| |
| """AppSecBench v1.1.0 — Ruby (Rails) and Scala (Spring Boot) snippet generator. |
| |
| Compact, idiom-specific vulnerable/secure pairs for every catalog vulnerability. |
| Placeholders filled by generic_ruby_scala(): {p}=param, {tbl}=table, {ep}=endpoint, |
| {id}=identifier, {fn}=function name. All snippets are ORIGINAL. |
| """ |
| from __future__ import annotations |
|
|
| import random |
| from vuln_catalog import CATALOG_BY_NAME |
|
|
| FUNCS = ["process", "handle", "resolve", "doAction", "run", "execute", "load", "save", "update", "delete"] |
|
|
|
|
| def _pick(rng, seq): |
| return rng.choice(seq) |
|
|
|
|
| |
| RUBY_SCALA = [ |
| ("SQL Injection", |
| 'def {fn}({p})\n # VULNERABLE: string interpolation into SQL\n User.find_by_sql("SELECT * FROM users WHERE name = \'#{params[:{p}]}\'")\nend', |
| 'def {fn}({p})\n # SECURE: bound parameter\n User.where("name = ?", params[:{p}])\nend', |
| 'def {fn}({p}: String): java.util.List[User] =\n // VULNERABLE: string concatenation\n jdbcTemplate.queryForList("SELECT * FROM users WHERE name = \'" + {p} + "\'")\n', |
| 'def {fn}({p}: String): java.util.List[User] =\n // SECURE: parameterized query\n jdbcTemplate.queryForList("SELECT * FROM users WHERE name = ?", {p})\n'), |
|
|
| ("Cross-Site Scripting", |
| 'def {fn}\n # VULNERABLE: raw user input rendered\n @out = params[:{p}]\n render inline: @out\nend', |
| 'def {fn}\n # SECURE: auto-escaped / html_escape\n @out = ERB::Util.html_escape(params[:{p}])\nend', |
| 'def {fn}({p}: String): String =\n // VULNERABLE: raw into template model\n s"Hello ${{{p}}}"\n', |
| 'def {fn}({p}: String): String =\n // SECURE: escaped output\n org.apache.commons.text.StringEscapeUtils.escapeHtml4({p})\n'), |
|
|
| ("Server-Side Request Forgery", |
| 'def {fn}\n # VULNERABLE: fetch arbitrary user URL\n uri = URI.parse(params[:{p}])\n Net::HTTP.get(uri)\nend', |
| 'def {fn}\n # SECURE: allow-list of hosts\n host = URI.parse(params[:{p}]).host\n raise "blocked" unless %w[api.a.com].include?(host)\n Net::HTTP.get(URI.parse(params[:{p}]))\nend', |
| 'def {fn}({p}: String): String =\n // VULNERABLE: fetch arbitrary URL\n scala.io.Source.fromURL({p}).mkString\n', |
| 'def {fn}({p}: String): String =\n // SECURE: allow-list + private-network block\n if (Set("https://api.a.com").contains({p})) scala.io.Source.fromURL({p}).mkString else throw new SecurityException("blocked")\n'), |
|
|
| ("Command Injection", |
| 'def {fn}\n # VULNERABLE: shell with user input\n `ping -c 1 #{params[:{p}]}`\nend', |
| 'def {fn}\n # SECURE: argument array, no shell\n system("ping", "-c", "1", params[:{p}])\nend', |
| 'def {fn}({p}: String): Int =\n // VULNERABLE: shell interpolation\n import sys.process._\n s"ping -c 1 ${{{p}}}".!\n', |
| 'def {fn}({p}: String): Int =\n // SECURE: argument vector\n Seq("ping", "-c", "1", {p}).!\n'), |
|
|
| ("Path Traversal", |
| 'def {fn}\n # VULNERABLE: user path joined to root\n send_file(Rails.root.join("public", params[:{p}]))\nend', |
| 'def {fn}\n # SECURE: canonicalize + scope check\n p = File.expand_path(File.join("public", params[:{p}]))\n raise "bad" unless p.start_with?(Rails.root.join("public").to_s)\n send_file(p)\nend', |
| 'def {fn}({p}: String): java.io.File =\n // VULNERABLE: join without canonicalization\n new java.io.File("uploads/" + {p})\n', |
