 40}, {"id": "P54", "stop": "S39", "volume_dl": 92}, {"id": "P55", "stop": "S40", "volume_dl": 13}], "vans": 4, "capacity_dl": 1278, "travel_s": [[0, 1930, 1830, 1806, 1918, 1928, 1888, 1869, 1861, 1925, 1972, 1890, 2105, 1905, 1965, 1778, 1820, 1893, 2039, 1873, 1909, 1959, 1959, 2029, 1957, 1952, 1866, 1834, 1960, 1932, 2057, 2032, 1827, 1885, 1903, 1996, 1952, 1998, 1817, 1937, 1916], [1888, 0, 407, 384, 116, 256, 44, 275, 136, 253, 170, 298, 415, 93, 275, 356, 134, 455, 622, 106, 184, 468, 486, 538, 666, 490, 375, 412, 487, 242, 366, 647, 158, 324, 302, 504, 461, 524, 395, 446, 325], [1752, 475, 0, 206, 419, 312, 434, 253, 390, 309, 472, 355, 489, 450, 349, 178, 370, 330, 497, 368, 325, 343, 340, 413, 541, 365, 249, 234, 344, 316, 441, 522, 288, 269, 287, 379, 336, 381, 217, 321, 382], [1712, 352, 194, 0, 340, 266, 310, 207, 283, 263, 393, 309, 443, 327, 303, 35, 242, 284, 451, 295, 279, 297, 297, 367, 495, 319, 204, 90, 298, 270, 395, 477, 249, 223, 241, 333, 290, 335, 74, 275, 336], [1855, 125, 374, 350, 0, 188, 83, 207, 102, 185, 53, 230, 347, 100, 207, 322, 101, 387, 554, 38, 116, 400, 418, 470, 598, 422, 307, 378, 419, 174, 298, 579, 124, 256, 234, 436, 393, 456, 361, 378, 257], [1895, 256, 324, 271, 200, 0, 215, 92, 171, 50, 253, 96, 250, 232, 110, 269, 152, 273, 439, 152, 106, 285, 303, 355, 483, 307, 192, 324, 304, 77, 202, 465, 175, 142, 119, 321, 278, 342, 308, 263, 142], [1844, 42, 363, 340, 72, 212, 0, 231, 92, 209, 126, 255, 371, 50, 231, 312, 90, 411, 578, 62, 140, 424, 442, 494, 622, 446, 331, 368, 443, 198, 323, 604, 114, 280, 258, 460, 417, 480, 351, 402, 281], [1783, 276, 265, 212, 219, 112, 234, 0, 190, 109, 272, 152, 289, 251, 149, 210, 171, 214, 380, 168, 125, 226, 242, 296, 424, 248, 132, 265, 246, 116, 241, 406, 194, 83, 34, 262, 220, 283, 249, 208, 182], [1787, 124, 306, 282, 112, 193, 83, 212, 0, 190, 166, 233, 352, 100, 212, 255, 33, 393, 559, 82, 121, 405, 433, 476, 603, 428, 312, 311, 437, 179, 304, 585, 57, 262, 239, 441, 399, 474, 290, 387, 263], [1870, 274, 342, 289, 218, 51, 232, 110, 189, 0, 271, 71, 268, 249, 128, 286, 169, 290, 456, 170, 123, 303, 321, 373, 501, 325, 210, 342, 322, 95, 219, 482, 192, 159, 136, 339, 296, 359, 325, 281, 97], [1903, 173, 422, 398, 48, 236, 131, 255, 150, 233, 0, 279, 395, 148, 255, 371, 149, 436, 602, 86, 164, 448, 466, 518, 646, 470, 355, 426, 467, 222, 347, 628, 172, 304, 282, 484, 441, 504, 410, 426, 306], [1890, 315, 379, 330, 258, 92, 273, 147, 226, 86, 312, 0, 308, 290, 168, 327, 210, 331, 497, 208, 164, 343, 359, 414, 538, 366, 249, 379, 363, 135, 260, 523, 233, 200, 177, 380, 337, 400, 362, 326, 41], [2022, 418, 586, 451, 362, 273, 376, 272, 333, 270, 415, 316, 0, 393, 169, 448, 313, 452, 619, 314, 268, 465, 483, 535, 663, 487, 372, 504, 484, 221, 48, 644, 337, 321, 298, 501, 458, 521, 487, 443, 342], [1868, 78, 387, 363, 96, 235, 36, 254, 115, 232, 149, 278, 394, 0, 254, 336, 114, 435, 601, 85, 164, 447, 466, 518, 645, 470, 355, 391, 467, 221, 346, 627, 137, 304, 281, 484, 441, 504, 375, 425, 305], [1950, 286, 454, 318, 229, 140, 244, 139, 200, 137, 282, 196, 157, 261, 0, 316, 181, 320, 486, 181, 135, 332, 350, 402, 530, 354, 239, 371, 351, 89, 108, 512, 204, 189, 166, 368, 326, 389, 355, 310, 197], [1692, 332, 190, 27, 320, 288, 290, 229, 262, 285, 373, 331, 466, 307, 325, 0, 221, 307, 473, 274, 301, 319, 320, 390, 517, 342, 226, 93, 320, 292, 417, 499, 228, 245, 264, 355, 313, 358, 76, 297, 358], [1754, 110, 273, 249, 98, 161, 68, 180, 41, 158, 151, 204, 320, 85, 180, 222, 0, 361, 527, 53, 89, 373, 403, 443, 571, 395, 280, 277, 404, 147, 272, 553, 23, 230, 207, 409, 366, 441, 260, 351, 231], [1774, 443, 330, 277, 387, 280, 402, 221, 358, 277, 440, 323, 457, 418, 317, 274, 338, 0, 379, 339, 293, 109, 329, 266, 210, 59, 165, 330, 330, 284, 409, 192, 362, 237, 255, 102, 140, 367, 313, 124, 349], [1926, 667, 553, 500, 610, 503, 625, 444, 581, 500, 664, 546, 680, 642, 540, 498, 562, 337, 0, 562, 516, 267, 552, 176, 432, 311, 247, 553, 553, 507, 632, 529, 585, 460, 478, 260, 363, 591, 537, 256, 573], [1919, 104, 332, 310, 48, 150, 63, 169, 82, 147, 101, 190, 309, 80, 169, 283, 61, 349, 516, 0, 78, 362, 377, 432, 558, 384, 268, 336, 381, 136, 261, 542, 85, 218, 196, 398, 355, 418, 318, 344, 219], [1824, 174, 342, 319, 118, 116, 133, 135, 89, 112, 171, 158, 275, 150, 135, 291, 70, 315, 482, 70, 0, 328, 346, 398, 526, 350, 235, 347, 347, 102, 226, 507, 93, 184, 161, 364, 321, 384, 330, 306, 185], [1889, 480, 366, 314, 424, 316, 438, 258, 394, 313, 477, 359, 494, 455, 354, 311, 375, 116, 295, 375, 329, 0, 366, 211, 326, 142, 111, 367, 367, 321, 445, 308, 398, 274, 292, 176, 177, 404, 350, 52, 386], [1866, 479, 345, 295, 423, 316, 437, 257, 394, 313, 476, 356, 493, 454, 353, 292, 374, 314, 480, 372, 328, 327, 0, 397, 522, 349, 233, 345, 143, 320, 444, 506, 398, 273, 291, 363, 320, 38, 327, 309, 385], [2015, 610, 497, 444, 554, 447, 568, 388, 525, 444, 607, 490, 624, 585, 484, 441, 505, 281, 183, 506, 460, 210, 496, 0, 491, 254, 190, 497, 497, 451, 576, 473, 529, 404, 422, 204, 307, 534, 480, 200, 516], [1845, 681, 568, 515, 625, 518, 640, 459, 596, 515, 678, 561, 695, 657, 555, 512, 577, 238, 418, 577, 531, 348, 564, 504, 0, 297, 402, 568, 568, 522, 647, 116, 600, 475, 493, 340, 378, 605, 547, 362, 588], [1825, 490, 377, 324, 434, 327, 449, 268, 405, 324, 487, 370, 504, 466, 364, 321, 386, 51, 322, 386, 340, 154, 376, 238, 262, 0, 171, 377, 377, 331, 456, 243, 409, 284, 302, 43, 187, 414, 360, 180, 396], [1917, 512, 399, 346, 456, 349, 471, 289, 426, 346, 509, 391, 526, 488, 386, 343, 408, 183, 246, 407, 362, 112, 397, 163, 392, 179, 0, 399, 399, 353, 478, 375, 431, 306, 324, 129, 209, 436, 381, 68, 418], [1745, 385, 243, 103, 373, 342, 343, 283, 316, 339, 426, 384, 519, 360, 379, 94, 275, 360, 526, 325, 354, 373, 370, 443, 571, 395, 281, 0, 374, 346, 470, 552, 282, 299, 317, 409, 366, 411, 17, 355, 411], [1855, 468, 337, 284, 412, 305, 426, 246, 383, 302, 465, 348, 482, 443, 342, 281, 363, 303, 470, 364, 318, 316, 112, 386, 514, 338, 223, 337, 0, 309, 434, 495, 387, 262, 280, 352, 309, 150, 320, 294, 374], [1860, 257, 425, 290, 200, 150, 215, 110, 171, 108, 254, 154, 213, 232, 73, 287, 152, 291, 457, 152, 106, 303, 322, 374, 501, 326, 210, 342, 322, 0, 164, 483, 175, 160, 137, 339, 297, 360, 326, 281, 181], [1974, 370, 538, 403, 313, 224, 328, 223, 284, 221, 367, 267, 48, 345, 121, 400, 265, 404, 570, 265, 219, 416, 435, 487, 614, 439, 324, 456, 436, 173, 0, 596, 288, 273, 250, 452, 410, 473, 439, 394, 294], [1905, 643, 530, 477, 587, 480, 601, 421, 558, 477, 640, 522, 657, 618, 517, 474, 538, 200, 484, 539, 492, 309, 529, 465, 125, 259, 365, 530, 530, 484, 608, 0, 562, 437, 455, 302, 340, 567, 513, 324, 549], [1731, 133, 250, 226, 121, 184, 91, 203, 64, 181, 174, 227, 343, 108, 203, 198, 23, 367, 533, 76, 112, 379, 379, 449, 577, 401, 286, 254, 380, 170, 295, 559, 0, 252, 230, 415, 372, 418, 237, 357, 254], [1808, 294, 290, 238, 238, 131, 252, 72, 209, 128, 291, 173, 308, 269, 168, 235, 189, 239, 405, 190, 143, 251, 270, 322, 449, 274, 158, 290, 270, 135, 259, 431, 212, 0, 106, 287, 245, 308, 274, 229, 200], [1808, 300, 289, 237, 243, 136, 258, 24, 214, 133, 297, 179, 314, 275, 174, 234, 195, 238, 404, 195, 149, 250, 269, 321, 448, 273, 158, 290, 270, 140, 265, 430, 218, 107, 0, 287, 244, 307, 273, 228, 206], [1875, 541, 427, 374, 484, 377, 499, 318, 455, 374, 538, 420, 554, 516, 414, 372, 436, 102, 279, 436, 390, 147, 426, 195, 312, 50, 128, 427, 427, 381, 506, 294, 459, 334, 352, 0, 237, 465, 411, 137, 447], [1840, 436, 322, 270, 379, 272, 394, 214, 350, 269, 433, 315, 450, 411, 310, 267, 331, 147, 362, 331, 285, 159, 322, 278, 357, 181, 178, 322, 323, 276, 401, 339, 354, 230, 248, 224, 0, 360, 306, 137, 342], [1904, 517, 386, 333, 461, 354, 476, 295, 432, 351, 514, 397, 531, 492, 391, 330, 412, 352, 519, 413, 367, 365, 38, 435, 563, 387, 272, 386, 181, 358, 483, 544, 436, 311, 329, 401, 358, 0, 369, 343, 423], [1729, 368, 226, 86, 356, 325, 326, 266, 299, 322, 410, 365, 502, 343, 362, 77, 258, 343, 510, 308, 338, 356, 353, 426, 554, 378, 262, 16, 357, 329, 454, 536, 265, 282, 300, 392, 349, 394, 0, 338, 394], [1877, 472, 361, 306, 416, 308, 430, 250, 386, 305, 469, 351, 486, 447, 346, 303, 367, 142, 267, 365, 321, 54, 355, 183, 353, 177, 74, 362, 359, 313, 437, 335, 390, 266, 284, 149, 169, 396, 338, 0, 378], [1890, 315, 382, 330, 258, 92, 273, 150, 229, 86, 312, 34, 308, 290, 168, 327, 210, 331, 497, 210, 164, 343, 362, 414, 541, 366, 250, 382, 362, 135, 260, 523, 233, 200, 177, 379, 337, 400, 366, 321, 0]]}, "reference": {"optimum_s": 18549, "optimality": "best_found", "lower_bound_s": 16567, "floor_s": 13880, "solve_s": 83.31, "ffd_s": 22489, "stop_aware_best_s": 20976, "stop_aware_mean_s": 21678.2, "route_id": "RouteID_59a577b4-9b30-48e2-9038-d1da8e695d7e", "plans": {"optimum": [{"route": ["S28", "S22", "S37", "S33", "S20", "S19", "S10", "S04", "S13", "S06", "S01", "S08", "S16", "S32"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S02", "S26", "S39", "S21", "S36"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S24", "S31", "S17", "S25", "S35", "S23", "S18"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S11", "S40", "S09", "S05", "S29", "S14", "S30", "S12", "S34", "S07", "S15", "S03", "S38", "S27"], "parcels": []}], "ffd": [{"route": ["S18", "S21", "S31"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S03", "S38", "S01", "S07", "S33", "S22", "S26", "S24"], "parcels": ["P09", "P29", "P32", "P35", "P52"]}, {"route": ["S16", "S08", "S06", "S29", "S30", "S11", "S07", "S37", "S39", "S35", "S17", "S02"], "parcels": ["P08", "P10", "P15", "P54"]}, {"route": ["S15", "S38", "S27", "S32", "S08", "S13", "S10", "S04", "S19", "S20", "S09", "S11", "S40", "S05", "S14", "S12", "S34", "S28", "S22", "S26", "S23", "S39", "S36", "S25", "S24"], "parcels": ["P11", "P12", "P16", "P28", "P31", "P33", "P36", "P37", "P51", "P53"]}], "stop_aware_best": [{"route": ["S16", "S08", "S11", "S40", "S18", "S31"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S02", "S15", "S38", "S27", "S01", "S06", "S10", "S14", "S33", "S35", "S17", "S24"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S32", "S19", "S05", "S34", "S28", "S22", "S37", "S36", "S39", "S21", "S25"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S13", "S04", "S20", "S09", "S29", "S12", "S30", "S07", "S26", "S23", "S03"], "parcels": []}]}}, "meta": {"route_id": "RouteID_59a577b4-9b30-48e2-9038-d1da8e695d7e", "split": "train", "stops": 40, "vans": 4, "tightness": 0.93, "station": "DSE4", "city": "DSE", "date": "2018-07-31", "seconds": 145.1, "stop_aware_best_reward": 0.4891, "optimality": "best_found"}}
{"id": "b31ea4e5-spread-n25-k3-t0.87-s0", "instance": {"stops": ["S01", "S02", "S03", "S04", "S05", "S06", "S07", "S08", "S09", "S10", "S11", "S12", "S13", "S14", "S15", "S16", "S17", "S18", "S19", "S20", "S21", "S22", "S23", "S24", "S25"], "parcels": [{"id": "P01", "stop": "S01", "volume_dl": 267}, {"id": "P02", "stop": "S01", "volume_dl": 73}, {"id": "P03", "stop": "S02", "volume_dl": 36}, {"id": "P04", "stop": "S03", "volume_dl": 552}, {"id": "P05", "stop": "S04", "volume_dl": 309}, {"id": "P06", "stop": "S04", "volume_dl": 477}, {"id": "P07", "stop": "S04", "volume_dl": 125}, {"id": "P08", "stop": "S05", "volume_dl": 133}, {"id": "P09", "stop": "S06", "volume_dl": 403}, {"id": "P10", "stop": "S07", "volume_dl": 92}, {"id": "P11", "stop": "S07", "volume_dl": 102}, {"id": "P12", "stop": "S07", "volume_dl": 133}, {"id": "P13", "stop": "S07", "volume_dl": 34}, {"id": "P14", "stop": "S07", "volume_dl": 104}, {"id": "P15", "stop": "S08", "volume_dl": 14}, {"id": "P16", "stop": "S08", "volume_dl": 452}, {"id": "P17", "stop": "S09", "volume_dl": 157}, {"id": "P18", "stop": "S10", "volume_dl": 179}, {"id": "P19", "stop": "S11", "volume_dl": 133}, {"id": "P20", "stop": "S11", "volume_dl": 104}, {"id": "P21", "stop": "S12", "volume_dl": 322}, {"id": "P22", "stop": "S12", "volume_dl": 542}, {"id": "P23", "stop": "S12", "volume_dl": 157}, {"id": "P24", "stop": "S12", "volume_dl": 92}, {"id": "P25", "stop": "S12", "volume_dl": 57}, {"id": "P26", "stop": "S13", "volume_dl": 12}, {"id": "P27", "stop": "S13", "volume_dl": 34}, {"id": "P28", "stop": "S13", "volume_dl": 7}, {"id": "P29", "stop": "S13", "volume_dl": 133}, {"id": "P30", "stop": "S14", "volume_dl": 95}, {"id": "P31", "stop": "S14", "volume_dl": 59}, {"id": "P32", "stop": "S14", "volume_dl": 94}, {"id": "P33", "stop": "S14", "volume_dl": 47}, {"id": "P34", "stop": "S14", "volume_dl": 4}, {"id": "P35", "stop": "S15", "volume_dl": 34}, {"id": "P36", "stop": "S16", "volume_dl": 462}, {"id": "P37", "stop": "S17", "volume_dl": 322}, {"id": "P38", "stop": "S18", "volume_dl": 104}, {"id": "P39", "stop": "S19", "volume_dl": 133}, {"id": "P40", "stop": "S20", "volume_dl": 6}, {"id": "P41", "stop": "S20", "volume_dl": 40}, {"id": "P42", "stop": "S20", "volume_dl": 40}, {"id": "P43", "stop": "S20", "volume_dl": 5}, {"id": "P44", "stop": "S20", "volume_dl": 41}, {"id": "P45", "stop": "S20", "volume_dl": 4}, {"id": "P46", "stop": "S20", "volume_dl": 57}, {"id": "P47", "stop": "S20", "volume_dl": 10}, {"id": "P48", "stop": "S21", "volume_dl": 92}, {"id": "P49", "stop": "S21", "volume_dl": 157}, {"id": "P50", "stop": "S22", "volume_dl": 157}, {"id": "P51", "stop": "S23", "volume_dl": 10}, {"id": "P52", "stop": "S23", "volume_dl": 10}, {"id": "P53", "stop": "S24", "volume_dl": 57}, {"id": "P54", "stop": "S24", "volume_dl": 26}, {"id": "P55", "stop": "S24", "volume_dl": 26}, {"id": "P56", "stop": "S24", "volume_dl": 57}, {"id": "P57", "stop": "S25", "volume_dl": 226}, {"id": "P58", "stop": "S25", "volume_dl": 104}], "vans": 3, "capacity_dl": 2957, "travel_s": [[0, 2643, 2711, 2619, 2534, 2502, 2480, 2623, 2629, 2709, 2526, 2657, 2667, 2730, 2558, 2726, 2670, 2674, 2733, 2705, 2519, 2627, 2612, 2616, 2587, 2660], [2496, 0, 68, 243, 97, 317, 456, 124, 102, 65, 342, 100, 50, 76, 146, 82, 179, 112, 90, 92, 128, 223, 118, 112, 170, 106], [2553, 75, 0, 318, 151, 375, 514, 210, 160, 65, 399, 180, 125, 62, 204, 48, 289, 188, 133, 128, 183, 274, 221, 105, 227, 203], [2539, 244, 311, 0, 355, 574, 714, 194, 281, 309, 599, 233, 268, 331, 408, 326, 156, 224, 266, 266, 383, 420, 183, 434, 282, 209], [2443, 107, 138, 350, 0, 264, 403, 234, 145, 156, 288, 210, 157, 100, 79, 140, 286, 219, 172, 178, 76, 131, 225, 78, 117, 213], [2522, 292, 374, 534, 235, 0, 296, 421, 330, 296, 25, 395, 342, 348, 259, 313, 466, 404, 357, 363, 220, 328, 410, 320, 288, 398], [2410, 328, 410, 570, 271, 97, 0, 457, 366, 332, 122, 431, 378, 384, 295, 349, 502, 440, 393, 399, 256, 364, 446, 356, 324, 434], [2615, 110, 209, 191, 207, 430, 570, 0, 213, 179, 455, 100, 94, 226, 260, 196, 141, 122, 186, 137, 238, 370, 8, 254, 268, 107], [2545, 101, 180, 290, 137, 366, 506, 214, 0, 115, 391, 152, 148, 188, 196, 132, 207, 100, 27, 95, 169, 272, 216, 216, 226, 114], [2489, 74, 65, 317, 86, 310, 449, 203, 113, 0, 334, 177, 124, 48, 139, 17, 253, 186, 140, 183, 118, 209, 193, 165, 163, 180], [2510, 280, 362, 522, 223, 25, 321, 409, 318, 284, 0, 383, 330, 336, 247, 301, 454, 392, 345, 351, 208, 316, 398, 308, 276, 386], [2595, 123, 176, 246, 192, 416, 555, 124, 148, 164, 441, 0, 62, 192, 246, 224, 126, 68, 116, 48, 224, 322, 117, 220, 220, 53], [2547, 48, 158, 248, 145, 368, 508, 116, 153, 117, 393, 82, 0, 166, 198, 134, 158, 96, 126, 76, 176, 274, 124, 202, 252, 