harshildarji commited on
Commit
c7ae48b
·
1 Parent(s): 833d81a

update extraction process

Browse files
Files changed (2) hide show
  1. README.md +1 -1
  2. problematic_case_slugs.txt +0 -677
README.md CHANGED
@@ -30,7 +30,7 @@ configs:
30
 
31
  ## Overview
32
 
33
- This dataset is a comprehensive collection of open legal case records in JSONL format. It comprises **251,038** cases extracted and processed from the [Open Legal Data dump](https://static.openlegaldata.io/dumps/de/2022-10-18/) (as of _2022-10-18_). The dataset is designed for legal research, data science, and natural language processing applications. While the majority of entries (especially _tenor_, _tatbestand_, _gründe_, and _entscheidungsgründe_) have been carefully separated and extracted, approximately **677** (**0.27%** of total) cases have been flagged as "_messy_" due to extraction or formatting issues. These messy entries are included for full transparency, and their "_slug_" IDs are available in [`problematic_case_slugs.txt`](https://huggingface.co/datasets/harshildarji/openlegaldata/blob/main/problematic_case_slugs.txt) so users can decide whether to filter them out or work with them. In references, law references and case references are also separated, as shown in the [example entry](#example-entry).
34
 
35
  ## Dataset Structure
36
 
 
30
 
31
  ## Overview
32
 
33
+ This dataset is a comprehensive collection of open legal case records in JSONL format. It comprises **251,038** cases extracted and processed from the [Open Legal Data dump](https://static.openlegaldata.io/dumps/de/2022-10-18/) (as of _2022-10-18_). The dataset is designed for legal research, data science, and natural language processing applications. Each decision is segmented into three main sections of judicial writing: _Tenor_, _Tatbestand_, and _Entscheidungsgründe_. In addition, the _Rechtsmittelbelehrung_ is extracted as a separate field, since it is part of the published decision but not considered a substantive section of it. In references, law references and case references are also separated, as shown in the [example entry](#example-entry).
34
 
35
  ## Dataset Structure
36
 
problematic_case_slugs.txt DELETED
@@ -1,677 +0,0 @@
1
- ag-aachen-2004-11-25-8-c-47104
2
- ag-altena-2000-04-03-8-c-f-11099
3
- ag-bielefeld-2002-06-05-42-c-95501
4
- ag-bielefeld-2006-05-31-17-c-33406
5
- ag-blomberg-2006-03-23-4-c-27105
6
- ag-bocholt-2014-03-13-11-c-10112
7
- ag-bocholt-2015-06-24-4-c-4815
8
- ag-bonn-2000-03-17-6-c-64099
9
- ag-bonn-2002-10-30-9-c-38202
10
- ag-bonn-2005-02-24-9-c-68304
11
- ag-borken-2000-12-06-15-c-29300
12
- ag-bruhl-2009-06-30-21-c-11509
13
- ag-coesfeld-2008-08-05-12-f-20207
14
- ag-dortmund-2004-09-22-174-f-22604
15
- ag-dortmund-2005-01-17-170-f-375803
16
- ag-dortmund-2005-11-04-175-f-25205
17
- ag-dortmund-2011-06-21-405-c-191311
18
- ag-duisburg-2004-02-04-35-c-472203
19
- ag-dusseldorf-2002-05-29-31-c-1465801
20
- ag-dusseldorf-2002-11-27-31-c-1133402
21
- ag-dusseldorf-2003-05-26-37-c-1567202
22
- ag-dusseldorf-2003-12-12-31-c-1406003
23
- ag-dusseldorf-2006-02-24-31-c-1319205
24
- ag-dusseldorf-2006-03-24-31-c-1541505
25
- ag-dusseldorf-2007-04-27-31-c-1681306
26
- ag-dusseldorf-2007-06-01-31-c-331707
27
- ag-dusseldorf-2007-10-30-23-c-247907
28
- ag-dusseldorf-2008-01-17-36-c-1299307
29
- ag-dusseldorf-2014-04-18-28-c-1657913
30
- ag-dusseldorf-2014-12-16-42-c-958414
31
- ag-essen-1983-01-10-105-f-4982
32
- ag-essen-2000-12-12-24-c-15600
33
- ag-essen-2001-02-13-132-c-39700
34
