"""Checks of the task add-user-testing against the planner app's state, exported by REA from a desktop application capture. It reads the app's data/get through the computer, takes the typed views of its files and evaluates each check: no model, no code from the task. A failure to reach the app raises, so the run fails rather than scoring the agent. """ import json import math import re from agentenv_protocol import client as protocol from agentenv_protocol.types import RPC_PATH APP = "planner" CHECKS = [ {"id": "user-testing", "kind": "value_equals", "file": "Documents/website-launch.planner", "pointer": "/root/children/[name=tasks]/children/[name=task][@name=User testing]/attributes/name", "value": "User testing"}, {"id": "requirements-kept", "kind": "value_equals", "file": "Documents/website-launch.planner", "pointer": "/root/children/[name=tasks]/children/[name=task][@name=Requirements]/attributes/name", "value": "Requirements"}, {"id": "design-kept", "kind": "value_equals", "file": "Documents/website-launch.planner", "pointer": "/root/children/[name=tasks]/children/[name=task][@name=Design]/attributes/name", "value": "Design"}, {"id": "development-kept", "kind": "value_equals", "file": "Documents/website-launch.planner", "pointer": "/root/children/[name=tasks]/children/[name=task][@name=Development]/attributes/work", "value": "144000"}, {"id": "launch-kept", "kind": "value_equals", "file": "Documents/website-launch.planner", "pointer": "/root/children/[name=tasks]/children/[name=task][@name=Launch]/attributes/name", "value": "Launch"}, ] MISSING = object() INDEX = re.compile(r"0|[1-9][0-9]*") VIEW_FORMATS = ("text", "json", "keyfile", "xml") NUMERAL = re.compile(r"[+-]?(?:[0-9]+(?:\.[0-9]*)?|\.[0-9]+)(?:[eE][+-]?[0-9]+)?") WHITESPACE_RUN = re.compile(r"[ \t\r\n]+") def _shown(value) -> str: text = json.dumps(value, ensure_ascii=False, separators=(",", ":")) return text if len(text) <= 200 else text[:200] + "…" def _same(actual, expected) -> bool: """JSON equality: numbers by value but never a boolean for a number, objects by their keys, arrays in order.""" if isinstance(expected, list): return (isinstance(actual, list) and len(actual) == len(expected) and all(_same(item, wanted) for item, wanted in zip(actual, expected))) if isinstance(expected, dict): return (isinstance(actual, dict) and len(actual) == len(expected) and all(key in actual and _same(actual[key], value) for key, value in expected.items())) if isinstance(expected, bool) or isinstance(actual, bool): return isinstance(expected, bool) and isinstance(actual, bool) and actual == expected if isinstance(expected, (int, float)): return isinstance(actual, (int, float)) and actual == expected return type(actual) is type(expected) and actual == expected def _bracketed(token: str) -> bool: return len(token) >= 2 and token.startswith("[") and token.endswith("]") def _selector(token: str): """A selector's conditions, [KEY=VALUE] or [@KEY=VALUE] one or more times, or None when the token is not one.""" if not _bracketed(token): return None conditions = [] for part in token[1:-1].split("]["): key, equals, value = part.partition("=") name = key[1:] if key.startswith("@") else key if not equals or not name: return None conditions.append((key.startswith("@"), name, value)) return conditions def _selects(member, conditions) -> bool: """Whether an array member meets every condition; selectors compare strings only.""" if not isinstance(member, dict): return False for attribute, key, value in conditions: fields = member.get("attributes") if attribute else member if not isinstance(fields, dict) or not isinstance(fields.get(key), str) or fields[key] != value: return False return True def _step(items: list, token: str, last: bool): """One step into an array, by index or by a selector that must match one member, or none when it is the last.""" if INDEX.fullmatch(token): return ("member", items[int(token)]) if int(token) < len(items) else ("none", None) conditions = _selector(token) if conditions is None: return ("unresolved", f"{token} is not a selector of the form [KEY=VALUE]") if _bracketed(token) else ( "none", None) matched = [item for item in items if _selects(item, conditions)] if len(matched) == 1: return "member", matched[0] if len(matched) > 1: return "unresolved", f"{token} matches {len(matched)} members, not one" return ("none" if last else "unresolved"), f"{token} matches no member" def _locate(view, pointer: str): """Where a pointer leads: ("value", value), ("none", why or None) or ("unresolved", problem), with the pointers to the arrays a selector searched on the way.""" current, searched = view, [] segments = pointer[1:].split("/") for position, segment in enumerate(segments): token = segment.replace("~1", "/").replace("~0", "~") if isinstance(current, list): if not INDEX.fullmatch(token) and _selector(token) is not None: searched.append("".join("/" + part for part in segments[:position])) kind, found = _step(current, token, position == len(segments) - 1) if kind != "member": return kind, found, searched current = found elif isinstance(current, dict) and token in current: current = current[token] else: return "none", None, searched return "value", current, searched def _number(value): """A number, or a numeral string read as one; None for anything else, a boolean, or a numeral past the doubles.""" if isinstance(value, bool): return None if isinstance(value, (int, float)): return value if not isinstance(value, str) or not NUMERAL.fullmatch(value): return None number = float(value) return number if math.isfinite(number) else None def _entry_leaves_out(entry) -> bool: return isinstance(entry, dict) and (isinstance(entry.get("view_error"), str) or ( entry.get("format") in ("text", "xml") and isinstance(entry.get("view"), dict) and entry["view"].get("truncated") is True)) def _viewless_entry(view, pointer: str): """The name of the entry whose view a pointer goes into when it has none, so its null is no JSON value, and why: binary, unread, or of a format without a view; None when it has one.""" parts = pointer[1:].split("/") if len(parts) < 3 or parts[0] != "entries" or parts[2] != "view": return None kind, item, _ = _locate(view, "/entries/" + parts[1]) if kind != "value" or not isinstance(item, dict): return None if isinstance(item.get("view_error"), str): reason = f"has no view: {item['view_error']}" elif item.get("format") == "binary": reason = "is binary and has no view" elif item.get("format") not in VIEW_FORMATS: reason = "has no view" else: return None return (item["name"] if isinstance(item.get("name"), str) else ""), reason def _array_leaves_out(form, view, array: str) -> bool: """Whether an array a selector searched may lack members: in a zip the listing or its entry's view, else the view's own truncation.""" if form != "zip": return _truncated(form, view) if array == "/entries": return isinstance(view, dict) and view.get("truncated") is True return _zip_leaves_out(view, array) def _zip_leaves_out(view, pointer: str) -> bool: """Whether a zip view leaves out what a pointer reaches: for a pointer into one listed entry, only that entry.""" if not isinstance(view, dict): return False parts = pointer[1:].split("/") if parts[0] == "entries" and len(parts) > 1: kind, entry, _ = _locate(view, "/entries/" + parts[1]) return _entry_leaves_out(entry) if kind == "value" else view.get("truncated") is True entries = view.get("entries") if isinstance(view.get("entries"), list) else [] return view.get("truncated") is True or any(_entry_leaves_out(entry) for entry in entries) def _truncated(form, view) -> bool: if not isinstance(view, dict): return False if form in ("text", "xml"): return view.get("truncated") is True if form != "sqlite": return False tables = view.get("tables") return view.get("tables_truncated") is True or any( isinstance(table, dict) and (table.get("truncated") is True or isinstance(table.get("error"), str)) for table in (tables.values() if isinstance(tables, dict) else [])) def _view_of(check, entry, form): """The view, whether it is truncated, and why the check cannot read it; an absent file reads as empty.""" if entry is None: return None, False, None if isinstance(entry.get("error"), str): return None, False, f"{check['file']} has no view: {entry['error']}" if entry.get("format") in (None, "binary"): return None, False, f"{check['file']} is binary and has no view" if form is not None and entry.get("format") != form: return None, False, f"{check['file']} is read as {entry.get('format')}, not {form}" return entry.get("view"), _truncated(entry.get("format"), entry.get("view")), None def _undecided(check): return False, f"the view of {check['file']} is truncated, so what it leaves out is unknown" def _compared(check, n: int, what: str): operator = next(key for key in ("equals", "at_least", "at_most") if check.get(key) is not None) expected = check[operator] met = n == expected if operator == "equals" else n >= expected if operator == "at_least" else n <= expected return met, f"{n} {what}, expected {operator.replace('_', ' ')} {expected}" def _lines(check, entry): view, truncated, problem = _view_of(check, entry, "text") if problem is not None: return False, problem lines = view.get("lines") if isinstance(view, dict) and isinstance(view.get("lines"), list) else [] lines = [line for line in lines if isinstance(line, str)] file = check["file"] if check["kind"] == "lines_present": missing = next((line for line in check["lines"] if line not in lines), None) return (True, f"{file} has the line(s) {_shown(check['lines'])}") if missing is None else ( False, f"{file} has no line {_shown(missing)}") if truncated: return _undecided(check) if check["kind"] == "lines_absent": found = next((line for line in