85], [2533, 98, 60, 337, 131, 354, 493, 229, 185, 44, 379, 188, 133, 0, 195, 28, 309, 208, 153, 148, 162, 260, 240, 68, 207, 211], [2490, 137, 213, 377, 74, 311, 450, 261, 173, 138, 336, 237, 184, 175, 0, 155, 313, 246, 200, 205, 150, 133, 253, 153, 144, 240], [2505, 90, 48, 333, 102, 326, 465, 254, 129, 16, 351, 224, 169, 31, 156, 0, 333, 232, 177, 172, 134, 225, 209, 110, 179, 196], [2642, 234, 290, 146, 282, 502, 641, 142, 208, 255, 526, 132, 195, 310, 335, 272, 0, 156, 193, 194, 310, 347, 141, 361, 209, 112], [2607, 132, 188, 230, 205, 428, 567, 134, 100, 177, 453, 70, 74, 208, 258, 236, 118, 0, 73, 78, 236, 348, 133, 233, 211, 14], [2572, 97, 153, 303, 170, 394, 533, 184, 27, 142, 418, 120, 122, 172, 223, 201, 192, 73, 0, 68, 202, 343, 195, 198, 206, 87], [2574, 72, 128, 299, 171, 395, 534, 135, 94, 171, 420, 52, 75, 147, 225, 175, 192, 79, 68, 0, 203, 375, 146, 172, 238, 93], [2423, 163, 172, 406, 55, 244, 383, 290, 201, 190, 269, 266, 213, 134, 135, 174, 319, 275, 228, 234, 0, 187, 281, 112, 140, 269], [2518, 166, 241, 405, 91, 340, 479, 289, 196, 166, 364, 266, 202, 203, 90, 184, 297, 274, 228, 234, 179, 0, 281, 170, 125, 258], [2577, 162, 218, 182, 215, 439, 578, 11, 213, 187, 464, 91, 103, 237, 268, 204, 133, 113, 186, 139, 247, 396, 0, 262, 259, 99], [2512, 177, 123, 420, 69, 334, 473, 304, 210, 181, 358, 280, 227, 97, 149, 125, 356, 289, 242, 248, 103, 201, 295, 0, 187, 283], [2521, 168, 262, 301, 123, 343, 482, 267, 201, 172, 367, 268, 218, 224, 228, 189, 218, 239, 242, 239, 151, 138, 296, 202, 0, 254], [2622, 146, 202, 216, 219, 443, 582, 127, 114, 191, 467, 84, 89, 210, 272, 250, 103, 14, 87, 93, 251, 299, 119, 247, 196, 0]]}, "reference": {"optimum_s": 16808, "optimality": "best_found", "lower_bound_s": 15485, "floor_s": 14670, "solve_s": 35.16, "ffd_s": 18387, "stop_aware_best_s": 17970, "stop_aware_mean_s": 18036.8, "route_id": "RouteID_b31ea4e5-c1b7-44a5-9dd5-9428f5fd2c16", "plans": {"optimum": [{"route": ["S22", "S07", "S12", "S01", "S02", "S15", "S09", "S13", "S23", "S20"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S06", "S05", "S10", "S24", "S21", "S14", "S04"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S08", "S18", "S19", "S11", "S25", "S17", "S16", "S03"], "parcels": []}], "ffd": [{"route": ["S06", "S20", "S04", "S14", "S08", "S12", "S16", "S03"], "parcels": ["P06", "P16", "P22", "P31", "P47"]}, {"route": ["S05", "S10", "S21", "S04", "S01", "S12", "S07", "S22", "S25", "S17", "S11", "S19", "S02", "S13", "S09"], "parcels": ["P01", "P05", "P12", "P19", "P21", "P23", "P29", "P49", "P57"]}, {"route": ["S24", "S21", "S14", "S01", "S12", "S07", "S11", "S25", "S18", "S08", "S15", "S13", "S23", "S04", "S20"], "parcels": ["P02", "P07", "P10", "P11", "P13", "P14", "P15", "P20", "P24", "P25", "P26", "P27", "P28", "P30", "P32", "P33", "P34", "P40", "P41", "P42", "P43", "P44", "P45", "P46", "P48", "P58"]}], "stop_aware_best": [{"route": ["S10", "S24", "S02", "S12", "S19", "S18", "S25", "S03"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S06", "S05", "S21", "S14", "S15", "S13", "S01", "S16"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S07", "S22", "S11", "S17", "S08", "S09", "S04", "S23", "S20"], "parcels": []}]}}, "meta": {"route_id": "RouteID_b31ea4e5-c1b7-44a5-9dd5-9428f5fd2c16", "split": "train", "stops": 25, "vans": 3, "tightness": 0.87, "station": "DSE4", "city": "DSE", "date": "2018-08-06", "seconds": 95.4, "stop_aware_best_reward": 0.4832, "optimality": "best_found"}}
{"id": "743bb359-spread-n40-k4-t0.85-s0", "instance": {"stops": ["S01", "S02", "S03", "S04", "S05", "S06", "S07", "S08", "S09", "S10", "S11", "S12", "S13", "S14", "S15", "S16", "S17", "S18", "S19", "S20", "S21", "S22", "S23", "S24", "S25", "S26", "S27", "S28", "S29", "S30", "S31", "S32", "S33", "S34", "S35", "S36", "S37", "S38", "S39", "S40"], "parcels": [{"id": "P01", "stop": "S01", "volume_dl": 157}, {"id": "P02", "stop": "S02", "volume_dl": 179}, {"id": "P03", "stop": "S02", "volume_dl": 388}, {"id": "P04", "stop": "S03", "volume_dl": 95}, {"id": "P05", "stop": "S04", "volume_dl": 179}, {"id": "P06", "stop": "S05", "volume_dl": 11}, {"id": "P07", "stop": "S06", "volume_dl": 179}, {"id": "P08", "stop": "S07", "volume_dl": 59}, {"id": "P09", "stop": "S08", "volume_dl": 429}, {"id": "P10", "stop": "S09", "volume_dl": 39}, {"id": "P11", "stop": "S10", "volume_dl": 226}, {"id": "P12", "stop": "S11", "volume_dl": 134}, {"id": "P13", "stop": "S12", "volume_dl": 133}, {"id": "P14", "stop": "S13", "volume_dl": 179}, {"id": "P15", "stop": "S14", "volume_dl": 179}, {"id": "P16", "stop": "S15", "volume_dl": 226}, {"id": "P17", "stop": "S16", "volume_dl": 37}, {"id": "P18", "stop": "S16", "volume_dl": 57}, {"id": "P19", "stop": "S17", "volume_dl": 34}, {"id": "P20", "stop": "S18", "volume_dl": 57}, {"id": "P21", "stop": "S19", "volume_dl": 133}, {"id": "P22", "stop": "S20", "volume_dl": 104}, {"id": "P23", "stop": "S21", "volume_dl": 315}, {"id": "P24", "stop": "S22", "volume_dl": 928}, {"id": "P25", "stop": "S23", "volume_dl": 13}, {"id": "P26", "stop": "S24", "volume_dl": 60}, {"id": "P27", "stop": "S25", "volume_dl": 17}, {"id": "P28", "stop": "S26", "volume_dl": 177}, {"id": "P29", "stop": "S27", "volume_dl": 157}, {"id": "P30", "stop": "S28", "volume_dl": 28}, {"id": "P31", "stop": "S29", "volume_dl": 16}, {"id": "P32", "stop": "S30", "volume_dl": 57}, {"id": "P33", "stop": "S31", "volume_dl": 133}, {"id": "P34", "stop": "S32", "volume_dl": 25}, {"id": "P35", "stop": "S32", "volume_dl": 43}, {"id": "P36", "stop": "S33", "volume_dl": 322}, {"id": "P37", "stop": "S34", "volume_dl": 11}, {"id": "P38", "stop": "S35", "volume_dl": 9}, {"id": "P39", "stop": "S35", "volume_dl": 12}, {"id": "P40", "stop": "S36", "volume_dl": 27}, {"id": "P41", "stop": "S37", "volume_dl": 133}, {"id": "P42", "stop": "S37", "volume_dl": 226}, {"id": "P43", "stop": "S38", "volume_dl": 133}, {"id": "P44", "stop": "S39", "volume_dl": 44}, {"id": "P45", "stop": "S40", "volume_dl": 76}], "vans": 4, "capacity_dl": 1817, "travel_s": [[0, 1673, 1748, 1813, 1678, 1982, 1875, 2002, 1846, 1966, 1786, 1939, 2027, 1666, 1637, 1945, 1890, 1907, 1953, 1852, 1794, 1883, 1928, 1596, 1878, 1897, 1875, 1903, 1806, 1716, 1904, 1963, 1935, 1974, 1919, 1588, 1630, 1830, 1963, 1892, 1862], [1847, 0, 337, 383, 178, 660, 386, 593, 692, 546, 345, 505, 618, 403, 226, 460, 400, 417, 544, 660, 382, 475, 435, 294, 405, 486, 385, 647, 624, 216, 495, 497, 526, 563, 508, 302, 384, 250, 553, 410, 333], [1839, 393, 0, 368, 397, 323, 595, 456, 834, 594, 565, 714, 480, 386, 131, 669, 610, 626, 407, 802, 45, 684, 483, 277, 433, 149, 594, 694, 766, 435, 253, 544, 389, 226, 171, 285, 367, 679, 600, 447, 417], [1867, 364, 366, 0, 397, 190, 447, 209, 466, 226, 489, 518, 234, 599, 373, 521, 462, 478, 160, 434, 320, 489, 115, 490, 65, 256, 446, 326, 398, 375, 112, 176, 142, 198, 371, 498, 580, 311, 232, 79, 49], [1883, 175, 372, 451, 0, 641, 304, 660, 610, 614, 274, 423, 685, 438, 261, 378, 319, 336, 611, 579, 418, 394, 503, 329, 472, 521, 304, 714, 543, 38, 563, 564, 593, 598, 543, 337, 419, 259, 620, 477, 401], [2014, 558, 344, 194, 591, 0, 641, 281, 659, 419, 682, 712, 306, 731, 520, 715, 655, 672, 232, 628, 299, 682, 308, 622, 259, 234, 640, 520, 592, 568, 90, 370, 214, 177, 349, 630, 712, 505, 426, 273, 242], [2044, 336, 533, 444, 262, 634, 0, 654, 427, 474, 230, 239, 679, 599, 422, 134, 135, 86, 605, 395, 579, 210, 496, 490, 466, 682, 120, 533, 359, 240, 556, 470, 587, 643, 704, 498, 580, 252, 480, 471, 394], [2062, 624, 466, 260, 657, 290, 707, 0, 684, 485, 748, 835, 98, 794, 568, 781, 721, 738, 222, 690, 420, 806, 374, 685, 325, 356, 706, 586, 644, 634, 212, 436, 80, 298, 471, 693, 775, 571, 492, 339, 308], [1907, 642, 822, 456, 568, 646, 446, 666, 0, 292, 502, 324, 691, 905, 728, 465, 296, 489, 617, 71, 777, 294, 351, 796, 472, 712, 386, 270, 132, 545, 568, 289, 599, 655, 827, 804, 886, 558, 299, 493, 462], [2014, 530, 574, 208, 562, 398, 479, 417, 301, 0, 535, 357, 442, 807, 581, 498, 329, 522, 369, 272, 529, 327, 102, 698, 224, 464, 419, 100, 261, 540, 320, 40, 351, 406, 579, 706, 788, 476, 6, 244, 214], [1826, 351, 548, 485, 307, 675, 221, 694, 501, 548, 0, 278, 720, 614, 437, 295, 235, 252, 646, 469, 594, 222, 537, 505, 507, 697, 220, 608, 434, 284, 597, 599, 628, 684, 720, 513, 595, 293, 554, 512, 435], [2005, 536, 734, 523, 462, 713, 235, 732, 312, 359, 247, 0, 757, 799, 622, 252, 117, 235, 684, 280, 779, 40, 417, 690, 538, 882, 208, 418, 244, 440, 635, 355, 665, 721, 905, 698, 780, 452, 366, 559, 595], [2150, 664, 477, 300, 697, 301, 747, 88, 772, 526, 788, 818, 0, 863, 656, 821, 761, 778, 233, 778, 432, 788, 415, 754, 365, 367, 746, 626, 732, 674, 223, 476, 92, 309, 482, 762, 844, 611, 532, 379, 348], [1769, 408, 364, 656, 412, 686, 610, 845, 916, 882, 580, 729, 870, 0, 296, 684, 625, 641, 796, 885, 409, 700, 771, 94, 722, 512, 610, 983, 849, 450, 617, 833, 778, 590, 535, 86, 165, 565, 889, 736, 705], [1686, 261, 111, 479, 266, 434, 464, 567, 770, 705, 433, 583, 592, 302, 0, 538, 478, 495, 518, 738, 156, 553, 594, 193, 544, 260, 463, 805, 702, 304, 364, 656, 500, 337, 282, 201, 283, 418, 711, 558, 528], [2036, 396, 593, 504, 322, 694, 113, 714, 432, 479, 279, 244, 739, 659, 482, 0, 140, 114, 665, 400, 639, 215, 557, 550, 526, 742, 141, 538, 364, 300, 616, 475, 647, 703, 764, 558, 640, 312, 485, 531, 455], [2052, 345, 542, 453, 271, 643, 149, 663, 290, 337, 238, 103, 688, 608, 431, 168, 0, 181, 614, 259, 588, 74, 396, 499, 475, 691, 90, 397, 223, 249, 565, 334, 596, 652, 713, 507, 589, 261, 344, 480, 403], [2006, 353, 550, 461, 279, 651, 51, 670, 443, 490, 248, 256, 695, 616, 439, 120, 152, 0, 622, 412, 595, 226, 513, 507, 482, 699, 136, 550, 376, 256, 573, 486, 604, 660, 721, 515, 597, 269, 497, 488, 411], [2053, 597, 410, 232, 629, 234, 680, 191, 698, 458, 721, 750, 216, 796, 559, 753, 694, 711, 0, 666, 364, 721, 347, 687, 297, 299, 679, 559, 803, 607, 156, 409, 124, 242, 414, 695, 777, 543, 465, 311, 281], [1884, 593, 774, 408, 519, 598, 397, 617, 61, 244, 453, 275, 642, 856, 679, 416, 247, 440, 568, 0, 728, 245, 302, 747, 423, 663, 338, 247, 83, 496, 519, 240, 550, 606, 778, 755, 837, 509, 250, 444, 413], [1884, 438, 46, 323, 443, 277, 770, 410, 788, 548, 610, 841, 435, 432, 177, 844, 784, 801, 362, 757, 0, 811, 438, 323, 388, 103, 769, 649, 721, 481, 208, 499, 343, 180, 126, 331, 413, 634, 555, 402, 371], [1965, 430, 627, 489, 355, 679, 195, 699, 278, 325, 208, 56, 724, 692, 516, 212, 83, 195, 650, 247, 672, 0, 384, 584, 505, 745, 174, 385, 211, 333, 601, 322, 632, 688, 798, 592, 674, 346, 332, 526, 488], [1972, 427, 472, 106, 460, 296, 526, 315, 351, 111, 581, 403, 340, 704, 478, 545, 375, 569, 266, 319, 426, 374, 0, 595, 121, 361, 466, 211, 283, 437, 217, 62, 248, 304, 476, 603, 685, 374, 117, 142, 111], [1675, 314, 270, 563, 319, 593, 517, 751, 823, 789, 486, 636, 776, 109, 203, 590, 531, 548, 703, 791, 316, 606, 678, 0, 628, 419, 516, 889, 755, 357, 523, 739, 685, 496, 441, 8, 90, 471, 795, 642, 612], [1923, 396, 422, 56, 429, 246, 479, 265, 459, 220, 521, 512, 290, 654, 428, 553, 484, 510, 216, 428, 376, 482, 109, 545, 0, 311, 478, 320, 392, 407, 168, 170, 198, 254, 426, 553, 635, 343, 226, 111, 81], [1998, 613, 159, 248, 645, 203, 695, 336, 714, 474, 737, 766, 361, 546, 291, 769, 710, 727, 287, 682, 114, 737, 363, 437, 313, 0, 695, 574, 646, 623, 133, 425, 269, 106, 164, 445, 527, 559, 480, 327, 297], [2030, 322, 519, 430, 248, 620, 126, 640, 394, 440, 216, 206, 665, 585, 408, 161, 102, 158, 591, 362, 565, 177, 482, 476, 452, 668, 0, 500, 326, 226, 542, 437, 573, 629, 690, 484, 566, 238, 447, 457, 380], [1955, 639, 684, 318, 637, 508, 516, 527, 242, 110, 571, 393, 552, 974, 690, 535, 365, 559, 478, 248, 638, 364, 212, 866, 333, 573, 456, 0, 202, 615, 430, 150, 460, 516, 688, 874, 956, 586, 103, 354, 324], [1861, 540, 721, 354, 466, 544, 344, 564, 118, 190, 400, 222, 589, 803, 626, 363, 194, 387, 515, 86, 675, 192, 249, 694, 370, 610, 284, 291, 0, 443, 466, 187, 497, 553, 725, 702, 784, 456, 197, 391, 360], [1977, 225, 422, 428, 50, 618, 281, 637, 587, 591, 251, 400, 662, 488, 311, 355, 296, 312, 588, 556, 468, 370, 480, 379, 449, 571, 280, 691, 520, 0, 540, 541, 570, 648, 594, 387, 469, 235, 597, 454, 378], [1936, 479, 254, 115, 512, 70, 562, 202, 580, 341, 604, 633, 227, 640, 386, 636, 577, 593, 154, 549, 208, 604, 230, 532, 180, 144, 561, 441, 513, 490, 0, 291, 136, 86, 259, 540, 622, 426, 347, 194, 164], [2035, 489, 534, 168, 522, 358, 464, 377, 289, 49, 520, 342, 402, 766, 540, 483, 314, 507, 328, 257, 488, 312, 62, 657, 183, 423, 404, 150, 221, 500, 280, 0, 310, 366, 538, 665, 747, 436, 56, 204, 174], [2029, 572, 386, 208, 605, 209, 655, 90, 758, 434, 697, 726, 111, 772, 534, 729, 670, 686, 141, 642, 340, 697, 323, 663, 273, 275, 655, 534, 718, 583, 131, 385, 0, 218, 390, 671, 753, 519, 440, 287, 257], [2010, 553, 234, 189, 586, 144, 636, 276, 654, 415, 678, 707, 301, 620, 366, 710, 651, 667, 228, 623, 189, 678, 304, 512, 254, 124, 635, 515, 587, 564, 74, 365, 210, 0, 239, 520, 602, 500, 421, 268, 238], [1993, 547, 154, 375, 551, 330, 823, 463, 841, 601, 719, 894, 488, 540, 285, 897, 837, 854, 414, 809, 108, 864, 490, 431, 440, 156, 822, 702, 774, 589, 260, 552, 396, 233, 0, 439, 521, 686, 608, 455, 424], [1683, 322, 278, 571, 327, 601, 525, 759, 831, 797, 494, 644, 784, 101, 211, 598, 539, 556, 711, 799, 324, 614, 686, 8, 636, 427, 524, 897, 763, 365, 531, 747, 693, 504, 449, 0, 82, 479, 803, 650, 620], [1755, 394, 350, 643, 399, 673, 597, 831, 903, 869, 566, 716, 856, 151, 283, 670, 611, 628, 783, 871, 396, 686, 758, 80, 708, 499, 596, 969, 835, 437, 603, 819, 765, 576, 521, 72, 0, 551, 875, 722, 692], [1977, 269, 466, 321, 195, 511, 245, 531, 551, 484, 287, 364, 556, 532, 355, 319, 260, 276, 482, 520, 512, 335, 373, 423, 343, 615, 245, 585, 484, 173, 433, 435, 464, 520, 638, 431, 513, 0, 491, 348, 271], [2008, 537, 581, 215, 569, 405, 486, 424, 294, 7, 542, 364, 449, 814, 588, 505, 336, 529, 376, 279, 536, 334, 109, 705, 230, 471, 426, 94, 254, 547, 327, 47, 358, 413, 586, 713, 795, 483, 0, 251, 221], [1959, 384, 459, 92, 417, 282, 467, 302, 495, 255, 508, 586, 327, 715, 538, 541, 481, 498, 253, 464, 413, 556, 144, 606, 114, 348, 466, 356, 428, 394, 204, 206, 235, 291, 463, 614, 696, 331, 262, 0, 68], [1917, 316, 416, 50, 348, 240, 398, 259, 453, 213, 440, 505, 284, 647, 423, 472, 413, 430, 210, 421, 370, 476, 102, 538, 71, 305, 398, 313, 385, 326, 162, 164, 192, 248, 421, 546, 628, 262, 219, 105, 0]]}, "reference": {"optimum_s": 19038, "optimality": "best_found", "lower_bound_s": 16537, "floor_s": 13052, "solve_s": 62.7, "ffd_s": 22539, "stop_aware_best_s": 21953, "stop_aware_mean_s": 22202.8, "route_id": "RouteID_743bb359-f47c-416d-920f-499b05cfb8af", "plans": {"optimum": [{"route": ["S01", "S14", "S02", "S23", "S36", "S13", "S35"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S04", "S29", "S06", "S17", "S15", "S16", "S11", "S21", "S28", "S19", "S08"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S20", "S34", "S25", "S33", "S30", "S05", "S18", "S32", "S12", "S07", "S39", "S40", "S37", "S26", "S10"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S03", "S24", "S22", "S31", "S09", "S38", "S27"], "parcels": []}], "ffd": [{"route": ["S35", "S02", "S24", "S22", "S08"], "parcels": ["P03", "P39"]}, {"route": ["S35", "S02", "S33", "S37", "S04", "S15", "S11", "S21", "S10"], "parcels": ["P02", "P38", "P42"]}, {"route": ["S01", "S37", "S06", "S26", "S19", "S27", "S38", "S31", "S12", "S25", "S20", "S14", "S13"], "parcels": ["P41"]}, {"route": ["S29", "S17", "S16", "S28", "S09", "S39", "S40", "S03", "S18", "S07", "S32", "S30", "S05", "S34", "S36", "S23"], "parcels": []}], "stop_aware_best": [{"route": ["S36", "S13", "S01", "S29", "S31", "S24", "S12", "S25", "S34", "S14"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S35", "S20", "S33", "S05", "S18", "S07", "S39", "S22", "S27"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S23", "S04", "S37", "S06", "S17", "S15", "S16", "S11", "S21", "S09", "S38", "S32"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S02", "S30", "S03", "S40", "S08", "S19", "S28", "S26", "S10"], "parcels": []}]}}, "meta": {"route_id": "RouteID_743bb359-f47c-416d-920f-499b05cfb8af", "split": "train", "stops": 40, "vans": 4, "tightness": 0.85, "station": "DBO3", "city": "DBO", "date": "2018-08-15", "seconds": 95.8, "stop_aware_best_reward": 0.5069, "optimality": "best_found"}}
