data_source string | prompt list | ability string | reward_model dict | pmid string | study_name string | gt_domains dict | domain_info dict | available_domain_count int64 | missing_domains list | is_e2e bool |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
rob_sr | [
{
"content": "\n**Role:** You are a meta-analysis expert. Your task is to perform a Risk of Bias assessment for a study based on the provided full-text and the Cochrane Risk of Bias 1.0 (RoB 1) tool criteria.\n\n**Inputs:**\n\n1. **Full text**: n engl j med 360;13 nejm.org march 26, 2009\n1283\n\n## Intensive... | rob_assessment | {
"ground_truth": {
"domain_info": {
"1": {
"label": "low",
"source_keys": [
"Domain1：Random sequence generation (selection bias)"
],
"thinking_labels": [
"Quote: “Patients were randomly assigned to a treatment group by the clinicians treating them or by l... | 19318384 | NICE SUGAR 2009 | {
"1": "low",
"2": "low",
"3": "high",
"4": "high",
"5": "low"
} | {
"1": {
"label": "low",
"source_keys": [
"Domain1：Random sequence generation (selection bias)"
],
"thinking_labels": [
"Quote: “Patients were randomly assigned to a treatment group by the clinicians treating them or by local study coordinators, with the use of a minimization algorithm” Qu... | 5 | [] | false |
rob_sr | [
{
"content": "\n**Role:** You are a meta-analysis expert. Your task is to perform a Risk of Bias assessment for a study based on the provided full-text and the Cochrane Risk of Bias 1.0 (RoB 1) tool criteria.\n\n**Inputs:**\n\n1. **Full text**: Br.J. Anaesth. (1976), 48, 571\n\n**Risk of Bias Domains (Cochrane ... | rob_assessment | {
"ground_truth": {
"domain_info": {
"1": {
"label": "unclear",
"source_keys": [
"Domain1：Random sequence generation (selection bias)"
],
"thinking_labels": [
"Sequence generation was not reported."
]
},
"2": {
"label": "unclear... | 952692 | Moodie 1976 | {
"1": "unclear",
"2": "unclear",
"3": "unclear",
"4": "unclear",
"5": "high"
} | {
"1": {
"label": "unclear",
"source_keys": [
"Domain1：Random sequence generation (selection bias)"
],
"thinking_labels": [
"Sequence generation was not reported."
]
},
"2": {
"label": "unclear",
"source_keys": [
"Domain2：Allocation concealment (selection bias)"
]... | 5 | [] | false |
rob_sr | [
{
"content": "\n**Role:** You are a meta-analysis expert. Your task is to perform a Risk of Bias assessment for a study based on the provided full-text and the Cochrane Risk of Bias 1.0 (RoB 1) tool criteria.\n\n**Inputs:**\n\n1. **Full text**: # Robot-assisted Vs Laparoscopic Sacrocolpopexy for High-stage Pelv... | rob_assessment | {
"ground_truth": {
"domain_info": {
"1": {
"label": "low",
"source_keys": [
"Domain1：Random sequence generation (selection bias)"
],
"thinking_labels": [
"Computer generated block randomisation"
]
},
"2": {
"label": "unclear",
... | 31563536 | Illiano 2019 | {
"1": "low",
"2": "unclear",
"3": "unclear",
"4": "high",
"5": "low"
} | {
"1": {
"label": "low",
"source_keys": [
"Domain1：Random sequence generation (selection bias)"
],
"thinking_labels": [
"Computer generated block randomisation"
]
},
"2": {
"label": "unclear",
"source_keys": [
"Domain2：Allocation concealment (selection bias)"
],
... | 5 | [] | false |
rob_sr | [
{
"content": "\n**Role:** You are a meta-analysis expert. Your task is to perform a Risk of Bias assessment for a study based on the provided full-text and the Cochrane Risk of Bias 1.0 (RoB 1) tool criteria.\n\n**Inputs:**\n\n1. **Full text**: ### RESULTS\n\nA total of 63 consecutive patients diagnosed with ph... | rob_assessment | {
"ground_truth": {
"domain_info": {
"1": {
"label": "unclear",
"source_keys": [
"Domain1：Random sequence generation (selection bias)"
],
"thinking_labels": [
"Quote from publication: \"The 59 remaining patients were randomly assigned to 0.1% triamcinolone... | 19692044 | Letendre 2009 | {
"1": "unclear",
"2": "unclear",
"3": "unclear",
"4": "low",
"5": "high"
} | {
"1": {
"label": "unclear",
"source_keys": [
"Domain1：Random sequence generation (selection bias)"
],
"thinking_labels": [
"Quote from publication: \"The 59 remaining patients were randomly assigned to 0.1% triamcinolone (group 2 of 29) or emollient cream (group 1 of 31)...\"; \"patients ... | 5 | [] | false |
rob_sr | [
{
"content": "\n**Role:** You are a meta-analysis expert. Your task is to perform a Risk of Bias assessment for a study based on the provided full-text and the Cochrane Risk of Bias 1.0 (RoB 1) tool criteria.\n\n**Inputs:**\n\n1. **Full text**: ## Methods\nThe study was approved by the Ethics Committee of the U... | rob_assessment | {
"ground_truth": {
"domain_info": {
"1": {
"label": "low",
"source_keys": [
"Domain1：Random sequence generation (selection bias)"
],
"thinking_labels": [
"Computer random number generator"
]
},
"2": {
"label": "low",
"s... | 16595616 | Tritapepe 2006 | {
"1": "low",
"2": "low",
"3": "low",
"4": "low",
"5": "low"
} | {
"1": {
"label": "low",
"source_keys": [
"Domain1：Random sequence generation (selection bias)"
],
"thinking_labels": [
"Computer random number generator"
]
},
"2": {
"label": "low",
"source_keys": [
"Domain2：Allocation concealment (selection bias)"
],
"thinki... | 5 | [] | false |
rob_sr | [
{
"content": "\n**Role:** You are a meta-analysis expert. Your task is to perform a Risk of Bias assessment for a study based on the provided full-text and the Cochrane Risk of Bias 1.0 (RoB 1) tool criteria.\n\n**Inputs:**\n\n1. **Full text**: CYNÄ KOLOCIE\n\n### MIttel signifikant niedriger ars in Gruppe B (p... | rob_assessment | {
"ground_truth": {
"domain_info": {
"1": {
"label": "unclear",
"source_keys": [
"Domain1：Random sequence generation (selection bias)"
],
"thinking_labels": [
"Not reported"
]
},
"2": {
"label": "unclear",
"source_keys":... | 8991841 | Kunz 1996 | {
"1": "unclear",
"2": "unclear",
"3": null,
"4": "high",
"5": "low"
} | {
"1": {
"label": "unclear",
"source_keys": [
"Domain1：Random sequence generation (selection bias)"
],
"thinking_labels": [
"Not reported"
]
},
"2": {
"label": "unclear",
"source_keys": [
"Domain2：Allocation concealment (selection bias)"
],
"thinking_labels": ... | 4 | [
3
] | false |
rob_sr | [
{
"content": "\n**Role:** You are a meta-analysis expert. Your task is to perform a Risk of Bias assessment for a study based on the provided full-text and the Cochrane Risk of Bias 1.0 (RoB 1) tool criteria.\n\n**Inputs:**\n\n1. **Full text**: RESEARCH ARTICLE\nOpen Access\n\n## Infant flow biphasic nasal cont... | rob_assessment | {
"ground_truth": {
"domain_info": {
"1": {
"label": "low",
"source_keys": [
"Domain1：Random sequence generation (selection bias)"
],
"thinking_labels": [
"Computer‐generated random list"
]
},
"2": {
"label": "low",
"sou... | 22475409 | O'Brien 2012 | {
"1": "low",
"2": "low",
"3": "high",
"4": "high",
"5": "low"
} | {
"1": {
"label": "low",
"source_keys": [
"Domain1：Random sequence generation (selection bias)"
],
"thinking_labels": [
"Computer‐generated random list"
]
},
"2": {
"label": "low",
"source_keys": [
"Domain2：Allocation concealment (selection bias)"
],
"thinking... | 5 | [] | false |
rob_sr | [
{
"content": "\n**Role:** You are a meta-analysis expert. Your task is to perform a Risk of Bias assessment for a study based on the provided full-text and the Cochrane Risk of Bias 1.0 (RoB 1) tool criteria.\n\n**Inputs:**\n\n1. **Full text**: # A randomized prospective study of single-port and four-port appro... | rob_assessment | {
"ground_truth": {
"domain_info": {
"1": {
"label": "low",
"source_keys": [
"Domain1：Random sequence generation (selection bias)"
],
"thinking_labels": [
"Randomisation: based on computer‐generated random sampling numbers"
]
},
"2": {
... | 21298522 | Jung 2011 | {
"1": "low",
"2": "unclear",
"3": null,
"4": "high",
"5": "unclear"
} | {
"1": {
"label": "low",
"source_keys": [
"Domain1：Random sequence generation (selection bias)"
],
"thinking_labels": [
"Randomisation: based on computer‐generated random sampling numbers"
]
},
"2": {
"label": "unclear",
"source_keys": [
"Domain2：Allocation concealmen... | 4 | [
3
] | false |
rob_sr | [
{
"content": "\n**Role:** You are a meta-analysis expert. Your task is to perform a Risk of Bias assessment for a study based on the provided full-text and the Cochrane Risk of Bias 1.0 (RoB 1) tool criteria.\n\n**Inputs:**\n\n1. **Full text**: # Prospective randomized trial of preoperative enteral immunonutrit... | rob_assessment | {
"ground_truth": {
"domain_info": {
"1": {
"label": "unclear",
"source_keys": [
"Domain1：Random sequence generation (selection bias)"
],
"thinking_labels": [
"Used minimisation method with an algorithm that stratified for institutions."
]
},... | 22367794 | Fujitani 2012 | {
"1": "unclear",
"2": "low",
"3": null,
"4": "high",
"5": "low"
} | {
"1": {
"label": "unclear",
"source_keys": [
"Domain1：Random sequence generation (selection bias)"
],
"thinking_labels": [
"Used minimisation method with an algorithm that stratified for institutions."
]
},
"2": {
"label": "low",
"source_keys": [
"Domain2：Allocation ... | 4 | [
3
] | false |
rob_sr | [
{
"content": "\n**Role:** You are a meta-analysis expert. Your task is to perform a Risk of Bias assessment for a study based on the provided full-text and the Cochrane Risk of Bias 1.0 (RoB 1) tool criteria.\n\n**Inputs:**\n\n1. **Full text**: ## Abstract:\n\nAtrial fibrillation (AF) is a common clinically sig... | rob_assessment | {
"ground_truth": {
"domain_info": {
"1": {
"label": "unclear",
"source_keys": [
"Domain1：Random sequence generation (selection bias)"
],
"thinking_labels": [
"An interactive voice response system (central) would allocate treatment on contact by the pharma... | 27828791 | Beatch 2017 | {
"1": "unclear",
"2": "low",
"3": "low",
"4": "low",
"5": "low"
} | {
"1": {
"label": "unclear",
"source_keys": [
"Domain1：Random sequence generation (selection bias)"
],
"thinking_labels": [
"An interactive voice response system (central) would allocate treatment on contact by the pharmacist. No information on how the sequence was created"
]
},
"2... | 5 | [] | false |
rob_sr | [
{
"content": "\n**Role:** You are a meta-analysis expert. Your task is to perform a Risk of Bias assessment for a study based on the provided full-text and the Cochrane Risk of Bias 1.0 (RoB 1) tool criteria.\n\n**Inputs:**\n\n1. **Full text**: # Comparison of vaginal mesh repair with sacrospinous vaginal colpo... | rob_assessment | {
"ground_truth": {
"domain_info": {
"1": {
"label": "unclear",
"source_keys": [
"Domain1：Random sequence generation (selection bias)"
],
"thinking_labels": [
"Computer randomisation based on hospital number?"
]
},
"2": {
"label... | 24615948 | Svabik 2014 | {
"1": "unclear",
"2": "unclear",
"3": "high",
"4": "high",
"5": "low"
} | {
"1": {
"label": "unclear",
"source_keys": [
"Domain1：Random sequence generation (selection bias)"
],
"thinking_labels": [
"Computer randomisation based on hospital number?"
