Checkpoint - 20 patients validated

validation/validation_results.json

@@ -1,96 +1,96 @@
 {
   "method": "algorithmic_HU_threshold_morphology",
-  "n_patients": 10,
+  "n_patients": 20,
   "summary": {
     "dice": {
-      "mean": 0.9675985528708468,
-      "std": 0.021550655355206807,
-      "min": 0.9089790463790003,
+      "mean": 0.9501202973399325,
+      "std": 0.03173901404116214,
+      "min": 0.8793602784210874,
       "max": 0.9833353954010368,
-      "median": 0.9760135869905877,
-      "ci95_lo": 0.9535187913721117,
-      "ci95_hi": 0.981678314369582,
-      "n": 10
+      "median": 0.9670692313457154,
+      "ci95_lo": 0.9358486961107132,
+      "ci95_hi": 0.9643918985691519,
+      "n": 20
     },
     "iou": {
-      "mean": 0.9380425234869977,
-      "std": 0.038887056561238226,
-      "min": 0.8331453611062204,
+      "mean": 0.9066837764306964,
+      "std": 0.056369792138279175,
+      "min": 0.7846949037128261,
       "max": 0.967217104788386,
-      "median": 0.9531509155061544,
-      "ci95_lo": 0.912636313200322,
-      "ci95_hi": 0.9634487337736733,
-      "n": 10
+      "median": 0.9362391929191369,
+      "ci95_lo": 0.8813368266568891,
+      "ci95_hi": 0.9320307262045038,
+      "n": 20
     },
     "f1": {
-      "mean": 0.9675985528708468,
-      "std": 0.021550655355206807,
-      "min": 0.9089790463790003,
+      "mean": 0.9501202973399325,
+      "std": 0.03173901404116214,
+      "min": 0.8793602784210874,
       "max": 0.9833353954010368,
-      "median": 0.9760135869905877,
-      "ci95_lo": 0.9535187913721117,
-      "ci95_hi": 0.981678314369582,
-      "n": 10
+      "median": 0.9670692313457154,
+      "ci95_lo": 0.9358486961107132,
+      "ci95_hi": 0.9643918985691519,
+      "n": 20
     },
     "precision": {
-      "mean": 0.9709267315353355,
-      "std": 0.0038844069010040908,
-      "min": 0.964853866861702,
-      "max": 0.9772917337763539,
-      "median": 0.9715241611040067,
-      "ci95_lo": 0.9683889190266795,
-      "ci95_hi": 0.9734645440439915,
-      "n": 10
+      "mean": 0.9694661226082768,
+      "std": 0.006107785968087994,
+      "min": 0.9492609533726224,
+      "max": 0.9787412880488462,
+      "median": 0.9692532702209137,
+      "ci95_lo": 0.966719727095898,
+      "ci95_hi": 0.9722125181206556,
+      "n": 20
     },
     "recall": {
-      "mean": 0.9650754043331927,
-      "std": 0.039539572533385296,
-      "min": 0.8574987772497311,
+      "mean": 0.9331639413103513,
+      "std": 0.05731913434693489,
+      "min": 0.8055778998193277,
       "max": 0.9937142831295428,
-      "median": 0.9793023397930442,
-      "ci95_lo": 0.939242883611381,
-      "ci95_hi": 0.9909079250550045,
-      "n": 10
+      "median": 0.9615304120110999,
+      "ci95_lo": 0.9073901152191376,
+      "ci95_hi": 0.958937767401565,
+      "n": 20
     },
     "sensitivity": {
-      "mean": 0.9650754043331927,
-      "std": 0.039539572533385296,
-      "min": 0.8574987772497311,
+      "mean": 0.9331639413103513,
+      "std": 0.05731913434693489,
+      "min": 0.8055778998193277,
       "max": 0.9937142831295428,
-      "median": 0.9793023397930442,
-      "ci95_lo": 0.939242883611381,
-      "ci95_hi": 0.9909079250550045,
-      "n": 10
+      "median": 0.9615304120110999,
+      "ci95_lo": 0.9073901152191376,
+      "ci95_hi": 0.958937767401565,
+      "n": 20
     },
     "specificity": {
-      "mean": 0.9969451297652181,
-      "std": 0.0008787832028959603,
-      "min": 0.9954554274693856,
-      "max": 0.9979755619310705,
-      "median": 0.997414088545286,
-      "ci95_lo": 0.9963709914059927,
-      "ci95_hi": 0.9975192681244435,
-      "n": 10
