pr para commentary commit_s commit_e draft para_hash block_hash url AB paragraph pr_dis node_dis_index paths mail_commentary 131 "When a PE receives a packet from a CE, on a given AC with DetNet service, it first checks via Stream Identification (see Clause 6. of IEEE8021CB and IEEEP8021CBdb) whether the packet belongs to a configured TSN Stream (i.e., App-flow from DetNet perspective). If no Stream ID is matched and no other (VPN) service is configured for the AC then packet MUST be dropped. If there is a matching TSN Stream then the Stream ID specific TSN functions are executed (e.g., ingress policing, header field manipulation in case of active Stream Identification, FRER, etc.). Source MAC lookup may also be used for local MAC address learning." "Adding commas , the editor will probably catch these . Hi , many thanks for the review . " fcee32ea5dd06be55c38ff89aaa34b62383e7527 fcee32ea5dd06be55c38ff89aaa34b62383e7527 draft-ietf-detnet-tsn-vpn-over-mpls 1cc9810ece3682deda626f30e1dfa36339ab3eb464ebaee290218394d3e4eff9 ['9729271c7f063c6e029ffbff4ea4bb4436ef19901e7bd69e7cde639df396fd54', '1cc9810ece3682deda626f30e1dfa36339ab3eb464ebaee290218394d3e4eff9'] A "when a pe receives a packet from a ce, on a given ac with detnet service, it first checks via stream identification (see clause 6. of ieee8021cb and ieeep8021cbdb) whether the packet belongs to a configured tsn stream (i.e., app-flow from detnet perspective). if no stream id is matched and no other (vpn) service is configured for the ac then packet must be dropped. if there is a matching tsn stream then the stream id specific tsn functions are executed (e.g., ingress policing, header field manipulation in case of active stream identification, frer, etc.). source mac lookup may also be used for local mac address learning." {130: 1, 6: 5, 79: 4, 90: 6, 51: 6, 62: 8, 85: 8, 68: 7, 35: 6, 110: 6, 91: 8, 114: 6, 97: 6, 31: 6, 13: 6, 67: 6, 38: 7, 26: 6, 124: 2, 98: 3, 54: 5, 127: 6, 8: 5, 96: 6, 64: 5, 30: 7, 61: 8, 55: 6, 27: 7, 15: 6, 52: 5, 129: 6, 115: 6, 84: 6, 76: 9, 87: 6, 131: 6, 102: 6, 113: 8, 99: 5, 36: 6, 24: 5, 53: 4, 72: 7} {168: 1, 1: 12, 4: 5, 9: 8, 10: 6, 15: 6, 24: 5, 25: 8, 26: 8, 27: 6, 39: 8, 43: 6, 49: 9, 50: 8, 58: 8, 59: 5, 64: 6, 69: 7, 81: 9, 82: 7, 86: 6, 96: 7, 97: 6, 100: 10, 108: 6, 109: 5, 110: 5, 111: 5, 114: 6, 115: 7, 116: 6, 118: 9, 119: 8, 120: 6, 121: 7, 122: 7, 123: 6, 124: 7, 128: 7, 129: 7, 130: 8, 132: 7, 136: 5, 145: 7, 147: 7, 151: 7, 152: 7, 154: 6, 156: 5, 161: 6, 162: 6, 165: 6, 169: 6, 172: 6, 180: 7, 184: 8, 187: 8, 188: 7, 191: 4, 194: 7, 202: 8, 203: 9, 206: 3, 207: 2, 215: 5, 217: 6, 218: 11, 220: 5, 221: 5, 222: 8, 224: 6, 227: 8, 229: 6, 235: 5, 241: 5, 242: 5, 243: 7, 244: 7, 245: 7, 248: 7, 250: 7, 258: 14, 262: 5, 263: 6, 264: 6, 267: 7, 270: 6, 272: 6, 273: 8, 287: 6, 289: 6, 291: 8, 299: 8, 300: 6, 304: 6, 309: 6, 314: 5, 315: 6, 320: 7, 323: 7, 327: 7, 328: 6, 329: 5, 330: 13, 334: 5, 335: 6, 341: 8, 342: 9, 347: 8, 348: 8, 350: 10, 351: 8, 352: 6, 353: 6, 354: 5, 358: 7, 365: 6, 366: 5, 369: 4, 371: 10, 372: 8, 376: 5, 384: 8, 385: 7, 386: 6, 387: 6, 392: 6, 393: 7, 396: 9, 397: 10, 398: 9, 402: 6} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 131 "When a PE receives a packet from a CE, on a given AC with DetNet service, it first checks via Stream Identification (see Clause 6. of IEEE8021CB and IEEEP8021CBdb) whether the packet belongs to a configured TSN Stream (i.e., App-flow from DetNet perspective). If no Stream ID is matched and no other (VPN) service is configured for the AC, then packet MUST be dropped. If there is a matching TSN Stream, then the Stream ID specific TSN functions are executed (e.g., ingress policing, header field manipulation in case of active Stream Identification, FRER, etc.). Source MAC lookup may also be used for local MAC address learning." "Adding commas , the editor will probably catch these . Hi , many thanks for the review . " fcee32ea5dd06be55c38ff89aaa34b62383e7527 fcee32ea5dd06be55c38ff89aaa34b62383e7527 draft-ietf-detnet-tsn-vpn-over-mpls 9729271c7f063c6e029ffbff4ea4bb4436ef19901e7bd69e7cde639df396fd54 ['9729271c7f063c6e029ffbff4ea4bb4436ef19901e7bd69e7cde639df396fd54', '1cc9810ece3682deda626f30e1dfa36339ab3eb464ebaee290218394d3e4eff9'] B "when a pe receives a packet from a ce, on a given ac with detnet service, it first checks via stream identification (see clause 6. of ieee8021cb and ieeep8021cbdb) whether the packet belongs to a configured tsn stream (i.e., app-flow from detnet perspective). if no stream id is matched and no other (vpn) service is configured for the ac, then packet must be dropped. if there is a matching tsn stream, then the stream id specific tsn functions are executed (e.g., ingress policing, header field manipulation in case of active stream identification, frer, etc.). source mac lookup may also be used for local mac address learning." {130: 1, 6: 5, 79: 4, 90: 6, 51: 6, 62: 8, 85: 8, 68: 7, 35: 6, 110: 6, 91: 8, 114: 6, 97: 6, 31: 6, 13: 6, 67: 6, 38: 7, 26: 6, 124: 2, 98: 3, 54: 5, 127: 6, 8: 5, 96: 6, 64: 5, 30: 7, 61: 8, 55: 6, 27: 7, 15: 6, 52: 5, 129: 6, 115: 6, 84: 6, 76: 9, 87: 6, 131: 6, 102: 6, 113: 8, 99: 5, 36: 6, 24: 5, 53: 4, 72: 7} {168: 1, 1: 12, 4: 5, 9: 8, 10: 6, 15: 6, 24: 5, 25: 8, 26: 8, 27: 6, 39: 8, 43: 6, 49: 9, 50: 8, 58: 8, 59: 5, 64: 6, 69: 7, 81: 9, 82: 7, 86: 6, 96: 7, 97: 6, 100: 10, 108: 6, 109: 5, 110: 5, 111: 5, 114: 6, 115: 7, 116: 6, 118: 9, 119: 8, 120: 6, 121: 7, 122: 7, 123: 6, 124: 7, 128: 7, 129: 7, 130: 8, 132: 7, 136: 5, 145: 7, 147: 7, 151: 7, 152: 7, 154: 6, 156: 5, 161: 6, 162: 6, 165: 6, 169: 6, 172: 6, 180: 7, 184: 8, 187: 8, 188: 7, 191: 4, 194: 7, 202: 8, 203: 9, 206: 3, 207: 2, 215: 5, 217: 6, 218: 11, 220: 5, 221: 5, 222: 8, 224: 6, 227: 8, 229: 6, 235: 5, 241: 5, 242: 5, 243: 7, 244: 7, 245: 7, 248: 7, 250: 7, 258: 14, 262: 5, 263: 6, 264: 6, 267: 7, 270: 6, 272: 6, 273: 8, 287: 6, 289: 6, 291: 8, 299: 8, 300: 6, 304: 6, 309: 6, 314: 5, 315: 6, 320: 7, 323: 7, 327: 7, 328: 6, 329: 5, 330: 13, 334: 5, 335: 6, 341: 8, 342: 9, 347: 8, 348: 8, 350: 10, 351: 8, 352: 6, 353: 6, 354: 5, 358: 7, 365: 6, 366: 5, 369: 4, 371: 10, 372: 8, 376: 5, 384: 8, 385: 7, 386: 6, 387: 6, 392: 6, 393: 7, 396: 9, 397: 10, 398: 9, 402: 6} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 131 "If the PE decides to forward the packet, the packet MUST be forwarded according to the TSN Stream specific configuration to connected CE(s) (in case of local bridging) and/or to the DetNet Service Proxy (in case of forwarding to remote CE(s)). If there are no TSN Stream specific forwarding configurations the PE MUST flood the packet to other locally attached CE(s) and to the DetNet Service Proxy. If the administrative policy on the PE does not allow flooding the PE MUST drop the packet." "Adding commas , the editor will probably catch these . Hi , many thanks for the review . " fcee32ea5dd06be55c38ff89aaa34b62383e7527 fcee32ea5dd06be55c38ff89aaa34b62383e7527 draft-ietf-detnet-tsn-vpn-over-mpls ab12071fc42e8540b5e57d7bcaff527c577148cf803114aa9627e1a77e39c093 ['ab12071fc42e8540b5e57d7bcaff527c577148cf803114aa9627e1a77e39c093', '9c5dac93c7991e4bb94e295e72cca6126469fd0bfd0f4b72029341535a74c8c1', '80c9534ddf55165b581d4c1dd118ce22169c5c53029a12e5096ca77cc90f4ce5', '702f27b5ac6792d33835d63983bde747072ac3fe361626fe44185d576bc05641', '4083b88441d42b789448a36d1a2c25a709a4230ddfbb5243525e9e403a2a3fca', 'df8de9173820ce9dbec12be38d4edebf5e90a9993b7ba1c762553f3c11aca961'] A "if the pe decides to forward the packet, the packet must be forwarded according to the tsn stream specific configuration to connected ce(s) (in case of local bridging) and/or to the detnet service proxy (in case of forwarding to remote ce(s)). if there are no tsn stream specific forwarding configurations the pe must flood the packet to other locally attached ce(s) and to the detnet service proxy. if the administrative policy on the pe does not allow flooding the pe must drop the packet." {124: 1, 130: 1, 6: 5, 79: 2, 90: 6, 51: 6, 62: 8, 85: 8, 68: 7, 35: 6, 110: 6, 91: 8, 114: 6, 97: 6, 31: 6, 13: 6, 67: 6, 38: 7, 26: 6, 98: 2, 54: 5, 127: 6, 8: 5, 96: 6, 64: 5, 30: 7, 61: 8, 55: 6, 27: 7, 15: 6, 52: 5, 129: 6, 115: 6, 84: 6, 76: 9, 87: 6, 131: 6, 102: 6, 113: 8, 99: 5, 36: 6, 24: 5, 53: 4, 72: 7} {109: 1, 262: 1, 1: 12, 4: 5, 9: 8, 10: 6, 15: 6, 24: 5, 25: 8, 26: 8, 27: 6, 39: 8, 43: 6, 49: 9, 50: 8, 58: 8, 59: 5, 64: 6, 69: 7, 81: 9, 82: 7, 86: 6, 96: 7, 97: 6, 100: 10, 108: 6, 110: 2, 111: 5, 114: 6, 115: 7, 116: 6, 118: 9, 119: 8, 120: 6, 121: 7, 122: 7, 123: 6, 124: 7, 128: 7, 129: 7, 130: 8, 132: 7, 136: 5, 145: 7, 147: 7, 151: 7, 152: 7, 154: 6, 156: 5, 161: 6, 162: 6, 165: 6, 168: 5, 169: 6, 172: 6, 180: 7, 184: 8, 187: 8, 188: 7, 191: 2, 194: 7, 202: 8, 203: 9, 206: 3, 207: 4, 215: 5, 217: 6, 218: 11, 220: 5, 221: 5, 222: 8, 224: 6, 227: 8, 229: 6, 234: 6, 235: 5, 241: 5, 242: 5, 243: 7, 244: 7, 245: 7, 248: 7, 250: 7, 258: 14, 264: 6, 267: 7, 270: 6, 272: 6, 273: 8, 287: 6, 289: 6, 291: 8, 299: 8, 300: 6, 304: 6, 309: 6, 314: 5, 315: 6, 320: 7, 323: 7, 327: 7, 328: 6, 329: 5, 330: 13, 334: 5, 335: 6, 341: 8, 342: 9, 347: 8, 348: 8, 350: 10, 351: 8, 352: 6, 353: 6, 354: 5, 358: 7, 365: 6, 366: 5, 369: 4, 371: 10, 372: 8, 376: 5, 384: 8, 385: 7, 386: 6, 387: 6, 392: 6, 393: 7, 396: 9, 397: 10, 398: 9, 402: 6} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 131 "When a TSN entity of the PE receives a packet from the DetNet Service Proxy, it first checks via Stream Identification (see Clause 6. of IEEE8021CB and IEEEP8021CBdb) whether the packet belongs to a configured TSN Stream. If no Stream ID is matched then packet is dropped. If there is a matching TSN Stream then the Stream ID specific TSN functions are executed (e.g., header field manipulation in case of active Stream Identification, FRER, etc.). Source MAC lookup may also be used for local MAC address learning." "Adding commas , the editor will probably catch these . Hi , many thanks for the review . " fcee32ea5dd06be55c38ff89aaa34b62383e7527 fcee32ea5dd06be55c38ff89aaa34b62383e7527 draft-ietf-detnet-tsn-vpn-over-mpls 702f27b5ac6792d33835d63983bde747072ac3fe361626fe44185d576bc05641 ['ab12071fc42e8540b5e57d7bcaff527c577148cf803114aa9627e1a77e39c093', '9c5dac93c7991e4bb94e295e72cca6126469fd0bfd0f4b72029341535a74c8c1', '80c9534ddf55165b581d4c1dd118ce22169c5c53029a12e5096ca77cc90f4ce5', '702f27b5ac6792d33835d63983bde747072ac3fe361626fe44185d576bc05641', '4083b88441d42b789448a36d1a2c25a709a4230ddfbb5243525e9e403a2a3fca', 'df8de9173820ce9dbec12be38d4edebf5e90a9993b7ba1c762553f3c11aca961'] A "when a tsn entity of the pe receives a packet from the detnet service proxy, it first checks via stream identification (see clause 6. of ieee8021cb and ieeep8021cbdb) whether the packet belongs to a configured tsn stream. if no stream id is matched then packet is dropped. if there is a matching tsn stream then the stream id specific tsn functions are executed (e.g., header field manipulation in case of active stream identification, frer, etc.). source mac lookup may also be used for local mac address learning." {124: 1, 130: 1, 6: 5, 79: 2, 90: 6, 51: 6, 62: 8, 85: 8, 68: 7, 35: 6, 110: 6, 91: 8, 114: 6, 97: 6, 31: 6, 13: 6, 67: 6, 38: 7, 26: 6, 98: 2, 54: 5, 127: 6, 8: 5, 96: 6, 64: 5, 30: 7, 61: 8, 55: 6, 27: 7, 15: 6, 52: 5, 129: 6, 115: 6, 84: 6, 76: 9, 87: 6, 131: 6, 102: 6, 113: 8, 99: 5, 36: 6, 24: 5, 53: 4, 72: 7} {109: 1, 262: 1, 1: 12, 4: 5, 9: 8, 10: 6, 15: 6, 24: 5, 25: 8, 26: 8, 27: 6, 39: 8, 43: 6, 49: 9, 50: 8, 58: 8, 59: 5, 64: 6, 69: 7, 81: 9, 82: 7, 86: 6, 96: 7, 97: 6, 100: 10, 108: 6, 110: 2, 111: 5, 114: 6, 115: 7, 116: 6, 118: 9, 119: 8, 120: 6, 121: 7, 122: 7, 123: 6, 124: 7, 128: 7, 129: 7, 130: 8, 132: 7, 136: 5, 145: 7, 147: 7, 151: 7, 152: 7, 154: 6, 156: 5, 161: 6, 162: 6, 165: 6, 168: 5, 169: 6, 172: 6, 180: 7, 184: 8, 187: 8, 188: 7, 191: 2, 194: 7, 202: 8, 203: 9, 206: 3, 207: 4, 215: 5, 217: 6, 218: 11, 220: 5, 221: 5, 222: 8, 224: 6, 227: 8, 229: 6, 234: 6, 235: 5, 241: 5, 242: 5, 243: 7, 244: 7, 245: 7, 248: 7, 250: 7, 258: 14, 264: 6, 267: 7, 270: 6, 272: 6, 273: 8, 287: 6, 289: 6, 291: 8, 299: 8, 300: 6, 304: 6, 309: 6, 314: 5, 315: 6, 320: 7, 323: 7, 327: 7, 328: 6, 329: 5, 330: 13, 334: 5, 335: 6, 341: 8, 342: 9, 347: 8, 348: 8, 350: 10, 351: 8, 352: 6, 353: 6, 354: 5, 358: 7, 365: 6, 366: 5, 369: 4, 371: 10, 372: 8, 376: 5, 384: 8, 385: 7, 386: 6, 387: 6, 392: 6, 393: 7, 396: 9, 397: 10, 398: 9, 402: 6} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 131 "If the PE decides to forward the packet, the packet is forwarded according to the TSN Stream specific configuration to connected CE(s). If there are no TSN Stream specific forwarding configurations the PE floods the packet to locally attached CE(s). If the administrative policy on the PE does not allow flooding the PE drops the packet." "Adding commas , the editor will probably catch these . Hi , many thanks for the review . " fcee32ea5dd06be55c38ff89aaa34b62383e7527 fcee32ea5dd06be55c38ff89aaa34b62383e7527 draft-ietf-detnet-tsn-vpn-over-mpls 9c5dac93c7991e4bb94e295e72cca6126469fd0bfd0f4b72029341535a74c8c1 ['ab12071fc42e8540b5e57d7bcaff527c577148cf803114aa9627e1a77e39c093', '9c5dac93c7991e4bb94e295e72cca6126469fd0bfd0f4b72029341535a74c8c1', '80c9534ddf55165b581d4c1dd118ce22169c5c53029a12e5096ca77cc90f4ce5', '702f27b5ac6792d33835d63983bde747072ac3fe361626fe44185d576bc05641', '4083b88441d42b789448a36d1a2c25a709a4230ddfbb5243525e9e403a2a3fca', 'df8de9173820ce9dbec12be38d4edebf5e90a9993b7ba1c762553f3c11aca961'] A "if the pe decides to forward the packet, the packet is forwarded according to the tsn stream specific configuration to connected ce(s). if there are no tsn stream specific forwarding configurations the pe floods the packet to locally attached ce(s). if the administrative policy on the pe does not allow flooding the pe drops the packet." {124: 1, 130: 1, 6: 5, 79: 2, 90: 6, 51: 6, 62: 8, 85: 8, 68: 7, 35: 6, 110: 6, 91: 8, 114: 6, 97: 6, 31: 6, 13: 6, 67: 6, 38: 7, 26: 6, 98: 2, 54: 5, 127: 6, 8: 5, 96: 6, 64: 5, 30: 7, 61: 8, 55: 6, 27: 7, 15: 6, 52: 5, 129: 6, 115: 6, 84: 6, 76: 9, 87: 6, 131: 6, 102: 6, 113: 8, 99: 5, 36: 6, 24: 5, 53: 4, 72: 7} {109: 1, 262: 1, 1: 12, 4: 5, 9: 8, 10: 6, 15: 6, 24: 5, 25: 8, 26: 8, 27: 6, 39: 8, 43: 6, 49: 9, 50: 8, 58: 8, 59: 5, 64: 6, 69: 7, 81: 9, 82: 7, 86: 6, 96: 7, 97: 6, 100: 10, 108: 6, 110: 2, 111: 5, 114: 6, 115: 7, 116: 6, 118: 9, 119: 8, 120: 6, 121: 7, 122: 7, 123: 6, 124: 7, 128: 7, 129: 7, 130: 8, 132: 7, 136: 5, 145: 7, 147: 7, 151: 7, 152: 7, 154: 6, 156: 5, 161: 6, 162: 6, 165: 6, 168: 5, 169: 6, 172: 6, 180: 7, 184: 8, 187: 8, 188: 7, 191: 2, 194: 7, 202: 8, 203: 9, 206: 3, 207: 4, 215: 5, 217: 6, 218: 11, 220: 5, 221: 5, 222: 8, 224: 6, 227: 8, 229: 6, 234: 6, 235: 5, 241: 5, 242: 5, 243: 7, 244: 7, 245: 7, 248: 7, 250: 7, 258: 14, 264: 6, 267: 7, 270: 6, 272: 6, 273: 8, 287: 6, 289: 6, 291: 8, 299: 8, 300: 6, 304: 6, 309: 6, 314: 5, 315: 6, 320: 7, 323: 7, 327: 7, 328: 6, 329: 5, 330: 13, 334: 5, 335: 6, 341: 8, 342: 9, 347: 8, 348: 8, 350: 10, 351: 8, 352: 6, 353: 6, 354: 5, 358: 7, 365: 6, 366: 5, 369: 4, 371: 10, 372: 8, 376: 5, 384: 8, 385: 7, 386: 6, 387: 6, 392: 6, 393: 7, 396: 9, 397: 10, 398: 9, 402: 6} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 131 "If the PE decides to forward the packet, the packet MUST be forwarded according to the TSN Stream specific configuration to connected CE(s) (in case of local bridging) and/or to the DetNet Service Proxy (in case of forwarding to remote CE(s)). If there are no TSN Stream specific forwarding configurations, the PE MUST flood the packet to other locally attached CE(s) and to the DetNet Service Proxy. If the administrative policy on the PE does not allow flooding, the PE MUST drop the packet." "Adding commas , the editor will probably catch these . Hi , many thanks for the review . " fcee32ea5dd06be55c38ff89aaa34b62383e7527 fcee32ea5dd06be55c38ff89aaa34b62383e7527 draft-ietf-detnet-tsn-vpn-over-mpls 4083b88441d42b789448a36d1a2c25a709a4230ddfbb5243525e9e403a2a3fca ['ab12071fc42e8540b5e57d7bcaff527c577148cf803114aa9627e1a77e39c093', '9c5dac93c7991e4bb94e295e72cca6126469fd0bfd0f4b72029341535a74c8c1', '80c9534ddf55165b581d4c1dd118ce22169c5c53029a12e5096ca77cc90f4ce5', '702f27b5ac6792d33835d63983bde747072ac3fe361626fe44185d576bc05641', '4083b88441d42b789448a36d1a2c25a709a4230ddfbb5243525e9e403a2a3fca', 'df8de9173820ce9dbec12be38d4edebf5e90a9993b7ba1c762553f3c11aca961'] B "if the pe decides to forward the packet, the packet must be forwarded according to the tsn stream specific configuration to connected ce(s) (in case of local bridging) and/or to the detnet service proxy (in case of forwarding to remote ce(s)). if there are no tsn stream specific forwarding configurations, the pe must flood the packet to other locally attached ce(s) and to the detnet service proxy. if the administrative policy on the pe does not allow flooding, the pe must drop the packet." {124: 1, 130: 1, 6: 5, 79: 2, 90: 6, 51: 6, 62: 8, 85: 8, 68: 7, 35: 6, 110: 6, 91: 8, 114: 6, 97: 6, 31: 6, 13: 6, 67: 6, 38: 7, 26: 6, 98: 2, 54: 5, 127: 6, 8: 5, 96: 6, 64: 5, 30: 7, 61: 8, 55: 6, 27: 7, 15: 6, 52: 5, 129: 6, 115: 6, 84: 6, 76: 9, 87: 6, 131: 6, 102: 6, 113: 8, 99: 5, 36: 6, 24: 5, 53: 4, 72: 7} {109: 1, 262: 1, 1: 12, 4: 5, 9: 8, 10: 6, 15: 6, 24: 5, 25: 8, 26: 8, 27: 6, 39: 8, 43: 6, 49: 9, 50: 8, 58: 8, 59: 5, 64: 6, 69: 7, 81: 9, 82: 7, 86: 6, 96: 7, 97: 6, 100: 10, 108: 6, 110: 2, 111: 5, 114: 6, 115: 7, 116: 6, 118: 9, 119: 8, 120: 6, 121: 7, 122: 7, 123: 6, 124: 7, 128: 7, 129: 7, 130: 8, 132: 7, 136: 5, 145: 7, 147: 7, 151: 7, 152: 7, 154: 6, 156: 5, 161: 6, 162: 6, 165: 6, 168: 5, 169: 6, 172: 6, 180: 7, 184: 8, 187: 8, 188: 7, 191: 2, 194: 7, 202: 8, 203: 9, 206: 3, 207: 4, 215: 5, 217: 6, 218: 11, 220: 5, 221: 5, 222: 8, 224: 6, 227: 8, 229: 6, 234: 6, 235: 5, 241: 5, 242: 5, 243: 7, 244: 7, 245: 7, 248: 7, 250: 7, 258: 14, 264: 6, 267: 7, 270: 6, 272: 6, 273: 8, 287: 6, 289: 6, 291: 8, 299: 8, 300: 6, 304: 6, 309: 6, 314: 5, 315: 6, 320: 7, 323: 7, 327: 7, 328: 6, 329: 5, 330: 13, 334: 5, 335: 6, 341: 8, 342: 9, 347: 8, 348: 8, 350: 10, 351: 8, 352: 6, 353: 6, 354: 5, 358: 7, 365: 6, 366: 5, 369: 4, 371: 10, 372: 8, 376: 5, 384: 8, 385: 7, 386: 6, 387: 6, 392: 6, 393: 7, 396: 9, 397: 10, 398: 9, 402: 6} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 131 "When a TSN entity of the PE receives a packet from the DetNet Service Proxy, it first checks via Stream Identification (see Clause 6. of IEEE8021CB and IEEEP8021CBdb) whether the packet belongs to a configured TSN Stream. If no Stream ID is matched, then packet is dropped. If there is a matching TSN Stream, then the Stream ID specific TSN functions are executed (e.g., header field manipulation in case of active Stream Identification, FRER, etc.). Source MAC lookup may also be used for local MAC address learning." "Adding commas , the editor will probably catch these . Hi , many thanks for the review . " fcee32ea5dd06be55c38ff89aaa34b62383e7527 fcee32ea5dd06be55c38ff89aaa34b62383e7527 draft-ietf-detnet-tsn-vpn-over-mpls 80c9534ddf55165b581d4c1dd118ce22169c5c53029a12e5096ca77cc90f4ce5 ['ab12071fc42e8540b5e57d7bcaff527c577148cf803114aa9627e1a77e39c093', '9c5dac93c7991e4bb94e295e72cca6126469fd0bfd0f4b72029341535a74c8c1', '80c9534ddf55165b581d4c1dd118ce22169c5c53029a12e5096ca77cc90f4ce5', '702f27b5ac6792d33835d63983bde747072ac3fe361626fe44185d576bc05641', '4083b88441d42b789448a36d1a2c25a709a4230ddfbb5243525e9e403a2a3fca', 'df8de9173820ce9dbec12be38d4edebf5e90a9993b7ba1c762553f3c11aca961'] B "when a tsn entity of the pe receives a packet from the detnet service proxy, it first checks via stream identification (see clause 6. of ieee8021cb and ieeep8021cbdb) whether the packet belongs to a configured tsn stream. if no stream id is matched, then packet is dropped. if there is a matching tsn stream, then the stream id specific tsn functions are executed (e.g., header field manipulation in case of active stream identification, frer, etc.). source mac lookup may also be used for local mac address learning." {124: 1, 130: 1, 6: 5, 79: 2, 90: 6, 51: 6, 62: 8, 85: 8, 68: 7, 35: 6, 110: 6, 91: 8, 114: 6, 97: 6, 31: 6, 13: 6, 67: 6, 38: 7, 26: 6, 98: 2, 54: 5, 127: 6, 8: 5, 96: 6, 64: 5, 30: 7, 61: 8, 55: 6, 27: 7, 15: 6, 52: 5, 129: 6, 115: 6, 84: 6, 76: 9, 87: 6, 131: 6, 102: 6, 113: 8, 99: 5, 36: 6, 24: 5, 53: 4, 72: 7} {109: 1, 262: 1, 1: 12, 4: 5, 9: 8, 10: 6, 15: 6, 24: 5, 25: 8, 26: 8, 27: 6, 39: 8, 43: 6, 49: 9, 50: 8, 58: 8, 59: 5, 64: 6, 69: 7, 81: 9, 82: 7, 86: 6, 96: 7, 97: 6, 100: 10, 108: 6, 110: 2, 111: 5, 114: 6, 115: 7, 116: 6, 118: 9, 119: 8, 120: 6, 121: 7, 122: 7, 123: 6, 124: 7, 128: 7, 129: 7, 130: 8, 132: 7, 136: 5, 145: 7, 147: 7, 151: 7, 152: 7, 154: 6, 156: 5, 161: 6, 162: 6, 165: 6, 168: 5, 169: 6, 172: 6, 180: 7, 184: 8, 187: 8, 188: 7, 191: 2, 194: 7, 202: 8, 203: 9, 206: 3, 207: 4, 215: 5, 217: 6, 218: 11, 220: 5, 221: 5, 222: 8, 224: 6, 227: 8, 229: 6, 234: 6, 235: 5, 241: 5, 242: 5, 243: 7, 244: 7, 245: 7, 248: 7, 250: 7, 258: 14, 264: 6, 267: 7, 270: 6, 272: 6, 273: 8, 287: 6, 289: 6, 291: 8, 299: 8, 300: 6, 304: 6, 309: 6, 314: 5, 315: 6, 320: 7, 323: 7, 327: 7, 328: 6, 329: 5, 330: 13, 334: 5, 335: 6, 341: 8, 342: 9, 347: 8, 348: 8, 350: 10, 351: 8, 352: 6, 353: 6, 354: 5, 358: 7, 365: 6, 366: 5, 369: 4, 371: 10, 372: 8, 376: 5, 384: 8, 385: 7, 386: 6, 387: 6, 392: 6, 393: 7, 396: 9, 397: 10, 398: 9, 402: 6} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 131 "If the PE decides to forward the packet, the packet is forwarded according to the TSN Stream specific configuration to connected CE(s). If there are no TSN Stream specific forwarding configurations, the PE floods the packet to locally attached CE(s). If the administrative policy on the PE does not allow flooding, the PE drops the packet." "Adding commas , the editor will probably catch these . Hi , many thanks for the review . " fcee32ea5dd06be55c38ff89aaa34b62383e7527 fcee32ea5dd06be55c38ff89aaa34b62383e7527 draft-ietf-detnet-tsn-vpn-over-mpls df8de9173820ce9dbec12be38d4edebf5e90a9993b7ba1c762553f3c11aca961 ['ab12071fc42e8540b5e57d7bcaff527c577148cf803114aa9627e1a77e39c093', '9c5dac93c7991e4bb94e295e72cca6126469fd0bfd0f4b72029341535a74c8c1', '80c9534ddf55165b581d4c1dd118ce22169c5c53029a12e5096ca77cc90f4ce5', '702f27b5ac6792d33835d63983bde747072ac3fe361626fe44185d576bc05641', '4083b88441d42b789448a36d1a2c25a709a4230ddfbb5243525e9e403a2a3fca', 'df8de9173820ce9dbec12be38d4edebf5e90a9993b7ba1c762553f3c11aca961'] B "if the pe decides to forward the packet, the packet is forwarded according to the tsn stream specific configuration to connected ce(s). if there are no tsn stream specific forwarding configurations, the pe floods the packet to locally attached ce(s). if the administrative policy on the pe does not allow flooding, the pe drops the packet." {124: 1, 130: 1, 6: 5, 79: 2, 90: 6, 51: 6, 62: 8, 85: 8, 68: 7, 35: 6, 110: 6, 91: 8, 114: 6, 97: 6, 31: 6, 13: 6, 67: 6, 38: 7, 26: 6, 98: 2, 54: 5, 127: 6, 8: 5, 96: 6, 64: 5, 30: 7, 61: 8, 55: 6, 27: 7, 15: 6, 52: 5, 129: 6, 115: 6, 84: 6, 76: 9, 87: 6, 131: 6, 102: 6, 113: 8, 99: 5, 36: 6, 24: 5, 53: 4, 72: 7} {109: 1, 262: 1, 1: 12, 4: 5, 9: 8, 10: 6, 15: 6, 24: 5, 25: 8, 26: 8, 27: 6, 39: 8, 43: 6, 49: 9, 50: 8, 58: 8, 59: 5, 64: 6, 69: 7, 81: 9, 82: 7, 86: 6, 96: 7, 97: 6, 100: 10, 108: 6, 110: 2, 111: 5, 114: 6, 115: 7, 116: 6, 118: 9, 119: 8, 120: 6, 121: 7, 122: 7, 123: 6, 124: 7, 128: 7, 129: 7, 130: 8, 132: 7, 136: 5, 145: 7, 147: 7, 151: 7, 152: 7, 154: 6, 156: 5, 161: 6, 162: 6, 165: 6, 168: 5, 169: 6, 172: 6, 180: 7, 184: 8, 187: 8, 188: 7, 191: 2, 194: 7, 202: 8, 203: 9, 206: 3, 207: 4, 215: 5, 217: 6, 218: 11, 220: 5, 221: 5, 222: 8, 224: 6, 227: 8, 229: 6, 234: 6, 235: 5, 241: 5, 242: 5, 243: 7, 244: 7, 245: 7, 248: 7, 250: 7, 258: 14, 264: 6, 267: 7, 270: 6, 272: 6, 273: 8, 287: 6, 289: 6, 291: 8, 299: 8, 300: 6, 304: 6, 309: 6, 314: 5, 315: 6, 320: 7, 323: 7, 327: 7, 328: 6, 329: 5, 330: 13, 334: 5, 335: 6, 341: 8, 342: 9, 347: 8, 348: 8, 350: 10, 351: 8, 352: 6, 353: 6, 354: 5, 358: 7, 365: 6, 366: 5, 369: 4, 371: 10, 372: 8, 376: 5, 384: 8, 385: 7, 386: 6, 387: 6, 392: 6, 393: 7, 396: 9, 397: 10, 398: 9, 402: 6} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 130 "This document specifies the Deterministic Networking MPLS data plane when operating over a TSN sub-network. This document does not define new procedures or processes. Whenever this document makes requirements statements or recommendations, these are taken from normative text in the referenced RFCs." "Comments resolved : Routing Directorate I approved these . The Changes looked good to me . I opened a small pull request to fix commas ." 7fe7425604ef66b60a158a23aecf46a764d6a9b3 7fe7425604ef66b60a158a23aecf46a764d6a9b3 draft-ietf-detnet-mpls-over-tsn 6580a6613cfcb10cffac5764156a46b91d3eb44fa7400dfa65ceab8dafefeb96 ['ae28cb0a308d03152114382b4e0008780ef2c0ec9dd53479488e7465c6b923a9', '706ec75b51fe58215f60547543433e275c41304edf84fe3e1b2a49a31b92492d', '6580a6613cfcb10cffac5764156a46b91d3eb44fa7400dfa65ceab8dafefeb96', 'b3ecfd42e3741322def5e4672c45f8aae56808c202fade28d5bb0b51f48a4050'] A "this document specifies the deterministic networking mpls data plane when operating over a tsn sub-network. this document does not define new procedures or processes. whenever this document makes requirements statements or recommendations, these are taken from normative text in the referenced rfcs." {124: 1, 67: 1, 64: 2, 52: 2} {158: 1, 268: 1, 133: 2, 391: 2, 305: 3} {133, 391, 268, 269, 305, 158} 130 "Deterministic Networking (DetNet) is a service that can be offered by a network to DetNet flows. DetNet provides these flows with a low packet loss rates and assured maximum end-to-end delivery latency. General background and concepts of DetNet can be found in RFC8655." "Comments resolved : Routing Directorate I approved these . The Changes looked good to me . I opened a small pull request to fix commas ." 7fe7425604ef66b60a158a23aecf46a764d6a9b3 7fe7425604ef66b60a158a23aecf46a764d6a9b3 draft-ietf-detnet-mpls-over-tsn ae28cb0a308d03152114382b4e0008780ef2c0ec9dd53479488e7465c6b923a9 ['ae28cb0a308d03152114382b4e0008780ef2c0ec9dd53479488e7465c6b923a9', '706ec75b51fe58215f60547543433e275c41304edf84fe3e1b2a49a31b92492d', '6580a6613cfcb10cffac5764156a46b91d3eb44fa7400dfa65ceab8dafefeb96', 'b3ecfd42e3741322def5e4672c45f8aae56808c202fade28d5bb0b51f48a4050'] A "deterministic networking (detnet) is a service that can be offered by a network to detnet flows. detnet provides these flows with a low packet loss rates and assured maximum end-to-end delivery latency. general background and concepts of detnet can be found in rfc8655." {124: 1, 67: 1, 64: 2, 52: 2} {158: 1, 268: 1, 133: 2, 391: 2, 305: 3} {133, 391, 268, 269, 305, 158} 130 "This document specifies the Deterministic Networking MPLS data plane when operating over an IEEE 802.1 Time-Sensitive Networking (TSN) sub-network. This document does not define new procedures or processes. Whenever this document makes requirements statements or recommendations, these are taken from normative text in the referenced RFCs." "Comments resolved : Routing Directorate I approved these . The Changes looked good to me . I opened a small pull request to fix commas ." 7fe7425604ef66b60a158a23aecf46a764d6a9b3 7fe7425604ef66b60a158a23aecf46a764d6a9b3 draft-ietf-detnet-mpls-over-tsn b3ecfd42e3741322def5e4672c45f8aae56808c202fade28d5bb0b51f48a4050 ['ae28cb0a308d03152114382b4e0008780ef2c0ec9dd53479488e7465c6b923a9', '706ec75b51fe58215f60547543433e275c41304edf84fe3e1b2a49a31b92492d', '6580a6613cfcb10cffac5764156a46b91d3eb44fa7400dfa65ceab8dafefeb96', 'b3ecfd42e3741322def5e4672c45f8aae56808c202fade28d5bb0b51f48a4050'] B "this document specifies the deterministic networking mpls data plane when operating over an ieee 802.1 time-sensitive networking (tsn) sub-network. this document does not define new procedures or processes. whenever this document makes requirements statements or recommendations, these are taken from normative text in the referenced rfcs." {124: 1, 67: 1, 64: 2, 52: 2} {158: 1, 268: 1, 133: 2, 391: 2, 305: 3} {133, 391, 268, 269, 305, 158} 130 "Deterministic Networking (DetNet) is a service that can be offered by a network to DetNet flows. DetNet provides these flows with low packet loss rates and assured maximum end-to-end delivery latency. General background and concepts of DetNet can be found in RFC8655." "Comments resolved : Routing Directorate I approved these . The Changes looked good to me . I opened a small pull request to fix commas ." 7fe7425604ef66b60a158a23aecf46a764d6a9b3 7fe7425604ef66b60a158a23aecf46a764d6a9b3 draft-ietf-detnet-mpls-over-tsn 706ec75b51fe58215f60547543433e275c41304edf84fe3e1b2a49a31b92492d ['ae28cb0a308d03152114382b4e0008780ef2c0ec9dd53479488e7465c6b923a9', '706ec75b51fe58215f60547543433e275c41304edf84fe3e1b2a49a31b92492d', '6580a6613cfcb10cffac5764156a46b91d3eb44fa7400dfa65ceab8dafefeb96', 'b3ecfd42e3741322def5e4672c45f8aae56808c202fade28d5bb0b51f48a4050'] B "deterministic networking (detnet) is a service that can be offered by a network to detnet flows. detnet provides these flows with low packet loss rates and assured maximum end-to-end delivery latency. general background and concepts of detnet can be found in rfc8655." {124: 1, 67: 1, 64: 2, 52: 2} {158: 1, 268: 1, 133: 2, 391: 2, 305: 3} {133, 391, 268, 269, 305, 158} 130 "The DetNet Architecture decomposes the DetNet related data plane functions into two sub-layers: a service sub-layer and a forwarding sub-layer. The service sub-layer is used to provide DetNet service protection and reordering. The forwarding sub-layer is used to provides congestion protection (low loss, assured latency, and limited reordering) leveraging MPLS Traffic Engineering mechanisms." "Comments resolved : Routing Directorate I approved these . The Changes looked good to me . I opened a small pull request to fix commas ." 7fe7425604ef66b60a158a23aecf46a764d6a9b3 7fe7425604ef66b60a158a23aecf46a764d6a9b3 draft-ietf-detnet-mpls-over-tsn f73b2fa284e31d30e9c6caf53c2f9ffb683d70710395f41c8a4705952f2f964b ['f73b2fa284e31d30e9c6caf53c2f9ffb683d70710395f41c8a4705952f2f964b', '16afb04e6abe6dce4d259846080cef35f420bb4bfc383ed9a96637c41358c6eb', '7ad57bf78cf143b966ae4569b3d68679d52f9dcd7dbc93fdad904b59ac5ee341', 'd3c07eef870b729834f306f06b1700c5b51b0ea2f10ce6d593c74c3b4085e08f', 'e4983013001e1ddceaff06711253fd265d6130d4198808a6fb23f33b424282fc', 'ba15410db2cc49458cc752e7e91423020895dea91889ec26db01e3a4b0414079', '31af09b736a8cb73f208bdf69e547e2bda95b885b778794fe7c9568fee6ad9ee', '2e301711e342971ae46ea5ef5932a09b7b42186c6928d97cfef8cf3349c47ea7'] A "the detnet architecture decomposes the detnet related data plane functions into two sub-layers: a service sub-layer and a forwarding sub-layer. the service sub-layer is used to provide detnet service protection and reordering. the forwarding sub-layer is used to provides congestion protection (low loss, assured latency, and limited reordering) leveraging mpls traffic engineering mechanisms." {67: 1, 52: 1, 130: 4, 79: 3, 51: 3, 112: 4, 55: 4, 64: 3, 62: 4, 37: 3, 38: 4, 69: 3, 68: 3, 33: 3, 25: 3, 53: 3, 80: 3, 127: 5, 91: 4} {66: 1, 337: 1, 0: 4, 389: 3, 390: 3, 135: 4, 142: 4, 14: 3, 400: 4, 17: 3, 19: 4, 149: 4, 406: 3, 279: 3, 280: 3, 281: 4, 278: 3, 294: 3, 296: 4, 45: 4, 308: 3, 56: 3, 185: 3, 192: 3, 321: 2, 322: 3, 196: 6, 197: 5, 324: 4, 77: 4, 78: 4, 216: 4, 380: 3, 255: 4} {0, 389, 390, 135, 142, 14, 400, 17, 399, 19, 149, 406, 279, 280, 281, 278, 294, 296, 45, 308, 56, 185, 192, 321, 322, 66, 196, 197, 324, 77, 78, 337, 216, 380, 255} 130 "I-D.ietf-detnet-mpls specifies the DetNet data plane operation for MPLS-based Packet Switched Network (PSN). MPLS encapsulated DetNet flows can be carried over network technologies that can provide the DetNet required level of service. This document focuses on the scenario where MPLS (DetNet) nodes are interconnected by a IEEE 802.1 TSN sub-network." "Comments resolved : Routing Directorate I approved these . The Changes looked good to me . I opened a small pull request to fix commas ." 7fe7425604ef66b60a158a23aecf46a764d6a9b3 7fe7425604ef66b60a158a23aecf46a764d6a9b3 draft-ietf-detnet-mpls-over-tsn d3c07eef870b729834f306f06b1700c5b51b0ea2f10ce6d593c74c3b4085e08f ['f73b2fa284e31d30e9c6caf53c2f9ffb683d70710395f41c8a4705952f2f964b', '16afb04e6abe6dce4d259846080cef35f420bb4bfc383ed9a96637c41358c6eb', '7ad57bf78cf143b966ae4569b3d68679d52f9dcd7dbc93fdad904b59ac5ee341', 'd3c07eef870b729834f306f06b1700c5b51b0ea2f10ce6d593c74c3b4085e08f', 'e4983013001e1ddceaff06711253fd265d6130d4198808a6fb23f33b424282fc', 'ba15410db2cc49458cc752e7e91423020895dea91889ec26db01e3a4b0414079', '31af09b736a8cb73f208bdf69e547e2bda95b885b778794fe7c9568fee6ad9ee', '2e301711e342971ae46ea5ef5932a09b7b42186c6928d97cfef8cf3349c47ea7'] A "i-d.ietf-detnet-mpls specifies the detnet data plane operation for mpls-based packet switched network (psn). mpls encapsulated detnet flows can be carried over network technologies that can provide the detnet required level of service. this document focuses on the scenario where mpls (detnet) nodes are interconnected by a ieee 802.1 tsn sub-network." {67: 1, 52: 1, 130: 4, 79: 3, 51: 3, 112: 4, 55: 4, 64: 3, 62: 4, 37: 3, 38: 4, 69: 3, 68: 3, 33: 3, 25: 3, 53: 3, 80: 3, 127: 5, 91: 4} {66: 1, 337: 1, 0: 4, 389: 3, 390: 3, 135: 4, 142: 4, 14: 3, 400: 4, 17: 3, 19: 4, 149: 4, 406: 3, 279: 3, 280: 3, 281: 4, 278: 3, 294: 3, 296: 4, 45: 4, 308: 3, 56: 3, 185: 3, 192: 3, 321: 2, 322: 3, 196: 6, 197: 5, 324: 4, 77: 4, 78: 4, 216: 4, 380: 3, 255: 4} {0, 389, 390, 135, 142, 14, 400, 17, 399, 19, 149, 406, 279, 280, 281, 278, 294, 296, 45, 308, 56, 185, 192, 321, 322, 66, 196, 197, 324, 77, 78, 337, 216, 380, 255} 130 "This document uses the terminology established in the DetNet architecture RFC8655 and I-D.ietf-detnet-mpls, and the reader is assumed to be familiar with that document and its terminology." "Comments resolved : Routing Directorate I approved these . The Changes looked good to me . I opened a small pull request to fix commas ." 7fe7425604ef66b60a158a23aecf46a764d6a9b3 7fe7425604ef66b60a158a23aecf46a764d6a9b3 draft-ietf-detnet-mpls-over-tsn 31af09b736a8cb73f208bdf69e547e2bda95b885b778794fe7c9568fee6ad9ee ['f73b2fa284e31d30e9c6caf53c2f9ffb683d70710395f41c8a4705952f2f964b', '16afb04e6abe6dce4d259846080cef35f420bb4bfc383ed9a96637c41358c6eb', '7ad57bf78cf143b966ae4569b3d68679d52f9dcd7dbc93fdad904b59ac5ee341', 'd3c07eef870b729834f306f06b1700c5b51b0ea2f10ce6d593c74c3b4085e08f', 'e4983013001e1ddceaff06711253fd265d6130d4198808a6fb23f33b424282fc', 'ba15410db2cc49458cc752e7e91423020895dea91889ec26db01e3a4b0414079', '31af09b736a8cb73f208bdf69e547e2bda95b885b778794fe7c9568fee6ad9ee', '2e301711e342971ae46ea5ef5932a09b7b42186c6928d97cfef8cf3349c47ea7'] A "this document uses the terminology established in the detnet architecture rfc8655 and i-d.ietf-detnet-mpls, and the reader is assumed to be familiar with that document and its terminology." {67: 1, 52: 1, 130: 4, 79: 3, 51: 3, 112: 4, 55: 4, 64: 3, 62: 4, 37: 3, 38: 4, 69: 3, 68: 3, 33: 3, 25: 3, 53: 3, 80: 3, 127: 5, 91: 4} {66: 1, 337: 1, 0: 4, 389: 3, 390: 3, 135: 4, 142: 4, 14: 3, 400: 4, 17: 3, 19: 4, 149: 4, 406: 3, 279: 3, 280: 3, 281: 4, 278: 3, 294: 3, 296: 4, 45: 4, 308: 3, 56: 3, 185: 3, 192: 3, 321: 2, 322: 3, 196: 6, 197: 5, 324: 4, 77: 4, 78: 4, 216: 4, 380: 3, 255: 4} {0, 389, 390, 135, 142, 14, 400, 17, 399, 19, 149, 406, 279, 280, 281, 278, 294, 296, 45, 308, 56, 185, 192, 321, 322, 66, 196, 197, 324, 77, 78, 337, 216, 380, 255} 130 "The DetNet Architecture decomposes the DetNet related data plane functions into two sub-layers: a service sub-layer and a forwarding sub-layer. The service sub-layer is used to provide DetNet service protection and reordering. The forwarding sub-layer is used to provide congestion protection (low loss, assured latency, and limited reordering) leveraging MPLS Traffic Engineering mechanisms." "Comments resolved : Routing Directorate I approved these . The Changes looked good to me . I opened a small pull request to fix commas ." 7fe7425604ef66b60a158a23aecf46a764d6a9b3 7fe7425604ef66b60a158a23aecf46a764d6a9b3 draft-ietf-detnet-mpls-over-tsn ba15410db2cc49458cc752e7e91423020895dea91889ec26db01e3a4b0414079 ['f73b2fa284e31d30e9c6caf53c2f9ffb683d70710395f41c8a4705952f2f964b', '16afb04e6abe6dce4d259846080cef35f420bb4bfc383ed9a96637c41358c6eb', '7ad57bf78cf143b966ae4569b3d68679d52f9dcd7dbc93fdad904b59ac5ee341', 'd3c07eef870b729834f306f06b1700c5b51b0ea2f10ce6d593c74c3b4085e08f', 'e4983013001e1ddceaff06711253fd265d6130d4198808a6fb23f33b424282fc', 'ba15410db2cc49458cc752e7e91423020895dea91889ec26db01e3a4b0414079', '31af09b736a8cb73f208bdf69e547e2bda95b885b778794fe7c9568fee6ad9ee', '2e301711e342971ae46ea5ef5932a09b7b42186c6928d97cfef8cf3349c47ea7'] B "the detnet architecture decomposes the detnet related data plane functions into two sub-layers: a service sub-layer and a forwarding sub-layer. the service sub-layer is used to provide detnet service protection and reordering. the forwarding sub-layer is used to provide congestion protection (low loss, assured latency, and limited reordering) leveraging mpls traffic engineering mechanisms." {67: 1, 52: 1, 130: 4, 79: 3, 51: 3, 112: 4, 55: 4, 64: 3, 62: 4, 37: 3, 38: 4, 69: 3, 68: 3, 33: 3, 25: 3, 53: 3, 80: 3, 127: 5, 91: 4} {66: 1, 337: 1, 0: 4, 389: 3, 390: 3, 135: 4, 142: 4, 14: 3, 400: 4, 17: 3, 19: 4, 149: 4, 406: 3, 279: 3, 280: 3, 281: 4, 278: 3, 294: 3, 296: 4, 45: 4, 308: 3, 56: 3, 185: 3, 192: 3, 321: 2, 322: 3, 196: 6, 197: 5, 324: 4, 77: 4, 78: 4, 216: 4, 380: 3, 255: 4} {0, 389, 390, 135, 142, 14, 400, 17, 399, 19, 149, 406, 279, 280, 281, 278, 294, 296, 45, 308, 56, 185, 192, 321, 322, 66, 196, 197, 324, 77, 78, 337, 216, 380, 255} 130 "RFC8964 specifies the DetNet data plane operation for MPLS-based Packet Switched Network (PSN). MPLS encapsulated DetNet flows can be carried over network technologies that can provide the DetNet required level of service. This document focuses on the scenario where MPLS (DetNet) nodes are interconnected by a IEEE 802.1 TSN sub- network. There is close cooperation between the IETF DetNet WG and the IEEE 802.1 TSN TG." "Comments resolved : Routing Directorate I approved these . The Changes looked good to me . I opened a small pull request to fix commas ." 7fe7425604ef66b60a158a23aecf46a764d6a9b3 7fe7425604ef66b60a158a23aecf46a764d6a9b3 draft-ietf-detnet-mpls-over-tsn 7ad57bf78cf143b966ae4569b3d68679d52f9dcd7dbc93fdad904b59ac5ee341 ['f73b2fa284e31d30e9c6caf53c2f9ffb683d70710395f41c8a4705952f2f964b', '16afb04e6abe6dce4d259846080cef35f420bb4bfc383ed9a96637c41358c6eb', '7ad57bf78cf143b966ae4569b3d68679d52f9dcd7dbc93fdad904b59ac5ee341', 'd3c07eef870b729834f306f06b1700c5b51b0ea2f10ce6d593c74c3b4085e08f', 'e4983013001e1ddceaff06711253fd265d6130d4198808a6fb23f33b424282fc', 'ba15410db2cc49458cc752e7e91423020895dea91889ec26db01e3a4b0414079', '31af09b736a8cb73f208bdf69e547e2bda95b885b778794fe7c9568fee6ad9ee', '2e301711e342971ae46ea5ef5932a09b7b42186c6928d97cfef8cf3349c47ea7'] B "rfc8964 specifies the detnet data plane operation for mpls-based packet switched network (psn). mpls encapsulated detnet flows can be carried over network technologies that can provide the detnet required level of service. this document focuses on the scenario where mpls (detnet) nodes are interconnected by a ieee 802.1 tsn sub- network. there is close cooperation between the ietf detnet wg and the ieee 802.1 tsn tg." {67: 1, 52: 1, 130: 4, 79: 3, 51: 3, 112: 4, 55: 4, 64: 3, 62: 4, 37: 3, 38: 4, 69: 3, 68: 3, 33: 3, 25: 3, 53: 3, 80: 3, 127: 5, 91: 4} {66: 1, 337: 1, 0: 4, 389: 3, 390: 3, 135: 4, 142: 4, 14: 3, 400: 4, 17: 3, 19: 4, 149: 4, 406: 3, 279: 3, 280: 3, 281: 4, 278: 3, 294: 3, 296: 4, 45: 4, 308: 3, 56: 3, 185: 3, 192: 3, 321: 2, 322: 3, 196: 6, 197: 5, 324: 4, 77: 4, 78: 4, 216: 4, 380: 3, 255: 4} {0, 389, 390, 135, 142, 14, 400, 17, 399, 19, 149, 406, 279, 280, 281, 278, 294, 296, 45, 308, 56, 185, 192, 321, 322, 66, 196, 197, 324, 77, 78, 337, 216, 380, 255} 130 "This document uses the terminology established in the DetNet architecture RFC8655 and RFC8964. TSN specific terms are defined in the TSN TG of IEEE 802.1 Working Group. The reader is assumed to be familiar with these documents and their terminology." "Comments resolved : Routing Directorate I approved these . The Changes looked good to me . I opened a small pull request to fix commas ." 7fe7425604ef66b60a158a23aecf46a764d6a9b3 7fe7425604ef66b60a158a23aecf46a764d6a9b3 draft-ietf-detnet-mpls-over-tsn e4983013001e1ddceaff06711253fd265d6130d4198808a6fb23f33b424282fc ['f73b2fa284e31d30e9c6caf53c2f9ffb683d70710395f41c8a4705952f2f964b', '16afb04e6abe6dce4d259846080cef35f420bb4bfc383ed9a96637c41358c6eb', '7ad57bf78cf143b966ae4569b3d68679d52f9dcd7dbc93fdad904b59ac5ee341', 'd3c07eef870b729834f306f06b1700c5b51b0ea2f10ce6d593c74c3b4085e08f', 'e4983013001e1ddceaff06711253fd265d6130d4198808a6fb23f33b424282fc', 'ba15410db2cc49458cc752e7e91423020895dea91889ec26db01e3a4b0414079', '31af09b736a8cb73f208bdf69e547e2bda95b885b778794fe7c9568fee6ad9ee', '2e301711e342971ae46ea5ef5932a09b7b42186c6928d97cfef8cf3349c47ea7'] B "this document uses the terminology established in the detnet architecture rfc8655 and rfc8964. tsn specific terms are defined in the tsn tg of ieee 802.1 working group. the reader is assumed to be familiar with these documents and their terminology." {67: 1, 52: 1, 130: 4, 79: 3, 51: 3, 112: 4, 55: 4, 64: 3, 62: 4, 37: 3, 38: 4, 69: 3, 68: 3, 33: 3, 25: 3, 53: 3, 80: 3, 127: 5, 91: 4} {66: 1, 337: 1, 0: 4, 389: 3, 390: 3, 135: 4, 142: 4, 14: 3, 400: 4, 17: 3, 19: 4, 149: 4, 406: 3, 279: 3, 280: 3, 281: 4, 278: 3, 294: 3, 296: 4, 45: 4, 308: 3, 56: 3, 185: 3, 192: 3, 321: 2, 322: 3, 196: 6, 197: 5, 324: 4, 77: 4, 78: 4, 216: 4, 380: 3, 255: 4} {0, 389, 390, 135, 142, 14, 400, 17, 399, 19, 149, 406, 279, 280, 281, 278, 294, 296, 45, 308, 56, 185, 192, 321, 322, 66, 196, 197, 324, 77, 78, 337, 216, 380, 255} 130 Aggregation label, a special case of an S-Label. "Comments resolved : Routing Directorate I approved these . The Changes looked good to me . I opened a small pull request to fix commas ." 7fe7425604ef66b60a158a23aecf46a764d6a9b3 7fe7425604ef66b60a158a23aecf46a764d6a9b3 draft-ietf-detnet-mpls-over-tsn 16afb04e6abe6dce4d259846080cef35f420bb4bfc383ed9a96637c41358c6eb ['f73b2fa284e31d30e9c6caf53c2f9ffb683d70710395f41c8a4705952f2f964b', '16afb04e6abe6dce4d259846080cef35f420bb4bfc383ed9a96637c41358c6eb', '7ad57bf78cf143b966ae4569b3d68679d52f9dcd7dbc93fdad904b59ac5ee341', 'd3c07eef870b729834f306f06b1700c5b51b0ea2f10ce6d593c74c3b4085e08f', 'e4983013001e1ddceaff06711253fd265d6130d4198808a6fb23f33b424282fc', 'ba15410db2cc49458cc752e7e91423020895dea91889ec26db01e3a4b0414079', '31af09b736a8cb73f208bdf69e547e2bda95b885b778794fe7c9568fee6ad9ee', '2e301711e342971ae46ea5ef5932a09b7b42186c6928d97cfef8cf3349c47ea7'] B aggregation label, a special case of an s-label. {67: 1, 52: 1, 130: 4, 79: 3, 51: 3, 112: 4, 55: 4, 64: 3, 62: 4, 37: 3, 38: 4, 69: 3, 68: 3, 33: 3, 25: 3, 53: 3, 80: 3, 127: 5, 91: 4} {66: 1, 337: 1, 0: 4, 389: 3, 390: 3, 135: 4, 142: 4, 14: 3, 400: 4, 17: 3, 19: 4, 149: 4, 406: 3, 279: 3, 280: 3, 281: 4, 278: 3, 294: 3, 296: 4, 45: 4, 308: 3, 56: 3, 185: 3, 192: 3, 321: 2, 322: 3, 196: 6, 197: 5, 324: 4, 77: 4, 78: 4, 216: 4, 380: 3, 255: 4} {0, 389, 390, 135, 142, 14, 400, 17, 399, 19, 149, 406, 279, 280, 281, 278, 294, 296, 45, 308, 56, 185, 192, 321, 322, 66, 196, 197, 324, 77, 78, 337, 216, 380, 255} 130 Forwarding label that identifies the LSP used by a DetNet flow. "Comments resolved : Routing Directorate I approved these . The Changes looked good to me . I opened a small pull request to fix commas ." 7fe7425604ef66b60a158a23aecf46a764d6a9b3 7fe7425604ef66b60a158a23aecf46a764d6a9b3 draft-ietf-detnet-mpls-over-tsn 2e301711e342971ae46ea5ef5932a09b7b42186c6928d97cfef8cf3349c47ea7 ['f73b2fa284e31d30e9c6caf53c2f9ffb683d70710395f41c8a4705952f2f964b', '16afb04e6abe6dce4d259846080cef35f420bb4bfc383ed9a96637c41358c6eb', '7ad57bf78cf143b966ae4569b3d68679d52f9dcd7dbc93fdad904b59ac5ee341', 'd3c07eef870b729834f306f06b1700c5b51b0ea2f10ce6d593c74c3b4085e08f', 'e4983013001e1ddceaff06711253fd265d6130d4198808a6fb23f33b424282fc', 'ba15410db2cc49458cc752e7e91423020895dea91889ec26db01e3a4b0414079', '31af09b736a8cb73f208bdf69e547e2bda95b885b778794fe7c9568fee6ad9ee', '2e301711e342971ae46ea5ef5932a09b7b42186c6928d97cfef8cf3349c47ea7'] B forwarding label that identifies the lsp used by a detnet flow. {67: 1, 52: 1, 130: 4, 79: 3, 51: 3, 112: 4, 55: 4, 64: 3, 62: 4, 37: 3, 38: 4, 69: 3, 68: 3, 33: 3, 25: 3, 53: 3, 80: 3, 127: 5, 91: 4} {66: 1, 337: 1, 0: 4, 389: 3, 390: 3, 135: 4, 142: 4, 14: 3, 400: 4, 17: 3, 19: 4, 149: 4, 406: 3, 279: 3, 280: 3, 281: 4, 278: 3, 294: 3, 296: 4, 45: 4, 308: 3, 56: 3, 185: 3, 192: 3, 321: 2, 322: 3, 196: 6, 197: 5, 324: 4, 77: 4, 78: 4, 216: 4, 380: 3, 255: 4} {0, 389, 390, 135, 142, 14, 400, 17, 399, 19, 149, 406, 279, 280, 281, 278, 294, 296, 45, 308, 56, 185, 192, 321, 322, 66, 196, 197, 324, 77, 78, 337, 216, 380, 255} 130 "A node operating on a DetNet flow in the Detnet service sub-layer, i.e. a node processing a DetNet packet which has the S-Label as top of stack uses the local context associated with that S-Label, for example a received F-Label, to determine what local DetNet operation(s) are applied to that packet. An S-Label may be unique when taken from the platform label space RFC3031, which would enable correct DetNet flow identification regardless of which input interface or LSP the packet arrives on. The service sub-layer functions (i.e., PREOF) use a DetNet control word (d-CW)." "Comments resolved : Routing Directorate I approved these . The Changes looked good to me . I opened a small pull request to fix commas ." 7fe7425604ef66b60a158a23aecf46a764d6a9b3 7fe7425604ef66b60a158a23aecf46a764d6a9b3 draft-ietf-detnet-mpls-over-tsn e746630d4b45cf2b654a14e4daaa03ad634e33d92c29c489e3ef3fcd5620c311 ['9bb95b3bbd3a7679dc5919f26761449292ad4eff20b684798f7665c2a0f1bf84', 'd08d9e4aed91fa9346e673690ceae79dfc6761c6ad95b9a62a622fb6b3a450fe', 'd135518ad4230c8f57a3510b3ddea8a99e2355363c9419a27340734427050729', 'e746630d4b45cf2b654a14e4daaa03ad634e33d92c29c489e3ef3fcd5620c311', '00a5a434fcd1ec3f2108cd25b51cb4fc8eea6d05d4f27db67cf0f1b0278988e7'] A "a node operating on a detnet flow in the detnet service sub-layer, i.e. a node processing a detnet packet which has the s-label as top of stack uses the local context associated with that s-label, for example a received f-label, to determine what local detnet operation(s) are applied to that packet. an s-label may be unique when taken from the platform label space rfc3031, which would enable correct detnet flow identification regardless of which input interface or lsp the packet arrives on. the service sub-layer functions (i.e., preof) use a detnet control word (d-cw)." {53: 1, 52: 1, 6: 2, 79: 2, 90: 3, 51: 3, 130: 2, 62: 5, 85: 5, 68: 4, 35: 3, 110: 3, 91: 5, 114: 3, 97: 3, 31: 3, 13: 3, 67: 3, 38: 4, 26: 3, 124: 3, 98: 2, 54: 2, 127: 3, 8: 2, 96: 3, 64: 2, 30: 4, 61: 5, 55: 3, 27: 4, 15: 3, 129: 3, 115: 3, 84: 3, 76: 6, 87: 3, 131: 5, 102: 3, 113: 5, 99: 2, 36: 3, 24: 2, 72: 4} {369: 1, 366: 1, 1: 9, 4: 2, 9: 5, 10: 3, 15: 3, 24: 2, 25: 5, 26: 5, 27: 3, 39: 5, 43: 3, 49: 6, 50: 5, 58: 5, 59: 2, 64: 3, 69: 4, 81: 6, 82: 4, 86: 3, 96: 4, 97: 3, 100: 7, 108: 3, 109: 4, 110: 4, 111: 2, 114: 3, 115: 4, 116: 3, 118: 6, 119: 5, 120: 3, 121: 4, 122: 4, 123: 3, 124: 4, 128: 4, 129: 4, 130: 5, 132: 4, 136: 2, 145: 4, 147: 4, 151: 4, 152: 4, 154: 3, 156: 2, 161: 3, 162: 3, 165: 3, 168: 4, 169: 3, 172: 3, 180: 4, 184: 5, 187: 5, 188: 4, 191: 3, 194: 4, 202: 5, 203: 6, 206: 2, 207: 3, 215: 2, 217: 3, 218: 8, 220: 2, 221: 2, 222: 5, 224: 3, 227: 5, 229: 3, 234: 5, 235: 2, 242: 2, 243: 4, 244: 4, 245: 4, 248: 4, 250: 4, 258: 11, 262: 4, 263: 5, 264: 3, 267: 4, 270: 3, 272: 3, 273: 5, 287: 3, 289: 3, 291: 5, 299: 5, 300: 3, 304: 3, 309: 3, 314: 2, 315: 3, 320: 4, 323: 4, 327: 4, 328: 3, 329: 2, 330: 10, 334: 2, 335: 3, 341: 5, 342: 6, 347: 5, 348: 5, 350: 7, 351: 5, 352: 3, 353: 3, 354: 2, 358: 4, 365: 3, 371: 7, 372: 5, 376: 2, 384: 5, 385: 4, 386: 3, 387: 3, 392: 3, 393: 4, 396: 6, 397: 7, 398: 6, 402: 3} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 130 "The DetNet MPLS data plane builds on MPLS Traffic Engineering encapsulations and mechanisms to provide a forwarding sub-layer that is responsible for providing resource allocation and explicit routes. The forwarding sub-layer is supported by one or more forwarding labels (F-Labels)." "Comments resolved : Routing Directorate I approved these . The Changes looked good to me . I opened a small pull request to fix commas ." 7fe7425604ef66b60a158a23aecf46a764d6a9b3 7fe7425604ef66b60a158a23aecf46a764d6a9b3 draft-ietf-detnet-mpls-over-tsn d135518ad4230c8f57a3510b3ddea8a99e2355363c9419a27340734427050729 ['9bb95b3bbd3a7679dc5919f26761449292ad4eff20b684798f7665c2a0f1bf84', 'd08d9e4aed91fa9346e673690ceae79dfc6761c6ad95b9a62a622fb6b3a450fe', 'd135518ad4230c8f57a3510b3ddea8a99e2355363c9419a27340734427050729', 'e746630d4b45cf2b654a14e4daaa03ad634e33d92c29c489e3ef3fcd5620c311', '00a5a434fcd1ec3f2108cd25b51cb4fc8eea6d05d4f27db67cf0f1b0278988e7'] A "the detnet mpls data plane builds on mpls traffic engineering encapsulations and mechanisms to provide a forwarding sub-layer that is responsible for providing resource allocation and explicit routes. the forwarding sub-layer is supported by one or more forwarding labels (f-labels)." {53: 1, 52: 1, 6: 2, 79: 2, 90: 3, 51: 3, 130: 2, 62: 5, 85: 5, 68: 4, 35: 3, 110: 3, 91: 5, 114: 3, 97: 3, 31: 3, 13: 3, 67: 3, 38: 4, 26: 3, 124: 3, 98: 2, 54: 2, 127: 3, 8: 2, 96: 3, 64: 2, 30: 4, 61: 5, 55: 3, 27: 4, 15: 3, 129: 3, 115: 3, 84: 3, 76: 6, 87: 3, 131: 5, 102: 3, 113: 5, 99: 2, 36: 3, 24: 2, 72: 4} {369: 1, 366: 1, 1: 9, 4: 2, 9: 5, 10: 3, 15: 3, 24: 2, 25: 5, 26: 5, 27: 3, 39: 5, 43: 3, 49: 6, 50: 5, 58: 5, 59: 2, 64: 3, 69: 4, 81: 6, 82: 4, 86: 3, 96: 4, 97: 3, 100: 7, 108: 3, 109: 4, 110: 4, 111: 2, 114: 3, 115: 4, 116: 3, 118: 6, 119: 5, 120: 3, 121: 4, 122: 4, 123: 3, 124: 4, 128: 4, 129: 4, 130: 5, 132: 4, 136: 2, 145: 4, 147: 4, 151: 4, 152: 4, 154: 3, 156: 2, 161: 3, 162: 3, 165: 3, 168: 4, 169: 3, 172: 3, 180: 4, 184: 5, 187: 5, 188: 4, 191: 3, 194: 4, 202: 5, 203: 6, 206: 2, 207: 3, 215: 2, 217: 3, 218: 8, 220: 2, 221: 2, 222: 5, 224: 3, 227: 5, 229: 3, 234: 5, 235: 2, 242: 2, 243: 4, 244: 4, 245: 4, 248: 4, 250: 4, 258: 11, 262: 4, 263: 5, 264: 3, 267: 4, 270: 3, 272: 3, 273: 5, 287: 3, 289: 3, 291: 5, 299: 5, 300: 3, 304: 3, 309: 3, 314: 2, 315: 3, 320: 4, 323: 4, 327: 4, 328: 3, 329: 2, 330: 10, 334: 2, 335: 3, 341: 5, 342: 6, 347: 5, 348: 5, 350: 7, 351: 5, 352: 3, 353: 3, 354: 2, 358: 4, 365: 3, 371: 7, 372: 5, 376: 2, 384: 5, 385: 4, 386: 3, 387: 3, 392: 3, 393: 4, 396: 6, 397: 7, 398: 6, 402: 3} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 130 Service label. "Comments resolved : Routing Directorate I approved these . The Changes looked good to me . I opened a small pull request to fix commas ." 7fe7425604ef66b60a158a23aecf46a764d6a9b3 7fe7425604ef66b60a158a23aecf46a764d6a9b3 draft-ietf-detnet-mpls-over-tsn 00a5a434fcd1ec3f2108cd25b51cb4fc8eea6d05d4f27db67cf0f1b0278988e7 ['9bb95b3bbd3a7679dc5919f26761449292ad4eff20b684798f7665c2a0f1bf84', 'd08d9e4aed91fa9346e673690ceae79dfc6761c6ad95b9a62a622fb6b3a450fe', 'd135518ad4230c8f57a3510b3ddea8a99e2355363c9419a27340734427050729', 'e746630d4b45cf2b654a14e4daaa03ad634e33d92c29c489e3ef3fcd5620c311', '00a5a434fcd1ec3f2108cd25b51cb4fc8eea6d05d4f27db67cf0f1b0278988e7'] B service label. {53: 1, 52: 1, 6: 2, 79: 2, 90: 3, 51: 3, 130: 2, 62: 5, 85: 5, 68: 4, 35: 3, 110: 3, 91: 5, 114: 3, 97: 3, 31: 3, 13: 3, 67: 3, 38: 4, 26: 3, 124: 3, 98: 2, 54: 2, 127: 3, 8: 2, 96: 3, 64: 2, 30: 4, 61: 5, 55: 3, 27: 4, 15: 3, 129: 3, 115: 3, 84: 3, 76: 6, 87: 3, 131: 5, 102: 3, 113: 5, 99: 2, 36: 3, 24: 2, 72: 4} {369: 1, 366: 1, 1: 9, 4: 2, 9: 5, 10: 3, 15: 3, 24: 2, 25: 5, 26: 5, 27: 3, 39: 5, 43: 3, 49: 6, 50: 5, 58: 5, 59: 2, 64: 3, 69: 4, 81: 6, 82: 4, 86: 3, 96: 4, 97: 3, 100: 7, 108: 3, 109: 4, 110: 4, 111: 2, 114: 3, 115: 4, 116: 3, 118: 6, 119: 5, 120: 3, 121: 4, 122: 4, 123: 3, 124: 4, 128: 4, 129: 4, 130: 5, 132: 4, 136: 2, 145: 4, 147: 4, 151: 4, 152: 4, 154: 3, 156: 2, 161: 3, 162: 3, 165: 3, 168: 4, 169: 3, 172: 3, 180: 4, 184: 5, 187: 5, 188: 4, 191: 3, 194: 4, 202: 5, 203: 6, 206: 2, 207: 3, 215: 2, 217: 3, 218: 8, 220: 2, 221: 2, 222: 5, 224: 3, 227: 5, 229: 3, 234: 5, 235: 2, 242: 2, 243: 4, 244: 4, 245: 4, 248: 4, 250: 4, 258: 11, 262: 4, 263: 5, 264: 3, 267: 4, 270: 3, 272: 3, 273: 5, 287: 3, 289: 3, 291: 5, 299: 5, 300: 3, 304: 3, 309: 3, 314: 2, 315: 3, 320: 4, 323: 4, 327: 4, 328: 3, 329: 2, 330: 10, 334: 2, 335: 3, 341: 5, 342: 6, 347: 5, 348: 5, 350: 7, 351: 5, 352: 3, 353: 3, 354: 2, 358: 4, 365: 3, 371: 7, 372: 5, 376: 2, 384: 5, 385: 4, 386: 3, 387: 3, 392: 3, 393: 4, 396: 6, 397: 7, 398: 6, 402: 3} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 130 "A node operating on a DetNet flow in the Detnet service sub-layer, i.e. a node processing a DetNet packet which has the S-Label as top of stack uses the local context associated with that service label (S-Label), for example a received forwarding label (F-Label), to determine what local DetNet operation(s) are applied to that packet. An S-Label may be unique when taken from the platform label space RFC3031, which would enable correct DetNet flow identification regardless of which input interface or LSP the packet arrives on. The service sub-layer functions (i.e., PREOF) use a DetNet control word (d-CW)." "Comments resolved : Routing Directorate I approved these . The Changes looked good to me . I opened a small pull request to fix commas ." 7fe7425604ef66b60a158a23aecf46a764d6a9b3 7fe7425604ef66b60a158a23aecf46a764d6a9b3 draft-ietf-detnet-mpls-over-tsn d08d9e4aed91fa9346e673690ceae79dfc6761c6ad95b9a62a622fb6b3a450fe ['9bb95b3bbd3a7679dc5919f26761449292ad4eff20b684798f7665c2a0f1bf84', 'd08d9e4aed91fa9346e673690ceae79dfc6761c6ad95b9a62a622fb6b3a450fe', 'd135518ad4230c8f57a3510b3ddea8a99e2355363c9419a27340734427050729', 'e746630d4b45cf2b654a14e4daaa03ad634e33d92c29c489e3ef3fcd5620c311', '00a5a434fcd1ec3f2108cd25b51cb4fc8eea6d05d4f27db67cf0f1b0278988e7'] B "a node operating on a detnet flow in the detnet service sub-layer, i.e. a node processing a detnet packet which has the s-label as top of stack uses the local context associated with that service label (s-label), for example a received forwarding label (f-label), to determine what local detnet operation(s) are applied to that packet. an s-label may be unique when taken from the platform label space rfc3031, which would enable correct detnet flow identification regardless of which input interface or lsp the packet arrives on. the service sub-layer functions (i.e., preof) use a detnet control word (d-cw)." {53: 1, 52: 1, 6: 2, 79: 2, 90: 3, 51: 3, 130: 2, 62: 5, 85: 5, 68: 4, 35: 3, 110: 3, 91: 5, 114: 3, 97: 3, 31: 3, 13: 3, 67: 3, 38: 4, 26: 3, 124: 3, 98: 2, 54: 2, 127: 3, 8: 2, 96: 3, 64: 2, 30: 4, 61: 5, 55: 3, 27: 4, 15: 3, 129: 3, 115: 3, 84: 3, 76: 6, 87: 3, 131: 5, 102: 3, 113: 5, 99: 2, 36: 3, 24: 2, 72: 4} {369: 1, 366: 1, 1: 9, 4: 2, 9: 5, 10: 3, 15: 3, 24: 2, 25: 5, 26: 5, 27: 3, 39: 5, 43: 3, 49: 6, 50: 5, 58: 5, 59: 2, 64: 3, 69: 4, 81: 6, 82: 4, 86: 3, 96: 4, 97: 3, 100: 7, 108: 3, 109: 4, 110: 4, 111: 2, 114: 3, 115: 4, 116: 3, 118: 6, 119: 5, 120: 3, 121: 4, 122: 4, 123: 3, 124: 4, 128: 4, 129: 4, 130: 5, 132: 4, 136: 2, 145: 4, 147: 4, 151: 4, 152: 4, 154: 3, 156: 2, 161: 3, 162: 3, 165: 3, 168: 4, 169: 3, 172: 3, 180: 4, 184: 5, 187: 5, 188: 4, 191: 3, 194: 4, 202: 5, 203: 6, 206: 2, 207: 3, 215: 2, 217: 3, 218: 8, 220: 2, 221: 2, 222: 5, 224: 3, 227: 5, 229: 3, 234: 5, 235: 2, 242: 2, 243: 4, 244: 4, 245: 4, 248: 4, 250: 4, 258: 11, 262: 4, 263: 5, 264: 3, 267: 4, 270: 3, 272: 3, 273: 5, 287: 3, 289: 3, 291: 5, 299: 5, 300: 3, 304: 3, 309: 3, 314: 2, 315: 3, 320: 4, 323: 4, 327: 4, 328: 3, 329: 2, 330: 10, 334: 2, 335: 3, 341: 5, 342: 6, 347: 5, 348: 5, 350: 7, 351: 5, 352: 3, 353: 3, 354: 2, 358: 4, 365: 3, 371: 7, 372: 5, 376: 2, 384: 5, 385: 4, 386: 3, 387: 3, 392: 3, 393: 4, 396: 6, 397: 7, 398: 6, 402: 3} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 130 "The DetNet MPLS data plane builds on MPLS Traffic Engineering encapsulations and mechanisms to provide a forwarding sub-layer that is responsible for providing resource allocation and explicit routes. The forwarding sub-layer is supported by one or more F-Labels." "Comments resolved : Routing Directorate I approved these . The Changes looked good to me . I opened a small pull request to fix commas ." 7fe7425604ef66b60a158a23aecf46a764d6a9b3 7fe7425604ef66b60a158a23aecf46a764d6a9b3 draft-ietf-detnet-mpls-over-tsn 9bb95b3bbd3a7679dc5919f26761449292ad4eff20b684798f7665c2a0f1bf84 ['9bb95b3bbd3a7679dc5919f26761449292ad4eff20b684798f7665c2a0f1bf84', 'd08d9e4aed91fa9346e673690ceae79dfc6761c6ad95b9a62a622fb6b3a450fe', 'd135518ad4230c8f57a3510b3ddea8a99e2355363c9419a27340734427050729', 'e746630d4b45cf2b654a14e4daaa03ad634e33d92c29c489e3ef3fcd5620c311', '00a5a434fcd1ec3f2108cd25b51cb4fc8eea6d05d4f27db67cf0f1b0278988e7'] B "the detnet mpls data plane builds on mpls traffic engineering encapsulations and mechanisms to provide a forwarding sub-layer that is responsible for providing resource allocation and explicit routes. the forwarding sub-layer is supported by one or more f-labels." {53: 1, 52: 1, 6: 2, 79: 2, 90: 3, 51: 3, 130: 2, 62: 5, 85: 5, 68: 4, 35: 3, 110: 3, 91: 5, 114: 3, 97: 3, 31: 3, 13: 3, 67: 3, 38: 4, 26: 3, 124: 3, 98: 2, 54: 2, 127: 3, 8: 2, 96: 3, 64: 2, 30: 4, 61: 5, 55: 3, 27: 4, 15: 3, 129: 3, 115: 3, 84: 3, 76: 6, 87: 3, 131: 5, 102: 3, 113: 5, 99: 2, 36: 3, 24: 2, 72: 4} {369: 1, 366: 1, 1: 9, 4: 2, 9: 5, 10: 3, 15: 3, 24: 2, 25: 5, 26: 5, 27: 3, 39: 5, 43: 3, 49: 6, 50: 5, 58: 5, 59: 2, 64: 3, 69: 4, 81: 6, 82: 4, 86: 3, 96: 4, 97: 3, 100: 7, 108: 3, 109: 4, 110: 4, 111: 2, 114: 3, 115: 4, 116: 3, 118: 6, 119: 5, 120: 3, 121: 4, 122: 4, 123: 3, 124: 4, 128: 4, 129: 4, 130: 5, 132: 4, 136: 2, 145: 4, 147: 4, 151: 4, 152: 4, 154: 3, 156: 2, 161: 3, 162: 3, 165: 3, 168: 4, 169: 3, 172: 3, 180: 4, 184: 5, 187: 5, 188: 4, 191: 3, 194: 4, 202: 5, 203: 6, 206: 2, 207: 3, 215: 2, 217: 3, 218: 8, 220: 2, 221: 2, 222: 5, 224: 3, 227: 5, 229: 3, 234: 5, 235: 2, 242: 2, 243: 4, 244: 4, 245: 4, 248: 4, 250: 4, 258: 11, 262: 4, 263: 5, 264: 3, 267: 4, 270: 3, 272: 3, 273: 5, 287: 3, 289: 3, 291: 5, 299: 5, 300: 3, 304: 3, 309: 3, 314: 2, 315: 3, 320: 4, 323: 4, 327: 4, 328: 3, 329: 2, 330: 10, 334: 2, 335: 3, 341: 5, 342: 6, 347: 5, 348: 5, 350: 7, 351: 5, 352: 3, 353: 3, 354: 2, 358: 4, 365: 3, 371: 7, 372: 5, 376: 2, 384: 5, 385: 4, 386: 3, 387: 3, 392: 3, 393: 4, 396: 6, 397: 7, 398: 6, 402: 3} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 130 "The Time-Sensitive Networking (TSN) Task Group of the IEEE 802.1 Working Group have defined (and are defining) a number of amendments to IEEE8021Q that provide zero congestion loss and bounded latency in bridged networks. Furthermore IEEE8021CB defines frame replication and elimination functions for reliability that should prove both compatible with and useful to, DetNet networks. All these functions have to identify flows those require TSN treatment." "Comments resolved : Routing Directorate I approved these . The Changes looked good to me . I opened a small pull request to fix commas ." 7fe7425604ef66b60a158a23aecf46a764d6a9b3 7fe7425604ef66b60a158a23aecf46a764d6a9b3 draft-ietf-detnet-mpls-over-tsn 9eae34a80d6c18174e433823135ec5765b2174c62c18b3a4bbbd2754dfbbb557 ['c0affd1b4592a11b049f0ecec59245a34958dead4673d43cf7ad7f62cfb81225', '9eae34a80d6c18174e433823135ec5765b2174c62c18b3a4bbbd2754dfbbb557'] A "the time-sensitive networking (tsn) task group of the ieee 802.1 working group have defined (and are defining) a number of amendments to ieee8021q that provide zero congestion loss and bounded latency in bridged networks. furthermore ieee8021cb defines frame replication and elimination functions for reliability that should prove both compatible with and useful to, detnet networks. all these functions have to identify flows those require tsn treatment." {51: 1, 6: 5, 79: 5, 90: 5, 130: 3, 62: 2, 85: 3, 68: 5, 35: 6, 110: 5, 91: 7, 114: 5, 97: 3, 31: 6, 13: 2, 67: 5, 38: 6, 26: 4, 124: 2, 98: 5, 54: 5, 127: 6, 8: 5, 96: 2, 64: 5, 30: 5, 61: 7, 55: 4, 27: 6, 15: 5, 52: 3, 129: 6, 115: 5, 84: 5, 76: 8, 87: 5, 131: 8, 102: 3, 113: 7, 99: 5, 36: 5, 24: 4, 53: 4, 72: 6} {82: 1, 1: 10, 4: 5, 9: 7, 10: 6, 15: 4, 24: 5, 25: 2, 26: 3, 27: 4, 39: 6, 43: 6, 49: 8, 50: 7, 58: 7, 59: 5, 64: 4, 69: 6, 81: 3, 86: 5, 96: 6, 97: 5, 100: 4, 108: 6, 109: 7, 110: 7, 111: 5, 114: 6, 115: 7, 116: 3, 118: 5, 119: 4, 120: 6, 121: 5, 122: 3, 123: 2, 124: 5, 128: 6, 129: 5, 130: 7, 132: 6, 136: 5, 145: 6, 147: 6, 151: 6, 152: 6, 154: 6, 156: 3, 161: 5, 162: 4, 165: 6, 168: 7, 169: 5, 172: 5, 180: 6, 184: 7, 187: 8, 188: 7, 191: 6, 194: 6, 202: 7, 203: 8, 206: 5, 207: 6, 215: 5, 217: 6, 218: 9, 220: 5, 221: 5, 222: 6, 224: 6, 227: 2, 229: 5, 234: 8, 235: 5, 241: 5, 242: 5, 243: 6, 244: 6, 245: 6, 248: 6, 250: 5, 258: 12, 262: 7, 263: 8, 264: 6, 267: 5, 270: 4, 272: 5, 273: 7, 287: 6, 289: 5, 291: 7, 300: 4, 304: 4, 309: 5, 314: 5, 315: 5, 320: 3, 323: 6, 327: 7, 328: 6, 329: 5, 330: 11, 334: 5, 335: 3, 341: 2, 342: 3, 347: 2, 348: 2, 350: 9, 351: 7, 352: 5, 353: 5, 354: 4, 358: 5, 365: 5, 366: 5, 369: 4, 371: 4, 372: 7, 376: 5, 384: 7, 385: 6, 386: 6, 387: 4, 392: 6, 393: 7, 396: 3, 397: 8, 398: 7, 402: 5} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 130 "The Time-Sensitive Networking (TSN) Task Group of the IEEE 802.1 Working Group have defined (and are defining) a number of amendments to IEEE8021Q that provide zero congestion loss and bounded latency in bridged networks. Furthermore IEEE8021CB defines frame replication and elimination functions for reliability that should prove both compatible with and useful to, DetNet networks. All these functions have to identify flows those require TSN treatment (i.e., applying TSN functions during forwarding)." "Comments resolved : Routing Directorate I approved these . The Changes looked good to me . I opened a small pull request to fix commas ." 7fe7425604ef66b60a158a23aecf46a764d6a9b3 7fe7425604ef66b60a158a23aecf46a764d6a9b3 draft-ietf-detnet-mpls-over-tsn c0affd1b4592a11b049f0ecec59245a34958dead4673d43cf7ad7f62cfb81225 ['c0affd1b4592a11b049f0ecec59245a34958dead4673d43cf7ad7f62cfb81225', '9eae34a80d6c18174e433823135ec5765b2174c62c18b3a4bbbd2754dfbbb557'] B "the time-sensitive networking (tsn) task group of the ieee 802.1 working group have defined (and are defining) a number of amendments to ieee8021q that provide zero congestion loss and bounded latency in bridged networks. furthermore ieee8021cb defines frame replication and elimination functions for reliability that should prove both compatible with and useful to, detnet networks. all these functions have to identify flows those require tsn treatment (i.e., applying tsn functions during forwarding)." {51: 1, 6: 5, 79: 5, 90: 5, 130: 3, 62: 2, 85: 3, 68: 5, 35: 6, 110: 5, 91: 7, 114: 5, 97: 3, 31: 6, 13: 2, 67: 5, 38: 6, 26: 4, 124: 2, 98: 5, 54: 5, 127: 6, 8: 5, 96: 2, 64: 5, 30: 5, 61: 7, 55: 4, 27: 6, 15: 5, 52: 3, 129: 6, 115: 5, 84: 5, 76: 8, 87: 5, 131: 8, 102: 3, 113: 7, 99: 5, 36: 5, 24: 4, 53: 4, 72: 6} {82: 1, 1: 10, 4: 5, 9: 7, 10: 6, 15: 4, 24: 5, 25: 2, 26: 3, 27: 4, 39: 6, 43: 6, 49: 8, 50: 7, 58: 7, 59: 5, 64: 4, 69: 6, 81: 3, 86: 5, 96: 6, 97: 5, 100: 4, 108: 6, 109: 7, 110: 7, 111: 5, 114: 6, 115: 7, 116: 3, 118: 5, 119: 4, 120: 6, 121: 5, 122: 3, 123: 2, 124: 5, 128: 6, 129: 5, 130: 7, 132: 6, 136: 5, 145: 6, 147: 6, 151: 6, 152: 6, 154: 6, 156: 3, 161: 5, 162: 4, 165: 6, 168: 7, 169: 5, 172: 5, 180: 6, 184: 7, 187: 8, 188: 7, 191: 6, 194: 6, 202: 7, 203: 8, 206: 5, 207: 6, 215: 5, 217: 6, 218: 9, 220: 5, 221: 5, 222: 6, 224: 6, 227: 2, 229: 5, 234: 8, 235: 5, 241: 5, 242: 5, 243: 6, 244: 6, 245: 6, 248: 6, 250: 5, 258: 12, 262: 7, 263: 8, 264: 6, 267: 5, 270: 4, 272: 5, 273: 7, 287: 6, 289: 5, 291: 7, 300: 4, 304: 4, 309: 5, 314: 5, 315: 5, 320: 3, 323: 6, 327: 7, 328: 6, 329: 5, 330: 11, 334: 5, 335: 3, 341: 2, 342: 3, 347: 2, 348: 2, 350: 9, 351: 7, 352: 5, 353: 5, 354: 4, 358: 5, 365: 5, 366: 5, 369: 4, 371: 4, 372: 7, 376: 5, 384: 7, 385: 6, 386: 6, 387: 4, 392: 6, 393: 7, 396: 3, 397: 8, 398: 7, 402: 5} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 130 "Placement of TSN functions depends on the TSN capabilities of nodes. MPLS (DetNet) Nodes may or may not support TSN functions. For a given TSN Stream (i.e., DetNet flow) an MPLS (DetNet) node is treated as a Talker or a Listener inside the TSN sub-network." "Comments resolved : Routing Directorate I approved these . The Changes looked good to me . I opened a small pull request to fix commas ." 7fe7425604ef66b60a158a23aecf46a764d6a9b3 7fe7425604ef66b60a158a23aecf46a764d6a9b3 draft-ietf-detnet-mpls-over-tsn 3703b0838ce47d992f259e22b20012a302240311d21f2d269cbb1414baec967f ['c2ec0a70883cb097b82a41899151bd7d70d7cdd2474a9670fb5982175fb1b35d', '3703b0838ce47d992f259e22b20012a302240311d21f2d269cbb1414baec967f'] A "placement of tsn functions depends on the tsn capabilities of nodes. mpls (detnet) nodes may or may not support tsn functions. for a given tsn stream (i.e., detnet flow) an mpls (detnet) node is treated as a talker or a listener inside the tsn sub-network." {52: 1, 6: 3, 79: 3, 90: 3, 51: 2, 130: 3, 62: 4, 85: 5, 68: 5, 35: 4, 110: 3, 91: 5, 114: 3, 97: 2, 31: 4, 13: 3, 67: 3, 38: 4, 26: 3, 124: 4, 98: 3, 54: 3, 127: 4, 8: 3, 96: 2, 64: 3, 30: 3, 61: 5, 55: 4, 27: 4, 15: 3, 129: 4, 115: 3, 84: 3, 76: 7, 87: 3, 131: 6, 102: 3, 113: 5, 99: 3, 36: 3, 24: 2, 53: 2, 72: 4} {156: 1, 1: 10, 4: 3, 9: 6, 10: 4, 15: 2, 24: 3, 25: 4, 26: 5, 27: 2, 39: 6, 43: 4, 49: 6, 50: 5, 58: 5, 59: 3, 64: 2, 69: 5, 81: 5, 82: 3, 86: 3, 96: 4, 97: 3, 100: 6, 108: 4, 109: 5, 110: 5, 111: 3, 114: 4, 115: 5, 116: 2, 118: 7, 119: 6, 120: 4, 121: 5, 122: 3, 123: 2, 124: 5, 128: 4, 129: 3, 130: 5, 132: 5, 136: 3, 145: 5, 147: 4, 151: 4, 152: 4, 154: 4, 161: 4, 162: 4, 165: 4, 168: 5, 169: 3, 172: 3, 180: 4, 184: 6, 187: 6, 188: 5, 191: 4, 194: 5, 202: 6, 203: 7, 206: 3, 207: 4, 215: 3, 217: 4, 218: 9, 220: 3, 221: 3, 222: 6, 224: 4, 227: 4, 229: 3, 234: 6, 235: 3, 241: 3, 242: 3, 243: 5, 244: 4, 245: 5, 248: 4, 250: 3, 258: 12, 262: 5, 263: 6, 264: 4, 267: 5, 270: 2, 272: 3, 273: 6, 287: 4, 289: 3, 291: 5, 299: 4, 300: 2, 309: 4, 314: 3, 315: 3, 320: 5, 323: 5, 327: 5, 328: 4, 329: 3, 330: 11, 334: 3, 335: 2, 341: 4, 342: 5, 347: 4, 348: 4, 350: 8, 351: 5, 352: 3, 353: 3, 354: 2, 358: 5, 365: 3, 366: 3, 369: 2, 371: 6, 372: 5, 376: 3, 384: 5, 385: 4, 386: 4, 387: 2, 392: 4, 393: 5, 396: 5, 397: 8, 398: 7, 402: 3} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 130 "Placement of TSN functions depends on the TSN capabilities of the nodes along the path. MPLS (DetNet) Nodes may or may not support TSN functions. For a given TSN Stream (i.e., DetNet flow) an MPLS (DetNet) node is treated as a Talker or a Listener inside the TSN sub-network." "Comments resolved : Routing Directorate I approved these . The Changes looked good to me . I opened a small pull request to fix commas ." 7fe7425604ef66b60a158a23aecf46a764d6a9b3 7fe7425604ef66b60a158a23aecf46a764d6a9b3 draft-ietf-detnet-mpls-over-tsn c2ec0a70883cb097b82a41899151bd7d70d7cdd2474a9670fb5982175fb1b35d ['c2ec0a70883cb097b82a41899151bd7d70d7cdd2474a9670fb5982175fb1b35d', '3703b0838ce47d992f259e22b20012a302240311d21f2d269cbb1414baec967f'] B "placement of tsn functions depends on the tsn capabilities of the nodes along the path. mpls (detnet) nodes may or may not support tsn functions. for a given tsn stream (i.e., detnet flow) an mpls (detnet) node is treated as a talker or a listener inside the tsn sub-network." {52: 1, 6: 3, 79: 3, 90: 3, 51: 2, 130: 3, 62: 4, 85: 5, 68: 5, 35: 4, 110: 3, 91: 5, 114: 3, 97: 2, 31: 4, 13: 3, 67: 3, 38: 4, 26: 3, 124: 4, 98: 3, 54: 3, 127: 4, 8: 3, 96: 2, 64: 3, 30: 3, 61: 5, 55: 4, 27: 4, 15: 3, 129: 4, 115: 3, 84: 3, 76: 7, 87: 3, 131: 6, 102: 3, 113: 5, 99: 3, 36: 3, 24: 2, 53: 2, 72: 4} {156: 1, 1: 10, 4: 3, 9: 6, 10: 4, 15: 2, 24: 3, 25: 4, 26: 5, 27: 2, 39: 6, 43: 4, 49: 6, 50: 5, 58: 5, 59: 3, 64: 2, 69: 5, 81: 5, 82: 3, 86: 3, 96: 4, 97: 3, 100: 6, 108: 4, 109: 5, 110: 5, 111: 3, 114: 4, 115: 5, 116: 2, 118: 7, 119: 6, 120: 4, 121: 5, 122: 3, 123: 2, 124: 5, 128: 4, 129: 3, 130: 5, 132: 5, 136: 3, 145: 5, 147: 4, 151: 4, 152: 4, 154: 4, 161: 4, 162: 4, 165: 4, 168: 5, 169: 3, 172: 3, 180: 4, 184: 6, 187: 6, 188: 5, 191: 4, 194: 5, 202: 6, 203: 7, 206: 3, 207: 4, 215: 3, 217: 4, 218: 9, 220: 3, 221: 3, 222: 6, 224: 4, 227: 4, 229: 3, 234: 6, 235: 3, 241: 3, 242: 3, 243: 5, 244: 4, 245: 5, 248: 4, 250: 3, 258: 12, 262: 5, 263: 6, 264: 4, 267: 5, 270: 2, 272: 3, 273: 6, 287: 4, 289: 3, 291: 5, 299: 4, 300: 2, 309: 4, 314: 3, 315: 3, 320: 5, 323: 5, 327: 5, 328: 4, 329: 3, 330: 11, 334: 3, 335: 2, 341: 4, 342: 5, 347: 4, 348: 4, 350: 8, 351: 5, 352: 3, 353: 3, 354: 2, 358: 5, 365: 3, 366: 3, 369: 2, 371: 6, 372: 5, 376: 3, 384: 5, 385: 4, 386: 4, 387: 2, 392: 4, 393: 5, 396: 5, 397: 8, 398: 7, 402: 3} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 130 "A TSN-aware MPLS (DetNet) node impementations must support the Stream Identification TSN component for recognizing flows." "Comments resolved : Routing Directorate I approved these . The Changes looked good to me . I opened a small pull request to fix commas ." 7fe7425604ef66b60a158a23aecf46a764d6a9b3 7fe7425604ef66b60a158a23aecf46a764d6a9b3 draft-ietf-detnet-mpls-over-tsn a15141054140f646c5e3217334260611d92fd3505283fb46aba6a169d9b9072d ['a15141054140f646c5e3217334260611d92fd3505283fb46aba6a169d9b9072d', 'cf162f273d32b90a57ddb5c2a7f3eae8b68c4a25dccbc7b14d42a8b090b97ea5'] A "a tsn-aware mpls (detnet) node impementations must support the stream identification tsn component for recognizing flows." {} {} {253} 130 "A TSN-aware MPLS (DetNet) node implementation must support the Stream Identification TSN component for recognizing flows." "Comments resolved : Routing Directorate I approved these . The Changes looked good to me . I opened a small pull request to fix commas ." 7fe7425604ef66b60a158a23aecf46a764d6a9b3 7fe7425604ef66b60a158a23aecf46a764d6a9b3 draft-ietf-detnet-mpls-over-tsn cf162f273d32b90a57ddb5c2a7f3eae8b68c4a25dccbc7b14d42a8b090b97ea5 ['a15141054140f646c5e3217334260611d92fd3505283fb46aba6a169d9b9072d', 'cf162f273d32b90a57ddb5c2a7f3eae8b68c4a25dccbc7b14d42a8b090b97ea5'] B "a tsn-aware mpls (detnet) node implementation must support the stream identification tsn component for recognizing flows." {} {} {253} 130 "A TSN-aware MPLS (DetNet) node implementations must support the Sequencing function and the Sequence encode/decode function as defined in Clause 7.4 and 7.6 of IEEE8021CB if FRER is used inside the TSN sub-network." "Comments resolved : Routing Directorate I approved these . The Changes looked good to me . I opened a small pull request to fix commas ." 7fe7425604ef66b60a158a23aecf46a764d6a9b3 7fe7425604ef66b60a158a23aecf46a764d6a9b3 draft-ietf-detnet-mpls-over-tsn 20e8a76d1d7117733605968119bf4ec6b79488ce412e4ca8f9eb89a742447e00 ['20e8a76d1d7117733605968119bf4ec6b79488ce412e4ca8f9eb89a742447e00', '8b60cc95ba286930101dd3736129b79d89c5d394873fcf2ffa520eaf76d90d00'] A "a tsn-aware mpls (detnet) node implementations must support the sequencing function and the sequence encode/decode function as defined in clause 7.4 and 7.6 of ieee8021cb if frer is used inside the tsn sub-network." {} {} {44} 130 "A TSN-aware MPLS (DetNet) node implementation must support the Sequencing function and the Sequence encode/decode function as defined in Clause 7.4 and 7.6 of IEEE8021CB if FRER is used inside the TSN sub-network." "Comments resolved : Routing Directorate I approved these . The Changes looked good to me . I opened a small pull request to fix commas ." 7fe7425604ef66b60a158a23aecf46a764d6a9b3 7fe7425604ef66b60a158a23aecf46a764d6a9b3 draft-ietf-detnet-mpls-over-tsn 8b60cc95ba286930101dd3736129b79d89c5d394873fcf2ffa520eaf76d90d00 ['20e8a76d1d7117733605968119bf4ec6b79488ce412e4ca8f9eb89a742447e00', '8b60cc95ba286930101dd3736129b79d89c5d394873fcf2ffa520eaf76d90d00'] B "a tsn-aware mpls (detnet) node implementation must support the sequencing function and the sequence encode/decode function as defined in clause 7.4 and 7.6 of ieee8021cb if frer is used inside the tsn sub-network." {} {} {44} 130 "A TSN-aware MPLS (DetNet) node implementations must support the Stream splitting function and the Individual recovery function as defined in Clause 7.7 and 7.5 of IEEE8021CB when the node is a replication or elimination point for FRER." "Comments resolved : Routing Directorate I approved these . The Changes looked good to me . I opened a small pull request to fix commas ." 7fe7425604ef66b60a158a23aecf46a764d6a9b3 7fe7425604ef66b60a158a23aecf46a764d6a9b3 draft-ietf-detnet-mpls-over-tsn a1408e5e5903e323b5c5c13c0d8d0afbc6d4e7ebd420c1031f6f935b42aadff0 ['a1408e5e5903e323b5c5c13c0d8d0afbc6d4e7ebd420c1031f6f935b42aadff0', '78fd680af3ed4f33199fc674c1e0b45db096d19fc3229badd011d16faf0c3263'] A "a tsn-aware mpls (detnet) node implementations must support the stream splitting function and the individual recovery function as defined in clause 7.7 and 7.5 of ieee8021cb when the node is a replication or elimination point for frer." {} {} {252} 130 "A TSN-aware MPLS (DetNet) node implementation must support the Stream splitting function and the Individual recovery function as defined in Clause 7.7 and 7.5 of IEEE8021CB when the node is a replication or elimination point for FRER." "Comments resolved : Routing Directorate I approved these . The Changes looked good to me . I opened a small pull request to fix commas ." 7fe7425604ef66b60a158a23aecf46a764d6a9b3 7fe7425604ef66b60a158a23aecf46a764d6a9b3 draft-ietf-detnet-mpls-over-tsn 78fd680af3ed4f33199fc674c1e0b45db096d19fc3229badd011d16faf0c3263 ['a1408e5e5903e323b5c5c13c0d8d0afbc6d4e7ebd420c1031f6f935b42aadff0', '78fd680af3ed4f33199fc674c1e0b45db096d19fc3229badd011d16faf0c3263'] B "a tsn-aware mpls (detnet) node implementation must support the stream splitting function and the individual recovery function as defined in clause 7.7 and 7.5 of ieee8021cb when the node is a replication or elimination point for frer." {} {} {252} 130 "Mapping between DetNet MPLS flow(s) (label information: A-labels, S-labels and F-labels as defined in I-D.ietf-detnet-mpls) and TSN Stream(s) (as stream identification information defined in IEEEP8021CBdb). Note, that managed objects for TSN Stream identification can be found in IEEEP8021CBcv." "Comments resolved : Routing Directorate I approved these . The Changes looked good to me . I opened a small pull request to fix commas ." 7fe7425604ef66b60a158a23aecf46a764d6a9b3 7fe7425604ef66b60a158a23aecf46a764d6a9b3 draft-ietf-detnet-mpls-over-tsn 43e5814a17a454f50eb0fb05d78e6d6e5f42f589075dc86370a9ed068d1f641f ['8480d9ca21cdd1e27e684e583c62c478124da92bec8b386c62f27747e2018e62', '00b078ed8c4467df11938165ba346a18c3aa3b0ea24c46f7046739aeaf9617c9', '43e5814a17a454f50eb0fb05d78e6d6e5f42f589075dc86370a9ed068d1f641f', '661c7ac6177c526d0c68e1371bbe0c7dba9685b71602762903636b3451e18b51'] A "mapping between detnet mpls flow(s) (label information: a-labels, s-labels and f-labels as defined in i-d.ietf-detnet-mpls) and tsn stream(s) (as stream identification information defined in ieeep8021cbdb). note, that managed objects for tsn stream identification can be found in ieeep8021cbcv." {97: 1, 98: 2, 96: 2, 127: 3, 124: 3} {12: 1, 13: 2, 403: 2, 153: 3, 63: 3} {12, 13, 208, 403, 153, 63} 130 "Mappings between DetNet and TSN management and control planes are out of scope of the document. Some of the challanges are highligthed below." "Comments resolved : Routing Directorate I approved these . The Changes looked good to me . I opened a small pull request to fix commas ." 7fe7425604ef66b60a158a23aecf46a764d6a9b3 7fe7425604ef66b60a158a23aecf46a764d6a9b3 draft-ietf-detnet-mpls-over-tsn 661c7ac6177c526d0c68e1371bbe0c7dba9685b71602762903636b3451e18b51 ['8480d9ca21cdd1e27e684e583c62c478124da92bec8b386c62f27747e2018e62', '00b078ed8c4467df11938165ba346a18c3aa3b0ea24c46f7046739aeaf9617c9', '43e5814a17a454f50eb0fb05d78e6d6e5f42f589075dc86370a9ed068d1f641f', '661c7ac6177c526d0c68e1371bbe0c7dba9685b71602762903636b3451e18b51'] A "mappings between detnet and tsn management and control planes are out of scope of the document. some of the challanges are highligthed below." {97: 1, 98: 2, 96: 2, 127: 3, 124: 3} {12: 1, 13: 2, 403: 2, 153: 3, 63: 3} {12, 13, 208, 403, 153, 63} 130 "Mapping between DetNet MPLS flow(s) (label information: A-labels, S-labels and F-labels as defined in RFC8964) and TSN Stream(s) (as stream identification information defined in IEEEP8021CBdb). Note, that managed objects for TSN Stream identification can be found in IEEEP8021CBcv." "Comments resolved : Routing Directorate I approved these . The Changes looked good to me . I opened a small pull request to fix commas ." 7fe7425604ef66b60a158a23aecf46a764d6a9b3 7fe7425604ef66b60a158a23aecf46a764d6a9b3 draft-ietf-detnet-mpls-over-tsn 00b078ed8c4467df11938165ba346a18c3aa3b0ea24c46f7046739aeaf9617c9 ['8480d9ca21cdd1e27e684e583c62c478124da92bec8b386c62f27747e2018e62', '00b078ed8c4467df11938165ba346a18c3aa3b0ea24c46f7046739aeaf9617c9', '43e5814a17a454f50eb0fb05d78e6d6e5f42f589075dc86370a9ed068d1f641f', '661c7ac6177c526d0c68e1371bbe0c7dba9685b71602762903636b3451e18b51'] B "mapping between detnet mpls flow(s) (label information: a-labels, s-labels and f-labels as defined in rfc8964) and tsn stream(s) (as stream identification information defined in ieeep8021cbdb). note, that managed objects for tsn stream identification can be found in ieeep8021cbcv." {97: 1, 98: 2, 96: 2, 127: 3, 124: 3} {12: 1, 13: 2, 403: 2, 153: 3, 63: 3} {12, 13, 208, 403, 153, 63} 130 "Mappings between DetNet and TSN management and control planes are out of scope of the document. Some of the challenges are highlighted below." "Comments resolved : Routing Directorate I approved these . The Changes looked good to me . I opened a small pull request to fix commas ." 7fe7425604ef66b60a158a23aecf46a764d6a9b3 7fe7425604ef66b60a158a23aecf46a764d6a9b3 draft-ietf-detnet-mpls-over-tsn 8480d9ca21cdd1e27e684e583c62c478124da92bec8b386c62f27747e2018e62 ['8480d9ca21cdd1e27e684e583c62c478124da92bec8b386c62f27747e2018e62', '00b078ed8c4467df11938165ba346a18c3aa3b0ea24c46f7046739aeaf9617c9', '43e5814a17a454f50eb0fb05d78e6d6e5f42f589075dc86370a9ed068d1f641f', '661c7ac6177c526d0c68e1371bbe0c7dba9685b71602762903636b3451e18b51'] B "mappings between detnet and tsn management and control planes are out of scope of the document. some of the challenges are highlighted below." {97: 1, 98: 2, 96: 2, 127: 3, 124: 3} {12: 1, 13: 2, 403: 2, 153: 3, 63: 3} {12, 13, 208, 403, 153, 63} 130 "Security considerations for DetNet are described in detail in I- D.ietf-detnet-security. General security considerations are described in RFC8655. DetNet MPLS data plane specific considerations are summarized in I-D.ietf-detnet-mpls. This section considers exclusively security considerations which are specific to the DetNet MPLS over TSN sub-network scenario." "Comments resolved : Routing Directorate I approved these . The Changes looked good to me . I opened a small pull request to fix commas ." 7fe7425604ef66b60a158a23aecf46a764d6a9b3 7fe7425604ef66b60a158a23aecf46a764d6a9b3 draft-ietf-detnet-mpls-over-tsn a0e0fcdf5b5fdc8e71b55e1780d9267f201453ab89e2c7f05fc980c2ab0b10b7 ['935a31c7c75d244fe736e86405faf4e857eaebb93fbbe369382988347e8ba983', 'a0e0fcdf5b5fdc8e71b55e1780d9267f201453ab89e2c7f05fc980c2ab0b10b7'] A "security considerations for detnet are described in detail in i- d.ietf-detnet-security. general security considerations are described in rfc8655. detnet mpls data plane specific considerations are summarized in i-d.ietf-detnet-mpls. this section considers exclusively security considerations which are specific to the detnet mpls over tsn sub-network scenario." {97: 1, 96: 2, 127: 3} {249: 1, 318: 2, 319: 3} {225, 249, 318, 319} 130 "Security considerations for DetNet are described in detail in I- D.ietf-detnet-security. General security considerations are described in RFC8655. DetNet MPLS data plane specific considerations are summarized in RFC8964. This section considers exclusively security considerations which are specific to the DetNet MPLS over TSN sub-network scenario." "Comments resolved : Routing Directorate I approved these . The Changes looked good to me . I opened a small pull request to fix commas ." 7fe7425604ef66b60a158a23aecf46a764d6a9b3 7fe7425604ef66b60a158a23aecf46a764d6a9b3 draft-ietf-detnet-mpls-over-tsn 935a31c7c75d244fe736e86405faf4e857eaebb93fbbe369382988347e8ba983 ['935a31c7c75d244fe736e86405faf4e857eaebb93fbbe369382988347e8ba983', 'a0e0fcdf5b5fdc8e71b55e1780d9267f201453ab89e2c7f05fc980c2ab0b10b7'] B "security considerations for detnet are described in detail in i- d.ietf-detnet-security. general security considerations are described in rfc8655. detnet mpls data plane specific considerations are summarized in rfc8964. this section considers exclusively security considerations which are specific to the detnet mpls over tsn sub-network scenario." {97: 1, 96: 2, 127: 3} {249: 1, 318: 2, 319: 3} {225, 249, 318, 319} 130 "This document specifies the use of a DetNet MPLS network to interconnect TSN nodes/network segments. DetNet MPLS data plane is defined in I-D.ietf-detnet-mpls." "Comments resolved : Routing Directorate I approved these . The Changes looked good to me . I opened a small pull request to fix commas ." 7fe7425604ef66b60a158a23aecf46a764d6a9b3 7fe7425604ef66b60a158a23aecf46a764d6a9b3 draft-ietf-detnet-tsn-vpn-over-mpls 01a18790f41b769613de4d30c8d1d12d964b688a283f28fffa0a449aeb9e677a ['01a18790f41b769613de4d30c8d1d12d964b688a283f28fffa0a449aeb9e677a', 'b3ed36256fe008568f0fa90ae790830c0c95e1447f8ac848455618113f63b1bf'] A "this document specifies the use of a detnet mpls network to interconnect tsn nodes/network segments. detnet mpls data plane is defined in i-d.ietf-detnet-mpls." {53: 1, 79: 3, 51: 3, 112: 4, 55: 4, 64: 2, 62: 4, 37: 3, 130: 4, 38: 3, 69: 3, 68: 3, 67: 2, 33: 2, 25: 3, 80: 3, 52: 2, 127: 3, 91: 4} {322: 1, 389: 3, 390: 3, 135: 4, 142: 4, 14: 2, 400: 4, 17: 3, 399: 4, 19: 3, 149: 4, 406: 3, 279: 3, 280: 3, 281: 2, 278: 2, 294: 3, 296: 4, 45: 4, 308: 3, 56: 2, 185: 3, 192: 3, 321: 2, 66: 3, 196: 4, 197: 3, 324: 3, 77: 4, 78: 4, 337: 5, 216: 4, 380: 3, 255: 2} {0, 389, 390, 135, 142, 14, 400, 17, 399, 19, 149, 406, 279, 280, 281, 278, 294, 296, 45, 308, 56, 185, 192, 321, 322, 66, 196, 197, 324, 77, 78, 337, 216, 380, 255} 130 "This document specifies the use of a DetNet MPLS network to interconnect TSN nodes/network segments. DetNet MPLS data plane is defined in RFC8964." "Comments resolved : Routing Directorate I approved these . The Changes looked good to me . I opened a small pull request to fix commas ." 7fe7425604ef66b60a158a23aecf46a764d6a9b3 7fe7425604ef66b60a158a23aecf46a764d6a9b3 draft-ietf-detnet-tsn-vpn-over-mpls b3ed36256fe008568f0fa90ae790830c0c95e1447f8ac848455618113f63b1bf ['01a18790f41b769613de4d30c8d1d12d964b688a283f28fffa0a449aeb9e677a', 'b3ed36256fe008568f0fa90ae790830c0c95e1447f8ac848455618113f63b1bf'] B "this document specifies the use of a detnet mpls network to interconnect tsn nodes/network segments. detnet mpls data plane is defined in rfc8964." {53: 1, 79: 3, 51: 3, 112: 4, 55: 4, 64: 2, 62: 4, 37: 3, 130: 4, 38: 3, 69: 3, 68: 3, 67: 2, 33: 2, 25: 3, 80: 3, 52: 2, 127: 3, 91: 4} {322: 1, 389: 3, 390: 3, 135: 4, 142: 4, 14: 2, 400: 4, 17: 3, 399: 4, 19: 3, 149: 4, 406: 3, 279: 3, 280: 3, 281: 2, 278: 2, 294: 3, 296: 4, 45: 4, 308: 3, 56: 2, 185: 3, 192: 3, 321: 2, 66: 3, 196: 4, 197: 3, 324: 3, 77: 4, 78: 4, 337: 5, 216: 4, 380: 3, 255: 2} {0, 389, 390, 135, 142, 14, 400, 17, 399, 19, 149, 406, 279, 280, 281, 278, 294, 296, 45, 308, 56, 185, 192, 321, 322, 66, 196, 197, 324, 77, 78, 337, 216, 380, 255} 130 "This document uses the terminology and concepts established in the DetNet architecture RFC8655 and RFC8938, and I-D.ietf-detnet-mpls. The reader is assumed to be familiar with these documents and their terminology." "Comments resolved : Routing Directorate I approved these . The Changes looked good to me . I opened a small pull request to fix commas ." 7fe7425604ef66b60a158a23aecf46a764d6a9b3 7fe7425604ef66b60a158a23aecf46a764d6a9b3 draft-ietf-detnet-tsn-vpn-over-mpls 7e104acddc07f8fbdbdb190e11f543a072b5d88a5a57f61edf7790fd16902d4f ['7e104acddc07f8fbdbdb190e11f543a072b5d88a5a57f61edf7790fd16902d4f', '7c107fc004f62dc2f2cc01e2ee8201d1d8ac443089fac9df37a3bbc4f74fa39a'] A "this document uses the terminology and concepts established in the detnet architecture rfc8655 and rfc8938, and i-d.ietf-detnet-mpls. the reader is assumed to be familiar with these documents and their terminology." {127: 1, 130: 4, 79: 5, 51: 5, 112: 6, 55: 6, 64: 4, 62: 6, 37: 5, 38: 5, 69: 5, 68: 5, 67: 2, 33: 4, 25: 5, 53: 3, 80: 5, 52: 4, 91: 6} {197: 1, 0: 4, 389: 5, 390: 5, 135: 6, 142: 6, 14: 4, 400: 6, 17: 5, 399: 6, 19: 5, 149: 6, 406: 5, 279: 5, 280: 5, 281: 2, 278: 4, 294: 5, 296: 6, 45: 6, 308: 5, 56: 4, 185: 5, 192: 5, 321: 4, 322: 3, 66: 5, 324: 5, 77: 6, 78: 6, 337: 7, 216: 6, 380: 5, 255: 4} {0, 389, 390, 135, 142, 14, 400, 17, 399, 19, 149, 406, 279, 280, 281, 278, 294, 296, 45, 308, 56, 185, 192, 321, 322, 66, 196, 197, 324, 77, 78, 337, 216, 380, 255} 130 "This document uses the terminology and concepts established in the DetNet architecture RFC8655 and RFC8938, and RFC8964. TSN specific terms are defined in the TSN TG of IEEE 802.1 Working Group. The reader is assumed to be familiar with these documents and their terminology." "Comments resolved : Routing Directorate I approved these . The Changes looked good to me . I opened a small pull request to fix commas ." 7fe7425604ef66b60a158a23aecf46a764d6a9b3 7fe7425604ef66b60a158a23aecf46a764d6a9b3 draft-ietf-detnet-tsn-vpn-over-mpls 7c107fc004f62dc2f2cc01e2ee8201d1d8ac443089fac9df37a3bbc4f74fa39a ['7e104acddc07f8fbdbdb190e11f543a072b5d88a5a57f61edf7790fd16902d4f', '7c107fc004f62dc2f2cc01e2ee8201d1d8ac443089fac9df37a3bbc4f74fa39a'] B "this document uses the terminology and concepts established in the detnet architecture rfc8655 and rfc8938, and rfc8964. tsn specific terms are defined in the tsn tg of ieee 802.1 working group. the reader is assumed to be familiar with these documents and their terminology." {127: 1, 130: 4, 79: 5, 51: 5, 112: 6, 55: 6, 64: 4, 62: 6, 37: 5, 38: 5, 69: 5, 68: 5, 67: 2, 33: 4, 25: 5, 53: 3, 80: 5, 52: 4, 91: 6} {197: 1, 0: 4, 389: 5, 390: 5, 135: 6, 142: 6, 14: 4, 400: 6, 17: 5, 399: 6, 19: 5, 149: 6, 406: 5, 279: 5, 280: 5, 281: 2, 278: 4, 294: 5, 296: 6, 45: 6, 308: 5, 56: 4, 185: 5, 192: 5, 321: 4, 322: 3, 66: 5, 324: 5, 77: 6, 78: 6, 337: 7, 216: 6, 380: 5, 255: 4} {0, 389, 390, 135, 142, 14, 400, 17, 399, 19, 149, 406, 279, 280, 281, 278, 294, 296, 45, 308, 56, 185, 192, 321, 322, 66, 196, 197, 324, 77, 78, 337, 216, 380, 255} 130 "In the figure, ""Application"" indicates the application payload carried by the TSN network. ""MPLS App-Flow"" indicates that the TSN Stream is the payload from the perspective of the DetNet MPLS data plane defined in I-D.ietf-detnet-mpls. A single DetNet MPLS flow can aggregate multiple TSN Streams." "Comments resolved : Routing Directorate I approved these . The Changes looked good to me . I opened a small pull request to fix commas ." 7fe7425604ef66b60a158a23aecf46a764d6a9b3 7fe7425604ef66b60a158a23aecf46a764d6a9b3 draft-ietf-detnet-tsn-vpn-over-mpls 1b8137b4c60774716e4a492efec48060d48abd7308563d8cc76edf32d98bd759 ['188756ded08eafae405fb8e58e6ed9e494490072d8272203c62c0b8c24c83d67', '1b8137b4c60774716e4a492efec48060d48abd7308563d8cc76edf32d98bd759'] A "in the figure, ""application"" indicates the application payload carried by the tsn network. ""mpls app-flow"" indicates that the tsn stream is the payload from the perspective of the detnet mpls data plane defined in i-d.ietf-detnet-mpls. a single detnet mpls flow can aggregate multiple tsn streams." {53: 1, 6: 2, 79: 2, 90: 3, 51: 3, 62: 5, 85: 5, 68: 4, 35: 3, 110: 3, 91: 5, 114: 3, 97: 3, 31: 3, 13: 3, 67: 3, 38: 4, 26: 3, 130: 2, 124: 3, 98: 2, 54: 2, 127: 3, 8: 2, 96: 3, 64: 2, 30: 4, 61: 5, 55: 3, 27: 4, 15: 3, 52: 2, 129: 3, 115: 3, 84: 3, 76: 6, 87: 3, 131: 5, 102: 3, 113: 5, 99: 2, 36: 3, 24: 2, 72: 4} {369: 1, 1: 9, 4: 2, 9: 5, 10: 3, 15: 3, 25: 5, 26: 5, 27: 3, 39: 5, 43: 3, 49: 6, 50: 5, 58: 5, 59: 2, 64: 3, 69: 4, 81: 6, 82: 4, 86: 3, 96: 4, 97: 3, 100: 7, 108: 3, 109: 4, 110: 4, 111: 2, 114: 3, 115: 4, 116: 3, 118: 6, 119: 5, 120: 3, 121: 4, 122: 4, 123: 3, 124: 4, 128: 4, 129: 4, 130: 5, 132: 4, 136: 2, 145: 4, 147: 4, 151: 4, 152: 4, 154: 3, 156: 2, 161: 3, 162: 3, 165: 3, 168: 4, 169: 3, 172: 3, 180: 4, 184: 5, 187: 5, 188: 4, 191: 3, 194: 4, 202: 5, 203: 6, 206: 2, 207: 3, 215: 2, 217: 3, 218: 8, 220: 2, 221: 2, 222: 5, 224: 3, 227: 5, 229: 3, 234: 5, 235: 2, 241: 2, 242: 2, 243: 4, 244: 4, 245: 4, 248: 4, 250: 4, 258: 11, 262: 4, 263: 5, 264: 3, 267: 4, 270: 3, 272: 3, 273: 5, 287: 3, 289: 3, 291: 5, 299: 5, 300: 3, 304: 3, 309: 3, 314: 2, 315: 3, 320: 4, 323: 4, 327: 4, 328: 3, 329: 2, 330: 10, 334: 2, 335: 3, 341: 5, 342: 6, 347: 5, 348: 5, 350: 7, 351: 5, 352: 3, 353: 3, 354: 2, 358: 4, 365: 3, 366: 2, 371: 7, 372: 5, 376: 2, 384: 5, 385: 4, 386: 3, 387: 3, 392: 3, 393: 4, 396: 6, 397: 7, 398: 6, 402: 3} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 130 "In the figure, ""Application"" indicates the application payload carried by the TSN network. ""MPLS App-Flow"" indicates that the TSN Stream is the payload from the perspective of the DetNet MPLS data plane defined in RFC8964. A single DetNet MPLS flow can aggregate multiple TSN Streams." "Comments resolved : Routing Directorate I approved these . The Changes looked good to me . I opened a small pull request to fix commas ." 7fe7425604ef66b60a158a23aecf46a764d6a9b3 7fe7425604ef66b60a158a23aecf46a764d6a9b3 draft-ietf-detnet-tsn-vpn-over-mpls 188756ded08eafae405fb8e58e6ed9e494490072d8272203c62c0b8c24c83d67 ['188756ded08eafae405fb8e58e6ed9e494490072d8272203c62c0b8c24c83d67', '1b8137b4c60774716e4a492efec48060d48abd7308563d8cc76edf32d98bd759'] B "in the figure, ""application"" indicates the application payload carried by the tsn network. ""mpls app-flow"" indicates that the tsn stream is the payload from the perspective of the detnet mpls data plane defined in rfc8964. a single detnet mpls flow can aggregate multiple tsn streams." {53: 1, 6: 2, 79: 2, 90: 3, 51: 3, 62: 5, 85: 5, 68: 4, 35: 3, 110: 3, 91: 5, 114: 3, 97: 3, 31: 3, 13: 3, 67: 3, 38: 4, 26: 3, 130: 2, 124: 3, 98: 2, 54: 2, 127: 3, 8: 2, 96: 3, 64: 2, 30: 4, 61: 5, 55: 3, 27: 4, 15: 3, 52: 2, 129: 3, 115: 3, 84: 3, 76: 6, 87: 3, 131: 5, 102: 3, 113: 5, 99: 2, 36: 3, 24: 2, 72: 4} {369: 1, 1: 9, 4: 2, 9: 5, 10: 3, 15: 3, 25: 5, 26: 5, 27: 3, 39: 5, 43: 3, 49: 6, 50: 5, 58: 5, 59: 2, 64: 3, 69: 4, 81: 6, 82: 4, 86: 3, 96: 4, 97: 3, 100: 7, 108: 3, 109: 4, 110: 4, 111: 2, 114: 3, 115: 4, 116: 3, 118: 6, 119: 5, 120: 3, 121: 4, 122: 4, 123: 3, 124: 4, 128: 4, 129: 4, 130: 5, 132: 4, 136: 2, 145: 4, 147: 4, 151: 4, 152: 4, 154: 3, 156: 2, 161: 3, 162: 3, 165: 3, 168: 4, 169: 3, 172: 3, 180: 4, 184: 5, 187: 5, 188: 4, 191: 3, 194: 4, 202: 5, 203: 6, 206: 2, 207: 3, 215: 2, 217: 3, 218: 8, 220: 2, 221: 2, 222: 5, 224: 3, 227: 5, 229: 3, 234: 5, 235: 2, 241: 2, 242: 2, 243: 4, 244: 4, 245: 4, 248: 4, 250: 4, 258: 11, 262: 4, 263: 5, 264: 3, 267: 4, 270: 3, 272: 3, 273: 5, 287: 3, 289: 3, 291: 5, 299: 5, 300: 3, 304: 3, 309: 3, 314: 2, 315: 3, 320: 4, 323: 4, 327: 4, 328: 3, 329: 2, 330: 10, 334: 2, 335: 3, 341: 5, 342: 6, 347: 5, 348: 5, 350: 7, 351: 5, 352: 3, 353: 3, 354: 2, 358: 4, 365: 3, 366: 2, 371: 7, 372: 5, 376: 2, 384: 5, 385: 4, 386: 3, 387: 3, 392: 3, 393: 4, 396: 6, 397: 7, 398: 6, 402: 3} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 130 "TSN specific functions are executed on the data received by the DetNet Edge Node from the connected CE before forwarded to connected CE(s) or presentation to the DetNet Service Proxy function for transmission across the DetNet domain, or on the data received from a DetNet PW by a PE before it is output on the Attachment Circuit(s) (AC)." "Comments resolved : Routing Directorate I approved these . The Changes looked good to me . I opened a small pull request to fix commas ." 7fe7425604ef66b60a158a23aecf46a764d6a9b3 7fe7425604ef66b60a158a23aecf46a764d6a9b3 draft-ietf-detnet-tsn-vpn-over-mpls 2e2975ca1e6c9674ad57d68234a7a66554f20a02dc288c2ba645f329c82428af ['f1fd304d5c41dded255b61cd6f2d49c9235bef27f0139a04efd807e05e1910de', '2e2975ca1e6c9674ad57d68234a7a66554f20a02dc288c2ba645f329c82428af'] A "tsn specific functions are executed on the data received by the detnet edge node from the connected ce before forwarded to connected ce(s) or presentation to the detnet service proxy function for transmission across the detnet domain, or on the data received from a detnet pw by a pe before it is output on the attachment circuit(s) (ac)." {79: 1, 6: 3, 90: 4, 51: 4, 130: 3, 62: 6, 85: 6, 68: 5, 35: 4, 110: 4, 91: 6, 114: 4, 97: 4, 31: 4, 13: 4, 67: 4, 38: 5, 26: 4, 124: 4, 98: 3, 54: 3, 127: 4, 8: 3, 96: 4, 64: 3, 30: 5, 61: 6, 55: 4, 27: 5, 15: 4, 52: 3, 129: 4, 115: 4, 84: 4, 76: 7, 87: 4, 131: 6, 102: 4, 113: 6, 99: 3, 36: 4, 24: 3, 53: 2, 72: 5} {59: 1, 1: 10, 4: 3, 9: 6, 10: 4, 15: 4, 24: 3, 25: 6, 26: 6, 27: 4, 39: 6, 43: 4, 49: 7, 50: 6, 58: 6, 64: 4, 69: 5, 81: 7, 82: 5, 86: 4, 96: 5, 97: 4, 100: 8, 108: 4, 109: 5, 110: 5, 111: 3, 114: 4, 115: 5, 116: 4, 118: 7, 119: 6, 120: 4, 121: 5, 122: 5, 123: 4, 124: 5, 128: 5, 129: 5, 130: 6, 132: 5, 136: 3, 145: 5, 147: 5, 151: 5, 152: 5, 154: 4, 156: 3, 161: 4, 162: 4, 165: 4, 168: 5, 169: 4, 172: 4, 180: 5, 184: 6, 187: 6, 188: 5, 191: 4, 194: 5, 202: 6, 203: 7, 206: 3, 207: 4, 215: 3, 217: 4, 218: 9, 220: 3, 221: 3, 222: 6, 224: 4, 227: 6, 229: 4, 234: 6, 235: 3, 241: 3, 242: 3, 243: 5, 244: 5, 245: 5, 248: 5, 250: 5, 258: 12, 262: 5, 263: 6, 264: 4, 267: 5, 270: 4, 272: 4, 273: 6, 287: 4, 289: 4, 291: 6, 299: 6, 300: 4, 304: 4, 309: 4, 314: 3, 315: 4, 320: 5, 323: 5, 327: 5, 328: 4, 329: 3, 330: 11, 334: 3, 335: 4, 341: 6, 342: 7, 347: 6, 348: 6, 350: 8, 351: 6, 352: 4, 353: 4, 354: 3, 358: 5, 365: 4, 366: 3, 369: 2, 371: 8, 372: 6, 376: 3, 384: 6, 385: 5, 387: 4, 392: 4, 393: 5, 396: 7, 397: 8, 398: 7, 402: 4} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 130 "TSN specific functions are executed on the data received by the DetNet Edge Node from the connected CE before forwarded to connected CE(s) or presentation to the DetNet Service Proxy function for transmission across the DetNet domain. TSN specific functions are also executed on the data received from a DetNet PW by a PE before the data is output on the Attachment Circuit(s) (AC)." "Comments resolved : Routing Directorate I approved these . The Changes looked good to me . I opened a small pull request to fix commas ." 7fe7425604ef66b60a158a23aecf46a764d6a9b3 7fe7425604ef66b60a158a23aecf46a764d6a9b3 draft-ietf-detnet-tsn-vpn-over-mpls f1fd304d5c41dded255b61cd6f2d49c9235bef27f0139a04efd807e05e1910de ['f1fd304d5c41dded255b61cd6f2d49c9235bef27f0139a04efd807e05e1910de', '2e2975ca1e6c9674ad57d68234a7a66554f20a02dc288c2ba645f329c82428af'] B "tsn specific functions are executed on the data received by the detnet edge node from the connected ce before forwarded to connected ce(s) or presentation to the detnet service proxy function for transmission across the detnet domain. tsn specific functions are also executed on the data received from a detnet pw by a pe before the data is output on the attachment circuit(s) (ac)." {79: 1, 6: 3, 90: 4, 51: 4, 130: 3, 62: 6, 85: 6, 68: 5, 35: 4, 110: 4, 91: 6, 114: 4, 97: 4, 31: 4, 13: 4, 67: 4, 38: 5, 26: 4, 124: 4, 98: 3, 54: 3, 127: 4, 8: 3, 96: 4, 64: 3, 30: 5, 61: 6, 55: 4, 27: 5, 15: 4, 52: 3, 129: 4, 115: 4, 84: 4, 76: 7, 87: 4, 131: 6, 102: 4, 113: 6, 99: 3, 36: 4, 24: 3, 53: 2, 72: 5} {59: 1, 1: 10, 4: 3, 9: 6, 10: 4, 15: 4, 24: 3, 25: 6, 26: 6, 27: 4, 39: 6, 43: 4, 49: 7, 50: 6, 58: 6, 64: 4, 69: 5, 81: 7, 82: 5, 86: 4, 96: 5, 97: 4, 100: 8, 108: 4, 109: 5, 110: 5, 111: 3, 114: 4, 115: 5, 116: 4, 118: 7, 119: 6, 120: 4, 121: 5, 122: 5, 123: 4, 124: 5, 128: 5, 129: 5, 130: 6, 132: 5, 136: 3, 145: 5, 147: 5, 151: 5, 152: 5, 154: 4, 156: 3, 161: 4, 162: 4, 165: 4, 168: 5, 169: 4, 172: 4, 180: 5, 184: 6, 187: 6, 188: 5, 191: 4, 194: 5, 202: 6, 203: 7, 206: 3, 207: 4, 215: 3, 217: 4, 218: 9, 220: 3, 221: 3, 222: 6, 224: 4, 227: 6, 229: 4, 234: 6, 235: 3, 241: 3, 242: 3, 243: 5, 244: 5, 245: 5, 248: 5, 250: 5, 258: 12, 262: 5, 263: 6, 264: 4, 267: 5, 270: 4, 272: 4, 273: 6, 287: 4, 289: 4, 291: 6, 299: 6, 300: 4, 304: 4, 309: 4, 314: 3, 315: 4, 320: 5, 323: 5, 327: 5, 328: 4, 329: 3, 330: 11, 334: 3, 335: 4, 341: 6, 342: 7, 347: 6, 348: 6, 350: 8, 351: 6, 352: 4, 353: 4, 354: 3, 358: 5, 365: 4, 366: 3, 369: 2, 371: 8, 372: 6, 376: 3, 384: 6, 385: 5, 387: 4, 392: 4, 393: 5, 396: 7, 397: 8, 398: 7, 402: 4} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 130 "When a PE receives a packet from a CE, on a given AC with DetNet service, it first checks via Stream Identification (see Clause 6. of IEEE8021CB and IEEEP8021CBdb) whether the packet belongs to a configured TSN Stream (i.e., App-flow from DetNet perspective). If no Stream ID is matched and no other (VPN) service is configured for the AC then packet MUST be dropped. If there is a matching TSN Stream then the Stream-ID specific TSN functions are executed (e.g., ingress policing, header field manipulation in case of active Stream Identification, FRER, etc.). Source MAC lookup may also be used for local MAC address learning." "Comments resolved : Routing Directorate I approved these . The Changes looked good to me . I opened a small pull request to fix commas ." 7fe7425604ef66b60a158a23aecf46a764d6a9b3 7fe7425604ef66b60a158a23aecf46a764d6a9b3 draft-ietf-detnet-tsn-vpn-over-mpls 6c0ff9c59095578c17a7e77c18fdf9eec24ffd9bdeb449e9d192e2f7a34f9455 ['6c0ff9c59095578c17a7e77c18fdf9eec24ffd9bdeb449e9d192e2f7a34f9455', '1cc9810ece3682deda626f30e1dfa36339ab3eb464ebaee290218394d3e4eff9'] A "when a pe receives a packet from a ce, on a given ac with detnet service, it first checks via stream identification (see clause 6. of ieee8021cb and ieeep8021cbdb) whether the packet belongs to a configured tsn stream (i.e., app-flow from detnet perspective). if no stream id is matched and no other (vpn) service is configured for the ac then packet must be dropped. if there is a matching tsn stream then the stream-id specific tsn functions are executed (e.g., ingress policing, header field manipulation in case of active stream identification, frer, etc.). source mac lookup may also be used for local mac address learning." {131: 1, 124: 1, 6: 4, 79: 3, 90: 5, 51: 5, 130: 4, 62: 7, 85: 7, 68: 6, 35: 5, 110: 5, 91: 7, 114: 5, 97: 5, 31: 5, 13: 5, 67: 5, 38: 6, 26: 5, 98: 2, 54: 4, 127: 5, 8: 4, 96: 5, 64: 4, 30: 6, 61: 7, 55: 5, 27: 6, 15: 5, 52: 4, 129: 5, 115: 5, 84: 5, 76: 8, 87: 5, 102: 5, 113: 7, 99: 4, 36: 5, 24: 4, 53: 3, 72: 6} {234: 1, 207: 1, 1: 11, 4: 4, 9: 7, 10: 5, 15: 5, 24: 4, 25: 7, 26: 7, 27: 5, 39: 7, 43: 5, 49: 8, 50: 7, 58: 7, 59: 4, 64: 5, 69: 6, 81: 8, 82: 6, 86: 5, 96: 6, 97: 5, 100: 9, 108: 5, 109: 4, 110: 4, 111: 4, 114: 5, 115: 6, 116: 5, 118: 8, 119: 7, 120: 5, 121: 6, 122: 6, 123: 5, 124: 6, 128: 6, 129: 6, 130: 7, 132: 6, 136: 4, 145: 6, 147: 6, 151: 6, 152: 6, 154: 5, 156: 4, 161: 5, 162: 5, 165: 5, 169: 5, 172: 5, 180: 6, 184: 7, 187: 7, 188: 6, 191: 3, 194: 6, 202: 7, 203: 8, 206: 2, 215: 4, 217: 5, 218: 10, 220: 4, 221: 4, 222: 7, 224: 5, 227: 7, 229: 5, 235: 4, 241: 4, 242: 4, 243: 6, 244: 6, 245: 6, 248: 6, 250: 6, 258: 13, 262: 4, 263: 5, 264: 5, 267: 6, 270: 5, 272: 5, 273: 7, 287: 5, 289: 5, 291: 7, 299: 7, 300: 5, 304: 5, 309: 5, 314: 4, 315: 5, 320: 6, 323: 6, 327: 6, 328: 5, 329: 4, 330: 12, 334: 4, 335: 5, 341: 7, 342: 8, 347: 7, 348: 7, 350: 9, 351: 7, 352: 5, 353: 5, 354: 4, 358: 6, 365: 5, 366: 4, 369: 3, 371: 9, 372: 7, 376: 4, 384: 7, 385: 6, 386: 5, 387: 5, 392: 5, 393: 6, 396: 8, 397: 9, 398: 8, 402: 5} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 130 "When a PE receives a packet from a CE, on a given AC with DetNet service, it first checks via Stream Identification (see Clause 6. of IEEE8021CB and IEEEP8021CBdb) whether the packet belongs to a configured TSN Stream (i.e., App-flow from DetNet perspective). If no Stream ID is matched and no other (VPN) service is configured for the AC then packet MUST be dropped. If there is a matching TSN Stream then the Stream ID specific TSN functions are executed (e.g., ingress policing, header field manipulation in case of active Stream Identification, FRER, etc.). Source MAC lookup may also be used for local MAC address learning." "Comments resolved : Routing Directorate I approved these . The Changes looked good to me . I opened a small pull request to fix commas ." 7fe7425604ef66b60a158a23aecf46a764d6a9b3 7fe7425604ef66b60a158a23aecf46a764d6a9b3 draft-ietf-detnet-tsn-vpn-over-mpls 1cc9810ece3682deda626f30e1dfa36339ab3eb464ebaee290218394d3e4eff9 ['6c0ff9c59095578c17a7e77c18fdf9eec24ffd9bdeb449e9d192e2f7a34f9455', '1cc9810ece3682deda626f30e1dfa36339ab3eb464ebaee290218394d3e4eff9'] B "when a pe receives a packet from a ce, on a given ac with detnet service, it first checks via stream identification (see clause 6. of ieee8021cb and ieeep8021cbdb) whether the packet belongs to a configured tsn stream (i.e., app-flow from detnet perspective). if no stream id is matched and no other (vpn) service is configured for the ac then packet must be dropped. if there is a matching tsn stream then the stream id specific tsn functions are executed (e.g., ingress policing, header field manipulation in case of active stream identification, frer, etc.). source mac lookup may also be used for local mac address learning." {131: 1, 124: 1, 6: 4, 79: 3, 90: 5, 51: 5, 130: 4, 62: 7, 85: 7, 68: 6, 35: 5, 110: 5, 91: 7, 114: 5, 97: 5, 31: 5, 13: 5, 67: 5, 38: 6, 26: 5, 98: 2, 54: 4, 127: 5, 8: 4, 96: 5, 64: 4, 30: 6, 61: 7, 55: 5, 27: 6, 15: 5, 52: 4, 129: 5, 115: 5, 84: 5, 76: 8, 87: 5, 102: 5, 113: 7, 99: 4, 36: 5, 24: 4, 53: 3, 72: 6} {234: 1, 207: 1, 1: 11, 4: 4, 9: 7, 10: 5, 15: 5, 24: 4, 25: 7, 26: 7, 27: 5, 39: 7, 43: 5, 49: 8, 50: 7, 58: 7, 59: 4, 64: 5, 69: 6, 81: 8, 82: 6, 86: 5, 96: 6, 97: 5, 100: 9, 108: 5, 109: 4, 110: 4, 111: 4, 114: 5, 115: 6, 116: 5, 118: 8, 119: 7, 120: 5, 121: 6, 122: 6, 123: 5, 124: 6, 128: 6, 129: 6, 130: 7, 132: 6, 136: 4, 145: 6, 147: 6, 151: 6, 152: 6, 154: 5, 156: 4, 161: 5, 162: 5, 165: 5, 169: 5, 172: 5, 180: 6, 184: 7, 187: 7, 188: 6, 191: 3, 194: 6, 202: 7, 203: 8, 206: 2, 215: 4, 217: 5, 218: 10, 220: 4, 221: 4, 222: 7, 224: 5, 227: 7, 229: 5, 235: 4, 241: 4, 242: 4, 243: 6, 244: 6, 245: 6, 248: 6, 250: 6, 258: 13, 262: 4, 263: 5, 264: 5, 267: 6, 270: 5, 272: 5, 273: 7, 287: 5, 289: 5, 291: 7, 299: 7, 300: 5, 304: 5, 309: 5, 314: 4, 315: 5, 320: 6, 323: 6, 327: 6, 328: 5, 329: 4, 330: 12, 334: 4, 335: 5, 341: 7, 342: 8, 347: 7, 348: 7, 350: 9, 351: 7, 352: 5, 353: 5, 354: 4, 358: 6, 365: 5, 366: 4, 369: 3, 371: 9, 372: 7, 376: 4, 384: 7, 385: 6, 386: 5, 387: 5, 392: 5, 393: 6, 396: 8, 397: 9, 398: 8, 402: 5} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 130 "If the PE decides to forward the packet, the packet MUST be forwarded according to the TSN Stream specific configuration to connected CE(s) (in case of local bridging) and/or to the DetNet Service Proxy (in case of forwarding to remote CE(s) required). If there are no TSN Stream specific forwarding configurations the PE MUST flood the packet to other locally attached CE(s) and to the DetNet Service Proxy. If the administrative policy on the PE does not allow flooding the PE MUST drop the packet." "Comments resolved : Routing Directorate I approved these . The Changes looked good to me . I opened a small pull request to fix commas ." 7fe7425604ef66b60a158a23aecf46a764d6a9b3 7fe7425604ef66b60a158a23aecf46a764d6a9b3 draft-ietf-detnet-tsn-vpn-over-mpls 8150f930a0d0b4ecb9a9a0e68adda4846f4092ea2a55c7de339962c1bb9d5ed8 ['ab12071fc42e8540b5e57d7bcaff527c577148cf803114aa9627e1a77e39c093', '8150f930a0d0b4ecb9a9a0e68adda4846f4092ea2a55c7de339962c1bb9d5ed8'] A "if the pe decides to forward the packet, the packet must be forwarded according to the tsn stream specific configuration to connected ce(s) (in case of local bridging) and/or to the detnet service proxy (in case of forwarding to remote ce(s) required). if there are no tsn stream specific forwarding configurations the pe must flood the packet to other locally attached ce(s) and to the detnet service proxy. if the administrative policy on the pe does not allow flooding the pe must drop the packet." {79: 1, 131: 1, 6: 4, 90: 5, 51: 5, 130: 4, 62: 7, 85: 7, 68: 6, 35: 5, 110: 5, 91: 7, 114: 5, 97: 5, 31: 5, 13: 5, 67: 5, 38: 6, 26: 5, 124: 2, 98: 2, 54: 4, 127: 5, 8: 4, 96: 5, 64: 4, 30: 6, 61: 7, 55: 5, 27: 6, 15: 5, 52: 4, 129: 5, 115: 5, 84: 5, 76: 8, 87: 5, 102: 5, 113: 7, 99: 4, 36: 5, 24: 4, 53: 3, 72: 6} {191: 1, 263: 1, 1: 11, 4: 4, 9: 7, 10: 5, 15: 5, 24: 4, 25: 7, 26: 7, 27: 5, 39: 7, 43: 5, 49: 8, 50: 7, 58: 7, 59: 4, 64: 5, 69: 6, 81: 8, 82: 6, 86: 5, 96: 6, 97: 5, 100: 9, 108: 5, 109: 2, 110: 2, 111: 4, 114: 5, 115: 6, 116: 5, 118: 8, 119: 7, 120: 5, 121: 6, 122: 6, 123: 5, 124: 6, 128: 6, 129: 6, 130: 7, 132: 6, 136: 4, 145: 6, 147: 6, 151: 6, 152: 6, 154: 5, 156: 4, 161: 5, 162: 5, 165: 5, 168: 4, 169: 5, 172: 5, 180: 6, 184: 7, 187: 7, 188: 6, 194: 6, 202: 7, 203: 8, 206: 2, 207: 3, 215: 4, 217: 5, 218: 10, 220: 4, 221: 4, 222: 7, 224: 5, 227: 7, 229: 5, 234: 5, 235: 4, 241: 4, 242: 4, 243: 6, 244: 6, 245: 6, 248: 6, 250: 6, 258: 13, 264: 5, 267: 6, 270: 5, 272: 5, 273: 7, 287: 5, 289: 5, 291: 7, 299: 7, 300: 5, 304: 5, 309: 5, 314: 4, 315: 5, 320: 6, 323: 6, 327: 6, 328: 5, 329: 4, 330: 12, 334: 4, 335: 5, 341: 7, 342: 8, 347: 7, 348: 7, 350: 9, 351: 7, 352: 5, 353: 5, 354: 4, 358: 6, 365: 5, 366: 4, 369: 3, 371: 9, 372: 7, 376: 4, 384: 7, 385: 6, 386: 5, 387: 5, 392: 5, 393: 6, 396: 8, 397: 9, 398: 8, 402: 5} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 130 "If the PE decides to forward the packet, the packet MUST be forwarded according to the TSN Stream specific configuration to connected CE(s) (in case of local bridging) and/or to the DetNet Service Proxy (in case of forwarding to remote CE(s)). If there are no TSN Stream specific forwarding configurations the PE MUST flood the packet to other locally attached CE(s) and to the DetNet Service Proxy. If the administrative policy on the PE does not allow flooding the PE MUST drop the packet." "Comments resolved : Routing Directorate I approved these . The Changes looked good to me . I opened a small pull request to fix commas ." 7fe7425604ef66b60a158a23aecf46a764d6a9b3 7fe7425604ef66b60a158a23aecf46a764d6a9b3 draft-ietf-detnet-tsn-vpn-over-mpls ab12071fc42e8540b5e57d7bcaff527c577148cf803114aa9627e1a77e39c093 ['ab12071fc42e8540b5e57d7bcaff527c577148cf803114aa9627e1a77e39c093', '8150f930a0d0b4ecb9a9a0e68adda4846f4092ea2a55c7de339962c1bb9d5ed8'] B "if the pe decides to forward the packet, the packet must be forwarded according to the tsn stream specific configuration to connected ce(s) (in case of local bridging) and/or to the detnet service proxy (in case of forwarding to remote ce(s)). if there are no tsn stream specific forwarding configurations the pe must flood the packet to other locally attached ce(s) and to the detnet service proxy. if the administrative policy on the pe does not allow flooding the pe must drop the packet." {79: 1, 131: 1, 6: 4, 90: 5, 51: 5, 130: 4, 62: 7, 85: 7, 68: 6, 35: 5, 110: 5, 91: 7, 114: 5, 97: 5, 31: 5, 13: 5, 67: 5, 38: 6, 26: 5, 124: 2, 98: 2, 54: 4, 127: 5, 8: 4, 96: 5, 64: 4, 30: 6, 61: 7, 55: 5, 27: 6, 15: 5, 52: 4, 129: 5, 115: 5, 84: 5, 76: 8, 87: 5, 102: 5, 113: 7, 99: 4, 36: 5, 24: 4, 53: 3, 72: 6} {191: 1, 263: 1, 1: 11, 4: 4, 9: 7, 10: 5, 15: 5, 24: 4, 25: 7, 26: 7, 27: 5, 39: 7, 43: 5, 49: 8, 50: 7, 58: 7, 59: 4, 64: 5, 69: 6, 81: 8, 82: 6, 86: 5, 96: 6, 97: 5, 100: 9, 108: 5, 109: 2, 110: 2, 111: 4, 114: 5, 115: 6, 116: 5, 118: 8, 119: 7, 120: 5, 121: 6, 122: 6, 123: 5, 124: 6, 128: 6, 129: 6, 130: 7, 132: 6, 136: 4, 145: 6, 147: 6, 151: 6, 152: 6, 154: 5, 156: 4, 161: 5, 162: 5, 165: 5, 168: 4, 169: 5, 172: 5, 180: 6, 184: 7, 187: 7, 188: 6, 194: 6, 202: 7, 203: 8, 206: 2, 207: 3, 215: 4, 217: 5, 218: 10, 220: 4, 221: 4, 222: 7, 224: 5, 227: 7, 229: 5, 234: 5, 235: 4, 241: 4, 242: 4, 243: 6, 244: 6, 245: 6, 248: 6, 250: 6, 258: 13, 264: 5, 267: 6, 270: 5, 272: 5, 273: 7, 287: 5, 289: 5, 291: 7, 299: 7, 300: 5, 304: 5, 309: 5, 314: 4, 315: 5, 320: 6, 323: 6, 327: 6, 328: 5, 329: 4, 330: 12, 334: 4, 335: 5, 341: 7, 342: 8, 347: 7, 348: 7, 350: 9, 351: 7, 352: 5, 353: 5, 354: 4, 358: 6, 365: 5, 366: 4, 369: 3, 371: 9, 372: 7, 376: 4, 384: 7, 385: 6, 386: 5, 387: 5, 392: 5, 393: 6, 396: 8, 397: 9, 398: 8, 402: 5} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 130 "In the design of I-D.ietf-detnet-mpls an MPLS service label (the S-Label), similar to a pseudowire (PW) label RFC3985, is used to identify both the DetNet flow identity and the payload MPLS payload type. The DetNet sequence number is carried in the DetNet Control word (d-CW) which carries the Data/OAM discriminator as well. In I- D.ietf-detnet-mpls two sequence number sizes are supported: a 16 bit sequence number and a 28 bit sequence number." "Comments resolved : Routing Directorate I approved these . The Changes looked good to me . I opened a small pull request to fix commas ." 7fe7425604ef66b60a158a23aecf46a764d6a9b3 7fe7425604ef66b60a158a23aecf46a764d6a9b3 draft-ietf-detnet-tsn-vpn-over-mpls ec6878825845c61b3049ad5dd168197c84938e7f6d4fc938670da2528cf86317 ['55f3ee7b99637c149e54826055e417f51b7df9650a712f7f3b5443a7f5103b87', 'ec6878825845c61b3049ad5dd168197c84938e7f6d4fc938670da2528cf86317'] A "in the design of i-d.ietf-detnet-mpls an mpls service label (the s-label), similar to a pseudowire (pw) label rfc3985, is used to identify both the detnet flow identity and the payload mpls payload type. the detnet sequence number is carried in the detnet control word (d-cw) which carries the data/oam discriminator as well. in i- d.ietf-detnet-mpls two sequence number sizes are supported: a 16 bit sequence number and a 28 bit sequence number." {53: 1, 6: 2, 79: 2, 90: 3, 51: 3, 130: 2, 62: 5, 85: 5, 68: 4, 35: 3, 110: 3, 91: 5, 114: 3, 97: 3, 31: 3, 13: 3, 67: 3, 38: 4, 26: 3, 124: 3, 98: 2, 54: 2, 127: 3, 8: 2, 96: 3, 64: 2, 30: 4, 61: 5, 55: 3, 27: 4, 15: 3, 52: 2, 129: 3, 115: 3, 84: 3, 76: 6, 87: 3, 131: 5, 102: 3, 113: 5, 99: 2, 36: 3, 24: 2, 72: 4} {369: 1, 1: 9, 4: 2, 9: 5, 10: 3, 15: 3, 24: 2, 25: 5, 26: 5, 27: 3, 39: 5, 43: 3, 49: 6, 50: 5, 58: 5, 59: 2, 64: 3, 69: 4, 81: 6, 82: 4, 86: 3, 96: 4, 97: 3, 100: 7, 108: 3, 109: 4, 110: 4, 111: 2, 114: 3, 115: 4, 116: 3, 118: 6, 119: 5, 120: 3, 121: 4, 122: 4, 123: 3, 124: 4, 128: 4, 129: 4, 130: 5, 132: 4, 145: 4, 147: 4, 151: 4, 152: 4, 154: 3, 156: 2, 161: 3, 162: 3, 165: 3, 168: 4, 169: 3, 172: 3, 180: 4, 184: 5, 187: 5, 188: 4, 191: 3, 194: 4, 202: 5, 203: 6, 206: 2, 207: 3, 215: 2, 217: 3, 218: 8, 220: 2, 221: 2, 222: 5, 224: 3, 227: 5, 229: 3, 234: 5, 235: 2, 241: 2, 242: 2, 243: 4, 244: 4, 245: 4, 248: 4, 250: 4, 258: 11, 262: 4, 263: 5, 264: 3, 267: 4, 270: 3, 272: 3, 273: 5, 287: 3, 289: 3, 291: 5, 299: 5, 300: 3, 304: 3, 309: 3, 314: 2, 315: 3, 320: 4, 323: 4, 327: 4, 328: 3, 329: 2, 330: 10, 334: 2, 335: 3, 341: 5, 342: 6, 347: 5, 348: 5, 350: 7, 351: 5, 352: 3, 353: 3, 354: 2, 358: 4, 365: 3, 366: 2, 371: 7, 372: 5, 376: 2, 384: 5, 385: 4, 386: 3, 387: 3, 392: 3, 393: 4, 396: 6, 397: 7, 398: 6, 402: 3} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 130 "In the design of RFC8964 an MPLS service label (the S-Label), similar to a pseudowire (PW) label RFC3985, is used to identify both the DetNet flow identity and the payload MPLS payload type. The DetNet sequence number is carried in the DetNet Control word (d-CW) which carries the Data/OAM discriminator as well. In RFC8964 two sequence number sizes are supported: a 16 bit sequence number and a 28 bit sequence number." "Comments resolved : Routing Directorate I approved these . The Changes looked good to me . I opened a small pull request to fix commas ." 7fe7425604ef66b60a158a23aecf46a764d6a9b3 7fe7425604ef66b60a158a23aecf46a764d6a9b3 draft-ietf-detnet-tsn-vpn-over-mpls 55f3ee7b99637c149e54826055e417f51b7df9650a712f7f3b5443a7f5103b87 ['55f3ee7b99637c149e54826055e417f51b7df9650a712f7f3b5443a7f5103b87', 'ec6878825845c61b3049ad5dd168197c84938e7f6d4fc938670da2528cf86317'] B "in the design of rfc8964 an mpls service label (the s-label), similar to a pseudowire (pw) label rfc3985, is used to identify both the detnet flow identity and the payload mpls payload type. the detnet sequence number is carried in the detnet control word (d-cw) which carries the data/oam discriminator as well. in rfc8964 two sequence number sizes are supported: a 16 bit sequence number and a 28 bit sequence number." {53: 1, 6: 2, 79: 2, 90: 3, 51: 3, 130: 2, 62: 5, 85: 5, 68: 4, 35: 3, 110: 3, 91: 5, 114: 3, 97: 3, 31: 3, 13: 3, 67: 3, 38: 4, 26: 3, 124: 3, 98: 2, 54: 2, 127: 3, 8: 2, 96: 3, 64: 2, 30: 4, 61: 5, 55: 3, 27: 4, 15: 3, 52: 2, 129: 3, 115: 3, 84: 3, 76: 6, 87: 3, 131: 5, 102: 3, 113: 5, 99: 2, 36: 3, 24: 2, 72: 4} {369: 1, 1: 9, 4: 2, 9: 5, 10: 3, 15: 3, 24: 2, 25: 5, 26: 5, 27: 3, 39: 5, 43: 3, 49: 6, 50: 5, 58: 5, 59: 2, 64: 3, 69: 4, 81: 6, 82: 4, 86: 3, 96: 4, 97: 3, 100: 7, 108: 3, 109: 4, 110: 4, 111: 2, 114: 3, 115: 4, 116: 3, 118: 6, 119: 5, 120: 3, 121: 4, 122: 4, 123: 3, 124: 4, 128: 4, 129: 4, 130: 5, 132: 4, 145: 4, 147: 4, 151: 4, 152: 4, 154: 3, 156: 2, 161: 3, 162: 3, 165: 3, 168: 4, 169: 3, 172: 3, 180: 4, 184: 5, 187: 5, 188: 4, 191: 3, 194: 4, 202: 5, 203: 6, 206: 2, 207: 3, 215: 2, 217: 3, 218: 8, 220: 2, 221: 2, 222: 5, 224: 3, 227: 5, 229: 3, 234: 5, 235: 2, 241: 2, 242: 2, 243: 4, 244: 4, 245: 4, 248: 4, 250: 4, 258: 11, 262: 4, 263: 5, 264: 3, 267: 4, 270: 3, 272: 3, 273: 5, 287: 3, 289: 3, 291: 5, 299: 5, 300: 3, 304: 3, 309: 3, 314: 2, 315: 3, 320: 4, 323: 4, 327: 4, 328: 3, 329: 2, 330: 10, 334: 2, 335: 3, 341: 5, 342: 6, 347: 5, 348: 5, 350: 7, 351: 5, 352: 3, 353: 3, 354: 2, 358: 4, 365: 3, 366: 2, 371: 7, 372: 5, 376: 2, 384: 5, 385: 4, 386: 3, 387: 3, 392: 3, 393: 4, 396: 6, 397: 7, 398: 6, 402: 3} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 130 "When a PE receives a packet from the Service Proxy function it MUST handle the packet as defined in I-D.ietf-detnet-mpls." "Comments resolved : Routing Directorate I approved these . The Changes looked good to me . I opened a small pull request to fix commas ." 7fe7425604ef66b60a158a23aecf46a764d6a9b3 7fe7425604ef66b60a158a23aecf46a764d6a9b3 draft-ietf-detnet-tsn-vpn-over-mpls 48ee4f00ec51885f8458a7bc1768580f6b6e466aad696766daccf33844e22f1f ['48ee4f00ec51885f8458a7bc1768580f6b6e466aad696766daccf33844e22f1f', 'a3c5499d5724a8b3cc5eb587612d841685407d85777237632647003cc5a84603'] A "when a pe receives a packet from the service proxy function it must handle the packet as defined in i-d.ietf-detnet-mpls." {127: 1, 6: 4, 79: 2, 90: 5, 51: 5, 130: 3, 62: 7, 85: 7, 68: 6, 35: 5, 110: 5, 91: 7, 114: 5, 97: 5, 31: 5, 13: 5, 67: 5, 38: 6, 26: 5, 124: 5, 98: 4, 54: 4, 8: 4, 96: 5, 64: 4, 30: 6, 61: 7, 55: 5, 27: 6, 15: 5, 52: 4, 129: 5, 115: 5, 84: 5, 76: 8, 87: 5, 131: 7, 102: 5, 113: 7, 99: 4, 36: 5, 24: 4, 53: 3, 72: 6} {114: 1, 1: 11, 4: 2, 9: 7, 10: 5, 15: 5, 24: 4, 25: 7, 26: 7, 27: 5, 39: 7, 43: 5, 49: 8, 50: 7, 58: 7, 59: 4, 64: 5, 69: 6, 81: 8, 82: 6, 86: 5, 96: 6, 97: 5, 100: 9, 108: 3, 109: 6, 110: 6, 111: 4, 116: 5, 118: 8, 119: 7, 120: 5, 121: 6, 122: 6, 123: 5, 124: 6, 128: 6, 129: 6, 130: 7, 132: 6, 136: 4, 145: 6, 147: 6, 151: 6, 152: 6, 154: 5, 156: 4, 161: 5, 162: 5, 165: 5, 168: 6, 169: 5, 172: 5, 180: 6, 184: 7, 187: 7, 188: 6, 191: 5, 194: 6, 202: 7, 203: 8, 206: 4, 207: 5, 215: 4, 217: 5, 218: 10, 220: 4, 221: 4, 222: 7, 224: 5, 227: 7, 229: 5, 234: 7, 235: 4, 241: 4, 242: 4, 243: 6, 244: 6, 245: 6, 248: 6, 250: 6, 258: 13, 262: 6, 263: 7, 264: 5, 267: 6, 270: 5, 272: 5, 273: 7, 287: 5, 289: 5, 291: 7, 299: 7, 300: 5, 304: 5, 309: 5, 314: 4, 315: 5, 320: 6, 323: 6, 327: 6, 328: 5, 329: 4, 330: 12, 334: 4, 335: 5, 341: 7, 342: 8, 347: 7, 348: 7, 350: 9, 351: 7, 352: 5, 353: 5, 354: 4, 358: 6, 365: 5, 366: 4, 369: 3, 371: 9, 372: 7, 376: 4, 384: 7, 385: 6, 386: 5, 387: 5, 392: 5, 393: 6, 396: 8, 397: 9, 398: 8, 402: 5} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 130 "When a PE receives a packet from the Service Proxy function it MUST handle the packet as defined in RFC8964." "Comments resolved : Routing Directorate I approved these . The Changes looked good to me . I opened a small pull request to fix commas ." 7fe7425604ef66b60a158a23aecf46a764d6a9b3 7fe7425604ef66b60a158a23aecf46a764d6a9b3 draft-ietf-detnet-tsn-vpn-over-mpls a3c5499d5724a8b3cc5eb587612d841685407d85777237632647003cc5a84603 ['48ee4f00ec51885f8458a7bc1768580f6b6e466aad696766daccf33844e22f1f', 'a3c5499d5724a8b3cc5eb587612d841685407d85777237632647003cc5a84603'] B "when a pe receives a packet from the service proxy function it must handle the packet as defined in rfc8964." {127: 1, 6: 4, 79: 2, 90: 5, 51: 5, 130: 3, 62: 7, 85: 7, 68: 6, 35: 5, 110: 5, 91: 7, 114: 5, 97: 5, 31: 5, 13: 5, 67: 5, 38: 6, 26: 5, 124: 5, 98: 4, 54: 4, 8: 4, 96: 5, 64: 4, 30: 6, 61: 7, 55: 5, 27: 6, 15: 5, 52: 4, 129: 5, 115: 5, 84: 5, 76: 8, 87: 5, 131: 7, 102: 5, 113: 7, 99: 4, 36: 5, 24: 4, 53: 3, 72: 6} {114: 1, 1: 11, 4: 2, 9: 7, 10: 5, 15: 5, 24: 4, 25: 7, 26: 7, 27: 5, 39: 7, 43: 5, 49: 8, 50: 7, 58: 7, 59: 4, 64: 5, 69: 6, 81: 8, 82: 6, 86: 5, 96: 6, 97: 5, 100: 9, 108: 3, 109: 6, 110: 6, 111: 4, 116: 5, 118: 8, 119: 7, 120: 5, 121: 6, 122: 6, 123: 5, 124: 6, 128: 6, 129: 6, 130: 7, 132: 6, 136: 4, 145: 6, 147: 6, 151: 6, 152: 6, 154: 5, 156: 4, 161: 5, 162: 5, 165: 5, 168: 6, 169: 5, 172: 5, 180: 6, 184: 7, 187: 7, 188: 6, 191: 5, 194: 6, 202: 7, 203: 8, 206: 4, 207: 5, 215: 4, 217: 5, 218: 10, 220: 4, 221: 4, 222: 7, 224: 5, 227: 7, 229: 5, 234: 7, 235: 4, 241: 4, 242: 4, 243: 6, 244: 6, 245: 6, 248: 6, 250: 6, 258: 13, 262: 6, 263: 7, 264: 5, 267: 6, 270: 5, 272: 5, 273: 7, 287: 5, 289: 5, 291: 7, 299: 7, 300: 5, 304: 5, 309: 5, 314: 4, 315: 5, 320: 6, 323: 6, 327: 6, 328: 5, 329: 4, 330: 12, 334: 4, 335: 5, 341: 7, 342: 8, 347: 7, 348: 7, 350: 9, 351: 7, 352: 5, 353: 5, 354: 4, 358: 6, 365: 5, 366: 4, 369: 3, 371: 9, 372: 7, 376: 4, 384: 7, 385: 6, 386: 5, 387: 5, 392: 5, 393: 6, 396: 8, 397: 9, 398: 8, 402: 5} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 130 "For further details on DetNet Service and Forwarding sub-layers see I-D.ietf-detnet-mpls." "Comments resolved : Routing Directorate I approved these . The Changes looked good to me . I opened a small pull request to fix commas ." 7fe7425604ef66b60a158a23aecf46a764d6a9b3 7fe7425604ef66b60a158a23aecf46a764d6a9b3 draft-ietf-detnet-tsn-vpn-over-mpls bb5d135a9e9a30c3058065510c25bd93854d5e9e3be536ad8fe71239a64ab26e ['46be311939ef958541b382559f1d9617db902384fe090f44f540aab5bbd4ad4b', 'bb5d135a9e9a30c3058065510c25bd93854d5e9e3be536ad8fe71239a64ab26e'] A "for further details on detnet service and forwarding sub-layers see i-d.ietf-detnet-mpls." {79: 1, 6: 3, 90: 4, 51: 4, 130: 3, 62: 6, 85: 6, 68: 5, 35: 4, 110: 4, 91: 6, 114: 4, 97: 4, 31: 4, 13: 4, 67: 4, 38: 5, 26: 4, 124: 4, 98: 3, 54: 3, 127: 2, 8: 3, 96: 4, 64: 3, 30: 5, 61: 6, 55: 4, 27: 5, 15: 4, 52: 3, 129: 4, 115: 4, 84: 4, 76: 7, 87: 4, 131: 6, 102: 4, 113: 6, 99: 3, 36: 4, 24: 3, 53: 2, 72: 5} {4: 1, 1: 10, 9: 6, 10: 4, 15: 4, 24: 3, 25: 6, 26: 6, 27: 4, 39: 6, 43: 4, 49: 7, 50: 6, 58: 6, 59: 3, 64: 4, 69: 5, 81: 7, 82: 5, 86: 4, 96: 5, 97: 4, 100: 8, 109: 5, 110: 5, 111: 3, 114: 2, 115: 3, 116: 4, 118: 7, 119: 6, 120: 4, 121: 5, 122: 5, 123: 4, 124: 5, 128: 5, 129: 5, 130: 6, 132: 5, 136: 3, 145: 5, 147: 5, 151: 5, 152: 5, 154: 4, 156: 3, 161: 4, 162: 4, 165: 4, 168: 5, 169: 4, 172: 4, 180: 5, 184: 6, 187: 6, 188: 5, 191: 4, 194: 5, 202: 6, 203: 7, 206: 3, 207: 4, 215: 3, 217: 4, 218: 9, 220: 3, 221: 3, 222: 6, 224: 4, 227: 6, 229: 4, 234: 6, 235: 3, 241: 3, 242: 3, 243: 5, 244: 5, 245: 5, 248: 5, 250: 5, 258: 12, 262: 5, 263: 6, 264: 4, 267: 5, 270: 4, 272: 4, 273: 6, 287: 4, 289: 4, 291: 6, 299: 6, 300: 4, 304: 4, 309: 4, 314: 3, 315: 4, 320: 5, 323: 5, 327: 5, 328: 4, 329: 3, 330: 11, 334: 3, 335: 4, 341: 6, 342: 7, 347: 6, 348: 6, 350: 8, 351: 6, 352: 4, 353: 4, 354: 3, 358: 5, 365: 4, 366: 3, 369: 2, 371: 8, 372: 6, 376: 3, 384: 6, 385: 5, 386: 4, 387: 4, 392: 4, 393: 5, 396: 7, 397: 8, 398: 7, 402: 4} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 130 "For further details on DetNet Service and Forwarding sub-layers see RFC8964." "Comments resolved : Routing Directorate I approved these . The Changes looked good to me . I opened a small pull request to fix commas ." 7fe7425604ef66b60a158a23aecf46a764d6a9b3 7fe7425604ef66b60a158a23aecf46a764d6a9b3 draft-ietf-detnet-tsn-vpn-over-mpls 46be311939ef958541b382559f1d9617db902384fe090f44f540aab5bbd4ad4b ['46be311939ef958541b382559f1d9617db902384fe090f44f540aab5bbd4ad4b', 'bb5d135a9e9a30c3058065510c25bd93854d5e9e3be536ad8fe71239a64ab26e'] B "for further details on detnet service and forwarding sub-layers see rfc8964." {79: 1, 6: 3, 90: 4, 51: 4, 130: 3, 62: 6, 85: 6, 68: 5, 35: 4, 110: 4, 91: 6, 114: 4, 97: 4, 31: 4, 13: 4, 67: 4, 38: 5, 26: 4, 124: 4, 98: 3, 54: 3, 127: 2, 8: 3, 96: 4, 64: 3, 30: 5, 61: 6, 55: 4, 27: 5, 15: 4, 52: 3, 129: 4, 115: 4, 84: 4, 76: 7, 87: 4, 131: 6, 102: 4, 113: 6, 99: 3, 36: 4, 24: 3, 53: 2, 72: 5} {4: 1, 1: 10, 9: 6, 10: 4, 15: 4, 24: 3, 25: 6, 26: 6, 27: 4, 39: 6, 43: 4, 49: 7, 50: 6, 58: 6, 59: 3, 64: 4, 69: 5, 81: 7, 82: 5, 86: 4, 96: 5, 97: 4, 100: 8, 109: 5, 110: 5, 111: 3, 114: 2, 115: 3, 116: 4, 118: 7, 119: 6, 120: 4, 121: 5, 122: 5, 123: 4, 124: 5, 128: 5, 129: 5, 130: 6, 132: 5, 136: 3, 145: 5, 147: 5, 151: 5, 152: 5, 154: 4, 156: 3, 161: 4, 162: 4, 165: 4, 168: 5, 169: 4, 172: 4, 180: 5, 184: 6, 187: 6, 188: 5, 191: 4, 194: 5, 202: 6, 203: 7, 206: 3, 207: 4, 215: 3, 217: 4, 218: 9, 220: 3, 221: 3, 222: 6, 224: 4, 227: 6, 229: 4, 234: 6, 235: 3, 241: 3, 242: 3, 243: 5, 244: 5, 245: 5, 248: 5, 250: 5, 258: 12, 262: 5, 263: 6, 264: 4, 267: 5, 270: 4, 272: 4, 273: 6, 287: 4, 289: 4, 291: 6, 299: 6, 300: 4, 304: 4, 309: 4, 314: 3, 315: 4, 320: 5, 323: 5, 327: 5, 328: 4, 329: 3, 330: 11, 334: 3, 335: 4, 341: 6, 342: 7, 347: 6, 348: 6, 350: 8, 351: 6, 352: 4, 353: 4, 354: 3, 358: 5, 365: 4, 366: 3, 369: 2, 371: 8, 372: 6, 376: 3, 384: 6, 385: 5, 386: 4, 387: 4, 392: 4, 393: 5, 396: 7, 397: 8, 398: 7, 402: 4} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 130 "DetNet MPLS data plane specific considerations are summarized and described in I-D.ietf-detnet-mpls including any application flow types. This document focuses on the scenario where TSN Streams are the application flows for DetNet and it is already covered by those DetNet MPLS data plane security considerations." "Comments resolved : Routing Directorate I approved these . The Changes looked good to me . I opened a small pull request to fix commas ." 7fe7425604ef66b60a158a23aecf46a764d6a9b3 7fe7425604ef66b60a158a23aecf46a764d6a9b3 draft-ietf-detnet-tsn-vpn-over-mpls 7abf825e7daf71e2cba4e28e337f5dd088374215bcb9c81b19e6b5fc20e4d109 ['7abf825e7daf71e2cba4e28e337f5dd088374215bcb9c81b19e6b5fc20e4d109', '5a6879b9c0382f59ce531633b93610e291ee24dfd4d8dfe71f5ed086218dac2d'] A "detnet mpls data plane specific considerations are summarized and described in i-d.ietf-detnet-mpls including any application flow types. this document focuses on the scenario where tsn streams are the application flows for detnet and it is already covered by those detnet mpls data plane security considerations." {98: 1, 6: 5, 79: 5, 90: 6, 51: 6, 130: 5, 62: 8, 85: 8, 68: 7, 35: 6, 110: 6, 91: 8, 114: 6, 97: 6, 31: 6, 13: 6, 67: 2, 38: 7, 26: 6, 124: 6, 54: 3, 127: 6, 8: 5, 96: 6, 64: 5, 30: 7, 61: 8, 55: 6, 27: 7, 15: 6, 52: 5, 129: 6, 115: 6, 84: 6, 76: 9, 87: 6, 131: 8, 102: 6, 113: 8, 99: 5, 36: 6, 24: 5, 53: 4, 72: 7} {188: 1, 1: 12, 4: 5, 9: 8, 10: 6, 15: 6, 24: 5, 25: 8, 26: 8, 27: 6, 39: 8, 43: 6, 49: 9, 50: 8, 58: 8, 59: 5, 64: 6, 69: 7, 81: 9, 82: 7, 86: 6, 96: 7, 97: 6, 100: 10, 108: 6, 109: 7, 110: 7, 111: 3, 114: 6, 115: 7, 116: 6, 118: 9, 119: 8, 120: 6, 121: 7, 122: 7, 123: 6, 124: 7, 128: 7, 129: 7, 130: 8, 132: 7, 136: 5, 145: 7, 147: 7, 151: 7, 152: 7, 154: 6, 156: 5, 161: 6, 162: 6, 165: 6, 168: 7, 169: 6, 172: 6, 180: 7, 184: 8, 191: 6, 194: 7, 202: 8, 203: 9, 206: 5, 207: 6, 215: 5, 217: 6, 218: 11, 220: 5, 221: 5, 222: 8, 224: 6, 227: 8, 229: 6, 234: 8, 235: 5, 241: 5, 242: 5, 243: 7, 244: 7, 245: 7, 248: 7, 250: 7, 258: 14, 262: 7, 263: 8, 264: 6, 267: 7, 270: 6, 272: 6, 273: 8, 287: 2, 289: 6, 291: 8, 299: 8, 300: 6, 304: 6, 309: 6, 314: 5, 315: 6, 320: 7, 323: 7, 327: 7, 328: 6, 329: 5, 330: 13, 334: 5, 335: 6, 341: 8, 342: 9, 347: 8, 348: 8, 350: 10, 351: 8, 352: 6, 353: 6, 354: 5, 358: 7, 365: 6, 366: 5, 369: 4, 371: 10, 372: 8, 376: 5, 384: 8, 385: 7, 386: 6, 387: 6, 392: 6, 393: 7, 396: 9, 397: 10, 398: 9, 402: 6} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 130 "DetNet MPLS data plane specific considerations are summarized and described in RFC8964 including any application flow types. This document focuses on the scenario where TSN Streams are the application flows for DetNet and it is already covered by those DetNet MPLS data plane security considerations." "Comments resolved : Routing Directorate I approved these . The Changes looked good to me . I opened a small pull request to fix commas ." 7fe7425604ef66b60a158a23aecf46a764d6a9b3 7fe7425604ef66b60a158a23aecf46a764d6a9b3 draft-ietf-detnet-tsn-vpn-over-mpls 5a6879b9c0382f59ce531633b93610e291ee24dfd4d8dfe71f5ed086218dac2d ['7abf825e7daf71e2cba4e28e337f5dd088374215bcb9c81b19e6b5fc20e4d109', '5a6879b9c0382f59ce531633b93610e291ee24dfd4d8dfe71f5ed086218dac2d'] B "detnet mpls data plane specific considerations are summarized and described in rfc8964 including any application flow types. this document focuses on the scenario where tsn streams are the application flows for detnet and it is already covered by those detnet mpls data plane security considerations." {98: 1, 6: 5, 79: 5, 90: 6, 51: 6, 130: 5, 62: 8, 85: 8, 68: 7, 35: 6, 110: 6, 91: 8, 114: 6, 97: 6, 31: 6, 13: 6, 67: 2, 38: 7, 26: 6, 124: 6, 54: 3, 127: 6, 8: 5, 96: 6, 64: 5, 30: 7, 61: 8, 55: 6, 27: 7, 15: 6, 52: 5, 129: 6, 115: 6, 84: 6, 76: 9, 87: 6, 131: 8, 102: 6, 113: 8, 99: 5, 36: 6, 24: 5, 53: 4, 72: 7} {188: 1, 1: 12, 4: 5, 9: 8, 10: 6, 15: 6, 24: 5, 25: 8, 26: 8, 27: 6, 39: 8, 43: 6, 49: 9, 50: 8, 58: 8, 59: 5, 64: 6, 69: 7, 81: 9, 82: 7, 86: 6, 96: 7, 97: 6, 100: 10, 108: 6, 109: 7, 110: 7, 111: 3, 114: 6, 115: 7, 116: 6, 118: 9, 119: 8, 120: 6, 121: 7, 122: 7, 123: 6, 124: 7, 128: 7, 129: 7, 130: 8, 132: 7, 136: 5, 145: 7, 147: 7, 151: 7, 152: 7, 154: 6, 156: 5, 161: 6, 162: 6, 165: 6, 168: 7, 169: 6, 172: 6, 180: 7, 184: 8, 191: 6, 194: 7, 202: 8, 203: 9, 206: 5, 207: 6, 215: 5, 217: 6, 218: 11, 220: 5, 221: 5, 222: 8, 224: 6, 227: 8, 229: 6, 234: 8, 235: 5, 241: 5, 242: 5, 243: 7, 244: 7, 245: 7, 248: 7, 250: 7, 258: 14, 262: 7, 263: 8, 264: 6, 267: 7, 270: 6, 272: 6, 273: 8, 287: 2, 289: 6, 291: 8, 299: 8, 300: 6, 304: 6, 309: 6, 314: 5, 315: 6, 320: 7, 323: 7, 327: 7, 328: 6, 329: 5, 330: 13, 334: 5, 335: 6, 341: 8, 342: 9, 347: 8, 348: 8, 350: 10, 351: 8, 352: 6, 353: 6, 354: 5, 358: 7, 365: 6, 366: 5, 369: 4, 371: 10, 372: 8, 376: 5, 384: 8, 385: 7, 386: 6, 387: 6, 392: 6, 393: 7, 396: 9, 397: 10, 398: 9, 402: 6} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 130 "This document uses the terminology and concepts established in the DetNet architecture RFC8655, and the reader is assumed to be familiar with that document and its terminology." "Comments resolved : Routing Directorate I approved these . The Changes looked good to me . I opened a small pull request to fix commas ." 7fe7425604ef66b60a158a23aecf46a764d6a9b3 7fe7425604ef66b60a158a23aecf46a764d6a9b3 draft-ietf-detnet-ip-over-tsn 282e50851af26440b586d2fc631b850514b6842d3964567acd88abe53c0d6dcd ['282e50851af26440b586d2fc631b850514b6842d3964567acd88abe53c0d6dcd', '3563745b6963815cca3fde21bc134a892975a2190106df79520737ee0449064e'] A "this document uses the terminology and concepts established in the detnet architecture rfc8655, and the reader is assumed to be familiar with that document and its terminology." {} {} {} 130 "This document uses the terminology and concepts established in the DetNet architecture RFC8655. TSN specific terms are defined in the TSN TG of IEEE 802.1 Working Group. The reader is assumed to be familiar with these documents and their terminology." "Comments resolved : Routing Directorate I approved these . The Changes looked good to me . I opened a small pull request to fix commas ." 7fe7425604ef66b60a158a23aecf46a764d6a9b3 7fe7425604ef66b60a158a23aecf46a764d6a9b3 draft-ietf-detnet-ip-over-tsn 3563745b6963815cca3fde21bc134a892975a2190106df79520737ee0449064e ['282e50851af26440b586d2fc631b850514b6842d3964567acd88abe53c0d6dcd', '3563745b6963815cca3fde21bc134a892975a2190106df79520737ee0449064e'] B "this document uses the terminology and concepts established in the detnet architecture rfc8655. tsn specific terms are defined in the tsn tg of ieee 802.1 working group. the reader is assumed to be familiar with these documents and their terminology." {} {} {} 130 "TSN capabilities of the TSN sub-network are made available for IP (DetNet) flows via the protocol interworking function desribed in Annex C.5 of IEEE8021CB. For example, applied on the TSN edge port it can convert an ingress unicast IP (DetNet) flow to use a specific Layer-2 multicast destination MAC address and a VLAN, in order to direct the packet through a specific path inside the bridged network. A similar interworking function pair at the other end of the TSN sub- network would restore the packet to its original Layer-2 destination MAC address and VLAN." "Comments resolved : Routing Directorate I approved these . The Changes looked good to me . I opened a small pull request to fix commas ." 7fe7425604ef66b60a158a23aecf46a764d6a9b3 7fe7425604ef66b60a158a23aecf46a764d6a9b3 draft-ietf-detnet-ip-over-tsn 4ce364c82139f8d4c118dcccd3634e6f7d075eb3d773d8014252133b22074ce0 ['4ce364c82139f8d4c118dcccd3634e6f7d075eb3d773d8014252133b22074ce0', '10eb636037ca26ce20c9f27756fcfc4886dde7193c47cd966771b3f2370cc068'] A "tsn capabilities of the tsn sub-network are made available for ip (detnet) flows via the protocol interworking function desribed in annex c.5 of ieee8021cb. for example, applied on the tsn edge port it can convert an ingress unicast ip (detnet) flow to use a specific layer-2 multicast destination mac address and a vlan, in order to direct the packet through a specific path inside the bridged network. a similar interworking function pair at the other end of the tsn sub- network would restore the packet to its original layer-2 destination mac address and vlan." {96: 1, 6: 4, 79: 4, 90: 4, 51: 2, 130: 3, 62: 3, 85: 4, 68: 6, 35: 5, 110: 4, 91: 6, 114: 4, 97: 2, 31: 5, 13: 3, 67: 4, 38: 5, 26: 4, 124: 3, 98: 4, 54: 4, 127: 5, 8: 4, 64: 4, 30: 4, 61: 6, 55: 5, 27: 5, 15: 4, 52: 2, 129: 5, 115: 4, 84: 4, 76: 8, 87: 4, 131: 7, 102: 4, 113: 6, 99: 4, 36: 4, 24: 3, 53: 3, 72: 5} {123: 1, 1: 11, 4: 4, 9: 7, 10: 5, 15: 3, 24: 4, 25: 3, 26: 4, 27: 3, 39: 7, 43: 5, 49: 7, 50: 6, 58: 6, 59: 4, 64: 3, 69: 6, 81: 4, 82: 2, 86: 4, 96: 5, 97: 4, 100: 5, 108: 5, 109: 6, 110: 6, 111: 4, 114: 5, 115: 6, 116: 2, 118: 6, 119: 5, 120: 5, 121: 6, 124: 6, 128: 5, 129: 4, 130: 6, 132: 6, 136: 4, 145: 6, 147: 5, 151: 5, 152: 5, 154: 5, 156: 2, 161: 5, 162: 5, 165: 5, 168: 6, 169: 4, 172: 4, 180: 5, 184: 7, 187: 7, 188: 6, 191: 5, 194: 6, 202: 7, 203: 8, 206: 4, 207: 5, 215: 4, 217: 5, 218: 10, 220: 4, 221: 4, 222: 7, 224: 5, 227: 3, 229: 4, 234: 7, 235: 4, 241: 4, 242: 4, 243: 6, 244: 5, 245: 6, 248: 5, 250: 4, 258: 13, 262: 6, 263: 7, 264: 5, 267: 6, 270: 3, 272: 4, 273: 7, 287: 5, 289: 4, 291: 6, 299: 3, 300: 3, 304: 3, 309: 5, 314: 4, 315: 4, 320: 4, 323: 6, 327: 6, 328: 5, 329: 4, 330: 12, 334: 4, 335: 2, 341: 3, 342: 4, 347: 3, 348: 3, 350: 9, 351: 6, 352: 4, 353: 4, 354: 3, 358: 6, 365: 4, 366: 4, 369: 3, 371: 5, 372: 6, 376: 4, 384: 6, 385: 5, 386: 5, 387: 3, 392: 5, 393: 6, 396: 4, 397: 9, 398: 8, 402: 4} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 130 "TSN capabilities of the TSN sub-network are made available for IP (DetNet) flows via the protocol interworking function described in Annex C.5 of IEEE8021CB. For example, applied on the TSN edge port it can convert an ingress unicast IP (DetNet) flow to use a specific Layer-2 multicast destination MAC address and a VLAN, in order to direct the packet through a specific path inside the bridged network. A similar interworking function pair at the other end of the TSN sub- network would restore the packet to its original Layer-2 destination MAC address and VLAN." "Comments resolved : Routing Directorate I approved these . The Changes looked good to me . I opened a small pull request to fix commas ." 7fe7425604ef66b60a158a23aecf46a764d6a9b3 7fe7425604ef66b60a158a23aecf46a764d6a9b3 draft-ietf-detnet-ip-over-tsn 10eb636037ca26ce20c9f27756fcfc4886dde7193c47cd966771b3f2370cc068 ['4ce364c82139f8d4c118dcccd3634e6f7d075eb3d773d8014252133b22074ce0', '10eb636037ca26ce20c9f27756fcfc4886dde7193c47cd966771b3f2370cc068'] B "tsn capabilities of the tsn sub-network are made available for ip (detnet) flows via the protocol interworking function described in annex c.5 of ieee8021cb. for example, applied on the tsn edge port it can convert an ingress unicast ip (detnet) flow to use a specific layer-2 multicast destination mac address and a vlan, in order to direct the packet through a specific path inside the bridged network. a similar interworking function pair at the other end of the tsn sub- network would restore the packet to its original layer-2 destination mac address and vlan." {96: 1, 6: 4, 79: 4, 90: 4, 51: 2, 130: 3, 62: 3, 85: 4, 68: 6, 35: 5, 110: 4, 91: 6, 114: 4, 97: 2, 31: 5, 13: 3, 67: 4, 38: 5, 26: 4, 124: 3, 98: 4, 54: 4, 127: 5, 8: 4, 64: 4, 30: 4, 61: 6, 55: 5, 27: 5, 15: 4, 52: 2, 129: 5, 115: 4, 84: 4, 76: 8, 87: 4, 131: 7, 102: 4, 113: 6, 99: 4, 36: 4, 24: 3, 53: 3, 72: 5} {123: 1, 1: 11, 4: 4, 9: 7, 10: 5, 15: 3, 24: 4, 25: 3, 26: 4, 27: 3, 39: 7, 43: 5, 49: 7, 50: 6, 58: 6, 59: 4, 64: 3, 69: 6, 81: 4, 82: 2, 86: 4, 96: 5, 97: 4, 100: 5, 108: 5, 109: 6, 110: 6, 111: 4, 114: 5, 115: 6, 116: 2, 118: 6, 119: 5, 120: 5, 121: 6, 124: 6, 128: 5, 129: 4, 130: 6, 132: 6, 136: 4, 145: 6, 147: 5, 151: 5, 152: 5, 154: 5, 156: 2, 161: 5, 162: 5, 165: 5, 168: 6, 169: 4, 172: 4, 180: 5, 184: 7, 187: 7, 188: 6, 191: 5, 194: 6, 202: 7, 203: 8, 206: 4, 207: 5, 215: 4, 217: 5, 218: 10, 220: 4, 221: 4, 222: 7, 224: 5, 227: 3, 229: 4, 234: 7, 235: 4, 241: 4, 242: 4, 243: 6, 244: 5, 245: 6, 248: 5, 250: 4, 258: 13, 262: 6, 263: 7, 264: 5, 267: 6, 270: 3, 272: 4, 273: 7, 287: 5, 289: 4, 291: 6, 299: 3, 300: 3, 304: 3, 309: 5, 314: 4, 315: 4, 320: 4, 323: 6, 327: 6, 328: 5, 329: 4, 330: 12, 334: 4, 335: 2, 341: 3, 342: 4, 347: 3, 348: 3, 350: 9, 351: 6, 352: 4, 353: 4, 354: 3, 358: 6, 365: 4, 366: 4, 369: 3, 371: 5, 372: 6, 376: 4, 384: 6, 385: 5, 386: 5, 387: 3, 392: 5, 393: 6, 396: 4, 397: 9, 398: 8, 402: 4} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 129 "This document specifies the MPLS Deterministic Networking data plane operation and encapsulation over an IP network. The approach is modeled on the operation of MPLS and over UDP/IP packet switched networks." Many small nits . a2261fd702b67e2a1ec0adbd72d37405c13452c8 a2261fd702b67e2a1ec0adbd72d37405c13452c8 draft-ietf-detnet-mpls-over-udp-ip 33554b9bc0f2b69c37913c3670f608d02603f8976f7d043fff518b56c3cd70bc ['33554b9bc0f2b69c37913c3670f608d02603f8976f7d043fff518b56c3cd70bc', '181b559505c06db26d08bb642411099e2395d57a75f8d4099058cabb9047f833'] A "this document specifies the mpls deterministic networking data plane operation and encapsulation over an ip network. the approach is modeled on the operation of mpls and over udp/ip packet switched networks." {38: 1} {71: 1} {70, 71} 129 "This document specifies the MPLS Deterministic Networking data plane operation and encapsulation over an IP network. The approach is based on the operation of MPLS-in-UDP technology." Many small nits . a2261fd702b67e2a1ec0adbd72d37405c13452c8 a2261fd702b67e2a1ec0adbd72d37405c13452c8 draft-ietf-detnet-mpls-over-udp-ip 181b559505c06db26d08bb642411099e2395d57a75f8d4099058cabb9047f833 ['33554b9bc0f2b69c37913c3670f608d02603f8976f7d043fff518b56c3cd70bc', '181b559505c06db26d08bb642411099e2395d57a75f8d4099058cabb9047f833'] B "this document specifies the mpls deterministic networking data plane operation and encapsulation over an ip network. the approach is based on the operation of mpls-in-udp technology." {38: 1} {71: 1} {70, 71} 129 A method for carrying queuing and forwarding indication. Many small nits . a2261fd702b67e2a1ec0adbd72d37405c13452c8 a2261fd702b67e2a1ec0adbd72d37405c13452c8 draft-ietf-detnet-mpls-over-udp-ip 6ab286c5c6814f3ce1ed2f2d478adf0a2f9976a5446998b122c1b9a108fca2e6 ['6ab286c5c6814f3ce1ed2f2d478adf0a2f9976a5446998b122c1b9a108fca2e6', '1b6fa0313ecb59c6261f4731c97486b80efab1af59359487a6075a5dfa315087'] A a method for carrying queuing and forwarding indication. {64: 1, 6: 3, 79: 3, 90: 4, 51: 4, 130: 3, 62: 6, 85: 6, 68: 5, 35: 4, 110: 4, 91: 6, 114: 4, 97: 4, 31: 4, 13: 4, 67: 4, 38: 5, 26: 4, 124: 4, 98: 3, 54: 3, 127: 4, 8: 3, 96: 4, 30: 5, 61: 6, 55: 4, 27: 5, 15: 4, 52: 3, 115: 4, 84: 4, 76: 7, 87: 4, 131: 6, 102: 4, 113: 6, 99: 3, 36: 4, 24: 3, 53: 2, 72: 5} {314: 1, 1: 10, 4: 3, 9: 6, 10: 4, 15: 4, 24: 3, 25: 6, 26: 6, 27: 4, 39: 6, 43: 4, 49: 7, 50: 6, 58: 6, 59: 3, 64: 4, 69: 5, 81: 7, 82: 5, 86: 4, 96: 5, 97: 4, 100: 8, 108: 4, 109: 5, 110: 5, 111: 3, 114: 4, 115: 5, 116: 4, 118: 7, 119: 6, 120: 4, 121: 5, 122: 5, 123: 4, 124: 5, 128: 5, 129: 5, 130: 6, 132: 5, 136: 3, 145: 5, 147: 5, 151: 5, 152: 5, 154: 4, 156: 3, 161: 4, 162: 4, 168: 5, 169: 4, 172: 4, 180: 5, 184: 6, 187: 6, 188: 5, 191: 4, 194: 5, 202: 6, 203: 7, 206: 3, 207: 4, 215: 3, 217: 4, 218: 9, 220: 3, 221: 3, 222: 6, 224: 4, 227: 6, 229: 4, 234: 6, 235: 3, 241: 3, 242: 3, 243: 5, 244: 5, 245: 5, 248: 5, 250: 5, 258: 12, 262: 5, 263: 6, 264: 4, 267: 5, 270: 4, 272: 4, 273: 6, 287: 4, 289: 4, 291: 6, 299: 6, 300: 4, 304: 4, 309: 4, 315: 4, 320: 5, 323: 5, 327: 5, 328: 4, 329: 3, 330: 11, 334: 3, 335: 4, 341: 6, 342: 7, 347: 6, 348: 6, 350: 8, 351: 6, 352: 4, 353: 4, 354: 3, 358: 5, 365: 4, 366: 3, 369: 2, 371: 8, 372: 6, 376: 3, 384: 6, 385: 5, 386: 4, 387: 4, 392: 4, 393: 5, 396: 7, 397: 8, 398: 7, 402: 4} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 129 A method for carrying queueing and forwarding indication. Many small nits . a2261fd702b67e2a1ec0adbd72d37405c13452c8 a2261fd702b67e2a1ec0adbd72d37405c13452c8 draft-ietf-detnet-mpls-over-udp-ip 1b6fa0313ecb59c6261f4731c97486b80efab1af59359487a6075a5dfa315087 ['6ab286c5c6814f3ce1ed2f2d478adf0a2f9976a5446998b122c1b9a108fca2e6', '1b6fa0313ecb59c6261f4731c97486b80efab1af59359487a6075a5dfa315087'] B a method for carrying queueing and forwarding indication. {64: 1, 6: 3, 79: 3, 90: 4, 51: 4, 130: 3, 62: 6, 85: 6, 68: 5, 35: 4, 110: 4, 91: 6, 114: 4, 97: 4, 31: 4, 13: 4, 67: 4, 38: 5, 26: 4, 124: 4, 98: 3, 54: 3, 127: 4, 8: 3, 96: 4, 30: 5, 61: 6, 55: 4, 27: 5, 15: 4, 52: 3, 115: 4, 84: 4, 76: 7, 87: 4, 131: 6, 102: 4, 113: 6, 99: 3, 36: 4, 24: 3, 53: 2, 72: 5} {314: 1, 1: 10, 4: 3, 9: 6, 10: 4, 15: 4, 24: 3, 25: 6, 26: 6, 27: 4, 39: 6, 43: 4, 49: 7, 50: 6, 58: 6, 59: 3, 64: 4, 69: 5, 81: 7, 82: 5, 86: 4, 96: 5, 97: 4, 100: 8, 108: 4, 109: 5, 110: 5, 111: 3, 114: 4, 115: 5, 116: 4, 118: 7, 119: 6, 120: 4, 121: 5, 122: 5, 123: 4, 124: 5, 128: 5, 129: 5, 130: 6, 132: 5, 136: 3, 145: 5, 147: 5, 151: 5, 152: 5, 154: 4, 156: 3, 161: 4, 162: 4, 168: 5, 169: 4, 172: 4, 180: 5, 184: 6, 187: 6, 188: 5, 191: 4, 194: 5, 202: 6, 203: 7, 206: 3, 207: 4, 215: 3, 217: 4, 218: 9, 220: 3, 221: 3, 222: 6, 224: 4, 227: 6, 229: 4, 234: 6, 235: 3, 241: 3, 242: 3, 243: 5, 244: 5, 245: 5, 248: 5, 250: 5, 258: 12, 262: 5, 263: 6, 264: 4, 267: 5, 270: 4, 272: 4, 273: 6, 287: 4, 289: 4, 291: 6, 299: 6, 300: 4, 304: 4, 309: 4, 315: 4, 320: 5, 323: 5, 327: 5, 328: 4, 329: 3, 330: 11, 334: 3, 335: 4, 341: 6, 342: 7, 347: 6, 348: 6, 350: 8, 351: 6, 352: 4, 353: 4, 354: 3, 358: 5, 365: 4, 366: 3, 369: 2, 371: 8, 372: 6, 376: 3, 384: 6, 385: 5, 386: 4, 387: 4, 392: 4, 393: 5, 396: 7, 397: 8, 398: 7, 402: 4} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 129 "Note that this encapsulation works equally well with IPv4, IPv6, and IPv6-based Segment Routing I-D.ietf-6man-segment-routing-header." Many small nits . a2261fd702b67e2a1ec0adbd72d37405c13452c8 a2261fd702b67e2a1ec0adbd72d37405c13452c8 draft-ietf-detnet-mpls-over-udp-ip f9fc192261364373cbe4483f9b2eda080f8f30590e18f2f559dc4dda7efc34a6 ['f9fc192261364373cbe4483f9b2eda080f8f30590e18f2f559dc4dda7efc34a6', 'bbef49542478dbcec9efdad77b363312a145f96160ff4d83623980042e2c230d'] A "note that this encapsulation works equally well with ipv4, ipv6, and ipv6-based segment routing i-d.ietf-6man-segment-routing-header." {} {} {} 129 "Note that this encapsulation works equally well with IPv4, IPv6, and IPv6-based Segment Routing RFC8754." Many small nits . a2261fd702b67e2a1ec0adbd72d37405c13452c8 a2261fd702b67e2a1ec0adbd72d37405c13452c8 draft-ietf-detnet-mpls-over-udp-ip bbef49542478dbcec9efdad77b363312a145f96160ff4d83623980042e2c230d ['f9fc192261364373cbe4483f9b2eda080f8f30590e18f2f559dc4dda7efc34a6', 'bbef49542478dbcec9efdad77b363312a145f96160ff4d83623980042e2c230d'] B "note that this encapsulation works equally well with ipv4, ipv6, and ipv6-based segment routing rfc8754." {} {} {} 129 "To support outgoing DetNet MPLS over UDP encapsulation, an implementation MUST support the provisioning of UDP and IP header information in addition or in place of F-Label(s). Note, when PRF is performed at the MPLS service sub-layer, there will be multiple member flows, and each member flow will require the provisioning of their own UDP and IP header information. The headers for each outgoing packet MUST be formatted according to the configuration information and as defined in RFC7510, and the UDP Source Port value MUST be set to uniquely identify the DetNet flow. The packet MUST then be handled as a DetNet IP packet, per I-D.ietf-detnet-ip. This includes QoS related traffic treatment." Many small nits . a2261fd702b67e2a1ec0adbd72d37405c13452c8 a2261fd702b67e2a1ec0adbd72d37405c13452c8 draft-ietf-detnet-mpls-over-udp-ip 4cbf6ea8a773c20409dd04b52b1206e56006cc54e1ea477456746123ae0c1bb3 ['4cbf6ea8a773c20409dd04b52b1206e56006cc54e1ea477456746123ae0c1bb3', '6f60b4515dedc8692f75e3e0b703b8e4d09f92bcaa0d329921e020cdb197ef3f'] A "to support outgoing detnet mpls over udp encapsulation, an implementation must support the provisioning of udp and ip header information in addition or in place of f-label(s). note, when prf is performed at the mpls service sub-layer, there will be multiple member flows, and each member flow will require the provisioning of their own udp and ip header information. the headers for each outgoing packet must be formatted according to the configuration information and as defined in rfc7510, and the udp source port value must be set to uniquely identify the detnet flow. the packet must then be handled as a detnet ip packet, per i-d.ietf-detnet-ip. this includes qos related traffic treatment." {} {} {} 129 "To support outgoing DetNet MPLS over UDP encapsulation, an implementation MUST support the provisioning of UDP and IP header information in addition to or in place of F-Label(s). Note, when PRF is performed at the MPLS service sub-layer, there will be multiple member flows, and each member flow will require the provisioning of their own UDP and IP header information. The headers for each outgoing packet MUST be formatted according to the configuration information and as defined in RFC7510, and the UDP Source Port value MUST be set to uniquely identify the DetNet flow. The packet MUST then be handled as a DetNet IP packet, per I-D.ietf-detnet-ip. This includes QoS related traffic treatment." Many small nits . a2261fd702b67e2a1ec0adbd72d37405c13452c8 a2261fd702b67e2a1ec0adbd72d37405c13452c8 draft-ietf-detnet-mpls-over-udp-ip 6f60b4515dedc8692f75e3e0b703b8e4d09f92bcaa0d329921e020cdb197ef3f ['4cbf6ea8a773c20409dd04b52b1206e56006cc54e1ea477456746123ae0c1bb3', '6f60b4515dedc8692f75e3e0b703b8e4d09f92bcaa0d329921e020cdb197ef3f'] B "to support outgoing detnet mpls over udp encapsulation, an implementation must support the provisioning of udp and ip header information in addition to or in place of f-label(s). note, when prf is performed at the mpls service sub-layer, there will be multiple member flows, and each member flow will require the provisioning of their own udp and ip header information. the headers for each outgoing packet must be formatted according to the configuration information and as defined in rfc7510, and the udp source port value must be set to uniquely identify the detnet flow. the packet must then be handled as a detnet ip packet, per i-d.ietf-detnet-ip. this includes qos related traffic treatment." {} {} {} 129 "Label information (A-labels, S-labels and F-labels) to be mapped to UDP/IP flow. Note that for example, a single S-Label can map to multiple sets of UDP/IP information when PREOF is used." Many small nits . a2261fd702b67e2a1ec0adbd72d37405c13452c8 a2261fd702b67e2a1ec0adbd72d37405c13452c8 draft-ietf-detnet-mpls-over-udp-ip 226c2778cb4b1ee9c69cb248b48f3f8a5944796767817307ba3b2c5b3d09426b ['226c2778cb4b1ee9c69cb248b48f3f8a5944796767817307ba3b2c5b3d09426b', 'bb667ffb25e85cde2a0e0f5a2a571caae902bae1b9c986afd457945a45d33139'] A "label information (a-labels, s-labels and f-labels) to be mapped to udp/ip flow. note that for example, a single s-label can map to multiple sets of udp/ip information when preof is used." {71: 1, 60: 4, 56: 3, 102: 3, 64: 2, 38: 2, 62: 4, 33: 3, 26: 3, 32: 2, 83: 4, 113: 2, 126: 2, 112: 2, 85: 4} {377: 1, 260: 4, 261: 3, 274: 3, 339: 3, 212: 2, 343: 2, 283: 4, 286: 4, 31: 3, 32: 3, 33: 2, 163: 4, 228: 2, 357: 2, 166: 2, 231: 2, 298: 2, 363: 4} {260, 261, 274, 283, 286, 31, 32, 33, 163, 166, 298, 46, 339, 212, 343, 228, 357, 231, 363, 377} 129 "Label information (A-labels, S-labels and F-labels) to be mapped to UDP/IP flows. Note that for example, a single S-Label can map to multiple sets of UDP/IP information when PREOF is used." Many small nits . a2261fd702b67e2a1ec0adbd72d37405c13452c8 a2261fd702b67e2a1ec0adbd72d37405c13452c8 draft-ietf-detnet-mpls-over-udp-ip bb667ffb25e85cde2a0e0f5a2a571caae902bae1b9c986afd457945a45d33139 ['226c2778cb4b1ee9c69cb248b48f3f8a5944796767817307ba3b2c5b3d09426b', 'bb667ffb25e85cde2a0e0f5a2a571caae902bae1b9c986afd457945a45d33139'] B "label information (a-labels, s-labels and f-labels) to be mapped to udp/ip flows. note that for example, a single s-label can map to multiple sets of udp/ip information when preof is used." {71: 1, 60: 4, 56: 3, 102: 3, 64: 2, 38: 2, 62: 4, 33: 3, 26: 3, 32: 2, 83: 4, 113: 2, 126: 2, 112: 2, 85: 4} {377: 1, 260: 4, 261: 3, 274: 3, 339: 3, 212: 2, 343: 2, 283: 4, 286: 4, 31: 3, 32: 3, 33: 2, 163: 4, 228: 2, 357: 2, 166: 2, 231: 2, 298: 2, 363: 4} {260, 261, 274, 283, 286, 31, 32, 33, 163, 166, 298, 46, 339, 212, 343, 228, 357, 231, 363, 377} 129 "The solution defined in this document reuses mechanisms specified in other documents, and the security considerations in those documents apply equally to this document. Notably RFC7510, as this document is primarily an application of MPLS-in-UDP. Additionally, the security considerations of DetNet in general are discussed in RFC8655 and I- D.ietf-detnet-security. Finally,MPLS and IP specific security considerations are described in I-D.ietf-detnet-mpls and I-D.ietf- detnet-ip. This draft does not have additional security considerations." Many small nits . a2261fd702b67e2a1ec0adbd72d37405c13452c8 a2261fd702b67e2a1ec0adbd72d37405c13452c8 draft-ietf-detnet-mpls-over-udp-ip 8f46de95fb292bd4c98da38a266d026309543639781e5d45534fb00aef687817 ['e7a8621ae68f107a7bd4df1cb2d0fb1e85318a1ab3f77f7cca551a43b6e53847', '8f46de95fb292bd4c98da38a266d026309543639781e5d45534fb00aef687817'] A "the solution defined in this document reuses mechanisms specified in other documents, and the security considerations in those documents apply equally to this document. notably rfc7510, as this document is primarily an application of mpls-in-udp. additionally, the security considerations of detnet in general are discussed in rfc8655 and i- d.ietf-detnet-security. finally,mpls and ip specific security considerations are described in i-d.ietf-detnet-mpls and i-d.ietf- detnet-ip. this draft does not have additional security considerations." {} {} {} 129 "The solution defined in this document reuses mechanisms specified in other documents, and the security considerations in those documents apply equally to this document. Of particular note is RFC7510, as this document is primarily an application of MPLS-in-UDP. Additionally, the security considerations of DetNet in general are discussed in RFC8655 and I-D.ietf-detnet-security. Finally, MPLS and IP specific security considerations are described in I-D.ietf-detnet- mpls and I-D.ietf-detnet-ip. This draft does not have additional security considerations." Many small nits . a2261fd702b67e2a1ec0adbd72d37405c13452c8 a2261fd702b67e2a1ec0adbd72d37405c13452c8 draft-ietf-detnet-mpls-over-udp-ip e7a8621ae68f107a7bd4df1cb2d0fb1e85318a1ab3f77f7cca551a43b6e53847 ['e7a8621ae68f107a7bd4df1cb2d0fb1e85318a1ab3f77f7cca551a43b6e53847', '8f46de95fb292bd4c98da38a266d026309543639781e5d45534fb00aef687817'] B "the solution defined in this document reuses mechanisms specified in other documents, and the security considerations in those documents apply equally to this document. of particular note is rfc7510, as this document is primarily an application of mpls-in-udp. additionally, the security considerations of detnet in general are discussed in rfc8655 and i-d.ietf-detnet-security. finally, mpls and ip specific security considerations are described in i-d.ietf-detnet- mpls and i-d.ietf-detnet-ip. this draft does not have additional security considerations." {} {} {} 127 "This document uses the terminology and concepts established in the DetNet architecture RFC8655 and I-D.ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework, and I-D.ietf-detnet-mpls. The reader is assumed to be familiar with these documents and their terminology." ip - over - tsn ( nits ) mpls - over - tsn ( nits ) tsn - vpn - over - mpls ( nits , ch5.2 , ch5.3 ) 13efc7c7be88a258baaff1e9b6bde4159f1db062 13efc7c7be88a258baaff1e9b6bde4159f1db062 draft-ietf-detnet-tsn-vpn-over-mpls b4be4bc772f37db441ba242ca8ca530a4ce79dd949586ca4ffb864fe93265792 ['7e104acddc07f8fbdbdb190e11f543a072b5d88a5a57f61edf7790fd16902d4f', 'b4be4bc772f37db441ba242ca8ca530a4ce79dd949586ca4ffb864fe93265792'] A "this document uses the terminology and concepts established in the detnet architecture rfc8655 and i-d.ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework, and i-d.ietf-detnet-mpls. the reader is assumed to be familiar with these documents and their terminology." {130: 1, 67: 1, 79: 4, 51: 4, 112: 5, 55: 5, 64: 3, 62: 5, 37: 4, 38: 4, 69: 4, 68: 4, 33: 3, 25: 4, 53: 2, 80: 4, 52: 3, 91: 5} {196: 1, 281: 1, 0: 3, 389: 4, 390: 4, 135: 5, 142: 5, 14: 3, 400: 5, 17: 4, 399: 5, 19: 4, 149: 5, 406: 4, 279: 4, 280: 4, 278: 3, 294: 4, 296: 5, 45: 5, 308: 4, 56: 3, 185: 4, 192: 4, 321: 3, 322: 2, 66: 4, 324: 4, 77: 5, 78: 5, 337: 6, 216: 5, 380: 4, 255: 3} {0, 389, 390, 135, 142, 14, 400, 17, 399, 19, 149, 406, 279, 280, 281, 278, 294, 296, 45, 308, 56, 185, 192, 321, 322, 66, 196, 197, 324, 77, 78, 337, 216, 380, 255} 127 "This document uses the terminology and concepts established in the DetNet architecture RFC8655 and RFC8938, and I-D.ietf-detnet-mpls. The reader is assumed to be familiar with these documents and their terminology." ip - over - tsn ( nits ) mpls - over - tsn ( nits ) tsn - vpn - over - mpls ( nits , ch5.2 , ch5.3 ) 13efc7c7be88a258baaff1e9b6bde4159f1db062 13efc7c7be88a258baaff1e9b6bde4159f1db062 draft-ietf-detnet-tsn-vpn-over-mpls 7e104acddc07f8fbdbdb190e11f543a072b5d88a5a57f61edf7790fd16902d4f ['7e104acddc07f8fbdbdb190e11f543a072b5d88a5a57f61edf7790fd16902d4f', 'b4be4bc772f37db441ba242ca8ca530a4ce79dd949586ca4ffb864fe93265792'] B "this document uses the terminology and concepts established in the detnet architecture rfc8655 and rfc8938, and i-d.ietf-detnet-mpls. the reader is assumed to be familiar with these documents and their terminology." {130: 1, 67: 1, 79: 4, 51: 4, 112: 5, 55: 5, 64: 3, 62: 5, 37: 4, 38: 4, 69: 4, 68: 4, 33: 3, 25: 4, 53: 2, 80: 4, 52: 3, 91: 5} {196: 1, 281: 1, 0: 3, 389: 4, 390: 4, 135: 5, 142: 5, 14: 3, 400: 5, 17: 4, 399: 5, 19: 4, 149: 5, 406: 4, 279: 4, 280: 4, 278: 3, 294: 4, 296: 5, 45: 5, 308: 4, 56: 3, 185: 4, 192: 4, 321: 3, 322: 2, 66: 4, 324: 4, 77: 5, 78: 5, 337: 6, 216: 5, 380: 4, 255: 3} {0, 389, 390, 135, 142, 14, 400, 17, 399, 19, 149, 406, 279, 280, 281, 278, 294, 296, 45, 308, 56, 185, 192, 321, 322, 66, 196, 197, 324, 77, 78, 337, 216, 380, 255} 127 "A MPLS DetNet flow is configured to carry any number of TSN flows. The DetNet flow specific bandwidth profile SHOULD match the required bandwidth of the App-flow aggregate." ip - over - tsn ( nits ) mpls - over - tsn ( nits ) tsn - vpn - over - mpls ( nits , ch5.2 , ch5.3 ) 13efc7c7be88a258baaff1e9b6bde4159f1db062 13efc7c7be88a258baaff1e9b6bde4159f1db062 draft-ietf-detnet-tsn-vpn-over-mpls 4563b77f2d7fb941efbd9e18e8d16d0624a43a1d731dcdaec24463df0e8903fc ['4563b77f2d7fb941efbd9e18e8d16d0624a43a1d731dcdaec24463df0e8903fc'] A "a mpls detnet flow is configured to carry any number of tsn flows. the detnet flow specific bandwidth profile should match the required bandwidth of the app-flow aggregate." {} {} {105} 127 "The LSP used to forward the DetNet packet may be of any type (MPLS- LDP, MPLS-TE, MPLS-TP RFC5921, or MPLS-SR RFC8660). The LSP (F-Label) label and/or the S-Label may be used to indicate the queue processing as well as the forwarding parameters." ip - over - tsn ( nits ) mpls - over - tsn ( nits ) tsn - vpn - over - mpls ( nits , ch5.2 , ch5.3 ) 13efc7c7be88a258baaff1e9b6bde4159f1db062 13efc7c7be88a258baaff1e9b6bde4159f1db062 draft-ietf-detnet-tsn-vpn-over-mpls 0ba8ffab7802b7e5fc4bc754246a4ac4b1486e1b346a8bee7988798eb7defc18 ['48ee4f00ec51885f8458a7bc1768580f6b6e466aad696766daccf33844e22f1f', '0ba8ffab7802b7e5fc4bc754246a4ac4b1486e1b346a8bee7988798eb7defc18', '5cb88eb295a658b2b9c8237a55cdfb96cf685c0066b6eccd7198eab4c5fdfcc4'] A "the lsp used to forward the detnet packet may be of any type (mpls- ldp, mpls-te, mpls-tp rfc5921, or mpls-sr rfc8660). the lsp (f-label) label and/or the s-label may be used to indicate the queue processing as well as the forwarding parameters." {79: 1, 130: 1, 6: 3, 90: 4, 51: 4, 62: 6, 85: 6, 68: 5, 35: 4, 110: 4, 91: 6, 114: 4, 97: 4, 31: 4, 13: 4, 67: 4, 38: 5, 26: 4, 124: 4, 98: 3, 54: 3, 8: 3, 96: 4, 64: 3, 30: 5, 61: 6, 55: 4, 27: 5, 15: 4, 52: 3, 129: 4, 115: 4, 84: 4, 76: 7, 87: 4, 131: 6, 102: 4, 113: 6, 99: 3, 36: 4, 24: 3, 53: 2, 72: 5} {4: 1, 115: 1, 1: 10, 9: 6, 10: 4, 15: 4, 24: 3, 25: 6, 26: 6, 27: 4, 39: 6, 43: 4, 49: 7, 50: 6, 58: 6, 59: 3, 64: 4, 69: 5, 81: 7, 82: 5, 86: 4, 96: 5, 97: 4, 100: 8, 108: 2, 109: 5, 110: 5, 111: 3, 116: 4, 118: 7, 119: 6, 120: 4, 121: 5, 122: 5, 123: 4, 124: 5, 128: 5, 129: 5, 130: 6, 132: 5, 136: 3, 145: 5, 147: 5, 151: 5, 152: 5, 154: 4, 156: 3, 161: 4, 162: 4, 165: 4, 168: 5, 169: 4, 172: 4, 180: 5, 184: 6, 187: 6, 188: 5, 191: 4, 194: 5, 202: 6, 203: 7, 206: 3, 207: 4, 215: 3, 217: 4, 218: 9, 220: 3, 221: 3, 222: 6, 224: 4, 227: 6, 229: 4, 234: 6, 235: 3, 241: 3, 242: 3, 243: 5, 244: 5, 245: 5, 248: 5, 250: 5, 258: 12, 262: 5, 263: 6, 264: 4, 267: 5, 270: 4, 272: 4, 273: 6, 287: 4, 289: 4, 291: 6, 299: 6, 300: 4, 304: 4, 309: 4, 314: 3, 315: 4, 320: 5, 323: 5, 327: 5, 328: 4, 329: 3, 330: 11, 334: 3, 335: 4, 341: 6, 342: 7, 347: 6, 348: 6, 350: 8, 351: 6, 352: 4, 353: 4, 354: 3, 358: 5, 365: 4, 366: 3, 369: 2, 371: 8, 372: 6, 376: 3, 384: 6, 385: 5, 386: 4, 387: 4, 392: 4, 393: 5, 396: 7, 397: 8, 398: 7, 402: 4} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 127 "When a PE receives a packet from the Service Proxy function it MUST add to the packet the DetNet flow-ID specific S-label and create a d-CW. The PE MUST forward the packet according to the configured DetNet Service and Forwarding sub-layer rules to other PE nodes." ip - over - tsn ( nits ) mpls - over - tsn ( nits ) tsn - vpn - over - mpls ( nits , ch5.2 , ch5.3 ) 13efc7c7be88a258baaff1e9b6bde4159f1db062 13efc7c7be88a258baaff1e9b6bde4159f1db062 draft-ietf-detnet-tsn-vpn-over-mpls 5cb88eb295a658b2b9c8237a55cdfb96cf685c0066b6eccd7198eab4c5fdfcc4 ['48ee4f00ec51885f8458a7bc1768580f6b6e466aad696766daccf33844e22f1f', '0ba8ffab7802b7e5fc4bc754246a4ac4b1486e1b346a8bee7988798eb7defc18', '5cb88eb295a658b2b9c8237a55cdfb96cf685c0066b6eccd7198eab4c5fdfcc4'] A "when a pe receives a packet from the service proxy function it must add to the packet the detnet flow-id specific s-label and create a d-cw. the pe must forward the packet according to the configured detnet service and forwarding sub-layer rules to other pe nodes." {79: 1, 130: 1, 6: 3, 90: 4, 51: 4, 62: 6, 85: 6, 68: 5, 35: 4, 110: 4, 91: 6, 114: 4, 97: 4, 31: 4, 13: 4, 67: 4, 38: 5, 26: 4, 124: 4, 98: 3, 54: 3, 8: 3, 96: 4, 64: 3, 30: 5, 61: 6, 55: 4, 27: 5, 15: 4, 52: 3, 129: 4, 115: 4, 84: 4, 76: 7, 87: 4, 131: 6, 102: 4, 113: 6, 99: 3, 36: 4, 24: 3, 53: 2, 72: 5} {4: 1, 115: 1, 1: 10, 9: 6, 10: 4, 15: 4, 24: 3, 25: 6, 26: 6, 27: 4, 39: 6, 43: 4, 49: 7, 50: 6, 58: 6, 59: 3, 64: 4, 69: 5, 81: 7, 82: 5, 86: 4, 96: 5, 97: 4, 100: 8, 108: 2, 109: 5, 110: 5, 111: 3, 116: 4, 118: 7, 119: 6, 120: 4, 121: 5, 122: 5, 123: 4, 124: 5, 128: 5, 129: 5, 130: 6, 132: 5, 136: 3, 145: 5, 147: 5, 151: 5, 152: 5, 154: 4, 156: 3, 161: 4, 162: 4, 165: 4, 168: 5, 169: 4, 172: 4, 180: 5, 184: 6, 187: 6, 188: 5, 191: 4, 194: 5, 202: 6, 203: 7, 206: 3, 207: 4, 215: 3, 217: 4, 218: 9, 220: 3, 221: 3, 222: 6, 224: 4, 227: 6, 229: 4, 234: 6, 235: 3, 241: 3, 242: 3, 243: 5, 244: 5, 245: 5, 248: 5, 250: 5, 258: 12, 262: 5, 263: 6, 264: 4, 267: 5, 270: 4, 272: 4, 273: 6, 287: 4, 289: 4, 291: 6, 299: 6, 300: 4, 304: 4, 309: 4, 314: 3, 315: 4, 320: 5, 323: 5, 327: 5, 328: 4, 329: 3, 330: 11, 334: 3, 335: 4, 341: 6, 342: 7, 347: 6, 348: 6, 350: 8, 351: 6, 352: 4, 353: 4, 354: 3, 358: 5, 365: 4, 366: 3, 369: 2, 371: 8, 372: 6, 376: 3, 384: 6, 385: 5, 386: 4, 387: 4, 392: 4, 393: 5, 396: 7, 397: 8, 398: 7, 402: 4} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 127 "When a PE receives a packet from the Service Proxy function it MUST handle the packet as defined in I-D.ietf-detnet-mpls." ip - over - tsn ( nits ) mpls - over - tsn ( nits ) tsn - vpn - over - mpls ( nits , ch5.2 , ch5.3 ) 13efc7c7be88a258baaff1e9b6bde4159f1db062 13efc7c7be88a258baaff1e9b6bde4159f1db062 draft-ietf-detnet-tsn-vpn-over-mpls 48ee4f00ec51885f8458a7bc1768580f6b6e466aad696766daccf33844e22f1f ['48ee4f00ec51885f8458a7bc1768580f6b6e466aad696766daccf33844e22f1f', '0ba8ffab7802b7e5fc4bc754246a4ac4b1486e1b346a8bee7988798eb7defc18', '5cb88eb295a658b2b9c8237a55cdfb96cf685c0066b6eccd7198eab4c5fdfcc4'] B "when a pe receives a packet from the service proxy function it must handle the packet as defined in i-d.ietf-detnet-mpls." {79: 1, 130: 1, 6: 3, 90: 4, 51: 4, 62: 6, 85: 6, 68: 5, 35: 4, 110: 4, 91: 6, 114: 4, 97: 4, 31: 4, 13: 4, 67: 4, 38: 5, 26: 4, 124: 4, 98: 3, 54: 3, 8: 3, 96: 4, 64: 3, 30: 5, 61: 6, 55: 4, 27: 5, 15: 4, 52: 3, 129: 4, 115: 4, 84: 4, 76: 7, 87: 4, 131: 6, 102: 4, 113: 6, 99: 3, 36: 4, 24: 3, 53: 2, 72: 5} {4: 1, 115: 1, 1: 10, 9: 6, 10: 4, 15: 4, 24: 3, 25: 6, 26: 6, 27: 4, 39: 6, 43: 4, 49: 7, 50: 6, 58: 6, 59: 3, 64: 4, 69: 5, 81: 7, 82: 5, 86: 4, 96: 5, 97: 4, 100: 8, 108: 2, 109: 5, 110: 5, 111: 3, 116: 4, 118: 7, 119: 6, 120: 4, 121: 5, 122: 5, 123: 4, 124: 5, 128: 5, 129: 5, 130: 6, 132: 5, 136: 3, 145: 5, 147: 5, 151: 5, 152: 5, 154: 4, 156: 3, 161: 4, 162: 4, 165: 4, 168: 5, 169: 4, 172: 4, 180: 5, 184: 6, 187: 6, 188: 5, 191: 4, 194: 5, 202: 6, 203: 7, 206: 3, 207: 4, 215: 3, 217: 4, 218: 9, 220: 3, 221: 3, 222: 6, 224: 4, 227: 6, 229: 4, 234: 6, 235: 3, 241: 3, 242: 3, 243: 5, 244: 5, 245: 5, 248: 5, 250: 5, 258: 12, 262: 5, 263: 6, 264: 4, 267: 5, 270: 4, 272: 4, 273: 6, 287: 4, 289: 4, 291: 6, 299: 6, 300: 4, 304: 4, 309: 4, 314: 3, 315: 4, 320: 5, 323: 5, 327: 5, 328: 4, 329: 3, 330: 11, 334: 3, 335: 4, 341: 6, 342: 7, 347: 6, 348: 6, 350: 8, 351: 6, 352: 4, 353: 4, 354: 3, 358: 5, 365: 4, 366: 3, 369: 2, 371: 8, 372: 6, 376: 3, 384: 6, 385: 5, 386: 4, 387: 4, 392: 4, 393: 5, 396: 7, 397: 8, 398: 7, 402: 4} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 127 "I-D.ietf-detnet-ip specifies the DetNet data plane operation for IP hosts and routers that provide DetNet service to IP encapsulated data. This document focuses on the scenario where DetNet IP nodes are interconnected by a TSN sub-network." ip - over - tsn ( nits ) mpls - over - tsn ( nits ) tsn - vpn - over - mpls ( nits , ch5.2 , ch5.3 ) 13efc7c7be88a258baaff1e9b6bde4159f1db062 13efc7c7be88a258baaff1e9b6bde4159f1db062 draft-ietf-detnet-ip-over-tsn 633ea70b163bc368a42e803fd948789b6ebb631f52b5222285fb6220c36d3a2b ['5089b2345083f356bc19e2bb9847032ec8fd3aec2364ec3e54cd82d2c9e98f93', '633ea70b163bc368a42e803fd948789b6ebb631f52b5222285fb6220c36d3a2b', '6d747a78e8d6145dbdaa61f5a544aaa808417714fdd5e3a65bf6ac9c03d63100', 'fb0e6e35656f1cec19cf451b05ee4fda79a70c3051056c56c6054a7998ec2dbb'] A "i-d.ietf-detnet-ip specifies the detnet data plane operation for ip hosts and routers that provide detnet service to ip encapsulated data. this document focuses on the scenario where detnet ip nodes are interconnected by a tsn sub-network." {51: 1, 124: 2, 30: 2} {157: 1, 22: 2, 254: 2} {131, 157, 22, 254} 127 "The DetNet Architecture decomposes the DetNet related data plane functions into two sub-layers: a service sub-layer and a forwarding sub-layer. The service sub-layer is used to provide DetNet service protection and reordering. The forwarding sub-layer is used to provides congestion protection (low loss, assured latency, and limited reordering). As described in I-D.ietf-detnet-ip no DetNet specific headers are added to support DetNet IP flows, only the forwarding sub-layer functions are supported inside the DetNet domain. Service protection can be provided on a per sub-network basis as shown here for the IEEE802.1 TSN sub-network scenario." ip - over - tsn ( nits ) mpls - over - tsn ( nits ) tsn - vpn - over - mpls ( nits , ch5.2 , ch5.3 ) 13efc7c7be88a258baaff1e9b6bde4159f1db062 13efc7c7be88a258baaff1e9b6bde4159f1db062 draft-ietf-detnet-ip-over-tsn fb0e6e35656f1cec19cf451b05ee4fda79a70c3051056c56c6054a7998ec2dbb ['5089b2345083f356bc19e2bb9847032ec8fd3aec2364ec3e54cd82d2c9e98f93', '633ea70b163bc368a42e803fd948789b6ebb631f52b5222285fb6220c36d3a2b', '6d747a78e8d6145dbdaa61f5a544aaa808417714fdd5e3a65bf6ac9c03d63100', 'fb0e6e35656f1cec19cf451b05ee4fda79a70c3051056c56c6054a7998ec2dbb'] A "the detnet architecture decomposes the detnet related data plane functions into two sub-layers: a service sub-layer and a forwarding sub-layer. the service sub-layer is used to provide detnet service protection and reordering. the forwarding sub-layer is used to provides congestion protection (low loss, assured latency, and limited reordering). as described in i-d.ietf-detnet-ip no detnet specific headers are added to support detnet ip flows, only the forwarding sub-layer functions are supported inside the detnet domain. service protection can be provided on a per sub-network basis as shown here for the ieee802.1 tsn sub-network scenario." {51: 1, 124: 2, 30: 2} {157: 1, 22: 2, 254: 2} {131, 157, 22, 254} 127 "RFC8939 specifies the DetNet data plane operation for IP hosts and routers that provide DetNet service to IP encapsulated data. This document focuses on the scenario where DetNet IP nodes are interconnected by a TSN sub-network." ip - over - tsn ( nits ) mpls - over - tsn ( nits ) tsn - vpn - over - mpls ( nits , ch5.2 , ch5.3 ) 13efc7c7be88a258baaff1e9b6bde4159f1db062 13efc7c7be88a258baaff1e9b6bde4159f1db062 draft-ietf-detnet-ip-over-tsn 5089b2345083f356bc19e2bb9847032ec8fd3aec2364ec3e54cd82d2c9e98f93 ['5089b2345083f356bc19e2bb9847032ec8fd3aec2364ec3e54cd82d2c9e98f93', '633ea70b163bc368a42e803fd948789b6ebb631f52b5222285fb6220c36d3a2b', '6d747a78e8d6145dbdaa61f5a544aaa808417714fdd5e3a65bf6ac9c03d63100', 'fb0e6e35656f1cec19cf451b05ee4fda79a70c3051056c56c6054a7998ec2dbb'] B "rfc8939 specifies the detnet data plane operation for ip hosts and routers that provide detnet service to ip encapsulated data. this document focuses on the scenario where detnet ip nodes are interconnected by a tsn sub-network." {51: 1, 124: 2, 30: 2} {157: 1, 22: 2, 254: 2} {131, 157, 22, 254} 127 "The DetNet Architecture decomposes the DetNet related data plane functions into two sub-layers: a service sub-layer and a forwarding sub-layer. The service sub-layer is used to provide DetNet service protection and reordering. The forwarding sub-layer is used to provides congestion protection (low loss, assured latency, and limited reordering). As described in RFC8939 no DetNet specific headers are added to support DetNet IP flows, only the forwarding sub-layer functions are supported inside the DetNet domain. Service protection can be provided on a per sub-network basis as shown here for the IEEE802.1 TSN sub-network scenario." ip - over - tsn ( nits ) mpls - over - tsn ( nits ) tsn - vpn - over - mpls ( nits , ch5.2 , ch5.3 ) 13efc7c7be88a258baaff1e9b6bde4159f1db062 13efc7c7be88a258baaff1e9b6bde4159f1db062 draft-ietf-detnet-ip-over-tsn 6d747a78e8d6145dbdaa61f5a544aaa808417714fdd5e3a65bf6ac9c03d63100 ['5089b2345083f356bc19e2bb9847032ec8fd3aec2364ec3e54cd82d2c9e98f93', '633ea70b163bc368a42e803fd948789b6ebb631f52b5222285fb6220c36d3a2b', '6d747a78e8d6145dbdaa61f5a544aaa808417714fdd5e3a65bf6ac9c03d63100', 'fb0e6e35656f1cec19cf451b05ee4fda79a70c3051056c56c6054a7998ec2dbb'] B "the detnet architecture decomposes the detnet related data plane functions into two sub-layers: a service sub-layer and a forwarding sub-layer. the service sub-layer is used to provide detnet service protection and reordering. the forwarding sub-layer is used to provides congestion protection (low loss, assured latency, and limited reordering). as described in rfc8939 no detnet specific headers are added to support detnet ip flows, only the forwarding sub-layer functions are supported inside the detnet domain. service protection can be provided on a per sub-network basis as shown here for the ieee802.1 tsn sub-network scenario." {51: 1, 124: 2, 30: 2} {157: 1, 22: 2, 254: 2} {131, 157, 22, 254} 127 "I-D.ietf-detnet-ip describes how IP is used by DetNet nodes, i.e., hosts and routers, to identify DetNet flows and provide a DetNet service. From a data plane perspective, an end-to-end IP model is followed. DetNet uses ""6-tuple"" based flow identification, where ""6-tuple"" refers to information carried in IP and higher layer protocol headers." ip - over - tsn ( nits ) mpls - over - tsn ( nits ) tsn - vpn - over - mpls ( nits , ch5.2 , ch5.3 ) 13efc7c7be88a258baaff1e9b6bde4159f1db062 13efc7c7be88a258baaff1e9b6bde4159f1db062 draft-ietf-detnet-ip-over-tsn ffe962a1522858cfb38db38e137a9571725732aa06512837018d7ce20e0cbcf6 ['e2ebeec985d747a780e9acfad3eac0833188c2ed139fd9608a61350f9cff73f0', 'ffe962a1522858cfb38db38e137a9571725732aa06512837018d7ce20e0cbcf6'] A "i-d.ietf-detnet-ip describes how ip is used by detnet nodes, i.e., hosts and routers, to identify detnet flows and provide a detnet service. from a data plane perspective, an end-to-end ip model is followed. detnet uses ""6-tuple"" based flow identification, where ""6-tuple"" refers to information carried in ip and higher layer protocol headers." {51: 1} {91: 1} {91, 364} 127 "RFC8939 describes how IP is used by DetNet nodes, i.e., hosts and routers, to identify DetNet flows and provide a DetNet service. From a data plane perspective, an end-to-end IP model is followed. DetNet uses ""6-tuple"" based flow identification, where ""6-tuple"" refers to information carried in IP and higher layer protocol headers." ip - over - tsn ( nits ) mpls - over - tsn ( nits ) tsn - vpn - over - mpls ( nits , ch5.2 , ch5.3 ) 13efc7c7be88a258baaff1e9b6bde4159f1db062 13efc7c7be88a258baaff1e9b6bde4159f1db062 draft-ietf-detnet-ip-over-tsn e2ebeec985d747a780e9acfad3eac0833188c2ed139fd9608a61350f9cff73f0 ['e2ebeec985d747a780e9acfad3eac0833188c2ed139fd9608a61350f9cff73f0', 'ffe962a1522858cfb38db38e137a9571725732aa06512837018d7ce20e0cbcf6'] B "rfc8939 describes how ip is used by detnet nodes, i.e., hosts and routers, to identify detnet flows and provide a detnet service. from a data plane perspective, an end-to-end ip model is followed. detnet uses ""6-tuple"" based flow identification, where ""6-tuple"" refers to information carried in ip and higher layer protocol headers." {51: 1} {91: 1} {91, 364} 127 "DetNet IP related configuration information according to the DetNet role of the DetNet IP node, as per I-D.ietf-detnet-ip." ip - over - tsn ( nits ) mpls - over - tsn ( nits ) tsn - vpn - over - mpls ( nits , ch5.2 , ch5.3 ) 13efc7c7be88a258baaff1e9b6bde4159f1db062 13efc7c7be88a258baaff1e9b6bde4159f1db062 draft-ietf-detnet-ip-over-tsn 865a4dd25342931383c0ae9a75ebc6db73fae9af899e0b378481a3e7f59d1bd8 ['6060505876485aa149ffd29bddff33ad76157c92510215db931d1559fd59114d', '8e8f83dde2079357a6fc95d06146eedc23be26c0c1101bd816f585d23ad39bdf', '112e5db0cd8223f39919ed0f065c4cd9b807044b5c4b3717481f6210cffac640', '865a4dd25342931383c0ae9a75ebc6db73fae9af899e0b378481a3e7f59d1bd8'] A "detnet ip related configuration information according to the detnet role of the detnet ip node, as per i-d.ietf-detnet-ip." {96: 1, 97: 2, 98: 2, 130: 3, 124: 3} {403: 1, 12: 2, 13: 2, 208: 3, 63: 3} {12, 13, 208, 403, 153, 63} 127 "Mapping between DetNet IP flow(s) (as flow identification defined in I-D.ietf-detnet-ip, it is summarized in Section 5.1 of that document, and includes all wildcards, port ranges and the ability to ignore specific IP fields) and TSN Stream(s) (as stream identification information defined in IEEE8021CB and IEEEP8021CBdb). Note, that managed objects for TSN Stream identification can be found in IEEEP8021CBcv." ip - over - tsn ( nits ) mpls - over - tsn ( nits ) tsn - vpn - over - mpls ( nits , ch5.2 , ch5.3 ) 13efc7c7be88a258baaff1e9b6bde4159f1db062 13efc7c7be88a258baaff1e9b6bde4159f1db062 draft-ietf-detnet-ip-over-tsn 6060505876485aa149ffd29bddff33ad76157c92510215db931d1559fd59114d ['6060505876485aa149ffd29bddff33ad76157c92510215db931d1559fd59114d', '8e8f83dde2079357a6fc95d06146eedc23be26c0c1101bd816f585d23ad39bdf', '112e5db0cd8223f39919ed0f065c4cd9b807044b5c4b3717481f6210cffac640', '865a4dd25342931383c0ae9a75ebc6db73fae9af899e0b378481a3e7f59d1bd8'] A "mapping between detnet ip flow(s) (as flow identification defined in i-d.ietf-detnet-ip, it is summarized in section 5.1 of that document, and includes all wildcards, port ranges and the ability to ignore specific ip fields) and tsn stream(s) (as stream identification information defined in ieee8021cb and ieeep8021cbdb). note, that managed objects for tsn stream identification can be found in ieeep8021cbcv." {96: 1, 97: 2, 98: 2, 130: 3, 124: 3} {403: 1, 12: 2, 13: 2, 208: 3, 63: 3} {12, 13, 208, 403, 153, 63} 127 "DetNet IP related configuration information according to the DetNet role of the DetNet IP node, as per RFC8939." ip - over - tsn ( nits ) mpls - over - tsn ( nits ) tsn - vpn - over - mpls ( nits , ch5.2 , ch5.3 ) 13efc7c7be88a258baaff1e9b6bde4159f1db062 13efc7c7be88a258baaff1e9b6bde4159f1db062 draft-ietf-detnet-ip-over-tsn 112e5db0cd8223f39919ed0f065c4cd9b807044b5c4b3717481f6210cffac640 ['6060505876485aa149ffd29bddff33ad76157c92510215db931d1559fd59114d', '8e8f83dde2079357a6fc95d06146eedc23be26c0c1101bd816f585d23ad39bdf', '112e5db0cd8223f39919ed0f065c4cd9b807044b5c4b3717481f6210cffac640', '865a4dd25342931383c0ae9a75ebc6db73fae9af899e0b378481a3e7f59d1bd8'] B "detnet ip related configuration information according to the detnet role of the detnet ip node, as per rfc8939." {96: 1, 97: 2, 98: 2, 130: 3, 124: 3} {403: 1, 12: 2, 13: 2, 208: 3, 63: 3} {12, 13, 208, 403, 153, 63} 127 "Mapping between DetNet IP flow(s) (as flow identification defined in RFC8939, it is summarized in Section 5.1 of that document, and includes all wildcards, port ranges and the ability to ignore specific IP fields) and TSN Stream(s) (as stream identification information defined in IEEE8021CB and IEEEP8021CBdb). Note, that managed objects for TSN Stream identification can be found in IEEEP8021CBcv." ip - over - tsn ( nits ) mpls - over - tsn ( nits ) tsn - vpn - over - mpls ( nits , ch5.2 , ch5.3 ) 13efc7c7be88a258baaff1e9b6bde4159f1db062 13efc7c7be88a258baaff1e9b6bde4159f1db062 draft-ietf-detnet-ip-over-tsn 8e8f83dde2079357a6fc95d06146eedc23be26c0c1101bd816f585d23ad39bdf ['6060505876485aa149ffd29bddff33ad76157c92510215db931d1559fd59114d', '8e8f83dde2079357a6fc95d06146eedc23be26c0c1101bd816f585d23ad39bdf', '112e5db0cd8223f39919ed0f065c4cd9b807044b5c4b3717481f6210cffac640', '865a4dd25342931383c0ae9a75ebc6db73fae9af899e0b378481a3e7f59d1bd8'] B "mapping between detnet ip flow(s) (as flow identification defined in rfc8939, it is summarized in section 5.1 of that document, and includes all wildcards, port ranges and the ability to ignore specific ip fields) and tsn stream(s) (as stream identification information defined in ieee8021cb and ieeep8021cbdb). note, that managed objects for tsn stream identification can be found in ieeep8021cbcv." {96: 1, 97: 2, 98: 2, 130: 3, 124: 3} {403: 1, 12: 2, 13: 2, 208: 3, 63: 3} {12, 13, 208, 403, 153, 63} 127 "Security considerations for DetNet are described in detail in I- D.ietf-detnet-security. General security considerations are described in RFC8655. DetNet IP data plane specific considerations are summarized in I-D.ietf-detnet-ip. This section considers exclusively security considerations which are specific to the DetNet IP over TSN sub-network scenario." ip - over - tsn ( nits ) mpls - over - tsn ( nits ) tsn - vpn - over - mpls ( nits , ch5.2 , ch5.3 ) 13efc7c7be88a258baaff1e9b6bde4159f1db062 13efc7c7be88a258baaff1e9b6bde4159f1db062 draft-ietf-detnet-ip-over-tsn ca7dba4455acdc335610acb8f2232a35ca50a8e64a6f61d6ffc87f018f6774fa ['ca7dba4455acdc335610acb8f2232a35ca50a8e64a6f61d6ffc87f018f6774fa', '89b5f150990abcf9faa758891c7a21576823ba799040257285e14506f6098501'] A "security considerations for detnet are described in detail in i- d.ietf-detnet-security. general security considerations are described in rfc8655. detnet ip data plane specific considerations are summarized in i-d.ietf-detnet-ip. this section considers exclusively security considerations which are specific to the detnet ip over tsn sub-network scenario." {96: 1, 130: 3, 97: 2} {318: 1, 225: 3, 249: 2} {225, 249, 318, 319} 127 "Security considerations for DetNet are described in detail in I- D.ietf-detnet-security. General security considerations are described in RFC8655. DetNet IP data plane specific considerations are summarized in RFC8939. This section considers exclusively security considerations which are specific to the DetNet IP over TSN sub-network scenario." ip - over - tsn ( nits ) mpls - over - tsn ( nits ) tsn - vpn - over - mpls ( nits , ch5.2 , ch5.3 ) 13efc7c7be88a258baaff1e9b6bde4159f1db062 13efc7c7be88a258baaff1e9b6bde4159f1db062 draft-ietf-detnet-ip-over-tsn 89b5f150990abcf9faa758891c7a21576823ba799040257285e14506f6098501 ['ca7dba4455acdc335610acb8f2232a35ca50a8e64a6f61d6ffc87f018f6774fa', '89b5f150990abcf9faa758891c7a21576823ba799040257285e14506f6098501'] B "security considerations for detnet are described in detail in i- d.ietf-detnet-security. general security considerations are described in rfc8655. detnet ip data plane specific considerations are summarized in rfc8939. this section considers exclusively security considerations which are specific to the detnet ip over tsn sub-network scenario." {96: 1, 130: 3, 97: 2} {318: 1, 225: 3, 249: 2} {225, 249, 318, 319} 126 "This information MUST be provisioned per DetNet flow via configuration, e.g., via the controller RFC8655 or management plane." In chapter 5 . Management and Control Information Summary one more bullet + clarification text to the paragraph after the list . d55437da5a06bbdbf7ad2ba340b7e379f3e95682 d55437da5a06bbdbf7ad2ba340b7e379f3e95682 draft-ietf-detnet-mpls-over-udp-ip c3dfebbd1fe07c70e60322b597ecb3d3a63aa8a746224e939a8230e7b9b19e33 ['6b04c1686ae658de6adc776afe74fa4dfccf9875e0d59f85ca35a40bbbef365a', 'c3dfebbd1fe07c70e60322b597ecb3d3a63aa8a746224e939a8230e7b9b19e33', 'f1ea7494eb63dbcbdd56600e50c5a3a1e80040da5c38bda5aecb447b7da486e9'] A "this information must be provisioned per detnet flow via configuration, e.g., via the controller rfc8655 or management plane." {71: 1, 60: 4, 56: 3, 102: 3, 64: 2, 38: 2, 62: 4, 33: 3, 26: 3, 32: 2, 83: 4, 113: 2, 112: 2, 85: 4, 129: 2} {377: 1, 260: 4, 261: 3, 274: 3, 339: 3, 212: 2, 343: 2, 283: 4, 286: 4, 31: 3, 32: 3, 33: 2, 163: 4, 228: 2, 357: 2, 231: 2, 298: 2, 363: 4, 46: 2} {260, 261, 274, 283, 286, 31, 32, 33, 163, 166, 298, 46, 339, 212, 343, 228, 357, 231, 363, 377} 126 Use/non-use of UDP checksum. In chapter 5 . Management and Control Information Summary one more bullet + clarification text to the paragraph after the list . d55437da5a06bbdbf7ad2ba340b7e379f3e95682 d55437da5a06bbdbf7ad2ba340b7e379f3e95682 draft-ietf-detnet-mpls-over-udp-ip 6b04c1686ae658de6adc776afe74fa4dfccf9875e0d59f85ca35a40bbbef365a ['6b04c1686ae658de6adc776afe74fa4dfccf9875e0d59f85ca35a40bbbef365a', 'c3dfebbd1fe07c70e60322b597ecb3d3a63aa8a746224e939a8230e7b9b19e33', 'f1ea7494eb63dbcbdd56600e50c5a3a1e80040da5c38bda5aecb447b7da486e9'] B use/non-use of udp checksum. {71: 1, 60: 4, 56: 3, 102: 3, 64: 2, 38: 2, 62: 4, 33: 3, 26: 3, 32: 2, 83: 4, 113: 2, 112: 2, 85: 4, 129: 2} {377: 1, 260: 4, 261: 3, 274: 3, 339: 3, 212: 2, 343: 2, 283: 4, 286: 4, 31: 3, 32: 3, 33: 2, 163: 4, 228: 2, 357: 2, 231: 2, 298: 2, 363: 4, 46: 2} {260, 261, 274, 283, 286, 31, 32, 33, 163, 166, 298, 46, 339, 212, 343, 228, 357, 231, 363, 377} 126 "This information MUST be provisioned per DetNet flow via configuration, e.g., via the controller RFC8655 or management plane. Not using the UDP checksum has to be evaluated on a case-by-case basis for a given network scenario based on the exception criteria's defined in RFC7510, particularly when IPv6 is used." In chapter 5 . Management and Control Information Summary one more bullet + clarification text to the paragraph after the list . d55437da5a06bbdbf7ad2ba340b7e379f3e95682 d55437da5a06bbdbf7ad2ba340b7e379f3e95682 draft-ietf-detnet-mpls-over-udp-ip f1ea7494eb63dbcbdd56600e50c5a3a1e80040da5c38bda5aecb447b7da486e9 ['6b04c1686ae658de6adc776afe74fa4dfccf9875e0d59f85ca35a40bbbef365a', 'c3dfebbd1fe07c70e60322b597ecb3d3a63aa8a746224e939a8230e7b9b19e33', 'f1ea7494eb63dbcbdd56600e50c5a3a1e80040da5c38bda5aecb447b7da486e9'] B "this information must be provisioned per detnet flow via configuration, e.g., via the controller rfc8655 or management plane. not using the udp checksum has to be evaluated on a case-by-case basis for a given network scenario based on the exception criteria's defined in rfc7510, particularly when ipv6 is used." {71: 1, 60: 4, 56: 3, 102: 3, 64: 2, 38: 2, 62: 4, 33: 3, 26: 3, 32: 2, 83: 4, 113: 2, 112: 2, 85: 4, 129: 2} {377: 1, 260: 4, 261: 3, 274: 3, 339: 3, 212: 2, 343: 2, 283: 4, 286: 4, 31: 3, 32: 3, 33: 2, 163: 4, 228: 2, 357: 2, 231: 2, 298: 2, 363: 4, 46: 2} {260, 261, 274, 283, 286, 31, 32, 33, 163, 166, 298, 46, 339, 212, 343, 228, 357, 231, 363, 377} 124 "This document specifies the Deterministic Networking MPLS data plane when operating over a TSN sub-network." TSN related documents are updated as follows : draft - ietf - detnet - ip - over - tsn AND draft - ietf - detnet - mpls - over - tsn type changed to informational overview shortened changing TSN related conformance language to informative text stating that mappings between DetNet and TSN management and control planes are out of scope of the document updating references draft - ietf - detnet - tsn - vpn - over - mpls overview shortened fixing 5.1 and 5.2 ( changing TSN related conformance language to informative text ) stating that mappings between DetNet and TSN management and control planes are out of scope of the document updating references 307e99a43b03cdb2231e27fbd7e9a248cf849106 307e99a43b03cdb2231e27fbd7e9a248cf849106 draft-ietf-detnet-mpls-over-tsn f27cd400f15b767c66b85f44128dca38137025888fc5c9762efbe1c927c792e7 ['6580a6613cfcb10cffac5764156a46b91d3eb44fa7400dfa65ceab8dafefeb96', 'f27cd400f15b767c66b85f44128dca38137025888fc5c9762efbe1c927c792e7'] A "this document specifies the deterministic networking mpls data plane when operating over a tsn sub-network." {130: 1, 52: 1, 64: 3, 67: 2} {269: 1, 391: 1, 133: 3, 268: 2, 305: 4} {133, 391, 268, 269, 305, 158} 124 "This document specifies the Deterministic Networking MPLS data plane when operating over a TSN sub-network. This document does not define new procedures or processes. Whenever this document makes requirements statements or recommendations, these are taken from normative text in the referenced RFCs." TSN related documents are updated as follows : draft - ietf - detnet - ip - over - tsn AND draft - ietf - detnet - mpls - over - tsn type changed to informational overview shortened changing TSN related conformance language to informative text stating that mappings between DetNet and TSN management and control planes are out of scope of the document updating references draft - ietf - detnet - tsn - vpn - over - mpls overview shortened fixing 5.1 and 5.2 ( changing TSN related conformance language to informative text ) stating that mappings between DetNet and TSN management and control planes are out of scope of the document updating references 307e99a43b03cdb2231e27fbd7e9a248cf849106 307e99a43b03cdb2231e27fbd7e9a248cf849106 draft-ietf-detnet-mpls-over-tsn 6580a6613cfcb10cffac5764156a46b91d3eb44fa7400dfa65ceab8dafefeb96 ['6580a6613cfcb10cffac5764156a46b91d3eb44fa7400dfa65ceab8dafefeb96', 'f27cd400f15b767c66b85f44128dca38137025888fc5c9762efbe1c927c792e7'] B "this document specifies the deterministic networking mpls data plane when operating over a tsn sub-network. this document does not define new procedures or processes. whenever this document makes requirements statements or recommendations, these are taken from normative text in the referenced rfcs." {130: 1, 52: 1, 64: 3, 67: 2} {269: 1, 391: 1, 133: 3, 268: 2, 305: 4} {133, 391, 268, 269, 305, 158} 124 "fig_mpls_detnet_part illustrates an extract of a DetNet enabled MPLS network. Edge/relay nodes sit at MPLS LSP boundaries and transit nodes are LSRs. In this figure, two MPLS nodes (the edge node and the transit node) are interconnected by a TSN sub-network." TSN related documents are updated as follows : draft - ietf - detnet - ip - over - tsn AND draft - ietf - detnet - mpls - over - tsn type changed to informational overview shortened changing TSN related conformance language to informative text stating that mappings between DetNet and TSN management and control planes are out of scope of the document updating references draft - ietf - detnet - tsn - vpn - over - mpls overview shortened fixing 5.1 and 5.2 ( changing TSN related conformance language to informative text ) stating that mappings between DetNet and TSN management and control planes are out of scope of the document updating references 307e99a43b03cdb2231e27fbd7e9a248cf849106 307e99a43b03cdb2231e27fbd7e9a248cf849106 draft-ietf-detnet-mpls-over-tsn cee8a70bcfc00996a87843150f50858ee830d692ae4678e50d5c074d43ff657c ['cee8a70bcfc00996a87843150f50858ee830d692ae4678e50d5c074d43ff657c', '8513e971fcab148ee6e2fb78ae3ef6e2645ec8f21ec8b42fecb7fd2978cabb1a'] A "fig_mpls_detnet_part illustrates an extract of a detnet enabled mpls network. edge/relay nodes sit at mpls lsp boundaries and transit nodes are lsrs. in this figure, two mpls nodes (the edge node and the transit node) are interconnected by a tsn sub-network." {52: 1, 6: 2, 79: 3, 90: 4, 51: 4, 130: 3, 62: 5, 85: 5, 68: 4, 35: 4, 110: 4, 91: 6, 114: 4, 97: 4, 31: 2, 13: 4, 67: 2, 38: 5, 26: 4, 124: 3, 98: 3, 54: 3, 127: 4, 8: 2, 96: 4, 64: 3, 30: 5, 61: 6, 55: 3, 27: 3, 15: 4, 129: 4, 115: 4, 84: 3, 76: 5, 87: 4, 131: 6, 102: 4, 113: 6, 99: 3, 36: 4, 24: 3, 53: 2, 72: 5} {215: 1, 1: 9, 4: 3, 9: 4, 10: 4, 15: 4, 24: 3, 25: 5, 26: 5, 27: 4, 39: 5, 43: 4, 49: 7, 50: 6, 58: 6, 59: 3, 64: 4, 69: 3, 81: 6, 82: 5, 86: 4, 96: 5, 97: 4, 100: 8, 108: 4, 109: 5, 110: 5, 111: 3, 114: 4, 115: 5, 116: 4, 118: 6, 119: 5, 120: 4, 121: 4, 122: 5, 123: 4, 124: 4, 128: 5, 129: 5, 130: 6, 132: 3, 136: 3, 145: 3, 147: 5, 151: 5, 152: 5, 154: 4, 156: 3, 161: 2, 162: 3, 165: 4, 168: 5, 169: 4, 172: 4, 180: 5, 184: 4, 187: 6, 188: 5, 191: 4, 194: 3, 202: 4, 203: 5, 206: 3, 207: 4, 217: 4, 218: 8, 220: 2, 221: 2, 222: 5, 224: 4, 227: 6, 229: 4, 234: 6, 235: 3, 241: 3, 242: 3, 243: 3, 244: 5, 245: 3, 248: 5, 250: 5, 258: 11, 262: 5, 263: 6, 264: 2, 267: 4, 270: 4, 272: 4, 273: 4, 287: 4, 289: 4, 291: 6, 299: 6, 300: 4, 304: 4, 309: 3, 314: 3, 315: 4, 320: 4, 323: 3, 327: 5, 329: 3, 330: 10, 334: 3, 335: 4, 341: 6, 342: 7, 347: 6, 348: 6, 350: 6, 351: 6, 352: 4, 353: 4, 354: 3, 358: 4, 365: 4, 366: 3, 369: 2, 371: 8, 372: 6, 376: 3, 384: 6, 385: 5, 386: 4, 387: 4, 392: 2, 393: 3, 396: 7, 397: 7, 398: 6, 402: 4} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 124 "MPLS (DetNet) nodes and transit nodes interconnected by a TSN sub- network are the primary focus of this document. The mapping of DetNet MPLS flows to TSN streams and TSN protection mechanisms are covered in mpls-over-tsn." TSN related documents are updated as follows : draft - ietf - detnet - ip - over - tsn AND draft - ietf - detnet - mpls - over - tsn type changed to informational overview shortened changing TSN related conformance language to informative text stating that mappings between DetNet and TSN management and control planes are out of scope of the document updating references draft - ietf - detnet - tsn - vpn - over - mpls overview shortened fixing 5.1 and 5.2 ( changing TSN related conformance language to informative text ) stating that mappings between DetNet and TSN management and control planes are out of scope of the document updating references 307e99a43b03cdb2231e27fbd7e9a248cf849106 307e99a43b03cdb2231e27fbd7e9a248cf849106 draft-ietf-detnet-mpls-over-tsn 8513e971fcab148ee6e2fb78ae3ef6e2645ec8f21ec8b42fecb7fd2978cabb1a ['cee8a70bcfc00996a87843150f50858ee830d692ae4678e50d5c074d43ff657c', '8513e971fcab148ee6e2fb78ae3ef6e2645ec8f21ec8b42fecb7fd2978cabb1a'] B "mpls (detnet) nodes and transit nodes interconnected by a tsn sub- network are the primary focus of this document. the mapping of detnet mpls flows to tsn streams and tsn protection mechanisms are covered in mpls-over-tsn." {52: 1, 6: 2, 79: 3, 90: 4, 51: 4, 130: 3, 62: 5, 85: 5, 68: 4, 35: 4, 110: 4, 91: 6, 114: 4, 97: 4, 31: 2, 13: 4, 67: 2, 38: 5, 26: 4, 124: 3, 98: 3, 54: 3, 127: 4, 8: 2, 96: 4, 64: 3, 30: 5, 61: 6, 55: 3, 27: 3, 15: 4, 129: 4, 115: 4, 84: 3, 76: 5, 87: 4, 131: 6, 102: 4, 113: 6, 99: 3, 36: 4, 24: 3, 53: 2, 72: 5} {215: 1, 1: 9, 4: 3, 9: 4, 10: 4, 15: 4, 24: 3, 25: 5, 26: 5, 27: 4, 39: 5, 43: 4, 49: 7, 50: 6, 58: 6, 59: 3, 64: 4, 69: 3, 81: 6, 82: 5, 86: 4, 96: 5, 97: 4, 100: 8, 108: 4, 109: 5, 110: 5, 111: 3, 114: 4, 115: 5, 116: 4, 118: 6, 119: 5, 120: 4, 121: 4, 122: 5, 123: 4, 124: 4, 128: 5, 129: 5, 130: 6, 132: 3, 136: 3, 145: 3, 147: 5, 151: 5, 152: 5, 154: 4, 156: 3, 161: 2, 162: 3, 165: 4, 168: 5, 169: 4, 172: 4, 180: 5, 184: 4, 187: 6, 188: 5, 191: 4, 194: 3, 202: 4, 203: 5, 206: 3, 207: 4, 217: 4, 218: 8, 220: 2, 221: 2, 222: 5, 224: 4, 227: 6, 229: 4, 234: 6, 235: 3, 241: 3, 242: 3, 243: 3, 244: 5, 245: 3, 248: 5, 250: 5, 258: 11, 262: 5, 263: 6, 264: 2, 267: 4, 270: 4, 272: 4, 273: 4, 287: 4, 289: 4, 291: 6, 299: 6, 300: 4, 304: 4, 309: 3, 314: 3, 315: 4, 320: 4, 323: 3, 327: 5, 329: 3, 330: 10, 334: 3, 335: 4, 341: 6, 342: 7, 347: 6, 348: 6, 350: 6, 351: 6, 352: 4, 353: 4, 354: 3, 358: 4, 365: 4, 366: 3, 369: 2, 371: 8, 372: 6, 376: 3, 384: 6, 385: 5, 386: 4, 387: 4, 392: 2, 393: 3, 396: 7, 397: 7, 398: 6, 402: 4} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 124 "As described in the DetNet architecture RFC8655 and also illustrated here in fig_mpls_detnet_part a sub-network provides from MPLS perspective a single hop connection between MPLS (DetNet) nodes. Functions used for resource allocation and explicit routes are treated as domain internal functions and does not require function interworking across the DetNet MPLS network and the TSN sub-network." TSN related documents are updated as follows : draft - ietf - detnet - ip - over - tsn AND draft - ietf - detnet - mpls - over - tsn type changed to informational overview shortened changing TSN related conformance language to informative text stating that mappings between DetNet and TSN management and control planes are out of scope of the document updating references draft - ietf - detnet - tsn - vpn - over - mpls overview shortened fixing 5.1 and 5.2 ( changing TSN related conformance language to informative text ) stating that mappings between DetNet and TSN management and control planes are out of scope of the document updating references 307e99a43b03cdb2231e27fbd7e9a248cf849106 307e99a43b03cdb2231e27fbd7e9a248cf849106 draft-ietf-detnet-mpls-over-tsn f5449b9a284f19507d5c9e268b9034c6f005352fd0bcdab4d25a7d97f8b01179 ['f5449b9a284f19507d5c9e268b9034c6f005352fd0bcdab4d25a7d97f8b01179', '6292eff98882da65fae90cceeacf1d4d5b7ec62b984bda28dff38e091321ef33'] A "as described in the detnet architecture rfc8655 and also illustrated here in fig_mpls_detnet_part a sub-network provides from mpls perspective a single hop connection between mpls (detnet) nodes. functions used for resource allocation and explicit routes are treated as domain internal functions and does not require function interworking across the detnet mpls network and the tsn sub-network." {67: 1, 6: 3, 79: 4, 90: 5, 51: 5, 130: 4, 62: 6, 85: 6, 68: 5, 35: 5, 110: 5, 91: 7, 114: 5, 97: 5, 31: 3, 13: 5, 38: 6, 26: 5, 124: 3, 98: 4, 54: 4, 127: 5, 8: 3, 96: 5, 64: 4, 30: 6, 61: 7, 55: 4, 27: 4, 15: 5, 52: 2, 129: 5, 115: 5, 84: 4, 76: 6, 87: 5, 131: 7, 102: 5, 113: 7, 99: 4, 36: 5, 24: 4, 53: 3, 72: 6} {392: 1, 1: 10, 4: 4, 9: 5, 10: 5, 15: 5, 24: 4, 25: 6, 26: 6, 27: 5, 39: 6, 43: 5, 49: 8, 50: 7, 58: 7, 59: 4, 64: 5, 69: 4, 81: 7, 82: 6, 86: 5, 96: 6, 97: 5, 100: 9, 108: 5, 109: 6, 110: 6, 111: 4, 114: 5, 115: 6, 116: 5, 118: 7, 119: 6, 120: 5, 121: 5, 122: 6, 123: 5, 124: 5, 128: 6, 129: 6, 130: 7, 132: 4, 136: 4, 145: 4, 147: 6, 151: 6, 152: 6, 154: 5, 156: 4, 161: 3, 162: 4, 165: 5, 168: 6, 169: 5, 172: 5, 180: 6, 184: 5, 187: 7, 188: 6, 191: 5, 194: 4, 202: 5, 203: 6, 206: 4, 207: 5, 215: 2, 217: 5, 218: 9, 220: 3, 221: 3, 222: 6, 224: 5, 227: 7, 229: 5, 234: 7, 235: 4, 241: 4, 242: 4, 243: 4, 244: 6, 245: 4, 248: 6, 250: 6, 258: 12, 262: 6, 263: 7, 264: 3, 267: 5, 270: 5, 272: 5, 273: 5, 287: 5, 289: 5, 291: 7, 299: 7, 300: 5, 304: 5, 309: 4, 314: 4, 315: 5, 320: 5, 323: 4, 327: 6, 328: 3, 329: 4, 330: 11, 334: 4, 335: 5, 341: 7, 342: 8, 347: 7, 348: 7, 350: 7, 351: 7, 352: 5, 353: 5, 354: 4, 358: 5, 365: 5, 366: 4, 369: 3, 371: 9, 372: 7, 376: 4, 384: 7, 385: 6, 386: 5, 387: 5, 396: 8, 397: 8, 398: 7, 402: 5} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 124 "As described in the DetNet architecture RFC8655 a sub-network provides from MPLS perspective a single hop connection between MPLS (DetNet) nodes. Functions used for resource allocation and explicit routes are treated as domain internal functions and does not require function interworking across the DetNet MPLS network and the TSN sub- network." TSN related documents are updated as follows : draft - ietf - detnet - ip - over - tsn AND draft - ietf - detnet - mpls - over - tsn type changed to informational overview shortened changing TSN related conformance language to informative text stating that mappings between DetNet and TSN management and control planes are out of scope of the document updating references draft - ietf - detnet - tsn - vpn - over - mpls overview shortened fixing 5.1 and 5.2 ( changing TSN related conformance language to informative text ) stating that mappings between DetNet and TSN management and control planes are out of scope of the document updating references 307e99a43b03cdb2231e27fbd7e9a248cf849106 307e99a43b03cdb2231e27fbd7e9a248cf849106 draft-ietf-detnet-mpls-over-tsn 6292eff98882da65fae90cceeacf1d4d5b7ec62b984bda28dff38e091321ef33 ['f5449b9a284f19507d5c9e268b9034c6f005352fd0bcdab4d25a7d97f8b01179', '6292eff98882da65fae90cceeacf1d4d5b7ec62b984bda28dff38e091321ef33'] B "as described in the detnet architecture rfc8655 a sub-network provides from mpls perspective a single hop connection between mpls (detnet) nodes. functions used for resource allocation and explicit routes are treated as domain internal functions and does not require function interworking across the detnet mpls network and the tsn sub- network." {67: 1, 6: 3, 79: 4, 90: 5, 51: 5, 130: 4, 62: 6, 85: 6, 68: 5, 35: 5, 110: 5, 91: 7, 114: 5, 97: 5, 31: 3, 13: 5, 38: 6, 26: 5, 124: 3, 98: 4, 54: 4, 127: 5, 8: 3, 96: 5, 64: 4, 30: 6, 61: 7, 55: 4, 27: 4, 15: 5, 52: 2, 129: 5, 115: 5, 84: 4, 76: 6, 87: 5, 131: 7, 102: 5, 113: 7, 99: 4, 36: 5, 24: 4, 53: 3, 72: 6} {392: 1, 1: 10, 4: 4, 9: 5, 10: 5, 15: 5, 24: 4, 25: 6, 26: 6, 27: 5, 39: 6, 43: 5, 49: 8, 50: 7, 58: 7, 59: 4, 64: 5, 69: 4, 81: 7, 82: 6, 86: 5, 96: 6, 97: 5, 100: 9, 108: 5, 109: 6, 110: 6, 111: 4, 114: 5, 115: 6, 116: 5, 118: 7, 119: 6, 120: 5, 121: 5, 122: 6, 123: 5, 124: 5, 128: 6, 129: 6, 130: 7, 132: 4, 136: 4, 145: 4, 147: 6, 151: 6, 152: 6, 154: 5, 156: 4, 161: 3, 162: 4, 165: 5, 168: 6, 169: 5, 172: 5, 180: 6, 184: 5, 187: 7, 188: 6, 191: 5, 194: 4, 202: 5, 203: 6, 206: 4, 207: 5, 215: 2, 217: 5, 218: 9, 220: 3, 221: 3, 222: 6, 224: 5, 227: 7, 229: 5, 234: 7, 235: 4, 241: 4, 242: 4, 243: 4, 244: 6, 245: 4, 248: 6, 250: 6, 258: 12, 262: 6, 263: 7, 264: 3, 267: 5, 270: 5, 272: 5, 273: 5, 287: 5, 289: 5, 291: 7, 299: 7, 300: 5, 304: 5, 309: 4, 314: 4, 315: 5, 320: 5, 323: 4, 327: 6, 328: 3, 329: 4, 330: 11, 334: 4, 335: 5, 341: 7, 342: 8, 347: 7, 348: 7, 350: 7, 351: 7, 352: 5, 353: 5, 354: 4, 358: 5, 365: 5, 366: 4, 369: 3, 371: 9, 372: 7, 376: 4, 384: 7, 385: 6, 386: 5, 387: 5, 396: 8, 397: 8, 398: 7, 402: 5} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 124 "When a PE receives a packet from a CE, on a given AC with DetNet service, it MUST first check via Stream Identification (see Clause 6. of IEEE8021CB and IEEEP8021CBdb) whether the packet belongs to a configured TSN Stream (i.e., App-flow from DetNet perspective). If no Stream ID is matched and no other (VPN) service is configured for the AC then packet MUST be dropped. If there is a matching TSN Stream then the Stream-ID specific TSN functions MUST be executed (e.g., ingress policing, header field manipulation in case of active Stream Identification, FRER, etc.). Source MAC lookup MAY also be used for local MAC address learning." TSN related documents are updated as follows : draft - ietf - detnet - ip - over - tsn AND draft - ietf - detnet - mpls - over - tsn type changed to informational overview shortened changing TSN related conformance language to informative text stating that mappings between DetNet and TSN management and control planes are out of scope of the document updating references draft - ietf - detnet - tsn - vpn - over - mpls overview shortened fixing 5.1 and 5.2 ( changing TSN related conformance language to informative text ) stating that mappings between DetNet and TSN management and control planes are out of scope of the document updating references 307e99a43b03cdb2231e27fbd7e9a248cf849106 307e99a43b03cdb2231e27fbd7e9a248cf849106 draft-ietf-detnet-tsn-vpn-over-mpls 81f9d94a65b8acfba1c176c8c58cddd74fa4535199be90f9ad2e00b2c539bb31 ['81f9d94a65b8acfba1c176c8c58cddd74fa4535199be90f9ad2e00b2c539bb31', '6c0ff9c59095578c17a7e77c18fdf9eec24ffd9bdeb449e9d192e2f7a34f9455'] A "when a pe receives a packet from a ce, on a given ac with detnet service, it must first check via stream identification (see clause 6. of ieee8021cb and ieeep8021cbdb) whether the packet belongs to a configured tsn stream (i.e., app-flow from detnet perspective). if no stream id is matched and no other (vpn) service is configured for the ac then packet must be dropped. if there is a matching tsn stream then the stream-id specific tsn functions must be executed (e.g., ingress policing, header field manipulation in case of active stream identification, frer, etc.). source mac lookup may also be used for local mac address learning." {130: 1, 98: 1, 6: 3, 79: 2, 90: 4, 51: 4, 62: 6, 85: 6, 68: 5, 35: 4, 110: 4, 91: 6, 114: 4, 97: 4, 31: 4, 13: 4, 67: 4, 38: 5, 26: 4, 124: 3, 54: 3, 127: 4, 8: 3, 96: 4, 64: 3, 30: 5, 61: 6, 55: 4, 27: 5, 15: 4, 52: 3, 129: 4, 115: 4, 84: 4, 76: 7, 87: 4, 131: 2, 102: 4, 113: 6, 99: 3, 36: 4, 24: 3, 53: 2, 72: 5} {168: 1, 206: 1, 1: 10, 4: 3, 9: 6, 10: 4, 15: 4, 24: 3, 25: 6, 26: 6, 27: 4, 39: 6, 43: 4, 49: 7, 50: 6, 58: 6, 59: 3, 64: 4, 69: 5, 81: 7, 82: 5, 86: 4, 96: 5, 97: 4, 100: 8, 108: 4, 109: 3, 110: 3, 111: 3, 114: 4, 115: 5, 116: 4, 118: 7, 119: 6, 120: 4, 121: 5, 122: 5, 123: 4, 124: 5, 128: 5, 129: 5, 130: 6, 132: 5, 136: 3, 145: 5, 147: 5, 151: 5, 152: 5, 154: 4, 156: 3, 161: 4, 162: 4, 165: 4, 169: 4, 172: 4, 180: 5, 184: 6, 187: 6, 188: 5, 191: 2, 194: 5, 202: 6, 203: 7, 215: 3, 217: 4, 218: 9, 220: 3, 221: 3, 222: 6, 224: 4, 227: 6, 229: 4, 234: 2, 235: 3, 241: 3, 242: 3, 243: 5, 244: 5, 245: 5, 248: 5, 250: 5, 258: 12, 262: 3, 263: 4, 264: 4, 267: 5, 270: 4, 272: 4, 273: 6, 287: 4, 289: 4, 291: 6, 299: 6, 300: 4, 304: 4, 309: 4, 314: 3, 315: 4, 320: 5, 323: 5, 327: 5, 328: 4, 329: 3, 330: 11, 334: 3, 335: 4, 341: 6, 342: 7, 347: 6, 348: 6, 350: 8, 351: 6, 352: 4, 353: 4, 354: 3, 358: 5, 365: 4, 366: 3, 369: 2, 371: 8, 372: 6, 376: 3, 384: 6, 385: 5, 386: 4, 387: 4, 392: 4, 393: 5, 396: 7, 397: 8, 398: 7, 402: 4} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 124 "When a PE receives a packet from a CE, on a given AC with DetNet service, it first checks via Stream Identification (see Clause 6. of IEEE8021CB and IEEEP8021CBdb) whether the packet belongs to a configured TSN Stream (i.e., App-flow from DetNet perspective). If no Stream ID is matched and no other (VPN) service is configured for the AC then packet MUST be dropped. If there is a matching TSN Stream then the Stream-ID specific TSN functions are executed (e.g., ingress policing, header field manipulation in case of active Stream Identification, FRER, etc.). Source MAC lookup may also be used for local MAC address learning." TSN related documents are updated as follows : draft - ietf - detnet - ip - over - tsn AND draft - ietf - detnet - mpls - over - tsn type changed to informational overview shortened changing TSN related conformance language to informative text stating that mappings between DetNet and TSN management and control planes are out of scope of the document updating references draft - ietf - detnet - tsn - vpn - over - mpls overview shortened fixing 5.1 and 5.2 ( changing TSN related conformance language to informative text ) stating that mappings between DetNet and TSN management and control planes are out of scope of the document updating references 307e99a43b03cdb2231e27fbd7e9a248cf849106 307e99a43b03cdb2231e27fbd7e9a248cf849106 draft-ietf-detnet-tsn-vpn-over-mpls 6c0ff9c59095578c17a7e77c18fdf9eec24ffd9bdeb449e9d192e2f7a34f9455 ['81f9d94a65b8acfba1c176c8c58cddd74fa4535199be90f9ad2e00b2c539bb31', '6c0ff9c59095578c17a7e77c18fdf9eec24ffd9bdeb449e9d192e2f7a34f9455'] B "when a pe receives a packet from a ce, on a given ac with detnet service, it first checks via stream identification (see clause 6. of ieee8021cb and ieeep8021cbdb) whether the packet belongs to a configured tsn stream (i.e., app-flow from detnet perspective). if no stream id is matched and no other (vpn) service is configured for the ac then packet must be dropped. if there is a matching tsn stream then the stream-id specific tsn functions are executed (e.g., ingress policing, header field manipulation in case of active stream identification, frer, etc.). source mac lookup may also be used for local mac address learning." {130: 1, 98: 1, 6: 3, 79: 2, 90: 4, 51: 4, 62: 6, 85: 6, 68: 5, 35: 4, 110: 4, 91: 6, 114: 4, 97: 4, 31: 4, 13: 4, 67: 4, 38: 5, 26: 4, 124: 3, 54: 3, 127: 4, 8: 3, 96: 4, 64: 3, 30: 5, 61: 6, 55: 4, 27: 5, 15: 4, 52: 3, 129: 4, 115: 4, 84: 4, 76: 7, 87: 4, 131: 2, 102: 4, 113: 6, 99: 3, 36: 4, 24: 3, 53: 2, 72: 5} {168: 1, 206: 1, 1: 10, 4: 3, 9: 6, 10: 4, 15: 4, 24: 3, 25: 6, 26: 6, 27: 4, 39: 6, 43: 4, 49: 7, 50: 6, 58: 6, 59: 3, 64: 4, 69: 5, 81: 7, 82: 5, 86: 4, 96: 5, 97: 4, 100: 8, 108: 4, 109: 3, 110: 3, 111: 3, 114: 4, 115: 5, 116: 4, 118: 7, 119: 6, 120: 4, 121: 5, 122: 5, 123: 4, 124: 5, 128: 5, 129: 5, 130: 6, 132: 5, 136: 3, 145: 5, 147: 5, 151: 5, 152: 5, 154: 4, 156: 3, 161: 4, 162: 4, 165: 4, 169: 4, 172: 4, 180: 5, 184: 6, 187: 6, 188: 5, 191: 2, 194: 5, 202: 6, 203: 7, 215: 3, 217: 4, 218: 9, 220: 3, 221: 3, 222: 6, 224: 4, 227: 6, 229: 4, 234: 2, 235: 3, 241: 3, 242: 3, 243: 5, 244: 5, 245: 5, 248: 5, 250: 5, 258: 12, 262: 3, 263: 4, 264: 4, 267: 5, 270: 4, 272: 4, 273: 6, 287: 4, 289: 4, 291: 6, 299: 6, 300: 4, 304: 4, 309: 4, 314: 3, 315: 4, 320: 5, 323: 5, 327: 5, 328: 4, 329: 3, 330: 11, 334: 3, 335: 4, 341: 6, 342: 7, 347: 6, 348: 6, 350: 8, 351: 6, 352: 4, 353: 4, 354: 3, 358: 5, 365: 4, 366: 3, 369: 2, 371: 8, 372: 6, 376: 3, 384: 6, 385: 5, 386: 4, 387: 4, 392: 4, 393: 5, 396: 7, 397: 8, 398: 7, 402: 4} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 124 "When a TSN entity of the PE receives a packet from the DetNet Service Proxy, it MUST first check via Stream Identification (see Clause 6. of IEEE8021CB and IEEEP8021CBdb) whether the packet belongs to a configured TSN Stream. If no Stream ID is matched then packet MUST be dropped. If there is a matching TSN Stream then the Stream ID specific TSN functions MUST be executed (e.g., header field manipulation in case of active Stream Identification, FRER, etc.). Source MAC lookup MAY also be used for local MAC address learning." TSN related documents are updated as follows : draft - ietf - detnet - ip - over - tsn AND draft - ietf - detnet - mpls - over - tsn type changed to informational overview shortened changing TSN related conformance language to informative text stating that mappings between DetNet and TSN management and control planes are out of scope of the document updating references draft - ietf - detnet - tsn - vpn - over - mpls overview shortened fixing 5.1 and 5.2 ( changing TSN related conformance language to informative text ) stating that mappings between DetNet and TSN management and control planes are out of scope of the document updating references 307e99a43b03cdb2231e27fbd7e9a248cf849106 307e99a43b03cdb2231e27fbd7e9a248cf849106 draft-ietf-detnet-tsn-vpn-over-mpls 47c3d01b384cf93dd5d888ecd50d922c6cb1b6edc5a8e6ce3cf67947d62d3937 ['47c3d01b384cf93dd5d888ecd50d922c6cb1b6edc5a8e6ce3cf67947d62d3937', '9c5dac93c7991e4bb94e295e72cca6126469fd0bfd0f4b72029341535a74c8c1', '702f27b5ac6792d33835d63983bde747072ac3fe361626fe44185d576bc05641', '7bc4af5f9333e0bb56e64cce4c0bf2278be3cb09764a3426a4b712a4ea5584ce'] A "when a tsn entity of the pe receives a packet from the detnet service proxy, it must first check via stream identification (see clause 6. of ieee8021cb and ieeep8021cbdb) whether the packet belongs to a configured tsn stream. if no stream id is matched then packet must be dropped. if there is a matching tsn stream then the stream id specific tsn functions must be executed (e.g., header field manipulation in case of active stream identification, frer, etc.). source mac lookup may also be used for local mac address learning." {131: 1, 98: 1, 79: 1, 6: 4, 90: 5, 51: 5, 130: 2, 62: 7, 85: 7, 68: 6, 35: 5, 110: 5, 91: 7, 114: 5, 97: 5, 31: 5, 13: 5, 67: 5, 38: 6, 26: 5, 54: 4, 127: 5, 8: 4, 96: 5, 64: 4, 30: 6, 61: 7, 55: 5, 27: 6, 15: 5, 52: 4, 129: 5, 115: 5, 84: 5, 76: 8, 124: 3, 87: 5, 102: 5, 113: 7, 99: 4, 36: 5, 24: 4, 53: 3, 72: 6} {263: 1, 110: 1, 191: 1, 1: 11, 4: 4, 9: 7, 10: 5, 15: 5, 24: 4, 25: 7, 26: 7, 27: 5, 39: 7, 43: 5, 49: 8, 50: 7, 58: 7, 59: 4, 64: 5, 69: 6, 81: 8, 82: 6, 86: 5, 96: 6, 97: 5, 100: 9, 108: 5, 111: 4, 114: 5, 115: 6, 116: 5, 118: 8, 119: 7, 120: 5, 121: 6, 122: 6, 123: 5, 124: 6, 128: 6, 129: 6, 130: 7, 132: 6, 136: 4, 145: 6, 147: 6, 151: 6, 152: 6, 154: 5, 156: 4, 161: 5, 162: 5, 165: 5, 168: 4, 169: 5, 172: 5, 180: 6, 184: 7, 187: 7, 188: 6, 194: 6, 202: 7, 203: 8, 206: 2, 207: 3, 215: 4, 217: 5, 218: 10, 220: 4, 221: 4, 222: 7, 224: 5, 227: 7, 229: 5, 234: 5, 235: 4, 241: 4, 242: 4, 243: 6, 244: 6, 245: 6, 248: 6, 250: 6, 258: 13, 262: 2, 264: 5, 267: 6, 270: 5, 272: 5, 273: 7, 287: 5, 289: 5, 291: 7, 299: 7, 300: 5, 304: 5, 309: 5, 314: 4, 315: 5, 320: 6, 323: 6, 327: 6, 328: 5, 329: 4, 330: 12, 334: 4, 335: 5, 341: 7, 342: 8, 347: 7, 348: 7, 350: 9, 351: 7, 352: 5, 353: 5, 354: 4, 358: 6, 365: 5, 366: 4, 369: 3, 371: 9, 372: 7, 376: 4, 384: 7, 385: 6, 386: 5, 387: 5, 392: 5, 393: 6, 396: 8, 397: 9, 398: 8, 402: 5} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 124 "If the PE decides to forward the packet, the packet MUST be forwarded according to the TSN Stream specific configuration to connected CE(s). If there are no TSN Stream specific forwarding configurations the PE MUST flood the packet to locally attached CE(s). If the administrative policy on the PE does not allow flooding the PE MUST drop the packet." TSN related documents are updated as follows : draft - ietf - detnet - ip - over - tsn AND draft - ietf - detnet - mpls - over - tsn type changed to informational overview shortened changing TSN related conformance language to informative text stating that mappings between DetNet and TSN management and control planes are out of scope of the document updating references draft - ietf - detnet - tsn - vpn - over - mpls overview shortened fixing 5.1 and 5.2 ( changing TSN related conformance language to informative text ) stating that mappings between DetNet and TSN management and control planes are out of scope of the document updating references 307e99a43b03cdb2231e27fbd7e9a248cf849106 307e99a43b03cdb2231e27fbd7e9a248cf849106 draft-ietf-detnet-tsn-vpn-over-mpls 7bc4af5f9333e0bb56e64cce4c0bf2278be3cb09764a3426a4b712a4ea5584ce ['47c3d01b384cf93dd5d888ecd50d922c6cb1b6edc5a8e6ce3cf67947d62d3937', '9c5dac93c7991e4bb94e295e72cca6126469fd0bfd0f4b72029341535a74c8c1', '702f27b5ac6792d33835d63983bde747072ac3fe361626fe44185d576bc05641', '7bc4af5f9333e0bb56e64cce4c0bf2278be3cb09764a3426a4b712a4ea5584ce'] A "if the pe decides to forward the packet, the packet must be forwarded according to the tsn stream specific configuration to connected ce(s). if there are no tsn stream specific forwarding configurations the pe must flood the packet to locally attached ce(s). if the administrative policy on the pe does not allow flooding the pe must drop the packet." {131: 1, 98: 1, 79: 1, 6: 4, 90: 5, 51: 5, 130: 2, 62: 7, 85: 7, 68: 6, 35: 5, 110: 5, 91: 7, 114: 5, 97: 5, 31: 5, 13: 5, 67: 5, 38: 6, 26: 5, 54: 4, 127: 5, 8: 4, 96: 5, 64: 4, 30: 6, 61: 7, 55: 5, 27: 6, 15: 5, 52: 4, 129: 5, 115: 5, 84: 5, 76: 8, 124: 3, 87: 5, 102: 5, 113: 7, 99: 4, 36: 5, 24: 4, 53: 3, 72: 6} {263: 1, 110: 1, 191: 1, 1: 11, 4: 4, 9: 7, 10: 5, 15: 5, 24: 4, 25: 7, 26: 7, 27: 5, 39: 7, 43: 5, 49: 8, 50: 7, 58: 7, 59: 4, 64: 5, 69: 6, 81: 8, 82: 6, 86: 5, 96: 6, 97: 5, 100: 9, 108: 5, 111: 4, 114: 5, 115: 6, 116: 5, 118: 8, 119: 7, 120: 5, 121: 6, 122: 6, 123: 5, 124: 6, 128: 6, 129: 6, 130: 7, 132: 6, 136: 4, 145: 6, 147: 6, 151: 6, 152: 6, 154: 5, 156: 4, 161: 5, 162: 5, 165: 5, 168: 4, 169: 5, 172: 5, 180: 6, 184: 7, 187: 7, 188: 6, 194: 6, 202: 7, 203: 8, 206: 2, 207: 3, 215: 4, 217: 5, 218: 10, 220: 4, 221: 4, 222: 7, 224: 5, 227: 7, 229: 5, 234: 5, 235: 4, 241: 4, 242: 4, 243: 6, 244: 6, 245: 6, 248: 6, 250: 6, 258: 13, 262: 2, 264: 5, 267: 6, 270: 5, 272: 5, 273: 7, 287: 5, 289: 5, 291: 7, 299: 7, 300: 5, 304: 5, 309: 5, 314: 4, 315: 5, 320: 6, 323: 6, 327: 6, 328: 5, 329: 4, 330: 12, 334: 4, 335: 5, 341: 7, 342: 8, 347: 7, 348: 7, 350: 9, 351: 7, 352: 5, 353: 5, 354: 4, 358: 6, 365: 5, 366: 4, 369: 3, 371: 9, 372: 7, 376: 4, 384: 7, 385: 6, 386: 5, 387: 5, 392: 5, 393: 6, 396: 8, 397: 9, 398: 8, 402: 5} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 124 "When a TSN entity of the PE receives a packet from the DetNet Service Proxy, it first checks via Stream Identification (see Clause 6. of IEEE8021CB and IEEEP8021CBdb) whether the packet belongs to a configured TSN Stream. If no Stream ID is matched then packet is dropped. If there is a matching TSN Stream then the Stream ID specific TSN functions are executed (e.g., header field manipulation in case of active Stream Identification, FRER, etc.). Source MAC lookup may also be used for local MAC address learning." TSN related documents are updated as follows : draft - ietf - detnet - ip - over - tsn AND draft - ietf - detnet - mpls - over - tsn type changed to informational overview shortened changing TSN related conformance language to informative text stating that mappings between DetNet and TSN management and control planes are out of scope of the document updating references draft - ietf - detnet - tsn - vpn - over - mpls overview shortened fixing 5.1 and 5.2 ( changing TSN related conformance language to informative text ) stating that mappings between DetNet and TSN management and control planes are out of scope of the document updating references 307e99a43b03cdb2231e27fbd7e9a248cf849106 307e99a43b03cdb2231e27fbd7e9a248cf849106 draft-ietf-detnet-tsn-vpn-over-mpls 702f27b5ac6792d33835d63983bde747072ac3fe361626fe44185d576bc05641 ['47c3d01b384cf93dd5d888ecd50d922c6cb1b6edc5a8e6ce3cf67947d62d3937', '9c5dac93c7991e4bb94e295e72cca6126469fd0bfd0f4b72029341535a74c8c1', '702f27b5ac6792d33835d63983bde747072ac3fe361626fe44185d576bc05641', '7bc4af5f9333e0bb56e64cce4c0bf2278be3cb09764a3426a4b712a4ea5584ce'] B "when a tsn entity of the pe receives a packet from the detnet service proxy, it first checks via stream identification (see clause 6. of ieee8021cb and ieeep8021cbdb) whether the packet belongs to a configured tsn stream. if no stream id is matched then packet is dropped. if there is a matching tsn stream then the stream id specific tsn functions are executed (e.g., header field manipulation in case of active stream identification, frer, etc.). source mac lookup may also be used for local mac address learning." {131: 1, 98: 1, 79: 1, 6: 4, 90: 5, 51: 5, 130: 2, 62: 7, 85: 7, 68: 6, 35: 5, 110: 5, 91: 7, 114: 5, 97: 5, 31: 5, 13: 5, 67: 5, 38: 6, 26: 5, 54: 4, 127: 5, 8: 4, 96: 5, 64: 4, 30: 6, 61: 7, 55: 5, 27: 6, 15: 5, 52: 4, 129: 5, 115: 5, 84: 5, 76: 8, 124: 3, 87: 5, 102: 5, 113: 7, 99: 4, 36: 5, 24: 4, 53: 3, 72: 6} {263: 1, 110: 1, 191: 1, 1: 11, 4: 4, 9: 7, 10: 5, 15: 5, 24: 4, 25: 7, 26: 7, 27: 5, 39: 7, 43: 5, 49: 8, 50: 7, 58: 7, 59: 4, 64: 5, 69: 6, 81: 8, 82: 6, 86: 5, 96: 6, 97: 5, 100: 9, 108: 5, 111: 4, 114: 5, 115: 6, 116: 5, 118: 8, 119: 7, 120: 5, 121: 6, 122: 6, 123: 5, 124: 6, 128: 6, 129: 6, 130: 7, 132: 6, 136: 4, 145: 6, 147: 6, 151: 6, 152: 6, 154: 5, 156: 4, 161: 5, 162: 5, 165: 5, 168: 4, 169: 5, 172: 5, 180: 6, 184: 7, 187: 7, 188: 6, 194: 6, 202: 7, 203: 8, 206: 2, 207: 3, 215: 4, 217: 5, 218: 10, 220: 4, 221: 4, 222: 7, 224: 5, 227: 7, 229: 5, 234: 5, 235: 4, 241: 4, 242: 4, 243: 6, 244: 6, 245: 6, 248: 6, 250: 6, 258: 13, 262: 2, 264: 5, 267: 6, 270: 5, 272: 5, 273: 7, 287: 5, 289: 5, 291: 7, 299: 7, 300: 5, 304: 5, 309: 5, 314: 4, 315: 5, 320: 6, 323: 6, 327: 6, 328: 5, 329: 4, 330: 12, 334: 4, 335: 5, 341: 7, 342: 8, 347: 7, 348: 7, 350: 9, 351: 7, 352: 5, 353: 5, 354: 4, 358: 6, 365: 5, 366: 4, 369: 3, 371: 9, 372: 7, 376: 4, 384: 7, 385: 6, 386: 5, 387: 5, 392: 5, 393: 6, 396: 8, 397: 9, 398: 8, 402: 5} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 124 "If the PE decides to forward the packet, the packet is forwarded according to the TSN Stream specific configuration to connected CE(s). If there are no TSN Stream specific forwarding configurations the PE floods the packet to locally attached CE(s). If the administrative policy on the PE does not allow flooding the PE drops the packet." TSN related documents are updated as follows : draft - ietf - detnet - ip - over - tsn AND draft - ietf - detnet - mpls - over - tsn type changed to informational overview shortened changing TSN related conformance language to informative text stating that mappings between DetNet and TSN management and control planes are out of scope of the document updating references draft - ietf - detnet - tsn - vpn - over - mpls overview shortened fixing 5.1 and 5.2 ( changing TSN related conformance language to informative text ) stating that mappings between DetNet and TSN management and control planes are out of scope of the document updating references 307e99a43b03cdb2231e27fbd7e9a248cf849106 307e99a43b03cdb2231e27fbd7e9a248cf849106 draft-ietf-detnet-tsn-vpn-over-mpls 9c5dac93c7991e4bb94e295e72cca6126469fd0bfd0f4b72029341535a74c8c1 ['47c3d01b384cf93dd5d888ecd50d922c6cb1b6edc5a8e6ce3cf67947d62d3937', '9c5dac93c7991e4bb94e295e72cca6126469fd0bfd0f4b72029341535a74c8c1', '702f27b5ac6792d33835d63983bde747072ac3fe361626fe44185d576bc05641', '7bc4af5f9333e0bb56e64cce4c0bf2278be3cb09764a3426a4b712a4ea5584ce'] B "if the pe decides to forward the packet, the packet is forwarded according to the tsn stream specific configuration to connected ce(s). if there are no tsn stream specific forwarding configurations the pe floods the packet to locally attached ce(s). if the administrative policy on the pe does not allow flooding the pe drops the packet." {131: 1, 98: 1, 79: 1, 6: 4, 90: 5, 51: 5, 130: 2, 62: 7, 85: 7, 68: 6, 35: 5, 110: 5, 91: 7, 114: 5, 97: 5, 31: 5, 13: 5, 67: 5, 38: 6, 26: 5, 54: 4, 127: 5, 8: 4, 96: 5, 64: 4, 30: 6, 61: 7, 55: 5, 27: 6, 15: 5, 52: 4, 129: 5, 115: 5, 84: 5, 76: 8, 124: 3, 87: 5, 102: 5, 113: 7, 99: 4, 36: 5, 24: 4, 53: 3, 72: 6} {263: 1, 110: 1, 191: 1, 1: 11, 4: 4, 9: 7, 10: 5, 15: 5, 24: 4, 25: 7, 26: 7, 27: 5, 39: 7, 43: 5, 49: 8, 50: 7, 58: 7, 59: 4, 64: 5, 69: 6, 81: 8, 82: 6, 86: 5, 96: 6, 97: 5, 100: 9, 108: 5, 111: 4, 114: 5, 115: 6, 116: 5, 118: 8, 119: 7, 120: 5, 121: 6, 122: 6, 123: 5, 124: 6, 128: 6, 129: 6, 130: 7, 132: 6, 136: 4, 145: 6, 147: 6, 151: 6, 152: 6, 154: 5, 156: 4, 161: 5, 162: 5, 165: 5, 168: 4, 169: 5, 172: 5, 180: 6, 184: 7, 187: 7, 188: 6, 194: 6, 202: 7, 203: 8, 206: 2, 207: 3, 215: 4, 217: 5, 218: 10, 220: 4, 221: 4, 222: 7, 224: 5, 227: 7, 229: 5, 234: 5, 235: 4, 241: 4, 242: 4, 243: 6, 244: 6, 245: 6, 248: 6, 250: 6, 258: 13, 262: 2, 264: 5, 267: 6, 270: 5, 272: 5, 273: 7, 287: 5, 289: 5, 291: 7, 299: 7, 300: 5, 304: 5, 309: 5, 314: 4, 315: 5, 320: 6, 323: 6, 327: 6, 328: 5, 329: 4, 330: 12, 334: 4, 335: 5, 341: 7, 342: 8, 347: 7, 348: 7, 350: 9, 351: 7, 352: 5, 353: 5, 354: 4, 358: 6, 365: 5, 366: 4, 369: 3, 371: 9, 372: 7, 376: 4, 384: 7, 385: 6, 386: 5, 387: 5, 392: 5, 393: 6, 396: 8, 397: 9, 398: 8, 402: 5} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 124 "App-Flow identification information to map received TSN Stream(s) to the DetNet flow. Parameters fo TSN stream identification are defined in IEEE8021CB and IEEEP8021CBdb." TSN related documents are updated as follows : draft - ietf - detnet - ip - over - tsn AND draft - ietf - detnet - mpls - over - tsn type changed to informational overview shortened changing TSN related conformance language to informative text stating that mappings between DetNet and TSN management and control planes are out of scope of the document updating references draft - ietf - detnet - tsn - vpn - over - mpls overview shortened fixing 5.1 and 5.2 ( changing TSN related conformance language to informative text ) stating that mappings between DetNet and TSN management and control planes are out of scope of the document updating references 307e99a43b03cdb2231e27fbd7e9a248cf849106 307e99a43b03cdb2231e27fbd7e9a248cf849106 draft-ietf-detnet-tsn-vpn-over-mpls 3136da2be70c53854924ac5e0394d8a0d0ac493519c1873f21b202ac3ed0e55e ['3136da2be70c53854924ac5e0394d8a0d0ac493519c1873f21b202ac3ed0e55e', 'aa836cb71874d3e3b4fc75fc49822f87eab9ddc7c164267b5d4fd9e0bc8ab412'] A "app-flow identification information to map received tsn stream(s) to the detnet flow. parameters fo tsn stream identification are defined in ieee8021cb and ieeep8021cbdb." {98: 1, 97: 2, 130: 3, 96: 2, 127: 3} {13: 1, 12: 2, 208: 3, 403: 2, 153: 3} {12, 13, 208, 403, 153, 63} 124 "App-Flow identification information to map received TSN Stream(s) to the DetNet flow. Parameters of TSN stream identification are defined in IEEE8021CB and IEEEP8021CBdb." TSN related documents are updated as follows : draft - ietf - detnet - ip - over - tsn AND draft - ietf - detnet - mpls - over - tsn type changed to informational overview shortened changing TSN related conformance language to informative text stating that mappings between DetNet and TSN management and control planes are out of scope of the document updating references draft - ietf - detnet - tsn - vpn - over - mpls overview shortened fixing 5.1 and 5.2 ( changing TSN related conformance language to informative text ) stating that mappings between DetNet and TSN management and control planes are out of scope of the document updating references 307e99a43b03cdb2231e27fbd7e9a248cf849106 307e99a43b03cdb2231e27fbd7e9a248cf849106 draft-ietf-detnet-tsn-vpn-over-mpls aa836cb71874d3e3b4fc75fc49822f87eab9ddc7c164267b5d4fd9e0bc8ab412 ['3136da2be70c53854924ac5e0394d8a0d0ac493519c1873f21b202ac3ed0e55e', 'aa836cb71874d3e3b4fc75fc49822f87eab9ddc7c164267b5d4fd9e0bc8ab412'] B "app-flow identification information to map received tsn stream(s) to the detnet flow. parameters of tsn stream identification are defined in ieee8021cb and ieeep8021cbdb." {98: 1, 97: 2, 130: 3, 96: 2, 127: 3} {13: 1, 12: 2, 208: 3, 403: 2, 153: 3} {12, 13, 208, 403, 153, 63} 124 "This document specifies the Deterministic Networking IP data plane when operating over a TSN sub-network." TSN related documents are updated as follows : draft - ietf - detnet - ip - over - tsn AND draft - ietf - detnet - mpls - over - tsn type changed to informational overview shortened changing TSN related conformance language to informative text stating that mappings between DetNet and TSN management and control planes are out of scope of the document updating references draft - ietf - detnet - tsn - vpn - over - mpls overview shortened fixing 5.1 and 5.2 ( changing TSN related conformance language to informative text ) stating that mappings between DetNet and TSN management and control planes are out of scope of the document updating references 307e99a43b03cdb2231e27fbd7e9a248cf849106 307e99a43b03cdb2231e27fbd7e9a248cf849106 draft-ietf-detnet-ip-over-tsn ac4fad5ceade9e0da8c34db80976dcde72f39347c8a6bdc367ecb0fb2d711e70 ['15544b9740013c3851f7ed39a28c9585a15ce590eca8ebf10205fb3cd0607220', 'ac4fad5ceade9e0da8c34db80976dcde72f39347c8a6bdc367ecb0fb2d711e70'] A "this document specifies the deterministic networking ip data plane when operating over a tsn sub-network." {51: 1, 127: 2, 30: 2} {157: 1, 131: 2, 254: 2} {131, 157, 22, 254} 124 "This document specifies the Deterministic Networking IP data plane when operating over a TSN sub-network. This document does not define new procedures or processes. Whenever this document makes requirements statements or recommendations, these are taken from normative text in the referenced RFCs." TSN related documents are updated as follows : draft - ietf - detnet - ip - over - tsn AND draft - ietf - detnet - mpls - over - tsn type changed to informational overview shortened changing TSN related conformance language to informative text stating that mappings between DetNet and TSN management and control planes are out of scope of the document updating references draft - ietf - detnet - tsn - vpn - over - mpls overview shortened fixing 5.1 and 5.2 ( changing TSN related conformance language to informative text ) stating that mappings between DetNet and TSN management and control planes are out of scope of the document updating references 307e99a43b03cdb2231e27fbd7e9a248cf849106 307e99a43b03cdb2231e27fbd7e9a248cf849106 draft-ietf-detnet-ip-over-tsn 15544b9740013c3851f7ed39a28c9585a15ce590eca8ebf10205fb3cd0607220 ['15544b9740013c3851f7ed39a28c9585a15ce590eca8ebf10205fb3cd0607220', 'ac4fad5ceade9e0da8c34db80976dcde72f39347c8a6bdc367ecb0fb2d711e70'] B "this document specifies the deterministic networking ip data plane when operating over a tsn sub-network. this document does not define new procedures or processes. whenever this document makes requirements statements or recommendations, these are taken from normative text in the referenced rfcs." {51: 1, 127: 2, 30: 2} {157: 1, 131: 2, 254: 2} {131, 157, 22, 254} 124 "Congestion protection, latency control and the resource allocation (queuing, policing, shaping) are supported using the underlying link / sub-net specific mechanisms. Service protections (packet replication and packet elimination functions) are not provided at the DetNet layer end-to-end due the lack of a unified end-to-end sequencing information that would be available for intermediate nodes. However, such service protection can be provided on a per underlying L2 link and sub-network basis." TSN related documents are updated as follows : draft - ietf - detnet - ip - over - tsn AND draft - ietf - detnet - mpls - over - tsn type changed to informational overview shortened changing TSN related conformance language to informative text stating that mappings between DetNet and TSN management and control planes are out of scope of the document updating references draft - ietf - detnet - tsn - vpn - over - mpls overview shortened fixing 5.1 and 5.2 ( changing TSN related conformance language to informative text ) stating that mappings between DetNet and TSN management and control planes are out of scope of the document updating references 307e99a43b03cdb2231e27fbd7e9a248cf849106 307e99a43b03cdb2231e27fbd7e9a248cf849106 draft-ietf-detnet-ip-over-tsn da15d4880e4b0ffd91ed06bbbd91b82967b5072475783d35d73a4d9a24ccdf38 ['da15d4880e4b0ffd91ed06bbbd91b82967b5072475783d35d73a4d9a24ccdf38', '2b58030ee3aece454f82806bc1415f1bd2ddb59dfa489859800ccdde2a0ae710', 'f5904a73b761c7f93647e670078f5880a077300f912bd26ad88b6235d38db053', 'f5a155e6a4a7b93b7717d43f4cc13100706c13d2e93677f9cb041aa9ed94f77d', 'ca8ff5cafc8cf8fe21d5c32033e7eaf2d8d483ee895512f4cc26334b0eb890b8', '2327f197493c9aeb867cb401b66068347b7d28ccc18c7b3206bc515002bbab69', '3979b4c486d79010edeff549c31179637e18383b5ce570061eea126ba99d5a97'] A "congestion protection, latency control and the resource allocation (queuing, policing, shaping) are supported using the underlying link / sub-net specific mechanisms. service protections (packet replication and packet elimination functions) are not provided at the detnet layer end-to-end due the lack of a unified end-to-end sequencing information that would be available for intermediate nodes. however, such service protection can be provided on a per underlying l2 link and sub-network basis." {51: 1, 96: 1, 6: 5, 79: 5, 90: 5, 130: 2, 62: 2, 85: 3, 68: 5, 35: 6, 110: 5, 91: 7, 114: 5, 97: 3, 31: 6, 13: 2, 67: 5, 38: 6, 26: 4, 124: 6, 98: 5, 54: 5, 127: 6, 8: 5, 64: 5, 30: 5, 61: 7, 55: 4, 27: 6, 15: 5, 52: 3, 129: 6, 115: 5, 84: 5, 76: 8, 87: 5, 131: 8, 102: 3, 113: 7, 99: 5, 36: 5, 24: 4, 53: 4, 72: 6} {82: 1, 348: 1, 1: 10, 4: 5, 9: 7, 10: 6, 15: 4, 24: 5, 25: 2, 26: 3, 27: 4, 39: 6, 43: 6, 49: 8, 50: 7, 58: 7, 59: 5, 64: 4, 69: 6, 81: 3, 86: 5, 96: 6, 97: 5, 100: 4, 108: 6, 109: 7, 110: 7, 111: 5, 114: 6, 115: 7, 116: 3, 118: 5, 119: 4, 120: 6, 121: 5, 122: 3, 123: 2, 124: 5, 128: 6, 129: 5, 130: 7, 132: 6, 136: 5, 145: 6, 147: 6, 151: 6, 152: 6, 154: 6, 156: 3, 161: 5, 162: 4, 165: 6, 168: 7, 169: 5, 172: 5, 180: 6, 184: 7, 187: 8, 188: 7, 191: 6, 194: 6, 202: 7, 203: 8, 206: 5, 207: 6, 215: 5, 217: 6, 218: 9, 220: 5, 221: 5, 222: 6, 224: 6, 227: 2, 229: 5, 234: 8, 235: 5, 241: 5, 242: 5, 243: 6, 244: 6, 245: 6, 248: 6, 250: 5, 258: 12, 262: 7, 263: 8, 264: 6, 267: 5, 270: 4, 272: 5, 273: 7, 287: 6, 289: 5, 291: 7, 299: 2, 300: 4, 304: 4, 309: 5, 314: 5, 315: 5, 320: 3, 323: 6, 327: 7, 328: 6, 329: 5, 330: 11, 334: 5, 335: 3, 341: 2, 342: 3, 350: 9, 351: 7, 352: 5, 353: 5, 354: 4, 358: 5, 365: 5, 366: 5, 369: 4, 371: 4, 372: 7, 376: 5, 384: 7, 385: 6, 386: 6, 387: 4, 392: 6, 393: 7, 396: 3, 397: 8, 398: 7, 402: 5} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 124 "fig_ip_detnet_part illustrates an extract of a DetNet enabled IP network, that uses a TSN sub-network as interconnection between two DetNet Nodes. In this figure, an Edge Node sits at the boundary of the DetNet domain and provide DetNet service proxies for the end applications by initiating and terminating DetNet service for the application's IP flows. Node and interface resources are allocated to ensure DetNet service requirements. Dotted lines around the Service components of the Edge and Relay Nodes indicate that they are DetNet service aware but do not perform any DetNet service sub-layer function, e.g., PREOF (Packet Replication, Elimination, and Ordering Functions). In this example the Edge Node and the Transit Node are interconnected by a TSN sub-network, being the primary focus of this document." TSN related documents are updated as follows : draft - ietf - detnet - ip - over - tsn AND draft - ietf - detnet - mpls - over - tsn type changed to informational overview shortened changing TSN related conformance language to informative text stating that mappings between DetNet and TSN management and control planes are out of scope of the document updating references draft - ietf - detnet - tsn - vpn - over - mpls overview shortened fixing 5.1 and 5.2 ( changing TSN related conformance language to informative text ) stating that mappings between DetNet and TSN management and control planes are out of scope of the document updating references 307e99a43b03cdb2231e27fbd7e9a248cf849106 307e99a43b03cdb2231e27fbd7e9a248cf849106 draft-ietf-detnet-ip-over-tsn 2327f197493c9aeb867cb401b66068347b7d28ccc18c7b3206bc515002bbab69 ['da15d4880e4b0ffd91ed06bbbd91b82967b5072475783d35d73a4d9a24ccdf38', '2b58030ee3aece454f82806bc1415f1bd2ddb59dfa489859800ccdde2a0ae710', 'f5904a73b761c7f93647e670078f5880a077300f912bd26ad88b6235d38db053', 'f5a155e6a4a7b93b7717d43f4cc13100706c13d2e93677f9cb041aa9ed94f77d', 'ca8ff5cafc8cf8fe21d5c32033e7eaf2d8d483ee895512f4cc26334b0eb890b8', '2327f197493c9aeb867cb401b66068347b7d28ccc18c7b3206bc515002bbab69', '3979b4c486d79010edeff549c31179637e18383b5ce570061eea126ba99d5a97'] A "fig_ip_detnet_part illustrates an extract of a detnet enabled ip network, that uses a tsn sub-network as interconnection between two detnet nodes. in this figure, an edge node sits at the boundary of the detnet domain and provide detnet service proxies for the end applications by initiating and terminating detnet service for the application's ip flows. node and interface resources are allocated to ensure detnet service requirements. dotted lines around the service components of the edge and relay nodes indicate that they are detnet service aware but do not perform any detnet service sub-layer function, e.g., preof (packet replication, elimination, and ordering functions). in this example the edge node and the transit node are interconnected by a tsn sub-network, being the primary focus of this document." {51: 1, 96: 1, 6: 5, 79: 5, 90: 5, 130: 2, 62: 2, 85: 3, 68: 5, 35: 6, 110: 5, 91: 7, 114: 5, 97: 3, 31: 6, 13: 2, 67: 5, 38: 6, 26: 4, 124: 6, 98: 5, 54: 5, 127: 6, 8: 5, 64: 5, 30: 5, 61: 7, 55: 4, 27: 6, 15: 5, 52: 3, 129: 6, 115: 5, 84: 5, 76: 8, 87: 5, 131: 8, 102: 3, 113: 7, 99: 5, 36: 5, 24: 4, 53: 4, 72: 6} {82: 1, 348: 1, 1: 10, 4: 5, 9: 7, 10: 6, 15: 4, 24: 5, 25: 2, 26: 3, 27: 4, 39: 6, 43: 6, 49: 8, 50: 7, 58: 7, 59: 5, 64: 4, 69: 6, 81: 3, 86: 5, 96: 6, 97: 5, 100: 4, 108: 6, 109: 7, 110: 7, 111: 5, 114: 6, 115: 7, 116: 3, 118: 5, 119: 4, 120: 6, 121: 5, 122: 3, 123: 2, 124: 5, 128: 6, 129: 5, 130: 7, 132: 6, 136: 5, 145: 6, 147: 6, 151: 6, 152: 6, 154: 6, 156: 3, 161: 5, 162: 4, 165: 6, 168: 7, 169: 5, 172: 5, 180: 6, 184: 7, 187: 8, 188: 7, 191: 6, 194: 6, 202: 7, 203: 8, 206: 5, 207: 6, 215: 5, 217: 6, 218: 9, 220: 5, 221: 5, 222: 6, 224: 6, 227: 2, 229: 5, 234: 8, 235: 5, 241: 5, 242: 5, 243: 6, 244: 6, 245: 6, 248: 6, 250: 5, 258: 12, 262: 7, 263: 8, 264: 6, 267: 5, 270: 4, 272: 5, 273: 7, 287: 6, 289: 5, 291: 7, 299: 2, 300: 4, 304: 4, 309: 5, 314: 5, 315: 5, 320: 3, 323: 6, 327: 7, 328: 6, 329: 5, 330: 11, 334: 5, 335: 3, 341: 2, 342: 3, 350: 9, 351: 7, 352: 5, 353: 5, 354: 4, 358: 5, 365: 5, 366: 5, 369: 4, 371: 4, 372: 7, 376: 5, 384: 7, 385: 6, 386: 6, 387: 4, 392: 6, 393: 7, 396: 3, 397: 8, 398: 7, 402: 5} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 124 "DetNet routers ensure that DetNet service requirements are met per hop by allocating local resources, both receive and transmit, and by mapping the service requirements of each flow to appropriate sub- network mechanisms. Such mappings are sub-network technology specific. The mapping of DetNet IP flows to TSN streams and TSN protection mechanisms are covered in mapping-tsn." TSN related documents are updated as follows : draft - ietf - detnet - ip - over - tsn AND draft - ietf - detnet - mpls - over - tsn type changed to informational overview shortened changing TSN related conformance language to informative text stating that mappings between DetNet and TSN management and control planes are out of scope of the document updating references draft - ietf - detnet - tsn - vpn - over - mpls overview shortened fixing 5.1 and 5.2 ( changing TSN related conformance language to informative text ) stating that mappings between DetNet and TSN management and control planes are out of scope of the document updating references 307e99a43b03cdb2231e27fbd7e9a248cf849106 307e99a43b03cdb2231e27fbd7e9a248cf849106 draft-ietf-detnet-ip-over-tsn 2b58030ee3aece454f82806bc1415f1bd2ddb59dfa489859800ccdde2a0ae710 ['da15d4880e4b0ffd91ed06bbbd91b82967b5072475783d35d73a4d9a24ccdf38', '2b58030ee3aece454f82806bc1415f1bd2ddb59dfa489859800ccdde2a0ae710', 'f5904a73b761c7f93647e670078f5880a077300f912bd26ad88b6235d38db053', 'f5a155e6a4a7b93b7717d43f4cc13100706c13d2e93677f9cb041aa9ed94f77d', 'ca8ff5cafc8cf8fe21d5c32033e7eaf2d8d483ee895512f4cc26334b0eb890b8', '2327f197493c9aeb867cb401b66068347b7d28ccc18c7b3206bc515002bbab69', '3979b4c486d79010edeff549c31179637e18383b5ce570061eea126ba99d5a97'] A "detnet routers ensure that detnet service requirements are met per hop by allocating local resources, both receive and transmit, and by mapping the service requirements of each flow to appropriate sub- network mechanisms. such mappings are sub-network technology specific. the mapping of detnet ip flows to tsn streams and tsn protection mechanisms are covered in mapping-tsn." {51: 1, 96: 1, 6: 5, 79: 5, 90: 5, 130: 2, 62: 2, 85: 3, 68: 5, 35: 6, 110: 5, 91: 7, 114: 5, 97: 3, 31: 6, 13: 2, 67: 5, 38: 6, 26: 4, 124: 6, 98: 5, 54: 5, 127: 6, 8: 5, 64: 5, 30: 5, 61: 7, 55: 4, 27: 6, 15: 5, 52: 3, 129: 6, 115: 5, 84: 5, 76: 8, 87: 5, 131: 8, 102: 3, 113: 7, 99: 5, 36: 5, 24: 4, 53: 4, 72: 6} {82: 1, 348: 1, 1: 10, 4: 5, 9: 7, 10: 6, 15: 4, 24: 5, 25: 2, 26: 3, 27: 4, 39: 6, 43: 6, 49: 8, 50: 7, 58: 7, 59: 5, 64: 4, 69: 6, 81: 3, 86: 5, 96: 6, 97: 5, 100: 4, 108: 6, 109: 7, 110: 7, 111: 5, 114: 6, 115: 7, 116: 3, 118: 5, 119: 4, 120: 6, 121: 5, 122: 3, 123: 2, 124: 5, 128: 6, 129: 5, 130: 7, 132: 6, 136: 5, 145: 6, 147: 6, 151: 6, 152: 6, 154: 6, 156: 3, 161: 5, 162: 4, 165: 6, 168: 7, 169: 5, 172: 5, 180: 6, 184: 7, 187: 8, 188: 7, 191: 6, 194: 6, 202: 7, 203: 8, 206: 5, 207: 6, 215: 5, 217: 6, 218: 9, 220: 5, 221: 5, 222: 6, 224: 6, 227: 2, 229: 5, 234: 8, 235: 5, 241: 5, 242: 5, 243: 6, 244: 6, 245: 6, 248: 6, 250: 5, 258: 12, 262: 7, 263: 8, 264: 6, 267: 5, 270: 4, 272: 5, 273: 7, 287: 6, 289: 5, 291: 7, 299: 2, 300: 4, 304: 4, 309: 5, 314: 5, 315: 5, 320: 3, 323: 6, 327: 7, 328: 6, 329: 5, 330: 11, 334: 5, 335: 3, 341: 2, 342: 3, 350: 9, 351: 7, 352: 5, 353: 5, 354: 4, 358: 5, 365: 5, 366: 5, 369: 4, 371: 4, 372: 7, 376: 5, 384: 7, 385: 6, 386: 6, 387: 4, 392: 6, 393: 7, 396: 3, 397: 8, 398: 7, 402: 5} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 124 "This section covers how DetNet IP flows operate over an IEEE 802.1 TSN sub-network. fig_ip_detnet_to_tsn illustrates such a scenario, where two IP (DetNet) nodes are interconnected by a TSN sub-network. Node-1 is single homed and Node-2 is dual-homed to the TSN sub- network." TSN related documents are updated as follows : draft - ietf - detnet - ip - over - tsn AND draft - ietf - detnet - mpls - over - tsn type changed to informational overview shortened changing TSN related conformance language to informative text stating that mappings between DetNet and TSN management and control planes are out of scope of the document updating references draft - ietf - detnet - tsn - vpn - over - mpls overview shortened fixing 5.1 and 5.2 ( changing TSN related conformance language to informative text ) stating that mappings between DetNet and TSN management and control planes are out of scope of the document updating references 307e99a43b03cdb2231e27fbd7e9a248cf849106 307e99a43b03cdb2231e27fbd7e9a248cf849106 draft-ietf-detnet-ip-over-tsn ca8ff5cafc8cf8fe21d5c32033e7eaf2d8d483ee895512f4cc26334b0eb890b8 ['da15d4880e4b0ffd91ed06bbbd91b82967b5072475783d35d73a4d9a24ccdf38', '2b58030ee3aece454f82806bc1415f1bd2ddb59dfa489859800ccdde2a0ae710', 'f5904a73b761c7f93647e670078f5880a077300f912bd26ad88b6235d38db053', 'f5a155e6a4a7b93b7717d43f4cc13100706c13d2e93677f9cb041aa9ed94f77d', 'ca8ff5cafc8cf8fe21d5c32033e7eaf2d8d483ee895512f4cc26334b0eb890b8', '2327f197493c9aeb867cb401b66068347b7d28ccc18c7b3206bc515002bbab69', '3979b4c486d79010edeff549c31179637e18383b5ce570061eea126ba99d5a97'] A "this section covers how detnet ip flows operate over an ieee 802.1 tsn sub-network. fig_ip_detnet_to_tsn illustrates such a scenario, where two ip (detnet) nodes are interconnected by a tsn sub-network. node-1 is single homed and node-2 is dual-homed to the tsn sub- network." {51: 1, 96: 1, 6: 5, 79: 5, 90: 5, 130: 2, 62: 2, 85: 3, 68: 5, 35: 6, 110: 5, 91: 7, 114: 5, 97: 3, 31: 6, 13: 2, 67: 5, 38: 6, 26: 4, 124: 6, 98: 5, 54: 5, 127: 6, 8: 5, 64: 5, 30: 5, 61: 7, 55: 4, 27: 6, 15: 5, 52: 3, 129: 6, 115: 5, 84: 5, 76: 8, 87: 5, 131: 8, 102: 3, 113: 7, 99: 5, 36: 5, 24: 4, 53: 4, 72: 6} {82: 1, 348: 1, 1: 10, 4: 5, 9: 7, 10: 6, 15: 4, 24: 5, 25: 2, 26: 3, 27: 4, 39: 6, 43: 6, 49: 8, 50: 7, 58: 7, 59: 5, 64: 4, 69: 6, 81: 3, 86: 5, 96: 6, 97: 5, 100: 4, 108: 6, 109: 7, 110: 7, 111: 5, 114: 6, 115: 7, 116: 3, 118: 5, 119: 4, 120: 6, 121: 5, 122: 3, 123: 2, 124: 5, 128: 6, 129: 5, 130: 7, 132: 6, 136: 5, 145: 6, 147: 6, 151: 6, 152: 6, 154: 6, 156: 3, 161: 5, 162: 4, 165: 6, 168: 7, 169: 5, 172: 5, 180: 6, 184: 7, 187: 8, 188: 7, 191: 6, 194: 6, 202: 7, 203: 8, 206: 5, 207: 6, 215: 5, 217: 6, 218: 9, 220: 5, 221: 5, 222: 6, 224: 6, 227: 2, 229: 5, 234: 8, 235: 5, 241: 5, 242: 5, 243: 6, 244: 6, 245: 6, 248: 6, 250: 5, 258: 12, 262: 7, 263: 8, 264: 6, 267: 5, 270: 4, 272: 5, 273: 7, 287: 6, 289: 5, 291: 7, 299: 2, 300: 4, 304: 4, 309: 5, 314: 5, 315: 5, 320: 3, 323: 6, 327: 7, 328: 6, 329: 5, 330: 11, 334: 5, 335: 3, 341: 2, 342: 3, 350: 9, 351: 7, 352: 5, 353: 5, 354: 4, 358: 5, 365: 5, 366: 5, 369: 4, 371: 4, 372: 7, 376: 5, 384: 7, 385: 6, 386: 6, 387: 4, 392: 6, 393: 7, 396: 3, 397: 8, 398: 7, 402: 5} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 124 "Congestion protection, latency control and the resource allocation (queuing, policing, shaping) are supported using the underlying link / sub-net specific mechanisms. Service protections (packet replication and packet elimination functions) are not provided at the IP DetNet layer end-to-end due the lack of a unified end-to-end sequencing information that would be available for intermediate nodes. However, such service protection can be provided on a per underlying L2 link and sub-network basis." TSN related documents are updated as follows : draft - ietf - detnet - ip - over - tsn AND draft - ietf - detnet - mpls - over - tsn type changed to informational overview shortened changing TSN related conformance language to informative text stating that mappings between DetNet and TSN management and control planes are out of scope of the document updating references draft - ietf - detnet - tsn - vpn - over - mpls overview shortened fixing 5.1 and 5.2 ( changing TSN related conformance language to informative text ) stating that mappings between DetNet and TSN management and control planes are out of scope of the document updating references 307e99a43b03cdb2231e27fbd7e9a248cf849106 307e99a43b03cdb2231e27fbd7e9a248cf849106 draft-ietf-detnet-ip-over-tsn 3979b4c486d79010edeff549c31179637e18383b5ce570061eea126ba99d5a97 ['da15d4880e4b0ffd91ed06bbbd91b82967b5072475783d35d73a4d9a24ccdf38', '2b58030ee3aece454f82806bc1415f1bd2ddb59dfa489859800ccdde2a0ae710', 'f5904a73b761c7f93647e670078f5880a077300f912bd26ad88b6235d38db053', 'f5a155e6a4a7b93b7717d43f4cc13100706c13d2e93677f9cb041aa9ed94f77d', 'ca8ff5cafc8cf8fe21d5c32033e7eaf2d8d483ee895512f4cc26334b0eb890b8', '2327f197493c9aeb867cb401b66068347b7d28ccc18c7b3206bc515002bbab69', '3979b4c486d79010edeff549c31179637e18383b5ce570061eea126ba99d5a97'] B "congestion protection, latency control and the resource allocation (queuing, policing, shaping) are supported using the underlying link / sub-net specific mechanisms. service protections (packet replication and packet elimination functions) are not provided at the ip detnet layer end-to-end due the lack of a unified end-to-end sequencing information that would be available for intermediate nodes. however, such service protection can be provided on a per underlying l2 link and sub-network basis." {51: 1, 96: 1, 6: 5, 79: 5, 90: 5, 130: 2, 62: 2, 85: 3, 68: 5, 35: 6, 110: 5, 91: 7, 114: 5, 97: 3, 31: 6, 13: 2, 67: 5, 38: 6, 26: 4, 124: 6, 98: 5, 54: 5, 127: 6, 8: 5, 64: 5, 30: 5, 61: 7, 55: 4, 27: 6, 15: 5, 52: 3, 129: 6, 115: 5, 84: 5, 76: 8, 87: 5, 131: 8, 102: 3, 113: 7, 99: 5, 36: 5, 24: 4, 53: 4, 72: 6} {82: 1, 348: 1, 1: 10, 4: 5, 9: 7, 10: 6, 15: 4, 24: 5, 25: 2, 26: 3, 27: 4, 39: 6, 43: 6, 49: 8, 50: 7, 58: 7, 59: 5, 64: 4, 69: 6, 81: 3, 86: 5, 96: 6, 97: 5, 100: 4, 108: 6, 109: 7, 110: 7, 111: 5, 114: 6, 115: 7, 116: 3, 118: 5, 119: 4, 120: 6, 121: 5, 122: 3, 123: 2, 124: 5, 128: 6, 129: 5, 130: 7, 132: 6, 136: 5, 145: 6, 147: 6, 151: 6, 152: 6, 154: 6, 156: 3, 161: 5, 162: 4, 165: 6, 168: 7, 169: 5, 172: 5, 180: 6, 184: 7, 187: 8, 188: 7, 191: 6, 194: 6, 202: 7, 203: 8, 206: 5, 207: 6, 215: 5, 217: 6, 218: 9, 220: 5, 221: 5, 222: 6, 224: 6, 227: 2, 229: 5, 234: 8, 235: 5, 241: 5, 242: 5, 243: 6, 244: 6, 245: 6, 248: 6, 250: 5, 258: 12, 262: 7, 263: 8, 264: 6, 267: 5, 270: 4, 272: 5, 273: 7, 287: 6, 289: 5, 291: 7, 299: 2, 300: 4, 304: 4, 309: 5, 314: 5, 315: 5, 320: 3, 323: 6, 327: 7, 328: 6, 329: 5, 330: 11, 334: 5, 335: 3, 341: 2, 342: 3, 350: 9, 351: 7, 352: 5, 353: 5, 354: 4, 358: 5, 365: 5, 366: 5, 369: 4, 371: 4, 372: 7, 376: 5, 384: 7, 385: 6, 386: 6, 387: 4, 392: 6, 393: 7, 396: 3, 397: 8, 398: 7, 402: 5} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 124 "DetNet routers ensure that DetNet service requirements are met per hop by allocating local resources, both receive and transmit, and by mapping the service requirements of each flow to appropriate sub- network mechanisms. Such mappings are sub-network technology specific. DetNet nodes interconnected by a TSN sub-network are the primary focus of this document. The mapping of DetNet IP flows to TSN streams and TSN protection mechanisms are covered in mapping-tsn." TSN related documents are updated as follows : draft - ietf - detnet - ip - over - tsn AND draft - ietf - detnet - mpls - over - tsn type changed to informational overview shortened changing TSN related conformance language to informative text stating that mappings between DetNet and TSN management and control planes are out of scope of the document updating references draft - ietf - detnet - tsn - vpn - over - mpls overview shortened fixing 5.1 and 5.2 ( changing TSN related conformance language to informative text ) stating that mappings between DetNet and TSN management and control planes are out of scope of the document updating references 307e99a43b03cdb2231e27fbd7e9a248cf849106 307e99a43b03cdb2231e27fbd7e9a248cf849106 draft-ietf-detnet-ip-over-tsn f5a155e6a4a7b93b7717d43f4cc13100706c13d2e93677f9cb041aa9ed94f77d ['da15d4880e4b0ffd91ed06bbbd91b82967b5072475783d35d73a4d9a24ccdf38', '2b58030ee3aece454f82806bc1415f1bd2ddb59dfa489859800ccdde2a0ae710', 'f5904a73b761c7f93647e670078f5880a077300f912bd26ad88b6235d38db053', 'f5a155e6a4a7b93b7717d43f4cc13100706c13d2e93677f9cb041aa9ed94f77d', 'ca8ff5cafc8cf8fe21d5c32033e7eaf2d8d483ee895512f4cc26334b0eb890b8', '2327f197493c9aeb867cb401b66068347b7d28ccc18c7b3206bc515002bbab69', '3979b4c486d79010edeff549c31179637e18383b5ce570061eea126ba99d5a97'] B "detnet routers ensure that detnet service requirements are met per hop by allocating local resources, both receive and transmit, and by mapping the service requirements of each flow to appropriate sub- network mechanisms. such mappings are sub-network technology specific. detnet nodes interconnected by a tsn sub-network are the primary focus of this document. the mapping of detnet ip flows to tsn streams and tsn protection mechanisms are covered in mapping-tsn." {51: 1, 96: 1, 6: 5, 79: 5, 90: 5, 130: 2, 62: 2, 85: 3, 68: 5, 35: 6, 110: 5, 91: 7, 114: 5, 97: 3, 31: 6, 13: 2, 67: 5, 38: 6, 26: 4, 124: 6, 98: 5, 54: 5, 127: 6, 8: 5, 64: 5, 30: 5, 61: 7, 55: 4, 27: 6, 15: 5, 52: 3, 129: 6, 115: 5, 84: 5, 76: 8, 87: 5, 131: 8, 102: 3, 113: 7, 99: 5, 36: 5, 24: 4, 53: 4, 72: 6} {82: 1, 348: 1, 1: 10, 4: 5, 9: 7, 10: 6, 15: 4, 24: 5, 25: 2, 26: 3, 27: 4, 39: 6, 43: 6, 49: 8, 50: 7, 58: 7, 59: 5, 64: 4, 69: 6, 81: 3, 86: 5, 96: 6, 97: 5, 100: 4, 108: 6, 109: 7, 110: 7, 111: 5, 114: 6, 115: 7, 116: 3, 118: 5, 119: 4, 120: 6, 121: 5, 122: 3, 123: 2, 124: 5, 128: 6, 129: 5, 130: 7, 132: 6, 136: 5, 145: 6, 147: 6, 151: 6, 152: 6, 154: 6, 156: 3, 161: 5, 162: 4, 165: 6, 168: 7, 169: 5, 172: 5, 180: 6, 184: 7, 187: 8, 188: 7, 191: 6, 194: 6, 202: 7, 203: 8, 206: 5, 207: 6, 215: 5, 217: 6, 218: 9, 220: 5, 221: 5, 222: 6, 224: 6, 227: 2, 229: 5, 234: 8, 235: 5, 241: 5, 242: 5, 243: 6, 244: 6, 245: 6, 248: 6, 250: 5, 258: 12, 262: 7, 263: 8, 264: 6, 267: 5, 270: 4, 272: 5, 273: 7, 287: 6, 289: 5, 291: 7, 299: 2, 300: 4, 304: 4, 309: 5, 314: 5, 315: 5, 320: 3, 323: 6, 327: 7, 328: 6, 329: 5, 330: 11, 334: 5, 335: 3, 341: 2, 342: 3, 350: 9, 351: 7, 352: 5, 353: 5, 354: 4, 358: 5, 365: 5, 366: 5, 369: 4, 371: 4, 372: 7, 376: 5, 384: 7, 385: 6, 386: 6, 387: 4, 392: 6, 393: 7, 396: 3, 397: 8, 398: 7, 402: 5} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 124 "This section covers how DetNet IP flows operate over an IEEE 802.1 TSN sub-network. fig_ip_detnet_to_tsn illustrates such a scenario, where two IP (DetNet) nodes are interconnected by a TSN sub-network. Dotted lines around the Service components of the IP (DetNet) Nodes indicate that they are DetNet service aware but do not perform any DetNet service sub-layer function. Node-1 is single homed and Node-2 is dual-homed to the TSN sub-network." TSN related documents are updated as follows : draft - ietf - detnet - ip - over - tsn AND draft - ietf - detnet - mpls - over - tsn type changed to informational overview shortened changing TSN related conformance language to informative text stating that mappings between DetNet and TSN management and control planes are out of scope of the document updating references draft - ietf - detnet - tsn - vpn - over - mpls overview shortened fixing 5.1 and 5.2 ( changing TSN related conformance language to informative text ) stating that mappings between DetNet and TSN management and control planes are out of scope of the document updating references 307e99a43b03cdb2231e27fbd7e9a248cf849106 307e99a43b03cdb2231e27fbd7e9a248cf849106 draft-ietf-detnet-ip-over-tsn f5904a73b761c7f93647e670078f5880a077300f912bd26ad88b6235d38db053 ['da15d4880e4b0ffd91ed06bbbd91b82967b5072475783d35d73a4d9a24ccdf38', '2b58030ee3aece454f82806bc1415f1bd2ddb59dfa489859800ccdde2a0ae710', 'f5904a73b761c7f93647e670078f5880a077300f912bd26ad88b6235d38db053', 'f5a155e6a4a7b93b7717d43f4cc13100706c13d2e93677f9cb041aa9ed94f77d', 'ca8ff5cafc8cf8fe21d5c32033e7eaf2d8d483ee895512f4cc26334b0eb890b8', '2327f197493c9aeb867cb401b66068347b7d28ccc18c7b3206bc515002bbab69', '3979b4c486d79010edeff549c31179637e18383b5ce570061eea126ba99d5a97'] B "this section covers how detnet ip flows operate over an ieee 802.1 tsn sub-network. fig_ip_detnet_to_tsn illustrates such a scenario, where two ip (detnet) nodes are interconnected by a tsn sub-network. dotted lines around the service components of the ip (detnet) nodes indicate that they are detnet service aware but do not perform any detnet service sub-layer function. node-1 is single homed and node-2 is dual-homed to the tsn sub-network." {51: 1, 96: 1, 6: 5, 79: 5, 90: 5, 130: 2, 62: 2, 85: 3, 68: 5, 35: 6, 110: 5, 91: 7, 114: 5, 97: 3, 31: 6, 13: 2, 67: 5, 38: 6, 26: 4, 124: 6, 98: 5, 54: 5, 127: 6, 8: 5, 64: 5, 30: 5, 61: 7, 55: 4, 27: 6, 15: 5, 52: 3, 129: 6, 115: 5, 84: 5, 76: 8, 87: 5, 131: 8, 102: 3, 113: 7, 99: 5, 36: 5, 24: 4, 53: 4, 72: 6} {82: 1, 348: 1, 1: 10, 4: 5, 9: 7, 10: 6, 15: 4, 24: 5, 25: 2, 26: 3, 27: 4, 39: 6, 43: 6, 49: 8, 50: 7, 58: 7, 59: 5, 64: 4, 69: 6, 81: 3, 86: 5, 96: 6, 97: 5, 100: 4, 108: 6, 109: 7, 110: 7, 111: 5, 114: 6, 115: 7, 116: 3, 118: 5, 119: 4, 120: 6, 121: 5, 122: 3, 123: 2, 124: 5, 128: 6, 129: 5, 130: 7, 132: 6, 136: 5, 145: 6, 147: 6, 151: 6, 152: 6, 154: 6, 156: 3, 161: 5, 162: 4, 165: 6, 168: 7, 169: 5, 172: 5, 180: 6, 184: 7, 187: 8, 188: 7, 191: 6, 194: 6, 202: 7, 203: 8, 206: 5, 207: 6, 215: 5, 217: 6, 218: 9, 220: 5, 221: 5, 222: 6, 224: 6, 227: 2, 229: 5, 234: 8, 235: 5, 241: 5, 242: 5, 243: 6, 244: 6, 245: 6, 248: 6, 250: 5, 258: 12, 262: 7, 263: 8, 264: 6, 267: 5, 270: 4, 272: 5, 273: 7, 287: 6, 289: 5, 291: 7, 299: 2, 300: 4, 304: 4, 309: 5, 314: 5, 315: 5, 320: 3, 323: 6, 327: 7, 328: 6, 329: 5, 330: 11, 334: 5, 335: 3, 341: 2, 342: 3, 350: 9, 351: 7, 352: 5, 353: 5, 354: 4, 358: 5, 365: 5, 366: 5, 369: 4, 371: 4, 372: 7, 376: 5, 384: 7, 385: 6, 386: 6, 387: 4, 392: 6, 393: 7, 396: 3, 397: 8, 398: 7, 402: 5} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 119 "As specified in RFC7510: ""MPLS-in-UDP MUST NOT be used over the general Internet, or over non-cooperating network operators, to carry traffic that is not congestion controlled."" This does apply to DetNet networks as this document focuses on solutions for networks that are under a single administrative control or within a closed group of administrative control." Changes OK 4a2e763435aa509db58e152c2508fa348e811e5c 4a2e763435aa509db58e152c2508fa348e811e5c draft-ietf-detnet-mpls-over-udp-ip fe98a64a7e2151f24e469d9598fd2c5f2d466706b6de94fa6788945e56d6c101 ['fe98a64a7e2151f24e469d9598fd2c5f2d466706b6de94fa6788945e56d6c101'] B "as specified in rfc7510: ""mpls-in-udp must not be used over the general internet, or over non-cooperating network operators, to carry traffic that is not congestion controlled."" this does apply to detnet networks as this document focuses on solutions for networks that are under a single administrative control or within a closed group of administrative control." {} {} {} 119 "Note: In the presence of network (and port) address translation devices/functions it would be up to the controller plane to determine the appropriate information to ensure proper mapping at the sender/ receiver." Changes OK 4a2e763435aa509db58e152c2508fa348e811e5c 4a2e763435aa509db58e152c2508fa348e811e5c draft-ietf-detnet-mpls-over-udp-ip e1bd31b03f4158ceaed77a4d1a77fe355ed6469d3694b3be72f7cba35d542e73 ['e1bd31b03f4158ceaed77a4d1a77fe355ed6469d3694b3be72f7cba35d542e73'] B "note: in the presence of network (and port) address translation devices/functions it would be up to the controller plane to determine the appropriate information to ensure proper mapping at the sender/ receiver." {} {} {} 118 "Main differences of mapping to DetNet MPLS (compared to plain MPLS) are that (1) there is a mandatory flow identification to make the forwarding decision (i.e., forwarding is not based on FEC), (2) the d-CW (DetNet Control Word) is mandatory for the MPLS encapsulation and (3) during forwarding over the DetNet MPLS network DetNet flow specific treatment is needed." Changes : 1 , Section “ 5 . IP over DetNet MPLS Procedures ” Add new text before section 5.1 . 2 , Fix a nit in penultimate paragraph of “ 5.1 . DetNet IP over DetNet MPLS Flow Identification and Aggregation Procedures ” f22095ca327a7b3a226e6703ce15e32e2029301b f22095ca327a7b3a226e6703ce15e32e2029301b draft-ietf-detnet-ip-over-mpls fabf2d3b2d4c9adac2a57aef673d7c31beb65a954550bc1ee7cd9a00a74f7aa6 ['fabf2d3b2d4c9adac2a57aef673d7c31beb65a954550bc1ee7cd9a00a74f7aa6'] B "main differences of mapping to detnet mpls (compared to plain mpls) are that (1) there is a mandatory flow identification to make the forwarding decision (i.e., forwarding is not based on fec), (2) the d-cw (detnet control word) is mandatory for the mpls encapsulation and (3) during forwarding over the detnet mpls network detnet flow specific treatment is needed." {} {} {} 118 "An implementation MUST support the provisioning for handling any received DetNet MPLS data plane as DetNet IP flows via configuration. Note that such configuration MAY include support from PREOF on the incoming DetNet MPLS flow." Changes : 1 , Section “ 5 . IP over DetNet MPLS Procedures ” Add new text before section 5.1 . 2 , Fix a nit in penultimate paragraph of “ 5.1 . DetNet IP over DetNet MPLS Flow Identification and Aggregation Procedures ” f22095ca327a7b3a226e6703ce15e32e2029301b f22095ca327a7b3a226e6703ce15e32e2029301b draft-ietf-detnet-ip-over-mpls 30b7f0b6d57fb79b461a3095454a10e40ff0e085b37c032b1b6efcd9a044fc28 ['30b7f0b6d57fb79b461a3095454a10e40ff0e085b37c032b1b6efcd9a044fc28', '00428f090e69ca0e21cf857fa1b207da7d4b89a6d50e9d4d5bbec0126599092a'] A "an implementation must support the provisioning for handling any received detnet mpls data plane as detnet ip flows via configuration. note that such configuration may include support from preof on the incoming detnet mpls flow." {63: 1, 30: 2, 38: 2, 69: 3} {102: 1, 103: 2, 175: 2, 401: 4, 407: 3, 414: 3} {414, 102, 103, 175, 401, 407, 62} 118 "An implementation MUST support the provisioning for handling any packet flows received via DetNet MPLS data plane as DetNet IP flows via configuration. Note that such configuration MAY include support from PREOF on the incoming DetNet MPLS flow." Changes : 1 , Section “ 5 . IP over DetNet MPLS Procedures ” Add new text before section 5.1 . 2 , Fix a nit in penultimate paragraph of “ 5.1 . DetNet IP over DetNet MPLS Flow Identification and Aggregation Procedures ” f22095ca327a7b3a226e6703ce15e32e2029301b f22095ca327a7b3a226e6703ce15e32e2029301b draft-ietf-detnet-ip-over-mpls 00428f090e69ca0e21cf857fa1b207da7d4b89a6d50e9d4d5bbec0126599092a ['30b7f0b6d57fb79b461a3095454a10e40ff0e085b37c032b1b6efcd9a044fc28', '00428f090e69ca0e21cf857fa1b207da7d4b89a6d50e9d4d5bbec0126599092a'] B "an implementation must support the provisioning for handling any packet flows received via detnet mpls data plane as detnet ip flows via configuration. note that such configuration may include support from preof on the incoming detnet mpls flow." {63: 1, 30: 2, 38: 2, 69: 3} {102: 1, 103: 2, 175: 2, 401: 4, 407: 3, 414: 3} {414, 102, 103, 175, 401, 407, 62} 117 "The DetNet Architecture models the DetNet related data plane functions decomposed into two sub-layers: a service sub-layer and a forwarding sub-layer. The service sub-layer is used to provide DetNet service functions such as protection and reordering. The forwarding sub-layer is used to provide forwarding assurance (low loss, assured latency, and limited out-of-order delivery)." Proposed changes : 0 , fixing < discusscomment 1 , change introduction to highlight additional functions of data plane and the focus of the draft 2 , highlight that implementation of PREOF is out of scope , pointing to related IEEE work ( i.e. , 802.1CB ) 3 , fixing the POF section and its configuration via controller plane 451415e8c7e13f715c6fef2c5fa7715cedc87b7a 451415e8c7e13f715c6fef2c5fa7715cedc87b7a draft-ietf-detnet-mpls e0c95d9bc605e911fd32ffc649664bff1d4bcf97e922cc62e17abefc214eedcd ['e0c95d9bc605e911fd32ffc649664bff1d4bcf97e922cc62e17abefc214eedcd', '5f9482dcae9a05bb1f6780cbff7c9ee49c0cc94f5afae6ba8450f30465d562be'] A "the detnet architecture models the detnet related data plane functions decomposed into two sub-layers: a service sub-layer and a forwarding sub-layer. the service sub-layer is used to provide detnet service functions such as protection and reordering. the forwarding sub-layer is used to provide forwarding assurance (low loss, assured latency, and limited out-of-order delivery)." {108: 1} {275: 1} {361, 275} 117 "The purpose of this document is to describe the use of the MPLS data plane to establish and support DetNet flows. The DetNet Architecture models the DetNet related data plane functions decomposed into two sub-layers: a service sub-layer and a forwarding sub-layer. The service sub-layer is used to provide DetNet service functions such as protection and reordering. At the DetNet data plane a new set of functions (PREOF) provide the service sub-layer specific tasks. The forwarding sub-layer is used to provide forwarding assurance (low loss, assured latency, and limited out-of-order delivery) via already existing Traffic Engineering and queuing tools. The use of the functionalities of the DetNet service sub-layer and the DetNet forwarding sub-layer require careful design and control by the controller plane in addition to the DetNet specific use of MPLS encapsulation as specified by this document." Proposed changes : 0 , fixing < discusscomment 1 , change introduction to highlight additional functions of data plane and the focus of the draft 2 , highlight that implementation of PREOF is out of scope , pointing to related IEEE work ( i.e. , 802.1CB ) 3 , fixing the POF section and its configuration via controller plane 451415e8c7e13f715c6fef2c5fa7715cedc87b7a 451415e8c7e13f715c6fef2c5fa7715cedc87b7a draft-ietf-detnet-mpls 5f9482dcae9a05bb1f6780cbff7c9ee49c0cc94f5afae6ba8450f30465d562be ['e0c95d9bc605e911fd32ffc649664bff1d4bcf97e922cc62e17abefc214eedcd', '5f9482dcae9a05bb1f6780cbff7c9ee49c0cc94f5afae6ba8450f30465d562be'] B "the purpose of this document is to describe the use of the mpls data plane to establish and support detnet flows. the detnet architecture models the detnet related data plane functions decomposed into two sub-layers: a service sub-layer and a forwarding sub-layer. the service sub-layer is used to provide detnet service functions such as protection and reordering. at the detnet data plane a new set of functions (preof) provide the service sub-layer specific tasks. the forwarding sub-layer is used to provide forwarding assurance (low loss, assured latency, and limited out-of-order delivery) via already existing traffic engineering and queuing tools. the use of the functionalities of the detnet service sub-layer and the detnet forwarding sub-layer require careful design and control by the controller plane in addition to the detnet specific use of mpls encapsulation as specified by this document." {108: 1} {275: 1} {361, 275} 117 "Implementation details of PREOF functions is out of scope for this document. IEEE802.1CB-2017 specifies replication and elimination specific aspects, which can be applied to PRF and PEF." Proposed changes : 0 , fixing < discusscomment 1 , change introduction to highlight additional functions of data plane and the focus of the draft 2 , highlight that implementation of PREOF is out of scope , pointing to related IEEE work ( i.e. , 802.1CB ) 3 , fixing the POF section and its configuration via controller plane 451415e8c7e13f715c6fef2c5fa7715cedc87b7a 451415e8c7e13f715c6fef2c5fa7715cedc87b7a draft-ietf-detnet-mpls 32f74e159bcccd4d7b479ffc37f39f3e42d7e7c3ae5dfb897b4416b7e36306b9 ['32f74e159bcccd4d7b479ffc37f39f3e42d7e7c3ae5dfb897b4416b7e36306b9'] B "implementation details of preof functions is out of scope for this document. ieee802.1cb-2017 specifies replication and elimination specific aspects, which can be applied to prf and pef." {} {} {} 117 "The latency impact on the system resources needed to support a specific DetNet flow will need to be evaluated by the controller plane based on that flow's traffic specification. An example traffic specification that can be used with MPLS with Traffic Engineering (MPLS-TE) can be found in RFC2212." Proposed changes : 0 , fixing < discusscomment 1 , change introduction to highlight additional functions of data plane and the focus of the draft 2 , highlight that implementation of PREOF is out of scope , pointing to related IEEE work ( i.e. , 802.1CB ) 3 , fixing the POF section and its configuration via controller plane 451415e8c7e13f715c6fef2c5fa7715cedc87b7a 451415e8c7e13f715c6fef2c5fa7715cedc87b7a draft-ietf-detnet-mpls 16f5c193fbbe5b7afdcfaa82390a8b7888506587c18b3154a26b7b0bb8f57894 ['2d301da0e093e05a85f2b23941e6ae021c6099a62e43fa8e35270d405ca73e85', '16f5c193fbbe5b7afdcfaa82390a8b7888506587c18b3154a26b7b0bb8f57894'] B "the latency impact on the system resources needed to support a specific detnet flow will need to be evaluated by the controller plane based on that flow's traffic specification. an example traffic specification that can be used with mpls with traffic engineering (mpls-te) can be found in rfc2212." {} {} {} 117 "DetNet uses flow-specific requirements (e.g., maximum number of out- of-order packets, maximum latency of the flow) for configuration of POF-related buffers. POF implementation details are out-of-scope for this document and POF configuration parameters are implementation specific. The Controller Plane determines and sets the POF configuration parameters. If PEF is combined with POF, then their configurations need to be coordinated to ensure the combined functionality." Proposed changes : 0 , fixing < discusscomment 1 , change introduction to highlight additional functions of data plane and the focus of the draft 2 , highlight that implementation of PREOF is out of scope , pointing to related IEEE work ( i.e. , 802.1CB ) 3 , fixing the POF section and its configuration via controller plane 451415e8c7e13f715c6fef2c5fa7715cedc87b7a 451415e8c7e13f715c6fef2c5fa7715cedc87b7a draft-ietf-detnet-mpls 2d301da0e093e05a85f2b23941e6ae021c6099a62e43fa8e35270d405ca73e85 ['2d301da0e093e05a85f2b23941e6ae021c6099a62e43fa8e35270d405ca73e85', '16f5c193fbbe5b7afdcfaa82390a8b7888506587c18b3154a26b7b0bb8f57894'] B "detnet uses flow-specific requirements (e.g., maximum number of out- of-order packets, maximum latency of the flow) for configuration of pof-related buffers. pof implementation details are out-of-scope for this document and pof configuration parameters are implementation specific. the controller plane determines and sets the pof configuration parameters. if pef is combined with pof, then their configurations need to be coordinated to ensure the combined functionality." {} {} {} 117 "To provide uninterrupted availability of the DetNet service, provisions can be made against DOS attacks and delay attacks. To protect against DOS attacks, excess traffic due to malicious or malfunctioning devices is prevented or mitigated through the use of existing mechanisms, for example by policing and shaping incoming traffic. To prevent DetNet packets from being delayed by an entity external to a DetNet domain, DetNet technology definition can allow for the mitigation of on-path attackers, for example through use of authentication and authorization of devices within the DetNet domain." Proposed changes : 0 , fixing < discusscomment 1 , change introduction to highlight additional functions of data plane and the focus of the draft 2 , highlight that implementation of PREOF is out of scope , pointing to related IEEE work ( i.e. , 802.1CB ) 3 , fixing the POF section and its configuration via controller plane 451415e8c7e13f715c6fef2c5fa7715cedc87b7a 451415e8c7e13f715c6fef2c5fa7715cedc87b7a draft-ietf-detnet-mpls 3c75c7253001ac57d6c8a269c8f4df047ddb7afb81234ce62ee0ef93954eba74 ['3c75c7253001ac57d6c8a269c8f4df047ddb7afb81234ce62ee0ef93954eba74', '659bfa2380ff5938d5767a05c420d95458d1fea2060fceb12394346ac34fe2c3'] A "to provide uninterrupted availability of the detnet service, provisions can be made against dos attacks and delay attacks. to protect against dos attacks, excess traffic due to malicious or malfunctioning devices is prevented or mitigated through the use of existing mechanisms, for example by policing and shaping incoming traffic. to prevent detnet packets from being delayed by an entity external to a detnet domain, detnet technology definition can allow for the mitigation of on-path attackers, for example through use of authentication and authorization of devices within the detnet domain." {114: 1} {92: 1} {92, 93} 117 "To provide uninterrupted availability of the DetNet service, provisions can be made against DOS attacks and delay attacks. To protect against DOS attacks, excess traffic due to malicious or malfunctioning devices is prevented or mitigated through the use of existing mechanisms, for example by policing and shaping incoming traffic. To prevent DetNet packets having their delay manipulated by an external entity, precautions need to be taken to ensure that all devices on an LSP are those intended to be there by the network operator and that they are well behaved. In addition to physical security, technical methods such as authentication and authorization of network equipment and the instrumentation and monitoring of the LSP packet delay may be used. If a delay attack is suspected, traffic may be moved to an alternate path, for example through changing the LSP or management of the PREOF configuration." Proposed changes : 0 , fixing < discusscomment 1 , change introduction to highlight additional functions of data plane and the focus of the draft 2 , highlight that implementation of PREOF is out of scope , pointing to related IEEE work ( i.e. , 802.1CB ) 3 , fixing the POF section and its configuration via controller plane 451415e8c7e13f715c6fef2c5fa7715cedc87b7a 451415e8c7e13f715c6fef2c5fa7715cedc87b7a draft-ietf-detnet-mpls 659bfa2380ff5938d5767a05c420d95458d1fea2060fceb12394346ac34fe2c3 ['3c75c7253001ac57d6c8a269c8f4df047ddb7afb81234ce62ee0ef93954eba74', '659bfa2380ff5938d5767a05c420d95458d1fea2060fceb12394346ac34fe2c3'] B "to provide uninterrupted availability of the detnet service, provisions can be made against dos attacks and delay attacks. to protect against dos attacks, excess traffic due to malicious or malfunctioning devices is prevented or mitigated through the use of existing mechanisms, for example by policing and shaping incoming traffic. to prevent detnet packets having their delay manipulated by an external entity, precautions need to be taken to ensure that all devices on an lsp are those intended to be there by the network operator and that they are well behaved. in addition to physical security, technical methods such as authentication and authorization of network equipment and the instrumentation and monitoring of the lsp packet delay may be used. if a delay attack is suspected, traffic may be moved to an alternate path, for example through changing the lsp or management of the preof configuration." {114: 1} {92: 1} {92, 93} 115 "Security aspects which are unique to DetNet are those whose aim is to provide the specific quality of service aspects of DetNet, which are primarily to deliver data flows with extremely low packet loss rates and bounded end-to-end delivery latency." All comments were replied and fixed as per 8:00pm CET , 09 - 09 - 2020 a2e6f79e46cb8305639e53ede08e31274153b1e2 a2e6f79e46cb8305639e53ede08e31274153b1e2 draft-ietf-detnet-ip-over-mpls fa6534a2fea10c93739f34a3a3ebc956aa92d44a1990ef9c3f8c57af2882f9cd ['6c2430de5b83a4a28568de74a171afe5f481d4e89f9c10f8ec877c0dd915d18e', 'fa6534a2fea10c93739f34a3a3ebc956aa92d44a1990ef9c3f8c57af2882f9cd'] A "security aspects which are unique to detnet are those whose aim is to provide the specific quality of service aspects of detnet, which are primarily to deliver data flows with extremely low packet loss rates and bounded end-to-end delivery latency." {36: 1, 24: 1, 102: 1, 90: 1, 13: 1, 6: 3, 79: 3, 51: 2, 130: 3, 62: 5, 85: 6, 68: 5, 35: 4, 110: 2, 91: 3, 114: 2, 97: 3, 31: 2, 67: 2, 38: 3, 26: 2, 124: 4, 98: 3, 54: 3, 127: 4, 8: 3, 96: 3, 64: 2, 30: 2, 61: 4, 55: 4, 27: 3, 15: 2, 52: 2, 129: 4, 84: 2, 76: 7, 87: 2, 131: 6, 113: 4, 99: 3, 53: 2, 72: 3} {353: 1, 354: 1, 272: 1, 402: 1, 315: 1, 1: 10, 4: 3, 9: 6, 10: 4, 15: 3, 24: 3, 25: 5, 26: 6, 27: 2, 39: 6, 43: 4, 49: 4, 50: 3, 58: 4, 59: 3, 64: 3, 69: 5, 81: 6, 82: 4, 86: 2, 96: 3, 97: 2, 100: 7, 108: 4, 109: 5, 110: 5, 111: 3, 114: 4, 115: 5, 116: 3, 118: 7, 119: 6, 120: 4, 121: 5, 122: 4, 123: 3, 124: 5, 128: 2, 129: 2, 130: 4, 132: 5, 136: 3, 145: 5, 147: 3, 151: 2, 152: 2, 154: 4, 156: 2, 161: 4, 162: 4, 165: 4, 168: 5, 172: 2, 180: 2, 184: 6, 187: 6, 188: 5, 191: 4, 194: 5, 202: 6, 203: 7, 206: 3, 207: 4, 215: 3, 217: 4, 218: 9, 220: 3, 221: 3, 222: 6, 224: 4, 227: 5, 229: 2, 234: 6, 235: 3, 241: 3, 242: 3, 243: 5, 244: 2, 245: 5, 248: 2, 250: 4, 258: 12, 262: 5, 263: 6, 264: 4, 267: 5, 270: 3, 273: 6, 287: 4, 289: 2, 291: 4, 299: 5, 300: 3, 304: 3, 309: 4, 314: 3, 320: 5, 323: 5, 327: 5, 328: 4, 329: 3, 330: 11, 334: 3, 335: 3, 341: 5, 342: 6, 347: 5, 348: 5, 350: 8, 351: 3, 352: 2, 358: 5, 365: 2, 366: 3, 369: 2, 371: 7, 372: 4, 376: 3, 384: 4, 385: 3, 386: 4, 387: 3, 392: 4, 393: 5, 396: 6, 397: 8, 398: 7} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 115 "Security aspects which are unique to DetNet are those whose aim is to protect the support of specific quality of service aspects of DetNet, which are primarily to deliver data flows with extremely low packet loss rates and bounded end-to-end delivery latency." All comments were replied and fixed as per 8:00pm CET , 09 - 09 - 2020 a2e6f79e46cb8305639e53ede08e31274153b1e2 a2e6f79e46cb8305639e53ede08e31274153b1e2 draft-ietf-detnet-ip-over-mpls 6c2430de5b83a4a28568de74a171afe5f481d4e89f9c10f8ec877c0dd915d18e ['6c2430de5b83a4a28568de74a171afe5f481d4e89f9c10f8ec877c0dd915d18e', 'fa6534a2fea10c93739f34a3a3ebc956aa92d44a1990ef9c3f8c57af2882f9cd'] B "security aspects which are unique to detnet are those whose aim is to protect the support of specific quality of service aspects of detnet, which are primarily to deliver data flows with extremely low packet loss rates and bounded end-to-end delivery latency." {36: 1, 24: 1, 102: 1, 90: 1, 13: 1, 6: 3, 79: 3, 51: 2, 130: 3, 62: 5, 85: 6, 68: 5, 35: 4, 110: 2, 91: 3, 114: 2, 97: 3, 31: 2, 67: 2, 38: 3, 26: 2, 124: 4, 98: 3, 54: 3, 127: 4, 8: 3, 96: 3, 64: 2, 30: 2, 61: 4, 55: 4, 27: 3, 15: 2, 52: 2, 129: 4, 84: 2, 76: 7, 87: 2, 131: 6, 113: 4, 99: 3, 53: 2, 72: 3} {353: 1, 354: 1, 272: 1, 402: 1, 315: 1, 1: 10, 4: 3, 9: 6, 10: 4, 15: 3, 24: 3, 25: 5, 26: 6, 27: 2, 39: 6, 43: 4, 49: 4, 50: 3, 58: 4, 59: 3, 64: 3, 69: 5, 81: 6, 82: 4, 86: 2, 96: 3, 97: 2, 100: 7, 108: 4, 109: 5, 110: 5, 111: 3, 114: 4, 115: 5, 116: 3, 118: 7, 119: 6, 120: 4, 121: 5, 122: 4, 123: 3, 124: 5, 128: 2, 129: 2, 130: 4, 132: 5, 136: 3, 145: 5, 147: 3, 151: 2, 152: 2, 154: 4, 156: 2, 161: 4, 162: 4, 165: 4, 168: 5, 172: 2, 180: 2, 184: 6, 187: 6, 188: 5, 191: 4, 194: 5, 202: 6, 203: 7, 206: 3, 207: 4, 215: 3, 217: 4, 218: 9, 220: 3, 221: 3, 222: 6, 224: 4, 227: 5, 229: 2, 234: 6, 235: 3, 241: 3, 242: 3, 243: 5, 244: 2, 245: 5, 248: 2, 250: 4, 258: 12, 262: 5, 263: 6, 264: 4, 267: 5, 270: 3, 273: 6, 287: 4, 289: 2, 291: 4, 299: 5, 300: 3, 304: 3, 309: 4, 314: 3, 320: 5, 323: 5, 327: 5, 328: 4, 329: 3, 330: 11, 334: 3, 335: 3, 341: 5, 342: 6, 347: 5, 348: 5, 350: 8, 351: 3, 352: 2, 358: 5, 365: 2, 366: 3, 369: 2, 371: 7, 372: 4, 376: 3, 384: 4, 385: 3, 386: 4, 387: 3, 392: 4, 393: 5, 396: 6, 397: 8, 398: 7} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 114 "Deterministic Networking (DetNet) is a service that can be offered by a network to DetNet flows. DetNet provides these flows with extremely low packet loss rates and assured maximum end-to-end delivery latency. General background and concepts of DetNet can be found in RFC8655." All comments were replied and fixed as per 8:00pm CET , 09 - 09 - 2020 277f76efd2c1f6d2040a8dd8f684c37826d12d75 277f76efd2c1f6d2040a8dd8f684c37826d12d75 draft-ietf-detnet-mpls 64357ac8e1fdd7c862616ce33c908ff751980892adfc8cc1cb46e97bdcf9cd57 ['68a3042de986294abc4a270d183a0a60be4909827d9d2a9162bd1d22fc74d410', '64357ac8e1fdd7c862616ce33c908ff751980892adfc8cc1cb46e97bdcf9cd57'] A "deterministic networking (detnet) is a service that can be offered by a network to detnet flows. detnet provides these flows with extremely low packet loss rates and assured maximum end-to-end delivery latency. general background and concepts of detnet can be found in rfc8655." {} {} {} 114 "Deterministic Networking (DetNet) is a service that can be offered by a network to DetNet flows. DetNet provides a capability to carry specified unicast or multicast data flows for real-time applications with extremely low data loss rates and bounded latency within a network domain. General background and concepts of DetNet can be found in the DetNet Architecture RFC8655." All comments were replied and fixed as per 8:00pm CET , 09 - 09 - 2020 277f76efd2c1f6d2040a8dd8f684c37826d12d75 277f76efd2c1f6d2040a8dd8f684c37826d12d75 draft-ietf-detnet-mpls 68a3042de986294abc4a270d183a0a60be4909827d9d2a9162bd1d22fc74d410 ['68a3042de986294abc4a270d183a0a60be4909827d9d2a9162bd1d22fc74d410', '64357ac8e1fdd7c862616ce33c908ff751980892adfc8cc1cb46e97bdcf9cd57'] B "deterministic networking (detnet) is a service that can be offered by a network to detnet flows. detnet provides a capability to carry specified unicast or multicast data flows for real-time applications with extremely low data loss rates and bounded latency within a network domain. general background and concepts of detnet can be found in the detnet architecture rfc8655." {} {} {} 114 "This document specifies the DetNet data plane operation and the on- wire encapsulation of DetNet flows over an MPLS-based Packet Switched Network (PSN) using the service reference model. MPLS encapsulation already provides a solid foundation of building blocks to enable the DetNet service and forwarding sub-layer functions. MPLS encapsulated DetNet can be carried over a variety of different network technologies that can provide the DetNet required level of service. However, the specific details of how DetNet MPLS is carried over different network technologies is out of scope of this document." All comments were replied and fixed as per 8:00pm CET , 09 - 09 - 2020 277f76efd2c1f6d2040a8dd8f684c37826d12d75 277f76efd2c1f6d2040a8dd8f684c37826d12d75 draft-ietf-detnet-mpls ea96134e066276ad9ad34b1dab319d97a827084b53c0661b6e43ef118265a1d3 ['66d0afbf1221eeb68d70db289f93037914e743ed9d1793f78fd068def5430e89', 'ea96134e066276ad9ad34b1dab319d97a827084b53c0661b6e43ef118265a1d3'] A "this document specifies the detnet data plane operation and the on- wire encapsulation of detnet flows over an mpls-based packet switched network (psn) using the service reference model. mpls encapsulation already provides a solid foundation of building blocks to enable the detnet service and forwarding sub-layer functions. mpls encapsulated detnet can be carried over a variety of different network technologies that can provide the detnet required level of service. however, the specific details of how detnet mpls is carried over different network technologies is out of scope of this document." {} {} {} 114 "This document specifies the DetNet data plane operation and the on- wire encapsulation of DetNet flows over an MPLS-based Packet Switched Network (PSN) using the service reference model. MPLS encapsulation already provides a solid foundation of building blocks to enable the DetNet service and forwarding sub-layer functions. MPLS encapsulated DetNet can be carried over a variety of different network technologies that can provide the DetNet required level of service. However, the specific details of how DetNet MPLS is carried over different network technologies are out of scope of this document." All comments were replied and fixed as per 8:00pm CET , 09 - 09 - 2020 277f76efd2c1f6d2040a8dd8f684c37826d12d75 277f76efd2c1f6d2040a8dd8f684c37826d12d75 draft-ietf-detnet-mpls 66d0afbf1221eeb68d70db289f93037914e743ed9d1793f78fd068def5430e89 ['66d0afbf1221eeb68d70db289f93037914e743ed9d1793f78fd068def5430e89', 'ea96134e066276ad9ad34b1dab319d97a827084b53c0661b6e43ef118265a1d3'] B "this document specifies the detnet data plane operation and the on- wire encapsulation of detnet flows over an mpls-based packet switched network (psn) using the service reference model. mpls encapsulation already provides a solid foundation of building blocks to enable the detnet service and forwarding sub-layer functions. mpls encapsulated detnet can be carried over a variety of different network technologies that can provide the detnet required level of service. however, the specific details of how detnet mpls is carried over different network technologies are out of scope of this document." {} {} {} 114 "A DetNet ""service"" label that is used between DetNet nodes that implement also the DetNet service sub-layer functions. An S-Label is also used to identify a DetNet flow at DetNet service sub-layer at a receiving DetNet node." All comments were replied and fixed as per 8:00pm CET , 09 - 09 - 2020 277f76efd2c1f6d2040a8dd8f684c37826d12d75 277f76efd2c1f6d2040a8dd8f684c37826d12d75 draft-ietf-detnet-mpls 3f9c015c194fe566f16dfef302e3b20066b56fbbb8c7b37555248b49ced418f4 ['09fdab4b91c92132981779301d6e79f8e358d2cb2dec2cab3d67aa5a701ab8ff', '3f9c015c194fe566f16dfef302e3b20066b56fbbb8c7b37555248b49ced418f4'] A "a detnet ""service"" label that is used between detnet nodes that implement also the detnet service sub-layer functions. an s-label is also used to identify a detnet flow at detnet service sub-layer at a receiving detnet node." {} {} {} 114 "A DetNet ""service"" label that is used between DetNet nodes that implement the DetNet service sub-layer functions. An S-Label is used to identify a DetNet flow at DetNet service sub-layer at a receiving DetNet node." All comments were replied and fixed as per 8:00pm CET , 09 - 09 - 2020 277f76efd2c1f6d2040a8dd8f684c37826d12d75 277f76efd2c1f6d2040a8dd8f684c37826d12d75 draft-ietf-detnet-mpls 09fdab4b91c92132981779301d6e79f8e358d2cb2dec2cab3d67aa5a701ab8ff ['09fdab4b91c92132981779301d6e79f8e358d2cb2dec2cab3d67aa5a701ab8ff', '3f9c015c194fe566f16dfef302e3b20066b56fbbb8c7b37555248b49ced418f4'] B "a detnet ""service"" label that is used between detnet nodes that implement the detnet service sub-layer functions. an s-label is used to identify a detnet flow at detnet service sub-layer at a receiving detnet node." {} {} {} 114 "A DetNet control word (d-CW) conforms to the Generic PW MPLS Control Word (PWMCW) defined in RFC4385. The d-CW formatted as shown in fig_detnet_cw MUST be present in all DetNet packets containing app- flow data. This format of the d-CW was created in order (1) to allow larger S/N space to avoid S/N rollover frequency in some applications and (2) to allow sequence numbering systems that include the value zero as a valid sequence number, which simplifies implementation." All comments were replied and fixed as per 8:00pm CET , 09 - 09 - 2020 277f76efd2c1f6d2040a8dd8f684c37826d12d75 277f76efd2c1f6d2040a8dd8f684c37826d12d75 draft-ietf-detnet-mpls 38076a02f6aa326089456ce89f52dd1100783147599300d0e4b60825a9fbe4e2 ['8cd9f6c13db1c8af76d7c7eb8bb80fd9f472052f2717b4146f514435eca5d1ae', '38076a02f6aa326089456ce89f52dd1100783147599300d0e4b60825a9fbe4e2'] A "a detnet control word (d-cw) conforms to the generic pw mpls control word (pwmcw) defined in rfc4385. the d-cw formatted as shown in fig_detnet_cw must be present in all detnet packets containing app- flow data. this format of the d-cw was created in order (1) to allow larger s/n space to avoid s/n rollover frequency in some applications and (2) to allow sequence numbering systems that include the value zero as a valid sequence number, which simplifies implementation." {113: 1, 72: 2} {125: 1, 288: 2} {288, 219, 125} 114 "A DetNet control word (d-CW) conforms to the Generic PW MPLS Control Word (PWMCW) defined in RFC4385. The d-CW formatted as shown in fig_detnet_cw MUST be present in all DetNet packets containing app- flow data. This format of the d-CW was created in order (1) to allow larger sequence number space to avoid sequence number rollover frequency in some applications and (2) to allow sequence numbering systems that include the value zero as a valid sequence number, which simplifies implementation." All comments were replied and fixed as per 8:00pm CET , 09 - 09 - 2020 277f76efd2c1f6d2040a8dd8f684c37826d12d75 277f76efd2c1f6d2040a8dd8f684c37826d12d75 draft-ietf-detnet-mpls 8cd9f6c13db1c8af76d7c7eb8bb80fd9f472052f2717b4146f514435eca5d1ae ['8cd9f6c13db1c8af76d7c7eb8bb80fd9f472052f2717b4146f514435eca5d1ae', '38076a02f6aa326089456ce89f52dd1100783147599300d0e4b60825a9fbe4e2'] B "a detnet control word (d-cw) conforms to the generic pw mpls control word (pwmcw) defined in rfc4385. the d-cw formatted as shown in fig_detnet_cw must be present in all detnet packets containing app- flow data. this format of the d-cw was created in order (1) to allow larger sequence number space to avoid sequence number rollover frequency in some applications and (2) to allow sequence numbering systems that include the value zero as a valid sequence number, which simplifies implementation." {113: 1, 72: 2} {125: 1, 288: 2} {288, 219, 125} 114 "Similarly, an Entropy Label Indicator/Entropy Label (ELI/EL) RFC6790 MAY be carried below the S-Label in the label stack in networks where DetNet flows would otherwise received ECMP treatment. When ELs are used, the same EL value SHOULD be used for all of the packets sent using a specific S-Label to force the flow to follow the same path. However, as outlined in I-D.ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework the use of ECMP for DetNet flows is NOT RECOMMENDED. ECMP MAY be used for non-DetNet flows within a DetNet domain." All comments were replied and fixed as per 8:00pm CET , 09 - 09 - 2020 277f76efd2c1f6d2040a8dd8f684c37826d12d75 277f76efd2c1f6d2040a8dd8f684c37826d12d75 draft-ietf-detnet-mpls fe655c38ec8539f882d03165056c8d797e063939855e400c221507bcca2045a2 ['fe655c38ec8539f882d03165056c8d797e063939855e400c221507bcca2045a2', 'deb4d83f4f0d00bc136f663eb52d672f93a14259f9a1a44085af857ab6a82b38'] A "similarly, an entropy label indicator/entropy label (eli/el) rfc6790 may be carried below the s-label in the label stack in networks where detnet flows would otherwise received ecmp treatment. when els are used, the same el value should be used for all of the packets sent using a specific s-label to force the flow to follow the same path. however, as outlined in i-d.ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework the use of ecmp for detnet flows is not recommended. ecmp may be used for non-detnet flows within a detnet domain." {113: 1} {183: 1} {408, 183} 114 "Similarly, an Entropy Label Indicator/Entropy Label (ELI/EL) RFC6790 MAY be carried below the S-Label in the label stack in networks where DetNet flows would otherwise receive ECMP treatment. When ELs are used, the same EL value SHOULD be used for all of the packets sent using a specific S-Label to force the flow to follow the same path. However, as outlined in I-D.ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework the use of ECMP for DetNet flows is NOT RECOMMENDED. ECMP MAY be used for non-DetNet flows within a DetNet domain." All comments were replied and fixed as per 8:00pm CET , 09 - 09 - 2020 277f76efd2c1f6d2040a8dd8f684c37826d12d75 277f76efd2c1f6d2040a8dd8f684c37826d12d75 draft-ietf-detnet-mpls deb4d83f4f0d00bc136f663eb52d672f93a14259f9a1a44085af857ab6a82b38 ['fe655c38ec8539f882d03165056c8d797e063939855e400c221507bcca2045a2', 'deb4d83f4f0d00bc136f663eb52d672f93a14259f9a1a44085af857ab6a82b38'] B "similarly, an entropy label indicator/entropy label (eli/el) rfc6790 may be carried below the s-label in the label stack in networks where detnet flows would otherwise receive ecmp treatment. when els are used, the same el value should be used for all of the packets sent using a specific s-label to force the flow to follow the same path. however, as outlined in i-d.ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework the use of ecmp for detnet flows is not recommended. ecmp may be used for non-detnet flows within a detnet domain." {113: 1} {183: 1} {408, 183} 114 "When receiving a DetNet MPLS packet, an implementation MUST identify the DetNet service associated with the incoming packet based on the S-Label. When a node is using platform labels for S-Labels, no additional information is needed as the S-label uniquely identifies the DetNet service. In the case where platform labels are not used, zero or more F-Labels and optionally, the incoming interface, proceeding the S-Label MUST be used together with the S-Label to uniquely identify the DetNet service associated with a received packet. The incoming interface MAY also be used together with any present F-Label(s) and the S-Label to uniquely identify an incoming DetNet service, for example, in the case where PHP is used. Note that choice to use platform label space for S-Label or S-Label plus one or more F-Labels to identify DetNet services is a local implementation choice, with one caveat. When one or more F-labels, or incoming interface, is needed together with an S-Label to uniquely identify a service, the controller plane must ensure that incoming DetNet MPLS packets arrive with the needed information (F-label(s) and/or incoming interface) and provision the needed information. The provisioned information MUST then be used to identify incoming DetNet service based on the combination of S-Label and F-Label(s) or incoming interface." All comments were replied and fixed as per 8:00pm CET , 09 - 09 - 2020 277f76efd2c1f6d2040a8dd8f684c37826d12d75 277f76efd2c1f6d2040a8dd8f684c37826d12d75 draft-ietf-detnet-mpls 9cc91bc45abfa7768a4d2c410b224f38ff5845de739c00fa0c29f29ab49a0ab0 ['9269d3d76b297bfd4a839985b280b64574ecf00d83416e41b91f816947593aae', '9cc91bc45abfa7768a4d2c410b224f38ff5845de739c00fa0c29f29ab49a0ab0'] A "when receiving a detnet mpls packet, an implementation must identify the detnet service associated with the incoming packet based on the s-label. when a node is using platform labels for s-labels, no additional information is needed as the s-label uniquely identifies the detnet service. in the case where platform labels are not used, zero or more f-labels and optionally, the incoming interface, proceeding the s-label must be used together with the s-label to uniquely identify the detnet service associated with a received packet. the incoming interface may also be used together with any present f-label(s) and the s-label to uniquely identify an incoming detnet service, for example, in the case where php is used. note that choice to use platform label space for s-label or s-label plus one or more f-labels to identify detnet services is a local implementation choice, with one caveat. when one or more f-labels, or incoming interface, is needed together with an s-label to uniquely identify a service, the controller plane must ensure that incoming detnet mpls packets arrive with the needed information (f-label(s) and/or incoming interface) and provision the needed information. the provisioned information must then be used to identify incoming detnet service based on the combination of s-label and f-label(s) or incoming interface." {} {} {} 114 "When receiving a DetNet MPLS packet, an implementation MUST identify the DetNet service associated with the incoming packet based on the S-Label. When a node is using platform labels for S-Labels, no additional information is needed as the S-label uniquely identifies the DetNet service. In the case where platform labels are not used, zero or more F-Labels proceeding the S-Label MUST be used together with the S-Label to uniquely identify the DetNet service associated with a received packet. The incoming interface MAY also be used together with any present F-Label(s) and the S-Label to uniquely identify an incoming DetNet service, for example, in the case where PHP is used. Note that choice to use platform label space for S-Label or S-Label plus one or more F-Labels to identify DetNet services is a local implementation choice, with one caveat. When one or more F-labels, or incoming interface, is needed together with an S-Label to uniquely identify a service, the controller plane must ensure that incoming DetNet MPLS packets arrive with the needed information (F-label(s) and/or incoming interface) and provision the needed information. The provisioned information MUST then be used to identify incoming DetNet service based on the combination of S-Label and F-Label(s) or incoming interface." All comments were replied and fixed as per 8:00pm CET , 09 - 09 - 2020 277f76efd2c1f6d2040a8dd8f684c37826d12d75 277f76efd2c1f6d2040a8dd8f684c37826d12d75 draft-ietf-detnet-mpls 9269d3d76b297bfd4a839985b280b64574ecf00d83416e41b91f816947593aae ['9269d3d76b297bfd4a839985b280b64574ecf00d83416e41b91f816947593aae', '9cc91bc45abfa7768a4d2c410b224f38ff5845de739c00fa0c29f29ab49a0ab0'] B "when receiving a detnet mpls packet, an implementation must identify the detnet service associated with the incoming packet based on the s-label. when a node is using platform labels for s-labels, no additional information is needed as the s-label uniquely identifies the detnet service. in the case where platform labels are not used, zero or more f-labels proceeding the s-label must be used together with the s-label to uniquely identify the detnet service associated with a received packet. the incoming interface may also be used together with any present f-label(s) and the s-label to uniquely identify an incoming detnet service, for example, in the case where php is used. note that choice to use platform label space for s-label or s-label plus one or more f-labels to identify detnet services is a local implementation choice, with one caveat. when one or more f-labels, or incoming interface, is needed together with an s-label to uniquely identify a service, the controller plane must ensure that incoming detnet mpls packets arrive with the needed information (f-label(s) and/or incoming interface) and provision the needed information. the provisioned information must then be used to identify incoming detnet service based on the combination of s-label and f-label(s) or incoming interface." {} {} {} 114 "After a DetNet service is identified for a received DetNet MPLS packet, as described above, an implementation MUST check if PEF is configured for that DetNet service. When configured, the implementation MUST track the sequence number contained in received d-CWs and MUST ensure that duplicate (replicated) instances of a particular sequence number are discarded. The specific mechanisms used for an implementation to identify which received packets are duplicates and which are new is an implementation choice. Note that per dn-sn the sequence number field length may be 16 or 28 bits, and the field value can wrap. PEF MUST NOT be used with DetNet flows configured with a d-CW sequence number field length of 0 bits." All comments were replied and fixed as per 8:00pm CET , 09 - 09 - 2020 277f76efd2c1f6d2040a8dd8f684c37826d12d75 277f76efd2c1f6d2040a8dd8f684c37826d12d75 draft-ietf-detnet-mpls d75d94ba607a565d21ce85603052a296c1d683f5fd6eec8aef0f6770260c9d9a ['1f7f2b84a8eaad2d3d5210269e8d5b5ba9d20ef952d3919d142bee230120b5f0', '4ce3bd6384eae7d27ece687757a2a7944388445af8ef5e40983088e229d81afb', '74181179e1bff7cb69469deba0503df7f1fb3c0ad51896ab11b8d038bf42a52a', 'd75d94ba607a565d21ce85603052a296c1d683f5fd6eec8aef0f6770260c9d9a'] A "after a detnet service is identified for a received detnet mpls packet, as described above, an implementation must check if pef is configured for that detnet service. when configured, the implementation must track the sequence number contained in received d-cws and must ensure that duplicate (replicated) instances of a particular sequence number are discarded. the specific mechanisms used for an implementation to identify which received packets are duplicates and which are new is an implementation choice. note that per dn-sn the sequence number field length may be 16 or 28 bits, and the field value can wrap. pef must not be used with detnet flows configured with a d-cw sequence number field length of 0 bits." {108: 1} {41: 1} {40, 41} 114 "Note that an implementation MAY wish to constrain the maximum number of sequence numbers that are tracked, on platform-wide or per flow basis. Some implementations MAY support the provisioning of the maximum number of sequence numbers that are tracked on either a platform-wide or per flow basis." All comments were replied and fixed as per 8:00pm CET , 09 - 09 - 2020 277f76efd2c1f6d2040a8dd8f684c37826d12d75 277f76efd2c1f6d2040a8dd8f684c37826d12d75 draft-ietf-detnet-mpls 1f7f2b84a8eaad2d3d5210269e8d5b5ba9d20ef952d3919d142bee230120b5f0 ['1f7f2b84a8eaad2d3d5210269e8d5b5ba9d20ef952d3919d142bee230120b5f0', '4ce3bd6384eae7d27ece687757a2a7944388445af8ef5e40983088e229d81afb', '74181179e1bff7cb69469deba0503df7f1fb3c0ad51896ab11b8d038bf42a52a', 'd75d94ba607a565d21ce85603052a296c1d683f5fd6eec8aef0f6770260c9d9a'] A "note that an implementation may wish to constrain the maximum number of sequence numbers that are tracked, on platform-wide or per flow basis. some implementations may support the provisioning of the maximum number of sequence numbers that are tracked on either a platform-wide or per flow basis." {108: 1} {41: 1} {40, 41} 114 "After a DetNet service is identified for a received DetNet MPLS packet, as described above, if PEF is configured for that DetNet service, duplicate (replicated) instances of a particular sequence number MUST be discarded. The specific mechanisms used for an implementation to identify which received packets are duplicates and which are new is an implementation choice. Note that per dn-sn the sequence number field length may be 16 or 28 bits, and the field value can wrap. PEF MUST NOT be used with DetNet flows configured with a d-CW sequence number field length of 0 bits." All comments were replied and fixed as per 8:00pm CET , 09 - 09 - 2020 277f76efd2c1f6d2040a8dd8f684c37826d12d75 277f76efd2c1f6d2040a8dd8f684c37826d12d75 draft-ietf-detnet-mpls 74181179e1bff7cb69469deba0503df7f1fb3c0ad51896ab11b8d038bf42a52a ['1f7f2b84a8eaad2d3d5210269e8d5b5ba9d20ef952d3919d142bee230120b5f0', '4ce3bd6384eae7d27ece687757a2a7944388445af8ef5e40983088e229d81afb', '74181179e1bff7cb69469deba0503df7f1fb3c0ad51896ab11b8d038bf42a52a', 'd75d94ba607a565d21ce85603052a296c1d683f5fd6eec8aef0f6770260c9d9a'] B "after a detnet service is identified for a received detnet mpls packet, as described above, if pef is configured for that detnet service, duplicate (replicated) instances of a particular sequence number must be discarded. the specific mechanisms used for an implementation to identify which received packets are duplicates and which are new is an implementation choice. note that per dn-sn the sequence number field length may be 16 or 28 bits, and the field value can wrap. pef must not be used with detnet flows configured with a d-cw sequence number field length of 0 bits." {108: 1} {41: 1} {40, 41} 114 "An implementation MAY constrain the maximum number of sequence numbers that are tracked on either a platform-wide or per flow basis. Some implementations MAY support the provisioning of the maximum number of sequence numbers that are tracked on either a platform-wide or per flow basis." All comments were replied and fixed as per 8:00pm CET , 09 - 09 - 2020 277f76efd2c1f6d2040a8dd8f684c37826d12d75 277f76efd2c1f6d2040a8dd8f684c37826d12d75 draft-ietf-detnet-mpls 4ce3bd6384eae7d27ece687757a2a7944388445af8ef5e40983088e229d81afb ['1f7f2b84a8eaad2d3d5210269e8d5b5ba9d20ef952d3919d142bee230120b5f0', '4ce3bd6384eae7d27ece687757a2a7944388445af8ef5e40983088e229d81afb', '74181179e1bff7cb69469deba0503df7f1fb3c0ad51896ab11b8d038bf42a52a', 'd75d94ba607a565d21ce85603052a296c1d683f5fd6eec8aef0f6770260c9d9a'] B "an implementation may constrain the maximum number of sequence numbers that are tracked on either a platform-wide or per flow basis. some implementations may support the provisioning of the maximum number of sequence numbers that are tracked on either a platform-wide or per flow basis." {108: 1} {41: 1} {40, 41} 114 "A function that is related to in-order delivery is the Packet Ordering Function (POF). Implementations MAY support POF. When supported, use of the POF for a particular DetNet service MUST be provisioned via configuration, e.g., via the controller plane described by I-D.ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework. Implementations MAY required that PEF and POF be used in combination. There is no requirement related to the order of execution of the Packet Elimination and Ordering Functions in an implementation." All comments were replied and fixed as per 8:00pm CET , 09 - 09 - 2020 277f76efd2c1f6d2040a8dd8f684c37826d12d75 277f76efd2c1f6d2040a8dd8f684c37826d12d75 draft-ietf-detnet-mpls c6f6dbd9f111baec510404eaaf7c0816a502bc89ded8b56f8d2a29b3952b6784 ['0f368d586c974d820a494136ac75ec7711de5f3ad6055d47fd7f044c39e2a650', '06e9a71d86fd540cbf7aa66e82e5fe64ac7ad4a4e83351d45493544078c5049e', 'c15191de1964acb1424ebf36bed4db6b337a1a2cb39efd24eea174c21477e839', '726425e8c18f189049ae306decdadc174a68b748dbd4b8cbeda77caac341e932', 'aafa3a178fd9bd8461351b9d8ecf40b0ca97accb3a1d97c1ba48986decc575c7', 'c6f6dbd9f111baec510404eaaf7c0816a502bc89ded8b56f8d2a29b3952b6784'] A "a function that is related to in-order delivery is the packet ordering function (pof). implementations may support pof. when supported, use of the pof for a particular detnet service must be provisioned via configuration, e.g., via the controller plane described by i-d.ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework. implementations may required that pef and pof be used in combination. there is no requirement related to the order of execution of the packet elimination and ordering functions in an implementation." {} {} {} 114 "After a DetNet service is identified for a received DetNet MPLS packet, as described above, an implementation MUST check if POF is configured for that DetNet service. When configured, the implementation MUST track the sequence number contained in received d-CWs and MUST ensure that packets are processed in the order indicated in the received d-CW sequence number field, which may not be in the order the packets are received. As defined in dn-sn the sequence number field length may be 16 or 28 bits, is incremented by one (1) for each new MPLS packet sent for a particular DetNet service, and the field value can wrap. The specific mechanisms used for an implementation to identify the order of received packets is an implementation choice." All comments were replied and fixed as per 8:00pm CET , 09 - 09 - 2020 277f76efd2c1f6d2040a8dd8f684c37826d12d75 277f76efd2c1f6d2040a8dd8f684c37826d12d75 draft-ietf-detnet-mpls 0f368d586c974d820a494136ac75ec7711de5f3ad6055d47fd7f044c39e2a650 ['0f368d586c974d820a494136ac75ec7711de5f3ad6055d47fd7f044c39e2a650', '06e9a71d86fd540cbf7aa66e82e5fe64ac7ad4a4e83351d45493544078c5049e', 'c15191de1964acb1424ebf36bed4db6b337a1a2cb39efd24eea174c21477e839', '726425e8c18f189049ae306decdadc174a68b748dbd4b8cbeda77caac341e932', 'aafa3a178fd9bd8461351b9d8ecf40b0ca97accb3a1d97c1ba48986decc575c7', 'c6f6dbd9f111baec510404eaaf7c0816a502bc89ded8b56f8d2a29b3952b6784'] A "after a detnet service is identified for a received detnet mpls packet, as described above, an implementation must check if pof is configured for that detnet service. when configured, the implementation must track the sequence number contained in received d-cws and must ensure that packets are processed in the order indicated in the received d-cw sequence number field, which may not be in the order the packets are received. as defined in dn-sn the sequence number field length may be 16 or 28 bits, is incremented by one (1) for each new mpls packet sent for a particular detnet service, and the field value can wrap. the specific mechanisms used for an implementation to identify the order of received packets is an implementation choice." {} {} {} 114 "Note that an implementation MAY wish to constrain the maximum number of out of order packets that can be processed, on platform-wide or per flow basis. Some implementations MAY support the provisioning of this number on either a platform-wide or per flow basis. The number of out of order packets that can be processed also impacts the latency of a flow." All comments were replied and fixed as per 8:00pm CET , 09 - 09 - 2020 277f76efd2c1f6d2040a8dd8f684c37826d12d75 277f76efd2c1f6d2040a8dd8f684c37826d12d75 draft-ietf-detnet-mpls aafa3a178fd9bd8461351b9d8ecf40b0ca97accb3a1d97c1ba48986decc575c7 ['0f368d586c974d820a494136ac75ec7711de5f3ad6055d47fd7f044c39e2a650', '06e9a71d86fd540cbf7aa66e82e5fe64ac7ad4a4e83351d45493544078c5049e', 'c15191de1964acb1424ebf36bed4db6b337a1a2cb39efd24eea174c21477e839', '726425e8c18f189049ae306decdadc174a68b748dbd4b8cbeda77caac341e932', 'aafa3a178fd9bd8461351b9d8ecf40b0ca97accb3a1d97c1ba48986decc575c7', 'c6f6dbd9f111baec510404eaaf7c0816a502bc89ded8b56f8d2a29b3952b6784'] A "note that an implementation may wish to constrain the maximum number of out of order packets that can be processed, on platform-wide or per flow basis. some implementations may support the provisioning of this number on either a platform-wide or per flow basis. the number of out of order packets that can be processed also impacts the latency of a flow." {} {} {} 114 "A function that is related to in-order delivery is the Packet Ordering Function (POF). Implementations MAY support POF. When supported, use of the POF for a particular DetNet service MUST be provisioned via configuration, e.g., via the controller plane described by I-D.ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework. Implementations MAY require that PEF and POF be used in combination. There is no requirement related to the order of execution of the Packet Elimination and Ordering Functions in an implementation." All comments were replied and fixed as per 8:00pm CET , 09 - 09 - 2020 277f76efd2c1f6d2040a8dd8f684c37826d12d75 277f76efd2c1f6d2040a8dd8f684c37826d12d75 draft-ietf-detnet-mpls 06e9a71d86fd540cbf7aa66e82e5fe64ac7ad4a4e83351d45493544078c5049e ['0f368d586c974d820a494136ac75ec7711de5f3ad6055d47fd7f044c39e2a650', '06e9a71d86fd540cbf7aa66e82e5fe64ac7ad4a4e83351d45493544078c5049e', 'c15191de1964acb1424ebf36bed4db6b337a1a2cb39efd24eea174c21477e839', '726425e8c18f189049ae306decdadc174a68b748dbd4b8cbeda77caac341e932', 'aafa3a178fd9bd8461351b9d8ecf40b0ca97accb3a1d97c1ba48986decc575c7', 'c6f6dbd9f111baec510404eaaf7c0816a502bc89ded8b56f8d2a29b3952b6784'] B "a function that is related to in-order delivery is the packet ordering function (pof). implementations may support pof. when supported, use of the pof for a particular detnet service must be provisioned via configuration, e.g., via the controller plane described by i-d.ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework. implementations may require that pef and pof be used in combination. there is no requirement related to the order of execution of the packet elimination and ordering functions in an implementation." {} {} {} 114 "After a DetNet service is identified for a received DetNet MPLS packet, as described above, if POF is configured for that DetNet service, packets MUST be processed in the order indicated in the received d-CW sequence number field, which may not be in the order the packets are received. As defined in dn-sn the sequence number field length may be 16 or 28 bits, is incremented by one (1) for each new MPLS packet sent for a particular DetNet service, and the field value can wrap. The specific mechanisms used for an implementation to identify the order of received packets is an implementation choice." All comments were replied and fixed as per 8:00pm CET , 09 - 09 - 2020 277f76efd2c1f6d2040a8dd8f684c37826d12d75 277f76efd2c1f6d2040a8dd8f684c37826d12d75 draft-ietf-detnet-mpls c15191de1964acb1424ebf36bed4db6b337a1a2cb39efd24eea174c21477e839 ['0f368d586c974d820a494136ac75ec7711de5f3ad6055d47fd7f044c39e2a650', '06e9a71d86fd540cbf7aa66e82e5fe64ac7ad4a4e83351d45493544078c5049e', 'c15191de1964acb1424ebf36bed4db6b337a1a2cb39efd24eea174c21477e839', '726425e8c18f189049ae306decdadc174a68b748dbd4b8cbeda77caac341e932', 'aafa3a178fd9bd8461351b9d8ecf40b0ca97accb3a1d97c1ba48986decc575c7', 'c6f6dbd9f111baec510404eaaf7c0816a502bc89ded8b56f8d2a29b3952b6784'] B "after a detnet service is identified for a received detnet mpls packet, as described above, if pof is configured for that detnet service, packets must be processed in the order indicated in the received d-cw sequence number field, which may not be in the order the packets are received. as defined in dn-sn the sequence number field length may be 16 or 28 bits, is incremented by one (1) for each new mpls packet sent for a particular detnet service, and the field value can wrap. the specific mechanisms used for an implementation to identify the order of received packets is an implementation choice." {} {} {} 114 "An implementation MAY constrain the maximum number of out of order packets that can be processed, on either a platform-wide or per flow basis. The number of out of order packets that can be processed also impacts the latency of a flow." All comments were replied and fixed as per 8:00pm CET , 09 - 09 - 2020 277f76efd2c1f6d2040a8dd8f684c37826d12d75 277f76efd2c1f6d2040a8dd8f684c37826d12d75 draft-ietf-detnet-mpls 726425e8c18f189049ae306decdadc174a68b748dbd4b8cbeda77caac341e932 ['0f368d586c974d820a494136ac75ec7711de5f3ad6055d47fd7f044c39e2a650', '06e9a71d86fd540cbf7aa66e82e5fe64ac7ad4a4e83351d45493544078c5049e', 'c15191de1964acb1424ebf36bed4db6b337a1a2cb39efd24eea174c21477e839', '726425e8c18f189049ae306decdadc174a68b748dbd4b8cbeda77caac341e932', 'aafa3a178fd9bd8461351b9d8ecf40b0ca97accb3a1d97c1ba48986decc575c7', 'c6f6dbd9f111baec510404eaaf7c0816a502bc89ded8b56f8d2a29b3952b6784'] B "an implementation may constrain the maximum number of out of order packets that can be processed, on either a platform-wide or per flow basis. the number of out of order packets that can be processed also impacts the latency of a flow." {} {} {} 114 "When multiple sets of outgoing F-Labels or interfaces are provisioned for a particular DetNet service, a copy of the outgoing packet, including the pushed member flow-specific S-Label, MUST be made per F-label set and outgoing interface. Each set of provisioned F-Labels are then pushed onto a copy of the packet. Each copy is then forwarded as described below in f-labels-all." All comments were replied and fixed as per 8:00pm CET , 09 - 09 - 2020 277f76efd2c1f6d2040a8dd8f684c37826d12d75 277f76efd2c1f6d2040a8dd8f684c37826d12d75 draft-ietf-detnet-mpls 966f93f23681d2f1aa29ef2813cb307a8b3329986cf173d079fb55c512af3c4e ['966f93f23681d2f1aa29ef2813cb307a8b3329986cf173d079fb55c512af3c4e', 'f96362449a4034111fe61243f63903c67db70d689c7f76223b36426bcb90305d'] A "when multiple sets of outgoing f-labels or interfaces are provisioned for a particular detnet service, a copy of the outgoing packet, including the pushed member flow-specific s-label, must be made per f-label set and outgoing interface. each set of provisioned f-labels are then pushed onto a copy of the packet. each copy is then forwarded as described below in f-labels-all." {104: 1} {214: 1} {214, 230} 114 "When multiple sets of outgoing F-Labels or interfaces are provisioned for a particular DetNet service (i.e., for PRF), a copy of the outgoing packet, including the pushed member flow-specific S-Label, MUST be made per F-label set and outgoing interface. Each set of provisioned F-Labels are then pushed onto a copy of the packet. Each copy is then forwarded as described below in f-labels-all." All comments were replied and fixed as per 8:00pm CET , 09 - 09 - 2020 277f76efd2c1f6d2040a8dd8f684c37826d12d75 277f76efd2c1f6d2040a8dd8f684c37826d12d75 draft-ietf-detnet-mpls f96362449a4034111fe61243f63903c67db70d689c7f76223b36426bcb90305d ['966f93f23681d2f1aa29ef2813cb307a8b3329986cf173d079fb55c512af3c4e', 'f96362449a4034111fe61243f63903c67db70d689c7f76223b36426bcb90305d'] B "when multiple sets of outgoing f-labels or interfaces are provisioned for a particular detnet service (i.e., for prf), a copy of the outgoing packet, including the pushed member flow-specific s-label, must be made per f-label set and outgoing interface. each set of provisioned f-labels are then pushed onto a copy of the packet. each copy is then forwarded as described below in f-labels-all." {104: 1} {214: 1} {214, 230} 114 "DetNet flows forwarded via MPLS can leverage MPLS-TE's existing support for hierarchical LSPs (H-LSPs), see RFC4206. H-LSPs are typically used to aggregate control and resources, they may also be used to provide OAM or protection for the aggregated LSPs. Arbitrary levels of aggregation naturally falls out of the definition for hierarchy and the MPLS label stack RFC3032. DetNet nodes which support aggregation (LSP hierarchy) map one or more LSPs (labels) into and from an H-LSP. Both carried LSPs and H-LSPs may or may not use the TC field, i.e., L-LSPs or E-LSPs. Such nodes will need to ensure that individual LSPs and H-LSPs receive the traffic treatment required to ensure the required DetNet service is preserved." All comments were replied and fixed as per 8:00pm CET , 09 - 09 - 2020 277f76efd2c1f6d2040a8dd8f684c37826d12d75 277f76efd2c1f6d2040a8dd8f684c37826d12d75 draft-ietf-detnet-mpls 983d649ff42bfa47769c86c09f9048affd7cfac6c278d860f1071cdda1c15646 ['ce5a46a9298103fe7a7c4ce948ee0326ee502cc9d75cadf8dcd2541131a9681a', '983d649ff42bfa47769c86c09f9048affd7cfac6c278d860f1071cdda1c15646'] A "detnet flows forwarded via mpls can leverage mpls-te's existing support for hierarchical lsps (h-lsps), see rfc4206. h-lsps are typically used to aggregate control and resources, they may also be used to provide oam or protection for the aggregated lsps. arbitrary levels of aggregation naturally falls out of the definition for hierarchy and the mpls label stack rfc3032. detnet nodes which support aggregation (lsp hierarchy) map one or more lsps (labels) into and from an h-lsp. both carried lsps and h-lsps may or may not use the tc field, i.e., l-lsps or e-lsps. such nodes will need to ensure that individual lsps and h-lsps receive the traffic treatment required to ensure the required detnet service is preserved." {35: 1, 26: 3, 27: 2} {204: 1, 306: 3, 307: 2} {306, 307, 204, 326} 114 "DetNet flows forwarded via MPLS can leverage MPLS-TE's existing support for hierarchical LSPs (H-LSPs), see RFC4206. H-LSPs are typically used to aggregate control and resources, they may also be used to provide OAM or protection for the aggregated LSPs. Arbitrary levels of aggregation naturally falls out of the definition for hierarchy and the MPLS label stack RFC3032. DetNet nodes which support aggregation (LSP hierarchy) map one or more LSPs (labels) into and from an H-LSP. Both carried LSPs and H-LSPs may or may not use the TC field, i.e., L-LSPs or E-LSPs RFC3270. Such nodes will need to ensure that individual LSPs and H-LSPs receive the traffic treatment required to ensure the required DetNet service is preserved." All comments were replied and fixed as per 8:00pm CET , 09 - 09 - 2020 277f76efd2c1f6d2040a8dd8f684c37826d12d75 277f76efd2c1f6d2040a8dd8f684c37826d12d75 draft-ietf-detnet-mpls ce5a46a9298103fe7a7c4ce948ee0326ee502cc9d75cadf8dcd2541131a9681a ['ce5a46a9298103fe7a7c4ce948ee0326ee502cc9d75cadf8dcd2541131a9681a', '983d649ff42bfa47769c86c09f9048affd7cfac6c278d860f1071cdda1c15646'] B "detnet flows forwarded via mpls can leverage mpls-te's existing support for hierarchical lsps (h-lsps), see rfc4206. h-lsps are typically used to aggregate control and resources, they may also be used to provide oam or protection for the aggregated lsps. arbitrary levels of aggregation naturally falls out of the definition for hierarchy and the mpls label stack rfc3032. detnet nodes which support aggregation (lsp hierarchy) map one or more lsps (labels) into and from an h-lsp. both carried lsps and h-lsps may or may not use the tc field, i.e., l-lsps or e-lsps rfc3270. such nodes will need to ensure that individual lsps and h-lsps receive the traffic treatment required to ensure the required detnet service is preserved." {35: 1, 26: 3, 27: 2} {204: 1, 306: 3, 307: 2} {306, 307, 204, 326} 114 "The sequence number length to be used for the service. Valid values included 0, 16 and 28 bits. 0 bits cannot be used when PEF or POF is configured for the service." All comments were replied and fixed as per 8:00pm CET , 09 - 09 - 2020 277f76efd2c1f6d2040a8dd8f684c37826d12d75 277f76efd2c1f6d2040a8dd8f684c37826d12d75 draft-ietf-detnet-mpls 8f88aafd49bbdbe311b64f0a9b37658727b795186259deed4f2c15d657bac8ed ['8f88aafd49bbdbe311b64f0a9b37658727b795186259deed4f2c15d657bac8ed', '7942594a4acd620aa4f1ca29f630affff7a2331d4ddd6e469f2c817a73c165c8'] A "the sequence number length to be used for the service. valid values included 0, 16 and 28 bits. 0 bits cannot be used when pef or pof is configured for the service." {} {} {} 114 "The sequence number length to be used for the service. Valid values include 0, 16 and 28 bits. 0 bits cannot be used when PEF or POF is configured for the service." All comments were replied and fixed as per 8:00pm CET , 09 - 09 - 2020 277f76efd2c1f6d2040a8dd8f684c37826d12d75 277f76efd2c1f6d2040a8dd8f684c37826d12d75 draft-ietf-detnet-mpls 7942594a4acd620aa4f1ca29f630affff7a2331d4ddd6e469f2c817a73c165c8 ['8f88aafd49bbdbe311b64f0a9b37658727b795186259deed4f2c15d657bac8ed', '7942594a4acd620aa4f1ca29f630affff7a2331d4ddd6e469f2c817a73c165c8'] B "the sequence number length to be used for the service. valid values include 0, 16 and 28 bits. 0 bits cannot be used when pef or pof is configured for the service." {} {} {} 114 "The traffic parameters associated with a specific label in the stack. Note that there may be multiple sets of traffic paramters associated with specific labels in the stack, e.g., when H-LSPs are used." All comments were replied and fixed as per 8:00pm CET , 09 - 09 - 2020 277f76efd2c1f6d2040a8dd8f684c37826d12d75 277f76efd2c1f6d2040a8dd8f684c37826d12d75 draft-ietf-detnet-mpls 2e1188e3ae68f9645fceeb16885fb2558ac488250197b0dac87311b7f9fc7ba3 ['2e1188e3ae68f9645fceeb16885fb2558ac488250197b0dac87311b7f9fc7ba3', '3fc568a1763bb8ce8cf7e3511ef01027b3b5418c9300fc3f673a19102db68dc5'] A "the traffic parameters associated with a specific label in the stack. note that there may be multiple sets of traffic paramters associated with specific labels in the stack, e.g., when h-lsps are used." {38: 1, 6: 5, 79: 5, 90: 4, 51: 5, 130: 5, 62: 7, 85: 8, 68: 7, 35: 6, 110: 4, 91: 6, 97: 5, 31: 5, 13: 4, 67: 4, 26: 2, 124: 6, 98: 5, 54: 5, 127: 6, 8: 5, 96: 5, 64: 5, 30: 5, 61: 2, 55: 6, 27: 2, 15: 4, 52: 4, 129: 6, 115: 4, 84: 4, 76: 9, 87: 4, 131: 8, 102: 4, 113: 2, 99: 5, 36: 4, 24: 3, 114: 4, 53: 4, 72: 5} {96: 1, 1: 12, 4: 5, 9: 8, 10: 6, 15: 5, 24: 5, 25: 7, 26: 8, 27: 5, 39: 8, 43: 6, 49: 7, 50: 6, 59: 5, 64: 5, 69: 7, 81: 8, 82: 6, 86: 4, 97: 2, 100: 9, 108: 6, 109: 7, 110: 7, 111: 5, 114: 6, 115: 7, 116: 5, 118: 9, 119: 8, 120: 6, 121: 7, 122: 6, 123: 5, 124: 7, 128: 5, 129: 5, 130: 2, 132: 7, 136: 5, 145: 7, 147: 2, 151: 5, 152: 5, 154: 6, 156: 4, 161: 6, 162: 6, 165: 6, 168: 7, 169: 4, 172: 4, 180: 5, 184: 8, 187: 8, 188: 7, 191: 6, 194: 7, 202: 8, 203: 9, 206: 5, 207: 6, 215: 5, 217: 6, 218: 11, 220: 5, 221: 5, 222: 8, 224: 6, 227: 7, 229: 4, 234: 8, 235: 5, 241: 5, 242: 5, 243: 7, 244: 5, 245: 7, 248: 5, 250: 6, 258: 14, 262: 7, 263: 8, 264: 6, 267: 7, 270: 5, 272: 4, 273: 8, 287: 6, 289: 4, 291: 2, 299: 7, 300: 5, 304: 5, 309: 6, 314: 5, 315: 4, 320: 7, 323: 7, 327: 7, 328: 6, 329: 5, 330: 13, 334: 5, 335: 5, 341: 7, 342: 8, 347: 7, 348: 7, 350: 10, 351: 6, 352: 4, 353: 4, 354: 3, 358: 7, 365: 4, 366: 5, 369: 4, 371: 9, 372: 2, 376: 5, 384: 6, 385: 5, 386: 6, 387: 5, 392: 6, 393: 7, 396: 8, 397: 10, 398: 9, 402: 4} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 114 "The traffic parameters associated with a specific label in the stack. Note that there may be multiple sets of traffic parameters associated with specific labels in the stack, e.g., when H-LSPs are used." All comments were replied and fixed as per 8:00pm CET , 09 - 09 - 2020 277f76efd2c1f6d2040a8dd8f684c37826d12d75 277f76efd2c1f6d2040a8dd8f684c37826d12d75 draft-ietf-detnet-mpls 3fc568a1763bb8ce8cf7e3511ef01027b3b5418c9300fc3f673a19102db68dc5 ['2e1188e3ae68f9645fceeb16885fb2558ac488250197b0dac87311b7f9fc7ba3', '3fc568a1763bb8ce8cf7e3511ef01027b3b5418c9300fc3f673a19102db68dc5'] B "the traffic parameters associated with a specific label in the stack. note that there may be multiple sets of traffic parameters associated with specific labels in the stack, e.g., when h-lsps are used." {38: 1, 6: 5, 79: 5, 90: 4, 51: 5, 130: 5, 62: 7, 85: 8, 68: 7, 35: 6, 110: 4, 91: 6, 97: 5, 31: 5, 13: 4, 67: 4, 26: 2, 124: 6, 98: 5, 54: 5, 127: 6, 8: 5, 96: 5, 64: 5, 30: 5, 61: 2, 55: 6, 27: 2, 15: 4, 52: 4, 129: 6, 115: 4, 84: 4, 76: 9, 87: 4, 131: 8, 102: 4, 113: 2, 99: 5, 36: 4, 24: 3, 114: 4, 53: 4, 72: 5} {96: 1, 1: 12, 4: 5, 9: 8, 10: 6, 15: 5, 24: 5, 25: 7, 26: 8, 27: 5, 39: 8, 43: 6, 49: 7, 50: 6, 59: 5, 64: 5, 69: 7, 81: 8, 82: 6, 86: 4, 97: 2, 100: 9, 108: 6, 109: 7, 110: 7, 111: 5, 114: 6, 115: 7, 116: 5, 118: 9, 119: 8, 120: 6, 121: 7, 122: 6, 123: 5, 124: 7, 128: 5, 129: 5, 130: 2, 132: 7, 136: 5, 145: 7, 147: 2, 151: 5, 152: 5, 154: 6, 156: 4, 161: 6, 162: 6, 165: 6, 168: 7, 169: 4, 172: 4, 180: 5, 184: 8, 187: 8, 188: 7, 191: 6, 194: 7, 202: 8, 203: 9, 206: 5, 207: 6, 215: 5, 217: 6, 218: 11, 220: 5, 221: 5, 222: 8, 224: 6, 227: 7, 229: 4, 234: 8, 235: 5, 241: 5, 242: 5, 243: 7, 244: 5, 245: 7, 248: 5, 250: 6, 258: 14, 262: 7, 263: 8, 264: 6, 267: 7, 270: 5, 272: 4, 273: 8, 287: 6, 289: 4, 291: 2, 299: 7, 300: 5, 304: 5, 309: 6, 314: 5, 315: 4, 320: 7, 323: 7, 327: 7, 328: 6, 329: 5, 330: 13, 334: 5, 335: 5, 341: 7, 342: 8, 347: 7, 348: 7, 350: 10, 351: 6, 352: 4, 353: 4, 354: 3, 358: 7, 365: 4, 366: 5, 369: 4, 371: 9, 372: 2, 376: 5, 384: 6, 385: 5, 386: 6, 387: 5, 392: 6, 393: 7, 396: 8, 397: 10, 398: 9, 402: 4} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 114 "Security aspects which are unique to DetNet are those whose aim is to provide the specific quality of service aspects of DetNet, which are primarily to deliver data flows with extremely low packet loss rates and bounded end-to-end delivery latency. Achieving such loss rates and bounded latency may not be possible in the face of a highly capable adversary, such as the one envisioned by the Internet Threat Model of BCP 72 that can arbitrarily drop or delay any or all traffic. In order to present meaningful security considerations, we consider a somewhat weaker attacker who does not control the physical links of the DetNet domain, but may have the ability to control a network node within the boundary of the DetNet domain." All comments were replied and fixed as per 8:00pm CET , 09 - 09 - 2020 277f76efd2c1f6d2040a8dd8f684c37826d12d75 277f76efd2c1f6d2040a8dd8f684c37826d12d75 draft-ietf-detnet-mpls eb547f8c9c36b0996c65f740889b85778a420e2c66df1702b899dfbf731073b5 ['e30afecfc76617a262182c81ea5ad3d36ff6cb97f12269ce22b2831c27cb3ab3', '32410d6455a5f700b1f26feccb1956237c7dc712b1dc26a28d72f672dee33a5a', 'c80633f7615d515deb8d711fdb83a24d028160cde5ffcf1a468d1274102ea68c', 'eb547f8c9c36b0996c65f740889b85778a420e2c66df1702b899dfbf731073b5', '25c28a5868848979f5dd76423824da3aa80614e1e1ee88b8808cc5229c198605', 'ee9b5b83f6be958b69fb724f7649a128a0c2c5f604c03ba6f386f5049c671d91'] A "security aspects which are unique to detnet are those whose aim is to provide the specific quality of service aspects of detnet, which are primarily to deliver data flows with extremely low packet loss rates and bounded end-to-end delivery latency. achieving such loss rates and bounded latency may not be possible in the face of a highly capable adversary, such as the one envisioned by the internet threat model of bcp 72 that can arbitrarily drop or delay any or all traffic. in order to present meaningful security considerations, we consider a somewhat weaker attacker who does not control the physical links of the detnet domain, but may have the ability to control a network node within the boundary of the detnet domain." {102: 1, 15: 1, 36: 1, 24: 1, 6: 3, 79: 3, 90: 2, 51: 3, 130: 3, 62: 5, 85: 6, 68: 5, 35: 4, 110: 2, 91: 3, 114: 4, 97: 3, 31: 3, 13: 2, 67: 2, 38: 3, 26: 2, 124: 4, 98: 3, 54: 3, 127: 4, 8: 3, 96: 3, 64: 2, 30: 2, 61: 4, 55: 4, 27: 3, 52: 2, 129: 4, 115: 2, 84: 2, 76: 7, 87: 2, 131: 6, 113: 4, 99: 3, 53: 2, 72: 3} {272: 1, 352: 1, 353: 1, 354: 1, 1: 10, 4: 3, 9: 6, 10: 4, 15: 3, 24: 3, 25: 5, 26: 6, 27: 3, 39: 6, 43: 4, 49: 4, 50: 3, 58: 4, 59: 3, 64: 3, 69: 5, 81: 6, 82: 4, 86: 2, 96: 3, 97: 2, 100: 7, 108: 4, 109: 5, 110: 5, 111: 3, 114: 4, 115: 5, 116: 3, 118: 7, 119: 6, 120: 4, 121: 5, 122: 4, 123: 3, 124: 5, 128: 2, 129: 2, 130: 4, 132: 5, 136: 3, 145: 5, 147: 3, 151: 3, 152: 2, 154: 4, 156: 2, 161: 4, 162: 4, 165: 4, 168: 5, 169: 2, 172: 2, 180: 2, 184: 6, 187: 6, 188: 5, 191: 4, 194: 5, 202: 6, 203: 7, 206: 3, 207: 4, 215: 3, 217: 4, 218: 9, 220: 3, 221: 3, 222: 6, 224: 4, 227: 5, 229: 2, 234: 6, 235: 3, 241: 3, 242: 3, 243: 5, 244: 3, 245: 5, 248: 3, 250: 4, 258: 12, 262: 5, 263: 6, 264: 4, 267: 5, 270: 3, 273: 6, 287: 4, 289: 2, 291: 4, 299: 5, 300: 3, 304: 3, 309: 4, 314: 3, 315: 2, 320: 5, 323: 5, 327: 5, 328: 4, 329: 3, 330: 11, 334: 3, 335: 3, 341: 5, 342: 6, 347: 5, 348: 5, 350: 8, 351: 4, 358: 5, 366: 3, 369: 2, 371: 7, 372: 4, 376: 3, 384: 4, 385: 3, 386: 4, 387: 3, 392: 4, 393: 5, 396: 6, 397: 8, 398: 7, 402: 2} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 114 "The primary consideration for the DetNet data plane is to maintain integrity of data and delivery of the associated DetNet service traversing the DetNet network. Application flows can be protected through whatever means are provided by the underlying technology. For example, encryption may be used, such as that provided by IPsec RFC4301 for IP flows and/or by an underlying sub-net using MACSec IEEE802.1AE-2018 for IP over Ethernet (Layer-2) flows." All comments were replied and fixed as per 8:00pm CET , 09 - 09 - 2020 277f76efd2c1f6d2040a8dd8f684c37826d12d75 277f76efd2c1f6d2040a8dd8f684c37826d12d75 draft-ietf-detnet-mpls c80633f7615d515deb8d711fdb83a24d028160cde5ffcf1a468d1274102ea68c ['e30afecfc76617a262182c81ea5ad3d36ff6cb97f12269ce22b2831c27cb3ab3', '32410d6455a5f700b1f26feccb1956237c7dc712b1dc26a28d72f672dee33a5a', 'c80633f7615d515deb8d711fdb83a24d028160cde5ffcf1a468d1274102ea68c', 'eb547f8c9c36b0996c65f740889b85778a420e2c66df1702b899dfbf731073b5', '25c28a5868848979f5dd76423824da3aa80614e1e1ee88b8808cc5229c198605', 'ee9b5b83f6be958b69fb724f7649a128a0c2c5f604c03ba6f386f5049c671d91'] A "the primary consideration for the detnet data plane is to maintain integrity of data and delivery of the associated detnet service traversing the detnet network. application flows can be protected through whatever means are provided by the underlying technology. for example, encryption may be used, such as that provided by ipsec rfc4301 for ip flows and/or by an underlying sub-net using macsec ieee802.1ae-2018 for ip over ethernet (layer-2) flows." {102: 1, 15: 1, 36: 1, 24: 1, 6: 3, 79: 3, 90: 2, 51: 3, 130: 3, 62: 5, 85: 6, 68: 5, 35: 4, 110: 2, 91: 3, 114: 4, 97: 3, 31: 3, 13: 2, 67: 2, 38: 3, 26: 2, 124: 4, 98: 3, 54: 3, 127: 4, 8: 3, 96: 3, 64: 2, 30: 2, 61: 4, 55: 4, 27: 3, 52: 2, 129: 4, 115: 2, 84: 2, 76: 7, 87: 2, 131: 6, 113: 4, 99: 3, 53: 2, 72: 3} {272: 1, 352: 1, 353: 1, 354: 1, 1: 10, 4: 3, 9: 6, 10: 4, 15: 3, 24: 3, 25: 5, 26: 6, 27: 3, 39: 6, 43: 4, 49: 4, 50: 3, 58: 4, 59: 3, 64: 3, 69: 5, 81: 6, 82: 4, 86: 2, 96: 3, 97: 2, 100: 7, 108: 4, 109: 5, 110: 5, 111: 3, 114: 4, 115: 5, 116: 3, 118: 7, 119: 6, 120: 4, 121: 5, 122: 4, 123: 3, 124: 5, 128: 2, 129: 2, 130: 4, 132: 5, 136: 3, 145: 5, 147: 3, 151: 3, 152: 2, 154: 4, 156: 2, 161: 4, 162: 4, 165: 4, 168: 5, 169: 2, 172: 2, 180: 2, 184: 6, 187: 6, 188: 5, 191: 4, 194: 5, 202: 6, 203: 7, 206: 3, 207: 4, 215: 3, 217: 4, 218: 9, 220: 3, 221: 3, 222: 6, 224: 4, 227: 5, 229: 2, 234: 6, 235: 3, 241: 3, 242: 3, 243: 5, 244: 3, 245: 5, 248: 3, 250: 4, 258: 12, 262: 5, 263: 6, 264: 4, 267: 5, 270: 3, 273: 6, 287: 4, 289: 2, 291: 4, 299: 5, 300: 3, 304: 3, 309: 4, 314: 3, 315: 2, 320: 5, 323: 5, 327: 5, 328: 4, 329: 3, 330: 11, 334: 3, 335: 3, 341: 5, 342: 6, 347: 5, 348: 5, 350: 8, 351: 4, 358: 5, 366: 3, 369: 2, 371: 7, 372: 4, 376: 3, 384: 4, 385: 3, 386: 4, 387: 3, 392: 4, 393: 5, 396: 6, 397: 8, 398: 7, 402: 2} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 114 "From a data plane perspective this document does not add or modify any header information." All comments were replied and fixed as per 8:00pm CET , 09 - 09 - 2020 277f76efd2c1f6d2040a8dd8f684c37826d12d75 277f76efd2c1f6d2040a8dd8f684c37826d12d75 draft-ietf-detnet-mpls e30afecfc76617a262182c81ea5ad3d36ff6cb97f12269ce22b2831c27cb3ab3 ['e30afecfc76617a262182c81ea5ad3d36ff6cb97f12269ce22b2831c27cb3ab3', '32410d6455a5f700b1f26feccb1956237c7dc712b1dc26a28d72f672dee33a5a', 'c80633f7615d515deb8d711fdb83a24d028160cde5ffcf1a468d1274102ea68c', 'eb547f8c9c36b0996c65f740889b85778a420e2c66df1702b899dfbf731073b5', '25c28a5868848979f5dd76423824da3aa80614e1e1ee88b8808cc5229c198605', 'ee9b5b83f6be958b69fb724f7649a128a0c2c5f604c03ba6f386f5049c671d91'] A "from a data plane perspective this document does not add or modify any header information." {102: 1, 15: 1, 36: 1, 24: 1, 6: 3, 79: 3, 90: 2, 51: 3, 130: 3, 62: 5, 85: 6, 68: 5, 35: 4, 110: 2, 91: 3, 114: 4, 97: 3, 31: 3, 13: 2, 67: 2, 38: 3, 26: 2, 124: 4, 98: 3, 54: 3, 127: 4, 8: 3, 96: 3, 64: 2, 30: 2, 61: 4, 55: 4, 27: 3, 52: 2, 129: 4, 115: 2, 84: 2, 76: 7, 87: 2, 131: 6, 113: 4, 99: 3, 53: 2, 72: 3} {272: 1, 352: 1, 353: 1, 354: 1, 1: 10, 4: 3, 9: 6, 10: 4, 15: 3, 24: 3, 25: 5, 26: 6, 27: 3, 39: 6, 43: 4, 49: 4, 50: 3, 58: 4, 59: 3, 64: 3, 69: 5, 81: 6, 82: 4, 86: 2, 96: 3, 97: 2, 100: 7, 108: 4, 109: 5, 110: 5, 111: 3, 114: 4, 115: 5, 116: 3, 118: 7, 119: 6, 120: 4, 121: 5, 122: 4, 123: 3, 124: 5, 128: 2, 129: 2, 130: 4, 132: 5, 136: 3, 145: 5, 147: 3, 151: 3, 152: 2, 154: 4, 156: 2, 161: 4, 162: 4, 165: 4, 168: 5, 169: 2, 172: 2, 180: 2, 184: 6, 187: 6, 188: 5, 191: 4, 194: 5, 202: 6, 203: 7, 206: 3, 207: 4, 215: 3, 217: 4, 218: 9, 220: 3, 221: 3, 222: 6, 224: 4, 227: 5, 229: 2, 234: 6, 235: 3, 241: 3, 242: 3, 243: 5, 244: 3, 245: 5, 248: 3, 250: 4, 258: 12, 262: 5, 263: 6, 264: 4, 267: 5, 270: 3, 273: 6, 287: 4, 289: 2, 291: 4, 299: 5, 300: 3, 304: 3, 309: 4, 314: 3, 315: 2, 320: 5, 323: 5, 327: 5, 328: 4, 329: 3, 330: 11, 334: 3, 335: 3, 341: 5, 342: 6, 347: 5, 348: 5, 350: 8, 351: 4, 358: 5, 366: 3, 369: 2, 371: 7, 372: 4, 376: 3, 384: 4, 385: 3, 386: 4, 387: 3, 392: 4, 393: 5, 396: 6, 397: 8, 398: 7, 402: 2} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 114 "Security aspects which are unique to DetNet are those whose aim is to protect the support of specific quality of service aspects of DetNet, which are primarily to deliver data flows with extremely low packet loss rates and bounded end-to-end delivery latency. Achieving such loss rates and bounded latency may not be possible in the face of a highly capable adversary, such as the one envisioned by the Internet Threat Model of BCP 72 that can arbitrarily drop or delay any or all traffic. In order to present meaningful security considerations, we consider a somewhat weaker attacker who does not control the physical links of the DetNet domain, but may have the ability to control a network node within the boundary of the DetNet domain." All comments were replied and fixed as per 8:00pm CET , 09 - 09 - 2020 277f76efd2c1f6d2040a8dd8f684c37826d12d75 277f76efd2c1f6d2040a8dd8f684c37826d12d75 draft-ietf-detnet-mpls ee9b5b83f6be958b69fb724f7649a128a0c2c5f604c03ba6f386f5049c671d91 ['e30afecfc76617a262182c81ea5ad3d36ff6cb97f12269ce22b2831c27cb3ab3', '32410d6455a5f700b1f26feccb1956237c7dc712b1dc26a28d72f672dee33a5a', 'c80633f7615d515deb8d711fdb83a24d028160cde5ffcf1a468d1274102ea68c', 'eb547f8c9c36b0996c65f740889b85778a420e2c66df1702b899dfbf731073b5', '25c28a5868848979f5dd76423824da3aa80614e1e1ee88b8808cc5229c198605', 'ee9b5b83f6be958b69fb724f7649a128a0c2c5f604c03ba6f386f5049c671d91'] B "security aspects which are unique to detnet are those whose aim is to protect the support of specific quality of service aspects of detnet, which are primarily to deliver data flows with extremely low packet loss rates and bounded end-to-end delivery latency. achieving such loss rates and bounded latency may not be possible in the face of a highly capable adversary, such as the one envisioned by the internet threat model of bcp 72 that can arbitrarily drop or delay any or all traffic. in order to present meaningful security considerations, we consider a somewhat weaker attacker who does not control the physical links of the detnet domain, but may have the ability to control a network node within the boundary of the detnet domain." {102: 1, 15: 1, 36: 1, 24: 1, 6: 3, 79: 3, 90: 2, 51: 3, 130: 3, 62: 5, 85: 6, 68: 5, 35: 4, 110: 2, 91: 3, 114: 4, 97: 3, 31: 3, 13: 2, 67: 2, 38: 3, 26: 2, 124: 4, 98: 3, 54: 3, 127: 4, 8: 3, 96: 3, 64: 2, 30: 2, 61: 4, 55: 4, 27: 3, 52: 2, 129: 4, 115: 2, 84: 2, 76: 7, 87: 2, 131: 6, 113: 4, 99: 3, 53: 2, 72: 3} {272: 1, 352: 1, 353: 1, 354: 1, 1: 10, 4: 3, 9: 6, 10: 4, 15: 3, 24: 3, 25: 5, 26: 6, 27: 3, 39: 6, 43: 4, 49: 4, 50: 3, 58: 4, 59: 3, 64: 3, 69: 5, 81: 6, 82: 4, 86: 2, 96: 3, 97: 2, 100: 7, 108: 4, 109: 5, 110: 5, 111: 3, 114: 4, 115: 5, 116: 3, 118: 7, 119: 6, 120: 4, 121: 5, 122: 4, 123: 3, 124: 5, 128: 2, 129: 2, 130: 4, 132: 5, 136: 3, 145: 5, 147: 3, 151: 3, 152: 2, 154: 4, 156: 2, 161: 4, 162: 4, 165: 4, 168: 5, 169: 2, 172: 2, 180: 2, 184: 6, 187: 6, 188: 5, 191: 4, 194: 5, 202: 6, 203: 7, 206: 3, 207: 4, 215: 3, 217: 4, 218: 9, 220: 3, 221: 3, 222: 6, 224: 4, 227: 5, 229: 2, 234: 6, 235: 3, 241: 3, 242: 3, 243: 5, 244: 3, 245: 5, 248: 3, 250: 4, 258: 12, 262: 5, 263: 6, 264: 4, 267: 5, 270: 3, 273: 6, 287: 4, 289: 2, 291: 4, 299: 5, 300: 3, 304: 3, 309: 4, 314: 3, 315: 2, 320: 5, 323: 5, 327: 5, 328: 4, 329: 3, 330: 11, 334: 3, 335: 3, 341: 5, 342: 6, 347: 5, 348: 5, 350: 8, 351: 4, 358: 5, 366: 3, 369: 2, 371: 7, 372: 4, 376: 3, 384: 4, 385: 3, 386: 4, 387: 3, 392: 4, 393: 5, 396: 6, 397: 8, 398: 7, 402: 2} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 114 "An additional consideration for the DetNet data plane is to maintain integrity of data and delivery of the associated DetNet service traversing the DetNet network. Application flows can be protected through whatever means are provided by the underlying technology. For example, encryption may be used, such as that provided by IPsec RFC4301 for IP flows and/or by an underlying sub-net using MACSec IEEE802.1AE-2018 for IP over Ethernet (Layer-2) flows. MPLS doesn't provide any native security services to account for confidentiality and integrity." All comments were replied and fixed as per 8:00pm CET , 09 - 09 - 2020 277f76efd2c1f6d2040a8dd8f684c37826d12d75 277f76efd2c1f6d2040a8dd8f684c37826d12d75 draft-ietf-detnet-mpls 25c28a5868848979f5dd76423824da3aa80614e1e1ee88b8808cc5229c198605 ['e30afecfc76617a262182c81ea5ad3d36ff6cb97f12269ce22b2831c27cb3ab3', '32410d6455a5f700b1f26feccb1956237c7dc712b1dc26a28d72f672dee33a5a', 'c80633f7615d515deb8d711fdb83a24d028160cde5ffcf1a468d1274102ea68c', 'eb547f8c9c36b0996c65f740889b85778a420e2c66df1702b899dfbf731073b5', '25c28a5868848979f5dd76423824da3aa80614e1e1ee88b8808cc5229c198605', 'ee9b5b83f6be958b69fb724f7649a128a0c2c5f604c03ba6f386f5049c671d91'] B "an additional consideration for the detnet data plane is to maintain integrity of data and delivery of the associated detnet service traversing the detnet network. application flows can be protected through whatever means are provided by the underlying technology. for example, encryption may be used, such as that provided by ipsec rfc4301 for ip flows and/or by an underlying sub-net using macsec ieee802.1ae-2018 for ip over ethernet (layer-2) flows. mpls doesn't provide any native security services to account for confidentiality and integrity." {102: 1, 15: 1, 36: 1, 24: 1, 6: 3, 79: 3, 90: 2, 51: 3, 130: 3, 62: 5, 85: 6, 68: 5, 35: 4, 110: 2, 91: 3, 114: 4, 97: 3, 31: 3, 13: 2, 67: 2, 38: 3, 26: 2, 124: 4, 98: 3, 54: 3, 127: 4, 8: 3, 96: 3, 64: 2, 30: 2, 61: 4, 55: 4, 27: 3, 52: 2, 129: 4, 115: 2, 84: 2, 76: 7, 87: 2, 131: 6, 113: 4, 99: 3, 53: 2, 72: 3} {272: 1, 352: 1, 353: 1, 354: 1, 1: 10, 4: 3, 9: 6, 10: 4, 15: 3, 24: 3, 25: 5, 26: 6, 27: 3, 39: 6, 43: 4, 49: 4, 50: 3, 58: 4, 59: 3, 64: 3, 69: 5, 81: 6, 82: 4, 86: 2, 96: 3, 97: 2, 100: 7, 108: 4, 109: 5, 110: 5, 111: 3, 114: 4, 115: 5, 116: 3, 118: 7, 119: 6, 120: 4, 121: 5, 122: 4, 123: 3, 124: 5, 128: 2, 129: 2, 130: 4, 132: 5, 136: 3, 145: 5, 147: 3, 151: 3, 152: 2, 154: 4, 156: 2, 161: 4, 162: 4, 165: 4, 168: 5, 169: 2, 172: 2, 180: 2, 184: 6, 187: 6, 188: 5, 191: 4, 194: 5, 202: 6, 203: 7, 206: 3, 207: 4, 215: 3, 217: 4, 218: 9, 220: 3, 221: 3, 222: 6, 224: 4, 227: 5, 229: 2, 234: 6, 235: 3, 241: 3, 242: 3, 243: 5, 244: 3, 245: 5, 248: 3, 250: 4, 258: 12, 262: 5, 263: 6, 264: 4, 267: 5, 270: 3, 273: 6, 287: 4, 289: 2, 291: 4, 299: 5, 300: 3, 304: 3, 309: 4, 314: 3, 315: 2, 320: 5, 323: 5, 327: 5, 328: 4, 329: 3, 330: 11, 334: 3, 335: 3, 341: 5, 342: 6, 347: 5, 348: 5, 350: 8, 351: 4, 358: 5, 366: 3, 369: 2, 371: 7, 372: 4, 376: 3, 384: 4, 385: 3, 386: 4, 387: 3, 392: 4, 393: 5, 396: 6, 397: 8, 398: 7, 402: 2} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 114 "From a data plane perspective this document does not add or modify any application header information." All comments were replied and fixed as per 8:00pm CET , 09 - 09 - 2020 277f76efd2c1f6d2040a8dd8f684c37826d12d75 277f76efd2c1f6d2040a8dd8f684c37826d12d75 draft-ietf-detnet-mpls 32410d6455a5f700b1f26feccb1956237c7dc712b1dc26a28d72f672dee33a5a ['e30afecfc76617a262182c81ea5ad3d36ff6cb97f12269ce22b2831c27cb3ab3', '32410d6455a5f700b1f26feccb1956237c7dc712b1dc26a28d72f672dee33a5a', 'c80633f7615d515deb8d711fdb83a24d028160cde5ffcf1a468d1274102ea68c', 'eb547f8c9c36b0996c65f740889b85778a420e2c66df1702b899dfbf731073b5', '25c28a5868848979f5dd76423824da3aa80614e1e1ee88b8808cc5229c198605', 'ee9b5b83f6be958b69fb724f7649a128a0c2c5f604c03ba6f386f5049c671d91'] B "from a data plane perspective this document does not add or modify any application header information." {102: 1, 15: 1, 36: 1, 24: 1, 6: 3, 79: 3, 90: 2, 51: 3, 130: 3, 62: 5, 85: 6, 68: 5, 35: 4, 110: 2, 91: 3, 114: 4, 97: 3, 31: 3, 13: 2, 67: 2, 38: 3, 26: 2, 124: 4, 98: 3, 54: 3, 127: 4, 8: 3, 96: 3, 64: 2, 30: 2, 61: 4, 55: 4, 27: 3, 52: 2, 129: 4, 115: 2, 84: 2, 76: 7, 87: 2, 131: 6, 113: 4, 99: 3, 53: 2, 72: 3} {272: 1, 352: 1, 353: 1, 354: 1, 1: 10, 4: 3, 9: 6, 10: 4, 15: 3, 24: 3, 25: 5, 26: 6, 27: 3, 39: 6, 43: 4, 49: 4, 50: 3, 58: 4, 59: 3, 64: 3, 69: 5, 81: 6, 82: 4, 86: 2, 96: 3, 97: 2, 100: 7, 108: 4, 109: 5, 110: 5, 111: 3, 114: 4, 115: 5, 116: 3, 118: 7, 119: 6, 120: 4, 121: 5, 122: 4, 123: 3, 124: 5, 128: 2, 129: 2, 130: 4, 132: 5, 136: 3, 145: 5, 147: 3, 151: 3, 152: 2, 154: 4, 156: 2, 161: 4, 162: 4, 165: 4, 168: 5, 169: 2, 172: 2, 180: 2, 184: 6, 187: 6, 188: 5, 191: 4, 194: 5, 202: 6, 203: 7, 206: 3, 207: 4, 215: 3, 217: 4, 218: 9, 220: 3, 221: 3, 222: 6, 224: 4, 227: 5, 229: 2, 234: 6, 235: 3, 241: 3, 242: 3, 243: 5, 244: 3, 245: 5, 248: 3, 250: 4, 258: 12, 262: 5, 263: 6, 264: 4, 267: 5, 270: 3, 273: 6, 287: 4, 289: 2, 291: 4, 299: 5, 300: 3, 304: 3, 309: 4, 314: 3, 315: 2, 320: 5, 323: 5, 327: 5, 328: 4, 329: 3, 330: 11, 334: 3, 335: 3, 341: 5, 342: 6, 347: 5, 348: 5, 350: 8, 351: 4, 358: 5, 366: 3, 369: 2, 371: 7, 372: 4, 376: 3, 384: 4, 385: 3, 386: 4, 387: 3, 392: 4, 393: 5, 396: 6, 397: 8, 398: 7, 402: 2} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 114 "To provide uninterrupted availability of the DetNet service, provisions can be made against DOS attacks and delay attacks. To protect against DOS attacks, excess traffic due to malicious or malfunctioning devices is prevented or mitigated through the use of existing mechanisms, for example by policing and shaping incoming traffic. To prevent DetNet packets from being delayed by an entity external to a DetNet domain, DetNet technology definition can allow for the mitigation of Man-In-The-Middle attacks, for example through use of authentication and authorization of devices within the DetNet domain." All comments were replied and fixed as per 8:00pm CET , 09 - 09 - 2020 277f76efd2c1f6d2040a8dd8f684c37826d12d75 277f76efd2c1f6d2040a8dd8f684c37826d12d75 draft-ietf-detnet-mpls 0e9a4286b4af3d821d8e9cc7fa8cd14950f7e31c52062b39ac83386ae410efad ['3c75c7253001ac57d6c8a269c8f4df047ddb7afb81234ce62ee0ef93954eba74', '0e9a4286b4af3d821d8e9cc7fa8cd14950f7e31c52062b39ac83386ae410efad'] A "to provide uninterrupted availability of the detnet service, provisions can be made against dos attacks and delay attacks. to protect against dos attacks, excess traffic due to malicious or malfunctioning devices is prevented or mitigated through the use of existing mechanisms, for example by policing and shaping incoming traffic. to prevent detnet packets from being delayed by an entity external to a detnet domain, detnet technology definition can allow for the mitigation of man-in-the-middle attacks, for example through use of authentication and authorization of devices within the detnet domain." {117: 1} {93: 1} {92, 93} 114 "To provide uninterrupted availability of the DetNet service, provisions can be made against DOS attacks and delay attacks. To protect against DOS attacks, excess traffic due to malicious or malfunctioning devices is prevented or mitigated through the use of existing mechanisms, for example by policing and shaping incoming traffic. To prevent DetNet packets from being delayed by an entity external to a DetNet domain, DetNet technology definition can allow for the mitigation of on-path attackers, for example through use of authentication and authorization of devices within the DetNet domain." All comments were replied and fixed as per 8:00pm CET , 09 - 09 - 2020 277f76efd2c1f6d2040a8dd8f684c37826d12d75 277f76efd2c1f6d2040a8dd8f684c37826d12d75 draft-ietf-detnet-mpls 3c75c7253001ac57d6c8a269c8f4df047ddb7afb81234ce62ee0ef93954eba74 ['3c75c7253001ac57d6c8a269c8f4df047ddb7afb81234ce62ee0ef93954eba74', '0e9a4286b4af3d821d8e9cc7fa8cd14950f7e31c52062b39ac83386ae410efad'] B "to provide uninterrupted availability of the detnet service, provisions can be made against dos attacks and delay attacks. to protect against dos attacks, excess traffic due to malicious or malfunctioning devices is prevented or mitigated through the use of existing mechanisms, for example by policing and shaping incoming traffic. to prevent detnet packets from being delayed by an entity external to a detnet domain, detnet technology definition can allow for the mitigation of on-path attackers, for example through use of authentication and authorization of devices within the detnet domain." {117: 1} {93: 1} {92, 93} 113 "A DetNet control word (d-CW) conforms to the Generic PW MPLS Control Word (PWMCW) defined in RFC4385. The d-CW formatted as shown in fig_detnet_cw MUST be present in all DetNet packets containing app- flow data. This format of the d-CW was created in order (1) to allow larger S/N space to avoid S/N rollover frequency in some applications and (2) to allow non-skip zero S/N what simplifies implementation." reference ( change framework to normative ) editorial ( zero as a valid sequence number topic ) 012e03396de0029b54ec65b26be02c3d29b7990d 012e03396de0029b54ec65b26be02c3d29b7990d draft-ietf-detnet-mpls 4dfe254c613424642c3643346654f0e0382b4073502256a9b94c0dde78d6aabf ['4dfe254c613424642c3643346654f0e0382b4073502256a9b94c0dde78d6aabf', '38076a02f6aa326089456ce89f52dd1100783147599300d0e4b60825a9fbe4e2'] A "a detnet control word (d-cw) conforms to the generic pw mpls control word (pwmcw) defined in rfc4385. the d-cw formatted as shown in fig_detnet_cw must be present in all detnet packets containing app- flow data. this format of the d-cw was created in order (1) to allow larger s/n space to avoid s/n rollover frequency in some applications and (2) to allow non-skip zero s/n what simplifies implementation." {72: 1, 114: 1} {288: 1, 219: 1} {288, 219, 125} 113 "A DetNet control word (d-CW) conforms to the Generic PW MPLS Control Word (PWMCW) defined in RFC4385. The d-CW formatted as shown in fig_detnet_cw MUST be present in all DetNet packets containing app- flow data. This format of the d-CW was created in order (1) to allow larger S/N space to avoid S/N rollover frequency in some applications and (2) to allow sequence numbering systems that include the value zero as a valid sequence number, which simplifies implementation." reference ( change framework to normative ) editorial ( zero as a valid sequence number topic ) 012e03396de0029b54ec65b26be02c3d29b7990d 012e03396de0029b54ec65b26be02c3d29b7990d draft-ietf-detnet-mpls 38076a02f6aa326089456ce89f52dd1100783147599300d0e4b60825a9fbe4e2 ['4dfe254c613424642c3643346654f0e0382b4073502256a9b94c0dde78d6aabf', '38076a02f6aa326089456ce89f52dd1100783147599300d0e4b60825a9fbe4e2'] B "a detnet control word (d-cw) conforms to the generic pw mpls control word (pwmcw) defined in rfc4385. the d-cw formatted as shown in fig_detnet_cw must be present in all detnet packets containing app- flow data. this format of the d-cw was created in order (1) to allow larger s/n space to avoid s/n rollover frequency in some applications and (2) to allow sequence numbering systems that include the value zero as a valid sequence number, which simplifies implementation." {72: 1, 114: 1} {288: 1, 219: 1} {288, 219, 125} 113 "When the sequence number field length is 16 or 28 bits for a flow, the sequence number MUST be incremented by one for each new app-flow packet sent. When the field length is 16 bits, d-CW bits 4 to 15 MUST be set to zero (0). The values carried in this field can wrap and it is important to note that zero (0) is a valid field value. For example, were the sequence number size is 16 bits, the sequence will contain: 65535, 0, 1, where zero (0) is an ordinary sequence number." reference ( change framework to normative ) editorial ( zero as a valid sequence number topic ) 012e03396de0029b54ec65b26be02c3d29b7990d 012e03396de0029b54ec65b26be02c3d29b7990d draft-ietf-detnet-mpls 6d7ab6393f61f074f755e5a9dd65269b554f82f124566d0c343bb84611d6df18 ['6d7ab6393f61f074f755e5a9dd65269b554f82f124566d0c343bb84611d6df18', 'b739cee7ff4cddb91d2ba02e2ab3ecfd1b045bcfd03045b299dc77baf19ac9db'] A "when the sequence number field length is 16 or 28 bits for a flow, the sequence number must be incremented by one for each new app-flow packet sent. when the field length is 16 bits, d-cw bits 4 to 15 must be set to zero (0). the values carried in this field can wrap and it is important to note that zero (0) is a valid field value. for example, were the sequence number size is 16 bits, the sequence will contain: 65535, 0, 1, where zero (0) is an ordinary sequence number." {38: 1} {195: 1} {195, 174} 113 "When the sequence number field length is 16 or 28 bits for a flow, the sequence number MUST be incremented by one for each new app-flow packet sent. When the field length is 16 bits, d-CW bits 4 to 15 MUST be set to zero (0). The values carried in this field can wrap and it is important to note that zero (0) is a valid field value. For example, where the sequence number size is 16 bits, the sequence will contain: 65535, 0, 1, where zero (0) is an ordinary sequence number." reference ( change framework to normative ) editorial ( zero as a valid sequence number topic ) 012e03396de0029b54ec65b26be02c3d29b7990d 012e03396de0029b54ec65b26be02c3d29b7990d draft-ietf-detnet-mpls b739cee7ff4cddb91d2ba02e2ab3ecfd1b045bcfd03045b299dc77baf19ac9db ['6d7ab6393f61f074f755e5a9dd65269b554f82f124566d0c343bb84611d6df18', 'b739cee7ff4cddb91d2ba02e2ab3ecfd1b045bcfd03045b299dc77baf19ac9db'] B "when the sequence number field length is 16 or 28 bits for a flow, the sequence number must be incremented by one for each new app-flow packet sent. when the field length is 16 bits, d-cw bits 4 to 15 must be set to zero (0). the values carried in this field can wrap and it is important to note that zero (0) is a valid field value. for example, where the sequence number size is 16 bits, the sequence will contain: 65535, 0, 1, where zero (0) is an ordinary sequence number." {38: 1} {195: 1} {195, 174} 113 "Similarly, an Entropy Label Indicator/Entropy Label (ELI/EL) RFC6790 MAY be carried below the S-Label in the label stack in networks where DetNet flows would otherwise received ECMP treatment. When ELs are used, the same EL value SHOULD be used for all of the packets sent using a specific S-Label to force the flow to follow the same path. However, as outlines in I-D.ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework the use of ECMP for DetNet flows is NOT RECOMMENDED. ECMP MAY be used for non-DetNet flows within a DetNet domain." reference ( change framework to normative ) editorial ( zero as a valid sequence number topic ) 012e03396de0029b54ec65b26be02c3d29b7990d 012e03396de0029b54ec65b26be02c3d29b7990d draft-ietf-detnet-mpls 785883f852224ec13a46a57228ca4fabeb29f37e2c67beb801f4be44afe115c6 ['785883f852224ec13a46a57228ca4fabeb29f37e2c67beb801f4be44afe115c6', 'fe655c38ec8539f882d03165056c8d797e063939855e400c221507bcca2045a2'] A "similarly, an entropy label indicator/entropy label (eli/el) rfc6790 may be carried below the s-label in the label stack in networks where detnet flows would otherwise received ecmp treatment. when els are used, the same el value should be used for all of the packets sent using a specific s-label to force the flow to follow the same path. however, as outlines in i-d.ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework the use of ecmp for detnet flows is not recommended. ecmp may be used for non-detnet flows within a detnet domain." {114: 1} {408: 1} {408, 183} 113 "Similarly, an Entropy Label Indicator/Entropy Label (ELI/EL) RFC6790 MAY be carried below the S-Label in the label stack in networks where DetNet flows would otherwise received ECMP treatment. When ELs are used, the same EL value SHOULD be used for all of the packets sent using a specific S-Label to force the flow to follow the same path. However, as outlined in I-D.ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework the use of ECMP for DetNet flows is NOT RECOMMENDED. ECMP MAY be used for non-DetNet flows within a DetNet domain." reference ( change framework to normative ) editorial ( zero as a valid sequence number topic ) 012e03396de0029b54ec65b26be02c3d29b7990d 012e03396de0029b54ec65b26be02c3d29b7990d draft-ietf-detnet-mpls fe655c38ec8539f882d03165056c8d797e063939855e400c221507bcca2045a2 ['785883f852224ec13a46a57228ca4fabeb29f37e2c67beb801f4be44afe115c6', 'fe655c38ec8539f882d03165056c8d797e063939855e400c221507bcca2045a2'] B "similarly, an entropy label indicator/entropy label (eli/el) rfc6790 may be carried below the s-label in the label stack in networks where detnet flows would otherwise received ecmp treatment. when els are used, the same el value should be used for all of the packets sent using a specific s-label to force the flow to follow the same path. however, as outlined in i-d.ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework the use of ecmp for detnet flows is not recommended. ecmp may be used for non-detnet flows within a detnet domain." {114: 1} {408: 1} {408, 183} 113 "F-Labels are supported the DetNet forwarding sub-layer. F-Labels are used to provide LSP-based connectivity between DetNet service sub- layer processing nodes." reference ( change framework to normative ) editorial ( zero as a valid sequence number topic ) 012e03396de0029b54ec65b26be02c3d29b7990d 012e03396de0029b54ec65b26be02c3d29b7990d draft-ietf-detnet-mpls f6a71c1f6920d6951277682bb4ea32bb138295225cb7c6e83e40b4e86f0f8866 ['f6a71c1f6920d6951277682bb4ea32bb138295225cb7c6e83e40b4e86f0f8866', 'fa2c2f58c0a810b21cd48bb60608370dd64f2fe94fccc535432fc6cd5721b7f5'] A "f-labels are supported the detnet forwarding sub-layer. f-labels are used to provide lsp-based connectivity between detnet service sub- layer processing nodes." {} {} {} 113 "F-Labels support the DetNet forwarding sub-layer. F-Labels are used to provide LSP-based connectivity between DetNet service sub-layer processing nodes." reference ( change framework to normative ) editorial ( zero as a valid sequence number topic ) 012e03396de0029b54ec65b26be02c3d29b7990d 012e03396de0029b54ec65b26be02c3d29b7990d draft-ietf-detnet-mpls fa2c2f58c0a810b21cd48bb60608370dd64f2fe94fccc535432fc6cd5721b7f5 ['f6a71c1f6920d6951277682bb4ea32bb138295225cb7c6e83e40b4e86f0f8866', 'fa2c2f58c0a810b21cd48bb60608370dd64f2fe94fccc535432fc6cd5721b7f5'] B "f-labels support the detnet forwarding sub-layer. f-labels are used to provide lsp-based connectivity between detnet service sub-layer processing nodes." {} {} {} 113 "Resources may be allocated in a hierarchical fashion per LSP that is represented by each F-Label. Each LSP MAY be provisioned with a service parameters that dictates the specific traffic treatment to be received by the traffic carried over that LSP. Implementations of this document MUST ensure that traffic carried over each LSP represented by one or more F-Labels receives the traffic treatment provisioned for that LSP. Typical mechanisms used to provide different treatment to different flows includes the allocation of system resources (such as queues and buffers) and provisioning or related parameters (such as shaping, and policing) that may be found in implementations of RFC2205 (RSVP) and RSVP-TE RFC3209 and RFC3473. Support can also be provided via an underlying network technology such IEEE802.1 TSN I-D.ietf-detnet-mpls-over-tsn. The specific mechanisms selected by a DetNet node to ensure DetNet service delivery requirements are met for supported DetNet flows is outside the scope of this document." reference ( change framework to normative ) editorial ( zero as a valid sequence number topic ) 012e03396de0029b54ec65b26be02c3d29b7990d 012e03396de0029b54ec65b26be02c3d29b7990d draft-ietf-detnet-mpls 752e921493231756cd917f50ee4eb90a38933ae2236b8433d007bf334a4695f7 ['752e921493231756cd917f50ee4eb90a38933ae2236b8433d007bf334a4695f7', '1f236345e753aa62b018f985c40e9e2a367ad641222686d300ccedd09d6ff925'] A "resources may be allocated in a hierarchical fashion per lsp that is represented by each f-label. each lsp may be provisioned with a service parameters that dictates the specific traffic treatment to be received by the traffic carried over that lsp. implementations of this document must ensure that traffic carried over each lsp represented by one or more f-labels receives the traffic treatment provisioned for that lsp. typical mechanisms used to provide different treatment to different flows includes the allocation of system resources (such as queues and buffers) and provisioning or related parameters (such as shaping, and policing) that may be found in implementations of rfc2205 (rsvp) and rsvp-te rfc3209 and rfc3473. support can also be provided via an underlying network technology such ieee802.1 tsn i-d.ietf-detnet-mpls-over-tsn. the specific mechanisms selected by a detnet node to ensure detnet service delivery requirements are met for supported detnet flows is outside the scope of this document." {} {} {} 113 "Resources may be allocated in a hierarchical fashion per LSP that is represented by each F-Label. Each LSP MAY be provisioned with a service parameter that dictates the specific traffic treatment to be received by the traffic carried over that LSP. Implementations of this document MUST ensure that traffic carried over each LSP represented by one or more F-Labels receives the traffic treatment provisioned for that LSP. Typical mechanisms used to provide different treatment to different flows includes the allocation of system resources (such as queues and buffers) and provisioning of related parameters (such as shaping, and policing) that may be found in implementations of RFC2205 (RSVP) and RSVP-TE RFC3209 and RFC3473. Support can also be provided via an underlying network technology such IEEE802.1 TSN I-D.ietf-detnet-mpls-over-tsn. The specific mechanisms selected by a DetNet node to ensure DetNet service delivery requirements are met for supported DetNet flows is outside the scope of this document." reference ( change framework to normative ) editorial ( zero as a valid sequence number topic ) 012e03396de0029b54ec65b26be02c3d29b7990d 012e03396de0029b54ec65b26be02c3d29b7990d draft-ietf-detnet-mpls 1f236345e753aa62b018f985c40e9e2a367ad641222686d300ccedd09d6ff925 ['752e921493231756cd917f50ee4eb90a38933ae2236b8433d007bf334a4695f7', '1f236345e753aa62b018f985c40e9e2a367ad641222686d300ccedd09d6ff925'] B "resources may be allocated in a hierarchical fashion per lsp that is represented by each f-label. each lsp may be provisioned with a service parameter that dictates the specific traffic treatment to be received by the traffic carried over that lsp. implementations of this document must ensure that traffic carried over each lsp represented by one or more f-labels receives the traffic treatment provisioned for that lsp. typical mechanisms used to provide different treatment to different flows includes the allocation of system resources (such as queues and buffers) and provisioning of related parameters (such as shaping, and policing) that may be found in implementations of rfc2205 (rsvp) and rsvp-te rfc3209 and rfc3473. support can also be provided via an underlying network technology such ieee802.1 tsn i-d.ietf-detnet-mpls-over-tsn. the specific mechanisms selected by a detnet node to ensure detnet service delivery requirements are met for supported detnet flows is outside the scope of this document." {} {} {} 113 "MUST ensure a CoS flow or service class does not impact the service delivered to other flows. This requirement is similar to requirement for MPLS LSRs to that CoS LSPs do not impact the resources allocated to TE LSPs, e.g., via RFC3473." reference ( change framework to normative ) editorial ( zero as a valid sequence number topic ) 012e03396de0029b54ec65b26be02c3d29b7990d 012e03396de0029b54ec65b26be02c3d29b7990d draft-ietf-detnet-mpls aee15ff883609fc9ccbba417b6d621149d69d857aa09f50b43fd06c2a1f94a9b ['17970d0c6f438151618c9afd867774ff8149c0b7966df56525a47d4206685ad8', 'aee15ff883609fc9ccbba417b6d621149d69d857aa09f50b43fd06c2a1f94a9b'] A "must ensure a cos flow or service class does not impact the service delivered to other flows. this requirement is similar to requirement for mpls lsrs to that cos lsps do not impact the resources allocated to te lsps, e.g., via rfc3473." {} {} {} 113 "MUST ensure a CoS flow or service class does not impact the service delivered to other flows. This requirement is similar to the requirement for MPLS LSRs that CoS LSPs do not impact the resources allocated to TE LSPs, e.g., via RFC3473." reference ( change framework to normative ) editorial ( zero as a valid sequence number topic ) 012e03396de0029b54ec65b26be02c3d29b7990d 012e03396de0029b54ec65b26be02c3d29b7990d draft-ietf-detnet-mpls 17970d0c6f438151618c9afd867774ff8149c0b7966df56525a47d4206685ad8 ['17970d0c6f438151618c9afd867774ff8149c0b7966df56525a47d4206685ad8', 'aee15ff883609fc9ccbba417b6d621149d69d857aa09f50b43fd06c2a1f94a9b'] B "must ensure a cos flow or service class does not impact the service delivered to other flows. this requirement is similar to the requirement for mpls lsrs that cos lsps do not impact the resources allocated to te lsps, e.g., via rfc3473." {} {} {} 113 "As in the previous section, nodes supporting this type of aggregation will need to ensure that individual and aggregated flows receive the traffic treatment required to ensure the required DetNet service is preserved. Also, it is the controller plane's responsibility to to ensure that the service required on the aggregate flow are properly provisioned." reference ( change framework to normative ) editorial ( zero as a valid sequence number topic ) 012e03396de0029b54ec65b26be02c3d29b7990d 012e03396de0029b54ec65b26be02c3d29b7990d draft-ietf-detnet-mpls 3e2590a5211de13c242382f078170e00e1e0cbc1547061da76b076c4612786bb ['3e2590a5211de13c242382f078170e00e1e0cbc1547061da76b076c4612786bb', '146e51fdeb95adac2a4e3d18971b0c5816136a8766b33621750bcb3ca2d0b141'] A "as in the previous section, nodes supporting this type of aggregation will need to ensure that individual and aggregated flows receive the traffic treatment required to ensure the required detnet service is preserved. also, it is the controller plane's responsibility to to ensure that the service required on the aggregate flow are properly provisioned." {35: 1, 26: 3, 27: 2, 38: 3} {94: 1, 265: 3, 266: 2, 205: 3} {265, 266, 205, 94, 95} 113 "As in the previous section, nodes supporting this type of aggregation will need to ensure that individual and aggregated flows receive the traffic treatment required to ensure the required DetNet service is preserved. Also, it is the controller plane's responsibility to ensure that the service required on the aggregate flow are properly provisioned." reference ( change framework to normative ) editorial ( zero as a valid sequence number topic ) 012e03396de0029b54ec65b26be02c3d29b7990d 012e03396de0029b54ec65b26be02c3d29b7990d draft-ietf-detnet-mpls 146e51fdeb95adac2a4e3d18971b0c5816136a8766b33621750bcb3ca2d0b141 ['3e2590a5211de13c242382f078170e00e1e0cbc1547061da76b076c4612786bb', '146e51fdeb95adac2a4e3d18971b0c5816136a8766b33621750bcb3ca2d0b141'] B "as in the previous section, nodes supporting this type of aggregation will need to ensure that individual and aggregated flows receive the traffic treatment required to ensure the required detnet service is preserved. also, it is the controller plane's responsibility to ensure that the service required on the aggregate flow are properly provisioned." {35: 1, 26: 3, 27: 2, 38: 3} {94: 1, 265: 3, 266: 2, 205: 3} {265, 266, 205, 94, 95} 113 "In addition to explicit routes, and packet replication and elimination, described in dn-dt-solution above, DetNet provides zero congestion loss and bounded latency and jitter. As described in RFC8655, there are different mechanisms that maybe used separately or in combination to deliver a zero congestion loss service. This includes Quality of Service (QoS) mechanisms at the MPLS layer, that may be combined with the mechanisms defined by the underlying network layer such as 802.1TSN." reference ( change framework to normative ) editorial ( zero as a valid sequence number topic ) 012e03396de0029b54ec65b26be02c3d29b7990d 012e03396de0029b54ec65b26be02c3d29b7990d draft-ietf-detnet-mpls 77939037ac48abc441ca9b5e57ba428da8d9e64f820dfe9574747380f2302b45 ['9992b4f39904d1c4a98bf285df1588fb3b7ef04963b36284cd27c958fd204db0', '77939037ac48abc441ca9b5e57ba428da8d9e64f820dfe9574747380f2302b45'] A "in addition to explicit routes, and packet replication and elimination, described in dn-dt-solution above, detnet provides zero congestion loss and bounded latency and jitter. as described in rfc8655, there are different mechanisms that maybe used separately or in combination to deliver a zero congestion loss service. this includes quality of service (qos) mechanisms at the mpls layer, that may be combined with the mechanisms defined by the underlying network layer such as 802.1tsn." {67: 1} {193: 1} {193, 237} 113 "In addition to explicit routes, and packet replication and elimination, described in dn-dt-solution above, DetNet provides zero congestion loss and bounded latency and jitter. As described in RFC8655, there are different mechanisms that may be used separately or in combination to deliver a zero congestion loss service. This includes Quality of Service (QoS) mechanisms at the MPLS layer, that may be combined with the mechanisms defined by the underlying network layer such as 802.1TSN." reference ( change framework to normative ) editorial ( zero as a valid sequence number topic ) 012e03396de0029b54ec65b26be02c3d29b7990d 012e03396de0029b54ec65b26be02c3d29b7990d draft-ietf-detnet-mpls 9992b4f39904d1c4a98bf285df1588fb3b7ef04963b36284cd27c958fd204db0 ['9992b4f39904d1c4a98bf285df1588fb3b7ef04963b36284cd27c958fd204db0', '77939037ac48abc441ca9b5e57ba428da8d9e64f820dfe9574747380f2302b45'] B "in addition to explicit routes, and packet replication and elimination, described in dn-dt-solution above, detnet provides zero congestion loss and bounded latency and jitter. as described in rfc8655, there are different mechanisms that may be used separately or in combination to deliver a zero congestion loss service. this includes quality of service (qos) mechanisms at the mpls layer, that may be combined with the mechanisms defined by the underlying network layer such as 802.1tsn." {67: 1} {193: 1} {193, 237} 113 "A baseline set of QoS capabilities for DetNet flows carried in PWs and MPLS can provided by MPLS with Traffic Engineering (MPLS-TE) RFC3209 and RFC3473. TE LSPs can also support explicit routes (path pinning). Current service definitions for packet TE LSPs can be found in ""Specification of the Controlled Load Quality of Service"", RFC2211, ""Specification of Guaranteed Quality of Service"", RFC2212, and ""Ethernet Traffic Parameters"", RFC6003. Additional service definitions are expected in future documents to support the full range of DetNet services. In all cases, the existing label-based marking mechanisms defined for TE-LSPs and even E-LSPs are use to support the identification of flows requiring DetNet QoS." reference ( change framework to normative ) editorial ( zero as a valid sequence number topic ) 012e03396de0029b54ec65b26be02c3d29b7990d 012e03396de0029b54ec65b26be02c3d29b7990d draft-ietf-detnet-mpls a8441eb535c111f96ae2b8a884cf2e7210ebd98b5a62ec080e3d0675d930452c ['6c23eddf3ac6c9be31eb13032532649a0531f538e1aa8460956e02701b1db0b0', 'a8441eb535c111f96ae2b8a884cf2e7210ebd98b5a62ec080e3d0675d930452c'] A "a baseline set of qos capabilities for detnet flows carried in pws and mpls can provided by mpls with traffic engineering (mpls-te) rfc3209 and rfc3473. te lsps can also support explicit routes (path pinning). current service definitions for packet te lsps can be found in ""specification of the controlled load quality of service"", rfc2211, ""specification of guaranteed quality of service"", rfc2212, and ""ethernet traffic parameters"", rfc6003. additional service definitions are expected in future documents to support the full range of detnet services. in all cases, the existing label-based marking mechanisms defined for te-lsps and even e-lsps are use to support the identification of flows requiring detnet qos." {} {} {} 113 "A baseline set of QoS capabilities for DetNet flows carried in PWs and MPLS can be provided by MPLS with Traffic Engineering (MPLS-TE) RFC3209 and RFC3473. TE LSPs can also support explicit routes (path pinning). Current service definitions for packet TE LSPs can be found in ""Specification of the Controlled Load Quality of Service"", RFC2211, ""Specification of Guaranteed Quality of Service"", RFC2212, and ""Ethernet Traffic Parameters"", RFC6003. Additional service definitions are expected in future documents to support the full range of DetNet services. In all cases, the existing label-based marking mechanisms defined for TE-LSPs and even E-LSPs are use to support the identification of flows requiring DetNet QoS." reference ( change framework to normative ) editorial ( zero as a valid sequence number topic ) 012e03396de0029b54ec65b26be02c3d29b7990d 012e03396de0029b54ec65b26be02c3d29b7990d draft-ietf-detnet-mpls 6c23eddf3ac6c9be31eb13032532649a0531f538e1aa8460956e02701b1db0b0 ['6c23eddf3ac6c9be31eb13032532649a0531f538e1aa8460956e02701b1db0b0', 'a8441eb535c111f96ae2b8a884cf2e7210ebd98b5a62ec080e3d0675d930452c'] B "a baseline set of qos capabilities for detnet flows carried in pws and mpls can be provided by mpls with traffic engineering (mpls-te) rfc3209 and rfc3473. te lsps can also support explicit routes (path pinning). current service definitions for packet te lsps can be found in ""specification of the controlled load quality of service"", rfc2211, ""specification of guaranteed quality of service"", rfc2212, and ""ethernet traffic parameters"", rfc6003. additional service definitions are expected in future documents to support the full range of detnet services. in all cases, the existing label-based marking mechanisms defined for te-lsps and even e-lsps are use to support the identification of flows requiring detnet qos." {} {} {} 113 "The outgoing S-Label for each of the service's outgoing DetNet (member) flow." reference ( change framework to normative ) editorial ( zero as a valid sequence number topic ) 012e03396de0029b54ec65b26be02c3d29b7990d 012e03396de0029b54ec65b26be02c3d29b7990d draft-ietf-detnet-mpls ed5af1049a2822fe7823f2c8219f153a5001cbed5b64b73b93bd974ece2ec2d9 ['ed5af1049a2822fe7823f2c8219f153a5001cbed5b64b73b93bd974ece2ec2d9', 'c632f346b2b59fcb47aa97d03cca43c0def08dcf89e2e0d0a15893331fc94882'] A "the outgoing s-label for each of the service's outgoing detnet (member) flow." {104: 1} {388: 1} {378, 388} 113 "The outgoing S-Label for each of the service's outgoing DetNet (member) flows." reference ( change framework to normative ) editorial ( zero as a valid sequence number topic ) 012e03396de0029b54ec65b26be02c3d29b7990d 012e03396de0029b54ec65b26be02c3d29b7990d draft-ietf-detnet-mpls c632f346b2b59fcb47aa97d03cca43c0def08dcf89e2e0d0a15893331fc94882 ['ed5af1049a2822fe7823f2c8219f153a5001cbed5b64b73b93bd974ece2ec2d9', 'c632f346b2b59fcb47aa97d03cca43c0def08dcf89e2e0d0a15893331fc94882'] B "the outgoing s-label for each of the service's outgoing detnet (member) flows." {104: 1} {388: 1} {378, 388} 113 "On the receiving node, the A-Label provides the forwarding context of an incoming interface or an F-Label and is used in subsequent service or forwarding sub-layer receive processing, as appropriated. The related addition configuration that may be provided discussed elsewhere in this section." reference ( change framework to normative ) editorial ( zero as a valid sequence number topic ) 012e03396de0029b54ec65b26be02c3d29b7990d 012e03396de0029b54ec65b26be02c3d29b7990d draft-ietf-detnet-mpls b863dd515fc616b5f20d11da86ec171c6d64e3cdd1fecce3d9201a8f011ed918 ['b863dd515fc616b5f20d11da86ec171c6d64e3cdd1fecce3d9201a8f011ed918', '954e864be92dc04395b72bbdbdc215b9ce150fea85109c9a0965c086dc09f9cb'] A "on the receiving node, the a-label provides the forwarding context of an incoming interface or an f-label and is used in subsequent service or forwarding sub-layer receive processing, as appropriated. the related addition configuration that may be provided discussed elsewhere in this section." {38: 1, 6: 5, 79: 5, 90: 4, 51: 5, 130: 5, 62: 7, 85: 8, 68: 7, 35: 6, 110: 4, 91: 6, 114: 2, 97: 5, 31: 5, 13: 4, 67: 4, 26: 2, 124: 6, 98: 5, 54: 5, 127: 6, 8: 5, 96: 5, 64: 5, 30: 5, 61: 2, 55: 6, 27: 2, 15: 4, 52: 4, 129: 6, 115: 4, 84: 4, 76: 9, 87: 4, 131: 8, 102: 4, 99: 5, 36: 4, 24: 3, 53: 4, 72: 5} {96: 1, 1: 12, 4: 5, 9: 8, 10: 6, 15: 5, 24: 5, 25: 7, 26: 8, 27: 5, 39: 8, 43: 6, 49: 7, 50: 6, 58: 2, 59: 5, 64: 5, 69: 7, 81: 8, 82: 6, 86: 4, 97: 2, 100: 9, 108: 6, 109: 7, 110: 7, 111: 5, 114: 6, 115: 7, 116: 5, 118: 9, 119: 8, 120: 6, 121: 7, 122: 6, 123: 5, 124: 7, 128: 5, 129: 5, 130: 2, 132: 7, 136: 5, 145: 7, 147: 2, 151: 5, 152: 5, 154: 6, 156: 4, 161: 6, 162: 6, 165: 6, 168: 7, 169: 4, 172: 4, 180: 5, 184: 8, 187: 8, 188: 7, 191: 6, 194: 7, 202: 8, 203: 9, 206: 5, 207: 6, 215: 5, 217: 6, 218: 11, 220: 5, 221: 5, 222: 8, 224: 6, 227: 7, 229: 4, 234: 8, 235: 5, 241: 5, 242: 5, 243: 7, 244: 5, 245: 7, 248: 5, 250: 6, 258: 14, 262: 7, 263: 8, 264: 6, 267: 7, 270: 5, 272: 4, 273: 8, 287: 6, 289: 4, 299: 7, 300: 5, 304: 5, 309: 6, 314: 5, 315: 4, 320: 7, 323: 7, 327: 7, 328: 6, 329: 5, 330: 13, 334: 5, 335: 5, 341: 7, 342: 8, 347: 7, 348: 7, 350: 10, 351: 6, 352: 4, 353: 4, 354: 3, 358: 7, 365: 4, 366: 5, 369: 4, 371: 9, 372: 2, 376: 5, 384: 6, 385: 5, 386: 6, 387: 5, 392: 6, 393: 7, 396: 8, 397: 10, 398: 9, 402: 4} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 113 "On the receiving node, the A-Label provides the forwarding context of an incoming interface or an F-Label and is used in subsequent service or forwarding sub-layer receive processing, as appropriated. The related additional configuration that may be provided is discussed elsewhere in this section." reference ( change framework to normative ) editorial ( zero as a valid sequence number topic ) 012e03396de0029b54ec65b26be02c3d29b7990d 012e03396de0029b54ec65b26be02c3d29b7990d draft-ietf-detnet-mpls 954e864be92dc04395b72bbdbdc215b9ce150fea85109c9a0965c086dc09f9cb ['b863dd515fc616b5f20d11da86ec171c6d64e3cdd1fecce3d9201a8f011ed918', '954e864be92dc04395b72bbdbdc215b9ce150fea85109c9a0965c086dc09f9cb'] B "on the receiving node, the a-label provides the forwarding context of an incoming interface or an f-label and is used in subsequent service or forwarding sub-layer receive processing, as appropriated. the related additional configuration that may be provided is discussed elsewhere in this section." {38: 1, 6: 5, 79: 5, 90: 4, 51: 5, 130: 5, 62: 7, 85: 8, 68: 7, 35: 6, 110: 4, 91: 6, 114: 2, 97: 5, 31: 5, 13: 4, 67: 4, 26: 2, 124: 6, 98: 5, 54: 5, 127: 6, 8: 5, 96: 5, 64: 5, 30: 5, 61: 2, 55: 6, 27: 2, 15: 4, 52: 4, 129: 6, 115: 4, 84: 4, 76: 9, 87: 4, 131: 8, 102: 4, 99: 5, 36: 4, 24: 3, 53: 4, 72: 5} {96: 1, 1: 12, 4: 5, 9: 8, 10: 6, 15: 5, 24: 5, 25: 7, 26: 8, 27: 5, 39: 8, 43: 6, 49: 7, 50: 6, 58: 2, 59: 5, 64: 5, 69: 7, 81: 8, 82: 6, 86: 4, 97: 2, 100: 9, 108: 6, 109: 7, 110: 7, 111: 5, 114: 6, 115: 7, 116: 5, 118: 9, 119: 8, 120: 6, 121: 7, 122: 6, 123: 5, 124: 7, 128: 5, 129: 5, 130: 2, 132: 7, 136: 5, 145: 7, 147: 2, 151: 5, 152: 5, 154: 6, 156: 4, 161: 6, 162: 6, 165: 6, 168: 7, 169: 4, 172: 4, 180: 5, 184: 8, 187: 8, 188: 7, 191: 6, 194: 7, 202: 8, 203: 9, 206: 5, 207: 6, 215: 5, 217: 6, 218: 11, 220: 5, 221: 5, 222: 8, 224: 6, 227: 7, 229: 4, 234: 8, 235: 5, 241: 5, 242: 5, 243: 7, 244: 5, 245: 7, 248: 5, 250: 6, 258: 14, 262: 7, 263: 8, 264: 6, 267: 7, 270: 5, 272: 4, 273: 8, 287: 6, 289: 4, 299: 7, 300: 5, 304: 5, 309: 6, 314: 5, 315: 4, 320: 7, 323: 7, 327: 7, 328: 6, 329: 5, 330: 13, 334: 5, 335: 5, 341: 7, 342: 8, 347: 7, 348: 7, 350: 10, 351: 6, 352: 4, 353: 4, 354: 3, 358: 7, 365: 4, 366: 5, 369: 4, 371: 9, 372: 2, 376: 5, 384: 6, 385: 5, 386: 6, 387: 5, 392: 6, 393: 7, 396: 8, 397: 10, 398: 9, 402: 4} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 113 "It is the responsibility of the DetNet controller plane to properly provision both flow identification information and the flow specific resources needed to provided the traffic treatment needed to meet each flow's service requirements. This applies for aggregated and individual flows." reference ( change framework to normative ) editorial ( zero as a valid sequence number topic ) 012e03396de0029b54ec65b26be02c3d29b7990d 012e03396de0029b54ec65b26be02c3d29b7990d draft-ietf-detnet-mpls ed421dfbc499208b19c13c14f07492fc0a6d8112c65bed9315f7f3d2b27f8234 ['95ac5753cca2b496928765c1eabd3143014466378c6c362afa67db6818afaf77', 'ed421dfbc499208b19c13c14f07492fc0a6d8112c65bed9315f7f3d2b27f8234'] A "it is the responsibility of the detnet controller plane to properly provision both flow identification information and the flow specific resources needed to provided the traffic treatment needed to meet each flow's service requirements. this applies for aggregated and individual flows." {32: 1, 112: 1, 71: 1, 60: 3, 56: 2, 102: 2, 64: 2, 38: 2, 62: 3, 33: 2, 26: 2, 83: 3, 126: 2, 85: 3, 129: 2} {33: 1, 298: 1, 377: 1, 260: 3, 261: 2, 274: 2, 339: 3, 212: 2, 343: 2, 283: 3, 286: 4, 31: 2, 32: 2, 163: 3, 357: 2, 166: 2, 231: 2, 363: 3, 46: 2} {260, 261, 274, 283, 286, 31, 32, 33, 163, 166, 298, 46, 339, 212, 343, 228, 357, 231, 363, 377} 113 "It is the responsibility of the DetNet controller plane to properly provision both flow identification information and the flow-specific resources needed to provided the traffic treatment needed to meet each flow's service requirements. This applies for aggregated and individual flows." reference ( change framework to normative ) editorial ( zero as a valid sequence number topic ) 012e03396de0029b54ec65b26be02c3d29b7990d 012e03396de0029b54ec65b26be02c3d29b7990d draft-ietf-detnet-mpls 95ac5753cca2b496928765c1eabd3143014466378c6c362afa67db6818afaf77 ['95ac5753cca2b496928765c1eabd3143014466378c6c362afa67db6818afaf77', 'ed421dfbc499208b19c13c14f07492fc0a6d8112c65bed9315f7f3d2b27f8234'] B "it is the responsibility of the detnet controller plane to properly provision both flow identification information and the flow-specific resources needed to provided the traffic treatment needed to meet each flow's service requirements. this applies for aggregated and individual flows." {32: 1, 112: 1, 71: 1, 60: 3, 56: 2, 102: 2, 64: 2, 38: 2, 62: 3, 33: 2, 26: 2, 83: 3, 126: 2, 85: 3, 129: 2} {33: 1, 298: 1, 377: 1, 260: 3, 261: 2, 274: 2, 339: 3, 212: 2, 343: 2, 283: 3, 286: 4, 31: 2, 32: 2, 163: 3, 357: 2, 166: 2, 231: 2, 363: 3, 46: 2} {260, 261, 274, 283, 286, 31, 32, 33, 163, 166, 298, 46, 339, 212, 343, 228, 357, 231, 363, 377} 112 Layer-3. Note to 5.1 , that multipath is out - of - scope . Please , check note and its placement that it is appropriate . 493b37fde874dc80ce98d5446cb57082d43acf63 493b37fde874dc80ce98d5446cb57082d43acf63 draft-ietf-detnet-ip-over-mpls 21c8ca6c564c2234d9a92828aa4c6d60e41a900ed5483238e033be2d0b19af71 ['21c8ca6c564c2234d9a92828aa4c6d60e41a900ed5483238e033be2d0b19af71', 'be783cb488ae6e1275dd4f9d7f0ff96f3649acbf22bd0a4f2c19de4bbaf5add7'] "https://mailarchive.ietf.org/arch/msg/detnet/GLBlvKQWog8V9iqoHaEcBGW5ECs/ https://mailarchive.ietf.org/arch/msg/detnet/MNJKPDUR57nHMEkH9j2idywThRs/" A layer-3. {37: 1, 51: 1, 130: 4, 79: 2, 112: 2, 55: 3, 64: 3, 62: 4, 38: 3, 69: 3, 68: 2, 67: 3, 33: 3, 25: 2, 53: 3, 80: 3, 52: 2, 127: 5, 91: 3} {296: 1, 308: 1, 0: 4, 389: 3, 390: 3, 135: 2, 142: 3, 14: 3, 400: 4, 17: 3, 399: 4, 19: 4, 149: 3, 406: 3, 279: 2, 280: 2, 281: 4, 278: 3, 294: 2, 56: 3, 185: 3, 192: 3, 321: 2, 322: 3, 66: 3, 196: 6, 197: 5, 324: 3, 77: 3, 78: 3, 337: 5, 216: 3, 380: 3, 255: 4} {0, 389, 390, 135, 142, 14, 400, 17, 399, 19, 149, 406, 279, 280, 281, 278, 294, 296, 45, 308, 56, 185, 192, 321, 322, 66, 196, 197, 324, 77, 78, 337, 216, 380, 255} "Hi , Thanks for the good memory . : -- ) ) ) Sure , You are right . I will add a note regarding multipath . Thanks & Cheers Bala'zs Hi , Thanks for your comments . Yes , transport layer is out - of - scope for DetNet scenarios . The framework document ( ) says explicitly : "" Use of packet - by - packet distribution of the same DetNet flow over multiple paths is not recommended ... Packet by packet load sharing , e.g. , via ECMP or UCMP , impacts ordering and possibly jitter . "" I will add an explicit note on this here as well . So , your comment is absolutely right , multipath would impact aggregation as well . Many thanks Bala'zs" 112 Provider Edge. Note to 5.1 , that multipath is out - of - scope . Please , check note and its placement that it is appropriate . 493b37fde874dc80ce98d5446cb57082d43acf63 493b37fde874dc80ce98d5446cb57082d43acf63 draft-ietf-detnet-ip-over-mpls be783cb488ae6e1275dd4f9d7f0ff96f3649acbf22bd0a4f2c19de4bbaf5add7 ['21c8ca6c564c2234d9a92828aa4c6d60e41a900ed5483238e033be2d0b19af71', 'be783cb488ae6e1275dd4f9d7f0ff96f3649acbf22bd0a4f2c19de4bbaf5add7'] "https://mailarchive.ietf.org/arch/msg/detnet/GLBlvKQWog8V9iqoHaEcBGW5ECs/ https://mailarchive.ietf.org/arch/msg/detnet/MNJKPDUR57nHMEkH9j2idywThRs/" A provider edge. {37: 1, 51: 1, 130: 4, 79: 2, 112: 2, 55: 3, 64: 3, 62: 4, 38: 3, 69: 3, 68: 2, 67: 3, 33: 3, 25: 2, 53: 3, 80: 3, 52: 2, 127: 5, 91: 3} {296: 1, 308: 1, 0: 4, 389: 3, 390: 3, 135: 2, 142: 3, 14: 3, 400: 4, 17: 3, 399: 4, 19: 4, 149: 3, 406: 3, 279: 2, 280: 2, 281: 4, 278: 3, 294: 2, 56: 3, 185: 3, 192: 3, 321: 2, 322: 3, 66: 3, 196: 6, 197: 5, 324: 3, 77: 3, 78: 3, 337: 5, 216: 3, 380: 3, 255: 4} {0, 389, 390, 135, 142, 14, 400, 17, 399, 19, 149, 406, 279, 280, 281, 278, 294, 296, 45, 308, 56, 185, 192, 321, 322, 66, 196, 197, 324, 77, 78, 337, 216, 380, 255} "Hi , Thanks for the good memory . : -- ) ) ) Sure , You are right . I will add a note regarding multipath . Thanks & Cheers Bala'zs Hi , Thanks for your comments . Yes , transport layer is out - of - scope for DetNet scenarios . The framework document ( ) says explicitly : "" Use of packet - by - packet distribution of the same DetNet flow over multiple paths is not recommended ... Packet by packet load sharing , e.g. , via ECMP or UCMP , impacts ordering and possibly jitter . "" I will add an explicit note on this here as well . So , your comment is absolutely right , multipath would impact aggregation as well . Many thanks Bala'zs" 112 Packet Switched Network. Note to 5.1 , that multipath is out - of - scope . Please , check note and its placement that it is appropriate . 493b37fde874dc80ce98d5446cb57082d43acf63 493b37fde874dc80ce98d5446cb57082d43acf63 draft-ietf-detnet-ip-over-mpls b44b885a406cb9ec036bed7a2f808cd599fef92864f4ac305f6309a2fb37cb4d ['54e1b234a202b3be32a7a43d2eab670c0c69c1cc84eea24b030d37929a33ad75', 'b44b885a406cb9ec036bed7a2f808cd599fef92864f4ac305f6309a2fb37cb4d'] "https://mailarchive.ietf.org/arch/msg/detnet/GLBlvKQWog8V9iqoHaEcBGW5ECs/ https://mailarchive.ietf.org/arch/msg/detnet/MNJKPDUR57nHMEkH9j2idywThRs/" A packet switched network. {79: 1, 37: 1, 51: 1, 68: 1, 130: 4, 55: 2, 64: 2, 62: 3, 38: 2, 69: 2, 67: 3, 33: 2, 25: 2, 112: 2, 53: 3, 80: 3, 52: 2, 127: 5, 91: 2} {280: 1, 296: 1, 308: 1, 279: 1, 0: 4, 389: 3, 390: 3, 142: 2, 14: 2, 400: 3, 17: 2, 399: 4, 19: 3, 149: 2, 406: 2, 281: 4, 278: 2, 294: 2, 45: 2, 56: 3, 185: 3, 192: 3, 321: 2, 322: 3, 66: 3, 196: 6, 197: 5, 324: 2, 77: 2, 78: 2, 337: 5, 216: 2, 380: 2, 255: 4} {0, 389, 390, 135, 142, 14, 400, 17, 399, 19, 149, 406, 279, 280, 281, 278, 294, 296, 45, 308, 56, 185, 192, 321, 322, 66, 196, 197, 324, 77, 78, 337, 216, 380, 255} "Hi , Thanks for the good memory . : -- ) ) ) Sure , You are right . I will add a note regarding multipath . Thanks & Cheers Bala'zs Hi , Thanks for your comments . Yes , transport layer is out - of - scope for DetNet scenarios . The framework document ( ) says explicitly : "" Use of packet - by - packet distribution of the same DetNet flow over multiple paths is not recommended ... Packet by packet load sharing , e.g. , via ECMP or UCMP , impacts ordering and possibly jitter . "" I will add an explicit note on this here as well . So , your comment is absolutely right , multipath would impact aggregation as well . Many thanks Bala'zs" 112 Switching Provider Edge. Note to 5.1 , that multipath is out - of - scope . Please , check note and its placement that it is appropriate . 493b37fde874dc80ce98d5446cb57082d43acf63 493b37fde874dc80ce98d5446cb57082d43acf63 draft-ietf-detnet-ip-over-mpls 54e1b234a202b3be32a7a43d2eab670c0c69c1cc84eea24b030d37929a33ad75 ['54e1b234a202b3be32a7a43d2eab670c0c69c1cc84eea24b030d37929a33ad75', 'b44b885a406cb9ec036bed7a2f808cd599fef92864f4ac305f6309a2fb37cb4d'] "https://mailarchive.ietf.org/arch/msg/detnet/GLBlvKQWog8V9iqoHaEcBGW5ECs/ https://mailarchive.ietf.org/arch/msg/detnet/MNJKPDUR57nHMEkH9j2idywThRs/" B switching provider edge. {79: 1, 37: 1, 51: 1, 68: 1, 130: 4, 55: 2, 64: 2, 62: 3, 38: 2, 69: 2, 67: 3, 33: 2, 25: 2, 112: 2, 53: 3, 80: 3, 52: 2, 127: 5, 91: 2} {280: 1, 296: 1, 308: 1, 279: 1, 0: 4, 389: 3, 390: 3, 142: 2, 14: 2, 400: 3, 17: 2, 399: 4, 19: 3, 149: 2, 406: 2, 281: 4, 278: 2, 294: 2, 45: 2, 56: 3, 185: 3, 192: 3, 321: 2, 322: 3, 66: 3, 196: 6, 197: 5, 324: 2, 77: 2, 78: 2, 337: 5, 216: 2, 380: 2, 255: 4} {0, 389, 390, 135, 142, 14, 400, 17, 399, 19, 149, 406, 279, 280, 281, 278, 294, 296, 45, 308, 56, 185, 192, 321, 322, 66, 196, 197, 324, 77, 78, 337, 216, 380, 255} "Hi , Thanks for the good memory . : -- ) ) ) Sure , You are right . I will add a note regarding multipath . Thanks & Cheers Bala'zs Hi , Thanks for your comments . Yes , transport layer is out - of - scope for DetNet scenarios . The framework document ( ) says explicitly : "" Use of packet - by - packet distribution of the same DetNet flow over multiple paths is not recommended ... Packet by packet load sharing , e.g. , via ECMP or UCMP , impacts ordering and possibly jitter . "" I will add an explicit note on this here as well . So , your comment is absolutely right , multipath would impact aggregation as well . Many thanks Bala'zs" 112 "Note: using Layer-4 (L4) transport protocols e.g., for multipath are out of scope of this document both for a single flow and aggregate flows." Note to 5.1 , that multipath is out - of - scope . Please , check note and its placement that it is appropriate . 493b37fde874dc80ce98d5446cb57082d43acf63 493b37fde874dc80ce98d5446cb57082d43acf63 draft-ietf-detnet-ip-over-mpls 56bf5bb9a56a11a491e6c5c5221e5d853edeb9848a9f29800b9e7f04c953f95e ['56bf5bb9a56a11a491e6c5c5221e5d853edeb9848a9f29800b9e7f04c953f95e'] "https://mailarchive.ietf.org/arch/msg/detnet/GLBlvKQWog8V9iqoHaEcBGW5ECs/ https://mailarchive.ietf.org/arch/msg/detnet/MNJKPDUR57nHMEkH9j2idywThRs/" B "note: using layer-4 (l4) transport protocols e.g., for multipath are out of scope of this document both for a single flow and aggregate flows." {} {} {} "Hi , Thanks for the good memory . : -- ) ) ) Sure , You are right . I will add a note regarding multipath . Thanks & Cheers Bala'zs Hi , Thanks for your comments . Yes , transport layer is out - of - scope for DetNet scenarios . The framework document ( ) says explicitly : "" Use of packet - by - packet distribution of the same DetNet flow over multiple paths is not recommended ... Packet by packet load sharing , e.g. , via ECMP or UCMP , impacts ordering and possibly jitter . "" I will add an explicit note on this here as well . So , your comment is absolutely right , multipath would impact aggregation as well . Many thanks Bala'zs" 112 "It is the responsibility of the DetNet controller plane to properly provision both flow identification information and the flow specific resources needed to provided the traffic treatment needed to meet each flow's service requirements. This applies for aggregated and individual flows." Note to 5.1 , that multipath is out - of - scope . Please , check note and its placement that it is appropriate . 493b37fde874dc80ce98d5446cb57082d43acf63 493b37fde874dc80ce98d5446cb57082d43acf63 draft-ietf-detnet-ip-over-mpls ed421dfbc499208b19c13c14f07492fc0a6d8112c65bed9315f7f3d2b27f8234 ['be8c091d5ef1c0efeafe5a3f5493bf807e5979193541e491030c379771bc80a4', 'ed421dfbc499208b19c13c14f07492fc0a6d8112c65bed9315f7f3d2b27f8234'] "https://mailarchive.ietf.org/arch/msg/detnet/GLBlvKQWog8V9iqoHaEcBGW5ECs/ https://mailarchive.ietf.org/arch/msg/detnet/MNJKPDUR57nHMEkH9j2idywThRs/" A "it is the responsibility of the detnet controller plane to properly provision both flow identification information and the flow specific resources needed to provided the traffic treatment needed to meet each flow's service requirements. this applies for aggregated and individual flows." {32: 1, 113: 1, 71: 1, 60: 3, 56: 2, 102: 2, 64: 2, 38: 2, 62: 3, 33: 2, 26: 2, 83: 3, 126: 2, 85: 3, 129: 2} {33: 1, 228: 1, 377: 1, 260: 3, 261: 2, 274: 2, 339: 3, 212: 2, 343: 2, 283: 3, 286: 4, 31: 2, 32: 2, 163: 3, 357: 2, 166: 2, 231: 2, 363: 3, 46: 2} {260, 261, 274, 283, 286, 31, 32, 33, 163, 166, 298, 46, 339, 212, 343, 228, 357, 231, 363, 377} "Hi , Thanks for the good memory . : -- ) ) ) Sure , You are right . I will add a note regarding multipath . Thanks & Cheers Bala'zs Hi , Thanks for your comments . Yes , transport layer is out - of - scope for DetNet scenarios . The framework document ( ) says explicitly : "" Use of packet - by - packet distribution of the same DetNet flow over multiple paths is not recommended ... Packet by packet load sharing , e.g. , via ECMP or UCMP , impacts ordering and possibly jitter . "" I will add an explicit note on this here as well . So , your comment is absolutely right , multipath would impact aggregation as well . Many thanks Bala'zs" 112 "It is the responsibility of the DetNet controller plane to properly provision both flow identification information and the flow-specific resources needed to provide the traffic treatment to meet each flow's service requirements. This applies for aggregated and individual flows." Note to 5.1 , that multipath is out - of - scope . Please , check note and its placement that it is appropriate . 493b37fde874dc80ce98d5446cb57082d43acf63 493b37fde874dc80ce98d5446cb57082d43acf63 draft-ietf-detnet-ip-over-mpls be8c091d5ef1c0efeafe5a3f5493bf807e5979193541e491030c379771bc80a4 ['be8c091d5ef1c0efeafe5a3f5493bf807e5979193541e491030c379771bc80a4', 'ed421dfbc499208b19c13c14f07492fc0a6d8112c65bed9315f7f3d2b27f8234'] "https://mailarchive.ietf.org/arch/msg/detnet/GLBlvKQWog8V9iqoHaEcBGW5ECs/ https://mailarchive.ietf.org/arch/msg/detnet/MNJKPDUR57nHMEkH9j2idywThRs/" B "it is the responsibility of the detnet controller plane to properly provision both flow identification information and the flow-specific resources needed to provide the traffic treatment to meet each flow's service requirements. this applies for aggregated and individual flows." {32: 1, 113: 1, 71: 1, 60: 3, 56: 2, 102: 2, 64: 2, 38: 2, 62: 3, 33: 2, 26: 2, 83: 3, 126: 2, 85: 3, 129: 2} {33: 1, 228: 1, 377: 1, 260: 3, 261: 2, 274: 2, 339: 3, 212: 2, 343: 2, 283: 3, 286: 4, 31: 2, 32: 2, 163: 3, 357: 2, 166: 2, 231: 2, 363: 3, 46: 2} {260, 261, 274, 283, 286, 31, 32, 33, 163, 166, 298, 46, 339, 212, 343, 228, 357, 231, 363, 377} "Hi , Thanks for the good memory . : -- ) ) ) Sure , You are right . I will add a note regarding multipath . Thanks & Cheers Bala'zs Hi , Thanks for your comments . Yes , transport layer is out - of - scope for DetNet scenarios . The framework document ( ) says explicitly : "" Use of packet - by - packet distribution of the same DetNet flow over multiple paths is not recommended ... Packet by packet load sharing , e.g. , via ECMP or UCMP , impacts ordering and possibly jitter . "" I will add an explicit note on this here as well . So , your comment is absolutely right , multipath would impact aggregation as well . Many thanks Bala'zs" 110 "This document specifies the Deterministic Networking data plane when operating in an IP over MPLS packet switched network." The changes are good . 144d973845395913fc7ee795d0deeadef660aef4 144d973845395913fc7ee795d0deeadef660aef4 draft-ietf-detnet-ip-over-mpls d648ede15f046d1f857c33092b697f500e8c9a523052a198a4cec4c43f3f2474 ['d648ede15f046d1f857c33092b697f500e8c9a523052a198a4cec4c43f3f2474', '6b219248eff7fdd9c732535413bea9bd3c23fb20e99c35f47f21470df1e2aaea'] A "this document specifies the deterministic networking data plane when operating in an ip over mpls packet switched network." {} {} {} 110 "This document specifies the Deterministic Networking data plane when encapsulating IP over an MPLS packet switched network." The changes are good . 144d973845395913fc7ee795d0deeadef660aef4 144d973845395913fc7ee795d0deeadef660aef4 draft-ietf-detnet-ip-over-mpls 6b219248eff7fdd9c732535413bea9bd3c23fb20e99c35f47f21470df1e2aaea ['d648ede15f046d1f857c33092b697f500e8c9a523052a198a4cec4c43f3f2474', '6b219248eff7fdd9c732535413bea9bd3c23fb20e99c35f47f21470df1e2aaea'] B "this document specifies the deterministic networking data plane when encapsulating ip over an mpls packet switched network." {} {} {} 110 "This document uses the terminology and concepts established in the DetNet architecture RFC8655 and I-D.ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework, and the reader is assumed to be familiar with these documents and their terminology." The changes are good . 144d973845395913fc7ee795d0deeadef660aef4 144d973845395913fc7ee795d0deeadef660aef4 draft-ietf-detnet-ip-over-mpls 497d11183e2eba685b73b7170eff84f3d79ddaaf72c4fdc8a15de42ee591d796 ['1c7c177c800edf138bbe698b3a211d481b19f648809b6abe7910aa17b4822f10', '497d11183e2eba685b73b7170eff84f3d79ddaaf72c4fdc8a15de42ee591d796'] A "this document uses the terminology and concepts established in the detnet architecture rfc8655 and i-d.ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework, and the reader is assumed to be familiar with these documents and their terminology." {67: 1} {117: 1} {34, 117} 110 "This document uses the terminology and concepts established in the DetNet architecture RFC8655 and I-D.ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework, the reader is assumed to be familiar with these documents and their terminology." The changes are good . 144d973845395913fc7ee795d0deeadef660aef4 144d973845395913fc7ee795d0deeadef660aef4 draft-ietf-detnet-ip-over-mpls 1c7c177c800edf138bbe698b3a211d481b19f648809b6abe7910aa17b4822f10 ['1c7c177c800edf138bbe698b3a211d481b19f648809b6abe7910aa17b4822f10', '497d11183e2eba685b73b7170eff84f3d79ddaaf72c4fdc8a15de42ee591d796'] B "this document uses the terminology and concepts established in the detnet architecture rfc8655 and i-d.ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework, the reader is assumed to be familiar with these documents and their terminology." {67: 1} {117: 1} {34, 117} 110 "fig_ip_detnet illustrates an IP DetNet, with an MPLS based DetNet network as a sub-network between the relay nodes. It shows a more complex DetNet enabled IP network where an IP flow is mapped to one or more PWs and MPLS (TE) LSPs. The end systems still originate IP encapsulated traffic that are identified as DetNet flows. The relay nodes follow procedures defined in ip-over-mpls to map each DetNet flow to MPLS LSPs. While not shown, relay nodes can provide service sub-layer functions such as PREOF using DetNet over MPLS, and this is indicated by the solid line for the MPLS facing portion of the Service component. Note that the Transit node is MPLS (TE) LSP aware and performs switching based on MPLS labels, and need not have any specific knowledge of the DetNet service or the corresponding DetNet flow identification. See ip-over-mpls for details on the mapping of IP flows to MPLS, and I-D.ietf-detnet-mpls for general support of DetNet services using MPLS." The changes are good . 144d973845395913fc7ee795d0deeadef660aef4 144d973845395913fc7ee795d0deeadef660aef4 draft-ietf-detnet-ip-over-mpls 93421a5340eb2948c8921eb4077062fd71e46024afd084212cc7ccfd4c90ffdb ['93421a5340eb2948c8921eb4077062fd71e46024afd084212cc7ccfd4c90ffdb', '9f02861c0303161d533787775e97cb85ec061781156fd83773e7cbe2a26f6d9b'] A "fig_ip_detnet illustrates an ip detnet, with an mpls based detnet network as a sub-network between the relay nodes. it shows a more complex detnet enabled ip network where an ip flow is mapped to one or more pws and mpls (te) lsps. the end systems still originate ip encapsulated traffic that are identified as detnet flows. the relay nodes follow procedures defined in ip-over-mpls to map each detnet flow to mpls lsps. while not shown, relay nodes can provide service sub-layer functions such as preof using detnet over mpls, and this is indicated by the solid line for the mpls facing portion of the service component. note that the transit node is mpls (te) lsp aware and performs switching based on mpls labels, and need not have any specific knowledge of the detnet service or the corresponding detnet flow identification. see ip-over-mpls for details on the mapping of ip flows to mpls, and i-d.ietf-detnet-mpls for general support of detnet services using mpls." {} {} {} 110 "fig_ip_detnet illustrates an IP DetNet, with an MPLS based DetNet network as a sub-network between the relay nodes. An IP flow is mapped to one or more PWs and MPLS (TE) LSPs. The end systems still originate IP encapsulated traffic, identified as DetNet flows. The relay nodes follow procedures defined in ip-over-mpls to map each DetNet flow to MPLS LSPs. While not shown, relay nodes can provide service sub-layer functions such as PREOF using DetNet over MPLS, and this is indicated by the solid line for the MPLS facing portion of the Service component. Note that the Transit node is MPLS (TE) LSP aware and performs switching based on MPLS labels, and need not have any specific knowledge of the DetNet service or the corresponding DetNet flow identification. See ip-over-mpls for details on the mapping of IP flows to MPLS, and I-D.ietf-detnet-mpls for general support of DetNet services using MPLS." The changes are good . 144d973845395913fc7ee795d0deeadef660aef4 144d973845395913fc7ee795d0deeadef660aef4 draft-ietf-detnet-ip-over-mpls 9f02861c0303161d533787775e97cb85ec061781156fd83773e7cbe2a26f6d9b ['93421a5340eb2948c8921eb4077062fd71e46024afd084212cc7ccfd4c90ffdb', '9f02861c0303161d533787775e97cb85ec061781156fd83773e7cbe2a26f6d9b'] B "fig_ip_detnet illustrates an ip detnet, with an mpls based detnet network as a sub-network between the relay nodes. an ip flow is mapped to one or more pws and mpls (te) lsps. the end systems still originate ip encapsulated traffic, identified as detnet flows. the relay nodes follow procedures defined in ip-over-mpls to map each detnet flow to mpls lsps. while not shown, relay nodes can provide service sub-layer functions such as preof using detnet over mpls, and this is indicated by the solid line for the mpls facing portion of the service component. note that the transit node is mpls (te) lsp aware and performs switching based on mpls labels, and need not have any specific knowledge of the detnet service or the corresponding detnet flow identification. see ip-over-mpls for details on the mapping of ip flows to mpls, and i-d.ietf-detnet-mpls for general support of detnet services using mpls." {} {} {} 110 "fig_ip_detnet illustrated DetNet enabled End Systems (hosts), connected to DetNet (DN) enabled IP networks, operating over a DetNet aware MPLS network. Using this figure we can have a case where the Relay nodes act as T-PEs and sit at the boundary of the MPLS domain since the non-MPLS domain is DetNet aware. This case is very similar to the DetNet MPLS Network figure 2 in I-D.ietf-detnet-mpls. However in I-D.ietf-detnet-mpls figure 2 the T-PEs are located at the end system and MPLS spans the whole DetNet service. The primary difference in this document is that the Relay nodes are at the edges of the MPLS domain and therefore function as T-PEs, and that MPLS service sub-layer functions are not provided over the DetNet IP network. The transit node functions show above are identical to those described in I-D.ietf-detnet-mpls." The changes are good . 144d973845395913fc7ee795d0deeadef660aef4 144d973845395913fc7ee795d0deeadef660aef4 draft-ietf-detnet-ip-over-mpls 70aeb876c1786421558a9c462ef7963ab6c9685bcd144fcd0d62619be564bd9d ['79e4d8cd2a0f1477b6d81c60e8ca86bebf5436167c29b56442e3f02cf168274e', '70aeb876c1786421558a9c462ef7963ab6c9685bcd144fcd0d62619be564bd9d'] A "fig_ip_detnet illustrated detnet enabled end systems (hosts), connected to detnet (dn) enabled ip networks, operating over a detnet aware mpls network. using this figure we can have a case where the relay nodes act as t-pes and sit at the boundary of the mpls domain since the non-mpls domain is detnet aware. this case is very similar to the detnet mpls network figure 2 in i-d.ietf-detnet-mpls. however in i-d.ietf-detnet-mpls figure 2 the t-pes are located at the end system and mpls spans the whole detnet service. the primary difference in this document is that the relay nodes are at the edges of the mpls domain and therefore function as t-pes, and that mpls service sub-layer functions are not provided over the detnet ip network. the transit node functions show above are identical to those described in i-d.ietf-detnet-mpls." {63: 1, 30: 3, 36: 2} {332: 1, 3: 3, 331: 2} {186, 331, 3, 332} 110 "fig_ip_detnet illustrates IP DetNet enabled End Systems (hosts) connected to DetNet (DN) enabled IP networks, operating over a DetNet aware MPLS network. In this Figure we have a case where the Relay nodes act as T-PEs and sit at the boundary of the MPLS domain since the non-MPLS domain is DetNet aware. This case is very similar to the DetNet MPLS Network Figure 2 in I-D.ietf-detnet-mpls. However, in I-D.ietf-detnet-mpls Figure 2, the T-PEs are located at the end system and MPLS spans the whole DetNet service. The primary difference in this document is that the Relay nodes are at the edges of the MPLS domain and therefore function as T-PEs, and that MPLS service sub-layer functions are not provided over the DetNet IP network. The transit node functions shown above are identical to those described in I-D.ietf-detnet-mpls." The changes are good . 144d973845395913fc7ee795d0deeadef660aef4 144d973845395913fc7ee795d0deeadef660aef4 draft-ietf-detnet-ip-over-mpls 79e4d8cd2a0f1477b6d81c60e8ca86bebf5436167c29b56442e3f02cf168274e ['79e4d8cd2a0f1477b6d81c60e8ca86bebf5436167c29b56442e3f02cf168274e', '70aeb876c1786421558a9c462ef7963ab6c9685bcd144fcd0d62619be564bd9d'] B "fig_ip_detnet illustrates ip detnet enabled end systems (hosts) connected to detnet (dn) enabled ip networks, operating over a detnet aware mpls network. in this figure we have a case where the relay nodes act as t-pes and sit at the boundary of the mpls domain since the non-mpls domain is detnet aware. this case is very similar to the detnet mpls network figure 2 in i-d.ietf-detnet-mpls. however, in i-d.ietf-detnet-mpls figure 2, the t-pes are located at the end system and mpls spans the whole detnet service. the primary difference in this document is that the relay nodes are at the edges of the mpls domain and therefore function as t-pes, and that mpls service sub-layer functions are not provided over the detnet ip network. the transit node functions shown above are identical to those described in i-d.ietf-detnet-mpls." {63: 1, 30: 3, 36: 2} {332: 1, 3: 3, 331: 2} {186, 331, 3, 332} 110 "fig_ip_detnet illustrates DetNet enabled End Systems, connected to DetNet (DN) enabled MPLS network. A similar situation occurs when end systems are are not DetNet aware. In this case, edge nodes sit at the boundary of the MPLS domain since it is also a DetNet domain boundary. The edge nodes provide DetNet service proxies for the end applications by initiating and terminating DetNet service for the application's IP flows. While the node types differ, there is essentially no difference in data plane processing between relay and edges. There are likely to be differences in controller plane operation, particularly when distributed control plane protocols are used." The changes are good . 144d973845395913fc7ee795d0deeadef660aef4 144d973845395913fc7ee795d0deeadef660aef4 draft-ietf-detnet-ip-over-mpls b764111efa0366820d9668f7bd6687c2ad852deb5723ad3d38a609ae03ad64ad ['25c2b441419d565e127bd1b4e087290c434853c17f82d22b1e3b3f67717fe94a', 'b764111efa0366820d9668f7bd6687c2ad852deb5723ad3d38a609ae03ad64ad'] A "fig_ip_detnet illustrates detnet enabled end systems, connected to detnet (dn) enabled mpls network. a similar situation occurs when end systems are are not detnet aware. in this case, edge nodes sit at the boundary of the mpls domain since it is also a detnet domain boundary. the edge nodes provide detnet service proxies for the end applications by initiating and terminating detnet service for the application's ip flows. while the node types differ, there is essentially no difference in data plane processing between relay and edges. there are likely to be differences in controller plane operation, particularly when distributed control plane protocols are used." {63: 1, 110: 2, 36: 2} {290: 1, 170: 2, 293: 2} {170, 290, 51, 293} 110 "fig_ip_detnet illustrates DetNet enabled End Systems connected to DetNet (DN) enabled MPLS network. A similar situation occurs when end systems are not DetNet aware. In this case, edge nodes sit at the boundary of the MPLS domain since it is also a DetNet domain boundary. The edge nodes provide DetNet service proxies for the end applications by initiating and terminating DetNet service for the application's IP flows. While the node types differ, there is essentially no difference in data plane processing between relay and edges. There are likely to be differences in controller plane operation, particularly when distributed control plane protocols are used." The changes are good . 144d973845395913fc7ee795d0deeadef660aef4 144d973845395913fc7ee795d0deeadef660aef4 draft-ietf-detnet-ip-over-mpls 25c2b441419d565e127bd1b4e087290c434853c17f82d22b1e3b3f67717fe94a ['25c2b441419d565e127bd1b4e087290c434853c17f82d22b1e3b3f67717fe94a', 'b764111efa0366820d9668f7bd6687c2ad852deb5723ad3d38a609ae03ad64ad'] B "fig_ip_detnet illustrates detnet enabled end systems connected to detnet (dn) enabled mpls network. a similar situation occurs when end systems are not detnet aware. in this case, edge nodes sit at the boundary of the mpls domain since it is also a detnet domain boundary. the edge nodes provide detnet service proxies for the end applications by initiating and terminating detnet service for the application's ip flows. while the node types differ, there is essentially no difference in data plane processing between relay and edges. there are likely to be differences in controller plane operation, particularly when distributed control plane protocols are used." {63: 1, 110: 2, 36: 2} {290: 1, 170: 2, 293: 2} {170, 290, 51, 293} 110 "It is still possible to provided DetNet service protection for non- DetNet aware end systems. This case is basically the same as fig_ip_pw_detnet, with the exception that CE1 and CE2 are non-DetNet aware end systems and R1 and R3 become edge nodes." The changes are good . 144d973845395913fc7ee795d0deeadef660aef4 144d973845395913fc7ee795d0deeadef660aef4 draft-ietf-detnet-ip-over-mpls 6f67ab9b885f9d0f53402b8e8e7b67db76eeba21e8d239a625a36e4b79d9f382 ['6c86f45860d212a36685e8164d76b2a6243dd2b70de25635f59d6ec861d93bc3', '6f67ab9b885f9d0f53402b8e8e7b67db76eeba21e8d239a625a36e4b79d9f382'] A "it is still possible to provided detnet service protection for non- detnet aware end systems. this case is basically the same as fig_ip_pw_detnet, with the exception that ce1 and ce2 are non-detnet aware end systems and r1 and r3 become edge nodes." {63: 1, 110: 2, 36: 2} {290: 1, 51: 2, 293: 2} {170, 290, 51, 293} 110 "It is still possible to provide DetNet service protection for non- DetNet aware end systems. This case is basically the same as fig_ip_pw_detnet, with the exception that CE1 and CE2 are non-DetNet aware end systems and R1 and R3 become edge nodes." The changes are good . 144d973845395913fc7ee795d0deeadef660aef4 144d973845395913fc7ee795d0deeadef660aef4 draft-ietf-detnet-ip-over-mpls 6c86f45860d212a36685e8164d76b2a6243dd2b70de25635f59d6ec861d93bc3 ['6c86f45860d212a36685e8164d76b2a6243dd2b70de25635f59d6ec861d93bc3', '6f67ab9b885f9d0f53402b8e8e7b67db76eeba21e8d239a625a36e4b79d9f382'] B "it is still possible to provide detnet service protection for non- detnet aware end systems. this case is basically the same as fig_ip_pw_detnet, with the exception that ce1 and ce2 are non-detnet aware end systems and r1 and r3 become edge nodes." {63: 1, 110: 2, 36: 2} {290: 1, 51: 2, 293: 2} {170, 290, 51, 293} 110 "Per Section 5.1 of I-D.ietf-detnet-mpls, the DetNet MPLS data plane uses a single S-Label to support a single app flow. DetNet IP Flow Identification Procedures in Section 4.4 of I-D.ietf-detnet-ip states that a single DetNet flow is identified based on IP, and next level protocol, header information. Section 4.4. (Aggregation Considerations) of I-D.ietf-detnet-ip defines the ways in which aggregation is supported through the use of prefixes, wildcards, lists, and port ranges. Collectively, this results in the fairly straightforward procedures defined in this section." The changes are good . 144d973845395913fc7ee795d0deeadef660aef4 144d973845395913fc7ee795d0deeadef660aef4 draft-ietf-detnet-ip-over-mpls c3ff5e891961cfaee984c9ec6e177cf829b2383d2dfdb323b2f310ba826db76a ['d9fc5ffaf6c9c388cc227c5973a22b90f80817cbaaf4fc53c07fdeb7a85b0640', 'c3ff5e891961cfaee984c9ec6e177cf829b2383d2dfdb323b2f310ba826db76a'] A "per section 5.1 of i-d.ietf-detnet-mpls, the detnet mpls data plane uses a single s-label to support a single app flow. detnet ip flow identification procedures in section 4.4 of i-d.ietf-detnet-ip states that a single detnet flow is identified based on ip, and next level protocol, header information. section 4.4. (aggregation considerations) of i-d.ietf-detnet-ip defines the ways in which aggregation is supported through the use of prefixes, wildcards, lists, and port ranges. collectively, this results in the fairly straightforward procedures defined in this section." {91: 1, 30: 3, 56: 3, 63: 2, 36: 3} {134: 1, 356: 3, 75: 3, 395: 2, 333: 3} {356, 134, 75, 395, 333, 346} 110 "Per Section 5.1 of I-D.ietf-detnet-mpls, the DetNet MPLS data plane uses a single S-Label to support a single app flow. DetNet IP Flow Identification Procedures in Section 4.4 of I-D.ietf-detnet-ip states that a single DetNet flow is identified based on IP, and next level protocol, header information. Section 4.4. (Aggregation Considerations) of I-D.ietf-detnet-ip defines the ways in which aggregation is supported through the use of prefixes, wildcards, lists, and port ranges. Collectively, this results in the fairly straightforward procedures defined in the next section." The changes are good . 144d973845395913fc7ee795d0deeadef660aef4 144d973845395913fc7ee795d0deeadef660aef4 draft-ietf-detnet-ip-over-mpls d9fc5ffaf6c9c388cc227c5973a22b90f80817cbaaf4fc53c07fdeb7a85b0640 ['d9fc5ffaf6c9c388cc227c5973a22b90f80817cbaaf4fc53c07fdeb7a85b0640', 'c3ff5e891961cfaee984c9ec6e177cf829b2383d2dfdb323b2f310ba826db76a'] B "per section 5.1 of i-d.ietf-detnet-mpls, the detnet mpls data plane uses a single s-label to support a single app flow. detnet ip flow identification procedures in section 4.4 of i-d.ietf-detnet-ip states that a single detnet flow is identified based on ip, and next level protocol, header information. section 4.4. (aggregation considerations) of i-d.ietf-detnet-ip defines the ways in which aggregation is supported through the use of prefixes, wildcards, lists, and port ranges. collectively, this results in the fairly straightforward procedures defined in the next section." {91: 1, 30: 3, 56: 3, 63: 2, 36: 3} {134: 1, 356: 3, 75: 3, 395: 2, 333: 3} {356, 134, 75, 395, 333, 346} 110 "Generals security considerations for DetNet are described in detail in I-D.ietf-detnet-security. DetNet MPLS and DetNet IP security considerations equally apply to this document and are described in I- D.ietf-detnet-mpls and I-D.ietf-detnet-ip." The changes are good . 144d973845395913fc7ee795d0deeadef660aef4 144d973845395913fc7ee795d0deeadef660aef4 draft-ietf-detnet-ip-over-mpls 253f7f90a87ce74c8736f3c8a834ff5575c13145eb5523c0523ac58dba36c8c4 ['253f7f90a87ce74c8736f3c8a834ff5575c13145eb5523c0523ac58dba36c8c4', '954d5aedb17b234440955d416fd4f2287c6692dcd9b802942992f19e47af096f'] A "generals security considerations for detnet are described in detail in i-d.ietf-detnet-security. detnet mpls and detnet ip security considerations equally apply to this document and are described in i- d.ietf-detnet-mpls and i-d.ietf-detnet-ip." {91: 1, 6: 6, 79: 6, 90: 4, 51: 5, 130: 6, 62: 8, 85: 9, 68: 8, 35: 7, 114: 4, 97: 6, 31: 5, 13: 4, 67: 2, 38: 6, 26: 5, 124: 7, 98: 6, 54: 6, 127: 7, 8: 6, 96: 6, 64: 4, 30: 4, 61: 7, 55: 7, 27: 6, 15: 4, 52: 5, 129: 7, 115: 4, 110: 4, 84: 4, 76: 10, 87: 4, 131: 9, 102: 4, 113: 7, 99: 6, 36: 3, 24: 4, 53: 5, 72: 6} {50: 1, 1: 13, 4: 6, 9: 9, 10: 7, 15: 6, 24: 6, 25: 8, 26: 9, 27: 5, 39: 9, 43: 7, 58: 7, 59: 6, 64: 6, 69: 8, 81: 9, 82: 7, 86: 5, 96: 6, 97: 5, 100: 10, 108: 7, 109: 8, 110: 8, 111: 6, 114: 7, 115: 8, 116: 6, 118: 10, 119: 9, 120: 7, 121: 8, 122: 7, 123: 6, 124: 8, 128: 4, 129: 4, 130: 7, 132: 8, 136: 6, 145: 8, 147: 6, 151: 5, 152: 5, 154: 7, 156: 5, 161: 7, 162: 7, 165: 7, 168: 8, 169: 4, 172: 4, 180: 2, 184: 9, 187: 9, 188: 8, 191: 7, 194: 8, 202: 9, 203: 10, 206: 6, 207: 7, 215: 6, 217: 7, 218: 12, 220: 6, 221: 6, 222: 9, 224: 7, 227: 8, 229: 4, 234: 9, 235: 6, 241: 6, 242: 6, 243: 8, 244: 5, 245: 8, 248: 5, 250: 7, 258: 15, 262: 8, 263: 9, 264: 7, 267: 8, 270: 6, 272: 4, 273: 9, 287: 7, 289: 4, 291: 7, 299: 8, 300: 6, 304: 6, 309: 7, 314: 6, 315: 4, 320: 8, 323: 8, 327: 8, 328: 7, 329: 6, 330: 14, 334: 6, 335: 6, 341: 8, 342: 9, 347: 8, 348: 8, 350: 11, 351: 6, 352: 4, 353: 3, 354: 4, 358: 8, 365: 4, 366: 6, 369: 5, 371: 10, 372: 7, 376: 6, 384: 7, 385: 6, 386: 7, 387: 6, 392: 7, 393: 8, 396: 9, 397: 11, 398: 10, 402: 4} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 110 "General security considerations for DetNet are described in detail in I-D.ietf-detnet-security. DetNet MPLS and DetNet IP security considerations equally apply to this document and are described in I- D.ietf-detnet-mpls and I-D.ietf-detnet-ip." The changes are good . 144d973845395913fc7ee795d0deeadef660aef4 144d973845395913fc7ee795d0deeadef660aef4 draft-ietf-detnet-ip-over-mpls 954d5aedb17b234440955d416fd4f2287c6692dcd9b802942992f19e47af096f ['253f7f90a87ce74c8736f3c8a834ff5575c13145eb5523c0523ac58dba36c8c4', '954d5aedb17b234440955d416fd4f2287c6692dcd9b802942992f19e47af096f'] B "general security considerations for detnet are described in detail in i-d.ietf-detnet-security. detnet mpls and detnet ip security considerations equally apply to this document and are described in i- d.ietf-detnet-mpls and i-d.ietf-detnet-ip." {91: 1, 6: 6, 79: 6, 90: 4, 51: 5, 130: 6, 62: 8, 85: 9, 68: 8, 35: 7, 114: 4, 97: 6, 31: 5, 13: 4, 67: 2, 38: 6, 26: 5, 124: 7, 98: 6, 54: 6, 127: 7, 8: 6, 96: 6, 64: 4, 30: 4, 61: 7, 55: 7, 27: 6, 15: 4, 52: 5, 129: 7, 115: 4, 110: 4, 84: 4, 76: 10, 87: 4, 131: 9, 102: 4, 113: 7, 99: 6, 36: 3, 24: 4, 53: 5, 72: 6} {50: 1, 1: 13, 4: 6, 9: 9, 10: 7, 15: 6, 24: 6, 25: 8, 26: 9, 27: 5, 39: 9, 43: 7, 58: 7, 59: 6, 64: 6, 69: 8, 81: 9, 82: 7, 86: 5, 96: 6, 97: 5, 100: 10, 108: 7, 109: 8, 110: 8, 111: 6, 114: 7, 115: 8, 116: 6, 118: 10, 119: 9, 120: 7, 121: 8, 122: 7, 123: 6, 124: 8, 128: 4, 129: 4, 130: 7, 132: 8, 136: 6, 145: 8, 147: 6, 151: 5, 152: 5, 154: 7, 156: 5, 161: 7, 162: 7, 165: 7, 168: 8, 169: 4, 172: 4, 180: 2, 184: 9, 187: 9, 188: 8, 191: 7, 194: 8, 202: 9, 203: 10, 206: 6, 207: 7, 215: 6, 217: 7, 218: 12, 220: 6, 221: 6, 222: 9, 224: 7, 227: 8, 229: 4, 234: 9, 235: 6, 241: 6, 242: 6, 243: 8, 244: 5, 245: 8, 248: 5, 250: 7, 258: 15, 262: 8, 263: 9, 264: 7, 267: 8, 270: 6, 272: 4, 273: 9, 287: 7, 289: 4, 291: 7, 299: 8, 300: 6, 304: 6, 309: 7, 314: 6, 315: 4, 320: 8, 323: 8, 327: 8, 328: 7, 329: 6, 330: 14, 334: 6, 335: 6, 341: 8, 342: 9, 347: 8, 348: 8, 350: 11, 351: 6, 352: 4, 353: 3, 354: 4, 358: 8, 365: 4, 366: 6, 369: 5, 371: 10, 372: 7, 376: 6, 384: 7, 385: 6, 386: 7, 387: 6, 392: 7, 393: 8, 396: 9, 397: 11, 398: 10, 402: 4} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 110 "The primary considerations for the data plane is to maintain integrity of data and delivery of the associated DetNet service traversing the DetNet network. Application flows can be protected through whatever means is provided by the underlying technology. For example, encryption may be used, such as that provided by IPSec RFC4301 for IP flows and/or by an underlying sub-net using MACSec IEEE802.1AE-2018 for IP over Ethernet (Layer-2) flows." The changes are good . 144d973845395913fc7ee795d0deeadef660aef4 144d973845395913fc7ee795d0deeadef660aef4 draft-ietf-detnet-ip-over-mpls 6d1c378f6ab7bd6ae836d4ac295f0de5a2664c0064bd50ab47c1dde2a64665c8 ['6d1c378f6ab7bd6ae836d4ac295f0de5a2664c0064bd50ab47c1dde2a64665c8', '9cd5099308dda5178dfc778daed2e53f93a4c789c440b0886d818bee2343f3ca'] A "the primary considerations for the data plane is to maintain integrity of data and delivery of the associated detnet service traversing the detnet network. application flows can be protected through whatever means is provided by the underlying technology. for example, encryption may be used, such as that provided by ipsec rfc4301 for ip flows and/or by an underlying sub-net using macsec ieee802.1ae-2018 for ip over ethernet (layer-2) flows." {102: 1, 36: 1, 24: 1, 15: 1, 6: 3, 79: 3, 90: 2, 51: 3, 130: 3, 62: 5, 85: 6, 68: 5, 35: 4, 110: 4, 91: 3, 114: 2, 97: 3, 31: 3, 13: 2, 67: 2, 38: 3, 26: 2, 124: 4, 98: 3, 54: 3, 127: 4, 8: 3, 96: 3, 64: 2, 30: 2, 61: 4, 55: 4, 27: 3, 52: 2, 129: 4, 115: 2, 84: 2, 76: 7, 87: 2, 131: 6, 113: 4, 99: 3, 53: 2, 72: 3} {272: 1, 353: 1, 354: 1, 352: 1, 1: 10, 4: 3, 9: 6, 10: 4, 15: 3, 24: 3, 25: 5, 26: 6, 27: 3, 39: 6, 43: 4, 49: 4, 50: 3, 58: 4, 59: 3, 64: 3, 69: 5, 81: 6, 82: 4, 86: 2, 96: 3, 97: 2, 100: 7, 108: 4, 109: 5, 110: 5, 111: 3, 114: 4, 115: 5, 116: 3, 118: 7, 119: 6, 120: 4, 121: 5, 122: 4, 123: 3, 124: 5, 128: 2, 129: 2, 130: 4, 132: 5, 136: 3, 145: 5, 147: 3, 151: 3, 152: 2, 154: 4, 156: 2, 161: 4, 162: 4, 165: 4, 168: 5, 169: 2, 180: 2, 184: 6, 187: 6, 188: 5, 191: 4, 194: 5, 202: 6, 203: 7, 206: 3, 207: 4, 215: 3, 217: 4, 218: 9, 220: 3, 221: 3, 222: 6, 224: 4, 227: 5, 229: 2, 234: 6, 235: 3, 241: 3, 242: 3, 243: 5, 244: 3, 245: 5, 248: 3, 250: 4, 258: 12, 262: 5, 263: 6, 264: 4, 267: 5, 270: 3, 273: 6, 287: 4, 289: 2, 291: 4, 299: 5, 300: 3, 304: 3, 309: 4, 314: 3, 315: 2, 320: 5, 323: 5, 327: 5, 328: 4, 329: 3, 330: 11, 334: 3, 335: 3, 341: 5, 342: 6, 347: 5, 348: 5, 350: 8, 351: 4, 358: 5, 365: 2, 366: 3, 369: 2, 371: 7, 372: 4, 376: 3, 384: 4, 385: 3, 386: 4, 387: 3, 392: 4, 393: 5, 396: 6, 397: 8, 398: 7, 402: 2} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 110 "The primary considerations for the data plane are to maintain integrity of data and delivery of the associated DetNet service traversing the DetNet network. Application flows can be protected through whatever means is provided by the underlying technology. For example, encryption may be used, such as that provided by IPSec RFC4301 for IP flows and/or by an underlying sub-net using MACSec IEEE802.1AE-2018 for IP over Ethernet (Layer-2) flows." The changes are good . 144d973845395913fc7ee795d0deeadef660aef4 144d973845395913fc7ee795d0deeadef660aef4 draft-ietf-detnet-ip-over-mpls 9cd5099308dda5178dfc778daed2e53f93a4c789c440b0886d818bee2343f3ca ['6d1c378f6ab7bd6ae836d4ac295f0de5a2664c0064bd50ab47c1dde2a64665c8', '9cd5099308dda5178dfc778daed2e53f93a4c789c440b0886d818bee2343f3ca'] B "the primary considerations for the data plane are to maintain integrity of data and delivery of the associated detnet service traversing the detnet network. application flows can be protected through whatever means is provided by the underlying technology. for example, encryption may be used, such as that provided by ipsec rfc4301 for ip flows and/or by an underlying sub-net using macsec ieee802.1ae-2018 for ip over ethernet (layer-2) flows." {102: 1, 36: 1, 24: 1, 15: 1, 6: 3, 79: 3, 90: 2, 51: 3, 130: 3, 62: 5, 85: 6, 68: 5, 35: 4, 110: 4, 91: 3, 114: 2, 97: 3, 31: 3, 13: 2, 67: 2, 38: 3, 26: 2, 124: 4, 98: 3, 54: 3, 127: 4, 8: 3, 96: 3, 64: 2, 30: 2, 61: 4, 55: 4, 27: 3, 52: 2, 129: 4, 115: 2, 84: 2, 76: 7, 87: 2, 131: 6, 113: 4, 99: 3, 53: 2, 72: 3} {272: 1, 353: 1, 354: 1, 352: 1, 1: 10, 4: 3, 9: 6, 10: 4, 15: 3, 24: 3, 25: 5, 26: 6, 27: 3, 39: 6, 43: 4, 49: 4, 50: 3, 58: 4, 59: 3, 64: 3, 69: 5, 81: 6, 82: 4, 86: 2, 96: 3, 97: 2, 100: 7, 108: 4, 109: 5, 110: 5, 111: 3, 114: 4, 115: 5, 116: 3, 118: 7, 119: 6, 120: 4, 121: 5, 122: 4, 123: 3, 124: 5, 128: 2, 129: 2, 130: 4, 132: 5, 136: 3, 145: 5, 147: 3, 151: 3, 152: 2, 154: 4, 156: 2, 161: 4, 162: 4, 165: 4, 168: 5, 169: 2, 180: 2, 184: 6, 187: 6, 188: 5, 191: 4, 194: 5, 202: 6, 203: 7, 206: 3, 207: 4, 215: 3, 217: 4, 218: 9, 220: 3, 221: 3, 222: 6, 224: 4, 227: 5, 229: 2, 234: 6, 235: 3, 241: 3, 242: 3, 243: 5, 244: 3, 245: 5, 248: 3, 250: 4, 258: 12, 262: 5, 263: 6, 264: 4, 267: 5, 270: 3, 273: 6, 287: 4, 289: 2, 291: 4, 299: 5, 300: 3, 304: 3, 309: 4, 314: 3, 315: 2, 320: 5, 323: 5, 327: 5, 328: 4, 329: 3, 330: 11, 334: 3, 335: 3, 341: 5, 342: 6, 347: 5, 348: 5, 350: 8, 351: 4, 358: 5, 365: 2, 366: 3, 369: 2, 371: 7, 372: 4, 376: 3, 384: 4, 385: 3, 386: 4, 387: 3, 392: 4, 393: 5, 396: 6, 397: 8, 398: 7, 402: 2} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 108 "The DetNet Architecture models the DetNet related data plane functions decomposed into two sub-layers: a service sub-layer and a forwarding sub-layer. The service sub-layer is used to provide DetNet service functions such as protection and reordering. The forwarding sub-layer is used to provide forwarding assurance (low loss, assured latency, and limited reordering)." "Includes changes as asked by . please do a "" make "" after review ." ad5c0735d2a8f5f076585d476abffa870dfb03cf ad5c0735d2a8f5f076585d476abffa870dfb03cf draft-ietf-detnet-mpls b2fc134f17101ca458a5eb9bc437758a99e59fdf182a9a37196e1cbaa85e5f28 ['b2fc134f17101ca458a5eb9bc437758a99e59fdf182a9a37196e1cbaa85e5f28', 'e0c95d9bc605e911fd32ffc649664bff1d4bcf97e922cc62e17abefc214eedcd'] A "the detnet architecture models the detnet related data plane functions decomposed into two sub-layers: a service sub-layer and a forwarding sub-layer. the service sub-layer is used to provide detnet service functions such as protection and reordering. the forwarding sub-layer is used to provide forwarding assurance (low loss, assured latency, and limited reordering)." {117: 1} {361: 1} {361, 275} 108 "The DetNet Architecture models the DetNet related data plane functions decomposed into two sub-layers: a service sub-layer and a forwarding sub-layer. The service sub-layer is used to provide DetNet service functions such as protection and reordering. The forwarding sub-layer is used to provide forwarding assurance (low loss, assured latency, and limited out-of-order delivery)." "Includes changes as asked by . please do a "" make "" after review ." ad5c0735d2a8f5f076585d476abffa870dfb03cf ad5c0735d2a8f5f076585d476abffa870dfb03cf draft-ietf-detnet-mpls e0c95d9bc605e911fd32ffc649664bff1d4bcf97e922cc62e17abefc214eedcd ['b2fc134f17101ca458a5eb9bc437758a99e59fdf182a9a37196e1cbaa85e5f28', 'e0c95d9bc605e911fd32ffc649664bff1d4bcf97e922cc62e17abefc214eedcd'] B "the detnet architecture models the detnet related data plane functions decomposed into two sub-layers: a service sub-layer and a forwarding sub-layer. the service sub-layer is used to provide detnet service functions such as protection and reordering. the forwarding sub-layer is used to provide forwarding assurance (low loss, assured latency, and limited out-of-order delivery)." {117: 1} {361: 1} {361, 275} 108 "The Packet Replication Function (PRF) function MAY be supported by an implementation for outgoing DetNet flows. The use of the PRF for a particular DetNet service MUST be provisioned via configuration, e.g., via the controller plane described in I-D.ietf-detnet-data- plane-framework. When replication is configure, the same app-flow data will be sent over multiple outgoing DetNet member flows using forwarding sub-layer LSPs. An S-Label value MUST be configured per outgoing member flow. The same d-CW field value MUST be used on all outgoing member flows for each replicated MPLS packet." "Includes changes as asked by . please do a "" make "" after review ." ad5c0735d2a8f5f076585d476abffa870dfb03cf ad5c0735d2a8f5f076585d476abffa870dfb03cf draft-ietf-detnet-mpls 6fe04f8b33c3d9af82ffd81cc7d9f8d03e7784282a48b667535db0b9e82ac8f9 ['349538ee233b3cb795653f05cc1291786682fd83030f727769de333e47656b9a', '6fe04f8b33c3d9af82ffd81cc7d9f8d03e7784282a48b667535db0b9e82ac8f9'] A "the packet replication function (prf) function may be supported by an implementation for outgoing detnet flows. the use of the prf for a particular detnet service must be provisioned via configuration, e.g., via the controller plane described in i-d.ietf-detnet-data- plane-framework. when replication is configure, the same app-flow data will be sent over multiple outgoing detnet member flows using forwarding sub-layer lsps. an s-label value must be configured per outgoing member flow. the same d-cw field value must be used on all outgoing member flows for each replicated mpls packet." {104: 1} {176: 1} {176, 76} 108 "The Packet Replication Function (PRF) function MAY be supported by an implementation for outgoing DetNet flows. The use of the PRF for a particular DetNet service MUST be provisioned via configuration, e.g., via the controller plane described in I-D.ietf-detnet-data- plane-framework. When replication is configured, the same app-flow data will be sent over multiple outgoing DetNet member flows using forwarding sub-layer LSPs. An S-Label value MUST be configured per outgoing member flow. The same d-CW field value MUST be used on all outgoing member flows for each replicated MPLS packet." "Includes changes as asked by . please do a "" make "" after review ." ad5c0735d2a8f5f076585d476abffa870dfb03cf ad5c0735d2a8f5f076585d476abffa870dfb03cf draft-ietf-detnet-mpls 349538ee233b3cb795653f05cc1291786682fd83030f727769de333e47656b9a ['349538ee233b3cb795653f05cc1291786682fd83030f727769de333e47656b9a', '6fe04f8b33c3d9af82ffd81cc7d9f8d03e7784282a48b667535db0b9e82ac8f9'] B "the packet replication function (prf) function may be supported by an implementation for outgoing detnet flows. the use of the prf for a particular detnet service must be provisioned via configuration, e.g., via the controller plane described in i-d.ietf-detnet-data- plane-framework. when replication is configured, the same app-flow data will be sent over multiple outgoing detnet member flows using forwarding sub-layer lsps. an s-label value must be configured per outgoing member flow. the same d-cw field value must be used on all outgoing member flows for each replicated mpls packet." {104: 1} {176: 1} {176, 76} 108 "Note that an implementation MAY wish to constrain the maximum number sequence numbers that are tracked, on platform-wide or per flow basis. Some implementations MAY support the provisioning of the maximum number sequence numbers that are tracked number on either a platform-wide or per flow basis." "Includes changes as asked by . please do a "" make "" after review ." ad5c0735d2a8f5f076585d476abffa870dfb03cf ad5c0735d2a8f5f076585d476abffa870dfb03cf draft-ietf-detnet-mpls 5c966c67e01cfb730822d1f9d63f0895f2c4a00d145a3d28e8a9de67720e3223 ['1f7f2b84a8eaad2d3d5210269e8d5b5ba9d20ef952d3919d142bee230120b5f0', '5c966c67e01cfb730822d1f9d63f0895f2c4a00d145a3d28e8a9de67720e3223'] A "note that an implementation may wish to constrain the maximum number sequence numbers that are tracked, on platform-wide or per flow basis. some implementations may support the provisioning of the maximum number sequence numbers that are tracked number on either a platform-wide or per flow basis." {114: 1} {40: 1} {40, 41} 108 "Note that an implementation MAY wish to constrain the maximum number of sequence numbers that are tracked, on platform-wide or per flow basis. Some implementations MAY support the provisioning of the maximum number of sequence numbers that are tracked on either a platform-wide or per flow basis." "Includes changes as asked by . please do a "" make "" after review ." ad5c0735d2a8f5f076585d476abffa870dfb03cf ad5c0735d2a8f5f076585d476abffa870dfb03cf draft-ietf-detnet-mpls 1f7f2b84a8eaad2d3d5210269e8d5b5ba9d20ef952d3919d142bee230120b5f0 ['1f7f2b84a8eaad2d3d5210269e8d5b5ba9d20ef952d3919d142bee230120b5f0', '5c966c67e01cfb730822d1f9d63f0895f2c4a00d145a3d28e8a9de67720e3223'] B "note that an implementation may wish to constrain the maximum number of sequence numbers that are tracked, on platform-wide or per flow basis. some implementations may support the provisioning of the maximum number of sequence numbers that are tracked on either a platform-wide or per flow basis." {114: 1} {40: 1} {40, 41} 108 "CoS for DetNet flows carried in PWs and MPLS is provided using the existing MPLS Differentiated Services (DiffServ) architecture RFC3270. Both E-LSP and L-LSP MPLS DiffServ modes MAY be used to support DetNet flows. The Traffic Class field (formerly the EXP field) of an MPLS label follows the definition of RFC5462 and RFC3270. The Uniform, Pipe, and Short Pipe DiffServ tunneling and TTL processing models are described in RFC3270 and RFC3443 and MAY be used for MPLS LSPs supporting DetNet flows. MPLS ECN MAY also be used as defined in ECN RFC5129 and updated by RFC5462." "Includes changes as asked by . please do a "" make "" after review ." ad5c0735d2a8f5f076585d476abffa870dfb03cf ad5c0735d2a8f5f076585d476abffa870dfb03cf draft-ietf-detnet-mpls 3179f7899e90603f440f31bd0501db62a963e606ac1482a8468549362b459a97 ['c9a55ff32866fcfd583f3e544abbcdd17cab7abb62cf5766d4df81f3ae90755f', '3179f7899e90603f440f31bd0501db62a963e606ac1482a8468549362b459a97'] A "cos for detnet flows carried in pws and mpls is provided using the existing mpls differentiated services (diffserv) architecture rfc3270. both e-lsp and l-lsp mpls diffserv modes may be used to support detnet flows. the traffic class field (formerly the exp field) of an mpls label follows the definition of rfc5462 and rfc3270. the uniform, pipe, and short pipe diffserv tunneling and ttl processing models are described in rfc3270 and rfc3443 and may be used for mpls lsps supporting detnet flows. mpls ecn may also be used as defined in ecn rfc5129 and updated by rfc5462." {} {} {} 108 "CoS for DetNet flows carried in PWs and MPLS is provided using the existing MPLS Differentiated Services (DiffServ) architecture RFC3270. Both E-LSP and L-LSP MPLS DiffServ modes MAY be used to support DetNet flows. The Traffic Class field (formerly the EXP field) of an MPLS label follows the definition of RFC5462 and RFC3270. The Uniform, Pipe, and Short Pipe DiffServ tunneling and TTL processing models are described in RFC3270 and RFC3443 and MAY be used for MPLS LSPs supporting DetNet flows. MPLS Explicit Congestion Notification (ECN) MAY also be used as defined in ECN RFC5129 and updated by RFC5462." "Includes changes as asked by . please do a "" make "" after review ." ad5c0735d2a8f5f076585d476abffa870dfb03cf ad5c0735d2a8f5f076585d476abffa870dfb03cf draft-ietf-detnet-mpls c9a55ff32866fcfd583f3e544abbcdd17cab7abb62cf5766d4df81f3ae90755f ['c9a55ff32866fcfd583f3e544abbcdd17cab7abb62cf5766d4df81f3ae90755f', '3179f7899e90603f440f31bd0501db62a963e606ac1482a8468549362b459a97'] B "cos for detnet flows carried in pws and mpls is provided using the existing mpls differentiated services (diffserv) architecture rfc3270. both e-lsp and l-lsp mpls diffserv modes may be used to support detnet flows. the traffic class field (formerly the exp field) of an mpls label follows the definition of rfc5462 and rfc3270. the uniform, pipe, and short pipe diffserv tunneling and ttl processing models are described in rfc3270 and rfc3443 and may be used for mpls lsps supporting detnet flows. mpls explicit congestion notification (ecn) may also be used as defined in ecn rfc5129 and updated by rfc5462." {} {} {} 104 F-Label(s). Clarifying S - Label procedures ( i.e. , allowing S - Label value per outgoing member flow after PRF ) . 28c90f47cf23729fc53b0a0c1e51e15c79c74de5 28c90f47cf23729fc53b0a0c1e51e15c79c74de5 draft-ietf-detnet-mpls 419c3844325cb4219bc23b91614c046156b5c3b65c3adb97e90de394897059df ['dc5e3d7adc9c88ccd59bdf14b2c2e830fce5d2433386b2b0c5499bee03761e64', '419c3844325cb4219bc23b91614c046156b5c3b65c3adb97e90de394897059df'] A f-label(s). {} {} {} 104 "F-Label(s). In some PREOF topologies, the node performing replication will be sending to multiple nodes performing PEF or POF, and may need to send different S-Label values for the different member flows for the same DetNet service." Clarifying S - Label procedures ( i.e. , allowing S - Label value per outgoing member flow after PRF ) . 28c90f47cf23729fc53b0a0c1e51e15c79c74de5 28c90f47cf23729fc53b0a0c1e51e15c79c74de5 draft-ietf-detnet-mpls dc5e3d7adc9c88ccd59bdf14b2c2e830fce5d2433386b2b0c5499bee03761e64 ['dc5e3d7adc9c88ccd59bdf14b2c2e830fce5d2433386b2b0c5499bee03761e64', '419c3844325cb4219bc23b91614c046156b5c3b65c3adb97e90de394897059df'] B "f-label(s). in some preof topologies, the node performing replication will be sending to multiple nodes performing pef or pof, and may need to send different s-label values for the different member flows for the same detnet service." {} {} {} 104 "The Packet Replication Function (PRF) function MAY be supported by an implementation for outgoing DetNet flows. The use of the PRF for a particular DetNet service MUST be provisioned via configuration, e.g., via the controller plane described in I-D.ietf-detnet-data- plane-framework. When replication is configure, the same app-flow data will be sent over multiple outgoing DetNet member flows using forwarding sub-layer LSPs. The same d-CW field value MUST be used on all outgoing member flows for each replicated MPLS packet." Clarifying S - Label procedures ( i.e. , allowing S - Label value per outgoing member flow after PRF ) . 28c90f47cf23729fc53b0a0c1e51e15c79c74de5 28c90f47cf23729fc53b0a0c1e51e15c79c74de5 draft-ietf-detnet-mpls 10f83a65537b4181396f36431d721ff3c2a2f28b6b59745e83a7e5202157976b ['6fe04f8b33c3d9af82ffd81cc7d9f8d03e7784282a48b667535db0b9e82ac8f9', '10f83a65537b4181396f36431d721ff3c2a2f28b6b59745e83a7e5202157976b'] A "the packet replication function (prf) function may be supported by an implementation for outgoing detnet flows. the use of the prf for a particular detnet service must be provisioned via configuration, e.g., via the controller plane described in i-d.ietf-detnet-data- plane-framework. when replication is configure, the same app-flow data will be sent over multiple outgoing detnet member flows using forwarding sub-layer lsps. the same d-cw field value must be used on all outgoing member flows for each replicated mpls packet." {108: 1} {76: 1} {176, 76} 104 "The Packet Replication Function (PRF) function MAY be supported by an implementation for outgoing DetNet flows. The use of the PRF for a particular DetNet service MUST be provisioned via configuration, e.g., via the controller plane described in I-D.ietf-detnet-data- plane-framework. When replication is configure, the same app-flow data will be sent over multiple outgoing DetNet member flows using forwarding sub-layer LSPs. An S-Label value MUST be configured per outgoing member flow. The same d-CW field value MUST be used on all outgoing member flows for each replicated MPLS packet." Clarifying S - Label procedures ( i.e. , allowing S - Label value per outgoing member flow after PRF ) . 28c90f47cf23729fc53b0a0c1e51e15c79c74de5 28c90f47cf23729fc53b0a0c1e51e15c79c74de5 draft-ietf-detnet-mpls 6fe04f8b33c3d9af82ffd81cc7d9f8d03e7784282a48b667535db0b9e82ac8f9 ['6fe04f8b33c3d9af82ffd81cc7d9f8d03e7784282a48b667535db0b9e82ac8f9', '10f83a65537b4181396f36431d721ff3c2a2f28b6b59745e83a7e5202157976b'] B "the packet replication function (prf) function may be supported by an implementation for outgoing detnet flows. the use of the prf for a particular detnet service must be provisioned via configuration, e.g., via the controller plane described in i-d.ietf-detnet-data- plane-framework. when replication is configure, the same app-flow data will be sent over multiple outgoing detnet member flows using forwarding sub-layer lsps. an s-label value must be configured per outgoing member flow. the same d-cw field value must be used on all outgoing member flows for each replicated mpls packet." {108: 1} {76: 1} {176, 76} 104 "When sending a DetNet flow, zero or more F-Labels MAY be pushed on top of an S-Label by the node pushing an S-Label. The F-Label(s) to be pushed when sending a particular DetNet service MUST be provisioned per DetNet service via configuration, e.g., via the controller plane discussed in I-D.ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework. F-Label(s) can also provide context for an S-Label. To allow for the omission of F-Label(s), an implementation SHOULD also allow an outgoing interface to be configured." Clarifying S - Label procedures ( i.e. , allowing S - Label value per outgoing member flow after PRF ) . 28c90f47cf23729fc53b0a0c1e51e15c79c74de5 28c90f47cf23729fc53b0a0c1e51e15c79c74de5 draft-ietf-detnet-mpls 20cabe13d2aed70c4b3094b1462189e92e6afb7da95fe37c888b3fdcea9ec3bf ['20cabe13d2aed70c4b3094b1462189e92e6afb7da95fe37c888b3fdcea9ec3bf', '2bd5b88b7cd3568a4376f8f022a0a2b36015939fc78a9796253551bb5db611e6', '905b63c5f1e9dad6818faf1f1cec4f1554e62630126b9f59e9079ac7cea55f70', 'e084aee0e5bd7e896cfbb7dc99eecbcead12edf7d3d429b58f8750938a9c6c5f'] A "when sending a detnet flow, zero or more f-labels may be pushed on top of an s-label by the node pushing an s-label. the f-label(s) to be pushed when sending a particular detnet service must be provisioned per detnet service via configuration, e.g., via the controller plane discussed in i-d.ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework. f-label(s) can also provide context for an s-label. to allow for the omission of f-label(s), an implementation should also allow an outgoing interface to be configured." {} {} {} 104 "When PRF is supported, the same app-flow data will be sent over multiple outgoing DetNet member flows using forwarding sub-layer LSPs. To support PRF an implementation MUST support the setting of different sets of F-Labels per DetNet member flow. To allow for the omission of F-Labels, an implementation SHOULD also allow multiple outgoing interfaces to be provisioned." Clarifying S - Label procedures ( i.e. , allowing S - Label value per outgoing member flow after PRF ) . 28c90f47cf23729fc53b0a0c1e51e15c79c74de5 28c90f47cf23729fc53b0a0c1e51e15c79c74de5 draft-ietf-detnet-mpls 2bd5b88b7cd3568a4376f8f022a0a2b36015939fc78a9796253551bb5db611e6 ['20cabe13d2aed70c4b3094b1462189e92e6afb7da95fe37c888b3fdcea9ec3bf', '2bd5b88b7cd3568a4376f8f022a0a2b36015939fc78a9796253551bb5db611e6', '905b63c5f1e9dad6818faf1f1cec4f1554e62630126b9f59e9079ac7cea55f70', 'e084aee0e5bd7e896cfbb7dc99eecbcead12edf7d3d429b58f8750938a9c6c5f'] A "when prf is supported, the same app-flow data will be sent over multiple outgoing detnet member flows using forwarding sub-layer lsps. to support prf an implementation must support the setting of different sets of f-labels per detnet member flow. to allow for the omission of f-labels, an implementation should also allow multiple outgoing interfaces to be provisioned." {} {} {} 104 "When sending a DetNet flow, zero or more F-Labels MAY be pushed on top of an S-Label by the node pushing an S-Label. The F-Label(s) to be pushed when sending a particular DetNet service MUST be provisioned per outgoing S-Label via configuration, e.g., via the controller plane discussed in I-D.ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework. F-Label(s) can also provide context for an S-Label. To allow for the omission of F-Label(s), an implementation SHOULD also allow an outgoing interface to be configured per S-Label." Clarifying S - Label procedures ( i.e. , allowing S - Label value per outgoing member flow after PRF ) . 28c90f47cf23729fc53b0a0c1e51e15c79c74de5 28c90f47cf23729fc53b0a0c1e51e15c79c74de5 draft-ietf-detnet-mpls 905b63c5f1e9dad6818faf1f1cec4f1554e62630126b9f59e9079ac7cea55f70 ['20cabe13d2aed70c4b3094b1462189e92e6afb7da95fe37c888b3fdcea9ec3bf', '2bd5b88b7cd3568a4376f8f022a0a2b36015939fc78a9796253551bb5db611e6', '905b63c5f1e9dad6818faf1f1cec4f1554e62630126b9f59e9079ac7cea55f70', 'e084aee0e5bd7e896cfbb7dc99eecbcead12edf7d3d429b58f8750938a9c6c5f'] B "when sending a detnet flow, zero or more f-labels may be pushed on top of an s-label by the node pushing an s-label. the f-label(s) to be pushed when sending a particular detnet service must be provisioned per outgoing s-label via configuration, e.g., via the controller plane discussed in i-d.ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework. f-label(s) can also provide context for an s-label. to allow for the omission of f-label(s), an implementation should also allow an outgoing interface to be configured per s-label." {} {} {} 104 "Note, when PRF is supported, the same app-flow data will be sent over multiple outgoing DetNet member flows using forwarding sub-layer LSPs. This means that implementation may be sending different sets of F-Labels per DetNet member flow, each with a different S-Label." Clarifying S - Label procedures ( i.e. , allowing S - Label value per outgoing member flow after PRF ) . 28c90f47cf23729fc53b0a0c1e51e15c79c74de5 28c90f47cf23729fc53b0a0c1e51e15c79c74de5 draft-ietf-detnet-mpls e084aee0e5bd7e896cfbb7dc99eecbcead12edf7d3d429b58f8750938a9c6c5f ['20cabe13d2aed70c4b3094b1462189e92e6afb7da95fe37c888b3fdcea9ec3bf', '2bd5b88b7cd3568a4376f8f022a0a2b36015939fc78a9796253551bb5db611e6', '905b63c5f1e9dad6818faf1f1cec4f1554e62630126b9f59e9079ac7cea55f70', 'e084aee0e5bd7e896cfbb7dc99eecbcead12edf7d3d429b58f8750938a9c6c5f'] B "note, when prf is supported, the same app-flow data will be sent over multiple outgoing detnet member flows using forwarding sub-layer lsps. this means that implementation may be sending different sets of f-labels per detnet member flow, each with a different s-label." {} {} {} 104 "When multiple sets of outgoing F-Labels or interfaces are provisioned for a particular DetNet service, a copy of the outgoing packet, including the pushed S-Label, MUST be made per F-label set and outgoing interface. Each set of provisioned F-Labels are then pushed onto a copy of the packet. Each copy is then forwarded as described below in f-labels-all." Clarifying S - Label procedures ( i.e. , allowing S - Label value per outgoing member flow after PRF ) . 28c90f47cf23729fc53b0a0c1e51e15c79c74de5 28c90f47cf23729fc53b0a0c1e51e15c79c74de5 draft-ietf-detnet-mpls 88336e5ead3b36fc40e5b913c337f666a90de72d2e8dd6777db11da269a17c2a ['88336e5ead3b36fc40e5b913c337f666a90de72d2e8dd6777db11da269a17c2a', '966f93f23681d2f1aa29ef2813cb307a8b3329986cf173d079fb55c512af3c4e'] A "when multiple sets of outgoing f-labels or interfaces are provisioned for a particular detnet service, a copy of the outgoing packet, including the pushed s-label, must be made per f-label set and outgoing interface. each set of provisioned f-labels are then pushed onto a copy of the packet. each copy is then forwarded as described below in f-labels-all." {114: 1} {230: 1} {214, 230} 104 "When multiple sets of outgoing F-Labels or interfaces are provisioned for a particular DetNet service, a copy of the outgoing packet, including the pushed member flow-specific S-Label, MUST be made per F-label set and outgoing interface. Each set of provisioned F-Labels are then pushed onto a copy of the packet. Each copy is then forwarded as described below in f-labels-all." Clarifying S - Label procedures ( i.e. , allowing S - Label value per outgoing member flow after PRF ) . 28c90f47cf23729fc53b0a0c1e51e15c79c74de5 28c90f47cf23729fc53b0a0c1e51e15c79c74de5 draft-ietf-detnet-mpls 966f93f23681d2f1aa29ef2813cb307a8b3329986cf173d079fb55c512af3c4e ['88336e5ead3b36fc40e5b913c337f666a90de72d2e8dd6777db11da269a17c2a', '966f93f23681d2f1aa29ef2813cb307a8b3329986cf173d079fb55c512af3c4e'] B "when multiple sets of outgoing f-labels or interfaces are provisioned for a particular detnet service, a copy of the outgoing packet, including the pushed member flow-specific s-label, must be made per f-label set and outgoing interface. each set of provisioned f-labels are then pushed onto a copy of the packet. each copy is then forwarded as described below in f-labels-all." {114: 1} {230: 1} {214, 230} 104 The outgoing S-Label for the service. Clarifying S - Label procedures ( i.e. , allowing S - Label value per outgoing member flow after PRF ) . 28c90f47cf23729fc53b0a0c1e51e15c79c74de5 28c90f47cf23729fc53b0a0c1e51e15c79c74de5 draft-ietf-detnet-mpls f2531ff5dc0cbc849d822efdfd8505955ffdd4d941a6444bb53ce62822e24147 ['f2531ff5dc0cbc849d822efdfd8505955ffdd4d941a6444bb53ce62822e24147', 'ed5af1049a2822fe7823f2c8219f153a5001cbed5b64b73b93bd974ece2ec2d9'] A the outgoing s-label for the service. {113: 1} {378: 1} {378, 388} 104 "The outgoing S-Label for each of the service's outgoing DetNet (member) flow." Clarifying S - Label procedures ( i.e. , allowing S - Label value per outgoing member flow after PRF ) . 28c90f47cf23729fc53b0a0c1e51e15c79c74de5 28c90f47cf23729fc53b0a0c1e51e15c79c74de5 draft-ietf-detnet-mpls ed5af1049a2822fe7823f2c8219f153a5001cbed5b64b73b93bd974ece2ec2d9 ['f2531ff5dc0cbc849d822efdfd8505955ffdd4d941a6444bb53ce62822e24147', 'ed5af1049a2822fe7823f2c8219f153a5001cbed5b64b73b93bd974ece2ec2d9'] B "the outgoing s-label for each of the service's outgoing detnet (member) flow." {113: 1} {378: 1} {378, 388} 102 "This document specifies the Deterministic Networking data plane when operating in an IP packet switched network." -- please approve and merge -- I 've uploaded this version ... b51489715e4f26f01dddc9265e5d15d7bbeac114 e749ebb19f9c5681460aa4e39c3b51f0b6fbb4b4 draft-ietf-detnet-ip c1b2f53256050bb070e55f9f05a48fff90d5daca8b836b6fee0d2b0de333d874 ['c1b2f53256050bb070e55f9f05a48fff90d5daca8b836b6fee0d2b0de333d874', 'f5a641b88edfd00a97b6b9c6da24d114e37792cba649b3344778fd6f06b1417f'] A "this document specifies the deterministic networking data plane when operating in an ip packet switched network." {} {} {} 102 "This document specifies the DetNet data plane operation for IP hosts and routers that provide DetNet service to IP encapsulated data. No DetNet-specific encapsulation is defined to support IP flows; instead the existing IP and higher layer protocol header information is used to support flow identification and DetNet service delivery. This document builds on the DetNet Architecture and Data Plane Framework." -- please approve and merge -- I 've uploaded this version ... b51489715e4f26f01dddc9265e5d15d7bbeac114 e749ebb19f9c5681460aa4e39c3b51f0b6fbb4b4 draft-ietf-detnet-ip f5a641b88edfd00a97b6b9c6da24d114e37792cba649b3344778fd6f06b1417f ['c1b2f53256050bb070e55f9f05a48fff90d5daca8b836b6fee0d2b0de333d874', 'f5a641b88edfd00a97b6b9c6da24d114e37792cba649b3344778fd6f06b1417f'] B "this document specifies the detnet data plane operation for ip hosts and routers that provide detnet service to ip encapsulated data. no detnet-specific encapsulation is defined to support ip flows; instead the existing ip and higher layer protocol header information is used to support flow identification and detnet service delivery. this document builds on the detnet architecture and data plane framework." {} {} {} 102 "This document specifies the DetNet data plane operation for IP hosts and routers that provide DetNet service to IP encapsulated data. No DetNet-specific encapsulation is defined to support IP flows, instead the existing IP and higher layer protocol header information is used to support flow identification and DetNet service delivery. Common data plane procedures and control information for all DetNet data planes can be found in the I-D.ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework." -- please approve and merge -- I 've uploaded this version ... b51489715e4f26f01dddc9265e5d15d7bbeac114 e749ebb19f9c5681460aa4e39c3b51f0b6fbb4b4 draft-ietf-detnet-ip d56fdfb2118295d1205c28a4dcb3c72bb1db4a2e7373b8533f02f4b62f427841 ['9a5732661fd3a943457a4628c35d7cbd5fba43f80d1b45172fcda8bf96097a1a', 'd56fdfb2118295d1205c28a4dcb3c72bb1db4a2e7373b8533f02f4b62f427841'] A "this document specifies the detnet data plane operation for ip hosts and routers that provide detnet service to ip encapsulated data. no detnet-specific encapsulation is defined to support ip flows, instead the existing ip and higher layer protocol header information is used to support flow identification and detnet service delivery. common data plane procedures and control information for all detnet data planes can be found in the i-d.ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework." {62: 1, 13: 2, 6: 3, 26: 2, 102: 3} {325: 1, 65: 2, 198: 3, 199: 2, 155: 3} {65, 325, 198, 199, 238, 155} 102 "This document specifies the DetNet data plane operation for IP hosts and routers that provide DetNet service to IP encapsulated data. No DetNet-specific encapsulation is defined to support IP flows; instead the existing IP and higher layer protocol header information is used to support flow identification and DetNet service delivery. Common data plane procedures and control information for all DetNet data planes can be found in I-D.ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework." -- please approve and merge -- I 've uploaded this version ... b51489715e4f26f01dddc9265e5d15d7bbeac114 e749ebb19f9c5681460aa4e39c3b51f0b6fbb4b4 draft-ietf-detnet-ip 9a5732661fd3a943457a4628c35d7cbd5fba43f80d1b45172fcda8bf96097a1a ['9a5732661fd3a943457a4628c35d7cbd5fba43f80d1b45172fcda8bf96097a1a', 'd56fdfb2118295d1205c28a4dcb3c72bb1db4a2e7373b8533f02f4b62f427841'] B "this document specifies the detnet data plane operation for ip hosts and routers that provide detnet service to ip encapsulated data. no detnet-specific encapsulation is defined to support ip flows; instead the existing ip and higher layer protocol header information is used to support flow identification and detnet service delivery. common data plane procedures and control information for all detnet data planes can be found in i-d.ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework." {62: 1, 13: 2, 6: 3, 26: 2, 102: 3} {325: 1, 65: 2, 198: 3, 199: 2, 155: 3} {65, 325, 198, 199, 238, 155} 102 "This document provides an overview of the DetNet IP data plane in sec_dt_dp, considerations that apply to providing DetNet services via the DetNet IP data plane in dn-gen-encap-solution. ip-procs provides the procedures for hosts and routers that support IP-based DetNet services. ip-flow-id-info summarizes the set of information that is needed to identify an individual DetNet flow." -- please approve and merge -- I 've uploaded this version ... b51489715e4f26f01dddc9265e5d15d7bbeac114 e749ebb19f9c5681460aa4e39c3b51f0b6fbb4b4 draft-ietf-detnet-ip 60d927ad7ea9b7c651b1128fa99ba39149525a5c0b98cf31de613296a37297f9 ['60d927ad7ea9b7c651b1128fa99ba39149525a5c0b98cf31de613296a37297f9', '9025d219197b170df84d18f7141f836e48d0431370e96891c8ff9d37258eb214'] A "this document provides an overview of the detnet ip data plane in sec_dt_dp, considerations that apply to providing detnet services via the detnet ip data plane in dn-gen-encap-solution. ip-procs provides the procedures for hosts and routers that support ip-based detnet services. ip-flow-id-info summarizes the set of information that is needed to identify an individual detnet flow." {13: 1, 62: 2, 6: 4, 26: 3, 102: 3} {65: 1, 325: 2, 198: 4, 199: 3, 238: 3} {65, 325, 198, 199, 238, 155} 102 "This document provides an overview of the DetNet IP data plane in sec_dt_dp, and considerations that apply to providing DetNet services via the DetNet IP data plane in dn-gen-encap-solution. ip-procs provides the procedures for hosts and routers that support IP-based DetNet services. ip-flow-id-info summarizes the set of information that is needed to identify an individual DetNet flow." -- please approve and merge -- I 've uploaded this version ... b51489715e4f26f01dddc9265e5d15d7bbeac114 e749ebb19f9c5681460aa4e39c3b51f0b6fbb4b4 draft-ietf-detnet-ip 9025d219197b170df84d18f7141f836e48d0431370e96891c8ff9d37258eb214 ['60d927ad7ea9b7c651b1128fa99ba39149525a5c0b98cf31de613296a37297f9', '9025d219197b170df84d18f7141f836e48d0431370e96891c8ff9d37258eb214'] B "this document provides an overview of the detnet ip data plane in sec_dt_dp, and considerations that apply to providing detnet services via the detnet ip data plane in dn-gen-encap-solution. ip-procs provides the procedures for hosts and routers that support ip-based detnet services. ip-flow-id-info summarizes the set of information that is needed to identify an individual detnet flow." {13: 1, 62: 2, 6: 4, 26: 3, 102: 3} {65: 1, 325: 2, 198: 4, 199: 3, 238: 3} {65, 325, 198, 199, 238, 155} 102 "This document describes how IP is used by DetNet nodes, i.e., hosts and routers, to identify DetNet flows and provide a DetNet service using an IP data plane. From a data plane perspective, an end-to-end IP model is followed. As mentioned above, existing IP and higher layer protocol header information is used to support flow identification and DetNet service delivery. Common data plane procedures and control information for all DetNet data planes can be found in the I-D.ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework." -- please approve and merge -- I 've uploaded this version ... b51489715e4f26f01dddc9265e5d15d7bbeac114 e749ebb19f9c5681460aa4e39c3b51f0b6fbb4b4 draft-ietf-detnet-ip 400bf736a5e13d1d94d0ec51ce637c1a7c981486fb999b363a151d4eb30aa9b7 ['169504a51734986840922b736edc8361a8e6e2c62fb40a0b0047ea50ed35a6b4', '400bf736a5e13d1d94d0ec51ce637c1a7c981486fb999b363a151d4eb30aa9b7', '07ea15b6f7ef49dbfdd3cd769e99a8c0cc7391a539a9eb3c65ea39bf88a68229', '0dce9318404f8942681c23283d06936397cb47bd6b17a00f4dba8ca332d393e2'] A "this document describes how ip is used by detnet nodes, i.e., hosts and routers, to identify detnet flows and provide a detnet service using an ip data plane. from a data plane perspective, an end-to-end ip model is followed. as mentioned above, existing ip and higher layer protocol header information is used to support flow identification and detnet service delivery. common data plane procedures and control information for all detnet data planes can be found in the i-d.ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework." {62: 1, 6: 3, 26: 2} {99: 1, 11: 3, 201: 2} {99, 201, 11, 23} 102 "The DetNet IP data plane primarily uses ""6-tuple"" based flow identification, where 6-tuple refers to information carried in IP and higher layer protocol headers. The 6-tuple referred to in this document is the same as that defined in RFC3290. Specifically 6-tuple is (destination address, source address, IP protocol, source port, destination port, and differentiated services (DiffServ) code point (DSCP). General background on the use of IP headers, and 5-tuples, to identify flows and support Quality of Service (QoS) can be found in RFC3670. RFC7657 also provides useful background on the delivery of DiffServ and ""tuple"" based flow identification. Note that a 6-tuple is composed of a 5-tuple plus the addition of a DSCP component." -- please approve and merge -- I 've uploaded this version ... b51489715e4f26f01dddc9265e5d15d7bbeac114 e749ebb19f9c5681460aa4e39c3b51f0b6fbb4b4 draft-ietf-detnet-ip 169504a51734986840922b736edc8361a8e6e2c62fb40a0b0047ea50ed35a6b4 ['169504a51734986840922b736edc8361a8e6e2c62fb40a0b0047ea50ed35a6b4', '400bf736a5e13d1d94d0ec51ce637c1a7c981486fb999b363a151d4eb30aa9b7', '07ea15b6f7ef49dbfdd3cd769e99a8c0cc7391a539a9eb3c65ea39bf88a68229', '0dce9318404f8942681c23283d06936397cb47bd6b17a00f4dba8ca332d393e2'] A "the detnet ip data plane primarily uses ""6-tuple"" based flow identification, where 6-tuple refers to information carried in ip and higher layer protocol headers. the 6-tuple referred to in this document is the same as that defined in rfc3290. specifically 6-tuple is (destination address, source address, ip protocol, source port, destination port, and differentiated services (diffserv) code point (dscp). general background on the use of ip headers, and 5-tuples, to identify flows and support quality of service (qos) can be found in rfc3670. rfc7657 also provides useful background on the delivery of diffserv and ""tuple"" based flow identification. note that a 6-tuple is composed of a 5-tuple plus the addition of a dscp component." {62: 1, 6: 3, 26: 2} {99: 1, 11: 3, 201: 2} {99, 201, 11, 23} 102 "This document describes how IP is used by DetNet nodes, i.e., hosts and routers, to identify DetNet flows and provide a DetNet service using an IP data plane. From a data plane perspective, an end-to-end IP model is followed. As mentioned above, existing IP and higher layer protocol header information is used to support flow identification and DetNet service delivery. Common data plane procedures and control information for all DetNet data planes can be found in I-D.ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework." -- please approve and merge -- I 've uploaded this version ... b51489715e4f26f01dddc9265e5d15d7bbeac114 e749ebb19f9c5681460aa4e39c3b51f0b6fbb4b4 draft-ietf-detnet-ip 07ea15b6f7ef49dbfdd3cd769e99a8c0cc7391a539a9eb3c65ea39bf88a68229 ['169504a51734986840922b736edc8361a8e6e2c62fb40a0b0047ea50ed35a6b4', '400bf736a5e13d1d94d0ec51ce637c1a7c981486fb999b363a151d4eb30aa9b7', '07ea15b6f7ef49dbfdd3cd769e99a8c0cc7391a539a9eb3c65ea39bf88a68229', '0dce9318404f8942681c23283d06936397cb47bd6b17a00f4dba8ca332d393e2'] B "this document describes how ip is used by detnet nodes, i.e., hosts and routers, to identify detnet flows and provide a detnet service using an ip data plane. from a data plane perspective, an end-to-end ip model is followed. as mentioned above, existing ip and higher layer protocol header information is used to support flow identification and detnet service delivery. common data plane procedures and control information for all detnet data planes can be found in i-d.ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework." {62: 1, 6: 3, 26: 2} {99: 1, 11: 3, 201: 2} {99, 201, 11, 23} 102 "The DetNet IP data plane primarily uses 6-tuple based flow identification, where ""6-tuple"" refers to information carried in IP and higher layer protocol headers. The 6-tuple referred to in this document is the same as that defined in RFC3290. Specifically 6-tuple is destination address, source address, IP protocol, source port, destination port, and differentiated services (DiffServ) code point (DSCP). General background on the use of IP headers, and 5-tuples, to identify flows and support Quality of Service (QoS) can be found in RFC3670. RFC7657 also provides useful background on the delivery of DiffServ and ""tuple"" based flow identification. Note that a 6-tuple is composed of a 5-tuple plus the addition of a DSCP component." -- please approve and merge -- I 've uploaded this version ... b51489715e4f26f01dddc9265e5d15d7bbeac114 e749ebb19f9c5681460aa4e39c3b51f0b6fbb4b4 draft-ietf-detnet-ip 0dce9318404f8942681c23283d06936397cb47bd6b17a00f4dba8ca332d393e2 ['169504a51734986840922b736edc8361a8e6e2c62fb40a0b0047ea50ed35a6b4', '400bf736a5e13d1d94d0ec51ce637c1a7c981486fb999b363a151d4eb30aa9b7', '07ea15b6f7ef49dbfdd3cd769e99a8c0cc7391a539a9eb3c65ea39bf88a68229', '0dce9318404f8942681c23283d06936397cb47bd6b17a00f4dba8ca332d393e2'] B "the detnet ip data plane primarily uses 6-tuple based flow identification, where ""6-tuple"" refers to information carried in ip and higher layer protocol headers. the 6-tuple referred to in this document is the same as that defined in rfc3290. specifically 6-tuple is destination address, source address, ip protocol, source port, destination port, and differentiated services (diffserv) code point (dscp). general background on the use of ip headers, and 5-tuples, to identify flows and support quality of service (qos) can be found in rfc3670. rfc7657 also provides useful background on the delivery of diffserv and ""tuple"" based flow identification. note that a 6-tuple is composed of a 5-tuple plus the addition of a dscp component." {62: 1, 6: 3, 26: 2} {99: 1, 11: 3, 201: 2} {99, 201, 11, 23} 102 "For some of the protocols 5-tuples and 6-tuples cannot be used because the port information is not available (e.g., ICMP, IPSec ESP). Same can be valid for flow aggregates. In such cases using smaller tuples are appropriate, e.g., a 3-tuple (2 IP addresses, IP protocol) or even a 2-tuple (all IP traffic between two IP addresses)." -- please approve and merge -- I 've uploaded this version ... b51489715e4f26f01dddc9265e5d15d7bbeac114 e749ebb19f9c5681460aa4e39c3b51f0b6fbb4b4 draft-ietf-detnet-ip a5d212993acd4cecd4b053af9083d57b28a719b5d45c8abf4a19865009312cea ['1d4b319c85663a43b4a432de55ed0c85c37823eaa88551f6499ea030640bfc9e', '9e35f6f383fc0251af4eb96a29f3593b59173bd428d5dc75dd38749ad7f4a0c0', 'a5d212993acd4cecd4b053af9083d57b28a719b5d45c8abf4a19865009312cea', 'fa9f0364c036dd1ff82a1a90e1d811fb27124c4bfd88aff9b7db3cb308fd4136'] A "for some of the protocols 5-tuples and 6-tuples cannot be used because the port information is not available (e.g., icmp, ipsec esp). same can be valid for flow aggregates. in such cases using smaller tuples are appropriate, e.g., a 3-tuple (2 ip addresses, ip protocol) or even a 2-tuple (all ip traffic between two ip addresses)." {85: 1, 56: 3, 60: 4, 62: 2, 102: 4} {312: 1, 368: 3, 146: 4, 282: 2, 189: 4, 190: 3} {38, 368, 146, 312, 282, 189, 190} 102 "Non-DetNet and DetNet IP packets are identical on the wire. Generally the fields used in flow identification are forwarded unmodified, however modification of these fields is allowed, for example changing the DSCP value, when required by the DetNet service." -- please approve and merge -- I 've uploaded this version ... b51489715e4f26f01dddc9265e5d15d7bbeac114 e749ebb19f9c5681460aa4e39c3b51f0b6fbb4b4 draft-ietf-detnet-ip fa9f0364c036dd1ff82a1a90e1d811fb27124c4bfd88aff9b7db3cb308fd4136 ['1d4b319c85663a43b4a432de55ed0c85c37823eaa88551f6499ea030640bfc9e', '9e35f6f383fc0251af4eb96a29f3593b59173bd428d5dc75dd38749ad7f4a0c0', 'a5d212993acd4cecd4b053af9083d57b28a719b5d45c8abf4a19865009312cea', 'fa9f0364c036dd1ff82a1a90e1d811fb27124c4bfd88aff9b7db3cb308fd4136'] A "non-detnet and detnet ip packets are identical on the wire. generally the fields used in flow identification are forwarded unmodified, however modification of these fields is allowed, for example changing the dscp value, when required by the detnet service." {85: 1, 56: 3, 60: 4, 62: 2, 102: 4} {312: 1, 368: 3, 146: 4, 282: 2, 189: 4, 190: 3} {38, 368, 146, 312, 282, 189, 190} 102 "For some of the protocols 5-tuples and 6-tuples cannot be used because the port information is not available (e.g., ICMP, IPSec ESP). This is also the case for flow aggregates. In such cases, using fewer fields is appropriate, e.g., a 3-tuple (2 IP addresses, IP protocol) or even a 2-tuple (all IP traffic between two IP addresses)." -- please approve and merge -- I 've uploaded this version ... b51489715e4f26f01dddc9265e5d15d7bbeac114 e749ebb19f9c5681460aa4e39c3b51f0b6fbb4b4 draft-ietf-detnet-ip 1d4b319c85663a43b4a432de55ed0c85c37823eaa88551f6499ea030640bfc9e ['1d4b319c85663a43b4a432de55ed0c85c37823eaa88551f6499ea030640bfc9e', '9e35f6f383fc0251af4eb96a29f3593b59173bd428d5dc75dd38749ad7f4a0c0', 'a5d212993acd4cecd4b053af9083d57b28a719b5d45c8abf4a19865009312cea', 'fa9f0364c036dd1ff82a1a90e1d811fb27124c4bfd88aff9b7db3cb308fd4136'] B "for some of the protocols 5-tuples and 6-tuples cannot be used because the port information is not available (e.g., icmp, ipsec esp). this is also the case for flow aggregates. in such cases, using fewer fields is appropriate, e.g., a 3-tuple (2 ip addresses, ip protocol) or even a 2-tuple (all ip traffic between two ip addresses)." {85: 1, 56: 3, 60: 4, 62: 2, 102: 4} {312: 1, 368: 3, 146: 4, 282: 2, 189: 4, 190: 3} {38, 368, 146, 312, 282, 189, 190} 102 "Non-DetNet and DetNet IP packets have the same protocol header format on the wire. Generally the fields used in flow identification are forwarded unmodified. However, standard modification of the DSCP field RFC2474 is not precluded." -- please approve and merge -- I 've uploaded this version ... b51489715e4f26f01dddc9265e5d15d7bbeac114 e749ebb19f9c5681460aa4e39c3b51f0b6fbb4b4 draft-ietf-detnet-ip 9e35f6f383fc0251af4eb96a29f3593b59173bd428d5dc75dd38749ad7f4a0c0 ['1d4b319c85663a43b4a432de55ed0c85c37823eaa88551f6499ea030640bfc9e', '9e35f6f383fc0251af4eb96a29f3593b59173bd428d5dc75dd38749ad7f4a0c0', 'a5d212993acd4cecd4b053af9083d57b28a719b5d45c8abf4a19865009312cea', 'fa9f0364c036dd1ff82a1a90e1d811fb27124c4bfd88aff9b7db3cb308fd4136'] B "non-detnet and detnet ip packets have the same protocol header format on the wire. generally the fields used in flow identification are forwarded unmodified. however, standard modification of the dscp field rfc2474 is not precluded." {85: 1, 56: 3, 60: 4, 62: 2, 102: 4} {312: 1, 368: 3, 146: 4, 282: 2, 189: 4, 190: 3} {38, 368, 146, 312, 282, 189, 190} 102 "fig_ip_detnet_simple illustrates a DetNet enabled IP network. The DetNet enabled end systems originate IP encapsulated traffic that is identified within the DetNet domain as DetNet flows. Relay nodes understand the forwarding requirements of the DetNet flow and ensure that node, interface and sub-network resources are allocated to ensure DetNet service requirements. The dotted line around the Service component of the Relay Nodes indicates that the transit routers are DetNet service aware but do not perform any DetNet service sub-layer function, e.g., PREOF (Packet Replication, Elimination and Ordering Function)." -- please approve and merge -- I 've uploaded this version ... b51489715e4f26f01dddc9265e5d15d7bbeac114 e749ebb19f9c5681460aa4e39c3b51f0b6fbb4b4 draft-ietf-detnet-ip 7ad17d56f09aaf8411c8e206ecc1b70bb21e3246d3c5514cfacf5aa46d8b2048 ['7ad17d56f09aaf8411c8e206ecc1b70bb21e3246d3c5514cfacf5aa46d8b2048', '2b4e0d9841e0c294da8cb4f5e9292fe7c2fab93321cf8c30d7c2ae159d4d3488', 'f69cebbdfcb0294535180d988d60f27e3b234b5693468cfef93a517650b0be94'] A "fig_ip_detnet_simple illustrates a detnet enabled ip network. the detnet enabled end systems originate ip encapsulated traffic that is identified within the detnet domain as detnet flows. relay nodes understand the forwarding requirements of the detnet flow and ensure that node, interface and sub-network resources are allocated to ensure detnet service requirements. the dotted line around the service component of the relay nodes indicates that the transit routers are detnet service aware but do not perform any detnet service sub-layer function, e.g., preof (packet replication, elimination and ordering function)." {85: 1, 102: 4, 56: 3, 60: 4, 62: 2} {190: 1, 38: 4, 368: 3, 146: 4, 312: 3, 282: 2} {38, 368, 146, 312, 282, 189, 190} 102 "The specific procedures that are required to be implemented by a DetNet node supporting this document can be found in ip-procs. The DetNet controller plane, as defined in RFC8655, is responsible for providing each node with the information needed to identify and handle each DetNet flow." -- please approve and merge -- I 've uploaded this version ... b51489715e4f26f01dddc9265e5d15d7bbeac114 e749ebb19f9c5681460aa4e39c3b51f0b6fbb4b4 draft-ietf-detnet-ip 2b4e0d9841e0c294da8cb4f5e9292fe7c2fab93321cf8c30d7c2ae159d4d3488 ['7ad17d56f09aaf8411c8e206ecc1b70bb21e3246d3c5514cfacf5aa46d8b2048', '2b4e0d9841e0c294da8cb4f5e9292fe7c2fab93321cf8c30d7c2ae159d4d3488', 'f69cebbdfcb0294535180d988d60f27e3b234b5693468cfef93a517650b0be94'] B "the specific procedures that are required to be implemented by a detnet node supporting this document can be found in ip-procs. the detnet controller plane, as defined in rfc8655, is responsible for providing each node with the information needed to identify and handle each detnet flow." {85: 1, 102: 4, 56: 3, 60: 4, 62: 2} {190: 1, 38: 4, 368: 3, 146: 4, 312: 3, 282: 2} {38, 368, 146, 312, 282, 189, 190} 102 "fig_ip_detnet_simple illustrates a DetNet enabled IP network. The DetNet enabled end systems originate IP encapsulated traffic that is identified within the DetNet domain as DetNet flows based on IP header information. Relay nodes understand the forwarding requirements of the DetNet flow and ensure that node, interface and sub-network resources are allocated to ensure DetNet service requirements. The dotted line around the Service component of the Relay Nodes indicates that the transit routers are DetNet service aware but do not perform any DetNet service sub-layer function, e.g., PREOF (Packet Replication, Elimination and Ordering Function)." -- please approve and merge -- I 've uploaded this version ... b51489715e4f26f01dddc9265e5d15d7bbeac114 e749ebb19f9c5681460aa4e39c3b51f0b6fbb4b4 draft-ietf-detnet-ip f69cebbdfcb0294535180d988d60f27e3b234b5693468cfef93a517650b0be94 ['7ad17d56f09aaf8411c8e206ecc1b70bb21e3246d3c5514cfacf5aa46d8b2048', '2b4e0d9841e0c294da8cb4f5e9292fe7c2fab93321cf8c30d7c2ae159d4d3488', 'f69cebbdfcb0294535180d988d60f27e3b234b5693468cfef93a517650b0be94'] B "fig_ip_detnet_simple illustrates a detnet enabled ip network. the detnet enabled end systems originate ip encapsulated traffic that is identified within the detnet domain as detnet flows based on ip header information. relay nodes understand the forwarding requirements of the detnet flow and ensure that node, interface and sub-network resources are allocated to ensure detnet service requirements. the dotted line around the service component of the relay nodes indicates that the transit routers are detnet service aware but do not perform any detnet service sub-layer function, e.g., preof (packet replication, elimination and ordering function)." {85: 1, 102: 4, 56: 3, 60: 4, 62: 2} {190: 1, 38: 4, 368: 3, 146: 4, 312: 3, 282: 2} {38, 368, 146, 312, 282, 189, 190} 102 "Note, that fig_ip_detnet_simple and fig_non_detnet_ip can be collapsed, so IP DetNet End Systems can communicate over DetNet IP network with IP End System." -- please approve and merge -- I 've uploaded this version ... b51489715e4f26f01dddc9265e5d15d7bbeac114 e749ebb19f9c5681460aa4e39c3b51f0b6fbb4b4 draft-ietf-detnet-ip 70bd929f7b7525f661d98655998fc5fa4dfa1b0b5643aec3360083890ea7a0f5 ['ca80e8882c3b1b7b43e7b4db56253a8c875d3703aa7f93577f17a05919cd0a5e', '2513a482b05f6b1d65ce337a5406f9458316189618c9f98c2ed8ef33f0608825', '96370dbc25c3f1e0e6f0205251af1a317f2d7d8ec612c52a59ce076bcafdd9a7', '6bf6934834360be8bde2779132bfcf68ec8e529cbec2de178df1564009136e7c', '70bd929f7b7525f661d98655998fc5fa4dfa1b0b5643aec3360083890ea7a0f5', '4b29ed570f29f27831629b625426485f6a8a813d016ddd8642ea443069fb5b45', 'd076fe48974d403615a9f7bbcf5bbef3f760aeaf116a2faf4d123cdb2dcad1d4', 'fd0d3d7ba40e65fa061931cfb7d0f55d4f3056ed210d3960b5adc00c479d8187'] A "note, that fig_ip_detnet_simple and fig_non_detnet_ip can be collapsed, so ip detnet end systems can communicate over detnet ip network with ip end system." {62: 1, 85: 1, 26: 1, 55: 1, 6: 2, 79: 4, 90: 2, 51: 2, 130: 3, 68: 2, 35: 5, 110: 5, 91: 7, 114: 5, 97: 4, 31: 3, 13: 2, 67: 4, 38: 6, 124: 3, 98: 4, 54: 4, 127: 5, 8: 2, 96: 3, 64: 4, 30: 6, 61: 7, 27: 3, 15: 5, 52: 3, 129: 5, 115: 5, 84: 2, 76: 5, 87: 5, 131: 7, 102: 5, 113: 7, 99: 4, 36: 5, 24: 4, 53: 3, 72: 6} {25: 1, 26: 1, 119: 1, 162: 1, 1: 7, 4: 4, 9: 4, 10: 5, 15: 5, 24: 4, 27: 5, 39: 3, 43: 5, 49: 8, 50: 7, 58: 7, 59: 4, 64: 5, 69: 3, 81: 2, 82: 2, 86: 5, 96: 6, 97: 5, 100: 5, 108: 5, 109: 6, 110: 6, 111: 4, 114: 5, 115: 6, 116: 4, 118: 2, 120: 5, 121: 2, 122: 4, 123: 3, 124: 2, 128: 6, 129: 6, 130: 7, 132: 3, 136: 4, 145: 3, 147: 6, 151: 6, 152: 6, 154: 5, 156: 4, 161: 2, 165: 5, 168: 6, 169: 5, 172: 5, 180: 6, 184: 4, 187: 7, 188: 6, 191: 5, 194: 3, 202: 4, 203: 5, 206: 4, 207: 5, 215: 3, 217: 5, 218: 6, 220: 2, 221: 2, 222: 3, 224: 5, 227: 3, 229: 5, 234: 7, 235: 4, 241: 4, 242: 4, 243: 3, 244: 6, 245: 3, 248: 6, 250: 6, 258: 9, 262: 6, 263: 7, 264: 3, 267: 2, 270: 5, 272: 5, 273: 4, 287: 5, 289: 5, 291: 7, 299: 3, 300: 5, 304: 5, 309: 2, 314: 4, 315: 5, 323: 3, 327: 6, 328: 4, 329: 4, 330: 8, 334: 4, 335: 4, 341: 3, 342: 4, 347: 3, 348: 3, 350: 6, 351: 7, 352: 5, 353: 5, 354: 4, 358: 2, 365: 5, 366: 4, 369: 3, 371: 5, 372: 7, 376: 4, 384: 7, 385: 6, 386: 5, 387: 5, 392: 4, 393: 5, 396: 4, 397: 5, 398: 4, 402: 5} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 102 "As non-DetNet and DetNet IP packets are identical on the wire, from data plane perspective, the only difference is that there is flow- associated DetNet information on each DetNet node that defines the flow related characteristics and required forwarding behavior. As shown above, edge nodes provide a Service Proxy function that ""associates"" one or more IP flows with the appropriate DetNet flow- specific information and ensures that the flow receives the proper traffic treatment within the domain." -- please approve and merge -- I 've uploaded this version ... b51489715e4f26f01dddc9265e5d15d7bbeac114 e749ebb19f9c5681460aa4e39c3b51f0b6fbb4b4 draft-ietf-detnet-ip 96370dbc25c3f1e0e6f0205251af1a317f2d7d8ec612c52a59ce076bcafdd9a7 ['ca80e8882c3b1b7b43e7b4db56253a8c875d3703aa7f93577f17a05919cd0a5e', '2513a482b05f6b1d65ce337a5406f9458316189618c9f98c2ed8ef33f0608825', '96370dbc25c3f1e0e6f0205251af1a317f2d7d8ec612c52a59ce076bcafdd9a7', '6bf6934834360be8bde2779132bfcf68ec8e529cbec2de178df1564009136e7c', '70bd929f7b7525f661d98655998fc5fa4dfa1b0b5643aec3360083890ea7a0f5', '4b29ed570f29f27831629b625426485f6a8a813d016ddd8642ea443069fb5b45', 'd076fe48974d403615a9f7bbcf5bbef3f760aeaf116a2faf4d123cdb2dcad1d4', 'fd0d3d7ba40e65fa061931cfb7d0f55d4f3056ed210d3960b5adc00c479d8187'] A "as non-detnet and detnet ip packets are identical on the wire, from data plane perspective, the only difference is that there is flow- associated detnet information on each detnet node that defines the flow related characteristics and required forwarding behavior. as shown above, edge nodes provide a service proxy function that ""associates"" one or more ip flows with the appropriate detnet flow- specific information and ensures that the flow receives the proper traffic treatment within the domain." {62: 1, 85: 1, 26: 1, 55: 1, 6: 2, 79: 4, 90: 2, 51: 2, 130: 3, 68: 2, 35: 5, 110: 5, 91: 7, 114: 5, 97: 4, 31: 3, 13: 2, 67: 4, 38: 6, 124: 3, 98: 4, 54: 4, 127: 5, 8: 2, 96: 3, 64: 4, 30: 6, 61: 7, 27: 3, 15: 5, 52: 3, 129: 5, 115: 5, 84: 2, 76: 5, 87: 5, 131: 7, 102: 5, 113: 7, 99: 4, 36: 5, 24: 4, 53: 3, 72: 6} {25: 1, 26: 1, 119: 1, 162: 1, 1: 7, 4: 4, 9: 4, 10: 5, 15: 5, 24: 4, 27: 5, 39: 3, 43: 5, 49: 8, 50: 7, 58: 7, 59: 4, 64: 5, 69: 3, 81: 2, 82: 2, 86: 5, 96: 6, 97: 5, 100: 5, 108: 5, 109: 6, 110: 6, 111: 4, 114: 5, 115: 6, 116: 4, 118: 2, 120: 5, 121: 2, 122: 4, 123: 3, 124: 2, 128: 6, 129: 6, 130: 7, 132: 3, 136: 4, 145: 3, 147: 6, 151: 6, 152: 6, 154: 5, 156: 4, 161: 2, 165: 5, 168: 6, 169: 5, 172: 5, 180: 6, 184: 4, 187: 7, 188: 6, 191: 5, 194: 3, 202: 4, 203: 5, 206: 4, 207: 5, 215: 3, 217: 5, 218: 6, 220: 2, 221: 2, 222: 3, 224: 5, 227: 3, 229: 5, 234: 7, 235: 4, 241: 4, 242: 4, 243: 3, 244: 6, 245: 3, 248: 6, 250: 6, 258: 9, 262: 6, 263: 7, 264: 3, 267: 2, 270: 5, 272: 5, 273: 4, 287: 5, 289: 5, 291: 7, 299: 3, 300: 5, 304: 5, 309: 2, 314: 4, 315: 5, 323: 3, 327: 6, 328: 4, 329: 4, 330: 8, 334: 4, 335: 4, 341: 3, 342: 4, 347: 3, 348: 3, 350: 6, 351: 7, 352: 5, 353: 5, 354: 4, 358: 2, 365: 5, 366: 4, 369: 3, 371: 5, 372: 7, 376: 4, 384: 7, 385: 6, 386: 5, 387: 5, 392: 4, 393: 5, 396: 4, 397: 5, 398: 4, 402: 5} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 102 "Note: The operation of IEEE802.1 TSN end systems over DetNet enabled IP networks is not described in this document. TSN over MPLS is discribed in I-D.ietf-detnet-tsn-vpn-over-mpls." -- please approve and merge -- I 've uploaded this version ... b51489715e4f26f01dddc9265e5d15d7bbeac114 e749ebb19f9c5681460aa4e39c3b51f0b6fbb4b4 draft-ietf-detnet-ip ca80e8882c3b1b7b43e7b4db56253a8c875d3703aa7f93577f17a05919cd0a5e ['ca80e8882c3b1b7b43e7b4db56253a8c875d3703aa7f93577f17a05919cd0a5e', '2513a482b05f6b1d65ce337a5406f9458316189618c9f98c2ed8ef33f0608825', '96370dbc25c3f1e0e6f0205251af1a317f2d7d8ec612c52a59ce076bcafdd9a7', '6bf6934834360be8bde2779132bfcf68ec8e529cbec2de178df1564009136e7c', '70bd929f7b7525f661d98655998fc5fa4dfa1b0b5643aec3360083890ea7a0f5', '4b29ed570f29f27831629b625426485f6a8a813d016ddd8642ea443069fb5b45', 'd076fe48974d403615a9f7bbcf5bbef3f760aeaf116a2faf4d123cdb2dcad1d4', 'fd0d3d7ba40e65fa061931cfb7d0f55d4f3056ed210d3960b5adc00c479d8187'] A "note: the operation of ieee802.1 tsn end systems over detnet enabled ip networks is not described in this document. tsn over mpls is discribed in i-d.ietf-detnet-tsn-vpn-over-mpls." {62: 1, 85: 1, 26: 1, 55: 1, 6: 2, 79: 4, 90: 2, 51: 2, 130: 3, 68: 2, 35: 5, 110: 5, 91: 7, 114: 5, 97: 4, 31: 3, 13: 2, 67: 4, 38: 6, 124: 3, 98: 4, 54: 4, 127: 5, 8: 2, 96: 3, 64: 4, 30: 6, 61: 7, 27: 3, 15: 5, 52: 3, 129: 5, 115: 5, 84: 2, 76: 5, 87: 5, 131: 7, 102: 5, 113: 7, 99: 4, 36: 5, 24: 4, 53: 3, 72: 6} {25: 1, 26: 1, 119: 1, 162: 1, 1: 7, 4: 4, 9: 4, 10: 5, 15: 5, 24: 4, 27: 5, 39: 3, 43: 5, 49: 8, 50: 7, 58: 7, 59: 4, 64: 5, 69: 3, 81: 2, 82: 2, 86: 5, 96: 6, 97: 5, 100: 5, 108: 5, 109: 6, 110: 6, 111: 4, 114: 5, 115: 6, 116: 4, 118: 2, 120: 5, 121: 2, 122: 4, 123: 3, 124: 2, 128: 6, 129: 6, 130: 7, 132: 3, 136: 4, 145: 3, 147: 6, 151: 6, 152: 6, 154: 5, 156: 4, 161: 2, 165: 5, 168: 6, 169: 5, 172: 5, 180: 6, 184: 4, 187: 7, 188: 6, 191: 5, 194: 3, 202: 4, 203: 5, 206: 4, 207: 5, 215: 3, 217: 5, 218: 6, 220: 2, 221: 2, 222: 3, 224: 5, 227: 3, 229: 5, 234: 7, 235: 4, 241: 4, 242: 4, 243: 3, 244: 6, 245: 3, 248: 6, 250: 6, 258: 9, 262: 6, 263: 7, 264: 3, 267: 2, 270: 5, 272: 5, 273: 4, 287: 5, 289: 5, 291: 7, 299: 3, 300: 5, 304: 5, 309: 2, 314: 4, 315: 5, 323: 3, 327: 6, 328: 4, 329: 4, 330: 8, 334: 4, 335: 4, 341: 3, 342: 4, 347: 3, 348: 3, 350: 6, 351: 7, 352: 5, 353: 5, 354: 4, 358: 2, 365: 5, 366: 4, 369: 3, 371: 5, 372: 7, 376: 4, 384: 7, 385: 6, 386: 5, 387: 5, 392: 4, 393: 5, 396: 4, 397: 5, 398: 4, 402: 5} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 102 "This section provides informative considerations related to providing DetNet service to flows which are identified based on their header information." -- please approve and merge -- I 've uploaded this version ... b51489715e4f26f01dddc9265e5d15d7bbeac114 e749ebb19f9c5681460aa4e39c3b51f0b6fbb4b4 draft-ietf-detnet-ip fd0d3d7ba40e65fa061931cfb7d0f55d4f3056ed210d3960b5adc00c479d8187 ['ca80e8882c3b1b7b43e7b4db56253a8c875d3703aa7f93577f17a05919cd0a5e', '2513a482b05f6b1d65ce337a5406f9458316189618c9f98c2ed8ef33f0608825', '96370dbc25c3f1e0e6f0205251af1a317f2d7d8ec612c52a59ce076bcafdd9a7', '6bf6934834360be8bde2779132bfcf68ec8e529cbec2de178df1564009136e7c', '70bd929f7b7525f661d98655998fc5fa4dfa1b0b5643aec3360083890ea7a0f5', '4b29ed570f29f27831629b625426485f6a8a813d016ddd8642ea443069fb5b45', 'd076fe48974d403615a9f7bbcf5bbef3f760aeaf116a2faf4d123cdb2dcad1d4', 'fd0d3d7ba40e65fa061931cfb7d0f55d4f3056ed210d3960b5adc00c479d8187'] A "this section provides informative considerations related to providing detnet service to flows which are identified based on their header information." {62: 1, 85: 1, 26: 1, 55: 1, 6: 2, 79: 4, 90: 2, 51: 2, 130: 3, 68: 2, 35: 5, 110: 5, 91: 7, 114: 5, 97: 4, 31: 3, 13: 2, 67: 4, 38: 6, 124: 3, 98: 4, 54: 4, 127: 5, 8: 2, 96: 3, 64: 4, 30: 6, 61: 7, 27: 3, 15: 5, 52: 3, 129: 5, 115: 5, 84: 2, 76: 5, 87: 5, 131: 7, 102: 5, 113: 7, 99: 4, 36: 5, 24: 4, 53: 3, 72: 6} {25: 1, 26: 1, 119: 1, 162: 1, 1: 7, 4: 4, 9: 4, 10: 5, 15: 5, 24: 4, 27: 5, 39: 3, 43: 5, 49: 8, 50: 7, 58: 7, 59: 4, 64: 5, 69: 3, 81: 2, 82: 2, 86: 5, 96: 6, 97: 5, 100: 5, 108: 5, 109: 6, 110: 6, 111: 4, 114: 5, 115: 6, 116: 4, 118: 2, 120: 5, 121: 2, 122: 4, 123: 3, 124: 2, 128: 6, 129: 6, 130: 7, 132: 3, 136: 4, 145: 3, 147: 6, 151: 6, 152: 6, 154: 5, 156: 4, 161: 2, 165: 5, 168: 6, 169: 5, 172: 5, 180: 6, 184: 4, 187: 7, 188: 6, 191: 5, 194: 3, 202: 4, 203: 5, 206: 4, 207: 5, 215: 3, 217: 5, 218: 6, 220: 2, 221: 2, 222: 3, 224: 5, 227: 3, 229: 5, 234: 7, 235: 4, 241: 4, 242: 4, 243: 3, 244: 6, 245: 3, 248: 6, 250: 6, 258: 9, 262: 6, 263: 7, 264: 3, 267: 2, 270: 5, 272: 5, 273: 4, 287: 5, 289: 5, 291: 7, 299: 3, 300: 5, 304: 5, 309: 2, 314: 4, 315: 5, 323: 3, 327: 6, 328: 4, 329: 4, 330: 8, 334: 4, 335: 4, 341: 3, 342: 4, 347: 3, 348: 3, 350: 6, 351: 7, 352: 5, 353: 5, 354: 4, 358: 2, 365: 5, 366: 4, 369: 3, 371: 5, 372: 7, 376: 4, 384: 7, 385: 6, 386: 5, 387: 5, 392: 4, 393: 5, 396: 4, 397: 5, 398: 4, 402: 5} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 102 "Note that fig_ip_detnet_simple and fig_non_detnet_ip can be collapsed, so IP DetNet End Systems can communicate over a DetNet IP network with IP End Systems." -- please approve and merge -- I 've uploaded this version ... b51489715e4f26f01dddc9265e5d15d7bbeac114 e749ebb19f9c5681460aa4e39c3b51f0b6fbb4b4 draft-ietf-detnet-ip d076fe48974d403615a9f7bbcf5bbef3f760aeaf116a2faf4d123cdb2dcad1d4 ['ca80e8882c3b1b7b43e7b4db56253a8c875d3703aa7f93577f17a05919cd0a5e', '2513a482b05f6b1d65ce337a5406f9458316189618c9f98c2ed8ef33f0608825', '96370dbc25c3f1e0e6f0205251af1a317f2d7d8ec612c52a59ce076bcafdd9a7', '6bf6934834360be8bde2779132bfcf68ec8e529cbec2de178df1564009136e7c', '70bd929f7b7525f661d98655998fc5fa4dfa1b0b5643aec3360083890ea7a0f5', '4b29ed570f29f27831629b625426485f6a8a813d016ddd8642ea443069fb5b45', 'd076fe48974d403615a9f7bbcf5bbef3f760aeaf116a2faf4d123cdb2dcad1d4', 'fd0d3d7ba40e65fa061931cfb7d0f55d4f3056ed210d3960b5adc00c479d8187'] B "note that fig_ip_detnet_simple and fig_non_detnet_ip can be collapsed, so ip detnet end systems can communicate over a detnet ip network with ip end systems." {62: 1, 85: 1, 26: 1, 55: 1, 6: 2, 79: 4, 90: 2, 51: 2, 130: 3, 68: 2, 35: 5, 110: 5, 91: 7, 114: 5, 97: 4, 31: 3, 13: 2, 67: 4, 38: 6, 124: 3, 98: 4, 54: 4, 127: 5, 8: 2, 96: 3, 64: 4, 30: 6, 61: 7, 27: 3, 15: 5, 52: 3, 129: 5, 115: 5, 84: 2, 76: 5, 87: 5, 131: 7, 102: 5, 113: 7, 99: 4, 36: 5, 24: 4, 53: 3, 72: 6} {25: 1, 26: 1, 119: 1, 162: 1, 1: 7, 4: 4, 9: 4, 10: 5, 15: 5, 24: 4, 27: 5, 39: 3, 43: 5, 49: 8, 50: 7, 58: 7, 59: 4, 64: 5, 69: 3, 81: 2, 82: 2, 86: 5, 96: 6, 97: 5, 100: 5, 108: 5, 109: 6, 110: 6, 111: 4, 114: 5, 115: 6, 116: 4, 118: 2, 120: 5, 121: 2, 122: 4, 123: 3, 124: 2, 128: 6, 129: 6, 130: 7, 132: 3, 136: 4, 145: 3, 147: 6, 151: 6, 152: 6, 154: 5, 156: 4, 161: 2, 165: 5, 168: 6, 169: 5, 172: 5, 180: 6, 184: 4, 187: 7, 188: 6, 191: 5, 194: 3, 202: 4, 203: 5, 206: 4, 207: 5, 215: 3, 217: 5, 218: 6, 220: 2, 221: 2, 222: 3, 224: 5, 227: 3, 229: 5, 234: 7, 235: 4, 241: 4, 242: 4, 243: 3, 244: 6, 245: 3, 248: 6, 250: 6, 258: 9, 262: 6, 263: 7, 264: 3, 267: 2, 270: 5, 272: 5, 273: 4, 287: 5, 289: 5, 291: 7, 299: 3, 300: 5, 304: 5, 309: 2, 314: 4, 315: 5, 323: 3, 327: 6, 328: 4, 329: 4, 330: 8, 334: 4, 335: 4, 341: 3, 342: 4, 347: 3, 348: 3, 350: 6, 351: 7, 352: 5, 353: 5, 354: 4, 358: 2, 365: 5, 366: 4, 369: 3, 371: 5, 372: 7, 376: 4, 384: 7, 385: 6, 386: 5, 387: 5, 392: 4, 393: 5, 396: 4, 397: 5, 398: 4, 402: 5} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 102 "As non-DetNet and DetNet IP packets have the same protocol header format on the wire, from a data plane perspective, the only difference is that there is flow-associated DetNet information on each DetNet node that defines the flow related characteristics and required forwarding behavior. As shown above, edge nodes provide a Service Proxy function that ""associates"" one or more IP flows with the appropriate DetNet flow-specific information and ensures that the flow receives the proper traffic treatment within the domain." -- please approve and merge -- I 've uploaded this version ... b51489715e4f26f01dddc9265e5d15d7bbeac114 e749ebb19f9c5681460aa4e39c3b51f0b6fbb4b4 draft-ietf-detnet-ip 4b29ed570f29f27831629b625426485f6a8a813d016ddd8642ea443069fb5b45 ['ca80e8882c3b1b7b43e7b4db56253a8c875d3703aa7f93577f17a05919cd0a5e', '2513a482b05f6b1d65ce337a5406f9458316189618c9f98c2ed8ef33f0608825', '96370dbc25c3f1e0e6f0205251af1a317f2d7d8ec612c52a59ce076bcafdd9a7', '6bf6934834360be8bde2779132bfcf68ec8e529cbec2de178df1564009136e7c', '70bd929f7b7525f661d98655998fc5fa4dfa1b0b5643aec3360083890ea7a0f5', '4b29ed570f29f27831629b625426485f6a8a813d016ddd8642ea443069fb5b45', 'd076fe48974d403615a9f7bbcf5bbef3f760aeaf116a2faf4d123cdb2dcad1d4', 'fd0d3d7ba40e65fa061931cfb7d0f55d4f3056ed210d3960b5adc00c479d8187'] B "as non-detnet and detnet ip packets have the same protocol header format on the wire, from a data plane perspective, the only difference is that there is flow-associated detnet information on each detnet node that defines the flow related characteristics and required forwarding behavior. as shown above, edge nodes provide a service proxy function that ""associates"" one or more ip flows with the appropriate detnet flow-specific information and ensures that the flow receives the proper traffic treatment within the domain." {62: 1, 85: 1, 26: 1, 55: 1, 6: 2, 79: 4, 90: 2, 51: 2, 130: 3, 68: 2, 35: 5, 110: 5, 91: 7, 114: 5, 97: 4, 31: 3, 13: 2, 67: 4, 38: 6, 124: 3, 98: 4, 54: 4, 127: 5, 8: 2, 96: 3, 64: 4, 30: 6, 61: 7, 27: 3, 15: 5, 52: 3, 129: 5, 115: 5, 84: 2, 76: 5, 87: 5, 131: 7, 102: 5, 113: 7, 99: 4, 36: 5, 24: 4, 53: 3, 72: 6} {25: 1, 26: 1, 119: 1, 162: 1, 1: 7, 4: 4, 9: 4, 10: 5, 15: 5, 24: 4, 27: 5, 39: 3, 43: 5, 49: 8, 50: 7, 58: 7, 59: 4, 64: 5, 69: 3, 81: 2, 82: 2, 86: 5, 96: 6, 97: 5, 100: 5, 108: 5, 109: 6, 110: 6, 111: 4, 114: 5, 115: 6, 116: 4, 118: 2, 120: 5, 121: 2, 122: 4, 123: 3, 124: 2, 128: 6, 129: 6, 130: 7, 132: 3, 136: 4, 145: 3, 147: 6, 151: 6, 152: 6, 154: 5, 156: 4, 161: 2, 165: 5, 168: 6, 169: 5, 172: 5, 180: 6, 184: 4, 187: 7, 188: 6, 191: 5, 194: 3, 202: 4, 203: 5, 206: 4, 207: 5, 215: 3, 217: 5, 218: 6, 220: 2, 221: 2, 222: 3, 224: 5, 227: 3, 229: 5, 234: 7, 235: 4, 241: 4, 242: 4, 243: 3, 244: 6, 245: 3, 248: 6, 250: 6, 258: 9, 262: 6, 263: 7, 264: 3, 267: 2, 270: 5, 272: 5, 273: 4, 287: 5, 289: 5, 291: 7, 299: 3, 300: 5, 304: 5, 309: 2, 314: 4, 315: 5, 323: 3, 327: 6, 328: 4, 329: 4, 330: 8, 334: 4, 335: 4, 341: 3, 342: 4, 347: 3, 348: 3, 350: 6, 351: 7, 352: 5, 353: 5, 354: 4, 358: 2, 365: 5, 366: 4, 369: 3, 371: 5, 372: 7, 376: 4, 384: 7, 385: 6, 386: 5, 387: 5, 392: 4, 393: 5, 396: 4, 397: 5, 398: 4, 402: 5} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 102 "Note: The operation of IEEE802.1 TSN end systems over DetNet enabled IP networks is not described in this document. TSN over MPLS is described in I-D.ietf-detnet-tsn-vpn-over-mpls." -- please approve and merge -- I 've uploaded this version ... b51489715e4f26f01dddc9265e5d15d7bbeac114 e749ebb19f9c5681460aa4e39c3b51f0b6fbb4b4 draft-ietf-detnet-ip 6bf6934834360be8bde2779132bfcf68ec8e529cbec2de178df1564009136e7c ['ca80e8882c3b1b7b43e7b4db56253a8c875d3703aa7f93577f17a05919cd0a5e', '2513a482b05f6b1d65ce337a5406f9458316189618c9f98c2ed8ef33f0608825', '96370dbc25c3f1e0e6f0205251af1a317f2d7d8ec612c52a59ce076bcafdd9a7', '6bf6934834360be8bde2779132bfcf68ec8e529cbec2de178df1564009136e7c', '70bd929f7b7525f661d98655998fc5fa4dfa1b0b5643aec3360083890ea7a0f5', '4b29ed570f29f27831629b625426485f6a8a813d016ddd8642ea443069fb5b45', 'd076fe48974d403615a9f7bbcf5bbef3f760aeaf116a2faf4d123cdb2dcad1d4', 'fd0d3d7ba40e65fa061931cfb7d0f55d4f3056ed210d3960b5adc00c479d8187'] B "note: the operation of ieee802.1 tsn end systems over detnet enabled ip networks is not described in this document. tsn over mpls is described in i-d.ietf-detnet-tsn-vpn-over-mpls." {62: 1, 85: 1, 26: 1, 55: 1, 6: 2, 79: 4, 90: 2, 51: 2, 130: 3, 68: 2, 35: 5, 110: 5, 91: 7, 114: 5, 97: 4, 31: 3, 13: 2, 67: 4, 38: 6, 124: 3, 98: 4, 54: 4, 127: 5, 8: 2, 96: 3, 64: 4, 30: 6, 61: 7, 27: 3, 15: 5, 52: 3, 129: 5, 115: 5, 84: 2, 76: 5, 87: 5, 131: 7, 102: 5, 113: 7, 99: 4, 36: 5, 24: 4, 53: 3, 72: 6} {25: 1, 26: 1, 119: 1, 162: 1, 1: 7, 4: 4, 9: 4, 10: 5, 15: 5, 24: 4, 27: 5, 39: 3, 43: 5, 49: 8, 50: 7, 58: 7, 59: 4, 64: 5, 69: 3, 81: 2, 82: 2, 86: 5, 96: 6, 97: 5, 100: 5, 108: 5, 109: 6, 110: 6, 111: 4, 114: 5, 115: 6, 116: 4, 118: 2, 120: 5, 121: 2, 122: 4, 123: 3, 124: 2, 128: 6, 129: 6, 130: 7, 132: 3, 136: 4, 145: 3, 147: 6, 151: 6, 152: 6, 154: 5, 156: 4, 161: 2, 165: 5, 168: 6, 169: 5, 172: 5, 180: 6, 184: 4, 187: 7, 188: 6, 191: 5, 194: 3, 202: 4, 203: 5, 206: 4, 207: 5, 215: 3, 217: 5, 218: 6, 220: 2, 221: 2, 222: 3, 224: 5, 227: 3, 229: 5, 234: 7, 235: 4, 241: 4, 242: 4, 243: 3, 244: 6, 245: 3, 248: 6, 250: 6, 258: 9, 262: 6, 263: 7, 264: 3, 267: 2, 270: 5, 272: 5, 273: 4, 287: 5, 289: 5, 291: 7, 299: 3, 300: 5, 304: 5, 309: 2, 314: 4, 315: 5, 323: 3, 327: 6, 328: 4, 329: 4, 330: 8, 334: 4, 335: 4, 341: 3, 342: 4, 347: 3, 348: 3, 350: 6, 351: 7, 352: 5, 353: 5, 354: 4, 358: 2, 365: 5, 366: 4, 369: 3, 371: 5, 372: 7, 376: 4, 384: 7, 385: 6, 386: 5, 387: 5, 392: 4, 393: 5, 396: 4, 397: 5, 398: 4, 402: 5} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 102 "This section provides considerations related to providing DetNet service to flows which are identified based on their header information." -- please approve and merge -- I 've uploaded this version ... b51489715e4f26f01dddc9265e5d15d7bbeac114 e749ebb19f9c5681460aa4e39c3b51f0b6fbb4b4 draft-ietf-detnet-ip 2513a482b05f6b1d65ce337a5406f9458316189618c9f98c2ed8ef33f0608825 ['ca80e8882c3b1b7b43e7b4db56253a8c875d3703aa7f93577f17a05919cd0a5e', '2513a482b05f6b1d65ce337a5406f9458316189618c9f98c2ed8ef33f0608825', '96370dbc25c3f1e0e6f0205251af1a317f2d7d8ec612c52a59ce076bcafdd9a7', '6bf6934834360be8bde2779132bfcf68ec8e529cbec2de178df1564009136e7c', '70bd929f7b7525f661d98655998fc5fa4dfa1b0b5643aec3360083890ea7a0f5', '4b29ed570f29f27831629b625426485f6a8a813d016ddd8642ea443069fb5b45', 'd076fe48974d403615a9f7bbcf5bbef3f760aeaf116a2faf4d123cdb2dcad1d4', 'fd0d3d7ba40e65fa061931cfb7d0f55d4f3056ed210d3960b5adc00c479d8187'] B "this section provides considerations related to providing detnet service to flows which are identified based on their header information." {62: 1, 85: 1, 26: 1, 55: 1, 6: 2, 79: 4, 90: 2, 51: 2, 130: 3, 68: 2, 35: 5, 110: 5, 91: 7, 114: 5, 97: 4, 31: 3, 13: 2, 67: 4, 38: 6, 124: 3, 98: 4, 54: 4, 127: 5, 8: 2, 96: 3, 64: 4, 30: 6, 61: 7, 27: 3, 15: 5, 52: 3, 129: 5, 115: 5, 84: 2, 76: 5, 87: 5, 131: 7, 102: 5, 113: 7, 99: 4, 36: 5, 24: 4, 53: 3, 72: 6} {25: 1, 26: 1, 119: 1, 162: 1, 1: 7, 4: 4, 9: 4, 10: 5, 15: 5, 24: 4, 27: 5, 39: 3, 43: 5, 49: 8, 50: 7, 58: 7, 59: 4, 64: 5, 69: 3, 81: 2, 82: 2, 86: 5, 96: 6, 97: 5, 100: 5, 108: 5, 109: 6, 110: 6, 111: 4, 114: 5, 115: 6, 116: 4, 118: 2, 120: 5, 121: 2, 122: 4, 123: 3, 124: 2, 128: 6, 129: 6, 130: 7, 132: 3, 136: 4, 145: 3, 147: 6, 151: 6, 152: 6, 154: 5, 156: 4, 161: 2, 165: 5, 168: 6, 169: 5, 172: 5, 180: 6, 184: 4, 187: 7, 188: 6, 191: 5, 194: 3, 202: 4, 203: 5, 206: 4, 207: 5, 215: 3, 217: 5, 218: 6, 220: 2, 221: 2, 222: 3, 224: 5, 227: 3, 229: 5, 234: 7, 235: 4, 241: 4, 242: 4, 243: 3, 244: 6, 245: 3, 248: 6, 250: 6, 258: 9, 262: 6, 263: 7, 264: 3, 267: 2, 270: 5, 272: 5, 273: 4, 287: 5, 289: 5, 291: 7, 299: 3, 300: 5, 304: 5, 309: 2, 314: 4, 315: 5, 323: 3, 327: 6, 328: 4, 329: 4, 330: 8, 334: 4, 335: 4, 341: 3, 342: 4, 347: 3, 348: 3, 350: 6, 351: 7, 352: 5, 353: 5, 354: 4, 358: 2, 365: 5, 366: 4, 369: 3, 371: 5, 372: 7, 376: 4, 384: 7, 385: 6, 386: 5, 387: 5, 392: 4, 393: 5, 396: 4, 397: 5, 398: 4, 402: 5} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 102 "Data-flows requiring DetNet service are generated and terminated on end systems. This document deals only with IP end systems. The protocols used by an IP end system are specific to an application, and end systems peer with other end systems. DetNet's use of 6-tuple IP flow identification means that DetNet must be aware of not only the format of the IP header, but also of the next protocol carried within an IP packet (see nxt-proto-field)." -- please approve and merge -- I 've uploaded this version ... b51489715e4f26f01dddc9265e5d15d7bbeac114 e749ebb19f9c5681460aa4e39c3b51f0b6fbb4b4 draft-ietf-detnet-ip 790dd88ab88c647b7acd94021caf186daf92d383a1c9c7e805d2697ebcf490d2 ['bb825c02e9795d84374729a89d8ff4baf13e773e38cea46ac65b885d6c2d12e1', 'c786ffb899c9a258e9e9536637881723374aed7b85edaac7638e0e126bb8a6d1', '3f674c828138a7a76987b51251797ff44638f72da66d218cb4a41efddb92f2fa', 'f301a3eb8d0fceffb909b6fbbb0f96741153fe02d5705a74cab611ef9e59bf33', '1525125d2a710fb92932e5f2bff5dfcd9b9e4d7ddfa205b68b802c1501888d49', '790dd88ab88c647b7acd94021caf186daf92d383a1c9c7e805d2697ebcf490d2', '2d7925c42c2ff77dad2e82b33d4eabc4e9fad48c55a0e2b8cf88afe0ecd746fc'] A "data-flows requiring detnet service are generated and terminated on end systems. this document deals only with ip end systems. the protocols used by an ip end system are specific to an application, and end systems peer with other end systems. detnet's use of 6-tuple ip flow identification means that detnet must be aware of not only the format of the ip header, but also of the next protocol carried within an ip packet (see nxt-proto-field)." {62: 1, 67: 2, 56: 2, 13: 2} {171: 1, 200: 2, 141: 2, 223: 2} {295, 200, 171, 141, 223} 102 "When IP end systems are DetNet-aware, no application-level or service-level proxy functions are needed inside the DetNet domain. For DetNet unaware IP end systems service-level proxy functions are needed inside the DetNet domain." -- please approve and merge -- I 've uploaded this version ... b51489715e4f26f01dddc9265e5d15d7bbeac114 e749ebb19f9c5681460aa4e39c3b51f0b6fbb4b4 draft-ietf-detnet-ip 1525125d2a710fb92932e5f2bff5dfcd9b9e4d7ddfa205b68b802c1501888d49 ['bb825c02e9795d84374729a89d8ff4baf13e773e38cea46ac65b885d6c2d12e1', 'c786ffb899c9a258e9e9536637881723374aed7b85edaac7638e0e126bb8a6d1', '3f674c828138a7a76987b51251797ff44638f72da66d218cb4a41efddb92f2fa', 'f301a3eb8d0fceffb909b6fbbb0f96741153fe02d5705a74cab611ef9e59bf33', '1525125d2a710fb92932e5f2bff5dfcd9b9e4d7ddfa205b68b802c1501888d49', '790dd88ab88c647b7acd94021caf186daf92d383a1c9c7e805d2697ebcf490d2', '2d7925c42c2ff77dad2e82b33d4eabc4e9fad48c55a0e2b8cf88afe0ecd746fc'] A "when ip end systems are detnet-aware, no application-level or service-level proxy functions are needed inside the detnet domain. for detnet unaware ip end systems service-level proxy functions are needed inside the detnet domain." {62: 1, 67: 2, 56: 2, 13: 2} {171: 1, 200: 2, 141: 2, 223: 2} {295, 200, 171, 141, 223} 102 "End systems need to ensure that DetNet service requirements are met when processing packets associated to a DetNet flow. When forwarding packets, this means that packets are appropriately shaped on transmission and receive appropriate traffic treatment on the connected sub-network, see QoS and dn_dom_spec_cons for more details. When receiving packets, this means that there are appropriate local node resources, e.g., buffers, to receive and process the packets of that DetNet flow." -- please approve and merge -- I 've uploaded this version ... b51489715e4f26f01dddc9265e5d15d7bbeac114 e749ebb19f9c5681460aa4e39c3b51f0b6fbb4b4 draft-ietf-detnet-ip f301a3eb8d0fceffb909b6fbbb0f96741153fe02d5705a74cab611ef9e59bf33 ['bb825c02e9795d84374729a89d8ff4baf13e773e38cea46ac65b885d6c2d12e1', 'c786ffb899c9a258e9e9536637881723374aed7b85edaac7638e0e126bb8a6d1', '3f674c828138a7a76987b51251797ff44638f72da66d218cb4a41efddb92f2fa', 'f301a3eb8d0fceffb909b6fbbb0f96741153fe02d5705a74cab611ef9e59bf33', '1525125d2a710fb92932e5f2bff5dfcd9b9e4d7ddfa205b68b802c1501888d49', '790dd88ab88c647b7acd94021caf186daf92d383a1c9c7e805d2697ebcf490d2', '2d7925c42c2ff77dad2e82b33d4eabc4e9fad48c55a0e2b8cf88afe0ecd746fc'] A "end systems need to ensure that detnet service requirements are met when processing packets associated to a detnet flow. when forwarding packets, this means that packets are appropriately shaped on transmission and receive appropriate traffic treatment on the connected sub-network, see qos and dn_dom_spec_cons for more details. when receiving packets, this means that there are appropriate local node resources, e.g., buffers, to receive and process the packets of that detnet flow." {62: 1, 67: 2, 56: 2, 13: 2} {171: 1, 200: 2, 141: 2, 223: 2} {295, 200, 171, 141, 223} 102 "Data-flows requiring DetNet service are generated and terminated on end systems. This document deals only with IP end systems. The protocols used by an IP end system are specific to an application, and end systems peer with other end systems. DetNet's use of 6-tuple IP flow identification means that DetNet must be aware of not only the format of the IP header, but also of the next protocol value carried within an IP packet (see nxt-proto-field)." -- please approve and merge -- I 've uploaded this version ... b51489715e4f26f01dddc9265e5d15d7bbeac114 e749ebb19f9c5681460aa4e39c3b51f0b6fbb4b4 draft-ietf-detnet-ip c786ffb899c9a258e9e9536637881723374aed7b85edaac7638e0e126bb8a6d1 ['bb825c02e9795d84374729a89d8ff4baf13e773e38cea46ac65b885d6c2d12e1', 'c786ffb899c9a258e9e9536637881723374aed7b85edaac7638e0e126bb8a6d1', '3f674c828138a7a76987b51251797ff44638f72da66d218cb4a41efddb92f2fa', 'f301a3eb8d0fceffb909b6fbbb0f96741153fe02d5705a74cab611ef9e59bf33', '1525125d2a710fb92932e5f2bff5dfcd9b9e4d7ddfa205b68b802c1501888d49', '790dd88ab88c647b7acd94021caf186daf92d383a1c9c7e805d2697ebcf490d2', '2d7925c42c2ff77dad2e82b33d4eabc4e9fad48c55a0e2b8cf88afe0ecd746fc'] B "data-flows requiring detnet service are generated and terminated on end systems. this document deals only with ip end systems. the protocols used by an ip end system are specific to an application, and end systems peer with other end systems. detnet's use of 6-tuple ip flow identification means that detnet must be aware of not only the format of the ip header, but also of the next protocol value carried within an ip packet (see nxt-proto-field)." {62: 1, 67: 2, 56: 2, 13: 2} {171: 1, 200: 2, 141: 2, 223: 2} {295, 200, 171, 141, 223} 102 "For DetNet unaware IP end systems service-level proxy functions are needed inside the DetNet domain." -- please approve and merge -- I 've uploaded this version ... b51489715e4f26f01dddc9265e5d15d7bbeac114 e749ebb19f9c5681460aa4e39c3b51f0b6fbb4b4 draft-ietf-detnet-ip bb825c02e9795d84374729a89d8ff4baf13e773e38cea46ac65b885d6c2d12e1 ['bb825c02e9795d84374729a89d8ff4baf13e773e38cea46ac65b885d6c2d12e1', 'c786ffb899c9a258e9e9536637881723374aed7b85edaac7638e0e126bb8a6d1', '3f674c828138a7a76987b51251797ff44638f72da66d218cb4a41efddb92f2fa', 'f301a3eb8d0fceffb909b6fbbb0f96741153fe02d5705a74cab611ef9e59bf33', '1525125d2a710fb92932e5f2bff5dfcd9b9e4d7ddfa205b68b802c1501888d49', '790dd88ab88c647b7acd94021caf186daf92d383a1c9c7e805d2697ebcf490d2', '2d7925c42c2ff77dad2e82b33d4eabc4e9fad48c55a0e2b8cf88afe0ecd746fc'] B "for detnet unaware ip end systems service-level proxy functions are needed inside the detnet domain." {62: 1, 67: 2, 56: 2, 13: 2} {171: 1, 200: 2, 141: 2, 223: 2} {295, 200, 171, 141, 223} 102 "When IP end systems are DetNet-aware, no application-level or service-level proxy functions are needed inside the DetNet domain. End systems need to ensure that DetNet service requirements are met when processing packets associated to a DetNet flow. When sending packets, this means that packets are appropriately shaped on transmission and receive appropriate traffic treatment on the connected sub-network; see QoS and dn_dom_spec_cons for more details. When receiving packets, this means that there are appropriate local node resources, e.g., buffers, to receive and process the packets of that DetNet flow." -- please approve and merge -- I 've uploaded this version ... b51489715e4f26f01dddc9265e5d15d7bbeac114 e749ebb19f9c5681460aa4e39c3b51f0b6fbb4b4 draft-ietf-detnet-ip 2d7925c42c2ff77dad2e82b33d4eabc4e9fad48c55a0e2b8cf88afe0ecd746fc ['bb825c02e9795d84374729a89d8ff4baf13e773e38cea46ac65b885d6c2d12e1', 'c786ffb899c9a258e9e9536637881723374aed7b85edaac7638e0e126bb8a6d1', '3f674c828138a7a76987b51251797ff44638f72da66d218cb4a41efddb92f2fa', 'f301a3eb8d0fceffb909b6fbbb0f96741153fe02d5705a74cab611ef9e59bf33', '1525125d2a710fb92932e5f2bff5dfcd9b9e4d7ddfa205b68b802c1501888d49', '790dd88ab88c647b7acd94021caf186daf92d383a1c9c7e805d2697ebcf490d2', '2d7925c42c2ff77dad2e82b33d4eabc4e9fad48c55a0e2b8cf88afe0ecd746fc'] B "when ip end systems are detnet-aware, no application-level or service-level proxy functions are needed inside the detnet domain. end systems need to ensure that detnet service requirements are met when processing packets associated to a detnet flow. when sending packets, this means that packets are appropriately shaped on transmission and receive appropriate traffic treatment on the connected sub-network; see qos and dn_dom_spec_cons for more details. when receiving packets, this means that there are appropriate local node resources, e.g., buffers, to receive and process the packets of that detnet flow." {62: 1, 67: 2, 56: 2, 13: 2} {171: 1, 200: 2, 141: 2, 223: 2} {295, 200, 171, 141, 223} 102 "An important additional consideration for DetNet-aware end systems is avoiding IP fragmentation. Full 6-tuple flow identification is not possible on IP fragments as fragments don't include the transport headers or their port information. As such, it is important that applications and/or end-systems use an IP packet size that will avoid fragmentation within the network when sending DetNet flows. The maximum size can be learned via path MTU discovery, RFC1192 and RFC8201, or via the controller plane. Note that path MTU discovery relies on ICMP, which may not follow the same path as an individual DetNet flow." -- please approve and merge -- I 've uploaded this version ... b51489715e4f26f01dddc9265e5d15d7bbeac114 e749ebb19f9c5681460aa4e39c3b51f0b6fbb4b4 draft-ietf-detnet-ip 3f674c828138a7a76987b51251797ff44638f72da66d218cb4a41efddb92f2fa ['bb825c02e9795d84374729a89d8ff4baf13e773e38cea46ac65b885d6c2d12e1', 'c786ffb899c9a258e9e9536637881723374aed7b85edaac7638e0e126bb8a6d1', '3f674c828138a7a76987b51251797ff44638f72da66d218cb4a41efddb92f2fa', 'f301a3eb8d0fceffb909b6fbbb0f96741153fe02d5705a74cab611ef9e59bf33', '1525125d2a710fb92932e5f2bff5dfcd9b9e4d7ddfa205b68b802c1501888d49', '790dd88ab88c647b7acd94021caf186daf92d383a1c9c7e805d2697ebcf490d2', '2d7925c42c2ff77dad2e82b33d4eabc4e9fad48c55a0e2b8cf88afe0ecd746fc'] B "an important additional consideration for detnet-aware end systems is avoiding ip fragmentation. full 6-tuple flow identification is not possible on ip fragments as fragments don't include the transport headers or their port information. as such, it is important that applications and/or end-systems use an ip packet size that will avoid fragmentation within the network when sending detnet flows. the maximum size can be learned via path mtu discovery, rfc1192 and rfc8201, or via the controller plane. note that path mtu discovery relies on icmp, which may not follow the same path as an individual detnet flow." {62: 1, 67: 2, 56: 2, 13: 2} {171: 1, 200: 2, 141: 2, 223: 2} {295, 200, 171, 141, 223} 102 "As a general rule, DetNet IP domains need to be able to forward any DetNet flow identified by the IP 6-tuple. Doing otherwise would limit the number of 6-tuple flow ID combinations that could be used by the end systems. From a practical standpoint this means that all nodes along the end-to-end path of DetNet flows need to agree on what fields are used for flow identification." -- please approve and merge -- I 've uploaded this version ... b51489715e4f26f01dddc9265e5d15d7bbeac114 e749ebb19f9c5681460aa4e39c3b51f0b6fbb4b4 draft-ietf-detnet-ip 2d31a07897ef9aef7d1a4343cc7e3f53d61076b5f7fda41d6a0863cff2e155d3 ['2d31a07897ef9aef7d1a4343cc7e3f53d61076b5f7fda41d6a0863cff2e155d3', '06e7acbc38a9d590652dd4252477a0a5b7548833c8199af045145a2cc57bf242'] A "as a general rule, detnet ip domains need to be able to forward any detnet flow identified by the ip 6-tuple. doing otherwise would limit the number of 6-tuple flow id combinations that could be used by the end systems. from a practical standpoint this means that all nodes along the end-to-end path of detnet flows need to agree on what fields are used for flow identification." {} {} {} 102 "As a general rule, DetNet IP domains need to be able to forward any DetNet flow identified by the IP 6-tuple. Doing otherwise would limit the number of 6-tuple flow ID combinations that could be used by the end systems. From a practical standpoint this means that all nodes along the end-to-end path of DetNet flows need to agree on what fields are used for flow identification. Possible consequences of not having such an agreement include some flows interfering with other flows, and the traffic treatment expected for a service not being provided." -- please approve and merge -- I 've uploaded this version ... b51489715e4f26f01dddc9265e5d15d7bbeac114 e749ebb19f9c5681460aa4e39c3b51f0b6fbb4b4 draft-ietf-detnet-ip 06e7acbc38a9d590652dd4252477a0a5b7548833c8199af045145a2cc57bf242 ['2d31a07897ef9aef7d1a4343cc7e3f53d61076b5f7fda41d6a0863cff2e155d3', '06e7acbc38a9d590652dd4252477a0a5b7548833c8199af045145a2cc57bf242'] B "as a general rule, detnet ip domains need to be able to forward any detnet flow identified by the ip 6-tuple. doing otherwise would limit the number of 6-tuple flow id combinations that could be used by the end systems. from a practical standpoint this means that all nodes along the end-to-end path of detnet flows need to agree on what fields are used for flow identification. possible consequences of not having such an agreement include some flows interfering with other flows, and the traffic treatment expected for a service not being provided." {} {} {} 102 "L3 (IP) end systems may use any of these connection types. A DetNet domain allows communication between any end-systems using the same encapsulation format, independent of their connection type and DetNet capability. DN attached end systems have no knowledge about the DetNet domain and its encapsulation format. See fig_es_con_types for L3 end system connection examples." -- please approve and merge -- I 've uploaded this version ... b51489715e4f26f01dddc9265e5d15d7bbeac114 e749ebb19f9c5681460aa4e39c3b51f0b6fbb4b4 draft-ietf-detnet-ip baf1bfd61b37f7ec6e156787e006712e4b9b956ed4c4c7aef3704c64b71f0f68 ['baf1bfd61b37f7ec6e156787e006712e4b9b956ed4c4c7aef3704c64b71f0f68', '2d740e17b71c63f221767b88af44af17651cafec48b0bde94887ee6a0259230a'] A "l3 (ip) end systems may use any of these connection types. a detnet domain allows communication between any end-systems using the same encapsulation format, independent of their connection type and detnet capability. dn attached end systems have no knowledge about the detnet domain and its encapsulation format. see fig_es_con_types for l3 end system connection examples." {} {} {} 102 "L3 (IP) end systems may use any of these connection types. A DetNet domain allows communication between any end systems using the same encapsulation format, independent of their connection type and DetNet capability. DN attached end systems have no knowledge about the DetNet domain and its encapsulation format. See fig_es_con_types for L3 end system connection examples." -- please approve and merge -- I 've uploaded this version ... b51489715e4f26f01dddc9265e5d15d7bbeac114 e749ebb19f9c5681460aa4e39c3b51f0b6fbb4b4 draft-ietf-detnet-ip 2d740e17b71c63f221767b88af44af17651cafec48b0bde94887ee6a0259230a ['baf1bfd61b37f7ec6e156787e006712e4b9b956ed4c4c7aef3704c64b71f0f68', '2d740e17b71c63f221767b88af44af17651cafec48b0bde94887ee6a0259230a'] B "l3 (ip) end systems may use any of these connection types. a detnet domain allows communication between any end systems using the same encapsulation format, independent of their connection type and detnet capability. dn attached end systems have no knowledge about the detnet domain and its encapsulation format. see fig_es_con_types for l3 end system connection examples." {} {} {} 102 "This solution provides DetNet functions end to end, but does so on a per link and sub-network basis. Congestion protection and latency control and the resource allocation (queuing, policing, shaping) are supported using the underlying link / sub net specific mechanisms. However, service protection (packet replication and packet elimination functions) is not provided at the DetNet layer end to end. Instead service protection can be provided on a per underlying L2 link and sub-network basis." -- please approve and merge -- I 've uploaded this version ... b51489715e4f26f01dddc9265e5d15d7bbeac114 e749ebb19f9c5681460aa4e39c3b51f0b6fbb4b4 draft-ietf-detnet-ip 719df1cfa31ad2f3dbd1a92e1f407728f380f9d6ed68519e05158dbec210d866 ['e862e996c92b5b1f1dc595d8f5b781fea4395440c84f749418216218de2a04c9', 'f58da35e6979ac45078d94265db03e7f67f6f888021e1a208ba01e4e034808b5', '47d2939b9784c5e5fe0f832035e1b37fe0e55472a4c8631faf69efa998fd99ad', '2d1b1c83cd2d1e3c8195562787578ef46cdc2dd5f130b38e6dca4bac803e4421', '719df1cfa31ad2f3dbd1a92e1f407728f380f9d6ed68519e05158dbec210d866', 'aa5bfda44b039c40bafc64fa8dc9d61ab3b51d3f761e897b1165d05a5de7354e', '37fdf4ef81d5a07abaf24a1e6faa6cd17a27a9119aa38540d4c671667ab2c2e4', '5060010f0d2c2cca55dc206885bd224f2b623044ecf78271e70cf65602b5b23a'] A "this solution provides detnet functions end to end, but does so on a per link and sub-network basis. congestion protection and latency control and the resource allocation (queuing, policing, shaping) are supported using the underlying link / sub net specific mechanisms. however, service protection (packet replication and packet elimination functions) is not provided at the detnet layer end to end. instead service protection can be provided on a per underlying l2 link and sub-network basis." {62: 1, 6: 7, 79: 7, 90: 7, 51: 3, 130: 4, 85: 5, 68: 7, 35: 8, 110: 7, 91: 9, 114: 7, 97: 5, 31: 8, 13: 2, 67: 7, 38: 8, 26: 6, 124: 4, 98: 7, 54: 7, 127: 8, 8: 7, 96: 4, 64: 7, 30: 7, 61: 9, 55: 6, 27: 8, 15: 7, 52: 5, 129: 8, 115: 7, 84: 7, 76: 10, 87: 7, 131: 10, 102: 5, 113: 9, 99: 7, 36: 7, 24: 6, 53: 6, 72: 8} {342: 1, 1: 12, 4: 7, 9: 9, 10: 8, 15: 6, 24: 7, 25: 4, 26: 5, 27: 6, 39: 8, 43: 8, 49: 10, 50: 9, 58: 9, 59: 7, 64: 6, 69: 8, 81: 5, 82: 3, 86: 7, 96: 8, 97: 7, 100: 2, 108: 8, 109: 9, 110: 9, 111: 7, 114: 8, 115: 9, 116: 5, 118: 7, 119: 6, 120: 8, 121: 7, 122: 5, 123: 4, 124: 7, 128: 8, 129: 7, 130: 9, 132: 8, 136: 7, 145: 8, 147: 8, 151: 8, 152: 8, 154: 8, 156: 5, 161: 7, 162: 6, 165: 8, 168: 9, 169: 7, 172: 7, 180: 8, 184: 9, 187: 10, 188: 9, 191: 8, 194: 8, 202: 9, 203: 10, 206: 7, 207: 8, 215: 7, 217: 8, 218: 11, 220: 7, 221: 7, 222: 8, 224: 8, 227: 4, 229: 7, 234: 10, 235: 7, 241: 7, 242: 7, 243: 8, 244: 8, 245: 8, 248: 8, 250: 7, 258: 14, 262: 9, 263: 10, 264: 8, 267: 7, 270: 6, 272: 7, 273: 9, 287: 8, 289: 7, 291: 9, 299: 4, 300: 6, 304: 6, 309: 7, 314: 7, 315: 7, 320: 5, 323: 8, 327: 9, 328: 8, 329: 7, 330: 13, 334: 7, 335: 5, 341: 2, 347: 4, 348: 4, 350: 11, 351: 9, 352: 7, 353: 7, 354: 6, 358: 7, 365: 7, 366: 7, 369: 6, 372: 9, 376: 7, 384: 9, 385: 8, 386: 8, 387: 6, 392: 8, 393: 9, 396: 5, 397: 10, 398: 9, 402: 7} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 102 "The DetNet Service Flow is mapped to the link / sub-network specific resources using an underlying system-specific means. This implies each DetNet-aware node on path looks into the forwarded DetNet Service Flow packet and utilize e.g., a 6-tuple to find out the required mapping within a node." -- please approve and merge -- I 've uploaded this version ... b51489715e4f26f01dddc9265e5d15d7bbeac114 e749ebb19f9c5681460aa4e39c3b51f0b6fbb4b4 draft-ietf-detnet-ip 37fdf4ef81d5a07abaf24a1e6faa6cd17a27a9119aa38540d4c671667ab2c2e4 ['e862e996c92b5b1f1dc595d8f5b781fea4395440c84f749418216218de2a04c9', 'f58da35e6979ac45078d94265db03e7f67f6f888021e1a208ba01e4e034808b5', '47d2939b9784c5e5fe0f832035e1b37fe0e55472a4c8631faf69efa998fd99ad', '2d1b1c83cd2d1e3c8195562787578ef46cdc2dd5f130b38e6dca4bac803e4421', '719df1cfa31ad2f3dbd1a92e1f407728f380f9d6ed68519e05158dbec210d866', 'aa5bfda44b039c40bafc64fa8dc9d61ab3b51d3f761e897b1165d05a5de7354e', '37fdf4ef81d5a07abaf24a1e6faa6cd17a27a9119aa38540d4c671667ab2c2e4', '5060010f0d2c2cca55dc206885bd224f2b623044ecf78271e70cf65602b5b23a'] A "the detnet service flow is mapped to the link / sub-network specific resources using an underlying system-specific means. this implies each detnet-aware node on path looks into the forwarded detnet service flow packet and utilize e.g., a 6-tuple to find out the required mapping within a node." {62: 1, 6: 7, 79: 7, 90: 7, 51: 3, 130: 4, 85: 5, 68: 7, 35: 8, 110: 7, 91: 9, 114: 7, 97: 5, 31: 8, 13: 2, 67: 7, 38: 8, 26: 6, 124: 4, 98: 7, 54: 7, 127: 8, 8: 7, 96: 4, 64: 7, 30: 7, 61: 9, 55: 6, 27: 8, 15: 7, 52: 5, 129: 8, 115: 7, 84: 7, 76: 10, 87: 7, 131: 10, 102: 5, 113: 9, 99: 7, 36: 7, 24: 6, 53: 6, 72: 8} {342: 1, 1: 12, 4: 7, 9: 9, 10: 8, 15: 6, 24: 7, 25: 4, 26: 5, 27: 6, 39: 8, 43: 8, 49: 10, 50: 9, 58: 9, 59: 7, 64: 6, 69: 8, 81: 5, 82: 3, 86: 7, 96: 8, 97: 7, 100: 2, 108: 8, 109: 9, 110: 9, 111: 7, 114: 8, 115: 9, 116: 5, 118: 7, 119: 6, 120: 8, 121: 7, 122: 5, 123: 4, 124: 7, 128: 8, 129: 7, 130: 9, 132: 8, 136: 7, 145: 8, 147: 8, 151: 8, 152: 8, 154: 8, 156: 5, 161: 7, 162: 6, 165: 8, 168: 9, 169: 7, 172: 7, 180: 8, 184: 9, 187: 10, 188: 9, 191: 8, 194: 8, 202: 9, 203: 10, 206: 7, 207: 8, 215: 7, 217: 8, 218: 11, 220: 7, 221: 7, 222: 8, 224: 8, 227: 4, 229: 7, 234: 10, 235: 7, 241: 7, 242: 7, 243: 8, 244: 8, 245: 8, 248: 8, 250: 7, 258: 14, 262: 9, 263: 10, 264: 8, 267: 7, 270: 6, 272: 7, 273: 9, 287: 8, 289: 7, 291: 9, 299: 4, 300: 6, 304: 6, 309: 7, 314: 7, 315: 7, 320: 5, 323: 8, 327: 9, 328: 8, 329: 7, 330: 13, 334: 7, 335: 5, 341: 2, 347: 4, 348: 4, 350: 11, 351: 9, 352: 7, 353: 7, 354: 6, 358: 7, 365: 7, 366: 7, 369: 6, 372: 9, 376: 7, 384: 9, 385: 8, 386: 8, 387: 6, 392: 8, 393: 9, 396: 5, 397: 10, 398: 9, 402: 7} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 102 "As noted earlier, service protection must be implemented within each link / sub-network independently, using the domain specific mechanisms. This is due to the lack of unified end-to-end sequencing information that could be used by the intermediate nodes. Therefore, service protection (if enabled) cannot be provided end-to-end, only within sub-networks. This is shown for a three sub-network scenario in fig_pref_in_subnets, where each sub-network can provide service protection between its borders. ""R"" and ""E"" denotes replication and elimination points within the sub-network." -- please approve and merge -- I 've uploaded this version ... b51489715e4f26f01dddc9265e5d15d7bbeac114 e749ebb19f9c5681460aa4e39c3b51f0b6fbb4b4 draft-ietf-detnet-ip 47d2939b9784c5e5fe0f832035e1b37fe0e55472a4c8631faf69efa998fd99ad ['e862e996c92b5b1f1dc595d8f5b781fea4395440c84f749418216218de2a04c9', 'f58da35e6979ac45078d94265db03e7f67f6f888021e1a208ba01e4e034808b5', '47d2939b9784c5e5fe0f832035e1b37fe0e55472a4c8631faf69efa998fd99ad', '2d1b1c83cd2d1e3c8195562787578ef46cdc2dd5f130b38e6dca4bac803e4421', '719df1cfa31ad2f3dbd1a92e1f407728f380f9d6ed68519e05158dbec210d866', 'aa5bfda44b039c40bafc64fa8dc9d61ab3b51d3f761e897b1165d05a5de7354e', '37fdf4ef81d5a07abaf24a1e6faa6cd17a27a9119aa38540d4c671667ab2c2e4', '5060010f0d2c2cca55dc206885bd224f2b623044ecf78271e70cf65602b5b23a'] A "as noted earlier, service protection must be implemented within each link / sub-network independently, using the domain specific mechanisms. this is due to the lack of unified end-to-end sequencing information that could be used by the intermediate nodes. therefore, service protection (if enabled) cannot be provided end-to-end, only within sub-networks. this is shown for a three sub-network scenario in fig_pref_in_subnets, where each sub-network can provide service protection between its borders. ""r"" and ""e"" denotes replication and elimination points within the sub-network." {62: 1, 6: 7, 79: 7, 90: 7, 51: 3, 130: 4, 85: 5, 68: 7, 35: 8, 110: 7, 91: 9, 114: 7, 97: 5, 31: 8, 13: 2, 67: 7, 38: 8, 26: 6, 124: 4, 98: 7, 54: 7, 127: 8, 8: 7, 96: 4, 64: 7, 30: 7, 61: 9, 55: 6, 27: 8, 15: 7, 52: 5, 129: 8, 115: 7, 84: 7, 76: 10, 87: 7, 131: 10, 102: 5, 113: 9, 99: 7, 36: 7, 24: 6, 53: 6, 72: 8} {342: 1, 1: 12, 4: 7, 9: 9, 10: 8, 15: 6, 24: 7, 25: 4, 26: 5, 27: 6, 39: 8, 43: 8, 49: 10, 50: 9, 58: 9, 59: 7, 64: 6, 69: 8, 81: 5, 82: 3, 86: 7, 96: 8, 97: 7, 100: 2, 108: 8, 109: 9, 110: 9, 111: 7, 114: 8, 115: 9, 116: 5, 118: 7, 119: 6, 120: 8, 121: 7, 122: 5, 123: 4, 124: 7, 128: 8, 129: 7, 130: 9, 132: 8, 136: 7, 145: 8, 147: 8, 151: 8, 152: 8, 154: 8, 156: 5, 161: 7, 162: 6, 165: 8, 168: 9, 169: 7, 172: 7, 180: 8, 184: 9, 187: 10, 188: 9, 191: 8, 194: 8, 202: 9, 203: 10, 206: 7, 207: 8, 215: 7, 217: 8, 218: 11, 220: 7, 221: 7, 222: 8, 224: 8, 227: 4, 229: 7, 234: 10, 235: 7, 241: 7, 242: 7, 243: 8, 244: 8, 245: 8, 248: 8, 250: 7, 258: 14, 262: 9, 263: 10, 264: 8, 267: 7, 270: 6, 272: 7, 273: 9, 287: 8, 289: 7, 291: 9, 299: 4, 300: 6, 304: 6, 309: 7, 314: 7, 315: 7, 320: 5, 323: 8, 327: 9, 328: 8, 329: 7, 330: 13, 334: 7, 335: 5, 341: 2, 347: 4, 348: 4, 350: 11, 351: 9, 352: 7, 353: 7, 354: 6, 358: 7, 365: 7, 366: 7, 369: 6, 372: 9, 376: 7, 384: 9, 385: 8, 386: 8, 387: 6, 392: 8, 393: 9, 396: 5, 397: 10, 398: 9, 402: 7} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 102 "If end to end service protection is desired, it can be implemented, for example, by the DetNet end systems using Layer-4 (L4) transport protocols or application protocols. However, these protocols are out of scope of this document." -- please approve and merge -- I 've uploaded this version ... b51489715e4f26f01dddc9265e5d15d7bbeac114 e749ebb19f9c5681460aa4e39c3b51f0b6fbb4b4 draft-ietf-detnet-ip 2d1b1c83cd2d1e3c8195562787578ef46cdc2dd5f130b38e6dca4bac803e4421 ['e862e996c92b5b1f1dc595d8f5b781fea4395440c84f749418216218de2a04c9', 'f58da35e6979ac45078d94265db03e7f67f6f888021e1a208ba01e4e034808b5', '47d2939b9784c5e5fe0f832035e1b37fe0e55472a4c8631faf69efa998fd99ad', '2d1b1c83cd2d1e3c8195562787578ef46cdc2dd5f130b38e6dca4bac803e4421', '719df1cfa31ad2f3dbd1a92e1f407728f380f9d6ed68519e05158dbec210d866', 'aa5bfda44b039c40bafc64fa8dc9d61ab3b51d3f761e897b1165d05a5de7354e', '37fdf4ef81d5a07abaf24a1e6faa6cd17a27a9119aa38540d4c671667ab2c2e4', '5060010f0d2c2cca55dc206885bd224f2b623044ecf78271e70cf65602b5b23a'] A "if end to end service protection is desired, it can be implemented, for example, by the detnet end systems using layer-4 (l4) transport protocols or application protocols. however, these protocols are out of scope of this document." {62: 1, 6: 7, 79: 7, 90: 7, 51: 3, 130: 4, 85: 5, 68: 7, 35: 8, 110: 7, 91: 9, 114: 7, 97: 5, 31: 8, 13: 2, 67: 7, 38: 8, 26: 6, 124: 4, 98: 7, 54: 7, 127: 8, 8: 7, 96: 4, 64: 7, 30: 7, 61: 9, 55: 6, 27: 8, 15: 7, 52: 5, 129: 8, 115: 7, 84: 7, 76: 10, 87: 7, 131: 10, 102: 5, 113: 9, 99: 7, 36: 7, 24: 6, 53: 6, 72: 8} {342: 1, 1: 12, 4: 7, 9: 9, 10: 8, 15: 6, 24: 7, 25: 4, 26: 5, 27: 6, 39: 8, 43: 8, 49: 10, 50: 9, 58: 9, 59: 7, 64: 6, 69: 8, 81: 5, 82: 3, 86: 7, 96: 8, 97: 7, 100: 2, 108: 8, 109: 9, 110: 9, 111: 7, 114: 8, 115: 9, 116: 5, 118: 7, 119: 6, 120: 8, 121: 7, 122: 5, 123: 4, 124: 7, 128: 8, 129: 7, 130: 9, 132: 8, 136: 7, 145: 8, 147: 8, 151: 8, 152: 8, 154: 8, 156: 5, 161: 7, 162: 6, 165: 8, 168: 9, 169: 7, 172: 7, 180: 8, 184: 9, 187: 10, 188: 9, 191: 8, 194: 8, 202: 9, 203: 10, 206: 7, 207: 8, 215: 7, 217: 8, 218: 11, 220: 7, 221: 7, 222: 8, 224: 8, 227: 4, 229: 7, 234: 10, 235: 7, 241: 7, 242: 7, 243: 8, 244: 8, 245: 8, 248: 8, 250: 7, 258: 14, 262: 9, 263: 10, 264: 8, 267: 7, 270: 6, 272: 7, 273: 9, 287: 8, 289: 7, 291: 9, 299: 4, 300: 6, 304: 6, 309: 7, 314: 7, 315: 7, 320: 5, 323: 8, 327: 9, 328: 8, 329: 7, 330: 13, 334: 7, 335: 5, 341: 2, 347: 4, 348: 4, 350: 11, 351: 9, 352: 7, 353: 7, 354: 6, 358: 7, 365: 7, 366: 7, 369: 6, 372: 9, 376: 7, 384: 9, 385: 8, 386: 8, 387: 6, 392: 8, 393: 9, 396: 5, 397: 10, 398: 9, 402: 7} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 102 "This solution provides DetNet functions end-to-end, but does so on a per link and sub-network basis. Congestion protection and latency control and the resource allocation (queuing, policing, shaping) are supported using the underlying link/sub-network specific mechanisms. However, service protection (packet replication and packet elimination functions) is not provided at the DetNet layer end-to- end. Instead service protection can be provided on a per underlying L2 link and sub-network basis." -- please approve and merge -- I 've uploaded this version ... b51489715e4f26f01dddc9265e5d15d7bbeac114 e749ebb19f9c5681460aa4e39c3b51f0b6fbb4b4 draft-ietf-detnet-ip f58da35e6979ac45078d94265db03e7f67f6f888021e1a208ba01e4e034808b5 ['e862e996c92b5b1f1dc595d8f5b781fea4395440c84f749418216218de2a04c9', 'f58da35e6979ac45078d94265db03e7f67f6f888021e1a208ba01e4e034808b5', '47d2939b9784c5e5fe0f832035e1b37fe0e55472a4c8631faf69efa998fd99ad', '2d1b1c83cd2d1e3c8195562787578ef46cdc2dd5f130b38e6dca4bac803e4421', '719df1cfa31ad2f3dbd1a92e1f407728f380f9d6ed68519e05158dbec210d866', 'aa5bfda44b039c40bafc64fa8dc9d61ab3b51d3f761e897b1165d05a5de7354e', '37fdf4ef81d5a07abaf24a1e6faa6cd17a27a9119aa38540d4c671667ab2c2e4', '5060010f0d2c2cca55dc206885bd224f2b623044ecf78271e70cf65602b5b23a'] B "this solution provides detnet functions end-to-end, but does so on a per link and sub-network basis. congestion protection and latency control and the resource allocation (queuing, policing, shaping) are supported using the underlying link/sub-network specific mechanisms. however, service protection (packet replication and packet elimination functions) is not provided at the detnet layer end-to- end. instead service protection can be provided on a per underlying l2 link and sub-network basis." {62: 1, 6: 7, 79: 7, 90: 7, 51: 3, 130: 4, 85: 5, 68: 7, 35: 8, 110: 7, 91: 9, 114: 7, 97: 5, 31: 8, 13: 2, 67: 7, 38: 8, 26: 6, 124: 4, 98: 7, 54: 7, 127: 8, 8: 7, 96: 4, 64: 7, 30: 7, 61: 9, 55: 6, 27: 8, 15: 7, 52: 5, 129: 8, 115: 7, 84: 7, 76: 10, 87: 7, 131: 10, 102: 5, 113: 9, 99: 7, 36: 7, 24: 6, 53: 6, 72: 8} {342: 1, 1: 12, 4: 7, 9: 9, 10: 8, 15: 6, 24: 7, 25: 4, 26: 5, 27: 6, 39: 8, 43: 8, 49: 10, 50: 9, 58: 9, 59: 7, 64: 6, 69: 8, 81: 5, 82: 3, 86: 7, 96: 8, 97: 7, 100: 2, 108: 8, 109: 9, 110: 9, 111: 7, 114: 8, 115: 9, 116: 5, 118: 7, 119: 6, 120: 8, 121: 7, 122: 5, 123: 4, 124: 7, 128: 8, 129: 7, 130: 9, 132: 8, 136: 7, 145: 8, 147: 8, 151: 8, 152: 8, 154: 8, 156: 5, 161: 7, 162: 6, 165: 8, 168: 9, 169: 7, 172: 7, 180: 8, 184: 9, 187: 10, 188: 9, 191: 8, 194: 8, 202: 9, 203: 10, 206: 7, 207: 8, 215: 7, 217: 8, 218: 11, 220: 7, 221: 7, 222: 8, 224: 8, 227: 4, 229: 7, 234: 10, 235: 7, 241: 7, 242: 7, 243: 8, 244: 8, 245: 8, 248: 8, 250: 7, 258: 14, 262: 9, 263: 10, 264: 8, 267: 7, 270: 6, 272: 7, 273: 9, 287: 8, 289: 7, 291: 9, 299: 4, 300: 6, 304: 6, 309: 7, 314: 7, 315: 7, 320: 5, 323: 8, 327: 9, 328: 8, 329: 7, 330: 13, 334: 7, 335: 5, 341: 2, 347: 4, 348: 4, 350: 11, 351: 9, 352: 7, 353: 7, 354: 6, 358: 7, 365: 7, 366: 7, 369: 6, 372: 9, 376: 7, 384: 9, 385: 8, 386: 8, 387: 6, 392: 8, 393: 9, 396: 5, 397: 10, 398: 9, 402: 7} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 102 "The DetNet Service Flow is mapped to the link/sub-network specific resources using an underlying system-specific means. This implies each DetNet-aware node on path looks into the forwarded DetNet Service Flow packet and utilize e.g., a 6-tuple to find out the required mapping within a node." -- please approve and merge -- I 've uploaded this version ... b51489715e4f26f01dddc9265e5d15d7bbeac114 e749ebb19f9c5681460aa4e39c3b51f0b6fbb4b4 draft-ietf-detnet-ip e862e996c92b5b1f1dc595d8f5b781fea4395440c84f749418216218de2a04c9 ['e862e996c92b5b1f1dc595d8f5b781fea4395440c84f749418216218de2a04c9', 'f58da35e6979ac45078d94265db03e7f67f6f888021e1a208ba01e4e034808b5', '47d2939b9784c5e5fe0f832035e1b37fe0e55472a4c8631faf69efa998fd99ad', '2d1b1c83cd2d1e3c8195562787578ef46cdc2dd5f130b38e6dca4bac803e4421', '719df1cfa31ad2f3dbd1a92e1f407728f380f9d6ed68519e05158dbec210d866', 'aa5bfda44b039c40bafc64fa8dc9d61ab3b51d3f761e897b1165d05a5de7354e', '37fdf4ef81d5a07abaf24a1e6faa6cd17a27a9119aa38540d4c671667ab2c2e4', '5060010f0d2c2cca55dc206885bd224f2b623044ecf78271e70cf65602b5b23a'] B "the detnet service flow is mapped to the link/sub-network specific resources using an underlying system-specific means. this implies each detnet-aware node on path looks into the forwarded detnet service flow packet and utilize e.g., a 6-tuple to find out the required mapping within a node." {62: 1, 6: 7, 79: 7, 90: 7, 51: 3, 130: 4, 85: 5, 68: 7, 35: 8, 110: 7, 91: 9, 114: 7, 97: 5, 31: 8, 13: 2, 67: 7, 38: 8, 26: 6, 124: 4, 98: 7, 54: 7, 127: 8, 8: 7, 96: 4, 64: 7, 30: 7, 61: 9, 55: 6, 27: 8, 15: 7, 52: 5, 129: 8, 115: 7, 84: 7, 76: 10, 87: 7, 131: 10, 102: 5, 113: 9, 99: 7, 36: 7, 24: 6, 53: 6, 72: 8} {342: 1, 1: 12, 4: 7, 9: 9, 10: 8, 15: 6, 24: 7, 25: 4, 26: 5, 27: 6, 39: 8, 43: 8, 49: 10, 50: 9, 58: 9, 59: 7, 64: 6, 69: 8, 81: 5, 82: 3, 86: 7, 96: 8, 97: 7, 100: 2, 108: 8, 109: 9, 110: 9, 111: 7, 114: 8, 115: 9, 116: 5, 118: 7, 119: 6, 120: 8, 121: 7, 122: 5, 123: 4, 124: 7, 128: 8, 129: 7, 130: 9, 132: 8, 136: 7, 145: 8, 147: 8, 151: 8, 152: 8, 154: 8, 156: 5, 161: 7, 162: 6, 165: 8, 168: 9, 169: 7, 172: 7, 180: 8, 184: 9, 187: 10, 188: 9, 191: 8, 194: 8, 202: 9, 203: 10, 206: 7, 207: 8, 215: 7, 217: 8, 218: 11, 220: 7, 221: 7, 222: 8, 224: 8, 227: 4, 229: 7, 234: 10, 235: 7, 241: 7, 242: 7, 243: 8, 244: 8, 245: 8, 248: 8, 250: 7, 258: 14, 262: 9, 263: 10, 264: 8, 267: 7, 270: 6, 272: 7, 273: 9, 287: 8, 289: 7, 291: 9, 299: 4, 300: 6, 304: 6, 309: 7, 314: 7, 315: 7, 320: 5, 323: 8, 327: 9, 328: 8, 329: 7, 330: 13, 334: 7, 335: 5, 341: 2, 347: 4, 348: 4, 350: 11, 351: 9, 352: 7, 353: 7, 354: 6, 358: 7, 365: 7, 366: 7, 369: 6, 372: 9, 376: 7, 384: 9, 385: 8, 386: 8, 387: 6, 392: 8, 393: 9, 396: 5, 397: 10, 398: 9, 402: 7} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 102 "As noted earlier, service protection must be implemented within each link/sub-network independently, using the domain specific mechanisms. This is due to the lack of unified end-to-end sequencing information that could be used by the intermediate nodes. Therefore, service protection (if enabled) cannot be provided end-to-end, only within sub-networks. This is shown for a three sub-network scenario in fig_pref_in_subnets, where each sub-network can provide service protection between its borders. ""R"" and ""E"" denote replication and elimination points within the sub-network." -- please approve and merge -- I 've uploaded this version ... b51489715e4f26f01dddc9265e5d15d7bbeac114 e749ebb19f9c5681460aa4e39c3b51f0b6fbb4b4 draft-ietf-detnet-ip 5060010f0d2c2cca55dc206885bd224f2b623044ecf78271e70cf65602b5b23a ['e862e996c92b5b1f1dc595d8f5b781fea4395440c84f749418216218de2a04c9', 'f58da35e6979ac45078d94265db03e7f67f6f888021e1a208ba01e4e034808b5', '47d2939b9784c5e5fe0f832035e1b37fe0e55472a4c8631faf69efa998fd99ad', '2d1b1c83cd2d1e3c8195562787578ef46cdc2dd5f130b38e6dca4bac803e4421', '719df1cfa31ad2f3dbd1a92e1f407728f380f9d6ed68519e05158dbec210d866', 'aa5bfda44b039c40bafc64fa8dc9d61ab3b51d3f761e897b1165d05a5de7354e', '37fdf4ef81d5a07abaf24a1e6faa6cd17a27a9119aa38540d4c671667ab2c2e4', '5060010f0d2c2cca55dc206885bd224f2b623044ecf78271e70cf65602b5b23a'] B "as noted earlier, service protection must be implemented within each link/sub-network independently, using the domain specific mechanisms. this is due to the lack of unified end-to-end sequencing information that could be used by the intermediate nodes. therefore, service protection (if enabled) cannot be provided end-to-end, only within sub-networks. this is shown for a three sub-network scenario in fig_pref_in_subnets, where each sub-network can provide service protection between its borders. ""r"" and ""e"" denote replication and elimination points within the sub-network." {62: 1, 6: 7, 79: 7, 90: 7, 51: 3, 130: 4, 85: 5, 68: 7, 35: 8, 110: 7, 91: 9, 114: 7, 97: 5, 31: 8, 13: 2, 67: 7, 38: 8, 26: 6, 124: 4, 98: 7, 54: 7, 127: 8, 8: 7, 96: 4, 64: 7, 30: 7, 61: 9, 55: 6, 27: 8, 15: 7, 52: 5, 129: 8, 115: 7, 84: 7, 76: 10, 87: 7, 131: 10, 102: 5, 113: 9, 99: 7, 36: 7, 24: 6, 53: 6, 72: 8} {342: 1, 1: 12, 4: 7, 9: 9, 10: 8, 15: 6, 24: 7, 25: 4, 26: 5, 27: 6, 39: 8, 43: 8, 49: 10, 50: 9, 58: 9, 59: 7, 64: 6, 69: 8, 81: 5, 82: 3, 86: 7, 96: 8, 97: 7, 100: 2, 108: 8, 109: 9, 110: 9, 111: 7, 114: 8, 115: 9, 116: 5, 118: 7, 119: 6, 120: 8, 121: 7, 122: 5, 123: 4, 124: 7, 128: 8, 129: 7, 130: 9, 132: 8, 136: 7, 145: 8, 147: 8, 151: 8, 152: 8, 154: 8, 156: 5, 161: 7, 162: 6, 165: 8, 168: 9, 169: 7, 172: 7, 180: 8, 184: 9, 187: 10, 188: 9, 191: 8, 194: 8, 202: 9, 203: 10, 206: 7, 207: 8, 215: 7, 217: 8, 218: 11, 220: 7, 221: 7, 222: 8, 224: 8, 227: 4, 229: 7, 234: 10, 235: 7, 241: 7, 242: 7, 243: 8, 244: 8, 245: 8, 248: 8, 250: 7, 258: 14, 262: 9, 263: 10, 264: 8, 267: 7, 270: 6, 272: 7, 273: 9, 287: 8, 289: 7, 291: 9, 299: 4, 300: 6, 304: 6, 309: 7, 314: 7, 315: 7, 320: 5, 323: 8, 327: 9, 328: 8, 329: 7, 330: 13, 334: 7, 335: 5, 341: 2, 347: 4, 348: 4, 350: 11, 351: 9, 352: 7, 353: 7, 354: 6, 358: 7, 365: 7, 366: 7, 369: 6, 372: 9, 376: 7, 384: 9, 385: 8, 386: 8, 387: 6, 392: 8, 393: 9, 396: 5, 397: 10, 398: 9, 402: 7} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 102 "If end-to-end service protection is desired, it can be implemented, for example, by the DetNet end systems using Layer-4 (L4) transport protocols or application protocols. However, these protocols are out of scope of this document." -- please approve and merge -- I 've uploaded this version ... b51489715e4f26f01dddc9265e5d15d7bbeac114 e749ebb19f9c5681460aa4e39c3b51f0b6fbb4b4 draft-ietf-detnet-ip aa5bfda44b039c40bafc64fa8dc9d61ab3b51d3f761e897b1165d05a5de7354e ['e862e996c92b5b1f1dc595d8f5b781fea4395440c84f749418216218de2a04c9', 'f58da35e6979ac45078d94265db03e7f67f6f888021e1a208ba01e4e034808b5', '47d2939b9784c5e5fe0f832035e1b37fe0e55472a4c8631faf69efa998fd99ad', '2d1b1c83cd2d1e3c8195562787578ef46cdc2dd5f130b38e6dca4bac803e4421', '719df1cfa31ad2f3dbd1a92e1f407728f380f9d6ed68519e05158dbec210d866', 'aa5bfda44b039c40bafc64fa8dc9d61ab3b51d3f761e897b1165d05a5de7354e', '37fdf4ef81d5a07abaf24a1e6faa6cd17a27a9119aa38540d4c671667ab2c2e4', '5060010f0d2c2cca55dc206885bd224f2b623044ecf78271e70cf65602b5b23a'] B "if end-to-end service protection is desired, it can be implemented, for example, by the detnet end systems using layer-4 (l4) transport protocols or application protocols. however, these protocols are out of scope of this document." {62: 1, 6: 7, 79: 7, 90: 7, 51: 3, 130: 4, 85: 5, 68: 7, 35: 8, 110: 7, 91: 9, 114: 7, 97: 5, 31: 8, 13: 2, 67: 7, 38: 8, 26: 6, 124: 4, 98: 7, 54: 7, 127: 8, 8: 7, 96: 4, 64: 7, 30: 7, 61: 9, 55: 6, 27: 8, 15: 7, 52: 5, 129: 8, 115: 7, 84: 7, 76: 10, 87: 7, 131: 10, 102: 5, 113: 9, 99: 7, 36: 7, 24: 6, 53: 6, 72: 8} {342: 1, 1: 12, 4: 7, 9: 9, 10: 8, 15: 6, 24: 7, 25: 4, 26: 5, 27: 6, 39: 8, 43: 8, 49: 10, 50: 9, 58: 9, 59: 7, 64: 6, 69: 8, 81: 5, 82: 3, 86: 7, 96: 8, 97: 7, 100: 2, 108: 8, 109: 9, 110: 9, 111: 7, 114: 8, 115: 9, 116: 5, 118: 7, 119: 6, 120: 8, 121: 7, 122: 5, 123: 4, 124: 7, 128: 8, 129: 7, 130: 9, 132: 8, 136: 7, 145: 8, 147: 8, 151: 8, 152: 8, 154: 8, 156: 5, 161: 7, 162: 6, 165: 8, 168: 9, 169: 7, 172: 7, 180: 8, 184: 9, 187: 10, 188: 9, 191: 8, 194: 8, 202: 9, 203: 10, 206: 7, 207: 8, 215: 7, 217: 8, 218: 11, 220: 7, 221: 7, 222: 8, 224: 8, 227: 4, 229: 7, 234: 10, 235: 7, 241: 7, 242: 7, 243: 8, 244: 8, 245: 8, 248: 8, 250: 7, 258: 14, 262: 9, 263: 10, 264: 8, 267: 7, 270: 6, 272: 7, 273: 9, 287: 8, 289: 7, 291: 9, 299: 4, 300: 6, 304: 6, 309: 7, 314: 7, 315: 7, 320: 5, 323: 8, 327: 9, 328: 8, 329: 7, 330: 13, 334: 7, 335: 5, 341: 2, 347: 4, 348: 4, 350: 11, 351: 9, 352: 7, 353: 7, 354: 6, 358: 7, 365: 7, 366: 7, 369: 6, 372: 9, 376: 7, 384: 9, 385: 8, 386: 8, 387: 6, 392: 8, 393: 9, 396: 5, 397: 10, 398: 9, 402: 7} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 102 "Quality of Service (QoS) for DetNet service flows carried in IP MUST be provided locally by the DetNet-aware hosts and routers supporting DetNet flows. Such support leverages the underlying network layer such as 802.1 TSN. The traffic control mechanisms used to deliver QoS for IP encapsulated DetNet flows are expected to be defined in a future document. From an encapsulation perspective, the combination of the 6-tuple i.e., the typical 5-tuple enhanced with the DSCP and previously mentioned optional field (i.e., flow label), uniquely identifies a DetNet IP flow." -- please approve and merge -- I 've uploaded this version ... b51489715e4f26f01dddc9265e5d15d7bbeac114 e749ebb19f9c5681460aa4e39c3b51f0b6fbb4b4 draft-ietf-detnet-ip fb8ec162cc7e7d2c80120b876b4280b6994799d3e32f9dbba306ef0fe5af2b85 ['fb8ec162cc7e7d2c80120b876b4280b6994799d3e32f9dbba306ef0fe5af2b85', '44dfff44e014e29e2bf0f3ac103547b72a49a488aa1351660a3dd98f09700c0f'] A "quality of service (qos) for detnet service flows carried in ip must be provided locally by the detnet-aware hosts and routers supporting detnet flows. such support leverages the underlying network layer such as 802.1 tsn. the traffic control mechanisms used to deliver qos for ip encapsulated detnet flows are expected to be defined in a future document. from an encapsulation perspective, the combination of the 6-tuple i.e., the typical 5-tuple enhanced with the dscp and previously mentioned optional field (i.e., flow label), uniquely identifies a detnet ip flow." {85: 1} {28: 1} {404, 28} 102 "Quality of Service (QoS) for DetNet service flows carried in IP must be provided locally by the DetNet-aware hosts and routers supporting DetNet flows. Such support leverages the underlying network layer such as 802.1 TSN. The node-internal traffic control mechanisms used to deliver QoS for IP encapsulated DetNet flows are outside the scope of this document. From an encapsulation perspective, the combination of the 6-tuple (the typical 5-tuple enhanced with the DSCP) and optionally the flow label uniquely identifies a DetNet IP flow." -- please approve and merge -- I 've uploaded this version ... b51489715e4f26f01dddc9265e5d15d7bbeac114 e749ebb19f9c5681460aa4e39c3b51f0b6fbb4b4 draft-ietf-detnet-ip 44dfff44e014e29e2bf0f3ac103547b72a49a488aa1351660a3dd98f09700c0f ['fb8ec162cc7e7d2c80120b876b4280b6994799d3e32f9dbba306ef0fe5af2b85', '44dfff44e014e29e2bf0f3ac103547b72a49a488aa1351660a3dd98f09700c0f'] B "quality of service (qos) for detnet service flows carried in ip must be provided locally by the detnet-aware hosts and routers supporting detnet flows. such support leverages the underlying network layer such as 802.1 tsn. the node-internal traffic control mechanisms used to deliver qos for ip encapsulated detnet flows are outside the scope of this document. from an encapsulation perspective, the combination of the 6-tuple (the typical 5-tuple enhanced with the dscp) and optionally the flow label uniquely identifies a detnet ip flow." {85: 1} {28: 1} {404, 28} 102 "Remarking packets associated with an incomplete reservation. Remarking can be accomplished by changing the value of the DSCP field to a value that results in the packet no longer matching any other reserved DetNet IP flow." -- please approve and merge -- I 've uploaded this version ... b51489715e4f26f01dddc9265e5d15d7bbeac114 e749ebb19f9c5681460aa4e39c3b51f0b6fbb4b4 draft-ietf-detnet-ip 38ab1cd1c2c3e41a33199b148948215d34f10bce326756d7f6ffbfa065623c6d ['38ab1cd1c2c3e41a33199b148948215d34f10bce326756d7f6ffbfa065623c6d', '742f6735ade53b1824e67a323f498ca6a0943792138e180302f4acecea1f3109'] A "remarking packets associated with an incomplete reservation. remarking can be accomplished by changing the value of the dscp field to a value that results in the packet no longer matching any other reserved detnet ip flow." {85: 1} {84: 1} {84, 85} 102 "Re-marking packets associated with an incomplete reservation. Re- marking can be accomplished by changing the value of the DSCP field to a value that results in the packet no longer matching any other reserved DetNet IP flow." -- please approve and merge -- I 've uploaded this version ... b51489715e4f26f01dddc9265e5d15d7bbeac114 e749ebb19f9c5681460aa4e39c3b51f0b6fbb4b4 draft-ietf-detnet-ip 742f6735ade53b1824e67a323f498ca6a0943792138e180302f4acecea1f3109 ['38ab1cd1c2c3e41a33199b148948215d34f10bce326756d7f6ffbfa065623c6d', '742f6735ade53b1824e67a323f498ca6a0943792138e180302f4acecea1f3109'] B "re-marking packets associated with an incomplete reservation. re- marking can be accomplished by changing the value of the dscp field to a value that results in the packet no longer matching any other reserved detnet ip flow." {85: 1} {84: 1} {84, 85} 102 "While path selection algorithms and mechanisms are out of scope of the DetNet data plane definition, it is important to highlight the implications of DetNet IP flow identification on path selection and next hops. As mentioned above, the DetNet IP data plane identifies flows using ""6-tuple"" header information as well as the additional optional header field. DetNet generally allows for both flow- specific traffic treatment and flow-specific next-hops." -- please approve and merge -- I 've uploaded this version ... b51489715e4f26f01dddc9265e5d15d7bbeac114 e749ebb19f9c5681460aa4e39c3b51f0b6fbb4b4 draft-ietf-detnet-ip ee580e1ca8dad15db164a2872881a6e56d194b2893ab09ce52a9298694b4715b ['ee580e1ca8dad15db164a2872881a6e56d194b2893ab09ce52a9298694b4715b', '299be9220abebfd8a53301fb42979bc02997c19f4f149c54d2b1f2557b45738c'] A "while path selection algorithms and mechanisms are out of scope of the detnet data plane definition, it is important to highlight the implications of detnet ip flow identification on path selection and next hops. as mentioned above, the detnet ip data plane identifies flows using ""6-tuple"" header information as well as the additional optional header field. detnet generally allows for both flow- specific traffic treatment and flow-specific next-hops." {60: 1, 56: 2, 62: 3, 102: 3} {383: 1, 80: 2, 367: 3, 79: 3} {367, 80, 79, 382, 383} 102 "While path selection algorithms and mechanisms are out of scope of the DetNet data plane definition, it is important to highlight the implications of DetNet IP flow identification on path selection and next hops. As mentioned above, the DetNet IP data plane identifies flows using ""6-tuple"" header information as well as the optional (flow label) header field. DetNet generally allows for both flow- specific traffic treatment and flow-specific next-hops." -- please approve and merge -- I 've uploaded this version ... b51489715e4f26f01dddc9265e5d15d7bbeac114 e749ebb19f9c5681460aa4e39c3b51f0b6fbb4b4 draft-ietf-detnet-ip 299be9220abebfd8a53301fb42979bc02997c19f4f149c54d2b1f2557b45738c ['ee580e1ca8dad15db164a2872881a6e56d194b2893ab09ce52a9298694b4715b', '299be9220abebfd8a53301fb42979bc02997c19f4f149c54d2b1f2557b45738c'] B "while path selection algorithms and mechanisms are out of scope of the detnet data plane definition, it is important to highlight the implications of detnet ip flow identification on path selection and next hops. as mentioned above, the detnet ip data plane identifies flows using ""6-tuple"" header information as well as the optional (flow label) header field. detnet generally allows for both flow- specific traffic treatment and flow-specific next-hops." {60: 1, 56: 2, 62: 3, 102: 3} {383: 1, 80: 2, 367: 3, 79: 3} {367, 80, 79, 382, 383} 102 "Care should be taken when using different next hops for the same 5-tuple. As discussed in RFC7657, unexpected behavior can occur when a single 5-tuple application flow experience reordering due to being split across multiple next hops. Understanding of the application and transport protocol impact of using different next hops for the same 6-tuple is required. Again, this impacts path selection for DetNet flows and this document only indirectly." -- please approve and merge -- I 've uploaded this version ... b51489715e4f26f01dddc9265e5d15d7bbeac114 e749ebb19f9c5681460aa4e39c3b51f0b6fbb4b4 draft-ietf-detnet-ip 379ed7662391edd7193f56bb9f62e34722f00818f68a2f78b11f5bcad444a9c4 ['379ed7662391edd7193f56bb9f62e34722f00818f68a2f78b11f5bcad444a9c4', 'c092dcb621c236b82d07d90ef7dfa87c756980516b24813314b61aa0009250d0'] A "care should be taken when using different next hops for the same 5-tuple. as discussed in rfc7657, unexpected behavior can occur when a single 5-tuple application flow experience reordering due to being split across multiple next hops. understanding of the application and transport protocol impact of using different next hops for the same 6-tuple is required. again, this impacts path selection for detnet flows and this document only indirectly." {56: 1, 62: 2, 102: 3, 60: 2} {80: 1, 367: 2, 382: 3, 383: 2} {367, 80, 79, 382, 383} 102 "Care should be taken when using different next hops for the same 5-tuple. As discussed in RFC7657, unexpected behavior can occur when a single 5-tuple application flow experiences reordering due to being split across multiple next hops. Understanding of the application and transport protocol impact of using different next hops for the same 5-tuple is required. Again, this impacts path selection for DetNet flows and this document only indirectly." -- please approve and merge -- I 've uploaded this version ... b51489715e4f26f01dddc9265e5d15d7bbeac114 e749ebb19f9c5681460aa4e39c3b51f0b6fbb4b4 draft-ietf-detnet-ip c092dcb621c236b82d07d90ef7dfa87c756980516b24813314b61aa0009250d0 ['379ed7662391edd7193f56bb9f62e34722f00818f68a2f78b11f5bcad444a9c4', 'c092dcb621c236b82d07d90ef7dfa87c756980516b24813314b61aa0009250d0'] B "care should be taken when using different next hops for the same 5-tuple. as discussed in rfc7657, unexpected behavior can occur when a single 5-tuple application flow experiences reordering due to being split across multiple next hops. understanding of the application and transport protocol impact of using different next hops for the same 5-tuple is required. again, this impacts path selection for detnet flows and this document only indirectly." {56: 1, 62: 2, 102: 3, 60: 2} {80: 1, 367: 2, 382: 3, 383: 2} {367, 80, 79, 382, 383} 102 "From a single node perspective, the aggregation of IP flows impacts DetNet IP data plane flow identification and resource allocation. As discussed above, IP flow identification uses the IP ""6-tuple"" for flow identification. DetNet IP flows can be aggregated using any of the 6-tuple, and an additional optional field (i.e., flow label). The use of prefixes, wildcards, lists, and value ranges allows a DetNet node to identify aggregate DetNet flows. From a resource allocation perspective, DetNet nodes ought to provide service to an aggregate rather than on a component flow basis." -- please approve and merge -- I 've uploaded this version ... b51489715e4f26f01dddc9265e5d15d7bbeac114 e749ebb19f9c5681460aa4e39c3b51f0b6fbb4b4 draft-ietf-detnet-ip a00162f89fba8d9cdb51e4693965c3a2b2020cfd3922aa95b3f95dcb03bccfc5 ['dfc20fe25c8030806e30322bf21a3c0ab00dd8c47ae3a2fbe66fa30f494ed9cb', 'a00162f89fba8d9cdb51e4693965c3a2b2020cfd3922aa95b3f95dcb03bccfc5', '44017f251cb61efcc6e89d7ce3cad69f5f7b5f87e8ead5f6b5200f809c0c50b7', '10159ac0e231428f7e5243a2220f1325f7b280c5a0940e5ba3faa07c2be94d97', 'ac4ae24402ca9286fcdbe4570e54b692051c93342d1e6ba0450afc23503fa923', '1136b8ed4df3b5bd1da7f83bd6df78da12336ff10390e4ef2bf46324538a7452', '5830d925bdf5631eed85b62338d020a790b594999f104f72da44ab0c7e67842e'] A "from a single node perspective, the aggregation of ip flows impacts detnet ip data plane flow identification and resource allocation. as discussed above, ip flow identification uses the ip ""6-tuple"" for flow identification. detnet ip flows can be aggregated using any of the 6-tuple, and an additional optional field (i.e., flow label). the use of prefixes, wildcards, lists, and value ranges allows a detnet node to identify aggregate detnet flows. from a resource allocation perspective, detnet nodes ought to provide service to an aggregate rather than on a component flow basis." {26: 1, 85: 1, 27: 2, 62: 2, 60: 3, 13: 2, 56: 2} {160: 1, 246: 1, 259: 2, 370: 2, 52: 3, 284: 2, 159: 2} {160, 259, 359, 370, 52, 246, 284, 159} 102 "It is the responsibility of the DetNet controller plane to properly provision the use of these aggregation mechanisms. This includes ensuring that aggregated flows have compatible e.g., the same or very similar QoS and/or CoS characteristics, see QoS. It also includes ensuring that per component-flow service requirements are satisfied by the aggregate, see ip-svc." -- please approve and merge -- I 've uploaded this version ... b51489715e4f26f01dddc9265e5d15d7bbeac114 e749ebb19f9c5681460aa4e39c3b51f0b6fbb4b4 draft-ietf-detnet-ip ac4ae24402ca9286fcdbe4570e54b692051c93342d1e6ba0450afc23503fa923 ['dfc20fe25c8030806e30322bf21a3c0ab00dd8c47ae3a2fbe66fa30f494ed9cb', 'a00162f89fba8d9cdb51e4693965c3a2b2020cfd3922aa95b3f95dcb03bccfc5', '44017f251cb61efcc6e89d7ce3cad69f5f7b5f87e8ead5f6b5200f809c0c50b7', '10159ac0e231428f7e5243a2220f1325f7b280c5a0940e5ba3faa07c2be94d97', 'ac4ae24402ca9286fcdbe4570e54b692051c93342d1e6ba0450afc23503fa923', '1136b8ed4df3b5bd1da7f83bd6df78da12336ff10390e4ef2bf46324538a7452', '5830d925bdf5631eed85b62338d020a790b594999f104f72da44ab0c7e67842e'] A "it is the responsibility of the detnet controller plane to properly provision the use of these aggregation mechanisms. this includes ensuring that aggregated flows have compatible e.g., the same or very similar qos and/or cos characteristics, see qos. it also includes ensuring that per component-flow service requirements are satisfied by the aggregate, see ip-svc." {26: 1, 85: 1, 27: 2, 62: 2, 60: 3, 13: 2, 56: 2} {160: 1, 246: 1, 259: 2, 370: 2, 52: 3, 284: 2, 159: 2} {160, 259, 359, 370, 52, 246, 284, 159} 102 "While the DetNet IP data plane must support bidirectional DetNet flows, there are no special bidirectional features with respect to the data plane other than the need for the two directions of a co- routed bidirectional flow to take the same path. That is to say that bidirectional DetNet flows are solely represented at the management and control plane levels, without specific support or knowledge within the DetNet data plane. Fate sharing and associated or co- routed bidirectional flows can be managed at the control level." -- please approve and merge -- I 've uploaded this version ... b51489715e4f26f01dddc9265e5d15d7bbeac114 e749ebb19f9c5681460aa4e39c3b51f0b6fbb4b4 draft-ietf-detnet-ip 1136b8ed4df3b5bd1da7f83bd6df78da12336ff10390e4ef2bf46324538a7452 ['dfc20fe25c8030806e30322bf21a3c0ab00dd8c47ae3a2fbe66fa30f494ed9cb', 'a00162f89fba8d9cdb51e4693965c3a2b2020cfd3922aa95b3f95dcb03bccfc5', '44017f251cb61efcc6e89d7ce3cad69f5f7b5f87e8ead5f6b5200f809c0c50b7', '10159ac0e231428f7e5243a2220f1325f7b280c5a0940e5ba3faa07c2be94d97', 'ac4ae24402ca9286fcdbe4570e54b692051c93342d1e6ba0450afc23503fa923', '1136b8ed4df3b5bd1da7f83bd6df78da12336ff10390e4ef2bf46324538a7452', '5830d925bdf5631eed85b62338d020a790b594999f104f72da44ab0c7e67842e'] A "while the detnet ip data plane must support bidirectional detnet flows, there are no special bidirectional features with respect to the data plane other than the need for the two directions of a co- routed bidirectional flow to take the same path. that is to say that bidirectional detnet flows are solely represented at the management and control plane levels, without specific support or knowledge within the detnet data plane. fate sharing and associated or co- routed bidirectional flows can be managed at the control level." {26: 1, 85: 1, 27: 2, 62: 2, 60: 3, 13: 2, 56: 2} {160: 1, 246: 1, 259: 2, 370: 2, 52: 3, 284: 2, 159: 2} {160, 259, 359, 370, 52, 246, 284, 159} 102 "From a single node perspective, the aggregation of IP flows impacts DetNet IP data plane flow identification and resource allocation. As discussed above, IP flow identification uses the IP ""6-tuple"" for flow identification. DetNet IP flows can be aggregated using any of the 6-tuple fields and optionally also by the flow label. The use of prefixes, wildcards, lists, and value ranges allows a DetNet node to identify aggregate DetNet flows. From a resource allocation perspective, DetNet nodes ought to provide service to an aggregate rather than on a component flow basis." -- please approve and merge -- I 've uploaded this version ... b51489715e4f26f01dddc9265e5d15d7bbeac114 e749ebb19f9c5681460aa4e39c3b51f0b6fbb4b4 draft-ietf-detnet-ip 10159ac0e231428f7e5243a2220f1325f7b280c5a0940e5ba3faa07c2be94d97 ['dfc20fe25c8030806e30322bf21a3c0ab00dd8c47ae3a2fbe66fa30f494ed9cb', 'a00162f89fba8d9cdb51e4693965c3a2b2020cfd3922aa95b3f95dcb03bccfc5', '44017f251cb61efcc6e89d7ce3cad69f5f7b5f87e8ead5f6b5200f809c0c50b7', '10159ac0e231428f7e5243a2220f1325f7b280c5a0940e5ba3faa07c2be94d97', 'ac4ae24402ca9286fcdbe4570e54b692051c93342d1e6ba0450afc23503fa923', '1136b8ed4df3b5bd1da7f83bd6df78da12336ff10390e4ef2bf46324538a7452', '5830d925bdf5631eed85b62338d020a790b594999f104f72da44ab0c7e67842e'] B "from a single node perspective, the aggregation of ip flows impacts detnet ip data plane flow identification and resource allocation. as discussed above, ip flow identification uses the ip ""6-tuple"" for flow