]
},
"2": {
"label": "unclear",
"source_keys": [
"Domain2：Allocation concealment (selection b... | 5 | [] | false |
rob_sr | [
{
"content": "\n**Role:** You are a meta-analysis expert. Your task is to perform a Risk of Bias assessment for a study based on the provided full-text and the Cochrane Risk of Bias 1.0 (RoB 1) tool criteria.\n\n**Inputs:**\n\n1. **Full text**: # Effects of Vedolizumab Induction Therapy for Patients With Crohn’... | rob_assessment | {
"ground_truth": {
"domain_info": {
"1": {
"label": "low",
"source_keys": [
"Domain1：Random sequence generation (selection bias)"
],
"thinking_labels": [
"Quote: \"randomization was computer‐generated centrally.\""
]
},
"2": {
... | 24859203 | Sands 2014 | {
"1": "low",
"2": "low",
"3": "low",
"4": "low",
"5": "low"
} | {
"1": {
"label": "low",
"source_keys": [
"Domain1：Random sequence generation (selection bias)"
],
"thinking_labels": [
"Quote: \"randomization was computer‐generated centrally.\""
]
},
"2": {
"label": "low",
"source_keys": [
"Domain2：Allocation concealment (selection... | 5 | [] | false |
rob_sr | [
{
"content": "\n**Role:** You are a meta-analysis expert. Your task is to perform a Risk of Bias assessment for a study based on the provided full-text and the Cochrane Risk of Bias 1.0 (RoB 1) tool criteria.\n\n**Inputs:**\n\n1. **Full text**: Journal of Antimicrobial Chemotherapy (1982) 10, Suppl. B, 125-135\... | rob_assessment | {
"ground_truth": {
"domain_info": {
"1": {
"label": "unclear",
"source_keys": [
"Domain1：Random sequence generation (selection bias)"
],
"thinking_labels": [
"Study 1: Reported as \"randomised\", but no description of randomisation sequence Study 2: Repor... | 6754685 | Henness 1982 | {
"1": "unclear",
"2": "unclear",
"3": null,
"4": "unclear",
"5": "high"
} | {
"1": {
"label": "unclear",
"source_keys": [
"Domain1：Random sequence generation (selection bias)"
],
"thinking_labels": [
"Study 1: Reported as \"randomised\", but no description of randomisation sequence Study 2: Reported as \"randomised\", but no description of randomisation sequence"
... | 4 | [
3
] | false |
rob_sr | [
{
"content": "\n**Role:** You are a meta-analysis expert. Your task is to perform a Risk of Bias assessment for a study based on the provided full-text and the Cochrane Risk of Bias 1.0 (RoB 1) tool criteria.\n\n**Inputs:**\n\n1. **Full text**: ## Patients Undergoing D2 Gastrectomy for Gastric Cancer:\n\n## A R... | rob_assessment | {
"ground_truth": {
"domain_info": {
"1": {
"label": "low",
"source_keys": [
"Domain1：Random sequence generation (selection bias)"
],
"thinking_labels": [
"Quote: “A simple randomization method (300 random numbers were generated through a random number tab... | 20878324 | Cao 2010 | {
"1": "low",
"2": "unclear",
"3": "high",
"4": "low",
"5": "low"
} | {
"1": {
"label": "low",
"source_keys": [
"Domain1：Random sequence generation (selection bias)"
],
"thinking_labels": [
"Quote: “A simple randomization method (300 random numbers were generated through a random number table) […] was used for allocating the patients to different groups […].... | 5 | [] | false |
rob_sr | [
{
"content": "\n**Role:** You are a meta-analysis expert. Your task is to perform a Risk of Bias assessment for a study based on the provided full-text and the Cochrane Risk of Bias 1.0 (RoB 1) tool criteria.\n\n**Inputs:**\n\n1. **Full text**: ## Abstract\n\n### Methods\n\nAll 151 primary healthcare units in t... | rob_assessment | {
"ground_truth": {
"domain_info": {
"1": {
"label": "unclear",
"source_keys": [
"Domain1：Random sequence generation (selection bias)"
],
"thinking_labels": [
"How the randomisation sequence was generated is not described. Study stated that the primary hea... | 21899766 | Johansson 2011 | {
"1": "unclear",
"2": "low",
"3": "high",
"4": "low",
"5": "low"
} | {
"1": {
"label": "unclear",
"source_keys": [
"Domain1：Random sequence generation (selection bias)"
],
"thinking_labels": [
"How the randomisation sequence was generated is not described. Study stated that the primary healthcare units were randomised 1:1 to intervention and control groups.... | 5 | [] | false |
rob_sr | [
{
"content": "\n**Role:** You are a meta-analysis expert. Your task is to perform a Risk of Bias assessment for a study based on the provided full-text and the Cochrane Risk of Bias 1.0 (RoB 1) tool criteria.\n\n**Inputs:**\n\n1. **Full text**: ## outcomes in well-nourished and malnourished gastrointestinal\n\n... | rob_assessment | {
"ground_truth": {
"domain_info": {
"1": {
"label": "low",
"source_keys": [
"Domain1：Random sequence generation (selection bias)"
],
"thinking_labels": [
"Randomisation undertaken by researcher."
]
},
"2": {
"label": "low",
... | 23801093 | Barker 2013 | {
"1": "low",
"2": "low",
"3": null,
"4": "unclear",
"5": "low"
} | {
"1": {
"label": "low",
"source_keys": [
"Domain1：Random sequence generation (selection bias)"
],
"thinking_labels": [
"Randomisation undertaken by researcher."
]
},
"2": {
"label": "low",
"source_keys": [
"Domain2：Allocation concealment (selection bias)"
],
... | 4 | [
3
] | false |
rob_sr | [
{
"content": "\n**Role:** You are a meta-analysis expert. Your task is to perform a Risk of Bias assessment for a study based on the provided full-text and the Cochrane Risk of Bias 1.0 (RoB 1) tool criteria.\n\n**Inputs:**\n\n1. **Full text**: ## A Randomized Trial\n\nJoel A. Simon, MD, MPH, Timothy P. Carmody... | rob_assessment | {
"ground_truth": {
"domain_info": {
"1": {
"label": "low",
"source_keys": [
"Domain1：Random sequence generation (selection bias)"
],
"thinking_labels": [
"\"Randomly assigned using computerized algorithm\""
]
},
"2": {
"label":... | 12753879 | Simon 2003 | {
"1": "low",
"2": "unclear",
"3": "high",
"4": "low",
"5": "low"
} | {
"1": {
"label": "low",
"source_keys": [
"Domain1：Random sequence generation (selection bias)"
],
"thinking_labels": [
"\"Randomly assigned using computerized algorithm\""
]
},
"2": {
"label": "unclear",
"source_keys": [
"Domain2：Allocation concealment (selection bia... | 5 | [] | false |
rob_sr | [
{
"content": "\n**Role:** You are a meta-analysis expert. Your task is to perform a Risk of Bias assessment for a study based on the provided full-text and the Cochrane Risk of Bias 1.0 (RoB 1) tool criteria.\n\n**Inputs:**\n\n1. **Full text**: Downloaded from http://journals.lww.com/psychopharmacology by BhDMf... | rob_assessment | {
"ground_truth": {
"domain_info": {
"1": {
"label": "low",
"source_keys": [
"Domain1：Random sequence generation (selection bias)"
],
"thinking_labels": [
"\"Computer generated by the CAMH Research Pharmacy\","
]
},
"2": {
"labe... | 32068562 | Zawertailo 2020 | {
"1": "low",
"2": "low",
"3": null,
"4": "low",
"5": "low"
} | {
"1": {
"label": "low",
"source_keys": [
"Domain1：Random sequence generation (selection bias)"
],
"thinking_labels": [
"\"Computer generated by the CAMH Research Pharmacy\","
]
},
"2": {
"label": "low",
"source_keys": [
"Domain2：Allocation concealment (selection bias... | 4 | [
3
] | false |
rob_sr | [
{
"content": "\n**Role:** You are a meta-analysis expert. Your task is to perform a Risk of Bias assessment for a study based on the provided full-text and the Cochrane Risk of Bias 1.0 (RoB 1) tool criteria.\n\n**Inputs:**\n\n1. **Full text**: ## Abstract\n\n### Materials and Methods:\n\nThis randomized clinic... | rob_assessment | {
"ground_truth": {
"domain_info": {
"1": {
"label": "unclear",
"source_keys": [
"Domain1：Random sequence generation (selection bias)"
],
"thinking_labels": [
"\"Imam Ali Comprehensive Urban Health Center has 5 population blocks based on geographical area.... | 33457344 | Nikkhah Ravari 2020 | {
"1": "unclear",
"2": "unclear",
"3": "unclear",
"4": "unclear",
"5": "low"
} | {
"1": {
"label": "unclear",
"source_keys": [
"Domain1：Random sequence generation (selection bias)"
],
"thinking_labels": [
"\"Imam Ali Comprehensive Urban Health Center has 5 population blocks based on geographical area. In order to prevent contamination, using random number table, blocks... | 5 | [] | false |
rob_sr | [
{
"content": "\n**Role:** You are a meta-analysis expert. Your task is to perform a Risk of Bias assessment for a study based on the provided full-text and the Cochrane Risk of Bias 1.0 (RoB 1) tool criteria.\n\n**Inputs:**\n\n1. **Full text**: ### 3. Results\n\nForty-nine patients were included in the study: 2... | rob_assessment | {
"ground_truth": {
"domain_info": {
"1": {
"label": "unclear",
"source_keys": [
"Domain1：Random sequence generation (selection bias)"
],
"thinking_labels": [
"Not stated"
]
},
"2": {
"label": "unclear",
"source_keys": [... | 17900584 | De Tayrac 2008 | {
"1": "unclear",
"2": "unclear",
"3": "unclear",
"4": "unclear",
"5": "low"
} | {
"1": {
"label": "unclear",
"source_keys": [
"Domain1：Random sequence generation (selection bias)"
],
"thinking_labels": [
"Not stated"
]
},
"2": {
"label": "unclear",
"source_keys": [
"Domain2：Allocation concealment (selection bias)"
],
"thinking_labels": [
... | 5 | [] | false |
rob_sr | [
{
"content": "\n**Role:** You are a meta-analysis expert. Your task is to perform a Risk of Bias assessment for a study based on the provided full-text and the Cochrane Risk of Bias 1.0 (RoB 1) tool criteria.\n\n**Inputs:**\n\n1. **Full text**: ## Abstract\n\n### STUDY DESIGN, SIZE, DURATION\n\nThis is the firs... | rob_assessment | {
"ground_truth": {
"domain_info": {
"1": {
"label": "low",
"source_keys": [
"Domain1：Random sequence generation (selection bias)"
],
"thinking_labels": [
"\"Randomization was performed centrally through the electronic case report form (e‐ CRF) and was str... | 38723189 | Lobo 2024 | {
"1": "low",
"2": "low",
"3": "high",
"4": "high",
"5": "high"
} | {
"1": {
"label": "low",
"source_keys": [
"Domain1：Random sequence generation (selection bias)"
],
"thinking_labels": [
"\"Randomization was performed centrally through the electronic case report form (e‐ CRF) and was stratified by centre and according to age ( < 35, 35– 37, and 38–40years... | 5 | [] | false |
rob_sr | [
{
"content": "\n**Role:** You are a meta-analysis expert. Your task is to perform a Risk of Bias assessment for a study based on the provided full-text and the Cochrane Risk of Bias 1.0 (RoB 1) tool criteria.\n\n**Inputs:**\n\n1. **Full text**: # Rectocele repair: A randomized trial of three surgical techniques... | rob_assessment | {
"ground_truth": {
"domain_info": {
"1": {
"label": "low",
"source_keys": [
"Domain1：Random sequence generation (selection bias)"
],
"thinking_labels": [
"Computer generated"
]
},
"2": {
"label": "low",
"source_keys": [... | 17132479 | Paraiso 2006 | {
"1": "low",
"2": "low",
"3": "low",
"4": "low",
"5": "low"
} | {
"1": {
"label": "low",
"source_keys": [
"Domain1：Random sequence generation (selection bias)"
],
"thinking_labels": [
"Computer generated"
]
},
"2": {
"label": "low",
"source_keys": [
"Domain2：Allocation concealment (selection bias)"
],
"thinking_labels": [
... | 5 | [] | false |
rob_sr | [
{
"content": "\n**Role:** You are a meta-analysis expert. Your task is to perform a Risk of Bias assessment for a study based on the provided full-text and the Cochrane Risk of Bias 1.0 (RoB 1) tool criteria.\n\n**Inputs:**\n\n1. **Full text**: www.thelancet.com/respiratory Published online March 18, 2019 h... | rob_assessment | {
"ground_truth": {
"domain_info": {
"1": {
"label": "unclear",
"source_keys": [
"Domain1：Random sequence generation (selection bias)"
],
"thinking_labels": [
"Quote: \"Randomization was computer‐generated in permuted blocks of four participants (unknown t... | 30898520 | Frat 2019 | {
"1": "unclear",
"2": "low",
"3": "high",
"4": "low",
"5": "low"
} | {
"1": {
"label": "unclear",
"source_keys": [
"Domain1：Random sequence generation (selection bias)"
],
"thinking_labels": [
"Quote: \"Randomization was computer‐generated in permuted blocks of four participants (unknown to investigators), with stratification according to the centre and PaO... | 5 | [] | false |
rob_sr | [
{
"content": "\n**Role:** You are a meta-analysis expert. Your task is to perform a Risk of Bias assessment for a study based on the provided full-text and the Cochrane Risk of Bias 1.0 (RoB 1) tool criteria.\n\n**Inputs:**\n\n1. **Full text**: \n\n**Risk of Bias Domains (Cochrane RoB 1.0):**\n\nPlease assess t... | rob_assessment | {
"ground_truth": {
"domain_info": {
"1": {
"label": "unclear",
"source_keys": [
"Domain1：Random sequence generation (selection bias)"
],
"thinking_labels": [
"Comment: not mentioned."
]
},
"2": {
"label": "unclear",
"so... | 32200994 | Wu 2020 | {
"1": "unclear",
"2": "unclear",
"3": "high",
"4": "unclear",
"5": "low"
} | {
"1": {
"label": "unclear",
"source_keys": [
"Domain1：Random sequence generation (selection bias)"
],
"thinking_labels": [
"Comment: not mentioned."
]
},
"2": {
"label": "unclear",
"source_keys": [
"Domain2：Allocation concealment (selection bias)"
],
"thinkin... | 5 | [] | false |
rob_sr | [
{
"content": "\n**Role:** You are a meta-analysis expert. Your task is to perform a Risk of Bias assessment for a study based on the provided full-text and the Cochrane Risk of Bias 1.0 (RoB 1) tool criteria.\n\n**Inputs:**\n\n1. **Full text**: ## Abstract\n\n### Methods:\n\nAdult patients undergoing elective l... | rob_assessment | {
"ground_truth": {
"domain_info": {
"1": {
"label": "low",
"source_keys": [
"Domain1：Random sequence generation (selection bias)"
],
"thinking_labels": [
"Computer‐generated random numbers."