check["lines"] if line in lines), None) return (True, f"{file} has none of the lines {_shown(check['lines'])}") if found is None else ( False, f"{file} still has the line {_shown(found)}") if check.get("contains") is not None: n = sum(1 for line in lines if check["contains"] in line) return _compared(check, n, f"line(s) of {file} contain {_shown(check['contains'])}") n = sum(1 for line in lines if line == check["exact"]) return _compared(check, n, f"line(s) of {file} match {_shown(check['exact'])}") def _near(at: str, found, expected, tolerance): """A value compared within a tolerance: numbers, and numeral strings, by their difference.""" number = _number(found) within = f"within {_shown(tolerance)} of {_shown(expected)}" if number is None: return False, f"{at} is {_shown(found)}, not a number" if abs(number - expected) <= tolerance: return True, f"{at} is {_shown(found)}, {within}" return False, f"{at} is {_shown(found)}, not {within}" def _value(check, entry): view, truncated, problem = _view_of(check, entry, None) if problem is not None: return False, problem kind, found, searched = ("none", None, []) if entry is None else _locate(view, check["pointer"]) at = f"{check['file']} at {check['pointer']}" viewless = _viewless_entry(view, check["pointer"]) if entry is not None and entry.get("format") == "zip" else None if viewless is not None: return False, f"{check['file']} entry {viewless[0]} {viewless[1]}" # A selector tells one member from several only in an array the view holds whole. if any(_array_leaves_out(entry.get("format"), view, array) for array in searched): return _undecided(check) if kind == "unresolved": return False, f"{at}: {found}" if entry is not None and entry.get("format") == "zip": truncated = _zip_leaves_out(view, check["pointer"]) if check["kind"] == "value_equals" and isinstance(check["value"], (dict, list)) and truncated: return _undecided(check) if check["kind"] == "value_equals": if kind == "none": return False, f"{at} has no value" if found is None else f"{at}: {found}" expected = check["value"] if check.get("tolerance") is not None and isinstance(expected, (int, float)) and not isinstance(expected, bool): return _near(at, found, expected, check["tolerance"]) if _same(found, check["value"]): return True, f"{at} is {_shown(check['value'])}" return False, f"{at} is {_shown(found)}, not {_shown(check['value'])}" if truncated: return _undecided(check) return (True, f"{at} has no value") if kind == "none" else (False, f"{at} is {_shown(found)}") def _is_element(value) -> bool: return (isinstance(value, dict) and isinstance(value.get("name"), str) and isinstance(value.get("attributes"), dict) and isinstance(value.get("children"), list)) def _element_text(element) -> str: """An element's text as XPath's string() reads it from what the view keeps: every text node among its children and its descendants', in document order.""" parts, pending = [], [element] while pending: node = pending.pop() if isinstance(node, str): parts.append(node) elif _is_element(node): pending.extend(reversed(node["children"])) return "".join(parts) def _collapse_whitespace(text: str) -> str: """Each run of XML whitespace (space, tab, CR, LF) made one space, none at either end, as normalize-space().""" return WHITESPACE_RUN.sub(" ", text).strip(" ") def _text_at(view, pointer: str) -> bool: """Whether a string a pointer reaches is text of the document: a member of an element's children (a text node) or attributes (an attribute's value), rather than an element's name or a field of the DOCTYPE.""" segments = pointer.split("/") if len(segments) < 3 or segments[-2] not in ("children", "attributes"): return False kind, owner, _ = _locate(view, "/".join(segments[:-2])) return kind == "value" and _is_element(owner) def _not_xml_entry(check, view): """Why a text check's pointer into an archive goes into no XML entry's view, or None when it does or names an entry not listed.""" parts = check["pointer"].split("/") if len(parts) < 4 or parts[3] != "view": return f"{check['file']} at {check['pointer']} does not point into an entry's view" if parts[1] != "entries": return None kind, item, _ = _locate(view, "/entries/" + parts[2]) if kind != "value" or not isinstance(item, dict) or item.get("format") == "xml": return None # An entry without a view failed before this, so its format is one with a view. name, form = (value if isinstance(value, str) else "" for value in (item.get("name"), item.get("format"))) return f"{check['file']} entry {name} is read as {form}, not xml" def _whole_text(check, entry): """An element's whole text, or a text node's, compared with the value or searched for it.""" view, truncated, problem = _view_of(check, entry, None) if problem is not None: return False, problem at = f"{check['file']} at {check['pointer']}" if entry is None: return False, f"{at} has no value" form = entry.get("format") if