{"id": "bc9642d5-spread-n25-k3-t0.94-s0", "instance": {"stops": ["S01", "S02", "S03", "S04", "S05", "S06", "S07", "S08", "S09", "S10", "S11", "S12", "S13", "S14", "S15", "S16", "S17", "S18", "S19", "S20", "S21", "S22", "S23", "S24", "S25"], "parcels": [{"id": "P01", "stop": "S01", "volume_dl": 95}, {"id": "P02", "stop": "S02", "volume_dl": 3}, {"id": "P03", "stop": "S03", "volume_dl": 226}, {"id": "P04", "stop": "S03", "volume_dl": 57}, {"id": "P05", "stop": "S04", "volume_dl": 265}, {"id": "P06", "stop": "S04", "volume_dl": 599}, {"id": "P07", "stop": "S05", "volume_dl": 277}, {"id": "P08", "stop": "S05", "volume_dl": 322}, {"id": "P09", "stop": "S06", "volume_dl": 104}, {"id": "P10", "stop": "S07", "volume_dl": 477}, {"id": "P11", "stop": "S08", "volume_dl": 37}, {"id": "P12", "stop": "S09", "volume_dl": 322}, {"id": "P13", "stop": "S10", "volume_dl": 95}, {"id": "P14", "stop": "S11", "volume_dl": 92}, {"id": "P15", "stop": "S12", "volume_dl": 92}, {"id": "P16", "stop": "S13", "volume_dl": 34}, {"id": "P17", "stop": "S14", "volume_dl": 57}, {"id": "P18", "stop": "S14", "volume_dl": 12}, {"id": "P19", "stop": "S15", "volume_dl": 104}, {"id": "P20", "stop": "S16", "volume_dl": 59}, {"id": "P21", "stop": "S17", "volume_dl": 157}, {"id": "P22", "stop": "S18", "volume_dl": 157}, {"id": "P23", "stop": "S19", "volume_dl": 542}, {"id": "P24", "stop": "S19", "volume_dl": 134}, {"id": "P25", "stop": "S19", "volume_dl": 95}, {"id": "P26", "stop": "S20", "volume_dl": 59}, {"id": "P27", "stop": "S20", "volume_dl": 57}, {"id": "P28", "stop": "S21", "volume_dl": 67}, {"id": "P29", "stop": "S22", "volume_dl": 157}, {"id": "P30", "stop": "S23", "volume_dl": 95}, {"id": "P31", "stop": "S24", "volume_dl": 179}, {"id": "P32", "stop": "S25", "volume_dl": 133}], "vans": 3, "capacity_dl": 1832, "travel_s": [[0, 2230, 2293, 2235, 1543, 2121, 2305, 2122, 2227, 2279, 1892, 1540, 2190, 2080, 2110, 2084, 1488, 2112, 2297, 2167, 2048, 2158, 2284, 2357, 1907, 2051], [2338, 0, 251, 193, 920, 286, 689, 464, 847, 237, 650, 923, 810, 278, 357, 168, 954, 448, 255, 307, 230, 298, 786, 154, 775, 365], [2382, 252, 0, 200, 965, 452, 734, 655, 891, 202, 841, 966, 854, 411, 440, 212, 988, 493, 220, 498, 246, 489, 830, 406, 966, 410], [2336, 206, 189, 0, 919, 406, 688, 609, 845, 175, 794, 920, 808, 364, 394, 166, 942, 447, 193, 451, 200, 443, 784, 360, 920, 363], [1653, 901, 965, 907, 0, 793, 977, 960, 899, 951, 661, 380, 862, 752, 782, 756, 258, 784, 969, 839, 720, 830, 956, 1029, 676, 722], [2244, 296, 455, 397, 905, 0, 598, 243, 756, 441, 428, 702, 719, 51, 131, 246, 733, 358, 459, 85, 210, 77, 695, 283, 520, 274], [2355, 650, 714, 656, 937, 542, 0, 746, 462, 700, 931, 938, 425, 501, 531, 505, 960, 206, 718, 588, 469, 579, 314, 778, 1056, 336], [2122, 462, 645, 587, 894, 250, 789, 0, 946, 631, 390, 667, 909, 242, 321, 436, 722, 548, 649, 154, 400, 164, 885, 448, 544, 464], [2327, 868, 932, 874, 909, 760, 494, 963, 0, 918, 1149, 910, 49, 719, 748, 723, 932, 447, 936, 806, 687, 797, 383, 996, 1078, 534], [2369, 239, 222, 186, 951, 438, 720, 642, 878, 0, 827, 952, 841, 397, 427, 199, 974, 480, 43, 484, 232, 476, 817, 393, 953, 396], [1969, 653, 836, 778, 610, 441, 980, 384, 1135, 822, 0, 406, 1098, 433, 512, 627, 438, 739, 840, 346, 591, 356, 1076, 639, 259, 655], [1545, 892, 956, 898, 296, 784, 968, 660, 890, 942, 404, 0, 853, 743, 773, 747, 66, 775, 960, 637, 711, 647, 947, 931, 420, 714], [2274, 815, 879, 821, 856, 707, 441, 910, 53, 865, 1096, 857, 0, 666, 695, 670, 879, 394, 883, 753, 634, 744, 330, 943, 1024, 481], [2196, 340, 404, 346, 906, 41, 547, 244, 704, 390, 430, 703, 667, 0, 79, 194, 734, 306, 408, 87, 158, 78, 643, 284, 555, 223], [2217, 361, 424, 367, 799, 132, 568, 335, 725, 411, 521, 794, 688, 91, 0, 216, 825, 327, 428, 178, 179, 169, 664, 375, 646, 244], [2170, 145, 209, 151, 752, 239, 521, 443, 679, 195, 628, 753, 642, 198, 228, 0, 775, 280, 213, 285, 33, 276, 618, 300, 754, 197], [1589, 916, 980, 922, 230, 808, 992, 716, 914, 966, 466, 56, 876, 767, 796, 771, 0, 799, 984, 698, 734, 708, 971, 992, 481, 737], [2217, 444, 508, 450, 799, 336, 241, 539, 422, 494, 725, 800, 385, 295, 324, 299, 822, 0, 512, 382, 263, 373, 337, 572, 850, 130], [2371, 240, 224, 188, 953, 440, 722, 644, 880, 46, 829, 954, 842, 399, 429, 201, 976, 481, 0, 486, 234, 477, 818, 395, 954, 398], [2158, 307, 490, 433, 819, 95, 634, 158, 791, 477, 343, 616, 754, 87, 166, 282, 647, 393, 494, 0, 245, 10, 730, 294, 468, 310], [2136, 181, 245, 187, 719, 206, 488, 409, 645, 231, 595, 720, 608, 165, 194, 36, 742, 247, 249, 252, 0, 243, 584, 336, 720, 164], [2167, 297, 481, 423, 828, 85, 624, 166, 782, 467, 352, 625, 744, 77, 156, 272, 656, 383, 485, 8, 236, 0, 720, 284, 477, 300], [2388, 751, 815, 757, 970, 643, 290, 846, 366, 801, 1032, 971, 329, 602, 631, 606, 993, 307, 819, 689, 570, 680, 0, 879, 1138, 437], [2487, 141, 393, 335, 1026, 284, 795, 463, 952, 379, 648, 921, 915, 276, 356, 309, 952, 554, 397, 305, 328, 296, 891, 0, 774, 471], [1956, 783, 942, 884, 596, 486, 1068, 550, 990, 928, 250, 393, 953, 538, 617, 732, 424, 876, 946, 483, 696, 493, 1048, 770, 0, 814], [2148, 362, 426, 368, 730, 254, 360, 458, 482, 412, 643, 731, 446, 213, 243, 217, 753, 167, 430, 300, 181, 291, 456, 490, 769, 0]]}, "reference": {"optimum_s": 16194, "optimality": "best_found", "lower_bound_s": 12097, "floor_s": 9099, "solve_s": 42.34, "ffd_s": 17980, "stop_aware_best_s": 18287, "stop_aware_mean_s": 18555.2, "route_id": "RouteID_bc9642d5-bdb8-4a8b-b62d-9b4fa08ae5f6", "plans": {"optimum": [{"route": ["S16", "S11", "S24", "S10", "S19", "S21", "S23", "S01", "S03", "S02", "S09", "S18", "S15", "S20"], "parcels": ["P24"]}, {"route": ["S14", "S13", "S05", "S19", "S07"], "parcels": ["P23", "P25"]}, {"route": ["S04", "S08", "S12", "S22", "S06", "S17", "S25"], "parcels": []}], "ffd": [{"route": ["S04", "S13", "S19", "S07", "S24"], "parcels": ["P06", "P23"]}, {"route": ["S04", "S05", "S03", "S09", "S18", "S17", "S06"], "parcels": ["P03", "P05"]}, {"route": ["S16", "S11", "S10", "S19", "S21", "S14", "S23", "S01", "S03", "S02", "S15", "S20", "S25", "S22", "S08", "S12"], "parcels": ["P04", "P24", "P25"]}], "stop_aware_best": [{"route": ["S08", "S22", "S25", "S03", "S23", "S21", "S07", "S24", "S16", "S11"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S12", "S06", "S17", "S02", "S09", "S18", "S20", "S14", "S13", "S19"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S04", "S15", "S01", "S05", "S10"], "parcels": []}]}}, "meta": {"route_id": "RouteID_bc9642d5-bdb8-4a8b-b62d-9b4fa08ae5f6", "split": "train", "stops": 25, "vans": 3, "tightness": 0.94, "station": "DBO3", "city": "DBO", "date": "2018-07-26", "seconds": 73.0, "stop_aware_best_reward": 0.6471, "optimality": "best_found"}}
{"id": "6fbdffbf-spread-n20-k3-t0.87-s0", "instance": {"stops": ["S01", "S02", "S03", "S04", "S05", "S06", "S07", "S08", "S09", "S10", "S11", "S12", "S13", "S14", "S15", "S16", "S17", "S18", "S19", "S20"], "parcels": [{"id": "P01", "stop": "S01", "volume_dl": 32}, {"id": "P02", "stop": "S01", "volume_dl": 22}, {"id": "P03", "stop": "S01", "volume_dl": 41}, {"id": "P04", "stop": "S02", "volume_dl": 104}, {"id": "P05", "stop": "S03", "volume_dl": 30}, {"id": "P06", "stop": "S04", "volume_dl": 58}, {"id": "P07", "stop": "S05", "volume_dl": 133}, {"id": "P08", "stop": "S05", "volume_dl": 322}, {"id": "P09", "stop": "S05", "volume_dl": 242}, {"id": "P10", "stop": "S06", "volume_dl": 104}, {"id": "P11", "stop": "S07", "volume_dl": 242}, {"id": "P12", "stop": "S08", "volume_dl": 11}, {"id": "P13", "stop": "S09", "volume_dl": 46}, {"id": "P14", "stop": "S10", "volume_dl": 63}, {"id": "P15", "stop": "S11", "volume_dl": 27}, {"id": "P16", "stop": "S12", "volume_dl": 63}, {"id": "P17", "stop": "S12", "volume_dl": 25}, {"id": "P18", "stop": "S13", "volume_dl": 46}, {"id": "P19", "stop": "S14", "volume_dl": 57}, {"id": "P20", "stop": "S14", "volume_dl": 95}, {"id": "P21", "stop": "S15", "volume_dl": 133}, {"id": "P22", "stop": "S16", "volume_dl": 59}, {"id": "P23", "stop": "S17", "volume_dl": 104}, {"id": "P24", "stop": "S17", "volume_dl": 429}, {"id": "P25", "stop": "S18", "volume_dl": 477}, {"id": "P26", "stop": "S19", "volume_dl": 133}, {"id": "P27", "stop": "S19", "volume_dl": 133}, {"id": "P28", "stop": "S20", "volume_dl": 65}], "vans": 3, "capacity_dl": 1264, "travel_s": [[0, 1516, 1441, 1364, 1567, 1375, 1462, 1410, 1345, 1426, 1507, 1412, 1342, 1468, 1454, 1439, 1369, 1535, 1499, 1447, 1436], [1530, 0, 483, 540, 744, 551, 666, 586, 521, 390, 711, 549, 518, 363, 433, 614, 416, 268, 223, 651, 640], [1486, 494, 0, 411, 615, 423, 515, 457, 393, 528, 560, 87, 390, 500, 248, 492, 121, 737, 404, 500, 488], [1447, 652, 436, 0, 296, 104, 218, 174, 44, 686, 263, 429, 107, 658, 471, 166, 386, 642, 562, 203, 192], [1566, 960, 630, 292, 0, 186, 156, 229, 287, 880, 151, 623, 249, 852, 665, 156, 580, 780, 756, 149, 171], [1455, 653, 444, 105, 192, 0, 114, 135, 100, 694, 160, 436, 86, 666, 477, 62, 394, 669, 570, 100, 88], [1468, 861, 505, 242, 146, 137, 0, 198, 237, 871, 45, 573, 218, 843, 616, 124, 531, 682, 925, 40, 26], [1490, 695, 478, 187, 224, 105, 164, 0, 172, 728, 210, 471, 80, 701, 513, 49, 428, 719, 604, 150, 138], [1428, 633, 416, 63, 290, 98, 213, 155, 0, 666, 258, 409, 87, 639, 451, 161, 366, 623, 542, 198, 187], [1438, 368, 521, 578, 782, 590, 704, 624, 560, 0, 749, 587, 557, 69, 424, 652, 454, 518, 261, 689, 678], [1510, 903, 547, 284, 147, 179, 42, 240, 279, 912, 0, 615, 260, 885, 657, 166, 572, 724, 967, 82, 68], [1530, 538, 103, 450, 653, 461, 564, 496, 431, 572, 609, 0, 428, 544, 292, 524, 205, 775, 448, 549, 538], [1410, 608, 399, 107, 269, 94, 208, 67, 92, 649, 254, 391, 0, 621, 434, 102, 349, 605, 525, 194, 182], [1470, 331, 484, 541, 744, 552, 667, 587, 522, 59, 712, 550, 519, 0, 434, 615, 417, 481, 224, 652, 641], [1343, 406, 248, 441, 644, 450, 567, 487, 422, 405, 612, 300, 417, 421, 0, 515, 176, 562, 324, 552, 541], [1456, 710, 494, 161, 175, 56, 116, 73, 157, 744, 161, 487, 94, 716, 529, 0, 444, 670, 620, 101, 90], [1410, 419, 98, 391, 594, 402, 516, 437, 372, 452, 562, 184, 369, 425, 173, 464, 0, 568, 328, 502, 490], [1565, 172, 503, 560, 764, 572, 686, 606, 542, 393, 732, 570, 539, 365, 452, 634, 436, 0, 243, 672, 660], [1448, 276, 260, 317, 521, 329, 443, 363, 298, 309, 488, 326, 296, 282, 210, 391, 193, 592, 0, 428, 417], [1463, 850, 576, 237, 176, 132, 30, 175, 232, 866, 75, 568, 195, 838, 609, 101, 526, 677, 921, 0, 21], [1442, 835, 479, 216, 172, 111, 26, 172, 211, 844, 71, 547, 192, 817, 589, 98, 504, 656, 899, 11, 0]]}, "reference": {"optimum_s": 10708, "optimality": "best_found", "lower_bound_s": 9783, "floor_s": 8055, "solve_s": 33.25, "ffd_s": 12747, "stop_aware_best_s": 12272, "stop_aware_mean_s": 12773.4, "route_id": "RouteID_6fbdffbf-bb2a-4128-a7b5-b3cf69e801b1", "plans": {"optimum": [{"route": ["S17", "S01", "S18", "S13", "S09"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S12", "S07", "S15", "S04", "S10", "S06", "S20", "S19"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S05", "S03", "S08", "S11", "S02", "S16", "S14"], "parcels": []}], "ffd": [{"route": ["S17", "S01", "S18", "S05"], "parcels": ["P01", "P08", "P24"]}, {"route": ["S02", "S03", "S07", "S15", "S05", "S19", "S06"], "parcels": ["P07", "P09"]}, {"route": ["S08", "S20", "S10", "S04", "S12", "S11", "S16", "S14", "S01", "S17", "S13", "S09"], "parcels": ["P02", "P03", "P23"]}], "stop_aware_best": [{"route": ["S19", "S06", "S05", "S12", "S16", "S13"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S09", "S18", "S02", "S14"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S17", "S01", "S11", "S03", "S08", "S07", "S15", "S04", "S10", "S20"], "parcels": []}]}}, "meta": {"route_id": "RouteID_6fbdffbf-bb2a-4128-a7b5-b3cf69e801b1", "split": "train", "stops": 20, "vans": 3, "tightness": 0.87, "station": "DLA7", "city": "DLA", "date": "2018-08-08", "seconds": 53.9, "stop_aware_best_reward": 0.4568, "optimality": "best_found"}}
{"id": "54a52d70-spread-n30-k4-t0.95-s0", "instance": {"stops": ["S01", "S02", "S03", "S04", "S05", "S06", "S07", "S08", "S09", "S10", "S11", "S12", "S13", "S14", "S15", "S16", "S17", "S18", "S19", "S20", "S21", "S22", "S23", "S24", "S25", "S26", "S27", "S28", "S29", "S30"], "parcels": [{"id": "P01", "stop": "S01", "volume_dl": 40}, {"id": "P02", "stop": "S02", "volume_dl": 31}, {"id": "P03", "stop": "S03", "volume_dl": 542}, {"id": "P04", "stop": "S03", "volume_dl": 134}, {"id": "P05", "stop": "S04", "volume_dl": 25}, {"id": "P06", "stop": "S05", "volume_dl": 12}, {"id": "P07", "stop": "S05", "volume_dl": 9}, {"id": "P08", "stop": "S06", "volume_dl": 14}, {"id": "P09", "stop": "S07", "volume_dl": 133}, {"id": "P10", "stop": "S07", "volume_dl": 44}, {"id": "P11", "stop": "S07", "volume_dl": 179}, {"id": "P12", "stop": "S08", "volume_dl": 38}, {"id": "P13", "stop": "S09", "volume_dl": 55}, {"id": "P14", "stop": "S10", "volume_dl": 157}, {"id": "P15", "stop": "S11", "volume_dl": 49}, {"id": "P16", "stop": "S11", "volume_dl": 92}, {"id": "P17", "stop": "S11", "volume_dl": 9}, {"id": "P18", "stop": "S11", "volume_dl": 29}, {"id": "P19", "stop": "S12", "volume_dl": 63}, {"id": "P20", "stop": "S12", "volume_dl": 53}, {"id": "P21", "stop": "S13", "volume_dl": 179}, {"id": "P22", "stop": "S14", "volume_dl": 95}, {"id": "P23", "stop": "S14", "volume_dl": 13}, {"id": "P24", "stop": "S15", "volume_dl": 16}, {"id": "P25", "stop": "S16", "volume_dl": 18}, {"id": "P26", "stop": "S17", "volume_dl": 126}, {"id": "P27", "stop": "S18", "volume_dl": 34}, {"id": "P28", "stop": "S19", "volume_dl": 324}, {"id": "P29", "stop": "S19", "volume_dl": 51}, {"id": "P30", "stop": "S19", "volume_dl": 26}, {"id": "P31", "stop": "S20", "volume_dl": 59}, {"id": "P32", "stop": "S21", "volume_dl": 3}, {"id": "P33", "stop": "S22", "volume_dl": 45}, {"id": "P34", "stop": "S22", "volume_dl": 322}, {"id": "P35", "stop": "S23", "volume_dl": 92}, {"id": "P36", "stop": "S24", "volume_dl": 56}, {"id": "P37", "stop": "S24", "volume_dl": 11}, {"id": "P38", "stop": "S25", "volume_dl": 368}, {"id": "P39", "stop": "S26", "volume_dl": 5}, {"id": "P40", "stop": "S27", "volume_dl": 81}, {"id": "P41", "stop": "S27", "volume_dl": 133}, {"id": "P42", "stop": "S28", "volume_dl": 55}, {"id": "P43", "stop": "S28", "volume_dl": 25}, {"id": "P44", "stop": "S29", "volume_dl": 12}, {"id": "P45", "stop": "S29", "volume_dl": 