"""Judge validation: controls, repeat noise, cross-judge agreement, agreement with reference-based ROUGE-L. Writes manifests/judge_validation.json.""" import json import sys from pathlib import Path import numpy as np import pandas as pd from scipy.stats import pearsonr, spearmanr sys.path.insert(0, "src") ROOT = Path("/mnt/localssd/seqroute1m") S = ROOT / "scores/judge" def jq(d): return 0.4 * d.factuality + 0.4 * d.coverage + 0.2 * (d.relevance + d.coherence + d.instruction_adherence) / 3 def load(name): d = pd.read_json(S / f"parsed_{name}.jsonl", lines=True) return d q = pd.read_parquet(ROOT / "queries/queries_20k.parquet", columns=["query_id", "task_family", "reference", "prompt"]).set_index("query_id") out = {} P = load("primary") raw = pd.read_json(S / "raw_primary.jsonl", lines=True) out["primary_calls"] = int(raw.id.str.contains("#r0$").sum()) out["primary_retried_calls"] = int(raw.id.str.contains("~rt").sum()) out["primary_unparsed"] = int((~P.parsed).sum()) P = P[P.parsed & P.get("empty_final", pd.Series(False, index=P.index)).fillna(False).eq(False)].copy() P["Qw"] = jq(P) ctrl = P[P.id.str.startswith("ctrl_")].copy() ctrl["kind"] = ctrl.id.str.split("|").str[0] ctrl["query_id"] = ctrl.id.str.split("|").str[1] ctrl["family"] = ctrl.query_id.map(q.task_family) out["controls_mean_Q"] = ctrl.groupby(["family", "kind"]).Qw.mean().round(3).unstack().to_dict() pos, neg = ctrl[ctrl.kind == "ctrl_ref"].set_index("query_id").Qw, ctrl[ctrl.kind == "ctrl_neg"].set_index("query_id").Qw both = pd.concat([pos.rename("ref"), neg.rename("neg")], axis=1).dropna() out["control_pairs"] = int(len(both)) out["control_ref_gt_neg_rate"] = float((both.ref > both.neg).mean()) out["control_neg_Q_below_3_rate"] = float((both.neg < 3).mean()) M = P[~P.id.str.startswith("ctrl_")].copy() M[["model_id", "query_id"]] = M.id.str.split("|", n=1, expand=True) M["family"] = M.query_id.map(q.task_family) out["Q_saturation"] = {f: dict(mean=float(g.Qw.mean()), share_ge_9=float((g.Qw >= 9).mean()), share_eq_10=float((g.Qw >= 9.99).mean())) for f, g in M.groupby("family")} # agreement with ROUGE-L against the dataset reference summary try: from rouge_score import rouge_scorer sc = rouge_scorer.RougeScorer(["rougeL"]) resp = {} for mfile in (ROOT / "responses").glob("*.jsonl"): pass sub = M.sample(min(3000, len(M)), random_state=0) vals = [] cache = {} for r in sub.itertuples(): if r.model_id not in cache: cache[r.model_id] = {j["id"]: j for j in map(json.loads, open(ROOT / "responses" / f"{r.model_id}.jsonl"))} t = cache[r.model_id][r.query_id]["text"] t = t.rsplit("", 1)[-1].strip() vals.append(sc.score(q.reference[r.query_id], t)["rougeL"].fmeasure) sub = sub.assign(rougeL=vals) out["corr_with_rougeL"] = {f: dict(pearson=float(pearsonr(g.Qw, g.rougeL)[0]), spearman=float(spearmanr(g.Qw, g.rougeL)[0]), n=int(len(g))) for f, g in sub.groupby("family")} except Exception as e: out["corr_with_rougeL"] = f"unavailable: {e!r}" # cross-judge try: A = load("alt") A = A[A.parsed & ~A.id.str.startswith("ctrl_")].copy() A["Qw"] = jq(A) A[["model_id", "query_id"]] = A.id.str.split("|", n=1, expand=True) J = M.merge(A[["id", "Qw"]], on="id", suffixes=("", "_alt")) out["cross_judge"] = {f: dict(n=int(len(g)), pearson=float(pearsonr(g.Qw, g.Qw_alt)[0]), spearman=float(spearmanr(g.Qw, g.Qw_alt)[0]), mean_primary=float(g.Qw.mean()), mean_alt=float(g.Qw_alt.mean()), mean_abs_diff=float((g.Qw - g.Qw_alt).abs().mean())) for f, g in J.groupby("family")} mp = J.groupby("model_id").Qw.mean(); ma = J.groupby("model_id").Qw_alt.mean() out["cross_judge_model_ranking_spearman"] = float(spearmanr(mp, ma.reindex(mp.index))[0]) except Exception as e: out["cross_judge"] = f"unavailable: {e!r}" # repeat noise on the weighted score try: R = load("repeat"); R = R[R.parsed & ~R.id.str.startswith("ctrl_")].copy(); R["Qw"] = jq(R) R["family"] = R.id.str.split("|").str[1].map(q.task_family) out["repeat"] = {f: dict(n_responses=int(g.id.nunique()), within_sd=float(np.sqrt(g.groupby("id").Qw.var(ddof=1).mean())), total_sd=float(g.Qw.std(ddof=1))) for f, g in R.groupby("family")} except Exception as e: out["repeat"] = f"unavailable: {e!r}" json.dump(out, open(ROOT / "manifests/judge_validation.json", "w"), indent=1) print(json.dumps({k: out[k] for k in out if k not in ("Q_saturation",)}, indent=1)[:3000])