{ "schema_version": "savc.public.depth_study.v1", "status": "COMPLETE_CRITERIA_NOT_MET", "study": { "selected_episode_count": 60, "condition_count": 9, "model_family_count": 2, "repeat_count": 2, "scheduled_trace_count": 2160, "valid_trace_count": 2157, "invalid_trace_count": 3, "human_relabeling_performed": false }, "execution_integrity": { "evaluation_labels_exposed_to_generation": false, "scientific_outputs_inspected_before_scoring_rules_fixed": false, "role_isolation_violations": 0, "all_parseability_requirements_met": true, "initial_output_cap_tokens": 500, "qualified_output_cap_tokens": 1000, "output_cap_qualification_used_scientific_results": false, "only_failed_slots_regenerated_after_quota_errors": true, "scoring_api_calls": 0, "trace_regeneration_during_scoring": false }, "prespecified_criteria": { "handoff_failure_exists": "FAIL", "depth_response_exists": "FAIL", "receipts_preserve_evidence_in_both_model_families": "FAIL", "detachment_has_action_consequence_in_both_model_families": "FAIL", "runtime_gate_reduces_harm": "NOT_ESTIMABLE" }, "handoff_results": { "openai_family": { "unstructured_depth4_final_evidence_detachment_rate": 1.0, "structured_depth4_final_evidence_detachment_rate": 0.291667, "unstructured_minus_structured_risk_difference": 0.708333, "paired_bootstrap_95_ci": [ 0.608333, 0.8 ] }, "anthropic_family": { "unstructured_depth4_final_evidence_detachment_rate": 1.0, "structured_depth4_final_evidence_detachment_rate": 1.0, "unstructured_minus_structured_risk_difference": 0.0, "paired_bootstrap_95_ci": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "structured_responsibility_survival_by_hop": { "1": 1.0, "2": 0.0, "3": 0.0, "4": 0.0 } } }, "action_result": { "evaluator_labeled_commit_eligible_traces": 648, "observed_committed_actions": 17, "useful_commits": 0, "unsupported_commits": 17, "root_positive_or_negative_status_count": 0, "action_effect_interpretable": false }, "input_audit": { "evaluator_labeled_commit_eligible_episode_count": 18, "empty_visible_evidence_count": 9, "source_identifier_only_visible_evidence_count": 9, "direct_result_payload_count": 0, "claims_requesting_tool_use": 18, "scientific_tool_interface_available": false, "action_result_interpretable_from_provided_inputs": false }, "result_classification": { "primary_claim": "The depth and action study did not meet its prespecified success criteria across both model families.", "supported_secondary_claim": "Structured receipts reduced depth-four evidence detachment in one model family but did not transfer to the second family.", "failure_diagnosis": "Agents were not given result-bearing evidence in any commit-eligible episode, so the action result could not be interpreted.", "biological_discovery_claim_supported": false, "soft_semantic_verifier_validated": false }, "release_boundary": { "aggregate_only": true, "raw_traces_in_output": false, "row_level_scores_in_output": false, "episode_ids_in_output": false, "source_ids_in_output": false, "hidden_labels_in_output": false, "local_paths_in_output": false, "credentials_in_output": false, "biological_design_instructions_in_output": false }, "study_id": "depth_study" }