identification. detnet ip flows can be aggregated using any of the 6-tuple fields and optionally also by the flow label. the use of prefixes, wildcards, lists, and value ranges allows a detnet node to identify aggregate detnet flows. from a resource allocation perspective, detnet nodes ought to provide service to an aggregate rather than on a component flow basis." {26: 1, 85: 1, 27: 2, 62: 2, 60: 3, 13: 2, 56: 2} {160: 1, 246: 1, 259: 2, 370: 2, 52: 3, 284: 2, 159: 2} {160, 259, 359, 370, 52, 246, 284, 159} 102 "It is the responsibility of the DetNet controller plane to properly provision the use of these aggregation mechanisms. This includes ensuring that aggregated flows have compatible (e.g., the same or very similar) QoS and/or CoS characteristics, see QoS. It also includes ensuring that per component-flow service requirements are satisfied by the aggregate, see ip-svc." -- please approve and merge -- I 've uploaded this version ... b51489715e4f26f01dddc9265e5d15d7bbeac114 e749ebb19f9c5681460aa4e39c3b51f0b6fbb4b4 draft-ietf-detnet-ip 44017f251cb61efcc6e89d7ce3cad69f5f7b5f87e8ead5f6b5200f809c0c50b7 ['dfc20fe25c8030806e30322bf21a3c0ab00dd8c47ae3a2fbe66fa30f494ed9cb', 'a00162f89fba8d9cdb51e4693965c3a2b2020cfd3922aa95b3f95dcb03bccfc5', '44017f251cb61efcc6e89d7ce3cad69f5f7b5f87e8ead5f6b5200f809c0c50b7', '10159ac0e231428f7e5243a2220f1325f7b280c5a0940e5ba3faa07c2be94d97', 'ac4ae24402ca9286fcdbe4570e54b692051c93342d1e6ba0450afc23503fa923', '1136b8ed4df3b5bd1da7f83bd6df78da12336ff10390e4ef2bf46324538a7452', '5830d925bdf5631eed85b62338d020a790b594999f104f72da44ab0c7e67842e'] B "it is the responsibility of the detnet controller plane to properly provision the use of these aggregation mechanisms. this includes ensuring that aggregated flows have compatible (e.g., the same or very similar) qos and/or cos characteristics, see qos. it also includes ensuring that per component-flow service requirements are satisfied by the aggregate, see ip-svc." {26: 1, 85: 1, 27: 2, 62: 2, 60: 3, 13: 2, 56: 2} {160: 1, 246: 1, 259: 2, 370: 2, 52: 3, 284: 2, 159: 2} {160, 259, 359, 370, 52, 246, 284, 159} 102 "The DetNet controller plane MUST ensure that non-congestion- responsive DetNet traffic is not forwarded outside a DetNet domain." -- please approve and merge -- I 've uploaded this version ... b51489715e4f26f01dddc9265e5d15d7bbeac114 e749ebb19f9c5681460aa4e39c3b51f0b6fbb4b4 draft-ietf-detnet-ip dfc20fe25c8030806e30322bf21a3c0ab00dd8c47ae3a2fbe66fa30f494ed9cb ['dfc20fe25c8030806e30322bf21a3c0ab00dd8c47ae3a2fbe66fa30f494ed9cb', 'a00162f89fba8d9cdb51e4693965c3a2b2020cfd3922aa95b3f95dcb03bccfc5', '44017f251cb61efcc6e89d7ce3cad69f5f7b5f87e8ead5f6b5200f809c0c50b7', '10159ac0e231428f7e5243a2220f1325f7b280c5a0940e5ba3faa07c2be94d97', 'ac4ae24402ca9286fcdbe4570e54b692051c93342d1e6ba0450afc23503fa923', '1136b8ed4df3b5bd1da7f83bd6df78da12336ff10390e4ef2bf46324538a7452', '5830d925bdf5631eed85b62338d020a790b594999f104f72da44ab0c7e67842e'] B "the detnet controller plane must ensure that non-congestion- responsive detnet traffic is not forwarded outside a detnet domain." {26: 1, 85: 1, 27: 2, 62: 2, 60: 3, 13: 2, 56: 2} {160: 1, 246: 1, 259: 2, 370: 2, 52: 3, 284: 2, 159: 2} {160, 259, 359, 370, 52, 246, 284, 159} 102 "While the DetNet IP data plane must support bidirectional DetNet flows, there are no special bidirectional features within the data plane. The special case of co-routed bidirectional DetNet flows are solely represented at the management and control plane levels, without specific support or knowledge within the DetNet data plane. Fate sharing and associated or co-routed bidirectional flows can be managed at the control level." -- please approve and merge -- I 've uploaded this version ... b51489715e4f26f01dddc9265e5d15d7bbeac114 e749ebb19f9c5681460aa4e39c3b51f0b6fbb4b4 draft-ietf-detnet-ip 5830d925bdf5631eed85b62338d020a790b594999f104f72da44ab0c7e67842e ['dfc20fe25c8030806e30322bf21a3c0ab00dd8c47ae3a2fbe66fa30f494ed9cb', 'a00162f89fba8d9cdb51e4693965c3a2b2020cfd3922aa95b3f95dcb03bccfc5', '44017f251cb61efcc6e89d7ce3cad69f5f7b5f87e8ead5f6b5200f809c0c50b7', '10159ac0e231428f7e5243a2220f1325f7b280c5a0940e5ba3faa07c2be94d97', 'ac4ae24402ca9286fcdbe4570e54b692051c93342d1e6ba0450afc23503fa923', '1136b8ed4df3b5bd1da7f83bd6df78da12336ff10390e4ef2bf46324538a7452', '5830d925bdf5631eed85b62338d020a790b594999f104f72da44ab0c7e67842e'] B "while the detnet ip data plane must support bidirectional detnet flows, there are no special bidirectional features within the data plane. the special case of co-routed bidirectional detnet flows are solely represented at the management and control plane levels, without specific support or knowledge within the detnet data plane. fate sharing and associated or co-routed bidirectional flows can be managed at the control level." {26: 1, 85: 1, 27: 2, 62: 2, 60: 3, 13: 2, 56: 2} {160: 1, 246: 1, 259: 2, 370: 2, 52: 3, 284: 2, 159: 2} {160, 259, 359, 370, 52, 246, 284, 159} 102 "This section provides DetNet IP data plane procedures. These procedures have been divided into the following areas: flow identification, forwarding and traffic treatment. Flow identification includes those procedures related to matching IP and higher layer protocol header information to DetNet flow (state) information and service requirements. Flow identification is also sometimes called Traffic classification, for example see RFC5777. Forwarding includes those procedures related to next hop selection and delivery. Traffic treatment includes those procedures related to providing an identified flow with the required DetNet service." -- please approve and merge -- I 've uploaded this version ... b51489715e4f26f01dddc9265e5d15d7bbeac114 e749ebb19f9c5681460aa4e39c3b51f0b6fbb4b4 draft-ietf-detnet-ip ef5718c025fc6fbc99891a8b5afb5c4d74d4e8ae274a23f35471bd4ef2e54058 ['ef5718c025fc6fbc99891a8b5afb5c4d74d4e8ae274a23f35471bd4ef2e54058', 'a0f2956f5cffa7475dbe548b554c81a54a7a5eaed3e31c2dd943eaf537cfdf33'] A "this section provides detnet ip data plane procedures. these procedures have been divided into the following areas: flow identification, forwarding and traffic treatment. flow identification includes those procedures related to matching ip and higher layer protocol header information to detnet flow (state) information and service requirements. flow identification is also sometimes called traffic classification, for example see rfc5777. forwarding includes those procedures related to next hop selection and delivery. traffic treatment includes those procedures related to providing an identified flow with the required detnet service." {} {} {} 102 "This section provides DetNet IP data plane procedures. These procedures have been divided into the following areas: flow identification, forwarding and traffic treatment. Flow identification includes those procedures related to matching IP and higher layer protocol header information to DetNet flow (state) information and service requirements. Flow identification is also sometimes called Traffic classification; for example see RFC5777. Forwarding includes those procedures related to next hop selection and delivery. Traffic treatment includes those procedures related to providing an identified flow with the required DetNet service." -- please approve and merge -- I 've uploaded this version ... b51489715e4f26f01dddc9265e5d15d7bbeac114 e749ebb19f9c5681460aa4e39c3b51f0b6fbb4b4 draft-ietf-detnet-ip a0f2956f5cffa7475dbe548b554c81a54a7a5eaed3e31c2dd943eaf537cfdf33 ['ef5718c025fc6fbc99891a8b5afb5c4d74d4e8ae274a23f35471bd4ef2e54058', 'a0f2956f5cffa7475dbe548b554c81a54a7a5eaed3e31c2dd943eaf537cfdf33'] B "this section provides detnet ip data plane procedures. these procedures have been divided into the following areas: flow identification, forwarding and traffic treatment. flow identification includes those procedures related to matching ip and higher layer protocol header information to detnet flow (state) information and service requirements. flow identification is also sometimes called traffic classification; for example see rfc5777. forwarding includes those procedures related to next hop selection and delivery. traffic treatment includes those procedures related to providing an identified flow with the required detnet service." {} {} {} 102 "IP and higher layer protocol header information is used to identify DetNet flows. All DetNet implementations that support this document MUST identify individual DetNet flows based on the set of information identified in this section. Note, that additional flow identification requirements, e.g., to support other higher layer protocols, may be defined in the future." -- please approve and merge -- I 've uploaded this version ... b51489715e4f26f01dddc9265e5d15d7bbeac114 e749ebb19f9c5681460aa4e39c3b51f0b6fbb4b4 draft-ietf-detnet-ip a119f79d1148b82bf1517d5da4f0e33704e230b3daddffd57220117fc3d03bb9 ['be7f71dea5090eeda71169c38ce2f1a88d1731b2bfc4c1c0281d70d4ce3806b0', 'a119f79d1148b82bf1517d5da4f0e33704e230b3daddffd57220117fc3d03bb9'] A "ip and higher layer protocol header information is used to identify detnet flows. all detnet implementations that support this document must identify individual detnet flows based on the set of information identified in this section. note, that additional flow identification requirements, e.g., to support other higher layer protocols, may be defined in the future." {62: 1} {143: 1} {297, 143} 102 "IP and higher layer protocol header information is used to identify DetNet flows. All DetNet implementations that support this document MUST identify individual DetNet flows based on the set of information identified in this section. Note that additional flow identification requirements, e.g., to support other higher layer protocols, may be defined in the future." -- please approve and merge -- I 've uploaded this version ... b51489715e4f26f01dddc9265e5d15d7bbeac114 e749ebb19f9c5681460aa4e39c3b51f0b6fbb4b4 draft-ietf-detnet-ip be7f71dea5090eeda71169c38ce2f1a88d1731b2bfc4c1c0281d70d4ce3806b0 ['be7f71dea5090eeda71169c38ce2f1a88d1731b2bfc4c1c0281d70d4ce3806b0', 'a119f79d1148b82bf1517d5da4f0e33704e230b3daddffd57220117fc3d03bb9'] B "ip and higher layer protocol header information is used to identify detnet flows. all detnet implementations that support this document must identify individual detnet flows based on the set of information identified in this section. note that additional flow identification requirements, e.g., to support other higher layer protocols, may be defined in the future." {62: 1} {143: 1} {297, 143} 102 "Implementations of this document MUST support DetNet flow identification based on the Source Address field of an IP packet. Implementations SHOULD support longest prefix matching for this field, see RFC1812 and RFC7608. Note that a prefix length of zero (0) effectively means that the field is ignored." -- please approve and merge -- I 've uploaded this version ... b51489715e4f26f01dddc9265e5d15d7bbeac114 e749ebb19f9c5681460aa4e39c3b51f0b6fbb4b4 draft-ietf-detnet-ip eb2b34ba584482d60bdd862b66b17ccd4ad0a7b1989d436cd38e03247b3c3f19 ['4894027919745f7845c232c4352d2eae016f0fdf5738bc9d3388e3edb03f3105', 'e0cfbecdf0b9c8c4762898ebd053c42a9c309ab287ab3d9084d32fd920c72cd0', '2421b52448af9e52fe9f4c84452acf2c8d81e99c350cd885cb80256e215591b8', 'eb2b34ba584482d60bdd862b66b17ccd4ad0a7b1989d436cd38e03247b3c3f19'] A "implementations of this document must support detnet flow identification based on the source address field of an ip packet. implementations should support longest prefix matching for this field, see rfc1812 and rfc7608. note that a prefix length of zero (0) effectively means that the field is ignored." {} {} {} 102 "Implementations of this document MUST support DetNet flow identification based on the Destination Address field of an IP packet. Implementations SHOULD support longest prefix matching for this field, see RFC1812 and RFC7608. Note that a prefix length of zero (0) effectively means that the field is ignored." -- please approve and merge -- I 've uploaded this version ... b51489715e4f26f01dddc9265e5d15d7bbeac114 e749ebb19f9c5681460aa4e39c3b51f0b6fbb4b4 draft-ietf-detnet-ip e0cfbecdf0b9c8c4762898ebd053c42a9c309ab287ab3d9084d32fd920c72cd0 ['4894027919745f7845c232c4352d2eae016f0fdf5738bc9d3388e3edb03f3105', 'e0cfbecdf0b9c8c4762898ebd053c42a9c309ab287ab3d9084d32fd920c72cd0', '2421b52448af9e52fe9f4c84452acf2c8d81e99c350cd885cb80256e215591b8', 'eb2b34ba584482d60bdd862b66b17ccd4ad0a7b1989d436cd38e03247b3c3f19'] A "implementations of this document must support detnet flow identification based on the destination address field of an ip packet. implementations should support longest prefix matching for this field, see rfc1812 and rfc7608. note that a prefix length of zero (0) effectively means that the field is ignored." {} {} {} 102 "Implementations of this document MUST support DetNet flow identification based on the Source Address field of an IP packet. Implementations SHOULD support longest prefix matching for this field (see RFC1812 and RFC7608.) Note that a prefix length of zero (0) effectively means that the field is ignored." -- please approve and merge -- I 've uploaded this version ... b51489715e4f26f01dddc9265e5d15d7bbeac114 e749ebb19f9c5681460aa4e39c3b51f0b6fbb4b4 draft-ietf-detnet-ip 2421b52448af9e52fe9f4c84452acf2c8d81e99c350cd885cb80256e215591b8 ['4894027919745f7845c232c4352d2eae016f0fdf5738bc9d3388e3edb03f3105', 'e0cfbecdf0b9c8c4762898ebd053c42a9c309ab287ab3d9084d32fd920c72cd0', '2421b52448af9e52fe9f4c84452acf2c8d81e99c350cd885cb80256e215591b8', 'eb2b34ba584482d60bdd862b66b17ccd4ad0a7b1989d436cd38e03247b3c3f19'] B "implementations of this document must support detnet flow identification based on the source address field of an ip packet. implementations should support longest prefix matching for this field (see rfc1812 and rfc7608.) note that a prefix length of zero (0) effectively means that the field is ignored." {} {} {} 102 "Implementations of this document MUST support DetNet flow identification based on the Destination Address field of an IP packet. Implementations SHOULD support longest prefix matching for this field (see RFC1812 and RFC7608.) Note that a prefix length of zero (0) effectively means that the field is ignored." -- please approve and merge -- I 've uploaded this version ... b51489715e4f26f01dddc9265e5d15d7bbeac114 e749ebb19f9c5681460aa4e39c3b51f0b6fbb4b4 draft-ietf-detnet-ip 4894027919745f7845c232c4352d2eae016f0fdf5738bc9d3388e3edb03f3105 ['4894027919745f7845c232c4352d2eae016f0fdf5738bc9d3388e3edb03f3105', 'e0cfbecdf0b9c8c4762898ebd053c42a9c309ab287ab3d9084d32fd920c72cd0', '2421b52448af9e52fe9f4c84452acf2c8d81e99c350cd885cb80256e215591b8', 'eb2b34ba584482d60bdd862b66b17ccd4ad0a7b1989d436cd38e03247b3c3f19'] B "implementations of this document must support detnet flow identification based on the destination address field of an ip packet. implementations should support longest prefix matching for this field (see rfc1812 and rfc7608.) note that a prefix length of zero (0) effectively means that the field is ignored." {} {} {} 102 "Implementations of this document MUST support DetNet flow identification based on the IPv4 Protocol field when processing IPv4 packets, and the IPv6 Next Header Field when processing IPv6 packets. An implementation MUST support flow identification based on the next protocol values defined in nxt-proto. Other, non-zero values, MUST be used for flow identification. Implementations SHOULD allow for these fields to be ignored for a specific DetNet flow." -- please approve and merge -- I 've uploaded this version ... b51489715e4f26f01dddc9265e5d15d7bbeac114 e749ebb19f9c5681460aa4e39c3b51f0b6fbb4b4 draft-ietf-detnet-ip b0ded4364e4dfd01420adcd6d8488b4347df1083c53c74a08c176c47b731320e ['85571ea4044b44eb5e284c170219c798494eda0c501c0d3fae9064ce34a072fa', 'b0ded4364e4dfd01420adcd6d8488b4347df1083c53c74a08c176c47b731320e'] A "implementations of this document must support detnet flow identification based on the ipv4 protocol field when processing ipv4 packets, and the ipv6 next header field when processing ipv6 packets. an implementation must support flow identification based on the next protocol values defined in nxt-proto. other, non-zero values, must be used for flow identification. implementations should allow for these fields to be ignored for a specific detnet flow." {62: 1} {42: 1} {210, 42} 102 "Implementations of this document MUST support DetNet flow identification based on the IPv4 Protocol field when processing IPv4 packets, and the IPv6 Next Header Field when processing IPv6 packets. This includes the next protocol values defined in nxt-proto and any other value, including zero. Implementations SHOULD allow for these fields to be ignored for a specific DetNet flow." -- please approve and merge -- I 've uploaded this version ... b51489715e4f26f01dddc9265e5d15d7bbeac114 e749ebb19f9c5681460aa4e39c3b51f0b6fbb4b4 draft-ietf-detnet-ip 85571ea4044b44eb5e284c170219c798494eda0c501c0d3fae9064ce34a072fa ['85571ea4044b44eb5e284c170219c798494eda0c501c0d3fae9064ce34a072fa', 'b0ded4364e4dfd01420adcd6d8488b4347df1083c53c74a08c176c47b731320e'] B "implementations of this document must support detnet flow identification based on the ipv4 protocol field when processing ipv4 packets, and the ipv6 next header field when processing ipv6 packets. this includes the next protocol values defined in nxt-proto and any other value, including zero. implementations should allow for these fields to be ignored for a specific detnet flow." {62: 1} {42: 1} {210, 42} 102 "These fields are used to support Differentiated Services RFC2474 RFC2475. Implementations of this document MUST support DetNet flow identification based on the DSCP field in the IPv4 Type of Service field when processing IPv4 packets, and the DSCP field in the IPv6 Traffic Class Field when processing IPv6 packets. Implementations MUST support list based matching of DSCP values, where the list is composed of possible field values that are to be considered when identifying a specific DetNet flow. Implementations SHOULD allow for this field to be ignored for a specific DetNet flow." -- please approve and merge -- I 've uploaded this version ... b51489715e4f26f01dddc9265e5d15d7bbeac114 e749ebb19f9c5681460aa4e39c3b51f0b6fbb4b4 draft-ietf-detnet-ip d8e864655c4e160952f098de8d69c8b26dea919dd41adee0bb44d62ab049dead ['d8e864655c4e160952f098de8d69c8b26dea919dd41adee0bb44d62ab049dead', 'ebd5abb9a353eacc1a443d190c48f025876a2a834df42764e058cd244b58fbf4'] A "these fields are used to support differentiated services rfc2474 rfc2475. implementations of this document must support detnet flow identification based on the dscp field in the ipv4 type of service field when processing ipv4 packets, and the dscp field in the ipv6 traffic class field when processing ipv6 packets. implementations must support list based matching of dscp values, where the list is composed of possible field values that are to be considered when identifying a specific detnet flow. implementations should allow for this field to be ignored for a specific detnet flow." {60: 1, 56: 2} {344: 1, 164: 2} {344, 345, 164} 102 "These fields are used to support Differentiated Services RFC2474 RFC2475. Implementations of this document MUST support DetNet flow identification based on the DSCP field in the IPv4 Type of Service field when processing IPv4 packets, and the DSCP field in the IPv6 Traffic Class Field when processing IPv6 packets. Implementations MUST support list-based matching of DSCP values, where the list is composed of possible field values that are to be considered when identifying a specific DetNet flow. Implementations SHOULD allow for this field to be ignored for a specific DetNet flow." -- please approve and merge -- I 've uploaded this version ... b51489715e4f26f01dddc9265e5d15d7bbeac114 e749ebb19f9c5681460aa4e39c3b51f0b6fbb4b4 draft-ietf-detnet-ip ebd5abb9a353eacc1a443d190c48f025876a2a834df42764e058cd244b58fbf4 ['d8e864655c4e160952f098de8d69c8b26dea919dd41adee0bb44d62ab049dead', 'ebd5abb9a353eacc1a443d190c48f025876a2a834df42764e058cd244b58fbf4'] B "these fields are used to support differentiated services rfc2474 rfc2475. implementations of this document must support detnet flow identification based on the dscp field in the ipv4 type of service field when processing ipv4 packets, and the dscp field in the ipv6 traffic class field when processing ipv6 packets. implementations must support list-based matching of dscp values, where the list is composed of possible field values that are to be considered when identifying a specific detnet flow. implementations should allow for this field to be ignored for a specific detnet flow." {60: 1, 56: 2} {344: 1, 164: 2} {344, 345, 164} 102 "Implementations of this document SHOULD support identification of DetNet flows based on the IPv6 Flow Label field. Implementations that support matching based on this field MUST allow for this field to be ignored for a specific DetNet flow. When this field is used to identify a specific DetNet flow, implementations MAY exclude the IPv6 Next Header field and next header information as part of DetNet flow identification." -- please approve and merge -- I 've uploaded this version ... b51489715e4f26f01dddc9265e5d15d7bbeac114 e749ebb19f9c5681460aa4e39c3b51f0b6fbb4b4 draft-ietf-detnet-ip 0e5e0c4748706c12ebfa391da0fe39f6aad87dd35d60c723e76d961d78e8edc0 ['0e5e0c4748706c12ebfa391da0fe39f6aad87dd35d60c723e76d961d78e8edc0', '12cb7d871bf91d8910c1d597d180850dc8d5ee00f2d77b19888857147222588c'] A "implementations of this document should support identification of detnet flows based on the ipv6 flow label field. implementations that support matching based on this field must allow for this field to be ignored for a specific detnet flow. when this field is used to identify a specific detnet flow, implementations may exclude the ipv6 next header field and next header information as part of detnet flow identification." {} {} {} 102 "Implementations of this document SHOULD support identification of DetNet flows based on the IPv6 Flow Label field. Implementations that support matching based on this field MUST allow for it to be ignored for a specific DetNet flow. When this field is used to identify a specific DetNet flow, implementations MAY exclude the IPv6 Next Header field and next header information as part of DetNet flow identification." -- please approve and merge -- I 've uploaded this version ... b51489715e4f26f01dddc9265e5d15d7bbeac114 e749ebb19f9c5681460aa4e39c3b51f0b6fbb4b4 draft-ietf-detnet-ip 12cb7d871bf91d8910c1d597d180850dc8d5ee00f2d77b19888857147222588c ['0e5e0c4748706c12ebfa391da0fe39f6aad87dd35d60c723e76d961d78e8edc0', '12cb7d871bf91d8910c1d597d180850dc8d5ee00f2d77b19888857147222588c'] B "implementations of this document should support identification of detnet flows based on the ipv6 flow label field. implementations that support matching based on this field must allow for it to be ignored for a specific detnet flow. when this field is used to identify a specific detnet flow, implementations may exclude the ipv6 next header field and next header information as part of detnet flow identification." {} {} {} 102 "DetNet flow identification for ICMP is achieved based on the protocol's header. Note that ICMP type is not included in the flow definition." -- please approve and merge -- I 've uploaded this version ... b51489715e4f26f01dddc9265e5d15d7bbeac114 e749ebb19f9c5681460aa4e39c3b51f0b6fbb4b4 draft-ietf-detnet-ip 727a4cc4bc1da20d6546d2a5332714a535a5e9f8a6436a8e33912f1946047719 ['727a4cc4bc1da20d6546d2a5332714a535a5e9f8a6436a8e33912f1946047719', '7fb1fdf8e6fee088b3aae44deef0a730cfadc0048b9b17e54d24646987e10036'] A "detnet flow identification for icmp is achieved based on the protocol's header. note that icmp type is not included in the flow definition." {85: 1} {178: 1} {178, 179} 102 "DetNet flow identification for ICMP RFC0792 is achieved based on the protocol number in the IP header. Note that ICMP type is not included in the flow definition." -- please approve and merge -- I 've uploaded this version ... b51489715e4f26f01dddc9265e5d15d7bbeac114 e749ebb19f9c5681460aa4e39c3b51f0b6fbb4b4 draft-ietf-detnet-ip 7fb1fdf8e6fee088b3aae44deef0a730cfadc0048b9b17e54d24646987e10036 ['727a4cc4bc1da20d6546d2a5332714a535a5e9f8a6436a8e33912f1946047719', '7fb1fdf8e6fee088b3aae44deef0a730cfadc0048b9b17e54d24646987e10036'] B "detnet flow identification for icmp rfc0792 is achieved based on the protocol number in the ip header. note that icmp type is not included in the flow definition." {85: 1} {178: 1} {178, 179} 102 "General requirements for IP nodes are defined in RFC1122, RFC1812 and RFC8504, and are not modified by this document. The typical next-hop selection process is impacted by DetNet. Specifically, implementations of this document SHALL use management and control information to select the one or more outgoing interfaces and next hops to be used for a packet associated with a DetNet flow." -- please approve and merge -- I 've uploaded this version ... b51489715e4f26f01dddc9265e5d15d7bbeac114 e749ebb19f9c5681460aa4e39c3b51f0b6fbb4b4 draft-ietf-detnet-ip 32773baad1fbdc5f542dd688f367b250271de3b0f1c110da46464085f88a24e6 ['32773baad1fbdc5f542dd688f367b250271de3b0f1c110da46464085f88a24e6', '332b88b2a2b95f1d538bb643e4b8c438fe57a391fe5cbe0816aed40078cc4894'] A "general requirements for ip nodes are defined in rfc1122, rfc1812 and rfc8504, and are not modified by this document. the typical next-hop selection process is impacted by detnet. specifically, implementations of this document shall use management and control information to select the one or more outgoing interfaces and next hops to be used for a packet associated with a detnet flow." {67: 1, 62: 2} {410: 1, 411: 2} {410, 411, 68} 102 "General requirements for IP nodes are defined in RFC1122, RFC1812 and RFC8504, and are not modified by this document. The typical next-hop selection process is impacted by DetNet. Specifically, implementations of this document SHALL use management and control information to select the one or more outgoing interfaces and next hops to be used for a packet associated with a DetNet flow. Specific management and control information will be defined in future documents, e.g., I-D.ietf-detnet-yang." -- please approve and merge -- I 've uploaded this version ... b51489715e4f26f01dddc9265e5d15d7bbeac114 e749ebb19f9c5681460aa4e39c3b51f0b6fbb4b4 draft-ietf-detnet-ip 332b88b2a2b95f1d538bb643e4b8c438fe57a391fe5cbe0816aed40078cc4894 ['32773baad1fbdc5f542dd688f367b250271de3b0f1c110da46464085f88a24e6', '332b88b2a2b95f1d538bb643e4b8c438fe57a391fe5cbe0816aed40078cc4894'] B "general requirements for ip nodes are defined in rfc1122, rfc1812 and rfc8504, and are not modified by this document. the typical next-hop selection process is impacted by detnet. specifically, implementations of this document shall use management and control information to select the one or more outgoing interfaces and next hops to be used for a packet associated with a detnet flow. specific management and control information will be defined in future documents, e.g., i-d.ietf-detnet-yang." {67: 1, 62: 2} {410: 1, 411: 2} {410, 411, 68} 102 "Implementations of this document MUST ensure that a DetNet flow receives the traffic treatment that is provisioned for it via configuration or the controller plane, e.g., via I-D.ietf-detnet- yang. General information on DetNet service can be found in I- D.ietf-detnet-flow-information-model. Typical mechanisms used to provide different treatment to different flows includes the allocation of system resources (such as queues and buffers) and provisioning or related parameters (such as shaping, and policing). Support can also be provided via an underlying network technology such as MPLS I-D.ietf-detnet-ip-over-mpls or IEEE802.1 TSN I-D.ietf- detnet-ip-over-tsn. Other mechanisms than the ones used in the TSN case are outside the scope of this document." -- please approve and merge -- I 've uploaded this version ... b51489715e4f26f01dddc9265e5d15d7bbeac114 e749ebb19f9c5681460aa4e39c3b51f0b6fbb4b4 draft-ietf-detnet-ip f7ff2c29bfd2298998219ea37f5f4223f98808aaf2cb23984ac7c10008fe4ad5 ['f7ff2c29bfd2298998219ea37f5f4223f98808aaf2cb23984ac7c10008fe4ad5', 'f45650abf99cca046f70649056c1a0e60d76fcb4a6d806e4fbba985090dd99a0'] A "implementations of this document must ensure that a detnet flow receives the traffic treatment that is provisioned for it via configuration or the controller plane, e.g., via i-d.ietf-detnet- yang. general information on detnet service can be found in i- d.ietf-detnet-flow-information-model. typical mechanisms used to provide different treatment to different flows includes the allocation of system resources (such as queues and buffers) and provisioning or related parameters (such as shaping, and policing). support can also be provided via an underlying network technology such as mpls i-d.ietf-detnet-ip-over-mpls or ieee802.1 tsn i-d.ietf- detnet-ip-over-tsn. other mechanisms than the ones used in the tsn case are outside the scope of this document." {} {} {} 102 "Implementations of this document must ensure that a DetNet flow receives the traffic treatment that is provisioned for it via configuration or the controller plane, e.g., via I-D.ietf-detnet- yang. General information on DetNet service can be found in I- D.ietf-detnet-flow-information-model. Typical mechanisms used to provide different treatment to different flows includes the allocation of system resources (such as queues and buffers) and provisioning of related parameters (such as shaping, and policing). Support can also be provided via an underlying network technology such as MPLS I-D.ietf-detnet-ip-over-mpls or IEEE802.1 TSN I-D.ietf- detnet-ip-over-tsn. Other mechanisms than the ones used in the TSN case are outside the scope of this document." -- please approve and merge -- I 've uploaded this version ... b51489715e4f26f01dddc9265e5d15d7bbeac114 e749ebb19f9c5681460aa4e39c3b51f0b6fbb4b4 draft-ietf-detnet-ip f45650abf99cca046f70649056c1a0e60d76fcb4a6d806e4fbba985090dd99a0 ['f7ff2c29bfd2298998219ea37f5f4223f98808aaf2cb23984ac7c10008fe4ad5', 'f45650abf99cca046f70649056c1a0e60d76fcb4a6d806e4fbba985090dd99a0'] B "implementations of this document must ensure that a detnet flow receives the traffic treatment that is provisioned for it via configuration or the controller plane, e.g., via i-d.ietf-detnet- yang. general information on detnet service can be found in i- d.ietf-detnet-flow-information-model. typical mechanisms used to provide different treatment to different flows includes the allocation of system resources (such as queues and buffers) and provisioning of related parameters (such as shaping, and policing). support can also be provided via an underlying network technology such as mpls i-d.ietf-detnet-ip-over-mpls or ieee802.1 tsn i-d.ietf- detnet-ip-over-tsn. other mechanisms than the ones used in the tsn case are outside the scope of this document." {} {} {} 102 "IPv4 protocol field. A limited set of values is allowed, and the ability to ignore this field, e.g., via configuration of the value zero (0), is desirable." -- please approve and merge -- I 've uploaded this version ... b51489715e4f26f01dddc9265e5d15d7bbeac114 e749ebb19f9c5681460aa4e39c3b51f0b6fbb4b4 draft-ietf-detnet-ip 262458695b60b9a04c924362650f709dc6d8ec4c29dbf4ab4b5b98a7c1189f6d ['580d70d349f3997f674bb34815b5b897870c9cf11eebcc57fe65ee44880085b8', '262458695b60b9a04c924362650f709dc6d8ec4c29dbf4ab4b5b98a7c1189f6d', 'df4bb69f89963c02243c41456c580ebe54398ef481fed354c1b133e77191c065', 'cf5fa5de23650d9c1a514ee33199b668fabb5841cb375e7f5d79efc3b31fed0b'] A "ipv4 protocol field. a limited set of values is allowed, and the ability to ignore this field, e.g., via configuration of the value zero (0), is desirable." {} {} {} 102 "IPv6 next header field. A limited set of values is allowed, and the ability to ignore this field, e.g., via configuration of the value zero (0), is desirable." -- please approve and merge -- I 've uploaded this version ... b51489715e4f26f01dddc9265e5d15d7bbeac114 e749ebb19f9c5681460aa4e39c3b51f0b6fbb4b4 draft-ietf-detnet-ip 580d70d349f3997f674bb34815b5b897870c9cf11eebcc57fe65ee44880085b8 ['580d70d349f3997f674bb34815b5b897870c9cf11eebcc57fe65ee44880085b8', '262458695b60b9a04c924362650f709dc6d8ec4c29dbf4ab4b5b98a7c1189f6d', 'df4bb69f89963c02243c41456c580ebe54398ef481fed354c1b133e77191c065', 'cf5fa5de23650d9c1a514ee33199b668fabb5841cb375e7f5d79efc3b31fed0b'] A "ipv6 next header field. a limited set of values is allowed, and the ability to ignore this field, e.g., via configuration of the value zero (0), is desirable." {} {} {} 102 "IPv4 protocol field. A limited set of values is allowed, and the ability to ignore this field is desirable." -- please approve and merge -- I 've uploaded this version ... b51489715e4f26f01dddc9265e5d15d7bbeac114 e749ebb19f9c5681460aa4e39c3b51f0b6fbb4b4 draft-ietf-detnet-ip df4bb69f89963c02243c41456c580ebe54398ef481fed354c1b133e77191c065 ['580d70d349f3997f674bb34815b5b897870c9cf11eebcc57fe65ee44880085b8', '262458695b60b9a04c924362650f709dc6d8ec4c29dbf4ab4b5b98a7c1189f6d', 'df4bb69f89963c02243c41456c580ebe54398ef481fed354c1b133e77191c065', 'cf5fa5de23650d9c1a514ee33199b668fabb5841cb375e7f5d79efc3b31fed0b'] B "ipv4 protocol field. a limited set of values is allowed, and the ability to ignore this field is desirable." {} {} {} 102 "IPv6 next header field. A limited set of values is allowed, and the ability to ignore this field is desirable." -- please approve and merge -- I 've uploaded this version ... b51489715e4f26f01dddc9265e5d15d7bbeac114 e749ebb19f9c5681460aa4e39c3b51f0b6fbb4b4 draft-ietf-detnet-ip cf5fa5de23650d9c1a514ee33199b668fabb5841cb375e7f5d79efc3b31fed0b ['580d70d349f3997f674bb34815b5b897870c9cf11eebcc57fe65ee44880085b8', '262458695b60b9a04c924362650f709dc6d8ec4c29dbf4ab4b5b98a7c1189f6d', 'df4bb69f89963c02243c41456c580ebe54398ef481fed354c1b133e77191c065', 'cf5fa5de23650d9c1a514ee33199b668fabb5841cb375e7f5d79efc3b31fed0b'] B "ipv6 next header field. a limited set of values is allowed, and the ability to ignore this field is desirable." {} {} {} 102 "IPv6 flow label field. This field can be optionally used for matching. When used, can be used instead of matching against the Next Header field." -- please approve and merge -- I 've uploaded this version ... b51489715e4f26f01dddc9265e5d15d7bbeac114 e749ebb19f9c5681460aa4e39c3b51f0b6fbb4b4 draft-ietf-detnet-ip b59ef38bc775ad389228cfd39677b5392e681fe36a24fc75e441bed9fca21593 ['b1f3b310f4dbed63f9f13a9c86ec9493d4fe1a42d8f889736e18c6a3ac41101e', '1c461fe81d5bcf71073032237c90a364fe0acc907c86f9c6b7bdd0239e4a6516', 'fdaf7b19e26a8f8943811671a6e8da3ec29bcf8fe9612e127a54c73037ab2f7b', '59f27c10d7da72693b21a980a2cf524398f9cf4dc009641ae9e9faa91f7d94f9', '4c7e714e12f70980245dffffd7d5f8029aca0c2c12808b318d9836dbce80995c', 'b59ef38bc775ad389228cfd39677b5392e681fe36a24fc75e441bed9fca21593', '1d0fbefb081c07437c994ac521c81a167d9d746ffb2d5dfd54e150761b4aa1df', '25aebb40a81451ce0de73406fcce1226ae111f3a495618fa71e24313928b8dd1', 'cc9e02cd6c86047ecb0eeaef6c605aa491126643903149ae2064b12d562356d9'] A "ipv6 flow label field. this field can be optionally used for matching. when used, can be used instead of matching against the next header field." {33: 1, 26: 1, 32: 1, 62: 1, 60: 3, 56: 2, 64: 2, 38: 2, 71: 2, 83: 3, 113: 2, 126: 3, 112: 2, 85: 3, 129: 3} {31: 1, 32: 1, 33: 1, 283: 1, 260: 3, 261: 2, 339: 3, 212: 2, 343: 3, 286: 4, 163: 3, 228: 2, 357: 2, 166: 3, 231: 2, 298: 2, 363: 3, 46: 3, 377: 2} {260, 261, 274, 283, 286, 31, 32, 33, 163, 166, 298, 46, 339, 212, 343, 228, 357, 231, 363, 377} 102 "TCP and UDP Source Port. Exact and wildcard matching is required. Port ranges can optionally be used." -- please approve and merge -- I 've uploaded this version ... b51489715e4f26f01dddc9265e5d15d7bbeac114 e749ebb19f9c5681460aa4e39c3b51f0b6fbb4b4 draft-ietf-detnet-ip 59f27c10d7da72693b21a980a2cf524398f9cf4dc009641ae9e9faa91f7d94f9 ['b1f3b310f4dbed63f9f13a9c86ec9493d4fe1a42d8f889736e18c6a3ac41101e', '1c461fe81d5bcf71073032237c90a364fe0acc907c86f9c6b7bdd0239e4a6516', 'fdaf7b19e26a8f8943811671a6e8da3ec29bcf8fe9612e127a54c73037ab2f7b', '59f27c10d7da72693b21a980a2cf524398f9cf4dc009641ae9e9faa91f7d94f9', '4c7e714e12f70980245dffffd7d5f8029aca0c2c12808b318d9836dbce80995c', 'b59ef38bc775ad389228cfd39677b5392e681fe36a24fc75e441bed9fca21593', '1d0fbefb081c07437c994ac521c81a167d9d746ffb2d5dfd54e150761b4aa1df', '25aebb40a81451ce0de73406fcce1226ae111f3a495618fa71e24313928b8dd1', 'cc9e02cd6c86047ecb0eeaef6c605aa491126643903149ae2064b12d562356d9'] A "tcp and udp source port. exact and wildcard matching is required. port ranges can optionally be used." {33: 1, 26: 1, 32: 1, 62: 1, 60: 3, 56: 2, 64: 2, 38: 2, 71: 2, 83: 3, 113: 2, 126: 3, 112: 2, 85: 3, 129: 3} {31: 1, 32: 1, 33: 1, 283: 1, 260: 3, 261: 2, 339: 3, 212: 2, 343: 3, 286: 4, 163: 3, 228: 2, 357: 2, 166: 3, 231: 2, 298: 2, 363: 3, 46: 3, 377: 2} {260, 261, 274, 283, 286, 31, 32, 33, 163, 166, 298, 46, 339, 212, 343, 228, 357, 231, 363, 377} 102 "TCP and UDP Destination Port. Exact and wildcard matching is required. Port ranges can optionally be used." -- please approve and merge -- I 've uploaded this version ... b51489715e4f26f01dddc9265e5d15d7bbeac114 e749ebb19f9c5681460aa4e39c3b51f0b6fbb4b4 draft-ietf-detnet-ip 1d0fbefb081c07437c994ac521c81a167d9d746ffb2d5dfd54e150761b4aa1df ['b1f3b310f4dbed63f9f13a9c86ec9493d4fe1a42d8f889736e18c6a3ac41101e', '1c461fe81d5bcf71073032237c90a364fe0acc907c86f9c6b7bdd0239e4a6516', 'fdaf7b19e26a8f8943811671a6e8da3ec29bcf8fe9612e127a54c73037ab2f7b', '59f27c10d7da72693b21a980a2cf524398f9cf4dc009641ae9e9faa91f7d94f9', '4c7e714e12f70980245dffffd7d5f8029aca0c2c12808b318d9836dbce80995c', 'b59ef38bc775ad389228cfd39677b5392e681fe36a24fc75e441bed9fca21593', '1d0fbefb081c07437c994ac521c81a167d9d746ffb2d5dfd54e150761b4aa1df', '25aebb40a81451ce0de73406fcce1226ae111f3a495618fa71e24313928b8dd1', 'cc9e02cd6c86047ecb0eeaef6c605aa491126643903149ae2064b12d562356d9'] A "tcp and udp destination port. exact and wildcard matching is required. port ranges can optionally be used." {33: 1, 26: 1, 32: 1, 62: 1, 60: 3, 56: 2, 64: 2, 38: 2, 71: 2, 83: 3, 113: 2, 126: 3, 112: 2, 85: 3, 129: 3} {31: 1, 32: 1, 33: 1, 283: 1, 260: 3, 261: 2, 339: 3, 212: 2, 343: 3, 286: 4, 163: 3, 228: 2, 357: 2, 166: 3, 231: 2, 298: 2, 363: 3, 46: 3, 377: 2} {260, 261, 274, 283, 286, 31, 32, 33, 163, 166, 298, 46, 339, 212, 343, 228, 357, 231, 363, 377} 102 "IPv6 flow label field. This field can be optionally used for matching. When used, this field can be used instead of matching against the Next Header field." -- please approve and merge -- I 've uploaded this version ... b51489715e4f26f01dddc9265e5d15d7bbeac114 e749ebb19f9c5681460aa4e39c3b51f0b6fbb4b4 draft-ietf-detnet-ip b1f3b310f4dbed63f9f13a9c86ec9493d4fe1a42d8f889736e18c6a3ac41101e ['b1f3b310f4dbed63f9f13a9c86ec9493d4fe1a42d8f889736e18c6a3ac41101e', '1c461fe81d5bcf71073032237c90a364fe0acc907c86f9c6b7bdd0239e4a6516', 'fdaf7b19e26a8f8943811671a6e8da3ec29bcf8fe9612e127a54c73037ab2f7b', '59f27c10d7da72693b21a980a2cf524398f9cf4dc009641ae9e9faa91f7d94f9', '4c7e714e12f70980245dffffd7d5f8029aca0c2c12808b318d9836dbce80995c', 'b59ef38bc775ad389228cfd39677b5392e681fe36a24fc75e441bed9fca21593', '1d0fbefb081c07437c994ac521c81a167d9d746ffb2d5dfd54e150761b4aa1df', '25aebb40a81451ce0de73406fcce1226ae111f3a495618fa71e24313928b8dd1', 'cc9e02cd6c86047ecb0eeaef6c605aa491126643903149ae2064b12d562356d9'] B "ipv6 flow label field. this field can be optionally used for matching. when used, this field can be used instead of matching against the next header field." {33: 1, 26: 1, 32: 1, 62: 1, 60: 3, 56: 2, 64: 2, 38: 2, 71: 2, 83: 3, 113: 2, 126: 3, 112: 2, 85: 3, 129: 3} {31: 1, 32: 1, 33: 1, 283: 1, 260: 3, 261: 2, 339: 3, 212: 2, 343: 3, 286: 4, 163: 3, 228: 2, 357: 2, 166: 3, 231: 2, 298: 2, 363: 3, 46: 3, 377: 2} {260, 261, 274, 283, 286, 31, 32, 33, 163, 166, 298, 46, 339, 212, 343, 228, 357, 231, 363, 377} 102 "TCP and UDP Source Port. Support for both exact and wildcard matching is required. Port ranges can optionally be used." -- please approve and merge -- I 've uploaded this version ... b51489715e4f26f01dddc9265e5d15d7bbeac114 e749ebb19f9c5681460aa4e39c3b51f0b6fbb4b4 draft-ietf-detnet-ip 25aebb40a81451ce0de73406fcce1226ae111f3a495618fa71e24313928b8dd1 ['b1f3b310f4dbed63f9f13a9c86ec9493d4fe1a42d8f889736e18c6a3ac41101e', '1c461fe81d5bcf71073032237c90a364fe0acc907c86f9c6b7bdd0239e4a6516', 'fdaf7b19e26a8f8943811671a6e8da3ec29bcf8fe9612e127a54c73037ab2f7b', '59f27c10d7da72693b21a980a2cf524398f9cf4dc009641ae9e9faa91f7d94f9', '4c7e714e12f70980245dffffd7d5f8029aca0c2c12808b318d9836dbce80995c', 'b59ef38bc775ad389228cfd39677b5392e681fe36a24fc75e441bed9fca21593', '1d0fbefb081c07437c994ac521c81a167d9d746ffb2d5dfd54e150761b4aa1df', '25aebb40a81451ce0de73406fcce1226ae111f3a495618fa71e24313928b8dd1', 'cc9e02cd6c86047ecb0eeaef6c605aa491126643903149ae2064b12d562356d9'] B "tcp and udp source port. support for both exact and wildcard matching is required. port ranges can optionally be used." {33: 1, 26: 1, 32: 1, 62: 1, 60: 3, 56: 2, 64: 2, 38: 2, 71: 2, 83: 3, 113: 2, 126: 3, 112: 2, 85: 3, 129: 3} {31: 1, 32: 1, 33: 1, 283: 1, 260: 3, 261: 2, 339: 3, 212: 2, 343: 3, 286: 4, 163: 3, 228: 2, 357: 2, 166: 3, 231: 2, 298: 2, 363: 3, 46: 3, 377: 2} {260, 261, 274, 283, 286, 31, 32, 33, 163, 166, 298, 46, 339, 212, 343, 228, 357, 231, 363, 377} 102 "TCP and UDP Destination Port. Support for both exact and wildcard matching is required. Port ranges can optionally be used." -- please approve and merge -- I 've uploaded this version ... b51489715e4f26f01dddc9265e5d15d7bbeac114 e749ebb19f9c5681460aa4e39c3b51f0b6fbb4b4 draft-ietf-detnet-ip fdaf7b19e26a8f8943811671a6e8da3ec29bcf8fe9612e127a54c73037ab2f7b ['b1f3b310f4dbed63f9f13a9c86ec9493d4fe1a42d8f889736e18c6a3ac41101e', '1c461fe81d5bcf71073032237c90a364fe0acc907c86f9c6b7bdd0239e4a6516', 'fdaf7b19e26a8f8943811671a6e8da3ec29bcf8fe9612e127a54c73037ab2f7b', '59f27c10d7da72693b21a980a2cf524398f9cf4dc009641ae9e9faa91f7d94f9', '4c7e714e12f70980245dffffd7d5f8029aca0c2c12808b318d9836dbce80995c', 'b59ef38bc775ad389228cfd39677b5392e681fe36a24fc75e441bed9fca21593', '1d0fbefb081c07437c994ac521c81a167d9d746ffb2d5dfd54e150761b4aa1df', '25aebb40a81451ce0de73406fcce1226ae111f3a495618fa71e24313928b8dd1', 'cc9e02cd6c86047ecb0eeaef6c605aa491126643903149ae2064b12d562356d9'] B "tcp and udp destination port. support for both exact and wildcard matching is required. port ranges can optionally be used." {33: 1, 26: 1, 32: 1, 62: 1, 60: 3, 56: 2, 64: 2, 38: 2, 71: 2, 83: 3, 113: 2, 126: 3, 112: 2, 85: 3, 129: 3} {31: 1, 32: 1, 33: 1, 283: 1, 260: 3, 261: 2, 339: 3, 212: 2, 343: 3, 286: 4, 163: 3, 228: 2, 357: 2, 166: 3, 231: 2, 298: 2, 363: 3, 46: 3, 377: 2} {260, 261, 274, 283, 286, 31, 32, 33, 163, 166, 298, 46, 339, 212, 343, 228, 357, 231, 363, 377} 102 "For end systems, an optional maximum IP packet size that should be used for that outgoing DetNet IP flow." -- please approve and merge -- I 've uploaded this version ... b51489715e4f26f01dddc9265e5d15d7bbeac114 e749ebb19f9c5681460aa4e39c3b51f0b6fbb4b4 draft-ietf-detnet-ip cc9e02cd6c86047ecb0eeaef6c605aa491126643903149ae2064b12d562356d9 ['b1f3b310f4dbed63f9f13a9c86ec9493d4fe1a42d8f889736e18c6a3ac41101e', '1c461fe81d5bcf71073032237c90a364fe0acc907c86f9c6b7bdd0239e4a6516', 'fdaf7b19e26a8f8943811671a6e8da3ec29bcf8fe9612e127a54c73037ab2f7b', '59f27c10d7da72693b21a980a2cf524398f9cf4dc009641ae9e9faa91f7d94f9', '4c7e714e12f70980245dffffd7d5f8029aca0c2c12808b318d9836dbce80995c', 'b59ef38bc775ad389228cfd39677b5392e681fe36a24fc75e441bed9fca21593', '1d0fbefb081c07437c994ac521c81a167d9d746ffb2d5dfd54e150761b4aa1df', '25aebb40a81451ce0de73406fcce1226ae111f3a495618fa71e24313928b8dd1', 'cc9e02cd6c86047ecb0eeaef6c605aa491126643903149ae2064b12d562356d9'] B "for end systems, an optional maximum ip packet size that should be used for that outgoing detnet ip flow." {33: 1, 26: 1, 32: 1, 62: 1, 60: 3, 56: 2, 64: 2, 38: 2, 71: 2, 83: 3, 113: 2, 126: 3, 112: 2, 85: 3, 129: 3} {31: 1, 32: 1, 33: 1, 283: 1, 260: 3, 261: 2, 339: 3, 212: 2, 343: 3, 286: 4, 163: 3, 228: 2, 357: 2, 166: 3, 231: 2, 298: 2, 363: 3, 46: 3, 377: 2} {260, 261, 274, 283, 286, 31, 32, 33, 163, 166, 298, 46, 339, 212, 343, 228, 357, 231, 363, 377} 102 "An implementation MUST support ordering of the set of information information used to identify an individual DetNet flow. This can, for example, be used to provide a DetNet service for a specific UDP flow, with unique Source and Destination Port field values, while providing a different service for the aggregate of all other flows with that same UDP Destination Port value." -- please approve and merge -- I 've uploaded this version ... b51489715e4f26f01dddc9265e5d15d7bbeac114 e749ebb19f9c5681460aa4e39c3b51f0b6fbb4b4 draft-ietf-detnet-ip 4c7e714e12f70980245dffffd7d5f8029aca0c2c12808b318d9836dbce80995c ['b1f3b310f4dbed63f9f13a9c86ec9493d4fe1a42d8f889736e18c6a3ac41101e', '1c461fe81d5bcf71073032237c90a364fe0acc907c86f9c6b7bdd0239e4a6516', 'fdaf7b19e26a8f8943811671a6e8da3ec29bcf8fe9612e127a54c73037ab2f7b', '59f27c10d7da72693b21a980a2cf524398f9cf4dc009641ae9e9faa91f7d94f9', '4c7e714e12f70980245dffffd7d5f8029aca0c2c12808b318d9836dbce80995c', 'b59ef38bc775ad389228cfd39677b5392e681fe36a24fc75e441bed9fca21593', '1d0fbefb081c07437c994ac521c81a167d9d746ffb2d5dfd54e150761b4aa1df', '25aebb40a81451ce0de73406fcce1226ae111f3a495618fa71e24313928b8dd1', 'cc9e02cd6c86047ecb0eeaef6c605aa491126643903149ae2064b12d562356d9'] B "an implementation must support ordering of the set of information information used to identify an individual detnet flow. this can, for example, be used to provide a detnet service for a specific udp flow, with unique source and destination port field values, while providing a different service for the aggregate of all other flows with that same udp destination port value." {33: 1, 26: 1, 32: 1, 62: 1, 60: 3, 56: 2, 64: 2, 38: 2, 71: 2, 83: 3, 113: 2, 126: 3, 112: 2, 85: 3, 129: 3} {31: 1, 32: 1, 33: 1, 283: 1, 260: 3, 261: 2, 339: 3, 212: 2, 343: 3, 286: 4, 163: 3, 228: 2, 357: 2, 166: 3, 231: 2, 298: 2, 363: 3, 46: 3, 377: 2} {260, 261, 274, 283, 286, 31, 32, 33, 163, 166, 298, 46, 339, 212, 343, 228, 357, 231, 363, 377} 102 "Security considerations for DetNet are described in detail in I- D.ietf-detnet-security. General security considerations are described in RFC8655. This section considers exclusively security considerations which are specific to the DetNet IP data plane." -- please approve and merge -- I 've uploaded this version ... b51489715e4f26f01dddc9265e5d15d7bbeac114 e749ebb19f9c5681460aa4e39c3b51f0b6fbb4b4 draft-ietf-detnet-ip af1c82a2e0ef80b87905c68c90063afbd27246ab50c8079777584bc93467514d ['af1c82a2e0ef80b87905c68c90063afbd27246ab50c8079777584bc93467514d', 'fa6534a2fea10c93739f34a3a3ebc956aa92d44a1990ef9c3f8c57af2882f9cd', 'b0b9dc4ce99cdc3d3e7bbf66fee0e6529e8889fca4483cb003034bb242dc2828', 'eb547f8c9c36b0996c65f740889b85778a420e2c66df1702b899dfbf731073b5', '6d1c378f6ab7bd6ae836d4ac295f0de5a2664c0064bd50ab47c1dde2a64665c8', '678c2a2f928e66c95cfc7fd485cdcb37780fb41818886e2dee62d41f38f88d6c'] A "security considerations for detnet are described in detail in i- d.ietf-detnet-security. general security considerations are described in rfc8655. this section considers exclusively security considerations which are specific to the detnet ip data plane." {67: 1, 115: 1, 110: 1, 15: 1, 36: 1, 24: 1, 114: 1, 90: 1, 13: 1, 6: 3, 79: 3, 51: 2, 130: 3, 62: 5, 85: 6, 68: 5, 35: 4, 91: 3, 97: 3, 31: 2, 38: 3, 26: 2, 124: 4, 98: 3, 54: 3, 127: 4, 8: 3, 96: 3, 64: 2, 30: 2, 61: 4, 55: 4, 27: 3, 52: 2, 129: 4, 84: 2, 76: 7, 87: 2, 131: 6, 113: 4, 102: 5, 99: 3, 53: 2, 72: 3} {152: 1, 169: 1, 172: 1, 352: 1, 353: 1, 354: 1, 365: 1, 402: 1, 315: 1, 1: 10, 4: 3, 9: 6, 10: 4, 15: 3, 24: 3, 25: 5, 26: 6, 27: 2, 39: 6, 43: 4, 49: 4, 50: 3, 58: 4, 59: 3, 64: 3, 69: 5, 81: 6, 82: 4, 86: 2, 96: 3, 97: 2, 100: 7, 108: 4, 109: 5, 110: 5, 111: 3, 114: 4, 115: 5, 116: 3, 118: 7, 119: 6, 120: 4, 121: 5, 122: 4, 123: 3, 124: 5, 128: 2, 129: 2, 130: 4, 132: 5, 136: 3, 145: 5, 147: 3, 151: 2, 154: 4, 156: 2, 161: 4, 162: 4, 165: 4, 168: 5, 180: 2, 184: 6, 187: 6, 188: 5, 191: 4, 194: 5, 202: 6, 203: 7, 206: 3, 207: 4, 215: 3, 217: 4, 218: 9, 220: 3, 221: 3, 222: 6, 224: 4, 227: 5, 229: 2, 234: 6, 235: 3, 241: 3, 242: 3, 243: 5, 244: 2, 245: 5, 248: 2, 250: 4, 258: 12, 262: 5, 263: 6, 264: 4, 267: 5, 270: 3, 273: 6, 287: 4, 289: 2, 291: 4, 299: 5, 300: 3, 304: 3, 309: 4, 314: 3, 320: 5, 323: 5, 327: 5, 328: 4, 329: 3, 330: 11, 334: 3, 335: 3, 341: 5, 342: 6, 347: 5, 348: 5, 350: 8, 351: 3, 358: 5, 366: 3, 369: 2, 371: 7, 372: 4, 376: 3, 384: 4, 385: 3, 386: 4, 387: 3, 392: 4, 393: 5, 396: 6, 397: 8, 398: 7} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 102 "Detailed security considerations for DetNet are cataloged in I- D.ietf-detnet-security, and more general security considerations are described in RFC8655. This section considers exclusively security considerations which are specific to the DetNet IP data plane." -- please approve and merge -- I 've uploaded this version ... b51489715e4f26f01dddc9265e5d15d7bbeac114 e749ebb19f9c5681460aa4e39c3b51f0b6fbb4b4 draft-ietf-detnet-ip b0b9dc4ce99cdc3d3e7bbf66fee0e6529e8889fca4483cb003034bb242dc2828 ['af1c82a2e0ef80b87905c68c90063afbd27246ab50c8079777584bc93467514d', 'fa6534a2fea10c93739f34a3a3ebc956aa92d44a1990ef9c3f8c57af2882f9cd', 'b0b9dc4ce99cdc3d3e7bbf66fee0e6529e8889fca4483cb003034bb242dc2828', 'eb547f8c9c36b0996c65f740889b85778a420e2c66df1702b899dfbf731073b5', '6d1c378f6ab7bd6ae836d4ac295f0de5a2664c0064bd50ab47c1dde2a64665c8', '678c2a2f928e66c95cfc7fd485cdcb37780fb41818886e2dee62d41f38f88d6c'] B "detailed security considerations for detnet are cataloged in i- d.ietf-detnet-security, and more general security considerations are described in rfc8655. this section considers exclusively security considerations which are specific to the detnet ip data plane." {67: 1, 115: 1, 110: 1, 15: 1, 36: 1, 24: 1, 114: 1, 90: 1, 13: 1, 6: 3, 79: 3, 51: 2, 130: 3, 62: 5, 85: 6, 68: 5, 35: 4, 91: 3, 97: 3, 31: 2, 38: 3, 26: 2, 124: 4, 98: 3, 54: 3, 127: 4, 8: 3, 96: 3, 64: 2, 30: 2, 61: 4, 55: 4, 27: 3, 52: 2, 129: 4, 84: 2, 76: 7, 87: 2, 131: 6, 113: 4, 102: 5, 99: 3, 53: 2, 72: 3} {152: 1, 169: 1, 172: 1, 352: 1, 353: 1, 354: 1, 365: 1, 402: 1, 315: 1, 1: 10, 4: 3, 9: 6, 10: 4, 15: 3, 24: 3, 25: 5, 26: 6, 27: 2, 39: 6, 43: 4, 49: 4, 50: 3, 58: 4, 59: 3, 64: 3, 69: 5, 81: 6, 82: 4, 86: 2, 96: 3, 97: 2, 100: 7, 108: 4, 109: 5, 110: 5, 111: 3, 114: 4, 115: 5, 116: 3, 118: 7, 119: 6, 120: 4, 121: 5, 122: 4, 123: 3, 124: 5, 128: 2, 129: 2, 130: 4, 132: 5, 136: 3, 145: 5, 147: 3, 151: 2, 154: 4, 156: 2, 161: 4, 162: 4, 165: 4, 168: 5, 180: 2, 184: 6, 187: 6, 188: 5, 191: 4, 194: 5, 202: 6, 203: 7, 206: 3, 207: 4, 215: 3, 217: 4, 218: 9, 220: 3, 221: 3, 222: 6, 224: 4, 227: 5, 229: 2, 234: 6, 235: 3, 241: 3, 242: 3, 243: 5, 244: 2, 245: 5, 248: 2, 250: 4, 258: 12, 262: 5, 263: 6, 264: 4, 267: 5, 270: 3, 273: 6, 287: 4, 289: 2, 291: 4, 299: 5, 300: 3, 304: 3, 309: 4, 314: 3, 320: 5, 323: 5, 327: 5, 328: 4, 329: 3, 330: 11, 334: 3, 335: 3, 341: 5, 342: 6, 347: 5, 348: 5, 350: 8, 351: 3, 358: 5, 366: 3, 369: 2, 371: 7, 372: 4, 376: 3, 384: 4, 385: 3, 386: 4, 387: 3, 392: 4, 393: 5, 396: 6, 397: 8, 398: 7} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 102 "Security aspects which are unique to DetNet are those whose aim is to provide the specific quality of service aspects of DetNet, which are primarily to deliver data flows with extremely low packet loss rates and bounded end-to-end delivery latency. Achieving such loss rates and bounded latency may not be possible in the face of a highly capable adversary, such as the one envisioned by the Internet Threat Model of BCP 72 that can arbitrarily drop or delay any or all traffic. In order to present meaningful security considerations, we consider a somewhat weaker attacker who does not control the physical links of the DetNet domain, but may have the ability to control a network node within the boundary of the DetNet domain." -- please approve and merge -- I 've uploaded this version ... b51489715e4f26f01dddc9265e5d15d7bbeac114 e749ebb19f9c5681460aa4e39c3b51f0b6fbb4b4 draft-ietf-detnet-ip eb547f8c9c36b0996c65f740889b85778a420e2c66df1702b899dfbf731073b5 ['af1c82a2e0ef80b87905c68c90063afbd27246ab50c8079777584bc93467514d', 'fa6534a2fea10c93739f34a3a3ebc956aa92d44a1990ef9c3f8c57af2882f9cd', 'b0b9dc4ce99cdc3d3e7bbf66fee0e6529e8889fca4483cb003034bb242dc2828', 'eb547f8c9c36b0996c65f740889b85778a420e2c66df1702b899dfbf731073b5', '6d1c378f6ab7bd6ae836d4ac295f0de5a2664c0064bd50ab47c1dde2a64665c8', '678c2a2f928e66c95cfc7fd485cdcb37780fb41818886e2dee62d41f38f88d6c'] B "security aspects which are unique to detnet are those whose aim is to provide the specific quality of service aspects of detnet, which are primarily to deliver data flows with extremely low packet loss rates and bounded end-to-end delivery latency. achieving such loss rates and bounded latency may not be possible in the face of a highly capable adversary, such as the one envisioned by the internet threat model of bcp 72 that can arbitrarily drop or delay any or all traffic. in order to present meaningful security considerations, we consider a somewhat weaker attacker who does not control the physical links of the detnet domain, but may have the ability to control a network node within the boundary of the detnet domain." {67: 1, 115: 1, 110: 1, 15: 1, 36: 1, 24: 1, 114: 1, 90: 1, 13: 1, 6: 3, 79: 3, 51: 2, 130: 3, 62: 5, 85: 6, 68: 5, 35: 4, 91: 3, 97: 3, 31: 2, 38: 3, 26: 2, 124: 4, 98: 3, 54: 3, 127: 4, 8: 3, 96: 3, 64: 2, 30: 2, 61: 4, 55: 4, 27: 3, 52: 2, 129: 4, 84: 2, 76: 7, 87: 2, 131: 6, 113: 4, 102: 5, 99: 3, 53: 2, 72: 3} {152: 1, 169: 1, 172: 1, 352: 1, 353: 1, 354: 1, 365: 1, 402: 1, 315: 1, 1: 10, 4: 3, 9: 6, 10: 4, 15: 3, 24: 3, 25: 5, 26: 6, 27: 2, 39: 6, 43: 4, 49: 4, 50: 3, 58: 4, 59: 3, 64: 3, 69: 5, 81: 6, 82: 4, 86: 2, 96: 3, 97: 2, 100: 7, 108: 4, 109: 5, 110: 5, 111: 3, 114: 4, 115: 5, 116: 3, 118: 7, 119: 6, 120: 4, 121: 5, 122: 4, 123: 3, 124: 5, 128: 2, 129: 2, 130: 4, 132: 5, 136: 3, 145: 5, 147: 3, 151: 2, 154: 4, 156: 2, 161: 4, 162: 4, 165: 4, 168: 5, 180: 2, 184: 6, 187: 6, 188: 5, 191: 4, 194: 5, 202: 6, 203: 7, 206: 3, 207: 4, 215: 3, 217: 4, 218: 9, 220: 3, 221: 3, 222: 6, 224: 4, 227: 5, 229: 2, 234: 6, 235: 3, 241: 3, 242: 3, 243: 5, 244: 2, 245: 5, 248: 2, 250: 4, 258: 12, 262: 5, 263: 6, 264: 4, 267: 5, 270: 3, 273: 6, 287: 4, 289: 2, 291: 4, 299: 5, 300: 3, 304: 3, 309: 4, 314: 3, 320: 5, 323: 5, 327: 5, 328: 4, 329: 3, 330: 11, 334: 3, 335: 3, 341: 5, 342: 6, 347: 5, 348: 5, 350: 8, 351: 3, 358: 5, 366: 3, 369: 2, 371: 7, 372: 4, 376: 3, 384: 4, 385: 3, 386: 4, 387: 3, 392: 4, 393: 5, 396: 6, 397: 8, 398: 7} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 102 "The primary consideration for the DetNet data plane is to maintain integrity of data and delivery of the associated DetNet service traversing the DetNet network. Since no DetNet-specific fields are available in the DetNet IP data plane, the integrity and confidentiality of application flows can be protected through whatever means are provided by the underlying technology. For example, encryption may be used, such as that provided by IPSec RFC4301 for IP flows and/or by an underlying sub-net using MACSec IEEE802.1AE-2018 for IP over Ethernet (Layer-2) flows." -- please approve and merge -- I 've uploaded this version ... b51489715e4f26f01dddc9265e5d15d7bbeac114 e749ebb19f9c5681460aa4e39c3b51f0b6fbb4b4 draft-ietf-detnet-ip 678c2a2f928e66c95cfc7fd485cdcb37780fb41818886e2dee62d41f38f88d6c ['af1c82a2e0ef80b87905c68c90063afbd27246ab50c8079777584bc93467514d', 'fa6534a2fea10c93739f34a3a3ebc956aa92d44a1990ef9c3f8c57af2882f9cd', 'b0b9dc4ce99cdc3d3e7bbf66fee0e6529e8889fca4483cb003034bb242dc2828', 'eb547f8c9c36b0996c65f740889b85778a420e2c66df1702b899dfbf731073b5', '6d1c378f6ab7bd6ae836d4ac295f0de5a2664c0064bd50ab47c1dde2a64665c8', '678c2a2f928e66c95cfc7fd485cdcb37780fb41818886e2dee62d41f38f88d6c'] B "the primary consideration for the detnet data plane is to maintain integrity of data and delivery of the associated detnet service traversing the detnet network. since no detnet-specific fields are available in the detnet ip data plane, the integrity and confidentiality of application flows can be protected through whatever means are provided by the underlying technology. for example, encryption may be used, such as that provided by ipsec rfc4301 for ip flows and/or by an underlying sub-net using macsec ieee802.1ae-2018 for ip over ethernet (layer-2) flows." {67: 1, 115: 1, 110: 1, 15: 1, 36: 1, 24: 1, 114: 1, 90: 1, 13: 1, 6: 3, 79: 3, 51: 2, 130: 3, 62: 5, 85: 6, 68: 5, 35: 4, 91: 3, 97: 3, 31: 2, 38: 3, 26: 2, 124: 4, 98: 3, 54: 3, 127: 4, 8: 3, 96: 3, 64: 2, 30: 2, 61: 4, 55: 4, 27: 3, 52: 2, 129: 4, 84: 2, 76: 7, 87: 2, 131: 6, 113: 4, 102: 5, 99: 3, 53: 2, 72: 3} {152: 1, 169: 1, 172: 1, 352: 1, 353: 1, 354: 1, 365: 1, 402: 1, 315: 1, 1: 10, 4: 3, 9: 6, 10: 4, 15: 3, 24: 3, 25: 5, 26: 6, 27: 2, 39: 6, 43: 4, 49: 4, 50: 3, 58: 4, 59: 3, 64: 3, 69: 5, 81: 6, 82: 4, 86: 2, 96: 3, 97: 2, 100: 7, 108: 4, 109: 5, 110: 5, 111: 3, 114: 4, 115: 5, 116: 3, 118: 7, 119: 6, 120: 4, 121: 5, 122: 4, 123: 3, 124: 5, 128: 2, 129: 2, 130: 4, 132: 5, 136: 3, 145: 5, 147: 3, 151: 2, 154: 4, 156: 2, 161: 4, 162: 4, 165: 4, 168: 5, 180: 2, 184: 6, 187: 6, 188: 5, 191: 4, 194: 5, 202: 6, 203: 7, 206: 3, 207: 4, 215: 3, 217: 4, 218: 9, 220: 3, 221: 3, 222: 6, 224: 4, 227: 5, 229: 2, 234: 6, 235: 3, 241: 3, 242: 3, 243: 5, 244: 2, 245: 5, 248: 2, 250: 4, 258: 12, 262: 5, 263: 6, 264: 4, 267: 5, 270: 3, 273: 6, 287: 4, 289: 2, 291: 4, 299: 5, 300: 3, 304: 3, 309: 4, 314: 3, 320: 5, 323: 5, 327: 5, 328: 4, 329: 3, 330: 11, 334: 3, 335: 3, 341: 5, 342: 6, 347: 5, 348: 5, 350: 8, 351: 3, 358: 5, 366: 3, 369: 2, 371: 7, 372: 4, 376: 3, 384: 4, 385: 3, 386: 4, 387: 3, 392: 4, 393: 5, 396: 6, 397: 8, 398: 7} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 102 "To provide uninterrupted availability of the DetNet service, provisions can be made against DOS attacks and delay attacks. To protect against DOS attacks, excess traffic due to malicious or malfunctioning devices can be prevented or mitigated, for example through the use of existing mechanism such as policing and shaping applied at the input of a DetNet domain or within an edge IEEE802.1 TSN domain. To prevent DetNet packets from being delayed by an entity external to a DetNet domain, DetNet technology definition can allow for the mitigation of Man-In-The-Middle attacks, for example through use of authentication and authorization of devices within the DetNet domain." -- please approve and merge -- I 've uploaded this version ... b51489715e4f26f01dddc9265e5d15d7bbeac114 e749ebb19f9c5681460aa4e39c3b51f0b6fbb4b4 draft-ietf-detnet-ip b877311d9cc7964b1f462f68479f9bde0a353f10bb8ee4294a5ce1cb4557e9d6 ['9660729dcccf51d5b146b7b549f874e0feac220bda1c96d69e1fcfab2efbb95f', 'b877311d9cc7964b1f462f68479f9bde0a353f10bb8ee4294a5ce1cb4557e9d6'] B "to provide uninterrupted availability of the detnet service, provisions can be made against dos attacks and delay attacks. to protect against dos attacks, excess traffic due to malicious or malfunctioning devices can be prevented or mitigated, for example through the use of existing mechanism such as policing and shaping applied at the input of a detnet domain or within an edge ieee802.1 tsn domain. to prevent detnet packets from being delayed by an entity external to a detnet domain, detnet technology definition can allow for the mitigation of man-in-the-middle attacks, for example through use of authentication and authorization of devices within the detnet domain." {} {} {} 99 "A node operating on a DetNet flow in the Detnet service sub- layer,uses the local context associated with that S-Label, provided by a received F-Label, to determine what local DetNet operation(s) are applied to that packet. An S-Label may be taken from the platform label space RFC3031, making it unique, enabling DetNet flow identification regardless of which input interface or LSP the packet arrives on." "Thanks for 's fine tuning . cam you review and merge if you 're good with the changes ." 6a9a07579e1ab7324d635b60bfd9276328dcfb47 6a9a07579e1ab7324d635b60bfd9276328dcfb47 draft-ietf-detnet-mpls 900b331df2dbeaa553b4ff60bb9626da70b4a60819e68532848cc18dfaa15c94 ['900b331df2dbeaa553b4ff60bb9626da70b4a60819e68532848cc18dfaa15c94', 'bee7933d599484f0c27fa55f363a6583c651574e6099f307c7afebe460156374'] A "a node operating on a detnet flow in the detnet service sub- layer,uses the local context associated with that s-label, provided by a received f-label, to determine what local detnet operation(s) are applied to that packet. an s-label may be taken from the platform label space rfc3031, making it unique, enabling detnet flow identification regardless of which input interface or lsp the packet arrives on." {} {} {} 99 "A node operating on a DetNet flow in the Detnet service sub-layer, uses the local context associated with that S-Label, provided by a received F-Label, to determine what local DetNet operation(s) are applied to that packet. An S-Label may be taken from the platform label space RFC3031, making it unique, enabling DetNet flow identification regardless of which input interface or LSP the packet arrives on." "Thanks for 's fine tuning . cam you review and merge if you 're good with the changes ." 6a9a07579e1ab7324d635b60bfd9276328dcfb47 6a9a07579e1ab7324d635b60bfd9276328dcfb47 draft-ietf-detnet-mpls bee7933d599484f0c27fa55f363a6583c651574e6099f307c7afebe460156374 ['900b331df2dbeaa553b4ff60bb9626da70b4a60819e68532848cc18dfaa15c94', 'bee7933d599484f0c27fa55f363a6583c651574e6099f307c7afebe460156374'] B "a node operating on a detnet flow in the detnet service sub-layer, uses the local context associated with that s-label, provided by a received f-label, to determine what local detnet operation(s) are applied to that packet. an s-label may be taken from the platform label space rfc3031, making it unique, enabling detnet flow identification regardless of which input interface or lsp the packet arrives on." {} {} {} 99 "The DetNet-aware forwarder selects the egress DetNet member flow segment based on the flow identification. The mapping of ingress DetNet member flow segment to egress DetNet member flow segment may be statically or dynamically configured. Additionally the DetNet- aware forwarder does duplicate frame elimination based on the flow identification and the sequence number combination. The packet replication is also done within the DetNet-aware forwarder. During elimination and the replication process the sequence number of the DetNet member flow MUST be preserved and copied to the egress DetNet member flow." "Thanks for 's fine tuning . cam you review and merge if you 're good with the changes ." 6a9a07579e1ab7324d635b60bfd9276328dcfb47 6a9a07579e1ab7324d635b60bfd9276328dcfb47 draft-ietf-detnet-mpls 09732023af932d8c578c8a7ead49feb80cdb5c629cee6add2e24fcd7999c0309 ['d214eb97a9afefbf83b751181186edfe7db0d380c6fe58f68a461e993787e53e', 'f6a8cfceb19b4cd796512223b8afd103c4aee7052247ebea8b50f743e9aa27b6', '5fb32827bc18a11173c526c6808a3244b1c4a63c59fc347d6a591ed7307f6b06', '09732023af932d8c578c8a7ead49feb80cdb5c629cee6add2e24fcd7999c0309', 'caeedc5fb097519e9c8aafd6d55302f119ca808b0b628387a6532d6fcc696b5b', '405f0ab79f6f7784024dd1bcc58ce2b1fde69e50af21a74f4ef96ac7f9552a69', 'f892089efdfaf264bbd88429161309e178a30e7cfb68ab63c77d748fa8e54546', '200fc77171ce0224e61968428de9b5cf36ae83b94a6c11a8e8d67ae042f2922e'] A "the detnet-aware forwarder selects the egress detnet member flow segment based on the flow identification. the mapping of ingress detnet member flow segment to egress detnet member flow segment may be statically or dynamically configured. additionally the detnet- aware forwarder does duplicate frame elimination based on the flow identification and the sequence number combination. the packet replication is also done within the detnet-aware forwarder. during elimination and the replication process the sequence number of the detnet member flow must be preserved and copied to the egress detnet member flow." {35: 1, 53: 1, 6: 2, 79: 2, 90: 3, 51: 3, 130: 2, 62: 5, 85: 5, 68: 4, 110: 3, 91: 5, 114: 3, 97: 3, 31: 3, 13: 3, 67: 3, 38: 4, 26: 3, 124: 3, 98: 2, 54: 2, 127: 3, 8: 2, 96: 3, 64: 2, 30: 4, 61: 5, 55: 3, 27: 4, 15: 3, 52: 2, 129: 3, 115: 3, 84: 3, 76: 6, 87: 3, 131: 5, 102: 3, 113: 5, 36: 3, 24: 2, 72: 4} {43: 1, 369: 1, 1: 9, 4: 2, 9: 5, 10: 3, 15: 3, 24: 2, 25: 5, 26: 5, 27: 3, 39: 5, 49: 6, 50: 5, 58: 5, 59: 2, 64: 3, 69: 4, 81: 6, 82: 4, 86: 3, 96: 4, 97: 3, 100: 7, 108: 3, 109: 4, 110: 4, 111: 2, 114: 3, 115: 4, 116: 3, 118: 6, 119: 5, 120: 3, 121: 4, 122: 4, 123: 3, 124: 4, 128: 4, 129: 4, 130: 5, 132: 4, 136: 2, 145: 4, 147: 4, 151: 4, 152: 4, 154: 3, 156: 2, 161: 3, 162: 3, 165: 3, 168: 4, 169: 3, 172: 3, 180: 4, 184: 5, 187: 5, 188: 4, 191: 3, 194: 4, 202: 5, 203: 6, 206: 2, 207: 3, 215: 2, 217: 3, 218: 8, 220: 2, 221: 2, 222: 5, 224: 3, 227: 5, 229: 3, 234: 5, 235: 2, 241: 2, 242: 2, 243: 4, 244: 4, 245: 4, 248: 4, 250: 4, 258: 11, 262: 4, 263: 5, 264: 3, 267: 4, 270: 3, 272: 3, 273: 5, 287: 3, 289: 3, 291: 5, 299: 5, 300: 3, 304: 3, 309: 3, 314: 2, 315: 3, 320: 4, 323: 4, 327: 4, 328: 3, 329: 2, 330: 10, 335: 3, 341: 5, 342: 6, 347: 5, 348: 5, 350: 7, 351: 5, 352: 3, 353: 3, 354: 2, 358: 4, 365: 3, 366: 2, 371: 7, 372: 5, 376: 2, 384: 5, 385: 4, 386: 3, 387: 3, 392: 3, 393: 4, 396: 6, 397: 7, 398: 6, 402: 3} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 99 "The internal design of a relay node is out of scope of this document. However the reader's attention is drawn to the need to make any PREOF state available to the packet processor(s) dealing with packets to which the PREOF functions must be applied, and to maintain that state is such as way that it is available to the packet processor operation on the next packet in the DetNet flow (which may be a duplicate, a late packet, or the next packet in sequence." "Thanks for 's fine tuning . cam you review and merge if you 're good with the changes ." 6a9a07579e1ab7324d635b60bfd9276328dcfb47 6a9a07579e1ab7324d635b60bfd9276328dcfb47 draft-ietf-detnet-mpls f6a8cfceb19b4cd796512223b8afd103c4aee7052247ebea8b50f743e9aa27b6 ['d214eb97a9afefbf83b751181186edfe7db0d380c6fe58f68a461e993787e53e', 'f6a8cfceb19b4cd796512223b8afd103c4aee7052247ebea8b50f743e9aa27b6', '5fb32827bc18a11173c526c6808a3244b1c4a63c59fc347d6a591ed7307f6b06', '09732023af932d8c578c8a7ead49feb80cdb5c629cee6add2e24fcd7999c0309', 'caeedc5fb097519e9c8aafd6d55302f119ca808b0b628387a6532d6fcc696b5b', '405f0ab79f6f7784024dd1bcc58ce2b1fde69e50af21a74f4ef96ac7f9552a69', 'f892089efdfaf264bbd88429161309e178a30e7cfb68ab63c77d748fa8e54546', '200fc77171ce0224e61968428de9b5cf36ae83b94a6c11a8e8d67ae042f2922e'] A "the internal design of a relay node is out of scope of this document. however the reader's attention is drawn to the need to make any preof state available to the packet processor(s) dealing with packets to which the preof functions must be applied, and to maintain that state is such as way that it is available to the packet processor operation on the next packet in the detnet flow (which may be a duplicate, a late packet, or the next packet in sequence." {35: 1, 53: 1, 6: 2, 79: 2, 90: 3, 51: 3, 130: 2, 62: 5, 85: 5, 68: 4, 110: 3, 91: 5, 114: 3, 97: 3, 31: 3, 13: 3, 67: 3, 38: 4, 26: 3, 124: 3, 98: 2, 54: 2, 127: 3, 8: 2, 96: 3, 64: 2, 30: 4, 61: 5, 55: 3, 27: 4, 15: 3, 52: 2, 129: 3, 115: 3, 84: 3, 76: 6, 87: 3, 131: 5, 102: 3, 113: 5, 36: 3, 24: 2, 72: 4} {43: 1, 369: 1, 1: 9, 4: 2, 9: 5, 10: 3, 15: 3, 24: 2, 25: 5, 26: 5, 27: 3, 39: 5, 49: 6, 50: 5, 58: 5, 59: 2, 64: 3, 69: 4, 81: 6, 82: 4, 86: 3, 96: 4, 97: 3, 100: 7, 108: 3, 109: 4, 110: 4, 111: 2, 114: 3, 115: 4, 116: 3, 118: 6, 119: 5, 120: 3, 121: 4, 122: 4, 123: 3, 124: 4, 128: 4, 129: 4, 130: 5, 132: 4, 136: 2, 145: 4, 147: 4, 151: 4, 152: 4, 154: 3, 156: 2, 161: 3, 162: 3, 165: 3, 168: 4, 169: 3, 172: 3, 180: 4, 184: 5, 187: 5, 188: 4, 191: 3, 194: 4, 202: 5, 203: 6, 206: 2, 207: 3, 215: 2, 217: 3, 218: 8, 220: 2, 221: 2, 222: 5, 224: 3, 227: 5, 229: 3, 234: 5, 235: 2, 241: 2, 242: 2, 243: 4, 244: 4, 245: 4, 248: 4, 250: 4, 258: 11, 262: 4, 263: 5, 264: 3, 267: 4, 270: 3, 272: 3, 273: 5, 287: 3, 289: 3, 291: 5, 299: 5, 300: 3, 304: 3, 309: 3, 314: 2, 315: 3, 320: 4, 323: 4, 327: 4, 328: 3, 329: 2, 330: 10, 335: 3, 341: 5, 342: 6, 347: 5, 348: 5, 350: 7, 351: 5, 352: 3, 353: 3, 354: 2, 358: 4, 365: 3, 366: 2, 371: 7, 372: 5, 376: 2, 384: 5, 385: 4, 386: 3, 387: 3, 392: 3, 393: 4, 396: 6, 397: 7, 398: 6, 402: 3} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 99 "A DetNet Relay node operates in the DetNet forwarding sub-layer . For DetNet using MPLS this processing is performed on the F-Label. This processing is done within an extended forwarder function. Whether an ingress DetNet member flow receives DetNet specific processing depends on how the forwarding is programmed. Some relay nodes may be DetNet service aware, while others may be unmodified LSRs that only understand how to switch MPLS-TE LSPs." "Thanks for 's fine tuning . cam you review and merge if you 're good with the changes ." 6a9a07579e1ab7324d635b60bfd9276328dcfb47 6a9a07579e1ab7324d635b60bfd9276328dcfb47 draft-ietf-detnet-mpls 200fc77171ce0224e61968428de9b5cf36ae83b94a6c11a8e8d67ae042f2922e ['d214eb97a9afefbf83b751181186edfe7db0d380c6fe58f68a461e993787e53e', 'f6a8cfceb19b4cd796512223b8afd103c4aee7052247ebea8b50f743e9aa27b6', '5fb32827bc18a11173c526c6808a3244b1c4a63c59fc347d6a591ed7307f6b06', '09732023af932d8c578c8a7ead49feb80cdb5c629cee6add2e24fcd7999c0309', 'caeedc5fb097519e9c8aafd6d55302f119ca808b0b628387a6532d6fcc696b5b', '405f0ab79f6f7784024dd1bcc58ce2b1fde69e50af21a74f4ef96ac7f9552a69', 'f892089efdfaf264bbd88429161309e178a30e7cfb68ab63c77d748fa8e54546', '200fc77171ce0224e61968428de9b5cf36ae83b94a6c11a8e8d67ae042f2922e'] A "a detnet relay node operates in the detnet forwarding sub-layer . for detnet using mpls this processing is performed on the f-label. this processing is done within an extended forwarder function. whether an ingress detnet member flow receives detnet specific processing depends on how the forwarding is programmed. some relay nodes may be detnet service aware, while others may be unmodified lsrs that only understand how to switch mpls-te lsps." {35: 1, 53: 1, 6: 2, 79: 2, 90: 3, 51: 3, 130: 2, 62: 5, 85: 5, 68: 4, 110: 3, 91: 5, 114: 3, 97: 3, 31: 3, 13: 3, 67: 3, 38: 4, 26: 3, 124: 3, 98: 2, 54: 2, 127: 3, 8: 2, 96: 3, 64: 2, 30: 4, 61: 5, 55: 3, 27: 4, 15: 3, 52: 2, 129: 3, 115: 3, 84: 3, 76: 6, 87: 3, 131: 5, 102: 3, 113: 5, 36: 3, 24: 2, 72: 4} {43: 1, 369: 1, 1: 9, 4: 2, 9: 5, 10: 3, 15: 3, 24: 2, 25: 5, 26: 5, 27: 3, 39: 5, 49: 6, 50: 5, 58: 5, 59: 2, 64: 3, 69: 4, 81: 6, 82: 4, 86: 3, 96: 4, 97: 3, 100: 7, 108: 3, 109: 4, 110: 4, 111: 2, 114: 3, 115: 4, 116: 3, 118: 6, 119: 5, 120: 3, 121: 4, 122: 4, 123: 3, 124: 4, 128: 4, 129: 4, 130: 5, 132: 4, 136: 2, 145: 4, 147: 4, 151: 4, 152: 4, 154: 3, 156: 2, 161: 3, 162: 3, 165: 3, 168: 4, 169: 3, 172: 3, 180: 4, 184: 5, 187: 5, 188: 4, 191: 3, 194: 4, 202: 5, 203: 6, 206: 2, 207: 3, 215: 2, 217: 3, 218: 8, 220: 2, 221: 2, 222: 5, 224: 3, 227: 5, 229: 3, 234: 5, 235: 2, 241: 2, 242: 2, 243: 4, 244: 4, 245: 4, 248: 4, 250: 4, 258: 11, 262: 4, 263: 5, 264: 3, 267: 4, 270: 3, 272: 3, 273: 5, 287: 3, 289: 3, 291: 5, 299: 5, 300: 3, 304: 3, 309: 3, 314: 2, 315: 3, 320: 4, 323: 4, 327: 4, 328: 3, 329: 2, 330: 10, 335: 3, 341: 5, 342: 6, 347: 5, 348: 5, 350: 7, 351: 5, 352: 3, 353: 3, 354: 2, 358: 4, 365: 3, 366: 2, 371: 7, 372: 5, 376: 2, 384: 5, 385: 4, 386: 3, 387: 3, 392: 3, 393: 4, 396: 6, 397: 7, 398: 6, 402: 3} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 99 "It is also possible to treat the relay node as a transit node, see FAG. Again, this is entirely up to how the forwarding has been programmed." "Thanks for 's fine tuning . cam you review and merge if you 're good with the changes ." 6a9a07579e1ab7324d635b60bfd9276328dcfb47 6a9a07579e1ab7324d635b60bfd9276328dcfb47 draft-ietf-detnet-mpls caeedc5fb097519e9c8aafd6d55302f119ca808b0b628387a6532d6fcc696b5b ['d214eb97a9afefbf83b751181186edfe7db0d380c6fe58f68a461e993787e53e', 'f6a8cfceb19b4cd796512223b8afd103c4aee7052247ebea8b50f743e9aa27b6', '5fb32827bc18a11173c526c6808a3244b1c4a63c59fc347d6a591ed7307f6b06', '09732023af932d8c578c8a7ead49feb80cdb5c629cee6add2e24fcd7999c0309', 'caeedc5fb097519e9c8aafd6d55302f119ca808b0b628387a6532d6fcc696b5b', '405f0ab79f6f7784024dd1bcc58ce2b1fde69e50af21a74f4ef96ac7f9552a69', 'f892089efdfaf264bbd88429161309e178a30e7cfb68ab63c77d748fa8e54546', '200fc77171ce0224e61968428de9b5cf36ae83b94a6c11a8e8d67ae042f2922e'] A "it is also possible to treat the relay node as a transit node, see fag. again, this is entirely up to how the forwarding has been programmed." {35: 1, 53: 1, 6: 2, 79: 2, 90: 3, 51: 3, 130: 2, 62: 5, 85: 5, 68: 4, 110: 3, 91: 5, 114: 3, 97: 3, 31: 3, 13: 3, 67: 3, 38: 4, 26: 3, 124: 3, 98: 2, 54: 2, 127: 3, 8: 2, 96: 3, 64: 2, 30: 4, 61: 5, 55: 3, 27: 4, 15: 3, 52: 2, 129: 3, 115: 3, 84: 3, 76: 6, 87: 3, 131: 5, 102: 3, 113: 5, 36: 3, 24: 2, 72: 4} {43: 1, 369: 1, 1: 9, 4: 2, 9: 5, 10: 3, 15: 3, 24: 2, 25: 5, 26: 5, 27: 3, 39: 5, 49: 6, 50: 5, 58: 5, 59: 2, 64: 3, 69: 4, 81: 6, 82: 4, 86: 3, 96: 4, 97: 3, 100: 7, 108: 3, 109: 4, 110: 4, 111: 2, 114: 3, 115: 4, 116: 3, 118: 6, 119: 5, 120: 3, 121: 4, 122: 4, 123: 3, 124: 4, 128: 4, 129: 4, 130: 5, 132: 4, 136: 2, 145: 4, 147: 4, 151: 4, 152: 4, 154: 3, 156: 2, 161: 3, 162: 3, 165: 3, 168: 4, 169: 3, 172: 3, 180: 4, 184: 5, 187: 5, 188: 4, 191: 3, 194: 4, 202: 5, 203: 6, 206: 2, 207: 3, 215: 2, 217: 3, 218: 8, 220: 2, 221: 2, 222: 5, 224: 3, 227: 5, 229: 3, 234: 5, 235: 2, 241: 2, 242: 2, 243: 4, 244: 4, 245: 4, 248: 4, 250: 4, 258: 11, 262: 4, 263: 5, 264: 3, 267: 4, 270: 3, 272: 3, 273: 5, 287: 3, 289: 3, 291: 5, 299: 5, 300: 3, 304: 3, 309: 3, 314: 2, 315: 3, 320: 4, 323: 4, 327: 4, 328: 3, 329: 2, 330: 10, 335: 3, 341: 5, 342: 6, 347: 5, 348: 5, 350: 7, 351: 5, 352: 3, 353: 3, 354: 2, 358: 4, 365: 3, 366: 2, 371: 7, 372: 5, 376: 2, 384: 5, 385: 4, 386: 3, 387: 3, 392: 3, 393: 4, 396: 6, 397: 7, 398: 6, 402: 3} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 99 "The DetNet-aware forwarder selects the egress DetNet member flow segment based on the flow identification. The mapping of ingress DetNet member flow segment to egress DetNet member flow segment may be statically or dynamically configured. Additionally the DetNet- aware forwarder does duplicate frame elimination based on the flow identification and the sequence number combination. The packet replication is also done within the DetNet-aware forwarder." "Thanks for 's fine tuning . cam you review and merge if you 're good with the changes ." 6a9a07579e1ab7324d635b60bfd9276328dcfb47 6a9a07579e1ab7324d635b60bfd9276328dcfb47 draft-ietf-detnet-mpls 405f0ab79f6f7784024dd1bcc58ce2b1fde69e50af21a74f4ef96ac7f9552a69 ['d214eb97a9afefbf83b751181186edfe7db0d380c6fe58f68a461e993787e53e', 'f6a8cfceb19b4cd796512223b8afd103c4aee7052247ebea8b50f743e9aa27b6', '5fb32827bc18a11173c526c6808a3244b1c4a63c59fc347d6a591ed7307f6b06', '09732023af932d8c578c8a7ead49feb80cdb5c629cee6add2e24fcd7999c0309', 'caeedc5fb097519e9c8aafd6d55302f119ca808b0b628387a6532d6fcc696b5b', '405f0ab79f6f7784024dd1bcc58ce2b1fde69e50af21a74f4ef96ac7f9552a69', 'f892089efdfaf264bbd88429161309e178a30e7cfb68ab63c77d748fa8e54546', '200fc77171ce0224e61968428de9b5cf36ae83b94a6c11a8e8d67ae042f2922e'] B "the detnet-aware forwarder selects the egress detnet member flow segment based on the flow identification. the mapping of ingress detnet member flow segment to egress detnet member flow segment may be statically or dynamically configured. additionally the detnet- aware forwarder does duplicate frame elimination based on the flow identification and the sequence number combination. the packet replication is also done within the detnet-aware forwarder." {35: 1, 53: 1, 6: 2, 79: 2, 90: 3, 51: 3, 130: 2, 62: 5, 85: 5, 68: 4, 110: 3, 91: 5, 114: 3, 97: 3, 31: 3, 13: 3, 67: 3, 38: 4, 26: 3, 124: 3, 98: 2, 54: 2, 127: 3, 8: 2, 96: 3, 64: 2, 30: 4, 61: 5, 55: 3, 27: 4, 15: 3, 52: 2, 129: 3, 115: 3, 84: 3, 76: 6, 87: 3, 131: 5, 102: 3, 113: 5, 36: 3, 24: 2, 72: 4} {43: 1, 369: 1, 1: 9, 4: 2, 9: 5, 10: 3, 15: 3, 24: 2, 25: 5, 26: 5, 27: 3, 39: 5, 49: 6, 50: 5, 58: 5, 59: 2, 64: 3, 69: 4, 81: 6, 82: 4, 86: 3, 96: 4, 97: 3, 100: 7, 108: 3, 109: 4, 110: 4, 111: 2, 114: 3, 115: 4, 116: 3, 118: 6, 119: 5, 120: 3, 121: 4, 122: 4, 123: 3, 124: 4, 128: 4, 129: 4, 130: 5, 132: 4, 136: 2, 145: 4, 147: 4, 151: 4, 152: 4, 154: 3, 156: 2, 161: 3, 162: 3, 165: 3, 168: 4, 169: 3, 172: 3, 180: 4, 184: 5, 187: 5, 188: 4, 191: 3, 194: 4, 202: 5, 203: 6, 206: 2, 207: 3, 215: 2, 217: 3, 218: 8, 220: 2, 221: 2, 222: 5, 224: 3, 227: 5, 229: 3, 234: 5, 235: 2, 241: 2, 242: 2, 243: 4, 244: 4, 245: 4, 248: 4, 250: 4, 258: 11, 262: 4, 263: 5, 264: 3, 267: 4, 270: 3, 272: 3, 273: 5, 287: 3, 289: 3, 291: 5, 299: 5, 300: 3, 304: 3, 309: 3, 314: 2, 315: 3, 320: 4, 323: 4, 327: 4, 328: 3, 329: 2, 330: 10, 335: 3, 341: 5, 342: 6, 347: 5, 348: 5, 350: 7, 351: 5, 352: 3, 353: 3, 354: 2, 358: 4, 365: 3, 366: 2, 371: 7, 372: 5, 376: 2, 384: 5, 385: 4, 386: 3, 387: 3, 392: 3, 393: 4, 396: 6, 397: 7, 398: 6, 402: 3} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 99 "A DetNet Relay node operates in the DetNet forwarding sub-layer and service sub-layer. For DetNet using MPLS forwarding related processing is performed on the F-Label. This processing is done within an extended forwarder function. Whether an ingress DetNet member flow receives DetNet specific processing depends on how the forwarding is programmed. Some relay nodes may be DetNet service aware for certain DetNet services, while for other DetNet services these nodes may perform as unmodified LSRs that only understand how to switch MPLS-TE LSPs, i.e., as a transit nodes, see FAG. Again, this is entirely up to how the forwarding has been programmed." "Thanks for 's fine tuning . cam you review and merge if you 're good with the changes ." 6a9a07579e1ab7324d635b60bfd9276328dcfb47 6a9a07579e1ab7324d635b60bfd9276328dcfb47 draft-ietf-detnet-mpls 5fb32827bc18a11173c526c6808a3244b1c4a63c59fc347d6a591ed7307f6b06 ['d214eb97a9afefbf83b751181186edfe7db0d380c6fe58f68a461e993787e53e', 'f6a8cfceb19b4cd796512223b8afd103c4aee7052247ebea8b50f743e9aa27b6', '5fb32827bc18a11173c526c6808a3244b1c4a63c59fc347d6a591ed7307f6b06', '09732023af932d8c578c8a7ead49feb80cdb5c629cee6add2e24fcd7999c0309', 'caeedc5fb097519e9c8aafd6d55302f119ca808b0b628387a6532d6fcc696b5b', '405f0ab79f6f7784024dd1bcc58ce2b1fde69e50af21a74f4ef96ac7f9552a69', 'f892089efdfaf264bbd88429161309e178a30e7cfb68ab63c77d748fa8e54546', '200fc77171ce0224e61968428de9b5cf36ae83b94a6c11a8e8d67ae042f2922e'] B "a detnet relay node operates in the detnet forwarding sub-layer and service sub-layer. for detnet using mpls forwarding related processing is performed on the f-label. this processing is done within an extended forwarder function. whether an ingress detnet member flow receives detnet specific processing depends on how the forwarding is programmed. some relay nodes may be detnet service aware for certain detnet services, while for other detnet services these nodes may perform as unmodified lsrs that only understand how to switch mpls-te lsps, i.e., as a transit nodes, see fag. again, this is entirely up to how the forwarding has been programmed." {35: 1, 53: 1, 6: 2, 79: 2, 90: 3, 51: 3, 130: 2, 62: 5, 85: 5, 68: 4, 110: 3, 91: 5, 114: 3, 97: 3, 31: 3, 13: 3, 67: 3, 38: 4, 26: 3, 124: 3, 98: 2, 54: 2, 127: 3, 8: 2, 96: 3, 64: 2, 30: 4, 61: 5, 55: 3, 27: 4, 15: 3, 52: 2, 129: 3, 115: 3, 84: 3, 76: 6, 87: 3, 131: 5, 102: 3, 113: 5, 36: 3, 24: 2, 72: 4} {43: 1, 369: 1, 1: 9, 4: 2, 9: 5, 10: 3, 15: 3, 24: 2, 25: 5, 26: 5, 27: 3, 39: 5, 49: 6, 50: 5, 58: 5, 59: 2, 64: 3, 69: 4, 81: 6, 82: 4, 86: 3, 96: 4, 97: 3, 100: 7, 108: 3, 109: 4, 110: 4, 111: 2, 114: 3, 115: 4, 116: 3, 118: 6, 119: 5, 120: 3, 121: 4, 122: 4, 123: 3, 124: 4, 128: 4, 129: 4, 130: 5, 132: 4, 136: 2, 145: 4, 147: 4, 151: 4, 152: 4, 154: 3, 156: 2, 161: 3, 162: 3, 165: 3, 168: 4, 169: 3, 172: 3, 180: 4, 184: 5, 187: 5, 188: 4, 191: 3, 194: 4, 202: 5, 203: 6, 206: 2, 207: 3, 215: 2, 217: 3, 218: 8, 220: 2, 221: 2, 222: 5, 224: 3, 227: 5, 229: 3, 234: 5, 235: 2, 241: 2, 242: 2, 243: 4, 244: 4, 245: 4, 248: 4, 250: 4, 258: 11, 262: 4, 263: 5, 264: 3, 267: 4, 270: 3, 272: 3, 273: 5, 287: 3, 289: 3, 291: 5, 299: 5, 300: 3, 304: 3, 309: 3, 314: 2, 315: 3, 320: 4, 323: 4, 327: 4, 328: 3, 329: 2, 330: 10, 335: 3, 341: 5, 342: 6, 347: 5, 348: 5, 350: 7, 351: 5, 352: 3, 353: 3, 354: 2, 358: 4, 365: 3, 366: 2, 371: 7, 372: 5, 376: 2, 384: 5, 385: 4, 386: 3, 387: 3, 392: 3, 393: 4, 396: 6, 397: 7, 398: 6, 402: 3} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 99 "During the elimination and replication process the sequence number of the ingress DetNet member flow MUST be preserved and copied to the corresponding egress DetNet member flow. Specifically, a relay node sends the same sequence number in an outgoing packet of a DetNet member flow that is received in the corresponding incoming packet of a DetNet compound flow. This is true whether or not PREOF is performed at the relay node." "Thanks for 's fine tuning . cam you review and merge if you 're good with the changes ." 6a9a07579e1ab7324d635b60bfd9276328dcfb47 6a9a07579e1ab7324d635b60bfd9276328dcfb47 draft-ietf-detnet-mpls d214eb97a9afefbf83b751181186edfe7db0d380c6fe58f68a461e993787e53e ['d214eb97a9afefbf83b751181186edfe7db0d380c6fe58f68a461e993787e53e', 'f6a8cfceb19b4cd796512223b8afd103c4aee7052247ebea8b50f743e9aa27b6', '5fb32827bc18a11173c526c6808a3244b1c4a63c59fc347d6a591ed7307f6b06', '09732023af932d8c578c8a7ead49feb80cdb5c629cee6add2e24fcd7999c0309', 'caeedc5fb097519e9c8aafd6d55302f119ca808b0b628387a6532d6fcc696b5b', '405f0ab79f6f7784024dd1bcc58ce2b1fde69e50af21a74f4ef96ac7f9552a69', 'f892089efdfaf264bbd88429161309e178a30e7cfb68ab63c77d748fa8e54546', '200fc77171ce0224e61968428de9b5cf36ae83b94a6c11a8e8d67ae042f2922e'] B "during the elimination and replication process the sequence number of the ingress detnet member flow must be preserved and copied to the corresponding egress detnet member flow. specifically, a relay node sends the same sequence number in an outgoing packet of a detnet member flow that is received in the corresponding incoming packet of a detnet compound flow. this is true whether or not preof is performed at the relay node." {35: 1, 53: 1, 6: 2, 79: 2, 90: 3, 51: 3, 130: 2, 62: 5, 85: 5, 68: 4, 110: 3, 91: 5, 114: 3, 97: 3, 31: 3, 13: 3, 67: 3, 38: 4, 26: 3, 124: 3, 98: 2, 54: 2, 127: 3, 8: 2, 96: 3, 64: 2, 30: 4, 61: 5, 55: 3, 27: 4, 15: 3, 52: 2, 129: 3, 115: 3, 84: 3, 76: 6, 87: 3, 131: 5, 102: 3, 113: 5, 36: 3, 24: 2, 72: 4} {43: 1, 369: 1, 1: 9, 4: 2, 9: 5, 10: 3, 15: 3, 24: 2, 25: 5, 26: 5, 27: 3, 39: 5, 49: 6, 50: 5, 58: 5, 59: 2, 64: 3, 69: 4, 81: 6, 82: 4, 86: 3, 96: 4, 97: 3, 100: 7, 108: 3, 109: 4, 110: 4, 111: 2, 114: 3, 115: 4, 116: 3, 118: 6, 119: 5, 120: 3, 121: 4, 122: 4, 123: 3, 124: 4, 128: 4, 129: 4, 130: 5, 132: 4, 136: 2, 145: 4, 147: 4, 151: 4, 152: 4, 154: 3, 156: 2, 161: 3, 162: 3, 165: 3, 168: 4, 169: 3, 172: 3, 180: 4, 184: 5, 187: 5, 188: 4, 191: 3, 194: 4, 202: 5, 203: 6, 206: 2, 207: 3, 215: 2, 217: 3, 218: 8, 220: 2, 221: 2, 222: 5, 224: 3, 227: 5, 229: 3, 234: 5, 235: 2, 241: 2, 242: 2, 243: 4, 244: 4, 245: 4, 248: 4, 250: 4, 258: 11, 262: 4, 263: 5, 264: 3, 267: 4, 270: 3, 272: 3, 273: 5, 287: 3, 289: 3, 291: 5, 299: 5, 300: 3, 304: 3, 309: 3, 314: 2, 315: 3, 320: 4, 323: 4, 327: 4, 328: 3, 329: 2, 330: 10, 335: 3, 341: 5, 342: 6, 347: 5, 348: 5, 350: 7, 351: 5, 352: 3, 353: 3, 354: 2, 358: 4, 365: 3, 366: 2, 371: 7, 372: 5, 376: 2, 384: 5, 385: 4, 386: 3, 387: 3, 392: 3, 393: 4, 396: 6, 397: 7, 398: 6, 402: 3} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 99 "The internal design of a relay node is out of scope of this document. However the reader's attention is drawn to the need to make any PREOF state available to the packet processor(s) dealing with packets to which the PREOF functions must be applied, and to maintain that state is such away that it is available to the packet processor operation on the next packet in the DetNet flow (which may be a duplicate, a late packet, or the next packet in sequence." "Thanks for 's fine tuning . cam you review and merge if you 're good with the changes ." 6a9a07579e1ab7324d635b60bfd9276328dcfb47 6a9a07579e1ab7324d635b60bfd9276328dcfb47 draft-ietf-detnet-mpls f892089efdfaf264bbd88429161309e178a30e7cfb68ab63c77d748fa8e54546 ['d214eb97a9afefbf83b751181186edfe7db0d380c6fe58f68a461e993787e53e', 'f6a8cfceb19b4cd796512223b8afd103c4aee7052247ebea8b50f743e9aa27b6', '5fb32827bc18a11173c526c6808a3244b1c4a63c59fc347d6a591ed7307f6b06', '09732023af932d8c578c8a7ead49feb80cdb5c629cee6add2e24fcd7999c0309', 'caeedc5fb097519e9c8aafd6d55302f119ca808b0b628387a6532d6fcc696b5b', '405f0ab79f6f7784024dd1bcc58ce2b1fde69e50af21a74f4ef96ac7f9552a69', 'f892089efdfaf264bbd88429161309e178a30e7cfb68ab63c77d748fa8e54546', '200fc77171ce0224e61968428de9b5cf36ae83b94a6c11a8e8d67ae042f2922e'] B "the internal design of a relay node is out of scope of this document. however the reader's attention is drawn to the need to make any preof state available to the packet processor(s) dealing with packets to which the preof functions must be applied, and to maintain that state is such away that it is available to the packet processor operation on the next packet in the detnet flow (which may be a duplicate, a late packet, or the next packet in sequence." {35: 1, 53: 1, 6: 2, 79: 2, 90: 3, 51: 3, 130: 2, 62: 5, 85: 5, 68: 4, 110: 3, 91: 5, 114: 3, 97: 3, 31: 3, 13: 3, 67: 3, 38: 4, 26: 3, 124: 3, 98: 2, 54: 2, 127: 3, 8: 2, 96: 3, 64: 2, 30: 4, 61: 5, 55: 3, 27: 4, 15: 3, 52: 2, 129: 3, 115: 3, 84: 3, 76: 6, 87: 3, 131: 5, 102: 3, 113: 5, 36: 3, 24: 2, 72: 4} {43: 1, 369: 1, 1: 9, 4: 2, 9: 5, 10: 3, 15: 3, 24: 2, 25: 5, 26: 5, 27: 3, 39: 5, 49: 6, 50: 5, 58: 5, 59: 2, 64: 3, 69: 4, 81: 6, 82: 4, 86: 3, 96: 4, 97: 3, 100: 7, 108: 3, 109: 4, 110: 4, 111: 2, 114: 3, 115: 4, 116: 3, 118: 6, 119: 5, 120: 3, 121: 4, 122: 4, 123: 3, 124: 4, 128: 4, 129: 4, 130: 5, 132: 4, 136: 2, 145: 4, 147: 4, 151: 4, 152: 4, 154: 3, 156: 2, 161: 3, 162: 3, 165: 3, 168: 4, 169: 3, 172: 3, 180: 4, 184: 5, 187: 5, 188: 4, 191: 3, 194: 4, 202: 5, 203: 6, 206: 2, 207: 3, 215: 2, 217: 3, 218: 8, 220: 2, 221: 2, 222: 5, 224: 3, 227: 5, 229: 3, 234: 5, 235: 2, 241: 2, 242: 2, 243: 4, 244: 4, 245: 4, 248: 4, 250: 4, 258: 11, 262: 4, 263: 5, 264: 3, 267: 4, 270: 3, 272: 3, 273: 5, 287: 3, 289: 3, 291: 5, 299: 5, 300: 3, 304: 3, 309: 3, 314: 2, 315: 3, 320: 4, 323: 4, 327: 4, 328: 3, 329: 2, 330: 10, 335: 3, 341: 5, 342: 6, 347: 5, 348: 5, 350: 7, 351: 5, 352: 3, 353: 3, 354: 2, 358: 4, 365: 3, 366: 2, 371: 7, 372: 5, 376: 2, 384: 5, 385: 4, 386: 3, 387: 3, 392: 3, 393: 4, 396: 6, 397: 7, 398: 6, 402: 3} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 98 "fig_tsn_mpls_detnet shows IEEE 802.1 TSN end stations operating over a TSN aware DetNet service running over an MPLS network. DetNet Edge Nodes sit at the boundary of a DetNet domain. They are responsible for mapping non-DetNet aware L2 traffic to DetNet services. They also support the imposition and disposition of the required DetNet encapsulation. These are functionally similar to pseudowire (PW) Terminating Provider Edge (T-PE) nodes which use MPLS-TE LSPs. In this example TSN Streams are simple applicaions over DetNet flows. The specific of this operation are discussed later in this document." Fixing conformance language Adding more definite references for TSN functions ( i.e. , Clause numbers ) 101eef2d9b0767474662e78c3f0eb41f4a7bd928 101eef2d9b0767474662e78c3f0eb41f4a7bd928 draft-ietf-detnet-tsn-vpn-over-mpls 09c22b9cb6ea58d24a88447212820f97b834b01b3d99ac5f5393fc662cf817be ['8b0f40983b39fb8620a96f1fa6ee33620c63e1347a78f0f3488a2e023965cc2d', '09c22b9cb6ea58d24a88447212820f97b834b01b3d99ac5f5393fc662cf817be'] A "fig_tsn_mpls_detnet shows ieee 802.1 tsn end stations operating over a tsn aware detnet service running over an mpls network. detnet edge nodes sit at the boundary of a detnet domain. they are responsible for mapping non-detnet aware l2 traffic to detnet services. they also support the imposition and disposition of the required detnet encapsulation. these are functionally similar to pseudowire (pw) terminating provider edge (t-pe) nodes which use mpls-te lsps. in this example tsn streams are simple applicaions over detnet flows. the specific of this operation are discussed later in this document." {54: 1, 6: 3, 79: 3, 90: 4, 51: 4, 130: 3, 62: 6, 85: 6, 68: 5, 35: 4, 110: 4, 91: 6, 114: 4, 97: 4, 31: 4, 13: 4, 67: 4, 38: 5, 26: 4, 124: 4, 98: 3, 127: 4, 8: 3, 96: 4, 64: 3, 30: 5, 61: 6, 55: 4, 27: 5, 15: 4, 52: 3, 129: 4, 115: 4, 84: 4, 76: 7, 87: 4, 131: 6, 102: 4, 113: 6, 99: 3, 36: 4, 24: 3, 53: 2, 72: 5} {329: 1, 1: 10, 4: 3, 9: 6, 10: 4, 15: 4, 24: 3, 25: 6, 26: 6, 27: 4, 39: 6, 43: 4, 49: 7, 50: 6, 58: 6, 59: 3, 64: 4, 69: 5, 81: 7, 82: 5, 86: 4, 96: 5, 97: 4, 100: 8, 108: 4, 109: 5, 110: 5, 111: 3, 114: 4, 115: 5, 116: 4, 118: 7, 119: 6, 120: 4, 121: 5, 122: 5, 123: 4, 124: 5, 128: 5, 129: 5, 130: 6, 132: 5, 136: 3, 145: 5, 147: 5, 151: 5, 152: 5, 154: 4, 156: 3, 161: 4, 162: 4, 165: 4, 168: 5, 169: 4, 172: 4, 180: 5, 184: 6, 187: 6, 188: 5, 191: 4, 194: 5, 202: 6, 203: 7, 206: 3, 207: 4, 215: 3, 218: 9, 220: 3, 221: 3, 222: 6, 224: 4, 227: 6, 229: 4, 234: 6, 235: 3, 241: 3, 242: 3, 243: 5, 244: 5, 245: 5, 248: 5, 250: 5, 258: 12, 262: 5, 263: 6, 264: 4, 267: 5, 270: 4, 272: 4, 273: 6, 287: 4, 289: 4, 291: 6, 299: 6, 300: 4, 304: 4, 309: 4, 314: 3, 315: 4, 320: 5, 323: 5, 327: 5, 328: 4, 330: 11, 334: 3, 335: 4, 341: 6, 342: 7, 347: 6, 348: 6, 350: 8, 351: 6, 352: 4, 353: 4, 354: 3, 358: 5, 365: 4, 366: 3, 369: 2, 371: 8, 372: 6, 376: 3, 384: 6, 385: 5, 386: 4, 387: 4, 392: 4, 393: 5, 396: 7, 397: 8, 398: 7, 402: 4} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 98 "fig_tsn_mpls_detnet shows IEEE 802.1 TSN end stations operating over a TSN aware DetNet service running over an MPLS network. DetNet Edge Nodes sit at the boundary of a DetNet domain. They are responsible for mapping non-DetNet aware L2 traffic to DetNet services. They also support the imposition and disposition of the required DetNet encapsulation. These are functionally similar to pseudowire (PW) Terminating Provider Edge (T-PE) nodes which use MPLS-TE LSPs. In this example TSN Streams are simple applications over DetNet flows. The specific of this operation are discussed later in this document." Fixing conformance language Adding more definite references for TSN functions ( i.e. , Clause numbers ) 101eef2d9b0767474662e78c3f0eb41f4a7bd928 101eef2d9b0767474662e78c3f0eb41f4a7bd928 draft-ietf-detnet-tsn-vpn-over-mpls 8b0f40983b39fb8620a96f1fa6ee33620c63e1347a78f0f3488a2e023965cc2d ['8b0f40983b39fb8620a96f1fa6ee33620c63e1347a78f0f3488a2e023965cc2d', '09c22b9cb6ea58d24a88447212820f97b834b01b3d99ac5f5393fc662cf817be'] B "fig_tsn_mpls_detnet shows ieee 802.1 tsn end stations operating over a tsn aware detnet service running over an mpls network. detnet edge nodes sit at the boundary of a detnet domain. they are responsible for mapping non-detnet aware l2 traffic to detnet services. they also support the imposition and disposition of the required detnet encapsulation. these are functionally similar to pseudowire (pw) terminating provider edge (t-pe) nodes which use mpls-te lsps. in this example tsn streams are simple applications over detnet flows. the specific of this operation are discussed later in this document." {54: 1, 6: 3, 79: 3, 90: 4, 51: 4, 130: 3, 62: 6, 85: 6, 68: 5, 35: 4, 110: 4, 91: 6, 114: 4, 97: 4, 31: 4, 13: 4, 67: 4, 38: 5, 26: 4, 124: 4, 98: 3, 127: 4, 8: 3, 96: 4, 64: 3, 30: 5, 61: 6, 55: 4, 27: 5, 15: 4, 52: 3, 129: 4, 115: 4, 84: 4, 76: 7, 87: 4, 131: 6, 102: 4, 113: 6, 99: 3, 36: 4, 24: 3, 53: 2, 72: 5} {329: 1, 1: 10, 4: 3, 9: 6, 10: 4, 15: 4, 24: 3, 25: 6, 26: 6, 27: 4, 39: 6, 43: 4, 49: 7, 50: 6, 58: 6, 59: 3, 64: 4, 69: 5, 81: 7, 82: 5, 86: 4, 96: 5, 97: 4, 100: 8, 108: 4, 109: 5, 110: 5, 111: 3, 114: 4, 115: 5, 116: 4, 118: 7, 119: 6, 120: 4, 121: 5, 122: 5, 123: 4, 124: 5, 128: 5, 129: 5, 130: 6, 132: 5, 136: 3, 145: 5, 147: 5, 151: 5, 152: 5, 154: 4, 156: 3, 161: 4, 162: 4, 165: 4, 168: 5, 169: 4, 172: 4, 180: 5, 184: 6, 187: 6, 188: 5, 191: 4, 194: 5, 202: 6, 203: 7, 206: 3, 207: 4, 215: 3, 218: 9, 220: 3, 221: 3, 222: 6, 224: 4, 227: 6, 229: 4, 234: 6, 235: 3, 241: 3, 242: 3, 243: 5, 244: 5, 245: 5, 248: 5, 250: 5, 258: 12, 262: 5, 263: 6, 264: 4, 267: 5, 270: 4, 272: 4, 273: 6, 287: 4, 289: 4, 291: 6, 299: 6, 300: 4, 304: 4, 309: 4, 314: 3, 315: 4, 320: 5, 323: 5, 327: 5, 328: 4, 330: 11, 334: 3, 335: 4, 341: 6, 342: 7, 347: 6, 348: 6, 350: 8, 351: 6, 352: 4, 353: 4, 354: 3, 358: 5, 365: 4, 366: 3, 369: 2, 371: 8, 372: 6, 376: 3, 384: 6, 385: 5, 386: 4, 387: 4, 392: 4, 393: 5, 396: 7, 397: 8, 398: 7, 402: 4} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 98 "The implementation of TSN entity (i.e., TSN packet processing functions) MUST be compliant with the relevant IEEE 802.1 standards." Fixing conformance language Adding more definite references for TSN functions ( i.e. , Clause numbers ) 101eef2d9b0767474662e78c3f0eb41f4a7bd928 101eef2d9b0767474662e78c3f0eb41f4a7bd928 draft-ietf-detnet-tsn-vpn-over-mpls b4aa7168676d2a2f27066b7be52326b820cf4a9e31a8480a6fccfe8701cf5362 ['b4aa7168676d2a2f27066b7be52326b820cf4a9e31a8480a6fccfe8701cf5362'] B "the implementation of tsn entity (i.e., tsn packet processing functions) must be compliant with the relevant ieee 802.1 standards." {} {} {} 98 "TSN specific function(s) of Edge Nodes (T-PE) are belonging to the native service processing (NSP) RFC3985 block. This is similar to other functionalities being defined by standard bodies other than the IETF (for example in case of Ethernet: stripping, overwriting or adding VLAN tags, etc.). Depending on the TSN role of the Edge Node in the end-to-end TSN service selected TSN functions must be supported." Fixing conformance language Adding more definite references for TSN functions ( i.e. , Clause numbers ) 101eef2d9b0767474662e78c3f0eb41f4a7bd928 101eef2d9b0767474662e78c3f0eb41f4a7bd928 draft-ietf-detnet-tsn-vpn-over-mpls cbe90e272b6be7696d3b8c171500847d2b0ae497f6911d0f9d5d8481101c4c1f ['81f9d94a65b8acfba1c176c8c58cddd74fa4535199be90f9ad2e00b2c539bb31', '587f48b07698471b5a402b25410ab19ee5ba0633e964cf0f9ad1eac5bcae58f2', 'cbe90e272b6be7696d3b8c171500847d2b0ae497f6911d0f9d5d8481101c4c1f', '70b648698de3f7f597cd96fefbc05013dfff52cdd170ffc74e42db88544d92a9'] A "tsn specific function(s) of edge nodes (t-pe) are belonging to the native service processing (nsp) rfc3985 block. this is similar to other functionalities being defined by standard bodies other than the ietf (for example in case of ethernet: stripping, overwriting or adding vlan tags, etc.). depending on the tsn role of the edge node in the end-to-end tsn service selected tsn functions must be supported." {79: 1, 53: 1, 124: 1, 6: 2, 90: 3, 51: 3, 130: 2, 62: 5, 85: 5, 68: 4, 35: 3, 110: 3, 91: 5, 114: 3, 97: 3, 31: 3, 13: 3, 67: 3, 38: 4, 26: 3, 98: 2, 54: 2, 127: 3, 8: 2, 96: 3, 64: 2, 30: 4, 61: 5, 55: 3, 27: 4, 15: 3, 52: 2, 129: 3, 115: 3, 84: 3, 76: 6, 87: 3, 131: 3, 102: 3, 113: 5, 99: 2, 36: 3, 24: 2, 72: 4} {191: 1, 369: 1, 207: 1, 1: 9, 4: 2, 9: 5, 10: 3, 15: 3, 24: 2, 25: 5, 26: 5, 27: 3, 39: 5, 43: 3, 49: 6, 50: 5, 58: 5, 59: 2, 64: 3, 69: 4, 81: 6, 82: 4, 86: 3, 96: 4, 97: 3, 100: 7, 108: 3, 109: 2, 110: 2, 111: 2, 114: 3, 115: 4, 116: 3, 118: 6, 119: 5, 120: 3, 121: 4, 122: 4, 123: 3, 124: 4, 128: 4, 129: 4, 130: 5, 132: 4, 136: 2, 145: 4, 147: 4, 151: 4, 152: 4, 154: 3, 156: 2, 161: 3, 162: 3, 165: 3, 168: 2, 169: 3, 172: 3, 180: 4, 184: 5, 187: 5, 188: 4, 194: 4, 202: 5, 203: 6, 215: 2, 217: 3, 218: 8, 220: 2, 221: 2, 222: 5, 224: 3, 227: 5, 229: 3, 234: 3, 235: 2, 241: 2, 242: 2, 243: 4, 244: 4, 245: 4, 248: 4, 250: 4, 258: 11, 262: 2, 263: 3, 264: 3, 267: 4, 270: 3, 272: 3, 273: 5, 287: 3, 289: 3, 291: 5, 299: 5, 300: 3, 304: 3, 309: 3, 314: 2, 315: 3, 320: 4, 323: 4, 327: 4, 328: 3, 329: 2, 330: 10, 334: 2, 335: 3, 341: 5, 342: 6, 347: 5, 348: 5, 350: 7, 351: 5, 352: 3, 353: 3, 354: 2, 358: 4, 365: 3, 366: 2, 371: 7, 372: 5, 376: 2, 384: 5, 385: 4, 386: 3, 387: 3, 392: 3, 393: 4, 396: 6, 397: 7, 398: 6, 402: 3} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 98 "When a PE receives a packet from a CE, on a given AC with DetNet service, it MUST first check via Stream Identification whether the packet belongs to a configured TSN Stream (i.e., App-flow from DetNet perspective). If no Stream ID is matched and no other (VPN) service is configured for the AC then packet MUST be dropped. If there is a matching TSN Stream then the Stream-ID specific TSN functions MUST be executed (e.g., ingress policing, header field manipulation in case of active Stream Identification, FRER, etc.). Source MAC lookup MAY also be used for local MAC address learning." Fixing conformance language Adding more definite references for TSN functions ( i.e. , Clause numbers ) 101eef2d9b0767474662e78c3f0eb41f4a7bd928 101eef2d9b0767474662e78c3f0eb41f4a7bd928 draft-ietf-detnet-tsn-vpn-over-mpls 70b648698de3f7f597cd96fefbc05013dfff52cdd170ffc74e42db88544d92a9 ['81f9d94a65b8acfba1c176c8c58cddd74fa4535199be90f9ad2e00b2c539bb31', '587f48b07698471b5a402b25410ab19ee5ba0633e964cf0f9ad1eac5bcae58f2', 'cbe90e272b6be7696d3b8c171500847d2b0ae497f6911d0f9d5d8481101c4c1f', '70b648698de3f7f597cd96fefbc05013dfff52cdd170ffc74e42db88544d92a9'] A "when a pe receives a packet from a ce, on a given ac with detnet service, it must first check via stream identification whether the packet belongs to a configured tsn stream (i.e., app-flow from detnet perspective). if no stream id is matched and no other (vpn) service is configured for the ac then packet must be dropped. if there is a matching tsn stream then the stream-id specific tsn functions must be executed (e.g., ingress policing, header field manipulation in case of active stream identification, frer, etc.). source mac lookup may also be used for local mac address learning." {79: 1, 53: 1, 124: 1, 6: 2, 90: 3, 51: 3, 130: 2, 62: 5, 85: 5, 68: 4, 35: 3, 110: 3, 91: 5, 114: 3, 97: 3, 31: 3, 13: 3, 67: 3, 38: 4, 26: 3, 98: 2, 54: 2, 127: 3, 8: 2, 96: 3, 64: 2, 30: 4, 61: 5, 55: 3, 27: 4, 15: 3, 52: 2, 129: 3, 115: 3, 84: 3, 76: 6, 87: 3, 131: 3, 102: 3, 113: 5, 99: 2, 36: 3, 24: 2, 72: 4} {191: 1, 369: 1, 207: 1, 1: 9, 4: 2, 9: 5, 10: 3, 15: 3, 24: 2, 25: 5, 26: 5, 27: 3, 39: 5, 43: 3, 49: 6, 50: 5, 58: 5, 59: 2, 64: 3, 69: 4, 81: 6, 82: 4, 86: 3, 96: 4, 97: 3, 100: 7, 108: 3, 109: 2, 110: 2, 111: 2, 114: 3, 115: 4, 116: 3, 118: 6, 119: 5, 120: 3, 121: 4, 122: 4, 123: 3, 124: 4, 128: 4, 129: 4, 130: 5, 132: 4, 136: 2, 145: 4, 147: 4, 151: 4, 152: 4, 154: 3, 156: 2, 161: 3, 162: 3, 165: 3, 168: 2, 169: 3, 172: 3, 180: 4, 184: 5, 187: 5, 188: 4, 194: 4, 202: 5, 203: 6, 215: 2, 217: 3, 218: 8, 220: 2, 221: 2, 222: 5, 224: 3, 227: 5, 229: 3, 234: 3, 235: 2, 241: 2, 242: 2, 243: 4, 244: 4, 245: 4, 248: 4, 250: 4, 258: 11, 262: 2, 263: 3, 264: 3, 267: 4, 270: 3, 272: 3, 273: 5, 287: 3, 289: 3, 291: 5, 299: 5, 300: 3, 304: 3, 309: 3, 314: 2, 315: 3, 320: 4, 323: 4, 327: 4, 328: 3, 329: 2, 330: 10, 334: 2, 335: 3, 341: 5, 342: 6, 347: 5, 348: 5, 350: 7, 351: 5, 352: 3, 353: 3, 354: 2, 358: 4, 365: 3, 366: 2, 371: 7, 372: 5, 376: 2, 384: 5, 385: 4, 386: 3, 387: 3, 392: 3, 393: 4, 396: 6, 397: 7, 398: 6, 402: 3} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 98 "TSN packet processing function(s) of Edge Nodes (T-PE) are belonging to the native service processing (NSP) RFC3985 block. This is similar to other functionalities being defined by standard bodies other than the IETF (for example in case of Ethernet: stripping, overwriting or adding VLAN tags, etc.). Depending on the TSN role of the Edge Node in the end-to-end TSN service selected TSN functions are supported." Fixing conformance language Adding more definite references for TSN functions ( i.e. , Clause numbers ) 101eef2d9b0767474662e78c3f0eb41f4a7bd928 101eef2d9b0767474662e78c3f0eb41f4a7bd928 draft-ietf-detnet-tsn-vpn-over-mpls 587f48b07698471b5a402b25410ab19ee5ba0633e964cf0f9ad1eac5bcae58f2 ['81f9d94a65b8acfba1c176c8c58cddd74fa4535199be90f9ad2e00b2c539bb31', '587f48b07698471b5a402b25410ab19ee5ba0633e964cf0f9ad1eac5bcae58f2', 'cbe90e272b6be7696d3b8c171500847d2b0ae497f6911d0f9d5d8481101c4c1f', '70b648698de3f7f597cd96fefbc05013dfff52cdd170ffc74e42db88544d92a9'] B "tsn packet processing function(s) of edge nodes (t-pe) are belonging to the native service processing (nsp) rfc3985 block. this is similar to other functionalities being defined by standard bodies other than the ietf (for example in case of ethernet: stripping, overwriting or adding vlan tags, etc.). depending on the tsn role of the edge node in the end-to-end tsn service selected tsn functions are supported." {79: 1, 53: 1, 124: 1, 6: 2, 90: 3, 51: 3, 130: 2, 62: 5, 85: 5, 68: 4, 35: 3, 110: 3, 91: 5, 114: 3, 97: 3, 31: 3, 13: 3, 67: 3, 38: 4, 26: 3, 98: 2, 54: 2, 127: 3, 8: 2, 96: 3, 64: 2, 30: 4, 61: 5, 55: 3, 27: 4, 15: 3, 52: 2, 129: 3, 115: 3, 84: 3, 76: 6, 87: 3, 131: 3, 102: 3, 113: 5, 99: 2, 36: 3, 24: 2, 72: 4} {191: 1, 369: 1, 207: 1, 1: 9, 4: 2, 9: 5, 10: 3, 15: 3, 24: 2, 25: 5, 26: 5, 27: 3, 39: 5, 43: 3, 49: 6, 50: 5, 58: 5, 59: 2, 64: 3, 69: 4, 81: 6, 82: 4, 86: 3, 96: 4, 97: 3, 100: 7, 108: 3, 109: 2, 110: 2, 111: 2, 114: 3, 115: 4, 116: 3, 118: 6, 119: 5, 120: 3, 121: 4, 122: 4, 123: 3, 124: 4, 128: 4, 129: 4, 130: 5, 132: 4, 136: 2, 145: 4, 147: 4, 151: 4, 152: 4, 154: 3, 156: 2, 161: 3, 162: 3, 165: 3, 168: 2, 169: 3, 172: 3, 180: 4, 184: 5, 187: 5, 188: 4, 194: 4, 202: 5, 203: 6, 215: 2, 217: 3, 218: 8, 220: 2, 221: 2, 222: 5, 224: 3, 227: 5, 229: 3, 234: 3, 235: 2, 241: 2, 242: 2, 243: 4, 244: 4, 245: 4, 248: 4, 250: 4, 258: 11, 262: 2, 263: 3, 264: 3, 267: 4, 270: 3, 272: 3, 273: 5, 287: 3, 289: 3, 291: 5, 299: 5, 300: 3, 304: 3, 309: 3, 314: 2, 315: 3, 320: 4, 323: 4, 327: 4, 328: 3, 329: 2, 330: 10, 334: 2, 335: 3, 341: 5, 342: 6, 347: 5, 348: 5, 350: 7, 351: 5, 352: 3, 353: 3, 354: 2, 358: 4, 365: 3, 366: 2, 371: 7, 372: 5, 376: 2, 384: 5, 385: 4, 386: 3, 387: 3, 392: 3, 393: 4, 396: 6, 397: 7, 398: 6, 402: 3} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 98 "When a PE receives a packet from a CE, on a given AC with DetNet service, it MUST first check via Stream Identification (see Clause 6. of IEEE8021CB and IEEEP8021CBdb) whether the packet belongs to a configured TSN Stream (i.e., App-flow from DetNet perspective). If no Stream ID is matched and no other (VPN) service is configured for the AC then packet MUST be dropped. If there is a matching TSN Stream then the Stream-ID specific TSN functions MUST be executed (e.g., ingress policing, header field manipulation in case of active Stream Identification, FRER, etc.). Source MAC lookup MAY also be used for local MAC address learning." Fixing conformance language Adding more definite references for TSN functions ( i.e. , Clause numbers ) 101eef2d9b0767474662e78c3f0eb41f4a7bd928 101eef2d9b0767474662e78c3f0eb41f4a7bd928 draft-ietf-detnet-tsn-vpn-over-mpls 81f9d94a65b8acfba1c176c8c58cddd74fa4535199be90f9ad2e00b2c539bb31 ['81f9d94a65b8acfba1c176c8c58cddd74fa4535199be90f9ad2e00b2c539bb31', '587f48b07698471b5a402b25410ab19ee5ba0633e964cf0f9ad1eac5bcae58f2', 'cbe90e272b6be7696d3b8c171500847d2b0ae497f6911d0f9d5d8481101c4c1f', '70b648698de3f7f597cd96fefbc05013dfff52cdd170ffc74e42db88544d92a9'] B "when a pe receives a packet from a ce, on a given ac with detnet service, it must first check via stream identification (see clause 6. of ieee8021cb and ieeep8021cbdb) whether the packet belongs to a configured tsn stream (i.e., app-flow from detnet perspective). if no stream id is matched and no other (vpn) service is configured for the ac then packet must be dropped. if there is a matching tsn stream then the stream-id specific tsn functions must be executed (e.g., ingress policing, header field manipulation in case of active stream identification, frer, etc.). source mac lookup may also be used for local mac address learning." {79: 1, 53: 1, 124: 1, 6: 2, 90: 3, 51: 3, 130: 2, 62: 5, 85: 5, 68: 4, 35: 3, 110: 3, 91: 5, 114: 3, 97: 3, 31: 3, 13: 3, 67: 3, 38: 4, 26: 3, 98: 2, 54: 2, 127: 3, 8: 2, 96: 3, 64: 2, 30: 4, 61: 5, 55: 3, 27: 4, 15: 3, 52: 2, 129: 3, 115: 3, 84: 3, 76: 6, 87: 3, 131: 3, 102: 3, 113: 5, 99: 2, 36: 3, 24: 2, 72: 4} {191: 1, 369: 1, 207: 1, 1: 9, 4: 2, 9: 5, 10: 3, 15: 3, 24: 2, 25: 5, 26: 5, 27: 3, 39: 5, 43: 3, 49: 6, 50: 5, 58: 5, 59: 2, 64: 3, 69: 4, 81: 6, 82: 4, 86: 3, 96: 4, 97: 3, 100: 7, 108: 3, 109: 2, 110: 2, 111: 2, 114: 3, 115: 4, 116: 3, 118: 6, 119: 5, 120: 3, 121: 4, 122: 4, 123: 3, 124: 4, 128: 4, 129: 4, 130: 5, 132: 4, 136: 2, 145: 4, 147: 4, 151: 4, 152: 4, 154: 3, 156: 2, 161: 3, 162: 3, 165: 3, 168: 2, 169: 3, 172: 3, 180: 4, 184: 5, 187: 5, 188: 4, 194: 4, 202: 5, 203: 6, 215: 2, 217: 3, 218: 8, 220: 2, 221: 2, 222: 5, 224: 3, 227: 5, 229: 3, 234: 3, 235: 2, 241: 2, 242: 2, 243: 4, 244: 4, 245: 4, 248: 4, 250: 4, 258: 11, 262: 2, 263: 3, 264: 3, 267: 4, 270: 3, 272: 3, 273: 5, 287: 3, 289: 3, 291: 5, 299: 5, 300: 3, 304: 3, 309: 3, 314: 2, 315: 3, 320: 4, 323: 4, 327: 4, 328: 3, 329: 2, 330: 10, 334: 2, 335: 3, 341: 5, 342: 6, 347: 5, 348: 5, 350: 7, 351: 5, 352: 3, 353: 3, 354: 2, 358: 4, 365: 3, 366: 2, 371: 7, 372: 5, 376: 2, 384: 5, 385: 4, 386: 3, 387: 3, 392: 3, 393: 4, 396: 6, 397: 7, 398: 6, 402: 3} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 98 "When a TSN entity of the PE receives a packet from the DetNet Service Proxy, it MUST first check via Stream Identification whether the packet belongs to a configured TSN Stream. If no Stream ID is matched then packet MUST be dropped. If there is a matching TSN Stream then the Stream ID specific TSN functions MUST be executed (e.g., header field manipulation in case of active Stream Identification, FRER, etc.). Source MAC lookup MAY also be used for local MAC address learning." Fixing conformance language Adding more definite references for TSN functions ( i.e. , Clause numbers ) 101eef2d9b0767474662e78c3f0eb41f4a7bd928 101eef2d9b0767474662e78c3f0eb41f4a7bd928 draft-ietf-detnet-tsn-vpn-over-mpls af1a4b0a05ca0995e7b4536c2884d3ecda01171388cd05f46f1ac501cdda7ec0 ['47c3d01b384cf93dd5d888ecd50d922c6cb1b6edc5a8e6ce3cf67947d62d3937', 'af1a4b0a05ca0995e7b4536c2884d3ecda01171388cd05f46f1ac501cdda7ec0'] A "when a tsn entity of the pe receives a packet from the detnet service proxy, it must first check via stream identification whether the packet belongs to a configured tsn stream. if no stream id is matched then packet must be dropped. if there is a matching tsn stream then the stream id specific tsn functions must be executed (e.g., header field manipulation in case of active stream identification, frer, etc.). source mac lookup may also be used for local mac address learning." {124: 1, 79: 1, 6: 4, 90: 5, 51: 5, 130: 2, 62: 7, 85: 7, 68: 6, 35: 5, 110: 5, 91: 7, 114: 5, 97: 5, 31: 5, 13: 5, 67: 5, 38: 6, 26: 5, 54: 4, 127: 5, 8: 4, 96: 5, 64: 4, 30: 6, 61: 7, 55: 5, 27: 6, 15: 5, 52: 4, 129: 5, 115: 5, 98: 2, 84: 5, 76: 8, 87: 5, 131: 2, 102: 5, 113: 7, 99: 4, 36: 5, 24: 4, 53: 3, 72: 6} {109: 1, 191: 1, 1: 11, 4: 4, 9: 7, 10: 5, 15: 5, 24: 4, 25: 7, 26: 7, 27: 5, 39: 7, 43: 5, 49: 8, 50: 7, 58: 7, 59: 4, 64: 5, 69: 6, 81: 8, 82: 6, 86: 5, 96: 6, 97: 5, 100: 9, 108: 5, 111: 4, 114: 5, 115: 6, 116: 5, 118: 8, 119: 7, 120: 5, 121: 6, 122: 6, 123: 5, 124: 6, 128: 6, 129: 6, 130: 7, 132: 6, 136: 4, 145: 6, 147: 6, 151: 6, 152: 6, 154: 5, 156: 4, 161: 5, 162: 5, 165: 5, 168: 4, 169: 5, 172: 5, 180: 6, 184: 7, 187: 7, 188: 6, 194: 6, 202: 7, 203: 8, 206: 2, 207: 3, 215: 4, 217: 5, 218: 10, 220: 4, 221: 4, 222: 7, 224: 5, 227: 7, 229: 5, 234: 5, 235: 4, 241: 4, 242: 4, 243: 6, 244: 6, 245: 6, 248: 6, 250: 6, 258: 13, 262: 2, 263: 2, 264: 5, 267: 6, 270: 5, 272: 5, 273: 7, 287: 5, 289: 5, 291: 7, 299: 7, 300: 5, 304: 5, 309: 5, 314: 4, 315: 5, 320: 6, 323: 6, 327: 6, 328: 5, 329: 4, 330: 12, 334: 4, 335: 5, 341: 7, 342: 8, 347: 7, 348: 7, 350: 9, 351: 7, 352: 5, 353: 5, 354: 4, 358: 6, 365: 5, 366: 4, 369: 3, 371: 9, 372: 7, 376: 4, 384: 7, 385: 6, 386: 5, 387: 5, 392: 5, 393: 6, 396: 8, 397: 9, 398: 8, 402: 5} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 98 "When a TSN entity of the PE receives a packet from the DetNet Service Proxy, it MUST first check via Stream Identification (see Clause 6. of IEEE8021CB and IEEEP8021CBdb) whether the packet belongs to a configured TSN Stream. If no Stream ID is matched then packet MUST be dropped. If there is a matching TSN Stream then the Stream ID specific TSN functions MUST be executed (e.g., header field manipulation in case of active Stream Identification, FRER, etc.). Source MAC lookup MAY also be used for local MAC address learning." Fixing conformance language Adding more definite references for TSN functions ( i.e. , Clause numbers ) 101eef2d9b0767474662e78c3f0eb41f4a7bd928 101eef2d9b0767474662e78c3f0eb41f4a7bd928 draft-ietf-detnet-tsn-vpn-over-mpls 47c3d01b384cf93dd5d888ecd50d922c6cb1b6edc5a8e6ce3cf67947d62d3937 ['47c3d01b384cf93dd5d888ecd50d922c6cb1b6edc5a8e6ce3cf67947d62d3937', 'af1a4b0a05ca0995e7b4536c2884d3ecda01171388cd05f46f1ac501cdda7ec0'] B "when a tsn entity of the pe receives a packet from the detnet service proxy, it must first check via stream identification (see clause 6. of ieee8021cb and ieeep8021cbdb) whether the packet belongs to a configured tsn stream. if no stream id is matched then packet must be dropped. if there is a matching tsn stream then the stream id specific tsn functions must be executed (e.g., header field manipulation in case of active stream identification, frer, etc.). source mac lookup may also be used for local mac address learning." {124: 1, 79: 1, 6: 4, 90: 5, 51: 5, 130: 2, 62: 7, 85: 7, 68: 6, 35: 5, 110: 5, 91: 7, 114: 5, 97: 5, 31: 5, 13: 5, 67: 5, 38: 6, 26: 5, 54: 4, 127: 5, 8: 4, 96: 5, 64: 4, 30: 6, 61: 7, 55: 5, 27: 6, 15: 5, 52: 4, 129: 5, 115: 5, 98: 2, 84: 5, 76: 8, 87: 5, 131: 2, 102: 5, 113: 7, 99: 4, 36: 5, 24: 4, 53: 3, 72: 6} {109: 1, 191: 1, 1: 11, 4: 4, 9: 7, 10: 5, 15: 5, 24: 4, 25: 7, 26: 7, 27: 5, 39: 7, 43: 5, 49: 8, 50: 7, 58: 7, 59: 4, 64: 5, 69: 6, 81: 8, 82: 6, 86: 5, 96: 6, 97: 5, 100: 9, 108: 5, 111: 4, 114: 5, 115: 6, 116: 5, 118: 8, 119: 7, 120: 5, 121: 6, 122: 6, 123: 5, 124: 6, 128: 6, 129: 6, 130: 7, 132: 6, 136: 4, 145: 6, 147: 6, 151: 6, 152: 6, 154: 5, 156: 4, 161: 5, 162: 5, 165: 5, 168: 4, 169: 5, 172: 5, 180: 6, 184: 7, 187: 7, 188: 6, 194: 6, 202: 7, 203: 8, 206: 2, 207: 3, 215: 4, 217: 5, 218: 10, 220: 4, 221: 4, 222: 7, 224: 5, 227: 7, 229: 5, 234: 5, 235: 4, 241: 4, 242: 4, 243: 6, 244: 6, 245: 6, 248: 6, 250: 6, 258: 13, 262: 2, 263: 2, 264: 5, 267: 6, 270: 5, 272: 5, 273: 7, 287: 5, 289: 5, 291: 7, 299: 7, 300: 5, 304: 5, 309: 5, 314: 4, 315: 5, 320: 6, 323: 6, 327: 6, 328: 5, 329: 4, 330: 12, 334: 4, 335: 5, 341: 7, 342: 8, 347: 7, 348: 7, 350: 9, 351: 7, 352: 5, 353: 5, 354: 4, 358: 6, 365: 5, 366: 4, 369: 3, 371: 9, 372: 7, 376: 4, 384: 7, 385: 6, 386: 5, 387: 5, 392: 5, 393: 6, 396: 8, 397: 9, 398: 8, 402: 5} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 98 "The Service Proxy function maps between App-flows and DetNet flows. The DetNet Edge Node TSN entity MUST support the TSN Stream identification functions and the related managed objects as defined in IEEE8021CB and IEEEP8021CBdb to recognize the App-flow related packets. The Service Proxy presents TSN Streams as an App-flow to a DetNet Flow." Fixing conformance language Adding more definite references for TSN functions ( i.e. , Clause numbers ) 101eef2d9b0767474662e78c3f0eb41f4a7bd928 101eef2d9b0767474662e78c3f0eb41f4a7bd928 draft-ietf-detnet-tsn-vpn-over-mpls 5ef9d12318016ad9d04ff6d1118feee37aa24df754bdd187f5df0a95e7cfb825 ['ce9024cd5dff8b94f44a5817f42d97b94d0d1aa2f80f9d362c62444bcabc3d63', '5ef9d12318016ad9d04ff6d1118feee37aa24df754bdd187f5df0a95e7cfb825'] A "the service proxy function maps between app-flows and detnet flows. the detnet edge node tsn entity must support the tsn stream identification functions and the related managed objects as defined in ieee8021cb and ieeep8021cbdb to recognize the app-flow related packets. the service proxy presents tsn streams as an app-flow to a detnet flow." {79: 1, 6: 4, 90: 5, 51: 5, 130: 4, 62: 7, 85: 7, 68: 6, 35: 5, 110: 5, 91: 7, 114: 5, 97: 5, 31: 5, 13: 5, 67: 5, 38: 6, 26: 5, 124: 5, 98: 4, 54: 2, 127: 5, 8: 4, 96: 5, 64: 4, 30: 6, 61: 7, 55: 5, 27: 6, 15: 5, 52: 4, 129: 5, 115: 5, 84: 5, 76: 8, 87: 5, 131: 7, 102: 5, 113: 7, 99: 4, 36: 5, 24: 4, 53: 3, 72: 6} {10: 1, 1: 11, 4: 4, 9: 7, 15: 5, 24: 4, 25: 7, 26: 7, 27: 5, 39: 7, 43: 5, 49: 8, 50: 7, 58: 7, 59: 4, 64: 5, 69: 6, 81: 8, 82: 6, 86: 5, 96: 6, 97: 5, 100: 9, 108: 5, 109: 6, 110: 6, 111: 4, 114: 5, 115: 6, 116: 5, 118: 8, 119: 7, 120: 5, 121: 6, 122: 6, 123: 5, 124: 6, 128: 6, 129: 6, 130: 7, 132: 6, 136: 4, 145: 6, 147: 6, 151: 6, 152: 6, 154: 5, 156: 4, 161: 5, 162: 5, 165: 5, 168: 6, 169: 5, 172: 5, 180: 6, 184: 7, 187: 7, 188: 6, 191: 5, 194: 6, 202: 7, 203: 8, 206: 4, 207: 5, 215: 4, 217: 5, 218: 10, 220: 4, 221: 4, 222: 7, 224: 5, 227: 7, 229: 5, 234: 7, 235: 4, 241: 4, 242: 2, 243: 6, 244: 6, 245: 6, 248: 6, 250: 6, 258: 13, 262: 6, 263: 7, 264: 5, 267: 6, 270: 5, 272: 5, 273: 7, 287: 5, 289: 5, 291: 7, 299: 7, 300: 5, 304: 5, 309: 5, 314: 4, 315: 5, 320: 6, 323: 6, 328: 5, 329: 4, 330: 12, 334: 4, 335: 5, 341: 7, 342: 8, 347: 7, 348: 7, 350: 9, 351: 7, 352: 5, 353: 5, 354: 4, 358: 6, 365: 5, 366: 4, 369: 3, 371: 9, 372: 7, 376: 4, 384: 7, 385: 6, 386: 5, 387: 5, 392: 5, 393: 6, 396: 8, 397: 9, 398: 8, 402: 5} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 98 "The Service Proxy function maps between App-flows and DetNet flows. The DetNet Edge Node TSN entity MUST support the TSN Stream identification functions and the related managed objects as defined in Clause 6. and Clause 9. of IEEE8021CB and IEEEP8021CBdb to recognize the App-flow related packets. The Service Proxy presents TSN Streams as an App-flow to a DetNet Flow." Fixing conformance language Adding more definite references for TSN functions ( i.e. , Clause numbers ) 101eef2d9b0767474662e78c3f0eb41f4a7bd928 101eef2d9b0767474662e78c3f0eb41f4a7bd928 draft-ietf-detnet-tsn-vpn-over-mpls ce9024cd5dff8b94f44a5817f42d97b94d0d1aa2f80f9d362c62444bcabc3d63 ['ce9024cd5dff8b94f44a5817f42d97b94d0d1aa2f80f9d362c62444bcabc3d63', '5ef9d12318016ad9d04ff6d1118feee37aa24df754bdd187f5df0a95e7cfb825'] B "the service proxy function maps between app-flows and detnet flows. the detnet edge node tsn entity must support the tsn stream identification functions and the related managed objects as defined in clause 6. and clause 9. of ieee8021cb and ieeep8021cbdb to recognize the app-flow related packets. the service proxy presents tsn streams as an app-flow to a detnet flow." {79: 1, 6: 4, 90: 5, 51: 5, 130: 4, 62: 7, 85: 7, 68: 6, 35: 5, 110: 5, 91: 7, 114: 5, 97: 5, 31: 5, 13: 5, 67: 5, 38: 6, 26: 5, 124: 5, 98: 4, 54: 2, 127: 5, 8: 4, 96: 5, 64: 4, 30: 6, 61: 7, 55: 5, 27: 6, 15: 5, 52: 4, 129: 5, 115: 5, 84: 5, 76: 8, 87: 5, 131: 7, 102: 5, 113: 7, 99: 4, 36: 5, 24: 4, 53: 3, 72: 6} {10: 1, 1: 11, 4: 4, 9: 7, 15: 5, 24: 4, 25: 7, 26: 7, 27: 5, 39: 7, 43: 5, 49: 8, 50: 7, 58: 7, 59: 4, 64: 5, 69: 6, 81: 8, 82: 6, 86: 5, 96: 6, 97: 5, 100: 9, 108: 5, 109: 6, 110: 6, 111: 4, 114: 5, 115: 6, 116: 5, 118: 8, 119: 7, 120: 5, 121: 6, 122: 6, 123: 5, 124: 6, 128: 6, 129: 6, 130: 7, 132: 6, 136: 4, 145: 6, 147: 6, 151: 6, 152: 6, 154: 5, 156: 4, 161: 5, 162: 5, 165: 5, 168: 6, 169: 5, 172: 5, 180: 6, 184: 7, 187: 7, 188: 6, 191: 5, 194: 6, 202: 7, 203: 8, 206: 4, 207: 5, 215: 4, 217: 5, 218: 10, 220: 4, 221: 4, 222: 7, 224: 5, 227: 7, 229: 5, 234: 7, 235: 4, 241: 4, 242: 2, 243: 6, 244: 6, 245: 6, 248: 6, 250: 6, 258: 13, 262: 6, 263: 7, 264: 5, 267: 6, 270: 5, 272: 5, 273: 7, 287: 5, 289: 5, 291: 7, 299: 7, 300: 5, 304: 5, 309: 5, 314: 4, 315: 5, 320: 6, 323: 6, 328: 5, 329: 4, 330: 12, 334: 4, 335: 5, 341: 7, 342: 8, 347: 7, 348: 7, 350: 9, 351: 7, 352: 5, 353: 5, 354: 4, 358: 6, 365: 5, 366: 4, 369: 3, 371: 9, 372: 7, 376: 4, 384: 7, 385: 6, 386: 5, 387: 5, 392: 5, 393: 6, 396: 8, 397: 9, 398: 8, 402: 5} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 98 "TSN related configuration information according to the TSN role of the DetNet MPLS node, as per IEEE8021Q, IEEE8021CB and IEEEP8021CBdb." Fixing conformance language Adding more definite references for TSN functions ( i.e. , Clause numbers ) 101eef2d9b0767474662e78c3f0eb41f4a7bd928 101eef2d9b0767474662e78c3f0eb41f4a7bd928 draft-ietf-detnet-tsn-vpn-over-mpls 0fa066981ce7173ac5c1337eb19532ec6d477367352cf708b24f5d7f909926c0 ['0fa066981ce7173ac5c1337eb19532ec6d477367352cf708b24f5d7f909926c0', 'fa9ee1de4b90f234826a8ec61f39b313e6f6c07026a1cb63e1bfee8aa1337fc8', 'a6dda5d9b88e1208cc173b1f0ba54c363d3d8765f7bdee7b8ad9924efe718c8a', '3136da2be70c53854924ac5e0394d8a0d0ac493519c1873f21b202ac3ed0e55e'] B "tsn related configuration information according to the tsn role of the detnet mpls node, as per ieee8021q, ieee8021cb and ieeep8021cbdb." {97: 1, 96: 1, 124: 1, 130: 2, 127: 2} {12: 1, 403: 1, 63: 1, 208: 2, 153: 2} {12, 13, 208, 403, 153, 63} 98 "DetNet MPLS related configuration information according to the DetNet role of the DetNet MPLS node, as per I-D.ietf-detnet-mpls." Fixing conformance language Adding more definite references for TSN functions ( i.e. , Clause numbers ) 101eef2d9b0767474662e78c3f0eb41f4a7bd928 101eef2d9b0767474662e78c3f0eb41f4a7bd928 draft-ietf-detnet-tsn-vpn-over-mpls a6dda5d9b88e1208cc173b1f0ba54c363d3d8765f7bdee7b8ad9924efe718c8a ['0fa066981ce7173ac5c1337eb19532ec6d477367352cf708b24f5d7f909926c0', 'fa9ee1de4b90f234826a8ec61f39b313e6f6c07026a1cb63e1bfee8aa1337fc8', 'a6dda5d9b88e1208cc173b1f0ba54c363d3d8765f7bdee7b8ad9924efe718c8a', '3136da2be70c53854924ac5e0394d8a0d0ac493519c1873f21b202ac3ed0e55e'] B "detnet mpls related configuration information according to the detnet role of the detnet mpls node, as per i-d.ietf-detnet-mpls." {97: 1, 96: 1, 124: 1, 130: 2, 127: 2} {12: 1, 403: 1, 63: 1, 208: 2, 153: 2} {12, 13, 208, 403, 153, 63} 98 "App-Flow identification information to map received TSN Stream(s) to the DetNet flow. Parameters fo TSN stream identification are defined in IEEE8021CB and IEEEP8021CBdb." Fixing conformance language Adding more definite references for TSN functions ( i.e. , Clause numbers ) 101eef2d9b0767474662e78c3f0eb41f4a7bd928 101eef2d9b0767474662e78c3f0eb41f4a7bd928 draft-ietf-detnet-tsn-vpn-over-mpls 3136da2be70c53854924ac5e0394d8a0d0ac493519c1873f21b202ac3ed0e55e ['0fa066981ce7173ac5c1337eb19532ec6d477367352cf708b24f5d7f909926c0', 'fa9ee1de4b90f234826a8ec61f39b313e6f6c07026a1cb63e1bfee8aa1337fc8', 'a6dda5d9b88e1208cc173b1f0ba54c363d3d8765f7bdee7b8ad9924efe718c8a', '3136da2be70c53854924ac5e0394d8a0d0ac493519c1873f21b202ac3ed0e55e'] B "app-flow identification information to map received tsn stream(s) to the detnet flow. parameters fo tsn stream identification are defined in ieee8021cb and ieeep8021cbdb." {97: 1, 96: 1, 124: 1, 130: 2, 127: 2} {12: 1, 403: 1, 63: 1, 208: 2, 153: 2} {12, 13, 208, 403, 153, 63} 98 This information MUST be provisioned per DetNet flow. Fixing conformance language Adding more definite references for TSN functions ( i.e. , Clause numbers ) 101eef2d9b0767474662e78c3f0eb41f4a7bd928 101eef2d9b0767474662e78c3f0eb41f4a7bd928 draft-ietf-detnet-tsn-vpn-over-mpls fa9ee1de4b90f234826a8ec61f39b313e6f6c07026a1cb63e1bfee8aa1337fc8 ['0fa066981ce7173ac5c1337eb19532ec6d477367352cf708b24f5d7f909926c0', 'fa9ee1de4b90f234826a8ec61f39b313e6f6c07026a1cb63e1bfee8aa1337fc8', 'a6dda5d9b88e1208cc173b1f0ba54c363d3d8765f7bdee7b8ad9924efe718c8a', '3136da2be70c53854924ac5e0394d8a0d0ac493519c1873f21b202ac3ed0e55e'] B this information must be provisioned per detnet flow. {97: 1, 96: 1, 124: 1, 130: 2, 127: 2} {12: 1, 403: 1, 63: 1, 208: 2, 153: 2} {12, 13, 208, 403, 153, 63} 98 "Security considerations for DetNet are described in detail in I- D.ietf-detnet-security. General security considerations are described in RFC8655. DetNet MPLS data plane specific considerations are summarized in I-D.ietf-detnet-mpls. The primary considerations for the data plane is to maintain integrity of data and delivery of the associated DetNet service traversing the DetNet network. Application flows can be protected through whatever means is provided by the underlying technology. For example, encryption may be used, such as that provided by IPSec RFC4301 for IP flows and/or by an underlying sub-net using MACSec IEEE802.1AE-2018 for IP over Ethernet (Layer-2) flows." Fixing conformance language Adding more definite references for TSN functions ( i.e. , Clause numbers ) 101eef2d9b0767474662e78c3f0eb41f4a7bd928 101eef2d9b0767474662e78c3f0eb41f4a7bd928 draft-ietf-detnet-tsn-vpn-over-mpls db8b0420da289e9ef760358aa74217460d16b962a48347dda57a7f650bc253ca ['7abf825e7daf71e2cba4e28e337f5dd088374215bcb9c81b19e6b5fc20e4d109', '624bfcfa9daaff0b9fc5595cd6a48a98add38665d687a30b8fbd525eda19373b', 'db8b0420da289e9ef760358aa74217460d16b962a48347dda57a7f650bc253ca'] A "security considerations for detnet are described in detail in i- d.ietf-detnet-security. general security considerations are described in rfc8655. detnet mpls data plane specific considerations are summarized in i-d.ietf-detnet-mpls. the primary considerations for the data plane is to maintain integrity of data and delivery of the associated detnet service traversing the detnet network. application flows can be protected through whatever means is provided by the underlying technology. for example, encryption may be used, such as that provided by ipsec rfc4301 for ip flows and/or by an underlying sub-net using macsec ieee802.1ae-2018 for ip over ethernet (layer-2) flows." {130: 1, 67: 1, 6: 4, 79: 4, 90: 5, 51: 5, 62: 7, 85: 7, 68: 6, 35: 5, 110: 5, 91: 7, 114: 5, 97: 5, 31: 5, 13: 5, 38: 6, 26: 5, 124: 5, 98: 4, 54: 2, 127: 5, 8: 4, 96: 5, 64: 4, 30: 6, 61: 7, 55: 5, 27: 6, 15: 5, 52: 4, 129: 5, 115: 5, 84: 5, 76: 8, 87: 5, 131: 7, 102: 5, 113: 7, 99: 4, 36: 5, 24: 4, 53: 3, 72: 6} {187: 1, 287: 1, 1: 11, 4: 4, 9: 7, 10: 5, 15: 5, 24: 4, 25: 7, 26: 7, 27: 5, 39: 7, 43: 5, 49: 8, 50: 7, 58: 7, 59: 4, 64: 5, 69: 6, 81: 8, 82: 6, 86: 5, 96: 6, 97: 5, 100: 9, 108: 5, 109: 6, 110: 6, 111: 2, 114: 5, 115: 6, 116: 5, 118: 8, 119: 7, 120: 5, 121: 6, 122: 6, 123: 5, 124: 6, 128: 6, 129: 6, 130: 7, 132: 6, 136: 4, 145: 6, 147: 6, 151: 6, 152: 6, 154: 5, 156: 4, 161: 5, 162: 5, 165: 5, 168: 6, 169: 5, 172: 5, 180: 6, 184: 7, 191: 5, 194: 6, 202: 7, 203: 8, 206: 4, 207: 5, 215: 4, 217: 5, 218: 10, 220: 4, 221: 4, 222: 7, 224: 5, 227: 7, 229: 5, 234: 7, 235: 4, 241: 4, 242: 4, 243: 6, 244: 6, 245: 6, 248: 6, 250: 6, 258: 13, 262: 6, 263: 7, 264: 5, 267: 6, 270: 5, 272: 5, 273: 7, 289: 5, 291: 7, 299: 7, 300: 5, 304: 5, 309: 5, 314: 4, 315: 5, 320: 6, 323: 6, 327: 6, 328: 5, 329: 4, 330: 12, 334: 4, 335: 5, 341: 7, 342: 8, 347: 7, 348: 7, 350: 9, 351: 7, 352: 5, 353: 5, 354: 4, 358: 6, 365: 5, 366: 4, 369: 3, 371: 9, 372: 7, 376: 4, 384: 7, 385: 6, 386: 5, 387: 5, 392: 5, 393: 6, 396: 8, 397: 9, 398: 8, 402: 5} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 98 "Security considerations for DetNet are described in detail in I- D.ietf-detnet-security. General security considerations are described in RFC8655." Fixing conformance language Adding more definite references for TSN functions ( i.e. , Clause numbers ) 101eef2d9b0767474662e78c3f0eb41f4a7bd928 101eef2d9b0767474662e78c3f0eb41f4a7bd928 draft-ietf-detnet-tsn-vpn-over-mpls 624bfcfa9daaff0b9fc5595cd6a48a98add38665d687a30b8fbd525eda19373b ['7abf825e7daf71e2cba4e28e337f5dd088374215bcb9c81b19e6b5fc20e4d109', '624bfcfa9daaff0b9fc5595cd6a48a98add38665d687a30b8fbd525eda19373b', 'db8b0420da289e9ef760358aa74217460d16b962a48347dda57a7f650bc253ca'] B "security considerations for detnet are described in detail in i- d.ietf-detnet-security. general security considerations are described in rfc8655." {130: 1, 67: 1, 6: 4, 79: 4, 90: 5, 51: 5, 62: 7, 85: 7, 68: 6, 35: 5, 110: 5, 91: 7, 114: 5, 97: 5, 31: 5, 13: 5, 38: 6, 26: 5, 124: 5, 98: 4, 54: 2, 127: 5, 8: 4, 96: 5, 64: 4, 30: 6, 61: 7, 55: 5, 27: 6, 15: 5, 52: 4, 129: 5, 115: 5, 84: 5, 76: 8, 87: 5, 131: 7, 102: 5, 113: 7, 99: 4, 36: 5, 24: 4, 53: 3, 72: 6} {187: 1, 287: 1, 1: 11, 4: 4, 9: 7, 10: 5, 15: 5, 24: 4, 25: 7, 26: 7, 27: 5, 39: 7, 43: 5, 49: 8, 50: 7, 58: 7, 59: 4, 64: 5, 69: 6, 81: 8, 82: 6, 86: 5, 96: 6, 97: 5, 100: 9, 108: 5, 109: 6, 110: 6, 111: 2, 114: 5, 115: 6, 116: 5, 118: 8, 119: 7, 120: 5, 121: 6, 122: 6, 123: 5, 124: 6, 128: 6, 129: 6, 130: 7, 132: 6, 136: 4, 145: 6, 147: 6, 151: 6, 152: 6, 154: 5, 156: 4, 161: 5, 162: 5, 165: 5, 168: 6, 169: 5, 172: 5, 180: 6, 184: 7, 191: 5, 194: 6, 202: 7, 203: 8, 206: 4, 207: 5, 215: 4, 217: 5, 218: 10, 220: 4, 221: 4, 222: 7, 224: 5, 227: 7, 229: 5, 234: 7, 235: 4, 241: 4, 242: 4, 243: 6, 244: 6, 245: 6, 248: 6, 250: 6, 258: 13, 262: 6, 263: 7, 264: 5, 267: 6, 270: 5, 272: 5, 273: 7, 289: 5, 291: 7, 299: 7, 300: 5, 304: 5, 309: 5, 314: 4, 315: 5, 320: 6, 323: 6, 327: 6, 328: 5, 329: 4, 330: 12, 334: 4, 335: 5, 341: 7, 342: 8, 347: 7, 348: 7, 350: 9, 351: 7, 352: 5, 353: 5, 354: 4, 358: 6, 365: 5, 366: 4, 369: 3, 371: 9, 372: 7, 376: 4, 384: 7, 385: 6, 386: 5, 387: 5, 392: 5, 393: 6, 396: 8, 397: 9, 398: 8, 402: 5} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 98 "DetNet MPLS data plane specific considerations are summarized and described in I-D.ietf-detnet-mpls including any application flow types. This document focuses on the scenario where TSN Streams are the application flows for DetNet and it is already covered by those DetNet MPLS data plane security considerations." Fixing conformance language Adding more definite references for TSN functions ( i.e. , Clause numbers ) 101eef2d9b0767474662e78c3f0eb41f4a7bd928 101eef2d9b0767474662e78c3f0eb41f4a7bd928 draft-ietf-detnet-tsn-vpn-over-mpls 7abf825e7daf71e2cba4e28e337f5dd088374215bcb9c81b19e6b5fc20e4d109 ['7abf825e7daf71e2cba4e28e337f5dd088374215bcb9c81b19e6b5fc20e4d109', '624bfcfa9daaff0b9fc5595cd6a48a98add38665d687a30b8fbd525eda19373b', 'db8b0420da289e9ef760358aa74217460d16b962a48347dda57a7f650bc253ca'] B "detnet mpls data plane specific considerations are summarized and described in i-d.ietf-detnet-mpls including any application flow types. this document focuses on the scenario where tsn streams are the application flows for detnet and it is already covered by those detnet mpls data plane security considerations." {130: 1, 67: 1, 6: 4, 79: 4, 90: 5, 51: 5, 62: 7, 85: 7, 68: 6, 35: 5, 110: 5, 91: 7, 114: 5, 97: 5, 31: 5, 13: 5, 38: 6, 26: 5, 124: 5, 98: 4, 54: 2, 127: 5, 8: 4, 96: 5, 64: 4, 30: 6, 61: 7, 55: 5, 27: 6, 15: 5, 52: 4, 129: 5, 115: 5, 84: 5, 76: 8, 87: 5, 131: 7, 102: 5, 113: 7, 99: 4, 36: 5, 24: 4, 53: 3, 72: 6} {187: 1, 287: 1, 1: 11, 4: 4, 9: 7, 10: 5, 15: 5, 24: 4, 25: 7, 26: 7, 27: 5, 39: 7, 43: 5, 49: 8, 50: 7, 58: 7, 59: 4, 64: 5, 69: 6, 81: 8, 82: 6, 86: 5, 96: 6, 97: 5, 100: 9, 108: 5, 109: 6, 110: 6, 111: 2, 114: 5, 115: 6, 116: 5, 118: 8, 119: 7, 120: 5, 121: 6, 122: 6, 123: 5, 124: 6, 128: 6, 129: 6, 130: 7, 132: 6, 136: 4, 145: 6, 147: 6, 151: 6, 152: 6, 154: 5, 156: 4, 161: 5, 162: 5, 165: 5, 168: 6, 169: 5, 172: 5, 180: 6, 184: 7, 191: 5, 194: 6, 202: 7, 203: 8, 206: 4, 207: 5, 215: 4, 217: 5, 218: 10, 220: 4, 221: 4, 222: 7, 224: 5, 227: 7, 229: 5, 234: 7, 235: 4, 241: 4, 242: 4, 243: 6, 244: 6, 245: 6, 248: 6, 250: 6, 258: 13, 262: 6, 263: 7, 264: 5, 267: 6, 270: 5, 272: 5, 273: 7, 289: 5, 291: 7, 299: 7, 300: 5, 304: 5, 309: 5, 314: 4, 315: 5, 320: 6, 323: 6, 327: 6, 328: 5, 329: 4, 330: 12, 334: 4, 335: 5, 341: 7, 342: 8, 347: 7, 348: 7, 350: 9, 351: 7, 352: 5, 353: 5, 354: 4, 358: 6, 365: 5, 366: 4, 369: 3, 371: 9, 372: 7, 376: 4, 384: 7, 385: 6, 386: 5, 387: 5, 392: 5, 393: 6, 396: 8, 397: 9, 398: 8, 402: 5} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 97 "TSN capabilities of the TSN sub-network are made available for MPLS (DetNet) flows via the protocol interworking function defined in IEEE8021CB. For example, applied on the TSN edge port it can convert an ingress unicast MPLS (DetNet) flow to use a specific Layer-2 multicast destination MAC address and a VLAN, in order to direct the packet through a specific path inside the bridged network. A similar interworking function pair at the other end of the TSN sub-network would restore the packet to its original Layer-2 destination MAC address and VLAN." Fixing conformance language Adding more definite references for TSN functions ( i.e. , Clause numbers ) 682dc592b0835e6a0817bcb5dee7aa2a80eb704a 682dc592b0835e6a0817bcb5dee7aa2a80eb704a draft-ietf-detnet-mpls-over-tsn ae74a9a2a182dd5a01fd950e728caccd2600bef5390e5cc261e81037cf194a98 ['ae74a9a2a182dd5a01fd950e728caccd2600bef5390e5cc261e81037cf194a98', '8c355f9baab116ab6d8af4bc7bf80952776fea498fa5fe602d37f1c79f00e893'] A "tsn capabilities of the tsn sub-network are made available for mpls (detnet) flows via the protocol interworking function defined in ieee8021cb. for example, applied on the tsn edge port it can convert an ingress unicast mpls (detnet) flow to use a specific layer-2 multicast destination mac address and a vlan, in order to direct the packet through a specific path inside the bridged network. a similar interworking function pair at the other end of the tsn sub-network would restore the packet to its original layer-2 destination mac address and vlan." {52: 1, 6: 3, 79: 3, 90: 3, 51: 2, 130: 2, 62: 4, 85: 5, 68: 5, 35: 4, 110: 3, 91: 5, 114: 3, 97: 2, 31: 4, 13: 3, 67: 3, 38: 4, 26: 3, 124: 4, 98: 3, 54: 3, 127: 4, 8: 3, 96: 2, 64: 3, 30: 3, 61: 5, 55: 4, 27: 4, 15: 3, 129: 4, 115: 3, 84: 3, 76: 7, 87: 3, 131: 6, 102: 3, 113: 5, 99: 3, 36: 3, 24: 2, 53: 2, 72: 4} {156: 1, 1: 10, 4: 3, 9: 6, 10: 4, 15: 2, 24: 3, 25: 4, 26: 5, 27: 2, 39: 6, 43: 4, 49: 6, 50: 5, 58: 5, 59: 3, 64: 2, 69: 5, 81: 5, 82: 3, 86: 3, 96: 4, 97: 3, 100: 6, 108: 4, 109: 5, 110: 5, 111: 3, 114: 4, 115: 5, 116: 2, 118: 7, 119: 6, 120: 4, 121: 5, 122: 3, 123: 2, 124: 5, 128: 4, 129: 3, 130: 5, 132: 5, 136: 3, 145: 5, 147: 4, 151: 4, 152: 4, 154: 4, 161: 4, 162: 4, 165: 4, 168: 5, 169: 3, 172: 3, 180: 4, 184: 6, 187: 6, 188: 5, 191: 4, 194: 5, 202: 6, 203: 7, 206: 3, 207: 4, 215: 3, 217: 4, 218: 9, 220: 3, 221: 3, 222: 6, 224: 4, 227: 4, 229: 3, 234: 6, 235: 3, 241: 3, 242: 3, 243: 5, 244: 4, 245: 5, 248: 4, 250: 3, 258: 12, 262: 5, 263: 6, 264: 4, 267: 5, 272: 3, 273: 6, 287: 4, 289: 3, 291: 5, 299: 4, 300: 2, 304: 2, 309: 4, 314: 3, 315: 3, 320: 5, 323: 5, 327: 5, 328: 4, 329: 3, 330: 11, 334: 3, 335: 2, 341: 4, 342: 5, 347: 4, 348: 4, 350: 8, 351: 5, 352: 3, 353: 3, 354: 2, 358: 5, 365: 3, 366: 3, 369: 2, 371: 6, 372: 5, 376: 3, 384: 5, 385: 4, 386: 4, 387: 2, 392: 4, 393: 5, 396: 5, 397: 8, 398: 7, 402: 3} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 97 "TSN capabilities of the TSN sub-network are made available for MPLS (DetNet) flows via the protocol interworking function defined in Annex C.5 of IEEE8021CB. For example, applied on the TSN edge port it can convert an ingress unicast MPLS (DetNet) flow to use a specific Layer-2 multicast destination MAC address and a VLAN, in order to direct the packet through a specific path inside the bridged network. A similar interworking function pair at the other end of the TSN sub-network would restore the packet to its original Layer-2 destination MAC address and VLAN." Fixing conformance language Adding more definite references for TSN functions ( i.e. , Clause numbers ) 682dc592b0835e6a0817bcb5dee7aa2a80eb704a 682dc592b0835e6a0817bcb5dee7aa2a80eb704a draft-ietf-detnet-mpls-over-tsn 8c355f9baab116ab6d8af4bc7bf80952776fea498fa5fe602d37f1c79f00e893 ['ae74a9a2a182dd5a01fd950e728caccd2600bef5390e5cc261e81037cf194a98', '8c355f9baab116ab6d8af4bc7bf80952776fea498fa5fe602d37f1c79f00e893'] B "tsn capabilities of the tsn sub-network are made available for mpls (detnet) flows via the protocol interworking function defined in annex c.5 of ieee8021cb. for example, applied on the tsn edge port it can convert an ingress unicast mpls (detnet) flow to use a specific layer-2 multicast destination mac address and a vlan, in order to direct the packet through a specific path inside the bridged network. a similar interworking function pair at the other end of the tsn sub-network would restore the packet to its original layer-2 destination mac address and vlan." {52: 1, 6: 3, 79: 3, 90: 3, 51: 2, 130: 2, 62: 4, 85: 5, 68: 5, 35: 4, 110: 3, 91: 5, 114: 3, 97: 2, 31: 4, 13: 3, 67: 3, 38: 4, 26: 3, 124: 4, 98: 3, 54: 3, 127: 4, 8: 3, 96: 2, 64: 3, 30: 3, 61: 5, 55: 4, 27: 4, 15: 3, 129: 4, 115: 3, 84: 3, 76: 7, 87: 3, 131: 6, 102: 3, 113: 5, 99: 3, 36: 3, 24: 2, 53: 2, 72: 4} {156: 1, 1: 10, 4: 3, 9: 6, 10: 4, 15: 2, 24: 3, 25: 4, 26: 5, 27: 2, 39: 6, 43: 4, 49: 6, 50: 5, 58: 5, 59: 3, 64: 2, 69: 5, 81: 5, 82: 3, 86: 3, 96: 4, 97: 3, 100: 6, 108: 4, 109: 5, 110: 5, 111: 3, 114: 4, 115: 5, 116: 2, 118: 7, 119: 6, 120: 4, 121: 5, 122: 3, 123: 2, 124: 5, 128: 4, 129: 3, 130: 5, 132: 5, 136: 3, 145: 5, 147: 4, 151: 4, 152: 4, 154: 4, 161: 4, 162: 4, 165: 4, 168: 5, 169: 3, 172: 3, 180: 4, 184: 6, 187: 6, 188: 5, 191: 4, 194: 5, 202: 6, 203: 7, 206: 3, 207: 4, 215: 3, 217: 4, 218: 9, 220: 3, 221: 3, 222: 6, 224: 4, 227: 4, 229: 3, 234: 6, 235: 3, 241: 3, 242: 3, 243: 5, 244: 4, 245: 5, 248: 4, 250: 3, 258: 12, 262: 5, 263: 6, 264: 4, 267: 5, 272: 3, 273: 6, 287: 4, 289: 3, 291: 5, 299: 4, 300: 2, 304: 2, 309: 4, 314: 3, 315: 3, 320: 5, 323: 5, 327: 5, 328: 4, 329: 3, 330: 11, 334: 3, 335: 2, 341: 4, 342: 5, 347: 4, 348: 4, 350: 8, 351: 5, 352: 3, 353: 3, 354: 2, 358: 5, 365: 3, 366: 3, 369: 2, 371: 6, 372: 5, 376: 3, 384: 5, 385: 4, 386: 4, 387: 2, 392: 4, 393: 5, 396: 5, 397: 8, 398: 7, 402: 3} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 97 "IEEEP8021CBdb defines a Mask-and-Match Stream identification function that can be used as a passive function for MPLS DetNet flows." Fixing conformance language Adding more definite references for TSN functions ( i.e. , Clause numbers ) 682dc592b0835e6a0817bcb5dee7aa2a80eb704a 682dc592b0835e6a0817bcb5dee7aa2a80eb704a draft-ietf-detnet-mpls-over-tsn 85d25c76743ed7e65b601d54f78150e74c3aa10e4c1b0b383304ba7887314a95 ['d24a636756b51f5d839dc10d41dce590b0ede734f13951b670b256cfe0f0cb58', '85d25c76743ed7e65b601d54f78150e74c3aa10e4c1b0b383304ba7887314a95', '630a7b3cd3eda2e026f158d16d3e4a4a2526a07124cf77aa8ed446ea760814d8', 'df0a8fe58a4b847540847a789ae8335edbf527c7064a255d6342892256a91000'] A "ieeep8021cbdb defines a mask-and-match stream identification function that can be used as a passive function for mpls detnet flows." {51: 1, 96: 1, 52: 1, 6: 3, 79: 3, 90: 3, 130: 2, 62: 3, 85: 4, 68: 5, 35: 4, 110: 3, 91: 5, 114: 3, 97: 2, 31: 4, 13: 3, 67: 3, 38: 4, 26: 3, 124: 3, 98: 3, 54: 3, 127: 4, 8: 3, 64: 3, 30: 3, 61: 5, 55: 4, 27: 4, 15: 3, 129: 4, 115: 3, 84: 3, 76: 7, 87: 3, 131: 6, 102: 3, 113: 5, 99: 3, 36: 3, 24: 2, 53: 2, 72: 4} {116: 1, 123: 1, 156: 1, 1: 10, 4: 3, 9: 6, 10: 4, 15: 2, 24: 3, 25: 3, 26: 4, 27: 2, 39: 6, 43: 4, 49: 6, 50: 5, 58: 5, 59: 3, 64: 2, 69: 5, 81: 4, 82: 2, 86: 3, 96: 4, 97: 3, 100: 5, 108: 4, 109: 5, 110: 5, 111: 3, 114: 4, 115: 5, 118: 6, 119: 5, 120: 4, 121: 5, 122: 2, 124: 5, 128: 4, 129: 3, 130: 5, 132: 5, 136: 3, 145: 5, 147: 4, 151: 4, 152: 4, 154: 4, 161: 4, 162: 4, 165: 4, 168: 5, 169: 3, 172: 3, 180: 4, 184: 6, 187: 6, 188: 5, 191: 4, 194: 5, 202: 6, 203: 7, 206: 3, 207: 4, 215: 3, 217: 4, 218: 9, 220: 3, 221: 3, 222: 6, 224: 4, 227: 3, 229: 3, 234: 6, 235: 3, 241: 3, 242: 3, 243: 5, 244: 4, 245: 5, 248: 4, 250: 3, 258: 12, 262: 5, 263: 6, 264: 4, 267: 5, 270: 2, 272: 3, 273: 6, 287: 4, 289: 3, 291: 5, 299: 3, 300: 2, 304: 2, 309: 4, 314: 3, 315: 3, 320: 4, 323: 5, 327: 5, 328: 4, 329: 3, 330: 11, 334: 3, 341: 3, 342: 4, 347: 3, 348: 3, 350: 8, 351: 5, 352: 3, 353: 3, 354: 2, 358: 5, 365: 3, 366: 3, 369: 2, 371: 5, 372: 5, 376: 3, 384: 5, 385: 4, 386: 4, 387: 2, 392: 4, 393: 5, 396: 4, 397: 8, 398: 7, 402: 3} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 97 "IEEE8021CB defines an Active Destination MAC and VLAN Stream identification function, what can replace some Ethernet header fields namely (1) the destination MAC-address, (2) the VLAN-ID and (3) priority parameters with alternate values. Replacement is provided for the frame passed down the stack from the upper layers or up the stack from the lower layers." Fixing conformance language Adding more definite references for TSN functions ( i.e. , Clause numbers ) 682dc592b0835e6a0817bcb5dee7aa2a80eb704a 682dc592b0835e6a0817bcb5dee7aa2a80eb704a draft-ietf-detnet-mpls-over-tsn 630a7b3cd3eda2e026f158d16d3e4a4a2526a07124cf77aa8ed446ea760814d8 ['d24a636756b51f5d839dc10d41dce590b0ede734f13951b670b256cfe0f0cb58', '85d25c76743ed7e65b601d54f78150e74c3aa10e4c1b0b383304ba7887314a95', '630a7b3cd3eda2e026f158d16d3e4a4a2526a07124cf77aa8ed446ea760814d8', 'df0a8fe58a4b847540847a789ae8335edbf527c7064a255d6342892256a91000'] A "ieee8021cb defines an active destination mac and vlan stream identification function, what can replace some ethernet header fields namely (1) the destination mac-address, (2) the vlan-id and (3) priority parameters with alternate values. replacement is provided for the frame passed down the stack from the upper layers or up the stack from the lower layers." {51: 1, 96: 1, 52: 1, 6: 3, 79: 3, 90: 3, 130: 2, 62: 3, 85: 4, 68: 5, 35: 4, 110: 3, 91: 5, 114: 3, 97: 2, 31: 4, 13: 3, 67: 3, 38: 4, 26: 3, 124: 3, 98: 3, 54: 3, 127: 4, 8: 3, 64: 3, 30: 3, 61: 5, 55: 4, 27: 4, 15: 3, 129: 4, 115: 3, 84: 3, 76: 7, 87: 3, 131: 6, 102: 3, 113: 5, 99: 3, 36: 3, 24: 2, 53: 2, 72: 4} {116: 1, 123: 1, 156: 1, 1: 10, 4: 3, 9: 6, 10: 4, 15: 2, 24: 3, 25: 3, 26: 4, 27: 2, 39: 6, 43: 4, 49: 6, 50: 5, 58: 5, 59: 3, 64: 2, 69: 5, 81: 4, 82: 2, 86: 3, 96: 4, 97: 3, 100: 5, 108: 4, 109: 5, 110: 5, 111: 3, 114: 4, 115: 5, 118: 6, 119: 5, 120: 4, 121: 5, 122: 2, 124: 5, 128: 4, 129: 3, 130: 5, 132: 5, 136: 3, 145: 5, 147: 4, 151: 4, 152: 4, 154: 4, 161: 4, 162: 4, 165: 4, 168: 5, 169: 3, 172: 3, 180: 4, 184: 6, 187: 6, 188: 5, 191: 4, 194: 5, 202: 6, 203: 7, 206: 3, 207: 4, 215: 3, 217: 4, 218: 9, 220: 3, 221: 3, 222: 6, 224: 4, 227: 3, 229: 3, 234: 6, 235: 3, 241: 3, 242: 3, 243: 5, 244: 4, 245: 5, 248: 4, 250: 3, 258: 12, 262: 5, 263: 6, 264: 4, 267: 5, 270: 2, 272: 3, 273: 6, 287: 4, 289: 3, 291: 5, 299: 3, 300: 2, 304: 2, 309: 4, 314: 3, 315: 3, 320: 4, 323: 5, 327: 5, 328: 4, 329: 3, 330: 11, 334: 3, 341: 3, 342: 4, 347: 3, 348: 3, 350: 8, 351: 5, 352: 3, 353: 3, 354: 2, 358: 5, 365: 3, 366: 3, 369: 2, 371: 5, 372: 5, 376: 3, 384: 5, 385: 4, 386: 4, 387: 2, 392: 4, 393: 5, 396: 4, 397: 8, 398: 7, 402: 3} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 97 "Clause 6.8 of IEEEP8021CBdb defines a Mask-and-Match Stream identification function that can be used as a passive function for MPLS DetNet flows." Fixing conformance language Adding more definite references for TSN functions ( i.e. , Clause numbers ) 682dc592b0835e6a0817bcb5dee7aa2a80eb704a 682dc592b0835e6a0817bcb5dee7aa2a80eb704a draft-ietf-detnet-mpls-over-tsn df0a8fe58a4b847540847a789ae8335edbf527c7064a255d6342892256a91000 ['d24a636756b51f5d839dc10d41dce590b0ede734f13951b670b256cfe0f0cb58', '85d25c76743ed7e65b601d54f78150e74c3aa10e4c1b0b383304ba7887314a95', '630a7b3cd3eda2e026f158d16d3e4a4a2526a07124cf77aa8ed446ea760814d8', 'df0a8fe58a4b847540847a789ae8335edbf527c7064a255d6342892256a91000'] B "clause 6.8 of ieeep8021cbdb defines a mask-and-match stream identification function that can be used as a passive function for mpls detnet flows." {51: 1, 96: 1, 52: 1, 6: 3, 79: 3, 90: 3, 130: 2, 62: 3, 85: 4, 68: 5, 35: 4, 110: 3, 91: 5, 114: 3, 97: 2, 31: 4, 13: 3, 67: 3, 38: 4, 26: 3, 124: 3, 98: 3, 54: 3, 127: 4, 8: 3, 64: 3, 30: 3, 61: 5, 55: 4, 27: 4, 15: 3, 129: 4, 115: 3, 84: 3, 76: 7, 87: 3, 131: 6, 102: 3, 113: 5, 99: 3, 36: 3, 24: 2, 53: 2, 72: 4} {116: 1, 123: 1, 156: 1, 1: 10, 4: 3, 9: 6, 10: 4, 15: 2, 24: 3, 25: 3, 26: 4, 27: 2, 39: 6, 43: 4, 49: 6, 50: 5, 58: 5, 59: 3, 64: 2, 69: 5, 81: 4, 82: 2, 86: 3, 96: 4, 97: 3, 100: 5, 108: 4, 109: 5, 110: 5, 111: 3, 114: 4, 115: 5, 118: 6, 119: 5, 120: 4, 121: 5, 122: 2, 124: 5, 128: 4, 129: 3, 130: 5, 132: 5, 136: 3, 145: 5, 147: 4, 151: 4, 152: 4, 154: 4, 161: 4, 162: 4, 165: 4, 168: 5, 169: 3, 172: 3, 180: 4, 184: 6, 187: 6, 188: 5, 191: 4, 194: 5, 202: 6, 203: 7, 206: 3, 207: 4, 215: 3, 217: 4, 218: 9, 220: 3, 221: 3, 222: 6, 224: 4, 227: 3, 229: 3, 234: 6, 235: 3, 241: 3, 242: 3, 243: 5, 244: 4, 245: 5, 248: 4, 250: 3, 258: 12, 262: 5, 263: 6, 264: 4, 267: 5, 270: 2, 272: 3, 273: 6, 287: 4, 289: 3, 291: 5, 299: 3, 300: 2, 304: 2, 309: 4, 314: 3, 315: 3, 320: 4, 323: 5, 327: 5, 328: 4, 329: 3, 330: 11, 334: 3, 341: 3, 342: 4, 347: 3, 348: 3, 350: 8, 351: 5, 352: 3, 353: 3, 354: 2, 358: 5, 365: 3, 366: 3, 369: 2, 371: 5, 372: 5, 376: 3, 384: 5, 385: 4, 386: 4, 387: 2, 392: 4, 393: 5, 396: 4, 397: 8, 398: 7, 402: 3} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 97 "Clause 6.6 of IEEE8021CB defines an Active Destination MAC and VLAN Stream identification function, what can replace some Ethernet header fields namely (1) the destination MAC-address, (2) the VLAN-ID and (3) priority parameters with alternate values. Replacement is provided for the frame passed down the stack from the upper layers or up the stack from the lower layers." Fixing conformance language Adding more definite references for TSN functions ( i.e. , Clause numbers ) 682dc592b0835e6a0817bcb5dee7aa2a80eb704a 682dc592b0835e6a0817bcb5dee7aa2a80eb704a draft-ietf-detnet-mpls-over-tsn d24a636756b51f5d839dc10d41dce590b0ede734f13951b670b256cfe0f0cb58 ['d24a636756b51f5d839dc10d41dce590b0ede734f13951b670b256cfe0f0cb58', '85d25c76743ed7e65b601d54f78150e74c3aa10e4c1b0b383304ba7887314a95', '630a7b3cd3eda2e026f158d16d3e4a4a2526a07124cf77aa8ed446ea760814d8', 'df0a8fe58a4b847540847a789ae8335edbf527c7064a255d6342892256a91000'] B "clause 6.6 of ieee8021cb defines an active destination mac and vlan stream identification function, what can replace some ethernet header fields namely (1) the destination mac-address, (2) the vlan-id and (3) priority parameters with alternate values. replacement is provided for the frame passed down the stack from the upper layers or up the stack from the lower layers." {51: 1, 96: 1, 52: 1, 6: 3, 79: 3, 90: 3, 130: 2, 62: 3, 85: 4, 68: 5, 35: 4, 110: 3, 91: 5, 114: 3, 97: 2, 31: 4, 13: 3, 67: 3, 38: 4, 26: 3, 124: 3, 98: 3, 54: 3, 127: 4, 8: 3, 64: 3, 30: 3, 61: 5, 55: 4, 27: 4, 15: 3, 129: 4, 115: 3, 84: 3, 76: 7, 87: 3, 131: 6, 102: 3, 113: 5, 99: 3, 36: 3, 24: 2, 53: 2, 72: 4} {116: 1, 123: 1, 156: 1, 1: 10, 4: 3, 9: 6, 10: 4, 15: 2, 24: 3, 25: 3, 26: 4, 27: 2, 39: 6, 43: 4, 49: 6, 50: 5, 58: 5, 59: 3, 64: 2, 69: 5, 81: 4, 82: 2, 86: 3, 96: 4, 97: 3, 100: 5, 108: 4, 109: 5, 110: 5, 111: 3, 114: 4, 115: 5, 118: 6, 119: 5, 120: 4, 121: 5, 122: 2, 124: 5, 128: 4, 129: 3, 130: 5, 132: 5, 136: 3, 145: 5, 147: 4, 151: 4, 152: 4, 154: 4, 161: 4, 162: 4, 165: 4, 168: 5, 169: 3, 172: 3, 180: 4, 184: 6, 187: 6, 188: 5, 191: 4, 194: 5, 202: 6, 203: 7, 206: 3, 207: 4, 215: 3, 217: 4, 218: 9, 220: 3, 221: 3, 222: 6, 224: 4, 227: 3, 229: 3, 234: 6, 235: 3, 241: 3, 242: 3, 243: 5, 244: 4, 245: 5, 248: 4, 250: 3, 258: 12, 262: 5, 263: 6, 264: 4, 267: 5, 270: 2, 272: 3, 273: 6, 287: 4, 289: 3, 291: 5, 299: 3, 300: 2, 304: 2, 309: 4, 314: 3, 315: 3, 320: 4, 323: 5, 327: 5, 328: 4, 329: 3, 330: 11, 334: 3, 341: 3, 342: 4, 347: 3, 348: 3, 350: 8, 351: 5, 352: 3, 353: 3, 354: 2, 358: 5, 365: 3, 366: 3, 369: 2, 371: 5, 372: 5, 376: 3, 384: 5, 385: 4, 386: 4, 387: 2, 392: 4, 393: 5, 396: 4, 397: 8, 398: 7, 402: 3} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 97 "This section covers required behavior of a TSN-aware MPLS (DetNet) node using a TSN sub-network." Fixing conformance language Adding more definite references for TSN functions ( i.e. , Clause numbers ) 682dc592b0835e6a0817bcb5dee7aa2a80eb704a 682dc592b0835e6a0817bcb5dee7aa2a80eb704a draft-ietf-detnet-mpls-over-tsn 314017bb601d7806be2da63e51d3ee14147fa3ac35c6b85ba05825de7c5de742 ['314017bb601d7806be2da63e51d3ee14147fa3ac35c6b85ba05825de7c5de742', '8e70c59c65b9b1a2240488b25484eb6555a4ce53dcd771754e519a71ea790513'] A "this section covers required behavior of a tsn-aware mpls (detnet) node using a tsn sub-network." {52: 1, 6: 3, 79: 3, 90: 3, 51: 2, 130: 2, 62: 4, 85: 5, 68: 5, 35: 4, 110: 3, 91: 5, 114: 3, 31: 4, 13: 3, 67: 3, 38: 4, 26: 3, 124: 4, 98: 3, 54: 3, 127: 4, 8: 3, 96: 2, 64: 3, 30: 3, 61: 5, 55: 4, 27: 4, 15: 3, 129: 4, 115: 3, 84: 3, 76: 7, 87: 3, 131: 6, 97: 2, 102: 3, 113: 5, 99: 3, 36: 3, 24: 2, 53: 2, 72: 4} {156: 1, 1: 10, 4: 3, 9: 6, 10: 4, 15: 2, 24: 3, 25: 4, 26: 5, 27: 2, 39: 6, 43: 4, 49: 6, 50: 5, 58: 5, 59: 3, 69: 5, 81: 5, 82: 3, 86: 3, 96: 4, 97: 3, 100: 6, 108: 4, 109: 5, 110: 5, 111: 3, 114: 4, 115: 5, 116: 2, 118: 7, 119: 6, 120: 4, 121: 5, 122: 3, 123: 2, 124: 5, 128: 4, 129: 3, 130: 5, 132: 5, 136: 3, 145: 5, 147: 4, 151: 4, 152: 4, 154: 4, 161: 4, 162: 4, 165: 4, 168: 5, 169: 3, 172: 3, 180: 4, 184: 6, 187: 6, 188: 5, 191: 4, 194: 5, 202: 6, 203: 7, 206: 3, 207: 4, 215: 3, 217: 4, 218: 9, 220: 3, 221: 3, 222: 6, 224: 4, 227: 4, 229: 3, 234: 6, 235: 3, 241: 3, 242: 3, 243: 5, 244: 4, 245: 5, 248: 4, 250: 3, 258: 12, 262: 5, 263: 6, 264: 4, 267: 5, 270: 2, 272: 3, 273: 6, 287: 4, 289: 3, 291: 5, 299: 4, 300: 2, 304: 2, 309: 4, 314: 3, 315: 3, 320: 5, 323: 5, 327: 5, 328: 4, 329: 3, 330: 11, 334: 3, 335: 2, 341: 4, 342: 5, 347: 4, 348: 4, 350: 8, 351: 5, 352: 3, 353: 3, 354: 2, 358: 5, 365: 3, 366: 3, 369: 2, 371: 6, 372: 5, 376: 3, 384: 5, 385: 4, 386: 4, 387: 2, 392: 4, 393: 5, 396: 5, 397: 8, 398: 7, 402: 3} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 97 "This section covers required behavior of a TSN-aware MPLS (DetNet) node using a TSN sub-network. The implementation of TSN packet processing functions MUST be compliant with the relevant IEEE 802.1 standards." Fixing conformance language Adding more definite references for TSN functions ( i.e. , Clause numbers ) 682dc592b0835e6a0817bcb5dee7aa2a80eb704a 682dc592b0835e6a0817bcb5dee7aa2a80eb704a draft-ietf-detnet-mpls-over-tsn 8e70c59c65b9b1a2240488b25484eb6555a4ce53dcd771754e519a71ea790513 ['314017bb601d7806be2da63e51d3ee14147fa3ac35c6b85ba05825de7c5de742', '8e70c59c65b9b1a2240488b25484eb6555a4ce53dcd771754e519a71ea790513'] B "this section covers required behavior of a tsn-aware mpls (detnet) node using a tsn sub-network. the implementation of tsn packet processing functions must be compliant with the relevant ieee 802.1 standards." {52: 1, 6: 3, 79: 3, 90: 3, 51: 2, 130: 2, 62: 4, 85: 5, 68: 5, 35: 4, 110: 3, 91: 5, 114: 3, 31: 4, 13: 3, 67: 3, 38: 4, 26: 3, 124: 4, 98: 3, 54: 3, 127: 4, 8: 3, 96: 2, 64: 3, 30: 3, 61: 5, 55: 4, 27: 4, 15: 3, 129: 4, 115: 3, 84: 3, 76: 7, 87: 3, 131: 6, 97: 2, 102: 3, 113: 5, 99: 3, 36: 3, 24: 2, 53: 2, 72: 4} {156: 1, 1: 10, 4: 3, 9: 6, 10: 4, 15: 2, 24: 3, 25: 4, 26: 5, 27: 2, 39: 6, 43: 4, 49: 6, 50: 5, 58: 5, 59: 3, 69: 5, 81: 5, 82: 3, 86: 3, 96: 4, 97: 3, 100: 6, 108: 4, 109: 5, 110: 5, 111: 3, 114: 4, 115: 5, 116: 2, 118: 7, 119: 6, 120: 4, 121: 5, 122: 3, 123: 2, 124: 5, 128: 4, 129: 3, 130: 5, 132: 5, 136: 3, 145: 5, 147: 4, 151: 4, 152: 4, 154: 4, 161: 4, 162: 4, 165: 4, 168: 5, 169: 3, 172: 3, 180: 4, 184: 6, 187: 6, 188: 5, 191: 4, 194: 5, 202: 6, 203: 7, 206: 3, 207: 4, 215: 3, 217: 4, 218: 9, 220: 3, 221: 3, 222: 6, 224: 4, 227: 4, 229: 3, 234: 6, 235: 3, 241: 3, 242: 3, 243: 5, 244: 4, 245: 5, 248: 4, 250: 3, 258: 12, 262: 5, 263: 6, 264: 4, 267: 5, 270: 2, 272: 3, 273: 6, 287: 4, 289: 3, 291: 5, 299: 4, 300: 2, 304: 2, 309: 4, 314: 3, 315: 3, 320: 5, 323: 5, 327: 5, 328: 4, 329: 3, 330: 11, 334: 3, 335: 2, 341: 4, 342: 5, 347: 4, 348: 4, 350: 8, 351: 5, 352: 3, 353: 3, 354: 2, 358: 5, 365: 3, 366: 3, 369: 2, 371: 6, 372: 5, 376: 3, 384: 5, 385: 4, 386: 4, 387: 2, 392: 4, 393: 5, 396: 5, 397: 8, 398: 7, 402: 3} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 97 "A TSN-aware MPLS (DetNet) node implementations MUST support the Sequencing function and the Sequence encode/decode function as defined in IEEE8021CB if FRER is used inside the TSN sub-network." Fixing conformance language Adding more definite references for TSN functions ( i.e. , Clause numbers ) 682dc592b0835e6a0817bcb5dee7aa2a80eb704a 682dc592b0835e6a0817bcb5dee7aa2a80eb704a draft-ietf-detnet-mpls-over-tsn 0246ffa7291c42bc165b0ac6acf1fc7285b5e41537731f44da530521ca5615d1 ['f24867bed3f59918d8b129c87f811a512fe7da16e6902f9926748d1d7338b34a', '0246ffa7291c42bc165b0ac6acf1fc7285b5e41537731f44da530521ca5615d1', '214810fe3ac0ef76db60e2d0623a8259b9bdf49040882a9e710901fe1eb32fde', 'ab53f0283dfc6a938ab85afcd9676923433c5b54408e584b493487c049a1acbe', '1e0f0046d820cf110ea005775dc60061aa1a4e522ecb86348ed2dfa748ba5c0d', '139b8c43623bbe83d6e84c494389cef4e57e6816c2829cf9bcbb604af1f3bd70'] A "a tsn-aware mpls (detnet) node implementations must support the sequencing function and the sequence encode/decode function as defined in ieee8021cb if frer is used inside the tsn sub-network." {51: 1, 52: 1, 96: 1, 6: 3, 79: 3, 90: 3, 130: 2, 62: 4, 85: 5, 68: 5, 35: 4, 110: 3, 91: 5, 114: 3, 97: 2, 31: 4, 13: 3, 67: 3, 38: 4, 26: 3, 124: 4, 98: 3, 54: 3, 127: 4, 8: 3, 64: 3, 30: 3, 61: 5, 55: 4, 27: 4, 15: 3, 129: 4, 115: 3, 84: 3, 76: 7, 87: 3, 131: 6, 102: 3, 113: 5, 99: 3, 36: 3, 24: 2, 53: 2, 72: 4} {15: 1, 156: 1, 300: 1, 1: 10, 4: 3, 9: 6, 10: 4, 24: 3, 25: 4, 26: 5, 27: 2, 39: 6, 43: 4, 49: 6, 50: 5, 58: 5, 59: 3, 64: 2, 69: 5, 81: 5, 82: 3, 86: 3, 96: 4, 97: 3, 100: 6, 108: 4, 109: 5, 110: 5, 111: 3, 114: 4, 115: 5, 116: 2, 118: 7, 119: 6, 120: 4, 121: 5, 122: 3, 123: 2, 124: 5, 128: 4, 129: 3, 130: 5, 132: 5, 136: 3, 145: 5, 147: 4, 151: 4, 152: 4, 154: 4, 161: 4, 162: 4, 165: 4, 168: 5, 169: 3, 172: 3, 180: 4, 184: 6, 187: 6, 188: 5, 191: 4, 194: 5, 202: 6, 203: 7, 206: 3, 207: 4, 215: 3, 217: 4, 218: 9, 220: 3, 221: 3, 222: 6, 224: 4, 227: 4, 229: 3, 234: 6, 235: 3, 241: 3, 242: 3, 243: 5, 244: 4, 245: 5, 248: 4, 250: 2, 258: 12, 262: 5, 263: 6, 264: 4, 267: 5, 270: 2, 272: 3, 273: 6, 287: 4, 289: 3, 291: 5, 299: 4, 304: 2, 309: 4, 314: 3, 315: 3, 320: 5, 323: 5, 327: 5, 328: 4, 329: 3, 330: 11, 334: 3, 335: 2, 341: 4, 342: 5, 347: 4, 348: 4, 350: 8, 351: 5, 352: 3, 353: 3, 354: 2, 358: 5, 365: 3, 366: 3, 369: 2, 371: 6, 372: 5, 376: 3, 384: 5, 385: 4, 386: 4, 392: 4, 393: 5, 396: 5, 397: 8, 398: 7, 402: 3} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 97 "A TSN-aware MPLS (DetNet) node implementations MUST support the Stream splitting function and the Individual recovery function as defined in IEEE8021CB when the node is a replication or elimination point for FRER." Fixing conformance language Adding more definite references for TSN functions ( i.e. , Clause numbers ) 682dc592b0835e6a0817bcb5dee7aa2a80eb704a 682dc592b0835e6a0817bcb5dee7aa2a80eb704a draft-ietf-detnet-mpls-over-tsn 139b8c43623bbe83d6e84c494389cef4e57e6816c2829cf9bcbb604af1f3bd70 ['f24867bed3f59918d8b129c87f811a512fe7da16e6902f9926748d1d7338b34a', '0246ffa7291c42bc165b0ac6acf1fc7285b5e41537731f44da530521ca5615d1', '214810fe3ac0ef76db60e2d0623a8259b9bdf49040882a9e710901fe1eb32fde', 'ab53f0283dfc6a938ab85afcd9676923433c5b54408e584b493487c049a1acbe', '1e0f0046d820cf110ea005775dc60061aa1a4e522ecb86348ed2dfa748ba5c0d', '139b8c43623bbe83d6e84c494389cef4e57e6816c2829cf9bcbb604af1f3bd70'] A "a tsn-aware mpls (detnet) node implementations must support the stream splitting function and the individual recovery function as defined in ieee8021cb when the node is a replication or elimination point for frer." {51: 1, 52: 1, 96: 1, 6: 3, 79: 3, 90: 3, 130: 2, 62: 4, 85: 5, 68: 5, 35: 4, 110: 3, 91: 5, 114: 3, 97: 2, 31: 4, 13: 3, 67: 3, 38: 4, 26: 3, 124: 4, 98: 3, 54: 3, 127: 4, 8: 3, 64: 3, 30: 3, 61: 5, 55: 4, 27: 4, 15: 3, 129: 4, 115: 3, 84: 3, 76: 7, 87: 3, 131: 6, 102: 3, 113: 5, 99: 3, 36: 3, 24: 2, 53: 2, 72: 4} {15: 1, 156: 1, 300: 1, 1: 10, 4: 3, 9: 6, 10: 4, 24: 3, 25: 4, 26: 5, 27: 2, 39: 6, 43: 4, 49: 6, 50: 5, 58: 5, 59: 3, 64: 2, 69: 5, 81: 5, 82: 3, 86: 3, 96: 4, 97: 3, 100: 6, 108: 4, 109: 5, 110: 5, 111: 3, 114: 4, 115: 5, 116: 2, 118: 7, 119: 6, 120: 4, 121: 5, 122: 3, 123: 2, 124: 5, 128: 4, 129: 3, 130: 5, 132: 5, 136: 3, 145: 5, 147: 4, 151: 4, 152: 4, 154: 4, 161: 4, 162: 4, 165: 4, 168: 5, 169: 3, 172: 3, 180: 4, 184: 6, 187: 6, 188: 5, 191: 4, 194: 5, 202: 6, 203: 7, 206: 3, 207: 4, 215: 3, 217: 4, 218: 9, 220: 3, 221: 3, 222: 6, 224: 4, 227: 4, 229: 3, 234: 6, 235: 3, 241: 3, 242: 3, 243: 5, 244: 4, 245: 5, 248: 4, 250: 2, 258: 12, 262: 5, 263: 6, 264: 4, 267: 5, 270: 2, 272: 3, 273: 6, 287: 4, 289: 3, 291: 5, 299: 4, 304: 2, 309: 4, 314: 3, 315: 3, 320: 5, 323: 5, 327: 5, 328: 4, 329: 3, 330: 11, 334: 3, 335: 2, 341: 4, 342: 5, 347: 4, 348: 4, 350: 8, 351: 5, 352: 3, 353: 3, 354: 2, 358: 5, 365: 3, 366: 3, 369: 2, 371: 6, 372: 5, 376: 3, 384: 5, 385: 4, 386: 4, 392: 4, 393: 5, 396: 5, 397: 8, 398: 7, 402: 3} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 97 "TSN Streams supporting DetNet flows may use Frame Replication and Elimination for Redundancy (FRER) as defined in IEEE8021CB based on the loss service requirements of the TSN Stream, which is derived from the DetNet service requirements of the DetNet mapped flow. The specific operation of FRER is not modified by the use of DetNet and follows IEEE8021CB." Fixing conformance language Adding more definite references for TSN functions ( i.e. , Clause numbers ) 682dc592b0835e6a0817bcb5dee7aa2a80eb704a 682dc592b0835e6a0817bcb5dee7aa2a80eb704a draft-ietf-detnet-mpls-over-tsn 214810fe3ac0ef76db60e2d0623a8259b9bdf49040882a9e710901fe1eb32fde ['f24867bed3f59918d8b129c87f811a512fe7da16e6902f9926748d1d7338b34a', '0246ffa7291c42bc165b0ac6acf1fc7285b5e41537731f44da530521ca5615d1', '214810fe3ac0ef76db60e2d0623a8259b9bdf49040882a9e710901fe1eb32fde', 'ab53f0283dfc6a938ab85afcd9676923433c5b54408e584b493487c049a1acbe', '1e0f0046d820cf110ea005775dc60061aa1a4e522ecb86348ed2dfa748ba5c0d', '139b8c43623bbe83d6e84c494389cef4e57e6816c2829cf9bcbb604af1f3bd70'] A "tsn streams supporting detnet flows may use frame replication and elimination for redundancy (frer) as defined in ieee8021cb based on the loss service requirements of the tsn stream, which is derived from the detnet service requirements of the detnet mapped flow. the specific operation of frer is not modified by the use of detnet and follows ieee8021cb." {51: 1, 52: 1, 96: 1, 6: 3, 79: 3, 90: 3, 130: 2, 62: 4, 85: 5, 68: 5, 35: 4, 110: 3, 91: 5, 114: 3, 97: 2, 31: 4, 13: 3, 67: 3, 38: 4, 26: 3, 124: 4, 98: 3, 54: 3, 127: 4, 8: 3, 64: 3, 30: 3, 61: 5, 55: 4, 27: 4, 15: 3, 129: 4, 115: 3, 84: 3, 76: 7, 87: 3, 131: 6, 102: 3, 113: 5, 99: 3, 36: 3, 24: 2, 53: 2, 72: 4} {15: 1, 156: 1, 300: 1, 1: 10, 4: 3, 9: 6, 10: 4, 24: 3, 25: 4, 26: 5, 27: 2, 39: 6, 43: 4, 49: 6, 50: 5, 58: 5, 59: 3, 64: 2, 69: 5, 81: 5, 82: 3, 86: 3, 96: 4, 97: 3, 100: 6, 108: 4, 109: 5, 110: 5, 111: 3, 114: 4, 115: 5, 116: 2, 118: 7, 119: 6, 120: 4, 121: 5, 122: 3, 123: 2, 124: 5, 128: 4, 129: 3, 130: 5, 132: 5, 136: 3, 145: 5, 147: 4, 151: 4, 152: 4, 154: 4, 161: 4, 162: 4, 165: 4, 168: 5, 169: 3, 172: 3, 180: 4, 184: 6, 187: 6, 188: 5, 191: 4, 194: 5, 202: 6, 203: 7, 206: 3, 207: 4, 215: 3, 217: 4, 218: 9, 220: 3, 221: 3, 222: 6, 224: 4, 227: 4, 229: 3, 234: 6, 235: 3, 241: 3, 242: 3, 243: 5, 244: 4, 245: 5, 248: 4, 250: 2, 258: 12, 262: 5, 263: 6, 264: 4, 267: 5, 270: 2, 272: 3, 273: 6, 287: 4, 289: 3, 291: 5, 299: 4, 304: 2, 309: 4, 314: 3, 315: 3, 320: 5, 323: 5, 327: 5, 328: 4, 329: 3, 330: 11, 334: 3, 335: 2, 341: 4, 342: 5, 347: 4, 348: 4, 350: 8, 351: 5, 352: 3, 353: 3, 354: 2, 358: 5, 365: 3, 366: 3, 369: 2, 371: 6, 372: 5, 376: 3, 384: 5, 385: 4, 386: 4, 392: 4, 393: 5, 396: 5, 397: 8, 398: 7, 402: 3} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 97 "A TSN-aware MPLS (DetNet) node implementations MUST support the Sequencing function and the Sequence encode/decode function as defined in Clause 7.4 and 7.6 of IEEE8021CB if FRER is used inside the TSN sub-network." Fixing conformance language Adding more definite references for TSN functions ( i.e. , Clause numbers ) 682dc592b0835e6a0817bcb5dee7aa2a80eb704a 682dc592b0835e6a0817bcb5dee7aa2a80eb704a draft-ietf-detnet-mpls-over-tsn 1e0f0046d820cf110ea005775dc60061aa1a4e522ecb86348ed2dfa748ba5c0d ['f24867bed3f59918d8b129c87f811a512fe7da16e6902f9926748d1d7338b34a', '0246ffa7291c42bc165b0ac6acf1fc7285b5e41537731f44da530521ca5615d1', '214810fe3ac0ef76db60e2d0623a8259b9bdf49040882a9e710901fe1eb32fde', 'ab53f0283dfc6a938ab85afcd9676923433c5b54408e584b493487c049a1acbe', '1e0f0046d820cf110ea005775dc60061aa1a4e522ecb86348ed2dfa748ba5c0d', '139b8c43623bbe83d6e84c494389cef4e57e6816c2829cf9bcbb604af1f3bd70'] B "a tsn-aware mpls (detnet) node implementations must support the sequencing function and the sequence encode/decode function as defined in clause 7.4 and 7.6 of ieee8021cb if frer is used inside the tsn sub-network." {51: 1, 52: 1, 96: 1, 6: 3, 79: 3, 90: 3, 130: 2, 62: 4, 85: 5, 68: 5, 35: 4, 110: 3, 91: 5, 114: 3, 97: 2, 31: 4, 13: 3, 67: 3, 38: 4, 26: 3, 124: 4, 98: 3, 54: 3, 127: 4, 8: 3, 64: 3, 30: 3, 61: 5, 55: 4, 27: 4, 15: 3, 129: 4, 115: 3, 84: 3, 76: 7, 87: 3, 131: 6, 102: 3, 113: 5, 99: 3, 36: 3, 24: 2, 53: 2, 72: 4} {15: 1, 156: 1, 300: 1, 1: 10, 4: 3, 9: 6, 10: 4, 24: 3, 25: 4, 26: 5, 27: 2, 39: 6, 43: 4, 49: 6, 50: 5, 58: 5, 59: 3, 64: 2, 69: 5, 81: 5, 82: 3, 86: 3, 96: 4, 97: 3, 100: 6, 108: 4, 109: 5, 110: 5, 111: 3, 114: 4, 115: 5, 116: 2, 118: 7, 119: 6, 120: 4, 121: 5, 122: 3, 123: 2, 124: 5, 128: 4, 129: 3, 130: 5, 132: 5, 136: 3, 145: 5, 147: 4, 151: 4, 152: 4, 154: 4, 161: 4, 162: 4, 165: 4, 168: 5, 169: 3, 172: 3, 180: 4, 184: 6, 187: 6, 188: 5, 191: 4, 194: 5, 202: 6, 203: 7, 206: 3, 207: 4, 215: 3, 217: 4, 218: 9, 220: 3, 221: 3, 222: 6, 224: 4, 227: 4, 229: 3, 234: 6, 235: 3, 241: 3, 242: 3, 243: 5, 244: 4, 245: 5, 248: 4, 250: 2, 258: 12, 262: 5, 263: 6, 264: 4, 267: 5, 270: 2, 272: 3, 273: 6, 287: 4, 289: 3, 291: 5, 299: 4, 304: 2, 309: 4, 314: 3, 315: 3, 320: 5, 323: 5, 327: 5, 328: 4, 329: 3, 330: 11, 334: 3, 335: 2, 341: 4, 342: 5, 347: 4, 348: 4, 350: 8, 351: 5, 352: 3, 353: 3, 354: 2, 358: 5, 365: 3, 366: 3, 369: 2, 371: 6, 372: 5, 376: 3, 384: 5, 385: 4, 386: 4, 392: 4, 393: 5, 396: 5, 397: 8, 398: 7, 402: 3} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 97 "A TSN-aware MPLS (DetNet) node implementations MUST support the Stream splitting function and the Individual recovery function as defined in Clause 7.7 and 7.5 of IEEE8021CB when the node is a replication or elimination point for FRER." Fixing conformance language Adding more definite references for TSN functions ( i.e. , Clause numbers ) 682dc592b0835e6a0817bcb5dee7aa2a80eb704a 682dc592b0835e6a0817bcb5dee7aa2a80eb704a draft-ietf-detnet-mpls-over-tsn f24867bed3f59918d8b129c87f811a512fe7da16e6902f9926748d1d7338b34a ['f24867bed3f59918d8b129c87f811a512fe7da16e6902f9926748d1d7338b34a', '0246ffa7291c42bc165b0ac6acf1fc7285b5e41537731f44da530521ca5615d1', '214810fe3ac0ef76db60e2d0623a8259b9bdf49040882a9e710901fe1eb32fde', 'ab53f0283dfc6a938ab85afcd9676923433c5b54408e584b493487c049a1acbe', '1e0f0046d820cf110ea005775dc60061aa1a4e522ecb86348ed2dfa748ba5c0d', '139b8c43623bbe83d6e84c494389cef4e57e6816c2829cf9bcbb604af1f3bd70'] B "a tsn-aware mpls (detnet) node implementations must support the stream splitting function and the individual recovery function as defined in clause 7.7 and 7.5 of ieee8021cb when the node is a replication or elimination point for frer." {51: 1, 52: 1, 96: 1, 6: 3, 79: 3, 90: 3, 130: 2, 62: 4, 85: 5, 68: 5, 35: 4, 110: 3, 91: 5, 114: 3, 97: 2, 31: 4, 13: 3, 67: 3, 38: 4, 26: 3, 124: 4, 98: 3, 54: 3, 127: 4, 8: 3, 64: 3, 30: 3, 61: 5, 55: 4, 27: 4, 15: 3, 129: 4, 115: 3, 84: 3, 76: 7, 87: 3, 131: 6, 102: 3, 113: 5, 99: 3, 36: 3, 24: 2, 53: 2, 72: 4} {15: 1, 156: 1, 300: 1, 1: 10, 4: 3, 9: 6, 10: 4, 24: 3, 25: 4, 26: 5, 27: 2, 39: 6, 43: 4, 49: 6, 50: 5, 58: 5, 59: 3, 64: 2, 69: 5, 81: 5, 82: 3, 86: 3, 96: 4, 97: 3, 100: 6, 108: 4, 109: 5, 110: 5, 111: 3, 114: 4, 115: 5, 116: 2, 118: 7, 119: 6, 120: 4, 121: 5, 122: 3, 123: 2, 124: 5, 128: 4, 129: 3, 130: 5, 132: 5, 136: 3, 145: 5, 147: 4, 151: 4, 152: 4, 154: 4, 161: 4, 162: 4, 165: 4, 168: 5, 169: 3, 172: 3, 180: 4, 184: 6, 187: 6, 188: 5, 191: 4, 194: 5, 202: 6, 203: 7, 206: 3, 207: 4, 215: 3, 217: 4, 218: 9, 220: 3, 221: 3, 222: 6, 224: 4, 227: 4, 229: 3, 234: 6, 235: 3, 241: 3, 242: 3, 243: 5, 244: 4, 245: 5, 248: 4, 250: 2, 258: 12, 262: 5, 263: 6, 264: 4, 267: 5, 270: 2, 272: 3, 273: 6, 287: 4, 289: 3, 291: 5, 299: 4, 304: 2, 309: 4, 314: 3, 315: 3, 320: 5, 323: 5, 327: 5, 328: 4, 329: 3, 330: 11, 334: 3, 335: 2, 341: 4, 342: 5, 347: 4, 348: 4, 350: 8, 351: 5, 352: 3, 353: 3, 354: 2, 358: 5, 365: 3, 366: 3, 369: 2, 371: 6, 372: 5, 376: 3, 384: 5, 385: 4, 386: 4, 392: 4, 393: 5, 396: 5, 397: 8, 398: 7, 402: 3} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 97 "TSN Streams supporting DetNet flows may use Frame Replication and Elimination for Redundancy (FRER) as defined in Clause 8. of IEEE8021CB based on the loss service requirements of the TSN Stream, which is derived from the DetNet service requirements of the DetNet mapped flow. The specific operation of FRER is not modified by the use of DetNet and follows IEEE8021CB." Fixing conformance language Adding more definite references for TSN functions ( i.e. , Clause numbers ) 682dc592b0835e6a0817bcb5dee7aa2a80eb704a 682dc592b0835e6a0817bcb5dee7aa2a80eb704a draft-ietf-detnet-mpls-over-tsn ab53f0283dfc6a938ab85afcd9676923433c5b54408e584b493487c049a1acbe ['f24867bed3f59918d8b129c87f811a512fe7da16e6902f9926748d1d7338b34a', '0246ffa7291c42bc165b0ac6acf1fc7285b5e41537731f44da530521ca5615d1', '214810fe3ac0ef76db60e2d0623a8259b9bdf49040882a9e710901fe1eb32fde', 'ab53f0283dfc6a938ab85afcd9676923433c5b54408e584b493487c049a1acbe', '1e0f0046d820cf110ea005775dc60061aa1a4e522ecb86348ed2dfa748ba5c0d', '139b8c43623bbe83d6e84c494389cef4e57e6816c2829cf9bcbb604af1f3bd70'] B "tsn streams supporting detnet flows may use frame replication and elimination for redundancy (frer) as defined in clause 8. of ieee8021cb based on the loss service requirements of the tsn stream, which is derived from the detnet service requirements of the detnet mapped flow. the specific operation of frer is not modified by the use of detnet and follows ieee8021cb." {51: 1, 52: 1, 96: 1, 6: 3, 79: 3, 90: 3, 130: 2, 62: 4, 85: 5, 68: 5, 35: 4, 110: 3, 91: 5, 114: 3, 97: 2, 31: 4, 13: 3, 67: 3, 38: 4, 26: 3, 124: 4, 98: 3, 54: 3, 127: 4, 8: 3, 64: 3, 30: 3, 61: 5, 55: 4, 27: 4, 15: 3, 129: 4, 115: 3, 84: 3, 76: 7, 87: 3, 131: 6, 102: 3, 113: 5, 99: 3, 36: 3, 24: 2, 53: 2, 72: 4} {15: 1, 156: 1, 300: 1, 1: 10, 4: 3, 9: 6, 10: 4, 24: 3, 25: 4, 26: 5, 27: 2, 39: 6, 43: 4, 49: 6, 50: 5, 58: 5, 59: 3, 64: 2, 69: 5, 81: 5, 82: 3, 86: 3, 96: 4, 97: 3, 100: 6, 108: 4, 109: 5, 110: 5, 111: 3, 114: 4, 115: 5, 116: 2, 118: 7, 119: 6, 120: 4, 121: 5, 122: 3, 123: 2, 124: 5, 128: 4, 129: 3, 130: 5, 132: 5, 136: 3, 145: 5, 147: 4, 151: 4, 152: 4, 154: 4, 161: 4, 162: 4, 165: 4, 168: 5, 169: 3, 172: 3, 180: 4, 184: 6, 187: 6, 188: 5, 191: 4, 194: 5, 202: 6, 203: 7, 206: 3, 207: 4, 215: 3, 217: 4, 218: 9, 220: 3, 221: 3, 222: 6, 224: 4, 227: 4, 229: 3, 234: 6, 235: 3, 241: 3, 242: 3, 243: 5, 244: 4, 245: 5, 248: 4, 250: 2, 258: 12, 262: 5, 263: 6, 264: 4, 267: 5, 270: 2, 272: 3, 273: 6, 287: 4, 289: 3, 291: 5, 299: 4, 304: 2, 309: 4, 314: 3, 315: 3, 320: 5, 323: 5, 327: 5, 328: 4, 329: 3, 330: 11, 334: 3, 335: 2, 341: 4, 342: 5, 347: 4, 348: 4, 350: 8, 351: 5, 352: 3, 353: 3, 354: 2, 358: 5, 365: 3, 366: 3, 369: 2, 371: 6, 372: 5, 376: 3, 384: 5, 385: 4, 386: 4, 392: 4, 393: 5, 396: 5, 397: 8, 398: 7, 402: 3} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 97 "DetNet MPLS related configuration information according to the DetNet role of the DetNet MPLS node, as per I-D.ietf-detnet-mpls." Fixing conformance language Adding more definite references for TSN functions ( i.e. , Clause numbers ) 682dc592b0835e6a0817bcb5dee7aa2a80eb704a 682dc592b0835e6a0817bcb5dee7aa2a80eb704a draft-ietf-detnet-mpls-over-tsn a6dda5d9b88e1208cc173b1f0ba54c363d3d8765f7bdee7b8ad9924efe718c8a ['0fa066981ce7173ac5c1337eb19532ec6d477367352cf708b24f5d7f909926c0', '43e5814a17a454f50eb0fb05d78e6d6e5f42f589075dc86370a9ed068d1f641f', 'a6dda5d9b88e1208cc173b1f0ba54c363d3d8765f7bdee7b8ad9924efe718c8a', 'fa9ee1de4b90f234826a8ec61f39b313e6f6c07026a1cb63e1bfee8aa1337fc8'] B "detnet mpls related configuration information according to the detnet role of the detnet mpls node, as per i-d.ietf-detnet-mpls." {130: 1, 96: 1, 98: 1, 127: 2, 124: 2} {208: 1, 403: 1, 13: 1, 153: 2, 63: 2} {12, 13, 208, 403, 153, 63} 97 "TSN related configuration information according to the TSN role of the DetNet MPLS node, as per IEEE8021Q, IEEE8021CB and IEEEP8021CBdb." Fixing conformance language Adding more definite references for TSN functions ( i.e. , Clause numbers ) 682dc592b0835e6a0817bcb5dee7aa2a80eb704a 682dc592b0835e6a0817bcb5dee7aa2a80eb704a draft-ietf-detnet-mpls-over-tsn 0fa066981ce7173ac5c1337eb19532ec6d477367352cf708b24f5d7f909926c0 ['0fa066981ce7173ac5c1337eb19532ec6d477367352cf708b24f5d7f909926c0', '43e5814a17a454f50eb0fb05d78e6d6e5f42f589075dc86370a9ed068d1f641f', 'a6dda5d9b88e1208cc173b1f0ba54c363d3d8765f7bdee7b8ad9924efe718c8a', 'fa9ee1de4b90f234826a8ec61f39b313e6f6c07026a1cb63e1bfee8aa1337fc8'] B "tsn related configuration information according to the tsn role of the detnet mpls node, as per ieee8021q, ieee8021cb and ieeep8021cbdb." {130: 1, 96: 1, 98: 1, 127: 2, 124: 2} {208: 1, 403: 1, 13: 1, 153: 2, 63: 2} {12, 13, 208, 403, 153, 63} 97 "Mapping between DetNet MPLS flow(s) (label information: A-labels, S-labels and F-labels as defined in I-D.ietf-detnet-mpls) and TSN Stream(s) (as stream identification information defined in IEEEP8021CBdb). Note, that managed objects for TSN Stream identification can be found in IEEEP8021CBcv." Fixing conformance language Adding more definite references for TSN functions ( i.e. , Clause numbers ) 682dc592b0835e6a0817bcb5dee7aa2a80eb704a 682dc592b0835e6a0817bcb5dee7aa2a80eb704a draft-ietf-detnet-mpls-over-tsn 43e5814a17a454f50eb0fb05d78e6d6e5f42f589075dc86370a9ed068d1f641f ['0fa066981ce7173ac5c1337eb19532ec6d477367352cf708b24f5d7f909926c0', '43e5814a17a454f50eb0fb05d78e6d6e5f42f589075dc86370a9ed068d1f641f', 'a6dda5d9b88e1208cc173b1f0ba54c363d3d8765f7bdee7b8ad9924efe718c8a', 'fa9ee1de4b90f234826a8ec61f39b313e6f6c07026a1cb63e1bfee8aa1337fc8'] B "mapping between detnet mpls flow(s) (label information: a-labels, s-labels and f-labels as defined in i-d.ietf-detnet-mpls) and tsn stream(s) (as stream identification information defined in ieeep8021cbdb). note, that managed objects for tsn stream identification can be found in ieeep8021cbcv." {130: 1, 96: 1, 98: 1, 127: 2, 124: 2} {208: 1, 403: 1, 13: 1, 153: 2, 63: 2} {12, 13, 208, 403, 153, 63} 97 This information MUST be provisioned per DetNet flow. Fixing conformance language Adding more definite references for TSN functions ( i.e. , Clause numbers ) 682dc592b0835e6a0817bcb5dee7aa2a80eb704a 682dc592b0835e6a0817bcb5dee7aa2a80eb704a draft-ietf-detnet-mpls-over-tsn fa9ee1de4b90f234826a8ec61f39b313e6f6c07026a1cb63e1bfee8aa1337fc8 ['0fa066981ce7173ac5c1337eb19532ec6d477367352cf708b24f5d7f909926c0', '43e5814a17a454f50eb0fb05d78e6d6e5f42f589075dc86370a9ed068d1f641f', 'a6dda5d9b88e1208cc173b1f0ba54c363d3d8765f7bdee7b8ad9924efe718c8a', 'fa9ee1de4b90f234826a8ec61f39b313e6f6c07026a1cb63e1bfee8aa1337fc8'] B this information must be provisioned per detnet flow. {130: 1, 96: 1, 98: 1, 127: 2, 124: 2} {208: 1, 403: 1, 13: 1, 153: 2, 63: 2} {12, 13, 208, 403, 153, 63} 97 "The security considerations of DetNet in general are discussed in RFC8655 and I-D.ietf-detnet-security. DetNet IP data plane specific considerations are summarized in I-D.ietf-detnet-ip. Encryption may provided by an underlying sub-net using MACSec IEEE802.1AE-2018 for DetNet IP over TSN flows." Fixing conformance language Adding more definite references for TSN functions ( i.e. , Clause numbers ) 682dc592b0835e6a0817bcb5dee7aa2a80eb704a 682dc592b0835e6a0817bcb5dee7aa2a80eb704a draft-ietf-detnet-mpls-over-tsn cba05296ebb141bdf62c1a9c0f5e737efed328b4fff899c70f6143ddc316e2c9 ['a0e0fcdf5b5fdc8e71b55e1780d9267f201453ab89e2c7f05fc980c2ab0b10b7', '309ff460bb958c980f2550a641cf52f7ab2c4e52f8bc2630c8b7ec877b22742e', 'cba05296ebb141bdf62c1a9c0f5e737efed328b4fff899c70f6143ddc316e2c9', 'b093dff74bf4875a4f90e3908d9bc756c2772e6bbc5fe0e39965853285a7cf4d'] A "the security considerations of detnet in general are discussed in rfc8655 and i-d.ietf-detnet-security. detnet ip data plane specific considerations are summarized in i-d.ietf-detnet-ip. encryption may provided by an underlying sub-net using macsec ieee802.1ae-2018 for detnet ip over tsn flows." {130: 1, 96: 1, 127: 2} {225: 1, 318: 1, 319: 2} {225, 249, 318, 319} 97 "Security considerations for DetNet are described in detail in I- D.ietf-detnet-security. General security considerations are described in RFC8655. DetNet MPLS data plane specific considerations are summarized in I-D.ietf-detnet-mpls. This section considers exclusively security considerations which are specific to the DetNet MPLS over TSN sub-network scenario." Fixing conformance language Adding more definite references for TSN functions ( i.e. , Clause numbers ) 682dc592b0835e6a0817bcb5dee7aa2a80eb704a 682dc592b0835e6a0817bcb5dee7aa2a80eb704a draft-ietf-detnet-mpls-over-tsn a0e0fcdf5b5fdc8e71b55e1780d9267f201453ab89e2c7f05fc980c2ab0b10b7 ['a0e0fcdf5b5fdc8e71b55e1780d9267f201453ab89e2c7f05fc980c2ab0b10b7', '309ff460bb958c980f2550a641cf52f7ab2c4e52f8bc2630c8b7ec877b22742e', 'cba05296ebb141bdf62c1a9c0f5e737efed328b4fff899c70f6143ddc316e2c9', 'b093dff74bf4875a4f90e3908d9bc756c2772e6bbc5fe0e39965853285a7cf4d'] B "security considerations for detnet are described in detail in i- d.ietf-detnet-security. general security considerations are described in rfc8655. detnet mpls data plane specific considerations are summarized in i-d.ietf-detnet-mpls. this section considers exclusively security considerations which are specific to the detnet mpls over tsn sub-network scenario." {130: 1, 96: 1, 127: 2} {225: 1, 318: 1, 319: 2} {225, 249, 318, 319} 97 "The sub-network between DetNet nodes needs to be subject to appropriate confidentiality. Additionally, knowledge of what DetNet/ TSN services are provided by a sub-network may supply information that can be used in a variety of security attacks. The ability to modify information exchanges between connected DetNet nodes may result in bogus operations. Therefore, it is important that the interface between DetNet nodes and TSN sub-network are subject to authorization, authentication, and encryption." Fixing conformance language Adding more definite references for TSN functions ( i.e. , Clause numbers ) 682dc592b0835e6a0817bcb5dee7aa2a80eb704a 682dc592b0835e6a0817bcb5dee7aa2a80eb704a draft-ietf-detnet-mpls-over-tsn b093dff74bf4875a4f90e3908d9bc756c2772e6bbc5fe0e39965853285a7cf4d ['a0e0fcdf5b5fdc8e71b55e1780d9267f201453ab89e2c7f05fc980c2ab0b10b7', '309ff460bb958c980f2550a641cf52f7ab2c4e52f8bc2630c8b7ec877b22742e', 'cba05296ebb141bdf62c1a9c0f5e737efed328b4fff899c70f6143ddc316e2c9', 'b093dff74bf4875a4f90e3908d9bc756c2772e6bbc5fe0e39965853285a7cf4d'] B "the sub-network between detnet nodes needs to be subject to appropriate confidentiality. additionally, knowledge of what detnet/ tsn services are provided by a sub-network may supply information that can be used in a variety of security attacks. the ability to modify information exchanges between connected detnet nodes may result in bogus operations. therefore, it is important that the interface between detnet nodes and tsn sub-network are subject to authorization, authentication, and encryption." {130: 1, 96: 1, 127: 2} {225: 1, 318: 1, 319: 2} {225, 249, 318, 319} 97 "The TSN sub-network operates at Layer-2 so various security mechanisms defined by IEEE can be used to secure the connection between the DetNet nodes (e.g., encryption may be provided using MACSec IEEE802.1AE-2018)." Fixing conformance language Adding more definite references for TSN functions ( i.e. , Clause numbers ) 682dc592b0835e6a0817bcb5dee7aa2a80eb704a 682dc592b0835e6a0817bcb5dee7aa2a80eb704a draft-ietf-detnet-mpls-over-tsn 309ff460bb958c980f2550a641cf52f7ab2c4e52f8bc2630c8b7ec877b22742e ['a0e0fcdf5b5fdc8e71b55e1780d9267f201453ab89e2c7f05fc980c2ab0b10b7', '309ff460bb958c980f2550a641cf52f7ab2c4e52f8bc2630c8b7ec877b22742e', 'cba05296ebb141bdf62c1a9c0f5e737efed328b4fff899c70f6143ddc316e2c9', 'b093dff74bf4875a4f90e3908d9bc756c2772e6bbc5fe0e39965853285a7cf4d'] B "the tsn sub-network operates at layer-2 so various security mechanisms defined by ieee can be used to secure the connection between the detnet nodes (e.g., encryption may be provided using macsec ieee802.1ae-2018)." {130: 1, 96: 1, 127: 2} {225: 1, 318: 1, 319: 2} {225, 249, 318, 319} 96 "Congestion protection, latency control and the resource allocation (queuing, policing, shaping) are supported using the underlying link / sub-net specific mechanisms. Service protections (packet replication and packet elimination functions) are not provided at the DetNet layer end to end due the lack of a unified end to end sequencing information that would be available for intermediate nodes. However, such service protection can be provided on a per underlying L2 link and sub-network basis." Fixing conformance language Adding more definite references for TSN functions ( i.e. , Clause numbers ) 8f154039ea3f048f61ad08104a2c94420471e8b6 8f154039ea3f048f61ad08104a2c94420471e8b6 draft-ietf-detnet-ip-over-tsn 4e26d4b73aeabbe456b8574eceb475840631aa5ff572588e9e8521eb55c3fc82 ['da15d4880e4b0ffd91ed06bbbd91b82967b5072475783d35d73a4d9a24ccdf38', '4e26d4b73aeabbe456b8574eceb475840631aa5ff572588e9e8521eb55c3fc82'] A "congestion protection, latency control and the resource allocation (queuing, policing, shaping) are supported using the underlying link / sub-net specific mechanisms. service protections (packet replication and packet elimination functions) are not provided at the detnet layer end to end due the lack of a unified end to end sequencing information that would be available for intermediate nodes. however, such service protection can be provided on a per underlying l2 link and sub-network basis." {51: 1, 124: 1, 6: 5, 79: 5, 90: 5, 130: 2, 62: 2, 85: 3, 68: 5, 35: 6, 110: 5, 91: 7, 114: 5, 97: 3, 31: 6, 13: 2, 67: 5, 38: 6, 26: 4, 98: 5, 54: 5, 127: 6, 8: 5, 96: 2, 64: 5, 30: 5, 61: 7, 55: 4, 27: 6, 15: 5, 52: 3, 129: 6, 115: 5, 84: 5, 76: 8, 87: 5, 131: 8, 102: 3, 113: 7, 99: 5, 36: 5, 24: 4, 53: 4, 72: 6} {82: 1, 347: 1, 1: 10, 4: 5, 9: 7, 10: 6, 15: 4, 24: 5, 25: 2, 26: 3, 27: 4, 39: 6, 43: 6, 49: 8, 50: 7, 58: 7, 59: 5, 64: 4, 69: 6, 81: 3, 86: 5, 96: 6, 97: 5, 100: 4, 108: 6, 109: 7, 110: 7, 111: 5, 114: 6, 115: 7, 116: 3, 118: 5, 119: 4, 120: 6, 121: 5, 122: 3, 123: 2, 124: 5, 128: 6, 129: 5, 130: 7, 132: 6, 136: 5, 145: 6, 147: 6, 151: 6, 152: 6, 154: 6, 156: 3, 161: 5, 162: 4, 165: 6, 168: 7, 169: 5, 172: 5, 180: 6, 184: 7, 187: 8, 188: 7, 191: 6, 194: 6, 202: 7, 203: 8, 206: 5, 207: 6, 215: 5, 217: 6, 218: 9, 220: 5, 221: 5, 222: 6, 224: 6, 227: 2, 229: 5, 234: 8, 235: 5, 241: 5, 242: 5, 243: 6, 244: 6, 245: 6, 248: 6, 250: 5, 258: 12, 262: 7, 263: 8, 264: 6, 267: 5, 270: 4, 272: 5, 273: 7, 287: 6, 289: 5, 291: 7, 299: 2, 300: 4, 304: 4, 309: 5, 314: 5, 315: 5, 320: 3, 323: 6, 327: 7, 328: 6, 329: 5, 330: 11, 334: 5, 335: 3, 341: 2, 342: 3, 350: 9, 351: 7, 352: 5, 353: 5, 354: 4, 358: 5, 365: 5, 366: 5, 369: 4, 371: 4, 372: 7, 376: 5, 384: 7, 385: 6, 386: 6, 387: 4, 392: 6, 393: 7, 396: 3, 397: 8, 398: 7, 402: 5} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 96 "Congestion protection, latency control and the resource allocation (queuing, policing, shaping) are supported using the underlying link / sub-net specific mechanisms. Service protections (packet replication and packet elimination functions) are not provided at the DetNet layer end-to-end due the lack of a unified end-to-end sequencing information that would be available for intermediate nodes. However, such service protection can be provided on a per underlying L2 link and sub-network basis." Fixing conformance language Adding more definite references for TSN functions ( i.e. , Clause numbers ) 8f154039ea3f048f61ad08104a2c94420471e8b6 8f154039ea3f048f61ad08104a2c94420471e8b6 draft-ietf-detnet-ip-over-tsn da15d4880e4b0ffd91ed06bbbd91b82967b5072475783d35d73a4d9a24ccdf38 ['da15d4880e4b0ffd91ed06bbbd91b82967b5072475783d35d73a4d9a24ccdf38', '4e26d4b73aeabbe456b8574eceb475840631aa5ff572588e9e8521eb55c3fc82'] B "congestion protection, latency control and the resource allocation (queuing, policing, shaping) are supported using the underlying link / sub-net specific mechanisms. service protections (packet replication and packet elimination functions) are not provided at the detnet layer end-to-end due the lack of a unified end-to-end sequencing information that would be available for intermediate nodes. however, such service protection can be provided on a per underlying l2 link and sub-network basis." {51: 1, 124: 1, 6: 5, 79: 5, 90: 5, 130: 2, 62: 2, 85: 3, 68: 5, 35: 6, 110: 5, 91: 7, 114: 5, 97: 3, 31: 6, 13: 2, 67: 5, 38: 6, 26: 4, 98: 5, 54: 5, 127: 6, 8: 5, 96: 2, 64: 5, 30: 5, 61: 7, 55: 4, 27: 6, 15: 5, 52: 3, 129: 6, 115: 5, 84: 5, 76: 8, 87: 5, 131: 8, 102: 3, 113: 7, 99: 5, 36: 5, 24: 4, 53: 4, 72: 6} {82: 1, 347: 1, 1: 10, 4: 5, 9: 7, 10: 6, 15: 4, 24: 5, 25: 2, 26: 3, 27: 4, 39: 6, 43: 6, 49: 8, 50: 7, 58: 7, 59: 5, 64: 4, 69: 6, 81: 3, 86: 5, 96: 6, 97: 5, 100: 4, 108: 6, 109: 7, 110: 7, 111: 5, 114: 6, 115: 7, 116: 3, 118: 5, 119: 4, 120: 6, 121: 5, 122: 3, 123: 2, 124: 5, 128: 6, 129: 5, 130: 7, 132: 6, 136: 5, 145: 6, 147: 6, 151: 6, 152: 6, 154: 6, 156: 3, 161: 5, 162: 4, 165: 6, 168: 7, 169: 5, 172: 5, 180: 6, 184: 7, 187: 8, 188: 7, 191: 6, 194: 6, 202: 7, 203: 8, 206: 5, 207: 6, 215: 5, 217: 6, 218: 9, 220: 5, 221: 5, 222: 6, 224: 6, 227: 2, 229: 5, 234: 8, 235: 5, 241: 5, 242: 5, 243: 6, 244: 6, 245: 6, 248: 6, 250: 5, 258: 12, 262: 7, 263: 8, 264: 6, 267: 5, 270: 4, 272: 5, 273: 7, 287: 6, 289: 5, 291: 7, 299: 2, 300: 4, 304: 4, 309: 5, 314: 5, 315: 5, 320: 3, 323: 6, 327: 7, 328: 6, 329: 5, 330: 11, 334: 5, 335: 3, 341: 2, 342: 3, 350: 9, 351: 7, 352: 5, 353: 5, 354: 4, 358: 5, 365: 5, 366: 5, 369: 4, 371: 4, 372: 7, 376: 5, 384: 7, 385: 6, 386: 6, 387: 4, 392: 6, 393: 7, 396: 3, 397: 8, 398: 7, 402: 5} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 96 "The Time-Sensitive Networking (TSN) Task Group of the IEEE 802.1 Working Group have defined (and are defining) a number of amendments to IEEE8021Q that provide zero congestion loss and bounded latency in bridged networks. Furthermore IEEE8021CB defines frame replication and elimination functions for reliability that should prove both compatible with and useful to DetNet networks. All these functions have to identify flows that require TSN treatment." Fixing conformance language Adding more definite references for TSN functions ( i.e. , Clause numbers ) 8f154039ea3f048f61ad08104a2c94420471e8b6 8f154039ea3f048f61ad08104a2c94420471e8b6 draft-ietf-detnet-ip-over-tsn 8090b6d14e467632f5876fb9da62cf017d0a0f609b7954197c60f826e83b1a8b ['4ce364c82139f8d4c118dcccd3634e6f7d075eb3d773d8014252133b22074ce0', '630a7b3cd3eda2e026f158d16d3e4a4a2526a07124cf77aa8ed446ea760814d8', '5c251860b930f4ed1b036c65cfedd1cde0e9e2cd4bb47de83d7037bbc07ee82f', '8a5a8b1153a1415dc82eef529c2f30d40ed768644ec1e81b08574b34a4c367ad', '87afe83611af7d4ddd502790e7471f1936c668ab46e21836c21e6d35b1e61565', 'b8c12baa29bbed12ce047012140eca99addd7f9c46c4c05ee59e6a60febac402', 'fe1fc1f847582eeb8a35d700bf8f4be6b97b56b4536f0164f4d5fb089f66b2ab', 'd24a636756b51f5d839dc10d41dce590b0ede734f13951b670b256cfe0f0cb58', '8090b6d14e467632f5876fb9da62cf017d0a0f609b7954197c60f826e83b1a8b', '4921d6589b1c7097e9863f5b0ed1aa0c4c4f3db46278b3c4d98973dabdda583c', '305c7722e6b3b59e9ffb631e06cb323c063d6d11b5282fd6a6664c1cb8d7ee91', 'c546b23df124ad84240cc37d49670549c25586001a024e95e3cb8779f514393e'] A "the time-sensitive networking (tsn) task group of the ieee 802.1 working group have defined (and are defining) a number of amendments to ieee8021q that provide zero congestion loss and bounded latency in bridged networks. furthermore ieee8021cb defines frame replication and elimination functions for reliability that should prove both compatible with and useful to detnet networks. all these functions have to identify flows that require tsn treatment." {51: 1, 130: 1, 97: 1, 52: 1, 6: 3, 79: 3, 90: 3, 62: 2, 85: 3, 68: 5, 35: 4, 110: 3, 91: 5, 114: 3, 31: 4, 13: 2, 67: 3, 38: 4, 26: 3, 124: 2, 98: 3, 54: 3, 127: 4, 8: 3, 64: 3, 30: 3, 61: 5, 55: 4, 27: 4, 15: 3, 129: 4, 115: 3, 84: 3, 76: 7, 87: 3, 131: 6, 96: 2, 102: 3, 113: 5, 99: 3, 36: 3, 24: 2, 53: 2, 72: 4} {82: 1, 116: 1, 122: 1, 335: 1, 156: 1, 1: 10, 4: 3, 9: 6, 10: 4, 15: 2, 24: 3, 25: 2, 26: 3, 27: 2, 39: 6, 43: 4, 49: 6, 50: 5, 58: 5, 59: 3, 64: 2, 69: 5, 81: 3, 86: 3, 96: 4, 97: 3, 100: 4, 108: 4, 109: 5, 110: 5, 111: 3, 114: 4, 115: 5, 118: 5, 119: 4, 120: 4, 121: 5, 124: 5, 128: 4, 129: 3, 130: 5, 132: 5, 136: 3, 145: 5, 147: 4, 151: 4, 152: 4, 154: 4, 161: 4, 162: 4, 165: 4, 168: 5, 169: 3, 172: 3, 180: 4, 184: 6, 187: 6, 188: 5, 191: 4, 194: 5, 202: 6, 203: 7, 206: 3, 207: 4, 215: 3, 217: 4, 218: 9, 220: 3, 221: 3, 222: 6, 224: 4, 227: 2, 229: 3, 234: 6, 235: 3, 241: 3, 242: 3, 243: 5, 244: 4, 245: 5, 248: 4, 250: 3, 258: 12, 262: 5, 263: 6, 264: 4, 267: 5, 270: 2, 272: 3, 273: 6, 287: 4, 289: 3, 291: 5, 299: 2, 300: 2, 304: 2, 309: 4, 314: 3, 315: 3, 320: 3, 323: 5, 327: 5, 328: 4, 329: 3, 330: 11, 334: 3, 341: 2, 342: 3, 347: 2, 348: 2, 350: 8, 351: 5, 352: 3, 353: 3, 354: 2, 358: 5, 365: 3, 366: 3, 369: 2, 371: 4, 372: 5, 376: 3, 384: 5, 385: 4, 386: 4, 387: 2, 392: 4, 393: 5, 396: 3, 397: 8, 398: 7, 402: 3} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 96 "TSN capabilities of the TSN sub-network are made available for IP (DetNet) flows via the protocol interworking function defined in IEEE8021CB. For example, applied on the TSN edge port it can convert an ingress unicast IP (DetNet) flow to use a specific Layer-2 multicast destination MAC address and a VLAN, in order to direct the packet through a specific path inside the bridged network. A similar interworking function pair at the other end of the TSN sub-network would restore the packet to its original Layer-2 destination MAC address and VLAN." Fixing conformance language Adding more definite references for TSN functions ( i.e. , Clause numbers ) 8f154039ea3f048f61ad08104a2c94420471e8b6 8f154039ea3f048f61ad08104a2c94420471e8b6 draft-ietf-detnet-ip-over-tsn 305c7722e6b3b59e9ffb631e06cb323c063d6d11b5282fd6a6664c1cb8d7ee91 ['4ce364c82139f8d4c118dcccd3634e6f7d075eb3d773d8014252133b22074ce0', '630a7b3cd3eda2e026f158d16d3e4a4a2526a07124cf77aa8ed446ea760814d8', '5c251860b930f4ed1b036c65cfedd1cde0e9e2cd4bb47de83d7037bbc07ee82f', '8a5a8b1153a1415dc82eef529c2f30d40ed768644ec1e81b08574b34a4c367ad', '87afe83611af7d4ddd502790e7471f1936c668ab46e21836c21e6d35b1e61565', 'b8c12baa29bbed12ce047012140eca99addd7f9c46c4c05ee59e6a60febac402', 'fe1fc1f847582eeb8a35d700bf8f4be6b97b56b4536f0164f4d5fb089f66b2ab', 'd24a636756b51f5d839dc10d41dce590b0ede734f13951b670b256cfe0f0cb58', '8090b6d14e467632f5876fb9da62cf017d0a0f609b7954197c60f826e83b1a8b', '4921d6589b1c7097e9863f5b0ed1aa0c4c4f3db46278b3c4d98973dabdda583c', '305c7722e6b3b59e9ffb631e06cb323c063d6d11b5282fd6a6664c1cb8d7ee91', 'c546b23df124ad84240cc37d49670549c25586001a024e95e3cb8779f514393e'] A "tsn capabilities of the tsn sub-network are made available for ip (detnet) flows via the protocol interworking function defined in ieee8021cb. for example, applied on the tsn edge port it can convert an ingress unicast ip (detnet) flow to use a specific layer-2 multicast destination mac address and a vlan, in order to direct the packet through a specific path inside the bridged network. a similar interworking function pair at the other end of the tsn sub-network would restore the packet to its original layer-2 destination mac address and vlan." {51: 1, 130: 1, 97: 1, 52: 1, 6: 3, 79: 3, 90: 3, 62: 2, 85: 3, 68: 5, 35: 4, 110: 3, 91: 5, 114: 3, 31: 4, 13: 2, 67: 3, 38: 4, 26: 3, 124: 2, 98: 3, 54: 3, 127: 4, 8: 3, 64: 3, 30: 3, 61: 5, 55: 4, 27: 4, 15: 3, 129: 4, 115: 3, 84: 3, 76: 7, 87: 3, 131: 6, 96: 2, 102: 3, 113: 5, 99: 3, 36: 3, 24: 2, 53: 2, 72: 4} {82: 1, 116: 1, 122: 1, 335: 1, 156: 1, 1: 10, 4: 3, 9: 6, 10: 4, 15: 2, 24: 3, 25: 2, 26: 3, 27: 2, 39: 6, 43: 4, 49: 6, 50: 5, 58: 5, 59: 3, 64: 2, 69: 5, 81: 3, 86: 3, 96: 4, 97: 3, 100: 4, 108: 4, 109: 5, 110: 5, 111: 3, 114: 4, 115: 5, 118: 5, 119: 4, 120: 4, 121: 5, 124: 5, 128: 4, 129: 3, 130: 5, 132: 5, 136: 3, 145: 5, 147: 4, 151: 4, 152: 4, 154: 4, 161: 4, 162: 4, 165: 4, 168: 5, 169: 3, 172: 3, 180: 4, 184: 6, 187: 6, 188: 5, 191: 4, 194: 5, 202: 6, 203: 7, 206: 3, 207: 4, 215: 3, 217: 4, 218: 9, 220: 3, 221: 3, 222: 6, 224: 4, 227: 2, 229: 3, 234: 6, 235: 3, 241: 3, 242: 3, 243: 5, 244: 4, 245: 5, 248: 4, 250: 3, 258: 12, 262: 5, 263: 6, 264: 4, 267: 5, 270: 2, 272: 3, 273: 6, 287: 4, 289: 3, 291: 5, 299: 2, 300: 2, 304: 2, 309: 4, 314: 3, 315: 3, 320: 3, 323: 5, 327: 5, 328: 4, 329: 3, 330: 11, 334: 3, 341: 2, 342: 3, 347: 2, 348: 2, 350: 8, 351: 5, 352: 3, 353: 3, 354: 2, 358: 5, 365: 3, 366: 3, 369: 2, 371: 4, 372: 5, 376: 3, 384: 5, 385: 4, 386: 4, 387: 2, 392: 4, 393: 5, 396: 3, 397: 8, 398: 7, 402: 3} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 96 "Placement of TSN functions depends on the TSN capabilities of nodes. IP (DetNet) Nodes may or may not support TSN functions. For a given TSN Stream (i.e., DetNet flow) an IP (DetNet) node is treated as a Talker or a Listener inside the TSN sub-network." Fixing conformance language Adding more definite references for TSN functions ( i.e. , Clause numbers ) 8f154039ea3f048f61ad08104a2c94420471e8b6 8f154039ea3f048f61ad08104a2c94420471e8b6 draft-ietf-detnet-ip-over-tsn b8c12baa29bbed12ce047012140eca99addd7f9c46c4c05ee59e6a60febac402 ['4ce364c82139f8d4c118dcccd3634e6f7d075eb3d773d8014252133b22074ce0', '630a7b3cd3eda2e026f158d16d3e4a4a2526a07124cf77aa8ed446ea760814d8', '5c251860b930f4ed1b036c65cfedd1cde0e9e2cd4bb47de83d7037bbc07ee82f', '8a5a8b1153a1415dc82eef529c2f30d40ed768644ec1e81b08574b34a4c367ad', '87afe83611af7d4ddd502790e7471f1936c668ab46e21836c21e6d35b1e61565', 'b8c12baa29bbed12ce047012140eca99addd7f9c46c4c05ee59e6a60febac402', 'fe1fc1f847582eeb8a35d700bf8f4be6b97b56b4536f0164f4d5fb089f66b2ab', 'd24a636756b51f5d839dc10d41dce590b0ede734f13951b670b256cfe0f0cb58', '8090b6d14e467632f5876fb9da62cf017d0a0f609b7954197c60f826e83b1a8b', '4921d6589b1c7097e9863f5b0ed1aa0c4c4f3db46278b3c4d98973dabdda583c', '305c7722e6b3b59e9ffb631e06cb323c063d6d11b5282fd6a6664c1cb8d7ee91', 'c546b23df124ad84240cc37d49670549c25586001a024e95e3cb8779f514393e'] A "placement of tsn functions depends on the tsn capabilities of nodes. ip (detnet) nodes may or may not support tsn functions. for a given tsn stream (i.e., detnet flow) an ip (detnet) node is treated as a talker or a listener inside the tsn sub-network." {51: 1, 130: 1, 97: 1, 52: 1, 6: 3, 79: 3, 90: 3, 62: 2, 85: 3, 68: 5, 35: 4, 110: 3, 91: 5, 114: 3, 31: 4, 13: 2, 67: 3, 38: 4, 26: 3, 124: 2, 98: 3, 54: 3, 127: 4, 8: 3, 64: 3, 30: 3, 61: 5, 55: 4, 27: 4, 15: 3, 129: 4, 115: 3, 84: 3, 76: 7, 87: 3, 131: 6, 96: 2, 102: 3, 113: 5, 99: 3, 36: 3, 24: 2, 53: 2, 72: 4} {82: 1, 116: 1, 122: 1, 335: 1, 156: 1, 1: 10, 4: 3, 9: 6, 10: 4, 15: 2, 24: 3, 25: 2, 26: 3, 27: 2, 39: 6, 43: 4, 49: 6, 50: 5, 58: 5, 59: 3, 64: 2, 69: 5, 81: 3, 86: 3, 96: 4, 97: 3, 100: 4, 108: 4, 109: 5, 110: 5, 111: 3, 114: 4, 115: 5, 118: 5, 119: 4, 120: 4, 121: 5, 124: 5, 128: 4, 129: 3, 130: 5, 132: 5, 136: 3, 145: 5, 147: 4, 151: 4, 152: 4, 154: 4, 161: 4, 162: 4, 165: 4, 168: 5, 169: 3, 172: 3, 180: 4, 184: 6, 187: 6, 188: 5, 191: 4, 194: 5, 202: 6, 203: 7, 206: 3, 207: 4, 215: 3, 217: 4, 218: 9, 220: 3, 221: 3, 222: 6, 224: 4, 227: 2, 229: 3, 234: 6, 235: 3, 241: 3, 242: 3, 243: 5, 244: 4, 245: 5, 248: 4, 250: 3, 258: 12, 262: 5, 263: 6, 264: 4, 267: 5, 270: 2, 272: 3, 273: 6, 287: 4, 289: 3, 291: 5, 299: 2, 300: 2, 304: 2, 309: 4, 314: 3, 315: 3, 320: 3, 323: 5, 327: 5, 328: 4, 329: 3, 330: 11, 334: 3, 341: 2, 342: 3, 347: 2, 348: 2, 350: 8, 351: 5, 352: 3, 353: 3, 354: 2, 358: 5, 365: 3, 366: 3, 369: 2, 371: 4, 372: 5, 376: 3, 384: 5, 385: 4, 386: 4, 387: 2, 392: 4, 393: 5, 396: 3, 397: 8, 398: 7, 402: 3} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 96 "Mapping of a DetNet IP flow to a TSN Stream is provided via the combination of a passive and an active stream identification function that operate at the frame level. The passive stream identification function is used to catch the 6-tuple of a DetNet IP flow and the active stream identification function is used to modify the Ethernet header according to ID of the mapped TSN Stream." Fixing conformance language Adding more definite references for TSN functions ( i.e. , Clause numbers ) 8f154039ea3f048f61ad08104a2c94420471e8b6 8f154039ea3f048f61ad08104a2c94420471e8b6 draft-ietf-detnet-ip-over-tsn 4921d6589b1c7097e9863f5b0ed1aa0c4c4f3db46278b3c4d98973dabdda583c ['4ce364c82139f8d4c118dcccd3634e6f7d075eb3d773d8014252133b22074ce0', '630a7b3cd3eda2e026f158d16d3e4a4a2526a07124cf77aa8ed446ea760814d8', '5c251860b930f4ed1b036c65cfedd1cde0e9e2cd4bb47de83d7037bbc07ee82f', '8a5a8b1153a1415dc82eef529c2f30d40ed768644ec1e81b08574b34a4c367ad', '87afe83611af7d4ddd502790e7471f1936c668ab46e21836c21e6d35b1e61565', 'b8c12baa29bbed12ce047012140eca99addd7f9c46c4c05ee59e6a60febac402', 'fe1fc1f847582eeb8a35d700bf8f4be6b97b56b4536f0164f4d5fb089f66b2ab', 'd24a636756b51f5d839dc10d41dce590b0ede734f13951b670b256cfe0f0cb58', '8090b6d14e467632f5876fb9da62cf017d0a0f609b7954197c60f826e83b1a8b', '4921d6589b1c7097e9863f5b0ed1aa0c4c4f3db46278b3c4d98973dabdda583c', '305c7722e6b3b59e9ffb631e06cb323c063d6d11b5282fd6a6664c1cb8d7ee91', 'c546b23df124ad84240cc37d49670549c25586001a024e95e3cb8779f514393e'] A "mapping of a detnet ip flow to a tsn stream is provided via the combination of a passive and an active stream identification function that operate at the frame level. the passive stream identification function is used to catch the 6-tuple of a detnet ip flow and the active stream identification function is used to modify the ethernet header according to id of the mapped tsn stream." {51: 1, 130: 1, 97: 1, 52: 1, 6: 3, 79: 3, 90: 3, 62: 2, 85: 3, 68: 5, 35: 4, 110: 3, 91: 5, 114: 3, 31: 4, 13: 2, 67: 3, 38: 4, 26: 3, 124: 2, 98: 3, 54: 3, 127: 4, 8: 3, 64: 3, 30: 3, 61: 5, 55: 4, 27: 4, 15: 3, 129: 4, 115: 3, 84: 3, 76: 7, 87: 3, 131: 6, 96: 2, 102: 3, 113: 5, 99: 3, 36: 3, 24: 2, 53: 2, 72: 4} {82: 1, 116: 1, 122: 1, 335: 1, 156: 1, 1: 10, 4: 3, 9: 6, 10: 4, 15: 2, 24: 3, 25: 2, 26: 3, 27: 2, 39: 6, 43: 4, 49: 6, 50: 5, 58: 5, 59: 3, 64: 2, 69: 5, 81: 3, 86: 3, 96: 4, 97: 3, 100: 4, 108: 4, 109: 5, 110: 5, 111: 3, 114: 4, 115: 5, 118: 5, 119: 4, 120: 4, 121: 5, 124: 5, 128: 4, 129: 3, 130: 5, 132: 5, 136: 3, 145: 5, 147: 4, 151: 4, 152: 4, 154: 4, 161: 4, 162: 4, 165: 4, 168: 5, 169: 3, 172: 3, 180: 4, 184: 6, 187: 6, 188: 5, 191: 4, 194: 5, 202: 6, 203: 7, 206: 3, 207: 4, 215: 3, 217: 4, 218: 9, 220: 3, 221: 3, 222: 6, 224: 4, 227: 2, 229: 3, 234: 6, 235: 3, 241: 3, 242: 3, 243: 5, 244: 4, 245: 5, 248: 4, 250: 3, 258: 12, 262: 5, 263: 6, 264: 4, 267: 5, 270: 2, 272: 3, 273: 6, 287: 4, 289: 3, 291: 5, 299: 2, 300: 2, 304: 2, 309: 4, 314: 3, 315: 3, 320: 3, 323: 5, 327: 5, 328: 4, 329: 3, 330: 11, 334: 3, 341: 2, 342: 3, 347: 2, 348: 2, 350: 8, 351: 5, 352: 3, 353: 3, 354: 2, 358: 5, 365: 3, 366: 3, 369: 2, 371: 4, 372: 5, 376: 3, 384: 5, 385: 4, 386: 4, 387: 2, 392: 4, 393: 5, 396: 3, 397: 8, 398: 7, 402: 3} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 96 "IEEE8021CB defines an IP Stream identification function that can be used as a passive function for IP DetNet flows using UDP or TCP. IEEEP8021CBdb defines a Mask-and-Match Stream identification function that can be used as a passive function for any IP DetNet flows." Fixing conformance language Adding more definite references for TSN functions ( i.e. , Clause numbers ) 8f154039ea3f048f61ad08104a2c94420471e8b6 8f154039ea3f048f61ad08104a2c94420471e8b6 draft-ietf-detnet-ip-over-tsn fe1fc1f847582eeb8a35d700bf8f4be6b97b56b4536f0164f4d5fb089f66b2ab ['4ce364c82139f8d4c118dcccd3634e6f7d075eb3d773d8014252133b22074ce0', '630a7b3cd3eda2e026f158d16d3e4a4a2526a07124cf77aa8ed446ea760814d8', '5c251860b930f4ed1b036c65cfedd1cde0e9e2cd4bb47de83d7037bbc07ee82f', '8a5a8b1153a1415dc82eef529c2f30d40ed768644ec1e81b08574b34a4c367ad', '87afe83611af7d4ddd502790e7471f1936c668ab46e21836c21e6d35b1e61565', 'b8c12baa29bbed12ce047012140eca99addd7f9c46c4c05ee59e6a60febac402', 'fe1fc1f847582eeb8a35d700bf8f4be6b97b56b4536f0164f4d5fb089f66b2ab', 'd24a636756b51f5d839dc10d41dce590b0ede734f13951b670b256cfe0f0cb58', '8090b6d14e467632f5876fb9da62cf017d0a0f609b7954197c60f826e83b1a8b', '4921d6589b1c7097e9863f5b0ed1aa0c4c4f3db46278b3c4d98973dabdda583c', '305c7722e6b3b59e9ffb631e06cb323c063d6d11b5282fd6a6664c1cb8d7ee91', 'c546b23df124ad84240cc37d49670549c25586001a024e95e3cb8779f514393e'] A "ieee8021cb defines an ip stream identification function that can be used as a passive function for ip detnet flows using udp or tcp. ieeep8021cbdb defines a mask-and-match stream identification function that can be used as a passive function for any ip detnet flows." {51: 1, 130: 1, 97: 1, 52: 1, 6: 3, 79: 3, 90: 3, 62: 2, 85: 3, 68: 5, 35: 4, 110: 3, 91: 5, 114: 3, 31: 4, 13: 2, 67: 3, 38: 4, 26: 3, 124: 2, 98: 3, 54: 3, 127: 4, 8: 3, 64: 3, 30: 3, 61: 5, 55: 4, 27: 4, 15: 3, 129: 4, 115: 3, 84: 3, 76: 7, 87: 3, 131: 6, 96: 2, 102: 3, 113: 5, 99: 3, 36: 3, 24: 2, 53: 2, 72: 4} {82: 1, 116: 1, 122: 1, 335: 1, 156: 1, 1: 10, 4: 3, 9: 6, 10: 4, 15: 2, 24: 3, 25: 2, 26: 3, 27: 2, 39: 6, 43: 4, 49: 6, 50: 5, 58: 5, 59: 3, 64: 2, 69: 5, 81: 3, 86: 3, 96: 4, 97: 3, 100: 4, 108: 4, 109: 5, 110: 5, 111: 3, 114: 4, 115: 5, 118: 5, 119: 4, 120: 4, 121: 5, 124: 5, 128: 4, 129: 3, 130: 5, 132: 5, 136: 3, 145: 5, 147: 4, 151: 4, 152: 4, 154: 4, 161: 4, 162: 4, 165: 4, 168: 5, 169: 3, 172: 3, 180: 4, 184: 6, 187: 6, 188: 5, 191: 4, 194: 5, 202: 6, 203: 7, 206: 3, 207: 4, 215: 3, 217: 4, 218: 9, 220: 3, 221: 3, 222: 6, 224: 4, 227: 2, 229: 3, 234: 6, 235: 3, 241: 3, 242: 3, 243: 5, 244: 4, 245: 5, 248: 4, 250: 3, 258: 12, 262: 5, 263: 6, 264: 4, 267: 5, 270: 2, 272: 3, 273: 6, 287: 4, 289: 3, 291: 5, 299: 2, 300: 2, 304: 2, 309: 4, 314: 3, 315: 3, 320: 3, 323: 5, 327: 5, 328: 4, 329: 3, 330: 11, 334: 3, 341: 2, 342: 3, 347: 2, 348: 2, 350: 8, 351: 5, 352: 3, 353: 3, 354: 2, 358: 5, 365: 3, 366: 3, 369: 2, 371: 4, 372: 5, 376: 3, 384: 5, 385: 4, 386: 4, 387: 2, 392: 4, 393: 5, 396: 3, 397: 8, 398: 7, 402: 3} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 96 "IEEE8021CB defines an Active Destination MAC and VLAN Stream identification function, what can replace some Ethernet header fields namely (1) the destination MAC-address, (2) the VLAN-ID and (3) priority parameters with alternate values. Replacement is provided for the frame passed down the stack from the upper layers or up the stack from the lower layers." Fixing conformance language Adding more definite references for TSN functions ( i.e. , Clause numbers ) 8f154039ea3f048f61ad08104a2c94420471e8b6 8f154039ea3f048f61ad08104a2c94420471e8b6 draft-ietf-detnet-ip-over-tsn 630a7b3cd3eda2e026f158d16d3e4a4a2526a07124cf77aa8ed446ea760814d8 ['4ce364c82139f8d4c118dcccd3634e6f7d075eb3d773d8014252133b22074ce0', '630a7b3cd3eda2e026f158d16d3e4a4a2526a07124cf77aa8ed446ea760814d8', '5c251860b930f4ed1b036c65cfedd1cde0e9e2cd4bb47de83d7037bbc07ee82f', '8a5a8b1153a1415dc82eef529c2f30d40ed768644ec1e81b08574b34a4c367ad', '87afe83611af7d4ddd502790e7471f1936c668ab46e21836c21e6d35b1e61565', 'b8c12baa29bbed12ce047012140eca99addd7f9c46c4c05ee59e6a60febac402', 'fe1fc1f847582eeb8a35d700bf8f4be6b97b56b4536f0164f4d5fb089f66b2ab', 'd24a636756b51f5d839dc10d41dce590b0ede734f13951b670b256cfe0f0cb58', '8090b6d14e467632f5876fb9da62cf017d0a0f609b7954197c60f826e83b1a8b', '4921d6589b1c7097e9863f5b0ed1aa0c4c4f3db46278b3c4d98973dabdda583c', '305c7722e6b3b59e9ffb631e06cb323c063d6d11b5282fd6a6664c1cb8d7ee91', 'c546b23df124ad84240cc37d49670549c25586001a024e95e3cb8779f514393e'] A "ieee8021cb defines an active destination mac and vlan stream identification function, what can replace some ethernet header fields namely (1) the destination mac-address, (2) the vlan-id and (3) priority parameters with alternate values. replacement is provided for the frame passed down the stack from the upper layers or up the stack from the lower layers." {51: 1, 130: 1, 97: 1, 52: 1, 6: 3, 79: 3, 90: 3, 62: 2, 85: 3, 68: 5, 35: 4, 110: 3, 91: 5, 114: 3, 31: 4, 13: 2, 67: 3, 38: 4, 26: 3, 124: 2, 98: 3, 54: 3, 127: 4, 8: 3, 64: 3, 30: 3, 61: 5, 55: 4, 27: 4, 15: 3, 129: 4, 115: 3, 84: 3, 76: 7, 87: 3, 131: 6, 96: 2, 102: 3, 113: 5, 99: 3, 36: 3, 24: 2, 53: 2, 72: 4} {82: 1, 116: 1, 122: 1, 335: 1, 156: 1, 1: 10, 4: 3, 9: 6, 10: 4, 15: 2, 24: 3, 25: 2, 26: 3, 27: 2, 39: 6, 43: 4, 49: 6, 50: 5, 58: 5, 59: 3, 64: 2, 69: 5, 81: 3, 86: 3, 96: 4, 97: 3, 100: 4, 108: 4, 109: 5, 110: 5, 111: 3, 114: 4, 115: 5, 118: 5, 119: 4, 120: 4, 121: 5, 124: 5, 128: 4, 129: 3, 130: 5, 132: 5, 136: 3, 145: 5, 147: 4, 151: 4, 152: 4, 154: 4, 161: 4, 162: 4, 165: 4, 168: 5, 169: 3, 172: 3, 180: 4, 184: 6, 187: 6, 188: 5, 191: 4, 194: 5, 202: 6, 203: 7, 206: 3, 207: 4, 215: 3, 217: 4, 218: 9, 220: 3, 221: 3, 222: 6, 224: 4, 227: 2, 229: 3, 234: 6, 235: 3, 241: 3, 242: 3, 243: 5, 244: 4, 245: 5, 248: 4, 250: 3, 258: 12, 262: 5, 263: 6, 264: 4, 267: 5, 270: 2, 272: 3, 273: 6, 287: 4, 289: 3, 291: 5, 299: 2, 300: 2, 304: 2, 309: 4, 314: 3, 315: 3, 320: 3, 323: 5, 327: 5, 328: 4, 329: 3, 330: 11, 334: 3, 341: 2, 342: 3, 347: 2, 348: 2, 350: 8, 351: 5, 352: 3, 353: 3, 354: 2, 358: 5, 365: 3, 366: 3, 369: 2, 371: 4, 372: 5, 376: 3, 384: 5, 385: 4, 386: 4, 387: 2, 392: 4, 393: 5, 396: 3, 397: 8, 398: 7, 402: 3} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 96 "The Time-Sensitive Networking (TSN) Task Group of the IEEE 802.1 Working Group have defined (and are defining) a number of amendments to IEEE8021Q that provide zero congestion loss and bounded latency in bridged networks. Furthermore, IEEE8021CB defines frame replication and elimination functions for reliability that should prove both compatible with and useful to DetNet networks. All these functions have to identify flows that require TSN treatment." Fixing conformance language Adding more definite references for TSN functions ( i.e. , Clause numbers ) 8f154039ea3f048f61ad08104a2c94420471e8b6 8f154039ea3f048f61ad08104a2c94420471e8b6 draft-ietf-detnet-ip-over-tsn c546b23df124ad84240cc37d49670549c25586001a024e95e3cb8779f514393e ['4ce364c82139f8d4c118dcccd3634e6f7d075eb3d773d8014252133b22074ce0', '630a7b3cd3eda2e026f158d16d3e4a4a2526a07124cf77aa8ed446ea760814d8', '5c251860b930f4ed1b036c65cfedd1cde0e9e2cd4bb47de83d7037bbc07ee82f', '8a5a8b1153a1415dc82eef529c2f30d40ed768644ec1e81b08574b34a4c367ad', '87afe83611af7d4ddd502790e7471f1936c668ab46e21836c21e6d35b1e61565', 'b8c12baa29bbed12ce047012140eca99addd7f9c46c4c05ee59e6a60febac402', 'fe1fc1f847582eeb8a35d700bf8f4be6b97b56b4536f0164f4d5fb089f66b2ab', 'd24a636756b51f5d839dc10d41dce590b0ede734f13951b670b256cfe0f0cb58', '8090b6d14e467632f5876fb9da62cf017d0a0f609b7954197c60f826e83b1a8b', '4921d6589b1c7097e9863f5b0ed1aa0c4c4f3db46278b3c4d98973dabdda583c', '305c7722e6b3b59e9ffb631e06cb323c063d6d11b5282fd6a6664c1cb8d7ee91', 'c546b23df124ad84240cc37d49670549c25586001a024e95e3cb8779f514393e'] B "the time-sensitive networking (tsn) task group of the ieee 802.1 working group have defined (and are defining) a number of amendments to ieee8021q that provide zero congestion loss and bounded latency in bridged networks. furthermore, ieee8021cb defines frame replication and elimination functions for reliability that should prove both compatible with and useful to detnet networks. all these functions have to identify flows that require tsn treatment." {51: 1, 130: 1, 97: 1, 52: 1, 6: 3, 79: 3, 90: 3, 62: 2, 85: 3, 68: 5, 35: 4, 110: 3, 91: 5, 114: 3, 31: 4, 13: 2, 67: 3, 38: 4, 26: 3, 124: 2, 98: 3, 54: 3, 127: 4, 8: 3, 64: 3, 30: 3, 61: 5, 55: 4, 27: 4, 15: 3, 129: 4, 115: 3, 84: 3, 76: 7, 87: 3, 131: 6, 96: 2, 102: 3, 113: 5, 99: 3, 36: 3, 24: 2, 53: 2, 72: 4} {82: 1, 116: 1, 122: 1, 335: 1, 156: 1, 1: 10, 4: 3, 9: 6, 10: 4, 15: 2, 24: 3, 25: 2, 26: 3, 27: 2, 39: 6, 43: 4, 49: 6, 50: 5, 58: 5, 59: 3, 64: 2, 69: 5, 81: 3, 86: 3, 96: 4, 97: 3, 100: 4, 108: 4, 109: 5, 110: 5, 111: 3, 114: 4, 115: 5, 118: 5, 119: 4, 120: 4, 121: 5, 124: 5, 128: 4, 129: 3, 130: 5, 132: 5, 136: 3, 145: 5, 147: 4, 151: 4, 152: 4, 154: 4, 161: 4, 162: 4, 165: 4, 168: 5, 169: 3, 172: 3, 180: 4, 184: 6, 187: 6, 188: 5, 191: 4, 194: 5, 202: 6, 203: 7, 206: 3, 207: 4, 215: 3, 217: 4, 218: 9, 220: 3, 221: 3, 222: 6, 224: 4, 227: 2, 229: 3, 234: 6, 235: 3, 241: 3, 242: 3, 243: 5, 244: 4, 245: 5, 248: 4, 250: 3, 258: 12, 262: 5, 263: 6, 264: 4, 267: 5, 270: 2, 272: 3, 273: 6, 287: 4, 289: 3, 291: 5, 299: 2, 300: 2, 304: 2, 309: 4, 314: 3, 315: 3, 320: 3, 323: 5, 327: 5, 328: 4, 329: 3, 330: 11, 334: 3, 341: 2, 342: 3, 347: 2, 348: 2, 350: 8, 351: 5, 352: 3, 353: 3, 354: 2, 358: 5, 365: 3, 366: 3, 369: 2, 371: 4, 372: 5, 376: 3, 384: 5, 385: 4, 386: 4, 387: 2, 392: 4, 393: 5, 396: 3, 397: 8, 398: 7, 402: 3} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 96 "TSN capabilities of the TSN sub-network are made available for IP (DetNet) flows via the protocol interworking function desribed in Annex C.5 of IEEE8021CB. For example, applied on the TSN edge port it can convert an ingress unicast IP (DetNet) flow to use a specific Layer-2 multicast destination MAC address and a VLAN, in order to direct the packet through a specific path inside the bridged network. A similar interworking function pair at the other end of the TSN sub- network would restore the packet to its original Layer-2 destination MAC address and VLAN." Fixing conformance language Adding more definite references for TSN functions ( i.e. , Clause numbers ) 8f154039ea3f048f61ad08104a2c94420471e8b6 8f154039ea3f048f61ad08104a2c94420471e8b6 draft-ietf-detnet-ip-over-tsn 4ce364c82139f8d4c118dcccd3634e6f7d075eb3d773d8014252133b22074ce0 ['4ce364c82139f8d4c118dcccd3634e6f7d075eb3d773d8014252133b22074ce0', '630a7b3cd3eda2e026f158d16d3e4a4a2526a07124cf77aa8ed446ea760814d8', '5c251860b930f4ed1b036c65cfedd1cde0e9e2cd4bb47de83d7037bbc07ee82f', '8a5a8b1153a1415dc82eef529c2f30d40ed768644ec1e81b08574b34a4c367ad', '87afe83611af7d4ddd502790e7471f1936c668ab46e21836c21e6d35b1e61565', 'b8c12baa29bbed12ce047012140eca99addd7f9c46c4c05ee59e6a60febac402', 'fe1fc1f847582eeb8a35d700bf8f4be6b97b56b4536f0164f4d5fb089f66b2ab', 'd24a636756b51f5d839dc10d41dce590b0ede734f13951b670b256cfe0f0cb58', '8090b6d14e467632f5876fb9da62cf017d0a0f609b7954197c60f826e83b1a8b', '4921d6589b1c7097e9863f5b0ed1aa0c4c4f3db46278b3c4d98973dabdda583c', '305c7722e6b3b59e9ffb631e06cb323c063d6d11b5282fd6a6664c1cb8d7ee91', 'c546b23df124ad84240cc37d49670549c25586001a024e95e3cb8779f514393e'] B "tsn capabilities of the tsn sub-network are made available for ip (detnet) flows via the protocol interworking function desribed in annex c.5 of ieee8021cb. for example, applied on the tsn edge port it can convert an ingress unicast ip (detnet) flow to use a specific layer-2 multicast destination mac address and a vlan, in order to direct the packet through a specific path inside the bridged network. a similar interworking function pair at the other end of the tsn sub- network would restore the packet to its original layer-2 destination mac address and vlan." {51: 1, 130: 1, 97: 1, 52: 1, 6: 3, 79: 3, 90: 3, 62: 2, 85: 3, 68: 5, 35: 4, 110: 3, 91: 5, 114: 3, 31: 4, 13: 2, 67: 3, 38: 4, 26: 3, 124: 2, 98: 3, 54: 3, 127: 4, 8: 3, 64: 3, 30: 3, 61: 5, 55: 4, 27: 4, 15: 3, 129: 4, 115: 3, 84: 3, 76: 7, 87: 3, 131: 6, 96: 2, 102: 3, 113: 5, 99: 3, 36: 3, 24: 2, 53: 2, 72: 4} {82: 1, 116: 1, 122: 1, 335: 1, 156: 1, 1: 10, 4: 3, 9: 6, 10: 4, 15: 2, 24: 3, 25: 2, 26: 3, 27: 2, 39: 6, 43: 4, 49: 6, 50: 5, 58: 5, 59: 3, 64: 2, 69: 5, 81: 3, 86: 3, 96: 4, 97: 3, 100: 4, 108: 4, 109: 5, 110: 5, 111: 3, 114: 4, 115: 5, 118: 5, 119: 4, 120: 4, 121: 5, 124: 5, 128: 4, 129: 3, 130: 5, 132: 5, 136: 3, 145: 5, 147: 4, 151: 4, 152: 4, 154: 4, 161: 4, 162: 4, 165: 4, 168: 5, 169: 3, 172: 3, 180: 4, 184: 6, 187: 6, 188: 5, 191: 4, 194: 5, 202: 6, 203: 7, 206: 3, 207: 4, 215: 3, 217: 4, 218: 9, 220: 3, 221: 3, 222: 6, 224: 4, 227: 2, 229: 3, 234: 6, 235: 3, 241: 3, 242: 3, 243: 5, 244: 4, 245: 5, 248: 4, 250: 3, 258: 12, 262: 5, 263: 6, 264: 4, 267: 5, 270: 2, 272: 3, 273: 6, 287: 4, 289: 3, 291: 5, 299: 2, 300: 2, 304: 2, 309: 4, 314: 3, 315: 3, 320: 3, 323: 5, 327: 5, 328: 4, 329: 3, 330: 11, 334: 3, 341: 2, 342: 3, 347: 2, 348: 2, 350: 8, 351: 5, 352: 3, 353: 3, 354: 2, 358: 5, 365: 3, 366: 3, 369: 2, 371: 4, 372: 5, 376: 3, 384: 5, 385: 4, 386: 4, 387: 2, 392: 4, 393: 5, 396: 3, 397: 8, 398: 7, 402: 3} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 96 "Placement of TSN functions depends on the TSN capabilities of nodes. IP (DetNet) Nodes may or may not support TSN functions. For a given TSN Stream (i.e., a mapped DetNet flow) an IP (DetNet) node is treated as a Talker or a Listener inside the TSN sub-network." Fixing conformance language Adding more definite references for TSN functions ( i.e. , Clause numbers ) 8f154039ea3f048f61ad08104a2c94420471e8b6 8f154039ea3f048f61ad08104a2c94420471e8b6 draft-ietf-detnet-ip-over-tsn 8a5a8b1153a1415dc82eef529c2f30d40ed768644ec1e81b08574b34a4c367ad ['4ce364c82139f8d4c118dcccd3634e6f7d075eb3d773d8014252133b22074ce0', '630a7b3cd3eda2e026f158d16d3e4a4a2526a07124cf77aa8ed446ea760814d8', '5c251860b930f4ed1b036c65cfedd1cde0e9e2cd4bb47de83d7037bbc07ee82f', '8a5a8b1153a1415dc82eef529c2f30d40ed768644ec1e81b08574b34a4c367ad', '87afe83611af7d4ddd502790e7471f1936c668ab46e21836c21e6d35b1e61565', 'b8c12baa29bbed12ce047012140eca99addd7f9c46c4c05ee59e6a60febac402', 'fe1fc1f847582eeb8a35d700bf8f4be6b97b56b4536f0164f4d5fb089f66b2ab', 'd24a636756b51f5d839dc10d41dce590b0ede734f13951b670b256cfe0f0cb58', '8090b6d14e467632f5876fb9da62cf017d0a0f609b7954197c60f826e83b1a8b', '4921d6589b1c7097e9863f5b0ed1aa0c4c4f3db46278b3c4d98973dabdda583c', '305c7722e6b3b59e9ffb631e06cb323c063d6d11b5282fd6a6664c1cb8d7ee91', 'c546b23df124ad84240cc37d49670549c25586001a024e95e3cb8779f514393e'] B "placement of tsn functions depends on the tsn capabilities of nodes. ip (detnet) nodes may or may not support tsn functions. for a given tsn stream (i.e., a mapped detnet flow) an ip (detnet) node is treated as a talker or a listener inside the tsn sub-network." {51: 1, 130: 1, 97: 1, 52: 1, 6: 3, 79: 3, 90: 3, 62: 2, 85: 3, 68: 5, 35: 4, 110: 3, 91: 5, 114: 3, 31: 4, 13: 2, 67: 3, 38: 4, 26: 3, 124: 2, 98: 3, 54: 3, 127: 4, 8: 3, 64: 3, 30: 3, 61: 5, 55: 4, 27: 4, 15: 3, 129: 4, 115: 3, 84: 3, 76: 7, 87: 3, 131: 6, 96: 2, 102: 3, 113: 5, 99: 3, 36: 3, 24: 2, 53: 2, 72: 4} {82: 1, 116: 1, 122: 1, 335: 1, 156: 1, 1: 10, 4: 3, 9: 6, 10: 4, 15: 2, 24: 3, 25: 2, 26: 3, 27: 2, 39: 6, 43: 4, 49: 6, 50: 5, 58: 5, 59: 3, 64: 2, 69: 5, 81: 3, 86: 3, 96: 4, 97: 3, 100: 4, 108: 4, 109: 5, 110: 5, 111: 3, 114: 4, 115: 5, 118: 5, 119: 4, 120: 4, 121: 5, 124: 5, 128: 4, 129: 3, 130: 5, 132: 5, 136: 3, 145: 5, 147: 4, 151: 4, 152: 4, 154: 4, 161: 4, 162: 4, 165: 4, 168: 5, 169: 3, 172: 3, 180: 4, 184: 6, 187: 6, 188: 5, 191: 4, 194: 5, 202: 6, 203: 7, 206: 3, 207: 4, 215: 3, 217: 4, 218: 9, 220: 3, 221: 3, 222: 6, 224: 4, 227: 2, 229: 3, 234: 6, 235: 3, 241: 3, 242: 3, 243: 5, 244: 4, 245: 5, 248: 4, 250: 3, 258: 12, 262: 5, 263: 6, 264: 4, 267: 5, 270: 2, 272: 3, 273: 6, 287: 4, 289: 3, 291: 5, 299: 2, 300: 2, 304: 2, 309: 4, 314: 3, 315: 3, 320: 3, 323: 5, 327: 5, 328: 4, 329: 3, 330: 11, 334: 3, 341: 2, 342: 3, 347: 2, 348: 2, 350: 8, 351: 5, 352: 3, 353: 3, 354: 2, 358: 5, 365: 3, 366: 3, 369: 2, 371: 4, 372: 5, 376: 3, 384: 5, 385: 4, 386: 4, 387: 2, 392: 4, 393: 5, 396: 3, 397: 8, 398: 7, 402: 3} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 96 "Mapping of a DetNet IP flow to a TSN Stream is provided via the combination of a passive and an active stream identification function that operate at the frame level (Layer-2). The passive stream identification function is used to catch the 6-tuple of a DetNet IP flow and the active stream identification function is used to modify the Ethernet header according to the ID of the mapped TSN Stream." Fixing conformance language Adding more definite references for TSN functions ( i.e. , Clause numbers ) 8f154039ea3f048f61ad08104a2c94420471e8b6 8f154039ea3f048f61ad08104a2c94420471e8b6 draft-ietf-detnet-ip-over-tsn 5c251860b930f4ed1b036c65cfedd1cde0e9e2cd4bb47de83d7037bbc07ee82f ['4ce364c82139f8d4c118dcccd3634e6f7d075eb3d773d8014252133b22074ce0', '630a7b3cd3eda2e026f158d16d3e4a4a2526a07124cf77aa8ed446ea760814d8', '5c251860b930f4ed1b036c65cfedd1cde0e9e2cd4bb47de83d7037bbc07ee82f', '8a5a8b1153a1415dc82eef529c2f30d40ed768644ec1e81b08574b34a4c367ad', '87afe83611af7d4ddd502790e7471f1936c668ab46e21836c21e6d35b1e61565', 'b8c12baa29bbed12ce047012140eca99addd7f9c46c4c05ee59e6a60febac402', 'fe1fc1f847582eeb8a35d700bf8f4be6b97b56b4536f0164f4d5fb089f66b2ab', 'd24a636756b51f5d839dc10d41dce590b0ede734f13951b670b256cfe0f0cb58', '8090b6d14e467632f5876fb9da62cf017d0a0f609b7954197c60f826e83b1a8b', '4921d6589b1c7097e9863f5b0ed1aa0c4c4f3db46278b3c4d98973dabdda583c', '305c7722e6b3b59e9ffb631e06cb323c063d6d11b5282fd6a6664c1cb8d7ee91', 'c546b23df124ad84240cc37d49670549c25586001a024e95e3cb8779f514393e'] B "mapping of a detnet ip flow to a tsn stream is provided via the combination of a passive and an active stream identification function that operate at the frame level (layer-2). the passive stream identification function is used to catch the 6-tuple of a detnet ip flow and the active stream identification function is used to modify the ethernet header according to the id of the mapped tsn stream." {51: 1, 130: 1, 97: 1, 52: 1, 6: 3, 79: 3, 90: 3, 62: 2, 85: 3, 68: 5, 35: 4, 110: 3, 91: 5, 114: 3, 31: 4, 13: 2, 67: 3, 38: 4, 26: 3, 124: 2, 98: 3, 54: 3, 127: 4, 8: 3, 64: 3, 30: 3, 61: 5, 55: 4, 27: 4, 15: 3, 129: 4, 115: 3, 84: 3, 76: 7, 87: 3, 131: 6, 96: 2, 102: 3, 113: 5, 99: 3, 36: 3, 24: 2, 53: 2, 72: 4} {82: 1, 116: 1, 122: 1, 335: 1, 156: 1, 1: 10, 4: 3, 9: 6, 10: 4, 15: 2, 24: 3, 25: 2, 26: 3, 27: 2, 39: 6, 43: 4, 49: 6, 50: 5, 58: 5, 59: 3, 64: 2, 69: 5, 81: 3, 86: 3, 96: 4, 97: 3, 100: 4, 108: 4, 109: 5, 110: 5, 111: 3, 114: 4, 115: 5, 118: 5, 119: 4, 120: 4, 121: 5, 124: 5, 128: 4, 129: 3, 130: 5, 132: 5, 136: 3, 145: 5, 147: 4, 151: 4, 152: 4, 154: 4, 161: 4, 162: 4, 165: 4, 168: 5, 169: 3, 172: 3, 180: 4, 184: 6, 187: 6, 188: 5, 191: 4, 194: 5, 202: 6, 203: 7, 206: 3, 207: 4, 215: 3, 217: 4, 218: 9, 220: 3, 221: 3, 222: 6, 224: 4, 227: 2, 229: 3, 234: 6, 235: 3, 241: 3, 242: 3, 243: 5, 244: 4, 245: 5, 248: 4, 250: 3, 258: 12, 262: 5, 263: 6, 264: 4, 267: 5, 270: 2, 272: 3, 273: 6, 287: 4, 289: 3, 291: 5, 299: 2, 300: 2, 304: 2, 309: 4, 314: 3, 315: 3, 320: 3, 323: 5, 327: 5, 328: 4, 329: 3, 330: 11, 334: 3, 341: 2, 342: 3, 347: 2, 348: 2, 350: 8, 351: 5, 352: 3, 353: 3, 354: 2, 358: 5, 365: 3, 366: 3, 369: 2, 371: 4, 372: 5, 376: 3, 384: 5, 385: 4, 386: 4, 387: 2, 392: 4, 393: 5, 396: 3, 397: 8, 398: 7, 402: 3} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 96 "Clause 6.7 of IEEE8021CB defines an IP Stream identification function that can be used as a passive function for IP DetNet flows using UDP or TCP. Clause 6.8 of IEEEP8021CBdb defines a Mask-and-Match Stream identification function that can be used as a passive function for any IP DetNet flows." Fixing conformance language Adding more definite references for TSN functions ( i.e. , Clause numbers ) 8f154039ea3f048f61ad08104a2c94420471e8b6 8f154039ea3f048f61ad08104a2c94420471e8b6 draft-ietf-detnet-ip-over-tsn 87afe83611af7d4ddd502790e7471f1936c668ab46e21836c21e6d35b1e61565 ['4ce364c82139f8d4c118dcccd3634e6f7d075eb3d773d8014252133b22074ce0', '630a7b3cd3eda2e026f158d16d3e4a4a2526a07124cf77aa8ed446ea760814d8', '5c251860b930f4ed1b036c65cfedd1cde0e9e2cd4bb47de83d7037bbc07ee82f', '8a5a8b1153a1415dc82eef529c2f30d40ed768644ec1e81b08574b34a4c367ad', '87afe83611af7d4ddd502790e7471f1936c668ab46e21836c21e6d35b1e61565', 'b8c12baa29bbed12ce047012140eca99addd7f9c46c4c05ee59e6a60febac402', 'fe1fc1f847582eeb8a35d700bf8f4be6b97b56b4536f0164f4d5fb089f66b2ab', 'd24a636756b51f5d839dc10d41dce590b0ede734f13951b670b256cfe0f0cb58', '8090b6d14e467632f5876fb9da62cf017d0a0f609b7954197c60f826e83b1a8b', '4921d6589b1c7097e9863f5b0ed1aa0c4c4f3db46278b3c4d98973dabdda583c', '305c7722e6b3b59e9ffb631e06cb323c063d6d11b5282fd6a6664c1cb8d7ee91', 'c546b23df124ad84240cc37d49670549c25586001a024e95e3cb8779f514393e'] B "clause 6.7 of ieee8021cb defines an ip stream identification function that can be used as a passive function for ip detnet flows using udp or tcp. clause 6.8 of ieeep8021cbdb defines a mask-and-match stream identification function that can be used as a passive function for any ip detnet flows." {51: 1, 130: 1, 97: 1, 52: 1, 6: 3, 79: 3, 90: 3, 62: 2, 85: 3, 68: 5, 35: 4, 110: 3, 91: 5, 114: 3, 31: 4, 13: 2, 67: 3, 38: 4, 26: 3, 124: 2, 98: 3, 54: 3, 127: 4, 8: 3, 64: 3, 30: 3, 61: 5, 55: 4, 27: 4, 15: 3, 129: 4, 115: 3, 84: 3, 76: 7, 87: 3, 131: 6, 96: 2, 102: 3, 113: 5, 99: 3, 36: 3, 24: 2, 53: 2, 72: 4} {82: 1, 116: 1, 122: 1, 335: 1, 156: 1, 1: 10, 4: 3, 9: 6, 10: 4, 15: 2, 24: 3, 25: 2, 26: 3, 27: 2, 39: 6, 43: 4, 49: 6, 50: 5, 58: 5, 59: 3, 64: 2, 69: 5, 81: 3, 86: 3, 96: 4, 97: 3, 100: 4, 108: 4, 109: 5, 110: 5, 111: 3, 114: 4, 115: 5, 118: 5, 119: 4, 120: 4, 121: 5, 124: 5, 128: 4, 129: 3, 130: 5, 132: 5, 136: 3, 145: 5, 147: 4, 151: 4, 152: 4, 154: 4, 161: 4, 162: 4, 165: 4, 168: 5, 169: 3, 172: 3, 180: 4, 184: 6, 187: 6, 188: 5, 191: 4, 194: 5, 202: 6, 203: 7, 206: 3, 207: 4, 215: 3, 217: 4, 218: 9, 220: 3, 221: 3, 222: 6, 224: 4, 227: 2, 229: 3, 234: 6, 235: 3, 241: 3, 242: 3, 243: 5, 244: 4, 245: 5, 248: 4, 250: 3, 258: 12, 262: 5, 263: 6, 264: 4, 267: 5, 270: 2, 272: 3, 273: 6, 287: 4, 289: 3, 291: 5, 299: 2, 300: 2, 304: 2, 309: 4, 314: 3, 315: 3, 320: 3, 323: 5, 327: 5, 328: 4, 329: 3, 330: 11, 334: 3, 341: 2, 342: 3, 347: 2, 348: 2, 350: 8, 351: 5, 352: 3, 353: 3, 354: 2, 358: 5, 365: 3, 366: 3, 369: 2, 371: 4, 372: 5, 376: 3, 384: 5, 385: 4, 386: 4, 387: 2, 392: 4, 393: 5, 396: 3, 397: 8, 398: 7, 402: 3} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 96 "Clause 6.6 of IEEE8021CB defines an Active Destination MAC and VLAN Stream identification function, what can replace some Ethernet header fields namely (1) the destination MAC-address, (2) the VLAN-ID and (3) priority parameters with alternate values. Replacement is provided for the frame passed down the stack from the upper layers or up the stack from the lower layers." Fixing conformance language Adding more definite references for TSN functions ( i.e. , Clause numbers ) 8f154039ea3f048f61ad08104a2c94420471e8b6 8f154039ea3f048f61ad08104a2c94420471e8b6 draft-ietf-detnet-ip-over-tsn d24a636756b51f5d839dc10d41dce590b0ede734f13951b670b256cfe0f0cb58 ['4ce364c82139f8d4c118dcccd3634e6f7d075eb3d773d8014252133b22074ce0', '630a7b3cd3eda2e026f158d16d3e4a4a2526a07124cf77aa8ed446ea760814d8', '5c251860b930f4ed1b036c65cfedd1cde0e9e2cd4bb47de83d7037bbc07ee82f', '8a5a8b1153a1415dc82eef529c2f30d40ed768644ec1e81b08574b34a4c367ad', '87afe83611af7d4ddd502790e7471f1936c668ab46e21836c21e6d35b1e61565', 'b8c12baa29bbed12ce047012140eca99addd7f9c46c4c05ee59e6a60febac402', 'fe1fc1f847582eeb8a35d700bf8f4be6b97b56b4536f0164f4d5fb089f66b2ab', 'd24a636756b51f5d839dc10d41dce590b0ede734f13951b670b256cfe0f0cb58', '8090b6d14e467632f5876fb9da62cf017d0a0f609b7954197c60f826e83b1a8b', '4921d6589b1c7097e9863f5b0ed1aa0c4c4f3db46278b3c4d98973dabdda583c', '305c7722e6b3b59e9ffb631e06cb323c063d6d11b5282fd6a6664c1cb8d7ee91', 'c546b23df124ad84240cc37d49670549c25586001a024e95e3cb8779f514393e'] B "clause 6.6 of ieee8021cb defines an active destination mac and vlan stream identification function, what can replace some ethernet header fields namely (1) the destination mac-address, (2) the vlan-id and (3) priority parameters with alternate values. replacement is provided for the frame passed down the stack from the upper layers or up the stack from the lower layers." {51: 1, 130: 1, 97: 1, 52: 1, 6: 3, 79: 3, 90: 3, 62: 2, 85: 3, 68: 5, 35: 4, 110: 3, 91: 5, 114: 3, 31: 4, 13: 2, 67: 3, 38: 4, 26: 3, 124: 2, 98: 3, 54: 3, 127: 4, 8: 3, 64: 3, 30: 3, 61: 5, 55: 4, 27: 4, 15: 3, 129: 4, 115: 3, 84: 3, 76: 7, 87: 3, 131: 6, 96: 2, 102: 3, 113: 5, 99: 3, 36: 3, 24: 2, 53: 2, 72: 4} {82: 1, 116: 1, 122: 1, 335: 1, 156: 1, 1: 10, 4: 3, 9: 6, 10: 4, 15: 2, 24: 3, 25: 2, 26: 3, 27: 2, 39: 6, 43: 4, 49: 6, 50: 5, 58: 5, 59: 3, 64: 2, 69: 5, 81: 3, 86: 3, 96: 4, 97: 3, 100: 4, 108: 4, 109: 5, 110: 5, 111: 3, 114: 4, 115: 5, 118: 5, 119: 4, 120: 4, 121: 5, 124: 5, 128: 4, 129: 3, 130: 5, 132: 5, 136: 3, 145: 5, 147: 4, 151: 4, 152: 4, 154: 4, 161: 4, 162: 4, 165: 4, 168: 5, 169: 3, 172: 3, 180: 4, 184: 6, 187: 6, 188: 5, 191: 4, 194: 5, 202: 6, 203: 7, 206: 3, 207: 4, 215: 3, 217: 4, 218: 9, 220: 3, 221: 3, 222: 6, 224: 4, 227: 2, 229: 3, 234: 6, 235: 3, 241: 3, 242: 3, 243: 5, 244: 4, 245: 5, 248: 4, 250: 3, 258: 12, 262: 5, 263: 6, 264: 4, 267: 5, 270: 2, 272: 3, 273: 6, 287: 4, 289: 3, 291: 5, 299: 2, 300: 2, 304: 2, 309: 4, 314: 3, 315: 3, 320: 3, 323: 5, 327: 5, 328: 4, 329: 3, 330: 11, 334: 3, 341: 2, 342: 3, 347: 2, 348: 2, 350: 8, 351: 5, 352: 3, 353: 3, 354: 2, 358: 5, 365: 3, 366: 3, 369: 2, 371: 4, 372: 5, 376: 3, 384: 5, 385: 4, 386: 4, 387: 2, 392: 4, 393: 5, 396: 3, 397: 8, 398: 7, 402: 3} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 96 "This section covers required behavior of a TSN-aware DetNet node using a TSN sub-network." Fixing conformance language Adding more definite references for TSN functions ( i.e. , Clause numbers ) 8f154039ea3f048f61ad08104a2c94420471e8b6 8f154039ea3f048f61ad08104a2c94420471e8b6 draft-ietf-detnet-ip-over-tsn 32f367c0df09e73fbac0f227a892fe94f0bf481c36bcaec69b0c9ae7d9198747 ['a0e207a167a3dce5a50aae1a2835f5e93b9227dbf68381c1dbd797df9659196c', '32f367c0df09e73fbac0f227a892fe94f0bf481c36bcaec69b0c9ae7d9198747'] A "this section covers required behavior of a tsn-aware detnet node using a tsn sub-network." {51: 1, 6: 4, 79: 4, 90: 4, 130: 3, 62: 5, 85: 6, 68: 6, 35: 5, 110: 4, 91: 6, 114: 4, 97: 2, 31: 5, 13: 4, 67: 4, 38: 5, 26: 4, 124: 5, 98: 4, 54: 4, 127: 5, 8: 4, 96: 2, 64: 4, 30: 4, 61: 6, 55: 5, 27: 5, 15: 4, 52: 2, 129: 5, 115: 4, 84: 4, 76: 8, 87: 4, 131: 7, 102: 4, 113: 6, 99: 4, 36: 4, 24: 3, 53: 3, 72: 5} {15: 1, 1: 11, 4: 4, 9: 7, 10: 5, 24: 4, 25: 5, 26: 6, 27: 3, 39: 7, 43: 5, 49: 7, 50: 6, 58: 6, 59: 4, 64: 3, 69: 6, 81: 6, 82: 4, 86: 4, 96: 5, 97: 4, 100: 7, 108: 5, 109: 6, 110: 6, 111: 4, 114: 5, 115: 6, 116: 3, 118: 8, 119: 7, 120: 5, 121: 6, 122: 4, 123: 3, 124: 6, 128: 5, 129: 4, 130: 6, 132: 6, 136: 4, 145: 6, 147: 5, 151: 5, 152: 5, 154: 5, 156: 2, 161: 5, 162: 5, 165: 5, 168: 6, 169: 4, 172: 4, 180: 5, 184: 7, 187: 7, 188: 6, 191: 5, 194: 6, 202: 7, 203: 8, 206: 4, 207: 5, 215: 4, 217: 5, 218: 10, 220: 4, 221: 4, 222: 7, 224: 5, 227: 5, 229: 4, 234: 7, 235: 4, 241: 4, 242: 4, 243: 6, 244: 5, 245: 6, 248: 5, 258: 13, 262: 6, 263: 7, 264: 5, 267: 6, 270: 3, 272: 4, 273: 7, 287: 5, 289: 4, 291: 6, 299: 5, 300: 2, 304: 3, 309: 5, 314: 4, 315: 4, 320: 6, 323: 6, 327: 6, 328: 5, 329: 4, 330: 12, 334: 4, 335: 3, 341: 5, 342: 6, 347: 5, 348: 5, 350: 9, 351: 6, 352: 4, 353: 4, 354: 3, 358: 6, 365: 4, 366: 4, 369: 3, 371: 7, 372: 6, 376: 4, 384: 6, 385: 5, 386: 5, 387: 2, 392: 5, 393: 6, 396: 6, 397: 9, 398: 8, 402: 4} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 96 "This section covers required behavior of a TSN-aware DetNet node using a TSN sub-network. The implementation of TSN packet processing functions MUST be compliant with the relevant IEEE 802.1 standards." Fixing conformance language Adding more definite references for TSN functions ( i.e. , Clause numbers ) 8f154039ea3f048f61ad08104a2c94420471e8b6 8f154039ea3f048f61ad08104a2c94420471e8b6 draft-ietf-detnet-ip-over-tsn a0e207a167a3dce5a50aae1a2835f5e93b9227dbf68381c1dbd797df9659196c ['a0e207a167a3dce5a50aae1a2835f5e93b9227dbf68381c1dbd797df9659196c', '32f367c0df09e73fbac0f227a892fe94f0bf481c36bcaec69b0c9ae7d9198747'] B "this section covers required behavior of a tsn-aware detnet node using a tsn sub-network. the implementation of tsn packet processing functions must be compliant with the relevant ieee 802.1 standards." {51: 1, 6: 4, 79: 4, 90: 4, 130: 3, 62: 5, 85: 6, 68: 6, 35: 5, 110: 4, 91: 6, 114: 4, 97: 2, 31: 5, 13: 4, 67: 4, 38: 5, 26: 4, 124: 5, 98: 4, 54: 4, 127: 5, 8: 4, 96: 2, 64: 4, 30: 4, 61: 6, 55: 5, 27: 5, 15: 4, 52: 2, 129: 5, 115: 4, 84: 4, 76: 8, 87: 4, 131: 7, 102: 4, 113: 6, 99: 4, 36: 4, 24: 3, 53: 3, 72: 5} {15: 1, 1: 11, 4: 4, 9: 7, 10: 5, 24: 4, 25: 5, 26: 6, 27: 3, 39: 7, 43: 5, 49: 7, 50: 6, 58: 6, 59: 4, 64: 3, 69: 6, 81: 6, 82: 4, 86: 4, 96: 5, 97: 4, 100: 7, 108: 5, 109: 6, 110: 6, 111: 4, 114: 5, 115: 6, 116: 3, 118: 8, 119: 7, 120: 5, 121: 6, 122: 4, 123: 3, 124: 6, 128: 5, 129: 4, 130: 6, 132: 6, 136: 4, 145: 6, 147: 5, 151: 5, 152: 5, 154: 5, 156: 2, 161: 5, 162: 5, 165: 5, 168: 6, 169: 4, 172: 4, 180: 5, 184: 7, 187: 7, 188: 6, 191: 5, 194: 6, 202: 7, 203: 8, 206: 4, 207: 5, 215: 4, 217: 5, 218: 10, 220: 4, 221: 4, 222: 7, 224: 5, 227: 5, 229: 4, 234: 7, 235: 4, 241: 4, 242: 4, 243: 6, 244: 5, 245: 6, 248: 5, 258: 13, 262: 6, 263: 7, 264: 5, 267: 6, 270: 3, 272: 4, 273: 7, 287: 5, 289: 4, 291: 6, 299: 5, 300: 2, 304: 3, 309: 5, 314: 4, 315: 4, 320: 6, 323: 6, 327: 6, 328: 5, 329: 4, 330: 12, 334: 4, 335: 3, 341: 5, 342: 6, 347: 5, 348: 5, 350: 9, 351: 6, 352: 4, 353: 4, 354: 3, 358: 6, 365: 4, 366: 4, 369: 3, 371: 7, 372: 6, 376: 4, 384: 6, 385: 5, 386: 5, 387: 2, 392: 5, 393: 6, 396: 6, 397: 9, 398: 8, 402: 4} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 96 "A TSN-aware IP (DetNet) node implementations MUST support the Sequencing function and the Sequence encode/decode function as defined in IEEE8021CB if FRER is used inside the TSN sub-network." Fixing conformance language Adding more definite references for TSN functions ( i.e. , Clause numbers ) 8f154039ea3f048f61ad08104a2c94420471e8b6 8f154039ea3f048f61ad08104a2c94420471e8b6 draft-ietf-detnet-ip-over-tsn 892d2555f9a89a54f020e44c71d17881727e9c245d0c7a7054f24fb2bfd083c9 ['c158ca16bcdc5ad922a62357c2790d9c6dd3ce65a6843ffd7083d1b4bfb27b73', '892d2555f9a89a54f020e44c71d17881727e9c245d0c7a7054f24fb2bfd083c9', '2f07ef13fb197dfbb24335dba11708eeddc61cae0c297c3eb842636965aba642', '214810fe3ac0ef76db60e2d0623a8259b9bdf49040882a9e710901fe1eb32fde', 'ab53f0283dfc6a938ab85afcd9676923433c5b54408e584b493487c049a1acbe', '0c46405157ad91fab020838f7adacd18f74fa0a01a63951f257572cd75d1bd74'] A "a tsn-aware ip (detnet) node implementations must support the sequencing function and the sequence encode/decode function as defined in ieee8021cb if frer is used inside the tsn sub-network." {51: 1, 52: 1, 97: 1, 6: 3, 79: 3, 90: 3, 130: 2, 62: 4, 85: 5, 68: 5, 35: 4, 110: 3, 91: 5, 114: 3, 31: 4, 13: 3, 67: 3, 38: 4, 26: 3, 124: 4, 98: 3, 54: 3, 127: 4, 8: 3, 96: 2, 64: 3, 30: 3, 61: 5, 55: 4, 27: 4, 15: 3, 129: 4, 115: 3, 84: 3, 76: 7, 87: 3, 131: 6, 102: 3, 113: 5, 99: 3, 36: 3, 24: 2, 53: 2, 72: 4} {15: 1, 156: 1, 387: 1, 1: 10, 4: 3, 9: 6, 10: 4, 24: 3, 25: 4, 26: 5, 27: 2, 39: 6, 43: 4, 49: 6, 50: 5, 58: 5, 59: 3, 64: 2, 69: 5, 81: 5, 82: 3, 86: 3, 96: 4, 97: 3, 100: 6, 108: 4, 109: 5, 110: 5, 111: 3, 114: 4, 115: 5, 116: 2, 118: 7, 119: 6, 120: 4, 121: 5, 122: 3, 123: 2, 124: 5, 128: 4, 129: 3, 130: 5, 132: 5, 136: 3, 145: 5, 147: 4, 151: 4, 152: 4, 154: 4, 161: 4, 162: 4, 165: 4, 168: 5, 169: 3, 172: 3, 180: 4, 184: 6, 187: 6, 188: 5, 191: 4, 194: 5, 202: 6, 203: 7, 206: 3, 207: 4, 215: 3, 217: 4, 218: 9, 220: 3, 221: 3, 222: 6, 224: 4, 227: 4, 229: 3, 234: 6, 235: 3, 241: 3, 242: 3, 243: 5, 244: 4, 245: 5, 248: 4, 250: 2, 258: 12, 262: 5, 263: 6, 264: 4, 267: 5, 270: 2, 272: 3, 273: 6, 287: 4, 289: 3, 291: 5, 299: 4, 304: 2, 309: 4, 314: 3, 315: 3, 320: 5, 323: 5, 327: 5, 328: 4, 329: 3, 330: 11, 334: 3, 335: 2, 341: 4, 342: 5, 347: 4, 348: 4, 350: 8, 351: 5, 352: 3, 353: 3, 354: 2, 358: 5, 365: 3, 366: 3, 369: 2, 371: 6, 372: 5, 376: 3, 384: 5, 385: 4, 386: 4, 392: 4, 393: 5, 396: 5, 397: 8, 398: 7, 402: 3} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 96 "A TSN-aware IP (DetNet) node implementations MUST support the Stream splitting function and the Individual recovery function as defined in IEEE8021CB when the node is a replication or elimination point for FRER." Fixing conformance language Adding more definite references for TSN functions ( i.e. , Clause numbers ) 8f154039ea3f048f61ad08104a2c94420471e8b6 8f154039ea3f048f61ad08104a2c94420471e8b6 draft-ietf-detnet-ip-over-tsn 2f07ef13fb197dfbb24335dba11708eeddc61cae0c297c3eb842636965aba642 ['c158ca16bcdc5ad922a62357c2790d9c6dd3ce65a6843ffd7083d1b4bfb27b73', '892d2555f9a89a54f020e44c71d17881727e9c245d0c7a7054f24fb2bfd083c9', '2f07ef13fb197dfbb24335dba11708eeddc61cae0c297c3eb842636965aba642', '214810fe3ac0ef76db60e2d0623a8259b9bdf49040882a9e710901fe1eb32fde', 'ab53f0283dfc6a938ab85afcd9676923433c5b54408e584b493487c049a1acbe', '0c46405157ad91fab020838f7adacd18f74fa0a01a63951f257572cd75d1bd74'] A "a tsn-aware ip (detnet) node implementations must support the stream splitting function and the individual recovery function as defined in ieee8021cb when the node is a replication or elimination point for frer." {51: 1, 52: 1, 97: 1, 6: 3, 79: 3, 90: 3, 130: 2, 62: 4, 85: 5, 68: 5, 35: 4, 110: 3, 91: 5, 114: 3, 31: 4, 13: 3, 67: 3, 38: 4, 26: 3, 124: 4, 98: 3, 54: 3, 127: 4, 8: 3, 96: 2, 64: 3, 30: 3, 61: 5, 55: 4, 27: 4, 15: 3, 129: 4, 115: 3, 84: 3, 76: 7, 87: 3, 131: 6, 102: 3, 113: 5, 99: 3, 36: 3, 24: 2, 53: 2, 72: 4} {15: 1, 156: 1, 387: 1, 1: 10, 4: 3, 9: 6, 10: 4, 24: 3, 25: 4, 26: 5, 27: 2, 39: 6, 43: 4, 49: 6, 50: 5, 58: 5, 59: 3, 64: 2, 69: 5, 81: 5, 82: 3, 86: 3, 96: 4, 97: 3, 100: 6, 108: 4, 109: 5, 110: 5, 111: 3, 114: 4, 115: 5, 116: 2, 118: 7, 119: 6, 120: 4, 121: 5, 122: 3, 123: 2, 124: 5, 128: 4, 129: 3, 130: 5, 132: 5, 136: 3, 145: 5, 147: 4, 151: 4, 152: 4, 154: 4, 161: 4, 162: 4, 165: 4, 168: 5, 169: 3, 172: 3, 180: 4, 184: 6, 187: 6, 188: 5, 191: 4, 194: 5, 202: 6, 203: 7, 206: 3, 207: 4, 215: 3, 217: 4, 218: 9, 220: 3, 221: 3, 222: 6, 224: 4, 227: 4, 229: 3, 234: 6, 235: 3, 241: 3, 242: 3, 243: 5, 244: 4, 245: 5, 248: 4, 250: 2, 258: 12, 262: 5, 263: 6, 264: 4, 267: 5, 270: 2, 272: 3, 273: 6, 287: 4, 289: 3, 291: 5, 299: 4, 304: 2, 309: 4, 314: 3, 315: 3, 320: 5, 323: 5, 327: 5, 328: 4, 329: 3, 330: 11, 334: 3, 335: 2, 341: 4, 342: 5, 347: 4, 348: 4, 350: 8, 351: 5, 352: 3, 353: 3, 354: 2, 358: 5, 365: 3, 366: 3, 369: 2, 371: 6, 372: 5, 376: 3, 384: 5, 385: 4, 386: 4, 392: 4, 393: 5, 396: 5, 397: 8, 398: 7, 402: 3} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 96 "TSN Streams supporting DetNet flows may use Frame Replication and Elimination for Redundancy (FRER) as defined in IEEE8021CB based on the loss service requirements of the TSN Stream, which is derived from the DetNet service requirements of the DetNet mapped flow. The specific operation of FRER is not modified by the use of DetNet and follows IEEE8021CB." Fixing conformance language Adding more definite references for TSN functions ( i.e. , Clause numbers ) 8f154039ea3f048f61ad08104a2c94420471e8b6 8f154039ea3f048f61ad08104a2c94420471e8b6 draft-ietf-detnet-ip-over-tsn 214810fe3ac0ef76db60e2d0623a8259b9bdf49040882a9e710901fe1eb32fde ['c158ca16bcdc5ad922a62357c2790d9c6dd3ce65a6843ffd7083d1b4bfb27b73', '892d2555f9a89a54f020e44c71d17881727e9c245d0c7a7054f24fb2bfd083c9', '2f07ef13fb197dfbb24335dba11708eeddc61cae0c297c3eb842636965aba642', '214810fe3ac0ef76db60e2d0623a8259b9bdf49040882a9e710901fe1eb32fde', 'ab53f0283dfc6a938ab85afcd9676923433c5b54408e584b493487c049a1acbe', '0c46405157ad91fab020838f7adacd18f74fa0a01a63951f257572cd75d1bd74'] A "tsn streams supporting detnet flows may use frame replication and elimination for redundancy (frer) as defined in ieee8021cb based on the loss service requirements of the tsn stream, which is derived from the detnet service requirements of the detnet mapped flow. the specific operation of frer is not modified by the use of detnet and follows ieee8021cb." {51: 1, 52: 1, 97: 1, 6: 3, 79: 3, 90: 3, 130: 2, 62: 4, 85: 5, 68: 5, 35: 4, 110: 3, 91: 5, 114: 3, 31: 4, 13: 3, 67: 3, 38: 4, 26: 3, 124: 4, 98: 3, 54: 3, 127: 4, 8: 3, 96: 2, 64: 3, 30: 3, 61: 5, 55: 4, 27: 4, 15: 3, 129: 4, 115: 3, 84: 3, 76: 7, 87: 3, 131: 6, 102: 3, 113: 5, 99: 3, 36: 3, 24: 2, 53: 2, 72: 4} {15: 1, 156: 1, 387: 1, 1: 10, 4: 3, 9: 6, 10: 4, 24: 3, 25: 4, 26: 5, 27: 2, 39: 6, 43: 4, 49: 6, 50: 5, 58: 5, 59: 3, 64: 2, 69: 5, 81: 5, 82: 3, 86: 3, 96: 4, 97: 3, 100: 6, 108: 4, 109: 5, 110: 5, 111: 3, 114: 4, 115: 5, 116: 2, 118: 7, 119: 6, 120: 4, 121: 5, 122: 3, 123: 2, 124: 5, 128: 4, 129: 3, 130: 5, 132: 5, 136: 3, 145: 5, 147: 4, 151: 4, 152: 4, 154: 4, 161: 4, 162: 4, 165: 4, 168: 5, 169: 3, 172: 3, 180: 4, 184: 6, 187: 6, 188: 5, 191: 4, 194: 5, 202: 6, 203: 7, 206: 3, 207: 4, 215: 3, 217: 4, 218: 9, 220: 3, 221: 3, 222: 6, 224: 4, 227: 4, 229: 3, 234: 6, 235: 3, 241: 3, 242: 3, 243: 5, 244: 4, 245: 5, 248: 4, 250: 2, 258: 12, 262: 5, 263: 6, 264: 4, 267: 5, 270: 2, 272: 3, 273: 6, 287: 4, 289: 3, 291: 5, 299: 4, 304: 2, 309: 4, 314: 3, 315: 3, 320: 5, 323: 5, 327: 5, 328: 4, 329: 3, 330: 11, 334: 3, 335: 2, 341: 4, 342: 5, 347: 4, 348: 4, 350: 8, 351: 5, 352: 3, 353: 3, 354: 2, 358: 5, 365: 3, 366: 3, 369: 2, 371: 6, 372: 5, 376: 3, 384: 5, 385: 4, 386: 4, 392: 4, 393: 5, 396: 5, 397: 8, 398: 7, 402: 3} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 96 "A TSN-aware IP (DetNet) node implementations MUST support the Sequencing function and the Sequence encode/decode function as defined in Clause 7.4 and 7.6 of IEEE8021CB if FRER is used inside the TSN sub-network." Fixing conformance language Adding more definite references for TSN functions ( i.e. , Clause numbers ) 8f154039ea3f048f61ad08104a2c94420471e8b6 8f154039ea3f048f61ad08104a2c94420471e8b6 draft-ietf-detnet-ip-over-tsn 0c46405157ad91fab020838f7adacd18f74fa0a01a63951f257572cd75d1bd74 ['c158ca16bcdc5ad922a62357c2790d9c6dd3ce65a6843ffd7083d1b4bfb27b73', '892d2555f9a89a54f020e44c71d17881727e9c245d0c7a7054f24fb2bfd083c9', '2f07ef13fb197dfbb24335dba11708eeddc61cae0c297c3eb842636965aba642', '214810fe3ac0ef76db60e2d0623a8259b9bdf49040882a9e710901fe1eb32fde', 'ab53f0283dfc6a938ab85afcd9676923433c5b54408e584b493487c049a1acbe', '0c46405157ad91fab020838f7adacd18f74fa0a01a63951f257572cd75d1bd74'] B "a tsn-aware ip (detnet) node implementations must support the sequencing function and the sequence encode/decode function as defined in clause 7.4 and 7.6 of ieee8021cb if frer is used inside the tsn sub-network." {51: 1, 52: 1, 97: 1, 6: 3, 79: 3, 90: 3, 130: 2, 62: 4, 85: 5, 68: 5, 35: 4, 110: 3, 91: 5, 114: 3, 31: 4, 13: 3, 67: 3, 38: 4, 26: 3, 124: 4, 98: 3, 54: 3, 127: 4, 8: 3, 96: 2, 64: 3, 30: 3, 61: 5, 55: 4, 27: 4, 15: 3, 129: 4, 115: 3, 84: 3, 76: 7, 87: 3, 131: 6, 102: 3, 113: 5, 99: 3, 36: 3, 24: 2, 53: 2, 72: 4} {15: 1, 156: 1, 387: 1, 1: 10, 4: 3, 9: 6, 10: 4, 24: 3, 25: 4, 26: 5, 27: 2, 39: 6, 43: 4, 49: 6, 50: 5, 58: 5, 59: 3, 64: 2, 69: 5, 81: 5, 82: 3, 86: 3, 96: 4, 97: 3, 100: 6, 108: 4, 109: 5, 110: 5, 111: 3, 114: 4, 115: 5, 116: 2, 118: 7, 119: 6, 120: 4, 121: 5, 122: 3, 123: 2, 124: 5, 128: 4, 129: 3, 130: 5, 132: 5, 136: 3, 145: 5, 147: 4, 151: 4, 152: 4, 154: 4, 161: 4, 162: 4, 165: 4, 168: 5, 169: 3, 172: 3, 180: 4, 184: 6, 187: 6, 188: 5, 191: 4, 194: 5, 202: 6, 203: 7, 206: 3, 207: 4, 215: 3, 217: 4, 218: 9, 220: 3, 221: 3, 222: 6, 224: 4, 227: 4, 229: 3, 234: 6, 235: 3, 241: 3, 242: 3, 243: 5, 244: 4, 245: 5, 248: 4, 250: 2, 258: 12, 262: 5, 263: 6, 264: 4, 267: 5, 270: 2, 272: 3, 273: 6, 287: 4, 289: 3, 291: 5, 299: 4, 304: 2, 309: 4, 314: 3, 315: 3, 320: 5, 323: 5, 327: 5, 328: 4, 329: 3, 330: 11, 334: 3, 335: 2, 341: 4, 342: 5, 347: 4, 348: 4, 350: 8, 351: 5, 352: 3, 353: 3, 354: 2, 358: 5, 365: 3, 366: 3, 369: 2, 371: 6, 372: 5, 376: 3, 384: 5, 385: 4, 386: 4, 392: 4, 393: 5, 396: 5, 397: 8, 398: 7, 402: 3} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 96 "A TSN-aware IP (DetNet) node implementations MUST support the Stream splitting function and the Individual recovery function as defined in Clause 7.7 and 7.5 of IEEE8021CB when the node is a replication or elimination point for FRER." Fixing conformance language Adding more definite references for TSN functions ( i.e. , Clause numbers ) 8f154039ea3f048f61ad08104a2c94420471e8b6 8f154039ea3f048f61ad08104a2c94420471e8b6 draft-ietf-detnet-ip-over-tsn c158ca16bcdc5ad922a62357c2790d9c6dd3ce65a6843ffd7083d1b4bfb27b73 ['c158ca16bcdc5ad922a62357c2790d9c6dd3ce65a6843ffd7083d1b4bfb27b73', '892d2555f9a89a54f020e44c71d17881727e9c245d0c7a7054f24fb2bfd083c9', '2f07ef13fb197dfbb24335dba11708eeddc61cae0c297c3eb842636965aba642', '214810fe3ac0ef76db60e2d0623a8259b9bdf49040882a9e710901fe1eb32fde', 'ab53f0283dfc6a938ab85afcd9676923433c5b54408e584b493487c049a1acbe', '0c46405157ad91fab020838f7adacd18f74fa0a01a63951f257572cd75d1bd74'] B "a tsn-aware ip (detnet) node implementations must support the stream splitting function and the individual recovery function as defined in clause 7.7 and 7.5 of ieee8021cb when the node is a replication or elimination point for frer." {51: 1, 52: 1, 97: 1, 6: 3, 79: 3, 90: 3, 130: 2, 62: 4, 85: 5, 68: 5, 35: 4, 110: 3, 91: 5, 114: 3, 31: 4, 13: 3, 67: 3, 38: 4, 26: 3, 124: 4, 98: 3, 54: 3, 127: 4, 8: 3, 96: 2, 64: 3, 30: 3, 61: 5, 55: 4, 27: 4, 15: 3, 129: 4, 115: 3, 84: 3, 76: 7, 87: 3, 131: 6, 102: 3, 113: 5, 99: 3, 36: 3, 24: 2, 53: 2, 72: 4} {15: 1, 156: 1, 387: 1, 1: 10, 4: 3, 9: 6, 10: 4, 24: 3, 25: 4, 26: 5, 27: 2, 39: 6, 43: 4, 49: 6, 50: 5, 58: 5, 59: 3, 64: 2, 69: 5, 81: 5, 82: 3, 86: 3, 96: 4, 97: 3, 100: 6, 108: 4, 109: 5, 110: 5, 111: 3, 114: 4, 115: 5, 116: 2, 118: 7, 119: 6, 120: 4, 121: 5, 122: 3, 123: 2, 124: 5, 128: 4, 129: 3, 130: 5, 132: 5, 136: 3, 145: 5, 147: 4, 151: 4, 152: 4, 154: 4, 161: 4, 162: 4, 165: 4, 168: 5, 169: 3, 172: 3, 180: 4, 184: 6, 187: 6, 188: 5, 191: 4, 194: 5, 202: 6, 203: 7, 206: 3, 207: 4, 215: 3, 217: 4, 218: 9, 220: 3, 221: 3, 222: 6, 224: 4, 227: 4, 229: 3, 234: 6, 235: 3, 241: 3, 242: 3, 243: 5, 244: 4, 245: 5, 248: 4, 250: 2, 258: 12, 262: 5, 263: 6, 264: 4, 267: 5, 270: 2, 272: 3, 273: 6, 287: 4, 289: 3, 291: 5, 299: 4, 304: 2, 309: 4, 314: 3, 315: 3, 320: 5, 323: 5, 327: 5, 328: 4, 329: 3, 330: 11, 334: 3, 335: 2, 341: 4, 342: 5, 347: 4, 348: 4, 350: 8, 351: 5, 352: 3, 353: 3, 354: 2, 358: 5, 365: 3, 366: 3, 369: 2, 371: 6, 372: 5, 376: 3, 384: 5, 385: 4, 386: 4, 392: 4, 393: 5, 396: 5, 397: 8, 398: 7, 402: 3} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 96 "TSN Streams supporting DetNet flows may use Frame Replication and Elimination for Redundancy (FRER) as defined in Clause 8. of IEEE8021CB based on the loss service requirements of the TSN Stream, which is derived from the DetNet service requirements of the DetNet mapped flow. The specific operation of FRER is not modified by the use of DetNet and follows IEEE8021CB." Fixing conformance language Adding more definite references for TSN functions ( i.e. , Clause numbers ) 8f154039ea3f048f61ad08104a2c94420471e8b6 8f154039ea3f048f61ad08104a2c94420471e8b6 draft-ietf-detnet-ip-over-tsn ab53f0283dfc6a938ab85afcd9676923433c5b54408e584b493487c049a1acbe ['c158ca16bcdc5ad922a62357c2790d9c6dd3ce65a6843ffd7083d1b4bfb27b73', '892d2555f9a89a54f020e44c71d17881727e9c245d0c7a7054f24fb2bfd083c9', '2f07ef13fb197dfbb24335dba11708eeddc61cae0c297c3eb842636965aba642', '214810fe3ac0ef76db60e2d0623a8259b9bdf49040882a9e710901fe1eb32fde', 'ab53f0283dfc6a938ab85afcd9676923433c5b54408e584b493487c049a1acbe', '0c46405157ad91fab020838f7adacd18f74fa0a01a63951f257572cd75d1bd74'] B "tsn streams supporting detnet flows may use frame replication and elimination for redundancy (frer) as defined in clause 8. of ieee8021cb based on the loss service requirements of the tsn stream, which is derived from the detnet service requirements of the detnet mapped flow. the specific operation of frer is not modified by the use of detnet and follows ieee8021cb." {51: 1, 52: 1, 97: 1, 6: 3, 79: 3, 90: 3, 130: 2, 62: 4, 85: 5, 68: 5, 35: 4, 110: 3, 91: 5, 114: 3, 31: 4, 13: 3, 67: 3, 38: 4, 26: 3, 124: 4, 98: 3, 54: 3, 127: 4, 8: 3, 96: 2, 64: 3, 30: 3, 61: 5, 55: 4, 27: 4, 15: 3, 129: 4, 115: 3, 84: 3, 76: 7, 87: 3, 131: 6, 102: 3, 113: 5, 99: 3, 36: 3, 24: 2, 53: 2, 72: 4} {15: 1, 156: 1, 387: 1, 1: 10, 4: 3, 9: 6, 10: 4, 24: 3, 25: 4, 26: 5, 27: 2, 39: 6, 43: 4, 49: 6, 50: 5, 58: 5, 59: 3, 64: 2, 69: 5, 81: 5, 82: 3, 86: 3, 96: 4, 97: 3, 100: 6, 108: 4, 109: 5, 110: 5, 111: 3, 114: 4, 115: 5, 116: 2, 118: 7, 119: 6, 120: 4, 121: 5, 122: 3, 123: 2, 124: 5, 128: 4, 129: 3, 130: 5, 132: 5, 136: 3, 145: 5, 147: 4, 151: 4, 152: 4, 154: 4, 161: 4, 162: 4, 165: 4, 168: 5, 169: 3, 172: 3, 180: 4, 184: 6, 187: 6, 188: 5, 191: 4, 194: 5, 202: 6, 203: 7, 206: 3, 207: 4, 215: 3, 217: 4, 218: 9, 220: 3, 221: 3, 222: 6, 224: 4, 227: 4, 229: 3, 234: 6, 235: 3, 241: 3, 242: 3, 243: 5, 244: 4, 245: 5, 248: 4, 250: 2, 258: 12, 262: 5, 263: 6, 264: 4, 267: 5, 270: 2, 272: 3, 273: 6, 287: 4, 289: 3, 291: 5, 299: 4, 304: 2, 309: 4, 314: 3, 315: 3, 320: 5, 323: 5, 327: 5, 328: 4, 329: 3, 330: 11, 334: 3, 335: 2, 341: 4, 342: 5, 347: 4, 348: 4, 350: 8, 351: 5, 352: 3, 353: 3, 354: 2, 358: 5, 365: 3, 366: 3, 369: 2, 371: 6, 372: 5, 376: 3, 384: 5, 385: 4, 386: 4, 392: 4, 393: 5, 396: 5, 397: 8, 398: 7, 402: 3} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 96 "DetNet IP related configuration information according to the DetNet role of the DetNet IP node, as per I-D.ietf-detnet-ip." Fixing conformance language Adding more definite references for TSN functions ( i.e. , Clause numbers ) 8f154039ea3f048f61ad08104a2c94420471e8b6 8f154039ea3f048f61ad08104a2c94420471e8b6 draft-ietf-detnet-ip-over-tsn 865a4dd25342931383c0ae9a75ebc6db73fae9af899e0b378481a3e7f59d1bd8 ['fa9ee1de4b90f234826a8ec61f39b313e6f6c07026a1cb63e1bfee8aa1337fc8', '6060505876485aa149ffd29bddff33ad76157c92510215db931d1559fd59114d', '6e61f5c2c26a388e9438981f332ec359885afede8a82dc7da907fd320ed11bc0', '865a4dd25342931383c0ae9a75ebc6db73fae9af899e0b378481a3e7f59d1bd8'] B "detnet ip related configuration information according to the detnet role of the detnet ip node, as per i-d.ietf-detnet-ip." {97: 1, 98: 1, 127: 1, 130: 2, 124: 2} {12: 1, 13: 1, 153: 1, 208: 2, 63: 2} {12, 13, 208, 403, 153, 63} 96 "TSN related configuration information according to the TSN role of the DetNet IP node, as per IEEE8021Q, IEEE8021CB and IEEEP8021CBdb." Fixing conformance language Adding more definite references for TSN functions ( i.e. , Clause numbers ) 8f154039ea3f048f61ad08104a2c94420471e8b6 8f154039ea3f048f61ad08104a2c94420471e8b6 draft-ietf-detnet-ip-over-tsn 6e61f5c2c26a388e9438981f332ec359885afede8a82dc7da907fd320ed11bc0 ['fa9ee1de4b90f234826a8ec61f39b313e6f6c07026a1cb63e1bfee8aa1337fc8', '6060505876485aa149ffd29bddff33ad76157c92510215db931d1559fd59114d', '6e61f5c2c26a388e9438981f332ec359885afede8a82dc7da907fd320ed11bc0', '865a4dd25342931383c0ae9a75ebc6db73fae9af899e0b378481a3e7f59d1bd8'] B "tsn related configuration information according to the tsn role of the detnet ip node, as per ieee8021q, ieee8021cb and ieeep8021cbdb." {97: 1, 98: 1, 127: 1, 130: 2, 124: 2} {12: 1, 13: 1, 153: 1, 208: 2, 63: 2} {12, 13, 208, 403, 153, 63} 96 "Mapping between DetNet IP flow(s) (as flow identification defined in I-D.ietf-detnet-ip, it is summarized in Section 5.1 of that document, and includes all wildcards, port ranges and the ability to ignore specific IP fields) and TSN Stream(s) (as stream identification information defined in IEEE8021CB and IEEEP8021CBdb). Note, that managed objects for TSN Stream identification can be found in IEEEP8021CBcv." Fixing conformance language Adding more definite references for TSN functions ( i.e. , Clause numbers ) 8f154039ea3f048f61ad08104a2c94420471e8b6 8f154039ea3f048f61ad08104a2c94420471e8b6 draft-ietf-detnet-ip-over-tsn 6060505876485aa149ffd29bddff33ad76157c92510215db931d1559fd59114d ['fa9ee1de4b90f234826a8ec61f39b313e6f6c07026a1cb63e1bfee8aa1337fc8', '6060505876485aa149ffd29bddff33ad76157c92510215db931d1559fd59114d', '6e61f5c2c26a388e9438981f332ec359885afede8a82dc7da907fd320ed11bc0', '865a4dd25342931383c0ae9a75ebc6db73fae9af899e0b378481a3e7f59d1bd8'] B "mapping between detnet ip flow(s) (as flow identification defined in i-d.ietf-detnet-ip, it is summarized in section 5.1 of that document, and includes all wildcards, port ranges and the ability to ignore specific ip fields) and tsn stream(s) (as stream identification information defined in ieee8021cb and ieeep8021cbdb). note, that managed objects for tsn stream identification can be found in ieeep8021cbcv." {97: 1, 98: 1, 127: 1, 130: 2, 124: 2} {12: 1, 13: 1, 153: 1, 208: 2, 63: 2} {12, 13, 208, 403, 153, 63} 96 This information MUST be provisioned per DetNet flow. Fixing conformance language Adding more definite references for TSN functions ( i.e. , Clause numbers ) 8f154039ea3f048f61ad08104a2c94420471e8b6 8f154039ea3f048f61ad08104a2c94420471e8b6 draft-ietf-detnet-ip-over-tsn fa9ee1de4b90f234826a8ec61f39b313e6f6c07026a1cb63e1bfee8aa1337fc8 ['fa9ee1de4b90f234826a8ec61f39b313e6f6c07026a1cb63e1bfee8aa1337fc8', '6060505876485aa149ffd29bddff33ad76157c92510215db931d1559fd59114d', '6e61f5c2c26a388e9438981f332ec359885afede8a82dc7da907fd320ed11bc0', '865a4dd25342931383c0ae9a75ebc6db73fae9af899e0b378481a3e7f59d1bd8'] B this information must be provisioned per detnet flow. {97: 1, 98: 1, 127: 1, 130: 2, 124: 2} {12: 1, 13: 1, 153: 1, 208: 2, 63: 2} {12, 13, 208, 403, 153, 63} 96 "In order to use a TSN sub-network between DetNet nodes, DetNet specific information must be converted to TSN sub-network specific ones. DetNet flow ID and flow related parameters/requirements must be converted to a TSN Stream ID and stream related parameters/ requirements. Note that, as the TSN sub-network is just a portion of the end2end DetNet path (i.e., single hop from IP perspective), some parameters (e.g., delay) may differ significantly. Other parameters (like bandwidth) also may have to be tuned due to the L2 encapsulation used within the TSN sub-network." Fixing conformance language Adding more definite references for TSN functions ( i.e. , Clause numbers ) 8f154039ea3f048f61ad08104a2c94420471e8b6 8f154039ea3f048f61ad08104a2c94420471e8b6 draft-ietf-detnet-ip-over-tsn f5a60a13bb46b3cce44df618c86626539a52d7da653dba2927f41e2f8ea94431 ['f5a60a13bb46b3cce44df618c86626539a52d7da653dba2927f41e2f8ea94431', '7a3a54dd32250df483b7ca36e9c3640d576e850d0c96f2a088ac2fda022ac6b8'] A "in order to use a tsn sub-network between detnet nodes, detnet specific information must be converted to tsn sub-network specific ones. detnet flow id and flow related parameters/requirements must be converted to a tsn stream id and stream related parameters/ requirements. note that, as the tsn sub-network is just a portion of the end2end detnet path (i.e., single hop from ip perspective), some parameters (e.g., delay) may differ significantly. other parameters (like bandwidth) also may have to be tuned due to the l2 encapsulation used within the tsn sub-network." {51: 1} {137: 1} {137, 394} 96 "In order to use a TSN sub-network between DetNet nodes, DetNet specific information must be converted to TSN sub-network specific ones. DetNet flow ID and flow related parameters/requirements must be converted to a TSN Stream ID and stream related parameters/ requirements. Note that, as the TSN sub-network is just a portion of the end-to-end DetNet path (i.e., single hop from IP perspective), some parameters (e.g., delay) may differ significantly. Other parameters (like bandwidth) also may have to be tuned due to the L2 encapsulation used within the TSN sub-network." Fixing conformance language Adding more definite references for TSN functions ( i.e. , Clause numbers ) 8f154039ea3f048f61ad08104a2c94420471e8b6 8f154039ea3f048f61ad08104a2c94420471e8b6 draft-ietf-detnet-ip-over-tsn 7a3a54dd32250df483b7ca36e9c3640d576e850d0c96f2a088ac2fda022ac6b8 ['f5a60a13bb46b3cce44df618c86626539a52d7da653dba2927f41e2f8ea94431', '7a3a54dd32250df483b7ca36e9c3640d576e850d0c96f2a088ac2fda022ac6b8'] B "in order to use a tsn sub-network between detnet nodes, detnet specific information must be converted to tsn sub-network specific ones. detnet flow id and flow related parameters/requirements must be converted to a tsn stream id and stream related parameters/ requirements. note that, as the tsn sub-network is just a portion of the end-to-end detnet path (i.e., single hop from ip perspective), some parameters (e.g., delay) may differ significantly. other parameters (like bandwidth) also may have to be tuned due to the l2 encapsulation used within the tsn sub-network." {51: 1} {137: 1} {137, 394} 96 "The security considerations of DetNet in general are discussed in RFC8655 and I-D.ietf-detnet-security. DetNet IP data plane specific considerations are summarized in I-D.ietf-detnet-ip. Encryption may provided by an underlying sub-net using MACSec IEEE802.1AE-2018 for DetNet IP over TSN flows." Fixing conformance language Adding more definite references for TSN functions ( i.e. , Clause numbers ) 8f154039ea3f048f61ad08104a2c94420471e8b6 8f154039ea3f048f61ad08104a2c94420471e8b6 draft-ietf-detnet-ip-over-tsn cba05296ebb141bdf62c1a9c0f5e737efed328b4fff899c70f6143ddc316e2c9 ['ca7dba4455acdc335610acb8f2232a35ca50a8e64a6f61d6ffc87f018f6774fa', '309ff460bb958c980f2550a641cf52f7ab2c4e52f8bc2630c8b7ec877b22742e', 'cba05296ebb141bdf62c1a9c0f5e737efed328b4fff899c70f6143ddc316e2c9', 'b093dff74bf4875a4f90e3908d9bc756c2772e6bbc5fe0e39965853285a7cf4d'] A "the security considerations of detnet in general are discussed in rfc8655 and i-d.ietf-detnet-security. detnet ip data plane specific considerations are summarized in i-d.ietf-detnet-ip. encryption may provided by an underlying sub-net using macsec ieee802.1ae-2018 for detnet ip over tsn flows." {97: 1, 127: 1, 130: 2} {249: 1, 319: 1, 225: 2} {225, 249, 318, 319} 96 "Security considerations for DetNet are described in detail in I- D.ietf-detnet-security. General security considerations are described in RFC8655. DetNet IP data plane specific considerations are summarized in I-D.ietf-detnet-ip. This section considers exclusively security considerations which are specific to the DetNet IP over TSN sub-network scenario." Fixing conformance language Adding more definite references for TSN functions ( i.e. , Clause numbers ) 8f154039ea3f048f61ad08104a2c94420471e8b6 8f154039ea3f048f61ad08104a2c94420471e8b6 draft-ietf-detnet-ip-over-tsn ca7dba4455acdc335610acb8f2232a35ca50a8e64a6f61d6ffc87f018f6774fa ['ca7dba4455acdc335610acb8f2232a35ca50a8e64a6f61d6ffc87f018f6774fa', '309ff460bb958c980f2550a641cf52f7ab2c4e52f8bc2630c8b7ec877b22742e', 'cba05296ebb141bdf62c1a9c0f5e737efed328b4fff899c70f6143ddc316e2c9', 'b093dff74bf4875a4f90e3908d9bc756c2772e6bbc5fe0e39965853285a7cf4d'] B "security considerations for detnet are described in detail in i- d.ietf-detnet-security. general security considerations are described in rfc8655. detnet ip data plane specific considerations are summarized in i-d.ietf-detnet-ip. this section considers exclusively security considerations which are specific to the detnet ip over tsn sub-network scenario." {97: 1, 127: 1, 130: 2} {249: 1, 319: 1, 225: 2} {225, 249, 318, 319} 96 "The sub-network between DetNet nodes needs to be subject to appropriate confidentiality. Additionally, knowledge of what DetNet/ TSN services are provided by a sub-network may supply information that can be used in a variety of security attacks. The ability to modify information exchanges between connected DetNet nodes may result in bogus operations. Therefore, it is important that the interface between DetNet nodes and TSN sub-network are subject to authorization, authentication, and encryption." Fixing conformance language Adding more definite references for TSN functions ( i.e. , Clause numbers ) 8f154039ea3f048f61ad08104a2c94420471e8b6 8f154039ea3f048f61ad08104a2c94420471e8b6 draft-ietf-detnet-ip-over-tsn b093dff74bf4875a4f90e3908d9bc756c2772e6bbc5fe0e39965853285a7cf4d ['ca7dba4455acdc335610acb8f2232a35ca50a8e64a6f61d6ffc87f018f6774fa', '309ff460bb958c980f2550a641cf52f7ab2c4e52f8bc2630c8b7ec877b22742e', 'cba05296ebb141bdf62c1a9c0f5e737efed328b4fff899c70f6143ddc316e2c9', 'b093dff74bf4875a4f90e3908d9bc756c2772e6bbc5fe0e39965853285a7cf4d'] B "the sub-network between detnet nodes needs to be subject to appropriate confidentiality. additionally, knowledge of what detnet/ tsn services are provided by a sub-network may supply information that can be used in a variety of security attacks. the ability to modify information exchanges between connected detnet nodes may result in bogus operations. therefore, it is important that the interface between detnet nodes and tsn sub-network are subject to authorization, authentication, and encryption." {97: 1, 127: 1, 130: 2} {249: 1, 319: 1, 225: 2} {225, 249, 318, 319} 96 "The TSN sub-network operates at Layer-2 so various security mechanisms defined by IEEE can be used to secure the connection between the DetNet nodes (e.g., encryption may be provided using MACSec IEEE802.1AE-2018)." Fixing conformance language Adding more definite references for TSN functions ( i.e. , Clause numbers ) 8f154039ea3f048f61ad08104a2c94420471e8b6 8f154039ea3f048f61ad08104a2c94420471e8b6 draft-ietf-detnet-ip-over-tsn 309ff460bb958c980f2550a641cf52f7ab2c4e52f8bc2630c8b7ec877b22742e ['ca7dba4455acdc335610acb8f2232a35ca50a8e64a6f61d6ffc87f018f6774fa', '309ff460bb958c980f2550a641cf52f7ab2c4e52f8bc2630c8b7ec877b22742e', 'cba05296ebb141bdf62c1a9c0f5e737efed328b4fff899c70f6143ddc316e2c9', 'b093dff74bf4875a4f90e3908d9bc756c2772e6bbc5fe0e39965853285a7cf4d'] B "the tsn sub-network operates at layer-2 so various security mechanisms defined by ieee can be used to secure the connection between the detnet nodes (e.g., encryption may be provided using macsec ieee802.1ae-2018)." {97: 1, 127: 1, 130: 2} {249: 1, 319: 1, 225: 2} {225, 249, 318, 319} 91 DetNet Control Word. Comments before 04 - 27 resolved . dd51857ea97b162ed6bd640dac7366aec1eff400 dd51857ea97b162ed6bd640dac7366aec1eff400 draft-ietf-detnet-ip-over-mpls 8a9f636b1cdab856d1233a7a3cfa4bc0e99b49da4ac574e376b09f10f4f341e9 ['8a9f636b1cdab856d1233a7a3cfa4bc0e99b49da4ac574e376b09f10f4f341e9'] B detnet control word. {55: 1, 68: 1, 130: 4, 79: 2, 51: 2, 112: 2, 64: 2, 62: 3, 37: 2, 38: 2, 69: 2, 67: 3, 33: 2, 25: 2, 53: 3, 80: 3, 52: 2, 127: 5, 91: 2} {142: 1, 279: 1, 0: 4, 389: 3, 390: 3, 135: 2, 14: 2, 400: 3, 17: 2, 399: 4, 19: 3, 149: 2, 406: 2, 280: 2, 281: 4, 278: 2, 294: 2, 296: 2, 45: 3, 308: 2, 56: 3, 185: 3, 192: 3, 321: 2, 322: 3, 66: 3, 196: 6, 197: 5, 324: 2, 77: 2, 78: 2, 337: 5, 380: 3, 255: 4} {0, 389, 390, 135, 142, 14, 400, 17, 399, 19, 149, 406, 279, 280, 281, 278, 294, 296, 45, 308, 56, 185, 192, 321, 322, 66, 196, 197, 324, 77, 78, 337, 216, 380, 255} 91 "DetNet ""service"" label." Comments before 04 - 27 resolved . dd51857ea97b162ed6bd640dac7366aec1eff400 dd51857ea97b162ed6bd640dac7366aec1eff400 draft-ietf-detnet-ip-over-mpls 34f6582bd92afa345dc5dcd62ba8f25eef20bd51d1919d3bde053a8ab6747c41 ['34f6582bd92afa345dc5dcd62ba8f25eef20bd51d1919d3bde053a8ab6747c41', '26473c01f76b3f46476cf53f2eb817abac81bbda38962b98172b76e776414d29'] B "detnet ""service"" label." {55: 1, 68: 1, 130: 4, 79: 2, 51: 2, 112: 2, 64: 2, 62: 3, 37: 2, 38: 2, 69: 2, 67: 3, 33: 2, 25: 2, 53: 3, 80: 3, 52: 2, 127: 5, 91: 2} {78: 1, 279: 1, 0: 4, 389: 3, 390: 3, 135: 2, 142: 2, 14: 2, 400: 3, 17: 2, 399: 4, 19: 3, 149: 2, 406: 2, 280: 2, 281: 4, 278: 2, 294: 2, 296: 2, 45: 3, 308: 2, 56: 3, 185: 3, 192: 3, 321: 2, 322: 3, 66: 3, 196: 6, 197: 5, 324: 2, 337: 5, 216: 2, 380: 3, 255: 4} {0, 389, 390, 135, 142, 14, 400, 17, 399, 19, 149, 406, 279, 280, 281, 278, 294, 296, 45, 308, 56, 185, 192, 321, 322, 66, 196, 197, 324, 77, 78, 337, 216, 380, 255} 91 Terminating Provider Edge. Comments before 04 - 27 resolved . dd51857ea97b162ed6bd640dac7366aec1eff400 dd51857ea97b162ed6bd640dac7366aec1eff400 draft-ietf-detnet-ip-over-mpls 26473c01f76b3f46476cf53f2eb817abac81bbda38962b98172b76e776414d29 ['34f6582bd92afa345dc5dcd62ba8f25eef20bd51d1919d3bde053a8ab6747c41', '26473c01f76b3f46476cf53f2eb817abac81bbda38962b98172b76e776414d29'] B terminating provider edge. {55: 1, 68: 1, 130: 4, 79: 2, 51: 2, 112: 2, 64: 2, 62: 3, 37: 2, 38: 2, 69: 2, 67: 3, 33: 2, 25: 2, 53: 3, 80: 3, 52: 2, 127: 5, 91: 2} {78: 1, 279: 1, 0: 4, 389: 3, 390: 3, 135: 2, 142: 2, 14: 2, 400: 3, 17: 2, 399: 4, 19: 3, 149: 2, 406: 2, 280: 2, 281: 4, 278: 2, 294: 2, 296: 2, 45: 3, 308: 2, 56: 3, 185: 3, 192: 3, 321: 2, 322: 3, 66: 3, 196: 6, 197: 5, 324: 2, 337: 5, 216: 2, 380: 3, 255: 4} {0, 389, 390, 135, 142, 14, 400, 17, 399, 19, 149, 406, 279, 280, 281, 278, 294, 296, 45, 308, 56, 185, 192, 321, 322, 66, 196, 197, 324, 77, 78, 337, 216, 380, 255} 91 "In fig_dn_ip_mpls_sn_ex ""App-Flow"" indicates the payload carried by the DetNet IP data plane. ""IP"" and ""NProto"" indicate the fields described in Section 5.1.1. IP Header Information and Section 5.1.2. Other Protocol Header Information in I-D.ietf-detnet-ip, respectively. ""App-Flow for MPLS"" indicates that an individual DetNet IP flow is the payload from the perspective of the DetNet MPLS data plane defined in I-D.ietf-detnet-mpls." Comments before 04 - 27 resolved . dd51857ea97b162ed6bd640dac7366aec1eff400 dd51857ea97b162ed6bd640dac7366aec1eff400 draft-ietf-detnet-ip-over-mpls 8efd63665bdd242791ce0e0fc3df6ebb3cb8285401a53e921d623ee329e88120 ['53c36c3d90d5007bc0198de38c15e629f4522743d0b145e20ce42205a78fcb55', '8efd63665bdd242791ce0e0fc3df6ebb3cb8285401a53e921d623ee329e88120', '7c3b073d48c204f2678d701bbeecdcfa30cff64f679911a1bd9d570735ddc2a8', 'c3ff5e891961cfaee984c9ec6e177cf829b2383d2dfdb323b2f310ba826db76a'] A "in fig_dn_ip_mpls_sn_ex ""app-flow"" indicates the payload carried by the detnet ip data plane. ""ip"" and ""nproto"" indicate the fields described in section 5.1.1. ip header information and section 5.1.2. other protocol header information in i-d.ietf-detnet-ip, respectively. ""app-flow for mpls"" indicates that an individual detnet ip flow is the payload from the perspective of the detnet mpls data plane defined in i-d.ietf-detnet-mpls." {110: 1, 63: 1, 30: 2, 56: 2, 36: 2} {346: 1, 395: 1, 356: 2, 75: 2, 333: 2} {356, 134, 75, 395, 333, 346} 91 "Per I-D.ietf-detnet-mpls, the DetNet MPLS data plane uses a single S-Label to support a single app flow. Section 5.1. DetNet IP Flow Identification Procedures in I-D.ietf-detnet-ip states that a single DetNet flow is identified based on IP, and next level protocol, header information. Section 4.4. Aggregation Considerations in I- D.ietf-detnet-ip defines the ways in which aggregation is supported through the use of prefixes, wildcards, lists, and port ranges. Collectively, this results in the fairly straightforward procedures defined in this section." Comments before 04 - 27 resolved . dd51857ea97b162ed6bd640dac7366aec1eff400 dd51857ea97b162ed6bd640dac7366aec1eff400 draft-ietf-detnet-ip-over-mpls 7c3b073d48c204f2678d701bbeecdcfa30cff64f679911a1bd9d570735ddc2a8 ['53c36c3d90d5007bc0198de38c15e629f4522743d0b145e20ce42205a78fcb55', '8efd63665bdd242791ce0e0fc3df6ebb3cb8285401a53e921d623ee329e88120', '7c3b073d48c204f2678d701bbeecdcfa30cff64f679911a1bd9d570735ddc2a8', 'c3ff5e891961cfaee984c9ec6e177cf829b2383d2dfdb323b2f310ba826db76a'] A "per i-d.ietf-detnet-mpls, the detnet mpls data plane uses a single s-label to support a single app flow. section 5.1. detnet ip flow identification procedures in i-d.ietf-detnet-ip states that a single detnet flow is identified based on ip, and next level protocol, header information. section 4.4. aggregation considerations in i- d.ietf-detnet-ip defines the ways in which aggregation is supported through the use of prefixes, wildcards, lists, and port ranges. collectively, this results in the fairly straightforward procedures defined in this section." {110: 1, 63: 1, 30: 2, 56: 2, 36: 2} {346: 1, 395: 1, 356: 2, 75: 2, 333: 2} {356, 134, 75, 395, 333, 346} 91 "In fig_dn_ip_mpls_sn_ex ""App-Flow"" indicates the payload carried by the DetNet IP data plane. ""IP"" and ""NProto"" indicate the fields described in Section 5.1.1. (IP Header Information) and Section 5.1.2. (Other Protocol Header Information) of I-D.ietf- detnet-ip, respectively. ""App-Flow for MPLS"" indicates that an individual DetNet IP flow is the payload from the perspective of the DetNet MPLS data plane defined in I-D.ietf-detnet-mpls." Comments before 04 - 27 resolved . dd51857ea97b162ed6bd640dac7366aec1eff400 dd51857ea97b162ed6bd640dac7366aec1eff400 draft-ietf-detnet-ip-over-mpls 53c36c3d90d5007bc0198de38c15e629f4522743d0b145e20ce42205a78fcb55 ['53c36c3d90d5007bc0198de38c15e629f4522743d0b145e20ce42205a78fcb55', '8efd63665bdd242791ce0e0fc3df6ebb3cb8285401a53e921d623ee329e88120', '7c3b073d48c204f2678d701bbeecdcfa30cff64f679911a1bd9d570735ddc2a8', 'c3ff5e891961cfaee984c9ec6e177cf829b2383d2dfdb323b2f310ba826db76a'] B "in fig_dn_ip_mpls_sn_ex ""app-flow"" indicates the payload carried by the detnet ip data plane. ""ip"" and ""nproto"" indicate the fields described in section 5.1.1. (ip header information) and section 5.1.2. (other protocol header information) of i-d.ietf- detnet-ip, respectively. ""app-flow for mpls"" indicates that an individual detnet ip flow is the payload from the perspective of the detnet mpls data plane defined in i-d.ietf-detnet-mpls." {110: 1, 63: 1, 30: 2, 56: 2, 36: 2} {346: 1, 395: 1, 356: 2, 75: 2, 333: 2} {356, 134, 75, 395, 333, 346} 91 "Per Section 5.1 of I-D.ietf-detnet-mpls, the DetNet MPLS data plane uses a single S-Label to support a single app flow. DetNet IP Flow Identification Procedures in Section 4.4 of I-D.ietf-detnet-ip states that a single DetNet flow is identified based on IP, and next level protocol, header information. Section 4.4. (Aggregation Considerations) of I-D.ietf-detnet-ip defines the ways in which aggregation is supported through the use of prefixes, wildcards, lists, and port ranges. Collectively, this results in the fairly straightforward procedures defined in this section." Comments before 04 - 27 resolved . dd51857ea97b162ed6bd640dac7366aec1eff400 dd51857ea97b162ed6bd640dac7366aec1eff400 draft-ietf-detnet-ip-over-mpls c3ff5e891961cfaee984c9ec6e177cf829b2383d2dfdb323b2f310ba826db76a ['53c36c3d90d5007bc0198de38c15e629f4522743d0b145e20ce42205a78fcb55', '8efd63665bdd242791ce0e0fc3df6ebb3cb8285401a53e921d623ee329e88120', '7c3b073d48c204f2678d701bbeecdcfa30cff64f679911a1bd9d570735ddc2a8', 'c3ff5e891961cfaee984c9ec6e177cf829b2383d2dfdb323b2f310ba826db76a'] B "per section 5.1 of i-d.ietf-detnet-mpls, the detnet mpls data plane uses a single s-label to support a single app flow. detnet ip flow identification procedures in section 4.4 of i-d.ietf-detnet-ip states that a single detnet flow is identified based on ip, and next level protocol, header information. section 4.4. (aggregation considerations) of i-d.ietf-detnet-ip defines the ways in which aggregation is supported through the use of prefixes, wildcards, lists, and port ranges. collectively, this results in the fairly straightforward procedures defined in this section." {110: 1, 63: 1, 30: 2, 56: 2, 36: 2} {346: 1, 395: 1, 356: 2, 75: 2, 333: 2} {356, 134, 75, 395, 333, 346} 91 "This draft does not have additional security considerations. Security considerations for DetNet are described in detail in I- D.ietf-detnet-security. General security considerations are described in RFC8655. MPLS and IP specific considerations are described in I-D.ietf-detnet-mpls and I-D.ietf-detnet-ip." Comments before 04 - 27 resolved . dd51857ea97b162ed6bd640dac7366aec1eff400 dd51857ea97b162ed6bd640dac7366aec1eff400 draft-ietf-detnet-ip-over-mpls c53f6e0d24b80106b9ec06e537d4dc146a88fd91cb85f46a1175d7b9b672d053 ['253f7f90a87ce74c8736f3c8a834ff5575c13145eb5523c0523ac58dba36c8c4', 'c53f6e0d24b80106b9ec06e537d4dc146a88fd91cb85f46a1175d7b9b672d053'] A "this draft does not have additional security considerations. security considerations for detnet are described in detail in i- d.ietf-detnet-security. general security considerations are described in rfc8655. mpls and ip specific considerations are described in i-d.ietf-detnet-mpls and i-d.ietf-detnet-ip." {110: 1, 67: 1, 6: 5, 79: 5, 90: 3, 51: 4, 130: 5, 62: 7, 85: 8, 68: 7, 35: 6, 114: 3, 97: 5, 31: 4, 13: 3, 38: 5, 26: 4, 124: 6, 98: 5, 54: 5, 127: 6, 8: 5, 96: 5, 64: 3, 30: 3, 61: 6, 55: 6, 27: 5, 15: 3, 52: 4, 129: 6, 115: 3, 84: 3, 76: 9, 87: 3, 131: 8, 102: 3, 113: 6, 99: 5, 36: 2, 24: 3, 53: 4, 72: 5} {49: 1, 180: 1, 1: 12, 4: 5, 9: 8, 10: 6, 15: 5, 24: 5, 25: 7, 26: 8, 27: 4, 39: 8, 43: 6, 58: 6, 59: 5, 64: 5, 69: 7, 81: 8, 82: 6, 86: 4, 96: 5, 97: 4, 100: 9, 108: 6, 109: 7, 110: 7, 111: 5, 114: 6, 115: 7, 116: 5, 118: 9, 119: 8, 120: 6, 121: 7, 122: 6, 123: 5, 124: 7, 128: 3, 129: 3, 130: 6, 132: 7, 136: 5, 145: 7, 147: 5, 151: 4, 152: 4, 154: 6, 156: 4, 161: 6, 162: 6, 165: 6, 168: 7, 169: 3, 172: 3, 184: 8, 187: 8, 188: 7, 191: 6, 194: 7, 202: 8, 203: 9, 206: 5, 207: 6, 215: 5, 217: 6, 218: 11, 220: 5, 221: 5, 222: 8, 224: 6, 227: 7, 229: 3, 234: 8, 235: 5, 241: 5, 242: 5, 243: 7, 244: 4, 245: 7, 248: 4, 250: 6, 258: 14, 262: 7, 263: 8, 264: 6, 267: 7, 270: 5, 272: 3, 273: 8, 287: 6, 289: 3, 291: 6, 299: 7, 300: 5, 304: 5, 309: 6, 314: 5, 315: 3, 320: 7, 323: 7, 327: 7, 328: 6, 329: 5, 330: 13, 334: 5, 335: 5, 341: 7, 342: 8, 347: 7, 348: 7, 350: 10, 351: 5, 352: 3, 353: 2, 354: 3, 358: 7, 365: 3, 366: 5, 369: 4, 371: 9, 372: 6, 376: 5, 384: 6, 385: 5, 386: 6, 387: 5, 392: 6, 393: 7, 396: 8, 397: 10, 398: 9, 402: 3} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 91 "Generals security considerations for DetNet are described in detail in I-D.ietf-detnet-security. DetNet MPLS and DetNet IP security considerations equally apply to this document and are described in I- D.ietf-detnet-mpls and I-D.ietf-detnet-ip." Comments before 04 - 27 resolved . dd51857ea97b162ed6bd640dac7366aec1eff400 dd51857ea97b162ed6bd640dac7366aec1eff400 draft-ietf-detnet-ip-over-mpls 253f7f90a87ce74c8736f3c8a834ff5575c13145eb5523c0523ac58dba36c8c4 ['253f7f90a87ce74c8736f3c8a834ff5575c13145eb5523c0523ac58dba36c8c4', 'c53f6e0d24b80106b9ec06e537d4dc146a88fd91cb85f46a1175d7b9b672d053'] B "generals security considerations for detnet are described in detail in i-d.ietf-detnet-security. detnet mpls and detnet ip security considerations equally apply to this document and are described in i- d.ietf-detnet-mpls and i-d.ietf-detnet-ip." {110: 1, 67: 1, 6: 5, 79: 5, 90: 3, 51: 4, 130: 5, 62: 7, 85: 8, 68: 7, 35: 6, 114: 3, 97: 5, 31: 4, 13: 3, 38: 5, 26: 4, 124: 6, 98: 5, 54: 5, 127: 6, 8: 5, 96: 5, 64: 3, 30: 3, 61: 6, 55: 6, 27: 5, 15: 3, 52: 4, 129: 6, 115: 3, 84: 3, 76: 9, 87: 3, 131: 8, 102: 3, 113: 6, 99: 5, 36: 2, 24: 3, 53: 4, 72: 5} {49: 1, 180: 1, 1: 12, 4: 5, 9: 8, 10: 6, 15: 5, 24: 5, 25: 7, 26: 8, 27: 4, 39: 8, 43: 6, 58: 6, 59: 5, 64: 5, 69: 7, 81: 8, 82: 6, 86: 4, 96: 5, 97: 4, 100: 9, 108: 6, 109: 7, 110: 7, 111: 5, 114: 6, 115: 7, 116: 5, 118: 9, 119: 8, 120: 6, 121: 7, 122: 6, 123: 5, 124: 7, 128: 3, 129: 3, 130: 6, 132: 7, 136: 5, 145: 7, 147: 5, 151: 4, 152: 4, 154: 6, 156: 4, 161: 6, 162: 6, 165: 6, 168: 7, 169: 3, 172: 3, 184: 8, 187: 8, 188: 7, 191: 6, 194: 7, 202: 8, 203: 9, 206: 5, 207: 6, 215: 5, 217: 6, 218: 11, 220: 5, 221: 5, 222: 8, 224: 6, 227: 7, 229: 3, 234: 8, 235: 5, 241: 5, 242: 5, 243: 7, 244: 4, 245: 7, 248: 4, 250: 6, 258: 14, 262: 7, 263: 8, 264: 6, 267: 7, 270: 5, 272: 3, 273: 8, 287: 6, 289: 3, 291: 6, 299: 7, 300: 5, 304: 5, 309: 6, 314: 5, 315: 3, 320: 7, 323: 7, 327: 7, 328: 6, 329: 5, 330: 13, 334: 5, 335: 5, 341: 7, 342: 8, 347: 7, 348: 7, 350: 10, 351: 5, 352: 3, 353: 2, 354: 3, 358: 7, 365: 3, 366: 5, 369: 4, 371: 9, 372: 6, 376: 5, 384: 6, 385: 5, 386: 6, 387: 5, 392: 6, 393: 7, 396: 8, 397: 10, 398: 9, 402: 3} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 91 "RFC7322 limits the number of authors listed on the front page of a draft to a maximum of 5. The editor wishes to thank and acknowledge the follow authors for contributing text to this draft." Comments before 04 - 27 resolved . dd51857ea97b162ed6bd640dac7366aec1eff400 dd51857ea97b162ed6bd640dac7366aec1eff400 draft-ietf-detnet-ip-over-mpls c4eb32d28b503e5f8e5975d1f351597a26a446deebe2e35f600c21fbad8e39da ['c4eb32d28b503e5f8e5975d1f351597a26a446deebe2e35f600c21fbad8e39da'] B "rfc7322 limits the number of authors listed on the front page of a draft to a maximum of 5. the editor wishes to thank and acknowledge the follow authors for contributing text to this draft." {} {} {} 90 "This document provides an overall framework for the DetNet data plane. It covers concepts and considerations that are generally common to any Deterministic Networking data plane specification." All comments received before 04 - 27 are resolved 1c9840576d54ede4a408e3460aaf92e9f8db0004 1c9840576d54ede4a408e3460aaf92e9f8db0004 draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework 647cc34881a74e186b4e0e5f3ea854a321e0dce68b2ed80157c09279b837a105 ['45c4b8e8e580d9e35e8f14e7f7079a78d035777e750790ed715ef0bc2cce448f', '647cc34881a74e186b4e0e5f3ea854a321e0dce68b2ed80157c09279b837a105'] A "this document provides an overall framework for the detnet data plane. it covers concepts and considerations that are generally common to any deterministic networking data plane specification." {55: 1, 6: 3, 8: 2, 67: 2} {61: 1, 113: 3, 60: 2, 375: 2} {106, 113, 375, 60, 61} 90 "This document provides an overall framework for the DetNet data plane. It covers concepts and considerations that are generally common to any Deterministic Networking data plane specification. It describes related controller plane considerations as well." All comments received before 04 - 27 are resolved 1c9840576d54ede4a408e3460aaf92e9f8db0004 1c9840576d54ede4a408e3460aaf92e9f8db0004 draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework 45c4b8e8e580d9e35e8f14e7f7079a78d035777e750790ed715ef0bc2cce448f ['45c4b8e8e580d9e35e8f14e7f7079a78d035777e750790ed715ef0bc2cce448f', '647cc34881a74e186b4e0e5f3ea854a321e0dce68b2ed80157c09279b837a105'] B "this document provides an overall framework for the detnet data plane. it covers concepts and considerations that are generally common to any deterministic networking data plane specification. it describes related controller plane considerations as well." {55: 1, 6: 3, 8: 2, 67: 2} {61: 1, 113: 3, 60: 2, 375: 2} {106, 113, 375, 60, 61} 90 "The DetNet Architecture models the DetNet related data plane functions decomposed into two sub-layers: a service sub-layer and a forwarding sub-layer. The service sub-layer is used to provide DetNet service protection and reordering. The forwarding sub-layer leverages Traffic Engineering mechanisms and provides congestion protection (low loss, assured latency, and limited out-of-order delivery). A particular forwarding sub-layer may have capabilities that are not available on other forwarding-sub layers. DetNet makes use of the existing forwarding sub-layers with their respective capabilities and does not require 1:1 equivalence between different forwarding sub-layer capabilities." All comments received before 04 - 27 are resolved 1c9840576d54ede4a408e3460aaf92e9f8db0004 1c9840576d54ede4a408e3460aaf92e9f8db0004 draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework 1d23c49cc89558646981bab7a83513b80fcc0d6dc2a60bff680d5c8114f9d82c ['1d23c49cc89558646981bab7a83513b80fcc0d6dc2a60bff680d5c8114f9d82c', '8c8824820b316629de62b8f55366905181592cf8798005a86e09f5eb822c0a9d'] A "the detnet architecture models the detnet related data plane functions decomposed into two sub-layers: a service sub-layer and a forwarding sub-layer. the service sub-layer is used to provide detnet service protection and reordering. the forwarding sub-layer leverages traffic engineering mechanisms and provides congestion protection (low loss, assured latency, and limited out-of-order delivery). a particular forwarding sub-layer may have capabilities that are not available on other forwarding-sub layers. detnet makes use of the existing forwarding sub-layers with their respective capabilities and does not require 1:1 equivalence between different forwarding sub-layer capabilities." {68: 1, 6: 5, 84: 3, 55: 2, 90: 4} {181: 1, 232: 5, 173: 5, 373: 3, 182: 2, 87: 4, 374: 4, 53: 4} {37, 232, 173, 373, 182, 87, 181, 374, 53} 90 "The DetNet Architecture models the DetNet related data plane functions as being decomposed into two sub-layers: a service sub- layer and a forwarding sub-layer. The service sub-layer is used to provide DetNet service protection and reordering. The forwarding sub-layer leverages Traffic Engineering mechanisms and provides congestion protection (low loss, assured latency, and limited out-of- order delivery). A particular forwarding sub-layer may have capabilities that are not available on other forwarding-sub layers. DetNet makes use of the existing forwarding sub-layers with their respective capabilities and does not require 1:1 equivalence between different forwarding sub-layer capabilities." All comments received before 04 - 27 are resolved 1c9840576d54ede4a408e3460aaf92e9f8db0004 1c9840576d54ede4a408e3460aaf92e9f8db0004 draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework 8c8824820b316629de62b8f55366905181592cf8798005a86e09f5eb822c0a9d ['1d23c49cc89558646981bab7a83513b80fcc0d6dc2a60bff680d5c8114f9d82c', '8c8824820b316629de62b8f55366905181592cf8798005a86e09f5eb822c0a9d'] B "the detnet architecture models the detnet related data plane functions as being decomposed into two sub-layers: a service sub- layer and a forwarding sub-layer. the service sub-layer is used to provide detnet service protection and reordering. the forwarding sub-layer leverages traffic engineering mechanisms and provides congestion protection (low loss, assured latency, and limited out-of- order delivery). a particular forwarding sub-layer may have capabilities that are not available on other forwarding-sub layers. detnet makes use of the existing forwarding sub-layers with their respective capabilities and does not require 1:1 equivalence between different forwarding sub-layer capabilities." {68: 1, 6: 5, 84: 3, 55: 2, 90: 4} {181: 1, 232: 5, 173: 5, 