]
},
"2": {
"label": "low",
... | 34398011 | Nam 2021 | {
"1": "low",
"2": "low",
"3": "unclear",
"4": "unclear",
"5": "low"
} | {
"1": {
"label": "low",
"source_keys": [
"Domain1：Random sequence generation (selection bias)"
],
"thinking_labels": [
"Computer‐generated random numbers."
]
},
"2": {
"label": "low",
"source_keys": [
"Domain2：Allocation concealment (selection bias)"
],
"thin... | 5 | [] | false |
rob_sr | [
{
"content": "\n**Role:** You are a meta-analysis expert. Your task is to perform a Risk of Bias assessment for a study based on the provided full-text and the Cochrane Risk of Bias 1.0 (RoB 1) tool criteria.\n\n**Inputs:**\n\n1. **Full text**: # Benefits of statin treatment in cardiac syndrome-X\n\n- **作者**：Ka... | rob_assessment | {
"ground_truth": {
"domain_info": {
"1": {
"label": "unclear",
"source_keys": [
"Domain1：Random sequence generation (selection bias)"
],
"thinking_labels": [
"Method of randomization not reported"
]
},
"2": {
"label": "unclear"... | 14613735 | Kayikcioglu 2003 | {
"1": "unclear",
"2": "unclear",
"3": "low",
"4": "low",
"5": "low"
} | {
"1": {
"label": "unclear",
"source_keys": [
"Domain1：Random sequence generation (selection bias)"
],
"thinking_labels": [
"Method of randomization not reported"
]
},
"2": {
"label": "unclear",
"source_keys": [
"Domain2：Allocation concealment (selection bias)"
],... | 5 | [] | false |
rob_sr | [
{
"content": "\n**Role:** You are a meta-analysis expert. Your task is to perform a Risk of Bias assessment for a study based on the provided full-text and the Cochrane Risk of Bias 1.0 (RoB 1) tool criteria.\n\n**Inputs:**\n\n1. **Full text**: ## Abstract\n\n### Methods\n\nWe performed a double-blind, randomiz... | rob_assessment | {
"ground_truth": {
"domain_info": {
"1": {
"label": "low",
"source_keys": [
"Domain1：Random sequence generation (selection bias)"
],
"thinking_labels": [
"Random numbers table: allocation was done on a 1:1:1 basis."
]
},
"2": {
... | 18591525 | Taddio 2008 | {
"1": "low",
"2": "low",
"3": null,
"4": "low",
"5": "low"
} | {
"1": {
"label": "low",
"source_keys": [
"Domain1：Random sequence generation (selection bias)"
],
"thinking_labels": [
"Random numbers table: allocation was done on a 1:1:1 basis."
]
},
"2": {
"label": "low",
"source_keys": [
"Domain2：Allocation concealment (selectio... | 4 | [
3
] | false |
rob_sr | [
{
"content": "\n**Role:** You are a meta-analysis expert. Your task is to perform a Risk of Bias assessment for a study based on the provided full-text and the Cochrane Risk of Bias 1.0 (RoB 1) tool criteria.\n\n**Inputs:**\n\n1. **Full text**: ## Abstract\n\nWe evaluated three different conservative treatment ... | rob_assessment | {
"ground_truth": {
"domain_info": {
"1": {
"label": "unclear",
"source_keys": [
"Domain1：Random sequence generation (selection bias)",
"Domain1：Group similarity at baseline"
],
"thinking_labels": [
"Quote: \"Patients fulfilling our inclusion cri... | 9883955 | Seferlis 1998 | {
"1": "unclear",
"2": "unclear",
"3": "high",
"4": "high",
"5": "high"
} | {
"1": {
"label": "unclear",
"source_keys": [
"Domain1：Random sequence generation (selection bias)",
"Domain1：Group similarity at baseline"
],
"thinking_labels": [
"Quote: \"Patients fulfilling our inclusion criteria were randomised into one of the three treatment programmes [...].\"... | 5 | [] | false |
rob_sr | [
{
"content": "\n**Role:** You are a meta-analysis expert. Your task is to perform a Risk of Bias assessment for a study based on the provided full-text and the Cochrane Risk of Bias 1.0 (RoB 1) tool criteria.\n\n**Inputs:**\n\n1. **Full text**: # Carbetocin versus oxytocin for the prevention of postpartum haemo... | rob_assessment | {
"ground_truth": {
"domain_info": {
"1": {
"label": "low",
"source_keys": [
"Domain1：Random sequence generation (selection bias)"
],
"thinking_labels": [
"The randomisation sequence (1:1 ratio—blocks of ten, no stratification) was generated by computer."
... | 20482535 | Attilakos 2010 | {
"1": "low",
"2": "low",
"3": "low",
"4": "high",
"5": "low"
} | {
"1": {
"label": "low",
"source_keys": [
"Domain1：Random sequence generation (selection bias)"
],
"thinking_labels": [
"The randomisation sequence (1:1 ratio—blocks of ten, no stratification) was generated by computer."
]
},
"2": {
"label": "low",
"source_keys": [
"D... | 5 | [] | false |
rob_sr | [
{
"content": "\n**Role:** You are a meta-analysis expert. Your task is to perform a Risk of Bias assessment for a study based on the provided full-text and the Cochrane Risk of Bias 1.0 (RoB 1) tool criteria.\n\n**Inputs:**\n\n1. **Full text**: # A multicentre randomized-controlled trial of inhaled milrinone in... | rob_assessment | {
"ground_truth": {
"domain_info": {
"1": {
"label": "low",
"source_keys": [
"Domain1：Random sequence generation (selection bias)"
],
"thinking_labels": [
"Computer random number generator"
]
},
"2": {
"label": "low",
"s... | 27470232 | Denault 2016 | {
"1": "low",
"2": "low",
"3": "low",
"4": "low",
"5": "low"
} | {
"1": {
"label": "low",
"source_keys": [
"Domain1：Random sequence generation (selection bias)"
],
"thinking_labels": [
"Computer random number generator"
]
},
"2": {
"label": "low",
"source_keys": [
"Domain2：Allocation concealment (selection bias)"
],
"thinki... | 5 | [] | false |
rob_sr | [
{
"content": "\n**Role:** You are a meta-analysis expert. Your task is to perform a Risk of Bias assessment for a study based on the provided full-text and the Cochrane Risk of Bias 1.0 (RoB 1) tool criteria.\n\n**Inputs:**\n\n1. **Full text**: ## Abstract\n\nPostoperative glucose control directly affects the i... | rob_assessment | {
"ground_truth": {
"domain_info": {
"1": {
"label": "unclear",
"source_keys": [
"Domain1：Random sequence generation (selection bias)"
],
"thinking_labels": [
"Method of randomisation not defined: \"patients were randomly assigned to 1 of 2 groups for diab... | 17215967 | Li 2006 | {
"1": "unclear",
"2": "high",
"3": "high",
"4": "high",
"5": "high"
} | {
"1": {
"label": "unclear",
"source_keys": [
"Domain1：Random sequence generation (selection bias)"
],
"thinking_labels": [
"Method of randomisation not defined: \"patients were randomly assigned to 1 of 2 groups for diabetic control\"."
]
},
"2": {
"label": "high",
"source... | 5 | [] | false |
rob_sr | [
{
"content": "\n**Role:** You are a meta-analysis expert. Your task is to perform a Risk of Bias assessment for a study based on the provided full-text and the Cochrane Risk of Bias 1.0 (RoB 1) tool criteria.\n\n**Inputs:**\n\n1. **Full text**: Copyright 2015 American Medical Association. All rights reserved.\n... | rob_assessment | {
"ground_truth": {
"domain_info": {
"1": {
"label": "unclear",
"source_keys": [
"Domain1：Random sequence generation (selection bias)"
],
"thinking_labels": [
"Comment: study did not describe the sequence generation process"
]
},
"2": {... | 25587645 | McElroy 2015 | {
"1": "unclear",
"2": "low",
"3": "low",
"4": "low",
"5": "low"
} | {
"1": {
"label": "unclear",
"source_keys": [
"Domain1：Random sequence generation (selection bias)"
],
"thinking_labels": [
"Comment: study did not describe the sequence generation process"
]
},
"2": {
"label": "low",
"source_keys": [
"Domain2：Allocation concealment (... | 5 | [] | false |
rob_sr | [
{
"content": "\n**Role:** You are a meta-analysis expert. Your task is to perform a Risk of Bias assessment for a study based on the provided full-text and the Cochrane Risk of Bias 1.0 (RoB 1) tool criteria.\n\n**Inputs:**\n\n1. **Full text**: ### Brigitte Robertson , MD\n\nAt the time this research was conduc... | rob_assessment | {
"ground_truth": {
"domain_info": {
"1": {
"label": "unclear",
"source_keys": [
"Domain1：Random sequence generation (selection bias)"
],
"thinking_labels": [
"Comment: study did not describe the sequence generation process"
]
},
"2": {... | 33185468 | Mattingly 2020 | {
"1": "unclear",
"2": "unclear",
"3": "low",
"4": "low",
"5": "low"
} | {
"1": {
"label": "unclear",
"source_keys": [
"Domain1：Random sequence generation (selection bias)"
],
"thinking_labels": [
"Comment: study did not describe the sequence generation process"
]
},
"2": {
"label": "unclear",
"source_keys": [
"Domain2：Allocation concealme... | 5 | [] | false |
rob_sr | [
{
"content": "\n**Role:** You are a meta-analysis expert. Your task is to perform a Risk of Bias assessment for a study based on the provided full-text and the Cochrane Risk of Bias 1.0 (RoB 1) tool criteria.\n\n**Inputs:**\n\n1. **Full text**: ## Materials and methods\n### Subjects\nTwelve healthy normal male ... | rob_assessment | {
"ground_truth": {
"domain_info": {
"1": {
"label": "low",
"source_keys": [
"Domain1：Random sequence generation (selection bias)"
],
"thinking_labels": [
"Comment: participants were randomly assigned."
]
},
"2": {
"label": "unc... | 23246855 | Nordin 2013 | {
"1": "low",
"2": "unclear",
"3": "low",
"4": "low",
"5": "low"
} | {
"1": {
"label": "low",
"source_keys": [
"Domain1：Random sequence generation (selection bias)"
],
"thinking_labels": [
"Comment: participants were randomly assigned."
]
},
"2": {
"label": "unclear",
"source_keys": [
"Domain2：Allocation concealment (selection bias)"
... | 5 | [] | false |
rob_sr | [
{
"content": "\n**Role:** You are a meta-analysis expert. Your task is to perform a Risk of Bias assessment for a study based on the provided full-text and the Cochrane Risk of Bias 1.0 (RoB 1) tool criteria.\n\n**Inputs:**\n\n1. **Full text**: # Carbetocin vs. oxytocin at elective caesarean delivery: a double-... | rob_assessment | {
"ground_truth": {
"domain_info": {
"1": {
"label": "low",
"source_keys": [
"Domain1：Random sequence generation (selection bias)"
],
"thinking_labels": [
"\"...randomly allocated by a research co-ordinator into four groups using computer-generated block r... | 35343585 | McDonagh 2022 | {
"1": "low",
"2": "low",
"3": "low",
"4": "unclear",
"5": "high"
} | {
"1": {
"label": "low",
"source_keys": [
"Domain1：Random sequence generation (selection bias)"
],
"thinking_labels": [
"\"...randomly allocated by a research co-ordinator into four groups using computer-generated block randomisation with a block size of 8.\""
]
},
"2": {
"labe... | 5 | [] | false |
rob_sr | [
{
"content": "\n**Role:** You are a meta-analysis expert. Your task is to perform a Risk of Bias assessment for a study based on the provided full-text and the Cochrane Risk of Bias 1.0 (RoB 1) tool criteria.\n\n**Inputs:**\n\n1. **Full text**: # Improvement of nutritional measures during preoperative parentera... | rob_assessment | {
"ground_truth": {
"domain_info": {
"1": {
"label": "unclear",
"source_keys": [
"Domain1：Random sequence generation (selection bias)"
],
"thinking_labels": [
"Randomly ordered cards in sealed envelopes opened after the prognostic nutrition index was obtai... | 3148039 | Smith 1988 | {
"1": "unclear",
"2": "low",
"3": null,
"4": "high",
"5": "low"
} | {
"1": {
"label": "unclear",
"source_keys": [
"Domain1：Random sequence generation (selection bias)"
],
"thinking_labels": [
"Randomly ordered cards in sealed envelopes opened after the prognostic nutrition index was obtained. Did not describe an audit trail for sealed envelopes."