form not in ("xml", "zip"): return False, f"{check['file']} is read as {form}, not xml" kind, found, searched = _locate(view, check["pointer"]) viewless = _viewless_entry(view, check["pointer"]) if form == "zip" else None if viewless is not None: return False, f"{check['file']} entry {viewless[0]} {viewless[1]}" if any(_array_leaves_out(form, view, array) for array in searched): return _undecided(check) problem = _not_xml_entry(check, view) if form == "zip" else None if problem is not None: return False, problem if kind == "unresolved": return False, f"{at}: {found}" if kind == "none": return False, f"{at} has no value" if found is None else f"{at}: {found}" if not (_text_at(view, check["pointer"]) if isinstance(found, str) else _is_element(found)): return False, f"{at} is {_shown(found)}, not an element, a text node or an attribute value" # A text node is whole. An element's text in a cut view may lack what the cut dropped from its middle. if form == "zip": truncated = _zip_leaves_out(view, check["pointer"]) if not isinstance(found, str) and truncated: return _undecided(check) return _compared_text(check, at, _element_text(found)) def _compared_text(check, at: str, found: str): """A text found at a pointer compared with the check's value or searched for it, both collapsed when it asks.""" collapse = check.get("normalize_whitespace") is True text = _collapse_whitespace(found) if collapse else found value = _collapse_whitespace(check["value"]) if collapse else check["value"] how = " with whitespace collapsed" if collapse else "" if check["kind"] == "text_equals": if text == value: return True, f"{at} has the text {_shown(value)}{how}" return False, f"{at} has the text {_shown(text)}{how}, not {_shown(value)}" if value in text: return True, f"{at} has text containing {_shown(value)}{how}" return False, f"{at} has the text {_shown(text)}{how}, without {_shown(value)}" def _rows(check, entry): view, _, problem = _view_of(check, entry, "sqlite") if problem is not None: return False, problem view = view if isinstance(view, dict) else {} tables = view.get("tables") if isinstance(view.get("tables"), dict) else {} table = tables[check["table"]] if check["table"] in tables else MISSING name = f"{check['file']} table {check['table']}" if table is MISSING and view.get("tables_truncated") is True: return _undecided(check) table = table if isinstance(table, dict) else {} if isinstance(table.get("error"), str): return False, f"{name} could not be read: {table['error']}" columns = table.get("columns") if isinstance(table.get("columns"), list) else [] rows = table.get("rows") if isinstance(table.get("rows"), list) else [] where = check.get("where") or {} def matches(row) -> bool: return isinstance(row, list) and all( column in columns and columns.index(column) < len(row) and _same(row[columns.index(column)], value) for column, value in where.items()) n = sum(1 for row in rows if matches(row)) if check["kind"] == "row_present": return (n > 0, f"{name} has a row with {_shown(where)}" if n > 0 else f"{name} has no row with {_shown(where)}") if table.get("truncated") is True: return _undecided(check) if check["kind"] == "row_absent": return (True, f"{name} has no row with {_shown(where)}") if n == 0 else ( False, f"{name} has {n} row(s) with {_shown(where)}") return _compared(check, n, f"row(s) of {name}" + (f" with {_shown(where)}" if "where" in check else "")) def _verdict(check, entry): kind = check["kind"] if kind == "file_present": return (entry is not None, f"{check['file']} exists" if entry is not None else f"{check['file']} does not exist") if kind == "file_absent": return (entry is None, f"{check['file']} does not exist" if entry is None else f"{check['file']} exists") if kind in ("lines_present", "lines_absent", "line_count"): return _lines(check, entry) if kind in ("value_equals", "value_absent"): return _value(check, entry) if kind in ("text_equals", "text_contains"): return _whole_text(check, entry) return _rows(check, entry) def evaluate(checks: list, views: dict) -> list: """One result per check against the views data/get returned, by home path.""" results = [] for check in checks: passed, description = _verdict(check, views.get(check["file"])) results.append({"id": check["id"], "result": passed, "description": description}) return results async def verify(mcp_url, env_url): card = await protocol.get_card(env_url) child = protocol.find_child(card, APP) if child is None: raise RuntimeError(f"the computer at {env_url} lists no app named {APP}") answer = await protocol.get_data(env_url + (child.get("url") or RPC_PATH).removesuffix(RPC_PATH), timeout=120) states = [part.data["state"] for part in answer.parts if part.kind == "data" and isinstance(part.data.get("state"), dict)] if not states: raise RuntimeError(f"the {APP} app's data/get returned no state views") return evaluate(CHECKS, states[0])