| 'def {fn}({p}: String): java.io.File =\n // SECURE: canonicalize and confine to base\n val f = java.nio.file.Paths.get("uploads", {p}).normalize\n if (f.startsWith(java.nio.file.Paths.get("uploads"))) f.toFile else throw new SecurityException("bad")\n'), |
|
|
| ("XML External Entity", |
| 'def {fn}(xml)\n # VULNERABLE: default parser resolves entities\n doc = Nokogiri::XML(xml)\n doc.xpath("//data").text\nend', |
| 'def {fn}(xml)\n # SECURE: disable DTD / entities\n doc = Nokogiri::XML(xml) { |cfg| cfg.nonet; cfg.noent = false }\n doc.xpath("//data").text\nend', |
| 'def {fn}(xml: String): String =\n // VULNERABLE: DOCTYPE allowed\n val factory = javax.xml.parsers.DocumentBuilderFactory.newInstance\n val doc = factory.newDocumentBuilder.parse(new java.io.ByteArrayInputStream(xml.getBytes))\n doc.getElementsByTagName("data").item(0).getTextContent\n', |
| 'def {fn}(xml: String): String =\n // SECURE: disallow DOCTYPE\n val factory = javax.xml.parsers.DocumentBuilderFactory.newInstance\n factory.setFeature("http://apache.org/xml/features/disallow-doctype-decl", true)\n val doc = factory.newDocumentBuilder.parse(new java.io.ByteArrayInputStream(xml.getBytes))\n doc.getElementsByTagName("data").item(0).getTextContent\n'), |
|
|
| ("Insecure Direct Object Reference", |
| 'def {fn}\n # VULNERABLE: trust client id\n @doc = Document.find(params[:id])\nend', |
| 'def {fn}\n # SECURE: scope to owner\n @doc = current_user.documents.find(params[:id])\nend', |
| 'def {fn}(id: Long): Doc =\n // VULNERABLE: no ownership check\n docRepo.findById(id).get\n', |
| 'def {fn}(id: Long): Doc =\n // SECURE: owner scoping\n docRepo.findByIdAndOwner(id, currentUser)\n'), |
|
|
| ("Broken Access Control", |
| 'def {fn}\n # VULNERABLE: no role check\n Admin::PanelController.new.index\nend', |
| 'def {fn}\n # SECURE: authorize before action\n authorize! :admin, :panel\n Admin::PanelController.new.index\nend', |
| 'def {fn}(): Unit =\n // VULNERABLE: no authorization\n adminService.deleteAll()\n', |
| 'def {fn}(): Unit =\n // SECURE: role gate\n if (auth.hasRole("ADMIN")) adminService.deleteAll() else throw new SecurityException("no")\n'), |
| ] |
|
|
|
|
| RUBY_SCALA += [ |
| ("Broken Authentication", |
| 'def {fn}\n # VULNERABLE: plaintext compare\n user = User.find_by(name: params[:user])\n session[:uid] = user.id if user && user.pw == params[:pw]\nend', |
| 'def {fn}\n # SECURE: bcrypt + lockout\n user = User.find_by(name: params[:user])\n if user && user.authenticate(params[:pw]) && !user.locked\n session[:uid] = user.id\n end\nend', |
| 'def {fn}(user: String, pw: String): Unit =\n // VULNERABLE: plaintext compare\n val u = userRepo.findByName(user)\n if (u != null && u.pw == pw) session.put("uid", u.id)\n', |
| 'def {fn}(user: String, pw: String): Unit =\n // SECURE: bcrypt + lockout\n val u = userRepo.findByName(user)\n if (u != null && u.locked == false && BCrypt.checkpw(pw, u.pw)) session.put("uid", u.id)\n'), |
|
|
| ("Broken Authorization", |
| 'def {fn}(doc)\n # VULNERABLE: no per-object authz\n doc.update(visible: true)\nend', |
| 'def {fn}(doc)\n # SECURE: policy check\n authorize!(:update, doc)\n doc.update(visible: true)\nend', |
| 'def {fn}(id: Long): Unit =\n // VULNERABLE: no authz\n docRepo.save(docRepo.findById(id).get.copy(visible = true))\n', |