- ag-essen-2002-07-15-11-c-25501
35
- ag-essen-2008-06-04-106-f-22705
36
- ag-euskirchen-2016-08-30-27-c-12516
37
- ag-geldern-2002-03-22-17-c-56701
38
- ag-hamm-2016-06-28-17-c-3316
39
- ag-herne-2006-05-29-18-c-23906
40
- ag-herne-2013-07-11-20-c-6713
41
- ag-koln-1986-09-17-315-f-10685
42
- ag-koln-2002-01-11-266-c-53400
43
- ag-koln-2004-11-02-266-c-35404
44
- ag-koln-2005-03-15-264-c-50204
45
- ag-koln-2005-11-24-266-c-55804
46
- ag-koln-2010-04-27-124-c-8110
47
- ag-koln-2013-03-26-272-c-1613
48
- ag-koln-2014-11-07-71-ik-714
49
- ag-koln-2015-09-01-146-c-17714
50
- ag-koln-2016-03-29-138-c-58415
51
- ag-koln-2016-05-31-268-c-6316
52
- ag-konigswinter-2001-10-31-9-c-3701
53
- ag-krefeld-2013-07-02-29-xiv-7613-b
54
- ag-krefeld-2014-08-20-29-xiv-b-4814
55
- ag-krefeld-2014-10-20-1-c-35014
56
- ag-langenfeld-2013-10-02-34-c-15413
57
- ag-lemgo-2007-11-15-18-c-35307
58
- ag-leverkusen-2005-04-20-33-f-14104
59
- ag-ludenscheid-2005-06-08-5-f-5605
60
- ag-ludwigslust-2009-11-19-5-f-28309
61
- ag-monchengladbach-2008-08-26-5-c-26008
62
- ag-munster-2005-12-21-59-c-260105
63
- ag-munster-2007-11-05-9-l-406
64
- ag-nettetal-2004-06-09-19-c-9104
65
- ag-nettetal-2005-02-24-19-c-33904
66
- ag-ratingen-1999-04-15-9-c-23297
67
- ag-rheda-wiedenbruck-2002-02-07-11-c-29601
68
- ag-siegburg-2003-02-12-33a-f-102
69
- ag-siegburg-2005-11-16-117-c-20105
70
- ag-stuttgart-2005-04-27-10-xvii-8903
71
- ag-viersen-2009-06-30-32-c-29008
72
- ag-warendorf-2002-07-16-9-f-24401
73
- ag-witten-2005-02-17-2-c-171304
74
- ag-witten-2005-06-23-2-c-36305
75
- ag-witten-2008-09-19-2-c-81308
76
- arbg-dortmund-2006-04-28-1-ga-3306
77
- arbg-dusseldorf-2008-06-12-6-bv-5808
78
- arbg-karlsruhe-2003-07-22-6-bvga-203
79
- arbg-kiel-2006-02-16-o-d-1-ca-2271-c05
80
- arbg-schwerin-2008-05-22-6-ca-221807
81
- arbg-stuttgart-2013-04-04-9-ca-38812
82
- awghnrw-2013-09-27-1-agh-1113
83
- bag-2010-08-31-3-abr-13909
84
- bag-2011-09-15-8-azr-78110-f
85
- bag-2014-04-08-9-azr-55012
86
- bag-2017-03-23-8-azr-54315
87
- bag-2017-03-23-8-azr-8915
88
- bag-2017-03-23-8-azr-9015
89
- bag-2017-03-23-8-azr-9115
90
- bfh-2010-09-30-iii-r-3908
91
- bfh-2011-05-04-i-r-6710
92
- bfh-2011-11-07-iii-b-5310
93
- bfh-2011-12-14-i-r-9210
94
- bfh-2013-03-25-i-b-2612
95
- bfh-2015-01-28-x-b-10314
96
- bfh-2017-06-14-x-b-11816
97
- bgh-2017-08-31-4-str-29417
98
- bgh-2018-06-14-iii-zr-5417
99
- eugh-2013-05-08-c-27112
100
- eugh-2014-03-27-c-26513
101
- eugh-2014-09-11-c-52712
102
- eugh-2015-10-22-c-27714
103
- eugh-2015-12-23-c-25014c-28914
104
- eugh-2018-06-27-c-45917c-46017
105
- fg-baden-wurttemberg-2014-04-28-13-k-189413
106
- fg-dusseldorf-2002-11-07-11-k-498199-bg
107
- fg-dusseldorf-2003-05-14-16-k-174601-invao
108
- fg-dusseldorf-2003-07-31-11-k-737601-e
109
- fg-dusseldorf-2005-10-17-11-k-561604-e
110
- fg-dusseldorf-2005-10-17-11-k-561704-e
111
- fg-dusseldorf-2008-12-18-11-k-8707-e
112
- fg-hamburg-2014-02-18-4-k-15012
113
- fg-koln-2003-05-27-8-k-744400
114
- fg-koln-2012-08-28-7-k-178011
115
- fg-koln-2015-09-30-3-k-70612
116
- fg-munster-2000-12-07-14-k-312799-e
117
- fg-munster-2002-09-02-4-k-270500-ef
118
- fg-munster-2003-10-07-15-k-616602-uf
119
- fg-munster-2003-12-09-15-k-42499-f
120
- fg-munster-2012-09-19-10-k-207912-f
121
- fg-munster-2013-07-16-2-k-208710-f
122
- fg-munster-2014-10-01-9-k-416910-kf
123
- fg-niedersachsisches-2010-03-02-16-k-38109
124
- lagd-1997-01-07-8-18-sa-158696
125
- lagham-2007-08-30-15-sa-104907
126
- lagham-2011-04-15-13-sa-11611
127
- lagham-2015-02-05-12-ta-56114