259}, {"id": "P46", "stop": "S30", "volume_dl": 11}], "vans": 4, "capacity_dl": 1087, "travel_s": [[0, 1092, 1202, 1127, 1074, 1126, 1306, 1366, 1016, 1196, 1142, 1076, 1082, 1068, 1164, 1134, 1157, 1097, 1077, 1036, 1145, 1064, 1096, 1078, 1122, 1127, 1168, 1151, 1052, 1222, 1029], [1100, 0, 381, 356, 159, 356, 472, 478, 352, 424, 274, 242, 401, 104, 280, 363, 148, 316, 54, 204, 210, 32, 132, 335, 257, 212, 444, 339, 137, 373, 86], [1236, 430, 0, 110, 280, 78, 104, 163, 204, 141, 243, 240, 205, 328, 328, 149, 399, 153, 400, 380, 302, 417, 301, 162, 254, 295, 144, 134, 328, 108, 361], [1167, 352, 108, 0, 202, 116, 212, 278, 131, 162, 283, 162, 148, 372, 251, 114, 321, 141, 322, 458, 344, 339, 371, 89, 175, 217, 149, 139, 291, 89, 283], [1085, 150, 272, 196, 0, 196, 376, 436, 192, 265, 180, 83, 241, 170, 120, 203, 118, 156, 120, 306, 157, 136, 178, 175, 97, 52, 237, 238, 47, 285, 80], [1158, 353, 76, 78, 202, 0, 180, 239, 126, 148, 284, 162, 127, 373, 252, 115, 321, 142, 323, 456, 345, 340, 372, 84, 176, 217, 149, 161, 292, 135, 283], [1290, 405, 95, 204, 374, 172, 0, 144, 298, 236, 237, 334, 300, 336, 372, 244, 361, 248, 367, 355, 311, 436, 309, 256, 349, 390, 238, 168, 423, 132, 456], [1357, 472, 172, 281, 452, 249, 142, 0, 375, 232, 305, 412, 377, 403, 438, 299, 428, 325, 434, 410, 378, 503, 376, 334, 425, 467, 294, 236, 500, 199, 533], [1049, 359, 206, 130, 233, 130, 310, 369, 0, 198, 319, 138, 103, 379, 286, 137, 346, 156, 329, 515, 380, 368, 407, 62, 124, 267, 171, 267, 276, 219, 287], [1234, 419, 139, 150, 268, 128, 244, 248, 198, 0, 350, 228, 160, 439, 317, 181, 387, 208, 389, 575, 411, 406, 438, 156, 243, 284, 215, 206, 317, 180, 350], [1211, 279, 210, 287, 172, 287, 247, 306, 285, 350, 0, 176, 334, 220, 135, 278, 171, 178, 240, 274, 166, 310, 194, 268, 191, 187, 272, 168, 220, 201, 253], [1069, 250, 229, 147, 100, 153, 333, 392, 149, 222, 181, 0, 198, 270, 148, 160, 219, 113, 220, 406, 242, 237, 269, 132, 14, 115, 194, 195, 148, 242, 181], [1126, 436, 184, 130, 247, 108, 288, 347, 93, 142, 329, 215, 0, 456, 297, 160, 366, 187, 406, 592, 390, 385, 417, 115, 200, 263, 194, 249, 337, 218, 364], [1078, 96, 308, 385, 194, 385, 397, 404, 384, 449, 201, 274, 433, 0, 273, 376, 119, 353, 58, 166, 107, 128, 28, 367, 289, 244, 370, 266, 169, 299, 153], [1208, 273, 348, 260, 122, 266, 386, 443, 262, 335, 138, 152, 310, 285, 0, 273, 235, 226, 243, 428, 231, 260, 258, 245, 167, 138, 308, 305, 212, 338, 204], [1160, 345, 158, 138, 194, 166, 262, 321, 123, 212, 276, 154, 165, 364, 242, 0, 313, 133, 314, 501, 336, 331, 364, 106, 169, 209, 95, 149, 242, 156, 275], [1185, 143, 324, 339, 147, 339, 362, 421, 335, 408, 196, 226, 384, 112, 238, 392, 0, 299, 105, 273, 123, 175, 86, 318, 240, 195, 387, 283, 148, 316, 181], [1112, 297, 160, 139, 146, 168, 264, 323, 142, 213, 176, 106, 191, 317, 195, 146, 265, 0, 267, 408, 289, 284, 316, 125, 121, 162, 141, 87, 195, 158, 228], [1098, 37, 327, 329, 132, 329, 417, 424, 325, 397, 220, 215, 374, 49, 275, 336, 93, 289, 0, 185, 156, 69, 77, 308, 230, 185, 389, 285, 110, 318, 94], [1038, 211, 370, 453, 320, 447, 360, 422, 513, 510, 263, 404, 562, 188, 396, 438, 297, 415, 196, 0, 285, 207, 216, 497, 418, 374, 432, 328, 298, 361, 268], [1152, 199, 258, 335, 156, 335, 295, 354, 354, 399, 151, 244, 403, 103, 236, 326, 146, 303, 161, 259, 0, 231, 76, 337, 259, 214, 320, 216, 205, 249, 238], [1068, 23, 389, 347, 150, 347, 427, 486, 343, 416, 282, 234, 392, 127, 271, 354, 171, 307, 77, 212, 234, 0, 156, 326, 248, 203, 388, 348, 128, 381, 89], [1105, 123, 294, 377, 166, 371, 331, 390, 363, 434, 187, 254, 412, 27, 243, 362, 91, 339, 85, 193, 78, 155, 0, 346, 267, 223, 356, 252, 193, 285, 180], [1121, 341, 174, 102, 190, 98, 278, 337, 72, 170, 272, 150, 111, 360, 238, 110, 309, 129, 310, 497, 332, 327, 360, 0, 196, 205, 144, 198, 238, 190, 271], [1058, 265, 244, 161, 114, 167, 348, 406, 163, 236, 196, 13, 211, 284, 164, 174, 233, 127, 234, 420, 256, 252, 284, 146, 0, 129, 209, 209, 204, 256, 195], [1131, 196, 301, 225, 46, 225, 405, 464, 221, 293, 222, 111, 270, 216, 149, 232, 165, 185, 166, 352, 188, 183, 215, 204, 126, 0, 266, 267, 94, 314, 127], [1198, 383, 156, 136, 232, 164, 260, 319, 161, 210, 314, 192, 203, 403, 280, 79, 351, 172, 353, 464, 375, 370, 402, 144, 207, 247, 0, 148, 280, 154, 313], [1180, 384, 142, 146, 233, 168, 179, 238, 223, 214, 177, 193, 271, 287, 282, 147, 308, 87, 354, 340, 262, 371, 260, 206, 208, 249, 141, 0, 282, 133, 315], [1053, 118, 331, 249, 58, 255, 506, 541, 251, 324, 240, 142, 346, 138, 181, 262, 182, 215, 88, 321, 245, 105, 212, 234, 156, 111, 296, 298, 0, 344, 49], [1240, 438, 101, 92, 287, 132, 139, 198, 216, 177, 237, 247, 234, 317, 337, 143, 406, 147, 408, 370, 292, 425, 290, 175, 261, 302, 138, 128, 377, 0, 369], [1029, 85, 363, 287, 90, 287, 515, 522, 283, 355, 271, 173, 332, 147, 211, 294, 191, 246, 97, 259, 253, 80, 175, 266, 188, 143, 328, 383, 67, 416, 0]]}, "reference": {"optimum_s": 11277, "optimality": "best_found", "lower_bound_s": 9810, "floor_s": 8180, "solve_s": 40.16, "ffd_s": 13788, "stop_aware_best_s": 12309, "stop_aware_mean_s": 12645.6, "route_id": "RouteID_54a52d70-8840-4fa3-81be-af11da123d59", "plans": {"optimum": [{"route": ["S21", "S01", "S18", "S16", "S20", "S10", "S14", "S25", "S04", "S11", "S24"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S12", "S09", "S02", "S05", "S03", "S23", "S08"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S30", "S28", "S13", "S22", "S19"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S17", "S27", "S07", "S06", "S29", "S26", "S15"], "parcels": []}], "ffd": [{"route": ["S10", "S16", "S25", "S03"], "parcels": ["P03"]}, {"route": ["S21", "S22", "S29", "S07", "S19"], "parcels": ["P11", "P28", "P34", "P45"]}, {"route": ["S23", "S15", "S26", "S03", "S07", "S27", "S17", "S11", "S14", "S13"], "parcels": ["P04", "P09", "P16", "P22"]}, {"route": ["S08", "S12", "S09", "S29", "S07", "S06", "S02", "S05", "S24", "S11", "S14", "S04", "S28", "S30", "S01", "S18", "S22", "S20", "S19"], "parcels": ["P10", "P15", "P17", "P18", "P23", "P29", "P30", "P33", "P44"]}], "stop_aware_best": [{"route": ["S12", "S26", "S14", "S25", "S04", "S30", "S19"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S09", "S05", "S03", "S24", "S11", "S28"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S08", "S23", "S17", "S27", "S07", "S06", "S16", "S13", "S01"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S21", "S18", "S22", "S20", "S10", "S29", "S02", "S15"], "parcels": []}]}}, "meta": {"route_id": "RouteID_54a52d70-8840-4fa3-81be-af11da123d59", "split": "train", "stops": 30, "vans": 4, "tightness": 0.95, "station": "DLA3", "city": "DLA", "date": "2018-07-28", "seconds": 100.4, "stop_aware_best_reward": 0.6195, "optimality": "best_found"}}
{"id": "4cd39093-spread-n20-k3-t0.85-s0", "instance": {"stops": ["S01", "S02", "S03", "S04", "S05", "S06", "S07", "S08", "S09", "S10", "S11", "S12", "S13", "S14", "S15", "S16", "S17", "S18", "S19", "S20"], "parcels": [{"id": "P01", "stop": "S01", "volume_dl": 157}, {"id": "P02", "stop": "S02", "volume_dl": 63}, {"id": "P03", "stop": "S02", "volume_dl": 34}, {"id": "P04", "stop": "S03", "volume_dl": 23}, {"id": "P05", "stop": "S03", "volume_dl": 58}, {"id": "P06", "stop": "S03", "volume_dl": 65}, {"id": "P07", "stop": "S03", "volume_dl": 328}, {"id": "P08", "stop": "S04", "volume_dl": 17}, {"id": "P09", "stop": "S04", "volume_dl": 326}, {"id": "P10", "stop": "S05", "volume_dl": 95}, {"id": "P11", "stop": "S05", "volume_dl": 226}, {"id": "P12", "stop": "S06", "volume_dl": 34}, {"id": "P13", "stop": "S07", "volume_dl": 4}, {"id": "P14", "stop": "S08", "volume_dl": 1428}, {"id": "P15", "stop": "S08", "volume_dl": 179}, {"id": "P16", "stop": "S09", "volume_dl": 408}, {"id": "P17", "stop": "S10", "volume_dl": 92}, {"id": "P18", "stop": "S11", "volume_dl": 29}, {"id": "P19", "stop": "S12", "volume_dl": 63}, {"id": "P20", "stop": "S13", "volume_dl": 133}, {"id": "P21", "stop": "S14", "volume_dl": 57}, {"id": "P22", "stop": "S15", "volume_dl": 5}, {"id": "P23", "stop": "S15", "volume_dl": 2213}, {"id": "P24", "stop": "S16", "volume_dl": 34}, {"id": "P25", "stop": "S17", "volume_dl": 90}, {"id": "P26", "stop": "S17", "volume_dl": 226}, {"id": "P27", "stop": "S18", "volume_dl": 133}, {"id": "P28", "stop": "S18", "volume_dl": 34}, {"id": "P29", "stop": "S19", "volume_dl": 59}, {"id": "P30", "stop": "S19", "volume_dl": 32}, {"id": "P31", "stop": "S19", "volume_dl": 242}, {"id": "P32", "stop": "S20", "volume_dl": 29}], "vans": 3, "capacity_dl": 2713, "travel_s": [[0, 2478, 2180, 2232, 2129, 2194, 2137, 2303, 2289, 2131, 2221, 2454, 2191, 2252, 2185, 2144, 2092, 2432, 2183, 2200, 2169], [2419, 0, 296, 270, 341, 273, 479, 275, 223, 416, 289, 155, 488, 226, 363, 392, 458, 77, 336, 302, 386], [2165, 317, 0, 111, 94, 22, 236, 138, 198, 207, 81, 325, 391, 99, 126, 176, 370, 289, 89, 38, 202], [2232, 261, 92, 0, 173, 95, 254, 59, 140, 165, 56, 337, 333, 25, 207, 162, 304, 209, 85, 88, 256], [2122, 378, 80, 158, 0, 102, 142, 168, 199, 196, 117, 352, 392, 178, 56, 162, 372, 308, 73, 112, 147], [2180, 298, 22, 94, 116, 0, 259, 132, 202, 212, 85, 302, 408, 81, 149, 188, 385, 265, 100, 61, 203], [2155, 462, 232, 256, 153, 255, 0, 252, 283, 218, 250, 483, 399, 281, 109, 177, 341, 444, 219, 252, 143], [2217, 267, 132, 59, 169, 134, 252, 0, 107, 163, 73, 371, 301, 83, 226, 158, 271, 239, 82, 105, 254], [2243, 217, 202, 147, 223, 205, 290, 131, 0, 197, 166, 372, 313, 154, 254, 186, 283, 204, 212, 199, 293], [2123, 365, 211, 171, 196, 217, 211, 155, 186, 0, 130, 459, 251, 194, 225, 60, 175, 359, 144, 162, 263], [2207, 281, 81, 58, 133, 87, 238, 74, 143, 126, 0, 329, 337, 64, 168, 136, 302, 248, 64, 32, 248], [2456, 171, 374, 359, 381, 358, 509, 364, 368, 474, 421, 0, 559, 322, 408, 496, 529, 217, 425, 348, 431], [2093, 453, 382, 322, 378, 400, 391, 294, 280, 247, 332, 555, 0, 348, 409, 288, 133, 423, 316, 357, 447], [2242, 251, 103, 28, 196, 104, 282, 84, 154, 192, 66, 312, 361, 0, 216, 184, 331, 184, 112, 98, 266], [2196, 414, 131, 207, 53, 153, 116, 203, 234, 239, 171, 383, 428, 220, 0, 199, 402, 332, 126, 150, 147], [2128, 362, 179, 162, 164, 192, 168, 162, 188, 61, 136, 465, 312, 188, 203, 0, 236, 362, 89, 129, 238], [2050, 435, 348, 289, 344, 366, 354, 261, 246, 197, 298, 521, 148, 314, 375, 254, 0, 389, 282, 323, 414], [2377, 78, 253, 209, 299, 236, 437, 232, 201, 356, 229, 210, 427, 181, 321, 337, 398, 0, 293, 265, 344], [2181, 310, 90, 85, 88, 103, 203, 99, 130, 139, 60, 388, 324, 111, 143, 87, 314, 297, 0, 41, 206], [2175, 305, 48, 98, 116, 71, 252, 115, 181, 169, 42, 349, 375, 88, 136, 138, 344, 277, 51, 0, 240], [2099, 444, 207, 238, 148, 230, 127, 234, 265, 266, 227, 410, 458, 263, 109, 233, 434, 360, 189, 230, 0]]}, "reference": {"optimum_s": 14709, "optimality": "best_found", "lower_bound_s": 13685, "floor_s": 12426, "solve_s": 46.17, "ffd_s": 15729, "stop_aware_best_s": 15580, "stop_aware_mean_s": 15747.4, "route_id": "RouteID_4cd39093-4444-4bee-b342-444a00a70dfc", "plans": {"optimum": [{"route": ["S16", "S12", "S08", "S17", "S01", "S11", "S20"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S06", "S14", "S04", "S18", "S07", "S03", "S13", "S10", "S19", "S02", "S05"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S09", "S15"], "parcels": []}], "ffd": [{"route": ["S09", "S10", "S15"], "parcels": ["P23"]}, {"route": ["S04", "S05", "S19", "S03", "S01", "S08", "S15"], "parcels": ["P07", "P09", "P11", "P14", "P22", "P31"]}, {"route": ["S06", "S20", "S14", "S04", "S18", "S19", "S02", "S05", "S11", "S17", "S13", "S03", "S07", "S08", "S12", "S16"], "parcels": ["P04", "P05", "P06", "P08", "P10", "P15", "P29", "P30"]}], "stop_aware_best": [{"route": ["S14", "S11", "S13", "S18", "S15"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S09", "S01", "S17", "S19", "S02", "S04", "S06", "S20"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S05", "S10", "S03", "S07", "S08", "S12", "S16"], "parcels": []}]}}, "meta": {"route_id": "RouteID_4cd39093-4444-4bee-b342-444a00a70dfc", "split": "train", "stops": 20, "vans": 3, "tightness": 0.85, "station": "DCH4", "city": "DCH", "date": "2018-07-27", "seconds": 95.8, "stop_aware_best_reward": 0.5851, "optimality": "best_found"}}
{"id": "4d460f58-spread-n20-k3-t0.86-s0", "instance": {"stops": ["S01", "S02", "S03", "S04", "S05", "S06", "S07", "S08", "S09", "S10", "S11", "S12", "S13", "S14", "S15", "S16", "S17", "S18", "S19", "S20"], "parcels": [{"id": "P01", "stop": "S01", "volume_dl": 220}, {"id": "P02", "stop": "S02", "volume_dl": 57}, {"id": "P03", "stop": "S03", "volume_dl": 37}, {"id": "P04", "stop": "S03", "volume_dl": 5}, {"id": "P05", "stop": "S04", "volume_dl": 57}, {"id": "P06", "stop": "S04", "volume_dl": 134}, {"id": "P07", "stop": "S05", "volume_dl": 34}, {"id": "P08", "stop": "S06", "volume_dl": 157}, {"id": "P09", "stop": "S07", "volume_dl": 29}, {"id": "P10", "stop": "S08", "volume_dl": 3}, {"id": "P11", "stop": "S09", "volume_dl": 59}, {"id": "P12", "stop": "S10", "volume_dl": 59}, {"id": "P13", "stop": "S11", "volume_dl": 552}, {"id": "P14", "stop": "S12", "volume_dl": 41}, {"id": "P15", "stop": "S13", "volume_dl": 136}, {"id": "P16", "stop": "S14", "volume_dl": 100}, {"id": "P17", "stop": "S15", "volume_dl": 56}, {"id": "P18", "stop": "S16", "volume_dl": 31}, {"id": "P19", "stop": "S17", "volume_dl": 226}, {"id": "P20", "stop": "S17", "volume_dl": 293}, {"id": "P21", "stop": "S18", "volume_dl": 552}, {"id": "P22", "stop": "S19", "volume_dl": 47}, {"id": "P23", "stop": "S20", "volume_dl": 21}], "vans": 3, "capacity_dl": 1127, "travel_s": [[0, 1219, 1223, 1108, 1254, 1190, 1413, 1151, 1191, 1383, 1066, 1102, 964, 1218, 1167, 1397, 1293, 1253, 1182, 1082, 1425], [1243, 0, 337, 330, 548, 356, 295, 144, 375, 266, 404, 234, 334, 513, 235, 279, 290, 162, 371, 305, 308], [1243, 336, 0, 150, 384, 146, 384, 331, 62, 337, 404, 282, 334, 349, 254, 275, 152, 200, 185, 192, 397], [1129, 306, 170, 0, 377, 138, 500, 238, 139, 463, 289, 190, 220, 341, 255, 401, 278, 233, 242, 78, 513], [1236, 568, 409, 401, 0, 314, 586, 512, 377, 538, 514, 464, 412, 172, 509, 476, 350, 455, 263, 443, 598], [1189, 340, 136, 128, 273, 0, 458, 331, 105, 411, 350, 282, 281, 237, 237, 349, 226, 183, 104, 170, 471], [1429, 267, 375, 491, 558, 459, 0, 330, 422, 164, 590, 420, 520, 500, 408, 289, 300, 335, 380, 533, 48], [1170, 158, 332, 257, 482, 332, 352, 0, 340, 323, 330, 161, 261, 447, 192, 337, 348, 219, 419, 231, 365], [1234, 365, 64, 140, 375, 136, 413, 343, 0, 366, 394, 295, 325, 340, 267, 304, 180, 213, 214, 182, 426], [1380, 218, 307, 423, 490, 392, 151, 280, 354, 0, 540, 371, 471, 455, 358, 221, 232, 285, 313, 465, 199], [1090, 383, 387, 273, 419, 355, 577, 316, 356, 548, 0, 267, 182, 383, 332, 562, 458, 418, 347, 247, 590], [1145, 232, 282, 256, 457, 264, 426, 164, 282, 397, 305, 0, 236, 422, 125, 411, 335, 211, 368, 206, 439], [993, 319, 323, 208, 354, 290, 513, 251, 291, 483, 166, 202, 0, 318, 267, 497, 393, 353, 282, 182, 525], [1272, 516, 357, 349, 160, 262, 518, 461, 326, 487, 432, 412, 363, 0, 457, 424, 298, 403, 211, 391, 516], [1202, 234, 241, 245, 462, 223, 415, 188, 242, 386, 363, 141, 294, 426, 0, 399, 294, 147, 327, 287, 428], [1448, 256, 270, 386, 453, 354, 274, 319, 317, 226, 609, 453, 540, 417, 426, 0, 195, 372, 275, 428, 286], [1306, 289, 169, 285, 308, 210, 306, 352, 216, 259, 466, 352, 397, 273, 324, 197, 0, 270, 131, 327, 319], [1265, 152, 197, 200, 418, 179, 333, 251, 198, 303, 426, 204, 356, 382, 143, 317, 250, 0, 283, 243, 345], [1213, 351, 185, 232, 244, 104, 378, 402, 209, 331, 374, 354, 304, 209, 341, 268, 142, 287, 0, 275, 391], [1104, 282, 213, 99, 420, 181, 476, 214, 182, 447, 265, 165, 196, 384, 230, 444, 321, 278, 285, 0, 488], [1425, 263, 371, 487, 554, 455, 66, 326, 418, 230, 586, 416, 516, 496, 404, 285, 296, 331, 376, 529, 0]]}, "reference": {"optimum_s": 9627, "optimality": "best_found", "lower_bound_s": 8302, "floor_s": 5871, "solve_s": 33.17, "ffd_s": 10948, "stop_aware_best_s": 10247, "stop_aware_mean_s": 10481.4, "route_id": "RouteID_4d460f58-115e-43b9-b39b-29c4d4236326", "plans": {"optimum": [{"route": ["S08", "S02", "S16", "S15", "S09", "S06", "S20", "S01", "S17"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S12", "S11", "S14", "S07"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S10", "S19", "S03", "S05", "S18", "S13", "S04"], "parcels": []}], "ffd": [{"route": ["S11", "S20", "S18"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S13", "S05", "S17", "S06", "S09", "S01"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S12", "S10", "S19", "S03", "S08", "S02", "S14", "S07", "S15", "S16", "S04"], "parcels": []}], "stop_aware_best": [{"route": ["S19", "S02", "S18", "S13", "S04"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S14", "S17", "S06", "S20", "S15", "S16", "S05", "S03"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S12", "S10", "S08", "S09", "S01", "S07", "S11"], "parcels": []}]}}, "meta": {"route_id": "RouteID_4d460f58-115e-43b9-b39b-29c4d4236326", "split": "train", "stops": 20, "vans": 3, "tightness": 0.86, "station": "DSE5", "city": "DSE", "date": "2018-08-03", "seconds": 33.5, "stop_aware_best_reward": 0.78, "optimality": "best_found"}}