| 'def {fn}(id: Long): Unit =\n // SECURE: authz gate\n if (authz.can(currentUser, "update", id)) docRepo.save(docRepo.findById(id).get.copy(visible = true))\n'), |
|
|
| ("JWT Vulnerabilities", |
| 'def {fn}(token)\n # VULNERABLE: none alg / weak secret\n payload = JWT.decode(token, "secret", "none")\nend', |
| 'def {fn}(token)\n # SECURE: verify HS256 + exp + aud\n payload = JWT.decode(token, Rails.application.secrets.jwt_secret, "HS256", verify_expiration: true)\nend', |
| 'def {fn}(token: String): Claims =\n // VULNERABLE: no signature verify\n Jwts.parser.parseClaimsJwt(token).getBody\n', |
| 'def {fn}(token: String): Claims =\n // SECURE: verify signature + exp\n Jwts.parser.setSigningKey(secret).parseClaimsJws(token).getBody\n'), |
|
|
| ("OAuth Vulnerabilities", |
| 'def {fn}\n # VULNERABLE: no redirect_uri validation\n redirect_to params[:redirect_uri]\nend', |
| 'def {fn}\n # SECURE: allow-list redirect\n raise "bad" unless params[:redirect_uri].start_with?("https://app.example.com")\n redirect_to params[:redirect_uri]\nend', |
| 'def {fn}(ru: String): Token =\n // VULNERABLE: no registered-uri check\n oauth.exchange(code, ru)\n', |
| 'def {fn}(ru: String): Token =\n // SECURE: registered URI + PKCE\n if (registered.contains(ru)) oauth.exchange(code, ru, pkce) else throw new IllegalArgumentException()\n'), |
|
|
| ("Session Management", |
| 'def {fn}\n # VULNERABLE: session in URL / no rotation\n redirect_to "/home?sid=#{session.id}"\nend', |
| 'def {fn}\n # SECURE: rotate on login, http-only cookie\n reset_session\n session[:uid] = current_user.id\nend', |
| 'def {fn}(): Unit =\n // VULNERABLE: session id in URL\n redirect(s"/home?sid=${{session.getId}}")\n', |
| 'def {fn}(): Unit =\n // SECURE: rotate + http-only\n session.invalidate(); val s = request.getSession(true); s.setAttribute("uid", uid)\n'), |
|
|
| ("Cross-Site Request Forgery", |
| 'def {fn}\n # VULNERABLE: no CSRF token\n # (Rails has per-form tokens by default; this disables it)\n skip_before_action :verify_authenticity_token\nend', |
| 'def {fn}\n # SECURE: keep CSRF protection on\n protect_from_forgery with: :exception\nend', |
| 'def {fn}(): Unit =\n // VULNERABLE: CSRF disabled\n // (Spring Security csrf().disable())\n "noop"\n', |
| 'def {fn}(): Unit =\n // SECURE: CSRF enabled\n // (Spring Security http.csrf())\n "noop"\n'), |
|
|
| ("Insecure File Upload", |
| 'def {fn}\n # VULNERABLE: save by original name, no type check\n File.open(Rails.root.join("public", params[:file].original_filename), "wb") { |f| f.write(params[:file].read) }\nend', |
| 'def {fn}\n # SECURE: random name + content-type allow-list\n ext = File.extname(params[:file].original_filename)\n raise "bad" unless %w[.png .jpg].include?(ext)\n File.open(Rails.root.join("public", SecureRandom.hex + ext), "wb") { |f| f.write(params[:file].read) }\nend', |
| 'def {fn}(file: MultipartFile): Unit =\n // VULNERABLE: original filename, no check\n Files.copy(file.getInputStream, Paths.get("uploads/" + file.getOriginalFilename))\n', |
| 'def {fn}(file: MultipartFile): Unit =\n // SECURE: random name + allow-list\n val ext = file.getOriginalFilename.split("\\.").last\n if (Set("png","jpg").contains(ext)) Files.copy(file.getInputStream, Paths.get("uploads/" + UUID.randomUUID + "." + ext)) else throw new SecurityException("bad")\n'), |
