// RUN: %verify --disable-nonlinear-arithmetic "%s" /******************************************************************************* * Original: Copyright (c) Microsoft Corporation * SPDX-License-Identifier: MIT * * Modifications and Extensions: Copyright by the contributors to the Dafny Project * SPDX-License-Identifier: MIT *******************************************************************************/ /* lemmas and functions in this file are used in the proofs in DivMod.dfy Specs/implements mathematical div and mod, not the C version. (x div n) * n + (x mod n) == x, where 0 <= x mod n < n. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Modulo_operation This may produce "surprising" results for negative values. For example, -3 div 5 is -1 and -3 mod 5 is 2. Note this is consistent: -3 * -1 + 2 == 5 */ include "GeneralInternals.dfy" include "MulInternals.dfy" include "../Mul.dfy" include "ModInternalsNonlinear.dfy" include "DivInternalsNonlinear.dfy" module {:options "-functionSyntax:4"} ModInternals { import opened GeneralInternals import opened Mul import opened MulInternalsNonlinear import opened MulInternals import opened ModInternalsNonlinear import opened DivInternalsNonlinear /* Performs modulus recursively. */ function {:opaque} ModRecursive(x: int, d: int): int requires d > 0 decreases if x < 0 then (d - x) else x { if x < 0 then ModRecursive(d + x, d) else if x < d then x else ModRecursive(x - d, d) } /* performs induction on modulus */ lemma LemmaModInductionForall(n: int, f: int -> bool) requires n > 0 requires forall i :: 0 <= i < n ==> f(i) requires forall i {:trigger f(i), f(i + n)} :: i >= 0 && f(i) ==> f(i + n) requires forall i {:trigger f(i), f(i - n)} :: i < n && f(i) ==> f(i - n) ensures forall i :: f(i) { forall i ensures f(i) { LemmaInductionHelper(n, f, i); } } /* given an integer x and divisor n, the remainder of x%n is equivalent to the remainder of (x+m)%n where m is a multiple of n */ lemma LemmaModInductionForall2(n: int, f:(int, int)->bool) requires n > 0 requires forall i, j :: 0 <= i < n && 0 <= j < n ==> f(i, j) requires forall i, j {:trigger f(i, j), f(i + n, j)} :: i >= 0 && f(i, j) ==> f(i + n, j) requires forall i, j {:trigger f(i, j), f(i, j + n)} :: j >= 0 && f(i, j) ==> f(i, j + n) requires forall i, j {:trigger f(i, j), f(i - n, j)} :: i < n && f(i, j) ==> f(i - n, j) requires forall i, j {:trigger f(i, j), f(i, j - n)} :: j < n && f(i, j) ==> f(i, j - n) ensures forall i, j :: f(i, j) { forall x, y ensures f(x, y) { forall i | 0 <= i < n ensures f(i, y) { var fj := j => f(i, j); LemmaModInductionForall(n, fj); assert fj(y); } var fi := i => f(i, y); LemmaModInductionForall(n, fi); assert fi(x); } } lemma LemmaDivAddDenominator(n: int, x: int) requires n > 0 ensures (x + n) / n == x / n + 1 { LemmaFundamentalDivMod(x, n); LemmaFundamentalDivMod(x + n, n); var zp := (x + n) / n - x / n - 1; forall ensures 0 == n * zp + ((x + n) % n) - (x % n) { LemmaMulAuto(); } if (zp > 0) { LemmaMulInequality(1, zp, n); } if (zp < 0) { LemmaMulInequality(zp, -1, n); } } lemma LemmaDivSubDenominator(n: int, x: int) requires n > 0 ensures (x - n) / n == x / n - 1 { LemmaFundamentalDivMod(x, n); LemmaFundamentalDivMod(x - n, n); var zm := (x - n) / n - x / n + 1; forall ensures 0 == n * zm + ((x - n) % n) - (x % n) { LemmaMulAuto(); } if (zm > 0) { LemmaMulInequality(1, zm, n); } if (zm < 0) { LemmaMulInequality(zm, -1, n); } } lemma LemmaModAddDenominator(n: int, x: int) requires n > 0 ensures (x + n) % n == x % n { LemmaFundamentalDivMod(x, n); LemmaFundamentalDivMod(x + n, n); var zp := (x + n) / n - x / n - 1; forall ensures 0 == n * zp + ((x + n) % n) - (x % n) { LemmaMulAuto(); } if (zp > 0) { LemmaMulInequality(1, zp, n); } if (zp < 0) { LemmaMulInequality(zp, -1, n); } } lemma LemmaModSubDenominator(n: int, x: int) requires n > 0 ensures (x - n) % n == x % n { LemmaFundamentalDivMod(x, n); LemmaFundamentalDivMod(x - n, n); var zm := (x - n) / n - x / n + 1; forall ensures 0 == n * zm + ((x - n) % n) - (x % n) { LemmaMulAuto(); } if (zm > 0) { LemmaMulInequality(1, zm, n); } if (zm < 0) { LemmaMulInequality(zm, -1, n); } } lemma LemmaModBelowDenominator(n: int, x: int) requires n > 0 ensures 0 <= x < n <==> x % n == x { forall x: int ensures 0 <= x < n <==> x % n == x { if (0 <= x < n) { LemmaSmallMod(x, n); } LemmaModRange(x, n); } } /* proves the basics of the modulus operation */ lemma LemmaModBasics(n: int) requires n > 0 ensures forall x: int {:trigger (x + n) % n} :: (x + n) % n == x % n ensures forall x: int {:trigger (x - n) % n} :: (x - n) % n == x % n ensures forall x: int {:trigger (x + n) / n} :: (x + n) / n == x / n + 1 ensures forall x: int {:trigger (x - n) / n} :: (x - n) / n == x / n - 1 ensures forall x: int {:trigger x % n} :: 0 <= x < n <==> x % n == x { forall x: int ensures (x + n) % n == x % n ensures (x - n) % n == x % n ensures (x + n) / n == x / n + 1 ensures (x - n) / n == x / n - 1 ensures 0 <= x < n <==> x % n == x { LemmaModBelowDenominator(n, x); LemmaModAddDenominator(n, x); LemmaModSubDenominator(n, x); LemmaDivAddDenominator(n, x); LemmaDivSubDenominator(n, x); } } /* proves the quotient remainder theorem */ lemma {:vcs_split_on_every_assert} LemmaQuotientAndRemainder(x: int, q: int, r: int, n: int) requires n > 0 requires 0 <= r < n requires x == q * n + r ensures q == x / n ensures r == x % n decreases if q > 0 then q else -q { LemmaModBasics(n); if q > 0 { MulInternalsNonlinear.LemmaMulIsDistributiveAdd(n, q - 1, 1); LemmaMulIsCommutativeAuto(); assert q * n + r == (q - 1) * n + n + r; LemmaQuotientAndRemainder(x - n, q - 1, r, n); } else if q < 0 { Mul.LemmaMulIsDistributiveSub(n, q + 1, 1); LemmaMulIsCommutativeAuto(); assert q * n + r == (q + 1) * n - n + r; LemmaQuotientAndRemainder(x + n, q + 1, r, n); } else { LemmaSmallDiv(); assert r / n == 0; } } /* automates the modulus operator process */ ghost predicate ModAuto(n: int) requires n > 0 { && (n % n == (-n) % n == 0) && (forall x: int {:trigger (x % n) % n} :: (x % n) % n == x % n) && (forall x: int {:trigger x % n} :: 0 <= x < n <==> x % n == x) && (forall x: int, y: int {:trigger (x + y) % n} :: (var z := (x % n) + (y % n); ( (0 <= z < n && (x + y) % n == z) || (n <= z < n + n && (x + y) % n == z - n)))) && (forall x: int, y: int {:trigger (x - y) % n} :: (var z := (x % n) - (y % n); ( (0 <= z < n && (x - y) % n == z) || (-n <= z < 0 && (x - y) % n == z + n)))) } /* ensures that ModAuto is true */ lemma LemmaModAuto(n: int) requires n > 0 ensures ModAuto(n) { LemmaModBasics(n); LemmaMulIsCommutativeAuto(); LemmaMulIsDistributiveAddAuto(); LemmaMulIsDistributiveSubAuto(); forall x: int, y: int {:trigger (x + y) % n} ensures var z := (x % n) + (y % n); || (0 <= z < n && (x + y) % n == z) || (n <= z < 2 * n && (x + y) % n == z - n) { var xq, xr := x / n, x % n; LemmaFundamentalDivMod(x, n); assert x == xq * n + xr; var yq, yr := y / n, y % n; LemmaFundamentalDivMod(y, n); assert y == yq * n + yr; if xr + yr < n { LemmaQuotientAndRemainder(x + y, xq + yq, xr + yr, n); } else { LemmaQuotientAndRemainder(x + y, xq + yq + 1, xr + yr - n, n); } } forall x: int, y: int {:trigger (x - y) % n} ensures var z := (x % n) - (y % n); || (0 <= z < n && (x - y) % n == z) || (-n <= z < 0 && (x - y) % n == z + n) { var xq, xr := x / n, x % n; LemmaFundamentalDivMod(x, n); assert x == xq * n + xr; var yq, yr := y / n, y % n; LemmaFundamentalDivMod(y, n); assert y == yq * n + yr; if xr - yr >= 0 { LemmaQuotientAndRemainder(x - y, xq - yq, xr - yr, n); } else { LemmaQuotientAndRemainder(x - y, xq - yq - 1, xr - yr + n, n); } } } /* performs auto induction for modulus */ lemma LemmaModInductionAuto(n: int, x: int, f: int -> bool) requires n > 0 requires ModAuto(n) ==> && (forall i {:trigger IsLe(0, i)} :: IsLe(0, i) && i < n ==> f(i)) && (forall i {:trigger IsLe(0, i)} :: IsLe(0, i) && f(i) ==> f(i + n)) && (forall i {:trigger IsLe(i + 1, n)} :: IsLe(i + 1, n) && f(i) ==> f(i - n)) ensures ModAuto(n) ensures f(x) { LemmaModAuto(n); assert forall i :: IsLe(0, i) && i < n ==> f(i); assert forall i {:trigger f(i), f(i + n)} :: IsLe(0, i) && f(i) ==> f(i + n); assert forall i {:trigger f(i), f(i - n)} :: IsLe(i + 1, n) && f(i) ==> f(i - n); LemmaModInductionForall(n, f); assert f(x); } // not used in other files /* performs auto induction on modulus for all i s.t. f(i) exists */ lemma LemmaModInductionAutoForall(n: int, f: int -> bool) requires n > 0 requires ModAuto(n) ==> && (forall i {:trigger IsLe(0, i)} :: IsLe(0, i) && i < n ==> f(i)) && (forall i {:trigger IsLe(0, i)} :: IsLe(0, i) && f(i) ==> f(i + n)) && (forall i {:trigger IsLe(i + 1, n)} :: IsLe(i + 1, n) && f(i) ==> f(i - n)) ensures ModAuto(n) ensures forall i {:trigger f(i)} :: f(i) { LemmaModAuto(n); assert forall i :: IsLe(0, i) && i < n ==> f(i); assert forall i {:trigger f(i), f(i + n)} :: IsLe(0, i) && f(i) ==> f(i + n); assert forall i {:trigger f(i), f(i - n)} :: IsLe(i + 1, n) && f(i) ==> f(i - n); LemmaModInductionForall(n, f); } }