128
- lagk-1983-02-02-5-sa-112282
129
- lagk-1986-04-10-8-sa-133885
130
- lagk-1989-05-31-21-sa-8389
131
- lagk-2003-05-22-10-sa-97002
132
- lagk-2006-03-21-9-sa-145005
133
- lagk-2011-03-15-12-tabv-7410
134
- lagmv-2020-08-26-3-sa-7620
135
- lagni-2004-11-23-13-sa-38504
136
- lagni-2006-11-08-17-sa-79606
137
- lagni-2006-11-08-17-sa-90306
138
- lagrlp-1999-09-21-2-tabv-1199
139
- lagrlp-2003-09-25-6-sa-57803
140
- lagrlp-2004-08-25-7-ta-1604
141
- lagrlp-2006-02-20-4-ta-2106
142
- lagrlp-2009-12-15-3-tabv-3209
143
- lagrlp-2010-07-08-5-sa-21010
144
- lagrlp-2011-11-29-11-ta-25411
145
- lagrlp-2012-02-13-1-ta-312
146
- lagst-2015-11-24-6-sa-24814
147
- larbgsh-2005-02-08-5-sa-43504
148
- lg-aachen-2002-08-21-4-o-23902
149
- lg-arnsberg-2015-02-24-5-t-3215
150
- lg-aurich-2006-12-15-4-o-20806
151
- lg-bielefeld-2006-03-14-6-o-61004
152
- lg-bielefeld-2008-03-27-8-o-13706
153
- lg-bielefeld-2016-08-26-7-o-27315
154
- lg-bochum-2012-11-27-17-o-10010
155
- lg-bochum-2014-10-28-6-kls-47-js-17614-4
156
- lg-bonn-2011-10-21-18-o-32711
157
- lg-bonn-2012-02-13-27-qs-410-js-51110-
158
- lg-bonn-2013-06-11-22-kls-664-js-445
159
- lg-bonn-2013-09-04-22-kls-664-js-40013
160
- lg-bonn-2020-09-02-9-o-39617
161
- lg-dortmund-2010-04-06-9-t-14110
162
- lg-dortmund-2010-04-20-9-t-10810
163
- lg-dortmund-2012-03-28-2-o-14410
164
- lg-duisburg-1979-02-13-13-7-s-36078
165
- lg-duisburg-1979-02-13-7-s-36078
166
- lg-duisburg-2011-09-27-22-o-8509
167
- lg-duisburg-2012-08-22-38-ns-115-js-25109-
168
- lg-dusseldorf-2001-03-15-4-o-35799
169
- lg-dusseldorf-2002-02-14-4-o-15700
170
- lg-dusseldorf-2002-08-01-4-o-27901
171
- lg-dusseldorf-2003-01-10-13_o_306_00
172
- lg-dusseldorf-2003-09-19-20-s-3603
173
- lg-dusseldorf-2004-01-29-4a-o-21503
174
- lg-dusseldorf-2005-01-20-4b-o-51703
175
- lg-dusseldorf-2005-05-06-20-s-605
176
- lg-dusseldorf-2006-04-06-4a-o-58105
177
- lg-dusseldorf-2007-01-12-12-o-34502
178
- lg-dusseldorf-2007-01-23-4a-o-52105
179
- lg-dusseldorf-2007-03-22-4a-o-56305
180
- lg-dusseldorf-2007-05-30-34-o-3507
181
- lg-dusseldorf-2009-02-17-4a-o-24808
182
- lg-dusseldorf-2011-01-10-7-o-19309
183
- lg-dusseldorf-2012-04-12-4a-o-1712-u
184
- lg-dusseldorf-2012-07-26-4a-o-2111-u
185
- lg-dusseldorf-2013-03-19-3-o-14212
186
- lg-dusseldorf-2014-12-17-2b-o-16713
187
- lg-dusseldorf-2015-05-08-2b-o-28313
188
- lg-dusseldorf-2020-11-03-10-o-38319
189
- lg-essen-1981-01-14-1-s-57080
190
- lg-essen-1989-05-11-4-o-7389
191
- lg-essen-2004-11-24-44-o-3204
192
- lg-essen-2005-06-09-43-o-2005
193
- lg-essen-2005-11-21-44-o-16104
194
- lg-essen-2005-11-29-12-o-9205
195
- lg-essen-2006-02-10-45-o-8805
196
- lg-essen-2006-12-20-41-o-9106
197
- lg-essen-2006-12-20-44-o-18606
198
- lg-essen-2007-06-29-45-o-1507
199
- lg-essen-2007-09-17-41-o-4505
200
- lg-essen-2007-11-20-12-o-37505
201
- lg-essen-2012-04-25-4-o-16308
202
- lg-essen-2012-11-28-44-o-2312
203
- lg-essen-2014-06-06-7-t-14214
204
- lg-hamburg-2018-11-16-412-hko-15917
205
- lg-hannover-2008-11-27-21-o-5208
206
- lg-hannover-2008-11-27-21-o-6108
207
- lg-karlsruhe-2005-01-25-2-o-204
208
- lg-kleve-2012-08-15-7-o-810
209
- lg-koln-2002-01-10-15-o-23701
210
- lg-koln-2002-05-15-23-s-7601
211
- lg-koln-2003-08-20-23-o-5702
212
- lg-koln-2003-10-08-23-s-4803
213
- lg-koln-2008-10-13-1-t-25008
214
- lg-koln-2010-03-24-1-t-10210
215
- lg-koln-2011-08-30-5-o-29910
216
- lg-koln-2012-02-23-14-o-910
217
- lg-koln-2013-03-20-23-o-2113
218
- lg-koln-2014-07-23-86-o-414
219
- lg-koln-2015-07-09-116-kls-212
220
