| """Render the CTA (A1_full) framework — cleaned, paper-grade version. |
| |
| Output: outputs/analysis/figs_framework/cta_framework.{png,pdf} |
| |
| Design principles: |
| * Two columns: left = data flow (single chain), right = side notes |
| (training losses + innovation list). |
| * Real/Fake sample paths use color (green / red) but only on the few |
| arrows that actually differ. Most arrows are shared (gray). |
| * Each innovation is marked with a single ★ inside the box; the |
| long captions live in the right-side panel, NOT on the diagram. |
| * Generous padding between modules. Total figure ~ 17 x 11. |
| |
| Run from project root: |
| python3 scripts/analysis/draw_cta_framework.py |
| """ |
| from __future__ import annotations |
|
|
| from pathlib import Path |
|
|
| import matplotlib |
| matplotlib.use("Agg") |
| import matplotlib.pyplot as plt |
| from matplotlib.patches import FancyArrowPatch, FancyBboxPatch |
|
|
|
|
| OUT_DIR = Path("outputs/analysis/figs_framework") |
| OUT_DIR.mkdir(parents=True, exist_ok=True) |
|
|
| |
| |
| |
| C_REAL = "#1E8449" |
| C_FAKE = "#C0392B" |
| C_SHARED = "#7F8C8D" |
|
|
| C_DATA_REAL_FILL = "#E8F8F0" |
| C_DATA_FAKE_FILL = "#FBEAEA" |
| C_DATA_AUDIO_FILL = "#FCF3CF" |
| C_DATA_AUDIO_EDGE = "#B7950B" |
|
|
| C_BB_FILL = "#EAF2F8" |
| C_BB_EDGE = "#5499C7" |
|
|
| C_CORE_FILL = "#FDEBD0" |
| C_CORE_EDGE = "#D35400" |
| C_CORE_TEXT = "#7B241C" |
|
|
| C_NEUTRAL_FILL = "#F4F6F7" |
| C_NEUTRAL_EDGE = "#7F8C8D" |
|
|
| C_OUT_FILL = "#E8DAEF" |
| C_OUT_EDGE = "#7D3C98" |
|
|
| C_PANEL_LOSS = "#FEF9E7" |
| C_PANEL_LOSS_EDGE = "#B7950B" |
| C_PANEL_INNO = "#FDEDEC" |
| C_PANEL_INNO_EDGE = "#C0392B" |
|
|
|
|
| |
| |
| |
| def box(ax, cx, cy, w, h, text, fill, edge, *, |
| fontsize=10, weight="normal", lw=1.5, padding=0.4, star=False, |
| text_color="black"): |
| rect = FancyBboxPatch( |
| (cx - w/2, cy - h/2), w, h, |
| boxstyle=f"round,pad={padding}", |
| facecolor=fill, edgecolor=edge, linewidth=lw, |
| ) |
| ax.add_patch(rect) |
| label = (("★ " + text) if star else text) |
| ax.text(cx, cy, label, ha="center", va="center", |
| fontsize=fontsize, weight=weight, color=text_color) |
|
|
|
|
| def arrow(ax, x1, y1, x2, y2, *, color=C_SHARED, lw=1.6, dashed=False, |
| mutation=14, alpha=1.0): |
| ls = (0, (5, 3)) if dashed else "-" |
| a = FancyArrowPatch( |
| (x1, y1), (x2, y2), |
| arrowstyle="->", mutation_scale=mutation, |
| color=color, linewidth=lw, linestyle=ls, alpha=alpha, |
| shrinkA=2, shrinkB=2, |
| ) |
| ax.add_patch(a) |
|
|
|
|
| def small(ax, cx, cy, text, *, fontsize=8.5, color="#566573", italic=True, |
| ha="center", weight="normal"): |