373: 3, 182: 2, 87: 4, 374: 4, 53: 4} {37, 232, 173, 373, 182, 87, 181, 374, 53} 90 "As defined in RFC8655, DetNet flows may be carried over network technologies that can provide the DetNet required service characteristics. For example, DetNet MPLS flows can be carried over IEEE 802.1 Time Sensitive Network (TSN) IEEE802.1TSNTG sub-networks. However, IEEE 802.1 TSN support is not required in DetNet. TSN frame preemption is an example of a forwarding layer capability that is typically not replicated in other forwarding technologies. Most of DetNet benefits can be gained by running over a data link layer that has not been specifically enhanced to support all TSN capabilities but for certain networks and traffic mixes delay and jitter performance may vary due to the forwarding sub-layer intrinsic properties." All comments received before 04 - 27 are resolved 1c9840576d54ede4a408e3460aaf92e9f8db0004 1c9840576d54ede4a408e3460aaf92e9f8db0004 draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework 260e3230868be0a02cb73a7fad223d4fe598500df2bfb5b6eb1d47396fcac262 ['260e3230868be0a02cb73a7fad223d4fe598500df2bfb5b6eb1d47396fcac262', '8e40dc1d41ab9b0f6c8c990f76690ee5860703751ce104dace78f5b987057201'] A "as defined in rfc8655, detnet flows may be carried over network technologies that can provide the detnet required service characteristics. for example, detnet mpls flows can be carried over ieee 802.1 time sensitive network (tsn) ieee802.1tsntg sub-networks. however, ieee 802.1 tsn support is not required in detnet. tsn frame preemption is an example of a forwarding layer capability that is typically not replicated in other forwarding technologies. most of detnet benefits can be gained by running over a data link layer that has not been specifically enhanced to support all tsn capabilities but for certain networks and traffic mixes delay and jitter performance may vary due to the forwarding sub-layer intrinsic properties." {84: 1, 90: 4, 6: 3, 68: 2, 55: 2} {373: 1, 37: 4, 232: 3, 173: 3, 182: 2, 87: 2, 181: 3, 374: 2} {37, 232, 173, 373, 182, 87, 181, 374, 53} 90 "As defined in RFC8655, DetNet flows may be carried over network technologies that can provide the DetNet required service characteristics. For example, DetNet MPLS flows can be carried over IEEE 802.1 Time Sensitive Network (TSN) IEEE802.1TSNTG sub-networks. However, IEEE 802.1 TSN support is not required in DetNet. TSN frame preemption is an example of a forwarding layer capability that is typically not replicated in other forwarding technologies. Most of DetNet benefits can be gained by running over a data link layer that has not been specifically enhanced to support all TSN capabilities but for such networks and traffic mixes delay and jitter performance may vary due to the forwarding sub-layer intrinsic properties." All comments received before 04 - 27 are resolved 1c9840576d54ede4a408e3460aaf92e9f8db0004 1c9840576d54ede4a408e3460aaf92e9f8db0004 draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework 8e40dc1d41ab9b0f6c8c990f76690ee5860703751ce104dace78f5b987057201 ['260e3230868be0a02cb73a7fad223d4fe598500df2bfb5b6eb1d47396fcac262', '8e40dc1d41ab9b0f6c8c990f76690ee5860703751ce104dace78f5b987057201'] B "as defined in rfc8655, detnet flows may be carried over network technologies that can provide the detnet required service characteristics. for example, detnet mpls flows can be carried over ieee 802.1 time sensitive network (tsn) ieee802.1tsntg sub-networks. however, ieee 802.1 tsn support is not required in detnet. tsn frame preemption is an example of a forwarding layer capability that is typically not replicated in other forwarding technologies. most of detnet benefits can be gained by running over a data link layer that has not been specifically enhanced to support all tsn capabilities but for such networks and traffic mixes delay and jitter performance may vary due to the forwarding sub-layer intrinsic properties." {84: 1, 90: 4, 6: 3, 68: 2, 55: 2} {373: 1, 37: 4, 232: 3, 173: 3, 182: 2, 87: 2, 181: 3, 374: 2} {37, 232, 173, 373, 182, 87, 181, 374, 53} 90 "The service sub-layer provides additional support beyond the connectivity function of the forwarding sub-layer. An example of this is Packet Replication, Elimination, and Ordering functions see PREOF. The ordering function (POF) uses sequence numbers added to packets enabling a range of packet order protection from simple ordering and dropping out-of-order packets to more complex reordering of a fixed number of out-of-order, minimally delayed packets. Reordering requires buffer resources and has impact on the delay and jitter of packets in the DetNet flow." All comments received before 04 - 27 are resolved 1c9840576d54ede4a408e3460aaf92e9f8db0004 1c9840576d54ede4a408e3460aaf92e9f8db0004 draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework 1537ce4979b31a2b49f3adc93e79afe072c85e531021772c93e6c056931c0f07 ['1537ce4979b31a2b49f3adc93e79afe072c85e531021772c93e6c056931c0f07', '3b9465cb501977987d076a5268f6964c828a94cc4a87f28e0962df7b909a3799', '4acccf70575db3f9d8ae9bdac1c0a7226e543af6fb467c02d8f9a6077076470d', 'a75bdb41dce0c8f5cb7afff0764c0e17b16ae197e9f669b76b0d15890be52784'] A "the service sub-layer provides additional support beyond the connectivity function of the forwarding sub-layer. an example of this is packet replication, elimination, and ordering functions see preof. the ordering function (pof) uses sequence numbers added to packets enabling a range of packet order protection from simple ordering and dropping out-of-order packets to more complex reordering of a fixed number of out-of-order, minimally delayed packets. reordering requires buffer resources and has impact on the delay and jitter of packets in the detnet flow." {84: 1, 55: 1, 6: 4, 8: 3, 68: 2, 31: 2, 67: 5, 90: 3} {21: 1, 247: 1, 256: 4, 2: 5, 5: 2, 8: 5, 74: 3, 271: 2, 209: 5, 83: 3, 277: 2, 276: 3, 88: 5, 233: 6, 236: 2, 302: 6, 47: 6, 303: 3, 112: 5, 126: 6, 127: 5} {256, 2, 5, 8, 271, 20, 21, 277, 276, 302, 47, 303, 74, 209, 83, 88, 233, 236, 112, 247, 126, 127} 90 "The method of instantiating each of the layers is specific to the particular DetNet data plane method, and more than one approach may be applicable to a given bearer network type." All comments received before 04 - 27 are resolved 1c9840576d54ede4a408e3460aaf92e9f8db0004 1c9840576d54ede4a408e3460aaf92e9f8db0004 draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework 3b9465cb501977987d076a5268f6964c828a94cc4a87f28e0962df7b909a3799 ['1537ce4979b31a2b49f3adc93e79afe072c85e531021772c93e6c056931c0f07', '3b9465cb501977987d076a5268f6964c828a94cc4a87f28e0962df7b909a3799', '4acccf70575db3f9d8ae9bdac1c0a7226e543af6fb467c02d8f9a6077076470d', 'a75bdb41dce0c8f5cb7afff0764c0e17b16ae197e9f669b76b0d15890be52784'] A "the method of instantiating each of the layers is specific to the particular detnet data plane method, and more than one approach may be applicable to a given bearer network type." {84: 1, 55: 1, 6: 4, 8: 3, 68: 2, 31: 2, 67: 5, 90: 3} {21: 1, 247: 1, 256: 4, 2: 5, 5: 2, 8: 5, 74: 3, 271: 2, 209: 5, 83: 3, 277: 2, 276: 3, 88: 5, 233: 6, 236: 2, 302: 6, 47: 6, 303: 3, 112: 5, 126: 6, 127: 5} {256, 2, 5, 8, 271, 20, 21, 277, 276, 302, 47, 303, 74, 209, 83, 88, 233, 236, 112, 247, 126, 127} 90 "The service sub-layer provides additional support beyond the connectivity function of the forwarding sub-layer. See PREOF as an example for Packet Replication, Elimination, and Ordering functions. The ordering function (POF) uses sequence numbers added to packets enabling a range of packet order protection from simple ordering and dropping out-of-order packets to more complex reordering of a fixed number of out-of-order, minimally delayed packets. Reordering requires buffer resources and has impact on the delay and jitter of packets in the DetNet flow." All comments received before 04 - 27 are resolved 1c9840576d54ede4a408e3460aaf92e9f8db0004 1c9840576d54ede4a408e3460aaf92e9f8db0004 draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework a75bdb41dce0c8f5cb7afff0764c0e17b16ae197e9f669b76b0d15890be52784 ['1537ce4979b31a2b49f3adc93e79afe072c85e531021772c93e6c056931c0f07', '3b9465cb501977987d076a5268f6964c828a94cc4a87f28e0962df7b909a3799', '4acccf70575db3f9d8ae9bdac1c0a7226e543af6fb467c02d8f9a6077076470d', 'a75bdb41dce0c8f5cb7afff0764c0e17b16ae197e9f669b76b0d15890be52784'] B "the service sub-layer provides additional support beyond the connectivity function of the forwarding sub-layer. see preof as an example for packet replication, elimination, and ordering functions. the ordering function (pof) uses sequence numbers added to packets enabling a range of packet order protection from simple ordering and dropping out-of-order packets to more complex reordering of a fixed number of out-of-order, minimally delayed packets. reordering requires buffer resources and has impact on the delay and jitter of packets in the detnet flow." {84: 1, 55: 1, 6: 4, 8: 3, 68: 2, 31: 2, 67: 5, 90: 3} {21: 1, 247: 1, 256: 4, 2: 5, 5: 2, 8: 5, 74: 3, 271: 2, 209: 5, 83: 3, 277: 2, 276: 3, 88: 5, 233: 6, 236: 2, 302: 6, 47: 6, 303: 3, 112: 5, 126: 6, 127: 5} {256, 2, 5, 8, 271, 20, 21, 277, 276, 302, 47, 303, 74, 209, 83, 88, 233, 236, 112, 247, 126, 127} 90 "The method of instantiating each of the layers is specific to the particular DetNet data plane method, and more than one approach may be applicable to a given network type." All comments received before 04 - 27 are resolved 1c9840576d54ede4a408e3460aaf92e9f8db0004 1c9840576d54ede4a408e3460aaf92e9f8db0004 draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework 4acccf70575db3f9d8ae9bdac1c0a7226e543af6fb467c02d8f9a6077076470d ['1537ce4979b31a2b49f3adc93e79afe072c85e531021772c93e6c056931c0f07', '3b9465cb501977987d076a5268f6964c828a94cc4a87f28e0962df7b909a3799', '4acccf70575db3f9d8ae9bdac1c0a7226e543af6fb467c02d8f9a6077076470d', 'a75bdb41dce0c8f5cb7afff0764c0e17b16ae197e9f669b76b0d15890be52784'] B "the method of instantiating each of the layers is specific to the particular detnet data plane method, and more than one approach may be applicable to a given network type." {84: 1, 55: 1, 6: 4, 8: 3, 68: 2, 31: 2, 67: 5, 90: 3} {21: 1, 247: 1, 256: 4, 2: 5, 5: 2, 8: 5, 74: 3, 271: 2, 209: 5, 83: 3, 277: 2, 276: 3, 88: 5, 233: 6, 236: 2, 302: 6, 47: 6, 303: 3, 112: 5, 126: 6, 127: 5} {256, 2, 5, 8, 271, 20, 21, 277, 276, 302, 47, 303, 74, 209, 83, 88, 233, 236, 112, 247, 126, 127} 90 "The DetNet data plane is provided by the DetNet service and forwarding sub layers. The DetNet service sub-layer generally provides its functions for the DetNet application flows by using or applying existing standardized headers and/or encapsulations. The Detnet forwarding sub-layer may provide capabilities leveraging that same header or encapsulation technology (e.g., DN IP or DN MPLS) or it may be achieved by other technologies (e.g., dn_svc_encaps). DetNet is currently defined for operation over packet-switched (IP) networks or label-switched (MPLS) networks." All comments received before 04 - 27 are resolved 1c9840576d54ede4a408e3460aaf92e9f8db0004 1c9840576d54ede4a408e3460aaf92e9f8db0004 draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework 13a20554ab07e9366fd1898bd73bc6cbe8b0be6fdfa7d694200ab108e9324af7 ['38a17449f002b8306d0eddad50972949300781b2bbf04f33ed680d8d593b91bc', '13a20554ab07e9366fd1898bd73bc6cbe8b0be6fdfa7d694200ab108e9324af7'] A "the detnet data plane is provided by the detnet service and forwarding sub layers. the detnet service sub-layer generally provides its functions for the detnet application flows by using or applying existing standardized headers and/or encapsulations. the detnet forwarding sub-layer may provide capabilities leveraging that same header or encapsulation technology (e.g., dn ip or dn mpls) or it may be achieved by other technologies (e.g., dn_svc_encaps). detnet is currently defined for operation over packet-switched (ip) networks or label-switched (mpls) networks." {84: 1, 6: 5, 8: 4, 68: 2, 31: 3, 67: 6, 90: 2, 55: 2} {277: 1, 256: 5, 2: 6, 5: 3, 8: 6, 74: 4, 271: 3, 209: 6, 20: 3, 21: 4, 276: 2, 88: 6, 233: 7, 236: 2, 302: 7, 47: 7, 303: 4, 112: 6, 247: 2, 126: 7, 127: 6} {256, 2, 5, 8, 271, 20, 21, 277, 276, 302, 47, 303, 74, 209, 83, 88, 233, 236, 112, 247, 126, 127} 90 "The DetNet data plane is provided by the DetNet service and forwarding sub layers. The DetNet service sub-layer generally provides its functions for the DetNet application flows by using or applying existing standardized headers and/or encapsulations. The Detnet forwarding sub-layer may provide capabilities leveraging that same header or encapsulation technology (e.g., DN IP or DN MPLS) or it may be achieved by other technologies as shown in dn_svc_encaps. DetNet is currently defined for operation over packet-switched (IP) networks or label-switched (MPLS) networks." All comments received before 04 - 27 are resolved 1c9840576d54ede4a408e3460aaf92e9f8db0004 1c9840576d54ede4a408e3460aaf92e9f8db0004 draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework 38a17449f002b8306d0eddad50972949300781b2bbf04f33ed680d8d593b91bc ['38a17449f002b8306d0eddad50972949300781b2bbf04f33ed680d8d593b91bc', '13a20554ab07e9366fd1898bd73bc6cbe8b0be6fdfa7d694200ab108e9324af7'] B "the detnet data plane is provided by the detnet service and forwarding sub layers. the detnet service sub-layer generally provides its functions for the detnet application flows by using or applying existing standardized headers and/or encapsulations. the detnet forwarding sub-layer may provide capabilities leveraging that same header or encapsulation technology (e.g., dn ip or dn mpls) or it may be achieved by other technologies as shown in dn_svc_encaps. detnet is currently defined for operation over packet-switched (ip) networks or label-switched (mpls) networks." {84: 1, 6: 5, 8: 4, 68: 2, 31: 3, 67: 6, 90: 2, 55: 2} {277: 1, 256: 5, 2: 6, 5: 3, 8: 6, 74: 4, 271: 3, 209: 6, 20: 3, 21: 4, 276: 2, 88: 6, 233: 7, 236: 2, 302: 7, 47: 7, 303: 4, 112: 6, 247: 2, 126: 7, 127: 6} {256, 2, 5, 8, 271, 20, 21, 277, 276, 302, 47, 303, 74, 209, 83, 88, 233, 236, 112, 247, 126, 127} 90 "DetNet encodes specific flow attributes (flow identity and sequence number) in packets. For example, in DetNet IP, zero encapsulation is used and no sequence number is available, and in DetNet MPLS, DetNet- specific information may be added explicitly to the packets in the format of S-label and d-CW I-D.ietf-detnet-mpls ." All comments received before 04 - 27 are resolved 1c9840576d54ede4a408e3460aaf92e9f8db0004 1c9840576d54ede4a408e3460aaf92e9f8db0004 draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework b33d183bf45b3a8104e696210b6301d7bef1b0d65cb49e4d40a3c12272b7cddf ['b33d183bf45b3a8104e696210b6301d7bef1b0d65cb49e4d40a3c12272b7cddf', '8a7c7d9d204e82e04eb849aefb3c81f6e8440941a551feb8efb42cd77ecc39bc'] A "detnet encodes specific flow attributes (flow identity and sequence number) in packets. for example, in detnet ip, zero encapsulation is used and no sequence number is available, and in detnet mpls, detnet- specific information may be added explicitly to the packets in the format of s-label and d-cw i-d.ietf-detnet-mpls ." {84: 1, 6: 5, 8: 4, 68: 2, 31: 3, 67: 6, 90: 2, 55: 2} {277: 1, 256: 5, 2: 6, 5: 3, 8: 6, 74: 4, 271: 3, 209: 6, 83: 2, 20: 3, 21: 4, 88: 6, 233: 7, 236: 2, 302: 7, 47: 7, 303: 4, 112: 6, 247: 2, 126: 7, 127: 6} {256, 2, 5, 8, 271, 20, 21, 277, 276, 302, 47, 303, 74, 209, 83, 88, 233, 236, 112, 247, 126, 127} 90 "DetNet encodes specific flow attributes (flow identity and sequence number) in packets. For example, in DetNet IP, zero encapsulation is used and no sequence number is available, and in DetNet MPLS, DetNet- specific information may be added explicitly to the packets in the form of S-label and d-CW I-D.ietf-detnet-mpls ." All comments received before 04 - 27 are resolved 1c9840576d54ede4a408e3460aaf92e9f8db0004 1c9840576d54ede4a408e3460aaf92e9f8db0004 draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework 8a7c7d9d204e82e04eb849aefb3c81f6e8440941a551feb8efb42cd77ecc39bc ['b33d183bf45b3a8104e696210b6301d7bef1b0d65cb49e4d40a3c12272b7cddf', '8a7c7d9d204e82e04eb849aefb3c81f6e8440941a551feb8efb42cd77ecc39bc'] B "detnet encodes specific flow attributes (flow identity and sequence number) in packets. for example, in detnet ip, zero encapsulation is used and no sequence number is available, and in detnet mpls, detnet- specific information may be added explicitly to the packets in the form of s-label and d-cw i-d.ietf-detnet-mpls ." {84: 1, 6: 5, 8: 4, 68: 2, 31: 3, 67: 6, 90: 2, 55: 2} {277: 1, 256: 5, 2: 6, 5: 3, 8: 6, 74: 4, 271: 3, 209: 6, 83: 2, 20: 3, 21: 4, 88: 6, 233: 7, 236: 2, 302: 7, 47: 7, 303: 4, 112: 6, 247: 2, 126: 7, 127: 6} {256, 2, 5, 8, 271, 20, 21, 277, 276, 302, 47, 303, 74, 209, 83, 88, 233, 236, 112, 247, 126, 127} 90 "The DetNet data plane framework supports a Flow-ID (for identification of the flow or aggregate flow) and/or a Sequence Number (for PREOF) for each DetNet flow. The DetNet Service sub- layer requires both; the DetNet forwarding sub-layer requires only Flow-ID. Metadata can also be used for OAM indications and instrumentation of DetNet data plane operation." All comments received before 04 - 27 are resolved 1c9840576d54ede4a408e3460aaf92e9f8db0004 1c9840576d54ede4a408e3460aaf92e9f8db0004 draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework 4fd2716d226b744f9c0a0c6d5b149320df824936e2b280f1c3c9c4b27ff71602 ['4fd2716d226b744f9c0a0c6d5b149320df824936e2b280f1c3c9c4b27ff71602', '2b13cab2b8e2f902619f7dbf389351056a70744e5f0dadaac41dbffa506571a4'] A "the detnet data plane framework supports a flow-id (for identification of the flow or aggregate flow) and/or a sequence number (for preof) for each detnet flow. the detnet service sub- layer requires both; the detnet forwarding sub-layer requires only flow-id. metadata can also be used for oam indications and instrumentation of detnet data plane operation." {55: 1, 6: 2, 8: 3, 68: 6, 31: 3, 67: 3, 90: 6, 84: 2} {127: 1, 256: 2, 2: 3, 5: 6, 8: 3, 74: 3, 271: 4, 209: 3, 83: 7, 20: 6, 21: 7, 277: 6, 276: 7, 88: 3, 233: 4, 236: 6, 302: 4, 47: 2, 303: 7, 112: 3, 247: 5} {256, 2, 5, 8, 271, 20, 21, 277, 276, 302, 47, 303, 74, 209, 83, 88, 233, 236, 112, 247, 126, 127} 90 "The DetNet data plane framework supports a Flow-ID (for identification of the flow or aggregate flow) and/or a Sequence Number (for PREOF) for each DetNet flow. The Flow-ID is used by both the service and forwarding sub-layers, but the sequence number is only used by the service layer. Metadata can also be used for OAM indications and instrumentation of DetNet data plane operation." All comments received before 04 - 27 are resolved 1c9840576d54ede4a408e3460aaf92e9f8db0004 1c9840576d54ede4a408e3460aaf92e9f8db0004 draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework 2b13cab2b8e2f902619f7dbf389351056a70744e5f0dadaac41dbffa506571a4 ['4fd2716d226b744f9c0a0c6d5b149320df824936e2b280f1c3c9c4b27ff71602', '2b13cab2b8e2f902619f7dbf389351056a70744e5f0dadaac41dbffa506571a4'] B "the detnet data plane framework supports a flow-id (for identification of the flow or aggregate flow) and/or a sequence number (for preof) for each detnet flow. the flow-id is used by both the service and forwarding sub-layers, but the sequence number is only used by the service layer. metadata can also be used for oam indications and instrumentation of detnet data plane operation." {55: 1, 6: 2, 8: 3, 68: 6, 31: 3, 67: 3, 90: 6, 84: 2} {127: 1, 256: 2, 2: 3, 5: 6, 8: 3, 74: 3, 271: 4, 209: 3, 83: 7, 20: 6, 21: 7, 277: 6, 276: 7, 88: 3, 233: 4, 236: 6, 302: 4, 47: 2, 303: 7, 112: 3, 247: 5} {256, 2, 5, 8, 271, 20, 21, 277, 276, 302, 47, 303, 74, 209, 83, 88, 233, 236, 112, 247, 126, 127} 90 "Some MPLS examples of implicit metadata include the sequence number for use by the PREOF function, or even all the essential information being included into the DetNet over MPLS label stack (the DetNet Control Word and the DetNet Service label)." All comments received before 04 - 27 are resolved 1c9840576d54ede4a408e3460aaf92e9f8db0004 1c9840576d54ede4a408e3460aaf92e9f8db0004 draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework 606988239d28536e84df7d549250c1946f70f108a94acb06ae4cbf536b9cd230 ['606988239d28536e84df7d549250c1946f70f108a94acb06ae4cbf536b9cd230', 'b9a36f2d1e1f8289b1d8d371b84b33bf07f65685093a7e9f138ecab747383440'] A "some mpls examples of implicit metadata include the sequence number for use by the preof function, or even all the essential information being included into the detnet over mpls label stack (the detnet control word and the detnet service label)." {} {} {} 90 "An MPLS example of explicit metadata is the sequence number used by the PREOF function, or even the case where all the essential information being included into the DetNet over MPLS label stack (the DetNet Control Word and the DetNet Service label)." All comments received before 04 - 27 are resolved 1c9840576d54ede4a408e3460aaf92e9f8db0004 1c9840576d54ede4a408e3460aaf92e9f8db0004 draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework b9a36f2d1e1f8289b1d8d371b84b33bf07f65685093a7e9f138ecab747383440 ['606988239d28536e84df7d549250c1946f70f108a94acb06ae4cbf536b9cd230', 'b9a36f2d1e1f8289b1d8d371b84b33bf07f65685093a7e9f138ecab747383440'] B "an mpls example of explicit metadata is the sequence number used by the preof function, or even the case where all the essential information being included into the detnet over mpls label stack (the detnet control word and the detnet service label)." {} {} {} 90 "Use of packet-by-packet distribution of the same DetNet flow over multiple paths is not recommended except for the cases listed above where PREOF is utilized to improve protection of traffic and maintain order. Packet by packet load sharing, e.g., via ECMP or UCMP, impacts ordering and possibly jitter." All comments received before 04 - 27 are resolved 1c9840576d54ede4a408e3460aaf92e9f8db0004 1c9840576d54ede4a408e3460aaf92e9f8db0004 draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework 4c3da6e0fffc80e62e5f664bd81a2936b6593757d8fb0d02cabd8102872696d4 ['4c3da6e0fffc80e62e5f664bd81a2936b6593757d8fb0d02cabd8102872696d4', '54b740d381b6deb0d9b3bf0cfab6c6e8c5d9c8fa27e8487d05826ae714d14539'] A "use of packet-by-packet distribution of the same detnet flow over multiple paths is not recommended except for the cases listed above where preof is utilized to improve protection of traffic and maintain order. packet by packet load sharing, e.g., via ecmp or ucmp, impacts ordering and possibly jitter." {55: 1, 6: 2, 79: 4, 90: 4, 51: 4, 130: 4, 62: 3, 85: 3, 68: 2, 35: 5, 110: 5, 91: 7, 114: 5, 97: 5, 31: 3, 13: 4, 67: 4, 38: 6, 26: 3, 124: 4, 98: 4, 54: 4, 127: 5, 8: 2, 96: 5, 64: 4, 30: 6, 61: 7, 27: 3, 15: 5, 52: 3, 129: 5, 115: 5, 84: 2, 76: 5, 87: 5, 131: 7, 102: 2, 113: 7, 99: 4, 36: 5, 24: 4, 53: 3, 72: 6} {162: 1, 1: 7, 4: 4, 9: 4, 10: 5, 15: 5, 24: 4, 25: 3, 26: 3, 27: 5, 39: 3, 43: 5, 49: 8, 50: 7, 58: 7, 59: 4, 64: 5, 69: 3, 81: 4, 82: 4, 86: 5, 96: 6, 97: 5, 100: 7, 108: 5, 109: 6, 110: 6, 111: 4, 114: 5, 115: 6, 116: 5, 118: 4, 119: 3, 120: 5, 122: 6, 123: 5, 124: 2, 128: 6, 129: 6, 130: 7, 132: 3, 136: 4, 145: 3, 147: 6, 151: 6, 152: 6, 154: 5, 156: 4, 161: 2, 165: 5, 168: 6, 169: 5, 172: 5, 180: 6, 184: 4, 187: 7, 188: 6, 191: 5, 194: 3, 202: 4, 203: 5, 206: 4, 207: 5, 215: 3, 217: 5, 218: 6, 220: 2, 221: 2, 222: 3, 224: 5, 227: 5, 229: 5, 234: 7, 235: 4, 241: 4, 242: 4, 243: 3, 244: 6, 245: 3, 248: 6, 250: 6, 258: 9, 262: 6, 263: 7, 264: 3, 267: 2, 270: 5, 272: 5, 273: 4, 287: 5, 289: 5, 291: 7, 299: 5, 300: 5, 304: 5, 309: 2, 314: 4, 315: 5, 320: 2, 323: 3, 327: 6, 328: 4, 329: 4, 330: 8, 334: 4, 335: 5, 341: 5, 342: 6, 347: 5, 348: 5, 350: 6, 351: 7, 352: 5, 353: 5, 354: 4, 358: 2, 365: 5, 366: 4, 369: 3, 371: 7, 372: 7, 376: 4, 384: 7, 385: 6, 386: 5, 387: 5, 392: 4, 393: 5, 396: 6, 397: 5, 398: 4, 402: 5} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 90 "Use of packet-by-packet load sharing of the same DetNet flow over multiple paths is not recommended except for the cases listed above where PREOF is utilized to improve protection of traffic and maintain order. Packet-by-packet load sharing, e.g., via ECMP or UCMP, impacts ordering and possibly jitter." All comments received before 04 - 27 are resolved 1c9840576d54ede4a408e3460aaf92e9f8db0004 1c9840576d54ede4a408e3460aaf92e9f8db0004 draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework 54b740d381b6deb0d9b3bf0cfab6c6e8c5d9c8fa27e8487d05826ae714d14539 ['4c3da6e0fffc80e62e5f664bd81a2936b6593757d8fb0d02cabd8102872696d4', '54b740d381b6deb0d9b3bf0cfab6c6e8c5d9c8fa27e8487d05826ae714d14539'] B "use of packet-by-packet load sharing of the same detnet flow over multiple paths is not recommended except for the cases listed above where preof is utilized to improve protection of traffic and maintain order. packet-by-packet load sharing, e.g., via ecmp or ucmp, impacts ordering and possibly jitter." {55: 1, 6: 2, 79: 4, 90: 4, 51: 4, 130: 4, 62: 3, 85: 3, 68: 2, 35: 5, 110: 5, 91: 7, 114: 5, 97: 5, 31: 3, 13: 4, 67: 4, 38: 6, 26: 3, 124: 4, 98: 4, 54: 4, 127: 5, 8: 2, 96: 5, 64: 4, 30: 6, 61: 7, 27: 3, 15: 5, 52: 3, 129: 5, 115: 5, 84: 2, 76: 5, 87: 5, 131: 7, 102: 2, 113: 7, 99: 4, 36: 5, 24: 4, 53: 3, 72: 6} {162: 1, 1: 7, 4: 4, 9: 4, 10: 5, 15: 5, 24: 4, 25: 3, 26: 3, 27: 5, 39: 3, 43: 5, 49: 8, 50: 7, 58: 7, 59: 4, 64: 5, 69: 3, 81: 4, 82: 4, 86: 5, 96: 6, 97: 5, 100: 7, 108: 5, 109: 6, 110: 6, 111: 4, 114: 5, 115: 6, 116: 5, 118: 4, 119: 3, 120: 5, 122: 6, 123: 5, 124: 2, 128: 6, 129: 6, 130: 7, 132: 3, 136: 4, 145: 3, 147: 6, 151: 6, 152: 6, 154: 5, 156: 4, 161: 2, 165: 5, 168: 6, 169: 5, 172: 5, 180: 6, 184: 4, 187: 7, 188: 6, 191: 5, 194: 3, 202: 4, 203: 5, 206: 4, 207: 5, 215: 3, 217: 5, 218: 6, 220: 2, 221: 2, 222: 3, 224: 5, 227: 5, 229: 5, 234: 7, 235: 4, 241: 4, 242: 4, 243: 3, 244: 6, 245: 3, 248: 6, 250: 6, 258: 9, 262: 6, 263: 7, 264: 3, 267: 2, 270: 5, 272: 5, 273: 4, 287: 5, 289: 5, 291: 7, 299: 5, 300: 5, 304: 5, 309: 2, 314: 4, 315: 5, 320: 2, 323: 3, 327: 6, 328: 4, 329: 4, 330: 8, 334: 4, 335: 5, 341: 5, 342: 6, 347: 5, 348: 5, 350: 6, 351: 7, 352: 5, 353: 5, 354: 4, 358: 2, 365: 5, 366: 4, 369: 3, 371: 7, 372: 7, 376: 4, 384: 7, 385: 6, 386: 5, 387: 5, 392: 4, 393: 5, 396: 6, 397: 5, 398: 4, 402: 5} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 90 "IP aggregation has both data plane and controller plane aspects. For the data plane, flows may be aggregated for treatment based on shared characteristics such as 6-tuple. Alternatively, an IP encapsulation may be used to tunnel an aggregate number of DetNet Flows between relay nodes." All comments received before 04 - 27 are resolved 1c9840576d54ede4a408e3460aaf92e9f8db0004 1c9840576d54ede4a408e3460aaf92e9f8db0004 draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework 0e41ec81b9f82db98d1cd35aa3b0765936fdeef25ac6fac5cccae550e3e2fb70 ['0e41ec81b9f82db98d1cd35aa3b0765936fdeef25ac6fac5cccae550e3e2fb70', '3a2937869b814cfc45b9307a17ee961209578178c1319d3dcdb93765fe1af826'] A "ip aggregation has both data plane and controller plane aspects. for the data plane, flows may be aggregated for treatment based on shared characteristics such as 6-tuple. alternatively, an ip encapsulation may be used to tunnel an aggregate number of detnet flows between relay nodes." {55: 1, 6: 2, 79: 5, 51: 6, 130: 5, 62: 5, 85: 5, 68: 4, 35: 6, 110: 6, 91: 8, 114: 6, 97: 6, 31: 2, 13: 6, 67: 4, 38: 7, 26: 5, 124: 4, 98: 5, 54: 5, 127: 6, 8: 2, 90: 4, 96: 6, 64: 5, 30: 7, 61: 8, 27: 3, 15: 6, 52: 3, 129: 6, 115: 6, 84: 3, 76: 5, 87: 6, 131: 8, 102: 4, 113: 8, 99: 5, 36: 6, 24: 5, 53: 4, 72: 7} {145: 1, 1: 9, 4: 5, 10: 6, 15: 6, 24: 5, 25: 5, 26: 5, 27: 6, 39: 5, 43: 6, 49: 9, 50: 8, 58: 8, 59: 5, 64: 6, 69: 3, 81: 6, 82: 6, 86: 6, 96: 7, 97: 6, 100: 9, 108: 6, 109: 7, 110: 7, 111: 5, 114: 6, 115: 7, 116: 6, 118: 6, 119: 5, 120: 6, 121: 4, 122: 7, 123: 6, 124: 4, 128: 7, 129: 7, 130: 8, 132: 2, 136: 5, 147: 7, 151: 7, 152: 7, 154: 6, 156: 5, 161: 2, 162: 3, 165: 6, 168: 7, 169: 6, 172: 6, 180: 7, 184: 2, 187: 8, 188: 7, 191: 6, 194: 3, 202: 4, 203: 5, 206: 5, 207: 6, 215: 3, 217: 6, 218: 8, 220: 4, 221: 4, 222: 5, 224: 6, 227: 7, 229: 6, 234: 8, 235: 5, 241: 5, 242: 5, 243: 3, 244: 7, 245: 3, 248: 7, 250: 7, 258: 11, 262: 7, 263: 8, 264: 3, 267: 4, 270: 6, 272: 6, 273: 4, 287: 6, 289: 6, 291: 8, 299: 7, 300: 6, 304: 6, 309: 4, 314: 5, 315: 6, 320: 4, 323: 3, 327: 7, 328: 4, 329: 5, 330: 10, 334: 5, 335: 6, 341: 7, 342: 8, 347: 7, 348: 7, 350: 6, 351: 8, 352: 6, 353: 6, 354: 5, 358: 4, 365: 6, 366: 5, 369: 4, 371: 9, 372: 8, 376: 5, 384: 8, 385: 7, 386: 6, 387: 6, 392: 4, 393: 5, 396: 8, 397: 7, 398: 6, 402: 6} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 90 "IP aggregation has both data plane and controller plane aspects. For the data plane, flows may be aggregated for treatment based on shared characteristics such as 6-tuple I-D.ietf-detnet-ip. Alternatively, an IP encapsulation may be used to tunnel an aggregate number of DetNet Flows between relay nodes." All comments received before 04 - 27 are resolved 1c9840576d54ede4a408e3460aaf92e9f8db0004 1c9840576d54ede4a408e3460aaf92e9f8db0004 draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework 3a2937869b814cfc45b9307a17ee961209578178c1319d3dcdb93765fe1af826 ['0e41ec81b9f82db98d1cd35aa3b0765936fdeef25ac6fac5cccae550e3e2fb70', '3a2937869b814cfc45b9307a17ee961209578178c1319d3dcdb93765fe1af826'] B "ip aggregation has both data plane and controller plane aspects. for the data plane, flows may be aggregated for treatment based on shared characteristics such as 6-tuple i-d.ietf-detnet-ip. alternatively, an ip encapsulation may be used to tunnel an aggregate number of detnet flows between relay nodes." {55: 1, 6: 2, 79: 5, 51: 6, 130: 5, 62: 5, 85: 5, 68: 4, 35: 6, 110: 6, 91: 8, 114: 6, 97: 6, 31: 2, 13: 6, 67: 4, 38: 7, 26: 5, 124: 4, 98: 5, 54: 5, 127: 6, 8: 2, 90: 4, 96: 6, 64: 5, 30: 7, 61: 8, 27: 3, 15: 6, 52: 3, 129: 6, 115: 6, 84: 3, 76: 5, 87: 6, 131: 8, 102: 4, 113: 8, 99: 5, 36: 6, 24: 5, 53: 4, 72: 7} {145: 1, 1: 9, 4: 5, 10: 6, 15: 6, 24: 5, 25: 5, 26: 5, 27: 6, 39: 5, 43: 6, 49: 9, 50: 8, 58: 8, 59: 5, 64: 6, 69: 3, 81: 6, 82: 6, 86: 6, 96: 7, 97: 6, 100: 9, 108: 6, 109: 7, 110: 7, 111: 5, 114: 6, 115: 7, 116: 6, 118: 6, 119: 5, 120: 6, 121: 4, 122: 7, 123: 6, 124: 4, 128: 7, 129: 7, 130: 8, 132: 2, 136: 5, 147: 7, 151: 7, 152: 7, 154: 6, 156: 5, 161: 2, 162: 3, 165: 6, 168: 7, 169: 6, 172: 6, 180: 7, 184: 2, 187: 8, 188: 7, 191: 6, 194: 3, 202: 4, 203: 5, 206: 5, 207: 6, 215: 3, 217: 6, 218: 8, 220: 4, 221: 4, 222: 5, 224: 6, 227: 7, 229: 6, 234: 8, 235: 5, 241: 5, 242: 5, 243: 3, 244: 7, 245: 3, 248: 7, 250: 7, 258: 11, 262: 7, 263: 8, 264: 3, 267: 4, 270: 6, 272: 6, 273: 4, 287: 6, 289: 6, 291: 8, 299: 7, 300: 6, 304: 6, 309: 4, 314: 5, 315: 6, 320: 4, 323: 3, 327: 7, 328: 4, 329: 5, 330: 10, 334: 5, 335: 6, 341: 7, 342: 8, 347: 7, 348: 7, 350: 6, 351: 8, 352: 6, 353: 6, 354: 5, 358: 4, 365: 6, 366: 5, 369: 4, 371: 9, 372: 8, 376: 5, 384: 8, 385: 7, 386: 6, 387: 6, 392: 4, 393: 5, 396: 8, 397: 7, 398: 6, 402: 6} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 90 "However, from a practical and implementation standpoint, they are not equivalent at all. Some approaches are more scalable than others in terms of signaling load on the network. Some can take advantage of global tracking of resources in the DetNet domain for better overall network resource optimization. Some are more resilient than others if link, node, or management equipment failures occur. While a detailed analysis of the control plane alternatives is out of the scope of this document, the requirements from this document can be used as the basis of a later analysis of the alternatives." All comments received before 04 - 27 are resolved 1c9840576d54ede4a408e3460aaf92e9f8db0004 1c9840576d54ede4a408e3460aaf92e9f8db0004 draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework a2791a57abb3aeef9c3d017581f8e22cadd3ff4aa96a60da4ae625c16fbce961 ['a2791a57abb3aeef9c3d017581f8e22cadd3ff4aa96a60da4ae625c16fbce961', 'b4be598df825265d41ec31241708c517f79a2f6724fcb86af8b29e3a1bbd3351'] A "however, from a practical and implementation standpoint, they are not equivalent at all. some approaches are more scalable than others in terms of signaling load on the network. some can take advantage of global tracking of resources in the detnet domain for better overall network resource optimization. some are more resilient than others if link, node, or management equipment failures occur. while a detailed analysis of the control plane alternatives is out of the scope of this document, the requirements from this document can be used as the basis of a later analysis of the alternatives." {} {} {} 90 "However, from a practical and implementation standpoint, controller plane alternatives are not equivalent at all. Some approaches are more scalable than others in terms of signaling load on the network. Some alternatives can take advantage of global tracking of resources in the DetNet domain for better overall network resource optimization. Some solutions are more resilient than others if link, node, or management equipment failures occur. While a detailed analysis of the control plane alternatives is out of the scope of this document, the requirements from this document can be used as the basis of a later analysis of the alternatives." All comments received before 04 - 27 are resolved 1c9840576d54ede4a408e3460aaf92e9f8db0004 1c9840576d54ede4a408e3460aaf92e9f8db0004 draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework b4be598df825265d41ec31241708c517f79a2f6724fcb86af8b29e3a1bbd3351 ['a2791a57abb3aeef9c3d017581f8e22cadd3ff4aa96a60da4ae625c16fbce961', 'b4be598df825265d41ec31241708c517f79a2f6724fcb86af8b29e3a1bbd3351'] B "however, from a practical and implementation standpoint, controller plane alternatives are not equivalent at all. some approaches are more scalable than others in terms of signaling load on the network. some alternatives can take advantage of global tracking of resources in the detnet domain for better overall network resource optimization. some solutions are more resilient than others if link, node, or management equipment failures occur. while a detailed analysis of the control plane alternatives is out of the scope of this document, the requirements from this document can be used as the basis of a later analysis of the alternatives." {} {} {} 90 "Explicit routes are used to ensure that packets are routed through the resources that have been reserved for them, and hence provide the DetNet application with the required service. A requirement for the DetNet Controller Plane will be the ability to assign a particular identified DetNet IP flow to a path through the DetNet domain that has been assigned the required nodal resources. This provides the appropriate traffic treatment for the flow and also includes particular links as a part of the path that are able to support the DetNet flow. For example, by using IEEE 802.1 TSN links (as discussed in I-D.ietf-detnet-mpls-over-tsn ) DetNet parameters can be maintained. Further considerations and requirements for the DetNet Controller Plane are discussed in control-management-requirements." All comments received before 04 - 27 are resolved 1c9840576d54ede4a408e3460aaf92e9f8db0004 1c9840576d54ede4a408e3460aaf92e9f8db0004 draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework 86b1f8609f0801a7f87967d7fc11492a8dfc742571effaabbdd314fed4b87785 ['436558eb31bc712d7ca6a4d3f92b083f0ff722fedd5b805d19272bb5b865971f', '86b1f8609f0801a7f87967d7fc11492a8dfc742571effaabbdd314fed4b87785'] A "explicit routes are used to ensure that packets are routed through the resources that have been reserved for them, and hence provide the detnet application with the required service. a requirement for the detnet controller plane will be the ability to assign a particular identified detnet ip flow to a path through the detnet domain that has been assigned the required nodal resources. this provides the appropriate traffic treatment for the flow and also includes particular links as a part of the path that are able to support the detnet flow. for example, by using ieee 802.1 tsn links (as discussed in i-d.ietf-detnet-mpls-over-tsn ) detnet parameters can be maintained. further considerations and requirements for the detnet controller plane are discussed in control-management-requirements." {31: 1, 8: 2, 6: 3, 84: 5, 55: 5} {211: 1, 226: 4, 360: 3, 409: 5, 107: 5, 138: 2, 338: 5, 89: 4} {226, 101, 360, 409, 107, 138, 338, 211, 89} 90 "Explicit routes are used to ensure that packets are routed through the resources that have been reserved for them, and hence provide the DetNet application with the required service. A requirement for the DetNet Controller Plane will be the ability to assign a particular identified DetNet IP flow to a path through the DetNet domain that has been assigned the required per-node resources. This provides the appropriate traffic treatment for the flow and also includes particular links as a part of the path that are able to support the DetNet flow. For example, by using IEEE 802.1 TSN links (as discussed in I-D.ietf-detnet-mpls-over-tsn ) DetNet parameters can be maintained. Further considerations and requirements for the DetNet Controller Plane are discussed in control-management-requirements." All comments received before 04 - 27 are resolved 1c9840576d54ede4a408e3460aaf92e9f8db0004 1c9840576d54ede4a408e3460aaf92e9f8db0004 draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework 436558eb31bc712d7ca6a4d3f92b083f0ff722fedd5b805d19272bb5b865971f ['436558eb31bc712d7ca6a4d3f92b083f0ff722fedd5b805d19272bb5b865971f', '86b1f8609f0801a7f87967d7fc11492a8dfc742571effaabbdd314fed4b87785'] B "explicit routes are used to ensure that packets are routed through the resources that have been reserved for them, and hence provide the detnet application with the required service. a requirement for the detnet controller plane will be the ability to assign a particular identified detnet ip flow to a path through the detnet domain that has been assigned the required per-node resources. this provides the appropriate traffic treatment for the flow and also includes particular links as a part of the path that are able to support the detnet flow. for example, by using ieee 802.1 tsn links (as discussed in i-d.ietf-detnet-mpls-over-tsn ) detnet parameters can be maintained. further considerations and requirements for the detnet controller plane are discussed in control-management-requirements." {31: 1, 8: 2, 6: 3, 84: 5, 55: 5} {211: 1, 226: 4, 360: 3, 409: 5, 107: 5, 138: 2, 338: 5, 89: 4} {226, 101, 360, 409, 107, 138, 338, 211, 89} 90 "See control-management-requirements for further discussion of these alternatives. In addition, RFC2386 contains useful background information on QoS-based routing, and RFC5575 discusses a specific mechanism used by BGP for traffic flow specification and policy-based routing." All comments received before 04 - 27 are resolved 1c9840576d54ede4a408e3460aaf92e9f8db0004 1c9840576d54ede4a408e3460aaf92e9f8db0004 draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework 973d15334c41750220167dc9bae7c76dc5e6a9fe42c42dde06286301574d6b1a ['973d15334c41750220167dc9bae7c76dc5e6a9fe42c42dde06286301574d6b1a', '38df0c303d87942bf98a5adcf8115c9071607c4a8de48c8e2dab87dddf464db4'] A "see control-management-requirements for further discussion of these alternatives. in addition, rfc2386 contains useful background information on qos-based routing, and rfc5575 discusses a specific mechanism used by bgp for traffic flow specification and policy-based routing." {} {} {} 90 "See control-management-requirements for further discussion of these alternatives. In addition, RFC2386 contains useful background information on QoS-based routing, and RFC5575 (being updated by I- D.ietf-idr-rfc5575bis) discusses a specific mechanism used by BGP for traffic flow specification and policy-based routing." All comments received before 04 - 27 are resolved 1c9840576d54ede4a408e3460aaf92e9f8db0004 1c9840576d54ede4a408e3460aaf92e9f8db0004 draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework 38df0c303d87942bf98a5adcf8115c9071607c4a8de48c8e2dab87dddf464db4 ['973d15334c41750220167dc9bae7c76dc5e6a9fe42c42dde06286301574d6b1a', '38df0c303d87942bf98a5adcf8115c9071607c4a8de48c8e2dab87dddf464db4'] B "see control-management-requirements for further discussion of these alternatives. in addition, rfc2386 contains useful background information on qos-based routing, and rfc5575 (being updated by i- d.ietf-idr-rfc5575bis) discusses a specific mechanism used by bgp for traffic flow specification and policy-based routing." {} {} {} 90 "The controller plane protocol solution required for managing the PREOF processing is outside the scope of this document. That said, it should be noted that the ability to determine, for a particular flow, optimal packet replication and elimination points in the DetNet domain requires explicit support. There may be capabilities that can be used, or extended, for example GMPLS end-to-end recovery RFC4872 and GMPLS segment recovery RFC4873." All comments received before 04 - 27 are resolved 1c9840576d54ede4a408e3460aaf92e9f8db0004 1c9840576d54ede4a408e3460aaf92e9f8db0004 draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework 6f8a54e6f6734a36a420cf878551c05649012f1442f53a45ee63ba45cffb33f5 ['fa6534a2fea10c93739f34a3a3ebc956aa92d44a1990ef9c3f8c57af2882f9cd', '6f410459b99f91e176c62475f217969b513ed6d2f9db4cccd92ab15f704540a3', '7d76eb2a44591ea22d40a37421afdcfa1d7675013b0151c8cfd22e967fd76c7a', 'd69209141d4946a6829e20f8b4b4b7e8ae7b6d91c2f310a11b6ad1360d13a505', '6f8a54e6f6734a36a420cf878551c05649012f1442f53a45ee63ba45cffb33f5', '80e03d9200afee14ea57a8e05a59ca0587a7e70d456b207161bc245d6fcbde70', '2b6f7ce605d7b90c5326cd4320828ae0c16e6278ffc3acdd67cf6c8e9bfe6257', '38a0a4ed16cf457fd346ca2d2feeecab03cbf7d6042e7a7467dcbcdb6b8d21dc'] A "the controller plane protocol solution required for managing the preof processing is outside the scope of this document. that said, it should be noted that the ability to determine, for a particular flow, optimal packet replication and elimination points in the detnet domain requires explicit support. there may be capabilities that can be used, or extended, for example gmpls end-to-end recovery rfc4872 and gmpls segment recovery rfc4873." {115: 1, 84: 1, 31: 1, 102: 1, 13: 1, 36: 1, 24: 1, 6: 3, 79: 3, 90: 5, 51: 2, 130: 3, 62: 5, 85: 6, 68: 5, 35: 4, 110: 2, 91: 3, 114: 2, 97: 3, 67: 2, 38: 3, 26: 2, 124: 4, 98: 3, 54: 3, 127: 4, 8: 3, 96: 3, 64: 2, 30: 2, 61: 4, 55: 4, 27: 3, 15: 2, 52: 2, 129: 4, 76: 7, 87: 2, 131: 6, 113: 4, 99: 3, 53: 2, 72: 3} {169: 1, 244: 1, 248: 1, 272: 1, 315: 1, 353: 1, 354: 1, 1: 10, 4: 3, 9: 6, 10: 4, 15: 3, 24: 3, 25: 5, 26: 6, 27: 2, 39: 6, 43: 4, 49: 4, 50: 3, 58: 4, 59: 3, 64: 3, 69: 5, 81: 6, 82: 4, 86: 2, 96: 3, 97: 2, 100: 7, 108: 4, 109: 5, 110: 5, 111: 3, 114: 4, 115: 5, 116: 3, 118: 7, 119: 6, 120: 4, 121: 5, 122: 4, 123: 3, 124: 5, 128: 2, 129: 2, 130: 4, 132: 5, 136: 3, 145: 5, 147: 3, 151: 2, 152: 2, 154: 4, 156: 2, 161: 4, 162: 4, 165: 4, 168: 5, 172: 2, 180: 2, 184: 6, 187: 6, 188: 5, 191: 4, 194: 5, 202: 6, 203: 7, 206: 3, 207: 4, 215: 3, 217: 4, 218: 9, 220: 3, 221: 3, 222: 6, 224: 4, 227: 5, 229: 2, 234: 6, 235: 3, 241: 3, 242: 3, 243: 5, 245: 5, 250: 4, 258: 12, 262: 5, 263: 6, 264: 4, 267: 5, 270: 3, 273: 6, 287: 4, 289: 2, 291: 4, 299: 5, 300: 3, 304: 3, 309: 4, 314: 3, 320: 5, 323: 5, 327: 5, 328: 4, 329: 3, 330: 11, 334: 3, 335: 3, 341: 5, 342: 6, 347: 5, 348: 5, 350: 8, 351: 2, 352: 2, 358: 5, 365: 2, 366: 3, 369: 2, 371: 7, 372: 4, 376: 3, 384: 4, 385: 3, 386: 4, 387: 3, 392: 4, 393: 5, 396: 6, 397: 8, 398: 7} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 90 "Security considerations for DetNet are described in detail in I- D.ietf-detnet-security. General security considerations for DetNet architecture are described in RFC8655. This section considers general security considerations applicable to all data planes." All comments received before 04 - 27 are resolved 1c9840576d54ede4a408e3460aaf92e9f8db0004 1c9840576d54ede4a408e3460aaf92e9f8db0004 draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework 38a0a4ed16cf457fd346ca2d2feeecab03cbf7d6042e7a7467dcbcdb6b8d21dc ['fa6534a2fea10c93739f34a3a3ebc956aa92d44a1990ef9c3f8c57af2882f9cd', '6f410459b99f91e176c62475f217969b513ed6d2f9db4cccd92ab15f704540a3', '7d76eb2a44591ea22d40a37421afdcfa1d7675013b0151c8cfd22e967fd76c7a', 'd69209141d4946a6829e20f8b4b4b7e8ae7b6d91c2f310a11b6ad1360d13a505', '6f8a54e6f6734a36a420cf878551c05649012f1442f53a45ee63ba45cffb33f5', '80e03d9200afee14ea57a8e05a59ca0587a7e70d456b207161bc245d6fcbde70', '2b6f7ce605d7b90c5326cd4320828ae0c16e6278ffc3acdd67cf6c8e9bfe6257', '38a0a4ed16cf457fd346ca2d2feeecab03cbf7d6042e7a7467dcbcdb6b8d21dc'] A "security considerations for detnet are described in detail in i- d.ietf-detnet-security. general security considerations for detnet architecture are described in rfc8655. this section considers general security considerations applicable to all data planes." {115: 1, 84: 1, 31: 1, 102: 1, 13: 1, 36: 1, 24: 1, 6: 3, 79: 3, 90: 5, 51: 2, 130: 3, 62: 5, 85: 6, 68: 5, 35: 4, 110: 2, 91: 3, 114: 2, 97: 3, 67: 2, 38: 3, 26: 2, 124: 4, 98: 3, 54: 3, 127: 4, 8: 3, 96: 3, 64: 2, 30: 2, 61: 4, 55: 4, 27: 3, 15: 2, 52: 2, 129: 4, 76: 7, 87: 2, 131: 6, 113: 4, 99: 3, 53: 2, 72: 3} {169: 1, 244: 1, 248: 1, 272: 1, 315: 1, 353: 1, 354: 1, 1: 10, 4: 3, 9: 6, 10: 4, 15: 3, 24: 3, 25: 5, 26: 6, 27: 2, 39: 6, 43: 4, 49: 4, 50: 3, 58: 4, 59: 3, 64: 3, 69: 5, 81: 6, 82: 4, 86: 2, 96: 3, 97: 2, 100: 7, 108: 4, 109: 5, 110: 5, 111: 3, 114: 4, 115: 5, 116: 3, 118: 7, 119: 6, 120: 4, 121: 5, 122: 4, 123: 3, 124: 5, 128: 2, 129: 2, 130: 4, 132: 5, 136: 3, 145: 5, 147: 3, 151: 2, 152: 2, 154: 4, 156: 2, 161: 4, 162: 4, 165: 4, 168: 5, 172: 2, 180: 2, 184: 6, 187: 6, 188: 5, 191: 4, 194: 5, 202: 6, 203: 7, 206: 3, 207: 4, 215: 3, 217: 4, 218: 9, 220: 3, 221: 3, 222: 6, 224: 4, 227: 5, 229: 2, 234: 6, 235: 3, 241: 3, 242: 3, 243: 5, 245: 5, 250: 4, 258: 12, 262: 5, 263: 6, 264: 4, 267: 5, 270: 3, 273: 6, 287: 4, 289: 2, 291: 4, 299: 5, 300: 3, 304: 3, 309: 4, 314: 3, 320: 5, 323: 5, 327: 5, 328: 4, 329: 3, 330: 11, 334: 3, 335: 3, 341: 5, 342: 6, 347: 5, 348: 5, 350: 8, 351: 2, 352: 2, 358: 5, 365: 2, 366: 3, 369: 2, 371: 7, 372: 4, 376: 3, 384: 4, 385: 3, 386: 4, 387: 3, 392: 4, 393: 5, 396: 6, 397: 8, 398: 7} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 90 "Security aspects which are unique to DetNet are those whose aim is to provide the specific quality of service aspects of DetNet, which are primarily to deliver data flows with extremely low packet loss rates and bounded end-to-end delivery latency." All comments received before 04 - 27 are resolved 1c9840576d54ede4a408e3460aaf92e9f8db0004 1c9840576d54ede4a408e3460aaf92e9f8db0004 draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework fa6534a2fea10c93739f34a3a3ebc956aa92d44a1990ef9c3f8c57af2882f9cd ['fa6534a2fea10c93739f34a3a3ebc956aa92d44a1990ef9c3f8c57af2882f9cd', '6f410459b99f91e176c62475f217969b513ed6d2f9db4cccd92ab15f704540a3', '7d76eb2a44591ea22d40a37421afdcfa1d7675013b0151c8cfd22e967fd76c7a', 'd69209141d4946a6829e20f8b4b4b7e8ae7b6d91c2f310a11b6ad1360d13a505', '6f8a54e6f6734a36a420cf878551c05649012f1442f53a45ee63ba45cffb33f5', '80e03d9200afee14ea57a8e05a59ca0587a7e70d456b207161bc245d6fcbde70', '2b6f7ce605d7b90c5326cd4320828ae0c16e6278ffc3acdd67cf6c8e9bfe6257', '38a0a4ed16cf457fd346ca2d2feeecab03cbf7d6042e7a7467dcbcdb6b8d21dc'] A "security aspects which are unique to detnet are those whose aim is to provide the specific quality of service aspects of detnet, which are primarily to deliver data flows with extremely low packet loss rates and bounded end-to-end delivery latency." {115: 1, 84: 1, 31: 1, 102: 1, 13: 1, 36: 1, 24: 1, 6: 3, 79: 3, 90: 5, 51: 2, 130: 3, 62: 5, 85: 6, 68: 5, 35: 4, 110: 2, 91: 3, 114: 2, 97: 3, 67: 2, 38: 3, 26: 2, 124: 4, 98: 3, 54: 3, 127: 4, 8: 3, 96: 3, 64: 2, 30: 2, 61: 4, 55: 4, 27: 3, 15: 2, 52: 2, 129: 4, 76: 7, 87: 2, 131: 6, 113: 4, 99: 3, 53: 2, 72: 3} {169: 1, 244: 1, 248: 1, 272: 1, 315: 1, 353: 1, 354: 1, 1: 10, 4: 3, 9: 6, 10: 4, 15: 3, 24: 3, 25: 5, 26: 6, 27: 2, 39: 6, 43: 4, 49: 4, 50: 3, 58: 4, 59: 3, 64: 3, 69: 5, 81: 6, 82: 4, 86: 2, 96: 3, 97: 2, 100: 7, 108: 4, 109: 5, 110: 5, 111: 3, 114: 4, 115: 5, 116: 3, 118: 7, 119: 6, 120: 4, 121: 5, 122: 4, 123: 3, 124: 5, 128: 2, 129: 2, 130: 4, 132: 5, 136: 3, 145: 5, 147: 3, 151: 2, 152: 2, 154: 4, 156: 2, 161: 4, 162: 4, 165: 4, 168: 5, 172: 2, 180: 2, 184: 6, 187: 6, 188: 5, 191: 4, 194: 5, 202: 6, 203: 7, 206: 3, 207: 4, 215: 3, 217: 4, 218: 9, 220: 3, 221: 3, 222: 6, 224: 4, 227: 5, 229: 2, 234: 6, 235: 3, 241: 3, 242: 3, 243: 5, 245: 5, 250: 4, 258: 12, 262: 5, 263: 6, 264: 4, 267: 5, 270: 3, 273: 6, 287: 4, 289: 2, 291: 4, 299: 5, 300: 3, 304: 3, 309: 4, 314: 3, 320: 5, 323: 5, 327: 5, 328: 4, 329: 3, 330: 11, 334: 3, 335: 3, 341: 5, 342: 6, 347: 5, 348: 5, 350: 8, 351: 2, 352: 2, 358: 5, 365: 2, 366: 3, 369: 2, 371: 7, 372: 4, 376: 3, 384: 4, 385: 3, 386: 4, 387: 3, 392: 4, 393: 5, 396: 6, 397: 8, 398: 7} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 90 "The primary consideration for the data plane is to maintain integrity of data and delivery of the associated DetNet service traversing the DetNet network. Application flows can be protected through whatever means is provided by the underlying technology. For example, encryption may be used, such as that provided by IPSec RFC4301 for IP flows and/or by an underlying sub-net using MACSec IEEE802.1AE-2018 for Ethernet (Layer-2) flows." All comments received before 04 - 27 are resolved 1c9840576d54ede4a408e3460aaf92e9f8db0004 1c9840576d54ede4a408e3460aaf92e9f8db0004 draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework d69209141d4946a6829e20f8b4b4b7e8ae7b6d91c2f310a11b6ad1360d13a505 ['fa6534a2fea10c93739f34a3a3ebc956aa92d44a1990ef9c3f8c57af2882f9cd', '6f410459b99f91e176c62475f217969b513ed6d2f9db4cccd92ab15f704540a3', '7d76eb2a44591ea22d40a37421afdcfa1d7675013b0151c8cfd22e967fd76c7a', 'd69209141d4946a6829e20f8b4b4b7e8ae7b6d91c2f310a11b6ad1360d13a505', '6f8a54e6f6734a36a420cf878551c05649012f1442f53a45ee63ba45cffb33f5', '80e03d9200afee14ea57a8e05a59ca0587a7e70d456b207161bc245d6fcbde70', '2b6f7ce605d7b90c5326cd4320828ae0c16e6278ffc3acdd67cf6c8e9bfe6257', '38a0a4ed16cf457fd346ca2d2feeecab03cbf7d6042e7a7467dcbcdb6b8d21dc'] A "the primary consideration for the data plane is to maintain integrity of data and delivery of the associated detnet service traversing the detnet network. application flows can be protected through whatever means is provided by the underlying technology. for example, encryption may be used, such as that provided by ipsec rfc4301 for ip flows and/or by an underlying sub-net using macsec ieee802.1ae-2018 for ethernet (layer-2) flows." {115: 1, 84: 1, 31: 1, 102: 1, 13: 1, 36: 1, 24: 1, 6: 3, 79: 3, 90: 5, 51: 2, 130: 3, 62: 5, 85: 6, 68: 5, 35: 4, 110: 2, 91: 3, 114: 2, 97: 3, 67: 2, 38: 3, 26: 2, 124: 4, 98: 3, 54: 3, 127: 4, 8: 3, 96: 3, 64: 2, 30: 2, 61: 4, 55: 4, 27: 3, 15: 2, 52: 2, 129: 4, 76: 7, 87: 2, 131: 6, 113: 4, 99: 3, 53: 2, 72: 3} {169: 1, 244: 1, 248: 1, 272: 1, 315: 1, 353: 1, 354: 1, 1: 10, 4: 3, 9: 6, 10: 4, 15: 3, 24: 3, 25: 5, 26: 6, 27: 2, 39: 6, 43: 4, 49: 4, 50: 3, 58: 4, 59: 3, 64: 3, 69: 5, 81: 6, 82: 4, 86: 2, 96: 3, 97: 2, 100: 7, 108: 4, 109: 5, 110: 5, 111: 3, 114: 4, 115: 5, 116: 3, 118: 7, 119: 6, 120: 4, 121: 5, 122: 4, 123: 3, 124: 5, 128: 2, 129: 2, 130: 4, 132: 5, 136: 3, 145: 5, 147: 3, 151: 2, 152: 2, 154: 4, 156: 2, 161: 4, 162: 4, 165: 4, 168: 5, 172: 2, 180: 2, 184: 6, 187: 6, 188: 5, 191: 4, 194: 5, 202: 6, 203: 7, 206: 3, 207: 4, 215: 3, 217: 4, 218: 9, 220: 3, 221: 3, 222: 6, 224: 4, 227: 5, 229: 2, 234: 6, 235: 3, 241: 3, 242: 3, 243: 5, 245: 5, 250: 4, 258: 12, 262: 5, 263: 6, 264: 4, 267: 5, 270: 3, 273: 6, 287: 4, 289: 2, 291: 4, 299: 5, 300: 3, 304: 3, 309: 4, 314: 3, 320: 5, 323: 5, 327: 5, 328: 4, 329: 3, 330: 11, 334: 3, 335: 3, 341: 5, 342: 6, 347: 5, 348: 5, 350: 8, 351: 2, 352: 2, 358: 5, 365: 2, 366: 3, 369: 2, 371: 7, 372: 4, 376: 3, 384: 4, 385: 3, 386: 4, 387: 3, 392: 4, 393: 5, 396: 6, 397: 8, 398: 7} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 90 "The controller plane protocol solution required for managing the PREOF processing is outside the scope of this document. That said, it should be noted that the ability to determine, for a particular flow, optimal packet replication and elimination points in the DetNet domain requires explicit support. There may be existing capabilities that can be used, or extended, for example GMPLS end-to-end recovery RFC4872 and GMPLS segment recovery RFC4873." All comments received before 04 - 27 are resolved 1c9840576d54ede4a408e3460aaf92e9f8db0004 1c9840576d54ede4a408e3460aaf92e9f8db0004 draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework 7d76eb2a44591ea22d40a37421afdcfa1d7675013b0151c8cfd22e967fd76c7a ['fa6534a2fea10c93739f34a3a3ebc956aa92d44a1990ef9c3f8c57af2882f9cd', '6f410459b99f91e176c62475f217969b513ed6d2f9db4cccd92ab15f704540a3', '7d76eb2a44591ea22d40a37421afdcfa1d7675013b0151c8cfd22e967fd76c7a', 'd69209141d4946a6829e20f8b4b4b7e8ae7b6d91c2f310a11b6ad1360d13a505', '6f8a54e6f6734a36a420cf878551c05649012f1442f53a45ee63ba45cffb33f5', '80e03d9200afee14ea57a8e05a59ca0587a7e70d456b207161bc245d6fcbde70', '2b6f7ce605d7b90c5326cd4320828ae0c16e6278ffc3acdd67cf6c8e9bfe6257', '38a0a4ed16cf457fd346ca2d2feeecab03cbf7d6042e7a7467dcbcdb6b8d21dc'] B "the controller plane protocol solution required for managing the preof processing is outside the scope of this document. that said, it should be noted that the ability to determine, for a particular flow, optimal packet replication and elimination points in the detnet domain requires explicit support. there may be existing capabilities that can be used, or extended, for example gmpls end-to-end recovery rfc4872 and gmpls segment recovery rfc4873." {115: 1, 84: 1, 31: 1, 102: 1, 13: 1, 36: 1, 24: 1, 6: 3, 79: 3, 90: 5, 51: 2, 130: 3, 62: 5, 85: 6, 68: 5, 35: 4, 110: 2, 91: 3, 114: 2, 97: 3, 67: 2, 38: 3, 26: 2, 124: 4, 98: 3, 54: 3, 127: 4, 8: 3, 96: 3, 64: 2, 30: 2, 61: 4, 55: 4, 27: 3, 15: 2, 52: 2, 129: 4, 76: 7, 87: 2, 131: 6, 113: 4, 99: 3, 53: 2, 72: 3} {169: 1, 244: 1, 248: 1, 272: 1, 315: 1, 353: 1, 354: 1, 1: 10, 4: 3, 9: 6, 10: 4, 15: 3, 24: 3, 25: 5, 26: 6, 27: 2, 39: 6, 43: 4, 49: 4, 50: 3, 58: 4, 59: 3, 64: 3, 69: 5, 81: 6, 82: 4, 86: 2, 96: 3, 97: 2, 100: 7, 108: 4, 109: 5, 110: 5, 111: 3, 114: 4, 115: 5, 116: 3, 118: 7, 119: 6, 120: 4, 121: 5, 122: 4, 123: 3, 124: 5, 128: 2, 129: 2, 130: 4, 132: 5, 136: 3, 145: 5, 147: 3, 151: 2, 152: 2, 154: 4, 156: 2, 161: 4, 162: 4, 165: 4, 168: 5, 172: 2, 180: 2, 184: 6, 187: 6, 188: 5, 191: 4, 194: 5, 202: 6, 203: 7, 206: 3, 207: 4, 215: 3, 217: 4, 218: 9, 220: 3, 221: 3, 222: 6, 224: 4, 227: 5, 229: 2, 234: 6, 235: 3, 241: 3, 242: 3, 243: 5, 245: 5, 250: 4, 258: 12, 262: 5, 263: 6, 264: 4, 267: 5, 270: 3, 273: 6, 287: 4, 289: 2, 291: 4, 299: 5, 300: 3, 304: 3, 309: 4, 314: 3, 320: 5, 323: 5, 327: 5, 328: 4, 329: 3, 330: 11, 334: 3, 335: 3, 341: 5, 342: 6, 347: 5, 348: 5, 350: 8, 351: 2, 352: 2, 358: 5, 365: 2, 366: 3, 369: 2, 371: 7, 372: 4, 376: 3, 384: 4, 385: 3, 386: 4, 387: 3, 392: 4, 393: 5, 396: 6, 397: 8, 398: 7} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 90 "Security considerations for DetNet are described in detail in I- D.ietf-detnet-security. General security considerations for DetNet architecture are described in RFC8655. This section considers architecture-level DetNet security considerations applicable to all data planes." All comments received before 04 - 27 are resolved 1c9840576d54ede4a408e3460aaf92e9f8db0004 1c9840576d54ede4a408e3460aaf92e9f8db0004 draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework 6f410459b99f91e176c62475f217969b513ed6d2f9db4cccd92ab15f704540a3 ['fa6534a2fea10c93739f34a3a3ebc956aa92d44a1990ef9c3f8c57af2882f9cd', '6f410459b99f91e176c62475f217969b513ed6d2f9db4cccd92ab15f704540a3', '7d76eb2a44591ea22d40a37421afdcfa1d7675013b0151c8cfd22e967fd76c7a', 'd69209141d4946a6829e20f8b4b4b7e8ae7b6d91c2f310a11b6ad1360d13a505', '6f8a54e6f6734a36a420cf878551c05649012f1442f53a45ee63ba45cffb33f5', '80e03d9200afee14ea57a8e05a59ca0587a7e70d456b207161bc245d6fcbde70', '2b6f7ce605d7b90c5326cd4320828ae0c16e6278ffc3acdd67cf6c8e9bfe6257', '38a0a4ed16cf457fd346ca2d2feeecab03cbf7d6042e7a7467dcbcdb6b8d21dc'] B "security considerations for detnet are described in detail in i- d.ietf-detnet-security. general security considerations for detnet architecture are described in rfc8655. this section considers architecture-level detnet security considerations applicable to all data planes." {115: 1, 84: 1, 31: 1, 102: 1, 13: 1, 36: 1, 24: 1, 6: 3, 79: 3, 90: 5, 51: 2, 130: 3, 62: 5, 85: 6, 68: 5, 35: 4, 110: 2, 91: 3, 114: 2, 97: 3, 67: 2, 38: 3, 26: 2, 124: 4, 98: 3, 54: 3, 127: 4, 8: 3, 96: 3, 64: 2, 30: 2, 61: 4, 55: 4, 27: 3, 15: 2, 52: 2, 129: 4, 76: 7, 87: 2, 131: 6, 113: 4, 99: 3, 53: 2, 72: 3} {169: 1, 244: 1, 248: 1, 272: 1, 315: 1, 353: 1, 354: 1, 1: 10, 4: 3, 9: 6, 10: 4, 15: 3, 24: 3, 25: 5, 26: 6, 27: 2, 39: 6, 43: 4, 49: 4, 50: 3, 58: 4, 59: 3, 64: 3, 69: 5, 81: 6, 82: 4, 86: 2, 96: 3, 97: 2, 100: 7, 108: 4, 109: 5, 110: 5, 111: 3, 114: 4, 115: 5, 116: 3, 118: 7, 119: 6, 120: 4, 121: 5, 122: 4, 123: 3, 124: 5, 128: 2, 129: 2, 130: 4, 132: 5, 136: 3, 145: 5, 147: 3, 151: 2, 152: 2, 154: 4, 156: 2, 161: 4, 162: 4, 165: 4, 168: 5, 172: 2, 180: 2, 184: 6, 187: 6, 188: 5, 191: 4, 194: 5, 202: 6, 203: 7, 206: 3, 207: 4, 215: 3, 217: 4, 218: 9, 220: 3, 221: 3, 222: 6, 224: 4, 227: 5, 229: 2, 234: 6, 235: 3, 241: 3, 242: 3, 243: 5, 245: 5, 250: 4, 258: 12, 262: 5, 263: 6, 264: 4, 267: 5, 270: 3, 273: 6, 287: 4, 289: 2, 291: 4, 299: 5, 300: 3, 304: 3, 309: 4, 314: 3, 320: 5, 323: 5, 327: 5, 328: 4, 329: 3, 330: 11, 334: 3, 335: 3, 341: 5, 342: 6, 347: 5, 348: 5, 350: 8, 351: 2, 352: 2, 358: 5, 365: 2, 366: 3, 369: 2, 371: 7, 372: 4, 376: 3, 384: 4, 385: 3, 386: 4, 387: 3, 392: 4, 393: 5, 396: 6, 397: 8, 398: 7} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 90 "Part of what makes DetNet unique is its ability to provide specific and reliable quality of service (delivering data flows with extremely low packet loss rates and bounded end-to-end delivery latency), and the security-related aspects of protecting that quality of service are similarly unique." All comments received before 04 - 27 are resolved 1c9840576d54ede4a408e3460aaf92e9f8db0004 1c9840576d54ede4a408e3460aaf92e9f8db0004 draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework 80e03d9200afee14ea57a8e05a59ca0587a7e70d456b207161bc245d6fcbde70 ['fa6534a2fea10c93739f34a3a3ebc956aa92d44a1990ef9c3f8c57af2882f9cd', '6f410459b99f91e176c62475f217969b513ed6d2f9db4cccd92ab15f704540a3', '7d76eb2a44591ea22d40a37421afdcfa1d7675013b0151c8cfd22e967fd76c7a', 'd69209141d4946a6829e20f8b4b4b7e8ae7b6d91c2f310a11b6ad1360d13a505', '6f8a54e6f6734a36a420cf878551c05649012f1442f53a45ee63ba45cffb33f5', '80e03d9200afee14ea57a8e05a59ca0587a7e70d456b207161bc245d6fcbde70', '2b6f7ce605d7b90c5326cd4320828ae0c16e6278ffc3acdd67cf6c8e9bfe6257', '38a0a4ed16cf457fd346ca2d2feeecab03cbf7d6042e7a7467dcbcdb6b8d21dc'] B "part of what makes detnet unique is its ability to provide specific and reliable quality of service (delivering data flows with extremely low packet loss rates and bounded end-to-end delivery latency), and the security-related aspects of protecting that quality of service are similarly unique." {115: 1, 84: 1, 31: 1, 102: 1, 13: 1, 36: 1, 24: 1, 6: 3, 79: 3, 90: 5, 51: 2, 130: 3, 62: 5, 85: 6, 68: 5, 35: 4, 110: 2, 91: 3, 114: 2, 97: 3, 67: 2, 38: 3, 26: 2, 124: 4, 98: 3, 54: 3, 127: 4, 8: 3, 96: 3, 64: 2, 30: 2, 61: 4, 55: 4, 27: 3, 15: 2, 52: 2, 129: 4, 76: 7, 87: 2, 131: 6, 113: 4, 99: 3, 53: 2, 72: 3} {169: 1, 244: 1, 248: 1, 272: 1, 315: 1, 353: 1, 354: 1, 1: 10, 4: 3, 9: 6, 10: 4, 15: 3, 24: 3, 25: 5, 26: 6, 27: 2, 39: 6, 43: 4, 49: 4, 50: 3, 58: 4, 59: 3, 64: 3, 69: 5, 81: 6, 82: 4, 86: 2, 96: 3, 97: 2, 100: 7, 108: 4, 109: 5, 110: 5, 111: 3, 114: 4, 115: 5, 116: 3, 118: 7, 119: 6, 120: 4, 121: 5, 122: 4, 123: 3, 124: 5, 128: 2, 129: 2, 130: 4, 132: 5, 136: 3, 145: 5, 147: 3, 151: 2, 152: 2, 154: 4, 156: 2, 161: 4, 162: 4, 165: 4, 168: 5, 172: 2, 180: 2, 184: 6, 187: 6, 188: 5, 191: 4, 194: 5, 202: 6, 203: 7, 206: 3, 207: 4, 215: 3, 217: 4, 218: 9, 220: 3, 221: 3, 222: 6, 224: 4, 227: 5, 229: 2, 234: 6, 235: 3, 241: 3, 242: 3, 243: 5, 245: 5, 250: 4, 258: 12, 262: 5, 263: 6, 264: 4, 267: 5, 270: 3, 273: 6, 287: 4, 289: 2, 291: 4, 299: 5, 300: 3, 304: 3, 309: 4, 314: 3, 320: 5, 323: 5, 327: 5, 328: 4, 329: 3, 330: 11, 334: 3, 335: 3, 341: 5, 342: 6, 347: 5, 348: 5, 350: 8, 351: 2, 352: 2, 358: 5, 365: 2, 366: 3, 369: 2, 371: 7, 372: 4, 376: 3, 384: 4, 385: 3, 386: 4, 387: 3, 392: 4, 393: 5, 396: 6, 397: 8, 398: 7} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 90 "As for all communications protocols, the primary consideration for the data plane is to maintain integrity of data and delivery of the associated DetNet service traversing the DetNet network. Application flows can be protected through whatever means is provided by the underlying technology. For example, encryption may be used, such as that provided by IPSec RFC4301 for IP flows and/or by an underlying sub-net using MACSec IEEE802.1AE-2018 for Ethernet (Layer-2) flows." All comments received before 04 - 27 are resolved 1c9840576d54ede4a408e3460aaf92e9f8db0004 1c9840576d54ede4a408e3460aaf92e9f8db0004 draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework 2b6f7ce605d7b90c5326cd4320828ae0c16e6278ffc3acdd67cf6c8e9bfe6257 ['fa6534a2fea10c93739f34a3a3ebc956aa92d44a1990ef9c3f8c57af2882f9cd', '6f410459b99f91e176c62475f217969b513ed6d2f9db4cccd92ab15f704540a3', '7d76eb2a44591ea22d40a37421afdcfa1d7675013b0151c8cfd22e967fd76c7a', 'd69209141d4946a6829e20f8b4b4b7e8ae7b6d91c2f310a11b6ad1360d13a505', '6f8a54e6f6734a36a420cf878551c05649012f1442f53a45ee63ba45cffb33f5', '80e03d9200afee14ea57a8e05a59ca0587a7e70d456b207161bc245d6fcbde70', '2b6f7ce605d7b90c5326cd4320828ae0c16e6278ffc3acdd67cf6c8e9bfe6257', '38a0a4ed16cf457fd346ca2d2feeecab03cbf7d6042e7a7467dcbcdb6b8d21dc'] B "as for all communications protocols, the primary consideration for the data plane is to maintain integrity of data and delivery of the associated detnet service traversing the detnet network. application flows can be protected through whatever means is provided by the underlying technology. for example, encryption may be used, such as that provided by ipsec rfc4301 for ip flows and/or by an underlying sub-net using macsec ieee802.1ae-2018 for ethernet (layer-2) flows." {115: 1, 84: 1, 31: 1, 102: 1, 13: 1, 36: 1, 24: 1, 6: 3, 79: 3, 90: 5, 51: 2, 130: 3, 62: 5, 85: 6, 68: 5, 35: 4, 110: 2, 91: 3, 114: 2, 97: 3, 67: 2, 38: 3, 26: 2, 124: 4, 98: 3, 54: 3, 127: 4, 8: 3, 96: 3, 64: 2, 30: 2, 61: 4, 55: 4, 27: 3, 15: 2, 52: 2, 129: 4, 76: 7, 87: 2, 131: 6, 113: 4, 99: 3, 53: 2, 72: 3} {169: 1, 244: 1, 248: 1, 272: 1, 315: 1, 353: 1, 354: 1, 1: 10, 4: 3, 9: 6, 10: 4, 15: 3, 24: 3, 25: 5, 26: 6, 27: 2, 39: 6, 43: 4, 49: 4, 50: 3, 58: 4, 59: 3, 64: 3, 69: 5, 81: 6, 82: 4, 86: 2, 96: 3, 97: 2, 100: 7, 108: 4, 109: 5, 110: 5, 111: 3, 114: 4, 115: 5, 116: 3, 118: 7, 119: 6, 120: 4, 121: 5, 122: 4, 123: 3, 124: 5, 128: 2, 129: 2, 130: 4, 132: 5, 136: 3, 145: 5, 147: 3, 151: 2, 152: 2, 154: 4, 156: 2, 161: 4, 162: 4, 165: 4, 168: 5, 172: 2, 180: 2, 184: 6, 187: 6, 188: 5, 191: 4, 194: 5, 202: 6, 203: 7, 206: 3, 207: 4, 215: 3, 217: 4, 218: 9, 220: 3, 221: 3, 222: 6, 224: 4, 227: 5, 229: 2, 234: 6, 235: 3, 241: 3, 242: 3, 243: 5, 245: 5, 250: 4, 258: 12, 262: 5, 263: 6, 264: 4, 267: 5, 270: 3, 273: 6, 287: 4, 289: 2, 291: 4, 299: 5, 300: 3, 304: 3, 309: 4, 314: 3, 320: 5, 323: 5, 327: 5, 328: 4, 329: 3, 330: 11, 334: 3, 335: 3, 341: 5, 342: 6, 347: 5, 348: 5, 350: 8, 351: 2, 352: 2, 358: 5, 365: 2, 366: 3, 369: 2, 371: 7, 372: 4, 376: 3, 384: 4, 385: 3, 386: 4, 387: 3, 392: 4, 393: 5, 396: 6, 397: 8, 398: 7} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 88 "existing mechanism, such as through policing and shaping. To prevent DetNet packets from being delayed by an entity external to a DetNet domain, DetNet technology definition can allow for the mitigation of Man-In-The-Middle attacks, for example through use of authentication and authorization of devices within the DetNet domain." Fixing authors and security in mpls 528beb75012b160f4a53922e93cc642e1442de4a 528beb75012b160f4a53922e93cc642e1442de4a draft-ietf-detnet-mpls 87fc8064b490b0997e08d0f83190a00a0169648b765faad277abf9c4b3767bc5 ['87fc8064b490b0997e08d0f83190a00a0169648b765faad277abf9c4b3767bc5', '1ae40f923a31c9855ea35e19223c5ac5c245b5a04b534247e4810aae94fc12af', '33ed7a4e03e187acb8bc376c33162e2f114e614a08fefe4335f6968d5913ee37'] A "existing mechanism, such as through policing and shaping. to prevent detnet packets from being delayed by an entity external to a detnet domain, detnet technology definition can allow for the mitigation of man-in-the-middle attacks, for example through use of authentication and authorization of devices within the detnet domain." {68: 1} {29: 1} {213, 29} 88 "existing mechanisms, for example by policing and shaping incoming traffic. To prevent DetNet packets from being delayed by an entity external to a DetNet domain, DetNet technology definition can allow for the mitigation of Man-In-The-Middle attacks, for example through use of authentication and authorization of devices within the DetNet domain." Fixing authors and security in mpls 528beb75012b160f4a53922e93cc642e1442de4a 528beb75012b160f4a53922e93cc642e1442de4a draft-ietf-detnet-mpls 33ed7a4e03e187acb8bc376c33162e2f114e614a08fefe4335f6968d5913ee37 ['87fc8064b490b0997e08d0f83190a00a0169648b765faad277abf9c4b3767bc5', '1ae40f923a31c9855ea35e19223c5ac5c245b5a04b534247e4810aae94fc12af', '33ed7a4e03e187acb8bc376c33162e2f114e614a08fefe4335f6968d5913ee37'] B "existing mechanisms, for example by policing and shaping incoming traffic. to prevent detnet packets from being delayed by an entity external to a detnet domain, detnet technology definition can allow for the mitigation of man-in-the-middle attacks, for example through use of authentication and authorization of devices within the detnet domain." {68: 1} {29: 1} {213, 29} 88 This document makes no IANA requests. Fixing authors and security in mpls 528beb75012b160f4a53922e93cc642e1442de4a 528beb75012b160f4a53922e93cc642e1442de4a draft-ietf-detnet-mpls 1ae40f923a31c9855ea35e19223c5ac5c245b5a04b534247e4810aae94fc12af ['87fc8064b490b0997e08d0f83190a00a0169648b765faad277abf9c4b3767bc5', '1ae40f923a31c9855ea35e19223c5ac5c245b5a04b534247e4810aae94fc12af', '33ed7a4e03e187acb8bc376c33162e2f114e614a08fefe4335f6968d5913ee37'] B this document makes no iana requests. {68: 1} {29: 1} {213, 29} 87 "General security considerations are described in RFC8655. Additionally, security considerations and a threat analysis are described in I-D.ietf-detnet-security. This section considers exclusively security considerations which are specific to the DetNet MPLS data plane." from april 20 call dd4c17faccd8015fc2031111f5e0d47a15207071 dd4c17faccd8015fc2031111f5e0d47a15207071 draft-ietf-detnet-mpls eee34f68dce1da0da38880a50952e4dbbb99435e1c45fd5fb58ddfa299f9a18b ['eee34f68dce1da0da38880a50952e4dbbb99435e1c45fd5fb58ddfa299f9a18b', '162bcf54bdc7b4e460e82639caf91d5927c423b263ff9ea20def8f38254c6bc0'] A "general security considerations are described in rfc8655. additionally, security considerations and a threat analysis are described in i-d.ietf-detnet-security. this section considers exclusively security considerations which are specific to the detnet mpls data plane." {72: 1, 6: 5, 79: 5, 90: 4, 51: 5, 130: 5, 62: 7, 85: 8, 68: 7, 35: 6, 110: 4, 91: 6, 114: 4, 97: 5, 31: 5, 13: 4, 67: 2, 38: 5, 26: 4, 124: 6, 98: 5, 54: 5, 127: 6, 8: 5, 96: 5, 64: 5, 30: 5, 61: 6, 55: 6, 27: 5, 15: 4, 52: 4, 129: 6, 115: 4, 84: 4, 76: 9, 87: 4, 131: 8, 102: 4, 113: 6, 99: 5, 36: 4, 24: 3, 53: 4} {385: 1, 1: 12, 4: 5, 9: 8, 10: 6, 15: 5, 24: 5, 25: 7, 26: 8, 27: 5, 39: 8, 43: 6, 49: 7, 50: 6, 58: 6, 59: 5, 64: 5, 69: 7, 81: 8, 82: 6, 86: 2, 96: 5, 97: 4, 100: 9, 108: 6, 109: 7, 110: 7, 111: 5, 114: 6, 115: 7, 116: 5, 118: 9, 119: 8, 120: 6, 121: 7, 122: 6, 123: 5, 124: 7, 128: 5, 129: 5, 130: 6, 132: 7, 136: 5, 145: 7, 147: 5, 151: 5, 152: 5, 154: 6, 156: 4, 161: 6, 162: 6, 165: 6, 168: 7, 169: 4, 172: 4, 180: 5, 184: 8, 187: 8, 188: 7, 191: 6, 194: 7, 202: 8, 203: 9, 206: 5, 207: 6, 215: 5, 217: 6, 218: 11, 220: 5, 221: 5, 222: 8, 224: 6, 227: 7, 229: 4, 234: 8, 235: 5, 241: 5, 242: 5, 243: 7, 244: 5, 245: 7, 248: 5, 250: 6, 258: 14, 262: 7, 263: 8, 264: 6, 267: 7, 270: 5, 272: 4, 273: 8, 287: 6, 289: 4, 291: 6, 299: 7, 300: 5, 304: 5, 309: 6, 314: 5, 315: 4, 320: 7, 323: 7, 327: 7, 328: 6, 329: 5, 330: 13, 334: 5, 335: 5, 341: 7, 342: 8, 347: 7, 348: 7, 350: 10, 351: 6, 352: 4, 353: 4, 354: 3, 358: 7, 365: 4, 366: 5, 369: 4, 371: 9, 372: 6, 376: 5, 386: 6, 387: 5, 392: 6, 393: 7, 396: 8, 397: 10, 398: 9, 402: 4} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 87 "General security considerations are described in RFC8655. Additionally, security considerations and a threat analysis are described in I-D.ietf-detnet-security. This section considers security considerations which are specific to the DetNet MPLS data plane. The considerations raised related to MPLS networks in general in RFC5920 are equally applicable to the the DetNet MPLS data plane." from april 20 call dd4c17faccd8015fc2031111f5e0d47a15207071 dd4c17faccd8015fc2031111f5e0d47a15207071 draft-ietf-detnet-mpls 162bcf54bdc7b4e460e82639caf91d5927c423b263ff9ea20def8f38254c6bc0 ['eee34f68dce1da0da38880a50952e4dbbb99435e1c45fd5fb58ddfa299f9a18b', '162bcf54bdc7b4e460e82639caf91d5927c423b263ff9ea20def8f38254c6bc0'] B "general security considerations are described in rfc8655. additionally, security considerations and a threat analysis are described in i-d.ietf-detnet-security. this section considers security considerations which are specific to the detnet mpls data plane. the considerations raised related to mpls networks in general in rfc5920 are equally applicable to the the detnet mpls data plane." {72: 1, 6: 5, 79: 5, 90: 4, 51: 5, 130: 5, 62: 7, 85: 8, 68: 7, 35: 6, 110: 4, 91: 6, 114: 4, 97: 5, 31: 5, 13: 4, 67: 2, 38: 5, 26: 4, 124: 6, 98: 5, 54: 5, 127: 6, 8: 5, 96: 5, 64: 5, 30: 5, 61: 6, 55: 6, 27: 5, 15: 4, 52: 4, 129: 6, 115: 4, 84: 4, 76: 9, 87: 4, 131: 8, 102: 4, 113: 6, 99: 5, 36: 4, 24: 3, 53: 4} {385: 1, 1: 12, 4: 5, 9: 8, 10: 6, 15: 5, 24: 5, 25: 7, 26: 8, 27: 5, 39: 8, 43: 6, 49: 7, 50: 6, 58: 6, 59: 5, 64: 5, 69: 7, 81: 8, 82: 6, 86: 2, 96: 5, 97: 4, 100: 9, 108: 6, 109: 7, 110: 7, 111: 5, 114: 6, 115: 7, 116: 5, 118: 9, 119: 8, 120: 6, 121: 7, 122: 6, 123: 5, 124: 7, 128: 5, 129: 5, 130: 6, 132: 7, 136: 5, 145: 7, 147: 5, 151: 5, 152: 5, 154: 6, 156: 4, 161: 6, 162: 6, 165: 6, 168: 7, 169: 4, 172: 4, 180: 5, 184: 8, 187: 8, 188: 7, 191: 6, 194: 7, 202: 8, 203: 9, 206: 5, 207: 6, 215: 5, 217: 6, 218: 11, 220: 5, 221: 5, 222: 8, 224: 6, 227: 7, 229: 4, 234: 8, 235: 5, 241: 5, 242: 5, 243: 7, 244: 5, 245: 7, 248: 5, 250: 6, 258: 14, 262: 7, 263: 8, 264: 6, 267: 7, 270: 5, 272: 4, 273: 8, 287: 6, 289: 4, 291: 6, 299: 7, 300: 5, 304: 5, 309: 6, 314: 5, 315: 4, 320: 7, 323: 7, 327: 7, 328: 6, 329: 5, 330: 13, 334: 5, 335: 5, 341: 7, 342: 8, 347: 7, 348: 7, 350: 10, 351: 6, 352: 4, 353: 4, 354: 3, 358: 7, 365: 4, 366: 5, 369: 4, 371: 9, 372: 6, 376: 5, 386: 6, 387: 5, 392: 6, 393: 7, 396: 8, 397: 10, 398: 9, 402: 4} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 87 "To provide uninterrupted availability of the DetNet service, provisions can be made against DOS attacks and delay attacks. To protect against DOS attacks, excess traffic due to malicious or malfunctioning devices can be prevented or mitigated, for example through the use of existing mechanism such as policing and shaping applied at the input of a DetNet domain. To prevent DetNet packets from being delayed by an entity external to a DetNet domain, DetNet technology definition can allow for the mitigation of Man-In-The- Middle attacks, for example through use of authentication and authorization of devices within the DetNet domain." from april 20 call dd4c17faccd8015fc2031111f5e0d47a15207071 dd4c17faccd8015fc2031111f5e0d47a15207071 draft-ietf-detnet-mpls 9660729dcccf51d5b146b7b549f874e0feac220bda1c96d69e1fcfab2efbb95f ['9660729dcccf51d5b146b7b549f874e0feac220bda1c96d69e1fcfab2efbb95f', '7f0ec8354022991f227ea5bb30cf54b0195ec2f46b9cecf195859b0ede9c3131'] A "to provide uninterrupted availability of the detnet service, provisions can be made against dos attacks and delay attacks. to protect against dos attacks, excess traffic due to malicious or malfunctioning devices can be prevented or mitigated, for example through the use of existing mechanism such as policing and shaping applied at the input of a detnet domain. to prevent detnet packets from being delayed by an entity external to a detnet domain, detnet technology definition can allow for the mitigation of man-in-the- middle attacks, for example through use of authentication and authorization of devices within the detnet domain." {15: 1, 84: 1, 24: 1, 36: 1, 6: 3, 79: 3, 90: 2, 51: 3, 130: 3, 62: 5, 85: 6, 68: 5, 35: 4, 110: 2, 91: 3, 114: 2, 97: 3, 31: 3, 13: 2, 67: 2, 38: 3, 26: 2, 124: 4, 98: 3, 54: 3, 127: 4, 8: 3, 96: 3, 64: 2, 30: 2, 61: 4, 55: 4, 27: 3, 52: 2, 129: 4, 115: 2, 76: 7, 131: 6, 102: 2, 113: 4, 99: 3, 53: 2, 87: 4, 72: 3} {352: 1, 289: 1, 354: 1, 353: 1, 1: 10, 4: 3, 9: 6, 10: 4, 15: 3, 24: 3, 25: 5, 26: 6, 27: 3, 39: 6, 43: 4, 49: 4, 50: 3, 58: 4, 59: 3, 64: 3, 69: 5, 81: 6, 82: 4, 86: 2, 96: 3, 97: 2, 100: 7, 108: 4, 109: 5, 110: 5, 111: 3, 114: 4, 115: 5, 116: 3, 118: 7, 119: 6, 120: 4, 121: 5, 122: 4, 123: 3, 124: 5, 128: 2, 129: 2, 130: 4, 132: 5, 136: 3, 145: 5, 147: 3, 151: 3, 152: 3, 154: 4, 156: 2, 161: 4, 162: 4, 165: 4, 168: 5, 169: 2, 172: 2, 180: 2, 184: 6, 187: 6, 188: 5, 191: 4, 194: 5, 202: 6, 203: 7, 206: 3, 207: 4, 215: 3, 217: 4, 218: 9, 220: 3, 221: 3, 222: 6, 224: 4, 227: 5, 234: 6, 235: 3, 241: 3, 242: 3, 243: 5, 244: 3, 245: 5, 248: 3, 250: 4, 258: 12, 262: 5, 263: 6, 264: 4, 267: 5, 270: 3, 272: 2, 273: 6, 287: 4, 291: 4, 299: 5, 300: 3, 304: 3, 309: 4, 314: 3, 315: 2, 320: 5, 323: 5, 327: 5, 328: 4, 329: 3, 330: 11, 334: 3, 335: 3, 341: 5, 342: 6, 347: 5, 348: 5, 350: 8, 351: 4, 358: 5, 365: 2, 366: 3, 369: 2, 371: 7, 372: 4, 376: 3, 384: 4, 385: 3, 386: 4, 387: 3, 392: 4, 393: 5, 396: 6, 397: 8, 398: 7, 402: 2} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 87 "To provide uninterrupted availability of the DetNet service, provisions can be made against DOS attacks and delay attacks. To protect against DOS attacks, excess traffic due to malicious or malfunctioning devices is prevented or mitigated through the use of existing mechanism, such as through policing and shaping. To prevent DetNet packets from being delayed by an entity external to a DetNet domain, DetNet technology definition can allow for the mitigation of Man-In-The-Middle attacks, for example through use of authentication and authorization of devices within the DetNet domain." from april 20 call dd4c17faccd8015fc2031111f5e0d47a15207071 dd4c17faccd8015fc2031111f5e0d47a15207071 draft-ietf-detnet-mpls 7f0ec8354022991f227ea5bb30cf54b0195ec2f46b9cecf195859b0ede9c3131 ['9660729dcccf51d5b146b7b549f874e0feac220bda1c96d69e1fcfab2efbb95f', '7f0ec8354022991f227ea5bb30cf54b0195ec2f46b9cecf195859b0ede9c3131'] B "to provide uninterrupted availability of the detnet service, provisions can be made against dos attacks and delay attacks. to protect against dos attacks, excess traffic due to malicious or malfunctioning devices is prevented or mitigated through the use of existing mechanism, such as through policing and shaping. to prevent detnet packets from being delayed by an entity external to a detnet domain, detnet technology definition can allow for the mitigation of man-in-the-middle attacks, for example through use of authentication and authorization of devices within the detnet domain." {15: 1, 84: 1, 24: 1, 36: 1, 6: 3, 79: 3, 90: 2, 51: 3, 130: 3, 62: 5, 85: 6, 68: 5, 35: 4, 110: 2, 91: 3, 114: 2, 97: 3, 31: 3, 13: 2, 67: 2, 38: 3, 26: 2, 124: 4, 98: 3, 54: 3, 127: 4, 8: 3, 96: 3, 64: 2, 30: 2, 61: 4, 55: 4, 27: 3, 52: 2, 129: 4, 115: 2, 76: 7, 131: 6, 102: 2, 113: 4, 99: 3, 53: 2, 87: 4, 72: 3} {352: 1, 289: 1, 354: 1, 353: 1, 1: 10, 4: 3, 9: 6, 10: 4, 15: 3, 24: 3, 25: 5, 26: 6, 27: 3, 39: 6, 43: 4, 49: 4, 50: 3, 58: 4, 59: 3, 64: 3, 69: 5, 81: 6, 82: 4, 86: 2, 96: 3, 97: 2, 100: 7, 108: 4, 109: 5, 110: 5, 111: 3, 114: 4, 115: 5, 116: 3, 118: 7, 119: 6, 120: 4, 121: 5, 122: 4, 123: 3, 124: 5, 128: 2, 129: 2, 130: 4, 132: 5, 136: 3, 145: 5, 147: 3, 151: 3, 152: 3, 154: 4, 156: 2, 161: 4, 162: 4, 165: 4, 168: 5, 169: 2, 172: 2, 180: 2, 184: 6, 187: 6, 188: 5, 191: 4, 194: 5, 202: 6, 203: 7, 206: 3, 207: 4, 215: 3, 217: 4, 218: 9, 220: 3, 221: 3, 222: 6, 224: 4, 227: 5, 234: 6, 235: 3, 241: 3, 242: 3, 243: 5, 244: 3, 245: 5, 248: 3, 250: 4, 258: 12, 262: 5, 263: 6, 264: 4, 267: 5, 270: 3, 272: 2, 273: 6, 287: 4, 291: 4, 299: 5, 300: 3, 304: 3, 309: 4, 314: 3, 315: 2, 320: 5, 323: 5, 327: 5, 328: 4, 329: 3, 330: 11, 334: 3, 335: 3, 341: 5, 342: 6, 347: 5, 348: 5, 350: 8, 351: 4, 358: 5, 365: 2, 366: 3, 369: 2, 371: 7, 372: 4, 376: 3, 384: 4, 385: 3, 386: 4, 387: 3, 392: 4, 393: 5, 396: 6, 397: 8, 398: 7, 402: 2} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 86 An unsigned value implementing the DetNet sequence number. "IESG review comment resolutions in this version : DONE , IANA , ( 03 - 12 ) , OK , ( 03 - 15 ) , Ready with Issues : Seq . Num . , ( 03 - 13 ) , Ready TO BE DISCUSSED : Security section , SecDir , ( 03 - 11 ) , Not , ( 03 - 13 ) , , ( 04 - 09 ) , decrease authors to 6 ! ! ! reviewed in April 22 meeting" 9d54eb76e384df6039a9875611ef733654932dee 9d54eb76e384df6039a9875611ef733654932dee draft-ietf-detnet-mpls 43cc51060cf5b13de637c83a0fd15b72de32a85216a77586a9996ed15d81a12f ['ef7d6626ad7c0fe1bc84276721b25014f18c2f4b7849cafdfe1b1a2aec3c1f94', '43cc51060cf5b13de637c83a0fd15b72de32a85216a77586a9996ed15d81a12f'] A an unsigned value implementing the detnet sequence number. {} {} {} 86 "An unsigned value implementing the DetNet sequence number. The sequence number space is a circular one." "IESG review comment resolutions in this version : DONE , IANA , ( 03 - 12 ) , OK , ( 03 - 15 ) , Ready with Issues : Seq . Num . , ( 03 - 13 ) , Ready TO BE DISCUSSED : Security section , SecDir , ( 03 - 11 ) , Not , ( 03 - 13 ) , , ( 04 - 09 ) , decrease authors to 6 ! ! ! reviewed in April 22 meeting" 9d54eb76e384df6039a9875611ef733654932dee 9d54eb76e384df6039a9875611ef733654932dee draft-ietf-detnet-mpls ef7d6626ad7c0fe1bc84276721b25014f18c2f4b7849cafdfe1b1a2aec3c1f94 ['ef7d6626ad7c0fe1bc84276721b25014f18c2f4b7849cafdfe1b1a2aec3c1f94', '43cc51060cf5b13de637c83a0fd15b72de32a85216a77586a9996ed15d81a12f'] B "an unsigned value implementing the detnet sequence number. the sequence number space is a circular one." {} {} {} 85 "Deterministic Networking (DetNet) is a service that can be offered by a network to DetNet flows. DetNet provides these flows extremely low packet loss rates and assured maximum end-to-end delivery latency. General background and concepts of DetNet can be found in the DetNet Architecture RFC8655." "IESG review comment resolutions in this version : DONE , ( ) , ( 03 - 09 ) , Ready with Nits , IANA , ( 03 - 12 ) , OK ( 03 - 12 ) , 03 - 12 , Nits , ( 03 - 15 ) , Comments and Many nits TO BE DISCUSSED : Security section , ( 04 - 09 ) , decrease authors to 5 ! ! ! reviewed in April 22 meeting" 19850197b1472544a5ae26d63718c2b9c5f1674f 19850197b1472544a5ae26d63718c2b9c5f1674f draft-ietf-detnet-ip 5009ed74341f7ae7bbd4e99b358c9f9c4df07b2c9a48127c851a8e710f660c50 ['5009ed74341f7ae7bbd4e99b358c9f9c4df07b2c9a48127c851a8e710f660c50', '728e0f9af1ee3974df5025feebc2c6e5a13d0f8dbeb6fb0512b1f1155429c7b4'] A "deterministic networking (detnet) is a service that can be offered by a network to detnet flows. detnet provides these flows extremely low packet loss rates and assured maximum end-to-end delivery latency. general background and concepts of detnet can be found in the detnet architecture rfc8655." {} {} {} 85 "Deterministic Networking (DetNet) is a service that can be offered by a network to DetNet flows. DetNet provides these flows with extremely low packet loss rates and assured maximum end-to-end delivery latency. General background and concepts of DetNet can be found in the DetNet Architecture RFC8655." "IESG review comment resolutions in this version : DONE , ( ) , ( 03 - 09 ) , Ready with Nits , IANA , ( 03 - 12 ) , OK ( 03 - 12 ) , 03 - 12 , Nits , ( 03 - 15 ) , Comments and Many nits TO BE DISCUSSED : Security section , ( 04 - 09 ) , decrease authors to 5 ! ! ! reviewed in April 22 meeting" 19850197b1472544a5ae26d63718c2b9c5f1674f 19850197b1472544a5ae26d63718c2b9c5f1674f draft-ietf-detnet-ip 728e0f9af1ee3974df5025feebc2c6e5a13d0f8dbeb6fb0512b1f1155429c7b4 ['5009ed74341f7ae7bbd4e99b358c9f9c4df07b2c9a48127c851a8e710f660c50', '728e0f9af1ee3974df5025feebc2c6e5a13d0f8dbeb6fb0512b1f1155429c7b4'] B "deterministic networking (detnet) is a service that can be offered by a network to detnet flows. detnet provides these flows with extremely low packet loss rates and assured maximum end-to-end delivery latency. general background and concepts of detnet can be found in the detnet architecture rfc8655." {} {} {} 85 "The DetNet Architecture models the DetNet related data plane functions as two sub-layers: a service sub-layer and a forwarding sub-layer. The service sub-layer is used to provide DetNet service protection (e.g., by packet replication and packet elimination functions) and reordering. The forwarding sub-layer is used to provide congestion protection (low loss, assured latency, and limited out-of-order delivery). The service sub-layer generally requires additional fields to provide its service; for example see I-D.ietf- detnet-mpls. Since no DetNet-specific fields are added to support DetNet IP flows, only the forwarding sub-layer functions are supported using the DetNet IP defined by this document. Service protection can be provided on a per sub-net basis using technologies such as MPLS I-D.ietf-detnet-dp-sol-mpls and Ethernet as specified in the IEEE 802.1 TSN task group(referred to in this document simply as IEEE802.1 TSN)." "IESG review comment resolutions in this version : DONE , ( ) , ( 03 - 09 ) , Ready with Nits , IANA , ( 03 - 12 ) , OK ( 03 - 12 ) , 03 - 12 , Nits , ( 03 - 15 ) , Comments and Many nits TO BE DISCUSSED : Security section , ( 04 - 09 ) , decrease authors to 5 ! ! ! reviewed in April 22 meeting" 19850197b1472544a5ae26d63718c2b9c5f1674f 19850197b1472544a5ae26d63718c2b9c5f1674f draft-ietf-detnet-ip 5774ebb3a2e4d46ee8530230b29256391a8e47d5fc0a923fe32c3bc5390092ce ['5774ebb3a2e4d46ee8530230b29256391a8e47d5fc0a923fe32c3bc5390092ce', '9273c0d9e0435a435658aa8061862980973c1e514b296791122df4111393ada7'] A "the detnet architecture models the detnet related data plane functions as two sub-layers: a service sub-layer and a forwarding sub-layer. the service sub-layer is used to provide detnet service protection (e.g., by packet replication and packet elimination functions) and reordering. the forwarding sub-layer is used to provide congestion protection (low loss, assured latency, and limited out-of-order delivery). the service sub-layer generally requires additional fields to provide its service; for example see i-d.ietf- detnet-mpls. since no detnet-specific fields are added to support detnet ip flows, only the forwarding sub-layer functions are supported using the detnet ip defined by this document. service protection can be provided on a per sub-net basis using technologies such as mpls i-d.ietf-detnet-dp-sol-mpls and ethernet as specified in the ieee 802.1 tsn task group(referred to in this document simply as ieee802.1 tsn)." {83: 1} {140: 1} {139, 140} 85 "The DetNet Architecture models the DetNet related data plane functions as two sub-layers: a service sub-layer and a forwarding sub-layer. The service sub-layer is used to provide DetNet service protection (e.g., by packet replication and packet elimination functions) and reordering. The forwarding sub-layer is used to provide congestion protection (low loss, assured latency, and limited out-of-order delivery). The service sub-layer generally requires additional header fields to provide its service; for example see I- D.ietf-detnet-mpls. Since no DetNet-specific fields are added to support DetNet IP flows, only the forwarding sub-layer functions are supported using the DetNet IP defined by this document. Service protection can be provided on a per sub-net basis using technologies such as MPLS I-D.ietf-detnet-dp-sol-mpls and Ethernet as specified in the IEEE 802.1 TSN (Time-Sensitive Networking) task group (referred to in this document simply as IEEE802.1 TSN)." "IESG review comment resolutions in this version : DONE , ( ) , ( 03 - 09 ) , Ready with Nits , IANA , ( 03 - 12 ) , OK ( 03 - 12 ) , 03 - 12 , Nits , ( 03 - 15 ) , Comments and Many nits TO BE DISCUSSED : Security section , ( 04 - 09 ) , decrease authors to 5 ! ! ! reviewed in April 22 meeting" 19850197b1472544a5ae26d63718c2b9c5f1674f 19850197b1472544a5ae26d63718c2b9c5f1674f draft-ietf-detnet-ip 9273c0d9e0435a435658aa8061862980973c1e514b296791122df4111393ada7 ['5774ebb3a2e4d46ee8530230b29256391a8e47d5fc0a923fe32c3bc5390092ce', '9273c0d9e0435a435658aa8061862980973c1e514b296791122df4111393ada7'] B "the detnet architecture models the detnet related data plane functions as two sub-layers: a service sub-layer and a forwarding sub-layer. the service sub-layer is used to provide detnet service protection (e.g., by packet replication and packet elimination functions) and reordering. the forwarding sub-layer is used to provide congestion protection (low loss, assured latency, and limited out-of-order delivery). the service sub-layer generally requires additional header fields to provide its service; for example see i- d.ietf-detnet-mpls. since no detnet-specific fields are added to support detnet ip flows, only the forwarding sub-layer functions are supported using the detnet ip defined by this document. service protection can be provided on a per sub-net basis using technologies such as mpls i-d.ietf-detnet-dp-sol-mpls and ethernet as specified in the ieee 802.1 tsn (time-sensitive networking) task group (referred to in this document simply as ieee802.1 tsn)." {83: 1} {140: 1} {139, 140} 85 "Non-DetNet and DetNet IP packets are identical on the wire. Generally the fields used in flow identification are forwarded unmodified, however modification of these fields is allowed, for example to a DSCP value, when required by the DetNet service." "IESG review comment resolutions in this version : DONE , ( ) , ( 03 - 09 ) , Ready with Nits , IANA , ( 03 - 12 ) , OK ( 03 - 12 ) , 03 - 12 , Nits , ( 03 - 15 ) , Comments and Many nits TO BE DISCUSSED : Security section , ( 04 - 09 ) , decrease authors to 5 ! ! ! reviewed in April 22 meeting" 19850197b1472544a5ae26d63718c2b9c5f1674f 19850197b1472544a5ae26d63718c2b9c5f1674f draft-ietf-detnet-ip c662e732a77494b783169aa979e82bc30b8da0cb91e4ba4d234056eb799f1946 ['c662e732a77494b783169aa979e82bc30b8da0cb91e4ba4d234056eb799f1946', 'a5d212993acd4cecd4b053af9083d57b28a719b5d45c8abf4a19865009312cea', 'fa9f0364c036dd1ff82a1a90e1d811fb27124c4bfd88aff9b7db3cb308fd4136'] A "non-detnet and detnet ip packets are identical on the wire. generally the fields used in flow identification are forwarded unmodified, however modification of these fields is allowed, for example to a dscp value, when required by the detnet service." {102: 1, 62: 1, 56: 2, 60: 3, 85: 2} {38: 1, 282: 1, 368: 2, 146: 3, 189: 3, 190: 2} {38, 368, 146, 312, 282, 189, 190} 85 "For some of the protocols 5-tuples and 6-tuples cannot be used because the port information is not available (e.g., ICMP, IPSec ESP). Same can be valid for flow aggregates. In such cases using smaller tuples are appropriate, e.g., a 3-tuple (2 IP addresses, IP protocol) or even a 2-tuple (all IP traffic between two IP addresses)." "IESG review comment resolutions in this version : DONE , ( ) , ( 03 - 09 ) , Ready with Nits , IANA , ( 03 - 12 ) , OK ( 03 - 12 ) , 03 - 12 , Nits , ( 03 - 15 ) , Comments and Many nits TO BE DISCUSSED : Security section , ( 04 - 09 ) , decrease authors to 5 ! ! ! reviewed in April 22 meeting" 19850197b1472544a5ae26d63718c2b9c5f1674f 19850197b1472544a5ae26d63718c2b9c5f1674f draft-ietf-detnet-ip a5d212993acd4cecd4b053af9083d57b28a719b5d45c8abf4a19865009312cea ['c662e732a77494b783169aa979e82bc30b8da0cb91e4ba4d234056eb799f1946', 'a5d212993acd4cecd4b053af9083d57b28a719b5d45c8abf4a19865009312cea', 'fa9f0364c036dd1ff82a1a90e1d811fb27124c4bfd88aff9b7db3cb308fd4136'] B "for some of the protocols 5-tuples and 6-tuples cannot be used because the port information is not available (e.g., icmp, ipsec esp). same can be valid for flow aggregates. in such cases using smaller tuples are appropriate, e.g., a 3-tuple (2 ip addresses, ip protocol) or even a 2-tuple (all ip traffic between two ip addresses)." {102: 1, 62: 1, 56: 2, 60: 3, 85: 2} {38: 1, 282: 1, 368: 2, 146: 3, 189: 3, 190: 2} {38, 368, 146, 312, 282, 189, 190} 85 "Non-DetNet and DetNet IP packets are identical on the wire. Generally the fields used in flow identification are forwarded unmodified, however modification of these fields is allowed, for example changing the DSCP value, when required by the DetNet service." "IESG review comment resolutions in this version : DONE , ( ) , ( 03 - 09 ) , Ready with Nits , IANA , ( 03 - 12 ) , OK ( 03 - 12 ) , 03 - 12 , Nits , ( 03 - 15 ) , Comments and Many nits TO BE DISCUSSED : Security section , ( 04 - 09 ) , decrease authors to 5 ! ! ! reviewed in April 22 meeting" 19850197b1472544a5ae26d63718c2b9c5f1674f 19850197b1472544a5ae26d63718c2b9c5f1674f draft-ietf-detnet-ip fa9f0364c036dd1ff82a1a90e1d811fb27124c4bfd88aff9b7db3cb308fd4136 ['c662e732a77494b783169aa979e82bc30b8da0cb91e4ba4d234056eb799f1946', 'a5d212993acd4cecd4b053af9083d57b28a719b5d45c8abf4a19865009312cea', 'fa9f0364c036dd1ff82a1a90e1d811fb27124c4bfd88aff9b7db3cb308fd4136'] B "non-detnet and detnet ip packets are identical on the wire. generally the fields used in flow identification are forwarded unmodified, however modification of these fields is allowed, for example changing the dscp value, when required by the detnet service." {102: 1, 62: 1, 56: 2, 60: 3, 85: 2} {38: 1, 282: 1, 368: 2, 146: 3, 189: 3, 190: 2} {38, 368, 146, 312, 282, 189, 190} 85 "fig_ip_detnet_simple illustrates a DetNet enabled IP network. The DetNet enabled end systems originate IP encapsulated traffic those are identified within the DetNet domain as DetNet flows, relay nodes understand the forwarding requirements of the DetNet flow and ensure that node, interface and sub-network resources are allocated to ensure DetNet service requirements. The dotted line around the Service component of the Relay Nodes indicates that the transit routers are DetNet service aware but do not perform any DetNet service sub-layer function, e.g., PREOF." "IESG review comment resolutions in this version : DONE , ( ) , ( 03 - 09 ) , Ready with Nits , IANA , ( 03 - 12 ) , OK ( 03 - 12 ) , 03 - 12 , Nits , ( 03 - 15 ) , Comments and Many nits TO BE DISCUSSED : Security section , ( 04 - 09 ) , decrease authors to 5 ! ! ! reviewed in April 22 meeting" 19850197b1472544a5ae26d63718c2b9c5f1674f 19850197b1472544a5ae26d63718c2b9c5f1674f draft-ietf-detnet-ip bc223456b83ca093e95c05a524f7fa0b165befad636a47e6a204eba7817a46fd ['7ad17d56f09aaf8411c8e206ecc1b70bb21e3246d3c5514cfacf5aa46d8b2048', 'bc223456b83ca093e95c05a524f7fa0b165befad636a47e6a204eba7817a46fd'] A "fig_ip_detnet_simple illustrates a detnet enabled ip network. the detnet enabled end systems originate ip encapsulated traffic those are identified within the detnet domain as detnet flows, relay nodes understand the forwarding requirements of the detnet flow and ensure that node, interface and sub-network resources are allocated to ensure detnet service requirements. the dotted line around the service component of the relay nodes indicates that the transit routers are detnet service aware but do not perform any detnet service sub-layer function, e.g., preof." {102: 1, 62: 1, 56: 2, 60: 3, 85: 2} {189: 1, 282: 1, 38: 3, 368: 2, 146: 3, 312: 2} {38, 368, 146, 312, 282, 189, 190} 85 "fig_ip_detnet_simple illustrates a DetNet enabled IP network. The DetNet enabled end systems originate IP encapsulated traffic that is identified within the DetNet domain as DetNet flows. Relay nodes understand the forwarding requirements of the DetNet flow and ensure that node, interface and sub-network resources are allocated to ensure DetNet service requirements. The dotted line around the Service component of the Relay Nodes indicates that the transit routers are DetNet service aware but do not perform any DetNet service sub-layer function, e.g., PREOF (Packet Replication, Elimination and Ordering Function)." "IESG review comment resolutions in this version : DONE , ( ) , ( 03 - 09 ) , Ready with Nits , IANA , ( 03 - 12 ) , OK ( 03 - 12 ) , 03 - 12 , Nits , ( 03 - 15 ) , Comments and Many nits TO BE DISCUSSED : Security section , ( 04 - 09 ) , decrease authors to 5 ! ! ! reviewed in April 22 meeting" 19850197b1472544a5ae26d63718c2b9c5f1674f 19850197b1472544a5ae26d63718c2b9c5f1674f draft-ietf-detnet-ip 7ad17d56f09aaf8411c8e206ecc1b70bb21e3246d3c5514cfacf5aa46d8b2048 ['7ad17d56f09aaf8411c8e206ecc1b70bb21e3246d3c5514cfacf5aa46d8b2048', 'bc223456b83ca093e95c05a524f7fa0b165befad636a47e6a204eba7817a46fd'] B "fig_ip_detnet_simple illustrates a detnet enabled ip network. the detnet enabled end systems originate ip encapsulated traffic that is identified within the detnet domain as detnet flows. relay nodes understand the forwarding requirements of the detnet flow and ensure that node, interface and sub-network resources are allocated to ensure detnet service requirements. the dotted line around the service component of the relay nodes indicates that the transit routers are detnet service aware but do not perform any detnet service sub-layer function, e.g., preof (packet replication, elimination and ordering function)." {102: 1, 62: 1, 56: 2, 60: 3, 85: 2} {189: 1, 282: 1, 38: 3, 368: 2, 146: 3, 312: 2} {38, 368, 146, 312, 282, 189, 190} 85 "As non-DetNet and DetNet IP packets are identical on the wire, from data plane perspective, the only difference is that there is flow- associated DetNet information on each DetNet node that defines the flow related characteristics and required forwarding behavior. As shown above, edge nodes provide a Service Proxy function that ""associates"" one or more IP flows with the appropriate DetNet flow- specific information and ensures that the receives the proper traffic treatment within the domain." "IESG review comment resolutions in this version : DONE , ( ) , ( 03 - 09 ) , Ready with Nits , IANA , ( 03 - 12 ) , OK ( 03 - 12 ) , 03 - 12 , Nits , ( 03 - 15 ) , Comments and Many nits TO BE DISCUSSED : Security section , ( 04 - 09 ) , decrease authors to 5 ! ! ! reviewed in April 22 meeting" 19850197b1472544a5ae26d63718c2b9c5f1674f 19850197b1472544a5ae26d63718c2b9c5f1674f draft-ietf-detnet-ip 19e5c260c02d6a258e0c900a28dfa2d136b991f72c68eafe6dc83852406ad1c9 ['19e5c260c02d6a258e0c900a28dfa2d136b991f72c68eafe6dc83852406ad1c9', '96370dbc25c3f1e0e6f0205251af1a317f2d7d8ec612c52a59ce076bcafdd9a7'] A "as non-detnet and detnet ip packets are identical on the wire, from data plane perspective, the only difference is that there is flow- associated detnet information on each detnet node that defines the flow related characteristics and required forwarding behavior. as shown above, edge nodes provide a service proxy function that ""associates"" one or more ip flows with the appropriate detnet flow- specific information and ensures that the receives the proper traffic treatment within the domain." {62: 1, 102: 1, 6: 3, 79: 5, 90: 3, 51: 2, 130: 3, 68: 3, 35: 6, 110: 6, 91: 8, 114: 6, 97: 4, 31: 4, 13: 2, 67: 5, 38: 7, 26: 2, 124: 3, 98: 5, 54: 5, 127: 6, 8: 3, 96: 3, 64: 5, 30: 6, 61: 8, 55: 2, 27: 4, 15: 6, 52: 4, 129: 6, 115: 6, 84: 3, 76: 6, 87: 6, 131: 8, 113: 8, 99: 5, 36: 6, 24: 5, 53: 4, 72: 7} {25: 1, 320: 1, 1: 8, 4: 5, 9: 5, 10: 6, 15: 5, 24: 5, 27: 5, 39: 4, 43: 6, 49: 9, 50: 8, 58: 8, 59: 5, 64: 5, 69: 4, 81: 2, 82: 2, 86: 6, 96: 7, 97: 6, 100: 5, 108: 6, 109: 7, 110: 7, 111: 5, 114: 6, 115: 7, 116: 4, 118: 3, 119: 2, 120: 6, 121: 3, 122: 4, 123: 3, 124: 3, 128: 7, 129: 6, 130: 8, 132: 4, 136: 5, 145: 4, 147: 7, 151: 7, 152: 7, 154: 6, 156: 4, 161: 3, 162: 2, 165: 6, 168: 7, 169: 6, 172: 6, 180: 7, 184: 5, 187: 8, 188: 7, 191: 6, 194: 4, 202: 5, 203: 6, 206: 5, 207: 6, 215: 4, 217: 6, 218: 7, 220: 3, 221: 3, 222: 4, 224: 6, 227: 3, 229: 6, 234: 8, 235: 5, 241: 5, 242: 5, 243: 4, 244: 7, 245: 4, 248: 7, 250: 6, 258: 10, 262: 7, 263: 8, 264: 4, 267: 3, 270: 5, 272: 6, 273: 5, 287: 6, 289: 6, 291: 8, 299: 3, 300: 5, 304: 5, 309: 3, 314: 5, 315: 6, 323: 4, 327: 7, 328: 5, 329: 5, 330: 9, 334: 5, 335: 4, 341: 3, 342: 4, 347: 3, 348: 3, 350: 7, 351: 8, 352: 6, 353: 6, 354: 5, 358: 3, 365: 6, 366: 5, 369: 4, 371: 5, 372: 8, 376: 5, 384: 8, 385: 7, 386: 6, 387: 5, 392: 5, 393: 6, 396: 4, 397: 6, 398: 5, 402: 6} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 85 "As non-DetNet and DetNet IP packets are identical on the wire, from data plane perspective, the only difference is that there is flow- associated DetNet information on each DetNet node that defines the flow related characteristics and required forwarding behavior. As shown above, edge nodes provide a Service Proxy function that ""associates"" one or more IP flows with the appropriate DetNet flow- specific information and ensures that the flow receives the proper traffic treatment within the domain." "IESG review comment resolutions in this version : DONE , ( ) , ( 03 - 09 ) , Ready with Nits , IANA , ( 03 - 12 ) , OK ( 03 - 12 ) , 03 - 12 , Nits , ( 03 - 15 ) , Comments and Many nits TO BE DISCUSSED : Security section , ( 04 - 09 ) , decrease authors to 5 ! ! ! reviewed in April 22 meeting" 19850197b1472544a5ae26d63718c2b9c5f1674f 19850197b1472544a5ae26d63718c2b9c5f1674f draft-ietf-detnet-ip 96370dbc25c3f1e0e6f0205251af1a317f2d7d8ec612c52a59ce076bcafdd9a7 ['19e5c260c02d6a258e0c900a28dfa2d136b991f72c68eafe6dc83852406ad1c9', '96370dbc25c3f1e0e6f0205251af1a317f2d7d8ec612c52a59ce076bcafdd9a7'] B "as non-detnet and detnet ip packets are identical on the wire, from data plane perspective, the only difference is that there is flow- associated detnet information on each detnet node that defines the flow related characteristics and required forwarding behavior. as shown above, edge nodes provide a service proxy function that ""associates"" one or more ip flows with the appropriate detnet flow- specific information and ensures that the flow receives the proper traffic treatment within the domain." {62: 1, 102: 1, 6: 3, 79: 5, 90: 3, 51: 2, 130: 3, 68: 3, 35: 6, 110: 6, 91: 8, 114: 6, 97: 4, 31: 4, 13: 2, 67: 5, 38: 7, 26: 2, 124: 3, 98: 5, 54: 5, 127: 6, 8: 3, 96: 3, 64: 5, 30: 6, 61: 8, 55: 2, 27: 4, 15: 6, 52: 4, 129: 6, 115: 6, 84: 3, 76: 6, 87: 6, 131: 8, 113: 8, 99: 5, 36: 6, 24: 5, 53: 4, 72: 7} {25: 1, 320: 1, 1: 8, 4: 5, 9: 5, 10: 6, 15: 5, 24: 5, 27: 5, 39: 4, 43: 6, 49: 9, 50: 8, 58: 8, 59: 5, 64: 5, 69: 4, 81: 2, 82: 2, 86: 6, 96: 7, 97: 6, 100: 5, 108: 6, 109: 7, 110: 7, 111: 5, 114: 6, 115: 7, 116: 4, 118: 3, 119: 2, 120: 6, 121: 3, 122: 4, 123: 3, 124: 3, 128: 7, 129: 6, 130: 8, 132: 4, 136: 5, 145: 4, 147: 7, 151: 7, 152: 7, 154: 6, 156: 4, 161: 3, 162: 2, 165: 6, 168: 7, 169: 6, 172: 6, 180: 7, 184: 5, 187: 8, 188: 7, 191: 6, 194: 4, 202: 5, 203: 6, 206: 5, 207: 6, 215: 4, 217: 6, 218: 7, 220: 3, 221: 3, 222: 4, 224: 6, 227: 3, 229: 6, 234: 8, 235: 5, 241: 5, 242: 5, 243: 4, 244: 7, 245: 4, 248: 7, 250: 6, 258: 10, 262: 7, 263: 8, 264: 4, 267: 3, 270: 5, 272: 6, 273: 5, 287: 6, 289: 6, 291: 8, 299: 3, 300: 5, 304: 5, 309: 3, 314: 5, 315: 6, 323: 4, 327: 7, 328: 5, 329: 5, 330: 9, 334: 5, 335: 4, 341: 3, 342: 4, 347: 3, 348: 3, 350: 7, 351: 8, 352: 6, 353: 6, 354: 5, 358: 3, 365: 6, 366: 5, 369: 4, 371: 5, 372: 8, 376: 5, 384: 8, 385: 7, 386: 6, 387: 5, 392: 5, 393: 6, 396: 4, 397: 6, 398: 5, 402: 6} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 85 "Class of Service (CoS) for DetNet flows carried in IPv4 and IPv6 is provided using the standard differentiated services code point (DSCP) field RFC2474 and related mechanisms." "IESG review comment resolutions in this version : DONE , ( ) , ( 03 - 09 ) , Ready with Nits , IANA , ( 03 - 12 ) , OK ( 03 - 12 ) , 03 - 12 , Nits , ( 03 - 15 ) , Comments and Many nits TO BE DISCUSSED : Security section , ( 04 - 09 ) , decrease authors to 5 ! ! ! reviewed in April 22 meeting" 19850197b1472544a5ae26d63718c2b9c5f1674f 19850197b1472544a5ae26d63718c2b9c5f1674f draft-ietf-detnet-ip 3add340149843f427e7c57ed2472db19f5c803047cd5b77d34b24e81da1ed4da ['3add340149843f427e7c57ed2472db19f5c803047cd5b77d34b24e81da1ed4da', '453e255aa9012a88bc922462eaac7aa5b9c62aa900c1dfdb50bdc8cd60c35fc2'] A "class of service (cos) for detnet flows carried in ipv4 and ipv6 is provided using the standard differentiated services code point (dscp) field rfc2474 and related mechanisms." {83: 1, 60: 2} {311: 1, 310: 2} {90, 310, 311} 85 "Class of Service (CoS) for DetNet flows carried in IPv4 and IPv6 is provided using the standard differentiated services (DSCP) field RFC2474 and related mechanisms." "IESG review comment resolutions in this version : DONE , ( ) , ( 03 - 09 ) , Ready with Nits , IANA , ( 03 - 12 ) , OK ( 03 - 12 ) , 03 - 12 , Nits , ( 03 - 15 ) , Comments and Many nits TO BE DISCUSSED : Security section , ( 04 - 09 ) , decrease authors to 5 ! ! ! reviewed in April 22 meeting" 19850197b1472544a5ae26d63718c2b9c5f1674f 19850197b1472544a5ae26d63718c2b9c5f1674f draft-ietf-detnet-ip 453e255aa9012a88bc922462eaac7aa5b9c62aa900c1dfdb50bdc8cd60c35fc2 ['3add340149843f427e7c57ed2472db19f5c803047cd5b77d34b24e81da1ed4da', '453e255aa9012a88bc922462eaac7aa5b9c62aa900c1dfdb50bdc8cd60c35fc2'] B "class of service (cos) for detnet flows carried in ipv4 and ipv6 is provided using the standard differentiated services (dscp) field rfc2474 and related mechanisms." {83: 1, 60: 2} {311: 1, 310: 2} {90, 310, 311} 85 "Quality of Service (QoS) for DetNet service flows carried in IP MUST be provided locally by the DetNet-aware hosts and routers supporting DetNet flows. Such support leverages the underlying network layer such as 802.1 TSN. The traffic control mechanisms used to deliver QoS for IP encapsulated DetNet flows are expected to be defined in a future document. From an encapsulation perspective, the combination of the 6-tuple i.e., the typical 5-tuple enhanced with the DSCP and previously mentioned optional field, uniquely identifies a DetNet IP flow." "IESG review comment resolutions in this version : DONE , ( ) , ( 03 - 09 ) , Ready with Nits , IANA , ( 03 - 12 ) , OK ( 03 - 12 ) , 03 - 12 , Nits , ( 03 - 15 ) , Comments and Many nits TO BE DISCUSSED : Security section , ( 04 - 09 ) , decrease authors to 5 ! ! ! reviewed in April 22 meeting" 19850197b1472544a5ae26d63718c2b9c5f1674f 19850197b1472544a5ae26d63718c2b9c5f1674f draft-ietf-detnet-ip 1a4313a692ef4eb515b22ce44c07bfedbc982a29efb8c4017f66c0a450037bf6 ['1a4313a692ef4eb515b22ce44c07bfedbc982a29efb8c4017f66c0a450037bf6', 'fb8ec162cc7e7d2c80120b876b4280b6994799d3e32f9dbba306ef0fe5af2b85'] A "quality of service (qos) for detnet service flows carried in ip must be provided locally by the detnet-aware hosts and routers supporting detnet flows. such support leverages the underlying network layer such as 802.1 tsn. the traffic control mechanisms used to deliver qos for ip encapsulated detnet flows are expected to be defined in a future document. from an encapsulation perspective, the combination of the 6-tuple i.e., the typical 5-tuple enhanced with the dscp and previously mentioned optional field, uniquely identifies a detnet ip flow." {102: 1} {404: 1} {404, 28} 85 "Quality of Service (QoS) for DetNet service flows carried in IP MUST be provided locally by the DetNet-aware hosts and routers supporting DetNet flows. Such support leverages the underlying network layer such as 802.1 TSN. The traffic control mechanisms used to deliver QoS for IP encapsulated DetNet flows are expected to be defined in a future document. From an encapsulation perspective, the combination of the 6-tuple i.e., the typical 5-tuple enhanced with the DSCP and previously mentioned optional field (i.e., flow label), uniquely identifies a DetNet IP flow." "IESG review comment resolutions in this version : DONE , ( ) , ( 03 - 09 ) , Ready with Nits , IANA , ( 03 - 12 ) , OK ( 03 - 12 ) , 03 - 12 , Nits , ( 03 - 15 ) , Comments and Many nits TO BE DISCUSSED : Security section , ( 04 - 09 ) , decrease authors to 5 ! ! ! reviewed in April 22 meeting" 19850197b1472544a5ae26d63718c2b9c5f1674f 19850197b1472544a5ae26d63718c2b9c5f1674f draft-ietf-detnet-ip fb8ec162cc7e7d2c80120b876b4280b6994799d3e32f9dbba306ef0fe5af2b85 ['1a4313a692ef4eb515b22ce44c07bfedbc982a29efb8c4017f66c0a450037bf6', 'fb8ec162cc7e7d2c80120b876b4280b6994799d3e32f9dbba306ef0fe5af2b85'] B "quality of service (qos) for detnet service flows carried in ip must be provided locally by the detnet-aware hosts and routers supporting detnet flows. such support leverages the underlying network layer such as 802.1 tsn. the traffic control mechanisms used to deliver qos for ip encapsulated detnet flows are expected to be defined in a future document. from an encapsulation perspective, the combination of the 6-tuple i.e., the typical 5-tuple enhanced with the dscp and previously mentioned optional field (i.e., flow label), uniquely identifies a detnet ip flow." {102: 1} {404: 1} {404, 28} 85 "Remarking packets associated with an incomplete reservation. Remarking can be accomplished by changing the value of the DSCP, or optional, field to a value that results in the packet no longer matching any other reserved DetNet IP flow." "IESG review comment resolutions in this version : DONE , ( ) , ( 03 - 09 ) , Ready with Nits , IANA , ( 03 - 12 ) , OK ( 03 - 12 ) , 03 - 12 , Nits , ( 03 - 15 ) , Comments and Many nits TO BE DISCUSSED : Security section , ( 04 - 09 ) , decrease authors to 5 ! ! ! reviewed in April 22 meeting" 19850197b1472544a5ae26d63718c2b9c5f1674f 19850197b1472544a5ae26d63718c2b9c5f1674f draft-ietf-detnet-ip 25d6493bc0674a3775f585c003b933b5a64aead4247a88b9474dfbce77aab51b ['38ab1cd1c2c3e41a33199b148948215d34f10bce326756d7f6ffbfa065623c6d', '25d6493bc0674a3775f585c003b933b5a64aead4247a88b9474dfbce77aab51b'] A "remarking packets associated with an incomplete reservation. remarking can be accomplished by changing the value of the dscp, or optional, field to a value that results in the packet no longer matching any other reserved detnet ip flow." {102: 1} {85: 1} {84, 85} 85 "Remarking packets associated with an incomplete reservation. Remarking can be accomplished by changing the value of the DSCP field to a value that results in the packet no longer matching any other reserved DetNet IP flow." "IESG review comment resolutions in this version : DONE , ( ) , ( 03 - 09 ) , Ready with Nits , IANA , ( 03 - 12 ) , OK ( 03 - 12 ) , 03 - 12 , Nits , ( 03 - 15 ) , Comments and Many nits TO BE DISCUSSED : Security section , ( 04 - 09 ) , decrease authors to 5 ! ! ! reviewed in April 22 meeting" 19850197b1472544a5ae26d63718c2b9c5f1674f 19850197b1472544a5ae26d63718c2b9c5f1674f draft-ietf-detnet-ip 38ab1cd1c2c3e41a33199b148948215d34f10bce326756d7f6ffbfa065623c6d ['38ab1cd1c2c3e41a33199b148948215d34f10bce326756d7f6ffbfa065623c6d', '25d6493bc0674a3775f585c003b933b5a64aead4247a88b9474dfbce77aab51b'] B "remarking packets associated with an incomplete reservation. remarking can be accomplished by changing the value of the dscp field to a value that results in the packet no longer matching any other reserved detnet ip flow." {102: 1} {85: 1} {84, 85} 85 "From a single node perspective, the aggregation of IP flows impacts DetNet IP data plane flow identification and resource allocation. As discussed above, IP flow identification uses the IP ""6-tuple"" for flow identification. DetNet IP flows can be aggregated using any of the 6-tuple, and an additional optional field defined in ip-flow-id. The use of prefixes, wildcards, lists, and value ranges allows a DetNet node to identify aggregate DetNet flows. From a resource allocation perspective, DetNet nodes must provide service to an aggregate and not on a component flow basis." "IESG review comment resolutions in this version : DONE , ( ) , ( 03 - 09 ) , Ready with Nits , IANA , ( 03 - 12 ) , OK ( 03 - 12 ) , 03 - 12 , Nits , ( 03 - 15 ) , Comments and Many nits TO BE DISCUSSED : Security section , ( 04 - 09 ) , decrease authors to 5 ! ! ! reviewed in April 22 meeting" 19850197b1472544a5ae26d63718c2b9c5f1674f 19850197b1472544a5ae26d63718c2b9c5f1674f draft-ietf-detnet-ip 022dbf3e563362d3bccd8237bc1e6bd94ea908b9e7f290e48813addfb360b444 ['a00162f89fba8d9cdb51e4693965c3a2b2020cfd3922aa95b3f95dcb03bccfc5', '022dbf3e563362d3bccd8237bc1e6bd94ea908b9e7f290e48813addfb360b444'] A "from a single node perspective, the aggregation of ip flows impacts detnet ip data plane flow identification and resource allocation. as discussed above, ip flow identification uses the ip ""6-tuple"" for flow identification. detnet ip flows can be aggregated using any of the 6-tuple, and an additional optional field defined in ip-flow-id. the use of prefixes, wildcards, lists, and value ranges allows a detnet node to identify aggregate detnet flows. from a resource allocation perspective, detnet nodes must provide service to an aggregate and not on a component flow basis." {62: 1, 102: 1, 26: 2, 27: 3, 60: 2, 13: 3, 56: 3} {370: 1, 359: 1, 160: 2, 259: 3, 52: 2, 284: 3, 159: 3} {160, 259, 359, 370, 52, 246, 284, 159} 85 "From a single node perspective, the aggregation of IP flows impacts DetNet IP data plane flow identification and resource allocation. As discussed above, IP flow identification uses the IP ""6-tuple"" for flow identification. DetNet IP flows can be aggregated using any of the 6-tuple, and an additional optional field (i.e., flow label). The use of prefixes, wildcards, lists, and value ranges allows a DetNet node to identify aggregate DetNet flows. From a resource allocation perspective, DetNet nodes ought to provide service to an aggregate rather than on a component flow basis." "IESG review comment resolutions in this version : DONE , ( ) , ( 03 - 09 ) , Ready with Nits , IANA , ( 03 - 12 ) , OK ( 03 - 12 ) , 03 - 12 , Nits , ( 03 - 15 ) , Comments and Many nits TO BE DISCUSSED : Security section , ( 04 - 09 ) , decrease authors to 5 ! ! ! reviewed in April 22 meeting" 19850197b1472544a5ae26d63718c2b9c5f1674f 19850197b1472544a5ae26d63718c2b9c5f1674f draft-ietf-detnet-ip a00162f89fba8d9cdb51e4693965c3a2b2020cfd3922aa95b3f95dcb03bccfc5 ['a00162f89fba8d9cdb51e4693965c3a2b2020cfd3922aa95b3f95dcb03bccfc5', '022dbf3e563362d3bccd8237bc1e6bd94ea908b9e7f290e48813addfb360b444'] B "from a single node perspective, the aggregation of ip flows impacts detnet ip data plane flow identification and resource allocation. as discussed above, ip flow identification uses the ip ""6-tuple"" for flow identification. detnet ip flows can be aggregated using any of the 6-tuple, and an additional optional field (i.e., flow label). the use of prefixes, wildcards, lists, and value ranges allows a detnet node to identify aggregate detnet flows. from a resource allocation perspective, detnet nodes ought to provide service to an aggregate rather than on a component flow basis." {62: 1, 102: 1, 26: 2, 27: 3, 60: 2, 13: 3, 56: 3} {370: 1, 359: 1, 160: 2, 259: 3, 52: 2, 284: 3, 159: 3} {160, 259, 359, 370, 52, 246, 284, 159} 85 "DetNet IP data plane establishment and operational procedures also have requirements on the control and management systems for DetNet flows and these are referred in this section. Specifically this section identifies a number of information elements that require support via the management and control interfaces supported by a DetNet node. The specific mechanism used for such support is out of the scope of this document. A summary of the requirements for management and control related information is included. Conformance language is not used in the summary since applies to future mechanisms such as those that may be provided in YANG models I- D.ietf-detnet-yang." "IESG review comment resolutions in this version : DONE , ( ) , ( 03 - 09 ) , Ready with Nits , IANA , ( 03 - 12 ) , OK ( 03 - 12 ) , 03 - 12 , Nits , ( 03 - 15 ) , Comments and Many nits TO BE DISCUSSED : Security section , ( 04 - 09 ) , decrease authors to 5 ! ! ! reviewed in April 22 meeting" 19850197b1472544a5ae26d63718c2b9c5f1674f 19850197b1472544a5ae26d63718c2b9c5f1674f draft-ietf-detnet-ip c051e448752705e60dfb2ff59cd3fcc726a5b73594c382fd38ba1b106dc7110b ['1c45beec760e6940f7a17b4b47b62ee06cd4eb667494b77da3d8335385af158f', 'c051e448752705e60dfb2ff59cd3fcc726a5b73594c382fd38ba1b106dc7110b'] A "detnet ip data plane establishment and operational procedures also have requirements on the control and management systems for detnet flows and these are referred in this section. specifically this section identifies a number of information elements that require support via the management and control interfaces supported by a detnet node. the specific mechanism used for such support is out of the scope of this document. a summary of the requirements for management and control related information is included. conformance language is not used in the summary since applies to future mechanisms such as those that may be provided in yang models i- d.ietf-detnet-yang." {13: 1} {285: 1} {285, 30} 85 "DetNet IP data plane establishment and operational procedures also have requirements on the control and management systems for DetNet flows and these are referred to in this section. Specifically this section identifies a number of information elements that require support via the management and control interfaces supported by a DetNet node. The specific mechanism used for such support is out of the scope of this document. A summary of the requirements for management and control related information is included. Conformance language is not used in the summary since it applies to future mechanisms such as those that may be provided in YANG models I- D.ietf-detnet-yang." "IESG review comment resolutions in this version : DONE , ( ) , ( 03 - 09 ) , Ready with Nits , IANA , ( 03 - 12 ) , OK ( 03 - 12 ) , 03 - 12 , Nits , ( 03 - 15 ) , Comments and Many nits TO BE DISCUSSED : Security section , ( 04 - 09 ) , decrease authors to 5 ! ! ! reviewed in April 22 meeting" 19850197b1472544a5ae26d63718c2b9c5f1674f 19850197b1472544a5ae26d63718c2b9c5f1674f draft-ietf-detnet-ip 1c45beec760e6940f7a17b4b47b62ee06cd4eb667494b77da3d8335385af158f ['1c45beec760e6940f7a17b4b47b62ee06cd4eb667494b77da3d8335385af158f', 'c051e448752705e60dfb2ff59cd3fcc726a5b73594c382fd38ba1b106dc7110b'] B "detnet ip data plane establishment and operational procedures also have requirements on the control and management systems for detnet flows and these are referred to in this section. specifically this section identifies a number of information elements that require support via the management and control interfaces supported by a detnet node. the specific mechanism used for such support is out of the scope of this document. a summary of the requirements for management and control related information is included. conformance language is not used in the summary since it applies to future mechanisms such as those that may be provided in yang models i- d.ietf-detnet-yang." {13: 1} {285: 1} {285, 30} 85 "Implementations of this document MUST support DetNet flow identification based on header information identified in this section. Support for TCP, UDP and IPsec flows is defined. Future documents are expected to define support for other protocols." "IESG review comment resolutions in this version : DONE , ( ) , ( 03 - 09 ) , Ready with Nits , IANA , ( 03 - 12 ) , OK ( 03 - 12 ) , 03 - 12 , Nits , ( 03 - 15 ) , Comments and Many nits TO BE DISCUSSED : Security section , ( 04 - 09 ) , decrease authors to 5 ! ! ! reviewed in April 22 meeting" 19850197b1472544a5ae26d63718c2b9c5f1674f 19850197b1472544a5ae26d63718c2b9c5f1674f draft-ietf-detnet-ip 33ffb013c57fd6cba987412277aca210ae444af0240acbacb08274a493e78a8e ['33ffb013c57fd6cba987412277aca210ae444af0240acbacb08274a493e78a8e', '6a420c1d8fa1ff3c3e6c1903c114d41ab8add7e1008d0d2d916a452e28a62ac1'] A "implementations of this document must support detnet flow identification based on header information identified in this section. support for tcp, udp and ipsec flows is defined. future documents are expected to define support for other protocols." {} {} {} 85 "Implementations of this document MUST support DetNet flow identification based on header information identified in this section. Support for TCP, UDP, ICMP and IPsec flows is defined. Future documents are expected to define support for other protocols." "IESG review comment resolutions in this version : DONE , ( ) , ( 03 - 09 ) , Ready with Nits , IANA , ( 03 - 12 ) , OK ( 03 - 12 ) , 03 - 12 , Nits , ( 03 - 15 ) , Comments and Many nits TO BE DISCUSSED : Security section , ( 04 - 09 ) , decrease authors to 5 ! ! ! reviewed in April 22 meeting" 19850197b1472544a5ae26d63718c2b9c5f1674f 19850197b1472544a5ae26d63718c2b9c5f1674f draft-ietf-detnet-ip 6a420c1d8fa1ff3c3e6c1903c114d41ab8add7e1008d0d2d916a452e28a62ac1 ['33ffb013c57fd6cba987412277aca210ae444af0240acbacb08274a493e78a8e', '6a420c1d8fa1ff3c3e6c1903c114d41ab8add7e1008d0d2d916a452e28a62ac1'] B "implementations of this document must support detnet flow identification based on header information identified in this section. support for tcp, udp, icmp and ipsec flows is defined. future documents are expected to define support for other protocols." {} {} {} 85 "DetNet flow identification for ICMP is achieved based on the protocol's header. Note that ICMP type is not included in the flow definition." "IESG review comment resolutions in this version : DONE , ( ) , ( 03 - 09 ) , Ready with Nits , IANA , ( 03 - 12 ) , OK ( 03 - 12 ) , 03 - 12 , Nits , ( 03 - 15 ) , Comments and Many nits TO BE DISCUSSED : Security section , ( 04 - 09 ) , decrease authors to 5 ! ! ! reviewed in April 22 meeting" 19850197b1472544a5ae26d63718c2b9c5f1674f 19850197b1472544a5ae26d63718c2b9c5f1674f draft-ietf-detnet-ip 727a4cc4bc1da20d6546d2a5332714a535a5e9f8a6436a8e33912f1946047719 ['727a4cc4bc1da20d6546d2a5332714a535a5e9f8a6436a8e33912f1946047719'] B "detnet flow identification for icmp is achieved based on the protocol's header. note that icmp type is not included in the flow definition." {102: 1} {179: 1} {178, 179} 85 "detnet-ip-over-tsn. Other than in the TSN case, the specific mechanisms used by a DetNet node to ensure DetNet service delivery requirements are met for supported DetNet flows is outside the scope of this document." "IESG review comment resolutions in this version : DONE , ( ) , ( 03 - 09 ) , Ready with Nits , IANA , ( 03 - 12 ) , OK ( 03 - 12 ) , 03 - 12 , Nits , ( 03 - 15 ) , Comments and Many nits TO BE DISCUSSED : Security section , ( 04 - 09 ) , decrease authors to 5 ! ! ! reviewed in April 22 meeting" 19850197b1472544a5ae26d63718c2b9c5f1674f 19850197b1472544a5ae26d63718c2b9c5f1674f draft-ietf-detnet-ip e5b806fb61212a06a2e5cdd89197696b07828b656dd0ab5262f5d6d003b746c8 ['e5b806fb61212a06a2e5cdd89197696b07828b656dd0ab5262f5d6d003b746c8', 'c790fb0c1e33536501ceb4798553e270d2404457ac00ef2f7499fccde7cc82ea'] A "detnet-ip-over-tsn. other than in the tsn case, the specific mechanisms used by a detnet node to ensure detnet service delivery requirements are met for supported detnet flows is outside the scope of this document." {} {} {} 85 "detnet-ip-over-tsn. Other mechanisms than the ones used in the TSN case are outside the scope of this document." "IESG review comment resolutions in this version : DONE , ( ) , ( 03 - 09 ) , Ready with Nits , IANA , ( 03 - 12 ) , OK ( 03 - 12 ) , 03 - 12 , Nits , ( 03 - 15 ) , Comments and Many nits TO BE DISCUSSED : Security section , ( 04 - 09 ) , decrease authors to 5 ! ! ! reviewed in April 22 meeting" 19850197b1472544a5ae26d63718c2b9c5f1674f 19850197b1472544a5ae26d63718c2b9c5f1674f draft-ietf-detnet-ip c790fb0c1e33536501ceb4798553e270d2404457ac00ef2f7499fccde7cc82ea ['e5b806fb61212a06a2e5cdd89197696b07828b656dd0ab5262f5d6d003b746c8', 'c790fb0c1e33536501ceb4798553e270d2404457ac00ef2f7499fccde7cc82ea'] B "detnet-ip-over-tsn. other mechanisms than the ones used in the tsn case are outside the scope of this document." {} {} {} 85 "If the DSCP field is to be used in flow identification. Ignoring the DSCP field is optional." "IESG review comment resolutions in this version : DONE , ( ) , ( 03 - 09 ) , Ready with Nits , IANA , ( 03 - 12 ) , OK ( 03 - 12 ) , 03 - 12 , Nits , ( 03 - 15 ) , Comments and Many nits TO BE DISCUSSED : Security section , ( 04 - 09 ) , decrease authors to 5 ! ! ! reviewed in April 22 meeting" 19850197b1472544a5ae26d63718c2b9c5f1674f 19850197b1472544a5ae26d63718c2b9c5f1674f draft-ietf-detnet-ip 7abba4f957bdaec7e3c1ced9a66b48c1a5c98589b09d32a90eacf73731daef32 ['e21941d35baca191b439d76713c4d1a96cb0019bf417ca069e1067ccfdaab083', '68cb2dd931e5871b2c966f47d172d5bfa42c1c4096ff184e4d57cd2a0ef49ca3', '7abba4f957bdaec7e3c1ced9a66b48c1a5c98589b09d32a90eacf73731daef32', '26af780d8649cd2ce83b080174b9ec314bc0421b11ab8c5f4facf398b4435a65'] A "if the dscp field is to be used in flow identification. ignoring the dscp field is optional." {83: 1, 56: 1, 60: 2, 102: 3, 64: 2, 38: 3, 62: 4, 71: 3, 33: 2, 26: 3, 32: 2, 113: 3, 126: 4, 112: 3, 129: 4} {163: 1, 261: 1, 260: 2, 274: 3, 339: 4, 212: 3, 343: 4, 283: 4, 286: 5, 31: 2, 32: 3, 33: 2, 228: 3, 357: 3, 166: 4, 231: 2, 298: 3, 46: 4, 377: 3} {260, 261, 274, 283, 286, 31, 32, 33, 163, 166, 298, 46, 339, 212, 343, 228, 357, 231, 363, 377} 85 "When the DSCP field is used in flow identification, a list of field values that may be used by a specific flow." "IESG review comment resolutions in this version : DONE , ( ) , ( 03 - 09 ) , Ready with Nits , IANA , ( 03 - 12 ) , OK ( 03 - 12 ) , 03 - 12 , Nits , ( 03 - 15 ) , Comments and Many nits TO BE DISCUSSED : Security section , ( 04 - 09 ) , decrease authors to 5 ! ! ! reviewed in April 22 meeting" 19850197b1472544a5ae26d63718c2b9c5f1674f 19850197b1472544a5ae26d63718c2b9c5f1674f draft-ietf-detnet-ip e21941d35baca191b439d76713c4d1a96cb0019bf417ca069e1067ccfdaab083 ['e21941d35baca191b439d76713c4d1a96cb0019bf417ca069e1067ccfdaab083', '68cb2dd931e5871b2c966f47d172d5bfa42c1c4096ff184e4d57cd2a0ef49ca3', '7abba4f957bdaec7e3c1ced9a66b48c1a5c98589b09d32a90eacf73731daef32', '26af780d8649cd2ce83b080174b9ec314bc0421b11ab8c5f4facf398b4435a65'] A "when the dscp field is used in flow identification, a list of field values that may be used by a specific flow." {83: 1, 56: 1, 60: 2, 102: 3, 64: 2, 38: 3, 62: 4, 71: 3, 33: 2, 26: 3, 32: 2, 113: 3, 126: 4, 112: 3, 129: 4} {163: 1, 261: 1, 260: 2, 274: 3, 339: 4, 212: 3, 343: 4, 283: 4, 286: 5, 31: 2, 32: 3, 33: 2, 228: 3, 357: 3, 166: 4, 231: 2, 298: 3, 46: 4, 377: 3} {260, 261, 274, 283, 286, 31, 32, 33, 163, 166, 298, 46, 339, 212, 343, 228, 357, 231, 363, 377} 85 "Whether or not the DSCP field is used in flow identification. Use of the DSCP field for flow identification is optional." "IESG review comment resolutions in this version : DONE , ( ) , ( 03 - 09 ) , Ready with Nits , IANA , ( 03 - 12 ) , OK ( 03 - 12 ) , 03 - 12 , Nits , ( 03 - 15 ) , Comments and Many nits TO BE DISCUSSED : Security section , ( 04 - 09 ) , decrease authors to 5 ! ! ! reviewed in April 22 meeting" 19850197b1472544a5ae26d63718c2b9c5f1674f 19850197b1472544a5ae26d63718c2b9c5f1674f draft-ietf-detnet-ip 68cb2dd931e5871b2c966f47d172d5bfa42c1c4096ff184e4d57cd2a0ef49ca3 ['e21941d35baca191b439d76713c4d1a96cb0019bf417ca069e1067ccfdaab083', '68cb2dd931e5871b2c966f47d172d5bfa42c1c4096ff184e4d57cd2a0ef49ca3', '7abba4f957bdaec7e3c1ced9a66b48c1a5c98589b09d32a90eacf73731daef32', '26af780d8649cd2ce83b080174b9ec314bc0421b11ab8c5f4facf398b4435a65'] B "whether or not the dscp field is used in flow identification. use of the dscp field for flow identification is optional." {83: 1, 56: 1, 60: 2, 102: 3, 64: 2, 38: 3, 62: 4, 71: 3, 33: 2, 26: 3, 32: 2, 113: 3, 126: 4, 112: 3, 129: 4} {163: 1, 261: 1, 260: 2, 274: 3, 339: 4, 212: 3, 343: 4, 283: 4, 286: 5, 31: 2, 32: 3, 33: 2, 228: 3, 357: 3, 166: 4, 231: 2, 298: 3, 46: 4, 377: 3} {260, 261, 274, 283, 286, 31, 32, 33, 163, 166, 298, 46, 339, 212, 343, 228, 357, 231, 363, 377} 85 "If the DSCP field is used to identify a flow, then the flow identification information (for that flow) includes a list of DSCPs used by that flow." "IESG review comment resolutions in this version : DONE , ( ) , ( 03 - 09 ) , Ready with Nits , IANA , ( 03 - 12 ) , OK ( 03 - 12 ) , 03 - 12 , Nits , ( 03 - 15 ) , Comments and Many nits TO BE DISCUSSED : Security section , ( 04 - 09 ) , decrease authors to 5 ! ! ! reviewed in April 22 meeting" 19850197b1472544a5ae26d63718c2b9c5f1674f 19850197b1472544a5ae26d63718c2b9c5f1674f draft-ietf-detnet-ip 26af780d8649cd2ce83b080174b9ec314bc0421b11ab8c5f4facf398b4435a65 ['e21941d35baca191b439d76713c4d1a96cb0019bf417ca069e1067ccfdaab083', '68cb2dd931e5871b2c966f47d172d5bfa42c1c4096ff184e4d57cd2a0ef49ca3', '7abba4f957bdaec7e3c1ced9a66b48c1a5c98589b09d32a90eacf73731daef32', '26af780d8649cd2ce83b080174b9ec314bc0421b11ab8c5f4facf398b4435a65'] B "if the dscp field is used to identify a flow, then the flow identification information (for that flow) includes a list of dscps used by that flow." {83: 1, 56: 1, 60: 2, 102: 3, 64: 2, 38: 3, 62: 4, 71: 3, 33: 2, 26: 3, 32: 2, 113: 3, 126: 4, 112: 3, 129: 4} {163: 1, 261: 1, 260: 2, 274: 3, 339: 4, 212: 3, 343: 4, 283: 4, 286: 5, 31: 2, 32: 3, 33: 2, 228: 3, 357: 3, 166: 4, 231: 2, 298: 3, 46: 4, 377: 3} {260, 261, 274, 283, 286, 31, 32, 33, 163, 166, 298, 46, 339, 212, 343, 228, 357, 231, 363, 377} 84 "This document describes the concepts needed by any DetNet data plane specification and provides considerations for any corresponding implementation. It covers the building blocks that provide the DetNet service, the DetNet service sub-layer and the DetNet forwarding sub-layer functions as described in the DetNet Architecture." "IESG review comment resolutions in this version : DONE , IANA , ( 03 - 12 ) , OK , ( 03 - 15 ) , Ready with Nits Yoshifumi Nishida , ( 04 - 07 ) , Ready with Nits ( 04 - 12 ) , Editorial nits mostly , ( 04 - 15 ) , Editorial comments TO BE DISCUSSED : , ( 03 - 13 ) , Ready with Issues ( Ready , as soon as I - D.ietf - detnet - security is reviewed and becomes an RFC . ) reviewed in April 22 meeting" f95284c65618abd001877da8cfc9f18a49096d95 f95284c65618abd001877da8cfc9f18a49096d95 draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework b88353808a7c24b82e9281212248ed08479099adb448be353457c40ece2b14d3 ['b88353808a7c24b82e9281212248ed08479099adb448be353457c40ece2b14d3', 'f4f8a66c5d57d54875099b92aaefce5d08c99004862755cf06b397ea9374bf8f'] A "this document describes the concepts needed by any detnet data plane specification and provides considerations for any corresponding implementation. it covers the building blocks that provide the detnet service, the detnet service sub-layer and the detnet forwarding sub-layer functions as described in the detnet architecture." {} {} {} 84 "This document describes the concepts needed by any DetNet data plane specification (i.e., the DetNet-specific use of packet header fields) and provides considerations for any corresponding implementation. It covers the building blocks that provide the DetNet service, the DetNet service sub-layer and the DetNet forwarding sub-layer functions as described in the DetNet Architecture." "IESG review comment resolutions in this version : DONE , IANA , ( 03 - 12 ) , OK , ( 03 - 15 ) , Ready with Nits Yoshifumi Nishida , ( 04 - 07 ) , Ready with Nits ( 04 - 12 ) , Editorial nits mostly , ( 04 - 15 ) , Editorial comments TO BE DISCUSSED : , ( 03 - 13 ) , Ready with Issues ( Ready , as soon as I - D.ietf - detnet - security is reviewed and becomes an RFC . ) reviewed in April 22 meeting" f95284c65618abd001877da8cfc9f18a49096d95 f95284c65618abd001877da8cfc9f18a49096d95 draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework f4f8a66c5d57d54875099b92aaefce5d08c99004862755cf06b397ea9374bf8f ['b88353808a7c24b82e9281212248ed08479099adb448be353457c40ece2b14d3', 'f4f8a66c5d57d54875099b92aaefce5d08c99004862755cf06b397ea9374bf8f'] B "this document describes the concepts needed by any detnet data plane specification (i.e., the detnet-specific use of packet header fields) and provides considerations for any corresponding implementation. it covers the building blocks that provide the detnet service, the detnet service sub-layer and the detnet forwarding sub-layer functions as described in the detnet architecture." {} {} {} 84 "As part of the service sub-layer functions, this document describes typical DetNet node data plane operation. It describes the function and operation of the Packet Replication (PRF) Packet Elimination (PEF) and the Packet Ordering (POF) functions within the service sub- layer. Furthermore, it also describes the forwarding sub-layer." "IESG review comment resolutions in this version : DONE , IANA , ( 03 - 12 ) , OK , ( 03 - 15 ) , Ready with Nits Yoshifumi Nishida , ( 04 - 07 ) , Ready with Nits ( 04 - 12 ) , Editorial nits mostly , ( 04 - 15 ) , Editorial comments TO BE DISCUSSED : , ( 03 - 13 ) , Ready with Issues ( Ready , as soon as I - D.ietf - detnet - security is reviewed and becomes an RFC . ) reviewed in April 22 meeting" f95284c65618abd001877da8cfc9f18a49096d95 f95284c65618abd001877da8cfc9f18a49096d95 draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework 4022ead35c2d329a5ba02b76ffd6e624e14d2317dbcd2328b803db3f88d69444 ['e8b3fb35e36b05ff93c43122e75d773a89efea6bec1ab2675cc2267657e2464c', '39d2e55483cabfd339f98acbff304a62f6afc0f3a6159d62ff48f10334f8c125', '76aee36de082398cf11835d6d9155416a946595d8d0feb9c4f40e9cd9b5aa148', '260e3230868be0a02cb73a7fad223d4fe598500df2bfb5b6eb1d47396fcac262', '4022ead35c2d329a5ba02b76ffd6e624e14d2317dbcd2328b803db3f88d69444', '78e1a9bed496d2c89822117980d4206fdf694bcb125095795c9bd07aa11ca9fb'] A "as part of the service sub-layer functions, this document describes typical detnet node data plane operation. it describes the function and operation of the packet replication (prf) packet elimination (pef) and the packet ordering (pof) functions within the service sub- layer. furthermore, it also describes the forwarding sub-layer." {90: 1, 55: 1, 68: 1, 6: 2} {53: 1, 87: 1, 182: 1, 374: 1, 37: 3, 232: 2, 173: 2, 181: 2} {37, 232, 173, 373, 182, 87, 181, 374, 53} 84 "DetNet flows may be carried over network technologies that can provide the DetNet required service characteristics. For example, DetNet MPLS flows can be carried over IEEE 802.1 Time Sensitive Network (TSN) IEEE802.1TSNTG sub-networks. However, IEEE 802.1 TSN support is not required in DetNet. TSN frame preemption is an example of a forwarding layer capability that is typically not replicated in other forwarding technologies. Most of DetNet benefits can be gained by running over a data link layer that has not been specifically enhanced to support all TSN capabilities but for certain networks and traffic mixes delay and jitter performance may vary due to the forwarding sub-layer intrinsic properties." "IESG review comment resolutions in this version : DONE , IANA , ( 03 - 12 ) , OK , ( 03 - 15 ) , Ready with Nits Yoshifumi Nishida , ( 04 - 07 ) , Ready with Nits ( 04 - 12 ) , Editorial nits mostly , ( 04 - 15 ) , Editorial comments TO BE DISCUSSED : , ( 03 - 13 ) , Ready with Issues ( Ready , as soon as I - D.ietf - detnet - security is reviewed and becomes an RFC . ) reviewed in April 22 meeting" f95284c65618abd001877da8cfc9f18a49096d95 f95284c65618abd001877da8cfc9f18a49096d95 draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework e8b3fb35e36b05ff93c43122e75d773a89efea6bec1ab2675cc2267657e2464c ['e8b3fb35e36b05ff93c43122e75d773a89efea6bec1ab2675cc2267657e2464c', '39d2e55483cabfd339f98acbff304a62f6afc0f3a6159d62ff48f10334f8c125', '76aee36de082398cf11835d6d9155416a946595d8d0feb9c4f40e9cd9b5aa148', '260e3230868be0a02cb73a7fad223d4fe598500df2bfb5b6eb1d47396fcac262', '4022ead35c2d329a5ba02b76ffd6e624e14d2317dbcd2328b803db3f88d69444', '78e1a9bed496d2c89822117980d4206fdf694bcb125095795c9bd07aa11ca9fb'] A "detnet flows may be carried over network technologies that can provide the detnet required service characteristics. for example, detnet mpls flows can be carried over ieee 802.1 time sensitive network (tsn) ieee802.1tsntg sub-networks. however, ieee 802.1 tsn support is not required in detnet. tsn frame preemption is an example of a forwarding layer capability that is typically not replicated in other forwarding technologies. most of detnet benefits can be gained by running over a data link layer that has not been specifically enhanced to support all tsn capabilities but for certain networks and traffic mixes delay and jitter performance may vary due to the forwarding sub-layer intrinsic properties." {90: 1, 55: 1, 68: 1, 6: 2} {53: 1, 87: 1, 182: 1, 374: 1, 37: 3, 232: 2, 173: 2, 181: 2} {37, 232, 173, 373, 182, 87, 181, 374, 53} 84 "Different application flows (e.g., Ethernet, IP, etc.), can be mapped on top of DetNet. DetNet can optionally reuse header information provided by, or shared with, applications. An example of shared header fields can be found in I-D.ietf-detnet-ip." "IESG review comment resolutions in this version : DONE , IANA , ( 03 - 12 ) , OK , ( 03 - 15 ) , Ready with Nits Yoshifumi Nishida , ( 04 - 07 ) , Ready with Nits ( 04 - 12 ) , Editorial nits mostly , ( 04 - 15 ) , Editorial comments TO BE DISCUSSED : , ( 03 - 13 ) , Ready with Issues ( Ready , as soon as I - D.ietf - detnet - security is reviewed and becomes an RFC . ) reviewed in April 22 meeting" f95284c65618abd001877da8cfc9f18a49096d95 f95284c65618abd001877da8cfc9f18a49096d95 draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework 39d2e55483cabfd339f98acbff304a62f6afc0f3a6159d62ff48f10334f8c125 ['e8b3fb35e36b05ff93c43122e75d773a89efea6bec1ab2675cc2267657e2464c', '39d2e55483cabfd339f98acbff304a62f6afc0f3a6159d62ff48f10334f8c125', '76aee36de082398cf11835d6d9155416a946595d8d0feb9c4f40e9cd9b5aa148', '260e3230868be0a02cb73a7fad223d4fe598500df2bfb5b6eb1d47396fcac262', '4022ead35c2d329a5ba02b76ffd6e624e14d2317dbcd2328b803db3f88d69444', '78e1a9bed496d2c89822117980d4206fdf694bcb125095795c9bd07aa11ca9fb'] A "different application flows (e.g., ethernet, ip, etc.), can be mapped on top of detnet. detnet can optionally reuse header information provided by, or shared with, applications. an example of shared header fields can be found in i-d.ietf-detnet-ip." {90: 1, 55: 1, 68: 1, 6: 2} {53: 1, 87: 1, 182: 1, 374: 1, 37: 3, 232: 2, 173: 2, 181: 2} {37, 232, 173, 373, 182, 87, 181, 374, 53} 84 "As part of the service sub-layer functions, this document describes typical DetNet node data plane operation. It describes the functionality and operation of the Packet Replication (PRF), Packet Elimination (PEF), and the Packet Ordering (POF) functions within the service sub-layer. Furthermore, it describes the forwarding sub- layer." "IESG review comment resolutions in this version : DONE , IANA , ( 03 - 12 ) , OK , ( 03 - 15 ) , Ready with Nits Yoshifumi Nishida , ( 04 - 07 ) , Ready with Nits ( 04 - 12 ) , Editorial nits mostly , ( 04 - 15 ) , Editorial comments TO BE DISCUSSED : , ( 03 - 13 ) , Ready with Issues ( Ready , as soon as I - D.ietf - detnet - security is reviewed and becomes an RFC . ) reviewed in April 22 meeting" f95284c65618abd001877da8cfc9f18a49096d95 f95284c65618abd001877da8cfc9f18a49096d95 draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework 78e1a9bed496d2c89822117980d4206fdf694bcb125095795c9bd07aa11ca9fb ['e8b3fb35e36b05ff93c43122e75d773a89efea6bec1ab2675cc2267657e2464c', '39d2e55483cabfd339f98acbff304a62f6afc0f3a6159d62ff48f10334f8c125', '76aee36de082398cf11835d6d9155416a946595d8d0feb9c4f40e9cd9b5aa148', '260e3230868be0a02cb73a7fad223d4fe598500df2bfb5b6eb1d47396fcac262', '4022ead35c2d329a5ba02b76ffd6e624e14d2317dbcd2328b803db3f88d69444', '78e1a9bed496d2c89822117980d4206fdf694bcb125095795c9bd07aa11ca9fb'] B "as part of the service sub-layer functions, this document describes typical detnet node data plane operation. it describes the functionality and operation of the packet replication (prf), packet elimination (pef), and the packet ordering (pof) functions within the service sub-layer. furthermore, it describes the forwarding sub- layer." {90: 1, 55: 1, 68: 1, 6: 2} {53: 1, 87: 1, 182: 1, 374: 1, 37: 3, 232: 2, 173: 2, 181: 2} {37, 232, 173, 373, 182, 87, 181, 374, 53} 84 "As defined in RFC8655, DetNet flows may be carried over network technologies that can provide the DetNet required service characteristics. For example, DetNet MPLS flows can be carried over IEEE 802.1 Time Sensitive Network (TSN) IEEE802.1TSNTG sub-networks. However, IEEE 802.1 TSN support is not required in DetNet. TSN frame preemption is an example of a forwarding layer capability that is typically not replicated in other forwarding technologies. Most of DetNet benefits can be gained by running over a data link layer that has not been specifically enhanced to support all TSN capabilities but for certain networks and traffic mixes delay and jitter performance may vary due to the forwarding sub-layer intrinsic properties." "IESG review comment resolutions in this version : DONE , IANA , ( 03 - 12 ) , OK , ( 03 - 15 ) , Ready with Nits Yoshifumi Nishida , ( 04 - 07 ) , Ready with Nits ( 04 - 12 ) , Editorial nits mostly , ( 04 - 15 ) , Editorial comments TO BE DISCUSSED : , ( 03 - 13 ) , Ready with Issues ( Ready , as soon as I - D.ietf - detnet - security is reviewed and becomes an RFC . ) reviewed in April 22 meeting" f95284c65618abd001877da8cfc9f18a49096d95 f95284c65618abd001877da8cfc9f18a49096d95 draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework 260e3230868be0a02cb73a7fad223d4fe598500df2bfb5b6eb1d47396fcac262 ['e8b3fb35e36b05ff93c43122e75d773a89efea6bec1ab2675cc2267657e2464c', '39d2e55483cabfd339f98acbff304a62f6afc0f3a6159d62ff48f10334f8c125', '76aee36de082398cf11835d6d9155416a946595d8d0feb9c4f40e9cd9b5aa148', '260e3230868be0a02cb73a7fad223d4fe598500df2bfb5b6eb1d47396fcac262', '4022ead35c2d329a5ba02b76ffd6e624e14d2317dbcd2328b803db3f88d69444', '78e1a9bed496d2c89822117980d4206fdf694bcb125095795c9bd07aa11ca9fb'] B "as defined in rfc8655, detnet flows may be carried over network technologies that can provide the detnet required service characteristics. for example, detnet mpls flows can be carried over ieee 802.1 time sensitive network (tsn) ieee802.1tsntg sub-networks. however, ieee 802.1 tsn support is not required in detnet. tsn frame preemption is an example of a forwarding layer capability that is typically not replicated in other forwarding technologies. most of detnet benefits can be gained by running over a data link layer that has not been specifically enhanced to support all tsn capabilities but for certain networks and traffic mixes delay and jitter performance may vary due to the forwarding sub-layer intrinsic properties." {90: 1, 55: 1, 68: 1, 6: 2} {53: 1, 87: 1, 182: 1, 374: 1, 37: 3, 232: 2, 173: 2, 181: 2} {37, 232, 173, 373, 182, 87, 181, 374, 53} 84 "Different application flows, such as Ethernet or IP, can be mapped on top of DetNet. DetNet can optionally reuse header information provided by, or shared with, applications. An example of shared header fields can be found in I-D.ietf-detnet-ip." "IESG review comment resolutions in this version : DONE , IANA , ( 03 - 12 ) , OK , ( 03 - 15 ) , Ready with Nits Yoshifumi Nishida , ( 04 - 07 ) , Ready with Nits ( 04 - 12 ) , Editorial nits mostly , ( 04 - 15 ) , Editorial comments TO BE DISCUSSED : , ( 03 - 13 ) , Ready with Issues ( Ready , as soon as I - D.ietf - detnet - security is reviewed and becomes an RFC . ) reviewed in April 22 meeting" f95284c65618abd001877da8cfc9f18a49096d95 f95284c65618abd001877da8cfc9f18a49096d95 draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework 76aee36de082398cf11835d6d9155416a946595d8d0feb9c4f40e9cd9b5aa148 ['e8b3fb35e36b05ff93c43122e75d773a89efea6bec1ab2675cc2267657e2464c', '39d2e55483cabfd339f98acbff304a62f6afc0f3a6159d62ff48f10334f8c125', '76aee36de082398cf11835d6d9155416a946595d8d0feb9c4f40e9cd9b5aa148', '260e3230868be0a02cb73a7fad223d4fe598500df2bfb5b6eb1d47396fcac262', '4022ead35c2d329a5ba02b76ffd6e624e14d2317dbcd2328b803db3f88d69444', '78e1a9bed496d2c89822117980d4206fdf694bcb125095795c9bd07aa11ca9fb'] B "different application flows, such as ethernet or ip, can be mapped on top of detnet. detnet can optionally reuse header information provided by, or shared with, applications. an example of shared header fields can be found in i-d.ietf-detnet-ip." {90: 1, 55: 1, 68: 1, 6: 2} {53: 1, 87: 1, 182: 1, 374: 1, 37: 3, 232: 2, 173: 2, 181: 2} {37, 232, 173, 373, 182, 87, 181, 374, 53} 84 "Border Gateway Protocol. Control Word." "IESG review comment resolutions in this version : DONE , IANA , ( 03 - 12 ) , OK , ( 03 - 15 ) , Ready with Nits Yoshifumi Nishida , ( 04 - 07 ) , Ready with Nits ( 04 - 12 ) , Editorial nits mostly , ( 04 - 15 ) , Editorial comments TO BE DISCUSSED : , ( 03 - 13 ) , Ready with Issues ( Ready , as soon as I - D.ietf - detnet - security is reviewed and becomes an RFC . ) reviewed in April 22 meeting" f95284c65618abd001877da8cfc9f18a49096d95 f95284c65618abd001877da8cfc9f18a49096d95 draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework 3e057f74301f418e69303110e8d2479c9dd215c1a31b6fc551bc3cbc79be8348 ['e7ff501dd61f92d84d05e6823e6a78aa21e433aeacedf7d73738da05607869ef', '3e057f74301f418e69303110e8d2479c9dd215c1a31b6fc551bc3cbc79be8348'] A "border gateway protocol. control word." {} {} {} 84 Border Gateway Protocol. "IESG review comment resolutions in this version : DONE , IANA , ( 03 - 12 ) , OK , ( 03 - 15 ) , Ready with Nits Yoshifumi Nishida , ( 04 - 07 ) , Ready with Nits ( 04 - 12 ) , Editorial nits mostly , ( 04 - 15 ) , Editorial comments TO BE DISCUSSED : , ( 03 - 13 ) , Ready with Issues ( Ready , as soon as I - D.ietf - detnet - security is reviewed and becomes an RFC . ) reviewed in April 22 meeting" f95284c65618abd001877da8cfc9f18a49096d95 f95284c65618abd001877da8cfc9f18a49096d95 draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework e7ff501dd61f92d84d05e6823e6a78aa21e433aeacedf7d73738da05607869ef ['e7ff501dd61f92d84d05e6823e6a78aa21e433aeacedf7d73738da05607869ef', '3e057f74301f418e69303110e8d2479c9dd215c1a31b6fc551bc3cbc79be8348'] B border gateway protocol. {} {} {} 84 "Label Switching Router. Multiprotocol Label Switching. Multiprotocol Label Switching - Traffic Engineering." "IESG review comment resolutions in this version : DONE , IANA , ( 03 - 12 ) , OK , ( 03 - 15 ) , Ready with Nits Yoshifumi Nishida , ( 04 - 07 ) , Ready with Nits ( 04 - 12 ) , Editorial nits mostly , ( 04 - 15 ) , Editorial comments TO BE DISCUSSED : , ( 03 - 13 ) , Ready with Issues ( Ready , as soon as I - D.ietf - detnet - security is reviewed and becomes an RFC . ) reviewed in April 22 meeting" f95284c65618abd001877da8cfc9f18a49096d95 f95284c65618abd001877da8cfc9f18a49096d95 draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework da51e21dc9056651ea1ddfcc16d3085ececd8c51ce583b2d9db49a8c83b827bb ['da51e21dc9056651ea1ddfcc16d3085ececd8c51ce583b2d9db49a8c83b827bb', '27460ea05387e1309fd60b3425a1204ce0eb8888fd9b8b6f0b81cac2c035b8c5'] A "label switching router. multiprotocol label switching. multiprotocol label switching - traffic engineering." {} {} {} 84 "Border Gateway Protocol. DetNet Control Word. Deterministic Networking. DetNet. Generalized Multiprotocol Label Switching. Generic Routing Encapsulation. IP Security. Layer 2. Label Switched Path. Multiprotocol Label Switching." "IESG review comment resolutions in this version : DONE , IANA , ( 03 - 12 ) , OK , ( 03 - 15 ) , Ready with Nits Yoshifumi Nishida , ( 04 - 07 ) , Ready with Nits ( 04 - 12 ) , Editorial nits mostly , ( 04 - 15 ) , Editorial comments TO BE DISCUSSED : , ( 03 - 13 ) , Ready with Issues ( Ready , as soon as I - D.ietf - detnet - security is reviewed and becomes an RFC . ) reviewed in April 22 meeting" f95284c65618abd001877da8cfc9f18a49096d95 f95284c65618abd001877da8cfc9f18a49096d95 draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework 27460ea05387e1309fd60b3425a1204ce0eb8888fd9b8b6f0b81cac2c035b8c5 ['da51e21dc9056651ea1ddfcc16d3085ececd8c51ce583b2d9db49a8c83b827bb', '27460ea05387e1309fd60b3425a1204ce0eb8888fd9b8b6f0b81cac2c035b8c5'] B "border gateway protocol. detnet control word. deterministic networking. detnet. generalized multiprotocol label switching. generic routing encapsulation. ip security. layer 2. label switched path. multiprotocol label switching." {} {} {} 84 "PseudoWire. Quality of Service. DetNet ""service"" label. Time-Division Multiplexing. Time-Sensitive Network. Yet Another Next Generation." "IESG review comment resolutions in this version : DONE , IANA , ( 03 - 12 ) , OK , ( 03 - 15 ) , Ready with Nits Yoshifumi Nishida , ( 04 - 07 ) , Ready with Nits ( 04 - 12 ) , Editorial nits mostly , ( 04 - 15 ) , Editorial comments TO BE DISCUSSED : , ( 03 - 13 ) , Ready with Issues ( Ready , as soon as I - D.ietf - detnet - security is reviewed and becomes an RFC . ) reviewed in April 22 meeting" f95284c65618abd001877da8cfc9f18a49096d95 f95284c65618abd001877da8cfc9f18a49096d95 draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework 9b650c6e61ba187cd1d31c92ae0728c9e46b540054b413d179d93fc5aa163c31 ['5229325985f1816fcd9a30c12e0e1a66a933af806e4a540f281b36fcaf214a02', '9b650c6e61ba187cd1d31c92ae0728c9e46b540054b413d179d93fc5aa163c31'] A "pseudowire. quality of service. detnet ""service"" label. time-division multiplexing. time-sensitive network. yet another next generation." {} {} {} 84 "Quality of Service. DetNet ""service"" label. Time-Division Multiplexing. Time-Sensitive Network. Yet Another Next Generation." "IESG review comment resolutions in this version : DONE , IANA , ( 03 - 12 ) , OK , ( 03 - 15 ) , Ready with Nits Yoshifumi Nishida , ( 04 - 07 ) , Ready with Nits ( 04 - 12 ) , Editorial nits mostly , ( 04 - 15 ) , Editorial comments TO BE DISCUSSED : , ( 03 - 13 ) , Ready with Issues ( Ready , as soon as I - D.ietf - detnet - security is reviewed and becomes an RFC . ) reviewed in April 22 meeting" f95284c65618abd001877da8cfc9f18a49096d95 f95284c65618abd001877da8cfc9f18a49096d95 draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework 5229325985f1816fcd9a30c12e0e1a66a933af806e4a540f281b36fcaf214a02 ['5229325985f1816fcd9a30c12e0e1a66a933af806e4a540f281b36fcaf214a02', '9b650c6e61ba187cd1d31c92ae0728c9e46b540054b413d179d93fc5aa163c31'] B "quality of service. detnet ""service"" label. time-division multiplexing. time-sensitive network. yet another next generation." {} {} {} 84 "This document describes how application flows, or app-flows, are carried over DetNet networks. The DetNet Architecture, RFC8655, models the DetNet related data plane functions as decomposed into two sub-layers: a service sub-layer and a forwarding sub-layer." "IESG review comment resolutions in this version : DONE , IANA , ( 03 - 12 ) , OK , ( 03 - 15 ) , Ready with Nits Yoshifumi Nishida , ( 04 - 07 ) , Ready with Nits ( 04 - 12 ) , Editorial nits mostly , ( 04 - 15 ) , Editorial comments TO BE DISCUSSED : , ( 03 - 13 ) , Ready with Issues ( Ready , as soon as I - D.ietf - detnet - security is reviewed and becomes an RFC . ) reviewed in April 22 meeting" f95284c65618abd001877da8cfc9f18a49096d95 f95284c65618abd001877da8cfc9f18a49096d95 draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework c259d1cc55a93ea197ab7ec35e48e33b5f93d66366d52c897c72ea0c318116c8 ['c259d1cc55a93ea197ab7ec35e48e33b5f93d66366d52c897c72ea0c318116c8', 'b5e1618a741a47eb74539c9592a20f86a6cb10e78c87befc4cd18c9ead825cba', '851ce706885ca08c0db13952986707051bdb577b0866cf9a6c5283d1ae40d7a7', '3f2de64637e59553094b88e5750c6049491cfb1a66fa32e9da72af1db3c7ab00'] A "this document describes how application flows, or app-flows, are carried over detnet networks. the detnet architecture, rfc8655, models the detnet related data plane functions as decomposed into two sub-layers: a service sub-layer and a forwarding sub-layer." {67: 1, 6: 2, 8: 3, 68: 6, 31: 3, 90: 4, 84: 4, 55: 2} {209: 1, 256: 2, 2: 3, 5: 6, 8: 3, 74: 3, 271: 4, 83: 7, 20: 6, 21: 7, 277: 6, 276: 7, 88: 3, 233: 2, 236: 6, 47: 4, 303: 7, 112: 3, 247: 5, 126: 4, 127: 3} {256, 2, 5, 8, 271, 20, 21, 277, 276, 302, 47, 303, 74, 209, 83, 88, 233, 236, 112, 247, 126, 127} 84 "ProtStack1 reproduced from the RFC8655,shows a logical DetNet service with the two sub-layers." "IESG review comment resolutions in this version : DONE , IANA , ( 03 - 12 ) , OK , ( 03 - 15 ) , Ready with Nits Yoshifumi Nishida , ( 04 - 07 ) , Ready with Nits ( 04 - 12 ) , Editorial nits mostly , ( 04 - 15 ) , Editorial comments TO BE DISCUSSED : , ( 03 - 13 ) , Ready with Issues ( Ready , as soon as I - D.ietf - detnet - security is reviewed and becomes an RFC . ) reviewed in April 22 meeting" f95284c65618abd001877da8cfc9f18a49096d95 f95284c65618abd001877da8cfc9f18a49096d95 draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework 851ce706885ca08c0db13952986707051bdb577b0866cf9a6c5283d1ae40d7a7 ['c259d1cc55a93ea197ab7ec35e48e33b5f93d66366d52c897c72ea0c318116c8', 'b5e1618a741a47eb74539c9592a20f86a6cb10e78c87befc4cd18c9ead825cba', '851ce706885ca08c0db13952986707051bdb577b0866cf9a6c5283d1ae40d7a7', '3f2de64637e59553094b88e5750c6049491cfb1a66fa32e9da72af1db3c7ab00'] A "protstack1 reproduced from the rfc8655,shows a logical detnet service with the two sub-layers." {67: 1, 6: 2, 8: 3, 68: 6, 31: 3, 90: 4, 84: 4, 55: 2} {209: 1, 256: 2, 2: 3, 5: 6, 8: 3, 74: 3, 271: 4, 83: 7, 20: 6, 21: 7, 277: 6, 276: 7, 88: 3, 233: 2, 236: 6, 47: 4, 303: 7, 112: 3, 247: 5, 126: 4, 127: 3} {256, 2, 5, 8, 271, 20, 21, 277, 276, 302, 47, 303, 74, 209, 83, 88, 233, 236, 112, 247, 126, 127} 84 "This document describes how application flows, or app-flows, are carried over DetNet networks. The DetNet Architecture RFC8655 models the DetNet-related data plane functions as decomposed into two sub- layers: a service sub-layer and a forwarding sub-layer." "IESG review comment resolutions in this version : DONE , IANA , ( 03 - 12 ) , OK , ( 03 - 15 ) , Ready with Nits Yoshifumi Nishida , ( 04 - 07 ) , Ready with Nits ( 04 - 12 ) , Editorial nits mostly , ( 04 - 15 ) , Editorial comments TO BE DISCUSSED : , ( 03 - 13 ) , Ready with Issues ( Ready , as soon as I - D.ietf - detnet - security is reviewed and becomes an RFC . ) reviewed in April 22 meeting" f95284c65618abd001877da8cfc9f18a49096d95 f95284c65618abd001877da8cfc9f18a49096d95 draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework b5e1618a741a47eb74539c9592a20f86a6cb10e78c87befc4cd18c9ead825cba ['c259d1cc55a93ea197ab7ec35e48e33b5f93d66366d52c897c72ea0c318116c8', 'b5e1618a741a47eb74539c9592a20f86a6cb10e78c87befc4cd18c9ead825cba', '851ce706885ca08c0db13952986707051bdb577b0866cf9a6c5283d1ae40d7a7', '3f2de64637e59553094b88e5750c6049491cfb1a66fa32e9da72af1db3c7ab00'] B "this document describes how application flows, or app-flows, are carried over detnet networks. the detnet architecture rfc8655 models the detnet-related data plane functions as decomposed into two sub- layers: a service sub-layer and a forwarding sub-layer." {67: 1, 6: 2, 8: 3, 68: 6, 31: 3, 90: 4, 84: 4, 55: 2} {209: 1, 256: 2, 2: 3, 5: 6, 8: 3, 74: 3, 271: 4, 83: 7, 20: 6, 21: 7, 277: 6, 276: 7, 88: 3, 233: 2, 236: 6, 47: 4, 303: 7, 112: 3, 247: 5, 126: 4, 127: 3} {256, 2, 5, 8, 271, 20, 21, 277, 276, 302, 47, 303, 74, 209, 83, 88, 233, 236, 112, 247, 126, 127} 84 "ProtStack1, reproduced from RFC8655, shows a logical DetNet service with the two sub-layers." "IESG review comment resolutions in this version : DONE , IANA , ( 03 - 12 ) , OK , ( 03 - 15 ) , Ready with Nits Yoshifumi Nishida , ( 04 - 07 ) , Ready with Nits ( 04 - 12 ) , Editorial nits mostly , ( 04 - 15 ) , Editorial comments TO BE DISCUSSED : , ( 03 - 13 ) , Ready with Issues ( Ready , as soon as I - D.ietf - detnet - security is reviewed and becomes an RFC . ) reviewed in April 22 meeting" f95284c65618abd001877da8cfc9f18a49096d95 f95284c65618abd001877da8cfc9f18a49096d95 draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework 3f2de64637e59553094b88e5750c6049491cfb1a66fa32e9da72af1db3c7ab00 ['c259d1cc55a93ea197ab7ec35e48e33b5f93d66366d52c897c72ea0c318116c8', 'b5e1618a741a47eb74539c9592a20f86a6cb10e78c87befc4cd18c9ead825cba', '851ce706885ca08c0db13952986707051bdb577b0866cf9a6c5283d1ae40d7a7', '3f2de64637e59553094b88e5750c6049491cfb1a66fa32e9da72af1db3c7ab00'] B "protstack1, reproduced from rfc8655, shows a logical detnet service with the two sub-layers." {67: 1, 6: 2, 8: 3, 68: 6, 31: 3, 90: 4, 84: 4, 55: 2} {209: 1, 256: 2, 2: 3, 5: 6, 8: 3, 74: 3, 271: 4, 83: 7, 20: 6, 21: 7, 277: 6, 276: 7, 88: 3, 233: 2, 236: 6, 47: 4, 303: 7, 112: 3, 247: 5, 126: 4, 127: 3} {256, 2, 5, 8, 271, 20, 21, 277, 276, 302, 47, 303, 74, 209, 83, 88, 233, 236, 112, 247, 126, 127} 84 "The service sub-layer provides additional support beyond the connectivity function of the forwarding sub-layer. An example of this is Packet Replication, Elimination, and Ordering functions see PREOF. The ordering (POF) uses sequence numbers added to packets enabling a range of packet order protection from simple ordering and dropping out-of-order packets to more complex reordering of a fixed number of out-of-order, minimally delayed packets. Reordering requires buffer resources and has impact on the delay and jitter of packets in the DetNet flow." "IESG review comment resolutions in this version : DONE , IANA , ( 03 - 12 ) , OK , ( 03 - 15 ) , Ready with Nits Yoshifumi Nishida , ( 04 - 07 ) , Ready with Nits ( 04 - 12 ) , Editorial nits mostly , ( 04 - 15 ) , Editorial comments TO BE DISCUSSED : , ( 03 - 13 ) , Ready with Issues ( Ready , as soon as I - D.ietf - detnet - security is reviewed and becomes an RFC . ) reviewed in April 22 meeting" f95284c65618abd001877da8cfc9f18a49096d95 f95284c65618abd001877da8cfc9f18a49096d95 draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework 62cccbc0f90baf0afe4a855d11d118c6af2fe1977470a99d6592172537661791 ['1537ce4979b31a2b49f3adc93e79afe072c85e531021772c93e6c056931c0f07', '62cccbc0f90baf0afe4a855d11d118c6af2fe1977470a99d6592172537661791'] A "the service sub-layer provides additional support beyond the connectivity function of the forwarding sub-layer. an example of this is packet replication, elimination, and ordering functions see preof. the ordering (pof) uses sequence numbers added to packets enabling a range of packet order protection from simple ordering and dropping out-of-order packets to more complex reordering of a fixed number of out-of-order, minimally delayed packets. reordering requires buffer resources and has impact on the delay and jitter of packets in the detnet flow." {68: 1, 90: 1, 6: 5, 8: 4, 31: 3, 67: 6, 84: 3, 55: 2} {5: 1, 20: 1, 256: 5, 2: 6, 8: 6, 74: 4, 271: 3, 209: 6, 83: 4, 277: 3, 276: 4, 88: 6, 233: 7, 236: 3, 302: 7, 47: 7, 303: 2, 112: 6, 247: 2, 126: 7, 127: 6} {256, 2, 5, 8, 271, 20, 21, 277, 276, 302, 47, 303, 74, 209, 83, 88, 233, 236, 112, 247, 126, 127} 84 "The service sub-layer provides additional support beyond the connectivity function of the forwarding sub-layer. An example of this is Packet Replication, Elimination, and Ordering functions see PREOF. The ordering function (POF) uses sequence numbers added to packets enabling a range of packet order protection from simple ordering and dropping out-of-order packets to more complex reordering of a fixed number of out-of-order, minimally delayed packets. Reordering requires buffer resources and has impact on the delay and jitter of packets in the DetNet flow." "IESG review comment resolutions in this version : DONE , IANA , ( 03 - 12 ) , OK , ( 03 - 15 ) , Ready with Nits Yoshifumi Nishida , ( 04 - 07 ) , Ready with Nits ( 04 - 12 ) , Editorial nits mostly , ( 04 - 15 ) , Editorial comments TO BE DISCUSSED : , ( 03 - 13 ) , Ready with Issues ( Ready , as soon as I - D.ietf - detnet - security is reviewed and becomes an RFC . ) reviewed in April 22 meeting" f95284c65618abd001877da8cfc9f18a49096d95 f95284c65618abd001877da8cfc9f18a49096d95 draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework 1537ce4979b31a2b49f3adc93e79afe072c85e531021772c93e6c056931c0f07 ['1537ce4979b31a2b49f3adc93e79afe072c85e531021772c93e6c056931c0f07', '62cccbc0f90baf0afe4a855d11d118c6af2fe1977470a99d6592172537661791'] B "the service sub-layer provides additional support beyond the connectivity function of the forwarding sub-layer. an example of this is packet replication, elimination, and ordering functions see preof. the ordering function (pof) uses sequence numbers added to packets enabling a range of packet order protection from simple ordering and dropping out-of-order packets to more complex reordering of a fixed number of out-of-order, minimally delayed packets. reordering requires buffer resources and has impact on the delay and jitter of packets in the detnet flow." {68: 1, 90: 1, 6: 5, 8: 4, 31: 3, 67: 6, 84: 3, 55: 2} {5: 1, 20: 1, 256: 5, 2: 6, 8: 6, 74: 4, 271: 3, 209: 6, 83: 4, 277: 3, 276: 4, 88: 6, 233: 7, 236: 3, 302: 7, 47: 7, 303: 2, 112: 6, 247: 2, 126: 7, 127: 6} {256, 2, 5, 8, 271, 20, 21, 277, 276, 302, 47, 303, 74, 209, 83, 88, 233, 236, 112, 247, 126, 127} 84 "The DetNet data plane is provided by the DetNet service and forwarding sub layers. The DetNet service sub-layer generally provides its functions for the DetNet application flows by using or applying existing standardized headers and/or encapsulations. The Detnet forwarding sub-layer may provide capabilities leveraging that same header or encapsulation technology (e.g., DN IP or DN MPLS) or it may be achieved by other technologies (e.g., dn_svc_encaps). DetNet is currently defined for operation over packet switched (IP) networks or label switched (MPLS) networks." "IESG review comment resolutions in this version : DONE , IANA , ( 03 - 12 ) , OK , ( 03 - 15 ) , Ready with Nits Yoshifumi Nishida , ( 04 - 07 ) , Ready with Nits ( 04 - 12 ) , Editorial nits mostly , ( 04 - 15 ) , Editorial comments TO BE DISCUSSED : , ( 03 - 13 ) , Ready with Issues ( Ready , as soon as I - D.ietf - detnet - security is reviewed and becomes an RFC . ) reviewed in April 22 meeting" f95284c65618abd001877da8cfc9f18a49096d95 f95284c65618abd001877da8cfc9f18a49096d95 draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework 97aa4c1b16326599f435c75216a6c84c0b02f881adb4481409a33958bfdcf917 ['b33d183bf45b3a8104e696210b6301d7bef1b0d65cb49e4d40a3c12272b7cddf', '97aa4c1b16326599f435c75216a6c84c0b02f881adb4481409a33958bfdcf917', '13a20554ab07e9366fd1898bd73bc6cbe8b0be6fdfa7d694200ab108e9324af7', '6504e518897e9b53c6aa1b9fa4202829289535d3aac3c96557a4f7f63f7bd49e'] A "the detnet data plane is provided by the detnet service and forwarding sub layers. the detnet service sub-layer generally provides its functions for the detnet application flows by using or applying existing standardized headers and/or encapsulations. the detnet forwarding sub-layer may provide capabilities leveraging that same header or encapsulation technology (e.g., dn ip or dn mpls) or it may be achieved by other technologies (e.g., dn_svc_encaps). detnet is currently defined for operation over packet switched (ip) networks or label switched (mpls) networks." {90: 1, 68: 1, 55: 1, 6: 4, 8: 3, 31: 2, 67: 5, 84: 3} {83: 1, 236: 1, 247: 1, 276: 1, 256: 4, 2: 5, 5: 2, 8: 5, 74: 3, 271: 2, 209: 5, 20: 2, 21: 3, 88: 5, 233: 6, 302: 6, 47: 6, 303: 3, 112: 5, 126: 6, 127: 5} {256, 2, 5, 8, 271, 20, 21, 277, 276, 302, 47, 303, 74, 209, 83, 88, 233, 236, 112, 247, 126, 127} 84 "DetNet encodes specific flow attributes (flow identity and sequence number) in packets. For example, in DetNet IP, zero encapsulation is used and no sequence number is available, and in DetNet MPLS, DetNet specific information may be added explicitly to the packets in the format of S-label and d-CW I-D.ietf-detnet-mpls ." "IESG review comment resolutions in this version : DONE , IANA , ( 03 - 12 ) , OK , ( 03 - 15 ) , Ready with Nits Yoshifumi Nishida , ( 04 - 07 ) , Ready with Nits ( 04 - 12 ) , Editorial nits mostly , ( 04 - 15 ) , Editorial comments TO BE DISCUSSED : , ( 03 - 13 ) , Ready with Issues ( Ready , as soon as I - D.ietf - detnet - security is reviewed and becomes an RFC . ) reviewed in April 22 meeting" f95284c65618abd001877da8cfc9f18a49096d95 f95284c65618abd001877da8cfc9f18a49096d95 draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework 6504e518897e9b53c6aa1b9fa4202829289535d3aac3c96557a4f7f63f7bd49e ['b33d183bf45b3a8104e696210b6301d7bef1b0d65cb49e4d40a3c12272b7cddf', '97aa4c1b16326599f435c75216a6c84c0b02f881adb4481409a33958bfdcf917', '13a20554ab07e9366fd1898bd73bc6cbe8b0be6fdfa7d694200ab108e9324af7', '6504e518897e9b53c6aa1b9fa4202829289535d3aac3c96557a4f7f63f7bd49e'] A "detnet encodes specific flow attributes (flow identity and sequence number) in packets. for example, in detnet ip, zero encapsulation is used and no sequence number is available, and in detnet mpls, detnet specific information may be added explicitly to the packets in the format of s-label and d-cw i-d.ietf-detnet-mpls ." {90: 1, 68: 1, 55: 1, 6: 4, 8: 3, 31: 2, 67: 5, 84: 3} {83: 1, 236: 1, 247: 1, 276: 1, 256: 4, 2: 5, 5: 2, 8: 5, 74: 3, 271: 2, 209: 5, 20: 2, 21: 3, 88: 5, 233: 6, 302: 6, 47: 6, 303: 3, 112: 5, 126: 6, 127: 5} {256, 2, 5, 8, 271, 20, 21, 277, 276, 302, 47, 303, 74, 209, 83, 88, 233, 236, 112, 247, 126, 127} 84 "The DetNet data plane is provided by the DetNet service and forwarding sub layers. The DetNet service sub-layer generally provides its functions for the DetNet application flows by using or applying existing standardized headers and/or encapsulations. The Detnet forwarding sub-layer may provide capabilities leveraging that same header or encapsulation technology (e.g., DN IP or DN MPLS) or it may be achieved by other technologies (e.g., dn_svc_encaps). DetNet is currently defined for operation over packet-switched (IP) networks or label-switched (MPLS) networks." "IESG review comment resolutions in this version : DONE , IANA , ( 03 - 12 ) , OK , ( 03 - 15 ) , Ready with Nits Yoshifumi Nishida , ( 04 - 07 ) , Ready with Nits ( 04 - 12 ) , Editorial nits mostly , ( 04 - 15 ) , Editorial comments TO BE DISCUSSED : , ( 03 - 13 ) , Ready with Issues ( Ready , as soon as I - D.ietf - detnet - security is reviewed and becomes an RFC . ) reviewed in April 22 meeting" f95284c65618abd001877da8cfc9f18a49096d95 f95284c65618abd001877da8cfc9f18a49096d95 draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework 13a20554ab07e9366fd1898bd73bc6cbe8b0be6fdfa7d694200ab108e9324af7 ['b33d183bf45b3a8104e696210b6301d7bef1b0d65cb49e4d40a3c12272b7cddf', '97aa4c1b16326599f435c75216a6c84c0b02f881adb4481409a33958bfdcf917', '13a20554ab07e9366fd1898bd73bc6cbe8b0be6fdfa7d694200ab108e9324af7', '6504e518897e9b53c6aa1b9fa4202829289535d3aac3c96557a4f7f63f7bd49e'] B "the detnet data plane is provided by the detnet service and forwarding sub layers. the detnet service sub-layer generally provides its functions for the detnet application flows by using or applying existing standardized headers and/or encapsulations. the detnet forwarding sub-layer may provide capabilities leveraging that same header or encapsulation technology (e.g., dn ip or dn mpls) or it may be achieved by other technologies (e.g., dn_svc_encaps). detnet is currently defined for operation over packet-switched (ip) networks or label-switched (mpls) networks." {90: 1, 68: 1, 55: 1, 6: 4, 8: 3, 31: 2, 67: 5, 84: 3} {83: 1, 236: 1, 247: 1, 276: 1, 256: 4, 2: 5, 5: 2, 8: 5, 74: 3, 271: 2, 209: 5, 20: 2, 21: 3, 88: 5, 233: 6, 302: 6, 47: 6, 303: 3, 112: 5, 126: 6, 127: 5} {256, 2, 5, 8, 271, 20, 21, 277, 276, 302, 47, 303, 74, 209, 83, 88, 233, 236, 112, 247, 126, 127} 84 "DetNet encodes specific flow attributes (flow identity and sequence number) in packets. For example, in DetNet IP, zero encapsulation is used and no sequence number is available, and in DetNet MPLS, DetNet- specific information may be added explicitly to the packets in the format of S-label and d-CW I-D.ietf-detnet-mpls ." "IESG review comment resolutions in this version : DONE , IANA , ( 03 - 12 ) , OK , ( 03 - 15 ) , Ready with Nits Yoshifumi Nishida , ( 04 - 07 ) , Ready with Nits ( 04 - 12 ) , Editorial nits mostly , ( 04 - 15 ) , Editorial comments TO BE DISCUSSED : , ( 03 - 13 ) , Ready with Issues ( Ready , as soon as I - D.ietf - detnet - security is reviewed and becomes an RFC . ) reviewed in April 22 meeting" f95284c65618abd001877da8cfc9f18a49096d95 f95284c65618abd001877da8cfc9f18a49096d95 draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework b33d183bf45b3a8104e696210b6301d7bef1b0d65cb49e4d40a3c12272b7cddf ['b33d183bf45b3a8104e696210b6301d7bef1b0d65cb49e4d40a3c12272b7cddf', '97aa4c1b16326599f435c75216a6c84c0b02f881adb4481409a33958bfdcf917', '13a20554ab07e9366fd1898bd73bc6cbe8b0be6fdfa7d694200ab108e9324af7', '6504e518897e9b53c6aa1b9fa4202829289535d3aac3c96557a4f7f63f7bd49e'] B "detnet encodes specific flow attributes (flow identity and sequence number) in packets. for example, in detnet ip, zero encapsulation is used and no sequence number is available, and in detnet mpls, detnet- specific information may be added explicitly to the packets in the format of s-label and d-cw i-d.ietf-detnet-mpls ." {90: 1, 68: 1, 55: 1, 6: 4, 8: 3, 31: 2, 67: 5, 84: 3} {83: 1, 236: 1, 247: 1, 276: 1, 256: 4, 2: 5, 5: 2, 8: 5, 74: 3, 271: 2, 209: 5, 20: 2, 21: 3, 88: 5, 233: 6, 302: 6, 47: 6, 303: 3, 112: 5, 126: 6, 127: 5} {256, 2, 5, 8, 271, 20, 21, 277, 276, 302, 47, 303, 74, 209, 83, 88, 233, 236, 112, 247, 126, 127} 84 "Metadata can be included implicit or explicit. Explicit means that a dedicated header field is used to include metadata in a DetNet packet. In case of implicit method a part of an already existing header field is used to encode the metadata." "IESG review comment resolutions in this version : DONE , IANA , ( 03 - 12 ) , OK , ( 03 - 15 ) , Ready with Nits Yoshifumi Nishida , ( 04 - 07 ) , Ready with Nits ( 04 - 12 ) , Editorial nits mostly , ( 04 - 15 ) , Editorial comments TO BE DISCUSSED : , ( 03 - 13 ) , Ready with Issues ( Ready , as soon as I - D.ietf - detnet - security is reviewed and becomes an RFC . ) reviewed in April 22 meeting" f95284c65618abd001877da8cfc9f18a49096d95 f95284c65618abd001877da8cfc9f18a49096d95 draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework 8681d3d5eafd1166db20c61cbfb31b1f58b8fdabd9e01f7f4b9b8f9c3dd7eb33 ['230dddfe4a01a05d5a9a3689b05aa59114a7e7a20d27e3cadc6b7312e37da14d', '8681d3d5eafd1166db20c61cbfb31b1f58b8fdabd9e01f7f4b9b8f9c3dd7eb33'] A "metadata can be included implicit or explicit. explicit means that a dedicated header field is used to include metadata in a detnet packet. in case of implicit method a part of an already existing header field is used to encode the metadata." {55: 1, 6: 2, 8: 3, 68: 6, 31: 3, 67: 3, 90: 2, 84: 4} {127: 1, 256: 2, 2: 3, 5: 6, 8: 3, 74: 3, 271: 4, 209: 3, 83: 7, 20: 6, 21: 7, 277: 6, 276: 7, 88: 3, 233: 4, 236: 6, 302: 4, 303: 7, 112: 3, 247: 5, 126: 2} {256, 2, 5, 8, 271, 20, 21, 277, 276, 302, 47, 303, 74, 209, 83, 88, 233, 236, 112, 247, 126, 127} 84 "Metadata inclusion can be implicit or explicit. Explicit inclusions involve a dedicated header field that is used to include metadata in a DetNet packet. In the implicit method, part of an already existing header field is used to encode the metadata." "IESG review comment resolutions in this version : DONE , IANA , ( 03 - 12 ) , OK , ( 03 - 15 ) , Ready with Nits Yoshifumi Nishida , ( 04 - 07 ) , Ready with Nits ( 04 - 12 ) , Editorial nits mostly , ( 04 - 15 ) , Editorial comments TO BE DISCUSSED : , ( 03 - 13 ) , Ready with Issues ( Ready , as soon as I - D.ietf - detnet - security is reviewed and becomes an RFC . ) reviewed in April 22 meeting" f95284c65618abd001877da8cfc9f18a49096d95 f95284c65618abd001877da8cfc9f18a49096d95 draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework 230dddfe4a01a05d5a9a3689b05aa59114a7e7a20d27e3cadc6b7312e37da14d ['230dddfe4a01a05d5a9a3689b05aa59114a7e7a20d27e3cadc6b7312e37da14d', '8681d3d5eafd1166db20c61cbfb31b1f58b8fdabd9e01f7f4b9b8f9c3dd7eb33'] B "metadata inclusion can be implicit or explicit. explicit inclusions involve a dedicated header field that is used to include metadata in a detnet packet. in the implicit method, part of an already existing header field is used to encode the metadata." {55: 1, 6: 2, 8: 3, 68: 6, 31: 3, 67: 3, 90: 2, 84: 4} {127: 1, 256: 2, 2: 3, 5: 6, 8: 3, 74: 3, 271: 4, 209: 3, 83: 7, 20: 6, 21: 7, 277: 6, 276: 7, 88: 3, 233: 4, 236: 6, 302: 4, 303: 7, 112: 3, 247: 5, 126: 2} {256, 2, 5, 8, 271, 20, 21, 277, 276, 302, 47, 303, 74, 209, 83, 88, 233, 236, 112, 247, 126, 127} 84 "An IP data plane may operate natively or through the use of an encapsulation. Many types of IP encapsulation can satisfy DetNet requirements and it is anticipated that more than one encapsulation may be deployed, for example GRE, IPSec etc." "IESG review comment resolutions in this version : DONE , IANA , ( 03 - 12 ) , OK , ( 03 - 15 ) , Ready with Nits Yoshifumi Nishida , ( 04 - 07 ) , Ready with Nits ( 04 - 12 ) , Editorial nits mostly , ( 04 - 15 ) , Editorial comments TO BE DISCUSSED : , ( 03 - 13 ) , Ready with Issues ( Ready , as soon as I - D.ietf - detnet - security is reviewed and becomes an RFC . ) reviewed in April 22 meeting" f95284c65618abd001877da8cfc9f18a49096d95 f95284c65618abd001877da8cfc9f18a49096d95 draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework 853be33484efcf8d9c687137501a8aa4dfbf75a63fa3418c763e1300f7112816 ['fc90651fc8620761a5054b7a07e2127e0b6c813b7dd98bfb8d1318541971656a', '853be33484efcf8d9c687137501a8aa4dfbf75a63fa3418c763e1300f7112816'] A "an ip data plane may operate natively or through the use of an encapsulation. many types of ip encapsulation can satisfy detnet requirements and it is anticipated that more than one encapsulation may be deployed, for example gre, ipsec etc." {55: 1} {104: 1} {104, 405} 84 "An IP data plane may operate natively or through the use of an encapsulation. Many types of IP encapsulation can satisfy DetNet requirements and it is anticipated that more than one encapsulation may be deployed, for example GRE, IPSec." "IESG review comment resolutions in this version : DONE , IANA , ( 03 - 12 ) , OK , ( 03 - 15 ) , Ready with Nits Yoshifumi Nishida , ( 04 - 07 ) , Ready with Nits ( 04 - 12 ) , Editorial nits mostly , ( 04 - 15 ) , Editorial comments TO BE DISCUSSED : , ( 03 - 13 ) , Ready with Issues ( Ready , as soon as I - D.ietf - detnet - security is reviewed and becomes an RFC . ) reviewed in April 22 meeting" f95284c65618abd001877da8cfc9f18a49096d95 f95284c65618abd001877da8cfc9f18a49096d95 draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework fc90651fc8620761a5054b7a07e2127e0b6c813b7dd98bfb8d1318541971656a ['fc90651fc8620761a5054b7a07e2127e0b6c813b7dd98bfb8d1318541971656a', '853be33484efcf8d9c687137501a8aa4dfbf75a63fa3418c763e1300f7112816'] B "an ip data plane may operate natively or through the use of an encapsulation. many types of ip encapsulation can satisfy detnet requirements and it is anticipated that more than one encapsulation may be deployed, for example gre, ipsec." {55: 1} {104: 1} {104, 405} 84 "In cases where metadata is needed to process an MPLS encapsulated packet at the service sub-layer, the d-CW I-D.ietf-detnet-mpls, RFC4385,can be used. Although such d-CWs are frequently 32 bits long, there is no architectural constraint on its size of this structure, only the requirement that it is fully understood by all parties operating on it in the DetNet service sub-layer. The operation of this method is described in detail in I-D.ietf-detnet- mpls." "IESG review comment resolutions in this version : DONE , IANA , ( 03 - 12 ) , OK , ( 03 - 15 ) , Ready with Nits Yoshifumi Nishida , ( 04 - 07 ) , Ready with Nits ( 04 - 12 ) , Editorial nits mostly , ( 04 - 15 ) , Editorial comments TO BE DISCUSSED : , ( 03 - 13 ) , Ready with Issues ( Ready , as soon as I - D.ietf - detnet - security is reviewed and becomes an RFC . ) reviewed in April 22 meeting" f95284c65618abd001877da8cfc9f18a49096d95 f95284c65618abd001877da8cfc9f18a49096d95 draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework 1e5d70e93b82aa586833e5be7efca0d50db5cd6617d4aa5557423b578ab21a7b ['ded39e50c58adcb9513a520d65bf43283b68a67250a727ac05dcc38123ca69d2', '1b6b07c6f930c56121f5fe8d18c17f34afbce5bae021d30a2897d216fef227bb', '90b123c76a34ce7125decbd1965f78537a0a72161610ed930b499214b2761fdf', 'd8d9782188c8a9d069ef77a763472ad1af4952bfaf2224d2e02a17f37edaa2d8', '0d878f194200010b99b1ab97c11eb90bfef402240ba968747d51c6cb2e0e323a', '923a35f1f95a2c2e0c5ca34c1759e5cd9005222aecf744f5f2cfbe2a937afc7c', '37b3aa728e069dac87a1c6719d534af53a3c16745b470dc65fa0ead08542736e', 'de2d79c94ff0eea2c57eefd0a5accf3926b966e7052ae4544a30107456509e7d', '1e5d70e93b82aa586833e5be7efca0d50db5cd6617d4aa5557423b578ab21a7b', '4dbf5013cae5ea2cf47a7fc85fb667c0e1c103f23c8f7656a08bb45679112ff7'] A "in cases where metadata is needed to process an mpls encapsulated packet at the service sub-layer, the d-cw i-d.ietf-detnet-mpls, rfc4385,can be used. although such d-cws are frequently 32 bits long, there is no architectural constraint on its size of this structure, only the requirement that it is fully understood by all parties operating on it in the detnet service sub-layer. the operation of this method is described in detail in i-d.ietf-detnet- mpls." {68: 1, 55: 1, 6: 2, 79: 4, 90: 2, 51: 4, 130: 4, 62: 3, 85: 3, 35: 5, 110: 5, 91: 7, 114: 5, 97: 5, 31: 3, 13: 4, 67: 4, 38: 6, 26: 3, 124: 4, 98: 4, 54: 4, 127: 5, 8: 2, 96: 5, 64: 4, 30: 6, 61: 7, 27: 3, 15: 5, 52: 3, 129: 5, 115: 5, 84: 2, 76: 5, 87: 5, 131: 7, 102: 2, 113: 7, 99: 4, 36: 5, 24: 4, 53: 3, 72: 6} {39: 1, 124: 1, 162: 1, 222: 1, 1: 5, 4: 4, 9: 4, 10: 5, 15: 5, 24: 4, 25: 3, 26: 3, 27: 5, 43: 5, 49: 8, 50: 7, 58: 7, 59: 4, 64: 5, 69: 3, 81: 4, 82: 4, 86: 5, 96: 6, 97: 5, 100: 7, 108: 5, 109: 6, 110: 6, 111: 4, 114: 5, 115: 6, 116: 5, 118: 4, 119: 3, 120: 5, 121: 2, 122: 6, 123: 5, 128: 6, 129: 6, 130: 7, 132: 3, 136: 4, 145: 3, 147: 6, 151: 6, 152: 6, 154: 5, 156: 4, 161: 2, 165: 5, 168: 6, 169: 5, 172: 5, 180: 6, 184: 4, 187: 7, 188: 6, 191: 5, 194: 3, 202: 4, 203: 5, 206: 4, 207: 5, 215: 3, 217: 5, 218: 4, 220: 2, 221: 2, 224: 5, 227: 5, 229: 5, 234: 7, 235: 4, 241: 4, 242: 4, 243: 3, 244: 6, 245: 3, 248: 6, 250: 6, 258: 7, 262: 6, 263: 7, 264: 3, 267: 2, 270: 5, 272: 5, 273: 4, 287: 5, 289: 5, 291: 7, 299: 5, 300: 5, 304: 5, 309: 2, 314: 4, 315: 5, 320: 2, 323: 3, 327: 6, 328: 4, 329: 4, 330: 6, 334: 4, 335: 5, 341: 5, 342: 6, 347: 5, 348: 5, 350: 6, 351: 7, 352: 5, 353: 5, 354: 4, 365: 5, 366: 4, 369: 3, 371: 7, 372: 7, 376: 4, 384: 7, 385: 6, 386: 5, 387: 5, 392: 4, 393: 5, 396: 6, 397: 3, 398: 2, 402: 5} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 84 "Reservation of resources can allocate resources to specific DetNet flows. This can eliminate packet contention and packet loss for DetNet traffic. This also can reduce jitter for DetNet traffic. Resources allocated to a DetNet flow protect it from other traffic flows. On the other hand, DetNet flows are assumed to behave with respect to the reserved traffic profile. Misbehaving DetNet flows must be able to be detected and ensure that they do not compromise QoS of other flows. Queuing, policing, and shaping policies can be used to ensure that the allocation of resources reserved for DetNet is met." "IESG review comment resolutions in this version : DONE , IANA , ( 03 - 12 ) , OK , ( 03 - 15 ) , Ready with Nits Yoshifumi Nishida , ( 04 - 07 ) , Ready with Nits ( 04 - 12 ) , Editorial nits mostly , ( 04 - 15 ) , Editorial comments TO BE DISCUSSED : , ( 03 - 13 ) , Ready with Issues ( Ready , as soon as I - D.ietf - detnet - security is reviewed and becomes an RFC . ) reviewed in April 22 meeting" f95284c65618abd001877da8cfc9f18a49096d95 f95284c65618abd001877da8cfc9f18a49096d95 draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework 4dbf5013cae5ea2cf47a7fc85fb667c0e1c103f23c8f7656a08bb45679112ff7 ['ded39e50c58adcb9513a520d65bf43283b68a67250a727ac05dcc38123ca69d2', '1b6b07c6f930c56121f5fe8d18c17f34afbce5bae021d30a2897d216fef227bb', '90b123c76a34ce7125decbd1965f78537a0a72161610ed930b499214b2761fdf', 'd8d9782188c8a9d069ef77a763472ad1af4952bfaf2224d2e02a17f37edaa2d8', '0d878f194200010b99b1ab97c11eb90bfef402240ba968747d51c6cb2e0e323a', '923a35f1f95a2c2e0c5ca34c1759e5cd9005222aecf744f5f2cfbe2a937afc7c', '37b3aa728e069dac87a1c6719d534af53a3c16745b470dc65fa0ead08542736e', 'de2d79c94ff0eea2c57eefd0a5accf3926b966e7052ae4544a30107456509e7d', '1e5d70e93b82aa586833e5be7efca0d50db5cd6617d4aa5557423b578ab21a7b', '4dbf5013cae5ea2cf47a7fc85fb667c0e1c103f23c8f7656a08bb45679112ff7'] A "reservation of resources can allocate resources to specific detnet flows. this can eliminate packet contention and packet loss for detnet traffic. this also can reduce jitter for detnet traffic. resources allocated to a detnet flow protect it from other traffic flows. on the other hand, detnet flows are assumed to behave with respect to the reserved traffic profile. misbehaving detnet flows must be able to be detected and ensure that they do not compromise qos of other flows. queuing, policing, and shaping policies can be used to ensure that the allocation of resources reserved for detnet is met." {68: 1, 55: 1, 6: 2, 79: 4, 90: 2, 51: 4, 130: 4, 62: 3, 85: 3, 35: 5, 110: 5, 91: 7, 114: 5, 97: 5, 31: 3, 13: 4, 67: 4, 38: 6, 26: 3, 124: 4, 98: 4, 54: 4, 127: 5, 8: 2, 96: 5, 64: 4, 30: 6, 61: 7, 27: 3, 15: 5, 52: 3, 129: 5, 115: 5, 84: 2, 76: 5, 87: 5, 131: 7, 102: 2, 113: 7, 99: 4, 36: 5, 24: 4, 53: 3, 72: 6} {39: 1, 124: 1, 162: 1, 222: 1, 1: 5, 4: 4, 9: 4, 10: 5, 15: 5, 24: 4, 25: 3, 26: 3, 27: 5, 43: 5, 49: 8, 50: 7, 58: 7, 59: 4, 64: 5, 69: 3, 81: 4, 82: 4, 86: 5, 96: 6, 97: 5, 100: 7, 108: 5, 109: 6, 110: 6, 111: 4, 114: 5, 115: 6, 116: 5, 118: 4, 119: 3, 120: 5, 121: 2, 122: 6, 123: 5, 128: 6, 129: 6, 130: 7, 132: 3, 136: 4, 145: 3, 147: 6, 151: 6, 152: 6, 154: 5, 156: 4, 161: 2, 165: 5, 168: 6, 169: 5, 172: 5, 180: 6, 184: 4, 187: 7, 188: 6, 191: 5, 194: 3, 202: 4, 203: 5, 206: 4, 207: 5, 215: 3, 217: 5, 218: 4, 220: 2, 221: 2, 224: 5, 227: 5, 229: 5, 234: 7, 235: 4, 241: 4, 242: 4, 243: 3, 244: 6, 245: 3, 248: 6, 250: 6, 258: 7, 262: 6, 263: 7, 264: 3, 267: 2, 270: 5, 272: 5, 273: 4, 287: 5, 289: 5, 291: 7, 299: 5, 300: 5, 304: 5, 309: 2, 314: 4, 315: 5, 320: 2, 323: 3, 327: 6, 328: 4, 329: 4, 330: 6, 334: 4, 335: 5, 341: 5, 342: 6, 347: 5, 348: 5, 350: 6, 351: 7, 352: 5, 353: 5, 354: 4, 365: 5, 366: 4, 369: 3, 371: 7, 372: 7, 376: 4, 384: 7, 385: 6, 386: 5, 387: 5, 392: 4, 393: 5, 396: 6, 397: 3, 398: 2, 402: 5} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 84 "Use of a specific path for a flow. This allows control of the network delay by steering the packet with the ability to influence the physical path. Explicit routes complement reservation by ensuring that a consistent path can be associated with its resources for the duration of that path. Coupled with the traffic mechanism, this limits misordering and bounds latency. Explicit route computation can encompass a wide set of constraints and optimize the path for a certain characteristic e.g. highest bandwidth or lowest jitter. In these cases the ""best"" path for any set of characteristics may not be a shortest path. The selection of path can take into account multiple network metrics. Some of these metrics are measured and distributed by the routing system as traffic engineering metrics." "IESG review comment resolutions in this version : DONE , IANA , ( 03 - 12 ) , OK , ( 03 - 15 ) , Ready with Nits Yoshifumi Nishida , ( 04 - 07 ) , Ready with Nits ( 04 - 12 ) , Editorial nits mostly , ( 04 - 15 ) , Editorial comments TO BE DISCUSSED : , ( 03 - 13 ) , Ready with Issues ( Ready , as soon as I - D.ietf - detnet - security is reviewed and becomes an RFC . ) reviewed in April 22 meeting" f95284c65618abd001877da8cfc9f18a49096d95 f95284c65618abd001877da8cfc9f18a49096d95 draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework 923a35f1f95a2c2e0c5ca34c1759e5cd9005222aecf744f5f2cfbe2a937afc7c ['ded39e50c58adcb9513a520d65bf43283b68a67250a727ac05dcc38123ca69d2', '1b6b07c6f930c56121f5fe8d18c17f34afbce5bae021d30a2897d216fef227bb', '90b123c76a34ce7125decbd1965f78537a0a72161610ed930b499214b2761fdf', 'd8d9782188c8a9d069ef77a763472ad1af4952bfaf2224d2e02a17f37edaa2d8', '0d878f194200010b99b1ab97c11eb90bfef402240ba968747d51c6cb2e0e323a', '923a35f1f95a2c2e0c5ca34c1759e5cd9005222aecf744f5f2cfbe2a937afc7c', '37b3aa728e069dac87a1c6719d534af53a3c16745b470dc65fa0ead08542736e', 'de2d79c94ff0eea2c57eefd0a5accf3926b966e7052ae4544a30107456509e7d', '1e5d70e93b82aa586833e5be7efca0d50db5cd6617d4aa5557423b578ab21a7b', '4dbf5013cae5ea2cf47a7fc85fb667c0e1c103f23c8f7656a08bb45679112ff7'] A "use of a specific path for a flow. this allows control of the network delay by steering the packet with the ability to influence the physical path. explicit routes complement reservation by ensuring that a consistent path can be associated with its resources for the duration of that path. coupled with the traffic mechanism, this limits misordering and bounds latency. explicit route computation can encompass a wide set of constraints and optimize the path for a certain characteristic e.g. highest bandwidth or lowest jitter. in these cases the ""best"" path for any set of characteristics may not be a shortest path. the selection of path can take into account multiple network metrics. some of these metrics are measured and distributed by the routing system as traffic engineering metrics." {68: 1, 55: 1, 6: 2, 79: 4, 90: 2, 51: 4, 130: 4, 62: 3, 85: 3, 35: 5, 110: 5, 91: 7, 114: 5, 97: 5, 31: 3, 13: 4, 67: 4, 38: 6, 26: 3, 124: 4, 98: 4, 54: 4, 127: 5, 8: 2, 96: 5, 64: 4, 30: 6, 61: 7, 27: 3, 15: 5, 52: 3, 129: 5, 115: 5, 84: 2, 76: 5, 87: 5, 131: 7, 102: 2, 113: 7, 99: 4, 36: 5, 24: 4, 53: 3, 72: 6} {39: 1, 124: 1, 162: 1, 222: 1, 1: 5, 4: 4, 9: 4, 10: 5, 15: 5, 24: 4, 25: 3, 26: 3, 27: 5, 43: 5, 49: 8, 50: 7, 58: 7, 59: 4, 64: 5, 69: 3, 81: 4, 82: 4, 86: 5, 96: 6, 97: 5, 100: 7, 108: 5, 109: 6, 110: 6, 111: 4, 114: 5, 115: 6, 116: 5, 118: 4, 119: 3, 120: 5, 121: 2, 122: 6, 123: 5, 128: 6, 129: 6, 130: 7, 132: 3, 136: 4, 145: 3, 147: 6, 151: 6, 152: 6, 154: 5, 156: 4, 161: 2, 165: 5, 168: 6, 169: 5, 172: 5, 180: 6, 184: 4, 187: 7, 188: 6, 191: 5, 194: 3, 202: 4, 203: 5, 206: 4, 207: 5, 215: 3, 217: 5, 218: 4, 220: 2, 221: 2, 224: 5, 227: 5, 229: 5, 234: 7, 235: 4, 241: 4, 242: 4, 243: 3, 244: 6, 245: 3, 248: 6, 250: 6, 258: 7, 262: 6, 263: 7, 264: 3, 267: 2, 270: 5, 272: 5, 273: 4, 287: 5, 289: 5, 291: 7, 299: 5, 300: 5, 304: 5, 309: 2, 314: 4, 315: 5, 320: 2, 323: 3, 327: 6, 328: 4, 329: 4, 330: 6, 334: 4, 335: 5, 341: 5, 342: 6, 347: 5, 348: 5, 350: 6, 351: 7, 352: 5, 353: 5, 354: 4, 365: 5, 366: 4, 369: 3, 371: 7, 372: 7, 376: 4, 384: 7, 385: 6, 386: 5, 387: 5, 392: 4, 393: 5, 396: 6, 397: 3, 398: 2, 402: 5} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 84 "Use of multiple packet streams using multiple paths, for example 1+1 or 1:1 linear protection. For DetNet this primarily relates to packet replication and elimination capabilities. MPLS offers a number of protection schemes. MPLS hitless protection can be used to switch traffic to an already established path in order to restore delivery rapidly after a failure. Path changes, even in the case of failure recovery, can lead to the out of order delivery of data requiring packet ordering functions either within the DetNet service or at a high layer in the application traffic. Establishment of new paths after a failure is out of scope for DetNet services." "IESG review comment resolutions in this version : DONE , IANA , ( 03 - 12 ) , OK , ( 03 - 15 ) , Ready with Nits Yoshifumi Nishida , ( 04 - 07 ) , Ready with Nits ( 04 - 12 ) , Editorial nits mostly , ( 04 - 15 ) , Editorial comments TO BE DISCUSSED : , ( 03 - 13 ) , Ready with Issues ( Ready , as soon as I - D.ietf - detnet - security is reviewed and becomes an RFC . ) reviewed in April 22 meeting" f95284c65618abd001877da8cfc9f18a49096d95 f95284c65618abd001877da8cfc9f18a49096d95 draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework 37b3aa728e069dac87a1c6719d534af53a3c16745b470dc65fa0ead08542736e ['ded39e50c58adcb9513a520d65bf43283b68a67250a727ac05dcc38123ca69d2', '1b6b07c6f930c56121f5fe8d18c17f34afbce5bae021d30a2897d216fef227bb', '90b123c76a34ce7125decbd1965f78537a0a72161610ed930b499214b2761fdf', 'd8d9782188c8a9d069ef77a763472ad1af4952bfaf2224d2e02a17f37edaa2d8', '0d878f194200010b99b1ab97c11eb90bfef402240ba968747d51c6cb2e0e323a', '923a35f1f95a2c2e0c5ca34c1759e5cd9005222aecf744f5f2cfbe2a937afc7c', '37b3aa728e069dac87a1c6719d534af53a3c16745b470dc65fa0ead08542736e', 'de2d79c94ff0eea2c57eefd0a5accf3926b966e7052ae4544a30107456509e7d', '1e5d70e93b82aa586833e5be7efca0d50db5cd6617d4aa5557423b578ab21a7b', '4dbf5013cae5ea2cf47a7fc85fb667c0e1c103f23c8f7656a08bb45679112ff7'] A "use of multiple packet streams using multiple paths, for example 1+1 or 1:1 linear protection. for detnet this primarily relates to packet replication and elimination capabilities. mpls offers a number of protection schemes. mpls hitless protection can be used to switch traffic to an already established path in order to restore delivery rapidly after a failure. path changes, even in the case of failure recovery, can lead to the out of order delivery of data requiring packet ordering functions either within the detnet service or at a high layer in the application traffic. establishment of new paths after a failure is out of scope for detnet services." {68: 1, 55: 1, 6: 2, 79: 4, 90: 2, 51: 4, 130: 4, 62: 3, 85: 3, 35: 5, 110: 5, 91: 7, 114: 5, 97: 5, 31: 3, 13: 4, 67: 4, 38: 6, 26: 3, 124: 4, 98: 4, 54: 4, 127: 5, 8: 2, 96: 5, 64: 4, 30: 6, 61: 7, 27: 3, 15: 5, 52: 3, 129: 5, 115: 5, 84: 2, 76: 5, 87: 5, 131: 7, 102: 2, 113: 7, 99: 4, 36: 5, 24: 4, 53: 3, 72: 6} {39: 1, 124: 1, 162: 1, 222: 1, 1: 5, 4: 4, 9: 4, 10: 5, 15: 5, 24: 4, 25: 3, 26: 3, 27: 5, 43: 5, 49: 8, 50: 7, 58: 7, 59: 4, 64: 5, 69: 3, 81: 4, 82: 4, 86: 5, 96: 6, 97: 5, 100: 7, 108: 5, 109: 6, 110: 6, 111: 4, 114: 5, 115: 6, 116: 5, 118: 4, 119: 3, 120: 5, 121: 2, 122: 6, 123: 5, 128: 6, 129: 6, 130: 7, 132: 3, 136: 4, 145: 3, 147: 6, 151: 6, 152: 6, 154: 5, 156: 4, 161: 2, 165: 5, 168: 6, 169: 5, 172: 5, 180: 6, 184: 4, 187: 7, 188: 6, 191: 5, 194: 3, 202: 4, 203: 5, 206: 4, 207: 5, 215: 3, 217: 5, 218: 4, 220: 2, 221: 2, 224: 5, 227: 5, 229: 5, 234: 7, 235: 4, 241: 4, 242: 4, 243: 3, 244: 6, 245: 3, 248: 6, 250: 6, 258: 7, 262: 6, 263: 7, 264: 3, 267: 2, 270: 5, 272: 5, 273: 4, 287: 5, 289: 5, 291: 7, 299: 5, 300: 5, 304: 5, 309: 2, 314: 4, 315: 5, 320: 2, 323: 3, 327: 6, 328: 4, 329: 4, 330: 6, 334: 4, 335: 5, 341: 5, 342: 6, 347: 5, 348: 5, 350: 6, 351: 7, 352: 5, 353: 5, 354: 4, 365: 5, 366: 4, 369: 3, 371: 7, 372: 7, 376: 4, 384: 7, 385: 6, 386: 5, 387: 5, 392: 4, 393: 5, 396: 6, 397: 3, 398: 2, 402: 5} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 84 Network Coding, nwcrg not to be confused with network programming, "IESG review comment resolutions in this version : DONE , IANA , ( 03 - 12 ) , OK , ( 03 - 15 ) , Ready with Nits Yoshifumi Nishida , ( 04 - 07 ) , Ready with Nits ( 04 - 12 ) , Editorial nits mostly , ( 04 - 15 ) , Editorial comments TO BE DISCUSSED : , ( 03 - 13 ) , Ready with Issues ( Ready , as soon as I - D.ietf - detnet - security is reviewed and becomes an RFC . ) reviewed in April 22 meeting" f95284c65618abd001877da8cfc9f18a49096d95 f95284c65618abd001877da8cfc9f18a49096d95 draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework 90b123c76a34ce7125decbd1965f78537a0a72161610ed930b499214b2761fdf ['ded39e50c58adcb9513a520d65bf43283b68a67250a727ac05dcc38123ca69d2', '1b6b07c6f930c56121f5fe8d18c17f34afbce5bae021d30a2897d216fef227bb', '90b123c76a34ce7125decbd1965f78537a0a72161610ed930b499214b2761fdf', 'd8d9782188c8a9d069ef77a763472ad1af4952bfaf2224d2e02a17f37edaa2d8', '0d878f194200010b99b1ab97c11eb90bfef402240ba968747d51c6cb2e0e323a', '923a35f1f95a2c2e0c5ca34c1759e5cd9005222aecf744f5f2cfbe2a937afc7c', '37b3aa728e069dac87a1c6719d534af53a3c16745b470dc65fa0ead08542736e', 'de2d79c94ff0eea2c57eefd0a5accf3926b966e7052ae4544a30107456509e7d', '1e5d70e93b82aa586833e5be7efca0d50db5cd6617d4aa5557423b578ab21a7b', '4dbf5013cae5ea2cf47a7fc85fb667c0e1c103f23c8f7656a08bb45679112ff7'] A network coding, nwcrg not to be confused with network programming, {68: 1, 55: 1, 6: 2, 79: 4, 90: 2, 51: 4, 130: 4, 62: 3, 85: 3, 35: 5, 110: 5, 91: 7, 114: 5, 97: 5, 31: 3, 13: 4, 67: 4, 38: 6, 26: 3, 124: 4, 98: 4, 54: 4, 127: 5, 8: 2, 96: 5, 64: 4, 30: 6, 61: 7, 27: 3, 15: 5, 52: 3, 129: 5, 115: 5, 84: 2, 76: 5, 87: 5, 131: 7, 102: 2, 113: 7, 99: 4, 36: 5, 24: 4, 53: 3, 72: 6} {39: 1, 124: 1, 162: 1, 222: 1, 1: 5, 4: 4, 9: 4, 10: 5, 15: 5, 24: 4, 25: 3, 26: 3, 27: 5, 43: 5, 49: 8, 50: 7, 58: 7, 59: 4, 64: 5, 69: 3, 81: 4, 82: 4, 86: 5, 96: 6, 97: 5, 100: 7, 108: 5, 109: 6, 110: 6, 111: 4, 114: 5, 115: 6, 116: 5, 118: 4, 119: 3, 120: 5, 121: 2, 122: 6, 123: 5, 128: 6, 129: 6, 130: 7, 132: 3, 136: 4, 145: 3, 147: 6, 151: 6, 152: 6, 154: 5, 156: 4, 161: 2, 165: 5, 168: 6, 169: 5, 172: 5, 180: 6, 184: 4, 187: 7, 188: 6, 191: 5, 194: 3, 202: 4, 203: 5, 206: 4, 207: 5, 215: 3, 217: 5, 218: 4, 220: 2, 221: 2, 224: 5, 227: 5, 229: 5, 234: 7, 235: 4, 241: 4, 242: 4, 243: 3, 244: 6, 245: 3, 248: 6, 250: 6, 258: 7, 262: 6, 263: 7, 264: 3, 267: 2, 270: 5, 272: 5, 273: 4, 287: 5, 289: 5, 291: 7, 299: 5, 300: 5, 304: 5, 309: 2, 314: 4, 315: 5, 320: 2, 323: 3, 327: 6, 328: 4, 329: 4, 330: 6, 334: 4, 335: 5, 341: 5, 342: 6, 347: 5, 348: 5, 350: 6, 351: 7, 352: 5, 353: 5, 354: 4, 365: 5, 366: 4, 369: 3, 371: 7, 372: 7, 376: 4, 384: 7, 385: 6, 386: 5, 387: 5, 392: 4, 393: 5, 396: 6, 397: 3, 398: 2, 402: 5} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 84 "In cases where metadata is needed to process an MPLS encapsulated packet at the service sub-layer, the d-CW I-D.ietf-detnet-mpls, RFC4385 can be used. Although such d-CWs are frequently 32 bits long, there is no architectural constraint on the size of this structure, only the requirement that it is fully understood by all parties operating on it in the DetNet service sub-layer. The operation of this method is described in detail in I-D.ietf-detnet- mpls." "IESG review comment resolutions in this version : DONE , IANA , ( 03 - 12 ) , OK , ( 03 - 15 ) , Ready with Nits Yoshifumi Nishida , ( 04 - 07 ) , Ready with Nits ( 04 - 12 ) , Editorial nits mostly , ( 04 - 15 ) , Editorial comments TO BE DISCUSSED : , ( 03 - 13 ) , Ready with Issues ( Ready , as soon as I - D.ietf - detnet - security is reviewed and becomes an RFC . ) reviewed in April 22 meeting" f95284c65618abd001877da8cfc9f18a49096d95 f95284c65618abd001877da8cfc9f18a49096d95 draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework ded39e50c58adcb9513a520d65bf43283b68a67250a727ac05dcc38123ca69d2 ['ded39e50c58adcb9513a520d65bf43283b68a67250a727ac05dcc38123ca69d2', '1b6b07c6f930c56121f5fe8d18c17f34afbce5bae021d30a2897d216fef227bb', '90b123c76a34ce7125decbd1965f78537a0a72161610ed930b499214b2761fdf', 'd8d9782188c8a9d069ef77a763472ad1af4952bfaf2224d2e02a17f37edaa2d8', '0d878f194200010b99b1ab97c11eb90bfef402240ba968747d51c6cb2e0e323a', '923a35f1f95a2c2e0c5ca34c1759e5cd9005222aecf744f5f2cfbe2a937afc7c', '37b3aa728e069dac87a1c6719d534af53a3c16745b470dc65fa0ead08542736e', 'de2d79c94ff0eea2c57eefd0a5accf3926b966e7052ae4544a30107456509e7d', '1e5d70e93b82aa586833e5be7efca0d50db5cd6617d4aa5557423b578ab21a7b', '4dbf5013cae5ea2cf47a7fc85fb667c0e1c103f23c8f7656a08bb45679112ff7'] B "in cases where metadata is needed to process an mpls encapsulated packet at the service sub-layer, the d-cw i-d.ietf-detnet-mpls, rfc4385 can be used. although such d-cws are frequently 32 bits long, there is no architectural constraint on the size of this structure, only the requirement that it is fully understood by all parties operating on it in the detnet service sub-layer. the operation of this method is described in detail in i-d.ietf-detnet- mpls." {68: 1, 55: 1, 6: 2, 79: 4, 90: 2, 51: 4, 130: 4, 62: 3, 85: 3, 35: 5, 110: 5, 91: 7, 114: 5, 97: 5, 31: 3, 13: 4, 67: 4, 38: 6, 26: 3, 124: 4, 98: 4, 54: 4, 127: 5, 8: 2, 96: 5, 64: 4, 30: 6, 61: 7, 27: 3, 15: 5, 52: 3, 129: 5, 115: 5, 84: 2, 76: 5, 87: 5, 131: 7, 102: 2, 113: 7, 99: 4, 36: 5, 24: 4, 53: 3, 72: 6} {39: 1, 124: 1, 162: 1, 222: 1, 1: 5, 4: 4, 9: 4, 10: 5, 15: 5, 24: 4, 25: 3, 26: 3, 27: 5, 43: 5, 49: 8, 50: 7, 58: 7, 59: 4, 64: 5, 69: 3, 81: 4, 82: 4, 86: 5, 96: 6, 97: 5, 100: 7, 108: 5, 109: 6, 110: 6, 111: 4, 114: 5, 115: 6, 116: 5, 118: 4, 119: 3, 120: 5, 121: 2, 122: 6, 123: 5, 128: 6, 129: 6, 130: 7, 132: 3, 136: 4, 145: 3, 147: 6, 151: 6, 152: 6, 154: 5, 156: 4, 161: 2, 165: 5, 168: 6, 169: 5, 172: 5, 180: 6, 184: 4, 187: 7, 188: 6, 191: 5, 194: 3, 202: 4, 203: 5, 206: 4, 207: 5, 215: 3, 217: 5, 218: 4, 220: 2, 221: 2, 224: 5, 227: 5, 229: 5, 234: 7, 235: 4, 241: 4, 242: 4, 243: 3, 244: 6, 245: 3, 248: 6, 250: 6, 258: 7, 262: 6, 263: 7, 264: 3, 267: 2, 270: 5, 272: 5, 273: 4, 287: 5, 289: 5, 291: 7, 299: 5, 300: 5, 304: 5, 309: 2, 314: 4, 315: 5, 320: 2, 323: 3, 327: 6, 328: 4, 329: 4, 330: 6, 334: 4, 335: 5, 341: 5, 342: 6, 347: 5, 348: 5, 350: 6, 351: 7, 352: 5, 353: 5, 354: 4, 365: 5, 366: 4, 369: 3, 371: 7, 372: 7, 376: 4, 384: 7, 385: 6, 386: 5, 387: 5, 392: 4, 393: 5, 396: 6, 397: 3, 398: 2, 402: 5} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 84 "Resources might be reserved in order to make them available for allocation to specific DetNet flows. This can eliminate packet contention and packet loss for DetNet traffic. This also can reduce jitter for DetNet traffic. Resources allocated to a DetNet flow protect it from other traffic flows. On the other hand, DetNet flows are assumed to behave with respect to the reserved traffic profile. It must be possible to detect misbehaving DetNet flows and to ensure that they do not compromise QoS of other flows. Queuing, policing, and shaping policies can be used to ensure that the allocation of resources reserved for DetNet is met." "IESG review comment resolutions in this version : DONE , IANA , ( 03 - 12 ) , OK , ( 03 - 15 ) , Ready with Nits Yoshifumi Nishida , ( 04 - 07 ) , Ready with Nits ( 04 - 12 ) , Editorial nits mostly , ( 04 - 15 ) , Editorial comments TO BE DISCUSSED : , ( 03 - 13 ) , Ready with Issues ( Ready , as soon as I - D.ietf - detnet - security is reviewed and becomes an RFC . ) reviewed in April 22 meeting" f95284c65618abd001877da8cfc9f18a49096d95 f95284c65618abd001877da8cfc9f18a49096d95 draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework 0d878f194200010b99b1ab97c11eb90bfef402240ba968747d51c6cb2e0e323a ['ded39e50c58adcb9513a520d65bf43283b68a67250a727ac05dcc38123ca69d2', '1b6b07c6f930c56121f5fe8d18c17f34afbce5bae021d30a2897d216fef227bb', '90b123c76a34ce7125decbd1965f78537a0a72161610ed930b499214b2761fdf', 'd8d9782188c8a9d069ef77a763472ad1af4952bfaf2224d2e02a17f37edaa2d8', '0d878f194200010b99b1ab97c11eb90bfef402240ba968747d51c6cb2e0e323a', '923a35f1f95a2c2e0c5ca34c1759e5cd9005222aecf744f5f2cfbe2a937afc7c', '37b3aa728e069dac87a1c6719d534af53a3c16745b470dc65fa0ead08542736e', 'de2d79c94ff0eea2c57eefd0a5accf3926b966e7052ae4544a30107456509e7d', '1e5d70e93b82aa586833e5be7efca0d50db5cd6617d4aa5557423b578ab21a7b', '4dbf5013cae5ea2cf47a7fc85fb667c0e1c103f23c8f7656a08bb45679112ff7'] B "resources might be reserved in order to make them available for allocation to specific detnet flows. this can eliminate packet contention and packet loss for detnet traffic. this also can reduce jitter for detnet traffic. resources allocated to a detnet flow protect it from other traffic flows. on the other hand, detnet flows are assumed to behave with respect to the reserved traffic profile. it must be possible to detect misbehaving detnet flows and to ensure that they do not compromise qos of other flows. queuing, policing, and shaping policies can be used to ensure that the allocation of resources reserved for detnet is met." {68: 1, 55: 1, 6: 2, 79: 4, 90: 2, 51: 4, 130: 4, 62: 3, 85: 3, 35: 5, 110: 5, 91: 7, 114: 5, 97: 5, 31: 3, 13: 4, 67: 4, 38: 6, 26: 3, 124: 4, 98: 4, 54: 4, 127: 5, 8: 2, 96: 5, 64: 4, 30: 6, 61: 7, 27: 3, 15: 5, 52: 3, 129: 5, 115: 5, 84: 2, 76: 5, 87: 5, 131: 7, 102: 2, 113: 7, 99: 4, 36: 5, 24: 4, 53: 3, 72: 6} {39: 1, 124: 1, 162: 1, 222: 1, 1: 5, 4: 4, 9: 4, 10: 5, 15: 5, 24: 4, 25: 3, 26: 3, 27: 5, 43: 5, 49: 8, 50: 7, 58: 7, 59: 4, 64: 5, 69: 3, 81: 4, 82: 4, 86: 5, 96: 6, 97: 5, 100: 7, 108: 5, 109: 6, 110: 6, 111: 4, 114: 5, 115: 6, 116: 5, 118: 4, 119: 3, 120: 5, 121: 2, 122: 6, 123: 5, 128: 6, 129: 6, 130: 7, 132: 3, 136: 4, 145: 3, 147: 6, 151: 6, 152: 6, 154: 5, 156: 4, 161: 2, 165: 5, 168: 6, 169: 5, 172: 5, 180: 6, 184: 4, 187: 7, 188: 6, 191: 5, 194: 3, 202: 4, 203: 5, 206: 4, 207: 5, 215: 3, 217: 5, 218: 4, 220: 2, 221: 2, 224: 5, 227: 5, 229: 5, 234: 7, 235: 4, 241: 4, 242: 4, 243: 3, 244: 6, 245: 3, 248: 6, 250: 6, 258: 7, 262: 6, 263: 7, 264: 3, 267: 2, 270: 5, 272: 5, 273: 4, 287: 5, 289: 5, 291: 7, 299: 5, 300: 5, 304: 5, 309: 2, 314: 4, 315: 5, 320: 2, 323: 3, 327: 6, 328: 4, 329: 4, 330: 6, 334: 4, 335: 5, 341: 5, 342: 6, 347: 5, 348: 5, 350: 6, 351: 7, 352: 5, 353: 5, 354: 4, 365: 5, 366: 4, 369: 3, 371: 7, 372: 7, 376: 4, 384: 7, 385: 6, 386: 5, 387: 5, 392: 4, 393: 5, 396: 6, 397: 3, 398: 2, 402: 5} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 84 "A flow can be routed over a specific, pre-computed path. This allows control of the network delay by steering the packet with the ability to influence the physical path. Explicit routes complement reservation by ensuring that a consistent path can be associated with its resources for the duration of that path. Coupled with the traffic mechanism, this limits misordering and bounds latency. Explicit route computation can encompass a wide set of constraints and can optimize the path for a certain characteristic, e.g., highest bandwidth or lowest jitter. In these cases the ""best"" path for any set of characteristics may not be a shortest path. The selection of path can take into account multiple network metrics. Some of these metrics are measured and distributed by the routing system as traffic engineering metrics." "IESG review comment resolutions in this version : DONE , IANA , ( 03 - 12 ) , OK , ( 03 - 15 ) , Ready with Nits Yoshifumi Nishida , ( 04 - 07 ) , Ready with Nits ( 04 - 12 ) , Editorial nits mostly , ( 04 - 15 ) , Editorial comments TO BE DISCUSSED : , ( 03 - 13 ) , Ready with Issues ( Ready , as soon as I - D.ietf - detnet - security is reviewed and becomes an RFC . ) reviewed in April 22 meeting" f95284c65618abd001877da8cfc9f18a49096d95 f95284c65618abd001877da8cfc9f18a49096d95 draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework de2d79c94ff0eea2c57eefd0a5accf3926b966e7052ae4544a30107456509e7d ['ded39e50c58adcb9513a520d65bf43283b68a67250a727ac05dcc38123ca69d2', '1b6b07c6f930c56121f5fe8d18c17f34afbce5bae021d30a2897d216fef227bb', '90b123c76a34ce7125decbd1965f78537a0a72161610ed930b499214b2761fdf', 'd8d9782188c8a9d069ef77a763472ad1af4952bfaf2224d2e02a17f37edaa2d8', '0d878f194200010b99b1ab97c11eb90bfef402240ba968747d51c6cb2e0e323a', '923a35f1f95a2c2e0c5ca34c1759e5cd9005222aecf744f5f2cfbe2a937afc7c', '37b3aa728e069dac87a1c6719d534af53a3c16745b470dc65fa0ead08542736e', 'de2d79c94ff0eea2c57eefd0a5accf3926b966e7052ae4544a30107456509e7d', '1e5d70e93b82aa586833e5be7efca0d50db5cd6617d4aa5557423b578ab21a7b', '4dbf5013cae5ea2cf47a7fc85fb667c0e1c103f23c8f7656a08bb45679112ff7'] B "a flow can be routed over a specific, pre-computed path. this allows control of the network delay by steering the packet with the ability to influence the physical path. explicit routes complement reservation by ensuring that a consistent path can be associated with its resources for the duration of that path. coupled with the traffic mechanism, this limits misordering and bounds latency. explicit route computation can encompass a wide set of constraints and can optimize the path for a certain characteristic, e.g., highest bandwidth or lowest jitter. in these cases the ""best"" path for any set of characteristics may not be a shortest path. the selection of path can take into account multiple network metrics. some of these metrics are measured and distributed by the routing system as traffic engineering metrics." {68: 1, 55: 1, 6: 2, 79: 4, 90: 2, 51: 4, 130: 4, 62: 3, 85: 3, 35: 5, 110: 5, 91: 7, 114: 5, 97: 5, 31: 3, 13: 4, 67: 4, 38: 6, 26: 3, 124: 4, 98: 4, 54: 4, 127: 5, 8: 2, 96: 5, 64: 4, 30: 6, 61: 7, 27: 3, 15: 5, 52: 3, 129: 5, 115: 5, 84: 2, 76: 5, 87: 5, 131: 7, 102: 2, 113: 7, 99: 4, 36: 5, 24: 4, 53: 3, 72: 6} {39: 1, 124: 1, 162: 1, 222: 1, 1: 5, 4: 4, 9: 4, 10: 5, 15: 5, 24: 4, 25: 3, 26: 3, 27: 5, 43: 5, 49: 8, 50: 7, 58: 7, 59: 4, 64: 5, 69: 3, 81: 4, 82: 4, 86: 5, 96: 6, 97: 5, 100: 7, 108: 5, 109: 6, 110: 6, 111: 4, 114: 5, 115: 6, 116: 5, 118: 4, 119: 3, 120: 5, 121: 2, 122: 6, 123: 5, 128: 6, 129: 6, 130: 7, 132: 3, 136: 4, 145: 3, 147: 6, 151: 6, 152: 6, 154: 5, 156: 4, 161: 2, 165: 5, 168: 6, 169: 5, 172: 5, 180: 6, 184: 4, 187: 7, 188: 6, 191: 5, 194: 3, 202: 4, 203: 5, 206: 4, 207: 5, 215: 3, 217: 5, 218: 4, 220: 2, 221: 2, 224: 5, 227: 5, 229: 5, 234: 7, 235: 4, 241: 4, 242: 4, 243: 3, 244: 6, 245: 3, 248: 6, 250: 6, 258: 7, 262: 6, 263: 7, 264: 3, 267: 2, 270: 5, 272: 5, 273: 4, 287: 5, 289: 5, 291: 7, 299: 5, 300: 5, 304: 5, 309: 2, 314: 4, 315: 5, 320: 2, 323: 3, 327: 6, 328: 4, 329: 4, 330: 6, 334: 4, 335: 5, 341: 5, 342: 6, 347: 5, 348: 5, 350: 6, 351: 7, 352: 5, 353: 5, 354: 4, 365: 5, 366: 4, 369: 3, 371: 7, 372: 7, 376: 4, 384: 7, 385: 6, 386: 5, 387: 5, 392: 4, 393: 5, 396: 6, 397: 3, 398: 2, 402: 5} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 84 "Service protection involves use of multiple packet streams using multiple paths, for example 1+1 or 1:1 linear protection. For DetNet, this primarily relates to packet replication and elimination capabilities. MPLS offers a number of protection schemes. MPLS hitless protection can be used to switch traffic to an already established path in order to restore delivery rapidly after a failure. Path changes, even in the case of failure recovery, can lead to the out of order delivery of data requiring packet ordering functions either within the DetNet service or at a high layer in the application traffic. Establishment of new paths after a failure is out of scope for DetNet services." "IESG review comment resolutions in this version : DONE , IANA , ( 03 - 12 ) , OK , ( 03 - 15 ) , Ready with Nits Yoshifumi Nishida , ( 04 - 07 ) , Ready with Nits ( 04 - 12 ) , Editorial nits mostly , ( 04 - 15 ) , Editorial comments TO BE DISCUSSED : , ( 03 - 13 ) , Ready with Issues ( Ready , as soon as I - D.ietf - detnet - security is reviewed and becomes an RFC . ) reviewed in April 22 meeting" f95284c65618abd001877da8cfc9f18a49096d95 f95284c65618abd001877da8cfc9f18a49096d95 draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework 1b6b07c6f930c56121f5fe8d18c17f34afbce5bae021d30a2897d216fef227bb ['ded39e50c58adcb9513a520d65bf43283b68a67250a727ac05dcc38123ca69d2', '1b6b07c6f930c56121f5fe8d18c17f34afbce5bae021d30a2897d216fef227bb', '90b123c76a34ce7125decbd1965f78537a0a72161610ed930b499214b2761fdf', 'd8d9782188c8a9d069ef77a763472ad1af4952bfaf2224d2e02a17f37edaa2d8', '0d878f194200010b99b1ab97c11eb90bfef402240ba968747d51c6cb2e0e323a', '923a35f1f95a2c2e0c5ca34c1759e5cd9005222aecf744f5f2cfbe2a937afc7c', '37b3aa728e069dac87a1c6719d534af53a3c16745b470dc65fa0ead08542736e', 'de2d79c94ff0eea2c57eefd0a5accf3926b966e7052ae4544a30107456509e7d', '1e5d70e93b82aa586833e5be7efca0d50db5cd6617d4aa5557423b578ab21a7b', '4dbf5013cae5ea2cf47a7fc85fb667c0e1c103f23c8f7656a08bb45679112ff7'] B "service protection involves use of multiple packet streams using multiple paths, for example 1+1 or 1:1 linear protection. for detnet, this primarily relates to packet replication and elimination capabilities. mpls offers a number of protection schemes. mpls hitless protection can be used to switch traffic to an already established path in order to restore delivery rapidly after a failure. path changes, even in the case of failure recovery, can lead to the out of order delivery of data requiring packet ordering functions either within the detnet service or at a high layer in the application traffic. establishment of new paths after a failure is out of scope for detnet services." {68: 1, 55: 1, 6: 2, 79: 4, 90: 2, 51: 4, 130: 4, 62: 3, 85: 3, 35: 5, 110: 5, 91: 7, 114: 5, 97: 5, 31: 3, 13: 4, 67: 4, 38: 6, 26: 3, 124: 4, 98: 4, 54: 4, 127: 5, 8: 2, 96: 5, 64: 4, 30: 6, 61: 7, 27: 3, 15: 5, 52: 3, 129: 5, 115: 5, 84: 2, 76: 5, 87: 5, 131: 7, 102: 2, 113: 7, 99: 4, 36: 5, 24: 4, 53: 3, 72: 6} {39: 1, 124: 1, 162: 1, 222: 1, 1: 5, 4: 4, 9: 4, 10: 5, 15: 5, 24: 4, 25: 3, 26: 3, 27: 5, 43: 5, 49: 8, 50: 7, 58: 7, 59: 4, 64: 5, 69: 3, 81: 4, 82: 4, 86: 5, 96: 6, 97: 5, 100: 7, 108: 5, 109: 6, 110: 6, 111: 4, 114: 5, 115: 6, 116: 5, 118: 4, 119: 3, 120: 5, 121: 2, 122: 6, 123: 5, 128: 6, 129: 6, 130: 7, 132: 3, 136: 4, 145: 3, 147: 6, 151: 6, 152: 6, 154: 5, 156: 4, 161: 2, 165: 5, 168: 6, 169: 5, 172: 5, 180: 6, 184: 4, 187: 7, 188: 6, 191: 5, 194: 3, 202: 4, 203: 5, 206: 4, 207: 5, 215: 3, 217: 5, 218: 4, 220: 2, 221: 2, 224: 5, 227: 5, 229: 5, 234: 7, 235: 4, 241: 4, 242: 4, 243: 3, 244: 6, 245: 3, 248: 6, 250: 6, 258: 7, 262: 6, 263: 7, 264: 3, 267: 2, 270: 5, 272: 5, 273: 4, 287: 5, 289: 5, 291: 7, 299: 5, 300: 5, 304: 5, 309: 2, 314: 4, 315: 5, 320: 2, 323: 3, 327: 6, 328: 4, 329: 4, 330: 6, 334: 4, 335: 5, 341: 5, 342: 6, 347: 5, 348: 5, 350: 6, 351: 7, 352: 5, 353: 5, 354: 4, 365: 5, 366: 4, 369: 3, 371: 7, 372: 7, 376: 4, 384: 7, 385: 6, 386: 5, 387: 5, 392: 4, 393: 5, 396: 6, 397: 3, 398: 2, 402: 5} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 84 Network Coding nwcrg, not to be confused with network programming, "IESG review comment resolutions in this version : DONE , IANA , ( 03 - 12 ) , OK , ( 03 - 15 ) , Ready with Nits Yoshifumi Nishida , ( 04 - 07 ) , Ready with Nits ( 04 - 12 ) , Editorial nits mostly , ( 04 - 15 ) , Editorial comments TO BE DISCUSSED : , ( 03 - 13 ) , Ready with Issues ( Ready , as soon as I - D.ietf - detnet - security is reviewed and becomes an RFC . ) reviewed in April 22 meeting" f95284c65618abd001877da8cfc9f18a49096d95 f95284c65618abd001877da8cfc9f18a49096d95 draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework d8d9782188c8a9d069ef77a763472ad1af4952bfaf2224d2e02a17f37edaa2d8 ['ded39e50c58adcb9513a520d65bf43283b68a67250a727ac05dcc38123ca69d2', '1b6b07c6f930c56121f5fe8d18c17f34afbce5bae021d30a2897d216fef227bb', '90b123c76a34ce7125decbd1965f78537a0a72161610ed930b499214b2761fdf', 'd8d9782188c8a9d069ef77a763472ad1af4952bfaf2224d2e02a17f37edaa2d8', '0d878f194200010b99b1ab97c11eb90bfef402240ba968747d51c6cb2e0e323a', '923a35f1f95a2c2e0c5ca34c1759e5cd9005222aecf744f5f2cfbe2a937afc7c', '37b3aa728e069dac87a1c6719d534af53a3c16745b470dc65fa0ead08542736e', 'de2d79c94ff0eea2c57eefd0a5accf3926b966e7052ae4544a30107456509e7d', '1e5d70e93b82aa586833e5be7efca0d50db5cd6617d4aa5557423b578ab21a7b', '4dbf5013cae5ea2cf47a7fc85fb667c0e1c103f23c8f7656a08bb45679112ff7'] B network coding nwcrg, not to be confused with network programming, {68: 1, 55: 1, 6: 2, 79: 4, 90: 2, 51: 4, 130: 4, 62: 3, 85: 3, 35: 5, 110: 5, 91: 7, 114: 5, 97: 5, 31: 3, 13: 4, 67: 4, 38: 6, 26: 3, 124: 4, 98: 4, 54: 4, 127: 5, 8: 2, 96: 5, 64: 4, 30: 6, 61: 7, 27: 3, 15: 5, 52: 3, 129: 5, 115: 5, 84: 2, 76: 5, 87: 5, 131: 7, 102: 2, 113: 7, 99: 4, 36: 5, 24: 4, 53: 3, 72: 6} {39: 1, 124: 1, 162: 1, 222: 1, 1: 5, 4: 4, 9: 4, 10: 5, 15: 5, 24: 4, 25: 3, 26: 3, 27: 5, 43: 5, 49: 8, 50: 7, 58: 7, 59: 4, 64: 5, 69: 3, 81: 4, 82: 4, 86: 5, 96: 6, 97: 5, 100: 7, 108: 5, 109: 6, 110: 6, 111: 4, 114: 5, 115: 6, 116: 5, 118: 4, 119: 3, 120: 5, 121: 2, 122: 6, 123: 5, 128: 6, 129: 6, 130: 7, 132: 3, 136: 4, 145: 3, 147: 6, 151: 6, 152: 6, 154: 5, 156: 4, 161: 2, 165: 5, 168: 6, 169: 5, 172: 5, 180: 6, 184: 4, 187: 7, 188: 6, 191: 5, 194: 3, 202: 4, 203: 5, 206: 4, 207: 5, 215: 3, 217: 5, 218: 4, 220: 2, 221: 2, 224: 5, 227: 5, 229: 5, 234: 7, 235: 4, 241: 4, 242: 4, 243: 3, 244: 6, 245: 3, 248: 6, 250: 6, 258: 7, 262: 6, 263: 7, 264: 3, 267: 2, 270: 5, 272: 5, 273: 4, 287: 5, 289: 5, 291: 7, 299: 5, 300: 5, 304: 5, 309: 2, 314: 4, 315: 5, 320: 2, 323: 3, 327: 6, 328: 4, 329: 4, 330: 6, 334: 4, 335: 5, 341: 5, 342: 6, 347: 5, 348: 5, 350: 6, 351: 7, 352: 5, 353: 5, 354: 4, 365: 5, 366: 4, 369: 3, 371: 7, 372: 7, 376: 4, 384: 7, 385: 6, 386: 5, 387: 5, 392: 4, 393: 5, 396: 6, 397: 3, 398: 2, 402: 5} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 84 "traditional methods. DetNet could utilized Network coding as an alternative to other protection means. Network coding is often applied in wireless networks and is being explored for other network types." "IESG review comment resolutions in this version : DONE , IANA , ( 03 - 12 ) , OK , ( 03 - 15 ) , Ready with Nits Yoshifumi Nishida , ( 04 - 07 ) , Ready with Nits ( 04 - 12 ) , Editorial nits mostly , ( 04 - 15 ) , Editorial comments TO BE DISCUSSED : , ( 03 - 13 ) , Ready with Issues ( Ready , as soon as I - D.ietf - detnet - security is reviewed and becomes an RFC . ) reviewed in April 22 meeting" f95284c65618abd001877da8cfc9f18a49096d95 f95284c65618abd001877da8cfc9f18a49096d95 draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework f8417f5d31e75acf604b3378b5cf05cacd9e049bf32c6d7d91f2f8ffddfdbeca ['f8417f5d31e75acf604b3378b5cf05cacd9e049bf32c6d7d91f2f8ffddfdbeca', 'c71fd3533ed43eda4ffac31bf28feee8d9215aa153e1ebff55380da5c50b8cb7'] A "traditional methods. detnet could utilized network coding as an alternative to other protection means. network coding is often applied in wireless networks and is being explored for other network types." {} {} {} 84 "traditional methods. DetNet could use Network coding as an alternative to other protection means. Network coding is often applied in wireless networks and is being explored for other network types." "IESG review comment resolutions in this version : DONE , IANA , ( 03 - 12 ) , OK , ( 03 - 15 ) , Ready with Nits Yoshifumi Nishida , ( 04 - 07 ) , Ready with Nits ( 04 - 12 ) , Editorial nits mostly , ( 04 - 15 ) , Editorial comments TO BE DISCUSSED : , ( 03 - 13 ) , Ready with Issues ( Ready , as soon as I - D.ietf - detnet - security is reviewed and becomes an RFC . ) reviewed in April 22 meeting" f95284c65618abd001877da8cfc9f18a49096d95 f95284c65618abd001877da8cfc9f18a49096d95 draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework c71fd3533ed43eda4ffac31bf28feee8d9215aa153e1ebff55380da5c50b8cb7 ['f8417f5d31e75acf604b3378b5cf05cacd9e049bf32c6d7d91f2f8ffddfdbeca', 'c71fd3533ed43eda4ffac31bf28feee8d9215aa153e1ebff55380da5c50b8cb7'] B "traditional methods. detnet could use network coding as an alternative to other protection means. network coding is often applied in wireless networks and is being explored for other network types." {} {} {} 84 "The provider of a DetNet service may provide other capabilities to monitor flows, such as more detailed loss statistics and time stamping of events. The details of these capabilities are currently out of scope for this document." "IESG review comment resolutions in this version : DONE , IANA , ( 03 - 12 ) , OK , ( 03 - 15 ) , Ready with Nits Yoshifumi Nishida , ( 04 - 07 ) , Ready with Nits ( 04 - 12 ) , Editorial nits mostly , ( 04 - 15 ) , Editorial comments TO BE DISCUSSED : , ( 03 - 13 ) , Ready with Issues ( Ready , as soon as I - D.ietf - detnet - security is reviewed and becomes an RFC . ) reviewed in April 22 meeting" f95284c65618abd001877da8cfc9f18a49096d95 f95284c65618abd001877da8cfc9f18a49096d95 draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework 1b772dfa25f8ed2049d2157cbed246e1cbe7f36eb5685c9f8a6739297691ec2a ['add50b0f13ddfd048ea5cf54b8181ddd931a19133d5c5575124a3dfd364fb875', '065c7e1c6b9427086dcdef9b8fa47187efb9aaaec8398dcbf074196ed72a8f88', '1b772dfa25f8ed2049d2157cbed246e1cbe7f36eb5685c9f8a6739297691ec2a', 'c9ec9d3a1a05ce0b6199728f2b223903f18a47307ea395ca6cc6c5b85c984e2c'] A "the provider of a detnet service may provide other capabilities to monitor flows, such as more detailed loss statistics and time stamping of events. the details of these capabilities are currently out of scope for this document." {55: 1, 6: 2, 79: 4, 90: 2, 51: 4, 130: 4, 62: 3, 85: 3, 68: 2, 35: 5, 110: 5, 91: 7, 114: 5, 97: 5, 31: 3, 13: 4, 67: 4, 38: 6, 26: 3, 124: 4, 98: 4, 54: 4, 127: 5, 8: 2, 96: 5, 64: 4, 30: 6, 61: 7, 27: 3, 15: 5, 52: 3, 129: 5, 115: 5, 84: 2, 76: 5, 87: 5, 131: 7, 102: 2, 113: 7, 99: 4, 36: 5, 24: 4, 53: 3, 72: 6} {162: 1, 1: 7, 4: 4, 9: 4, 10: 5, 15: 5, 24: 4, 25: 3, 26: 3, 27: 5, 39: 3, 43: 5, 49: 8, 50: 7, 58: 7, 59: 4, 64: 5, 69: 3, 81: 4, 82: 4, 86: 5, 96: 6, 97: 5, 100: 7, 108: 5, 109: 6, 110: 6, 111: 4, 114: 5, 115: 6, 116: 5, 118: 4, 119: 3, 120: 5, 121: 2, 122: 6, 123: 5, 124: 2, 128: 6, 129: 6, 130: 7, 132: 3, 136: 4, 145: 3, 147: 6, 151: 6, 152: 6, 154: 5, 156: 4, 161: 2, 165: 5, 168: 6, 169: 5, 172: 5, 180: 6, 184: 4, 187: 7, 188: 6, 191: 5, 194: 3, 202: 4, 203: 5, 206: 4, 207: 5, 215: 3, 217: 5, 218: 6, 220: 2, 221: 2, 222: 3, 224: 5, 227: 5, 229: 5, 234: 7, 235: 4, 241: 4, 242: 4, 243: 3, 244: 6, 245: 3, 248: 6, 250: 6, 258: 9, 262: 6, 263: 7, 264: 3, 270: 5, 272: 5, 273: 4, 287: 5, 289: 5, 291: 7, 299: 5, 300: 5, 304: 5, 309: 2, 314: 4, 315: 5, 320: 2, 323: 3, 327: 6, 328: 4, 329: 4, 330: 8, 334: 4, 335: 5, 341: 5, 342: 6, 347: 5, 348: 5, 350: 6, 351: 7, 352: 5, 353: 5, 354: 4, 358: 2, 365: 5, 366: 4, 369: 3, 371: 7, 372: 7, 376: 4, 384: 7, 385: 6, 386: 5, 387: 5, 392: 4, 393: 5, 396: 6, 397: 5, 398: 4, 402: 5} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 84 "Service protection allow DetNet services to increase reliability and maintain a DetNet Service Assurance in the case of network congestion or network failure. Detnet relies on the underlying technology capabilities for various protection schemes. Protection schemes enable partial or complete coverage of the network paths and active protection with combinations of PRF, PEF, and POF." "IESG review comment resolutions in this version : DONE , IANA , ( 03 - 12 ) , OK , ( 03 - 15 ) , Ready with Nits Yoshifumi Nishida , ( 04 - 07 ) , Ready with Nits ( 04 - 12 ) , Editorial nits mostly , ( 04 - 15 ) , Editorial comments TO BE DISCUSSED : , ( 03 - 13 ) , Ready with Issues ( Ready , as soon as I - D.ietf - detnet - security is reviewed and becomes an RFC . ) reviewed in April 22 meeting" f95284c65618abd001877da8cfc9f18a49096d95 f95284c65618abd001877da8cfc9f18a49096d95 draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework 065c7e1c6b9427086dcdef9b8fa47187efb9aaaec8398dcbf074196ed72a8f88 ['add50b0f13ddfd048ea5cf54b8181ddd931a19133d5c5575124a3dfd364fb875', '065c7e1c6b9427086dcdef9b8fa47187efb9aaaec8398dcbf074196ed72a8f88', '1b772dfa25f8ed2049d2157cbed246e1cbe7f36eb5685c9f8a6739297691ec2a', 'c9ec9d3a1a05ce0b6199728f2b223903f18a47307ea395ca6cc6c5b85c984e2c'] A "service protection allow detnet services to increase reliability and maintain a detnet service assurance in the case of network congestion or network failure. detnet relies on the underlying technology capabilities for various protection schemes. protection schemes enable partial or complete coverage of the network paths and active protection with combinations of prf, pef, and pof." {55: 1, 6: 2, 79: 4, 90: 2, 51: 4, 130: 4, 62: 3, 85: 3, 68: 2, 35: 5, 110: 5, 91: 7, 114: 5, 97: 5, 31: 3, 13: 4, 67: 4, 38: 6, 26: 3, 124: 4, 98: 4, 54: 4, 127: 5, 8: 2, 96: 5, 64: 4, 30: 6, 61: 7, 27: 3, 15: 5, 52: 3, 129: 5, 115: 5, 84: 2, 76: 5, 87: 5, 131: 7, 102: 2, 113: 7, 99: 4, 36: 5, 24: 4, 53: 3, 72: 6} {162: 1, 1: 7, 4: 4, 9: 4, 10: 5, 15: 5, 24: 4, 25: 3, 26: 3, 27: 5, 39: 3, 43: 5, 49: 8, 50: 7, 58: 7, 59: 4, 64: 5, 69: 3, 81: 4, 82: 4, 86: 5, 96: 6, 97: 5, 100: 7, 108: 5, 109: 6, 110: 6, 111: 4, 114: 5, 115: 6, 116: 5, 118: 4, 119: 3, 120: 5, 121: 2, 122: 6, 123: 5, 124: 2, 128: 6, 129: 6, 130: 7, 132: 3, 136: 4, 145: 3, 147: 6, 151: 6, 152: 6, 154: 5, 156: 4, 161: 2, 165: 5, 168: 6, 169: 5, 172: 5, 180: 6, 184: 4, 187: 7, 188: 6, 191: 5, 194: 3, 202: 4, 203: 5, 206: 4, 207: 5, 215: 3, 217: 5, 218: 6, 220: 2, 221: 2, 222: 3, 224: 5, 227: 5, 229: 5, 234: 7, 235: 4, 241: 4, 242: 4, 243: 3, 244: 6, 245: 3, 248: 6, 250: 6, 258: 9, 262: 6, 263: 7, 264: 3, 270: 5, 272: 5, 273: 4, 287: 5, 289: 5, 291: 7, 299: 5, 300: 5, 304: 5, 309: 2, 314: 4, 315: 5, 320: 2, 323: 3, 327: 6, 328: 4, 329: 4, 330: 8, 334: 4, 335: 5, 341: 5, 342: 6, 347: 5, 348: 5, 350: 6, 351: 7, 352: 5, 353: 5, 354: 4, 358: 2, 365: 5, 366: 4, 369: 3, 371: 7, 372: 7, 376: 4, 384: 7, 385: 6, 386: 5, 387: 5, 392: 4, 393: 5, 396: 6, 397: 5, 398: 4, 402: 5} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 84 "The provider of a DetNet service may provide other capabilities to monitor flows, such as more detailed loss statistics and time stamping of events. The details of these capabilities are out of scope for this document." "IESG review comment resolutions in this version : DONE , IANA , ( 03 - 12 ) , OK , ( 03 - 15 ) , Ready with Nits Yoshifumi Nishida , ( 04 - 07 ) , Ready with Nits ( 04 - 12 ) , Editorial nits mostly , ( 04 - 15 ) , Editorial comments TO BE DISCUSSED : , ( 03 - 13 ) , Ready with Issues ( Ready , as soon as I - D.ietf - detnet - security is reviewed and becomes an RFC . ) reviewed in April 22 meeting" f95284c65618abd001877da8cfc9f18a49096d95 f95284c65618abd001877da8cfc9f18a49096d95 draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework c9ec9d3a1a05ce0b6199728f2b223903f18a47307ea395ca6cc6c5b85c984e2c ['add50b0f13ddfd048ea5cf54b8181ddd931a19133d5c5575124a3dfd364fb875', '065c7e1c6b9427086dcdef9b8fa47187efb9aaaec8398dcbf074196ed72a8f88', '1b772dfa25f8ed2049d2157cbed246e1cbe7f36eb5685c9f8a6739297691ec2a', 'c9ec9d3a1a05ce0b6199728f2b223903f18a47307ea395ca6cc6c5b85c984e2c'] B "the provider of a detnet service may provide other capabilities to monitor flows, such as more detailed loss statistics and time stamping of events. the details of these capabilities are out of scope for this document." {55: 1, 6: 2, 79: 4, 90: 2, 51: 4, 130: 4, 62: 3, 85: 3, 68: 2, 35: 5, 110: 5, 91: 7, 114: 5, 97: 5, 31: 3, 13: 4, 67: 4, 38: 6, 26: 3, 124: 4, 98: 4, 54: 4, 127: 5, 8: 2, 96: 5, 64: 4, 30: 6, 61: 7, 27: 3, 15: 5, 52: 3, 129: 5, 115: 5, 84: 2, 76: 5, 87: 5, 131: 7, 102: 2, 113: 7, 99: 4, 36: 5, 24: 4, 53: 3, 72: 6} {162: 1, 1: 7, 4: 4, 9: 4, 10: 5, 15: 5, 24: 4, 25: 3, 26: 3, 27: 5, 39: 3, 43: 5, 49: 8, 50: 7, 58: 7, 59: 4, 64: 5, 69: 3, 81: 4, 82: 4, 86: 5, 96: 6, 97: 5, 100: 7, 108: 5, 109: 6, 110: 6, 111: 4, 114: 5, 115: 6, 116: 5, 118: 4, 119: 3, 120: 5, 121: 2, 122: 6, 123: 5, 124: 2, 128: 6, 129: 6, 130: 7, 132: 3, 136: 4, 145: 3, 147: 6, 151: 6, 152: 6, 154: 5, 156: 4, 161: 2, 165: 5, 168: 6, 169: 5, 172: 5, 180: 6, 184: 4, 187: 7, 188: 6, 191: 5, 194: 3, 202: 4, 203: 5, 206: 4, 207: 5, 215: 3, 217: 5, 218: 6, 220: 2, 221: 2, 222: 3, 224: 5, 227: 5, 229: 5, 234: 7, 235: 4, 241: 4, 242: 4, 243: 3, 244: 6, 245: 3, 248: 6, 250: 6, 258: 9, 262: 6, 263: 7, 264: 3, 270: 5, 272: 5, 273: 4, 287: 5, 289: 5, 291: 7, 299: 5, 300: 5, 304: 5, 309: 2, 314: 4, 315: 5, 320: 2, 323: 3, 327: 6, 328: 4, 329: 4, 330: 8, 334: 4, 335: 5, 341: 5, 342: 6, 347: 5, 348: 5, 350: 6, 351: 7, 352: 5, 353: 5, 354: 4, 358: 2, 365: 5, 366: 4, 369: 3, 371: 7, 372: 7, 376: 4, 384: 7, 385: 6, 386: 5, 387: 5, 392: 4, 393: 5, 396: 6, 397: 5, 398: 4, 402: 5} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 84 "Service protection allows DetNet services to increase reliability and maintain a DetNet Service Assurance in the case of network congestion or network failure. Detnet relies on the underlying technology capabilities for various protection schemes. Protection schemes enable partial or complete coverage of the network paths and active protection with combinations of PRF, PEF, and POF." "IESG review comment resolutions in this version : DONE , IANA , ( 03 - 12 ) , OK , ( 03 - 15 ) , Ready with Nits Yoshifumi Nishida , ( 04 - 07 ) , Ready with Nits ( 04 - 12 ) , Editorial nits mostly , ( 04 - 15 ) , Editorial comments TO BE DISCUSSED : , ( 03 - 13 ) , Ready with Issues ( Ready , as soon as I - D.ietf - detnet - security is reviewed and becomes an RFC . ) reviewed in April 22 meeting" f95284c65618abd001877da8cfc9f18a49096d95 f95284c65618abd001877da8cfc9f18a49096d95 draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework add50b0f13ddfd048ea5cf54b8181ddd931a19133d5c5575124a3dfd364fb875 ['add50b0f13ddfd048ea5cf54b8181ddd931a19133d5c5575124a3dfd364fb875', '065c7e1c6b9427086dcdef9b8fa47187efb9aaaec8398dcbf074196ed72a8f88', '1b772dfa25f8ed2049d2157cbed246e1cbe7f36eb5685c9f8a6739297691ec2a', 'c9ec9d3a1a05ce0b6199728f2b223903f18a47307ea395ca6cc6c5b85c984e2c'] B "service protection allows detnet services to increase reliability and maintain a detnet service assurance in the case of network congestion or network failure. detnet relies on the underlying technology capabilities for various protection schemes. protection schemes enable partial or complete coverage of the network paths and active protection with combinations of prf, pef, and pof." {55: 1, 6: 2, 79: 4, 90: 2, 51: 4, 130: 4, 62: 3, 85: 3, 68: 2, 35: 5, 110: 5, 91: 7, 114: 5, 97: 5, 31: 3, 13: 4, 67: 4, 38: 6, 26: 3, 124: 4, 98: 4, 54: 4, 127: 5, 8: 2, 96: 5, 64: 4, 30: 6, 61: 7, 27: 3, 15: 5, 52: 3, 129: 5, 115: 5, 84: 2, 76: 5, 87: 5, 131: 7, 102: 2, 113: 7, 99: 4, 36: 5, 24: 4, 53: 3, 72: 6} {162: 1, 1: 7, 4: 4, 9: 4, 10: 5, 15: 5, 24: 4, 25: 3, 26: 3, 27: 5, 39: 3, 43: 5, 49: 8, 50: 7, 58: 7, 59: 4, 64: 5, 69: 3, 81: 4, 82: 4, 86: 5, 96: 6, 97: 5, 100: 7, 108: 5, 109: 6, 110: 6, 111: 4, 114: 5, 115: 6, 116: 5, 118: 4, 119: 3, 120: 5, 121: 2, 122: 6, 123: 5, 124: 2, 128: 6, 129: 6, 130: 7, 132: 3, 136: 4, 145: 3, 147: 6, 151: 6, 152: 6, 154: 5, 156: 4, 161: 2, 165: 5, 168: 6, 169: 5, 172: 5, 180: 6, 184: 4, 187: 7, 188: 6, 191: 5, 194: 3, 202: 4, 203: 5, 206: 4, 207: 5, 215: 3, 217: 5, 218: 6, 220: 2, 221: 2, 222: 3, 224: 5, 227: 5, 229: 5, 234: 7, 235: 4, 241: 4, 242: 4, 243: 3, 244: 6, 245: 3, 248: 6, 250: 6, 258: 9, 262: 6, 263: 7, 264: 3, 270: 5, 272: 5, 273: 4, 287: 5, 289: 5, 291: 7, 299: 5, 300: 5, 304: 5, 309: 2, 314: 4, 315: 5, 320: 2, 323: 3, 327: 6, 328: 4, 329: 4, 330: 8, 334: 4, 335: 5, 341: 5, 342: 6, 347: 5, 348: 5, 350: 6, 351: 7, 352: 5, 353: 5, 354: 4, 358: 2, 365: 5, 366: 4, 369: 3, 371: 7, 372: 7, 376: 4, 384: 7, 385: 6, 386: 5, 387: 5, 392: 4, 393: 5, 396: 6, 397: 5, 398: 4, 402: 5} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 84 "In dn_protection_flow the numbers are used to identify the instance of a packet. Packet 1 is the original packet, and packets 1.1, and second generation copy of packet 1.2 etc. Note that these numbers never appear in the packet, and are not to be confused with sequence numbers, labels or any other identifier that appears in the packet. They simply indicate the generation number of the original packet so that its passage through the network fragment can be identified to the reader." "IESG review comment resolutions in this version : DONE , IANA , ( 03 - 12 ) , OK , ( 03 - 15 ) , Ready with Nits Yoshifumi Nishida , ( 04 - 07 ) , Ready with Nits ( 04 - 12 ) , Editorial nits mostly , ( 04 - 15 ) , Editorial comments TO BE DISCUSSED : , ( 03 - 13 ) , Ready with Issues ( Ready , as soon as I - D.ietf - detnet - security is reviewed and becomes an RFC . ) reviewed in April 22 meeting" f95284c65618abd001877da8cfc9f18a49096d95 f95284c65618abd001877da8cfc9f18a49096d95 draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework a85e74c9b4b1466815e7da43ea7c6bd527776c47a0a3d19ed2cabafaed94d4f3 ['a85e74c9b4b1466815e7da43ea7c6bd527776c47a0a3d19ed2cabafaed94d4f3', '1c2029f5d9e0c10396f5947c6de89b2bb5ad59ea654a12d6593e484784eb7374'] A "in dn_protection_flow the numbers are used to identify the instance of a packet. packet 1 is the original packet, and packets 1.1, and second generation copy of packet 1.2 etc. note that these numbers never appear in the packet, and are not to be confused with sequence numbers, labels or any other identifier that appears in the packet. they simply indicate the generation number of the original packet so that its passage through the network fragment can be identified to the reader." {} {} {} 84 "In dn_protection_flow the numbers are used to identify the instance of a packet. Packet 1 is the original packet, and packets 1.1, and second generation copy of packet 1.2, etc. Note that these numbers never appear in the packet, and are not to be confused with sequence numbers, labels or any other identifier that appears in the packet. They simply indicate the generation number of the original packet so that its passage through the network fragment can be identified to the reader." "IESG review comment resolutions in this version : DONE , IANA , ( 03 - 12 ) , OK , ( 03 - 15 ) , Ready with Nits Yoshifumi Nishida , ( 04 - 07 ) , Ready with Nits ( 04 - 12 ) , Editorial nits mostly , ( 04 - 15 ) , Editorial comments TO BE DISCUSSED : , ( 03 - 13 ) , Ready with Issues ( Ready , as soon as I - D.ietf - detnet - security is reviewed and becomes an RFC . ) reviewed in April 22 meeting" f95284c65618abd001877da8cfc9f18a49096d95 f95284c65618abd001877da8cfc9f18a49096d95 draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework 1c2029f5d9e0c10396f5947c6de89b2bb5ad59ea654a12d6593e484784eb7374 ['a85e74c9b4b1466815e7da43ea7c6bd527776c47a0a3d19ed2cabafaed94d4f3', '1c2029f5d9e0c10396f5947c6de89b2bb5ad59ea654a12d6593e484784eb7374'] B "in dn_protection_flow the numbers are used to identify the instance of a packet. packet 1 is the original packet, and packets 1.1, and second generation copy of packet 1.2, etc. note that these numbers never appear in the packet, and are not to be confused with sequence numbers, labels or any other identifier that appears in the packet. they simply indicate the generation number of the original packet so that its passage through the network fragment can be identified to the reader." {} {} {} 84 "Note that along the path from EN1 to R1 there may be zero or more nodes which, for clarity, are not shown. The same is true for any other path between two DetNet entities shown in dn_protection_flow ." "IESG review comment resolutions in this version : DONE , IANA , ( 03 - 12 ) , OK , ( 03 - 15 ) , Ready with Nits Yoshifumi Nishida , ( 04 - 07 ) , Ready with Nits ( 04 - 12 ) , Editorial nits mostly , ( 04 - 15 ) , Editorial comments TO BE DISCUSSED : , ( 03 - 13 ) , Ready with Issues ( Ready , as soon as I - D.ietf - detnet - security is reviewed and becomes an RFC . ) reviewed in April 22 meeting" f95284c65618abd001877da8cfc9f18a49096d95 f95284c65618abd001877da8cfc9f18a49096d95 draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework 7c4efe66437cfbee01a00d61df6ef4d030ed30bb5727f73bcac50e7cd171243e ['7c4efe66437cfbee01a00d61df6ef4d030ed30bb5727f73bcac50e7cd171243e', '2233a210a8607a576683defdfb9ab223f16db0122bd5795c3376ac172d46337b'] A "note that along the path from en1 to r1 there may be zero or more nodes which, for clarity, are not shown. the same is true for any other path between two detnet entities shown in dn_protection_flow ." {6: 1, 79: 4, 90: 3, 51: 5, 130: 4, 62: 4, 85: 4, 68: 3, 35: 5, 110: 5, 91: 7, 114: 5, 97: 5, 31: 2, 13: 5, 67: 3, 38: 6, 26: 4, 124: 3, 98: 4, 54: 4, 127: 5, 8: 2, 96: 5, 64: 4, 30: 6, 61: 7, 55: 2, 27: 2, 15: 5, 52: 2, 129: 5, 115: 5, 84: 3, 76: 4, 87: 5, 131: 7, 102: 3, 113: 7, 99: 4, 36: 5, 24: 4, 53: 3, 72: 6} {161: 1, 1: 8, 4: 4, 9: 3, 10: 5, 15: 5, 24: 4, 25: 4, 26: 4, 27: 5, 39: 4, 43: 5, 49: 8, 50: 7, 58: 7, 59: 4, 64: 5, 69: 2, 81: 5, 82: 5, 86: 5, 96: 6, 97: 5, 100: 8, 108: 5, 109: 6, 110: 6, 111: 4, 114: 5, 115: 6, 116: 5, 118: 5, 119: 4, 120: 5, 121: 3, 122: 6, 123: 5, 124: 3, 128: 6, 129: 6, 130: 7, 132: 2, 136: 4, 145: 2, 147: 6, 151: 6, 152: 6, 154: 5, 156: 4, 162: 2, 165: 5, 168: 6, 169: 5, 172: 5, 180: 6, 184: 3, 187: 7, 188: 6, 191: 5, 202: 3, 203: 4, 206: 4, 207: 5, 215: 2, 217: 5, 218: 7, 220: 3, 221: 3, 222: 4, 224: 5, 227: 6, 229: 5, 234: 7, 235: 4, 241: 4, 242: 4, 243: 2, 244: 6, 245: 2, 248: 6, 250: 6, 258: 10, 262: 6, 263: 7, 264: 2, 267: 3, 270: 5, 272: 5, 273: 3, 287: 5, 289: 5, 291: 7, 299: 6, 300: 5, 304: 5, 309: 3, 314: 4, 315: 5, 320: 3, 323: 2, 327: 6, 328: 3, 329: 4, 330: 9, 334: 4, 335: 5, 341: 6, 342: 7, 347: 6, 348: 6, 350: 5, 351: 7, 352: 5, 353: 5, 354: 4, 358: 3, 365: 5, 366: 4, 369: 3, 371: 8, 372: 7, 376: 4, 384: 7, 385: 6, 386: 5, 387: 5, 392: 3, 393: 4, 396: 7, 397: 6, 398: 5, 402: 5} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 84 "Note that along the path from EN1 to R1 there may be zero or more nodes which, for clarity, are not shown. The same is true for any other path between two DetNet entities shown in dn_protection_flow." "IESG review comment resolutions in this version : DONE , IANA , ( 03 - 12 ) , OK , ( 03 - 15 ) , Ready with Nits Yoshifumi Nishida , ( 04 - 07 ) , Ready with Nits ( 04 - 12 ) , Editorial nits mostly , ( 04 - 15 ) , Editorial comments TO BE DISCUSSED : , ( 03 - 13 ) , Ready with Issues ( Ready , as soon as I - D.ietf - detnet - security is reviewed and becomes an RFC . ) reviewed in April 22 meeting" f95284c65618abd001877da8cfc9f18a49096d95 f95284c65618abd001877da8cfc9f18a49096d95 draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework 2233a210a8607a576683defdfb9ab223f16db0122bd5795c3376ac172d46337b ['7c4efe66437cfbee01a00d61df6ef4d030ed30bb5727f73bcac50e7cd171243e', '2233a210a8607a576683defdfb9ab223f16db0122bd5795c3376ac172d46337b'] B "note that along the path from en1 to r1 there may be zero or more nodes which, for clarity, are not shown. the same is true for any other path between two detnet entities shown in dn_protection_flow." {6: 1, 79: 4, 90: 3, 51: 5, 130: 4, 62: 4, 85: 4, 68: 3, 35: 5, 110: 5, 91: 7, 114: 5, 97: 5, 31: 2, 13: 5, 67: 3, 38: 6, 26: 4, 124: 3, 98: 4, 54: 4, 127: 5, 8: 2, 96: 5, 64: 4, 30: 6, 61: 7, 55: 2, 27: 2, 15: 5, 52: 2, 129: 5, 115: 5, 84: 3, 76: 4, 87: 5, 131: 7, 102: 3, 113: 7, 99: 4, 36: 5, 24: 4, 53: 3, 72: 6} {161: 1, 1: 8, 4: 4, 9: 3, 10: 5, 15: 5, 24: 4, 25: 4, 26: 4, 27: 5, 39: 4, 43: 5, 49: 8, 50: 7, 58: 7, 59: 4, 64: 5, 69: 2, 81: 5, 82: 5, 86: 5, 96: 6, 97: 5, 100: 8, 108: 5, 109: 6, 110: 6, 111: 4, 114: 5, 115: 6, 116: 5, 118: 5, 119: 4, 120: 5, 121: 3, 122: 6, 123: 5, 124: 3, 128: 6, 129: 6, 130: 7, 132: 2, 136: 4, 145: 2, 147: 6, 151: 6, 152: 6, 154: 5, 156: 4, 162: 2, 165: 5, 168: 6, 169: 5, 172: 5, 180: 6, 184: 3, 187: 7, 188: 6, 191: 5, 202: 3, 203: 4, 206: 4, 207: 5, 215: 2, 217: 5, 218: 7, 220: 3, 221: 3, 222: 4, 224: 5, 227: 6, 229: 5, 234: 7, 235: 4, 241: 4, 242: 4, 243: 2, 244: 6, 245: 2, 248: 6, 250: 6, 258: 10, 262: 6, 263: 7, 264: 2, 267: 3, 270: 5, 272: 5, 273: 3, 287: 5, 289: 5, 291: 7, 299: 6, 300: 5, 304: 5, 309: 3, 314: 4, 315: 5, 320: 3, 323: 2, 327: 6, 328: 3, 329: 4, 330: 9, 334: 4, 335: 5, 341: 6, 342: 7, 347: 6, 348: 6, 350: 5, 351: 7, 352: 5, 353: 5, 354: 4, 358: 3, 365: 5, 366: 4, 369: 3, 371: 8, 372: 7, 376: 4, 384: 7, 385: 6, 386: 5, 387: 5, 392: 3, 393: 4, 396: 7, 397: 6, 398: 5, 402: 5} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 84 "This example also illustrates 1:1 protection scheme meaning there is traffic over each segment of the end to end path. Local DetNet relay nodes determine which packets are eliminated and which packets are forwarded. A 1+1 scheme where only one path is used for traffic at a time, could use the same topology. In this case there is no PRF function and traffic is switched upon detection of failure. An OAM scheme that monitors the paths detects the loss of path or traffic is required to initiate the switch. A POF may still be used in this case to prevent misordering of packets. In both cases the protection paths are established and maintained for the duration of the DetNet service." "IESG review comment resolutions in this version : DONE , IANA , ( 03 - 12 ) , OK , ( 03 - 15 ) , Ready with Nits Yoshifumi Nishida , ( 04 - 07 ) , Ready with Nits ( 04 - 12 ) , Editorial nits mostly , ( 04 - 15 ) , Editorial comments TO BE DISCUSSED : , ( 03 - 13 ) , Ready with Issues ( Ready , as soon as I - D.ietf - detnet - security is reviewed and becomes an RFC . ) reviewed in April 22 meeting" f95284c65618abd001877da8cfc9f18a49096d95 f95284c65618abd001877da8cfc9f18a49096d95 draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework 9e9309b8b08938690b6c4ce01d9558354be1e89154a136fddc2be8d51e125ea2 ['803a9ecf57717ba8b7c268aac7167a4178bb6fe026c71c84f3303202affe1492', 'a3a3ddc5527b8304623f957c97dc48ac5e43fc1da5d4e51d3a07cfbc18498fb4', '9e9309b8b08938690b6c4ce01d9558354be1e89154a136fddc2be8d51e125ea2', 'ace3cdbcd28170a64f3c17e96393bde27f2ecebb3d9ac5d8cba0b4883c0ed108'] A "this example also illustrates 1:1 protection scheme meaning there is traffic over each segment of the end to end path. local detnet relay nodes determine which packets are eliminated and which packets are forwarded. a 1+1 scheme where only one path is used for traffic at a time, could use the same topology. in this case there is no prf function and traffic is switched upon detection of failure. an oam scheme that monitors the paths detects the loss of path or traffic is required to initiate the switch. a pof may still be used in this case to prevent misordering of packets. in both cases the protection paths are established and maintained for the duration of the detnet service." {76: 1, 55: 1, 6: 2, 79: 5, 90: 4, 51: 6, 130: 5, 62: 5, 85: 5, 68: 2, 35: 6, 110: 6, 91: 8, 114: 6, 97: 6, 31: 2, 13: 6, 67: 4, 38: 7, 26: 5, 124: 4, 98: 5, 54: 5, 127: 6, 8: 3, 96: 6, 64: 5, 30: 7, 61: 8, 27: 2, 15: 6, 52: 3, 129: 6, 115: 6, 84: 2, 87: 6, 131: 8, 102: 4, 113: 8, 99: 5, 36: 6, 24: 5, 53: 4, 72: 7} {203: 1, 243: 1, 1: 9, 4: 5, 9: 4, 10: 6, 15: 6, 24: 5, 25: 5, 26: 5, 27: 6, 39: 5, 43: 6, 49: 9, 50: 8, 58: 8, 59: 5, 64: 6, 69: 2, 81: 6, 82: 6, 86: 6, 96: 7, 97: 6, 100: 9, 108: 6, 109: 7, 110: 7, 111: 5, 114: 6, 115: 7, 116: 6, 118: 6, 119: 5, 120: 6, 121: 4, 122: 7, 123: 6, 124: 4, 128: 7, 129: 7, 130: 8, 132: 3, 136: 5, 145: 3, 147: 7, 151: 7, 152: 7, 154: 6, 156: 5, 161: 2, 162: 3, 165: 6, 168: 7, 169: 6, 172: 6, 180: 7, 184: 4, 187: 8, 188: 7, 191: 6, 194: 3, 206: 5, 207: 6, 215: 3, 217: 6, 218: 8, 220: 4, 221: 4, 222: 5, 224: 6, 227: 7, 229: 6, 234: 8, 235: 5, 241: 5, 242: 5, 244: 7, 245: 2, 248: 7, 250: 7, 258: 11, 262: 7, 263: 8, 264: 3, 267: 4, 270: 6, 272: 6, 273: 2, 287: 6, 289: 6, 291: 8, 299: 7, 300: 6, 304: 6, 309: 4, 314: 5, 315: 6, 320: 4, 323: 2, 327: 7, 328: 4, 329: 5, 330: 10, 334: 5, 335: 6, 341: 7, 342: 8, 347: 7, 348: 7, 350: 2, 351: 8, 352: 6, 353: 6, 354: 5, 358: 4, 365: 6, 366: 5, 369: 4, 371: 9, 372: 8, 376: 5, 384: 8, 385: 7, 386: 6, 387: 6, 392: 4, 393: 5, 396: 8, 397: 7, 398: 6, 402: 6} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 84 "In the preceding example, proper working of duplicate elimination and reordering of packets are dependent on the number of out-of-order packets that can be buffered and the delay difference of arriving packets. DetNet uses flow specific requirements (e.g., maximum number of out-of-order packets, maximum latency of the flow, etc.) for configuration of POF related buffers. If the differential delay between paths is excessively large or there is excessive mis-ordering of the packets, then packets may be dropped instead of being reordered. Likewise, PEF uses the sequence number to identify duplicate packets, and large differential delays combined with high numbers of packets may exceed the ability of the PEF to work properly." "IESG review comment resolutions in this version : DONE , IANA , ( 03 - 12 ) , OK , ( 03 - 15 ) , Ready with Nits Yoshifumi Nishida , ( 04 - 07 ) , Ready with Nits ( 04 - 12 ) , Editorial nits mostly , ( 04 - 15 ) , Editorial comments TO BE DISCUSSED : , ( 03 - 13 ) , Ready with Issues ( Ready , as soon as I - D.ietf - detnet - security is reviewed and becomes an RFC . ) reviewed in April 22 meeting" f95284c65618abd001877da8cfc9f18a49096d95 f95284c65618abd001877da8cfc9f18a49096d95 draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework 803a9ecf57717ba8b7c268aac7167a4178bb6fe026c71c84f3303202affe1492 ['803a9ecf57717ba8b7c268aac7167a4178bb6fe026c71c84f3303202affe1492', 'a3a3ddc5527b8304623f957c97dc48ac5e43fc1da5d4e51d3a07cfbc18498fb4', '9e9309b8b08938690b6c4ce01d9558354be1e89154a136fddc2be8d51e125ea2', 'ace3cdbcd28170a64f3c17e96393bde27f2ecebb3d9ac5d8cba0b4883c0ed108'] A "in the preceding example, proper working of duplicate elimination and reordering of packets are dependent on the number of out-of-order packets that can be buffered and the delay difference of arriving packets. detnet uses flow specific requirements (e.g., maximum number of out-of-order packets, maximum latency of the flow, etc.) for configuration of pof related buffers. if the differential delay between paths is excessively large or there is excessive mis-ordering of the packets, then packets may be dropped instead of being reordered. likewise, pef uses the sequence number to identify duplicate packets, and large differential delays combined with high numbers of packets may exceed the ability of the pef to work properly." {76: 1, 55: 1, 6: 2, 79: 5, 90: 4, 51: 6, 130: 5, 62: 5, 85: 5, 68: 2, 35: 6, 110: 6, 91: 8, 114: 6, 97: 6, 31: 2, 13: 6, 67: 4, 38: 7, 26: 5, 124: 4, 98: 5, 54: 5, 127: 6, 8: 3, 96: 6, 64: 5, 30: 7, 61: 8, 27: 2, 15: 6, 52: 3, 129: 6, 115: 6, 84: 2, 87: 6, 131: 8, 102: 4, 113: 8, 99: 5, 36: 6, 24: 5, 53: 4, 72: 7} {203: 1, 243: 1, 1: 9, 4: 5, 9: 4, 10: 6, 15: 6, 24: 5, 25: 5, 26: 5, 27: 6, 39: 5, 43: 6, 49: 9, 50: 8, 58: 8, 59: 5, 64: 6, 69: 2, 81: 6, 82: 6, 86: 6, 96: 7, 97: 6, 100: 9, 108: 6, 109: 7, 110: 7, 111: 5, 114: 6, 115: 7, 116: 6, 118: 6, 119: 5, 120: 6, 121: 4, 122: 7, 123: 6, 124: 4, 128: 7, 129: 7, 130: 8, 132: 3, 136: 5, 145: 3, 147: 7, 151: 7, 152: 7, 154: 6, 156: 5, 161: 2, 162: 3, 165: 6, 168: 7, 169: 6, 172: 6, 180: 7, 184: 4, 187: 8, 188: 7, 191: 6, 194: 3, 206: 5, 207: 6, 215: 3, 217: 6, 218: 8, 220: 4, 221: 4, 222: 5, 224: 6, 227: 7, 229: 6, 234: 8, 235: 5, 241: 5, 242: 5, 244: 7, 245: 2, 248: 7, 250: 7, 258: 11, 262: 7, 263: 8, 264: 3, 267: 4, 270: 6, 272: 6, 273: 2, 287: 6, 289: 6, 291: 8, 299: 7, 300: 6, 304: 6, 309: 4, 314: 5, 315: 6, 320: 4, 323: 2, 327: 7, 328: 4, 329: 5, 330: 10, 334: 5, 335: 6, 341: 7, 342: 8, 347: 7, 348: 7, 350: 2, 351: 8, 352: 6, 353: 6, 354: 5, 358: 4, 365: 6, 366: 5, 369: 4, 371: 9, 372: 8, 376: 5, 384: 8, 385: 7, 386: 6, 387: 6, 392: 4, 393: 5, 396: 8, 397: 7, 398: 6, 402: 6} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 84 "This example also illustrates 1:1 protection scheme meaning there is traffic over each segment of the end-to-end path. Local DetNet relay nodes determine which packets are eliminated and which packets are forwarded. A 1+1 scheme where only one path is used for traffic at a time could use the same topology. In this case there is no PRF function and traffic is switched upon detection of failure. An OAM scheme that monitors the paths to detect the loss of path or traffic is required to initiate the switch. A POF may still be used in this case to prevent misordering of packets. In both cases the protection paths are established and maintained for the duration of the DetNet service." "IESG review comment resolutions in this version : DONE , IANA , ( 03 - 12 ) , OK , ( 03 - 15 ) , Ready with Nits Yoshifumi Nishida , ( 04 - 07 ) , Ready with Nits ( 04 - 12 ) , Editorial nits mostly , ( 04 - 15 ) , Editorial comments TO BE DISCUSSED : , ( 03 - 13 ) , Ready with Issues ( Ready , as soon as I - D.ietf - detnet - security is reviewed and becomes an RFC . ) reviewed in April 22 meeting" f95284c65618abd001877da8cfc9f18a49096d95 f95284c65618abd001877da8cfc9f18a49096d95 draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework a3a3ddc5527b8304623f957c97dc48ac5e43fc1da5d4e51d3a07cfbc18498fb4 ['803a9ecf57717ba8b7c268aac7167a4178bb6fe026c71c84f3303202affe1492', 'a3a3ddc5527b8304623f957c97dc48ac5e43fc1da5d4e51d3a07cfbc18498fb4', '9e9309b8b08938690b6c4ce01d9558354be1e89154a136fddc2be8d51e125ea2', 'ace3cdbcd28170a64f3c17e96393bde27f2ecebb3d9ac5d8cba0b4883c0ed108'] B "this example also illustrates 1:1 protection scheme meaning there is traffic over each segment of the end-to-end path. local detnet relay nodes determine which packets are eliminated and which packets are forwarded. a 1+1 scheme where only one path is used for traffic at a time could use the same topology. in this case there is no prf function and traffic is switched upon detection of failure. an oam scheme that monitors the paths to detect the loss of path or traffic is required to initiate the switch. a pof may still be used in this case to prevent misordering of packets. in both cases the protection paths are established and maintained for the duration of the detnet service." {76: 1, 55: 1, 6: 2, 79: 5, 90: 4, 51: 6, 130: 5, 62: 5, 85: 5, 68: 2, 35: 6, 110: 6, 91: 8, 114: 6, 97: 6, 31: 2, 13: 6, 67: 4, 38: 7, 26: 5, 124: 4, 98: 5, 54: 5, 127: 6, 8: 3, 96: 6, 64: 5, 30: 7, 61: 8, 27: 2, 15: 6, 52: 3, 129: 6, 115: 6, 84: 2, 87: 6, 131: 8, 102: 4, 113: 8, 99: 5, 36: 6, 24: 5, 53: 4, 72: 7} {203: 1, 243: 1, 1: 9, 4: 5, 9: 4, 10: 6, 15: 6, 24: 5, 25: 5, 26: 5, 27: 6, 39: 5, 43: 6, 49: 9, 50: 8, 58: 8, 59: 5, 64: 6, 69: 2, 81: 6, 82: 6, 86: 6, 96: 7, 97: 6, 100: 9, 108: 6, 109: 7, 110: 7, 111: 5, 114: 6, 115: 7, 116: 6, 118: 6, 119: 5, 120: 6, 121: 4, 122: 7, 123: 6, 124: 4, 128: 7, 129: 7, 130: 8, 132: 3, 136: 5, 145: 3, 147: 7, 151: 7, 152: 7, 154: 6, 156: 5, 161: 2, 162: 3, 165: 6, 168: 7, 169: 6, 172: 6, 180: 7, 184: 4, 187: 8, 188: 7, 191: 6, 194: 3, 206: 5, 207: 6, 215: 3, 217: 6, 218: 8, 220: 4, 221: 4, 222: 5, 224: 6, 227: 7, 229: 6, 234: 8, 235: 5, 241: 5, 242: 5, 244: 7, 245: 2, 248: 7, 250: 7, 258: 11, 262: 7, 263: 8, 264: 3, 267: 4, 270: 6, 272: 6, 273: 2, 287: 6, 289: 6, 291: 8, 299: 7, 300: 6, 304: 6, 309: 4, 314: 5, 315: 6, 320: 4, 323: 2, 327: 7, 328: 4, 329: 5, 330: 10, 334: 5, 335: 6, 341: 7, 342: 8, 347: 7, 348: 7, 350: 2, 351: 8, 352: 6, 353: 6, 354: 5, 358: 4, 365: 6, 366: 5, 369: 4, 371: 9, 372: 8, 376: 5, 384: 8, 385: 7, 386: 6, 387: 6, 392: 4, 393: 5, 396: 8, 397: 7, 398: 6, 402: 6} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 84 "In the preceding example, proper working of duplicate elimination and reordering of packets are dependent on the number of out-of-order packets that can be buffered and the delay difference of arriving packets. DetNet uses flow-specific requirements (e.g., maximum number of out-of-order packets, maximum latency of the flow) for configuration of POF-related buffers. If the differential delay between paths is excessively large or there is excessive mis-ordering of the packets, then packets may be dropped instead of being reordered. Likewise, PEF uses the sequence number to identify duplicate packets, and large differential delays combined with high numbers of packets may exceed the ability of the PEF to work properly." "IESG review comment resolutions in this version : DONE , IANA , ( 03 - 12 ) , OK , ( 03 - 15 ) , Ready with Nits Yoshifumi Nishida , ( 04 - 07 ) , Ready with Nits ( 04 - 12 ) , Editorial nits mostly , ( 04 - 15 ) , Editorial comments TO BE DISCUSSED : , ( 03 - 13 ) , Ready with Issues ( Ready , as soon as I - D.ietf - detnet - security is reviewed and becomes an RFC . ) reviewed in April 22 meeting" f95284c65618abd001877da8cfc9f18a49096d95 f95284c65618abd001877da8cfc9f18a49096d95 draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework ace3cdbcd28170a64f3c17e96393bde27f2ecebb3d9ac5d8cba0b4883c0ed108 ['803a9ecf57717ba8b7c268aac7167a4178bb6fe026c71c84f3303202affe1492', 'a3a3ddc5527b8304623f957c97dc48ac5e43fc1da5d4e51d3a07cfbc18498fb4', '9e9309b8b08938690b6c4ce01d9558354be1e89154a136fddc2be8d51e125ea2', 'ace3cdbcd28170a64f3c17e96393bde27f2ecebb3d9ac5d8cba0b4883c0ed108'] B "in the preceding example, proper working of duplicate elimination and reordering of packets are dependent on the number of out-of-order packets that can be buffered and the delay difference of arriving packets. detnet uses flow-specific requirements (e.g., maximum number of out-of-order packets, maximum latency of the flow) for configuration of pof-related buffers. if the differential delay between paths is excessively large or there is excessive mis-ordering of the packets, then packets may be dropped instead of being reordered. likewise, pef uses the sequence number to identify duplicate packets, and large differential delays combined with high numbers of packets may exceed the ability of the pef to work properly." {76: 1, 55: 1, 6: 2, 79: 5, 90: 4, 51: 6, 130: 5, 62: 5, 85: 5, 68: 2, 35: 6, 110: 6, 91: 8, 114: 6, 97: 6, 31: 2, 13: 6, 67: 4, 38: 7, 26: 5, 124: 4, 98: 5, 54: 5, 127: 6, 8: 3, 96: 6, 64: 5, 30: 7, 61: 8, 27: 2, 15: 6, 52: 3, 129: 6, 115: 6, 84: 2, 87: 6, 131: 8, 102: 4, 113: 8, 99: 5, 36: 6, 24: 5, 53: 4, 72: 7} {203: 1, 243: 1, 1: 9, 4: 5, 9: 4, 10: 6, 15: 6, 24: 5, 25: 5, 26: 5, 27: 6, 39: 5, 43: 6, 49: 9, 50: 8, 58: 8, 59: 5, 64: 6, 69: 2, 81: 6, 82: 6, 86: 6, 96: 7, 97: 6, 100: 9, 108: 6, 109: 7, 110: 7, 111: 5, 114: 6, 115: 7, 116: 6, 118: 6, 119: 5, 120: 6, 121: 4, 122: 7, 123: 6, 124: 4, 128: 7, 129: 7, 130: 8, 132: 3, 136: 5, 145: 3, 147: 7, 151: 7, 152: 7, 154: 6, 156: 5, 161: 2, 162: 3, 165: 6, 168: 7, 169: 6, 172: 6, 180: 7, 184: 4, 187: 8, 188: 7, 191: 6, 194: 3, 206: 5, 207: 6, 215: 3, 217: 6, 218: 8, 220: 4, 221: 4, 222: 5, 224: 6, 227: 7, 229: 6, 234: 8, 235: 5, 241: 5, 242: 5, 244: 7, 245: 2, 248: 7, 250: 7, 258: 11, 262: 7, 263: 8, 264: 3, 267: 4, 270: 6, 272: 6, 273: 2, 287: 6, 289: 6, 291: 8, 299: 7, 300: 6, 304: 6, 309: 4, 314: 5, 315: 6, 320: 4, 323: 2, 327: 7, 328: 4, 329: 5, 330: 10, 334: 5, 335: 6, 341: 7, 342: 8, 347: 7, 348: 7, 350: 2, 351: 8, 352: 6, 353: 6, 354: 5, 358: 4, 365: 6, 366: 5, 369: 4, 371: 9, 372: 8, 376: 5, 384: 8, 385: 7, 386: 6, 387: 6, 392: 4, 393: 5, 396: 8, 397: 7, 398: 6, 402: 6} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 84 "Ring protection may also be supported if the underlying technology supports it. Many of the same concepts apply however rings are normally 1+1 protection for data efficiency reasons. RFC8227 is an example of MPLS-TP data plane that supports Ring protection." "IESG review comment resolutions in this version : DONE , IANA , ( 03 - 12 ) , OK , ( 03 - 15 ) , Ready with Nits Yoshifumi Nishida , ( 04 - 07 ) , Ready with Nits ( 04 - 12 ) , Editorial nits mostly , ( 04 - 15 ) , Editorial comments TO BE DISCUSSED : , ( 03 - 13 ) , Ready with Issues ( Ready , as soon as I - D.ietf - detnet - security is reviewed and becomes an RFC . ) reviewed in April 22 meeting" f95284c65618abd001877da8cfc9f18a49096d95 f95284c65618abd001877da8cfc9f18a49096d95 draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework 786ebf4d558af2b0bf12537895bec65737b19e4f3e70521436cf1d8c1ef76ab0 ['af5eb17e01686194e0ed7768da488772dd45e4ccee3c93265023f7d3bab467e8', '3a5df463c16a91a436518238c6f83b2a3f5c5dff933dc2331135f2e1ff783ff0', '348305afe3633e23dfb47aabccd6c1c8bea4a4d715a2d1887410dc2ce260cd62', 'f507abc6f0c89ad2171679d7fa41df6fcbbec870b5ebb589d4b1816cbc434aa7', 'cb36b3e74a93b3557fc45abc21839977e6a029bca7aee6c63148321383721bb6', '7c6c581d25fee738abd981ab0cf9ae13e5a3c473d98a8a8c8bb18b1a334901a7', '786ebf4d558af2b0bf12537895bec65737b19e4f3e70521436cf1d8c1ef76ab0', 'd6b8581165ce4de94d63adc76a5eb1f9d02d042d44a133a85cdad114720ee5b2'] A "ring protection may also be supported if the underlying technology supports it. many of the same concepts apply however rings are normally 1+1 protection for data efficiency reasons. rfc8227 is an example of mpls-tp data plane that supports ring protection." {55: 1, 6: 2, 79: 5, 90: 4, 51: 6, 130: 5, 62: 5, 85: 5, 68: 4, 35: 6, 110: 6, 91: 8, 114: 6, 97: 6, 31: 2, 13: 6, 67: 4, 38: 7, 26: 5, 124: 4, 98: 5, 54: 5, 127: 6, 8: 3, 96: 6, 64: 5, 30: 7, 61: 8, 27: 2, 15: 6, 52: 3, 129: 6, 115: 6, 84: 2, 76: 3, 87: 6, 131: 8, 102: 4, 113: 8, 99: 5, 36: 6, 24: 5, 53: 4, 72: 7} {243: 1, 1: 9, 4: 5, 9: 4, 10: 6, 15: 6, 24: 5, 25: 5, 26: 5, 27: 6, 39: 5, 43: 6, 49: 9, 50: 8, 58: 8, 59: 5, 64: 6, 69: 2, 81: 6, 82: 6, 86: 6, 96: 7, 97: 6, 100: 9, 108: 6, 109: 7, 110: 7, 111: 5, 114: 6, 115: 7, 116: 6, 118: 6, 119: 5, 120: 6, 121: 4, 122: 7, 123: 6, 124: 4, 128: 7, 129: 7, 130: 8, 132: 3, 136: 5, 145: 3, 147: 7, 151: 7, 152: 7, 154: 6, 156: 5, 161: 2, 162: 3, 165: 6, 168: 7, 169: 6, 172: 6, 180: 7, 184: 4, 187: 8, 188: 7, 191: 6, 194: 3, 202: 2, 203: 3, 206: 5, 207: 6, 215: 3, 217: 6, 218: 8, 220: 4, 221: 4, 222: 5, 224: 6, 227: 7, 229: 6, 234: 8, 235: 5, 241: 5, 242: 5, 244: 7, 245: 2, 248: 7, 250: 7, 258: 11, 262: 7, 263: 8, 264: 3, 267: 4, 270: 6, 272: 6, 287: 6, 289: 6, 291: 8, 299: 7, 300: 6, 304: 6, 309: 4, 314: 5, 315: 6, 320: 4, 323: 2, 327: 7, 328: 4, 329: 5, 330: 10, 334: 5, 335: 6, 341: 7, 342: 8, 347: 7, 348: 7, 350: 4, 351: 8, 352: 6, 353: 6, 354: 5, 358: 4, 365: 6, 366: 5, 369: 4, 371: 9, 372: 8, 376: 5, 384: 8, 385: 7, 386: 6, 387: 6, 392: 4, 393: 5, 396: 8, 397: 7, 398: 6, 402: 6} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 84 "The DetNet data plane also allows for the aggregation of DetNet flows, which can improve scalability by reducing the per-hop state. How this is accomplished is data plane or control plane dependent. When DetNet flows are aggregated, transit nodes provide service to the aggregate and not on a per-DetNet flow basis. When aggregating DetNet flows the flows should be compatible i.e. the same or very similar QoS and CoS characteristics. In this case, nodes performing aggregation will ensure that per-flow service requirements are achieved." "IESG review comment resolutions in this version : DONE , IANA , ( 03 - 12 ) , OK , ( 03 - 15 ) , Ready with Nits Yoshifumi Nishida , ( 04 - 07 ) , Ready with Nits ( 04 - 12 ) , Editorial nits mostly , ( 04 - 15 ) , Editorial comments TO BE DISCUSSED : , ( 03 - 13 ) , Ready with Issues ( Ready , as soon as I - D.ietf - detnet - security is reviewed and becomes an RFC . ) reviewed in April 22 meeting" f95284c65618abd001877da8cfc9f18a49096d95 f95284c65618abd001877da8cfc9f18a49096d95 draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework cb36b3e74a93b3557fc45abc21839977e6a029bca7aee6c63148321383721bb6 ['af5eb17e01686194e0ed7768da488772dd45e4ccee3c93265023f7d3bab467e8', '3a5df463c16a91a436518238c6f83b2a3f5c5dff933dc2331135f2e1ff783ff0', '348305afe3633e23dfb47aabccd6c1c8bea4a4d715a2d1887410dc2ce260cd62', 'f507abc6f0c89ad2171679d7fa41df6fcbbec870b5ebb589d4b1816cbc434aa7', 'cb36b3e74a93b3557fc45abc21839977e6a029bca7aee6c63148321383721bb6', '7c6c581d25fee738abd981ab0cf9ae13e5a3c473d98a8a8c8bb18b1a334901a7', '786ebf4d558af2b0bf12537895bec65737b19e4f3e70521436cf1d8c1ef76ab0', 'd6b8581165ce4de94d63adc76a5eb1f9d02d042d44a133a85cdad114720ee5b2'] A "the detnet data plane also allows for the aggregation of detnet flows, which can improve scalability by reducing the per-hop state. how this is accomplished is data plane or control plane dependent. when detnet flows are aggregated, transit nodes provide service to the aggregate and not on a per-detnet flow basis. when aggregating detnet flows the flows should be compatible i.e. the same or very similar qos and cos characteristics. in this case, nodes performing aggregation will ensure that per-flow service requirements are achieved." {55: 1, 6: 2, 79: 5, 90: 4, 51: 6, 130: 5, 62: 5, 85: 5, 68: 4, 35: 6, 110: 6, 91: 8, 114: 6, 97: 6, 31: 2, 13: 6, 67: 4, 38: 7, 26: 5, 124: 4, 98: 5, 54: 5, 127: 6, 8: 3, 96: 6, 64: 5, 30: 7, 61: 8, 27: 2, 15: 6, 52: 3, 129: 6, 115: 6, 84: 2, 76: 3, 87: 6, 131: 8, 102: 4, 113: 8, 99: 5, 36: 6, 24: 5, 53: 4, 72: 7} {243: 1, 1: 9, 4: 5, 9: 4, 10: 6, 15: 6, 24: 5, 25: 5, 26: 5, 27: 6, 39: 5, 43: 6, 49: 9, 50: 8, 58: 8, 59: 5, 64: 6, 69: 2, 81: 6, 82: 6, 86: 6, 96: 7, 97: 6, 100: 9, 108: 6, 109: 7, 110: 7, 111: 5, 114: 6, 115: 7, 116: 6, 118: 6, 119: 5, 120: 6, 121: 4, 122: 7, 123: 6, 124: 4, 128: 7, 129: 7, 130: 8, 132: 3, 136: 5, 145: 3, 147: 7, 151: 7, 152: 7, 154: 6, 156: 5, 161: 2, 162: 3, 165: 6, 168: 7, 169: 6, 172: 6, 180: 7, 184: 4, 187: 8, 188: 7, 191: 6, 194: 3, 202: 2, 203: 3, 206: 5, 207: 6, 215: 3, 217: 6, 218: 8, 220: 4, 221: 4, 222: 5, 224: 6, 227: 7, 229: 6, 234: 8, 235: 5, 241: 5, 242: 5, 244: 7, 245: 2, 248: 7, 250: 7, 258: 11, 262: 7, 263: 8, 264: 3, 267: 4, 270: 6, 272: 6, 287: 6, 289: 6, 291: 8, 299: 7, 300: 6, 304: 6, 309: 4, 314: 5, 315: 6, 320: 4, 323: 2, 327: 7, 328: 4, 329: 5, 330: 10, 334: 5, 335: 6, 341: 7, 342: 8, 347: 7, 348: 7, 350: 4, 351: 8, 352: 6, 353: 6, 354: 5, 358: 4, 365: 6, 366: 5, 369: 4, 371: 9, 372: 8, 376: 5, 384: 8, 385: 7, 386: 6, 387: 6, 392: 4, 393: 5, 396: 8, 397: 7, 398: 6, 402: 6} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 84 "If bandwidth reservations are used, the sum of the reservations should be the sum of all the individual reservations; in other words, the reservations should not add up to an over-subscription of bandwidth reservation. If maximum delay bounds are used, the system should ensure that the aggregate does not exceed the delay bounds of the individual flows." "IESG review comment resolutions in this version : DONE , IANA , ( 03 - 12 ) , OK , ( 03 - 15 ) , Ready with Nits Yoshifumi Nishida , ( 04 - 07 ) , Ready with Nits ( 04 - 12 ) , Editorial nits mostly , ( 04 - 15 ) , Editorial comments TO BE DISCUSSED : , ( 03 - 13 ) , Ready with Issues ( Ready , as soon as I - D.ietf - detnet - security is reviewed and becomes an RFC . ) reviewed in April 22 meeting" f95284c65618abd001877da8cfc9f18a49096d95 f95284c65618abd001877da8cfc9f18a49096d95 draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework f507abc6f0c89ad2171679d7fa41df6fcbbec870b5ebb589d4b1816cbc434aa7 ['af5eb17e01686194e0ed7768da488772dd45e4ccee3c93265023f7d3bab467e8', '3a5df463c16a91a436518238c6f83b2a3f5c5dff933dc2331135f2e1ff783ff0', '348305afe3633e23dfb47aabccd6c1c8bea4a4d715a2d1887410dc2ce260cd62', 'f507abc6f0c89ad2171679d7fa41df6fcbbec870b5ebb589d4b1816cbc434aa7', 'cb36b3e74a93b3557fc45abc21839977e6a029bca7aee6c63148321383721bb6', '7c6c581d25fee738abd981ab0cf9ae13e5a3c473d98a8a8c8bb18b1a334901a7', '786ebf4d558af2b0bf12537895bec65737b19e4f3e70521436cf1d8c1ef76ab0', 'd6b8581165ce4de94d63adc76a5eb1f9d02d042d44a133a85cdad114720ee5b2'] A "if bandwidth reservations are used, the sum of the reservations should be the sum of all the individual reservations; in other words, the reservations should not add up to an over-subscription of bandwidth reservation. if maximum delay bounds are used, the system should ensure that the aggregate does not exceed the delay bounds of the individual flows." {55: 1, 6: 2, 79: 5, 90: 4, 51: 6, 130: 5, 62: 5, 85: 5, 68: 4, 35: 6, 110: 6, 91: 8, 114: 6, 97: 6, 31: 2, 13: 6, 67: 4, 38: 7, 26: 5, 124: 4, 98: 5, 54: 5, 127: 6, 8: 3, 96: 6, 64: 5, 30: 7, 61: 8, 27: 2, 15: 6, 52: 3, 129: 6, 115: 6, 84: 2, 76: 3, 87: 6, 131: 8, 102: 4, 113: 8, 99: 5, 36: 6, 24: 5, 53: 4, 72: 7} {243: 1, 1: 9, 4: 5, 9: 4, 10: 6, 15: 6, 24: 5, 25: 5, 26: 5, 27: 6, 39: 5, 43: 6, 49: 9, 50: 8, 58: 8, 59: 5, 64: 6, 69: 2, 81: 6, 82: 6, 86: 6, 96: 7, 97: 6, 100: 9, 108: 6, 109: 7, 110: 7, 111: 5, 114: 6, 115: 7, 116: 6, 118: 6, 119: 5, 120: 6, 121: 4, 122: 7, 123: 6, 124: 4, 128: 7, 129: 7, 130: 8, 132: 3, 136: 5, 145: 3, 147: 7, 151: 7, 152: 7, 154: 6, 156: 5, 161: 2, 162: 3, 165: 6, 168: 7, 169: 6, 172: 6, 180: 7, 184: 4, 187: 8, 188: 7, 191: 6, 194: 3, 202: 2, 203: 3, 206: 5, 207: 6, 215: 3, 217: 6, 218: 8, 220: 4, 221: 4, 222: 5, 224: 6, 227: 7, 229: 6, 234: 8, 235: 5, 241: 5, 242: 5, 244: 7, 245: 2, 248: 7, 250: 7, 258: 11, 262: 7, 263: 8, 264: 3, 267: 4, 270: 6, 272: 6, 287: 6, 289: 6, 291: 8, 299: 7, 300: 6, 304: 6, 309: 4, 314: 5, 315: 6, 320: 4, 323: 2, 327: 7, 328: 4, 329: 5, 330: 10, 334: 5, 335: 6, 341: 7, 342: 8, 347: 7, 348: 7, 350: 4, 351: 8, 352: 6, 353: 6, 354: 5, 358: 4, 365: 6, 366: 5, 369: 4, 371: 9, 372: 8, 376: 5, 384: 8, 385: 7, 386: 6, 387: 6, 392: 4, 393: 5, 396: 8, 397: 7, 398: 6, 402: 6} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 84 "When an encapsulation is used the choice of reserving a maximum resource level and then tracking the services in the aggregated service or adjusting the aggregated resources as the services are added is implementation and technology specific." "IESG review comment resolutions in this version : DONE , IANA , ( 03 - 12 ) , OK , ( 03 - 15 ) , Ready with Nits Yoshifumi Nishida , ( 04 - 07 ) , Ready with Nits ( 04 - 12 ) , Editorial nits mostly , ( 04 - 15 ) , Editorial comments TO BE DISCUSSED : , ( 03 - 13 ) , Ready with Issues ( Ready , as soon as I - D.ietf - detnet - security is reviewed and becomes an RFC . ) reviewed in April 22 meeting" f95284c65618abd001877da8cfc9f18a49096d95 f95284c65618abd001877da8cfc9f18a49096d95 draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework d6b8581165ce4de94d63adc76a5eb1f9d02d042d44a133a85cdad114720ee5b2 ['af5eb17e01686194e0ed7768da488772dd45e4ccee3c93265023f7d3bab467e8', '3a5df463c16a91a436518238c6f83b2a3f5c5dff933dc2331135f2e1ff783ff0', '348305afe3633e23dfb47aabccd6c1c8bea4a4d715a2d1887410dc2ce260cd62', 'f507abc6f0c89ad2171679d7fa41df6fcbbec870b5ebb589d4b1816cbc434aa7', 'cb36b3e74a93b3557fc45abc21839977e6a029bca7aee6c63148321383721bb6', '7c6c581d25fee738abd981ab0cf9ae13e5a3c473d98a8a8c8bb18b1a334901a7', '786ebf4d558af2b0bf12537895bec65737b19e4f3e70521436cf1d8c1ef76ab0', 'd6b8581165ce4de94d63adc76a5eb1f9d02d042d44a133a85cdad114720ee5b2'] A "when an encapsulation is used the choice of reserving a maximum resource level and then tracking the services in the aggregated service or adjusting the aggregated resources as the services are added is implementation and technology specific." {55: 1, 6: 2, 79: 5, 90: 4, 51: 6, 130: 5, 62: 5, 85: 5, 68: 4, 35: 6, 110: 6, 91: 8, 114: 6, 97: 6, 31: 2, 13: 6, 67: 4, 38: 7, 26: 5, 124: 4, 98: 5, 54: 5, 127: 6, 8: 3, 96: 6, 64: 5, 30: 7, 61: 8, 27: 2, 15: 6, 52: 3, 129: 6, 115: 6, 84: 2, 76: 3, 87: 6, 131: 8, 102: 4, 113: 8, 99: 5, 36: 6, 24: 5, 53: 4, 72: 7} {243: 1, 1: 9, 4: 5, 9: 4, 10: 6, 15: 6, 24: 5, 25: 5, 26: 5, 27: 6, 39: 5, 43: 6, 49: 9, 50: 8, 58: 8, 59: 5, 64: 6, 69: 2, 81: 6, 82: 6, 86: 6, 96: 7, 97: 6, 100: 9, 108: 6, 109: 7, 110: 7, 111: 5, 114: 6, 115: 7, 116: 6, 118: 6, 119: 5, 120: 6, 121: 4, 122: 7, 123: 6, 124: 4, 128: 7, 129: 7, 130: 8, 132: 3, 136: 5, 145: 3, 147: 7, 151: 7, 152: 7, 154: 6, 156: 5, 161: 2, 162: 3, 165: 6, 168: 7, 169: 6, 172: 6, 180: 7, 184: 4, 187: 8, 188: 7, 191: 6, 194: 3, 202: 2, 203: 3, 206: 5, 207: 6, 215: 3, 217: 6, 218: 8, 220: 4, 221: 4, 222: 5, 224: 6, 227: 7, 229: 6, 234: 8, 235: 5, 241: 5, 242: 5, 244: 7, 245: 2, 248: 7, 250: 7, 258: 11, 262: 7, 263: 8, 264: 3, 267: 4, 270: 6, 272: 6, 287: 6, 289: 6, 291: 8, 299: 7, 300: 6, 304: 6, 309: 4, 314: 5, 315: 6, 320: 4, 323: 2, 327: 7, 328: 4, 329: 5, 330: 10, 334: 5, 335: 6, 341: 7, 342: 8, 347: 7, 348: 7, 350: 4, 351: 8, 352: 6, 353: 6, 354: 5, 358: 4, 365: 6, 366: 5, 369: 4, 371: 9, 372: 8, 376: 5, 384: 8, 385: 7, 386: 6, 387: 6, 392: 4, 393: 5, 396: 8, 397: 7, 398: 6, 402: 6} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 84 "Ring protection may also be supported if the underlying technology supports it. Many of the same concepts apply, however rings are normally 1+1 protection for data efficiency reasons. RFC8227 is an example of MPLS-TP data plane that supports Ring protection." "IESG review comment resolutions in this version : DONE , IANA , ( 03 - 12 ) , OK , ( 03 - 15 ) , Ready with Nits Yoshifumi Nishida , ( 04 - 07 ) , Ready with Nits ( 04 - 12 ) , Editorial nits mostly , ( 04 - 15 ) , Editorial comments TO BE DISCUSSED : , ( 03 - 13 ) , Ready with Issues ( Ready , as soon as I - D.ietf - detnet - security is reviewed and becomes an RFC . ) reviewed in April 22 meeting" f95284c65618abd001877da8cfc9f18a49096d95 f95284c65618abd001877da8cfc9f18a49096d95 draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework af5eb17e01686194e0ed7768da488772dd45e4ccee3c93265023f7d3bab467e8 ['af5eb17e01686194e0ed7768da488772dd45e4ccee3c93265023f7d3bab467e8', '3a5df463c16a91a436518238c6f83b2a3f5c5dff933dc2331135f2e1ff783ff0', '348305afe3633e23dfb47aabccd6c1c8bea4a4d715a2d1887410dc2ce260cd62', 'f507abc6f0c89ad2171679d7fa41df6fcbbec870b5ebb589d4b1816cbc434aa7', 'cb36b3e74a93b3557fc45abc21839977e6a029bca7aee6c63148321383721bb6', '7c6c581d25fee738abd981ab0cf9ae13e5a3c473d98a8a8c8bb18b1a334901a7', '786ebf4d558af2b0bf12537895bec65737b19e4f3e70521436cf1d8c1ef76ab0', 'd6b8581165ce4de94d63adc76a5eb1f9d02d042d44a133a85cdad114720ee5b2'] B "ring protection may also be supported if the underlying technology supports it. many of the same concepts apply, however rings are normally 1+1 protection for data efficiency reasons. rfc8227 is an example of mpls-tp data plane that supports ring protection." {55: 1, 6: 2, 79: 5, 90: 4, 51: 6, 130: 5, 62: 5, 85: 5, 68: 4, 35: 6, 110: 6, 91: 8, 114: 6, 97: 6, 31: 2, 13: 6, 67: 4, 38: 7, 26: 5, 124: 4, 98: 5, 54: 5, 127: 6, 8: 3, 96: 6, 64: 5, 30: 7, 61: 8, 27: 2, 15: 6, 52: 3, 129: 6, 115: 6, 84: 2, 76: 3, 87: 6, 131: 8, 102: 4, 113: 8, 99: 5, 36: 6, 24: 5, 53: 4, 72: 7} {243: 1, 1: 9, 4: 5, 9: 4, 10: 6, 15: 6, 24: 5, 25: 5, 26: 5, 27: 6, 39: 5, 43: 6, 49: 9, 50: 8, 58: 8, 59: 5, 64: 6, 69: 2, 81: 6, 82: 6, 86: 6, 96: 7, 97: 6, 100: 9, 108: 6, 109: 7, 110: 7, 111: 5, 114: 6, 115: 7, 116: 6, 118: 6, 119: 5, 120: 6, 121: 4, 122: 7, 123: 6, 124: 4, 128: 7, 129: 7, 130: 8, 132: 3, 136: 5, 145: 3, 147: 7, 151: 7, 152: 7, 154: 6, 156: 5, 161: 2, 162: 3, 165: 6, 168: 7, 169: 6, 172: 6, 180: 7, 184: 4, 187: 8, 188: 7, 191: 6, 194: 3, 202: 2, 203: 3, 206: 5, 207: 6, 215: 3, 217: 6, 218: 8, 220: 4, 221: 4, 222: 5, 224: 6, 227: 7, 229: 6, 234: 8, 235: 5, 241: 5, 242: 5, 244: 7, 245: 2, 248: 7, 250: 7, 258: 11, 262: 7, 263: 8, 264: 3, 267: 4, 270: 6, 272: 6, 287: 6, 289: 6, 291: 8, 299: 7, 300: 6, 304: 6, 309: 4, 314: 5, 315: 6, 320: 4, 323: 2, 327: 7, 328: 4, 329: 5, 330: 10, 334: 5, 335: 6, 341: 7, 342: 8, 347: 7, 348: 7, 350: 4, 351: 8, 352: 6, 353: 6, 354: 5, 358: 4, 365: 6, 366: 5, 369: 4, 371: 9, 372: 8, 376: 5, 384: 8, 385: 7, 386: 6, 387: 6, 392: 4, 393: 5, 396: 8, 397: 7, 398: 6, 402: 6} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 84 "The DetNet data plane also allows for the aggregation of DetNet flows, which can improve scalability by reducing the per-hop state. How this is accomplished is data plane or control plane dependent. When DetNet flows are aggregated, transit nodes provide service to the aggregate and not on a per-DetNet flow basis. When aggregating DetNet flows, the flows should be compatible, i.e., the same or very similar QoS and CoS characteristics. In this case, nodes performing aggregation will ensure that per-flow service requirements are achieved." "IESG review comment resolutions in this version : DONE , IANA , ( 03 - 12 ) , OK , ( 03 - 15 ) , Ready with Nits Yoshifumi Nishida , ( 04 - 07 ) , Ready with Nits ( 04 - 12 ) , Editorial nits mostly , ( 04 - 15 ) , Editorial comments TO BE DISCUSSED : , ( 03 - 13 ) , Ready with Issues ( Ready , as soon as I - D.ietf - detnet - security is reviewed and becomes an RFC . ) reviewed in April 22 meeting" f95284c65618abd001877da8cfc9f18a49096d95 f95284c65618abd001877da8cfc9f18a49096d95 draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework 3a5df463c16a91a436518238c6f83b2a3f5c5dff933dc2331135f2e1ff783ff0 ['af5eb17e01686194e0ed7768da488772dd45e4ccee3c93265023f7d3bab467e8', '3a5df463c16a91a436518238c6f83b2a3f5c5dff933dc2331135f2e1ff783ff0', '348305afe3633e23dfb47aabccd6c1c8bea4a4d715a2d1887410dc2ce260cd62', 'f507abc6f0c89ad2171679d7fa41df6fcbbec870b5ebb589d4b1816cbc434aa7', 'cb36b3e74a93b3557fc45abc21839977e6a029bca7aee6c63148321383721bb6', '7c6c581d25fee738abd981ab0cf9ae13e5a3c473d98a8a8c8bb18b1a334901a7', '786ebf4d558af2b0bf12537895bec65737b19e4f3e70521436cf1d8c1ef76ab0', 'd6b8581165ce4de94d63adc76a5eb1f9d02d042d44a133a85cdad114720ee5b2'] B "the detnet data plane also allows for the aggregation of detnet flows, which can improve scalability by reducing the per-hop state. how this is accomplished is data plane or control plane dependent. when detnet flows are aggregated, transit nodes provide service to the aggregate and not on a per-detnet flow basis. when aggregating detnet flows, the flows should be compatible, i.e., the same or very similar qos and cos characteristics. in this case, nodes performing aggregation will ensure that per-flow service requirements are achieved." {55: 1, 6: 2, 79: 5, 90: 4, 51: 6, 130: 5, 62: 5, 85: 5, 68: 4, 35: 6, 110: 6, 91: 8, 114: 6, 97: 6, 31: 2, 13: 6, 67: 4, 38: 7, 26: 5, 124: 4, 98: 5, 54: 5, 127: 6, 8: 3, 96: 6, 64: 5, 30: 7, 61: 8, 27: 2, 15: 6, 52: 3, 129: 6, 115: 6, 84: 2, 76: 3, 87: 6, 131: 8, 102: 4, 113: 8, 99: 5, 36: 6, 24: 5, 53: 4, 72: 7} {243: 1, 1: 9, 4: 5, 9: 4, 10: 6, 15: 6, 24: 5, 25: 5, 26: 5, 27: 6, 39: 5, 43: 6, 49: 9, 50: 8, 58: 8, 59: 5, 64: 6, 69: 2, 81: 6, 82: 6, 86: 6, 96: 7, 97: 6, 100: 9, 108: 6, 109: 7, 110: 7, 111: 5, 114: 6, 115: 7, 116: 6, 118: 6, 119: 5, 120: 6, 121: 4, 122: 7, 123: 6, 124: 4, 128: 7, 129: 7, 130: 8, 132: 3, 136: 5, 145: 3, 147: 7, 151: 7, 152: 7, 154: 6, 156: 5, 161: 2, 162: 3, 165: 6, 168: 7, 169: 6, 172: 6, 180: 7, 184: 4, 187: 8, 188: 7, 191: 6, 194: 3, 202: 2, 203: 3, 206: 5, 207: 6, 215: 3, 217: 6, 218: 8, 220: 4, 221: 4, 222: 5, 224: 6, 227: 7, 229: 6, 234: 8, 235: 5, 241: 5, 242: 5, 244: 7, 245: 2, 248: 7, 250: 7, 258: 11, 262: 7, 263: 8, 264: 3, 267: 4, 270: 6, 272: 6, 287: 6, 289: 6, 291: 8, 299: 7, 300: 6, 304: 6, 309: 4, 314: 5, 315: 6, 320: 4, 323: 2, 327: 7, 328: 4, 329: 5, 330: 10, 334: 5, 335: 6, 341: 7, 342: 8, 347: 7, 348: 7, 350: 4, 351: 8, 352: 6, 353: 6, 354: 5, 358: 4, 365: 6, 366: 5, 369: 4, 371: 9, 372: 8, 376: 5, 384: 8, 385: 7, 386: 6, 387: 6, 392: 4, 393: 5, 396: 8, 397: 7, 398: 6, 402: 6} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 84 "If bandwidth reservations are used, the reservation should be the sum of all the individual reservations; in other words, the reservations should not add up to an over-subscription of bandwidth reservation. If maximum delay bounds are used, the system should ensure that the aggregate does not exceed the delay bounds of the individual flows." "IESG review comment resolutions in this version : DONE , IANA , ( 03 - 12 ) , OK , ( 03 - 15 ) , Ready with Nits Yoshifumi Nishida , ( 04 - 07 ) , Ready with Nits ( 04 - 12 ) , Editorial nits mostly , ( 04 - 15 ) , Editorial comments TO BE DISCUSSED : , ( 03 - 13 ) , Ready with Issues ( Ready , as soon as I - D.ietf - detnet - security is reviewed and becomes an RFC . ) reviewed in April 22 meeting" f95284c65618abd001877da8cfc9f18a49096d95 f95284c65618abd001877da8cfc9f18a49096d95 draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework 7c6c581d25fee738abd981ab0cf9ae13e5a3c473d98a8a8c8bb18b1a334901a7 ['af5eb17e01686194e0ed7768da488772dd45e4ccee3c93265023f7d3bab467e8', '3a5df463c16a91a436518238c6f83b2a3f5c5dff933dc2331135f2e1ff783ff0', '348305afe3633e23dfb47aabccd6c1c8bea4a4d715a2d1887410dc2ce260cd62', 'f507abc6f0c89ad2171679d7fa41df6fcbbec870b5ebb589d4b1816cbc434aa7', 'cb36b3e74a93b3557fc45abc21839977e6a029bca7aee6c63148321383721bb6', '7c6c581d25fee738abd981ab0cf9ae13e5a3c473d98a8a8c8bb18b1a334901a7', '786ebf4d558af2b0bf12537895bec65737b19e4f3e70521436cf1d8c1ef76ab0', 'd6b8581165ce4de94d63adc76a5eb1f9d02d042d44a133a85cdad114720ee5b2'] B "if bandwidth reservations are used, the reservation should be the sum of all the individual reservations; in other words, the reservations should not add up to an over-subscription of bandwidth reservation. if maximum delay bounds are used, the system should ensure that the aggregate does not exceed the delay bounds of the individual flows." {55: 1, 6: 2, 79: 5, 90: 4, 51: 6, 130: 5, 62: 5, 85: 5, 68: 4, 35: 6, 110: 6, 91: 8, 114: 6, 97: 6, 31: 2, 13: 6, 67: 4, 38: 7, 26: 5, 124: 4, 98: 5, 54: 5, 127: 6, 8: 3, 96: 6, 64: 5, 30: 7, 61: 8, 27: 2, 15: 6, 52: 3, 129: 6, 115: 6, 84: 2, 76: 3, 87: 6, 131: 8, 102: 4, 113: 8, 99: 5, 36: 6, 24: 5, 53: 4, 72: 7} {243: 1, 1: 9, 4: 5, 9: 4, 10: 6, 15: 6, 24: 5, 25: 5, 26: 5, 27: 6, 39: 5, 43: 6, 49: 9, 50: 8, 58: 8, 59: 5, 64: 6, 69: 2, 81: 6, 82: 6, 86: 6, 96: 7, 97: 6, 100: 9, 108: 6, 109: 7, 110: 7, 111: 5, 114: 6, 115: 7, 116: 6, 118: 6, 119: 5, 120: 6, 121: 4, 122: 7, 123: 6, 124: 4, 128: 7, 129: 7, 130: 8, 132: 3, 136: 5, 145: 3, 147: 7, 151: 7, 152: 7, 154: 6, 156: 5, 161: 2, 162: 3, 165: 6, 168: 7, 169: 6, 172: 6, 180: 7, 184: 4, 187: 8, 188: 7, 191: 6, 194: 3, 202: 2, 203: 3, 206: 5, 207: 6, 215: 3, 217: 6, 218: 8, 220: 4, 221: 4, 222: 5, 224: 6, 227: 7, 229: 6, 234: 8, 235: 5, 241: 5, 242: 5, 244: 7, 245: 2, 248: 7, 250: 7, 258: 11, 262: 7, 263: 8, 264: 3, 267: 4, 270: 6, 272: 6, 287: 6, 289: 6, 291: 8, 299: 7, 300: 6, 304: 6, 309: 4, 314: 5, 315: 6, 320: 4, 323: 2, 327: 7, 328: 4, 329: 5, 330: 10, 334: 5, 335: 6, 341: 7, 342: 8, 347: 7, 348: 7, 350: 4, 351: 8, 352: 6, 353: 6, 354: 5, 358: 4, 365: 6, 366: 5, 369: 4, 371: 9, 372: 8, 376: 5, 384: 8, 385: 7, 386: 6, 387: 6, 392: 4, 393: 5, 396: 8, 397: 7, 398: 6, 402: 6} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 84 "When an encapsulation is used, the choice of reserving a maximum resource level and then tracking the services in the aggregated service or adjusting the aggregated resources as the services are added is implementation and technology specific." "IESG review comment resolutions in this version : DONE , IANA , ( 03 - 12 ) , OK , ( 03 - 15 ) , Ready with Nits Yoshifumi Nishida , ( 04 - 07 ) , Ready with Nits ( 04 - 12 ) , Editorial nits mostly , ( 04 - 15 ) , Editorial comments TO BE DISCUSSED : , ( 03 - 13 ) , Ready with Issues ( Ready , as soon as I - D.ietf - detnet - security is reviewed and becomes an RFC . ) reviewed in April 22 meeting" f95284c65618abd001877da8cfc9f18a49096d95 f95284c65618abd001877da8cfc9f18a49096d95 draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework 348305afe3633e23dfb47aabccd6c1c8bea4a4d715a2d1887410dc2ce260cd62 ['af5eb17e01686194e0ed7768da488772dd45e4ccee3c93265023f7d3bab467e8', '3a5df463c16a91a436518238c6f83b2a3f5c5dff933dc2331135f2e1ff783ff0', '348305afe3633e23dfb47aabccd6c1c8bea4a4d715a2d1887410dc2ce260cd62', 