municipalbench-full / code /scripts /frontend /verify_dataset_agreement.py
Yuquanlee's picture
Update dataset documentation and provenance
268c55e verified
Raw History Blame Contribute Delete
7.5 kB
"""Independent annotation-export checks; does not call its metric functions.
Uses explicit coincidence matrices for alpha and a separate augmenting-path
cardinality matcher for the headline instance counts.
"""
from __future__ import annotations
import argparse
import json
import math
from collections import Counter
from itertools import combinations
from pathlib import Path
import numpy as np
def reference_alpha(values, levels, squared, *, ordinal=False):
coincidence = np.zeros((len(levels), len(levels)))
pairable = [v for v in values if len(v) >= 2]
if len(pairable) < 2: return None
for ratings in pairable:
counts=Counter(ratings)
for i,a in enumerate(levels):
for j,b in enumerate(levels):
coincidence[i,j] += counts[a]*(counts[b]-(a==b))/(len(ratings)-1)
marginals=coincidence.sum(axis=1); n=marginals.sum()
expected=np.outer(marginals,marginals)-np.diag(marginals)
distance=np.array([[(a-b)**2 if squared else float(a!=b) for b in levels] for a in levels], dtype=float)
if ordinal:
for i in range(len(levels)):
for j in range(len(levels)):
lo,hi=sorted((i,j))
distance[i,j]=(sum(marginals[lo:hi+1])-(marginals[lo]+marginals[hi])/2)**2
do=(coincidence*distance).sum()/n
de=(expected*distance).sum()/(n*(n-1))
return None if de<=0 else float(1-do/de)
def overlap(a,b):
ix=max(0,min(a[0]+a[2],b[0]+b[2])-max(a[0],b[0]))
iy=max(0,min(a[1]+a[3],b[1]+b[3])-max(a[1],b[1]))
intersection=ix*iy
return intersection/(a[2]*a[3]+b[2]*b[3]-intersection)
def maximum_pairs(a,b):
edges=[[j for j,y in enumerate(b) if x['use_case_id']==y['use_case_id'] and overlap(x['bbox'],y['bbox'])>=.5] for x in a]
owners={}
def visit(i,seen):
for j in edges[i]:
if j in seen: continue
seen.add(j)
if j not in owners or visit(owners[j],seen):
owners[j]=i
return True
return False
for i in range(len(a)): visit(i,set())
return [(i,j) for j,i in owners.items()]
def equal(actual,expected):
assert (actual is None and expected is None) or (actual is not None and expected is not None and math.isclose(actual,expected,abs_tol=1e-11)),(actual,expected)
def verify(artifact_path, gold_path, iaa_path, manifest_path):
artifact=json.loads(artifact_path.read_text()); gold=json.loads(gold_path.read_text()); raw=json.loads(iaa_path.read_text())
gold_ids={r['image_id']:{v['use_case_id'] for v in r['gold']['violations']} for r in gold}
categories={r['image_id']:r['category'] for r in map(json.loads,manifest_path.read_text().splitlines())}
prepared={}
for r in raw:
labels=r['first_pass']
ratings={k:[a[k] for a in labels if not a.get('reported') and type(a.get(k)) is int and 1<=a[k]<=5] for k in ('plausibility','naturalness')}
usable=[a for a in labels if not a.get('reported') and bool(a['no_violation_detected']) != bool(a['violations'])]
sets=[{v['use_case_id'] for v in a['violations']} for a in usable]
pairs=list(combinations(usable,2))
matches=Counter(); endpoints=Counter(); raw_matches=raw_endpoints=0
for a,b in pairs:
m=maximum_pairs(a['violations'],b['violations'])
for v in a['violations']+b['violations']: endpoints[v['use_case_id']]+=1/len(pairs)
for i,j in m: matches[a['violations'][i]['use_case_id']]+=1/len(pairs)
raw_matches+=len(m);raw_endpoints+=len(a['violations'])+len(b['violations'])
prepared[r['image_id']]={'ratings':ratings,'sets':sets,'matches':matches,'endpoints':endpoints,
'raw_matches':raw_matches,'raw_endpoints':raw_endpoints}
checks=0
for group in artifact['groups'].values():
selected=[(i,p) for i,p in prepared.items() if (group['population']=='all' or i in gold_ids) and (group['source']=='all' or categories[i]==group['source'])]
for row in group['rows']:
ids=set(c for cs in artifact['domains'].values() for c in cs) if row['kind']=='overall' else set(artifact['domains'].get(row['id'],[row['id']]))
qrows=[p for i,p in selected if row['kind']=='overall' or gold_ids.get(i,set())&ids]
for k in ('plausibility','naturalness'):
values=[p['ratings'][k] for p in qrows if len(p['ratings'][k])>=2]
q=row['quality'][k]
assert q['eligible']==len(values)
equal(q['alpha']['value'],reference_alpha(values,list(range(1,6)),True,ordinal=True))
equal(q['interval_alpha']['value'],reference_alpha(values,list(range(1,6)),True))
equal(q['exact']['value'],sum(len(set(v))==1 for v in values)/len(values) if values else None)
equal(q['within_one']['value'],sum(max(v)-min(v)<=1 for v in values)/len(values) if values else None)
checks+=5
label_rows=[[s&ids for s in p['sets']] for _,p in selected if len(p['sets'])>=2]
a=dis=0
for sets in label_rows:
comparisons=list(combinations(sets,2))
for x,y in comparisons:
a+=len(x&y)/len(comparisons);dis+=len(x^y)/len(comparisons)
agreement=row['agreement']
equal(agreement['exact']['value'],sum(len({tuple(sorted(s)) for s in sets})==1 for sets in label_rows)/len(label_rows) if label_rows else None)
equal(agreement['positive_agreement']['value'],2*a/(2*a+dis) if a or dis else None)
if row['kind']=='class':
equal(agreement['alpha']['value'],reference_alpha([[int(bool(s)) for s in sets] for sets in label_rows],[0,1],False))
checks+=1
matches=sum(sum(p['matches'][c] for c in ids) for _,p in selected)
endpoints=sum(sum(p['endpoints'][c] for c in ids) for _,p in selected)
equal(agreement['instance_f1']['value'],2*matches/endpoints if endpoints else None)
equal(agreement['support']['match_5'],matches)
equal(agreement['support']['box_endpoints'],endpoints)
assert agreement['support']['label_n']==len(label_rows)
checks+=6
print(f"Verified {group['population']} / {group['source']}",flush=True)
result={'status':'passed','checks':checks,'images':len(raw),'groups':len(artifact['groups']),
'source_hashes':{k:v['sha256'] for k,v in artifact['sources'].items()},
'methods':['Independent explicit coincidence matrices for ordinal/interval/nominal alpha',
'Raw first-pass exact/within-one and class-set aggregation',
'Independent augmenting-path instance cardinality at IoU 0.50'],
'limits':['Point estimates verified; bootstrap distribution and optimal-IoU tie cases are tested separately.']}
print(json.dumps(result,indent=2))
return result
if __name__=='__main__':
parser=argparse.ArgumentParser(description=__doc__)
parser.add_argument('--artifact',type=Path,required=True)
parser.add_argument('--gold',type=Path,required=True)
parser.add_argument('--iaa',type=Path,required=True)
parser.add_argument('--manifest',type=Path,required=True)
parser.add_argument('--output',type=Path)
a=parser.parse_args()
result=verify(a.artifact,a.gold,a.iaa,a.manifest)
if a.output: a.output.write_text(json.dumps(result,indent=2)+'\n')