| style = "italic" if italic else "normal" |
| ax.text(cx, cy, text, ha=ha, va="center", |
| fontsize=fontsize, style=style, color=color, weight=weight) |
|
|
|
|
| |
| |
| |
| fig, ax = plt.subplots(figsize=(17, 11)) |
| ax.set_xlim(0, 100) |
| ax.set_ylim(0, 100) |
| ax.set_aspect("equal") |
| ax.axis("off") |
|
|
|
|
| |
| ax.text(50, 96.5, "CTA: Cross-modal Translation Asymmetry — Framework", |
| ha="center", va="center", fontsize=18, weight="bold") |
| small(ax, 50, 92.8, |
| "★ marks the four innovations (described on the right)", |
| fontsize=10, italic=True, color="#566573") |
|
|
|
|
| |
| ax.plot([6, 10], [89, 89], color=C_REAL, lw=2.4) |
| ax.text(10.6, 89, "real", fontsize=9, va="center", color=C_REAL, weight="bold") |
| ax.plot([16, 20], [89, 89], color=C_FAKE, lw=2.4, linestyle=(0, (5, 3))) |
| ax.text(20.6, 89, "fake", fontsize=9, va="center", color=C_FAKE, weight="bold") |
| ax.plot([26, 30], [89, 89], color=C_SHARED, lw=2.4) |
| ax.text(30.6, 89, "shared", fontsize=9, va="center", color=C_SHARED) |
|
|
|
|
| |
| COL_L, COL_R = 22, 50 |
| COL_C = (COL_L + COL_R) / 2 |
|
|
| |
| y_in = 84 |
| box(ax, 12, y_in, 16, 5, "Real video\n(label = 0)", |
| C_DATA_REAL_FILL, C_REAL, fontsize=10) |
| box(ax, 31, y_in, 16, 5, "Fake video\n(label = 1)", |
| C_DATA_FAKE_FILL, C_FAKE, fontsize=10) |
| box(ax, 56, y_in, 22, 5, "Audio ★ always real", |
| C_DATA_AUDIO_FILL, C_DATA_AUDIO_EDGE, fontsize=10, weight="bold", |
| text_color="#7E5109") |
|
|
| |
| y_bb = 73 |
| box(ax, COL_L, y_bb, 28, 5, |
| "VideoMAE-base (freeze 70 %)", |
| C_BB_FILL, C_BB_EDGE, fontsize=10) |
| box(ax, 56, y_bb, 22, 5, |
| "Wav2Vec2-base (freeze 80 %)", |
| C_BB_FILL, C_BB_EDGE, fontsize=10) |
|
|
| |
| arrow(ax, 12, y_in - 2.6, COL_L - 5, y_bb + 2.6, color=C_REAL, lw=2.0) |
| arrow(ax, 31, y_in - 2.6, COL_L + 5, y_bb + 2.6, color=C_FAKE, lw=2.0, dashed=True) |
| arrow(ax, 56, y_in - 2.6, 56, y_bb + 2.6, color=C_SHARED, lw=2.0) |
|
|
| |
| small(ax, 22, y_bb - 4, "v.tokens / v.pooled", |
| fontsize=8, italic=True, color="#566573") |
| small(ax, 56, y_bb - 4, "a.tokens / a.pooled", |
| fontsize=8, italic=True, color="#566573") |
|
|
|
|
| |
| y_pr = 60 |
| box(ax, 22, y_pr, 28, 7, |
| "$f_{A \\to V}$ predictor\nTransformer Decoder × 4", |
| C_CORE_FILL, C_CORE_EDGE, fontsize=10, lw=2.5, star=True, |
| text_color=C_CORE_TEXT, weight="bold") |
| box(ax, 56, y_pr, 28, 7, |
| "$f_{V \\to A}$ predictor\nTransformer Decoder × 4", |
| C_CORE_FILL, C_CORE_EDGE, fontsize=10, lw=2.5, star=True, |
| text_color=C_CORE_TEXT, weight="bold") |
|
|
| |
| small(ax, 22, y_pr - 4.5, |
| "trained on real pairs only", |