- lg-koln-2022-02-11-5-o-31319
221
- lg-krefeld-1988-10-26-2-s-1388
222
- lg-krefeld-1990-09-12-2-s-2290
223
- lg-krefeld-1990-09-12-2-s-4390
224
- lg-monchengladbach-2002-06-27-10-o-58797
225
- lg-monchengladbach-2008-04-29-3-o-24807
226
- lg-munster-2005-02-28-2-o-83104
227
- lg-munster-2005-04-05-11-o-4504
228
- lg-munster-2005-06-23-12-o-64104
229
- lg-munster-2020-07-23-5-oh-620
230
- lg-wuppertal-2007-08-10-6-t-50805
231
- lg-wuppertal-2015-01-05-9-t-215
232
- lg-wuppertal-2016-02-03-25-ks-45-js-2315-7
233
- lsgnihb-2022-03-02-l-9-as-30117-b
234
- lsgnrw-2000-03-15-l-14-ra-3299
235
- lsgnrw-2000-03-23-l-11-ka-12398
236
- lsgnrw-2002-01-23-l-10-sb-14501
237
- lsgnrw-2004-03-03-l-12-al-12703
238
- lsgnrw-2006-12-04-l-16-b-3906-kr
239
- lsgnrw-2006-12-13-l-20-b-14006-as
240
- lsgnrw-2007-01-16-l-16-b-7906-kr-er
241
- lsgnrw-2007-02-12-l-16-b-706-sf
242
- lsgnrw-2007-02-28-l-16-b-107-sf
243
- lsgnrw-2007-03-05-l-16-b-307-sf
244
- lsgnrw-2007-04-19-l-16-b-907-kr
245
- lsgnrw-2007-07-26-l-16-kr-1105
246
- lsgnrw-2007-10-01-l-16-b-1207-kr
247
- lsgnrw-2007-11-27-l-16-b-3807-kr
248
- lsgnrw-2008-02-05-l-16-b-407-r
249
- lsgnrw-2008-02-26-l-16-b-708-kr
250
- lsgnrw-2008-03-03-l-16-b-3707-kr
251
- lsgnrw-2008-03-17-l-16-b-408-r
252
- lsgnrw-2008-04-30-l-16-b-507-r
253
- lsgnrw-2008-04-30-l-16-b-808-kr
254
- lsgnrw-2008-05-07-l-16-b-1808-kr
255
- lsgnrw-2008-06-26-l-16-b-3308-kr
256
- lsgnrw-2008-07-03-l-16-b-3108-kr
257
- lsgnrw-2008-09-02-l-16-b-4308-kr
258
- lsgnrw-2008-10-16-l-16-b-6008-kr
259
- lsgnrw-2008-10-31-l-16-b-1208-sf
260
- lsgnrw-2008-11-24-l-16-b-5708-kr
261
- lsgnrw-2008-12-11-l-16-b-3708-kr
262
- lsgnrw-2009-01-13-l-16-b-7808-kr
263
- lsgnrw-2009-01-13-l-16-b-8508-kr
264
- lsgnrw-2009-01-27-l-16-b-1308-r
265
- lsgnrw-2009-01-27-l-16-b-2408-r
266
- lsgnrw-2009-01-30-l-16-ar-408
267
- lsgnrw-2009-05-14-l-16-b-309-sv
268
- lsgnrw-2009-11-09-l-16-b-709-sv
269
- lsgnrw-2009-11-30-l-16-b-1009-sv
270
- lsgnrw-2010-02-16-l-4-b-1309
271
- lsgnrw-2010-04-14-l-12-al-7310-b
272
- lsgnrw-2010-04-26-l-16-b-909-sv
273
- lsgnrw-2010-04-28-l-8-r-3009
274
- lsgnrw-2011-09-26-l-3-r-25111
275
- lsgnrw-2012-01-11-l-19-as-197511-b
276
- lsgnrw-2015-05-06-l-11-ka-1014-b-er
277
- lsgnrw-2016-06-29-l-11-ka-415
278
- lsgnrw-2016-06-29-l-11-ka-515
279
- lsgrlp-2010-09-30-l-1-al-12209
280
- lsgst-2010-06-16-l-5-as-21710
281
- lsgst-2017-01-19-l-2-as-64014
282
- olgbs-2005-11-30-3-u-2103
283
- olgbs-2014-10-22-1-ar-ausl-614
284
- olgd-2001-12-19-vi-kart-2100-v
285
- olgd-2002-10-31-i-2-u-9199
286
- olgd-2004-02-04-vi-kart-2602-v
287
- olgd-2004-02-11-vi-kart-403-v
288
- olgd-2004-10-27-vi-kart-704-v
289
- olgd-2004-11-17-vi-kart-1304-v
290
- olgd-2004-11-24-vi-2-kart-1004-v
291
- olgd-2006-03-20-vi-3-kart-15506-v
292
- olgd-2006-03-20-vi-3-kart-15606-v
293
- olgd-2006-03-20-vi-3-kart-15906-v
294
- olgd-2006-03-20-vi-3-kart-16006-v
295
- olgd-2006-06-28-vi-3-kart-15106-v
296
- olgd-2006-06-28-vi-3-kart-15206-v
297
- olgd-2006-06-28-vi-3-kart-15306-v
298
- olgd-2006-08-14-i-1-u-22405
299
- olgd-2007-03-14-vi-kart-506-v
300
- olgd-2008-11-10-iii-4-ws-590-08
301
- olgd-2009-06-16-i-24-u-16908
302
- olgd-2010-12-16-i-2-u-7902
303
- olgd-2011-07-14-i-2-u-2605
304
- olgd-2011-10-13-i-2-u-7210
305
- olgd-2011-10-27-i-2-u-6410
306
- olgd-2012-01-19-i-2-u-12310
307
- olgd-2012-01-19-i-2-u-12410
308
- olgd-2012-04-26-i-2-u-13110
309
- olgd-2012-07-24-i-20-w-14111
310
- olgd-2014-09-19-ii-2-uf-9514
311
- olgd-2016-02-25-i-15-u-13714
312
- olgham-1998-05-27-20-u-24797
313
- olgham-1998-11-20-13-uf-18998