{"id": "56e66ffc-spread-n25-k3-t0.94-s0", "instance": {"stops": ["S01", "S02", "S03", "S04", "S05", "S06", "S07", "S08", "S09", "S10", "S11", "S12", "S13", "S14", "S15", "S16", "S17", "S18", "S19", "S20", "S21", "S22", "S23", "S24", "S25"], "parcels": [{"id": "P01", "stop": "S01", "volume_dl": 12}, {"id": "P02", "stop": "S02", "volume_dl": 95}, {"id": "P03", "stop": "S02", "volume_dl": 46}, {"id": "P04", "stop": "S03", "volume_dl": 12}, {"id": "P05", "stop": "S04", "volume_dl": 92}, {"id": "P06", "stop": "S05", "volume_dl": 29}, {"id": "P07", "stop": "S05", "volume_dl": 34}, {"id": "P08", "stop": "S05", "volume_dl": 322}, {"id": "P09", "stop": "S06", "volume_dl": 43}, {"id": "P10", "stop": "S07", "volume_dl": 57}, {"id": "P11", "stop": "S08", "volume_dl": 31}, {"id": "P12", "stop": "S09", "volume_dl": 259}, {"id": "P13", "stop": "S10", "volume_dl": 57}, {"id": "P14", "stop": "S11", "volume_dl": 30}, {"id": "P15", "stop": "S12", "volume_dl": 179}, {"id": "P16", "stop": "S12", "volume_dl": 36}, {"id": "P17", "stop": "S13", "volume_dl": 16}, {"id": "P18", "stop": "S14", "volume_dl": 57}, {"id": "P19", "stop": "S15", "volume_dl": 20}, {"id": "P20", "stop": "S16", "volume_dl": 29}, {"id": "P21", "stop": "S17", "volume_dl": 179}, {"id": "P22", "stop": "S18", "volume_dl": 36}, {"id": "P23", "stop": "S19", "volume_dl": 34}, {"id": "P24", "stop": "S19", "volume_dl": 90}, {"id": "P25", "stop": "S20", "volume_dl": 35}, {"id": "P26", "stop": "S21", "volume_dl": 34}, {"id": "P27", "stop": "S22", "volume_dl": 134}, {"id": "P28", "stop": "S23", "volume_dl": 779}, {"id": "P29", "stop": "S24", "volume_dl": 30}, {"id": "P30", "stop": "S25", "volume_dl": 37}], "vans": 3, "capacity_dl": 1010, "travel_s": [[0, 2689, 2625, 2532, 2739, 2422, 2680, 2529, 2428, 2789, 2588, 2546, 2599, 2542, 2384, 2390, 2474, 2647, 2662, 2480, 2724, 2375, 2474, 2440, 2419, 2498], [2675, 0, 137, 361, 225, 569, 160, 363, 445, 143, 459, 376, 397, 412, 474, 426, 458, 341, 260, 356, 174, 534, 449, 536, 456, 402], [2680, 158, 0, 361, 207, 506, 139, 364, 382, 258, 382, 376, 333, 412, 410, 363, 458, 278, 260, 357, 354, 470, 449, 473, 392, 403], [2585, 348, 347, 0, 415, 548, 325, 141, 414, 448, 367, 284, 382, 249, 443, 395, 295, 552, 264, 134, 479, 462, 357, 508, 425, 296], [2608, 244, 225, 445, 0, 732, 266, 474, 598, 344, 551, 468, 566, 522, 627, 579, 569, 430, 366, 467, 375, 720, 541, 684, 609, 495], [2389, 468, 404, 445, 518, 0, 460, 447, 137, 568, 349, 307, 355, 386, 92, 98, 348, 426, 423, 440, 503, 284, 236, 148, 128, 259], [2686, 171, 104, 329, 236, 608, 0, 331, 474, 271, 351, 344, 302, 380, 503, 455, 426, 326, 228, 324, 302, 520, 417, 523, 484, 370], [2579, 388, 387, 159, 455, 596, 365, 0, 462, 487, 422, 332, 428, 216, 491, 443, 249, 591, 304, 128, 518, 399, 421, 445, 484, 267], [2477, 474, 410, 436, 524, 243, 466, 439, 0, 574, 340, 299, 346, 378, 137, 72, 340, 432, 415, 432, 509, 276, 227, 176, 101, 251], [2782, 130, 243, 467, 331, 676, 266, 470, 552, 0, 565, 482, 503, 518, 580, 533, 564, 399, 366, 463, 218, 640, 555, 643, 562, 509], [2708, 440, 376, 377, 490, 473, 346, 379, 339, 540, 0, 122, 121, 346, 368, 320, 392, 398, 356, 372, 475, 461, 282, 424, 350, 218], [2635, 393, 392, 294, 460, 400, 415, 296, 266, 493, 122, 0, 190, 280, 295, 247, 326, 467, 273, 290, 544, 388, 209, 352, 277, 163], [2700, 378, 314, 414, 428, 466, 284, 421, 332, 478, 128, 205, 0, 338, 361, 313, 384, 336, 393, 410, 413, 454, 275, 417, 343, 210], [2658, 430, 429, 244, 497, 508, 407, 203, 373, 530, 353, 287, 359, 0, 402, 355, 78, 605, 346, 244, 561, 304, 276, 342, 381, 143], [2428, 444, 379, 420, 493, 194, 435, 423, 112, 544, 324, 283, 330, 362, 0, 74, 324, 402, 399, 416, 478, 260, 211, 124, 103, 235], [2449, 412, 348, 389, 462, 215, 404, 391, 63, 512, 293, 251, 299, 330, 110, 0, 292, 370, 368, 384, 447, 228, 180, 104, 29, 203], [2590, 466, 465, 281, 533, 446, 443, 239, 312, 566, 389, 323, 395, 91, 341, 293, 0, 537, 382, 252, 614, 236, 227, 274, 313, 180], [2718, 321, 295, 563, 409, 536, 359, 565, 401, 358, 406, 483, 357, 610, 430, 382, 572, 0, 462, 558, 171, 490, 459, 493, 412, 483], [2744, 258, 257, 282, 326, 510, 235, 284, 376, 358, 329, 246, 344, 333, 405, 357, 379, 462, 0, 277, 389, 498, 319, 461, 387, 272], [2535, 386, 386, 157, 454, 586, 364, 132, 452, 486, 405, 322, 420, 238, 481, 468, 212, 590, 302, 0, 517, 363, 429, 409, 448, 293], [2774, 150, 263, 487, 351, 591, 287, 490, 457, 187, 461, 502, 412, 538, 486, 438, 585, 181, 386, 483, 0, 545, 575, 548, 468, 529], [2537, 527, 462, 451, 576, 433, 518, 390, 274, 627, 425, 384, 437, 322, 328, 281, 254, 484, 500, 355, 561, 0, 309, 222, 261, 336], [2575, 437, 412, 339, 505, 340, 415, 341, 206, 537, 242, 201, 248, 281, 235, 187, 254, 434, 317, 334, 511, 302, 0, 292, 217, 153], [2453, 500, 436, 477, 550, 269, 492, 479, 180, 600, 381, 339, 387, 415, 164, 117, 347, 458, 456, 471, 535, 248, 268, 0, 97, 291], [2469, 432, 368, 409, 482, 235, 423, 411, 83, 532, 312, 271, 319, 350, 130, 20, 312, 390, 387, 404, 467, 248, 199, 99, 0, 223], [2634, 416, 415, 296, 483, 400, 393, 254, 265, 516, 209, 186, 216, 128, 294, 246, 174, 493, 296, 296, 569, 410, 208, 351, 276, 0]]}, "reference": {"optimum_s": 18388, "optimality": "best_found", "lower_bound_s": 17395, "floor_s": 14292, "solve_s": 33.12, "ffd_s": 20491, "stop_aware_best_s": 19872, "stop_aware_mean_s": 20292.2, "route_id": "RouteID_56e66ffc-e668-4b42-ae4c-843c74406af0", "plans": {"optimum": [{"route": ["S19", "S07", "S03", "S18", "S06", "S02", "S17", "S20", "S09", "S01", "S04"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S14", "S15", "S24", "S23"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S21", "S16", "S13", "S25", "S12", "S10", "S11", "S22", "S08", "S05"], "parcels": []}], "ffd": [{"route": ["S23", "S12", "S02"], "parcels": ["P03", "P15"]}, {"route": ["S05", "S15", "S22", "S17", "S09", "S02"], "parcels": ["P02", "P08"]}, {"route": ["S19", "S07", "S03", "S18", "S06", "S04", "S01", "S20", "S12", "S10", "S11", "S25", "S13", "S16", "S21", "S24", "S08", "S14", "S05"], "parcels": ["P06", "P07", "P16"]}], "stop_aware_best": [{"route": ["S21", "S23", "S15", "S18", "S01", "S04"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S05", "S14", "S24", "S12", "S02", "S03", "S19", "S13", "S16"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S08", "S22", "S25", "S11", "S10", "S17", "S20", "S09", "S06", "S07"], "parcels": []}]}}, "meta": {"route_id": "RouteID_56e66ffc-e668-4b42-ae4c-843c74406af0", "split": "train", "stops": 25, "vans": 3, "tightness": 0.94, "station": "DCH3", "city": "DCH", "date": "2018-08-15", "seconds": 37.2, "stop_aware_best_reward": 0.5944, "optimality": "best_found"}}
{"id": "62af093a-spread-n40-k4-t0.87-s0", "instance": {"stops": ["S01", "S02", "S03", "S04", "S05", "S06", "S07", "S08", "S09", "S10", "S11", "S12", "S13", "S14", "S15", "S16", "S17", "S18", "S19", "S20", "S21", "S22", "S23", "S24", "S25", "S26", "S27", "S28", "S29", "S30", "S31", "S32", "S33", "S34", "S35", "S36", "S37", "S38", "S39", "S40"], "parcels": [{"id": "P01", "stop": "S01", "volume_dl": 42}, {"id": "P02", "stop": "S02", "volume_dl": 57}, {"id": "P03", "stop": "S03", "volume_dl": 429}, {"id": "P04", "stop": "S04", "volume_dl": 59}, {"id": "P05", "stop": "S04", "volume_dl": 32}, {"id": "P06", "stop": "S05", "volume_dl": 55}, {"id": "P07", "stop": "S05", "volume_dl": 134}, {"id": "P08", "stop": "S06", "volume_dl": 57}, {"id": "P09", "stop": "S07", "volume_dl": 322}, {"id": "P10", "stop": "S08", "volume_dl": 254}, {"id": "P11", "stop": "S09", "volume_dl": 34}, {"id": "P12", "stop": "S10", "volume_dl": 59}, {"id": "P13", "stop": "S10", "volume_dl": 9}, {"id": "P14", "stop": "S11", "volume_dl": 104}, {"id": "P15", "stop": "S12", "volume_dl": 92}, {"id": "P16", "stop": "S12", "volume_dl": 8}, {"id": "P17", "stop": "S13", "volume_dl": 60}, {"id": "P18", "stop": "S14", "volume_dl": 134}, {"id": "P19", "stop": "S15", "volume_dl": 226}, {"id": "P20", "stop": "S16", "volume_dl": 9}, {"id": "P21", "stop": "S17", "volume_dl": 63}, {"id": "P22", "stop": "S18", "volume_dl": 92}, {"id": "P23", "stop": "S19", "volume_dl": 157}, {"id": "P24", "stop": "S19", "volume_dl": 63}, {"id": "P25", "stop": "S20", "volume_dl": 75}, {"id": "P26", "stop": "S21", "volume_dl": 134}, {"id": "P27", "stop": "S22", "volume_dl": 35}, {"id": "P28", "stop": "S23", "volume_dl": 11}, {"id": "P29", "stop": "S23", "volume_dl": 4}, {"id": "P30", "stop": "S24", "volume_dl": 200}, {"id": "P31", "stop": "S24", "volume_dl": 20}, {"id": "P32", "stop": "S25", "volume_dl": 58}, {"id": "P33", "stop": "S26", "volume_dl": 34}, {"id": "P34", "stop": "S27", "volume_dl": 8}, {"id": "P35", "stop": "S28", "volume_dl": 11}, {"id": "P36", "stop": "S29", "volume_dl": 33}, {"id": "P37", "stop": "S30", "volume_dl": 259}, {"id": "P38", "stop": "S31", "volume_dl": 57}, {"id": "P39", "stop": "S32", "volume_dl": 25}, {"id": "P40", "stop": "S32", "volume_dl": 9}, {"id": "P41", "stop": "S33", "volume_dl": 12}, {"id": "P42", "stop": "S34", "volume_dl": 104}, {"id": "P43", "stop": "S35", "volume_dl": 34}, {"id": "P44", "stop": "S35", "volume_dl": 9}, {"id": "P45", "stop": "S35", "volume_dl": 92}, {"id": "P46", "stop": "S35", "volume_dl": 34}, {"id": "P47", "stop": "S36", "volume_dl": 54}, {"id": "P48", "stop": "S37", "volume_dl": 92}, {"id": "P49", "stop": "S38", "volume_dl": 104}, {"id": "P50", "stop": "S39", "volume_dl": 37}, {"id": "P51", "stop": "S40", "volume_dl": 34}, {"id": "P52", "stop": "S40", "volume_dl": 104}, {"id": "P53", "stop": "S40", "volume_dl": 13}], "vans": 4, "capacity_dl": 1222, "travel_s": [[0, 1893, 1624, 1982, 1593, 1620, 1882, 1986, 1940, 2031, 1837, 1727, 1918, 1910, 1972, 1822, 1765, 1862, 1856, 2000, 1761, 1916, 1881, 1770, 1717, 1649, 1606, 1376, 1706, 1783, 1561, 1901, 1508, 2060, 1593, 1802, 1557, 1896, 1757, 1331, 1632], [1878, 0, 774, 247, 743, 652, 157, 565, 573, 524, 470, 659, 130, 110, 237, 402, 551, 136, 92, 265, 558, 181, 580, 607, 590, 646, 756, 913, 623, 499, 676, 481, 679, 325, 669, 608, 1094, 161, 631, 1034, 743], [1654, 761, 0, 814, 56, 198, 750, 650, 497, 739, 394, 274, 786, 778, 803, 505, 342, 730, 724, 868, 339, 794, 427, 317, 294, 227, 49, 311, 252, 361, 128, 566, 119, 898, 197, 349, 492, 764, 335, 431, 252], [1884, 141, 780, 0, 748, 658, 186, 376, 578, 424, 476, 664, 189, 169, 9, 407, 557, 160, 151, 178, 564, 103, 586, 613, 596, 652, 762, 919, 629, 505, 682, 382, 684, 85, 674, 613, 1100, 99, 636, 1039, 749], [1640, 747, 54, 800, 0, 184, 736, 636, 483, 726, 380, 260, 772, 764, 790, 491, 328, 716, 711, 854, 325, 780, 413, 303, 280, 213, 36, 297, 238, 347, 114, 552, 105, 884, 200, 335, 478, 750, 321, 417, 238], [1733, 643, 211, 696, 169, 0, 632, 532, 379, 621, 266, 265, 658, 660, 685, 387, 224, 612, 606, 739, 221, 676, 320, 201, 181, 99, 192, 390, 174, 243, 113, 448, 105, 780, 110, 264, 571, 646, 217, 510, 138], [1868, 177, 764, 291, 733, 643, 0, 555, 563, 567, 460, 649, 36, 56, 281, 392, 541, 173, 76, 308, 549, 225, 570, 597, 580, 637, 746, 903, 613, 489, 666, 471, 669, 368, 659, 598, 1084, 204, 621, 1024, 733], [1986, 431, 668, 337, 636, 546, 476, 0, 466, 263, 363, 552, 478, 458, 327, 246, 444, 449, 440, 457, 452, 317, 473, 501, 483, 540, 649, 824, 516, 392, 570, 200, 572, 422, 562, 501, 1005, 388, 524, 944, 637], [1927, 595, 499, 647, 468, 378, 584, 484, 0, 573, 173, 384, 620, 612, 637, 339, 276, 564, 558, 702, 284, 627, 221, 332, 315, 372, 481, 656, 348, 224, 401, 400, 404, 732, 394, 333, 836, 598, 356, 776, 468], [2048, 383, 693, 289, 662, 572, 428, 220, 492, 0, 389, 578, 431, 411, 279, 272, 470, 402, 392, 409, 478, 270, 499, 526, 509, 566, 675, 850, 542, 418, 595, 226, 598, 374, 588, 527, 1030, 340, 550, 970, 662], [1839, 506, 411, 559, 379, 289, 496, 396, 167, 485, 0, 295, 531, 523, 549, 250, 187, 475, 470, 613, 195, 539, 165, 244, 226, 283, 392, 567, 260, 135, 313, 311, 315, 644, 305, 244, 748, 509, 267, 687, 380], [1798, 685, 287, 738, 255, 281, 674, 574, 435, 643, 364, 0, 710, 702, 727, 429, 272, 654, 648, 792, 142, 718, 277, 94, 200, 275, 268, 455, 118, 285, 305, 490, 307, 822, 297, 90, 636, 688, 241, 575, 372], [1902, 141, 798, 284, 767, 667, 34, 589, 597, 560, 494, 683, 0, 20, 274, 426, 575, 165, 81, 301, 582, 218, 604, 631, 619, 670, 780, 937, 647, 523, 700, 505, 703, 361, 693, 632, 1118, 197, 655, 1058, 767], [1886, 121, 782, 264, 751, 661, 54, 573, 581, 540, 478, 667, 20, 0, 253, 410, 559, 144, 61, 281, 567, 198, 588, 615, 598, 655, 764, 921, 631, 507, 684, 489, 687, 341, 677, 616, 1102, 177, 639, 1042, 751], [1875, 132, 771, 10, 739, 649, 178, 367, 569, 415, 466, 656, 180, 160, 0, 398, 548, 151, 142, 169, 555, 73, 576, 604, 587, 643, 752, 910, 620, 496, 673, 373, 675, 95, 665, 604, 1091, 90, 627, 1030, 740], [1808, 495, 532, 401, 501, 410, 431, 238, 331, 327, 228, 417, 467, 522, 391, 0, 309, 411, 406, 521, 316, 381, 338, 365, 348, 404, 514, 688, 381, 257, 434, 132, 437, 486, 426, 366, 869, 452, 389, 809, 501], [1901, 550, 369, 603, 338, 247, 540, 440, 286, 529, 184, 274, 575, 568, 593, 294, 0, 519, 514, 657, 135, 583, 224, 202, 118, 241, 351, 525, 218, 150, 271, 355, 274, 688, 263, 184, 706, 553, 99, 646, 338], [1860, 164, 757, 260, 725, 635, 163, 548, 555, 536, 452, 641, 199, 181, 250, 384, 533, 0, 137, 278, 541, 194, 562, 590, 572, 629, 738, 896, 605, 481, 659, 463, 661, 338, 651, 590, 1076, 174, 613, 1016, 726], [1852, 102, 748, 245, 717, 626, 66, 539, 547, 521, 444, 633, 101, 81, 235, 376, 525, 126, 0, 263, 532, 179, 554, 581, 564, 620, 730, 887, 597, 473, 650, 454, 653, 323, 642, 582, 1068, 159, 605, 1008, 717], [2004, 261, 900, 185, 868, 768, 306, 458, 698, 507, 596, 784, 309, 289, 175, 527, 677, 280, 271, 0, 