'f507abc6f0c89ad2171679d7fa41df6fcbbec870b5ebb589d4b1816cbc434aa7', 'cb36b3e74a93b3557fc45abc21839977e6a029bca7aee6c63148321383721bb6', '7c6c581d25fee738abd981ab0cf9ae13e5a3c473d98a8a8c8bb18b1a334901a7', '786ebf4d558af2b0bf12537895bec65737b19e4f3e70521436cf1d8c1ef76ab0', 'd6b8581165ce4de94d63adc76a5eb1f9d02d042d44a133a85cdad114720ee5b2'] B "when an encapsulation is used, the choice of reserving a maximum resource level and then tracking the services in the aggregated service or adjusting the aggregated resources as the services are added is implementation and technology specific." {55: 1, 6: 2, 79: 5, 90: 4, 51: 6, 130: 5, 62: 5, 85: 5, 68: 4, 35: 6, 110: 6, 91: 8, 114: 6, 97: 6, 31: 2, 13: 6, 67: 4, 38: 7, 26: 5, 124: 4, 98: 5, 54: 5, 127: 6, 8: 3, 96: 6, 64: 5, 30: 7, 61: 8, 27: 2, 15: 6, 52: 3, 129: 6, 115: 6, 84: 2, 76: 3, 87: 6, 131: 8, 102: 4, 113: 8, 99: 5, 36: 6, 24: 5, 53: 4, 72: 7} {243: 1, 1: 9, 4: 5, 9: 4, 10: 6, 15: 6, 24: 5, 25: 5, 26: 5, 27: 6, 39: 5, 43: 6, 49: 9, 50: 8, 58: 8, 59: 5, 64: 6, 69: 2, 81: 6, 82: 6, 86: 6, 96: 7, 97: 6, 100: 9, 108: 6, 109: 7, 110: 7, 111: 5, 114: 6, 115: 7, 116: 6, 118: 6, 119: 5, 120: 6, 121: 4, 122: 7, 123: 6, 124: 4, 128: 7, 129: 7, 130: 8, 132: 3, 136: 5, 145: 3, 147: 7, 151: 7, 152: 7, 154: 6, 156: 5, 161: 2, 162: 3, 165: 6, 168: 7, 169: 6, 172: 6, 180: 7, 184: 4, 187: 8, 188: 7, 191: 6, 194: 3, 202: 2, 203: 3, 206: 5, 207: 6, 215: 3, 217: 6, 218: 8, 220: 4, 221: 4, 222: 5, 224: 6, 227: 7, 229: 6, 234: 8, 235: 5, 241: 5, 242: 5, 244: 7, 245: 2, 248: 7, 250: 7, 258: 11, 262: 7, 263: 8, 264: 3, 267: 4, 270: 6, 272: 6, 287: 6, 289: 6, 291: 8, 299: 7, 300: 6, 304: 6, 309: 4, 314: 5, 315: 6, 320: 4, 323: 2, 327: 7, 328: 4, 329: 5, 330: 10, 334: 5, 335: 6, 341: 7, 342: 8, 347: 7, 348: 7, 350: 4, 351: 8, 352: 6, 353: 6, 354: 5, 358: 4, 365: 6, 366: 5, 369: 4, 371: 9, 372: 8, 376: 5, 384: 8, 385: 7, 386: 6, 387: 6, 392: 4, 393: 5, 396: 8, 397: 7, 398: 6, 402: 6} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 84 "sub-network technologies. L2 represent a generic layer-2 encapsulation that might be used on a point-to-point link. TSN represents the encapsulation used on an IEEE 802.1 TSN network, as described in I-D.ietf-detnet-mpls-over-tsn. UDP/IP represents the encapsulation used on a DetNet IP PSN, as described in I-D.ietf- detnet-mpls-over-udp-ip." "IESG review comment resolutions in this version : DONE , IANA , ( 03 - 12 ) , OK , ( 03 - 15 ) , Ready with Nits Yoshifumi Nishida , ( 04 - 07 ) , Ready with Nits ( 04 - 12 ) , Editorial nits mostly , ( 04 - 15 ) , Editorial comments TO BE DISCUSSED : , ( 03 - 13 ) , Ready with Issues ( Ready , as soon as I - D.ietf - detnet - security is reviewed and becomes an RFC . ) reviewed in April 22 meeting" f95284c65618abd001877da8cfc9f18a49096d95 f95284c65618abd001877da8cfc9f18a49096d95 draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework 6276510aca271bee0f719155ea7c468963848c7790dacfb64e6bd08e33802ad8 ['fb68dcfb7e59e9047b6106782d4a93cc04fd34d0d4a3a0b7f96cf465e4f9cfc5', '6276510aca271bee0f719155ea7c468963848c7790dacfb64e6bd08e33802ad8'] A "sub-network technologies. l2 represent a generic layer-2 encapsulation that might be used on a point-to-point link. tsn represents the encapsulation used on an ieee 802.1 tsn network, as described in i-d.ietf-detnet-mpls-over-tsn. udp/ip represents the encapsulation used on a detnet ip psn, as described in i-d.ietf- detnet-mpls-over-udp-ip." {} {} {} 84 "sub-network technologies. L2 represents a generic layer-2 encapsulation that might be used on a point-to-point link. TSN represents the encapsulation used on an IEEE 802.1 TSN network, as described in I-D.ietf-detnet-mpls-over-tsn. UDP/IP represents the encapsulation used on a DetNet IP PSN, as described in I-D.ietf- detnet-mpls-over-udp-ip." "IESG review comment resolutions in this version : DONE , IANA , ( 03 - 12 ) , OK , ( 03 - 15 ) , Ready with Nits Yoshifumi Nishida , ( 04 - 07 ) , Ready with Nits ( 04 - 12 ) , Editorial nits mostly , ( 04 - 15 ) , Editorial comments TO BE DISCUSSED : , ( 03 - 13 ) , Ready with Issues ( Ready , as soon as I - D.ietf - detnet - security is reviewed and becomes an RFC . ) reviewed in April 22 meeting" f95284c65618abd001877da8cfc9f18a49096d95 f95284c65618abd001877da8cfc9f18a49096d95 draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework fb68dcfb7e59e9047b6106782d4a93cc04fd34d0d4a3a0b7f96cf465e4f9cfc5 ['fb68dcfb7e59e9047b6106782d4a93cc04fd34d0d4a3a0b7f96cf465e4f9cfc5', '6276510aca271bee0f719155ea7c468963848c7790dacfb64e6bd08e33802ad8'] B "sub-network technologies. l2 represents a generic layer-2 encapsulation that might be used on a point-to-point link. tsn represents the encapsulation used on an ieee 802.1 tsn network, as described in i-d.ietf-detnet-mpls-over-tsn. udp/ip represents the encapsulation used on a detnet ip psn, as described in i-d.ietf- detnet-mpls-over-udp-ip." {} {} {} 84 "The Controller Plane corresponds to the aggregation of the Control and Management Planes discussed in RFC7426 and RFC8655. While more details of any DetNet controller plane are out of the scope of this document, there are particular considerations and requirements for such that result from the unique characteristics of the DetNet architecture RFC8655 and data plane as defined herein." "IESG review comment resolutions in this version : DONE , IANA , ( 03 - 12 ) , OK , ( 03 - 15 ) , Ready with Nits Yoshifumi Nishida , ( 04 - 07 ) , Ready with Nits ( 04 - 12 ) , Editorial nits mostly , ( 04 - 15 ) , Editorial comments TO BE DISCUSSED : , ( 03 - 13 ) , Ready with Issues ( Ready , as soon as I - D.ietf - detnet - security is reviewed and becomes an RFC . ) reviewed in April 22 meeting" f95284c65618abd001877da8cfc9f18a49096d95 f95284c65618abd001877da8cfc9f18a49096d95 draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework cba646b446e735cabd8548774cdf7fcc3c5ce876a7e56e50d00430721bbbb190 ['5dfa1cd80e670804bfb342ce233591a3e7ecdc6253a1b29ce041b8ce4c21e232', 'cba646b446e735cabd8548774cdf7fcc3c5ce876a7e56e50d00430721bbbb190'] A "the controller plane corresponds to the aggregation of the control and management planes discussed in rfc7426 and rfc8655. while more details of any detnet controller plane are out of the scope of this document, there are particular considerations and requirements for such that result from the unique characteristics of the detnet architecture rfc8655 and data plane as defined herein." {68: 1, 67: 2} {317: 1, 316: 2} {316, 317, 150} 84 "The Controller Plane corresponds to the aggregation of the Control and Management Planes discussed in RFC7426 and RFC8655. While more details of any DetNet controller plane are out of the scope of this document, there are particular considerations and requirements for such that result from the unique characteristics of the DetNet architecture and data plane as defined herein." "IESG review comment resolutions in this version : DONE , IANA , ( 03 - 12 ) , OK , ( 03 - 15 ) , Ready with Nits Yoshifumi Nishida , ( 04 - 07 ) , Ready with Nits ( 04 - 12 ) , Editorial nits mostly , ( 04 - 15 ) , Editorial comments TO BE DISCUSSED : , ( 03 - 13 ) , Ready with Issues ( Ready , as soon as I - D.ietf - detnet - security is reviewed and becomes an RFC . ) reviewed in April 22 meeting" f95284c65618abd001877da8cfc9f18a49096d95 f95284c65618abd001877da8cfc9f18a49096d95 draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework 5dfa1cd80e670804bfb342ce233591a3e7ecdc6253a1b29ce041b8ce4c21e232 ['5dfa1cd80e670804bfb342ce233591a3e7ecdc6253a1b29ce041b8ce4c21e232', 'cba646b446e735cabd8548774cdf7fcc3c5ce876a7e56e50d00430721bbbb190'] B "the controller plane corresponds to the aggregation of the control and management planes discussed in rfc7426 and rfc8655. while more details of any detnet controller plane are out of the scope of this document, there are particular considerations and requirements for such that result from the unique characteristics of the detnet architecture and data plane as defined herein." {68: 1, 67: 2} {317: 1, 316: 2} {316, 317, 150} 84 "Each respective data plane document also covers the control plane considerations for that technology. For example I-D.ietf-detnet-ip covers IP control plane normative considerations and I-D.ietf-detnet- mpls covers MPLS control plane normative considerations." "IESG review comment resolutions in this version : DONE , IANA , ( 03 - 12 ) , OK , ( 03 - 15 ) , Ready with Nits Yoshifumi Nishida , ( 04 - 07 ) , Ready with Nits ( 04 - 12 ) , Editorial nits mostly , ( 04 - 15 ) , Editorial comments TO BE DISCUSSED : , ( 03 - 13 ) , Ready with Issues ( Ready , as soon as I - D.ietf - detnet - security is reviewed and becomes an RFC . ) reviewed in April 22 meeting" f95284c65618abd001877da8cfc9f18a49096d95 f95284c65618abd001877da8cfc9f18a49096d95 draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework bf3f209fa4140bc37109f3d00ca3505333b7bf181a38d2e2ba3ad1c7030b53ab ['1c95630d6db1dddba29a65af38e151fa80a5c2fa2789f81585f7f837742633d0', 'bf3f209fa4140bc37109f3d00ca3505333b7bf181a38d2e2ba3ad1c7030b53ab', 'f92ed364d57d02f3aa03068751692d2ae8e44f5751e96ae780673e2a32789191', '05704ea35dd447a36e4713a65e9f5eb93a7263c95670e8d681bfeb96b31b2921'] A "each respective data plane document also covers the control plane considerations for that technology. for example i-d.ietf-detnet-ip covers ip control plane normative considerations and i-d.ietf-detnet- mpls covers mpls control plane normative considerations." {55: 1} {35: 1} {35, 36} 84 "Flow aggregation means that multiple App-flows are served by a single new DetNet flow. There are many techniques to achieve aggregation, for example in case of IP, it can be grouping of IP flows that share 6-tuple attributes or flow identifiers at the DetNet sub-layer. Another example includes aggregation accomplished through the use of hierarchical LSPs in MPLS and tunnels." "IESG review comment resolutions in this version : DONE , IANA , ( 03 - 12 ) , OK , ( 03 - 15 ) , Ready with Nits Yoshifumi Nishida , ( 04 - 07 ) , Ready with Nits ( 04 - 12 ) , Editorial nits mostly , ( 04 - 15 ) , Editorial comments TO BE DISCUSSED : , ( 03 - 13 ) , Ready with Issues ( Ready , as soon as I - D.ietf - detnet - security is reviewed and becomes an RFC . ) reviewed in April 22 meeting" f95284c65618abd001877da8cfc9f18a49096d95 f95284c65618abd001877da8cfc9f18a49096d95 draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework 1c95630d6db1dddba29a65af38e151fa80a5c2fa2789f81585f7f837742633d0 ['1c95630d6db1dddba29a65af38e151fa80a5c2fa2789f81585f7f837742633d0', 'bf3f209fa4140bc37109f3d00ca3505333b7bf181a38d2e2ba3ad1c7030b53ab', 'f92ed364d57d02f3aa03068751692d2ae8e44f5751e96ae780673e2a32789191', '05704ea35dd447a36e4713a65e9f5eb93a7263c95670e8d681bfeb96b31b2921'] A "flow aggregation means that multiple app-flows are served by a single new detnet flow. there are many techniques to achieve aggregation, for example in case of ip, it can be grouping of ip flows that share 6-tuple attributes or flow identifiers at the detnet sub-layer. another example includes aggregation accomplished through the use of hierarchical lsps in mpls and tunnels." {55: 1} {35: 1} {35, 36} 84 "Each respective data plane document also covers the control plane considerations for that technology. For example, I-D.ietf-detnet-ip covers IP control plane normative considerations and I-D.ietf-detnet- mpls covers MPLS control plane normative considerations." "IESG review comment resolutions in this version : DONE , IANA , ( 03 - 12 ) , OK , ( 03 - 15 ) , Ready with Nits Yoshifumi Nishida , ( 04 - 07 ) , Ready with Nits ( 04 - 12 ) , Editorial nits mostly , ( 04 - 15 ) , Editorial comments TO BE DISCUSSED : , ( 03 - 13 ) , Ready with Issues ( Ready , as soon as I - D.ietf - detnet - security is reviewed and becomes an RFC . ) reviewed in April 22 meeting" f95284c65618abd001877da8cfc9f18a49096d95 f95284c65618abd001877da8cfc9f18a49096d95 draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework f92ed364d57d02f3aa03068751692d2ae8e44f5751e96ae780673e2a32789191 ['1c95630d6db1dddba29a65af38e151fa80a5c2fa2789f81585f7f837742633d0', 'bf3f209fa4140bc37109f3d00ca3505333b7bf181a38d2e2ba3ad1c7030b53ab', 'f92ed364d57d02f3aa03068751692d2ae8e44f5751e96ae780673e2a32789191', '05704ea35dd447a36e4713a65e9f5eb93a7263c95670e8d681bfeb96b31b2921'] B "each respective data plane document also covers the control plane considerations for that technology. for example, i-d.ietf-detnet-ip covers ip control plane normative considerations and i-d.ietf-detnet- mpls covers mpls control plane normative considerations." {55: 1} {35: 1} {35, 36} 84 "Flow aggregation means that multiple app-flows are served by a single new DetNet flow. There are many techniques to achieve aggregation. For example, in the case of IP, IP flows that share 6-tuple attributes or flow identifiers at the DetNet sub-layer can be grouped. Another example includes aggregation accomplished through the use of hierarchical LSPs in MPLS and tunnels." "IESG review comment resolutions in this version : DONE , IANA , ( 03 - 12 ) , OK , ( 03 - 15 ) , Ready with Nits Yoshifumi Nishida , ( 04 - 07 ) , Ready with Nits ( 04 - 12 ) , Editorial nits mostly , ( 04 - 15 ) , Editorial comments TO BE DISCUSSED : , ( 03 - 13 ) , Ready with Issues ( Ready , as soon as I - D.ietf - detnet - security is reviewed and becomes an RFC . ) reviewed in April 22 meeting" f95284c65618abd001877da8cfc9f18a49096d95 f95284c65618abd001877da8cfc9f18a49096d95 draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework 05704ea35dd447a36e4713a65e9f5eb93a7263c95670e8d681bfeb96b31b2921 ['1c95630d6db1dddba29a65af38e151fa80a5c2fa2789f81585f7f837742633d0', 'bf3f209fa4140bc37109f3d00ca3505333b7bf181a38d2e2ba3ad1c7030b53ab', 'f92ed364d57d02f3aa03068751692d2ae8e44f5751e96ae780673e2a32789191', '05704ea35dd447a36e4713a65e9f5eb93a7263c95670e8d681bfeb96b31b2921'] B "flow aggregation means that multiple app-flows are served by a single new detnet flow. there are many techniques to achieve aggregation. for example, in the case of ip, ip flows that share 6-tuple attributes or flow identifiers at the detnet sub-layer can be grouped. another example includes aggregation accomplished through the use of hierarchical lsps in mpls and tunnels." {55: 1} {35: 1} {35, 36} 84 "When DetNet services are provisioned or requested one or more paths meeting the requirements are selected and the resources verified and recorded." "IESG review comment resolutions in this version : DONE , IANA , ( 03 - 12 ) , OK , ( 03 - 15 ) , Ready with Nits Yoshifumi Nishida , ( 04 - 07 ) , Ready with Nits ( 04 - 12 ) , Editorial nits mostly , ( 04 - 15 ) , Editorial comments TO BE DISCUSSED : , ( 03 - 13 ) , Ready with Issues ( Ready , as soon as I - D.ietf - detnet - security is reviewed and becomes an RFC . ) reviewed in April 22 meeting" f95284c65618abd001877da8cfc9f18a49096d95 f95284c65618abd001877da8cfc9f18a49096d95 draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework d496f59b691217221c3b8b412e850321136fe8a9e4371d9188fb7f5f23814b87 ['fea96278590d299e3725f48f8715f69858746fda53e79a3c8eb0453379a15e30', '47c9f23f512c31c70f2092d85925d2fe3b0435266c29d6941e0c474ed7e2ff2f', 'd496f59b691217221c3b8b412e850321136fe8a9e4371d9188fb7f5f23814b87', '5a1564e118a8099605762dbb1521e734b9f5b578d76183df5b3f098454e39a5a'] A "when detnet services are provisioned or requested one or more paths meeting the requirements are selected and the resources verified and recorded." {8: 1, 90: 5, 6: 2, 31: 4, 55: 2} {226: 1, 101: 5, 360: 2, 107: 4, 138: 3, 338: 2, 211: 4, 89: 3} {226, 101, 360, 409, 107, 138, 338, 211, 89} 84 "The assignment of resources along the path depends on the technology and it includes assignment of specific links and coordination of the queuing and other traffic management capabilities such as policing and shaping." "IESG review comment resolutions in this version : DONE , IANA , ( 03 - 12 ) , OK , ( 03 - 15 ) , Ready with Nits Yoshifumi Nishida , ( 04 - 07 ) , Ready with Nits ( 04 - 12 ) , Editorial nits mostly , ( 04 - 15 ) , Editorial comments TO BE DISCUSSED : , ( 03 - 13 ) , Ready with Issues ( Ready , as soon as I - D.ietf - detnet - security is reviewed and becomes an RFC . ) reviewed in April 22 meeting" f95284c65618abd001877da8cfc9f18a49096d95 f95284c65618abd001877da8cfc9f18a49096d95 draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework 47c9f23f512c31c70f2092d85925d2fe3b0435266c29d6941e0c474ed7e2ff2f ['fea96278590d299e3725f48f8715f69858746fda53e79a3c8eb0453379a15e30', '47c9f23f512c31c70f2092d85925d2fe3b0435266c29d6941e0c474ed7e2ff2f', 'd496f59b691217221c3b8b412e850321136fe8a9e4371d9188fb7f5f23814b87', '5a1564e118a8099605762dbb1521e734b9f5b578d76183df5b3f098454e39a5a'] A "the assignment of resources along the path depends on the technology and it includes assignment of specific links and coordination of the queuing and other traffic management capabilities such as policing and shaping." {8: 1, 90: 5, 6: 2, 31: 4, 55: 2} {226: 1, 101: 5, 360: 2, 107: 4, 138: 3, 338: 2, 211: 4, 89: 3} {226, 101, 360, 409, 107, 138, 338, 211, 89} 84 "When DetNet services are provisioned or requested, one or more paths meeting the requirements are selected and the resources verified and recorded." "IESG review comment resolutions in this version : DONE , IANA , ( 03 - 12 ) , OK , ( 03 - 15 ) , Ready with Nits Yoshifumi Nishida , ( 04 - 07 ) , Ready with Nits ( 04 - 12 ) , Editorial nits mostly , ( 04 - 15 ) , Editorial comments TO BE DISCUSSED : , ( 03 - 13 ) , Ready with Issues ( Ready , as soon as I - D.ietf - detnet - security is reviewed and becomes an RFC . ) reviewed in April 22 meeting" f95284c65618abd001877da8cfc9f18a49096d95 f95284c65618abd001877da8cfc9f18a49096d95 draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework 5a1564e118a8099605762dbb1521e734b9f5b578d76183df5b3f098454e39a5a ['fea96278590d299e3725f48f8715f69858746fda53e79a3c8eb0453379a15e30', '47c9f23f512c31c70f2092d85925d2fe3b0435266c29d6941e0c474ed7e2ff2f', 'd496f59b691217221c3b8b412e850321136fe8a9e4371d9188fb7f5f23814b87', '5a1564e118a8099605762dbb1521e734b9f5b578d76183df5b3f098454e39a5a'] B "when detnet services are provisioned or requested, one or more paths meeting the requirements are selected and the resources verified and recorded." {8: 1, 90: 5, 6: 2, 31: 4, 55: 2} {226: 1, 101: 5, 360: 2, 107: 4, 138: 3, 338: 2, 211: 4, 89: 3} {226, 101, 360, 409, 107, 138, 338, 211, 89} 84 "The assignment of resources along the path depends on the technology and includes assignment of specific links, coordination of queueing, and other traffic management capabilities such as policing and shaping." "IESG review comment resolutions in this version : DONE , IANA , ( 03 - 12 ) , OK , ( 03 - 15 ) , Ready with Nits Yoshifumi Nishida , ( 04 - 07 ) , Ready with Nits ( 04 - 12 ) , Editorial nits mostly , ( 04 - 15 ) , Editorial comments TO BE DISCUSSED : , ( 03 - 13 ) , Ready with Issues ( Ready , as soon as I - D.ietf - detnet - security is reviewed and becomes an RFC . ) reviewed in April 22 meeting" f95284c65618abd001877da8cfc9f18a49096d95 f95284c65618abd001877da8cfc9f18a49096d95 draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework fea96278590d299e3725f48f8715f69858746fda53e79a3c8eb0453379a15e30 ['fea96278590d299e3725f48f8715f69858746fda53e79a3c8eb0453379a15e30', '47c9f23f512c31c70f2092d85925d2fe3b0435266c29d6941e0c474ed7e2ff2f', 'd496f59b691217221c3b8b412e850321136fe8a9e4371d9188fb7f5f23814b87', '5a1564e118a8099605762dbb1521e734b9f5b578d76183df5b3f098454e39a5a'] B "the assignment of resources along the path depends on the technology and includes assignment of specific links, coordination of queueing, and other traffic management capabilities such as policing and shaping." {8: 1, 90: 5, 6: 2, 31: 4, 55: 2} {226: 1, 101: 5, 360: 2, 107: 4, 138: 3, 338: 2, 211: 4, 89: 3} {226, 101, 360, 409, 107, 138, 338, 211, 89} 84 "Control and management mechanisms need to support bidirectional flows, but the specification of such mechanisms are out of scope of this document. An example control plane solution for MPLS can be found in RFC3473 , RFC6387 and RFC7551. These requirements are included in control-management-requirements." "IESG review comment resolutions in this version : DONE , IANA , ( 03 - 12 ) , OK , ( 03 - 15 ) , Ready with Nits Yoshifumi Nishida , ( 04 - 07 ) , Ready with Nits ( 04 - 12 ) , Editorial nits mostly , ( 04 - 15 ) , Editorial comments TO BE DISCUSSED : , ( 03 - 13 ) , Ready with Issues ( Ready , as soon as I - D.ietf - detnet - security is reviewed and becomes an RFC . ) reviewed in April 22 meeting" f95284c65618abd001877da8cfc9f18a49096d95 f95284c65618abd001877da8cfc9f18a49096d95 draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework cdd5b072944aa22bab9a7c77cb9e99afc3034e431e6803901ac512084fd334a5 ['890c15436a0e2a30145b9ce9acdac4951b477236533b734de12ad3f53171409a', 'cdd5b072944aa22bab9a7c77cb9e99afc3034e431e6803901ac512084fd334a5'] A "control and management mechanisms need to support bidirectional flows, but the specification of such mechanisms are out of scope of this document. an example control plane solution for mpls can be found in rfc3473 , rfc6387 and rfc7551. these requirements are included in control-management-requirements." {} {} {} 84 "Control and management mechanisms need to support bidirectional flows, but the specification of such mechanisms are out of scope of this document. Example control plane solutions for MPLS can be found in RFC3473 , RFC6387 and RFC7551. These requirements are included in control-management-requirements." "IESG review comment resolutions in this version : DONE , IANA , ( 03 - 12 ) , OK , ( 03 - 15 ) , Ready with Nits Yoshifumi Nishida , ( 04 - 07 ) , Ready with Nits ( 04 - 12 ) , Editorial nits mostly , ( 04 - 15 ) , Editorial comments TO BE DISCUSSED : , ( 03 - 13 ) , Ready with Issues ( Ready , as soon as I - D.ietf - detnet - security is reviewed and becomes an RFC . ) reviewed in April 22 meeting" f95284c65618abd001877da8cfc9f18a49096d95 f95284c65618abd001877da8cfc9f18a49096d95 draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework 890c15436a0e2a30145b9ce9acdac4951b477236533b734de12ad3f53171409a ['890c15436a0e2a30145b9ce9acdac4951b477236533b734de12ad3f53171409a', 'cdd5b072944aa22bab9a7c77cb9e99afc3034e431e6803901ac512084fd334a5'] B "control and management mechanisms need to support bidirectional flows, but the specification of such mechanisms are out of scope of this document. example control plane solutions for mpls can be found in rfc3473 , rfc6387 and rfc7551. these requirements are included in control-management-requirements." {} {} {} 84 "Security considerations for DetNet are described in detail in I- D.ietf-detnet-security. General security considerations are described in RFC8655. This section considers general security considerations applicable to all data planes." "IESG review comment resolutions in this version : DONE , IANA , ( 03 - 12 ) , OK , ( 03 - 15 ) , Ready with Nits Yoshifumi Nishida , ( 04 - 07 ) , Ready with Nits ( 04 - 12 ) , Editorial nits mostly , ( 04 - 15 ) , Editorial comments TO BE DISCUSSED : , ( 03 - 13 ) , Ready with Issues ( Ready , as soon as I - D.ietf - detnet - security is reviewed and becomes an RFC . ) reviewed in April 22 meeting" f95284c65618abd001877da8cfc9f18a49096d95 f95284c65618abd001877da8cfc9f18a49096d95 draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework a488530ff7f46a9e785fc2ebd8536826140261d94b1d948be414cdabc20df4d6 ['9e9f77a071d3a97f3aef1abe88bdbbbd520589be867f06f7aab99e2fd42ec963', 'd69209141d4946a6829e20f8b4b4b7e8ae7b6d91c2f310a11b6ad1360d13a505', '38a0a4ed16cf457fd346ca2d2feeecab03cbf7d6042e7a7467dcbcdb6b8d21dc', 'a488530ff7f46a9e785fc2ebd8536826140261d94b1d948be414cdabc20df4d6'] A "security considerations for detnet are described in detail in i- d.ietf-detnet-security. general security considerations are described in rfc8655. this section considers general security considerations applicable to all data planes." {90: 1, 67: 1, 6: 4, 79: 4, 51: 3, 130: 4, 62: 6, 85: 7, 68: 6, 35: 5, 110: 3, 91: 4, 114: 3, 97: 4, 31: 2, 13: 2, 38: 4, 26: 3, 124: 5, 98: 4, 54: 4, 127: 5, 8: 4, 96: 4, 64: 3, 30: 3, 61: 5, 55: 5, 27: 4, 15: 3, 52: 3, 129: 5, 115: 2, 84: 3, 76: 8, 87: 3, 131: 7, 102: 2, 113: 5, 99: 4, 36: 2, 24: 2, 53: 3, 72: 4} {402: 1, 351: 1, 1: 11, 4: 4, 9: 7, 10: 5, 15: 4, 24: 4, 25: 6, 26: 7, 27: 3, 39: 7, 43: 5, 49: 5, 50: 4, 58: 5, 59: 4, 64: 4, 69: 6, 81: 7, 82: 5, 86: 3, 96: 4, 97: 3, 100: 8, 108: 5, 109: 6, 110: 6, 111: 4, 114: 5, 115: 6, 116: 4, 118: 8, 119: 7, 120: 5, 121: 6, 122: 5, 123: 4, 124: 6, 128: 3, 129: 3, 130: 5, 132: 6, 136: 4, 145: 6, 147: 4, 151: 3, 152: 3, 154: 5, 156: 3, 161: 5, 162: 5, 165: 5, 168: 6, 169: 2, 172: 3, 180: 3, 184: 7, 187: 7, 188: 6, 191: 5, 194: 6, 202: 7, 203: 8, 206: 4, 207: 5, 215: 4, 217: 5, 218: 10, 220: 4, 221: 4, 222: 7, 224: 5, 227: 6, 229: 3, 234: 7, 235: 4, 241: 4, 242: 4, 243: 6, 245: 6, 248: 2, 250: 5, 258: 13, 262: 6, 263: 7, 264: 5, 267: 6, 270: 4, 272: 2, 273: 7, 287: 5, 289: 3, 291: 5, 299: 6, 300: 4, 304: 4, 309: 5, 314: 4, 315: 2, 320: 6, 323: 6, 327: 6, 328: 5, 329: 4, 330: 12, 334: 4, 335: 4, 341: 6, 342: 7, 347: 6, 348: 6, 350: 9, 352: 3, 353: 2, 354: 2, 358: 6, 365: 3, 366: 4, 369: 3, 371: 8, 372: 5, 376: 4, 384: 5, 385: 4, 386: 5, 387: 4, 392: 5, 393: 6, 396: 7, 397: 9, 398: 8} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 84 "The primary considerations for the data plane is to maintain integrity of data and delivery of the associated DetNet service traversing the DetNet network. Application flows can be protected through whatever means is provided by the underlying technology. For example, encryption may be used, such as that provided by IPSec RFC4301 for IP flows and/or by an underlying sub-net using MACSec IEEE802.1AE-2018 for Ethernet (Layer-2) flows." "IESG review comment resolutions in this version : DONE , IANA , ( 03 - 12 ) , OK , ( 03 - 15 ) , Ready with Nits Yoshifumi Nishida , ( 04 - 07 ) , Ready with Nits ( 04 - 12 ) , Editorial nits mostly , ( 04 - 15 ) , Editorial comments TO BE DISCUSSED : , ( 03 - 13 ) , Ready with Issues ( Ready , as soon as I - D.ietf - detnet - security is reviewed and becomes an RFC . ) reviewed in April 22 meeting" f95284c65618abd001877da8cfc9f18a49096d95 f95284c65618abd001877da8cfc9f18a49096d95 draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework 9e9f77a071d3a97f3aef1abe88bdbbbd520589be867f06f7aab99e2fd42ec963 ['9e9f77a071d3a97f3aef1abe88bdbbbd520589be867f06f7aab99e2fd42ec963', 'd69209141d4946a6829e20f8b4b4b7e8ae7b6d91c2f310a11b6ad1360d13a505', '38a0a4ed16cf457fd346ca2d2feeecab03cbf7d6042e7a7467dcbcdb6b8d21dc', 'a488530ff7f46a9e785fc2ebd8536826140261d94b1d948be414cdabc20df4d6'] A "the primary considerations for the data plane is to maintain integrity of data and delivery of the associated detnet service traversing the detnet network. application flows can be protected through whatever means is provided by the underlying technology. for example, encryption may be used, such as that provided by ipsec rfc4301 for ip flows and/or by an underlying sub-net using macsec ieee802.1ae-2018 for ethernet (layer-2) flows." {90: 1, 67: 1, 6: 4, 79: 4, 51: 3, 130: 4, 62: 6, 85: 7, 68: 6, 35: 5, 110: 3, 91: 4, 114: 3, 97: 4, 31: 2, 13: 2, 38: 4, 26: 3, 124: 5, 98: 4, 54: 4, 127: 5, 8: 4, 96: 4, 64: 3, 30: 3, 61: 5, 55: 5, 27: 4, 15: 3, 52: 3, 129: 5, 115: 2, 84: 3, 76: 8, 87: 3, 131: 7, 102: 2, 113: 5, 99: 4, 36: 2, 24: 2, 53: 3, 72: 4} {402: 1, 351: 1, 1: 11, 4: 4, 9: 7, 10: 5, 15: 4, 24: 4, 25: 6, 26: 7, 27: 3, 39: 7, 43: 5, 49: 5, 50: 4, 58: 5, 59: 4, 64: 4, 69: 6, 81: 7, 82: 5, 86: 3, 96: 4, 97: 3, 100: 8, 108: 5, 109: 6, 110: 6, 111: 4, 114: 5, 115: 6, 116: 4, 118: 8, 119: 7, 120: 5, 121: 6, 122: 5, 123: 4, 124: 6, 128: 3, 129: 3, 130: 5, 132: 6, 136: 4, 145: 6, 147: 4, 151: 3, 152: 3, 154: 5, 156: 3, 161: 5, 162: 5, 165: 5, 168: 6, 169: 2, 172: 3, 180: 3, 184: 7, 187: 7, 188: 6, 191: 5, 194: 6, 202: 7, 203: 8, 206: 4, 207: 5, 215: 4, 217: 5, 218: 10, 220: 4, 221: 4, 222: 7, 224: 5, 227: 6, 229: 3, 234: 7, 235: 4, 241: 4, 242: 4, 243: 6, 245: 6, 248: 2, 250: 5, 258: 13, 262: 6, 263: 7, 264: 5, 267: 6, 270: 4, 272: 2, 273: 7, 287: 5, 289: 3, 291: 5, 299: 6, 300: 4, 304: 4, 309: 5, 314: 4, 315: 2, 320: 6, 323: 6, 327: 6, 328: 5, 329: 4, 330: 12, 334: 4, 335: 4, 341: 6, 342: 7, 347: 6, 348: 6, 350: 9, 352: 3, 353: 2, 354: 2, 358: 6, 365: 3, 366: 4, 369: 3, 371: 8, 372: 5, 376: 4, 384: 5, 385: 4, 386: 5, 387: 4, 392: 5, 393: 6, 396: 7, 397: 9, 398: 8} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 84 "Security considerations for DetNet are described in detail in I- D.ietf-detnet-security. General security considerations for DetNet architecture are described in RFC8655. This section considers general security considerations applicable to all data planes." "IESG review comment resolutions in this version : DONE , IANA , ( 03 - 12 ) , OK , ( 03 - 15 ) , Ready with Nits Yoshifumi Nishida , ( 04 - 07 ) , Ready with Nits ( 04 - 12 ) , Editorial nits mostly , ( 04 - 15 ) , Editorial comments TO BE DISCUSSED : , ( 03 - 13 ) , Ready with Issues ( Ready , as soon as I - D.ietf - detnet - security is reviewed and becomes an RFC . ) reviewed in April 22 meeting" f95284c65618abd001877da8cfc9f18a49096d95 f95284c65618abd001877da8cfc9f18a49096d95 draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework 38a0a4ed16cf457fd346ca2d2feeecab03cbf7d6042e7a7467dcbcdb6b8d21dc ['9e9f77a071d3a97f3aef1abe88bdbbbd520589be867f06f7aab99e2fd42ec963', 'd69209141d4946a6829e20f8b4b4b7e8ae7b6d91c2f310a11b6ad1360d13a505', '38a0a4ed16cf457fd346ca2d2feeecab03cbf7d6042e7a7467dcbcdb6b8d21dc', 'a488530ff7f46a9e785fc2ebd8536826140261d94b1d948be414cdabc20df4d6'] B "security considerations for detnet are described in detail in i- d.ietf-detnet-security. general security considerations for detnet architecture are described in rfc8655. this section considers general security considerations applicable to all data planes." {90: 1, 67: 1, 6: 4, 79: 4, 51: 3, 130: 4, 62: 6, 85: 7, 68: 6, 35: 5, 110: 3, 91: 4, 114: 3, 97: 4, 31: 2, 13: 2, 38: 4, 26: 3, 124: 5, 98: 4, 54: 4, 127: 5, 8: 4, 96: 4, 64: 3, 30: 3, 61: 5, 55: 5, 27: 4, 15: 3, 52: 3, 129: 5, 115: 2, 84: 3, 76: 8, 87: 3, 131: 7, 102: 2, 113: 5, 99: 4, 36: 2, 24: 2, 53: 3, 72: 4} {402: 1, 351: 1, 1: 11, 4: 4, 9: 7, 10: 5, 15: 4, 24: 4, 25: 6, 26: 7, 27: 3, 39: 7, 43: 5, 49: 5, 50: 4, 58: 5, 59: 4, 64: 4, 69: 6, 81: 7, 82: 5, 86: 3, 96: 4, 97: 3, 100: 8, 108: 5, 109: 6, 110: 6, 111: 4, 114: 5, 115: 6, 116: 4, 118: 8, 119: 7, 120: 5, 121: 6, 122: 5, 123: 4, 124: 6, 128: 3, 129: 3, 130: 5, 132: 6, 136: 4, 145: 6, 147: 4, 151: 3, 152: 3, 154: 5, 156: 3, 161: 5, 162: 5, 165: 5, 168: 6, 169: 2, 172: 3, 180: 3, 184: 7, 187: 7, 188: 6, 191: 5, 194: 6, 202: 7, 203: 8, 206: 4, 207: 5, 215: 4, 217: 5, 218: 10, 220: 4, 221: 4, 222: 7, 224: 5, 227: 6, 229: 3, 234: 7, 235: 4, 241: 4, 242: 4, 243: 6, 245: 6, 248: 2, 250: 5, 258: 13, 262: 6, 263: 7, 264: 5, 267: 6, 270: 4, 272: 2, 273: 7, 287: 5, 289: 3, 291: 5, 299: 6, 300: 4, 304: 4, 309: 5, 314: 4, 315: 2, 320: 6, 323: 6, 327: 6, 328: 5, 329: 4, 330: 12, 334: 4, 335: 4, 341: 6, 342: 7, 347: 6, 348: 6, 350: 9, 352: 3, 353: 2, 354: 2, 358: 6, 365: 3, 366: 4, 369: 3, 371: 8, 372: 5, 376: 4, 384: 5, 385: 4, 386: 5, 387: 4, 392: 5, 393: 6, 396: 7, 397: 9, 398: 8} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 84 "The primary consideration for the data plane is to maintain integrity of data and delivery of the associated DetNet service traversing the DetNet network. Application flows can be protected through whatever means is provided by the underlying technology. For example, encryption may be used, such as that provided by IPSec RFC4301 for IP flows and/or by an underlying sub-net using MACSec IEEE802.1AE-2018 for Ethernet (Layer-2) flows." "IESG review comment resolutions in this version : DONE , IANA , ( 03 - 12 ) , OK , ( 03 - 15 ) , Ready with Nits Yoshifumi Nishida , ( 04 - 07 ) , Ready with Nits ( 04 - 12 ) , Editorial nits mostly , ( 04 - 15 ) , Editorial comments TO BE DISCUSSED : , ( 03 - 13 ) , Ready with Issues ( Ready , as soon as I - D.ietf - detnet - security is reviewed and becomes an RFC . ) reviewed in April 22 meeting" f95284c65618abd001877da8cfc9f18a49096d95 f95284c65618abd001877da8cfc9f18a49096d95 draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework d69209141d4946a6829e20f8b4b4b7e8ae7b6d91c2f310a11b6ad1360d13a505 ['9e9f77a071d3a97f3aef1abe88bdbbbd520589be867f06f7aab99e2fd42ec963', 'd69209141d4946a6829e20f8b4b4b7e8ae7b6d91c2f310a11b6ad1360d13a505', '38a0a4ed16cf457fd346ca2d2feeecab03cbf7d6042e7a7467dcbcdb6b8d21dc', 'a488530ff7f46a9e785fc2ebd8536826140261d94b1d948be414cdabc20df4d6'] B "the primary consideration for the data plane is to maintain integrity of data and delivery of the associated detnet service traversing the detnet network. application flows can be protected through whatever means is provided by the underlying technology. for example, encryption may be used, such as that provided by ipsec rfc4301 for ip flows and/or by an underlying sub-net using macsec ieee802.1ae-2018 for ethernet (layer-2) flows." {90: 1, 67: 1, 6: 4, 79: 4, 51: 3, 130: 4, 62: 6, 85: 7, 68: 6, 35: 5, 110: 3, 91: 4, 114: 3, 97: 4, 31: 2, 13: 2, 38: 4, 26: 3, 124: 5, 98: 4, 54: 4, 127: 5, 8: 4, 96: 4, 64: 3, 30: 3, 61: 5, 55: 5, 27: 4, 15: 3, 52: 3, 129: 5, 115: 2, 84: 3, 76: 8, 87: 3, 131: 7, 102: 2, 113: 5, 99: 4, 36: 2, 24: 2, 53: 3, 72: 4} {402: 1, 351: 1, 1: 11, 4: 4, 9: 7, 10: 5, 15: 4, 24: 4, 25: 6, 26: 7, 27: 3, 39: 7, 43: 5, 49: 5, 50: 4, 58: 5, 59: 4, 64: 4, 69: 6, 81: 7, 82: 5, 86: 3, 96: 4, 97: 3, 100: 8, 108: 5, 109: 6, 110: 6, 111: 4, 114: 5, 115: 6, 116: 4, 118: 8, 119: 7, 120: 5, 121: 6, 122: 5, 123: 4, 124: 6, 128: 3, 129: 3, 130: 5, 132: 6, 136: 4, 145: 6, 147: 4, 151: 3, 152: 3, 154: 5, 156: 3, 161: 5, 162: 5, 165: 5, 168: 6, 169: 2, 172: 3, 180: 3, 184: 7, 187: 7, 188: 6, 191: 5, 194: 6, 202: 7, 203: 8, 206: 4, 207: 5, 215: 4, 217: 5, 218: 10, 220: 4, 221: 4, 222: 7, 224: 5, 227: 6, 229: 3, 234: 7, 235: 4, 241: 4, 242: 4, 243: 6, 245: 6, 248: 2, 250: 5, 258: 13, 262: 6, 263: 7, 264: 5, 267: 6, 270: 4, 272: 2, 273: 7, 287: 5, 289: 3, 291: 5, 299: 6, 300: 4, 304: 4, 309: 5, 314: 4, 315: 2, 320: 6, 323: 6, 327: 6, 328: 5, 329: 4, 330: 12, 334: 4, 335: 4, 341: 6, 342: 7, 347: 6, 348: 6, 350: 9, 352: 3, 353: 2, 354: 2, 358: 6, 365: 3, 366: 4, 369: 3, 371: 8, 372: 5, 376: 4, 384: 5, 385: 4, 386: 5, 387: 4, 392: 5, 393: 6, 396: 7, 397: 9, 398: 8} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 84 "To provide uninterrupted availability of the DetNet service, provisions can be made against DOS attacks and delay attacks. To protect against DOS attacks, excess traffic due to malicious or malfunctioning devices can be prevented or mitigated, for example through the use of existing mechanism such as policing and shaping applied at the input of a DetNet domain. To prevent DetNet packets from being delayed by an entity external to a DetNet domain, DetNet technology definition can allow for the mitigation of Man-In-The- Middle attacks, for example through use of authentication and authorization of devices within the DetNet domain." "IESG review comment resolutions in this version : DONE , IANA , ( 03 - 12 ) , OK , ( 03 - 15 ) , Ready with Nits Yoshifumi Nishida , ( 04 - 07 ) , Ready with Nits ( 04 - 12 ) , Editorial nits mostly , ( 04 - 15 ) , Editorial comments TO BE DISCUSSED : , ( 03 - 13 ) , Ready with Issues ( Ready , as soon as I - D.ietf - detnet - security is reviewed and becomes an RFC . ) reviewed in April 22 meeting" f95284c65618abd001877da8cfc9f18a49096d95 f95284c65618abd001877da8cfc9f18a49096d95 draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework 9660729dcccf51d5b146b7b549f874e0feac220bda1c96d69e1fcfab2efbb95f ['b6c3c443fd30b435fb3c22bc431645c3d888b67d16321f77aa6044b757524bc5', '9660729dcccf51d5b146b7b549f874e0feac220bda1c96d69e1fcfab2efbb95f'] A "to provide uninterrupted availability of the detnet service, provisions can be made against dos attacks and delay attacks. to protect against dos attacks, excess traffic due to malicious or malfunctioning devices can be prevented or mitigated, for example through the use of existing mechanism such as policing and shaping applied at the input of a detnet domain. to prevent detnet packets from being delayed by an entity external to a detnet domain, detnet technology definition can allow for the mitigation of man-in-the- middle attacks, for example through use of authentication and authorization of devices within the detnet domain." {87: 1, 15: 1, 36: 1, 24: 1, 6: 3, 79: 3, 90: 2, 51: 3, 130: 3, 62: 5, 85: 6, 68: 5, 35: 4, 110: 2, 91: 3, 114: 2, 97: 3, 31: 3, 13: 2, 67: 2, 38: 3, 26: 2, 124: 4, 98: 3, 54: 3, 127: 4, 8: 3, 96: 3, 64: 2, 30: 2, 61: 4, 55: 4, 27: 3, 52: 2, 129: 4, 115: 2, 84: 3, 76: 7, 131: 6, 102: 2, 113: 4, 99: 3, 53: 2, 72: 3} {229: 1, 352: 1, 353: 1, 354: 1, 1: 10, 4: 3, 9: 6, 10: 4, 15: 3, 24: 3, 25: 5, 26: 6, 27: 3, 39: 6, 43: 4, 49: 4, 50: 3, 58: 4, 59: 3, 64: 3, 69: 5, 81: 6, 82: 4, 86: 2, 96: 3, 97: 2, 100: 7, 108: 4, 109: 5, 110: 5, 111: 3, 114: 4, 115: 5, 116: 3, 118: 7, 119: 6, 120: 4, 121: 5, 122: 4, 123: 3, 124: 5, 128: 2, 129: 2, 130: 4, 132: 5, 136: 3, 145: 5, 147: 3, 151: 3, 152: 3, 154: 4, 156: 2, 161: 4, 162: 4, 165: 4, 168: 5, 169: 2, 172: 2, 180: 2, 184: 6, 187: 6, 188: 5, 191: 4, 194: 5, 202: 6, 203: 7, 206: 3, 207: 4, 215: 3, 217: 4, 218: 9, 220: 3, 221: 3, 222: 6, 224: 4, 227: 5, 234: 6, 235: 3, 241: 3, 242: 3, 243: 5, 244: 3, 245: 5, 248: 3, 250: 4, 258: 12, 262: 5, 263: 6, 264: 4, 267: 5, 270: 3, 272: 2, 273: 6, 287: 4, 291: 4, 299: 5, 300: 3, 304: 3, 309: 4, 314: 3, 315: 2, 320: 5, 323: 5, 327: 5, 328: 4, 329: 3, 330: 11, 334: 3, 335: 3, 341: 5, 342: 6, 347: 5, 348: 5, 350: 8, 351: 4, 358: 5, 365: 2, 366: 3, 369: 2, 371: 7, 372: 4, 376: 3, 384: 4, 385: 3, 386: 4, 387: 3, 392: 4, 393: 5, 396: 6, 397: 8, 398: 7, 402: 2} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 84 "To provide uninterrupted availability of the DetNet service, provisions can be made against DOS attacks and delay attacks. To protect against DOS attacks, excess traffic due to malicious or malfunctioning devices can be prevented or mitigated, for example through the use of existing mechanisms such as policing and shaping applied at the input of a DetNet domain. To prevent DetNet packets from being delayed by an entity external to a DetNet domain, DetNet technology definition can allow for the mitigation of Man-In-The- Middle attacks, for example through use of authentication and authorization of devices within the DetNet domain." "IESG review comment resolutions in this version : DONE , IANA , ( 03 - 12 ) , OK , ( 03 - 15 ) , Ready with Nits Yoshifumi Nishida , ( 04 - 07 ) , Ready with Nits ( 04 - 12 ) , Editorial nits mostly , ( 04 - 15 ) , Editorial comments TO BE DISCUSSED : , ( 03 - 13 ) , Ready with Issues ( Ready , as soon as I - D.ietf - detnet - security is reviewed and becomes an RFC . ) reviewed in April 22 meeting" f95284c65618abd001877da8cfc9f18a49096d95 f95284c65618abd001877da8cfc9f18a49096d95 draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework b6c3c443fd30b435fb3c22bc431645c3d888b67d16321f77aa6044b757524bc5 ['b6c3c443fd30b435fb3c22bc431645c3d888b67d16321f77aa6044b757524bc5', '9660729dcccf51d5b146b7b549f874e0feac220bda1c96d69e1fcfab2efbb95f'] B "to provide uninterrupted availability of the detnet service, provisions can be made against dos attacks and delay attacks. to protect against dos attacks, excess traffic due to malicious or malfunctioning devices can be prevented or mitigated, for example through the use of existing mechanisms such as policing and shaping applied at the input of a detnet domain. to prevent detnet packets from being delayed by an entity external to a detnet domain, detnet technology definition can allow for the mitigation of man-in-the- middle attacks, for example through use of authentication and authorization of devices within the detnet domain." {87: 1, 15: 1, 36: 1, 24: 1, 6: 3, 79: 3, 90: 2, 51: 3, 130: 3, 62: 5, 85: 6, 68: 5, 35: 4, 110: 2, 91: 3, 114: 2, 97: 3, 31: 3, 13: 2, 67: 2, 38: 3, 26: 2, 124: 4, 98: 3, 54: 3, 127: 4, 8: 3, 96: 3, 64: 2, 30: 2, 61: 4, 55: 4, 27: 3, 52: 2, 129: 4, 115: 2, 84: 3, 76: 7, 131: 6, 102: 2, 113: 4, 99: 3, 53: 2, 72: 3} {229: 1, 352: 1, 353: 1, 354: 1, 1: 10, 4: 3, 9: 6, 10: 4, 15: 3, 24: 3, 25: 5, 26: 6, 27: 3, 39: 6, 43: 4, 49: 4, 50: 3, 58: 4, 59: 3, 64: 3, 69: 5, 81: 6, 82: 4, 86: 2, 96: 3, 97: 2, 100: 7, 108: 4, 109: 5, 110: 5, 111: 3, 114: 4, 115: 5, 116: 3, 118: 7, 119: 6, 120: 4, 121: 5, 122: 4, 123: 3, 124: 5, 128: 2, 129: 2, 130: 4, 132: 5, 136: 3, 145: 5, 147: 3, 151: 3, 152: 3, 154: 4, 156: 2, 161: 4, 162: 4, 165: 4, 168: 5, 169: 2, 172: 2, 180: 2, 184: 6, 187: 6, 188: 5, 191: 4, 194: 5, 202: 6, 203: 7, 206: 3, 207: 4, 215: 3, 217: 4, 218: 9, 220: 3, 221: 3, 222: 6, 224: 4, 227: 5, 234: 6, 235: 3, 241: 3, 242: 3, 243: 5, 244: 3, 245: 5, 248: 3, 250: 4, 258: 12, 262: 5, 263: 6, 264: 4, 267: 5, 270: 3, 272: 2, 273: 6, 287: 4, 291: 4, 299: 5, 300: 3, 304: 3, 309: 4, 314: 3, 315: 2, 320: 5, 323: 5, 327: 5, 328: 4, 329: 3, 330: 11, 334: 3, 335: 3, 341: 5, 342: 6, 347: 5, 348: 5, 350: 8, 351: 4, 358: 5, 365: 2, 366: 3, 369: 2, 371: 7, 372: 4, 376: 3, 384: 4, 385: 3, 386: 4, 387: 3, 392: 4, 393: 5, 396: 6, 397: 8, 398: 7, 402: 2} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 83 "The DetNet Architecture models the DetNet related data plane functions as two sub-layers: functions into two sub-layers: a service sub-layer and a forwarding sub-layer. The service sub-layer is used to provide DetNet service protection (e.g., by packet replication and packet elimination functions) and reordering. The forwarding sub- layer is used to provide congestion protection (low loss, assured latency, and limited out-of-order delivery). The service sub-layer generally requires additional fields to provide its service; for example see I-D.ietf-detnet-mpls. Since no DetNet-specific fields are added to support DetNet IP flows, only the forwarding sub-layer functions are supported using the DetNet IP defined by this document. Service protection can be provided on a per sub-net basis using technologies such as MPLS I-D.ietf-detnet-dp-sol-mpls and Ethernet as specified in the IEEE 802.1 TSN task group(referred to in this document simply as IEEE802.1 TSN)." from and Tero 13eb5e7e607144b4897aa0f55053179fdf71518c 13eb5e7e607144b4897aa0f55053179fdf71518c draft-ietf-detnet-ip fa4c0a27dfaeacb3fabfd8a4bf12e48b1a4c5003b903fffb2419d3df0e13a8d5 ['5774ebb3a2e4d46ee8530230b29256391a8e47d5fc0a923fe32c3bc5390092ce', 'fa4c0a27dfaeacb3fabfd8a4bf12e48b1a4c5003b903fffb2419d3df0e13a8d5'] A "the detnet architecture models the detnet related data plane functions as two sub-layers: functions into two sub-layers: a service sub-layer and a forwarding sub-layer. the service sub-layer is used to provide detnet service protection (e.g., by packet replication and packet elimination functions) and reordering. the forwarding sub- layer is used to provide congestion protection (low loss, assured latency, and limited out-of-order delivery). the service sub-layer generally requires additional fields to provide its service; for example see i-d.ietf-detnet-mpls. since no detnet-specific fields are added to support detnet ip flows, only the forwarding sub-layer functions are supported using the detnet ip defined by this document. service protection can be provided on a per sub-net basis using technologies such as mpls i-d.ietf-detnet-dp-sol-mpls and ethernet as specified in the ieee 802.1 tsn task group(referred to in this document simply as ieee802.1 tsn)." {85: 1} {139: 1} {139, 140} 83 "The DetNet Architecture models the DetNet related data plane functions as two sub-layers: a service sub-layer and a forwarding sub-layer. The service sub-layer is used to provide DetNet service protection (e.g., by packet replication and packet elimination functions) and reordering. The forwarding sub-layer is used to provide congestion protection (low loss, assured latency, and limited out-of-order delivery). The service sub-layer generally requires additional fields to provide its service; for example see I-D.ietf- detnet-mpls. Since no DetNet-specific fields are added to support DetNet IP flows, only the forwarding sub-layer functions are supported using the DetNet IP defined by this document. Service protection can be provided on a per sub-net basis using technologies such as MPLS I-D.ietf-detnet-dp-sol-mpls and Ethernet as specified in the IEEE 802.1 TSN task group(referred to in this document simply as IEEE802.1 TSN)." from and Tero 13eb5e7e607144b4897aa0f55053179fdf71518c 13eb5e7e607144b4897aa0f55053179fdf71518c draft-ietf-detnet-ip 5774ebb3a2e4d46ee8530230b29256391a8e47d5fc0a923fe32c3bc5390092ce ['5774ebb3a2e4d46ee8530230b29256391a8e47d5fc0a923fe32c3bc5390092ce', 'fa4c0a27dfaeacb3fabfd8a4bf12e48b1a4c5003b903fffb2419d3df0e13a8d5'] B "the detnet architecture models the detnet related data plane functions as two sub-layers: a service sub-layer and a forwarding sub-layer. the service sub-layer is used to provide detnet service protection (e.g., by packet replication and packet elimination functions) and reordering. the forwarding sub-layer is used to provide congestion protection (low loss, assured latency, and limited out-of-order delivery). the service sub-layer generally requires additional fields to provide its service; for example see i-d.ietf- detnet-mpls. since no detnet-specific fields are added to support detnet ip flows, only the forwarding sub-layer functions are supported using the detnet ip defined by this document. service protection can be provided on a per sub-net basis using technologies such as mpls i-d.ietf-detnet-dp-sol-mpls and ethernet as specified in the ieee 802.1 tsn task group(referred to in this document simply as ieee802.1 tsn)." {85: 1} {139: 1} {139, 140} 83 "Class of Service (CoS) for DetNet flows carried in IPv6 is provided using the standard differentiated services code point (DSCP) field RFC2474 and related mechanisms." from and Tero 13eb5e7e607144b4897aa0f55053179fdf71518c 13eb5e7e607144b4897aa0f55053179fdf71518c draft-ietf-detnet-ip c617cb71f30ac8b299bff02bc0043bda2a90f7f6f9a3a4504cd1e92b15effebf ['c617cb71f30ac8b299bff02bc0043bda2a90f7f6f9a3a4504cd1e92b15effebf', '3add340149843f427e7c57ed2472db19f5c803047cd5b77d34b24e81da1ed4da'] A "class of service (cos) for detnet flows carried in ipv6 is provided using the standard differentiated services code point (dscp) field rfc2474 and related mechanisms." {85: 1, 60: 1} {90: 1, 310: 1} {90, 310, 311} 83 "Class of Service (CoS) for DetNet flows carried in IPv4 and IPv6 is provided using the standard differentiated services code point (DSCP) field RFC2474 and related mechanisms." from and Tero 13eb5e7e607144b4897aa0f55053179fdf71518c 13eb5e7e607144b4897aa0f55053179fdf71518c draft-ietf-detnet-ip 3add340149843f427e7c57ed2472db19f5c803047cd5b77d34b24e81da1ed4da ['c617cb71f30ac8b299bff02bc0043bda2a90f7f6f9a3a4504cd1e92b15effebf', '3add340149843f427e7c57ed2472db19f5c803047cd5b77d34b24e81da1ed4da'] B "class of service (cos) for detnet flows carried in ipv4 and ipv6 is provided using the standard differentiated services code point (dscp) field rfc2474 and related mechanisms." {85: 1, 60: 1} {90: 1, 310: 1} {90, 310, 311} 83 "The rules defined in this section only apply when the IPv4 Protocol or IPv6 Next Header Field contains the IANA defined value for UDP or TCP." from and Tero 13eb5e7e607144b4897aa0f55053179fdf71518c 13eb5e7e607144b4897aa0f55053179fdf71518c draft-ietf-detnet-ip 15867c818b74d7fcb159846130b4ba3ff2649439bf99f5964141223fb1f3c1fa ['15867c818b74d7fcb159846130b4ba3ff2649439bf99f5964141223fb1f3c1fa'] B "the rules defined in this section only apply when the ipv4 protocol or ipv6 next header field contains the iana defined value for udp or tcp." {} {} {} 83 "The rules defined in this section only apply when the IPv4 Protocol or IPv6 Next Header Field contains the IANA defined value for AH or ESP." from and Tero 13eb5e7e607144b4897aa0f55053179fdf71518c 13eb5e7e607144b4897aa0f55053179fdf71518c draft-ietf-detnet-ip b78e86c2fa38ac086ce230e8469368fed9b72f63288268819005a37a460ec19b ['b78e86c2fa38ac086ce230e8469368fed9b72f63288268819005a37a460ec19b'] B "the rules defined in this section only apply when the ipv4 protocol or ipv6 next header field contains the iana defined value for ah or esp." {} {} {} 83 "If the DSCP field is to be used in flow identification. Ignoring the DSCP filed is optional." from and Tero 13eb5e7e607144b4897aa0f55053179fdf71518c 13eb5e7e607144b4897aa0f55053179fdf71518c draft-ietf-detnet-ip 6a045f59ae53d8c90751f230e053f9392cc5e00ef0382c3dbf69c8cd5273bbb0 ['6a045f59ae53d8c90751f230e053f9392cc5e00ef0382c3dbf69c8cd5273bbb0', '7abba4f957bdaec7e3c1ced9a66b48c1a5c98589b09d32a90eacf73731daef32'] A "if the dscp field is to be used in flow identification. ignoring the dscp filed is optional." {85: 1, 56: 1, 60: 2, 102: 3, 64: 2, 38: 3, 62: 4, 71: 3, 33: 2, 26: 3, 32: 2, 113: 3, 126: 4, 112: 3, 129: 4} {363: 1, 261: 1, 260: 2, 274: 3, 339: 4, 212: 3, 343: 4, 283: 4, 286: 5, 31: 2, 32: 3, 33: 2, 228: 3, 357: 3, 166: 4, 231: 2, 298: 3, 46: 4, 377: 3} {260, 261, 274, 283, 286, 31, 32, 33, 163, 166, 298, 46, 339, 212, 343, 228, 357, 231, 363, 377} 83 "If the DSCP field is to be used in flow identification. Ignoring the DSCP field is optional." from and Tero 13eb5e7e607144b4897aa0f55053179fdf71518c 13eb5e7e607144b4897aa0f55053179fdf71518c draft-ietf-detnet-ip 7abba4f957bdaec7e3c1ced9a66b48c1a5c98589b09d32a90eacf73731daef32 ['6a045f59ae53d8c90751f230e053f9392cc5e00ef0382c3dbf69c8cd5273bbb0', '7abba4f957bdaec7e3c1ced9a66b48c1a5c98589b09d32a90eacf73731daef32'] B "if the dscp field is to be used in flow identification. ignoring the dscp field is optional." {85: 1, 56: 1, 60: 2, 102: 3, 64: 2, 38: 3, 62: 4, 71: 3, 33: 2, 26: 3, 32: 2, 113: 3, 126: 4, 112: 3, 129: 4} {363: 1, 261: 1, 260: 2, 274: 3, 339: 4, 212: 3, 343: 4, 283: 4, 286: 5, 31: 2, 32: 3, 33: 2, 228: 3, 357: 3, 166: 4, 231: 2, 298: 3, 46: 4, 377: 3} {260, 261, 274, 283, 286, 31, 32, 33, 163, 166, 298, 46, 339, 212, 343, 228, 357, 231, 363, 377} 83 IPsec Header SPI field. Exact matching is required. from and Tero 13eb5e7e607144b4897aa0f55053179fdf71518c 13eb5e7e607144b4897aa0f55053179fdf71518c draft-ietf-detnet-ip a6f05aafd4996bb8e56e1e0f7f907b8cf657c4d7631c0c93d638cfce30798835 ['d25277a16dfa81929cc8d91485d6e572e925491b99e4bda9523f79ca72651acc', 'a6f05aafd4996bb8e56e1e0f7f907b8cf657c4d7631c0c93d638cfce30798835'] A ipsec header spi field. exact matching is required. {13: 1} {257: 1} {336, 257} 83 "IPsec Header SPI field. Exact matching is required. Support for wildcard matching is recommended." from and Tero 13eb5e7e607144b4897aa0f55053179fdf71518c 13eb5e7e607144b4897aa0f55053179fdf71518c draft-ietf-detnet-ip d25277a16dfa81929cc8d91485d6e572e925491b99e4bda9523f79ca72651acc ['d25277a16dfa81929cc8d91485d6e572e925491b99e4bda9523f79ca72651acc', 'a6f05aafd4996bb8e56e1e0f7f907b8cf657c4d7631c0c93d638cfce30798835'] B "ipsec header spi field. exact matching is required. support for wildcard matching is recommended." {13: 1} {257: 1} {336, 257} 80 Frame Replication and Elimination for Redundancy (TSN function). Remove of editorial comments and update of abbreviations and references . 49777f2a1f4a7bbd19c5e3e505e331597655877b 49777f2a1f4a7bbd19c5e3e505e331597655877b draft-ietf-detnet-ip-over-tsn 7c29d182df52ad8a912d64a1a9fa6feee494e1142ce6abeb5c37c626b5e5590f ['7c29d182df52ad8a912d64a1a9fa6feee494e1142ce6abeb5c37c626b5e5590f'] B frame replication and elimination for redundancy (tsn function). {53: 1, 52: 1, 130: 3, 79: 2, 51: 2, 112: 3, 55: 3, 64: 2, 62: 3, 37: 2, 38: 3, 69: 2, 68: 2, 67: 2, 33: 2, 25: 2, 127: 4, 91: 3} {185: 1, 321: 1, 0: 3, 389: 2, 390: 2, 135: 3, 142: 3, 14: 2, 400: 3, 17: 2, 399: 3, 19: 3, 149: 3, 406: 2, 279: 2, 280: 2, 281: 3, 278: 2, 294: 2, 296: 3, 45: 3, 308: 2, 56: 2, 322: 2, 66: 2, 196: 5, 197: 4, 324: 3, 77: 3, 78: 3, 337: 4, 216: 3, 380: 2, 255: 3} {0, 389, 390, 135, 142, 14, 400, 17, 399, 19, 149, 406, 279, 280, 281, 278, 294, 296, 45, 308, 56, 185, 192, 321, 322, 66, 196, 197, 324, 77, 78, 337, 216, 380, 255} 79 Class of Service. Adding conformance language and packet processing details . 3bfedfa5d8087d355944e1061153643e51701145 3bfedfa5d8087d355944e1061153643e51701145 draft-ietf-detnet-tsn-vpn-over-mpls f26b50ed804ba5111d76706f92b83072518815ec945b0054da2495f47279287a ['f26b50ed804ba5111d76706f92b83072518815ec945b0054da2495f47279287a'] A class of service. {52: 1, 51: 1, 130: 3, 112: 3, 55: 3, 64: 2, 62: 3, 37: 2, 38: 3, 69: 2, 68: 2, 79: 2, 67: 2, 33: 2, 25: 2, 53: 2, 80: 2, 127: 4, 91: 3} {321: 1, 390: 1, 0: 3, 135: 3, 142: 3, 14: 2, 400: 3, 17: 2, 399: 3, 19: 3, 149: 3, 406: 2, 279: 2, 280: 2, 281: 3, 278: 2, 294: 2, 296: 3, 45: 3, 308: 2, 56: 2, 185: 2, 192: 2, 322: 2, 66: 2, 196: 5, 197: 4, 324: 3, 77: 3, 78: 3, 337: 4, 216: 3, 380: 2, 255: 3} {0, 389, 390, 135, 142, 14, 400, 17, 399, 19, 149, 406, 279, 280, 281, 278, 294, 296, 45, 308, 56, 185, 192, 321, 322, 66, 196, 197, 324, 77, 78, 337, 216, 380, 255} 79 Multi-Segment PseudoWire (MS-PW). Adding conformance language and packet processing details . 3bfedfa5d8087d355944e1061153643e51701145 3bfedfa5d8087d355944e1061153643e51701145 draft-ietf-detnet-tsn-vpn-over-mpls c2441bad9168c35aef67c82d8c8ca1d32bfa5f2bd7b4e3fdcb0c74913367661f ['b44b885a406cb9ec036bed7a2f808cd599fef92864f4ac305f6309a2fb37cb4d', 'fcbb4b68ae78c4ce9cca6d03e0f62a1b8515b67ad1bc512e0d4857a6b428fb55', 'c2441bad9168c35aef67c82d8c8ca1d32bfa5f2bd7b4e3fdcb0c74913367661f', '09f6b6a812132eee463de5625d44082094351e5e01c90e0e4dc14d2893ef6a38', '45bc601f4e7c8b80cc0c429fc5273808e88ddf7f6b0c7053a4c557e2c279a10d', '18586b4a34af8afb3b19ff32c04e0b7b2f961021e15338b0a5a3ccafbea3e89f'] A multi-segment pseudowire (ms-pw). {112: 1, 68: 1, 52: 1, 37: 1, 51: 1, 69: 1, 130: 3, 79: 2, 55: 2, 64: 2, 62: 2, 38: 2, 67: 2, 33: 2, 25: 2, 53: 2, 80: 2, 127: 4, 91: 2} {135: 1, 279: 1, 321: 1, 296: 1, 308: 1, 406: 1, 380: 1, 0: 3, 389: 2, 390: 2, 142: 2, 14: 2, 400: 2, 17: 2, 399: 3, 19: 3, 149: 2, 281: 3, 278: 2, 294: 2, 45: 2, 56: 2, 185: 2, 192: 2, 322: 2, 66: 2, 196: 5, 197: 4, 324: 2, 77: 2, 78: 2, 337: 4, 216: 2, 255: 3} {0, 389, 390, 135, 142, 14, 400, 17, 399, 19, 149, 406, 279, 280, 281, 278, 294, 296, 45, 308, 56, 185, 192, 321, 322, 66, 196, 197, 324, 77, 78, 337, 216, 380, 255} 79 Packet Elimination Function. Adding conformance language and packet processing details . 3bfedfa5d8087d355944e1061153643e51701145 3bfedfa5d8087d355944e1061153643e51701145 draft-ietf-detnet-tsn-vpn-over-mpls 18586b4a34af8afb3b19ff32c04e0b7b2f961021e15338b0a5a3ccafbea3e89f ['b44b885a406cb9ec036bed7a2f808cd599fef92864f4ac305f6309a2fb37cb4d', 'fcbb4b68ae78c4ce9cca6d03e0f62a1b8515b67ad1bc512e0d4857a6b428fb55', 'c2441bad9168c35aef67c82d8c8ca1d32bfa5f2bd7b4e3fdcb0c74913367661f', '09f6b6a812132eee463de5625d44082094351e5e01c90e0e4dc14d2893ef6a38', '45bc601f4e7c8b80cc0c429fc5273808e88ddf7f6b0c7053a4c557e2c279a10d', '18586b4a34af8afb3b19ff32c04e0b7b2f961021e15338b0a5a3ccafbea3e89f'] A packet elimination function. {112: 1, 68: 1, 52: 1, 37: 1, 51: 1, 69: 1, 130: 3, 79: 2, 55: 2, 64: 2, 62: 2, 38: 2, 67: 2, 33: 2, 25: 2, 53: 2, 80: 2, 127: 4, 91: 2} {135: 1, 279: 1, 321: 1, 296: 1, 308: 1, 406: 1, 380: 1, 0: 3, 389: 2, 390: 2, 142: 2, 14: 2, 400: 2, 17: 2, 399: 3, 19: 3, 149: 2, 281: 3, 278: 2, 294: 2, 45: 2, 56: 2, 185: 2, 192: 2, 322: 2, 66: 2, 196: 5, 197: 4, 324: 2, 77: 2, 78: 2, 337: 4, 216: 2, 255: 3} {0, 389, 390, 135, 142, 14, 400, 17, 399, 19, 149, 406, 279, 280, 281, 278, 294, 296, 45, 308, 56, 185, 192, 321, 322, 66, 196, 197, 324, 77, 78, 337, 216, 380, 255} 79 Packet Replication Function. Adding conformance language and packet processing details . 3bfedfa5d8087d355944e1061153643e51701145 3bfedfa5d8087d355944e1061153643e51701145 draft-ietf-detnet-tsn-vpn-over-mpls fcbb4b68ae78c4ce9cca6d03e0f62a1b8515b67ad1bc512e0d4857a6b428fb55 ['b44b885a406cb9ec036bed7a2f808cd599fef92864f4ac305f6309a2fb37cb4d', 'fcbb4b68ae78c4ce9cca6d03e0f62a1b8515b67ad1bc512e0d4857a6b428fb55', 'c2441bad9168c35aef67c82d8c8ca1d32bfa5f2bd7b4e3fdcb0c74913367661f', '09f6b6a812132eee463de5625d44082094351e5e01c90e0e4dc14d2893ef6a38', '45bc601f4e7c8b80cc0c429fc5273808e88ddf7f6b0c7053a4c557e2c279a10d', '18586b4a34af8afb3b19ff32c04e0b7b2f961021e15338b0a5a3ccafbea3e89f'] A packet replication function. {112: 1, 68: 1, 52: 1, 37: 1, 51: 1, 69: 1, 130: 3, 79: 2, 55: 2, 64: 2, 62: 2, 38: 2, 67: 2, 33: 2, 25: 2, 53: 2, 80: 2, 127: 4, 91: 2} {135: 1, 279: 1, 321: 1, 296: 1, 308: 1, 406: 1, 380: 1, 0: 3, 389: 2, 390: 2, 142: 2, 14: 2, 400: 2, 17: 2, 399: 3, 19: 3, 149: 2, 281: 3, 278: 2, 294: 2, 45: 2, 56: 2, 185: 2, 192: 2, 322: 2, 66: 2, 196: 5, 197: 4, 324: 2, 77: 2, 78: 2, 337: 4, 216: 2, 255: 3} {0, 389, 390, 135, 142, 14, 400, 17, 399, 19, 149, 406, 279, 280, 281, 278, 294, 296, 45, 308, 56, 185, 192, 321, 322, 66, 196, 197, 324, 77, 78, 337, 216, 380, 255} 79 Packet Ordering Function. Adding conformance language and packet processing details . 3bfedfa5d8087d355944e1061153643e51701145 3bfedfa5d8087d355944e1061153643e51701145 draft-ietf-detnet-tsn-vpn-over-mpls 45bc601f4e7c8b80cc0c429fc5273808e88ddf7f6b0c7053a4c557e2c279a10d ['b44b885a406cb9ec036bed7a2f808cd599fef92864f4ac305f6309a2fb37cb4d', 'fcbb4b68ae78c4ce9cca6d03e0f62a1b8515b67ad1bc512e0d4857a6b428fb55', 'c2441bad9168c35aef67c82d8c8ca1d32bfa5f2bd7b4e3fdcb0c74913367661f', '09f6b6a812132eee463de5625d44082094351e5e01c90e0e4dc14d2893ef6a38', '45bc601f4e7c8b80cc0c429fc5273808e88ddf7f6b0c7053a4c557e2c279a10d', '18586b4a34af8afb3b19ff32c04e0b7b2f961021e15338b0a5a3ccafbea3e89f'] A packet ordering function. {112: 1, 68: 1, 52: 1, 37: 1, 51: 1, 69: 1, 130: 3, 79: 2, 55: 2, 64: 2, 62: 2, 38: 2, 67: 2, 33: 2, 25: 2, 53: 2, 80: 2, 127: 4, 91: 2} {135: 1, 279: 1, 321: 1, 296: 1, 308: 1, 406: 1, 380: 1, 0: 3, 389: 2, 390: 2, 142: 2, 14: 2, 400: 2, 17: 2, 399: 3, 19: 3, 149: 2, 281: 3, 278: 2, 294: 2, 45: 2, 56: 2, 185: 2, 192: 2, 322: 2, 66: 2, 196: 5, 197: 4, 324: 2, 77: 2, 78: 2, 337: 4, 216: 2, 255: 3} {0, 389, 390, 135, 142, 14, 400, 17, 399, 19, 149, 406, 279, 280, 281, 278, 294, 296, 45, 308, 56, 185, 192, 321, 322, 66, 196, 197, 324, 77, 78, 337, 216, 380, 255} 79 Packet Switched Network. Adding conformance language and packet processing details . 3bfedfa5d8087d355944e1061153643e51701145 3bfedfa5d8087d355944e1061153643e51701145 draft-ietf-detnet-tsn-vpn-over-mpls b44b885a406cb9ec036bed7a2f808cd599fef92864f4ac305f6309a2fb37cb4d ['b44b885a406cb9ec036bed7a2f808cd599fef92864f4ac305f6309a2fb37cb4d', 'fcbb4b68ae78c4ce9cca6d03e0f62a1b8515b67ad1bc512e0d4857a6b428fb55', 'c2441bad9168c35aef67c82d8c8ca1d32bfa5f2bd7b4e3fdcb0c74913367661f', '09f6b6a812132eee463de5625d44082094351e5e01c90e0e4dc14d2893ef6a38', '45bc601f4e7c8b80cc0c429fc5273808e88ddf7f6b0c7053a4c557e2c279a10d', '18586b4a34af8afb3b19ff32c04e0b7b2f961021e15338b0a5a3ccafbea3e89f'] A packet switched network. {112: 1, 68: 1, 52: 1, 37: 1, 51: 1, 69: 1, 130: 3, 79: 2, 55: 2, 64: 2, 62: 2, 38: 2, 67: 2, 33: 2, 25: 2, 53: 2, 80: 2, 127: 4, 91: 2} {135: 1, 279: 1, 321: 1, 296: 1, 308: 1, 406: 1, 380: 1, 0: 3, 389: 2, 390: 2, 142: 2, 14: 2, 400: 2, 17: 2, 399: 3, 19: 3, 149: 2, 281: 3, 278: 2, 294: 2, 45: 2, 56: 2, 185: 2, 192: 2, 322: 2, 66: 2, 196: 5, 197: 4, 324: 2, 77: 2, 78: 2, 337: 4, 216: 2, 255: 3} {0, 389, 390, 135, 142, 14, 400, 17, 399, 19, 149, 406, 279, 280, 281, 278, 294, 296, 45, 308, 56, 185, 192, 321, 322, 66, 196, 197, 324, 77, 78, 337, 216, 380, 255} 79 Quality of Service. Adding conformance language and packet processing details . 3bfedfa5d8087d355944e1061153643e51701145 3bfedfa5d8087d355944e1061153643e51701145 draft-ietf-detnet-tsn-vpn-over-mpls 09f6b6a812132eee463de5625d44082094351e5e01c90e0e4dc14d2893ef6a38 ['b44b885a406cb9ec036bed7a2f808cd599fef92864f4ac305f6309a2fb37cb4d', 'fcbb4b68ae78c4ce9cca6d03e0f62a1b8515b67ad1bc512e0d4857a6b428fb55', 'c2441bad9168c35aef67c82d8c8ca1d32bfa5f2bd7b4e3fdcb0c74913367661f', '09f6b6a812132eee463de5625d44082094351e5e01c90e0e4dc14d2893ef6a38', '45bc601f4e7c8b80cc0c429fc5273808e88ddf7f6b0c7053a4c557e2c279a10d', '18586b4a34af8afb3b19ff32c04e0b7b2f961021e15338b0a5a3ccafbea3e89f'] A quality of service. {112: 1, 68: 1, 52: 1, 37: 1, 51: 1, 69: 1, 130: 3, 79: 2, 55: 2, 64: 2, 62: 2, 38: 2, 67: 2, 33: 2, 25: 2, 53: 2, 80: 2, 127: 4, 91: 2} {135: 1, 279: 1, 321: 1, 296: 1, 308: 1, 406: 1, 380: 1, 0: 3, 389: 2, 390: 2, 142: 2, 14: 2, 400: 2, 17: 2, 399: 3, 19: 3, 149: 2, 281: 3, 278: 2, 294: 2, 45: 2, 56: 2, 185: 2, 192: 2, 322: 2, 66: 2, 196: 5, 197: 4, 324: 2, 77: 2, 78: 2, 337: 4, 216: 2, 255: 3} {0, 389, 390, 135, 142, 14, 400, 17, 399, 19, 149, 406, 279, 280, 281, 278, 294, 296, 45, 308, 56, 185, 192, 321, 322, 66, 196, 197, 324, 77, 78, 337, 216, 380, 255} 79 "The sub-sections describe procedures for forwarding packets by DetNet Edge nodes, where such packets are received from either directly connected CEs (TSN nodes) or some other DetNet Edge nodes." Adding conformance language and packet processing details . 3bfedfa5d8087d355944e1061153643e51701145 3bfedfa5d8087d355944e1061153643e51701145 draft-ietf-detnet-tsn-vpn-over-mpls 5e66409e58138bc7224f146605854d88baae264776825dd495f82347c14a7ed4 ['5e66409e58138bc7224f146605854d88baae264776825dd495f82347c14a7ed4'] B "the sub-sections describe procedures for forwarding packets by detnet edge nodes, where such packets are received from either directly connected ces (tsn nodes) or some other detnet edge nodes." {} {} {} 79 "TSN specific functions are executed on the data received by the PE from the CE before presentation to the DetNet PW for transmission across the DetNet domain, or on the data received from a DetNet PW by a PE before it is output on the Attachment Circuit (AC)." Adding conformance language and packet processing details . 3bfedfa5d8087d355944e1061153643e51701145 3bfedfa5d8087d355944e1061153643e51701145 draft-ietf-detnet-tsn-vpn-over-mpls 5cc97b8f56cdeeb02e7c96183745dc53dd8ec3ec02424107d16eb438c2c9363c ['2e2975ca1e6c9674ad57d68234a7a66554f20a02dc288c2ba645f329c82428af', '5cc97b8f56cdeeb02e7c96183745dc53dd8ec3ec02424107d16eb438c2c9363c'] A "tsn specific functions are executed on the data received by the pe from the ce before presentation to the detnet pw for transmission across the detnet domain, or on the data received from a detnet pw by a pe before it is output on the attachment circuit (ac)." {53: 1, 130: 1, 6: 2, 79: 2, 90: 3, 51: 3, 62: 5, 85: 5, 68: 4, 35: 3, 110: 3, 91: 5, 114: 3, 97: 3, 31: 3, 13: 3, 67: 3, 38: 4, 26: 3, 124: 3, 98: 2, 54: 2, 127: 3, 8: 2, 96: 3, 64: 2, 30: 4, 61: 5, 55: 3, 27: 4, 15: 3, 52: 2, 129: 3, 115: 3, 84: 3, 76: 6, 87: 3, 131: 5, 102: 3, 113: 5, 99: 2, 36: 3, 24: 2, 72: 4} {369: 1, 386: 1, 1: 9, 4: 2, 9: 5, 10: 3, 15: 3, 24: 2, 25: 5, 26: 5, 27: 3, 39: 5, 43: 3, 49: 6, 50: 5, 58: 5, 64: 3, 69: 4, 81: 6, 82: 4, 86: 3, 96: 4, 97: 3, 100: 7, 108: 3, 109: 4, 110: 4, 111: 2, 114: 3, 115: 4, 116: 3, 118: 6, 119: 5, 120: 3, 121: 4, 122: 4, 123: 3, 124: 4, 128: 4, 129: 4, 130: 5, 132: 4, 136: 2, 145: 4, 147: 4, 151: 4, 152: 4, 154: 3, 156: 2, 161: 3, 162: 3, 165: 3, 168: 4, 169: 3, 172: 3, 180: 4, 184: 5, 187: 5, 188: 4, 191: 3, 194: 4, 202: 5, 203: 6, 206: 2, 207: 3, 215: 2, 217: 3, 218: 8, 220: 2, 221: 2, 222: 5, 224: 3, 227: 5, 229: 3, 234: 5, 235: 2, 241: 2, 242: 2, 243: 4, 244: 4, 245: 4, 248: 4, 250: 4, 258: 11, 262: 4, 263: 5, 264: 3, 267: 4, 270: 3, 272: 3, 273: 5, 287: 3, 289: 3, 291: 5, 299: 5, 300: 3, 304: 3, 309: 3, 314: 2, 315: 3, 320: 4, 323: 4, 327: 4, 328: 3, 329: 2, 330: 10, 334: 2, 335: 3, 341: 5, 342: 6, 347: 5, 348: 5, 350: 7, 351: 5, 352: 3, 353: 3, 354: 2, 358: 4, 365: 3, 366: 2, 371: 7, 372: 5, 376: 2, 384: 5, 385: 4, 387: 3, 392: 3, 393: 4, 396: 6, 397: 7, 398: 6, 402: 3} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 79 "TSN specific functions are executed on the data received by the DetNet Edge Node from the connected CE before forwarded to connected CE(s) or presentation to the DetNet Service Proxy function for transmission across the DetNet domain, or on the data received from a DetNet PW by a PE before it is output on the Attachment Circuit(s) (AC)." Adding conformance language and packet processing details . 3bfedfa5d8087d355944e1061153643e51701145 3bfedfa5d8087d355944e1061153643e51701145 draft-ietf-detnet-tsn-vpn-over-mpls 2e2975ca1e6c9674ad57d68234a7a66554f20a02dc288c2ba645f329c82428af ['2e2975ca1e6c9674ad57d68234a7a66554f20a02dc288c2ba645f329c82428af', '5cc97b8f56cdeeb02e7c96183745dc53dd8ec3ec02424107d16eb438c2c9363c'] B "tsn specific functions are executed on the data received by the detnet edge node from the connected ce before forwarded to connected ce(s) or presentation to the detnet service proxy function for transmission across the detnet domain, or on the data received from a detnet pw by a pe before it is output on the attachment circuit(s) (ac)." {53: 1, 130: 1, 6: 2, 79: 2, 90: 3, 51: 3, 62: 5, 85: 5, 68: 4, 35: 3, 110: 3, 91: 5, 114: 3, 97: 3, 31: 3, 13: 3, 67: 3, 38: 4, 26: 3, 124: 3, 98: 2, 54: 2, 127: 3, 8: 2, 96: 3, 64: 2, 30: 4, 61: 5, 55: 3, 27: 4, 15: 3, 52: 2, 129: 3, 115: 3, 84: 3, 76: 6, 87: 3, 131: 5, 102: 3, 113: 5, 99: 2, 36: 3, 24: 2, 72: 4} {369: 1, 386: 1, 1: 9, 4: 2, 9: 5, 10: 3, 15: 3, 24: 2, 25: 5, 26: 5, 27: 3, 39: 5, 43: 3, 49: 6, 50: 5, 58: 5, 64: 3, 69: 4, 81: 6, 82: 4, 86: 3, 96: 4, 97: 3, 100: 7, 108: 3, 109: 4, 110: 4, 111: 2, 114: 3, 115: 4, 116: 3, 118: 6, 119: 5, 120: 3, 121: 4, 122: 4, 123: 3, 124: 4, 128: 4, 129: 4, 130: 5, 132: 4, 136: 2, 145: 4, 147: 4, 151: 4, 152: 4, 154: 3, 156: 2, 161: 3, 162: 3, 165: 3, 168: 4, 169: 3, 172: 3, 180: 4, 184: 5, 187: 5, 188: 4, 191: 3, 194: 4, 202: 5, 203: 6, 206: 2, 207: 3, 215: 2, 217: 3, 218: 8, 220: 2, 221: 2, 222: 5, 224: 3, 227: 5, 229: 3, 234: 5, 235: 2, 241: 2, 242: 2, 243: 4, 244: 4, 245: 4, 248: 4, 250: 4, 258: 11, 262: 4, 263: 5, 264: 3, 267: 4, 270: 3, 272: 3, 273: 5, 287: 3, 289: 3, 291: 5, 299: 5, 300: 3, 304: 3, 309: 3, 314: 2, 315: 3, 320: 4, 323: 4, 327: 4, 328: 3, 329: 2, 330: 10, 334: 2, 335: 3, 341: 5, 342: 6, 347: 5, 348: 5, 350: 7, 351: 5, 352: 3, 353: 3, 354: 2, 358: 4, 365: 3, 366: 2, 371: 7, 372: 5, 376: 2, 384: 5, 385: 4, 387: 3, 392: 3, 393: 4, 396: 6, 397: 7, 398: 6, 402: 3} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 79 "When a PE receives a packet from a CE, on a given AC with DetNet service, it MUST first check via Stream Identification whether the packet belongs to a configured TSN Stream (i.e., App-flow from DetNet perspective). If no Stream ID is matched and no other (VPN) service is configured for the AC then packet MUST be dropped. If there is a matching TSN Stream then the Stream-ID specific TSN functions MUST be executed (e.g., ingress policing, header field manipulation in case of active Stream Identification, FRER, etc.). Source MAC lookup MAY also be used for local MAC address learning." Adding conformance language and packet processing details . 3bfedfa5d8087d355944e1061153643e51701145 3bfedfa5d8087d355944e1061153643e51701145 draft-ietf-detnet-tsn-vpn-over-mpls 70b648698de3f7f597cd96fefbc05013dfff52cdd170ffc74e42db88544d92a9 ['7bc4af5f9333e0bb56e64cce4c0bf2278be3cb09764a3426a4b712a4ea5584ce', '8150f930a0d0b4ecb9a9a0e68adda4846f4092ea2a55c7de339962c1bb9d5ed8', 'af1a4b0a05ca0995e7b4536c2884d3ecda01171388cd05f46f1ac501cdda7ec0', '70b648698de3f7f597cd96fefbc05013dfff52cdd170ffc74e42db88544d92a9'] B "when a pe receives a packet from a ce, on a given ac with detnet service, it must first check via stream identification whether the packet belongs to a configured tsn stream (i.e., app-flow from detnet perspective). if no stream id is matched and no other (vpn) service is configured for the ac then packet must be dropped. if there is a matching tsn stream then the stream-id specific tsn functions must be executed (e.g., ingress policing, header field manipulation in case of active stream identification, frer, etc.). source mac lookup may also be used for local mac address learning." {124: 1, 98: 1, 130: 1, 6: 3, 79: 3, 90: 4, 51: 4, 62: 6, 85: 6, 68: 5, 35: 4, 110: 4, 91: 6, 114: 4, 97: 4, 31: 4, 13: 4, 67: 4, 38: 5, 26: 4, 54: 3, 127: 4, 8: 3, 96: 4, 64: 3, 30: 5, 61: 6, 55: 4, 27: 5, 15: 4, 52: 3, 129: 4, 115: 4, 84: 4, 76: 7, 87: 4, 131: 2, 102: 4, 113: 6, 99: 3, 36: 4, 24: 3, 53: 2, 72: 5} {109: 1, 110: 1, 206: 1, 262: 1, 1: 10, 4: 3, 9: 6, 10: 4, 15: 4, 24: 3, 25: 6, 26: 6, 27: 4, 39: 6, 43: 4, 49: 7, 50: 6, 58: 6, 59: 3, 64: 4, 69: 5, 81: 7, 82: 5, 86: 4, 96: 5, 97: 4, 100: 8, 108: 4, 111: 3, 114: 4, 115: 5, 116: 4, 118: 7, 119: 6, 120: 4, 121: 5, 122: 5, 123: 4, 124: 5, 128: 5, 129: 5, 130: 6, 132: 5, 136: 3, 145: 5, 147: 5, 151: 5, 152: 5, 154: 4, 156: 3, 161: 4, 162: 4, 165: 4, 168: 3, 169: 4, 172: 4, 180: 5, 184: 6, 187: 6, 188: 5, 194: 5, 202: 6, 203: 7, 207: 2, 215: 3, 217: 4, 218: 9, 220: 3, 221: 3, 222: 6, 224: 4, 227: 6, 229: 4, 234: 4, 235: 3, 241: 3, 242: 3, 243: 5, 244: 5, 245: 5, 248: 5, 250: 5, 258: 12, 263: 2, 264: 4, 267: 5, 270: 4, 272: 4, 273: 6, 287: 4, 289: 4, 291: 6, 299: 6, 300: 4, 304: 4, 309: 4, 314: 3, 315: 4, 320: 5, 323: 5, 327: 5, 328: 4, 329: 3, 330: 11, 334: 3, 335: 4, 341: 6, 342: 7, 347: 6, 348: 6, 350: 8, 351: 6, 352: 4, 353: 4, 354: 3, 358: 5, 365: 4, 366: 3, 369: 2, 371: 8, 372: 6, 376: 3, 384: 6, 385: 5, 386: 4, 387: 4, 392: 4, 393: 5, 396: 7, 397: 8, 398: 7, 402: 4} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 79 "If the PE decides to forward the packet, the packet MUST be forwarded according to the TSN Stream specific configuration to connected CE(s) (in case of local bridging) and/or to the DetNet Service Proxy (in case of forwarding to remote CE(s) required). If there are no TSN Stream specific forwarding configurations the PE MUST flood the packet to other locally attached CE(s) and to the DetNet Service Proxy. If the administrative policy on the PE does not allow flooding the PE MUST drop the packet." Adding conformance language and packet processing details . 3bfedfa5d8087d355944e1061153643e51701145 3bfedfa5d8087d355944e1061153643e51701145 draft-ietf-detnet-tsn-vpn-over-mpls 8150f930a0d0b4ecb9a9a0e68adda4846f4092ea2a55c7de339962c1bb9d5ed8 ['7bc4af5f9333e0bb56e64cce4c0bf2278be3cb09764a3426a4b712a4ea5584ce', '8150f930a0d0b4ecb9a9a0e68adda4846f4092ea2a55c7de339962c1bb9d5ed8', 'af1a4b0a05ca0995e7b4536c2884d3ecda01171388cd05f46f1ac501cdda7ec0', '70b648698de3f7f597cd96fefbc05013dfff52cdd170ffc74e42db88544d92a9'] B "if the pe decides to forward the packet, the packet must be forwarded according to the tsn stream specific configuration to connected ce(s) (in case of local bridging) and/or to the detnet service proxy (in case of forwarding to remote ce(s) required). if there are no tsn stream specific forwarding configurations the pe must flood the packet to other locally attached ce(s) and to the detnet service proxy. if the administrative policy on the pe does not allow flooding the pe must drop the packet." {124: 1, 98: 1, 130: 1, 6: 3, 79: 3, 90: 4, 51: 4, 62: 6, 85: 6, 68: 5, 35: 4, 110: 4, 91: 6, 114: 4, 97: 4, 31: 4, 13: 4, 67: 4, 38: 5, 26: 4, 54: 3, 127: 4, 8: 3, 96: 4, 64: 3, 30: 5, 61: 6, 55: 4, 27: 5, 15: 4, 52: 3, 129: 4, 115: 4, 84: 4, 76: 7, 87: 4, 131: 2, 102: 4, 113: 6, 99: 3, 36: 4, 24: 3, 53: 2, 72: 5} {109: 1, 110: 1, 206: 1, 262: 1, 1: 10, 4: 3, 9: 6, 10: 4, 15: 4, 24: 3, 25: 6, 26: 6, 27: 4, 39: 6, 43: 4, 49: 7, 50: 6, 58: 6, 59: 3, 64: 4, 69: 5, 81: 7, 82: 5, 86: 4, 96: 5, 97: 4, 100: 8, 108: 4, 111: 3, 114: 4, 115: 5, 116: 4, 118: 7, 119: 6, 120: 4, 121: 5, 122: 5, 123: 4, 124: 5, 128: 5, 129: 5, 130: 6, 132: 5, 136: 3, 145: 5, 147: 5, 151: 5, 152: 5, 154: 4, 156: 3, 161: 4, 162: 4, 165: 4, 168: 3, 169: 4, 172: 4, 180: 5, 184: 6, 187: 6, 188: 5, 194: 5, 202: 6, 203: 7, 207: 2, 215: 3, 217: 4, 218: 9, 220: 3, 221: 3, 222: 6, 224: 4, 227: 6, 229: 4, 234: 4, 235: 3, 241: 3, 242: 3, 243: 5, 244: 5, 245: 5, 248: 5, 250: 5, 258: 12, 263: 2, 264: 4, 267: 5, 270: 4, 272: 4, 273: 6, 287: 4, 289: 4, 291: 6, 299: 6, 300: 4, 304: 4, 309: 4, 314: 3, 315: 4, 320: 5, 323: 5, 327: 5, 328: 4, 329: 3, 330: 11, 334: 3, 335: 4, 341: 6, 342: 7, 347: 6, 348: 6, 350: 8, 351: 6, 352: 4, 353: 4, 354: 3, 358: 5, 365: 4, 366: 3, 369: 2, 371: 8, 372: 6, 376: 3, 384: 6, 385: 5, 386: 4, 387: 4, 392: 4, 393: 5, 396: 7, 397: 8, 398: 7, 402: 4} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 79 "When a TSN entity of the PE receives a packet from the DetNet Service Proxy, it MUST first check via Stream Identification whether the packet belongs to a configured TSN Stream. If no Stream ID is matched then packet MUST be dropped. If there is a matching TSN Stream then the Stream ID specific TSN functions MUST be executed (e.g., header field manipulation in case of active Stream Identification, FRER, etc.). Source MAC lookup MAY also be used for local MAC address learning." Adding conformance language and packet processing details . 3bfedfa5d8087d355944e1061153643e51701145 3bfedfa5d8087d355944e1061153643e51701145 draft-ietf-detnet-tsn-vpn-over-mpls af1a4b0a05ca0995e7b4536c2884d3ecda01171388cd05f46f1ac501cdda7ec0 ['7bc4af5f9333e0bb56e64cce4c0bf2278be3cb09764a3426a4b712a4ea5584ce', '8150f930a0d0b4ecb9a9a0e68adda4846f4092ea2a55c7de339962c1bb9d5ed8', 'af1a4b0a05ca0995e7b4536c2884d3ecda01171388cd05f46f1ac501cdda7ec0', '70b648698de3f7f597cd96fefbc05013dfff52cdd170ffc74e42db88544d92a9'] B "when a tsn entity of the pe receives a packet from the detnet service proxy, it must first check via stream identification whether the packet belongs to a configured tsn stream. if no stream id is matched then packet must be dropped. if there is a matching tsn stream then the stream id specific tsn functions must be executed (e.g., header field manipulation in case of active stream identification, frer, etc.). source mac lookup may also be used for local mac address learning." {124: 1, 98: 1, 130: 1, 6: 3, 79: 3, 90: 4, 51: 4, 62: 6, 85: 6, 68: 5, 35: 4, 110: 4, 91: 6, 114: 4, 97: 4, 31: 4, 13: 4, 67: 4, 38: 5, 26: 4, 54: 3, 127: 4, 8: 3, 96: 4, 64: 3, 30: 5, 61: 6, 55: 4, 27: 5, 15: 4, 52: 3, 129: 4, 115: 4, 84: 4, 76: 7, 87: 4, 131: 2, 102: 4, 113: 6, 99: 3, 36: 4, 24: 3, 53: 2, 72: 5} {109: 1, 110: 1, 206: 1, 262: 1, 1: 10, 4: 3, 9: 6, 10: 4, 15: 4, 24: 3, 25: 6, 26: 6, 27: 4, 39: 6, 43: 4, 49: 7, 50: 6, 58: 6, 59: 3, 64: 4, 69: 5, 81: 7, 82: 5, 86: 4, 96: 5, 97: 4, 100: 8, 108: 4, 111: 3, 114: 4, 115: 5, 116: 4, 118: 7, 119: 6, 120: 4, 121: 5, 122: 5, 123: 4, 124: 5, 128: 5, 129: 5, 130: 6, 132: 5, 136: 3, 145: 5, 147: 5, 151: 5, 152: 5, 154: 4, 156: 3, 161: 4, 162: 4, 165: 4, 168: 3, 169: 4, 172: 4, 180: 5, 184: 6, 187: 6, 188: 5, 194: 5, 202: 6, 203: 7, 207: 2, 215: 3, 217: 4, 218: 9, 220: 3, 221: 3, 222: 6, 224: 4, 227: 6, 229: 4, 234: 4, 235: 3, 241: 3, 242: 3, 243: 5, 244: 5, 245: 5, 248: 5, 250: 5, 258: 12, 263: 2, 264: 4, 267: 5, 270: 4, 272: 4, 273: 6, 287: 4, 289: 4, 291: 6, 299: 6, 300: 4, 304: 4, 309: 4, 314: 3, 315: 4, 320: 5, 323: 5, 327: 5, 328: 4, 329: 3, 330: 11, 334: 3, 335: 4, 341: 6, 342: 7, 347: 6, 348: 6, 350: 8, 351: 6, 352: 4, 353: 4, 354: 3, 358: 5, 365: 4, 366: 3, 369: 2, 371: 8, 372: 6, 376: 3, 384: 6, 385: 5, 386: 4, 387: 4, 392: 4, 393: 5, 396: 7, 397: 8, 398: 7, 402: 4} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 79 "If the PE decides to forward the packet, the packet MUST be forwarded according to the TSN Stream specific configuration to connected CE(s). If there are no TSN Stream specific forwarding configurations the PE MUST flood the packet to locally attached CE(s). If the administrative policy on the PE does not allow flooding the PE MUST drop the packet." Adding conformance language and packet processing details . 3bfedfa5d8087d355944e1061153643e51701145 3bfedfa5d8087d355944e1061153643e51701145 draft-ietf-detnet-tsn-vpn-over-mpls 7bc4af5f9333e0bb56e64cce4c0bf2278be3cb09764a3426a4b712a4ea5584ce ['7bc4af5f9333e0bb56e64cce4c0bf2278be3cb09764a3426a4b712a4ea5584ce', '8150f930a0d0b4ecb9a9a0e68adda4846f4092ea2a55c7de339962c1bb9d5ed8', 'af1a4b0a05ca0995e7b4536c2884d3ecda01171388cd05f46f1ac501cdda7ec0', '70b648698de3f7f597cd96fefbc05013dfff52cdd170ffc74e42db88544d92a9'] B "if the pe decides to forward the packet, the packet must be forwarded according to the tsn stream specific configuration to connected ce(s). if there are no tsn stream specific forwarding configurations the pe must flood the packet to locally attached ce(s). if the administrative policy on the pe does not allow flooding the pe must drop the packet." {124: 1, 98: 1, 130: 1, 6: 3, 79: 3, 90: 4, 51: 4, 62: 6, 85: 6, 68: 5, 35: 4, 110: 4, 91: 6, 114: 4, 97: 4, 31: 4, 13: 4, 67: 4, 38: 5, 26: 4, 54: 3, 127: 4, 8: 3, 96: 4, 64: 3, 30: 5, 61: 6, 55: 4, 27: 5, 15: 4, 52: 3, 129: 4, 115: 4, 84: 4, 76: 7, 87: 4, 131: 2, 102: 4, 113: 6, 99: 3, 36: 4, 24: 3, 53: 2, 72: 5} {109: 1, 110: 1, 206: 1, 262: 1, 1: 10, 4: 3, 9: 6, 10: 4, 15: 4, 24: 3, 25: 6, 26: 6, 27: 4, 39: 6, 43: 4, 49: 7, 50: 6, 58: 6, 59: 3, 64: 4, 69: 5, 81: 7, 82: 5, 86: 4, 96: 5, 97: 4, 100: 8, 108: 4, 111: 3, 114: 4, 115: 5, 116: 4, 118: 7, 119: 6, 120: 4, 121: 5, 122: 5, 123: 4, 124: 5, 128: 5, 129: 5, 130: 6, 132: 5, 136: 3, 145: 5, 147: 5, 151: 5, 152: 5, 154: 4, 156: 3, 161: 4, 162: 4, 165: 4, 168: 3, 169: 4, 172: 4, 180: 5, 184: 6, 187: 6, 188: 5, 194: 5, 202: 6, 203: 7, 207: 2, 215: 3, 217: 4, 218: 9, 220: 3, 221: 3, 222: 6, 224: 4, 227: 6, 229: 4, 234: 4, 235: 3, 241: 3, 242: 3, 243: 5, 244: 5, 245: 5, 248: 5, 250: 5, 258: 12, 263: 2, 264: 4, 267: 5, 270: 4, 272: 4, 273: 6, 287: 4, 289: 4, 291: 6, 299: 6, 300: 4, 304: 4, 309: 4, 314: 3, 315: 4, 320: 5, 323: 5, 327: 5, 328: 4, 329: 3, 330: 11, 334: 3, 335: 4, 341: 6, 342: 7, 347: 6, 348: 6, 350: 8, 351: 6, 352: 4, 353: 4, 354: 3, 358: 5, 365: 4, 366: 3, 369: 2, 371: 8, 372: 6, 376: 3, 384: 6, 385: 5, 386: 4, 387: 4, 392: 4, 393: 5, 396: 7, 397: 8, 398: 7, 402: 4} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 79 "The Service Proxy function maps between App-flows and DetNet flows. The DetNet Edge Node TSN function MUST support the TSN Stream identification functions and the related managed objects as defined in IEEE8021CB and IEEEP8021CBdb to recognize the App-flow related packets. The Service Proxy presents TSN Streams as an App-flow to a DetNet Flow." Adding conformance language and packet processing details . 3bfedfa5d8087d355944e1061153643e51701145 3bfedfa5d8087d355944e1061153643e51701145 draft-ietf-detnet-tsn-vpn-over-mpls 0882426f04ffe7d1fb83d25c8b8c589112e7bfc884827f292935052160a05cb7 ['0e70d5d98f2d3d2892547acb98045bd63d3f9614ec18e61acc3c2c203ae73332', '0882426f04ffe7d1fb83d25c8b8c589112e7bfc884827f292935052160a05cb7', '5ef9d12318016ad9d04ff6d1118feee37aa24df754bdd187f5df0a95e7cfb825', '7c2dd5af0e20f2488424f4673ecba8c8df3b14ad9f7470bee4edae6561832276'] A "the service proxy function maps between app-flows and detnet flows. the detnet edge node tsn function must support the tsn stream identification functions and the related managed objects as defined in ieee8021cb and ieeep8021cbdb to recognize the app-flow related packets. the service proxy presents tsn streams as an app-flow to a detnet flow." {54: 1, 98: 1, 6: 3, 79: 3, 90: 4, 51: 4, 130: 3, 62: 6, 85: 6, 68: 5, 35: 4, 110: 4, 91: 6, 114: 4, 97: 4, 31: 4, 13: 4, 67: 4, 38: 5, 26: 4, 124: 4, 127: 4, 8: 3, 96: 4, 64: 3, 30: 5, 61: 6, 55: 4, 27: 5, 15: 4, 52: 3, 129: 4, 115: 4, 84: 4, 76: 7, 87: 4, 131: 6, 102: 4, 113: 6, 99: 3, 36: 4, 24: 3, 53: 2, 72: 5} {242: 1, 327: 1, 1: 10, 4: 3, 9: 6, 15: 4, 24: 3, 25: 6, 26: 6, 27: 4, 39: 6, 43: 4, 49: 7, 50: 6, 58: 6, 59: 3, 64: 4, 69: 5, 81: 7, 82: 5, 86: 4, 96: 5, 97: 4, 100: 8, 108: 4, 109: 5, 110: 5, 111: 3, 114: 4, 115: 5, 116: 4, 118: 7, 119: 6, 120: 4, 121: 5, 122: 5, 123: 4, 124: 5, 128: 5, 129: 5, 130: 6, 132: 5, 136: 3, 145: 5, 147: 5, 151: 5, 152: 5, 154: 4, 156: 3, 161: 4, 162: 4, 165: 4, 168: 5, 169: 4, 172: 4, 180: 5, 184: 6, 187: 6, 188: 5, 191: 4, 194: 5, 202: 6, 203: 7, 206: 3, 207: 4, 215: 3, 217: 4, 218: 9, 220: 3, 221: 3, 222: 6, 224: 4, 227: 6, 229: 4, 234: 6, 235: 3, 241: 3, 243: 5, 244: 5, 245: 5, 248: 5, 250: 5, 258: 12, 262: 5, 263: 6, 264: 4, 267: 5, 270: 4, 272: 4, 273: 6, 287: 4, 289: 4, 291: 6, 299: 6, 300: 4, 304: 4, 309: 4, 314: 3, 315: 4, 320: 5, 323: 5, 328: 4, 329: 3, 330: 11, 334: 3, 335: 4, 341: 6, 342: 7, 347: 6, 348: 6, 350: 8, 351: 6, 352: 4, 353: 4, 354: 3, 358: 5, 365: 4, 366: 3, 369: 2, 371: 8, 372: 6, 376: 3, 384: 6, 385: 5, 386: 4, 387: 4, 392: 4, 393: 5, 396: 7, 397: 8, 398: 7, 402: 4} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 79 "The Service Proxy function maps between App-flows and DetNet flows. The DetNet Edge Node TSN entity MUST support the TSN Stream identification functions and the related managed objects as defined in IEEE8021CB and IEEEP8021CBdb to recognize the App-flow related packets. The Service Proxy presents TSN Streams as an App-flow to a DetNet Flow." Adding conformance language and packet processing details . 3bfedfa5d8087d355944e1061153643e51701145 3bfedfa5d8087d355944e1061153643e51701145 draft-ietf-detnet-tsn-vpn-over-mpls 5ef9d12318016ad9d04ff6d1118feee37aa24df754bdd187f5df0a95e7cfb825 ['0e70d5d98f2d3d2892547acb98045bd63d3f9614ec18e61acc3c2c203ae73332', '0882426f04ffe7d1fb83d25c8b8c589112e7bfc884827f292935052160a05cb7', '5ef9d12318016ad9d04ff6d1118feee37aa24df754bdd187f5df0a95e7cfb825', '7c2dd5af0e20f2488424f4673ecba8c8df3b14ad9f7470bee4edae6561832276'] B "the service proxy function maps between app-flows and detnet flows. the detnet edge node tsn entity must support the tsn stream identification functions and the related managed objects as defined in ieee8021cb and ieeep8021cbdb to recognize the app-flow related packets. the service proxy presents tsn streams as an app-flow to a detnet flow." {54: 1, 98: 1, 6: 3, 79: 3, 90: 4, 51: 4, 130: 3, 62: 6, 85: 6, 68: 5, 35: 4, 110: 4, 91: 6, 114: 4, 97: 4, 31: 4, 13: 4, 67: 4, 38: 5, 26: 4, 124: 4, 127: 4, 8: 3, 96: 4, 64: 3, 30: 5, 61: 6, 55: 4, 27: 5, 15: 4, 52: 3, 129: 4, 115: 4, 84: 4, 76: 7, 87: 4, 131: 6, 102: 4, 113: 6, 99: 3, 36: 4, 24: 3, 53: 2, 72: 5} {242: 1, 327: 1, 1: 10, 4: 3, 9: 6, 15: 4, 24: 3, 25: 6, 26: 6, 27: 4, 39: 6, 43: 4, 49: 7, 50: 6, 58: 6, 59: 3, 64: 4, 69: 5, 81: 7, 82: 5, 86: 4, 96: 5, 97: 4, 100: 8, 108: 4, 109: 5, 110: 5, 111: 3, 114: 4, 115: 5, 116: 4, 118: 7, 119: 6, 120: 4, 121: 5, 122: 5, 123: 4, 124: 5, 128: 5, 129: 5, 130: 6, 132: 5, 136: 3, 145: 5, 147: 5, 151: 5, 152: 5, 154: 4, 156: 3, 161: 4, 162: 4, 165: 4, 168: 5, 169: 4, 172: 4, 180: 5, 184: 6, 187: 6, 188: 5, 191: 4, 194: 5, 202: 6, 203: 7, 206: 3, 207: 4, 215: 3, 217: 4, 218: 9, 220: 3, 221: 3, 222: 6, 224: 4, 227: 6, 229: 4, 234: 6, 235: 3, 241: 3, 243: 5, 244: 5, 245: 5, 248: 5, 250: 5, 258: 12, 262: 5, 263: 6, 264: 4, 267: 5, 270: 4, 272: 4, 273: 6, 287: 4, 289: 4, 291: 6, 299: 6, 300: 4, 304: 4, 309: 4, 314: 3, 315: 4, 320: 5, 323: 5, 328: 4, 329: 3, 330: 11, 334: 3, 335: 4, 341: 6, 342: 7, 347: 6, 348: 6, 350: 8, 351: 6, 352: 4, 353: 4, 354: 3, 358: 5, 365: 4, 366: 3, 369: 2, 371: 8, 372: 6, 376: 3, 384: 6, 385: 5, 386: 4, 387: 4, 392: 4, 393: 5, 396: 7, 397: 8, 398: 7, 402: 4} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 79 "When a DetNet Service Proxy receives a packet from the TSN Entity it MUST check whether such an App-flow is present in its mapping table. If present it associates the internal DetNet flow-ID to the packet and MUST forward it to the DetNet Service and Forwarding sub-layers. If no matching statement is present it MUST drop the packet." Adding conformance language and packet processing details . 3bfedfa5d8087d355944e1061153643e51701145 3bfedfa5d8087d355944e1061153643e51701145 draft-ietf-detnet-tsn-vpn-over-mpls 0e70d5d98f2d3d2892547acb98045bd63d3f9614ec18e61acc3c2c203ae73332 ['0e70d5d98f2d3d2892547acb98045bd63d3f9614ec18e61acc3c2c203ae73332', '0882426f04ffe7d1fb83d25c8b8c589112e7bfc884827f292935052160a05cb7', '5ef9d12318016ad9d04ff6d1118feee37aa24df754bdd187f5df0a95e7cfb825', '7c2dd5af0e20f2488424f4673ecba8c8df3b14ad9f7470bee4edae6561832276'] B "when a detnet service proxy receives a packet from the tsn entity it must check whether such an app-flow is present in its mapping table. if present it associates the internal detnet flow-id to the packet and must forward it to the detnet service and forwarding sub-layers. if no matching statement is present it must drop the packet." {54: 1, 98: 1, 6: 3, 79: 3, 90: 4, 51: 4, 130: 3, 62: 6, 85: 6, 68: 5, 35: 4, 110: 4, 91: 6, 114: 4, 97: 4, 31: 4, 13: 4, 67: 4, 38: 5, 26: 4, 124: 4, 127: 4, 8: 3, 96: 4, 64: 3, 30: 5, 61: 6, 55: 4, 27: 5, 15: 4, 52: 3, 129: 4, 115: 4, 84: 4, 76: 7, 87: 4, 131: 6, 102: 4, 113: 6, 99: 3, 36: 4, 24: 3, 53: 2, 72: 5} {242: 1, 327: 1, 1: 10, 4: 3, 9: 6, 15: 4, 24: 3, 25: 6, 26: 6, 27: 4, 39: 6, 43: 4, 49: 7, 50: 6, 58: 6, 59: 3, 64: 4, 69: 5, 81: 7, 82: 5, 86: 4, 96: 5, 97: 4, 100: 8, 108: 4, 109: 5, 110: 5, 111: 3, 114: 4, 115: 5, 116: 4, 118: 7, 119: 6, 120: 4, 121: 5, 122: 5, 123: 4, 124: 5, 128: 5, 129: 5, 130: 6, 132: 5, 136: 3, 145: 5, 147: 5, 151: 5, 152: 5, 154: 4, 156: 3, 161: 4, 162: 4, 165: 4, 168: 5, 169: 4, 172: 4, 180: 5, 184: 6, 187: 6, 188: 5, 191: 4, 194: 5, 202: 6, 203: 7, 206: 3, 207: 4, 215: 3, 217: 4, 218: 9, 220: 3, 221: 3, 222: 6, 224: 4, 227: 6, 229: 4, 234: 6, 235: 3, 241: 3, 243: 5, 244: 5, 245: 5, 248: 5, 250: 5, 258: 12, 262: 5, 263: 6, 264: 4, 267: 5, 270: 4, 272: 4, 273: 6, 287: 4, 289: 4, 291: 6, 299: 6, 300: 4, 304: 4, 309: 4, 314: 3, 315: 4, 320: 5, 323: 5, 328: 4, 329: 3, 330: 11, 334: 3, 335: 4, 341: 6, 342: 7, 347: 6, 348: 6, 350: 8, 351: 6, 352: 4, 353: 4, 354: 3, 358: 5, 365: 4, 366: 3, 369: 2, 371: 8, 372: 6, 376: 3, 384: 6, 385: 5, 386: 4, 387: 4, 392: 4, 393: 5, 396: 7, 397: 8, 398: 7, 402: 4} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 79 "When a DetNet Service Proxy receives a packet from the DetNet Service and Forwarding sub-layers it MUST be forwarded to the Edge Node TSN Entity." Adding conformance language and packet processing details . 3bfedfa5d8087d355944e1061153643e51701145 3bfedfa5d8087d355944e1061153643e51701145 draft-ietf-detnet-tsn-vpn-over-mpls 7c2dd5af0e20f2488424f4673ecba8c8df3b14ad9f7470bee4edae6561832276 ['0e70d5d98f2d3d2892547acb98045bd63d3f9614ec18e61acc3c2c203ae73332', '0882426f04ffe7d1fb83d25c8b8c589112e7bfc884827f292935052160a05cb7', '5ef9d12318016ad9d04ff6d1118feee37aa24df754bdd187f5df0a95e7cfb825', '7c2dd5af0e20f2488424f4673ecba8c8df3b14ad9f7470bee4edae6561832276'] B "when a detnet service proxy receives a packet from the detnet service and forwarding sub-layers it must be forwarded to the edge node tsn entity." {54: 1, 98: 1, 6: 3, 79: 3, 90: 4, 51: 4, 130: 3, 62: 6, 85: 6, 68: 5, 35: 4, 110: 4, 91: 6, 114: 4, 97: 4, 31: 4, 13: 4, 67: 4, 38: 5, 26: 4, 124: 4, 127: 4, 8: 3, 96: 4, 64: 3, 30: 5, 61: 6, 55: 4, 27: 5, 15: 4, 52: 3, 129: 4, 115: 4, 84: 4, 76: 7, 87: 4, 131: 6, 102: 4, 113: 6, 99: 3, 36: 4, 24: 3, 53: 2, 72: 5} {242: 1, 327: 1, 1: 10, 4: 3, 9: 6, 15: 4, 24: 3, 25: 6, 26: 6, 27: 4, 39: 6, 43: 4, 49: 7, 50: 6, 58: 6, 59: 3, 64: 4, 69: 5, 81: 7, 82: 5, 86: 4, 96: 5, 97: 4, 100: 8, 108: 4, 109: 5, 110: 5, 111: 3, 114: 4, 115: 5, 116: 4, 118: 7, 119: 6, 120: 4, 121: 5, 122: 5, 123: 4, 124: 5, 128: 5, 129: 5, 130: 6, 132: 5, 136: 3, 145: 5, 147: 5, 151: 5, 152: 5, 154: 4, 156: 3, 161: 4, 162: 4, 165: 4, 168: 5, 169: 4, 172: 4, 180: 5, 184: 6, 187: 6, 188: 5, 191: 4, 194: 5, 202: 6, 203: 7, 206: 3, 207: 4, 215: 3, 217: 4, 218: 9, 220: 3, 221: 3, 222: 6, 224: 4, 227: 6, 229: 4, 234: 6, 235: 3, 241: 3, 243: 5, 244: 5, 245: 5, 248: 5, 250: 5, 258: 12, 262: 5, 263: 6, 264: 4, 267: 5, 270: 4, 272: 4, 273: 6, 287: 4, 289: 4, 291: 6, 299: 6, 300: 4, 304: 4, 309: 4, 314: 3, 315: 4, 320: 5, 323: 5, 328: 4, 329: 3, 330: 11, 334: 3, 335: 4, 341: 6, 342: 7, 347: 6, 348: 6, 350: 8, 351: 6, 352: 4, 353: 4, 354: 3, 358: 5, 365: 4, 366: 3, 369: 2, 371: 8, 372: 6, 376: 3, 384: 6, 385: 5, 386: 4, 387: 4, 392: 4, 393: 5, 396: 7, 397: 8, 398: 7, 402: 4} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 79 "The LSP used to forward the DetNet packet may be of any type (MPLS- LDP, MPLS-TE, MPLS-TP RFC5921, or MPLS-SR I-D.ietf-spring-segment- routing-mpls). The LSP (F-Label) label and/or the S-Label may be used to indicate the queue processing as well as the forwarding parameters." Adding conformance language and packet processing details . 3bfedfa5d8087d355944e1061153643e51701145 3bfedfa5d8087d355944e1061153643e51701145 draft-ietf-detnet-tsn-vpn-over-mpls 056859e4aa430e2eb983e93f08bb85d9afe9aec44f0e73263cf072df70b7c475 ['056859e4aa430e2eb983e93f08bb85d9afe9aec44f0e73263cf072df70b7c475', 'a247c110d665dc3828e9dafffc0a3becf4d846e09a5a66994f80c4dbdda75ea1', 'c7286f8983508fdd7d94ae798cdc3950cbf65865e905c00a76838a34eb79cf2c', 'bb5d135a9e9a30c3058065510c25bd93854d5e9e3be536ad8fe71239a64ab26e', '0ba8ffab7802b7e5fc4bc754246a4ac4b1486e1b346a8bee7988798eb7defc18', '5cb88eb295a658b2b9c8237a55cdfb96cf685c0066b6eccd7198eab4c5fdfcc4'] A "the lsp used to forward the detnet packet may be of any type (mpls- ldp, mpls-te, mpls-tp rfc5921, or mpls-sr i-d.ietf-spring-segment- routing-mpls). the lsp (f-label) label and/or the s-label may be used to indicate the queue processing as well as the forwarding parameters." {53: 1, 127: 1, 130: 1, 6: 2, 90: 3, 79: 2, 51: 3, 62: 5, 85: 5, 68: 4, 35: 3, 110: 3, 91: 5, 114: 3, 97: 3, 31: 3, 13: 3, 67: 3, 38: 4, 26: 3, 124: 3, 98: 2, 54: 2, 8: 2, 96: 3, 64: 2, 30: 4, 61: 5, 55: 3, 27: 4, 15: 3, 52: 2, 129: 3, 115: 3, 84: 3, 76: 6, 87: 3, 131: 5, 102: 3, 113: 5, 99: 2, 36: 3, 24: 2, 72: 4} {369: 1, 114: 1, 108: 1, 1: 9, 9: 5, 10: 3, 15: 3, 24: 2, 25: 5, 26: 5, 27: 3, 39: 5, 43: 3, 49: 6, 50: 5, 58: 5, 59: 2, 64: 3, 69: 4, 81: 6, 82: 4, 86: 3, 96: 4, 97: 3, 100: 7, 109: 4, 110: 4, 111: 2, 115: 2, 116: 3, 118: 6, 119: 5, 120: 3, 121: 4, 122: 4, 123: 3, 124: 4, 128: 4, 129: 4, 130: 5, 132: 4, 136: 2, 145: 4, 147: 4, 151: 4, 152: 4, 154: 3, 156: 2, 161: 3, 162: 3, 165: 3, 168: 4, 169: 3, 172: 3, 180: 4, 184: 5, 187: 5, 188: 4, 191: 3, 194: 4, 202: 5, 203: 6, 206: 2, 207: 3, 215: 2, 217: 3, 218: 8, 220: 2, 221: 2, 222: 5, 224: 3, 227: 5, 229: 3, 234: 5, 235: 2, 241: 2, 242: 2, 243: 4, 244: 4, 245: 4, 248: 4, 250: 4, 258: 11, 262: 4, 263: 5, 264: 3, 267: 4, 270: 3, 272: 3, 273: 5, 287: 3, 289: 3, 291: 5, 299: 5, 300: 3, 304: 3, 309: 3, 314: 2, 315: 3, 320: 4, 323: 4, 327: 4, 328: 3, 329: 2, 330: 10, 334: 2, 335: 3, 341: 5, 342: 6, 347: 5, 348: 5, 350: 7, 351: 5, 352: 3, 353: 3, 354: 2, 358: 4, 365: 3, 366: 2, 371: 7, 372: 5, 376: 2, 384: 5, 385: 4, 386: 3, 387: 3, 392: 3, 393: 4, 396: 6, 397: 7, 398: 6, 402: 3} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 79 For further details see I-D.ietf-detnet-mpls. Adding conformance language and packet processing details . 3bfedfa5d8087d355944e1061153643e51701145 3bfedfa5d8087d355944e1061153643e51701145 draft-ietf-detnet-tsn-vpn-over-mpls c7286f8983508fdd7d94ae798cdc3950cbf65865e905c00a76838a34eb79cf2c ['056859e4aa430e2eb983e93f08bb85d9afe9aec44f0e73263cf072df70b7c475', 'a247c110d665dc3828e9dafffc0a3becf4d846e09a5a66994f80c4dbdda75ea1', 'c7286f8983508fdd7d94ae798cdc3950cbf65865e905c00a76838a34eb79cf2c', 'bb5d135a9e9a30c3058065510c25bd93854d5e9e3be536ad8fe71239a64ab26e', '0ba8ffab7802b7e5fc4bc754246a4ac4b1486e1b346a8bee7988798eb7defc18', '5cb88eb295a658b2b9c8237a55cdfb96cf685c0066b6eccd7198eab4c5fdfcc4'] A for further details see i-d.ietf-detnet-mpls. {53: 1, 127: 1, 130: 1, 6: 2, 90: 3, 79: 2, 51: 3, 62: 5, 85: 5, 68: 4, 35: 3, 110: 3, 91: 5, 114: 3, 97: 3, 31: 3, 13: 3, 67: 3, 38: 4, 26: 3, 124: 3, 98: 2, 54: 2, 8: 2, 96: 3, 64: 2, 30: 4, 61: 5, 55: 3, 27: 4, 15: 3, 52: 2, 129: 3, 115: 3, 84: 3, 76: 6, 87: 3, 131: 5, 102: 3, 113: 5, 99: 2, 36: 3, 24: 2, 72: 4} {369: 1, 114: 1, 108: 1, 1: 9, 9: 5, 10: 3, 15: 3, 24: 2, 25: 5, 26: 5, 27: 3, 39: 5, 43: 3, 49: 6, 50: 5, 58: 5, 59: 2, 64: 3, 69: 4, 81: 6, 82: 4, 86: 3, 96: 4, 97: 3, 100: 7, 109: 4, 110: 4, 111: 2, 115: 2, 116: 3, 118: 6, 119: 5, 120: 3, 121: 4, 122: 4, 123: 3, 124: 4, 128: 4, 129: 4, 130: 5, 132: 4, 136: 2, 145: 4, 147: 4, 151: 4, 152: 4, 154: 3, 156: 2, 161: 3, 162: 3, 165: 3, 168: 4, 169: 3, 172: 3, 180: 4, 184: 5, 187: 5, 188: 4, 191: 3, 194: 4, 202: 5, 203: 6, 206: 2, 207: 3, 215: 2, 217: 3, 218: 8, 220: 2, 221: 2, 222: 5, 224: 3, 227: 5, 229: 3, 234: 5, 235: 2, 241: 2, 242: 2, 243: 4, 244: 4, 245: 4, 248: 4, 250: 4, 258: 11, 262: 4, 263: 5, 264: 3, 267: 4, 270: 3, 272: 3, 273: 5, 287: 3, 289: 3, 291: 5, 299: 5, 300: 3, 304: 3, 309: 3, 314: 2, 315: 3, 320: 4, 323: 4, 327: 4, 328: 3, 329: 2, 330: 10, 334: 2, 335: 3, 341: 5, 342: 6, 347: 5, 348: 5, 350: 7, 351: 5, 352: 3, 353: 3, 354: 2, 358: 4, 365: 3, 366: 2, 371: 7, 372: 5, 376: 2, 384: 5, 385: 4, 386: 3, 387: 3, 392: 3, 393: 4, 396: 6, 397: 7, 398: 6, 402: 3} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 79 "The LSP used to forward the DetNet packet may be of any type (MPLS- LDP, MPLS-TE, MPLS-TP RFC5921, or MPLS-SR RFC8660). The LSP (F-Label) label and/or the S-Label may be used to indicate the queue processing as well as the forwarding parameters." Adding conformance language and packet processing details . 3bfedfa5d8087d355944e1061153643e51701145 3bfedfa5d8087d355944e1061153643e51701145 draft-ietf-detnet-tsn-vpn-over-mpls 0ba8ffab7802b7e5fc4bc754246a4ac4b1486e1b346a8bee7988798eb7defc18 ['056859e4aa430e2eb983e93f08bb85d9afe9aec44f0e73263cf072df70b7c475', 'a247c110d665dc3828e9dafffc0a3becf4d846e09a5a66994f80c4dbdda75ea1', 'c7286f8983508fdd7d94ae798cdc3950cbf65865e905c00a76838a34eb79cf2c', 'bb5d135a9e9a30c3058065510c25bd93854d5e9e3be536ad8fe71239a64ab26e', '0ba8ffab7802b7e5fc4bc754246a4ac4b1486e1b346a8bee7988798eb7defc18', '5cb88eb295a658b2b9c8237a55cdfb96cf685c0066b6eccd7198eab4c5fdfcc4'] B "the lsp used to forward the detnet packet may be of any type (mpls- ldp, mpls-te, mpls-tp rfc5921, or mpls-sr rfc8660). the lsp (f-label) label and/or the s-label may be used to indicate the queue processing as well as the forwarding parameters." {53: 1, 127: 1, 130: 1, 6: 2, 90: 3, 79: 2, 51: 3, 62: 5, 85: 5, 68: 4, 35: 3, 110: 3, 91: 5, 114: 3, 97: 3, 31: 3, 13: 3, 67: 3, 38: 4, 26: 3, 124: 3, 98: 2, 54: 2, 8: 2, 96: 3, 64: 2, 30: 4, 61: 5, 55: 3, 27: 4, 15: 3, 52: 2, 129: 3, 115: 3, 84: 3, 76: 6, 87: 3, 131: 5, 102: 3, 113: 5, 99: 2, 36: 3, 24: 2, 72: 4} {369: 1, 114: 1, 108: 1, 1: 9, 9: 5, 10: 3, 15: 3, 24: 2, 25: 5, 26: 5, 27: 3, 39: 5, 43: 3, 49: 6, 50: 5, 58: 5, 59: 2, 64: 3, 69: 4, 81: 6, 82: 4, 86: 3, 96: 4, 97: 3, 100: 7, 109: 4, 110: 4, 111: 2, 115: 2, 116: 3, 118: 6, 119: 5, 120: 3, 121: 4, 122: 4, 123: 3, 124: 4, 128: 4, 129: 4, 130: 5, 132: 4, 136: 2, 145: 4, 147: 4, 151: 4, 152: 4, 154: 3, 156: 2, 161: 3, 162: 3, 165: 3, 168: 4, 169: 3, 172: 3, 180: 4, 184: 5, 187: 5, 188: 4, 191: 3, 194: 4, 202: 5, 203: 6, 206: 2, 207: 3, 215: 2, 217: 3, 218: 8, 220: 2, 221: 2, 222: 5, 224: 3, 227: 5, 229: 3, 234: 5, 235: 2, 241: 2, 242: 2, 243: 4, 244: 4, 245: 4, 248: 4, 250: 4, 258: 11, 262: 4, 263: 5, 264: 3, 267: 4, 270: 3, 272: 3, 273: 5, 287: 3, 289: 3, 291: 5, 299: 5, 300: 3, 304: 3, 309: 3, 314: 2, 315: 3, 320: 4, 323: 4, 327: 4, 328: 3, 329: 2, 330: 10, 334: 2, 335: 3, 341: 5, 342: 6, 347: 5, 348: 5, 350: 7, 351: 5, 352: 3, 353: 3, 354: 2, 358: 4, 365: 3, 366: 2, 371: 7, 372: 5, 376: 2, 384: 5, 385: 4, 386: 3, 387: 3, 392: 3, 393: 4, 396: 6, 397: 7, 398: 6, 402: 3} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 79 "When a PE receives a packet from the Service Proxy function it MUST add to the packet the DetNet flow-ID specific S-label and create a d-CW. The PE MUST forward the packet according to the configured DetNet Service and Forwarding sub-layer rules to other PE nodes." Adding conformance language and packet processing details . 3bfedfa5d8087d355944e1061153643e51701145 3bfedfa5d8087d355944e1061153643e51701145 draft-ietf-detnet-tsn-vpn-over-mpls 5cb88eb295a658b2b9c8237a55cdfb96cf685c0066b6eccd7198eab4c5fdfcc4 ['056859e4aa430e2eb983e93f08bb85d9afe9aec44f0e73263cf072df70b7c475', 'a247c110d665dc3828e9dafffc0a3becf4d846e09a5a66994f80c4dbdda75ea1', 'c7286f8983508fdd7d94ae798cdc3950cbf65865e905c00a76838a34eb79cf2c', 'bb5d135a9e9a30c3058065510c25bd93854d5e9e3be536ad8fe71239a64ab26e', '0ba8ffab7802b7e5fc4bc754246a4ac4b1486e1b346a8bee7988798eb7defc18', '5cb88eb295a658b2b9c8237a55cdfb96cf685c0066b6eccd7198eab4c5fdfcc4'] B "when a pe receives a packet from the service proxy function it must add to the packet the detnet flow-id specific s-label and create a d-cw. the pe must forward the packet according to the configured detnet service and forwarding sub-layer rules to other pe nodes." {53: 1, 127: 1, 130: 1, 6: 2, 90: 3, 79: 2, 51: 3, 62: 5, 85: 5, 68: 4, 35: 3, 110: 3, 91: 5, 114: 3, 97: 3, 31: 3, 13: 3, 67: 3, 38: 4, 26: 3, 124: 3, 98: 2, 54: 2, 8: 2, 96: 3, 64: 2, 30: 4, 61: 5, 55: 3, 27: 4, 15: 3, 52: 2, 129: 3, 115: 3, 84: 3, 76: 6, 87: 3, 131: 5, 102: 3, 113: 5, 99: 2, 36: 3, 24: 2, 72: 4} {369: 1, 114: 1, 108: 1, 1: 9, 9: 5, 10: 3, 15: 3, 24: 2, 25: 5, 26: 5, 27: 3, 39: 5, 43: 3, 49: 6, 50: 5, 58: 5, 59: 2, 64: 3, 69: 4, 81: 6, 82: 4, 86: 3, 96: 4, 97: 3, 100: 7, 109: 4, 110: 4, 111: 2, 115: 2, 116: 3, 118: 6, 119: 5, 120: 3, 121: 4, 122: 4, 123: 3, 124: 4, 128: 4, 129: 4, 130: 5, 132: 4, 136: 2, 145: 4, 147: 4, 151: 4, 152: 4, 154: 3, 156: 2, 161: 3, 162: 3, 165: 3, 168: 4, 169: 3, 172: 3, 180: 4, 184: 5, 187: 5, 188: 4, 191: 3, 194: 4, 202: 5, 203: 6, 206: 2, 207: 3, 215: 2, 217: 3, 218: 8, 220: 2, 221: 2, 222: 5, 224: 3, 227: 5, 229: 3, 234: 5, 235: 2, 241: 2, 242: 2, 243: 4, 244: 4, 245: 4, 248: 4, 250: 4, 258: 11, 262: 4, 263: 5, 264: 3, 267: 4, 270: 3, 272: 3, 273: 5, 287: 3, 289: 3, 291: 5, 299: 5, 300: 3, 304: 3, 309: 3, 314: 2, 315: 3, 320: 4, 323: 4, 327: 4, 328: 3, 329: 2, 330: 10, 334: 2, 335: 3, 341: 5, 342: 6, 347: 5, 348: 5, 350: 7, 351: 5, 352: 3, 353: 3, 354: 2, 358: 4, 365: 3, 366: 2, 371: 7, 372: 5, 376: 2, 384: 5, 385: 4, 386: 3, 387: 3, 392: 3, 393: 4, 396: 6, 397: 7, 398: 6, 402: 3} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 79 "When a PE receives an MPLS packet from a remote PE, then, after processing the MPLS label stack, if the top MPLS label ends up being a DetNet S-label that was advertised by this node, then the PE MUST forward the packet according to the configured DetNet Service and Forwarding sub-layer rules to other PE nodes or via the Detnet Service Proxy function towards locally connected CE(s)." Adding conformance language and packet processing details . 3bfedfa5d8087d355944e1061153643e51701145 3bfedfa5d8087d355944e1061153643e51701145 draft-ietf-detnet-tsn-vpn-over-mpls a247c110d665dc3828e9dafffc0a3becf4d846e09a5a66994f80c4dbdda75ea1 ['056859e4aa430e2eb983e93f08bb85d9afe9aec44f0e73263cf072df70b7c475', 'a247c110d665dc3828e9dafffc0a3becf4d846e09a5a66994f80c4dbdda75ea1', 'c7286f8983508fdd7d94ae798cdc3950cbf65865e905c00a76838a34eb79cf2c', 'bb5d135a9e9a30c3058065510c25bd93854d5e9e3be536ad8fe71239a64ab26e', '0ba8ffab7802b7e5fc4bc754246a4ac4b1486e1b346a8bee7988798eb7defc18', '5cb88eb295a658b2b9c8237a55cdfb96cf685c0066b6eccd7198eab4c5fdfcc4'] B "when a pe receives an mpls packet from a remote pe, then, after processing the mpls label stack, if the top mpls label ends up being a detnet s-label that was advertised by this node, then the pe must forward the packet according to the configured detnet service and forwarding sub-layer rules to other pe nodes or via the detnet service proxy function towards locally connected ce(s)." {53: 1, 127: 1, 130: 1, 6: 2, 90: 3, 79: 2, 51: 3, 62: 5, 85: 5, 68: 4, 35: 3, 110: 3, 91: 5, 114: 3, 97: 3, 31: 3, 13: 3, 67: 3, 38: 4, 26: 3, 124: 3, 98: 2, 54: 2, 8: 2, 96: 3, 64: 2, 30: 4, 61: 5, 55: 3, 27: 4, 15: 3, 52: 2, 129: 3, 115: 3, 84: 3, 76: 6, 87: 3, 131: 5, 102: 3, 113: 5, 99: 2, 36: 3, 24: 2, 72: 4} {369: 1, 114: 1, 108: 1, 1: 9, 9: 5, 10: 3, 15: 3, 24: 2, 25: 5, 26: 5, 27: 3, 39: 5, 43: 3, 49: 6, 50: 5, 58: 5, 59: 2, 64: 3, 69: 4, 81: 6, 82: 4, 86: 3, 96: 4, 97: 3, 100: 7, 109: 4, 110: 4, 111: 2, 115: 2, 116: 3, 118: 6, 119: 5, 120: 3, 121: 4, 122: 4, 123: 3, 124: 4, 128: 4, 129: 4, 130: 5, 132: 4, 136: 2, 145: 4, 147: 4, 151: 4, 152: 4, 154: 3, 156: 2, 161: 3, 162: 3, 165: 3, 168: 4, 169: 3, 172: 3, 180: 4, 184: 5, 187: 5, 188: 4, 191: 3, 194: 4, 202: 5, 203: 6, 206: 2, 207: 3, 215: 2, 217: 3, 218: 8, 220: 2, 221: 2, 222: 5, 224: 3, 227: 5, 229: 3, 234: 5, 235: 2, 241: 2, 242: 2, 243: 4, 244: 4, 245: 4, 248: 4, 250: 4, 258: 11, 262: 4, 263: 5, 264: 3, 267: 4, 270: 3, 272: 3, 273: 5, 287: 3, 289: 3, 291: 5, 299: 5, 300: 3, 304: 3, 309: 3, 314: 2, 315: 3, 320: 4, 323: 4, 327: 4, 328: 3, 329: 2, 330: 10, 334: 2, 335: 3, 341: 5, 342: 6, 347: 5, 348: 5, 350: 7, 351: 5, 352: 3, 353: 3, 354: 2, 358: 4, 365: 3, 366: 2, 371: 7, 372: 5, 376: 2, 384: 5, 385: 4, 386: 3, 387: 3, 392: 3, 393: 4, 396: 6, 397: 7, 398: 6, 402: 3} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 79 "For further details on DetNet Service and Forwarding sub-layers see I-D.ietf-detnet-mpls." Adding conformance language and packet processing details . 3bfedfa5d8087d355944e1061153643e51701145 3bfedfa5d8087d355944e1061153643e51701145 draft-ietf-detnet-tsn-vpn-over-mpls bb5d135a9e9a30c3058065510c25bd93854d5e9e3be536ad8fe71239a64ab26e ['056859e4aa430e2eb983e93f08bb85d9afe9aec44f0e73263cf072df70b7c475', 'a247c110d665dc3828e9dafffc0a3becf4d846e09a5a66994f80c4dbdda75ea1', 'c7286f8983508fdd7d94ae798cdc3950cbf65865e905c00a76838a34eb79cf2c', 'bb5d135a9e9a30c3058065510c25bd93854d5e9e3be536ad8fe71239a64ab26e', '0ba8ffab7802b7e5fc4bc754246a4ac4b1486e1b346a8bee7988798eb7defc18', '5cb88eb295a658b2b9c8237a55cdfb96cf685c0066b6eccd7198eab4c5fdfcc4'] B "for further details on detnet service and forwarding sub-layers see i-d.ietf-detnet-mpls." {53: 1, 127: 1, 130: 1, 6: 2, 90: 3, 79: 2, 51: 3, 62: 5, 85: 5, 68: 4, 35: 3, 110: 3, 91: 5, 114: 3, 97: 3, 31: 3, 13: 3, 67: 3, 38: 4, 26: 3, 124: 3, 98: 2, 54: 2, 8: 2, 96: 3, 64: 2, 30: 4, 61: 5, 55: 3, 27: 4, 15: 3, 52: 2, 129: 3, 115: 3, 84: 3, 76: 6, 87: 3, 131: 5, 102: 3, 113: 5, 99: 2, 36: 3, 24: 2, 72: 4} {369: 1, 114: 1, 108: 1, 1: 9, 9: 5, 10: 3, 15: 3, 24: 2, 25: 5, 26: 5, 27: 3, 39: 5, 43: 3, 49: 6, 50: 5, 58: 5, 59: 2, 64: 3, 69: 4, 81: 6, 82: 4, 86: 3, 96: 4, 97: 3, 100: 7, 109: 4, 110: 4, 111: 2, 115: 2, 116: 3, 118: 6, 119: 5, 120: 3, 121: 4, 122: 4, 123: 3, 124: 4, 128: 4, 129: 4, 130: 5, 132: 4, 136: 2, 145: 4, 147: 4, 151: 4, 152: 4, 154: 3, 156: 2, 161: 3, 162: 3, 165: 3, 168: 4, 169: 3, 172: 3, 180: 4, 184: 5, 187: 5, 188: 4, 191: 3, 194: 4, 202: 5, 203: 6, 206: 2, 207: 3, 215: 2, 217: 3, 218: 8, 220: 2, 221: 2, 222: 5, 224: 3, 227: 5, 229: 3, 234: 5, 235: 2, 241: 2, 242: 2, 243: 4, 244: 4, 245: 4, 248: 4, 250: 4, 258: 11, 262: 4, 263: 5, 264: 3, 267: 4, 270: 3, 272: 3, 273: 5, 287: 3, 289: 3, 291: 5, 299: 5, 300: 3, 304: 3, 309: 3, 314: 2, 315: 3, 320: 4, 323: 4, 327: 4, 328: 3, 329: 2, 330: 10, 334: 2, 335: 3, 341: 5, 342: 6, 347: 5, 348: 5, 350: 7, 351: 5, 352: 3, 353: 3, 354: 2, 358: 4, 365: 3, 366: 2, 371: 7, 372: 5, 376: 2, 384: 5, 385: 4, 386: 3, 387: 3, 392: 3, 393: 4, 396: 6, 397: 7, 398: 6, 402: 3} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 76 "In the preceding example, reordering of packets is dependent on the number of out-of-order packets that can be buffered and the delay difference of arriving packets. DetNet uses configuration of the number of maximum number out-of-order packets and the maximum delay that out-of-order packets can be held before being delivered. If the differential delay between paths is large enough or the arrival rate of packets large enough packets may be dropped instead of being reordered. Likewise elimination uses the sequence number to eliminate duplicate packets and large differential delays combined with high numbers of packets may exceed the ability of this elimination function to eliminate all duplicate packets. Path selection for DetNet services needs to take these factors into account." Updates from call Feb 3rd . 2c2a1ae3603e50273fbac93129e7d15207fb3fb7 2c2a1ae3603e50273fbac93129e7d15207fb3fb7 draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework da2f851aa0b73253e5a1cb02855811e64b038e227fea4a7825678075e1eb266f ['803a9ecf57717ba8b7c268aac7167a4178bb6fe026c71c84f3303202affe1492', 'da2f851aa0b73253e5a1cb02855811e64b038e227fea4a7825678075e1eb266f'] A "in the preceding example, reordering of packets is dependent on the number of out-of-order packets that can be buffered and the delay difference of arriving packets. detnet uses configuration of the number of maximum number out-of-order packets and the maximum delay that out-of-order packets can be held before being delivered. if the differential delay between paths is large enough or the arrival rate of packets large enough packets may be dropped instead of being reordered. likewise elimination uses the sequence number to eliminate duplicate packets and large differential delays combined with high numbers of packets may exceed the ability of this elimination function to eliminate all duplicate packets. path selection for detnet services needs to take these factors into account." {84: 1, 68: 1, 6: 3, 79: 6, 90: 5, 51: 7, 130: 6, 62: 6, 85: 6, 35: 7, 110: 7, 91: 9, 114: 7, 97: 7, 31: 3, 13: 7, 67: 5, 38: 8, 26: 6, 124: 5, 98: 6, 54: 6, 127: 7, 8: 4, 96: 7, 64: 6, 30: 8, 61: 9, 55: 2, 27: 3, 15: 7, 52: 4, 129: 7, 115: 7, 87: 7, 131: 9, 102: 5, 113: 9, 99: 6, 36: 7, 24: 6, 53: 5, 72: 8} {202: 1, 350: 1, 1: 10, 4: 6, 9: 5, 10: 7, 15: 7, 24: 6, 25: 6, 26: 6, 27: 7, 39: 6, 43: 7, 49: 10, 50: 9, 58: 9, 59: 6, 64: 7, 69: 3, 81: 7, 82: 7, 86: 7, 96: 8, 97: 7, 100: 10, 108: 7, 109: 8, 110: 8, 111: 6, 114: 7, 115: 8, 116: 7, 118: 7, 119: 6, 120: 7, 121: 5, 122: 8, 123: 7, 124: 5, 128: 8, 129: 8, 130: 9, 132: 4, 136: 6, 145: 4, 147: 8, 151: 8, 152: 8, 154: 7, 156: 6, 161: 3, 162: 4, 165: 7, 168: 8, 169: 7, 172: 7, 180: 8, 184: 5, 187: 9, 188: 8, 191: 7, 194: 4, 206: 6, 207: 7, 215: 4, 217: 7, 218: 9, 220: 5, 221: 5, 222: 6, 224: 7, 227: 8, 229: 7, 234: 9, 235: 6, 241: 6, 242: 6, 243: 2, 244: 8, 245: 3, 248: 8, 250: 8, 258: 12, 262: 8, 263: 9, 264: 4, 267: 5, 270: 7, 272: 7, 273: 3, 287: 7, 289: 7, 291: 9, 299: 8, 300: 7, 304: 7, 309: 5, 314: 6, 315: 7, 320: 5, 323: 3, 327: 8, 328: 5, 329: 6, 330: 11, 334: 6, 335: 7, 341: 8, 342: 9, 347: 8, 348: 8, 351: 9, 352: 7, 353: 7, 354: 6, 358: 5, 365: 7, 366: 6, 369: 5, 371: 10, 372: 9, 376: 6, 384: 9, 385: 8, 386: 7, 387: 7, 392: 5, 393: 6, 396: 9, 397: 8, 398: 7, 402: 7} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 76 "In the preceding example, proper working of duplicate elimination and reordering of packets are dependent on the number of out-of-order packets that can be buffered and the delay difference of arriving packets. DetNet uses flow specific requirements (e.g., maximum number of out-of-order packets, maximum latency of the flow, etc.) for configuration of POF related buffers. If the differential delay between paths is excessively large or there is excessive mis-ordering of the packets, then packets may be dropped instead of being reordered. Likewise, PEF uses the sequence number to identify duplicate packets, and large differential delays combined with high numbers of packets may exceed the ability of the PEF to work properly." Updates from call Feb 3rd . 2c2a1ae3603e50273fbac93129e7d15207fb3fb7 2c2a1ae3603e50273fbac93129e7d15207fb3fb7 draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework 803a9ecf57717ba8b7c268aac7167a4178bb6fe026c71c84f3303202affe1492 ['803a9ecf57717ba8b7c268aac7167a4178bb6fe026c71c84f3303202affe1492', 'da2f851aa0b73253e5a1cb02855811e64b038e227fea4a7825678075e1eb266f'] B "in the preceding example, proper working of duplicate elimination and reordering of packets are dependent on the number of out-of-order packets that can be buffered and the delay difference of arriving packets. detnet uses flow specific requirements (e.g., maximum number of out-of-order packets, maximum latency of the flow, etc.) for configuration of pof related buffers. if the differential delay between paths is excessively large or there is excessive mis-ordering of the packets, then packets may be dropped instead of being reordered. likewise, pef uses the sequence number to identify duplicate packets, and large differential delays combined with high numbers of packets may exceed the ability of the pef to work properly." {84: 1, 68: 1, 6: 3, 79: 6, 90: 5, 51: 7, 130: 6, 62: 6, 85: 6, 35: 7, 110: 7, 91: 9, 114: 7, 97: 7, 31: 3, 13: 7, 67: 5, 38: 8, 26: 6, 124: 5, 98: 6, 54: 6, 127: 7, 8: 4, 96: 7, 64: 6, 30: 8, 61: 9, 55: 2, 27: 3, 15: 7, 52: 4, 129: 7, 115: 7, 87: 7, 131: 9, 102: 5, 113: 9, 99: 6, 36: 7, 24: 6, 53: 5, 72: 8} {202: 1, 350: 1, 1: 10, 4: 6, 9: 5, 10: 7, 15: 7, 24: 6, 25: 6, 26: 6, 27: 7, 39: 6, 43: 7, 49: 10, 50: 9, 58: 9, 59: 6, 64: 7, 69: 3, 81: 7, 82: 7, 86: 7, 96: 8, 97: 7, 100: 10, 108: 7, 109: 8, 110: 8, 111: 6, 114: 7, 115: 8, 116: 7, 118: 7, 119: 6, 120: 7, 121: 5, 122: 8, 123: 7, 124: 5, 128: 8, 129: 8, 130: 9, 132: 4, 136: 6, 145: 4, 147: 8, 151: 8, 152: 8, 154: 7, 156: 6, 161: 3, 162: 4, 165: 7, 168: 8, 169: 7, 172: 7, 180: 8, 184: 5, 187: 9, 188: 8, 191: 7, 194: 4, 206: 6, 207: 7, 215: 4, 217: 7, 218: 9, 220: 5, 221: 5, 222: 6, 224: 7, 227: 8, 229: 7, 234: 9, 235: 6, 241: 6, 242: 6, 243: 2, 244: 8, 245: 3, 248: 8, 250: 8, 258: 12, 262: 8, 263: 9, 264: 4, 267: 5, 270: 7, 272: 7, 273: 3, 287: 7, 289: 7, 291: 9, 299: 8, 300: 7, 304: 7, 309: 5, 314: 6, 315: 7, 320: 5, 323: 3, 327: 8, 328: 5, 329: 6, 330: 11, 334: 6, 335: 7, 341: 8, 342: 9, 347: 8, 348: 8, 351: 9, 352: 7, 353: 7, 354: 6, 358: 5, 365: 7, 366: 6, 369: 5, 371: 10, 372: 9, 376: 6, 384: 9, 385: 8, 386: 7, 387: 7, 392: 5, 393: 6, 396: 9, 397: 8, 398: 7, 402: 7} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 72 "This document uses the terminology established in the DetNet architecture RFC8655 and the the DetNet Data Plane Framework I- D.ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework. The reader is assumed to be familiar with these documents and any terminology defined therein." "Fixing the comments received during the IESG review . MPLS document MPLS : All 01 - 27 changes updated Done" d39a927be3e958ae0ec7e5a999f66ee50bd34570 d39a927be3e958ae0ec7e5a999f66ee50bd34570 draft-ietf-detnet-mpls 320c823ce95acd6aa4c5f15fcc4a98503c5f419c04f271fc060924564b314201 ['320c823ce95acd6aa4c5f15fcc4a98503c5f419c04f271fc060924564b314201', 'a9cd718dec80e2f64a4c6344d62d6529c19212f10682e9e9c357458a4fa6c00d'] A "this document uses the terminology established in the detnet architecture rfc8655 and the the detnet data plane framework i- d.ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework. the reader is assumed to be familiar with these documents and any terminology defined therein." {67: 1} {16: 1} {16, 67} 72 "This document uses the terminology established in the DetNet architecture RFC8655 and the the DetNet Data Plane Framework I- D.ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework. The reader is assumed to be familiar with these documents, any terminology defined therein and basic MPLS related terminologies in RFC3031." "Fixing the comments received during the IESG review . MPLS document MPLS : All 01 - 27 changes updated Done" d39a927be3e958ae0ec7e5a999f66ee50bd34570 d39a927be3e958ae0ec7e5a999f66ee50bd34570 draft-ietf-detnet-mpls a9cd718dec80e2f64a4c6344d62d6529c19212f10682e9e9c357458a4fa6c00d ['320c823ce95acd6aa4c5f15fcc4a98503c5f419c04f271fc060924564b314201', 'a9cd718dec80e2f64a4c6344d62d6529c19212f10682e9e9c357458a4fa6c00d'] B "this document uses the terminology established in the detnet architecture rfc8655 and the the detnet data plane framework i- d.ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework. the reader is assumed to be familiar with these documents, any terminology defined therein and basic mpls related terminologies in rfc3031." {67: 1} {16: 1} {16, 67} 72 "The LSP used to forward the DetNet packet may be of any type (MPLS- LDP, MPLS-TE, MPLS-TP RFC5921, or MPLS-SR I-D.ietf-spring-segment- routing-mpls). The LSP (F-Label) label and/or the S-Label may be used to indicate the queue processing as well as the forwarding parameters. Note that the possible use of Penultimate Hop Popping (PHP) means that the S-Label may be the only label received at the terminating DetNet service." "Fixing the comments received during the IESG review . MPLS document MPLS : All 01 - 27 changes updated Done" d39a927be3e958ae0ec7e5a999f66ee50bd34570 d39a927be3e958ae0ec7e5a999f66ee50bd34570 draft-ietf-detnet-mpls 77fd818b986cf3a0cc1b077eb6ef8a811b497cbab2cdc0f572dc78babcd7c1a9 ['77fd818b986cf3a0cc1b077eb6ef8a811b497cbab2cdc0f572dc78babcd7c1a9', 'dbee28622c9e1a15fd06e411e07989538d5626bd63444404b7d2c7fd9d488f06'] A "the lsp used to forward the detnet packet may be of any type (mpls- ldp, mpls-te, mpls-tp rfc5921, or mpls-sr i-d.ietf-spring-segment- routing-mpls). the lsp (f-label) label and/or the s-label may be used to indicate the queue processing as well as the forwarding parameters. note that the possible use of penultimate hop popping (php) means that the s-label may be the only label received at the terminating detnet service." {} {} {} 72 "The LSP used to forward the DetNet packet is not restricted regarding any method used for establishing that LSP (for example, MPLS-LDP, MPLS-TE, MPLS-TP RFC5921, MPLS-SR RFC8660, etc.). The LSP (F-Label) label and/or the S-Label may be used to indicate the queue processing as well as the forwarding parameters. Note that the possible use of Penultimate Hop Popping (PHP) means that the S-Label may be the only label received at the terminating DetNet service." "Fixing the comments received during the IESG review . MPLS document MPLS : All 01 - 27 changes updated Done" d39a927be3e958ae0ec7e5a999f66ee50bd34570 d39a927be3e958ae0ec7e5a999f66ee50bd34570 draft-ietf-detnet-mpls dbee28622c9e1a15fd06e411e07989538d5626bd63444404b7d2c7fd9d488f06 ['77fd818b986cf3a0cc1b077eb6ef8a811b497cbab2cdc0f572dc78babcd7c1a9', 'dbee28622c9e1a15fd06e411e07989538d5626bd63444404b7d2c7fd9d488f06'] B "the lsp used to forward the detnet packet is not restricted regarding any method used for establishing that lsp (for example, mpls-ldp, mpls-te, mpls-tp rfc5921, mpls-sr rfc8660, etc.). the lsp (f-label) label and/or the s-label may be used to indicate the queue processing as well as the forwarding parameters. note that the possible use of penultimate hop popping (php) means that the s-label may be the only label received at the terminating detnet service." {} {} {} 72 "A DetNet control word (d-CW) conforms to the Generic PW MPLS Control Word (PWMCW) defined in RFC4385. The d-CW formatted as shown in fig_detnet_cw MUST be present in all DetNet packets containing app- flow data." "Fixing the comments received during the IESG review . MPLS document MPLS : All 01 - 27 changes updated Done" d39a927be3e958ae0ec7e5a999f66ee50bd34570 d39a927be3e958ae0ec7e5a999f66ee50bd34570 draft-ietf-detnet-mpls b666e6120001b6019569aa404ba72ddeea39c6676d5ebe151a9e36d26b2e7774 ['b666e6120001b6019569aa404ba72ddeea39c6676d5ebe151a9e36d26b2e7774', '4dfe254c613424642c3643346654f0e0382b4073502256a9b94c0dde78d6aabf'] A "a detnet control word (d-cw) conforms to the generic pw mpls control word (pwmcw) defined in rfc4385. the d-cw formatted as shown in fig_detnet_cw must be present in all detnet packets containing app- flow data." {113: 1, 114: 2} {125: 1, 219: 2} {288, 219, 125} 72 "A DetNet control word (d-CW) conforms to the Generic PW MPLS Control Word (PWMCW) defined in RFC4385. The d-CW formatted as shown in fig_detnet_cw MUST be present in all DetNet packets containing app- flow data. This format of the d-CW was created in order (1) to allow larger S/N space to avoid S/N rollover frequency in some applications and (2) to allow non-skip zero S/N what simplifies implementation." "Fixing the comments received during the IESG review . MPLS document MPLS : All 01 - 27 changes updated Done" d39a927be3e958ae0ec7e5a999f66ee50bd34570 d39a927be3e958ae0ec7e5a999f66ee50bd34570 draft-ietf-detnet-mpls 4dfe254c613424642c3643346654f0e0382b4073502256a9b94c0dde78d6aabf ['b666e6120001b6019569aa404ba72ddeea39c6676d5ebe151a9e36d26b2e7774', '4dfe254c613424642c3643346654f0e0382b4073502256a9b94c0dde78d6aabf'] B "a detnet control word (d-cw) conforms to the generic pw mpls control word (pwmcw) defined in rfc4385. the d-cw formatted as shown in fig_detnet_cw must be present in all detnet packets containing app- flow data. this format of the d-cw was created in order (1) to allow larger s/n space to avoid s/n rollover frequency in some applications and (2) to allow non-skip zero s/n what simplifies implementation." {113: 1, 114: 2} {125: 1, 219: 2} {288, 219, 125} 72 "Additional considerations on DetNet-specific OAM are subjects for further study." "Fixing the comments received during the IESG review . MPLS document MPLS : All 01 - 27 changes updated Done" d39a927be3e958ae0ec7e5a999f66ee50bd34570 d39a927be3e958ae0ec7e5a999f66ee50bd34570 draft-ietf-detnet-mpls 98752e154c3248fd7e807ebac796cb1ed9fd701234bf3f35c597e5b0e5807f1b ['98752e154c3248fd7e807ebac796cb1ed9fd701234bf3f35c597e5b0e5807f1b'] B "additional considerations on detnet-specific oam are subjects for further study." {} {} {} 72 "Security considerations for DetNet are described in detail in I- D.ietf-detnet-security. General security considerations are described in RFC8655. This section considers exclusively security considerations which are specific to the DetNet MPLS data plane." "Fixing the comments received during the IESG review . MPLS document MPLS : All 01 - 27 changes updated Done" d39a927be3e958ae0ec7e5a999f66ee50bd34570 d39a927be3e958ae0ec7e5a999f66ee50bd34570 draft-ietf-detnet-mpls 1a2bf6e02adafb2c1f1e2c209e8410b52c2f457d677486c5f56a5fa41beda4ab ['eee34f68dce1da0da38880a50952e4dbbb99435e1c45fd5fb58ddfa299f9a18b', '1a2bf6e02adafb2c1f1e2c209e8410b52c2f457d677486c5f56a5fa41beda4ab'] A "security considerations for detnet are described in detail in i- d.ietf-detnet-security. general security considerations are described in rfc8655. this section considers exclusively security considerations which are specific to the detnet mpls data plane." {67: 1, 87: 1, 6: 4, 79: 4, 90: 3, 51: 4, 130: 4, 62: 6, 85: 7, 68: 6, 35: 5, 110: 3, 91: 5, 114: 3, 97: 4, 31: 4, 13: 3, 38: 4, 26: 3, 124: 5, 98: 4, 54: 4, 127: 5, 8: 4, 96: 4, 64: 4, 30: 4, 61: 5, 55: 5, 27: 4, 15: 3, 52: 3, 129: 5, 115: 3, 84: 3, 76: 8, 131: 7, 102: 3, 113: 5, 99: 4, 36: 3, 24: 2, 53: 3} {86: 1, 384: 1, 1: 11, 4: 4, 9: 7, 10: 5, 15: 4, 24: 4, 25: 6, 26: 7, 27: 4, 39: 7, 43: 5, 49: 6, 50: 5, 58: 5, 59: 4, 64: 4, 69: 6, 81: 7, 82: 5, 96: 4, 97: 3, 100: 8, 108: 5, 109: 6, 110: 6, 111: 4, 114: 5, 115: 6, 116: 4, 118: 8, 119: 7, 120: 5, 121: 6, 122: 5, 123: 4, 124: 6, 128: 4, 129: 4, 130: 5, 132: 6, 136: 4, 145: 6, 147: 4, 151: 4, 152: 4, 154: 5, 156: 3, 161: 5, 162: 5, 165: 5, 168: 6, 169: 3, 172: 3, 180: 4, 184: 7, 187: 7, 188: 6, 191: 5, 194: 6, 202: 7, 203: 8, 206: 4, 207: 5, 215: 4, 217: 5, 218: 10, 220: 4, 221: 4, 222: 7, 224: 5, 227: 6, 229: 3, 234: 7, 235: 4, 241: 4, 242: 4, 243: 6, 244: 4, 245: 6, 248: 4, 250: 5, 258: 13, 262: 6, 263: 7, 264: 5, 267: 6, 270: 4, 272: 3, 273: 7, 287: 5, 289: 3, 291: 5, 299: 6, 300: 4, 304: 4, 309: 5, 314: 4, 315: 3, 320: 6, 323: 6, 327: 6, 328: 5, 329: 4, 330: 12, 334: 4, 335: 4, 341: 6, 342: 7, 347: 6, 348: 6, 350: 9, 351: 5, 352: 3, 353: 3, 354: 2, 358: 6, 365: 3, 366: 4, 369: 3, 371: 8, 372: 5, 376: 4, 386: 5, 387: 4, 392: 5, 393: 6, 396: 7, 397: 9, 398: 8, 402: 3} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 72 "General security considerations are described in RFC8655. Additionally, security considerations and a threat analysis are described in I-D.ietf-detnet-security. This section considers exclusively security considerations which are specific to the DetNet MPLS data plane." "Fixing the comments received during the IESG review . MPLS document MPLS : All 01 - 27 changes updated Done" d39a927be3e958ae0ec7e5a999f66ee50bd34570 d39a927be3e958ae0ec7e5a999f66ee50bd34570 draft-ietf-detnet-mpls eee34f68dce1da0da38880a50952e4dbbb99435e1c45fd5fb58ddfa299f9a18b ['eee34f68dce1da0da38880a50952e4dbbb99435e1c45fd5fb58ddfa299f9a18b', '1a2bf6e02adafb2c1f1e2c209e8410b52c2f457d677486c5f56a5fa41beda4ab'] B "general security considerations are described in rfc8655. additionally, security considerations and a threat analysis are described in i-d.ietf-detnet-security. this section considers exclusively security considerations which are specific to the detnet mpls data plane." {67: 1, 87: 1, 6: 4, 79: 4, 90: 3, 51: 4, 130: 4, 62: 6, 85: 7, 68: 6, 35: 5, 110: 3, 91: 5, 114: 3, 97: 4, 31: 4, 13: 3, 38: 4, 26: 3, 124: 5, 98: 4, 54: 4, 127: 5, 8: 4, 96: 4, 64: 4, 30: 4, 61: 5, 55: 5, 27: 4, 15: 3, 52: 3, 129: 5, 115: 3, 84: 3, 76: 8, 131: 7, 102: 3, 113: 5, 99: 4, 36: 3, 24: 2, 53: 3} {86: 1, 384: 1, 1: 11, 4: 4, 9: 7, 10: 5, 15: 4, 24: 4, 25: 6, 26: 7, 27: 4, 39: 7, 43: 5, 49: 6, 50: 5, 58: 5, 59: 4, 64: 4, 69: 6, 81: 7, 82: 5, 96: 4, 97: 3, 100: 8, 108: 5, 109: 6, 110: 6, 111: 4, 114: 5, 115: 6, 116: 4, 118: 8, 119: 7, 120: 5, 121: 6, 122: 5, 123: 4, 124: 6, 128: 4, 129: 4, 130: 5, 132: 6, 136: 4, 145: 6, 147: 4, 151: 4, 152: 4, 154: 5, 156: 3, 161: 5, 162: 5, 165: 5, 168: 6, 169: 3, 172: 3, 180: 4, 184: 7, 187: 7, 188: 6, 191: 5, 194: 6, 202: 7, 203: 8, 206: 4, 207: 5, 215: 4, 217: 5, 218: 10, 220: 4, 221: 4, 222: 7, 224: 5, 227: 6, 229: 3, 234: 7, 235: 4, 241: 4, 242: 4, 243: 6, 244: 4, 245: 6, 248: 4, 250: 5, 258: 13, 262: 6, 263: 7, 264: 5, 267: 6, 270: 4, 272: 3, 273: 7, 287: 5, 289: 3, 291: 5, 299: 6, 300: 4, 304: 4, 309: 5, 314: 4, 315: 3, 320: 6, 323: 6, 327: 6, 328: 5, 329: 4, 330: 12, 334: 4, 335: 4, 341: 6, 342: 7, 347: 6, 348: 6, 350: 9, 351: 5, 352: 3, 353: 3, 354: 2, 358: 6, 365: 3, 366: 4, 369: 3, 371: 8, 372: 5, 376: 4, 386: 5, 387: 4, 392: 5, 393: 6, 396: 7, 397: 9, 398: 8, 402: 3} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 71 "S-Labels, d-CW and zero or more F-Labels are used as defined in I- D.ietf-detnet-mpls and are not modified by this document. In case of aggregates the A-Label is treated as an S-Label and it too is not modified." "IESG review comments resolved in this version MPLSoUDP MPLSoUDP : all 01 - 27 changes done . can be merged once comments integrater , per Jan 27th meeting" 1fec474f2cea96f96627539c042a7ee9ebeb6827 1fec474f2cea96f96627539c042a7ee9ebeb6827 draft-ietf-detnet-mpls-over-udp-ip bfaf3a51efcf3eea1985bb60b5e162a78b2466aa3eb6c99c4f9fb9a7d9583399 ['b5e3d7ea97e66f0b9d54f4294da1751d5333e0e1b365fd09f8bdfa094c41b038', 'bfaf3a51efcf3eea1985bb60b5e162a78b2466aa3eb6c99c4f9fb9a7d9583399'] A "s-labels, d-cw and zero or more f-labels are used as defined in i- d.ietf-detnet-mpls and are not modified by this document. in case of aggregates the a-label is treated as an s-label and it too is not modified." {64: 1, 60: 5, 56: 4, 102: 4, 38: 2, 62: 5, 33: 3, 26: 4, 32: 4, 83: 5, 113: 4, 126: 4, 112: 4, 85: 5, 129: 4, 71: 3} {339: 1, 260: 5, 261: 4, 274: 4, 212: 2, 343: 3, 283: 5, 31: 3, 32: 4, 33: 4, 163: 5, 228: 4, 357: 4, 166: 4, 231: 4, 298: 4, 363: 5, 46: 4, 377: 3} {260, 261, 274, 283, 286, 31, 32, 33, 163, 166, 298, 46, 339, 212, 343, 228, 357, 231, 363, 377} 71 "S-Labels, A-Labels (when present), d-CW and zero or more F-Labels are used as defined in I-D.ietf-detnet-mpls and are not modified by this document." "IESG review comments resolved in this version MPLSoUDP MPLSoUDP : all 01 - 27 changes done . can be merged once comments integrater , per Jan 27th meeting" 1fec474f2cea96f96627539c042a7ee9ebeb6827 1fec474f2cea96f96627539c042a7ee9ebeb6827 draft-ietf-detnet-mpls-over-udp-ip b5e3d7ea97e66f0b9d54f4294da1751d5333e0e1b365fd09f8bdfa094c41b038 ['b5e3d7ea97e66f0b9d54f4294da1751d5333e0e1b365fd09f8bdfa094c41b038', 'bfaf3a51efcf3eea1985bb60b5e162a78b2466aa3eb6c99c4f9fb9a7d9583399'] B "s-labels, a-labels (when present), d-cw and zero or more f-labels are used as defined in i-d.ietf-detnet-mpls and are not modified by this document." {64: 1, 60: 5, 56: 4, 102: 4, 38: 2, 62: 5, 33: 3, 26: 4, 32: 4, 83: 5, 113: 4, 126: 4, 112: 4, 85: 5, 129: 4, 71: 3} {339: 1, 260: 5, 261: 4, 274: 4, 212: 2, 343: 3, 283: 5, 31: 3, 32: 4, 33: 4, 163: 5, 228: 4, 357: 4, 166: 4, 231: 4, 298: 4, 363: 5, 46: 4, 377: 3} {260, 261, 274, 283, 286, 31, 32, 33, 163, 166, 298, 46, 339, 212, 343, 228, 357, 231, 363, 377} 71 "To support outgoing DetNet MPLS over UDP/IP encapsulation, an implementation MUST support the provisioning of UDP and IP header information in addition or in place of F-Label(s). Note, when PRF is performed at the MPLS service sub-layer, there will be multiple member flows, and each member flow will require the provisioning of their own UDP and IP header information. The headers for each outgoing packet MUST be formatted according to the configuration information and as defined in RFC7510, with one exception. Note that the UDP Source Port value MUST be set to uniquely identify the DetNet flow. The packet MUST then be handed as a DetNet IP packet, per I- D.ietf-detnet-ip. This includes QoS related traffic treatment." "IESG review comments resolved in this version MPLSoUDP MPLSoUDP : all 01 - 27 changes done . can be merged once comments integrater , per Jan 27th meeting" 1fec474f2cea96f96627539c042a7ee9ebeb6827 1fec474f2cea96f96627539c042a7ee9ebeb6827 draft-ietf-detnet-mpls-over-udp-ip d81065afcde0c1d522ef7389a33fc4bf24820d17239ed99f681791dc6918482b ['ed421dfbc499208b19c13c14f07492fc0a6d8112c65bed9315f7f3d2b27f8234', '7fce71a1abba19c15aad5abbf2f440dc6cf13c973dc4b1f3fae8a72979dea692', '78e5c37125916ed96a19fc61f4632c7048556a2d27efd6661850cdb5dff8b0de', 'c3dfebbd1fe07c70e60322b597ecb3d3a63aa8a746224e939a8230e7b9b19e33', 'd81065afcde0c1d522ef7389a33fc4bf24820d17239ed99f681791dc6918482b', 'ac137fda64918d1759d6885e276707d1ac0fd5b5049504674f4076baf6f22eb3', '9d16780139ac5a5bcc5887b86d737bec08525c621de153cecbe258b0f310cab1', '226c2778cb4b1ee9c69cb248b48f3f8a5944796767817307ba3b2c5b3d09426b', '8608ea9644514c7e7713b3f8f31f6774035a827b6ad028aedbc7aa196024ec1a', '293373c349f280fdf218971329f6687b90f4c3419e23662523d02bd34093bd79', 'e017b1a97c1a28146e0d9bf9ccc4f8ee912af0403ef57166df5480ff49b8b833', '098fdfe92caff68d89dd619dbfd0e0cfa4e0c86676e7633b6e9cefe45674c4b0'] A "to support outgoing detnet mpls over udp/ip encapsulation, an implementation must support the provisioning of udp and ip header information in addition or in place of f-label(s). note, when prf is performed at the mpls service sub-layer, there will be multiple member flows, and each member flow will require the provisioning of their own udp and ip header information. the headers for each outgoing packet must be formatted according to the configuration information and as defined in rfc7510, with one exception. note that the udp source port value must be set to uniquely identify the detnet flow. the packet must then be handed as a detnet ip packet, per i- d.ietf-detnet-ip. this includes qos related traffic treatment." {32: 1, 129: 1, 126: 1, 38: 1, 113: 1, 64: 1, 112: 1, 60: 3, 56: 2, 102: 2, 62: 3, 71: 3, 33: 2, 26: 2, 83: 3, 85: 3} {33: 1, 46: 1, 166: 1, 212: 1, 228: 1, 231: 1, 298: 1, 343: 1, 357: 1, 260: 3, 261: 2, 274: 2, 339: 2, 283: 3, 286: 3, 31: 2, 32: 2, 163: 3, 363: 3} {260, 261, 274, 283, 286, 31, 32, 33, 163, 166, 298, 46, 339, 212, 343, 228, 357, 231, 363, 377} 71 "To support receive processing an implementation MUST also support the provisioning of received UDP and IP header information. The provisioned information MUST be used to identify incoming app-flows based on the combination of S-Label and incoming encapsulation header information. Normal receive processing as defined in I-D.ietf- detnet-mpls, including PEF and POF, can then take place." "IESG review comments resolved in this version MPLSoUDP MPLSoUDP : all 01 - 27 changes done . can be merged once comments integrater , per Jan 27th meeting" 1fec474f2cea96f96627539c042a7ee9ebeb6827 1fec474f2cea96f96627539c042a7ee9ebeb6827 draft-ietf-detnet-mpls-over-udp-ip 9d16780139ac5a5bcc5887b86d737bec08525c621de153cecbe258b0f310cab1 ['ed421dfbc499208b19c13c14f07492fc0a6d8112c65bed9315f7f3d2b27f8234', '7fce71a1abba19c15aad5abbf2f440dc6cf13c973dc4b1f3fae8a72979dea692', '78e5c37125916ed96a19fc61f4632c7048556a2d27efd6661850cdb5dff8b0de', 'c3dfebbd1fe07c70e60322b597ecb3d3a63aa8a746224e939a8230e7b9b19e33', 'd81065afcde0c1d522ef7389a33fc4bf24820d17239ed99f681791dc6918482b', 'ac137fda64918d1759d6885e276707d1ac0fd5b5049504674f4076baf6f22eb3', '9d16780139ac5a5bcc5887b86d737bec08525c621de153cecbe258b0f310cab1', '226c2778cb4b1ee9c69cb248b48f3f8a5944796767817307ba3b2c5b3d09426b', '8608ea9644514c7e7713b3f8f31f6774035a827b6ad028aedbc7aa196024ec1a', '293373c349f280fdf218971329f6687b90f4c3419e23662523d02bd34093bd79', 'e017b1a97c1a28146e0d9bf9ccc4f8ee912af0403ef57166df5480ff49b8b833', '098fdfe92caff68d89dd619dbfd0e0cfa4e0c86676e7633b6e9cefe45674c4b0'] A "to support receive processing an implementation must also support the provisioning of received udp and ip header information. the provisioned information must be used to identify incoming app-flows based on the combination of s-label and incoming encapsulation header information. normal receive processing as defined in i-d.ietf- detnet-mpls, including pef and pof, can then take place." {32: 1, 129: 1, 126: 1, 38: 1, 113: 1, 64: 1, 112: 1, 60: 3, 56: 2, 102: 2, 62: 3, 71: 3, 33: 2, 26: 2, 83: 3, 85: 3} {33: 1, 46: 1, 166: 1, 212: 1, 228: 1, 231: 1, 298: 1, 343: 1, 357: 1, 260: 3, 261: 2, 274: 2, 339: 2, 283: 3, 286: 3, 31: 2, 32: 2, 163: 3, 363: 3} {260, 261, 274, 283, 286, 31, 32, 33, 163, 166, 298, 46, 339, 212, 343, 228, 357, 231, 363, 377} 71 "Label information (S-label or F-label) to be mapped to UDP/IP flow. Note that a single S-Label can map to multiple sets of UPD/ IP information when PREOF is used." "IESG review comments resolved in this version MPLSoUDP MPLSoUDP : all 01 - 27 changes done . can be merged once comments integrater , per Jan 27th meeting" 1fec474f2cea96f96627539c042a7ee9ebeb6827 1fec474f2cea96f96627539c042a7ee9ebeb6827 draft-ietf-detnet-mpls-over-udp-ip e017b1a97c1a28146e0d9bf9ccc4f8ee912af0403ef57166df5480ff49b8b833 ['ed421dfbc499208b19c13c14f07492fc0a6d8112c65bed9315f7f3d2b27f8234', '7fce71a1abba19c15aad5abbf2f440dc6cf13c973dc4b1f3fae8a72979dea692', '78e5c37125916ed96a19fc61f4632c7048556a2d27efd6661850cdb5dff8b0de', 'c3dfebbd1fe07c70e60322b597ecb3d3a63aa8a746224e939a8230e7b9b19e33', 'd81065afcde0c1d522ef7389a33fc4bf24820d17239ed99f681791dc6918482b', 'ac137fda64918d1759d6885e276707d1ac0fd5b5049504674f4076baf6f22eb3', '9d16780139ac5a5bcc5887b86d737bec08525c621de153cecbe258b0f310cab1', '226c2778cb4b1ee9c69cb248b48f3f8a5944796767817307ba3b2c5b3d09426b', '8608ea9644514c7e7713b3f8f31f6774035a827b6ad028aedbc7aa196024ec1a', '293373c349f280fdf218971329f6687b90f4c3419e23662523d02bd34093bd79', 'e017b1a97c1a28146e0d9bf9ccc4f8ee912af0403ef57166df5480ff49b8b833', '098fdfe92caff68d89dd619dbfd0e0cfa4e0c86676e7633b6e9cefe45674c4b0'] A "label information (s-label or f-label) to be mapped to udp/ip flow. note that a single s-label can map to multiple sets of upd/ ip information when preof is used." {32: 1, 129: 1, 126: 1, 38: 1, 113: 1, 64: 1, 112: 1, 60: 3, 56: 2, 102: 2, 62: 3, 71: 3, 33: 2, 26: 2, 83: 3, 85: 3} {33: 1, 46: 1, 166: 1, 212: 1, 228: 1, 231: 1, 298: 1, 343: 1, 357: 1, 260: 3, 261: 2, 274: 2, 339: 2, 283: 3, 286: 3, 31: 2, 32: 2, 163: 3, 363: 3} {260, 261, 274, 283, 286, 31, 32, 33, 163, 166, 298, 46, 339, 212, 343, 228, 357, 231, 363, 377} 71 IPv4 Type of Service or IPv6 Traffic Class Fields. "IESG review comments resolved in this version MPLSoUDP MPLSoUDP : all 01 - 27 changes done . can be merged once comments integrater , per Jan 27th meeting" 1fec474f2cea96f96627539c042a7ee9ebeb6827 1fec474f2cea96f96627539c042a7ee9ebeb6827 draft-ietf-detnet-mpls-over-udp-ip 7fce71a1abba19c15aad5abbf2f440dc6cf13c973dc4b1f3fae8a72979dea692 ['ed421dfbc499208b19c13c14f07492fc0a6d8112c65bed9315f7f3d2b27f8234', '7fce71a1abba19c15aad5abbf2f440dc6cf13c973dc4b1f3fae8a72979dea692', '78e5c37125916ed96a19fc61f4632c7048556a2d27efd6661850cdb5dff8b0de', 'c3dfebbd1fe07c70e60322b597ecb3d3a63aa8a746224e939a8230e7b9b19e33', 'd81065afcde0c1d522ef7389a33fc4bf24820d17239ed99f681791dc6918482b', 'ac137fda64918d1759d6885e276707d1ac0fd5b5049504674f4076baf6f22eb3', '9d16780139ac5a5bcc5887b86d737bec08525c621de153cecbe258b0f310cab1', '226c2778cb4b1ee9c69cb248b48f3f8a5944796767817307ba3b2c5b3d09426b', '8608ea9644514c7e7713b3f8f31f6774035a827b6ad028aedbc7aa196024ec1a', '293373c349f280fdf218971329f6687b90f4c3419e23662523d02bd34093bd79', 'e017b1a97c1a28146e0d9bf9ccc4f8ee912af0403ef57166df5480ff49b8b833', '098fdfe92caff68d89dd619dbfd0e0cfa4e0c86676e7633b6e9cefe45674c4b0'] A ipv4 type of service or ipv6 traffic class fields. {32: 1, 129: 1, 126: 1, 38: 1, 113: 1, 64: 1, 112: 1, 60: 3, 56: 2, 102: 2, 62: 3, 71: 3, 33: 2, 26: 2, 83: 3, 85: 3} {33: 1, 46: 1, 166: 1, 212: 1, 228: 1, 231: 1, 298: 1, 343: 1, 357: 1, 260: 3, 261: 2, 274: 2, 339: 2, 283: 3, 286: 3, 31: 2, 32: 2, 163: 3, 363: 3} {260, 261, 274, 283, 286, 31, 32, 33, 163, 166, 298, 46, 339, 212, 343, 228, 357, 231, 363, 377} 71 "This information MUST be provisioned per DetNet flow via configuration, e.g., via the controller or management plane." "IESG review comments resolved in this version MPLSoUDP MPLSoUDP : all 01 - 27 changes done . can be merged once comments integrater , per Jan 27th meeting" 1fec474f2cea96f96627539c042a7ee9ebeb6827 1fec474f2cea96f96627539c042a7ee9ebeb6827 draft-ietf-detnet-mpls-over-udp-ip 78e5c37125916ed96a19fc61f4632c7048556a2d27efd6661850cdb5dff8b0de ['ed421dfbc499208b19c13c14f07492fc0a6d8112c65bed9315f7f3d2b27f8234', '7fce71a1abba19c15aad5abbf2f440dc6cf13c973dc4b1f3fae8a72979dea692', '78e5c37125916ed96a19fc61f4632c7048556a2d27efd6661850cdb5dff8b0de', 'c3dfebbd1fe07c70e60322b597ecb3d3a63aa8a746224e939a8230e7b9b19e33', 'd81065afcde0c1d522ef7389a33fc4bf24820d17239ed99f681791dc6918482b', 'ac137fda64918d1759d6885e276707d1ac0fd5b5049504674f4076baf6f22eb3', '9d16780139ac5a5bcc5887b86d737bec08525c621de153cecbe258b0f310cab1', '226c2778cb4b1ee9c69cb248b48f3f8a5944796767817307ba3b2c5b3d09426b', '8608ea9644514c7e7713b3f8f31f6774035a827b6ad028aedbc7aa196024ec1a', '293373c349f280fdf218971329f6687b90f4c3419e23662523d02bd34093bd79', 'e017b1a97c1a28146e0d9bf9ccc4f8ee912af0403ef57166df5480ff49b8b833', '098fdfe92caff68d89dd619dbfd0e0cfa4e0c86676e7633b6e9cefe45674c4b0'] A "this information must be provisioned per detnet flow via configuration, e.g., via the controller or management plane." {32: 1, 129: 1, 126: 1, 38: 1, 113: 1, 64: 1, 112: 1, 60: 3, 56: 2, 102: 2, 62: 3, 71: 3, 33: 2, 26: 2, 83: 3, 85: 3} {33: 1, 46: 1, 166: 1, 212: 1, 228: 1, 231: 1, 298: 1, 343: 1, 357: 1, 260: 3, 261: 2, 274: 2, 339: 2, 283: 3, 286: 3, 31: 2, 32: 2, 163: 3, 363: 3} {260, 261, 274, 283, 286, 31, 32, 33, 163, 166, 298, 46, 339, 212, 343, 228, 357, 231, 363, 377} 71 "It is the responsibility of the DetNet controller plane to properly provision both flow identification information and the flow specific resources needed to provided the traffic treatment needed to meet each flow's service requirements. This applies for aggregated and individual flows." "IESG review comments resolved in this version MPLSoUDP MPLSoUDP : all 01 - 27 changes done . can be merged once comments integrater , per Jan 27th meeting" 1fec474f2cea96f96627539c042a7ee9ebeb6827 1fec474f2cea96f96627539c042a7ee9ebeb6827 draft-ietf-detnet-mpls-over-udp-ip ed421dfbc499208b19c13c14f07492fc0a6d8112c65bed9315f7f3d2b27f8234 ['ed421dfbc499208b19c13c14f07492fc0a6d8112c65bed9315f7f3d2b27f8234', '7fce71a1abba19c15aad5abbf2f440dc6cf13c973dc4b1f3fae8a72979dea692', '78e5c37125916ed96a19fc61f4632c7048556a2d27efd6661850cdb5dff8b0de', 'c3dfebbd1fe07c70e60322b597ecb3d3a63aa8a746224e939a8230e7b9b19e33', 'd81065afcde0c1d522ef7389a33fc4bf24820d17239ed99f681791dc6918482b', 'ac137fda64918d1759d6885e276707d1ac0fd5b5049504674f4076baf6f22eb3', '9d16780139ac5a5bcc5887b86d737bec08525c621de153cecbe258b0f310cab1', '226c2778cb4b1ee9c69cb248b48f3f8a5944796767817307ba3b2c5b3d09426b', '8608ea9644514c7e7713b3f8f31f6774035a827b6ad028aedbc7aa196024ec1a', '293373c349f280fdf218971329f6687b90f4c3419e23662523d02bd34093bd79', 'e017b1a97c1a28146e0d9bf9ccc4f8ee912af0403ef57166df5480ff49b8b833', '098fdfe92caff68d89dd619dbfd0e0cfa4e0c86676e7633b6e9cefe45674c4b0'] A "it is the responsibility of the detnet controller plane to properly provision both flow identification information and the flow specific resources needed to provided the traffic treatment needed to meet each flow's service requirements. this applies for aggregated and individual flows." {32: 1, 129: 1, 126: 1, 38: 1, 113: 1, 64: 1, 112: 1, 60: 3, 56: 2, 102: 2, 62: 3, 71: 3, 33: 2, 26: 2, 83: 3, 85: 3} {33: 1, 46: 1, 166: 1, 212: 1, 228: 1, 231: 1, 298: 1, 343: 1, 357: 1, 260: 3, 261: 2, 274: 2, 339: 2, 283: 3, 286: 3, 31: 2, 32: 2, 163: 3, 363: 3} {260, 261, 274, 283, 286, 31, 32, 33, 163, 166, 298, 46, 339, 212, 343, 228, 357, 231, 363, 377} 71 "To support outgoing DetNet MPLS over UDP/IP encapsulation, an implementation MUST support the provisioning of UDP and IP header information in addition or in place of F-Label(s). Note, when PRF is performed at the MPLS service sub-layer, there will be multiple member flows, and each member flow will require the provisioning of their own UDP and IP header information. The headers for each outgoing packet MUST be formatted according to the configuration information and as defined in RFC7510, and the UDP Source Port value MUST be set to uniquely identify the DetNet flow. The packet MUST then be handled as a DetNet IP packet, per I-D.ietf-detnet-ip. This includes QoS related traffic treatment." "IESG review comments resolved in this version MPLSoUDP MPLSoUDP : all 01 - 27 changes done . can be merged once comments integrater , per Jan 27th meeting" 1fec474f2cea96f96627539c042a7ee9ebeb6827 1fec474f2cea96f96627539c042a7ee9ebeb6827 draft-ietf-detnet-mpls-over-udp-ip 293373c349f280fdf218971329f6687b90f4c3419e23662523d02bd34093bd79 ['ed421dfbc499208b19c13c14f07492fc0a6d8112c65bed9315f7f3d2b27f8234', '7fce71a1abba19c15aad5abbf2f440dc6cf13c973dc4b1f3fae8a72979dea692', '78e5c37125916ed96a19fc61f4632c7048556a2d27efd6661850cdb5dff8b0de', 'c3dfebbd1fe07c70e60322b597ecb3d3a63aa8a746224e939a8230e7b9b19e33', 'd81065afcde0c1d522ef7389a33fc4bf24820d17239ed99f681791dc6918482b', 'ac137fda64918d1759d6885e276707d1ac0fd5b5049504674f4076baf6f22eb3', '9d16780139ac5a5bcc5887b86d737bec08525c621de153cecbe258b0f310cab1', '226c2778cb4b1ee9c69cb248b48f3f8a5944796767817307ba3b2c5b3d09426b', '8608ea9644514c7e7713b3f8f31f6774035a827b6ad028aedbc7aa196024ec1a', '293373c349f280fdf218971329f6687b90f4c3419e23662523d02bd34093bd79', 'e017b1a97c1a28146e0d9bf9ccc4f8ee912af0403ef57166df5480ff49b8b833', '098fdfe92caff68d89dd619dbfd0e0cfa4e0c86676e7633b6e9cefe45674c4b0'] B "to support outgoing detnet mpls over udp/ip encapsulation, an implementation must support the provisioning of udp and ip header information in addition or in place of f-label(s). note, when prf is performed at the mpls service sub-layer, there will be multiple member flows, and each member flow will require the provisioning of their own udp and ip header information. the headers for each outgoing packet must be formatted according to the configuration information and as defined in rfc7510, and the udp source port value must be set to uniquely identify the detnet flow. the packet must then be handled as a detnet ip packet, per i-d.ietf-detnet-ip. this includes qos related traffic treatment." {32: 1, 129: 1, 126: 1, 38: 1, 113: 1, 64: 1, 112: 1, 60: 3, 56: 2, 102: 2, 62: 3, 71: 3, 33: 2, 26: 2, 83: 3, 85: 3} {33: 1, 46: 1, 166: 1, 212: 1, 228: 1, 231: 1, 298: 1, 343: 1, 357: 1, 260: 3, 261: 2, 274: 2, 339: 2, 283: 3, 286: 3, 31: 2, 32: 2, 163: 3, 363: 3} {260, 261, 274, 283, 286, 31, 32, 33, 163, 166, 298, 46, 339, 212, 343, 228, 357, 231, 363, 377} 71 "To support the receive processing defined in this document, an implementation MUST also support the provisioning of received UDP and IP header information. The provisioned information MUST be used to identify incoming app-flows based on the combination of S-Label and incoming encapsulation header information. Normal receive processing as defined in I-D.ietf-detnet-mpls, including PEF and POF, can then take place." "IESG review comments resolved in this version MPLSoUDP MPLSoUDP : all 01 - 27 changes done . can be merged once comments integrater , per Jan 27th meeting" 1fec474f2cea96f96627539c042a7ee9ebeb6827 1fec474f2cea96f96627539c042a7ee9ebeb6827 draft-ietf-detnet-mpls-over-udp-ip ac137fda64918d1759d6885e276707d1ac0fd5b5049504674f4076baf6f22eb3 ['ed421dfbc499208b19c13c14f07492fc0a6d8112c65bed9315f7f3d2b27f8234', '7fce71a1abba19c15aad5abbf2f440dc6cf13c973dc4b1f3fae8a72979dea692', '78e5c37125916ed96a19fc61f4632c7048556a2d27efd6661850cdb5dff8b0de', 'c3dfebbd1fe07c70e60322b597ecb3d3a63aa8a746224e939a8230e7b9b19e33', 'd81065afcde0c1d522ef7389a33fc4bf24820d17239ed99f681791dc6918482b', 'ac137fda64918d1759d6885e276707d1ac0fd5b5049504674f4076baf6f22eb3', '9d16780139ac5a5bcc5887b86d737bec08525c621de153cecbe258b0f310cab1', '226c2778cb4b1ee9c69cb248b48f3f8a5944796767817307ba3b2c5b3d09426b', '8608ea9644514c7e7713b3f8f31f6774035a827b6ad028aedbc7aa196024ec1a', '293373c349f280fdf218971329f6687b90f4c3419e23662523d02bd34093bd79', 'e017b1a97c1a28146e0d9bf9ccc4f8ee912af0403ef57166df5480ff49b8b833', '098fdfe92caff68d89dd619dbfd0e0cfa4e0c86676e7633b6e9cefe45674c4b0'] B "to support the receive processing defined in this document, an implementation must also support the provisioning of received udp and ip header information. the provisioned information must be used to identify incoming app-flows based on the combination of s-label and incoming encapsulation header information. normal receive processing as defined in i-d.ietf-detnet-mpls, including pef and pof, can then take place." {32: 1, 129: 1, 126: 1, 38: 1, 113: 1, 64: 1, 112: 1, 60: 3, 56: 2, 102: 2, 62: 3, 71: 3, 33: 2, 26: 2, 83: 3, 85: 3} {33: 1, 46: 1, 166: 1, 212: 1, 228: 1, 231: 1, 298: 1, 343: 1, 357: 1, 260: 3, 261: 2, 274: 2, 339: 2, 283: 3, 286: 3, 31: 2, 32: 2, 163: 3, 363: 3} {260, 261, 274, 283, 286, 31, 32, 33, 163, 166, 298, 46, 339, 212, 343, 228, 357, 231, 363, 377} 71 "Label information (A-labels, S-labels and F-labels) to be mapped to UDP/IP flow. Note that for example, a single S-Label can map to multiple sets of UDP/IP information when PREOF is used." "IESG review comments resolved in this version MPLSoUDP MPLSoUDP : all 01 - 27 changes done . can be merged once comments integrater , per Jan 27th meeting" 1fec474f2cea96f96627539c042a7ee9ebeb6827 1fec474f2cea96f96627539c042a7ee9ebeb6827 draft-ietf-detnet-mpls-over-udp-ip 226c2778cb4b1ee9c69cb248b48f3f8a5944796767817307ba3b2c5b3d09426b ['ed421dfbc499208b19c13c14f07492fc0a6d8112c65bed9315f7f3d2b27f8234', '7fce71a1abba19c15aad5abbf2f440dc6cf13c973dc4b1f3fae8a72979dea692', '78e5c37125916ed96a19fc61f4632c7048556a2d27efd6661850cdb5dff8b0de', 'c3dfebbd1fe07c70e60322b597ecb3d3a63aa8a746224e939a8230e7b9b19e33', 'd81065afcde0c1d522ef7389a33fc4bf24820d17239ed99f681791dc6918482b', 'ac137fda64918d1759d6885e276707d1ac0fd5b5049504674f4076baf6f22eb3', '9d16780139ac5a5bcc5887b86d737bec08525c621de153cecbe258b0f310cab1', '226c2778cb4b1ee9c69cb248b48f3f8a5944796767817307ba3b2c5b3d09426b', '8608ea9644514c7e7713b3f8f31f6774035a827b6ad028aedbc7aa196024ec1a', '293373c349f280fdf218971329f6687b90f4c3419e23662523d02bd34093bd79', 'e017b1a97c1a28146e0d9bf9ccc4f8ee912af0403ef57166df5480ff49b8b833', '098fdfe92caff68d89dd619dbfd0e0cfa4e0c86676e7633b6e9cefe45674c4b0'] B "label information (a-labels, s-labels and f-labels) to be mapped to udp/ip flow. note that for example, a single s-label can map to multiple sets of udp/ip information when preof is used." {32: 1, 129: 1, 126: 1, 38: 1, 113: 1, 64: 1, 112: 1, 60: 3, 56: 2, 102: 2, 62: 3, 71: 3, 33: 2, 26: 2, 83: 3, 85: 3} {33: 1, 46: 1, 166: 1, 212: 1, 228: 1, 231: 1, 298: 1, 343: 1, 357: 1, 260: 3, 261: 2, 274: 2, 339: 2, 283: 3, 286: 3, 31: 2, 32: 2, 163: 3, 363: 3} {260, 261, 274, 283, 286, 31, 32, 33, 163, 166, 298, 46, 339, 212, 343, 228, 357, 231, 363, 377} 71 "DSCP Field in either IPv4 Type of Service or IPv6 Traffic Class Fields." "IESG review comments resolved in this version MPLSoUDP MPLSoUDP : all 01 - 27 changes done . can be merged once comments integrater , per Jan 27th meeting" 1fec474f2cea96f96627539c042a7ee9ebeb6827 1fec474f2cea96f96627539c042a7ee9ebeb6827 draft-ietf-detnet-mpls-over-udp-ip 098fdfe92caff68d89dd619dbfd0e0cfa4e0c86676e7633b6e9cefe45674c4b0 ['ed421dfbc499208b19c13c14f07492fc0a6d8112c65bed9315f7f3d2b27f8234', '7fce71a1abba19c15aad5abbf2f440dc6cf13c973dc4b1f3fae8a72979dea692', '78e5c37125916ed96a19fc61f4632c7048556a2d27efd6661850cdb5dff8b0de', 'c3dfebbd1fe07c70e60322b597ecb3d3a63aa8a746224e939a8230e7b9b19e33', 'd81065afcde0c1d522ef7389a33fc4bf24820d17239ed99f681791dc6918482b', 'ac137fda64918d1759d6885e276707d1ac0fd5b5049504674f4076baf6f22eb3', '9d16780139ac5a5bcc5887b86d737bec08525c621de153cecbe258b0f310cab1', '226c2778cb4b1ee9c69cb248b48f3f8a5944796767817307ba3b2c5b3d09426b', '8608ea9644514c7e7713b3f8f31f6774035a827b6ad028aedbc7aa196024ec1a', '293373c349f280fdf218971329f6687b90f4c3419e23662523d02bd34093bd79', 'e017b1a97c1a28146e0d9bf9ccc4f8ee912af0403ef57166df5480ff49b8b833', '098fdfe92caff68d89dd619dbfd0e0cfa4e0c86676e7633b6e9cefe45674c4b0'] B "dscp field in either ipv4 type of service or ipv6 traffic class fields." {32: 1, 129: 1, 126: 1, 38: 1, 113: 1, 64: 1, 112: 1, 60: 3, 56: 2, 102: 2, 62: 3, 71: 3, 33: 2, 26: 2, 83: 3, 85: 3} {33: 1, 46: 1, 166: 1, 212: 1, 228: 1, 231: 1, 298: 1, 343: 1, 357: 1, 260: 3, 261: 2, 274: 2, 339: 2, 283: 3, 286: 3, 31: 2, 32: 2, 163: 3, 363: 3} {260, 261, 274, 283, 286, 31, 32, 33, 163, 166, 298, 46, 339, 212, 343, 228, 357, 231, 363, 377} 71 "This information MUST be provisioned per DetNet flow via configuration, e.g., via the controller RFC8655 or management plane." "IESG review comments resolved in this version MPLSoUDP MPLSoUDP : all 01 - 27 changes done . can be merged once comments integrater , per Jan 27th meeting" 1fec474f2cea96f96627539c042a7ee9ebeb6827 1fec474f2cea96f96627539c042a7ee9ebeb6827 draft-ietf-detnet-mpls-over-udp-ip c3dfebbd1fe07c70e60322b597ecb3d3a63aa8a746224e939a8230e7b9b19e33 ['ed421dfbc499208b19c13c14f07492fc0a6d8112c65bed9315f7f3d2b27f8234', '7fce71a1abba19c15aad5abbf2f440dc6cf13c973dc4b1f3fae8a72979dea692', '78e5c37125916ed96a19fc61f4632c7048556a2d27efd6661850cdb5dff8b0de', 'c3dfebbd1fe07c70e60322b597ecb3d3a63aa8a746224e939a8230e7b9b19e33', 'd81065afcde0c1d522ef7389a33fc4bf24820d17239ed99f681791dc6918482b', 'ac137fda64918d1759d6885e276707d1ac0fd5b5049504674f4076baf6f22eb3', '9d16780139ac5a5bcc5887b86d737bec08525c621de153cecbe258b0f310cab1', '226c2778cb4b1ee9c69cb248b48f3f8a5944796767817307ba3b2c5b3d09426b', '8608ea9644514c7e7713b3f8f31f6774035a827b6ad028aedbc7aa196024ec1a', '293373c349f280fdf218971329f6687b90f4c3419e23662523d02bd34093bd79', 'e017b1a97c1a28146e0d9bf9ccc4f8ee912af0403ef57166df5480ff49b8b833', '098fdfe92caff68d89dd619dbfd0e0cfa4e0c86676e7633b6e9cefe45674c4b0'] B "this information must be provisioned per detnet flow via configuration, e.g., via the controller rfc8655 or management plane." {32: 1, 129: 1, 126: 1, 38: 1, 113: 1, 64: 1, 112: 1, 60: 3, 56: 2, 102: 2, 62: 3, 71: 3, 33: 2, 26: 2, 83: 3, 85: 3} {33: 1, 46: 1, 166: 1, 212: 1, 228: 1, 231: 1, 298: 1, 343: 1, 357: 1, 260: 3, 261: 2, 274: 2, 339: 2, 283: 3, 286: 3, 31: 2, 32: 2, 163: 3, 363: 3} {260, 261, 274, 283, 286, 31, 32, 33, 163, 166, 298, 46, 339, 212, 343, 228, 357, 231, 363, 377} 71 "It is the responsibility of the DetNet controller plane to properly provision both flow identification information and the flow specific resources needed to provide the traffic treatment needed to meet each flow's service requirements. This applies for aggregated and individual flows." "IESG review comments resolved in this version MPLSoUDP MPLSoUDP : all 01 - 27 changes done . can be merged once comments integrater , per Jan 27th meeting" 1fec474f2cea96f96627539c042a7ee9ebeb6827 1fec474f2cea96f96627539c042a7ee9ebeb6827 draft-ietf-detnet-mpls-over-udp-ip 8608ea9644514c7e7713b3f8f31f6774035a827b6ad028aedbc7aa196024ec1a ['ed421dfbc499208b19c13c14f07492fc0a6d8112c65bed9315f7f3d2b27f8234', '7fce71a1abba19c15aad5abbf2f440dc6cf13c973dc4b1f3fae8a72979dea692', '78e5c37125916ed96a19fc61f4632c7048556a2d27efd6661850cdb5dff8b0de', 'c3dfebbd1fe07c70e60322b597ecb3d3a63aa8a746224e939a8230e7b9b19e33', 'd81065afcde0c1d522ef7389a33fc4bf24820d17239ed99f681791dc6918482b', 'ac137fda64918d1759d6885e276707d1ac0fd5b5049504674f4076baf6f22eb3', '9d16780139ac5a5bcc5887b86d737bec08525c621de153cecbe258b0f310cab1', '226c2778cb4b1ee9c69cb248b48f3f8a5944796767817307ba3b2c5b3d09426b', '8608ea9644514c7e7713b3f8f31f6774035a827b6ad028aedbc7aa196024ec1a', '293373c349f280fdf218971329f6687b90f4c3419e23662523d02bd34093bd79', 'e017b1a97c1a28146e0d9bf9ccc4f8ee912af0403ef57166df5480ff49b8b833', '098fdfe92caff68d89dd619dbfd0e0cfa4e0c86676e7633b6e9cefe45674c4b0'] B "it is the responsibility of the detnet controller plane to properly provision both flow identification information and the flow specific resources needed to provide the traffic treatment needed to meet each flow's service requirements. this applies for aggregated and individual flows." {32: 1, 129: 1, 126: 1, 38: 1, 113: 1, 64: 1, 112: 1, 60: 3, 56: 2, 102: 2, 62: 3, 71: 3, 33: 2, 26: 2, 83: 3, 85: 3} {33: 1, 46: 1, 166: 1, 212: 1, 228: 1, 231: 1, 298: 1, 343: 1, 357: 1, 260: 3, 261: 2, 274: 2, 339: 2, 283: 3, 286: 3, 31: 2, 32: 2, 163: 3, 363: 3} {260, 261, 274, 283, 286, 31, 32, 33, 163, 166, 298, 46, 339, 212, 343, 228, 357, 231, 363, 377} 69 Packet Replication, Ordering and Elimination Function. Updates from comments on the mailing list . 35782f042de00210d718794b0c1faa8a6d2d044a 35782f042de00210d718794b0c1faa8a6d2d044a draft-ietf-detnet-ip-over-mpls 5d071d73c4129b79be70ee4a57fb281390644dcb50da26d288ed337c66102485 ['fcbb4b68ae78c4ce9cca6d03e0f62a1b8515b67ad1bc512e0d4857a6b428fb55', 'cdc15b05d37b640ea4b7794cf9a229c6c28f8a1b7491f0460010ab5fcc44ff69', '5d071d73c4129b79be70ee4a57fb281390644dcb50da26d288ed337c66102485', '45bc601f4e7c8b80cc0c429fc5273808e88ddf7f6b0c7053a4c557e2c279a10d', '18586b4a34af8afb3b19ff32c04e0b7b2f961021e15338b0a5a3ccafbea3e89f'] A packet replication, ordering and elimination function. {64: 1, 68: 1, 79: 1, 52: 1, 33: 1, 62: 1, 130: 3, 51: 2, 112: 2, 55: 2, 37: 2, 38: 2, 67: 2, 25: 2, 53: 2, 80: 2, 127: 4, 91: 2} {14: 1, 279: 1, 280: 1, 321: 1, 324: 1, 400: 1, 0: 3, 389: 2, 390: 2, 135: 2, 142: 2, 17: 2, 399: 3, 19: 3, 149: 2, 281: 3, 278: 2, 294: 2, 296: 2, 45: 3, 308: 2, 56: 2, 185: 2, 192: 2, 322: 2, 66: 2, 196: 5, 197: 4, 77: 2, 78: 2, 337: 4, 216: 2, 380: 2, 255: 3} {0, 389, 390, 135, 142, 14, 400, 17, 399, 19, 149, 406, 279, 280, 281, 278, 294, 296, 45, 308, 56, 185, 192, 321, 322, 66, 196, 197, 324, 77, 78, 337, 216, 380, 255} 69 Packet Elimination Function. Updates from comments on the mailing list . 35782f042de00210d718794b0c1faa8a6d2d044a 35782f042de00210d718794b0c1faa8a6d2d044a draft-ietf-detnet-ip-over-mpls 18586b4a34af8afb3b19ff32c04e0b7b2f961021e15338b0a5a3ccafbea3e89f ['fcbb4b68ae78c4ce9cca6d03e0f62a1b8515b67ad1bc512e0d4857a6b428fb55', 'cdc15b05d37b640ea4b7794cf9a229c6c28f8a1b7491f0460010ab5fcc44ff69', '5d071d73c4129b79be70ee4a57fb281390644dcb50da26d288ed337c66102485', '45bc601f4e7c8b80cc0c429fc5273808e88ddf7f6b0c7053a4c557e2c279a10d', '18586b4a34af8afb3b19ff32c04e0b7b2f961021e15338b0a5a3ccafbea3e89f'] B packet elimination function. {64: 1, 68: 1, 79: 1, 52: 1, 33: 1, 62: 1, 130: 3, 51: 2, 112: 2, 55: 2, 37: 2, 38: 2, 67: 2, 25: 2, 53: 2, 80: 2, 127: 4, 91: 2} {14: 1, 279: 1, 280: 1, 321: 1, 324: 1, 400: 1, 0: 3, 389: 2, 390: 2, 135: 2, 142: 2, 17: 2, 399: 3, 19: 3, 149: 2, 281: 3, 278: 2, 294: 2, 296: 2, 45: 3, 308: 2, 56: 2, 185: 2, 192: 2, 322: 2, 66: 2, 196: 5, 197: 4, 77: 2, 78: 2, 337: 4, 216: 2, 380: 2, 255: 3} {0, 389, 390, 135, 142, 14, 400, 17, 399, 19, 149, 406, 279, 280, 281, 278, 294, 296, 45, 308, 56, 185, 192, 321, 322, 66, 196, 197, 324, 77, 78, 337, 216, 380, 255} 69 Packet Replication Function. Updates from comments on the mailing list . 35782f042de00210d718794b0c1faa8a6d2d044a 35782f042de00210d718794b0c1faa8a6d2d044a draft-ietf-detnet-ip-over-mpls fcbb4b68ae78c4ce9cca6d03e0f62a1b8515b67ad1bc512e0d4857a6b428fb55 ['fcbb4b68ae78c4ce9cca6d03e0f62a1b8515b67ad1bc512e0d4857a6b428fb55', 'cdc15b05d37b640ea4b7794cf9a229c6c28f8a1b7491f0460010ab5fcc44ff69', '5d071d73c4129b79be70ee4a57fb281390644dcb50da26d288ed337c66102485', '45bc601f4e7c8b80cc0c429fc5273808e88ddf7f6b0c7053a4c557e2c279a10d', '18586b4a34af8afb3b19ff32c04e0b7b2f961021e15338b0a5a3ccafbea3e89f'] B packet replication function. {64: 1, 68: 1, 79: 1, 52: 1, 33: 1, 62: 1, 130: 3, 51: 2, 112: 2, 55: 2, 37: 2, 38: 2, 67: 2, 25: 2, 53: 2, 80: 2, 127: 4, 91: 2} {14: 1, 279: 1, 280: 1, 321: 1, 324: 1, 400: 1, 0: 3, 389: 2, 390: 2, 135: 2, 142: 2, 17: 2, 399: 3, 19: 3, 149: 2, 281: 3, 278: 2, 294: 2, 296: 2, 45: 3, 308: 2, 56: 2, 185: 2, 192: 2, 322: 2, 66: 2, 196: 5, 197: 4, 77: 2, 78: 2, 337: 4, 216: 2, 380: 2, 255: 3} {0, 389, 390, 135, 142, 14, 400, 17, 399, 19, 149, 406, 279, 280, 281, 278, 294, 296, 45, 308, 56, 185, 192, 321, 322, 66, 196, 197, 324, 77, 78, 337, 216, 380, 255} 69 Packet Replication, Elimination and Ordering Functions. Updates from comments on the mailing list . 35782f042de00210d718794b0c1faa8a6d2d044a 35782f042de00210d718794b0c1faa8a6d2d044a draft-ietf-detnet-ip-over-mpls cdc15b05d37b640ea4b7794cf9a229c6c28f8a1b7491f0460010ab5fcc44ff69 ['fcbb4b68ae78c4ce9cca6d03e0f62a1b8515b67ad1bc512e0d4857a6b428fb55', 'cdc15b05d37b640ea4b7794cf9a229c6c28f8a1b7491f0460010ab5fcc44ff69', '5d071d73c4129b79be70ee4a57fb281390644dcb50da26d288ed337c66102485', '45bc601f4e7c8b80cc0c429fc5273808e88ddf7f6b0c7053a4c557e2c279a10d', '18586b4a34af8afb3b19ff32c04e0b7b2f961021e15338b0a5a3ccafbea3e89f'] B packet replication, elimination and ordering functions. {64: 1, 68: 1, 79: 1, 52: 1, 33: 1, 62: 1, 130: 3, 51: 2, 112: 2, 55: 2, 37: 2, 38: 2, 67: 2, 25: 2, 53: 2, 80: 2, 127: 4, 91: 2} {14: 1, 279: 1, 280: 1, 321: 1, 324: 1, 400: 1, 0: 3, 389: 2, 390: 2, 135: 2, 142: 2, 17: 2, 399: 3, 19: 3, 149: 2, 281: 3, 278: 2, 294: 2, 296: 2, 45: 3, 308: 2, 56: 2, 185: 2, 192: 2, 322: 2, 66: 2, 196: 5, 197: 4, 77: 2, 78: 2, 337: 4, 216: 2, 380: 2, 255: 3} {0, 389, 390, 135, 142, 14, 400, 17, 399, 19, 149, 406, 279, 280, 281, 278, 294, 296, 45, 308, 56, 185, 192, 321, 322, 66, 196, 197, 324, 77, 78, 337, 216, 380, 255} 69 Packet Ordering Function. Updates from comments on the mailing list . 35782f042de00210d718794b0c1faa8a6d2d044a 35782f042de00210d718794b0c1faa8a6d2d044a draft-ietf-detnet-ip-over-mpls 45bc601f4e7c8b80cc0c429fc5273808e88ddf7f6b0c7053a4c557e2c279a10d ['fcbb4b68ae78c4ce9cca6d03e0f62a1b8515b67ad1bc512e0d4857a6b428fb55', 'cdc15b05d37b640ea4b7794cf9a229c6c28f8a1b7491f0460010ab5fcc44ff69', '5d071d73c4129b79be70ee4a57fb281390644dcb50da26d288ed337c66102485', '45bc601f4e7c8b80cc0c429fc5273808e88ddf7f6b0c7053a4c557e2c279a10d', '18586b4a34af8afb3b19ff32c04e0b7b2f961021e15338b0a5a3ccafbea3e89f'] B packet ordering function. {64: 1, 68: 1, 79: 1, 52: 1, 33: 1, 62: 1, 130: 3, 51: 2, 112: 2, 55: 2, 37: 2, 38: 2, 67: 2, 25: 2, 53: 2, 80: 2, 127: 4, 91: 2} {14: 1, 279: 1, 280: 1, 321: 1, 324: 1, 400: 1, 0: 3, 389: 2, 390: 2, 135: 2, 142: 2, 17: 2, 399: 3, 19: 3, 149: 2, 281: 3, 278: 2, 294: 2, 296: 2, 45: 3, 308: 2, 56: 2, 185: 2, 192: 2, 322: 2, 66: 2, 196: 5, 197: 4, 77: 2, 78: 2, 337: 4, 216: 2, 380: 2, 255: 3} {0, 389, 390, 135, 142, 14, 400, 17, 399, 19, 149, 406, 279, 280, 281, 278, 294, 296, 45, 308, 56, 185, 192, 321, 322, 66, 196, 197, 324, 77, 78, 337, 216, 380, 255} 69 "A DetNet relay node (ingress T-PE) that sends a DetNet IP flow over a DetNet MPLS network MUST map a DetNet IP flow, as identified in I- D.ietf-detnet-ip into a single MPLS DetNet flow and MUST process it in accordance to the procedures defined in I-D.ietf-detnet-mpls Section 6.1. PRF MAY be supported at the MPLS level for DetNet IP flows sent over an DetNet MPLS network. Aggregation MAY be supported as defined in I-D.ietf-detnet-mpls Section 5.4. Aggregation considerations in I-D.ietf-detnet-ip MAY be used to identify an individual DetNet IP flow. The provisioning of the mapping of DetNet IP flows to DetNet MPLS flows MUST be supported via configuration, e.g., via the controller plane." Updates from comments on the mailing list . 35782f042de00210d718794b0c1faa8a6d2d044a 35782f042de00210d718794b0c1faa8a6d2d044a draft-ietf-detnet-ip-over-mpls 761b1f644f5fd8372e1b54b441e473a079c1cc3b5d9682281bfa60336852a64e ['f862e2831c0e2bbc418b2c6446b811c7a0e8f884afcf832dc3fa9da7276a2106', '761b1f644f5fd8372e1b54b441e473a079c1cc3b5d9682281bfa60336852a64e'] A "a detnet relay node (ingress t-pe) that sends a detnet ip flow over a detnet mpls network must map a detnet ip flow, as identified in i- d.ietf-detnet-ip into a single mpls detnet flow and must process it in accordance to the procedures defined in i-d.ietf-detnet-mpls section 6.1. prf may be supported at the mpls level for detnet ip flows sent over an detnet mpls network. aggregation may be supported as defined in i-d.ietf-detnet-mpls section 5.4. aggregation considerations in i-d.ietf-detnet-ip may be used to identify an individual detnet ip flow. the provisioning of the mapping of detnet ip flows to detnet mpls flows must be supported via configuration, e.g., via the controller plane." {38: 1, 63: 3, 30: 2, 69: 4, 118: 4} {414: 1, 102: 3, 103: 2, 175: 3, 407: 4, 62: 4} {414, 102, 103, 175, 401, 407, 62} 69 "A DetNet relay node (ingress T-PE) that sends a DetNet IP flow over a DetNet MPLS network MUST map a DetNet IP flow, as identified in I- D.ietf-detnet-ip into a single MPLS DetNet flow and MUST process it in accordance to the procedures defined in I-D.ietf-detnet-mpls. PRF MAY be supported at the MPLS level for DetNet IP flows sent over an DetNet MPLS network. Aggregation MAY be supported as defined in I- D.ietf-detnet-mpls Section 4.4. Aggregation considerations in I- D.ietf-detnet-ip MAY be used to identify an individual DetNet IP flow. The provisioning of the mapping of DetNet IP flows to DetNet MPLS flows MUST be supported via configuration, e.g., via the controller plane." Updates from comments on the mailing list . 35782f042de00210d718794b0c1faa8a6d2d044a 35782f042de00210d718794b0c1faa8a6d2d044a draft-ietf-detnet-ip-over-mpls f862e2831c0e2bbc418b2c6446b811c7a0e8f884afcf832dc3fa9da7276a2106 ['f862e2831c0e2bbc418b2c6446b811c7a0e8f884afcf832dc3fa9da7276a2106', '761b1f644f5fd8372e1b54b441e473a079c1cc3b5d9682281bfa60336852a64e'] B "a detnet relay node (ingress t-pe) that sends a detnet ip flow over a detnet mpls network must map a detnet ip flow, as identified in i- d.ietf-detnet-ip into a single mpls detnet flow and must process it in accordance to the procedures defined in i-d.ietf-detnet-mpls. prf may be supported at the mpls level for detnet ip flows sent over an detnet mpls network. aggregation may be supported as defined in i- d.ietf-detnet-mpls section 4.4. aggregation considerations in i- d.ietf-detnet-ip may be used to identify an individual detnet ip flow. the provisioning of the mapping of detnet ip flows to detnet mpls flows must be supported via configuration, e.g., via the controller plane." {38: 1, 63: 3, 30: 2, 69: 4, 118: 4} {414: 1, 102: 3, 103: 2, 175: 3, 407: 4, 62: 4} {414, 102, 103, 175, 401, 407, 62} 69 "A DetNet relay node (egress T-PE) MAY be provisioned to handle packets received via the DetNet MPLS data plane as DetNet IP flows. A single incoming DetNet MPLS flow MAY be treated as a single DetNet IP flow, without examination of IP headers. Alternatively, packets received via the DetNet MPLS data plane MAY follow the normal DetNet IP flow identification procedures defined in I-D.ietf-detnet-ip Section 7.1." Updates from comments on the mailing list . 35782f042de00210d718794b0c1faa8a6d2d044a 35782f042de00210d718794b0c1faa8a6d2d044a draft-ietf-detnet-ip-over-mpls 45bad6139846a5f50679742f54023cff55efc88bca3176c14f972e49165457f7 ['fe45615de9ec967c21c2921b60b9e6b442dd97177f6e96ffb5945ff7f9135157', '45bad6139846a5f50679742f54023cff55efc88bca3176c14f972e49165457f7'] A "a detnet relay node (egress t-pe) may be provisioned to handle packets received via the detnet mpls data plane as detnet ip flows. a single incoming detnet mpls flow may be treated as a single detnet ip flow, without examination of ip headers. alternatively, packets received via the detnet mpls data plane may follow the normal detnet ip flow identification procedures defined in i-d.ietf-detnet-ip section 7.1." {38: 1, 63: 2, 30: 2, 69: 4, 118: 3} {175: 1, 414: 3, 102: 2, 103: 2, 401: 4, 62: 3} {414, 102, 103, 175, 401, 407, 62} 69 "A DetNet relay node (egress T-PE) MAY be provisioned to handle packets received via the DetNet MPLS data plane as DetNet IP flows. A single incoming DetNet MPLS flow MAY be treated as a single DetNet IP flow, without examination of IP headers. Alternatively, packets received via the DetNet MPLS data plane MAY follow the normal DetNet IP flow identification procedures defined in I-D.ietf-detnet-ip Section 5.1." Updates from comments on the mailing list . 35782f042de00210d718794b0c1faa8a6d2d044a 35782f042de00210d718794b0c1faa8a6d2d044a draft-ietf-detnet-ip-over-mpls fe45615de9ec967c21c2921b60b9e6b442dd97177f6e96ffb5945ff7f9135157 ['fe45615de9ec967c21c2921b60b9e6b442dd97177f6e96ffb5945ff7f9135157', '45bad6139846a5f50679742f54023cff55efc88bca3176c14f972e49165457f7'] B "a detnet relay node (egress t-pe) may be provisioned to handle packets received via the detnet mpls data plane as detnet ip flows. a single incoming detnet mpls flow may be treated as a single detnet ip flow, without examination of ip headers. alternatively, packets received via the detnet mpls data plane may follow the normal detnet ip flow identification procedures defined in i-d.ietf-detnet-ip section 5.1." {38: 1, 63: 2, 30: 2, 69: 4, 118: 3} {175: 1, 414: 3, 102: 2, 103: 2, 401: 4, 62: 3} {414, 102, 103, 175, 401, 407, 62} 68 "The DetNet Architecture models the DetNet related data plane functions decomposed into two sub-layers: a service sub-layer and a forwarding sub-layer. The service sub-layer is used to provide DetNet service protection and reordering. The forwarding sub-layer leverages Traffic Engineering mechanisms and provides congestion protection (low loss, assured latency, and limited out-of-order delivery)." changes look good 9b5906939d7fc5f5c463322e3063c95e1ec9ac88 9b5906939d7fc5f5c463322e3063c95e1ec9ac88 draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework 772b85d3bb02da9f14ffb89c621617e2ac18b8e3807dbd4286803c7169505810 ['772b85d3bb02da9f14ffb89c621617e2ac18b8e3807dbd4286803c7169505810', '1d23c49cc89558646981bab7a83513b80fcc0d6dc2a60bff680d5c8114f9d82c'] A "the detnet architecture models the detnet related data plane functions decomposed into two sub-layers: a service sub-layer and a forwarding sub-layer. the service sub-layer is used to provide detnet service protection and reordering. the forwarding sub-layer leverages traffic engineering mechanisms and provides congestion protection (low loss, assured latency, and limited out-of-order delivery)." {90: 1, 55: 1, 6: 4, 68: 3, 84: 2} {37: 1, 182: 1, 232: 4, 173: 4, 373: 2, 87: 3, 374: 3, 53: 3} {37, 232, 173, 373, 182, 87, 181, 374, 53} 68 "The DetNet Architecture models the DetNet related data plane functions decomposed into two sub-layers: a service sub-layer and a forwarding sub-layer. The service sub-layer is used to provide DetNet service protection and reordering. The forwarding sub-layer leverages Traffic Engineering mechanisms and provides congestion protection (low loss, assured latency, and limited out-of-order delivery). A particular forwarding sub-layer may have capabilities that are not available on other forwarding-sub layers. DetNet makes use of the existing forwarding sub-layers with their respective capabilities and does not require 1:1 equivalence between different forwarding sub-layer capabilities." changes look good 9b5906939d7fc5f5c463322e3063c95e1ec9ac88 9b5906939d7fc5f5c463322e3063c95e1ec9ac88 draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework 1d23c49cc89558646981bab7a83513b80fcc0d6dc2a60bff680d5c8114f9d82c ['772b85d3bb02da9f14ffb89c621617e2ac18b8e3807dbd4286803c7169505810', '1d23c49cc89558646981bab7a83513b80fcc0d6dc2a60bff680d5c8114f9d82c'] B "the detnet architecture models the detnet related data plane functions decomposed into two sub-layers: a service sub-layer and a forwarding sub-layer. the service sub-layer is used to provide detnet service protection and reordering. the forwarding sub-layer leverages traffic engineering mechanisms and provides congestion protection (low loss, assured latency, and limited out-of-order delivery). a particular forwarding sub-layer may have capabilities that are not available on other forwarding-sub layers. detnet makes use of the existing forwarding sub-layers with their respective capabilities and does not require 1:1 equivalence between different forwarding sub-layer capabilities." {90: 1, 55: 1, 6: 4, 68: 3, 84: 2} {37: 1, 182: 1, 232: 4, 173: 4, 373: 2, 87: 3, 374: 3, 53: 3} {37, 232, 173, 373, 182, 87, 181, 374, 53} 68 "DetNet flows may be carried over network technologies that can provide the DetNet required service characteristics. For example, DetNet MPLS flows can be carried over IEEE 802.1 Time Sensitive Network (TSN) IEEE802.1TSNTG sub-networks. However, IEEE 802.1 TSN support is not required and some of the DetNet benefits can be gained by running over a data link layer that has not been specifically enhanced to support TSN." changes look good 9b5906939d7fc5f5c463322e3063c95e1ec9ac88 9b5906939d7fc5f5c463322e3063c95e1ec9ac88 draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework 750206659c7178c6805b5eb7404a928a50175007fe7f74f6d2d9b5de22e7e83f ['e8b3fb35e36b05ff93c43122e75d773a89efea6bec1ab2675cc2267657e2464c', '750206659c7178c6805b5eb7404a928a50175007fe7f74f6d2d9b5de22e7e83f'] A "detnet flows may be carried over network technologies that can provide the detnet required service characteristics. for example, detnet mpls flows can be carried over ieee 802.1 time sensitive network (tsn) ieee802.1tsntg sub-networks. however, ieee 802.1 tsn support is not required and some of the detnet benefits can be gained by running over a data link layer that has not been specifically enhanced to support tsn." {84: 1, 90: 2, 6: 3, 68: 3, 55: 2} {373: 1, 37: 4, 232: 3, 173: 3, 182: 2, 87: 2, 181: 3, 53: 2} {37, 232, 173, 373, 182, 87, 181, 374, 53} 68 "DetNet flows may be carried over network technologies that can provide the DetNet required service characteristics. For example, DetNet MPLS flows can be carried over IEEE 802.1 Time Sensitive Network (TSN) IEEE802.1TSNTG sub-networks. However, IEEE 802.1 TSN support is not required in DetNet. TSN frame preemption is an example of a forwarding layer capability that is typically not replicated in other forwarding technologies. Most of DetNet benefits can be gained by running over a data link layer that has not been specifically enhanced to support all TSN capabilities but for certain networks and traffic mixes delay and jitter performance may vary due to the forwarding sub-layer intrinsic properties." changes look good 9b5906939d7fc5f5c463322e3063c95e1ec9ac88 9b5906939d7fc5f5c463322e3063c95e1ec9ac88 draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework e8b3fb35e36b05ff93c43122e75d773a89efea6bec1ab2675cc2267657e2464c ['e8b3fb35e36b05ff93c43122e75d773a89efea6bec1ab2675cc2267657e2464c', '750206659c7178c6805b5eb7404a928a50175007fe7f74f6d2d9b5de22e7e83f'] B "detnet flows may be carried over network technologies that can provide the detnet required service characteristics. for example, detnet mpls flows can be carried over ieee 802.1 time sensitive network (tsn) ieee802.1tsntg sub-networks. however, ieee 802.1 tsn support is not required in detnet. tsn frame preemption is an example of a forwarding layer capability that is typically not replicated in other forwarding technologies. most of detnet benefits can be gained by running over a data link layer that has not been specifically enhanced to support all tsn capabilities but for certain networks and traffic mixes delay and jitter performance may vary due to the forwarding sub-layer intrinsic properties." {84: 1, 90: 2, 6: 3, 68: 3, 55: 2} {373: 1, 37: 4, 232: 3, 173: 3, 182: 2, 87: 2, 181: 3, 53: 2} {37, 232, 173, 373, 182, 87, 181, 374, 53} 68 "This document also covers basic concepts related to the controller plane and Operations, Administration, and Maintenance (OAM). Data plane OAM specifics are out of scope for this docuement." changes look good 9b5906939d7fc5f5c463322e3063c95e1ec9ac88 9b5906939d7fc5f5c463322e3063c95e1ec9ac88 draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework da3dfab4dea569b45dfc7b358af41efc223f062e88d2fa4683765559c6b3ec70 ['6d420d76985dc0a7ff6077e5f7761266ce668df030f4da1fd69c35b8c0ebe18f', 'da3dfab4dea569b45dfc7b358af41efc223f062e88d2fa4683765559c6b3ec70'] A "this document also covers basic concepts related to the controller plane and operations, administration, and maintenance (oam). data plane oam specifics are out of scope for this docuement." {55: 1, 90: 3, 6: 2, 84: 2, 68: 3} {87: 1, 37: 5, 232: 2, 373: 2, 182: 3, 181: 4, 374: 3, 53: 3} {37, 232, 173, 373, 182, 87, 181, 374, 53} 68 "This document also covers basic concepts related to the controller plane and Operations, Administration, and Maintenance (OAM). Data plane OAM specifics are out of scope for this document." changes look good 9b5906939d7fc5f5c463322e3063c95e1ec9ac88 9b5906939d7fc5f5c463322e3063c95e1ec9ac88 draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework 6d420d76985dc0a7ff6077e5f7761266ce668df030f4da1fd69c35b8c0ebe18f ['6d420d76985dc0a7ff6077e5f7761266ce668df030f4da1fd69c35b8c0ebe18f', 'da3dfab4dea569b45dfc7b358af41efc223f062e88d2fa4683765559c6b3ec70'] B "this document also covers basic concepts related to the controller plane and operations, administration, and maintenance (oam). data plane oam specifics are out of scope for this document." {55: 1, 90: 3, 6: 2, 84: 2, 68: 3} {87: 1, 37: 5, 232: 2, 373: 2, 182: 3, 181: 4, 374: 3, 53: 3} {37, 232, 173, 373, 182, 87, 181, 374, 53} 68 Control Word. changes look good 9b5906939d7fc5f5c463322e3063c95e1ec9ac88 9b5906939d7fc5f5c463322e3063c95e1ec9ac88 draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework 0af69069e9963489a014eb853d2a6ecda9ae7da34113cf3389c1167163e82dcf ['b3713da5dc7b1531fd348079a30e2f5ac724e78c334f13dcd3da81aefb4a647d', '5d1ba8eea8ba53e9a9d0a6d166225ec30fafe99cff8f1aa38baf7ba9ff273aa6', 'cdc15b05d37b640ea4b7794cf9a229c6c28f8a1b7491f0460010ab5fcc44ff69', '652bfd8e78af5fb6764d1cd3c06e0842d2b7be3658a25654db9db79dcf0dc03c', 'b8d8f64f0f09d4c8fa40ff054a5f0e468afa79876dab10bea529c2c1e1430fbc', '58925b1ef76bb083d7d886d21f9aa7fc2143a26177ca339c06f960bc8c37c866', 'c2a31a816fad375f9df24bfcd3a1baa2c591de01e6733384a2811b4fd944d8ef', '34f6582bd92afa345dc5dcd62ba8f25eef20bd51d1919d3bde053a8ab6747c41', '8a9f636b1cdab856d1233a7a3cfa4bc0e99b49da4ac574e376b09f10f4f341e9', 'b5e2c587228a4238fbc26703235a5c512628fc7011c15e8d9bb25b28cbb1de10', '09f6b6a812132eee463de5625d44082094351e5e01c90e0e4dc14d2893ef6a38', '45bc601f4e7c8b80cc0c429fc5273808e88ddf7f6b0c7053a4c557e2c279a10d', '539441e88ca7396e33d2f25233286cf28b38761225330959445669581bd22411', '0af69069e9963489a014eb853d2a6ecda9ae7da34113cf3389c1167163e82dcf', '44be41afed3494e0381ae1126c4bb4f4f2977a0e1a01591ebd945f08460f1d1b', 'bb194dc58a0eb7e52501603ff614fb1131422ca453ab5b879033dd20511649fb', '2cb2fafbc456d565a9a6271284cb082c73a12c678dbaca52fa4304dd16824479', '18586b4a34af8afb3b19ff32c04e0b7b2f961021e15338b0a5a3ccafbea3e89f', '5da7ebc4953e83090f06af6e486dc3a244576cd2b94ec353133be3ced3251dcd', 'b44b885a406cb9ec036bed7a2f808cd599fef92864f4ac305f6309a2fb37cb4d', 'fcbb4b68ae78c4ce9cca6d03e0f62a1b8515b67ad1bc512e0d4857a6b428fb55', '97c985aeb00a2b45cdc26ddc7cc9e5e08475164523c7e555feb34c739c6a3ec7'] A control word. {64: 1, 37: 1, 91: 1, 55: 1, 112: 1, 38: 1, 33: 1, 79: 1, 52: 1, 25: 1, 51: 1, 69: 1, 130: 3, 62: 2, 67: 2, 53: 2, 80: 2, 127: 4} {14: 1, 17: 1, 77: 1, 78: 1, 135: 1, 142: 1, 149: 1, 216: 1, 278: 1, 280: 1, 321: 1, 324: 1, 294: 1, 296: 1, 308: 1, 406: 1, 0: 3, 389: 2, 390: 2, 400: 2, 399: 3, 19: 2, 281: 3, 45: 2, 56: 2, 185: 2, 192: 2, 322: 2, 66: 2, 196: 5, 197: 4, 337: 4, 380: 2, 255: 3} {0, 389, 390, 135, 142, 14, 400, 17, 399, 19, 149, 406, 279, 280, 281, 278, 294, 296, 45, 308, 56, 185, 192, 321, 322, 66, 196, 197, 324, 77, 78, 337, 216, 380, 255} 68 DetNet Control Word. changes look good 9b5906939d7fc5f5c463322e3063c95e1ec9ac88 9b5906939d7fc5f5c463322e3063c95e1ec9ac88 draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework 8a9f636b1cdab856d1233a7a3cfa4bc0e99b49da4ac574e376b09f10f4f341e9 ['b3713da5dc7b1531fd348079a30e2f5ac724e78c334f13dcd3da81aefb4a647d', '5d1ba8eea8ba53e9a9d0a6d166225ec30fafe99cff8f1aa38baf7ba9ff273aa6', 'cdc15b05d37b640ea4b7794cf9a229c6c28f8a1b7491f0460010ab5fcc44ff69', '652bfd8e78af5fb6764d1cd3c06e0842d2b7be3658a25654db9db79dcf0dc03c', 'b8d8f64f0f09d4c8fa40ff054a5f0e468afa79876dab10bea529c2c1e1430fbc', '58925b1ef76bb083d7d886d21f9aa7fc2143a26177ca339c06f960bc8c37c866', 'c2a31a816fad375f9df24bfcd3a1baa2c591de01e6733384a2811b4fd944d8ef', '34f6582bd92afa345dc5dcd62ba8f25eef20bd51d1919d3bde053a8ab6747c41', '8a9f636b1cdab856d1233a7a3cfa4bc0e99b49da4ac574e376b09f10f4f341e9', 'b5e2c587228a4238fbc26703235a5c512628fc7011c15e8d9bb25b28cbb1de10', '09f6b6a812132eee463de5625d44082094351e5e01c90e0e4dc14d2893ef6a38', '45bc601f4e7c8b80cc0c429fc5273808e88ddf7f6b0c7053a4c557e2c279a10d', '539441e88ca7396e33d2f25233286cf28b38761225330959445669581bd22411', '0af69069e9963489a014eb853d2a6ecda9ae7da34113cf3389c1167163e82dcf', '44be41afed3494e0381ae1126c4bb4f4f2977a0e1a01591ebd945f08460f1d1b', 'bb194dc58a0eb7e52501603ff614fb1131422ca453ab5b879033dd20511649fb', '2cb2fafbc456d565a9a6271284cb082c73a12c678dbaca52fa4304dd16824479', '18586b4a34af8afb3b19ff32c04e0b7b2f961021e15338b0a5a3ccafbea3e89f', '5da7ebc4953e83090f06af6e486dc3a244576cd2b94ec353133be3ced3251dcd', 'b44b885a406cb9ec036bed7a2f808cd599fef92864f4ac305f6309a2fb37cb4d', 'fcbb4b68ae78c4ce9cca6d03e0f62a1b8515b67ad1bc512e0d4857a6b428fb55', '97c985aeb00a2b45cdc26ddc7cc9e5e08475164523c7e555feb34c739c6a3ec7'] A detnet control word. {64: 1, 37: 1, 91: 1, 55: 1, 112: 1, 38: 1, 33: 1, 79: 1, 52: 1, 25: 1, 51: 1, 69: 1, 130: 3, 62: 2, 67: 2, 53: 2, 80: 2, 127: 4} {14: 1, 17: 1, 77: 1, 78: 1, 135: 1, 142: 1, 149: 1, 216: 1, 278: 1, 280: 1, 321: 1, 324: 1, 294: 1, 296: 1, 308: 1, 406: 1, 0: 3, 389: 2, 390: 2, 400: 2, 399: 3, 19: 2, 281: 3, 45: 2, 56: 2, 185: 2, 192: 2, 322: 2, 66: 2, 196: 5, 197: 4, 337: 4, 380: 2, 255: 3} {0, 389, 390, 135, 142, 14, 400, 17, 399, 19, 149, 406, 279, 280, 281, 278, 294, 296, 45, 308, 56, 185, 192, 321, 322, 66, 196, 197, 324, 77, 78, 337, 216, 380, 255} 68 Deterministic Networking. changes look good 9b5906939d7fc5f5c463322e3063c95e1ec9ac88 9b5906939d7fc5f5c463322e3063c95e1ec9ac88 draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework c2a31a816fad375f9df24bfcd3a1baa2c591de01e6733384a2811b4fd944d8ef ['b3713da5dc7b1531fd348079a30e2f5ac724e78c334f13dcd3da81aefb4a647d', '5d1ba8eea8ba53e9a9d0a6d166225ec30fafe99cff8f1aa38baf7ba9ff273aa6', 'cdc15b05d37b640ea4b7794cf9a229c6c28f8a1b7491f0460010ab5fcc44ff69', '652bfd8e78af5fb6764d1cd3c06e0842d2b7be3658a25654db9db79dcf0dc03c', 'b8d8f64f0f09d4c8fa40ff054a5f0e468afa79876dab10bea529c2c1e1430fbc', '58925b1ef76bb083d7d886d21f9aa7fc2143a26177ca339c06f960bc8c37c866', 'c2a31a816fad375f9df24bfcd3a1baa2c591de01e6733384a2811b4fd944d8ef', '34f6582bd92afa345dc5dcd62ba8f25eef20bd51d1919d3bde053a8ab6747c41', '8a9f636b1cdab856d1233a7a3cfa4bc0e99b49da4ac574e376b09f10f4f341e9', 'b5e2c587228a4238fbc26703235a5c512628fc7011c15e8d9bb25b28cbb1de10', '09f6b6a812132eee463de5625d44082094351e5e01c90e0e4dc14d2893ef6a38', '45bc601f4e7c8b80cc0c429fc5273808e88ddf7f6b0c7053a4c557e2c279a10d', '539441e88ca7396e33d2f25233286cf28b38761225330959445669581bd22411', '0af69069e9963489a014eb853d2a6ecda9ae7da34113cf3389c1167163e82dcf', '44be41afed3494e0381ae1126c4bb4f4f2977a0e1a01591ebd945f08460f1d1b', 'bb194dc58a0eb7e52501603ff614fb1131422ca453ab5b879033dd20511649fb', '2cb2fafbc456d565a9a6271284cb082c73a12c678dbaca52fa4304dd16824479', '18586b4a34af8afb3b19ff32c04e0b7b2f961021e15338b0a5a3ccafbea3e89f', '5da7ebc4953e83090f06af6e486dc3a244576cd2b94ec353133be3ced3251dcd', 'b44b885a406cb9ec036bed7a2f808cd599fef92864f4ac305f6309a2fb37cb4d', 'fcbb4b68ae78c4ce9cca6d03e0f62a1b8515b67ad1bc512e0d4857a6b428fb55', '97c985aeb00a2b45cdc26ddc7cc9e5e08475164523c7e555feb34c739c6a3ec7'] A deterministic networking. {64: 1, 37: 1, 91: 1, 55: 1, 112: 1, 38: 1, 33: 1, 79: 1, 52: 1, 25: 1, 51: 1, 69: 1, 130: 3, 62: 2, 67: 2, 53: 2, 80: 2, 127: 4} {14: 1, 17: 1, 77: 1, 78: 1, 135: 1, 142: 1, 149: 1, 216: 1, 278: 1, 280: 1, 321: 1, 324: 1, 294: 1, 296: 1, 308: 1, 406: 1, 0: 3, 389: 2, 390: 2, 400: 2, 399: 3, 19: 2, 281: 3, 45: 2, 56: 2, 185: 2, 192: 2, 322: 2, 66: 2, 196: 5, 197: 4, 337: 4, 380: 2, 255: 3} {0, 389, 390, 135, 142, 14, 400, 17, 399, 19, 149, 406, 279, 280, 281, 278, 294, 296, 45, 308, 56, 185, 192, 321, 322, 66, 196, 197, 324, 77, 78, 337, 216, 380, 255} 68 DetNet. changes look good 9b5906939d7fc5f5c463322e3063c95e1ec9ac88 9b5906939d7fc5f5c463322e3063c95e1ec9ac88 draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework 58925b1ef76bb083d7d886d21f9aa7fc2143a26177ca339c06f960bc8c37c866 ['b3713da5dc7b1531fd348079a30e2f5ac724e78c334f13dcd3da81aefb4a647d', '5d1ba8eea8ba53e9a9d0a6d166225ec30fafe99cff8f1aa38baf7ba9ff273aa6', 'cdc15b05d37b640ea4b7794cf9a229c6c28f8a1b7491f0460010ab5fcc44ff69', '652bfd8e78af5fb6764d1cd3c06e0842d2b7be3658a25654db9db79dcf0dc03c', 'b8d8f64f0f09d4c8fa40ff054a5f0e468afa79876dab10bea529c2c1e1430fbc', '58925b1ef76bb083d7d886d21f9aa7fc2143a26177ca339c06f960bc8c37c866', 'c2a31a816fad375f9df24bfcd3a1baa2c591de01e6733384a2811b4fd944d8ef', '34f6582bd92afa345dc5dcd62ba8f25eef20bd51d1919d3bde053a8ab6747c41', '8a9f636b1cdab856d1233a7a3cfa4bc0e99b49da4ac574e376b09f10f4f341e9', 'b5e2c587228a4238fbc26703235a5c512628fc7011c15e8d9bb25b28cbb1de10', '09f6b6a812132eee463de5625d44082094351e5e01c90e0e4dc14d2893ef6a38', '45bc601f4e7c8b80cc0c429fc5273808e88ddf7f6b0c7053a4c557e2c279a10d', '539441e88ca7396e33d2f25233286cf28b38761225330959445669581bd22411', '0af69069e9963489a014eb853d2a6ecda9ae7da34113cf3389c1167163e82dcf', '44be41afed3494e0381ae1126c4bb4f4f2977a0e1a01591ebd945f08460f1d1b', 'bb194dc58a0eb7e52501603ff614fb1131422ca453ab5b879033dd20511649fb', '2cb2fafbc456d565a9a6271284cb082c73a12c678dbaca52fa4304dd16824479', '18586b4a34af8afb3b19ff32c04e0b7b2f961021e15338b0a5a3ccafbea3e89f', '5da7ebc4953e83090f06af6e486dc3a244576cd2b94ec353133be3ced3251dcd', 'b44b885a406cb9ec036bed7a2f808cd599fef92864f4ac305f6309a2fb37cb4d', 'fcbb4b68ae78c4ce9cca6d03e0f62a1b8515b67ad1bc512e0d4857a6b428fb55', '97c985aeb00a2b45cdc26ddc7cc9e5e08475164523c7e555feb34c739c6a3ec7'] A detnet. {64: 1, 37: 1, 91: 1, 55: 1, 112: 1, 38: 1, 33: 1, 79: 1, 52: 1, 25: 1, 51: 1, 69: 1, 130: 3, 62: 2, 67: 2, 53: 2, 80: 2, 127: 4} {14: 1, 17: 1, 77: 1, 78: 1, 135: 1, 142: 1, 149: 1, 216: 1, 278: 1, 280: 1, 321: 1, 324: 1, 294: 1, 296: 1, 308: 1, 406: 1, 0: 3, 389: 2, 390: 2, 400: 2, 399: 3, 19: 2, 281: 3, 45: 2, 56: 2, 185: 2, 192: 2, 322: 2, 66: 2, 196: 5, 197: 4, 337: 4, 380: 2, 255: 3} {0, 389, 390, 135, 142, 14, 400, 17, 399, 19, 149, 406, 279, 280, 281, 278, 294, 296, 45, 308, 56, 185, 192, 321, 322, 66, 196, 197, 324, 77, 78, 337, 216, 380, 255} 68 Generic Routing Encapsulation. changes look good 9b5906939d7fc5f5c463322e3063c95e1ec9ac88 9b5906939d7fc5f5c463322e3063c95e1ec9ac88 draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework 539441e88ca7396e33d2f25233286cf28b38761225330959445669581bd22411 ['b3713da5dc7b1531fd348079a30e2f5ac724e78c334f13dcd3da81aefb4a647d', '5d1ba8eea8ba53e9a9d0a6d166225ec30fafe99cff8f1aa38baf7ba9ff273aa6', 'cdc15b05d37b640ea4b7794cf9a229c6c28f8a1b7491f0460010ab5fcc44ff69', '652bfd8e78af5fb6764d1cd3c06e0842d2b7be3658a25654db9db79dcf0dc03c', 'b8d8f64f0f09d4c8fa40ff054a5f0e468afa79876dab10bea529c2c1e1430fbc', '58925b1ef76bb083d7d886d21f9aa7fc2143a26177ca339c06f960bc8c37c866', 'c2a31a816fad375f9df24bfcd3a1baa2c591de01e6733384a2811b4fd944d8ef', '34f6582bd92afa345dc5dcd62ba8f25eef20bd51d1919d3bde053a8ab6747c41', '8a9f636b1cdab856d1233a7a3cfa4bc0e99b49da4ac574e376b09f10f4f341e9', 'b5e2c587228a4238fbc26703235a5c512628fc7011c15e8d9bb25b28cbb1de10', '09f6b6a812132eee463de5625d44082094351e5e01c90e0e4dc14d2893ef6a38', '45bc601f4e7c8b80cc0c429fc5273808e88ddf7f6b0c7053a4c557e2c279a10d', '539441e88ca7396e33d2f25233286cf28b38761225330959445669581bd22411', '0af69069e9963489a014eb853d2a6ecda9ae7da34113cf3389c1167163e82dcf', '44be41afed3494e0381ae1126c4bb4f4f2977a0e1a01591ebd945f08460f1d1b', 'bb194dc58a0eb7e52501603ff614fb1131422ca453ab5b879033dd20511649fb', '2cb2fafbc456d565a9a6271284cb082c73a12c678dbaca52fa4304dd16824479', '18586b4a34af8afb3b19ff32c04e0b7b2f961021e15338b0a5a3ccafbea3e89f', '5da7ebc4953e83090f06af6e486dc3a244576cd2b94ec353133be3ced3251dcd', 'b44b885a406cb9ec036bed7a2f808cd599fef92864f4ac305f6309a2fb37cb4d', 'fcbb4b68ae78c4ce9cca6d03e0f62a1b8515b67ad1bc512e0d4857a6b428fb55', '97c985aeb00a2b45cdc26ddc7cc9e5e08475164523c7e555feb34c739c6a3ec7'] A generic routing encapsulation. {64: 1, 37: 1, 91: 1, 55: 1, 112: 1, 38: 1, 33: 1, 79: 1, 52: 1, 25: 1, 51: 1, 69: 1, 130: 3, 62: 2, 67: 2, 53: 2, 80: 2, 127: 4} {14: 1, 17: 1, 77: 1, 78: 1, 135: 1, 142: 1, 149: 1, 216: 1, 278: 1, 280: 1, 321: 1, 324: 1, 294: 1, 296: 1, 308: 1, 406: 1, 0: 3, 389: 2, 390: 2, 400: 2, 399: 3, 19: 2, 281: 3, 45: 2, 56: 2, 185: 2, 192: 2, 322: 2, 66: 2, 196: 5, 197: 4, 337: 4, 380: 2, 255: 3} {0, 389, 390, 135, 142, 14, 400, 17, 399, 19, 149, 406, 279, 280, 281, 278, 294, 296, 45, 308, 56, 185, 192, 321, 322, 66, 196, 197, 324, 77, 78, 337, 216, 380, 255} 68 IP Security. changes look good 9b5906939d7fc5f5c463322e3063c95e1ec9ac88 9b5906939d7fc5f5c463322e3063c95e1ec9ac88 draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework 44be41afed3494e0381ae1126c4bb4f4f2977a0e1a01591ebd945f08460f1d1b ['b3713da5dc7b1531fd348079a30e2f5ac724e78c334f13dcd3da81aefb4a647d', '5d1ba8eea8ba53e9a9d0a6d166225ec30fafe99cff8f1aa38baf7ba9ff273aa6', 'cdc15b05d37b640ea4b7794cf9a229c6c28f8a1b7491f0460010ab5fcc44ff69', '652bfd8e78af5fb6764d1cd3c06e0842d2b7be3658a25654db9db79dcf0dc03c', 'b8d8f64f0f09d4c8fa40ff054a5f0e468afa79876dab10bea529c2c1e1430fbc', '58925b1ef76bb083d7d886d21f9aa7fc2143a26177ca339c06f960bc8c37c866', 'c2a31a816fad375f9df24bfcd3a1baa2c591de01e6733384a2811b4fd944d8ef', '34f6582bd92afa345dc5dcd62ba8f25eef20bd51d1919d3bde053a8ab6747c41', '8a9f636b1cdab856d1233a7a3cfa4bc0e99b49da4ac574e376b09f10f4f341e9', 'b5e2c587228a4238fbc26703235a5c512628fc7011c15e8d9bb25b28cbb1de10', '09f6b6a812132eee463de5625d44082094351e5e01c90e0e4dc14d2893ef6a38', '45bc601f4e7c8b80cc0c429fc5273808e88ddf7f6b0c7053a4c557e2c279a10d', '539441e88ca7396e33d2f25233286cf28b38761225330959445669581bd22411', '0af69069e9963489a014eb853d2a6ecda9ae7da34113cf3389c1167163e82dcf', '44be41afed3494e0381ae1126c4bb4f4f2977a0e1a01591ebd945f08460f1d1b', 'bb194dc58a0eb7e52501603ff614fb1131422ca453ab5b879033dd20511649fb', '2cb2fafbc456d565a9a6271284cb082c73a12c678dbaca52fa4304dd16824479', '18586b4a34af8afb3b19ff32c04e0b7b2f961021e15338b0a5a3ccafbea3e89f', '5da7ebc4953e83090f06af6e486dc3a244576cd2b94ec353133be3ced3251dcd', 'b44b885a406cb9ec036bed7a2f808cd599fef92864f4ac305f6309a2fb37cb4d', 'fcbb4b68ae78c4ce9cca6d03e0f62a1b8515b67ad1bc512e0d4857a6b428fb55', '97c985aeb00a2b45cdc26ddc7cc9e5e08475164523c7e555feb34c739c6a3ec7'] A ip security. {64: 1, 37: 1, 91: 1, 55: 1, 112: 1, 38: 1, 33: 1, 79: 1, 52: 1, 25: 1, 51: 1, 69: 1, 130: 3, 62: 2, 67: 2, 53: 2, 80: 2, 127: 4} {14: 1, 17: 1, 77: 1, 78: 1, 135: 1, 142: 1, 149: 1, 216: 1, 278: 1, 280: 1, 321: 1, 324: 1, 294: 1, 296: 1, 308: 1, 406: 1, 0: 3, 389: 2, 390: 2, 400: 2, 399: 3, 19: 2, 281: 3, 45: 2, 56: 2, 185: 2, 192: 2, 322: 2, 66: 2, 196: 5, 197: 4, 337: 4, 380: 2, 255: 3} {0, 389, 390, 135, 142, 14, 400, 17, 399, 19, 149, 406, 279, 280, 281, 278, 294, 296, 45, 308, 56, 185, 192, 321, 322, 66, 196, 197, 324, 77, 78, 337, 216, 380, 255} 68 Layer 2. changes look good 9b5906939d7fc5f5c463322e3063c95e1ec9ac88 9b5906939d7fc5f5c463322e3063c95e1ec9ac88 draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework 97c985aeb00a2b45cdc26ddc7cc9e5e08475164523c7e555feb34c739c6a3ec7 ['b3713da5dc7b1531fd348079a30e2f5ac724e78c334f13dcd3da81aefb4a647d', '5d1ba8eea8ba53e9a9d0a6d166225ec30fafe99cff8f1aa38baf7ba9ff273aa6', 'cdc15b05d37b640ea4b7794cf9a229c6c28f8a1b7491f0460010ab5fcc44ff69', '652bfd8e78af5fb6764d1cd3c06e0842d2b7be3658a25654db9db79dcf0dc03c', 'b8d8f64f0f09d4c8fa40ff054a5f0e468afa79876dab10bea529c2c1e1430fbc', '58925b1ef76bb083d7d886d21f9aa7fc2143a26177ca339c06f960bc8c37c866', 'c2a31a816fad375f9df24bfcd3a1baa2c591de01e6733384a2811b4fd944d8ef', '34f6582bd92afa345dc5dcd62ba8f25eef20bd51d1919d3bde053a8ab6747c41', '8a9f636b1cdab856d1233a7a3cfa4bc0e99b49da4ac574e376b09f10f4f341e9', 'b5e2c587228a4238fbc26703235a5c512628fc7011c15e8d9bb25b28cbb1de10', '09f6b6a812132eee463de5625d44082094351e5e01c90e0e4dc14d2893ef6a38', '45bc601f4e7c8b80cc0c429fc5273808e88ddf7f6b0c7053a4c557e2c279a10d', '539441e88ca7396e33d2f25233286cf28b38761225330959445669581bd22411', '0af69069e9963489a014eb853d2a6ecda9ae7da34113cf3389c1167163e82dcf', '44be41afed3494e0381ae1126c4bb4f4f2977a0e1a01591ebd945f08460f1d1b', 'bb194dc58a0eb7e52501603ff614fb1131422ca453ab5b879033dd20511649fb', '2cb2fafbc456d565a9a6271284cb082c73a12c678dbaca52fa4304dd16824479', '18586b4a34af8afb3b19ff32c04e0b7b2f961021e15338b0a5a3ccafbea3e89f', '5da7ebc4953e83090f06af6e486dc3a244576cd2b94ec353133be3ced3251dcd', 'b44b885a406cb9ec036bed7a2f808cd599fef92864f4ac305f6309a2fb37cb4d', 'fcbb4b68ae78c4ce9cca6d03e0f62a1b8515b67ad1bc512e0d4857a6b428fb55', '97c985aeb00a2b45cdc26ddc7cc9e5e08475164523c7e555feb34c739c6a3ec7'] A layer 2. {64: 1, 37: 1, 91: 1, 55: 1, 112: 1, 38: 1, 33: 1, 79: 1, 52: 1, 25: 1, 51: 1, 69: 1, 130: 3, 62: 2, 67: 2, 53: 2, 80: 2, 127: 4} {14: 1, 17: 1, 77: 1, 78: 1, 135: 1, 142: 1, 149: 1, 216: 1, 278: 1, 280: 1, 321: 1, 324: 1, 294: 1, 296: 1, 308: 1, 406: 1, 0: 3, 389: 2, 390: 2, 400: 2, 399: 3, 19: 2, 281: 3, 45: 2, 56: 2, 185: 2, 192: 2, 322: 2, 66: 2, 196: 5, 197: 4, 337: 4, 380: 2, 255: 3} {0, 389, 390, 135, 142, 14, 400, 17, 399, 19, 149, 406, 279, 280, 281, 278, 294, 296, 45, 308, 56, 185, 192, 321, 322, 66, 196, 197, 324, 77, 78, 337, 216, 380, 255} 68 Label Switching Router. changes look good 9b5906939d7fc5f5c463322e3063c95e1ec9ac88 9b5906939d7fc5f5c463322e3063c95e1ec9ac88 draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework b3713da5dc7b1531fd348079a30e2f5ac724e78c334f13dcd3da81aefb4a647d ['b3713da5dc7b1531fd348079a30e2f5ac724e78c334f13dcd3da81aefb4a647d', '5d1ba8eea8ba53e9a9d0a6d166225ec30fafe99cff8f1aa38baf7ba9ff273aa6', 'cdc15b05d37b640ea4b7794cf9a229c6c28f8a1b7491f0460010ab5fcc44ff69', '652bfd8e78af5fb6764d1cd3c06e0842d2b7be3658a25654db9db79dcf0dc03c', 'b8d8f64f0f09d4c8fa40ff054a5f0e468afa79876dab10bea529c2c1e1430fbc', '58925b1ef76bb083d7d886d21f9aa7fc2143a26177ca339c06f960bc8c37c866', 'c2a31a816fad375f9df24bfcd3a1baa2c591de01e6733384a2811b4fd944d8ef', '34f6582bd92afa345dc5dcd62ba8f25eef20bd51d1919d3bde053a8ab6747c41', '8a9f636b1cdab856d1233a7a3cfa4bc0e99b49da4ac574e376b09f10f4f341e9', 'b5e2c587228a4238fbc26703235a5c512628fc7011c15e8d9bb25b28cbb1de10', '09f6b6a812132eee463de5625d44082094351e5e01c90e0e4dc14d2893ef6a38', '45bc601f4e7c8b80cc0c429fc5273808e88ddf7f6b0c7053a4c557e2c279a10d', '539441e88ca7396e33d2f25233286cf28b38761225330959445669581bd22411', '0af69069e9963489a014eb853d2a6ecda9ae7da34113cf3389c1167163e82dcf', '44be41afed3494e0381ae1126c4bb4f4f2977a0e1a01591ebd945f08460f1d1b', 'bb194dc58a0eb7e52501603ff614fb1131422ca453ab5b879033dd20511649fb', '2cb2fafbc456d565a9a6271284cb082c73a12c678dbaca52fa4304dd16824479', '18586b4a34af8afb3b19ff32c04e0b7b2f961021e15338b0a5a3ccafbea3e89f', '5da7ebc4953e83090f06af6e486dc3a244576cd2b94ec353133be3ced3251dcd', 'b44b885a406cb9ec036bed7a2f808cd599fef92864f4ac305f6309a2fb37cb4d', 'fcbb4b68ae78c4ce9cca6d03e0f62a1b8515b67ad1bc512e0d4857a6b428fb55', '97c985aeb00a2b45cdc26ddc7cc9e5e08475164523c7e555feb34c739c6a3ec7'] A label switching router. {64: 1, 37: 1, 91: 1, 55: 1, 112: 1, 38: 1, 33: 1, 79: 1, 52: 1, 25: 1, 51: 1, 69: 1, 130: 3, 62: 2, 67: 2, 53: 2, 80: 2, 127: 4} {14: 1, 17: 1, 77: 1, 78: 1, 135: 1, 142: 1, 149: 1, 216: 1, 278: 1, 280: 1, 321: 1, 324: 1, 294: 1, 296: 1, 308: 1, 406: 1, 0: 3, 389: 2, 390: 2, 400: 2, 399: 3, 19: 2, 281: 3, 45: 2, 56: 2, 185: 2, 192: 2, 322: 2, 66: 2, 196: 5, 197: 4, 337: 4, 380: 2, 255: 3} {0, 389, 390, 135, 142, 14, 400, 17, 399, 19, 149, 406, 279, 280, 281, 278, 294, 296, 45, 308, 56, 185, 192, 321, 322, 66, 196, 197, 324, 77, 78, 337, 216, 380, 255} 68 Multiprotocol Label Switching. changes look good 9b5906939d7fc5f5c463322e3063c95e1ec9ac88 9b5906939d7fc5f5c463322e3063c95e1ec9ac88 draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework 5d1ba8eea8ba53e9a9d0a6d166225ec30fafe99cff8f1aa38baf7ba9ff273aa6 ['b3713da5dc7b1531fd348079a30e2f5ac724e78c334f13dcd3da81aefb4a647d', '5d1ba8eea8ba53e9a9d0a6d166225ec30fafe99cff8f1aa38baf7ba9ff273aa6', 'cdc15b05d37b640ea4b7794cf9a229c6c28f8a1b7491f0460010ab5fcc44ff69', '652bfd8e78af5fb6764d1cd3c06e0842d2b7be3658a25654db9db79dcf0dc03c', 'b8d8f64f0f09d4c8fa40ff054a5f0e468afa79876dab10bea529c2c1e1430fbc', '58925b1ef76bb083d7d886d21f9aa7fc2143a26177ca339c06f960bc8c37c866', 'c2a31a816fad375f9df24bfcd3a1baa2c591de01e6733384a2811b4fd944d8ef', '34f6582bd92afa345dc5dcd62ba8f25eef20bd51d1919d3bde053a8ab6747c41', '8a9f636b1cdab856d1233a7a3cfa4bc0e99b49da4ac574e376b09f10f4f341e9', 'b5e2c587228a4238fbc26703235a5c512628fc7011c15e8d9bb25b28cbb1de10', '09f6b6a812132eee463de5625d44082094351e5e01c90e0e4dc14d2893ef6a38', '45bc601f4e7c8b80cc0c429fc5273808e88ddf7f6b0c7053a4c557e2c279a10d', '539441e88ca7396e33d2f25233286cf28b38761225330959445669581bd22411', '0af69069e9963489a014eb853d2a6ecda9ae7da34113cf3389c1167163e82dcf', '44be41afed3494e0381ae1126c4bb4f4f2977a0e1a01591ebd945f08460f1d1b', 'bb194dc58a0eb7e52501603ff614fb1131422ca453ab5b879033dd20511649fb', '2cb2fafbc456d565a9a6271284cb082c73a12c678dbaca52fa4304dd16824479', '18586b4a34af8afb3b19ff32c04e0b7b2f961021e15338b0a5a3ccafbea3e89f', '5da7ebc4953e83090f06af6e486dc3a244576cd2b94ec353133be3ced3251dcd', 'b44b885a406cb9ec036bed7a2f808cd599fef92864f4ac305f6309a2fb37cb4d', 'fcbb4b68ae78c4ce9cca6d03e0f62a1b8515b67ad1bc512e0d4857a6b428fb55', '97c985aeb00a2b45cdc26ddc7cc9e5e08475164523c7e555feb34c739c6a3ec7'] A multiprotocol label switching. {64: 1, 37: 1, 91: 1, 55: 1, 112: 1, 38: 1, 33: 1, 79: 1, 52: 1, 25: 1, 51: 1, 69: 1, 130: 3, 62: 2, 67: 2, 53: 2, 80: 2, 127: 4} {14: 1, 17: 1, 77: 1, 78: 1, 135: 1, 142: 1, 149: 1, 216: 1, 278: 1, 280: 1, 321: 1, 324: 1, 294: 1, 296: 1, 308: 1, 406: 1, 0: 3, 389: 2, 390: 2, 400: 2, 399: 3, 19: 2, 281: 3, 45: 2, 56: 2, 185: 2, 192: 2, 322: 2, 66: 2, 196: 5, 197: 4, 337: 4, 380: 2, 255: 3} {0, 389, 390, 135, 142, 14, 400, 17, 399, 19, 149, 406, 279, 280, 281, 278, 294, 296, 45, 308, 56, 185, 192, 321, 322, 66, 196, 197, 324, 77, 78, 337, 216, 380, 255} 68 Multiprotocol Label Switching - Traffic Engineering. changes look good 9b5906939d7fc5f5c463322e3063c95e1ec9ac88 9b5906939d7fc5f5c463322e3063c95e1ec9ac88 draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework b8d8f64f0f09d4c8fa40ff054a5f0e468afa79876dab10bea529c2c1e1430fbc ['b3713da5dc7b1531fd348079a30e2f5ac724e78c334f13dcd3da81aefb4a647d', '5d1ba8eea8ba53e9a9d0a6d166225ec30fafe99cff8f1aa38baf7ba9ff273aa6', 'cdc15b05d37b640ea4b7794cf9a229c6c28f8a1b7491f0460010ab5fcc44ff69', '652bfd8e78af5fb6764d1cd3c06e0842d2b7be3658a25654db9db79dcf0dc03c', 'b8d8f64f0f09d4c8fa40ff054a5f0e468afa79876dab10bea529c2c1e1430fbc', '58925b1ef76bb083d7d886d21f9aa7fc2143a26177ca339c06f960bc8c37c866', 'c2a31a816fad375f9df24bfcd3a1baa2c591de01e6733384a2811b4fd944d8ef', '34f6582bd92afa345dc5dcd62ba8f25eef20bd51d1919d3bde053a8ab6747c41', '8a9f636b1cdab856d1233a7a3cfa4bc0e99b49da4ac574e376b09f10f4f341e9', 'b5e2c587228a4238fbc26703235a5c512628fc7011c15e8d9bb25b28cbb1de10', '09f6b6a812132eee463de5625d44082094351e5e01c90e0e4dc14d2893ef6a38', '45bc601f4e7c8b80cc0c429fc5273808e88ddf7f6b0c7053a4c557e2c279a10d', '539441e88ca7396e33d2f25233286cf28b38761225330959445669581bd22411', '0af69069e9963489a014eb853d2a6ecda9ae7da34113cf3389c1167163e82dcf', '44be41afed3494e0381ae1126c4bb4f4f2977a0e1a01591ebd945f08460f1d1b', 'bb194dc58a0eb7e52501603ff614fb1131422ca453ab5b879033dd20511649fb', '2cb2fafbc456d565a9a6271284cb082c73a12c678dbaca52fa4304dd16824479', '18586b4a34af8afb3b19ff32c04e0b7b2f961021e15338b0a5a3ccafbea3e89f', '5da7ebc4953e83090f06af6e486dc3a244576cd2b94ec353133be3ced3251dcd', 'b44b885a406cb9ec036bed7a2f808cd599fef92864f4ac305f6309a2fb37cb4d', 'fcbb4b68ae78c4ce9cca6d03e0f62a1b8515b67ad1bc512e0d4857a6b428fb55', '97c985aeb00a2b45cdc26ddc7cc9e5e08475164523c7e555feb34c739c6a3ec7'] A multiprotocol label switching - traffic engineering. {64: 1, 37: 1, 91: 1, 55: 1, 112: 1, 38: 1, 33: 1, 79: 1, 52: 1, 25: 1, 51: 1, 69: 1, 130: 3, 62: 2, 67: 2, 53: 2, 80: 2, 127: 4} {14: 1, 17: 1, 77: 1, 78: 1, 135: 1, 142: 1, 149: 1, 216: 1, 278: 1, 280: 1, 321: 1, 324: 1, 294: 1, 296: 1, 308: 1, 406: 1, 0: 3, 389: 2, 390: 2, 400: 2, 399: 3, 19: 2, 281: 3, 45: 2, 56: 2, 185: 2, 192: 2, 322: 2, 66: 2, 196: 5, 197: 4, 337: 4, 380: 2, 255: 3} {0, 389, 390, 135, 142, 14, 400, 17, 399, 19, 149, 406, 279, 280, 281, 278, 294, 296, 45, 308, 56, 185, 192, 321, 322, 66, 196, 197, 324, 77, 78, 337, 216, 380, 255} 68 Operations, Administration, and Maintenance. changes look good 9b5906939d7fc5f5c463322e3063c95e1ec9ac88 9b5906939d7fc5f5c463322e3063c95e1ec9ac88 draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework bb194dc58a0eb7e52501603ff614fb1131422ca453ab5b879033dd20511649fb ['b3713da5dc7b1531fd348079a30e2f5ac724e78c334f13dcd3da81aefb4a647d', '5d1ba8eea8ba53e9a9d0a6d166225ec30fafe99cff8f1aa38baf7ba9ff273aa6', 'cdc15b05d37b640ea4b7794cf9a229c6c28f8a1b7491f0460010ab5fcc44ff69', '652bfd8e78af5fb6764d1cd3c06e0842d2b7be3658a25654db9db79dcf0dc03c', 'b8d8f64f0f09d4c8fa40ff054a5f0e468afa79876dab10bea529c2c1e1430fbc', '58925b1ef76bb083d7d886d21f9aa7fc2143a26177ca339c06f960bc8c37c866', 'c2a31a816fad375f9df24bfcd3a1baa2c591de01e6733384a2811b4fd944d8ef', '34f6582bd92afa345dc5dcd62ba8f25eef20bd51d1919d3bde053a8ab6747c41', '8a9f636b1cdab856d1233a7a3cfa4bc0e99b49da4ac574e376b09f10f4f341e9', 'b5e2c587228a4238fbc26703235a5c512628fc7011c15e8d9bb25b28cbb1de10', '09f6b6a812132eee463de5625d44082094351e5e01c90e0e4dc14d2893ef6a38', '45bc601f4e7c8b80cc0c429fc5273808e88ddf7f6b0c7053a4c557e2c279a10d', '539441e88ca7396e33d2f25233286cf28b38761225330959445669581bd22411', '0af69069e9963489a014eb853d2a6ecda9ae7da34113cf3389c1167163e82dcf', '44be41afed3494e0381ae1126c4bb4f4f2977a0e1a01591ebd945f08460f1d1b', 'bb194dc58a0eb7e52501603ff614fb1131422ca453ab5b879033dd20511649fb', '2cb2fafbc456d565a9a6271284cb082c73a12c678dbaca52fa4304dd16824479', '18586b4a34af8afb3b19ff32c04e0b7b2f961021e15338b0a5a3ccafbea3e89f', '5da7ebc4953e83090f06af6e486dc3a244576cd2b94ec353133be3ced3251dcd', 'b44b885a406cb9ec036bed7a2f808cd599fef92864f4ac305f6309a2fb37cb4d', 'fcbb4b68ae78c4ce9cca6d03e0f62a1b8515b67ad1bc512e0d4857a6b428fb55', '97c985aeb00a2b45cdc26ddc7cc9e5e08475164523c7e555feb34c739c6a3ec7'] A operations, administration, and maintenance. {64: 1, 37: 1, 91: 1, 55: 1, 112: 1, 38: 1, 33: 1, 79: 1, 52: 1, 25: 1, 51: 1, 69: 1, 130: 3, 62: 2, 67: 2, 53: 2, 80: 2, 127: 4} {14: 1, 17: 1, 77: 1, 78: 1, 135: 1, 142: 1, 149: 1, 216: 1, 278: 1, 280: 1, 321: 1, 324: 1, 294: 1, 296: 1, 308: 1, 406: 1, 0: 3, 389: 2, 390: 2, 400: 2, 399: 3, 19: 2, 281: 3, 45: 2, 56: 2, 185: 2, 192: 2, 322: 2, 66: 2, 196: 5, 197: 4, 337: 4, 380: 2, 255: 3} {0, 389, 390, 135, 142, 14, 400, 17, 399, 19, 149, 406, 279, 280, 281, 278, 294, 296, 45, 308, 56, 185, 192, 321, 322, 66, 196, 197, 324, 77, 78, 337, 216, 380, 255} 68 Packet Elimination Function. changes look good 9b5906939d7fc5f5c463322e3063c95e1ec9ac88 9b5906939d7fc5f5c463322e3063c95e1ec9ac88 draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework 18586b4a34af8afb3b19ff32c04e0b7b2f961021e15338b0a5a3ccafbea3e89f ['b3713da5dc7b1531fd348079a30e2f5ac724e78c334f13dcd3da81aefb4a647d', '5d1ba8eea8ba53e9a9d0a6d166225ec30fafe99cff8f1aa38baf7ba9ff273aa6', 'cdc15b05d37b640ea4b7794cf9a229c6c28f8a1b7491f0460010ab5fcc44ff69', '652bfd8e78af5fb6764d1cd3c06e0842d2b7be3658a25654db9db79dcf0dc03c', 'b8d8f64f0f09d4c8fa40ff054a5f0e468afa79876dab10bea529c2c1e1430fbc', '58925b1ef76bb083d7d886d21f9aa7fc2143a26177ca339c06f960bc8c37c866', 'c2a31a816fad375f9df24bfcd3a1baa2c591de01e6733384a2811b4fd944d8ef', '34f6582bd92afa345dc5dcd62ba8f25eef20bd51d1919d3bde053a8ab6747c41', '8a9f636b1cdab856d1233a7a3cfa4bc0e99b49da4ac574e376b09f10f4f341e9', 'b5e2c587228a4238fbc26703235a5c512628fc7011c15e8d9bb25b28cbb1de10', '09f6b6a812132eee463de5625d44082094351e5e01c90e0e4dc14d2893ef6a38', '45bc601f4e7c8b80cc0c429fc5273808e88ddf7f6b0c7053a4c557e2c279a10d', '539441e88ca7396e33d2f25233286cf28b38761225330959445669581bd22411', '0af69069e9963489a014eb853d2a6ecda9ae7da34113cf3389c1167163e82dcf', '44be41afed3494e0381ae1126c4bb4f4f2977a0e1a01591ebd945f08460f1d1b', 'bb194dc58a0eb7e52501603ff614fb1131422ca453ab5b879033dd20511649fb', '2cb2fafbc456d565a9a6271284cb082c73a12c678dbaca52fa4304dd16824479', '18586b4a34af8afb3b19ff32c04e0b7b2f961021e15338b0a5a3ccafbea3e89f', '5da7ebc4953e83090f06af6e486dc3a244576cd2b94ec353133be3ced3251dcd', 'b44b885a406cb9ec036bed7a2f808cd599fef92864f4ac305f6309a2fb37cb4d', 'fcbb4b68ae78c4ce9cca6d03e0f62a1b8515b67ad1bc512e0d4857a6b428fb55', '97c985aeb00a2b45cdc26ddc7cc9e5e08475164523c7e555feb34c739c6a3ec7'] A packet elimination function. {64: 1, 37: 1, 91: 1, 55: 1, 112: 1, 38: 1, 33: 1, 79: 1, 52: 1, 25: 1, 51: 1, 69: 1, 130: 3, 62: 2, 67: 2, 53: 2, 80: 2, 127: 4} {14: 1, 17: 1, 77: 1, 78: 1, 135: 1, 142: 1, 149: 1, 216: 1, 278: 1, 280: 1, 321: 1, 324: 1, 294: 1, 296: 1, 308: 1, 406: 1, 0: 3, 389: 2, 390: 2, 400: 2, 399: 3, 19: 2, 281: 3, 45: 2, 56: 2, 185: 2, 192: 2, 322: 2, 66: 2, 196: 5, 197: 4, 337: 4, 380: 2, 255: 3} {0, 389, 390, 135, 142, 14, 400, 17, 399, 19, 149, 406, 279, 280, 281, 278, 294, 296, 45, 308, 56, 185, 192, 321, 322, 66, 196, 197, 324, 77, 78, 337, 216, 380, 255} 68 Packet Replication Function. changes look good 9b5906939d7fc5f5c463322e3063c95e1ec9ac88 9b5906939d7fc5f5c463322e3063c95e1ec9ac88 draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework fcbb4b68ae78c4ce9cca6d03e0f62a1b8515b67ad1bc512e0d4857a6b428fb55 ['b3713da5dc7b1531fd348079a30e2f5ac724e78c334f13dcd3da81aefb4a647d', '5d1ba8eea8ba53e9a9d0a6d166225ec30fafe99cff8f1aa38baf7ba9ff273aa6', 'cdc15b05d37b640ea4b7794cf9a229c6c28f8a1b7491f0460010ab5fcc44ff69', '652bfd8e78af5fb6764d1cd3c06e0842d2b7be3658a25654db9db79dcf0dc03c', 'b8d8f64f0f09d4c8fa40ff054a5f0e468afa79876dab10bea529c2c1e1430fbc', '58925b1ef76bb083d7d886d21f9aa7fc2143a26177ca339c06f960bc8c37c866', 'c2a31a816fad375f9df24bfcd3a1baa2c591de01e6733384a2811b4fd944d8ef', '34f6582bd92afa345dc5dcd62ba8f25eef20bd51d1919d3bde053a8ab6747c41', '8a9f636b1cdab856d1233a7a3cfa4bc0e99b49da4ac574e376b09f10f4f341e9', 'b5e2c587228a4238fbc26703235a5c512628fc7011c15e8d9bb25b28cbb1de10', '09f6b6a812132eee463de5625d44082094351e5e01c90e0e4dc14d2893ef6a38', '45bc601f4e7c8b80cc0c429fc5273808e88ddf7f6b0c7053a4c557e2c279a10d', '539441e88ca7396e33d2f25233286cf28b38761225330959445669581bd22411', '0af69069e9963489a014eb853d2a6ecda9ae7da34113cf3389c1167163e82dcf', '44be41afed3494e0381ae1126c4bb4f4f2977a0e1a01591ebd945f08460f1d1b', 'bb194dc58a0eb7e52501603ff614fb1131422ca453ab5b879033dd20511649fb', '2cb2fafbc456d565a9a6271284cb082c73a12c678dbaca52fa4304dd16824479', '18586b4a34af8afb3b19ff32c04e0b7b2f961021e15338b0a5a3ccafbea3e89f', '5da7ebc4953e83090f06af6e486dc3a244576cd2b94ec353133be3ced3251dcd', 'b44b885a406cb9ec036bed7a2f808cd599fef92864f4ac305f6309a2fb37cb4d', 'fcbb4b68ae78c4ce9cca6d03e0f62a1b8515b67ad1bc512e0d4857a6b428fb55', '97c985aeb00a2b45cdc26ddc7cc9e5e08475164523c7e555feb34c739c6a3ec7'] A packet replication function. {64: 1, 37: 1, 91: 1, 55: 1, 112: 1, 38: 1, 33: 1, 79: 1, 52: 1, 25: 1, 51: 1, 69: 1, 130: 3, 62: 2, 67: 2, 53: 2, 80: 2, 127: 4} {14: 1, 17: 1, 77: 1, 78: 1, 135: 1, 142: 1, 149: 1, 216: 1, 278: 1, 280: 1, 321: 1, 324: 1, 294: 1, 296: 1, 308: 1, 406: 1, 0: 3, 389: 2, 390: 2, 400: 2, 399: 3, 19: 2, 281: 3, 45: 2, 56: 2, 185: 2, 192: 2, 322: 2, 66: 2, 196: 5, 197: 4, 337: 4, 380: 2, 255: 3} {0, 389, 390, 135, 142, 14, 400, 17, 399, 19, 149, 406, 279, 280, 281, 278, 294, 296, 45, 308, 56, 185, 192, 321, 322, 66, 196, 197, 324, 77, 78, 337, 216, 380, 255} 68 Packet Replication, Elimination and Ordering Functions. changes look good 9b5906939d7fc5f5c463322e3063c95e1ec9ac88 9b5906939d7fc5f5c463322e3063c95e1ec9ac88 draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework cdc15b05d37b640ea4b7794cf9a229c6c28f8a1b7491f0460010ab5fcc44ff69 ['b3713da5dc7b1531fd348079a30e2f5ac724e78c334f13dcd3da81aefb4a647d', '5d1ba8eea8ba53e9a9d0a6d166225ec30fafe99cff8f1aa38baf7ba9ff273aa6', 'cdc15b05d37b640ea4b7794cf9a229c6c28f8a1b7491f0460010ab5fcc44ff69', '652bfd8e78af5fb6764d1cd3c06e0842d2b7be3658a25654db9db79dcf0dc03c', 'b8d8f64f0f09d4c8fa40ff054a5f0e468afa79876dab10bea529c2c1e1430fbc', '58925b1ef76bb083d7d886d21f9aa7fc2143a26177ca339c06f960bc8c37c866', 'c2a31a816fad375f9df24bfcd3a1baa2c591de01e6733384a2811b4fd944d8ef', '34f6582bd92afa345dc5dcd62ba8f25eef20bd51d1919d3bde053a8ab6747c41', '8a9f636b1cdab856d1233a7a3cfa4bc0e99b49da4ac574e376b09f10f4f341e9', 'b5e2c587228a4238fbc26703235a5c512628fc7011c15e8d9bb25b28cbb1de10', '09f6b6a812132eee463de5625d44082094351e5e01c90e0e4dc14d2893ef6a38', '45bc601f4e7c8b80cc0c429fc5273808e88ddf7f6b0c7053a4c557e2c279a10d', '539441e88ca7396e33d2f25233286cf28b38761225330959445669581bd22411', '0af69069e9963489a014eb853d2a6ecda9ae7da34113cf3389c1167163e82dcf', '44be41afed3494e0381ae1126c4bb4f4f2977a0e1a01591ebd945f08460f1d1b', 'bb194dc58a0eb7e52501603ff614fb1131422ca453ab5b879033dd20511649fb', '2cb2fafbc456d565a9a6271284cb082c73a12c678dbaca52fa4304dd16824479', '18586b4a34af8afb3b19ff32c04e0b7b2f961021e15338b0a5a3ccafbea3e89f', '5da7ebc4953e83090f06af6e486dc3a244576cd2b94ec353133be3ced3251dcd', 'b44b885a406cb9ec036bed7a2f808cd599fef92864f4ac305f6309a2fb37cb4d', 'fcbb4b68ae78c4ce9cca6d03e0f62a1b8515b67ad1bc512e0d4857a6b428fb55', '97c985aeb00a2b45cdc26ddc7cc9e5e08475164523c7e555feb34c739c6a3ec7'] A packet replication, elimination and ordering functions. {64: 1, 37: 1, 91: 1, 55: 1, 112: 1, 38: 1, 33: 1, 79: 1, 52: 1, 25: 1, 51: 1, 69: 1, 130: 3, 62: 2, 67: 2, 53: 2, 80: 2, 127: 4} {14: 1, 17: 1, 77: 1, 78: 1, 135: 1, 142: 1, 149: 1, 216: 1, 278: 1, 280: 1, 321: 1, 324: 1, 294: 1, 296: 1, 308: 1, 406: 1, 0: 3, 389: 2, 390: 2, 400: 2, 399: 3, 19: 2, 281: 3, 45: 2, 56: 2, 185: 2, 192: 2, 322: 2, 66: 2, 196: 5, 197: 4, 337: 4, 380: 2, 255: 3} {0, 389, 390, 135, 142, 14, 400, 17, 399, 19, 149, 406, 279, 280, 281, 278, 294, 296, 45, 308, 56, 185, 192, 321, 322, 66, 196, 197, 324, 77, 78, 337, 216, 380, 255} 68 Packet Ordering Function. changes look good 9b5906939d7fc5f5c463322e3063c95e1ec9ac88 9b5906939d7fc5f5c463322e3063c95e1ec9ac88 draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework 45bc601f4e7c8b80cc0c429fc5273808e88ddf7f6b0c7053a4c557e2c279a10d ['b3713da5dc7b1531fd348079a30e2f5ac724e78c334f13dcd3da81aefb4a647d', '5d1ba8eea8ba53e9a9d0a6d166225ec30fafe99cff8f1aa38baf7ba9ff273aa6', 'cdc15b05d37b640ea4b7794cf9a229c6c28f8a1b7491f0460010ab5fcc44ff69', '652bfd8e78af5fb6764d1cd3c06e0842d2b7be3658a25654db9db79dcf0dc03c', 'b8d8f64f0f09d4c8fa40ff054a5f0e468afa79876dab10bea529c2c1e1430fbc', '58925b1ef76bb083d7d886d21f9aa7fc2143a26177ca339c06f960bc8c37c866', 'c2a31a816fad375f9df24bfcd3a1baa2c591de01e6733384a2811b4fd944d8ef', '34f6582bd92afa345dc5dcd62ba8f25eef20bd51d1919d3bde053a8ab6747c41', '8a9f636b1cdab856d1233a7a3cfa4bc0e99b49da4ac574e376b09f10f4f341e9', 'b5e2c587228a4238fbc26703235a5c512628fc7011c15e8d9bb25b28cbb1de10', '09f6b6a812132eee463de5625d44082094351e5e01c90e0e4dc14d2893ef6a38', '45bc601f4e7c8b80cc0c429fc5273808e88ddf7f6b0c7053a4c557e2c279a10d', '539441e88ca7396e33d2f25233286cf28b38761225330959445669581bd22411', '0af69069e9963489a014eb853d2a6ecda9ae7da34113cf3389c1167163e82dcf', '44be41afed3494e0381ae1126c4bb4f4f2977a0e1a01591ebd945f08460f1d1b', 'bb194dc58a0eb7e52501603ff614fb1131422ca453ab5b879033dd20511649fb', '2cb2fafbc456d565a9a6271284cb082c73a12c678dbaca52fa4304dd16824479', '18586b4a34af8afb3b19ff32c04e0b7b2f961021e15338b0a5a3ccafbea3e89f', '5da7ebc4953e83090f06af6e486dc3a244576cd2b94ec353133be3ced3251dcd', 'b44b885a406cb9ec036bed7a2f808cd599fef92864f4ac305f6309a2fb37cb4d', 'fcbb4b68ae78c4ce9cca6d03e0f62a1b8515b67ad1bc512e0d4857a6b428fb55', '97c985aeb00a2b45cdc26ddc7cc9e5e08475164523c7e555feb34c739c6a3ec7'] A packet ordering function. {64: 1, 37: 1, 91: 1, 55: 1, 112: 1, 38: 1, 33: 1, 79: 1, 52: 1, 25: 1, 51: 1, 69: 1, 130: 3, 62: 2, 67: 2, 53: 2, 80: 2, 127: 4} {14: 1, 17: 1, 77: 1, 78: 1, 135: 1, 142: 1, 149: 1, 216: 1, 278: 1, 280: 1, 321: 1, 324: 1, 294: 1, 296: 1, 308: 1, 406: 1, 0: 3, 389: 2, 390: 2, 400: 2, 399: 3, 19: 2, 281: 3, 45: 2, 56: 2, 185: 2, 192: 2, 322: 2, 66: 2, 196: 5, 197: 4, 337: 4, 380: 2, 255: 3} {0, 389, 390, 135, 142, 14, 400, 17, 399, 19, 149, 406, 279, 280, 281, 278, 294, 296, 45, 308, 56, 185, 192, 321, 322, 66, 196, 197, 324, 77, 78, 337, 216, 380, 255} 68 Packet Switched Network. changes look good 9b5906939d7fc5f5c463322e3063c95e1ec9ac88 9b5906939d7fc5f5c463322e3063c95e1ec9ac88 draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework b44b885a406cb9ec036bed7a2f808cd599fef92864f4ac305f6309a2fb37cb4d ['b3713da5dc7b1531fd348079a30e2f5ac724e78c334f13dcd3da81aefb4a647d', '5d1ba8eea8ba53e9a9d0a6d166225ec30fafe99cff8f1aa38baf7ba9ff273aa6', 'cdc15b05d37b640ea4b7794cf9a229c6c28f8a1b7491f0460010ab5fcc44ff69', '652bfd8e78af5fb6764d1cd3c06e0842d2b7be3658a25654db9db79dcf0dc03c', 'b8d8f64f0f09d4c8fa40ff054a5f0e468afa79876dab10bea529c2c1e1430fbc', '58925b1ef76bb083d7d886d21f9aa7fc2143a26177ca339c06f960bc8c37c866', 'c2a31a816fad375f9df24bfcd3a1baa2c591de01e6733384a2811b4fd944d8ef', '34f6582bd92afa345dc5dcd62ba8f25eef20bd51d1919d3bde053a8ab6747c41', '8a9f636b1cdab856d1233a7a3cfa4bc0e99b49da4ac574e376b09f10f4f341e9', 'b5e2c587228a4238fbc26703235a5c512628fc7011c15e8d9bb25b28cbb1de10', '09f6b6a812132eee463de5625d44082094351e5e01c90e0e4dc14d2893ef6a38', '45bc601f4e7c8b80cc0c429fc5273808e88ddf7f6b0c7053a4c557e2c279a10d', '539441e88ca7396e33d2f25233286cf28b38761225330959445669581bd22411', '0af69069e9963489a014eb853d2a6ecda9ae7da34113cf3389c1167163e82dcf', '44be41afed3494e0381ae1126c4bb4f4f2977a0e1a01591ebd945f08460f1d1b', 'bb194dc58a0eb7e52501603ff614fb1131422ca453ab5b879033dd20511649fb', '2cb2fafbc456d565a9a6271284cb082c73a12c678dbaca52fa4304dd16824479', '18586b4a34af8afb3b19ff32c04e0b7b2f961021e15338b0a5a3ccafbea3e89f', '5da7ebc4953e83090f06af6e486dc3a244576cd2b94ec353133be3ced3251dcd', 'b44b885a406cb9ec036bed7a2f808cd599fef92864f4ac305f6309a2fb37cb4d', 'fcbb4b68ae78c4ce9cca6d03e0f62a1b8515b67ad1bc512e0d4857a6b428fb55', '97c985aeb00a2b45cdc26ddc7cc9e5e08475164523c7e555feb34c739c6a3ec7'] A packet switched network. {64: 1, 37: 1, 91: 1, 55: 1, 112: 1, 38: 1, 33: 1, 79: 1, 52: 1, 25: 1, 51: 1, 69: 1, 130: 3, 62: 2, 67: 2, 53: 2, 80: 2, 127: 4} {14: 1, 17: 1, 77: 1, 78: 1, 135: 1, 142: 1, 149: 1, 216: 1, 278: 1, 280: 1, 321: 1, 324: 1, 294: 1, 296: 1, 308: 1, 406: 1, 0: 3, 389: 2, 390: 2, 400: 2, 399: 3, 19: 2, 281: 3, 45: 2, 56: 2, 185: 2, 192: 2, 322: 2, 66: 2, 196: 5, 197: 4, 337: 4, 380: 2, 255: 3} {0, 389, 390, 135, 142, 14, 400, 17, 399, 19, 149, 406, 279, 280, 281, 278, 294, 296, 45, 308, 56, 185, 192, 321, 322, 66, 196, 197, 324, 77, 78, 337, 216, 380, 255} 68 PseudoWire. changes look good 9b5906939d7fc5f5c463322e3063c95e1ec9ac88 9b5906939d7fc5f5c463322e3063c95e1ec9ac88 draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework 5da7ebc4953e83090f06af6e486dc3a244576cd2b94ec353133be3ced3251dcd ['b3713da5dc7b1531fd348079a30e2f5ac724e78c334f13dcd3da81aefb4a647d', '5d1ba8eea8ba53e9a9d0a6d166225ec30fafe99cff8f1aa38baf7ba9ff273aa6', 'cdc15b05d37b640ea4b7794cf9a229c6c28f8a1b7491f0460010ab5fcc44ff69', '652bfd8e78af5fb6764d1cd3c06e0842d2b7be3658a25654db9db79dcf0dc03c', 'b8d8f64f0f09d4c8fa40ff054a5f0e468afa79876dab10bea529c2c1e1430fbc', '58925b1ef76bb083d7d886d21f9aa7fc2143a26177ca339c06f960bc8c37c866', 'c2a31a816fad375f9df24bfcd3a1baa2c591de01e6733384a2811b4fd944d8ef', '34f6582bd92afa345dc5dcd62ba8f25eef20bd51d1919d3bde053a8ab6747c41', '8a9f636b1cdab856d1233a7a3cfa4bc0e99b49da4ac574e376b09f10f4f341e9', 'b5e2c587228a4238fbc26703235a5c512628fc7011c15e8d9bb25b28cbb1de10', '09f6b6a812132eee463de5625d44082094351e5e01c90e0e4dc14d2893ef6a38', '45bc601f4e7c8b80cc0c429fc5273808e88ddf7f6b0c7053a4c557e2c279a10d', '539441e88ca7396e33d2f25233286cf28b38761225330959445669581bd22411', '0af69069e9963489a014eb853d2a6ecda9ae7da34113cf3389c1167163e82dcf', '44be41afed3494e0381ae1126c4bb4f4f2977a0e1a01591ebd945f08460f1d1b', 'bb194dc58a0eb7e52501603ff614fb1131422ca453ab5b879033dd20511649fb', '2cb2fafbc456d565a9a6271284cb082c73a12c678dbaca52fa4304dd16824479', '18586b4a34af8afb3b19ff32c04e0b7b2f961021e15338b0a5a3ccafbea3e89f', '5da7ebc4953e83090f06af6e486dc3a244576cd2b94ec353133be3ced3251dcd', 'b44b885a406cb9ec036bed7a2f808cd599fef92864f4ac305f6309a2fb37cb4d', 'fcbb4b68ae78c4ce9cca6d03e0f62a1b8515b67ad1bc512e0d4857a6b428fb55', '97c985aeb00a2b45cdc26ddc7cc9e5e08475164523c7e555feb34c739c6a3ec7'] A pseudowire. {64: 1, 37: 1, 91: 1, 55: 1, 112: 1, 38: 1, 33: 1, 79: 1, 52: 1, 25: 1, 51: 1, 69: 1, 130: 3, 62: 2, 67: 2, 53: 2, 80: 2, 127: 4} {14: 1, 17: 1, 77: 1, 78: 1, 135: 1, 142: 1, 149: 1, 216: 1, 278: 1, 280: 1, 321: 1, 324: 1, 294: 1, 296: 1, 308: 1, 406: 1, 0: 3, 389: 2, 390: 2, 400: 2, 399: 3, 19: 2, 281: 3, 45: 2, 56: 2, 185: 2, 192: 2, 322: 2, 66: 2, 196: 5, 197: 4, 337: 4, 380: 2, 255: 3} {0, 389, 390, 135, 142, 14, 400, 17, 399, 19, 149, 406, 279, 280, 281, 278, 294, 296, 45, 308, 56, 185, 192, 321, 322, 66, 196, 197, 324, 77, 78, 337, 216, 380, 255} 68 Quality of Service. changes look good 9b5906939d7fc5f5c463322e3063c95e1ec9ac88 9b5906939d7fc5f5c463322e3063c95e1ec9ac88 draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework 09f6b6a812132eee463de5625d44082094351e5e01c90e0e4dc14d2893ef6a38 ['b3713da5dc7b1531fd348079a30e2f5ac724e78c334f13dcd3da81aefb4a647d', '5d1ba8eea8ba53e9a9d0a6d166225ec30fafe99cff8f1aa38baf7ba9ff273aa6', 'cdc15b05d37b640ea4b7794cf9a229c6c28f8a1b7491f0460010ab5fcc44ff69', '652bfd8e78af5fb6764d1cd3c06e0842d2b7be3658a25654db9db79dcf0dc03c', 'b8d8f64f0f09d4c8fa40ff054a5f0e468afa79876dab10bea529c2c1e1430fbc', '58925b1ef76bb083d7d886d21f9aa7fc2143a26177ca339c06f960bc8c37c866', 'c2a31a816fad375f9df24bfcd3a1baa2c591de01e6733384a2811b4fd944d8ef', '34f6582bd92afa345dc5dcd62ba8f25eef20bd51d1919d3bde053a8ab6747c41', '8a9f636b1cdab856d1233a7a3cfa4bc0e99b49da4ac574e376b09f10f4f341e9', 'b5e2c587228a4238fbc26703235a5c512628fc7011c15e8d9bb25b28cbb1de10', '09f6b6a812132eee463de5625d44082094351e5e01c90e0e4dc14d2893ef6a38', '45bc601f4e7c8b80cc0c429fc5273808e88ddf7f6b0c7053a4c557e2c279a10d', '539441e88ca7396e33d2f25233286cf28b38761225330959445669581bd22411', '0af69069e9963489a014eb853d2a6ecda9ae7da34113cf3389c1167163e82dcf', '44be41afed3494e0381ae1126c4bb4f4f2977a0e1a01591ebd945f08460f1d1b', 'bb194dc58a0eb7e52501603ff614fb1131422ca453ab5b879033dd20511649fb', '2cb2fafbc456d565a9a6271284cb082c73a12c678dbaca52fa4304dd16824479', '18586b4a34af8afb3b19ff32c04e0b7b2f961021e15338b0a5a3ccafbea3e89f', '5da7ebc4953e83090f06af6e486dc3a244576cd2b94ec353133be3ced3251dcd', 'b44b885a406cb9ec036bed7a2f808cd599fef92864f4ac305f6309a2fb37cb4d', 'fcbb4b68ae78c4ce9cca6d03e0f62a1b8515b67ad1bc512e0d4857a6b428fb55', '97c985aeb00a2b45cdc26ddc7cc9e5e08475164523c7e555feb34c739c6a3ec7'] A quality of service. {64: 1, 37: 1, 91: 1, 55: 1, 112: 1, 38: 1, 33: 1, 79: 1, 52: 1, 25: 1, 51: 1, 69: 1, 130: 3, 62: 2, 67: 2, 53: 2, 80: 2, 127: 4} {14: 1, 17: 1, 77: 1, 78: 1, 135: 1, 142: 1, 149: 1, 216: 1, 278: 1, 280: 1, 321: 1, 324: 1, 294: 1, 296: 1, 308: 1, 406: 1, 0: 3, 389: 2, 390: 2, 400: 2, 399: 3, 19: 2, 281: 3, 45: 2, 56: 2, 185: 2, 192: 2, 322: 2, 66: 2, 196: 5, 197: 4, 337: 4, 380: 2, 255: 3} {0, 389, 390, 135, 142, 14, 400, 17, 399, 19, 149, 406, 279, 280, 281, 278, 294, 296, 45, 308, 56, 185, 192, 321, 322, 66, 196, 197, 324, 77, 78, 337, 216, 380, 255} 68 "DetNet ""service"" label." changes look good 9b5906939d7fc5f5c463322e3063c95e1ec9ac88 9b5906939d7fc5f5c463322e3063c95e1ec9ac88 draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework 34f6582bd92afa345dc5dcd62ba8f25eef20bd51d1919d3bde053a8ab6747c41 ['b3713da5dc7b1531fd348079a30e2f5ac724e78c334f13dcd3da81aefb4a647d', '5d1ba8eea8ba53e9a9d0a6d166225ec30fafe99cff8f1aa38baf7ba9ff273aa6', 'cdc15b05d37b640ea4b7794cf9a229c6c28f8a1b7491f0460010ab5fcc44ff69', '652bfd8e78af5fb6764d1cd3c06e0842d2b7be3658a25654db9db79dcf0dc03c', 'b8d8f64f0f09d4c8fa40ff054a5f0e468afa79876dab10bea529c2c1e1430fbc', '58925b1ef76bb083d7d886d21f9aa7fc2143a26177ca339c06f960bc8c37c866', 'c2a31a816fad375f9df24bfcd3a1baa2c591de01e6733384a2811b4fd944d8ef', '34f6582bd92afa345dc5dcd62ba8f25eef20bd51d1919d3bde053a8ab6747c41', '8a9f636b1cdab856d1233a7a3cfa4bc0e99b49da4ac574e376b09f10f4f341e9', 'b5e2c587228a4238fbc26703235a5c512628fc7011c15e8d9bb25b28cbb1de10', '09f6b6a812132eee463de5625d44082094351e5e01c90e0e4dc14d2893ef6a38', '45bc601f4e7c8b80cc0c429fc5273808e88ddf7f6b0c7053a4c557e2c279a10d', '539441e88ca7396e33d2f25233286cf28b38761225330959445669581bd22411', '0af69069e9963489a014eb853d2a6ecda9ae7da34113cf3389c1167163e82dcf', '44be41afed3494e0381ae1126c4bb4f4f2977a0e1a01591ebd945f08460f1d1b', 'bb194dc58a0eb7e52501603ff614fb1131422ca453ab5b879033dd20511649fb', '2cb2fafbc456d565a9a6271284cb082c73a12c678dbaca52fa4304dd16824479', '18586b4a34af8afb3b19ff32c04e0b7b2f961021e15338b0a5a3ccafbea3e89f', '5da7ebc4953e83090f06af6e486dc3a244576cd2b94ec353133be3ced3251dcd', 'b44b885a406cb9ec036bed7a2f808cd599fef92864f4ac305f6309a2fb37cb4d', 'fcbb4b68ae78c4ce9cca6d03e0f62a1b8515b67ad1bc512e0d4857a6b428fb55', '97c985aeb00a2b45cdc26ddc7cc9e5e08475164523c7e555feb34c739c6a3ec7'] A "detnet ""service"" label." {64: 1, 37: 1, 91: 1, 55: 1, 112: 1, 38: 1, 33: 1, 79: 1, 52: 1, 25: 1, 51: 1, 69: 1, 130: 3, 62: 2, 67: 2, 53: 2, 80: 2, 127: 4} {14: 1, 17: 1, 77: 1, 78: 1, 135: 1, 142: 1, 149: 1, 216: 1, 278: 1, 280: 1, 321: 1, 324: 1, 294: 1, 296: 1, 308: 1, 406: 1, 0: 3, 389: 2, 390: 2, 400: 2, 399: 3, 19: 2, 281: 3, 45: 2, 56: 2, 185: 2, 192: 2, 322: 2, 66: 2, 196: 5, 197: 4, 337: 4, 380: 2, 255: 3} {0, 389, 390, 135, 142, 14, 400, 17, 399, 19, 149, 406, 279, 280, 281, 278, 294, 296, 45, 308, 56, 185, 192, 321, 322, 66, 196, 197, 324, 77, 78, 337, 216, 380, 255} 68 Time-Division Multiplexing. changes look good 9b5906939d7fc5f5c463322e3063c95e1ec9ac88 9b5906939d7fc5f5c463322e3063c95e1ec9ac88 draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework b5e2c587228a4238fbc26703235a5c512628fc7011c15e8d9bb25b28cbb1de10 ['b3713da5dc7b1531fd348079a30e2f5ac724e78c334f13dcd3da81aefb4a647d', '5d1ba8eea8ba53e9a9d0a6d166225ec30fafe99cff8f1aa38baf7ba9ff273aa6', 'cdc15b05d37b640ea4b7794cf9a229c6c28f8a1b7491f0460010ab5fcc44ff69', '652bfd8e78af5fb6764d1cd3c06e0842d2b7be3658a25654db9db79dcf0dc03c', 'b8d8f64f0f09d4c8fa40ff054a5f0e468afa79876dab10bea529c2c1e1430fbc', '58925b1ef76bb083d7d886d21f9aa7fc2143a26177ca339c06f960bc8c37c866', 'c2a31a816fad375f9df24bfcd3a1baa2c591de01e6733384a2811b4fd944d8ef', '34f6582bd92afa345dc5dcd62ba8f25eef20bd51d1919d3bde053a8ab6747c41', '8a9f636b1cdab856d1233a7a3cfa4bc0e99b49da4ac574e376b09f10f4f341e9', 'b5e2c587228a4238fbc26703235a5c512628fc7011c15e8d9bb25b28cbb1de10', '09f6b6a812132eee463de5625d44082094351e5e01c90e0e4dc14d2893ef6a38', '45bc601f4e7c8b80cc0c429fc5273808e88ddf7f6b0c7053a4c557e2c279a10d', '539441e88ca7396e33d2f25233286cf28b38761225330959445669581bd22411', '0af69069e9963489a014eb853d2a6ecda9ae7da34113cf3389c1167163e82dcf', '44be41afed3494e0381ae1126c4bb4f4f2977a0e1a01591ebd945f08460f1d1b', 'bb194dc58a0eb7e52501603ff614fb1131422ca453ab5b879033dd20511649fb', '2cb2fafbc456d565a9a6271284cb082c73a12c678dbaca52fa4304dd16824479', '18586b4a34af8afb3b19ff32c04e0b7b2f961021e15338b0a5a3ccafbea3e89f', '5da7ebc4953e83090f06af6e486dc3a244576cd2b94ec353133be3ced3251dcd', 'b44b885a406cb9ec036bed7a2f808cd599fef92864f4ac305f6309a2fb37cb4d', 'fcbb4b68ae78c4ce9cca6d03e0f62a1b8515b67ad1bc512e0d4857a6b428fb55', '97c985aeb00a2b45cdc26ddc7cc9e5e08475164523c7e555feb34c739c6a3ec7'] A time-division multiplexing. {64: 1, 37: 1, 91: 1, 55: 1, 112: 1, 38: 1, 33: 1, 79: 1, 52: 1, 25: 1, 51: 1, 69: 1, 130: 3, 62: 2, 67: 2, 53: 2, 80: 2, 127: 4} {14: 1, 17: 1, 77: 1, 78: 1, 135: 1, 142: 1, 149: 1, 216: 1, 278: 1, 280: 1, 321: 1, 324: 1, 294: 1, 296: 1, 308: 1, 406: 1, 0: 3, 389: 2, 390: 2, 400: 2, 399: 3, 19: 2, 281: 3, 45: 2, 56: 2, 185: 2, 192: 2, 322: 2, 66: 2, 196: 5, 197: 4, 337: 4, 380: 2, 255: 3} {0, 389, 390, 135, 142, 14, 400, 17, 399, 19, 149, 406, 279, 280, 281, 278, 294, 296, 45, 308, 56, 185, 192, 321, 322, 66, 196, 197, 324, 77, 78, 337, 216, 380, 255} 68 Time-Sensitive Network. changes look good 9b5906939d7fc5f5c463322e3063c95e1ec9ac88 9b5906939d7fc5f5c463322e3063c95e1ec9ac88 draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework 652bfd8e78af5fb6764d1cd3c06e0842d2b7be3658a25654db9db79dcf0dc03c ['b3713da5dc7b1531fd348079a30e2f5ac724e78c334f13dcd3da81aefb4a647d', '5d1ba8eea8ba53e9a9d0a6d166225ec30fafe99cff8f1aa38baf7ba9ff273aa6', 'cdc15b05d37b640ea4b7794cf9a229c6c28f8a1b7491f0460010ab5fcc44ff69', '652bfd8e78af5fb6764d1cd3c06e0842d2b7be3658a25654db9db79dcf0dc03c', 'b8d8f64f0f09d4c8fa40ff054a5f0e468afa79876dab10bea529c2c1e1430fbc', '58925b1ef76bb083d7d886d21f9aa7fc2143a26177ca339c06f960bc8c37c866', 'c2a31a816fad375f9df24bfcd3a1baa2c591de01e6733384a2811b4fd944d8ef', '34f6582bd92afa345dc5dcd62ba8f25eef20bd51d1919d3bde053a8ab6747c41', '8a9f636b1cdab856d1233a7a3cfa4bc0e99b49da4ac574e376b09f10f4f341e9', 'b5e2c587228a4238fbc26703235a5c512628fc7011c15e8d9bb25b28cbb1de10', '09f6b6a812132eee463de5625d44082094351e5e01c90e0e4dc14d2893ef6a38', '45bc601f4e7c8b80cc0c429fc5273808e88ddf7f6b0c7053a4c557e2c279a10d', '539441e88ca7396e33d2f25233286cf28b38761225330959445669581bd22411', '0af69069e9963489a014eb853d2a6ecda9ae7da34113cf3389c1167163e82dcf', '44be41afed3494e0381ae1126c4bb4f4f2977a0e1a01591ebd945f08460f1d1b', 'bb194dc58a0eb7e52501603ff614fb1131422ca453ab5b879033dd20511649fb', '2cb2fafbc456d565a9a6271284cb082c73a12c678dbaca52fa4304dd16824479', '18586b4a34af8afb3b19ff32c04e0b7b2f961021e15338b0a5a3ccafbea3e89f', '5da7ebc4953e83090f06af6e486dc3a244576cd2b94ec353133be3ced3251dcd', 'b44b885a406cb9ec036bed7a2f808cd599fef92864f4ac305f6309a2fb37cb4d', 'fcbb4b68ae78c4ce9cca6d03e0f62a1b8515b67ad1bc512e0d4857a6b428fb55', '97c985aeb00a2b45cdc26ddc7cc9e5e08475164523c7e555feb34c739c6a3ec7'] A time-sensitive network. {64: 1, 37: 1, 91: 1, 55: 1, 112: 1, 38: 1, 33: 1, 79: 1, 52: 1, 25: 1, 51: 1, 69: 1, 130: 3, 62: 2, 67: 2, 53: 2, 80: 2, 127: 4} {14: 1, 17: 1, 77: 1, 78: 1, 135: 1, 142: 1, 149: 1, 216: 1, 278: 1, 280: 1, 321: 1, 324: 1, 294: 1, 296: 1, 308: 1, 406: 1, 0: 3, 389: 2, 390: 2, 400: 2, 399: 3, 19: 2, 281: 3, 45: 2, 56: 2, 185: 2, 192: 2, 322: 2, 66: 2, 196: 5, 197: 4, 337: 4, 380: 2, 255: 3} {0, 389, 390, 135, 142, 14, 400, 17, 399, 19, 149, 406, 279, 280, 281, 278, 294, 296, 45, 308, 56, 185, 192, 321, 322, 66, 196, 197, 324, 77, 78, 337, 216, 380, 255} 68 "Border Gateway Protocol. Control Word. DetNet Control Word. Deterministic Networking. DetNet. Generalized Multiprotocol Label Switching. Generic Routing Encapsulation. IP Security. Layer 2. Label Switched Path. Label Switching Router. Multiprotocol Label Switching. Multiprotocol Label Switching - Traffic Engineering. Operations, Administration, and Maintenance. Path Computation Element Communication Protocol. Packet Elimination Function. Packet Replication Function. Packet Replication, Elimination and Ordering Functions. Packet Ordering Function. Packet Switched Network. PseudoWire. Quality of Service. DetNet ""service"" label. Time-Division Multiplexing. Time-Sensitive Network. Yet Another Next Generation." changes look good 9b5906939d7fc5f5c463322e3063c95e1ec9ac88 9b5906939d7fc5f5c463322e3063c95e1ec9ac88 draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework 2cb2fafbc456d565a9a6271284cb082c73a12c678dbaca52fa4304dd16824479 ['b3713da5dc7b1531fd348079a30e2f5ac724e78c334f13dcd3da81aefb4a647d', '5d1ba8eea8ba53e9a9d0a6d166225ec30fafe99cff8f1aa38baf7ba9ff273aa6', 'cdc15b05d37b640ea4b7794cf9a229c6c28f8a1b7491f0460010ab5fcc44ff69', '652bfd8e78af5fb6764d1cd3c06e0842d2b7be3658a25654db9db79dcf0dc03c', 'b8d8f64f0f09d4c8fa40ff054a5f0e468afa79876dab10bea529c2c1e1430fbc', '58925b1ef76bb083d7d886d21f9aa7fc2143a26177ca339c06f960bc8c37c866', 'c2a31a816fad375f9df24bfcd3a1baa2c591de01e6733384a2811b4fd944d8ef', '34f6582bd92afa345dc5dcd62ba8f25eef20bd51d1919d3bde053a8ab6747c41', '8a9f636b1cdab856d1233a7a3cfa4bc0e99b49da4ac574e376b09f10f4f341e9', 'b5e2c587228a4238fbc26703235a5c512628fc7011c15e8d9bb25b28cbb1de10', '09f6b6a812132eee463de5625d44082094351e5e01c90e0e4dc14d2893ef6a38', '45bc601f4e7c8b80cc0c429fc5273808e88ddf7f6b0c7053a4c557e2c279a10d', '539441e88ca7396e33d2f25233286cf28b38761225330959445669581bd22411', '0af69069e9963489a014eb853d2a6ecda9ae7da34113cf3389c1167163e82dcf', '44be41afed3494e0381ae1126c4bb4f4f2977a0e1a01591ebd945f08460f1d1b', 'bb194dc58a0eb7e52501603ff614fb1131422ca453ab5b879033dd20511649fb', '2cb2fafbc456d565a9a6271284cb082c73a12c678dbaca52fa4304dd16824479', '18586b4a34af8afb3b19ff32c04e0b7b2f961021e15338b0a5a3ccafbea3e89f', '5da7ebc4953e83090f06af6e486dc3a244576cd2b94ec353133be3ced3251dcd', 'b44b885a406cb9ec036bed7a2f808cd599fef92864f4ac305f6309a2fb37cb4d', 'fcbb4b68ae78c4ce9cca6d03e0f62a1b8515b67ad1bc512e0d4857a6b428fb55', '97c985aeb00a2b45cdc26ddc7cc9e5e08475164523c7e555feb34c739c6a3ec7'] B "border gateway protocol. control word. detnet control word. deterministic networking. detnet. generalized multiprotocol label switching. generic routing encapsulation. ip security. layer 2. label switched path. label switching router. multiprotocol label switching. multiprotocol label switching - traffic engineering. operations, administration, and maintenance. path computation element communication protocol. packet elimination function. packet replication function. packet replication, elimination and ordering functions. packet ordering function. packet switched network. pseudowire. quality of service. detnet ""service"" label. time-division multiplexing. time-sensitive network. yet another next generation." {64: 1, 37: 1, 91: 1, 55: 1, 112: 1, 38: 1, 33: 1, 79: 1, 52: 1, 25: 1, 51: 1, 69: 1, 130: 3, 62: 2, 67: 2, 53: 2, 80: 2, 127: 4} {14: 1, 17: 1, 77: 1, 78: 1, 135: 1, 142: 1, 149: 1, 216: 1, 278: 1, 280: 1, 321: 1, 324: 1, 294: 1, 296: 1, 308: 1, 406: 1, 0: 3, 389: 2, 390: 2, 400: 2, 399: 3, 19: 2, 281: 3, 45: 2, 56: 2, 185: 2, 192: 2, 322: 2, 66: 2, 196: 5, 197: 4, 337: 4, 380: 2, 255: 3} {0, 389, 390, 135, 142, 14, 400, 17, 399, 19, 149, 406, 279, 280, 281, 278, 294, 296, 45, 308, 56, 185, 192, 321, 322, 66, 196, 197, 324, 77, 78, 337, 216, 380, 255} 68 "The forwarding sub-layer provides the QoS related functions needed by the DetNet flow. It may do this directly through the use of queuing techniques and traffic engineering methods, or it may do this through the assistance of its underlying connectivity. For example it may call upon Ethernet TSN capabilities defined in IEEE 802.1 TSN IEEE802.1TSNTG." changes look good 9b5906939d7fc5f5c463322e3063c95e1ec9ac88 9b5906939d7fc5f5c463322e3063c95e1ec9ac88 draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework c26e775a7006bf44235b02ccc2462157252f2a42a9eafd79b7ba1f54e285b0d5 ['07cdea5163ec715727ddf4e230db06ecb20384d7a95db42dd7bb137028ff3b03', 'c26e775a7006bf44235b02ccc2462157252f2a42a9eafd79b7ba1f54e285b0d5', 'd0883bba9c43f15784cb05698f6be4bedf895e9b131603649d5019a9c77f94b2', '62cccbc0f90baf0afe4a855d11d118c6af2fe1977470a99d6592172537661791'] A "the forwarding sub-layer provides the qos related functions needed by the detnet flow. it may do this directly through the use of queuing techniques and traffic engineering methods, or it may do this through the assistance of its underlying connectivity. for example it may call upon ethernet tsn capabilities defined in ieee 802.1 tsn ieee802.1tsntg." {55: 1, 84: 1, 6: 4, 8: 3, 31: 2, 67: 5, 90: 2, 68: 2} {303: 1, 21: 1, 247: 1, 256: 4, 2: 5, 8: 5, 74: 3, 271: 2, 209: 5, 83: 3, 20: 2, 277: 2, 276: 3, 88: 5, 233: 6, 236: 2, 302: 6, 47: 6, 112: 5, 126: 6, 127: 5} {256, 2, 5, 8, 271, 20, 21, 277, 276, 302, 47, 303, 74, 209, 83, 88, 233, 236, 112, 247, 126, 127} 68 "The service sub-layer provides additional support beyond the connectivity function of the forwarding sub-layer. An example of this is Packet Replication, Elimination, and Ordering functions see PREOF." changes look good 9b5906939d7fc5f5c463322e3063c95e1ec9ac88 9b5906939d7fc5f5c463322e3063c95e1ec9ac88 draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework d0883bba9c43f15784cb05698f6be4bedf895e9b131603649d5019a9c77f94b2 ['07cdea5163ec715727ddf4e230db06ecb20384d7a95db42dd7bb137028ff3b03', 'c26e775a7006bf44235b02ccc2462157252f2a42a9eafd79b7ba1f54e285b0d5', 'd0883bba9c43f15784cb05698f6be4bedf895e9b131603649d5019a9c77f94b2', '62cccbc0f90baf0afe4a855d11d118c6af2fe1977470a99d6592172537661791'] A "the service sub-layer provides additional support beyond the connectivity function of the forwarding sub-layer. an example of this is packet replication, elimination, and ordering functions see preof." {55: 1, 84: 1, 6: 4, 8: 3, 31: 2, 67: 5, 90: 2, 68: 2} {303: 1, 21: 1, 247: 1, 256: 4, 2: 5, 8: 5, 74: 3, 271: 2, 209: 5, 83: 3, 20: 2, 277: 2, 276: 3, 88: 5, 233: 6, 236: 2, 302: 6, 47: 6, 112: 5, 126: 6, 127: 5} {256, 2, 5, 8, 271, 20, 21, 277, 276, 302, 47, 303, 74, 209, 83, 88, 233, 236, 112, 247, 126, 127} 68 "The forwarding sub-layer provides the QoS related functions needed by the DetNet flow. It may do this directly through the use of queuing techniques and traffic engineering methods, or it may do this through the assistance of its underlying connectivity. For example it may call upon Ethernet TSN capabilities defined in IEEE 802.1 TSN IEEE802.1TSNTG. The forwarding sub-layer uses buffer resources for packet queuing, as well as reservation and allocation of bandwidth capacity resources." changes look good 9b5906939d7fc5f5c463322e3063c95e1ec9ac88 9b5906939d7fc5f5c463322e3063c95e1ec9ac88 draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework 07cdea5163ec715727ddf4e230db06ecb20384d7a95db42dd7bb137028ff3b03 ['07cdea5163ec715727ddf4e230db06ecb20384d7a95db42dd7bb137028ff3b03', 'c26e775a7006bf44235b02ccc2462157252f2a42a9eafd79b7ba1f54e285b0d5', 'd0883bba9c43f15784cb05698f6be4bedf895e9b131603649d5019a9c77f94b2', '62cccbc0f90baf0afe4a855d11d118c6af2fe1977470a99d6592172537661791'] B "the forwarding sub-layer provides the qos related functions needed by the detnet flow. it may do this directly through the use of queuing techniques and traffic engineering methods, or it may do this through the assistance of its underlying connectivity. for example it may call upon ethernet tsn capabilities defined in ieee 802.1 tsn ieee802.1tsntg. the forwarding sub-layer uses buffer resources for packet queuing, as well as reservation and allocation of bandwidth capacity resources." {55: 1, 84: 1, 6: 4, 8: 3, 31: 2, 67: 5, 90: 2, 68: 2} {303: 1, 21: 1, 247: 1, 256: 4, 2: 5, 8: 5, 74: 3, 271: 2, 209: 5, 83: 3, 20: 2, 277: 2, 276: 3, 88: 5, 233: 6, 236: 2, 302: 6, 47: 6, 112: 5, 126: 6, 127: 5} {256, 2, 5, 8, 271, 20, 21, 277, 276, 302, 47, 303, 74, 209, 83, 88, 233, 236, 112, 247, 126, 127} 68 "The service sub-layer provides additional support beyond the connectivity function of the forwarding sub-layer. An example of this is Packet Replication, Elimination, and Ordering functions see PREOF. The ordering (POF) uses sequence numbers added to packets enabling a range of packet order protection from simple ordering and dropping out-of-order packets to more complex reordering of a fixed number of out-of-order, minimally delayed packets. Reordering requires buffer resources and has impact on the delay and jitter of packets in the DetNet flow." changes look good 9b5906939d7fc5f5c463322e3063c95e1ec9ac88 9b5906939d7fc5f5c463322e3063c95e1ec9ac88 draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework 62cccbc0f90baf0afe4a855d11d118c6af2fe1977470a99d6592172537661791 ['07cdea5163ec715727ddf4e230db06ecb20384d7a95db42dd7bb137028ff3b03', 'c26e775a7006bf44235b02ccc2462157252f2a42a9eafd79b7ba1f54e285b0d5', 'd0883bba9c43f15784cb05698f6be4bedf895e9b131603649d5019a9c77f94b2', '62cccbc0f90baf0afe4a855d11d118c6af2fe1977470a99d6592172537661791'] B "the service sub-layer provides additional support beyond the connectivity function of the forwarding sub-layer. an example of this is packet replication, elimination, and ordering functions see preof. the ordering (pof) uses sequence numbers added to packets enabling a range of packet order protection from simple ordering and dropping out-of-order packets to more complex reordering of a fixed number of out-of-order, minimally delayed packets. reordering requires buffer resources and has impact on the delay and jitter of packets in the detnet flow." {55: 1, 84: 1, 6: 4, 8: 3, 31: 2, 67: 5, 90: 2, 68: 2} {303: 1, 21: 1, 247: 1, 256: 4, 2: 5, 8: 5, 74: 3, 271: 2, 209: 5, 83: 3, 20: 2, 277: 2, 276: 3, 88: 5, 233: 6, 236: 2, 302: 6, 47: 6, 112: 5, 126: 6, 127: 5} {256, 2, 5, 8, 271, 20, 21, 277, 276, 302, 47, 303, 74, 209, 83, 88, 233, 236, 112, 247, 126, 127} 68 "DetNet encodes specific flow attributes (flow identity and sequence number) in packets. For example, in DetNet IP, zero encapsulation is used and no sequence number is available, and in DetNet MPLS, DetNet specific information may be added explicitly to the packets in the format of S-label and d-CW." changes look good 9b5906939d7fc5f5c463322e3063c95e1ec9ac88 9b5906939d7fc5f5c463322e3063c95e1ec9ac88 draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework 98e6edcdea07bab422ddf8f1f0c5cd894ba787d69fdc681a8ca417cc3bc2c950 ['98e6edcdea07bab422ddf8f1f0c5cd894ba787d69fdc681a8ca417cc3bc2c950', '6504e518897e9b53c6aa1b9fa4202829289535d3aac3c96557a4f7f63f7bd49e'] A "detnet encodes specific flow attributes (flow identity and sequence number) in packets. for example, in detnet ip, zero encapsulation is used and no sequence number is available, and in detnet mpls, detnet specific information may be added explicitly to the packets in the format of s-label and d-cw." {84: 1, 55: 1, 6: 4, 8: 3, 68: 2, 31: 2, 67: 5, 90: 2} {277: 1, 247: 1, 256: 4, 2: 5, 5: 2, 8: 5, 74: 3, 271: 2, 209: 5, 83: 2, 20: 2, 21: 3, 276: 2, 88: 5, 233: 6, 302: 6, 47: 6, 303: 3, 112: 5, 126: 6, 127: 5} {256, 2, 5, 8, 271, 20, 21, 277, 276, 302, 47, 303, 74, 209, 83, 88, 233, 236, 112, 247, 126, 127} 68 "DetNet encodes specific flow attributes (flow identity and sequence number) in packets. For example, in DetNet IP, zero encapsulation is used and no sequence number is available, and in DetNet MPLS, DetNet specific information may be added explicitly to the packets in the format of S-label and d-CW I-D.ietf-detnet-mpls ." changes look good 9b5906939d7fc5f5c463322e3063c95e1ec9ac88 9b5906939d7fc5f5c463322e3063c95e1ec9ac88 draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework 6504e518897e9b53c6aa1b9fa4202829289535d3aac3c96557a4f7f63f7bd49e ['98e6edcdea07bab422ddf8f1f0c5cd894ba787d69fdc681a8ca417cc3bc2c950', '6504e518897e9b53c6aa1b9fa4202829289535d3aac3c96557a4f7f63f7bd49e'] B "detnet encodes specific flow attributes (flow identity and sequence number) in packets. for example, in detnet ip, zero encapsulation is used and no sequence number is available, and in detnet mpls, detnet specific information may be added explicitly to the packets in the format of s-label and d-cw i-d.ietf-detnet-mpls ." {84: 1, 55: 1, 6: 4, 8: 3, 68: 2, 31: 2, 67: 5, 90: 2} {277: 1, 247: 1, 256: 4, 2: 5, 5: 2, 8: 5, 74: 3, 271: 2, 209: 5, 83: 2, 20: 2, 21: 3, 276: 2, 88: 5, 233: 6, 302: 6, 47: 6, 303: 3, 112: 5, 126: 6, 127: 5} {256, 2, 5, 8, 271, 20, 21, 277, 276, 302, 47, 303, 74, 209, 83, 88, 233, 236, 112, 247, 126, 127} 68 "MPLS provides the ability to forward traffic over implicit and explicit paths to the point in the network where the next DetNet service sub-layer action needs to take place. It does this through the use of a stack of one or more labels with various forwarding semantics." changes look good 9b5906939d7fc5f5c463322e3063c95e1ec9ac88 9b5906939d7fc5f5c463322e3063c95e1ec9ac88 draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework 86156bf77b4f5f7977d5e1684a269e01270045775780cc2cc759d55f97c1a38e ['a88e21e9850be54833dce43fb920754ff16be49e547976b246ef1b145505b998', '86156bf77b4f5f7977d5e1684a269e01270045775780cc2cc759d55f97c1a38e'] A "mpls provides the ability to forward traffic over implicit and explicit paths to the point in the network where the next detnet service sub-layer action needs to take place. it does this through the use of a stack of one or more labels with various forwarding semantics." {8: 1, 6: 2, 79: 11, 90: 9, 51: 11, 130: 11, 62: 10, 85: 10, 68: 6, 35: 12, 110: 12, 91: 14, 114: 12, 97: 12, 31: 4, 13: 11, 67: 11, 38: 13, 26: 10, 124: 11, 98: 11, 54: 11, 127: 12, 96: 12, 64: 11, 30: 13, 61: 14, 55: 5, 27: 10, 15: 12, 52: 10, 129: 12, 115: 12, 84: 7, 76: 12, 87: 12, 131: 14, 102: 9, 113: 14, 99: 11, 36: 12, 24: 11, 53: 10, 72: 13} {330: 1, 1: 2, 4: 11, 9: 11, 10: 12, 15: 12, 24: 11, 25: 10, 26: 10, 27: 12, 39: 6, 43: 12, 49: 15, 50: 14, 58: 14, 59: 11, 64: 12, 69: 10, 81: 11, 82: 11, 86: 12, 96: 13, 97: 12, 100: 14, 108: 12, 109: 13, 110: 13, 111: 11, 114: 12, 115: 13, 116: 12, 118: 11, 119: 10, 120: 12, 121: 9, 122: 13, 123: 12, 124: 8, 128: 13, 129: 13, 130: 14, 132: 10, 136: 11, 145: 10, 147: 13, 151: 13, 152: 13, 154: 12, 156: 11, 161: 9, 162: 8, 165: 12, 168: 13, 169: 12, 172: 12, 180: 13, 184: 11, 187: 14, 188: 13, 191: 12, 194: 10, 202: 11, 203: 12, 206: 11, 207: 12, 215: 10, 217: 12, 218: 3, 220: 9, 221: 9, 222: 8, 224: 12, 227: 12, 229: 12, 234: 14, 235: 11, 241: 11, 242: 11, 243: 10, 244: 13, 245: 10, 248: 13, 250: 13, 262: 13, 263: 14, 264: 10, 267: 9, 270: 12, 272: 12, 273: 11, 287: 12, 289: 12, 291: 14, 299: 12, 300: 12, 304: 12, 309: 9, 314: 11, 315: 12, 320: 9, 323: 10, 327: 13, 328: 11, 329: 11, 334: 11, 335: 12, 341: 12, 342: 13, 347: 12, 348: 12, 350: 13, 351: 14, 352: 12, 353: 12, 354: 11, 358: 7, 365: 12, 366: 11, 369: 10, 371: 14, 372: 14, 376: 11, 384: 14, 385: 13, 386: 12, 387: 12, 392: 11, 393: 12, 396: 13, 397: 4, 398: 5, 402: 12} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 68 "MPLS provides a forwarding sub-layer for traffic over implicit and explicit paths to the point in the network where the next DetNet service sub-layer action needs to take place. It does this through the use of a stack of one or more labels with various forwarding semantics." changes look good 9b5906939d7fc5f5c463322e3063c95e1ec9ac88 9b5906939d7fc5f5c463322e3063c95e1ec9ac88 draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework a88e21e9850be54833dce43fb920754ff16be49e547976b246ef1b145505b998 ['a88e21e9850be54833dce43fb920754ff16be49e547976b246ef1b145505b998', '86156bf77b4f5f7977d5e1684a269e01270045775780cc2cc759d55f97c1a38e'] B "mpls provides a forwarding sub-layer for traffic over implicit and explicit paths to the point in the network where the next detnet service sub-layer action needs to take place. it does this through the use of a stack of one or more labels with various forwarding semantics." {8: 1, 6: 2, 79: 11, 90: 9, 51: 11, 130: 11, 62: 10, 85: 10, 68: 6, 35: 12, 110: 12, 91: 14, 114: 12, 97: 12, 31: 4, 13: 11, 67: 11, 38: 13, 26: 10, 124: 11, 98: 11, 54: 11, 127: 12, 96: 12, 64: 11, 30: 13, 61: 14, 55: 5, 27: 10, 15: 12, 52: 10, 129: 12, 115: 12, 84: 7, 76: 12, 87: 12, 131: 14, 102: 9, 113: 14, 99: 11, 36: 12, 24: 11, 53: 10, 72: 13} {330: 1, 1: 2, 4: 11, 9: 11, 10: 12, 15: 12, 24: 11, 25: 10, 26: 10, 27: 12, 39: 6, 43: 12, 49: 15, 50: 14, 58: 14, 59: 11, 64: 12, 69: 10, 81: 11, 82: 11, 86: 12, 96: 13, 97: 12, 100: 14, 108: 12, 109: 13, 110: 13, 111: 11, 114: 12, 115: 13, 116: 12, 118: 11, 119: 10, 120: 12, 121: 9, 122: 13, 123: 12, 124: 8, 128: 13, 129: 13, 130: 14, 132: 10, 136: 11, 145: 10, 147: 13, 151: 13, 152: 13, 154: 12, 156: 11, 161: 9, 162: 8, 165: 12, 168: 13, 169: 12, 172: 12, 180: 13, 184: 11, 187: 14, 188: 13, 191: 12, 194: 10, 202: 11, 203: 12, 206: 11, 207: 12, 215: 10, 217: 12, 218: 3, 220: 9, 221: 9, 222: 8, 224: 12, 227: 12, 229: 12, 234: 14, 235: 11, 241: 11, 242: 11, 243: 10, 244: 13, 245: 10, 248: 13, 250: 13, 262: 13, 263: 14, 264: 10, 267: 9, 270: 12, 272: 12, 273: 11, 287: 12, 289: 12, 291: 14, 299: 12, 300: 12, 304: 12, 309: 9, 314: 11, 315: 12, 320: 9, 323: 10, 327: 13, 328: 11, 329: 11, 334: 11, 335: 12, 341: 12, 342: 13, 347: 12, 348: 12, 350: 13, 351: 14, 352: 12, 353: 12, 354: 11, 358: 7, 365: 12, 366: 11, 369: 10, 371: 14, 372: 14, 376: 11, 384: 14, 385: 13, 386: 12, 387: 12, 392: 11, 393: 12, 396: 13, 397: 4, 398: 5, 402: 12} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 68 "In cases where metadata is needed to process an MPLS encapsulated packet at the service sub-layer, a shim layer called a control word (CW) RFC4385 can be used. Although such CWs are frequently 32 bits long, there is no architectural constraint on its size of this structure, only the requirement that it is fully understood by all parties operating on it in the DetNet service sub-layer. The operation of this method is described in detail in I-D.ietf-detnet- mpls." changes look good 9b5906939d7fc5f5c463322e3063c95e1ec9ac88 9b5906939d7fc5f5c463322e3063c95e1ec9ac88 draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework 51a2a7e138780c471cccd38ccd2535db6f103ac1686110677780525a4ccb5c33 ['1e5d70e93b82aa586833e5be7efca0d50db5cd6617d4aa5557423b578ab21a7b', '51a2a7e138780c471cccd38ccd2535db6f103ac1686110677780525a4ccb5c33'] A "in cases where metadata is needed to process an mpls encapsulated packet at the service sub-layer, a shim layer called a control word (cw) rfc4385 can be used. although such cws are frequently 32 bits long, there is no architectural constraint on its size of this structure, only the requirement that it is fully understood by all parties operating on it in the detnet service sub-layer. the operation of this method is described in detail in i-d.ietf-detnet- mpls." {55: 1, 84: 1, 6: 3, 79: 5, 90: 3, 51: 5, 130: 5, 62: 4, 85: 4, 35: 6, 110: 6, 91: 8, 114: 6, 97: 6, 31: 2, 13: 5, 67: 5, 38: 7, 26: 4, 124: 5, 98: 5, 54: 5, 127: 6, 8: 3, 96: 6, 68: 2, 64: 5, 30: 7, 61: 8, 27: 4, 15: 6, 52: 4, 129: 6, 115: 6, 76: 6, 87: 6, 131: 8, 102: 3, 113: 8, 99: 5, 36: 6, 24: 5, 53: 4, 72: 7} {398: 1, 358: 1, 1: 4, 4: 5, 9: 5, 10: 6, 15: 6, 24: 5, 25: 4, 26: 4, 27: 6, 43: 6, 49: 9, 50: 8, 58: 8, 59: 5, 64: 6, 69: 4, 81: 5, 82: 5, 86: 6, 96: 7, 97: 6, 100: 8, 108: 6, 109: 7, 110: 7, 111: 5, 114: 6, 115: 7, 116: 6, 118: 5, 119: 4, 120: 6, 121: 3, 122: 7, 123: 6, 124: 2, 128: 7, 129: 7, 130: 8, 132: 4, 136: 5, 145: 4, 147: 7, 151: 7, 152: 7, 154: 6, 156: 5, 161: 3, 162: 2, 165: 6, 168: 7, 169: 6, 172: 6, 180: 7, 184: 5, 187: 8, 188: 7, 191: 6, 194: 4, 202: 5, 203: 6, 206: 5, 207: 6, 215: 4, 217: 6, 218: 3, 220: 3, 221: 3, 222: 2, 224: 6, 227: 6, 229: 6, 234: 8, 235: 5, 241: 5, 242: 5, 243: 4, 244: 7, 245: 4, 248: 7, 250: 7, 258: 6, 262: 7, 263: 8, 264: 4, 267: 3, 270: 6, 272: 6, 273: 5, 287: 6, 289: 6, 291: 8, 299: 6, 300: 6, 304: 6, 309: 3, 314: 5, 315: 6, 320: 3, 323: 4, 327: 7, 328: 5, 329: 5, 330: 5, 334: 5, 335: 6, 341: 6, 342: 7, 347: 6, 348: 6, 350: 7, 351: 8, 352: 6, 353: 6, 354: 5, 365: 6, 366: 5, 369: 4, 371: 8, 372: 8, 376: 5, 384: 8, 385: 7, 386: 6, 387: 6, 392: 5, 393: 6, 396: 7, 397: 2, 402: 6} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 68 "In cases where metadata is needed to process an MPLS encapsulated packet at the service sub-layer, the d-CW I-D.ietf-detnet-mpls, RFC4385,can be used. Although such d-CWs are frequently 32 bits long, there is no architectural constraint on its size of this structure, only the requirement that it is fully understood by all parties operating on it in the DetNet service sub-layer. The operation of this method is described in detail in I-D.ietf-detnet- mpls." changes look good 9b5906939d7fc5f5c463322e3063c95e1ec9ac88 9b5906939d7fc5f5c463322e3063c95e1ec9ac88 draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework 1e5d70e93b82aa586833e5be7efca0d50db5cd6617d4aa5557423b578ab21a7b ['1e5d70e93b82aa586833e5be7efca0d50db5cd6617d4aa5557423b578ab21a7b', '51a2a7e138780c471cccd38ccd2535db6f103ac1686110677780525a4ccb5c33'] B "in cases where metadata is needed to process an mpls encapsulated packet at the service sub-layer, the d-cw i-d.ietf-detnet-mpls, rfc4385,can be used. although such d-cws are frequently 32 bits long, there is no architectural constraint on its size of this structure, only the requirement that it is fully understood by all parties operating on it in the detnet service sub-layer. the operation of this method is described in detail in i-d.ietf-detnet- mpls." {55: 1, 84: 1, 6: 3, 79: 5, 90: 3, 51: 5, 130: 5, 62: 4, 85: 4, 35: 6, 110: 6, 91: 8, 114: 6, 97: 6, 31: 2, 13: 5, 67: 5, 38: 7, 26: 4, 124: 5, 98: 5, 54: 5, 127: 6, 8: 3, 96: 6, 68: 2, 64: 5, 30: 7, 61: 8, 27: 4, 15: 6, 52: 4, 129: 6, 115: 6, 76: 6, 87: 6, 131: 8, 102: 3, 113: 8, 99: 5, 36: 6, 24: 5, 53: 4, 72: 7} {398: 1, 358: 1, 1: 4, 4: 5, 9: 5, 10: 6, 15: 6, 24: 5, 25: 4, 26: 4, 27: 6, 43: 6, 49: 9, 50: 8, 58: 8, 59: 5, 64: 6, 69: 4, 81: 5, 82: 5, 86: 6, 96: 7, 97: 6, 100: 8, 108: 6, 109: 7, 110: 7, 111: 5, 114: 6, 115: 7, 116: 6, 118: 5, 119: 4, 120: 6, 121: 3, 122: 7, 123: 6, 124: 2, 128: 7, 129: 7, 130: 8, 132: 4, 136: 5, 145: 4, 147: 7, 151: 7, 152: 7, 154: 6, 156: 5, 161: 3, 162: 2, 165: 6, 168: 7, 169: 6, 172: 6, 180: 7, 184: 5, 187: 8, 188: 7, 191: 6, 194: 4, 202: 5, 203: 6, 206: 5, 207: 6, 215: 4, 217: 6, 218: 3, 220: 3, 221: 3, 222: 2, 224: 6, 227: 6, 229: 6, 234: 8, 235: 5, 241: 5, 242: 5, 243: 4, 244: 7, 245: 4, 248: 7, 250: 7, 258: 6, 262: 7, 263: 8, 264: 4, 267: 3, 270: 6, 272: 6, 273: 5, 287: 6, 289: 6, 291: 8, 299: 6, 300: 6, 304: 6, 309: 3, 314: 5, 315: 6, 320: 3, 323: 4, 327: 7, 328: 5, 329: 5, 330: 5, 334: 5, 335: 6, 341: 6, 342: 7, 347: 6, 348: 6, 350: 7, 351: 8, 352: 6, 353: 6, 354: 5, 365: 6, 366: 5, 369: 4, 371: 8, 372: 8, 376: 5, 384: 8, 385: 7, 386: 6, 387: 6, 392: 5, 393: 6, 396: 7, 397: 2, 402: 6} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 68 "Reservation of resources can allocate resources to specific DetNet flows. This can eliminate packet contention and packet loss for DetNet traffic. This also can reduce jitter for DetNet traffic. Resources allocated to a DetNet flow protect it from other traffic flows. On the other hand, DetNet flows are assumed to behave with respect to the reserved traffic profile. Misbehaving DetNet flows must be detected and it have to be ensured that they do not compromise QoS of other flows. The use of (queuing, policing, shaping) policies can be used to ensure that the allocation of resources reserved for DetNet is met." changes look good 9b5906939d7fc5f5c463322e3063c95e1ec9ac88 9b5906939d7fc5f5c463322e3063c95e1ec9ac88 draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework 878e4eb62fa086fa63f78e831077af12faaf0d2fc1d35390eae3936514aa7756 ['4dbf5013cae5ea2cf47a7fc85fb667c0e1c103f23c8f7656a08bb45679112ff7', '878e4eb62fa086fa63f78e831077af12faaf0d2fc1d35390eae3936514aa7756'] A "reservation of resources can allocate resources to specific detnet flows. this can eliminate packet contention and packet loss for detnet traffic. this also can reduce jitter for detnet traffic. resources allocated to a detnet flow protect it from other traffic flows. on the other hand, detnet flows are assumed to behave with respect to the reserved traffic profile. misbehaving detnet flows must be detected and it have to be ensured that they do not compromise qos of other flows. the use of (queuing, policing, shaping) policies can be used to ensure that the allocation of resources reserved for detnet is met." {55: 1, 84: 1, 6: 2, 79: 4, 90: 2, 51: 4, 130: 4, 62: 3, 85: 3, 68: 2, 35: 5, 110: 5, 91: 7, 114: 5, 97: 5, 31: 3, 13: 4, 67: 4, 38: 6, 26: 3, 124: 4, 98: 4, 54: 4, 127: 5, 8: 2, 96: 5, 64: 4, 30: 6, 61: 7, 27: 3, 15: 5, 52: 3, 129: 5, 115: 5, 76: 5, 87: 5, 131: 7, 102: 2, 113: 7, 99: 4, 36: 5, 24: 4, 53: 3, 72: 6} {162: 1, 358: 1, 1: 6, 4: 4, 9: 4, 10: 5, 15: 5, 24: 4, 25: 3, 26: 3, 27: 5, 39: 2, 43: 5, 49: 8, 50: 7, 58: 7, 59: 4, 64: 5, 69: 3, 81: 4, 82: 4, 86: 5, 96: 6, 97: 5, 100: 7, 108: 5, 109: 6, 110: 6, 111: 4, 114: 5, 115: 6, 116: 5, 118: 4, 119: 3, 120: 5, 121: 2, 122: 6, 123: 5, 128: 6, 129: 6, 130: 7, 132: 3, 136: 4, 145: 3, 147: 6, 151: 6, 152: 6, 154: 5, 156: 4, 161: 2, 165: 5, 168: 6, 169: 5, 172: 5, 180: 6, 184: 4, 187: 7, 188: 6, 191: 5, 194: 3, 202: 4, 203: 5, 206: 4, 207: 5, 215: 3, 217: 5, 218: 5, 220: 2, 221: 2, 222: 2, 224: 5, 227: 5, 229: 5, 234: 7, 235: 4, 241: 4, 242: 4, 243: 3, 244: 6, 245: 3, 248: 6, 250: 6, 258: 8, 262: 6, 263: 7, 264: 3, 267: 2, 270: 5, 272: 5, 273: 4, 287: 5, 289: 5, 291: 7, 299: 5, 300: 5, 304: 5, 309: 2, 314: 4, 315: 5, 320: 2, 323: 3, 327: 6, 328: 4, 329: 4, 330: 7, 334: 4, 335: 5, 341: 5, 342: 6, 347: 5, 348: 5, 350: 6, 351: 7, 352: 5, 353: 5, 354: 4, 365: 5, 366: 4, 369: 3, 371: 7, 372: 7, 376: 4, 384: 7, 385: 6, 386: 5, 387: 5, 392: 4, 393: 5, 396: 6, 397: 4, 398: 3, 402: 5} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 68 "Reservation of resources can allocate resources to specific DetNet flows. This can eliminate packet contention and packet loss for DetNet traffic. This also can reduce jitter for DetNet traffic. Resources allocated to a DetNet flow protect it from other traffic flows. On the other hand, DetNet flows are assumed to behave with respect to the reserved traffic profile. Misbehaving DetNet flows must be able to be detected and ensure that they do not compromise QoS of other flows. Queuing, policing, and shaping policies can be used to ensure that the allocation of resources reserved for DetNet is met." changes look good 9b5906939d7fc5f5c463322e3063c95e1ec9ac88 9b5906939d7fc5f5c463322e3063c95e1ec9ac88 draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework 4dbf5013cae5ea2cf47a7fc85fb667c0e1c103f23c8f7656a08bb45679112ff7 ['4dbf5013cae5ea2cf47a7fc85fb667c0e1c103f23c8f7656a08bb45679112ff7', '878e4eb62fa086fa63f78e831077af12faaf0d2fc1d35390eae3936514aa7756'] B "reservation of resources can allocate resources to specific detnet flows. this can eliminate packet contention and packet loss for detnet traffic. this also can reduce jitter for detnet traffic. resources allocated to a detnet flow protect it from other traffic flows. on the other hand, detnet flows are assumed to behave with respect to the reserved traffic profile. misbehaving detnet flows must be able to be detected and ensure that they do not compromise qos of other flows. queuing, policing, and shaping policies can be used to ensure that the allocation of resources reserved for detnet is met." {55: 1, 84: 1, 6: 2, 79: 4, 90: 2, 51: 4, 130: 4, 62: 3, 85: 3, 68: 2, 35: 5, 110: 5, 91: 7, 114: 5, 97: 5, 31: 3, 13: 4, 67: 4, 38: 6, 26: 3, 124: 4, 98: 4, 54: 4, 127: 5, 8: 2, 96: 5, 64: 4, 30: 6, 61: 7, 27: 3, 15: 5, 52: 3, 129: 5, 115: 5, 76: 5, 87: 5, 131: 7, 102: 2, 113: 7, 99: 4, 36: 5, 24: 4, 53: 3, 72: 6} {162: 1, 358: 1, 1: 6, 4: 4, 9: 4, 10: 5, 15: 5, 24: 4, 25: 3, 26: 3, 27: 5, 39: 2, 43: 5, 49: 8, 50: 7, 58: 7, 59: 4, 64: 5, 69: 3, 81: 4, 82: 4, 86: 5, 96: 6, 97: 5, 100: 7, 108: 5, 109: 6, 110: 6, 111: 4, 114: 5, 115: 6, 116: 5, 118: 4, 119: 3, 120: 5, 121: 2, 122: 6, 123: 5, 128: 6, 129: 6, 130: 7, 132: 3, 136: 4, 145: 3, 147: 6, 151: 6, 152: 6, 154: 5, 156: 4, 161: 2, 165: 5, 168: 6, 169: 5, 172: 5, 180: 6, 184: 4, 187: 7, 188: 6, 191: 5, 194: 3, 202: 4, 203: 5, 206: 4, 207: 5, 215: 3, 217: 5, 218: 5, 220: 2, 221: 2, 222: 2, 224: 5, 227: 5, 229: 5, 234: 7, 235: 4, 241: 4, 242: 4, 243: 3, 244: 6, 245: 3, 248: 6, 250: 6, 258: 8, 262: 6, 263: 7, 264: 3, 267: 2, 270: 5, 272: 5, 273: 4, 287: 5, 289: 5, 291: 7, 299: 5, 300: 5, 304: 5, 309: 2, 314: 4, 315: 5, 320: 2, 323: 3, 327: 6, 328: 4, 329: 4, 330: 7, 334: 4, 335: 5, 341: 5, 342: 6, 347: 5, 348: 5, 350: 6, 351: 7, 352: 5, 353: 5, 354: 4, 365: 5, 366: 4, 369: 3, 371: 7, 372: 7, 376: 4, 384: 7, 385: 6, 386: 5, 387: 5, 392: 4, 393: 5, 396: 6, 397: 4, 398: 3, 402: 5} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 68 Network Coding, not to be confused with network programming, changes look good 9b5906939d7fc5f5c463322e3063c95e1ec9ac88 9b5906939d7fc5f5c463322e3063c95e1ec9ac88 draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework 7416e752bc7b010aff69f0c06a4372568eb12c623c66cc68e19a745c14231c08 ['90b123c76a34ce7125decbd1965f78537a0a72161610ed930b499214b2761fdf', '7416e752bc7b010aff69f0c06a4372568eb12c623c66cc68e19a745c14231c08'] A network coding, not to be confused with network programming, {84: 1, 6: 3, 79: 5, 90: 3, 51: 5, 130: 5, 62: 4, 85: 4, 68: 2, 35: 6, 110: 6, 91: 8, 114: 6, 97: 6, 31: 4, 13: 5, 67: 5, 38: 7, 26: 4, 124: 5, 98: 5, 54: 5, 127: 6, 8: 3, 96: 6, 64: 5, 30: 7, 61: 8, 55: 2, 27: 4, 15: 6, 52: 4, 129: 6, 115: 6, 76: 6, 87: 6, 131: 8, 102: 3, 113: 8, 99: 5, 36: 6, 24: 5, 53: 4, 72: 7} {358: 1, 1: 6, 4: 5, 9: 5, 10: 6, 15: 6, 24: 5, 25: 4, 26: 4, 27: 6, 39: 2, 43: 6, 49: 9, 50: 8, 58: 8, 59: 5, 64: 6, 69: 4, 81: 5, 82: 5, 86: 6, 96: 7, 97: 6, 100: 8, 108: 6, 109: 7, 110: 7, 111: 5, 114: 6, 115: 7, 116: 6, 118: 5, 119: 4, 120: 6, 121: 3, 122: 7, 123: 6, 124: 2, 128: 7, 129: 7, 130: 8, 132: 4, 136: 5, 145: 4, 147: 7, 151: 7, 152: 7, 154: 6, 156: 5, 161: 3, 162: 2, 165: 6, 168: 7, 169: 6, 172: 6, 180: 7, 184: 5, 187: 8, 188: 7, 191: 6, 194: 4, 202: 5, 203: 6, 206: 5, 207: 6, 215: 4, 217: 6, 218: 5, 220: 3, 221: 3, 224: 6, 227: 6, 229: 6, 234: 8, 235: 5, 241: 5, 242: 5, 243: 4, 244: 7, 245: 4, 248: 7, 250: 7, 258: 8, 262: 7, 263: 8, 264: 4, 267: 3, 270: 6, 272: 6, 273: 5, 287: 6, 289: 6, 291: 8, 299: 6, 300: 6, 304: 6, 309: 3, 314: 5, 315: 6, 320: 3, 323: 4, 327: 7, 328: 5, 329: 5, 330: 7, 334: 5, 335: 6, 341: 6, 342: 7, 347: 6, 348: 6, 350: 7, 351: 8, 352: 6, 353: 6, 354: 5, 365: 6, 366: 5, 369: 4, 371: 8, 372: 8, 376: 5, 384: 8, 385: 7, 386: 6, 387: 6, 392: 5, 393: 6, 396: 7, 397: 4, 398: 3, 402: 6} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 68 Network Coding, nwcrg not to be confused with network programming, changes look good 9b5906939d7fc5f5c463322e3063c95e1ec9ac88 9b5906939d7fc5f5c463322e3063c95e1ec9ac88 draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework 90b123c76a34ce7125decbd1965f78537a0a72161610ed930b499214b2761fdf ['90b123c76a34ce7125decbd1965f78537a0a72161610ed930b499214b2761fdf', '7416e752bc7b010aff69f0c06a4372568eb12c623c66cc68e19a745c14231c08'] B network coding, nwcrg not to be confused with network programming, {84: 1, 6: 3, 79: 5, 90: 3, 51: 5, 130: 5, 62: 4, 85: 4, 68: 2, 35: 6, 110: 6, 91: 8, 114: 6, 97: 6, 31: 4, 13: 5, 67: 5, 38: 7, 26: 4, 124: 5, 98: 5, 54: 5, 127: 6, 8: 3, 96: 6, 64: 5, 30: 7, 61: 8, 55: 2, 27: 4, 15: 6, 52: 4, 129: 6, 115: 6, 76: 6, 87: 6, 131: 8, 102: 3, 113: 8, 99: 5, 36: 6, 24: 5, 53: 4, 72: 7} {358: 1, 1: 6, 4: 5, 9: 5, 10: 6, 15: 6, 24: 5, 25: 4, 26: 4, 27: 6, 39: 2, 43: 6, 49: 9, 50: 8, 58: 8, 59: 5, 64: 6, 69: 4, 81: 5, 82: 5, 86: 6, 96: 7, 97: 6, 100: 8, 108: 6, 109: 7, 110: 7, 111: 5, 114: 6, 115: 7, 116: 6, 118: 5, 119: 4, 120: 6, 121: 3, 122: 7, 123: 6, 124: 2, 128: 7, 129: 7, 130: 8, 132: 4, 136: 5, 145: 4, 147: 7, 151: 7, 152: 7, 154: 6, 156: 5, 161: 3, 162: 2, 165: 6, 168: 7, 169: 6, 172: 6, 180: 7, 184: 5, 187: 8, 188: 7, 191: 6, 194: 4, 202: 5, 203: 6, 206: 5, 207: 6, 215: 4, 217: 6, 218: 5, 220: 3, 221: 3, 224: 6, 227: 6, 229: 6, 234: 8, 235: 5, 241: 5, 242: 5, 243: 4, 244: 7, 245: 4, 248: 7, 250: 7, 258: 8, 262: 7, 263: 8, 264: 4, 267: 3, 270: 6, 272: 6, 273: 5, 287: 6, 289: 6, 291: 8, 299: 6, 300: 6, 304: 6, 309: 3, 314: 5, 315: 6, 320: 3, 323: 4, 327: 7, 328: 5, 329: 5, 330: 7, 334: 5, 335: 6, 341: 6, 342: 7, 347: 6, 348: 6, 350: 7, 351: 8, 352: 6, 353: 6, 354: 5, 365: 6, 366: 5, 369: 4, 371: 8, 372: 8, 376: 5, 384: 8, 385: 7, 386: 6, 387: 6, 392: 5, 393: 6, 396: 7, 397: 4, 398: 3, 402: 6} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 68 "In the preceding example, reordering of packets is dependent on the number of out-of-order packets that can be buffered and the delay difference of arriving packets. DetNet uses configuration of the number of maximum number out-of-order packets and the maximum delay that out-of-order packets can be held before being delivered. If the differential delay between paths is large enough or the arrival rate of packets large enough packets may be dropped instead of being reordered. Likewise elimination uses the sequence number to eliminate duplicate packets and large differential delays combined with high numbers of packets may exceed the ability of this elimination function to eliminate all duplicate packets. Path selection for DetNet services needs to take these factors into account." changes look good 9b5906939d7fc5f5c463322e3063c95e1ec9ac88 9b5906939d7fc5f5c463322e3063c95e1ec9ac88 draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework da2f851aa0b73253e5a1cb02855811e64b038e227fea4a7825678075e1eb266f ['da2f851aa0b73253e5a1cb02855811e64b038e227fea4a7825678075e1eb266f'] B "in the preceding example, reordering of packets is dependent on the number of out-of-order packets that can be buffered and the delay difference of arriving packets. detnet uses configuration of the number of maximum number out-of-order packets and the maximum delay that out-of-order packets can be held before being delivered. if the differential delay between paths is large enough or the arrival rate of packets large enough packets may be dropped instead of being reordered. likewise elimination uses the sequence number to eliminate duplicate packets and large differential delays combined with high numbers of packets may exceed the ability of this elimination function to eliminate all duplicate packets. path selection for detnet services needs to take these factors into account." {76: 1, 6: 4, 79: 7, 90: 6, 51: 8, 130: 7, 62: 7, 85: 7, 68: 6, 35: 8, 110: 8, 91: 10, 114: 8, 97: 8, 31: 4, 13: 8, 67: 6, 38: 9, 26: 7, 124: 6, 98: 7, 54: 7, 127: 8, 8: 5, 96: 8, 64: 7, 30: 9, 61: 10, 55: 3, 27: 4, 15: 8, 52: 5, 129: 8, 115: 8, 84: 2, 87: 8, 131: 10, 102: 6, 113: 10, 99: 7, 36: 8, 24: 7, 53: 6, 72: 9} {203: 1, 1: 11, 4: 7, 9: 6, 10: 8, 15: 8, 24: 7, 25: 7, 26: 7, 27: 8, 39: 7, 43: 8, 49: 11, 50: 10, 58: 10, 59: 7, 64: 8, 69: 4, 81: 8, 82: 8, 86: 8, 96: 9, 97: 8, 100: 11, 108: 8, 109: 9, 110: 9, 111: 7, 114: 8, 115: 9, 116: 8, 118: 8, 119: 7, 120: 8, 121: 6, 122: 9, 123: 8, 124: 6, 128: 9, 129: 9, 130: 10, 132: 5, 136: 7, 145: 5, 147: 9, 151: 9, 152: 9, 154: 8, 156: 7, 161: 4, 162: 5, 165: 8, 168: 9, 169: 8, 172: 8, 180: 9, 184: 6, 187: 10, 188: 9, 191: 8, 194: 5, 202: 2, 206: 7, 207: 8, 215: 5, 217: 8, 218: 10, 220: 6, 221: 6, 222: 7, 224: 8, 227: 9, 229: 8, 234: 10, 235: 7, 241: 7, 242: 7, 243: 3, 244: 9, 245: 4, 248: 9, 250: 9, 258: 13, 262: 9, 263: 10, 264: 5, 267: 6, 270: 8, 272: 8, 273: 4, 287: 8, 289: 8, 291: 10, 299: 9, 300: 8, 304: 8, 309: 6, 314: 7, 315: 8, 320: 6, 323: 4, 327: 9, 328: 6, 329: 7, 330: 12, 334: 7, 335: 8, 341: 9, 342: 10, 347: 9, 348: 9, 351: 10, 352: 8, 353: 8, 354: 7, 358: 6, 365: 8, 366: 7, 369: 6, 371: 11, 372: 10, 376: 7, 384: 10, 385: 9, 386: 8, 387: 8, 392: 6, 393: 7, 396: 10, 397: 9, 398: 8, 402: 8} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 68 "While the definition of controller plane for DetNet is out of the scope of this document, there are particular considerations and requirements for such that result from the unique characteristics of the DetNet architecture RFC8655 and data plane as defined herein." changes look good 9b5906939d7fc5f5c463322e3063c95e1ec9ac88 9b5906939d7fc5f5c463322e3063c95e1ec9ac88 draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework ca5c7910044048c8d52542b54fc179d292866487e4290614c2760486514bd397 ['ca5c7910044048c8d52542b54fc179d292866487e4290614c2760486514bd397', 'cba646b446e735cabd8548774cdf7fcc3c5ce876a7e56e50d00430721bbbb190'] A "while the definition of controller plane for detnet is out of the scope of this document, there are particular considerations and requirements for such that result from the unique characteristics of the detnet architecture rfc8655 and data plane as defined herein." {84: 1, 67: 1} {150: 1, 316: 1} {316, 317, 150} 68 "The Controller Plane corresponds to the aggregation of the Control and Management Planes discussed in RFC7426 and RFC8655. While more details of any DetNet controller plane are out of the scope of this document, there are particular considerations and requirements for such that result from the unique characteristics of the DetNet architecture RFC8655 and data plane as defined herein." changes look good 9b5906939d7fc5f5c463322e3063c95e1ec9ac88 9b5906939d7fc5f5c463322e3063c95e1ec9ac88 draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework cba646b446e735cabd8548774cdf7fcc3c5ce876a7e56e50d00430721bbbb190 ['ca5c7910044048c8d52542b54fc179d292866487e4290614c2760486514bd397', 'cba646b446e735cabd8548774cdf7fcc3c5ce876a7e56e50d00430721bbbb190'] B "the controller plane corresponds to the aggregation of the control and management planes discussed in rfc7426 and rfc8655. while more details of any detnet controller plane are out of the scope of this document, there are particular considerations and requirements for such that result from the unique characteristics of the detnet architecture rfc8655 and data plane as defined herein." {84: 1, 67: 1} {150: 1, 316: 1} {316, 317, 150} 68 "As discussed in sec_intro, this document does not specify the mechanisms needed to eliminate packet contention, packet loss or reduce jitter for DetNet flows at the DetNet forwarding sub-layer. The ability to manage node and link resources to be able to provide these functions is a necessary part of the DetNet controller plane. It is also necessary to be able to control the required queuing mechanisms used to provide these functions along a flow's path through the network. See I-D.ietf-detnet-ip and control-management- requirements for further discussion of these requirements." changes look good 9b5906939d7fc5f5c463322e3063c95e1ec9ac88 9b5906939d7fc5f5c463322e3063c95e1ec9ac88 draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework f82aadda4024e265c92d63bcb59028df221f122155e57383bda57423f014d8d8 ['3f11b1065f913725ac7261896cbd2188207be104e9d9eab07de0f7b46e9a68d5', 'c17efa863a8efd1106e92fd2a304456fe1964f3cdfc9d34f7d3aece6237b85cb', 'e1ed9c5b2caa93138014c5466477c3bfcf65cce7faf991398470715fc69bbf9a', 'f82aadda4024e265c92d63bcb59028df221f122155e57383bda57423f014d8d8'] A "as discussed in sec_intro, this document does not specify the mechanisms needed to eliminate packet contention, packet loss or reduce jitter for detnet flows at the detnet forwarding sub-layer. the ability to manage node and link resources to be able to provide these functions is a necessary part of the detnet controller plane. it is also necessary to be able to control the required queuing mechanisms used to provide these functions along a flow's path through the network. see i-d.ietf-detnet-ip and control-management- requirements for further discussion of these requirements." {6: 1, 8: 2} {301: 1, 148: 2} {98, 148, 301} 68 "DetNet applications typically generate bidirectional traffic. IP and MPLS typically treat each direction separately and do not force interdependence of each direction. MPLS has considered bidirectional traffic requirements and the MPLS definitions from RFC5654 are useful to illustrate terms such as associated bidirectional flows and co- routed bidirectional flows. MPLS defines a point-to-point associated bidirectional LSP as consisting of two unidirectional point-to-point LSPs, one from A to B and the other from B to A, which are regarded as providing a single logical bidirectional forwarding path. This is analogous to standard IP routing. MPLS defines a point-to-point co- routed bidirectional LSP as an associated bidirectional LSP which satisfies the additional constraint that its two unidirectional component LSPs follow the same path (in terms of both nodes and links) in both directions. An important property of co-routed bidirectional LSPs is that their unidirectional component LSPs share fate. In both types of bidirectional LSPs, resource reservations may differ in each direction. The concepts of associated bidirectional flows and co-routed bidirectional flows can also be applied to DetNet IP flows." changes look good 9b5906939d7fc5f5c463322e3063c95e1ec9ac88 9b5906939d7fc5f5c463322e3063c95e1ec9ac88 draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework c17efa863a8efd1106e92fd2a304456fe1964f3cdfc9d34f7d3aece6237b85cb ['3f11b1065f913725ac7261896cbd2188207be104e9d9eab07de0f7b46e9a68d5', 'c17efa863a8efd1106e92fd2a304456fe1964f3cdfc9d34f7d3aece6237b85cb', 'e1ed9c5b2caa93138014c5466477c3bfcf65cce7faf991398470715fc69bbf9a', 'f82aadda4024e265c92d63bcb59028df221f122155e57383bda57423f014d8d8'] A "detnet applications typically generate bidirectional traffic. ip and mpls typically treat each direction separately and do not force interdependence of each direction. mpls has considered bidirectional traffic requirements and the mpls definitions from rfc5654 are useful to illustrate terms such as associated bidirectional flows and co- routed bidirectional flows. mpls defines a point-to-point associated bidirectional lsp as consisting of two unidirectional point-to-point lsps, one from a to b and the other from b to a, which are regarded as providing a single logical bidirectional forwarding path. this is analogous to standard ip routing. mpls defines a point-to-point co- routed bidirectional lsp as an associated bidirectional lsp which satisfies the additional constraint that its two unidirectional component lsps follow the same path (in terms of both nodes and links) in both directions. an important property of co-routed bidirectional lsps is that their unidirectional component lsps share fate. in both types of bidirectional lsps, resource reservations may differ in each direction. the concepts of associated bidirectional flows and co-routed bidirectional flows can also be applied to detnet ip flows." {6: 1, 8: 2} {301: 1, 148: 2} {98, 148, 301} 68 "As discussed in sec_intro, this document does not specify the mechanisms needed to eliminate packet contention, packet loss or reduce jitter for DetNet flows at the DetNet forwarding sub-layer. The ability to manage node and link resources to be able to provide these functions is a necessary part of the DetNet controller plane. It is also necessary to be able to control the required queuing mechanisms used to provide these functions along a flow's path through the network. See I-D.ietf-detnet-ip and control-management- requirements for further discussion of these requirements. Some forms of protection may minimize packet loss or change jitter characteristics in the cases where packets are reordered when out-of- order packets are received at the service sub-layer." changes look good 9b5906939d7fc5f5c463322e3063c95e1ec9ac88 9b5906939d7fc5f5c463322e3063c95e1ec9ac88 draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework 3f11b1065f913725ac7261896cbd2188207be104e9d9eab07de0f7b46e9a68d5 ['3f11b1065f913725ac7261896cbd2188207be104e9d9eab07de0f7b46e9a68d5', 'c17efa863a8efd1106e92fd2a304456fe1964f3cdfc9d34f7d3aece6237b85cb', 'e1ed9c5b2caa93138014c5466477c3bfcf65cce7faf991398470715fc69bbf9a', 'f82aadda4024e265c92d63bcb59028df221f122155e57383bda57423f014d8d8'] B "as discussed in sec_intro, this document does not specify the mechanisms needed to eliminate packet contention, packet loss or reduce jitter for detnet flows at the detnet forwarding sub-layer. the ability to manage node and link resources to be able to provide these functions is a necessary part of the detnet controller plane. it is also necessary to be able to control the required queuing mechanisms used to provide these functions along a flow's path through the network. see i-d.ietf-detnet-ip and control-management- requirements for further discussion of these requirements. some forms of protection may minimize packet loss or change jitter characteristics in the cases where packets are reordered when out-of- order packets are received at the service sub-layer." {6: 1, 8: 2} {301: 1, 148: 2} {98, 148, 301} 68 "In many cases DetNet flows can be considered unidirectional and independent. However, there are cases where the DetNet service requires bidirectional traffic from a DetNet application service perspective. IP and MPLS typically treat each direction separately and do not force interdependence of each direction. MPLS has considered bidirectional traffic requirements and the MPLS definitions from RFC5654 are useful to illustrate terms such as associated bidirectional flows and co-routed bidirectional flows. MPLS defines a point-to-point associated bidirectional LSP as consisting of two unidirectional point-to-point LSPs, one from A to B and the other from B to A, which are regarded as providing a single logical bidirectional forwarding path. This is analogous to standard IP routing. MPLS defines a point-to-point co-routed bidirectional LSP as an associated bidirectional LSP which satisfies the additional constraint that its two unidirectional component LSPs follow the same path (in terms of both nodes and links) in both directions. An important property of co-routed bidirectional LSPs is that their unidirectional component LSPs share fate. In both types of bidirectional LSPs, resource reservations may differ in each direction. The concepts of associated bidirectional flows and co- routed bidirectional flows can also be applied to DetNet IP flows." changes look good 9b5906939d7fc5f5c463322e3063c95e1ec9ac88 9b5906939d7fc5f5c463322e3063c95e1ec9ac88 draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework e1ed9c5b2caa93138014c5466477c3bfcf65cce7faf991398470715fc69bbf9a ['3f11b1065f913725ac7261896cbd2188207be104e9d9eab07de0f7b46e9a68d5', 'c17efa863a8efd1106e92fd2a304456fe1964f3cdfc9d34f7d3aece6237b85cb', 'e1ed9c5b2caa93138014c5466477c3bfcf65cce7faf991398470715fc69bbf9a', 'f82aadda4024e265c92d63bcb59028df221f122155e57383bda57423f014d8d8'] B "in many cases detnet flows can be considered unidirectional and independent. however, there are cases where the detnet service requires bidirectional traffic from a detnet application service perspective. ip and mpls typically treat each direction separately and do not force interdependence of each direction. mpls has considered bidirectional traffic requirements and the mpls definitions from rfc5654 are useful to illustrate terms such as associated bidirectional flows and co-routed bidirectional flows. mpls defines a point-to-point associated bidirectional lsp as consisting of two unidirectional point-to-point lsps, one from a to b and the other from b to a, which are regarded as providing a single logical bidirectional forwarding path. this is analogous to standard ip routing. mpls defines a point-to-point co-routed bidirectional lsp as an associated bidirectional lsp which satisfies the additional constraint that its two unidirectional component lsps follow the same path (in terms of both nodes and links) in both directions. an important property of co-routed bidirectional lsps is that their unidirectional component lsps share fate. in both types of bidirectional lsps, resource reservations may differ in each direction. the concepts of associated bidirectional flows and co- routed bidirectional flows can also be applied to detnet ip flows." {6: 1, 8: 2} {301: 1, 148: 2} {98, 148, 301} 68 This document makes no IANA requests. changes look good 9b5906939d7fc5f5c463322e3063c95e1ec9ac88 9b5906939d7fc5f5c463322e3063c95e1ec9ac88 draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework 1ae40f923a31c9855ea35e19223c5ac5c245b5a04b534247e4810aae94fc12af ['1ae40f923a31c9855ea35e19223c5ac5c245b5a04b534247e4810aae94fc12af'] B this document makes no iana requests. {88: 1} {213: 1} {213, 29} 67 "Deterministic Networking (DetNet) is a service that can be offered by a network to DetNet flows. DetNet provides these flows with a low packet loss rates and assured maximum end-to-end delivery latency. General background and concepts of DetNet can be found in I-D.ietf- detnet-architecture." "Update references , fix nits , fix one minor change as discussed on list ( IP doc ) add new revisions for submission to IESG : ip , mpls , ip - over - mpls , mpls - over - udp - ip please merge and upload mpls / IDs / draft - ietf - detnet - mpls- mpls - over - udp - ip / IDs / draft - ietf - detnet - mpls - over - udp - ip- ip - over - mpls / IDs / draft - ietf - detnet - ip - over - mpls- ip / IDs / draft - ietf - detnet - ip- OK . Thanks for the updates . B." afbab6972936aa8e00398f77148290ca8cdb6383 afbab6972936aa8e00398f77148290ca8cdb6383 draft-ietf-detnet-mpls-over-tsn 3d716739e661873cd0f36b5c496d8e17986829051d23d574f690a45927327f6e ['ae28cb0a308d03152114382b4e0008780ef2c0ec9dd53479488e7465c6b923a9', '3d716739e661873cd0f36b5c496d8e17986829051d23d574f690a45927327f6e'] A "deterministic networking (detnet) is a service that can be offered by a network to detnet flows. detnet provides these flows with a low packet loss rates and assured maximum end-to-end delivery latency. general background and concepts of detnet can be found in i-d.ietf- detnet-architecture." {64: 1, 130: 1, 52: 3, 67: 2, 124: 2} {133: 1, 269: 1, 391: 3, 305: 2, 158: 2} {133, 391, 268, 269, 305, 158} 67 "Deterministic Networking (DetNet) is a service that can be offered by a network to DetNet flows. DetNet provides these flows with a low packet loss rates and assured maximum end-to-end delivery latency. General background and concepts of DetNet can be found in RFC8655." "Update references , fix nits , fix one minor change as discussed on list ( IP doc ) add new revisions for submission to IESG : ip , mpls , ip - over - mpls , mpls - over - udp - ip please merge and upload mpls / IDs / draft - ietf - detnet - mpls- mpls - over - udp - ip / IDs / draft - ietf - detnet - mpls - over - udp - ip- ip - over - mpls / IDs / draft - ietf - detnet - ip - over - mpls- ip / IDs / draft - ietf - detnet - ip- OK . Thanks for the updates . B." afbab6972936aa8e00398f77148290ca8cdb6383 afbab6972936aa8e00398f77148290ca8cdb6383 draft-ietf-detnet-mpls-over-tsn ae28cb0a308d03152114382b4e0008780ef2c0ec9dd53479488e7465c6b923a9 ['ae28cb0a308d03152114382b4e0008780ef2c0ec9dd53479488e7465c6b923a9', '3d716739e661873cd0f36b5c496d8e17986829051d23d574f690a45927327f6e'] B "deterministic networking (detnet) is a service that can be offered by a network to detnet flows. detnet provides these flows with a low packet loss rates and assured maximum end-to-end delivery latency. general background and concepts of detnet can be found in rfc8655." {64: 1, 130: 1, 52: 3, 67: 2, 124: 2} {133: 1, 269: 1, 391: 3, 305: 2, 158: 2} {133, 391, 268, 269, 305, 158} 67 "This document uses the terminology established in the DetNet architecture I-D.ietf-detnet-architecture and I-D.ietf-detnet-mpls, and the reader is assumed to be familiar with that document and its terminology." "Update references , fix nits , fix one minor change as discussed on list ( IP doc ) add new revisions for submission to IESG : ip , mpls , ip - over - mpls , mpls - over - udp - ip please merge and upload mpls / IDs / draft - ietf - detnet - mpls- mpls - over - udp - ip / IDs / draft - ietf - detnet - mpls - over - udp - ip- ip - over - mpls / IDs / draft - ietf - detnet - ip - over - mpls- ip / IDs / draft - ietf - detnet - ip- OK . Thanks for the updates . B." afbab6972936aa8e00398f77148290ca8cdb6383 afbab6972936aa8e00398f77148290ca8cdb6383 draft-ietf-detnet-mpls-over-tsn 0dd575583d4427fd1c98abc06595c8d3719b98bf537e86e8c3f332281f235909 ['31af09b736a8cb73f208bdf69e547e2bda95b885b778794fe7c9568fee6ad9ee', '0dd575583d4427fd1c98abc06595c8d3719b98bf537e86e8c3f332281f235909'] A "this document uses the terminology established in the detnet architecture i-d.ietf-detnet-architecture and i-d.ietf-detnet-mpls, and the reader is assumed to be familiar with that document and its terminology." {52: 1, 130: 1, 79: 2, 51: 2, 112: 3, 55: 3, 64: 2, 62: 3, 37: 2, 38: 3, 69: 2, 68: 2, 67: 2, 33: 2, 25: 2, 53: 2, 80: 2, 127: 4, 91: 3} {321: 1, 399: 1, 0: 3, 389: 2, 390: 2, 135: 3, 142: 3, 14: 2, 400: 3, 17: 2, 19: 3, 149: 3, 406: 2, 279: 2, 280: 2, 281: 3, 278: 2, 294: 2, 296: 3, 45: 3, 308: 2, 56: 2, 185: 2, 192: 2, 322: 2, 196: 5, 197: 4, 324: 3, 77: 3, 78: 3, 337: 2, 216: 3, 380: 2, 255: 3} {0, 389, 390, 135, 142, 14, 400, 17, 399, 19, 149, 406, 279, 280, 281, 278, 294, 296, 45, 308, 56, 185, 192, 321, 322, 66, 196, 197, 324, 77, 78, 337, 216, 380, 255} 67 "This document uses the terminology established in the DetNet architecture RFC8655 and I-D.ietf-detnet-mpls, and the reader is assumed to be familiar with that document and its terminology." "Update references , fix nits , fix one minor change as discussed on list ( IP doc ) add new revisions for submission to IESG : ip , mpls , ip - over - mpls , mpls - over - udp - ip please merge and upload mpls / IDs / draft - ietf - detnet - mpls- mpls - over - udp - ip / IDs / draft - ietf - detnet - mpls - over - udp - ip- ip - over - mpls / IDs / draft - ietf - detnet - ip - over - mpls- ip / IDs / draft - ietf - detnet - ip- OK . Thanks for the updates . B." afbab6972936aa8e00398f77148290ca8cdb6383 afbab6972936aa8e00398f77148290ca8cdb6383 draft-ietf-detnet-mpls-over-tsn 31af09b736a8cb73f208bdf69e547e2bda95b885b778794fe7c9568fee6ad9ee ['31af09b736a8cb73f208bdf69e547e2bda95b885b778794fe7c9568fee6ad9ee', '0dd575583d4427fd1c98abc06595c8d3719b98bf537e86e8c3f332281f235909'] B "this document uses the terminology established in the detnet architecture rfc8655 and i-d.ietf-detnet-mpls, and the reader is assumed to be familiar with that document and its terminology." {52: 1, 130: 1, 79: 2, 51: 2, 112: 3, 55: 3, 64: 2, 62: 3, 37: 2, 38: 3, 69: 2, 68: 2, 67: 2, 33: 2, 25: 2, 53: 2, 80: 2, 127: 4, 91: 3} {321: 1, 399: 1, 0: 3, 389: 2, 390: 2, 135: 3, 142: 3, 14: 2, 400: 3, 17: 2, 19: 3, 149: 3, 406: 2, 279: 2, 280: 2, 281: 3, 278: 2, 294: 2, 296: 3, 45: 3, 308: 2, 56: 2, 185: 2, 192: 2, 322: 2, 196: 5, 197: 4, 324: 3, 77: 3, 78: 3, 337: 2, 216: 3, 380: 2, 255: 3} {0, 389, 390, 135, 142, 14, 400, 17, 399, 19, 149, 406, 279, 280, 281, 278, 294, 296, 45, 308, 56, 185, 192, 321, 322, 66, 196, 197, 324, 77, 78, 337, 216, 380, 255} 67 "As described in the DetNet architecture I-D.ietf-detnet-architecture and also illustrated here in fig_mpls_detnet_part a sub-network provides from MPLS perspective a single hop connection between MPLS (DetNet) nodes. Functions used for resource allocation and explicit routes are treated as domain internal functions and does not require function interworking across the DetNet MPLS network and the TSN sub- network." "Update references , fix nits , fix one minor change as discussed on list ( IP doc ) add new revisions for submission to IESG : ip , mpls , ip - over - mpls , mpls - over - udp - ip please merge and upload mpls / IDs / draft - ietf - detnet - mpls- mpls - over - udp - ip / IDs / draft - ietf - detnet - mpls - over - udp - ip- ip - over - mpls / IDs / draft - ietf - detnet - ip - over - mpls- ip / IDs / draft - ietf - detnet - ip- OK . Thanks for the updates . B." afbab6972936aa8e00398f77148290ca8cdb6383 afbab6972936aa8e00398f77148290ca8cdb6383 draft-ietf-detnet-mpls-over-tsn 5324bae9de9c301e9f6c475f9348fb2673813fe613070bb08ffd35c8a0e54204 ['f5449b9a284f19507d5c9e268b9034c6f005352fd0bcdab4d25a7d97f8b01179', '5324bae9de9c301e9f6c475f9348fb2673813fe613070bb08ffd35c8a0e54204'] A "as described in the detnet architecture i-d.ietf-detnet-architecture and also illustrated here in fig_mpls_detnet_part a sub-network provides from mpls perspective a single hop connection between mpls (detnet) nodes. functions used for resource allocation and explicit routes are treated as domain internal functions and does not require function interworking across the detnet mpls network and the tsn sub- network." {52: 1, 124: 1, 6: 2, 79: 3, 90: 4, 51: 4, 130: 3, 62: 5, 85: 5, 68: 4, 35: 4, 110: 4, 91: 6, 114: 4, 97: 4, 31: 2, 13: 4, 67: 4, 38: 5, 26: 4, 98: 3, 54: 3, 127: 4, 8: 2, 96: 4, 64: 3, 30: 5, 61: 6, 55: 3, 27: 3, 15: 4, 129: 4, 115: 4, 84: 3, 76: 5, 87: 4, 131: 6, 102: 4, 113: 6, 99: 3, 36: 4, 24: 3, 53: 2, 72: 5} {215: 1, 393: 1, 1: 9, 4: 3, 9: 4, 10: 4, 15: 4, 24: 3, 25: 5, 26: 5, 27: 4, 39: 5, 43: 4, 49: 7, 50: 6, 58: 6, 59: 3, 64: 4, 69: 3, 81: 6, 82: 5, 86: 4, 96: 5, 97: 4, 100: 8, 108: 4, 109: 5, 110: 5, 111: 3, 114: 4, 115: 5, 116: 4, 118: 6, 119: 5, 120: 4, 121: 4, 122: 5, 123: 4, 124: 4, 128: 5, 129: 5, 130: 6, 132: 3, 136: 3, 145: 3, 147: 5, 151: 5, 152: 5, 154: 4, 156: 3, 161: 2, 162: 3, 165: 4, 168: 5, 169: 4, 172: 4, 180: 5, 184: 4, 187: 6, 188: 5, 191: 4, 194: 3, 202: 4, 203: 5, 206: 3, 207: 4, 217: 4, 218: 8, 220: 2, 221: 2, 222: 5, 224: 4, 227: 6, 229: 4, 234: 6, 235: 3, 241: 3, 242: 3, 243: 3, 244: 5, 245: 3, 248: 5, 250: 5, 258: 11, 262: 5, 263: 6, 264: 2, 267: 4, 270: 4, 272: 4, 273: 4, 287: 4, 289: 4, 291: 6, 299: 6, 300: 4, 304: 4, 309: 3, 314: 3, 315: 4, 320: 4, 323: 3, 327: 5, 328: 2, 329: 3, 330: 10, 334: 3, 335: 4, 341: 6, 342: 7, 347: 6, 348: 6, 350: 6, 351: 6, 352: 4, 353: 4, 354: 3, 358: 4, 365: 4, 366: 3, 369: 2, 371: 8, 372: 6, 376: 3, 384: 6, 385: 5, 386: 4, 387: 4, 396: 7, 397: 7, 398: 6, 402: 4} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 67 "As described in the DetNet architecture RFC8655 and also illustrated here in fig_mpls_detnet_part a sub-network provides from MPLS perspective a single hop connection between MPLS (DetNet) nodes. Functions used for resource allocation and explicit routes are treated as domain internal functions and does not require function interworking across the DetNet MPLS network and the TSN sub-network." "Update references , fix nits , fix one minor change as discussed on list ( IP doc ) add new revisions for submission to IESG : ip , mpls , ip - over - mpls , mpls - over - udp - ip please merge and upload mpls / IDs / draft - ietf - detnet - mpls- mpls - over - udp - ip / IDs / draft - ietf - detnet - mpls - over - udp - ip- ip - over - mpls / IDs / draft - ietf - detnet - ip - over - mpls- ip / IDs / draft - ietf - detnet - ip- OK . Thanks for the updates . B." afbab6972936aa8e00398f77148290ca8cdb6383 afbab6972936aa8e00398f77148290ca8cdb6383 draft-ietf-detnet-mpls-over-tsn f5449b9a284f19507d5c9e268b9034c6f005352fd0bcdab4d25a7d97f8b01179 ['f5449b9a284f19507d5c9e268b9034c6f005352fd0bcdab4d25a7d97f8b01179', '5324bae9de9c301e9f6c475f9348fb2673813fe613070bb08ffd35c8a0e54204'] B "as described in the detnet architecture rfc8655 and also illustrated here in fig_mpls_detnet_part a sub-network provides from mpls perspective a single hop connection between mpls (detnet) nodes. functions used for resource allocation and explicit routes are treated as domain internal functions and does not require function interworking across the detnet mpls network and the tsn sub-network." {52: 1, 124: 1, 6: 2, 79: 3, 90: 4, 51: 4, 130: 3, 62: 5, 85: 5, 68: 4, 35: 4, 110: 4, 91: 6, 114: 4, 97: 4, 31: 2, 13: 4, 67: 4, 38: 5, 26: 4, 98: 3, 54: 3, 127: 4, 8: 2, 96: 4, 64: 3, 30: 5, 61: 6, 55: 3, 27: 3, 15: 4, 129: 4, 115: 4, 84: 3, 76: 5, 87: 4, 131: 6, 102: 4, 113: 6, 99: 3, 36: 4, 24: 3, 53: 2, 72: 5} {215: 1, 393: 1, 1: 9, 4: 3, 9: 4, 10: 4, 15: 4, 24: 3, 25: 5, 26: 5, 27: 4, 39: 5, 43: 4, 49: 7, 50: 6, 58: 6, 59: 3, 64: 4, 69: 3, 81: 6, 82: 5, 86: 4, 96: 5, 97: 4, 100: 8, 108: 4, 109: 5, 110: 5, 111: 3, 114: 4, 115: 5, 116: 4, 118: 6, 119: 5, 120: 4, 121: 4, 122: 5, 123: 4, 124: 4, 128: 5, 129: 5, 130: 6, 132: 3, 136: 3, 145: 3, 147: 5, 151: 5, 152: 5, 154: 4, 156: 3, 161: 2, 162: 3, 165: 4, 168: 5, 169: 4, 172: 4, 180: 5, 184: 4, 187: 6, 188: 5, 191: 4, 194: 3, 202: 4, 203: 5, 206: 3, 207: 4, 217: 4, 218: 8, 220: 2, 221: 2, 222: 5, 224: 4, 227: 6, 229: 4, 234: 6, 235: 3, 241: 3, 242: 3, 243: 3, 244: 5, 245: 3, 248: 5, 250: 5, 258: 11, 262: 5, 263: 6, 264: 2, 267: 4, 270: 4, 272: 4, 273: 4, 287: 4, 289: 4, 291: 6, 299: 6, 300: 4, 304: 4, 309: 3, 314: 3, 315: 4, 320: 4, 323: 3, 327: 5, 328: 2, 329: 3, 330: 10, 334: 3, 335: 4, 341: 6, 342: 7, 347: 6, 348: 6, 350: 6, 351: 6, 352: 4, 353: 4, 354: 3, 358: 4, 365: 4, 366: 3, 369: 2, 371: 8, 372: 6, 376: 3, 384: 6, 385: 5, 386: 4, 387: 4, 396: 7, 397: 7, 398: 6, 402: 4} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 67 "The Time-Sensitive Networking Task Group (TSN TG) within IEEE 802.1 Working Group deals with deterministic services through IEEE 802 networks. Deterministic Networking (DetNet) defined by IETF is a service that can be offered by a L3 network to DetNet flows. General background and concepts of DetNet can be found in I-D.ietf-detnet- architecture." "Update references , fix nits , fix one minor change as discussed on list ( IP doc ) add new revisions for submission to IESG : ip , mpls , ip - over - mpls , mpls - over - udp - ip please merge and upload mpls / IDs / draft - ietf - detnet - mpls- mpls - over - udp - ip / IDs / draft - ietf - detnet - mpls - over - udp - ip- ip - over - mpls / IDs / draft - ietf - detnet - ip - over - mpls- ip / IDs / draft - ietf - detnet - ip- OK . Thanks for the updates . B." afbab6972936aa8e00398f77148290ca8cdb6383 afbab6972936aa8e00398f77148290ca8cdb6383 draft-ietf-detnet-tsn-vpn-over-mpls 41da8cc1d1b5b4bc6079224be7d1964e3e96805bc2fa507df55caba9874e48e4 ['a36e03ddbd138ebab4f165cc0e6fdef67bbceaed902502ca6fc8b834c04a0149', '41da8cc1d1b5b4bc6079224be7d1964e3e96805bc2fa507df55caba9874e48e4'] A "the time-sensitive networking task group (tsn tg) within ieee 802.1 working group deals with deterministic services through ieee 802 networks. deterministic networking (detnet) defined by ietf is a service that can be offered by a l3 network to detnet flows. general background and concepts of detnet can be found in i-d.ietf-detnet- architecture." {53: 1, 130: 2, 79: 3, 51: 3, 112: 4, 55: 4, 64: 2, 62: 4, 37: 3, 38: 3, 69: 3, 68: 3, 67: 2, 33: 2, 25: 3, 80: 3, 52: 2, 127: 3, 91: 4} {322: 1, 0: 2, 389: 3, 390: 3, 135: 4, 142: 4, 14: 2, 400: 4, 17: 3, 399: 4, 19: 3, 149: 4, 406: 3, 279: 3, 280: 3, 281: 2, 278: 2, 294: 3, 296: 4, 45: 4, 308: 3, 56: 2, 185: 3, 192: 3, 321: 2, 66: 3, 196: 4, 197: 3, 324: 3, 77: 4, 78: 4, 337: 5, 216: 4, 380: 3} {0, 389, 390, 135, 142, 14, 400, 17, 399, 19, 149, 406, 279, 280, 281, 278, 294, 296, 45, 308, 56, 185, 192, 321, 322, 66, 196, 197, 324, 77, 78, 337, 216, 380, 255} 67 "The Time-Sensitive Networking Task Group (TSN TG) within IEEE 802.1 Working Group deals with deterministic services through IEEE 802 networks. Deterministic Networking (DetNet) defined by IETF is a service that can be offered by a L3 network to DetNet flows. General background and concepts of DetNet can be found in RFC8655." "Update references , fix nits , fix one minor change as discussed on list ( IP doc ) add new revisions for submission to IESG : ip , mpls , ip - over - mpls , mpls - over - udp - ip please merge and upload mpls / IDs / draft - ietf - detnet - mpls- mpls - over - udp - ip / IDs / draft - ietf - detnet - mpls - over - udp - ip- ip - over - mpls / IDs / draft - ietf - detnet - ip - over - mpls- ip / IDs / draft - ietf - detnet - ip- OK . Thanks for the updates . B." afbab6972936aa8e00398f77148290ca8cdb6383 afbab6972936aa8e00398f77148290ca8cdb6383 draft-ietf-detnet-tsn-vpn-over-mpls a36e03ddbd138ebab4f165cc0e6fdef67bbceaed902502ca6fc8b834c04a0149 ['a36e03ddbd138ebab4f165cc0e6fdef67bbceaed902502ca6fc8b834c04a0149', '41da8cc1d1b5b4bc6079224be7d1964e3e96805bc2fa507df55caba9874e48e4'] B "the time-sensitive networking task group (tsn tg) within ieee 802.1 working group deals with deterministic services through ieee 802 networks. deterministic networking (detnet) defined by ietf is a service that can be offered by a l3 network to detnet flows. general background and concepts of detnet can be found in rfc8655." {53: 1, 130: 2, 79: 3, 51: 3, 112: 4, 55: 4, 64: 2, 62: 4, 37: 3, 38: 3, 69: 3, 68: 3, 67: 2, 33: 2, 25: 3, 80: 3, 52: 2, 127: 3, 91: 4} {322: 1, 0: 2, 389: 3, 390: 3, 135: 4, 142: 4, 14: 2, 400: 4, 17: 3, 399: 4, 19: 3, 149: 4, 406: 3, 279: 3, 280: 3, 281: 2, 278: 2, 294: 3, 296: 4, 45: 4, 308: 3, 56: 2, 185: 3, 192: 3, 321: 2, 66: 3, 196: 4, 197: 3, 324: 3, 77: 4, 78: 4, 337: 5, 216: 4, 380: 3} {0, 389, 390, 135, 142, 14, 400, 17, 399, 19, 149, 406, 279, 280, 281, 278, 294, 296, 45, 308, 56, 185, 192, 321, 322, 66, 196, 197, 324, 77, 78, 337, 216, 380, 255} 67 "This document uses the terminology and concepts established in the DetNet architecture I-D.ietf-detnet-architecture and I-D.ietf-detnet- data-plane-framework, and I-D.ietf-detnet-mpls. The reader is assumed to be familiar with these documents and their terminology." "Update references , fix nits , fix one minor change as discussed on list ( IP doc ) add new revisions for submission to IESG : ip , mpls , ip - over - mpls , mpls - over - udp - ip please merge and upload mpls / IDs / draft - ietf - detnet - mpls- mpls - over - udp - ip / IDs / draft - ietf - detnet - mpls - over - udp - ip- ip - over - mpls / IDs / draft - ietf - detnet - ip - over - mpls- ip / IDs / draft - ietf - detnet - ip- OK . Thanks for the updates . B." afbab6972936aa8e00398f77148290ca8cdb6383 afbab6972936aa8e00398f77148290ca8cdb6383 draft-ietf-detnet-tsn-vpn-over-mpls 9b5c5844768e19db649b44b3150e50cd8e12a4cee15d559ee61213e3602f502b ['b4be4bc772f37db441ba242ca8ca530a4ce79dd949586ca4ffb864fe93265792', '9b5c5844768e19db649b44b3150e50cd8e12a4cee15d559ee61213e3602f502b'] A "this document uses the terminology and concepts established in the detnet architecture i-d.ietf-detnet-architecture and i-d.ietf-detnet- data-plane-framework, and i-d.ietf-detnet-mpls. the reader is assumed to be familiar with these documents and their terminology." {127: 1, 53: 1, 130: 2, 79: 3, 51: 3, 112: 4, 55: 4, 64: 2, 62: 4, 37: 3, 38: 3, 69: 3, 68: 3, 33: 2, 25: 3, 67: 2, 80: 3, 52: 2, 91: 4} {197: 1, 322: 1, 0: 2, 389: 3, 390: 3, 135: 4, 142: 4, 14: 2, 400: 4, 17: 3, 399: 4, 19: 3, 149: 4, 406: 3, 279: 3, 280: 3, 278: 2, 294: 3, 296: 4, 45: 4, 308: 3, 56: 2, 185: 3, 192: 3, 321: 2, 66: 3, 196: 2, 324: 3, 77: 4, 78: 4, 337: 5, 216: 4, 380: 3, 255: 2} {0, 389, 390, 135, 142, 14, 400, 17, 399, 19, 149, 406, 279, 280, 281, 278, 294, 296, 45, 308, 56, 185, 192, 321, 322, 66, 196, 197, 324, 77, 78, 337, 216, 380, 255} 67 "This document uses the terminology and concepts established in the DetNet architecture RFC8655 and I-D.ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework, and I-D.ietf-detnet-mpls. The reader is assumed to be familiar with these documents and their terminology." "Update references , fix nits , fix one minor change as discussed on list ( IP doc ) add new revisions for submission to IESG : ip , mpls , ip - over - mpls , mpls - over - udp - ip please merge and upload mpls / IDs / draft - ietf - detnet - mpls- mpls - over - udp - ip / IDs / draft - ietf - detnet - mpls - over - udp - ip- ip - over - mpls / IDs / draft - ietf - detnet - ip - over - mpls- ip / IDs / draft - ietf - detnet - ip- OK . Thanks for the updates . B." afbab6972936aa8e00398f77148290ca8cdb6383 afbab6972936aa8e00398f77148290ca8cdb6383 draft-ietf-detnet-tsn-vpn-over-mpls b4be4bc772f37db441ba242ca8ca530a4ce79dd949586ca4ffb864fe93265792 ['b4be4bc772f37db441ba242ca8ca530a4ce79dd949586ca4ffb864fe93265792', '9b5c5844768e19db649b44b3150e50cd8e12a4cee15d559ee61213e3602f502b'] B "this document uses the terminology and concepts established in the detnet architecture rfc8655 and i-d.ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework, and i-d.ietf-detnet-mpls. the reader is assumed to be familiar with these documents and their terminology." {127: 1, 53: 1, 130: 2, 79: 3, 51: 3, 112: 4, 55: 4, 64: 2, 62: 4, 37: 3, 38: 3, 69: 3, 68: 3, 33: 2, 25: 3, 67: 2, 80: 3, 52: 2, 91: 4} {197: 1, 322: 1, 0: 2, 389: 3, 390: 3, 135: 4, 142: 4, 14: 2, 400: 4, 17: 3, 399: 4, 19: 3, 149: 4, 406: 3, 279: 3, 280: 3, 278: 2, 294: 3, 296: 4, 45: 4, 308: 3, 56: 2, 185: 3, 192: 3, 321: 2, 66: 3, 196: 2, 324: 3, 77: 4, 78: 4, 337: 5, 216: 4, 380: 3, 255: 2} {0, 389, 390, 135, 142, 14, 400, 17, 399, 19, 149, 406, 279, 280, 281, 278, 294, 296, 45, 308, 56, 185, 192, 321, 322, 66, 196, 197, 324, 77, 78, 337, 216, 380, 255} 67 "Security considerations for DetNet are described in detail in I- D.ietf-detnet-security. General security considerations are described in I-D.ietf-detnet-architecture. DetNet MPLS data plane specific considerations are summarized in I-D.ietf-detnet-mpls. The primary considerations for the data plane is to maintain integrity of data and delivery of the associated DetNet service traversing the DetNet network. Application flows can be protected through whatever means is provided by the underlying technology. For example, encryption may be used, such as that provided by IPSec RFC4301 for IP flows and/or by an underlying sub-net using MACSec IEEE802.1AE-2018 for IP over Ethernet (Layer-2) flows." "Update references , fix nits , fix one minor change as discussed on list ( IP doc ) add new revisions for submission to IESG : ip , mpls , ip - over - mpls , mpls - over - udp - ip please merge and upload mpls / IDs / draft - ietf - detnet - mpls- mpls - over - udp - ip / IDs / draft - ietf - detnet - mpls - over - udp - ip- ip - over - mpls / IDs / draft - ietf - detnet - ip - over - mpls- ip / IDs / draft - ietf - detnet - ip- OK . Thanks for the updates . B." afbab6972936aa8e00398f77148290ca8cdb6383 afbab6972936aa8e00398f77148290ca8cdb6383 draft-ietf-detnet-tsn-vpn-over-mpls b6643a8327dedf9a3d90b48af7d54e9564919d5451389e71da900e4fbeb3bcb7 ['b6643a8327dedf9a3d90b48af7d54e9564919d5451389e71da900e4fbeb3bcb7', 'db8b0420da289e9ef760358aa74217460d16b962a48347dda57a7f650bc253ca'] A "security considerations for detnet are described in detail in i- d.ietf-detnet-security. general security considerations are described in i-d.ietf-detnet-architecture. detnet mpls data plane specific considerations are summarized in i-d.ietf-detnet-mpls. the primary considerations for the data plane is to maintain integrity of data and delivery of the associated detnet service traversing the detnet network. application flows can be protected through whatever means is provided by the underlying technology. for example, encryption may be used, such as that provided by ipsec rfc4301 for ip flows and/or by an underlying sub-net using macsec ieee802.1ae-2018 for ip over ethernet (layer-2) flows." {54: 1, 98: 1, 6: 3, 79: 3, 90: 4, 51: 4, 130: 2, 62: 6, 85: 6, 68: 5, 35: 4, 110: 4, 91: 6, 114: 4, 97: 4, 31: 4, 13: 4, 67: 4, 38: 5, 26: 4, 124: 4, 127: 4, 8: 3, 96: 4, 64: 3, 30: 5, 61: 6, 55: 4, 27: 5, 15: 4, 52: 3, 129: 4, 115: 4, 84: 4, 76: 7, 87: 4, 131: 6, 102: 4, 113: 6, 99: 3, 36: 4, 24: 3, 53: 2, 72: 5} {111: 1, 188: 1, 1: 10, 4: 3, 9: 6, 10: 4, 15: 4, 24: 3, 25: 6, 26: 6, 27: 4, 39: 6, 43: 4, 49: 7, 50: 6, 58: 6, 59: 3, 64: 4, 69: 5, 81: 7, 82: 5, 86: 4, 96: 5, 97: 4, 100: 8, 108: 4, 109: 5, 110: 5, 114: 4, 115: 5, 116: 4, 118: 7, 119: 6, 120: 4, 121: 5, 122: 5, 123: 4, 124: 5, 128: 5, 129: 5, 130: 6, 132: 5, 136: 3, 145: 5, 147: 5, 151: 5, 152: 5, 154: 4, 156: 3, 161: 4, 162: 4, 165: 4, 168: 5, 169: 4, 172: 4, 180: 5, 184: 6, 187: 2, 191: 4, 194: 5, 202: 6, 203: 7, 206: 3, 207: 4, 215: 3, 217: 4, 218: 9, 220: 3, 221: 3, 222: 6, 224: 4, 227: 6, 229: 4, 234: 6, 235: 3, 241: 3, 242: 3, 243: 5, 244: 5, 245: 5, 248: 5, 250: 5, 258: 12, 262: 5, 263: 6, 264: 4, 267: 5, 270: 4, 272: 4, 273: 6, 289: 4, 291: 6, 299: 6, 300: 4, 304: 4, 309: 4, 314: 3, 315: 4, 320: 5, 323: 5, 327: 5, 328: 4, 329: 3, 330: 11, 334: 3, 335: 4, 341: 6, 342: 7, 347: 6, 348: 6, 350: 8, 351: 6, 352: 4, 353: 4, 354: 3, 358: 5, 365: 4, 366: 3, 369: 2, 371: 8, 372: 6, 376: 3, 384: 6, 385: 5, 386: 4, 387: 4, 392: 4, 393: 5, 396: 7, 397: 8, 398: 7, 402: 4} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 67 "Security considerations for DetNet are described in detail in I- D.ietf-detnet-security. General security considerations are described in RFC8655. DetNet MPLS data plane specific considerations are summarized in I-D.ietf-detnet-mpls. The primary considerations for the data plane is to maintain integrity of data and delivery of the associated DetNet service traversing the DetNet network. Application flows can be protected through whatever means is provided by the underlying technology. For example, encryption may be used, such as that provided by IPSec RFC4301 for IP flows and/or by an underlying sub-net using MACSec IEEE802.1AE-2018 for IP over Ethernet (Layer-2) flows." "Update references , fix nits , fix one minor change as discussed on list ( IP doc ) add new revisions for submission to IESG : ip , mpls , ip - over - mpls , mpls - over - udp - ip please merge and upload mpls / IDs / draft - ietf - detnet - mpls- mpls - over - udp - ip / IDs / draft - ietf - detnet - mpls - over - udp - ip- ip - over - mpls / IDs / draft - ietf - detnet - ip - over - mpls- ip / IDs / draft - ietf - detnet - ip- OK . Thanks for the updates . B." afbab6972936aa8e00398f77148290ca8cdb6383 afbab6972936aa8e00398f77148290ca8cdb6383 draft-ietf-detnet-tsn-vpn-over-mpls db8b0420da289e9ef760358aa74217460d16b962a48347dda57a7f650bc253ca ['b6643a8327dedf9a3d90b48af7d54e9564919d5451389e71da900e4fbeb3bcb7', 'db8b0420da289e9ef760358aa74217460d16b962a48347dda57a7f650bc253ca'] B "security considerations for detnet are described in detail in i- d.ietf-detnet-security. general security considerations are described in rfc8655. detnet mpls data plane specific considerations are summarized in i-d.ietf-detnet-mpls. the primary considerations for the data plane is to maintain integrity of data and delivery of the associated detnet service traversing the detnet network. application flows can be protected through whatever means is provided by the underlying technology. for example, encryption may be used, such as that provided by ipsec rfc4301 for ip flows and/or by an underlying sub-net using macsec ieee802.1ae-2018 for ip over ethernet (layer-2) flows." {54: 1, 98: 1, 6: 3, 79: 3, 90: 4, 51: 4, 130: 2, 62: 6, 85: 6, 68: 5, 35: 4, 110: 4, 91: 6, 114: 4, 97: 4, 31: 4, 13: 4, 67: 4, 38: 5, 26: 4, 124: 4, 127: 4, 8: 3, 96: 4, 64: 3, 30: 5, 61: 6, 55: 4, 27: 5, 15: 4, 52: 3, 129: 4, 115: 4, 84: 4, 76: 7, 87: 4, 131: 6, 102: 4, 113: 6, 99: 3, 36: 4, 24: 3, 53: 2, 72: 5} {111: 1, 188: 1, 1: 10, 4: 3, 9: 6, 10: 4, 15: 4, 24: 3, 25: 6, 26: 6, 27: 4, 39: 6, 43: 4, 49: 7, 50: 6, 58: 6, 59: 3, 64: 4, 69: 5, 81: 7, 82: 5, 86: 4, 96: 5, 97: 4, 100: 8, 108: 4, 109: 5, 110: 5, 114: 4, 115: 5, 116: 4, 118: 7, 119: 6, 120: 4, 121: 5, 122: 5, 123: 4, 124: 5, 128: 5, 129: 5, 130: 6, 132: 5, 136: 3, 145: 5, 147: 5, 151: 5, 152: 5, 154: 4, 156: 3, 161: 4, 162: 4, 165: 4, 168: 5, 169: 4, 172: 4, 180: 5, 184: 6, 187: 2, 191: 4, 194: 5, 202: 6, 203: 7, 206: 3, 207: 4, 215: 3, 217: 4, 218: 9, 220: 3, 221: 3, 222: 6, 224: 4, 227: 6, 229: 4, 234: 6, 235: 3, 241: 3, 242: 3, 243: 5, 244: 5, 245: 5, 248: 5, 250: 5, 258: 12, 262: 5, 263: 6, 264: 4, 267: 5, 270: 4, 272: 4, 273: 6, 289: 4, 291: 6, 299: 6, 300: 4, 304: 4, 309: 4, 314: 3, 315: 4, 320: 5, 323: 5, 327: 5, 328: 4, 329: 3, 330: 11, 334: 3, 335: 4, 341: 6, 342: 7, 347: 6, 348: 6, 350: 8, 351: 6, 352: 4, 353: 4, 354: 3, 358: 5, 365: 4, 366: 3, 369: 2, 371: 8, 372: 6, 376: 3, 384: 6, 385: 5, 386: 4, 387: 4, 392: 4, 393: 5, 396: 7, 397: 8, 398: 7, 402: 4} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 67 "This document uses the terminology and concepts established in the DetNet architecture I-D.ietf-detnet-architecture and I-D.ietf-detnet- data-plane-framework, and the reader is assumed to be familiar with these documents and their terminology." "Update references , fix nits , fix one minor change as discussed on list ( IP doc ) add new revisions for submission to IESG : ip , mpls , ip - over - mpls , mpls - over - udp - ip please merge and upload mpls / IDs / draft - ietf - detnet - mpls- mpls - over - udp - ip / IDs / draft - ietf - detnet - mpls - over - udp - ip- ip - over - mpls / IDs / draft - ietf - detnet - ip - over - mpls- ip / IDs / draft - ietf - detnet - ip- OK . Thanks for the updates . B." afbab6972936aa8e00398f77148290ca8cdb6383 afbab6972936aa8e00398f77148290ca8cdb6383 draft-ietf-detnet-ip-over-mpls d623524a983870d52627d73ed6d226dc8c044930179bd9330d89cf4ab4b2f46c ['497d11183e2eba685b73b7170eff84f3d79ddaaf72c4fdc8a15de42ee591d796', 'd623524a983870d52627d73ed6d226dc8c044930179bd9330d89cf4ab4b2f46c'] A "this document uses the terminology and concepts established in the detnet architecture i-d.ietf-detnet-architecture and i-d.ietf-detnet- data-plane-framework, and the reader is assumed to be familiar with these documents and their terminology." {110: 1} {34: 1} {34, 117} 67 "This document uses the terminology and concepts established in the DetNet architecture RFC8655 and I-D.ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework, and the reader is assumed to be familiar with these documents and their terminology." "Update references , fix nits , fix one minor change as discussed on list ( IP doc ) add new revisions for submission to IESG : ip , mpls , ip - over - mpls , mpls - over - udp - ip please merge and upload mpls / IDs / draft - ietf - detnet - mpls- mpls - over - udp - ip / IDs / draft - ietf - detnet - mpls - over - udp - ip- ip - over - mpls / IDs / draft - ietf - detnet - ip - over - mpls- ip / IDs / draft - ietf - detnet - ip- OK . Thanks for the updates . B." afbab6972936aa8e00398f77148290ca8cdb6383 afbab6972936aa8e00398f77148290ca8cdb6383 draft-ietf-detnet-ip-over-mpls 497d11183e2eba685b73b7170eff84f3d79ddaaf72c4fdc8a15de42ee591d796 ['497d11183e2eba685b73b7170eff84f3d79ddaaf72c4fdc8a15de42ee591d796', 'd623524a983870d52627d73ed6d226dc8c044930179bd9330d89cf4ab4b2f46c'] B "this document uses the terminology and concepts established in the detnet architecture rfc8655 and i-d.ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework, and the reader is assumed to be familiar with these documents and their terminology." {110: 1} {34: 1} {34, 117} 67 "This draft does not have additional security considerations. Security considerations for DetNet are described in detail in I- D.ietf-detnet-security. General security considerations are described in I-D.ietf-detnet-architecture. MPLS and IP specific considerations are described in I-D.ietf-detnet-mpls and I-D.ietf- detnet-ip." "Update references , fix nits , fix one minor change as discussed on list ( IP doc ) add new revisions for submission to IESG : ip , mpls , ip - over - mpls , mpls - over - udp - ip please merge and upload mpls / IDs / draft - ietf - detnet - mpls- mpls - over - udp - ip / IDs / draft - ietf - detnet - mpls - over - udp - ip- ip - over - mpls / IDs / draft - ietf - detnet - ip - over - mpls- ip / IDs / draft - ietf - detnet - ip- OK . Thanks for the updates . B." afbab6972936aa8e00398f77148290ca8cdb6383 afbab6972936aa8e00398f77148290ca8cdb6383 draft-ietf-detnet-ip-over-mpls 7562688d7a135b11e38770a6d49690faf2cb7a0f8c5fa58478c102540a5ec84c ['7562688d7a135b11e38770a6d49690faf2cb7a0f8c5fa58478c102540a5ec84c', 'c53f6e0d24b80106b9ec06e537d4dc146a88fd91cb85f46a1175d7b9b672d053'] A "this draft does not have additional security considerations. security considerations for detnet are described in detail in i- d.ietf-detnet-security. general security considerations are described in i-d.ietf-detnet-architecture. mpls and ip specific considerations are described in i-d.ietf-detnet-mpls and i-d.ietf- detnet-ip." {91: 1, 36: 1, 6: 4, 79: 4, 90: 2, 51: 3, 130: 4, 62: 6, 85: 7, 68: 6, 35: 5, 110: 2, 114: 2, 97: 4, 31: 3, 13: 2, 67: 3, 38: 4, 26: 3, 124: 5, 98: 4, 54: 4, 127: 5, 8: 4, 96: 4, 64: 2, 30: 2, 61: 5, 55: 5, 27: 4, 15: 2, 52: 3, 129: 5, 115: 2, 84: 2, 76: 8, 87: 2, 131: 7, 102: 2, 113: 5, 99: 4, 24: 2, 53: 3, 72: 4} {50: 1, 353: 1, 1: 11, 4: 4, 9: 7, 10: 5, 15: 4, 24: 4, 25: 6, 26: 7, 27: 3, 39: 7, 43: 5, 49: 2, 58: 5, 59: 4, 64: 4, 69: 6, 81: 7, 82: 5, 86: 3, 96: 4, 97: 3, 100: 8, 108: 5, 109: 6, 110: 6, 111: 4, 114: 5, 115: 6, 116: 4, 118: 8, 119: 7, 120: 5, 121: 6, 122: 5, 123: 4, 124: 6, 128: 2, 129: 2, 130: 5, 132: 6, 136: 4, 145: 6, 147: 4, 151: 3, 152: 3, 154: 5, 156: 3, 161: 5, 162: 5, 165: 5, 168: 6, 169: 2, 172: 2, 184: 7, 187: 7, 188: 6, 191: 5, 194: 6, 202: 7, 203: 8, 206: 4, 207: 5, 215: 4, 217: 5, 218: 10, 220: 4, 221: 4, 222: 7, 224: 5, 227: 6, 229: 2, 234: 7, 235: 4, 241: 4, 242: 4, 243: 6, 244: 3, 245: 6, 248: 3, 250: 5, 258: 13, 262: 6, 263: 7, 264: 5, 267: 6, 270: 4, 272: 2, 273: 7, 287: 5, 289: 2, 291: 5, 299: 6, 300: 4, 304: 4, 309: 5, 314: 4, 315: 2, 320: 6, 323: 6, 327: 6, 328: 5, 329: 4, 330: 12, 334: 4, 335: 4, 341: 6, 342: 7, 347: 6, 348: 6, 350: 9, 351: 4, 352: 2, 354: 2, 358: 6, 365: 2, 366: 4, 369: 3, 371: 8, 372: 5, 376: 4, 384: 5, 385: 4, 386: 5, 387: 4, 392: 5, 393: 6, 396: 7, 397: 9, 398: 8, 402: 2} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 67 "This draft does not have additional security considerations. Security considerations for DetNet are described in detail in I- D.ietf-detnet-security. General security considerations are described in RFC8655. MPLS and IP specific considerations are described in I-D.ietf-detnet-mpls and I-D.ietf-detnet-ip." "Update references , fix nits , fix one minor change as discussed on list ( IP doc ) add new revisions for submission to IESG : ip , mpls , ip - over - mpls , mpls - over - udp - ip please merge and upload mpls / IDs / draft - ietf - detnet - mpls- mpls - over - udp - ip / IDs / draft - ietf - detnet - mpls - over - udp - ip- ip - over - mpls / IDs / draft - ietf - detnet - ip - over - mpls- ip / IDs / draft - ietf - detnet - ip- OK . Thanks for the updates . B." afbab6972936aa8e00398f77148290ca8cdb6383 afbab6972936aa8e00398f77148290ca8cdb6383 draft-ietf-detnet-ip-over-mpls c53f6e0d24b80106b9ec06e537d4dc146a88fd91cb85f46a1175d7b9b672d053 ['7562688d7a135b11e38770a6d49690faf2cb7a0f8c5fa58478c102540a5ec84c', 'c53f6e0d24b80106b9ec06e537d4dc146a88fd91cb85f46a1175d7b9b672d053'] B "this draft does not have additional security considerations. security considerations for detnet are described in detail in i- d.ietf-detnet-security. general security considerations are described in rfc8655. mpls and ip specific considerations are described in i-d.ietf-detnet-mpls and i-d.ietf-detnet-ip." {91: 1, 36: 1, 6: 4, 79: 4, 90: 2, 51: 3, 130: 4, 62: 6, 85: 7, 68: 6, 35: 5, 110: 2, 114: 2, 97: 4, 31: 3, 13: 2, 67: 3, 38: 4, 26: 3, 124: 5, 98: 4, 54: 4, 127: 5, 8: 4, 96: 4, 64: 2, 30: 2, 61: 5, 55: 5, 27: 4, 15: 2, 52: 3, 129: 5, 115: 2, 84: 2, 76: 8, 87: 2, 131: 7, 102: 2, 113: 5, 99: 4, 24: 2, 53: 3, 72: 4} {50: 1, 353: 1, 1: 11, 4: 4, 9: 7, 10: 5, 15: 4, 24: 4, 25: 6, 26: 7, 27: 3, 39: 7, 43: 5, 49: 2, 58: 5, 59: 4, 64: 4, 69: 6, 81: 7, 82: 5, 86: 3, 96: 4, 97: 3, 100: 8, 108: 5, 109: 6, 110: 6, 111: 4, 114: 5, 115: 6, 116: 4, 118: 8, 119: 7, 120: 5, 121: 6, 122: 5, 123: 4, 124: 6, 128: 2, 129: 2, 130: 5, 132: 6, 136: 4, 145: 6, 147: 4, 151: 3, 152: 3, 154: 5, 156: 3, 161: 5, 162: 5, 165: 5, 168: 6, 169: 2, 172: 2, 184: 7, 187: 7, 188: 6, 191: 5, 194: 6, 202: 7, 203: 8, 206: 4, 207: 5, 215: 4, 217: 5, 218: 10, 220: 4, 221: 4, 222: 7, 224: 5, 227: 6, 229: 2, 234: 7, 235: 4, 241: 4, 242: 4, 243: 6, 244: 3, 245: 6, 248: 3, 250: 5, 258: 13, 262: 6, 263: 7, 264: 5, 267: 6, 270: 4, 272: 2, 273: 7, 287: 5, 289: 2, 291: 5, 299: 6, 300: 4, 304: 4, 309: 5, 314: 4, 315: 2, 320: 6, 323: 6, 327: 6, 328: 5, 329: 4, 330: 12, 334: 4, 335: 4, 341: 6, 342: 7, 347: 6, 348: 6, 350: 9, 351: 4, 352: 2, 354: 2, 358: 6, 365: 2, 366: 4, 369: 3, 371: 8, 372: 5, 376: 4, 384: 5, 385: 4, 386: 5, 387: 4, 392: 5, 393: 6, 396: 7, 397: 9, 398: 8, 402: 2} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 67 "Deterministic Networking (DetNet) is a service that can be offered by a network to DetNet flows. DetNet provides these flows extremely low packet loss rates and assured maximum end-to-end delivery latency. General background and concepts of DetNet can be found in I-D.ietf- detnet-architecture." "Update references , fix nits , fix one minor change as discussed on list ( IP doc ) add new revisions for submission to IESG : ip , mpls , ip - over - mpls , mpls - over - udp - ip please merge and upload mpls / IDs / draft - ietf - detnet - mpls- mpls - over - udp - ip / IDs / draft - ietf - detnet - mpls - over - udp - ip- ip - over - mpls / IDs / draft - ietf - detnet - ip - over - mpls- ip / IDs / draft - ietf - detnet - ip- OK . Thanks for the updates . B." afbab6972936aa8e00398f77148290ca8cdb6383 afbab6972936aa8e00398f77148290ca8cdb6383 draft-ietf-detnet-mpls c31ce0549ab35905c9dd24d8f3e2a8ba13713e0b09f48d20922dae3ede970714 ['c31ce0549ab35905c9dd24d8f3e2a8ba13713e0b09f48d20922dae3ede970714', '5395b0161e6d5540c9b8a42408d25c4e71f2b4acd554940cc3f38997e94453c0'] A "deterministic networking (detnet) is a service that can be offered by a network to detnet flows. detnet provides these flows extremely low packet loss rates and assured maximum end-to-end delivery latency. general background and concepts of detnet can be found in i-d.ietf- detnet-architecture." {64: 1, 52: 5, 67: 2, 130: 3, 124: 4} {133: 1, 391: 5, 268: 2, 269: 3, 158: 4} {133, 391, 268, 269, 305, 158} 67 "Deterministic Networking (DetNet) is a service that can be offered by a network to DetNet flows. DetNet provides these flows extremely low packet loss rates and assured maximum end-to-end delivery latency. General background and concepts of DetNet can be found in RFC8655." "Update references , fix nits , fix one minor change as discussed on list ( IP doc ) add new revisions for submission to IESG : ip , mpls , ip - over - mpls , mpls - over - udp - ip please merge and upload mpls / IDs / draft - ietf - detnet - mpls- mpls - over - udp - ip / IDs / draft - ietf - detnet - mpls - over - udp - ip- ip - over - mpls / IDs / draft - ietf - detnet - ip - over - mpls- ip / IDs / draft - ietf - detnet - ip- OK . Thanks for the updates . B." afbab6972936aa8e00398f77148290ca8cdb6383 afbab6972936aa8e00398f77148290ca8cdb6383 draft-ietf-detnet-mpls 5395b0161e6d5540c9b8a42408d25c4e71f2b4acd554940cc3f38997e94453c0 ['c31ce0549ab35905c9dd24d8f3e2a8ba13713e0b09f48d20922dae3ede970714', '5395b0161e6d5540c9b8a42408d25c4e71f2b4acd554940cc3f38997e94453c0'] B "deterministic networking (detnet) is a service that can be offered by a network to detnet flows. detnet provides these flows extremely low packet loss rates and assured maximum end-to-end delivery latency. general background and concepts of detnet can be found in rfc8655." {64: 1, 52: 5, 67: 2, 130: 3, 124: 4} {133: 1, 391: 5, 268: 2, 269: 3, 158: 4} {133, 391, 268, 269, 305, 158} 67 "This document uses the terminology established in the DetNet architecture I-D.ietf-detnet-architecture and the the DetNet Data Plane Framework I-D.ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework. The reader is assumed to be familiar with these documents and any terminology defined therein." "Update references , fix nits , fix one minor change as discussed on list ( IP doc ) add new revisions for submission to IESG : ip , mpls , ip - over - mpls , mpls - over - udp - ip please merge and upload mpls / IDs / draft - ietf - detnet - mpls- mpls - over - udp - ip / IDs / draft - ietf - detnet - mpls - over - udp - ip- ip - over - mpls / IDs / draft - ietf - detnet - ip - over - mpls- ip / IDs / draft - ietf - detnet - ip- OK . Thanks for the updates . B." afbab6972936aa8e00398f77148290ca8cdb6383 afbab6972936aa8e00398f77148290ca8cdb6383 draft-ietf-detnet-mpls 10db62b97aa8647794986bd0bbb19e31d3d80b41eb26315f74a92754f7aec13c ['10db62b97aa8647794986bd0bbb19e31d3d80b41eb26315f74a92754f7aec13c', '320c823ce95acd6aa4c5f15fcc4a98503c5f419c04f271fc060924564b314201'] A "this document uses the terminology established in the detnet architecture i-d.ietf-detnet-architecture and the the detnet data plane framework i-d.ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework. the reader is assumed to be familiar with these documents and any terminology defined therein." {72: 1} {67: 1} {16, 67} 67 "This document uses the terminology established in the DetNet architecture RFC8655 and the the DetNet Data Plane Framework I- D.ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework. The reader is assumed to be familiar with these documents and any terminology defined therein." "Update references , fix nits , fix one minor change as discussed on list ( IP doc ) add new revisions for submission to IESG : ip , mpls , ip - over - mpls , mpls - over - udp - ip please merge and upload mpls / IDs / draft - ietf - detnet - mpls- mpls - over - udp - ip / IDs / draft - ietf - detnet - mpls - over - udp - ip- ip - over - mpls / IDs / draft - ietf - detnet - ip - over - mpls- ip / IDs / draft - ietf - detnet - ip- OK . Thanks for the updates . B." afbab6972936aa8e00398f77148290ca8cdb6383 afbab6972936aa8e00398f77148290ca8cdb6383 draft-ietf-detnet-mpls 320c823ce95acd6aa4c5f15fcc4a98503c5f419c04f271fc060924564b314201 ['10db62b97aa8647794986bd0bbb19e31d3d80b41eb26315f74a92754f7aec13c', '320c823ce95acd6aa4c5f15fcc4a98503c5f419c04f271fc060924564b314201'] B "this document uses the terminology established in the detnet architecture rfc8655 and the the detnet data plane framework i- d.ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework. the reader is assumed to be familiar with these documents and any terminology defined therein." {72: 1} {67: 1} {16, 67} 67 "In addition to explicit routes, and packet replication and elimination, described in dn-dt-solution above, DetNet provides zero congestion loss and bounded latency and jitter. As described in I- D.ietf-detnet-architecture, there are different mechanisms that maybe used separately or in combination to deliver a zero congestion loss service. This includes Quality of Service (QoS) mechanisms at the MPLS layer, that may be combined with the mechanisms defined by the underlying network layer such as 802.1TSN." "Update references , fix nits , fix one minor change as discussed on list ( IP doc ) add new revisions for submission to IESG : ip , mpls , ip - over - mpls , mpls - over - udp - ip please merge and upload mpls / IDs / draft - ietf - detnet - mpls- mpls - over - udp - ip / IDs / draft - ietf - detnet - mpls - over - udp - ip- ip - over - mpls / IDs / draft - ietf - detnet - ip - over - mpls- ip / IDs / draft - ietf - detnet - ip- OK . Thanks for the updates . B." afbab6972936aa8e00398f77148290ca8cdb6383 afbab6972936aa8e00398f77148290ca8cdb6383 draft-ietf-detnet-mpls 7c3edff8ec1e8e355c7bdbce4c54e761261a81b8456c76fdf167651fe3d5b308 ['7c3edff8ec1e8e355c7bdbce4c54e761261a81b8456c76fdf167651fe3d5b308', '77939037ac48abc441ca9b5e57ba428da8d9e64f820dfe9574747380f2302b45'] A "in addition to explicit routes, and packet replication and elimination, described in dn-dt-solution above, detnet provides zero congestion loss and bounded latency and jitter. as described in i- d.ietf-detnet-architecture, there are different mechanisms that maybe used separately or in combination to deliver a zero congestion loss service. this includes quality of service (qos) mechanisms at the mpls layer, that may be combined with the mechanisms defined by the underlying network layer such as 802.1tsn." {113: 1} {237: 1} {193, 237} 67 "In addition to explicit routes, and packet replication and elimination, described in dn-dt-solution above, DetNet provides zero congestion loss and bounded latency and jitter. As described in RFC8655, there are different mechanisms that maybe used separately or in combination to deliver a zero congestion loss service. This includes Quality of Service (QoS) mechanisms at the MPLS layer, that may be combined with the mechanisms defined by the underlying network layer such as 802.1TSN." "Update references , fix nits , fix one minor change as discussed on list ( IP doc ) add new revisions for submission to IESG : ip , mpls , ip - over - mpls , mpls - over - udp - ip please merge and upload mpls / IDs / draft - ietf - detnet - mpls- mpls - over - udp - ip / IDs / draft - ietf - detnet - mpls - over - udp - ip- ip - over - mpls / IDs / draft - ietf - detnet - ip - over - mpls- ip / IDs / draft - ietf - detnet - ip- OK . Thanks for the updates . B." afbab6972936aa8e00398f77148290ca8cdb6383 afbab6972936aa8e00398f77148290ca8cdb6383 draft-ietf-detnet-mpls 77939037ac48abc441ca9b5e57ba428da8d9e64f820dfe9574747380f2302b45 ['7c3edff8ec1e8e355c7bdbce4c54e761261a81b8456c76fdf167651fe3d5b308', '77939037ac48abc441ca9b5e57ba428da8d9e64f820dfe9574747380f2302b45'] B "in addition to explicit routes, and packet replication and elimination, described in dn-dt-solution above, detnet provides zero congestion loss and bounded latency and jitter. as described in rfc8655, there are different mechanisms that maybe used separately or in combination to deliver a zero congestion loss service. this includes quality of service (qos) mechanisms at the mpls layer, that may be combined with the mechanisms defined by the underlying network layer such as 802.1tsn." {113: 1} {237: 1} {193, 237} 67 "Security considerations for DetNet are described in detail in I- D.ietf-detnet-security. General security considerations are described in I-D.ietf-detnet-architecture. This section considers exclusively security considerations which are specific to the DetNet MPLS data plane." "Update references , fix nits , fix one minor change as discussed on list ( IP doc ) add new revisions for submission to IESG : ip , mpls , ip - over - mpls , mpls - over - udp - ip please merge and upload mpls / IDs / draft - ietf - detnet - mpls- mpls - over - udp - ip / IDs / draft - ietf - detnet - mpls - over - udp - ip- ip - over - mpls / IDs / draft - ietf - detnet - ip - over - mpls- ip / IDs / draft - ietf - detnet - ip- OK . Thanks for the updates . B." afbab6972936aa8e00398f77148290ca8cdb6383 afbab6972936aa8e00398f77148290ca8cdb6383 draft-ietf-detnet-mpls 3951ac678b26e62e013f5f8c59ef14ad8700f7dd165471e101a3a7c0ccb8bc5f ['3951ac678b26e62e013f5f8c59ef14ad8700f7dd165471e101a3a7c0ccb8bc5f', '1a2bf6e02adafb2c1f1e2c209e8410b52c2f457d677486c5f56a5fa41beda4ab'] A "security considerations for detnet are described in detail in i- d.ietf-detnet-security. general security considerations are described in i-d.ietf-detnet-architecture. this section considers exclusively security considerations which are specific to the detnet mpls data plane." {72: 1, 24: 1, 6: 3, 79: 3, 90: 2, 51: 3, 130: 3, 62: 5, 85: 6, 68: 5, 35: 4, 110: 2, 91: 4, 114: 2, 97: 3, 31: 3, 13: 2, 38: 3, 26: 2, 124: 4, 98: 3, 54: 3, 127: 4, 8: 3, 96: 3, 64: 3, 30: 3, 61: 4, 55: 4, 27: 3, 15: 2, 67: 3, 52: 2, 129: 4, 115: 2, 84: 2, 76: 7, 87: 2, 131: 6, 102: 2, 113: 4, 99: 3, 36: 2, 53: 2} {385: 1, 354: 1, 1: 10, 4: 3, 9: 6, 10: 4, 15: 3, 24: 3, 25: 5, 26: 6, 27: 3, 39: 6, 43: 4, 49: 5, 50: 4, 58: 4, 59: 3, 64: 3, 69: 5, 81: 6, 82: 4, 96: 3, 97: 2, 100: 7, 108: 4, 109: 5, 110: 5, 111: 3, 114: 4, 115: 5, 116: 3, 118: 7, 119: 6, 120: 4, 121: 5, 122: 4, 123: 3, 124: 5, 128: 3, 129: 3, 130: 4, 132: 5, 136: 3, 145: 5, 147: 3, 151: 3, 152: 3, 154: 4, 156: 2, 161: 4, 162: 4, 165: 4, 168: 5, 169: 2, 172: 2, 180: 3, 184: 6, 187: 6, 188: 5, 191: 4, 194: 5, 202: 6, 203: 7, 206: 3, 207: 4, 215: 3, 217: 4, 218: 9, 220: 3, 221: 3, 222: 6, 224: 4, 227: 5, 229: 2, 234: 6, 235: 3, 241: 3, 242: 3, 243: 5, 244: 3, 245: 5, 248: 3, 250: 4, 258: 12, 262: 5, 263: 6, 264: 4, 267: 5, 270: 3, 272: 2, 273: 6, 287: 4, 289: 2, 291: 4, 299: 5, 300: 3, 304: 3, 309: 4, 314: 3, 315: 2, 320: 5, 323: 5, 327: 5, 328: 4, 329: 3, 330: 11, 334: 3, 335: 3, 341: 5, 342: 6, 347: 5, 348: 5, 350: 8, 351: 4, 352: 2, 353: 2, 358: 5, 365: 2, 366: 3, 369: 2, 371: 7, 372: 4, 376: 3, 384: 2, 386: 4, 387: 3, 392: 4, 393: 5, 396: 6, 397: 8, 398: 7, 402: 2} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 67 "Security considerations for DetNet are described in detail in I- D.ietf-detnet-security. General security considerations are described in RFC8655. This section considers exclusively security considerations which are specific to the DetNet MPLS data plane." "Update references , fix nits , fix one minor change as discussed on list ( IP doc ) add new revisions for submission to IESG : ip , mpls , ip - over - mpls , mpls - over - udp - ip please merge and upload mpls / IDs / draft - ietf - detnet - mpls- mpls - over - udp - ip / IDs / draft - ietf - detnet - mpls - over - udp - ip- ip - over - mpls / IDs / draft - ietf - detnet - ip - over - mpls- ip / IDs / draft - ietf - detnet - ip- OK . Thanks for the updates . B." afbab6972936aa8e00398f77148290ca8cdb6383 afbab6972936aa8e00398f77148290ca8cdb6383 draft-ietf-detnet-mpls 1a2bf6e02adafb2c1f1e2c209e8410b52c2f457d677486c5f56a5fa41beda4ab ['3951ac678b26e62e013f5f8c59ef14ad8700f7dd165471e101a3a7c0ccb8bc5f', '1a2bf6e02adafb2c1f1e2c209e8410b52c2f457d677486c5f56a5fa41beda4ab'] B "security considerations for detnet are described in detail in i- d.ietf-detnet-security. general security considerations are described in rfc8655. this section considers exclusively security considerations which are specific to the detnet mpls data plane." {72: 1, 24: 1, 6: 3, 79: 3, 90: 2, 51: 3, 130: 3, 62: 5, 85: 6, 68: 5, 35: 4, 110: 2, 91: 4, 114: 2, 97: 3, 31: 3, 13: 2, 38: 3, 26: 2, 124: 4, 98: 3, 54: 3, 127: 4, 8: 3, 96: 3, 64: 3, 30: 3, 61: 4, 55: 4, 27: 3, 15: 2, 67: 3, 52: 2, 129: 4, 115: 2, 84: 2, 76: 7, 87: 2, 131: 6, 102: 2, 113: 4, 99: 3, 36: 2, 53: 2} {385: 1, 354: 1, 1: 10, 4: 3, 9: 6, 10: 4, 15: 3, 24: 3, 25: 5, 26: 6, 27: 3, 39: 6, 43: 4, 49: 5, 50: 4, 58: 4, 59: 3, 64: 3, 69: 5, 81: 6, 82: 4, 96: 3, 97: 2, 100: 7, 108: 4, 109: 5, 110: 5, 111: 3, 114: 4, 115: 5, 116: 3, 118: 7, 119: 6, 120: 4, 121: 5, 122: 4, 123: 3, 124: 5, 128: 3, 129: 3, 130: 4, 132: 5, 136: 3, 145: 5, 147: 3, 151: 3, 152: 3, 154: 4, 156: 2, 161: 4, 162: 4, 165: 4, 168: 5, 169: 2, 172: 2, 180: 3, 184: 6, 187: 6, 188: 5, 191: 4, 194: 5, 202: 6, 203: 7, 206: 3, 207: 4, 215: 3, 217: 4, 218: 9, 220: 3, 221: 3, 222: 6, 224: 4, 227: 5, 229: 2, 234: 6, 235: 3, 241: 3, 242: 3, 243: 5, 244: 3, 245: 5, 248: 3, 250: 4, 258: 12, 262: 5, 263: 6, 264: 4, 267: 5, 270: 3, 272: 2, 273: 6, 287: 4, 289: 2, 291: 4, 299: 5, 300: 3, 304: 3, 309: 4, 314: 3, 315: 2, 320: 5, 323: 5, 327: 5, 328: 4, 329: 3, 330: 11, 334: 3, 335: 3, 341: 5, 342: 6, 347: 5, 348: 5, 350: 8, 351: 4, 352: 2, 353: 2, 358: 5, 365: 2, 366: 3, 369: 2, 371: 7, 372: 4, 376: 3, 384: 2, 386: 4, 387: 3, 392: 4, 393: 5, 396: 6, 397: 8, 398: 7, 402: 2} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 67 "DetNet (Deterministic Networking) provides a capability to carry specified unicast or multicast data flows for real-time applications with extremely low packet loss rates and assured maximum end-to-end delivery latency. A description of the general background and concepts of DetNet can be found in I-D.ietf-detnet-architecture." "Update references , fix nits , fix one minor change as discussed on list ( IP doc ) add new revisions for submission to IESG : ip , mpls , ip - over - mpls , mpls - over - udp - ip please merge and upload mpls / IDs / draft - ietf - detnet - mpls- mpls - over - udp - ip / IDs / draft - ietf - detnet - mpls - over - udp - ip- ip - over - mpls / IDs / draft - ietf - detnet - ip - over - mpls- ip / IDs / draft - ietf - detnet - ip- OK . Thanks for the updates . B." afbab6972936aa8e00398f77148290ca8cdb6383 afbab6972936aa8e00398f77148290ca8cdb6383 draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework d1b8d09d5e630c379b5359b0282f20f77ae549765b1fccdef4bdbb94a56a98e2 ['ea62a3ec52d2b67667733c901fa070acf5eb80be1be500be1aaea3c51e5e24d3', 'd1b8d09d5e630c379b5359b0282f20f77ae549765b1fccdef4bdbb94a56a98e2'] A "detnet (deterministic networking) provides a capability to carry specified unicast or multicast data flows for real-time applications with extremely low packet loss rates and assured maximum end-to-end delivery latency. a description of the general background and concepts of detnet can be found in i-d.ietf-detnet-architecture." {55: 1, 6: 3, 90: 2, 8: 2} {61: 1, 113: 3, 106: 2, 60: 2} {106, 113, 375, 60, 61} 67 "DetNet (Deterministic Networking) provides a capability to carry specified unicast or multicast data flows for real-time applications with extremely low packet loss rates and assured maximum end-to-end delivery latency. A description of the general background and concepts of DetNet can be found in RFC8655." "Update references , fix nits , fix one minor change as discussed on list ( IP doc ) add new revisions for submission to IESG : ip , mpls , ip - over - mpls , mpls - over - udp - ip please merge and upload mpls / IDs / draft - ietf - detnet - mpls- mpls - over - udp - ip / IDs / draft - ietf - detnet - mpls - over - udp - ip- ip - over - mpls / IDs / draft - ietf - detnet - ip - over - mpls- ip / IDs / draft - ietf - detnet - ip- OK . Thanks for the updates . B." afbab6972936aa8e00398f77148290ca8cdb6383 afbab6972936aa8e00398f77148290ca8cdb6383 draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework ea62a3ec52d2b67667733c901fa070acf5eb80be1be500be1aaea3c51e5e24d3 ['ea62a3ec52d2b67667733c901fa070acf5eb80be1be500be1aaea3c51e5e24d3', 'd1b8d09d5e630c379b5359b0282f20f77ae549765b1fccdef4bdbb94a56a98e2'] B "detnet (deterministic networking) provides a capability to carry specified unicast or multicast data flows for real-time applications with extremely low packet loss rates and assured maximum end-to-end delivery latency. a description of the general background and concepts of detnet can be found in rfc8655." {55: 1, 6: 3, 90: 2, 8: 2} {61: 1, 113: 3, 106: 2, 60: 2} {106, 113, 375, 60, 61} 67 "This document uses the terminology established in the DetNet architecture I-D.ietf-detnet-architecture, and the reader is assumed to be familiar with that document and its terminology." "Update references , fix nits , fix one minor change as discussed on list ( IP doc ) add new revisions for submission to IESG : ip , mpls , ip - over - mpls , mpls - over - udp - ip please merge and upload mpls / IDs / draft - ietf - detnet - mpls- mpls - over - udp - ip / IDs / draft - ietf - detnet - mpls - over - udp - ip- ip - over - mpls / IDs / draft - ietf - detnet - ip - over - mpls- ip / IDs / draft - ietf - detnet - ip- OK . Thanks for the updates . B." afbab6972936aa8e00398f77148290ca8cdb6383 afbab6972936aa8e00398f77148290ca8cdb6383 draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework cae70a041f2bb7a437801975d64fbc6aa981e51be14ad7536d6a022d294d2c70 ['26dc046a4f58b1965321c2ca1c26d2246404ea3c259d0662366f915790031fc6', 'cae70a041f2bb7a437801975d64fbc6aa981e51be14ad7536d6a022d294d2c70'] A "this document uses the terminology established in the detnet architecture i-d.ietf-detnet-architecture, and the reader is assumed to be familiar with that document and its terminology." {52: 1, 53: 1, 130: 2, 79: 2, 51: 2, 112: 3, 55: 3, 64: 2, 62: 3, 37: 2, 38: 3, 69: 2, 68: 2, 67: 2, 33: 2, 25: 2, 80: 2, 127: 3, 91: 3} {321: 1, 322: 1, 0: 2, 389: 2, 390: 2, 135: 3, 142: 3, 14: 2, 400: 3, 17: 2, 399: 3, 19: 3, 149: 3, 406: 2, 279: 2, 280: 2, 281: 2, 278: 2, 294: 2, 296: 3, 45: 3, 308: 2, 185: 2, 192: 2, 66: 2, 196: 4, 197: 3, 324: 3, 77: 3, 78: 3, 337: 4, 216: 3, 380: 2, 255: 2} {0, 389, 390, 135, 142, 14, 400, 17, 399, 19, 149, 406, 279, 280, 281, 278, 294, 296, 45, 308, 56, 185, 192, 321, 322, 66, 196, 197, 324, 77, 78, 337, 216, 380, 255} 67 "This document uses the terminology established in the DetNet architecture RFC8655, and the reader is assumed to be familiar with that document and its terminology." "Update references , fix nits , fix one minor change as discussed on list ( IP doc ) add new revisions for submission to IESG : ip , mpls , ip - over - mpls , mpls - over - udp - ip please merge and upload mpls / IDs / draft - ietf - detnet - mpls- mpls - over - udp - ip / IDs / draft - ietf - detnet - mpls - over - udp - ip- ip - over - mpls / IDs / draft - ietf - detnet - ip - over - mpls- ip / IDs / draft - ietf - detnet - ip- OK . Thanks for the updates . B." afbab6972936aa8e00398f77148290ca8cdb6383 afbab6972936aa8e00398f77148290ca8cdb6383 draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework 26dc046a4f58b1965321c2ca1c26d2246404ea3c259d0662366f915790031fc6 ['26dc046a4f58b1965321c2ca1c26d2246404ea3c259d0662366f915790031fc6', 'cae70a041f2bb7a437801975d64fbc6aa981e51be14ad7536d6a022d294d2c70'] B "this document uses the terminology established in the detnet architecture rfc8655, and the reader is assumed to be familiar with that document and its terminology." {52: 1, 53: 1, 130: 2, 79: 2, 51: 2, 112: 3, 55: 3, 64: 2, 62: 3, 37: 2, 38: 3, 69: 2, 68: 2, 67: 2, 33: 2, 25: 2, 80: 2, 127: 3, 91: 3} {321: 1, 322: 1, 0: 2, 389: 2, 390: 2, 135: 3, 142: 3, 14: 2, 400: 3, 17: 2, 399: 3, 19: 3, 149: 3, 406: 2, 279: 2, 280: 2, 281: 2, 278: 2, 294: 2, 296: 3, 45: 3, 308: 2, 185: 2, 192: 2, 66: 2, 196: 4, 197: 3, 324: 3, 77: 3, 78: 3, 337: 4, 216: 3, 380: 2, 255: 2} {0, 389, 390, 135, 142, 14, 400, 17, 399, 19, 149, 406, 279, 280, 281, 278, 294, 296, 45, 308, 56, 185, 192, 321, 322, 66, 196, 197, 324, 77, 78, 337, 216, 380, 255} 67 "This document describes how application flows, or app-flows, are carried over DetNet networks. The DetNet Architecture, I-D.ietf- detnet-architecture, models the DetNet related data plane functions as decomposed into two sub-layers: a service sub-layer and a forwarding sub-layer." "Update references , fix nits , fix one minor change as discussed on list ( IP doc ) add new revisions for submission to IESG : ip , mpls , ip - over - mpls , mpls - over - udp - ip please merge and upload mpls / IDs / draft - ietf - detnet - mpls- mpls - over - udp - ip / IDs / draft - ietf - detnet - mpls - over - udp - ip- ip - over - mpls / IDs / draft - ietf - detnet - ip - over - mpls- ip / IDs / draft - ietf - detnet - ip- OK . Thanks for the updates . B." afbab6972936aa8e00398f77148290ca8cdb6383 afbab6972936aa8e00398f77148290ca8cdb6383 draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework 97237d5170b46905eb8b44d82316bc9c68296691e70bb325be1a4c9273a8bd88 ['851ce706885ca08c0db13952986707051bdb577b0866cf9a6c5283d1ae40d7a7', 'c259d1cc55a93ea197ab7ec35e48e33b5f93d66366d52c897c72ea0c318116c8', '97237d5170b46905eb8b44d82316bc9c68296691e70bb325be1a4c9273a8bd88', '719f8e9e5c42f854a1057606072b0627541bda75126a5245d94ddbf2bc08744e'] A "this document describes how application flows, or app-flows, are carried over detnet networks. the detnet architecture, i-d.ietf- detnet-architecture, models the detnet related data plane functions as decomposed into two sub-layers: a service sub-layer and a forwarding sub-layer." {6: 1, 55: 1, 84: 1, 8: 2, 68: 5, 31: 2, 90: 3} {256: 1, 233: 1, 302: 1, 2: 2, 5: 5, 8: 2, 74: 2, 271: 3, 83: 6, 20: 5, 21: 6, 277: 5, 276: 6, 88: 2, 236: 5, 47: 3, 303: 6, 112: 2, 247: 4, 126: 3, 127: 2} {256, 2, 5, 8, 271, 20, 21, 277, 276, 302, 47, 303, 74, 209, 83, 88, 233, 236, 112, 247, 126, 127} 67 "ProtStack1 reproduced from the I-D.ietf-detnet-architecture,shows a logical DetNet service with the two sub-layers." "Update references , fix nits , fix one minor change as discussed on list ( IP doc ) add new revisions for submission to IESG : ip , mpls , ip - over - mpls , mpls - over - udp - ip please merge and upload mpls / IDs / draft - ietf - detnet - mpls- mpls - over - udp - ip / IDs / draft - ietf - detnet - mpls - over - udp - ip- ip - over - mpls / IDs / draft - ietf - detnet - ip - over - mpls- ip / IDs / draft - ietf - detnet - ip- OK . Thanks for the updates . B." afbab6972936aa8e00398f77148290ca8cdb6383 afbab6972936aa8e00398f77148290ca8cdb6383 draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework 719f8e9e5c42f854a1057606072b0627541bda75126a5245d94ddbf2bc08744e ['851ce706885ca08c0db13952986707051bdb577b0866cf9a6c5283d1ae40d7a7', 'c259d1cc55a93ea197ab7ec35e48e33b5f93d66366d52c897c72ea0c318116c8', '97237d5170b46905eb8b44d82316bc9c68296691e70bb325be1a4c9273a8bd88', '719f8e9e5c42f854a1057606072b0627541bda75126a5245d94ddbf2bc08744e'] A "protstack1 reproduced from the i-d.ietf-detnet-architecture,shows a logical detnet service with the two sub-layers." {6: 1, 55: 1, 84: 1, 8: 2, 68: 5, 31: 2, 90: 3} {256: 1, 233: 1, 302: 1, 2: 2, 5: 5, 8: 2, 74: 2, 271: 3, 83: 6, 20: 5, 21: 6, 277: 5, 276: 6, 88: 2, 236: 5, 47: 3, 303: 6, 112: 2, 247: 4, 126: 3, 127: 2} {256, 2, 5, 8, 271, 20, 21, 277, 276, 302, 47, 303, 74, 209, 83, 88, 233, 236, 112, 247, 126, 127} 67 "This document describes how application flows, or app-flows, are carried over DetNet networks. The DetNet Architecture, RFC8655, models the DetNet related data plane functions as decomposed into two sub-layers: a service sub-layer and a forwarding sub-layer." "Update references , fix nits , fix one minor change as discussed on list ( IP doc ) add new revisions for submission to IESG : ip , mpls , ip - over - mpls , mpls - over - udp - ip please merge and upload mpls / IDs / draft - ietf - detnet - mpls- mpls - over - udp - ip / IDs / draft - ietf - detnet - mpls - over - udp - ip- ip - over - mpls / IDs / draft - ietf - detnet - ip - over - mpls- ip / IDs / draft - ietf - detnet - ip- OK . Thanks for the updates . B." afbab6972936aa8e00398f77148290ca8cdb6383 afbab6972936aa8e00398f77148290ca8cdb6383 draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework c259d1cc55a93ea197ab7ec35e48e33b5f93d66366d52c897c72ea0c318116c8 ['851ce706885ca08c0db13952986707051bdb577b0866cf9a6c5283d1ae40d7a7', 'c259d1cc55a93ea197ab7ec35e48e33b5f93d66366d52c897c72ea0c318116c8', '97237d5170b46905eb8b44d82316bc9c68296691e70bb325be1a4c9273a8bd88', '719f8e9e5c42f854a1057606072b0627541bda75126a5245d94ddbf2bc08744e'] B "this document describes how application flows, or app-flows, are carried over detnet networks. the detnet architecture, rfc8655, models the detnet related data plane functions as decomposed into two sub-layers: a service sub-layer and a forwarding sub-layer." {6: 1, 55: 1, 84: 1, 8: 2, 68: 5, 31: 2, 90: 3} {256: 1, 233: 1, 302: 1, 2: 2, 5: 5, 8: 2, 74: 2, 271: 3, 83: 6, 20: 5, 21: 6, 277: 5, 276: 6, 88: 2, 236: 5, 47: 3, 303: 6, 112: 2, 247: 4, 126: 3, 127: 2} {256, 2, 5, 8, 271, 20, 21, 277, 276, 302, 47, 303, 74, 209, 83, 88, 233, 236, 112, 247, 126, 127} 67 "ProtStack1 reproduced from the RFC8655,shows a logical DetNet service with the two sub-layers." "Update references , fix nits , fix one minor change as discussed on list ( IP doc ) add new revisions for submission to IESG : ip , mpls , ip - over - mpls , mpls - over - udp - ip please merge and upload mpls / IDs / draft - ietf - detnet - mpls- mpls - over - udp - ip / IDs / draft - ietf - detnet - mpls - over - udp - ip- ip - over - mpls / IDs / draft - ietf - detnet - ip - over - mpls- ip / IDs / draft - ietf - detnet - ip- OK . Thanks for the updates . B." afbab6972936aa8e00398f77148290ca8cdb6383 afbab6972936aa8e00398f77148290ca8cdb6383 draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework 851ce706885ca08c0db13952986707051bdb577b0866cf9a6c5283d1ae40d7a7 ['851ce706885ca08c0db13952986707051bdb577b0866cf9a6c5283d1ae40d7a7', 'c259d1cc55a93ea197ab7ec35e48e33b5f93d66366d52c897c72ea0c318116c8', '97237d5170b46905eb8b44d82316bc9c68296691e70bb325be1a4c9273a8bd88', '719f8e9e5c42f854a1057606072b0627541bda75126a5245d94ddbf2bc08744e'] B "protstack1 reproduced from the rfc8655,shows a logical detnet service with the two sub-layers." {6: 1, 55: 1, 84: 1, 8: 2, 68: 5, 31: 2, 90: 3} {256: 1, 233: 1, 302: 1, 2: 2, 5: 5, 8: 2, 74: 2, 271: 3, 83: 6, 20: 5, 21: 6, 277: 5, 276: 6, 88: 2, 236: 5, 47: 3, 303: 6, 112: 2, 247: 4, 126: 3, 127: 2} {256, 2, 5, 8, 271, 20, 21, 277, 276, 302, 47, 303, 74, 209, 83, 88, 233, 236, 112, 247, 126, 127} 67 "While the definition of controller plane for DetNet is out of the scope of this document, there are particular considerations and requirements for such that result from the unique characteristics of the DetNet architecture I-D.ietf-detnet-architecture and data plane as defined herein." "Update references , fix nits , fix one minor change as discussed on list ( IP doc ) add new revisions for submission to IESG : ip , mpls , ip - over - mpls , mpls - over - udp - ip please merge and upload mpls / IDs / draft - ietf - detnet - mpls- mpls - over - udp - ip / IDs / draft - ietf - detnet - mpls - over - udp - ip- ip - over - mpls / IDs / draft - ietf - detnet - ip - over - mpls- ip / IDs / draft - ietf - detnet - ip- OK . Thanks for the updates . B." afbab6972936aa8e00398f77148290ca8cdb6383 afbab6972936aa8e00398f77148290ca8cdb6383 draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework 45fae2bbf430fdf406f20e47f2957a66bbaabe5edb5a17a5a3ceb646e8af3fc9 ['ca5c7910044048c8d52542b54fc179d292866487e4290614c2760486514bd397', '45fae2bbf430fdf406f20e47f2957a66bbaabe5edb5a17a5a3ceb646e8af3fc9'] A "while the definition of controller plane for detnet is out of the scope of this document, there are particular considerations and requirements for such that result from the unique characteristics of the detnet architecture i-d.ietf-detnet-architecture and data plane as defined herein." {68: 1, 84: 2} {317: 1, 150: 2} {316, 317, 150} 67 "While the definition of controller plane for DetNet is out of the scope of this document, there are particular considerations and requirements for such that result from the unique characteristics of the DetNet architecture RFC8655 and data plane as defined herein." "Update references , fix nits , fix one minor change as discussed on list ( IP doc ) add new revisions for submission to IESG : ip , mpls , ip - over - mpls , mpls - over - udp - ip please merge and upload mpls / IDs / draft - ietf - detnet - mpls- mpls - over - udp - ip / IDs / draft - ietf - detnet - mpls - over - udp - ip- ip - over - mpls / IDs / draft - ietf - detnet - ip - over - mpls- ip / IDs / draft - ietf - detnet - ip- OK . Thanks for the updates . B." afbab6972936aa8e00398f77148290ca8cdb6383 afbab6972936aa8e00398f77148290ca8cdb6383 draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework ca5c7910044048c8d52542b54fc179d292866487e4290614c2760486514bd397 ['ca5c7910044048c8d52542b54fc179d292866487e4290614c2760486514bd397', '45fae2bbf430fdf406f20e47f2957a66bbaabe5edb5a17a5a3ceb646e8af3fc9'] B "while the definition of controller plane for detnet is out of the scope of this document, there are particular considerations and requirements for such that result from the unique characteristics of the detnet architecture rfc8655 and data plane as defined herein." {68: 1, 84: 2} {317: 1, 150: 2} {316, 317, 150} 67 "While management plane and control planes are traditionally considered separately, from the Data Plane perspective there is no practical difference based on the origin of flow provisioning information, and the DetNet architecture I-D.ietf-detnet-architecture refers to these collectively as the 'Controller Plane'. This document therefore does not distinguish between information provided by distributed control plane protocols, e.g., RSVP-TE RFC3209 and RFC3473, or by centralized network management mechanisms, e.g., RestConf RFC8040, YANG RFC7950, and the Path Computation Element Communication Protocol (PCEP) I-D.ietf-pce-pcep-extension-for-pce- controller or any combination thereof. Specific considerations and requirements for the DetNet Controller Plane are discussed in control-management-requirements." "Update references , fix nits , fix one minor change as discussed on list ( IP doc ) add new revisions for submission to IESG : ip , mpls , ip - over - mpls , mpls - over - udp - ip please merge and upload mpls / IDs / draft - ietf - detnet - mpls- mpls - over - udp - ip / IDs / draft - ietf - detnet - mpls - over - udp - ip- ip - over - mpls / IDs / draft - ietf - detnet - ip - over - mpls- ip / IDs / draft - ietf - detnet - ip- OK . Thanks for the updates . B." afbab6972936aa8e00398f77148290ca8cdb6383 afbab6972936aa8e00398f77148290ca8cdb6383 draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework cb3c4ea04d8cf52c35afeea09af3623280c997644378d17330a563a513c849d2 ['cb3c4ea04d8cf52c35afeea09af3623280c997644378d17330a563a513c849d2', 'dfa6a9b49e0d57e5cf7126cf12fa6fdf2d778310effdb2940cde4ce8eb604b4f'] A "while management plane and control planes are traditionally considered separately, from the data plane perspective there is no practical difference based on the origin of flow provisioning information, and the detnet architecture i-d.ietf-detnet-architecture refers to these collectively as the 'controller plane'. this document therefore does not distinguish between information provided by distributed control plane protocols, e.g., rsvp-te rfc3209 and rfc3473, or by centralized network management mechanisms, e.g., restconf rfc8040, yang rfc7950, and the path computation element communication protocol (pcep) i-d.ietf-pce-pcep-extension-for-pce- controller or any combination thereof. specific considerations and requirements for the detnet controller plane are discussed in control-management-requirements." {} {} {} 67 "While management plane and control planes are traditionally considered separately, from the Data Plane perspective there is no practical difference based on the origin of flow provisioning information, and the DetNet architecture RFC8655 refers to these collectively as the 'Controller Plane'. This document therefore does not distinguish between information provided by distributed control plane protocols, e.g., RSVP-TE RFC3209 and RFC3473, or by centralized network management mechanisms, e.g., RestConf RFC8040, YANG RFC7950, and the Path Computation Element Communication Protocol (PCEP) I- D.ietf-pce-pcep-extension-for-pce-controller or any combination thereof. Specific considerations and requirements for the DetNet Controller Plane are discussed in control-management-requirements." "Update references , fix nits , fix one minor change as discussed on list ( IP doc ) add new revisions for submission to IESG : ip , mpls , ip - over - mpls , mpls - over - udp - ip please merge and upload mpls / IDs / draft - ietf - detnet - mpls- mpls - over - udp - ip / IDs / draft - ietf - detnet - mpls - over - udp - ip- ip - over - mpls / IDs / draft - ietf - detnet - ip - over - mpls- ip / IDs / draft - ietf - detnet - ip- OK . Thanks for the updates . B." afbab6972936aa8e00398f77148290ca8cdb6383 afbab6972936aa8e00398f77148290ca8cdb6383 draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework dfa6a9b49e0d57e5cf7126cf12fa6fdf2d778310effdb2940cde4ce8eb604b4f ['cb3c4ea04d8cf52c35afeea09af3623280c997644378d17330a563a513c849d2', 'dfa6a9b49e0d57e5cf7126cf12fa6fdf2d778310effdb2940cde4ce8eb604b4f'] B "while management plane and control planes are traditionally considered separately, from the data plane perspective there is no practical difference based on the origin of flow provisioning information, and the detnet architecture rfc8655 refers to these collectively as the 'controller plane'. this document therefore does not distinguish between information provided by distributed control plane protocols, e.g., rsvp-te rfc3209 and rfc3473, or by centralized network management mechanisms, e.g., restconf rfc8040, yang rfc7950, and the path computation element communication protocol (pcep) i- d.ietf-pce-pcep-extension-for-pce-controller or any combination thereof. specific considerations and requirements for the detnet controller plane are discussed in control-management-requirements." {} {} {} 67 "Security considerations for DetNet are described in detail in I- D.ietf-detnet-security. General security considerations are described in I-D.ietf-detnet-architecture. This section considers general security considerations applicable to all data planes." "Update references , fix nits , fix one minor change as discussed on list ( IP doc ) add new revisions for submission to IESG : ip , mpls , ip - over - mpls , mpls - over - udp - ip please merge and upload mpls / IDs / draft - ietf - detnet - mpls- mpls - over - udp - ip / IDs / draft - ietf - detnet - mpls - over - udp - ip- ip - over - mpls / IDs / draft - ietf - detnet - ip - over - mpls- ip / IDs / draft - ietf - detnet - ip- OK . Thanks for the updates . B." afbab6972936aa8e00398f77148290ca8cdb6383 afbab6972936aa8e00398f77148290ca8cdb6383 draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework db65d4cdd3acb056fbdb0dd2b0ff50644de28cb40bf2ae02fed9bc6d7f2bf019 ['db65d4cdd3acb056fbdb0dd2b0ff50644de28cb40bf2ae02fed9bc6d7f2bf019', 'a488530ff7f46a9e785fc2ebd8536826140261d94b1d948be414cdabc20df4d6'] A "security considerations for detnet are described in detail in i- d.ietf-detnet-security. general security considerations are described in i-d.ietf-detnet-architecture. this section considers general security considerations applicable to all data planes." {84: 1, 6: 5, 79: 5, 90: 2, 51: 4, 130: 5, 62: 7, 85: 8, 68: 7, 35: 6, 110: 4, 91: 5, 114: 4, 97: 5, 31: 3, 13: 3, 67: 4, 38: 5, 26: 4, 124: 6, 98: 5, 54: 5, 127: 6, 8: 5, 96: 5, 64: 4, 30: 4, 61: 6, 55: 6, 27: 5, 15: 4, 52: 4, 129: 6, 115: 3, 76: 9, 87: 4, 131: 8, 102: 3, 113: 6, 99: 5, 36: 3, 24: 3, 53: 4, 72: 5} {244: 1, 1: 12, 4: 5, 9: 8, 10: 6, 15: 5, 24: 5, 25: 7, 26: 8, 27: 4, 39: 8, 43: 6, 49: 6, 50: 5, 58: 6, 59: 5, 64: 5, 69: 7, 81: 8, 82: 6, 86: 4, 96: 5, 97: 4, 100: 9, 108: 6, 109: 7, 110: 7, 111: 5, 114: 6, 115: 7, 116: 5, 118: 9, 119: 8, 120: 6, 121: 7, 122: 6, 123: 5, 124: 7, 128: 4, 129: 4, 130: 6, 132: 7, 136: 5, 145: 7, 147: 5, 151: 4, 152: 4, 154: 6, 156: 4, 161: 6, 162: 6, 165: 6, 168: 7, 169: 3, 172: 4, 180: 4, 184: 8, 187: 8, 188: 7, 191: 6, 194: 7, 202: 8, 203: 9, 206: 5, 207: 6, 215: 5, 217: 6, 218: 11, 220: 5, 221: 5, 222: 8, 224: 6, 227: 7, 229: 4, 234: 8, 235: 5, 241: 5, 242: 5, 243: 7, 245: 7, 248: 3, 250: 6, 258: 14, 262: 7, 263: 8, 264: 6, 267: 7, 270: 5, 272: 3, 273: 8, 287: 6, 289: 4, 291: 6, 299: 7, 300: 5, 304: 5, 309: 6, 314: 5, 315: 3, 320: 7, 323: 7, 327: 7, 328: 6, 329: 5, 330: 13, 334: 5, 335: 5, 341: 7, 342: 8, 347: 7, 348: 7, 350: 10, 352: 4, 353: 3, 354: 3, 358: 7, 365: 4, 366: 5, 369: 4, 371: 9, 372: 6, 376: 5, 384: 6, 385: 5, 386: 6, 387: 5, 392: 6, 393: 7, 396: 8, 397: 10, 398: 9, 402: 2} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 67 "Security considerations for DetNet are described in detail in I- D.ietf-detnet-security. General security considerations are described in RFC8655. This section considers general security considerations applicable to all data planes." "Update references , fix nits , fix one minor change as discussed on list ( IP doc ) add new revisions for submission to IESG : ip , mpls , ip - over - mpls , mpls - over - udp - ip please merge and upload mpls / IDs / draft - ietf - detnet - mpls- mpls - over - udp - ip / IDs / draft - ietf - detnet - mpls - over - udp - ip- ip - over - mpls / IDs / draft - ietf - detnet - ip - over - mpls- ip / IDs / draft - ietf - detnet - ip- OK . Thanks for the updates . B." afbab6972936aa8e00398f77148290ca8cdb6383 afbab6972936aa8e00398f77148290ca8cdb6383 draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework a488530ff7f46a9e785fc2ebd8536826140261d94b1d948be414cdabc20df4d6 ['db65d4cdd3acb056fbdb0dd2b0ff50644de28cb40bf2ae02fed9bc6d7f2bf019', 'a488530ff7f46a9e785fc2ebd8536826140261d94b1d948be414cdabc20df4d6'] B "security considerations for detnet are described in detail in i- d.ietf-detnet-security. general security considerations are described in rfc8655. this section considers general security considerations applicable to all data planes." {84: 1, 6: 5, 79: 5, 90: 2, 51: 4, 130: 5, 62: 7, 85: 8, 68: 7, 35: 6, 110: 4, 91: 5, 114: 4, 97: 5, 31: 3, 13: 3, 67: 4, 38: 5, 26: 4, 124: 6, 98: 5, 54: 5, 127: 6, 8: 5, 96: 5, 64: 4, 30: 4, 61: 6, 55: 6, 27: 5, 15: 4, 52: 4, 129: 6, 115: 3, 76: 9, 87: 4, 131: 8, 102: 3, 113: 6, 99: 5, 36: 3, 24: 3, 53: 4, 72: 5} {244: 1, 1: 12, 4: 5, 9: 8, 10: 6, 15: 5, 24: 5, 25: 7, 26: 8, 27: 4, 39: 8, 43: 6, 49: 6, 50: 5, 58: 6, 59: 5, 64: 5, 69: 7, 81: 8, 82: 6, 86: 4, 96: 5, 97: 4, 100: 9, 108: 6, 109: 7, 110: 7, 111: 5, 114: 6, 115: 7, 116: 5, 118: 9, 119: 8, 120: 6, 121: 7, 122: 6, 123: 5, 124: 7, 128: 4, 129: 4, 130: 6, 132: 7, 136: 5, 145: 7, 147: 5, 151: 4, 152: 4, 154: 6, 156: 4, 161: 6, 162: 6, 165: 6, 168: 7, 169: 3, 172: 4, 180: 4, 184: 8, 187: 8, 188: 7, 191: 6, 194: 7, 202: 8, 203: 9, 206: 5, 207: 6, 215: 5, 217: 6, 218: 11, 220: 5, 221: 5, 222: 8, 224: 6, 227: 7, 229: 4, 234: 8, 235: 5, 241: 5, 242: 5, 243: 7, 245: 7, 248: 3, 250: 6, 258: 14, 262: 7, 263: 8, 264: 6, 267: 7, 270: 5, 272: 3, 273: 8, 287: 6, 289: 4, 291: 6, 299: 7, 300: 5, 304: 5, 309: 6, 314: 5, 315: 3, 320: 7, 323: 7, 327: 7, 328: 6, 329: 5, 330: 13, 334: 5, 335: 5, 341: 7, 342: 8, 347: 7, 348: 7, 350: 10, 352: 4, 353: 3, 354: 3, 358: 7, 365: 4, 366: 5, 369: 4, 371: 9, 372: 6, 376: 5, 384: 6, 385: 5, 386: 6, 387: 5, 392: 6, 393: 7, 396: 8, 397: 10, 398: 9, 402: 2} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 67 "In order to maximize reuse of 5-tuple based mechanisms, e.g, traceroute, DetNet-aware applications and end systems SHOULD NOT mix DetNet and non-DetNet traffic within a single 5-tuple." "Update references , fix nits , fix one minor change as discussed on list ( IP doc ) add new revisions for submission to IESG : ip , mpls , ip - over - mpls , mpls - over - udp - ip please merge and upload mpls / IDs / draft - ietf - detnet - mpls- mpls - over - udp - ip / IDs / draft - ietf - detnet - mpls - over - udp - ip- ip - over - mpls / IDs / draft - ietf - detnet - ip - over - mpls- ip / IDs / draft - ietf - detnet - ip- OK . Thanks for the updates . B." afbab6972936aa8e00398f77148290ca8cdb6383 afbab6972936aa8e00398f77148290ca8cdb6383 draft-ietf-detnet-ip 7a5ee85c91420f1cbb2c08b3c7f20867e8846d52976197d764721e6dcb957956 ['7e3b3482f1155af619f330244c3a43f1e4f8c01b7d17b1cb993d232a7a0f3fb4', '7a5ee85c91420f1cbb2c08b3c7f20867e8846d52976197d764721e6dcb957956'] A "in order to maximize reuse of 5-tuple based mechanisms, e.g, traceroute, detnet-aware applications and end systems should not mix detnet and non-detnet traffic within a single 5-tuple." {62: 1, 13: 2, 56: 2, 102: 2} {171: 1, 223: 2, 141: 2, 295: 2} {295, 200, 171, 141, 223} 67 "In order to maximize reuse of existing mechanisms, DetNet-aware applications and end systems SHOULD NOT mix DetNet and non-DetNet traffic within a single 5-tuple." "Update references , fix nits , fix one minor change as discussed on list ( IP doc ) add new revisions for submission to IESG : ip , mpls , ip - over - mpls , mpls - over - udp - ip please merge and upload mpls / IDs / draft - ietf - detnet - mpls- mpls - over - udp - ip / IDs / draft - ietf - detnet - mpls - over - udp - ip- ip - over - mpls / IDs / draft - ietf - detnet - ip - over - mpls- ip / IDs / draft - ietf - detnet - ip- OK . Thanks for the updates . B." afbab6972936aa8e00398f77148290ca8cdb6383 afbab6972936aa8e00398f77148290ca8cdb6383 draft-ietf-detnet-ip 7e3b3482f1155af619f330244c3a43f1e4f8c01b7d17b1cb993d232a7a0f3fb4 ['7e3b3482f1155af619f330244c3a43f1e4f8c01b7d17b1cb993d232a7a0f3fb4', '7a5ee85c91420f1cbb2c08b3c7f20867e8846d52976197d764721e6dcb957956'] B "in order to maximize reuse of existing mechanisms, detnet-aware applications and end systems should not mix detnet and non-detnet traffic within a single 5-tuple." {62: 1, 13: 2, 56: 2, 102: 2} {171: 1, 223: 2, 141: 2, 295: 2} {295, 200, 171, 141, 223} 67 "General requirements for IP nodes are defined in RFC1122, RFC1812 and RFC6434, and are not modified by this document. The typical next-hop selection process is impacted by DetNet. Specifically, implementations of this document SHALL use management and control information to select the one or more outgoing interfaces and next hops to be used for a packet associated with a DetNet flow." "Update references , fix nits , fix one minor change as discussed on list ( IP doc ) add new revisions for submission to IESG : ip , mpls , ip - over - mpls , mpls - over - udp - ip please merge and upload mpls / IDs / draft - ietf - detnet - mpls- mpls - over - udp - ip / IDs / draft - ietf - detnet - mpls - over - udp - ip- ip - over - mpls / IDs / draft - ietf - detnet - ip - over - mpls- ip / IDs / draft - ietf - detnet - ip- OK . Thanks for the updates . B." afbab6972936aa8e00398f77148290ca8cdb6383 afbab6972936aa8e00398f77148290ca8cdb6383 draft-ietf-detnet-ip ff9160824b2ceeba0a9963bd72e84ecf9c9753366765cd5042458c0b5438793d ['ff9160824b2ceeba0a9963bd72e84ecf9c9753366765cd5042458c0b5438793d', '32773baad1fbdc5f542dd688f367b250271de3b0f1c110da46464085f88a24e6'] A "general requirements for ip nodes are defined in rfc1122, rfc1812 and rfc6434, and are not modified by this document. the typical next-hop selection process is impacted by detnet. specifically, implementations of this document shall use management and control information to select the one or more outgoing interfaces and next hops to be used for a packet associated with a detnet flow." {102: 1, 62: 1} {68: 1, 411: 1} {410, 411, 68} 67 "General requirements for IP nodes are defined in RFC1122, RFC1812 and RFC8504, and are not modified by this document. The typical next-hop selection process is impacted by DetNet. Specifically, implementations of this document SHALL use management and control information to select the one or more outgoing interfaces and next hops to be used for a packet associated with a DetNet flow." "Update references , fix nits , fix one minor change as discussed on list ( IP doc ) add new revisions for submission to IESG : ip , mpls , ip - over - mpls , mpls - over - udp - ip please merge and upload mpls / IDs / draft - ietf - detnet - mpls- mpls - over - udp - ip / IDs / draft - ietf - detnet - mpls - over - udp - ip- ip - over - mpls / IDs / draft - ietf - detnet - ip - over - mpls- ip / IDs / draft - ietf - detnet - ip- OK . Thanks for the updates . B." afbab6972936aa8e00398f77148290ca8cdb6383 afbab6972936aa8e00398f77148290ca8cdb6383 draft-ietf-detnet-ip 32773baad1fbdc5f542dd688f367b250271de3b0f1c110da46464085f88a24e6 ['ff9160824b2ceeba0a9963bd72e84ecf9c9753366765cd5042458c0b5438793d', '32773baad1fbdc5f542dd688f367b250271de3b0f1c110da46464085f88a24e6'] B "general requirements for ip nodes are defined in rfc1122, rfc1812 and rfc8504, and are not modified by this document. the typical next-hop selection process is impacted by detnet. specifically, implementations of this document shall use management and control information to select the one or more outgoing interfaces and next hops to be used for a packet associated with a detnet flow." {102: 1, 62: 1} {68: 1, 411: 1} {410, 411, 68} 67 "Security considerations for DetNet are described in detail in I- D.ietf-detnet-security. General security considerations are described in I-D.ietf-detnet-architecture. This section considers exclusively security considerations which are specific to the DetNet IP data plane." "Update references , fix nits , fix one minor change as discussed on list ( IP doc ) add new revisions for submission to IESG : ip , mpls , ip - over - mpls , mpls - over - udp - ip please merge and upload mpls / IDs / draft - ietf - detnet - mpls- mpls - over - udp - ip / IDs / draft - ietf - detnet - mpls - over - udp - ip- ip - over - mpls / IDs / draft - ietf - detnet - ip - over - mpls- ip / IDs / draft - ietf - detnet - ip- OK . Thanks for the updates . B." afbab6972936aa8e00398f77148290ca8cdb6383 afbab6972936aa8e00398f77148290ca8cdb6383 draft-ietf-detnet-ip 5fb337c0ea74cb1ccd64478106e7c2651e41470c7d941503b9db8f2960086545 ['5fb337c0ea74cb1ccd64478106e7c2651e41470c7d941503b9db8f2960086545', 'af1c82a2e0ef80b87905c68c90063afbd27246ab50c8079777584bc93467514d'] A "security considerations for detnet are described in detail in i- d.ietf-detnet-security. general security considerations are described in i-d.ietf-detnet-architecture. this section considers exclusively security considerations which are specific to the detnet ip data plane." {15: 1, 102: 1, 6: 4, 79: 4, 90: 2, 51: 3, 130: 4, 62: 6, 85: 7, 68: 6, 35: 5, 110: 2, 91: 4, 114: 2, 97: 4, 31: 3, 13: 2, 67: 3, 38: 4, 26: 3, 124: 5, 98: 4, 54: 4, 127: 5, 8: 4, 96: 4, 64: 3, 30: 3, 61: 5, 55: 5, 27: 4, 52: 3, 129: 5, 115: 2, 84: 3, 76: 8, 87: 3, 131: 7, 113: 5, 99: 4, 36: 2, 24: 2, 53: 3, 72: 4} {151: 1, 272: 1, 1: 11, 4: 4, 9: 7, 10: 5, 15: 4, 24: 4, 25: 6, 26: 7, 27: 3, 39: 7, 43: 5, 49: 5, 50: 4, 58: 5, 59: 4, 64: 4, 69: 6, 81: 7, 82: 5, 86: 3, 96: 4, 97: 3, 100: 8, 108: 5, 109: 6, 110: 6, 111: 4, 114: 5, 115: 6, 116: 4, 118: 8, 119: 7, 120: 5, 121: 6, 122: 5, 123: 4, 124: 6, 128: 3, 129: 3, 130: 5, 132: 6, 136: 4, 145: 6, 147: 4, 154: 5, 156: 3, 161: 5, 162: 5, 165: 5, 168: 6, 169: 2, 172: 2, 180: 3, 184: 7, 187: 7, 188: 6, 191: 5, 194: 6, 202: 7, 203: 8, 206: 4, 207: 5, 215: 4, 217: 5, 218: 10, 220: 4, 221: 4, 222: 7, 224: 5, 227: 6, 229: 3, 234: 7, 235: 4, 241: 4, 242: 4, 243: 6, 244: 3, 245: 6, 248: 3, 250: 5, 258: 13, 262: 6, 263: 7, 264: 5, 267: 6, 270: 4, 273: 7, 287: 5, 289: 3, 291: 5, 299: 6, 300: 4, 304: 4, 309: 5, 314: 4, 315: 2, 320: 6, 323: 6, 327: 6, 328: 5, 329: 4, 330: 12, 334: 4, 335: 4, 341: 6, 342: 7, 347: 6, 348: 6, 350: 9, 351: 4, 352: 2, 353: 2, 354: 2, 358: 6, 365: 2, 366: 4, 369: 3, 371: 8, 372: 5, 376: 4, 384: 5, 385: 4, 386: 5, 387: 4, 392: 5, 393: 6, 396: 7, 397: 9, 398: 8, 402: 2} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 67 "Security considerations for DetNet are described in detail in I- D.ietf-detnet-security. General security considerations are described in RFC8655. This section considers exclusively security considerations which are specific to the DetNet IP data plane." "Update references , fix nits , fix one minor change as discussed on list ( IP doc ) add new revisions for submission to IESG : ip , mpls , ip - over - mpls , mpls - over - udp - ip please merge and upload mpls / IDs / draft - ietf - detnet - mpls- mpls - over - udp - ip / IDs / draft - ietf - detnet - mpls - over - udp - ip- ip - over - mpls / IDs / draft - ietf - detnet - ip - over - mpls- ip / IDs / draft - ietf - detnet - ip- OK . Thanks for the updates . B." afbab6972936aa8e00398f77148290ca8cdb6383 afbab6972936aa8e00398f77148290ca8cdb6383 draft-ietf-detnet-ip af1c82a2e0ef80b87905c68c90063afbd27246ab50c8079777584bc93467514d ['5fb337c0ea74cb1ccd64478106e7c2651e41470c7d941503b9db8f2960086545', 'af1c82a2e0ef80b87905c68c90063afbd27246ab50c8079777584bc93467514d'] B "security considerations for detnet are described in detail in i- d.ietf-detnet-security. general security considerations are described in rfc8655. this section considers exclusively security considerations which are specific to the detnet ip data plane." {15: 1, 102: 1, 6: 4, 79: 4, 90: 2, 51: 3, 130: 4, 62: 6, 85: 7, 68: 6, 35: 5, 110: 2, 91: 4, 114: 2, 97: 4, 31: 3, 13: 2, 67: 3, 38: 4, 26: 3, 124: 5, 98: 4, 54: 4, 127: 5, 8: 4, 96: 4, 64: 3, 30: 3, 61: 5, 55: 5, 27: 4, 52: 3, 129: 5, 115: 2, 84: 3, 76: 8, 87: 3, 131: 7, 113: 5, 99: 4, 36: 2, 24: 2, 53: 3, 72: 4} {151: 1, 272: 1, 1: 11, 4: 4, 9: 7, 10: 5, 15: 4, 24: 4, 25: 6, 26: 7, 27: 3, 39: 7, 43: 5, 49: 5, 50: 4, 58: 5, 59: 4, 64: 4, 69: 6, 81: 7, 82: 5, 86: 3, 96: 4, 97: 3, 100: 8, 108: 5, 109: 6, 110: 6, 111: 4, 114: 5, 115: 6, 116: 4, 118: 8, 119: 7, 120: 5, 121: 6, 122: 5, 123: 4, 124: 6, 128: 3, 129: 3, 130: 5, 132: 6, 136: 4, 145: 6, 147: 4, 154: 5, 156: 3, 161: 5, 162: 5, 165: 5, 168: 6, 169: 2, 172: 2, 180: 3, 184: 7, 187: 7, 188: 6, 191: 5, 194: 6, 202: 7, 203: 8, 206: 4, 207: 5, 215: 4, 217: 5, 218: 10, 220: 4, 221: 4, 222: 7, 224: 5, 227: 6, 229: 3, 234: 7, 235: 4, 241: 4, 242: 4, 243: 6, 244: 3, 245: 6, 248: 3, 250: 5, 258: 13, 262: 6, 263: 7, 264: 5, 267: 6, 270: 4, 273: 7, 287: 5, 289: 3, 291: 5, 299: 6, 300: 4, 304: 4, 309: 5, 314: 4, 315: 2, 320: 6, 323: 6, 327: 6, 328: 5, 329: 4, 330: 12, 334: 4, 335: 4, 341: 6, 342: 7, 347: 6, 348: 6, 350: 9, 351: 4, 352: 2, 353: 2, 354: 2, 358: 6, 365: 2, 366: 4, 369: 3, 371: 8, 372: 5, 376: 4, 384: 5, 385: 4, 386: 5, 387: 4, 392: 5, 393: 6, 396: 7, 397: 9, 398: 8, 402: 2} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 64 "Deterministic Networking (DetNet) is a service that can be offered by a network to DetNet flows. DetNet provides these flows with a low packet loss rates and assured maximum end-to-end delivery latency. General background and concepts of DetNet can be found in I-D.ietf- detnet-architecture." Looks good to me , d431d1876f9704f0aa60ecf2d0a1035f8b5833c5 d431d1876f9704f0aa60ecf2d0a1035f8b5833c5 draft-ietf-detnet-mpls-over-udp-ip 3d716739e661873cd0f36b5c496d8e17986829051d23d574f690a45927327f6e ['5395b0161e6d5540c9b8a42408d25c4e71f2b4acd554940cc3f38997e94453c0', '3d716739e661873cd0f36b5c496d8e17986829051d23d574f690a45927327f6e'] A "deterministic networking (detnet) is a service that can be offered by a network to detnet flows. detnet provides these flows with a low packet loss rates and assured maximum end-to-end delivery latency. general background and concepts of detnet can be found in i-d.ietf- detnet-architecture." {67: 1, 52: 4, 130: 2, 124: 3} {305: 1, 268: 1, 391: 4, 269: 2, 158: 3} {133, 391, 268, 269, 305, 158} 64 "Deterministic Networking (DetNet) is a service that can be offered by a network to DetNet flows. DetNet provides these flows extremely low packet loss rates and assured maximum end-to-end delivery latency. General background and concepts of DetNet can be found in RFC8655." Looks good to me , d431d1876f9704f0aa60ecf2d0a1035f8b5833c5 d431d1876f9704f0aa60ecf2d0a1035f8b5833c5 draft-ietf-detnet-mpls-over-udp-ip 5395b0161e6d5540c9b8a42408d25c4e71f2b4acd554940cc3f38997e94453c0 ['5395b0161e6d5540c9b8a42408d25c4e71f2b4acd554940cc3f38997e94453c0', '3d716739e661873cd0f36b5c496d8e17986829051d23d574f690a45927327f6e'] B "deterministic networking (detnet) is a service that can be offered by a network to detnet flows. detnet provides these flows extremely low packet loss rates and assured maximum end-to-end delivery latency. general background and concepts of detnet can be found in rfc8655." {67: 1, 52: 4, 130: 2, 124: 3} {305: 1, 268: 1, 391: 4, 269: 2, 158: 3} {133, 391, 268, 269, 305, 158} 64 "A method of identifying the DetNet flow group to the processing element." Looks good to me , d431d1876f9704f0aa60ecf2d0a1035f8b5833c5 d431d1876f9704f0aa60ecf2d0a1035f8b5833c5 draft-ietf-detnet-mpls-over-udp-ip 82f56d4694c2ec964de0a4413954f87ca621628c63d7425944baeff9aa4b6dad ['c7ee085ee854e0b1712bd45394a76361fb4ef19b0c191f4b383df6f81eddcaa7', '0e313215df9694bc26777ba4ac347cb8ef73f8475d2bfed664aab722833589ae', '870147c2dad0a0dda2dd0a9f85ef83b3c4de9a304fdff6d9fa9ccc4bde9d70c0', '345246c6f81f5877c3d78b5a09dbb76c86a0a24b89709f41c28ac81151ea98bd', 'a6a4ee1a9211a2be0e24cf91f9742499a46567acff4c78f62b568b34e38c08de', '82f56d4694c2ec964de0a4413954f87ca621628c63d7425944baeff9aa4b6dad', 'cfc7fa99a0fdb212aa4e5322f7ac945147112ba2dee1be7cc31e6d276c62f99a', '6ab286c5c6814f3ce1ed2f2d478adf0a2f9976a5446998b122c1b9a108fca2e6'] A "a method of identifying the detnet flow group to the processing element." {129: 1, 53: 1, 6: 2, 79: 2, 90: 3, 51: 3, 130: 2, 62: 5, 85: 5, 68: 4, 35: 3, 110: 3, 91: 5, 114: 3, 97: 3, 31: 3, 13: 3, 67: 3, 38: 4, 26: 3, 124: 3, 98: 2, 54: 2, 127: 3, 8: 2, 96: 3, 64: 4, 30: 4, 61: 5, 55: 3, 27: 4, 15: 3, 52: 2, 115: 3, 84: 3, 76: 6, 87: 3, 131: 5, 102: 3, 113: 5, 99: 2, 36: 3, 24: 2, 72: 4} {165: 1, 369: 1, 1: 9, 4: 2, 9: 5, 10: 3, 15: 3, 24: 2, 25: 5, 26: 5, 27: 3, 39: 5, 43: 3, 49: 6, 50: 5, 58: 5, 59: 2, 64: 3, 69: 4, 81: 6, 82: 4, 86: 3, 96: 4, 97: 3, 100: 7, 108: 3, 109: 4, 110: 4, 111: 2, 114: 3, 115: 4, 116: 3, 118: 6, 119: 5, 120: 3, 121: 4, 122: 4, 123: 3, 124: 4, 128: 4, 129: 4, 130: 5, 132: 4, 136: 2, 145: 4, 147: 4, 151: 4, 152: 4, 154: 3, 156: 2, 161: 3, 162: 3, 168: 4, 169: 3, 172: 3, 180: 4, 184: 5, 187: 5, 188: 4, 191: 3, 194: 4, 202: 5, 203: 6, 206: 2, 207: 3, 215: 2, 217: 3, 218: 8, 220: 2, 221: 2, 222: 5, 224: 3, 227: 5, 229: 3, 234: 5, 235: 2, 241: 2, 242: 2, 243: 4, 244: 4, 245: 4, 248: 4, 250: 4, 258: 11, 262: 4, 263: 5, 264: 3, 267: 4, 270: 3, 272: 3, 273: 5, 287: 3, 289: 3, 291: 5, 299: 5, 300: 3, 304: 3, 309: 3, 315: 3, 320: 4, 323: 4, 327: 4, 328: 3, 329: 2, 330: 10, 334: 2, 335: 3, 341: 5, 342: 6, 347: 5, 348: 5, 350: 7, 351: 5, 352: 3, 353: 3, 354: 2, 358: 4, 365: 3, 366: 2, 371: 7, 372: 5, 376: 2, 384: 5, 385: 4, 386: 3, 387: 3, 392: 3, 393: 4, 396: 6, 397: 7, 398: 6, 402: 3} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 64 A method of carrying the DetNet sequence number. Looks good to me , d431d1876f9704f0aa60ecf2d0a1035f8b5833c5 d431d1876f9704f0aa60ecf2d0a1035f8b5833c5 draft-ietf-detnet-mpls-over-udp-ip 870147c2dad0a0dda2dd0a9f85ef83b3c4de9a304fdff6d9fa9ccc4bde9d70c0 ['c7ee085ee854e0b1712bd45394a76361fb4ef19b0c191f4b383df6f81eddcaa7', '0e313215df9694bc26777ba4ac347cb8ef73f8475d2bfed664aab722833589ae', '870147c2dad0a0dda2dd0a9f85ef83b3c4de9a304fdff6d9fa9ccc4bde9d70c0', '345246c6f81f5877c3d78b5a09dbb76c86a0a24b89709f41c28ac81151ea98bd', 'a6a4ee1a9211a2be0e24cf91f9742499a46567acff4c78f62b568b34e38c08de', '82f56d4694c2ec964de0a4413954f87ca621628c63d7425944baeff9aa4b6dad', 'cfc7fa99a0fdb212aa4e5322f7ac945147112ba2dee1be7cc31e6d276c62f99a', '6ab286c5c6814f3ce1ed2f2d478adf0a2f9976a5446998b122c1b9a108fca2e6'] A a method of carrying the detnet sequence number. {129: 1, 53: 1, 6: 2, 79: 2, 90: 3, 51: 3, 130: 2, 62: 5, 85: 5, 68: 4, 35: 3, 110: 3, 91: 5, 114: 3, 97: 3, 31: 3, 13: 3, 67: 3, 38: 4, 26: 3, 124: 3, 98: 2, 54: 2, 127: 3, 8: 2, 96: 3, 64: 4, 30: 4, 61: 5, 55: 3, 27: 4, 15: 3, 52: 2, 115: 3, 84: 3, 76: 6, 87: 3, 131: 5, 102: 3, 113: 5, 99: 2, 36: 3, 24: 2, 72: 4} {165: 1, 369: 1, 1: 9, 4: 2, 9: 5, 10: 3, 15: 3, 24: 2, 25: 5, 26: 5, 27: 3, 39: 5, 43: 3, 49: 6, 50: 5, 58: 5, 59: 2, 64: 3, 69: 4, 81: 6, 82: 4, 86: 3, 96: 4, 97: 3, 100: 7, 108: 3, 109: 4, 110: 4, 111: 2, 114: 3, 115: 4, 116: 3, 118: 6, 119: 5, 120: 3, 121: 4, 122: 4, 123: 3, 124: 4, 128: 4, 129: 4, 130: 5, 132: 4, 136: 2, 145: 4, 147: 4, 151: 4, 152: 4, 154: 3, 156: 2, 161: 3, 162: 3, 168: 4, 169: 3, 172: 3, 180: 4, 184: 5, 187: 5, 188: 4, 191: 3, 194: 4, 202: 5, 203: 6, 206: 2, 207: 3, 215: 2, 217: 3, 218: 8, 220: 2, 221: 2, 222: 5, 224: 3, 227: 5, 229: 3, 234: 5, 235: 2, 241: 2, 242: 2, 243: 4, 244: 4, 245: 4, 248: 4, 250: 4, 258: 11, 262: 4, 263: 5, 264: 3, 267: 4, 270: 3, 272: 3, 273: 5, 287: 3, 289: 3, 291: 5, 299: 5, 300: 3, 304: 3, 309: 3, 315: 3, 320: 4, 323: 4, 327: 4, 328: 3, 329: 2, 330: 10, 334: 2, 335: 3, 341: 5, 342: 6, 347: 5, 348: 5, 350: 7, 351: 5, 352: 3, 353: 3, 354: 2, 358: 4, 365: 3, 366: 2, 371: 7, 372: 5, 376: 2, 384: 5, 385: 4, 386: 3, 387: 3, 392: 3, 393: 4, 396: 6, 397: 7, 398: 6, 402: 3} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 64 "A method of distinguishing DetNet OAM packets from DetNet data packets." Looks good to me , d431d1876f9704f0aa60ecf2d0a1035f8b5833c5 d431d1876f9704f0aa60ecf2d0a1035f8b5833c5 draft-ietf-detnet-mpls-over-udp-ip 0e313215df9694bc26777ba4ac347cb8ef73f8475d2bfed664aab722833589ae ['c7ee085ee854e0b1712bd45394a76361fb4ef19b0c191f4b383df6f81eddcaa7', '0e313215df9694bc26777ba4ac347cb8ef73f8475d2bfed664aab722833589ae', '870147c2dad0a0dda2dd0a9f85ef83b3c4de9a304fdff6d9fa9ccc4bde9d70c0', '345246c6f81f5877c3d78b5a09dbb76c86a0a24b89709f41c28ac81151ea98bd', 'a6a4ee1a9211a2be0e24cf91f9742499a46567acff4c78f62b568b34e38c08de', '82f56d4694c2ec964de0a4413954f87ca621628c63d7425944baeff9aa4b6dad', 'cfc7fa99a0fdb212aa4e5322f7ac945147112ba2dee1be7cc31e6d276c62f99a', '6ab286c5c6814f3ce1ed2f2d478adf0a2f9976a5446998b122c1b9a108fca2e6'] A "a method of distinguishing detnet oam packets from detnet data packets." {129: 1, 53: 1, 6: 2, 79: 2, 90: 3, 51: 3, 130: 2, 62: 5, 85: 5, 68: 4, 35: 3, 110: 3, 91: 5, 114: 3, 97: 3, 31: 3, 13: 3, 67: 3, 38: 4, 26: 3, 124: 3, 98: 2, 54: 2, 127: 3, 8: 2, 96: 3, 64: 4, 30: 4, 61: 5, 55: 3, 27: 4, 15: 3, 52: 2, 115: 3, 84: 3, 76: 6, 87: 3, 131: 5, 102: 3, 113: 5, 99: 2, 36: 3, 24: 2, 72: 4} {165: 1, 369: 1, 1: 9, 4: 2, 9: 5, 10: 3, 15: 3, 24: 2, 25: 5, 26: 5, 27: 3, 39: 5, 43: 3, 49: 6, 50: 5, 58: 5, 59: 2, 64: 3, 69: 4, 81: 6, 82: 4, 86: 3, 96: 4, 97: 3, 100: 7, 108: 3, 109: 4, 110: 4, 111: 2, 114: 3, 115: 4, 116: 3, 118: 6, 119: 5, 120: 3, 121: 4, 122: 4, 123: 3, 124: 4, 128: 4, 129: 4, 130: 5, 132: 4, 136: 2, 145: 4, 147: 4, 151: 4, 152: 4, 154: 3, 156: 2, 161: 3, 162: 3, 168: 4, 169: 3, 172: 3, 180: 4, 184: 5, 187: 5, 188: 4, 191: 3, 194: 4, 202: 5, 203: 6, 206: 2, 207: 3, 215: 2, 217: 3, 218: 8, 220: 2, 221: 2, 222: 5, 224: 3, 227: 5, 229: 3, 234: 5, 235: 2, 241: 2, 242: 2, 243: 4, 244: 4, 245: 4, 248: 4, 250: 4, 258: 11, 262: 4, 263: 5, 264: 3, 267: 4, 270: 3, 272: 3, 273: 5, 287: 3, 289: 3, 291: 5, 299: 5, 300: 3, 304: 3, 309: 3, 315: 3, 320: 4, 323: 4, 327: 4, 328: 3, 329: 2, 330: 10, 334: 2, 335: 3, 341: 5, 342: 6, 347: 5, 348: 5, 350: 7, 351: 5, 352: 3, 353: 3, 354: 2, 358: 4, 365: 3, 366: 2, 371: 7, 372: 5, 376: 2, 384: 5, 385: 4, 386: 3, 387: 3, 392: 3, 393: 4, 396: 6, 397: 7, 398: 6, 402: 3} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 64 A method of carrying queuing and forwarding indication. Looks good to me , d431d1876f9704f0aa60ecf2d0a1035f8b5833c5 d431d1876f9704f0aa60ecf2d0a1035f8b5833c5 draft-ietf-detnet-mpls-over-udp-ip a6a4ee1a9211a2be0e24cf91f9742499a46567acff4c78f62b568b34e38c08de ['c7ee085ee854e0b1712bd45394a76361fb4ef19b0c191f4b383df6f81eddcaa7', '0e313215df9694bc26777ba4ac347cb8ef73f8475d2bfed664aab722833589ae', '870147c2dad0a0dda2dd0a9f85ef83b3c4de9a304fdff6d9fa9ccc4bde9d70c0', '345246c6f81f5877c3d78b5a09dbb76c86a0a24b89709f41c28ac81151ea98bd', 'a6a4ee1a9211a2be0e24cf91f9742499a46567acff4c78f62b568b34e38c08de', '82f56d4694c2ec964de0a4413954f87ca621628c63d7425944baeff9aa4b6dad', 'cfc7fa99a0fdb212aa4e5322f7ac945147112ba2dee1be7cc31e6d276c62f99a', '6ab286c5c6814f3ce1ed2f2d478adf0a2f9976a5446998b122c1b9a108fca2e6'] A a method of carrying queuing and forwarding indication. {129: 1, 53: 1, 6: 2, 79: 2, 90: 3, 51: 3, 130: 2, 62: 5, 85: 5, 68: 4, 35: 3, 110: 3, 91: 5, 114: 3, 97: 3, 31: 3, 13: 3, 67: 3, 38: 4, 26: 3, 124: 3, 98: 2, 54: 2, 127: 3, 8: 2, 96: 3, 64: 4, 30: 4, 61: 5, 55: 3, 27: 4, 15: 3, 52: 2, 115: 3, 84: 3, 76: 6, 87: 3, 131: 5, 102: 3, 113: 5, 99: 2, 36: 3, 24: 2, 72: 4} {165: 1, 369: 1, 1: 9, 4: 2, 9: 5, 10: 3, 15: 3, 24: 2, 25: 5, 26: 5, 27: 3, 39: 5, 43: 3, 49: 6, 50: 5, 58: 5, 59: 2, 64: 3, 69: 4, 81: 6, 82: 4, 86: 3, 96: 4, 97: 3, 100: 7, 108: 3, 109: 4, 110: 4, 111: 2, 114: 3, 115: 4, 116: 3, 118: 6, 119: 5, 120: 3, 121: 4, 122: 4, 123: 3, 124: 4, 128: 4, 129: 4, 130: 5, 132: 4, 136: 2, 145: 4, 147: 4, 151: 4, 152: 4, 154: 3, 156: 2, 161: 3, 162: 3, 168: 4, 169: 3, 172: 3, 180: 4, 184: 5, 187: 5, 188: 4, 191: 3, 194: 4, 202: 5, 203: 6, 206: 2, 207: 3, 215: 2, 217: 3, 218: 8, 220: 2, 221: 2, 222: 5, 224: 3, 227: 5, 229: 3, 234: 5, 235: 2, 241: 2, 242: 2, 243: 4, 244: 4, 245: 4, 248: 4, 250: 4, 258: 11, 262: 4, 263: 5, 264: 3, 267: 4, 270: 3, 272: 3, 273: 5, 287: 3, 289: 3, 291: 5, 299: 5, 300: 3, 304: 3, 309: 3, 315: 3, 320: 4, 323: 4, 327: 4, 328: 3, 329: 2, 330: 10, 334: 2, 335: 3, 341: 5, 342: 6, 347: 5, 348: 5, 350: 7, 351: 5, 352: 3, 353: 3, 354: 2, 358: 4, 365: 3, 366: 2, 371: 7, 372: 5, 376: 2, 384: 5, 385: 4, 386: 3, 387: 3, 392: 3, 393: 4, 396: 6, 397: 7, 398: 6, 402: 3} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 64 A method for identifying DetNet flows to the processing element. Looks good to me , d431d1876f9704f0aa60ecf2d0a1035f8b5833c5 d431d1876f9704f0aa60ecf2d0a1035f8b5833c5 draft-ietf-detnet-mpls-over-udp-ip cfc7fa99a0fdb212aa4e5322f7ac945147112ba2dee1be7cc31e6d276c62f99a ['c7ee085ee854e0b1712bd45394a76361fb4ef19b0c191f4b383df6f81eddcaa7', '0e313215df9694bc26777ba4ac347cb8ef73f8475d2bfed664aab722833589ae', '870147c2dad0a0dda2dd0a9f85ef83b3c4de9a304fdff6d9fa9ccc4bde9d70c0', '345246c6f81f5877c3d78b5a09dbb76c86a0a24b89709f41c28ac81151ea98bd', 'a6a4ee1a9211a2be0e24cf91f9742499a46567acff4c78f62b568b34e38c08de', '82f56d4694c2ec964de0a4413954f87ca621628c63d7425944baeff9aa4b6dad', 'cfc7fa99a0fdb212aa4e5322f7ac945147112ba2dee1be7cc31e6d276c62f99a', '6ab286c5c6814f3ce1ed2f2d478adf0a2f9976a5446998b122c1b9a108fca2e6'] B a method for identifying detnet flows to the processing element. {129: 1, 53: 1, 6: 2, 79: 2, 90: 3, 51: 3, 130: 2, 62: 5, 85: 5, 68: 4, 35: 3, 110: 3, 91: 5, 114: 3, 97: 3, 31: 3, 13: 3, 67: 3, 38: 4, 26: 3, 124: 3, 98: 2, 54: 2, 127: 3, 8: 2, 96: 3, 64: 4, 30: 4, 61: 5, 55: 3, 27: 4, 15: 3, 52: 2, 115: 3, 84: 3, 76: 6, 87: 3, 131: 5, 102: 3, 113: 5, 99: 2, 36: 3, 24: 2, 72: 4} {165: 1, 369: 1, 1: 9, 4: 2, 9: 5, 10: 3, 15: 3, 24: 2, 25: 5, 26: 5, 27: 3, 39: 5, 43: 3, 49: 6, 50: 5, 58: 5, 59: 2, 64: 3, 69: 4, 81: 6, 82: 4, 86: 3, 96: 4, 97: 3, 100: 7, 108: 3, 109: 4, 110: 4, 111: 2, 114: 3, 115: 4, 116: 3, 118: 6, 119: 5, 120: 3, 121: 4, 122: 4, 123: 3, 124: 4, 128: 4, 129: 4, 130: 5, 132: 4, 136: 2, 145: 4, 147: 4, 151: 4, 152: 4, 154: 3, 156: 2, 161: 3, 162: 3, 168: 4, 169: 3, 172: 3, 180: 4, 184: 5, 187: 5, 188: 4, 191: 3, 194: 4, 202: 5, 203: 6, 206: 2, 207: 3, 215: 2, 217: 3, 218: 8, 220: 2, 221: 2, 222: 5, 224: 3, 227: 5, 229: 3, 234: 5, 235: 2, 241: 2, 242: 2, 243: 4, 244: 4, 245: 4, 248: 4, 250: 4, 258: 11, 262: 4, 263: 5, 264: 3, 267: 4, 270: 3, 272: 3, 273: 5, 287: 3, 289: 3, 291: 5, 299: 5, 300: 3, 304: 3, 309: 3, 315: 3, 320: 4, 323: 4, 327: 4, 328: 3, 329: 2, 330: 10, 334: 2, 335: 3, 341: 5, 342: 6, 347: 5, 348: 5, 350: 7, 351: 5, 352: 3, 353: 3, 354: 2, 358: 4, 365: 3, 366: 2, 371: 7, 372: 5, 376: 2, 384: 5, 385: 4, 386: 3, 387: 3, 392: 3, 393: 4, 396: 6, 397: 7, 398: 6, 402: 3} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 64 A method for carrying the DetNet sequence number. Looks good to me , d431d1876f9704f0aa60ecf2d0a1035f8b5833c5 d431d1876f9704f0aa60ecf2d0a1035f8b5833c5 draft-ietf-detnet-mpls-over-udp-ip 345246c6f81f5877c3d78b5a09dbb76c86a0a24b89709f41c28ac81151ea98bd ['c7ee085ee854e0b1712bd45394a76361fb4ef19b0c191f4b383df6f81eddcaa7', '0e313215df9694bc26777ba4ac347cb8ef73f8475d2bfed664aab722833589ae', '870147c2dad0a0dda2dd0a9f85ef83b3c4de9a304fdff6d9fa9ccc4bde9d70c0', '345246c6f81f5877c3d78b5a09dbb76c86a0a24b89709f41c28ac81151ea98bd', 'a6a4ee1a9211a2be0e24cf91f9742499a46567acff4c78f62b568b34e38c08de', '82f56d4694c2ec964de0a4413954f87ca621628c63d7425944baeff9aa4b6dad', 'cfc7fa99a0fdb212aa4e5322f7ac945147112ba2dee1be7cc31e6d276c62f99a', '6ab286c5c6814f3ce1ed2f2d478adf0a2f9976a5446998b122c1b9a108fca2e6'] B a method for carrying the detnet sequence number. {129: 1, 53: 1, 6: 2, 79: 2, 90: 3, 51: 3, 130: 2, 62: 5, 85: 5, 68: 4, 35: 3, 110: 3, 91: 5, 114: 3, 97: 3, 31: 3, 13: 3, 67: 3, 38: 4, 26: 3, 124: 3, 98: 2, 54: 2, 127: 3, 8: 2, 96: 3, 64: 4, 30: 4, 61: 5, 55: 3, 27: 4, 15: 3, 52: 2, 115: 3, 84: 3, 76: 6, 87: 3, 131: 5, 102: 3, 113: 5, 99: 2, 36: 3, 24: 2, 72: 4} {165: 1, 369: 1, 1: 9, 4: 2, 9: 5, 10: 3, 15: 3, 24: 2, 25: 5, 26: 5, 27: 3, 39: 5, 43: 3, 49: 6, 50: 5, 58: 5, 59: 2, 64: 3, 69: 4, 81: 6, 82: 4, 86: 3, 96: 4, 97: 3, 100: 7, 108: 3, 109: 4, 110: 4, 111: 2, 114: 3, 115: 4, 116: 3, 118: 6, 119: 5, 120: 3, 121: 4, 122: 4, 123: 3, 124: 4, 128: 4, 129: 4, 130: 5, 132: 4, 136: 2, 145: 4, 147: 4, 151: 4, 152: 4, 154: 3, 156: 2, 161: 3, 162: 3, 168: 4, 169: 3, 172: 3, 180: 4, 184: 5, 187: 5, 188: 4, 191: 3, 194: 4, 202: 5, 203: 6, 206: 2, 207: 3, 215: 2, 217: 3, 218: 8, 220: 2, 221: 2, 222: 5, 224: 3, 227: 5, 229: 3, 234: 5, 235: 2, 241: 2, 242: 2, 243: 4, 244: 4, 245: 4, 248: 4, 250: 4, 258: 11, 262: 4, 263: 5, 264: 3, 267: 4, 270: 3, 272: 3, 273: 5, 287: 3, 289: 3, 291: 5, 299: 5, 300: 3, 304: 3, 309: 3, 315: 3, 320: 4, 323: 4, 327: 4, 328: 3, 329: 2, 330: 10, 334: 2, 335: 3, 341: 5, 342: 6, 347: 5, 348: 5, 350: 7, 351: 5, 352: 3, 353: 3, 354: 2, 358: 4, 365: 3, 366: 2, 371: 7, 372: 5, 376: 2, 384: 5, 385: 4, 386: 3, 387: 3, 392: 3, 393: 4, 396: 6, 397: 7, 398: 6, 402: 3} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 64 "A method for distinguishing DetNet OAM packets from DetNet data packets." Looks good to me , d431d1876f9704f0aa60ecf2d0a1035f8b5833c5 d431d1876f9704f0aa60ecf2d0a1035f8b5833c5 draft-ietf-detnet-mpls-over-udp-ip c7ee085ee854e0b1712bd45394a76361fb4ef19b0c191f4b383df6f81eddcaa7 ['c7ee085ee854e0b1712bd45394a76361fb4ef19b0c191f4b383df6f81eddcaa7', '0e313215df9694bc26777ba4ac347cb8ef73f8475d2bfed664aab722833589ae', '870147c2dad0a0dda2dd0a9f85ef83b3c4de9a304fdff6d9fa9ccc4bde9d70c0', '345246c6f81f5877c3d78b5a09dbb76c86a0a24b89709f41c28ac81151ea98bd', 'a6a4ee1a9211a2be0e24cf91f9742499a46567acff4c78f62b568b34e38c08de', '82f56d4694c2ec964de0a4413954f87ca621628c63d7425944baeff9aa4b6dad', 'cfc7fa99a0fdb212aa4e5322f7ac945147112ba2dee1be7cc31e6d276c62f99a', '6ab286c5c6814f3ce1ed2f2d478adf0a2f9976a5446998b122c1b9a108fca2e6'] B "a method for distinguishing detnet oam packets from detnet data packets." {129: 1, 53: 1, 6: 2, 79: 2, 90: 3, 51: 3, 130: 2, 62: 5, 85: 5, 68: 4, 35: 3, 110: 3, 91: 5, 114: 3, 97: 3, 31: 3, 13: 3, 67: 3, 38: 4, 26: 3, 124: 3, 98: 2, 54: 2, 127: 3, 8: 2, 96: 3, 64: 4, 30: 4, 61: 5, 55: 3, 27: 4, 15: 3, 52: 2, 115: 3, 84: 3, 76: 6, 87: 3, 131: 5, 102: 3, 113: 5, 99: 2, 36: 3, 24: 2, 72: 4} {165: 1, 369: 1, 1: 9, 4: 2, 9: 5, 10: 3, 15: 3, 24: 2, 25: 5, 26: 5, 27: 3, 39: 5, 43: 3, 49: 6, 50: 5, 58: 5, 59: 2, 64: 3, 69: 4, 81: 6, 82: 4, 86: 3, 96: 4, 97: 3, 100: 7, 108: 3, 109: 4, 110: 4, 111: 2, 114: 3, 115: 4, 116: 3, 118: 6, 119: 5, 120: 3, 121: 4, 122: 4, 123: 3, 124: 4, 128: 4, 129: 4, 130: 5, 132: 4, 136: 2, 145: 4, 147: 4, 151: 4, 152: 4, 154: 3, 156: 2, 161: 3, 162: 3, 168: 4, 169: 3, 172: 3, 180: 4, 184: 5, 187: 5, 188: 4, 191: 3, 194: 4, 202: 5, 203: 6, 206: 2, 207: 3, 215: 2, 217: 3, 218: 8, 220: 2, 221: 2, 222: 5, 224: 3, 227: 5, 229: 3, 234: 5, 235: 2, 241: 2, 242: 2, 243: 4, 244: 4, 245: 4, 248: 4, 250: 4, 258: 11, 262: 4, 263: 5, 264: 3, 267: 4, 270: 3, 272: 3, 273: 5, 287: 3, 289: 3, 291: 5, 299: 5, 300: 3, 304: 3, 309: 3, 315: 3, 320: 4, 323: 4, 327: 4, 328: 3, 329: 2, 330: 10, 334: 2, 335: 3, 341: 5, 342: 6, 347: 5, 348: 5, 350: 7, 351: 5, 352: 3, 353: 3, 354: 2, 358: 4, 365: 3, 366: 2, 371: 7, 372: 5, 376: 2, 384: 5, 385: 4, 386: 3, 387: 3, 392: 3, 393: 4, 396: 6, 397: 7, 398: 6, 402: 3} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 64 A method for carrying queuing and forwarding indication. Looks good to me , d431d1876f9704f0aa60ecf2d0a1035f8b5833c5 d431d1876f9704f0aa60ecf2d0a1035f8b5833c5 draft-ietf-detnet-mpls-over-udp-ip 6ab286c5c6814f3ce1ed2f2d478adf0a2f9976a5446998b122c1b9a108fca2e6 ['c7ee085ee854e0b1712bd45394a76361fb4ef19b0c191f4b383df6f81eddcaa7', '0e313215df9694bc26777ba4ac347cb8ef73f8475d2bfed664aab722833589ae', '870147c2dad0a0dda2dd0a9f85ef83b3c4de9a304fdff6d9fa9ccc4bde9d70c0', '345246c6f81f5877c3d78b5a09dbb76c86a0a24b89709f41c28ac81151ea98bd', 'a6a4ee1a9211a2be0e24cf91f9742499a46567acff4c78f62b568b34e38c08de', '82f56d4694c2ec964de0a4413954f87ca621628c63d7425944baeff9aa4b6dad', 'cfc7fa99a0fdb212aa4e5322f7ac945147112ba2dee1be7cc31e6d276c62f99a', '6ab286c5c6814f3ce1ed2f2d478adf0a2f9976a5446998b122c1b9a108fca2e6'] B a method for carrying queuing and forwarding indication. {129: 1, 53: 1, 6: 2, 79: 2, 90: 3, 51: 3, 130: 2, 62: 5, 85: 5, 68: 4, 35: 3, 110: 3, 91: 5, 114: 3, 97: 3, 31: 3, 13: 3, 67: 3, 38: 4, 26: 3, 124: 3, 98: 2, 54: 2, 127: 3, 8: 2, 96: 3, 64: 4, 30: 4, 61: 5, 55: 3, 27: 4, 15: 3, 52: 2, 115: 3, 84: 3, 76: 6, 87: 3, 131: 5, 102: 3, 113: 5, 99: 2, 36: 3, 24: 2, 72: 4} {165: 1, 369: 1, 1: 9, 4: 2, 9: 5, 10: 3, 15: 3, 24: 2, 25: 5, 26: 5, 27: 3, 39: 5, 43: 3, 49: 6, 50: 5, 58: 5, 59: 2, 64: 3, 69: 4, 81: 6, 82: 4, 86: 3, 96: 4, 97: 3, 100: 7, 108: 3, 109: 4, 110: 4, 111: 2, 114: 3, 115: 4, 116: 3, 118: 6, 119: 5, 120: 3, 121: 4, 122: 4, 123: 3, 124: 4, 128: 4, 129: 4, 130: 5, 132: 4, 136: 2, 145: 4, 147: 4, 151: 4, 152: 4, 154: 3, 156: 2, 161: 3, 162: 3, 168: 4, 169: 3, 172: 3, 180: 4, 184: 5, 187: 5, 188: 4, 191: 3, 194: 4, 202: 5, 203: 6, 206: 2, 207: 3, 215: 2, 217: 3, 218: 8, 220: 2, 221: 2, 222: 5, 224: 3, 227: 5, 229: 3, 234: 5, 235: 2, 241: 2, 242: 2, 243: 4, 244: 4, 245: 4, 248: 4, 250: 4, 258: 11, 262: 4, 263: 5, 264: 3, 267: 4, 270: 3, 272: 3, 273: 5, 287: 3, 289: 3, 291: 5, 299: 5, 300: 3, 304: 3, 309: 3, 315: 3, 320: 4, 323: 4, 327: 4, 328: 3, 329: 2, 330: 10, 334: 2, 335: 3, 341: 5, 342: 6, 347: 5, 348: 5, 350: 7, 351: 5, 352: 3, 353: 3, 354: 2, 358: 4, 365: 3, 366: 2, 371: 7, 372: 5, 376: 2, 384: 5, 385: 4, 386: 3, 387: 3, 392: 3, 393: 4, 396: 6, 397: 7, 398: 6, 402: 3} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 64 "This document uses the terminology established in the DetNet architecture I-D.ietf-detnet-architecture, and the reader is assumed to be familiar with that document and its terminology." Looks good to me , d431d1876f9704f0aa60ecf2d0a1035f8b5833c5 d431d1876f9704f0aa60ecf2d0a1035f8b5833c5 draft-ietf-detnet-mpls-over-udp-ip cae70a041f2bb7a437801975d64fbc6aa981e51be14ad7536d6a022d294d2c70 ['26dc046a4f58b1965321c2ca1c26d2246404ea3c259d0662366f915790031fc6', 'cae70a041f2bb7a437801975d64fbc6aa981e51be14ad7536d6a022d294d2c70'] A "this document uses the terminology established in the detnet architecture i-d.ietf-detnet-architecture, and the reader is assumed to be familiar with that document and its terminology." {52: 1, 53: 1, 130: 2, 79: 2, 51: 2, 112: 3, 55: 3, 64: 2, 62: 3, 37: 2, 38: 3, 69: 2, 68: 2, 67: 2, 33: 2, 25: 2, 80: 2, 127: 3, 91: 3} {321: 1, 322: 1, 0: 2, 389: 2, 390: 2, 135: 3, 142: 3, 14: 2, 400: 3, 17: 2, 399: 3, 19: 3, 149: 3, 406: 2, 279: 2, 280: 2, 281: 2, 278: 2, 294: 2, 296: 3, 45: 3, 308: 2, 185: 2, 192: 2, 66: 2, 196: 4, 197: 3, 324: 3, 77: 3, 78: 3, 337: 4, 216: 3, 380: 2, 255: 2} {0, 389, 390, 135, 142, 14, 400, 17, 399, 19, 149, 406, 279, 280, 281, 278, 294, 296, 45, 308, 56, 185, 192, 321, 322, 66, 196, 197, 324, 77, 78, 337, 216, 380, 255} 64 "This document uses the terminology established in the DetNet architecture RFC8655, and the reader is assumed to be familiar with that document and its terminology." Looks good to me , d431d1876f9704f0aa60ecf2d0a1035f8b5833c5 d431d1876f9704f0aa60ecf2d0a1035f8b5833c5 draft-ietf-detnet-mpls-over-udp-ip 26dc046a4f58b1965321c2ca1c26d2246404ea3c259d0662366f915790031fc6 ['26dc046a4f58b1965321c2ca1c26d2246404ea3c259d0662366f915790031fc6', 'cae70a041f2bb7a437801975d64fbc6aa981e51be14ad7536d6a022d294d2c70'] B "this document uses the terminology established in the detnet architecture rfc8655, and the reader is assumed to be familiar with that document and its terminology." {52: 1, 53: 1, 130: 2, 79: 2, 51: 2, 112: 3, 55: 3, 64: 2, 62: 3, 37: 2, 38: 3, 69: 2, 68: 2, 67: 2, 33: 2, 25: 2, 80: 2, 127: 3, 91: 3} {321: 1, 322: 1, 0: 2, 389: 2, 390: 2, 135: 3, 142: 3, 14: 2, 400: 3, 17: 2, 399: 3, 19: 3, 149: 3, 406: 2, 279: 2, 280: 2, 281: 2, 278: 2, 294: 2, 296: 3, 45: 3, 308: 2, 185: 2, 192: 2, 66: 2, 196: 4, 197: 3, 324: 3, 77: 3, 78: 3, 337: 4, 216: 3, 380: 2, 255: 2} {0, 389, 390, 135, 142, 14, 400, 17, 399, 19, 149, 406, 279, 280, 281, 278, 294, 296, 45, 308, 56, 185, 192, 321, 322, 66, 196, 197, 324, 77, 78, 337, 216, 380, 255} 64 "A DetNet ""service"" label that is used between DetNet nodes that implement also the DetNet service sub-layer functions. An S-Label is also used to identify a DetNet flow at DetNet service sub- layer." Looks good to me , d431d1876f9704f0aa60ecf2d0a1035f8b5833c5 d431d1876f9704f0aa60ecf2d0a1035f8b5833c5 draft-ietf-detnet-mpls-over-udp-ip 101d6488f0f475a04aa297b74fc9f2861a180e4eb1a083da451550a5788c81e8 ['101d6488f0f475a04aa297b74fc9f2861a180e4eb1a083da451550a5788c81e8', 'cdc15b05d37b640ea4b7794cf9a229c6c28f8a1b7491f0460010ab5fcc44ff69', '721f6ecd2747b4ac6e14124d94c2ada61d234a9bb4361e357ca99d80a40aa1a8'] A "a detnet ""service"" label that is used between detnet nodes that implement also the detnet service sub-layer functions. an s-label is also used to identify a detnet flow at detnet service sub- layer." {52: 1, 53: 1, 33: 1, 69: 1, 68: 1, 130: 2, 79: 2, 51: 2, 112: 2, 55: 2, 62: 2, 37: 2, 38: 2, 67: 2, 25: 2, 80: 2, 127: 3, 91: 2} {321: 1, 322: 1, 324: 1, 406: 1, 279: 1, 0: 2, 389: 2, 390: 2, 135: 2, 142: 2, 400: 2, 17: 2, 399: 3, 19: 3, 149: 2, 280: 2, 281: 2, 278: 2, 294: 2, 296: 2, 45: 3, 308: 2, 56: 2, 185: 2, 192: 2, 66: 2, 196: 4, 197: 3, 77: 2, 78: 2, 337: 4, 216: 2, 380: 2, 255: 2} {0, 389, 390, 135, 142, 14, 400, 17, 399, 19, 149, 406, 279, 280, 281, 278, 294, 296, 45, 308, 56, 185, 192, 321, 322, 66, 196, 197, 324, 77, 78, 337, 216, 380, 255} 64 Packet Replication, Elimination and Ordering Functions. Looks good to me , d431d1876f9704f0aa60ecf2d0a1035f8b5833c5 d431d1876f9704f0aa60ecf2d0a1035f8b5833c5 draft-ietf-detnet-mpls-over-udp-ip cdc15b05d37b640ea4b7794cf9a229c6c28f8a1b7491f0460010ab5fcc44ff69 ['101d6488f0f475a04aa297b74fc9f2861a180e4eb1a083da451550a5788c81e8', 'cdc15b05d37b640ea4b7794cf9a229c6c28f8a1b7491f0460010ab5fcc44ff69', '721f6ecd2747b4ac6e14124d94c2ada61d234a9bb4361e357ca99d80a40aa1a8'] B packet replication, elimination and ordering functions. {52: 1, 53: 1, 33: 1, 69: 1, 68: 1, 130: 2, 79: 2, 51: 2, 112: 2, 55: 2, 62: 2, 37: 2, 38: 2, 67: 2, 25: 2, 80: 2, 127: 3, 91: 2} {321: 1, 322: 1, 324: 1, 406: 1, 279: 1, 0: 2, 389: 2, 390: 2, 135: 2, 142: 2, 400: 2, 17: 2, 399: 3, 19: 3, 149: 2, 280: 2, 281: 2, 278: 2, 294: 2, 296: 2, 45: 3, 308: 2, 56: 2, 185: 2, 192: 2, 66: 2, 196: 4, 197: 3, 77: 2, 78: 2, 337: 4, 216: 2, 380: 2, 255: 2} {0, 389, 390, 135, 142, 14, 400, 17, 399, 19, 149, 406, 279, 280, 281, 278, 294, 296, 45, 308, 56, 185, 192, 321, 322, 66, 196, 197, 324, 77, 78, 337, 216, 380, 255} 64 "A DetNet ""service"" label that is used between DetNet nodes that also implement the DetNet service sub-layer functions. An S-Label is also used to identify a DetNet flow at DetNet service sub- layer." Looks good to me , d431d1876f9704f0aa60ecf2d0a1035f8b5833c5 d431d1876f9704f0aa60ecf2d0a1035f8b5833c5 draft-ietf-detnet-mpls-over-udp-ip 721f6ecd2747b4ac6e14124d94c2ada61d234a9bb4361e357ca99d80a40aa1a8 ['101d6488f0f475a04aa297b74fc9f2861a180e4eb1a083da451550a5788c81e8', 'cdc15b05d37b640ea4b7794cf9a229c6c28f8a1b7491f0460010ab5fcc44ff69', '721f6ecd2747b4ac6e14124d94c2ada61d234a9bb4361e357ca99d80a40aa1a8'] B "a detnet ""service"" label that is used between detnet nodes that also implement the detnet service sub-layer functions. an s-label is also used to identify a detnet flow at detnet service sub- layer." {52: 1, 53: 1, 33: 1, 69: 1, 68: 1, 130: 2, 79: 2, 51: 2, 112: 2, 55: 2, 62: 2, 37: 2, 38: 2, 67: 2, 25: 2, 80: 2, 127: 3, 91: 2} {321: 1, 322: 1, 324: 1, 406: 1, 279: 1, 0: 2, 389: 2, 390: 2, 135: 2, 142: 2, 400: 2, 17: 2, 399: 3, 19: 3, 149: 2, 280: 2, 281: 2, 278: 2, 294: 2, 296: 2, 45: 3, 308: 2, 56: 2, 185: 2, 192: 2, 66: 2, 196: 4, 197: 3, 77: 2, 78: 2, 337: 4, 216: 2, 380: 2, 255: 2} {0, 389, 390, 135, 142, 14, 400, 17, 399, 19, 149, 406, 279, 280, 281, 278, 294, 296, 45, 308, 56, 185, 192, 321, 322, 66, 196, 197, 324, 77, 78, 337, 216, 380, 255} 64 "d-CW, S-Labels and zero or more F-Labels are used as defined in I- D.ietf-detnet-mpls and are not modified by this document. In case of aggregates the A-Label is treated as an S-Label and it too is not modified." Looks good to me , d431d1876f9704f0aa60ecf2d0a1035f8b5833c5 d431d1876f9704f0aa60ecf2d0a1035f8b5833c5 draft-ietf-detnet-mpls-over-udp-ip d5b29348bd685f249f0739f769413f01a84804f106345439899be82b4b06c21d ['d5b29348bd685f249f0739f769413f01a84804f106345439899be82b4b06c21d', 'bfaf3a51efcf3eea1985bb60b5e162a78b2466aa3eb6c99c4f9fb9a7d9583399'] A "d-cw, s-labels and zero or more f-labels are used as defined in i- d.ietf-detnet-mpls and are not modified by this document. in case of aggregates the a-label is treated as an s-label and it too is not modified." {38: 1, 71: 1, 60: 4, 56: 3, 102: 3, 64: 2, 62: 4, 33: 2, 26: 3, 32: 3, 83: 4, 113: 3, 126: 3, 112: 3, 85: 4, 129: 3} {212: 1, 286: 1, 260: 4, 261: 3, 274: 3, 343: 2, 283: 4, 31: 2, 32: 3, 33: 3, 163: 4, 228: 3, 357: 3, 166: 3, 231: 3, 298: 3, 363: 4, 46: 3, 377: 2} {260, 261, 274, 283, 286, 31, 32, 33, 163, 166, 298, 46, 339, 212, 343, 228, 357, 231, 363, 377} 64 "S-Labels, d-CW and zero or more F-Labels are used as defined in I- D.ietf-detnet-mpls and are not modified by this document. In case of aggregates the A-Label is treated as an S-Label and it too is not modified." Looks good to me , d431d1876f9704f0aa60ecf2d0a1035f8b5833c5 d431d1876f9704f0aa60ecf2d0a1035f8b5833c5 draft-ietf-detnet-mpls-over-udp-ip bfaf3a51efcf3eea1985bb60b5e162a78b2466aa3eb6c99c4f9fb9a7d9583399 ['d5b29348bd685f249f0739f769413f01a84804f106345439899be82b4b06c21d', 'bfaf3a51efcf3eea1985bb60b5e162a78b2466aa3eb6c99c4f9fb9a7d9583399'] B "s-labels, d-cw and zero or more f-labels are used as defined in i- d.ietf-detnet-mpls and are not modified by this document. in case of aggregates the a-label is treated as an s-label and it too is not modified." {38: 1, 71: 1, 60: 4, 56: 3, 102: 3, 64: 2, 62: 4, 33: 2, 26: 3, 32: 3, 83: 4, 113: 3, 126: 3, 112: 3, 85: 4, 129: 3} {212: 1, 286: 1, 260: 4, 261: 3, 274: 3, 343: 2, 283: 4, 31: 2, 32: 3, 33: 3, 163: 4, 228: 3, 357: 3, 166: 3, 231: 3, 298: 3, 363: 4, 46: 3, 377: 2} {260, 261, 274, 283, 286, 31, 32, 33, 163, 166, 298, 46, 339, 212, 343, 228, 357, 231, 363, 377} 64 "To support outgoing DetNet MPLS over UDP/IP encapsulation, an implementation MUST support the provisioning of UDP and IP header information in addition or in place of F-Label(s). Note, when PRF is performed at the MPLS service sub-layer, there will be multiple member flows, and each member flow will require the provisioning of their own UDP and IP header information. The headers for each outgoing packet MUST be formatted on the configuration information and as defined in RFC7510, with one exception. Note that the UDP Source Port value MUST be set to uniquely identify the DetNet flow. The packet MUST then be handed as a DetNet IP packet, per I-D.ietf- detnet-ip. This includes QoS related traffic treatment." Looks good to me , d431d1876f9704f0aa60ecf2d0a1035f8b5833c5 d431d1876f9704f0aa60ecf2d0a1035f8b5833c5 draft-ietf-detnet-mpls-over-udp-ip 75e1b9b6b6c2e723fb5593a62465d328747fe29245449a4233a49cd981a5e16d ['d81065afcde0c1d522ef7389a33fc4bf24820d17239ed99f681791dc6918482b', '75e1b9b6b6c2e723fb5593a62465d328747fe29245449a4233a49cd981a5e16d'] A "to support outgoing detnet mpls over udp/ip encapsulation, an implementation must support the provisioning of udp and ip header information in addition or in place of f-label(s). note, when prf is performed at the mpls service sub-layer, there will be multiple member flows, and each member flow will require the provisioning of their own udp and ip header information. the headers for each outgoing packet must be formatted on the configuration information and as defined in rfc7510, with one exception. note that the udp source port value must be set to uniquely identify the detnet flow. the packet must then be handed as a detnet ip packet, per i-d.ietf- detnet-ip. this includes qos related traffic treatment." {38: 1, 71: 1, 60: 4, 56: 3, 102: 3, 64: 2, 62: 4, 33: 2, 26: 3, 32: 2, 83: 4, 113: 2, 126: 2, 112: 2, 85: 4, 129: 2} {212: 1, 377: 1, 260: 4, 261: 3, 274: 3, 339: 2, 283: 4, 286: 3, 31: 2, 32: 3, 33: 2, 163: 4, 228: 2, 357: 2, 166: 2, 231: 2, 298: 2, 363: 4, 46: 2} {260, 261, 274, 283, 286, 31, 32, 33, 163, 166, 298, 46, 339, 212, 343, 228, 357, 231, 363, 377} 64 "To support outgoing DetNet MPLS over UDP/IP encapsulation, an implementation MUST support the provisioning of UDP and IP header information in addition or in place of F-Label(s). Note, when PRF is performed at the MPLS service sub-layer, there will be multiple member flows, and each member flow will require the provisioning of their own UDP and IP header information. The headers for each outgoing packet MUST be formatted according to the configuration information and as defined in RFC7510, with one exception. Note that the UDP Source Port value MUST be set to uniquely identify the DetNet flow. The packet MUST then be handed as a DetNet IP packet, per I- D.ietf-detnet-ip. This includes QoS related traffic treatment." Looks good to me , d431d1876f9704f0aa60ecf2d0a1035f8b5833c5 d431d1876f9704f0aa60ecf2d0a1035f8b5833c5 draft-ietf-detnet-mpls-over-udp-ip d81065afcde0c1d522ef7389a33fc4bf24820d17239ed99f681791dc6918482b ['d81065afcde0c1d522ef7389a33fc4bf24820d17239ed99f681791dc6918482b', '75e1b9b6b6c2e723fb5593a62465d328747fe29245449a4233a49cd981a5e16d'] B "to support outgoing detnet mpls over udp/ip encapsulation, an implementation must support the provisioning of udp and ip header information in addition or in place of f-label(s). note, when prf is performed at the mpls service sub-layer, there will be multiple member flows, and each member flow will require the provisioning of their own udp and ip header information. the headers for each outgoing packet must be formatted according to the configuration information and as defined in rfc7510, with one exception. note that the udp source port value must be set to uniquely identify the detnet flow. the packet must then be handed as a detnet ip packet, per i- d.ietf-detnet-ip. this includes qos related traffic treatment." {38: 1, 71: 1, 60: 4, 56: 3, 102: 3, 64: 2, 62: 4, 33: 2, 26: 3, 32: 2, 83: 4, 113: 2, 126: 2, 112: 2, 85: 4, 129: 2} {212: 1, 377: 1, 260: 4, 261: 3, 274: 3, 339: 2, 283: 4, 286: 3, 31: 2, 32: 3, 33: 2, 163: 4, 228: 2, 357: 2, 166: 2, 231: 2, 298: 2, 363: 4, 46: 2} {260, 261, 274, 283, 286, 31, 32, 33, 163, 166, 298, 46, 339, 212, 343, 228, 357, 231, 363, 377} 64 IPv4 and IPv6 source address field. Looks good to me , d431d1876f9704f0aa60ecf2d0a1035f8b5833c5 d431d1876f9704f0aa60ecf2d0a1035f8b5833c5 draft-ietf-detnet-mpls-over-udp-ip 9342ca6d50ed2fbe47d699d8ce2e5c82fe69e8aa2ace8cc64d89f65a7d7257cf ['96a5bc850fbc49a5d6ae998f2012f991e0270d10599b96bd7cc8123067914e14', '4f7a168d3aabe87035387dd5ed5d34faa28fab189b0c1b7473456086f1761fc8', '7fce71a1abba19c15aad5abbf2f440dc6cf13c973dc4b1f3fae8a72979dea692', '9342ca6d50ed2fbe47d699d8ce2e5c82fe69e8aa2ace8cc64d89f65a7d7257cf', 'ed47eb0d948aaafe3fe98a275f72750550a541031202bfd96990bcbd8c4de09d', 'bc79ce01a05be22183c6aa6db4fbc2c25eb19cc11ddba3f100f412ecb7d49863'] A ipv4 and ipv6 source address field. {32: 1, 56: 1, 71: 1, 60: 2, 102: 2, 64: 2, 38: 2, 62: 3, 33: 2, 26: 2, 83: 2, 113: 2, 126: 2, 112: 2, 85: 2, 129: 2} {33: 1, 261: 1, 377: 1, 260: 2, 274: 2, 339: 3, 212: 2, 343: 2, 283: 3, 286: 4, 31: 2, 32: 2, 163: 2, 228: 2, 357: 2, 166: 2, 298: 2, 363: 2, 46: 2} {260, 261, 274, 283, 286, 31, 32, 33, 163, 166, 298, 46, 339, 212, 343, 228, 357, 231, 363, 377} 64 IPv4 and IPv6 destination address field. Looks good to me , d431d1876f9704f0aa60ecf2d0a1035f8b5833c5 d431d1876f9704f0aa60ecf2d0a1035f8b5833c5 draft-ietf-detnet-mpls-over-udp-ip bc79ce01a05be22183c6aa6db4fbc2c25eb19cc11ddba3f100f412ecb7d49863 ['96a5bc850fbc49a5d6ae998f2012f991e0270d10599b96bd7cc8123067914e14', '4f7a168d3aabe87035387dd5ed5d34faa28fab189b0c1b7473456086f1761fc8', '7fce71a1abba19c15aad5abbf2f440dc6cf13c973dc4b1f3fae8a72979dea692', '9342ca6d50ed2fbe47d699d8ce2e5c82fe69e8aa2ace8cc64d89f65a7d7257cf', 'ed47eb0d948aaafe3fe98a275f72750550a541031202bfd96990bcbd8c4de09d', 'bc79ce01a05be22183c6aa6db4fbc2c25eb19cc11ddba3f100f412ecb7d49863'] A ipv4 and ipv6 destination address field. {32: 1, 56: 1, 71: 1, 60: 2, 102: 2, 64: 2, 38: 2, 62: 3, 33: 2, 26: 2, 83: 2, 113: 2, 126: 2, 112: 2, 85: 2, 129: 2} {33: 1, 261: 1, 377: 1, 260: 2, 274: 2, 339: 3, 212: 2, 343: 2, 283: 3, 286: 4, 31: 2, 32: 2, 163: 2, 228: 2, 357: 2, 166: 2, 298: 2, 363: 2, 46: 2} {260, 261, 274, 283, 286, 31, 32, 33, 163, 166, 298, 46, 339, 212, 343, 228, 357, 231, 363, 377} 64 IPv4 Type of Service and IPv6 Traffic Class Fields. Looks good to me , d431d1876f9704f0aa60ecf2d0a1035f8b5833c5 d431d1876f9704f0aa60ecf2d0a1035f8b5833c5 draft-ietf-detnet-mpls-over-udp-ip 4f7a168d3aabe87035387dd5ed5d34faa28fab189b0c1b7473456086f1761fc8 ['96a5bc850fbc49a5d6ae998f2012f991e0270d10599b96bd7cc8123067914e14', '4f7a168d3aabe87035387dd5ed5d34faa28fab189b0c1b7473456086f1761fc8', '7fce71a1abba19c15aad5abbf2f440dc6cf13c973dc4b1f3fae8a72979dea692', '9342ca6d50ed2fbe47d699d8ce2e5c82fe69e8aa2ace8cc64d89f65a7d7257cf', 'ed47eb0d948aaafe3fe98a275f72750550a541031202bfd96990bcbd8c4de09d', 'bc79ce01a05be22183c6aa6db4fbc2c25eb19cc11ddba3f100f412ecb7d49863'] A ipv4 type of service and ipv6 traffic class fields. {32: 1, 56: 1, 71: 1, 60: 2, 102: 2, 64: 2, 38: 2, 62: 3, 33: 2, 26: 2, 83: 2, 113: 2, 126: 2, 112: 2, 85: 2, 129: 2} {33: 1, 261: 1, 377: 1, 260: 2, 274: 2, 339: 3, 212: 2, 343: 2, 283: 3, 286: 4, 31: 2, 32: 2, 163: 2, 228: 2, 357: 2, 166: 2, 298: 2, 363: 2, 46: 2} {260, 261, 274, 283, 286, 31, 32, 33, 163, 166, 298, 46, 339, 212, 343, 228, 357, 231, 363, 377} 64 IPv4 or IPv6 source address field. Looks good to me , d431d1876f9704f0aa60ecf2d0a1035f8b5833c5 d431d1876f9704f0aa60ecf2d0a1035f8b5833c5 draft-ietf-detnet-mpls-over-udp-ip 96a5bc850fbc49a5d6ae998f2012f991e0270d10599b96bd7cc8123067914e14 ['96a5bc850fbc49a5d6ae998f2012f991e0270d10599b96bd7cc8123067914e14', '4f7a168d3aabe87035387dd5ed5d34faa28fab189b0c1b7473456086f1761fc8', '7fce71a1abba19c15aad5abbf2f440dc6cf13c973dc4b1f3fae8a72979dea692', '9342ca6d50ed2fbe47d699d8ce2e5c82fe69e8aa2ace8cc64d89f65a7d7257cf', 'ed47eb0d948aaafe3fe98a275f72750550a541031202bfd96990bcbd8c4de09d', 'bc79ce01a05be22183c6aa6db4fbc2c25eb19cc11ddba3f100f412ecb7d49863'] B ipv4 or ipv6 source address field. {32: 1, 56: 1, 71: 1, 60: 2, 102: 2, 64: 2, 38: 2, 62: 3, 33: 2, 26: 2, 83: 2, 113: 2, 126: 2, 112: 2, 85: 2, 129: 2} {33: 1, 261: 1, 377: 1, 260: 2, 274: 2, 339: 3, 212: 2, 343: 2, 283: 3, 286: 4, 31: 2, 32: 2, 163: 2, 228: 2, 357: 2, 166: 2, 298: 2, 363: 2, 46: 2} {260, 261, 274, 283, 286, 31, 32, 33, 163, 166, 298, 46, 339, 212, 343, 228, 357, 231, 363, 377} 64 IPv4 or IPv6 destination address field. Looks good to me , d431d1876f9704f0aa60ecf2d0a1035f8b5833c5 d431d1876f9704f0aa60ecf2d0a1035f8b5833c5 draft-ietf-detnet-mpls-over-udp-ip ed47eb0d948aaafe3fe98a275f72750550a541031202bfd96990bcbd8c4de09d ['96a5bc850fbc49a5d6ae998f2012f991e0270d10599b96bd7cc8123067914e14', '4f7a168d3aabe87035387dd5ed5d34faa28fab189b0c1b7473456086f1761fc8', '7fce71a1abba19c15aad5abbf2f440dc6cf13c973dc4b1f3fae8a72979dea692', '9342ca6d50ed2fbe47d699d8ce2e5c82fe69e8aa2ace8cc64d89f65a7d7257cf', 'ed47eb0d948aaafe3fe98a275f72750550a541031202bfd96990bcbd8c4de09d', 'bc79ce01a05be22183c6aa6db4fbc2c25eb19cc11ddba3f100f412ecb7d49863'] B ipv4 or ipv6 destination address field. {32: 1, 56: 1, 71: 1, 60: 2, 102: 2, 64: 2, 38: 2, 62: 3, 33: 2, 26: 2, 83: 2, 113: 2, 126: 2, 112: 2, 85: 2, 129: 2} {33: 1, 261: 1, 377: 1, 260: 2, 274: 2, 339: 3, 212: 2, 343: 2, 283: 3, 286: 4, 31: 2, 32: 2, 163: 2, 228: 2, 357: 2, 166: 2, 298: 2, 363: 2, 46: 2} {260, 261, 274, 283, 286, 31, 32, 33, 163, 166, 298, 46, 339, 212, 343, 228, 357, 231, 363, 377} 64 IPv4 Type of Service or IPv6 Traffic Class Fields. Looks good to me , d431d1876f9704f0aa60ecf2d0a1035f8b5833c5 d431d1876f9704f0aa60ecf2d0a1035f8b5833c5 draft-ietf-detnet-mpls-over-udp-ip 7fce71a1abba19c15aad5abbf2f440dc6cf13c973dc4b1f3fae8a72979dea692 ['96a5bc850fbc49a5d6ae998f2012f991e0270d10599b96bd7cc8123067914e14', '4f7a168d3aabe87035387dd5ed5d34faa28fab189b0c1b7473456086f1761fc8', '7fce71a1abba19c15aad5abbf2f440dc6cf13c973dc4b1f3fae8a72979dea692', '9342ca6d50ed2fbe47d699d8ce2e5c82fe69e8aa2ace8cc64d89f65a7d7257cf', 'ed47eb0d948aaafe3fe98a275f72750550a541031202bfd96990bcbd8c4de09d', 'bc79ce01a05be22183c6aa6db4fbc2c25eb19cc11ddba3f100f412ecb7d49863'] B ipv4 type of service or ipv6 traffic class fields. {32: 1, 56: 1, 71: 1, 60: 2, 102: 2, 64: 2, 38: 2, 62: 3, 33: 2, 26: 2, 83: 2, 113: 2, 126: 2, 112: 2, 85: 2, 129: 2} {33: 1, 261: 1, 377: 1, 260: 2, 274: 2, 339: 3, 212: 2, 343: 2, 283: 3, 286: 4, 31: 2, 32: 2, 163: 2, 228: 2, 357: 2, 166: 2, 298: 2, 363: 2, 46: 2} {260, 261, 274, 283, 286, 31, 32, 33, 163, 166, 298, 46, 339, 212, 343, 228, 357, 231, 363, 377} 64 "The security considerations of DetNet in general are discussed in I- D.ietf-detnet-architecture and I-D.ietf-detnet-security. MPLS and IP specific security considerations are described in I-D.ietf-detnet- mpls and I-D.ietf-detnet-ip. This draft does not have additional security considerations." Looks good to me , d431d1876f9704f0aa60ecf2d0a1035f8b5833c5 d431d1876f9704f0aa60ecf2d0a1035f8b5833c5 draft-ietf-detnet-mpls-over-udp-ip 5024c49f483b8d46eb4017736cd7ced5b578f170328bf15ff1060aa0235be4b8 ['5024c49f483b8d46eb4017736cd7ced5b578f170328bf15ff1060aa0235be4b8', '9b484bd2df7d208fcb8a8c33d4a15e1725e2d0ca52dba6e3aff9550429ecba44'] A "the security considerations of detnet in general are discussed in i- d.ietf-detnet-architecture and i-d.ietf-detnet-security. mpls and ip specific security considerations are described in i-d.ietf-detnet- mpls and i-d.ietf-detnet-ip. this draft does not have additional security considerations." {30: 1, 36: 1, 6: 4, 79: 4, 90: 2, 51: 2, 130: 4, 62: 6, 85: 7, 68: 6, 35: 5, 110: 2, 91: 3, 114: 2, 97: 4, 31: 3, 13: 2, 67: 2, 38: 4, 26: 3, 124: 5, 98: 4, 54: 4, 127: 5, 8: 4, 96: 4, 61: 5, 55: 5, 27: 4, 15: 2, 52: 3, 129: 5, 115: 2, 84: 2, 76: 8, 87: 2, 131: 7, 102: 2, 113: 5, 64: 4, 99: 4, 24: 2, 53: 3, 72: 4} {129: 1, 353: 1, 1: 11, 4: 4, 9: 7, 10: 5, 15: 4, 24: 4, 25: 6, 26: 7, 27: 2, 39: 7, 43: 5, 49: 4, 50: 3, 58: 5, 59: 4, 64: 4, 69: 6, 81: 7, 82: 5, 86: 3, 96: 4, 97: 3, 100: 8, 108: 5, 109: 6, 110: 6, 111: 4, 114: 5, 115: 6, 116: 4, 118: 8, 119: 7, 120: 5, 121: 6, 122: 5, 123: 4, 124: 6, 130: 5, 132: 6, 136: 4, 145: 6, 147: 4, 151: 3, 152: 3, 154: 5, 156: 3, 161: 5, 162: 5, 165: 5, 168: 6, 169: 2, 172: 2, 180: 2, 184: 7, 187: 7, 188: 6, 191: 5, 194: 6, 202: 7, 203: 8, 206: 4, 207: 5, 215: 4, 217: 5, 218: 10, 220: 4, 221: 4, 222: 7, 224: 5, 227: 6, 229: 2, 234: 7, 235: 4, 241: 4, 242: 4, 243: 6, 244: 3, 245: 6, 248: 3, 250: 5, 258: 13, 262: 6, 263: 7, 264: 5, 267: 6, 270: 4, 272: 2, 273: 7, 287: 5, 289: 2, 291: 5, 299: 6, 300: 4, 304: 4, 309: 5, 314: 4, 315: 2, 320: 6, 323: 6, 327: 6, 328: 5, 329: 4, 330: 12, 334: 4, 335: 4, 341: 6, 342: 7, 347: 6, 348: 6, 350: 9, 351: 4, 352: 2, 354: 2, 358: 6, 365: 2, 366: 4, 369: 3, 371: 8, 372: 5, 376: 4, 384: 5, 385: 4, 386: 5, 387: 4, 392: 5, 393: 6, 396: 7, 397: 9, 398: 8, 402: 2} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 64 "The security considerations of DetNet in general are discussed in RFC8655 and I-D.ietf-detnet-security. MPLS and IP specific security considerations are described in I-D.ietf-detnet-mpls and I-D.ietf- detnet-ip. This draft does not have additional security considerations." Looks good to me , d431d1876f9704f0aa60ecf2d0a1035f8b5833c5 d431d1876f9704f0aa60ecf2d0a1035f8b5833c5 draft-ietf-detnet-mpls-over-udp-ip 9b484bd2df7d208fcb8a8c33d4a15e1725e2d0ca52dba6e3aff9550429ecba44 ['5024c49f483b8d46eb4017736cd7ced5b578f170328bf15ff1060aa0235be4b8', '9b484bd2df7d208fcb8a8c33d4a15e1725e2d0ca52dba6e3aff9550429ecba44'] B "the security considerations of detnet in general are discussed in rfc8655 and i-d.ietf-detnet-security. mpls and ip specific security considerations are described in i-d.ietf-detnet-mpls and i-d.ietf- detnet-ip. this draft does not have additional security considerations." {30: 1, 36: 1, 6: 4, 79: 4, 90: 2, 51: 2, 130: 4, 62: 6, 85: 7, 68: 6, 35: 5, 110: 2, 91: 3, 114: 2, 97: 4, 31: 3, 13: 2, 67: 2, 38: 4, 26: 3, 124: 5, 98: 4, 54: 4, 127: 5, 8: 4, 96: 4, 61: 5, 55: 5, 27: 4, 15: 2, 52: 3, 129: 5, 115: 2, 84: 2, 76: 8, 87: 2, 131: 7, 102: 2, 113: 5, 64: 4, 99: 4, 24: 2, 53: 3, 72: 4} {129: 1, 353: 1, 1: 11, 4: 4, 9: 7, 10: 5, 15: 4, 24: 4, 25: 6, 26: 7, 27: 2, 39: 7, 43: 5, 49: 4, 50: 3, 58: 5, 59: 4, 64: 4, 69: 6, 81: 7, 82: 5, 86: 3, 96: 4, 97: 3, 100: 8, 108: 5, 109: 6, 110: 6, 111: 4, 114: 5, 115: 6, 116: 4, 118: 8, 119: 7, 120: 5, 121: 6, 122: 5, 123: 4, 124: 6, 130: 5, 132: 6, 136: 4, 145: 6, 147: 4, 151: 3, 152: 3, 154: 5, 156: 3, 161: 5, 162: 5, 165: 5, 168: 6, 169: 2, 172: 2, 180: 2, 184: 7, 187: 7, 188: 6, 191: 5, 194: 6, 202: 7, 203: 8, 206: 4, 207: 5, 215: 4, 217: 5, 218: 10, 220: 4, 221: 4, 222: 7, 224: 5, 227: 6, 229: 2, 234: 7, 235: 4, 241: 4, 242: 4, 243: 6, 244: 3, 245: 6, 248: 3, 250: 5, 258: 13, 262: 6, 263: 7, 264: 5, 267: 6, 270: 4, 272: 2, 273: 7, 287: 5, 289: 2, 291: 5, 299: 6, 300: 4, 304: 4, 309: 5, 314: 4, 315: 2, 320: 6, 323: 6, 327: 6, 328: 5, 329: 4, 330: 12, 334: 4, 335: 4, 341: 6, 342: 7, 347: 6, 348: 6, 350: 9, 351: 4, 352: 2, 354: 2, 358: 6, 365: 2, 366: 4, 369: 3, 371: 8, 372: 5, 376: 4, 384: 5, 385: 4, 386: 5, 387: 4, 392: 5, 393: 6, 396: 7, 397: 9, 398: 8, 402: 2} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 63 "fig_ip_detnet illustrated DetNet enabled End Systems (hosts), connected to DetNet (DN) enabled IP networks, operating over a DetNet aware MPLS network. iUsing this figure we can have a case where the Relay nodes act as T-PEs and sit at the boundary of the MPLS domain since the non-MPLS domain is DetNet aware. This case is very similar to the DetNet MPLS Network figure 2 in I-D.ietf-detnet-mpls. However in I-D.ietf-detnet-mpls figure 2 the T-PEs are located at the end syetem and MPLS spans the whole DetNet service. The primary difference in this document is that the Relay nodes are at the edges of the MPLS domain and therefore function as T-PEs, and that iMPLS service sub-layer functions are not provided over the DetNet IP network. The transit node functions show above are identical to those described in I-D.ietf-detnet-mpls." Changes are good . b727a81806c5531c2bff739e01694cd92ba4439c b727a81806c5531c2bff739e01694cd92ba4439c draft-ietf-detnet-ip-over-mpls d0c99b712d781b6359b2fe1767b3baaf9b56308f6a7a2547c29e2651a7678193 ['d0c99b712d781b6359b2fe1767b3baaf9b56308f6a7a2547c29e2651a7678193', '70aeb876c1786421558a9c462ef7963ab6c9685bcd144fcd0d62619be564bd9d'] A "fig_ip_detnet illustrated detnet enabled end systems (hosts), connected to detnet (dn) enabled ip networks, operating over a detnet aware mpls network. iusing this figure we can have a case where the relay nodes act as t-pes and sit at the boundary of the mpls domain since the non-mpls domain is detnet aware. this case is very similar to the detnet mpls network figure 2 in i-d.ietf-detnet-mpls. however in i-d.ietf-detnet-mpls figure 2 the t-pes are located at the end syetem and mpls spans the whole detnet service. the primary difference in this document is that the relay nodes are at the edges of the mpls domain and therefore function as t-pes, and that impls service sub-layer functions are not provided over the detnet ip network. the transit node functions show above are identical to those described in i-d.ietf-detnet-mpls." {110: 1, 36: 1, 30: 2} {186: 1, 331: 1, 3: 2} {186, 331, 3, 332} 63 "fig_ip_detnet illustrated DetNet enabled End Systems (hosts), connected to DetNet (DN) enabled IP networks, operating over a DetNet aware MPLS network. Using this figure we can have a case where the Relay nodes act as T-PEs and sit at the boundary of the MPLS domain since the non-MPLS domain is DetNet aware. This case is very similar to the DetNet MPLS Network figure 2 in I-D.ietf-detnet-mpls. However in I-D.ietf-detnet-mpls figure 2 the T-PEs are located at the end system and MPLS spans the whole DetNet service. The primary difference in this document is that the Relay nodes are at the edges of the MPLS domain and therefore function as T-PEs, and that MPLS service sub-layer functions are not provided over the DetNet IP network. The transit node functions show above are identical to those described in I-D.ietf-detnet-mpls." Changes are good . b727a81806c5531c2bff739e01694cd92ba4439c b727a81806c5531c2bff739e01694cd92ba4439c draft-ietf-detnet-ip-over-mpls 70aeb876c1786421558a9c462ef7963ab6c9685bcd144fcd0d62619be564bd9d ['d0c99b712d781b6359b2fe1767b3baaf9b56308f6a7a2547c29e2651a7678193', '70aeb876c1786421558a9c462ef7963ab6c9685bcd144fcd0d62619be564bd9d'] B "fig_ip_detnet illustrated detnet enabled end systems (hosts), connected to detnet (dn) enabled ip networks, operating over a detnet aware mpls network. using this figure we can have a case where the relay nodes act as t-pes and sit at the boundary of the mpls domain since the non-mpls domain is detnet aware. this case is very similar to the detnet mpls network figure 2 in i-d.ietf-detnet-mpls. however in i-d.ietf-detnet-mpls figure 2 the t-pes are located at the end system and mpls spans the whole detnet service. the primary difference in this document is that the relay nodes are at the edges of the mpls domain and therefore function as t-pes, and that mpls service sub-layer functions are not provided over the detnet ip network. the transit node functions show above are identical to those described in i-d.ietf-detnet-mpls." {110: 1, 36: 1, 30: 2} {186: 1, 331: 1, 3: 2} {186, 331, 3, 332} 63 "fig_ip_detnet illustrates DetNet enabled End Systems (hosts), connected to DetNet (DN) enabled MPLS network. A similar situation occurs when end systems are are not DetNet aware. In this case, edge nodes sit at the boundary of the MPLS domain since it is also a DetNet domain boundary. The edge nodes provide DetNet service proxies for the end applications by initiating and terminating DetNet service for the application's IP flows. While the node types differ, there is essentially no difference in data plane processing between relay and edges. There are likely to be differences in controller plane operation, particularly when distributed control plane protocols are used." Changes are good . b727a81806c5531c2bff739e01694cd92ba4439c b727a81806c5531c2bff739e01694cd92ba4439c draft-ietf-detnet-ip-over-mpls 7f7392ff2f0b6588a9167305ba0eccfa64509738c00edee63fa3900150d2f7f6 ['b764111efa0366820d9668f7bd6687c2ad852deb5723ad3d38a609ae03ad64ad', 'b9d3772ed35ae1221961bcd5c98363c10a419ac6a8b8696322db56f713e00158', '6f67ab9b885f9d0f53402b8e8e7b67db76eeba21e8d239a625a36e4b79d9f382', '7f7392ff2f0b6588a9167305ba0eccfa64509738c00edee63fa3900150d2f7f6'] A "fig_ip_detnet illustrates detnet enabled end systems (hosts), connected to detnet (dn) enabled mpls network. a similar situation occurs when end systems are are not detnet aware. in this case, edge nodes sit at the boundary of the mpls domain since it is also a detnet domain boundary. the edge nodes provide detnet service proxies for the end applications by initiating and terminating detnet service for the application's ip flows. while the node types differ, there is essentially no difference in data plane processing between relay and edges. there are likely to be differences in controller plane operation, particularly when distributed control plane protocols are used." {110: 1, 36: 1} {51: 1, 170: 1, 293: 1} {170, 290, 51, 293} 63 "It is still possible to provided DetNet service protection for non- DetNet aware end systems. case is basically the same as fig_ip_pw_detnet, with the exception that CE1 and CE2 are non-DetNet aware end systems and R1 and R3 become edge nodes." Changes are good . b727a81806c5531c2bff739e01694cd92ba4439c b727a81806c5531c2bff739e01694cd92ba4439c draft-ietf-detnet-ip-over-mpls b9d3772ed35ae1221961bcd5c98363c10a419ac6a8b8696322db56f713e00158 ['b764111efa0366820d9668f7bd6687c2ad852deb5723ad3d38a609ae03ad64ad', 'b9d3772ed35ae1221961bcd5c98363c10a419ac6a8b8696322db56f713e00158', '6f67ab9b885f9d0f53402b8e8e7b67db76eeba21e8d239a625a36e4b79d9f382', '7f7392ff2f0b6588a9167305ba0eccfa64509738c00edee63fa3900150d2f7f6'] A "it is still possible to provided detnet service protection for non- detnet aware end systems. case is basically the same as fig_ip_pw_detnet, with the exception that ce1 and ce2 are non-detnet aware end systems and r1 and r3 become edge nodes." {110: 1, 36: 1} {51: 1, 170: 1, 293: 1} {170, 290, 51, 293} 63 "fig_ip_detnet illustrates DetNet enabled End Systems, connected to DetNet (DN) enabled MPLS network. A similar situation occurs when end systems are are not DetNet aware. In this case, edge nodes sit at the boundary of the MPLS domain since it is also a DetNet domain boundary. The edge nodes provide DetNet service proxies for the end applications by initiating and terminating DetNet service for the application's IP flows. While the node types differ, there is essentially no difference in data plane processing between relay and edges. There are likely to be differences in controller plane operation, particularly when distributed control plane protocols are used." Changes are good . b727a81806c5531c2bff739e01694cd92ba4439c b727a81806c5531c2bff739e01694cd92ba4439c draft-ietf-detnet-ip-over-mpls b764111efa0366820d9668f7bd6687c2ad852deb5723ad3d38a609ae03ad64ad ['b764111efa0366820d9668f7bd6687c2ad852deb5723ad3d38a609ae03ad64ad', 'b9d3772ed35ae1221961bcd5c98363c10a419ac6a8b8696322db56f713e00158', '6f67ab9b885f9d0f53402b8e8e7b67db76eeba21e8d239a625a36e4b79d9f382', '7f7392ff2f0b6588a9167305ba0eccfa64509738c00edee63fa3900150d2f7f6'] B "fig_ip_detnet illustrates detnet enabled end systems, connected to detnet (dn) enabled mpls network. a similar situation occurs when end systems are are not detnet aware. in this case, edge nodes sit at the boundary of the mpls domain since it is also a detnet domain boundary. the edge nodes provide detnet service proxies for the end applications by initiating and terminating detnet service for the application's ip flows. while the node types differ, there is essentially no difference in data plane processing between relay and edges. there are likely to be differences in controller plane operation, particularly when distributed control plane protocols are used." {110: 1, 36: 1} {51: 1, 170: 1, 293: 1} {170, 290, 51, 293} 63 "It is still possible to provided DetNet service protection for non- DetNet aware end systems. This case is basically the same as fig_ip_pw_detnet, with the exception that CE1 and CE2 are non-DetNet aware end systems and R1 and R3 become edge nodes." Changes are good . b727a81806c5531c2bff739e01694cd92ba4439c b727a81806c5531c2bff739e01694cd92ba4439c draft-ietf-detnet-ip-over-mpls 6f67ab9b885f9d0f53402b8e8e7b67db76eeba21e8d239a625a36e4b79d9f382 ['b764111efa0366820d9668f7bd6687c2ad852deb5723ad3d38a609ae03ad64ad', 'b9d3772ed35ae1221961bcd5c98363c10a419ac6a8b8696322db56f713e00158', '6f67ab9b885f9d0f53402b8e8e7b67db76eeba21e8d239a625a36e4b79d9f382', '7f7392ff2f0b6588a9167305ba0eccfa64509738c00edee63fa3900150d2f7f6'] B "it is still possible to provided detnet service protection for non- detnet aware end systems. this case is basically the same as fig_ip_pw_detnet, with the exception that ce1 and ce2 are non-detnet aware end systems and r1 and r3 become edge nodes." {110: 1, 36: 1} {51: 1, 170: 1, 293: 1} {170, 290, 51, 293} 63 "In the figure, ""App-Flow"" indicates the payload carried by the DetNet IP data plane. ""IP"" and ""NProto"" indicate the fields described in Section 7.1.1. IP Header Information and Section 7.1.2. Other Protocol Header Information in I-D.ietf-detnet-ip, respectively. ""MPLS App-Flow"" indicates that an individual DetNet IP flow is the payload from the perspective of the DetNet MPLS data plane defined in I-D.ietf-detnet-mpls." Changes are good . b727a81806c5531c2bff739e01694cd92ba4439c b727a81806c5531c2bff739e01694cd92ba4439c draft-ietf-detnet-ip-over-mpls f5ddd9ef16285ed7fd98d3046dec38979acca9d003e847aa25e5018b536be9f0 ['f5ddd9ef16285ed7fd98d3046dec38979acca9d003e847aa25e5018b536be9f0', '8efd63665bdd242791ce0e0fc3df6ebb3cb8285401a53e921d623ee329e88120', '887a463221610bcc4362ce703db1d0235972be4b97884fcd7390c9196f8a1e92', 'b2f2d54d9f9d280603f69878b55eaa9a8db0012cc54e0ce86579712b28f64690', 'd2110b86acf572e0194460f6eafffa6032a44789a0222d08159595dfdfd35657', '117b368427deaeb78c79a6100ddbe167ef4f180ae58f9f1417f6479c7a9ba601', '3436c05b6ab78e77474da86a23f798b9280952989b51e6a7453a7a1afa172bb4', '7c3b073d48c204f2678d701bbeecdcfa30cff64f679911a1bd9d570735ddc2a8'] A "in the figure, ""app-flow"" indicates the payload carried by the detnet ip data plane. ""ip"" and ""nproto"" indicate the fields described in section 7.1.1. ip header information and section 7.1.2. other protocol header information in i-d.ietf-detnet-ip, respectively. ""mpls app-flow"" indicates that an individual detnet ip flow is the payload from the perspective of the detnet mpls data plane defined in i-d.ietf-detnet-mpls." {56: 1, 91: 1, 36: 1, 30: 1, 110: 2} {75: 1, 134: 1, 333: 1, 356: 1, 346: 2} {356, 134, 75, 395, 333, 346} 63 "Per I-D.ietf-detnet-mpls, the DetNet MPLS data plane uses a single S-Label to support a single app flow. Section 7.1. DetNet IP Flow Identification Procedures in I-D.ietf-detnet-ip states that a single DetNet flow is identified based on IP, and next level protocol, header information. Section 7.4. Aggregation Considerations in I- D.ietf-detnet-ip defines that aggregation is supported through the use of prefixes, wildcards, lists, and port ranges. Collectively, this results in the fairly straight forward procedures defined in this section." Changes are good . b727a81806c5531c2bff739e01694cd92ba4439c b727a81806c5531c2bff739e01694cd92ba4439c draft-ietf-detnet-ip-over-mpls 3436c05b6ab78e77474da86a23f798b9280952989b51e6a7453a7a1afa172bb4 ['f5ddd9ef16285ed7fd98d3046dec38979acca9d003e847aa25e5018b536be9f0', '8efd63665bdd242791ce0e0fc3df6ebb3cb8285401a53e921d623ee329e88120', '887a463221610bcc4362ce703db1d0235972be4b97884fcd7390c9196f8a1e92', 'b2f2d54d9f9d280603f69878b55eaa9a8db0012cc54e0ce86579712b28f64690', 'd2110b86acf572e0194460f6eafffa6032a44789a0222d08159595dfdfd35657', '117b368427deaeb78c79a6100ddbe167ef4f180ae58f9f1417f6479c7a9ba601', '3436c05b6ab78e77474da86a23f798b9280952989b51e6a7453a7a1afa172bb4', '7c3b073d48c204f2678d701bbeecdcfa30cff64f679911a1bd9d570735ddc2a8'] A "per i-d.ietf-detnet-mpls, the detnet mpls data plane uses a single s-label to support a single app flow. section 7.1. detnet ip flow identification procedures in i-d.ietf-detnet-ip states that a single detnet flow is identified based on ip, and next level protocol, header information. section 7.4. aggregation considerations in i- d.ietf-detnet-ip defines that aggregation is supported through the use of prefixes, wildcards, lists, and port ranges. collectively, this results in the fairly straight forward procedures defined in this section." {56: 1, 91: 1, 36: 1, 30: 1, 110: 2} {75: 1, 134: 1, 333: 1, 356: 1, 346: 2} {356, 134, 75, 395, 333, 346} 63 "As shown in fig_ip_pw_detnet, DetNet relay nodes are responsible for the mapping of a DetNet flow, at the service sub-layer, from the IP to MPLS DetNet data planes and back again. Their related DetNet IP over DetNet MPLS data plane operation is comprised of two sets of procedures: the mapping of flow identifiers; and ensuring proper traffic treatment." Changes are good . b727a81806c5531c2bff739e01694cd92ba4439c b727a81806c5531c2bff739e01694cd92ba4439c draft-ietf-detnet-ip-over-mpls 117b368427deaeb78c79a6100ddbe167ef4f180ae58f9f1417f6479c7a9ba601 ['f5ddd9ef16285ed7fd98d3046dec38979acca9d003e847aa25e5018b536be9f0', '8efd63665bdd242791ce0e0fc3df6ebb3cb8285401a53e921d623ee329e88120', '887a463221610bcc4362ce703db1d0235972be4b97884fcd7390c9196f8a1e92', 'b2f2d54d9f9d280603f69878b55eaa9a8db0012cc54e0ce86579712b28f64690', 'd2110b86acf572e0194460f6eafffa6032a44789a0222d08159595dfdfd35657', '117b368427deaeb78c79a6100ddbe167ef4f180ae58f9f1417f6479c7a9ba601', '3436c05b6ab78e77474da86a23f798b9280952989b51e6a7453a7a1afa172bb4', '7c3b073d48c204f2678d701bbeecdcfa30cff64f679911a1bd9d570735ddc2a8'] A "as shown in fig_ip_pw_detnet, detnet relay nodes are responsible for the mapping of a detnet flow, at the service sub-layer, from the ip to mpls detnet data planes and back again. their related detnet ip over detnet mpls data plane operation is comprised of two sets of procedures: the mapping of flow identifiers; and ensuring proper traffic treatment." {56: 1, 91: 1, 36: 1, 30: 1, 110: 2} {75: 1, 134: 1, 333: 1, 356: 1, 346: 2} {356, 134, 75, 395, 333, 346} 63 "Mapping of IP to the MPLS Detnet is similar for IP Detnet flows and IP flows. The six-tuple of IP is mapped to the S-Label in both cases. The various fields may be mapped or ignored when going from IP to MPLS." Changes are good . b727a81806c5531c2bff739e01694cd92ba4439c b727a81806c5531c2bff739e01694cd92ba4439c draft-ietf-detnet-ip-over-mpls d2110b86acf572e0194460f6eafffa6032a44789a0222d08159595dfdfd35657 ['f5ddd9ef16285ed7fd98d3046dec38979acca9d003e847aa25e5018b536be9f0', '8efd63665bdd242791ce0e0fc3df6ebb3cb8285401a53e921d623ee329e88120', '887a463221610bcc4362ce703db1d0235972be4b97884fcd7390c9196f8a1e92', 'b2f2d54d9f9d280603f69878b55eaa9a8db0012cc54e0ce86579712b28f64690', 'd2110b86acf572e0194460f6eafffa6032a44789a0222d08159595dfdfd35657', '117b368427deaeb78c79a6100ddbe167ef4f180ae58f9f1417f6479c7a9ba601', '3436c05b6ab78e77474da86a23f798b9280952989b51e6a7453a7a1afa172bb4', '7c3b073d48c204f2678d701bbeecdcfa30cff64f679911a1bd9d570735ddc2a8'] A "mapping of ip to the mpls detnet is similar for ip detnet flows and ip flows. the six-tuple of ip is mapped to the s-label in both cases. the various fields may be mapped or ignored when going from ip to mpls." {56: 1, 91: 1, 36: 1, 30: 1, 110: 2} {75: 1, 134: 1, 333: 1, 356: 1, 346: 2} {356, 134, 75, 395, 333, 346} 63 "In fig_dn_ip_mpls_sn_ex ""App-Flow"" indicates the payload carried by the DetNet IP data plane. ""IP"" and ""NProto"" indicate the fields described in Section 5.1.1. IP Header Information and Section 5.1.2. Other Protocol Header Information in I-D.ietf-detnet-ip, respectively. ""App-Flow for MPLS"" indicates that an individual DetNet IP flow is the payload from the perspective of the DetNet MPLS data plane defined in I-D.ietf-detnet-mpls." Changes are good . b727a81806c5531c2bff739e01694cd92ba4439c b727a81806c5531c2bff739e01694cd92ba4439c draft-ietf-detnet-ip-over-mpls 8efd63665bdd242791ce0e0fc3df6ebb3cb8285401a53e921d623ee329e88120 ['f5ddd9ef16285ed7fd98d3046dec38979acca9d003e847aa25e5018b536be9f0', '8efd63665bdd242791ce0e0fc3df6ebb3cb8285401a53e921d623ee329e88120', '887a463221610bcc4362ce703db1d0235972be4b97884fcd7390c9196f8a1e92', 'b2f2d54d9f9d280603f69878b55eaa9a8db0012cc54e0ce86579712b28f64690', 'd2110b86acf572e0194460f6eafffa6032a44789a0222d08159595dfdfd35657', '117b368427deaeb78c79a6100ddbe167ef4f180ae58f9f1417f6479c7a9ba601', '3436c05b6ab78e77474da86a23f798b9280952989b51e6a7453a7a1afa172bb4', '7c3b073d48c204f2678d701bbeecdcfa30cff64f679911a1bd9d570735ddc2a8'] B "in fig_dn_ip_mpls_sn_ex ""app-flow"" indicates the payload carried by the detnet ip data plane. ""ip"" and ""nproto"" indicate the fields described in section 5.1.1. ip header information and section 5.1.2. other protocol header information in i-d.ietf-detnet-ip, respectively. ""app-flow for mpls"" indicates that an individual detnet ip flow is the payload from the perspective of the detnet mpls data plane defined in i-d.ietf-detnet-mpls." {56: 1, 91: 1, 36: 1, 30: 1, 110: 2} {75: 1, 134: 1, 333: 1, 356: 1, 346: 2} {356, 134, 75, 395, 333, 346} 63 "Per I-D.ietf-detnet-mpls, the DetNet MPLS data plane uses a single S-Label to support a single app flow. Section 5.1. DetNet IP Flow Identification Procedures in I-D.ietf-detnet-ip states that a single DetNet flow is identified based on IP, and next level protocol, header information. Section 4.4. Aggregation Considerations in I- D.ietf-detnet-ip defines the ways in which aggregation is supported through the use of prefixes, wildcards, lists, and port ranges. Collectively, this results in the fairly straightforward procedures defined in this section." Changes are good . b727a81806c5531c2bff739e01694cd92ba4439c b727a81806c5531c2bff739e01694cd92ba4439c draft-ietf-detnet-ip-over-mpls 7c3b073d48c204f2678d701bbeecdcfa30cff64f679911a1bd9d570735ddc2a8 ['f5ddd9ef16285ed7fd98d3046dec38979acca9d003e847aa25e5018b536be9f0', '8efd63665bdd242791ce0e0fc3df6ebb3cb8285401a53e921d623ee329e88120', '887a463221610bcc4362ce703db1d0235972be4b97884fcd7390c9196f8a1e92', 'b2f2d54d9f9d280603f69878b55eaa9a8db0012cc54e0ce86579712b28f64690', 'd2110b86acf572e0194460f6eafffa6032a44789a0222d08159595dfdfd35657', '117b368427deaeb78c79a6100ddbe167ef4f180ae58f9f1417f6479c7a9ba601', '3436c05b6ab78e77474da86a23f798b9280952989b51e6a7453a7a1afa172bb4', '7c3b073d48c204f2678d701bbeecdcfa30cff64f679911a1bd9d570735ddc2a8'] B "per i-d.ietf-detnet-mpls, the detnet mpls data plane uses a single s-label to support a single app flow. section 5.1. detnet ip flow identification procedures in i-d.ietf-detnet-ip states that a single detnet flow is identified based on ip, and next level protocol, header information. section 4.4. aggregation considerations in i- d.ietf-detnet-ip defines the ways in which aggregation is supported through the use of prefixes, wildcards, lists, and port ranges. collectively, this results in the fairly straightforward procedures defined in this section." {56: 1, 91: 1, 36: 1, 30: 1, 110: 2} {75: 1, 134: 1, 333: 1, 356: 1, 346: 2} {356, 134, 75, 395, 333, 346} 63 "As shown in fig_ip_pw_detnet, DetNet relay nodes are responsible for the mapping of a DetNet flow, at the service sub-layer, from the IP to MPLS DetNet data planes and back again. Their related DetNet IP over DetNet MPLS data plane operation is comprised of two sets of procedures: the mapping of flow identifiers, and ensuring proper traffic treatment." Changes are good . b727a81806c5531c2bff739e01694cd92ba4439c b727a81806c5531c2bff739e01694cd92ba4439c draft-ietf-detnet-ip-over-mpls 887a463221610bcc4362ce703db1d0235972be4b97884fcd7390c9196f8a1e92 ['f5ddd9ef16285ed7fd98d3046dec38979acca9d003e847aa25e5018b536be9f0', '8efd63665bdd242791ce0e0fc3df6ebb3cb8285401a53e921d623ee329e88120', '887a463221610bcc4362ce703db1d0235972be4b97884fcd7390c9196f8a1e92', 'b2f2d54d9f9d280603f69878b55eaa9a8db0012cc54e0ce86579712b28f64690', 'd2110b86acf572e0194460f6eafffa6032a44789a0222d08159595dfdfd35657', '117b368427deaeb78c79a6100ddbe167ef4f180ae58f9f1417f6479c7a9ba601', '3436c05b6ab78e77474da86a23f798b9280952989b51e6a7453a7a1afa172bb4', '7c3b073d48c204f2678d701bbeecdcfa30cff64f679911a1bd9d570735ddc2a8'] B "as shown in fig_ip_pw_detnet, detnet relay nodes are responsible for the mapping of a detnet flow, at the service sub-layer, from the ip to mpls detnet data planes and back again. their related detnet ip over detnet mpls data plane operation is comprised of two sets of procedures: the mapping of flow identifiers, and ensuring proper traffic treatment." {56: 1, 91: 1, 36: 1, 30: 1, 110: 2} {75: 1, 134: 1, 333: 1, 356: 1, 346: 2} {356, 134, 75, 395, 333, 346} 63 "Mapping of IP to DetNet MPLS is similar for DetNet IP flows and IP flows. The six-tuple of IP is mapped to the S-Label in both cases. The various fields may be mapped or ignored when going from IP to MPLS." Changes are good . b727a81806c5531c2bff739e01694cd92ba4439c b727a81806c5531c2bff739e01694cd92ba4439c draft-ietf-detnet-ip-over-mpls b2f2d54d9f9d280603f69878b55eaa9a8db0012cc54e0ce86579712b28f64690 ['f5ddd9ef16285ed7fd98d3046dec38979acca9d003e847aa25e5018b536be9f0', '8efd63665bdd242791ce0e0fc3df6ebb3cb8285401a53e921d623ee329e88120', '887a463221610bcc4362ce703db1d0235972be4b97884fcd7390c9196f8a1e92', 'b2f2d54d9f9d280603f69878b55eaa9a8db0012cc54e0ce86579712b28f64690', 'd2110b86acf572e0194460f6eafffa6032a44789a0222d08159595dfdfd35657', '117b368427deaeb78c79a6100ddbe167ef4f180ae58f9f1417f6479c7a9ba601', '3436c05b6ab78e77474da86a23f798b9280952989b51e6a7453a7a1afa172bb4', '7c3b073d48c204f2678d701bbeecdcfa30cff64f679911a1bd9d570735ddc2a8'] B "mapping of ip to detnet mpls is similar for detnet ip flows and ip flows. the six-tuple of ip is mapped to the s-label in both cases. the various fields may be mapped or ignored when going from ip to mpls." {56: 1, 91: 1, 36: 1, 30: 1, 110: 2} {75: 1, 134: 1, 333: 1, 356: 1, 346: 2} {356, 134, 75, 395, 333, 346} 63 "An implementation MUST support the provisioning for handling any received DetNet MPLS data plane as DetNet IP flows via configuration. Note that such configuration MAY include support from PEOF on the incoming DetNet MPLS flow." Changes are good . b727a81806c5531c2bff739e01694cd92ba4439c b727a81806c5531c2bff739e01694cd92ba4439c draft-ietf-detnet-ip-over-mpls 48021bb0dc65be3a24f669cc5d3b055b74a408d0225c7294bceafb6b3299b4c3 ['44de7b78d6ed4dcd01617ba5ecccd7da26f06e9624d990776ecbc1bf3941bc44', '2eb2c5adbc8257531bb4a12aaa59f6659c366c7819742ec93dd46b689bc86757', '30b7f0b6d57fb79b461a3095454a10e40ff0e085b37c032b1b6efcd9a044fc28', '48021bb0dc65be3a24f669cc5d3b055b74a408d0225c7294bceafb6b3299b4c3', '136f6a2420b1eb371227af0448612d75134ef6cb1036940face467a303e36756', '06c74b21af5fe3ae834b9badbbc0bb53db82a638e0b1078bb224f1f039b218e1'] A "an implementation must support the provisioning for handling any received detnet mpls data plane as detnet ip flows via configuration. note that such configuration may include support from peof on the incoming detnet mpls flow." {118: 1, 38: 1, 30: 1, 69: 2} {62: 1, 175: 1, 103: 1, 401: 3, 407: 2, 414: 2} {414, 102, 103, 175, 401, 407, 62} 63 "The traffic treatment required for a particular DetNet IP flow is provisioned via configuration or the controller plane. When an DetNet IP flow is sent over DetNet MPLS, a DetNet relay node MUST ensure that the provisioned DetNet IP traffic treatment is provided at the forwarding sub-layer as described in I-D.ietf-detnet-mpls Section 5.2. Note that the PRF function MAY be utilized when sending IP over MPLS." Changes are good . b727a81806c5531c2bff739e01694cd92ba4439c b727a81806c5531c2bff739e01694cd92ba4439c draft-ietf-detnet-ip-over-mpls 44de7b78d6ed4dcd01617ba5ecccd7da26f06e9624d990776ecbc1bf3941bc44 ['44de7b78d6ed4dcd01617ba5ecccd7da26f06e9624d990776ecbc1bf3941bc44', '2eb2c5adbc8257531bb4a12aaa59f6659c366c7819742ec93dd46b689bc86757', '30b7f0b6d57fb79b461a3095454a10e40ff0e085b37c032b1b6efcd9a044fc28', '48021bb0dc65be3a24f669cc5d3b055b74a408d0225c7294bceafb6b3299b4c3', '136f6a2420b1eb371227af0448612d75134ef6cb1036940face467a303e36756', '06c74b21af5fe3ae834b9badbbc0bb53db82a638e0b1078bb224f1f039b218e1'] A "the traffic treatment required for a particular detnet ip flow is provisioned via configuration or the controller plane. when an detnet ip flow is sent over detnet mpls, a detnet relay node must ensure that the provisioned detnet ip traffic treatment is provided at the forwarding sub-layer as described in i-d.ietf-detnet-mpls section 5.2. note that the prf function may be utilized when sending ip over mpls." {118: 1, 38: 1, 30: 1, 69: 2} {62: 1, 175: 1, 103: 1, 401: 3, 407: 2, 414: 2} {414, 102, 103, 175, 401, 407, 62} 63 "Traffic treatment for DetNet IP flows received over the DetNet MPLS data plane MUST follow Section 7.3 DetNet IP Traffic Treatment Procedures in I-D.ietf-detnet-ip." Changes are good . b727a81806c5531c2bff739e01694cd92ba4439c b727a81806c5531c2bff739e01694cd92ba4439c draft-ietf-detnet-ip-over-mpls 06c74b21af5fe3ae834b9badbbc0bb53db82a638e0b1078bb224f1f039b218e1 ['44de7b78d6ed4dcd01617ba5ecccd7da26f06e9624d990776ecbc1bf3941bc44', '2eb2c5adbc8257531bb4a12aaa59f6659c366c7819742ec93dd46b689bc86757', '30b7f0b6d57fb79b461a3095454a10e40ff0e085b37c032b1b6efcd9a044fc28', '48021bb0dc65be3a24f669cc5d3b055b74a408d0225c7294bceafb6b3299b4c3', '136f6a2420b1eb371227af0448612d75134ef6cb1036940face467a303e36756', '06c74b21af5fe3ae834b9badbbc0bb53db82a638e0b1078bb224f1f039b218e1'] A "traffic treatment for detnet ip flows received over the detnet mpls data plane must follow section 7.3 detnet ip traffic treatment procedures in i-d.ietf-detnet-ip." {118: 1, 38: 1, 30: 1, 69: 2} {62: 1, 175: 1, 103: 1, 401: 3, 407: 2, 414: 2} {414, 102, 103, 175, 401, 407, 62} 63 "An implementation MUST support the provisioning for handling any received DetNet MPLS data plane as DetNet IP flows via configuration. Note that such configuration MAY include support from PREOF on the incoming DetNet MPLS flow." Changes are good . b727a81806c5531c2bff739e01694cd92ba4439c b727a81806c5531c2bff739e01694cd92ba4439c draft-ietf-detnet-ip-over-mpls 30b7f0b6d57fb79b461a3095454a10e40ff0e085b37c032b1b6efcd9a044fc28 ['44de7b78d6ed4dcd01617ba5ecccd7da26f06e9624d990776ecbc1bf3941bc44', '2eb2c5adbc8257531bb4a12aaa59f6659c366c7819742ec93dd46b689bc86757', '30b7f0b6d57fb79b461a3095454a10e40ff0e085b37c032b1b6efcd9a044fc28', '48021bb0dc65be3a24f669cc5d3b055b74a408d0225c7294bceafb6b3299b4c3', '136f6a2420b1eb371227af0448612d75134ef6cb1036940face467a303e36756', '06c74b21af5fe3ae834b9badbbc0bb53db82a638e0b1078bb224f1f039b218e1'] B "an implementation must support the provisioning for handling any received detnet mpls data plane as detnet ip flows via configuration. note that such configuration may include support from preof on the incoming detnet mpls flow." {118: 1, 38: 1, 30: 1, 69: 2} {62: 1, 175: 1, 103: 1, 401: 3, 407: 2, 414: 2} {414, 102, 103, 175, 401, 407, 62} 63 "The traffic treatment required for a particular DetNet IP flow is provisioned via configuration or the controller plane. When a DetNet IP flow is sent over DetNet MPLS, a DetNet relay node MUST ensure that the provisioned DetNet IP traffic treatment is provided at the forwarding sub-layer as described in I-D.ietf-detnet-mpls Section 5.2. Note that the PRF function MAY be utilized when sending IP over MPLS." Changes are good . b727a81806c5531c2bff739e01694cd92ba4439c b727a81806c5531c2bff739e01694cd92ba4439c draft-ietf-detnet-ip-over-mpls 136f6a2420b1eb371227af0448612d75134ef6cb1036940face467a303e36756 ['44de7b78d6ed4dcd01617ba5ecccd7da26f06e9624d990776ecbc1bf3941bc44', '2eb2c5adbc8257531bb4a12aaa59f6659c366c7819742ec93dd46b689bc86757', '30b7f0b6d57fb79b461a3095454a10e40ff0e085b37c032b1b6efcd9a044fc28', '48021bb0dc65be3a24f669cc5d3b055b74a408d0225c7294bceafb6b3299b4c3', '136f6a2420b1eb371227af0448612d75134ef6cb1036940face467a303e36756', '06c74b21af5fe3ae834b9badbbc0bb53db82a638e0b1078bb224f1f039b218e1'] B "the traffic treatment required for a particular detnet ip flow is provisioned via configuration or the controller plane. when a detnet ip flow is sent over detnet mpls, a detnet relay node must ensure that the provisioned detnet ip traffic treatment is provided at the forwarding sub-layer as described in i-d.ietf-detnet-mpls section 5.2. note that the prf function may be utilized when sending ip over mpls." {118: 1, 38: 1, 30: 1, 69: 2} {62: 1, 175: 1, 103: 1, 401: 3, 407: 2, 414: 2} {414, 102, 103, 175, 401, 407, 62} 63 "Traffic treatment for DetNet IP flows received over the DetNet MPLS data plane MUST follow Section 5.3 DetNet IP Traffic Treatment Procedures in I-D.ietf-detnet-ip." Changes are good . b727a81806c5531c2bff739e01694cd92ba4439c b727a81806c5531c2bff739e01694cd92ba4439c draft-ietf-detnet-ip-over-mpls 2eb2c5adbc8257531bb4a12aaa59f6659c366c7819742ec93dd46b689bc86757 ['44de7b78d6ed4dcd01617ba5ecccd7da26f06e9624d990776ecbc1bf3941bc44', '2eb2c5adbc8257531bb4a12aaa59f6659c366c7819742ec93dd46b689bc86757', '30b7f0b6d57fb79b461a3095454a10e40ff0e085b37c032b1b6efcd9a044fc28', '48021bb0dc65be3a24f669cc5d3b055b74a408d0225c7294bceafb6b3299b4c3', '136f6a2420b1eb371227af0448612d75134ef6cb1036940face467a303e36756', '06c74b21af5fe3ae834b9badbbc0bb53db82a638e0b1078bb224f1f039b218e1'] B "traffic treatment for detnet ip flows received over the detnet mpls data plane must follow section 5.3 detnet ip traffic treatment procedures in i-d.ietf-detnet-ip." {118: 1, 38: 1, 30: 1, 69: 2} {62: 1, 175: 1, 103: 1, 401: 3, 407: 2, 414: 2} {414, 102, 103, 175, 401, 407, 62} 63 "Each MPLS App-Flow is identified using the IP flow identification information as defined in I-D.ietf-detnet-ip. The information is summarized in Section 6 of that document, and includes all wildcards, port ranges and ability to ignore specific IP fields." Changes are good . b727a81806c5531c2bff739e01694cd92ba4439c b727a81806c5531c2bff739e01694cd92ba4439c draft-ietf-detnet-ip-over-mpls 9a91fa91ba6f43a82ddbc51a7f55cbcb68b1bc3b9a29e883764f4b8d92c2587c ['9a91fa91ba6f43a82ddbc51a7f55cbcb68b1bc3b9a29e883764f4b8d92c2587c', 'c0e928ab67249941c1df89bb9b511723eca5f4a6c608dc99485599ee5fde218a', '7e3c24ae37f35e03a8a41f63c39c58a8f4503969c99bc06361631c98bda926c9', '0f117588fdc21825cb3c8b18e8c2f35be3b4616416784fa6a551a38ba5d6966b'] A "each mpls app-flow is identified using the ip flow identification information as defined in i-d.ietf-detnet-ip. the information is summarized in section 6 of that document, and includes all wildcards, port ranges and ability to ignore specific ip fields." {38: 1} {239: 1} {240, 239} 63 "The DetNet MPLS service that is to be used to send the matching IP traffic. Logically this is a pointer to the information provided in I-D.ietf-detnet-mpls Section 5.1, and includes both service and traffic delivery information." Changes are good . b727a81806c5531c2bff739e01694cd92ba4439c b727a81806c5531c2bff739e01694cd92ba4439c draft-ietf-detnet-ip-over-mpls 0f117588fdc21825cb3c8b18e8c2f35be3b4616416784fa6a551a38ba5d6966b ['9a91fa91ba6f43a82ddbc51a7f55cbcb68b1bc3b9a29e883764f4b8d92c2587c', 'c0e928ab67249941c1df89bb9b511723eca5f4a6c608dc99485599ee5fde218a', '7e3c24ae37f35e03a8a41f63c39c58a8f4503969c99bc06361631c98bda926c9', '0f117588fdc21825cb3c8b18e8c2f35be3b4616416784fa6a551a38ba5d6966b'] A "the detnet mpls service that is to be used to send the matching ip traffic. logically this is a pointer to the information provided in i-d.ietf-detnet-mpls section 5.1, and includes both service and traffic delivery information." {38: 1} {239: 1} {240, 239} 63 "Each MPLS App-Flow is identified using the IP flow identification information as defined in I-D.ietf-detnet-ip. The information is summarized in Section 5.1 of that document, and includes all wildcards, port ranges and the ability to ignore specific IP fields." Changes are good . b727a81806c5531c2bff739e01694cd92ba4439c b727a81806c5531c2bff739e01694cd92ba4439c draft-ietf-detnet-ip-over-mpls c0e928ab67249941c1df89bb9b511723eca5f4a6c608dc99485599ee5fde218a ['9a91fa91ba6f43a82ddbc51a7f55cbcb68b1bc3b9a29e883764f4b8d92c2587c', 'c0e928ab67249941c1df89bb9b511723eca5f4a6c608dc99485599ee5fde218a', '7e3c24ae37f35e03a8a41f63c39c58a8f4503969c99bc06361631c98bda926c9', '0f117588fdc21825cb3c8b18e8c2f35be3b4616416784fa6a551a38ba5d6966b'] B "each mpls app-flow is identified using the ip flow identification information as defined in i-d.ietf-detnet-ip. the information is summarized in section 5.1 of that document, and includes all wildcards, port ranges and the ability to ignore specific ip fields." {38: 1} {239: 1} {240, 239} 63 "The DetNet MPLS service that is to be used to send the matching IP traffic. This matching information is provided in I-D.ietf- detnet-mpls Section 5.1, and includes both service and traffic delivery information." Changes are good . b727a81806c5531c2bff739e01694cd92ba4439c b727a81806c5531c2bff739e01694cd92ba4439c draft-ietf-detnet-ip-over-mpls 7e3c24ae37f35e03a8a41f63c39c58a8f4503969c99bc06361631c98bda926c9 ['9a91fa91ba6f43a82ddbc51a7f55cbcb68b1bc3b9a29e883764f4b8d92c2587c', 'c0e928ab67249941c1df89bb9b511723eca5f4a6c608dc99485599ee5fde218a', '7e3c24ae37f35e03a8a41f63c39c58a8f4503969c99bc06361631c98bda926c9', '0f117588fdc21825cb3c8b18e8c2f35be3b4616416784fa6a551a38ba5d6966b'] B "the detnet mpls service that is to be used to send the matching ip traffic. this matching information is provided in i-d.ietf- detnet-mpls section 5.1, and includes both service and traffic delivery information." {38: 1} {239: 1} {240, 239} 62 "This document specifies the DetNet data plane operation for IP hosts and routers that provide DetNet service to IP encapsulated data. No DetNet specific encapsulation is defined to support IP flows, instead the existing IP and higher layer protocol header information is used to support flow identification and DetNet service delivery. Common data plane procedures and control information for all DetNet data planes can be found in the I-D.ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework." As discussed in Nov 28 call 778c768d7d6a73347d014627cc0f8e72210817a9 778c768d7d6a73347d014627cc0f8e72210817a9 draft-ietf-detnet-ip d834df81950974f39bdbcd4a82eb893fdfa1af68224b90c51cb289da163fd869 ['ce42594c0b3ddc3b211fc17191da6560ed45831138e87300b7775f8ad5a7968f', 'd7e5b51625dd0f10006a75fc7c52364f4d76e07f67d4911e2dfe02da3dd04d5b', 'd834df81950974f39bdbcd4a82eb893fdfa1af68224b90c51cb289da163fd869', 'd56fdfb2118295d1205c28a4dcb3c72bb1db4a2e7373b8533f02f4b62f427841'] A "this document specifies the detnet data plane operation for ip hosts and routers that provide detnet service to ip encapsulated data. no detnet specific encapsulation is defined to support ip flows, instead the existing ip and higher layer protocol header information is used to support flow identification and detnet service delivery. common data plane procedures and control information for all detnet data planes can be found in the i-d.ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework." {13: 1, 26: 1, 102: 1, 6: 2} {65: 1, 199: 1, 238: 1, 198: 2, 155: 2} {65, 325, 198, 199, 238, 155} 62 "The DetNet Architecture models the DetNet related data plane functions decomposed into two sub-layers: functions into two sub- layers: a service sub-layer and a forwarding sub-layer. The service sub-layer is used to provide DetNet service protection and reordering. The forwarding sub-layer is used to provides congestion protection (low loss, assured latency, and limited out-of-order delivery). Since no DetNet specific headers are added to support DetNet IP flows, only the forwarding sub-layer functions are supported using the DetNet IP defined by this document. Service protection can be provided on a per sub-net basis using technologies such as MPLS I-D.ietf-detnet-dp-sol-mpls and Ethernet as specified in the IEEE 802.1 TSN task group(referred to in this document simply as IEEE802.1 TSN)." As discussed in Nov 28 call 778c768d7d6a73347d014627cc0f8e72210817a9 778c768d7d6a73347d014627cc0f8e72210817a9 draft-ietf-detnet-ip d7e5b51625dd0f10006a75fc7c52364f4d76e07f67d4911e2dfe02da3dd04d5b ['ce42594c0b3ddc3b211fc17191da6560ed45831138e87300b7775f8ad5a7968f', 'd7e5b51625dd0f10006a75fc7c52364f4d76e07f67d4911e2dfe02da3dd04d5b', 'd834df81950974f39bdbcd4a82eb893fdfa1af68224b90c51cb289da163fd869', 'd56fdfb2118295d1205c28a4dcb3c72bb1db4a2e7373b8533f02f4b62f427841'] A "the detnet architecture models the detnet related data plane functions decomposed into two sub-layers: functions into two sub- layers: a service sub-layer and a forwarding sub-layer. the service sub-layer is used to provide detnet service protection and reordering. the forwarding sub-layer is used to provides congestion protection (low loss, assured latency, and limited out-of-order delivery). since no detnet specific headers are added to support detnet ip flows, only the forwarding sub-layer functions are supported using the detnet ip defined by this document. service protection can be provided on a per sub-net basis using technologies such as mpls i-d.ietf-detnet-dp-sol-mpls and ethernet as specified in the ieee 802.1 tsn task group(referred to in this document simply as ieee802.1 tsn)." {13: 1, 26: 1, 102: 1, 6: 2} {65: 1, 199: 1, 238: 1, 198: 2, 155: 2} {65, 325, 198, 199, 238, 155} 62 "This document specifies the DetNet data plane operation for IP hosts and routers that provide DetNet service to IP encapsulated data. No DetNet-specific encapsulation is defined to support IP flows, instead the existing IP and higher layer protocol header information is used to support flow identification and DetNet service delivery. Common data plane procedures and control information for all DetNet data planes can be found in the I-D.ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework." As discussed in Nov 28 call 778c768d7d6a73347d014627cc0f8e72210817a9 778c768d7d6a73347d014627cc0f8e72210817a9 draft-ietf-detnet-ip d56fdfb2118295d1205c28a4dcb3c72bb1db4a2e7373b8533f02f4b62f427841 ['ce42594c0b3ddc3b211fc17191da6560ed45831138e87300b7775f8ad5a7968f', 'd7e5b51625dd0f10006a75fc7c52364f4d76e07f67d4911e2dfe02da3dd04d5b', 'd834df81950974f39bdbcd4a82eb893fdfa1af68224b90c51cb289da163fd869', 'd56fdfb2118295d1205c28a4dcb3c72bb1db4a2e7373b8533f02f4b62f427841'] B "this document specifies the detnet data plane operation for ip hosts and routers that provide detnet service to ip encapsulated data. no detnet-specific encapsulation is defined to support ip flows, instead the existing ip and higher layer protocol header information is used to support flow identification and detnet service delivery. common data plane procedures and control information for all detnet data planes can be found in the i-d.ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework." {13: 1, 26: 1, 102: 1, 6: 2} {65: 1, 199: 1, 238: 1, 198: 2, 155: 2} {65, 325, 198, 199, 238, 155} 62 "The DetNet Architecture models the DetNet related data plane functions as two sub-layers: functions into two sub-layers: a service sub-layer and a forwarding sub-layer. The service sub-layer is used to provide DetNet service protection (e.g., by packet replication and packet elimination functions) and reordering. The forwarding sub- layer is used to provides congestion protection (low loss, assured latency, and limited out-of-order delivery). The service sub-layer generally requires additional fields to provide its service; for example see I-D.ietf-detnet-mpls. Since no DetNet-specific fields are added to support DetNet IP flows, only the forwarding sub-layer functions are supported using the DetNet IP defined by this document. Service protection can be provided on a per sub-net basis using technologies such as MPLS I-D.ietf-detnet-dp-sol-mpls and Ethernet as specified in the IEEE 802.1 TSN task group(referred to in this document simply as IEEE802.1 TSN)." As discussed in Nov 28 call 778c768d7d6a73347d014627cc0f8e72210817a9 778c768d7d6a73347d014627cc0f8e72210817a9 draft-ietf-detnet-ip ce42594c0b3ddc3b211fc17191da6560ed45831138e87300b7775f8ad5a7968f ['ce42594c0b3ddc3b211fc17191da6560ed45831138e87300b7775f8ad5a7968f', 'd7e5b51625dd0f10006a75fc7c52364f4d76e07f67d4911e2dfe02da3dd04d5b', 'd834df81950974f39bdbcd4a82eb893fdfa1af68224b90c51cb289da163fd869', 'd56fdfb2118295d1205c28a4dcb3c72bb1db4a2e7373b8533f02f4b62f427841'] B "the detnet architecture models the detnet related data plane functions as two sub-layers: functions into two sub-layers: a service sub-layer and a forwarding sub-layer. the service sub-layer is used to provide detnet service protection (e.g., by packet replication and packet elimination functions) and reordering. the forwarding sub- layer is used to provides congestion protection (low loss, assured latency, and limited out-of-order delivery). the service sub-layer generally requires additional fields to provide its service; for example see i-d.ietf-detnet-mpls. since no detnet-specific fields are added to support detnet ip flows, only the forwarding sub-layer functions are supported using the detnet ip defined by this document. service protection can be provided on a per sub-net basis using technologies such as mpls i-d.ietf-detnet-dp-sol-mpls and ethernet as specified in the ieee 802.1 tsn task group(referred to in this document simply as ieee802.1 tsn)." {13: 1, 26: 1, 102: 1, 6: 2} {65: 1, 199: 1, 238: 1, 198: 2, 155: 2} {65, 325, 198, 199, 238, 155} 62 Packet Replication, Ordering and Elimination Function. As discussed in Nov 28 call 778c768d7d6a73347d014627cc0f8e72210817a9 778c768d7d6a73347d014627cc0f8e72210817a9 draft-ietf-detnet-ip 5d071d73c4129b79be70ee4a57fb281390644dcb50da26d288ed337c66102485 ['f7564defec86be6dda4684aca636cc82f225120667ea733bb1be90ab0764eaec', '5d071d73c4129b79be70ee4a57fb281390644dcb50da26d288ed337c66102485'] A packet replication, ordering and elimination function. {69: 1, 130: 4, 79: 2, 51: 3, 112: 3, 55: 3, 64: 2, 37: 3, 38: 3, 68: 2, 67: 3, 33: 2, 25: 3, 53: 3, 80: 3, 52: 2, 127: 5, 91: 3} {406: 1, 0: 4, 389: 3, 390: 3, 135: 3, 142: 3, 14: 2, 17: 3, 399: 4, 19: 4, 149: 3, 279: 2, 280: 2, 281: 4, 278: 3, 294: 3, 296: 3, 45: 4, 308: 3, 56: 3, 185: 3, 192: 3, 321: 2, 322: 3, 66: 3, 196: 6, 197: 5, 324: 2, 77: 3, 78: 3, 337: 5, 216: 3, 380: 3, 255: 4} {0, 389, 390, 135, 142, 14, 400, 17, 399, 19, 149, 406, 279, 280, 281, 278, 294, 296, 45, 308, 56, 185, 192, 321, 322, 66, 196, 197, 324, 77, 78, 337, 216, 380, 255} 62 Packet Replication, Elimination and Ordering Function. As discussed in Nov 28 call 778c768d7d6a73347d014627cc0f8e72210817a9 778c768d7d6a73347d014627cc0f8e72210817a9 draft-ietf-detnet-ip f7564defec86be6dda4684aca636cc82f225120667ea733bb1be90ab0764eaec ['f7564defec86be6dda4684aca636cc82f225120667ea733bb1be90ab0764eaec', '5d071d73c4129b79be70ee4a57fb281390644dcb50da26d288ed337c66102485'] B packet replication, elimination and ordering function. {69: 1, 130: 4, 79: 2, 51: 3, 112: 3, 55: 3, 64: 2, 37: 3, 38: 3, 68: 2, 67: 3, 33: 2, 25: 3, 53: 3, 80: 3, 52: 2, 127: 5, 91: 3} {406: 1, 0: 4, 389: 3, 390: 3, 135: 3, 142: 3, 14: 2, 17: 3, 399: 4, 19: 4, 149: 3, 279: 2, 280: 2, 281: 4, 278: 3, 294: 3, 296: 3, 45: 4, 308: 3, 56: 3, 185: 3, 192: 3, 321: 2, 322: 3, 66: 3, 196: 6, 197: 5, 324: 2, 77: 3, 78: 3, 337: 5, 216: 3, 380: 3, 255: 4} {0, 389, 390, 135, 142, 14, 400, 17, 399, 19, 149, 406, 279, 280, 281, 278, 294, 296, 45, 308, 56, 185, 192, 321, 322, 66, 196, 197, 324, 77, 78, 337, 216, 380, 255} 62 "This document describes how IP is used by DetNet nodes, i.e., hosts and routers, identify DetNet flows and provide a DetNet service using an IP data plane. From a data plane perspective, an end-to-end IP model is followed. As mentioned above, existing IP and higher layer protocol header information is used to support flow identification and DetNet service delivery. Common data plane procedures and control information for all DetNet data planes can be found in the I- D.ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework." As discussed in Nov 28 call 778c768d7d6a73347d014627cc0f8e72210817a9 778c768d7d6a73347d014627cc0f8e72210817a9 draft-ietf-detnet-ip 7f94aafb335769dcfafc14037eed1da59f73de88a52916bf0395cb4da015df44 ['400bf736a5e13d1d94d0ec51ce637c1a7c981486fb999b363a151d4eb30aa9b7', '7f94aafb335769dcfafc14037eed1da59f73de88a52916bf0395cb4da015df44'] A "this document describes how ip is used by detnet nodes, i.e., hosts and routers, identify detnet flows and provide a detnet service using an ip data plane. from a data plane perspective, an end-to-end ip model is followed. as mentioned above, existing ip and higher layer protocol header information is used to support flow identification and detnet service delivery. common data plane procedures and control information for all detnet data planes can be found in the i- d.ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework." {102: 1, 26: 1, 6: 2} {23: 1, 201: 1, 11: 2} {99, 201, 11, 23} 62 "This document describes how IP is used by DetNet nodes, i.e., hosts and routers, to identify DetNet flows and provide a DetNet service using an IP data plane. From a data plane perspective, an end-to-end IP model is followed. As mentioned above, existing IP and higher layer protocol header information is used to support flow identification and DetNet service delivery. Common data plane procedures and control information for all DetNet data planes can be found in the I-D.ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework." As discussed in Nov 28 call 778c768d7d6a73347d014627cc0f8e72210817a9 778c768d7d6a73347d014627cc0f8e72210817a9 draft-ietf-detnet-ip 400bf736a5e13d1d94d0ec51ce637c1a7c981486fb999b363a151d4eb30aa9b7 ['400bf736a5e13d1d94d0ec51ce637c1a7c981486fb999b363a151d4eb30aa9b7', '7f94aafb335769dcfafc14037eed1da59f73de88a52916bf0395cb4da015df44'] B "this document describes how ip is used by detnet nodes, i.e., hosts and routers, to identify detnet flows and provide a detnet service using an ip data plane. from a data plane perspective, an end-to-end ip model is followed. as mentioned above, existing ip and higher layer protocol header information is used to support flow identification and detnet service delivery. common data plane procedures and control information for all detnet data planes can be found in the i-d.ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework." {102: 1, 26: 1, 6: 2} {23: 1, 201: 1, 11: 2} {99, 201, 11, 23} 62 "Generally the fields used in flow identification are forward unmodified but modification is allowed, for example to a DSCP value, when required by the DetNet service." As discussed in Nov 28 call 778c768d7d6a73347d014627cc0f8e72210817a9 778c768d7d6a73347d014627cc0f8e72210817a9 draft-ietf-detnet-ip 315ac7ffbe2845d939f67d9d31548da3262eafb3624a11481b34bff6f4231126 ['b4c8b5df5e942ee2bb1a290dfff942c5863bd978d77d9f00d40ba6b5c1e7b1b1', '529c74ed049e346c22b062f8433d808bc13b8a15bb2898afe8be075ee4514a3b', 'bc223456b83ca093e95c05a524f7fa0b165befad636a47e6a204eba7817a46fd', 'c662e732a77494b783169aa979e82bc30b8da0cb91e4ba4d234056eb799f1946', 'e8a69bded8c204d197cf36ae8623618497f89a1fef08483805a85f3e46c62935', '315ac7ffbe2845d939f67d9d31548da3262eafb3624a11481b34bff6f4231126'] A "generally the fields used in flow identification are forward unmodified but modification is allowed, for example to a dscp value, when required by the detnet service." {85: 1, 56: 1, 102: 2, 60: 2} {190: 1, 312: 1, 368: 1, 38: 2, 146: 2, 189: 2} {38, 368, 146, 312, 282, 189, 190} 62 "DetNet flow aggregation may be enabled via the use of wildcards, masks, lists, prefixes and ranges. IP tunnels may also be used to support flow aggregation. In these cases, it is expected that DetNet aware intermediate nodes will provide DetNet service assurance on the aggregate through resource allocation and congestion control mechanisms." As discussed in Nov 28 call 778c768d7d6a73347d014627cc0f8e72210817a9 778c768d7d6a73347d014627cc0f8e72210817a9 draft-ietf-detnet-ip 529c74ed049e346c22b062f8433d808bc13b8a15bb2898afe8be075ee4514a3b ['b4c8b5df5e942ee2bb1a290dfff942c5863bd978d77d9f00d40ba6b5c1e7b1b1', '529c74ed049e346c22b062f8433d808bc13b8a15bb2898afe8be075ee4514a3b', 'bc223456b83ca093e95c05a524f7fa0b165befad636a47e6a204eba7817a46fd', 'c662e732a77494b783169aa979e82bc30b8da0cb91e4ba4d234056eb799f1946', 'e8a69bded8c204d197cf36ae8623618497f89a1fef08483805a85f3e46c62935', '315ac7ffbe2845d939f67d9d31548da3262eafb3624a11481b34bff6f4231126'] A "detnet flow aggregation may be enabled via the use of wildcards, masks, lists, prefixes and ranges. ip tunnels may also be used to support flow aggregation. in these cases, it is expected that detnet aware intermediate nodes will provide detnet service assurance on the aggregate through resource allocation and congestion control mechanisms." {85: 1, 56: 1, 102: 2, 60: 2} {190: 1, 312: 1, 368: 1, 38: 2, 146: 2, 189: 2} {38, 368, 146, 312, 282, 189, 190} 62 "fig_ip_detnet_simple illustrates a DetNet enabled IP network. The DetNet enabled end systems originate IP encapsulated traffic that is identified as DetNet flows, relay nodes understand the forwarding requirements of the DetNet flow and ensure that node, interface and sub-network resources are allocated to ensure DetNet service requirements. The dotted line around the Service component of the Relay Nodes indicates that the transit routers are DetNet service aware but do not perform any DetNet service sub-layer function, e.g., PREOF. IEEE 802.1 TSN is an example sub-network type which can provide support for DetNet flows and service." As discussed in Nov 28 call 778c768d7d6a73347d014627cc0f8e72210817a9 778c768d7d6a73347d014627cc0f8e72210817a9 draft-ietf-detnet-ip e8a69bded8c204d197cf36ae8623618497f89a1fef08483805a85f3e46c62935 ['b4c8b5df5e942ee2bb1a290dfff942c5863bd978d77d9f00d40ba6b5c1e7b1b1', '529c74ed049e346c22b062f8433d808bc13b8a15bb2898afe8be075ee4514a3b', 'bc223456b83ca093e95c05a524f7fa0b165befad636a47e6a204eba7817a46fd', 'c662e732a77494b783169aa979e82bc30b8da0cb91e4ba4d234056eb799f1946', 'e8a69bded8c204d197cf36ae8623618497f89a1fef08483805a85f3e46c62935', '315ac7ffbe2845d939f67d9d31548da3262eafb3624a11481b34bff6f4231126'] A "fig_ip_detnet_simple illustrates a detnet enabled ip network. the detnet enabled end systems originate ip encapsulated traffic that is identified as detnet flows, relay nodes understand the forwarding requirements of the detnet flow and ensure that node, interface and sub-network resources are allocated to ensure detnet service requirements. the dotted line around the service component of the relay nodes indicates that the transit routers are detnet service aware but do not perform any detnet service sub-layer function, e.g., preof. ieee 802.1 tsn is an example sub-network type which can provide support for detnet flows and service." {85: 1, 56: 1, 102: 2, 60: 2} {190: 1, 312: 1, 368: 1, 38: 2, 146: 2, 189: 2} {38, 368, 146, 312, 282, 189, 190} 62 "Non-DetNet and DetNet IP packets are identical on the wire. Generally the fields used in flow identification are forwarded unmodified, however modification of these fields is allowed, for example to a DSCP value, when required by the DetNet service." As discussed in Nov 28 call 778c768d7d6a73347d014627cc0f8e72210817a9 778c768d7d6a73347d014627cc0f8e72210817a9 draft-ietf-detnet-ip c662e732a77494b783169aa979e82bc30b8da0cb91e4ba4d234056eb799f1946 ['b4c8b5df5e942ee2bb1a290dfff942c5863bd978d77d9f00d40ba6b5c1e7b1b1', '529c74ed049e346c22b062f8433d808bc13b8a15bb2898afe8be075ee4514a3b', 'bc223456b83ca093e95c05a524f7fa0b165befad636a47e6a204eba7817a46fd', 'c662e732a77494b783169aa979e82bc30b8da0cb91e4ba4d234056eb799f1946', 'e8a69bded8c204d197cf36ae8623618497f89a1fef08483805a85f3e46c62935', '315ac7ffbe2845d939f67d9d31548da3262eafb3624a11481b34bff6f4231126'] B "non-detnet and detnet ip packets are identical on the wire. generally the fields used in flow identification are forwarded unmodified, however modification of these fields is allowed, for example to a dscp value, when required by the detnet service." {85: 1, 56: 1, 102: 2, 60: 2} {190: 1, 312: 1, 368: 1, 38: 2, 146: 2, 189: 2} {38, 368, 146, 312, 282, 189, 190} 62 "DetNet flow aggregation may be enabled via the use of wildcards, masks, lists, prefixes and ranges. IP tunnels may also be used to support flow aggregation. In these cases, it is expected that DetNet-aware intermediate nodes will provide DetNet service on the aggregate through resource allocation and congestion control mechanisms." As discussed in Nov 28 call 778c768d7d6a73347d014627cc0f8e72210817a9 778c768d7d6a73347d014627cc0f8e72210817a9 draft-ietf-detnet-ip b4c8b5df5e942ee2bb1a290dfff942c5863bd978d77d9f00d40ba6b5c1e7b1b1 ['b4c8b5df5e942ee2bb1a290dfff942c5863bd978d77d9f00d40ba6b5c1e7b1b1', '529c74ed049e346c22b062f8433d808bc13b8a15bb2898afe8be075ee4514a3b', 'bc223456b83ca093e95c05a524f7fa0b165befad636a47e6a204eba7817a46fd', 'c662e732a77494b783169aa979e82bc30b8da0cb91e4ba4d234056eb799f1946', 'e8a69bded8c204d197cf36ae8623618497f89a1fef08483805a85f3e46c62935', '315ac7ffbe2845d939f67d9d31548da3262eafb3624a11481b34bff6f4231126'] B "detnet flow aggregation may be enabled via the use of wildcards, masks, lists, prefixes and ranges. ip tunnels may also be used to support flow aggregation. in these cases, it is expected that detnet-aware intermediate nodes will provide detnet service on the aggregate through resource allocation and congestion control mechanisms." {85: 1, 56: 1, 102: 2, 60: 2} {190: 1, 312: 1, 368: 1, 38: 2, 146: 2, 189: 2} {38, 368, 146, 312, 282, 189, 190} 62 "fig_ip_detnet_simple illustrates a DetNet enabled IP network. The DetNet enabled end systems originate IP encapsulated traffic those are identified within the DetNet domain as DetNet flows, relay nodes understand the forwarding requirements of the DetNet flow and ensure that node, interface and sub-network resources are allocated to ensure DetNet service requirements. The dotted line around the Service component of the Relay Nodes indicates that the transit routers are DetNet service aware but do not perform any DetNet service sub-layer function, e.g., PREOF." As discussed in Nov 28 call 778c768d7d6a73347d014627cc0f8e72210817a9 778c768d7d6a73347d014627cc0f8e72210817a9 draft-ietf-detnet-ip bc223456b83ca093e95c05a524f7fa0b165befad636a47e6a204eba7817a46fd ['b4c8b5df5e942ee2bb1a290dfff942c5863bd978d77d9f00d40ba6b5c1e7b1b1', '529c74ed049e346c22b062f8433d808bc13b8a15bb2898afe8be075ee4514a3b', 'bc223456b83ca093e95c05a524f7fa0b165befad636a47e6a204eba7817a46fd', 'c662e732a77494b783169aa979e82bc30b8da0cb91e4ba4d234056eb799f1946', 'e8a69bded8c204d197cf36ae8623618497f89a1fef08483805a85f3e46c62935', '315ac7ffbe2845d939f67d9d31548da3262eafb3624a11481b34bff6f4231126'] B "fig_ip_detnet_simple illustrates a detnet enabled ip network. the detnet enabled end systems originate ip encapsulated traffic those are identified within the detnet domain as detnet flows, relay nodes understand the forwarding requirements of the detnet flow and ensure that node, interface and sub-network resources are allocated to ensure detnet service requirements. the dotted line around the service component of the relay nodes indicates that the transit routers are detnet service aware but do not perform any detnet service sub-layer function, e.g., preof." {85: 1, 56: 1, 102: 2, 60: 2} {190: 1, 312: 1, 368: 1, 38: 2, 146: 2, 189: 2} {38, 368, 146, 312, 282, 189, 190} 62 "Note, that fig_ip_detnet_simple and fig_non_detnet_ip can be combined, so IP DetNet End Systems can communicate over DetNet IP network with IP End System." As discussed in Nov 28 call 778c768d7d6a73347d014627cc0f8e72210817a9 778c768d7d6a73347d014627cc0f8e72210817a9 draft-ietf-detnet-ip 37f4a84181adc18c68a964f05858e06e668480d1faccf666c278810df368396f ['19e5c260c02d6a258e0c900a28dfa2d136b991f72c68eafe6dc83852406ad1c9', '37f4a84181adc18c68a964f05858e06e668480d1faccf666c278810df368396f', 'b3b276ab53d2bb9ff622f9b2ea7e7643e0598c3bed12033cbd25e47851d54961', '70bd929f7b7525f661d98655998fc5fa4dfa1b0b5643aec3360083890ea7a0f5'] A "note, that fig_ip_detnet_simple and fig_non_detnet_ip can be combined, so ip detnet end systems can communicate over detnet ip network with ip end system." {102: 1, 13: 1, 85: 1, 51: 1, 6: 3, 79: 5, 90: 3, 130: 2, 68: 3, 35: 6, 110: 5, 91: 7, 114: 5, 97: 3, 31: 4, 67: 5, 38: 6, 26: 2, 124: 2, 98: 5, 54: 5, 127: 6, 8: 3, 96: 2, 64: 5, 30: 5, 61: 7, 55: 2, 27: 4, 15: 5, 52: 3, 129: 6, 115: 5, 84: 3, 76: 6, 87: 5, 131: 8, 113: 7, 99: 5, 62: 3, 36: 5, 24: 4, 53: 4, 72: 6} {320: 1, 81: 1, 26: 1, 82: 1, 1: 8, 4: 5, 9: 5, 10: 6, 15: 4, 24: 5, 27: 4, 39: 4, 43: 6, 49: 8, 50: 7, 58: 7, 59: 5, 64: 4, 69: 4, 86: 5, 96: 6, 97: 5, 100: 4, 108: 6, 109: 7, 110: 7, 111: 5, 114: 6, 115: 7, 116: 3, 118: 3, 119: 2, 120: 6, 121: 3, 122: 3, 123: 2, 124: 3, 128: 6, 129: 5, 130: 7, 132: 4, 136: 5, 145: 4, 147: 6, 151: 6, 152: 6, 154: 6, 156: 3, 161: 3, 162: 2, 165: 6, 168: 7, 169: 5, 172: 5, 180: 6, 184: 5, 187: 8, 188: 7, 191: 6, 194: 4, 202: 5, 203: 6, 206: 5, 207: 6, 215: 4, 217: 6, 218: 7, 220: 3, 221: 3, 222: 4, 224: 6, 227: 2, 229: 5, 234: 8, 235: 5, 241: 5, 242: 5, 243: 4, 244: 6, 245: 4, 248: 6, 250: 5, 258: 10, 262: 7, 263: 8, 264: 4, 267: 3, 270: 4, 272: 5, 273: 5, 287: 6, 289: 5, 291: 7, 299: 2, 300: 4, 304: 4, 309: 3, 314: 5, 315: 5, 323: 4, 327: 7, 328: 5, 329: 5, 330: 9, 334: 5, 335: 3, 341: 2, 342: 3, 347: 2, 348: 2, 350: 7, 351: 7, 352: 5, 353: 5, 354: 4, 358: 3, 365: 5, 366: 5, 369: 4, 371: 4, 372: 7, 376: 5, 384: 7, 385: 6, 386: 6, 387: 4, 392: 5, 393: 6, 396: 3, 397: 6, 398: 5, 402: 5} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 62 "Non-DetNet and DetNet IP packets are identical on the wire. From data plane perspective, the only difference is that there is flow- associated DetNet information on each DetNet node that defines the flow related characteristics and required forwarding behavior. As shown above, edge nodes provide a Service Proxy function that ""associates"" one or more IP flows with the appropriate DetNet flow- specific information and ensures that the receives the proper traffic treatment within the domain." As discussed in Nov 28 call 778c768d7d6a73347d014627cc0f8e72210817a9 778c768d7d6a73347d014627cc0f8e72210817a9 draft-ietf-detnet-ip b3b276ab53d2bb9ff622f9b2ea7e7643e0598c3bed12033cbd25e47851d54961 ['19e5c260c02d6a258e0c900a28dfa2d136b991f72c68eafe6dc83852406ad1c9', '37f4a84181adc18c68a964f05858e06e668480d1faccf666c278810df368396f', 'b3b276ab53d2bb9ff622f9b2ea7e7643e0598c3bed12033cbd25e47851d54961', '70bd929f7b7525f661d98655998fc5fa4dfa1b0b5643aec3360083890ea7a0f5'] A "non-detnet and detnet ip packets are identical on the wire. from data plane perspective, the only difference is that there is flow- associated detnet information on each detnet node that defines the flow related characteristics and required forwarding behavior. as shown above, edge nodes provide a service proxy function that ""associates"" one or more ip flows with the appropriate detnet flow- specific information and ensures that the receives the proper traffic treatment within the domain." {102: 1, 13: 1, 85: 1, 51: 1, 6: 3, 79: 5, 90: 3, 130: 2, 68: 3, 35: 6, 110: 5, 91: 7, 114: 5, 97: 3, 31: 4, 67: 5, 38: 6, 26: 2, 124: 2, 98: 5, 54: 5, 127: 6, 8: 3, 96: 2, 64: 5, 30: 5, 61: 7, 55: 2, 27: 4, 15: 5, 52: 3, 129: 6, 115: 5, 84: 3, 76: 6, 87: 5, 131: 8, 113: 7, 99: 5, 62: 3, 36: 5, 24: 4, 53: 4, 72: 6} {320: 1, 81: 1, 26: 1, 82: 1, 1: 8, 4: 5, 9: 5, 10: 6, 15: 4, 24: 5, 27: 4, 39: 4, 43: 6, 49: 8, 50: 7, 58: 7, 59: 5, 64: 4, 69: 4, 86: 5, 96: 6, 97: 5, 100: 4, 108: 6, 109: 7, 110: 7, 111: 5, 114: 6, 115: 7, 116: 3, 118: 3, 119: 2, 120: 6, 121: 3, 122: 3, 123: 2, 124: 3, 128: 6, 129: 5, 130: 7, 132: 4, 136: 5, 145: 4, 147: 6, 151: 6, 152: 6, 154: 6, 156: 3, 161: 3, 162: 2, 165: 6, 168: 7, 169: 5, 172: 5, 180: 6, 184: 5, 187: 8, 188: 7, 191: 6, 194: 4, 202: 5, 203: 6, 206: 5, 207: 6, 215: 4, 217: 6, 218: 7, 220: 3, 221: 3, 222: 4, 224: 6, 227: 2, 229: 5, 234: 8, 235: 5, 241: 5, 242: 5, 243: 4, 244: 6, 245: 4, 248: 6, 250: 5, 258: 10, 262: 7, 263: 8, 264: 4, 267: 3, 270: 4, 272: 5, 273: 5, 287: 6, 289: 5, 291: 7, 299: 2, 300: 4, 304: 4, 309: 3, 314: 5, 315: 5, 323: 4, 327: 7, 328: 5, 329: 5, 330: 9, 334: 5, 335: 3, 341: 2, 342: 3, 347: 2, 348: 2, 350: 7, 351: 7, 352: 5, 353: 5, 354: 4, 358: 3, 365: 5, 366: 5, 369: 4, 371: 4, 372: 7, 376: 5, 384: 7, 385: 6, 386: 6, 387: 4, 392: 5, 393: 6, 396: 3, 397: 6, 398: 5, 402: 5} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 62 "Note, that fig_ip_detnet_simple and fig_non_detnet_ip can be collapsed, so IP DetNet End Systems can communicate over DetNet IP network with IP End System." As discussed in Nov 28 call 778c768d7d6a73347d014627cc0f8e72210817a9 778c768d7d6a73347d014627cc0f8e72210817a9 draft-ietf-detnet-ip 70bd929f7b7525f661d98655998fc5fa4dfa1b0b5643aec3360083890ea7a0f5 ['19e5c260c02d6a258e0c900a28dfa2d136b991f72c68eafe6dc83852406ad1c9', '37f4a84181adc18c68a964f05858e06e668480d1faccf666c278810df368396f', 'b3b276ab53d2bb9ff622f9b2ea7e7643e0598c3bed12033cbd25e47851d54961', '70bd929f7b7525f661d98655998fc5fa4dfa1b0b5643aec3360083890ea7a0f5'] B "note, that fig_ip_detnet_simple and fig_non_detnet_ip can be collapsed, so ip detnet end systems can communicate over detnet ip network with ip end system." {102: 1, 13: 1, 85: 1, 51: 1, 6: 3, 79: 5, 90: 3, 130: 2, 68: 3, 35: 6, 110: 5, 91: 7, 114: 5, 97: 3, 31: 4, 67: 5, 38: 6, 26: 2, 124: 2, 98: 5, 54: 5, 127: 6, 8: 3, 96: 2, 64: 5, 30: 5, 61: 7, 55: 2, 27: 4, 15: 5, 52: 3, 129: 6, 115: 5, 84: 3, 76: 6, 87: 5, 131: 8, 113: 7, 99: 5, 62: 3, 36: 5, 24: 4, 53: 4, 72: 6} {320: 1, 81: 1, 26: 1, 82: 1, 1: 8, 4: 5, 9: 5, 10: 6, 15: 4, 24: 5, 27: 4, 39: 4, 43: 6, 49: 8, 50: 7, 58: 7, 59: 5, 64: 4, 69: 4, 86: 5, 96: 6, 97: 5, 100: 4, 108: 6, 109: 7, 110: 7, 111: 5, 114: 6, 115: 7, 116: 3, 118: 3, 119: 2, 120: 6, 121: 3, 122: 3, 123: 2, 124: 3, 128: 6, 129: 5, 130: 7, 132: 4, 136: 5, 145: 4, 147: 6, 151: 6, 152: 6, 154: 6, 156: 3, 161: 3, 162: 2, 165: 6, 168: 7, 169: 5, 172: 5, 180: 6, 184: 5, 187: 8, 188: 7, 191: 6, 194: 4, 202: 5, 203: 6, 206: 5, 207: 6, 215: 4, 217: 6, 218: 7, 220: 3, 221: 3, 222: 4, 224: 6, 227: 2, 229: 5, 234: 8, 235: 5, 241: 5, 242: 5, 243: 4, 244: 6, 245: 4, 248: 6, 250: 5, 258: 10, 262: 7, 263: 8, 264: 4, 267: 3, 270: 4, 272: 5, 273: 5, 287: 6, 289: 5, 291: 7, 299: 2, 300: 4, 304: 4, 309: 3, 314: 5, 315: 5, 323: 4, 327: 7, 328: 5, 329: 5, 330: 9, 334: 5, 335: 3, 341: 2, 342: 3, 347: 2, 348: 2, 350: 7, 351: 7, 352: 5, 353: 5, 354: 4, 358: 3, 365: 5, 366: 5, 369: 4, 371: 4, 372: 7, 376: 5, 384: 7, 385: 6, 386: 6, 387: 4, 392: 5, 393: 6, 396: 3, 397: 6, 398: 5, 402: 5} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 62 "As non-DetNet and DetNet IP packets are identical on the wire, from data plane perspective, the only difference is that there is flow- associated DetNet information on each DetNet node that defines the flow related characteristics and required forwarding behavior. As shown above, edge nodes provide a Service Proxy function that ""associates"" one or more IP flows with the appropriate DetNet flow- specific information and ensures that the receives the proper traffic treatment within the domain." As discussed in Nov 28 call 778c768d7d6a73347d014627cc0f8e72210817a9 778c768d7d6a73347d014627cc0f8e72210817a9 draft-ietf-detnet-ip 19e5c260c02d6a258e0c900a28dfa2d136b991f72c68eafe6dc83852406ad1c9 ['19e5c260c02d6a258e0c900a28dfa2d136b991f72c68eafe6dc83852406ad1c9', '37f4a84181adc18c68a964f05858e06e668480d1faccf666c278810df368396f', 'b3b276ab53d2bb9ff622f9b2ea7e7643e0598c3bed12033cbd25e47851d54961', '70bd929f7b7525f661d98655998fc5fa4dfa1b0b5643aec3360083890ea7a0f5'] B "as non-detnet and detnet ip packets are identical on the wire, from data plane perspective, the only difference is that there is flow- associated detnet information on each detnet node that defines the flow related characteristics and required forwarding behavior. as shown above, edge nodes provide a service proxy function that ""associates"" one or more ip flows with the appropriate detnet flow- specific information and ensures that the receives the proper traffic treatment within the domain." {102: 1, 13: 1, 85: 1, 51: 1, 6: 3, 79: 5, 90: 3, 130: 2, 68: 3, 35: 6, 110: 5, 91: 7, 114: 5, 97: 3, 31: 4, 67: 5, 38: 6, 26: 2, 124: 2, 98: 5, 54: 5, 127: 6, 8: 3, 96: 2, 64: 5, 30: 5, 61: 7, 55: 2, 27: 4, 15: 5, 52: 3, 129: 6, 115: 5, 84: 3, 76: 6, 87: 5, 131: 8, 113: 7, 99: 5, 62: 3, 36: 5, 24: 4, 53: 4, 72: 6} {320: 1, 81: 1, 26: 1, 82: 1, 1: 8, 4: 5, 9: 5, 10: 6, 15: 4, 24: 5, 27: 4, 39: 4, 43: 6, 49: 8, 50: 7, 58: 7, 59: 5, 64: 4, 69: 4, 86: 5, 96: 6, 97: 5, 100: 4, 108: 6, 109: 7, 110: 7, 111: 5, 114: 6, 115: 7, 116: 3, 118: 3, 119: 2, 120: 6, 121: 3, 122: 3, 123: 2, 124: 3, 128: 6, 129: 5, 130: 7, 132: 4, 136: 5, 145: 4, 147: 6, 151: 6, 152: 6, 154: 6, 156: 3, 161: 3, 162: 2, 165: 6, 168: 7, 169: 5, 172: 5, 180: 6, 184: 5, 187: 8, 188: 7, 191: 6, 194: 4, 202: 5, 203: 6, 206: 5, 207: 6, 215: 4, 217: 6, 218: 7, 220: 3, 221: 3, 222: 4, 224: 6, 227: 2, 229: 5, 234: 8, 235: 5, 241: 5, 242: 5, 243: 4, 244: 6, 245: 4, 248: 6, 250: 5, 258: 10, 262: 7, 263: 8, 264: 4, 267: 3, 270: 4, 272: 5, 273: 5, 287: 6, 289: 5, 291: 7, 299: 2, 300: 4, 304: 4, 309: 3, 314: 5, 315: 5, 323: 4, 327: 7, 328: 5, 329: 5, 330: 9, 334: 5, 335: 3, 341: 2, 342: 3, 347: 2, 348: 2, 350: 7, 351: 7, 352: 5, 353: 5, 354: 4, 358: 3, 365: 5, 366: 5, 369: 4, 371: 4, 372: 7, 376: 5, 384: 7, 385: 6, 386: 6, 387: 4, 392: 5, 393: 6, 396: 3, 397: 6, 398: 5, 402: 5} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 62 "Data-flows requiring DetNet service are generated and terminated on end systems. This document deals only with IP end systems. The protocols used by an IP end system are specific to an application and end systems peer with end systems using the same application encapsulation format. This said, DetNet's use of 6-tuple IP flow identification means that DetNet must be aware of not only the format of the IP header, but also of the next protocol carried within an IP packet." As discussed in Nov 28 call 778c768d7d6a73347d014627cc0f8e72210817a9 778c768d7d6a73347d014627cc0f8e72210817a9 draft-ietf-detnet-ip 51ca66249e5731f28331f8db7714014afabeace74bae285fa1369a199f08bad7 ['6cef8879203010947dae2fccbce29ef157cbc83dcee3ce716da07322a2f996ce', '586147cf635541ce0930e441ab43112c6170f1a1bd5e4892961cb14b5d442b2b', '7a5ee85c91420f1cbb2c08b3c7f20867e8846d52976197d764721e6dcb957956', '6af6aeb091775f483e8cebd06fb8d8988f79c7204748ee0abee8eefee433363a', 'f301a3eb8d0fceffb909b6fbbb0f96741153fe02d5705a74cab611ef9e59bf33', '51ca66249e5731f28331f8db7714014afabeace74bae285fa1369a199f08bad7', '91fc5823dabd2169348ad98ddd941b03f82dfb8a2bf5cd175898b5eb2c9f786c', '1525125d2a710fb92932e5f2bff5dfcd9b9e4d7ddfa205b68b802c1501888d49', '61edd2fa3f5afff23818543bb8d4691cb47348e39d924a483af4fcb48b6f880a', '790dd88ab88c647b7acd94021caf186daf92d383a1c9c7e805d2697ebcf490d2'] A "data-flows requiring detnet service are generated and terminated on end systems. this document deals only with ip end systems. the protocols used by an ip end system are specific to an application and end systems peer with end systems using the same application encapsulation format. this said, detnet's use of 6-tuple ip flow identification means that detnet must be aware of not only the format of the ip header, but also of the next protocol carried within an ip packet." {56: 1, 67: 1, 102: 1, 13: 1} {141: 1, 200: 1, 295: 1, 223: 1} {295, 200, 171, 141, 223} 62 "When IP end systems are DetNet aware, no application-level or service-level proxy functions are needed inside the DetNet domain. For DetNet unaware IP end systems service-level proxy functions are needed inside the DetNet domain." As discussed in Nov 28 call 778c768d7d6a73347d014627cc0f8e72210817a9 778c768d7d6a73347d014627cc0f8e72210817a9 draft-ietf-detnet-ip 61edd2fa3f5afff23818543bb8d4691cb47348e39d924a483af4fcb48b6f880a ['6cef8879203010947dae2fccbce29ef157cbc83dcee3ce716da07322a2f996ce', '586147cf635541ce0930e441ab43112c6170f1a1bd5e4892961cb14b5d442b2b', '7a5ee85c91420f1cbb2c08b3c7f20867e8846d52976197d764721e6dcb957956', '6af6aeb091775f483e8cebd06fb8d8988f79c7204748ee0abee8eefee433363a', 'f301a3eb8d0fceffb909b6fbbb0f96741153fe02d5705a74cab611ef9e59bf33', '51ca66249e5731f28331f8db7714014afabeace74bae285fa1369a199f08bad7', '91fc5823dabd2169348ad98ddd941b03f82dfb8a2bf5cd175898b5eb2c9f786c', '1525125d2a710fb92932e5f2bff5dfcd9b9e4d7ddfa205b68b802c1501888d49', '61edd2fa3f5afff23818543bb8d4691cb47348e39d924a483af4fcb48b6f880a', '790dd88ab88c647b7acd94021caf186daf92d383a1c9c7e805d2697ebcf490d2'] A "when ip end systems are detnet aware, no application-level or service-level proxy functions are needed inside the detnet domain. for detnet unaware ip end systems service-level proxy functions are needed inside the detnet domain." {56: 1, 67: 1, 102: 1, 13: 1} {141: 1, 200: 1, 295: 1, 223: 1} {295, 200, 171, 141, 223} 62 "End systems need to ensure that DetNet service requirements are met when processing packets associated with a DetNet flow. When forwarding packets, this means that packets are appropriately shaped on transmission and received appropriate traffic treatment on the connected sub-network, see QoS and dn_dom_spec_cons for more details. When receiving packets, this means that there are appropriate local node resources, e.g., buffers, to receive and process a DetNet flow packets." As discussed in Nov 28 call 778c768d7d6a73347d014627cc0f8e72210817a9 778c768d7d6a73347d014627cc0f8e72210817a9 draft-ietf-detnet-ip 91fc5823dabd2169348ad98ddd941b03f82dfb8a2bf5cd175898b5eb2c9f786c ['6cef8879203010947dae2fccbce29ef157cbc83dcee3ce716da07322a2f996ce', '586147cf635541ce0930e441ab43112c6170f1a1bd5e4892961cb14b5d442b2b', '7a5ee85c91420f1cbb2c08b3c7f20867e8846d52976197d764721e6dcb957956', '6af6aeb091775f483e8cebd06fb8d8988f79c7204748ee0abee8eefee433363a', 'f301a3eb8d0fceffb909b6fbbb0f96741153fe02d5705a74cab611ef9e59bf33', '51ca66249e5731f28331f8db7714014afabeace74bae285fa1369a199f08bad7', '91fc5823dabd2169348ad98ddd941b03f82dfb8a2bf5cd175898b5eb2c9f786c', '1525125d2a710fb92932e5f2bff5dfcd9b9e4d7ddfa205b68b802c1501888d49', '61edd2fa3f5afff23818543bb8d4691cb47348e39d924a483af4fcb48b6f880a', '790dd88ab88c647b7acd94021caf186daf92d383a1c9c7e805d2697ebcf490d2'] A "end systems need to ensure that detnet service requirements are met when processing packets associated with a detnet flow. when forwarding packets, this means that packets are appropriately shaped on transmission and received appropriate traffic treatment on the connected sub-network, see qos and dn_dom_spec_cons for more details. when receiving packets, this means that there are appropriate local node resources, e.g., buffers, to receive and process a detnet flow packets." {56: 1, 67: 1, 102: 1, 13: 1} {141: 1, 200: 1, 295: 1, 223: 1} {295, 200, 171, 141, 223} 62 "In order to maximize reuse of 5-tuple based mechanisms, e.g, traceroute, DetNet aware applications and end systems SHOULD NOT mix DetNet and non-DetNet traffic within a single 5-tuple." As discussed in Nov 28 call 778c768d7d6a73347d014627cc0f8e72210817a9 778c768d7d6a73347d014627cc0f8e72210817a9 draft-ietf-detnet-ip 586147cf635541ce0930e441ab43112c6170f1a1bd5e4892961cb14b5d442b2b ['6cef8879203010947dae2fccbce29ef157cbc83dcee3ce716da07322a2f996ce', '586147cf635541ce0930e441ab43112c6170f1a1bd5e4892961cb14b5d442b2b', '7a5ee85c91420f1cbb2c08b3c7f20867e8846d52976197d764721e6dcb957956', '6af6aeb091775f483e8cebd06fb8d8988f79c7204748ee0abee8eefee433363a', 'f301a3eb8d0fceffb909b6fbbb0f96741153fe02d5705a74cab611ef9e59bf33', '51ca66249e5731f28331f8db7714014afabeace74bae285fa1369a199f08bad7', '91fc5823dabd2169348ad98ddd941b03f82dfb8a2bf5cd175898b5eb2c9f786c', '1525125d2a710fb92932e5f2bff5dfcd9b9e4d7ddfa205b68b802c1501888d49', '61edd2fa3f5afff23818543bb8d4691cb47348e39d924a483af4fcb48b6f880a', '790dd88ab88c647b7acd94021caf186daf92d383a1c9c7e805d2697ebcf490d2'] A "in order to maximize reuse of 5-tuple based mechanisms, e.g, traceroute, detnet aware applications and end systems should not mix detnet and non-detnet traffic within a single 5-tuple." {56: 1, 67: 1, 102: 1, 13: 1} {141: 1, 200: 1, 295: 1, 223: 1} {295, 200, 171, 141, 223} 62 "As a general rule, DetNet IP domains need to be able to forward any DetNet flow identified by the IP 6-tuple. Doing otherwise would limit end system encapsulation format. From a practical standpoint this means that all nodes along the end-to-end path of DetNet flows need to agree on what fields are used for flow identification, and the transport protocols (e.g., TCP/UDP/IPsec) which can be used to identify 6-tuple protocol ports." As discussed in Nov 28 call 778c768d7d6a73347d014627cc0f8e72210817a9 778c768d7d6a73347d014627cc0f8e72210817a9 draft-ietf-detnet-ip 6af6aeb091775f483e8cebd06fb8d8988f79c7204748ee0abee8eefee433363a ['6cef8879203010947dae2fccbce29ef157cbc83dcee3ce716da07322a2f996ce', '586147cf635541ce0930e441ab43112c6170f1a1bd5e4892961cb14b5d442b2b', '7a5ee85c91420f1cbb2c08b3c7f20867e8846d52976197d764721e6dcb957956', '6af6aeb091775f483e8cebd06fb8d8988f79c7204748ee0abee8eefee433363a', 'f301a3eb8d0fceffb909b6fbbb0f96741153fe02d5705a74cab611ef9e59bf33', '51ca66249e5731f28331f8db7714014afabeace74bae285fa1369a199f08bad7', '91fc5823dabd2169348ad98ddd941b03f82dfb8a2bf5cd175898b5eb2c9f786c', '1525125d2a710fb92932e5f2bff5dfcd9b9e4d7ddfa205b68b802c1501888d49', '61edd2fa3f5afff23818543bb8d4691cb47348e39d924a483af4fcb48b6f880a', '790dd88ab88c647b7acd94021caf186daf92d383a1c9c7e805d2697ebcf490d2'] A "as a general rule, detnet ip domains need to be able to forward any detnet flow identified by the ip 6-tuple. doing otherwise would limit end system encapsulation format. from a practical standpoint this means that all nodes along the end-to-end path of detnet flows need to agree on what fields are used for flow identification, and the transport protocols (e.g., tcp/udp/ipsec) which can be used to identify 6-tuple protocol ports." {56: 1, 67: 1, 102: 1, 13: 1} {141: 1, 200: 1, 295: 1, 223: 1} {295, 200, 171, 141, 223} 62 "Data-flows requiring DetNet service are generated and terminated on end systems. This document deals only with IP end systems. The protocols used by an IP end system are specific to an application, and end systems peer with other end systems. DetNet's use of 6-tuple IP flow identification means that DetNet must be aware of not only the format of the IP header, but also of the next protocol carried within an IP packet (see nxt-proto-field)." As discussed in Nov 28 call 778c768d7d6a73347d014627cc0f8e72210817a9 778c768d7d6a73347d014627cc0f8e72210817a9 draft-ietf-detnet-ip 790dd88ab88c647b7acd94021caf186daf92d383a1c9c7e805d2697ebcf490d2 ['6cef8879203010947dae2fccbce29ef157cbc83dcee3ce716da07322a2f996ce', '586147cf635541ce0930e441ab43112c6170f1a1bd5e4892961cb14b5d442b2b', '7a5ee85c91420f1cbb2c08b3c7f20867e8846d52976197d764721e6dcb957956', '6af6aeb091775f483e8cebd06fb8d8988f79c7204748ee0abee8eefee433363a', 'f301a3eb8d0fceffb909b6fbbb0f96741153fe02d5705a74cab611ef9e59bf33', '51ca66249e5731f28331f8db7714014afabeace74bae285fa1369a199f08bad7', '91fc5823dabd2169348ad98ddd941b03f82dfb8a2bf5cd175898b5eb2c9f786c', '1525125d2a710fb92932e5f2bff5dfcd9b9e4d7ddfa205b68b802c1501888d49', '61edd2fa3f5afff23818543bb8d4691cb47348e39d924a483af4fcb48b6f880a', '790dd88ab88c647b7acd94021caf186daf92d383a1c9c7e805d2697ebcf490d2'] B "data-flows requiring detnet service are generated and terminated on end systems. this document deals only with ip end systems. the protocols used by an ip end system are specific to an application, and end systems peer with other end systems. detnet's use of 6-tuple ip flow identification means that detnet must be aware of not only the format of the ip header, but also of the next protocol carried within an ip packet (see nxt-proto-field)." {56: 1, 67: 1, 102: 1, 13: 1} {141: 1, 200: 1, 295: 1, 223: 1} {295, 200, 171, 141, 223} 62 "When IP end systems are DetNet-aware, no application-level or service-level proxy functions are needed inside the DetNet domain. For DetNet unaware IP end systems service-level proxy functions are needed inside the DetNet domain." As discussed in Nov 28 call 778c768d7d6a73347d014627cc0f8e72210817a9 778c768d7d6a73347d014627cc0f8e72210817a9 draft-ietf-detnet-ip 1525125d2a710fb92932e5f2bff5dfcd9b9e4d7ddfa205b68b802c1501888d49 ['6cef8879203010947dae2fccbce29ef157cbc83dcee3ce716da07322a2f996ce', '586147cf635541ce0930e441ab43112c6170f1a1bd5e4892961cb14b5d442b2b', '7a5ee85c91420f1cbb2c08b3c7f20867e8846d52976197d764721e6dcb957956', '6af6aeb091775f483e8cebd06fb8d8988f79c7204748ee0abee8eefee433363a', 'f301a3eb8d0fceffb909b6fbbb0f96741153fe02d5705a74cab611ef9e59bf33', '51ca66249e5731f28331f8db7714014afabeace74bae285fa1369a199f08bad7', '91fc5823dabd2169348ad98ddd941b03f82dfb8a2bf5cd175898b5eb2c9f786c', '1525125d2a710fb92932e5f2bff5dfcd9b9e4d7ddfa205b68b802c1501888d49', '61edd2fa3f5afff23818543bb8d4691cb47348e39d924a483af4fcb48b6f880a', '790dd88ab88c647b7acd94021caf186daf92d383a1c9c7e805d2697ebcf490d2'] B "when ip end systems are detnet-aware, no application-level or service-level proxy functions are needed inside the detnet domain. for detnet unaware ip end systems service-level proxy functions are needed inside the detnet domain." {56: 1, 67: 1, 102: 1, 13: 1} {141: 1, 200: 1, 295: 1, 223: 1} {295, 200, 171, 141, 223} 62 "End systems need to ensure that DetNet service requirements are met when processing packets associated to a DetNet flow. When forwarding packets, this means that packets are appropriately shaped on transmission and receive appropriate traffic treatment on the connected sub-network, see QoS and dn_dom_spec_cons for more details. When receiving packets, this means that there are appropriate local node resources, e.g., buffers, to receive and process the packets of that DetNet flow." As discussed in Nov 28 call 778c768d7d6a73347d014627cc0f8e72210817a9 778c768d7d6a73347d014627cc0f8e72210817a9 draft-ietf-detnet-ip f301a3eb8d0fceffb909b6fbbb0f96741153fe02d5705a74cab611ef9e59bf33 ['6cef8879203010947dae2fccbce29ef157cbc83dcee3ce716da07322a2f996ce', '586147cf635541ce0930e441ab43112c6170f1a1bd5e4892961cb14b5d442b2b', '7a5ee85c91420f1cbb2c08b3c7f20867e8846d52976197d764721e6dcb957956', '6af6aeb091775f483e8cebd06fb8d8988f79c7204748ee0abee8eefee433363a', 'f301a3eb8d0fceffb909b6fbbb0f96741153fe02d5705a74cab611ef9e59bf33', '51ca66249e5731f28331f8db7714014afabeace74bae285fa1369a199f08bad7', '91fc5823dabd2169348ad98ddd941b03f82dfb8a2bf5cd175898b5eb2c9f786c', '1525125d2a710fb92932e5f2bff5dfcd9b9e4d7ddfa205b68b802c1501888d49', '61edd2fa3f5afff23818543bb8d4691cb47348e39d924a483af4fcb48b6f880a', '790dd88ab88c647b7acd94021caf186daf92d383a1c9c7e805d2697ebcf490d2'] B "end systems need to ensure that detnet service requirements are met when processing packets associated to a detnet flow. when forwarding packets, this means that packets are appropriately shaped on transmission and receive appropriate traffic treatment on the connected sub-network, see qos and dn_dom_spec_cons for more details. when receiving packets, this means that there are appropriate local node resources, e.g., buffers, to receive and process the packets of that detnet flow." {56: 1, 67: 1, 102: 1, 13: 1} {141: 1, 200: 1, 295: 1, 223: 1} {295, 200, 171, 141, 223} 62 "In order to maximize reuse of 5-tuple based mechanisms, e.g, traceroute, DetNet-aware applications and end systems SHOULD NOT mix DetNet and non-DetNet traffic within a single 5-tuple." As discussed in Nov 28 call 778c768d7d6a73347d014627cc0f8e72210817a9 778c768d7d6a73347d014627cc0f8e72210817a9 draft-ietf-detnet-ip 7a5ee85c91420f1cbb2c08b3c7f20867e8846d52976197d764721e6dcb957956 ['6cef8879203010947dae2fccbce29ef157cbc83dcee3ce716da07322a2f996ce', '586147cf635541ce0930e441ab43112c6170f1a1bd5e4892961cb14b5d442b2b', '7a5ee85c91420f1cbb2c08b3c7f20867e8846d52976197d764721e6dcb957956', '6af6aeb091775f483e8cebd06fb8d8988f79c7204748ee0abee8eefee433363a', 'f301a3eb8d0fceffb909b6fbbb0f96741153fe02d5705a74cab611ef9e59bf33', '51ca66249e5731f28331f8db7714014afabeace74bae285fa1369a199f08bad7', '91fc5823dabd2169348ad98ddd941b03f82dfb8a2bf5cd175898b5eb2c9f786c', '1525125d2a710fb92932e5f2bff5dfcd9b9e4d7ddfa205b68b802c1501888d49', '61edd2fa3f5afff23818543bb8d4691cb47348e39d924a483af4fcb48b6f880a', '790dd88ab88c647b7acd94021caf186daf92d383a1c9c7e805d2697ebcf490d2'] B "in order to maximize reuse of 5-tuple based mechanisms, e.g, traceroute, detnet-aware applications and end systems should not mix detnet and non-detnet traffic within a single 5-tuple." {56: 1, 67: 1, 102: 1, 13: 1} {141: 1, 200: 1, 295: 1, 223: 1} {295, 200, 171, 141, 223} 62 "As a general rule, DetNet IP domains need to be able to forward any DetNet flow identified by the IP 6-tuple. Doing otherwise would limit the number of 6-tuple flow ID combinations that could be used by the end systems. From a practical standpoint this means that all nodes along the end-to-end path of DetNet flows need to agree on what fields are used for flow identification, and the transport protocols (e.g., TCP/UDP/IPsec) which can be used to identify 6-tuple protocol ports." As discussed in Nov 28 call 778c768d7d6a73347d014627cc0f8e72210817a9 778c768d7d6a73347d014627cc0f8e72210817a9 draft-ietf-detnet-ip 6cef8879203010947dae2fccbce29ef157cbc83dcee3ce716da07322a2f996ce ['6cef8879203010947dae2fccbce29ef157cbc83dcee3ce716da07322a2f996ce', '586147cf635541ce0930e441ab43112c6170f1a1bd5e4892961cb14b5d442b2b', '7a5ee85c91420f1cbb2c08b3c7f20867e8846d52976197d764721e6dcb957956', '6af6aeb091775f483e8cebd06fb8d8988f79c7204748ee0abee8eefee433363a', 'f301a3eb8d0fceffb909b6fbbb0f96741153fe02d5705a74cab611ef9e59bf33', '51ca66249e5731f28331f8db7714014afabeace74bae285fa1369a199f08bad7', '91fc5823dabd2169348ad98ddd941b03f82dfb8a2bf5cd175898b5eb2c9f786c', '1525125d2a710fb92932e5f2bff5dfcd9b9e4d7ddfa205b68b802c1501888d49', '61edd2fa3f5afff23818543bb8d4691cb47348e39d924a483af4fcb48b6f880a', '790dd88ab88c647b7acd94021caf186daf92d383a1c9c7e805d2697ebcf490d2'] B "as a general rule, detnet ip domains need to be able to forward any detnet flow identified by the ip 6-tuple. doing otherwise would limit the number of 6-tuple flow id combinations that could be used by the end systems. from a practical standpoint this means that all nodes along the end-to-end path of detnet flows need to agree on what fields are used for flow identification, and the transport protocols (e.g., tcp/udp/ipsec) which can be used to identify 6-tuple protocol ports." {56: 1, 67: 1, 102: 1, 13: 1} {141: 1, 200: 1, 295: 1, 223: 1} {295, 200, 171, 141, 223} 62 "Within a DetNet domain, the DetNet enabled IP Routers are interconnected by links and sub-networks to support end-to-end delivery of DetNet flows. From a DetNet architecture perspective, these routers are DetNet relays, as they must be DetNet service aware. Such routers identify DetNet flows based on the IP 6-tuple, and ensure that the DetNet service required traffic treatment is provided both on the node and on any attached sub-network." As discussed in Nov 28 call 778c768d7d6a73347d014627cc0f8e72210817a9 778c768d7d6a73347d014627cc0f8e72210817a9 draft-ietf-detnet-ip 0fb620bfff4797e39e9a464415d6a923a665213722fa4b2caf11d03679f72f2d ['f6f70fe6b65f60320c114bfbcd3b6e1bec5bf3dbe96649a49ec0c212ecb36153', '0fb620bfff4797e39e9a464415d6a923a665213722fa4b2caf11d03679f72f2d'] A "within a detnet domain, the detnet enabled ip routers are interconnected by links and sub-networks to support end-to-end delivery of detnet flows. from a detnet architecture perspective, these routers are detnet relays, as they must be detnet service aware. such routers identify detnet flows based on the ip 6-tuple, and ensure that the detnet service required traffic treatment is provided both on the node and on any attached sub-network." {13: 1, 6: 6, 79: 6, 90: 6, 51: 2, 130: 3, 62: 3, 85: 4, 68: 6, 35: 7, 110: 6, 91: 8, 114: 6, 97: 4, 31: 7, 67: 6, 38: 7, 26: 5, 124: 3, 98: 6, 54: 6, 127: 7, 8: 6, 96: 3, 64: 6, 30: 6, 61: 8, 55: 5, 27: 7, 15: 6, 52: 4, 129: 7, 115: 6, 84: 6, 76: 9, 87: 6, 131: 9, 102: 4, 113: 8, 99: 6, 36: 6, 24: 5, 53: 5, 72: 7} {227: 1, 1: 11, 4: 6, 9: 8, 10: 7, 15: 5, 24: 6, 25: 3, 26: 4, 27: 5, 39: 7, 43: 7, 49: 9, 50: 8, 58: 8, 59: 6, 64: 5, 69: 7, 81: 4, 82: 2, 86: 6, 96: 7, 97: 6, 100: 5, 108: 7, 109: 8, 110: 8, 111: 6, 114: 7, 115: 8, 116: 4, 118: 6, 119: 5, 120: 7, 121: 6, 122: 4, 123: 3, 124: 6, 128: 7, 129: 6, 130: 8, 132: 7, 136: 6, 145: 7, 147: 7, 151: 7, 152: 7, 154: 7, 156: 4, 161: 6, 162: 5, 165: 7, 168: 8, 169: 6, 172: 6, 180: 7, 184: 8, 187: 9, 188: 8, 191: 7, 194: 7, 202: 8, 203: 9, 206: 6, 207: 7, 215: 6, 217: 7, 218: 10, 220: 6, 221: 6, 222: 7, 224: 7, 229: 6, 234: 9, 235: 6, 241: 6, 242: 6, 243: 7, 244: 7, 245: 7, 248: 7, 250: 6, 258: 13, 262: 8, 263: 9, 264: 7, 267: 6, 270: 5, 272: 6, 273: 8, 287: 7, 289: 6, 291: 8, 299: 3, 300: 5, 304: 5, 309: 6, 314: 6, 315: 6, 320: 4, 323: 7, 327: 8, 328: 7, 329: 6, 330: 12, 334: 6, 335: 4, 341: 3, 342: 4, 347: 3, 348: 3, 350: 10, 351: 8, 352: 6, 353: 6, 354: 5, 358: 6, 365: 6, 366: 6, 369: 5, 371: 5, 372: 8, 376: 6, 384: 8, 385: 7, 386: 7, 387: 5, 392: 7, 393: 8, 397: 9, 398: 8, 402: 6} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 62 "Within a DetNet domain, the DetNet-enabled IP Routers are interconnected by links and sub-networks to support end-to-end delivery of DetNet flows. From a DetNet architecture perspective, these routers are DetNet relays, as they must be DetNet service aware. Such routers identify DetNet flows based on the IP 6-tuple, and ensure that the DetNet service required traffic treatment is provided both on the node and on any attached sub-network." As discussed in Nov 28 call 778c768d7d6a73347d014627cc0f8e72210817a9 778c768d7d6a73347d014627cc0f8e72210817a9 draft-ietf-detnet-ip f6f70fe6b65f60320c114bfbcd3b6e1bec5bf3dbe96649a49ec0c212ecb36153 ['f6f70fe6b65f60320c114bfbcd3b6e1bec5bf3dbe96649a49ec0c212ecb36153', '0fb620bfff4797e39e9a464415d6a923a665213722fa4b2caf11d03679f72f2d'] B "within a detnet domain, the detnet-enabled ip routers are interconnected by links and sub-networks to support end-to-end delivery of detnet flows. from a detnet architecture perspective, these routers are detnet relays, as they must be detnet service aware. such routers identify detnet flows based on the ip 6-tuple, and ensure that the detnet service required traffic treatment is provided both on the node and on any attached sub-network." {13: 1, 6: 6, 79: 6, 90: 6, 51: 2, 130: 3, 62: 3, 85: 4, 68: 6, 35: 7, 110: 6, 91: 8, 114: 6, 97: 4, 31: 7, 67: 6, 38: 7, 26: 5, 124: 3, 98: 6, 54: 6, 127: 7, 8: 6, 96: 3, 64: 6, 30: 6, 61: 8, 55: 5, 27: 7, 15: 6, 52: 4, 129: 7, 115: 6, 84: 6, 76: 9, 87: 6, 131: 9, 102: 4, 113: 8, 99: 6, 36: 6, 24: 5, 53: 5, 72: 7} {227: 1, 1: 11, 4: 6, 9: 8, 10: 7, 15: 5, 24: 6, 25: 3, 26: 4, 27: 5, 39: 7, 43: 7, 49: 9, 50: 8, 58: 8, 59: 6, 64: 5, 69: 7, 81: 4, 82: 2, 86: 6, 96: 7, 97: 6, 100: 5, 108: 7, 109: 8, 110: 8, 111: 6, 114: 7, 115: 8, 116: 4, 118: 6, 119: 5, 120: 7, 121: 6, 122: 4, 123: 3, 124: 6, 128: 7, 129: 6, 130: 8, 132: 7, 136: 6, 145: 7, 147: 7, 151: 7, 152: 7, 154: 7, 156: 4, 161: 6, 162: 5, 165: 7, 168: 8, 169: 6, 172: 6, 180: 7, 184: 8, 187: 9, 188: 8, 191: 7, 194: 7, 202: 8, 203: 9, 206: 6, 207: 7, 215: 6, 217: 7, 218: 10, 220: 6, 221: 6, 222: 7, 224: 7, 229: 6, 234: 9, 235: 6, 241: 6, 242: 6, 243: 7, 244: 7, 245: 7, 248: 7, 250: 6, 258: 13, 262: 8, 263: 9, 264: 7, 267: 6, 270: 5, 272: 6, 273: 8, 287: 7, 289: 6, 291: 8, 299: 3, 300: 5, 304: 5, 309: 6, 314: 6, 315: 6, 320: 4, 323: 7, 327: 8, 328: 7, 329: 6, 330: 12, 334: 6, 335: 4, 341: 3, 342: 4, 347: 3, 348: 3, 350: 10, 351: 8, 352: 6, 353: 6, 354: 5, 358: 6, 365: 6, 366: 6, 369: 5, 371: 5, 372: 8, 376: 6, 384: 8, 385: 7, 386: 7, 387: 5, 392: 7, 393: 8, 397: 9, 398: 8, 402: 6} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 62 "This solution provides DetNet functions end to end, but does so on a per link and sub-network basis. Congestion protection and latency control and the resource allocation (queuing, policing, shaping) are supported using the underlying link / sub net specific mechanisms. However, service protections (packet replication and packet elimination functions) are not provided at the DetNet layer end to end. Instead service protection can be provided on a per underlying L2 link and sub-network basis." As discussed in Nov 28 call 778c768d7d6a73347d014627cc0f8e72210817a9 778c768d7d6a73347d014627cc0f8e72210817a9 draft-ietf-detnet-ip b8e6cbf31efd7c78529473fe1b3205e8958b649c56724964b745b8b64b71c888 ['d80ec058522c8cd1260ab4fe31e58a0dad2982c6160fc0431750fcca5967776b', '47d2939b9784c5e5fe0f832035e1b37fe0e55472a4c8631faf69efa998fd99ad', '49ceb4d132b698dd26ed6e731d5ac52b7409063abcff006e4793492e7b6220a4', '719df1cfa31ad2f3dbd1a92e1f407728f380f9d6ed68519e05158dbec210d866', '37fdf4ef81d5a07abaf24a1e6faa6cd17a27a9119aa38540d4c671667ab2c2e4', 'b8e6cbf31efd7c78529473fe1b3205e8958b649c56724964b745b8b64b71c888'] A "this solution provides detnet functions end to end, but does so on a per link and sub-network basis. congestion protection and latency control and the resource allocation (queuing, policing, shaping) are supported using the underlying link / sub net specific mechanisms. however, service protections (packet replication and packet elimination functions) are not provided at the detnet layer end to end. instead service protection can be provided on a per underlying l2 link and sub-network basis." {13: 1, 102: 1, 6: 6, 79: 6, 90: 6, 51: 2, 130: 3, 62: 3, 85: 4, 68: 6, 35: 7, 110: 6, 91: 8, 114: 6, 97: 4, 31: 7, 67: 6, 38: 7, 26: 5, 124: 3, 98: 6, 54: 6, 127: 7, 8: 6, 96: 3, 64: 6, 30: 6, 61: 8, 55: 5, 27: 7, 15: 6, 52: 4, 129: 7, 115: 6, 84: 6, 76: 9, 87: 6, 131: 9, 113: 8, 99: 6, 36: 6, 24: 5, 53: 5, 72: 7} {100: 1, 341: 1, 371: 1, 1: 11, 4: 6, 9: 8, 10: 7, 15: 5, 24: 6, 25: 3, 26: 4, 27: 5, 39: 7, 43: 7, 49: 9, 50: 8, 58: 8, 59: 6, 64: 5, 69: 7, 81: 4, 82: 2, 86: 6, 96: 7, 97: 6, 108: 7, 109: 8, 110: 8, 111: 6, 114: 7, 115: 8, 116: 4, 118: 6, 119: 5, 120: 7, 121: 6, 122: 4, 123: 3, 124: 6, 128: 7, 129: 6, 130: 8, 132: 7, 136: 6, 145: 7, 147: 7, 151: 7, 152: 7, 154: 7, 156: 4, 161: 6, 162: 5, 165: 7, 168: 8, 169: 6, 172: 6, 180: 7, 184: 8, 187: 9, 188: 8, 191: 7, 194: 7, 202: 8, 203: 9, 206: 6, 207: 7, 215: 6, 217: 7, 218: 10, 220: 6, 221: 6, 222: 7, 224: 7, 227: 3, 229: 6, 234: 9, 235: 6, 241: 6, 242: 6, 243: 7, 244: 7, 245: 7, 248: 7, 250: 6, 258: 13, 262: 8, 263: 9, 264: 7, 267: 6, 270: 5, 272: 6, 273: 8, 287: 7, 289: 6, 291: 8, 299: 3, 300: 5, 304: 5, 309: 6, 314: 6, 315: 6, 320: 4, 323: 7, 327: 8, 328: 7, 329: 6, 330: 12, 334: 6, 335: 4, 347: 3, 348: 3, 350: 10, 351: 8, 352: 6, 353: 6, 354: 5, 358: 6, 365: 6, 366: 6, 369: 5, 372: 8, 376: 6, 384: 8, 385: 7, 386: 7, 387: 5, 392: 7, 393: 8, 396: 4, 397: 9, 398: 8, 402: 6} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 62 "The DetNet Service Flow is mapped to the link / sub-network specific resources using an underlying system specific means. This implies each DetNet aware node on path looks into the forwarded DetNet Service Flow packet and utilize e.g., a 6-tuple to find out the required mapping within a node." As discussed in Nov 28 call 778c768d7d6a73347d014627cc0f8e72210817a9 778c768d7d6a73347d014627cc0f8e72210817a9 draft-ietf-detnet-ip d80ec058522c8cd1260ab4fe31e58a0dad2982c6160fc0431750fcca5967776b ['d80ec058522c8cd1260ab4fe31e58a0dad2982c6160fc0431750fcca5967776b', '47d2939b9784c5e5fe0f832035e1b37fe0e55472a4c8631faf69efa998fd99ad', '49ceb4d132b698dd26ed6e731d5ac52b7409063abcff006e4793492e7b6220a4', '719df1cfa31ad2f3dbd1a92e1f407728f380f9d6ed68519e05158dbec210d866', '37fdf4ef81d5a07abaf24a1e6faa6cd17a27a9119aa38540d4c671667ab2c2e4', 'b8e6cbf31efd7c78529473fe1b3205e8958b649c56724964b745b8b64b71c888'] A "the detnet service flow is mapped to the link / sub-network specific resources using an underlying system specific means. this implies each detnet aware node on path looks into the forwarded detnet service flow packet and utilize e.g., a 6-tuple to find out the required mapping within a node." {13: 1, 102: 1, 6: 6, 79: 6, 90: 6, 51: 2, 130: 3, 62: 3, 85: 4, 68: 6, 35: 7, 110: 6, 91: 8, 114: 6, 97: 4, 31: 7, 67: 6, 38: 7, 26: 5, 124: 3, 98: 6, 54: 6, 127: 7, 8: 6, 96: 3, 64: 6, 30: 6, 61: 8, 55: 5, 27: 7, 15: 6, 52: 4, 129: 7, 115: 6, 84: 6, 76: 9, 87: 6, 131: 9, 113: 8, 99: 6, 36: 6, 24: 5, 53: 5, 72: 7} {100: 1, 341: 1, 371: 1, 1: 11, 4: 6, 9: 8, 10: 7, 15: 5, 24: 6, 25: 3, 26: 4, 27: 5, 39: 7, 43: 7, 49: 9, 50: 8, 58: 8, 59: 6, 64: 5, 69: 7, 81: 4, 82: 2, 86: 6, 96: 7, 97: 6, 108: 7, 109: 8, 110: 8, 111: 6, 114: 7, 115: 8, 116: 4, 118: 6, 119: 5, 120: 7, 121: 6, 122: 4, 123: 3, 124: 6, 128: 7, 129: 6, 130: 8, 132: 7, 136: 6, 145: 7, 147: 7, 151: 7, 152: 7, 154: 7, 156: 4, 161: 6, 162: 5, 165: 7, 168: 8, 169: 6, 172: 6, 180: 7, 184: 8, 187: 9, 188: 8, 191: 7, 194: 7, 202: 8, 203: 9, 206: 6, 207: 7, 215: 6, 217: 7, 218: 10, 220: 6, 221: 6, 222: 7, 224: 7, 227: 3, 229: 6, 234: 9, 235: 6, 241: 6, 242: 6, 243: 7, 244: 7, 245: 7, 248: 7, 250: 6, 258: 13, 262: 8, 263: 9, 264: 7, 267: 6, 270: 5, 272: 6, 273: 8, 287: 7, 289: 6, 291: 8, 299: 3, 300: 5, 304: 5, 309: 6, 314: 6, 315: 6, 320: 4, 323: 7, 327: 8, 328: 7, 329: 6, 330: 12, 334: 6, 335: 4, 347: 3, 348: 3, 350: 10, 351: 8, 352: 6, 353: 6, 354: 5, 358: 6, 365: 6, 366: 6, 369: 5, 372: 8, 376: 6, 384: 8, 385: 7, 386: 7, 387: 5, 392: 7, 393: 8, 396: 4, 397: 9, 398: 8, 402: 6} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 62 "As noted earlier, the Service Protection is done within each link / sub-network independently using the domain specific mechanisms (due the lack of a unified end to end sequencing information that would be available for intermediate nodes). Therefore, service protection (if enabled) cannot be provided end-to-end, only within sub-networks. This is shown for a three sub-network scenario in fig_pref_in_subnets, where each sub-network can provide service protection between its borders. ""R"" and ""E"" denotes replication and elimination points within the sub-network." As discussed in Nov 28 call 778c768d7d6a73347d014627cc0f8e72210817a9 778c768d7d6a73347d014627cc0f8e72210817a9 draft-ietf-detnet-ip 49ceb4d132b698dd26ed6e731d5ac52b7409063abcff006e4793492e7b6220a4 ['d80ec058522c8cd1260ab4fe31e58a0dad2982c6160fc0431750fcca5967776b', '47d2939b9784c5e5fe0f832035e1b37fe0e55472a4c8631faf69efa998fd99ad', '49ceb4d132b698dd26ed6e731d5ac52b7409063abcff006e4793492e7b6220a4', '719df1cfa31ad2f3dbd1a92e1f407728f380f9d6ed68519e05158dbec210d866', '37fdf4ef81d5a07abaf24a1e6faa6cd17a27a9119aa38540d4c671667ab2c2e4', 'b8e6cbf31efd7c78529473fe1b3205e8958b649c56724964b745b8b64b71c888'] A "as noted earlier, the service protection is done within each link / sub-network independently using the domain specific mechanisms (due the lack of a unified end to end sequencing information that would be available for intermediate nodes). therefore, service protection (if enabled) cannot be provided end-to-end, only within sub-networks. this is shown for a three sub-network scenario in fig_pref_in_subnets, where each sub-network can provide service protection between its borders. ""r"" and ""e"" denotes replication and elimination points within the sub-network." {13: 1, 102: 1, 6: 6, 79: 6, 90: 6, 51: 2, 130: 3, 62: 3, 85: 4, 68: 6, 35: 7, 110: 6, 91: 8, 114: 6, 97: 4, 31: 7, 67: 6, 38: 7, 26: 5, 124: 3, 98: 6, 54: 6, 127: 7, 8: 6, 96: 3, 64: 6, 30: 6, 61: 8, 55: 5, 27: 7, 15: 6, 52: 4, 129: 7, 115: 6, 84: 6, 76: 9, 87: 6, 131: 9, 113: 8, 99: 6, 36: 6, 24: 5, 53: 5, 72: 7} {100: 1, 341: 1, 371: 1, 1: 11, 4: 6, 9: 8, 10: 7, 15: 5, 24: 6, 25: 3, 26: 4, 27: 5, 39: 7, 43: 7, 49: 9, 50: 8, 58: 8, 59: 6, 64: 5, 69: 7, 81: 4, 82: 2, 86: 6, 96: 7, 97: 6, 108: 7, 109: 8, 110: 8, 111: 6, 114: 7, 115: 8, 116: 4, 118: 6, 119: 5, 120: 7, 121: 6, 122: 4, 123: 3, 124: 6, 128: 7, 129: 6, 130: 8, 132: 7, 136: 6, 145: 7, 147: 7, 151: 7, 152: 7, 154: 7, 156: 4, 161: 6, 162: 5, 165: 7, 168: 8, 169: 6, 172: 6, 180: 7, 184: 8, 187: 9, 188: 8, 191: 7, 194: 7, 202: 8, 203: 9, 206: 6, 207: 7, 215: 6, 217: 7, 218: 10, 220: 6, 221: 6, 222: 7, 224: 7, 227: 3, 229: 6, 234: 9, 235: 6, 241: 6, 242: 6, 243: 7, 244: 7, 245: 7, 248: 7, 250: 6, 258: 13, 262: 8, 263: 9, 264: 7, 267: 6, 270: 5, 272: 6, 273: 8, 287: 7, 289: 6, 291: 8, 299: 3, 300: 5, 304: 5, 309: 6, 314: 6, 315: 6, 320: 4, 323: 7, 327: 8, 328: 7, 329: 6, 330: 12, 334: 6, 335: 4, 347: 3, 348: 3, 350: 10, 351: 8, 352: 6, 353: 6, 354: 5, 358: 6, 365: 6, 366: 6, 369: 5, 372: 8, 376: 6, 384: 8, 385: 7, 386: 7, 387: 5, 392: 7, 393: 8, 396: 4, 397: 9, 398: 8, 402: 6} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 62 "This solution provides DetNet functions end to end, but does so on a per link and sub-network basis. Congestion protection and latency control and the resource allocation (queuing, policing, shaping) are supported using the underlying link / sub net specific mechanisms. However, service protection (packet replication and packet elimination functions) is not provided at the DetNet layer end to end. Instead service protection can be provided on a per underlying L2 link and sub-network basis." As discussed in Nov 28 call 778c768d7d6a73347d014627cc0f8e72210817a9 778c768d7d6a73347d014627cc0f8e72210817a9 draft-ietf-detnet-ip 719df1cfa31ad2f3dbd1a92e1f407728f380f9d6ed68519e05158dbec210d866 ['d80ec058522c8cd1260ab4fe31e58a0dad2982c6160fc0431750fcca5967776b', '47d2939b9784c5e5fe0f832035e1b37fe0e55472a4c8631faf69efa998fd99ad', '49ceb4d132b698dd26ed6e731d5ac52b7409063abcff006e4793492e7b6220a4', '719df1cfa31ad2f3dbd1a92e1f407728f380f9d6ed68519e05158dbec210d866', '37fdf4ef81d5a07abaf24a1e6faa6cd17a27a9119aa38540d4c671667ab2c2e4', 'b8e6cbf31efd7c78529473fe1b3205e8958b649c56724964b745b8b64b71c888'] B "this solution provides detnet functions end to end, but does so on a per link and sub-network basis. congestion protection and latency control and the resource allocation (queuing, policing, shaping) are supported using the underlying link / sub net specific mechanisms. however, service protection (packet replication and packet elimination functions) is not provided at the detnet layer end to end. instead service protection can be provided on a per underlying l2 link and sub-network basis." {13: 1, 102: 1, 6: 6, 79: 6, 90: 6, 51: 2, 130: 3, 62: 3, 85: 4, 68: 6, 35: 7, 110: 6, 91: 8, 114: 6, 97: 4, 31: 7, 67: 6, 38: 7, 26: 5, 124: 3, 98: 6, 54: 6, 127: 7, 8: 6, 96: 3, 64: 6, 30: 6, 61: 8, 55: 5, 27: 7, 15: 6, 52: 4, 129: 7, 115: 6, 84: 6, 76: 9, 87: 6, 131: 9, 113: 8, 99: 6, 36: 6, 24: 5, 53: 5, 72: 7} {100: 1, 341: 1, 371: 1, 1: 11, 4: 6, 9: 8, 10: 7, 15: 5, 24: 6, 25: 3, 26: 4, 27: 5, 39: 7, 43: 7, 49: 9, 50: 8, 58: 8, 59: 6, 64: 5, 69: 7, 81: 4, 82: 2, 86: 6, 96: 7, 97: 6, 108: 7, 109: 8, 110: 8, 111: 6, 114: 7, 115: 8, 116: 4, 118: 6, 119: 5, 120: 7, 121: 6, 122: 4, 123: 3, 124: 6, 128: 7, 129: 6, 130: 8, 132: 7, 136: 6, 145: 7, 147: 7, 151: 7, 152: 7, 154: 7, 156: 4, 161: 6, 162: 5, 165: 7, 168: 8, 169: 6, 172: 6, 180: 7, 184: 8, 187: 9, 188: 8, 191: 7, 194: 7, 202: 8, 203: 9, 206: 6, 207: 7, 215: 6, 217: 7, 218: 10, 220: 6, 221: 6, 222: 7, 224: 7, 227: 3, 229: 6, 234: 9, 235: 6, 241: 6, 242: 6, 243: 7, 244: 7, 245: 7, 248: 7, 250: 6, 258: 13, 262: 8, 263: 9, 264: 7, 267: 6, 270: 5, 272: 6, 273: 8, 287: 7, 289: 6, 291: 8, 299: 3, 300: 5, 304: 5, 309: 6, 314: 6, 315: 6, 320: 4, 323: 7, 327: 8, 328: 7, 329: 6, 330: 12, 334: 6, 335: 4, 347: 3, 348: 3, 350: 10, 351: 8, 352: 6, 353: 6, 354: 5, 358: 6, 365: 6, 366: 6, 369: 5, 372: 8, 376: 6, 384: 8, 385: 7, 386: 7, 387: 5, 392: 7, 393: 8, 396: 4, 397: 9, 398: 8, 402: 6} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 62 "The DetNet Service Flow is mapped to the link / sub-network specific resources using an underlying system-specific means. This implies each DetNet-aware node on path looks into the forwarded DetNet Service Flow packet and utilize e.g., a 6-tuple to find out the required mapping within a node." As discussed in Nov 28 call 778c768d7d6a73347d014627cc0f8e72210817a9 778c768d7d6a73347d014627cc0f8e72210817a9 draft-ietf-detnet-ip 37fdf4ef81d5a07abaf24a1e6faa6cd17a27a9119aa38540d4c671667ab2c2e4 ['d80ec058522c8cd1260ab4fe31e58a0dad2982c6160fc0431750fcca5967776b', '47d2939b9784c5e5fe0f832035e1b37fe0e55472a4c8631faf69efa998fd99ad', '49ceb4d132b698dd26ed6e731d5ac52b7409063abcff006e4793492e7b6220a4', '719df1cfa31ad2f3dbd1a92e1f407728f380f9d6ed68519e05158dbec210d866', '37fdf4ef81d5a07abaf24a1e6faa6cd17a27a9119aa38540d4c671667ab2c2e4', 'b8e6cbf31efd7c78529473fe1b3205e8958b649c56724964b745b8b64b71c888'] B "the detnet service flow is mapped to the link / sub-network specific resources using an underlying system-specific means. this implies each detnet-aware node on path looks into the forwarded detnet service flow packet and utilize e.g., a 6-tuple to find out the required mapping within a node." {13: 1, 102: 1, 6: 6, 79: 6, 90: 6, 51: 2, 130: 3, 62: 3, 85: 4, 68: 6, 35: 7, 110: 6, 91: 8, 114: 6, 97: 4, 31: 7, 67: 6, 38: 7, 26: 5, 124: 3, 98: 6, 54: 6, 127: 7, 8: 6, 96: 3, 64: 6, 30: 6, 61: 8, 55: 5, 27: 7, 15: 6, 52: 4, 129: 7, 115: 6, 84: 6, 76: 9, 87: 6, 131: 9, 113: 8, 99: 6, 36: 6, 24: 5, 53: 5, 72: 7} {100: 1, 341: 1, 371: 1, 1: 11, 4: 6, 9: 8, 10: 7, 15: 5, 24: 6, 25: 3, 26: 4, 27: 5, 39: 7, 43: 7, 49: 9, 50: 8, 58: 8, 59: 6, 64: 5, 69: 7, 81: 4, 82: 2, 86: 6, 96: 7, 97: 6, 108: 7, 109: 8, 110: 8, 111: 6, 114: 7, 115: 8, 116: 4, 118: 6, 119: 5, 120: 7, 121: 6, 122: 4, 123: 3, 124: 6, 128: 7, 129: 6, 130: 8, 132: 7, 136: 6, 145: 7, 147: 7, 151: 7, 152: 7, 154: 7, 156: 4, 161: 6, 162: 5, 165: 7, 168: 8, 169: 6, 172: 6, 180: 7, 184: 8, 187: 9, 188: 8, 191: 7, 194: 7, 202: 8, 203: 9, 206: 6, 207: 7, 215: 6, 217: 7, 218: 10, 220: 6, 221: 6, 222: 7, 224: 7, 227: 3, 229: 6, 234: 9, 235: 6, 241: 6, 242: 6, 243: 7, 244: 7, 245: 7, 248: 7, 250: 6, 258: 13, 262: 8, 263: 9, 264: 7, 267: 6, 270: 5, 272: 6, 273: 8, 287: 7, 289: 6, 291: 8, 299: 3, 300: 5, 304: 5, 309: 6, 314: 6, 315: 6, 320: 4, 323: 7, 327: 8, 328: 7, 329: 6, 330: 12, 334: 6, 335: 4, 347: 3, 348: 3, 350: 10, 351: 8, 352: 6, 353: 6, 354: 5, 358: 6, 365: 6, 366: 6, 369: 5, 372: 8, 376: 6, 384: 8, 385: 7, 386: 7, 387: 5, 392: 7, 393: 8, 396: 4, 397: 9, 398: 8, 402: 6} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 62 "As noted earlier, service protection must be implemented within each link / sub-network independently, using the domain specific mechanisms. This is due to the lack of unified end-to-end sequencing information that could be used by the intermediate nodes. Therefore, service protection (if enabled) cannot be provided end-to-end, only within sub-networks. This is shown for a three sub-network scenario in fig_pref_in_subnets, where each sub-network can provide service protection between its borders. ""R"" and ""E"" denotes replication and elimination points within the sub-network." As discussed in Nov 28 call 778c768d7d6a73347d014627cc0f8e72210817a9 778c768d7d6a73347d014627cc0f8e72210817a9 draft-ietf-detnet-ip 47d2939b9784c5e5fe0f832035e1b37fe0e55472a4c8631faf69efa998fd99ad ['d80ec058522c8cd1260ab4fe31e58a0dad2982c6160fc0431750fcca5967776b', '47d2939b9784c5e5fe0f832035e1b37fe0e55472a4c8631faf69efa998fd99ad', '49ceb4d132b698dd26ed6e731d5ac52b7409063abcff006e4793492e7b6220a4', '719df1cfa31ad2f3dbd1a92e1f407728f380f9d6ed68519e05158dbec210d866', '37fdf4ef81d5a07abaf24a1e6faa6cd17a27a9119aa38540d4c671667ab2c2e4', 'b8e6cbf31efd7c78529473fe1b3205e8958b649c56724964b745b8b64b71c888'] B "as noted earlier, service protection must be implemented within each link / sub-network independently, using the domain specific mechanisms. this is due to the lack of unified end-to-end sequencing information that could be used by the intermediate nodes. therefore, service protection (if enabled) cannot be provided end-to-end, only within sub-networks. this is shown for a three sub-network scenario in fig_pref_in_subnets, where each sub-network can provide service protection between its borders. ""r"" and ""e"" denotes replication and elimination points within the sub-network." {13: 1, 102: 1, 6: 6, 79: 6, 90: 6, 51: 2, 130: 3, 62: 3, 85: 4, 68: 6, 35: 7, 110: 6, 91: 8, 114: 6, 97: 4, 31: 7, 67: 6, 38: 7, 26: 5, 124: 3, 98: 6, 54: 6, 127: 7, 8: 6, 96: 3, 64: 6, 30: 6, 61: 8, 55: 5, 27: 7, 15: 6, 52: 4, 129: 7, 115: 6, 84: 6, 76: 9, 87: 6, 131: 9, 113: 8, 99: 6, 36: 6, 24: 5, 53: 5, 72: 7} {100: 1, 341: 1, 371: 1, 1: 11, 4: 6, 9: 8, 10: 7, 15: 5, 24: 6, 25: 3, 26: 4, 27: 5, 39: 7, 43: 7, 49: 9, 50: 8, 58: 8, 59: 6, 64: 5, 69: 7, 81: 4, 82: 2, 86: 6, 96: 7, 97: 6, 108: 7, 109: 8, 110: 8, 111: 6, 114: 7, 115: 8, 116: 4, 118: 6, 119: 5, 120: 7, 121: 6, 122: 4, 123: 3, 124: 6, 128: 7, 129: 6, 130: 8, 132: 7, 136: 6, 145: 7, 147: 7, 151: 7, 152: 7, 154: 7, 156: 4, 161: 6, 162: 5, 165: 7, 168: 8, 169: 6, 172: 6, 180: 7, 184: 8, 187: 9, 188: 8, 191: 7, 194: 7, 202: 8, 203: 9, 206: 6, 207: 7, 215: 6, 217: 7, 218: 10, 220: 6, 221: 6, 222: 7, 224: 7, 227: 3, 229: 6, 234: 9, 235: 6, 241: 6, 242: 6, 243: 7, 244: 7, 245: 7, 248: 7, 250: 6, 258: 13, 262: 8, 263: 9, 264: 7, 267: 6, 270: 5, 272: 6, 273: 8, 287: 7, 289: 6, 291: 8, 299: 3, 300: 5, 304: 5, 309: 6, 314: 6, 315: 6, 320: 4, 323: 7, 327: 8, 328: 7, 329: 6, 330: 12, 334: 6, 335: 4, 347: 3, 348: 3, 350: 10, 351: 8, 352: 6, 353: 6, 354: 5, 358: 6, 365: 6, 366: 6, 369: 5, 372: 8, 376: 6, 384: 8, 385: 7, 386: 7, 387: 5, 392: 7, 393: 8, 396: 4, 397: 9, 398: 8, 402: 6} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 62 "Note that not mixing DetNet and non-DetNet traffic within a single 5-tuple, as described above, enables simpler 5-tuple filters to be reused at the edges of a DetNet network to prevent non-congestion responsive DetNet traffic from escaping the DetNet domain." As discussed in Nov 28 call 778c768d7d6a73347d014627cc0f8e72210817a9 778c768d7d6a73347d014627cc0f8e72210817a9 draft-ietf-detnet-ip 3360a796437e0afeabb77c2572808eac8dd92be3ecd12723c545de974ab208bf ['3360a796437e0afeabb77c2572808eac8dd92be3ecd12723c545de974ab208bf', '3ee6be65c8a87c1022068bfd70338e14525fc4aa42f2688ed4c70c1a39d77a8f'] A "note that not mixing detnet and non-detnet traffic within a single 5-tuple, as described above, enables simpler 5-tuple filters to be reused at the edges of a detnet network to prevent non-congestion responsive detnet traffic from escaping the detnet domain." {56: 1} {72: 1} {72, 73} 62 "Note that not mixing DetNet and non-DetNet traffic within a single 5-tuple, as described above, enables simpler 5-tuple filters to be used (or re-used) at the edges of a DetNet network to prevent non- congestion-responsive DetNet traffic from escaping the DetNet domain." As discussed in Nov 28 call 778c768d7d6a73347d014627cc0f8e72210817a9 778c768d7d6a73347d014627cc0f8e72210817a9 draft-ietf-detnet-ip 3ee6be65c8a87c1022068bfd70338e14525fc4aa42f2688ed4c70c1a39d77a8f ['3360a796437e0afeabb77c2572808eac8dd92be3ecd12723c545de974ab208bf', '3ee6be65c8a87c1022068bfd70338e14525fc4aa42f2688ed4c70c1a39d77a8f'] B "note that not mixing detnet and non-detnet traffic within a single 5-tuple, as described above, enables simpler 5-tuple filters to be used (or re-used) at the edges of a detnet network to prevent non- congestion-responsive detnet traffic from escaping the detnet domain." {56: 1} {72: 1} {72, 73} 62 "One additional consideration for DetNet nodes which support CoS services is that they MUST ensure that the CoS service classes do not impact the congestion protection and latency control mechanisms used to provide DetNet QoS. This requirement is similar to requirement for MPLS LSRs to that CoS LSPs do not impact the resources allocated to TE LSPs via RFC3473." As discussed in Nov 28 call 778c768d7d6a73347d014627cc0f8e72210817a9 778c768d7d6a73347d014627cc0f8e72210817a9 draft-ietf-detnet-ip 5b53faab4c3dd03781cf62b38a327e2ec2c1db2f2cb36be8d1c6310896b4d57b ['48dc514f47e22346431f306e3771e45cc990b71d6433b97d8254e08bad267c19', '5b53faab4c3dd03781cf62b38a327e2ec2c1db2f2cb36be8d1c6310896b4d57b'] A "one additional consideration for detnet nodes which support cos services is that they must ensure that the cos service classes do not impact the congestion protection and latency control mechanisms used to provide detnet qos. this requirement is similar to requirement for mpls lsrs to that cos lsps do not impact the resources allocated to te lsps via rfc3473." {} {} {} 62 "One additional consideration for DetNet nodes which support CoS services is that they MUST ensure that the CoS service classes do not impact the congestion protection and latency control mechanisms used to provide DetNet QoS. This requirement is similar to the requirement for MPLS LSRs that CoS LSPs cannot impact the resources allocated to TE LSPs RFC3473." As discussed in Nov 28 call 778c768d7d6a73347d014627cc0f8e72210817a9 778c768d7d6a73347d014627cc0f8e72210817a9 draft-ietf-detnet-ip 48dc514f47e22346431f306e3771e45cc990b71d6433b97d8254e08bad267c19 ['48dc514f47e22346431f306e3771e45cc990b71d6433b97d8254e08bad267c19', '5b53faab4c3dd03781cf62b38a327e2ec2c1db2f2cb36be8d1c6310896b4d57b'] B "one additional consideration for detnet nodes which support cos services is that they must ensure that the cos service classes do not impact the congestion protection and latency control mechanisms used to provide detnet qos. this requirement is similar to the requirement for mpls lsrs that cos lsps cannot impact the resources allocated to te lsps rfc3473." {} {} {} 62 "In non-DetNet IP forwarding, it is generally assumed that the same series of next hops, i.e., the same path, will be used for a particular 5-tuple or, in some cases, e.g., RFC5120, for a particular 6-tuple. Using different next hops for different 5-tuples does not take any special consideration for DetNet aware applications." As discussed in Nov 28 call 778c768d7d6a73347d014627cc0f8e72210817a9 778c768d7d6a73347d014627cc0f8e72210817a9 draft-ietf-detnet-ip e785c312c8f6fcb8cc39fabe2da9eab3a234620125e2a92de07cd181c9115a85 ['e785c312c8f6fcb8cc39fabe2da9eab3a234620125e2a92de07cd181c9115a85', '3443017252178e4422ee375742d1bc844165961d5994fe36b104af38e4d09d34'] A "in non-detnet ip forwarding, it is generally assumed that the same series of next hops, i.e., the same path, will be used for a particular 5-tuple or, in some cases, e.g., rfc5120, for a particular 6-tuple. using different next hops for different 5-tuples does not take any special consideration for detnet aware applications." {56: 1, 102: 2, 60: 2} {80: 1, 79: 2, 382: 3, 383: 2} {367, 80, 79, 382, 383} 62 "In non-DetNet IP forwarding, it is generally assumed that the same series of next hops, i.e., the same path, will be used for a particular 5-tuple or, in some cases, e.g., RFC5120, for a particular 6-tuple. Using different next hops for different 5-tuples does not take any special consideration for DetNet-aware applications." As discussed in Nov 28 call 778c768d7d6a73347d014627cc0f8e72210817a9 778c768d7d6a73347d014627cc0f8e72210817a9 draft-ietf-detnet-ip 3443017252178e4422ee375742d1bc844165961d5994fe36b104af38e4d09d34 ['e785c312c8f6fcb8cc39fabe2da9eab3a234620125e2a92de07cd181c9115a85', '3443017252178e4422ee375742d1bc844165961d5994fe36b104af38e4d09d34'] B "in non-detnet ip forwarding, it is generally assumed that the same series of next hops, i.e., the same path, will be used for a particular 5-tuple or, in some cases, e.g., rfc5120, for a particular 6-tuple. using different next hops for different 5-tuples does not take any special consideration for detnet-aware applications." {56: 1, 102: 2, 60: 2} {80: 1, 79: 2, 382: 3, 383: 2} {367, 80, 79, 382, 383} 62 "From a single node perspective, the aggregation of IP flows impacts DetNet IP data plane flow identification and resource allocation. As discussed above, IP flow identification uses the IP ""6-tuple"" for flow identification. DetNet IP flows can be aggregated using any of the 6-tuple, and an additional optional field defined in ip-flow-id. The use of prefixes, wildcards, lists, and value ranges allows a DetNet node to identify aggregate DetNet flows. From a resource allocation perspective, DetNet nodes must provide service to a aggregate and not on a component flow basis." As discussed in Nov 28 call 778c768d7d6a73347d014627cc0f8e72210817a9 778c768d7d6a73347d014627cc0f8e72210817a9 draft-ietf-detnet-ip e84c5b6e05a6fa9cbdd775a416d6c49eca61fba924566ead4bad4ce464efa0d4 ['e84c5b6e05a6fa9cbdd775a416d6c49eca61fba924566ead4bad4ce464efa0d4', '022dbf3e563362d3bccd8237bc1e6bd94ea908b9e7f290e48813addfb360b444'] A "from a single node perspective, the aggregation of ip flows impacts detnet ip data plane flow identification and resource allocation. as discussed above, ip flow identification uses the ip ""6-tuple"" for flow identification. detnet ip flows can be aggregated using any of the 6-tuple, and an additional optional field defined in ip-flow-id. the use of prefixes, wildcards, lists, and value ranges allows a detnet node to identify aggregate detnet flows. from a resource allocation perspective, detnet nodes must provide service to a aggregate and not on a component flow basis." {60: 1, 85: 1, 26: 3, 27: 4, 102: 2, 13: 4, 56: 2} {52: 1, 246: 1, 160: 3, 259: 4, 359: 2, 284: 4, 159: 2} {160, 259, 359, 370, 52, 246, 284, 159} 62 "From a single node perspective, the aggregation of IP flows impacts DetNet IP data plane flow identification and resource allocation. As discussed above, IP flow identification uses the IP ""6-tuple"" for flow identification. DetNet IP flows can be aggregated using any of the 6-tuple, and an additional optional field defined in ip-flow-id. The use of prefixes, wildcards, lists, and value ranges allows a DetNet node to identify aggregate DetNet flows. From a resource allocation perspective, DetNet nodes must provide service to an aggregate and not on a component flow basis." As discussed in Nov 28 call 778c768d7d6a73347d014627cc0f8e72210817a9 778c768d7d6a73347d014627cc0f8e72210817a9 draft-ietf-detnet-ip 022dbf3e563362d3bccd8237bc1e6bd94ea908b9e7f290e48813addfb360b444 ['e84c5b6e05a6fa9cbdd775a416d6c49eca61fba924566ead4bad4ce464efa0d4', '022dbf3e563362d3bccd8237bc1e6bd94ea908b9e7f290e48813addfb360b444'] B "from a single node perspective, the aggregation of ip flows impacts detnet ip data plane flow identification and resource allocation. as discussed above, ip flow identification uses the ip ""6-tuple"" for flow identification. detnet ip flows can be aggregated using any of the 6-tuple, and an additional optional field defined in ip-flow-id. the use of prefixes, wildcards, lists, and value ranges allows a detnet node to identify aggregate detnet flows. from a resource allocation perspective, detnet nodes must provide service to an aggregate and not on a component flow basis." {60: 1, 85: 1, 26: 3, 27: 4, 102: 2, 13: 4, 56: 2} {52: 1, 246: 1, 160: 3, 259: 4, 359: 2, 284: 4, 159: 2} {160, 259, 359, 370, 52, 246, 284, 159} 62 "IP and higher layer protocol header information is used to identify DetNet flows. All DetNet implementations that support this document MUST identify individual DetNet flows based on the set of information identified in this section. Note, that additional flow identification requirements, e.g., to support other higher layer protocols, may be defined in future." As discussed in Nov 28 call 778c768d7d6a73347d014627cc0f8e72210817a9 778c768d7d6a73347d014627cc0f8e72210817a9 draft-ietf-detnet-ip 589b1a19bc398a4f053c2ce7749d7c70a7596f1a182ec12825fd561818879967 ['589b1a19bc398a4f053c2ce7749d7c70a7596f1a182ec12825fd561818879967', 'a119f79d1148b82bf1517d5da4f0e33704e230b3daddffd57220117fc3d03bb9'] A "ip and higher layer protocol header information is used to identify detnet flows. all detnet implementations that support this document must identify individual detnet flows based on the set of information identified in this section. note, that additional flow identification requirements, e.g., to support other higher layer protocols, may be defined in future." {102: 1} {297: 1} {297, 143} 62 "IP and higher layer protocol header information is used to identify DetNet flows. All DetNet implementations that support this document MUST identify individual DetNet flows based on the set of information identified in this section. Note, that additional flow identification requirements, e.g., to support other higher layer protocols, may be defined in the future." As discussed in Nov 28 call 778c768d7d6a73347d014627cc0f8e72210817a9 778c768d7d6a73347d014627cc0f8e72210817a9 draft-ietf-detnet-ip a119f79d1148b82bf1517d5da4f0e33704e230b3daddffd57220117fc3d03bb9 ['589b1a19bc398a4f053c2ce7749d7c70a7596f1a182ec12825fd561818879967', 'a119f79d1148b82bf1517d5da4f0e33704e230b3daddffd57220117fc3d03bb9'] B "ip and higher layer protocol header information is used to identify detnet flows. all detnet implementations that support this document must identify individual detnet flows based on the set of information identified in this section. note, that additional flow identification requirements, e.g., to support other higher layer protocols, may be defined in the future." {102: 1} {297: 1} {297, 143} 62 "Implementations of this document MUST support DetNet flow identification when the implementation is acting as a DetNet end systems, a relay node or as an edge node." As discussed in Nov 28 call 778c768d7d6a73347d014627cc0f8e72210817a9 778c768d7d6a73347d014627cc0f8e72210817a9 draft-ietf-detnet-ip f3becb9b56f737d3494ca4c1d37acec5150ee9a34cadedceda76c64c2ed71805 ['f3becb9b56f737d3494ca4c1d37acec5150ee9a34cadedceda76c64c2ed71805', 'a47d290dbaf785b1f6516a8cdeb7386c1c664ad280b81e6c86d15c7a3e3716d5'] A "implementations of this document must support detnet flow identification when the implementation is acting as a detnet end systems, a relay node or as an edge node." {} {} {} 62 "Implementations of this document MUST support DetNet flow identification when the implementation is acting as a DetNet end systems, a relay node, or as an edge node." As discussed in Nov 28 call 778c768d7d6a73347d014627cc0f8e72210817a9 778c768d7d6a73347d014627cc0f8e72210817a9 draft-ietf-detnet-ip a47d290dbaf785b1f6516a8cdeb7386c1c664ad280b81e6c86d15c7a3e3716d5 ['f3becb9b56f737d3494ca4c1d37acec5150ee9a34cadedceda76c64c2ed71805', 'a47d290dbaf785b1f6516a8cdeb7386c1c664ad280b81e6c86d15c7a3e3716d5'] B "implementations of this document must support detnet flow identification when the implementation is acting as a detnet end systems, a relay node, or as an edge node." {} {} {} 62 "Implementations of this document MUST support DetNet flow identification based on the IPv4 Protocol field when processing IPv4 packets, and the IPv6 Next Header Field when processing IPv6 packets. An implementation MUST support flow identification based based the next protocol values defined in nxt-proto. Other, non-zero values, MUST be used for flow identification. Implementations SHOULD allow for these fields to be ignored for a specific DetNet flow." As discussed in Nov 28 call 778c768d7d6a73347d014627cc0f8e72210817a9 778c768d7d6a73347d014627cc0f8e72210817a9 draft-ietf-detnet-ip 1fd1055e2375df028713d1ea47c2511a5db1680d75a2b363a593792807854c55 ['1fd1055e2375df028713d1ea47c2511a5db1680d75a2b363a593792807854c55', 'b0ded4364e4dfd01420adcd6d8488b4347df1083c53c74a08c176c47b731320e'] A "implementations of this document must support detnet flow identification based on the ipv4 protocol field when processing ipv4 packets, and the ipv6 next header field when processing ipv6 packets. an implementation must support flow identification based based the next protocol values defined in nxt-proto. other, non-zero values, must be used for flow identification. implementations should allow for these fields to be ignored for a specific detnet flow." {102: 1} {210: 1} {210, 42} 62 "Implementations of this document MUST support DetNet flow identification based on the IPv4 Protocol field when processing IPv4 packets, and the IPv6 Next Header Field when processing IPv6 packets. An implementation MUST support flow identification based on the next protocol values defined in nxt-proto. Other, non-zero values, MUST be used for flow identification. Implementations SHOULD allow for these fields to be ignored for a specific DetNet flow." As discussed in Nov 28 call 778c768d7d6a73347d014627cc0f8e72210817a9 778c768d7d6a73347d014627cc0f8e72210817a9 draft-ietf-detnet-ip b0ded4364e4dfd01420adcd6d8488b4347df1083c53c74a08c176c47b731320e ['1fd1055e2375df028713d1ea47c2511a5db1680d75a2b363a593792807854c55', 'b0ded4364e4dfd01420adcd6d8488b4347df1083c53c74a08c176c47b731320e'] B "implementations of this document must support detnet flow identification based on the ipv4 protocol field when processing ipv4 packets, and the ipv6 next header field when processing ipv6 packets. an implementation must support flow identification based on the next protocol values defined in nxt-proto. other, non-zero values, must be used for flow identification. implementations should allow for these fields to be ignored for a specific detnet flow." {102: 1} {210: 1} {210, 42} 62 "General requirements for IP nodes are defined in RFC1122, RFC1812 and RFC6434, and are not modified by this document. The typical next-hop selection process is impacted by DetNet. Specifically, implementations of this document SHALL use management and control information to select the one or more outgoing interfaces and next hops to be used for a packet belonging to a DetNet flow." As discussed in Nov 28 call 778c768d7d6a73347d014627cc0f8e72210817a9 778c768d7d6a73347d014627cc0f8e72210817a9 draft-ietf-detnet-ip 5d6009015c4a553f42dc959459aa60ed49b52668f755d951e3bd3638932928b5 ['ff9160824b2ceeba0a9963bd72e84ecf9c9753366765cd5042458c0b5438793d', '5d6009015c4a553f42dc959459aa60ed49b52668f755d951e3bd3638932928b5'] A "general requirements for ip nodes are defined in rfc1122, rfc1812 and rfc6434, and are not modified by this document. the typical next-hop selection process is impacted by detnet. specifically, implementations of this document shall use management and control information to select the one or more outgoing interfaces and next hops to be used for a packet belonging to a detnet flow." {67: 1, 102: 2} {410: 1, 68: 2} {410, 411, 68} 62 "General requirements for IP nodes are defined in RFC1122, RFC1812 and RFC6434, and are not modified by this document. The typical next-hop selection process is impacted by DetNet. Specifically, implementations of this document SHALL use management and control information to select the one or more outgoing interfaces and next hops to be used for a packet associated with a DetNet flow." As discussed in Nov 28 call 778c768d7d6a73347d014627cc0f8e72210817a9 778c768d7d6a73347d014627cc0f8e72210817a9 draft-ietf-detnet-ip ff9160824b2ceeba0a9963bd72e84ecf9c9753366765cd5042458c0b5438793d ['ff9160824b2ceeba0a9963bd72e84ecf9c9753366765cd5042458c0b5438793d', '5d6009015c4a553f42dc959459aa60ed49b52668f755d951e3bd3638932928b5'] B "general requirements for ip nodes are defined in rfc1122, rfc1812 and rfc6434, and are not modified by this document. the typical next-hop selection process is impacted by detnet. specifically, implementations of this document shall use management and control information to select the one or more outgoing interfaces and next hops to be used for a packet associated with a detnet flow." {67: 1, 102: 2} {410: 1, 68: 2} {410, 411, 68} 62 "Implementations if this document MUST ensure that a DetNet flow receives the traffic treatment that is provisioned for it via configuration or the controller plane, e.g., via I-D.ietf-detnet- yang. General information on DetNet service can be found in I- D.ietf-detnet-flow-information-model. Typical mechanisms used to provide different treatment to different flows includes the allocation of system resources (such as queues and buffers) and provisioning or related parameters (such as shaping, and policing). Support can also be provided via an underlying network technology such as MPLS I-D.ietf-detnet-ip-over-mpls. and IEEE802.1 TSN I- D.ietf-detnet-ip-over-tsn. Other than in the TSN case, the specific mechanisms used by a DetNet node to ensure DetNet service delivery requirements are met for supported DetNet flows is outside the scope of this document." As discussed in Nov 28 call 778c768d7d6a73347d014627cc0f8e72210817a9 778c768d7d6a73347d014627cc0f8e72210817a9 draft-ietf-detnet-ip d623c0853943d6ffca9ca2bb44b3294c6403dacda4c84c2de236d884f154299b ['4ed65c0053cec37f5f86b9dcfe703d20b5f7ff03440a427d2cc432a546a7a0f4', 'd623c0853943d6ffca9ca2bb44b3294c6403dacda4c84c2de236d884f154299b'] A "implementations if this document must ensure that a detnet flow receives the traffic treatment that is provisioned for it via configuration or the controller plane, e.g., via i-d.ietf-detnet- yang. general information on detnet service can be found in i- d.ietf-detnet-flow-information-model. typical mechanisms used to provide different treatment to different flows includes the allocation of system resources (such as queues and buffers) and provisioning or related parameters (such as shaping, and policing). support can also be provided via an underlying network technology such as mpls i-d.ietf-detnet-ip-over-mpls. and ieee802.1 tsn i- d.ietf-detnet-ip-over-tsn. other than in the tsn case, the specific mechanisms used by a detnet node to ensure detnet service delivery requirements are met for supported detnet flows is outside the scope of this document." {} {} {} 62 "Implementations if this document MUST ensure that a DetNet flow receives the traffic treatment that is provisioned for it via configuration or the controller plane, e.g., via I-D.ietf-detnet- yang. General information on DetNet service can be found in I- D.ietf-detnet-flow-information-model. Typical mechanisms used to provide different treatment to different flows includes the allocation of system resources (such as queues and buffers) and provisioning or related parameters (such as shaping, and policing). Support can also be provided via an underlying network technology such as MPLS I-D.ietf-detnet-ip-over-mpls or IEEE802.1 TSN I-D.ietf- detnet-ip-over-tsn. Other than in the TSN case, the specific mechanisms used by a DetNet node to ensure DetNet service delivery requirements are met for supported DetNet flows is outside the scope of this document." As discussed in Nov 28 call 778c768d7d6a73347d014627cc0f8e72210817a9 778c768d7d6a73347d014627cc0f8e72210817a9 draft-ietf-detnet-ip 4ed65c0053cec37f5f86b9dcfe703d20b5f7ff03440a427d2cc432a546a7a0f4 ['4ed65c0053cec37f5f86b9dcfe703d20b5f7ff03440a427d2cc432a546a7a0f4', 'd623c0853943d6ffca9ca2bb44b3294c6403dacda4c84c2de236d884f154299b'] B "implementations if this document must ensure that a detnet flow receives the traffic treatment that is provisioned for it via configuration or the controller plane, e.g., via i-d.ietf-detnet- yang. general information on detnet service can be found in i- d.ietf-detnet-flow-information-model. typical mechanisms used to provide different treatment to different flows includes the allocation of system resources (such as queues and buffers) and provisioning or related parameters (such as shaping, and policing). support can also be provided via an underlying network technology such as mpls i-d.ietf-detnet-ip-over-mpls or ieee802.1 tsn i-d.ietf- detnet-ip-over-tsn. other than in the tsn case, the specific mechanisms used by a detnet node to ensure detnet service delivery requirements are met for supported detnet flows is outside the scope of this document." {} {} {} 62 "IPv6 flow label field. This field can be optionally used for matching. When used, can be exclusive of matching against the next header field." As discussed in Nov 28 call 778c768d7d6a73347d014627cc0f8e72210817a9 778c768d7d6a73347d014627cc0f8e72210817a9 draft-ietf-detnet-ip f37543eb03d19cf20943b5eba843b632c0146da62ab154dd8cdfed91658b7bbe ['b59ef38bc775ad389228cfd39677b5392e681fe36a24fc75e441bed9fca21593', 'f37543eb03d19cf20943b5eba843b632c0146da62ab154dd8cdfed91658b7bbe'] A "ipv6 flow label field. this field can be optionally used for matching. when used, can be exclusive of matching against the next header field." {102: 1, 60: 4, 56: 3, 64: 3, 38: 3, 71: 3, 33: 2, 26: 2, 32: 2, 83: 4, 113: 3, 126: 4, 112: 3, 85: 4, 129: 4} {274: 1, 260: 4, 261: 3, 339: 4, 212: 3, 343: 4, 286: 5, 31: 2, 32: 2, 33: 2, 163: 4, 228: 3, 357: 3, 166: 4, 231: 3, 298: 3, 363: 4, 46: 4, 377: 3} {260, 261, 274, 283, 286, 31, 32, 33, 163, 166, 298, 46, 339, 212, 343, 228, 357, 231, 363, 377} 62 "IPv6 flow label field. This field can be optionally used for matching. When used, can be used instead of matching against the Next Header field." As discussed in Nov 28 call 778c768d7d6a73347d014627cc0f8e72210817a9 778c768d7d6a73347d014627cc0f8e72210817a9 draft-ietf-detnet-ip b59ef38bc775ad389228cfd39677b5392e681fe36a24fc75e441bed9fca21593 ['b59ef38bc775ad389228cfd39677b5392e681fe36a24fc75e441bed9fca21593', 'f37543eb03d19cf20943b5eba843b632c0146da62ab154dd8cdfed91658b7bbe'] B "ipv6 flow label field. this field can be optionally used for matching. when used, can be used instead of matching against the next header field." {102: 1, 60: 4, 56: 3, 64: 3, 38: 3, 71: 3, 33: 2, 26: 2, 32: 2, 83: 4, 113: 3, 126: 4, 112: 3, 85: 4, 129: 4} {274: 1, 260: 4, 261: 3, 339: 4, 212: 3, 343: 4, 286: 5, 31: 2, 32: 2, 33: 2, 163: 4, 228: 3, 357: 3, 166: 4, 231: 3, 298: 3, 363: 4, 46: 4, 377: 3} {260, 261, 274, 283, 286, 31, 32, 33, 163, 166, 298, 46, 339, 212, 343, 228, 357, 231, 363, 377} 61 "The forwarding sub-layer information associated with the output of the service sub-layer. Note that when the PRF function is provisioned, this information is per DetNet member flow. Logically this is a pointer to details provided below for transmission of Detnet flows at the forwarding sub-layer." "Based on 's comment ( 10.24 ) . Distinction without a difference" 6adef4987c9313789bdff920336f570a2a1044c5 6adef4987c9313789bdff920336f570a2a1044c5 draft-ietf-detnet-mpls e88833dfc4793019fd0d380a39254338e0e1620775d4f0f64ba50f65f6304990 ['e88833dfc4793019fd0d380a39254338e0e1620775d4f0f64ba50f65f6304990', '3c52468ce8b76f4b504e0203ed3dec12ef5015c7e89ca8010b8729c377bef2f8'] A "the forwarding sub-layer information associated with the output of the service sub-layer. note that when the prf function is provisioned, this information is per detnet member flow. logically this is a pointer to details provided below for transmission of detnet flows at the forwarding sub-layer." {38: 1, 6: 5, 79: 5, 90: 4, 51: 5, 130: 5, 62: 7, 85: 8, 68: 7, 35: 6, 110: 4, 91: 6, 114: 2, 97: 5, 31: 5, 13: 4, 67: 4, 26: 2, 124: 6, 98: 5, 54: 5, 127: 6, 8: 5, 96: 5, 64: 5, 30: 5, 61: 2, 55: 6, 27: 2, 15: 4, 52: 4, 129: 6, 115: 4, 84: 4, 76: 9, 87: 4, 131: 8, 102: 4, 113: 2, 99: 5, 36: 4, 24: 3, 53: 4, 72: 5} {96: 1, 1: 12, 4: 5, 9: 8, 10: 6, 15: 5, 24: 5, 25: 7, 26: 8, 27: 5, 39: 8, 43: 6, 49: 7, 50: 6, 58: 2, 59: 5, 64: 5, 69: 7, 81: 8, 82: 6, 86: 4, 97: 2, 100: 9, 108: 6, 109: 7, 110: 7, 111: 5, 114: 6, 115: 7, 116: 5, 118: 9, 119: 8, 120: 6, 121: 7, 122: 6, 123: 5, 124: 7, 128: 5, 129: 5, 130: 2, 132: 7, 136: 5, 145: 7, 147: 2, 151: 5, 152: 5, 154: 6, 156: 4, 161: 6, 162: 6, 165: 6, 168: 7, 169: 4, 172: 4, 180: 5, 184: 8, 187: 8, 188: 7, 191: 6, 194: 7, 202: 8, 203: 9, 206: 5, 207: 6, 215: 5, 217: 6, 218: 11, 220: 5, 221: 5, 222: 8, 224: 6, 227: 7, 229: 4, 234: 8, 235: 5, 241: 5, 242: 5, 243: 7, 244: 5, 245: 7, 248: 5, 250: 6, 258: 14, 262: 7, 263: 8, 264: 6, 267: 7, 270: 5, 272: 4, 273: 8, 287: 6, 289: 4, 291: 2, 299: 7, 300: 5, 304: 5, 309: 6, 314: 5, 315: 4, 320: 7, 323: 7, 327: 7, 328: 6, 329: 5, 330: 13, 334: 5, 335: 5, 341: 7, 342: 8, 347: 7, 348: 7, 350: 10, 351: 6, 352: 4, 353: 4, 354: 3, 358: 7, 365: 4, 366: 5, 369: 4, 371: 9, 376: 5, 384: 6, 385: 5, 386: 6, 387: 5, 392: 6, 393: 7, 396: 8, 397: 10, 398: 9, 402: 4} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 61 "The forwarding sub-layer information associated with the output of the service sub-layer. Note that when the PRF function is provisioned, this information is per DetNet member flow. Logically the forwarding sub-layer information is a pointer to further details of transmission of Detnet flows at the forwarding sub-layer." "Based on 's comment ( 10.24 ) . Distinction without a difference" 6adef4987c9313789bdff920336f570a2a1044c5 6adef4987c9313789bdff920336f570a2a1044c5 draft-ietf-detnet-mpls 3c52468ce8b76f4b504e0203ed3dec12ef5015c7e89ca8010b8729c377bef2f8 ['e88833dfc4793019fd0d380a39254338e0e1620775d4f0f64ba50f65f6304990', '3c52468ce8b76f4b504e0203ed3dec12ef5015c7e89ca8010b8729c377bef2f8'] B "the forwarding sub-layer information associated with the output of the service sub-layer. note that when the prf function is provisioned, this information is per detnet member flow. logically the forwarding sub-layer information is a pointer to further details of transmission of detnet flows at the forwarding sub-layer." {38: 1, 6: 5, 79: 5, 90: 4, 51: 5, 130: 5, 62: 7, 85: 8, 68: 7, 35: 6, 110: 4, 91: 6, 114: 2, 97: 5, 31: 5, 13: 4, 67: 4, 26: 2, 124: 6, 98: 5, 54: 5, 127: 6, 8: 5, 96: 5, 64: 5, 30: 5, 61: 2, 55: 6, 27: 2, 15: 4, 52: 4, 129: 6, 115: 4, 84: 4, 76: 9, 87: 4, 131: 8, 102: 4, 113: 2, 99: 5, 36: 4, 24: 3, 53: 4, 72: 5} {96: 1, 1: 12, 4: 5, 9: 8, 10: 6, 15: 5, 24: 5, 25: 7, 26: 8, 27: 5, 39: 8, 43: 6, 49: 7, 50: 6, 58: 2, 59: 5, 64: 5, 69: 7, 81: 8, 82: 6, 86: 4, 97: 2, 100: 9, 108: 6, 109: 7, 110: 7, 111: 5, 114: 6, 115: 7, 116: 5, 118: 9, 119: 8, 120: 6, 121: 7, 122: 6, 123: 5, 124: 7, 128: 5, 129: 5, 130: 2, 132: 7, 136: 5, 145: 7, 147: 2, 151: 5, 152: 5, 154: 6, 156: 4, 161: 6, 162: 6, 165: 6, 168: 7, 169: 4, 172: 4, 180: 5, 184: 8, 187: 8, 188: 7, 191: 6, 194: 7, 202: 8, 203: 9, 206: 5, 207: 6, 215: 5, 217: 6, 218: 11, 220: 5, 221: 5, 222: 8, 224: 6, 227: 7, 229: 4, 234: 8, 235: 5, 241: 5, 242: 5, 243: 7, 244: 5, 245: 7, 248: 5, 250: 6, 258: 14, 262: 7, 263: 8, 264: 6, 267: 7, 270: 5, 272: 4, 273: 8, 287: 6, 289: 4, 291: 2, 299: 7, 300: 5, 304: 5, 309: 6, 314: 5, 315: 4, 320: 7, 323: 7, 327: 7, 328: 6, 329: 5, 330: 13, 334: 5, 335: 5, 341: 7, 342: 8, 347: 7, 348: 7, 350: 10, 351: 6, 352: 4, 353: 4, 354: 3, 358: 7, 365: 4, 366: 5, 369: 4, 371: 9, 376: 5, 384: 6, 385: 5, 386: 6, 387: 5, 392: 6, 393: 7, 396: 8, 397: 10, 398: 9, 402: 4} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 61 "The forwarding sub-layer information associated with the input of the service sub-layer. Note that when the PEF function is provisioned, this information is per DetNet member flow. Logically this is a pointer to details provided below related to the reception of Detnet flows at the forwarding sub-layer or A-Label." "Based on 's comment ( 10.24 ) . Distinction without a difference" 6adef4987c9313789bdff920336f570a2a1044c5 6adef4987c9313789bdff920336f570a2a1044c5 draft-ietf-detnet-mpls 3ad381ce14d392b11bc71c7f84aec9aa4faec501b897070e8cad5dfe435f09ff ['507cad44d330c863b1b2f50df6e0d2f929c5999d1f8f7937b98cababa3569234', '3ad381ce14d392b11bc71c7f84aec9aa4faec501b897070e8cad5dfe435f09ff'] A "the forwarding sub-layer information associated with the input of the service sub-layer. note that when the pef function is provisioned, this information is per detnet member flow. logically this is a pointer to details provided below related to the reception of detnet flows at the forwarding sub-layer or a-label." {38: 1, 6: 5, 79: 5, 90: 4, 51: 5, 130: 5, 62: 7, 85: 8, 68: 7, 35: 6, 110: 4, 91: 6, 114: 2, 97: 5, 31: 5, 13: 4, 67: 4, 26: 2, 124: 6, 98: 5, 54: 5, 127: 6, 8: 5, 96: 5, 64: 5, 30: 5, 55: 6, 27: 2, 15: 4, 52: 4, 129: 6, 115: 4, 84: 4, 76: 9, 87: 4, 131: 8, 102: 4, 113: 2, 99: 5, 36: 4, 24: 3, 53: 4, 61: 2, 72: 5} {96: 1, 1: 12, 4: 5, 9: 8, 10: 6, 15: 5, 24: 5, 25: 7, 26: 8, 27: 5, 39: 8, 43: 6, 49: 7, 50: 6, 58: 2, 59: 5, 64: 5, 69: 7, 81: 8, 82: 6, 86: 4, 97: 2, 100: 9, 108: 6, 109: 7, 110: 7, 111: 5, 114: 6, 115: 7, 116: 5, 118: 9, 119: 8, 120: 6, 121: 7, 122: 6, 123: 5, 124: 7, 128: 5, 129: 5, 132: 7, 136: 5, 145: 7, 147: 2, 151: 5, 152: 5, 154: 6, 156: 4, 161: 6, 162: 6, 165: 6, 168: 7, 169: 4, 172: 4, 180: 5, 184: 8, 187: 8, 188: 7, 191: 6, 194: 7, 202: 8, 203: 9, 206: 5, 207: 6, 215: 5, 217: 6, 218: 11, 220: 5, 221: 5, 222: 8, 224: 6, 227: 7, 229: 4, 234: 8, 235: 5, 241: 5, 242: 5, 243: 7, 244: 5, 245: 7, 248: 5, 250: 6, 258: 14, 262: 7, 263: 8, 264: 6, 267: 7, 270: 5, 272: 4, 273: 8, 287: 6, 289: 4, 291: 2, 299: 7, 300: 5, 304: 5, 309: 6, 314: 5, 315: 4, 320: 7, 323: 7, 327: 7, 328: 6, 329: 5, 330: 13, 334: 5, 335: 5, 341: 7, 342: 8, 347: 7, 348: 7, 350: 10, 351: 6, 352: 4, 353: 4, 354: 3, 358: 7, 365: 4, 366: 5, 369: 4, 371: 9, 372: 2, 376: 5, 384: 6, 385: 5, 386: 6, 387: 5, 392: 6, 393: 7, 396: 8, 397: 10, 398: 9, 402: 4} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 61 "The forwarding sub-layer information associated with the input of the service sub-layer. Note that when the PEF function is provisioned, this information is per DetNet member flow. Logically the forwarding sub-layer information is a pointer to further details of the reception of Detnet flows at the forwarding sub-layer or A-Label." "Based on 's comment ( 10.24 ) . Distinction without a difference" 6adef4987c9313789bdff920336f570a2a1044c5 6adef4987c9313789bdff920336f570a2a1044c5 draft-ietf-detnet-mpls 507cad44d330c863b1b2f50df6e0d2f929c5999d1f8f7937b98cababa3569234 ['507cad44d330c863b1b2f50df6e0d2f929c5999d1f8f7937b98cababa3569234', '3ad381ce14d392b11bc71c7f84aec9aa4faec501b897070e8cad5dfe435f09ff'] B "the forwarding sub-layer information associated with the input of the service sub-layer. note that when the pef function is provisioned, this information is per detnet member flow. logically the forwarding sub-layer information is a pointer to further details of the reception of detnet flows at the forwarding sub-layer or a-label." {38: 1, 6: 5, 79: 5, 90: 4, 51: 5, 130: 5, 62: 7, 85: 8, 68: 7, 35: 6, 110: 4, 91: 6, 114: 2, 97: 5, 31: 5, 13: 4, 67: 4, 26: 2, 124: 6, 98: 5, 54: 5, 127: 6, 8: 5, 96: 5, 64: 5, 30: 5, 55: 6, 27: 2, 15: 4, 52: 4, 129: 6, 115: 4, 84: 4, 76: 9, 87: 4, 131: 8, 102: 4, 113: 2, 99: 5, 36: 4, 24: 3, 53: 4, 61: 2, 72: 5} {96: 1, 1: 12, 4: 5, 9: 8, 10: 6, 15: 5, 24: 5, 25: 7, 26: 8, 27: 5, 39: 8, 43: 6, 49: 7, 50: 6, 58: 2, 59: 5, 64: 5, 69: 7, 81: 8, 82: 6, 86: 4, 97: 2, 100: 9, 108: 6, 109: 7, 110: 7, 111: 5, 114: 6, 115: 7, 116: 5, 118: 9, 119: 8, 120: 6, 121: 7, 122: 6, 123: 5, 124: 7, 128: 5, 129: 5, 132: 7, 136: 5, 145: 7, 147: 2, 151: 5, 152: 5, 154: 6, 156: 4, 161: 6, 162: 6, 165: 6, 168: 7, 169: 4, 172: 4, 180: 5, 184: 8, 187: 8, 188: 7, 191: 6, 194: 7, 202: 8, 203: 9, 206: 5, 207: 6, 215: 5, 217: 6, 218: 11, 220: 5, 221: 5, 222: 8, 224: 6, 227: 7, 229: 4, 234: 8, 235: 5, 241: 5, 242: 5, 243: 7, 244: 5, 245: 7, 248: 5, 250: 6, 258: 14, 262: 7, 263: 8, 264: 6, 267: 7, 270: 5, 272: 4, 273: 8, 287: 6, 289: 4, 291: 2, 299: 7, 300: 5, 304: 5, 309: 6, 314: 5, 315: 4, 320: 7, 323: 7, 327: 7, 328: 6, 329: 5, 330: 13, 334: 5, 335: 5, 341: 7, 342: 8, 347: 7, 348: 7, 350: 10, 351: 6, 352: 4, 353: 4, 354: 3, 358: 7, 365: 4, 366: 5, 369: 4, 371: 9, 372: 2, 376: 5, 384: 6, 385: 5, 386: 6, 387: 5, 392: 6, 393: 7, 396: 8, 397: 10, 398: 9, 402: 4} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 60 Explicit Congestion Notification. "ready for merge - per list discussion Thanks . Changes are OK ." 8d9945d40158282d2429081d2e4a958e0ecd8cb5 8d9945d40158282d2429081d2e4a958e0ecd8cb5 draft-ietf-detnet-ip 6b41c3988f2ee982484e1e07e84b8ef952a84112e6e1e1a662b0369d8d477966 ['6b41c3988f2ee982484e1e07e84b8ef952a84112e6e1e1a662b0369d8d477966'] A explicit congestion notification. {} {} {167} 60 "The DetNet IP data plane also allows for optional matching on two additional data fields. The optional fields are the ECN Field, as in RFC3168, and the IPv6 flow label field, as defined in RFC8200." "ready for merge - per list discussion Thanks . Changes are OK ." 8d9945d40158282d2429081d2e4a958e0ecd8cb5 8d9945d40158282d2429081d2e4a958e0ecd8cb5 draft-ietf-detnet-ip 3d98aa680516b54de01a6f5a3cbe9fb7127a5d582a69c829fddbc2cbd73c20f6 ['5aaded925dc6f8bbec82bdb220dd611df02ed765dd07fdf34f8ada669c6668dd', '3d98aa680516b54de01a6f5a3cbe9fb7127a5d582a69c829fddbc2cbd73c20f6'] A "the detnet ip data plane also allows for optional matching on two additional data fields. the optional fields are the ecn field, as in rfc3168, and the ipv6 flow label field, as defined in rfc8200." {56: 1, 102: 4, 85: 3, 62: 2} {368: 1, 38: 4, 312: 3, 282: 2, 189: 4, 190: 3} {38, 368, 146, 312, 282, 189, 190} 60 "The DetNet IP data plane also allows for optional matching on the IPv6 flow label field, as defined in RFC8200." "ready for merge - per list discussion Thanks . Changes are OK ." 8d9945d40158282d2429081d2e4a958e0ecd8cb5 8d9945d40158282d2429081d2e4a958e0ecd8cb5 draft-ietf-detnet-ip 5aaded925dc6f8bbec82bdb220dd611df02ed765dd07fdf34f8ada669c6668dd ['5aaded925dc6f8bbec82bdb220dd611df02ed765dd07fdf34f8ada669c6668dd', '3d98aa680516b54de01a6f5a3cbe9fb7127a5d582a69c829fddbc2cbd73c20f6'] B "the detnet ip data plane also allows for optional matching on the ipv6 flow label field, as defined in rfc8200." {56: 1, 102: 4, 85: 3, 62: 2} {368: 1, 38: 4, 312: 3, 282: 2, 189: 4, 190: 3} {38, 368, 146, 312, 282, 189, 190} 60 "Class of Service (CoS) for DetNet flows carried in IPv6 is provided using the standard differentiated services code point (DSCP) field RFC2474 and related mechanisms. The 2-bit explicit congestion notification (ECN) RFC3168 field MAY also be used." "ready for merge - per list discussion Thanks . Changes are OK ." 