314
- olgham-1998-11-30-8-uf-24898
315
- olgham-1999-02-15-26-u-598
316
- olgham-1999-03-18-18-u-8498
317
- olgham-1999-05-19-20-u-199
318
- olgham-1999-07-23-20-u-4899
319
- olgham-1999-08-25-20-u-7299
320
- olgham-2000-06-09-9-u-22699
321
- olgham-2000-09-15-20-u-22399
322
- olgham-2000-09-22-9-u-21099
323
- olgham-2000-10-17-9-u-8300
324
- olgham-2001-02-23-20-u-12500
325
- olgham-2002-01-25-9-u-6201
326
- olgham-2002-03-21-4-uf-18001
327
- olgham-2002-05-29-30-u-21601
328
- olgham-2003-07-21-13-u-18500
329
- olgham-2004-02-09-13-u-22401
330
- olgham-2004-03-03-13-u-18303
331
- olgham-2005-02-21-13-u-2504
332
- olgham-2005-06-15-13-u-6305
333
- olgham-2005-06-27-13-u-19304
334
- olgham-2005-10-06-27-u-19504
335
- olgham-2005-10-10-13-u-5205
336
- olgham-2014-03-11-15-w-31613
337
- olgham-2020-11-20-7-uf-14220
338
- olgk-1987-01-14-2-u-6986
339
- olgk-1999-03-30-22-u-4897
340
- olgk-2004-05-26-2-u-3904
341
- olgk-2005-11-04-2-ws-51705
342
- olgk-2011-03-30-13-u-9110
343
- olgk-2012-03-14-6-w-4212
344
- olgk-2014-02-25-2-wx-3814
345
- olgk-2015-07-30-3-u-4615
346
- olgkarl-2013-08-12-6-w-5613
347
- olgkobl-2009-01-28-1-verg-508
348
- olgsh-2020-02-17-16-u-4319
349
- olgstut-2007-10-11-8-w-35307
350
- ovghh-2017-07-03-4-bs-14117
351
- ovgmv-2015-09-23-3-l-21510
352
- ovgnrw-1989-12-20-3-a-200786
353
- ovgnrw-1995-09-13-21-a-227391
354
- ovgnrw-1996-04-25-7-a-395992
355
- ovgnrw-1996-05-02-7-a-337893
356
- ovgnrw-1996-06-12-16-a-102096
357
- ovgnrw-1996-08-09-2-a-420093
358
- ovgnrw-1996-10-09-25-a-154196
359
- ovgnrw-1996-10-24-22-a-341594
360
- ovgnrw-1996-11-29-25-a-211296
361
- ovgnrw-1997-01-23-22-a-245596
362
- ovgnrw-1997-02-12-17-a-546494
363
- ovgnrw-1997-03-26-2-a-513994
364
- ovgnrw-1997-03-27-2-a-487594
365
- ovgnrw-1997-04-21-3-a-350892
366
- ovgnrw-1997-04-28-2-a-94694
367
- ovgnrw-1997-05-06-25-a-492694
368
- ovgnrw-1997-09-12-22-a-577996
369
- ovgnrw-1997-09-23-25-a-528294
370
- ovgnrw-1997-10-28-25-a-436494
371
- ovgnrw-1997-12-08-2-a-191596
372
- ovgnrw-1998-02-02-2-a-138195
373
- ovgnrw-1998-02-02-2-a-296195
374
- ovgnrw-1998-04-17-11-a-255395
375
- ovgnrw-1998-04-29-25-a-467095
376
- ovgnrw-1998-05-05-2-a-501795
377
- ovgnrw-1998-05-27-12-a-699095
378
- ovgnrw-1998-08-31-3-a-122292
379
- ovgnrw-1998-09-29-3-a-119394
380
- ovgnrw-1998-10-28-25-a-128496a
381
- ovgnrw-1998-12-18-9-a-348494
382
- ovgnrw-1999-02-09-3-a-273594
383
- ovgnrw-1999-12-17-10-a-60699
384
- ovgnrw-2000-01-28-4-a-497697
385
- ovgnrw-2000-02-15-15-a-55297
386
- ovgnrw-2000-07-24-10-a-569398
387
- ovgnrw-2000-08-03-7-a-470499
388
- ovgnrw-2000-11-14-21-a-45798a
389
- ovgnrw-2001-01-22-8-a-495199a
390
- ovgnrw-2001-03-02-7-a-502098
391
- ovgnrw-2001-04-24-15-a-302197
392
- ovgnrw-2001-06-12-10-a-9799
393
- ovgnrw-2001-10-04-9-a-36600
394
- ovgnrw-2003-07-23-8-a-392002a
395
- ovgnrw-2003-09-04-1-a-243001
396
- ovgnrw-2004-03-11-7a-d-10303ne
397
- ovgnrw-2004-05-17-7-a-355602
398
- ovgnrw-2004-08-04-6-a-30404
399
- ovgnrw-2005-06-07-11-a-119302
400
- ovgnrw-2005-11-08-6-a-265003
401
- ovgnrw-2008-04-24-10-b-36008
402
- ovgnrw-2008-04-24-10-b-36108
403
- ovgnrw-2010-04-08-12-a-278407
404
- ovgnrw-2012-05-25-13-a-138410
405
- ovgnrw-2012-05-25-13-a-139910
406
- ovgnrw-2015-03-16-16-a-149414
407
- ovgnrw-2021-07-07-4-a-169519
408
- ovgrlp-2005-04-08-5-a-1010005
409
- ovgrlp-2015-07-22-8-a-1004115
410
- ovgst-2012-09-11-4-l-16009
411
- ovgst-2016-04-21-2-m-9315
412
- polgzwe-2017-07-13-1-olg-2-ss-2517
413
- sg-aachen-2009-09-29-s-13-21-kr-8207
414