| ] |
|
|
|
|
| RUBY_SCALA += [ |
| ("Insecure Deserialization", |
| 'def {fn}(data)\n # VULNERABLE: Marshal.load on untrusted input\n Marshal.load(Base64.decode64(data))\nend', |
| 'def {fn}(data)\n # SECURE: parse only expected shape (JSON)\n JSON.parse(data)\nend', |
| 'def {fn}(data: String): Any =\n // VULNERABLE: Java deserialization\n new ObjectInputStream(new ByteArrayInputStream(Base64.getDecoder.decode(data))).readObject\n', |
| 'def {fn}(data: String): Any =\n // SECURE: JSON only\n jackson.readValue(data, classOf[Map[String,Any]])\n'), |
|
|
| ("Open Redirect", |
| 'def {fn}\n # VULNERABLE: arbitrary redirect\n redirect_to params[:url]\nend', |
| 'def {fn}\n # SECURE: allow-list host\n uri = URI.parse(params[:url])\n raise "bad" unless uri.host == "app.example.com"\n redirect_to params[:url]\nend', |
| 'def {fn}(url: String): String =\n // VULNERABLE: arbitrary redirect\n "redirect:" + url\n', |
| 'def {fn}(url: String): String =\n // SECURE: host allow-list\n if (new URI(url).getHost == "app.example.com") "redirect:" + url else throw new SecurityException("bad")\n'), |
|
|
| ("Race Condition", |
| 'def {fn}\n # VULNERABLE: check-then-act\n if !$used[params[:id]]\n $used[params[:id]] = true\n end\nend', |
| 'def {fn}\n # SECURE: atomic DB update\n User.update_all(["used = true WHERE id = ? AND used = false", params[:id]])\nend', |
| 'def {fn}(id: String): Unit =\n // VULNERABLE: check-then-act\n if (!used.contains(id)) used.add(id)\n', |
| 'def {fn}(id: String): Unit =\n // SECURE: atomic update\n jdbcTemplate.update("UPDATE t SET used=true WHERE id=? AND used=false", id)\n'), |
|
|
| ("Insecure Cryptography", |
| 'def {fn}(data)\n # VULNERABLE: MD5 digest for integrity\n Digest::MD5.hexdigest(data)\nend', |
| 'def {fn}(data)\n # SECURE: HMAC-SHA256 with secret\n OpenSSL::HMAC.hexdigest("SHA256", SECRET, data)\nend', |
| 'def {fn}(data: String): String =\n // VULNERABLE: MD5\n java.security.MessageDigest.getInstance("MD5").digest(data.getBytes).map("%02x".format(_)).mkString\n', |
| 'def {fn}(data: String): String =\n // SECURE: HMAC-SHA256\n import javax.crypto.Mac\n val m = Mac.getInstance("HmacSHA256"); m.init(secret); m.doFinal(data.getBytes).map("%02x".format(_)).mkString\n'), |
|
|
| ("Hardcoded Secrets", |
| 'SECRET = "sk_live_9f8a7b6c5d4e3f2a"\n\n# VULNERABLE: hardcoded key\n def {fn}(data)\n OpenSSL::HMAC.hexdigest("SHA256", SECRET, data)\nend', |
| 'require "rails/application"\n# SECURE: read from env / secret store\n def {fn}(data)\n OpenSSL::HMAC.hexdigest("SHA256", ENV["SECRET"], data)\nend', |
| 'val SECRET = "sk_live_9f8a7b6c5d4e3f2a"\n// VULNERABLE: hardcoded key\n def {fn}(data: String): String =\n mac(SECRET, data)\n', |
| '// SECURE: from env / vault\n def {fn}(data: String): String =\n mac(sys.env.get("SECRET").get, data)\n'), |
|
|
| ("Business Logic", |
| 'def {fn}(cart)\n # VULNERABLE: negative quantity accepted\n cart.items.each { |i| charge(i.price * i.qty) }\nend', |
| 'def {fn}(cart)\n # SECURE: reject non-positive qty\n raise "bad" if cart.items.any? { |i| i.qty <= 0 }\n cart.items.each { |i| charge(i.price * i.qty) }\nend', |
| 'def {fn}(cart: Cart): Unit =\n // VULNERABLE: negative qty accepted\n cart.items.foreach(i => charge(i.price * i.qty))\n', |