8d9945d40158282d2429081d2e4a958e0ecd8cb5 8d9945d40158282d2429081d2e4a958e0ecd8cb5 draft-ietf-detnet-ip 2625523410899417635d7e9ee0ea3544e0c34635bed648830d11cdff23469d9d ['c617cb71f30ac8b299bff02bc0043bda2a90f7f6f9a3a4504cd1e92b15effebf', '2625523410899417635d7e9ee0ea3544e0c34635bed648830d11cdff23469d9d'] A "class of service (cos) for detnet flows carried in ipv6 is provided using the standard differentiated services code point (dscp) field rfc2474 and related mechanisms. the 2-bit explicit congestion notification (ecn) rfc3168 field may also be used." {83: 1, 85: 2} {311: 1, 90: 2} {90, 310, 311} 60 "Class of Service (CoS) for DetNet flows carried in IPv6 is provided using the standard differentiated services code point (DSCP) field RFC2474 and related mechanisms." "ready for merge - per list discussion Thanks . Changes are OK ." 8d9945d40158282d2429081d2e4a958e0ecd8cb5 8d9945d40158282d2429081d2e4a958e0ecd8cb5 draft-ietf-detnet-ip c617cb71f30ac8b299bff02bc0043bda2a90f7f6f9a3a4504cd1e92b15effebf ['c617cb71f30ac8b299bff02bc0043bda2a90f7f6f9a3a4504cd1e92b15effebf', '2625523410899417635d7e9ee0ea3544e0c34635bed648830d11cdff23469d9d'] B "class of service (cos) for detnet flows carried in ipv6 is provided using the standard differentiated services code point (dscp) field rfc2474 and related mechanisms." {83: 1, 85: 2} {311: 1, 90: 2} {90, 310, 311} 60 "Quality of Service (QoS) for DetNet service flows carried in IP MUST be provided locally by the DetNet-aware hosts and routers supporting DetNet flows. Such support leverages the underlying network layer such as 802.1 TSN. The traffic control mechanisms used to deliver QoS for IP encapsulated DetNet flows are expected to be defined in a future document. From an encapsulation perspective, the combination of the 6-tuple i.e., the typical 5-tuple enhanced with the DSCP and previously mentioned two optional fields, uniquely identifies a DetNet service flow." "ready for merge - per list discussion Thanks . Changes are OK ." 8d9945d40158282d2429081d2e4a958e0ecd8cb5 8d9945d40158282d2429081d2e4a958e0ecd8cb5 draft-ietf-detnet-ip edae7bd78053411c01d803eb09feb670f4d1fdf32e7a1d5f70b50c6a4f09c308 ['b9cda9f5c388ec8b9f0b5c2b19f9d445e8e320452dfa095326e7703db40326a8', 'edae7bd78053411c01d803eb09feb670f4d1fdf32e7a1d5f70b50c6a4f09c308'] A "quality of service (qos) for detnet service flows carried in ip must be provided locally by the detnet-aware hosts and routers supporting detnet flows. such support leverages the underlying network layer such as 802.1 tsn. the traffic control mechanisms used to deliver qos for ip encapsulated detnet flows are expected to be defined in a future document. from an encapsulation perspective, the combination of the 6-tuple i.e., the typical 5-tuple enhanced with the dscp and previously mentioned two optional fields, uniquely identifies a detnet service flow." {56: 1} {381: 1} {292, 381} 60 "Quality of Service (QoS) for DetNet service flows carried in IP MUST be provided locally by the DetNet-aware hosts and routers supporting DetNet flows. Such support leverages the underlying network layer such as 802.1 TSN. The traffic control mechanisms used to deliver QoS for IP encapsulated DetNet flows are expected to be defined in a future document. From an encapsulation perspective, the combination of the 6-tuple i.e., the typical 5-tuple enhanced with the DSCP and previously mentioned optional field, uniquely identifies a DetNet service flow." "ready for merge - per list discussion Thanks . Changes are OK ." 8d9945d40158282d2429081d2e4a958e0ecd8cb5 8d9945d40158282d2429081d2e4a958e0ecd8cb5 draft-ietf-detnet-ip b9cda9f5c388ec8b9f0b5c2b19f9d445e8e320452dfa095326e7703db40326a8 ['b9cda9f5c388ec8b9f0b5c2b19f9d445e8e320452dfa095326e7703db40326a8', 'edae7bd78053411c01d803eb09feb670f4d1fdf32e7a1d5f70b50c6a4f09c308'] B "quality of service (qos) for detnet service flows carried in ip must be provided locally by the detnet-aware hosts and routers supporting detnet flows. such support leverages the underlying network layer such as 802.1 tsn. the traffic control mechanisms used to deliver qos for ip encapsulated detnet flows are expected to be defined in a future document. from an encapsulation perspective, the combination of the 6-tuple i.e., the typical 5-tuple enhanced with the dscp and previously mentioned optional field, uniquely identifies a detnet service flow." {56: 1} {381: 1} {292, 381} 60 "While path selection algorithms and mechanisms are out of scope of the DetNet data plane definition, it is important to highlight the implications of DetNet IP flow identification on path selection and next hops. As mentioned above, the DetNet IP data plane identifies flows using ""6-tuple"" header information as well as two additional optional header fields. DetNet generally allows for both flow- specific traffic treatment and flow-specific next-hops." "ready for merge - per list discussion Thanks . Changes are OK ." 8d9945d40158282d2429081d2e4a958e0ecd8cb5 8d9945d40158282d2429081d2e4a958e0ecd8cb5 draft-ietf-detnet-ip 6237efce14a2f9d507e4815a4f48b88b001a98eaca040a6e8e0f91e8fa7eaa75 ['ee580e1ca8dad15db164a2872881a6e56d194b2893ab09ce52a9298694b4715b', '6237efce14a2f9d507e4815a4f48b88b001a98eaca040a6e8e0f91e8fa7eaa75'] A "while path selection algorithms and mechanisms are out of scope of the detnet data plane definition, it is important to highlight the implications of detnet ip flow identification on path selection and next hops. as mentioned above, the detnet ip data plane identifies flows using ""6-tuple"" header information as well as two additional optional header fields. detnet generally allows for both flow- specific traffic treatment and flow-specific next-hops." {56: 1, 102: 1, 62: 2} {80: 1, 382: 1, 367: 2, 79: 2} {367, 80, 79, 382, 383} 60 "While path selection algorithms and mechanisms are out of scope of the DetNet data plane definition, it is important to highlight the implications of DetNet IP flow identification on path selection and next hops. As mentioned above, the DetNet IP data plane identifies flows using ""6-tuple"" header information as well as the additional optional header field. DetNet generally allows for both flow- specific traffic treatment and flow-specific next-hops." "ready for merge - per list discussion Thanks . Changes are OK ." 8d9945d40158282d2429081d2e4a958e0ecd8cb5 8d9945d40158282d2429081d2e4a958e0ecd8cb5 draft-ietf-detnet-ip ee580e1ca8dad15db164a2872881a6e56d194b2893ab09ce52a9298694b4715b ['ee580e1ca8dad15db164a2872881a6e56d194b2893ab09ce52a9298694b4715b', '6237efce14a2f9d507e4815a4f48b88b001a98eaca040a6e8e0f91e8fa7eaa75'] B "while path selection algorithms and mechanisms are out of scope of the detnet data plane definition, it is important to highlight the implications of detnet ip flow identification on path selection and next hops. as mentioned above, the detnet ip data plane identifies flows using ""6-tuple"" header information as well as the additional optional header field. detnet generally allows for both flow- specific traffic treatment and flow-specific next-hops." {56: 1, 102: 1, 62: 2} {80: 1, 382: 1, 367: 2, 79: 2} {367, 80, 79, 382, 383} 60 "From a single node perspective, the aggregation of IP flows impacts DetNet IP data plane flow identification and resource allocation. As discussed above, IP flow identification uses the IP ""6-tuple"" for flow identification. DetNet IP flows can be aggregated using any of the 6-tuple, or two additional optional fields defined in ip-flow-id. The use of prefixes, wildcards, lists, and value ranges allows a DetNet node to identify aggregate DetNet flows. From a resource allocation perspective, DetNet nodes must provide service to a aggregate and not on a component flow basis." "ready for merge - per list discussion Thanks . Changes are OK ." 8d9945d40158282d2429081d2e4a958e0ecd8cb5 8d9945d40158282d2429081d2e4a958e0ecd8cb5 draft-ietf-detnet-ip 260c526752ebe3fe2227ec577fbbb13f4dc3f09a3c5140247dc59c72a1978cf7 ['260c526752ebe3fe2227ec577fbbb13f4dc3f09a3c5140247dc59c72a1978cf7', 'e84c5b6e05a6fa9cbdd775a416d6c49eca61fba924566ead4bad4ce464efa0d4'] A "from a single node perspective, the aggregation of ip flows impacts detnet ip data plane flow identification and resource allocation. as discussed above, ip flow identification uses the ip ""6-tuple"" for flow identification. detnet ip flows can be aggregated using any of the 6-tuple, or two additional optional fields defined in ip-flow-id. the use of prefixes, wildcards, lists, and value ranges allows a detnet node to identify aggregate detnet flows. from a resource allocation perspective, detnet nodes must provide service to a aggregate and not on a component flow basis." {62: 1, 56: 1, 26: 2, 27: 3, 102: 3, 85: 2, 13: 3} {370: 1, 159: 1, 160: 2, 259: 3, 359: 3, 246: 2, 284: 3} {160, 259, 359, 370, 52, 246, 284, 159} 60 "From a single node perspective, the aggregation of IP flows impacts DetNet IP data plane flow identification and resource allocation. As discussed above, IP flow identification uses the IP ""6-tuple"" for flow identification. DetNet IP flows can be aggregated using any of the 6-tuple, and an additional optional field defined in ip-flow-id. The use of prefixes, wildcards, lists, and value ranges allows a DetNet node to identify aggregate DetNet flows. From a resource allocation perspective, DetNet nodes must provide service to a aggregate and not on a component flow basis." "ready for merge - per list discussion Thanks . Changes are OK ." 8d9945d40158282d2429081d2e4a958e0ecd8cb5 8d9945d40158282d2429081d2e4a958e0ecd8cb5 draft-ietf-detnet-ip e84c5b6e05a6fa9cbdd775a416d6c49eca61fba924566ead4bad4ce464efa0d4 ['260c526752ebe3fe2227ec577fbbb13f4dc3f09a3c5140247dc59c72a1978cf7', 'e84c5b6e05a6fa9cbdd775a416d6c49eca61fba924566ead4bad4ce464efa0d4'] B "from a single node perspective, the aggregation of ip flows impacts detnet ip data plane flow identification and resource allocation. as discussed above, ip flow identification uses the ip ""6-tuple"" for flow identification. detnet ip flows can be aggregated using any of the 6-tuple, and an additional optional field defined in ip-flow-id. the use of prefixes, wildcards, lists, and value ranges allows a detnet node to identify aggregate detnet flows. from a resource allocation perspective, detnet nodes must provide service to a aggregate and not on a component flow basis." {62: 1, 56: 1, 26: 2, 27: 3, 102: 3, 85: 2, 13: 3} {370: 1, 159: 1, 160: 2, 259: 3, 359: 3, 246: 2, 284: 3} {160, 259, 359, 370, 52, 246, 284, 159} 60 "These fields are used to support Differentiated Services RFC2474 and Explicit Congestion Notification RFC3168. Implementations of this document MUST support DetNet flow identification based on the IPv4 Type of Service field when processing IPv4 packets, and the IPv6 Traffic Class Field when processing IPv6 packets. Implementations MUST support list based matching of DSCP values, where the list is composed of possible field values that are to be considered when identifying a specific DetNet flow. Implementations SHOULD allow for this field to be ignored for a specific DetNet flow." "ready for merge - per list discussion Thanks . Changes are OK ." 8d9945d40158282d2429081d2e4a958e0ecd8cb5 8d9945d40158282d2429081d2e4a958e0ecd8cb5 draft-ietf-detnet-ip 92990758301c318d415c89ac34c0beb81e876f9668ed083ecd9e56fd78699a48 ['d8e864655c4e160952f098de8d69c8b26dea919dd41adee0bb44d62ab049dead', 'c368f75a4199d83c7430b1f1eac16130aa07fda56efa17d42da3360dffbb0a86', '92990758301c318d415c89ac34c0beb81e876f9668ed083ecd9e56fd78699a48'] A "these fields are used to support differentiated services rfc2474 and explicit congestion notification rfc3168. implementations of this document must support detnet flow identification based on the ipv4 type of service field when processing ipv4 packets, and the ipv6 traffic class field when processing ipv6 packets. implementations must support list based matching of dscp values, where the list is composed of possible field values that are to be considered when identifying a specific detnet flow. implementations should allow for this field to be ignored for a specific detnet flow." {56: 1, 102: 1} {164: 1, 345: 1} {344, 345, 164} 60 "Implementations of this document MUST allow the ECN field to be ignored as part of DetNet flow identification. Additionally, implementations SHOULD support identification of DetNet flows based on the value carried in the ECN field. When this field is used to identify a specific DetNet flow, implementations MUST support a list of ECN values that match a specific slow." "ready for merge - per list discussion Thanks . Changes are OK ." 8d9945d40158282d2429081d2e4a958e0ecd8cb5 8d9945d40158282d2429081d2e4a958e0ecd8cb5 draft-ietf-detnet-ip c368f75a4199d83c7430b1f1eac16130aa07fda56efa17d42da3360dffbb0a86 ['d8e864655c4e160952f098de8d69c8b26dea919dd41adee0bb44d62ab049dead', 'c368f75a4199d83c7430b1f1eac16130aa07fda56efa17d42da3360dffbb0a86', '92990758301c318d415c89ac34c0beb81e876f9668ed083ecd9e56fd78699a48'] A "implementations of this document must allow the ecn field to be ignored as part of detnet flow identification. additionally, implementations should support identification of detnet flows based on the value carried in the ecn field. when this field is used to identify a specific detnet flow, implementations must support a list of ecn values that match a specific slow." {56: 1, 102: 1} {164: 1, 345: 1} {344, 345, 164} 60 "These fields are used to support Differentiated Services RFC2474 RFC2475. Implementations of this document MUST support DetNet flow identification based on the DSCP field in the IPv4 Type of Service field when processing IPv4 packets, and the DSCP field in the IPv6 Traffic Class Field when processing IPv6 packets. Implementations MUST support list based matching of DSCP values, where the list is composed of possible field values that are to be considered when identifying a specific DetNet flow. Implementations SHOULD allow for this field to be ignored for a specific DetNet flow." "ready for merge - per list discussion Thanks . Changes are OK ." 8d9945d40158282d2429081d2e4a958e0ecd8cb5 8d9945d40158282d2429081d2e4a958e0ecd8cb5 draft-ietf-detnet-ip d8e864655c4e160952f098de8d69c8b26dea919dd41adee0bb44d62ab049dead ['d8e864655c4e160952f098de8d69c8b26dea919dd41adee0bb44d62ab049dead', 'c368f75a4199d83c7430b1f1eac16130aa07fda56efa17d42da3360dffbb0a86', '92990758301c318d415c89ac34c0beb81e876f9668ed083ecd9e56fd78699a48'] B "these fields are used to support differentiated services rfc2474 rfc2475. implementations of this document must support detnet flow identification based on the dscp field in the ipv4 type of service field when processing ipv4 packets, and the dscp field in the ipv6 traffic class field when processing ipv6 packets. implementations must support list based matching of dscp values, where the list is composed of possible field values that are to be considered when identifying a specific detnet flow. implementations should allow for this field to be ignored for a specific detnet flow." {56: 1, 102: 1} {164: 1, 345: 1} {344, 345, 164} 60 "If the ECN field is to be used in flow identification. Matching based on ECN filed values is optional." "ready for merge - per list discussion Thanks . Changes are OK ." 8d9945d40158282d2429081d2e4a958e0ecd8cb5 8d9945d40158282d2429081d2e4a958e0ecd8cb5 draft-ietf-detnet-ip 2cc501aecbca542e8a89581cc80369d31be3e3fc2280905928a095b8b24250e8 ['a9d9bfcd10e75c9e7c0a530418daf779856a676ecbe97ff9c54e7e2a7feb2c52', '2cc501aecbca542e8a89581cc80369d31be3e3fc2280905928a095b8b24250e8'] A "if the ecn field is to be used in flow identification. matching based on ecn filed values is optional." {56: 1, 102: 3, 64: 2, 38: 3, 62: 4, 71: 3, 33: 2, 26: 3, 32: 2, 83: 2, 113: 3, 126: 4, 112: 3, 85: 2, 129: 4} {261: 1, 274: 3, 339: 4, 212: 3, 343: 4, 283: 4, 286: 5, 31: 2, 32: 3, 33: 2, 163: 2, 228: 3, 357: 3, 166: 4, 231: 2, 298: 3, 363: 2, 46: 4, 377: 3} {260, 261, 274, 283, 286, 31, 32, 33, 163, 166, 298, 46, 339, 212, 343, 228, 357, 231, 363, 377} 60 "When ECN field is used in flow identification, a list of field values that may be used by a specific flow." "ready for merge - per list discussion Thanks . Changes are OK ." 8d9945d40158282d2429081d2e4a958e0ecd8cb5 8d9945d40158282d2429081d2e4a958e0ecd8cb5 draft-ietf-detnet-ip a9d9bfcd10e75c9e7c0a530418daf779856a676ecbe97ff9c54e7e2a7feb2c52 ['a9d9bfcd10e75c9e7c0a530418daf779856a676ecbe97ff9c54e7e2a7feb2c52', '2cc501aecbca542e8a89581cc80369d31be3e3fc2280905928a095b8b24250e8'] A "when ecn field is used in flow identification, a list of field values that may be used by a specific flow." {56: 1, 102: 3, 64: 2, 38: 3, 62: 4, 71: 3, 33: 2, 26: 3, 32: 2, 83: 2, 113: 3, 126: 4, 112: 3, 85: 2, 129: 4} {261: 1, 274: 3, 339: 4, 212: 3, 343: 4, 283: 4, 286: 5, 31: 2, 32: 3, 33: 2, 163: 2, 228: 3, 357: 3, 166: 4, 231: 2, 298: 3, 363: 2, 46: 4, 377: 3} {260, 261, 274, 283, 286, 31, 32, 33, 163, 166, 298, 46, 339, 212, 343, 228, 357, 231, 363, 377} 58 "Important background information common to all data planes for DetNet can be found in the DetNet Data Plane Framework I-D.ietf-detnet-data- plane-framework." OK . Thanks . f452cebb567bec82f0db29c8aef423d40d7ef0f9 f452cebb567bec82f0db29c8aef423d40d7ef0f9 draft-ietf-detnet-mpls d4bcb29436924978e745b766093c3ba81e6e1b57314e0166530acd13ef2197ca ['d4bcb29436924978e745b766093c3ba81e6e1b57314e0166530acd13ef2197ca', '28e5011ee43d15d25f212f79dbad4f6cd4305ba47f353f054a97ad27a3c136d1'] A "important background information common to all data planes for detnet can be found in the detnet data plane framework i-d.ietf-detnet-data- plane-framework." {} {} {} 58 "Background information common to all data planes for DetNet can be found in the DetNet Data Plane Framework I-D.ietf-detnet-data-plane- framework." OK . Thanks . f452cebb567bec82f0db29c8aef423d40d7ef0f9 f452cebb567bec82f0db29c8aef423d40d7ef0f9 draft-ietf-detnet-mpls 28e5011ee43d15d25f212f79dbad4f6cd4305ba47f353f054a97ad27a3c136d1 ['d4bcb29436924978e745b766093c3ba81e6e1b57314e0166530acd13ef2197ca', '28e5011ee43d15d25f212f79dbad4f6cd4305ba47f353f054a97ad27a3c136d1'] B "background information common to all data planes for detnet can be found in the detnet data plane framework i-d.ietf-detnet-data-plane- framework." {} {} {} 57 "MPLS encapsulated DetNet flows can carry different types of traffic. The details of the types of traffic that are carried in DetNet are also out of scope of this document. An example of IP using DetNet MPLS sub-networks can be found in [I-D.ietf-detnet-ip]. DetNet MPLS may use an associated controller and Operations, Administration, and Maintenance (OAM) functions that are defined outside of this document." OK . Thanks 72587a6c893160661ab505edf3f0e8d3690261a7 72587a6c893160661ab505edf3f0e8d3690261a7 draft-ietf-detnet-mpls 0bbae8a2a94872e6963a28edd77b4d190d8098bda8294765a15335b7d3048d4c ['50bef79523bd9d36567b34b93750555141f14e5a67cdaa7ff1046d2904ebcb47', '0bbae8a2a94872e6963a28edd77b4d190d8098bda8294765a15335b7d3048d4c'] A "mpls encapsulated detnet flows can carry different types of traffic. the details of the types of traffic that are carried in detnet are also out of scope of this document. an example of ip using detnet mpls sub-networks can be found in [i-d.ietf-detnet-ip]. detnet mpls may use an associated controller and operations, administration, and maintenance (oam) functions that are defined outside of this document." {} {} {} 57 "MPLS encapsulated DetNet flows can carry different types of traffic. The details of the types of traffic that are carried in DetNet are also out of scope of this document. An example of IP using DetNet MPLS sub-networks can be found in I-D.ietf-detnet-ip. DetNet MPLS may use an associated controller and Operations, Administration, and Maintenance (OAM) functions that are defined outside of this document." OK . Thanks 72587a6c893160661ab505edf3f0e8d3690261a7 72587a6c893160661ab505edf3f0e8d3690261a7 draft-ietf-detnet-mpls 50bef79523bd9d36567b34b93750555141f14e5a67cdaa7ff1046d2904ebcb47 ['50bef79523bd9d36567b34b93750555141f14e5a67cdaa7ff1046d2904ebcb47', '0bbae8a2a94872e6963a28edd77b4d190d8098bda8294765a15335b7d3048d4c'] B "mpls encapsulated detnet flows can carry different types of traffic. the details of the types of traffic that are carried in detnet are also out of scope of this document. an example of ip using detnet mpls sub-networks can be found in i-d.ietf-detnet-ip. detnet mpls may use an associated controller and operations, administration, and maintenance (oam) functions that are defined outside of this document." {} {} {} 57 RFC3473, RFC4875, RFC5440, and RFC6006. OK . Thanks 72587a6c893160661ab505edf3f0e8d3690261a7 72587a6c893160661ab505edf3f0e8d3690261a7 draft-ietf-detnet-mpls c54c7fa2a5653bf1094e5f921a94d076c05bfc1849d680e6e8036cdd8d80a3d6 ['c54c7fa2a5653bf1094e5f921a94d076c05bfc1849d680e6e8036cdd8d80a3d6', '43443f87b464329eb18e3b8fa4b09cd6f56fc6495c8d5b935135f134435cd476'] A rfc3473, rfc4875, rfc5440, and rfc6006. {} {} {} 57 RFC3473, RFC4875, RFC5440, and RFC8306. OK . Thanks 72587a6c893160661ab505edf3f0e8d3690261a7 72587a6c893160661ab505edf3f0e8d3690261a7 draft-ietf-detnet-mpls 43443f87b464329eb18e3b8fa4b09cd6f56fc6495c8d5b935135f134435cd476 ['c54c7fa2a5653bf1094e5f921a94d076c05bfc1849d680e6e8036cdd8d80a3d6', '43443f87b464329eb18e3b8fa4b09cd6f56fc6495c8d5b935135f134435cd476'] B rfc3473, rfc4875, rfc5440, and rfc8306. {} {} {} 56 "Per I-D.ietf-detnet-mpls, the DetNet MPLS data plane uses a single S-Label to support a single app flow. Section 7.1. DetNet IP Flow Identification Procedures in I-D.ietf-detnet-ip states that a single DetNet flow is identified based on IP, and next level protocol, header information. Section 7.4. Aggregation Considerations in I- D.ietf-detnet-ip defines that aggregation is supported through the use of prefixes, wildcards, bitmasks, and port ranges. Collectively, this results in the fairly straight forward procedures defined in this section." resolve his comments per Oct 14 call . 832959dd6ba0b0c35a996d3520a82bafb21bd150 832959dd6ba0b0c35a996d3520a82bafb21bd150 draft-ietf-detnet-ip-over-mpls 579b516d9ca57730fb565d4430419670c629bb39295198b23984685aeaee201a ['3436c05b6ab78e77474da86a23f798b9280952989b51e6a7453a7a1afa172bb4', '579b516d9ca57730fb565d4430419670c629bb39295198b23984685aeaee201a'] A "per i-d.ietf-detnet-mpls, the detnet mpls data plane uses a single s-label to support a single app flow. section 7.1. detnet ip flow identification procedures in i-d.ietf-detnet-ip states that a single detnet flow is identified based on ip, and next level protocol, header information. section 7.4. aggregation considerations in i- d.ietf-detnet-ip defines that aggregation is supported through the use of prefixes, wildcards, bitmasks, and port ranges. collectively, this results in the fairly straight forward procedures defined in this section." {63: 1, 30: 2, 91: 2, 36: 2, 110: 3} {395: 1, 356: 2, 134: 2, 333: 2, 346: 3} {356, 134, 75, 395, 333, 346} 56 "Per I-D.ietf-detnet-mpls, the DetNet MPLS data plane uses a single S-Label to support a single app flow. Section 7.1. DetNet IP Flow Identification Procedures in I-D.ietf-detnet-ip states that a single DetNet flow is identified based on IP, and next level protocol, header information. Section 7.4. Aggregation Considerations in I- D.ietf-detnet-ip defines that aggregation is supported through the use of prefixes, wildcards, lists, and port ranges. Collectively, this results in the fairly straight forward procedures defined in this section." resolve his comments per Oct 14 call . 832959dd6ba0b0c35a996d3520a82bafb21bd150 832959dd6ba0b0c35a996d3520a82bafb21bd150 draft-ietf-detnet-ip-over-mpls 3436c05b6ab78e77474da86a23f798b9280952989b51e6a7453a7a1afa172bb4 ['3436c05b6ab78e77474da86a23f798b9280952989b51e6a7453a7a1afa172bb4', '579b516d9ca57730fb565d4430419670c629bb39295198b23984685aeaee201a'] B "per i-d.ietf-detnet-mpls, the detnet mpls data plane uses a single s-label to support a single app flow. section 7.1. detnet ip flow identification procedures in i-d.ietf-detnet-ip states that a single detnet flow is identified based on ip, and next level protocol, header information. section 7.4. aggregation considerations in i- d.ietf-detnet-ip defines that aggregation is supported through the use of prefixes, wildcards, lists, and port ranges. collectively, this results in the fairly straight forward procedures defined in this section." {63: 1, 30: 2, 91: 2, 36: 2, 110: 3} {395: 1, 356: 2, 134: 2, 333: 2, 346: 3} {356, 134, 75, 395, 333, 346} 56 Explicit Congestion Notification. resolve his comments per Oct 14 call . 832959dd6ba0b0c35a996d3520a82bafb21bd150 832959dd6ba0b0c35a996d3520a82bafb21bd150 draft-ietf-detnet-ip 6b41c3988f2ee982484e1e07e84b8ef952a84112e6e1e1a662b0369d8d477966 ['6b41c3988f2ee982484e1e07e84b8ef952a84112e6e1e1a662b0369d8d477966'] B explicit congestion notification. {} {} {167} 56 "The DetNet IP data plane uses ""6-tuple"" based flow identification, where 6-tuple refers to information carried in IP and higher layer protocol headers. The 6-tuple referred to in this document is the same as that defined in RFC3290. Specifically 6-tuple is (destination address, source address, IP protocol, source port, destination port, and differentiated services (DiffServ) code point (DSCP). General background on the use of IP headers, and 5-tuples, to identify flows and support Quality of Service (QoS) can be found in RFC3670. RFC7657 also provides useful background on the delivery of DiffServ and ""tuple"" based flow identification. Referring to a 6-tuple allows DetNet nodes to forward packets with the 6-tuple as is or remap the DSCP where required by the DetNet service." resolve his comments per Oct 14 call . 832959dd6ba0b0c35a996d3520a82bafb21bd150 832959dd6ba0b0c35a996d3520a82bafb21bd150 draft-ietf-detnet-ip 1726aa9ded1d01bbf90a01c110e2acdc8bfe7d4c2315f1531e1cdf779dadd5c6 ['e7b1deb2ec97a39249b374d672a5899fc1e28d0f54463197c2fc5fa049e18f27', '529c74ed049e346c22b062f8433d808bc13b8a15bb2898afe8be075ee4514a3b', '1726aa9ded1d01bbf90a01c110e2acdc8bfe7d4c2315f1531e1cdf779dadd5c6', 'fbd9a29ddc1391ab9f9f70db5c673a0f3c05b0886d4461d0ad6be36ee964e872', '3d98aa680516b54de01a6f5a3cbe9fb7127a5d582a69c829fddbc2cbd73c20f6', '315ac7ffbe2845d939f67d9d31548da3262eafb3624a11481b34bff6f4231126'] A "the detnet ip data plane uses ""6-tuple"" based flow identification, where 6-tuple refers to information carried in ip and higher layer protocol headers. the 6-tuple referred to in this document is the same as that defined in rfc3290. specifically 6-tuple is (destination address, source address, ip protocol, source port, destination port, and differentiated services (diffserv) code point (dscp). general background on the use of ip headers, and 5-tuples, to identify flows and support quality of service (qos) can be found in rfc3670. rfc7657 also provides useful background on the delivery of diffserv and ""tuple"" based flow identification. referring to a 6-tuple allows detnet nodes to forward packets with the 6-tuple as is or remap the dscp where required by the detnet service." {60: 1, 62: 1, 102: 3, 85: 2} {146: 1, 282: 1, 38: 3, 312: 2, 189: 3, 190: 2} {38, 368, 146, 312, 282, 189, 190} 56 "DetNet flow aggregation may be enabled via the use of wildcards, masks, prefixes and ranges. IP tunnels may also be used to support flow aggregation. In these cases, it is expected that DetNet aware intermediate nodes will provide DetNet service assurance on the aggregate through resource allocation and congestion control mechanisms." resolve his comments per Oct 14 call . 832959dd6ba0b0c35a996d3520a82bafb21bd150 832959dd6ba0b0c35a996d3520a82bafb21bd150 draft-ietf-detnet-ip e7b1deb2ec97a39249b374d672a5899fc1e28d0f54463197c2fc5fa049e18f27 ['e7b1deb2ec97a39249b374d672a5899fc1e28d0f54463197c2fc5fa049e18f27', '529c74ed049e346c22b062f8433d808bc13b8a15bb2898afe8be075ee4514a3b', '1726aa9ded1d01bbf90a01c110e2acdc8bfe7d4c2315f1531e1cdf779dadd5c6', 'fbd9a29ddc1391ab9f9f70db5c673a0f3c05b0886d4461d0ad6be36ee964e872', '3d98aa680516b54de01a6f5a3cbe9fb7127a5d582a69c829fddbc2cbd73c20f6', '315ac7ffbe2845d939f67d9d31548da3262eafb3624a11481b34bff6f4231126'] A "detnet flow aggregation may be enabled via the use of wildcards, masks, prefixes and ranges. ip tunnels may also be used to support flow aggregation. in these cases, it is expected that detnet aware intermediate nodes will provide detnet service assurance on the aggregate through resource allocation and congestion control mechanisms." {60: 1, 62: 1, 102: 3, 85: 2} {146: 1, 282: 1, 38: 3, 312: 2, 189: 3, 190: 2} {38, 368, 146, 312, 282, 189, 190} 56 "The DetNet IP data plane primarily uses ""6-tuple"" based flow identification, where 6-tuple refers to information carried in IP and higher layer protocol headers. The 6-tuple referred to in this document is the same as that defined in RFC3290. Specifically 6-tuple is (destination address, source address, IP protocol, source port, destination port, and differentiated services (DiffServ) code point (DSCP). General background on the use of IP headers, and 5-tuples, to identify flows and support Quality of Service (QoS) can be found in RFC3670. RFC7657 also provides useful background on the delivery of DiffServ and ""tuple"" based flow identification." resolve his comments per Oct 14 call . 832959dd6ba0b0c35a996d3520a82bafb21bd150 832959dd6ba0b0c35a996d3520a82bafb21bd150 draft-ietf-detnet-ip fbd9a29ddc1391ab9f9f70db5c673a0f3c05b0886d4461d0ad6be36ee964e872 ['e7b1deb2ec97a39249b374d672a5899fc1e28d0f54463197c2fc5fa049e18f27', '529c74ed049e346c22b062f8433d808bc13b8a15bb2898afe8be075ee4514a3b', '1726aa9ded1d01bbf90a01c110e2acdc8bfe7d4c2315f1531e1cdf779dadd5c6', 'fbd9a29ddc1391ab9f9f70db5c673a0f3c05b0886d4461d0ad6be36ee964e872', '3d98aa680516b54de01a6f5a3cbe9fb7127a5d582a69c829fddbc2cbd73c20f6', '315ac7ffbe2845d939f67d9d31548da3262eafb3624a11481b34bff6f4231126'] B "the detnet ip data plane primarily uses ""6-tuple"" based flow identification, where 6-tuple refers to information carried in ip and higher layer protocol headers. the 6-tuple referred to in this document is the same as that defined in rfc3290. specifically 6-tuple is (destination address, source address, ip protocol, source port, destination port, and differentiated services (diffserv) code point (dscp). general background on the use of ip headers, and 5-tuples, to identify flows and support quality of service (qos) can be found in rfc3670. rfc7657 also provides useful background on the delivery of diffserv and ""tuple"" based flow identification." {60: 1, 62: 1, 102: 3, 85: 2} {146: 1, 282: 1, 38: 3, 312: 2, 189: 3, 190: 2} {38, 368, 146, 312, 282, 189, 190} 56 "The DetNet IP data plane also allows for optional matching on two additional data fields. The optional fields are the ECN Field, as in RFC3168, and the IPv6 flow label field, as defined in RFC8200." resolve his comments per Oct 14 call . 832959dd6ba0b0c35a996d3520a82bafb21bd150 832959dd6ba0b0c35a996d3520a82bafb21bd150 draft-ietf-detnet-ip 3d98aa680516b54de01a6f5a3cbe9fb7127a5d582a69c829fddbc2cbd73c20f6 ['e7b1deb2ec97a39249b374d672a5899fc1e28d0f54463197c2fc5fa049e18f27', '529c74ed049e346c22b062f8433d808bc13b8a15bb2898afe8be075ee4514a3b', '1726aa9ded1d01bbf90a01c110e2acdc8bfe7d4c2315f1531e1cdf779dadd5c6', 'fbd9a29ddc1391ab9f9f70db5c673a0f3c05b0886d4461d0ad6be36ee964e872', '3d98aa680516b54de01a6f5a3cbe9fb7127a5d582a69c829fddbc2cbd73c20f6', '315ac7ffbe2845d939f67d9d31548da3262eafb3624a11481b34bff6f4231126'] B "the detnet ip data plane also allows for optional matching on two additional data fields. the optional fields are the ecn field, as in rfc3168, and the ipv6 flow label field, as defined in rfc8200." {60: 1, 62: 1, 102: 3, 85: 2} {146: 1, 282: 1, 38: 3, 312: 2, 189: 3, 190: 2} {38, 368, 146, 312, 282, 189, 190} 56 "Generally the fields used in flow identification are forward unmodified but modification is allowed, for example to a DSCP value, when required by the DetNet service." resolve his comments per Oct 14 call . 832959dd6ba0b0c35a996d3520a82bafb21bd150 832959dd6ba0b0c35a996d3520a82bafb21bd150 draft-ietf-detnet-ip 315ac7ffbe2845d939f67d9d31548da3262eafb3624a11481b34bff6f4231126 ['e7b1deb2ec97a39249b374d672a5899fc1e28d0f54463197c2fc5fa049e18f27', '529c74ed049e346c22b062f8433d808bc13b8a15bb2898afe8be075ee4514a3b', '1726aa9ded1d01bbf90a01c110e2acdc8bfe7d4c2315f1531e1cdf779dadd5c6', 'fbd9a29ddc1391ab9f9f70db5c673a0f3c05b0886d4461d0ad6be36ee964e872', '3d98aa680516b54de01a6f5a3cbe9fb7127a5d582a69c829fddbc2cbd73c20f6', '315ac7ffbe2845d939f67d9d31548da3262eafb3624a11481b34bff6f4231126'] B "generally the fields used in flow identification are forward unmodified but modification is allowed, for example to a dscp value, when required by the detnet service." {60: 1, 62: 1, 102: 3, 85: 2} {146: 1, 282: 1, 38: 3, 312: 2, 189: 3, 190: 2} {38, 368, 146, 312, 282, 189, 190} 56 "DetNet flow aggregation may be enabled via the use of wildcards, masks, lists, prefixes and ranges. IP tunnels may also be used to support flow aggregation. In these cases, it is expected that DetNet aware intermediate nodes will provide DetNet service assurance on the aggregate through resource allocation and congestion control mechanisms." resolve his comments per Oct 14 call . 832959dd6ba0b0c35a996d3520a82bafb21bd150 832959dd6ba0b0c35a996d3520a82bafb21bd150 draft-ietf-detnet-ip 529c74ed049e346c22b062f8433d808bc13b8a15bb2898afe8be075ee4514a3b ['e7b1deb2ec97a39249b374d672a5899fc1e28d0f54463197c2fc5fa049e18f27', '529c74ed049e346c22b062f8433d808bc13b8a15bb2898afe8be075ee4514a3b', '1726aa9ded1d01bbf90a01c110e2acdc8bfe7d4c2315f1531e1cdf779dadd5c6', 'fbd9a29ddc1391ab9f9f70db5c673a0f3c05b0886d4461d0ad6be36ee964e872', '3d98aa680516b54de01a6f5a3cbe9fb7127a5d582a69c829fddbc2cbd73c20f6', '315ac7ffbe2845d939f67d9d31548da3262eafb3624a11481b34bff6f4231126'] B "detnet flow aggregation may be enabled via the use of wildcards, masks, lists, prefixes and ranges. ip tunnels may also be used to support flow aggregation. in these cases, it is expected that detnet aware intermediate nodes will provide detnet service assurance on the aggregate through resource allocation and congestion control mechanisms." {60: 1, 62: 1, 102: 3, 85: 2} {146: 1, 282: 1, 38: 3, 312: 2, 189: 3, 190: 2} {38, 368, 146, 312, 282, 189, 190} 56 "In order to maximize reuse of 5-tuple based mechanisms, e.g, traceroute, DetNet aware applications and end systems SHOULD NOT mix DetNet and non-DetNet traffic within a single 5-tuple." resolve his comments per Oct 14 call . 832959dd6ba0b0c35a996d3520a82bafb21bd150 832959dd6ba0b0c35a996d3520a82bafb21bd150 draft-ietf-detnet-ip 586147cf635541ce0930e441ab43112c6170f1a1bd5e4892961cb14b5d442b2b ['586147cf635541ce0930e441ab43112c6170f1a1bd5e4892961cb14b5d442b2b'] B "in order to maximize reuse of 5-tuple based mechanisms, e.g, traceroute, detnet aware applications and end systems should not mix detnet and non-detnet traffic within a single 5-tuple." {62: 1, 67: 2, 13: 2, 102: 2} {171: 1, 200: 2, 223: 2, 295: 2} {295, 200, 171, 141, 223} 56 "Note that not mixing DetNet and non-DetNet traffic within a single 5-tuple, as described above, enables simpler 5-tuple filters to be reused at the edges of a DetNet network to prevent non-congestion responsive DetNet traffic from escaping the DetNet domain." resolve his comments per Oct 14 call . 832959dd6ba0b0c35a996d3520a82bafb21bd150 832959dd6ba0b0c35a996d3520a82bafb21bd150 draft-ietf-detnet-ip 3360a796437e0afeabb77c2572808eac8dd92be3ecd12723c545de974ab208bf ['3360a796437e0afeabb77c2572808eac8dd92be3ecd12723c545de974ab208bf'] B "note that not mixing detnet and non-detnet traffic within a single 5-tuple, as described above, enables simpler 5-tuple filters to be reused at the edges of a detnet network to prevent non-congestion responsive detnet traffic from escaping the detnet domain." {62: 1} {73: 1} {72, 73} 56 "Quality of Service (QoS) for DetNet service flows carried in IP MUST be provided locally by the DetNet-aware hosts and routers supporting DetNet flows. Such support leverages the underlying network layer such as 802.1 TSN. The traffic control mechanisms used to deliver QoS for IP encapsulated DetNet flows are expected to be defined in a future document. From an encapsulation perspective, the combination of the 6-tuple i.e., the typical 5-tuple enhanced with the DSCP code, uniquely identifies a DetNet service flow." resolve his comments per Oct 14 call . 832959dd6ba0b0c35a996d3520a82bafb21bd150 832959dd6ba0b0c35a996d3520a82bafb21bd150 draft-ietf-detnet-ip 767450f9172193307412f183fdf48209e2c334ab888fe7f0fb09f52dc7e8ee18 ['edae7bd78053411c01d803eb09feb670f4d1fdf32e7a1d5f70b50c6a4f09c308', '767450f9172193307412f183fdf48209e2c334ab888fe7f0fb09f52dc7e8ee18'] A "quality of service (qos) for detnet service flows carried in ip must be provided locally by the detnet-aware hosts and routers supporting detnet flows. such support leverages the underlying network layer such as 802.1 tsn. the traffic control mechanisms used to deliver qos for ip encapsulated detnet flows are expected to be defined in a future document. from an encapsulation perspective, the combination of the 6-tuple i.e., the typical 5-tuple enhanced with the dscp code, uniquely identifies a detnet service flow." {60: 1} {292: 1} {292, 381} 56 "Quality of Service (QoS) for DetNet service flows carried in IP MUST be provided locally by the DetNet-aware hosts and routers supporting DetNet flows. Such support leverages the underlying network layer such as 802.1 TSN. The traffic control mechanisms used to deliver QoS for IP encapsulated DetNet flows are expected to be defined in a future document. From an encapsulation perspective, the combination of the 6-tuple i.e., the typical 5-tuple enhanced with the DSCP and previously mentioned two optional fields, uniquely identifies a DetNet service flow." resolve his comments per Oct 14 call . 832959dd6ba0b0c35a996d3520a82bafb21bd150 832959dd6ba0b0c35a996d3520a82bafb21bd150 draft-ietf-detnet-ip edae7bd78053411c01d803eb09feb670f4d1fdf32e7a1d5f70b50c6a4f09c308 ['edae7bd78053411c01d803eb09feb670f4d1fdf32e7a1d5f70b50c6a4f09c308', '767450f9172193307412f183fdf48209e2c334ab888fe7f0fb09f52dc7e8ee18'] B "quality of service (qos) for detnet service flows carried in ip must be provided locally by the detnet-aware hosts and routers supporting detnet flows. such support leverages the underlying network layer such as 802.1 tsn. the traffic control mechanisms used to deliver qos for ip encapsulated detnet flows are expected to be defined in a future document. from an encapsulation perspective, the combination of the 6-tuple i.e., the typical 5-tuple enhanced with the dscp and previously mentioned two optional fields, uniquely identifies a detnet service flow." {60: 1} {292: 1} {292, 381} 56 "While path selection algorithms and mechanisms are out of scope of the DetNet data plane definition, it is important to highlight the implications of DetNet IP flow identification on path selection and next hops. As mentioned above, the DetNet IP data plane identifies flows using ""6-tuple"" header information as well as two additional optional header fields. DetNet generally allows for both flow- specific traffic treatment and flow-specific next-hops." resolve his comments per Oct 14 call . 832959dd6ba0b0c35a996d3520a82bafb21bd150 832959dd6ba0b0c35a996d3520a82bafb21bd150 draft-ietf-detnet-ip 6237efce14a2f9d507e4815a4f48b88b001a98eaca040a6e8e0f91e8fa7eaa75 ['379ed7662391edd7193f56bb9f62e34722f00818f68a2f78b11f5bcad444a9c4', 'e785c312c8f6fcb8cc39fabe2da9eab3a234620125e2a92de07cd181c9115a85', '6237efce14a2f9d507e4815a4f48b88b001a98eaca040a6e8e0f91e8fa7eaa75'] B "while path selection algorithms and mechanisms are out of scope of the detnet data plane definition, it is important to highlight the implications of detnet ip flow identification on path selection and next hops. as mentioned above, the detnet ip data plane identifies flows using ""6-tuple"" header information as well as two additional optional header fields. detnet generally allows for both flow- specific traffic treatment and flow-specific next-hops." {102: 1, 62: 1, 60: 1} {79: 1, 367: 1, 383: 1, 382: 2} {367, 80, 79, 382, 383} 56 "In non-DetNet IP forwarding, it is generally assumed that the same series of next hops, i.e., the same path, will be used for a particular 5-tuple or, in some cases, e.g., RFC5120, for a particular 6-tuple. Using different next hops for different 5-tuples does not take any special consideration for DetNet aware applications." resolve his comments per Oct 14 call . 832959dd6ba0b0c35a996d3520a82bafb21bd150 832959dd6ba0b0c35a996d3520a82bafb21bd150 draft-ietf-detnet-ip e785c312c8f6fcb8cc39fabe2da9eab3a234620125e2a92de07cd181c9115a85 ['379ed7662391edd7193f56bb9f62e34722f00818f68a2f78b11f5bcad444a9c4', 'e785c312c8f6fcb8cc39fabe2da9eab3a234620125e2a92de07cd181c9115a85', '6237efce14a2f9d507e4815a4f48b88b001a98eaca040a6e8e0f91e8fa7eaa75'] B "in non-detnet ip forwarding, it is generally assumed that the same series of next hops, i.e., the same path, will be used for a particular 5-tuple or, in some cases, e.g., rfc5120, for a particular 6-tuple. using different next hops for different 5-tuples does not take any special consideration for detnet aware applications." {102: 1, 62: 1, 60: 1} {79: 1, 367: 1, 383: 1, 382: 2} {367, 80, 79, 382, 383} 56 "Care should be taken when using different next hops for the same 5-tuple. As discussed in RFC7657, unexpected behavior can occur when a single 5-tuple application flow experience reordering due to being split across multiple next hops. Understanding of the application and transport protocol impact of using different next hops for the same 6-tuple is required. Again, this impacts path selection for DetNet flows and this document only indirectly." resolve his comments per Oct 14 call . 832959dd6ba0b0c35a996d3520a82bafb21bd150 832959dd6ba0b0c35a996d3520a82bafb21bd150 draft-ietf-detnet-ip 379ed7662391edd7193f56bb9f62e34722f00818f68a2f78b11f5bcad444a9c4 ['379ed7662391edd7193f56bb9f62e34722f00818f68a2f78b11f5bcad444a9c4', 'e785c312c8f6fcb8cc39fabe2da9eab3a234620125e2a92de07cd181c9115a85', '6237efce14a2f9d507e4815a4f48b88b001a98eaca040a6e8e0f91e8fa7eaa75'] B "care should be taken when using different next hops for the same 5-tuple. as discussed in rfc7657, unexpected behavior can occur when a single 5-tuple application flow experience reordering due to being split across multiple next hops. understanding of the application and transport protocol impact of using different next hops for the same 6-tuple is required. again, this impacts path selection for detnet flows and this document only indirectly." {102: 1, 62: 1, 60: 1} {79: 1, 367: 1, 383: 1, 382: 2} {367, 80, 79, 382, 383} 56 "From a single node perspective, the aggregation of IP flows impacts DetNet IP data plane flow identification and resource allocation. As discussed above, IP flow identification uses the IP ""6-tuple"" for flow identification. DetNet IP flows can be aggregated using any of the 6-tuple fields defined in ip-flow-id. The use of prefixes, wildcards, bitmasks, and value ranges allows a DetNet node to identify aggregate DetNet flows. From a resource allocation perspective, DetNet nodes must provide service to a aggregate and not on a component flow basis." resolve his comments per Oct 14 call . 832959dd6ba0b0c35a996d3520a82bafb21bd150 832959dd6ba0b0c35a996d3520a82bafb21bd150 draft-ietf-detnet-ip 662aa0d783f701117ae9f6c23ee467f7f8526a1989762db6050bdf9b769ebfbf ['662aa0d783f701117ae9f6c23ee467f7f8526a1989762db6050bdf9b769ebfbf', '260c526752ebe3fe2227ec577fbbb13f4dc3f09a3c5140247dc59c72a1978cf7'] A "from a single node perspective, the aggregation of ip flows impacts detnet ip data plane flow identification and resource allocation. as discussed above, ip flow identification uses the ip ""6-tuple"" for flow identification. detnet ip flows can be aggregated using any of the 6-tuple fields defined in ip-flow-id. the use of prefixes, wildcards, bitmasks, and value ranges allows a detnet node to identify aggregate detnet flows. from a resource allocation perspective, detnet nodes must provide service to a aggregate and not on a component flow basis." {60: 1, 26: 1, 27: 2, 102: 2, 62: 2, 85: 3, 13: 2} {52: 1, 160: 1, 259: 2, 359: 2, 370: 2, 246: 3, 284: 2} {160, 259, 359, 370, 52, 246, 284, 159} 56 "From a single node perspective, the aggregation of IP flows impacts DetNet IP data plane flow identification and resource allocation. As discussed above, IP flow identification uses the IP ""6-tuple"" for flow identification. DetNet IP flows can be aggregated using any of the 6-tuple, or two additional optional fields defined in ip-flow-id. The use of prefixes, wildcards, lists, and value ranges allows a DetNet node to identify aggregate DetNet flows. From a resource allocation perspective, DetNet nodes must provide service to a aggregate and not on a component flow basis." resolve his comments per Oct 14 call . 832959dd6ba0b0c35a996d3520a82bafb21bd150 832959dd6ba0b0c35a996d3520a82bafb21bd150 draft-ietf-detnet-ip 260c526752ebe3fe2227ec577fbbb13f4dc3f09a3c5140247dc59c72a1978cf7 ['662aa0d783f701117ae9f6c23ee467f7f8526a1989762db6050bdf9b769ebfbf', '260c526752ebe3fe2227ec577fbbb13f4dc3f09a3c5140247dc59c72a1978cf7'] B "from a single node perspective, the aggregation of ip flows impacts detnet ip data plane flow identification and resource allocation. as discussed above, ip flow identification uses the ip ""6-tuple"" for flow identification. detnet ip flows can be aggregated using any of the 6-tuple, or two additional optional fields defined in ip-flow-id. the use of prefixes, wildcards, lists, and value ranges allows a detnet node to identify aggregate detnet flows. from a resource allocation perspective, detnet nodes must provide service to a aggregate and not on a component flow basis." {60: 1, 26: 1, 27: 2, 102: 2, 62: 2, 85: 3, 13: 2} {52: 1, 160: 1, 259: 2, 359: 2, 370: 2, 246: 3, 284: 2} {160, 259, 359, 370, 52, 246, 284, 159} 56 "These fields are used to support Differentiated Services RFC2474 and Explicit Congestion Notification RFC3168. Implementations of this document MUST support DetNet flow identification based on the IPv4 Type of Service field when processing IPv4 packets, and the IPv6 Traffic Class Field when processing IPv6 packets. Implementations MUST support bitmask based matching, where bits set to one (1) in the bitmask indicate which subset of the bits in the field are to be used in determining a match. Note that all bits set to zero (0) value as a bitmask effectively means that these fields are ignored." resolve his comments per Oct 14 call . 832959dd6ba0b0c35a996d3520a82bafb21bd150 832959dd6ba0b0c35a996d3520a82bafb21bd150 draft-ietf-detnet-ip 6a63d9689280158ea74c88e41cd6bacc8ee94423ce73cdf3c2094347e4d96c5a ['6a63d9689280158ea74c88e41cd6bacc8ee94423ce73cdf3c2094347e4d96c5a', 'c368f75a4199d83c7430b1f1eac16130aa07fda56efa17d42da3360dffbb0a86', '92990758301c318d415c89ac34c0beb81e876f9668ed083ecd9e56fd78699a48'] A "these fields are used to support differentiated services rfc2474 and explicit congestion notification rfc3168. implementations of this document must support detnet flow identification based on the ipv4 type of service field when processing ipv4 packets, and the ipv6 traffic class field when processing ipv6 packets. implementations must support bitmask based matching, where bits set to one (1) in the bitmask indicate which subset of the bits in the field are to be used in determining a match. note that all bits set to zero (0) value as a bitmask effectively means that these fields are ignored." {60: 1, 102: 2} {344: 1, 345: 2} {344, 345, 164} 56 "These fields are used to support Differentiated Services RFC2474 and Explicit Congestion Notification RFC3168. Implementations of this document MUST support DetNet flow identification based on the IPv4 Type of Service field when processing IPv4 packets, and the IPv6 Traffic Class Field when processing IPv6 packets. Implementations MUST support list based matching of DSCP values, where the list is composed of possible field values that are to be considered when identifying a specific DetNet flow. Implementations SHOULD allow for this field to be ignored for a specific DetNet flow." resolve his comments per Oct 14 call . 832959dd6ba0b0c35a996d3520a82bafb21bd150 832959dd6ba0b0c35a996d3520a82bafb21bd150 draft-ietf-detnet-ip 92990758301c318d415c89ac34c0beb81e876f9668ed083ecd9e56fd78699a48 ['6a63d9689280158ea74c88e41cd6bacc8ee94423ce73cdf3c2094347e4d96c5a', 'c368f75a4199d83c7430b1f1eac16130aa07fda56efa17d42da3360dffbb0a86', '92990758301c318d415c89ac34c0beb81e876f9668ed083ecd9e56fd78699a48'] B "these fields are used to support differentiated services rfc2474 and explicit congestion notification rfc3168. implementations of this document must support detnet flow identification based on the ipv4 type of service field when processing ipv4 packets, and the ipv6 traffic class field when processing ipv6 packets. implementations must support list based matching of dscp values, where the list is composed of possible field values that are to be considered when identifying a specific detnet flow. implementations should allow for this field to be ignored for a specific detnet flow." {60: 1, 102: 2} {344: 1, 345: 2} {344, 345, 164} 56 "Implementations of this document MUST allow the ECN field to be ignored as part of DetNet flow identification. Additionally, implementations SHOULD support identification of DetNet flows based on the value carried in the ECN field. When this field is used to identify a specific DetNet flow, implementations MUST support a list of ECN values that match a specific slow." resolve his comments per Oct 14 call . 832959dd6ba0b0c35a996d3520a82bafb21bd150 832959dd6ba0b0c35a996d3520a82bafb21bd150 draft-ietf-detnet-ip c368f75a4199d83c7430b1f1eac16130aa07fda56efa17d42da3360dffbb0a86 ['6a63d9689280158ea74c88e41cd6bacc8ee94423ce73cdf3c2094347e4d96c5a', 'c368f75a4199d83c7430b1f1eac16130aa07fda56efa17d42da3360dffbb0a86', '92990758301c318d415c89ac34c0beb81e876f9668ed083ecd9e56fd78699a48'] B "implementations of this document must allow the ecn field to be ignored as part of detnet flow identification. additionally, implementations should support identification of detnet flows based on the value carried in the ecn field. when this field is used to identify a specific detnet flow, implementations must support a list of ecn values that match a specific slow." {60: 1, 102: 2} {344: 1, 345: 2} {344, 345, 164} 56 IPv4 Type of Service and IPv6 Traffic Class Fields. resolve his comments per Oct 14 call . 832959dd6ba0b0c35a996d3520a82bafb21bd150 832959dd6ba0b0c35a996d3520a82bafb21bd150 draft-ietf-detnet-ip 4f7a168d3aabe87035387dd5ed5d34faa28fab189b0c1b7473456086f1761fc8 ['a9d9bfcd10e75c9e7c0a530418daf779856a676ecbe97ff9c54e7e2a7feb2c52', 'e21941d35baca191b439d76713c4d1a96cb0019bf417ca069e1067ccfdaab083', '2cc501aecbca542e8a89581cc80369d31be3e3fc2280905928a095b8b24250e8', '4f7a168d3aabe87035387dd5ed5d34faa28fab189b0c1b7473456086f1761fc8', '6a045f59ae53d8c90751f230e053f9392cc5e00ef0382c3dbf69c8cd5273bbb0', 'c5286e5f2f650dc15466adcf108165abf439ed3a89340a782042fe713c6de8ac'] A ipv4 type of service and ipv6 traffic class fields. {33: 1, 32: 1, 83: 1, 64: 1, 60: 1, 85: 1, 102: 2, 38: 2, 62: 3, 71: 2, 26: 2, 113: 2, 126: 3, 112: 2, 129: 3} {31: 1, 33: 1, 163: 1, 231: 1, 260: 1, 363: 1, 274: 2, 339: 3, 212: 2, 343: 3, 283: 3, 286: 4, 32: 2, 228: 2, 357: 2, 166: 3, 298: 2, 46: 3, 377: 2} {260, 261, 274, 283, 286, 31, 32, 33, 163, 166, 298, 46, 339, 212, 343, 228, 357, 231, 363, 377} 56 "IPv4 Type of Service and IPv6 Traffic Class Field Bitmask, where a zero (0) effectively means that theses fields are ignored." resolve his comments per Oct 14 call . 832959dd6ba0b0c35a996d3520a82bafb21bd150 832959dd6ba0b0c35a996d3520a82bafb21bd150 draft-ietf-detnet-ip c5286e5f2f650dc15466adcf108165abf439ed3a89340a782042fe713c6de8ac ['a9d9bfcd10e75c9e7c0a530418daf779856a676ecbe97ff9c54e7e2a7feb2c52', 'e21941d35baca191b439d76713c4d1a96cb0019bf417ca069e1067ccfdaab083', '2cc501aecbca542e8a89581cc80369d31be3e3fc2280905928a095b8b24250e8', '4f7a168d3aabe87035387dd5ed5d34faa28fab189b0c1b7473456086f1761fc8', '6a045f59ae53d8c90751f230e053f9392cc5e00ef0382c3dbf69c8cd5273bbb0', 'c5286e5f2f650dc15466adcf108165abf439ed3a89340a782042fe713c6de8ac'] A "ipv4 type of service and ipv6 traffic class field bitmask, where a zero (0) effectively means that theses fields are ignored." {33: 1, 32: 1, 83: 1, 64: 1, 60: 1, 85: 1, 102: 2, 38: 2, 62: 3, 71: 2, 26: 2, 113: 2, 126: 3, 112: 2, 129: 3} {31: 1, 33: 1, 163: 1, 231: 1, 260: 1, 363: 1, 274: 2, 339: 3, 212: 2, 343: 3, 283: 3, 286: 4, 32: 2, 228: 2, 357: 2, 166: 3, 298: 2, 46: 3, 377: 2} {260, 261, 274, 283, 286, 31, 32, 33, 163, 166, 298, 46, 339, 212, 343, 228, 357, 231, 363, 377} 56 "If the DSCP field is to be used in flow identification. Ignoring the DSCP filed is optional." resolve his comments per Oct 14 call . 832959dd6ba0b0c35a996d3520a82bafb21bd150 832959dd6ba0b0c35a996d3520a82bafb21bd150 draft-ietf-detnet-ip 6a045f59ae53d8c90751f230e053f9392cc5e00ef0382c3dbf69c8cd5273bbb0 ['a9d9bfcd10e75c9e7c0a530418daf779856a676ecbe97ff9c54e7e2a7feb2c52', 'e21941d35baca191b439d76713c4d1a96cb0019bf417ca069e1067ccfdaab083', '2cc501aecbca542e8a89581cc80369d31be3e3fc2280905928a095b8b24250e8', '4f7a168d3aabe87035387dd5ed5d34faa28fab189b0c1b7473456086f1761fc8', '6a045f59ae53d8c90751f230e053f9392cc5e00ef0382c3dbf69c8cd5273bbb0', 'c5286e5f2f650dc15466adcf108165abf439ed3a89340a782042fe713c6de8ac'] B "if the dscp field is to be used in flow identification. ignoring the dscp filed is optional." {33: 1, 32: 1, 83: 1, 64: 1, 60: 1, 85: 1, 102: 2, 38: 2, 62: 3, 71: 2, 26: 2, 113: 2, 126: 3, 112: 2, 129: 3} {31: 1, 33: 1, 163: 1, 231: 1, 260: 1, 363: 1, 274: 2, 339: 3, 212: 2, 343: 3, 283: 3, 286: 4, 32: 2, 228: 2, 357: 2, 166: 3, 298: 2, 46: 3, 377: 2} {260, 261, 274, 283, 286, 31, 32, 33, 163, 166, 298, 46, 339, 212, 343, 228, 357, 231, 363, 377} 56 "When the DSCP field is used in flow identification, a list of field values that may be used by a specific flow." resolve his comments per Oct 14 call . 832959dd6ba0b0c35a996d3520a82bafb21bd150 832959dd6ba0b0c35a996d3520a82bafb21bd150 draft-ietf-detnet-ip e21941d35baca191b439d76713c4d1a96cb0019bf417ca069e1067ccfdaab083 ['a9d9bfcd10e75c9e7c0a530418daf779856a676ecbe97ff9c54e7e2a7feb2c52', 'e21941d35baca191b439d76713c4d1a96cb0019bf417ca069e1067ccfdaab083', '2cc501aecbca542e8a89581cc80369d31be3e3fc2280905928a095b8b24250e8', '4f7a168d3aabe87035387dd5ed5d34faa28fab189b0c1b7473456086f1761fc8', '6a045f59ae53d8c90751f230e053f9392cc5e00ef0382c3dbf69c8cd5273bbb0', 'c5286e5f2f650dc15466adcf108165abf439ed3a89340a782042fe713c6de8ac'] B "when the dscp field is used in flow identification, a list of field values that may be used by a specific flow." {33: 1, 32: 1, 83: 1, 64: 1, 60: 1, 85: 1, 102: 2, 38: 2, 62: 3, 71: 2, 26: 2, 113: 2, 126: 3, 112: 2, 129: 3} {31: 1, 33: 1, 163: 1, 231: 1, 260: 1, 363: 1, 274: 2, 339: 3, 212: 2, 343: 3, 283: 3, 286: 4, 32: 2, 228: 2, 357: 2, 166: 3, 298: 2, 46: 3, 377: 2} {260, 261, 274, 283, 286, 31, 32, 33, 163, 166, 298, 46, 339, 212, 343, 228, 357, 231, 363, 377} 56 "If the ECN field is to be used in flow identification. Matching based on ECN filed values is optional." resolve his comments per Oct 14 call . 832959dd6ba0b0c35a996d3520a82bafb21bd150 832959dd6ba0b0c35a996d3520a82bafb21bd150 draft-ietf-detnet-ip 2cc501aecbca542e8a89581cc80369d31be3e3fc2280905928a095b8b24250e8 ['a9d9bfcd10e75c9e7c0a530418daf779856a676ecbe97ff9c54e7e2a7feb2c52', 'e21941d35baca191b439d76713c4d1a96cb0019bf417ca069e1067ccfdaab083', '2cc501aecbca542e8a89581cc80369d31be3e3fc2280905928a095b8b24250e8', '4f7a168d3aabe87035387dd5ed5d34faa28fab189b0c1b7473456086f1761fc8', '6a045f59ae53d8c90751f230e053f9392cc5e00ef0382c3dbf69c8cd5273bbb0', 'c5286e5f2f650dc15466adcf108165abf439ed3a89340a782042fe713c6de8ac'] B "if the ecn field is to be used in flow identification. matching based on ecn filed values is optional." {33: 1, 32: 1, 83: 1, 64: 1, 60: 1, 85: 1, 102: 2, 38: 2, 62: 3, 71: 2, 26: 2, 113: 2, 126: 3, 112: 2, 129: 3} {31: 1, 33: 1, 163: 1, 231: 1, 260: 1, 363: 1, 274: 2, 339: 3, 212: 2, 343: 3, 283: 3, 286: 4, 32: 2, 228: 2, 357: 2, 166: 3, 298: 2, 46: 3, 377: 2} {260, 261, 274, 283, 286, 31, 32, 33, 163, 166, 298, 46, 339, 212, 343, 228, 357, 231, 363, 377} 56 "When ECN field is used in flow identification, a list of field values that may be used by a specific flow." resolve his comments per Oct 14 call . 832959dd6ba0b0c35a996d3520a82bafb21bd150 832959dd6ba0b0c35a996d3520a82bafb21bd150 draft-ietf-detnet-ip a9d9bfcd10e75c9e7c0a530418daf779856a676ecbe97ff9c54e7e2a7feb2c52 ['a9d9bfcd10e75c9e7c0a530418daf779856a676ecbe97ff9c54e7e2a7feb2c52', 'e21941d35baca191b439d76713c4d1a96cb0019bf417ca069e1067ccfdaab083', '2cc501aecbca542e8a89581cc80369d31be3e3fc2280905928a095b8b24250e8', '4f7a168d3aabe87035387dd5ed5d34faa28fab189b0c1b7473456086f1761fc8', '6a045f59ae53d8c90751f230e053f9392cc5e00ef0382c3dbf69c8cd5273bbb0', 'c5286e5f2f650dc15466adcf108165abf439ed3a89340a782042fe713c6de8ac'] B "when ecn field is used in flow identification, a list of field values that may be used by a specific flow." {33: 1, 32: 1, 83: 1, 64: 1, 60: 1, 85: 1, 102: 2, 38: 2, 62: 3, 71: 2, 26: 2, 113: 2, 126: 3, 112: 2, 129: 3} {31: 1, 33: 1, 163: 1, 231: 1, 260: 1, 363: 1, 274: 2, 339: 3, 212: 2, 343: 3, 283: 3, 286: 4, 32: 2, 228: 2, 357: 2, 166: 3, 298: 2, 46: 3, 377: 2} {260, 261, 274, 283, 286, 31, 32, 33, 163, 166, 298, 46, 339, 212, 343, 228, 357, 231, 363, 377} 55 "This document provides an overall framework for the Deterministic Networking data plane. It covers concepts and considerations that are generally common to any Deterministic Networking data plane specification." "Update based on the comments of ( 01.10 ) and ( 04.10 ) . I agree with , it 's a well - known and deployed example . I 'm not sure why it was removed . Cheers , comments have been resolved" 5627886f9da3fa5ecb5b7bcfceeb9ab7c3c19e9f 5627886f9da3fa5ecb5b7bcfceeb9ab7c3c19e9f draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework a7228dbbaceab75b948f0fad7513810edde3e62ac0cad5cb6e836bd1b2bf8af4 ['30ae1549030b97583f33f7f53045c22dc52d45e745e519d0c21886cedd3953b4', '647cc34881a74e186b4e0e5f3ea854a321e0dce68b2ed80157c09279b837a105', 'a7228dbbaceab75b948f0fad7513810edde3e62ac0cad5cb6e836bd1b2bf8af4', 'd1b8d09d5e630c379b5359b0282f20f77ae549765b1fccdef4bdbb94a56a98e2'] A "this document provides an overall framework for the deterministic networking data plane. it covers concepts and considerations that are generally common to any deterministic networking data plane specification." {8: 1, 90: 1, 67: 1, 6: 2} {60: 1, 106: 1, 375: 1, 113: 2} {106, 113, 375, 60, 61} 55 "Deterministic Networking (DetNet) provides a capability to carry specified unicast or multicast data flows for real-time applications with extremely low packet loss rates and assured maximum end-to-end delivery latency. A description of the general background and concepts of DetNet can be found in I-D.ietf-detnet-architecture." "Update based on the comments of ( 01.10 ) and ( 04.10 ) . I agree with , it 's a well - known and deployed example . I 'm not sure why it was removed . Cheers , comments have been resolved" 5627886f9da3fa5ecb5b7bcfceeb9ab7c3c19e9f 5627886f9da3fa5ecb5b7bcfceeb9ab7c3c19e9f draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework 30ae1549030b97583f33f7f53045c22dc52d45e745e519d0c21886cedd3953b4 ['30ae1549030b97583f33f7f53045c22dc52d45e745e519d0c21886cedd3953b4', '647cc34881a74e186b4e0e5f3ea854a321e0dce68b2ed80157c09279b837a105', 'a7228dbbaceab75b948f0fad7513810edde3e62ac0cad5cb6e836bd1b2bf8af4', 'd1b8d09d5e630c379b5359b0282f20f77ae549765b1fccdef4bdbb94a56a98e2'] A "deterministic networking (detnet) provides a capability to carry specified unicast or multicast data flows for real-time applications with extremely low packet loss rates and assured maximum end-to-end delivery latency. a description of the general background and concepts of detnet can be found in i-d.ietf-detnet-architecture." {8: 1, 90: 1, 67: 1, 6: 2} {60: 1, 106: 1, 375: 1, 113: 2} {106, 113, 375, 60, 61} 55 "This document provides an overall framework for the DetNet data plane. It covers concepts and considerations that are generally common to any Deterministic Networking data plane specification." "Update based on the comments of ( 01.10 ) and ( 04.10 ) . I agree with , it 's a well - known and deployed example . I 'm not sure why it was removed . Cheers , comments have been resolved" 5627886f9da3fa5ecb5b7bcfceeb9ab7c3c19e9f 5627886f9da3fa5ecb5b7bcfceeb9ab7c3c19e9f draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework 647cc34881a74e186b4e0e5f3ea854a321e0dce68b2ed80157c09279b837a105 ['30ae1549030b97583f33f7f53045c22dc52d45e745e519d0c21886cedd3953b4', '647cc34881a74e186b4e0e5f3ea854a321e0dce68b2ed80157c09279b837a105', 'a7228dbbaceab75b948f0fad7513810edde3e62ac0cad5cb6e836bd1b2bf8af4', 'd1b8d09d5e630c379b5359b0282f20f77ae549765b1fccdef4bdbb94a56a98e2'] B "this document provides an overall framework for the detnet data plane. it covers concepts and considerations that are generally common to any deterministic networking data plane specification." {8: 1, 90: 1, 67: 1, 6: 2} {60: 1, 106: 1, 375: 1, 113: 2} {106, 113, 375, 60, 61} 55 "DetNet (Deterministic Networking) provides a capability to carry specified unicast or multicast data flows for real-time applications with extremely low packet loss rates and assured maximum end-to-end delivery latency. A description of the general background and concepts of DetNet can be found in I-D.ietf-detnet-architecture." "Update based on the comments of ( 01.10 ) and ( 04.10 ) . I agree with , it 's a well - known and deployed example . I 'm not sure why it was removed . Cheers , comments have been resolved" 5627886f9da3fa5ecb5b7bcfceeb9ab7c3c19e9f 5627886f9da3fa5ecb5b7bcfceeb9ab7c3c19e9f draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework d1b8d09d5e630c379b5359b0282f20f77ae549765b1fccdef4bdbb94a56a98e2 ['30ae1549030b97583f33f7f53045c22dc52d45e745e519d0c21886cedd3953b4', '647cc34881a74e186b4e0e5f3ea854a321e0dce68b2ed80157c09279b837a105', 'a7228dbbaceab75b948f0fad7513810edde3e62ac0cad5cb6e836bd1b2bf8af4', 'd1b8d09d5e630c379b5359b0282f20f77ae549765b1fccdef4bdbb94a56a98e2'] B "detnet (deterministic networking) provides a capability to carry specified unicast or multicast data flows for real-time applications with extremely low packet loss rates and assured maximum end-to-end delivery latency. a description of the general background and concepts of detnet can be found in i-d.ietf-detnet-architecture." {8: 1, 90: 1, 67: 1, 6: 2} {60: 1, 106: 1, 375: 1, 113: 2} {106, 113, 375, 60, 61} 55 "The DetNet Architecture models the DetNet related data plane functions decomposed into two sub-layers: a service sub-layer and a forwarding sub-layer. The service sub-layer is used to provide DetNet service protection and reordering. The forwarding sub-layer is used to provide congestion protection (low loss, assured latency, and limited out-of-order delivery) and leverages Traffic Engineering mechanisms." "Update based on the comments of ( 01.10 ) and ( 04.10 ) . I agree with , it 's a well - known and deployed example . I 'm not sure why it was removed . Cheers , comments have been resolved" 5627886f9da3fa5ecb5b7bcfceeb9ab7c3c19e9f 5627886f9da3fa5ecb5b7bcfceeb9ab7c3c19e9f draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework b81b66a28fd8768804454f03c1b4911ca5d0234e80b8259cbfa27139b475c080 ['772b85d3bb02da9f14ffb89c621617e2ac18b8e3807dbd4286803c7169505810', '4022ead35c2d329a5ba02b76ffd6e624e14d2317dbcd2328b803db3f88d69444', 'b81b66a28fd8768804454f03c1b4911ca5d0234e80b8259cbfa27139b475c080', 'c52c7cf23463e9a43ab1e2eb946445da7193b68253e8938c10d3de6b90e2bab2'] A "the detnet architecture models the detnet related data plane functions decomposed into two sub-layers: a service sub-layer and a forwarding sub-layer. the service sub-layer is used to provide detnet service protection and reordering. the forwarding sub-layer is used to provide congestion protection (low loss, assured latency, and limited out-of-order delivery) and leverages traffic engineering mechanisms." {68: 1, 84: 1, 90: 2, 6: 3, 55: 2} {181: 1, 373: 1, 37: 2, 232: 3, 173: 3, 87: 2, 374: 2, 53: 2} {37, 232, 173, 373, 182, 87, 181, 374, 53} 55 "As part of the service sub-layer functions, this document describes typical DetNet node data plane operation. It describes the function and operation of the Packet Replication (PRF) Packet Elimination (PEF) and the Packet Ordering (POF) functions within the service sub- layer. It also describes the forwarding sub-layer that is used to eliminate (or reduce) contention loss and provide bounded latency for DetNet flows." "Update based on the comments of ( 01.10 ) and ( 04.10 ) . I agree with , it 's a well - known and deployed example . I 'm not sure why it was removed . Cheers , comments have been resolved" 5627886f9da3fa5ecb5b7bcfceeb9ab7c3c19e9f 5627886f9da3fa5ecb5b7bcfceeb9ab7c3c19e9f draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework c52c7cf23463e9a43ab1e2eb946445da7193b68253e8938c10d3de6b90e2bab2 ['772b85d3bb02da9f14ffb89c621617e2ac18b8e3807dbd4286803c7169505810', '4022ead35c2d329a5ba02b76ffd6e624e14d2317dbcd2328b803db3f88d69444', 'b81b66a28fd8768804454f03c1b4911ca5d0234e80b8259cbfa27139b475c080', 'c52c7cf23463e9a43ab1e2eb946445da7193b68253e8938c10d3de6b90e2bab2'] A "as part of the service sub-layer functions, this document describes typical detnet node data plane operation. it describes the function and operation of the packet replication (prf) packet elimination (pef) and the packet ordering (pof) functions within the service sub- layer. it also describes the forwarding sub-layer that is used to eliminate (or reduce) contention loss and provide bounded latency for detnet flows." {68: 1, 84: 1, 90: 2, 6: 3, 55: 2} {181: 1, 373: 1, 37: 2, 232: 3, 173: 3, 87: 2, 374: 2, 53: 2} {37, 232, 173, 373, 182, 87, 181, 374, 53} 55 "The DetNet Architecture models the DetNet related data plane functions decomposed into two sub-layers: a service sub-layer and a forwarding sub-layer. The service sub-layer is used to provide DetNet service protection and reordering. The forwarding sub-layer leverages Traffic Engineering mechanisms and provides congestion protection (low loss, assured latency, and limited out-of-order delivery)." "Update based on the comments of ( 01.10 ) and ( 04.10 ) . I agree with , it 's a well - known and deployed example . I 'm not sure why it was removed . Cheers , comments have been resolved" 5627886f9da3fa5ecb5b7bcfceeb9ab7c3c19e9f 5627886f9da3fa5ecb5b7bcfceeb9ab7c3c19e9f draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework 772b85d3bb02da9f14ffb89c621617e2ac18b8e3807dbd4286803c7169505810 ['772b85d3bb02da9f14ffb89c621617e2ac18b8e3807dbd4286803c7169505810', '4022ead35c2d329a5ba02b76ffd6e624e14d2317dbcd2328b803db3f88d69444', 'b81b66a28fd8768804454f03c1b4911ca5d0234e80b8259cbfa27139b475c080', 'c52c7cf23463e9a43ab1e2eb946445da7193b68253e8938c10d3de6b90e2bab2'] B "the detnet architecture models the detnet related data plane functions decomposed into two sub-layers: a service sub-layer and a forwarding sub-layer. the service sub-layer is used to provide detnet service protection and reordering. the forwarding sub-layer leverages traffic engineering mechanisms and provides congestion protection (low loss, assured latency, and limited out-of-order delivery)." {68: 1, 84: 1, 90: 2, 6: 3, 55: 2} {181: 1, 373: 1, 37: 2, 232: 3, 173: 3, 87: 2, 374: 2, 53: 2} {37, 232, 173, 373, 182, 87, 181, 374, 53} 55 "As part of the service sub-layer functions, this document describes typical DetNet node data plane operation. It describes the function and operation of the Packet Replication (PRF) Packet Elimination (PEF) and the Packet Ordering (POF) functions within the service sub- layer. Furthermore, it also describes the forwarding sub-layer." "Update based on the comments of ( 01.10 ) and ( 04.10 ) . I agree with , it 's a well - known and deployed example . I 'm not sure why it was removed . Cheers , comments have been resolved" 5627886f9da3fa5ecb5b7bcfceeb9ab7c3c19e9f 5627886f9da3fa5ecb5b7bcfceeb9ab7c3c19e9f draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework 4022ead35c2d329a5ba02b76ffd6e624e14d2317dbcd2328b803db3f88d69444 ['772b85d3bb02da9f14ffb89c621617e2ac18b8e3807dbd4286803c7169505810', '4022ead35c2d329a5ba02b76ffd6e624e14d2317dbcd2328b803db3f88d69444', 'b81b66a28fd8768804454f03c1b4911ca5d0234e80b8259cbfa27139b475c080', 'c52c7cf23463e9a43ab1e2eb946445da7193b68253e8938c10d3de6b90e2bab2'] B "as part of the service sub-layer functions, this document describes typical detnet node data plane operation. it describes the function and operation of the packet replication (prf) packet elimination (pef) and the packet ordering (pof) functions within the service sub- layer. furthermore, it also describes the forwarding sub-layer." {68: 1, 84: 1, 90: 2, 6: 3, 55: 2} {181: 1, 373: 1, 37: 2, 232: 3, 173: 3, 87: 2, 374: 2, 53: 2} {37, 232, 173, 373, 182, 87, 181, 374, 53} 55 "Different traffic types, or application flows, can be mapped on top of DetNet. DetNet can optionally reuse header information provided by, or shared with, applications. An example of shared header fields can be found in I-D.ietf-detnet-ip." "Update based on the comments of ( 01.10 ) and ( 04.10 ) . I agree with , it 's a well - known and deployed example . I 'm not sure why it was removed . Cheers , comments have been resolved" 5627886f9da3fa5ecb5b7bcfceeb9ab7c3c19e9f 5627886f9da3fa5ecb5b7bcfceeb9ab7c3c19e9f draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework b364f3ed7d4ba720c42afe45cd6fadcd470139c51ea1f3eab26f3482469b4cc7 ['39d2e55483cabfd339f98acbff304a62f6afc0f3a6159d62ff48f10334f8c125', '81aff0665c9f5b55a1994be664539a936b2f8c880c503eaf4d8ee3481614d7a2', 'b364f3ed7d4ba720c42afe45cd6fadcd470139c51ea1f3eab26f3482469b4cc7', 'da3dfab4dea569b45dfc7b358af41efc223f062e88d2fa4683765559c6b3ec70'] A "different traffic types, or application flows, can be mapped on top of detnet. detnet can optionally reuse header information provided by, or shared with, applications. an example of shared header fields can be found in i-d.ietf-detnet-ip." {6: 1, 84: 1, 68: 1, 90: 2, 55: 2} {232: 1, 373: 1, 173: 1, 37: 4, 182: 2, 181: 3, 374: 2, 53: 2} {37, 232, 173, 373, 182, 87, 181, 374, 53} 55 "This document also covers concepts related to the controller plane and Operations, Administration, and Maintenance (OAM) functions related to the control plane. Data plane OAM specifics are out of scope for this docuement." "Update based on the comments of ( 01.10 ) and ( 04.10 ) . I agree with , it 's a well - known and deployed example . I 'm not sure why it was removed . Cheers , comments have been resolved" 5627886f9da3fa5ecb5b7bcfceeb9ab7c3c19e9f 5627886f9da3fa5ecb5b7bcfceeb9ab7c3c19e9f draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework 81aff0665c9f5b55a1994be664539a936b2f8c880c503eaf4d8ee3481614d7a2 ['39d2e55483cabfd339f98acbff304a62f6afc0f3a6159d62ff48f10334f8c125', '81aff0665c9f5b55a1994be664539a936b2f8c880c503eaf4d8ee3481614d7a2', 'b364f3ed7d4ba720c42afe45cd6fadcd470139c51ea1f3eab26f3482469b4cc7', 'da3dfab4dea569b45dfc7b358af41efc223f062e88d2fa4683765559c6b3ec70'] A "this document also covers concepts related to the controller plane and operations, administration, and maintenance (oam) functions related to the control plane. data plane oam specifics are out of scope for this docuement." {6: 1, 84: 1, 68: 1, 90: 2, 55: 2} {232: 1, 373: 1, 173: 1, 37: 4, 182: 2, 181: 3, 374: 2, 53: 2} {37, 232, 173, 373, 182, 87, 181, 374, 53} 55 "Different application flows (e.g., Ethernet, IP, etc.), can be mapped on top of DetNet. DetNet can optionally reuse header information provided by, or shared with, applications. An example of shared header fields can be found in I-D.ietf-detnet-ip." "Update based on the comments of ( 01.10 ) and ( 04.10 ) . I agree with , it 's a well - known and deployed example . I 'm not sure why it was removed . Cheers , comments have been resolved" 5627886f9da3fa5ecb5b7bcfceeb9ab7c3c19e9f 5627886f9da3fa5ecb5b7bcfceeb9ab7c3c19e9f draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework 39d2e55483cabfd339f98acbff304a62f6afc0f3a6159d62ff48f10334f8c125 ['39d2e55483cabfd339f98acbff304a62f6afc0f3a6159d62ff48f10334f8c125', '81aff0665c9f5b55a1994be664539a936b2f8c880c503eaf4d8ee3481614d7a2', 'b364f3ed7d4ba720c42afe45cd6fadcd470139c51ea1f3eab26f3482469b4cc7', 'da3dfab4dea569b45dfc7b358af41efc223f062e88d2fa4683765559c6b3ec70'] B "different application flows (e.g., ethernet, ip, etc.), can be mapped on top of detnet. detnet can optionally reuse header information provided by, or shared with, applications. an example of shared header fields can be found in i-d.ietf-detnet-ip." {6: 1, 84: 1, 68: 1, 90: 2, 55: 2} {232: 1, 373: 1, 173: 1, 37: 4, 182: 2, 181: 3, 374: 2, 53: 2} {37, 232, 173, 373, 182, 87, 181, 374, 53} 55 "This document also covers basic concepts related to the controller plane and Operations, Administration, and Maintenance (OAM). Data plane OAM specifics are out of scope for this docuement." "Update based on the comments of ( 01.10 ) and ( 04.10 ) . I agree with , it 's a well - known and deployed example . I 'm not sure why it was removed . Cheers , comments have been resolved" 5627886f9da3fa5ecb5b7bcfceeb9ab7c3c19e9f 5627886f9da3fa5ecb5b7bcfceeb9ab7c3c19e9f draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework da3dfab4dea569b45dfc7b358af41efc223f062e88d2fa4683765559c6b3ec70 ['39d2e55483cabfd339f98acbff304a62f6afc0f3a6159d62ff48f10334f8c125', '81aff0665c9f5b55a1994be664539a936b2f8c880c503eaf4d8ee3481614d7a2', 'b364f3ed7d4ba720c42afe45cd6fadcd470139c51ea1f3eab26f3482469b4cc7', 'da3dfab4dea569b45dfc7b358af41efc223f062e88d2fa4683765559c6b3ec70'] B "this document also covers basic concepts related to the controller plane and operations, administration, and maintenance (oam). data plane oam specifics are out of scope for this docuement." {6: 1, 84: 1, 68: 1, 90: 2, 55: 2} {232: 1, 373: 1, 173: 1, 37: 4, 182: 2, 181: 3, 374: 2, 53: 2} {37, 232, 173, 373, 182, 87, 181, 374, 53} 55 DetNet Control Word. "Update based on the comments of ( 01.10 ) and ( 04.10 ) . I agree with , it 's a well - known and deployed example . I 'm not sure why it was removed . Cheers , comments have been resolved" 5627886f9da3fa5ecb5b7bcfceeb9ab7c3c19e9f 5627886f9da3fa5ecb5b7bcfceeb9ab7c3c19e9f draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework 8a9f636b1cdab856d1233a7a3cfa4bc0e99b49da4ac574e376b09f10f4f341e9 ['58925b1ef76bb083d7d886d21f9aa7fc2143a26177ca339c06f960bc8c37c866', '8a9f636b1cdab856d1233a7a3cfa4bc0e99b49da4ac574e376b09f10f4f341e9'] B detnet control word. {91: 1, 68: 1, 130: 4, 79: 2, 51: 2, 112: 2, 64: 2, 62: 3, 37: 2, 38: 2, 69: 2, 67: 3, 33: 2, 25: 2, 53: 3, 80: 3, 52: 2, 127: 5, 55: 2} {216: 1, 279: 1, 0: 4, 389: 3, 390: 3, 135: 2, 14: 2, 400: 3, 17: 2, 399: 4, 19: 3, 149: 2, 406: 2, 280: 2, 281: 4, 278: 2, 294: 2, 296: 2, 45: 3, 308: 2, 56: 3, 185: 3, 192: 3, 321: 2, 322: 3, 66: 3, 196: 6, 197: 5, 324: 2, 77: 2, 78: 2, 337: 5, 380: 3, 255: 4} {0, 389, 390, 135, 142, 14, 400, 17, 399, 19, 149, 406, 279, 280, 281, 278, 294, 296, 45, 308, 56, 185, 192, 321, 322, 66, 196, 197, 324, 77, 78, 337, 216, 380, 255} 55 DetNet. "Update based on the comments of ( 01.10 ) and ( 04.10 ) . I agree with , it 's a well - known and deployed example . I 'm not sure why it was removed . Cheers , comments have been resolved" 5627886f9da3fa5ecb5b7bcfceeb9ab7c3c19e9f 5627886f9da3fa5ecb5b7bcfceeb9ab7c3c19e9f draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework 58925b1ef76bb083d7d886d21f9aa7fc2143a26177ca339c06f960bc8c37c866 ['58925b1ef76bb083d7d886d21f9aa7fc2143a26177ca339c06f960bc8c37c866', '8a9f636b1cdab856d1233a7a3cfa4bc0e99b49da4ac574e376b09f10f4f341e9'] B detnet. {91: 1, 68: 1, 130: 4, 79: 2, 51: 2, 112: 2, 64: 2, 62: 3, 37: 2, 38: 2, 69: 2, 67: 3, 33: 2, 25: 2, 53: 3, 80: 3, 52: 2, 127: 5, 55: 2} {216: 1, 279: 1, 0: 4, 389: 3, 390: 3, 135: 2, 14: 2, 400: 3, 17: 2, 399: 4, 19: 3, 149: 2, 406: 2, 280: 2, 281: 4, 278: 2, 294: 2, 296: 2, 45: 3, 308: 2, 56: 3, 185: 3, 192: 3, 321: 2, 322: 3, 66: 3, 196: 6, 197: 5, 324: 2, 77: 2, 78: 2, 337: 5, 380: 3, 255: 4} {0, 389, 390, 135, 142, 14, 400, 17, 399, 19, 149, 406, 279, 280, 281, 278, 294, 296, 45, 308, 56, 185, 192, 321, 322, 66, 196, 197, 324, 77, 78, 337, 216, 380, 255} 55 "DetNet ""service"" label." "Update based on the comments of ( 01.10 ) and ( 04.10 ) . I agree with , it 's a well - known and deployed example . I 'm not sure why it was removed . Cheers , comments have been resolved" 5627886f9da3fa5ecb5b7bcfceeb9ab7c3c19e9f 5627886f9da3fa5ecb5b7bcfceeb9ab7c3c19e9f draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework 34f6582bd92afa345dc5dcd62ba8f25eef20bd51d1919d3bde053a8ab6747c41 ['34f6582bd92afa345dc5dcd62ba8f25eef20bd51d1919d3bde053a8ab6747c41', 'b5e2c587228a4238fbc26703235a5c512628fc7011c15e8d9bb25b28cbb1de10'] B "detnet ""service"" label." {91: 1, 68: 1, 130: 4, 79: 2, 51: 2, 112: 2, 55: 2, 64: 2, 62: 3, 37: 2, 38: 2, 69: 2, 67: 3, 33: 2, 25: 2, 53: 3, 80: 3, 52: 2, 127: 5} {77: 1, 279: 1, 0: 4, 389: 3, 390: 3, 135: 2, 142: 2, 14: 2, 400: 3, 17: 2, 399: 4, 19: 3, 149: 2, 406: 2, 280: 2, 281: 4, 278: 2, 294: 2, 296: 2, 45: 3, 308: 2, 56: 3, 185: 3, 192: 3, 321: 2, 322: 3, 66: 3, 196: 6, 197: 5, 324: 2, 337: 5, 216: 2, 380: 3, 255: 4} {0, 389, 390, 135, 142, 14, 400, 17, 399, 19, 149, 406, 279, 280, 281, 278, 294, 296, 45, 308, 56, 185, 192, 321, 322, 66, 196, 197, 324, 77, 78, 337, 216, 380, 255} 55 Time-Division Multiplexing. "Update based on the comments of ( 01.10 ) and ( 04.10 ) . I agree with , it 's a well - known and deployed example . I 'm not sure why it was removed . Cheers , comments have been resolved" 5627886f9da3fa5ecb5b7bcfceeb9ab7c3c19e9f 5627886f9da3fa5ecb5b7bcfceeb9ab7c3c19e9f draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework b5e2c587228a4238fbc26703235a5c512628fc7011c15e8d9bb25b28cbb1de10 ['34f6582bd92afa345dc5dcd62ba8f25eef20bd51d1919d3bde053a8ab6747c41', 'b5e2c587228a4238fbc26703235a5c512628fc7011c15e8d9bb25b28cbb1de10'] B time-division multiplexing. {91: 1, 68: 1, 130: 4, 79: 2, 51: 2, 112: 2, 55: 2, 64: 2, 62: 3, 37: 2, 38: 2, 69: 2, 67: 3, 33: 2, 25: 2, 53: 3, 80: 3, 52: 2, 127: 5} {77: 1, 279: 1, 0: 4, 389: 3, 390: 3, 135: 2, 142: 2, 14: 2, 400: 3, 17: 2, 399: 4, 19: 3, 149: 2, 406: 2, 280: 2, 281: 4, 278: 2, 294: 2, 296: 2, 45: 3, 308: 2, 56: 3, 185: 3, 192: 3, 321: 2, 322: 3, 66: 3, 196: 6, 197: 5, 324: 2, 337: 5, 216: 2, 380: 3, 255: 4} {0, 389, 390, 135, 142, 14, 400, 17, 399, 19, 149, 406, 279, 280, 281, 278, 294, 296, 45, 308, 56, 185, 192, 321, 322, 66, 196, 197, 324, 77, 78, 337, 216, 380, 255} 55 "This document describes how application flows, or app-flows, are carried over DetNet networks. The DetNet Architecture, I-D.ietf- detnet-architecture, models the DetNet related data plane functions decomposed into two sub-layers: a service sub-layer and a forwarding sub-layer." "Update based on the comments of ( 01.10 ) and ( 04.10 ) . I agree with , it 's a well - known and deployed example . I 'm not sure why it was removed . Cheers , comments have been resolved" 5627886f9da3fa5ecb5b7bcfceeb9ab7c3c19e9f 5627886f9da3fa5ecb5b7bcfceeb9ab7c3c19e9f draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework 6a0bf39ea100b653a9ac408a2db75e4aa4b0b917f9f43663acf033ca5261af45 ['97237d5170b46905eb8b44d82316bc9c68296691e70bb325be1a4c9273a8bd88', '6a0bf39ea100b653a9ac408a2db75e4aa4b0b917f9f43663acf033ca5261af45'] A "this document describes how application flows, or app-flows, are carried over detnet networks. the detnet architecture, i-d.ietf- detnet-architecture, models the detnet related data plane functions decomposed into two sub-layers: a service sub-layer and a forwarding sub-layer." {67: 1, 6: 2, 8: 3, 68: 6, 31: 3, 90: 4, 84: 2, 55: 3} {209: 1, 256: 2, 2: 3, 5: 6, 8: 3, 74: 3, 271: 4, 83: 7, 20: 6, 21: 7, 277: 6, 276: 7, 88: 3, 236: 6, 302: 2, 47: 4, 303: 7, 112: 3, 247: 5, 126: 4, 127: 3} {256, 2, 5, 8, 271, 20, 21, 277, 276, 302, 47, 303, 74, 209, 83, 88, 233, 236, 112, 247, 126, 127} 55 "This document describes how application flows, or app-flows, are carried over DetNet networks. The DetNet Architecture, I-D.ietf- detnet-architecture, models the DetNet related data plane functions as decomposed into two sub-layers: a service sub-layer and a forwarding sub-layer." "Update based on the comments of ( 01.10 ) and ( 04.10 ) . I agree with , it 's a well - known and deployed example . I 'm not sure why it was removed . Cheers , comments have been resolved" 5627886f9da3fa5ecb5b7bcfceeb9ab7c3c19e9f 5627886f9da3fa5ecb5b7bcfceeb9ab7c3c19e9f draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework 97237d5170b46905eb8b44d82316bc9c68296691e70bb325be1a4c9273a8bd88 ['97237d5170b46905eb8b44d82316bc9c68296691e70bb325be1a4c9273a8bd88', '6a0bf39ea100b653a9ac408a2db75e4aa4b0b917f9f43663acf033ca5261af45'] B "this document describes how application flows, or app-flows, are carried over detnet networks. the detnet architecture, i-d.ietf- detnet-architecture, models the detnet related data plane functions as decomposed into two sub-layers: a service sub-layer and a forwarding sub-layer." {67: 1, 6: 2, 8: 3, 68: 6, 31: 3, 90: 4, 84: 2, 55: 3} {209: 1, 256: 2, 2: 3, 5: 6, 8: 3, 74: 3, 271: 4, 83: 7, 20: 6, 21: 7, 277: 6, 276: 7, 88: 3, 236: 6, 302: 2, 47: 4, 303: 7, 112: 3, 247: 5, 126: 4, 127: 3} {256, 2, 5, 8, 271, 20, 21, 277, 276, 302, 47, 303, 74, 209, 83, 88, 233, 236, 112, 247, 126, 127} 55 "The forwarding sub-layer provides the quality underpin needed by the DetNet flow. It may do this directly through the use of queuing techniques and traffic engineering methods, or it may do this through the assistance of its underlying connectivity. For example it may call upon Ethernet TSN capabilities defined in IEEE 802.1 TSN IEEE802.1TSNTG." "Update based on the comments of ( 01.10 ) and ( 04.10 ) . I agree with , it 's a well - known and deployed example . I 'm not sure why it was removed . Cheers , comments have been resolved" 5627886f9da3fa5ecb5b7bcfceeb9ab7c3c19e9f 5627886f9da3fa5ecb5b7bcfceeb9ab7c3c19e9f draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework 229dfe9ab51091734d07a37b59b3ad1b9a42ab76d696219fba6d894d8072b5b7 ['c26e775a7006bf44235b02ccc2462157252f2a42a9eafd79b7ba1f54e285b0d5', '229dfe9ab51091734d07a37b59b3ad1b9a42ab76d696219fba6d894d8072b5b7'] A "the forwarding sub-layer provides the quality underpin needed by the detnet flow. it may do this directly through the use of queuing techniques and traffic engineering methods, or it may do this through the assistance of its underlying connectivity. for example it may call upon ethernet tsn capabilities defined in ieee 802.1 tsn ieee802.1tsntg." {68: 1, 6: 5, 8: 4, 31: 3, 67: 6, 90: 3, 84: 2, 55: 2} {5: 1, 256: 5, 2: 6, 8: 6, 74: 4, 271: 3, 209: 6, 83: 4, 20: 3, 21: 2, 277: 3, 276: 4, 88: 6, 233: 7, 236: 3, 302: 7, 47: 7, 112: 6, 247: 2, 126: 7, 127: 6} {256, 2, 5, 8, 271, 20, 21, 277, 276, 302, 47, 303, 74, 209, 83, 88, 233, 236, 112, 247, 126, 127} 55 "The forwarding sub-layer provides the QoS related functions needed by the DetNet flow. It may do this directly through the use of queuing techniques and traffic engineering methods, or it may do this through the assistance of its underlying connectivity. For example it may call upon Ethernet TSN capabilities defined in IEEE 802.1 TSN IEEE802.1TSNTG." "Update based on the comments of ( 01.10 ) and ( 04.10 ) . I agree with , it 's a well - known and deployed example . I 'm not sure why it was removed . Cheers , comments have been resolved" 5627886f9da3fa5ecb5b7bcfceeb9ab7c3c19e9f 5627886f9da3fa5ecb5b7bcfceeb9ab7c3c19e9f draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework c26e775a7006bf44235b02ccc2462157252f2a42a9eafd79b7ba1f54e285b0d5 ['c26e775a7006bf44235b02ccc2462157252f2a42a9eafd79b7ba1f54e285b0d5', '229dfe9ab51091734d07a37b59b3ad1b9a42ab76d696219fba6d894d8072b5b7'] B "the forwarding sub-layer provides the qos related functions needed by the detnet flow. it may do this directly through the use of queuing techniques and traffic engineering methods, or it may do this through the assistance of its underlying connectivity. for example it may call upon ethernet tsn capabilities defined in ieee 802.1 tsn ieee802.1tsntg." {68: 1, 6: 5, 8: 4, 31: 3, 67: 6, 90: 3, 84: 2, 55: 2} {5: 1, 256: 5, 2: 6, 8: 6, 74: 4, 271: 3, 209: 6, 83: 4, 20: 3, 21: 2, 277: 3, 276: 4, 88: 6, 233: 7, 236: 3, 302: 7, 47: 7, 112: 6, 247: 2, 126: 7, 127: 6} {256, 2, 5, 8, 271, 20, 21, 277, 276, 302, 47, 303, 74, 209, 83, 88, 233, 236, 112, 247, 126, 127} 55 "The service sub-layer provides additional support beyond the connectivity function of the forwarding sub-layer. An example of this is Packet Replication, Elimination, and Ordering (PREOF) functions see PREOF." "Update based on the comments of ( 01.10 ) and ( 04.10 ) . I agree with , it 's a well - known and deployed example . I 'm not sure why it was removed . Cheers , comments have been resolved" 5627886f9da3fa5ecb5b7bcfceeb9ab7c3c19e9f 5627886f9da3fa5ecb5b7bcfceeb9ab7c3c19e9f draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework e5d666435c4ada60f396bc49ecc362afbdce3a1a8f09e51c583470b2f4fb9984 ['a07e9665033cfb799ba9142b6988795e52916ec39393710e0ce755aca43a9791', 'ae8fa4d819a308bedba82353bb058a7322212cce6eed6c2f0519be327173936b', 'e5d666435c4ada60f396bc49ecc362afbdce3a1a8f09e51c583470b2f4fb9984', '97aa4c1b16326599f435c75216a6c84c0b02f881adb4481409a33958bfdcf917', 'c4b1ad7197fcc5833a3f5c3c37514c60507d05de1172c62f11f754ed01325c44', 'd0883bba9c43f15784cb05698f6be4bedf895e9b131603649d5019a9c77f94b2', 'c6d49800bd9ba05523ed5f7162b56a108cde2d07cfff40d9ae9a5162525ee8e0', '98e6edcdea07bab422ddf8f1f0c5cd894ba787d69fdc681a8ca417cc3bc2c950', '6ac8fb3fc9c8c625f2e6cf7f55d5c157e1940efdde6d93c8bc8921a841ba2170', '3b9465cb501977987d076a5268f6964c828a94cc4a87f28e0962df7b909a3799', 'b157d31c42404d29242c7d4ab9b93ad6babecc68fb67029210687bfeb457b806', 'c97f2c10fb4468119ce142fa536ccd07f9296561704d58a17ae1bd463c7758cb', '87c1adc613b81a29b38f4116ca298576193ec5aa096e764b169e18efdcb7a34d'] A "the service sub-layer provides additional support beyond the connectivity function of the forwarding sub-layer. an example of this is packet replication, elimination, and ordering (preof) functions see preof." {68: 1, 90: 1, 31: 1, 84: 1, 6: 3, 8: 2, 67: 4, 55: 2} {5: 1, 20: 1, 236: 1, 271: 1, 277: 1, 256: 3, 2: 4, 8: 4, 74: 2, 209: 4, 83: 2, 21: 2, 276: 2, 88: 4, 233: 5, 302: 5, 47: 5, 303: 2, 112: 4, 126: 5, 127: 4} {256, 2, 5, 8, 271, 20, 21, 277, 276, 302, 47, 303, 74, 209, 83, 88, 233, 236, 112, 247, 126, 127} 55 "The method of instantiating each of the layers is specific to the particular DetNet data plane method. There may be more than one approach that is applicable to a given bearer network type." "Update based on the comments of ( 01.10 ) and ( 04.10 ) . I agree with , it 's a well - known and deployed example . I 'm not sure why it was removed . Cheers , comments have been resolved" 5627886f9da3fa5ecb5b7bcfceeb9ab7c3c19e9f 5627886f9da3fa5ecb5b7bcfceeb9ab7c3c19e9f draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework ae8fa4d819a308bedba82353bb058a7322212cce6eed6c2f0519be327173936b ['a07e9665033cfb799ba9142b6988795e52916ec39393710e0ce755aca43a9791', 'ae8fa4d819a308bedba82353bb058a7322212cce6eed6c2f0519be327173936b', 'e5d666435c4ada60f396bc49ecc362afbdce3a1a8f09e51c583470b2f4fb9984', '97aa4c1b16326599f435c75216a6c84c0b02f881adb4481409a33958bfdcf917', 'c4b1ad7197fcc5833a3f5c3c37514c60507d05de1172c62f11f754ed01325c44', 'd0883bba9c43f15784cb05698f6be4bedf895e9b131603649d5019a9c77f94b2', 'c6d49800bd9ba05523ed5f7162b56a108cde2d07cfff40d9ae9a5162525ee8e0', '98e6edcdea07bab422ddf8f1f0c5cd894ba787d69fdc681a8ca417cc3bc2c950', '6ac8fb3fc9c8c625f2e6cf7f55d5c157e1940efdde6d93c8bc8921a841ba2170', '3b9465cb501977987d076a5268f6964c828a94cc4a87f28e0962df7b909a3799', 'b157d31c42404d29242c7d4ab9b93ad6babecc68fb67029210687bfeb457b806', 'c97f2c10fb4468119ce142fa536ccd07f9296561704d58a17ae1bd463c7758cb', '87c1adc613b81a29b38f4116ca298576193ec5aa096e764b169e18efdcb7a34d'] A "the method of instantiating each of the layers is specific to the particular detnet data plane method. there may be more than one approach that is applicable to a given bearer network type." {68: 1, 90: 1, 31: 1, 84: 1, 6: 3, 8: 2, 67: 4, 55: 2} {5: 1, 20: 1, 236: 1, 271: 1, 277: 1, 256: 3, 2: 4, 8: 4, 74: 2, 209: 4, 83: 2, 21: 2, 276: 2, 88: 4, 233: 5, 302: 5, 47: 5, 303: 2, 112: 4, 126: 5, 127: 4} {256, 2, 5, 8, 271, 20, 21, 277, 276, 302, 47, 303, 74, 209, 83, 88, 233, 236, 112, 247, 126, 127} 55 "Data plane technology: The DetNet data plane is provided by the DetNet service and forwarding sub layers. The DetNet service sub- layer generally provides its functions for the DetNet application flows by using or applying existing standardized headers and/or encapsulations. The Detnet forwarding sub-layer may provide capabilities leveraging that same header or encapsulation technology e.g. dn_svcs or it may be achieved by other technologies e.g. dn_svc_encaps. DetNet is currently defined for operation over packet switched (IP) networks or label switched (MPLS) networks." "Update based on the comments of ( 01.10 ) and ( 04.10 ) . I agree with , it 's a well - known and deployed example . I 'm not sure why it was removed . Cheers , comments have been resolved" 5627886f9da3fa5ecb5b7bcfceeb9ab7c3c19e9f 5627886f9da3fa5ecb5b7bcfceeb9ab7c3c19e9f draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework b157d31c42404d29242c7d4ab9b93ad6babecc68fb67029210687bfeb457b806 ['a07e9665033cfb799ba9142b6988795e52916ec39393710e0ce755aca43a9791', 'ae8fa4d819a308bedba82353bb058a7322212cce6eed6c2f0519be327173936b', 'e5d666435c4ada60f396bc49ecc362afbdce3a1a8f09e51c583470b2f4fb9984', '97aa4c1b16326599f435c75216a6c84c0b02f881adb4481409a33958bfdcf917', 'c4b1ad7197fcc5833a3f5c3c37514c60507d05de1172c62f11f754ed01325c44', 'd0883bba9c43f15784cb05698f6be4bedf895e9b131603649d5019a9c77f94b2', 'c6d49800bd9ba05523ed5f7162b56a108cde2d07cfff40d9ae9a5162525ee8e0', '98e6edcdea07bab422ddf8f1f0c5cd894ba787d69fdc681a8ca417cc3bc2c950', '6ac8fb3fc9c8c625f2e6cf7f55d5c157e1940efdde6d93c8bc8921a841ba2170', '3b9465cb501977987d076a5268f6964c828a94cc4a87f28e0962df7b909a3799', 'b157d31c42404d29242c7d4ab9b93ad6babecc68fb67029210687bfeb457b806', 'c97f2c10fb4468119ce142fa536ccd07f9296561704d58a17ae1bd463c7758cb', '87c1adc613b81a29b38f4116ca298576193ec5aa096e764b169e18efdcb7a34d'] A "data plane technology: the detnet data plane is provided by the detnet service and forwarding sub layers. the detnet service sub- layer generally provides its functions for the detnet application flows by using or applying existing standardized headers and/or encapsulations. the detnet forwarding sub-layer may provide capabilities leveraging that same header or encapsulation technology e.g. dn_svcs or it may be achieved by other technologies e.g. dn_svc_encaps. detnet is currently defined for operation over packet switched (ip) networks or label switched (mpls) networks." {68: 1, 90: 1, 31: 1, 84: 1, 6: 3, 8: 2, 67: 4, 55: 2} {5: 1, 20: 1, 236: 1, 271: 1, 277: 1, 256: 3, 2: 4, 8: 4, 74: 2, 209: 4, 83: 2, 21: 2, 276: 2, 88: 4, 233: 5, 302: 5, 47: 5, 303: 2, 112: 4, 126: 5, 127: 4} {256, 2, 5, 8, 271, 20, 21, 277, 276, 302, 47, 303, 74, 209, 83, 88, 233, 236, 112, 247, 126, 127} 55 "Encapsulation format: DetNet encodes specific flow attributes (namely flow identity and sequence number) in packets. For example, in DetNet IP, zero encapsulation may be used and no sequence number is available, and in DetNet MPLS, DetNet specific information may be added explicitly to the packets in the format of S-label and d-CW." "Update based on the comments of ( 01.10 ) and ( 04.10 ) . I agree with , it 's a well - known and deployed example . I 'm not sure why it was removed . Cheers , comments have been resolved" 5627886f9da3fa5ecb5b7bcfceeb9ab7c3c19e9f 5627886f9da3fa5ecb5b7bcfceeb9ab7c3c19e9f draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework 87c1adc613b81a29b38f4116ca298576193ec5aa096e764b169e18efdcb7a34d ['a07e9665033cfb799ba9142b6988795e52916ec39393710e0ce755aca43a9791', 'ae8fa4d819a308bedba82353bb058a7322212cce6eed6c2f0519be327173936b', 'e5d666435c4ada60f396bc49ecc362afbdce3a1a8f09e51c583470b2f4fb9984', '97aa4c1b16326599f435c75216a6c84c0b02f881adb4481409a33958bfdcf917', 'c4b1ad7197fcc5833a3f5c3c37514c60507d05de1172c62f11f754ed01325c44', 'd0883bba9c43f15784cb05698f6be4bedf895e9b131603649d5019a9c77f94b2', 'c6d49800bd9ba05523ed5f7162b56a108cde2d07cfff40d9ae9a5162525ee8e0', '98e6edcdea07bab422ddf8f1f0c5cd894ba787d69fdc681a8ca417cc3bc2c950', '6ac8fb3fc9c8c625f2e6cf7f55d5c157e1940efdde6d93c8bc8921a841ba2170', '3b9465cb501977987d076a5268f6964c828a94cc4a87f28e0962df7b909a3799', 'b157d31c42404d29242c7d4ab9b93ad6babecc68fb67029210687bfeb457b806', 'c97f2c10fb4468119ce142fa536ccd07f9296561704d58a17ae1bd463c7758cb', '87c1adc613b81a29b38f4116ca298576193ec5aa096e764b169e18efdcb7a34d'] A "encapsulation format: detnet encodes specific flow attributes (namely flow identity and sequence number) in packets. for example, in detnet ip, zero encapsulation may be used and no sequence number is available, and in detnet mpls, detnet specific information may be added explicitly to the packets in the format of s-label and d-cw." {68: 1, 90: 1, 31: 1, 84: 1, 6: 3, 8: 2, 67: 4, 55: 2} {5: 1, 20: 1, 236: 1, 271: 1, 277: 1, 256: 3, 2: 4, 8: 4, 74: 2, 209: 4, 83: 2, 21: 2, 276: 2, 88: 4, 233: 5, 302: 5, 47: 5, 303: 2, 112: 4, 126: 5, 127: 4} {256, 2, 5, 8, 271, 20, 21, 277, 276, 302, 47, 303, 74, 209, 83, 88, 233, 236, 112, 247, 126, 127} 55 "The encapsulation of the DetNet flows allows them to be sent over a data plane technology other than their native type. Encapsulation is essential if, for example, it is required to send Ethernet TSN stream as a DetNet Application over a data plane such as MPLS. dn_svc_encaps illustrates some relationships between the components." "Update based on the comments of ( 01.10 ) and ( 04.10 ) . I agree with , it 's a well - known and deployed example . I 'm not sure why it was removed . Cheers , comments have been resolved" 5627886f9da3fa5ecb5b7bcfceeb9ab7c3c19e9f 5627886f9da3fa5ecb5b7bcfceeb9ab7c3c19e9f draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework c97f2c10fb4468119ce142fa536ccd07f9296561704d58a17ae1bd463c7758cb ['a07e9665033cfb799ba9142b6988795e52916ec39393710e0ce755aca43a9791', 'ae8fa4d819a308bedba82353bb058a7322212cce6eed6c2f0519be327173936b', 'e5d666435c4ada60f396bc49ecc362afbdce3a1a8f09e51c583470b2f4fb9984', '97aa4c1b16326599f435c75216a6c84c0b02f881adb4481409a33958bfdcf917', 'c4b1ad7197fcc5833a3f5c3c37514c60507d05de1172c62f11f754ed01325c44', 'd0883bba9c43f15784cb05698f6be4bedf895e9b131603649d5019a9c77f94b2', 'c6d49800bd9ba05523ed5f7162b56a108cde2d07cfff40d9ae9a5162525ee8e0', '98e6edcdea07bab422ddf8f1f0c5cd894ba787d69fdc681a8ca417cc3bc2c950', '6ac8fb3fc9c8c625f2e6cf7f55d5c157e1940efdde6d93c8bc8921a841ba2170', '3b9465cb501977987d076a5268f6964c828a94cc4a87f28e0962df7b909a3799', 'b157d31c42404d29242c7d4ab9b93ad6babecc68fb67029210687bfeb457b806', 'c97f2c10fb4468119ce142fa536ccd07f9296561704d58a17ae1bd463c7758cb', '87c1adc613b81a29b38f4116ca298576193ec5aa096e764b169e18efdcb7a34d'] A "the encapsulation of the detnet flows allows them to be sent over a data plane technology other than their native type. encapsulation is essential if, for example, it is required to send ethernet tsn stream as a detnet application over a data plane such as mpls. dn_svc_encaps illustrates some relationships between the components." {68: 1, 90: 1, 31: 1, 84: 1, 6: 3, 8: 2, 67: 4, 55: 2} {5: 1, 20: 1, 236: 1, 271: 1, 277: 1, 256: 3, 2: 4, 8: 4, 74: 2, 209: 4, 83: 2, 21: 2, 276: 2, 88: 4, 233: 5, 302: 5, 47: 5, 303: 2, 112: 4, 126: 5, 127: 4} {256, 2, 5, 8, 271, 20, 21, 277, 276, 302, 47, 303, 74, 209, 83, 88, 233, 236, 112, 247, 126, 127} 55 "The use of encapsulation is also required if additional information (meta-data) is needed by the DetNet data plane and there is either no ability to include it in the client data packet, or the specification of the client data plane does not permit the modification of the packet to include additional data. An example of such meta-data is the inclusion of a sequence number required by the PREOF function." "Update based on the comments of ( 01.10 ) and ( 04.10 ) . I agree with , it 's a well - known and deployed example . I 'm not sure why it was removed . Cheers , comments have been resolved" 5627886f9da3fa5ecb5b7bcfceeb9ab7c3c19e9f 5627886f9da3fa5ecb5b7bcfceeb9ab7c3c19e9f draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework a07e9665033cfb799ba9142b6988795e52916ec39393710e0ce755aca43a9791 ['a07e9665033cfb799ba9142b6988795e52916ec39393710e0ce755aca43a9791', 'ae8fa4d819a308bedba82353bb058a7322212cce6eed6c2f0519be327173936b', 'e5d666435c4ada60f396bc49ecc362afbdce3a1a8f09e51c583470b2f4fb9984', '97aa4c1b16326599f435c75216a6c84c0b02f881adb4481409a33958bfdcf917', 'c4b1ad7197fcc5833a3f5c3c37514c60507d05de1172c62f11f754ed01325c44', 'd0883bba9c43f15784cb05698f6be4bedf895e9b131603649d5019a9c77f94b2', 'c6d49800bd9ba05523ed5f7162b56a108cde2d07cfff40d9ae9a5162525ee8e0', '98e6edcdea07bab422ddf8f1f0c5cd894ba787d69fdc681a8ca417cc3bc2c950', '6ac8fb3fc9c8c625f2e6cf7f55d5c157e1940efdde6d93c8bc8921a841ba2170', '3b9465cb501977987d076a5268f6964c828a94cc4a87f28e0962df7b909a3799', 'b157d31c42404d29242c7d4ab9b93ad6babecc68fb67029210687bfeb457b806', 'c97f2c10fb4468119ce142fa536ccd07f9296561704d58a17ae1bd463c7758cb', '87c1adc613b81a29b38f4116ca298576193ec5aa096e764b169e18efdcb7a34d'] A "the use of encapsulation is also required if additional information (meta-data) is needed by the detnet data plane and there is either no ability to include it in the client data packet, or the specification of the client data plane does not permit the modification of the packet to include additional data. an example of such meta-data is the inclusion of a sequence number required by the preof function." {68: 1, 90: 1, 31: 1, 84: 1, 6: 3, 8: 2, 67: 4, 55: 2} {5: 1, 20: 1, 236: 1, 271: 1, 277: 1, 256: 3, 2: 4, 8: 4, 74: 2, 209: 4, 83: 2, 21: 2, 276: 2, 88: 4, 233: 5, 302: 5, 47: 5, 303: 2, 112: 4, 126: 5, 127: 4} {256, 2, 5, 8, 271, 20, 21, 277, 276, 302, 47, 303, 74, 209, 83, 88, 233, 236, 112, 247, 126, 127} 55 "The service sub-layer provides additional support beyond the connectivity function of the forwarding sub-layer. An example of this is Packet Replication, Elimination, and Ordering functions see PREOF." "Update based on the comments of ( 01.10 ) and ( 04.10 ) . I agree with , it 's a well - known and deployed example . I 'm not sure why it was removed . Cheers , comments have been resolved" 5627886f9da3fa5ecb5b7bcfceeb9ab7c3c19e9f 5627886f9da3fa5ecb5b7bcfceeb9ab7c3c19e9f draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework d0883bba9c43f15784cb05698f6be4bedf895e9b131603649d5019a9c77f94b2 ['a07e9665033cfb799ba9142b6988795e52916ec39393710e0ce755aca43a9791', 'ae8fa4d819a308bedba82353bb058a7322212cce6eed6c2f0519be327173936b', 'e5d666435c4ada60f396bc49ecc362afbdce3a1a8f09e51c583470b2f4fb9984', '97aa4c1b16326599f435c75216a6c84c0b02f881adb4481409a33958bfdcf917', 'c4b1ad7197fcc5833a3f5c3c37514c60507d05de1172c62f11f754ed01325c44', 'd0883bba9c43f15784cb05698f6be4bedf895e9b131603649d5019a9c77f94b2', 'c6d49800bd9ba05523ed5f7162b56a108cde2d07cfff40d9ae9a5162525ee8e0', '98e6edcdea07bab422ddf8f1f0c5cd894ba787d69fdc681a8ca417cc3bc2c950', '6ac8fb3fc9c8c625f2e6cf7f55d5c157e1940efdde6d93c8bc8921a841ba2170', '3b9465cb501977987d076a5268f6964c828a94cc4a87f28e0962df7b909a3799', 'b157d31c42404d29242c7d4ab9b93ad6babecc68fb67029210687bfeb457b806', 'c97f2c10fb4468119ce142fa536ccd07f9296561704d58a17ae1bd463c7758cb', '87c1adc613b81a29b38f4116ca298576193ec5aa096e764b169e18efdcb7a34d'] B "the service sub-layer provides additional support beyond the connectivity function of the forwarding sub-layer. an example of this is packet replication, elimination, and ordering functions see preof." {68: 1, 90: 1, 31: 1, 84: 1, 6: 3, 8: 2, 67: 4, 55: 2} {5: 1, 20: 1, 236: 1, 271: 1, 277: 1, 256: 3, 2: 4, 8: 4, 74: 2, 209: 4, 83: 2, 21: 2, 276: 2, 88: 4, 233: 5, 302: 5, 47: 5, 303: 2, 112: 4, 126: 5, 127: 4} {256, 2, 5, 8, 271, 20, 21, 277, 276, 302, 47, 303, 74, 209, 83, 88, 233, 236, 112, 247, 126, 127} 55 "The method of instantiating each of the layers is specific to the particular DetNet data plane method, and more than one approach may be applicable to a given bearer network type." "Update based on the comments of ( 01.10 ) and ( 04.10 ) . I agree with , it 's a well - known and deployed example . I 'm not sure why it was removed . Cheers , comments have been resolved" 5627886f9da3fa5ecb5b7bcfceeb9ab7c3c19e9f 5627886f9da3fa5ecb5b7bcfceeb9ab7c3c19e9f draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework 3b9465cb501977987d076a5268f6964c828a94cc4a87f28e0962df7b909a3799 ['a07e9665033cfb799ba9142b6988795e52916ec39393710e0ce755aca43a9791', 'ae8fa4d819a308bedba82353bb058a7322212cce6eed6c2f0519be327173936b', 'e5d666435c4ada60f396bc49ecc362afbdce3a1a8f09e51c583470b2f4fb9984', '97aa4c1b16326599f435c75216a6c84c0b02f881adb4481409a33958bfdcf917', 'c4b1ad7197fcc5833a3f5c3c37514c60507d05de1172c62f11f754ed01325c44', 'd0883bba9c43f15784cb05698f6be4bedf895e9b131603649d5019a9c77f94b2', 'c6d49800bd9ba05523ed5f7162b56a108cde2d07cfff40d9ae9a5162525ee8e0', '98e6edcdea07bab422ddf8f1f0c5cd894ba787d69fdc681a8ca417cc3bc2c950', '6ac8fb3fc9c8c625f2e6cf7f55d5c157e1940efdde6d93c8bc8921a841ba2170', '3b9465cb501977987d076a5268f6964c828a94cc4a87f28e0962df7b909a3799', 'b157d31c42404d29242c7d4ab9b93ad6babecc68fb67029210687bfeb457b806', 'c97f2c10fb4468119ce142fa536ccd07f9296561704d58a17ae1bd463c7758cb', '87c1adc613b81a29b38f4116ca298576193ec5aa096e764b169e18efdcb7a34d'] B "the method of instantiating each of the layers is specific to the particular detnet data plane method, and more than one approach may be applicable to a given bearer network type." {68: 1, 90: 1, 31: 1, 84: 1, 6: 3, 8: 2, 67: 4, 55: 2} {5: 1, 20: 1, 236: 1, 271: 1, 277: 1, 256: 3, 2: 4, 8: 4, 74: 2, 209: 4, 83: 2, 21: 2, 276: 2, 88: 4, 233: 5, 302: 5, 47: 5, 303: 2, 112: 4, 126: 5, 127: 4} {256, 2, 5, 8, 271, 20, 21, 277, 276, 302, 47, 303, 74, 209, 83, 88, 233, 236, 112, 247, 126, 127} 55 "There are two major characteristics to the data plane: the technology and the encapsulation, as discussed below." "Update based on the comments of ( 01.10 ) and ( 04.10 ) . I agree with , it 's a well - known and deployed example . I 'm not sure why it was removed . Cheers , comments have been resolved" 5627886f9da3fa5ecb5b7bcfceeb9ab7c3c19e9f 5627886f9da3fa5ecb5b7bcfceeb9ab7c3c19e9f draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework 6ac8fb3fc9c8c625f2e6cf7f55d5c157e1940efdde6d93c8bc8921a841ba2170 ['a07e9665033cfb799ba9142b6988795e52916ec39393710e0ce755aca43a9791', 'ae8fa4d819a308bedba82353bb058a7322212cce6eed6c2f0519be327173936b', 'e5d666435c4ada60f396bc49ecc362afbdce3a1a8f09e51c583470b2f4fb9984', '97aa4c1b16326599f435c75216a6c84c0b02f881adb4481409a33958bfdcf917', 'c4b1ad7197fcc5833a3f5c3c37514c60507d05de1172c62f11f754ed01325c44', 'd0883bba9c43f15784cb05698f6be4bedf895e9b131603649d5019a9c77f94b2', 'c6d49800bd9ba05523ed5f7162b56a108cde2d07cfff40d9ae9a5162525ee8e0', '98e6edcdea07bab422ddf8f1f0c5cd894ba787d69fdc681a8ca417cc3bc2c950', '6ac8fb3fc9c8c625f2e6cf7f55d5c157e1940efdde6d93c8bc8921a841ba2170', '3b9465cb501977987d076a5268f6964c828a94cc4a87f28e0962df7b909a3799', 'b157d31c42404d29242c7d4ab9b93ad6babecc68fb67029210687bfeb457b806', 'c97f2c10fb4468119ce142fa536ccd07f9296561704d58a17ae1bd463c7758cb', '87c1adc613b81a29b38f4116ca298576193ec5aa096e764b169e18efdcb7a34d'] B "there are two major characteristics to the data plane: the technology and the encapsulation, as discussed below." {68: 1, 90: 1, 31: 1, 84: 1, 6: 3, 8: 2, 67: 4, 55: 2} {5: 1, 20: 1, 236: 1, 271: 1, 277: 1, 256: 3, 2: 4, 8: 4, 74: 2, 209: 4, 83: 2, 21: 2, 276: 2, 88: 4, 233: 5, 302: 5, 47: 5, 303: 2, 112: 4, 126: 5, 127: 4} {256, 2, 5, 8, 271, 20, 21, 277, 276, 302, 47, 303, 74, 209, 83, 88, 233, 236, 112, 247, 126, 127} 55 "The DetNet data plane is provided by the DetNet service and forwarding sub layers. The DetNet service sub-layer generally provides its functions for the DetNet application flows by using or applying existing standardized headers and/or encapsulations. The Detnet forwarding sub-layer may provide capabilities leveraging that same header or encapsulation technology (e.g., DN IP or DN MPLS) or it may be achieved by other technologies (e.g., dn_svc_encaps). DetNet is currently defined for operation over packet switched (IP) networks or label switched (MPLS) networks." "Update based on the comments of ( 01.10 ) and ( 04.10 ) . I agree with , it 's a well - known and deployed example . I 'm not sure why it was removed . Cheers , comments have been resolved" 5627886f9da3fa5ecb5b7bcfceeb9ab7c3c19e9f 5627886f9da3fa5ecb5b7bcfceeb9ab7c3c19e9f draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework 97aa4c1b16326599f435c75216a6c84c0b02f881adb4481409a33958bfdcf917 ['a07e9665033cfb799ba9142b6988795e52916ec39393710e0ce755aca43a9791', 'ae8fa4d819a308bedba82353bb058a7322212cce6eed6c2f0519be327173936b', 'e5d666435c4ada60f396bc49ecc362afbdce3a1a8f09e51c583470b2f4fb9984', '97aa4c1b16326599f435c75216a6c84c0b02f881adb4481409a33958bfdcf917', 'c4b1ad7197fcc5833a3f5c3c37514c60507d05de1172c62f11f754ed01325c44', 'd0883bba9c43f15784cb05698f6be4bedf895e9b131603649d5019a9c77f94b2', 'c6d49800bd9ba05523ed5f7162b56a108cde2d07cfff40d9ae9a5162525ee8e0', '98e6edcdea07bab422ddf8f1f0c5cd894ba787d69fdc681a8ca417cc3bc2c950', '6ac8fb3fc9c8c625f2e6cf7f55d5c157e1940efdde6d93c8bc8921a841ba2170', '3b9465cb501977987d076a5268f6964c828a94cc4a87f28e0962df7b909a3799', 'b157d31c42404d29242c7d4ab9b93ad6babecc68fb67029210687bfeb457b806', 'c97f2c10fb4468119ce142fa536ccd07f9296561704d58a17ae1bd463c7758cb', '87c1adc613b81a29b38f4116ca298576193ec5aa096e764b169e18efdcb7a34d'] B "the detnet data plane is provided by the detnet service and forwarding sub layers. the detnet service sub-layer generally provides its functions for the detnet application flows by using or applying existing standardized headers and/or encapsulations. the detnet forwarding sub-layer may provide capabilities leveraging that same header or encapsulation technology (e.g., dn ip or dn mpls) or it may be achieved by other technologies (e.g., dn_svc_encaps). detnet is currently defined for operation over packet switched (ip) networks or label switched (mpls) networks." {68: 1, 90: 1, 31: 1, 84: 1, 6: 3, 8: 2, 67: 4, 55: 2} {5: 1, 20: 1, 236: 1, 271: 1, 277: 1, 256: 3, 2: 4, 8: 4, 74: 2, 209: 4, 83: 2, 21: 2, 276: 2, 88: 4, 233: 5, 302: 5, 47: 5, 303: 2, 112: 4, 126: 5, 127: 4} {256, 2, 5, 8, 271, 20, 21, 277, 276, 302, 47, 303, 74, 209, 83, 88, 233, 236, 112, 247, 126, 127} 55 "DetNet encodes specific flow attributes (flow identity and sequence number) in packets. For example, in DetNet IP, zero encapsulation is used and no sequence number is available, and in DetNet MPLS, DetNet specific information may be added explicitly to the packets in the format of S-label and d-CW." "Update based on the comments of ( 01.10 ) and ( 04.10 ) . I agree with , it 's a well - known and deployed example . I 'm not sure why it was removed . Cheers , comments have been resolved" 5627886f9da3fa5ecb5b7bcfceeb9ab7c3c19e9f 5627886f9da3fa5ecb5b7bcfceeb9ab7c3c19e9f draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework 98e6edcdea07bab422ddf8f1f0c5cd894ba787d69fdc681a8ca417cc3bc2c950 ['a07e9665033cfb799ba9142b6988795e52916ec39393710e0ce755aca43a9791', 'ae8fa4d819a308bedba82353bb058a7322212cce6eed6c2f0519be327173936b', 'e5d666435c4ada60f396bc49ecc362afbdce3a1a8f09e51c583470b2f4fb9984', '97aa4c1b16326599f435c75216a6c84c0b02f881adb4481409a33958bfdcf917', 'c4b1ad7197fcc5833a3f5c3c37514c60507d05de1172c62f11f754ed01325c44', 'd0883bba9c43f15784cb05698f6be4bedf895e9b131603649d5019a9c77f94b2', 'c6d49800bd9ba05523ed5f7162b56a108cde2d07cfff40d9ae9a5162525ee8e0', '98e6edcdea07bab422ddf8f1f0c5cd894ba787d69fdc681a8ca417cc3bc2c950', '6ac8fb3fc9c8c625f2e6cf7f55d5c157e1940efdde6d93c8bc8921a841ba2170', '3b9465cb501977987d076a5268f6964c828a94cc4a87f28e0962df7b909a3799', 'b157d31c42404d29242c7d4ab9b93ad6babecc68fb67029210687bfeb457b806', 'c97f2c10fb4468119ce142fa536ccd07f9296561704d58a17ae1bd463c7758cb', '87c1adc613b81a29b38f4116ca298576193ec5aa096e764b169e18efdcb7a34d'] B "detnet encodes specific flow attributes (flow identity and sequence number) in packets. for example, in detnet ip, zero encapsulation is used and no sequence number is available, and in detnet mpls, detnet specific information may be added explicitly to the packets in the format of s-label and d-cw." {68: 1, 90: 1, 31: 1, 84: 1, 6: 3, 8: 2, 67: 4, 55: 2} {5: 1, 20: 1, 236: 1, 271: 1, 277: 1, 256: 3, 2: 4, 8: 4, 74: 2, 209: 4, 83: 2, 21: 2, 276: 2, 88: 4, 233: 5, 302: 5, 47: 5, 303: 2, 112: 4, 126: 5, 127: 4} {256, 2, 5, 8, 271, 20, 21, 277, 276, 302, 47, 303, 74, 209, 83, 88, 233, 236, 112, 247, 126, 127} 55 "The encapsulation of a DetNet flow allows it to be sent over a data plane technology other than its native type. DetNet uses header information to perform traffic classification, i.e., identify DetNet flows, and provide DetNet service and forwarding functions. As mentioned above, DetNet may add headers, as is the case for DN MPLS, or may use headers that are already present, as is the case in DN IP. dn_svc_encaps illustrates some relationships between the components." "Update based on the comments of ( 01.10 ) and ( 04.10 ) . I agree with , it 's a well - known and deployed example . I 'm not sure why it was removed . Cheers , comments have been resolved" 5627886f9da3fa5ecb5b7bcfceeb9ab7c3c19e9f 5627886f9da3fa5ecb5b7bcfceeb9ab7c3c19e9f draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework c6d49800bd9ba05523ed5f7162b56a108cde2d07cfff40d9ae9a5162525ee8e0 ['a07e9665033cfb799ba9142b6988795e52916ec39393710e0ce755aca43a9791', 'ae8fa4d819a308bedba82353bb058a7322212cce6eed6c2f0519be327173936b', 'e5d666435c4ada60f396bc49ecc362afbdce3a1a8f09e51c583470b2f4fb9984', '97aa4c1b16326599f435c75216a6c84c0b02f881adb4481409a33958bfdcf917', 'c4b1ad7197fcc5833a3f5c3c37514c60507d05de1172c62f11f754ed01325c44', 'd0883bba9c43f15784cb05698f6be4bedf895e9b131603649d5019a9c77f94b2', 'c6d49800bd9ba05523ed5f7162b56a108cde2d07cfff40d9ae9a5162525ee8e0', '98e6edcdea07bab422ddf8f1f0c5cd894ba787d69fdc681a8ca417cc3bc2c950', '6ac8fb3fc9c8c625f2e6cf7f55d5c157e1940efdde6d93c8bc8921a841ba2170', '3b9465cb501977987d076a5268f6964c828a94cc4a87f28e0962df7b909a3799', 'b157d31c42404d29242c7d4ab9b93ad6babecc68fb67029210687bfeb457b806', 'c97f2c10fb4468119ce142fa536ccd07f9296561704d58a17ae1bd463c7758cb', '87c1adc613b81a29b38f4116ca298576193ec5aa096e764b169e18efdcb7a34d'] B "the encapsulation of a detnet flow allows it to be sent over a data plane technology other than its native type. detnet uses header information to perform traffic classification, i.e., identify detnet flows, and provide detnet service and forwarding functions. as mentioned above, detnet may add headers, as is the case for dn mpls, or may use headers that are already present, as is the case in dn ip. dn_svc_encaps illustrates some relationships between the components." {68: 1, 90: 1, 31: 1, 84: 1, 6: 3, 8: 2, 67: 4, 55: 2} {5: 1, 20: 1, 236: 1, 271: 1, 277: 1, 256: 3, 2: 4, 8: 4, 74: 2, 209: 4, 83: 2, 21: 2, 276: 2, 88: 4, 233: 5, 302: 5, 47: 5, 303: 2, 112: 4, 126: 5, 127: 4} {256, 2, 5, 8, 271, 20, 21, 277, 276, 302, 47, 303, 74, 209, 83, 88, 233, 236, 112, 247, 126, 127} 55 "The use of encapsulation is also required if additional information (metadata) is needed by the DetNet data plane and there is either no ability to include it in the client data packet, or the specification of the client data plane does not permit the modification of the packet to include additional data. An example of such metadata is the inclusion of a sequence number required by the PREOF function." "Update based on the comments of ( 01.10 ) and ( 04.10 ) . I agree with , it 's a well - known and deployed example . I 'm not sure why it was removed . Cheers , comments have been resolved" 5627886f9da3fa5ecb5b7bcfceeb9ab7c3c19e9f 5627886f9da3fa5ecb5b7bcfceeb9ab7c3c19e9f draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework c4b1ad7197fcc5833a3f5c3c37514c60507d05de1172c62f11f754ed01325c44 ['a07e9665033cfb799ba9142b6988795e52916ec39393710e0ce755aca43a9791', 'ae8fa4d819a308bedba82353bb058a7322212cce6eed6c2f0519be327173936b', 'e5d666435c4ada60f396bc49ecc362afbdce3a1a8f09e51c583470b2f4fb9984', '97aa4c1b16326599f435c75216a6c84c0b02f881adb4481409a33958bfdcf917', 'c4b1ad7197fcc5833a3f5c3c37514c60507d05de1172c62f11f754ed01325c44', 'd0883bba9c43f15784cb05698f6be4bedf895e9b131603649d5019a9c77f94b2', 'c6d49800bd9ba05523ed5f7162b56a108cde2d07cfff40d9ae9a5162525ee8e0', '98e6edcdea07bab422ddf8f1f0c5cd894ba787d69fdc681a8ca417cc3bc2c950', '6ac8fb3fc9c8c625f2e6cf7f55d5c157e1940efdde6d93c8bc8921a841ba2170', '3b9465cb501977987d076a5268f6964c828a94cc4a87f28e0962df7b909a3799', 'b157d31c42404d29242c7d4ab9b93ad6babecc68fb67029210687bfeb457b806', 'c97f2c10fb4468119ce142fa536ccd07f9296561704d58a17ae1bd463c7758cb', '87c1adc613b81a29b38f4116ca298576193ec5aa096e764b169e18efdcb7a34d'] B "the use of encapsulation is also required if additional information (metadata) is needed by the detnet data plane and there is either no ability to include it in the client data packet, or the specification of the client data plane does not permit the modification of the packet to include additional data. an example of such metadata is the inclusion of a sequence number required by the preof function." {68: 1, 90: 1, 31: 1, 84: 1, 6: 3, 8: 2, 67: 4, 55: 2} {5: 1, 20: 1, 236: 1, 271: 1, 277: 1, 256: 3, 2: 4, 8: 4, 74: 2, 209: 4, 83: 2, 21: 2, 276: 2, 88: 4, 233: 5, 302: 5, 47: 5, 303: 2, 112: 4, 126: 5, 127: 4} {256, 2, 5, 8, 271, 20, 21, 277, 276, 302, 47, 303, 74, 209, 83, 88, 233, 236, 112, 247, 126, 127} 55 "Both of these metadata are required for DetNet service sub-layer specific functions (e.g., PREOF). DetNet forwarding sub-layer related functions require only Flow-ID." "Update based on the comments of ( 01.10 ) and ( 04.10 ) . I agree with , it 's a well - known and deployed example . I 'm not sure why it was removed . Cheers , comments have been resolved" 5627886f9da3fa5ecb5b7bcfceeb9ab7c3c19e9f 5627886f9da3fa5ecb5b7bcfceeb9ab7c3c19e9f draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework ab8ed32978756bb0616421883398e0e8657dfb2bc966f2e1c6c1be5cf7905af9 ['4fd2716d226b744f9c0a0c6d5b149320df824936e2b280f1c3c9c4b27ff71602', 'ab8ed32978756bb0616421883398e0e8657dfb2bc966f2e1c6c1be5cf7905af9', '0853c80510efdb5ecae37f42b545181aad0fe7b945aac3bf00a4544d4d9e0150', '8681d3d5eafd1166db20c61cbfb31b1f58b8fdabd9e01f7f4b9b8f9c3dd7eb33'] A "both of these metadata are required for detnet service sub-layer specific functions (e.g., preof). detnet forwarding sub-layer related functions require only flow-id." {84: 1, 90: 1, 6: 1, 8: 2, 68: 5, 31: 2, 67: 2, 55: 3} {47: 1, 126: 1, 256: 1, 2: 2, 5: 5, 8: 2, 74: 2, 271: 3, 209: 2, 83: 6, 20: 5, 21: 6, 277: 5, 276: 6, 88: 2, 233: 3, 236: 5, 302: 3, 303: 6, 112: 2, 247: 4} {256, 2, 5, 8, 271, 20, 21, 277, 276, 302, 47, 303, 74, 209, 83, 88, 233, 236, 112, 247, 126, 127} 55 "Metadata can be a useful way of identifying packets that need to be treated as a flow or flow aggregate. It is also useful as a way of including a sequence number the packet for use by the PREOF function or as a place to carry OAM indications or OAM information to instrument DetNet data plane operation." "Update based on the comments of ( 01.10 ) and ( 04.10 ) . I agree with , it 's a well - known and deployed example . I 'm not sure why it was removed . Cheers , comments have been resolved" 5627886f9da3fa5ecb5b7bcfceeb9ab7c3c19e9f 5627886f9da3fa5ecb5b7bcfceeb9ab7c3c19e9f draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework 0853c80510efdb5ecae37f42b545181aad0fe7b945aac3bf00a4544d4d9e0150 ['4fd2716d226b744f9c0a0c6d5b149320df824936e2b280f1c3c9c4b27ff71602', 'ab8ed32978756bb0616421883398e0e8657dfb2bc966f2e1c6c1be5cf7905af9', '0853c80510efdb5ecae37f42b545181aad0fe7b945aac3bf00a4544d4d9e0150', '8681d3d5eafd1166db20c61cbfb31b1f58b8fdabd9e01f7f4b9b8f9c3dd7eb33'] A "metadata can be a useful way of identifying packets that need to be treated as a flow or flow aggregate. it is also useful as a way of including a sequence number the packet for use by the preof function or as a place to carry oam indications or oam information to instrument detnet data plane operation." {84: 1, 90: 1, 6: 1, 8: 2, 68: 5, 31: 2, 67: 2, 55: 3} {47: 1, 126: 1, 256: 1, 2: 2, 5: 5, 8: 2, 74: 2, 271: 3, 209: 2, 83: 6, 20: 5, 21: 6, 277: 5, 276: 6, 88: 2, 233: 3, 236: 5, 302: 3, 303: 6, 112: 2, 247: 4} {256, 2, 5, 8, 271, 20, 21, 277, 276, 302, 47, 303, 74, 209, 83, 88, 233, 236, 112, 247, 126, 127} 55 "The DetNet data plane framework supports a Flow-ID (for identification of the flow or aggregate flow) and/or a Sequence Number (for PREOF) for each DetNet flow. The DetNet Service sub- layer requires both; the DetNet forwarding sub-layer requires only Flow-ID. Metadata can also be used for OAM indications and instrumentation of DetNet data plane operation." "Update based on the comments of ( 01.10 ) and ( 04.10 ) . I agree with , it 's a well - known and deployed example . I 'm not sure why it was removed . Cheers , comments have been resolved" 5627886f9da3fa5ecb5b7bcfceeb9ab7c3c19e9f 5627886f9da3fa5ecb5b7bcfceeb9ab7c3c19e9f draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework 4fd2716d226b744f9c0a0c6d5b149320df824936e2b280f1c3c9c4b27ff71602 ['4fd2716d226b744f9c0a0c6d5b149320df824936e2b280f1c3c9c4b27ff71602', 'ab8ed32978756bb0616421883398e0e8657dfb2bc966f2e1c6c1be5cf7905af9', '0853c80510efdb5ecae37f42b545181aad0fe7b945aac3bf00a4544d4d9e0150', '8681d3d5eafd1166db20c61cbfb31b1f58b8fdabd9e01f7f4b9b8f9c3dd7eb33'] B "the detnet data plane framework supports a flow-id (for identification of the flow or aggregate flow) and/or a sequence number (for preof) for each detnet flow. the detnet service sub- layer requires both; the detnet forwarding sub-layer requires only flow-id. metadata can also be used for oam indications and instrumentation of detnet data plane operation." {84: 1, 90: 1, 6: 1, 8: 2, 68: 5, 31: 2, 67: 2, 55: 3} {47: 1, 126: 1, 256: 1, 2: 2, 5: 5, 8: 2, 74: 2, 271: 3, 209: 2, 83: 6, 20: 5, 21: 6, 277: 5, 276: 6, 88: 2, 233: 3, 236: 5, 302: 3, 303: 6, 112: 2, 247: 4} {256, 2, 5, 8, 271, 20, 21, 277, 276, 302, 47, 303, 74, 209, 83, 88, 233, 236, 112, 247, 126, 127} 55 "Metadata can be included implicit or explicit. Explicit means that a dedicated header field is used to include metadata in a DetNet packet. In case of implicit method a part of an already existing header field is used to encode the metadata." "Update based on the comments of ( 01.10 ) and ( 04.10 ) . I agree with , it 's a well - known and deployed example . I 'm not sure why it was removed . Cheers , comments have been resolved" 5627886f9da3fa5ecb5b7bcfceeb9ab7c3c19e9f 5627886f9da3fa5ecb5b7bcfceeb9ab7c3c19e9f draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework 8681d3d5eafd1166db20c61cbfb31b1f58b8fdabd9e01f7f4b9b8f9c3dd7eb33 ['4fd2716d226b744f9c0a0c6d5b149320df824936e2b280f1c3c9c4b27ff71602', 'ab8ed32978756bb0616421883398e0e8657dfb2bc966f2e1c6c1be5cf7905af9', '0853c80510efdb5ecae37f42b545181aad0fe7b945aac3bf00a4544d4d9e0150', '8681d3d5eafd1166db20c61cbfb31b1f58b8fdabd9e01f7f4b9b8f9c3dd7eb33'] B "metadata can be included implicit or explicit. explicit means that a dedicated header field is used to include metadata in a detnet packet. in case of implicit method a part of an already existing header field is used to encode the metadata." {84: 1, 90: 1, 6: 1, 8: 2, 68: 5, 31: 2, 67: 2, 55: 3} {47: 1, 126: 1, 256: 1, 2: 2, 5: 5, 8: 2, 74: 2, 271: 3, 209: 2, 83: 6, 20: 5, 21: 6, 277: 5, 276: 6, 88: 2, 233: 3, 236: 5, 302: 3, 303: 6, 112: 2, 247: 4} {256, 2, 5, 8, 271, 20, 21, 277, 276, 302, 47, 303, 74, 209, 83, 88, 233, 236, 112, 247, 126, 127} 55 "An IP data plane may operate natively or through the use of an encapsulation. Many types of IP encapsulation can satisfy DetNet requirements and it is anticipated that more than one encapsulation may be deployed for example GRE, IPSec etc." "Update based on the comments of ( 01.10 ) and ( 04.10 ) . I agree with , it 's a well - known and deployed example . I 'm not sure why it was removed . Cheers , comments have been resolved" 5627886f9da3fa5ecb5b7bcfceeb9ab7c3c19e9f 5627886f9da3fa5ecb5b7bcfceeb9ab7c3c19e9f draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework 26f1985978c33dabae95a180c8a2951c2cff2e5682d451b22803cbc1fbb7207a ['453fc5745d087952c99380270d6b9cb166039ec445b7bbec68fc04a32c5d4114', '26f1985978c33dabae95a180c8a2951c2cff2e5682d451b22803cbc1fbb7207a', 'd0eb2c6c6960aab0139f5a1533a14e46a03acb5eb70876f7d287172a4d383314', '853be33484efcf8d9c687137501a8aa4dfbf75a63fa3418c763e1300f7112816'] A "an ip data plane may operate natively or through the use of an encapsulation. many types of ip encapsulation can satisfy detnet requirements and it is anticipated that more than one encapsulation may be deployed for example gre, ipsec etc." {84: 1} {405: 1} {104, 405} 55 "One method of operating an IP DetNet data plane without encapsulation is to use ""6-tuple"" based flow identification, where ""6-tuple"" refers to information carried in IP and higher layer protocol headers. General background on the use of IP headers, and ""6-tuples"", to identify flows and support Quality of Service (QoS) can be found in RFC3670. RFC7657 also provides useful background on the delivery differentiated services (DiffServ) and ""tuple"" based flow identification. DetNet flow aggregation may be enabled via the use of wildcards, masks, prefixes and ranges. The operation of this method is described in detail in I-D.ietf-detnet-ip." "Update based on the comments of ( 01.10 ) and ( 04.10 ) . I agree with , it 's a well - known and deployed example . I 'm not sure why it was removed . Cheers , comments have been resolved" 5627886f9da3fa5ecb5b7bcfceeb9ab7c3c19e9f 5627886f9da3fa5ecb5b7bcfceeb9ab7c3c19e9f draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework d0eb2c6c6960aab0139f5a1533a14e46a03acb5eb70876f7d287172a4d383314 ['453fc5745d087952c99380270d6b9cb166039ec445b7bbec68fc04a32c5d4114', '26f1985978c33dabae95a180c8a2951c2cff2e5682d451b22803cbc1fbb7207a', 'd0eb2c6c6960aab0139f5a1533a14e46a03acb5eb70876f7d287172a4d383314', '853be33484efcf8d9c687137501a8aa4dfbf75a63fa3418c763e1300f7112816'] A "one method of operating an ip detnet data plane without encapsulation is to use ""6-tuple"" based flow identification, where ""6-tuple"" refers to information carried in ip and higher layer protocol headers. general background on the use of ip headers, and ""6-tuples"", to identify flows and support quality of service (qos) can be found in rfc3670. rfc7657 also provides useful background on the delivery differentiated services (diffserv) and ""tuple"" based flow identification. detnet flow aggregation may be enabled via the use of wildcards, masks, prefixes and ranges. the operation of this method is described in detail in i-d.ietf-detnet-ip." {84: 1} {405: 1} {104, 405} 55 "An IP data plane may operate natively or through the use of an encapsulation. Many types of IP encapsulation can satisfy DetNet requirements and it is anticipated that more than one encapsulation may be deployed, for example GRE, IPSec etc." "Update based on the comments of ( 01.10 ) and ( 04.10 ) . I agree with , it 's a well - known and deployed example . I 'm not sure why it was removed . Cheers , comments have been resolved" 5627886f9da3fa5ecb5b7bcfceeb9ab7c3c19e9f 5627886f9da3fa5ecb5b7bcfceeb9ab7c3c19e9f draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework 853be33484efcf8d9c687137501a8aa4dfbf75a63fa3418c763e1300f7112816 ['453fc5745d087952c99380270d6b9cb166039ec445b7bbec68fc04a32c5d4114', '26f1985978c33dabae95a180c8a2951c2cff2e5682d451b22803cbc1fbb7207a', 'd0eb2c6c6960aab0139f5a1533a14e46a03acb5eb70876f7d287172a4d383314', '853be33484efcf8d9c687137501a8aa4dfbf75a63fa3418c763e1300f7112816'] B "an ip data plane may operate natively or through the use of an encapsulation. many types of ip encapsulation can satisfy detnet requirements and it is anticipated that more than one encapsulation may be deployed, for example gre, ipsec etc." {84: 1} {405: 1} {104, 405} 55 "One method of operating an IP DetNet data plane without encapsulation is to use ""6-tuple"" based flow identification, where ""6-tuple"" refers to information carried in IP and higher layer protocol headers. General background on the use of IP headers, and ""6-tuples"", to identify flows and support Quality of Service (QoS) can be found in RFC3670. RFC7657 provides useful background on differentiated services (DiffServ) and ""tuple"" based flow identification. DetNet flow aggregation may be enabled via the use of wildcards, masks, prefixes and ranges. The operation of this method is described in detail in I-D.ietf-detnet-ip." "Update based on the comments of ( 01.10 ) and ( 04.10 ) . I agree with , it 's a well - known and deployed example . I 'm not sure why it was removed . Cheers , comments have been resolved" 5627886f9da3fa5ecb5b7bcfceeb9ab7c3c19e9f 5627886f9da3fa5ecb5b7bcfceeb9ab7c3c19e9f draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework 453fc5745d087952c99380270d6b9cb166039ec445b7bbec68fc04a32c5d4114 ['453fc5745d087952c99380270d6b9cb166039ec445b7bbec68fc04a32c5d4114', '26f1985978c33dabae95a180c8a2951c2cff2e5682d451b22803cbc1fbb7207a', 'd0eb2c6c6960aab0139f5a1533a14e46a03acb5eb70876f7d287172a4d383314', '853be33484efcf8d9c687137501a8aa4dfbf75a63fa3418c763e1300f7112816'] B "one method of operating an ip detnet data plane without encapsulation is to use ""6-tuple"" based flow identification, where ""6-tuple"" refers to information carried in ip and higher layer protocol headers. general background on the use of ip headers, and ""6-tuples"", to identify flows and support quality of service (qos) can be found in rfc3670. rfc7657 provides useful background on differentiated services (diffserv) and ""tuple"" based flow identification. detnet flow aggregation may be enabled via the use of wildcards, masks, prefixes and ranges. the operation of this method is described in detail in i-d.ietf-detnet-ip." {84: 1} {405: 1} {104, 405} 55 "In cases where metadata is needed to process an MPLS encapsulated packet at the service sub-layer, a shim layer also called a control word (CW) RFC4385 can be used. Although such CWs are frequently 32 bits long, there is no architectural constraint on its size of this structure, only the requirement that it is fully understood by all parties operating on it in the DetNet service sub-layer. The operation of this method is described in detail in I-D.ietf-detnet- mpls." "Update based on the comments of ( 01.10 ) and ( 04.10 ) . I agree with , it 's a well - known and deployed example . I 'm not sure why it was removed . Cheers , comments have been resolved" 5627886f9da3fa5ecb5b7bcfceeb9ab7c3c19e9f 5627886f9da3fa5ecb5b7bcfceeb9ab7c3c19e9f draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework f71f75d35dcc2acd07fda08a3fb81b53c376a734ccbbfc6a11ca7d42b1e06d5c ['f71f75d35dcc2acd07fda08a3fb81b53c376a734ccbbfc6a11ca7d42b1e06d5c', '51a2a7e138780c471cccd38ccd2535db6f103ac1686110677780525a4ccb5c33'] A "in cases where metadata is needed to process an mpls encapsulated packet at the service sub-layer, a shim layer also called a control word (cw) rfc4385 can be used. although such cws are frequently 32 bits long, there is no architectural constraint on its size of this structure, only the requirement that it is fully understood by all parties operating on it in the detnet service sub-layer. the operation of this method is described in detail in i-d.ietf-detnet- mpls." {68: 1, 31: 1, 6: 3, 79: 6, 90: 4, 51: 6, 130: 6, 62: 5, 85: 5, 35: 7, 110: 7, 91: 9, 114: 7, 97: 7, 13: 6, 67: 6, 38: 8, 26: 5, 124: 6, 98: 6, 54: 6, 127: 7, 8: 2, 96: 7, 64: 6, 30: 8, 61: 9, 55: 3, 27: 5, 15: 7, 52: 5, 129: 7, 115: 7, 84: 2, 76: 7, 87: 7, 131: 9, 102: 4, 113: 9, 99: 6, 36: 7, 24: 6, 53: 5, 72: 8} {39: 1, 397: 1, 1: 3, 4: 6, 9: 6, 10: 7, 15: 7, 24: 6, 25: 5, 26: 5, 27: 7, 43: 7, 49: 10, 50: 9, 58: 9, 59: 6, 64: 7, 69: 5, 81: 6, 82: 6, 86: 7, 96: 8, 97: 7, 100: 9, 108: 7, 109: 8, 110: 8, 111: 6, 114: 7, 115: 8, 116: 7, 118: 6, 119: 5, 120: 7, 121: 4, 122: 8, 123: 7, 124: 3, 128: 8, 129: 8, 130: 9, 132: 5, 136: 6, 145: 5, 147: 8, 151: 8, 152: 8, 154: 7, 156: 6, 161: 4, 162: 3, 165: 7, 168: 8, 169: 7, 172: 7, 180: 8, 184: 6, 187: 9, 188: 8, 191: 7, 194: 5, 202: 6, 203: 7, 206: 6, 207: 7, 215: 5, 217: 7, 218: 2, 220: 4, 221: 4, 222: 3, 224: 7, 227: 7, 229: 7, 234: 9, 235: 6, 241: 6, 242: 6, 243: 5, 244: 8, 245: 5, 248: 8, 250: 8, 258: 5, 262: 8, 263: 9, 264: 5, 267: 4, 270: 7, 272: 7, 273: 6, 287: 7, 289: 7, 291: 9, 299: 7, 300: 7, 304: 7, 309: 4, 314: 6, 315: 7, 320: 4, 323: 5, 327: 8, 328: 6, 329: 6, 330: 4, 334: 6, 335: 7, 341: 7, 342: 8, 347: 7, 348: 7, 350: 8, 351: 9, 352: 7, 353: 7, 354: 6, 358: 2, 365: 7, 366: 6, 369: 5, 371: 9, 372: 9, 376: 6, 384: 9, 385: 8, 386: 7, 387: 7, 392: 6, 393: 7, 396: 8, 402: 7} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 55 "In cases where metadata is needed to process an MPLS encapsulated packet at the service sub-layer, a shim layer called a control word (CW) RFC4385 can be used. Although such CWs are frequently 32 bits long, there is no architectural constraint on its size of this structure, only the requirement that it is fully understood by all parties operating on it in the DetNet service sub-layer. The operation of this method is described in detail in I-D.ietf-detnet- mpls." "Update based on the comments of ( 01.10 ) and ( 04.10 ) . I agree with , it 's a well - known and deployed example . I 'm not sure why it was removed . Cheers , comments have been resolved" 5627886f9da3fa5ecb5b7bcfceeb9ab7c3c19e9f 5627886f9da3fa5ecb5b7bcfceeb9ab7c3c19e9f draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework 51a2a7e138780c471cccd38ccd2535db6f103ac1686110677780525a4ccb5c33 ['f71f75d35dcc2acd07fda08a3fb81b53c376a734ccbbfc6a11ca7d42b1e06d5c', '51a2a7e138780c471cccd38ccd2535db6f103ac1686110677780525a4ccb5c33'] B "in cases where metadata is needed to process an mpls encapsulated packet at the service sub-layer, a shim layer called a control word (cw) rfc4385 can be used. although such cws are frequently 32 bits long, there is no architectural constraint on its size of this structure, only the requirement that it is fully understood by all parties operating on it in the detnet service sub-layer. the operation of this method is described in detail in i-d.ietf-detnet- mpls." {68: 1, 31: 1, 6: 3, 79: 6, 90: 4, 51: 6, 130: 6, 62: 5, 85: 5, 35: 7, 110: 7, 91: 9, 114: 7, 97: 7, 13: 6, 67: 6, 38: 8, 26: 5, 124: 6, 98: 6, 54: 6, 127: 7, 8: 2, 96: 7, 64: 6, 30: 8, 61: 9, 55: 3, 27: 5, 15: 7, 52: 5, 129: 7, 115: 7, 84: 2, 76: 7, 87: 7, 131: 9, 102: 4, 113: 9, 99: 6, 36: 7, 24: 6, 53: 5, 72: 8} {39: 1, 397: 1, 1: 3, 4: 6, 9: 6, 10: 7, 15: 7, 24: 6, 25: 5, 26: 5, 27: 7, 43: 7, 49: 10, 50: 9, 58: 9, 59: 6, 64: 7, 69: 5, 81: 6, 82: 6, 86: 7, 96: 8, 97: 7, 100: 9, 108: 7, 109: 8, 110: 8, 111: 6, 114: 7, 115: 8, 116: 7, 118: 6, 119: 5, 120: 7, 121: 4, 122: 8, 123: 7, 124: 3, 128: 8, 129: 8, 130: 9, 132: 5, 136: 6, 145: 5, 147: 8, 151: 8, 152: 8, 154: 7, 156: 6, 161: 4, 162: 3, 165: 7, 168: 8, 169: 7, 172: 7, 180: 8, 184: 6, 187: 9, 188: 8, 191: 7, 194: 5, 202: 6, 203: 7, 206: 6, 207: 7, 215: 5, 217: 7, 218: 2, 220: 4, 221: 4, 222: 3, 224: 7, 227: 7, 229: 7, 234: 9, 235: 6, 241: 6, 242: 6, 243: 5, 244: 8, 245: 5, 248: 8, 250: 8, 258: 5, 262: 8, 263: 9, 264: 5, 267: 4, 270: 7, 272: 7, 273: 6, 287: 7, 289: 7, 291: 9, 299: 7, 300: 7, 304: 7, 309: 4, 314: 6, 315: 7, 320: 4, 323: 5, 327: 8, 328: 6, 329: 6, 330: 4, 334: 6, 335: 7, 341: 7, 342: 8, 347: 7, 348: 7, 350: 8, 351: 9, 352: 7, 353: 7, 354: 6, 358: 2, 365: 7, 366: 6, 369: 5, 371: 9, 372: 9, 376: 6, 384: 9, 385: 8, 386: 7, 387: 7, 392: 6, 393: 7, 396: 8, 402: 7} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 55 "Reservation of resources can allocate resources to specific DetNet flows. This can eliminate packet contention and loss for DetNet traffic. This also can reduce jitter for the DetNet traffic. DetNet flows are assumed to behave with respect to the reserved traffic profile. If other traffic shares the link resources, the use of (queuing, policing, shaping) policies can be used to ensure that the allocation of resources reserved for DetNet is met. Queuing and shaping of DetNet traffic could be required to ensure that DetNet traffic does not exceed its reserved profile but this would impact the DetNet service characteristics." "Update based on the comments of ( 01.10 ) and ( 04.10 ) . I agree with , it 's a well - known and deployed example . I 'm not sure why it was removed . Cheers , comments have been resolved" 5627886f9da3fa5ecb5b7bcfceeb9ab7c3c19e9f 5627886f9da3fa5ecb5b7bcfceeb9ab7c3c19e9f draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework 1d461b45ddd8d23bc4da82c7319696451df56fdf43af8bec67d483088c4ccd80 ['6a0240a7089e9eb5374ec83c67aef29bce159a2350fae0b9675eca23103d04c7', 'b4f663df7a56c4c3c7893956b9297f583a3ee08b6e667404871701c5db6884e5', '48d8a67306a5b7377d474058a02289ef5b0d47c7b426e70ca86c86fbaacd1c90', '1d461b45ddd8d23bc4da82c7319696451df56fdf43af8bec67d483088c4ccd80', 'c5585816f0df6bac1e8561d23945939d704941f0bc9b379d59f610db1feeae52', '37b3aa728e069dac87a1c6719d534af53a3c16745b470dc65fa0ead08542736e', '4c3da6e0fffc80e62e5f664bd81a2936b6593757d8fb0d02cabd8102872696d4', '09338bff4c055a4fa57185ce910ed41cd32622051fe170615aabadb84e10faa4', '0742ec0639e4bb03bafb0b62e474707c4e711aef2ade5826cd84de4e7122cea3', '83839a4b6f00a98b672d7d42db0e734dfc50262a09e90121413fa7e8f02a1fa3', '595ccef56e4f3f92cf6c8157968607922c16102040d858595d47562c1a6e672a', '427d7237acb5ebe013716dee7c43d7e5886164be733489be210e182ac81eb225', 'af8a420dec9dcad3ccc2748056ca06e500c69eca257e211cf29eb20635ea76e9', '878e4eb62fa086fa63f78e831077af12faaf0d2fc1d35390eae3936514aa7756', '065c7e1c6b9427086dcdef9b8fa47187efb9aaaec8398dcbf074196ed72a8f88', '923a35f1f95a2c2e0c5ca34c1759e5cd9005222aecf744f5f2cfbe2a937afc7c', '30d108135e5d5ca29f1851710d998b43e17cf658cb0bf7a20218abc345bf0b4e', '99a17c464525b7a715b4d8ac74d0889fc6ae244d5119ca838f8eedb1f0435444', 'fd0d3d7ba40e65fa061931cfb7d0f55d4f3056ed210d3960b5adc00c479d8187', '1b772dfa25f8ed2049d2157cbed246e1cbe7f36eb5685c9f8a6739297691ec2a', 'b9bbfabb58957652f3a296054fff42678c08ff84156bc8d94d3610e121e772bf'] A "reservation of resources can allocate resources to specific detnet flows. this can eliminate packet contention and loss for detnet traffic. this also can reduce jitter for the detnet traffic. detnet flows are assumed to behave with respect to the reserved traffic profile. if other traffic shares the link resources, the use of (queuing, policing, shaping) policies can be used to ensure that the allocation of resources reserved for detnet is met. queuing and shaping of detnet traffic could be required to ensure that detnet traffic does not exceed its reserved profile but this would impact the detnet service characteristics." {90: 1, 68: 1, 6: 1, 102: 1, 84: 1, 8: 1, 79: 3, 51: 3, 130: 3, 62: 2, 85: 2, 35: 4, 110: 4, 91: 6, 114: 4, 97: 4, 31: 2, 13: 3, 67: 3, 38: 5, 26: 2, 124: 3, 98: 3, 54: 3, 127: 4, 96: 4, 64: 3, 30: 5, 61: 6, 55: 2, 27: 2, 15: 4, 52: 2, 129: 4, 115: 4, 76: 4, 87: 4, 131: 6, 113: 6, 99: 3, 36: 4, 24: 3, 53: 2, 72: 5} {121: 1, 124: 1, 161: 1, 320: 1, 358: 1, 267: 1, 309: 1, 220: 1, 221: 1, 1: 6, 4: 3, 9: 3, 10: 4, 15: 4, 24: 3, 25: 2, 26: 2, 27: 4, 39: 2, 43: 4, 49: 7, 50: 6, 58: 6, 59: 3, 64: 4, 69: 2, 81: 3, 82: 3, 86: 4, 96: 5, 97: 4, 100: 6, 108: 4, 109: 5, 110: 5, 111: 3, 114: 4, 115: 5, 116: 4, 118: 3, 119: 2, 120: 4, 122: 5, 123: 4, 128: 5, 129: 5, 130: 6, 132: 2, 136: 3, 145: 2, 147: 5, 151: 5, 152: 5, 154: 4, 156: 3, 165: 4, 168: 5, 169: 4, 172: 4, 180: 5, 184: 3, 187: 6, 188: 5, 191: 4, 194: 2, 202: 3, 203: 4, 206: 3, 207: 4, 215: 2, 217: 4, 218: 5, 222: 2, 224: 4, 227: 4, 229: 4, 234: 6, 235: 3, 241: 3, 242: 3, 243: 2, 244: 5, 245: 2, 248: 5, 250: 5, 258: 8, 262: 5, 263: 6, 264: 2, 270: 4, 272: 4, 273: 3, 287: 4, 289: 4, 291: 6, 299: 4, 300: 4, 304: 4, 314: 3, 315: 4, 323: 2, 327: 5, 328: 3, 329: 3, 330: 7, 334: 3, 335: 4, 341: 4, 342: 5, 347: 4, 348: 4, 350: 5, 351: 6, 352: 4, 353: 4, 354: 3, 365: 4, 366: 3, 369: 2, 371: 6, 372: 6, 376: 3, 384: 6, 385: 5, 386: 4, 387: 4, 392: 3, 393: 4, 396: 5, 397: 4, 398: 3, 402: 4} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 55 "Use of a specific path for a flow. This allows control of the network delay by steering the packet with the ability to influence the physical path. Explicit routes complement reservation by ensuring that a consistent path can be associated with its resources for the duration of that path. Coupled with the traffic mechanism, this limits misordering and bounds latency. Explicit route computation can encompass a wide set of constraints and optimize the path for a certain characteristic e.g. highest bandwidth or lowest jitter. In these cases the ""best"" path for any set of characteristics may not be a shortest path. The selection of path can take into account multiple network metrics. Some of these metrics are measured and distributed by the routing system as traffic engineering metrics." "Update based on the comments of ( 01.10 ) and ( 04.10 ) . I agree with , it 's a well - known and deployed example . I 'm not sure why it was removed . Cheers , comments have been resolved" 5627886f9da3fa5ecb5b7bcfceeb9ab7c3c19e9f 5627886f9da3fa5ecb5b7bcfceeb9ab7c3c19e9f draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework c5585816f0df6bac1e8561d23945939d704941f0bc9b379d59f610db1feeae52 ['6a0240a7089e9eb5374ec83c67aef29bce159a2350fae0b9675eca23103d04c7', 'b4f663df7a56c4c3c7893956b9297f583a3ee08b6e667404871701c5db6884e5', '48d8a67306a5b7377d474058a02289ef5b0d47c7b426e70ca86c86fbaacd1c90', '1d461b45ddd8d23bc4da82c7319696451df56fdf43af8bec67d483088c4ccd80', 'c5585816f0df6bac1e8561d23945939d704941f0bc9b379d59f610db1feeae52', '37b3aa728e069dac87a1c6719d534af53a3c16745b470dc65fa0ead08542736e', '4c3da6e0fffc80e62e5f664bd81a2936b6593757d8fb0d02cabd8102872696d4', '09338bff4c055a4fa57185ce910ed41cd32622051fe170615aabadb84e10faa4', '0742ec0639e4bb03bafb0b62e474707c4e711aef2ade5826cd84de4e7122cea3', '83839a4b6f00a98b672d7d42db0e734dfc50262a09e90121413fa7e8f02a1fa3', '595ccef56e4f3f92cf6c8157968607922c16102040d858595d47562c1a6e672a', '427d7237acb5ebe013716dee7c43d7e5886164be733489be210e182ac81eb225', 'af8a420dec9dcad3ccc2748056ca06e500c69eca257e211cf29eb20635ea76e9', '878e4eb62fa086fa63f78e831077af12faaf0d2fc1d35390eae3936514aa7756', '065c7e1c6b9427086dcdef9b8fa47187efb9aaaec8398dcbf074196ed72a8f88', '923a35f1f95a2c2e0c5ca34c1759e5cd9005222aecf744f5f2cfbe2a937afc7c', '30d108135e5d5ca29f1851710d998b43e17cf658cb0bf7a20218abc345bf0b4e', '99a17c464525b7a715b4d8ac74d0889fc6ae244d5119ca838f8eedb1f0435444', 'fd0d3d7ba40e65fa061931cfb7d0f55d4f3056ed210d3960b5adc00c479d8187', '1b772dfa25f8ed2049d2157cbed246e1cbe7f36eb5685c9f8a6739297691ec2a', 'b9bbfabb58957652f3a296054fff42678c08ff84156bc8d94d3610e121e772bf'] A "use of a specific path for a flow. this allows control of the network delay by steering the packet with the ability to influence the physical path. explicit routes complement reservation by ensuring that a consistent path can be associated with its resources for the duration of that path. coupled with the traffic mechanism, this limits misordering and bounds latency. explicit route computation can encompass a wide set of constraints and optimize the path for a certain characteristic e.g. highest bandwidth or lowest jitter. in these cases the ""best"" path for any set of characteristics may not be a shortest path. the selection of path can take into account multiple network metrics. some of these metrics are measured and distributed by the routing system as traffic engineering metrics." {90: 1, 68: 1, 6: 1, 102: 1, 84: 1, 8: 1, 79: 3, 51: 3, 130: 3, 62: 2, 85: 2, 35: 4, 110: 4, 91: 6, 114: 4, 97: 4, 31: 2, 13: 3, 67: 3, 38: 5, 26: 2, 124: 3, 98: 3, 54: 3, 127: 4, 96: 4, 64: 3, 30: 5, 61: 6, 55: 2, 27: 2, 15: 4, 52: 2, 129: 4, 115: 4, 76: 4, 87: 4, 131: 6, 113: 6, 99: 3, 36: 4, 24: 3, 53: 2, 72: 5} {121: 1, 124: 1, 161: 1, 320: 1, 358: 1, 267: 1, 309: 1, 220: 1, 221: 1, 1: 6, 4: 3, 9: 3, 10: 4, 15: 4, 24: 3, 25: 2, 26: 2, 27: 4, 39: 2, 43: 4, 49: 7, 50: 6, 58: 6, 59: 3, 64: 4, 69: 2, 81: 3, 82: 3, 86: 4, 96: 5, 97: 4, 100: 6, 108: 4, 109: 5, 110: 5, 111: 3, 114: 4, 115: 5, 116: 4, 118: 3, 119: 2, 120: 4, 122: 5, 123: 4, 128: 5, 129: 5, 130: 6, 132: 2, 136: 3, 145: 2, 147: 5, 151: 5, 152: 5, 154: 4, 156: 3, 165: 4, 168: 5, 169: 4, 172: 4, 180: 5, 184: 3, 187: 6, 188: 5, 191: 4, 194: 2, 202: 3, 203: 4, 206: 3, 207: 4, 215: 2, 217: 4, 218: 5, 222: 2, 224: 4, 227: 4, 229: 4, 234: 6, 235: 3, 241: 3, 242: 3, 243: 2, 244: 5, 245: 2, 248: 5, 250: 5, 258: 8, 262: 5, 263: 6, 264: 2, 270: 4, 272: 4, 273: 3, 287: 4, 289: 4, 291: 6, 299: 4, 300: 4, 304: 4, 314: 3, 315: 4, 323: 2, 327: 5, 328: 3, 329: 3, 330: 7, 334: 3, 335: 4, 341: 4, 342: 5, 347: 4, 348: 4, 350: 5, 351: 6, 352: 4, 353: 4, 354: 3, 365: 4, 366: 3, 369: 2, 371: 6, 372: 6, 376: 3, 384: 6, 385: 5, 386: 4, 387: 4, 392: 3, 393: 4, 396: 5, 397: 4, 398: 3, 402: 4} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 55 "Use of multiple packet streams using multiple paths, for example 1+1 or 1:1 linear protection. For DetNet this primarily relates to packet replication and elimination capabilities. MPLS offers a number of protection schemes. MPLS hitless protection can be used to switch traffic to an already established path in order to restore delivery rapidly after a failure. Path changes, even in the case of failure recovery, can lead to the out of order delivery of data requiring packet ordering functions either within the DetNet service or at a high layer in the application traffic. Establishment of new paths after a failure is out of scope for DetNet services." "Update based on the comments of ( 01.10 ) and ( 04.10 ) . I agree with , it 's a well - known and deployed example . I 'm not sure why it was removed . Cheers , comments have been resolved" 5627886f9da3fa5ecb5b7bcfceeb9ab7c3c19e9f 5627886f9da3fa5ecb5b7bcfceeb9ab7c3c19e9f draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework 0742ec0639e4bb03bafb0b62e474707c4e711aef2ade5826cd84de4e7122cea3 ['6a0240a7089e9eb5374ec83c67aef29bce159a2350fae0b9675eca23103d04c7', 'b4f663df7a56c4c3c7893956b9297f583a3ee08b6e667404871701c5db6884e5', '48d8a67306a5b7377d474058a02289ef5b0d47c7b426e70ca86c86fbaacd1c90', '1d461b45ddd8d23bc4da82c7319696451df56fdf43af8bec67d483088c4ccd80', 'c5585816f0df6bac1e8561d23945939d704941f0bc9b379d59f610db1feeae52', '37b3aa728e069dac87a1c6719d534af53a3c16745b470dc65fa0ead08542736e', '4c3da6e0fffc80e62e5f664bd81a2936b6593757d8fb0d02cabd8102872696d4', '09338bff4c055a4fa57185ce910ed41cd32622051fe170615aabadb84e10faa4', '0742ec0639e4bb03bafb0b62e474707c4e711aef2ade5826cd84de4e7122cea3', '83839a4b6f00a98b672d7d42db0e734dfc50262a09e90121413fa7e8f02a1fa3', '595ccef56e4f3f92cf6c8157968607922c16102040d858595d47562c1a6e672a', '427d7237acb5ebe013716dee7c43d7e5886164be733489be210e182ac81eb225', 'af8a420dec9dcad3ccc2748056ca06e500c69eca257e211cf29eb20635ea76e9', '878e4eb62fa086fa63f78e831077af12faaf0d2fc1d35390eae3936514aa7756', '065c7e1c6b9427086dcdef9b8fa47187efb9aaaec8398dcbf074196ed72a8f88', '923a35f1f95a2c2e0c5ca34c1759e5cd9005222aecf744f5f2cfbe2a937afc7c', '30d108135e5d5ca29f1851710d998b43e17cf658cb0bf7a20218abc345bf0b4e', '99a17c464525b7a715b4d8ac74d0889fc6ae244d5119ca838f8eedb1f0435444', 'fd0d3d7ba40e65fa061931cfb7d0f55d4f3056ed210d3960b5adc00c479d8187', '1b772dfa25f8ed2049d2157cbed246e1cbe7f36eb5685c9f8a6739297691ec2a', 'b9bbfabb58957652f3a296054fff42678c08ff84156bc8d94d3610e121e772bf'] A "use of multiple packet streams using multiple paths, for example 1+1 or 1:1 linear protection. for detnet this primarily relates to packet replication and elimination capabilities. mpls offers a number of protection schemes. mpls hitless protection can be used to switch traffic to an already established path in order to restore delivery rapidly after a failure. path changes, even in the case of failure recovery, can lead to the out of order delivery of data requiring packet ordering functions either within the detnet service or at a high layer in the application traffic. establishment of new paths after a failure is out of scope for detnet services." {90: 1, 68: 1, 6: 1, 102: 1, 84: 1, 8: 1, 79: 3, 51: 3, 130: 3, 62: 2, 85: 2, 35: 4, 110: 4, 91: 6, 114: 4, 97: 4, 31: 2, 13: 3, 67: 3, 38: 5, 26: 2, 124: 3, 98: 3, 54: 3, 127: 4, 96: 4, 64: 3, 30: 5, 61: 6, 55: 2, 27: 2, 15: 4, 52: 2, 129: 4, 115: 4, 76: 4, 87: 4, 131: 6, 113: 6, 99: 3, 36: 4, 24: 3, 53: 2, 72: 5} {121: 1, 124: 1, 161: 1, 320: 1, 358: 1, 267: 1, 309: 1, 220: 1, 221: 1, 1: 6, 4: 3, 9: 3, 10: 4, 15: 4, 24: 3, 25: 2, 26: 2, 27: 4, 39: 2, 43: 4, 49: 7, 50: 6, 58: 6, 59: 3, 64: 4, 69: 2, 81: 3, 82: 3, 86: 4, 96: 5, 97: 4, 100: 6, 108: 4, 109: 5, 110: 5, 111: 3, 114: 4, 115: 5, 116: 4, 118: 3, 119: 2, 120: 4, 122: 5, 123: 4, 128: 5, 129: 5, 130: 6, 132: 2, 136: 3, 145: 2, 147: 5, 151: 5, 152: 5, 154: 4, 156: 3, 165: 4, 168: 5, 169: 4, 172: 4, 180: 5, 184: 3, 187: 6, 188: 5, 191: 4, 194: 2, 202: 3, 203: 4, 206: 3, 207: 4, 215: 2, 217: 4, 218: 5, 222: 2, 224: 4, 227: 4, 229: 4, 234: 6, 235: 3, 241: 3, 242: 3, 243: 2, 244: 5, 245: 2, 248: 5, 250: 5, 258: 8, 262: 5, 263: 6, 264: 2, 270: 4, 272: 4, 273: 3, 287: 4, 289: 4, 291: 6, 299: 4, 300: 4, 304: 4, 314: 3, 315: 4, 323: 2, 327: 5, 328: 3, 329: 3, 330: 7, 334: 3, 335: 4, 341: 4, 342: 5, 347: 4, 348: 4, 350: 5, 351: 6, 352: 4, 353: 4, 354: 3, 365: 4, 366: 3, 369: 2, 371: 6, 372: 6, 376: 3, 384: 6, 385: 5, 386: 4, 387: 4, 392: 3, 393: 4, 396: 5, 397: 4, 398: 3, 402: 4} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 55 "Network Coding, not to be confused with network programming, comprises several techniques where multiple data flows are encoded. These resulting flows can then be sent on different paths. The encoding operation can combine flows and error recovery information. When the encoded flows are decoded and recombined the original flows can be recovered. Note that Network coding uses an alternative to packet by packet PREOF. Therefore, for certain network topologies and traffic loads, Network Coding can be used to improve a network's throughput, efficiency, latency, and scalability, as well as resilience to partition, attacks, and eavesdropping, as compared to traditional methods. DetNet could utilized Network coding as an alternative to other protection means. Network coding is often applied in wireless networks and is being explored for other network types." "Update based on the comments of ( 01.10 ) and ( 04.10 ) . I agree with , it 's a well - known and deployed example . I 'm not sure why it was removed . Cheers , comments have been resolved" 5627886f9da3fa5ecb5b7bcfceeb9ab7c3c19e9f 5627886f9da3fa5ecb5b7bcfceeb9ab7c3c19e9f draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework 595ccef56e4f3f92cf6c8157968607922c16102040d858595d47562c1a6e672a ['6a0240a7089e9eb5374ec83c67aef29bce159a2350fae0b9675eca23103d04c7', 'b4f663df7a56c4c3c7893956b9297f583a3ee08b6e667404871701c5db6884e5', '48d8a67306a5b7377d474058a02289ef5b0d47c7b426e70ca86c86fbaacd1c90', '1d461b45ddd8d23bc4da82c7319696451df56fdf43af8bec67d483088c4ccd80', 'c5585816f0df6bac1e8561d23945939d704941f0bc9b379d59f610db1feeae52', '37b3aa728e069dac87a1c6719d534af53a3c16745b470dc65fa0ead08542736e', '4c3da6e0fffc80e62e5f664bd81a2936b6593757d8fb0d02cabd8102872696d4', '09338bff4c055a4fa57185ce910ed41cd32622051fe170615aabadb84e10faa4', '0742ec0639e4bb03bafb0b62e474707c4e711aef2ade5826cd84de4e7122cea3', '83839a4b6f00a98b672d7d42db0e734dfc50262a09e90121413fa7e8f02a1fa3', '595ccef56e4f3f92cf6c8157968607922c16102040d858595d47562c1a6e672a', '427d7237acb5ebe013716dee7c43d7e5886164be733489be210e182ac81eb225', 'af8a420dec9dcad3ccc2748056ca06e500c69eca257e211cf29eb20635ea76e9', '878e4eb62fa086fa63f78e831077af12faaf0d2fc1d35390eae3936514aa7756', '065c7e1c6b9427086dcdef9b8fa47187efb9aaaec8398dcbf074196ed72a8f88', '923a35f1f95a2c2e0c5ca34c1759e5cd9005222aecf744f5f2cfbe2a937afc7c', '30d108135e5d5ca29f1851710d998b43e17cf658cb0bf7a20218abc345bf0b4e', '99a17c464525b7a715b4d8ac74d0889fc6ae244d5119ca838f8eedb1f0435444', 'fd0d3d7ba40e65fa061931cfb7d0f55d4f3056ed210d3960b5adc00c479d8187', '1b772dfa25f8ed2049d2157cbed246e1cbe7f36eb5685c9f8a6739297691ec2a', 'b9bbfabb58957652f3a296054fff42678c08ff84156bc8d94d3610e121e772bf'] A "network coding, not to be confused with network programming, comprises several techniques where multiple data flows are encoded. these resulting flows can then be sent on different paths. the encoding operation can combine flows and error recovery information. when the encoded flows are decoded and recombined the original flows can be recovered. note that network coding uses an alternative to packet by packet preof. therefore, for certain network topologies and traffic loads, network coding can be used to improve a network's throughput, efficiency, latency, and scalability, as well as resilience to partition, attacks, and eavesdropping, as compared to traditional methods. detnet could utilized network coding as an alternative to other protection means. network coding is often applied in wireless networks and is being explored for other network types." {90: 1, 68: 1, 6: 1, 102: 1, 84: 1, 8: 1, 79: 3, 51: 3, 130: 3, 62: 2, 85: 2, 35: 4, 110: 4, 91: 6, 114: 4, 97: 4, 31: 2, 13: 3, 67: 3, 38: 5, 26: 2, 124: 3, 98: 3, 54: 3, 127: 4, 96: 4, 64: 3, 30: 5, 61: 6, 55: 2, 27: 2, 15: 4, 52: 2, 129: 4, 115: 4, 76: 4, 87: 4, 131: 6, 113: 6, 99: 3, 36: 4, 24: 3, 53: 2, 72: 5} {121: 1, 124: 1, 161: 1, 320: 1, 358: 1, 267: 1, 309: 1, 220: 1, 221: 1, 1: 6, 4: 3, 9: 3, 10: 4, 15: 4, 24: 3, 25: 2, 26: 2, 27: 4, 39: 2, 43: 4, 49: 7, 50: 6, 58: 6, 59: 3, 64: 4, 69: 2, 81: 3, 82: 3, 86: 4, 96: 5, 97: 4, 100: 6, 108: 4, 109: 5, 110: 5, 111: 3, 114: 4, 115: 5, 116: 4, 118: 3, 119: 2, 120: 4, 122: 5, 123: 4, 128: 5, 129: 5, 130: 6, 132: 2, 136: 3, 145: 2, 147: 5, 151: 5, 152: 5, 154: 4, 156: 3, 165: 4, 168: 5, 169: 4, 172: 4, 180: 5, 184: 3, 187: 6, 188: 5, 191: 4, 194: 2, 202: 3, 203: 4, 206: 3, 207: 4, 215: 2, 217: 4, 218: 5, 222: 2, 224: 4, 227: 4, 229: 4, 234: 6, 235: 3, 241: 3, 242: 3, 243: 2, 244: 5, 245: 2, 248: 5, 250: 5, 258: 8, 262: 5, 263: 6, 264: 2, 270: 4, 272: 4, 273: 3, 287: 4, 289: 4, 291: 6, 299: 4, 300: 4, 304: 4, 314: 3, 315: 4, 323: 2, 327: 5, 328: 3, 329: 3, 330: 7, 334: 3, 335: 4, 341: 4, 342: 5, 347: 4, 348: 4, 350: 5, 351: 6, 352: 4, 353: 4, 354: 3, 365: 4, 366: 3, 369: 2, 371: 6, 372: 6, 376: 3, 384: 6, 385: 5, 386: 4, 387: 4, 392: 3, 393: 4, 396: 5, 397: 4, 398: 3, 402: 4} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 55 "Use of packet by packet distribution of the same DetNet flow over multiple paths is not recommended except for the cases listed above where PREOF is utilized to improve protection of traffic and maintain order. Packet by packet load sharing, e.g., via ECMP or UCMP, impacts ordering and possibly jitter." "Update based on the comments of ( 01.10 ) and ( 04.10 ) . I agree with , it 's a well - known and deployed example . I 'm not sure why it was removed . Cheers , comments have been resolved" 5627886f9da3fa5ecb5b7bcfceeb9ab7c3c19e9f 5627886f9da3fa5ecb5b7bcfceeb9ab7c3c19e9f draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework 30d108135e5d5ca29f1851710d998b43e17cf658cb0bf7a20218abc345bf0b4e ['6a0240a7089e9eb5374ec83c67aef29bce159a2350fae0b9675eca23103d04c7', 'b4f663df7a56c4c3c7893956b9297f583a3ee08b6e667404871701c5db6884e5', '48d8a67306a5b7377d474058a02289ef5b0d47c7b426e70ca86c86fbaacd1c90', '1d461b45ddd8d23bc4da82c7319696451df56fdf43af8bec67d483088c4ccd80', 'c5585816f0df6bac1e8561d23945939d704941f0bc9b379d59f610db1feeae52', '37b3aa728e069dac87a1c6719d534af53a3c16745b470dc65fa0ead08542736e', '4c3da6e0fffc80e62e5f664bd81a2936b6593757d8fb0d02cabd8102872696d4', '09338bff4c055a4fa57185ce910ed41cd32622051fe170615aabadb84e10faa4', '0742ec0639e4bb03bafb0b62e474707c4e711aef2ade5826cd84de4e7122cea3', '83839a4b6f00a98b672d7d42db0e734dfc50262a09e90121413fa7e8f02a1fa3', '595ccef56e4f3f92cf6c8157968607922c16102040d858595d47562c1a6e672a', '427d7237acb5ebe013716dee7c43d7e5886164be733489be210e182ac81eb225', 'af8a420dec9dcad3ccc2748056ca06e500c69eca257e211cf29eb20635ea76e9', '878e4eb62fa086fa63f78e831077af12faaf0d2fc1d35390eae3936514aa7756', '065c7e1c6b9427086dcdef9b8fa47187efb9aaaec8398dcbf074196ed72a8f88', '923a35f1f95a2c2e0c5ca34c1759e5cd9005222aecf744f5f2cfbe2a937afc7c', '30d108135e5d5ca29f1851710d998b43e17cf658cb0bf7a20218abc345bf0b4e', '99a17c464525b7a715b4d8ac74d0889fc6ae244d5119ca838f8eedb1f0435444', 'fd0d3d7ba40e65fa061931cfb7d0f55d4f3056ed210d3960b5adc00c479d8187', '1b772dfa25f8ed2049d2157cbed246e1cbe7f36eb5685c9f8a6739297691ec2a', 'b9bbfabb58957652f3a296054fff42678c08ff84156bc8d94d3610e121e772bf'] A "use of packet by packet distribution of the same detnet flow over multiple paths is not recommended except for the cases listed above where preof is utilized to improve protection of traffic and maintain order. packet by packet load sharing, e.g., via ecmp or ucmp, impacts ordering and possibly jitter." {90: 1, 68: 1, 6: 1, 102: 1, 84: 1, 8: 1, 79: 3, 51: 3, 130: 3, 62: 2, 85: 2, 35: 4, 110: 4, 91: 6, 114: 4, 97: 4, 31: 2, 13: 3, 67: 3, 38: 5, 26: 2, 124: 3, 98: 3, 54: 3, 127: 4, 96: 4, 64: 3, 30: 5, 61: 6, 55: 2, 27: 2, 15: 4, 52: 2, 129: 4, 115: 4, 76: 4, 87: 4, 131: 6, 113: 6, 99: 3, 36: 4, 24: 3, 53: 2, 72: 5} {121: 1, 124: 1, 161: 1, 320: 1, 358: 1, 267: 1, 309: 1, 220: 1, 221: 1, 1: 6, 4: 3, 9: 3, 10: 4, 15: 4, 24: 3, 25: 2, 26: 2, 27: 4, 39: 2, 43: 4, 49: 7, 50: 6, 58: 6, 59: 3, 64: 4, 69: 2, 81: 3, 82: 3, 86: 4, 96: 5, 97: 4, 100: 6, 108: 4, 109: 5, 110: 5, 111: 3, 114: 4, 115: 5, 116: 4, 118: 3, 119: 2, 120: 4, 122: 5, 123: 4, 128: 5, 129: 5, 130: 6, 132: 2, 136: 3, 145: 2, 147: 5, 151: 5, 152: 5, 154: 4, 156: 3, 165: 4, 168: 5, 169: 4, 172: 4, 180: 5, 184: 3, 187: 6, 188: 5, 191: 4, 194: 2, 202: 3, 203: 4, 206: 3, 207: 4, 215: 2, 217: 4, 218: 5, 222: 2, 224: 4, 227: 4, 229: 4, 234: 6, 235: 3, 241: 3, 242: 3, 243: 2, 244: 5, 245: 2, 248: 5, 250: 5, 258: 8, 262: 5, 263: 6, 264: 2, 270: 4, 272: 4, 273: 3, 287: 4, 289: 4, 291: 6, 299: 4, 300: 4, 304: 4, 314: 3, 315: 4, 323: 2, 327: 5, 328: 3, 329: 3, 330: 7, 334: 3, 335: 4, 341: 4, 342: 5, 347: 4, 348: 4, 350: 5, 351: 6, 352: 4, 353: 4, 354: 3, 365: 4, 366: 3, 369: 2, 371: 6, 372: 6, 376: 3, 384: 6, 385: 5, 386: 4, 387: 4, 392: 3, 393: 4, 396: 5, 397: 4, 398: 3, 402: 4} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 55 "Since Detnet leverages many different forwarding sub-layers, those technologies also support a number of tools to troubleshoot connectivity for example, to support identification of misbehaving flows. At the service layer again there are existing mechanisms to troubleshoot or monitor flows. Many of these mechanisms exist for IP and MPLS networks. A client of a DetNet service can introduce any monitoring applications which can detect and monitor delay and loss." "Update based on the comments of ( 01.10 ) and ( 04.10 ) . I agree with , it 's a well - known and deployed example . I 'm not sure why it was removed . Cheers , comments have been resolved" 5627886f9da3fa5ecb5b7bcfceeb9ab7c3c19e9f 5627886f9da3fa5ecb5b7bcfceeb9ab7c3c19e9f draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework 09338bff4c055a4fa57185ce910ed41cd32622051fe170615aabadb84e10faa4 ['6a0240a7089e9eb5374ec83c67aef29bce159a2350fae0b9675eca23103d04c7', 'b4f663df7a56c4c3c7893956b9297f583a3ee08b6e667404871701c5db6884e5', '48d8a67306a5b7377d474058a02289ef5b0d47c7b426e70ca86c86fbaacd1c90', '1d461b45ddd8d23bc4da82c7319696451df56fdf43af8bec67d483088c4ccd80', 'c5585816f0df6bac1e8561d23945939d704941f0bc9b379d59f610db1feeae52', '37b3aa728e069dac87a1c6719d534af53a3c16745b470dc65fa0ead08542736e', '4c3da6e0fffc80e62e5f664bd81a2936b6593757d8fb0d02cabd8102872696d4', '09338bff4c055a4fa57185ce910ed41cd32622051fe170615aabadb84e10faa4', '0742ec0639e4bb03bafb0b62e474707c4e711aef2ade5826cd84de4e7122cea3', '83839a4b6f00a98b672d7d42db0e734dfc50262a09e90121413fa7e8f02a1fa3', '595ccef56e4f3f92cf6c8157968607922c16102040d858595d47562c1a6e672a', '427d7237acb5ebe013716dee7c43d7e5886164be733489be210e182ac81eb225', 'af8a420dec9dcad3ccc2748056ca06e500c69eca257e211cf29eb20635ea76e9', '878e4eb62fa086fa63f78e831077af12faaf0d2fc1d35390eae3936514aa7756', '065c7e1c6b9427086dcdef9b8fa47187efb9aaaec8398dcbf074196ed72a8f88', '923a35f1f95a2c2e0c5ca34c1759e5cd9005222aecf744f5f2cfbe2a937afc7c', '30d108135e5d5ca29f1851710d998b43e17cf658cb0bf7a20218abc345bf0b4e', '99a17c464525b7a715b4d8ac74d0889fc6ae244d5119ca838f8eedb1f0435444', 'fd0d3d7ba40e65fa061931cfb7d0f55d4f3056ed210d3960b5adc00c479d8187', '1b772dfa25f8ed2049d2157cbed246e1cbe7f36eb5685c9f8a6739297691ec2a', 'b9bbfabb58957652f3a296054fff42678c08ff84156bc8d94d3610e121e772bf'] A "since detnet leverages many different forwarding sub-layers, those technologies also support a number of tools to troubleshoot connectivity for example, to support identification of misbehaving flows. at the service layer again there are existing mechanisms to troubleshoot or monitor flows. many of these mechanisms exist for ip and mpls networks. a client of a detnet service can introduce any monitoring applications which can detect and monitor delay and loss." {90: 1, 68: 1, 6: 1, 102: 1, 84: 1, 8: 1, 79: 3, 51: 3, 130: 3, 62: 2, 85: 2, 35: 4, 110: 4, 91: 6, 114: 4, 97: 4, 31: 2, 13: 3, 67: 3, 38: 5, 26: 2, 124: 3, 98: 3, 54: 3, 127: 4, 96: 4, 64: 3, 30: 5, 61: 6, 55: 2, 27: 2, 15: 4, 52: 2, 129: 4, 115: 4, 76: 4, 87: 4, 131: 6, 113: 6, 99: 3, 36: 4, 24: 3, 53: 2, 72: 5} {121: 1, 124: 1, 161: 1, 320: 1, 358: 1, 267: 1, 309: 1, 220: 1, 221: 1, 1: 6, 4: 3, 9: 3, 10: 4, 15: 4, 24: 3, 25: 2, 26: 2, 27: 4, 39: 2, 43: 4, 49: 7, 50: 6, 58: 6, 59: 3, 64: 4, 69: 2, 81: 3, 82: 3, 86: 4, 96: 5, 97: 4, 100: 6, 108: 4, 109: 5, 110: 5, 111: 3, 114: 4, 115: 5, 116: 4, 118: 3, 119: 2, 120: 4, 122: 5, 123: 4, 128: 5, 129: 5, 130: 6, 132: 2, 136: 3, 145: 2, 147: 5, 151: 5, 152: 5, 154: 4, 156: 3, 165: 4, 168: 5, 169: 4, 172: 4, 180: 5, 184: 3, 187: 6, 188: 5, 191: 4, 194: 2, 202: 3, 203: 4, 206: 3, 207: 4, 215: 2, 217: 4, 218: 5, 222: 2, 224: 4, 227: 4, 229: 4, 234: 6, 235: 3, 241: 3, 242: 3, 243: 2, 244: 5, 245: 2, 248: 5, 250: 5, 258: 8, 262: 5, 263: 6, 264: 2, 270: 4, 272: 4, 273: 3, 287: 4, 289: 4, 291: 6, 299: 4, 300: 4, 304: 4, 314: 3, 315: 4, 323: 2, 327: 5, 328: 3, 329: 3, 330: 7, 334: 3, 335: 4, 341: 4, 342: 5, 347: 4, 348: 4, 350: 5, 351: 6, 352: 4, 353: 4, 354: 3, 365: 4, 366: 3, 369: 2, 371: 6, 372: 6, 376: 3, 384: 6, 385: 5, 386: 4, 387: 4, 392: 3, 393: 4, 396: 5, 397: 4, 398: 3, 402: 4} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 55 "To a large degree this follows the logic in the previous section. Analytics can be inherited from the two sub-layers. At the DetNet service edge packet and bit counters e.g. sent, received, dropped, and out of sequence are maintained." "Update based on the comments of ( 01.10 ) and ( 04.10 ) . I agree with , it 's a well - known and deployed example . I 'm not sure why it was removed . Cheers , comments have been resolved" 5627886f9da3fa5ecb5b7bcfceeb9ab7c3c19e9f 5627886f9da3fa5ecb5b7bcfceeb9ab7c3c19e9f draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework 48d8a67306a5b7377d474058a02289ef5b0d47c7b426e70ca86c86fbaacd1c90 ['6a0240a7089e9eb5374ec83c67aef29bce159a2350fae0b9675eca23103d04c7', 'b4f663df7a56c4c3c7893956b9297f583a3ee08b6e667404871701c5db6884e5', '48d8a67306a5b7377d474058a02289ef5b0d47c7b426e70ca86c86fbaacd1c90', '1d461b45ddd8d23bc4da82c7319696451df56fdf43af8bec67d483088c4ccd80', 'c5585816f0df6bac1e8561d23945939d704941f0bc9b379d59f610db1feeae52', '37b3aa728e069dac87a1c6719d534af53a3c16745b470dc65fa0ead08542736e', '4c3da6e0fffc80e62e5f664bd81a2936b6593757d8fb0d02cabd8102872696d4', '09338bff4c055a4fa57185ce910ed41cd32622051fe170615aabadb84e10faa4', '0742ec0639e4bb03bafb0b62e474707c4e711aef2ade5826cd84de4e7122cea3', '83839a4b6f00a98b672d7d42db0e734dfc50262a09e90121413fa7e8f02a1fa3', '595ccef56e4f3f92cf6c8157968607922c16102040d858595d47562c1a6e672a', '427d7237acb5ebe013716dee7c43d7e5886164be733489be210e182ac81eb225', 'af8a420dec9dcad3ccc2748056ca06e500c69eca257e211cf29eb20635ea76e9', '878e4eb62fa086fa63f78e831077af12faaf0d2fc1d35390eae3936514aa7756', '065c7e1c6b9427086dcdef9b8fa47187efb9aaaec8398dcbf074196ed72a8f88', '923a35f1f95a2c2e0c5ca34c1759e5cd9005222aecf744f5f2cfbe2a937afc7c', '30d108135e5d5ca29f1851710d998b43e17cf658cb0bf7a20218abc345bf0b4e', '99a17c464525b7a715b4d8ac74d0889fc6ae244d5119ca838f8eedb1f0435444', 'fd0d3d7ba40e65fa061931cfb7d0f55d4f3056ed210d3960b5adc00c479d8187', '1b772dfa25f8ed2049d2157cbed246e1cbe7f36eb5685c9f8a6739297691ec2a', 'b9bbfabb58957652f3a296054fff42678c08ff84156bc8d94d3610e121e772bf'] A "to a large degree this follows the logic in the previous section. analytics can be inherited from the two sub-layers. at the detnet service edge packet and bit counters e.g. sent, received, dropped, and out of sequence are maintained." {90: 1, 68: 1, 6: 1, 102: 1, 84: 1, 8: 1, 79: 3, 51: 3, 130: 3, 62: 2, 85: 2, 35: 4, 110: 4, 91: 6, 114: 4, 97: 4, 31: 2, 13: 3, 67: 3, 38: 5, 26: 2, 124: 3, 98: 3, 54: 3, 127: 4, 96: 4, 64: 3, 30: 5, 61: 6, 55: 2, 27: 2, 15: 4, 52: 2, 129: 4, 115: 4, 76: 4, 87: 4, 131: 6, 113: 6, 99: 3, 36: 4, 24: 3, 53: 2, 72: 5} {121: 1, 124: 1, 161: 1, 320: 1, 358: 1, 267: 1, 309: 1, 220: 1, 221: 1, 1: 6, 4: 3, 9: 3, 10: 4, 15: 4, 24: 3, 25: 2, 26: 2, 27: 4, 39: 2, 43: 4, 49: 7, 50: 6, 58: 6, 59: 3, 64: 4, 69: 2, 81: 3, 82: 3, 86: 4, 96: 5, 97: 4, 100: 6, 108: 4, 109: 5, 110: 5, 111: 3, 114: 4, 115: 5, 116: 4, 118: 3, 119: 2, 120: 4, 122: 5, 123: 4, 128: 5, 129: 5, 130: 6, 132: 2, 136: 3, 145: 2, 147: 5, 151: 5, 152: 5, 154: 4, 156: 3, 165: 4, 168: 5, 169: 4, 172: 4, 180: 5, 184: 3, 187: 6, 188: 5, 191: 4, 194: 2, 202: 3, 203: 4, 206: 3, 207: 4, 215: 2, 217: 4, 218: 5, 222: 2, 224: 4, 227: 4, 229: 4, 234: 6, 235: 3, 241: 3, 242: 3, 243: 2, 244: 5, 245: 2, 248: 5, 250: 5, 258: 8, 262: 5, 263: 6, 264: 2, 270: 4, 272: 4, 273: 3, 287: 4, 289: 4, 291: 6, 299: 4, 300: 4, 304: 4, 314: 3, 315: 4, 323: 2, 327: 5, 328: 3, 329: 3, 330: 7, 334: 3, 335: 4, 341: 4, 342: 5, 347: 4, 348: 4, 350: 5, 351: 6, 352: 4, 353: 4, 354: 3, 365: 4, 366: 3, 369: 2, 371: 6, 372: 6, 376: 3, 384: 6, 385: 5, 386: 4, 387: 4, 392: 3, 393: 4, 396: 5, 397: 4, 398: 3, 402: 4} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 55 "The provider of a DetNet service may allow other capabilities to monitor flows such as more detail loss statistics and time stamping of events. The details of these capabilities are currently out of scope for this document." "Update based on the comments of ( 01.10 ) and ( 04.10 ) . I agree with , it 's a well - known and deployed example . I 'm not sure why it was removed . Cheers , comments have been resolved" 5627886f9da3fa5ecb5b7bcfceeb9ab7c3c19e9f 5627886f9da3fa5ecb5b7bcfceeb9ab7c3c19e9f draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework b9bbfabb58957652f3a296054fff42678c08ff84156bc8d94d3610e121e772bf ['6a0240a7089e9eb5374ec83c67aef29bce159a2350fae0b9675eca23103d04c7', 'b4f663df7a56c4c3c7893956b9297f583a3ee08b6e667404871701c5db6884e5', '48d8a67306a5b7377d474058a02289ef5b0d47c7b426e70ca86c86fbaacd1c90', '1d461b45ddd8d23bc4da82c7319696451df56fdf43af8bec67d483088c4ccd80', 'c5585816f0df6bac1e8561d23945939d704941f0bc9b379d59f610db1feeae52', '37b3aa728e069dac87a1c6719d534af53a3c16745b470dc65fa0ead08542736e', '4c3da6e0fffc80e62e5f664bd81a2936b6593757d8fb0d02cabd8102872696d4', '09338bff4c055a4fa57185ce910ed41cd32622051fe170615aabadb84e10faa4', '0742ec0639e4bb03bafb0b62e474707c4e711aef2ade5826cd84de4e7122cea3', '83839a4b6f00a98b672d7d42db0e734dfc50262a09e90121413fa7e8f02a1fa3', '595ccef56e4f3f92cf6c8157968607922c16102040d858595d47562c1a6e672a', '427d7237acb5ebe013716dee7c43d7e5886164be733489be210e182ac81eb225', 'af8a420dec9dcad3ccc2748056ca06e500c69eca257e211cf29eb20635ea76e9', '878e4eb62fa086fa63f78e831077af12faaf0d2fc1d35390eae3936514aa7756', '065c7e1c6b9427086dcdef9b8fa47187efb9aaaec8398dcbf074196ed72a8f88', '923a35f1f95a2c2e0c5ca34c1759e5cd9005222aecf744f5f2cfbe2a937afc7c', '30d108135e5d5ca29f1851710d998b43e17cf658cb0bf7a20218abc345bf0b4e', '99a17c464525b7a715b4d8ac74d0889fc6ae244d5119ca838f8eedb1f0435444', 'fd0d3d7ba40e65fa061931cfb7d0f55d4f3056ed210d3960b5adc00c479d8187', '1b772dfa25f8ed2049d2157cbed246e1cbe7f36eb5685c9f8a6739297691ec2a', 'b9bbfabb58957652f3a296054fff42678c08ff84156bc8d94d3610e121e772bf'] A "the provider of a detnet service may allow other capabilities to monitor flows such as more detail loss statistics and time stamping of events. the details of these capabilities are currently out of scope for this document." {90: 1, 68: 1, 6: 1, 102: 1, 84: 1, 8: 1, 79: 3, 51: 3, 130: 3, 62: 2, 85: 2, 35: 4, 110: 4, 91: 6, 114: 4, 97: 4, 31: 2, 13: 3, 67: 3, 38: 5, 26: 2, 124: 3, 98: 3, 54: 3, 127: 4, 96: 4, 64: 3, 30: 5, 61: 6, 55: 2, 27: 2, 15: 4, 52: 2, 129: 4, 115: 4, 76: 4, 87: 4, 131: 6, 113: 6, 99: 3, 36: 4, 24: 3, 53: 2, 72: 5} {121: 1, 124: 1, 161: 1, 320: 1, 358: 1, 267: 1, 309: 1, 220: 1, 221: 1, 1: 6, 4: 3, 9: 3, 10: 4, 15: 4, 24: 3, 25: 2, 26: 2, 27: 4, 39: 2, 43: 4, 49: 7, 50: 6, 58: 6, 59: 3, 64: 4, 69: 2, 81: 3, 82: 3, 86: 4, 96: 5, 97: 4, 100: 6, 108: 4, 109: 5, 110: 5, 111: 3, 114: 4, 115: 5, 116: 4, 118: 3, 119: 2, 120: 4, 122: 5, 123: 4, 128: 5, 129: 5, 130: 6, 132: 2, 136: 3, 145: 2, 147: 5, 151: 5, 152: 5, 154: 4, 156: 3, 165: 4, 168: 5, 169: 4, 172: 4, 180: 5, 184: 3, 187: 6, 188: 5, 191: 4, 194: 2, 202: 3, 203: 4, 206: 3, 207: 4, 215: 2, 217: 4, 218: 5, 222: 2, 224: 4, 227: 4, 229: 4, 234: 6, 235: 3, 241: 3, 242: 3, 243: 2, 244: 5, 245: 2, 248: 5, 250: 5, 258: 8, 262: 5, 263: 6, 264: 2, 270: 4, 272: 4, 273: 3, 287: 4, 289: 4, 291: 6, 299: 4, 300: 4, 304: 4, 314: 3, 315: 4, 323: 2, 327: 5, 328: 3, 329: 3, 330: 7, 334: 3, 335: 4, 341: 4, 342: 5, 347: 4, 348: 4, 350: 5, 351: 6, 352: 4, 353: 4, 354: 3, 365: 4, 366: 3, 369: 2, 371: 6, 372: 6, 376: 3, 384: 6, 385: 5, 386: 4, 387: 4, 392: 3, 393: 4, 396: 5, 397: 4, 398: 3, 402: 4} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 55 Several of these capabilities are expanded upon in more detail below. "Update based on the comments of ( 01.10 ) and ( 04.10 ) . I agree with , it 's a well - known and deployed example . I 'm not sure why it was removed . Cheers , comments have been resolved" 5627886f9da3fa5ecb5b7bcfceeb9ab7c3c19e9f 5627886f9da3fa5ecb5b7bcfceeb9ab7c3c19e9f draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework 83839a4b6f00a98b672d7d42db0e734dfc50262a09e90121413fa7e8f02a1fa3 ['6a0240a7089e9eb5374ec83c67aef29bce159a2350fae0b9675eca23103d04c7', 'b4f663df7a56c4c3c7893956b9297f583a3ee08b6e667404871701c5db6884e5', '48d8a67306a5b7377d474058a02289ef5b0d47c7b426e70ca86c86fbaacd1c90', '1d461b45ddd8d23bc4da82c7319696451df56fdf43af8bec67d483088c4ccd80', 'c5585816f0df6bac1e8561d23945939d704941f0bc9b379d59f610db1feeae52', '37b3aa728e069dac87a1c6719d534af53a3c16745b470dc65fa0ead08542736e', '4c3da6e0fffc80e62e5f664bd81a2936b6593757d8fb0d02cabd8102872696d4', '09338bff4c055a4fa57185ce910ed41cd32622051fe170615aabadb84e10faa4', '0742ec0639e4bb03bafb0b62e474707c4e711aef2ade5826cd84de4e7122cea3', '83839a4b6f00a98b672d7d42db0e734dfc50262a09e90121413fa7e8f02a1fa3', '595ccef56e4f3f92cf6c8157968607922c16102040d858595d47562c1a6e672a', '427d7237acb5ebe013716dee7c43d7e5886164be733489be210e182ac81eb225', 'af8a420dec9dcad3ccc2748056ca06e500c69eca257e211cf29eb20635ea76e9', '878e4eb62fa086fa63f78e831077af12faaf0d2fc1d35390eae3936514aa7756', '065c7e1c6b9427086dcdef9b8fa47187efb9aaaec8398dcbf074196ed72a8f88', '923a35f1f95a2c2e0c5ca34c1759e5cd9005222aecf744f5f2cfbe2a937afc7c', '30d108135e5d5ca29f1851710d998b43e17cf658cb0bf7a20218abc345bf0b4e', '99a17c464525b7a715b4d8ac74d0889fc6ae244d5119ca838f8eedb1f0435444', 'fd0d3d7ba40e65fa061931cfb7d0f55d4f3056ed210d3960b5adc00c479d8187', '1b772dfa25f8ed2049d2157cbed246e1cbe7f36eb5685c9f8a6739297691ec2a', 'b9bbfabb58957652f3a296054fff42678c08ff84156bc8d94d3610e121e772bf'] A several of these capabilities are expanded upon in more detail below. {90: 1, 68: 1, 6: 1, 102: 1, 84: 1, 8: 1, 79: 3, 51: 3, 130: 3, 62: 2, 85: 2, 35: 4, 110: 4, 91: 6, 114: 4, 97: 4, 31: 2, 13: 3, 67: 3, 38: 5, 26: 2, 124: 3, 98: 3, 54: 3, 127: 4, 96: 4, 64: 3, 30: 5, 61: 6, 55: 2, 27: 2, 15: 4, 52: 2, 129: 4, 115: 4, 76: 4, 87: 4, 131: 6, 113: 6, 99: 3, 36: 4, 24: 3, 53: 2, 72: 5} {121: 1, 124: 1, 161: 1, 320: 1, 358: 1, 267: 1, 309: 1, 220: 1, 221: 1, 1: 6, 4: 3, 9: 3, 10: 4, 15: 4, 24: 3, 25: 2, 26: 2, 27: 4, 39: 2, 43: 4, 49: 7, 50: 6, 58: 6, 59: 3, 64: 4, 69: 2, 81: 3, 82: 3, 86: 4, 96: 5, 97: 4, 100: 6, 108: 4, 109: 5, 110: 5, 111: 3, 114: 4, 115: 5, 116: 4, 118: 3, 119: 2, 120: 4, 122: 5, 123: 4, 128: 5, 129: 5, 130: 6, 132: 2, 136: 3, 145: 2, 147: 5, 151: 5, 152: 5, 154: 4, 156: 3, 165: 4, 168: 5, 169: 4, 172: 4, 180: 5, 184: 3, 187: 6, 188: 5, 191: 4, 194: 2, 202: 3, 203: 4, 206: 3, 207: 4, 215: 2, 217: 4, 218: 5, 222: 2, 224: 4, 227: 4, 229: 4, 234: 6, 235: 3, 241: 3, 242: 3, 243: 2, 244: 5, 245: 2, 248: 5, 250: 5, 258: 8, 262: 5, 263: 6, 264: 2, 270: 4, 272: 4, 273: 3, 287: 4, 289: 4, 291: 6, 299: 4, 300: 4, 304: 4, 314: 3, 315: 4, 323: 2, 327: 5, 328: 3, 329: 3, 330: 7, 334: 3, 335: 4, 341: 4, 342: 5, 347: 4, 348: 4, 350: 5, 351: 6, 352: 4, 353: 4, 354: 3, 365: 4, 366: 3, 369: 2, 371: 6, 372: 6, 376: 3, 384: 6, 385: 5, 386: 4, 387: 4, 392: 3, 393: 4, 396: 5, 397: 4, 398: 3, 402: 4} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 55 "Service protection allow DetNet services to increase reliability and maintain a DetNet Service Assurance in the case of network congestion or some failures. Detnet relies on the underlying technology capabilities for various protection schemes. Protection schemes enable partial or complete coverage of the network paths and active protection with combinations of PRF, PRE, and POF." "Update based on the comments of ( 01.10 ) and ( 04.10 ) . I agree with , it 's a well - known and deployed example . I 'm not sure why it was removed . Cheers , comments have been resolved" 5627886f9da3fa5ecb5b7bcfceeb9ab7c3c19e9f 5627886f9da3fa5ecb5b7bcfceeb9ab7c3c19e9f draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework 6a0240a7089e9eb5374ec83c67aef29bce159a2350fae0b9675eca23103d04c7 ['6a0240a7089e9eb5374ec83c67aef29bce159a2350fae0b9675eca23103d04c7', 'b4f663df7a56c4c3c7893956b9297f583a3ee08b6e667404871701c5db6884e5', '48d8a67306a5b7377d474058a02289ef5b0d47c7b426e70ca86c86fbaacd1c90', '1d461b45ddd8d23bc4da82c7319696451df56fdf43af8bec67d483088c4ccd80', 'c5585816f0df6bac1e8561d23945939d704941f0bc9b379d59f610db1feeae52', '37b3aa728e069dac87a1c6719d534af53a3c16745b470dc65fa0ead08542736e', '4c3da6e0fffc80e62e5f664bd81a2936b6593757d8fb0d02cabd8102872696d4', '09338bff4c055a4fa57185ce910ed41cd32622051fe170615aabadb84e10faa4', '0742ec0639e4bb03bafb0b62e474707c4e711aef2ade5826cd84de4e7122cea3', '83839a4b6f00a98b672d7d42db0e734dfc50262a09e90121413fa7e8f02a1fa3', '595ccef56e4f3f92cf6c8157968607922c16102040d858595d47562c1a6e672a', '427d7237acb5ebe013716dee7c43d7e5886164be733489be210e182ac81eb225', 'af8a420dec9dcad3ccc2748056ca06e500c69eca257e211cf29eb20635ea76e9', '878e4eb62fa086fa63f78e831077af12faaf0d2fc1d35390eae3936514aa7756', '065c7e1c6b9427086dcdef9b8fa47187efb9aaaec8398dcbf074196ed72a8f88', '923a35f1f95a2c2e0c5ca34c1759e5cd9005222aecf744f5f2cfbe2a937afc7c', '30d108135e5d5ca29f1851710d998b43e17cf658cb0bf7a20218abc345bf0b4e', '99a17c464525b7a715b4d8ac74d0889fc6ae244d5119ca838f8eedb1f0435444', 'fd0d3d7ba40e65fa061931cfb7d0f55d4f3056ed210d3960b5adc00c479d8187', '1b772dfa25f8ed2049d2157cbed246e1cbe7f36eb5685c9f8a6739297691ec2a', 'b9bbfabb58957652f3a296054fff42678c08ff84156bc8d94d3610e121e772bf'] A "service protection allow detnet services to increase reliability and maintain a detnet service assurance in the case of network congestion or some failures. detnet relies on the underlying technology capabilities for various protection schemes. protection schemes enable partial or complete coverage of the network paths and active protection with combinations of prf, pre, and pof." {90: 1, 68: 1, 6: 1, 102: 1, 84: 1, 8: 1, 79: 3, 51: 3, 130: 3, 62: 2, 85: 2, 35: 4, 110: 4, 91: 6, 114: 4, 97: 4, 31: 2, 13: 3, 67: 3, 38: 5, 26: 2, 124: 3, 98: 3, 54: 3, 127: 4, 96: 4, 64: 3, 30: 5, 61: 6, 55: 2, 27: 2, 15: 4, 52: 2, 129: 4, 115: 4, 76: 4, 87: 4, 131: 6, 113: 6, 99: 3, 36: 4, 24: 3, 53: 2, 72: 5} {121: 1, 124: 1, 161: 1, 320: 1, 358: 1, 267: 1, 309: 1, 220: 1, 221: 1, 1: 6, 4: 3, 9: 3, 10: 4, 15: 4, 24: 3, 25: 2, 26: 2, 27: 4, 39: 2, 43: 4, 49: 7, 50: 6, 58: 6, 59: 3, 64: 4, 69: 2, 81: 3, 82: 3, 86: 4, 96: 5, 97: 4, 100: 6, 108: 4, 109: 5, 110: 5, 111: 3, 114: 4, 115: 5, 116: 4, 118: 3, 119: 2, 120: 4, 122: 5, 123: 4, 128: 5, 129: 5, 130: 6, 132: 2, 136: 3, 145: 2, 147: 5, 151: 5, 152: 5, 154: 4, 156: 3, 165: 4, 168: 5, 169: 4, 172: 4, 180: 5, 184: 3, 187: 6, 188: 5, 191: 4, 194: 2, 202: 3, 203: 4, 206: 3, 207: 4, 215: 2, 217: 4, 218: 5, 222: 2, 224: 4, 227: 4, 229: 4, 234: 6, 235: 3, 241: 3, 242: 3, 243: 2, 244: 5, 245: 2, 248: 5, 250: 5, 258: 8, 262: 5, 263: 6, 264: 2, 270: 4, 272: 4, 273: 3, 287: 4, 289: 4, 291: 6, 299: 4, 300: 4, 304: 4, 314: 3, 315: 4, 323: 2, 327: 5, 328: 3, 329: 3, 330: 7, 334: 3, 335: 4, 341: 4, 342: 5, 347: 4, 348: 4, 350: 5, 351: 6, 352: 4, 353: 4, 354: 3, 365: 4, 366: 3, 369: 2, 371: 6, 372: 6, 376: 3, 384: 6, 385: 5, 386: 4, 387: 4, 392: 3, 393: 4, 396: 5, 397: 4, 398: 3, 402: 4} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 55 "This section provides informative considerations related to providing DetNet service to flows which are identified based on their header information." "Update based on the comments of ( 01.10 ) and ( 04.10 ) . I agree with , it 's a well - known and deployed example . I 'm not sure why it was removed . Cheers , comments have been resolved" 5627886f9da3fa5ecb5b7bcfceeb9ab7c3c19e9f 5627886f9da3fa5ecb5b7bcfceeb9ab7c3c19e9f draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework fd0d3d7ba40e65fa061931cfb7d0f55d4f3056ed210d3960b5adc00c479d8187 ['6a0240a7089e9eb5374ec83c67aef29bce159a2350fae0b9675eca23103d04c7', 'b4f663df7a56c4c3c7893956b9297f583a3ee08b6e667404871701c5db6884e5', '48d8a67306a5b7377d474058a02289ef5b0d47c7b426e70ca86c86fbaacd1c90', '1d461b45ddd8d23bc4da82c7319696451df56fdf43af8bec67d483088c4ccd80', 'c5585816f0df6bac1e8561d23945939d704941f0bc9b379d59f610db1feeae52', '37b3aa728e069dac87a1c6719d534af53a3c16745b470dc65fa0ead08542736e', '4c3da6e0fffc80e62e5f664bd81a2936b6593757d8fb0d02cabd8102872696d4', '09338bff4c055a4fa57185ce910ed41cd32622051fe170615aabadb84e10faa4', '0742ec0639e4bb03bafb0b62e474707c4e711aef2ade5826cd84de4e7122cea3', '83839a4b6f00a98b672d7d42db0e734dfc50262a09e90121413fa7e8f02a1fa3', '595ccef56e4f3f92cf6c8157968607922c16102040d858595d47562c1a6e672a', '427d7237acb5ebe013716dee7c43d7e5886164be733489be210e182ac81eb225', 'af8a420dec9dcad3ccc2748056ca06e500c69eca257e211cf29eb20635ea76e9', '878e4eb62fa086fa63f78e831077af12faaf0d2fc1d35390eae3936514aa7756', '065c7e1c6b9427086dcdef9b8fa47187efb9aaaec8398dcbf074196ed72a8f88', '923a35f1f95a2c2e0c5ca34c1759e5cd9005222aecf744f5f2cfbe2a937afc7c', '30d108135e5d5ca29f1851710d998b43e17cf658cb0bf7a20218abc345bf0b4e', '99a17c464525b7a715b4d8ac74d0889fc6ae244d5119ca838f8eedb1f0435444', 'fd0d3d7ba40e65fa061931cfb7d0f55d4f3056ed210d3960b5adc00c479d8187', '1b772dfa25f8ed2049d2157cbed246e1cbe7f36eb5685c9f8a6739297691ec2a', 'b9bbfabb58957652f3a296054fff42678c08ff84156bc8d94d3610e121e772bf'] B "this section provides informative considerations related to providing detnet service to flows which are identified based on their header information." {90: 1, 68: 1, 6: 1, 102: 1, 84: 1, 8: 1, 79: 3, 51: 3, 130: 3, 62: 2, 85: 2, 35: 4, 110: 4, 91: 6, 114: 4, 97: 4, 31: 2, 13: 3, 67: 3, 38: 5, 26: 2, 124: 3, 98: 3, 54: 3, 127: 4, 96: 4, 64: 3, 30: 5, 61: 6, 55: 2, 27: 2, 15: 4, 52: 2, 129: 4, 115: 4, 76: 4, 87: 4, 131: 6, 113: 6, 99: 3, 36: 4, 24: 3, 53: 2, 72: 5} {121: 1, 124: 1, 161: 1, 320: 1, 358: 1, 267: 1, 309: 1, 220: 1, 221: 1, 1: 6, 4: 3, 9: 3, 10: 4, 15: 4, 24: 3, 25: 2, 26: 2, 27: 4, 39: 2, 43: 4, 49: 7, 50: 6, 58: 6, 59: 3, 64: 4, 69: 2, 81: 3, 82: 3, 86: 4, 96: 5, 97: 4, 100: 6, 108: 4, 109: 5, 110: 5, 111: 3, 114: 4, 115: 5, 116: 4, 118: 3, 119: 2, 120: 4, 122: 5, 123: 4, 128: 5, 129: 5, 130: 6, 132: 2, 136: 3, 145: 2, 147: 5, 151: 5, 152: 5, 154: 4, 156: 3, 165: 4, 168: 5, 169: 4, 172: 4, 180: 5, 184: 3, 187: 6, 188: 5, 191: 4, 194: 2, 202: 3, 203: 4, 206: 3, 207: 4, 215: 2, 217: 4, 218: 5, 222: 2, 224: 4, 227: 4, 229: 4, 234: 6, 235: 3, 241: 3, 242: 3, 243: 2, 244: 5, 245: 2, 248: 5, 250: 5, 258: 8, 262: 5, 263: 6, 264: 2, 270: 4, 272: 4, 273: 3, 287: 4, 289: 4, 291: 6, 299: 4, 300: 4, 304: 4, 314: 3, 315: 4, 323: 2, 327: 5, 328: 3, 329: 3, 330: 7, 334: 3, 335: 4, 341: 4, 342: 5, 347: 4, 348: 4, 350: 5, 351: 6, 352: 4, 353: 4, 354: 3, 365: 4, 366: 3, 369: 2, 371: 6, 372: 6, 376: 3, 384: 6, 385: 5, 386: 4, 387: 4, 392: 3, 393: 4, 396: 5, 397: 4, 398: 3, 402: 4} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 55 "At a high level, the following functions are provided on a per flow basis." "Update based on the comments of ( 01.10 ) and ( 04.10 ) . I agree with , it 's a well - known and deployed example . I 'm not sure why it was removed . Cheers , comments have been resolved" 5627886f9da3fa5ecb5b7bcfceeb9ab7c3c19e9f 5627886f9da3fa5ecb5b7bcfceeb9ab7c3c19e9f draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework 99a17c464525b7a715b4d8ac74d0889fc6ae244d5119ca838f8eedb1f0435444 ['6a0240a7089e9eb5374ec83c67aef29bce159a2350fae0b9675eca23103d04c7', 'b4f663df7a56c4c3c7893956b9297f583a3ee08b6e667404871701c5db6884e5', '48d8a67306a5b7377d474058a02289ef5b0d47c7b426e70ca86c86fbaacd1c90', '1d461b45ddd8d23bc4da82c7319696451df56fdf43af8bec67d483088c4ccd80', 'c5585816f0df6bac1e8561d23945939d704941f0bc9b379d59f610db1feeae52', '37b3aa728e069dac87a1c6719d534af53a3c16745b470dc65fa0ead08542736e', '4c3da6e0fffc80e62e5f664bd81a2936b6593757d8fb0d02cabd8102872696d4', '09338bff4c055a4fa57185ce910ed41cd32622051fe170615aabadb84e10faa4', '0742ec0639e4bb03bafb0b62e474707c4e711aef2ade5826cd84de4e7122cea3', '83839a4b6f00a98b672d7d42db0e734dfc50262a09e90121413fa7e8f02a1fa3', '595ccef56e4f3f92cf6c8157968607922c16102040d858595d47562c1a6e672a', '427d7237acb5ebe013716dee7c43d7e5886164be733489be210e182ac81eb225', 'af8a420dec9dcad3ccc2748056ca06e500c69eca257e211cf29eb20635ea76e9', '878e4eb62fa086fa63f78e831077af12faaf0d2fc1d35390eae3936514aa7756', '065c7e1c6b9427086dcdef9b8fa47187efb9aaaec8398dcbf074196ed72a8f88', '923a35f1f95a2c2e0c5ca34c1759e5cd9005222aecf744f5f2cfbe2a937afc7c', '30d108135e5d5ca29f1851710d998b43e17cf658cb0bf7a20218abc345bf0b4e', '99a17c464525b7a715b4d8ac74d0889fc6ae244d5119ca838f8eedb1f0435444', 'fd0d3d7ba40e65fa061931cfb7d0f55d4f3056ed210d3960b5adc00c479d8187', '1b772dfa25f8ed2049d2157cbed246e1cbe7f36eb5685c9f8a6739297691ec2a', 'b9bbfabb58957652f3a296054fff42678c08ff84156bc8d94d3610e121e772bf'] B "at a high level, the following functions are provided on a per flow basis." {90: 1, 68: 1, 6: 1, 102: 1, 84: 1, 8: 1, 79: 3, 51: 3, 130: 3, 62: 2, 85: 2, 35: 4, 110: 4, 91: 6, 114: 4, 97: 4, 31: 2, 13: 3, 67: 3, 38: 5, 26: 2, 124: 3, 98: 3, 54: 3, 127: 4, 96: 4, 64: 3, 30: 5, 61: 6, 55: 2, 27: 2, 15: 4, 52: 2, 129: 4, 115: 4, 76: 4, 87: 4, 131: 6, 113: 6, 99: 3, 36: 4, 24: 3, 53: 2, 72: 5} {121: 1, 124: 1, 161: 1, 320: 1, 358: 1, 267: 1, 309: 1, 220: 1, 221: 1, 1: 6, 4: 3, 9: 3, 10: 4, 15: 4, 24: 3, 25: 2, 26: 2, 27: 4, 39: 2, 43: 4, 49: 7, 50: 6, 58: 6, 59: 3, 64: 4, 69: 2, 81: 3, 82: 3, 86: 4, 96: 5, 97: 4, 100: 6, 108: 4, 109: 5, 110: 5, 111: 3, 114: 4, 115: 5, 116: 4, 118: 3, 119: 2, 120: 4, 122: 5, 123: 4, 128: 5, 129: 5, 130: 6, 132: 2, 136: 3, 145: 2, 147: 5, 151: 5, 152: 5, 154: 4, 156: 3, 165: 4, 168: 5, 169: 4, 172: 4, 180: 5, 184: 3, 187: 6, 188: 5, 191: 4, 194: 2, 202: 3, 203: 4, 206: 3, 207: 4, 215: 2, 217: 4, 218: 5, 222: 2, 224: 4, 227: 4, 229: 4, 234: 6, 235: 3, 241: 3, 242: 3, 243: 2, 244: 5, 245: 2, 248: 5, 250: 5, 258: 8, 262: 5, 263: 6, 264: 2, 270: 4, 272: 4, 273: 3, 287: 4, 289: 4, 291: 6, 299: 4, 300: 4, 304: 4, 314: 3, 315: 4, 323: 2, 327: 5, 328: 3, 329: 3, 330: 7, 334: 3, 335: 4, 341: 4, 342: 5, 347: 4, 348: 4, 350: 5, 351: 6, 352: 4, 353: 4, 354: 3, 365: 4, 366: 3, 369: 2, 371: 6, 372: 6, 376: 3, 384: 6, 385: 5, 386: 4, 387: 4, 392: 3, 393: 4, 396: 5, 397: 4, 398: 3, 402: 4} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 55 "Reservation of resources can allocate resources to specific DetNet flows. This can eliminate packet contention and packet loss for DetNet traffic. This also can reduce jitter for DetNet traffic. Resources allocated to a DetNet flow protect it from other traffic flows. On the other hand, DetNet flows are assumed to behave with respect to the reserved traffic profile. Misbehaving DetNet flows must be detected and it have to be ensured that they do not compromise QoS of other flows. The use of (queuing, policing, shaping) policies can be used to ensure that the allocation of resources reserved for DetNet is met." "Update based on the comments of ( 01.10 ) and ( 04.10 ) . I agree with , it 's a well - known and deployed example . I 'm not sure why it was removed . Cheers , comments have been resolved" 5627886f9da3fa5ecb5b7bcfceeb9ab7c3c19e9f 5627886f9da3fa5ecb5b7bcfceeb9ab7c3c19e9f draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework 878e4eb62fa086fa63f78e831077af12faaf0d2fc1d35390eae3936514aa7756 ['6a0240a7089e9eb5374ec83c67aef29bce159a2350fae0b9675eca23103d04c7', 'b4f663df7a56c4c3c7893956b9297f583a3ee08b6e667404871701c5db6884e5', '48d8a67306a5b7377d474058a02289ef5b0d47c7b426e70ca86c86fbaacd1c90', '1d461b45ddd8d23bc4da82c7319696451df56fdf43af8bec67d483088c4ccd80', 'c5585816f0df6bac1e8561d23945939d704941f0bc9b379d59f610db1feeae52', '37b3aa728e069dac87a1c6719d534af53a3c16745b470dc65fa0ead08542736e', '4c3da6e0fffc80e62e5f664bd81a2936b6593757d8fb0d02cabd8102872696d4', '09338bff4c055a4fa57185ce910ed41cd32622051fe170615aabadb84e10faa4', '0742ec0639e4bb03bafb0b62e474707c4e711aef2ade5826cd84de4e7122cea3', '83839a4b6f00a98b672d7d42db0e734dfc50262a09e90121413fa7e8f02a1fa3', '595ccef56e4f3f92cf6c8157968607922c16102040d858595d47562c1a6e672a', '427d7237acb5ebe013716dee7c43d7e5886164be733489be210e182ac81eb225', 'af8a420dec9dcad3ccc2748056ca06e500c69eca257e211cf29eb20635ea76e9', '878e4eb62fa086fa63f78e831077af12faaf0d2fc1d35390eae3936514aa7756', '065c7e1c6b9427086dcdef9b8fa47187efb9aaaec8398dcbf074196ed72a8f88', '923a35f1f95a2c2e0c5ca34c1759e5cd9005222aecf744f5f2cfbe2a937afc7c', '30d108135e5d5ca29f1851710d998b43e17cf658cb0bf7a20218abc345bf0b4e', '99a17c464525b7a715b4d8ac74d0889fc6ae244d5119ca838f8eedb1f0435444', 'fd0d3d7ba40e65fa061931cfb7d0f55d4f3056ed210d3960b5adc00c479d8187', '1b772dfa25f8ed2049d2157cbed246e1cbe7f36eb5685c9f8a6739297691ec2a', 'b9bbfabb58957652f3a296054fff42678c08ff84156bc8d94d3610e121e772bf'] B "reservation of resources can allocate resources to specific detnet flows. this can eliminate packet contention and packet loss for detnet traffic. this also can reduce jitter for detnet traffic. resources allocated to a detnet flow protect it from other traffic flows. on the other hand, detnet flows are assumed to behave with respect to the reserved traffic profile. misbehaving detnet flows must be detected and it have to be ensured that they do not compromise qos of other flows. the use of (queuing, policing, shaping) policies can be used to ensure that the allocation of resources reserved for detnet is met." {90: 1, 68: 1, 6: 1, 102: 1, 84: 1, 8: 1, 79: 3, 51: 3, 130: 3, 62: 2, 85: 2, 35: 4, 110: 4, 91: 6, 114: 4, 97: 4, 31: 2, 13: 3, 67: 3, 38: 5, 26: 2, 124: 3, 98: 3, 54: 3, 127: 4, 96: 4, 64: 3, 30: 5, 61: 6, 55: 2, 27: 2, 15: 4, 52: 2, 129: 4, 115: 4, 76: 4, 87: 4, 131: 6, 113: 6, 99: 3, 36: 4, 24: 3, 53: 2, 72: 5} {121: 1, 124: 1, 161: 1, 320: 1, 358: 1, 267: 1, 309: 1, 220: 1, 221: 1, 1: 6, 4: 3, 9: 3, 10: 4, 15: 4, 24: 3, 25: 2, 26: 2, 27: 4, 39: 2, 43: 4, 49: 7, 50: 6, 58: 6, 59: 3, 64: 4, 69: 2, 81: 3, 82: 3, 86: 4, 96: 5, 97: 4, 100: 6, 108: 4, 109: 5, 110: 5, 111: 3, 114: 4, 115: 5, 116: 4, 118: 3, 119: 2, 120: 4, 122: 5, 123: 4, 128: 5, 129: 5, 130: 6, 132: 2, 136: 3, 145: 2, 147: 5, 151: 5, 152: 5, 154: 4, 156: 3, 165: 4, 168: 5, 169: 4, 172: 4, 180: 5, 184: 3, 187: 6, 188: 5, 191: 4, 194: 2, 202: 3, 203: 4, 206: 3, 207: 4, 215: 2, 217: 4, 218: 5, 222: 2, 224: 4, 227: 4, 229: 4, 234: 6, 235: 3, 241: 3, 242: 3, 243: 2, 244: 5, 245: 2, 248: 5, 250: 5, 258: 8, 262: 5, 263: 6, 264: 2, 270: 4, 272: 4, 273: 3, 287: 4, 289: 4, 291: 6, 299: 4, 300: 4, 304: 4, 314: 3, 315: 4, 323: 2, 327: 5, 328: 3, 329: 3, 330: 7, 334: 3, 335: 4, 341: 4, 342: 5, 347: 4, 348: 4, 350: 5, 351: 6, 352: 4, 353: 4, 354: 3, 365: 4, 366: 3, 369: 2, 371: 6, 372: 6, 376: 3, 384: 6, 385: 5, 386: 4, 387: 4, 392: 3, 393: 4, 396: 5, 397: 4, 398: 3, 402: 4} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 55 "Use of a specific path for a flow. This allows control of the network delay by steering the packet with the ability to influence the physical path. Explicit routes complement reservation by ensuring that a consistent path can be associated with its resources for the duration of that path. Coupled with the traffic mechanism, this limits misordering and bounds latency. Explicit route computation can encompass a wide set of constraints and optimize the path for a certain characteristic e.g. highest bandwidth or lowest jitter. In these cases the ""best"" path for any set of characteristics may not be a shortest path. The selection of path can take into account multiple network metrics. Some of these metrics are measured and distributed by the routing system as traffic engineering metrics." "Update based on the comments of ( 01.10 ) and ( 04.10 ) . I agree with , it 's a well - known and deployed example . I 'm not sure why it was removed . Cheers , comments have been resolved" 5627886f9da3fa5ecb5b7bcfceeb9ab7c3c19e9f 5627886f9da3fa5ecb5b7bcfceeb9ab7c3c19e9f draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework 923a35f1f95a2c2e0c5ca34c1759e5cd9005222aecf744f5f2cfbe2a937afc7c ['6a0240a7089e9eb5374ec83c67aef29bce159a2350fae0b9675eca23103d04c7', 'b4f663df7a56c4c3c7893956b9297f583a3ee08b6e667404871701c5db6884e5', '48d8a67306a5b7377d474058a02289ef5b0d47c7b426e70ca86c86fbaacd1c90', '1d461b45ddd8d23bc4da82c7319696451df56fdf43af8bec67d483088c4ccd80', 'c5585816f0df6bac1e8561d23945939d704941f0bc9b379d59f610db1feeae52', '37b3aa728e069dac87a1c6719d534af53a3c16745b470dc65fa0ead08542736e', '4c3da6e0fffc80e62e5f664bd81a2936b6593757d8fb0d02cabd8102872696d4', '09338bff4c055a4fa57185ce910ed41cd32622051fe170615aabadb84e10faa4', '0742ec0639e4bb03bafb0b62e474707c4e711aef2ade5826cd84de4e7122cea3', '83839a4b6f00a98b672d7d42db0e734dfc50262a09e90121413fa7e8f02a1fa3', '595ccef56e4f3f92cf6c8157968607922c16102040d858595d47562c1a6e672a', '427d7237acb5ebe013716dee7c43d7e5886164be733489be210e182ac81eb225', 'af8a420dec9dcad3ccc2748056ca06e500c69eca257e211cf29eb20635ea76e9', '878e4eb62fa086fa63f78e831077af12faaf0d2fc1d35390eae3936514aa7756', '065c7e1c6b9427086dcdef9b8fa47187efb9aaaec8398dcbf074196ed72a8f88', '923a35f1f95a2c2e0c5ca34c1759e5cd9005222aecf744f5f2cfbe2a937afc7c', '30d108135e5d5ca29f1851710d998b43e17cf658cb0bf7a20218abc345bf0b4e', '99a17c464525b7a715b4d8ac74d0889fc6ae244d5119ca838f8eedb1f0435444', 'fd0d3d7ba40e65fa061931cfb7d0f55d4f3056ed210d3960b5adc00c479d8187', '1b772dfa25f8ed2049d2157cbed246e1cbe7f36eb5685c9f8a6739297691ec2a', 'b9bbfabb58957652f3a296054fff42678c08ff84156bc8d94d3610e121e772bf'] B "use of a specific path for a flow. this allows control of the network delay by steering the packet with the ability to influence the physical path. explicit routes complement reservation by ensuring that a consistent path can be associated with its resources for the duration of that path. coupled with the traffic mechanism, this limits misordering and bounds latency. explicit route computation can encompass a wide set of constraints and optimize the path for a certain characteristic e.g. highest bandwidth or lowest jitter. in these cases the ""best"" path for any set of characteristics may not be a shortest path. the selection of path can take into account multiple network metrics. some of these metrics are measured and distributed by the routing system as traffic engineering metrics." {90: 1, 68: 1, 6: 1, 102: 1, 84: 1, 8: 1, 79: 3, 51: 3, 130: 3, 62: 2, 85: 2, 35: 4, 110: 4, 91: 6, 114: 4, 97: 4, 31: 2, 13: 3, 67: 3, 38: 5, 26: 2, 124: 3, 98: 3, 54: 3, 127: 4, 96: 4, 64: 3, 30: 5, 61: 6, 55: 2, 27: 2, 15: 4, 52: 2, 129: 4, 115: 4, 76: 4, 87: 4, 131: 6, 113: 6, 99: 3, 36: 4, 24: 3, 53: 2, 72: 5} {121: 1, 124: 1, 161: 1, 320: 1, 358: 1, 267: 1, 309: 1, 220: 1, 221: 1, 1: 6, 4: 3, 9: 3, 10: 4, 15: 4, 24: 3, 25: 2, 26: 2, 27: 4, 39: 2, 43: 4, 49: 7, 50: 6, 58: 6, 59: 3, 64: 4, 69: 2, 81: 3, 82: 3, 86: 4, 96: 5, 97: 4, 100: 6, 108: 4, 109: 5, 110: 5, 111: 3, 114: 4, 115: 5, 116: 4, 118: 3, 119: 2, 120: 4, 122: 5, 123: 4, 128: 5, 129: 5, 130: 6, 132: 2, 136: 3, 145: 2, 147: 5, 151: 5, 152: 5, 154: 4, 156: 3, 165: 4, 168: 5, 169: 4, 172: 4, 180: 5, 184: 3, 187: 6, 188: 5, 191: 4, 194: 2, 202: 3, 203: 4, 206: 3, 207: 4, 215: 2, 217: 4, 218: 5, 222: 2, 224: 4, 227: 4, 229: 4, 234: 6, 235: 3, 241: 3, 242: 3, 243: 2, 244: 5, 245: 2, 248: 5, 250: 5, 258: 8, 262: 5, 263: 6, 264: 2, 270: 4, 272: 4, 273: 3, 287: 4, 289: 4, 291: 6, 299: 4, 300: 4, 304: 4, 314: 3, 315: 4, 323: 2, 327: 5, 328: 3, 329: 3, 330: 7, 334: 3, 335: 4, 341: 4, 342: 5, 347: 4, 348: 4, 350: 5, 351: 6, 352: 4, 353: 4, 354: 3, 365: 4, 366: 3, 369: 2, 371: 6, 372: 6, 376: 3, 384: 6, 385: 5, 386: 4, 387: 4, 392: 3, 393: 4, 396: 5, 397: 4, 398: 3, 402: 4} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 55 "Use of multiple packet streams using multiple paths, for example 1+1 or 1:1 linear protection. For DetNet this primarily relates to packet replication and elimination capabilities. MPLS offers a number of protection schemes. MPLS hitless protection can be used to switch traffic to an already established path in order to restore delivery rapidly after a failure. Path changes, even in the case of failure recovery, can lead to the out of order delivery of data requiring packet ordering functions either within the DetNet service or at a high layer in the application traffic. Establishment of new paths after a failure is out of scope for DetNet services." "Update based on the comments of ( 01.10 ) and ( 04.10 ) . I agree with , it 's a well - known and deployed example . I 'm not sure why it was removed . Cheers , comments have been resolved" 5627886f9da3fa5ecb5b7bcfceeb9ab7c3c19e9f 5627886f9da3fa5ecb5b7bcfceeb9ab7c3c19e9f draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework 37b3aa728e069dac87a1c6719d534af53a3c16745b470dc65fa0ead08542736e ['6a0240a7089e9eb5374ec83c67aef29bce159a2350fae0b9675eca23103d04c7', 'b4f663df7a56c4c3c7893956b9297f583a3ee08b6e667404871701c5db6884e5', '48d8a67306a5b7377d474058a02289ef5b0d47c7b426e70ca86c86fbaacd1c90', '1d461b45ddd8d23bc4da82c7319696451df56fdf43af8bec67d483088c4ccd80', 'c5585816f0df6bac1e8561d23945939d704941f0bc9b379d59f610db1feeae52', '37b3aa728e069dac87a1c6719d534af53a3c16745b470dc65fa0ead08542736e', '4c3da6e0fffc80e62e5f664bd81a2936b6593757d8fb0d02cabd8102872696d4', '09338bff4c055a4fa57185ce910ed41cd32622051fe170615aabadb84e10faa4', '0742ec0639e4bb03bafb0b62e474707c4e711aef2ade5826cd84de4e7122cea3', '83839a4b6f00a98b672d7d42db0e734dfc50262a09e90121413fa7e8f02a1fa3', '595ccef56e4f3f92cf6c8157968607922c16102040d858595d47562c1a6e672a', '427d7237acb5ebe013716dee7c43d7e5886164be733489be210e182ac81eb225', 'af8a420dec9dcad3ccc2748056ca06e500c69eca257e211cf29eb20635ea76e9', '878e4eb62fa086fa63f78e831077af12faaf0d2fc1d35390eae3936514aa7756', '065c7e1c6b9427086dcdef9b8fa47187efb9aaaec8398dcbf074196ed72a8f88', '923a35f1f95a2c2e0c5ca34c1759e5cd9005222aecf744f5f2cfbe2a937afc7c', '30d108135e5d5ca29f1851710d998b43e17cf658cb0bf7a20218abc345bf0b4e', '99a17c464525b7a715b4d8ac74d0889fc6ae244d5119ca838f8eedb1f0435444', 'fd0d3d7ba40e65fa061931cfb7d0f55d4f3056ed210d3960b5adc00c479d8187', '1b772dfa25f8ed2049d2157cbed246e1cbe7f36eb5685c9f8a6739297691ec2a', 'b9bbfabb58957652f3a296054fff42678c08ff84156bc8d94d3610e121e772bf'] B "use of multiple packet streams using multiple paths, for example 1+1 or 1:1 linear protection. for detnet this primarily relates to packet replication and elimination capabilities. mpls offers a number of protection schemes. mpls hitless protection can be used to switch traffic to an already established path in order to restore delivery rapidly after a failure. path changes, even in the case of failure recovery, can lead to the out of order delivery of data requiring packet ordering functions either within the detnet service or at a high layer in the application traffic. establishment of new paths after a failure is out of scope for detnet services." {90: 1, 68: 1, 6: 1, 102: 1, 84: 1, 8: 1, 79: 3, 51: 3, 130: 3, 62: 2, 85: 2, 35: 4, 110: 4, 91: 6, 114: 4, 97: 4, 31: 2, 13: 3, 67: 3, 38: 5, 26: 2, 124: 3, 98: 3, 54: 3, 127: 4, 96: 4, 64: 3, 30: 5, 61: 6, 55: 2, 27: 2, 15: 4, 52: 2, 129: 4, 115: 4, 76: 4, 87: 4, 131: 6, 113: 6, 99: 3, 36: 4, 24: 3, 53: 2, 72: 5} {121: 1, 124: 1, 161: 1, 320: 1, 358: 1, 267: 1, 309: 1, 220: 1, 221: 1, 1: 6, 4: 3, 9: 3, 10: 4, 15: 4, 24: 3, 25: 2, 26: 2, 27: 4, 39: 2, 43: 4, 49: 7, 50: 6, 58: 6, 59: 3, 64: 4, 69: 2, 81: 3, 82: 3, 86: 4, 96: 5, 97: 4, 100: 6, 108: 4, 109: 5, 110: 5, 111: 3, 114: 4, 115: 5, 116: 4, 118: 3, 119: 2, 120: 4, 122: 5, 123: 4, 128: 5, 129: 5, 130: 6, 132: 2, 136: 3, 145: 2, 147: 5, 151: 5, 152: 5, 154: 4, 156: 3, 165: 4, 168: 5, 169: 4, 172: 4, 180: 5, 184: 3, 187: 6, 188: 5, 191: 4, 194: 2, 202: 3, 203: 4, 206: 3, 207: 4, 215: 2, 217: 4, 218: 5, 222: 2, 224: 4, 227: 4, 229: 4, 234: 6, 235: 3, 241: 3, 242: 3, 243: 2, 244: 5, 245: 2, 248: 5, 250: 5, 258: 8, 262: 5, 263: 6, 264: 2, 270: 4, 272: 4, 273: 3, 287: 4, 289: 4, 291: 6, 299: 4, 300: 4, 304: 4, 314: 3, 315: 4, 323: 2, 327: 5, 328: 3, 329: 3, 330: 7, 334: 3, 335: 4, 341: 4, 342: 5, 347: 4, 348: 4, 350: 5, 351: 6, 352: 4, 353: 4, 354: 3, 365: 4, 366: 3, 369: 2, 371: 6, 372: 6, 376: 3, 384: 6, 385: 5, 386: 4, 387: 4, 392: 3, 393: 4, 396: 5, 397: 4, 398: 3, 402: 4} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 55 "Network Coding, not to be confused with network programming, comprises several techniques where multiple data flows are encoded. These resulting flows can then be sent on different paths. The encoding operation can combine flows and error recovery information. When the encoded flows are decoded and recombined the original flows can be recovered. Note that Network coding uses an alternative to packet by packet PREOF. Therefore, for certain network topologies and traffic loads, Network Coding can be used to improve a network's throughput, efficiency, latency, and scalability, as well as resilience to partition, attacks, and eavesdropping, as compared to traditional methods. DetNet could utilized Network coding as an alternative to other protection means. Network coding is often applied in wireless networks and is being explored for other network types." "Update based on the comments of ( 01.10 ) and ( 04.10 ) . I agree with , it 's a well - known and deployed example . I 'm not sure why it was removed . Cheers , comments have been resolved" 5627886f9da3fa5ecb5b7bcfceeb9ab7c3c19e9f 5627886f9da3fa5ecb5b7bcfceeb9ab7c3c19e9f draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework af8a420dec9dcad3ccc2748056ca06e500c69eca257e211cf29eb20635ea76e9 ['6a0240a7089e9eb5374ec83c67aef29bce159a2350fae0b9675eca23103d04c7', 'b4f663df7a56c4c3c7893956b9297f583a3ee08b6e667404871701c5db6884e5', '48d8a67306a5b7377d474058a02289ef5b0d47c7b426e70ca86c86fbaacd1c90', '1d461b45ddd8d23bc4da82c7319696451df56fdf43af8bec67d483088c4ccd80', 'c5585816f0df6bac1e8561d23945939d704941f0bc9b379d59f610db1feeae52', '37b3aa728e069dac87a1c6719d534af53a3c16745b470dc65fa0ead08542736e', '4c3da6e0fffc80e62e5f664bd81a2936b6593757d8fb0d02cabd8102872696d4', '09338bff4c055a4fa57185ce910ed41cd32622051fe170615aabadb84e10faa4', '0742ec0639e4bb03bafb0b62e474707c4e711aef2ade5826cd84de4e7122cea3', '83839a4b6f00a98b672d7d42db0e734dfc50262a09e90121413fa7e8f02a1fa3', '595ccef56e4f3f92cf6c8157968607922c16102040d858595d47562c1a6e672a', '427d7237acb5ebe013716dee7c43d7e5886164be733489be210e182ac81eb225', 'af8a420dec9dcad3ccc2748056ca06e500c69eca257e211cf29eb20635ea76e9', '878e4eb62fa086fa63f78e831077af12faaf0d2fc1d35390eae3936514aa7756', '065c7e1c6b9427086dcdef9b8fa47187efb9aaaec8398dcbf074196ed72a8f88', '923a35f1f95a2c2e0c5ca34c1759e5cd9005222aecf744f5f2cfbe2a937afc7c', '30d108135e5d5ca29f1851710d998b43e17cf658cb0bf7a20218abc345bf0b4e', '99a17c464525b7a715b4d8ac74d0889fc6ae244d5119ca838f8eedb1f0435444', 'fd0d3d7ba40e65fa061931cfb7d0f55d4f3056ed210d3960b5adc00c479d8187', '1b772dfa25f8ed2049d2157cbed246e1cbe7f36eb5685c9f8a6739297691ec2a', 'b9bbfabb58957652f3a296054fff42678c08ff84156bc8d94d3610e121e772bf'] B "network coding, not to be confused with network programming, comprises several techniques where multiple data flows are encoded. these resulting flows can then be sent on different paths. the encoding operation can combine flows and error recovery information. when the encoded flows are decoded and recombined the original flows can be recovered. note that network coding uses an alternative to packet by packet preof. therefore, for certain network topologies and traffic loads, network coding can be used to improve a network's throughput, efficiency, latency, and scalability, as well as resilience to partition, attacks, and eavesdropping, as compared to traditional methods. detnet could utilized network coding as an alternative to other protection means. network coding is often applied in wireless networks and is being explored for other network types." {90: 1, 68: 1, 6: 1, 102: 1, 84: 1, 8: 1, 79: 3, 51: 3, 130: 3, 62: 2, 85: 2, 35: 4, 110: 4, 91: 6, 114: 4, 97: 4, 31: 2, 13: 3, 67: 3, 38: 5, 26: 2, 124: 3, 98: 3, 54: 3, 127: 4, 96: 4, 64: 3, 30: 5, 61: 6, 55: 2, 27: 2, 15: 4, 52: 2, 129: 4, 115: 4, 76: 4, 87: 4, 131: 6, 113: 6, 99: 3, 36: 4, 24: 3, 53: 2, 72: 5} {121: 1, 124: 1, 161: 1, 320: 1, 358: 1, 267: 1, 309: 1, 220: 1, 221: 1, 1: 6, 4: 3, 9: 3, 10: 4, 15: 4, 24: 3, 25: 2, 26: 2, 27: 4, 39: 2, 43: 4, 49: 7, 50: 6, 58: 6, 59: 3, 64: 4, 69: 2, 81: 3, 82: 3, 86: 4, 96: 5, 97: 4, 100: 6, 108: 4, 109: 5, 110: 5, 111: 3, 114: 4, 115: 5, 116: 4, 118: 3, 119: 2, 120: 4, 122: 5, 123: 4, 128: 5, 129: 5, 130: 6, 132: 2, 136: 3, 145: 2, 147: 5, 151: 5, 152: 5, 154: 4, 156: 3, 165: 4, 168: 5, 169: 4, 172: 4, 180: 5, 184: 3, 187: 6, 188: 5, 191: 4, 194: 2, 202: 3, 203: 4, 206: 3, 207: 4, 215: 2, 217: 4, 218: 5, 222: 2, 224: 4, 227: 4, 229: 4, 234: 6, 235: 3, 241: 3, 242: 3, 243: 2, 244: 5, 245: 2, 248: 5, 250: 5, 258: 8, 262: 5, 263: 6, 264: 2, 270: 4, 272: 4, 273: 3, 287: 4, 289: 4, 291: 6, 299: 4, 300: 4, 304: 4, 314: 3, 315: 4, 323: 2, 327: 5, 328: 3, 329: 3, 330: 7, 334: 3, 335: 4, 341: 4, 342: 5, 347: 4, 348: 4, 350: 5, 351: 6, 352: 4, 353: 4, 354: 3, 365: 4, 366: 3, 369: 2, 371: 6, 372: 6, 376: 3, 384: 6, 385: 5, 386: 4, 387: 4, 392: 3, 393: 4, 396: 5, 397: 4, 398: 3, 402: 4} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 55 "Use of packet-by-packet distribution of the same DetNet flow over multiple paths is not recommended except for the cases listed above where PREOF is utilized to improve protection of traffic and maintain order. Packet by packet load sharing, e.g., via ECMP or UCMP, impacts ordering and possibly jitter." "Update based on the comments of ( 01.10 ) and ( 04.10 ) . I agree with , it 's a well - known and deployed example . I 'm not sure why it was removed . Cheers , comments have been resolved" 5627886f9da3fa5ecb5b7bcfceeb9ab7c3c19e9f 5627886f9da3fa5ecb5b7bcfceeb9ab7c3c19e9f draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework 4c3da6e0fffc80e62e5f664bd81a2936b6593757d8fb0d02cabd8102872696d4 ['6a0240a7089e9eb5374ec83c67aef29bce159a2350fae0b9675eca23103d04c7', 'b4f663df7a56c4c3c7893956b9297f583a3ee08b6e667404871701c5db6884e5', '48d8a67306a5b7377d474058a02289ef5b0d47c7b426e70ca86c86fbaacd1c90', '1d461b45ddd8d23bc4da82c7319696451df56fdf43af8bec67d483088c4ccd80', 'c5585816f0df6bac1e8561d23945939d704941f0bc9b379d59f610db1feeae52', '37b3aa728e069dac87a1c6719d534af53a3c16745b470dc65fa0ead08542736e', '4c3da6e0fffc80e62e5f664bd81a2936b6593757d8fb0d02cabd8102872696d4', '09338bff4c055a4fa57185ce910ed41cd32622051fe170615aabadb84e10faa4', '0742ec0639e4bb03bafb0b62e474707c4e711aef2ade5826cd84de4e7122cea3', '83839a4b6f00a98b672d7d42db0e734dfc50262a09e90121413fa7e8f02a1fa3', '595ccef56e4f3f92cf6c8157968607922c16102040d858595d47562c1a6e672a', '427d7237acb5ebe013716dee7c43d7e5886164be733489be210e182ac81eb225', 'af8a420dec9dcad3ccc2748056ca06e500c69eca257e211cf29eb20635ea76e9', '878e4eb62fa086fa63f78e831077af12faaf0d2fc1d35390eae3936514aa7756', '065c7e1c6b9427086dcdef9b8fa47187efb9aaaec8398dcbf074196ed72a8f88', '923a35f1f95a2c2e0c5ca34c1759e5cd9005222aecf744f5f2cfbe2a937afc7c', '30d108135e5d5ca29f1851710d998b43e17cf658cb0bf7a20218abc345bf0b4e', '99a17c464525b7a715b4d8ac74d0889fc6ae244d5119ca838f8eedb1f0435444', 'fd0d3d7ba40e65fa061931cfb7d0f55d4f3056ed210d3960b5adc00c479d8187', '1b772dfa25f8ed2049d2157cbed246e1cbe7f36eb5685c9f8a6739297691ec2a', 'b9bbfabb58957652f3a296054fff42678c08ff84156bc8d94d3610e121e772bf'] B "use of packet-by-packet distribution of the same detnet flow over multiple paths is not recommended except for the cases listed above where preof is utilized to improve protection of traffic and maintain order. packet by packet load sharing, e.g., via ecmp or ucmp, impacts ordering and possibly jitter." {90: 1, 68: 1, 6: 1, 102: 1, 84: 1, 8: 1, 79: 3, 51: 3, 130: 3, 62: 2, 85: 2, 35: 4, 110: 4, 91: 6, 114: 4, 97: 4, 31: 2, 13: 3, 67: 3, 38: 5, 26: 2, 124: 3, 98: 3, 54: 3, 127: 4, 96: 4, 64: 3, 30: 5, 61: 6, 55: 2, 27: 2, 15: 4, 52: 2, 129: 4, 115: 4, 76: 4, 87: 4, 131: 6, 113: 6, 99: 3, 36: 4, 24: 3, 53: 2, 72: 5} {121: 1, 124: 1, 161: 1, 320: 1, 358: 1, 267: 1, 309: 1, 220: 1, 221: 1, 1: 6, 4: 3, 9: 3, 10: 4, 15: 4, 24: 3, 25: 2, 26: 2, 27: 4, 39: 2, 43: 4, 49: 7, 50: 6, 58: 6, 59: 3, 64: 4, 69: 2, 81: 3, 82: 3, 86: 4, 96: 5, 97: 4, 100: 6, 108: 4, 109: 5, 110: 5, 111: 3, 114: 4, 115: 5, 116: 4, 118: 3, 119: 2, 120: 4, 122: 5, 123: 4, 128: 5, 129: 5, 130: 6, 132: 2, 136: 3, 145: 2, 147: 5, 151: 5, 152: 5, 154: 4, 156: 3, 165: 4, 168: 5, 169: 4, 172: 4, 180: 5, 184: 3, 187: 6, 188: 5, 191: 4, 194: 2, 202: 3, 203: 4, 206: 3, 207: 4, 215: 2, 217: 4, 218: 5, 222: 2, 224: 4, 227: 4, 229: 4, 234: 6, 235: 3, 241: 3, 242: 3, 243: 2, 244: 5, 245: 2, 248: 5, 250: 5, 258: 8, 262: 5, 263: 6, 264: 2, 270: 4, 272: 4, 273: 3, 287: 4, 289: 4, 291: 6, 299: 4, 300: 4, 304: 4, 314: 3, 315: 4, 323: 2, 327: 5, 328: 3, 329: 3, 330: 7, 334: 3, 335: 4, 341: 4, 342: 5, 347: 4, 348: 4, 350: 5, 351: 6, 352: 4, 353: 4, 354: 3, 365: 4, 366: 3, 369: 2, 371: 6, 372: 6, 376: 3, 384: 6, 385: 5, 386: 4, 387: 4, 392: 3, 393: 4, 396: 5, 397: 4, 398: 3, 402: 4} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 55 "Detnet leverages many different forwarding sub-layers, each of which supports various tools to troubleshoot connectivity, for example identification of misbehaving flows. The DetNet Service layer can leverage existing mechanisms to troubleshoot or monitor flows, such as those in use by IP and MPLS networks. At the Application layer a client of a DetNet service can use existing techniques to detect and monitor delay and loss." "Update based on the comments of ( 01.10 ) and ( 04.10 ) . I agree with , it 's a well - known and deployed example . I 'm not sure why it was removed . Cheers , comments have been resolved" 5627886f9da3fa5ecb5b7bcfceeb9ab7c3c19e9f 5627886f9da3fa5ecb5b7bcfceeb9ab7c3c19e9f draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework b4f663df7a56c4c3c7893956b9297f583a3ee08b6e667404871701c5db6884e5 ['6a0240a7089e9eb5374ec83c67aef29bce159a2350fae0b9675eca23103d04c7', 'b4f663df7a56c4c3c7893956b9297f583a3ee08b6e667404871701c5db6884e5', '48d8a67306a5b7377d474058a02289ef5b0d47c7b426e70ca86c86fbaacd1c90', '1d461b45ddd8d23bc4da82c7319696451df56fdf43af8bec67d483088c4ccd80', 'c5585816f0df6bac1e8561d23945939d704941f0bc9b379d59f610db1feeae52', '37b3aa728e069dac87a1c6719d534af53a3c16745b470dc65fa0ead08542736e', '4c3da6e0fffc80e62e5f664bd81a2936b6593757d8fb0d02cabd8102872696d4', '09338bff4c055a4fa57185ce910ed41cd32622051fe170615aabadb84e10faa4', '0742ec0639e4bb03bafb0b62e474707c4e711aef2ade5826cd84de4e7122cea3', '83839a4b6f00a98b672d7d42db0e734dfc50262a09e90121413fa7e8f02a1fa3', '595ccef56e4f3f92cf6c8157968607922c16102040d858595d47562c1a6e672a', '427d7237acb5ebe013716dee7c43d7e5886164be733489be210e182ac81eb225', 'af8a420dec9dcad3ccc2748056ca06e500c69eca257e211cf29eb20635ea76e9', '878e4eb62fa086fa63f78e831077af12faaf0d2fc1d35390eae3936514aa7756', '065c7e1c6b9427086dcdef9b8fa47187efb9aaaec8398dcbf074196ed72a8f88', '923a35f1f95a2c2e0c5ca34c1759e5cd9005222aecf744f5f2cfbe2a937afc7c', '30d108135e5d5ca29f1851710d998b43e17cf658cb0bf7a20218abc345bf0b4e', '99a17c464525b7a715b4d8ac74d0889fc6ae244d5119ca838f8eedb1f0435444', 'fd0d3d7ba40e65fa061931cfb7d0f55d4f3056ed210d3960b5adc00c479d8187', '1b772dfa25f8ed2049d2157cbed246e1cbe7f36eb5685c9f8a6739297691ec2a', 'b9bbfabb58957652f3a296054fff42678c08ff84156bc8d94d3610e121e772bf'] B "detnet leverages many different forwarding sub-layers, each of which supports various tools to troubleshoot connectivity, for example identification of misbehaving flows. the detnet service layer can leverage existing mechanisms to troubleshoot or monitor flows, such as those in use by ip and mpls networks. at the application layer a client of a detnet service can use existing techniques to detect and monitor delay and loss." {90: 1, 68: 1, 6: 1, 102: 1, 84: 1, 8: 1, 79: 3, 51: 3, 130: 3, 62: 2, 85: 2, 35: 4, 110: 4, 91: 6, 114: 4, 97: 4, 31: 2, 13: 3, 67: 3, 38: 5, 26: 2, 124: 3, 98: 3, 54: 3, 127: 4, 96: 4, 64: 3, 30: 5, 61: 6, 55: 2, 27: 2, 15: 4, 52: 2, 129: 4, 115: 4, 76: 4, 87: 4, 131: 6, 113: 6, 99: 3, 36: 4, 24: 3, 53: 2, 72: 5} {121: 1, 124: 1, 161: 1, 320: 1, 358: 1, 267: 1, 309: 1, 220: 1, 221: 1, 1: 6, 4: 3, 9: 3, 10: 4, 15: 4, 24: 3, 25: 2, 26: 2, 27: 4, 39: 2, 43: 4, 49: 7, 50: 6, 58: 6, 59: 3, 64: 4, 69: 2, 81: 3, 82: 3, 86: 4, 96: 5, 97: 4, 100: 6, 108: 4, 109: 5, 110: 5, 111: 3, 114: 4, 115: 5, 116: 4, 118: 3, 119: 2, 120: 4, 122: 5, 123: 4, 128: 5, 129: 5, 130: 6, 132: 2, 136: 3, 145: 2, 147: 5, 151: 5, 152: 5, 154: 4, 156: 3, 165: 4, 168: 5, 169: 4, 172: 4, 180: 5, 184: 3, 187: 6, 188: 5, 191: 4, 194: 2, 202: 3, 203: 4, 206: 3, 207: 4, 215: 2, 217: 4, 218: 5, 222: 2, 224: 4, 227: 4, 229: 4, 234: 6, 235: 3, 241: 3, 242: 3, 243: 2, 244: 5, 245: 2, 248: 5, 250: 5, 258: 8, 262: 5, 263: 6, 264: 2, 270: 4, 272: 4, 273: 3, 287: 4, 289: 4, 291: 6, 299: 4, 300: 4, 304: 4, 314: 3, 315: 4, 323: 2, 327: 5, 328: 3, 329: 3, 330: 7, 334: 3, 335: 4, 341: 4, 342: 5, 347: 4, 348: 4, 350: 5, 351: 6, 352: 4, 353: 4, 354: 3, 365: 4, 366: 3, 369: 2, 371: 6, 372: 6, 376: 3, 384: 6, 385: 5, 386: 4, 387: 4, 392: 3, 393: 4, 396: 5, 397: 4, 398: 3, 402: 4} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 55 "Network analytics can be inherited from the technologies of the Service and Forwarding sub-layers. At the DetNet service edge, packet and bit counters (e.g. sent, received, dropped, and out-of- sequence) can be maintained." "Update based on the comments of ( 01.10 ) and ( 04.10 ) . I agree with , it 's a well - known and deployed example . I 'm not sure why it was removed . Cheers , comments have been resolved" 5627886f9da3fa5ecb5b7bcfceeb9ab7c3c19e9f 5627886f9da3fa5ecb5b7bcfceeb9ab7c3c19e9f draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework 427d7237acb5ebe013716dee7c43d7e5886164be733489be210e182ac81eb225 ['6a0240a7089e9eb5374ec83c67aef29bce159a2350fae0b9675eca23103d04c7', 'b4f663df7a56c4c3c7893956b9297f583a3ee08b6e667404871701c5db6884e5', '48d8a67306a5b7377d474058a02289ef5b0d47c7b426e70ca86c86fbaacd1c90', '1d461b45ddd8d23bc4da82c7319696451df56fdf43af8bec67d483088c4ccd80', 'c5585816f0df6bac1e8561d23945939d704941f0bc9b379d59f610db1feeae52', '37b3aa728e069dac87a1c6719d534af53a3c16745b470dc65fa0ead08542736e', '4c3da6e0fffc80e62e5f664bd81a2936b6593757d8fb0d02cabd8102872696d4', '09338bff4c055a4fa57185ce910ed41cd32622051fe170615aabadb84e10faa4', '0742ec0639e4bb03bafb0b62e474707c4e711aef2ade5826cd84de4e7122cea3', '83839a4b6f00a98b672d7d42db0e734dfc50262a09e90121413fa7e8f02a1fa3', '595ccef56e4f3f92cf6c8157968607922c16102040d858595d47562c1a6e672a', '427d7237acb5ebe013716dee7c43d7e5886164be733489be210e182ac81eb225', 'af8a420dec9dcad3ccc2748056ca06e500c69eca257e211cf29eb20635ea76e9', '878e4eb62fa086fa63f78e831077af12faaf0d2fc1d35390eae3936514aa7756', '065c7e1c6b9427086dcdef9b8fa47187efb9aaaec8398dcbf074196ed72a8f88', '923a35f1f95a2c2e0c5ca34c1759e5cd9005222aecf744f5f2cfbe2a937afc7c', '30d108135e5d5ca29f1851710d998b43e17cf658cb0bf7a20218abc345bf0b4e', '99a17c464525b7a715b4d8ac74d0889fc6ae244d5119ca838f8eedb1f0435444', 'fd0d3d7ba40e65fa061931cfb7d0f55d4f3056ed210d3960b5adc00c479d8187', '1b772dfa25f8ed2049d2157cbed246e1cbe7f36eb5685c9f8a6739297691ec2a', 'b9bbfabb58957652f3a296054fff42678c08ff84156bc8d94d3610e121e772bf'] B "network analytics can be inherited from the technologies of the service and forwarding sub-layers. at the detnet service edge, packet and bit counters (e.g. sent, received, dropped, and out-of- sequence) can be maintained." {90: 1, 68: 1, 6: 1, 102: 1, 84: 1, 8: 1, 79: 3, 51: 3, 130: 3, 62: 2, 85: 2, 35: 4, 110: 4, 91: 6, 114: 4, 97: 4, 31: 2, 13: 3, 67: 3, 38: 5, 26: 2, 124: 3, 98: 3, 54: 3, 127: 4, 96: 4, 64: 3, 30: 5, 61: 6, 55: 2, 27: 2, 15: 4, 52: 2, 129: 4, 115: 4, 76: 4, 87: 4, 131: 6, 113: 6, 99: 3, 36: 4, 24: 3, 53: 2, 72: 5} {121: 1, 124: 1, 161: 1, 320: 1, 358: 1, 267: 1, 309: 1, 220: 1, 221: 1, 1: 6, 4: 3, 9: 3, 10: 4, 15: 4, 24: 3, 25: 2, 26: 2, 27: 4, 39: 2, 43: 4, 49: 7, 50: 6, 58: 6, 59: 3, 64: 4, 69: 2, 81: 3, 82: 3, 86: 4, 96: 5, 97: 4, 100: 6, 108: 4, 109: 5, 110: 5, 111: 3, 114: 4, 115: 5, 116: 4, 118: 3, 119: 2, 120: 4, 122: 5, 123: 4, 128: 5, 129: 5, 130: 6, 132: 2, 136: 3, 145: 2, 147: 5, 151: 5, 152: 5, 154: 4, 156: 3, 165: 4, 168: 5, 169: 4, 172: 4, 180: 5, 184: 3, 187: 6, 188: 5, 191: 4, 194: 2, 202: 3, 203: 4, 206: 3, 207: 4, 215: 2, 217: 4, 218: 5, 222: 2, 224: 4, 227: 4, 229: 4, 234: 6, 235: 3, 241: 3, 242: 3, 243: 2, 244: 5, 245: 2, 248: 5, 250: 5, 258: 8, 262: 5, 263: 6, 264: 2, 270: 4, 272: 4, 273: 3, 287: 4, 289: 4, 291: 6, 299: 4, 300: 4, 304: 4, 314: 3, 315: 4, 323: 2, 327: 5, 328: 3, 329: 3, 330: 7, 334: 3, 335: 4, 341: 4, 342: 5, 347: 4, 348: 4, 350: 5, 351: 6, 352: 4, 353: 4, 354: 3, 365: 4, 366: 3, 369: 2, 371: 6, 372: 6, 376: 3, 384: 6, 385: 5, 386: 4, 387: 4, 392: 3, 393: 4, 396: 5, 397: 4, 398: 3, 402: 4} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 55 "The provider of a DetNet service may provide other capabilities to monitor flows, such as more detailed loss statistics and time stamping of events. The details of these capabilities are currently out of scope for this document." "Update based on the comments of ( 01.10 ) and ( 04.10 ) . I agree with , it 's a well - known and deployed example . I 'm not sure why it was removed . Cheers , comments have been resolved" 5627886f9da3fa5ecb5b7bcfceeb9ab7c3c19e9f 5627886f9da3fa5ecb5b7bcfceeb9ab7c3c19e9f draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework 1b772dfa25f8ed2049d2157cbed246e1cbe7f36eb5685c9f8a6739297691ec2a ['6a0240a7089e9eb5374ec83c67aef29bce159a2350fae0b9675eca23103d04c7', 'b4f663df7a56c4c3c7893956b9297f583a3ee08b6e667404871701c5db6884e5', '48d8a67306a5b7377d474058a02289ef5b0d47c7b426e70ca86c86fbaacd1c90', '1d461b45ddd8d23bc4da82c7319696451df56fdf43af8bec67d483088c4ccd80', 'c5585816f0df6bac1e8561d23945939d704941f0bc9b379d59f610db1feeae52', '37b3aa728e069dac87a1c6719d534af53a3c16745b470dc65fa0ead08542736e', '4c3da6e0fffc80e62e5f664bd81a2936b6593757d8fb0d02cabd8102872696d4', '09338bff4c055a4fa57185ce910ed41cd32622051fe170615aabadb84e10faa4', '0742ec0639e4bb03bafb0b62e474707c4e711aef2ade5826cd84de4e7122cea3', '83839a4b6f00a98b672d7d42db0e734dfc50262a09e90121413fa7e8f02a1fa3', '595ccef56e4f3f92cf6c8157968607922c16102040d858595d47562c1a6e672a', '427d7237acb5ebe013716dee7c43d7e5886164be733489be210e182ac81eb225', 'af8a420dec9dcad3ccc2748056ca06e500c69eca257e211cf29eb20635ea76e9', '878e4eb62fa086fa63f78e831077af12faaf0d2fc1d35390eae3936514aa7756', '065c7e1c6b9427086dcdef9b8fa47187efb9aaaec8398dcbf074196ed72a8f88', '923a35f1f95a2c2e0c5ca34c1759e5cd9005222aecf744f5f2cfbe2a937afc7c', '30d108135e5d5ca29f1851710d998b43e17cf658cb0bf7a20218abc345bf0b4e', '99a17c464525b7a715b4d8ac74d0889fc6ae244d5119ca838f8eedb1f0435444', 'fd0d3d7ba40e65fa061931cfb7d0f55d4f3056ed210d3960b5adc00c479d8187', '1b772dfa25f8ed2049d2157cbed246e1cbe7f36eb5685c9f8a6739297691ec2a', 'b9bbfabb58957652f3a296054fff42678c08ff84156bc8d94d3610e121e772bf'] B "the provider of a detnet service may provide other capabilities to monitor flows, such as more detailed loss statistics and time stamping of events. the details of these capabilities are currently out of scope for this document." {90: 1, 68: 1, 6: 1, 102: 1, 84: 1, 8: 1, 79: 3, 51: 3, 130: 3, 62: 2, 85: 2, 35: 4, 110: 4, 91: 6, 114: 4, 97: 4, 31: 2, 13: 3, 67: 3, 38: 5, 26: 2, 124: 3, 98: 3, 54: 3, 127: 4, 96: 4, 64: 3, 30: 5, 61: 6, 55: 2, 27: 2, 15: 4, 52: 2, 129: 4, 115: 4, 76: 4, 87: 4, 131: 6, 113: 6, 99: 3, 36: 4, 24: 3, 53: 2, 72: 5} {121: 1, 124: 1, 161: 1, 320: 1, 358: 1, 267: 1, 309: 1, 220: 1, 221: 1, 1: 6, 4: 3, 9: 3, 10: 4, 15: 4, 24: 3, 25: 2, 26: 2, 27: 4, 39: 2, 43: 4, 49: 7, 50: 6, 58: 6, 59: 3, 64: 4, 69: 2, 81: 3, 82: 3, 86: 4, 96: 5, 97: 4, 100: 6, 108: 4, 109: 5, 110: 5, 111: 3, 114: 4, 115: 5, 116: 4, 118: 3, 119: 2, 120: 4, 122: 5, 123: 4, 128: 5, 129: 5, 130: 6, 132: 2, 136: 3, 145: 2, 147: 5, 151: 5, 152: 5, 154: 4, 156: 3, 165: 4, 168: 5, 169: 4, 172: 4, 180: 5, 184: 3, 187: 6, 188: 5, 191: 4, 194: 2, 202: 3, 203: 4, 206: 3, 207: 4, 215: 2, 217: 4, 218: 5, 222: 2, 224: 4, 227: 4, 229: 4, 234: 6, 235: 3, 241: 3, 242: 3, 243: 2, 244: 5, 245: 2, 248: 5, 250: 5, 258: 8, 262: 5, 263: 6, 264: 2, 270: 4, 272: 4, 273: 3, 287: 4, 289: 4, 291: 6, 299: 4, 300: 4, 304: 4, 314: 3, 315: 4, 323: 2, 327: 5, 328: 3, 329: 3, 330: 7, 334: 3, 335: 4, 341: 4, 342: 5, 347: 4, 348: 4, 350: 5, 351: 6, 352: 4, 353: 4, 354: 3, 365: 4, 366: 3, 369: 2, 371: 6, 372: 6, 376: 3, 384: 6, 385: 5, 386: 4, 387: 4, 392: 3, 393: 4, 396: 5, 397: 4, 398: 3, 402: 4} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 55 "Service protection allow DetNet services to increase reliability and maintain a DetNet Service Assurance in the case of network congestion or network failure. Detnet relies on the underlying technology capabilities for various protection schemes. Protection schemes enable partial or complete coverage of the network paths and active protection with combinations of PRF, PEF, and POF." "Update based on the comments of ( 01.10 ) and ( 04.10 ) . I agree with , it 's a well - known and deployed example . I 'm not sure why it was removed . Cheers , comments have been resolved" 5627886f9da3fa5ecb5b7bcfceeb9ab7c3c19e9f 5627886f9da3fa5ecb5b7bcfceeb9ab7c3c19e9f draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework 065c7e1c6b9427086dcdef9b8fa47187efb9aaaec8398dcbf074196ed72a8f88 ['6a0240a7089e9eb5374ec83c67aef29bce159a2350fae0b9675eca23103d04c7', 'b4f663df7a56c4c3c7893956b9297f583a3ee08b6e667404871701c5db6884e5', '48d8a67306a5b7377d474058a02289ef5b0d47c7b426e70ca86c86fbaacd1c90', '1d461b45ddd8d23bc4da82c7319696451df56fdf43af8bec67d483088c4ccd80', 'c5585816f0df6bac1e8561d23945939d704941f0bc9b379d59f610db1feeae52', '37b3aa728e069dac87a1c6719d534af53a3c16745b470dc65fa0ead08542736e', '4c3da6e0fffc80e62e5f664bd81a2936b6593757d8fb0d02cabd8102872696d4', '09338bff4c055a4fa57185ce910ed41cd32622051fe170615aabadb84e10faa4', '0742ec0639e4bb03bafb0b62e474707c4e711aef2ade5826cd84de4e7122cea3', '83839a4b6f00a98b672d7d42db0e734dfc50262a09e90121413fa7e8f02a1fa3', '595ccef56e4f3f92cf6c8157968607922c16102040d858595d47562c1a6e672a', '427d7237acb5ebe013716dee7c43d7e5886164be733489be210e182ac81eb225', 'af8a420dec9dcad3ccc2748056ca06e500c69eca257e211cf29eb20635ea76e9', '878e4eb62fa086fa63f78e831077af12faaf0d2fc1d35390eae3936514aa7756', '065c7e1c6b9427086dcdef9b8fa47187efb9aaaec8398dcbf074196ed72a8f88', '923a35f1f95a2c2e0c5ca34c1759e5cd9005222aecf744f5f2cfbe2a937afc7c', '30d108135e5d5ca29f1851710d998b43e17cf658cb0bf7a20218abc345bf0b4e', '99a17c464525b7a715b4d8ac74d0889fc6ae244d5119ca838f8eedb1f0435444', 'fd0d3d7ba40e65fa061931cfb7d0f55d4f3056ed210d3960b5adc00c479d8187', '1b772dfa25f8ed2049d2157cbed246e1cbe7f36eb5685c9f8a6739297691ec2a', 'b9bbfabb58957652f3a296054fff42678c08ff84156bc8d94d3610e121e772bf'] B "service protection allow detnet services to increase reliability and maintain a detnet service assurance in the case of network congestion or network failure. detnet relies on the underlying technology capabilities for various protection schemes. protection schemes enable partial or complete coverage of the network paths and active protection with combinations of prf, pef, and pof." {90: 1, 68: 1, 6: 1, 102: 1, 84: 1, 8: 1, 79: 3, 51: 3, 130: 3, 62: 2, 85: 2, 35: 4, 110: 4, 91: 6, 114: 4, 97: 4, 31: 2, 13: 3, 67: 3, 38: 5, 26: 2, 124: 3, 98: 3, 54: 3, 127: 4, 96: 4, 64: 3, 30: 5, 61: 6, 55: 2, 27: 2, 15: 4, 52: 2, 129: 4, 115: 4, 76: 4, 87: 4, 131: 6, 113: 6, 99: 3, 36: 4, 24: 3, 53: 2, 72: 5} {121: 1, 124: 1, 161: 1, 320: 1, 358: 1, 267: 1, 309: 1, 220: 1, 221: 1, 1: 6, 4: 3, 9: 3, 10: 4, 15: 4, 24: 3, 25: 2, 26: 2, 27: 4, 39: 2, 43: 4, 49: 7, 50: 6, 58: 6, 59: 3, 64: 4, 69: 2, 81: 3, 82: 3, 86: 4, 96: 5, 97: 4, 100: 6, 108: 4, 109: 5, 110: 5, 111: 3, 114: 4, 115: 5, 116: 4, 118: 3, 119: 2, 120: 4, 122: 5, 123: 4, 128: 5, 129: 5, 130: 6, 132: 2, 136: 3, 145: 2, 147: 5, 151: 5, 152: 5, 154: 4, 156: 3, 165: 4, 168: 5, 169: 4, 172: 4, 180: 5, 184: 3, 187: 6, 188: 5, 191: 4, 194: 2, 202: 3, 203: 4, 206: 3, 207: 4, 215: 2, 217: 4, 218: 5, 222: 2, 224: 4, 227: 4, 229: 4, 234: 6, 235: 3, 241: 3, 242: 3, 243: 2, 244: 5, 245: 2, 248: 5, 250: 5, 258: 8, 262: 5, 263: 6, 264: 2, 270: 4, 272: 4, 273: 3, 287: 4, 289: 4, 291: 6, 299: 4, 300: 4, 304: 4, 314: 3, 315: 4, 323: 2, 327: 5, 328: 3, 329: 3, 330: 7, 334: 3, 335: 4, 341: 4, 342: 5, 347: 4, 348: 4, 350: 5, 351: 6, 352: 4, 353: 4, 354: 3, 365: 4, 366: 3, 369: 2, 371: 6, 372: 6, 376: 3, 384: 6, 385: 5, 386: 4, 387: 4, 392: 3, 393: 4, 396: 5, 397: 4, 398: 3, 402: 4} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 55 "This example also illustrates 1:1 protection scheme meaning there is traffic and path for each segment of the end to end path. Local DetNet relay nodes determine which packets are eliminated and which packets are forwarded. A 1+1 scheme where only one path is used for traffic at a time, could use the same topology. In this case there is no PRF function and traffic is switched upon detection of failure. An OAM scheme that monitors the paths detects the loss of path or traffic is required to initiate the switch. A POF may still be used in this case to prevent misordering of packets. In both cases the protection paths are established and maintained for the duration of the DetNet service." "Update based on the comments of ( 01.10 ) and ( 04.10 ) . I agree with , it 's a well - known and deployed example . I 'm not sure why it was removed . Cheers , comments have been resolved" 5627886f9da3fa5ecb5b7bcfceeb9ab7c3c19e9f 5627886f9da3fa5ecb5b7bcfceeb9ab7c3c19e9f draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework 9283a73ca025c686c922c33dd2ed832d8ee84f73c4d6ebb8f5a0fccc7689e4d2 ['9e9309b8b08938690b6c4ce01d9558354be1e89154a136fddc2be8d51e125ea2', '9283a73ca025c686c922c33dd2ed832d8ee84f73c4d6ebb8f5a0fccc7689e4d2', 'f507abc6f0c89ad2171679d7fa41df6fcbbec870b5ebb589d4b1816cbc434aa7', '17c7b257bc9a74ada3610b169a11c651dffd113a06ac432f686bf57e04743c29', 'cb36b3e74a93b3557fc45abc21839977e6a029bca7aee6c63148321383721bb6', '5a0d2766b652539bb9b04ed20679fff09a69e02d22e250fa0a177db3d886ff2b', '61014e6e8d3f5344f8f3c8c5674b189d6fbe221923e2f7afdda5acb8e3f89aa7', 'd6b8581165ce4de94d63adc76a5eb1f9d02d042d44a133a85cdad114720ee5b2'] A "this example also illustrates 1:1 protection scheme meaning there is traffic and path for each segment of the end to end path. local detnet relay nodes determine which packets are eliminated and which packets are forwarded. a 1+1 scheme where only one path is used for traffic at a time, could use the same topology. in this case there is no prf function and traffic is switched upon detection of failure. an oam scheme that monitors the paths detects the loss of path or traffic is required to initiate the switch. a pof may still be used in this case to prevent misordering of packets. in both cases the protection paths are established and maintained for the duration of the detnet service." {31: 1, 6: 1, 84: 1, 27: 1, 79: 4, 90: 3, 51: 5, 130: 4, 62: 4, 85: 4, 68: 3, 35: 5, 110: 5, 91: 7, 114: 5, 97: 5, 13: 5, 67: 3, 38: 6, 26: 4, 124: 3, 98: 4, 54: 4, 127: 5, 8: 2, 96: 5, 64: 4, 30: 6, 61: 7, 55: 2, 15: 5, 52: 2, 129: 5, 115: 5, 76: 2, 87: 5, 131: 7, 102: 3, 113: 7, 99: 4, 36: 5, 24: 4, 53: 3, 72: 6} {69: 1, 161: 1, 202: 1, 323: 1, 273: 1, 245: 1, 1: 8, 4: 4, 9: 3, 10: 5, 15: 5, 24: 4, 25: 4, 26: 4, 27: 5, 39: 4, 43: 5, 49: 8, 50: 7, 58: 7, 59: 4, 64: 5, 81: 5, 82: 5, 86: 5, 96: 6, 97: 5, 100: 8, 108: 5, 109: 6, 110: 6, 111: 4, 114: 5, 115: 6, 116: 5, 118: 5, 119: 4, 120: 5, 121: 3, 122: 6, 123: 5, 124: 3, 128: 6, 129: 6, 130: 7, 132: 2, 136: 4, 145: 2, 147: 6, 151: 6, 152: 6, 154: 5, 156: 4, 162: 2, 165: 5, 168: 6, 169: 5, 172: 5, 180: 6, 184: 3, 187: 7, 188: 6, 191: 5, 194: 2, 203: 2, 206: 4, 207: 5, 215: 2, 217: 5, 218: 7, 220: 3, 221: 3, 222: 4, 224: 5, 227: 6, 229: 5, 234: 7, 235: 4, 241: 4, 242: 4, 244: 6, 248: 6, 250: 6, 258: 10, 262: 6, 263: 7, 264: 2, 267: 3, 270: 5, 272: 5, 287: 5, 289: 5, 291: 7, 299: 6, 300: 5, 304: 5, 309: 3, 314: 4, 315: 5, 320: 3, 327: 6, 328: 3, 329: 4, 330: 9, 334: 4, 335: 5, 341: 6, 342: 7, 347: 6, 348: 6, 350: 3, 351: 7, 352: 5, 353: 5, 354: 4, 358: 3, 365: 5, 366: 4, 369: 3, 371: 8, 372: 7, 376: 4, 384: 7, 385: 6, 386: 5, 387: 5, 392: 3, 393: 4, 396: 7, 397: 6, 398: 5, 402: 5} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 55 "The DetNet data plane also allows for the aggregation of DetNet flows, to improved scaling by reducing the state per hop. How this is accomplished is data plane or control plane dependent. When DetNet flows are aggregated, transit nodes provide service to the aggregate and not on a per-DetNet flow basis. When aggregating DetNet flows the flows should be compatible i.e. the same or very similar QoS and CoS characteristics. In this case, nodes performing aggregation will ensure that per-flow service requirements are achieved." "Update based on the comments of ( 01.10 ) and ( 04.10 ) . I agree with , it 's a well - known and deployed example . I 'm not sure why it was removed . Cheers , comments have been resolved" 5627886f9da3fa5ecb5b7bcfceeb9ab7c3c19e9f 5627886f9da3fa5ecb5b7bcfceeb9ab7c3c19e9f draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework 61014e6e8d3f5344f8f3c8c5674b189d6fbe221923e2f7afdda5acb8e3f89aa7 ['9e9309b8b08938690b6c4ce01d9558354be1e89154a136fddc2be8d51e125ea2', '9283a73ca025c686c922c33dd2ed832d8ee84f73c4d6ebb8f5a0fccc7689e4d2', 'f507abc6f0c89ad2171679d7fa41df6fcbbec870b5ebb589d4b1816cbc434aa7', '17c7b257bc9a74ada3610b169a11c651dffd113a06ac432f686bf57e04743c29', 'cb36b3e74a93b3557fc45abc21839977e6a029bca7aee6c63148321383721bb6', '5a0d2766b652539bb9b04ed20679fff09a69e02d22e250fa0a177db3d886ff2b', '61014e6e8d3f5344f8f3c8c5674b189d6fbe221923e2f7afdda5acb8e3f89aa7', 'd6b8581165ce4de94d63adc76a5eb1f9d02d042d44a133a85cdad114720ee5b2'] A "the detnet data plane also allows for the aggregation of detnet flows, to improved scaling by reducing the state per hop. how this is accomplished is data plane or control plane dependent. when detnet flows are aggregated, transit nodes provide service to the aggregate and not on a per-detnet flow basis. when aggregating detnet flows the flows should be compatible i.e. the same or very similar qos and cos characteristics. in this case, nodes performing aggregation will ensure that per-flow service requirements are achieved." {31: 1, 6: 1, 84: 1, 27: 1, 79: 4, 90: 3, 51: 5, 130: 4, 62: 4, 85: 4, 68: 3, 35: 5, 110: 5, 91: 7, 114: 5, 97: 5, 13: 5, 67: 3, 38: 6, 26: 4, 124: 3, 98: 4, 54: 4, 127: 5, 8: 2, 96: 5, 64: 4, 30: 6, 61: 7, 55: 2, 15: 5, 52: 2, 129: 5, 115: 5, 76: 2, 87: 5, 131: 7, 102: 3, 113: 7, 99: 4, 36: 5, 24: 4, 53: 3, 72: 6} {69: 1, 161: 1, 202: 1, 323: 1, 273: 1, 245: 1, 1: 8, 4: 4, 9: 3, 10: 5, 15: 5, 24: 4, 25: 4, 26: 4, 27: 5, 39: 4, 43: 5, 49: 8, 50: 7, 58: 7, 59: 4, 64: 5, 81: 5, 82: 5, 86: 5, 96: 6, 97: 5, 100: 8, 108: 5, 109: 6, 110: 6, 111: 4, 114: 5, 115: 6, 116: 5, 118: 5, 119: 4, 120: 5, 121: 3, 122: 6, 123: 5, 124: 3, 128: 6, 129: 6, 130: 7, 132: 2, 136: 4, 145: 2, 147: 6, 151: 6, 152: 6, 154: 5, 156: 4, 162: 2, 165: 5, 168: 6, 169: 5, 172: 5, 180: 6, 184: 3, 187: 7, 188: 6, 191: 5, 194: 2, 203: 2, 206: 4, 207: 5, 215: 2, 217: 5, 218: 7, 220: 3, 221: 3, 222: 4, 224: 5, 227: 6, 229: 5, 234: 7, 235: 4, 241: 4, 242: 4, 244: 6, 248: 6, 250: 6, 258: 10, 262: 6, 263: 7, 264: 2, 267: 3, 270: 5, 272: 5, 287: 5, 289: 5, 291: 7, 299: 6, 300: 5, 304: 5, 309: 3, 314: 4, 315: 5, 320: 3, 327: 6, 328: 3, 329: 4, 330: 9, 334: 4, 335: 5, 341: 6, 342: 7, 347: 6, 348: 6, 350: 3, 351: 7, 352: 5, 353: 5, 354: 4, 358: 3, 365: 5, 366: 4, 369: 3, 371: 8, 372: 7, 376: 4, 384: 7, 385: 6, 386: 5, 387: 5, 392: 3, 393: 4, 396: 7, 397: 6, 398: 5, 402: 5} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 55 "If bandwidth reservations are used, the sum of the reservations should be the sum of all the individual reservations, in other words, the reservations should not create an over subscription of bandwidth reservation. If maximum delay bounds are used the system should ensure that the aggregate does not exceed the delay bounds of the individual flows." "Update based on the comments of ( 01.10 ) and ( 04.10 ) . I agree with , it 's a well - known and deployed example . I 'm not sure why it was removed . Cheers , comments have been resolved" 5627886f9da3fa5ecb5b7bcfceeb9ab7c3c19e9f 5627886f9da3fa5ecb5b7bcfceeb9ab7c3c19e9f draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework 5a0d2766b652539bb9b04ed20679fff09a69e02d22e250fa0a177db3d886ff2b ['9e9309b8b08938690b6c4ce01d9558354be1e89154a136fddc2be8d51e125ea2', '9283a73ca025c686c922c33dd2ed832d8ee84f73c4d6ebb8f5a0fccc7689e4d2', 'f507abc6f0c89ad2171679d7fa41df6fcbbec870b5ebb589d4b1816cbc434aa7', '17c7b257bc9a74ada3610b169a11c651dffd113a06ac432f686bf57e04743c29', 'cb36b3e74a93b3557fc45abc21839977e6a029bca7aee6c63148321383721bb6', '5a0d2766b652539bb9b04ed20679fff09a69e02d22e250fa0a177db3d886ff2b', '61014e6e8d3f5344f8f3c8c5674b189d6fbe221923e2f7afdda5acb8e3f89aa7', 'd6b8581165ce4de94d63adc76a5eb1f9d02d042d44a133a85cdad114720ee5b2'] A "if bandwidth reservations are used, the sum of the reservations should be the sum of all the individual reservations, in other words, the reservations should not create an over subscription of bandwidth reservation. if maximum delay bounds are used the system should ensure that the aggregate does not exceed the delay bounds of the individual flows." {31: 1, 6: 1, 84: 1, 27: 1, 79: 4, 90: 3, 51: 5, 130: 4, 62: 4, 85: 4, 68: 3, 35: 5, 110: 5, 91: 7, 114: 5, 97: 5, 13: 5, 67: 3, 38: 6, 26: 4, 124: 3, 98: 4, 54: 4, 127: 5, 8: 2, 96: 5, 64: 4, 30: 6, 61: 7, 55: 2, 15: 5, 52: 2, 129: 5, 115: 5, 76: 2, 87: 5, 131: 7, 102: 3, 113: 7, 99: 4, 36: 5, 24: 4, 53: 3, 72: 6} {69: 1, 161: 1, 202: 1, 323: 1, 273: 1, 245: 1, 1: 8, 4: 4, 9: 3, 10: 5, 15: 5, 24: 4, 25: 4, 26: 4, 27: 5, 39: 4, 43: 5, 49: 8, 50: 7, 58: 7, 59: 4, 64: 5, 81: 5, 82: 5, 86: 5, 96: 6, 97: 5, 100: 8, 108: 5, 109: 6, 110: 6, 111: 4, 114: 5, 115: 6, 116: 5, 118: 5, 119: 4, 120: 5, 121: 3, 122: 6, 123: 5, 124: 3, 128: 6, 129: 6, 130: 7, 132: 2, 136: 4, 145: 2, 147: 6, 151: 6, 152: 6, 154: 5, 156: 4, 162: 2, 165: 5, 168: 6, 169: 5, 172: 5, 180: 6, 184: 3, 187: 7, 188: 6, 191: 5, 194: 2, 203: 2, 206: 4, 207: 5, 215: 2, 217: 5, 218: 7, 220: 3, 221: 3, 222: 4, 224: 5, 227: 6, 229: 5, 234: 7, 235: 4, 241: 4, 242: 4, 244: 6, 248: 6, 250: 6, 258: 10, 262: 6, 263: 7, 264: 2, 267: 3, 270: 5, 272: 5, 287: 5, 289: 5, 291: 7, 299: 6, 300: 5, 304: 5, 309: 3, 314: 4, 315: 5, 320: 3, 327: 6, 328: 3, 329: 4, 330: 9, 334: 4, 335: 5, 341: 6, 342: 7, 347: 6, 348: 6, 350: 3, 351: 7, 352: 5, 353: 5, 354: 4, 358: 3, 365: 5, 366: 4, 369: 3, 371: 8, 372: 7, 376: 4, 384: 7, 385: 6, 386: 5, 387: 5, 392: 3, 393: 4, 396: 7, 397: 6, 398: 5, 402: 5} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 55 "DetNet encapsulation is a data plane mechanism that can be used to aggregate traffic. Encapsulation can either be in the same service type or in a different service type see dn_svc_encaps for example. When an encapsulation is used the choice of reserving a maximum resource level and then tracking the services in the aggregated service or adjusting the aggregated resources as the services are added is implementation and technology specific." "Update based on the comments of ( 01.10 ) and ( 04.10 ) . I agree with , it 's a well - known and deployed example . I 'm not sure why it was removed . Cheers , comments have been resolved" 5627886f9da3fa5ecb5b7bcfceeb9ab7c3c19e9f 5627886f9da3fa5ecb5b7bcfceeb9ab7c3c19e9f draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework 17c7b257bc9a74ada3610b169a11c651dffd113a06ac432f686bf57e04743c29 ['9e9309b8b08938690b6c4ce01d9558354be1e89154a136fddc2be8d51e125ea2', '9283a73ca025c686c922c33dd2ed832d8ee84f73c4d6ebb8f5a0fccc7689e4d2', 'f507abc6f0c89ad2171679d7fa41df6fcbbec870b5ebb589d4b1816cbc434aa7', '17c7b257bc9a74ada3610b169a11c651dffd113a06ac432f686bf57e04743c29', 'cb36b3e74a93b3557fc45abc21839977e6a029bca7aee6c63148321383721bb6', '5a0d2766b652539bb9b04ed20679fff09a69e02d22e250fa0a177db3d886ff2b', '61014e6e8d3f5344f8f3c8c5674b189d6fbe221923e2f7afdda5acb8e3f89aa7', 'd6b8581165ce4de94d63adc76a5eb1f9d02d042d44a133a85cdad114720ee5b2'] A "detnet encapsulation is a data plane mechanism that can be used to aggregate traffic. encapsulation can either be in the same service type or in a different service type see dn_svc_encaps for example. when an encapsulation is used the choice of reserving a maximum resource level and then tracking the services in the aggregated service or adjusting the aggregated resources as the services are added is implementation and technology specific." {31: 1, 6: 1, 84: 1, 27: 1, 79: 4, 90: 3, 51: 5, 130: 4, 62: 4, 85: 4, 68: 3, 35: 5, 110: 5, 91: 7, 114: 5, 97: 5, 13: 5, 67: 3, 38: 6, 26: 4, 124: 3, 98: 4, 54: 4, 127: 5, 8: 2, 96: 5, 64: 4, 30: 6, 61: 7, 55: 2, 15: 5, 52: 2, 129: 5, 115: 5, 76: 2, 87: 5, 131: 7, 102: 3, 113: 7, 99: 4, 36: 5, 24: 4, 53: 3, 72: 6} {69: 1, 161: 1, 202: 1, 323: 1, 273: 1, 245: 1, 1: 8, 4: 4, 9: 3, 10: 5, 15: 5, 24: 4, 25: 4, 26: 4, 27: 5, 39: 4, 43: 5, 49: 8, 50: 7, 58: 7, 59: 4, 64: 5, 81: 5, 82: 5, 86: 5, 96: 6, 97: 5, 100: 8, 108: 5, 109: 6, 110: 6, 111: 4, 114: 5, 115: 6, 116: 5, 118: 5, 119: 4, 120: 5, 121: 3, 122: 6, 123: 5, 124: 3, 128: 6, 129: 6, 130: 7, 132: 2, 136: 4, 145: 2, 147: 6, 151: 6, 152: 6, 154: 5, 156: 4, 162: 2, 165: 5, 168: 6, 169: 5, 172: 5, 180: 6, 184: 3, 187: 7, 188: 6, 191: 5, 194: 2, 203: 2, 206: 4, 207: 5, 215: 2, 217: 5, 218: 7, 220: 3, 221: 3, 222: 4, 224: 5, 227: 6, 229: 5, 234: 7, 235: 4, 241: 4, 242: 4, 244: 6, 248: 6, 250: 6, 258: 10, 262: 6, 263: 7, 264: 2, 267: 3, 270: 5, 272: 5, 287: 5, 289: 5, 291: 7, 299: 6, 300: 5, 304: 5, 309: 3, 314: 4, 315: 5, 320: 3, 327: 6, 328: 3, 329: 4, 330: 9, 334: 4, 335: 5, 341: 6, 342: 7, 347: 6, 348: 6, 350: 3, 351: 7, 352: 5, 353: 5, 354: 4, 358: 3, 365: 5, 366: 4, 369: 3, 371: 8, 372: 7, 376: 4, 384: 7, 385: 6, 386: 5, 387: 5, 392: 3, 393: 4, 396: 7, 397: 6, 398: 5, 402: 5} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 55 "This example also illustrates 1:1 protection scheme meaning there is traffic over each segment of the end to end path. Local DetNet relay nodes determine which packets are eliminated and which packets are forwarded. A 1+1 scheme where only one path is used for traffic at a time, could use the same topology. In this case there is no PRF function and traffic is switched upon detection of failure. An OAM scheme that monitors the paths detects the loss of path or traffic is required to initiate the switch. A POF may still be used in this case to prevent misordering of packets. In both cases the protection paths are established and maintained for the duration of the DetNet service." "Update based on the comments of ( 01.10 ) and ( 04.10 ) . I agree with , it 's a well - known and deployed example . I 'm not sure why it was removed . Cheers , comments have been resolved" 5627886f9da3fa5ecb5b7bcfceeb9ab7c3c19e9f 5627886f9da3fa5ecb5b7bcfceeb9ab7c3c19e9f draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework 9e9309b8b08938690b6c4ce01d9558354be1e89154a136fddc2be8d51e125ea2 ['9e9309b8b08938690b6c4ce01d9558354be1e89154a136fddc2be8d51e125ea2', '9283a73ca025c686c922c33dd2ed832d8ee84f73c4d6ebb8f5a0fccc7689e4d2', 'f507abc6f0c89ad2171679d7fa41df6fcbbec870b5ebb589d4b1816cbc434aa7', '17c7b257bc9a74ada3610b169a11c651dffd113a06ac432f686bf57e04743c29', 'cb36b3e74a93b3557fc45abc21839977e6a029bca7aee6c63148321383721bb6', '5a0d2766b652539bb9b04ed20679fff09a69e02d22e250fa0a177db3d886ff2b', '61014e6e8d3f5344f8f3c8c5674b189d6fbe221923e2f7afdda5acb8e3f89aa7', 'd6b8581165ce4de94d63adc76a5eb1f9d02d042d44a133a85cdad114720ee5b2'] B "this example also illustrates 1:1 protection scheme meaning there is traffic over each segment of the end to end path. local detnet relay nodes determine which packets are eliminated and which packets are forwarded. a 1+1 scheme where only one path is used for traffic at a time, could use the same topology. in this case there is no prf function and traffic is switched upon detection of failure. an oam scheme that monitors the paths detects the loss of path or traffic is required to initiate the switch. a pof may still be used in this case to prevent misordering of packets. in both cases the protection paths are established and maintained for the duration of the detnet service." {31: 1, 6: 1, 84: 1, 27: 1, 79: 4, 90: 3, 51: 5, 130: 4, 62: 4, 85: 4, 68: 3, 35: 5, 110: 5, 91: 7, 114: 5, 97: 5, 13: 5, 67: 3, 38: 6, 26: 4, 124: 3, 98: 4, 54: 4, 127: 5, 8: 2, 96: 5, 64: 4, 30: 6, 61: 7, 55: 2, 15: 5, 52: 2, 129: 5, 115: 5, 76: 2, 87: 5, 131: 7, 102: 3, 113: 7, 99: 4, 36: 5, 24: 4, 53: 3, 72: 6} {69: 1, 161: 1, 202: 1, 323: 1, 273: 1, 245: 1, 1: 8, 4: 4, 9: 3, 10: 5, 15: 5, 24: 4, 25: 4, 26: 4, 27: 5, 39: 4, 43: 5, 49: 8, 50: 7, 58: 7, 59: 4, 64: 5, 81: 5, 82: 5, 86: 5, 96: 6, 97: 5, 100: 8, 108: 5, 109: 6, 110: 6, 111: 4, 114: 5, 115: 6, 116: 5, 118: 5, 119: 4, 120: 5, 121: 3, 122: 6, 123: 5, 124: 3, 128: 6, 129: 6, 130: 7, 132: 2, 136: 4, 145: 2, 147: 6, 151: 6, 152: 6, 154: 5, 156: 4, 162: 2, 165: 5, 168: 6, 169: 5, 172: 5, 180: 6, 184: 3, 187: 7, 188: 6, 191: 5, 194: 2, 203: 2, 206: 4, 207: 5, 215: 2, 217: 5, 218: 7, 220: 3, 221: 3, 222: 4, 224: 5, 227: 6, 229: 5, 234: 7, 235: 4, 241: 4, 242: 4, 244: 6, 248: 6, 250: 6, 258: 10, 262: 6, 263: 7, 264: 2, 267: 3, 270: 5, 272: 5, 287: 5, 289: 5, 291: 7, 299: 6, 300: 5, 304: 5, 309: 3, 314: 4, 315: 5, 320: 3, 327: 6, 328: 3, 329: 4, 330: 9, 334: 4, 335: 5, 341: 6, 342: 7, 347: 6, 348: 6, 350: 3, 351: 7, 352: 5, 353: 5, 354: 4, 358: 3, 365: 5, 366: 4, 369: 3, 371: 8, 372: 7, 376: 4, 384: 7, 385: 6, 386: 5, 387: 5, 392: 3, 393: 4, 396: 7, 397: 6, 398: 5, 402: 5} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 55 "The DetNet data plane also allows for the aggregation of DetNet flows, which can improve scalability by reducing the per-hop state. How this is accomplished is data plane or control plane dependent. When DetNet flows are aggregated, transit nodes provide service to the aggregate and not on a per-DetNet flow basis. When aggregating DetNet flows the flows should be compatible i.e. the same or very similar QoS and CoS characteristics. In this case, nodes performing aggregation will ensure that per-flow service requirements are achieved." "Update based on the comments of ( 01.10 ) and ( 04.10 ) . I agree with , it 's a well - known and deployed example . I 'm not sure why it was removed . Cheers , comments have been resolved" 5627886f9da3fa5ecb5b7bcfceeb9ab7c3c19e9f 5627886f9da3fa5ecb5b7bcfceeb9ab7c3c19e9f draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework cb36b3e74a93b3557fc45abc21839977e6a029bca7aee6c63148321383721bb6 ['9e9309b8b08938690b6c4ce01d9558354be1e89154a136fddc2be8d51e125ea2', '9283a73ca025c686c922c33dd2ed832d8ee84f73c4d6ebb8f5a0fccc7689e4d2', 'f507abc6f0c89ad2171679d7fa41df6fcbbec870b5ebb589d4b1816cbc434aa7', '17c7b257bc9a74ada3610b169a11c651dffd113a06ac432f686bf57e04743c29', 'cb36b3e74a93b3557fc45abc21839977e6a029bca7aee6c63148321383721bb6', '5a0d2766b652539bb9b04ed20679fff09a69e02d22e250fa0a177db3d886ff2b', '61014e6e8d3f5344f8f3c8c5674b189d6fbe221923e2f7afdda5acb8e3f89aa7', 'd6b8581165ce4de94d63adc76a5eb1f9d02d042d44a133a85cdad114720ee5b2'] B "the detnet data plane also allows for the aggregation of detnet flows, which can improve scalability by reducing the per-hop state. how this is accomplished is data plane or control plane dependent. when detnet flows are aggregated, transit nodes provide service to the aggregate and not on a per-detnet flow basis. when aggregating detnet flows the flows should be compatible i.e. the same or very similar qos and cos characteristics. in this case, nodes performing aggregation will ensure that per-flow service requirements are achieved." {31: 1, 6: 1, 84: 1, 27: 1, 79: 4, 90: 3, 51: 5, 130: 4, 62: 4, 85: 4, 68: 3, 35: 5, 110: 5, 91: 7, 114: 5, 97: 5, 13: 5, 67: 3, 38: 6, 26: 4, 124: 3, 98: 4, 54: 4, 127: 5, 8: 2, 96: 5, 64: 4, 30: 6, 61: 7, 55: 2, 15: 5, 52: 2, 129: 5, 115: 5, 76: 2, 87: 5, 131: 7, 102: 3, 113: 7, 99: 4, 36: 5, 24: 4, 53: 3, 72: 6} {69: 1, 161: 1, 202: 1, 323: 1, 273: 1, 245: 1, 1: 8, 4: 4, 9: 3, 10: 5, 15: 5, 24: 4, 25: 4, 26: 4, 27: 5, 39: 4, 43: 5, 49: 8, 50: 7, 58: 7, 59: 4, 64: 5, 81: 5, 82: 5, 86: 5, 96: 6, 97: 5, 100: 8, 108: 5, 109: 6, 110: 6, 111: 4, 114: 5, 115: 6, 116: 5, 118: 5, 119: 4, 120: 5, 121: 3, 122: 6, 123: 5, 124: 3, 128: 6, 129: 6, 130: 7, 132: 2, 136: 4, 145: 2, 147: 6, 151: 6, 152: 6, 154: 5, 156: 4, 162: 2, 165: 5, 168: 6, 169: 5, 172: 5, 180: 6, 184: 3, 187: 7, 188: 6, 191: 5, 194: 2, 203: 2, 206: 4, 207: 5, 215: 2, 217: 5, 218: 7, 220: 3, 221: 3, 222: 4, 224: 5, 227: 6, 229: 5, 234: 7, 235: 4, 241: 4, 242: 4, 244: 6, 248: 6, 250: 6, 258: 10, 262: 6, 263: 7, 264: 2, 267: 3, 270: 5, 272: 5, 287: 5, 289: 5, 291: 7, 299: 6, 300: 5, 304: 5, 309: 3, 314: 4, 315: 5, 320: 3, 327: 6, 328: 3, 329: 4, 330: 9, 334: 4, 335: 5, 341: 6, 342: 7, 347: 6, 348: 6, 350: 3, 351: 7, 352: 5, 353: 5, 354: 4, 358: 3, 365: 5, 366: 4, 369: 3, 371: 8, 372: 7, 376: 4, 384: 7, 385: 6, 386: 5, 387: 5, 392: 3, 393: 4, 396: 7, 397: 6, 398: 5, 402: 5} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 55 "If bandwidth reservations are used, the sum of the reservations should be the sum of all the individual reservations; in other words, the reservations should not add up to an over-subscription of bandwidth reservation. If maximum delay bounds are used, the system should ensure that the aggregate does not exceed the delay bounds of the individual flows." "Update based on the comments of ( 01.10 ) and ( 04.10 ) . I agree with , it 's a well - known and deployed example . I 'm not sure why it was removed . Cheers , comments have been resolved" 5627886f9da3fa5ecb5b7bcfceeb9ab7c3c19e9f 5627886f9da3fa5ecb5b7bcfceeb9ab7c3c19e9f draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework f507abc6f0c89ad2171679d7fa41df6fcbbec870b5ebb589d4b1816cbc434aa7 ['9e9309b8b08938690b6c4ce01d9558354be1e89154a136fddc2be8d51e125ea2', '9283a73ca025c686c922c33dd2ed832d8ee84f73c4d6ebb8f5a0fccc7689e4d2', 'f507abc6f0c89ad2171679d7fa41df6fcbbec870b5ebb589d4b1816cbc434aa7', '17c7b257bc9a74ada3610b169a11c651dffd113a06ac432f686bf57e04743c29', 'cb36b3e74a93b3557fc45abc21839977e6a029bca7aee6c63148321383721bb6', '5a0d2766b652539bb9b04ed20679fff09a69e02d22e250fa0a177db3d886ff2b', '61014e6e8d3f5344f8f3c8c5674b189d6fbe221923e2f7afdda5acb8e3f89aa7', 'd6b8581165ce4de94d63adc76a5eb1f9d02d042d44a133a85cdad114720ee5b2'] B "if bandwidth reservations are used, the sum of the reservations should be the sum of all the individual reservations; in other words, the reservations should not add up to an over-subscription of bandwidth reservation. if maximum delay bounds are used, the system should ensure that the aggregate does not exceed the delay bounds of the individual flows." {31: 1, 6: 1, 84: 1, 27: 1, 79: 4, 90: 3, 51: 5, 130: 4, 62: 4, 85: 4, 68: 3, 35: 5, 110: 5, 91: 7, 114: 5, 97: 5, 13: 5, 67: 3, 38: 6, 26: 4, 124: 3, 98: 4, 54: 4, 127: 5, 8: 2, 96: 5, 64: 4, 30: 6, 61: 7, 55: 2, 15: 5, 52: 2, 129: 5, 115: 5, 76: 2, 87: 5, 131: 7, 102: 3, 113: 7, 99: 4, 36: 5, 24: 4, 53: 3, 72: 6} {69: 1, 161: 1, 202: 1, 323: 1, 273: 1, 245: 1, 1: 8, 4: 4, 9: 3, 10: 5, 15: 5, 24: 4, 25: 4, 26: 4, 27: 5, 39: 4, 43: 5, 49: 8, 50: 7, 58: 7, 59: 4, 64: 5, 81: 5, 82: 5, 86: 5, 96: 6, 97: 5, 100: 8, 108: 5, 109: 6, 110: 6, 111: 4, 114: 5, 115: 6, 116: 5, 118: 5, 119: 4, 120: 5, 121: 3, 122: 6, 123: 5, 124: 3, 128: 6, 129: 6, 130: 7, 132: 2, 136: 4, 145: 2, 147: 6, 151: 6, 152: 6, 154: 5, 156: 4, 162: 2, 165: 5, 168: 6, 169: 5, 172: 5, 180: 6, 184: 3, 187: 7, 188: 6, 191: 5, 194: 2, 203: 2, 206: 4, 207: 5, 215: 2, 217: 5, 218: 7, 220: 3, 221: 3, 222: 4, 224: 5, 227: 6, 229: 5, 234: 7, 235: 4, 241: 4, 242: 4, 244: 6, 248: 6, 250: 6, 258: 10, 262: 6, 263: 7, 264: 2, 267: 3, 270: 5, 272: 5, 287: 5, 289: 5, 291: 7, 299: 6, 300: 5, 304: 5, 309: 3, 314: 4, 315: 5, 320: 3, 327: 6, 328: 3, 329: 4, 330: 9, 334: 4, 335: 5, 341: 6, 342: 7, 347: 6, 348: 6, 350: 3, 351: 7, 352: 5, 353: 5, 354: 4, 358: 3, 365: 5, 366: 4, 369: 3, 371: 8, 372: 7, 376: 4, 384: 7, 385: 6, 386: 5, 387: 5, 392: 3, 393: 4, 396: 7, 397: 6, 398: 5, 402: 5} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 55 "When an encapsulation is used the choice of reserving a maximum resource level and then tracking the services in the aggregated service or adjusting the aggregated resources as the services are added is implementation and technology specific." "Update based on the comments of ( 01.10 ) and ( 04.10 ) . I agree with , it 's a well - known and deployed example . I 'm not sure why it was removed . Cheers , comments have been resolved" 5627886f9da3fa5ecb5b7bcfceeb9ab7c3c19e9f 5627886f9da3fa5ecb5b7bcfceeb9ab7c3c19e9f draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework d6b8581165ce4de94d63adc76a5eb1f9d02d042d44a133a85cdad114720ee5b2 ['9e9309b8b08938690b6c4ce01d9558354be1e89154a136fddc2be8d51e125ea2', '9283a73ca025c686c922c33dd2ed832d8ee84f73c4d6ebb8f5a0fccc7689e4d2', 'f507abc6f0c89ad2171679d7fa41df6fcbbec870b5ebb589d4b1816cbc434aa7', '17c7b257bc9a74ada3610b169a11c651dffd113a06ac432f686bf57e04743c29', 'cb36b3e74a93b3557fc45abc21839977e6a029bca7aee6c63148321383721bb6', '5a0d2766b652539bb9b04ed20679fff09a69e02d22e250fa0a177db3d886ff2b', '61014e6e8d3f5344f8f3c8c5674b189d6fbe221923e2f7afdda5acb8e3f89aa7', 'd6b8581165ce4de94d63adc76a5eb1f9d02d042d44a133a85cdad114720ee5b2'] B "when an encapsulation is used the choice of reserving a maximum resource level and then tracking the services in the aggregated service or adjusting the aggregated resources as the services are added is implementation and technology specific." {31: 1, 6: 1, 84: 1, 27: 1, 79: 4, 90: 3, 51: 5, 130: 4, 62: 4, 85: 4, 68: 3, 35: 5, 110: 5, 91: 7, 114: 5, 97: 5, 13: 5, 67: 3, 38: 6, 26: 4, 124: 3, 98: 4, 54: 4, 127: 5, 8: 2, 96: 5, 64: 4, 30: 6, 61: 7, 55: 2, 15: 5, 52: 2, 129: 5, 115: 5, 76: 2, 87: 5, 131: 7, 102: 3, 113: 7, 99: 4, 36: 5, 24: 4, 53: 3, 72: 6} {69: 1, 161: 1, 202: 1, 323: 1, 273: 1, 245: 1, 1: 8, 4: 4, 9: 3, 10: 5, 15: 5, 24: 4, 25: 4, 26: 4, 27: 5, 39: 4, 43: 5, 49: 8, 50: 7, 58: 7, 59: 4, 64: 5, 81: 5, 82: 5, 86: 5, 96: 6, 97: 5, 100: 8, 108: 5, 109: 6, 110: 6, 111: 4, 114: 5, 115: 6, 116: 5, 118: 5, 119: 4, 120: 5, 121: 3, 122: 6, 123: 5, 124: 3, 128: 6, 129: 6, 130: 7, 132: 2, 136: 4, 145: 2, 147: 6, 151: 6, 152: 6, 154: 5, 156: 4, 162: 2, 165: 5, 168: 6, 169: 5, 172: 5, 180: 6, 184: 3, 187: 7, 188: 6, 191: 5, 194: 2, 203: 2, 206: 4, 207: 5, 215: 2, 217: 5, 218: 7, 220: 3, 221: 3, 222: 4, 224: 5, 227: 6, 229: 5, 234: 7, 235: 4, 241: 4, 242: 4, 244: 6, 248: 6, 250: 6, 258: 10, 262: 6, 263: 7, 264: 2, 267: 3, 270: 5, 272: 5, 287: 5, 289: 5, 291: 7, 299: 6, 300: 5, 304: 5, 309: 3, 314: 4, 315: 5, 320: 3, 327: 6, 328: 3, 329: 4, 330: 9, 334: 4, 335: 5, 341: 6, 342: 7, 347: 6, 348: 6, 350: 3, 351: 7, 352: 5, 353: 5, 354: 4, 358: 3, 365: 5, 366: 4, 369: 3, 371: 8, 372: 7, 376: 4, 384: 7, 385: 6, 386: 5, 387: 5, 392: 3, 393: 4, 396: 7, 397: 6, 398: 5, 402: 5} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 55 "DetNet flows at edges must be able to handle rejection to an aggregation group due to lack of resources as well as conditions where general requirements are not satisfied." "Update based on the comments of ( 01.10 ) and ( 04.10 ) . I agree with , it 's a well - known and deployed example . I 'm not sure why it was removed . Cheers , comments have been resolved" 5627886f9da3fa5ecb5b7bcfceeb9ab7c3c19e9f 5627886f9da3fa5ecb5b7bcfceeb9ab7c3c19e9f draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework 685699140cefd1e1e66aa17dc3988b9e5199f0b20725eaff95c5fb402dd99ab1 ['5aa07ccd4fe1b59b4cdeb039171c2db94e91641a5c5054552543bd338566d2a3', '5f96858898baf084da1400010804dc3eb02f27b0726c6b31ba7c6065af6f3772', '685699140cefd1e1e66aa17dc3988b9e5199f0b20725eaff95c5fb402dd99ab1', '792b6cb16ba1a98b61881cf7634e377446c537dede9fcdd334103fb79c2e7dce', '22605ce31a47b84168adec6e3d14544cc40de016dde0b5b700ab7985db601845', 'cc53e673d6189fb03bd07364e033c8ad0195b7b2ca5c67b9555686b6466da06c', 'da829f4ffbc9e8fb80029b032811c1f7bebe7dd754e34e6f0c47da01bfd96e41', '0e41ec81b9f82db98d1cd35aa3b0765936fdeef25ac6fac5cccae550e3e2fb70', '1125615d9fac73e6f3135e67ed29fa750f6222195d89cdd592fbb345a99ba301', 'a6402401c31bbef50b804dc1d0bc35132bb6974c0b295c9ae1779371bc52776a'] A "detnet flows at edges must be able to handle rejection to an aggregation group due to lack of resources as well as conditions where general requirements are not satisfied." {90: 1, 8: 1, 31: 1, 6: 1, 79: 4, 51: 5, 130: 4, 62: 4, 85: 4, 68: 3, 35: 5, 110: 5, 91: 7, 114: 5, 97: 5, 13: 5, 67: 3, 38: 6, 26: 4, 124: 3, 98: 4, 54: 4, 127: 5, 96: 5, 64: 4, 30: 6, 61: 7, 27: 2, 15: 5, 52: 2, 55: 2, 129: 5, 115: 5, 84: 2, 76: 4, 87: 5, 131: 7, 102: 3, 113: 7, 99: 4, 36: 5, 24: 4, 53: 3, 72: 6} {9: 1, 132: 1, 184: 1, 161: 1, 1: 8, 4: 4, 10: 5, 15: 5, 24: 4, 25: 4, 26: 4, 27: 5, 39: 4, 43: 5, 49: 8, 50: 7, 58: 7, 59: 4, 64: 5, 69: 2, 81: 5, 82: 5, 86: 5, 96: 6, 97: 5, 100: 8, 108: 5, 109: 6, 110: 6, 111: 4, 114: 5, 115: 6, 116: 5, 118: 5, 119: 4, 120: 5, 121: 3, 122: 6, 123: 5, 124: 3, 128: 6, 129: 6, 130: 7, 136: 4, 147: 6, 151: 6, 152: 6, 154: 5, 156: 4, 162: 2, 165: 5, 168: 6, 169: 5, 172: 5, 180: 6, 187: 7, 188: 6, 191: 5, 194: 2, 202: 3, 203: 4, 206: 4, 207: 5, 215: 2, 217: 5, 218: 7, 220: 3, 221: 3, 222: 4, 224: 5, 227: 6, 229: 5, 234: 7, 235: 4, 241: 4, 242: 4, 243: 2, 244: 6, 245: 2, 248: 6, 250: 6, 258: 10, 262: 6, 263: 7, 264: 2, 267: 3, 270: 5, 272: 5, 273: 3, 287: 5, 289: 5, 291: 7, 299: 6, 300: 5, 304: 5, 309: 3, 314: 4, 315: 5, 320: 3, 323: 2, 327: 6, 328: 3, 329: 4, 330: 9, 334: 4, 335: 5, 341: 6, 342: 7, 347: 6, 348: 6, 350: 5, 351: 7, 352: 5, 353: 5, 354: 4, 358: 3, 365: 5, 366: 4, 369: 3, 371: 8, 372: 7, 376: 4, 384: 7, 385: 6, 386: 5, 387: 5, 392: 3, 393: 4, 396: 7, 397: 6, 398: 5, 402: 5} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 55 "IP aggregation has both data plane and controller plane aspects. For the data plane flows may be aggregated for treatment based on shared characteristics such as 6-tuple. Alternatively, an IP encapsulation may be used to tunnel an aggregate number of DetNet Flows between relay nodes." "Update based on the comments of ( 01.10 ) and ( 04.10 ) . I agree with , it 's a well - known and deployed example . I 'm not sure why it was removed . Cheers , comments have been resolved" 5627886f9da3fa5ecb5b7bcfceeb9ab7c3c19e9f 5627886f9da3fa5ecb5b7bcfceeb9ab7c3c19e9f draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework 5f96858898baf084da1400010804dc3eb02f27b0726c6b31ba7c6065af6f3772 ['5aa07ccd4fe1b59b4cdeb039171c2db94e91641a5c5054552543bd338566d2a3', '5f96858898baf084da1400010804dc3eb02f27b0726c6b31ba7c6065af6f3772', '685699140cefd1e1e66aa17dc3988b9e5199f0b20725eaff95c5fb402dd99ab1', '792b6cb16ba1a98b61881cf7634e377446c537dede9fcdd334103fb79c2e7dce', '22605ce31a47b84168adec6e3d14544cc40de016dde0b5b700ab7985db601845', 'cc53e673d6189fb03bd07364e033c8ad0195b7b2ca5c67b9555686b6466da06c', 'da829f4ffbc9e8fb80029b032811c1f7bebe7dd754e34e6f0c47da01bfd96e41', '0e41ec81b9f82db98d1cd35aa3b0765936fdeef25ac6fac5cccae550e3e2fb70', '1125615d9fac73e6f3135e67ed29fa750f6222195d89cdd592fbb345a99ba301', 'a6402401c31bbef50b804dc1d0bc35132bb6974c0b295c9ae1779371bc52776a'] A "ip aggregation has both data plane and controller plane aspects. for the data plane flows may be aggregated for treatment based on shared characteristics such as 6-tuple. alternatively, an ip encapsulation may be used to tunnel an aggregate number of detnet flows between relay nodes." {90: 1, 8: 1, 31: 1, 6: 1, 79: 4, 51: 5, 130: 4, 62: 4, 85: 4, 68: 3, 35: 5, 110: 5, 91: 7, 114: 5, 97: 5, 13: 5, 67: 3, 38: 6, 26: 4, 124: 3, 98: 4, 54: 4, 127: 5, 96: 5, 64: 4, 30: 6, 61: 7, 27: 2, 15: 5, 52: 2, 55: 2, 129: 5, 115: 5, 84: 2, 76: 4, 87: 5, 131: 7, 102: 3, 113: 7, 99: 4, 36: 5, 24: 4, 53: 3, 72: 6} {9: 1, 132: 1, 184: 1, 161: 1, 1: 8, 4: 4, 10: 5, 15: 5, 24: 4, 25: 4, 26: 4, 27: 5, 39: 4, 43: 5, 49: 8, 50: 7, 58: 7, 59: 4, 64: 5, 69: 2, 81: 5, 82: 5, 86: 5, 96: 6, 97: 5, 100: 8, 108: 5, 109: 6, 110: 6, 111: 4, 114: 5, 115: 6, 116: 5, 118: 5, 119: 4, 120: 5, 121: 3, 122: 6, 123: 5, 124: 3, 128: 6, 129: 6, 130: 7, 136: 4, 147: 6, 151: 6, 152: 6, 154: 5, 156: 4, 162: 2, 165: 5, 168: 6, 169: 5, 172: 5, 180: 6, 187: 7, 188: 6, 191: 5, 194: 2, 202: 3, 203: 4, 206: 4, 207: 5, 215: 2, 217: 5, 218: 7, 220: 3, 221: 3, 222: 4, 224: 5, 227: 6, 229: 5, 234: 7, 235: 4, 241: 4, 242: 4, 243: 2, 244: 6, 245: 2, 248: 6, 250: 6, 258: 10, 262: 6, 263: 7, 264: 2, 267: 3, 270: 5, 272: 5, 273: 3, 287: 5, 289: 5, 291: 7, 299: 6, 300: 5, 304: 5, 309: 3, 314: 4, 315: 5, 320: 3, 323: 2, 327: 6, 328: 3, 329: 4, 330: 9, 334: 4, 335: 5, 341: 6, 342: 7, 347: 6, 348: 6, 350: 5, 351: 7, 352: 5, 353: 5, 354: 4, 358: 3, 365: 5, 366: 4, 369: 3, 371: 8, 372: 7, 376: 4, 384: 7, 385: 6, 386: 5, 387: 5, 392: 3, 393: 4, 396: 7, 397: 6, 398: 5, 402: 5} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 55 "MPLS aggregation similarly has data plane and controller plane aspects. In the case of MPLS flows are often tunneled in a forwarding sub-layer and reservation is associated with that MPLS tunnel." "Update based on the comments of ( 01.10 ) and ( 04.10 ) . I agree with , it 's a well - known and deployed example . I 'm not sure why it was removed . Cheers , comments have been resolved" 5627886f9da3fa5ecb5b7bcfceeb9ab7c3c19e9f 5627886f9da3fa5ecb5b7bcfceeb9ab7c3c19e9f draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework a6402401c31bbef50b804dc1d0bc35132bb6974c0b295c9ae1779371bc52776a ['5aa07ccd4fe1b59b4cdeb039171c2db94e91641a5c5054552543bd338566d2a3', '5f96858898baf084da1400010804dc3eb02f27b0726c6b31ba7c6065af6f3772', '685699140cefd1e1e66aa17dc3988b9e5199f0b20725eaff95c5fb402dd99ab1', '792b6cb16ba1a98b61881cf7634e377446c537dede9fcdd334103fb79c2e7dce', '22605ce31a47b84168adec6e3d14544cc40de016dde0b5b700ab7985db601845', 'cc53e673d6189fb03bd07364e033c8ad0195b7b2ca5c67b9555686b6466da06c', 'da829f4ffbc9e8fb80029b032811c1f7bebe7dd754e34e6f0c47da01bfd96e41', '0e41ec81b9f82db98d1cd35aa3b0765936fdeef25ac6fac5cccae550e3e2fb70', '1125615d9fac73e6f3135e67ed29fa750f6222195d89cdd592fbb345a99ba301', 'a6402401c31bbef50b804dc1d0bc35132bb6974c0b295c9ae1779371bc52776a'] A "mpls aggregation similarly has data plane and controller plane aspects. in the case of mpls flows are often tunneled in a forwarding sub-layer and reservation is associated with that mpls tunnel." {90: 1, 8: 1, 31: 1, 6: 1, 79: 4, 51: 5, 130: 4, 62: 4, 85: 4, 68: 3, 35: 5, 110: 5, 91: 7, 114: 5, 97: 5, 13: 5, 67: 3, 38: 6, 26: 4, 124: 3, 98: 4, 54: 4, 127: 5, 96: 5, 64: 4, 30: 6, 61: 7, 27: 2, 15: 5, 52: 2, 55: 2, 129: 5, 115: 5, 84: 2, 76: 4, 87: 5, 131: 7, 102: 3, 113: 7, 99: 4, 36: 5, 24: 4, 53: 3, 72: 6} {9: 1, 132: 1, 184: 1, 161: 1, 1: 8, 4: 4, 10: 5, 15: 5, 24: 4, 25: 4, 26: 4, 27: 5, 39: 4, 43: 5, 49: 8, 50: 7, 58: 7, 59: 4, 64: 5, 69: 2, 81: 5, 82: 5, 86: 5, 96: 6, 97: 5, 100: 8, 108: 5, 109: 6, 110: 6, 111: 4, 114: 5, 115: 6, 116: 5, 118: 5, 119: 4, 120: 5, 121: 3, 122: 6, 123: 5, 124: 3, 128: 6, 129: 6, 130: 7, 136: 4, 147: 6, 151: 6, 152: 6, 154: 5, 156: 4, 162: 2, 165: 5, 168: 6, 169: 5, 172: 5, 180: 6, 187: 7, 188: 6, 191: 5, 194: 2, 202: 3, 203: 4, 206: 4, 207: 5, 215: 2, 217: 5, 218: 7, 220: 3, 221: 3, 222: 4, 224: 5, 227: 6, 229: 5, 234: 7, 235: 4, 241: 4, 242: 4, 243: 2, 244: 6, 245: 2, 248: 6, 250: 6, 258: 10, 262: 6, 263: 7, 264: 2, 267: 3, 270: 5, 272: 5, 273: 3, 287: 5, 289: 5, 291: 7, 299: 6, 300: 5, 304: 5, 309: 3, 314: 4, 315: 5, 320: 3, 323: 2, 327: 6, 328: 3, 329: 4, 330: 9, 334: 4, 335: 5, 341: 6, 342: 7, 347: 6, 348: 6, 350: 5, 351: 7, 352: 5, 353: 5, 354: 4, 358: 3, 365: 5, 366: 4, 369: 3, 371: 8, 372: 7, 376: 4, 384: 7, 385: 6, 386: 5, 387: 5, 392: 3, 393: 4, 396: 7, 397: 6, 398: 5, 402: 5} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 55 "Data-flows requiring DetNet service are generated and terminated on end-systems. Encapsulation depends on the application and its preferences. For example, a DetNet MPLS domain the DN functions use the d-CWs, S-Labels and F-Labels to provide DetNet services. However, an application may exchange further flow related parameters (e.g., time-stamp), which are not provided by DN functions." "Update based on the comments of ( 01.10 ) and ( 04.10 ) . I agree with , it 's a well - known and deployed example . I 'm not sure why it was removed . Cheers , comments have been resolved" 5627886f9da3fa5ecb5b7bcfceeb9ab7c3c19e9f 5627886f9da3fa5ecb5b7bcfceeb9ab7c3c19e9f draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework 792b6cb16ba1a98b61881cf7634e377446c537dede9fcdd334103fb79c2e7dce ['5aa07ccd4fe1b59b4cdeb039171c2db94e91641a5c5054552543bd338566d2a3', '5f96858898baf084da1400010804dc3eb02f27b0726c6b31ba7c6065af6f3772', '685699140cefd1e1e66aa17dc3988b9e5199f0b20725eaff95c5fb402dd99ab1', '792b6cb16ba1a98b61881cf7634e377446c537dede9fcdd334103fb79c2e7dce', '22605ce31a47b84168adec6e3d14544cc40de016dde0b5b700ab7985db601845', 'cc53e673d6189fb03bd07364e033c8ad0195b7b2ca5c67b9555686b6466da06c', 'da829f4ffbc9e8fb80029b032811c1f7bebe7dd754e34e6f0c47da01bfd96e41', '0e41ec81b9f82db98d1cd35aa3b0765936fdeef25ac6fac5cccae550e3e2fb70', '1125615d9fac73e6f3135e67ed29fa750f6222195d89cdd592fbb345a99ba301', 'a6402401c31bbef50b804dc1d0bc35132bb6974c0b295c9ae1779371bc52776a'] A "data-flows requiring detnet service are generated and terminated on end-systems. encapsulation depends on the application and its preferences. for example, a detnet mpls domain the dn functions use the d-cws, s-labels and f-labels to provide detnet services. however, an application may exchange further flow related parameters (e.g., time-stamp), which are not provided by dn functions." {90: 1, 8: 1, 31: 1, 6: 1, 79: 4, 51: 5, 130: 4, 62: 4, 85: 4, 68: 3, 35: 5, 110: 5, 91: 7, 114: 5, 97: 5, 13: 5, 67: 3, 38: 6, 26: 4, 124: 3, 98: 4, 54: 4, 127: 5, 96: 5, 64: 4, 30: 6, 61: 7, 27: 2, 15: 5, 52: 2, 55: 2, 129: 5, 115: 5, 84: 2, 76: 4, 87: 5, 131: 7, 102: 3, 113: 7, 99: 4, 36: 5, 24: 4, 53: 3, 72: 6} {9: 1, 132: 1, 184: 1, 161: 1, 1: 8, 4: 4, 10: 5, 15: 5, 24: 4, 25: 4, 26: 4, 27: 5, 39: 4, 43: 5, 49: 8, 50: 7, 58: 7, 59: 4, 64: 5, 69: 2, 81: 5, 82: 5, 86: 5, 96: 6, 97: 5, 100: 8, 108: 5, 109: 6, 110: 6, 111: 4, 114: 5, 115: 6, 116: 5, 118: 5, 119: 4, 120: 5, 121: 3, 122: 6, 123: 5, 124: 3, 128: 6, 129: 6, 130: 7, 136: 4, 147: 6, 151: 6, 152: 6, 154: 5, 156: 4, 162: 2, 165: 5, 168: 6, 169: 5, 172: 5, 180: 6, 187: 7, 188: 6, 191: 5, 194: 2, 202: 3, 203: 4, 206: 4, 207: 5, 215: 2, 217: 5, 218: 7, 220: 3, 221: 3, 222: 4, 224: 5, 227: 6, 229: 5, 234: 7, 235: 4, 241: 4, 242: 4, 243: 2, 244: 6, 245: 2, 248: 6, 250: 6, 258: 10, 262: 6, 263: 7, 264: 2, 267: 3, 270: 5, 272: 5, 273: 3, 287: 5, 289: 5, 291: 7, 299: 6, 300: 5, 304: 5, 309: 3, 314: 4, 315: 5, 320: 3, 323: 2, 327: 6, 328: 3, 329: 4, 330: 9, 334: 4, 335: 5, 341: 6, 342: 7, 347: 6, 348: 6, 350: 5, 351: 7, 352: 5, 353: 5, 354: 4, 358: 3, 365: 5, 366: 4, 369: 3, 371: 8, 372: 7, 376: 4, 384: 7, 385: 6, 386: 5, 387: 5, 392: 3, 393: 4, 396: 7, 397: 6, 398: 5, 402: 5} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 55 "As a general rule, DetNet domains are capable of forwarding any DetNet flows and the DetNet domain does not mandate the end-system or edge system encapsulation format. Unless there is a proxy of some form present, end-systems peer with similar end-systems using the same application encapsulation format. For example, as shown in fig_es_connect, IP applications peer with IP applications and Ethernet applications peer with Ethernet applications." "Update based on the comments of ( 01.10 ) and ( 04.10 ) . I agree with , it 's a well - known and deployed example . I 'm not sure why it was removed . Cheers , comments have been resolved" 5627886f9da3fa5ecb5b7bcfceeb9ab7c3c19e9f 5627886f9da3fa5ecb5b7bcfceeb9ab7c3c19e9f draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework 1125615d9fac73e6f3135e67ed29fa750f6222195d89cdd592fbb345a99ba301 ['5aa07ccd4fe1b59b4cdeb039171c2db94e91641a5c5054552543bd338566d2a3', '5f96858898baf084da1400010804dc3eb02f27b0726c6b31ba7c6065af6f3772', '685699140cefd1e1e66aa17dc3988b9e5199f0b20725eaff95c5fb402dd99ab1', '792b6cb16ba1a98b61881cf7634e377446c537dede9fcdd334103fb79c2e7dce', '22605ce31a47b84168adec6e3d14544cc40de016dde0b5b700ab7985db601845', 'cc53e673d6189fb03bd07364e033c8ad0195b7b2ca5c67b9555686b6466da06c', 'da829f4ffbc9e8fb80029b032811c1f7bebe7dd754e34e6f0c47da01bfd96e41', '0e41ec81b9f82db98d1cd35aa3b0765936fdeef25ac6fac5cccae550e3e2fb70', '1125615d9fac73e6f3135e67ed29fa750f6222195d89cdd592fbb345a99ba301', 'a6402401c31bbef50b804dc1d0bc35132bb6974c0b295c9ae1779371bc52776a'] A "as a general rule, detnet domains are capable of forwarding any detnet flows and the detnet domain does not mandate the end-system or edge system encapsulation format. unless there is a proxy of some form present, end-systems peer with similar end-systems using the same application encapsulation format. for example, as shown in fig_es_connect, ip applications peer with ip applications and ethernet applications peer with ethernet applications." {90: 1, 8: 1, 31: 1, 6: 1, 79: 4, 51: 5, 130: 4, 62: 4, 85: 4, 68: 3, 35: 5, 110: 5, 91: 7, 114: 5, 97: 5, 13: 5, 67: 3, 38: 6, 26: 4, 124: 3, 98: 4, 54: 4, 127: 5, 96: 5, 64: 4, 30: 6, 61: 7, 27: 2, 15: 5, 52: 2, 55: 2, 129: 5, 115: 5, 84: 2, 76: 4, 87: 5, 131: 7, 102: 3, 113: 7, 99: 4, 36: 5, 24: 4, 53: 3, 72: 6} {9: 1, 132: 1, 184: 1, 161: 1, 1: 8, 4: 4, 10: 5, 15: 5, 24: 4, 25: 4, 26: 4, 27: 5, 39: 4, 43: 5, 49: 8, 50: 7, 58: 7, 59: 4, 64: 5, 69: 2, 81: 5, 82: 5, 86: 5, 96: 6, 97: 5, 100: 8, 108: 5, 109: 6, 110: 6, 111: 4, 114: 5, 115: 6, 116: 5, 118: 5, 119: 4, 120: 5, 121: 3, 122: 6, 123: 5, 124: 3, 128: 6, 129: 6, 130: 7, 136: 4, 147: 6, 151: 6, 152: 6, 154: 5, 156: 4, 162: 2, 165: 5, 168: 6, 169: 5, 172: 5, 180: 6, 187: 7, 188: 6, 191: 5, 194: 2, 202: 3, 203: 4, 206: 4, 207: 5, 215: 2, 217: 5, 218: 7, 220: 3, 221: 3, 222: 4, 224: 5, 227: 6, 229: 5, 234: 7, 235: 4, 241: 4, 242: 4, 243: 2, 244: 6, 245: 2, 248: 6, 250: 6, 258: 10, 262: 6, 263: 7, 264: 2, 267: 3, 270: 5, 272: 5, 273: 3, 287: 5, 289: 5, 291: 7, 299: 6, 300: 5, 304: 5, 309: 3, 314: 4, 315: 5, 320: 3, 323: 2, 327: 6, 328: 3, 329: 4, 330: 9, 334: 4, 335: 5, 341: 6, 342: 7, 347: 6, 348: 6, 350: 5, 351: 7, 352: 5, 353: 5, 354: 4, 358: 3, 365: 5, 366: 4, 369: 3, 371: 8, 372: 7, 376: 4, 384: 7, 385: 6, 386: 5, 387: 5, 392: 3, 393: 4, 396: 7, 397: 6, 398: 5, 402: 5} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 55 "DetNet flows at edges must be able to handle rejection to an aggregation group due to lack of resources as well as conditions where requirements are not satisfied." "Update based on the comments of ( 01.10 ) and ( 04.10 ) . I agree with , it 's a well - known and deployed example . I 'm not sure why it was removed . Cheers , comments have been resolved" 5627886f9da3fa5ecb5b7bcfceeb9ab7c3c19e9f 5627886f9da3fa5ecb5b7bcfceeb9ab7c3c19e9f draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework cc53e673d6189fb03bd07364e033c8ad0195b7b2ca5c67b9555686b6466da06c ['5aa07ccd4fe1b59b4cdeb039171c2db94e91641a5c5054552543bd338566d2a3', '5f96858898baf084da1400010804dc3eb02f27b0726c6b31ba7c6065af6f3772', '685699140cefd1e1e66aa17dc3988b9e5199f0b20725eaff95c5fb402dd99ab1', '792b6cb16ba1a98b61881cf7634e377446c537dede9fcdd334103fb79c2e7dce', '22605ce31a47b84168adec6e3d14544cc40de016dde0b5b700ab7985db601845', 'cc53e673d6189fb03bd07364e033c8ad0195b7b2ca5c67b9555686b6466da06c', 'da829f4ffbc9e8fb80029b032811c1f7bebe7dd754e34e6f0c47da01bfd96e41', '0e41ec81b9f82db98d1cd35aa3b0765936fdeef25ac6fac5cccae550e3e2fb70', '1125615d9fac73e6f3135e67ed29fa750f6222195d89cdd592fbb345a99ba301', 'a6402401c31bbef50b804dc1d0bc35132bb6974c0b295c9ae1779371bc52776a'] B "detnet flows at edges must be able to handle rejection to an aggregation group due to lack of resources as well as conditions where requirements are not satisfied." {90: 1, 8: 1, 31: 1, 6: 1, 79: 4, 51: 5, 130: 4, 62: 4, 85: 4, 68: 3, 35: 5, 110: 5, 91: 7, 114: 5, 97: 5, 13: 5, 67: 3, 38: 6, 26: 4, 124: 3, 98: 4, 54: 4, 127: 5, 96: 5, 64: 4, 30: 6, 61: 7, 27: 2, 15: 5, 52: 2, 55: 2, 129: 5, 115: 5, 84: 2, 76: 4, 87: 5, 131: 7, 102: 3, 113: 7, 99: 4, 36: 5, 24: 4, 53: 3, 72: 6} {9: 1, 132: 1, 184: 1, 161: 1, 1: 8, 4: 4, 10: 5, 15: 5, 24: 4, 25: 4, 26: 4, 27: 5, 39: 4, 43: 5, 49: 8, 50: 7, 58: 7, 59: 4, 64: 5, 69: 2, 81: 5, 82: 5, 86: 5, 96: 6, 97: 5, 100: 8, 108: 5, 109: 6, 110: 6, 111: 4, 114: 5, 115: 6, 116: 5, 118: 5, 119: 4, 120: 5, 121: 3, 122: 6, 123: 5, 124: 3, 128: 6, 129: 6, 130: 7, 136: 4, 147: 6, 151: 6, 152: 6, 154: 5, 156: 4, 162: 2, 165: 5, 168: 6, 169: 5, 172: 5, 180: 6, 187: 7, 188: 6, 191: 5, 194: 2, 202: 3, 203: 4, 206: 4, 207: 5, 215: 2, 217: 5, 218: 7, 220: 3, 221: 3, 222: 4, 224: 5, 227: 6, 229: 5, 234: 7, 235: 4, 241: 4, 242: 4, 243: 2, 244: 6, 245: 2, 248: 6, 250: 6, 258: 10, 262: 6, 263: 7, 264: 2, 267: 3, 270: 5, 272: 5, 273: 3, 287: 5, 289: 5, 291: 7, 299: 6, 300: 5, 304: 5, 309: 3, 314: 4, 315: 5, 320: 3, 323: 2, 327: 6, 328: 3, 329: 4, 330: 9, 334: 4, 335: 5, 341: 6, 342: 7, 347: 6, 348: 6, 350: 5, 351: 7, 352: 5, 353: 5, 354: 4, 358: 3, 365: 5, 366: 4, 369: 3, 371: 8, 372: 7, 376: 4, 384: 7, 385: 6, 386: 5, 387: 5, 392: 3, 393: 4, 396: 7, 397: 6, 398: 5, 402: 5} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 55 "IP aggregation has both data plane and controller plane aspects. For the data plane, flows may be aggregated for treatment based on shared characteristics such as 6-tuple. Alternatively, an IP encapsulation may be used to tunnel an aggregate number of DetNet Flows between relay nodes." "Update based on the comments of ( 01.10 ) and ( 04.10 ) . I agree with , it 's a well - known and deployed example . I 'm not sure why it was removed . Cheers , comments have been resolved" 5627886f9da3fa5ecb5b7bcfceeb9ab7c3c19e9f 5627886f9da3fa5ecb5b7bcfceeb9ab7c3c19e9f draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework 0e41ec81b9f82db98d1cd35aa3b0765936fdeef25ac6fac5cccae550e3e2fb70 ['5aa07ccd4fe1b59b4cdeb039171c2db94e91641a5c5054552543bd338566d2a3', '5f96858898baf084da1400010804dc3eb02f27b0726c6b31ba7c6065af6f3772', '685699140cefd1e1e66aa17dc3988b9e5199f0b20725eaff95c5fb402dd99ab1', '792b6cb16ba1a98b61881cf7634e377446c537dede9fcdd334103fb79c2e7dce', '22605ce31a47b84168adec6e3d14544cc40de016dde0b5b700ab7985db601845', 'cc53e673d6189fb03bd07364e033c8ad0195b7b2ca5c67b9555686b6466da06c', 'da829f4ffbc9e8fb80029b032811c1f7bebe7dd754e34e6f0c47da01bfd96e41', '0e41ec81b9f82db98d1cd35aa3b0765936fdeef25ac6fac5cccae550e3e2fb70', '1125615d9fac73e6f3135e67ed29fa750f6222195d89cdd592fbb345a99ba301', 'a6402401c31bbef50b804dc1d0bc35132bb6974c0b295c9ae1779371bc52776a'] B "ip aggregation has both data plane and controller plane aspects. for the data plane, flows may be aggregated for treatment based on shared characteristics such as 6-tuple. alternatively, an ip encapsulation may be used to tunnel an aggregate number of detnet flows between relay nodes." {90: 1, 8: 1, 31: 1, 6: 1, 79: 4, 51: 5, 130: 4, 62: 4, 85: 4, 68: 3, 35: 5, 110: 5, 91: 7, 114: 5, 97: 5, 13: 5, 67: 3, 38: 6, 26: 4, 124: 3, 98: 4, 54: 4, 127: 5, 96: 5, 64: 4, 30: 6, 61: 7, 27: 2, 15: 5, 52: 2, 55: 2, 129: 5, 115: 5, 84: 2, 76: 4, 87: 5, 131: 7, 102: 3, 113: 7, 99: 4, 36: 5, 24: 4, 53: 3, 72: 6} {9: 1, 132: 1, 184: 1, 161: 1, 1: 8, 4: 4, 10: 5, 15: 5, 24: 4, 25: 4, 26: 4, 27: 5, 39: 4, 43: 5, 49: 8, 50: 7, 58: 7, 59: 4, 64: 5, 69: 2, 81: 5, 82: 5, 86: 5, 96: 6, 97: 5, 100: 8, 108: 5, 109: 6, 110: 6, 111: 4, 114: 5, 115: 6, 116: 5, 118: 5, 119: 4, 120: 5, 121: 3, 122: 6, 123: 5, 124: 3, 128: 6, 129: 6, 130: 7, 136: 4, 147: 6, 151: 6, 152: 6, 154: 5, 156: 4, 162: 2, 165: 5, 168: 6, 169: 5, 172: 5, 180: 6, 187: 7, 188: 6, 191: 5, 194: 2, 202: 3, 203: 4, 206: 4, 207: 5, 215: 2, 217: 5, 218: 7, 220: 3, 221: 3, 222: 4, 224: 5, 227: 6, 229: 5, 234: 7, 235: 4, 241: 4, 242: 4, 243: 2, 244: 6, 245: 2, 248: 6, 250: 6, 258: 10, 262: 6, 263: 7, 264: 2, 267: 3, 270: 5, 272: 5, 273: 3, 287: 5, 289: 5, 291: 7, 299: 6, 300: 5, 304: 5, 309: 3, 314: 4, 315: 5, 320: 3, 323: 2, 327: 6, 328: 3, 329: 4, 330: 9, 334: 4, 335: 5, 341: 6, 342: 7, 347: 6, 348: 6, 350: 5, 351: 7, 352: 5, 353: 5, 354: 4, 358: 3, 365: 5, 366: 4, 369: 3, 371: 8, 372: 7, 376: 4, 384: 7, 385: 6, 386: 5, 387: 5, 392: 3, 393: 4, 396: 7, 397: 6, 398: 5, 402: 5} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 55 "MPLS aggregation also has data plane and controller plane aspects. MPLS flows are often tunneled in a forwarding sub-layer, under the reservation associated with that MPLS tunnel." "Update based on the comments of ( 01.10 ) and ( 04.10 ) . I agree with , it 's a well - known and deployed example . I 'm not sure why it was removed . Cheers , comments have been resolved" 5627886f9da3fa5ecb5b7bcfceeb9ab7c3c19e9f 5627886f9da3fa5ecb5b7bcfceeb9ab7c3c19e9f draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework da829f4ffbc9e8fb80029b032811c1f7bebe7dd754e34e6f0c47da01bfd96e41 ['5aa07ccd4fe1b59b4cdeb039171c2db94e91641a5c5054552543bd338566d2a3', '5f96858898baf084da1400010804dc3eb02f27b0726c6b31ba7c6065af6f3772', '685699140cefd1e1e66aa17dc3988b9e5199f0b20725eaff95c5fb402dd99ab1', '792b6cb16ba1a98b61881cf7634e377446c537dede9fcdd334103fb79c2e7dce', '22605ce31a47b84168adec6e3d14544cc40de016dde0b5b700ab7985db601845', 'cc53e673d6189fb03bd07364e033c8ad0195b7b2ca5c67b9555686b6466da06c', 'da829f4ffbc9e8fb80029b032811c1f7bebe7dd754e34e6f0c47da01bfd96e41', '0e41ec81b9f82db98d1cd35aa3b0765936fdeef25ac6fac5cccae550e3e2fb70', '1125615d9fac73e6f3135e67ed29fa750f6222195d89cdd592fbb345a99ba301', 'a6402401c31bbef50b804dc1d0bc35132bb6974c0b295c9ae1779371bc52776a'] B "mpls aggregation also has data plane and controller plane aspects. mpls flows are often tunneled in a forwarding sub-layer, under the reservation associated with that mpls tunnel." {90: 1, 8: 1, 31: 1, 6: 1, 79: 4, 51: 5, 130: 4, 62: 4, 85: 4, 68: 3, 35: 5, 110: 5, 91: 7, 114: 5, 97: 5, 13: 5, 67: 3, 38: 6, 26: 4, 124: 3, 98: 4, 54: 4, 127: 5, 96: 5, 64: 4, 30: 6, 61: 7, 27: 2, 15: 5, 52: 2, 55: 2, 129: 5, 115: 5, 84: 2, 76: 4, 87: 5, 131: 7, 102: 3, 113: 7, 99: 4, 36: 5, 24: 4, 53: 3, 72: 6} {9: 1, 132: 1, 184: 1, 161: 1, 1: 8, 4: 4, 10: 5, 15: 5, 24: 4, 25: 4, 26: 4, 27: 5, 39: 4, 43: 5, 49: 8, 50: 7, 58: 7, 59: 4, 64: 5, 69: 2, 81: 5, 82: 5, 86: 5, 96: 6, 97: 5, 100: 8, 108: 5, 109: 6, 110: 6, 111: 4, 114: 5, 115: 6, 116: 5, 118: 5, 119: 4, 120: 5, 121: 3, 122: 6, 123: 5, 124: 3, 128: 6, 129: 6, 130: 7, 136: 4, 147: 6, 151: 6, 152: 6, 154: 5, 156: 4, 162: 2, 165: 5, 168: 6, 169: 5, 172: 5, 180: 6, 187: 7, 188: 6, 191: 5, 194: 2, 202: 3, 203: 4, 206: 4, 207: 5, 215: 2, 217: 5, 218: 7, 220: 3, 221: 3, 222: 4, 224: 5, 227: 6, 229: 5, 234: 7, 235: 4, 241: 4, 242: 4, 243: 2, 244: 6, 245: 2, 248: 6, 250: 6, 258: 10, 262: 6, 263: 7, 264: 2, 267: 3, 270: 5, 272: 5, 273: 3, 287: 5, 289: 5, 291: 7, 299: 6, 300: 5, 304: 5, 309: 3, 314: 4, 315: 5, 320: 3, 323: 2, 327: 6, 328: 3, 329: 4, 330: 9, 334: 4, 335: 5, 341: 6, 342: 7, 347: 6, 348: 6, 350: 5, 351: 7, 352: 5, 353: 5, 354: 4, 358: 3, 365: 5, 366: 4, 369: 3, 371: 8, 372: 7, 376: 4, 384: 7, 385: 6, 386: 5, 387: 5, 392: 3, 393: 4, 396: 7, 397: 6, 398: 5, 402: 5} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 55 "Data-flows requiring DetNet service are generated and terminated on end-systems. Encapsulation depends on the application and its preferences. For example, in a DetNet MPLS domain the sub-layer functions use the d-CWs, S-Labels and F-Labels to provide DetNet services. However, an application may exchange further flow related parameters (e.g., time-stamp), which are not provided by DetNet functions." "Update based on the comments of ( 01.10 ) and ( 04.10 ) . I agree with , it 's a well - known and deployed example . I 'm not sure why it was removed . Cheers , comments have been resolved" 5627886f9da3fa5ecb5b7bcfceeb9ab7c3c19e9f 5627886f9da3fa5ecb5b7bcfceeb9ab7c3c19e9f draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework 5aa07ccd4fe1b59b4cdeb039171c2db94e91641a5c5054552543bd338566d2a3 ['5aa07ccd4fe1b59b4cdeb039171c2db94e91641a5c5054552543bd338566d2a3', '5f96858898baf084da1400010804dc3eb02f27b0726c6b31ba7c6065af6f3772', '685699140cefd1e1e66aa17dc3988b9e5199f0b20725eaff95c5fb402dd99ab1', '792b6cb16ba1a98b61881cf7634e377446c537dede9fcdd334103fb79c2e7dce', '22605ce31a47b84168adec6e3d14544cc40de016dde0b5b700ab7985db601845', 'cc53e673d6189fb03bd07364e033c8ad0195b7b2ca5c67b9555686b6466da06c', 'da829f4ffbc9e8fb80029b032811c1f7bebe7dd754e34e6f0c47da01bfd96e41', '0e41ec81b9f82db98d1cd35aa3b0765936fdeef25ac6fac5cccae550e3e2fb70', '1125615d9fac73e6f3135e67ed29fa750f6222195d89cdd592fbb345a99ba301', 'a6402401c31bbef50b804dc1d0bc35132bb6974c0b295c9ae1779371bc52776a'] B "data-flows requiring detnet service are generated and terminated on end-systems. encapsulation depends on the application and its preferences. for example, in a detnet mpls domain the sub-layer functions use the d-cws, s-labels and f-labels to provide detnet services. however, an application may exchange further flow related parameters (e.g., time-stamp), which are not provided by detnet functions." {90: 1, 8: 1, 31: 1, 6: 1, 79: 4, 51: 5, 130: 4, 62: 4, 85: 4, 68: 3, 35: 5, 110: 5, 91: 7, 114: 5, 97: 5, 13: 5, 67: 3, 38: 6, 26: 4, 124: 3, 98: 4, 54: 4, 127: 5, 96: 5, 64: 4, 30: 6, 61: 7, 27: 2, 15: 5, 52: 2, 55: 2, 129: 5, 115: 5, 84: 2, 76: 4, 87: 5, 131: 7, 102: 3, 113: 7, 99: 4, 36: 5, 24: 4, 53: 3, 72: 6} {9: 1, 132: 1, 184: 1, 161: 1, 1: 8, 4: 4, 10: 5, 15: 5, 24: 4, 25: 4, 26: 4, 27: 5, 39: 4, 43: 5, 49: 8, 50: 7, 58: 7, 59: 4, 64: 5, 69: 2, 81: 5, 82: 5, 86: 5, 96: 6, 97: 5, 100: 8, 108: 5, 109: 6, 110: 6, 111: 4, 114: 5, 115: 6, 116: 5, 118: 5, 119: 4, 120: 5, 121: 3, 122: 6, 123: 5, 124: 3, 128: 6, 129: 6, 130: 7, 136: 4, 147: 6, 151: 6, 152: 6, 154: 5, 156: 4, 162: 2, 165: 5, 168: 6, 169: 5, 172: 5, 180: 6, 187: 7, 188: 6, 191: 5, 194: 2, 202: 3, 203: 4, 206: 4, 207: 5, 215: 2, 217: 5, 218: 7, 220: 3, 221: 3, 222: 4, 224: 5, 227: 6, 229: 5, 234: 7, 235: 4, 241: 4, 242: 4, 243: 2, 244: 6, 245: 2, 248: 6, 250: 6, 258: 10, 262: 6, 263: 7, 264: 2, 267: 3, 270: 5, 272: 5, 273: 3, 287: 5, 289: 5, 291: 7, 299: 6, 300: 5, 304: 5, 309: 3, 314: 4, 315: 5, 320: 3, 323: 2, 327: 6, 328: 3, 329: 4, 330: 9, 334: 4, 335: 5, 341: 6, 342: 7, 347: 6, 348: 6, 350: 5, 351: 7, 352: 5, 353: 5, 354: 4, 358: 3, 365: 5, 366: 4, 369: 3, 371: 8, 372: 7, 376: 4, 384: 7, 385: 6, 386: 5, 387: 5, 392: 3, 393: 4, 396: 7, 397: 6, 398: 5, 402: 5} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 55 "As a general rule, DetNet domains are capable of forwarding any DetNet flows and the DetNet domain does not mandate the end-system or edge node encapsulation format. Unless there is a proxy of some form present, end-systems peer with similar end-systems using the same application encapsulation format. For example, as shown in fig_es_connect, IP applications peer with IP applications and Ethernet applications peer with Ethernet applications." "Update based on the comments of ( 01.10 ) and ( 04.10 ) . I agree with , it 's a well - known and deployed example . I 'm not sure why it was removed . Cheers , comments have been resolved" 5627886f9da3fa5ecb5b7bcfceeb9ab7c3c19e9f 5627886f9da3fa5ecb5b7bcfceeb9ab7c3c19e9f draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework 22605ce31a47b84168adec6e3d14544cc40de016dde0b5b700ab7985db601845 ['5aa07ccd4fe1b59b4cdeb039171c2db94e91641a5c5054552543bd338566d2a3', '5f96858898baf084da1400010804dc3eb02f27b0726c6b31ba7c6065af6f3772', '685699140cefd1e1e66aa17dc3988b9e5199f0b20725eaff95c5fb402dd99ab1', '792b6cb16ba1a98b61881cf7634e377446c537dede9fcdd334103fb79c2e7dce', '22605ce31a47b84168adec6e3d14544cc40de016dde0b5b700ab7985db601845', 'cc53e673d6189fb03bd07364e033c8ad0195b7b2ca5c67b9555686b6466da06c', 'da829f4ffbc9e8fb80029b032811c1f7bebe7dd754e34e6f0c47da01bfd96e41', '0e41ec81b9f82db98d1cd35aa3b0765936fdeef25ac6fac5cccae550e3e2fb70', '1125615d9fac73e6f3135e67ed29fa750f6222195d89cdd592fbb345a99ba301', 'a6402401c31bbef50b804dc1d0bc35132bb6974c0b295c9ae1779371bc52776a'] B "as a general rule, detnet domains are capable of forwarding any detnet flows and the detnet domain does not mandate the end-system or edge node encapsulation format. unless there is a proxy of some form present, end-systems peer with similar end-systems using the same application encapsulation format. for example, as shown in fig_es_connect, ip applications peer with ip applications and ethernet applications peer with ethernet applications." {90: 1, 8: 1, 31: 1, 6: 1, 79: 4, 51: 5, 130: 4, 62: 4, 85: 4, 68: 3, 35: 5, 110: 5, 91: 7, 114: 5, 97: 5, 13: 5, 67: 3, 38: 6, 26: 4, 124: 3, 98: 4, 54: 4, 127: 5, 96: 5, 64: 4, 30: 6, 61: 7, 27: 2, 15: 5, 52: 2, 55: 2, 129: 5, 115: 5, 84: 2, 76: 4, 87: 5, 131: 7, 102: 3, 113: 7, 99: 4, 36: 5, 24: 4, 53: 3, 72: 6} {9: 1, 132: 1, 184: 1, 161: 1, 1: 8, 4: 4, 10: 5, 15: 5, 24: 4, 25: 4, 26: 4, 27: 5, 39: 4, 43: 5, 49: 8, 50: 7, 58: 7, 59: 4, 64: 5, 69: 2, 81: 5, 82: 5, 86: 5, 96: 6, 97: 5, 100: 8, 108: 5, 109: 6, 110: 6, 111: 4, 114: 5, 115: 6, 116: 5, 118: 5, 119: 4, 120: 5, 121: 3, 122: 6, 123: 5, 124: 3, 128: 6, 129: 6, 130: 7, 136: 4, 147: 6, 151: 6, 152: 6, 154: 5, 156: 4, 162: 2, 165: 5, 168: 6, 169: 5, 172: 5, 180: 6, 187: 7, 188: 6, 191: 5, 194: 2, 202: 3, 203: 4, 206: 4, 207: 5, 215: 2, 217: 5, 218: 7, 220: 3, 221: 3, 222: 4, 224: 5, 227: 6, 229: 5, 234: 7, 235: 4, 241: 4, 242: 4, 243: 2, 244: 6, 245: 2, 248: 6, 250: 6, 258: 10, 262: 6, 263: 7, 264: 2, 267: 3, 270: 5, 272: 5, 273: 3, 287: 5, 289: 5, 291: 7, 299: 6, 300: 5, 304: 5, 309: 3, 314: 4, 315: 5, 320: 3, 323: 2, 327: 6, 328: 3, 329: 4, 330: 9, 334: 4, 335: 5, 341: 6, 342: 7, 347: 6, 348: 6, 350: 5, 351: 7, 352: 5, 353: 5, 354: 4, 358: 3, 365: 5, 366: 4, 369: 3, 371: 8, 372: 7, 376: 4, 384: 7, 385: 6, 386: 5, 387: 5, 392: 3, 393: 4, 396: 7, 397: 6, 398: 5, 402: 5} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 55 "Flow aggregation includes aggregation accomplished through the use of hierarchical LSPs in MPLS and tunnels, in the case of IP, MPLS and TSN, all of which aggregate multiple DetNet flows into a single new DetNet flow. Aggregation can also be grouping of IP flows that share 6-tuple attributes or flow identifiers at the DetNet sub-layer." "Update based on the comments of ( 01.10 ) and ( 04.10 ) . I agree with , it 's a well - known and deployed example . I 'm not sure why it was removed . Cheers , comments have been resolved" 5627886f9da3fa5ecb5b7bcfceeb9ab7c3c19e9f 5627886f9da3fa5ecb5b7bcfceeb9ab7c3c19e9f draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework 528e62e9c289fc29059a710d2040d609f4ca61c50bbae4e8ae492a0c9a7856bc ['1c95630d6db1dddba29a65af38e151fa80a5c2fa2789f81585f7f837742633d0', '528e62e9c289fc29059a710d2040d609f4ca61c50bbae4e8ae492a0c9a7856bc'] A "flow aggregation includes aggregation accomplished through the use of hierarchical lsps in mpls and tunnels, in the case of ip, mpls and tsn, all of which aggregate multiple detnet flows into a single new detnet flow. aggregation can also be grouping of ip flows that share 6-tuple attributes or flow identifiers at the detnet sub-layer." {84: 1} {36: 1} {35, 36} 55 "Flow aggregation means that multiple App-flows are served by a single new DetNet flow. There are many techniques to achieve aggregation, for example in case of IP, it can be grouping of IP flows that share 6-tuple attributes or flow identifiers at the DetNet sub-layer. Another example includes aggregation accomplished through the use of hierarchical LSPs in MPLS and tunnels." "Update based on the comments of ( 01.10 ) and ( 04.10 ) . I agree with , it 's a well - known and deployed example . I 'm not sure why it was removed . Cheers , comments have been resolved" 5627886f9da3fa5ecb5b7bcfceeb9ab7c3c19e9f 5627886f9da3fa5ecb5b7bcfceeb9ab7c3c19e9f draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework 1c95630d6db1dddba29a65af38e151fa80a5c2fa2789f81585f7f837742633d0 ['1c95630d6db1dddba29a65af38e151fa80a5c2fa2789f81585f7f837742633d0', '528e62e9c289fc29059a710d2040d609f4ca61c50bbae4e8ae492a0c9a7856bc'] B "flow aggregation means that multiple app-flows are served by a single new detnet flow. there are many techniques to achieve aggregation, for example in case of ip, it can be grouping of ip flows that share 6-tuple attributes or flow identifiers at the detnet sub-layer. another example includes aggregation accomplished through the use of hierarchical lsps in mpls and tunnels." {84: 1} {36: 1} {35, 36} 55 "Depending on the specific technology the assigned resources are updated and distributed in the databases preventing over subscription." "Update based on the comments of ( 01.10 ) and ( 04.10 ) . I agree with , it 's a well - known and deployed example . I 'm not sure why it was removed . Cheers , comments have been resolved" 5627886f9da3fa5ecb5b7bcfceeb9ab7c3c19e9f 5627886f9da3fa5ecb5b7bcfceeb9ab7c3c19e9f draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework d564daf1a9dc26ca896eedca786a6bfca02e9b99ddc05e4dcb39eb9cecde2400 ['d564daf1a9dc26ca896eedca786a6bfca02e9b99ddc05e4dcb39eb9cecde2400', '42f92618bb4160ed7c9a96ada9903c6200a948d98a3908a2de5ae9f2db49e1c4'] A "depending on the specific technology the assigned resources are updated and distributed in the databases preventing over subscription." {8: 1, 90: 5, 6: 2, 84: 2, 31: 4} {226: 1, 101: 5, 360: 2, 409: 2, 107: 4, 138: 3, 211: 4, 89: 3} {226, 101, 360, 409, 107, 138, 338, 211, 89} 55 "Depending on the specific technology, the assigned resources are updated and distributed in the databases, preventing over- subscription." "Update based on the comments of ( 01.10 ) and ( 04.10 ) . I agree with , it 's a well - known and deployed example . I 'm not sure why it was removed . Cheers , comments have been resolved" 5627886f9da3fa5ecb5b7bcfceeb9ab7c3c19e9f 5627886f9da3fa5ecb5b7bcfceeb9ab7c3c19e9f draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework 42f92618bb4160ed7c9a96ada9903c6200a948d98a3908a2de5ae9f2db49e1c4 ['d564daf1a9dc26ca896eedca786a6bfca02e9b99ddc05e4dcb39eb9cecde2400', '42f92618bb4160ed7c9a96ada9903c6200a948d98a3908a2de5ae9f2db49e1c4'] B "depending on the specific technology, the assigned resources are updated and distributed in the databases, preventing over- subscription." {8: 1, 90: 5, 6: 2, 84: 2, 31: 4} {226: 1, 101: 5, 360: 2, 409: 2, 107: 4, 138: 3, 211: 4, 89: 3} {226, 101, 360, 409, 107, 138, 338, 211, 89} 55 "DetNet's use of PREOF may increase the complexity of using co-routing bidirectional flows, since if PREOF is used, then the replication points in one direction would have to match the elimination points in the other direction, and vice versa, and the optimal points for these functions in one direction may not match the optimal points in the other subsequent to the network and traffic constraints. Furthermore, due to the per packet service protection nature, bidirectional forwarding per packet may not be ensured. The first packet of received member flows is selected by the elimination function independently of which path it has taken through the network." "Update based on the comments of ( 01.10 ) and ( 04.10 ) . I agree with , it 's a well - known and deployed example . I 'm not sure why it was removed . Cheers , comments have been resolved" 5627886f9da3fa5ecb5b7bcfceeb9ab7c3c19e9f 5627886f9da3fa5ecb5b7bcfceeb9ab7c3c19e9f draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework 0a4a7357752df2d665a99e86be13cf06a534521e6d9325850e17f52732bfbb86 ['0a4a7357752df2d665a99e86be13cf06a534521e6d9325850e17f52732bfbb86', 'dce3a321dca424b041083a9fe6bde15774660e3e4a5bfaa32e74b227d2296374'] A "detnet's use of preof may increase the complexity of using co-routing bidirectional flows, since if preof is used, then the replication points in one direction would have to match the elimination points in the other direction, and vice versa, and the optimal points for these functions in one direction may not match the optimal points in the other subsequent to the network and traffic constraints. furthermore, due to the per packet service protection nature, bidirectional forwarding per packet may not be ensured. the first packet of received member flows is selected by the elimination function independently of which path it has taken through the network." {} {} {} 55 "DetNet's use of PREOF may increase the complexity of using co-routing bidirectional flows, since if PREOF is used, then the replication points in one direction would have to match the elimination points in the other direction, and vice versa. In such cases the optimal points for these functions in one direction may not match the optimal points in the other, due to network and traffic constraints. Furthermore, due to the per packet service protection nature, bidirectional forwarding per packet may not be ensured. The first packet of received member flows is selected by the elimination function independently of which path it has taken through the network." "Update based on the comments of ( 01.10 ) and ( 04.10 ) . I agree with , it 's a well - known and deployed example . I 'm not sure why it was removed . Cheers , comments have been resolved" 5627886f9da3fa5ecb5b7bcfceeb9ab7c3c19e9f 5627886f9da3fa5ecb5b7bcfceeb9ab7c3c19e9f draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework dce3a321dca424b041083a9fe6bde15774660e3e4a5bfaa32e74b227d2296374 ['0a4a7357752df2d665a99e86be13cf06a534521e6d9325850e17f52732bfbb86', 'dce3a321dca424b041083a9fe6bde15774660e3e4a5bfaa32e74b227d2296374'] B "detnet's use of preof may increase the complexity of using co-routing bidirectional flows, since if preof is used, then the replication points in one direction would have to match the elimination points in the other direction, and vice versa. in such cases the optimal points for these functions in one direction may not match the optimal points in the other, due to network and traffic constraints. furthermore, due to the per packet service protection nature, bidirectional forwarding per packet may not be ensured. the first packet of received member flows is selected by the elimination function independently of which path it has taken through the network." {} {} {} 55 "From a data plane perspective DetNet does not add or modify any header information." "Update based on the comments of ( 01.10 ) and ( 04.10 ) . I agree with , it 's a well - known and deployed example . I 'm not sure why it was removed . Cheers , comments have been resolved" 5627886f9da3fa5ecb5b7bcfceeb9ab7c3c19e9f 5627886f9da3fa5ecb5b7bcfceeb9ab7c3c19e9f draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework 9cb842c44fa1a73e9f8fa83d2dbb79cd69a96453e2eeae44ddafa6d03de3a18c ['9cb842c44fa1a73e9f8fa83d2dbb79cd69a96453e2eeae44ddafa6d03de3a18c'] A "from a data plane perspective detnet does not add or modify any header information." {} {} {} 55 "In order to prevent or mitigate DetNet attacks on other networks via flow escape, edge devices can for example use existing mechanism such as policing and shaping applied at the output of a DetNet domain." "Update based on the comments of ( 01.10 ) and ( 04.10 ) . I agree with , it 's a well - known and deployed example . I 'm not sure why it was removed . Cheers , comments have been resolved" 5627886f9da3fa5ecb5b7bcfceeb9ab7c3c19e9f 5627886f9da3fa5ecb5b7bcfceeb9ab7c3c19e9f draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework 172ec48ea5a7c6d4c8cda4bcd562504d8b9fcc567c9a8a9fdf0baec055463192 ['172ec48ea5a7c6d4c8cda4bcd562504d8b9fcc567c9a8a9fdf0baec055463192'] B "in order to prevent or mitigate detnet attacks on other networks via flow escape, edge devices can for example use existing mechanism such as policing and shaping applied at the output of a detnet domain." {} {} {} 54 "fig_tsn_mpls_detnet shows IEEE 802.1 TSN end stations operating over a TSN aware DetNet service running over an MPLS network. DetNet Edge Nodes sit at the boundary of a DetNet domain. They are responsible for mapping non-DetNet aware L2 traffic to DetNet services. They also support the imposition and disposition of the required DetNet encapsulation. These are functionally similar to pseudowire (PW) Terminating Provider Edge (T-PE) nodes which use MPLS-TE LSPs. In this example they understand and support IEEE 802.1 TSN and are able to map TSN Streams into DetNet flows. The specific of this operation are discussed later in this document." Work In progress - Wanted to get the figure changes out for review . Need to check if the overly wording is complete . There was a lot of inter working text - I have commented out . 