- sg-aachen-2011-04-14-s-15-kr-15610
415
- sg-braunschweig-2009-05-22-s-36-r-35706
416
- sg-braunschweig-2009-05-28-s-36-r-51708
417
- sg-detmold-2011-06-16-s-2-so-20510
418
- sg-dortmund-2009-02-18-s-47-so-30308-er
419
- sg-duisburg-2008-09-09-s-7-so-1007
420
- sg-duisburg-2009-02-25-s-24-sb-5908
421
- sg-dusseldorf-2006-07-07-s-25-3-al-20605
422
- sg-gelsenkirchen-2008-05-29-s-17-182824-kn-4
423
- sg-karlsruhe-2009-05-28-s-4-so-335208
424
- sg-koln-2012-10-26-s-33-r-86710
425
- sg-munster-2006-06-23-s-5-as-805
426
- vg-aachen-2003-11-12-9-k-169703a
427
- vg-aachen-2004-04-29-1-k-163803
428
- vg-aachen-2004-07-19-2-k-290404
429
- vg-aachen-2004-10-08-4-k-72402a
430
- vg-aachen-2005-03-01-2-k-153302
431
- vg-aachen-2006-08-16-3-k-45606
432
- vg-aachen-2006-09-07-4-k-366104a
433
- vg-aachen-2006-09-14-4-k-340804a
434
- vg-aachen-2008-06-17-2-k-113206a
435
- vg-aachen-2008-06-18-8-k-251303
436
- vg-aachen-2009-01-22-4-k-232805
437
- vg-aachen-2009-02-05-1-k-12307
438
- vg-aachen-2009-05-14-4-k-11708
439
- vg-aachen-2009-12-21-4-k-5609
440
- vg-aachen-2011-05-17-2-k-91509
441
- vg-aachen-2011-09-23-7-k-121210a
442
- vg-aachen-2011-10-07-9-k-194010
443
- vg-aachen-2012-03-14-8-k-115910
444
- vg-aachen-2012-07-03-7-k-144511
445
- vg-aachen-2022-07-29-5-k-169618
446
- vg-arnsberg-2001-11-08-7-k-361900
447
- vg-arnsberg-2002-06-12-2-k-390300
448
- vg-arnsberg-2003-01-23-7-k-431901
449
- vg-arnsberg-2003-05-16-12-k-259002
450
- vg-arnsberg-2004-05-14-5-k-267603a
451
- vg-arnsberg-2004-11-26-12-k-443103
452
- vg-arnsberg-2005-01-24-9-k-100104a
453
- vg-arnsberg-2009-03-05-4-k-262107
454
- vg-arnsberg-2012-05-10-7-k-96611
455
- vg-dusseldorf-1999-07-14-5-k-958995
456
- vg-dusseldorf-2000-02-28-14-k-825499a
457
- vg-dusseldorf-2000-05-26-24-k-848899
458
- vg-dusseldorf-2000-09-14-18-k-1053198
459
- vg-dusseldorf-2000-10-26-4-k-90499
460
- vg-dusseldorf-2002-02-26-17-k-484501
461
- vg-dusseldorf-2002-04-19-1-k-855999
462
- vg-dusseldorf-2002-11-26-14-k-139902a
463
- vg-dusseldorf-2003-02-26-21-k-846099
464
- vg-dusseldorf-2003-05-14-19-k-865799
465
- vg-dusseldorf-2003-06-05-24-k-471201
466
- vg-dusseldorf-2003-07-24-11-k-458801
467
- vg-dusseldorf-2003-07-28-19-k-860699
468
- vg-dusseldorf-2003-08-22-1-k-321803a
469
- vg-dusseldorf-2003-08-26-24-l-237303
470
- vg-dusseldorf-2003-10-30-4-k-6101
471
- vg-dusseldorf-2004-03-24-5-k-59502a
472
- vg-dusseldorf-2004-10-28-4-k-426604
473
- vg-dusseldorf-2006-10-16-5-k-433606a
474
- vg-dusseldorf-2007-06-06-5-k-106807a
475
- vg-dusseldorf-2007-09-17-5-k-542106a
476
- vg-dusseldorf-2008-01-25-13-k-2507
477
- vg-dusseldorf-2009-11-04-18-k-55109
478
- vg-dusseldorf-2011-05-05-8-k-680709a
479
- vg-dusseldorf-2013-03-13-17-k-135613a
480
- vg-dusseldorf-2013-03-15-21-k-462512
481
- vg-dusseldorf-2013-03-28-24-k-538312
482
- vg-dusseldorf-2013-07-02-17-k-539311a
483
- vg-dusseldorf-2014-01-07-17-k-80413a
484
- vg-dusseldorf-2014-03-21-26-k-889212
485
- vg-dusseldorf-2014-06-20-21-k-913612
486
- vg-dusseldorf-2015-01-22-17-k-640414a
487
- vg-dusseldorf-2015-02-17-17-k-676414a
488
- vg-dusseldorf-2015-02-17-17-k-750014a
489
- vg-dusseldorf-2015-03-05-17-k-620314a
490
- vg-dusseldorf-2015-03-05-17-k-826814a
491
- vg-dusseldorf-2015-03-10-17-k-313514a
492
- vg-dusseldorf-2015-03-11-17-k-831314a
493
- vg-dusseldorf-2015-03-17-17-k-714714a
494
- vg-dusseldorf-2015-03-17-17-k-714814a
495
- vg-dusseldorf-2015-06-24-17-k-706714a
496
- vg-dusseldorf-2015-11-13-17-k-245614a
497
- vg-dusseldorf-2016-03-08-17-k-595315a
498
- vg-dusseldorf-2016-03-10-17-k-17616a