]
}... | 4 | [
3
] | false |
rob_sr | [
{
"content": "\n**Role:** You are a meta-analysis expert. Your task is to perform a Risk of Bias assessment for a study based on the provided full-text and the Cochrane Risk of Bias 1.0 (RoB 1) tool criteria.\n\n**Inputs:**\n\n1. **Full text**: ### Methods\n\nWe did a four-arm, parallel-group, randomised contro... | rob_assessment | {
"ground_truth": {
"domain_info": {
"1": {
"label": "low",
"source_keys": [
"Domain1：Random sequence generation (selection bias)"
],
"thinking_labels": [
"\"The study statistician (M-SY) prepared site-specific randomisation lists using the sample function... | 33857436 | Cobb 2021 | {
"1": "low",
"2": "low",
"3": "low",
"4": "low",
"5": "low"
} | {
"1": {
"label": "low",
"source_keys": [
"Domain1：Random sequence generation (selection bias)"
],
"thinking_labels": [
"\"The study statistician (M-SY) prepared site-specific randomisation lists using the sample function in R version 3.2.0 (blocks of eight). These lists were uploaded onto... | 5 | [] | false |
rob_sr | [
{
"content": "\n**Role:** You are a meta-analysis expert. Your task is to perform a Risk of Bias assessment for a study based on the provided full-text and the Cochrane Risk of Bias 1.0 (RoB 1) tool criteria.\n\n**Inputs:**\n\n1. **Full text**: ## Abstract\n\n### Methods\n\nThis multiregional, double-blind stud... | rob_assessment | {
"ground_truth": {
"domain_info": {
"1": {
"label": "low",
"source_keys": [
"Domain1：Random sequence generation (selection bias)"
],
"thinking_labels": [
"Quote: \"After an up‐to‐4‐week screening period, eligible patients were randomised using interactive... | 24920915 | Hassanein 2014 | {
"1": "low",
"2": "low",
"3": "low",
"4": "unclear",
"5": "high"
} | {
"1": {
"label": "low",
"source_keys": [
"Domain1：Random sequence generation (selection bias)"
],
"thinking_labels": [
"Quote: \"After an up‐to‐4‐week screening period, eligible patients were randomised using interactive response technology in a 1:1 ratio to receive either vildagliptin or... | 5 | [] | false |
rob_sr | [
{
"content": "\n**Role:** You are a meta-analysis expert. Your task is to perform a Risk of Bias assessment for a study based on the provided full-text and the Cochrane Risk of Bias 1.0 (RoB 1) tool criteria.\n\n**Inputs:**\n\n1. **Full text**: Downloaded from http://journals.lww.com/jpelvicsurgery by BhDMf5ePH... | rob_assessment | {
"ground_truth": {
"domain_info": {
"1": {
"label": "low",
"source_keys": [
"Domain1：Random sequence generation (selection bias)"
],
"thinking_labels": [
"Block computer‐generated randomisation"
]
},
"2": {
"label": "low",
... | 31990800 | Aslam 2020 | {
"1": "low",
"2": "low",
"3": "high",
"4": "high",
"5": "low"
} | {
"1": {
"label": "low",
"source_keys": [
"Domain1：Random sequence generation (selection bias)"
],
"thinking_labels": [
"Block computer‐generated randomisation"
]
},
"2": {
"label": "low",
"source_keys": [
"Domain2：Allocation concealment (selection bias)"
],
"... | 5 | [] | false |
rob_sr | [
{
"content": "\n**Role:** You are a meta-analysis expert. Your task is to perform a Risk of Bias assessment for a study based on the provided full-text and the Cochrane Risk of Bias 1.0 (RoB 1) tool criteria.\n\n**Inputs:**\n\n1. **Full text**: ## Outcomes Using a Conservative Versus Liberal Red\n\n**Risk of Bi... | rob_assessment | {
"ground_truth": {
"domain_info": {
"1": {
"label": "low",
"source_keys": [
"Domain1：Random sequence generation (selection bias)"
],
"thinking_labels": [
"Insufficient information given in published paper. As with Cholette 2011 , we appealed to the first ... | 27496630 | Cholette 2017 | {
"1": "low",
"2": "low",
"3": "low",
"4": "low",
"5": "low"
} | {
"1": {
"label": "low",
"source_keys": [
"Domain1：Random sequence generation (selection bias)"
],
"thinking_labels": [
"Insufficient information given in published paper. As with Cholette 2011 , we appealed to the first author for further information. It was clarified that \"We used a com... | 5 | [] | false |
rob_sr | [
{
"content": "\n**Role:** You are a meta-analysis expert. Your task is to perform a Risk of Bias assessment for a study based on the provided full-text and the Cochrane Risk of Bias 1.0 (RoB 1) tool criteria.\n\n**Inputs:**\n\n1. **Full text**: ## Abstract\n\n### Design:\n\nA randomized controlled design with r... | rob_assessment | {
"ground_truth": {
"domain_info": {
"1": {
"label": "low",
"source_keys": [
"Domain1：Random sequence generation (selection bias)",
"Domain1：Groups balanced at baseline?"
],
"thinking_labels": [
"“Simple randomization was used in this study. The ... | 30170422 | Peng 2018 | {
"1": "low",
"2": "low",
"3": "low",
"4": "unclear",
"5": "unclear"
} | {
"1": {
"label": "low",
"source_keys": [
"Domain1：Random sequence generation (selection bias)",
"Domain1：Groups balanced at baseline?"
],
"thinking_labels": [
"“Simple randomization was used in this study. The 98 eligible patients were randomly assigned to either the experimental gr... | 5 | [] | false |
rob_sr | [
{
"content": "\n**Role:** You are a meta-analysis expert. Your task is to perform a Risk of Bias assessment for a study based on the provided full-text and the Cochrane Risk of Bias 1.0 (RoB 1) tool criteria.\n\n**Inputs:**\n\n1. **Full text**: ## 2 Methods\n### 2.1 Design and setting\nThis article presents a r... | rob_assessment | {
"ground_truth": {
"domain_info": {
"1": {
"label": "low",
"source_keys": [
"Domain1：Random sequence generation (selection bias)"
],
"thinking_labels": [
"\"An allocation sequence based on a random‐number table was used to randomly assign all enrolled par... | 21112451 | De Azevedo 2010 | {
"1": "low",
"2": "low",
"3": "high",
"4": "high",
"5": "low"
} | {
"1": {
"label": "low",
"source_keys": [
"Domain1：Random sequence generation (selection bias)"
],
"thinking_labels": [
"\"An allocation sequence based on a random‐number table was used to randomly assign all enrolled participants\"."
]
},
"2": {
"label": "low",
"source_key... | 5 | [] | false |
rob_sr | [
{
"content": "\n**Role:** You are a meta-analysis expert. Your task is to perform a Risk of Bias assessment for a study based on the provided full-text and the Cochrane Risk of Bias 1.0 (RoB 1) tool criteria.\n\n**Inputs:**\n\n1. **Full text**: ## Abstract\n\nBACKGROUND: In total knee arthroplasty surgery, a bl... | rob_assessment | {
"ground_truth": {
"domain_info": {
"1": {
"label": "low",
"source_keys": [
"Domain1：Random sequence generation (selection bias)"
],
"thinking_labels": [
"Quote: \"Patients were assigned to tranexamic acid group or control group with software that provide... | 18067499 | Alvarez 2008 | {
"1": "low",
"2": "unclear",
"3": "high",
"4": "low",
"5": "low"
} | {
"1": {
"label": "low",
"source_keys": [
"Domain1：Random sequence generation (selection bias)"
],
"thinking_labels": [
"Quote: \"Patients were assigned to tranexamic acid group or control group with software that provided a series of random numbers.\" Judgement comment: cmputer‐generated ... | 5 | [] | false |
rob_sr | [
{
"content": "\n**Role:** You are a meta-analysis expert. Your task is to perform a Risk of Bias assessment for a study based on the provided full-text and the Cochrane Risk of Bias 1.0 (RoB 1) tool criteria.\n\n**Inputs:**\n\n1. **Full text**: ## ABSTRACT\n\n### DESIGN AND SETTING:\n\nProspective, randomized, ... | rob_assessment | {
"ground_truth": {
"domain_info": {
"1": {
"label": "low",
"source_keys": [
"Domain1：Random sequence generation (selection bias)"
],
"thinking_labels": [
"Computer‐generated randomisation scheme"
]
},
"2": {
"label": "low",
... | 17992396 | Cicarelli 2007 | {
"1": "low",
"2": "low",
"3": "low",
"4": "low",
"5": "unclear"
} | {
"1": {
"label": "low",
"source_keys": [
"Domain1：Random sequence generation (selection bias)"
],
"thinking_labels": [
"Computer‐generated randomisation scheme"
]
},
"2": {
"label": "low",
"source_keys": [
"Domain2：Allocation concealment (selection bias)"
],
... | 5 | [] | false |
rob_sr | [
{
"content": "\n**Role:** You are a meta-analysis expert. Your task is to perform a Risk of Bias assessment for a study based on the provided full-text and the Cochrane Risk of Bias 1.0 (RoB 1) tool criteria.\n\n**Inputs:**\n\n1. **Full text**: Vot. 10,1991\n949\n\n### the Treatment of Streptococcal\n\n### Quin... | rob_assessment | {
"ground_truth": {
"domain_info": {
"1": {
"label": "unclear",
"source_keys": [
"Domain1：Random sequence generation (selection bias)"
],
"thinking_labels": [
"\"Random number code\" was used, but unclear how it was generated"
]
},
"2":... | 1838978 | Stein 1991 | {
"1": "unclear",
"2": "unclear",
"3": null,
"4": "low",
"5": "high"
} | {
"1": {
"label": "unclear",
"source_keys": [
"Domain1：Random sequence generation (selection bias)"
],
"thinking_labels": [
"\"Random number code\" was used, but unclear how it was generated"
]
},
"2": {
"label": "unclear",
"source_keys": [
"Domain2：Allocation conceal... | 4 | [
3
] | false |
rob_sr | [
{
"content": "\n**Role:** You are a meta-analysis expert. Your task is to perform a Risk of Bias assessment for a study based on the provided full-text and the Cochrane Risk of Bias 1.0 (RoB 1) tool criteria.\n\n**Inputs:**\n\n1. **Full text**: # Pain relief effect of breast feeding and music therapy during hee... | rob_assessment | {
"ground_truth": {
"domain_info": {
"1": {
"label": "low",
"source_keys": [
"Domain1：Random sequence generation (selection bias)"
],
"thinking_labels": [
"The main researcher used an online tool to randomly generate 72 sets of numbers, each set containing... | 25467598 | Zhu 2015 (Heel lance) | {
"1": "low",
"2": "low",
"3": null,
"4": "unclear",
"5": "low"
} | {
"1": {
"label": "low",
"source_keys": [
"Domain1：Random sequence generation (selection bias)"
],
"thinking_labels": [
"The main researcher used an online tool to randomly generate 72 sets of numbers, each set containing 4 numbers ranging from 1 to 4 with random order"
]
},
"2": {... | 4 | [
3
] | false |
rob_sr | [
{
"content": "\n**Role:** You are a meta-analysis expert. Your task is to perform a Risk of Bias assessment for a study based on the provided full-text and the Cochrane Risk of Bias 1.0 (RoB 1) tool criteria.\n\n**Inputs:**\n\n1. **Full text**: # Phimotic ring topical corticoid cream (0.1% mometasone furoate) t... | rob_assessment | {
"ground_truth": {
"domain_info": {
"1": {
"label": "unclear",
"source_keys": [
"Domain1：Random sequence generation (selection bias)"
],
"thinking_labels": [
"Quote from publication: \"...randomized double‐blind clinical trial...\" Comment: study describe... | 17923208 | Pileggi 2007 | {
"1": "unclear",
"2": "low",
"3": "low",
"4": "low",
"5": "unclear"
} | {
"1": {
"label": "unclear",
"source_keys": [
"Domain1：Random sequence generation (selection bias)"
],
"thinking_labels": [
"Quote from publication: \"...randomized double‐blind clinical trial...\" Comment: study described as randomized, but randomization method not reported."