684, 147, 706, 733, 720, 772, 882, 1039, 749, 625, 802, 465, 804, 270, 794, 733, 1220, 155, 756, 1159, 869], [1839, 566, 340, 619, 309, 218, 556, 456, 328, 545, 257, 138, 592, 584, 609, 310, 130, 535, 530, 673, 0, 599, 135, 157, 199, 212, 322, 496, 189, 166, 242, 371, 245, 704, 234, 49, 677, 569, 179, 617, 309], [1915, 172, 811, 79, 779, 689, 218, 372, 609, 421, 506, 696, 220, 200, 68, 438, 588, 191, 182, 180, 595, 0, 616, 644, 627, 683, 792, 950, 660, 536, 713, 379, 715, 159, 705, 644, 1131, 130, 667, 1070, 780], [1928, 594, 446, 646, 414, 324, 583, 483, 244, 572, 174, 255, 619, 611, 636, 338, 214, 563, 558, 701, 117, 627, 0, 274, 262, 318, 427, 602, 295, 194, 348, 399, 350, 731, 340, 166, 783, 597, 290, 722, 415], [1826, 609, 327, 661, 295, 195, 598, 498, 345, 587, 242, 90, 634, 626, 651, 353, 190, 578, 572, 716, 140, 642, 276, 0, 129, 199, 308, 483, 86, 209, 229, 414, 231, 746, 221, 89, 664, 612, 165, 603, 296], [1816, 579, 317, 632, 290, 185, 568, 468, 315, 557, 217, 183, 609, 596, 621, 323, 138, 548, 542, 690, 157, 612, 256, 136, 0, 189, 298, 473, 165, 179, 219, 384, 226, 716, 211, 187, 654, 582, 41, 593, 290], [1695, 642, 256, 694, 224, 108, 631, 531, 378, 620, 275, 264, 667, 659, 684, 386, 223, 611, 606, 749, 220, 675, 319, 200, 175, 0, 237, 434, 173, 242, 158, 447, 160, 779, 150, 263, 615, 645, 216, 555, 183], [1646, 754, 40, 806, 49, 191, 743, 643, 490, 732, 387, 266, 779, 771, 796, 498, 335, 723, 717, 860, 332, 786, 420, 310, 287, 220, 0, 304, 245, 354, 120, 558, 112, 891, 189, 342, 484, 757, 328, 424, 245], [1438, 882, 323, 935, 292, 320, 872, 772, 618, 861, 516, 426, 907, 900, 925, 626, 464, 851, 846, 989, 460, 915, 580, 469, 416, 348, 305, 0, 405, 482, 260, 687, 207, 1020, 292, 502, 181, 885, 456, 215, 331], [1801, 640, 302, 693, 271, 180, 630, 530, 377, 619, 274, 132, 666, 658, 683, 384, 222, 609, 604, 747, 233, 673, 344, 92, 217, 174, 284, 459, 0, 240, 204, 445, 207, 778, 197, 182, 639, 643, 258, 579, 271], [1853, 502, 398, 555, 366, 276, 492, 392, 239, 481, 136, 282, 528, 520, 545, 246, 174, 471, 466, 609, 182, 535, 203, 231, 214, 270, 379, 554, 246, 0, 300, 307, 302, 640, 292, 231, 735, 505, 254, 674, 367], [1638, 688, 133, 741, 101, 125, 678, 578, 424, 666, 321, 240, 713, 705, 730, 432, 270, 657, 652, 795, 266, 721, 393, 283, 222, 154, 114, 296, 219, 288, 0, 493, 46, 825, 57, 315, 476, 691, 262, 416, 179], [1897, 474, 580, 380, 548, 458, 519, 217, 378, 306, 275, 464, 521, 501, 370, 148, 356, 492, 483, 500, 364, 360, 385, 412, 395, 452, 561, 736, 428, 304, 482, 0, 484, 465, 474, 413, 917, 431, 436, 856, 548], [1559, 675, 180, 728, 117, 112, 664, 564, 411, 654, 308, 285, 700, 692, 718, 419, 256, 644, 639, 782, 253, 708, 352, 233, 208, 141, 130, 216, 206, 275, 51, 480, 0, 812, 108, 296, 397, 678, 249, 336, 166], [1963, 221, 860, 79, 828, 738, 266, 455, 658, 504, 555, 744, 268, 248, 88, 487, 636, 239, 230, 257, 644, 159, 665, 692, 675, 732, 841, 998, 708, 584, 762, 462, 764, 0, 754, 693, 1179, 178, 716, 1119, 828], [1654, 689, 190, 742, 159, 132, 679, 579, 488, 668, 322, 197, 714, 706, 732, 433, 271, 658, 653, 796, 324, 722, 351, 240, 223, 155, 172, 312, 176, 289, 57, 494, 104, 827, 0, 273, 492, 692, 263, 432, 203], [1886, 618, 386, 671, 355, 265, 608, 508, 380, 596, 309, 89, 643, 635, 660, 362, 182, 587, 582, 725, 52, 651, 187, 108, 184, 259, 368, 543, 184, 218, 288, 423, 291, 755, 281, 0, 724, 621, 225, 663, 355], [1616, 1061, 501, 1113, 471, 498, 1050, 950, 797, 1039, 694, 605, 1086, 1078, 1103, 805, 642, 1030, 1024, 1167, 638, 1093, 758, 648, 594, 526, 484, 178, 583, 661, 438, 865, 386, 1198, 470, 680, 0, 1064, 635, 394, 510], [1899, 156, 795, 180, 763, 673, 201, 408, 593, 456, 490, 679, 204, 184, 170, 422, 571, 175, 165, 138, 579, 114, 600, 628, 610, 667, 776, 934, 644, 519, 697, 414, 699, 257, 689, 628, 1114, 0, 651, 1054, 764], [1864, 627, 365, 680, 333, 243, 617, 517, 363, 606, 260, 231, 652, 644, 670, 371, 106, 596, 591, 734, 192, 660, 301, 180, 48, 237, 346, 521, 214, 227, 267, 432, 269, 764, 259, 230, 702, 630, 0, 641, 334], [1382, 1001, 441, 1053, 411, 438, 990, 890, 737, 979, 634, 545, 1026, 1018, 1043, 745, 582, 970, 964, 1108, 579, 1033, 698, 588, 534, 466, 424, 194, 524, 601, 378, 806, 326, 1138, 411, 620, 374, 1004, 575, 0, 450], [1689, 737, 279, 789, 247, 128, 726, 626, 473, 715, 370, 359, 762, 754, 779, 481, 318, 706, 700, 843, 314, 769, 414, 295, 275, 162, 260, 346, 267, 337, 181, 541, 226, 874, 193, 358, 527, 740, 311, 466, 0]]}, "reference": {"optimum_s": 18519, "optimality": "best_found", "lower_bound_s": 15019, "floor_s": 10852, "solve_s": 70.27, "ffd_s": 22655, "stop_aware_best_s": 21515, "stop_aware_mean_s": 21713, "route_id": "RouteID_62af093a-8635-4387-ac46-74207d7401d8", "plans": {"optimum": [{"route": ["S15", "S31", "S07", "S09", "S01", "S18", "S06", "S12", "S13", "S17"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S39", "S36", "S27", "S40", "S05", "S34", "S30", "S04", "S26", "S02"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S37", "S19", "S21", "S33", "S03", "S14"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S32", "S24", "S38", "S16", "S29", "S10", "S08", "S22", "S20", "S35", "S11", "S23", "S28", "S25"], "parcels": []}], "ffd": [{"route": ["S30", "S24", "S07", "S33", "S03"], "parcels": ["P30"]}, {"route": ["S05", "S23", "S11", "S20", "S08", "S15", "S19", "S21", "S14"], "parcels": ["P07", "P23", "P29"]}, {"route": ["S18", "S06", "S12", "S13", "S17", "S37", "S19", "S31", "S10", "S35", "S38", "S25", "S40", "S34", "S04", "S02"], "parcels": ["P04", "P15", "P24", "P45", "P52"]}, {"route": ["S39", "S36", "S27", "S32", "S04", "S26", "S40", "S05", "S28", "S23", "S35", "S22", "S16", "S24", "S29", "S09", "S01", "S12"], "parcels": ["P05", "P06", "P16", "P28", "P31", "P43", "P44", "P46", "P51", "P53"]}], "stop_aware_best": [{"route": ["S36", "S04", "S26", "S02", "S38", "S11", "S35", "S20", "S22", "S29", "S07", "S37"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S30", "S34", "S05", "S24", "S16", "S10", "S09", "S17", "S18", "S06"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S39", "S32", "S08", "S31", "S21", "S14", "S03", "S12"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S27", "S40", "S25", "S28", "S23", "S15", "S33", "S19", "S01", "S13"], "parcels": []}]}}, "meta": {"route_id": "RouteID_62af093a-8635-4387-ac46-74207d7401d8", "split": "train", "stops": 40, "vans": 4, "tightness": 0.87, "station": "DCH3", "city": "DCH", "date": "2018-08-14", "seconds": 131.1, "stop_aware_best_reward": 0.5699, "optimality": "best_found"}}
{"id": "ff3c4430-spread-n25-k3-t0.93-s0", "instance": {"stops": ["S01", "S02", "S03", "S04", "S05", "S06", "S07", "S08", "S09", "S10", "S11", "S12", "S13", "S14", "S15", "S16", "S17", "S18", "S19", "S20", "S21", "S22", "S23", "S24", "S25"], "parcels": [{"id": "P01", "stop": "S01", "volume_dl": 18}, {"id": "P02", "stop": "S01", "volume_dl": 6}, {"id": "P03", "stop": "S02", "volume_dl": 57}, {"id": "P04", "stop": "S03", "volume_dl": 92}, {"id": "P05", "stop": "S03", "volume_dl": 11}, {"id": "P06", "stop": "S04", "volume_dl": 242}, {"id": "P07", "stop": "S05", "volume_dl": 21}, {"id": "P08", "stop": "S06", "volume_dl": 34}, {"id": "P09", "stop": "S07", "volume_dl": 242}, {"id": "P10", "stop": "S08", "volume_dl": 179}, {"id": "P11", "stop": "S09", "volume_dl": 2}, {"id": "P12", "stop": "S09", "volume_dl": 57}, {"id": "P13", "stop": "S09", "volume_dl": 57}, {"id": "P14", "stop": "S10", "volume_dl": 79}, {"id": "P15", "stop": "S11", "volume_dl": 13}, {"id": "P16", "stop": "S12", "volume_dl": 11}, {"id": "P17", "stop": "S13", "volume_dl": 133}, {"id": "P18", "stop": "S13", "volume_dl": 157}, {"id": "P19", "stop": "S13", "volume_dl": 211}, {"id": "P20", "stop": "S13", "volume_dl": 57}, {"id": "P21", "stop": "S14", "volume_dl": 14}, {"id": "P22", "stop": "S15", "volume_dl": 57}, {"id": "P23", "stop": "S16", "volume_dl": 41}, {"id": "P24", "stop": "S17", "volume_dl": 32}, {"id": "P25", "stop": "S17", "volume_dl": 19}, {"id": "P26", "stop": "S18", "volume_dl": 90}, {"id": "P27", "stop": "S19", "volume_dl": 95}, {"id": "P28", "stop": "S19", "volume_dl": 38}, {"id": "P29", "stop": "S20", "volume_dl": 226}, {"id": "P30", "stop": "S20", "volume_dl": 259}, {"id": "P31", "stop": "S21", "volume_dl": 542}, {"id": "P32", "stop": "S21", "volume_dl": 41}, {"id": "P33", "stop": "S21", "volume_dl": 287}, {"id": "P34", "stop": "S21", "volume_dl": 36}, {"id": "P35", "stop": "S22", "volume_dl": 133}, {"id": "P36", "stop": "S23", "volume_dl": 6}, {"id": "P37", "stop": "S24", "volume_dl": 542}, {"id": "P38", "stop": "S24", "volume_dl": 27}, {"id": "P39", "stop": "S24", "volume_dl": 242}, {"id": "P40", "stop": "S25", "volume_dl": 429}], "vans": 3, "capacity_dl": 1734, "travel_s": [[0, 3311, 3270, 3179, 3210, 3191, 3063, 3343, 3255, 3265, 3374, 3388, 3301, 3299, 3359, 3309, 3271, 3279, 3290, 3309, 3357, 3354, 3140, 3280, 3325, 3265], [3599, 0, 554, 590, 559, 125, 482, 588, 574, 144, 137, 130, 98, 530, 148, 330, 442, 41, 71, 244, 301, 196, 459, 166, 89, 151], [3459, 585, 0, 269, 238, 599, 249, 120, 238, 426, 536, 557, 592, 116, 575, 471, 262, 625, 525, 263, 518, 623, 169, 610, 602, 625], [3348, 658, 289, 0, 31, 649, 414, 164, 309, 529, 639, 579, 695, 213, 559, 480, 236, 647, 629, 571, 528, 554, 292, 501, 568, 516], [3379, 658, 258, 31, 0, 672, 382, 132, 278, 499, 608, 630, 664, 182, 590, 449, 204, 698, 598, 254, 497, 585, 261, 532, 600, 547], [3468, 120, 583, 618, 587, 0, 510, 616, 603, 173, 166, 197, 110, 558, 215, 359, 470, 88, 99, 656, 330, 223, 487, 150, 176, 134], [3290, 509, 265, 406, 375, 523, 0, 291, 251, 350, 459, 481, 515, 295, 499, 395, 392, 549, 449, 304, 442, 547, 135, 534, 526, 548], [3472, 621, 140, 174, 143, 635, 260, 0, 213, 462, 572, 593, 628, 83, 611, 413, 174, 661, 561, 190, 460, 605, 170, 552, 638, 566], [3448, 607, 260, 290, 259, 621, 236, 204, 0, 448, 558, 579, 614, 270, 597, 493, 358, 647, 547, 188, 540, 645, 115, 632, 624, 647], [3453, 160, 409, 443, 413, 174, 336, 442, 429, 1, 110, 132, 166, 384, 150, 185, 296, 200, 100, 481, 154, 197, 313, 219, 176, 233], [3577, 145, 533, 568, 537, 159, 460, 566, 553, 123, 0, 147, 152, 508, 165, 309, 420, 185, 85, 606, 279, 213, 437, 234, 162, 224], [3571, 130, 526, 561, 530, 202, 454, 559, 546, 116, 139, 0, 195, 502, 18, 244, 413, 171, 119, 600, 273, 66, 430, 87, 72, 101], [3620, 89, 575, 611, 580, 130, 503, 608, 595, 165, 158, 189, 0, 551, 208, 351, 462, 129, 92, 649, 322, 256, 480, 246, 169, 230], [3520, 610, 136, 213, 182, 624, 278, 107, 268, 448, 560, 582, 616, 0, 600, 401, 189, 650, 550, 492, 449, 593, 199, 541, 627, 555], [3590, 157, 546, 581, 550, 217, 473, 579, 566, 136, 158, 19, 214, 521, 0, 229, 433, 197, 146, 619, 292, 48, 450, 69, 92, 83], [3486, 363, 442, 434, 403, 350, 369, 389, 462, 177, 286, 244, 342, 368, 246, 0, 260, 404, 276, 515, 65, 291, 346, 275, 305, 289], [3422, 548, 272, 218, 187, 561, 305, 186, 379, 388, 498, 519, 554, 179, 537, 316, 0, 588, 488, 356, 363, 458, 281, 406, 473, 420], [3556, 50, 594, 628, 599, 88, 522, 628, 614, 184, 177, 160, 122, 569, 178, 370, 481, 0, 111, 284, 340, 226, 499, 170, 121, 154], [3543, 106, 498, 534, 503, 109, 426, 532, 518, 88, 81, 112, 101, 474, 131, 274, 385, 146, 0, 572, 245, 178, 403, 154, 77, 139], [3483, 642, 253, 265, 234, 656, 271, 180, 166, 482, 592, 614, 648, 427, 632, 528, 333, 683, 582, 0, 57, 316, 150, 667, 659, 682], [3543, 326, 499, 491, 460, 340, 426, 446, 519, 165, 276, 299, 332, 425, 301, 55, 318, 366, 266, 572, 0, 345, 403, 332, 360, 346], [3601, 187, 603, 588, 608, 201, 531, 637, 623, 193, 216, 77, 262, 579, 58, 285, 490, 199, 176, 293, 350, 0, 508, 53, 101, 68], [3333, 492, 171, 271, 240, 506, 121, 171, 116, 333, 442, 464, 498, 200, 482, 378, 339, 532, 432, 169, 425, 530, 0, 517, 509, 532], [3548, 156, 624, 536, 583, 148, 552, 570, 644, 214, 227, 98, 209, 548, 79, 264, 436, 146, 146, 698, 329, 73, 529, 0, 67, 14], [3622, 89, 577, 612, 581, 182, 504, 610, 597, 167, 160, 76, 187, 553, 81, 289, 464, 130, 78, 651, 324, 111, 481, 77, 0, 62], [3562, 141, 629, 550, 598, 133, 556, 584, 649, 219, 212, 112, 194, 563, 93, 279, 450, 131, 130, 702, 343, 88, 533, 14, 52, 0]]}, "reference": {"optimum_s": 22141, "optimality": "best_found", "lower_bound_s": 20746, "floor_s": 19059, "solve_s": 63.24, "ffd_s": 24503, "stop_aware_best_s": 23420, "stop_aware_mean_s": 23732.8, "route_id": "RouteID_ff3c4430-40a2-4241-b598-51ef70977cb2", "plans": {"optimum": [{"route": ["S05", "S12", "S18", "S24", "S01", "S17", "S19", "S20", "S15", "S16"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S25", "S23", "S21", "S14", "S11", "S10", "S09"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S06", "S22", "S08", "S02", "S13", "S07", "S04", "S03"], "parcels": []}], "ffd": [{"route": ["S25", "S21", "S24", "S01", "S09", "S13"], "parcels": ["P02", "P11", "P19", "P31", "P37"]}, {"route": ["S21", "S24", "S20", "S04", "S07", "S02", "S08"], "parcels": ["P33", "P39"]}, {"route": ["S06", "S22", "S19", "S21", "S23", "S14", "S11", "S24", "S01", "S17", "S05", "S12", "S18", "S10", "S09", "S15", "S16", "S13", "S03"], "parcels": ["P01", "P12", "P13", "P17", "P18", "P20", "P32", "P34", "P38"]}], "stop_aware_best": [{"route": ["S23", "S24", "S09", "S20", "S08"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S25", "S17", "S12", "S18", "S10", "S11", "S14", "S15", "S16", "S13", "S04", "S03"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S05", "S01", "S21", "S19", "S07", "S02", "S22", "S06"], "parcels": []}]}}, "meta": {"route_id": "RouteID_ff3c4430-40a2-4241-b598-51ef70977cb2", "split": "train", "stops": 25, "vans": 3, "tightness": 0.93, "station": "DBO3", "city": "DBO", "date": "2018-08-11", "seconds": 115.1, "stop_aware_best_reward": 0.5581, "optimality": "best_found"}}