| 'def {fn}(cart: Cart): Unit =\n // SECURE: reject non-positive qty\n if (cart.items.exists(_.qty <= 0)) throw new IllegalArgumentException() else cart.items.foreach(i => charge(i.price * i.qty))\n'), |
| ] |
|
|
|
|
| RUBY_SCALA += [ |
| ("Missing Rate Limiting", |
| 'def {fn}\n # VULNERABLE: no throttle\n login(params[:user], params[:pw])\nend', |
| 'def {fn}\n # SECURE: rack-attack / throttle\n throttle("logins/ip", limit: 5, period: 60) { login(params[:user], params[:pw]) }\nend', |
| 'def {fn}(ip: String): Unit =\n // VULNERABLE: no throttle\n login(ip)\n', |
| 'def {fn}(ip: String): Unit =\n // SECURE: bucket4j rate limit\n if (limiter.tryConsume(ip)) login(ip) else throw new RateLimitExceeded("429")\n'), |
|
|
| ("Sensitive Data Logging", |
| 'def {fn}\n # VULNERABLE: logs secret\n Rails.logger.info("token=#{params[:token]}")\nend', |
| 'def {fn}\n # SECURE: redact\n Rails.logger.info("token=REDACTED")\nend', |
| 'def {fn}(token: String): Unit =\n // VULNERABLE: logs secret\n logger.info(s"token=$token")\n', |
| 'def {fn}(token: String): Unit =\n // SECURE: redact\n logger.info("token=REDACTED")\n'), |
|
|
| ("Header Injection", |
| 'def {fn}\n # VULNERABLE: user input into header\n response.headers["X-User"] = params[:user]\nend', |
| 'def {fn}\n # SECURE: validate / strip CRLF\n v = params[:user].gsub(/[\\r\\n]/, "")\n response.headers["X-User"] = v\nend', |
| 'def {fn}(user: String): Unit =\n // VULNERABLE: CRLF in header\n response.setHeader("X-User", user)\n', |
| 'def {fn}(user: String): Unit =\n // SECURE: strip CRLF\n response.setHeader("X-User", user.replaceAll("[\\r\\n]", ""))\n'), |
|
|
| ("Prompt Injection", |
| 'def {fn}(msg)\n # VULNERABLE: untrusted text into system prompt\n call_llm("You are helpful. User: #{msg}")\nend', |
| 'def {fn}(msg)\n # SECURE: separate system vs user, delimit\n call_llm(system: "You are helpful.", user: msg)\nend', |
| 'def {fn}(msg: String): String =\n // VULNERABLE: concat into prompt\n llm(s"System: helpful. User: $msg")\n', |
| 'def {fn}(msg: String): String =\n // SECURE: separated channels\n llm(system = "helpful", user = msg)\n'), |
|
|
| ("RAG Security", |
| 'def {fn}(q)\n # VULNERABLE: query into retrieval + prompt untrusted\n ctx = db.similarity_search(q)\n call_llm(ctx + q)\nend', |
| 'def {fn}(q)\n # SECURE: sanitize query, scope context, delimit\n call_llm(system: "Answer from context only.", user: sanitize(q), context: scoped(ctx))\nend', |
| 'def {fn}(q: String): String =\n // VULNERABLE: untrusted into RAG prompt\n llm(retrieve(q) + q)\n', |
| 'def {fn}(q: String): String =\n // SECURE: scope + delimit\n llm(system = "context only", context = scoped(retrieve(sanitize(q))))\n'), |
| ] |
|
|
| |
|
|
|
|
| def generic_ruby_scala(vuln, language, framework, difficulty, rng): |
| """Return (vuln_code, secure_code, exploit) for Ruby or Scala.""" |
| ep = _pick(rng, ["/api/x", "/v1/x", "/x", "/act"]) |
| p = _pick(rng, ["id", "q", "name", "token", "url", "file"]) |
| tbl = _pick(rng, ["users", "orders", "docs"]) |
| fn = _pick(rng, FUNCS) |
| for name, rv, rs, sv, ss in RUBY_SCALA: |
| if name == vuln: |
| comment = "# " if language == "Ruby" else "// " |
| if language == "Ruby": |
| v = rv.replace("{fn}", fn).replace("{p}", p).replace("{tbl}", tbl).replace("{ep}", ep).replace("{id}", p) |