]
},
... | 5 | [] | false |
rob_sr | [
{
"content": "\n**Role:** You are a meta-analysis expert. Your task is to perform a Risk of Bias assessment for a study based on the provided full-text and the Cochrane Risk of Bias 1.0 (RoB 1) tool criteria.\n\n**Inputs:**\n\n1. **Full text**: # The effect of music and skin contact with the newborn on pain and... | rob_assessment | {
"ground_truth": {
"domain_info": {
"1": {
"label": "low",
"source_keys": [
"Domain1：Random sequence generation (selection bias)"
],
"thinking_labels": [
"“Before delivery closed envelopes that were assigned the letters A, B, C were randomly distributed t... | 33277203 | Solt 2022 | {
"1": "low",
"2": "unclear",
"3": "high",
"4": "high",
"5": "low"
} | {
"1": {
"label": "low",
"source_keys": [
"Domain1：Random sequence generation (selection bias)"
],
"thinking_labels": [
"“Before delivery closed envelopes that were assigned the letters A, B, C were randomly distributed to the women by a midwife who was not involved with the study” p.211"
... | 5 | [] | false |
rob_sr | [
{
"content": "\n**Role:** You are a meta-analysis expert. Your task is to perform a Risk of Bias assessment for a study based on the provided full-text and the Cochrane Risk of Bias 1.0 (RoB 1) tool criteria.\n\n**Inputs:**\n\n1. **Full text**: # Impact of letrozole co-treatment during ovarian stimulation with ... | rob_assessment | {
"ground_truth": {
"domain_info": {
"1": {
"label": "low",
"source_keys": [
"Domain1：Random sequence generation (selection bias)"
],
"thinking_labels": [
"\"Identical capsules with letrozole or placebo were prepared by a certified research pharmacy and ra... | 34792133 | Bülow 2022 | {
"1": "low",
"2": "low",
"3": "low",
"4": "low",
"5": "high"
} | {
"1": {
"label": "low",
"source_keys": [
"Domain1：Random sequence generation (selection bias)"
],
"thinking_labels": [
"\"Identical capsules with letrozole or placebo were prepared by a certified research pharmacy and randomized in blocks of six in a ratio of 1:1 and stored in consecutive... | 5 | [] | false |
rob_sr | [
{
"content": "\n**Role:** You are a meta-analysis expert. Your task is to perform a Risk of Bias assessment for a study based on the provided full-text and the Cochrane Risk of Bias 1.0 (RoB 1) tool criteria.\n\n**Inputs:**\n\n1. **Full text**: # Our experience of controlling diabetes in the peri-operative peri... | rob_assessment | {
"ground_truth": {
"domain_info": {
"1": {
"label": "unclear",
"source_keys": [
"Domain1：Random sequence generation (selection bias)"
],
"thinking_labels": [
"Method of randomisation not defined"
]
},
"2": {
"label": "unclear",... | 20395003 | Emam 2010 | {
"1": "unclear",
"2": "unclear",
"3": "unclear",
"4": "unclear",
"5": "low"
} | {
"1": {
"label": "unclear",
"source_keys": [
"Domain1：Random sequence generation (selection bias)"
],
"thinking_labels": [
"Method of randomisation not defined"
]
},
"2": {
"label": "unclear",
"source_keys": [
"Domain2：Allocation concealment (selection bias)"
],
... | 5 | [] | false |
rob_sr | [
{
"content": "\n**Role:** You are a meta-analysis expert. Your task is to perform a Risk of Bias assessment for a study based on the provided full-text and the Cochrane Risk of Bias 1.0 (RoB 1) tool criteria.\n\n**Inputs:**\n\n1. **Full text**: 0041-1337/01/7202-284/0\nTRANSPLANTATION\nVol. 72, 284–290, No. 2, ... | rob_assessment | {
"ground_truth": {
"domain_info": {
"1": {
"label": "low",
"source_keys": [
"Domain1：Random sequence generation (selection bias)"
],
"thinking_labels": [
"Block randomisation in three blocks of 20 followed by one block of 10"
]
},
"2":... | 11477354 | Wolf 2001 | {
"1": "low",
"2": "low",
"3": null,
"4": "high",
"5": "unclear"
} | {
"1": {
"label": "low",
"source_keys": [
"Domain1：Random sequence generation (selection bias)"
],
"thinking_labels": [
"Block randomisation in three blocks of 20 followed by one block of 10"
]
},
"2": {
"label": "low",
"source_keys": [
"Domain2：Allocation concealment... | 4 | [
3
] | false |
rob_sr | [
{
"content": "\n**Role:** You are a meta-analysis expert. Your task is to perform a Risk of Bias assessment for a study based on the provided full-text and the Cochrane Risk of Bias 1.0 (RoB 1) tool criteria.\n\n**Inputs:**\n\n1. **Full text**: The new engl and jour nal of medicine\nn engl j med 369;7 nejm.org... | rob_assessment | {
"ground_truth": {
"domain_info": {
"1": {
"label": "low",
"source_keys": [
"Domain1：Random sequence generation (selection bias)"
],
"thinking_labels": [
"Web‐based randomisation"
]
},
"2": {
"label": "low",
"source_key... | 23944299 | Kirpalani 2013 | {
"1": "low",
"2": "low",
"3": "high",
"4": "high",
"5": "low"
} | {
"1": {
"label": "low",
"source_keys": [
"Domain1：Random sequence generation (selection bias)"
],
"thinking_labels": [
"Web‐based randomisation"
]
},
"2": {
"label": "low",
"source_keys": [
"Domain2：Allocation concealment (selection bias)"
],
"thinking_labels... | 5 | [] | false |
rob_sr | [
{
"content": "\n**Role:** You are a meta-analysis expert. Your task is to perform a Risk of Bias assessment for a study based on the provided full-text and the Cochrane Risk of Bias 1.0 (RoB 1) tool criteria.\n\n**Inputs:**\n\n1. **Full text**: ## Cardiac Surgery Patients\n\nAthos J. Rassias, MD*, Charles A. S.... | rob_assessment | {
"ground_truth": {
"domain_info": {
"1": {
"label": "unclear",
"source_keys": [
"Domain1：Random sequence generation (selection bias)"
],
"thinking_labels": [
"Quote : \"Patients were prospectively randomized into one of two treatment groups...\" Comment: ... | 10320160 | Rassias 1999 | {
"1": "unclear",
"2": "unclear",
"3": "high",
"4": "unclear",
"5": "low"
} | {
"1": {
"label": "unclear",
"source_keys": [
"Domain1：Random sequence generation (selection bias)"
],
"thinking_labels": [
"Quote : \"Patients were prospectively randomized into one of two treatment groups...\" Comment: described as randomised but no additional details provided about the ... | 5 | [] | false |
rob_sr | [
{
"content": "\n**Role:** You are a meta-analysis expert. Your task is to perform a Risk of Bias assessment for a study based on the provided full-text and the Cochrane Risk of Bias 1.0 (RoB 1) tool criteria.\n\n**Inputs:**\n\n1. **Full text**: \n\n**Risk of Bias Domains (Cochrane RoB 1.0):**\n\nPlease assess t... | rob_assessment | {
"ground_truth": {
"domain_info": {
"1": {
"label": "unclear",
"source_keys": [
"Domain1：Random sequence generation (selection bias)"
],
"thinking_labels": [
"Infants were stratified by birth weight and randomised, but how the sequence was generated is no... | 6864403 | Tyson 1983 | {
"1": "unclear",
"2": "low",
"3": "unclear",
"4": "unclear",
"5": "low"
} | {
"1": {
"label": "unclear",
"source_keys": [
"Domain1：Random sequence generation (selection bias)"
],
"thinking_labels": [
"Infants were stratified by birth weight and randomised, but how the sequence was generated is not stated"
]
},
"2": {
"label": "low",
"source_keys": ... | 5 | [] | false |
rob_sr | [
{
"content": "\n**Role:** You are a meta-analysis expert. Your task is to perform a Risk of Bias assessment for a study based on the provided full-text and the Cochrane Risk of Bias 1.0 (RoB 1) tool criteria.\n\n**Inputs:**\n\n1. **Full text**: ## Abstract\n\nIN BRIEF Painful diabetic peripheral neuropathy (PDP... | rob_assessment | {
"ground_truth": {
"domain_info": {
"1": {
"label": "low",
"source_keys": [
"Domain1：Random sequence generation (selection bias)"
],
"thinking_labels": [
"Patients were randomly allocated to a waiting list or MBSR using computer‐generated random numbers i... | 29263572 | Nathan 2017 | {
"1": "low",
"2": "low",
"3": "unclear",
"4": "unclear",
"5": "low"
} | {
"1": {
"label": "low",
"source_keys": [
"Domain1：Random sequence generation (selection bias)"
],
"thinking_labels": [
"Patients were randomly allocated to a waiting list or MBSR using computer‐generated random numbers in a permuted block design with randomly varying block lengths. Alloca... | 5 | [] | false |
rob_sr | [
{
"content": "\n**Role:** You are a meta-analysis expert. Your task is to perform a Risk of Bias assessment for a study based on the provided full-text and the Cochrane Risk of Bias 1.0 (RoB 1) tool criteria.\n\n**Inputs:**\n\n1. **Full text**: # Comparative study of vaginal, laparoscopically assisted vaginal a... | rob_assessment | {
"ground_truth": {
"domain_info": {
"1": {
"label": "low",
"source_keys": [
"Domain1：Random sequence generation (selection bias)"
],
"thinking_labels": [
"Computer‐generated block randomisation numbers"
]
},
"2": {
"label": "lo... | 12519109 | Hwang 2002 | {
"1": "low",
"2": "low",
"3": null,
"4": "high",
"5": "low"
} | {
"1": {
"label": "low",
"source_keys": [
"Domain1：Random sequence generation (selection bias)"
],
"thinking_labels": [
"Computer‐generated block randomisation numbers"
]
},
"2": {
"label": "low",
"source_keys": [
"Domain2：Allocation concealment (selection bias)"
... | 4 | [
3
] | false |
rob_sr | [
{
"content": "\n**Role:** You are a meta-analysis expert. Your task is to perform a Risk of Bias assessment for a study based on the provided full-text and the Cochrane Risk of Bias 1.0 (RoB 1) tool criteria.\n\n**Inputs:**\n\n1. **Full text**: # Aerobic Training Decreases B-Type Natriuretic Peptide Expression ... | rob_assessment | {
"ground_truth": {
"domain_info": {
"1": {
"label": "unclear",
"source_keys": [
"Domain1：Random sequence generation (selection bias)"
],
"thinking_labels": [
"Not reported"
]
},
"2": {
"label": "unclear",
"source_keys":... | 16682309 | Passino 2006 | {
"1": "unclear",
"2": "unclear",
"3": "low",
"4": "unclear",
"5": "low"
} | {
"1": {
"label": "unclear",
"source_keys": [
"Domain1：Random sequence generation (selection bias)"
],
"thinking_labels": [
"Not reported"
]
},
"2": {
"label": "unclear",
"source_keys": [
"Domain2：Allocation concealment (selection bias)"
],
"thinking_labels": ... | 5 | [] | false |
rob_sr | [
{
"content": "\n**Role:** You are a meta-analysis expert. Your task is to perform a Risk of Bias assessment for a study based on the provided full-text and the Cochrane Risk of Bias 1.0 (RoB 1) tool criteria.\n\n**Inputs:**\n\n1. **Full text**: Nutrición\nHospitalaria\nNutr Hosp. 2014;30(5):1071-1076 \nISSN 021... | rob_assessment | {
"ground_truth": {
"domain_info": {
"1": {
"label": "unclear",
"source_keys": [
"Domain1：Random sequence generation (selection bias)"
],
"thinking_labels": [
"A random sample of 93 newborns was taken from all the babies in the unit, who were required to u... | 25365010 | Cordero 2014 (Heel lance) | {
"1": "unclear",
"2": "high",
"3": null,
"4": "high",
"5": "low"
} | {
"1": {
"label": "unclear",
"source_keys": [
"Domain1：Random sequence generation (selection bias)"
],
"thinking_labels": [
"A random sample of 93 newborns was taken from all the babies in the unit, who were required to undergo the heel lance procedure. The population sample for the study ... | 4 | [
3
] | false |
rob_sr | [
{
"content": "\n**Role:** You are a meta-analysis expert. Your task is to perform a Risk of Bias assessment for a study based on the provided full-text and the Cochrane Risk of Bias 1.0 (RoB 1) tool criteria.\n\n**Inputs:**\n\n1. **Full text**: DOI: 10.1542/peds.2013-1834\n; originally published online January ... | rob_assessment | {
"ground_truth": {
"domain_info": {
"1": {
"label": "unclear",
"source_keys": [
"Domain1：Is it clear that the order of receiving treatments was randomised?"
],
"thinking_labels": [
"Although the study authors stated that the sequence of allocation was ran... | 24470641 | Hallenberger 2014 | {
"1": "unclear",
"2": "low",
"3": "low",
"4": "low",
"5": "high"
} | {
"1": {
"label": "unclear",
"source_keys": [
"Domain1：Is it clear that the order of receiving treatments was randomised?"
],
"thinking_labels": [
"Although the study authors stated that the sequence of allocation was randomised and the number of infants that received each allocation was d... | 5 | [] | false |
rob_sr | [
{
"content": "\n**Role:** You are a meta-analysis expert. Your task is to perform a Risk of Bias assessment for a study based on the provided full-text and the Cochrane Risk of Bias 1.0 (RoB 1) tool criteria.\n\n**Inputs:**\n\n1. **Full text**: ## Materials and methods\n\nApproval for the study was obtained fro... | rob_assessment | {
"ground_truth": {
"domain_info": {
"1": {
"label": "low",
"source_keys": [
"Domain1：Random sequence generation (selection bias)"
],
"thinking_labels": [
"Randomization done by chit in a box technique."
]
},
"2": {
"label": "un... | 19335346 | Singh 2009 | {
"1": "low",
"2": "unclear",
"3": "high",
"4": "low",
"5": "low"
} | {
"1": {
"label": "low",
"source_keys": [
"Domain1：Random sequence generation (selection bias)"
],
"thinking_labels": [
"Randomization done by chit in a box technique."
]
},
"2": {
"label": "unclear",
"source_keys": [
"Domain2：Allocation concealment (selection bias)"
... | 5 | [] | false |
rob_sr | [
{
"content": "\n**Role:** You are a meta-analysis expert. Your task is to perform a Risk of Bias assessment for a study based on the provided full-text and the Cochrane Risk of Bias 1.0 (RoB 1) tool criteria.\n\n**Inputs:**\n\n1. **Full text**: ## Abstract\n\n### Materials and Methods:\n\nSixty neonates schedul... | rob_assessment | {
"ground_truth": {
"domain_info": {
"1": {
"label": "low",
"source_keys": [
"Domain1：Random sequence generation (selection bias)"
],
"thinking_labels": [
"Randomization was performed by an independent statistician in a 1:1 ratio."
]
},
... | 30692885 | Salama 2019 | {
"1": "low",
"2": "low",
"3": "high",
"4": "low",
"5": "low"
} | {
"1": {
"label": "low",
"source_keys": [
"Domain1：Random sequence generation (selection bias)"
],
"thinking_labels": [
"Randomization was performed by an independent statistician in a 1:1 ratio."
]
},
"2": {
"label": "low",
"source_keys": [
"Domain2：Allocation concea... | 5 | [] | false |
rob_sr | [
{
"content": "\n**Role:** You are a meta-analysis expert. Your task is to perform a Risk of Bias assessment for a study based on the provided full-text and the Cochrane Risk of Bias 1.0 (RoB 1) tool criteria.\n\n**Inputs:**\n\n1. **Full text**: ## Abstract\n\n### Methods and Results\n\nOne hundred patients sche... | rob_assessment | {
"ground_truth": {
"domain_info": {
"1": {
"label": "unclear",
"source_keys": [
"Domain1：Random sequence generation (selection bias)"
],
"thinking_labels": [
"Not described."
]
},
"2": {
"label": "low",
"source_keys": [... | 27936214 | Torensma 2016 | {
"1": "unclear",
"2": "low",
"3": "unclear",
"4": "unclear",
"5": "low"
} | {
"1": {
"label": "unclear",
"source_keys": [
"Domain1：Random sequence generation (selection bias)"
],
"thinking_labels": [
"Not described."