{"id": "cfd4c198-spread-n30-k4-t0.86-s0", "instance": {"stops": ["S01", "S02", "S03", "S04", "S05", "S06", "S07", "S08", "S09", "S10", "S11", "S12", "S13", "S14", "S15", "S16", "S17", "S18", "S19", "S20", "S21", "S22", "S23", "S24", "S25", "S26", "S27", "S28", "S29", "S30"], "parcels": [{"id": "P01", "stop": "S01", "volume_dl": 477}, {"id": "P02", "stop": "S01", "volume_dl": 133}, {"id": "P03", "stop": "S01", "volume_dl": 477}, {"id": "P04", "stop": "S01", "volume_dl": 34}, {"id": "P05", "stop": "S01", "volume_dl": 21}, {"id": "P06", "stop": "S01", "volume_dl": 28}, {"id": "P07", "stop": "S01", "volume_dl": 104}, {"id": "P08", "stop": "S01", "volume_dl": 57}, {"id": "P09", "stop": "S01", "volume_dl": 57}, {"id": "P10", "stop": "S02", "volume_dl": 57}, {"id": "P11", "stop": "S03", "volume_dl": 157}, {"id": "P12", "stop": "S04", "volume_dl": 95}, {"id": "P13", "stop": "S05", "volume_dl": 16}, {"id": "P14", "stop": "S05", "volume_dl": 22}, {"id": "P15", "stop": "S06", "volume_dl": 242}, {"id": "P16", "stop": "S07", "volume_dl": 57}, {"id": "P17", "stop": "S07", "volume_dl": 36}, {"id": "P18", "stop": "S07", "volume_dl": 429}, {"id": "P19", "stop": "S07", "volume_dl": 242}, {"id": "P20", "stop": "S07", "volume_dl": 8}, {"id": "P21", "stop": "S08", "volume_dl": 633}, {"id": "P22", "stop": "S08", "volume_dl": 37}, {"id": "P23", "stop": "S08", "volume_dl": 25}, {"id": "P24", "stop": "S09", "volume_dl": 259}, {"id": "P25", "stop": "S09", "volume_dl": 104}, {"id": "P26", "stop": "S09", "volume_dl": 31}, {"id": "P27", "stop": "S09", "volume_dl": 928}, {"id": "P28", "stop": "S10", "volume_dl": 32}, {"id": "P29", "stop": "S10", "volume_dl": 43}, {"id": "P30", "stop": "S10", "volume_dl": 34}, {"id": "P31", "stop": "S10", "volume_dl": 157}, {"id": "P32", "stop": "S10", "volume_dl": 34}, {"id": "P33", "stop": "S10", "volume_dl": 133}, {"id": "P34", "stop": "S10", "volume_dl": 5}, {"id": "P35", "stop": "S10", "volume_dl": 32}, {"id": "P36", "stop": "S10", "volume_dl": 59}, {"id": "P37", "stop": "S10", "volume_dl": 34}, {"id": "P38", "stop": "S11", "volume_dl": 92}, {"id": "P39", "stop": "S11", "volume_dl": 43}, {"id": "P40", "stop": "S11", "volume_dl": 51}, {"id": "P41", "stop": "S12", "volume_dl": 57}, {"id": "P42", "stop": "S13", "volume_dl": 57}, {"id": "P43", "stop": "S14", "volume_dl": 95}, {"id": "P44", "stop": "S15", "volume_dl": 133}, {"id": "P45", "stop": "S16", "volume_dl": 57}, {"id": "P46", "stop": "S16", "volume_dl": 104}, {"id": "P47", "stop": "S16", "volume_dl": 28}, {"id": "P48", "stop": "S17", "volume_dl": 57}, {"id": "P49", "stop": "S18", "volume_dl": 57}, {"id": "P50", "stop": "S18", "volume_dl": 104}, {"id": "P51", "stop": "S18", "volume_dl": 57}, {"id": "P52", "stop": "S19", "volume_dl": 242}, {"id": "P53", "stop": "S19", "volume_dl": 34}, {"id": "P54", "stop": "S20", "volume_dl": 322}, {"id": "P55", "stop": "S20", "volume_dl": 36}, {"id": "P56", "stop": "S20", "volume_dl": 179}, {"id": "P57", "stop": "S21", "volume_dl": 12}, {"id": "P58", "stop": "S22", "volume_dl": 40}, {"id": "P59", "stop": "S23", "volume_dl": 34}, {"id": "P60", "stop": "S23", "volume_dl": 53}, {"id": "P61", "stop": "S24", "volume_dl": 16}, {"id": "P62", "stop": "S24", "volume_dl": 63}, {"id": "P63", "stop": "S25", "volume_dl": 24}, {"id": "P64", "stop": "S26", "volume_dl": 133}, {"id": "P65", "stop": "S27", "volume_dl": 599}, {"id": "P66", "stop": "S28", "volume_dl": 34}, {"id": "P67", "stop": "S28", "volume_dl": 134}, {"id": "P68", "stop": "S28", "volume_dl": 242}, {"id": "P69", "stop": "S29", "volume_dl": 429}, {"id": "P70", "stop": "S30", "volume_dl": 46}, {"id": "P71", "stop": "S30", "volume_dl": 561}, {"id": "P72", "stop": "S30", "volume_dl": 9}, {"id": "P73", "stop": "S30", "volume_dl": 8}, {"id": "P74", "stop": "S30", "volume_dl": 322}], "vans": 4, "capacity_dl": 2879, "travel_s": [[0, 615, 584, 662, 749, 753, 748, 728, 633, 614, 762, 776, 716, 711, 663, 635, 606, 617, 675, 574, 622, 622, 611, 619, 628, 723, 643, 644, 605, 519, 574], [548, 0, 170, 175, 230, 266, 161, 135, 166, 82, 282, 206, 249, 102, 195, 133, 304, 150, 130, 96, 72, 169, 186, 132, 324, 132, 169, 111, 164, 562, 141], [530, 198, 0, 278, 332, 336, 248, 260, 49, 180, 345, 358, 132, 227, 245, 316, 264, 33, 111, 287, 188, 213, 242, 35, 286, 210, 225, 155, 355, 408, 282], [653, 226, 269, 0, 156, 151, 247, 227, 232, 294, 160, 200, 258, 275, 395, 304, 404, 268, 223, 268, 302, 184, 349, 252, 426, 287, 375, 285, 343, 496, 312], [699, 226, 329, 142, 0, 118, 247, 227, 292, 311, 131, 67, 318, 275, 399, 305, 464, 328, 283, 268, 300, 244, 349, 312, 486, 287, 379, 299, 343, 556, 312], [736, 276, 351, 140, 81, 0, 300, 281, 314, 376, 129, 82, 340, 328, 452, 358, 494, 350, 305, 322, 354, 267, 402, 331, 509, 340, 432, 352, 396, 578, 373], [655, 133, 180, 271, 307, 328, 0, 163, 125, 109, 338, 334, 208, 130, 216, 258, 316, 179, 134, 221, 116, 96, 212, 163, 338, 113, 196, 92, 296, 483, 253], [698, 173, 224, 189, 237, 280, 43, 0, 168, 152, 290, 220, 251, 173, 259, 300, 366, 222, 177, 264, 161, 139, 257, 203, 382, 156, 238, 136, 339, 526, 303], [517, 271, 210, 230, 283, 287, 323, 335, 0, 249, 296, 266, 83, 302, 344, 416, 352, 108, 186, 386, 257, 102, 341, 100, 367, 285, 324, 230, 420, 359, 389], [627, 70, 168, 251, 300, 343, 199, 164, 165, 0, 352, 283, 248, 131, 188, 198, 303, 149, 123, 161, 71, 168, 185, 131, 318, 161, 168, 110, 236, 560, 232], [753, 307, 368, 158, 122, 134, 325, 306, 332, 394, 0, 124, 358, 353, 477, 383, 512, 367, 323, 358, 379, 284, 427, 351, 526, 365, 457, 385, 422, 595, 398], [691, 215, 321, 153, 12, 129, 239, 218, 284, 303, 141, 0, 310, 267, 391, 297, 464, 320, 275, 260, 293, 237, 341, 301, 478, 279, 371, 291, 335, 548, 312], [597, 263, 236, 307, 360, 364, 313, 325, 113, 239, 373, 387, 0, 292, 346, 393, 357, 98, 175, 357, 246, 277, 342, 92, 379, 274, 326, 219, 432, 475, 383], [618, 117, 289, 184, 232, 275, 170, 150, 263, 201, 284, 259, 320, 0, 289, 195, 357, 270, 243, 159, 190, 246, 240, 254, 379, 178, 269, 190, 234, 558, 203], [560, 291, 174, 452, 487, 509, 372, 384, 222, 249, 518, 513, 306, 351, 0, 311, 152, 207, 284, 250, 256, 336, 205, 209, 174, 333, 188, 278, 356, 527, 245], [550, 167, 343, 270, 266, 361, 283, 264, 336, 252, 370, 292, 406, 247, 309, 0, 356, 320, 294, 178, 241, 314, 259, 304, 378, 259, 289, 271, 253, 672, 222], [537, 249, 132, 410, 445, 468, 330, 342, 181, 207, 477, 428, 264, 309, 166, 269, 0, 165, 243, 220, 216, 295, 163, 164, 15, 292, 146, 237, 286, 485, 211], [533, 289, 225, 245, 299, 302, 339, 351, 16, 265, 312, 325, 99, 318, 360, 431, 360, 0, 202, 402, 272, 118, 357, 118, 382, 301, 340, 246, 436, 375, 397], [612, 113, 176, 295, 343, 386, 194, 206, 174, 71, 395, 326, 257, 173, 172, 243, 287, 158, 0, 226, 79, 158, 169, 139, 301, 156, 152, 101, 282, 569, 216], [552, 198, 165, 360, 409, 440, 283, 295, 202, 160, 450, 392, 297, 262, 130, 233, 216, 198, 209, 0, 169, 248, 127, 197, 243, 245, 110, 190, 250, 518, 164], [583, 165, 98, 324, 395, 381, 246, 258, 94, 123, 390, 378, 177, 225, 224, 295, 241, 78, 52, 266, 0, 210, 221, 60, 256, 208, 204, 153, 334, 489, 268], [570, 144, 84, 302, 350, 393, 194, 206, 99, 110, 402, 377, 182, 173, 211, 274, 220, 83, 39, 253, 117, 0, 208, 67, 242, 156, 191, 101, 313, 494, 248], [507, 86, 210, 233, 282, 325, 219, 200, 255, 170, 334, 309, 338, 183, 176, 106, 265, 239, 212, 46, 160, 250, 0, 223, 287, 195, 156, 200, 123, 564, 92], [549, 260, 148, 365, 418, 424, 341, 353, 138, 218, 431, 401, 218, 320, 283, 354, 309, 119, 197, 336, 226, 305, 279, 0, 325, 302, 262, 247, 393, 427, 327], [523, 230, 118, 396, 431, 452, 316, 328, 166, 193, 461, 413, 250, 295, 152, 255, 130, 151, 228, 206, 201, 280, 149, 150, 0, 278, 132, 222, 272, 471, 195], [693, 171, 218, 252, 301, 344, 38, 107, 164, 147, 353, 328, 247, 168, 254, 296, 354, 217, 173, 260, 154, 134, 251, 201, 376, 0, 234, 130, 334, 521, 291], [524, 103, 222, 250, 299, 342, 236, 217, 270, 187, 351, 326, 354, 200, 193, 123, 200, 255, 229, 62, 176, 267, 17, 240, 222, 212, 0, 216, 140, 575, 57], [634, 208, 148, 366, 414, 457, 258, 270, 163, 173, 466, 441, 246, 237, 275, 338, 284, 147, 102, 317, 181, 64, 271, 131, 306, 219, 254, 0, 376, 558, 312], [566, 321, 207, 485, 545, 542, 405, 417, 256, 282, 552, 528, 339, 384, 241, 344, 174, 240, 318, 283, 290, 369, 238, 242, 189, 366, 221, 312, 0, 560, 286], [841, 605, 490, 654, 741, 745, 683, 695, 539, 560, 754, 768, 622, 662, 625, 696, 644, 523, 620, 667, 567, 647, 621, 525, 666, 644, 604, 589, 735, 0, 662], [569, 323, 210, 488, 548, 545, 408, 420, 258, 285, 554, 531, 342, 387, 244, 347, 177, 243, 320, 298, 293, 372, 241, 242, 193, 369, 224, 314, 366, 563, 0]]}, "reference": {"optimum_s": 7595, "optimality": "best_found", "lower_bound_s": 6043, "floor_s": 4104, "solve_s": 55.24, "ffd_s": 11320, "stop_aware_best_s": 9285, "stop_aware_mean_s": 9361.6, "route_id": "RouteID_cfd4c198-959a-462f-bcb9-e7b3944483bd", "plans": {"optimum": [{"route": ["S03", "S10", "S05", "S11", "S04", "S01", "S28"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S30", "S16", "S24", "S26", "S22", "S19", "S14"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S27", "S21", "S18", "S09", "S20", "S23"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S29", "S02", "S17", "S08", "S12", "S25", "S07", "S06", "S13", "S15"], "parcels": []}], "ffd": [{"route": ["S09", "S27", "S08", "S03", "S30"], "parcels": ["P21", "P27", "P71"]}, {"route": ["S29", "S10", "S07", "S20", "S09", "S01", "S30"], "parcels": ["P01", "P03", "P18", "P24", "P31", "P34", "P54", "P74"]}, {"route": ["S28", "S16", "S24", "S26", "S19", "S14", "S02", "S10", "S05", "S11", "S04", "S07", "S06", "S20", "S18", "S09", "S01", "S15"], "parcels": ["P02", "P07", "P08", "P09", "P13", "P16", "P19", "P25", "P33", "P36", "P38", "P46", "P50", "P52", "P56", "P62", "P67", "P68"]}, {"route": ["S28", "S16", "S24", "S30", "S22", "S19", "S09", "S01", "S13", "S10", "S05", "S11", "S07", "S25", "S21", "S18", "S20", "S17", "S08", "S12", "S23"], "parcels": ["P04", "P05", "P06", "P14", "P17", "P20", "P22", "P23", "P26", "P28", "P29", "P30", "P32", "P35", "P37", "P39", "P40", "P45", "P47", "P49", "P51", "P53", "P55", "P61", "P66", "P70", "P72", "P73"]}], "stop_aware_best": [{"route": ["S29", "S08", "S23", "S18", "S25", "S07", "S03", "S05", "S11", "S15"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S10", "S06", "S20", "S17", "S21", "S13", "S19", "S14", "S22", "S28"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S02", "S12", "S04", "S01", "S26", "S30"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S09", "S27", "S16", "S24"], "parcels": []}]}}, "meta": {"route_id": "RouteID_cfd4c198-959a-462f-bcb9-e7b3944483bd", "split": "train", "stops": 30, "vans": 4, "tightness": 0.86, "station": "DBO1", "city": "DBO", "date": "2018-08-10", "seconds": 115.5, "stop_aware_best_reward": 0.5121, "optimality": "best_found"}}
{"id": "3f5cab24-spread-n40-k4-t0.91-s0", "instance": {"stops": ["S01", "S02", "S03", "S04", "S05", "S06", "S07", "S08", "S09", "S10", "S11", "S12", "S13", "S14", "S15", "S16", "S17", "S18", "S19", "S20", "S21", "S22", "S23", "S24", "S25", "S26", "S27", "S28", "S29", "S30", "S31", "S32", "S33", "S34", "S35", "S36", "S37", "S38", "S39", "S40"], "parcels": [{"id": "P01", "stop": "S01", "volume_dl": 133}, {"id": "P02", "stop": "S02", "volume_dl": 6}, {"id": "P03", "stop": "S03", "volume_dl": 92}, {"id": "P04", "stop": "S04", "volume_dl": 40}, {"id": "P05", "stop": "S05", "volume_dl": 95}, {"id": "P06", "stop": "S06", "volume_dl": 46}, {"id": "P07", "stop": "S07", "volume_dl": 25}, {"id": "P08", "stop": "S07", "volume_dl": 5}, {"id": "P09", "stop": "S08", "volume_dl": 179}, {"id": "P10", "stop": "S08", "volume_dl": 179}, {"id": "P11", "stop": "S08", "volume_dl": 36}, {"id": "P12", "stop": "S09", "volume_dl": 104}, {"id": "P13", "stop": "S10", "volume_dl": 289}, {"id": "P14", "stop": "S11", "volume_dl": 57}, {"id": "P15", "stop": "S12", "volume_dl": 14}, {"id": "P16", "stop": "S13", "volume_dl": 277}, {"id": "P17", "stop": "S13", "volume_dl": 157}, {"id": "P18", "stop": "S14", "volume_dl": 133}, {"id": "P19", "stop": "S15", "volume_dl": 21}, {"id": "P20", "stop": "S15", "volume_dl": 690}, {"id": "P21", "stop": "S16", "volume_dl": 25}, {"id": "P22", "stop": "S17", "volume_dl": 34}, {"id": "P23", "stop": "S18", "volume_dl": 57}, {"id": "P24", "stop": "S19", "volume_dl": 24}, {"id": "P25", "stop": "S20", "volume_dl": 322}, {"id": "P26", "stop": "S21", "volume_dl": 57}, {"id": "P27", "stop": "S21", "volume_dl": 18}, {"id": "P28", "stop": "S22", "volume_dl": 133}, {"id": "P29", "stop": "S23", "volume_dl": 599}, {"id": "P30", "stop": "S24", "volume_dl": 79}, {"id": "P31", "stop": "S25", "volume_dl": 104}, {"id": "P32", "stop": "S25", "volume_dl": 557}, {"id": "P33", "stop": "S25", "volume_dl": 433}, {"id": "P34", "stop": "S26", "volume_dl": 34}, {"id": "P35", "stop": "S26", "volume_dl": 13}, {"id": "P36", "stop": "S27", "volume_dl": 104}, {"id": "P37", "stop": "S27", "volume_dl": 57}, {"id": "P38", "stop": "S27", "volume_dl": 57}, {"id": "P39", "stop": "S27", "volume_dl": 11}, {"id": "P40", "stop": "S27", "volume_dl": 33}, {"id": "P41", "stop": "S27", "volume_dl": 92}, {"id": "P42", "stop": "S27", "volume_dl": 133}, {"id": "P43", "stop": "S27", "volume_dl": 12}, {"id": "P44", "stop": "S27", "volume_dl": 289}, {"id": "P45", "stop": "S27", "volume_dl": 9}, {"id": "P46", "stop": "S27", "volume_dl": 34}, {"id": "P47", "stop": "S27", "volume_dl": 57}, {"id": "P48", "stop": "S27", "volume_dl": 133}, {"id": "P49", "stop": "S27", "volume_dl": 95}, {"id": "P50", "stop": "S27", "volume_dl": 95}, {"id": "P51", "stop": "S28", "volume_dl": 182}, {"id": "P52", "stop": "S28", "volume_dl": 59}, {"id": "P53", "stop": "S28", "volume_dl": 104}, {"id": "P54", "stop": "S29", "volume_dl": 226}, {"id": "P55", "stop": "S30", "volume_dl": 779}, {"id": "P56", "stop": "S30", "volume_dl": 45}, {"id": "P57", "stop": "S31", "volume_dl": 240}, {"id": "P58", "stop": "S32", "volume_dl": 179}, {"id": "P59", "stop": "S32", "volume_dl": 116}, {"id": "P60", "stop": "S32", "volume_dl": 289}, {"id": "P61", "stop": "S32", "volume_dl": 34}, {"id": "P62", "stop": "S33", "volume_dl": 8}, {"id": "P63", "stop": "S34", "volume_dl": 396}, {"id": "P64", "stop": "S35", "volume_dl": 445}, {"id": "P65", "stop": "S35", "volume_dl": 63}, {"id": "P66", "stop": "S35", "volume_dl": 57}, {"id": "P67", "stop": "S36", "volume_dl": 232}, {"id": "P68", "stop": "S37", "volume_dl": 288}, {"id": "P69", "stop": "S37", "volume_dl": 28}, {"id": "P70", "stop": "S38", "volume_dl": 28}, {"id": "P71", "stop": "S39", "volume_dl": 134}, {"id": "P72", "stop": "S40", "volume_dl": 60}, {"id": "P73", "stop": "S40", "volume_dl": 63}], "vans": 4, "capacity_dl": 2841, "travel_s": [[0, 2130, 2074, 2147, 2030, 2100, 2118, 2178, 2165, 2055, 2204, 2076, 2214, 2058, 2181, 2141, 2088, 2145, 2188, 2100, 2261, 2196, 2190, 2032, 2215, 2062, 1968, 2149, 2202, 2122, 2155, 2133, 2184, 1991, 2134, 2111, 2084, 2162, 2089, 2084, 2066], [2233, 0, 199, 252, 310, 285, 302, 314, 150, 181, 368, 331, 378, 231, 318, 270, 252, 134, 173, 167, 249, 360, 155, 83, 197, 155, 278, 115, 197, 334, 367, 141, 348, 305, 268, 94, 151, 326, 190, 143, 347], [2214, 206, 0, 95, 128, 114, 131, 369, 177, 207, 423, 252, 432, 17, 372, 113, 306, 157, 201, 244, 316, 414, 214, 160, 291, 115, 126, 225, 234, 240, 273, 146, 402, 153, 322, 187, 228, 381, 10, 97, 190], [2270, 228, 83, 0, 218, 142, 159, 418, 198, 228, 472, 194, 482, 115, 421, 73, 356, 178, 222, 265, 221, 464, 235, 181, 312, 136, 214, 246, 166, 201, 234, 167, 452, 240, 372, 208, 249, 430, 74, 118, 159], [2152, 307, 122, 207, 0, 172, 189, 342, 292, 194, 396, 191, 406, 106, 345, 194, 279, 272, 315, 292, 389, 387, 328, 224, 392, 189, 99, 326, 317, 219, 252, 260, 375, 126, 296, 288, 276, 354, 138, 211, 124], [2236, 263, 103, 125, 184, 0, 17, 426, 234, 264, 480, 282, 490, 87, 430, 143, 364, 214, 258, 300, 346, 472, 270, 217, 348, 172, 183, 282, 263, 270, 303, 202, 460, 210, 380, 244, 285, 438, 110, 154, 220], [2250, 277, 117, 138, 198, 14, 0, 440, 248, 278, 494, 296, 504, 101, 444, 157, 378, 228, 272, 314, 360, 486, 284, 231, 362, 186, 197, 296, 277, 284, 317, 216, 474, 224, 394, 258, 298, 452, 124, 168, 234], [2255, 342, 392, 445, 348, 442, 459, 0, 386, 284, 195, 500, 444, 376, 47, 466, 105, 365, 357, 312, 416, 187, 377, 245, 427, 339, 290, 322, 378, 488, 522, 388, 417, 309, 88, 323, 296, 281, 382, 361, 436], [2328, 145, 186, 160, 321, 262, 279, 368, 0, 244, 422, 206, 432, 218, 372, 159, 306, 22, 24, 221, 190, 414, 70, 137, 252, 126, 281, 97, 118, 209, 242, 46, 402, 308, 322, 148, 205, 380, 177, 88, 219], [2175, 174, 204, 257, 203, 290, 307, 283, 216, 0, 336, 373, 346, 236, 286, 275, 220, 196, 240, 157, 327, 328, 233, 90, 259, 149, 172, 193, 275, 362, 395, 219, 316, 198, 236, 155, 142, 294, 195, 171, 312], [2331, 418, 468, 521, 424, 518, 535, 191, 460, 360, 0, 576, 520, 452, 194, 539, 181, 441, 434, 388, 493, 88, 453, 321, 504, 415, 363, 395, 454, 565, 598, 464, 490, 385, 164, 400, 372, 357, 459, 437, 515], [2189, 355, 262, 215, 216, 284, 301, 499, 228, 377, 553, 0, 563, 246, 502, 154, 437, 250, 202, 449, 226, 545, 