+      "mean": 0.9965790556187312,
+      "std": 0.0011762484013296195,
+      "min": 0.9940946064700706,
+      "max": 0.9981278191827389,
+      "median": 0.9968109570583062,
+      "ci95_lo": 0.9960501498339291,
+      "ci95_hi": 0.9971079614035332,
+      "n": 20
     },
     "hd95": {
-      "mean": 9.826935018302626,
-      "std": 5.406602273707354,
-      "min": 3.605551275463989,
+      "mean": 9.515805485808299,
+      "std": 5.389753793658917,
+      "min": 2.0,
       "max": 20.493901531919196,
-      "median": 8.238844848978964,
-      "ci95_lo": 6.294621532813821,
-      "ci95_hi": 13.35924850379143,
-      "n": 10
+      "median": 8.55521678957215,
+      "ci95_lo": 7.092276614778646,
+      "ci95_hi": 11.939334356837952,
+      "n": 20
     },
     "vol_error": {
-      "mean": 0.023958447141596135,
-      "std": 0.03181829326336091,
+      "mean": 0.04907179706838049,
+      "std": 0.047398642140271466,
       "min": 0.0010751006515144742,
-      "max": 0.11327052990796194,
-      "median": 0.017809247646479516,
-      "ci95_lo": 0.003170495542867014,
-      "ci95_hi": 0.04474639874032525,
-      "n": 10
+      "max": 0.1678092140670482,
+      "median": 0.024233037954862147,
+      "ci95_lo": 0.027758768297066607,
+      "ci95_hi": 0.07038482583969437,
+      "n": 20
     }
   },
   "per_patient": {
@@ -283,6 +283,196 @@
       "gt_voxels": 4878382,
       "uid": "coronacases_010",
       "failure_case": false
+    },
+    "radiopaedia_10_85902_1": {
+      "dice": 0.9320394564863881,
+      "iou": 0.8727283626228356,
+      "f1": 0.9320394564863881,
+      "precision": 0.9674560838894993,
+      "recall": 0.8991243180210186,
+      "sensitivity": 0.8991243180210186,
+      "specificity": 0.9963873370065524,
+      "hd95": 4.47213595499958,
+      "vol_error": 0.07063035419014099,
+      "tp": 1485018,
+      "fp": 49954,
+      "fn": 166609,
+      "tn": 13777519,
+      "pred_voxels": 1534972,
+      "gt_voxels": 1651627,
+      "uid": "radiopaedia_10_85902_1",
+      "failure_case": true
+    },
+    "radiopaedia_10_85902_3": {
+      "dice": 0.9663251482925468,
+      "iou": 0.9348444016958968,
+      "f1": 0.9663251482925468,
+      "precision": 0.9787412880488462,
+      "recall": 0.9542200802633501,
+      "sensitivity": 0.9542200802633501,
+      "specificity": 0.9975523127359182,
+      "hd95": 16.431676725154983,
+      "vol_error": 0.02505381972224892,
+      "tp": 16721100,
+      "fp": 363190,
+      "fn": 802216,
+      "tn": 148017694,
+      "pred_voxels": 17084290,
+      "gt_voxels": 17523316,
+      "uid": "radiopaedia_10_85902_3",
+      "failure_case": false
+    },
+    "radiopaedia_14_85914_0": {
+      "dice": 0.9421648139993933,
+      "iou": 0.8906536920571534,
+      "f1": 0.9421648139993933,
+      "precision": 0.9756121822954966,
+      "recall": 0.9109348102687125,
+      "sensitivity": 0.9109348102687125,
+      "specificity": 0.9956747714513079,
+      "hd95": 17.291616465790582,
+      "vol_error": 0.06629414146369175,
+      "tp": 4040772,
+      "fp": 101009,
+      "fn": 395080,
+      "tn": 23252439,
+      "pred_voxels": 4141781,
+      "gt_voxels": 4435852,
+      "uid": "radiopaedia_14_85914_0",
+      "failure_case": true
+    },
+    "radiopaedia_27_86410_0": {
+      "dice": 0.9349912840344724,
+      "iou": 0.8779189034024383,
+      "f1": 0.9349912840344724,
+      "precision": 0.9704038156483261,
+      "recall": 0.9020723436189062,
+      "sensitivity": 0.9020723436189062,
+      "specificity": 0.9966866126035242,
+      "hd95": 9.1104335791443,
+      "vol_error": 0.07041550221419107,
+      "tp": 2539966,
+      "fp": 77466,
+      "fn": 275735,