| fontsize=8.2, italic=True, color=C_REAL, weight="bold") |
| small(ax, 56, y_pr - 4.5, |
| "trained on real pairs only", |
| fontsize=8.2, italic=True, color=C_REAL, weight="bold") |
|
|
| |
| |
| arrow(ax, 22, y_bb - 2.6, 22, y_pr + 4, color=C_SHARED, lw=1.4) |
| arrow(ax, 22, y_bb - 2.6, 50, y_pr + 4, color=C_SHARED, lw=1.0, |
| alpha=0.55) |
| arrow(ax, 56, y_bb - 2.6, 56, y_pr + 4, color=C_SHARED, lw=1.4) |
| arrow(ax, 56, y_bb - 2.6, 28, y_pr + 4, color=C_SHARED, lw=1.0, |
| alpha=0.55) |
|
|
|
|
| |
| y_res = 47 |
| box(ax, 22, y_res, 26, 4.5, |
| "$L_{A \\to V}$ = MSE(v_pred, v.tokens)", |
| C_CORE_FILL, C_CORE_EDGE, fontsize=10, lw=2.0) |
| box(ax, 56, y_res, 26, 4.5, |
| "$L_{V \\to A}$ = MSE(a_pred, a.tokens)", |
| C_CORE_FILL, C_CORE_EDGE, fontsize=10, lw=2.0) |
|
|
| arrow(ax, 22, y_pr - 4, 22, y_res + 2.5, color=C_SHARED, lw=1.4) |
| arrow(ax, 56, y_pr - 4, 56, y_res + 2.5, color=C_SHARED, lw=1.4) |
|
|
|
|
| |
| y_asym = 38 |
| box(ax, 39, y_asym, 50, 5, |
| "$s_{\\rm asym}$ = $L_{V\\to A}$ − $L_{A\\to V}$ " |
| "$L_{\\rm total}$ = $L_{V\\to A}$ + $L_{A\\to V}$", |
| C_CORE_FILL, C_CORE_EDGE, fontsize=10.5, lw=2.5, star=True, |
| text_color=C_CORE_TEXT, weight="bold") |
|
|
| arrow(ax, 22, y_res - 2.3, 30, y_asym + 2.5, color=C_SHARED, lw=1.4) |
| arrow(ax, 56, y_res - 2.3, 48, y_asym + 2.5, color=C_SHARED, lw=1.4) |
|
|
|
|
| |
| y_det = 30.5 |
| small(ax, 39, y_det, ".detach() ★ cuts gradient back to predictors", |
| fontsize=10, italic=True, color=C_CORE_TEXT, weight="bold") |
| arrow(ax, 39, y_asym - 2.5, 39, y_det + 1, color=C_SHARED, lw=1.4) |
|
|
|
|
| |
| y_cls = 22.5 |
| box(ax, 39, y_cls, 56, 6, |
| "Classifier Head MLP (1538 → 256 → 1)\n" |
| "input = concat[ v.pooled , a.pooled , $s_{\\rm asym}$ , $L_{\\rm total}$ ]", |
| C_BB_FILL, C_BB_EDGE, fontsize=10) |
| arrow(ax, 39, y_det - 0.7, 39, y_cls + 3, color=C_SHARED, lw=1.4) |
|
|
| |
| arrow(ax, 22, y_bb - 2.6, 12, y_cls + 1, color=C_SHARED, lw=0.7, |
| alpha=0.45) |
| arrow(ax, 56, y_bb - 2.6, 66, y_cls + 1, color=C_SHARED, lw=0.7, |
| alpha=0.45) |
|
|
|
|
| |
| y_out = 13 |
| box(ax, 39, y_out, 28, 4.5, |
| "score = sigmoid(logit) ∈ [0, 1]\nhigh ⇒ fake", |
| C_OUT_FILL, C_OUT_EDGE, fontsize=10.5, weight="bold") |
| arrow(ax, 39, y_cls - 3, 39, y_out + 2.3, color=C_SHARED, lw=1.6) |
|
|
|
|
| |
|
|
| |
| inn_w, inn_h = 28, 38 |
| inn_cx, inn_cy = 84, 67 |
| inn = FancyBboxPatch( |
| (inn_cx - inn_w/2, inn_cy - inn_h/2), inn_w, inn_h, |
| boxstyle="round,pad=0.5", |
| facecolor=C_PANEL_INNO, edgecolor=C_PANEL_INNO_EDGE, linewidth=2, |
| ) |
| ax.add_patch(inn) |
|
|
| ax.text(inn_cx, inn_cy + inn_h/2 - 2, |