261, 381, 505, 329, 264, 245, 213, 74, 107, 275, 533, 291, 453, 401, 433, 511, 267, 311, 114], [2510, 500, 580, 536, 517, 638, 656, 303, 454, 453, 357, 582, 0, 612, 307, 535, 241, 476, 428, 591, 487, 349, 447, 507, 622, 580, 456, 390, 448, 585, 618, 500, 16, 478, 257, 518, 575, 297, 571, 542, 598], [2204, 227, 16, 116, 111, 98, 115, 352, 198, 223, 406, 235, 416, 0, 355, 134, 290, 178, 222, 265, 337, 398, 235, 181, 312, 136, 109, 247, 255, 223, 256, 167, 386, 136, 306, 208, 249, 364, 31, 118, 171], [2240, 328, 377, 430, 333, 427, 444, 49, 369, 269, 181, 486, 429, 361, 0, 448, 90, 350, 343, 298, 402, 172, 362, 230, 413, 324, 272, 305, 363, 474, 507, 373, 399, 295, 74, 309, 282, 266, 368, 346, 424], [2252, 257, 113, 64, 212, 171, 188, 451, 228, 258, 501, 130, 511, 144, 451, 0, 385, 208, 157, 294, 227, 493, 264, 211, 342, 166, 212, 276, 168, 132, 166, 196, 481, 239, 401, 238, 278, 459, 104, 147, 146], [2183, 270, 320, 373, 276, 370, 387, 100, 311, 212, 154, 428, 372, 304, 103, 391, 0, 293, 285, 240, 344, 146, 305, 172, 355, 266, 215, 247, 306, 416, 450, 316, 342, 237, 16, 251, 224, 209, 310, 289, 367], [2266, 123, 165, 180, 300, 251, 268, 347, 20, 222, 400, 226, 410, 196, 350, 179, 284, 0, 44, 199, 193, 392, 74, 115, 230, 104, 259, 99, 138, 228, 262, 29, 380, 286, 300, 126, 183, 358, 155, 66, 242], [2305, 171, 180, 136, 301, 239, 256, 395, 26, 270, 448, 182, 458, 212, 398, 135, 332, 48, 0, 247, 127, 440, 96, 163, 278, 152, 299, 122, 94, 185, 218, 72, 428, 326, 348, 174, 231, 406, 171, 114, 198], [2196, 180, 230, 282, 333, 316, 333, 278, 223, 144, 331, 449, 341, 261, 281, 301, 215, 203, 246, 0, 334, 323, 240, 82, 265, 185, 301, 199, 282, 437, 470, 225, 311, 250, 231, 161, 36, 289, 220, 212, 387], [2419, 270, 308, 225, 404, 367, 384, 430, 155, 375, 484, 229, 572, 340, 464, 220, 368, 204, 129, 361, 0, 476, 130, 277, 392, 308, 405, 160, 143, 236, 269, 211, 542, 432, 384, 288, 345, 492, 299, 270, 321], [2323, 410, 460, 513, 416, 510, 527, 186, 452, 352, 69, 568, 512, 444, 186, 531, 173, 433, 426, 380, 485, 0, 445, 313, 495, 407, 355, 387, 446, 557, 590, 456, 482, 377, 156, 391, 364, 349, 451, 429, 504], [2355, 158, 230, 186, 351, 289, 306, 396, 89, 263, 450, 232, 460, 262, 400, 185, 334, 74, 78, 249, 120, 442, 0, 165, 280, 178, 333, 86, 99, 235, 268, 80, 430, 360, 350, 176, 233, 408, 221, 140, 248], [2149, 98, 147, 200, 258, 233, 250, 231, 140, 98, 285, 366, 295, 179, 234, 218, 168, 120, 164, 83, 251, 276, 157, 0, 183, 103, 227, 116, 199, 354, 388, 143, 264, 254, 185, 79, 68, 243, 138, 129, 305], [2263, 105, 229, 282, 340, 315, 332, 344, 205, 211, 398, 398, 408, 261, 348, 300, 282, 186, 229, 197, 316, 390, 222, 113, 0, 185, 309, 182, 264, 436, 470, 208, 378, 336, 298, 77, 181, 356, 220, 194, 387], [2173, 159, 92, 145, 198, 178, 195, 323, 129, 129, 373, 311, 383, 124, 322, 163, 257, 109, 153, 196, 302, 365, 183, 113, 244, 0, 166, 178, 247, 299, 332, 126, 353, 193, 273, 140, 180, 331, 83, 74, 250], [2072, 241, 143, 228, 99, 193, 210, 264, 275, 166, 314, 251, 324, 127, 264, 215, 198, 255, 299, 210, 394, 306, 300, 143, 326, 172, 0, 260, 342, 239, 272, 244, 294, 60, 214, 222, 194, 272, 158, 195, 187], [2267, 110, 214, 170, 335, 272, 290, 352, 88, 215, 403, 216, 412, 246, 352, 169, 286, 95, 62, 201, 134, 394, 81, 118, 232, 189, 313, 0, 82, 219, 252, 101, 382, 340, 302, 128, 185, 361, 205, 161, 232], [2329, 195, 205, 161, 325, 263, 280, 386, 79, 300, 436, 287, 497, 236, 416, 160, 320, 101, 53, 286, 120, 428, 101, 202, 317, 205, 323, 84, 0, 293, 326, 125, 467, 350, 336, 213, 270, 444, 196, 167, 220], [2266, 352, 250, 215, 255, 272, 289, 495, 225, 365, 549, 76, 558, 234, 498, 151, 432, 247, 199, 444, 232, 540, 258, 362, 493, 317, 252, 242, 210, 0, 53, 272, 528, 279, 448, 389, 429, 507, 255, 299, 152], [2297, 366, 264, 229, 265, 286, 303, 512, 239, 379, 563, 108, 572, 248, 512, 165, 446, 261, 213, 459, 246, 554, 272, 376, 507, 331, 266, 256, 224, 54, 0, 286, 542, 293, 462, 403, 443, 521, 269, 313, 179], [2263, 149, 161, 192, 296, 247, 264, 378, 32, 219, 432, 238, 442, 193, 381, 191, 316, 37, 56, 230, 188, 424, 68, 147, 262, 141, 256, 94, 150, 241, 274, 0, 412, 283, 332, 158, 215, 390, 152, 66, 254], [2494, 484, 564, 520, 500, 622, 639, 291, 438, 436, 341, 566, 30, 595, 290, 519, 224, 460, 412, 574, 471, 332, 431, 491, 606, 564, 439, 373, 432, 568, 602, 484, 0, 462, 241, 502, 559, 281, 554, 526, 579], [2125, 293, 160, 245, 116, 210, 227, 313, 310, 212, 367, 268, 377, 144, 317, 232, 251, 290, 333, 263, 427, 359, 346, 196, 378, 207, 70, 312, 395, 256, 290, 278, 347, 0, 267, 274, 247, 325, 176, 229, 207], [2166, 254, 303, 356, 260, 354, 371, 187, 295, 196, 319, 412, 356, 288, 165, 375, 229, 277, 269, 224, 328, 311, 288, 156, 339, 250, 198, 231, 289, 400, 433, 299, 326, 221, 0, 235, 208, 193, 294, 273, 350], [2213, 94, 180, 233, 291, 266, 283, 299, 156, 162, 349, 349, 359, 211, 298, 251, 232, 136, 180, 147, 267, 340, 173, 64, 152, 135, 259, 133, 215, 387, 420, 159, 328, 286, 249, 0, 132, 307, 170, 145, 337], [2200, 184, 233, 286, 336, 319, 336, 282, 227, 148, 335, 453, 345, 265, 285, 305, 219, 207, 250, 36, 338, 327, 243, 86, 269, 189, 305, 203, 286, 441, 474, 229, 315, 254, 235, 165, 0, 293, 224, 216, 391], [2256, 343, 393, 491, 349, 443, 460, 273, 409, 285, 330, 501, 353, 377, 252, 490, 214, 366, 383, 313, 442, 322, 402, 246, 428, 340, 288, 344, 403, 490, 523, 389, 323, 310, 298, 324, 297, 0, 384, 362, 437], [2203, 196, 9, 85, 152, 115, 132, 386, 167, 196, 440, 249, 450, 41, 390, 103, 324, 147, 190, 233, 306, 432, 203, 150, 281, 105, 150, 215, 223, 238, 271, 135, 420, 177, 340, 177, 217, 398, 0, 86, 188], [2200, 147, 99, 152, 234, 185, 202, 346, 80, 156, 400, 318, 410, 130, 350, 170, 284, 60, 104, 211, 254, 392, 134, 128, 254, 82, 193, 160, 198, 306, 339, 72, 380, 220, 300, 150, 195, 358, 90, 0, 256], [2133, 349, 190, 156, 150, 213, 230, 439, 317, 306, 489, 94, 499, 171, 439, 140, 373, 300, 226, 385, 308, 481, 356, 303, 434, 258, 192, 265, 233, 138, 171, 288, 466, 219, 389, 330, 369, 444, 196, 239, 0]]}, "reference": {"optimum_s": 20692, "optimality": "best_found", "lower_bound_s": 18206, "floor_s": 16160, "solve_s": 62.46, "ffd_s": 24287, "stop_aware_best_s": 22598, "stop_aware_mean_s": 22835.6, "route_id": "RouteID_3f5cab24-ce9f-4eca-b10c-6bcba85424f1", "plans": {"optimum": [{"route": ["S09", "S35", "S24", "S01", "S32", "S12", "S37", "S21", "S10", "S07", "S14", "S16", "S34"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S23", "S22", "S20", "S28", "S18", "S08", "S17", "S31", "S39", "S38", "S02", "S13", "S26"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S33", "S04", "S05", "S06", "S03", "S15", "S29", "S30", "S11", "S40"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S25", "S27", "S36", "S19"], "parcels": []}], "ffd": [{"route": ["S30", "S15", "S28", "S17", "S25", "S23"], "parcels": ["P20", "P32", "P51", "P55"]}, {"route": ["S32", "S37", "S10", "S34", "S20", "S27", "S24", "S35", "S25"], "parcels": ["P33", "P39", "P44", "P60", "P64", "P68"]}, {"route": ["S29", "S06", "S13", "S25", "S39", "S31", "S08", "S22", "S27", "S01", "S36", "S09", "S32", "S14"], "parcels": ["P09", "P10", "P31", "P42", "P48", "P58", "P59"]}, {"route": ["S26", "S33", "S04", "S40", "S11", "S30", "S15", "S03", "S05", "S02", "S38", "S08", "S18", "S28", "S27", "S35", "S19", "S12", "S32", "S37", "S21", "S07", "S16"], "parcels": ["P11", "P19", "P36", "P37", "P38", "P40", "P41", "P43", "P45", "P46", "P47", "P49", "P50", "P52", "P53", "P56", "P61", "P65", "P66", "P69"]}], "stop_aware_best": [{"route": ["S05", "S15", "S22", "S27", "S24", "S35", "S16"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S04", "S13", "S03", "S28", "S39", "S19", "S12", "S32", "S37", "S21", "S10", "S34"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S26", "S38", "S40", "S11", "S30", "S20", "S18", "S08", "S01", "S09", "S07", "S14"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S33", "S29", "S06", "S02", "S25", "S31", "S17", "S23", "S36"], "parcels": []}]}}, "meta": {"route_id": "RouteID_3f5cab24-ce9f-4eca-b10c-6bcba85424f1", "split": "train", "stops": 40, "vans": 4, "tightness": 0.91, "station": "DLA7", "city": "DLA", "date": "2018-08-03", "seconds": 123.3, "stop_aware_best_reward": 0.5513, "optimality": "best_found"}}
{"id": "2d83827e-spread-n25-k3-t0.92-s0", "instance": {"stops": ["S01", "S02", "S03", "S04", "S05", "S06", "S07", "S08", "S09", "S10", "S11", "S12", "S13", "S14", "S15", "S16", "S17", "S18", "S19", "S20", "S21", "S22", "S23", "S24", "S25"], "parcels": [{"id": "P01", "stop": "S01", "volume_dl": 779}, {"id": "P02", "stop": "S02", "volume_dl": 38}, {"id": "P03", "stop": "S02", "volume_dl": 46}, {"id": "P04", "stop": "S03", "volume_dl": 242}, {"id": "P05", "stop": "S04", "volume_dl": 53}, {"id": "P06", "stop": "S05", "volume_dl": 179}, {"id": "P07", "stop": "S06", "volume_dl": 242}, {"id": "P08", "stop": "S07", "volume_dl": 133}, {"id": "P09", "stop": "S08", "volume_dl": 322}, {"id": "P10", "stop": "S08", "volume_dl": 157}, {"id": "P11", "stop": "S08", "volume_dl": 322}, {"id": "P12", "stop": "S09", "volume_dl": 157}, {"id": "P13", "stop": "S09", "volume_dl": 242}, {"id": "P14", "stop": "S10", "volume_dl": 14}, {"id": "P15", "stop": "S10", "volume_dl": 34}, {"id": "P16", "stop": "S10", "volume_dl": 104}, {"id": "P17", "stop": "S11", "volume_dl": 179}, {"id": "P18", "stop": "S12", "volume_dl": 29}, {"id": "P19", "stop": "S12", "volume_dl": 226}, {"id": "P20", "stop": "S12", "volume_dl": 779}, {"id": "P21", "stop": "S13", "volume_dl": 16}, {"id": "P22", "stop": "S14", "volume_dl": 51}, {"id": "P23", "stop": "S15", "volume_dl": 44}, {"id": "P24", "stop": "S16", "volume_dl": 119}, {"id": "P25", "stop": "S17", "volume_dl": 57}, {"id": "P26", "stop": "S18", "volume_dl": 57}, {"id": "P27", "stop": "S18", "volume_dl": 133}, {"id": "P28", "stop": "S18", "volume_dl": 95}, {"id": "P29", "stop": "S19", "volume_dl": 201}, {"id": "P30", "stop": "S20", "volume_dl": 3}, {"id": "P31", "stop": "S20", "volume_dl": 16}, {"id": "P32", "stop": "S20", "volume_dl": 12}, {"id": "P33", "stop": "S20", "volume_dl": 259}, {"id": "P34", "stop": "S21", "volume_dl": 368}, {"id": "P35", "stop": "S21", "volume_dl": 133}, {"id": "P36", "stop": "S22", "volume_dl": 59}, {"id": "P37", "stop": "S23", "volume_dl": 194}, {"id": "P38", "stop": "S24", "volume_dl": 57}, {"id": "P39", "stop": "S25", "volume_dl": 95}], "vans": 3, "capacity_dl": 2265, "travel_s": [[0, 2341, 2385, 2392, 2188, 2395, 2355, 2295, 2254, 2258, 2216, 2324, 2280, 2243, 2394, 2337, 2483, 2365, 2484, 2373, 2312, 2260, 2268, 2188, 2220, 2456], [2058, 0, 400, 278, 410, 409, 576, 296, 470, 163, 97, 210, 184, 101, 53, 271, 363, 639, 143, 362, 278, 411, 55, 121, 442, 115], [1992, 390, 0, 231, 355, 45, 592, 144, 266, 323, 379, 244, 344, 360, 402, 317, 568, 584, 530, 298, 161, 202, 404, 350, 324, 505], [1951, 308, 249, 0, 314, 285, 480, 178, 333, 241, 337, 209, 262, 318, 320, 275, 466, 543, 451, 332, 195, 274, 322, 309, 346, 423], [2008, 401, 470, 450, 0, 481, 322, 380, 311, 316, 319, 382, 338, 336, 414, 441, 541, 385, 544, 534, 397, 346, 371, 290, 211, 516], [2011, 408, 47, 250, 373, 0, 604, 163, 278, 342, 397, 280, 363, 378, 421, 336, 588, 603, 551, 318, 180, 219, 422, 369, 336, 523], [2154, 576, 593, 626, 378, 604, 0, 503, 446, 492, 541, 557, 513, 512, 589, 617, 717, 126, 719, 657, 520, 469, 569, 512, 392, 692], [2072, 299, 137, 161, 389, 147, 499, 0, 173, 232, 355, 122, 254, 370, 312, 226, 424, 517, 442, 154, 17, 114, 313, 379, 231, 414], [2107, 497, 289, 361, 367, 299, 448, 198, 0, 430, 501, 320, 452, 496, 510, 425, 623, 512, 637, 353, 215, 164, 511, 473, 121, 612], [1976, 145, 324, 214, 327, 345, 494, 232, 406, 0, 202, 146, 21, 174, 158, 125, 225, 557, 285, 306, 214, 347, 159, 225, 360, 260], [2039, 108, 436, 326, 391, 457, 557, 344, 483, 210, 0, 258, 232, 60, 162, 319, 471, 620, 248, 410, 326, 459, 83, 79, 423, 224], [2065, 197, 245, 188, 398, 281, 591, 127, 300, 131, 254, 0, 152, 268, 210, 125, 356, 546, 340, 208, 108, 241, 212, 278, 358, 313], [1994, 163, 354, 233, 346, 363, 512, 278, 450, 18, 220, 216, 0, 192, 176, 103, 203, 558, 303, 284, 259, 392, 178, 244, 378, 279], [1992, 92, 432, 310, 343, 441, 510, 328, 435, 190, 60, 242, 211, 0, 146, 303, 455, 572, 235, 394, 310, 443, 72, 57, 375, 208], [2068, 64, 409, 288, 419, 418, 585, 306, 479, 172, 162, 220, 194, 175, 0, 281, 384, 648, 165, 372, 288, 420, 130, 185, 451, 137], [2052, 256, 332, 247, 456, 342, 520, 195, 367, 190, 313, 133, 109, 327, 269, 0, 252, 475, 399, 201, 176, 310, 270, 336, 347, 372], [2209, 378, 560, 448, 560, 570, 727, 423, 597, 233, 435, 390, 215, 407, 391, 278, 0, 722, 246, 415, 405, 538, 392, 458, 593, 274], [2179, 673, 656, 710, 440, 666, 137, 566, 509, 576, 573, 586, 597, 600, 673, 529, 758, 0, 816, 565, 554, 532, 625, 545, 455, 788], [2196, 138, 538, 416, 547, 547, 714, 434, 608, 279, 235, 348, 261, 239, 169, 324, 223, 777, 0, 500, 416, 549, 193, 259, 580, 25], [2092, 371, 318, 353, 504, 328, 560, 180, 354, 304, 428, 194, 326, 442, 384, 212, 422, 515, 514, 0, 162, 265, 385, 457, 386, 486], [2077, 282, 155, 179, 407, 166, 518, 18, 192, 215, 339, 105, 237, 353, 295, 210, 407, 500, 422, 137, 0, 133, 296, 362, 250, 397], [2120, 401, 193, 265, 363, 203, 473, 103, 147, 335, 458, 224, 356, 472, 414, 329, 527, 538, 541, 257, 120, 0, 416, 478, 205, 517], [2050, 64, 417, 296, 401, 426, 568, 314, 487, 180, 67, 227, 201, 70, 117, 288, 426, 631, 207, 380, 295, 428, 0, 90, 434, 179], [2013, 134, 474, 352, 364, 483, 531, 370, 456, 236, 63, 284, 258, 60, 188, 345, 497, 594, 277, 436, 352, 485, 115, 0, 396, 250], [2028, 450, 341, 413, 278, 351, 403, 250, 146, 365, 414, 372, 387, 386, 463, 490, 590, 467, 593, 405, 267, 216, 443, 386, 0, 565], [2171, 113, 513, 392, 523, 522, 689, 410, 583, 304, 210, 323, 286, 214, 144, 349, 247, 752, 28, 476, 391, 524, 168, 234, 555, 0]]}, "reference": {"optimum_s": 15755, "optimality": "best_found", "lower_bound_s": 14467, "floor_s": 12417, "solve_s": 38.15, "ffd_s": 18054, "stop_aware_best_s": 17102, "stop_aware_mean_s": 17531.8, "route_id": "RouteID_2d83827e-d6b9-44a8-a631-532e7cc52cbc", "plans": {"optimum": [{"route": ["S23", "S10", "S13", "S22", "S01", "S14", "S25", "S18", "S16", "S12", "S09"], "parcels": ["P13", "P18"]}, {"route": ["S04", "S06", "S17", "S24", "S08", "S21", "S05", "S02"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S09", "S12", "S15", "S11", "S19", "S20", "S07", "S03"], "parcels": ["P12", "P19", "P20"]}], "ffd": [{"route": ["S08", "S21", "S12", "S01", "S13"], "parcels": ["P09", "P20", "P34"]}, {"route": ["S23", "S09", "S12", "S03", "S19", "S20", "S05", "S08", "S06"], "parcels": ["P10", "P11", "P13", "P19", "P33"]}, {"route": ["S10", "S22", "S14", "S25", "S18", "S16", "S09", "S12", "S15", "S11", "S20", "S07", "S02", "S21", "S24", "S04", "S17"], "parcels": ["P12", "P18", "P30", "P31", "P32", "P35"]}], "stop_aware_best": [{"route": ["S24", "S20", "S05", "S03", "S12", "S14", "S13"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S17", "S06", "S08", "S21", "S02", "S07", "S19", "S15", "S22"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S04", "S23", "S10", "S01", "S25", "S18", "S16", "S09", "S11"], "parcels": []}]}}, "meta": {"route_id": "RouteID_2d83827e-d6b9-44a8-a631-532e7cc52cbc", "split": "train", "stops": 25, "vans": 3, "tightness": 0.92, "station": "DSE5", "city": "DSE", "date": "2018-08-16", "seconds": 88.8, "stop_aware_best_reward": 0.5654, "optimality": "best_found"}}