+      "tn": 23302233,
+      "pred_voxels": 2617432,
+      "gt_voxels": 2815701,
+      "uid": "radiopaedia_27_86410_0",
+      "failure_case": true
+    },
+    "radiopaedia_29_86490_1": {
+      "dice": 0.9250090755604247,
+      "iou": 0.860480823168553,
+      "f1": 0.9250090755604247,
+      "precision": 0.9715107970007523,
+      "recall": 0.8827556517741525,
+      "sensitivity": 0.8827556517741525,
+      "specificity": 0.9981278191827389,
+      "hd95": 4.898979485566356,
+      "vol_error": 0.09135785778262429,
+      "tp": 992476,
+      "fp": 29104,
+      "fn": 131817,
+      "tn": 15516403,
+      "pred_voxels": 1021580,
+      "gt_voxels": 1124293,
+      "uid": "radiopaedia_29_86490_1",
+      "failure_case": true
+    },
+    "radiopaedia_29_86491_1": {
+      "dice": 0.9734242977918107,
+      "iou": 0.9482245641485221,
+      "f1": 0.9734242977918107,
+      "precision": 0.9673170454304648,
+      "recall": 0.9796091576259068,
+      "sensitivity": 0.9796091576259068,
+      "specificity": 0.9953616211269929,
+      "hd95": 3.0,
+      "vol_error": 0.012707428503937853,
+      "tp": 2007179,
+      "fp": 67817,
+      "fn": 41780,
+      "tn": 14553024,
+      "pred_voxels": 2074996,
+      "gt_voxels": 2048959,
+      "uid": "radiopaedia_29_86491_1",
+      "failure_case": false
+    },
+    "radiopaedia_36_86526_0": {
+      "dice": 0.9718592078914323,
+      "iou": 0.9452588744176772,
+      "f1": 0.9718592078914323,
+      "precision": 0.9656406904175405,
+      "recall": 0.9781583363010922,
+      "sensitivity": 0.9781583363010922,
+      "specificity": 0.9946096123407059,
+      "hd95": 2.0,
+      "vol_error": 0.012963047236694496,
+      "tp": 2342878,
+      "fp": 83364,
+      "fn": 52315,
+      "tn": 15381943,
+      "pred_voxels": 2426242,
+      "gt_voxels": 2395193,
+      "uid": "radiopaedia_36_86526_0",
+      "failure_case": false
+    },
+    "radiopaedia_40_86625_0": {
+      "dice": 0.8793602784210874,
+      "iou": 0.7846949037128261,
+      "f1": 0.8793602784210874,
+      "precision": 0.9680206912122301,
+      "recall": 0.8055778998193277,
+      "sensitivity": 0.8055778998193277,
+      "specificity": 0.9979900456545566,
+      "hd95": 14.035668847618199,
+      "vol_error": 0.1678092140670482,
+      "tp": 2088070,
+      "fp": 68981,
+      "fn": 503945,
+      "tn": 34250704,
+      "pred_voxels": 2157051,
+      "gt_voxels": 2592015,
+      "uid": "radiopaedia_40_86625_0",
+      "failure_case": true
+    },
+    "radiopaedia_4_85506_1": {
+      "dice": 0.90320386067586,
+      "iou": 0.8234929247950066,
+      "f1": 0.90320386067586,
+      "precision": 0.9660915894964042,
+      "recall": 0.8480031015850841,
+      "sensitivity": 0.8480031015850841,
+      "specificity": 0.9956450761500717,
+      "hd95": 8.0,
+      "vol_error": 0.12223322218645546,
+      "tp": 1675454,
+      "fp": 58806,
+      "fn": 300310,
+      "tn": 13444530,
+      "pred_voxels": 1734260,
+      "gt_voxels": 1975764,
+      "uid": "radiopaedia_4_85506_1",
+      "failure_case": true
+    },
+    "radiopaedia_7_85703_0": {
+      "dice": 0.8980429949367631,
+      "iou": 0.8149528437230412,
+      "f1": 0.8980429949367631,
+      "precision": 0.9492609533726224,
+      "recall": 0.852069083597547,
+      "sensitivity": 0.852069083597547,
+      "specificity": 0.9940946064700706,
+      "hd95": 12.806248474865697,
+      "vol_error": 0.10238688258461551,
+      "tp": 1746774,
+      "fp": 93367,
+      "fn": 303264,
+      "tn": 15717095,
+      "pred_voxels": 1840141,
+      "gt_voxels": 2050038,
+      "uid": "radiopaedia_7_85703_0",
+      "failure_case": true
     }
   }
 }