| "Key Innovations ★", |
| ha="center", fontsize=12.5, weight="bold", color=C_CORE_TEXT) |
|
|
| |
| ix = inn_cx - inn_w/2 + 1.2 |
| iy = inn_cy + inn_h/2 - 5.0 |
|
|
| bullets = [ |
| ("★ 1. Bidirectional cross-modal predictors", |
| " A→V and V→A (Transformer Decoders)"), |
| ("★ 2. Trained on REAL pairs ONLY", |
| " loss_av, loss_va masked by label = 0"), |
| ("★ 3. Asymmetry score $s_\\mathrm{asym}$ = detector", |
| " real ≈ 0 ; fake ≪ 0 (OOD signature)"), |
| ("★ 4. detach() before classifier head", |
| " keeps predictors from leaking to BCE"), |
| ("★ 5. Cross-generator consistency loss", |
| " same num, alt generator → same $s_\\mathrm{asym}$"), |
| ] |
| for title, gloss in bullets: |
| ax.text(ix, iy, title, fontsize=9.4, weight="bold", color=C_CORE_TEXT) |
| iy -= 1.7 |
| ax.text(ix, iy, gloss, fontsize=8.2, color="#7B241C", style="italic") |
| iy -= 3.6 |
|
|
|
|
| |
| lp_w, lp_h = 28, 36 |
| lp_cx, lp_cy = 84, 25 |
| lp = FancyBboxPatch( |
| (lp_cx - lp_w/2, lp_cy - lp_h/2), lp_w, lp_h, |
| boxstyle="round,pad=0.5", |
| facecolor=C_PANEL_LOSS, edgecolor=C_PANEL_LOSS_EDGE, linewidth=2, |
| ) |
| ax.add_patch(lp) |
|
|
| ax.text(lp_cx, lp_cy + lp_h/2 - 2.0, |
| "Training losses & sample masks", |
| ha="center", fontsize=11.5, weight="bold") |
|
|
| lx = lp_cx - lp_w/2 + 1.2 |
| ly = lp_cy + lp_h/2 - 5.0 |
|
|
| losses = [ |
| ("$\\mathrm{loss}_{av}$ = mean($L_{A\\to V}$ | label=0)", |
| "REAL only", C_REAL), |
| ("$\\mathrm{loss}_{va}$ = mean($L_{V\\to A}$ | label=0)", |
| "REAL only", C_REAL), |
| ("$\\mathrm{loss}_{asym}$ = ReLU($s_\\mathrm{fake}$ − $s_\\mathrm{real}$)", |
| "BOTH (margin)", "#566573"), |
| ("$\\mathrm{loss}_{cls}$ = BCE(score, label)", |
| "BOTH", "#566573"), |
| ("$\\mathrm{loss}_{aux}$ = MSE($s_\\mathrm{asym}$, $s_\\mathrm{asym, alt}$)", |
| "paired FAKEs", C_FAKE), |
| ] |
| for line, mask, color in losses: |
| ax.text(lx, ly, line, fontsize=9.0) |
| ly -= 1.5 |
| ax.text(lx, ly, " sample mask: " + mask, |
| fontsize=8, color=color, style="italic") |
| ly -= 2.7 |
|
|
| ax.text(lp_cx, lp_cy - lp_h/2 + 3.5, |
| "Total = 1·$loss_{av}$ + 1·$loss_{va}$ + 0.5·$loss_{asym}$\n" |
| " + 1·$loss_{cls}$ + 0.1·$loss_{aux}$", |
| ha="center", va="center", fontsize=8.8, weight="bold") |
|
|
|
|
| |
| |
| |
| out_png = OUT_DIR / "cta_framework.png" |
| out_pdf = OUT_DIR / "cta_framework.pdf" |
| plt.tight_layout(pad=0.6) |
| plt.savefig(out_png, dpi=240, bbox_inches="tight", facecolor="white") |
| plt.savefig(out_pdf, bbox_inches="tight", facecolor="white") |
| plt.close(fig) |
| print(f"[draw] wrote {out_png}") |
| print(f"[draw] wrote {out_pdf}") |
|
|