]
},
"2": {
"label": "low",
"source_keys": [
"Domain2：Allocation concealment (selection bias)"
],
"thinking_labels": [
... | 5 | [] | false |
rob_sr | [
{
"content": "\n**Role:** You are a meta-analysis expert. Your task is to perform a Risk of Bias assessment for a study based on the provided full-text and the Cochrane Risk of Bias 1.0 (RoB 1) tool criteria.\n\n**Inputs:**\n\n1. **Full text**: ## Resultados\nLa cohorte original era seleccionada de los 6.738 en... | rob_assessment | {
"ground_truth": {
"domain_info": {
"1": {
"label": "low",
"source_keys": [
"Domain1：Random sequence generation (selection bias)"
],
"thinking_labels": [
"Computerised algorithm used for randomisation"
]
},
"2": {
"label": "unc... | 20870337 | Ortega 2011a | {
"1": "low",
"2": "unclear",
"3": "unclear",
"4": "unclear",
"5": "high"
} | {
"1": {
"label": "low",
"source_keys": [
"Domain1：Random sequence generation (selection bias)"
],
"thinking_labels": [
"Computerised algorithm used for randomisation"
]
},
"2": {
"label": "unclear",
"source_keys": [
"Domain2：Allocation concealment (selection bias)"
... | 5 | [] | false |
rob_sr | [
{
"content": "\n**Role:** You are a meta-analysis expert. Your task is to perform a Risk of Bias assessment for a study based on the provided full-text and the Cochrane Risk of Bias 1.0 (RoB 1) tool criteria.\n\n**Inputs:**\n\n1. **Full text**: # Exploring the efficacy of an acceptance, mindfulness & compassion... | rob_assessment | {
"ground_truth": {
"domain_info": {
"1": {
"label": "low",
"source_keys": [
"Domain1：Random sequence generation (selection bias)"
],
"thinking_labels": [
"Randomly assigned to an experimental or to control conditions by a member of the research team, usin... | 28119138 | Palmeira 2017 | {
"1": "low",
"2": "unclear",
"3": "unclear",
"4": "low",
"5": "unclear"
} | {
"1": {
"label": "low",
"source_keys": [
"Domain1：Random sequence generation (selection bias)"
],
"thinking_labels": [
"Randomly assigned to an experimental or to control conditions by a member of the research team, using a computer‐based random allocation."
]
},
"2": {
"label... | 5 | [] | false |
rob_sr | [
{
"content": "\n**Role:** You are a meta-analysis expert. Your task is to perform a Risk of Bias assessment for a study based on the provided full-text and the Cochrane Risk of Bias 1.0 (RoB 1) tool criteria.\n\n**Inputs:**\n\n1. **Full text**: ### capacity and quality of life in patients with\n\n**Risk of Bias... | rob_assessment | {
"ground_truth": {
"domain_info": {
"1": {
"label": "unclear",
"source_keys": [
"Domain1：Random sequence generation (selection bias)"
],
"thinking_labels": [
"Not reported"
]
},
"2": {
"label": "unclear",
"source_keys":... | 18719752 | Bocalini 2008 | {
"1": "unclear",
"2": "unclear",
"3": "low",
"4": "unclear",
"5": "high"
} | {
"1": {
"label": "unclear",
"source_keys": [
"Domain1：Random sequence generation (selection bias)"
],
"thinking_labels": [
"Not reported"
]
},
"2": {
"label": "unclear",
"source_keys": [
"Domain2：Allocation concealment (selection bias)"
],
"thinking_labels": ... | 5 | [] | false |
rob_sr | [
{
"content": "\n**Role:** You are a meta-analysis expert. Your task is to perform a Risk of Bias assessment for a study based on the provided full-text and the Cochrane Risk of Bias 1.0 (RoB 1) tool criteria.\n\n**Inputs:**\n\n1. **Full text**: # Early effects of statin therapy on endothelial function and micro... | rob_assessment | {
"ground_truth": {
"domain_info": {
"1": {
"label": "low",
"source_keys": [
"Domain1：Random sequence generation (selection bias)"
],
"thinking_labels": [
"Random number table randomization in the study was performed by an independent observer and occurred... | 15976803 | Ling 2005 | {
"1": "low",
"2": "low",
"3": "low",
"4": "unclear",
"5": "high"
} | {
"1": {
"label": "low",
"source_keys": [
"Domain1：Random sequence generation (selection bias)"
],
"thinking_labels": [
"Random number table randomization in the study was performed by an independent observer and occurred in blocks."
]
},
"2": {
"label": "low",
"source_keys... | 5 | [] | false |
rob_sr | [
{
"content": "\n**Role:** You are a meta-analysis expert. Your task is to perform a Risk of Bias assessment for a study based on the provided full-text and the Cochrane Risk of Bias 1.0 (RoB 1) tool criteria.\n\n**Inputs:**\n\n1. **Full text**: # A pilot-randomized comparison of sublingual misoprostol with synt... | rob_assessment | {
"ground_truth": {
"domain_info": {
"1": {
"label": "low",
"source_keys": [
"Domain1：Random sequence generation (selection bias)"
],
"thinking_labels": [
"Allocated using a random number-generated table."
]
},
"2": {
"label": "... | 15225189 | Lam 2004 | {
"1": "low",
"2": "unclear",
"3": "high",
"4": "unclear",
"5": "unclear"
} | {
"1": {
"label": "low",
"source_keys": [
"Domain1：Random sequence generation (selection bias)"
],
"thinking_labels": [
"Allocated using a random number-generated table."
]
},
"2": {
"label": "unclear",
"source_keys": [
"Domain2：Allocation concealment (selection bias)... | 5 | [] | false |
rob_sr | [
{
"content": "\n**Role:** You are a meta-analysis expert. Your task is to perform a Risk of Bias assessment for a study based on the provided full-text and the Cochrane Risk of Bias 1.0 (RoB 1) tool criteria.\n\n**Inputs:**\n\n1. **Full text**: # Supporting Play, Exploration, and Early Development Intervention ... | rob_assessment | {
"ground_truth": {
"domain_info": {
"1": {
"label": "low",
"source_keys": [
"Domain1：Random sequence generation (selection bias)"
],
"thinking_labels": [
"Computer‐generated allocation sequence"
]
},
"2": {
"label": "low",
... | 33137579 | Finlayson 2020 | {
"1": "low",
"2": "low",
"3": "high",
"4": "low",
"5": "low"
} | {
"1": {
"label": "low",
"source_keys": [
"Domain1：Random sequence generation (selection bias)"
],
"thinking_labels": [
"Computer‐generated allocation sequence"
]
},
"2": {
"label": "low",
"source_keys": [
"Domain2：Allocation concealment (selection bias)"
],
"... | 5 | [] | false |
rob_sr | [
{
"content": "\n**Role:** You are a meta-analysis expert. Your task is to perform a Risk of Bias assessment for a study based on the provided full-text and the Cochrane Risk of Bias 1.0 (RoB 1) tool criteria.\n\n**Inputs:**\n\n1. **Full text**: 180\n102\n16.3\n28.9\nRelative risk, 1.77 (95% CI, 1.43–2.20)\nBioc... | rob_assessment | {
"ground_truth": {
"domain_info": {
"1": {
"label": "low",
"source_keys": [
"Domain1：Random sequence generation (selection bias)"
],
"thinking_labels": [
"An automated, centralized, online randomization system in a protected environment at the Clinical Tr... | 38354139 | Auer 2024 | {
"1": "low",
"2": "low",
"3": "high",
"4": "low",
"5": "low"
} | {
"1": {
"label": "low",
"source_keys": [
"Domain1：Random sequence generation (selection bias)"
],
"thinking_labels": [
"An automated, centralized, online randomization system in a protected environment at the Clinical Trials Unit in Bern, Switzerland, then generated randomization sequence... | 5 | [] | false |
rob_sr | [
{
"content": "\n**Role:** You are a meta-analysis expert. Your task is to perform a Risk of Bias assessment for a study based on the provided full-text and the Cochrane Risk of Bias 1.0 (RoB 1) tool criteria.\n\n**Inputs:**\n\n1. **Full text**: ## Abstract\n\n### Methods\n\nOur power analysis of this study was ... | rob_assessment | {
"ground_truth": {
"domain_info": {
"1": {
"label": "low",
"source_keys": [
"Domain1：Random sequence generation (selection bias)"
],
"thinking_labels": [
"Quote: \"Patients were randomly assigned into 3 groups by an independent research assistant who was ... | 33511201 | Yen 2021 | {
"1": "low",
"2": "low",
"3": "high",
"4": "low",
"5": "unclear"
} | {
"1": {
"label": "low",
"source_keys": [
"Domain1：Random sequence generation (selection bias)"
],
"thinking_labels": [
"Quote: \"Patients were randomly assigned into 3 groups by an independent research assistant who was not taking part in the study via a computer‐generated simple randomiz... | 5 | [] | false |
rob_sr | [
{
"content": "\n**Role:** You are a meta-analysis expert. Your task is to perform a Risk of Bias assessment for a study based on the provided full-text and the Cochrane Risk of Bias 1.0 (RoB 1) tool criteria.\n\n**Inputs:**\n\n1. **Full text**: ## Abstract\n\nThe aim of this study was to investigate whether dee... | rob_assessment | {
"ground_truth": {
"domain_info": {
"1": {
"label": "low",
"source_keys": [
"Domain1：Random sequence generation (selection bias)"
],
"thinking_labels": [
"Computer‐generated random sequence."
]
},
"2": {
"label": "low",
... | 34768608 | Koo 2021 | {
"1": "low",
"2": "low",
"3": "low",
"4": "low",
"5": "unclear"
} | {
"1": {
"label": "low",
"source_keys": [
"Domain1：Random sequence generation (selection bias)"
],
"thinking_labels": [
"Computer‐generated random sequence."
]
},
"2": {
"label": "low",
"source_keys": [
"Domain2：Allocation concealment (selection bias)"
],
"thi... | 5 | [] | false |
rob_sr | [
{
"content": "\n**Role:** You are a meta-analysis expert. Your task is to perform a Risk of Bias assessment for a study based on the provided full-text and the Cochrane Risk of Bias 1.0 (RoB 1) tool criteria.\n\n**Inputs:**\n\n1. **Full text**: # Effects of eccentric training on hand strength in subjects with l... | rob_assessment | {
"ground_truth": {
"domain_info": {
"1": {
"label": "low",
"source_keys": [
"Domain1：Random sequence generation (selection bias)"
],
"thinking_labels": [
"A randomised block design was used with stratification for duration of elbow pain and whether the pa... | 21496112 | Soderberg 2012 | {
"1": "low",
"2": "low",
"3": "high",
"4": "high",
"5": "low"
} | {
"1": {
"label": "low",
"source_keys": [
"Domain1：Random sequence generation (selection bias)"
],
"thinking_labels": [
"A randomised block design was used with stratification for duration of elbow pain and whether the participant was referred from a medical caregiver."
]
},
"2": {... | 5 | [] | false |
rob_sr | [
{
"content": "\n**Role:** You are a meta-analysis expert. Your task is to perform a Risk of Bias assessment for a study based on the provided full-text and the Cochrane Risk of Bias 1.0 (RoB 1) tool criteria.\n\n**Inputs:**\n\n1. **Full text**: # Vaginal hysterectomy versus laparoscopically assisted vaginal hys... | rob_assessment | {
"ground_truth": {
"domain_info": {
"1": {
"label": "low",
"source_keys": [
"Domain1：Random sequence generation (selection bias)"
],
"thinking_labels": [
"The randomisation procedure was based on a computer‐generated list"
]
},
"2": {
... | 28508344 | Mohammed 2017 | {
"1": "low",
"2": "low",
"3": null,
"4": "high",
"5": "low"
} | {
"1": {
"label": "low",
"source_keys": [
"Domain1：Random sequence generation (selection bias)"
],
"thinking_labels": [
"The randomisation procedure was based on a computer‐generated list"
]
},
"2": {
"label": "low",
"source_keys": [
"Domain2：Allocation concealment (s... | 4 | [
3
] | false |
rob_sr | [
{
"content": "\n**Role:** You are a meta-analysis expert. Your task is to perform a Risk of Bias assessment for a study based on the provided full-text and the Cochrane Risk of Bias 1.0 (RoB 1) tool criteria.\n\n**Inputs:**\n\n1. **Full text**: ## A Prospective Randomized Comparative Study of Vaginal,\n\n**Risk... | rob_assessment | {
"ground_truth": {
"domain_info": {
"1": {
"label": "unclear",
"source_keys": [
"Domain1：Random sequence generation (selection bias)"
],
"thinking_labels": [
"No information provided about type randomisation"
]
},
"2": {
"label... | 27651635 | Nanavati 2016 | {
"1": "unclear",
"2": "unclear",
"3": null,
"4": "high",
"5": "unclear"
} | {
"1": {
"label": "unclear",
"source_keys": [
"Domain1：Random sequence generation (selection bias)"
],
"thinking_labels": [
"No information provided about type randomisation"
]
},
"2": {
"label": "unclear",
"source_keys": [
"Domain2：Allocation concealment (selection b... | 4 | [
3
] | false |
rob_sr | [
{
"content": "\n**Role:** You are a meta-analysis expert. Your task is to perform a Risk of Bias assessment for a study based on the provided full-text and the Cochrane Risk of Bias 1.0 (RoB 1) tool criteria.\n\n**Inputs:**\n\n1. **Full text**: # The effects of an early developmental mother–child intervention p... | rob_assessment | {
"ground_truth": {
"domain_info": {
"1": {
"label": "unclear",
"source_keys": [
"Domain1：Random sequence generation (selection bias)"
],
"thinking_labels": [
"Unclear: infants randomly assigned into 2 groups matched for GA; no other information given"
... | 16530990 | Gianni 2006 | {
"1": "unclear",
"2": "unclear",
"3": "high",
"4": "low",
"5": "unclear"
} | {
"1": {
"label": "unclear",
"source_keys": [
"Domain1：Random sequence generation (selection bias)"
],
"thinking_labels": [
"Unclear: infants randomly assigned into 2 groups matched for GA; no other information given"
]
},
"2": {
"label": "unclear",
"source_keys": [
"... | 5 | [] | false |
rob_sr | [
{
"content": "\n**Role:** You are a meta-analysis expert. Your task is to perform a Risk of Bias assessment for a study based on the provided full-text and the Cochrane Risk of Bias 1.0 (RoB 1) tool criteria.\n\n**Inputs:**\n\n1. **Full text**: ## Abstract\n\nObjective: This phase 3, laboratory classroom study ... | rob_assessment | {
"ground_truth": {
"domain_info": {
"1": {
"label": "low",
"source_keys": [
"Domain1：Random sequence generation (selection bias)"
],
"thinking_labels": [
"Comment: \"Subjects were randomly assigned (1:1) to receive either MPH ERCT, at their optimal open‐l... | 28557548 | Wigal 2017 | {
"1": "low",
"2": "low",
"3": "low",
"4": "low",
"5": "low"
} | {
"1": {
"label": "low",
"source_keys": [
"Domain1：Random sequence generation (selection bias)"
],
"thinking_labels": [
"Comment: \"Subjects were randomly assigned (1:1) to receive either MPH ERCT, at their optimal open‐label dose (20–60 mg/ day), or placebo daily for 1 week. Randomization... | 5 | [] | false |
rob_sr | [
{
"content": "\n**Role:** You are a meta-analysis expert. Your task is to perform a Risk of Bias assessment for a study based on the provided full-text and the Cochrane Risk of Bias 1.0 (RoB 1) tool criteria.\n\n**Inputs:**\n\n1. **Full text**: # A randomized, controlled trial of combined cognitive-behavioral t... | rob_assessment | {
"ground_truth": {
"domain_info": {
"1": {
"label": "low",
"source_keys": [
"Domain1：Random sequence generation (selection bias)"
],
"thinking_labels": [
"Quote: \"Patients were randomly assigned to one of the two treatment arms using computerized randomi... | 25456571 | Petitjean 2014 | {
"1": "low",
"2": "low",
"3": "high",
"4": "unclear",
"5": "low"
} | {
"1": {
"label": "low",
"source_keys": [
"Domain1：Random sequence generation (selection bias)"
],
"thinking_labels": [
"Quote: \"Patients were randomly assigned to one of the two treatment arms using computerized randomization\""
]
},
"2": {
"label": "low",
"source_keys": ... | 5 | [] | false |
rob_sr | [
{
"content": "\n**Role:** You are a meta-analysis expert. Your task is to perform a Risk of Bias assessment for a study based on the provided full-text and the Cochrane Risk of Bias 1.0 (RoB 1) tool criteria.\n\n**Inputs:**\n\n1. **Full text**: # A double-blind placebo controlled randomised trial of misoprostol... | rob_assessment | {
"ground_truth": {
"domain_info": {
"1": {
"label": "low",
"source_keys": [
"Domain1：Random sequence generation (selection bias)"
],
"thinking_labels": [
"Computer-generated random numbers."