499
- vg-dusseldorf-2016-07-01-17-k-694316a
500
- vg-dusseldorf-2016-07-06-17-k-638416a
501
- vg-dusseldorf-2016-07-12-5-k-585316a
502
- vg-dusseldorf-2016-08-11-17-k-777415a
503
- vg-dusseldorf-2020-05-08-21-k-212318a
504
- vg-dusseldorf-2020-08-20-26-l-151620
505
- vg-dusseldorf-2020-11-24-17-k-303720a
506
- vg-dusseldorf-2020-11-24-17-k-358820a
507
- vg-dusseldorf-2020-12-01-17-k-648219a
508
- vg-dusseldorf-2021-11-24-5-k-399221
509
- vg-dusseldorf-2022-02-09-5-k-645521
510
- vg-dusseldorf-2022-02-16-5-k-239921
511
- vg-dusseldorf-2022-03-15-14-kammer
512
- vg-dusseldorf-2022-08-16-20-k-21721
513
- vg-dusseldorf-2022-08-16-20-k-39322
514
- vg-dusseldorf-2022-08-16-20-k-748820
515
- vg-freiburg-2014-09-18-4-k-230413
516
- vg-gelsenkirchen-2001-09-27-5-k-628198
517
- vg-gelsenkirchen-2001-10-30-10-l-208101
518
- vg-gelsenkirchen-2001-11-13-11-k-278499
519
- vg-gelsenkirchen-2002-05-14-9-k-213700
520
- vg-gelsenkirchen-2003-03-12-4-k-171302
521
- vg-gelsenkirchen-2003-04-11-17-l-50203
522
- vg-gelsenkirchen-2003-05-15-16-k-94102
523
- vg-gelsenkirchen-2003-06-05-17-k-282100
524
- vg-gelsenkirchen-2003-11-09-1-k-553800
525
- vg-gelsenkirchen-2004-04-07-4-l-76704
526
- vg-gelsenkirchen-2004-04-30-15-k-172801
527
- vg-gelsenkirchen-2004-10-20-17-l-231904
528
- vg-gelsenkirchen-2004-10-30-17-k-75502
529
- vg-gelsenkirchen-2004-11-19-3-k-181503
530
- vg-gelsenkirchen-2005-04-28-10-k-43305
531
- vg-gelsenkirchen-2005-05-12-11-k-52705
532
- vg-gelsenkirchen-2005-06-22-16-k-66802
533
- vg-gelsenkirchen-2014-09-18-13a-k-586013a
534
- vg-gelsenkirchen-2014-10-23-5a-k-163014a
535
- vg-gelsenkirchen-2015-07-22-1a-k-512514a
536
- vg-gelsenkirchen-2015-10-15-13-k-105715
537
- vg-gelsenkirchen-2015-10-29-8-k-141814
538
- vg-gelsenkirchen-2016-02-19-17-k-609212
539
- vg-gelsenkirchen-2021-10-06-10-k-1051217
540
- vg-gottingen-2021-02-23-3-a-22820
541
- vg-hamburg-2015-03-12-17-a-530613
542
- vg-hannover-2018-04-03-10-a-788317
543
- vg-karlsruhe-2005-03-14-11-k-23305
544
- vg-karlsruhe-2018-03-22-3-k-323915
545
- vg-koln-1999-03-23-21-k-84097
546
- vg-koln-2001-10-10-20-k-850298
547
- vg-koln-2002-07-25-1-k-572099
548
- vg-koln-2002-09-13-11-k-517601
549
- vg-koln-2002-10-30-10-k-633702
550
- vg-koln-2003-04-01-5-k-603300
551
- vg-koln-2003-07-15-14-k-588001
552
- vg-koln-2003-08-28-20-k-506202
553
- vg-koln-2003-10-07-26-k-897300
554
- vg-koln-2003-11-21-19-k-953702
555
- vg-koln-2004-03-04-26-k-796700
556
- vg-koln-2004-03-19-19-k-211703
557
- vg-koln-2004-03-19-19-k-466403
558
- vg-koln-2005-05-02-25-k-922003
559
- vg-koln-2005-08-30-7-k-268504
560
- vg-koln-2005-08-30-7-k-268704
561
- vg-koln-2005-10-10-25-k-3205
562
- vg-koln-2005-10-20-1-k-672402
563
- vg-koln-2005-12-13-7-k-1039902
564
- vg-koln-2005-12-14-24-k-354604
565
- vg-koln-2006-01-10-7-k-542503
566
- vg-koln-2006-01-24-7-k-680403
567
- vg-koln-2006-01-24-7-k-701303
568
- vg-koln-2006-02-21-7-k-204005
569
- vg-koln-2006-02-21-7-k-85003
570
- vg-koln-2006-04-18-7-k-154304
571
- vg-koln-2006-07-25-7-k-142504
572
- vg-koln-2006-07-25-7-k-190804
573
- vg-koln-2006-07-25-7-k-309304
574
- vg-koln-2006-08-08-7-k-28505
575
- vg-koln-2006-08-08-7-k-427504
576
- vg-koln-2006-08-29-7-k-851104
577
- vg-koln-2006-10-24-7-k-72704
578
- vg-koln-2006-11-14-7-k-416004
579
- vg-koln-2006-11-14-7-k-771704
580
- vg-koln-2006-11-28-7-k-507406
581
- vg-koln-2006-12-12-7-k-140804
582
- vg-koln-2006-12-12-7-k-140904
583
- vg-koln-2007-02-27-7-k-270304
584
- vg-koln-2007-03-09-18-k-309105
585
- vg-koln-2007-04-24-7-k-720003
586
