***************************************** * This do-file replicates a research claim from Mohammad Alamgir Hossain (2020) * "Is the spread of COVID-19 across countries influenced by environmental, economic and social factors?" * H*: At the country level, the democracy index will be positively associated with * the total number of confirmed infections per one million people. * ***************************************** version 15.1 clear all cd "..." /*Change directory*/ *Start a log file local log_name "Hossain_Replication" /*Give a name to the log where session is recorded*/ log using `log_name', replace use "COVID replication.dta" /*Import provided replication dataset*/ local dataset = 1 *Value dataset = 1 COVID cases at time frame of the original study (i.e. cases of infection per one million people on April 03 2020) *Value dataset = 2 COVID cases at time frame after the original study was conducted (i.e. cases of infection per one million people after April 03 2020) *Value dataset = 3 COVID cases at whole frame (i.e. cases of infection per one million people between December 31 2019 and August 11 2020) *Value dataset = 4 COVID cases at time frames not used in the original study *(i.e. cases of infection per one million people between December 31 2019 and August 11 2020; and cases of infection per one million people after April 03 2020) *Value dataset = 5 all available time frames if `dataset'==1 { *COVID_12_31_04_03 is confirmed COVID cases 12.31.2019 to 04.03.2020 rename COVID_12_31_04_03 total_cases } else if `dataset'==2 { *COVID_04_04_08_11 is confirmed COVID cases 04.04.2020 to 08.11.2020 rename COVID_04_04_08_11 total_cases } else if `dataset'==3 { *COVID_12_31_08_11 is confirmed COVID cases 12.31.2019 to 08.11.2020 rename COVID_12_31_08_11 total_cases } else if `dataset'==4 { save temp.dta, replace *COVID_04_04_08_11 is confirmed COVID cases 04.04.2020 to 08.11.2020 gen total_cases=COVID_04_04_08_11 append using temp.dta *COVID_12_31_08_11 is confirmed COVID cases 12.31.2019 to 08.11.2020 replace total_cases=COVID_12_31_08_11 if total_cases==. erase temp.dta } else { save temp.dta, replace *COVID_12_31_04_03 is confirmed COVID cases 12.31.2019 to 04.03.2020 gen total_cases=COVID_12_31_04_03 append using temp.dta *COVID_04_04_08_11 is confirmed COVID cases 04.04.2020 to 08.11.2020 replace total_cases=COVID_04_04_08_11 if total_cases==. append using temp.dta **COVID_12_31_08_11 is confirmed COVID cases 12.31.2019 to 08.11.2020 replace total_cases=COVID_12_31_08_11 if total_cases==. erase temp.dta } ********* Dependent variable: Cases of infection per one million people ********* *Page 10: "Total cases of infection are converted to cases per one million population *to capture the population effect. Cases of infection per one million people on *03 April 2020 by countries is denoted by Y and used as the dependent variable in our experimentation." *Page 11: "Y is the total number of cases of confirmed infection per one million *people in a country on a day (03 April 2020)" *While in the original study the time frame is April 03 2020, in the replication it depends on the type of analysis chosen *Use total COVID cases (total_cases) and population (popData2019) to construct total number of cases per million people gen cases_per_million = total_cases/popData2019*1000000 *Page 11: "X1 is yearly average temperature of countries, * X2 is yearly average precipitation of countries, * X3 is openness measured by international trade as a percentage of GDP of countries * X4 is democracy index of countries and * X5 is population density of countries in 2018. *Page 13: "We apply Least Squares method on model (1) and find *that precipitation and population density have no significant effect on *the number of infection cases per one million people (Y). Those variables *are then excluded, and the model is re-estimated" ********************** Focal independent variable: Democracy ********************** *Use Democracy for the democracy index. rename Democracy democracy *Note The Economist publishes the index with a scale from 0 to 10. However, Gapminder (the data source for democracy index) *has converted the index from 0 to 100 to make it easier to communicate as a percentage. *See https://www.gapminder.org/data/documentation/democracy-index/ *Because the author of the original study used the scores of democracy index compiled by Economist *Intelligence Unit (page 9), the data obtained in Gapminder is divided by 10 replace democracy = democracy/10 ************************ Other controls ************************ *1) Yearly average temperature of countries: *Variable: Annual_temp *Annual temperature (averaged 1961 to 1999) *Continuous variable rename Annual_temp temperature *2) Openness measured by international trade as a percentage of GDP of countriess: *Variable: trade_2016 *International trade (imputed) *Continuous variable rename trade_2016 openness ************************ Test of the SCORE claim, H* ************************ *Page 11: "We first simply regress total number of cases of infection per one *million people by countries reported on a recent day (03 April 2020) on our *selected explanatory variables. Specifically, we estimate the following regression: * Y = \delta + \mu_{1}X1 + \mu_{2}X2 + \mu_{3}X3 + \mu_{4}X4 + \mu_{5}X5 + \nu (1) *Y is the total number of cases of confirmed infection per one million people in *a country on a day (03 April 2020), X1 is yearly average temperature of countries, *X2 is yearly average precipitation of countries, X3 is openness measured by *international trade as a percentage of GDP of countries, X4 is democracy index *of countries and X5 is population density of countries in 2018. *Page 13: "We apply Least Squares method on model (1) and find that precipitation *and population density have no significant effect on the number of infection cases *per one million people (Y). Those variables are then excluded, and the model is re-estimated" *Control variables *1)Temperature *2)Openness local covariates "temperature openness" *Regression model reg cases_per_million democracy `covariates' *Close log log close *Create PDF from log translate `log_name'.smcl `log_name'.pdf, replace display `End of Do-file'