]
},
"2": {
"label": "low",
... | 11002954 | Walley 2000 | {
"1": "low",
"2": "low",
"3": "low",
"4": "high",
"5": "low"
} | {
"1": {
"label": "low",
"source_keys": [
"Domain1：Random sequence generation (selection bias)"
],
"thinking_labels": [
"Computer-generated random numbers."
]
},
"2": {
"label": "low",
"source_keys": [
"Domain2：Allocation concealment (selection bias)"
],
"thin... | 5 | [] | false |
rob_sr | [
{
"content": "\n**Role:** You are a meta-analysis expert. Your task is to perform a Risk of Bias assessment for a study based on the provided full-text and the Cochrane Risk of Bias 1.0 (RoB 1) tool criteria.\n\n**Inputs:**\n\n1. **Full text**: Article\nA randomized controlled trial of\nthe effects of muscle st... | rob_assessment | {
"ground_truth": {
"domain_info": {
"1": {
"label": "low",
"source_keys": [
"Domain1：Random sequence generation (selection bias)",
"Domain1：Group similarity at baseline"
],
"thinking_labels": [
"Quote: \"[...] group assignments derived from a ra... | 21831926 | Grunnesjö 2011 | {
"1": "low",
"2": "low",
"3": "high",
"4": "high",
"5": "low"
} | {
"1": {
"label": "low",
"source_keys": [
"Domain1：Random sequence generation (selection bias)",
"Domain1：Group similarity at baseline"
],
"thinking_labels": [
"Quote: \"[...] group assignments derived from a random table.\"",
"The study measured age, sex, BMI, cigarette smoker... | 5 | [] | false |
rob_sr | [
{
"content": "\n**Role:** You are a meta-analysis expert. Your task is to perform a Risk of Bias assessment for a study based on the provided full-text and the Cochrane Risk of Bias 1.0 (RoB 1) tool criteria.\n\n**Inputs:**\n\n1. **Full text**: \n\n**Risk of Bias Domains (Cochrane RoB 1.0):**\n\nPlease assess t... | rob_assessment | {
"ground_truth": {
"domain_info": {
"1": {
"label": "unclear",
"source_keys": [
"Domain1：Random sequence generation (selection bias)"
],
"thinking_labels": [
"Computer‐generated random numbers were used for randomisation. While assigning groups to envelop... | 23024529 | Chakraborty 2011 | {
"1": "unclear",
"2": "low",
"3": null,
"4": "high",
"5": "low"
} | {
"1": {
"label": "unclear",
"source_keys": [
"Domain1：Random sequence generation (selection bias)"
],
"thinking_labels": [
"Computer‐generated random numbers were used for randomisation. While assigning groups to envelopes, if the computer‐generated random number was odd, the assigned gro... | 4 | [
3
] | false |
rob_sr | [
{
"content": "\n**Role:** You are a meta-analysis expert. Your task is to perform a Risk of Bias assessment for a study based on the provided full-text and the Cochrane Risk of Bias 1.0 (RoB 1) tool criteria.\n\n**Inputs:**\n\n1. **Full text**: ## 2 Materials and methods\nThe study protocol was in accordance wi... | rob_assessment | {
"ground_truth": {
"domain_info": {
"1": {
"label": "unclear",
"source_keys": [
"Domain1：Random sequence generation (selection bias)"
],
"thinking_labels": [
"Method of randomisation not reported"
]
},
"2": {
"label": "low",
... | 16973256 | Baytur 2007 | {
"1": "unclear",
"2": "low",
"3": "unclear",
"4": "unclear",
"5": "low"
} | {
"1": {
"label": "unclear",
"source_keys": [
"Domain1：Random sequence generation (selection bias)"
],
"thinking_labels": [
"Method of randomisation not reported"
]
},
"2": {
"label": "low",
"source_keys": [
"Domain2：Allocation concealment (selection bias)"
],
... | 5 | [] | false |
rob_sr | [
{
"content": "\n**Role:** You are a meta-analysis expert. Your task is to perform a Risk of Bias assessment for a study based on the provided full-text and the Cochrane Risk of Bias 1.0 (RoB 1) tool criteria.\n\n**Inputs:**\n\n1. **Full text**: ## Treatment of Knee Osteoarthritis With Allogeneic\n\n## A Randomi... | rob_assessment | {
"ground_truth": {
"domain_info": {
"1": {
"label": "low",
"source_keys": [
"Domain1：Random sequence generation (selection bias)"
],
"thinking_labels": [
"Block randomisation in 1:1 ratio performed by the quality control manager of the cell production fac... | 25822648 | Vega 2015 | {
"1": "low",
"2": "unclear",
"3": "low",
"4": null,
"5": "low"
} | {
"1": {
"label": "low",
"source_keys": [
"Domain1：Random sequence generation (selection bias)"
],
"thinking_labels": [
"Block randomisation in 1:1 ratio performed by the quality control manager of the cell production facility, who was blinded; however, the method of random sequence genera... | 4 | [
4
] | false |
rob_sr | [
{
"content": "\n**Role:** You are a meta-analysis expert. Your task is to perform a Risk of Bias assessment for a study based on the provided full-text and the Cochrane Risk of Bias 1.0 (RoB 1) tool criteria.\n\n**Inputs:**\n\n1. **Full text**: # Efficacy of oral tranexamic acid on blood loss in primary total h... | rob_assessment | {
"ground_truth": {
"domain_info": {
"1": {
"label": "low",
"source_keys": [
"Domain1：Random sequence generation (selection bias)"
],
"thinking_labels": [
"Quote: \"Patients recruited into the study were randomized into three groups using a computer‐genera... | 29492612 | Zhao 2018 | {
"1": "low",
"2": "unclear",
"3": "low",
"4": "low",
"5": "low"
} | {
"1": {
"label": "low",
"source_keys": [
"Domain1：Random sequence generation (selection bias)"
],
"thinking_labels": [
"Quote: \"Patients recruited into the study were randomized into three groups using a computer‐generated randomization table at an allocation ratio of 1:1:1 with a maximu... | 5 | [] | false |
rob_sr | [
{
"content": "\n**Role:** You are a meta-analysis expert. Your task is to perform a Risk of Bias assessment for a study based on the provided full-text and the Cochrane Risk of Bias 1.0 (RoB 1) tool criteria.\n\n**Inputs:**\n\n1. **Full text**: ## Abstract\n\n### Methods\n\nA randomized controlled trial in term... | rob_assessment | {
"ground_truth": {
"domain_info": {
"1": {
"label": "low",
"source_keys": [
"Domain1：Random sequence generation (selection bias)"
],
"thinking_labels": [
"Participants are randomly assigned following simple randomisation procedure in 1 : 1 ratio to 1 of t... | 29484209 | Mannaerts 2018 | {
"1": "low",
"2": "unclear",
"3": "low",
"4": "unclear",
"5": "high"
} | {
"1": {
"label": "low",
"source_keys": [
"Domain1：Random sequence generation (selection bias)"
],
"thinking_labels": [
"Participants are randomly assigned following simple randomisation procedure in 1 : 1 ratio to 1 of the 2 treatment groups. A computer-generated randomisation list was ge... | 5 | [] | false |
rob_sr | [
{
"content": "\n**Role:** You are a meta-analysis expert. Your task is to perform a Risk of Bias assessment for a study based on the provided full-text and the Cochrane Risk of Bias 1.0 (RoB 1) tool criteria.\n\n**Inputs:**\n\n1. **Full text**: ## Perioperative Tight Glucose Control Reduces\n\n## Cardiac Surger... | rob_assessment | {
"ground_truth": {
"domain_info": {
"1": {
"label": "low",
"source_keys": [
"Domain1：Random sequence generation (selection bias)"
],
"thinking_labels": [
"\"(A) simple randomization procedure according to a computer‐generated list of random numbers was us... | 26079777 | Blaha 2015 | {
"1": "low",
"2": "unclear",
"3": "unclear",
"4": "low",
"5": "high"
} | {
"1": {
"label": "low",
"source_keys": [
"Domain1：Random sequence generation (selection bias)"
],
"thinking_labels": [
"\"(A) simple randomization procedure according to a computer‐generated list of random numbers was used.\""
]
},
"2": {
"label": "unclear",
"source_keys":... | 5 | [] | false |
rob_sr | [
{
"content": "\n**Role:** You are a meta-analysis expert. Your task is to perform a Risk of Bias assessment for a study based on the provided full-text and the Cochrane Risk of Bias 1.0 (RoB 1) tool criteria.\n\n**Inputs:**\n\n1. **Full text**: ## Abstract\n\nIntroduction : Our aim was to describe feasibility a... | rob_assessment | {
"ground_truth": {
"domain_info": {
"1": {
"label": "low",
"source_keys": [
"Domain1：Random sequence generation (selection bias)"
],
"thinking_labels": [
"“We randomized participants to either the intervention (n = 20) or the standard care (n = 20) group ... | 31738574 | Crenshaw 2019 | {
"1": "low",
"2": "low",
"3": "high",
"4": "high",
"5": "high"
} | {
"1": {
"label": "low",
"source_keys": [
"Domain1：Random sequence generation (selection bias)"
],
"thinking_labels": [
"“We randomized participants to either the intervention (n = 20) or the standard care (n = 20) group by mothers opening an envelope identifying their assigned group after... | 5 | [] | false |
rob_sr | [
{
"content": "\n**Role:** You are a meta-analysis expert. Your task is to perform a Risk of Bias assessment for a study based on the provided full-text and the Cochrane Risk of Bias 1.0 (RoB 1) tool criteria.\n\n**Inputs:**\n\n1. **Full text**: ## 2 Materials and methods\n### 2.1 Patient population\nAdult inpat... | rob_assessment | {
"ground_truth": {
"domain_info": {
"1": {
"label": "low",
"source_keys": [
"Domain1：Random sequence generation (selection bias)"
],
"thinking_labels": [
"Computer‐generated randomisation list"
]
},
"2": {
"label": "unclear",
... | 16039733 | CAFCIN 2006 | {
"1": "low",
"2": "unclear",
"3": "high",
"4": "low",
"5": "high"
} | {
"1": {
"label": "low",
"source_keys": [
"Domain1：Random sequence generation (selection bias)"
],
"thinking_labels": [
"Computer‐generated randomisation list"
]
},
"2": {
"label": "unclear",
"source_keys": [
"Domain2：Allocation concealment (selection bias)"
],
... | 5 | [] | false |
rob_sr | [
{
"content": "\n**Role:** You are a meta-analysis expert. Your task is to perform a Risk of Bias assessment for a study based on the provided full-text and the Cochrane Risk of Bias 1.0 (RoB 1) tool criteria.\n\n**Inputs:**\n\n1. **Full text**: ## Abstract\n\nAim: To assess the effectiveness of oral misoprostol... | rob_assessment | {
"ground_truth": {
"domain_info": {
"1": {
"label": "low",
"source_keys": [
"Domain1：Random sequence generation (selection bias)"
],
"thinking_labels": [
"Randomisation was by simple random selection. An independent statistician generated sets of 4 random... | 18001447 | Enakpene 2007 | {
"1": "low",
"2": "low",
"3": "unclear",
"4": "high",
"5": "low"
} | {
"1": {
"label": "low",
"source_keys": [
"Domain1：Random sequence generation (selection bias)"
],
"thinking_labels": [
"Randomisation was by simple random selection. An independent statistician generated sets of 4 random letters, which were in boxes, and each box contained 4 separate rand... | 5 | [] | false |
rob_sr | [
{
"content": "\n**Role:** You are a meta-analysis expert. Your task is to perform a Risk of Bias assessment for a study based on the provided full-text and the Cochrane Risk of Bias 1.0 (RoB 1) tool criteria.\n\n**Inputs:**\n\n1. **Full text**: # Treatment of Active Crohn's Disease With MLN0002, a Humanized Ant... | rob_assessment | {
"ground_truth": {
"domain_info": {
"1": {
"label": "unclear",
"source_keys": [
"Domain1：Random sequence generation (selection bias)"
],
"thinking_labels": [
"Process of random sequence generation not described. Contacted study authors by e‐mail but recei... | 18829392 | Feagan 2008 | {
"1": "unclear",
"2": "unclear",
"3": "low",
"4": "unclear",
"5": "low"
} | {
"1": {
"label": "unclear",
"source_keys": [
"Domain1：Random sequence generation (selection bias)"
],
"thinking_labels": [
"Process of random sequence generation not described. Contacted study authors by e‐mail but received no response."