- vg-koln-2007-06-19-7-k-760104
587
- vg-koln-2007-06-19-7-k-863204
588
- vg-koln-2007-07-17-7-k-62905
589
- vg-koln-2007-07-31-7-k-308305
590
- vg-koln-2007-07-31-7-k-563904
591
- vg-koln-2007-08-14-7-k-29305
592
- vg-koln-2007-09-06-1-k-397406a
593
- vg-koln-2007-10-12-18-k-126205a
594
- vg-koln-2007-10-16-7-k-645104
595
- vg-koln-2008-01-08-14-k-326806
596
- vg-koln-2008-01-29-7-k-422704
597
- vg-koln-2008-04-01-7-k-485606
598
- vg-koln-2008-05-15-20-k-295307
599
- vg-koln-2008-08-21-20-k-263407
600
- vg-koln-2008-08-26-7-k-40106
601
- vg-koln-2008-08-26-7-k-40206
602
- vg-koln-2008-09-29-18-k-498705
603
- vg-koln-2008-09-30-7-k-297405
604
- vg-koln-2008-09-30-7-k-297505
605
- vg-koln-2008-10-07-7-k-151607
606
- vg-koln-2008-10-07-7-k-302707
607
- vg-koln-2008-11-11-7-k-637205
608
- vg-koln-2008-11-18-7-k-867099
609
- vg-koln-2008-11-26-24-k-797104
610
- vg-koln-2008-11-28-23-k-498506
611
- vg-koln-2009-02-04-23-k-277808
612
- vg-koln-2009-03-31-7-k-416105
613
- vg-koln-2009-03-31-7-k-878104
614
- vg-koln-2009-09-17-4-k-769708
615
- vg-koln-2009-10-27-7-k-631905
616
- vg-koln-2009-10-27-7-k-738005
617
- vg-koln-2009-11-19-6-k-203208
618
- vg-koln-2009-11-24-7-k-516407
619
- vg-koln-2009-12-03-20-k-84809
620
- vg-koln-2009-12-15-7-k-20408
621
- vg-koln-2010-01-19-7-k-234009
622
- vg-koln-2010-02-23-7-k-33608
623
- vg-koln-2010-10-19-14-k-129710
624
- vg-koln-2013-09-27-11-k-621312
625
- vg-koln-2015-07-31-25-k-181114
626
- vg-koln-2015-07-31-25-k-384612
627
- vg-koln-2015-07-31-25-k-415812
628
- vg-koln-2015-07-31-25-k-415912
629
- vg-koln-2015-07-31-25-k-416012
630
- vg-koln-2015-07-31-25-k-416112
631
- vg-koln-2015-07-31-25-k-578312
632
- vg-koln-2015-07-31-25-k-71214
633
- vg-luneburg-2005-05-04-1-a-36001
634
- vg-luneburg-2005-06-01-1-a-2102
635
- vg-luneburg-2005-06-29-1-a-21202
636
- vg-luneburg-2005-07-06-1-a-402
637
- vg-mainz-2005-01-24-6-k-72704
638
- vg-mainz-2020-06-18-1-k-38119mz
639
- vg-minden-1999-08-09-6-k-425298
640
- vg-minden-2000-03-30-2-k-387499
641
- vg-minden-2001-10-17-3-k-265100
642
- vg-minden-2002-10-02-4-k-154600
643
- vg-minden-2002-12-11-11-k-151101
644
- vg-minden-2005-06-15-11-k-231104
645
- vg-minden-2006-12-06-4-k-193005
646
- vg-minden-2007-08-01-4-k-279406
647
- vg-minden-2011-02-18-8-k-268610
648
- vg-minden-2011-12-07-11-k-215010
649
- vg-minden-2012-08-17-4-k-296009
650
- vg-munster-2005-12-28-9-k-371003a
651
- vg-munster-2006-09-12-5-k-353704
652
- vg-munster-2007-02-05-2-k-225002
653
- vg-munster-2008-04-08-5-k-5407
654
- vg-munster-2009-03-05-4-k-180007
655
- vg-munster-2009-04-29-3-k-131108
656
- vg-munster-2009-05-06-5-k-9508
657
- vg-munster-2009-09-02-5-k-143208
658
- vg-munster-2009-09-09-5-k-177908
659
- vg-munster-2009-10-14-5-k-144508
660
- vg-munster-2009-10-14-5-k-148608
661
- vg-munster-2009-10-14-5-k-151008
662
- vg-munster-2010-11-03-9-k-168909
663
- vg-munster-2012-08-08-6-k-126711
664
- vg-neustadt-an-der-weinstrae-2014-04-11-1-l-21514nw
665
- vg-oldenburg-oldenburg-2003-06-02-12-b-177103
666
- vg-regensburg-2019-04-18-12-c-181893
667
- vg-schleswig-holsteinisches-2014-06-18-1-b-5414
668
- vg-schleswig-holsteinisches-2014-09-04-12-b-2114
669
- vg-schleswig-holsteinisches-2017-03-14-2-a-21914
670
- vg-schwerin-2009-12-30-6-a-85707
671
- vg-schwerin-2012-09-21-6-a-103009
672
- vg-schwerin-2019-05-08-6-a-220717-sn
673
- vg-sigmaringen-2016-01-20-5-k-259014
674
- vg-trier-2009-04-29-5-k-80608tr
675
- vg-wurzburg-2020-08-11-w-4-s-20938
676
- vghbw-2018-07-04-5-s-211716
677
- vghbw-2018-08-16-1-s-62518