| s = rs.replace("{fn}", fn).replace("{p}", p).replace("{tbl}", tbl).replace("{ep}", ep).replace("{id}", p) |
| else: |
| v = sv.replace("{fn}", fn).replace("{p}", p).replace("{tbl}", tbl).replace("{ep}", ep).replace("{id}", p) |
| s = ss.replace("{fn}", fn).replace("{p}", p).replace("{tbl}", tbl).replace("{ep}", ep).replace("{id}", p) |
| return v, s, f"Trigger via {ep}?{p}=<malicious>." |
| |
| if language == "Ruby": |
| if vuln == "GraphQL Security": |
| v = 'def {fn}\n # VULNERABLE: introspection + batching open\n MySchema.execute(params[:query])\nend'.replace("{fn}", fn) |
| s = 'def {fn}\n # SECURE: disable introspection in prod, cap depth\n MySchema.execute(params[:query], max_depth: 8)\nend'.replace("{fn}", fn) |
| elif vuln == "REST API Security": |
| v = 'def {fn}\n # VULNERABLE: no auth on endpoint\n render json: User.all\nend'.replace("{fn}", fn) |
| s = 'def {fn}\n # SECURE: before_action auth\n before_action :authenticate!\n render json: current_user.records\nend'.replace("{fn}", fn) |
| elif vuln == "gRPC Security": |
| v = 'def {fn}(req, ctx)\n # VULNERABLE: no authz\n GrpcServer.new.delete(req.id)\nend'.replace("{fn}", fn) |
| s = 'def {fn}(req, ctx)\n # SECURE: interceptor authz\n raise "forbidden" unless admin?(ctx)\n GrpcServer.new.delete(req.id)\nend'.replace("{fn}", fn) |
| elif vuln in ("Cloud Misconfiguration", "Kubernetes Security", "Docker Security"): |
| v = "# VULNERABLE: overly permissive config\n" + ("bucket.acl = 'public-read'" if vuln == "Cloud Misconfiguration" else "privileged: true") |
| s = "# SECURE: least privilege\n" + ("bucket.acl = 'private'" if vuln == "Cloud Misconfiguration" else "privileged: false\nreadOnlyRootFilesystem: true") |
| else: |
| v = f"# {vuln}: vulnerable pattern (Ruby)\nputs params[:{p}]" |
| s = f"# {vuln}: secure pattern (Ruby)\nputs sanitize(params[:{p}])" |
| else: |
| if vuln == "GraphQL Security": |
| v = 'def {fn}(q: String): Any =\n // VULNERABLE: introspection open\n executor.execute(q)\n'.replace("{fn}", fn) |
| s = 'def {fn}(q: String): Any =\n // SECURE: disable introspection + depth limit\n executor.execute(q, maxDepth = 8)\n'.replace("{fn}", fn) |
| elif vuln == "REST API Security": |
| v = 'def {fn}(): List[User] =\n // VULNERABLE: no auth\n userRepo.findAll()\n'.replace("{fn}", fn) |
| s = 'def {fn}(): List[User] =\n // SECURE: auth gate\n if (auth.authenticated) userRepo.findByOwner(currentUser) else throw new SecurityException("no")\n'.replace("{fn}", fn) |
| elif vuln == "gRPC Security": |
| v = 'def {fn}(req: Id): Unit =\n // VULNERABLE: no authz\n grpcServer.delete(req.id)\n'.replace("{fn}", fn) |
| s = 'def {fn}(req: Id): Unit =\n // SECURE: interceptor authz\n if (authz.can(currentUser, "delete")) grpcServer.delete(req.id)\n'.replace("{fn}", fn) |
| elif vuln in ("Cloud Misconfiguration", "Kubernetes Security", "Docker Security"): |
| v = "// VULNERABLE: overly permissive config\n" + ("bucket.setAcl(PUBLIC_READ)" if vuln == "Cloud Misconfiguration" else "privileged = true") |
| s = "// SECURE: least privilege\n" + ("bucket.setAcl(PRIVATE)" if vuln == "Cloud Misconfiguration" else "privileged = false\nreadOnlyRootFilesystem = true") |
| else: |
| v = f"// {vuln}: vulnerable pattern (Scala)\nprintln({p})" |
| s = f"// {vuln}: secure pattern (Scala)\nsanitize({p})" |
| return v, s, f"Trigger via {ep}." |
|
|