]
},
"2": {
"label": "unclear",
"so... | 5 | [] | false |
rob_sr | [
{
"content": "\n**Role:** You are a meta-analysis expert. Your task is to perform a Risk of Bias assessment for a study based on the provided full-text and the Cochrane Risk of Bias 1.0 (RoB 1) tool criteria.\n\n**Inputs:**\n\n1. **Full text**: ## Maintenance Patients Through Voucher-Based\n\n### tingent interv... | rob_assessment | {
"ground_truth": {
"domain_info": {
"1": {
"label": "low",
"source_keys": [
"Domain1：Random sequence generation (selection bias)"
],
"thinking_labels": [
"Quote: \"[P]atients were randomly assigned to the abstinence reinforcement or control group using mi... | 8624184 | Silverman 1996 | {
"1": "low",
"2": "unclear",
"3": "high",
"4": "unclear",
"5": "low"
} | {
"1": {
"label": "low",
"source_keys": [
"Domain1：Random sequence generation (selection bias)"
],
"thinking_labels": [
"Quote: \"[P]atients were randomly assigned to the abstinence reinforcement or control group using minimum likelihood allocation. This procedure stratified patients accor... | 5 | [] | false |
rob_sr | [
{
"content": "\n**Role:** You are a meta-analysis expert. Your task is to perform a Risk of Bias assessment for a study based on the provided full-text and the Cochrane Risk of Bias 1.0 (RoB 1) tool criteria.\n\n**Inputs:**\n\n1. **Full text**: ## A Randomized Controlled Trial\n\n**Risk of Bias Domains (Cochran... | rob_assessment | {
"ground_truth": {
"domain_info": {
"1": {
"label": "low",
"source_keys": [
"Domain1：Random sequence generation (selection bias)"
],
"thinking_labels": [
"Computer-generated without any blocking or stratification."
]
},
"2": {
... | 12738151 | Caliskan 2003 | {
"1": "low",
"2": "low",
"3": "low",
"4": "low",
"5": "high"
} | {
"1": {
"label": "low",
"source_keys": [
"Domain1：Random sequence generation (selection bias)"
],
"thinking_labels": [
"Computer-generated without any blocking or stratification."
]
},
"2": {
"label": "low",
"source_keys": [
"Domain2：Allocation concealment (selection... | 5 | [] | false |
rob_sr | [
{
"content": "\n**Role:** You are a meta-analysis expert. Your task is to perform a Risk of Bias assessment for a study based on the provided full-text and the Cochrane Risk of Bias 1.0 (RoB 1) tool criteria.\n\n**Inputs:**\n\n1. **Full text**: ## Abstract\n\nMaintaining deep neuromuscular block during surgery ... | rob_assessment | {
"ground_truth": {
"domain_info": {
"1": {
"label": "low",
"source_keys": [
"Domain1：Random sequence generation (selection bias)"
],
"thinking_labels": [
"Computer‐generated random sequence."
]
},
"2": {
"label": "unclear",
... | 31455832 | Koo 2019 | {
"1": "low",
"2": "unclear",
"3": "unclear",
"4": "low",
"5": "low"
} | {
"1": {
"label": "low",
"source_keys": [
"Domain1：Random sequence generation (selection bias)"
],
"thinking_labels": [
"Computer‐generated random sequence."
]
},
"2": {
"label": "unclear",
"source_keys": [
"Domain2：Allocation concealment (selection bias)"
],
... | 5 | [] | false |
rob_sr | [
{
"content": "\n**Role:** You are a meta-analysis expert. Your task is to perform a Risk of Bias assessment for a study based on the provided full-text and the Cochrane Risk of Bias 1.0 (RoB 1) tool criteria.\n\n**Inputs:**\n\n1. **Full text**: ## Abstract\n\n### Methods\n\nTwelve-week, randomized 2X2, factoria... | rob_assessment | {
"ground_truth": {
"domain_info": {
"1": {
"label": "low",
"source_keys": [
"Domain1：Random sequence generation (selection bias)"
],
"thinking_labels": [
"Quote: \"A masked, computerized urn randomization program used in previous trials... was used to pro... | 29286595 | Carroll 2018 | {
"1": "low",
"2": "unclear",
"3": "high",
"4": "unclear",
"5": "low"
} | {
"1": {
"label": "low",
"source_keys": [
"Domain1：Random sequence generation (selection bias)"
],
"thinking_labels": [
"Quote: \"A masked, computerized urn randomization program used in previous trials... was used to produce equivalent group size and balance groups with respect to baselin... | 5 | [] | false |
rob_sr | [
{
"content": "\n**Role:** You are a meta-analysis expert. Your task is to perform a Risk of Bias assessment for a study based on the provided full-text and the Cochrane Risk of Bias 1.0 (RoB 1) tool criteria.\n\n**Inputs:**\n\n1. **Full text**: Eur J Clin Pharmacol (1994) 46:221-224\n\n## Pravastatin treatment ... | rob_assessment | {
"ground_truth": {
"domain_info": {
"1": {
"label": "unclear",
"source_keys": [
"Domain1：Random sequence generation (selection bias)"
],
"thinking_labels": [
"Method of randomization not reported"
]
},
"2": {
"label": "unclear"... | 8070502 | Zambon 1994 | {
"1": "unclear",
"2": "unclear",
"3": "low",
"4": "low",
"5": "low"
} | {
"1": {
"label": "unclear",
"source_keys": [
"Domain1：Random sequence generation (selection bias)"
],
"thinking_labels": [
"Method of randomization not reported"
]
},
"2": {
"label": "unclear",
"source_keys": [
"Domain2：Allocation concealment (selection bias)"
],... | 5 | [] | false |
rob_sr | [
{
"content": "\n**Role:** You are a meta-analysis expert. Your task is to perform a Risk of Bias assessment for a study based on the provided full-text and the Cochrane Risk of Bias 1.0 (RoB 1) tool criteria.\n\n**Inputs:**\n\n1. **Full text**: disease.\nN Engl\nJ Med\n1983;309:385-389.\n5. Kottke\nBA, Zinsmeis... | rob_assessment | {
"ground_truth": {
"domain_info": {
"1": {
"label": "unclear",
"source_keys": [
"Domain1：Random sequence generation (selection bias)"
],
"thinking_labels": [
"No information on method for sequence generation"
]
},
"2": {
"label... | 2178386 | Noc 1990 | {
"1": "unclear",
"2": "unclear",
"3": "high",
"4": "unclear",
"5": "low"
} | {
"1": {
"label": "unclear",
"source_keys": [
"Domain1：Random sequence generation (selection bias)"
],
"thinking_labels": [
"No information on method for sequence generation"
]
},
"2": {
"label": "unclear",
"source_keys": [
"Domain2：Allocation concealment (selection b... | 5 | [] | false |
rob_sr | [
{
"content": "\n**Role:** You are a meta-analysis expert. Your task is to perform a Risk of Bias assessment for a study based on the provided full-text and the Cochrane Risk of Bias 1.0 (RoB 1) tool criteria.\n\n**Inputs:**\n\n1. **Full text**: # Contingency management is effective across cocaine-dependent outp... | rob_assessment | {
"ground_truth": {
"domain_info": {
"1": {
"label": "low",
"source_keys": [
"Domain1：Random sequence generation (selection bias)"
],
"thinking_labels": [
"Quote: \"Computer‐generated randomization list\""
]
},
"2": {
"label": "... | 22999380 | Secades Villa 2013 | {
"1": "low",
"2": "unclear",
"3": "high",
"4": "unclear",
"5": "high"
} | {
"1": {
"label": "low",
"source_keys": [
"Domain1：Random sequence generation (selection bias)"
],
"thinking_labels": [
"Quote: \"Computer‐generated randomization list\""
]
},
"2": {
"label": "unclear",
"source_keys": [
"Domain2：Allocation concealment (selection bias)... | 5 | [] | false |
rob_sr | [
{
"content": "\n**Role:** You are a meta-analysis expert. Your task is to perform a Risk of Bias assessment for a study based on the provided full-text and the Cochrane Risk of Bias 1.0 (RoB 1) tool criteria.\n\n**Inputs:**\n\n1. **Full text**: ## Treatment of Elderly Patients With Hypercholesterolemia\n\n## RE... | rob_assessment | {
"ground_truth": {
"domain_info": {
"1": {
"label": "unclear",
"source_keys": [
"Domain1：Random sequence generation (selection bias)"
],
"thinking_labels": [
"Method of randomization not reported"
]
},
"2": {
"label": "unclear"... | 8017448 | Santinga 1994 | {
"1": "unclear",
"2": "unclear",
"3": "low",
"4": "unclear",
"5": "low"
} | {
"1": {
"label": "unclear",
"source_keys": [
"Domain1：Random sequence generation (selection bias)"
],
"thinking_labels": [
"Method of randomization not reported"
]
},
"2": {
"label": "unclear",
"source_keys": [
"Domain2：Allocation concealment (selection bias)"
],... | 5 | [] | false |
rob_sr | [
{
"content": "\n**Role:** You are a meta-analysis expert. Your task is to perform a Risk of Bias assessment for a study based on the provided full-text and the Cochrane Risk of Bias 1.0 (RoB 1) tool criteria.\n\n**Inputs:**\n\n1. **Full text**: # Long-Term Effects of a Group-Based High-Intensity Aerobic Interva... | rob_assessment | {
"ground_truth": {
"domain_info": {
"1": {
"label": "unclear",
"source_keys": [
"Domain1：Random sequence generation (selection bias)"
],
"thinking_labels": [
"\"computer‐generated table of random numbers\""
]
},
"2": {
"label":... | 18940296 | Nilsson 2008 | {
"1": "unclear",
"2": "unclear",
"3": "low",
"4": "low",
"5": "low"
} | {
"1": {
"label": "unclear",
"source_keys": [
"Domain1：Random sequence generation (selection bias)"
],
"thinking_labels": [
"\"computer‐generated table of random numbers\""
]
},
"2": {
"label": "unclear",
"source_keys": [
"Domain2：Allocation concealment (selection bia... | 5 | [] | false |
rob_sr | [
{
"content": "\n**Role:** You are a meta-analysis expert. Your task is to perform a Risk of Bias assessment for a study based on the provided full-text and the Cochrane Risk of Bias 1.0 (RoB 1) tool criteria.\n\n**Inputs:**\n\n1. **Full text**: ## Treatment of Hyperlipidemia in the Nephrotic Syndrome:\n\n### Th... | rob_assessment | {
"ground_truth": {
"domain_info": {
"1": {
"label": "unclear",
"source_keys": [
"Domain1：Random sequence generation (selection bias)"
],
"thinking_labels": [
"Method of random sequence generation was not reported."
]
},
"2": {
... | 8322777 | Spitalewitz 1993 | {
"1": "unclear",
"2": "unclear",
"3": "low",
"4": "low",
"5": "low"
} | {
"1": {
"label": "unclear",
"source_keys": [
"Domain1：Random sequence generation (selection bias)"
],
"thinking_labels": [
"Method of random sequence generation was not reported."
]
},
"2": {
"label": "unclear",
"source_keys": [
"Domain2：Allocation concealment (selec... | 5 | [] | false |
rob_sr | [
{
"content": "\n**Role:** You are a meta-analysis expert. Your task is to perform a Risk of Bias assessment for a study based on the provided full-text and the Cochrane Risk of Bias 1.0 (RoB 1) tool criteria.\n\n**Inputs:**\n\n1. **Full text**: ## patients with symptomatic coronary artery disease\n\nJeffrey L. ... | rob_assessment | {
"ground_truth": {
"domain_info": {
"1": {
"label": "low",
"source_keys": [
"Domain1：Random sequence generation (selection bias)"
],
"thinking_labels": [
"A computer program generated the allocation sequence, implementing a permuted block randomisation pr... | 23708168 | Carson 2013 (MINT pilot) | {
"1": "low",
"2": "low",
"3": "low",
"4": "low",
"5": "low"
} | {
"1": {
"label": "low",
"source_keys": [
"Domain1：Random sequence generation (selection bias)"
],
"thinking_labels": [
"A computer program generated the allocation sequence, implementing a permuted block randomisation process stratified by clinical site and clinical diagnosis."
]
},... | 5 | [] | false |
Subsets and Splits
No community queries yet
The top public SQL queries from the community will appear here once available.