09628b87523cba93ddd8631311103af6546c1a62 09628b87523cba93ddd8631311103af6546c1a62 draft-ietf-detnet-tsn-vpn-over-mpls d09f9c27ee143aea9bbf83458b7d4d3cc08075045d4c1703ac51ec8b761e9ab4 ['d09f9c27ee143aea9bbf83458b7d4d3cc08075045d4c1703ac51ec8b761e9ab4', '75db9ae91b710fcf1df3553b8f9653b12d014f74ba1ee8f931870d2433e163f1', '968c42859199601f49429a3aac2a234d6ab939968be28ec4112b7ba034b2d747', '09c22b9cb6ea58d24a88447212820f97b834b01b3d99ac5f5393fc662cf817be'] A "fig_tsn_mpls_detnet shows ieee 802.1 tsn end stations operating over a tsn aware detnet service running over an mpls network. detnet edge nodes sit at the boundary of a detnet domain. they are responsible for mapping non-detnet aware l2 traffic to detnet services. they also support the imposition and disposition of the required detnet encapsulation. these are functionally similar to pseudowire (pw) terminating provider edge (t-pe) nodes which use mpls-te lsps. in this example they understand and support ieee 802.1 tsn and are able to map tsn streams into detnet flows. the specific of this operation are discussed later in this document." {98: 1, 53: 1, 6: 2, 79: 2, 90: 3, 51: 3, 130: 2, 62: 5, 85: 5, 68: 4, 35: 3, 110: 3, 91: 5, 114: 3, 97: 3, 31: 3, 13: 3, 67: 3, 38: 4, 26: 3, 124: 3, 54: 2, 127: 3, 8: 2, 96: 3, 64: 2, 30: 4, 61: 5, 55: 3, 27: 4, 15: 3, 52: 2, 129: 3, 115: 3, 84: 3, 76: 6, 87: 3, 131: 5, 102: 3, 113: 5, 99: 2, 36: 3, 24: 2, 72: 4} {217: 1, 369: 1, 1: 9, 4: 2, 9: 5, 10: 3, 15: 3, 24: 2, 25: 5, 26: 5, 27: 3, 39: 5, 43: 3, 49: 6, 50: 5, 58: 5, 59: 2, 64: 3, 69: 4, 81: 6, 82: 4, 86: 3, 96: 4, 97: 3, 100: 7, 108: 3, 109: 4, 110: 4, 111: 2, 114: 3, 115: 4, 116: 3, 118: 6, 119: 5, 120: 3, 121: 4, 122: 4, 123: 3, 124: 4, 128: 4, 129: 4, 130: 5, 132: 4, 136: 2, 145: 4, 147: 4, 151: 4, 152: 4, 154: 3, 156: 2, 161: 3, 162: 3, 165: 3, 168: 4, 169: 3, 172: 3, 180: 4, 184: 5, 187: 5, 188: 4, 191: 3, 194: 4, 202: 5, 203: 6, 206: 2, 207: 3, 215: 2, 218: 8, 220: 2, 221: 2, 222: 5, 224: 3, 227: 5, 229: 3, 234: 5, 235: 2, 241: 2, 242: 2, 243: 4, 244: 4, 245: 4, 248: 4, 250: 4, 258: 11, 262: 4, 263: 5, 264: 3, 267: 4, 270: 3, 272: 3, 273: 5, 287: 3, 289: 3, 291: 5, 299: 5, 300: 3, 304: 3, 309: 3, 314: 2, 315: 3, 320: 4, 323: 4, 327: 4, 328: 3, 330: 10, 334: 2, 335: 3, 341: 5, 342: 6, 347: 5, 348: 5, 350: 7, 351: 5, 352: 3, 353: 3, 354: 2, 358: 4, 365: 3, 366: 2, 371: 7, 372: 5, 376: 2, 384: 5, 385: 4, 386: 3, 387: 3, 392: 3, 393: 4, 396: 6, 397: 7, 398: 6, 402: 3} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 54 "In this example, edge nodes provide a service proxy function that ""associates"" the DetNet flows and native flows (i.e., TSN Streams) at the edge of the DetNet domain. This ensures that the DN Flow is properly served at the Edge node (and inside the domain)." Work In progress - Wanted to get the figure changes out for review . Need to check if the overly wording is complete . There was a lot of inter working text - I have commented out . 09628b87523cba93ddd8631311103af6546c1a62 09628b87523cba93ddd8631311103af6546c1a62 draft-ietf-detnet-tsn-vpn-over-mpls 75db9ae91b710fcf1df3553b8f9653b12d014f74ba1ee8f931870d2433e163f1 ['d09f9c27ee143aea9bbf83458b7d4d3cc08075045d4c1703ac51ec8b761e9ab4', '75db9ae91b710fcf1df3553b8f9653b12d014f74ba1ee8f931870d2433e163f1', '968c42859199601f49429a3aac2a234d6ab939968be28ec4112b7ba034b2d747', '09c22b9cb6ea58d24a88447212820f97b834b01b3d99ac5f5393fc662cf817be'] A "in this example, edge nodes provide a service proxy function that ""associates"" the detnet flows and native flows (i.e., tsn streams) at the edge of the detnet domain. this ensures that the dn flow is properly served at the edge node (and inside the domain)." {98: 1, 53: 1, 6: 2, 79: 2, 90: 3, 51: 3, 130: 2, 62: 5, 85: 5, 68: 4, 35: 3, 110: 3, 91: 5, 114: 3, 97: 3, 31: 3, 13: 3, 67: 3, 38: 4, 26: 3, 124: 3, 54: 2, 127: 3, 8: 2, 96: 3, 64: 2, 30: 4, 61: 5, 55: 3, 27: 4, 15: 3, 52: 2, 129: 3, 115: 3, 84: 3, 76: 6, 87: 3, 131: 5, 102: 3, 113: 5, 99: 2, 36: 3, 24: 2, 72: 4} {217: 1, 369: 1, 1: 9, 4: 2, 9: 5, 10: 3, 15: 3, 24: 2, 25: 5, 26: 5, 27: 3, 39: 5, 43: 3, 49: 6, 50: 5, 58: 5, 59: 2, 64: 3, 69: 4, 81: 6, 82: 4, 86: 3, 96: 4, 97: 3, 100: 7, 108: 3, 109: 4, 110: 4, 111: 2, 114: 3, 115: 4, 116: 3, 118: 6, 119: 5, 120: 3, 121: 4, 122: 4, 123: 3, 124: 4, 128: 4, 129: 4, 130: 5, 132: 4, 136: 2, 145: 4, 147: 4, 151: 4, 152: 4, 154: 3, 156: 2, 161: 3, 162: 3, 165: 3, 168: 4, 169: 3, 172: 3, 180: 4, 184: 5, 187: 5, 188: 4, 191: 3, 194: 4, 202: 5, 203: 6, 206: 2, 207: 3, 215: 2, 218: 8, 220: 2, 221: 2, 222: 5, 224: 3, 227: 5, 229: 3, 234: 5, 235: 2, 241: 2, 242: 2, 243: 4, 244: 4, 245: 4, 248: 4, 250: 4, 258: 11, 262: 4, 263: 5, 264: 3, 267: 4, 270: 3, 272: 3, 273: 5, 287: 3, 289: 3, 291: 5, 299: 5, 300: 3, 304: 3, 309: 3, 314: 2, 315: 3, 320: 4, 323: 4, 327: 4, 328: 3, 330: 10, 334: 2, 335: 3, 341: 5, 342: 6, 347: 5, 348: 5, 350: 7, 351: 5, 352: 3, 353: 3, 354: 2, 358: 4, 365: 3, 366: 2, 371: 7, 372: 5, 376: 2, 384: 5, 385: 4, 386: 3, 387: 3, 392: 3, 393: 4, 396: 6, 397: 7, 398: 6, 402: 3} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 54 "fig_tsn_mpls_detnet shows IEEE 802.1 TSN end stations operating over a TSN aware DetNet service running over an MPLS network. DetNet Edge Nodes sit at the boundary of a DetNet domain. They are responsible for mapping non-DetNet aware L2 traffic to DetNet services. They also support the imposition and disposition of the required DetNet encapsulation. These are functionally similar to pseudowire (PW) Terminating Provider Edge (T-PE) nodes which use MPLS-TE LSPs. In this example TSN Streams are simple applicaions over DetNet flows. The specific of this operation are discussed later in this document." Work In progress - Wanted to get the figure changes out for review . Need to check if the overly wording is complete . There was a lot of inter working text - I have commented out . 09628b87523cba93ddd8631311103af6546c1a62 09628b87523cba93ddd8631311103af6546c1a62 draft-ietf-detnet-tsn-vpn-over-mpls 09c22b9cb6ea58d24a88447212820f97b834b01b3d99ac5f5393fc662cf817be ['d09f9c27ee143aea9bbf83458b7d4d3cc08075045d4c1703ac51ec8b761e9ab4', '75db9ae91b710fcf1df3553b8f9653b12d014f74ba1ee8f931870d2433e163f1', '968c42859199601f49429a3aac2a234d6ab939968be28ec4112b7ba034b2d747', '09c22b9cb6ea58d24a88447212820f97b834b01b3d99ac5f5393fc662cf817be'] B "fig_tsn_mpls_detnet shows ieee 802.1 tsn end stations operating over a tsn aware detnet service running over an mpls network. detnet edge nodes sit at the boundary of a detnet domain. they are responsible for mapping non-detnet aware l2 traffic to detnet services. they also support the imposition and disposition of the required detnet encapsulation. these are functionally similar to pseudowire (pw) terminating provider edge (t-pe) nodes which use mpls-te lsps. in this example tsn streams are simple applicaions over detnet flows. the specific of this operation are discussed later in this document." {98: 1, 53: 1, 6: 2, 79: 2, 90: 3, 51: 3, 130: 2, 62: 5, 85: 5, 68: 4, 35: 3, 110: 3, 91: 5, 114: 3, 97: 3, 31: 3, 13: 3, 67: 3, 38: 4, 26: 3, 124: 3, 54: 2, 127: 3, 8: 2, 96: 3, 64: 2, 30: 4, 61: 5, 55: 3, 27: 4, 15: 3, 52: 2, 129: 3, 115: 3, 84: 3, 76: 6, 87: 3, 131: 5, 102: 3, 113: 5, 99: 2, 36: 3, 24: 2, 72: 4} {217: 1, 369: 1, 1: 9, 4: 2, 9: 5, 10: 3, 15: 3, 24: 2, 25: 5, 26: 5, 27: 3, 39: 5, 43: 3, 49: 6, 50: 5, 58: 5, 59: 2, 64: 3, 69: 4, 81: 6, 82: 4, 86: 3, 96: 4, 97: 3, 100: 7, 108: 3, 109: 4, 110: 4, 111: 2, 114: 3, 115: 4, 116: 3, 118: 6, 119: 5, 120: 3, 121: 4, 122: 4, 123: 3, 124: 4, 128: 4, 129: 4, 130: 5, 132: 4, 136: 2, 145: 4, 147: 4, 151: 4, 152: 4, 154: 3, 156: 2, 161: 3, 162: 3, 165: 3, 168: 4, 169: 3, 172: 3, 180: 4, 184: 5, 187: 5, 188: 4, 191: 3, 194: 4, 202: 5, 203: 6, 206: 2, 207: 3, 215: 2, 218: 8, 220: 2, 221: 2, 222: 5, 224: 3, 227: 5, 229: 3, 234: 5, 235: 2, 241: 2, 242: 2, 243: 4, 244: 4, 245: 4, 248: 4, 250: 4, 258: 11, 262: 4, 263: 5, 264: 3, 267: 4, 270: 3, 272: 3, 273: 5, 287: 3, 289: 3, 291: 5, 299: 5, 300: 3, 304: 3, 309: 3, 314: 2, 315: 3, 320: 4, 323: 4, 327: 4, 328: 3, 330: 10, 334: 2, 335: 3, 341: 5, 342: 6, 347: 5, 348: 5, 350: 7, 351: 5, 352: 3, 353: 3, 354: 2, 358: 4, 365: 3, 366: 2, 371: 7, 372: 5, 376: 2, 384: 5, 385: 4, 386: 3, 387: 3, 392: 3, 393: 4, 396: 6, 397: 7, 398: 6, 402: 3} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 54 "In this example, edge nodes provide a service proxy function that ""associates"" the DetNet flows and native flows (i.e., TSN Streams) at the edge of the DetNet domain. TSN streams are treated as App-flows for DetNet. The whole DetNet domain behaves as a TSN relay node for the TSN streams. The service proxy behaves as a port of that TSN relay node." Work In progress - Wanted to get the figure changes out for review . Need to check if the overly wording is complete . There was a lot of inter working text - I have commented out . 09628b87523cba93ddd8631311103af6546c1a62 09628b87523cba93ddd8631311103af6546c1a62 draft-ietf-detnet-tsn-vpn-over-mpls 968c42859199601f49429a3aac2a234d6ab939968be28ec4112b7ba034b2d747 ['d09f9c27ee143aea9bbf83458b7d4d3cc08075045d4c1703ac51ec8b761e9ab4', '75db9ae91b710fcf1df3553b8f9653b12d014f74ba1ee8f931870d2433e163f1', '968c42859199601f49429a3aac2a234d6ab939968be28ec4112b7ba034b2d747', '09c22b9cb6ea58d24a88447212820f97b834b01b3d99ac5f5393fc662cf817be'] B "in this example, edge nodes provide a service proxy function that ""associates"" the detnet flows and native flows (i.e., tsn streams) at the edge of the detnet domain. tsn streams are treated as app-flows for detnet. the whole detnet domain behaves as a tsn relay node for the tsn streams. the service proxy behaves as a port of that tsn relay node." {98: 1, 53: 1, 6: 2, 79: 2, 90: 3, 51: 3, 130: 2, 62: 5, 85: 5, 68: 4, 35: 3, 110: 3, 91: 5, 114: 3, 97: 3, 31: 3, 13: 3, 67: 3, 38: 4, 26: 3, 124: 3, 54: 2, 127: 3, 8: 2, 96: 3, 64: 2, 30: 4, 61: 5, 55: 3, 27: 4, 15: 3, 52: 2, 129: 3, 115: 3, 84: 3, 76: 6, 87: 3, 131: 5, 102: 3, 113: 5, 99: 2, 36: 3, 24: 2, 72: 4} {217: 1, 369: 1, 1: 9, 4: 2, 9: 5, 10: 3, 15: 3, 24: 2, 25: 5, 26: 5, 27: 3, 39: 5, 43: 3, 49: 6, 50: 5, 58: 5, 59: 2, 64: 3, 69: 4, 81: 6, 82: 4, 86: 3, 96: 4, 97: 3, 100: 7, 108: 3, 109: 4, 110: 4, 111: 2, 114: 3, 115: 4, 116: 3, 118: 6, 119: 5, 120: 3, 121: 4, 122: 4, 123: 3, 124: 4, 128: 4, 129: 4, 130: 5, 132: 4, 136: 2, 145: 4, 147: 4, 151: 4, 152: 4, 154: 3, 156: 2, 161: 3, 162: 3, 165: 3, 168: 4, 169: 3, 172: 3, 180: 4, 184: 5, 187: 5, 188: 4, 191: 3, 194: 4, 202: 5, 203: 6, 206: 2, 207: 3, 215: 2, 218: 8, 220: 2, 221: 2, 222: 5, 224: 3, 227: 5, 229: 3, 234: 5, 235: 2, 241: 2, 242: 2, 243: 4, 244: 4, 245: 4, 248: 4, 250: 4, 258: 11, 262: 4, 263: 5, 264: 3, 267: 4, 270: 3, 272: 3, 273: 5, 287: 3, 289: 3, 291: 5, 299: 5, 300: 3, 304: 3, 309: 3, 314: 2, 315: 3, 320: 4, 323: 4, 327: 4, 328: 3, 330: 10, 334: 2, 335: 3, 341: 5, 342: 6, 347: 5, 348: 5, 350: 7, 351: 5, 352: 3, 353: 3, 354: 2, 358: 4, 365: 3, 366: 2, 371: 7, 372: 5, 376: 2, 384: 5, 385: 4, 386: 3, 387: 3, 392: 3, 393: 4, 396: 6, 397: 7, 398: 6, 402: 3} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 54 "The Service Proxy function maps between App-flows and DetNet flows. It MUST support the TSN Stream identification functions and the related managed objects as defined in IEEE8021CB and IEEEP8021CBdb to recognize the App-flow related packets." Work In progress - Wanted to get the figure changes out for review . Need to check if the overly wording is complete . There was a lot of inter working text - I have commented out . 09628b87523cba93ddd8631311103af6546c1a62 09628b87523cba93ddd8631311103af6546c1a62 draft-ietf-detnet-tsn-vpn-over-mpls 1920ebb46d0cee2d379ef48c15f8f6abd01e2a183f316da235e0c3b7515feade ['9c009028e84c6286cfbda36b79b477778368ff8c256a81d8396d8b9e04f3096c', '1920ebb46d0cee2d379ef48c15f8f6abd01e2a183f316da235e0c3b7515feade', '249c961ea29438959ea2204728df24964ec80b8cd91c657715c47014f5e5a462', '0882426f04ffe7d1fb83d25c8b8c589112e7bfc884827f292935052160a05cb7'] A "the service proxy function maps between app-flows and detnet flows. it must support the tsn stream identification functions and the related managed objects as defined in ieee8021cb and ieeep8021cbdb to recognize the app-flow related packets." {79: 1, 53: 1, 6: 2, 90: 3, 51: 3, 130: 2, 62: 5, 85: 5, 68: 4, 35: 3, 110: 3, 91: 5, 114: 3, 97: 3, 31: 3, 13: 3, 67: 3, 38: 4, 26: 3, 124: 3, 98: 2, 54: 2, 127: 3, 8: 2, 96: 3, 64: 2, 30: 4, 61: 5, 55: 3, 27: 4, 15: 3, 52: 2, 129: 3, 115: 3, 84: 3, 76: 6, 87: 3, 131: 5, 102: 3, 113: 5, 99: 2, 36: 3, 24: 2, 72: 4} {10: 1, 369: 1, 1: 9, 4: 2, 9: 5, 15: 3, 24: 2, 25: 5, 26: 5, 27: 3, 39: 5, 43: 3, 49: 6, 50: 5, 58: 5, 59: 2, 64: 3, 69: 4, 81: 6, 82: 4, 86: 3, 96: 4, 97: 3, 100: 7, 108: 3, 109: 4, 110: 4, 111: 2, 114: 3, 115: 4, 116: 3, 118: 6, 119: 5, 120: 3, 121: 4, 122: 4, 123: 3, 124: 4, 128: 4, 129: 4, 130: 5, 132: 4, 136: 2, 145: 4, 147: 4, 151: 4, 152: 4, 154: 3, 156: 2, 161: 3, 162: 3, 165: 3, 168: 4, 169: 3, 172: 3, 180: 4, 184: 5, 187: 5, 188: 4, 191: 3, 194: 4, 202: 5, 203: 6, 206: 2, 207: 3, 215: 2, 217: 3, 218: 8, 220: 2, 221: 2, 222: 5, 224: 3, 227: 5, 229: 3, 234: 5, 235: 2, 241: 2, 243: 4, 244: 4, 245: 4, 248: 4, 250: 4, 258: 11, 262: 4, 263: 5, 264: 3, 267: 4, 270: 3, 272: 3, 273: 5, 287: 3, 289: 3, 291: 5, 299: 5, 300: 3, 304: 3, 309: 3, 314: 2, 315: 3, 320: 4, 323: 4, 327: 2, 328: 3, 329: 2, 330: 10, 334: 2, 335: 3, 341: 5, 342: 6, 347: 5, 348: 5, 350: 7, 351: 5, 352: 3, 353: 3, 354: 2, 358: 4, 365: 3, 366: 2, 371: 7, 372: 5, 376: 2, 384: 5, 385: 4, 386: 3, 387: 3, 392: 3, 393: 4, 396: 6, 397: 7, 398: 6, 402: 3} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 54 "Implementations of this document SHALL use management and control information to map a TSN Stream to a DetNet flow. N:1 mapping (aggregating TSN Streams in a single DetNet flow) SHALL be supported. The management or control function that provisions flow mapping SHALL ensure that adequate resources are allocated and configured to provide proper service requirements of the mapped flows." Work In progress - Wanted to get the figure changes out for review . Need to check if the overly wording is complete . There was a lot of inter working text - I have commented out . 09628b87523cba93ddd8631311103af6546c1a62 09628b87523cba93ddd8631311103af6546c1a62 draft-ietf-detnet-tsn-vpn-over-mpls 249c961ea29438959ea2204728df24964ec80b8cd91c657715c47014f5e5a462 ['9c009028e84c6286cfbda36b79b477778368ff8c256a81d8396d8b9e04f3096c', '1920ebb46d0cee2d379ef48c15f8f6abd01e2a183f316da235e0c3b7515feade', '249c961ea29438959ea2204728df24964ec80b8cd91c657715c47014f5e5a462', '0882426f04ffe7d1fb83d25c8b8c589112e7bfc884827f292935052160a05cb7'] A "implementations of this document shall use management and control information to map a tsn stream to a detnet flow. n:1 mapping (aggregating tsn streams in a single detnet flow) shall be supported. the management or control function that provisions flow mapping shall ensure that adequate resources are allocated and configured to provide proper service requirements of the mapped flows." {79: 1, 53: 1, 6: 2, 90: 3, 51: 3, 130: 2, 62: 5, 85: 5, 68: 4, 35: 3, 110: 3, 91: 5, 114: 3, 97: 3, 31: 3, 13: 3, 67: 3, 38: 4, 26: 3, 124: 3, 98: 2, 54: 2, 127: 3, 8: 2, 96: 3, 64: 2, 30: 4, 61: 5, 55: 3, 27: 4, 15: 3, 52: 2, 129: 3, 115: 3, 84: 3, 76: 6, 87: 3, 131: 5, 102: 3, 113: 5, 99: 2, 36: 3, 24: 2, 72: 4} {10: 1, 369: 1, 1: 9, 4: 2, 9: 5, 15: 3, 24: 2, 25: 5, 26: 5, 27: 3, 39: 5, 43: 3, 49: 6, 50: 5, 58: 5, 59: 2, 64: 3, 69: 4, 81: 6, 82: 4, 86: 3, 96: 4, 97: 3, 100: 7, 108: 3, 109: 4, 110: 4, 111: 2, 114: 3, 115: 4, 116: 3, 118: 6, 119: 5, 120: 3, 121: 4, 122: 4, 123: 3, 124: 4, 128: 4, 129: 4, 130: 5, 132: 4, 136: 2, 145: 4, 147: 4, 151: 4, 152: 4, 154: 3, 156: 2, 161: 3, 162: 3, 165: 3, 168: 4, 169: 3, 172: 3, 180: 4, 184: 5, 187: 5, 188: 4, 191: 3, 194: 4, 202: 5, 203: 6, 206: 2, 207: 3, 215: 2, 217: 3, 218: 8, 220: 2, 221: 2, 222: 5, 224: 3, 227: 5, 229: 3, 234: 5, 235: 2, 241: 2, 243: 4, 244: 4, 245: 4, 248: 4, 250: 4, 258: 11, 262: 4, 263: 5, 264: 3, 267: 4, 270: 3, 272: 3, 273: 5, 287: 3, 289: 3, 291: 5, 299: 5, 300: 3, 304: 3, 309: 3, 314: 2, 315: 3, 320: 4, 323: 4, 327: 2, 328: 3, 329: 2, 330: 10, 334: 2, 335: 3, 341: 5, 342: 6, 347: 5, 348: 5, 350: 7, 351: 5, 352: 3, 353: 3, 354: 2, 358: 4, 365: 3, 366: 2, 371: 7, 372: 5, 376: 2, 384: 5, 385: 4, 386: 3, 387: 3, 392: 3, 393: 4, 396: 6, 397: 7, 398: 6, 402: 3} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 54 "The Service Proxy function maps between App-flows and DetNet flows. The DetNet Edge Node TSN function MUST support the TSN Stream identification functions and the related managed objects as defined in IEEE8021CB and IEEEP8021CBdb to recognize the App-flow related packets. The Service Proxy presents TSN Streams as an App-flow to a DetNet Flow." Work In progress - Wanted to get the figure changes out for review . Need to check if the overly wording is complete . There was a lot of inter working text - I have commented out . 09628b87523cba93ddd8631311103af6546c1a62 09628b87523cba93ddd8631311103af6546c1a62 draft-ietf-detnet-tsn-vpn-over-mpls 0882426f04ffe7d1fb83d25c8b8c589112e7bfc884827f292935052160a05cb7 ['9c009028e84c6286cfbda36b79b477778368ff8c256a81d8396d8b9e04f3096c', '1920ebb46d0cee2d379ef48c15f8f6abd01e2a183f316da235e0c3b7515feade', '249c961ea29438959ea2204728df24964ec80b8cd91c657715c47014f5e5a462', '0882426f04ffe7d1fb83d25c8b8c589112e7bfc884827f292935052160a05cb7'] B "the service proxy function maps between app-flows and detnet flows. the detnet edge node tsn function must support the tsn stream identification functions and the related managed objects as defined in ieee8021cb and ieeep8021cbdb to recognize the app-flow related packets. the service proxy presents tsn streams as an app-flow to a detnet flow." {79: 1, 53: 1, 6: 2, 90: 3, 51: 3, 130: 2, 62: 5, 85: 5, 68: 4, 35: 3, 110: 3, 91: 5, 114: 3, 97: 3, 31: 3, 13: 3, 67: 3, 38: 4, 26: 3, 124: 3, 98: 2, 54: 2, 127: 3, 8: 2, 96: 3, 64: 2, 30: 4, 61: 5, 55: 3, 27: 4, 15: 3, 52: 2, 129: 3, 115: 3, 84: 3, 76: 6, 87: 3, 131: 5, 102: 3, 113: 5, 99: 2, 36: 3, 24: 2, 72: 4} {10: 1, 369: 1, 1: 9, 4: 2, 9: 5, 15: 3, 24: 2, 25: 5, 26: 5, 27: 3, 39: 5, 43: 3, 49: 6, 50: 5, 58: 5, 59: 2, 64: 3, 69: 4, 81: 6, 82: 4, 86: 3, 96: 4, 97: 3, 100: 7, 108: 3, 109: 4, 110: 4, 111: 2, 114: 3, 115: 4, 116: 3, 118: 6, 119: 5, 120: 3, 121: 4, 122: 4, 123: 3, 124: 4, 128: 4, 129: 4, 130: 5, 132: 4, 136: 2, 145: 4, 147: 4, 151: 4, 152: 4, 154: 3, 156: 2, 161: 3, 162: 3, 165: 3, 168: 4, 169: 3, 172: 3, 180: 4, 184: 5, 187: 5, 188: 4, 191: 3, 194: 4, 202: 5, 203: 6, 206: 2, 207: 3, 215: 2, 217: 3, 218: 8, 220: 2, 221: 2, 222: 5, 224: 3, 227: 5, 229: 3, 234: 5, 235: 2, 241: 2, 243: 4, 244: 4, 245: 4, 248: 4, 250: 4, 258: 11, 262: 4, 263: 5, 264: 3, 267: 4, 270: 3, 272: 3, 273: 5, 287: 3, 289: 3, 291: 5, 299: 5, 300: 3, 304: 3, 309: 3, 314: 2, 315: 3, 320: 4, 323: 4, 327: 2, 328: 3, 329: 2, 330: 10, 334: 2, 335: 3, 341: 5, 342: 6, 347: 5, 348: 5, 350: 7, 351: 5, 352: 3, 353: 3, 354: 2, 358: 4, 365: 3, 366: 2, 371: 7, 372: 5, 376: 2, 384: 5, 385: 4, 386: 3, 387: 3, 392: 3, 393: 4, 396: 6, 397: 7, 398: 6, 402: 3} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 54 "Implementations of this document SHALL use management and control information to map a TSN Stream to a DetNet flow. N:1 mapping (aggregating multiple TSN Streams in a single DetNet flow) SHALL be supported. The management or control function that provisions flow mapping SHALL ensure that adequate resources are allocated and configured to provide proper service requirements of the mapped flows." Work In progress - Wanted to get the figure changes out for review . Need to check if the overly wording is complete . There was a lot of inter working text - I have commented out . 09628b87523cba93ddd8631311103af6546c1a62 09628b87523cba93ddd8631311103af6546c1a62 draft-ietf-detnet-tsn-vpn-over-mpls 9c009028e84c6286cfbda36b79b477778368ff8c256a81d8396d8b9e04f3096c ['9c009028e84c6286cfbda36b79b477778368ff8c256a81d8396d8b9e04f3096c', '1920ebb46d0cee2d379ef48c15f8f6abd01e2a183f316da235e0c3b7515feade', '249c961ea29438959ea2204728df24964ec80b8cd91c657715c47014f5e5a462', '0882426f04ffe7d1fb83d25c8b8c589112e7bfc884827f292935052160a05cb7'] B "implementations of this document shall use management and control information to map a tsn stream to a detnet flow. n:1 mapping (aggregating multiple tsn streams in a single detnet flow) shall be supported. the management or control function that provisions flow mapping shall ensure that adequate resources are allocated and configured to provide proper service requirements of the mapped flows." {79: 1, 53: 1, 6: 2, 90: 3, 51: 3, 130: 2, 62: 5, 85: 5, 68: 4, 35: 3, 110: 3, 91: 5, 114: 3, 97: 3, 31: 3, 13: 3, 67: 3, 38: 4, 26: 3, 124: 3, 98: 2, 54: 2, 127: 3, 8: 2, 96: 3, 64: 2, 30: 4, 61: 5, 55: 3, 27: 4, 15: 3, 52: 2, 129: 3, 115: 3, 84: 3, 76: 6, 87: 3, 131: 5, 102: 3, 113: 5, 99: 2, 36: 3, 24: 2, 72: 4} {10: 1, 369: 1, 1: 9, 4: 2, 9: 5, 15: 3, 24: 2, 25: 5, 26: 5, 27: 3, 39: 5, 43: 3, 49: 6, 50: 5, 58: 5, 59: 2, 64: 3, 69: 4, 81: 6, 82: 4, 86: 3, 96: 4, 97: 3, 100: 7, 108: 3, 109: 4, 110: 4, 111: 2, 114: 3, 115: 4, 116: 3, 118: 6, 119: 5, 120: 3, 121: 4, 122: 4, 123: 3, 124: 4, 128: 4, 129: 4, 130: 5, 132: 4, 136: 2, 145: 4, 147: 4, 151: 4, 152: 4, 154: 3, 156: 2, 161: 3, 162: 3, 165: 3, 168: 4, 169: 3, 172: 3, 180: 4, 184: 5, 187: 5, 188: 4, 191: 3, 194: 4, 202: 5, 203: 6, 206: 2, 207: 3, 215: 2, 217: 3, 218: 8, 220: 2, 221: 2, 222: 5, 224: 3, 227: 5, 229: 3, 234: 5, 235: 2, 241: 2, 243: 4, 244: 4, 245: 4, 248: 4, 250: 4, 258: 11, 262: 4, 263: 5, 264: 3, 267: 4, 270: 3, 272: 3, 273: 5, 287: 3, 289: 3, 291: 5, 299: 5, 300: 3, 304: 3, 309: 3, 314: 2, 315: 3, 320: 4, 323: 4, 327: 2, 328: 3, 329: 2, 330: 10, 334: 2, 335: 3, 341: 5, 342: 6, 347: 5, 348: 5, 350: 7, 351: 5, 352: 3, 353: 3, 354: 2, 358: 4, 365: 3, 366: 2, 371: 7, 372: 5, 376: 2, 384: 5, 385: 4, 386: 3, 387: 3, 392: 3, 393: 4, 396: 6, 397: 7, 398: 6, 402: 3} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 54 "A MPLS DetNet flow is configured to carry any number of TSN flows. The DetNet flow specific bandwidth profile SHOULD match the required bandwidth of the App-flow aggregate." Work In progress - Wanted to get the figure changes out for review . Need to check if the overly wording is complete . There was a lot of inter working text - I have commented out . 09628b87523cba93ddd8631311103af6546c1a62 09628b87523cba93ddd8631311103af6546c1a62 draft-ietf-detnet-tsn-vpn-over-mpls 4563b77f2d7fb941efbd9e18e8d16d0624a43a1d731dcdaec24463df0e8903fc ['4563b77f2d7fb941efbd9e18e8d16d0624a43a1d731dcdaec24463df0e8903fc'] B "a mpls detnet flow is configured to carry any number of tsn flows. the detnet flow specific bandwidth profile should match the required bandwidth of the app-flow aggregate." {} {} {105} 54 "In order to use a DetNet network to interconnect TSN segments, TSN specific information must be converted to DetNet domain specific ones. TSN Stream ID(s) and stream(s) related parameters/requirements must be converted to a DetNet flow-ID and flow related parameters/ requirements. Note that, as the DetNet network is just a portion of the end2end TSN path (i.e., single hop from Ethernet perspective), some parameters (e.g., delay) may differ significantly. Other parameters (like bandwidth) also may have to be tuned due to the MPLS encapsulation used within the DetNet network." Work In progress - Wanted to get the figure changes out for review . Need to check if the overly wording is complete . There was a lot of inter working text - I have commented out . 09628b87523cba93ddd8631311103af6546c1a62 09628b87523cba93ddd8631311103af6546c1a62 draft-ietf-detnet-tsn-vpn-over-mpls b03d79d1a547b36a28c6cba78f57b8244a4855f6b31003de3e617a5b5eddc070 ['984ead46c17c8240192f91015cf9917bc3323564722bdd2774aaffd4184ca6d4', 'b03d79d1a547b36a28c6cba78f57b8244a4855f6b31003de3e617a5b5eddc070', 'c98270ca090eb9b20663ebffccbba51b4f09ab5265dc64f27cab3838f4d8544b'] A "in order to use a detnet network to interconnect tsn segments, tsn specific information must be converted to detnet domain specific ones. tsn stream id(s) and stream(s) related parameters/requirements must be converted to a detnet flow-id and flow related parameters/ requirements. note that, as the detnet network is just a portion of the end2end tsn path (i.e., single hop from ethernet perspective), some parameters (e.g., delay) may differ significantly. other parameters (like bandwidth) also may have to be tuned due to the mpls encapsulation used within the detnet network." {53: 1, 6: 2, 79: 2, 90: 3, 51: 3, 130: 2, 62: 5, 85: 5, 68: 4, 35: 3, 110: 3, 91: 5, 114: 3, 97: 3, 31: 3, 13: 3, 67: 3, 38: 4, 26: 3, 124: 3, 98: 2, 54: 2, 127: 3, 8: 2, 96: 3, 64: 2, 30: 4, 61: 5, 55: 3, 27: 4, 15: 3, 52: 2, 129: 3, 115: 3, 84: 3, 76: 6, 87: 3, 131: 5, 102: 3, 113: 5, 99: 2, 36: 3, 24: 2, 72: 4} {369: 1, 1: 9, 4: 2, 9: 5, 10: 3, 15: 3, 24: 2, 25: 5, 26: 5, 27: 3, 39: 5, 43: 3, 49: 6, 50: 5, 58: 5, 59: 2, 64: 3, 69: 4, 81: 6, 82: 4, 86: 3, 96: 4, 97: 3, 100: 7, 108: 3, 109: 4, 110: 4, 111: 2, 114: 3, 115: 4, 116: 3, 118: 6, 119: 5, 120: 3, 121: 4, 122: 4, 123: 3, 124: 4, 128: 4, 129: 4, 130: 5, 132: 4, 136: 2, 145: 4, 147: 4, 151: 4, 152: 4, 154: 3, 156: 2, 161: 3, 162: 3, 165: 3, 168: 4, 169: 3, 172: 3, 180: 4, 184: 5, 187: 5, 188: 4, 191: 3, 194: 4, 202: 5, 203: 6, 206: 2, 207: 3, 215: 2, 217: 3, 218: 8, 220: 2, 221: 2, 222: 5, 224: 3, 227: 5, 229: 3, 234: 5, 241: 2, 242: 2, 243: 4, 244: 4, 245: 4, 248: 4, 250: 4, 258: 11, 262: 4, 263: 5, 264: 3, 267: 4, 270: 3, 272: 3, 273: 5, 287: 3, 289: 3, 291: 5, 299: 5, 300: 3, 304: 3, 309: 3, 314: 2, 315: 3, 320: 4, 323: 4, 327: 4, 328: 3, 329: 2, 330: 10, 334: 2, 335: 3, 341: 5, 342: 6, 347: 5, 348: 5, 350: 7, 351: 5, 352: 3, 353: 3, 354: 2, 358: 4, 365: 3, 366: 2, 371: 7, 372: 5, 376: 2, 384: 5, 385: 4, 386: 3, 387: 3, 392: 3, 393: 4, 396: 6, 397: 7, 398: 6, 402: 3} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 54 "Note that, as the DetNet network is just a portion of the end to end TSN path (i.e., single hop from Ethernet perspective), some parameters (e.g., delay) may differ significantly. Since there is no interworking function the bandwidth of DetNet network is assumed to be set large enough to handle all TSN Flows it will support. At the egress of the Detnet Domain the MPLS headers are stripped and the TSN flow continues on as a normal TSN flow." Work In progress - Wanted to get the figure changes out for review . Need to check if the overly wording is complete . There was a lot of inter working text - I have commented out . 09628b87523cba93ddd8631311103af6546c1a62 09628b87523cba93ddd8631311103af6546c1a62 draft-ietf-detnet-tsn-vpn-over-mpls c98270ca090eb9b20663ebffccbba51b4f09ab5265dc64f27cab3838f4d8544b ['984ead46c17c8240192f91015cf9917bc3323564722bdd2774aaffd4184ca6d4', 'b03d79d1a547b36a28c6cba78f57b8244a4855f6b31003de3e617a5b5eddc070', 'c98270ca090eb9b20663ebffccbba51b4f09ab5265dc64f27cab3838f4d8544b'] B "note that, as the detnet network is just a portion of the end to end tsn path (i.e., single hop from ethernet perspective), some parameters (e.g., delay) may differ significantly. since there is no interworking function the bandwidth of detnet network is assumed to be set large enough to handle all tsn flows it will support. at the egress of the detnet domain the mpls headers are stripped and the tsn flow continues on as a normal tsn flow." {53: 1, 6: 2, 79: 2, 90: 3, 51: 3, 130: 2, 62: 5, 85: 5, 68: 4, 35: 3, 110: 3, 91: 5, 114: 3, 97: 3, 31: 3, 13: 3, 67: 3, 38: 4, 26: 3, 124: 3, 98: 2, 54: 2, 127: 3, 8: 2, 96: 3, 64: 2, 30: 4, 61: 5, 55: 3, 27: 4, 15: 3, 52: 2, 129: 3, 115: 3, 84: 3, 76: 6, 87: 3, 131: 5, 102: 3, 113: 5, 99: 2, 36: 3, 24: 2, 72: 4} {369: 1, 1: 9, 4: 2, 9: 5, 10: 3, 15: 3, 24: 2, 25: 5, 26: 5, 27: 3, 39: 5, 43: 3, 49: 6, 50: 5, 58: 5, 59: 2, 64: 3, 69: 4, 81: 6, 82: 4, 86: 3, 96: 4, 97: 3, 100: 7, 108: 3, 109: 4, 110: 4, 111: 2, 114: 3, 115: 4, 116: 3, 118: 6, 119: 5, 120: 3, 121: 4, 122: 4, 123: 3, 124: 4, 128: 4, 129: 4, 130: 5, 132: 4, 136: 2, 145: 4, 147: 4, 151: 4, 152: 4, 154: 3, 156: 2, 161: 3, 162: 3, 165: 3, 168: 4, 169: 3, 172: 3, 180: 4, 184: 5, 187: 5, 188: 4, 191: 3, 194: 4, 202: 5, 203: 6, 206: 2, 207: 3, 215: 2, 217: 3, 218: 8, 220: 2, 221: 2, 222: 5, 224: 3, 227: 5, 229: 3, 234: 5, 241: 2, 242: 2, 243: 4, 244: 4, 245: 4, 248: 4, 250: 4, 258: 11, 262: 4, 263: 5, 264: 3, 267: 4, 270: 3, 272: 3, 273: 5, 287: 3, 289: 3, 291: 5, 299: 5, 300: 3, 304: 3, 309: 3, 314: 2, 315: 3, 320: 4, 323: 4, 327: 4, 328: 3, 329: 2, 330: 10, 334: 2, 335: 3, 341: 5, 342: 6, 347: 5, 348: 5, 350: 7, 351: 5, 352: 3, 353: 3, 354: 2, 358: 4, 365: 3, 366: 2, 371: 7, 372: 5, 376: 2, 384: 5, 385: 4, 386: 3, 387: 3, 392: 3, 393: 4, 396: 6, 397: 7, 398: 6, 402: 3} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 54 "In order to use a DetNet network to interconnect TSN segments, TSN specific information must be converted to DetNet domain specific ones. TSN Stream ID(s) and stream(s) related parameters/requirements must be converted to a DetNet flow-ID and flow related parameters/ requirements." Work In progress - Wanted to get the figure changes out for review . Need to check if the overly wording is complete . There was a lot of inter working text - I have commented out . 09628b87523cba93ddd8631311103af6546c1a62 09628b87523cba93ddd8631311103af6546c1a62 draft-ietf-detnet-tsn-vpn-over-mpls 984ead46c17c8240192f91015cf9917bc3323564722bdd2774aaffd4184ca6d4 ['984ead46c17c8240192f91015cf9917bc3323564722bdd2774aaffd4184ca6d4', 'b03d79d1a547b36a28c6cba78f57b8244a4855f6b31003de3e617a5b5eddc070', 'c98270ca090eb9b20663ebffccbba51b4f09ab5265dc64f27cab3838f4d8544b'] B "in order to use a detnet network to interconnect tsn segments, tsn specific information must be converted to detnet domain specific ones. tsn stream id(s) and stream(s) related parameters/requirements must be converted to a detnet flow-id and flow related parameters/ requirements." {53: 1, 6: 2, 79: 2, 90: 3, 51: 3, 130: 2, 62: 5, 85: 5, 68: 4, 35: 3, 110: 3, 91: 5, 114: 3, 97: 3, 31: 3, 13: 3, 67: 3, 38: 4, 26: 3, 124: 3, 98: 2, 54: 2, 127: 3, 8: 2, 96: 3, 64: 2, 30: 4, 61: 5, 55: 3, 27: 4, 15: 3, 52: 2, 129: 3, 115: 3, 84: 3, 76: 6, 87: 3, 131: 5, 102: 3, 113: 5, 99: 2, 36: 3, 24: 2, 72: 4} {369: 1, 1: 9, 4: 2, 9: 5, 10: 3, 15: 3, 24: 2, 25: 5, 26: 5, 27: 3, 39: 5, 43: 3, 49: 6, 50: 5, 58: 5, 59: 2, 64: 3, 69: 4, 81: 6, 82: 4, 86: 3, 96: 4, 97: 3, 100: 7, 108: 3, 109: 4, 110: 4, 111: 2, 114: 3, 115: 4, 116: 3, 118: 6, 119: 5, 120: 3, 121: 4, 122: 4, 123: 3, 124: 4, 128: 4, 129: 4, 130: 5, 132: 4, 136: 2, 145: 4, 147: 4, 151: 4, 152: 4, 154: 3, 156: 2, 161: 3, 162: 3, 165: 3, 168: 4, 169: 3, 172: 3, 180: 4, 184: 5, 187: 5, 188: 4, 191: 3, 194: 4, 202: 5, 203: 6, 206: 2, 207: 3, 215: 2, 217: 3, 218: 8, 220: 2, 221: 2, 222: 5, 224: 3, 227: 5, 229: 3, 234: 5, 241: 2, 242: 2, 243: 4, 244: 4, 245: 4, 248: 4, 250: 4, 258: 11, 262: 4, 263: 5, 264: 3, 267: 4, 270: 3, 272: 3, 273: 5, 287: 3, 289: 3, 291: 5, 299: 5, 300: 3, 304: 3, 309: 3, 314: 2, 315: 3, 320: 4, 323: 4, 327: 4, 328: 3, 329: 2, 330: 10, 334: 2, 335: 3, 341: 5, 342: 6, 347: 5, 348: 5, 350: 7, 351: 5, 352: 3, 353: 3, 354: 2, 358: 4, 365: 3, 366: 2, 371: 7, 372: 5, 376: 2, 384: 5, 385: 4, 386: 3, 387: 3, 392: 3, 393: 4, 396: 6, 397: 7, 398: 6, 402: 3} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 54 "The security considerations of DetNet in general are discussed in I- D.ietf-detnet-architecture and I-D.ietf-detnet-security. DetNet MPLS data plane specific considerations are summarized in I-D.ietf-detnet- mpls. Encryption may provided within the TSN network using MACSec IEEE802.1AE-2018." Work In progress - Wanted to get the figure changes out for review . Need to check if the overly wording is complete . There was a lot of inter working text - I have commented out . 09628b87523cba93ddd8631311103af6546c1a62 09628b87523cba93ddd8631311103af6546c1a62 draft-ietf-detnet-tsn-vpn-over-mpls 4826376633600232b766cb8a62d4054b0f5ea45d74878bcf57356e567088300c ['4826376633600232b766cb8a62d4054b0f5ea45d74878bcf57356e567088300c', 'b6643a8327dedf9a3d90b48af7d54e9564919d5451389e71da900e4fbeb3bcb7'] A "the security considerations of detnet in general are discussed in i- d.ietf-detnet-architecture and i-d.ietf-detnet-security. detnet mpls data plane specific considerations are summarized in i-d.ietf-detnet- mpls. encryption may provided within the tsn network using macsec ieee802.1ae-2018." {53: 1, 67: 1, 6: 2, 79: 2, 90: 3, 51: 3, 130: 2, 62: 5, 85: 5, 68: 4, 35: 3, 110: 3, 91: 5, 114: 3, 97: 3, 31: 3, 13: 3, 38: 4, 26: 3, 124: 3, 98: 2, 127: 3, 8: 2, 96: 3, 64: 2, 30: 4, 61: 5, 55: 3, 27: 4, 15: 3, 52: 2, 129: 3, 115: 3, 84: 3, 76: 6, 87: 3, 131: 5, 54: 2, 102: 3, 113: 5, 99: 2, 36: 3, 24: 2, 72: 4} {369: 1, 287: 1, 1: 9, 4: 2, 9: 5, 10: 3, 15: 3, 24: 2, 25: 5, 26: 5, 27: 3, 39: 5, 43: 3, 49: 6, 50: 5, 58: 5, 59: 2, 64: 3, 69: 4, 81: 6, 82: 4, 86: 3, 96: 4, 97: 3, 100: 7, 108: 3, 109: 4, 110: 4, 114: 3, 115: 4, 116: 3, 118: 6, 119: 5, 120: 3, 121: 4, 122: 4, 123: 3, 124: 4, 128: 4, 129: 4, 130: 5, 132: 4, 136: 2, 145: 4, 147: 4, 151: 4, 152: 4, 154: 3, 156: 2, 161: 3, 162: 3, 165: 3, 168: 4, 169: 3, 172: 3, 180: 4, 184: 5, 187: 3, 188: 2, 191: 3, 194: 4, 202: 5, 203: 6, 206: 2, 207: 3, 215: 2, 217: 3, 218: 8, 220: 2, 221: 2, 222: 5, 224: 3, 227: 5, 229: 3, 234: 5, 235: 2, 241: 2, 242: 2, 243: 4, 244: 4, 245: 4, 248: 4, 250: 4, 258: 11, 262: 4, 263: 5, 264: 3, 267: 4, 270: 3, 272: 3, 273: 5, 289: 3, 291: 5, 299: 5, 300: 3, 304: 3, 309: 3, 314: 2, 315: 3, 320: 4, 323: 4, 327: 4, 328: 3, 329: 2, 330: 10, 334: 2, 335: 3, 341: 5, 342: 6, 347: 5, 348: 5, 350: 7, 351: 5, 352: 3, 353: 3, 354: 2, 358: 4, 365: 3, 366: 2, 371: 7, 372: 5, 376: 2, 384: 5, 385: 4, 386: 3, 387: 3, 392: 3, 393: 4, 396: 6, 397: 7, 398: 6, 402: 3} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 54 "Security considerations for DetNet are described in detail in I- D.ietf-detnet-security. General security considerations are described in I-D.ietf-detnet-architecture. DetNet MPLS data plane specific considerations are summarized in I-D.ietf-detnet-mpls. The primary considerations for the data plane is to maintain integrity of data and delivery of the associated DetNet service traversing the DetNet network. Application flows can be protected through whatever means is provided by the underlying technology. For example, encryption may be used, such as that provided by IPSec RFC4301 for IP flows and/or by an underlying sub-net using MACSec IEEE802.1AE-2018 for IP over Ethernet (Layer-2) flows." Work In progress - Wanted to get the figure changes out for review . Need to check if the overly wording is complete . There was a lot of inter working text - I have commented out . 09628b87523cba93ddd8631311103af6546c1a62 09628b87523cba93ddd8631311103af6546c1a62 draft-ietf-detnet-tsn-vpn-over-mpls b6643a8327dedf9a3d90b48af7d54e9564919d5451389e71da900e4fbeb3bcb7 ['4826376633600232b766cb8a62d4054b0f5ea45d74878bcf57356e567088300c', 'b6643a8327dedf9a3d90b48af7d54e9564919d5451389e71da900e4fbeb3bcb7'] B "security considerations for detnet are described in detail in i- d.ietf-detnet-security. general security considerations are described in i-d.ietf-detnet-architecture. detnet mpls data plane specific considerations are summarized in i-d.ietf-detnet-mpls. the primary considerations for the data plane is to maintain integrity of data and delivery of the associated detnet service traversing the detnet network. application flows can be protected through whatever means is provided by the underlying technology. for example, encryption may be used, such as that provided by ipsec rfc4301 for ip flows and/or by an underlying sub-net using macsec ieee802.1ae-2018 for ip over ethernet (layer-2) flows." {53: 1, 67: 1, 6: 2, 79: 2, 90: 3, 51: 3, 130: 2, 62: 5, 85: 5, 68: 4, 35: 3, 110: 3, 91: 5, 114: 3, 97: 3, 31: 3, 13: 3, 38: 4, 26: 3, 124: 3, 98: 2, 127: 3, 8: 2, 96: 3, 64: 2, 30: 4, 61: 5, 55: 3, 27: 4, 15: 3, 52: 2, 129: 3, 115: 3, 84: 3, 76: 6, 87: 3, 131: 5, 54: 2, 102: 3, 113: 5, 99: 2, 36: 3, 24: 2, 72: 4} {369: 1, 287: 1, 1: 9, 4: 2, 9: 5, 10: 3, 15: 3, 24: 2, 25: 5, 26: 5, 27: 3, 39: 5, 43: 3, 49: 6, 50: 5, 58: 5, 59: 2, 64: 3, 69: 4, 81: 6, 82: 4, 86: 3, 96: 4, 97: 3, 100: 7, 108: 3, 109: 4, 110: 4, 114: 3, 115: 4, 116: 3, 118: 6, 119: 5, 120: 3, 121: 4, 122: 4, 123: 3, 124: 4, 128: 4, 129: 4, 130: 5, 132: 4, 136: 2, 145: 4, 147: 4, 151: 4, 152: 4, 154: 3, 156: 2, 161: 3, 162: 3, 165: 3, 168: 4, 169: 3, 172: 3, 180: 4, 184: 5, 187: 3, 188: 2, 191: 3, 194: 4, 202: 5, 203: 6, 206: 2, 207: 3, 215: 2, 217: 3, 218: 8, 220: 2, 221: 2, 222: 5, 224: 3, 227: 5, 229: 3, 234: 5, 235: 2, 241: 2, 242: 2, 243: 4, 244: 4, 245: 4, 248: 4, 250: 4, 258: 11, 262: 4, 263: 5, 264: 3, 267: 4, 270: 3, 272: 3, 273: 5, 289: 3, 291: 5, 299: 5, 300: 3, 304: 3, 309: 3, 314: 2, 315: 3, 320: 4, 323: 4, 327: 4, 328: 3, 329: 2, 330: 10, 334: 2, 335: 3, 341: 5, 342: 6, 347: 5, 348: 5, 350: 7, 351: 5, 352: 3, 353: 3, 354: 2, 358: 4, 365: 3, 366: 2, 371: 7, 372: 5, 376: 2, 384: 5, 385: 4, 386: 3, 387: 3, 392: 3, 393: 4, 396: 6, 397: 7, 398: 6, 402: 3} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 53 "This document specifies the Deterministic Networking data plane when TSN networks interconnected over an MPLS Packet Switched Networks." "Major clean up and simplification as data plane drafts can be referred for MPLS related details . TSN over DetNet MPLS follows the concept of RFC3985 . Description focus on Edge Nodes procedures and functions . Text covers the Edge Nodes components : ( 1 ) TSN functions ( in NSP block ) ; ( 2 ) DetNet Service Proxy ; and ( 3 ) DetNet sub - layers . Approving from teelcon review" 3486514b01b74d57f031bcf660311de328a6e0dc 3486514b01b74d57f031bcf660311de328a6e0dc draft-ietf-detnet-tsn-vpn-over-mpls 809ec4f8b1f3a5ee64b403784e2cec044fc8310d10e39ff0aa57e939a96af960 ['cae70a041f2bb7a437801975d64fbc6aa981e51be14ad7536d6a022d294d2c70', '809ec4f8b1f3a5ee64b403784e2cec044fc8310d10e39ff0aa57e939a96af960', '101d6488f0f475a04aa297b74fc9f2861a180e4eb1a083da451550a5788c81e8', '2a6155467d7734762edcbb115219fa2034b5155fbeebef9e57c2926f910375de', 'b4e58098ddc365c5552b862a0113a228a093c4d0e43777c907381a6a46a6e046', '01a18790f41b769613de4d30c8d1d12d964b688a283f28fffa0a449aeb9e677a', '8c2397a8ea6483407dd11b2bed5aadbe7d786fff862554da5f6c29a99d2be887', '41da8cc1d1b5b4bc6079224be7d1964e3e96805bc2fa507df55caba9874e48e4', '9b5c5844768e19db649b44b3150e50cd8e12a4cee15d559ee61213e3602f502b'] A "this document specifies the deterministic networking data plane when tsn networks interconnected over an mpls packet switched networks." {130: 1, 64: 1, 67: 1, 33: 1, 52: 1, 79: 2, 51: 2, 112: 3, 55: 3, 62: 3, 37: 2, 38: 2, 69: 2, 68: 2, 25: 2, 53: 2, 80: 2, 127: 2, 91: 3} {0: 1, 14: 1, 56: 1, 255: 1, 278: 1, 281: 1, 321: 1, 389: 2, 390: 2, 135: 3, 142: 3, 400: 3, 17: 2, 399: 3, 19: 2, 149: 3, 406: 2, 279: 2, 280: 2, 294: 2, 296: 3, 45: 3, 308: 2, 185: 2, 192: 2, 66: 2, 196: 3, 197: 2, 324: 2, 77: 3, 78: 3, 337: 4, 216: 3, 380: 2} {0, 389, 390, 135, 142, 14, 400, 17, 399, 19, 149, 406, 279, 280, 281, 278, 294, 296, 45, 308, 56, 185, 192, 321, 322, 66, 196, 197, 324, 77, 78, 337, 216, 380, 255} 53 "This document uses the terminology established in the DetNet architecture I-D.ietf-detnet-architecture, and the reader is assumed to be familiar with that document and its terminology." "Major clean up and simplification as data plane drafts can be referred for MPLS related details . TSN over DetNet MPLS follows the concept of RFC3985 . Description focus on Edge Nodes procedures and functions . Text covers the Edge Nodes components : ( 1 ) TSN functions ( in NSP block ) ; ( 2 ) DetNet Service Proxy ; and ( 3 ) DetNet sub - layers . Approving from teelcon review" 3486514b01b74d57f031bcf660311de328a6e0dc 3486514b01b74d57f031bcf660311de328a6e0dc draft-ietf-detnet-tsn-vpn-over-mpls cae70a041f2bb7a437801975d64fbc6aa981e51be14ad7536d6a022d294d2c70 ['cae70a041f2bb7a437801975d64fbc6aa981e51be14ad7536d6a022d294d2c70', '809ec4f8b1f3a5ee64b403784e2cec044fc8310d10e39ff0aa57e939a96af960', '101d6488f0f475a04aa297b74fc9f2861a180e4eb1a083da451550a5788c81e8', '2a6155467d7734762edcbb115219fa2034b5155fbeebef9e57c2926f910375de', 'b4e58098ddc365c5552b862a0113a228a093c4d0e43777c907381a6a46a6e046', '01a18790f41b769613de4d30c8d1d12d964b688a283f28fffa0a449aeb9e677a', '8c2397a8ea6483407dd11b2bed5aadbe7d786fff862554da5f6c29a99d2be887', '41da8cc1d1b5b4bc6079224be7d1964e3e96805bc2fa507df55caba9874e48e4', '9b5c5844768e19db649b44b3150e50cd8e12a4cee15d559ee61213e3602f502b'] A "this document uses the terminology established in the detnet architecture i-d.ietf-detnet-architecture, and the reader is assumed to be familiar with that document and its terminology." {130: 1, 64: 1, 67: 1, 33: 1, 52: 1, 79: 2, 51: 2, 112: 3, 55: 3, 62: 3, 37: 2, 38: 2, 69: 2, 68: 2, 25: 2, 53: 2, 80: 2, 127: 2, 91: 3} {0: 1, 14: 1, 56: 1, 255: 1, 278: 1, 281: 1, 321: 1, 389: 2, 390: 2, 135: 3, 142: 3, 400: 3, 17: 2, 399: 3, 19: 2, 149: 3, 406: 2, 279: 2, 280: 2, 294: 2, 296: 3, 45: 3, 308: 2, 185: 2, 192: 2, 66: 2, 196: 3, 197: 2, 324: 2, 77: 3, 78: 3, 337: 4, 216: 3, 380: 2} {0, 389, 390, 135, 142, 14, 400, 17, 399, 19, 149, 406, 279, 280, 281, 278, 294, 296, 45, 308, 56, 185, 192, 321, 322, 66, 196, 197, 324, 77, 78, 337, 216, 380, 255} 53 "A Detnet ""forwarding"" label that identifies the LSP used to forward a DetNet flow across an MPLS PSN, e.g., a hop-by-hop label used between label switching routers (LSR)." "Major clean up and simplification as data plane drafts can be referred for MPLS related details . TSN over DetNet MPLS follows the concept of RFC3985 . Description focus on Edge Nodes procedures and functions . Text covers the Edge Nodes components : ( 1 ) TSN functions ( in NSP block ) ; ( 2 ) DetNet Service Proxy ; and ( 3 ) DetNet sub - layers . Approving from teelcon review" 3486514b01b74d57f031bcf660311de328a6e0dc 3486514b01b74d57f031bcf660311de328a6e0dc draft-ietf-detnet-tsn-vpn-over-mpls 2a6155467d7734762edcbb115219fa2034b5155fbeebef9e57c2926f910375de ['cae70a041f2bb7a437801975d64fbc6aa981e51be14ad7536d6a022d294d2c70', '809ec4f8b1f3a5ee64b403784e2cec044fc8310d10e39ff0aa57e939a96af960', '101d6488f0f475a04aa297b74fc9f2861a180e4eb1a083da451550a5788c81e8', '2a6155467d7734762edcbb115219fa2034b5155fbeebef9e57c2926f910375de', 'b4e58098ddc365c5552b862a0113a228a093c4d0e43777c907381a6a46a6e046', '01a18790f41b769613de4d30c8d1d12d964b688a283f28fffa0a449aeb9e677a', '8c2397a8ea6483407dd11b2bed5aadbe7d786fff862554da5f6c29a99d2be887', '41da8cc1d1b5b4bc6079224be7d1964e3e96805bc2fa507df55caba9874e48e4', '9b5c5844768e19db649b44b3150e50cd8e12a4cee15d559ee61213e3602f502b'] A "a detnet ""forwarding"" label that identifies the lsp used to forward a detnet flow across an mpls psn, e.g., a hop-by-hop label used between label switching routers (lsr)." {130: 1, 64: 1, 67: 1, 33: 1, 52: 1, 79: 2, 51: 2, 112: 3, 55: 3, 62: 3, 37: 2, 38: 2, 69: 2, 68: 2, 25: 2, 53: 2, 80: 2, 127: 2, 91: 3} {0: 1, 14: 1, 56: 1, 255: 1, 278: 1, 281: 1, 321: 1, 389: 2, 390: 2, 135: 3, 142: 3, 400: 3, 17: 2, 399: 3, 19: 2, 149: 3, 406: 2, 279: 2, 280: 2, 294: 2, 296: 3, 45: 3, 308: 2, 185: 2, 192: 2, 66: 2, 196: 3, 197: 2, 324: 2, 77: 3, 78: 3, 337: 4, 216: 3, 380: 2} {0, 389, 390, 135, 142, 14, 400, 17, 399, 19, 149, 406, 279, 280, 281, 278, 294, 296, 45, 308, 56, 185, 192, 321, 322, 66, 196, 197, 324, 77, 78, 337, 216, 380, 255} 53 "A DetNet ""service"" label that is used between DetNet nodes that implement also the DetNet service sub-layer functions. An S-Label is also used to identify a DetNet flow at DetNet service sub- layer." "Major clean up and simplification as data plane drafts can be referred for MPLS related details . TSN over DetNet MPLS follows the concept of RFC3985 . Description focus on Edge Nodes procedures and functions . Text covers the Edge Nodes components : ( 1 ) TSN functions ( in NSP block ) ; ( 2 ) DetNet Service Proxy ; and ( 3 ) DetNet sub - layers . Approving from teelcon review" 3486514b01b74d57f031bcf660311de328a6e0dc 3486514b01b74d57f031bcf660311de328a6e0dc draft-ietf-detnet-tsn-vpn-over-mpls 101d6488f0f475a04aa297b74fc9f2861a180e4eb1a083da451550a5788c81e8 ['cae70a041f2bb7a437801975d64fbc6aa981e51be14ad7536d6a022d294d2c70', '809ec4f8b1f3a5ee64b403784e2cec044fc8310d10e39ff0aa57e939a96af960', '101d6488f0f475a04aa297b74fc9f2861a180e4eb1a083da451550a5788c81e8', '2a6155467d7734762edcbb115219fa2034b5155fbeebef9e57c2926f910375de', 'b4e58098ddc365c5552b862a0113a228a093c4d0e43777c907381a6a46a6e046', '01a18790f41b769613de4d30c8d1d12d964b688a283f28fffa0a449aeb9e677a', '8c2397a8ea6483407dd11b2bed5aadbe7d786fff862554da5f6c29a99d2be887', '41da8cc1d1b5b4bc6079224be7d1964e3e96805bc2fa507df55caba9874e48e4', '9b5c5844768e19db649b44b3150e50cd8e12a4cee15d559ee61213e3602f502b'] A "a detnet ""service"" label that is used between detnet nodes that implement also the detnet service sub-layer functions. an s-label is also used to identify a detnet flow at detnet service sub- layer." {130: 1, 64: 1, 67: 1, 33: 1, 52: 1, 79: 2, 51: 2, 112: 3, 55: 3, 62: 3, 37: 2, 38: 2, 69: 2, 68: 2, 25: 2, 53: 2, 80: 2, 127: 2, 91: 3} {0: 1, 14: 1, 56: 1, 255: 1, 278: 1, 281: 1, 321: 1, 389: 2, 390: 2, 135: 3, 142: 3, 400: 3, 17: 2, 399: 3, 19: 2, 149: 3, 406: 2, 279: 2, 280: 2, 294: 2, 296: 3, 45: 3, 308: 2, 185: 2, 192: 2, 66: 2, 196: 3, 197: 2, 324: 2, 77: 3, 78: 3, 337: 4, 216: 3, 380: 2} {0, 389, 390, 135, 142, 14, 400, 17, 399, 19, 149, 406, 279, 280, 281, 278, 294, 296, 45, 308, 56, 185, 192, 321, 322, 66, 196, 197, 324, 77, 78, 337, 216, 380, 255} 53 "A DetNet Control Word (d-CW) is used for sequencing and identifying duplicate packets of a DetNet flow at the DetNet service sub-layer." "Major clean up and simplification as data plane drafts can be referred for MPLS related details . TSN over DetNet MPLS follows the concept of RFC3985 . Description focus on Edge Nodes procedures and functions . Text covers the Edge Nodes components : ( 1 ) TSN functions ( in NSP block ) ; ( 2 ) DetNet Service Proxy ; and ( 3 ) DetNet sub - layers . Approving from teelcon review" 3486514b01b74d57f031bcf660311de328a6e0dc 3486514b01b74d57f031bcf660311de328a6e0dc draft-ietf-detnet-tsn-vpn-over-mpls b4e58098ddc365c5552b862a0113a228a093c4d0e43777c907381a6a46a6e046 ['cae70a041f2bb7a437801975d64fbc6aa981e51be14ad7536d6a022d294d2c70', '809ec4f8b1f3a5ee64b403784e2cec044fc8310d10e39ff0aa57e939a96af960', '101d6488f0f475a04aa297b74fc9f2861a180e4eb1a083da451550a5788c81e8', '2a6155467d7734762edcbb115219fa2034b5155fbeebef9e57c2926f910375de', 'b4e58098ddc365c5552b862a0113a228a093c4d0e43777c907381a6a46a6e046', '01a18790f41b769613de4d30c8d1d12d964b688a283f28fffa0a449aeb9e677a', '8c2397a8ea6483407dd11b2bed5aadbe7d786fff862554da5f6c29a99d2be887', '41da8cc1d1b5b4bc6079224be7d1964e3e96805bc2fa507df55caba9874e48e4', '9b5c5844768e19db649b44b3150e50cd8e12a4cee15d559ee61213e3602f502b'] A "a detnet control word (d-cw) is used for sequencing and identifying duplicate packets of a detnet flow at the detnet service sub-layer." {130: 1, 64: 1, 67: 1, 33: 1, 52: 1, 79: 2, 51: 2, 112: 3, 55: 3, 62: 3, 37: 2, 38: 2, 69: 2, 68: 2, 25: 2, 53: 2, 80: 2, 127: 2, 91: 3} {0: 1, 14: 1, 56: 1, 255: 1, 278: 1, 281: 1, 321: 1, 389: 2, 390: 2, 135: 3, 142: 3, 400: 3, 17: 2, 399: 3, 19: 2, 149: 3, 406: 2, 279: 2, 280: 2, 294: 2, 296: 3, 45: 3, 308: 2, 185: 2, 192: 2, 66: 2, 196: 3, 197: 2, 324: 2, 77: 3, 78: 3, 337: 4, 216: 3, 380: 2} {0, 389, 390, 135, 142, 14, 400, 17, 399, 19, 149, 406, 279, 280, 281, 278, 294, 296, 45, 308, 56, 185, 192, 321, 322, 66, 196, 197, 324, 77, 78, 337, 216, 380, 255} 53 "This document specifies the Deterministic Networking data plane when TSN networks are interconnected over a DetNet MPLS Network." "Major clean up and simplification as data plane drafts can be referred for MPLS related details . TSN over DetNet MPLS follows the concept of RFC3985 . Description focus on Edge Nodes procedures and functions . Text covers the Edge Nodes components : ( 1 ) TSN functions ( in NSP block ) ; ( 2 ) DetNet Service Proxy ; and ( 3 ) DetNet sub - layers . Approving from teelcon review" 3486514b01b74d57f031bcf660311de328a6e0dc 3486514b01b74d57f031bcf660311de328a6e0dc draft-ietf-detnet-tsn-vpn-over-mpls 8c2397a8ea6483407dd11b2bed5aadbe7d786fff862554da5f6c29a99d2be887 ['cae70a041f2bb7a437801975d64fbc6aa981e51be14ad7536d6a022d294d2c70', '809ec4f8b1f3a5ee64b403784e2cec044fc8310d10e39ff0aa57e939a96af960', '101d6488f0f475a04aa297b74fc9f2861a180e4eb1a083da451550a5788c81e8', '2a6155467d7734762edcbb115219fa2034b5155fbeebef9e57c2926f910375de', 'b4e58098ddc365c5552b862a0113a228a093c4d0e43777c907381a6a46a6e046', '01a18790f41b769613de4d30c8d1d12d964b688a283f28fffa0a449aeb9e677a', '8c2397a8ea6483407dd11b2bed5aadbe7d786fff862554da5f6c29a99d2be887', '41da8cc1d1b5b4bc6079224be7d1964e3e96805bc2fa507df55caba9874e48e4', '9b5c5844768e19db649b44b3150e50cd8e12a4cee15d559ee61213e3602f502b'] B "this document specifies the deterministic networking data plane when tsn networks are interconnected over a detnet mpls network." {130: 1, 64: 1, 67: 1, 33: 1, 52: 1, 79: 2, 51: 2, 112: 3, 55: 3, 62: 3, 37: 2, 38: 2, 69: 2, 68: 2, 25: 2, 53: 2, 80: 2, 127: 2, 91: 3} {0: 1, 14: 1, 56: 1, 255: 1, 278: 1, 281: 1, 321: 1, 389: 2, 390: 2, 135: 3, 142: 3, 400: 3, 17: 2, 399: 3, 19: 2, 149: 3, 406: 2, 279: 2, 280: 2, 294: 2, 296: 3, 45: 3, 308: 2, 185: 2, 192: 2, 66: 2, 196: 3, 197: 2, 324: 2, 77: 3, 78: 3, 337: 4, 216: 3, 380: 2} {0, 389, 390, 135, 142, 14, 400, 17, 399, 19, 149, 406, 279, 280, 281, 278, 294, 296, 45, 308, 56, 185, 192, 321, 322, 66, 196, 197, 324, 77, 78, 337, 216, 380, 255} 53 "The Time-Sensitive Networking Task Group (TSN TG) within IEEE 802.1 Working Group deals with deterministic services through IEEE 802 networks. Deterministic Networking (DetNet) defined by IETF is a service that can be offered by a L3 network to DetNet flows. General background and concepts of DetNet can be found in I-D.ietf-detnet- architecture." "Major clean up and simplification as data plane drafts can be referred for MPLS related details . TSN over DetNet MPLS follows the concept of RFC3985 . Description focus on Edge Nodes procedures and functions . Text covers the Edge Nodes components : ( 1 ) TSN functions ( in NSP block ) ; ( 2 ) DetNet Service Proxy ; and ( 3 ) DetNet sub - layers . Approving from teelcon review" 3486514b01b74d57f031bcf660311de328a6e0dc 3486514b01b74d57f031bcf660311de328a6e0dc draft-ietf-detnet-tsn-vpn-over-mpls 41da8cc1d1b5b4bc6079224be7d1964e3e96805bc2fa507df55caba9874e48e4 ['cae70a041f2bb7a437801975d64fbc6aa981e51be14ad7536d6a022d294d2c70', '809ec4f8b1f3a5ee64b403784e2cec044fc8310d10e39ff0aa57e939a96af960', '101d6488f0f475a04aa297b74fc9f2861a180e4eb1a083da451550a5788c81e8', '2a6155467d7734762edcbb115219fa2034b5155fbeebef9e57c2926f910375de', 'b4e58098ddc365c5552b862a0113a228a093c4d0e43777c907381a6a46a6e046', '01a18790f41b769613de4d30c8d1d12d964b688a283f28fffa0a449aeb9e677a', '8c2397a8ea6483407dd11b2bed5aadbe7d786fff862554da5f6c29a99d2be887', '41da8cc1d1b5b4bc6079224be7d1964e3e96805bc2fa507df55caba9874e48e4', '9b5c5844768e19db649b44b3150e50cd8e12a4cee15d559ee61213e3602f502b'] B "the time-sensitive networking task group (tsn tg) within ieee 802.1 working group deals with deterministic services through ieee 802 networks. deterministic networking (detnet) defined by ietf is a service that can be offered by a l3 network to detnet flows. general background and concepts of detnet can be found in i-d.ietf-detnet- architecture." {130: 1, 64: 1, 67: 1, 33: 1, 52: 1, 79: 2, 51: 2, 112: 3, 55: 3, 62: 3, 37: 2, 38: 2, 69: 2, 68: 2, 25: 2, 53: 2, 80: 2, 127: 2, 91: 3} {0: 1, 14: 1, 56: 1, 255: 1, 278: 1, 281: 1, 321: 1, 389: 2, 390: 2, 135: 3, 142: 3, 400: 3, 17: 2, 399: 3, 19: 2, 149: 3, 406: 2, 279: 2, 280: 2, 294: 2, 296: 3, 45: 3, 308: 2, 185: 2, 192: 2, 66: 2, 196: 3, 197: 2, 324: 2, 77: 3, 78: 3, 337: 4, 216: 3, 380: 2} {0, 389, 390, 135, 142, 14, 400, 17, 399, 19, 149, 406, 279, 280, 281, 278, 294, 296, 45, 308, 56, 185, 192, 321, 322, 66, 196, 197, 324, 77, 78, 337, 216, 380, 255} 53 "This document specifies the use of a DetNet MPLS network to interconnect TSN nodes/network segments. DetNet MPLS data plane is defined in I-D.ietf-detnet-mpls." "Major clean up and simplification as data plane drafts can be referred for MPLS related details . TSN over DetNet MPLS follows the concept of RFC3985 . Description focus on Edge Nodes procedures and functions . Text covers the Edge Nodes components : ( 1 ) TSN functions ( in NSP block ) ; ( 2 ) DetNet Service Proxy ; and ( 3 ) DetNet sub - layers . Approving from teelcon review" 3486514b01b74d57f031bcf660311de328a6e0dc 3486514b01b74d57f031bcf660311de328a6e0dc draft-ietf-detnet-tsn-vpn-over-mpls 01a18790f41b769613de4d30c8d1d12d964b688a283f28fffa0a449aeb9e677a ['cae70a041f2bb7a437801975d64fbc6aa981e51be14ad7536d6a022d294d2c70', '809ec4f8b1f3a5ee64b403784e2cec044fc8310d10e39ff0aa57e939a96af960', '101d6488f0f475a04aa297b74fc9f2861a180e4eb1a083da451550a5788c81e8', '2a6155467d7734762edcbb115219fa2034b5155fbeebef9e57c2926f910375de', 'b4e58098ddc365c5552b862a0113a228a093c4d0e43777c907381a6a46a6e046', '01a18790f41b769613de4d30c8d1d12d964b688a283f28fffa0a449aeb9e677a', '8c2397a8ea6483407dd11b2bed5aadbe7d786fff862554da5f6c29a99d2be887', '41da8cc1d1b5b4bc6079224be7d1964e3e96805bc2fa507df55caba9874e48e4', '9b5c5844768e19db649b44b3150e50cd8e12a4cee15d559ee61213e3602f502b'] B "this document specifies the use of a detnet mpls network to interconnect tsn nodes/network segments. detnet mpls data plane is defined in i-d.ietf-detnet-mpls." {130: 1, 64: 1, 67: 1, 33: 1, 52: 1, 79: 2, 51: 2, 112: 3, 55: 3, 62: 3, 37: 2, 38: 2, 69: 2, 68: 2, 25: 2, 53: 2, 80: 2, 127: 2, 91: 3} {0: 1, 14: 1, 56: 1, 255: 1, 278: 1, 281: 1, 321: 1, 389: 2, 390: 2, 135: 3, 142: 3, 400: 3, 17: 2, 399: 3, 19: 2, 149: 3, 406: 2, 279: 2, 280: 2, 294: 2, 296: 3, 45: 3, 308: 2, 185: 2, 192: 2, 66: 2, 196: 3, 197: 2, 324: 2, 77: 3, 78: 3, 337: 4, 216: 3, 380: 2} {0, 389, 390, 135, 142, 14, 400, 17, 399, 19, 149, 406, 279, 280, 281, 278, 294, 296, 45, 308, 56, 185, 192, 321, 322, 66, 196, 197, 324, 77, 78, 337, 216, 380, 255} 53 "This document uses the terminology and concepts established in the DetNet architecture I-D.ietf-detnet-architecture and I-D.ietf-detnet- data-plane-framework, and I-D.ietf-detnet-mpls. The reader is assumed to be familiar with these documents and their terminology." "Major clean up and simplification as data plane drafts can be referred for MPLS related details . TSN over DetNet MPLS follows the concept of RFC3985 . Description focus on Edge Nodes procedures and functions . Text covers the Edge Nodes components : ( 1 ) TSN functions ( in NSP block ) ; ( 2 ) DetNet Service Proxy ; and ( 3 ) DetNet sub - layers . Approving from teelcon review" 3486514b01b74d57f031bcf660311de328a6e0dc 3486514b01b74d57f031bcf660311de328a6e0dc draft-ietf-detnet-tsn-vpn-over-mpls 9b5c5844768e19db649b44b3150e50cd8e12a4cee15d559ee61213e3602f502b ['cae70a041f2bb7a437801975d64fbc6aa981e51be14ad7536d6a022d294d2c70', '809ec4f8b1f3a5ee64b403784e2cec044fc8310d10e39ff0aa57e939a96af960', '101d6488f0f475a04aa297b74fc9f2861a180e4eb1a083da451550a5788c81e8', '2a6155467d7734762edcbb115219fa2034b5155fbeebef9e57c2926f910375de', 'b4e58098ddc365c5552b862a0113a228a093c4d0e43777c907381a6a46a6e046', '01a18790f41b769613de4d30c8d1d12d964b688a283f28fffa0a449aeb9e677a', '8c2397a8ea6483407dd11b2bed5aadbe7d786fff862554da5f6c29a99d2be887', '41da8cc1d1b5b4bc6079224be7d1964e3e96805bc2fa507df55caba9874e48e4', '9b5c5844768e19db649b44b3150e50cd8e12a4cee15d559ee61213e3602f502b'] B "this document uses the terminology and concepts established in the detnet architecture i-d.ietf-detnet-architecture and i-d.ietf-detnet- data-plane-framework, and i-d.ietf-detnet-mpls. the reader is assumed to be familiar with these documents and their terminology." {130: 1, 64: 1, 67: 1, 33: 1, 52: 1, 79: 2, 51: 2, 112: 3, 55: 3, 62: 3, 37: 2, 38: 2, 69: 2, 68: 2, 25: 2, 53: 2, 80: 2, 127: 2, 91: 3} {0: 1, 14: 1, 56: 1, 255: 1, 278: 1, 281: 1, 321: 1, 389: 2, 390: 2, 135: 3, 142: 3, 400: 3, 17: 2, 399: 3, 19: 2, 149: 3, 406: 2, 279: 2, 280: 2, 294: 2, 296: 3, 45: 3, 308: 2, 185: 2, 192: 2, 66: 2, 196: 3, 197: 2, 324: 2, 77: 3, 78: 3, 337: 4, 216: 3, 380: 2} {0, 389, 390, 135, 142, 14, 400, 17, 399, 19, 149, 406, 279, 280, 281, 278, 294, 296, 45, 308, 56, 185, 192, 321, 322, 66, 196, 197, 324, 77, 78, 337, 216, 380, 255} 53 DetNet Inter-Working Function. "Major clean up and simplification as data plane drafts can be referred for MPLS related details . TSN over DetNet MPLS follows the concept of RFC3985 . Description focus on Edge Nodes procedures and functions . Text covers the Edge Nodes components : ( 1 ) TSN functions ( in NSP block ) ; ( 2 ) DetNet Service Proxy ; and ( 3 ) DetNet sub - layers . Approving from teelcon review" 3486514b01b74d57f031bcf660311de328a6e0dc 3486514b01b74d57f031bcf660311de328a6e0dc draft-ietf-detnet-tsn-vpn-over-mpls 798866c5ba6606c0230b5e31f7d949471ef699d268b844c3bf0c994e96864245 ['798866c5ba6606c0230b5e31f7d949471ef699d268b844c3bf0c994e96864245', '7c29d182df52ad8a912d64a1a9fa6feee494e1142ce6abeb5c37c626b5e5590f'] A detnet inter-working function. {37: 1, 80: 1, 52: 1, 130: 3, 79: 2, 51: 2, 112: 3, 55: 3, 64: 2, 62: 3, 38: 3, 69: 2, 68: 2, 67: 2, 33: 2, 25: 2, 53: 2, 127: 4, 91: 3} {17: 1, 192: 1, 321: 1, 0: 3, 389: 2, 390: 2, 135: 3, 142: 3, 14: 2, 400: 3, 399: 3, 19: 3, 149: 3, 406: 2, 279: 2, 280: 2, 281: 3, 278: 2, 294: 2, 296: 3, 45: 3, 308: 2, 56: 2, 322: 2, 66: 2, 196: 5, 197: 4, 324: 3, 77: 3, 78: 3, 337: 4, 216: 3, 380: 2, 255: 3} {0, 389, 390, 135, 142, 14, 400, 17, 399, 19, 149, 406, 279, 280, 281, 278, 294, 296, 45, 308, 56, 185, 192, 321, 322, 66, 196, 197, 324, 77, 78, 337, 216, 380, 255} 53 Frame Replication and Elimination for Redundancy (TSN function). "Major clean up and simplification as data plane drafts can be referred for MPLS related details . TSN over DetNet MPLS follows the concept of RFC3985 . Description focus on Edge Nodes procedures and functions . Text covers the Edge Nodes components : ( 1 ) TSN functions ( in NSP block ) ; ( 2 ) DetNet Service Proxy ; and ( 3 ) DetNet sub - layers . Approving from teelcon review" 3486514b01b74d57f031bcf660311de328a6e0dc 3486514b01b74d57f031bcf660311de328a6e0dc draft-ietf-detnet-tsn-vpn-over-mpls 7c29d182df52ad8a912d64a1a9fa6feee494e1142ce6abeb5c37c626b5e5590f ['798866c5ba6606c0230b5e31f7d949471ef699d268b844c3bf0c994e96864245', '7c29d182df52ad8a912d64a1a9fa6feee494e1142ce6abeb5c37c626b5e5590f'] B frame replication and elimination for redundancy (tsn function). {37: 1, 80: 1, 52: 1, 130: 3, 79: 2, 51: 2, 112: 3, 55: 3, 64: 2, 62: 3, 38: 3, 69: 2, 68: 2, 67: 2, 33: 2, 25: 2, 53: 2, 127: 4, 91: 3} {17: 1, 192: 1, 321: 1, 0: 3, 389: 2, 390: 2, 135: 3, 142: 3, 14: 2, 400: 3, 399: 3, 19: 3, 149: 3, 406: 2, 279: 2, 280: 2, 281: 3, 278: 2, 294: 2, 296: 3, 45: 3, 308: 2, 56: 2, 322: 2, 66: 2, 196: 5, 197: 4, 324: 3, 77: 3, 78: 3, 337: 4, 216: 3, 380: 2, 255: 3} {0, 389, 390, 135, 142, 14, 400, 17, 399, 19, 149, 406, 279, 280, 281, 278, 294, 296, 45, 308, 56, 185, 192, 321, 322, 66, 196, 197, 324, 77, 78, 337, 216, 380, 255} 53 "to map TSN flows into DetNet flows. The specific of this operation are discussed later in this document." "Major clean up and simplification as data plane drafts can be referred for MPLS related details . TSN over DetNet MPLS follows the concept of RFC3985 . Description focus on Edge Nodes procedures and functions . Text covers the Edge Nodes components : ( 1 ) TSN functions ( in NSP block ) ; ( 2 ) DetNet Service Proxy ; and ( 3 ) DetNet sub - layers . Approving from teelcon review" 3486514b01b74d57f031bcf660311de328a6e0dc 3486514b01b74d57f031bcf660311de328a6e0dc draft-ietf-detnet-tsn-vpn-over-mpls 71dfcd074b80de90c4955890bdbe127d12b249ed764c7c4ca23dc81c74fde71d ['e82e49a3c764c0ede490d9e8afe0d0a379ec1e2fb734910d7e42f179709f894c', '1b5276bed81725e3cab5fa8d2491ae7fc344c8638906d8e62ee7c31696edcb52', 'a6a4ee1a9211a2be0e24cf91f9742499a46567acff4c78f62b568b34e38c08de', '44d22f065218a14d5aa04288e7553c8a6d81bb222066c74ea38571bbe922a729', 'c757c3611002031d5ce1ac79d9984d826f392e6628a0657e045c348e52b7eda2', '8a105d9f9ffbf3e747a101e48de19122931cd0cce896dc27f57d16df9dbb75ac', 'a8ff14472a8fa48bacdc11d7089a9d1054c0a786f6152f510b5d4092c22e121f', 'e746630d4b45cf2b654a14e4daaa03ad634e33d92c29c489e3ef3fcd5620c311', '16375944152e6c3e73492437880fe39d7f0123a9292d062e8e9c7d317e4b878f', '42f5214bb177fd7faf01b7943e7f313a615b2490f9109d5cefa8b24101735c32', '5cc97b8f56cdeeb02e7c96183745dc53dd8ec3ec02424107d16eb438c2c9363c', 'a816e4d1392c9c85d398ee2c5116b5de849a9823bc552d322ac8725f7c9b859e', 'c7286f8983508fdd7d94ae798cdc3950cbf65865e905c00a76838a34eb79cf2c', '6924f7b3002e9f0dff9023b70bcc9d484e643c3a2d95b0d5c853c084ad3f68ab', '2d8fce3963de03360a5d98758067925a60474b5430fd8091fc72f3c50a9d38e5', '77f9aaec42bbb94079fae33b8c564cd7f64721106f615e11f22673310efaf01b', '09f8dc962fd9202d148a0b378c9a078ea850056b4b5c360c0914d4a1de6af454', '4826376633600232b766cb8a62d4054b0f5ea45d74878bcf57356e567088300c', '82b410c949db1d81b3f197adbaaba7b82b6e497600cd9883150af2bb815caa19', '0eb73f51f3b491bd6d969a05acf2b527e6e2f09a460cb88266513ab952bd3fc6', '1076eab6753435c114e8a720c951b03da6d4e1bbbf1290f8d58ad7f97a0b8c64', '4ccf918f8b8ae99a769d89e0868a12e4af1536487652436b6c188bc99e14fdb6', '2a5cef1e9c76b52b9b56c6c021a857b0fa757897b6e3c96cc8170d5b73ba8dd8', '07267e696bfbb5af98da5a8efe2b8cf604bc9ab1ce95e4766f017473bfcd0de1', '82f56d4694c2ec964de0a4413954f87ca621628c63d7425944baeff9aa4b6dad', '01e1da53fe2751e7196114efc63dd70d9babc69b4b73c03d4b7528dcc10c05d3', 'fb8f3ca7fafc9c173404ce7f909038443a6078a0c278cb024639410e33f49f88', '44e497e2df0461bad9215c57918855022435eb6e28266916161de3f7902bb352', '84f5bc0e0be5d04b515e8e49efb393e4aec7189222b92c0555cc1be542e74549', '3195c90c03cf6a438b5684cc93128c53f794660a661e2aa85d043ca5ac7060b9', 'b5bacf05f766e143f6de9484b0b5a2d9655d62854368373bd77974b94cb722e6', '2442b9072d522cde54849b40cab26789e4af909f1dd81391cd8c87023515a21c', 'b03d79d1a547b36a28c6cba78f57b8244a4855f6b31003de3e617a5b5eddc070', 'e386562e3156c91934ceb045df46d7e847bb9afcad2794bda59be854f988befc', 'cc980749457292da3a6a4a3ce669ad487409ce72e20857e80c75741c83af7f0a', '75db9ae91b710fcf1df3553b8f9653b12d014f74ba1ee8f931870d2433e163f1', '0e313215df9694bc26777ba4ac347cb8ef73f8475d2bfed664aab722833589ae', '1094721b24c22ff67539ffeabab887f87e538bdd9ebe50b0b369de138d326802', 'fb2b9389e1455c6d64ae19158396d767d88969013b14075bcfdcc764f610108c', 'ae3bdd3a81d96e4aaa02f7d597a2684146f3af75b743bde8e31c3cf5883707db', '1b8137b4c60774716e4a492efec48060d48abd7308563d8cc76edf32d98bd759', '09732023af932d8c578c8a7ead49feb80cdb5c629cee6add2e24fcd7999c0309', '75b7020073ec0c8cedf517f1b56d554e2a5cfdf89d204633c30b863c42ed6f5f', '4be1dfb90ea542d5d84c23c0ba29b91db2491a39973839ee646eeec25c71adb4', 'c98d52f719106d13b14f27abde81ce00305cbf62889690b72da3e3ddc0286c02', '056859e4aa430e2eb983e93f08bb85d9afe9aec44f0e73263cf072df70b7c475', '870147c2dad0a0dda2dd0a9f85ef83b3c4de9a304fdff6d9fa9ccc4bde9d70c0', '26e942b0353fee8f5ac0a2c2e26c9b695c50b35c501eeb4bff343b1648b5cebc', '036168e918418eb807bc3efd361a8e66067192564da41e30e076d22be0f87935', 'a491df768673d76ae7dee4c9bf1ea1456e6c537a1f1683368d8bc6869cd89bf0', 'f6a8cfceb19b4cd796512223b8afd103c4aee7052247ebea8b50f743e9aa27b6', 'd135518ad4230c8f57a3510b3ddea8a99e2355363c9419a27340734427050729', 'cbe90e272b6be7696d3b8c171500847d2b0ae497f6911d0f9d5d8481101c4c1f', '249c961ea29438959ea2204728df24964ec80b8cd91c657715c47014f5e5a462', '1920ebb46d0cee2d379ef48c15f8f6abd01e2a183f316da235e0c3b7515feade', '6d1573b42d5f89f89b26b32cbbd32ff41660e0e8c3b3091f1cb278a42651e049', 'ec6878825845c61b3049ad5dd168197c84938e7f6d4fc938670da2528cf86317', '9829b13faebde69c2279c38cd54d524aa31acfdcc1cfba7910b9d69caa42e0dd', '2755ae7cda161df0c24e1fa9f1c3308bc9ef81a599d859668490484290ca72f4', '09d9dcfc1716808b0c62e47a771ff4d39ba71f22c8640776e65624747a995626', '71dfcd074b80de90c4955890bdbe127d12b249ed764c7c4ca23dc81c74fde71d', '3c1afbb156ee2d672ca131c7c966bc6875374a95d927848bafcc5a158edf67bb'] A "to map tsn flows into detnet flows. the specific of this operation are discussed later in this document." {79: 1, 130: 1, 54: 1, 52: 1, 98: 1, 6: 1, 8: 1, 64: 1, 99: 1, 24: 1, 90: 2, 51: 2, 62: 4, 85: 4, 68: 3, 35: 2, 110: 2, 91: 4, 114: 2, 97: 2, 31: 2, 13: 2, 67: 2, 38: 3, 26: 2, 124: 2, 127: 2, 96: 2, 30: 3, 61: 4, 55: 2, 27: 3, 15: 2, 129: 2, 115: 2, 84: 2, 76: 5, 87: 2, 131: 4, 102: 2, 113: 4, 36: 2, 72: 3} {4: 1, 24: 1, 59: 1, 111: 1, 136: 1, 156: 1, 206: 1, 215: 1, 220: 1, 221: 1, 235: 1, 241: 1, 242: 1, 314: 1, 329: 1, 334: 1, 354: 1, 366: 1, 376: 1, 1: 8, 9: 4, 10: 2, 15: 2, 25: 4, 26: 4, 27: 2, 39: 4, 43: 2, 49: 5, 50: 4, 58: 4, 64: 2, 69: 3, 81: 5, 82: 3, 86: 2, 96: 3, 97: 2, 100: 6, 108: 2, 109: 3, 110: 3, 114: 2, 115: 3, 116: 2, 118: 5, 119: 4, 120: 2, 121: 3, 122: 3, 123: 2, 124: 3, 128: 3, 129: 3, 130: 4, 132: 3, 145: 3, 147: 3, 151: 3, 152: 3, 154: 2, 161: 2, 162: 2, 165: 2, 168: 3, 169: 2, 172: 2, 180: 3, 184: 4, 187: 4, 188: 3, 191: 2, 194: 3, 202: 4, 203: 5, 207: 2, 217: 2, 218: 7, 222: 4, 224: 2, 227: 4, 229: 2, 234: 4, 243: 3, 244: 3, 245: 3, 248: 3, 250: 3, 258: 10, 262: 3, 263: 4, 264: 2, 267: 3, 270: 2, 272: 2, 273: 4, 287: 2, 289: 2, 291: 4, 299: 4, 300: 2, 304: 2, 309: 2, 315: 2, 320: 3, 323: 3, 327: 3, 328: 2, 330: 9, 335: 2, 341: 4, 342: 5, 347: 4, 348: 4, 350: 6, 351: 4, 352: 2, 353: 2, 358: 3, 365: 2, 371: 6, 372: 4, 384: 4, 385: 3, 386: 2, 387: 2, 392: 2, 393: 3, 396: 5, 397: 6, 398: 5, 402: 2} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 53 "Native TSN flow and DetNet MPLS flow differ not only by the additional MPLS specific encapsulation, but DetNet MPLS flows have on each DetNet node an associated DetNet specific data structure, what defines flow related characteristics and required forwarding functions. In this example, edge Nodes provide a service proxy function that ""associates"" the DetNet flows and native flows at the edge of the DetNet domain. This ensures that the DN Flow is properly served at the Edge node (and inside the domain)." "Major clean up and simplification as data plane drafts can be referred for MPLS related details . TSN over DetNet MPLS follows the concept of RFC3985 . Description focus on Edge Nodes procedures and functions . Text covers the Edge Nodes components : ( 1 ) TSN functions ( in NSP block ) ; ( 2 ) DetNet Service Proxy ; and ( 3 ) DetNet sub - layers . Approving from teelcon review" 3486514b01b74d57f031bcf660311de328a6e0dc 3486514b01b74d57f031bcf660311de328a6e0dc draft-ietf-detnet-tsn-vpn-over-mpls 1b5276bed81725e3cab5fa8d2491ae7fc344c8638906d8e62ee7c31696edcb52 ['e82e49a3c764c0ede490d9e8afe0d0a379ec1e2fb734910d7e42f179709f894c', '1b5276bed81725e3cab5fa8d2491ae7fc344c8638906d8e62ee7c31696edcb52', 'a6a4ee1a9211a2be0e24cf91f9742499a46567acff4c78f62b568b34e38c08de', '44d22f065218a14d5aa04288e7553c8a6d81bb222066c74ea38571bbe922a729', 'c757c3611002031d5ce1ac79d9984d826f392e6628a0657e045c348e52b7eda2', '8a105d9f9ffbf3e747a101e48de19122931cd0cce896dc27f57d16df9dbb75ac', 'a8ff14472a8fa48bacdc11d7089a9d1054c0a786f6152f510b5d4092c22e121f', 'e746630d4b45cf2b654a14e4daaa03ad634e33d92c29c489e3ef3fcd5620c311', '16375944152e6c3e73492437880fe39d7f0123a9292d062e8e9c7d317e4b878f', '42f5214bb177fd7faf01b7943e7f313a615b2490f9109d5cefa8b24101735c32', '5cc97b8f56cdeeb02e7c96183745dc53dd8ec3ec02424107d16eb438c2c9363c', 'a816e4d1392c9c85d398ee2c5116b5de849a9823bc552d322ac8725f7c9b859e', 'c7286f8983508fdd7d94ae798cdc3950cbf65865e905c00a76838a34eb79cf2c', '6924f7b3002e9f0dff9023b70bcc9d484e643c3a2d95b0d5c853c084ad3f68ab', '2d8fce3963de03360a5d98758067925a60474b5430fd8091fc72f3c50a9d38e5', '77f9aaec42bbb94079fae33b8c564cd7f64721106f615e11f22673310efaf01b', '09f8dc962fd9202d148a0b378c9a078ea850056b4b5c360c0914d4a1de6af454', '4826376633600232b766cb8a62d4054b0f5ea45d74878bcf57356e567088300c', '82b410c949db1d81b3f197adbaaba7b82b6e497600cd9883150af2bb815caa19', '0eb73f51f3b491bd6d969a05acf2b527e6e2f09a460cb88266513ab952bd3fc6', '1076eab6753435c114e8a720c951b03da6d4e1bbbf1290f8d58ad7f97a0b8c64', '4ccf918f8b8ae99a769d89e0868a12e4af1536487652436b6c188bc99e14fdb6', '2a5cef1e9c76b52b9b56c6c021a857b0fa757897b6e3c96cc8170d5b73ba8dd8', '07267e696bfbb5af98da5a8efe2b8cf604bc9ab1ce95e4766f017473bfcd0de1', '82f56d4694c2ec964de0a4413954f87ca621628c63d7425944baeff9aa4b6dad', '01e1da53fe2751e7196114efc63dd70d9babc69b4b73c03d4b7528dcc10c05d3', 'fb8f3ca7fafc9c173404ce7f909038443a6078a0c278cb024639410e33f49f88', '44e497e2df0461bad9215c57918855022435eb6e28266916161de3f7902bb352', '84f5bc0e0be5d04b515e8e49efb393e4aec7189222b92c0555cc1be542e74549', '3195c90c03cf6a438b5684cc93128c53f794660a661e2aa85d043ca5ac7060b9', 'b5bacf05f766e143f6de9484b0b5a2d9655d62854368373bd77974b94cb722e6', '2442b9072d522cde54849b40cab26789e4af909f1dd81391cd8c87023515a21c', 'b03d79d1a547b36a28c6cba78f57b8244a4855f6b31003de3e617a5b5eddc070', 'e386562e3156c91934ceb045df46d7e847bb9afcad2794bda59be854f988befc', 'cc980749457292da3a6a4a3ce669ad487409ce72e20857e80c75741c83af7f0a', '75db9ae91b710fcf1df3553b8f9653b12d014f74ba1ee8f931870d2433e163f1', '0e313215df9694bc26777ba4ac347cb8ef73f8475d2bfed664aab722833589ae', '1094721b24c22ff67539ffeabab887f87e538bdd9ebe50b0b369de138d326802', 'fb2b9389e1455c6d64ae19158396d767d88969013b14075bcfdcc764f610108c', 'ae3bdd3a81d96e4aaa02f7d597a2684146f3af75b743bde8e31c3cf5883707db', '1b8137b4c60774716e4a492efec48060d48abd7308563d8cc76edf32d98bd759', '09732023af932d8c578c8a7ead49feb80cdb5c629cee6add2e24fcd7999c0309', '75b7020073ec0c8cedf517f1b56d554e2a5cfdf89d204633c30b863c42ed6f5f', '4be1dfb90ea542d5d84c23c0ba29b91db2491a39973839ee646eeec25c71adb4', 'c98d52f719106d13b14f27abde81ce00305cbf62889690b72da3e3ddc0286c02', '056859e4aa430e2eb983e93f08bb85d9afe9aec44f0e73263cf072df70b7c475', '870147c2dad0a0dda2dd0a9f85ef83b3c4de9a304fdff6d9fa9ccc4bde9d70c0', '26e942b0353fee8f5ac0a2c2e26c9b695c50b35c501eeb4bff343b1648b5cebc', '036168e918418eb807bc3efd361a8e66067192564da41e30e076d22be0f87935', 'a491df768673d76ae7dee4c9bf1ea1456e6c537a1f1683368d8bc6869cd89bf0', 'f6a8cfceb19b4cd796512223b8afd103c4aee7052247ebea8b50f743e9aa27b6', 'd135518ad4230c8f57a3510b3ddea8a99e2355363c9419a27340734427050729', 'cbe90e272b6be7696d3b8c171500847d2b0ae497f6911d0f9d5d8481101c4c1f', '249c961ea29438959ea2204728df24964ec80b8cd91c657715c47014f5e5a462', '1920ebb46d0cee2d379ef48c15f8f6abd01e2a183f316da235e0c3b7515feade', '6d1573b42d5f89f89b26b32cbbd32ff41660e0e8c3b3091f1cb278a42651e049', 'ec6878825845c61b3049ad5dd168197c84938e7f6d4fc938670da2528cf86317', '9829b13faebde69c2279c38cd54d524aa31acfdcc1cfba7910b9d69caa42e0dd', '2755ae7cda161df0c24e1fa9f1c3308bc9ef81a599d859668490484290ca72f4', '09d9dcfc1716808b0c62e47a771ff4d39ba71f22c8640776e65624747a995626', '71dfcd074b80de90c4955890bdbe127d12b249ed764c7c4ca23dc81c74fde71d', '3c1afbb156ee2d672ca131c7c966bc6875374a95d927848bafcc5a158edf67bb'] A "native tsn flow and detnet mpls flow differ not only by the additional mpls specific encapsulation, but detnet mpls flows have on each detnet node an associated detnet specific data structure, what defines flow related characteristics and required forwarding functions. in this example, edge nodes provide a service proxy function that ""associates"" the detnet flows and native flows at the edge of the detnet domain. this ensures that the dn flow is properly served at the edge node (and inside the domain)." {79: 1, 130: 1, 54: 1, 52: 1, 98: 1, 6: 1, 8: 1, 64: 1, 99: 1, 24: 1, 90: 2, 51: 2, 62: 4, 85: 4, 68: 3, 35: 2, 110: 2, 91: 4, 114: 2, 97: 2, 31: 2, 13: 2, 67: 2, 38: 3, 26: 2, 124: 2, 127: 2, 96: 2, 30: 3, 61: 4, 55: 2, 27: 3, 15: 2, 129: 2, 115: 2, 84: 2, 76: 5, 87: 2, 131: 4, 102: 2, 113: 4, 36: 2, 72: 3} {4: 1, 24: 1, 59: 1, 111: 1, 136: 1, 156: 1, 206: 1, 215: 1, 220: 1, 221: 1, 235: 1, 241: 1, 242: 1, 314: 1, 329: 1, 334: 1, 354: 1, 366: 1, 376: 1, 1: 8, 9: 4, 10: 2, 15: 2, 25: 4, 26: 4, 27: 2, 39: 4, 43: 2, 49: 5, 50: 4, 58: 4, 64: 2, 69: 3, 81: 5, 82: 3, 86: 2, 96: 3, 97: 2, 100: 6, 108: 2, 109: 3, 110: 3, 114: 2, 115: 3, 116: 2, 118: 5, 119: 4, 120: 2, 121: 3, 122: 3, 123: 2, 124: 3, 128: 3, 129: 3, 130: 4, 132: 3, 145: 3, 147: 3, 151: 3, 152: 3, 154: 2, 161: 2, 162: 2, 165: 2, 168: 3, 169: 2, 172: 2, 180: 3, 184: 4, 187: 4, 188: 3, 191: 2, 194: 3, 202: 4, 203: 5, 207: 2, 217: 2, 218: 7, 222: 4, 224: 2, 227: 4, 229: 2, 234: 4, 243: 3, 244: 3, 245: 3, 248: 3, 250: 3, 258: 10, 262: 3, 263: 4, 264: 2, 267: 3, 270: 2, 272: 2, 273: 4, 287: 2, 289: 2, 291: 4, 299: 4, 300: 2, 304: 2, 309: 2, 315: 2, 320: 3, 323: 3, 327: 3, 328: 2, 330: 9, 335: 2, 341: 4, 342: 5, 347: 4, 348: 4, 350: 6, 351: 4, 352: 2, 353: 2, 358: 3, 365: 2, 371: 6, 372: 4, 384: 4, 385: 3, 386: 2, 387: 2, 392: 2, 393: 3, 396: 5, 397: 6, 398: 5, 402: 2} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 53 "fig_8021_detnet illustrates how DetNet can provide services for IEEE 802.1TSN end systems, CE1 and CE2, over a DetNet enabled MPLS network. Edge nodes, E1 and E2, insert and remove required DetNet data plane encapsulation. The 'X' in the edge nodes and relay node, R1, represent a potential DetNet compound flow packet replication and elimination point. This conceptually parallels L2VPN services, and could leverage existing related solutions as discussed below." "Major clean up and simplification as data plane drafts can be referred for MPLS related details . TSN over DetNet MPLS follows the concept of RFC3985 . Description focus on Edge Nodes procedures and functions . Text covers the Edge Nodes components : ( 1 ) TSN functions ( in NSP block ) ; ( 2 ) DetNet Service Proxy ; and ( 3 ) DetNet sub - layers . Approving from teelcon review" 3486514b01b74d57f031bcf660311de328a6e0dc 3486514b01b74d57f031bcf660311de328a6e0dc draft-ietf-detnet-tsn-vpn-over-mpls cc980749457292da3a6a4a3ce669ad487409ce72e20857e80c75741c83af7f0a ['e82e49a3c764c0ede490d9e8afe0d0a379ec1e2fb734910d7e42f179709f894c', '1b5276bed81725e3cab5fa8d2491ae7fc344c8638906d8e62ee7c31696edcb52', 'a6a4ee1a9211a2be0e24cf91f9742499a46567acff4c78f62b568b34e38c08de', '44d22f065218a14d5aa04288e7553c8a6d81bb222066c74ea38571bbe922a729', 'c757c3611002031d5ce1ac79d9984d826f392e6628a0657e045c348e52b7eda2', '8a105d9f9ffbf3e747a101e48de19122931cd0cce896dc27f57d16df9dbb75ac', 'a8ff14472a8fa48bacdc11d7089a9d1054c0a786f6152f510b5d4092c22e121f', 'e746630d4b45cf2b654a14e4daaa03ad634e33d92c29c489e3ef3fcd5620c311', '16375944152e6c3e73492437880fe39d7f0123a9292d062e8e9c7d317e4b878f', '42f5214bb177fd7faf01b7943e7f313a615b2490f9109d5cefa8b24101735c32', '5cc97b8f56cdeeb02e7c96183745dc53dd8ec3ec02424107d16eb438c2c9363c', 'a816e4d1392c9c85d398ee2c5116b5de849a9823bc552d322ac8725f7c9b859e', 'c7286f8983508fdd7d94ae798cdc3950cbf65865e905c00a76838a34eb79cf2c', '6924f7b3002e9f0dff9023b70bcc9d484e643c3a2d95b0d5c853c084ad3f68ab', '2d8fce3963de03360a5d98758067925a60474b5430fd8091fc72f3c50a9d38e5', '77f9aaec42bbb94079fae33b8c564cd7f64721106f615e11f22673310efaf01b', '09f8dc962fd9202d148a0b378c9a078ea850056b4b5c360c0914d4a1de6af454', '4826376633600232b766cb8a62d4054b0f5ea45d74878bcf57356e567088300c', '82b410c949db1d81b3f197adbaaba7b82b6e497600cd9883150af2bb815caa19', '0eb73f51f3b491bd6d969a05acf2b527e6e2f09a460cb88266513ab952bd3fc6', '1076eab6753435c114e8a720c951b03da6d4e1bbbf1290f8d58ad7f97a0b8c64', '4ccf918f8b8ae99a769d89e0868a12e4af1536487652436b6c188bc99e14fdb6', '2a5cef1e9c76b52b9b56c6c021a857b0fa757897b6e3c96cc8170d5b73ba8dd8', '07267e696bfbb5af98da5a8efe2b8cf604bc9ab1ce95e4766f017473bfcd0de1', '82f56d4694c2ec964de0a4413954f87ca621628c63d7425944baeff9aa4b6dad', '01e1da53fe2751e7196114efc63dd70d9babc69b4b73c03d4b7528dcc10c05d3', 'fb8f3ca7fafc9c173404ce7f909038443a6078a0c278cb024639410e33f49f88', '44e497e2df0461bad9215c57918855022435eb6e28266916161de3f7902bb352', '84f5bc0e0be5d04b515e8e49efb393e4aec7189222b92c0555cc1be542e74549', '3195c90c03cf6a438b5684cc93128c53f794660a661e2aa85d043ca5ac7060b9', 'b5bacf05f766e143f6de9484b0b5a2d9655d62854368373bd77974b94cb722e6', '2442b9072d522cde54849b40cab26789e4af909f1dd81391cd8c87023515a21c', 'b03d79d1a547b36a28c6cba78f57b8244a4855f6b31003de3e617a5b5eddc070', 'e386562e3156c91934ceb045df46d7e847bb9afcad2794bda59be854f988befc', 'cc980749457292da3a6a4a3ce669ad487409ce72e20857e80c75741c83af7f0a', '75db9ae91b710fcf1df3553b8f9653b12d014f74ba1ee8f931870d2433e163f1', '0e313215df9694bc26777ba4ac347cb8ef73f8475d2bfed664aab722833589ae', '1094721b24c22ff67539ffeabab887f87e538bdd9ebe50b0b369de138d326802', 'fb2b9389e1455c6d64ae19158396d767d88969013b14075bcfdcc764f610108c', 'ae3bdd3a81d96e4aaa02f7d597a2684146f3af75b743bde8e31c3cf5883707db', '1b8137b4c60774716e4a492efec48060d48abd7308563d8cc76edf32d98bd759', '09732023af932d8c578c8a7ead49feb80cdb5c629cee6add2e24fcd7999c0309', '75b7020073ec0c8cedf517f1b56d554e2a5cfdf89d204633c30b863c42ed6f5f', '4be1dfb90ea542d5d84c23c0ba29b91db2491a39973839ee646eeec25c71adb4', 'c98d52f719106d13b14f27abde81ce00305cbf62889690b72da3e3ddc0286c02', '056859e4aa430e2eb983e93f08bb85d9afe9aec44f0e73263cf072df70b7c475', '870147c2dad0a0dda2dd0a9f85ef83b3c4de9a304fdff6d9fa9ccc4bde9d70c0', '26e942b0353fee8f5ac0a2c2e26c9b695c50b35c501eeb4bff343b1648b5cebc', '036168e918418eb807bc3efd361a8e66067192564da41e30e076d22be0f87935', 'a491df768673d76ae7dee4c9bf1ea1456e6c537a1f1683368d8bc6869cd89bf0', 'f6a8cfceb19b4cd796512223b8afd103c4aee7052247ebea8b50f743e9aa27b6', 'd135518ad4230c8f57a3510b3ddea8a99e2355363c9419a27340734427050729', 'cbe90e272b6be7696d3b8c171500847d2b0ae497f6911d0f9d5d8481101c4c1f', '249c961ea29438959ea2204728df24964ec80b8cd91c657715c47014f5e5a462', '1920ebb46d0cee2d379ef48c15f8f6abd01e2a183f316da235e0c3b7515feade', '6d1573b42d5f89f89b26b32cbbd32ff41660e0e8c3b3091f1cb278a42651e049', 'ec6878825845c61b3049ad5dd168197c84938e7f6d4fc938670da2528cf86317', '9829b13faebde69c2279c38cd54d524aa31acfdcc1cfba7910b9d69caa42e0dd', '2755ae7cda161df0c24e1fa9f1c3308bc9ef81a599d859668490484290ca72f4', '09d9dcfc1716808b0c62e47a771ff4d39ba71f22c8640776e65624747a995626', '71dfcd074b80de90c4955890bdbe127d12b249ed764c7c4ca23dc81c74fde71d', '3c1afbb156ee2d672ca131c7c966bc6875374a95d927848bafcc5a158edf67bb'] A "fig_8021_detnet illustrates how detnet can provide services for ieee 802.1tsn end systems, ce1 and ce2, over a detnet enabled mpls network. edge nodes, e1 and e2, insert and remove required detnet data plane encapsulation. the 'x' in the edge nodes and relay node, r1, represent a potential detnet compound flow packet replication and elimination point. this conceptually parallels l2vpn services, and could leverage existing related solutions as discussed below." {79: 1, 130: 1, 54: 1, 52: 1, 98: 1, 6: 1, 8: 1, 64: 1, 99: 1, 24: 1, 90: 2, 51: 2, 62: 4, 85: 4, 68: 3, 35: 2, 110: 2, 91: 4, 114: 2, 97: 2, 31: 2, 13: 2, 67: 2, 38: 3, 26: 2, 124: 2, 127: 2, 96: 2, 30: 3, 61: 4, 55: 2, 27: 3, 15: 2, 129: 2, 115: 2, 84: 2, 76: 5, 87: 2, 131: 4, 102: 2, 113: 4, 36: 2, 72: 3} {4: 1, 24: 1, 59: 1, 111: 1, 136: 1, 156: 1, 206: 1, 215: 1, 220: 1, 221: 1, 235: 1, 241: 1, 242: 1, 314: 1, 329: 1, 334: 1, 354: 1, 366: 1, 376: 1, 1: 8, 9: 4, 10: 2, 15: 2, 25: 4, 26: 4, 27: 2, 39: 4, 43: 2, 49: 5, 50: 4, 58: 4, 64: 2, 69: 3, 81: 5, 82: 3, 86: 2, 96: 3, 97: 2, 100: 6, 108: 2, 109: 3, 110: 3, 114: 2, 115: 3, 116: 2, 118: 5, 119: 4, 120: 2, 121: 3, 122: 3, 123: 2, 124: 3, 128: 3, 129: 3, 130: 4, 132: 3, 145: 3, 147: 3, 151: 3, 152: 3, 154: 2, 161: 2, 162: 2, 165: 2, 168: 3, 169: 2, 172: 2, 180: 3, 184: 4, 187: 4, 188: 3, 191: 2, 194: 3, 202: 4, 203: 5, 207: 2, 217: 2, 218: 7, 222: 4, 224: 2, 227: 4, 229: 2, 234: 4, 243: 3, 244: 3, 245: 3, 248: 3, 250: 3, 258: 10, 262: 3, 263: 4, 264: 2, 267: 3, 270: 2, 272: 2, 273: 4, 287: 2, 289: 2, 291: 4, 299: 4, 300: 2, 304: 2, 309: 2, 315: 2, 320: 3, 323: 3, 327: 3, 328: 2, 330: 9, 335: 2, 341: 4, 342: 5, 347: 4, 348: 4, 350: 6, 351: 4, 352: 2, 353: 2, 358: 3, 365: 2, 371: 6, 372: 4, 384: 4, 385: 3, 386: 2, 387: 2, 392: 2, 393: 3, 396: 5, 397: 6, 398: 5, 402: 2} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 53 "Use of allocated resources (queuing, policing, shaping) to ensure that the congestion-related loss and latency/jitter requirements of a DetNet flow are met." "Major clean up and simplification as data plane drafts can be referred for MPLS related details . TSN over DetNet MPLS follows the concept of RFC3985 . Description focus on Edge Nodes procedures and functions . Text covers the Edge Nodes components : ( 1 ) TSN functions ( in NSP block ) ; ( 2 ) DetNet Service Proxy ; and ( 3 ) DetNet sub - layers . Approving from teelcon review" 3486514b01b74d57f031bcf660311de328a6e0dc 3486514b01b74d57f031bcf660311de328a6e0dc draft-ietf-detnet-tsn-vpn-over-mpls ae3bdd3a81d96e4aaa02f7d597a2684146f3af75b743bde8e31c3cf5883707db ['e82e49a3c764c0ede490d9e8afe0d0a379ec1e2fb734910d7e42f179709f894c', '1b5276bed81725e3cab5fa8d2491ae7fc344c8638906d8e62ee7c31696edcb52', 'a6a4ee1a9211a2be0e24cf91f9742499a46567acff4c78f62b568b34e38c08de', '44d22f065218a14d5aa04288e7553c8a6d81bb222066c74ea38571bbe922a729', 'c757c3611002031d5ce1ac79d9984d826f392e6628a0657e045c348e52b7eda2', '8a105d9f9ffbf3e747a101e48de19122931cd0cce896dc27f57d16df9dbb75ac', 'a8ff14472a8fa48bacdc11d7089a9d1054c0a786f6152f510b5d4092c22e121f', 'e746630d4b45cf2b654a14e4daaa03ad634e33d92c29c489e3ef3fcd5620c311', '16375944152e6c3e73492437880fe39d7f0123a9292d062e8e9c7d317e4b878f', '42f5214bb177fd7faf01b7943e7f313a615b2490f9109d5cefa8b24101735c32', '5cc97b8f56cdeeb02e7c96183745dc53dd8ec3ec02424107d16eb438c2c9363c', 'a816e4d1392c9c85d398ee2c5116b5de849a9823bc552d322ac8725f7c9b859e', 'c7286f8983508fdd7d94ae798cdc3950cbf65865e905c00a76838a34eb79cf2c', '6924f7b3002e9f0dff9023b70bcc9d484e643c3a2d95b0d5c853c084ad3f68ab', '2d8fce3963de03360a5d98758067925a60474b5430fd8091fc72f3c50a9d38e5', '77f9aaec42bbb94079fae33b8c564cd7f64721106f615e11f22673310efaf01b', '09f8dc962fd9202d148a0b378c9a078ea850056b4b5c360c0914d4a1de6af454', '4826376633600232b766cb8a62d4054b0f5ea45d74878bcf57356e567088300c', '82b410c949db1d81b3f197adbaaba7b82b6e497600cd9883150af2bb815caa19', '0eb73f51f3b491bd6d969a05acf2b527e6e2f09a460cb88266513ab952bd3fc6', '1076eab6753435c114e8a720c951b03da6d4e1bbbf1290f8d58ad7f97a0b8c64', '4ccf918f8b8ae99a769d89e0868a12e4af1536487652436b6c188bc99e14fdb6', '2a5cef1e9c76b52b9b56c6c021a857b0fa757897b6e3c96cc8170d5b73ba8dd8', '07267e696bfbb5af98da5a8efe2b8cf604bc9ab1ce95e4766f017473bfcd0de1', '82f56d4694c2ec964de0a4413954f87ca621628c63d7425944baeff9aa4b6dad', '01e1da53fe2751e7196114efc63dd70d9babc69b4b73c03d4b7528dcc10c05d3', 'fb8f3ca7fafc9c173404ce7f909038443a6078a0c278cb024639410e33f49f88', '44e497e2df0461bad9215c57918855022435eb6e28266916161de3f7902bb352', '84f5bc0e0be5d04b515e8e49efb393e4aec7189222b92c0555cc1be542e74549', '3195c90c03cf6a438b5684cc93128c53f794660a661e2aa85d043ca5ac7060b9', 'b5bacf05f766e143f6de9484b0b5a2d9655d62854368373bd77974b94cb722e6', '2442b9072d522cde54849b40cab26789e4af909f1dd81391cd8c87023515a21c', 'b03d79d1a547b36a28c6cba78f57b8244a4855f6b31003de3e617a5b5eddc070', 'e386562e3156c91934ceb045df46d7e847bb9afcad2794bda59be854f988befc', 'cc980749457292da3a6a4a3ce669ad487409ce72e20857e80c75741c83af7f0a', '75db9ae91b710fcf1df3553b8f9653b12d014f74ba1ee8f931870d2433e163f1', '0e313215df9694bc26777ba4ac347cb8ef73f8475d2bfed664aab722833589ae', '1094721b24c22ff67539ffeabab887f87e538bdd9ebe50b0b369de138d326802', 'fb2b9389e1455c6d64ae19158396d767d88969013b14075bcfdcc764f610108c', 'ae3bdd3a81d96e4aaa02f7d597a2684146f3af75b743bde8e31c3cf5883707db', '1b8137b4c60774716e4a492efec48060d48abd7308563d8cc76edf32d98bd759', '09732023af932d8c578c8a7ead49feb80cdb5c629cee6add2e24fcd7999c0309', '75b7020073ec0c8cedf517f1b56d554e2a5cfdf89d204633c30b863c42ed6f5f', '4be1dfb90ea542d5d84c23c0ba29b91db2491a39973839ee646eeec25c71adb4', 'c98d52f719106d13b14f27abde81ce00305cbf62889690b72da3e3ddc0286c02', '056859e4aa430e2eb983e93f08bb85d9afe9aec44f0e73263cf072df70b7c475', '870147c2dad0a0dda2dd0a9f85ef83b3c4de9a304fdff6d9fa9ccc4bde9d70c0', '26e942b0353fee8f5ac0a2c2e26c9b695c50b35c501eeb4bff343b1648b5cebc', '036168e918418eb807bc3efd361a8e66067192564da41e30e076d22be0f87935', 'a491df768673d76ae7dee4c9bf1ea1456e6c537a1f1683368d8bc6869cd89bf0', 'f6a8cfceb19b4cd796512223b8afd103c4aee7052247ebea8b50f743e9aa27b6', 'd135518ad4230c8f57a3510b3ddea8a99e2355363c9419a27340734427050729', 'cbe90e272b6be7696d3b8c171500847d2b0ae497f6911d0f9d5d8481101c4c1f', '249c961ea29438959ea2204728df24964ec80b8cd91c657715c47014f5e5a462', '1920ebb46d0cee2d379ef48c15f8f6abd01e2a183f316da235e0c3b7515feade', '6d1573b42d5f89f89b26b32cbbd32ff41660e0e8c3b3091f1cb278a42651e049', 'ec6878825845c61b3049ad5dd168197c84938e7f6d4fc938670da2528cf86317', '9829b13faebde69c2279c38cd54d524aa31acfdcc1cfba7910b9d69caa42e0dd', '2755ae7cda161df0c24e1fa9f1c3308bc9ef81a599d859668490484290ca72f4', '09d9dcfc1716808b0c62e47a771ff4d39ba71f22c8640776e65624747a995626', '71dfcd074b80de90c4955890bdbe127d12b249ed764c7c4ca23dc81c74fde71d', '3c1afbb156ee2d672ca131c7c966bc6875374a95d927848bafcc5a158edf67bb'] A "use of allocated resources (queuing, policing, shaping) to ensure that the congestion-related loss and latency/jitter requirements of a detnet flow are met." {79: 1, 130: 1, 54: 1, 52: 1, 98: 1, 6: 1, 8: 1, 64: 1, 99: 1, 24: 1, 90: 2, 51: 2, 62: 4, 85: 4, 68: 3, 35: 2, 110: 2, 91: 4, 114: 2, 97: 2, 31: 2, 13: 2, 67: 2, 38: 3, 26: 2, 124: 2, 127: 2, 96: 2, 30: 3, 61: 4, 55: 2, 27: 3, 15: 2, 129: 2, 115: 2, 84: 2, 76: 5, 87: 2, 131: 4, 102: 2, 113: 4, 36: 2, 72: 3} {4: 1, 24: 1, 59: 1, 111: 1, 136: 1, 156: 1, 206: 1, 215: 1, 220: 1, 221: 1, 235: 1, 241: 1, 242: 1, 314: 1, 329: 1, 334: 1, 354: 1, 366: 1, 376: 1, 1: 8, 9: 4, 10: 2, 15: 2, 25: 4, 26: 4, 27: 2, 39: 4, 43: 2, 49: 5, 50: 4, 58: 4, 64: 2, 69: 3, 81: 5, 82: 3, 86: 2, 96: 3, 97: 2, 100: 6, 108: 2, 109: 3, 110: 3, 114: 2, 115: 3, 116: 2, 118: 5, 119: 4, 120: 2, 121: 3, 122: 3, 123: 2, 124: 3, 128: 3, 129: 3, 130: 4, 132: 3, 145: 3, 147: 3, 151: 3, 152: 3, 154: 2, 161: 2, 162: 2, 165: 2, 168: 3, 169: 2, 172: 2, 180: 3, 184: 4, 187: 4, 188: 3, 191: 2, 194: 3, 202: 4, 203: 5, 207: 2, 217: 2, 218: 7, 222: 4, 224: 2, 227: 4, 229: 2, 234: 4, 243: 3, 244: 3, 245: 3, 248: 3, 250: 3, 258: 10, 262: 3, 263: 4, 264: 2, 267: 3, 270: 2, 272: 2, 273: 4, 287: 2, 289: 2, 291: 4, 299: 4, 300: 2, 304: 2, 309: 2, 315: 2, 320: 3, 323: 3, 327: 3, 328: 2, 330: 9, 335: 2, 341: 4, 342: 5, 347: 4, 348: 4, 350: 6, 351: 4, 352: 2, 353: 2, 358: 3, 365: 2, 371: 6, 372: 4, 384: 4, 385: 3, 386: 2, 387: 2, 392: 2, 393: 3, 396: 5, 397: 6, 398: 5, 402: 2} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 53 "Use of a specific path for a flow. This limits misordering and bounds latency." "Major clean up and simplification as data plane drafts can be referred for MPLS related details . TSN over DetNet MPLS follows the concept of RFC3985 . Description focus on Edge Nodes procedures and functions . Text covers the Edge Nodes components : ( 1 ) TSN functions ( in NSP block ) ; ( 2 ) DetNet Service Proxy ; and ( 3 ) DetNet sub - layers . Approving from teelcon review" 3486514b01b74d57f031bcf660311de328a6e0dc 3486514b01b74d57f031bcf660311de328a6e0dc draft-ietf-detnet-tsn-vpn-over-mpls fb2b9389e1455c6d64ae19158396d767d88969013b14075bcfdcc764f610108c ['e82e49a3c764c0ede490d9e8afe0d0a379ec1e2fb734910d7e42f179709f894c', '1b5276bed81725e3cab5fa8d2491ae7fc344c8638906d8e62ee7c31696edcb52', 'a6a4ee1a9211a2be0e24cf91f9742499a46567acff4c78f62b568b34e38c08de', '44d22f065218a14d5aa04288e7553c8a6d81bb222066c74ea38571bbe922a729', 'c757c3611002031d5ce1ac79d9984d826f392e6628a0657e045c348e52b7eda2', '8a105d9f9ffbf3e747a101e48de19122931cd0cce896dc27f57d16df9dbb75ac', 'a8ff14472a8fa48bacdc11d7089a9d1054c0a786f6152f510b5d4092c22e121f', 'e746630d4b45cf2b654a14e4daaa03ad634e33d92c29c489e3ef3fcd5620c311', '16375944152e6c3e73492437880fe39d7f0123a9292d062e8e9c7d317e4b878f', '42f5214bb177fd7faf01b7943e7f313a615b2490f9109d5cefa8b24101735c32', '5cc97b8f56cdeeb02e7c96183745dc53dd8ec3ec02424107d16eb438c2c9363c', 'a816e4d1392c9c85d398ee2c5116b5de849a9823bc552d322ac8725f7c9b859e', 'c7286f8983508fdd7d94ae798cdc3950cbf65865e905c00a76838a34eb79cf2c', '6924f7b3002e9f0dff9023b70bcc9d484e643c3a2d95b0d5c853c084ad3f68ab', '2d8fce3963de03360a5d98758067925a60474b5430fd8091fc72f3c50a9d38e5', '77f9aaec42bbb94079fae33b8c564cd7f64721106f615e11f22673310efaf01b', '09f8dc962fd9202d148a0b378c9a078ea850056b4b5c360c0914d4a1de6af454', '4826376633600232b766cb8a62d4054b0f5ea45d74878bcf57356e567088300c', '82b410c949db1d81b3f197adbaaba7b82b6e497600cd9883150af2bb815caa19', '0eb73f51f3b491bd6d969a05acf2b527e6e2f09a460cb88266513ab952bd3fc6', '1076eab6753435c114e8a720c951b03da6d4e1bbbf1290f8d58ad7f97a0b8c64', '4ccf918f8b8ae99a769d89e0868a12e4af1536487652436b6c188bc99e14fdb6', '2a5cef1e9c76b52b9b56c6c021a857b0fa757897b6e3c96cc8170d5b73ba8dd8', '07267e696bfbb5af98da5a8efe2b8cf604bc9ab1ce95e4766f017473bfcd0de1', '82f56d4694c2ec964de0a4413954f87ca621628c63d7425944baeff9aa4b6dad', '01e1da53fe2751e7196114efc63dd70d9babc69b4b73c03d4b7528dcc10c05d3', 'fb8f3ca7fafc9c173404ce7f909038443a6078a0c278cb024639410e33f49f88', '44e497e2df0461bad9215c57918855022435eb6e28266916161de3f7902bb352', '84f5bc0e0be5d04b515e8e49efb393e4aec7189222b92c0555cc1be542e74549', '3195c90c03cf6a438b5684cc93128c53f794660a661e2aa85d043ca5ac7060b9', 'b5bacf05f766e143f6de9484b0b5a2d9655d62854368373bd77974b94cb722e6', '2442b9072d522cde54849b40cab26789e4af909f1dd81391cd8c87023515a21c', 'b03d79d1a547b36a28c6cba78f57b8244a4855f6b31003de3e617a5b5eddc070', 'e386562e3156c91934ceb045df46d7e847bb9afcad2794bda59be854f988befc', 'cc980749457292da3a6a4a3ce669ad487409ce72e20857e80c75741c83af7f0a', '75db9ae91b710fcf1df3553b8f9653b12d014f74ba1ee8f931870d2433e163f1', '0e313215df9694bc26777ba4ac347cb8ef73f8475d2bfed664aab722833589ae', '1094721b24c22ff67539ffeabab887f87e538bdd9ebe50b0b369de138d326802', 'fb2b9389e1455c6d64ae19158396d767d88969013b14075bcfdcc764f610108c', 'ae3bdd3a81d96e4aaa02f7d597a2684146f3af75b743bde8e31c3cf5883707db', '1b8137b4c60774716e4a492efec48060d48abd7308563d8cc76edf32d98bd759', '09732023af932d8c578c8a7ead49feb80cdb5c629cee6add2e24fcd7999c0309', '75b7020073ec0c8cedf517f1b56d554e2a5cfdf89d204633c30b863c42ed6f5f', '4be1dfb90ea542d5d84c23c0ba29b91db2491a39973839ee646eeec25c71adb4', 'c98d52f719106d13b14f27abde81ce00305cbf62889690b72da3e3ddc0286c02', '056859e4aa430e2eb983e93f08bb85d9afe9aec44f0e73263cf072df70b7c475', '870147c2dad0a0dda2dd0a9f85ef83b3c4de9a304fdff6d9fa9ccc4bde9d70c0', '26e942b0353fee8f5ac0a2c2e26c9b695c50b35c501eeb4bff343b1648b5cebc', '036168e918418eb807bc3efd361a8e66067192564da41e30e076d22be0f87935', 'a491df768673d76ae7dee4c9bf1ea1456e6c537a1f1683368d8bc6869cd89bf0', 'f6a8cfceb19b4cd796512223b8afd103c4aee7052247ebea8b50f743e9aa27b6', 'd135518ad4230c8f57a3510b3ddea8a99e2355363c9419a27340734427050729', 'cbe90e272b6be7696d3b8c171500847d2b0ae497f6911d0f9d5d8481101c4c1f', '249c961ea29438959ea2204728df24964ec80b8cd91c657715c47014f5e5a462', '1920ebb46d0cee2d379ef48c15f8f6abd01e2a183f316da235e0c3b7515feade', '6d1573b42d5f89f89b26b32cbbd32ff41660e0e8c3b3091f1cb278a42651e049', 'ec6878825845c61b3049ad5dd168197c84938e7f6d4fc938670da2528cf86317', '9829b13faebde69c2279c38cd54d524aa31acfdcc1cfba7910b9d69caa42e0dd', '2755ae7cda161df0c24e1fa9f1c3308bc9ef81a599d859668490484290ca72f4', '09d9dcfc1716808b0c62e47a771ff4d39ba71f22c8640776e65624747a995626', '71dfcd074b80de90c4955890bdbe127d12b249ed764c7c4ca23dc81c74fde71d', '3c1afbb156ee2d672ca131c7c966bc6875374a95d927848bafcc5a158edf67bb'] A "use of a specific path for a flow. this limits misordering and bounds latency." {79: 1, 130: 1, 54: 1, 52: 1, 98: 1, 6: 1, 8: 1, 64: 1, 99: 1, 24: 1, 90: 2, 51: 2, 62: 4, 85: 4, 68: 3, 35: 2, 110: 2, 91: 4, 114: 2, 97: 2, 31: 2, 13: 2, 67: 2, 38: 3, 26: 2, 124: 2, 127: 2, 96: 2, 30: 3, 61: 4, 55: 2, 27: 3, 15: 2, 129: 2, 115: 2, 84: 2, 76: 5, 87: 2, 131: 4, 102: 2, 113: 4, 36: 2, 72: 3} {4: 1, 24: 1, 59: 1, 111: 1, 136: 1, 156: 1, 206: 1, 215: 1, 220: 1, 221: 1, 235: 1, 241: 1, 242: 1, 314: 1, 329: 1, 334: 1, 354: 1, 366: 1, 376: 1, 1: 8, 9: 4, 10: 2, 15: 2, 25: 4, 26: 4, 27: 2, 39: 4, 43: 2, 49: 5, 50: 4, 58: 4, 64: 2, 69: 3, 81: 5, 82: 3, 86: 2, 96: 3, 97: 2, 100: 6, 108: 2, 109: 3, 110: 3, 114: 2, 115: 3, 116: 2, 118: 5, 119: 4, 120: 2, 121: 3, 122: 3, 123: 2, 124: 3, 128: 3, 129: 3, 130: 4, 132: 3, 145: 3, 147: 3, 151: 3, 152: 3, 154: 2, 161: 2, 162: 2, 165: 2, 168: 3, 169: 2, 172: 2, 180: 3, 184: 4, 187: 4, 188: 3, 191: 2, 194: 3, 202: 4, 203: 5, 207: 2, 217: 2, 218: 7, 222: 4, 224: 2, 227: 4, 229: 2, 234: 4, 243: 3, 244: 3, 245: 3, 248: 3, 250: 3, 258: 10, 262: 3, 263: 4, 264: 2, 267: 3, 270: 2, 272: 2, 273: 4, 287: 2, 289: 2, 291: 4, 299: 4, 300: 2, 304: 2, 309: 2, 315: 2, 320: 3, 323: 3, 327: 3, 328: 2, 330: 9, 335: 2, 341: 4, 342: 5, 347: 4, 348: 4, 350: 6, 351: 4, 352: 2, 353: 2, 358: 3, 365: 2, 371: 6, 372: 4, 384: 4, 385: 3, 386: 2, 387: 2, 392: 2, 393: 3, 396: 5, 397: 6, 398: 5, 402: 2} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 53 "Which in the case of this document primarily relates to replication and elimination. Changing the explicit path after a failure is detected in order to restore delivery of the required DetNet service characteristics is also possible. Path changes, even in the case of failure recovery, can lead to the out of order delivery of data." "Major clean up and simplification as data plane drafts can be referred for MPLS related details . TSN over DetNet MPLS follows the concept of RFC3985 . Description focus on Edge Nodes procedures and functions . Text covers the Edge Nodes components : ( 1 ) TSN functions ( in NSP block ) ; ( 2 ) DetNet Service Proxy ; and ( 3 ) DetNet sub - layers . Approving from teelcon review" 3486514b01b74d57f031bcf660311de328a6e0dc 3486514b01b74d57f031bcf660311de328a6e0dc draft-ietf-detnet-tsn-vpn-over-mpls 9829b13faebde69c2279c38cd54d524aa31acfdcc1cfba7910b9d69caa42e0dd ['e82e49a3c764c0ede490d9e8afe0d0a379ec1e2fb734910d7e42f179709f894c', '1b5276bed81725e3cab5fa8d2491ae7fc344c8638906d8e62ee7c31696edcb52', 'a6a4ee1a9211a2be0e24cf91f9742499a46567acff4c78f62b568b34e38c08de', '44d22f065218a14d5aa04288e7553c8a6d81bb222066c74ea38571bbe922a729', 'c757c3611002031d5ce1ac79d9984d826f392e6628a0657e045c348e52b7eda2', '8a105d9f9ffbf3e747a101e48de19122931cd0cce896dc27f57d16df9dbb75ac', 'a8ff14472a8fa48bacdc11d7089a9d1054c0a786f6152f510b5d4092c22e121f', 'e746630d4b45cf2b654a14e4daaa03ad634e33d92c29c489e3ef3fcd5620c311', '16375944152e6c3e73492437880fe39d7f0123a9292d062e8e9c7d317e4b878f', '42f5214bb177fd7faf01b7943e7f313a615b2490f9109d5cefa8b24101735c32', '5cc97b8f56cdeeb02e7c96183745dc53dd8ec3ec02424107d16eb438c2c9363c', 'a816e4d1392c9c85d398ee2c5116b5de849a9823bc552d322ac8725f7c9b859e', 'c7286f8983508fdd7d94ae798cdc3950cbf65865e905c00a76838a34eb79cf2c', '6924f7b3002e9f0dff9023b70bcc9d484e643c3a2d95b0d5c853c084ad3f68ab', '2d8fce3963de03360a5d98758067925a60474b5430fd8091fc72f3c50a9d38e5', '77f9aaec42bbb94079fae33b8c564cd7f64721106f615e11f22673310efaf01b', '09f8dc962fd9202d148a0b378c9a078ea850056b4b5c360c0914d4a1de6af454', '4826376633600232b766cb8a62d4054b0f5ea45d74878bcf57356e567088300c', '82b410c949db1d81b3f197adbaaba7b82b6e497600cd9883150af2bb815caa19', '0eb73f51f3b491bd6d969a05acf2b527e6e2f09a460cb88266513ab952bd3fc6', '1076eab6753435c114e8a720c951b03da6d4e1bbbf1290f8d58ad7f97a0b8c64', '4ccf918f8b8ae99a769d89e0868a12e4af1536487652436b6c188bc99e14fdb6', '2a5cef1e9c76b52b9b56c6c021a857b0fa757897b6e3c96cc8170d5b73ba8dd8', '07267e696bfbb5af98da5a8efe2b8cf604bc9ab1ce95e4766f017473bfcd0de1', '82f56d4694c2ec964de0a4413954f87ca621628c63d7425944baeff9aa4b6dad', '01e1da53fe2751e7196114efc63dd70d9babc69b4b73c03d4b7528dcc10c05d3', 'fb8f3ca7fafc9c173404ce7f909038443a6078a0c278cb024639410e33f49f88', '44e497e2df0461bad9215c57918855022435eb6e28266916161de3f7902bb352', '84f5bc0e0be5d04b515e8e49efb393e4aec7189222b92c0555cc1be542e74549', '3195c90c03cf6a438b5684cc93128c53f794660a661e2aa85d043ca5ac7060b9', 'b5bacf05f766e143f6de9484b0b5a2d9655d62854368373bd77974b94cb722e6', '2442b9072d522cde54849b40cab26789e4af909f1dd81391cd8c87023515a21c', 'b03d79d1a547b36a28c6cba78f57b8244a4855f6b31003de3e617a5b5eddc070', 'e386562e3156c91934ceb045df46d7e847bb9afcad2794bda59be854f988befc', 'cc980749457292da3a6a4a3ce669ad487409ce72e20857e80c75741c83af7f0a', '75db9ae91b710fcf1df3553b8f9653b12d014f74ba1ee8f931870d2433e163f1', '0e313215df9694bc26777ba4ac347cb8ef73f8475d2bfed664aab722833589ae', '1094721b24c22ff67539ffeabab887f87e538bdd9ebe50b0b369de138d326802', 'fb2b9389e1455c6d64ae19158396d767d88969013b14075bcfdcc764f610108c', 'ae3bdd3a81d96e4aaa02f7d597a2684146f3af75b743bde8e31c3cf5883707db', '1b8137b4c60774716e4a492efec48060d48abd7308563d8cc76edf32d98bd759', '09732023af932d8c578c8a7ead49feb80cdb5c629cee6add2e24fcd7999c0309', '75b7020073ec0c8cedf517f1b56d554e2a5cfdf89d204633c30b863c42ed6f5f', '4be1dfb90ea542d5d84c23c0ba29b91db2491a39973839ee646eeec25c71adb4', 'c98d52f719106d13b14f27abde81ce00305cbf62889690b72da3e3ddc0286c02', '056859e4aa430e2eb983e93f08bb85d9afe9aec44f0e73263cf072df70b7c475', '870147c2dad0a0dda2dd0a9f85ef83b3c4de9a304fdff6d9fa9ccc4bde9d70c0', '26e942b0353fee8f5ac0a2c2e26c9b695c50b35c501eeb4bff343b1648b5cebc', '036168e918418eb807bc3efd361a8e66067192564da41e30e076d22be0f87935', 'a491df768673d76ae7dee4c9bf1ea1456e6c537a1f1683368d8bc6869cd89bf0', 'f6a8cfceb19b4cd796512223b8afd103c4aee7052247ebea8b50f743e9aa27b6', 'd135518ad4230c8f57a3510b3ddea8a99e2355363c9419a27340734427050729', 'cbe90e272b6be7696d3b8c171500847d2b0ae497f6911d0f9d5d8481101c4c1f', '249c961ea29438959ea2204728df24964ec80b8cd91c657715c47014f5e5a462', '1920ebb46d0cee2d379ef48c15f8f6abd01e2a183f316da235e0c3b7515feade', '6d1573b42d5f89f89b26b32cbbd32ff41660e0e8c3b3091f1cb278a42651e049', 'ec6878825845c61b3049ad5dd168197c84938e7f6d4fc938670da2528cf86317', '9829b13faebde69c2279c38cd54d524aa31acfdcc1cfba7910b9d69caa42e0dd', '2755ae7cda161df0c24e1fa9f1c3308bc9ef81a599d859668490484290ca72f4', '09d9dcfc1716808b0c62e47a771ff4d39ba71f22c8640776e65624747a995626', '71dfcd074b80de90c4955890bdbe127d12b249ed764c7c4ca23dc81c74fde71d', '3c1afbb156ee2d672ca131c7c966bc6875374a95d927848bafcc5a158edf67bb'] A "which in the case of this document primarily relates to replication and elimination. changing the explicit path after a failure is detected in order to restore delivery of the required detnet service characteristics is also possible. path changes, even in the case of failure recovery, can lead to the out of order delivery of data." {79: 1, 130: 1, 54: 1, 52: 1, 98: 1, 6: 1, 8: 1, 64: 1, 99: 1, 24: 1, 90: 2, 51: 2, 62: 4, 85: 4, 68: 3, 35: 2, 110: 2, 91: 4, 114: 2, 97: 2, 31: 2, 13: 2, 67: 2, 38: 3, 26: 2, 124: 2, 127: 2, 96: 2, 30: 3, 61: 4, 55: 2, 27: 3, 15: 2, 129: 2, 115: 2, 84: 2, 76: 5, 87: 2, 131: 4, 102: 2, 113: 4, 36: 2, 72: 3} {4: 1, 24: 1, 59: 1, 111: 1, 136: 1, 156: 1, 206: 1, 215: 1, 220: 1, 221: 1, 235: 1, 241: 1, 242: 1, 314: 1, 329: 1, 334: 1, 354: 1, 366: 1, 376: 1, 1: 8, 9: 4, 10: 2, 15: 2, 25: 4, 26: 4, 27: 2, 39: 4, 43: 2, 49: 5, 50: 4, 58: 4, 64: 2, 69: 3, 81: 5, 82: 3, 86: 2, 96: 3, 97: 2, 100: 6, 108: 2, 109: 3, 110: 3, 114: 2, 115: 3, 116: 2, 118: 5, 119: 4, 120: 2, 121: 3, 122: 3, 123: 2, 124: 3, 128: 3, 129: 3, 130: 4, 132: 3, 145: 3, 147: 3, 151: 3, 152: 3, 154: 2, 161: 2, 162: 2, 165: 2, 168: 3, 169: 2, 172: 2, 180: 3, 184: 4, 187: 4, 188: 3, 191: 2, 194: 3, 202: 4, 203: 5, 207: 2, 217: 2, 218: 7, 222: 4, 224: 2, 227: 4, 229: 2, 234: 4, 243: 3, 244: 3, 245: 3, 248: 3, 250: 3, 258: 10, 262: 3, 263: 4, 264: 2, 267: 3, 270: 2, 272: 2, 273: 4, 287: 2, 289: 2, 291: 4, 299: 4, 300: 2, 304: 2, 309: 2, 315: 2, 320: 3, 323: 3, 327: 3, 328: 2, 330: 9, 335: 2, 341: 4, 342: 5, 347: 4, 348: 4, 350: 6, 351: 4, 352: 2, 353: 2, 358: 3, 365: 2, 371: 6, 372: 4, 384: 4, 385: 3, 386: 2, 387: 2, 392: 2, 393: 3, 396: 5, 397: 6, 398: 5, 402: 2} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 53 "Generally, distributing packets of the same DetNet flow over multiple paths is not recommended. Such load sharing, e.g., via ECMP or UCMP, impacts ordering and possibly jitter." "Major clean up and simplification as data plane drafts can be referred for MPLS related details . TSN over DetNet MPLS follows the concept of RFC3985 . Description focus on Edge Nodes procedures and functions . Text covers the Edge Nodes components : ( 1 ) TSN functions ( in NSP block ) ; ( 2 ) DetNet Service Proxy ; and ( 3 ) DetNet sub - layers . Approving from teelcon review" 3486514b01b74d57f031bcf660311de328a6e0dc 3486514b01b74d57f031bcf660311de328a6e0dc draft-ietf-detnet-tsn-vpn-over-mpls 26e942b0353fee8f5ac0a2c2e26c9b695c50b35c501eeb4bff343b1648b5cebc ['e82e49a3c764c0ede490d9e8afe0d0a379ec1e2fb734910d7e42f179709f894c', '1b5276bed81725e3cab5fa8d2491ae7fc344c8638906d8e62ee7c31696edcb52', 'a6a4ee1a9211a2be0e24cf91f9742499a46567acff4c78f62b568b34e38c08de', '44d22f065218a14d5aa04288e7553c8a6d81bb222066c74ea38571bbe922a729', 'c757c3611002031d5ce1ac79d9984d826f392e6628a0657e045c348e52b7eda2', '8a105d9f9ffbf3e747a101e48de19122931cd0cce896dc27f57d16df9dbb75ac', 'a8ff14472a8fa48bacdc11d7089a9d1054c0a786f6152f510b5d4092c22e121f', 'e746630d4b45cf2b654a14e4daaa03ad634e33d92c29c489e3ef3fcd5620c311', '16375944152e6c3e73492437880fe39d7f0123a9292d062e8e9c7d317e4b878f', '42f5214bb177fd7faf01b7943e7f313a615b2490f9109d5cefa8b24101735c32', '5cc97b8f56cdeeb02e7c96183745dc53dd8ec3ec02424107d16eb438c2c9363c', 'a816e4d1392c9c85d398ee2c5116b5de849a9823bc552d322ac8725f7c9b859e', 'c7286f8983508fdd7d94ae798cdc3950cbf65865e905c00a76838a34eb79cf2c', '6924f7b3002e9f0dff9023b70bcc9d484e643c3a2d95b0d5c853c084ad3f68ab', '2d8fce3963de03360a5d98758067925a60474b5430fd8091fc72f3c50a9d38e5', '77f9aaec42bbb94079fae33b8c564cd7f64721106f615e11f22673310efaf01b', '09f8dc962fd9202d148a0b378c9a078ea850056b4b5c360c0914d4a1de6af454', '4826376633600232b766cb8a62d4054b0f5ea45d74878bcf57356e567088300c', '82b410c949db1d81b3f197adbaaba7b82b6e497600cd9883150af2bb815caa19', '0eb73f51f3b491bd6d969a05acf2b527e6e2f09a460cb88266513ab952bd3fc6', '1076eab6753435c114e8a720c951b03da6d4e1bbbf1290f8d58ad7f97a0b8c64', '4ccf918f8b8ae99a769d89e0868a12e4af1536487652436b6c188bc99e14fdb6', '2a5cef1e9c76b52b9b56c6c021a857b0fa757897b6e3c96cc8170d5b73ba8dd8', '07267e696bfbb5af98da5a8efe2b8cf604bc9ab1ce95e4766f017473bfcd0de1', '82f56d4694c2ec964de0a4413954f87ca621628c63d7425944baeff9aa4b6dad', '01e1da53fe2751e7196114efc63dd70d9babc69b4b73c03d4b7528dcc10c05d3', 'fb8f3ca7fafc9c173404ce7f909038443a6078a0c278cb024639410e33f49f88', '44e497e2df0461bad9215c57918855022435eb6e28266916161de3f7902bb352', '84f5bc0e0be5d04b515e8e49efb393e4aec7189222b92c0555cc1be542e74549', '3195c90c03cf6a438b5684cc93128c53f794660a661e2aa85d043ca5ac7060b9', 'b5bacf05f766e143f6de9484b0b5a2d9655d62854368373bd77974b94cb722e6', '2442b9072d522cde54849b40cab26789e4af909f1dd81391cd8c87023515a21c', 'b03d79d1a547b36a28c6cba78f57b8244a4855f6b31003de3e617a5b5eddc070', 'e386562e3156c91934ceb045df46d7e847bb9afcad2794bda59be854f988befc', 'cc980749457292da3a6a4a3ce669ad487409ce72e20857e80c75741c83af7f0a', '75db9ae91b710fcf1df3553b8f9653b12d014f74ba1ee8f931870d2433e163f1', '0e313215df9694bc26777ba4ac347cb8ef73f8475d2bfed664aab722833589ae', '1094721b24c22ff67539ffeabab887f87e538bdd9ebe50b0b369de138d326802', 'fb2b9389e1455c6d64ae19158396d767d88969013b14075bcfdcc764f610108c', 'ae3bdd3a81d96e4aaa02f7d597a2684146f3af75b743bde8e31c3cf5883707db', '1b8137b4c60774716e4a492efec48060d48abd7308563d8cc76edf32d98bd759', '09732023af932d8c578c8a7ead49feb80cdb5c629cee6add2e24fcd7999c0309', '75b7020073ec0c8cedf517f1b56d554e2a5cfdf89d204633c30b863c42ed6f5f', '4be1dfb90ea542d5d84c23c0ba29b91db2491a39973839ee646eeec25c71adb4', 'c98d52f719106d13b14f27abde81ce00305cbf62889690b72da3e3ddc0286c02', '056859e4aa430e2eb983e93f08bb85d9afe9aec44f0e73263cf072df70b7c475', '870147c2dad0a0dda2dd0a9f85ef83b3c4de9a304fdff6d9fa9ccc4bde9d70c0', '26e942b0353fee8f5ac0a2c2e26c9b695c50b35c501eeb4bff343b1648b5cebc', '036168e918418eb807bc3efd361a8e66067192564da41e30e076d22be0f87935', 'a491df768673d76ae7dee4c9bf1ea1456e6c537a1f1683368d8bc6869cd89bf0', 'f6a8cfceb19b4cd796512223b8afd103c4aee7052247ebea8b50f743e9aa27b6', 'd135518ad4230c8f57a3510b3ddea8a99e2355363c9419a27340734427050729', 'cbe90e272b6be7696d3b8c171500847d2b0ae497f6911d0f9d5d8481101c4c1f', '249c961ea29438959ea2204728df24964ec80b8cd91c657715c47014f5e5a462', '1920ebb46d0cee2d379ef48c15f8f6abd01e2a183f316da235e0c3b7515feade', '6d1573b42d5f89f89b26b32cbbd32ff41660e0e8c3b3091f1cb278a42651e049', 'ec6878825845c61b3049ad5dd168197c84938e7f6d4fc938670da2528cf86317', '9829b13faebde69c2279c38cd54d524aa31acfdcc1cfba7910b9d69caa42e0dd', '2755ae7cda161df0c24e1fa9f1c3308bc9ef81a599d859668490484290ca72f4', '09d9dcfc1716808b0c62e47a771ff4d39ba71f22c8640776e65624747a995626', '71dfcd074b80de90c4955890bdbe127d12b249ed764c7c4ca23dc81c74fde71d', '3c1afbb156ee2d672ca131c7c966bc6875374a95d927848bafcc5a158edf67bb'] A "generally, distributing packets of the same detnet flow over multiple paths is not recommended. such load sharing, e.g., via ecmp or ucmp, impacts ordering and possibly jitter." {79: 1, 130: 1, 54: 1, 52: 1, 98: 1, 6: 1, 8: 1, 64: 1, 99: 1, 24: 1, 90: 2, 51: 2, 62: 4, 85: 4, 68: 3, 35: 2, 110: 2, 91: 4, 114: 2, 97: 2, 31: 2, 13: 2, 67: 2, 38: 3, 26: 2, 124: 2, 127: 2, 96: 2, 30: 3, 61: 4, 55: 2, 27: 3, 15: 2, 129: 2, 115: 2, 84: 2, 76: 5, 87: 2, 131: 4, 102: 2, 113: 4, 36: 2, 72: 3} {4: 1, 24: 1, 59: 1, 111: 1, 136: 1, 156: 1, 206: 1, 215: 1, 220: 1, 221: 1, 235: 1, 241: 1, 242: 1, 314: 1, 329: 1, 334: 1, 354: 1, 366: 1, 376: 1, 1: 8, 9: 4, 10: 2, 15: 2, 25: 4, 26: 4, 27: 2, 39: 4, 43: 2, 49: 5, 50: 4, 58: 4, 64: 2, 69: 3, 81: 5, 82: 3, 86: 2, 96: 3, 97: 2, 100: 6, 108: 2, 109: 3, 110: 3, 114: 2, 115: 3, 116: 2, 118: 5, 119: 4, 120: 2, 121: 3, 122: 3, 123: 2, 124: 3, 128: 3, 129: 3, 130: 4, 132: 3, 145: 3, 147: 3, 151: 3, 152: 3, 154: 2, 161: 2, 162: 2, 165: 2, 168: 3, 169: 2, 172: 2, 180: 3, 184: 4, 187: 4, 188: 3, 191: 2, 194: 3, 202: 4, 203: 5, 207: 2, 217: 2, 218: 7, 222: 4, 224: 2, 227: 4, 229: 2, 234: 4, 243: 3, 244: 3, 245: 3, 248: 3, 250: 3, 258: 10, 262: 3, 263: 4, 264: 2, 267: 3, 270: 2, 272: 2, 273: 4, 287: 2, 289: 2, 291: 4, 299: 4, 300: 2, 304: 2, 309: 2, 315: 2, 320: 3, 323: 3, 327: 3, 328: 2, 330: 9, 335: 2, 341: 4, 342: 5, 347: 4, 348: 4, 350: 6, 351: 4, 352: 2, 353: 2, 358: 3, 365: 2, 371: 6, 372: 4, 384: 4, 385: 3, 386: 2, 387: 2, 392: 2, 393: 3, 396: 5, 397: 6, 398: 5, 402: 2} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 53 For example, to support identification of misbehaving flows. "Major clean up and simplification as data plane drafts can be referred for MPLS related details . TSN over DetNet MPLS follows the concept of RFC3985 . Description focus on Edge Nodes procedures and functions . Text covers the Edge Nodes components : ( 1 ) TSN functions ( in NSP block ) ; ( 2 ) DetNet Service Proxy ; and ( 3 ) DetNet sub - layers . Approving from teelcon review" 3486514b01b74d57f031bcf660311de328a6e0dc 3486514b01b74d57f031bcf660311de328a6e0dc draft-ietf-detnet-tsn-vpn-over-mpls 036168e918418eb807bc3efd361a8e66067192564da41e30e076d22be0f87935 ['e82e49a3c764c0ede490d9e8afe0d0a379ec1e2fb734910d7e42f179709f894c', '1b5276bed81725e3cab5fa8d2491ae7fc344c8638906d8e62ee7c31696edcb52', 'a6a4ee1a9211a2be0e24cf91f9742499a46567acff4c78f62b568b34e38c08de', '44d22f065218a14d5aa04288e7553c8a6d81bb222066c74ea38571bbe922a729', 'c757c3611002031d5ce1ac79d9984d826f392e6628a0657e045c348e52b7eda2', '8a105d9f9ffbf3e747a101e48de19122931cd0cce896dc27f57d16df9dbb75ac', 'a8ff14472a8fa48bacdc11d7089a9d1054c0a786f6152f510b5d4092c22e121f', 'e746630d4b45cf2b654a14e4daaa03ad634e33d92c29c489e3ef3fcd5620c311', '16375944152e6c3e73492437880fe39d7f0123a9292d062e8e9c7d317e4b878f', '42f5214bb177fd7faf01b7943e7f313a615b2490f9109d5cefa8b24101735c32', '5cc97b8f56cdeeb02e7c96183745dc53dd8ec3ec02424107d16eb438c2c9363c', 'a816e4d1392c9c85d398ee2c5116b5de849a9823bc552d322ac8725f7c9b859e', 'c7286f8983508fdd7d94ae798cdc3950cbf65865e905c00a76838a34eb79cf2c', '6924f7b3002e9f0dff9023b70bcc9d484e643c3a2d95b0d5c853c084ad3f68ab', '2d8fce3963de03360a5d98758067925a60474b5430fd8091fc72f3c50a9d38e5', '77f9aaec42bbb94079fae33b8c564cd7f64721106f615e11f22673310efaf01b', '09f8dc962fd9202d148a0b378c9a078ea850056b4b5c360c0914d4a1de6af454', '4826376633600232b766cb8a62d4054b0f5ea45d74878bcf57356e567088300c', '82b410c949db1d81b3f197adbaaba7b82b6e497600cd9883150af2bb815caa19', '0eb73f51f3b491bd6d969a05acf2b527e6e2f09a460cb88266513ab952bd3fc6', '1076eab6753435c114e8a720c951b03da6d4e1bbbf1290f8d58ad7f97a0b8c64', '4ccf918f8b8ae99a769d89e0868a12e4af1536487652436b6c188bc99e14fdb6', '2a5cef1e9c76b52b9b56c6c021a857b0fa757897b6e3c96cc8170d5b73ba8dd8', '07267e696bfbb5af98da5a8efe2b8cf604bc9ab1ce95e4766f017473bfcd0de1', '82f56d4694c2ec964de0a4413954f87ca621628c63d7425944baeff9aa4b6dad', '01e1da53fe2751e7196114efc63dd70d9babc69b4b73c03d4b7528dcc10c05d3', 'fb8f3ca7fafc9c173404ce7f909038443a6078a0c278cb024639410e33f49f88', '44e497e2df0461bad9215c57918855022435eb6e28266916161de3f7902bb352', '84f5bc0e0be5d04b515e8e49efb393e4aec7189222b92c0555cc1be542e74549', '3195c90c03cf6a438b5684cc93128c53f794660a661e2aa85d043ca5ac7060b9', 'b5bacf05f766e143f6de9484b0b5a2d9655d62854368373bd77974b94cb722e6', '2442b9072d522cde54849b40cab26789e4af909f1dd81391cd8c87023515a21c', 'b03d79d1a547b36a28c6cba78f57b8244a4855f6b31003de3e617a5b5eddc070', 'e386562e3156c91934ceb045df46d7e847bb9afcad2794bda59be854f988befc', 'cc980749457292da3a6a4a3ce669ad487409ce72e20857e80c75741c83af7f0a', '75db9ae91b710fcf1df3553b8f9653b12d014f74ba1ee8f931870d2433e163f1', '0e313215df9694bc26777ba4ac347cb8ef73f8475d2bfed664aab722833589ae', '1094721b24c22ff67539ffeabab887f87e538bdd9ebe50b0b369de138d326802', 'fb2b9389e1455c6d64ae19158396d767d88969013b14075bcfdcc764f610108c', 'ae3bdd3a81d96e4aaa02f7d597a2684146f3af75b743bde8e31c3cf5883707db', '1b8137b4c60774716e4a492efec48060d48abd7308563d8cc76edf32d98bd759', '09732023af932d8c578c8a7ead49feb80cdb5c629cee6add2e24fcd7999c0309', '75b7020073ec0c8cedf517f1b56d554e2a5cfdf89d204633c30b863c42ed6f5f', '4be1dfb90ea542d5d84c23c0ba29b91db2491a39973839ee646eeec25c71adb4', 'c98d52f719106d13b14f27abde81ce00305cbf62889690b72da3e3ddc0286c02', '056859e4aa430e2eb983e93f08bb85d9afe9aec44f0e73263cf072df70b7c475', '870147c2dad0a0dda2dd0a9f85ef83b3c4de9a304fdff6d9fa9ccc4bde9d70c0', '26e942b0353fee8f5ac0a2c2e26c9b695c50b35c501eeb4bff343b1648b5cebc', '036168e918418eb807bc3efd361a8e66067192564da41e30e076d22be0f87935', 'a491df768673d76ae7dee4c9bf1ea1456e6c537a1f1683368d8bc6869cd89bf0', 'f6a8cfceb19b4cd796512223b8afd103c4aee7052247ebea8b50f743e9aa27b6', 'd135518ad4230c8f57a3510b3ddea8a99e2355363c9419a27340734427050729', 'cbe90e272b6be7696d3b8c171500847d2b0ae497f6911d0f9d5d8481101c4c1f', '249c961ea29438959ea2204728df24964ec80b8cd91c657715c47014f5e5a462', '1920ebb46d0cee2d379ef48c15f8f6abd01e2a183f316da235e0c3b7515feade', '6d1573b42d5f89f89b26b32cbbd32ff41660e0e8c3b3091f1cb278a42651e049', 'ec6878825845c61b3049ad5dd168197c84938e7f6d4fc938670da2528cf86317', '9829b13faebde69c2279c38cd54d524aa31acfdcc1cfba7910b9d69caa42e0dd', '2755ae7cda161df0c24e1fa9f1c3308bc9ef81a599d859668490484290ca72f4', '09d9dcfc1716808b0c62e47a771ff4d39ba71f22c8640776e65624747a995626', '71dfcd074b80de90c4955890bdbe127d12b249ed764c7c4ca23dc81c74fde71d', '3c1afbb156ee2d672ca131c7c966bc6875374a95d927848bafcc5a158edf67bb'] A for example, to support identification of misbehaving flows. {79: 1, 130: 1, 54: 1, 52: 1, 98: 1, 6: 1, 8: 1, 64: 1, 99: 1, 24: 1, 90: 2, 51: 2, 62: 4, 85: 4, 68: 3, 35: 2, 110: 2, 91: 4, 114: 2, 97: 2, 31: 2, 13: 2, 67: 2, 38: 3, 26: 2, 124: 2, 127: 2, 96: 2, 30: 3, 61: 4, 55: 2, 27: 3, 15: 2, 129: 2, 115: 2, 84: 2, 76: 5, 87: 2, 131: 4, 102: 2, 113: 4, 36: 2, 72: 3} {4: 1, 24: 1, 59: 1, 111: 1, 136: 1, 156: 1, 206: 1, 215: 1, 220: 1, 221: 1, 235: 1, 241: 1, 242: 1, 314: 1, 329: 1, 334: 1, 354: 1, 366: 1, 376: 1, 1: 8, 9: 4, 10: 2, 15: 2, 25: 4, 26: 4, 27: 2, 39: 4, 43: 2, 49: 5, 50: 4, 58: 4, 64: 2, 69: 3, 81: 5, 82: 3, 86: 2, 96: 3, 97: 2, 100: 6, 108: 2, 109: 3, 110: 3, 114: 2, 115: 3, 116: 2, 118: 5, 119: 4, 120: 2, 121: 3, 122: 3, 123: 2, 124: 3, 128: 3, 129: 3, 130: 4, 132: 3, 145: 3, 147: 3, 151: 3, 152: 3, 154: 2, 161: 2, 162: 2, 165: 2, 168: 3, 169: 2, 172: 2, 180: 3, 184: 4, 187: 4, 188: 3, 191: 2, 194: 3, 202: 4, 203: 5, 207: 2, 217: 2, 218: 7, 222: 4, 224: 2, 227: 4, 229: 2, 234: 4, 243: 3, 244: 3, 245: 3, 248: 3, 250: 3, 258: 10, 262: 3, 263: 4, 264: 2, 267: 3, 270: 2, 272: 2, 273: 4, 287: 2, 289: 2, 291: 4, 299: 4, 300: 2, 304: 2, 309: 2, 315: 2, 320: 3, 323: 3, 327: 3, 328: 2, 330: 9, 335: 2, 341: 4, 342: 5, 347: 4, 348: 4, 350: 6, 351: 4, 352: 2, 353: 2, 358: 3, 365: 2, 371: 6, 372: 4, 384: 4, 385: 3, 386: 2, 387: 2, 392: 2, 393: 3, 396: 5, 397: 6, 398: 5, 402: 2} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 53 For example, increase counters. "Major clean up and simplification as data plane drafts can be referred for MPLS related details . TSN over DetNet MPLS follows the concept of RFC3985 . Description focus on Edge Nodes procedures and functions . Text covers the Edge Nodes components : ( 1 ) TSN functions ( in NSP block ) ; ( 2 ) DetNet Service Proxy ; and ( 3 ) DetNet sub - layers . Approving from teelcon review" 3486514b01b74d57f031bcf660311de328a6e0dc 3486514b01b74d57f031bcf660311de328a6e0dc draft-ietf-detnet-tsn-vpn-over-mpls 2755ae7cda161df0c24e1fa9f1c3308bc9ef81a599d859668490484290ca72f4 ['e82e49a3c764c0ede490d9e8afe0d0a379ec1e2fb734910d7e42f179709f894c', '1b5276bed81725e3cab5fa8d2491ae7fc344c8638906d8e62ee7c31696edcb52', 'a6a4ee1a9211a2be0e24cf91f9742499a46567acff4c78f62b568b34e38c08de', '44d22f065218a14d5aa04288e7553c8a6d81bb222066c74ea38571bbe922a729', 'c757c3611002031d5ce1ac79d9984d826f392e6628a0657e045c348e52b7eda2', '8a105d9f9ffbf3e747a101e48de19122931cd0cce896dc27f57d16df9dbb75ac', 'a8ff14472a8fa48bacdc11d7089a9d1054c0a786f6152f510b5d4092c22e121f', 'e746630d4b45cf2b654a14e4daaa03ad634e33d92c29c489e3ef3fcd5620c311', '16375944152e6c3e73492437880fe39d7f0123a9292d062e8e9c7d317e4b878f', '42f5214bb177fd7faf01b7943e7f313a615b2490f9109d5cefa8b24101735c32', '5cc97b8f56cdeeb02e7c96183745dc53dd8ec3ec02424107d16eb438c2c9363c', 'a816e4d1392c9c85d398ee2c5116b5de849a9823bc552d322ac8725f7c9b859e', 'c7286f8983508fdd7d94ae798cdc3950cbf65865e905c00a76838a34eb79cf2c', '6924f7b3002e9f0dff9023b70bcc9d484e643c3a2d95b0d5c853c084ad3f68ab', '2d8fce3963de03360a5d98758067925a60474b5430fd8091fc72f3c50a9d38e5', '77f9aaec42bbb94079fae33b8c564cd7f64721106f615e11f22673310efaf01b', '09f8dc962fd9202d148a0b378c9a078ea850056b4b5c360c0914d4a1de6af454', '4826376633600232b766cb8a62d4054b0f5ea45d74878bcf57356e567088300c', '82b410c949db1d81b3f197adbaaba7b82b6e497600cd9883150af2bb815caa19', '0eb73f51f3b491bd6d969a05acf2b527e6e2f09a460cb88266513ab952bd3fc6', '1076eab6753435c114e8a720c951b03da6d4e1bbbf1290f8d58ad7f97a0b8c64', '4ccf918f8b8ae99a769d89e0868a12e4af1536487652436b6c188bc99e14fdb6', '2a5cef1e9c76b52b9b56c6c021a857b0fa757897b6e3c96cc8170d5b73ba8dd8', '07267e696bfbb5af98da5a8efe2b8cf604bc9ab1ce95e4766f017473bfcd0de1', '82f56d4694c2ec964de0a4413954f87ca621628c63d7425944baeff9aa4b6dad', '01e1da53fe2751e7196114efc63dd70d9babc69b4b73c03d4b7528dcc10c05d3', 'fb8f3ca7fafc9c173404ce7f909038443a6078a0c278cb024639410e33f49f88', '44e497e2df0461bad9215c57918855022435eb6e28266916161de3f7902bb352', '84f5bc0e0be5d04b515e8e49efb393e4aec7189222b92c0555cc1be542e74549', '3195c90c03cf6a438b5684cc93128c53f794660a661e2aa85d043ca5ac7060b9', 'b5bacf05f766e143f6de9484b0b5a2d9655d62854368373bd77974b94cb722e6', '2442b9072d522cde54849b40cab26789e4af909f1dd81391cd8c87023515a21c', 'b03d79d1a547b36a28c6cba78f57b8244a4855f6b31003de3e617a5b5eddc070', 'e386562e3156c91934ceb045df46d7e847bb9afcad2794bda59be854f988befc', 'cc980749457292da3a6a4a3ce669ad487409ce72e20857e80c75741c83af7f0a', '75db9ae91b710fcf1df3553b8f9653b12d014f74ba1ee8f931870d2433e163f1', '0e313215df9694bc26777ba4ac347cb8ef73f8475d2bfed664aab722833589ae', '1094721b24c22ff67539ffeabab887f87e538bdd9ebe50b0b369de138d326802', 'fb2b9389e1455c6d64ae19158396d767d88969013b14075bcfdcc764f610108c', 'ae3bdd3a81d96e4aaa02f7d597a2684146f3af75b743bde8e31c3cf5883707db', '1b8137b4c60774716e4a492efec48060d48abd7308563d8cc76edf32d98bd759', '09732023af932d8c578c8a7ead49feb80cdb5c629cee6add2e24fcd7999c0309', '75b7020073ec0c8cedf517f1b56d554e2a5cfdf89d204633c30b863c42ed6f5f', '4be1dfb90ea542d5d84c23c0ba29b91db2491a39973839ee646eeec25c71adb4', 'c98d52f719106d13b14f27abde81ce00305cbf62889690b72da3e3ddc0286c02', '056859e4aa430e2eb983e93f08bb85d9afe9aec44f0e73263cf072df70b7c475', '870147c2dad0a0dda2dd0a9f85ef83b3c4de9a304fdff6d9fa9ccc4bde9d70c0', '26e942b0353fee8f5ac0a2c2e26c9b695c50b35c501eeb4bff343b1648b5cebc', '036168e918418eb807bc3efd361a8e66067192564da41e30e076d22be0f87935', 'a491df768673d76ae7dee4c9bf1ea1456e6c537a1f1683368d8bc6869cd89bf0', 'f6a8cfceb19b4cd796512223b8afd103c4aee7052247ebea8b50f743e9aa27b6', 'd135518ad4230c8f57a3510b3ddea8a99e2355363c9419a27340734427050729', 'cbe90e272b6be7696d3b8c171500847d2b0ae497f6911d0f9d5d8481101c4c1f', '249c961ea29438959ea2204728df24964ec80b8cd91c657715c47014f5e5a462', '1920ebb46d0cee2d379ef48c15f8f6abd01e2a183f316da235e0c3b7515feade', '6d1573b42d5f89f89b26b32cbbd32ff41660e0e8c3b3091f1cb278a42651e049', 'ec6878825845c61b3049ad5dd168197c84938e7f6d4fc938670da2528cf86317', '9829b13faebde69c2279c38cd54d524aa31acfdcc1cfba7910b9d69caa42e0dd', '2755ae7cda161df0c24e1fa9f1c3308bc9ef81a599d859668490484290ca72f4', '09d9dcfc1716808b0c62e47a771ff4d39ba71f22c8640776e65624747a995626', '71dfcd074b80de90c4955890bdbe127d12b249ed764c7c4ca23dc81c74fde71d', '3c1afbb156ee2d672ca131c7c966bc6875374a95d927848bafcc5a158edf67bb'] A for example, increase counters. {79: 1, 130: 1, 54: 1, 52: 1, 98: 1, 6: 1, 8: 1, 64: 1, 99: 1, 24: 1, 90: 2, 51: 2, 62: 4, 85: 4, 68: 3, 35: 2, 110: 2, 91: 4, 114: 2, 97: 2, 31: 2, 13: 2, 67: 2, 38: 3, 26: 2, 124: 2, 127: 2, 96: 2, 30: 3, 61: 4, 55: 2, 27: 3, 15: 2, 129: 2, 115: 2, 84: 2, 76: 5, 87: 2, 131: 4, 102: 2, 113: 4, 36: 2, 72: 3} {4: 1, 24: 1, 59: 1, 111: 1, 136: 1, 156: 1, 206: 1, 215: 1, 220: 1, 221: 1, 235: 1, 241: 1, 242: 1, 314: 1, 329: 1, 334: 1, 354: 1, 366: 1, 376: 1, 1: 8, 9: 4, 10: 2, 15: 2, 25: 4, 26: 4, 27: 2, 39: 4, 43: 2, 49: 5, 50: 4, 58: 4, 64: 2, 69: 3, 81: 5, 82: 3, 86: 2, 96: 3, 97: 2, 100: 6, 108: 2, 109: 3, 110: 3, 114: 2, 115: 3, 116: 2, 118: 5, 119: 4, 120: 2, 121: 3, 122: 3, 123: 2, 124: 3, 128: 3, 129: 3, 130: 4, 132: 3, 145: 3, 147: 3, 151: 3, 152: 3, 154: 2, 161: 2, 162: 2, 165: 2, 168: 3, 169: 2, 172: 2, 180: 3, 184: 4, 187: 4, 188: 3, 191: 2, 194: 3, 202: 4, 203: 5, 207: 2, 217: 2, 218: 7, 222: 4, 224: 2, 227: 4, 229: 2, 234: 4, 243: 3, 244: 3, 245: 3, 248: 3, 250: 3, 258: 10, 262: 3, 263: 4, 264: 2, 267: 3, 270: 2, 272: 2, 273: 4, 287: 2, 289: 2, 291: 4, 299: 4, 300: 2, 304: 2, 309: 2, 315: 2, 320: 3, 323: 3, 327: 3, 328: 2, 330: 9, 335: 2, 341: 4, 342: 5, 347: 4, 348: 4, 350: 6, 351: 4, 352: 2, 353: 2, 358: 3, 365: 2, 371: 6, 372: 4, 384: 4, 385: 3, 386: 2, 387: 2, 392: 2, 393: 3, 396: 5, 397: 6, 398: 5, 402: 2} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 53 For example, unexpected loss. "Major clean up and simplification as data plane drafts can be referred for MPLS related details . TSN over DetNet MPLS follows the concept of RFC3985 . Description focus on Edge Nodes procedures and functions . Text covers the Edge Nodes components : ( 1 ) TSN functions ( in NSP block ) ; ( 2 ) DetNet Service Proxy ; and ( 3 ) DetNet sub - layers . Approving from teelcon review" 3486514b01b74d57f031bcf660311de328a6e0dc 3486514b01b74d57f031bcf660311de328a6e0dc draft-ietf-detnet-tsn-vpn-over-mpls a8ff14472a8fa48bacdc11d7089a9d1054c0a786f6152f510b5d4092c22e121f ['e82e49a3c764c0ede490d9e8afe0d0a379ec1e2fb734910d7e42f179709f894c', '1b5276bed81725e3cab5fa8d2491ae7fc344c8638906d8e62ee7c31696edcb52', 'a6a4ee1a9211a2be0e24cf91f9742499a46567acff4c78f62b568b34e38c08de', '44d22f065218a14d5aa04288e7553c8a6d81bb222066c74ea38571bbe922a729', 'c757c3611002031d5ce1ac79d9984d826f392e6628a0657e045c348e52b7eda2', '8a105d9f9ffbf3e747a101e48de19122931cd0cce896dc27f57d16df9dbb75ac', 'a8ff14472a8fa48bacdc11d7089a9d1054c0a786f6152f510b5d4092c22e121f', 'e746630d4b45cf2b654a14e4daaa03ad634e33d92c29c489e3ef3fcd5620c311', '16375944152e6c3e73492437880fe39d7f0123a9292d062e8e9c7d317e4b878f', '42f5214bb177fd7faf01b7943e7f313a615b2490f9109d5cefa8b24101735c32', '5cc97b8f56cdeeb02e7c96183745dc53dd8ec3ec02424107d16eb438c2c9363c', 'a816e4d1392c9c85d398ee2c5116b5de849a9823bc552d322ac8725f7c9b859e', 'c7286f8983508fdd7d94ae798cdc3950cbf65865e905c00a76838a34eb79cf2c', '6924f7b3002e9f0dff9023b70bcc9d484e643c3a2d95b0d5c853c084ad3f68ab', '2d8fce3963de03360a5d98758067925a60474b5430fd8091fc72f3c50a9d38e5', '77f9aaec42bbb94079fae33b8c564cd7f64721106f615e11f22673310efaf01b', '09f8dc962fd9202d148a0b378c9a078ea850056b4b5c360c0914d4a1de6af454', '4826376633600232b766cb8a62d4054b0f5ea45d74878bcf57356e567088300c', '82b410c949db1d81b3f197adbaaba7b82b6e497600cd9883150af2bb815caa19', '0eb73f51f3b491bd6d969a05acf2b527e6e2f09a460cb88266513ab952bd3fc6', '1076eab6753435c114e8a720c951b03da6d4e1bbbf1290f8d58ad7f97a0b8c64', '4ccf918f8b8ae99a769d89e0868a12e4af1536487652436b6c188bc99e14fdb6', '2a5cef1e9c76b52b9b56c6c021a857b0fa757897b6e3c96cc8170d5b73ba8dd8', '07267e696bfbb5af98da5a8efe2b8cf604bc9ab1ce95e4766f017473bfcd0de1', '82f56d4694c2ec964de0a4413954f87ca621628c63d7425944baeff9aa4b6dad', '01e1da53fe2751e7196114efc63dd70d9babc69b4b73c03d4b7528dcc10c05d3', 'fb8f3ca7fafc9c173404ce7f909038443a6078a0c278cb024639410e33f49f88', '44e497e2df0461bad9215c57918855022435eb6e28266916161de3f7902bb352', '84f5bc0e0be5d04b515e8e49efb393e4aec7189222b92c0555cc1be542e74549', '3195c90c03cf6a438b5684cc93128c53f794660a661e2aa85d043ca5ac7060b9', 'b5bacf05f766e143f6de9484b0b5a2d9655d62854368373bd77974b94cb722e6', '2442b9072d522cde54849b40cab26789e4af909f1dd81391cd8c87023515a21c', 'b03d79d1a547b36a28c6cba78f57b8244a4855f6b31003de3e617a5b5eddc070', 'e386562e3156c91934ceb045df46d7e847bb9afcad2794bda59be854f988befc', 'cc980749457292da3a6a4a3ce669ad487409ce72e20857e80c75741c83af7f0a', '75db9ae91b710fcf1df3553b8f9653b12d014f74ba1ee8f931870d2433e163f1', '0e313215df9694bc26777ba4ac347cb8ef73f8475d2bfed664aab722833589ae', '1094721b24c22ff67539ffeabab887f87e538bdd9ebe50b0b369de138d326802', 'fb2b9389e1455c6d64ae19158396d767d88969013b14075bcfdcc764f610108c', 'ae3bdd3a81d96e4aaa02f7d597a2684146f3af75b743bde8e31c3cf5883707db', '1b8137b4c60774716e4a492efec48060d48abd7308563d8cc76edf32d98bd759', '09732023af932d8c578c8a7ead49feb80cdb5c629cee6add2e24fcd7999c0309', '75b7020073ec0c8cedf517f1b56d554e2a5cfdf89d204633c30b863c42ed6f5f', '4be1dfb90ea542d5d84c23c0ba29b91db2491a39973839ee646eeec25c71adb4', 'c98d52f719106d13b14f27abde81ce00305cbf62889690b72da3e3ddc0286c02', '056859e4aa430e2eb983e93f08bb85d9afe9aec44f0e73263cf072df70b7c475', '870147c2dad0a0dda2dd0a9f85ef83b3c4de9a304fdff6d9fa9ccc4bde9d70c0', '26e942b0353fee8f5ac0a2c2e26c9b695c50b35c501eeb4bff343b1648b5cebc', '036168e918418eb807bc3efd361a8e66067192564da41e30e076d22be0f87935', 'a491df768673d76ae7dee4c9bf1ea1456e6c537a1f1683368d8bc6869cd89bf0', 'f6a8cfceb19b4cd796512223b8afd103c4aee7052247ebea8b50f743e9aa27b6', 'd135518ad4230c8f57a3510b3ddea8a99e2355363c9419a27340734427050729', 'cbe90e272b6be7696d3b8c171500847d2b0ae497f6911d0f9d5d8481101c4c1f', '249c961ea29438959ea2204728df24964ec80b8cd91c657715c47014f5e5a462', '1920ebb46d0cee2d379ef48c15f8f6abd01e2a183f316da235e0c3b7515feade', '6d1573b42d5f89f89b26b32cbbd32ff41660e0e8c3b3091f1cb278a42651e049', 'ec6878825845c61b3049ad5dd168197c84938e7f6d4fc938670da2528cf86317', '9829b13faebde69c2279c38cd54d524aa31acfdcc1cfba7910b9d69caa42e0dd', '2755ae7cda161df0c24e1fa9f1c3308bc9ef81a599d859668490484290ca72f4', '09d9dcfc1716808b0c62e47a771ff4d39ba71f22c8640776e65624747a995626', '71dfcd074b80de90c4955890bdbe127d12b249ed764c7c4ca23dc81c74fde71d', '3c1afbb156ee2d672ca131c7c966bc6875374a95d927848bafcc5a158edf67bb'] A for example, unexpected loss. {79: 1, 130: 1, 54: 1, 52: 1, 98: 1, 6: 1, 8: 1, 64: 1, 99: 1, 24: 1, 90: 2, 51: 2, 62: 4, 85: 4, 68: 3, 35: 2, 110: 2, 91: 4, 114: 2, 97: 2, 31: 2, 13: 2, 67: 2, 38: 3, 26: 2, 124: 2, 127: 2, 96: 2, 30: 3, 61: 4, 55: 2, 27: 3, 15: 2, 129: 2, 115: 2, 84: 2, 76: 5, 87: 2, 131: 4, 102: 2, 113: 4, 36: 2, 72: 3} {4: 1, 24: 1, 59: 1, 111: 1, 136: 1, 156: 1, 206: 1, 215: 1, 220: 1, 221: 1, 235: 1, 241: 1, 242: 1, 314: 1, 329: 1, 334: 1, 354: 1, 366: 1, 376: 1, 1: 8, 9: 4, 10: 2, 15: 2, 25: 4, 26: 4, 27: 2, 39: 4, 43: 2, 49: 5, 50: 4, 58: 4, 64: 2, 69: 3, 81: 5, 82: 3, 86: 2, 96: 3, 97: 2, 100: 6, 108: 2, 109: 3, 110: 3, 114: 2, 115: 3, 116: 2, 118: 5, 119: 4, 120: 2, 121: 3, 122: 3, 123: 2, 124: 3, 128: 3, 129: 3, 130: 4, 132: 3, 145: 3, 147: 3, 151: 3, 152: 3, 154: 2, 161: 2, 162: 2, 165: 2, 168: 3, 169: 2, 172: 2, 180: 3, 184: 4, 187: 4, 188: 3, 191: 2, 194: 3, 202: 4, 203: 5, 207: 2, 217: 2, 218: 7, 222: 4, 224: 2, 227: 4, 229: 2, 234: 4, 243: 3, 244: 3, 245: 3, 248: 3, 250: 3, 258: 10, 262: 3, 263: 4, 264: 2, 267: 3, 270: 2, 272: 2, 273: 4, 287: 2, 289: 2, 291: 4, 299: 4, 300: 2, 304: 2, 309: 2, 315: 2, 320: 3, 323: 3, 327: 3, 328: 2, 330: 9, 335: 2, 341: 4, 342: 5, 347: 4, 348: 4, 350: 6, 351: 4, 352: 2, 353: 2, 358: 3, 365: 2, 371: 6, 372: 4, 384: 4, 385: 3, 386: 2, 387: 2, 392: 2, 393: 3, 396: 5, 397: 6, 398: 5, 402: 2} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 53 "The DetNet data plane also allows for the aggregation of DetNet flows, e.g., via MPLS hierarchical LSPs, to improved scaling. When DetNet flows are aggregated, transit nodes provide service to the aggregate and not on a per-DetNet flow basis. In this case, nodes performing aggregation will ensure that per-flow service requirements are achieved." "Major clean up and simplification as data plane drafts can be referred for MPLS related details . TSN over DetNet MPLS follows the concept of RFC3985 . Description focus on Edge Nodes procedures and functions . Text covers the Edge Nodes components : ( 1 ) TSN functions ( in NSP block ) ; ( 2 ) DetNet Service Proxy ; and ( 3 ) DetNet sub - layers . Approving from teelcon review" 3486514b01b74d57f031bcf660311de328a6e0dc 3486514b01b74d57f031bcf660311de328a6e0dc draft-ietf-detnet-tsn-vpn-over-mpls 16375944152e6c3e73492437880fe39d7f0123a9292d062e8e9c7d317e4b878f ['e82e49a3c764c0ede490d9e8afe0d0a379ec1e2fb734910d7e42f179709f894c', '1b5276bed81725e3cab5fa8d2491ae7fc344c8638906d8e62ee7c31696edcb52', 'a6a4ee1a9211a2be0e24cf91f9742499a46567acff4c78f62b568b34e38c08de', '44d22f065218a14d5aa04288e7553c8a6d81bb222066c74ea38571bbe922a729', 'c757c3611002031d5ce1ac79d9984d826f392e6628a0657e045c348e52b7eda2', '8a105d9f9ffbf3e747a101e48de19122931cd0cce896dc27f57d16df9dbb75ac', 'a8ff14472a8fa48bacdc11d7089a9d1054c0a786f6152f510b5d4092c22e121f', 'e746630d4b45cf2b654a14e4daaa03ad634e33d92c29c489e3ef3fcd5620c311', '16375944152e6c3e73492437880fe39d7f0123a9292d062e8e9c7d317e4b878f', '42f5214bb177fd7faf01b7943e7f313a615b2490f9109d5cefa8b24101735c32', '5cc97b8f56cdeeb02e7c96183745dc53dd8ec3ec02424107d16eb438c2c9363c', 'a816e4d1392c9c85d398ee2c5116b5de849a9823bc552d322ac8725f7c9b859e', 'c7286f8983508fdd7d94ae798cdc3950cbf65865e905c00a76838a34eb79cf2c', '6924f7b3002e9f0dff9023b70bcc9d484e643c3a2d95b0d5c853c084ad3f68ab', '2d8fce3963de03360a5d98758067925a60474b5430fd8091fc72f3c50a9d38e5', '77f9aaec42bbb94079fae33b8c564cd7f64721106f615e11f22673310efaf01b', '09f8dc962fd9202d148a0b378c9a078ea850056b4b5c360c0914d4a1de6af454', '4826376633600232b766cb8a62d4054b0f5ea45d74878bcf57356e567088300c', '82b410c949db1d81b3f197adbaaba7b82b6e497600cd9883150af2bb815caa19', '0eb73f51f3b491bd6d969a05acf2b527e6e2f09a460cb88266513ab952bd3fc6', '1076eab6753435c114e8a720c951b03da6d4e1bbbf1290f8d58ad7f97a0b8c64', '4ccf918f8b8ae99a769d89e0868a12e4af1536487652436b6c188bc99e14fdb6', '2a5cef1e9c76b52b9b56c6c021a857b0fa757897b6e3c96cc8170d5b73ba8dd8', '07267e696bfbb5af98da5a8efe2b8cf604bc9ab1ce95e4766f017473bfcd0de1', '82f56d4694c2ec964de0a4413954f87ca621628c63d7425944baeff9aa4b6dad', '01e1da53fe2751e7196114efc63dd70d9babc69b4b73c03d4b7528dcc10c05d3', 'fb8f3ca7fafc9c173404ce7f909038443a6078a0c278cb024639410e33f49f88', '44e497e2df0461bad9215c57918855022435eb6e28266916161de3f7902bb352', '84f5bc0e0be5d04b515e8e49efb393e4aec7189222b92c0555cc1be542e74549', '3195c90c03cf6a438b5684cc93128c53f794660a661e2aa85d043ca5ac7060b9', 'b5bacf05f766e143f6de9484b0b5a2d9655d62854368373bd77974b94cb722e6', '2442b9072d522cde54849b40cab26789e4af909f1dd81391cd8c87023515a21c', 'b03d79d1a547b36a28c6cba78f57b8244a4855f6b31003de3e617a5b5eddc070', 'e386562e3156c91934ceb045df46d7e847bb9afcad2794bda59be854f988befc', 'cc980749457292da3a6a4a3ce669ad487409ce72e20857e80c75741c83af7f0a', '75db9ae91b710fcf1df3553b8f9653b12d014f74ba1ee8f931870d2433e163f1', '0e313215df9694bc26777ba4ac347cb8ef73f8475d2bfed664aab722833589ae', '1094721b24c22ff67539ffeabab887f87e538bdd9ebe50b0b369de138d326802', 'fb2b9389e1455c6d64ae19158396d767d88969013b14075bcfdcc764f610108c', 'ae3bdd3a81d96e4aaa02f7d597a2684146f3af75b743bde8e31c3cf5883707db', '1b8137b4c60774716e4a492efec48060d48abd7308563d8cc76edf32d98bd759', '09732023af932d8c578c8a7ead49feb80cdb5c629cee6add2e24fcd7999c0309', '75b7020073ec0c8cedf517f1b56d554e2a5cfdf89d204633c30b863c42ed6f5f', '4be1dfb90ea542d5d84c23c0ba29b91db2491a39973839ee646eeec25c71adb4', 'c98d52f719106d13b14f27abde81ce00305cbf62889690b72da3e3ddc0286c02', '056859e4aa430e2eb983e93f08bb85d9afe9aec44f0e73263cf072df70b7c475', '870147c2dad0a0dda2dd0a9f85ef83b3c4de9a304fdff6d9fa9ccc4bde9d70c0', '26e942b0353fee8f5ac0a2c2e26c9b695c50b35c501eeb4bff343b1648b5cebc', '036168e918418eb807bc3efd361a8e66067192564da41e30e076d22be0f87935', 'a491df768673d76ae7dee4c9bf1ea1456e6c537a1f1683368d8bc6869cd89bf0', 'f6a8cfceb19b4cd796512223b8afd103c4aee7052247ebea8b50f743e9aa27b6', 'd135518ad4230c8f57a3510b3ddea8a99e2355363c9419a27340734427050729', 'cbe90e272b6be7696d3b8c171500847d2b0ae497f6911d0f9d5d8481101c4c1f', '249c961ea29438959ea2204728df24964ec80b8cd91c657715c47014f5e5a462', '1920ebb46d0cee2d379ef48c15f8f6abd01e2a183f316da235e0c3b7515feade', '6d1573b42d5f89f89b26b32cbbd32ff41660e0e8c3b3091f1cb278a42651e049', 'ec6878825845c61b3049ad5dd168197c84938e7f6d4fc938670da2528cf86317', '9829b13faebde69c2279c38cd54d524aa31acfdcc1cfba7910b9d69caa42e0dd', '2755ae7cda161df0c24e1fa9f1c3308bc9ef81a599d859668490484290ca72f4', '09d9dcfc1716808b0c62e47a771ff4d39ba71f22c8640776e65624747a995626', '71dfcd074b80de90c4955890bdbe127d12b249ed764c7c4ca23dc81c74fde71d', '3c1afbb156ee2d672ca131c7c966bc6875374a95d927848bafcc5a158edf67bb'] A "the detnet data plane also allows for the aggregation of detnet flows, e.g., via mpls hierarchical lsps, to improved scaling. when detnet flows are aggregated, transit nodes provide service to the aggregate and not on a per-detnet flow basis. in this case, nodes performing aggregation will ensure that per-flow service requirements are achieved." {79: 1, 130: 1, 54: 1, 52: 1, 98: 1, 6: 1, 8: 1, 64: 1, 99: 1, 24: 1, 90: 2, 51: 2, 62: 4, 85: 4, 68: 3, 35: 2, 110: 2, 91: 4, 114: 2, 97: 2, 31: 2, 13: 2, 67: 2, 38: 3, 26: 2, 124: 2, 127: 2, 96: 2, 30: 3, 61: 4, 55: 2, 27: 3, 15: 2, 129: 2, 115: 2, 84: 2, 76: 5, 87: 2, 131: 4, 102: 2, 113: 4, 36: 2, 72: 3} {4: 1, 24: 1, 59: 1, 111: 1, 136: 1, 156: 1, 206: 1, 215: 1, 220: 1, 221: 1, 235: 1, 241: 1, 242: 1, 314: 1, 329: 1, 334: 1, 354: 1, 366: 1, 376: 1, 1: 8, 9: 4, 10: 2, 15: 2, 25: 4, 26: 4, 27: 2, 39: 4, 43: 2, 49: 5, 50: 4, 58: 4, 64: 2, 69: 3, 81: 5, 82: 3, 86: 2, 96: 3, 97: 2, 100: 6, 108: 2, 109: 3, 110: 3, 114: 2, 115: 3, 116: 2, 118: 5, 119: 4, 120: 2, 121: 3, 122: 3, 123: 2, 124: 3, 128: 3, 129: 3, 130: 4, 132: 3, 145: 3, 147: 3, 151: 3, 152: 3, 154: 2, 161: 2, 162: 2, 165: 2, 168: 3, 169: 2, 172: 2, 180: 3, 184: 4, 187: 4, 188: 3, 191: 2, 194: 3, 202: 4, 203: 5, 207: 2, 217: 2, 218: 7, 222: 4, 224: 2, 227: 4, 229: 2, 234: 4, 243: 3, 244: 3, 245: 3, 248: 3, 250: 3, 258: 10, 262: 3, 263: 4, 264: 2, 267: 3, 270: 2, 272: 2, 273: 4, 287: 2, 289: 2, 291: 4, 299: 4, 300: 2, 304: 2, 309: 2, 315: 2, 320: 3, 323: 3, 327: 3, 328: 2, 330: 9, 335: 2, 341: 4, 342: 5, 347: 4, 348: 4, 350: 6, 351: 4, 352: 2, 353: 2, 358: 3, 365: 2, 371: 6, 372: 4, 384: 4, 385: 3, 386: 2, 387: 2, 392: 2, 393: 3, 396: 5, 397: 6, 398: 5, 402: 2} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 53 "Data-flows requiring DetNet service are generated and terminated on end-systems. Encapsulation depends on application and its preferences. In a DetNet MPLS domain the DN functions use the d-CWs, S-Labels and F-Labels to provide DetNet services. However, an application may exchange further flow related parameters (e.g., time- stamp), which are not provided by DN functions." "Major clean up and simplification as data plane drafts can be referred for MPLS related details . TSN over DetNet MPLS follows the concept of RFC3985 . Description focus on Edge Nodes procedures and functions . Text covers the Edge Nodes components : ( 1 ) TSN functions ( in NSP block ) ; ( 2 ) DetNet Service Proxy ; and ( 3 ) DetNet sub - layers . Approving from teelcon review" 3486514b01b74d57f031bcf660311de328a6e0dc 3486514b01b74d57f031bcf660311de328a6e0dc draft-ietf-detnet-tsn-vpn-over-mpls 09d9dcfc1716808b0c62e47a771ff4d39ba71f22c8640776e65624747a995626 ['e82e49a3c764c0ede490d9e8afe0d0a379ec1e2fb734910d7e42f179709f894c', '1b5276bed81725e3cab5fa8d2491ae7fc344c8638906d8e62ee7c31696edcb52', 'a6a4ee1a9211a2be0e24cf91f9742499a46567acff4c78f62b568b34e38c08de', '44d22f065218a14d5aa04288e7553c8a6d81bb222066c74ea38571bbe922a729', 'c757c3611002031d5ce1ac79d9984d826f392e6628a0657e045c348e52b7eda2', '8a105d9f9ffbf3e747a101e48de19122931cd0cce896dc27f57d16df9dbb75ac', 'a8ff14472a8fa48bacdc11d7089a9d1054c0a786f6152f510b5d4092c22e121f', 'e746630d4b45cf2b654a14e4daaa03ad634e33d92c29c489e3ef3fcd5620c311', '16375944152e6c3e73492437880fe39d7f0123a9292d062e8e9c7d317e4b878f', '42f5214bb177fd7faf01b7943e7f313a615b2490f9109d5cefa8b24101735c32', '5cc97b8f56cdeeb02e7c96183745dc53dd8ec3ec02424107d16eb438c2c9363c', 'a816e4d1392c9c85d398ee2c5116b5de849a9823bc552d322ac8725f7c9b859e', 'c7286f8983508fdd7d94ae798cdc3950cbf65865e905c00a76838a34eb79cf2c', '6924f7b3002e9f0dff9023b70bcc9d484e643c3a2d95b0d5c853c084ad3f68ab', '2d8fce3963de03360a5d98758067925a60474b5430fd8091fc72f3c50a9d38e5', '77f9aaec42bbb94079fae33b8c564cd7f64721106f615e11f22673310efaf01b', '09f8dc962fd9202d148a0b378c9a078ea850056b4b5c360c0914d4a1de6af454', '4826376633600232b766cb8a62d4054b0f5ea45d74878bcf57356e567088300c', '82b410c949db1d81b3f197adbaaba7b82b6e497600cd9883150af2bb815caa19', '0eb73f51f3b491bd6d969a05acf2b527e6e2f09a460cb88266513ab952bd3fc6', '1076eab6753435c114e8a720c951b03da6d4e1bbbf1290f8d58ad7f97a0b8c64', '4ccf918f8b8ae99a769d89e0868a12e4af1536487652436b6c188bc99e14fdb6', '2a5cef1e9c76b52b9b56c6c021a857b0fa757897b6e3c96cc8170d5b73ba8dd8', '07267e696bfbb5af98da5a8efe2b8cf604bc9ab1ce95e4766f017473bfcd0de1', '82f56d4694c2ec964de0a4413954f87ca621628c63d7425944baeff9aa4b6dad', '01e1da53fe2751e7196114efc63dd70d9babc69b4b73c03d4b7528dcc10c05d3', 'fb8f3ca7fafc9c173404ce7f909038443a6078a0c278cb024639410e33f49f88', '44e497e2df0461bad9215c57918855022435eb6e28266916161de3f7902bb352', '84f5bc0e0be5d04b515e8e49efb393e4aec7189222b92c0555cc1be542e74549', '3195c90c03cf6a438b5684cc93128c53f794660a661e2aa85d043ca5ac7060b9', 'b5bacf05f766e143f6de9484b0b5a2d9655d62854368373bd77974b94cb722e6', '2442b9072d522cde54849b40cab26789e4af909f1dd81391cd8c87023515a21c', 'b03d79d1a547b36a28c6cba78f57b8244a4855f6b31003de3e617a5b5eddc070', 'e386562e3156c91934ceb045df46d7e847bb9afcad2794bda59be854f988befc', 'cc980749457292da3a6a4a3ce669ad487409ce72e20857e80c75741c83af7f0a', '75db9ae91b710fcf1df3553b8f9653b12d014f74ba1ee8f931870d2433e163f1', '0e313215df9694bc26777ba4ac347cb8ef73f8475d2bfed664aab722833589ae', '1094721b24c22ff67539ffeabab887f87e538bdd9ebe50b0b369de138d326802', 'fb2b9389e1455c6d64ae19158396d767d88969013b14075bcfdcc764f610108c', 'ae3bdd3a81d96e4aaa02f7d597a2684146f3af75b743bde8e31c3cf5883707db', '1b8137b4c60774716e4a492efec48060d48abd7308563d8cc76edf32d98bd759', '09732023af932d8c578c8a7ead49feb80cdb5c629cee6add2e24fcd7999c0309', '75b7020073ec0c8cedf517f1b56d554e2a5cfdf89d204633c30b863c42ed6f5f', '4be1dfb90ea542d5d84c23c0ba29b91db2491a39973839ee646eeec25c71adb4', 'c98d52f719106d13b14f27abde81ce00305cbf62889690b72da3e3ddc0286c02', '056859e4aa430e2eb983e93f08bb85d9afe9aec44f0e73263cf072df70b7c475', '870147c2dad0a0dda2dd0a9f85ef83b3c4de9a304fdff6d9fa9ccc4bde9d70c0', '26e942b0353fee8f5ac0a2c2e26c9b695c50b35c501eeb4bff343b1648b5cebc', '036168e918418eb807bc3efd361a8e66067192564da41e30e076d22be0f87935', 'a491df768673d76ae7dee4c9bf1ea1456e6c537a1f1683368d8bc6869cd89bf0', 'f6a8cfceb19b4cd796512223b8afd103c4aee7052247ebea8b50f743e9aa27b6', 'd135518ad4230c8f57a3510b3ddea8a99e2355363c9419a27340734427050729', 'cbe90e272b6be7696d3b8c171500847d2b0ae497f6911d0f9d5d8481101c4c1f', '249c961ea29438959ea2204728df24964ec80b8cd91c657715c47014f5e5a462', '1920ebb46d0cee2d379ef48c15f8f6abd01e2a183f316da235e0c3b7515feade', '6d1573b42d5f89f89b26b32cbbd32ff41660e0e8c3b3091f1cb278a42651e049', 'ec6878825845c61b3049ad5dd168197c84938e7f6d4fc938670da2528cf86317', '9829b13faebde69c2279c38cd54d524aa31acfdcc1cfba7910b9d69caa42e0dd', '2755ae7cda161df0c24e1fa9f1c3308bc9ef81a599d859668490484290ca72f4', '09d9dcfc1716808b0c62e47a771ff4d39ba71f22c8640776e65624747a995626', '71dfcd074b80de90c4955890bdbe127d12b249ed764c7c4ca23dc81c74fde71d', '3c1afbb156ee2d672ca131c7c966bc6875374a95d927848bafcc5a158edf67bb'] A "data-flows requiring detnet service are generated and terminated on end-systems. encapsulation depends on application and its preferences. in a detnet mpls domain the dn functions use the d-cws, s-labels and f-labels to provide detnet services. however, an application may exchange further flow related parameters (e.g., time- stamp), which are not provided by dn functions." {79: 1, 130: 1, 54: 1, 52: 1, 98: 1, 6: 1, 8: 1, 64: 1, 99: 1, 24: 1, 90: 2, 51: 2, 62: 4, 85: 4, 68: 3, 35: 2, 110: 2, 91: 4, 114: 2, 97: 2, 31: 2, 13: 2, 67: 2, 38: 3, 26: 2, 124: 2, 127: 2, 96: 2, 30: 3, 61: 4, 55: 2, 27: 3, 15: 2, 129: 2, 115: 2, 84: 2, 76: 5, 87: 2, 131: 4, 102: 2, 113: 4, 36: 2, 72: 3} {4: 1, 24: 1, 59: 1, 111: 1, 136: 1, 156: 1, 206: 1, 215: 1, 220: 1, 221: 1, 235: 1, 241: 1, 242: 1, 314: 1, 329: 1, 334: 1, 354: 1, 366: 1, 376: 1, 1: 8, 9: 4, 10: 2, 15: 2, 25: 4, 26: 4, 27: 2, 39: 4, 43: 2, 49: 5, 50: 4, 58: 4, 64: 2, 69: 3, 81: 5, 82: 3, 86: 2, 96: 3, 97: 2, 100: 6, 108: 2, 109: 3, 110: 3, 114: 2, 115: 3, 116: 2, 118: 5, 119: 4, 120: 2, 121: 3, 122: 3, 123: 2, 124: 3, 128: 3, 129: 3, 130: 4, 132: 3, 145: 3, 147: 3, 151: 3, 152: 3, 154: 2, 161: 2, 162: 2, 165: 2, 168: 3, 169: 2, 172: 2, 180: 3, 184: 4, 187: 4, 188: 3, 191: 2, 194: 3, 202: 4, 203: 5, 207: 2, 217: 2, 218: 7, 222: 4, 224: 2, 227: 4, 229: 2, 234: 4, 243: 3, 244: 3, 245: 3, 248: 3, 250: 3, 258: 10, 262: 3, 263: 4, 264: 2, 267: 3, 270: 2, 272: 2, 273: 4, 287: 2, 289: 2, 291: 4, 299: 4, 300: 2, 304: 2, 309: 2, 315: 2, 320: 3, 323: 3, 327: 3, 328: 2, 330: 9, 335: 2, 341: 4, 342: 5, 347: 4, 348: 4, 350: 6, 351: 4, 352: 2, 353: 2, 358: 3, 365: 2, 371: 6, 372: 4, 384: 4, 385: 3, 386: 2, 387: 2, 392: 2, 393: 3, 396: 5, 397: 6, 398: 5, 402: 2} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 53 "Specifics related to non-MPLS DetNet end station behavior are out side the scope of this document. For example, details on support for DetNet IP data flows can be found in I-D.ietf-detnet-dp-sol-ip. This document is also useful for end stations that map IP flows to DetNet flows." "Major clean up and simplification as data plane drafts can be referred for MPLS related details . TSN over DetNet MPLS follows the concept of RFC3985 . Description focus on Edge Nodes procedures and functions . Text covers the Edge Nodes components : ( 1 ) TSN functions ( in NSP block ) ; ( 2 ) DetNet Service Proxy ; and ( 3 ) DetNet sub - layers . Approving from teelcon review" 3486514b01b74d57f031bcf660311de328a6e0dc 3486514b01b74d57f031bcf660311de328a6e0dc draft-ietf-detnet-tsn-vpn-over-mpls c757c3611002031d5ce1ac79d9984d826f392e6628a0657e045c348e52b7eda2 ['e82e49a3c764c0ede490d9e8afe0d0a379ec1e2fb734910d7e42f179709f894c', '1b5276bed81725e3cab5fa8d2491ae7fc344c8638906d8e62ee7c31696edcb52', 'a6a4ee1a9211a2be0e24cf91f9742499a46567acff4c78f62b568b34e38c08de', '44d22f065218a14d5aa04288e7553c8a6d81bb222066c74ea38571bbe922a729', 'c757c3611002031d5ce1ac79d9984d826f392e6628a0657e045c348e52b7eda2', '8a105d9f9ffbf3e747a101e48de19122931cd0cce896dc27f57d16df9dbb75ac', 'a8ff14472a8fa48bacdc11d7089a9d1054c0a786f6152f510b5d4092c22e121f', 'e746630d4b45cf2b654a14e4daaa03ad634e33d92c29c489e3ef3fcd5620c311', '16375944152e6c3e73492437880fe39d7f0123a9292d062e8e9c7d317e4b878f', '42f5214bb177fd7faf01b7943e7f313a615b2490f9109d5cefa8b24101735c32', '5cc97b8f56cdeeb02e7c96183745dc53dd8ec3ec02424107d16eb438c2c9363c', 'a816e4d1392c9c85d398ee2c5116b5de849a9823bc552d322ac8725f7c9b859e', 'c7286f8983508fdd7d94ae798cdc3950cbf65865e905c00a76838a34eb79cf2c', '6924f7b3002e9f0dff9023b70bcc9d484e643c3a2d95b0d5c853c084ad3f68ab', '2d8fce3963de03360a5d98758067925a60474b5430fd8091fc72f3c50a9d38e5', '77f9aaec42bbb94079fae33b8c564cd7f64721106f615e11f22673310efaf01b', '09f8dc962fd9202d148a0b378c9a078ea850056b4b5c360c0914d4a1de6af454', '4826376633600232b766cb8a62d4054b0f5ea45d74878bcf57356e567088300c', '82b410c949db1d81b3f197adbaaba7b82b6e497600cd9883150af2bb815caa19', '0eb73f51f3b491bd6d969a05acf2b527e6e2f09a460cb88266513ab952bd3fc6', '1076eab6753435c114e8a720c951b03da6d4e1bbbf1290f8d58ad7f97a0b8c64', '4ccf918f8b8ae99a769d89e0868a12e4af1536487652436b6c188bc99e14fdb6', '2a5cef1e9c76b52b9b56c6c021a857b0fa757897b6e3c96cc8170d5b73ba8dd8', '07267e696bfbb5af98da5a8efe2b8cf604bc9ab1ce95e4766f017473bfcd0de1', '82f56d4694c2ec964de0a4413954f87ca621628c63d7425944baeff9aa4b6dad', '01e1da53fe2751e7196114efc63dd70d9babc69b4b73c03d4b7528dcc10c05d3', 'fb8f3ca7fafc9c173404ce7f909038443a6078a0c278cb024639410e33f49f88', '44e497e2df0461bad9215c57918855022435eb6e28266916161de3f7902bb352', '84f5bc0e0be5d04b515e8e49efb393e4aec7189222b92c0555cc1be542e74549', '3195c90c03cf6a438b5684cc93128c53f794660a661e2aa85d043ca5ac7060b9', 'b5bacf05f766e143f6de9484b0b5a2d9655d62854368373bd77974b94cb722e6', '2442b9072d522cde54849b40cab26789e4af909f1dd81391cd8c87023515a21c', 'b03d79d1a547b36a28c6cba78f57b8244a4855f6b31003de3e617a5b5eddc070', 'e386562e3156c91934ceb045df46d7e847bb9afcad2794bda59be854f988befc', 'cc980749457292da3a6a4a3ce669ad487409ce72e20857e80c75741c83af7f0a', '75db9ae91b710fcf1df3553b8f9653b12d014f74ba1ee8f931870d2433e163f1', '0e313215df9694bc26777ba4ac347cb8ef73f8475d2bfed664aab722833589ae', '1094721b24c22ff67539ffeabab887f87e538bdd9ebe50b0b369de138d326802', 'fb2b9389e1455c6d64ae19158396d767d88969013b14075bcfdcc764f610108c', 'ae3bdd3a81d96e4aaa02f7d597a2684146f3af75b743bde8e31c3cf5883707db', '1b8137b4c60774716e4a492efec48060d48abd7308563d8cc76edf32d98bd759', '09732023af932d8c578c8a7ead49feb80cdb5c629cee6add2e24fcd7999c0309', '75b7020073ec0c8cedf517f1b56d554e2a5cfdf89d204633c30b863c42ed6f5f', '4be1dfb90ea542d5d84c23c0ba29b91db2491a39973839ee646eeec25c71adb4', 'c98d52f719106d13b14f27abde81ce00305cbf62889690b72da3e3ddc0286c02', '056859e4aa430e2eb983e93f08bb85d9afe9aec44f0e73263cf072df70b7c475', '870147c2dad0a0dda2dd0a9f85ef83b3c4de9a304fdff6d9fa9ccc4bde9d70c0', '26e942b0353fee8f5ac0a2c2e26c9b695c50b35c501eeb4bff343b1648b5cebc', '036168e918418eb807bc3efd361a8e66067192564da41e30e076d22be0f87935', 'a491df768673d76ae7dee4c9bf1ea1456e6c537a1f1683368d8bc6869cd89bf0', 'f6a8cfceb19b4cd796512223b8afd103c4aee7052247ebea8b50f743e9aa27b6', 'd135518ad4230c8f57a3510b3ddea8a99e2355363c9419a27340734427050729', 'cbe90e272b6be7696d3b8c171500847d2b0ae497f6911d0f9d5d8481101c4c1f', '249c961ea29438959ea2204728df24964ec80b8cd91c657715c47014f5e5a462', '1920ebb46d0cee2d379ef48c15f8f6abd01e2a183f316da235e0c3b7515feade', '6d1573b42d5f89f89b26b32cbbd32ff41660e0e8c3b3091f1cb278a42651e049', 'ec6878825845c61b3049ad5dd168197c84938e7f6d4fc938670da2528cf86317', '9829b13faebde69c2279c38cd54d524aa31acfdcc1cfba7910b9d69caa42e0dd', '2755ae7cda161df0c24e1fa9f1c3308bc9ef81a599d859668490484290ca72f4', '09d9dcfc1716808b0c62e47a771ff4d39ba71f22c8640776e65624747a995626', '71dfcd074b80de90c4955890bdbe127d12b249ed764c7c4ca23dc81c74fde71d', '3c1afbb156ee2d672ca131c7c966bc6875374a95d927848bafcc5a158edf67bb'] A "specifics related to non-mpls detnet end station behavior are out side the scope of this document. for example, details on support for detnet ip data flows can be found in i-d.ietf-detnet-dp-sol-ip. this document is also useful for end stations that map ip flows to detnet flows." {79: 1, 130: 1, 54: 1, 52: 1, 98: 1, 6: 1, 8: 1, 64: 1, 99: 1, 24: 1, 90: 2, 51: 2, 62: 4, 85: 4, 68: 3, 35: 2, 110: 2, 91: 4, 114: 2, 97: 2, 31: 2, 13: 2, 67: 2, 38: 3, 26: 2, 124: 2, 127: 2, 96: 2, 30: 3, 61: 4, 55: 2, 27: 3, 15: 2, 129: 2, 115: 2, 84: 2, 76: 5, 87: 2, 131: 4, 102: 2, 113: 4, 36: 2, 72: 3} {4: 1, 24: 1, 59: 1, 111: 1, 136: 1, 156: 1, 206: 1, 215: 1, 220: 1, 221: 1, 235: 1, 241: 1, 242: 1, 314: 1, 329: 1, 334: 1, 354: 1, 366: 1, 376: 1, 1: 8, 9: 4, 10: 2, 15: 2, 25: 4, 26: 4, 27: 2, 39: 4, 43: 2, 49: 5, 50: 4, 58: 4, 64: 2, 69: 3, 81: 5, 82: 3, 86: 2, 96: 3, 97: 2, 100: 6, 108: 2, 109: 3, 110: 3, 114: 2, 115: 3, 116: 2, 118: 5, 119: 4, 120: 2, 121: 3, 122: 3, 123: 2, 124: 3, 128: 3, 129: 3, 130: 4, 132: 3, 145: 3, 147: 3, 151: 3, 152: 3, 154: 2, 161: 2, 162: 2, 165: 2, 168: 3, 169: 2, 172: 2, 180: 3, 184: 4, 187: 4, 188: 3, 191: 2, 194: 3, 202: 4, 203: 5, 207: 2, 217: 2, 218: 7, 222: 4, 224: 2, 227: 4, 229: 2, 234: 4, 243: 3, 244: 3, 245: 3, 248: 3, 250: 3, 258: 10, 262: 3, 263: 4, 264: 2, 267: 3, 270: 2, 272: 2, 273: 4, 287: 2, 289: 2, 291: 4, 299: 4, 300: 2, 304: 2, 309: 2, 315: 2, 320: 3, 323: 3, 327: 3, 328: 2, 330: 9, 335: 2, 341: 4, 342: 5, 347: 4, 348: 4, 350: 6, 351: 4, 352: 2, 353: 2, 358: 3, 365: 2, 371: 6, 372: 4, 384: 4, 385: 3, 386: 2, 387: 2, 392: 2, 393: 3, 396: 5, 397: 6, 398: 5, 402: 2} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 53 "As a general rule, DetNet MPLS domains are capable of forwarding any DetNet MPLS flows and the DetNet domain does not mandate the end- system or edge system encapsulation format. Unless there is a proxy of some form present, end-systems peer with similar end-systems using the same application encapsulation format. For example, as shown in fig_es_connect, IP applications peer with IP applications and Ethernet L2VPN applications peer with Ethernet L2VPN applications." "Major clean up and simplification as data plane drafts can be referred for MPLS related details . TSN over DetNet MPLS follows the concept of RFC3985 . Description focus on Edge Nodes procedures and functions . Text covers the Edge Nodes components : ( 1 ) TSN functions ( in NSP block ) ; ( 2 ) DetNet Service Proxy ; and ( 3 ) DetNet sub - layers . Approving from teelcon review" 3486514b01b74d57f031bcf660311de328a6e0dc 3486514b01b74d57f031bcf660311de328a6e0dc draft-ietf-detnet-tsn-vpn-over-mpls c98d52f719106d13b14f27abde81ce00305cbf62889690b72da3e3ddc0286c02 ['e82e49a3c764c0ede490d9e8afe0d0a379ec1e2fb734910d7e42f179709f894c', '1b5276bed81725e3cab5fa8d2491ae7fc344c8638906d8e62ee7c31696edcb52', 'a6a4ee1a9211a2be0e24cf91f9742499a46567acff4c78f62b568b34e38c08de', '44d22f065218a14d5aa04288e7553c8a6d81bb222066c74ea38571bbe922a729', 'c757c3611002031d5ce1ac79d9984d826f392e6628a0657e045c348e52b7eda2', '8a105d9f9ffbf3e747a101e48de19122931cd0cce896dc27f57d16df9dbb75ac', 'a8ff14472a8fa48bacdc11d7089a9d1054c0a786f6152f510b5d4092c22e121f', 'e746630d4b45cf2b654a14e4daaa03ad634e33d92c29c489e3ef3fcd5620c311', '16375944152e6c3e73492437880fe39d7f0123a9292d062e8e9c7d317e4b878f', '42f5214bb177fd7faf01b7943e7f313a615b2490f9109d5cefa8b24101735c32', '5cc97b8f56cdeeb02e7c96183745dc53dd8ec3ec02424107d16eb438c2c9363c', 'a816e4d1392c9c85d398ee2c5116b5de849a9823bc552d322ac8725f7c9b859e', 'c7286f8983508fdd7d94ae798cdc3950cbf65865e905c00a76838a34eb79cf2c', '6924f7b3002e9f0dff9023b70bcc9d484e643c3a2d95b0d5c853c084ad3f68ab', '2d8fce3963de03360a5d98758067925a60474b5430fd8091fc72f3c50a9d38e5', '77f9aaec42bbb94079fae33b8c564cd7f64721106f615e11f22673310efaf01b', '09f8dc962fd9202d148a0b378c9a078ea850056b4b5c360c0914d4a1de6af454', '4826376633600232b766cb8a62d4054b0f5ea45d74878bcf57356e567088300c', '82b410c949db1d81b3f197adbaaba7b82b6e497600cd9883150af2bb815caa19', '0eb73f51f3b491bd6d969a05acf2b527e6e2f09a460cb88266513ab952bd3fc6', '1076eab6753435c114e8a720c951b03da6d4e1bbbf1290f8d58ad7f97a0b8c64', '4ccf918f8b8ae99a769d89e0868a12e4af1536487652436b6c188bc99e14fdb6', '2a5cef1e9c76b52b9b56c6c021a857b0fa757897b6e3c96cc8170d5b73ba8dd8', '07267e696bfbb5af98da5a8efe2b8cf604bc9ab1ce95e4766f017473bfcd0de1', '82f56d4694c2ec964de0a4413954f87ca621628c63d7425944baeff9aa4b6dad', '01e1da53fe2751e7196114efc63dd70d9babc69b4b73c03d4b7528dcc10c05d3', 'fb8f3ca7fafc9c173404ce7f909038443a6078a0c278cb024639410e33f49f88', '44e497e2df0461bad9215c57918855022435eb6e28266916161de3f7902bb352', '84f5bc0e0be5d04b515e8e49efb393e4aec7189222b92c0555cc1be542e74549', '3195c90c03cf6a438b5684cc93128c53f794660a661e2aa85d043ca5ac7060b9', 'b5bacf05f766e143f6de9484b0b5a2d9655d62854368373bd77974b94cb722e6', '2442b9072d522cde54849b40cab26789e4af909f1dd81391cd8c87023515a21c', 'b03d79d1a547b36a28c6cba78f57b8244a4855f6b31003de3e617a5b5eddc070', 'e386562e3156c91934ceb045df46d7e847bb9afcad2794bda59be854f988befc', 'cc980749457292da3a6a4a3ce669ad487409ce72e20857e80c75741c83af7f0a', '75db9ae91b710fcf1df3553b8f9653b12d014f74ba1ee8f931870d2433e163f1', '0e313215df9694bc26777ba4ac347cb8ef73f8475d2bfed664aab722833589ae', '1094721b24c22ff67539ffeabab887f87e538bdd9ebe50b0b369de138d326802', 'fb2b9389e1455c6d64ae19158396d767d88969013b14075bcfdcc764f610108c', 'ae3bdd3a81d96e4aaa02f7d597a2684146f3af75b743bde8e31c3cf5883707db', '1b8137b4c60774716e4a492efec48060d48abd7308563d8cc76edf32d98bd759', '09732023af932d8c578c8a7ead49feb80cdb5c629cee6add2e24fcd7999c0309', '75b7020073ec0c8cedf517f1b56d554e2a5cfdf89d204633c30b863c42ed6f5f', '4be1dfb90ea542d5d84c23c0ba29b91db2491a39973839ee646eeec25c71adb4', 'c98d52f719106d13b14f27abde81ce00305cbf62889690b72da3e3ddc0286c02', '056859e4aa430e2eb983e93f08bb85d9afe9aec44f0e73263cf072df70b7c475', '870147c2dad0a0dda2dd0a9f85ef83b3c4de9a304fdff6d9fa9ccc4bde9d70c0', '26e942b0353fee8f5ac0a2c2e26c9b695c50b35c501eeb4bff343b1648b5cebc', '036168e918418eb807bc3efd361a8e66067192564da41e30e076d22be0f87935', 'a491df768673d76ae7dee4c9bf1ea1456e6c537a1f1683368d8bc6869cd89bf0', 'f6a8cfceb19b4cd796512223b8afd103c4aee7052247ebea8b50f743e9aa27b6', 'd135518ad4230c8f57a3510b3ddea8a99e2355363c9419a27340734427050729', 'cbe90e272b6be7696d3b8c171500847d2b0ae497f6911d0f9d5d8481101c4c1f', '249c961ea29438959ea2204728df24964ec80b8cd91c657715c47014f5e5a462', '1920ebb46d0cee2d379ef48c15f8f6abd01e2a183f316da235e0c3b7515feade', '6d1573b42d5f89f89b26b32cbbd32ff41660e0e8c3b3091f1cb278a42651e049', 'ec6878825845c61b3049ad5dd168197c84938e7f6d4fc938670da2528cf86317', '9829b13faebde69c2279c38cd54d524aa31acfdcc1cfba7910b9d69caa42e0dd', '2755ae7cda161df0c24e1fa9f1c3308bc9ef81a599d859668490484290ca72f4', '09d9dcfc1716808b0c62e47a771ff4d39ba71f22c8640776e65624747a995626', '71dfcd074b80de90c4955890bdbe127d12b249ed764c7c4ca23dc81c74fde71d', '3c1afbb156ee2d672ca131c7c966bc6875374a95d927848bafcc5a158edf67bb'] A "as a general rule, detnet mpls domains are capable of forwarding any detnet mpls flows and the detnet domain does not mandate the end- system or edge system encapsulation format. unless there is a proxy of some form present, end-systems peer with similar end-systems using the same application encapsulation format. for example, as shown in fig_es_connect, ip applications peer with ip applications and ethernet l2vpn applications peer with ethernet l2vpn applications." {79: 1, 130: 1, 54: 1, 52: 1, 98: 1, 6: 1, 8: 1, 64: 1, 99: 1, 24: 1, 90: 2, 51: 2, 62: 4, 85: 4, 68: 3, 35: 2, 110: 2, 91: 4, 114: 2, 97: 2, 31: 2, 13: 2, 67: 2, 38: 3, 26: 2, 124: 2, 127: 2, 96: 2, 30: 3, 61: 4, 55: 2, 27: 3, 15: 2, 129: 2, 115: 2, 84: 2, 76: 5, 87: 2, 131: 4, 102: 2, 113: 4, 36: 2, 72: 3} {4: 1, 24: 1, 59: 1, 111: 1, 136: 1, 156: 1, 206: 1, 215: 1, 220: 1, 221: 1, 235: 1, 241: 1, 242: 1, 314: 1, 329: 1, 334: 1, 354: 1, 366: 1, 376: 1, 1: 8, 9: 4, 10: 2, 15: 2, 25: 4, 26: 4, 27: 2, 39: 4, 43: 2, 49: 5, 50: 4, 58: 4, 64: 2, 69: 3, 81: 5, 82: 3, 86: 2, 96: 3, 97: 2, 100: 6, 108: 2, 109: 3, 110: 3, 114: 2, 115: 3, 116: 2, 118: 5, 119: 4, 120: 2, 121: 3, 122: 3, 123: 2, 124: 3, 128: 3, 129: 3, 130: 4, 132: 3, 145: 3, 147: 3, 151: 3, 152: 3, 154: 2, 161: 2, 162: 2, 165: 2, 168: 3, 169: 2, 172: 2, 180: 3, 184: 4, 187: 4, 188: 3, 191: 2, 194: 3, 202: 4, 203: 5, 207: 2, 217: 2, 218: 7, 222: 4, 224: 2, 227: 4, 229: 2, 234: 4, 243: 3, 244: 3, 245: 3, 248: 3, 250: 3, 258: 10, 262: 3, 263: 4, 264: 2, 267: 3, 270: 2, 272: 2, 273: 4, 287: 2, 289: 2, 291: 4, 299: 4, 300: 2, 304: 2, 309: 2, 315: 2, 320: 3, 323: 3, 327: 3, 328: 2, 330: 9, 335: 2, 341: 4, 342: 5, 347: 4, 348: 4, 350: 6, 351: 4, 352: 2, 353: 2, 358: 3, 365: 2, 371: 6, 372: 4, 384: 4, 385: 3, 386: 2, 387: 2, 392: 2, 393: 3, 396: 5, 397: 6, 398: 5, 402: 2} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 53 A method of identifying the MPLS payload type. "Major clean up and simplification as data plane drafts can be referred for MPLS related details . TSN over DetNet MPLS follows the concept of RFC3985 . Description focus on Edge Nodes procedures and functions . Text covers the Edge Nodes components : ( 1 ) TSN functions ( in NSP block ) ; ( 2 ) DetNet Service Proxy ; and ( 3 ) DetNet sub - layers . Approving from teelcon review" 3486514b01b74d57f031bcf660311de328a6e0dc 3486514b01b74d57f031bcf660311de328a6e0dc draft-ietf-detnet-tsn-vpn-over-mpls e82e49a3c764c0ede490d9e8afe0d0a379ec1e2fb734910d7e42f179709f894c ['e82e49a3c764c0ede490d9e8afe0d0a379ec1e2fb734910d7e42f179709f894c', '1b5276bed81725e3cab5fa8d2491ae7fc344c8638906d8e62ee7c31696edcb52', 'a6a4ee1a9211a2be0e24cf91f9742499a46567acff4c78f62b568b34e38c08de', '44d22f065218a14d5aa04288e7553c8a6d81bb222066c74ea38571bbe922a729', 'c757c3611002031d5ce1ac79d9984d826f392e6628a0657e045c348e52b7eda2', '8a105d9f9ffbf3e747a101e48de19122931cd0cce896dc27f57d16df9dbb75ac', 'a8ff14472a8fa48bacdc11d7089a9d1054c0a786f6152f510b5d4092c22e121f', 'e746630d4b45cf2b654a14e4daaa03ad634e33d92c29c489e3ef3fcd5620c311', '16375944152e6c3e73492437880fe39d7f0123a9292d062e8e9c7d317e4b878f', '42f5214bb177fd7faf01b7943e7f313a615b2490f9109d5cefa8b24101735c32', '5cc97b8f56cdeeb02e7c96183745dc53dd8ec3ec02424107d16eb438c2c9363c', 'a816e4d1392c9c85d398ee2c5116b5de849a9823bc552d322ac8725f7c9b859e', 'c7286f8983508fdd7d94ae798cdc3950cbf65865e905c00a76838a34eb79cf2c', '6924f7b3002e9f0dff9023b70bcc9d484e643c3a2d95b0d5c853c084ad3f68ab', '2d8fce3963de03360a5d98758067925a60474b5430fd8091fc72f3c50a9d38e5', '77f9aaec42bbb94079fae33b8c564cd7f64721106f615e11f22673310efaf01b', '09f8dc962fd9202d148a0b378c9a078ea850056b4b5c360c0914d4a1de6af454', '4826376633600232b766cb8a62d4054b0f5ea45d74878bcf57356e567088300c', '82b410c949db1d81b3f197adbaaba7b82b6e497600cd9883150af2bb815caa19', '0eb73f51f3b491bd6d969a05acf2b527e6e2f09a460cb88266513ab952bd3fc6', '1076eab6753435c114e8a720c951b03da6d4e1bbbf1290f8d58ad7f97a0b8c64', '4ccf918f8b8ae99a769d89e0868a12e4af1536487652436b6c188bc99e14fdb6', '2a5cef1e9c76b52b9b56c6c021a857b0fa757897b6e3c96cc8170d5b73ba8dd8', '07267e696bfbb5af98da5a8efe2b8cf604bc9ab1ce95e4766f017473bfcd0de1', '82f56d4694c2ec964de0a4413954f87ca621628c63d7425944baeff9aa4b6dad', '01e1da53fe2751e7196114efc63dd70d9babc69b4b73c03d4b7528dcc10c05d3', 'fb8f3ca7fafc9c173404ce7f909038443a6078a0c278cb024639410e33f49f88', '44e497e2df0461bad9215c57918855022435eb6e28266916161de3f7902bb352', '84f5bc0e0be5d04b515e8e49efb393e4aec7189222b92c0555cc1be542e74549', '3195c90c03cf6a438b5684cc93128c53f794660a661e2aa85d043ca5ac7060b9', 'b5bacf05f766e143f6de9484b0b5a2d9655d62854368373bd77974b94cb722e6', '2442b9072d522cde54849b40cab26789e4af909f1dd81391cd8c87023515a21c', 'b03d79d1a547b36a28c6cba78f57b8244a4855f6b31003de3e617a5b5eddc070', 'e386562e3156c91934ceb045df46d7e847bb9afcad2794bda59be854f988befc', 'cc980749457292da3a6a4a3ce669ad487409ce72e20857e80c75741c83af7f0a', '75db9ae91b710fcf1df3553b8f9653b12d014f74ba1ee8f931870d2433e163f1', '0e313215df9694bc26777ba4ac347cb8ef73f8475d2bfed664aab722833589ae', '1094721b24c22ff67539ffeabab887f87e538bdd9ebe50b0b369de138d326802', 'fb2b9389e1455c6d64ae19158396d767d88969013b14075bcfdcc764f610108c', 'ae3bdd3a81d96e4aaa02f7d597a2684146f3af75b743bde8e31c3cf5883707db', '1b8137b4c60774716e4a492efec48060d48abd7308563d8cc76edf32d98bd759', '09732023af932d8c578c8a7ead49feb80cdb5c629cee6add2e24fcd7999c0309', '75b7020073ec0c8cedf517f1b56d554e2a5cfdf89d204633c30b863c42ed6f5f', '4be1dfb90ea542d5d84c23c0ba29b91db2491a39973839ee646eeec25c71adb4', 'c98d52f719106d13b14f27abde81ce00305cbf62889690b72da3e3ddc0286c02', '056859e4aa430e2eb983e93f08bb85d9afe9aec44f0e73263cf072df70b7c475', '870147c2dad0a0dda2dd0a9f85ef83b3c4de9a304fdff6d9fa9ccc4bde9d70c0', '26e942b0353fee8f5ac0a2c2e26c9b695c50b35c501eeb4bff343b1648b5cebc', '036168e918418eb807bc3efd361a8e66067192564da41e30e076d22be0f87935', 'a491df768673d76ae7dee4c9bf1ea1456e6c537a1f1683368d8bc6869cd89bf0', 'f6a8cfceb19b4cd796512223b8afd103c4aee7052247ebea8b50f743e9aa27b6', 'd135518ad4230c8f57a3510b3ddea8a99e2355363c9419a27340734427050729', 'cbe90e272b6be7696d3b8c171500847d2b0ae497f6911d0f9d5d8481101c4c1f', '249c961ea29438959ea2204728df24964ec80b8cd91c657715c47014f5e5a462', '1920ebb46d0cee2d379ef48c15f8f6abd01e2a183f316da235e0c3b7515feade', '6d1573b42d5f89f89b26b32cbbd32ff41660e0e8c3b3091f1cb278a42651e049', 'ec6878825845c61b3049ad5dd168197c84938e7f6d4fc938670da2528cf86317', '9829b13faebde69c2279c38cd54d524aa31acfdcc1cfba7910b9d69caa42e0dd', '2755ae7cda161df0c24e1fa9f1c3308bc9ef81a599d859668490484290ca72f4', '09d9dcfc1716808b0c62e47a771ff4d39ba71f22c8640776e65624747a995626', '71dfcd074b80de90c4955890bdbe127d12b249ed764c7c4ca23dc81c74fde71d', '3c1afbb156ee2d672ca131c7c966bc6875374a95d927848bafcc5a158edf67bb'] A a method of identifying the mpls payload type. {79: 1, 130: 1, 54: 1, 52: 1, 98: 1, 6: 1, 8: 1, 64: 1, 99: 1, 24: 1, 90: 2, 51: 2, 62: 4, 85: 4, 68: 3, 35: 2, 110: 2, 91: 4, 114: 2, 97: 2, 31: 2, 13: 2, 67: 2, 38: 3, 26: 2, 124: 2, 127: 2, 96: 2, 30: 3, 61: 4, 55: 2, 27: 3, 15: 2, 129: 2, 115: 2, 84: 2, 76: 5, 87: 2, 131: 4, 102: 2, 113: 4, 36: 2, 72: 3} {4: 1, 24: 1, 59: 1, 111: 1, 136: 1, 156: 1, 206: 1, 215: 1, 220: 1, 221: 1, 235: 1, 241: 1, 242: 1, 314: 1, 329: 1, 334: 1, 354: 1, 366: 1, 376: 1, 1: 8, 9: 4, 10: 2, 15: 2, 25: 4, 26: 4, 27: 2, 39: 4, 43: 2, 49: 5, 50: 4, 58: 4, 64: 2, 69: 3, 81: 5, 82: 3, 86: 2, 96: 3, 97: 2, 100: 6, 108: 2, 109: 3, 110: 3, 114: 2, 115: 3, 116: 2, 118: 5, 119: 4, 120: 2, 121: 3, 122: 3, 123: 2, 124: 3, 128: 3, 129: 3, 130: 4, 132: 3, 145: 3, 147: 3, 151: 3, 152: 3, 154: 2, 161: 2, 162: 2, 165: 2, 168: 3, 169: 2, 172: 2, 180: 3, 184: 4, 187: 4, 188: 3, 191: 2, 194: 3, 202: 4, 203: 5, 207: 2, 217: 2, 218: 7, 222: 4, 224: 2, 227: 4, 229: 2, 234: 4, 243: 3, 244: 3, 245: 3, 248: 3, 250: 3, 258: 10, 262: 3, 263: 4, 264: 2, 267: 3, 270: 2, 272: 2, 273: 4, 287: 2, 289: 2, 291: 4, 299: 4, 300: 2, 304: 2, 309: 2, 315: 2, 320: 3, 323: 3, 327: 3, 328: 2, 330: 9, 335: 2, 341: 4, 342: 5, 347: 4, 348: 4, 350: 6, 351: 4, 352: 2, 353: 2, 358: 3, 365: 2, 371: 6, 372: 4, 384: 4, 385: 3, 386: 2, 387: 2, 392: 2, 393: 3, 396: 5, 397: 6, 398: 5, 402: 2} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 53 "A method of identifying the DetNet flow group to the processing element." "Major clean up and simplification as data plane drafts can be referred for MPLS related details . TSN over DetNet MPLS follows the concept of RFC3985 . Description focus on Edge Nodes procedures and functions . Text covers the Edge Nodes components : ( 1 ) TSN functions ( in NSP block ) ; ( 2 ) DetNet Service Proxy ; and ( 3 ) DetNet sub - layers . Approving from teelcon review" 3486514b01b74d57f031bcf660311de328a6e0dc 3486514b01b74d57f031bcf660311de328a6e0dc draft-ietf-detnet-tsn-vpn-over-mpls 82f56d4694c2ec964de0a4413954f87ca621628c63d7425944baeff9aa4b6dad ['e82e49a3c764c0ede490d9e8afe0d0a379ec1e2fb734910d7e42f179709f894c', '1b5276bed81725e3cab5fa8d2491ae7fc344c8638906d8e62ee7c31696edcb52', 'a6a4ee1a9211a2be0e24cf91f9742499a46567acff4c78f62b568b34e38c08de', '44d22f065218a14d5aa04288e7553c8a6d81bb222066c74ea38571bbe922a729', 'c757c3611002031d5ce1ac79d9984d826f392e6628a0657e045c348e52b7eda2', '8a105d9f9ffbf3e747a101e48de19122931cd0cce896dc27f57d16df9dbb75ac', 'a8ff14472a8fa48bacdc11d7089a9d1054c0a786f6152f510b5d4092c22e121f', 'e746630d4b45cf2b654a14e4daaa03ad634e33d92c29c489e3ef3fcd5620c311', '16375944152e6c3e73492437880fe39d7f0123a9292d062e8e9c7d317e4b878f', '42f5214bb177fd7faf01b7943e7f313a615b2490f9109d5cefa8b24101735c32', '5cc97b8f56cdeeb02e7c96183745dc53dd8ec3ec02424107d16eb438c2c9363c', 'a816e4d1392c9c85d398ee2c5116b5de849a9823bc552d322ac8725f7c9b859e', 'c7286f8983508fdd7d94ae798cdc3950cbf65865e905c00a76838a34eb79cf2c', '6924f7b3002e9f0dff9023b70bcc9d484e643c3a2d95b0d5c853c084ad3f68ab', '2d8fce3963de03360a5d98758067925a60474b5430fd8091fc72f3c50a9d38e5', '77f9aaec42bbb94079fae33b8c564cd7f64721106f615e11f22673310efaf01b', '09f8dc962fd9202d148a0b378c9a078ea850056b4b5c360c0914d4a1de6af454', '4826376633600232b766cb8a62d4054b0f5ea45d74878bcf57356e567088300c', '82b410c949db1d81b3f197adbaaba7b82b6e497600cd9883150af2bb815caa19', '0eb73f51f3b491bd6d969a05acf2b527e6e2f09a460cb88266513ab952bd3fc6', '1076eab6753435c114e8a720c951b03da6d4e1bbbf1290f8d58ad7f97a0b8c64', '4ccf918f8b8ae99a769d89e0868a12e4af1536487652436b6c188bc99e14fdb6', '2a5cef1e9c76b52b9b56c6c021a857b0fa757897b6e3c96cc8170d5b73ba8dd8', '07267e696bfbb5af98da5a8efe2b8cf604bc9ab1ce95e4766f017473bfcd0de1', '82f56d4694c2ec964de0a4413954f87ca621628c63d7425944baeff9aa4b6dad', '01e1da53fe2751e7196114efc63dd70d9babc69b4b73c03d4b7528dcc10c05d3', 'fb8f3ca7fafc9c173404ce7f909038443a6078a0c278cb024639410e33f49f88', '44e497e2df0461bad9215c57918855022435eb6e28266916161de3f7902bb352', '84f5bc0e0be5d04b515e8e49efb393e4aec7189222b92c0555cc1be542e74549', '3195c90c03cf6a438b5684cc93128c53f794660a661e2aa85d043ca5ac7060b9', 'b5bacf05f766e143f6de9484b0b5a2d9655d62854368373bd77974b94cb722e6', '2442b9072d522cde54849b40cab26789e4af909f1dd81391cd8c87023515a21c', 'b03d79d1a547b36a28c6cba78f57b8244a4855f6b31003de3e617a5b5eddc070', 'e386562e3156c91934ceb045df46d7e847bb9afcad2794bda59be854f988befc', 'cc980749457292da3a6a4a3ce669ad487409ce72e20857e80c75741c83af7f0a', '75db9ae91b710fcf1df3553b8f9653b12d014f74ba1ee8f931870d2433e163f1', '0e313215df9694bc26777ba4ac347cb8ef73f8475d2bfed664aab722833589ae', '1094721b24c22ff67539ffeabab887f87e538bdd9ebe50b0b369de138d326802', 'fb2b9389e1455c6d64ae19158396d767d88969013b14075bcfdcc764f610108c', 'ae3bdd3a81d96e4aaa02f7d597a2684146f3af75b743bde8e31c3cf5883707db', '1b8137b4c60774716e4a492efec48060d48abd7308563d8cc76edf32d98bd759', '09732023af932d8c578c8a7ead49feb80cdb5c629cee6add2e24fcd7999c0309', '75b7020073ec0c8cedf517f1b56d554e2a5cfdf89d204633c30b863c42ed6f5f', '4be1dfb90ea542d5d84c23c0ba29b91db2491a39973839ee646eeec25c71adb4', 'c98d52f719106d13b14f27abde81ce00305cbf62889690b72da3e3ddc0286c02', '056859e4aa430e2eb983e93f08bb85d9afe9aec44f0e73263cf072df70b7c475', '870147c2dad0a0dda2dd0a9f85ef83b3c4de9a304fdff6d9fa9ccc4bde9d70c0', '26e942b0353fee8f5ac0a2c2e26c9b695c50b35c501eeb4bff343b1648b5cebc', '036168e918418eb807bc3efd361a8e66067192564da41e30e076d22be0f87935', 'a491df768673d76ae7dee4c9bf1ea1456e6c537a1f1683368d8bc6869cd89bf0', 'f6a8cfceb19b4cd796512223b8afd103c4aee7052247ebea8b50f743e9aa27b6', 'd135518ad4230c8f57a3510b3ddea8a99e2355363c9419a27340734427050729', 'cbe90e272b6be7696d3b8c171500847d2b0ae497f6911d0f9d5d8481101c4c1f', '249c961ea29438959ea2204728df24964ec80b8cd91c657715c47014f5e5a462', '1920ebb46d0cee2d379ef48c15f8f6abd01e2a183f316da235e0c3b7515feade', '6d1573b42d5f89f89b26b32cbbd32ff41660e0e8c3b3091f1cb278a42651e049', 'ec6878825845c61b3049ad5dd168197c84938e7f6d4fc938670da2528cf86317', '9829b13faebde69c2279c38cd54d524aa31acfdcc1cfba7910b9d69caa42e0dd', '2755ae7cda161df0c24e1fa9f1c3308bc9ef81a599d859668490484290ca72f4', '09d9dcfc1716808b0c62e47a771ff4d39ba71f22c8640776e65624747a995626', '71dfcd074b80de90c4955890bdbe127d12b249ed764c7c4ca23dc81c74fde71d', '3c1afbb156ee2d672ca131c7c966bc6875374a95d927848bafcc5a158edf67bb'] A "a method of identifying the detnet flow group to the processing element." {79: 1, 130: 1, 54: 1, 52: 1, 98: 1, 6: 1, 8: 1, 64: 1, 99: 1, 24: 1, 90: 2, 51: 2, 62: 4, 85: 4, 68: 3, 35: 2, 110: 2, 91: 4, 114: 2, 97: 2, 31: 2, 13: 2, 67: 2, 38: 3, 26: 2, 124: 2, 127: 2, 96: 2, 30: 3, 61: 4, 55: 2, 27: 3, 15: 2, 129: 2, 115: 2, 84: 2, 76: 5, 87: 2, 131: 4, 102: 2, 113: 4, 36: 2, 72: 3} {4: 1, 24: 1, 59: 1, 111: 1, 136: 1, 156: 1, 206: 1, 215: 1, 220: 1, 221: 1, 235: 1, 241: 1, 242: 1, 314: 1, 329: 1, 334: 1, 354: 1, 366: 1, 376: 1, 1: 8, 9: 4, 10: 2, 15: 2, 25: 4, 26: 4, 27: 2, 39: 4, 43: 2, 49: 5, 50: 4, 58: 4, 64: 2, 69: 3, 81: 5, 82: 3, 86: 2, 96: 3, 97: 2, 100: 6, 108: 2, 109: 3, 110: 3, 114: 2, 115: 3, 116: 2, 118: 5, 119: 4, 120: 2, 121: 3, 122: 3, 123: 2, 124: 3, 128: 3, 129: 3, 130: 4, 132: 3, 145: 3, 147: 3, 151: 3, 152: 3, 154: 2, 161: 2, 162: 2, 165: 2, 168: 3, 169: 2, 172: 2, 180: 3, 184: 4, 187: 4, 188: 3, 191: 2, 194: 3, 202: 4, 203: 5, 207: 2, 217: 2, 218: 7, 222: 4, 224: 2, 227: 4, 229: 2, 234: 4, 243: 3, 244: 3, 245: 3, 248: 3, 250: 3, 258: 10, 262: 3, 263: 4, 264: 2, 267: 3, 270: 2, 272: 2, 273: 4, 287: 2, 289: 2, 291: 4, 299: 4, 300: 2, 304: 2, 309: 2, 315: 2, 320: 3, 323: 3, 327: 3, 328: 2, 330: 9, 335: 2, 341: 4, 342: 5, 347: 4, 348: 4, 350: 6, 351: 4, 352: 2, 353: 2, 358: 3, 365: 2, 371: 6, 372: 4, 384: 4, 385: 3, 386: 2, 387: 2, 392: 2, 393: 3, 396: 5, 397: 6, 398: 5, 402: 2} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 53 "A method of distinguishing DetNet OAM packets from DetNet data packets." "Major clean up and simplification as data plane drafts can be referred for MPLS related details . TSN over DetNet MPLS follows the concept of RFC3985 . Description focus on Edge Nodes procedures and functions . Text covers the Edge Nodes components : ( 1 ) TSN functions ( in NSP block ) ; ( 2 ) DetNet Service Proxy ; and ( 3 ) DetNet sub - layers . Approving from teelcon review" 3486514b01b74d57f031bcf660311de328a6e0dc 3486514b01b74d57f031bcf660311de328a6e0dc draft-ietf-detnet-tsn-vpn-over-mpls 0e313215df9694bc26777ba4ac347cb8ef73f8475d2bfed664aab722833589ae ['e82e49a3c764c0ede490d9e8afe0d0a379ec1e2fb734910d7e42f179709f894c', '1b5276bed81725e3cab5fa8d2491ae7fc344c8638906d8e62ee7c31696edcb52', 'a6a4ee1a9211a2be0e24cf91f9742499a46567acff4c78f62b568b34e38c08de', '44d22f065218a14d5aa04288e7553c8a6d81bb222066c74ea38571bbe922a729', 'c757c3611002031d5ce1ac79d9984d826f392e6628a0657e045c348e52b7eda2', '8a105d9f9ffbf3e747a101e48de19122931cd0cce896dc27f57d16df9dbb75ac', 'a8ff14472a8fa48bacdc11d7089a9d1054c0a786f6152f510b5d4092c22e121f', 'e746630d4b45cf2b654a14e4daaa03ad634e33d92c29c489e3ef3fcd5620c311', '16375944152e6c3e73492437880fe39d7f0123a9292d062e8e9c7d317e4b878f', '42f5214bb177fd7faf01b7943e7f313a615b2490f9109d5cefa8b24101735c32', '5cc97b8f56cdeeb02e7c96183745dc53dd8ec3ec02424107d16eb438c2c9363c', 'a816e4d1392c9c85d398ee2c5116b5de849a9823bc552d322ac8725f7c9b859e', 'c7286f8983508fdd7d94ae798cdc3950cbf65865e905c00a76838a34eb79cf2c', '6924f7b3002e9f0dff9023b70bcc9d484e643c3a2d95b0d5c853c084ad3f68ab', '2d8fce3963de03360a5d98758067925a60474b5430fd8091fc72f3c50a9d38e5', '77f9aaec42bbb94079fae33b8c564cd7f64721106f615e11f22673310efaf01b', '09f8dc962fd9202d148a0b378c9a078ea850056b4b5c360c0914d4a1de6af454', '4826376633600232b766cb8a62d4054b0f5ea45d74878bcf57356e567088300c', '82b410c949db1d81b3f197adbaaba7b82b6e497600cd9883150af2bb815caa19', '0eb73f51f3b491bd6d969a05acf2b527e6e2f09a460cb88266513ab952bd3fc6', '1076eab6753435c114e8a720c951b03da6d4e1bbbf1290f8d58ad7f97a0b8c64', '4ccf918f8b8ae99a769d89e0868a12e4af1536487652436b6c188bc99e14fdb6', '2a5cef1e9c76b52b9b56c6c021a857b0fa757897b6e3c96cc8170d5b73ba8dd8', '07267e696bfbb5af98da5a8efe2b8cf604bc9ab1ce95e4766f017473bfcd0de1', '82f56d4694c2ec964de0a4413954f87ca621628c63d7425944baeff9aa4b6dad', '01e1da53fe2751e7196114efc63dd70d9babc69b4b73c03d4b7528dcc10c05d3', 'fb8f3ca7fafc9c173404ce7f909038443a6078a0c278cb024639410e33f49f88', '44e497e2df0461bad9215c57918855022435eb6e28266916161de3f7902bb352', '84f5bc0e0be5d04b515e8e49efb393e4aec7189222b92c0555cc1be542e74549', '3195c90c03cf6a438b5684cc93128c53f794660a661e2aa85d043ca5ac7060b9', 'b5bacf05f766e143f6de9484b0b5a2d9655d62854368373bd77974b94cb722e6', '2442b9072d522cde54849b40cab26789e4af909f1dd81391cd8c87023515a21c', 'b03d79d1a547b36a28c6cba78f57b8244a4855f6b31003de3e617a5b5eddc070', 'e386562e3156c91934ceb045df46d7e847bb9afcad2794bda59be854f988befc', 'cc980749457292da3a6a4a3ce669ad487409ce72e20857e80c75741c83af7f0a', '75db9ae91b710fcf1df3553b8f9653b12d014f74ba1ee8f931870d2433e163f1', '0e313215df9694bc26777ba4ac347cb8ef73f8475d2bfed664aab722833589ae', '1094721b24c22ff67539ffeabab887f87e538bdd9ebe50b0b369de138d326802', 'fb2b9389e1455c6d64ae19158396d767d88969013b14075bcfdcc764f610108c', 'ae3bdd3a81d96e4aaa02f7d597a2684146f3af75b743bde8e31c3cf5883707db', '1b8137b4c60774716e4a492efec48060d48abd7308563d8cc76edf32d98bd759', '09732023af932d8c578c8a7ead49feb80cdb5c629cee6add2e24fcd7999c0309', '75b7020073ec0c8cedf517f1b56d554e2a5cfdf89d204633c30b863c42ed6f5f', '4be1dfb90ea542d5d84c23c0ba29b91db2491a39973839ee646eeec25c71adb4', 'c98d52f719106d13b14f27abde81ce00305cbf62889690b72da3e3ddc0286c02', '056859e4aa430e2eb983e93f08bb85d9afe9aec44f0e73263cf072df70b7c475', '870147c2dad0a0dda2dd0a9f85ef83b3c4de9a304fdff6d9fa9ccc4bde9d70c0', '26e942b0353fee8f5ac0a2c2e26c9b695c50b35c501eeb4bff343b1648b5cebc', '036168e918418eb807bc3efd361a8e66067192564da41e30e076d22be0f87935', 'a491df768673d76ae7dee4c9bf1ea1456e6c537a1f1683368d8bc6869cd89bf0', 'f6a8cfceb19b4cd796512223b8afd103c4aee7052247ebea8b50f743e9aa27b6', 'd135518ad4230c8f57a3510b3ddea8a99e2355363c9419a27340734427050729', 'cbe90e272b6be7696d3b8c171500847d2b0ae497f6911d0f9d5d8481101c4c1f', '249c961ea29438959ea2204728df24964ec80b8cd91c657715c47014f5e5a462', '1920ebb46d0cee2d379ef48c15f8f6abd01e2a183f316da235e0c3b7515feade', '6d1573b42d5f89f89b26b32cbbd32ff41660e0e8c3b3091f1cb278a42651e049', 'ec6878825845c61b3049ad5dd168197c84938e7f6d4fc938670da2528cf86317', '9829b13faebde69c2279c38cd54d524aa31acfdcc1cfba7910b9d69caa42e0dd', '2755ae7cda161df0c24e1fa9f1c3308bc9ef81a599d859668490484290ca72f4', '09d9dcfc1716808b0c62e47a771ff4d39ba71f22c8640776e65624747a995626', '71dfcd074b80de90c4955890bdbe127d12b249ed764c7c4ca23dc81c74fde71d', '3c1afbb156ee2d672ca131c7c966bc6875374a95d927848bafcc5a158edf67bb'] A "a method of distinguishing detnet oam packets from detnet data packets." {79: 1, 130: 1, 54: 1, 52: 1, 98: 1, 6: 1, 8: 1, 64: 1, 99: 1, 24: 1, 90: 2, 51: 2, 62: 4, 85: 4, 68: 3, 35: 2, 110: 2, 91: 4, 114: 2, 97: 2, 31: 2, 13: 2, 67: 2, 38: 3, 26: 2, 124: 2, 127: 2, 96: 2, 30: 3, 61: 4, 55: 2, 27: 3, 15: 2, 129: 2, 115: 2, 84: 2, 76: 5, 87: 2, 131: 4, 102: 2, 113: 4, 36: 2, 72: 3} {4: 1, 24: 1, 59: 1, 111: 1, 136: 1, 156: 1, 206: 1, 215: 1, 220: 1, 221: 1, 235: 1, 241: 1, 242: 1, 314: 1, 329: 1, 334: 1, 354: 1, 366: 1, 376: 1, 1: 8, 9: 4, 10: 2, 15: 2, 25: 4, 26: 4, 27: 2, 39: 4, 43: 2, 49: 5, 50: 4, 58: 4, 64: 2, 69: 3, 81: 5, 82: 3, 86: 2, 96: 3, 97: 2, 100: 6, 108: 2, 109: 3, 110: 3, 114: 2, 115: 3, 116: 2, 118: 5, 119: 4, 120: 2, 121: 3, 122: 3, 123: 2, 124: 3, 128: 3, 129: 3, 130: 4, 132: 3, 145: 3, 147: 3, 151: 3, 152: 3, 154: 2, 161: 2, 162: 2, 165: 2, 168: 3, 169: 2, 172: 2, 180: 3, 184: 4, 187: 4, 188: 3, 191: 2, 194: 3, 202: 4, 203: 5, 207: 2, 217: 2, 218: 7, 222: 4, 224: 2, 227: 4, 229: 2, 234: 4, 243: 3, 244: 3, 245: 3, 248: 3, 250: 3, 258: 10, 262: 3, 263: 4, 264: 2, 267: 3, 270: 2, 272: 2, 273: 4, 287: 2, 289: 2, 291: 4, 299: 4, 300: 2, 304: 2, 309: 2, 315: 2, 320: 3, 323: 3, 327: 3, 328: 2, 330: 9, 335: 2, 341: 4, 342: 5, 347: 4, 348: 4, 350: 6, 351: 4, 352: 2, 353: 2, 358: 3, 365: 2, 371: 6, 372: 4, 384: 4, 385: 3, 386: 2, 387: 2, 392: 2, 393: 3, 396: 5, 397: 6, 398: 5, 402: 2} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 53 A method of carrying the DetNet sequence number. "Major clean up and simplification as data plane drafts can be referred for MPLS related details . TSN over DetNet MPLS follows the concept of RFC3985 . Description focus on Edge Nodes procedures and functions . Text covers the Edge Nodes components : ( 1 ) TSN functions ( in NSP block ) ; ( 2 ) DetNet Service Proxy ; and ( 3 ) DetNet sub - layers . Approving from teelcon review" 3486514b01b74d57f031bcf660311de328a6e0dc 3486514b01b74d57f031bcf660311de328a6e0dc draft-ietf-detnet-tsn-vpn-over-mpls 870147c2dad0a0dda2dd0a9f85ef83b3c4de9a304fdff6d9fa9ccc4bde9d70c0 ['e82e49a3c764c0ede490d9e8afe0d0a379ec1e2fb734910d7e42f179709f894c', '1b5276bed81725e3cab5fa8d2491ae7fc344c8638906d8e62ee7c31696edcb52', 'a6a4ee1a9211a2be0e24cf91f9742499a46567acff4c78f62b568b34e38c08de', '44d22f065218a14d5aa04288e7553c8a6d81bb222066c74ea38571bbe922a729', 'c757c3611002031d5ce1ac79d9984d826f392e6628a0657e045c348e52b7eda2', '8a105d9f9ffbf3e747a101e48de19122931cd0cce896dc27f57d16df9dbb75ac', 'a8ff14472a8fa48bacdc11d7089a9d1054c0a786f6152f510b5d4092c22e121f', 'e746630d4b45cf2b654a14e4daaa03ad634e33d92c29c489e3ef3fcd5620c311', '16375944152e6c3e73492437880fe39d7f0123a9292d062e8e9c7d317e4b878f', '42f5214bb177fd7faf01b7943e7f313a615b2490f9109d5cefa8b24101735c32', '5cc97b8f56cdeeb02e7c96183745dc53dd8ec3ec02424107d16eb438c2c9363c', 'a816e4d1392c9c85d398ee2c5116b5de849a9823bc552d322ac8725f7c9b859e', 'c7286f8983508fdd7d94ae798cdc3950cbf65865e905c00a76838a34eb79cf2c', '6924f7b3002e9f0dff9023b70bcc9d484e643c3a2d95b0d5c853c084ad3f68ab', '2d8fce3963de03360a5d98758067925a60474b5430fd8091fc72f3c50a9d38e5', '77f9aaec42bbb94079fae33b8c564cd7f64721106f615e11f22673310efaf01b', '09f8dc962fd9202d148a0b378c9a078ea850056b4b5c360c0914d4a1de6af454', '4826376633600232b766cb8a62d4054b0f5ea45d74878bcf57356e567088300c', '82b410c949db1d81b3f197adbaaba7b82b6e497600cd9883150af2bb815caa19', '0eb73f51f3b491bd6d969a05acf2b527e6e2f09a460cb88266513ab952bd3fc6', '1076eab6753435c114e8a720c951b03da6d4e1bbbf1290f8d58ad7f97a0b8c64', '4ccf918f8b8ae99a769d89e0868a12e4af1536487652436b6c188bc99e14fdb6', '2a5cef1e9c76b52b9b56c6c021a857b0fa757897b6e3c96cc8170d5b73ba8dd8', '07267e696bfbb5af98da5a8efe2b8cf604bc9ab1ce95e4766f017473bfcd0de1', '82f56d4694c2ec964de0a4413954f87ca621628c63d7425944baeff9aa4b6dad', '01e1da53fe2751e7196114efc63dd70d9babc69b4b73c03d4b7528dcc10c05d3', 'fb8f3ca7fafc9c173404ce7f909038443a6078a0c278cb024639410e33f49f88', '44e497e2df0461bad9215c57918855022435eb6e28266916161de3f7902bb352', '84f5bc0e0be5d04b515e8e49efb393e4aec7189222b92c0555cc1be542e74549', '3195c90c03cf6a438b5684cc93128c53f794660a661e2aa85d043ca5ac7060b9', 'b5bacf05f766e143f6de9484b0b5a2d9655d62854368373bd77974b94cb722e6', '2442b9072d522cde54849b40cab26789e4af909f1dd81391cd8c87023515a21c', 'b03d79d1a547b36a28c6cba78f57b8244a4855f6b31003de3e617a5b5eddc070', 'e386562e3156c91934ceb045df46d7e847bb9afcad2794bda59be854f988befc', 'cc980749457292da3a6a4a3ce669ad487409ce72e20857e80c75741c83af7f0a', '75db9ae91b710fcf1df3553b8f9653b12d014f74ba1ee8f931870d2433e163f1', '0e313215df9694bc26777ba4ac347cb8ef73f8475d2bfed664aab722833589ae', '1094721b24c22ff67539ffeabab887f87e538bdd9ebe50b0b369de138d326802', 'fb2b9389e1455c6d64ae19158396d767d88969013b14075bcfdcc764f610108c', 'ae3bdd3a81d96e4aaa02f7d597a2684146f3af75b743bde8e31c3cf5883707db', '1b8137b4c60774716e4a492efec48060d48abd7308563d8cc76edf32d98bd759', '09732023af932d8c578c8a7ead49feb80cdb5c629cee6add2e24fcd7999c0309', '75b7020073ec0c8cedf517f1b56d554e2a5cfdf89d204633c30b863c42ed6f5f', '4be1dfb90ea542d5d84c23c0ba29b91db2491a39973839ee646eeec25c71adb4', 'c98d52f719106d13b14f27abde81ce00305cbf62889690b72da3e3ddc0286c02', '056859e4aa430e2eb983e93f08bb85d9afe9aec44f0e73263cf072df70b7c475', '870147c2dad0a0dda2dd0a9f85ef83b3c4de9a304fdff6d9fa9ccc4bde9d70c0', '26e942b0353fee8f5ac0a2c2e26c9b695c50b35c501eeb4bff343b1648b5cebc', '036168e918418eb807bc3efd361a8e66067192564da41e30e076d22be0f87935', 'a491df768673d76ae7dee4c9bf1ea1456e6c537a1f1683368d8bc6869cd89bf0', 'f6a8cfceb19b4cd796512223b8afd103c4aee7052247ebea8b50f743e9aa27b6', 'd135518ad4230c8f57a3510b3ddea8a99e2355363c9419a27340734427050729', 'cbe90e272b6be7696d3b8c171500847d2b0ae497f6911d0f9d5d8481101c4c1f', '249c961ea29438959ea2204728df24964ec80b8cd91c657715c47014f5e5a462', '1920ebb46d0cee2d379ef48c15f8f6abd01e2a183f316da235e0c3b7515feade', '6d1573b42d5f89f89b26b32cbbd32ff41660e0e8c3b3091f1cb278a42651e049', 'ec6878825845c61b3049ad5dd168197c84938e7f6d4fc938670da2528cf86317', '9829b13faebde69c2279c38cd54d524aa31acfdcc1cfba7910b9d69caa42e0dd', '2755ae7cda161df0c24e1fa9f1c3308bc9ef81a599d859668490484290ca72f4', '09d9dcfc1716808b0c62e47a771ff4d39ba71f22c8640776e65624747a995626', '71dfcd074b80de90c4955890bdbe127d12b249ed764c7c4ca23dc81c74fde71d', '3c1afbb156ee2d672ca131c7c966bc6875374a95d927848bafcc5a158edf67bb'] A a method of carrying the detnet sequence number. {79: 1, 130: 1, 54: 1, 52: 1, 98: 1, 6: 1, 8: 1, 64: 1, 99: 1, 24: 1, 90: 2, 51: 2, 62: 4, 85: 4, 68: 3, 35: 2, 110: 2, 91: 4, 114: 2, 97: 2, 31: 2, 13: 2, 67: 2, 38: 3, 26: 2, 124: 2, 127: 2, 96: 2, 30: 3, 61: 4, 55: 2, 27: 3, 15: 2, 129: 2, 115: 2, 84: 2, 76: 5, 87: 2, 131: 4, 102: 2, 113: 4, 36: 2, 72: 3} {4: 1, 24: 1, 59: 1, 111: 1, 136: 1, 156: 1, 206: 1, 215: 1, 220: 1, 221: 1, 235: 1, 241: 1, 242: 1, 314: 1, 329: 1, 334: 1, 354: 1, 366: 1, 376: 1, 1: 8, 9: 4, 10: 2, 15: 2, 25: 4, 26: 4, 27: 2, 39: 4, 43: 2, 49: 5, 50: 4, 58: 4, 64: 2, 69: 3, 81: 5, 82: 3, 86: 2, 96: 3, 97: 2, 100: 6, 108: 2, 109: 3, 110: 3, 114: 2, 115: 3, 116: 2, 118: 5, 119: 4, 120: 2, 121: 3, 122: 3, 123: 2, 124: 3, 128: 3, 129: 3, 130: 4, 132: 3, 145: 3, 147: 3, 151: 3, 152: 3, 154: 2, 161: 2, 162: 2, 165: 2, 168: 3, 169: 2, 172: 2, 180: 3, 184: 4, 187: 4, 188: 3, 191: 2, 194: 3, 202: 4, 203: 5, 207: 2, 217: 2, 218: 7, 222: 4, 224: 2, 227: 4, 229: 2, 234: 4, 243: 3, 244: 3, 245: 3, 248: 3, 250: 3, 258: 10, 262: 3, 263: 4, 264: 2, 267: 3, 270: 2, 272: 2, 273: 4, 287: 2, 289: 2, 291: 4, 299: 4, 300: 2, 304: 2, 309: 2, 315: 2, 320: 3, 323: 3, 327: 3, 328: 2, 330: 9, 335: 2, 341: 4, 342: 5, 347: 4, 348: 4, 350: 6, 351: 4, 352: 2, 353: 2, 358: 3, 365: 2, 371: 6, 372: 4, 384: 4, 385: 3, 386: 2, 387: 2, 392: 2, 393: 3, 396: 5, 397: 6, 398: 5, 402: 2} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 53 A suitable LSP to deliver the packet to the egress PE. "Major clean up and simplification as data plane drafts can be referred for MPLS related details . TSN over DetNet MPLS follows the concept of RFC3985 . Description focus on Edge Nodes procedures and functions . Text covers the Edge Nodes components : ( 1 ) TSN functions ( in NSP block ) ; ( 2 ) DetNet Service Proxy ; and ( 3 ) DetNet sub - layers . Approving from teelcon review" 3486514b01b74d57f031bcf660311de328a6e0dc 3486514b01b74d57f031bcf660311de328a6e0dc draft-ietf-detnet-tsn-vpn-over-mpls 2a5cef1e9c76b52b9b56c6c021a857b0fa757897b6e3c96cc8170d5b73ba8dd8 ['e82e49a3c764c0ede490d9e8afe0d0a379ec1e2fb734910d7e42f179709f894c', '1b5276bed81725e3cab5fa8d2491ae7fc344c8638906d8e62ee7c31696edcb52', 'a6a4ee1a9211a2be0e24cf91f9742499a46567acff4c78f62b568b34e38c08de', '44d22f065218a14d5aa04288e7553c8a6d81bb222066c74ea38571bbe922a729', 'c757c3611002031d5ce1ac79d9984d826f392e6628a0657e045c348e52b7eda2', '8a105d9f9ffbf3e747a101e48de19122931cd0cce896dc27f57d16df9dbb75ac', 'a8ff14472a8fa48bacdc11d7089a9d1054c0a786f6152f510b5d4092c22e121f', 'e746630d4b45cf2b654a14e4daaa03ad634e33d92c29c489e3ef3fcd5620c311', '16375944152e6c3e73492437880fe39d7f0123a9292d062e8e9c7d317e4b878f', '42f5214bb177fd7faf01b7943e7f313a615b2490f9109d5cefa8b24101735c32', '5cc97b8f56cdeeb02e7c96183745dc53dd8ec3ec02424107d16eb438c2c9363c', 'a816e4d1392c9c85d398ee2c5116b5de849a9823bc552d322ac8725f7c9b859e', 'c7286f8983508fdd7d94ae798cdc3950cbf65865e905c00a76838a34eb79cf2c', '6924f7b3002e9f0dff9023b70bcc9d484e643c3a2d95b0d5c853c084ad3f68ab', '2d8fce3963de03360a5d98758067925a60474b5430fd8091fc72f3c50a9d38e5', '77f9aaec42bbb94079fae33b8c564cd7f64721106f615e11f22673310efaf01b', '09f8dc962fd9202d148a0b378c9a078ea850056b4b5c360c0914d4a1de6af454', '4826376633600232b766cb8a62d4054b0f5ea45d74878bcf57356e567088300c', '82b410c949db1d81b3f197adbaaba7b82b6e497600cd9883150af2bb815caa19', '0eb73f51f3b491bd6d969a05acf2b527e6e2f09a460cb88266513ab952bd3fc6', '1076eab6753435c114e8a720c951b03da6d4e1bbbf1290f8d58ad7f97a0b8c64', '4ccf918f8b8ae99a769d89e0868a12e4af1536487652436b6c188bc99e14fdb6', '2a5cef1e9c76b52b9b56c6c021a857b0fa757897b6e3c96cc8170d5b73ba8dd8', '07267e696bfbb5af98da5a8efe2b8cf604bc9ab1ce95e4766f017473bfcd0de1', '82f56d4694c2ec964de0a4413954f87ca621628c63d7425944baeff9aa4b6dad', '01e1da53fe2751e7196114efc63dd70d9babc69b4b73c03d4b7528dcc10c05d3', 'fb8f3ca7fafc9c173404ce7f909038443a6078a0c278cb024639410e33f49f88', '44e497e2df0461bad9215c57918855022435eb6e28266916161de3f7902bb352', '84f5bc0e0be5d04b515e8e49efb393e4aec7189222b92c0555cc1be542e74549', '3195c90c03cf6a438b5684cc93128c53f794660a661e2aa85d043ca5ac7060b9', 'b5bacf05f766e143f6de9484b0b5a2d9655d62854368373bd77974b94cb722e6', '2442b9072d522cde54849b40cab26789e4af909f1dd81391cd8c87023515a21c', 'b03d79d1a547b36a28c6cba78f57b8244a4855f6b31003de3e617a5b5eddc070', 'e386562e3156c91934ceb045df46d7e847bb9afcad2794bda59be854f988befc', 'cc980749457292da3a6a4a3ce669ad487409ce72e20857e80c75741c83af7f0a', '75db9ae91b710fcf1df3553b8f9653b12d014f74ba1ee8f931870d2433e163f1', '0e313215df9694bc26777ba4ac347cb8ef73f8475d2bfed664aab722833589ae', '1094721b24c22ff67539ffeabab887f87e538bdd9ebe50b0b369de138d326802', 'fb2b9389e1455c6d64ae19158396d767d88969013b14075bcfdcc764f610108c', 'ae3bdd3a81d96e4aaa02f7d597a2684146f3af75b743bde8e31c3cf5883707db', '1b8137b4c60774716e4a492efec48060d48abd7308563d8cc76edf32d98bd759', '09732023af932d8c578c8a7ead49feb80cdb5c629cee6add2e24fcd7999c0309', '75b7020073ec0c8cedf517f1b56d554e2a5cfdf89d204633c30b863c42ed6f5f', '4be1dfb90ea542d5d84c23c0ba29b91db2491a39973839ee646eeec25c71adb4', 'c98d52f719106d13b14f27abde81ce00305cbf62889690b72da3e3ddc0286c02', '056859e4aa430e2eb983e93f08bb85d9afe9aec44f0e73263cf072df70b7c475', '870147c2dad0a0dda2dd0a9f85ef83b3c4de9a304fdff6d9fa9ccc4bde9d70c0', '26e942b0353fee8f5ac0a2c2e26c9b695c50b35c501eeb4bff343b1648b5cebc', '036168e918418eb807bc3efd361a8e66067192564da41e30e076d22be0f87935', 'a491df768673d76ae7dee4c9bf1ea1456e6c537a1f1683368d8bc6869cd89bf0', 'f6a8cfceb19b4cd796512223b8afd103c4aee7052247ebea8b50f743e9aa27b6', 'd135518ad4230c8f57a3510b3ddea8a99e2355363c9419a27340734427050729', 'cbe90e272b6be7696d3b8c171500847d2b0ae497f6911d0f9d5d8481101c4c1f', '249c961ea29438959ea2204728df24964ec80b8cd91c657715c47014f5e5a462', '1920ebb46d0cee2d379ef48c15f8f6abd01e2a183f316da235e0c3b7515feade', '6d1573b42d5f89f89b26b32cbbd32ff41660e0e8c3b3091f1cb278a42651e049', 'ec6878825845c61b3049ad5dd168197c84938e7f6d4fc938670da2528cf86317', '9829b13faebde69c2279c38cd54d524aa31acfdcc1cfba7910b9d69caa42e0dd', '2755ae7cda161df0c24e1fa9f1c3308bc9ef81a599d859668490484290ca72f4', '09d9dcfc1716808b0c62e47a771ff4d39ba71f22c8640776e65624747a995626', '71dfcd074b80de90c4955890bdbe127d12b249ed764c7c4ca23dc81c74fde71d', '3c1afbb156ee2d672ca131c7c966bc6875374a95d927848bafcc5a158edf67bb'] A a suitable lsp to deliver the packet to the egress pe. {79: 1, 130: 1, 54: 1, 52: 1, 98: 1, 6: 1, 8: 1, 64: 1, 99: 1, 24: 1, 90: 2, 51: 2, 62: 4, 85: 4, 68: 3, 35: 2, 110: 2, 91: 4, 114: 2, 97: 2, 31: 2, 13: 2, 67: 2, 38: 3, 26: 2, 124: 2, 127: 2, 96: 2, 30: 3, 61: 4, 55: 2, 27: 3, 15: 2, 129: 2, 115: 2, 84: 2, 76: 5, 87: 2, 131: 4, 102: 2, 113: 4, 36: 2, 72: 3} {4: 1, 24: 1, 59: 1, 111: 1, 136: 1, 156: 1, 206: 1, 215: 1, 220: 1, 221: 1, 235: 1, 241: 1, 242: 1, 314: 1, 329: 1, 334: 1, 354: 1, 366: 1, 376: 1, 1: 8, 9: 4, 10: 2, 15: 2, 25: 4, 26: 4, 27: 2, 39: 4, 43: 2, 49: 5, 50: 4, 58: 4, 64: 2, 69: 3, 81: 5, 82: 3, 86: 2, 96: 3, 97: 2, 100: 6, 108: 2, 109: 3, 110: 3, 114: 2, 115: 3, 116: 2, 118: 5, 119: 4, 120: 2, 121: 3, 122: 3, 123: 2, 124: 3, 128: 3, 129: 3, 130: 4, 132: 3, 145: 3, 147: 3, 151: 3, 152: 3, 154: 2, 161: 2, 162: 2, 165: 2, 168: 3, 169: 2, 172: 2, 180: 3, 184: 4, 187: 4, 188: 3, 191: 2, 194: 3, 202: 4, 203: 5, 207: 2, 217: 2, 218: 7, 222: 4, 224: 2, 227: 4, 229: 2, 234: 4, 243: 3, 244: 3, 245: 3, 248: 3, 250: 3, 258: 10, 262: 3, 263: 4, 264: 2, 267: 3, 270: 2, 272: 2, 273: 4, 287: 2, 289: 2, 291: 4, 299: 4, 300: 2, 304: 2, 309: 2, 315: 2, 320: 3, 323: 3, 327: 3, 328: 2, 330: 9, 335: 2, 341: 4, 342: 5, 347: 4, 348: 4, 350: 6, 351: 4, 352: 2, 353: 2, 358: 3, 365: 2, 371: 6, 372: 4, 384: 4, 385: 3, 386: 2, 387: 2, 392: 2, 393: 3, 396: 5, 397: 6, 398: 5, 402: 2} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 53 A method of carrying queuing and forwarding indication. "Major clean up and simplification as data plane drafts can be referred for MPLS related details . TSN over DetNet MPLS follows the concept of RFC3985 . Description focus on Edge Nodes procedures and functions . Text covers the Edge Nodes components : ( 1 ) TSN functions ( in NSP block ) ; ( 2 ) DetNet Service Proxy ; and ( 3 ) DetNet sub - layers . Approving from teelcon review" 3486514b01b74d57f031bcf660311de328a6e0dc 3486514b01b74d57f031bcf660311de328a6e0dc draft-ietf-detnet-tsn-vpn-over-mpls a6a4ee1a9211a2be0e24cf91f9742499a46567acff4c78f62b568b34e38c08de ['e82e49a3c764c0ede490d9e8afe0d0a379ec1e2fb734910d7e42f179709f894c', '1b5276bed81725e3cab5fa8d2491ae7fc344c8638906d8e62ee7c31696edcb52', 'a6a4ee1a9211a2be0e24cf91f9742499a46567acff4c78f62b568b34e38c08de', '44d22f065218a14d5aa04288e7553c8a6d81bb222066c74ea38571bbe922a729', 'c757c3611002031d5ce1ac79d9984d826f392e6628a0657e045c348e52b7eda2', '8a105d9f9ffbf3e747a101e48de19122931cd0cce896dc27f57d16df9dbb75ac', 'a8ff14472a8fa48bacdc11d7089a9d1054c0a786f6152f510b5d4092c22e121f', 'e746630d4b45cf2b654a14e4daaa03ad634e33d92c29c489e3ef3fcd5620c311', '16375944152e6c3e73492437880fe39d7f0123a9292d062e8e9c7d317e4b878f', '42f5214bb177fd7faf01b7943e7f313a615b2490f9109d5cefa8b24101735c32', '5cc97b8f56cdeeb02e7c96183745dc53dd8ec3ec02424107d16eb438c2c9363c', 'a816e4d1392c9c85d398ee2c5116b5de849a9823bc552d322ac8725f7c9b859e', 'c7286f8983508fdd7d94ae798cdc3950cbf65865e905c00a76838a34eb79cf2c', '6924f7b3002e9f0dff9023b70bcc9d484e643c3a2d95b0d5c853c084ad3f68ab', '2d8fce3963de03360a5d98758067925a60474b5430fd8091fc72f3c50a9d38e5', '77f9aaec42bbb94079fae33b8c564cd7f64721106f615e11f22673310efaf01b', '09f8dc962fd9202d148a0b378c9a078ea850056b4b5c360c0914d4a1de6af454', '4826376633600232b766cb8a62d4054b0f5ea45d74878bcf57356e567088300c', '82b410c949db1d81b3f197adbaaba7b82b6e497600cd9883150af2bb815caa19', '0eb73f51f3b491bd6d969a05acf2b527e6e2f09a460cb88266513ab952bd3fc6', '1076eab6753435c114e8a720c951b03da6d4e1bbbf1290f8d58ad7f97a0b8c64', '4ccf918f8b8ae99a769d89e0868a12e4af1536487652436b6c188bc99e14fdb6', '2a5cef1e9c76b52b9b56c6c021a857b0fa757897b6e3c96cc8170d5b73ba8dd8', '07267e696bfbb5af98da5a8efe2b8cf604bc9ab1ce95e4766f017473bfcd0de1', '82f56d4694c2ec964de0a4413954f87ca621628c63d7425944baeff9aa4b6dad', '01e1da53fe2751e7196114efc63dd70d9babc69b4b73c03d4b7528dcc10c05d3', 'fb8f3ca7fafc9c173404ce7f909038443a6078a0c278cb024639410e33f49f88', '44e497e2df0461bad9215c57918855022435eb6e28266916161de3f7902bb352', '84f5bc0e0be5d04b515e8e49efb393e4aec7189222b92c0555cc1be542e74549', '3195c90c03cf6a438b5684cc93128c53f794660a661e2aa85d043ca5ac7060b9', 'b5bacf05f766e143f6de9484b0b5a2d9655d62854368373bd77974b94cb722e6', '2442b9072d522cde54849b40cab26789e4af909f1dd81391cd8c87023515a21c', 'b03d79d1a547b36a28c6cba78f57b8244a4855f6b31003de3e617a5b5eddc070', 'e386562e3156c91934ceb045df46d7e847bb9afcad2794bda59be854f988befc', 'cc980749457292da3a6a4a3ce669ad487409ce72e20857e80c75741c83af7f0a', '75db9ae91b710fcf1df3553b8f9653b12d014f74ba1ee8f931870d2433e163f1', '0e313215df9694bc26777ba4ac347cb8ef73f8475d2bfed664aab722833589ae', '1094721b24c22ff67539ffeabab887f87e538bdd9ebe50b0b369de138d326802', 'fb2b9389e1455c6d64ae19158396d767d88969013b14075bcfdcc764f610108c', 'ae3bdd3a81d96e4aaa02f7d597a2684146f3af75b743bde8e31c3cf5883707db', '1b8137b4c60774716e4a492efec48060d48abd7308563d8cc76edf32d98bd759', '09732023af932d8c578c8a7ead49feb80cdb5c629cee6add2e24fcd7999c0309', '75b7020073ec0c8cedf517f1b56d554e2a5cfdf89d204633c30b863c42ed6f5f', '4be1dfb90ea542d5d84c23c0ba29b91db2491a39973839ee646eeec25c71adb4', 'c98d52f719106d13b14f27abde81ce00305cbf62889690b72da3e3ddc0286c02', '056859e4aa430e2eb983e93f08bb85d9afe9aec44f0e73263cf072df70b7c475', '870147c2dad0a0dda2dd0a9f85ef83b3c4de9a304fdff6d9fa9ccc4bde9d70c0', '26e942b0353fee8f5ac0a2c2e26c9b695c50b35c501eeb4bff343b1648b5cebc', '036168e918418eb807bc3efd361a8e66067192564da41e30e076d22be0f87935', 'a491df768673d76ae7dee4c9bf1ea1456e6c537a1f1683368d8bc6869cd89bf0', 'f6a8cfceb19b4cd796512223b8afd103c4aee7052247ebea8b50f743e9aa27b6', 'd135518ad4230c8f57a3510b3ddea8a99e2355363c9419a27340734427050729', 'cbe90e272b6be7696d3b8c171500847d2b0ae497f6911d0f9d5d8481101c4c1f', '249c961ea29438959ea2204728df24964ec80b8cd91c657715c47014f5e5a462', '1920ebb46d0cee2d379ef48c15f8f6abd01e2a183f316da235e0c3b7515feade', '6d1573b42d5f89f89b26b32cbbd32ff41660e0e8c3b3091f1cb278a42651e049', 'ec6878825845c61b3049ad5dd168197c84938e7f6d4fc938670da2528cf86317', '9829b13faebde69c2279c38cd54d524aa31acfdcc1cfba7910b9d69caa42e0dd', '2755ae7cda161df0c24e1fa9f1c3308bc9ef81a599d859668490484290ca72f4', '09d9dcfc1716808b0c62e47a771ff4d39ba71f22c8640776e65624747a995626', '71dfcd074b80de90c4955890bdbe127d12b249ed764c7c4ca23dc81c74fde71d', '3c1afbb156ee2d672ca131c7c966bc6875374a95d927848bafcc5a158edf67bb'] A a method of carrying queuing and forwarding indication. {79: 1, 130: 1, 54: 1, 52: 1, 98: 1, 6: 1, 8: 1, 64: 1, 99: 1, 24: 1, 90: 2, 51: 2, 62: 4, 85: 4, 68: 3, 35: 2, 110: 2, 91: 4, 114: 2, 97: 2, 31: 2, 13: 2, 67: 2, 38: 3, 26: 2, 124: 2, 127: 2, 96: 2, 30: 3, 61: 4, 55: 2, 27: 3, 15: 2, 129: 2, 115: 2, 84: 2, 76: 5, 87: 2, 131: 4, 102: 2, 113: 4, 36: 2, 72: 3} {4: 1, 24: 1, 59: 1, 111: 1, 136: 1, 156: 1, 206: 1, 215: 1, 220: 1, 221: 1, 235: 1, 241: 1, 242: 1, 314: 1, 329: 1, 334: 1, 354: 1, 366: 1, 376: 1, 1: 8, 9: 4, 10: 2, 15: 2, 25: 4, 26: 4, 27: 2, 39: 4, 43: 2, 49: 5, 50: 4, 58: 4, 64: 2, 69: 3, 81: 5, 82: 3, 86: 2, 96: 3, 97: 2, 100: 6, 108: 2, 109: 3, 110: 3, 114: 2, 115: 3, 116: 2, 118: 5, 119: 4, 120: 2, 121: 3, 122: 3, 123: 2, 124: 3, 128: 3, 129: 3, 130: 4, 132: 3, 145: 3, 147: 3, 151: 3, 152: 3, 154: 2, 161: 2, 162: 2, 165: 2, 168: 3, 169: 2, 172: 2, 180: 3, 184: 4, 187: 4, 188: 3, 191: 2, 194: 3, 202: 4, 203: 5, 207: 2, 217: 2, 218: 7, 222: 4, 224: 2, 227: 4, 229: 2, 234: 4, 243: 3, 244: 3, 245: 3, 248: 3, 250: 3, 258: 10, 262: 3, 263: 4, 264: 2, 267: 3, 270: 2, 272: 2, 273: 4, 287: 2, 289: 2, 291: 4, 299: 4, 300: 2, 304: 2, 309: 2, 315: 2, 320: 3, 323: 3, 327: 3, 328: 2, 330: 9, 335: 2, 341: 4, 342: 5, 347: 4, 348: 4, 350: 6, 351: 4, 352: 2, 353: 2, 358: 3, 365: 2, 371: 6, 372: 4, 384: 4, 385: 3, 386: 2, 387: 2, 392: 2, 393: 3, 396: 5, 397: 6, 398: 5, 402: 2} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 53 "In this design an MPLS service label (the S-Label), similar to a pseudowire (PW) label RFC3985, is used to identify both the DetNet flow identity and the payload MPLS payload type satisfying (1) and (2) in the list above. OAM traffic discrimination happens through the use of the Associated Channel method described in RFC4385. The DetNet sequence number is carried in the DetNet Control word which carries the Data/OAM discriminator. To simplify implementation and to maximize interoperability two sequence number sizes are supported: a 16 bit sequence number and a 28 bit sequence number. The 16 bit sequence number is needed to support some types of legacy clients. The 28 bit sequence number is used in situations where it is necessary ensure that in high speed networks the sequence number space does not wrap whilst packets are in flight." "Major clean up and simplification as data plane drafts can be referred for MPLS related details . TSN over DetNet MPLS follows the concept of RFC3985 . Description focus on Edge Nodes procedures and functions . Text covers the Edge Nodes components : ( 1 ) TSN functions ( in NSP block ) ; ( 2 ) DetNet Service Proxy ; and ( 3 ) DetNet sub - layers . Approving from teelcon review" 3486514b01b74d57f031bcf660311de328a6e0dc 3486514b01b74d57f031bcf660311de328a6e0dc draft-ietf-detnet-tsn-vpn-over-mpls 6924f7b3002e9f0dff9023b70bcc9d484e643c3a2d95b0d5c853c084ad3f68ab ['e82e49a3c764c0ede490d9e8afe0d0a379ec1e2fb734910d7e42f179709f894c', '1b5276bed81725e3cab5fa8d2491ae7fc344c8638906d8e62ee7c31696edcb52', 'a6a4ee1a9211a2be0e24cf91f9742499a46567acff4c78f62b568b34e38c08de', '44d22f065218a14d5aa04288e7553c8a6d81bb222066c74ea38571bbe922a729', 'c757c3611002031d5ce1ac79d9984d826f392e6628a0657e045c348e52b7eda2', '8a105d9f9ffbf3e747a101e48de19122931cd0cce896dc27f57d16df9dbb75ac', 'a8ff14472a8fa48bacdc11d7089a9d1054c0a786f6152f510b5d4092c22e121f', 'e746630d4b45cf2b654a14e4daaa03ad634e33d92c29c489e3ef3fcd5620c311', '16375944152e6c3e73492437880fe39d7f0123a9292d062e8e9c7d317e4b878f', '42f5214bb177fd7faf01b7943e7f313a615b2490f9109d5cefa8b24101735c32', '5cc97b8f56cdeeb02e7c96183745dc53dd8ec3ec02424107d16eb438c2c9363c', 'a816e4d1392c9c85d398ee2c5116b5de849a9823bc552d322ac8725f7c9b859e', 'c7286f8983508fdd7d94ae798cdc3950cbf65865e905c00a76838a34eb79cf2c', '6924f7b3002e9f0dff9023b70bcc9d484e643c3a2d95b0d5c853c084ad3f68ab', '2d8fce3963de03360a5d98758067925a60474b5430fd8091fc72f3c50a9d38e5', '77f9aaec42bbb94079fae33b8c564cd7f64721106f615e11f22673310efaf01b', '09f8dc962fd9202d148a0b378c9a078ea850056b4b5c360c0914d4a1de6af454', '4826376633600232b766cb8a62d4054b0f5ea45d74878bcf57356e567088300c', '82b410c949db1d81b3f197adbaaba7b82b6e497600cd9883150af2bb815caa19', '0eb73f51f3b491bd6d969a05acf2b527e6e2f09a460cb88266513ab952bd3fc6', '1076eab6753435c114e8a720c951b03da6d4e1bbbf1290f8d58ad7f97a0b8c64', '4ccf918f8b8ae99a769d89e0868a12e4af1536487652436b6c188bc99e14fdb6', '2a5cef1e9c76b52b9b56c6c021a857b0fa757897b6e3c96cc8170d5b73ba8dd8', '07267e696bfbb5af98da5a8efe2b8cf604bc9ab1ce95e4766f017473bfcd0de1', '82f56d4694c2ec964de0a4413954f87ca621628c63d7425944baeff9aa4b6dad', '01e1da53fe2751e7196114efc63dd70d9babc69b4b73c03d4b7528dcc10c05d3', 'fb8f3ca7fafc9c173404ce7f909038443a6078a0c278cb024639410e33f49f88', '44e497e2df0461bad9215c57918855022435eb6e28266916161de3f7902bb352', '84f5bc0e0be5d04b515e8e49efb393e4aec7189222b92c0555cc1be542e74549', '3195c90c03cf6a438b5684cc93128c53f794660a661e2aa85d043ca5ac7060b9', 'b5bacf05f766e143f6de9484b0b5a2d9655d62854368373bd77974b94cb722e6', '2442b9072d522cde54849b40cab26789e4af909f1dd81391cd8c87023515a21c', 'b03d79d1a547b36a28c6cba78f57b8244a4855f6b31003de3e617a5b5eddc070', 'e386562e3156c91934ceb045df46d7e847bb9afcad2794bda59be854f988befc', 'cc980749457292da3a6a4a3ce669ad487409ce72e20857e80c75741c83af7f0a', '75db9ae91b710fcf1df3553b8f9653b12d014f74ba1ee8f931870d2433e163f1', '0e313215df9694bc26777ba4ac347cb8ef73f8475d2bfed664aab722833589ae', '1094721b24c22ff67539ffeabab887f87e538bdd9ebe50b0b369de138d326802', 'fb2b9389e1455c6d64ae19158396d767d88969013b14075bcfdcc764f610108c', 'ae3bdd3a81d96e4aaa02f7d597a2684146f3af75b743bde8e31c3cf5883707db', '1b8137b4c60774716e4a492efec48060d48abd7308563d8cc76edf32d98bd759', '09732023af932d8c578c8a7ead49feb80cdb5c629cee6add2e24fcd7999c0309', '75b7020073ec0c8cedf517f1b56d554e2a5cfdf89d204633c30b863c42ed6f5f', '4be1dfb90ea542d5d84c23c0ba29b91db2491a39973839ee646eeec25c71adb4', 'c98d52f719106d13b14f27abde81ce00305cbf62889690b72da3e3ddc0286c02', '056859e4aa430e2eb983e93f08bb85d9afe9aec44f0e73263cf072df70b7c475', '870147c2dad0a0dda2dd0a9f85ef83b3c4de9a304fdff6d9fa9ccc4bde9d70c0', '26e942b0353fee8f5ac0a2c2e26c9b695c50b35c501eeb4bff343b1648b5cebc', '036168e918418eb807bc3efd361a8e66067192564da41e30e076d22be0f87935', 'a491df768673d76ae7dee4c9bf1ea1456e6c537a1f1683368d8bc6869cd89bf0', 'f6a8cfceb19b4cd796512223b8afd103c4aee7052247ebea8b50f743e9aa27b6', 'd135518ad4230c8f57a3510b3ddea8a99e2355363c9419a27340734427050729', 'cbe90e272b6be7696d3b8c171500847d2b0ae497f6911d0f9d5d8481101c4c1f', '249c961ea29438959ea2204728df24964ec80b8cd91c657715c47014f5e5a462', '1920ebb46d0cee2d379ef48c15f8f6abd01e2a183f316da235e0c3b7515feade', '6d1573b42d5f89f89b26b32cbbd32ff41660e0e8c3b3091f1cb278a42651e049', 'ec6878825845c61b3049ad5dd168197c84938e7f6d4fc938670da2528cf86317', '9829b13faebde69c2279c38cd54d524aa31acfdcc1cfba7910b9d69caa42e0dd', '2755ae7cda161df0c24e1fa9f1c3308bc9ef81a599d859668490484290ca72f4', '09d9dcfc1716808b0c62e47a771ff4d39ba71f22c8640776e65624747a995626', '71dfcd074b80de90c4955890bdbe127d12b249ed764c7c4ca23dc81c74fde71d', '3c1afbb156ee2d672ca131c7c966bc6875374a95d927848bafcc5a158edf67bb'] A "in this design an mpls service label (the s-label), similar to a pseudowire (pw) label rfc3985, is used to identify both the detnet flow identity and the payload mpls payload type satisfying (1) and (2) in the list above. oam traffic discrimination happens through the use of the associated channel method described in rfc4385. the detnet sequence number is carried in the detnet control word which carries the data/oam discriminator. to simplify implementation and to maximize interoperability two sequence number sizes are supported: a 16 bit sequence number and a 28 bit sequence number. the 16 bit sequence number is needed to support some types of legacy clients. the 28 bit sequence number is used in situations where it is necessary ensure that in high speed networks the sequence number space does not wrap whilst packets are in flight." {79: 1, 130: 1, 54: 1, 52: 1, 98: 1, 6: 1, 8: 1, 64: 1, 99: 1, 24: 1, 90: 2, 51: 2, 62: 4, 85: 4, 68: 3, 35: 2, 110: 2, 91: 4, 114: 2, 97: 2, 31: 2, 13: 2, 67: 2, 38: 3, 26: 2, 124: 2, 127: 2, 96: 2, 30: 3, 61: 4, 55: 2, 27: 3, 15: 2, 129: 2, 115: 2, 84: 2, 76: 5, 87: 2, 131: 4, 102: 2, 113: 4, 36: 2, 72: 3} {4: 1, 24: 1, 59: 1, 111: 1, 136: 1, 156: 1, 206: 1, 215: 1, 220: 1, 221: 1, 235: 1, 241: 1, 242: 1, 314: 1, 329: 1, 334: 1, 354: 1, 366: 1, 376: 1, 1: 8, 9: 4, 10: 2, 15: 2, 25: 4, 26: 4, 27: 2, 39: 4, 43: 2, 49: 5, 50: 4, 58: 4, 64: 2, 69: 3, 81: 5, 82: 3, 86: 2, 96: 3, 97: 2, 100: 6, 108: 2, 109: 3, 110: 3, 114: 2, 115: 3, 116: 2, 118: 5, 119: 4, 120: 2, 121: 3, 122: 3, 123: 2, 124: 3, 128: 3, 129: 3, 130: 4, 132: 3, 145: 3, 147: 3, 151: 3, 152: 3, 154: 2, 161: 2, 162: 2, 165: 2, 168: 3, 169: 2, 172: 2, 180: 3, 184: 4, 187: 4, 188: 3, 191: 2, 194: 3, 202: 4, 203: 5, 207: 2, 217: 2, 218: 7, 222: 4, 224: 2, 227: 4, 229: 2, 234: 4, 243: 3, 244: 3, 245: 3, 248: 3, 250: 3, 258: 10, 262: 3, 263: 4, 264: 2, 267: 3, 270: 2, 272: 2, 273: 4, 287: 2, 289: 2, 291: 4, 299: 4, 300: 2, 304: 2, 309: 2, 315: 2, 320: 3, 323: 3, 327: 3, 328: 2, 330: 9, 335: 2, 341: 4, 342: 5, 347: 4, 348: 4, 350: 6, 351: 4, 352: 2, 353: 2, 358: 3, 365: 2, 371: 6, 372: 4, 384: 4, 385: 3, 386: 2, 387: 2, 392: 2, 393: 3, 396: 5, 397: 6, 398: 5, 402: 2} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 53 "The LSP used to forward the DetNet packet may be of any type (MPLS- LDP, MPLS-TE, MPLS-TP RFC5921, or MPLS-SR I-D.ietf-spring-segment- routing-mpls). The LSP (F-Label) label and/or the S-Label may be used to indicate the queue processing as well as the forwarding parameters. Note that the possible use of Penultimate Hop Popping (PHP) means that the only label in a received label stack may be the S-Label." "Major clean up and simplification as data plane drafts can be referred for MPLS related details . TSN over DetNet MPLS follows the concept of RFC3985 . Description focus on Edge Nodes procedures and functions . Text covers the Edge Nodes components : ( 1 ) TSN functions ( in NSP block ) ; ( 2 ) DetNet Service Proxy ; and ( 3 ) DetNet sub - layers . Approving from teelcon review" 3486514b01b74d57f031bcf660311de328a6e0dc 3486514b01b74d57f031bcf660311de328a6e0dc draft-ietf-detnet-tsn-vpn-over-mpls 75b7020073ec0c8cedf517f1b56d554e2a5cfdf89d204633c30b863c42ed6f5f ['e82e49a3c764c0ede490d9e8afe0d0a379ec1e2fb734910d7e42f179709f894c', '1b5276bed81725e3cab5fa8d2491ae7fc344c8638906d8e62ee7c31696edcb52', 'a6a4ee1a9211a2be0e24cf91f9742499a46567acff4c78f62b568b34e38c08de', '44d22f065218a14d5aa04288e7553c8a6d81bb222066c74ea38571bbe922a729', 'c757c3611002031d5ce1ac79d9984d826f392e6628a0657e045c348e52b7eda2', '8a105d9f9ffbf3e747a101e48de19122931cd0cce896dc27f57d16df9dbb75ac', 'a8ff14472a8fa48bacdc11d7089a9d1054c0a786f6152f510b5d4092c22e121f', 'e746630d4b45cf2b654a14e4daaa03ad634e33d92c29c489e3ef3fcd5620c311', '16375944152e6c3e73492437880fe39d7f0123a9292d062e8e9c7d317e4b878f', '42f5214bb177fd7faf01b7943e7f313a615b2490f9109d5cefa8b24101735c32', '5cc97b8f56cdeeb02e7c96183745dc53dd8ec3ec02424107d16eb438c2c9363c', 'a816e4d1392c9c85d398ee2c5116b5de849a9823bc552d322ac8725f7c9b859e', 'c7286f8983508fdd7d94ae798cdc3950cbf65865e905c00a76838a34eb79cf2c', '6924f7b3002e9f0dff9023b70bcc9d484e643c3a2d95b0d5c853c084ad3f68ab', '2d8fce3963de03360a5d98758067925a60474b5430fd8091fc72f3c50a9d38e5', '77f9aaec42bbb94079fae33b8c564cd7f64721106f615e11f22673310efaf01b', '09f8dc962fd9202d148a0b378c9a078ea850056b4b5c360c0914d4a1de6af454', '4826376633600232b766cb8a62d4054b0f5ea45d74878bcf57356e567088300c', '82b410c949db1d81b3f197adbaaba7b82b6e497600cd9883150af2bb815caa19', '0eb73f51f3b491bd6d969a05acf2b527e6e2f09a460cb88266513ab952bd3fc6', '1076eab6753435c114e8a720c951b03da6d4e1bbbf1290f8d58ad7f97a0b8c64', '4ccf918f8b8ae99a769d89e0868a12e4af1536487652436b6c188bc99e14fdb6', '2a5cef1e9c76b52b9b56c6c021a857b0fa757897b6e3c96cc8170d5b73ba8dd8', '07267e696bfbb5af98da5a8efe2b8cf604bc9ab1ce95e4766f017473bfcd0de1', '82f56d4694c2ec964de0a4413954f87ca621628c63d7425944baeff9aa4b6dad', '01e1da53fe2751e7196114efc63dd70d9babc69b4b73c03d4b7528dcc10c05d3', 'fb8f3ca7fafc9c173404ce7f909038443a6078a0c278cb024639410e33f49f88', '44e497e2df0461bad9215c57918855022435eb6e28266916161de3f7902bb352', '84f5bc0e0be5d04b515e8e49efb393e4aec7189222b92c0555cc1be542e74549', '3195c90c03cf6a438b5684cc93128c53f794660a661e2aa85d043ca5ac7060b9', 'b5bacf05f766e143f6de9484b0b5a2d9655d62854368373bd77974b94cb722e6', '2442b9072d522cde54849b40cab26789e4af909f1dd81391cd8c87023515a21c', 'b03d79d1a547b36a28c6cba78f57b8244a4855f6b31003de3e617a5b5eddc070', 'e386562e3156c91934ceb045df46d7e847bb9afcad2794bda59be854f988befc', 'cc980749457292da3a6a4a3ce669ad487409ce72e20857e80c75741c83af7f0a', '75db9ae91b710fcf1df3553b8f9653b12d014f74ba1ee8f931870d2433e163f1', '0e313215df9694bc26777ba4ac347cb8ef73f8475d2bfed664aab722833589ae', '1094721b24c22ff67539ffeabab887f87e538bdd9ebe50b0b369de138d326802', 'fb2b9389e1455c6d64ae19158396d767d88969013b14075bcfdcc764f610108c', 'ae3bdd3a81d96e4aaa02f7d597a2684146f3af75b743bde8e31c3cf5883707db', '1b8137b4c60774716e4a492efec48060d48abd7308563d8cc76edf32d98bd759', '09732023af932d8c578c8a7ead49feb80cdb5c629cee6add2e24fcd7999c0309', '75b7020073ec0c8cedf517f1b56d554e2a5cfdf89d204633c30b863c42ed6f5f', '4be1dfb90ea542d5d84c23c0ba29b91db2491a39973839ee646eeec25c71adb4', 'c98d52f719106d13b14f27abde81ce00305cbf62889690b72da3e3ddc0286c02', '056859e4aa430e2eb983e93f08bb85d9afe9aec44f0e73263cf072df70b7c475', '870147c2dad0a0dda2dd0a9f85ef83b3c4de9a304fdff6d9fa9ccc4bde9d70c0', '26e942b0353fee8f5ac0a2c2e26c9b695c50b35c501eeb4bff343b1648b5cebc', '036168e918418eb807bc3efd361a8e66067192564da41e30e076d22be0f87935', 'a491df768673d76ae7dee4c9bf1ea1456e6c537a1f1683368d8bc6869cd89bf0', 'f6a8cfceb19b4cd796512223b8afd103c4aee7052247ebea8b50f743e9aa27b6', 'd135518ad4230c8f57a3510b3ddea8a99e2355363c9419a27340734427050729', 'cbe90e272b6be7696d3b8c171500847d2b0ae497f6911d0f9d5d8481101c4c1f', '249c961ea29438959ea2204728df24964ec80b8cd91c657715c47014f5e5a462', '1920ebb46d0cee2d379ef48c15f8f6abd01e2a183f316da235e0c3b7515feade', '6d1573b42d5f89f89b26b32cbbd32ff41660e0e8c3b3091f1cb278a42651e049', 'ec6878825845c61b3049ad5dd168197c84938e7f6d4fc938670da2528cf86317', '9829b13faebde69c2279c38cd54d524aa31acfdcc1cfba7910b9d69caa42e0dd', '2755ae7cda161df0c24e1fa9f1c3308bc9ef81a599d859668490484290ca72f4', '09d9dcfc1716808b0c62e47a771ff4d39ba71f22c8640776e65624747a995626', '71dfcd074b80de90c4955890bdbe127d12b249ed764c7c4ca23dc81c74fde71d', '3c1afbb156ee2d672ca131c7c966bc6875374a95d927848bafcc5a158edf67bb'] A "the lsp used to forward the detnet packet may be of any type (mpls- ldp, mpls-te, mpls-tp rfc5921, or mpls-sr i-d.ietf-spring-segment- routing-mpls). the lsp (f-label) label and/or the s-label may be used to indicate the queue processing as well as the forwarding parameters. note that the possible use of penultimate hop popping (php) means that the only label in a received label stack may be the s-label." {79: 1, 130: 1, 54: 1, 52: 1, 98: 1, 6: 1, 8: 1, 64: 1, 99: 1, 24: 1, 90: 2, 51: 2, 62: 4, 85: 4, 68: 3, 35: 2, 110: 2, 91: 4, 114: 2, 97: 2, 31: 2, 13: 2, 67: 2, 38: 3, 26: 2, 124: 2, 127: 2, 96: 2, 30: 3, 61: 4, 55: 2, 27: 3, 15: 2, 129: 2, 115: 2, 84: 2, 76: 5, 87: 2, 131: 4, 102: 2, 113: 4, 36: 2, 72: 3} {4: 1, 24: 1, 59: 1, 111: 1, 136: 1, 156: 1, 206: 1, 215: 1, 220: 1, 221: 1, 235: 1, 241: 1, 242: 1, 314: 1, 329: 1, 334: 1, 354: 1, 366: 1, 376: 1, 1: 8, 9: 4, 10: 2, 15: 2, 25: 4, 26: 4, 27: 2, 39: 4, 43: 2, 49: 5, 50: 4, 58: 4, 64: 2, 69: 3, 81: 5, 82: 3, 86: 2, 96: 3, 97: 2, 100: 6, 108: 2, 109: 3, 110: 3, 114: 2, 115: 3, 116: 2, 118: 5, 119: 4, 120: 2, 121: 3, 122: 3, 123: 2, 124: 3, 128: 3, 129: 3, 130: 4, 132: 3, 145: 3, 147: 3, 151: 3, 152: 3, 154: 2, 161: 2, 162: 2, 165: 2, 168: 3, 169: 2, 172: 2, 180: 3, 184: 4, 187: 4, 188: 3, 191: 2, 194: 3, 202: 4, 203: 5, 207: 2, 217: 2, 218: 7, 222: 4, 224: 2, 227: 4, 229: 2, 234: 4, 243: 3, 244: 3, 245: 3, 248: 3, 250: 3, 258: 10, 262: 3, 263: 4, 264: 2, 267: 3, 270: 2, 272: 2, 273: 4, 287: 2, 289: 2, 291: 4, 299: 4, 300: 2, 304: 2, 309: 2, 315: 2, 320: 3, 323: 3, 327: 3, 328: 2, 330: 9, 335: 2, 341: 4, 342: 5, 347: 4, 348: 4, 350: 6, 351: 4, 352: 2, 353: 2, 358: 3, 365: 2, 371: 6, 372: 4, 384: 4, 385: 3, 386: 2, 387: 2, 392: 2, 393: 3, 396: 5, 397: 6, 398: 5, 402: 2} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 53 "An edge node is resposable for matching ingress packets to the service they require and encapsulating them accordingly.An edge node may participate in the packet replication and duplication elimination." "Major clean up and simplification as data plane drafts can be referred for MPLS related details . TSN over DetNet MPLS follows the concept of RFC3985 . Description focus on Edge Nodes procedures and functions . Text covers the Edge Nodes components : ( 1 ) TSN functions ( in NSP block ) ; ( 2 ) DetNet Service Proxy ; and ( 3 ) DetNet sub - layers . Approving from teelcon review" 3486514b01b74d57f031bcf660311de328a6e0dc 3486514b01b74d57f031bcf660311de328a6e0dc draft-ietf-detnet-tsn-vpn-over-mpls fb8f3ca7fafc9c173404ce7f909038443a6078a0c278cb024639410e33f49f88 ['e82e49a3c764c0ede490d9e8afe0d0a379ec1e2fb734910d7e42f179709f894c', '1b5276bed81725e3cab5fa8d2491ae7fc344c8638906d8e62ee7c31696edcb52', 'a6a4ee1a9211a2be0e24cf91f9742499a46567acff4c78f62b568b34e38c08de', '44d22f065218a14d5aa04288e7553c8a6d81bb222066c74ea38571bbe922a729', 'c757c3611002031d5ce1ac79d9984d826f392e6628a0657e045c348e52b7eda2', '8a105d9f9ffbf3e747a101e48de19122931cd0cce896dc27f57d16df9dbb75ac', 'a8ff14472a8fa48bacdc11d7089a9d1054c0a786f6152f510b5d4092c22e121f', 'e746630d4b45cf2b654a14e4daaa03ad634e33d92c29c489e3ef3fcd5620c311', '16375944152e6c3e73492437880fe39d7f0123a9292d062e8e9c7d317e4b878f', '42f5214bb177fd7faf01b7943e7f313a615b2490f9109d5cefa8b24101735c32', '5cc97b8f56cdeeb02e7c96183745dc53dd8ec3ec02424107d16eb438c2c9363c', 'a816e4d1392c9c85d398ee2c5116b5de849a9823bc552d322ac8725f7c9b859e', 'c7286f8983508fdd7d94ae798cdc3950cbf65865e905c00a76838a34eb79cf2c', '6924f7b3002e9f0dff9023b70bcc9d484e643c3a2d95b0d5c853c084ad3f68ab', '2d8fce3963de03360a5d98758067925a60474b5430fd8091fc72f3c50a9d38e5', '77f9aaec42bbb94079fae33b8c564cd7f64721106f615e11f22673310efaf01b', '09f8dc962fd9202d148a0b378c9a078ea850056b4b5c360c0914d4a1de6af454', '4826376633600232b766cb8a62d4054b0f5ea45d74878bcf57356e567088300c', '82b410c949db1d81b3f197adbaaba7b82b6e497600cd9883150af2bb815caa19', '0eb73f51f3b491bd6d969a05acf2b527e6e2f09a460cb88266513ab952bd3fc6', '1076eab6753435c114e8a720c951b03da6d4e1bbbf1290f8d58ad7f97a0b8c64', '4ccf918f8b8ae99a769d89e0868a12e4af1536487652436b6c188bc99e14fdb6', '2a5cef1e9c76b52b9b56c6c021a857b0fa757897b6e3c96cc8170d5b73ba8dd8', '07267e696bfbb5af98da5a8efe2b8cf604bc9ab1ce95e4766f017473bfcd0de1', '82f56d4694c2ec964de0a4413954f87ca621628c63d7425944baeff9aa4b6dad', '01e1da53fe2751e7196114efc63dd70d9babc69b4b73c03d4b7528dcc10c05d3', 'fb8f3ca7fafc9c173404ce7f909038443a6078a0c278cb024639410e33f49f88', '44e497e2df0461bad9215c57918855022435eb6e28266916161de3f7902bb352', '84f5bc0e0be5d04b515e8e49efb393e4aec7189222b92c0555cc1be542e74549', '3195c90c03cf6a438b5684cc93128c53f794660a661e2aa85d043ca5ac7060b9', 'b5bacf05f766e143f6de9484b0b5a2d9655d62854368373bd77974b94cb722e6', '2442b9072d522cde54849b40cab26789e4af909f1dd81391cd8c87023515a21c', 'b03d79d1a547b36a28c6cba78f57b8244a4855f6b31003de3e617a5b5eddc070', 'e386562e3156c91934ceb045df46d7e847bb9afcad2794bda59be854f988befc', 'cc980749457292da3a6a4a3ce669ad487409ce72e20857e80c75741c83af7f0a', '75db9ae91b710fcf1df3553b8f9653b12d014f74ba1ee8f931870d2433e163f1', '0e313215df9694bc26777ba4ac347cb8ef73f8475d2bfed664aab722833589ae', '1094721b24c22ff67539ffeabab887f87e538bdd9ebe50b0b369de138d326802', 'fb2b9389e1455c6d64ae19158396d767d88969013b14075bcfdcc764f610108c', 'ae3bdd3a81d96e4aaa02f7d597a2684146f3af75b743bde8e31c3cf5883707db', '1b8137b4c60774716e4a492efec48060d48abd7308563d8cc76edf32d98bd759', '09732023af932d8c578c8a7ead49feb80cdb5c629cee6add2e24fcd7999c0309', '75b7020073ec0c8cedf517f1b56d554e2a5cfdf89d204633c30b863c42ed6f5f', '4be1dfb90ea542d5d84c23c0ba29b91db2491a39973839ee646eeec25c71adb4', 'c98d52f719106d13b14f27abde81ce00305cbf62889690b72da3e3ddc0286c02', '056859e4aa430e2eb983e93f08bb85d9afe9aec44f0e73263cf072df70b7c475', '870147c2dad0a0dda2dd0a9f85ef83b3c4de9a304fdff6d9fa9ccc4bde9d70c0', '26e942b0353fee8f5ac0a2c2e26c9b695c50b35c501eeb4bff343b1648b5cebc', '036168e918418eb807bc3efd361a8e66067192564da41e30e076d22be0f87935', 'a491df768673d76ae7dee4c9bf1ea1456e6c537a1f1683368d8bc6869cd89bf0', 'f6a8cfceb19b4cd796512223b8afd103c4aee7052247ebea8b50f743e9aa27b6', 'd135518ad4230c8f57a3510b3ddea8a99e2355363c9419a27340734427050729', 'cbe90e272b6be7696d3b8c171500847d2b0ae497f6911d0f9d5d8481101c4c1f', '249c961ea29438959ea2204728df24964ec80b8cd91c657715c47014f5e5a462', '1920ebb46d0cee2d379ef48c15f8f6abd01e2a183f316da235e0c3b7515feade', '6d1573b42d5f89f89b26b32cbbd32ff41660e0e8c3b3091f1cb278a42651e049', 'ec6878825845c61b3049ad5dd168197c84938e7f6d4fc938670da2528cf86317', '9829b13faebde69c2279c38cd54d524aa31acfdcc1cfba7910b9d69caa42e0dd', '2755ae7cda161df0c24e1fa9f1c3308bc9ef81a599d859668490484290ca72f4', '09d9dcfc1716808b0c62e47a771ff4d39ba71f22c8640776e65624747a995626', '71dfcd074b80de90c4955890bdbe127d12b249ed764c7c4ca23dc81c74fde71d', '3c1afbb156ee2d672ca131c7c966bc6875374a95d927848bafcc5a158edf67bb'] A "an edge node is resposable for matching ingress packets to the service they require and encapsulating them accordingly.an edge node may participate in the packet replication and duplication elimination." {79: 1, 130: 1, 54: 1, 52: 1, 98: 1, 6: 1, 8: 1, 64: 1, 99: 1, 24: 1, 90: 2, 51: 2, 62: 4, 85: 4, 68: 3, 35: 2, 110: 2, 91: 4, 114: 2, 97: 2, 31: 2, 13: 2, 67: 2, 38: 3, 26: 2, 124: 2, 127: 2, 96: 2, 30: 3, 61: 4, 55: 2, 27: 3, 15: 2, 129: 2, 115: 2, 84: 2, 76: 5, 87: 2, 131: 4, 102: 2, 113: 4, 36: 2, 72: 3} {4: 1, 24: 1, 59: 1, 111: 1, 136: 1, 156: 1, 206: 1, 215: 1, 220: 1, 221: 1, 235: 1, 241: 1, 242: 1, 314: 1, 329: 1, 334: 1, 354: 1, 366: 1, 376: 1, 1: 8, 9: 4, 10: 2, 15: 2, 25: 4, 26: 4, 27: 2, 39: 4, 43: 2, 49: 5, 50: 4, 58: 4, 64: 2, 69: 3, 81: 5, 82: 3, 86: 2, 96: 3, 97: 2, 100: 6, 108: 2, 109: 3, 110: 3, 114: 2, 115: 3, 116: 2, 118: 5, 119: 4, 120: 2, 121: 3, 122: 3, 123: 2, 124: 3, 128: 3, 129: 3, 130: 4, 132: 3, 145: 3, 147: 3, 151: 3, 152: 3, 154: 2, 161: 2, 162: 2, 165: 2, 168: 3, 169: 2, 172: 2, 180: 3, 184: 4, 187: 4, 188: 3, 191: 2, 194: 3, 202: 4, 203: 5, 207: 2, 217: 2, 218: 7, 222: 4, 224: 2, 227: 4, 229: 2, 234: 4, 243: 3, 244: 3, 245: 3, 248: 3, 250: 3, 258: 10, 262: 3, 263: 4, 264: 2, 267: 3, 270: 2, 272: 2, 273: 4, 287: 2, 289: 2, 291: 4, 299: 4, 300: 2, 304: 2, 309: 2, 315: 2, 320: 3, 323: 3, 327: 3, 328: 2, 330: 9, 335: 2, 341: 4, 342: 5, 347: 4, 348: 4, 350: 6, 351: 4, 352: 2, 353: 2, 358: 3, 365: 2, 371: 6, 372: 4, 384: 4, 385: 3, 386: 2, 387: 2, 392: 2, 393: 3, 396: 5, 397: 6, 398: 5, 402: 2} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 53 "The DetNet-aware forwarder selects the egress DetNet member flow segment based on the flow identification. The mapping of ingress DetNet member flow segment to egress DetNet member flow segment may be statically or dynamically configured. Additionally the DetNet- aware forwarder does duplicate frame elimination based on the flow identification and the sequence number combination. The packet replication is also done within the DetNet-aware forwarder. During elimination and the replication process the sequence number of the DetNet member flow MUST be preserved and copied to the egress DetNet member flow." "Major clean up and simplification as data plane drafts can be referred for MPLS related details . TSN over DetNet MPLS follows the concept of RFC3985 . Description focus on Edge Nodes procedures and functions . Text covers the Edge Nodes components : ( 1 ) TSN functions ( in NSP block ) ; ( 2 ) DetNet Service Proxy ; and ( 3 ) DetNet sub - layers . Approving from teelcon review" 3486514b01b74d57f031bcf660311de328a6e0dc 3486514b01b74d57f031bcf660311de328a6e0dc draft-ietf-detnet-tsn-vpn-over-mpls 09732023af932d8c578c8a7ead49feb80cdb5c629cee6add2e24fcd7999c0309 ['e82e49a3c764c0ede490d9e8afe0d0a379ec1e2fb734910d7e42f179709f894c', '1b5276bed81725e3cab5fa8d2491ae7fc344c8638906d8e62ee7c31696edcb52', 'a6a4ee1a9211a2be0e24cf91f9742499a46567acff4c78f62b568b34e38c08de', '44d22f065218a14d5aa04288e7553c8a6d81bb222066c74ea38571bbe922a729', 'c757c3611002031d5ce1ac79d9984d826f392e6628a0657e045c348e52b7eda2', '8a105d9f9ffbf3e747a101e48de19122931cd0cce896dc27f57d16df9dbb75ac', 'a8ff14472a8fa48bacdc11d7089a9d1054c0a786f6152f510b5d4092c22e121f', 'e746630d4b45cf2b654a14e4daaa03ad634e33d92c29c489e3ef3fcd5620c311', '16375944152e6c3e73492437880fe39d7f0123a9292d062e8e9c7d317e4b878f', '42f5214bb177fd7faf01b7943e7f313a615b2490f9109d5cefa8b24101735c32', '5cc97b8f56cdeeb02e7c96183745dc53dd8ec3ec02424107d16eb438c2c9363c', 'a816e4d1392c9c85d398ee2c5116b5de849a9823bc552d322ac8725f7c9b859e', 'c7286f8983508fdd7d94ae798cdc3950cbf65865e905c00a76838a34eb79cf2c', '6924f7b3002e9f0dff9023b70bcc9d484e643c3a2d95b0d5c853c084ad3f68ab', '2d8fce3963de03360a5d98758067925a60474b5430fd8091fc72f3c50a9d38e5', '77f9aaec42bbb94079fae33b8c564cd7f64721106f615e11f22673310efaf01b', '09f8dc962fd9202d148a0b378c9a078ea850056b4b5c360c0914d4a1de6af454', '4826376633600232b766cb8a62d4054b0f5ea45d74878bcf57356e567088300c', '82b410c949db1d81b3f197adbaaba7b82b6e497600cd9883150af2bb815caa19', '0eb73f51f3b491bd6d969a05acf2b527e6e2f09a460cb88266513ab952bd3fc6', '1076eab6753435c114e8a720c951b03da6d4e1bbbf1290f8d58ad7f97a0b8c64', '4ccf918f8b8ae99a769d89e0868a12e4af1536487652436b6c188bc99e14fdb6', '2a5cef1e9c76b52b9b56c6c021a857b0fa757897b6e3c96cc8170d5b73ba8dd8', '07267e696bfbb5af98da5a8efe2b8cf604bc9ab1ce95e4766f017473bfcd0de1', '82f56d4694c2ec964de0a4413954f87ca621628c63d7425944baeff9aa4b6dad', '01e1da53fe2751e7196114efc63dd70d9babc69b4b73c03d4b7528dcc10c05d3', 'fb8f3ca7fafc9c173404ce7f909038443a6078a0c278cb024639410e33f49f88', '44e497e2df0461bad9215c57918855022435eb6e28266916161de3f7902bb352', '84f5bc0e0be5d04b515e8e49efb393e4aec7189222b92c0555cc1be542e74549', '3195c90c03cf6a438b5684cc93128c53f794660a661e2aa85d043ca5ac7060b9', 'b5bacf05f766e143f6de9484b0b5a2d9655d62854368373bd77974b94cb722e6', '2442b9072d522cde54849b40cab26789e4af909f1dd81391cd8c87023515a21c', 'b03d79d1a547b36a28c6cba78f57b8244a4855f6b31003de3e617a5b5eddc070', 'e386562e3156c91934ceb045df46d7e847bb9afcad2794bda59be854f988befc', 'cc980749457292da3a6a4a3ce669ad487409ce72e20857e80c75741c83af7f0a', '75db9ae91b710fcf1df3553b8f9653b12d014f74ba1ee8f931870d2433e163f1', '0e313215df9694bc26777ba4ac347cb8ef73f8475d2bfed664aab722833589ae', '1094721b24c22ff67539ffeabab887f87e538bdd9ebe50b0b369de138d326802', 'fb2b9389e1455c6d64ae19158396d767d88969013b14075bcfdcc764f610108c', 'ae3bdd3a81d96e4aaa02f7d597a2684146f3af75b743bde8e31c3cf5883707db', '1b8137b4c60774716e4a492efec48060d48abd7308563d8cc76edf32d98bd759', '09732023af932d8c578c8a7ead49feb80cdb5c629cee6add2e24fcd7999c0309', '75b7020073ec0c8cedf517f1b56d554e2a5cfdf89d204633c30b863c42ed6f5f', '4be1dfb90ea542d5d84c23c0ba29b91db2491a39973839ee646eeec25c71adb4', 'c98d52f719106d13b14f27abde81ce00305cbf62889690b72da3e3ddc0286c02', '056859e4aa430e2eb983e93f08bb85d9afe9aec44f0e73263cf072df70b7c475', '870147c2dad0a0dda2dd0a9f85ef83b3c4de9a304fdff6d9fa9ccc4bde9d70c0', '26e942b0353fee8f5ac0a2c2e26c9b695c50b35c501eeb4bff343b1648b5cebc', '036168e918418eb807bc3efd361a8e66067192564da41e30e076d22be0f87935', 'a491df768673d76ae7dee4c9bf1ea1456e6c537a1f1683368d8bc6869cd89bf0', 'f6a8cfceb19b4cd796512223b8afd103c4aee7052247ebea8b50f743e9aa27b6', 'd135518ad4230c8f57a3510b3ddea8a99e2355363c9419a27340734427050729', 'cbe90e272b6be7696d3b8c171500847d2b0ae497f6911d0f9d5d8481101c4c1f', '249c961ea29438959ea2204728df24964ec80b8cd91c657715c47014f5e5a462', '1920ebb46d0cee2d379ef48c15f8f6abd01e2a183f316da235e0c3b7515feade', '6d1573b42d5f89f89b26b32cbbd32ff41660e0e8c3b3091f1cb278a42651e049', 'ec6878825845c61b3049ad5dd168197c84938e7f6d4fc938670da2528cf86317', '9829b13faebde69c2279c38cd54d524aa31acfdcc1cfba7910b9d69caa42e0dd', '2755ae7cda161df0c24e1fa9f1c3308bc9ef81a599d859668490484290ca72f4', '09d9dcfc1716808b0c62e47a771ff4d39ba71f22c8640776e65624747a995626', '71dfcd074b80de90c4955890bdbe127d12b249ed764c7c4ca23dc81c74fde71d', '3c1afbb156ee2d672ca131c7c966bc6875374a95d927848bafcc5a158edf67bb'] A "the detnet-aware forwarder selects the egress detnet member flow segment based on the flow identification. the mapping of ingress detnet member flow segment to egress detnet member flow segment may be statically or dynamically configured. additionally the detnet- aware forwarder does duplicate frame elimination based on the flow identification and the sequence number combination. the packet replication is also done within the detnet-aware forwarder. during elimination and the replication process the sequence number of the detnet member flow must be preserved and copied to the egress detnet member flow." {79: 1, 130: 1, 54: 1, 52: 1, 98: 1, 6: 1, 8: 1, 64: 1, 99: 1, 24: 1, 90: 2, 51: 2, 62: 4, 85: 4, 68: 3, 35: 2, 110: 2, 91: 4, 114: 2, 97: 2, 31: 2, 13: 2, 67: 2, 38: 3, 26: 2, 124: 2, 127: 2, 96: 2, 30: 3, 61: 4, 55: 2, 27: 3, 15: 2, 129: 2, 115: 2, 84: 2, 76: 5, 87: 2, 131: 4, 102: 2, 113: 4, 36: 2, 72: 3} {4: 1, 24: 1, 59: 1, 111: 1, 136: 1, 156: 1, 206: 1, 215: 1, 220: 1, 221: 1, 235: 1, 241: 1, 242: 1, 314: 1, 329: 1, 334: 1, 354: 1, 366: 1, 376: 1, 1: 8, 9: 4, 10: 2, 15: 2, 25: 4, 26: 4, 27: 2, 39: 4, 43: 2, 49: 5, 50: 4, 58: 4, 64: 2, 69: 3, 81: 5, 82: 3, 86: 2, 96: 3, 97: 2, 100: 6, 108: 2, 109: 3, 110: 3, 114: 2, 115: 3, 116: 2, 118: 5, 119: 4, 120: 2, 121: 3, 122: 3, 123: 2, 124: 3, 128: 3, 129: 3, 130: 4, 132: 3, 145: 3, 147: 3, 151: 3, 152: 3, 154: 2, 161: 2, 162: 2, 165: 2, 168: 3, 169: 2, 172: 2, 180: 3, 184: 4, 187: 4, 188: 3, 191: 2, 194: 3, 202: 4, 203: 5, 207: 2, 217: 2, 218: 7, 222: 4, 224: 2, 227: 4, 229: 2, 234: 4, 243: 3, 244: 3, 245: 3, 248: 3, 250: 3, 258: 10, 262: 3, 263: 4, 264: 2, 267: 3, 270: 2, 272: 2, 273: 4, 287: 2, 289: 2, 291: 4, 299: 4, 300: 2, 304: 2, 309: 2, 315: 2, 320: 3, 323: 3, 327: 3, 328: 2, 330: 9, 335: 2, 341: 4, 342: 5, 347: 4, 348: 4, 350: 6, 351: 4, 352: 2, 353: 2, 358: 3, 365: 2, 371: 6, 372: 4, 384: 4, 385: 3, 386: 2, 387: 2, 392: 2, 393: 3, 396: 5, 397: 6, 398: 5, 402: 2} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 53 "The internal design of a relay node is out of scope of this document. However the reader's attention is drawn to the need to make any PREOF state available to the packet processor(s) dealing with packets to which the PREOF functions must be applied, and to maintain that state is such as way that it is available to the packet processor operation on the next packet in the DetNet flow (which may be a duplicate, a late packet, or the next packet in sequence." "Major clean up and simplification as data plane drafts can be referred for MPLS related details . TSN over DetNet MPLS follows the concept of RFC3985 . Description focus on Edge Nodes procedures and functions . Text covers the Edge Nodes components : ( 1 ) TSN functions ( in NSP block ) ; ( 2 ) DetNet Service Proxy ; and ( 3 ) DetNet sub - layers . Approving from teelcon review" 3486514b01b74d57f031bcf660311de328a6e0dc 3486514b01b74d57f031bcf660311de328a6e0dc draft-ietf-detnet-tsn-vpn-over-mpls f6a8cfceb19b4cd796512223b8afd103c4aee7052247ebea8b50f743e9aa27b6 ['e82e49a3c764c0ede490d9e8afe0d0a379ec1e2fb734910d7e42f179709f894c', '1b5276bed81725e3cab5fa8d2491ae7fc344c8638906d8e62ee7c31696edcb52', 'a6a4ee1a9211a2be0e24cf91f9742499a46567acff4c78f62b568b34e38c08de', '44d22f065218a14d5aa04288e7553c8a6d81bb222066c74ea38571bbe922a729', 'c757c3611002031d5ce1ac79d9984d826f392e6628a0657e045c348e52b7eda2', '8a105d9f9ffbf3e747a101e48de19122931cd0cce896dc27f57d16df9dbb75ac', 'a8ff14472a8fa48bacdc11d7089a9d1054c0a786f6152f510b5d4092c22e121f', 'e746630d4b45cf2b654a14e4daaa03ad634e33d92c29c489e3ef3fcd5620c311', '16375944152e6c3e73492437880fe39d7f0123a9292d062e8e9c7d317e4b878f', '42f5214bb177fd7faf01b7943e7f313a615b2490f9109d5cefa8b24101735c32', '5cc97b8f56cdeeb02e7c96183745dc53dd8ec3ec02424107d16eb438c2c9363c', 'a816e4d1392c9c85d398ee2c5116b5de849a9823bc552d322ac8725f7c9b859e', 'c7286f8983508fdd7d94ae798cdc3950cbf65865e905c00a76838a34eb79cf2c', '6924f7b3002e9f0dff9023b70bcc9d484e643c3a2d95b0d5c853c084ad3f68ab', '2d8fce3963de03360a5d98758067925a60474b5430fd8091fc72f3c50a9d38e5', '77f9aaec42bbb94079fae33b8c564cd7f64721106f615e11f22673310efaf01b', '09f8dc962fd9202d148a0b378c9a078ea850056b4b5c360c0914d4a1de6af454', '4826376633600232b766cb8a62d4054b0f5ea45d74878bcf57356e567088300c', '82b410c949db1d81b3f197adbaaba7b82b6e497600cd9883150af2bb815caa19', '0eb73f51f3b491bd6d969a05acf2b527e6e2f09a460cb88266513ab952bd3fc6', '1076eab6753435c114e8a720c951b03da6d4e1bbbf1290f8d58ad7f97a0b8c64', '4ccf918f8b8ae99a769d89e0868a12e4af1536487652436b6c188bc99e14fdb6', '2a5cef1e9c76b52b9b56c6c021a857b0fa757897b6e3c96cc8170d5b73ba8dd8', '07267e696bfbb5af98da5a8efe2b8cf604bc9ab1ce95e4766f017473bfcd0de1', '82f56d4694c2ec964de0a4413954f87ca621628c63d7425944baeff9aa4b6dad', '01e1da53fe2751e7196114efc63dd70d9babc69b4b73c03d4b7528dcc10c05d3', 'fb8f3ca7fafc9c173404ce7f909038443a6078a0c278cb024639410e33f49f88', '44e497e2df0461bad9215c57918855022435eb6e28266916161de3f7902bb352', '84f5bc0e0be5d04b515e8e49efb393e4aec7189222b92c0555cc1be542e74549', '3195c90c03cf6a438b5684cc93128c53f794660a661e2aa85d043ca5ac7060b9', 'b5bacf05f766e143f6de9484b0b5a2d9655d62854368373bd77974b94cb722e6', '2442b9072d522cde54849b40cab26789e4af909f1dd81391cd8c87023515a21c', 'b03d79d1a547b36a28c6cba78f57b8244a4855f6b31003de3e617a5b5eddc070', 'e386562e3156c91934ceb045df46d7e847bb9afcad2794bda59be854f988befc', 'cc980749457292da3a6a4a3ce669ad487409ce72e20857e80c75741c83af7f0a', '75db9ae91b710fcf1df3553b8f9653b12d014f74ba1ee8f931870d2433e163f1', '0e313215df9694bc26777ba4ac347cb8ef73f8475d2bfed664aab722833589ae', '1094721b24c22ff67539ffeabab887f87e538bdd9ebe50b0b369de138d326802', 'fb2b9389e1455c6d64ae19158396d767d88969013b14075bcfdcc764f610108c', 'ae3bdd3a81d96e4aaa02f7d597a2684146f3af75b743bde8e31c3cf5883707db', '1b8137b4c60774716e4a492efec48060d48abd7308563d8cc76edf32d98bd759', '09732023af932d8c578c8a7ead49feb80cdb5c629cee6add2e24fcd7999c0309', '75b7020073ec0c8cedf517f1b56d554e2a5cfdf89d204633c30b863c42ed6f5f', '4be1dfb90ea542d5d84c23c0ba29b91db2491a39973839ee646eeec25c71adb4', 'c98d52f719106d13b14f27abde81ce00305cbf62889690b72da3e3ddc0286c02', '056859e4aa430e2eb983e93f08bb85d9afe9aec44f0e73263cf072df70b7c475', '870147c2dad0a0dda2dd0a9f85ef83b3c4de9a304fdff6d9fa9ccc4bde9d70c0', '26e942b0353fee8f5ac0a2c2e26c9b695c50b35c501eeb4bff343b1648b5cebc', '036168e918418eb807bc3efd361a8e66067192564da41e30e076d22be0f87935', 'a491df768673d76ae7dee4c9bf1ea1456e6c537a1f1683368d8bc6869cd89bf0', 'f6a8cfceb19b4cd796512223b8afd103c4aee7052247ebea8b50f743e9aa27b6', 'd135518ad4230c8f57a3510b3ddea8a99e2355363c9419a27340734427050729', 'cbe90e272b6be7696d3b8c171500847d2b0ae497f6911d0f9d5d8481101c4c1f', '249c961ea29438959ea2204728df24964ec80b8cd91c657715c47014f5e5a462', '1920ebb46d0cee2d379ef48c15f8f6abd01e2a183f316da235e0c3b7515feade', '6d1573b42d5f89f89b26b32cbbd32ff41660e0e8c3b3091f1cb278a42651e049', 'ec6878825845c61b3049ad5dd168197c84938e7f6d4fc938670da2528cf86317', '9829b13faebde69c2279c38cd54d524aa31acfdcc1cfba7910b9d69caa42e0dd', '2755ae7cda161df0c24e1fa9f1c3308bc9ef81a599d859668490484290ca72f4', '09d9dcfc1716808b0c62e47a771ff4d39ba71f22c8640776e65624747a995626', '71dfcd074b80de90c4955890bdbe127d12b249ed764c7c4ca23dc81c74fde71d', '3c1afbb156ee2d672ca131c7c966bc6875374a95d927848bafcc5a158edf67bb'] A "the internal design of a relay node is out of scope of this document. however the reader's attention is drawn to the need to make any preof state available to the packet processor(s) dealing with packets to which the preof functions must be applied, and to maintain that state is such as way that it is available to the packet processor operation on the next packet in the detnet flow (which may be a duplicate, a late packet, or the next packet in sequence." {79: 1, 130: 1, 54: 1, 52: 1, 98: 1, 6: 1, 8: 1, 64: 1, 99: 1, 24: 1, 90: 2, 51: 2, 62: 4, 85: 4, 68: 3, 35: 2, 110: 2, 91: 4, 114: 2, 97: 2, 31: 2, 13: 2, 67: 2, 38: 3, 26: 2, 124: 2, 127: 2, 96: 2, 30: 3, 61: 4, 55: 2, 27: 3, 15: 2, 129: 2, 115: 2, 84: 2, 76: 5, 87: 2, 131: 4, 102: 2, 113: 4, 36: 2, 72: 3} {4: 1, 24: 1, 59: 1, 111: 1, 136: 1, 156: 1, 206: 1, 215: 1, 220: 1, 221: 1, 235: 1, 241: 1, 242: 1, 314: 1, 329: 1, 334: 1, 354: 1, 366: 1, 376: 1, 1: 8, 9: 4, 10: 2, 15: 2, 25: 4, 26: 4, 27: 2, 39: 4, 43: 2, 49: 5, 50: 4, 58: 4, 64: 2, 69: 3, 81: 5, 82: 3, 86: 2, 96: 3, 97: 2, 100: 6, 108: 2, 109: 3, 110: 3, 114: 2, 115: 3, 116: 2, 118: 5, 119: 4, 120: 2, 121: 3, 122: 3, 123: 2, 124: 3, 128: 3, 129: 3, 130: 4, 132: 3, 145: 3, 147: 3, 151: 3, 152: 3, 154: 2, 161: 2, 162: 2, 165: 2, 168: 3, 169: 2, 172: 2, 180: 3, 184: 4, 187: 4, 188: 3, 191: 2, 194: 3, 202: 4, 203: 5, 207: 2, 217: 2, 218: 7, 222: 4, 224: 2, 227: 4, 229: 2, 234: 4, 243: 3, 244: 3, 245: 3, 248: 3, 250: 3, 258: 10, 262: 3, 263: 4, 264: 2, 267: 3, 270: 2, 272: 2, 273: 4, 287: 2, 289: 2, 291: 4, 299: 4, 300: 2, 304: 2, 309: 2, 315: 2, 320: 3, 323: 3, 327: 3, 328: 2, 330: 9, 335: 2, 341: 4, 342: 5, 347: 4, 348: 4, 350: 6, 351: 4, 352: 2, 353: 2, 358: 3, 365: 2, 371: 6, 372: 4, 384: 4, 385: 3, 386: 2, 387: 2, 392: 2, 393: 3, 396: 5, 397: 6, 398: 5, 402: 2} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 53 "This may be done in the DetNet layer, or where the native service processing (NSP) RFC3985 is IEEE 802.1CB IEEE8021CB capable, the packet replication and duplicate elimination MAY entirely be done in the NSP, bypassing the DetNet flow encapsulation and logic entirely. This enables operating over unmodified implementations and deployments. The NSP approach works only between edge nodes and cannot make use of relay nodes." "Major clean up and simplification as data plane drafts can be referred for MPLS related details . TSN over DetNet MPLS follows the concept of RFC3985 . Description focus on Edge Nodes procedures and functions . Text covers the Edge Nodes components : ( 1 ) TSN functions ( in NSP block ) ; ( 2 ) DetNet Service Proxy ; and ( 3 ) DetNet sub - layers . Approving from teelcon review" 3486514b01b74d57f031bcf660311de328a6e0dc 3486514b01b74d57f031bcf660311de328a6e0dc draft-ietf-detnet-tsn-vpn-over-mpls 6d1573b42d5f89f89b26b32cbbd32ff41660e0e8c3b3091f1cb278a42651e049 ['e82e49a3c764c0ede490d9e8afe0d0a379ec1e2fb734910d7e42f179709f894c', '1b5276bed81725e3cab5fa8d2491ae7fc344c8638906d8e62ee7c31696edcb52', 'a6a4ee1a9211a2be0e24cf91f9742499a46567acff4c78f62b568b34e38c08de', '44d22f065218a14d5aa04288e7553c8a6d81bb222066c74ea38571bbe922a729', 'c757c3611002031d5ce1ac79d9984d826f392e6628a0657e045c348e52b7eda2', '8a105d9f9ffbf3e747a101e48de19122931cd0cce896dc27f57d16df9dbb75ac', 'a8ff14472a8fa48bacdc11d7089a9d1054c0a786f6152f510b5d4092c22e121f', 'e746630d4b45cf2b654a14e4daaa03ad634e33d92c29c489e3ef3fcd5620c311', '16375944152e6c3e73492437880fe39d7f0123a9292d062e8e9c7d317e4b878f', '42f5214bb177fd7faf01b7943e7f313a615b2490f9109d5cefa8b24101735c32', '5cc97b8f56cdeeb02e7c96183745dc53dd8ec3ec02424107d16eb438c2c9363c', 'a816e4d1392c9c85d398ee2c5116b5de849a9823bc552d322ac8725f7c9b859e', 'c7286f8983508fdd7d94ae798cdc3950cbf65865e905c00a76838a34eb79cf2c', '6924f7b3002e9f0dff9023b70bcc9d484e643c3a2d95b0d5c853c084ad3f68ab', '2d8fce3963de03360a5d98758067925a60474b5430fd8091fc72f3c50a9d38e5', '77f9aaec42bbb94079fae33b8c564cd7f64721106f615e11f22673310efaf01b', '09f8dc962fd9202d148a0b378c9a078ea850056b4b5c360c0914d4a1de6af454', '4826376633600232b766cb8a62d4054b0f5ea45d74878bcf57356e567088300c', '82b410c949db1d81b3f197adbaaba7b82b6e497600cd9883150af2bb815caa19', '0eb73f51f3b491bd6d969a05acf2b527e6e2f09a460cb88266513ab952bd3fc6', '1076eab6753435c114e8a720c951b03da6d4e1bbbf1290f8d58ad7f97a0b8c64', '4ccf918f8b8ae99a769d89e0868a12e4af1536487652436b6c188bc99e14fdb6', '2a5cef1e9c76b52b9b56c6c021a857b0fa757897b6e3c96cc8170d5b73ba8dd8', '07267e696bfbb5af98da5a8efe2b8cf604bc9ab1ce95e4766f017473bfcd0de1', '82f56d4694c2ec964de0a4413954f87ca621628c63d7425944baeff9aa4b6dad', '01e1da53fe2751e7196114efc63dd70d9babc69b4b73c03d4b7528dcc10c05d3', 'fb8f3ca7fafc9c173404ce7f909038443a6078a0c278cb024639410e33f49f88', '44e497e2df0461bad9215c57918855022435eb6e28266916161de3f7902bb352', '84f5bc0e0be5d04b515e8e49efb393e4aec7189222b92c0555cc1be542e74549', '3195c90c03cf6a438b5684cc93128c53f794660a661e2aa85d043ca5ac7060b9', 'b5bacf05f766e143f6de9484b0b5a2d9655d62854368373bd77974b94cb722e6', '2442b9072d522cde54849b40cab26789e4af909f1dd81391cd8c87023515a21c', 'b03d79d1a547b36a28c6cba78f57b8244a4855f6b31003de3e617a5b5eddc070', 'e386562e3156c91934ceb045df46d7e847bb9afcad2794bda59be854f988befc', 'cc980749457292da3a6a4a3ce669ad487409ce72e20857e80c75741c83af7f0a', '75db9ae91b710fcf1df3553b8f9653b12d014f74ba1ee8f931870d2433e163f1', '0e313215df9694bc26777ba4ac347cb8ef73f8475d2bfed664aab722833589ae', '1094721b24c22ff67539ffeabab887f87e538bdd9ebe50b0b369de138d326802', 'fb2b9389e1455c6d64ae19158396d767d88969013b14075bcfdcc764f610108c', 'ae3bdd3a81d96e4aaa02f7d597a2684146f3af75b743bde8e31c3cf5883707db', '1b8137b4c60774716e4a492efec48060d48abd7308563d8cc76edf32d98bd759', '09732023af932d8c578c8a7ead49feb80cdb5c629cee6add2e24fcd7999c0309', '75b7020073ec0c8cedf517f1b56d554e2a5cfdf89d204633c30b863c42ed6f5f', '4be1dfb90ea542d5d84c23c0ba29b91db2491a39973839ee646eeec25c71adb4', 'c98d52f719106d13b14f27abde81ce00305cbf62889690b72da3e3ddc0286c02', '056859e4aa430e2eb983e93f08bb85d9afe9aec44f0e73263cf072df70b7c475', '870147c2dad0a0dda2dd0a9f85ef83b3c4de9a304fdff6d9fa9ccc4bde9d70c0', '26e942b0353fee8f5ac0a2c2e26c9b695c50b35c501eeb4bff343b1648b5cebc', '036168e918418eb807bc3efd361a8e66067192564da41e30e076d22be0f87935', 'a491df768673d76ae7dee4c9bf1ea1456e6c537a1f1683368d8bc6869cd89bf0', 'f6a8cfceb19b4cd796512223b8afd103c4aee7052247ebea8b50f743e9aa27b6', 'd135518ad4230c8f57a3510b3ddea8a99e2355363c9419a27340734427050729', 'cbe90e272b6be7696d3b8c171500847d2b0ae497f6911d0f9d5d8481101c4c1f', '249c961ea29438959ea2204728df24964ec80b8cd91c657715c47014f5e5a462', '1920ebb46d0cee2d379ef48c15f8f6abd01e2a183f316da235e0c3b7515feade', '6d1573b42d5f89f89b26b32cbbd32ff41660e0e8c3b3091f1cb278a42651e049', 'ec6878825845c61b3049ad5dd168197c84938e7f6d4fc938670da2528cf86317', '9829b13faebde69c2279c38cd54d524aa31acfdcc1cfba7910b9d69caa42e0dd', '2755ae7cda161df0c24e1fa9f1c3308bc9ef81a599d859668490484290ca72f4', '09d9dcfc1716808b0c62e47a771ff4d39ba71f22c8640776e65624747a995626', '71dfcd074b80de90c4955890bdbe127d12b249ed764c7c4ca23dc81c74fde71d', '3c1afbb156ee2d672ca131c7c966bc6875374a95d927848bafcc5a158edf67bb'] A "this may be done in the detnet layer, or where the native service processing (nsp) rfc3985 is ieee 802.1cb ieee8021cb capable, the packet replication and duplicate elimination may entirely be done in the nsp, bypassing the detnet flow encapsulation and logic entirely. this enables operating over unmodified implementations and deployments. the nsp approach works only between edge nodes and cannot make use of relay nodes." {79: 1, 130: 1, 54: 1, 52: 1, 98: 1, 6: 1, 8: 1, 64: 1, 99: 1, 24: 1, 90: 2, 51: 2, 62: 4, 85: 4, 68: 3, 35: 2, 110: 2, 91: 4, 114: 2, 97: 2, 31: 2, 13: 2, 67: 2, 38: 3, 26: 2, 124: 2, 127: 2, 96: 2, 30: 3, 61: 4, 55: 2, 27: 3, 15: 2, 129: 2, 115: 2, 84: 2, 76: 5, 87: 2, 131: 4, 102: 2, 113: 4, 36: 2, 72: 3} {4: 1, 24: 1, 59: 1, 111: 1, 136: 1, 156: 1, 206: 1, 215: 1, 220: 1, 221: 1, 235: 1, 241: 1, 242: 1, 314: 1, 329: 1, 334: 1, 354: 1, 366: 1, 376: 1, 1: 8, 9: 4, 10: 2, 15: 2, 25: 4, 26: 4, 27: 2, 39: 4, 43: 2, 49: 5, 50: 4, 58: 4, 64: 2, 69: 3, 81: 5, 82: 3, 86: 2, 96: 3, 97: 2, 100: 6, 108: 2, 109: 3, 110: 3, 114: 2, 115: 3, 116: 2, 118: 5, 119: 4, 120: 2, 121: 3, 122: 3, 123: 2, 124: 3, 128: 3, 129: 3, 130: 4, 132: 3, 145: 3, 147: 3, 151: 3, 152: 3, 154: 2, 161: 2, 162: 2, 165: 2, 168: 3, 169: 2, 172: 2, 180: 3, 184: 4, 187: 4, 188: 3, 191: 2, 194: 3, 202: 4, 203: 5, 207: 2, 217: 2, 218: 7, 222: 4, 224: 2, 227: 4, 229: 2, 234: 4, 243: 3, 244: 3, 245: 3, 248: 3, 250: 3, 258: 10, 262: 3, 263: 4, 264: 2, 267: 3, 270: 2, 272: 2, 273: 4, 287: 2, 289: 2, 291: 4, 299: 4, 300: 2, 304: 2, 309: 2, 315: 2, 320: 3, 323: 3, 327: 3, 328: 2, 330: 9, 335: 2, 341: 4, 342: 5, 347: 4, 348: 4, 350: 6, 351: 4, 352: 2, 353: 2, 358: 3, 365: 2, 371: 6, 372: 4, 384: 4, 385: 3, 386: 2, 387: 2, 392: 2, 393: 3, 396: 5, 397: 6, 398: 5, 402: 2} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 53 "The NSP approach is useful end to end tunnel and for for ""island interconnect"" scenarios. However, when there is a need to do PREOF in a middle of the network, such plain edge to edge operation is not sufficient." "Major clean up and simplification as data plane drafts can be referred for MPLS related details . TSN over DetNet MPLS follows the concept of RFC3985 . Description focus on Edge Nodes procedures and functions . Text covers the Edge Nodes components : ( 1 ) TSN functions ( in NSP block ) ; ( 2 ) DetNet Service Proxy ; and ( 3 ) DetNet sub - layers . Approving from teelcon review" 3486514b01b74d57f031bcf660311de328a6e0dc 3486514b01b74d57f031bcf660311de328a6e0dc draft-ietf-detnet-tsn-vpn-over-mpls 8a105d9f9ffbf3e747a101e48de19122931cd0cce896dc27f57d16df9dbb75ac ['e82e49a3c764c0ede490d9e8afe0d0a379ec1e2fb734910d7e42f179709f894c', '1b5276bed81725e3cab5fa8d2491ae7fc344c8638906d8e62ee7c31696edcb52', 'a6a4ee1a9211a2be0e24cf91f9742499a46567acff4c78f62b568b34e38c08de', '44d22f065218a14d5aa04288e7553c8a6d81bb222066c74ea38571bbe922a729', 'c757c3611002031d5ce1ac79d9984d826f392e6628a0657e045c348e52b7eda2', '8a105d9f9ffbf3e747a101e48de19122931cd0cce896dc27f57d16df9dbb75ac', 'a8ff14472a8fa48bacdc11d7089a9d1054c0a786f6152f510b5d4092c22e121f', 'e746630d4b45cf2b654a14e4daaa03ad634e33d92c29c489e3ef3fcd5620c311', '16375944152e6c3e73492437880fe39d7f0123a9292d062e8e9c7d317e4b878f', '42f5214bb177fd7faf01b7943e7f313a615b2490f9109d5cefa8b24101735c32', '5cc97b8f56cdeeb02e7c96183745dc53dd8ec3ec02424107d16eb438c2c9363c', 'a816e4d1392c9c85d398ee2c5116b5de849a9823bc552d322ac8725f7c9b859e', 'c7286f8983508fdd7d94ae798cdc3950cbf65865e905c00a76838a34eb79cf2c', '6924f7b3002e9f0dff9023b70bcc9d484e643c3a2d95b0d5c853c084ad3f68ab', '2d8fce3963de03360a5d98758067925a60474b5430fd8091fc72f3c50a9d38e5', '77f9aaec42bbb94079fae33b8c564cd7f64721106f615e11f22673310efaf01b', '09f8dc962fd9202d148a0b378c9a078ea850056b4b5c360c0914d4a1de6af454', '4826376633600232b766cb8a62d4054b0f5ea45d74878bcf57356e567088300c', '82b410c949db1d81b3f197adbaaba7b82b6e497600cd9883150af2bb815caa19', '0eb73f51f3b491bd6d969a05acf2b527e6e2f09a460cb88266513ab952bd3fc6', '1076eab6753435c114e8a720c951b03da6d4e1bbbf1290f8d58ad7f97a0b8c64', '4ccf918f8b8ae99a769d89e0868a12e4af1536487652436b6c188bc99e14fdb6', '2a5cef1e9c76b52b9b56c6c021a857b0fa757897b6e3c96cc8170d5b73ba8dd8', '07267e696bfbb5af98da5a8efe2b8cf604bc9ab1ce95e4766f017473bfcd0de1', '82f56d4694c2ec964de0a4413954f87ca621628c63d7425944baeff9aa4b6dad', '01e1da53fe2751e7196114efc63dd70d9babc69b4b73c03d4b7528dcc10c05d3', 'fb8f3ca7fafc9c173404ce7f909038443a6078a0c278cb024639410e33f49f88', '44e497e2df0461bad9215c57918855022435eb6e28266916161de3f7902bb352', '84f5bc0e0be5d04b515e8e49efb393e4aec7189222b92c0555cc1be542e74549', '3195c90c03cf6a438b5684cc93128c53f794660a661e2aa85d043ca5ac7060b9', 'b5bacf05f766e143f6de9484b0b5a2d9655d62854368373bd77974b94cb722e6', '2442b9072d522cde54849b40cab26789e4af909f1dd81391cd8c87023515a21c', 'b03d79d1a547b36a28c6cba78f57b8244a4855f6b31003de3e617a5b5eddc070', 'e386562e3156c91934ceb045df46d7e847bb9afcad2794bda59be854f988befc', 'cc980749457292da3a6a4a3ce669ad487409ce72e20857e80c75741c83af7f0a', '75db9ae91b710fcf1df3553b8f9653b12d014f74ba1ee8f931870d2433e163f1', '0e313215df9694bc26777ba4ac347cb8ef73f8475d2bfed664aab722833589ae', '1094721b24c22ff67539ffeabab887f87e538bdd9ebe50b0b369de138d326802', 'fb2b9389e1455c6d64ae19158396d767d88969013b14075bcfdcc764f610108c', 'ae3bdd3a81d96e4aaa02f7d597a2684146f3af75b743bde8e31c3cf5883707db', '1b8137b4c60774716e4a492efec48060d48abd7308563d8cc76edf32d98bd759', '09732023af932d8c578c8a7ead49feb80cdb5c629cee6add2e24fcd7999c0309', '75b7020073ec0c8cedf517f1b56d554e2a5cfdf89d204633c30b863c42ed6f5f', '4be1dfb90ea542d5d84c23c0ba29b91db2491a39973839ee646eeec25c71adb4', 'c98d52f719106d13b14f27abde81ce00305cbf62889690b72da3e3ddc0286c02', '056859e4aa430e2eb983e93f08bb85d9afe9aec44f0e73263cf072df70b7c475', '870147c2dad0a0dda2dd0a9f85ef83b3c4de9a304fdff6d9fa9ccc4bde9d70c0', '26e942b0353fee8f5ac0a2c2e26c9b695c50b35c501eeb4bff343b1648b5cebc', '036168e918418eb807bc3efd361a8e66067192564da41e30e076d22be0f87935', 'a491df768673d76ae7dee4c9bf1ea1456e6c537a1f1683368d8bc6869cd89bf0', 'f6a8cfceb19b4cd796512223b8afd103c4aee7052247ebea8b50f743e9aa27b6', 'd135518ad4230c8f57a3510b3ddea8a99e2355363c9419a27340734427050729', 'cbe90e272b6be7696d3b8c171500847d2b0ae497f6911d0f9d5d8481101c4c1f', '249c961ea29438959ea2204728df24964ec80b8cd91c657715c47014f5e5a462', '1920ebb46d0cee2d379ef48c15f8f6abd01e2a183f316da235e0c3b7515feade', '6d1573b42d5f89f89b26b32cbbd32ff41660e0e8c3b3091f1cb278a42651e049', 'ec6878825845c61b3049ad5dd168197c84938e7f6d4fc938670da2528cf86317', '9829b13faebde69c2279c38cd54d524aa31acfdcc1cfba7910b9d69caa42e0dd', '2755ae7cda161df0c24e1fa9f1c3308bc9ef81a599d859668490484290ca72f4', '09d9dcfc1716808b0c62e47a771ff4d39ba71f22c8640776e65624747a995626', '71dfcd074b80de90c4955890bdbe127d12b249ed764c7c4ca23dc81c74fde71d', '3c1afbb156ee2d672ca131c7c966bc6875374a95d927848bafcc5a158edf67bb'] A "the nsp approach is useful end to end tunnel and for for ""island interconnect"" scenarios. however, when there is a need to do preof in a middle of the network, such plain edge to edge operation is not sufficient." {79: 1, 130: 1, 54: 1, 52: 1, 98: 1, 6: 1, 8: 1, 64: 1, 99: 1, 24: 1, 90: 2, 51: 2, 62: 4, 85: 4, 68: 3, 35: 2, 110: 2, 91: 4, 114: 2, 97: 2, 31: 2, 13: 2, 67: 2, 38: 3, 26: 2, 124: 2, 127: 2, 96: 2, 30: 3, 61: 4, 55: 2, 27: 3, 15: 2, 129: 2, 115: 2, 84: 2, 76: 5, 87: 2, 131: 4, 102: 2, 113: 4, 36: 2, 72: 3} {4: 1, 24: 1, 59: 1, 111: 1, 136: 1, 156: 1, 206: 1, 215: 1, 220: 1, 221: 1, 235: 1, 241: 1, 242: 1, 314: 1, 329: 1, 334: 1, 354: 1, 366: 1, 376: 1, 1: 8, 9: 4, 10: 2, 15: 2, 25: 4, 26: 4, 27: 2, 39: 4, 43: 2, 49: 5, 50: 4, 58: 4, 64: 2, 69: 3, 81: 5, 82: 3, 86: 2, 96: 3, 97: 2, 100: 6, 108: 2, 109: 3, 110: 3, 114: 2, 115: 3, 116: 2, 118: 5, 119: 4, 120: 2, 121: 3, 122: 3, 123: 2, 124: 3, 128: 3, 129: 3, 130: 4, 132: 3, 145: 3, 147: 3, 151: 3, 152: 3, 154: 2, 161: 2, 162: 2, 165: 2, 168: 3, 169: 2, 172: 2, 180: 3, 184: 4, 187: 4, 188: 3, 191: 2, 194: 3, 202: 4, 203: 5, 207: 2, 217: 2, 218: 7, 222: 4, 224: 2, 227: 4, 229: 2, 234: 4, 243: 3, 244: 3, 245: 3, 248: 3, 250: 3, 258: 10, 262: 3, 263: 4, 264: 2, 267: 3, 270: 2, 272: 2, 273: 4, 287: 2, 289: 2, 291: 4, 299: 4, 300: 2, 304: 2, 309: 2, 315: 2, 320: 3, 323: 3, 327: 3, 328: 2, 330: 9, 335: 2, 341: 4, 342: 5, 347: 4, 348: 4, 350: 6, 351: 4, 352: 2, 353: 2, 358: 3, 365: 2, 371: 6, 372: 4, 384: 4, 385: 3, 386: 2, 387: 2, 392: 2, 393: 3, 396: 5, 397: 6, 398: 5, 402: 2} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 53 "The extended forwarder MAY copy the sequencing information from the native DetNet packet into the DetNet sequence number field and vice versa. If there is no existing sequencing information available in the native packet or the forwarder chose not to copy it from the native packet, then the extended forwarder MUST maintain a sequence number counter for each DetNet flow (indexed by the DetNet flow identification)." "Major clean up and simplification as data plane drafts can be referred for MPLS related details . TSN over DetNet MPLS follows the concept of RFC3985 . Description focus on Edge Nodes procedures and functions . Text covers the Edge Nodes components : ( 1 ) TSN functions ( in NSP block ) ; ( 2 ) DetNet Service Proxy ; and ( 3 ) DetNet sub - layers . Approving from teelcon review" 3486514b01b74d57f031bcf660311de328a6e0dc 3486514b01b74d57f031bcf660311de328a6e0dc draft-ietf-detnet-tsn-vpn-over-mpls 82b410c949db1d81b3f197adbaaba7b82b6e497600cd9883150af2bb815caa19 ['e82e49a3c764c0ede490d9e8afe0d0a379ec1e2fb734910d7e42f179709f894c', '1b5276bed81725e3cab5fa8d2491ae7fc344c8638906d8e62ee7c31696edcb52', 'a6a4ee1a9211a2be0e24cf91f9742499a46567acff4c78f62b568b34e38c08de', '44d22f065218a14d5aa04288e7553c8a6d81bb222066c74ea38571bbe922a729', 'c757c3611002031d5ce1ac79d9984d826f392e6628a0657e045c348e52b7eda2', '8a105d9f9ffbf3e747a101e48de19122931cd0cce896dc27f57d16df9dbb75ac', 'a8ff14472a8fa48bacdc11d7089a9d1054c0a786f6152f510b5d4092c22e121f', 'e746630d4b45cf2b654a14e4daaa03ad634e33d92c29c489e3ef3fcd5620c311', '16375944152e6c3e73492437880fe39d7f0123a9292d062e8e9c7d317e4b878f', '42f5214bb177fd7faf01b7943e7f313a615b2490f9109d5cefa8b24101735c32', '5cc97b8f56cdeeb02e7c96183745dc53dd8ec3ec02424107d16eb438c2c9363c', 'a816e4d1392c9c85d398ee2c5116b5de849a9823bc552d322ac8725f7c9b859e', 'c7286f8983508fdd7d94ae798cdc3950cbf65865e905c00a76838a34eb79cf2c', '6924f7b3002e9f0dff9023b70bcc9d484e643c3a2d95b0d5c853c084ad3f68ab', '2d8fce3963de03360a5d98758067925a60474b5430fd8091fc72f3c50a9d38e5', '77f9aaec42bbb94079fae33b8c564cd7f64721106f615e11f22673310efaf01b', '09f8dc962fd9202d148a0b378c9a078ea850056b4b5c360c0914d4a1de6af454', '4826376633600232b766cb8a62d4054b0f5ea45d74878bcf57356e567088300c', '82b410c949db1d81b3f197adbaaba7b82b6e497600cd9883150af2bb815caa19', '0eb73f51f3b491bd6d969a05acf2b527e6e2f09a460cb88266513ab952bd3fc6', '1076eab6753435c114e8a720c951b03da6d4e1bbbf1290f8d58ad7f97a0b8c64', '4ccf918f8b8ae99a769d89e0868a12e4af1536487652436b6c188bc99e14fdb6', '2a5cef1e9c76b52b9b56c6c021a857b0fa757897b6e3c96cc8170d5b73ba8dd8', '07267e696bfbb5af98da5a8efe2b8cf604bc9ab1ce95e4766f017473bfcd0de1', '82f56d4694c2ec964de0a4413954f87ca621628c63d7425944baeff9aa4b6dad', '01e1da53fe2751e7196114efc63dd70d9babc69b4b73c03d4b7528dcc10c05d3', 'fb8f3ca7fafc9c173404ce7f909038443a6078a0c278cb024639410e33f49f88', '44e497e2df0461bad9215c57918855022435eb6e28266916161de3f7902bb352', '84f5bc0e0be5d04b515e8e49efb393e4aec7189222b92c0555cc1be542e74549', '3195c90c03cf6a438b5684cc93128c53f794660a661e2aa85d043ca5ac7060b9', 'b5bacf05f766e143f6de9484b0b5a2d9655d62854368373bd77974b94cb722e6', '2442b9072d522cde54849b40cab26789e4af909f1dd81391cd8c87023515a21c', 'b03d79d1a547b36a28c6cba78f57b8244a4855f6b31003de3e617a5b5eddc070', 'e386562e3156c91934ceb045df46d7e847bb9afcad2794bda59be854f988befc', 'cc980749457292da3a6a4a3ce669ad487409ce72e20857e80c75741c83af7f0a', '75db9ae91b710fcf1df3553b8f9653b12d014f74ba1ee8f931870d2433e163f1', '0e313215df9694bc26777ba4ac347cb8ef73f8475d2bfed664aab722833589ae', '1094721b24c22ff67539ffeabab887f87e538bdd9ebe50b0b369de138d326802', 'fb2b9389e1455c6d64ae19158396d767d88969013b14075bcfdcc764f610108c', 'ae3bdd3a81d96e4aaa02f7d597a2684146f3af75b743bde8e31c3cf5883707db', '1b8137b4c60774716e4a492efec48060d48abd7308563d8cc76edf32d98bd759', '09732023af932d8c578c8a7ead49feb80cdb5c629cee6add2e24fcd7999c0309', '75b7020073ec0c8cedf517f1b56d554e2a5cfdf89d204633c30b863c42ed6f5f', '4be1dfb90ea542d5d84c23c0ba29b91db2491a39973839ee646eeec25c71adb4', 'c98d52f719106d13b14f27abde81ce00305cbf62889690b72da3e3ddc0286c02', '056859e4aa430e2eb983e93f08bb85d9afe9aec44f0e73263cf072df70b7c475', '870147c2dad0a0dda2dd0a9f85ef83b3c4de9a304fdff6d9fa9ccc4bde9d70c0', '26e942b0353fee8f5ac0a2c2e26c9b695c50b35c501eeb4bff343b1648b5cebc', '036168e918418eb807bc3efd361a8e66067192564da41e30e076d22be0f87935', 'a491df768673d76ae7dee4c9bf1ea1456e6c537a1f1683368d8bc6869cd89bf0', 'f6a8cfceb19b4cd796512223b8afd103c4aee7052247ebea8b50f743e9aa27b6', 'd135518ad4230c8f57a3510b3ddea8a99e2355363c9419a27340734427050729', 'cbe90e272b6be7696d3b8c171500847d2b0ae497f6911d0f9d5d8481101c4c1f', '249c961ea29438959ea2204728df24964ec80b8cd91c657715c47014f5e5a462', '1920ebb46d0cee2d379ef48c15f8f6abd01e2a183f316da235e0c3b7515feade', '6d1573b42d5f89f89b26b32cbbd32ff41660e0e8c3b3091f1cb278a42651e049', 'ec6878825845c61b3049ad5dd168197c84938e7f6d4fc938670da2528cf86317', '9829b13faebde69c2279c38cd54d524aa31acfdcc1cfba7910b9d69caa42e0dd', '2755ae7cda161df0c24e1fa9f1c3308bc9ef81a599d859668490484290ca72f4', '09d9dcfc1716808b0c62e47a771ff4d39ba71f22c8640776e65624747a995626', '71dfcd074b80de90c4955890bdbe127d12b249ed764c7c4ca23dc81c74fde71d', '3c1afbb156ee2d672ca131c7c966bc6875374a95d927848bafcc5a158edf67bb'] A "the extended forwarder may copy the sequencing information from the native detnet packet into the detnet sequence number field and vice versa. if there is no existing sequencing information available in the native packet or the forwarder chose not to copy it from the native packet, then the extended forwarder must maintain a sequence number counter for each detnet flow (indexed by the detnet flow identification)." {79: 1, 130: 1, 54: 1, 52: 1, 98: 1, 6: 1, 8: 1, 64: 1, 99: 1, 24: 1, 90: 2, 51: 2, 62: 4, 85: 4, 68: 3, 35: 2, 110: 2, 91: 4, 114: 2, 97: 2, 31: 2, 13: 2, 67: 2, 38: 3, 26: 2, 124: 2, 127: 2, 96: 2, 30: 3, 61: 4, 55: 2, 27: 3, 15: 2, 129: 2, 115: 2, 84: 2, 76: 5, 87: 2, 131: 4, 102: 2, 113: 4, 36: 2, 72: 3} {4: 1, 24: 1, 59: 1, 111: 1, 136: 1, 156: 1, 206: 1, 215: 1, 220: 1, 221: 1, 235: 1, 241: 1, 242: 1, 314: 1, 329: 1, 334: 1, 354: 1, 366: 1, 376: 1, 1: 8, 9: 4, 10: 2, 15: 2, 25: 4, 26: 4, 27: 2, 39: 4, 43: 2, 49: 5, 50: 4, 58: 4, 64: 2, 69: 3, 81: 5, 82: 3, 86: 2, 96: 3, 97: 2, 100: 6, 108: 2, 109: 3, 110: 3, 114: 2, 115: 3, 116: 2, 118: 5, 119: 4, 120: 2, 121: 3, 122: 3, 123: 2, 124: 3, 128: 3, 129: 3, 130: 4, 132: 3, 145: 3, 147: 3, 151: 3, 152: 3, 154: 2, 161: 2, 162: 2, 165: 2, 168: 3, 169: 2, 172: 2, 180: 3, 184: 4, 187: 4, 188: 3, 191: 2, 194: 3, 202: 4, 203: 5, 207: 2, 217: 2, 218: 7, 222: 4, 224: 2, 227: 4, 229: 2, 234: 4, 243: 3, 244: 3, 245: 3, 248: 3, 250: 3, 258: 10, 262: 3, 263: 4, 264: 2, 267: 3, 270: 2, 272: 2, 273: 4, 287: 2, 289: 2, 291: 4, 299: 4, 300: 2, 304: 2, 309: 2, 315: 2, 320: 3, 323: 3, 327: 3, 328: 2, 330: 9, 335: 2, 341: 4, 342: 5, 347: 4, 348: 4, 350: 6, 351: 4, 352: 2, 353: 2, 358: 3, 365: 2, 371: 6, 372: 4, 384: 4, 385: 3, 386: 2, 387: 2, 392: 2, 393: 3, 396: 5, 397: 6, 398: 5, 402: 2} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 53 "The Time-Sensitive Networking (TSN) Task Group of the IEEE 802.1 Working Group have defined (and are defining) a number of amendments to IEEE8021Q that provide zero congestion loss and bounded latency in bridged networks. IEEE8021CB defines packet replication and elimination functions that should prove both compatible with and useful to, DetNet networks." "Major clean up and simplification as data plane drafts can be referred for MPLS related details . TSN over DetNet MPLS follows the concept of RFC3985 . Description focus on Edge Nodes procedures and functions . Text covers the Edge Nodes components : ( 1 ) TSN functions ( in NSP block ) ; ( 2 ) DetNet Service Proxy ; and ( 3 ) DetNet sub - layers . Approving from teelcon review" 3486514b01b74d57f031bcf660311de328a6e0dc 3486514b01b74d57f031bcf660311de328a6e0dc draft-ietf-detnet-tsn-vpn-over-mpls 3195c90c03cf6a438b5684cc93128c53f794660a661e2aa85d043ca5ac7060b9 ['e82e49a3c764c0ede490d9e8afe0d0a379ec1e2fb734910d7e42f179709f894c', '1b5276bed81725e3cab5fa8d2491ae7fc344c8638906d8e62ee7c31696edcb52', 'a6a4ee1a9211a2be0e24cf91f9742499a46567acff4c78f62b568b34e38c08de', '44d22f065218a14d5aa04288e7553c8a6d81bb222066c74ea38571bbe922a729', 'c757c3611002031d5ce1ac79d9984d826f392e6628a0657e045c348e52b7eda2', '8a105d9f9ffbf3e747a101e48de19122931cd0cce896dc27f57d16df9dbb75ac', 'a8ff14472a8fa48bacdc11d7089a9d1054c0a786f6152f510b5d4092c22e121f', 'e746630d4b45cf2b654a14e4daaa03ad634e33d92c29c489e3ef3fcd5620c311', '16375944152e6c3e73492437880fe39d7f0123a9292d062e8e9c7d317e4b878f', '42f5214bb177fd7faf01b7943e7f313a615b2490f9109d5cefa8b24101735c32', '5cc97b8f56cdeeb02e7c96183745dc53dd8ec3ec02424107d16eb438c2c9363c', 'a816e4d1392c9c85d398ee2c5116b5de849a9823bc552d322ac8725f7c9b859e', 'c7286f8983508fdd7d94ae798cdc3950cbf65865e905c00a76838a34eb79cf2c', '6924f7b3002e9f0dff9023b70bcc9d484e643c3a2d95b0d5c853c084ad3f68ab', '2d8fce3963de03360a5d98758067925a60474b5430fd8091fc72f3c50a9d38e5', '77f9aaec42bbb94079fae33b8c564cd7f64721106f615e11f22673310efaf01b', '09f8dc962fd9202d148a0b378c9a078ea850056b4b5c360c0914d4a1de6af454', '4826376633600232b766cb8a62d4054b0f5ea45d74878bcf57356e567088300c', '82b410c949db1d81b3f197adbaaba7b82b6e497600cd9883150af2bb815caa19', '0eb73f51f3b491bd6d969a05acf2b527e6e2f09a460cb88266513ab952bd3fc6', '1076eab6753435c114e8a720c951b03da6d4e1bbbf1290f8d58ad7f97a0b8c64', '4ccf918f8b8ae99a769d89e0868a12e4af1536487652436b6c188bc99e14fdb6', '2a5cef1e9c76b52b9b56c6c021a857b0fa757897b6e3c96cc8170d5b73ba8dd8', '07267e696bfbb5af98da5a8efe2b8cf604bc9ab1ce95e4766f017473bfcd0de1', '82f56d4694c2ec964de0a4413954f87ca621628c63d7425944baeff9aa4b6dad', '01e1da53fe2751e7196114efc63dd70d9babc69b4b73c03d4b7528dcc10c05d3', 'fb8f3ca7fafc9c173404ce7f909038443a6078a0c278cb024639410e33f49f88', '44e497e2df0461bad9215c57918855022435eb6e28266916161de3f7902bb352', '84f5bc0e0be5d04b515e8e49efb393e4aec7189222b92c0555cc1be542e74549', '3195c90c03cf6a438b5684cc93128c53f794660a661e2aa85d043ca5ac7060b9', 'b5bacf05f766e143f6de9484b0b5a2d9655d62854368373bd77974b94cb722e6', '2442b9072d522cde54849b40cab26789e4af909f1dd81391cd8c87023515a21c', 'b03d79d1a547b36a28c6cba78f57b8244a4855f6b31003de3e617a5b5eddc070', 'e386562e3156c91934ceb045df46d7e847bb9afcad2794bda59be854f988befc', 'cc980749457292da3a6a4a3ce669ad487409ce72e20857e80c75741c83af7f0a', '75db9ae91b710fcf1df3553b8f9653b12d014f74ba1ee8f931870d2433e163f1', '0e313215df9694bc26777ba4ac347cb8ef73f8475d2bfed664aab722833589ae', '1094721b24c22ff67539ffeabab887f87e538bdd9ebe50b0b369de138d326802', 'fb2b9389e1455c6d64ae19158396d767d88969013b14075bcfdcc764f610108c', 'ae3bdd3a81d96e4aaa02f7d597a2684146f3af75b743bde8e31c3cf5883707db', '1b8137b4c60774716e4a492efec48060d48abd7308563d8cc76edf32d98bd759', '09732023af932d8c578c8a7ead49feb80cdb5c629cee6add2e24fcd7999c0309', '75b7020073ec0c8cedf517f1b56d554e2a5cfdf89d204633c30b863c42ed6f5f', '4be1dfb90ea542d5d84c23c0ba29b91db2491a39973839ee646eeec25c71adb4', 'c98d52f719106d13b14f27abde81ce00305cbf62889690b72da3e3ddc0286c02', '056859e4aa430e2eb983e93f08bb85d9afe9aec44f0e73263cf072df70b7c475', '870147c2dad0a0dda2dd0a9f85ef83b3c4de9a304fdff6d9fa9ccc4bde9d70c0', '26e942b0353fee8f5ac0a2c2e26c9b695c50b35c501eeb4bff343b1648b5cebc', '036168e918418eb807bc3efd361a8e66067192564da41e30e076d22be0f87935', 'a491df768673d76ae7dee4c9bf1ea1456e6c537a1f1683368d8bc6869cd89bf0', 'f6a8cfceb19b4cd796512223b8afd103c4aee7052247ebea8b50f743e9aa27b6', 'd135518ad4230c8f57a3510b3ddea8a99e2355363c9419a27340734427050729', 'cbe90e272b6be7696d3b8c171500847d2b0ae497f6911d0f9d5d8481101c4c1f', '249c961ea29438959ea2204728df24964ec80b8cd91c657715c47014f5e5a462', '1920ebb46d0cee2d379ef48c15f8f6abd01e2a183f316da235e0c3b7515feade', '6d1573b42d5f89f89b26b32cbbd32ff41660e0e8c3b3091f1cb278a42651e049', 'ec6878825845c61b3049ad5dd168197c84938e7f6d4fc938670da2528cf86317', '9829b13faebde69c2279c38cd54d524aa31acfdcc1cfba7910b9d69caa42e0dd', '2755ae7cda161df0c24e1fa9f1c3308bc9ef81a599d859668490484290ca72f4', '09d9dcfc1716808b0c62e47a771ff4d39ba71f22c8640776e65624747a995626', '71dfcd074b80de90c4955890bdbe127d12b249ed764c7c4ca23dc81c74fde71d', '3c1afbb156ee2d672ca131c7c966bc6875374a95d927848bafcc5a158edf67bb'] A "the time-sensitive networking (tsn) task group of the ieee 802.1 working group have defined (and are defining) a number of amendments to ieee8021q that provide zero congestion loss and bounded latency in bridged networks. ieee8021cb defines packet replication and elimination functions that should prove both compatible with and useful to, detnet networks." {79: 1, 130: 1, 54: 1, 52: 1, 98: 1, 6: 1, 8: 1, 64: 1, 99: 1, 24: 1, 90: 2, 51: 2, 62: 4, 85: 4, 68: 3, 35: 2, 110: 2, 91: 4, 114: 2, 97: 2, 31: 2, 13: 2, 67: 2, 38: 3, 26: 2, 124: 2, 127: 2, 96: 2, 30: 3, 61: 4, 55: 2, 27: 3, 15: 2, 129: 2, 115: 2, 84: 2, 76: 5, 87: 2, 131: 4, 102: 2, 113: 4, 36: 2, 72: 3} {4: 1, 24: 1, 59: 1, 111: 1, 136: 1, 156: 1, 206: 1, 215: 1, 220: 1, 221: 1, 235: 1, 241: 1, 242: 1, 314: 1, 329: 1, 334: 1, 354: 1, 366: 1, 376: 1, 1: 8, 9: 4, 10: 2, 15: 2, 25: 4, 26: 4, 27: 2, 39: 4, 43: 2, 49: 5, 50: 4, 58: 4, 64: 2, 69: 3, 81: 5, 82: 3, 86: 2, 96: 3, 97: 2, 100: 6, 108: 2, 109: 3, 110: 3, 114: 2, 115: 3, 116: 2, 118: 5, 119: 4, 120: 2, 121: 3, 122: 3, 123: 2, 124: 3, 128: 3, 129: 3, 130: 4, 132: 3, 145: 3, 147: 3, 151: 3, 152: 3, 154: 2, 161: 2, 162: 2, 165: 2, 168: 3, 169: 2, 172: 2, 180: 3, 184: 4, 187: 4, 188: 3, 191: 2, 194: 3, 202: 4, 203: 5, 207: 2, 217: 2, 218: 7, 222: 4, 224: 2, 227: 4, 229: 2, 234: 4, 243: 3, 244: 3, 245: 3, 248: 3, 250: 3, 258: 10, 262: 3, 263: 4, 264: 2, 267: 3, 270: 2, 272: 2, 273: 4, 287: 2, 289: 2, 291: 4, 299: 4, 300: 2, 304: 2, 309: 2, 315: 2, 320: 3, 323: 3, 327: 3, 328: 2, 330: 9, 335: 2, 341: 4, 342: 5, 347: 4, 348: 4, 350: 6, 351: 4, 352: 2, 353: 2, 358: 3, 365: 2, 371: 6, 372: 4, 384: 4, 385: 3, 386: 2, 387: 2, 392: 2, 393: 3, 396: 5, 397: 6, 398: 5, 402: 2} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 53 "As is the case for DetNet, a Layer 2 network node such as a bridge may need to identify the specific DetNet flow to which a packet belongs in order to provide the TSN/DetNet QoS for that packet. It also will likely need a CoS marking, such as the priority field of an IEEE Std 802.1Q VLAN tag, to give the packet proper service." "Major clean up and simplification as data plane drafts can be referred for MPLS related details . TSN over DetNet MPLS follows the concept of RFC3985 . Description focus on Edge Nodes procedures and functions . Text covers the Edge Nodes components : ( 1 ) TSN functions ( in NSP block ) ; ( 2 ) DetNet Service Proxy ; and ( 3 ) DetNet sub - layers . Approving from teelcon review" 3486514b01b74d57f031bcf660311de328a6e0dc 3486514b01b74d57f031bcf660311de328a6e0dc draft-ietf-detnet-tsn-vpn-over-mpls a491df768673d76ae7dee4c9bf1ea1456e6c537a1f1683368d8bc6869cd89bf0 ['e82e49a3c764c0ede490d9e8afe0d0a379ec1e2fb734910d7e42f179709f894c', '1b5276bed81725e3cab5fa8d2491ae7fc344c8638906d8e62ee7c31696edcb52', 'a6a4ee1a9211a2be0e24cf91f9742499a46567acff4c78f62b568b34e38c08de', '44d22f065218a14d5aa04288e7553c8a6d81bb222066c74ea38571bbe922a729', 'c757c3611002031d5ce1ac79d9984d826f392e6628a0657e045c348e52b7eda2', '8a105d9f9ffbf3e747a101e48de19122931cd0cce896dc27f57d16df9dbb75ac', 'a8ff14472a8fa48bacdc11d7089a9d1054c0a786f6152f510b5d4092c22e121f', 'e746630d4b45cf2b654a14e4daaa03ad634e33d92c29c489e3ef3fcd5620c311', '16375944152e6c3e73492437880fe39d7f0123a9292d062e8e9c7d317e4b878f', '42f5214bb177fd7faf01b7943e7f313a615b2490f9109d5cefa8b24101735c32', '5cc97b8f56cdeeb02e7c96183745dc53dd8ec3ec02424107d16eb438c2c9363c', 'a816e4d1392c9c85d398ee2c5116b5de849a9823bc552d322ac8725f7c9b859e', 'c7286f8983508fdd7d94ae798cdc3950cbf65865e905c00a76838a34eb79cf2c', '6924f7b3002e9f0dff9023b70bcc9d484e643c3a2d95b0d5c853c084ad3f68ab', '2d8fce3963de03360a5d98758067925a60474b5430fd8091fc72f3c50a9d38e5', '77f9aaec42bbb94079fae33b8c564cd7f64721106f615e11f22673310efaf01b', '09f8dc962fd9202d148a0b378c9a078ea850056b4b5c360c0914d4a1de6af454', '4826376633600232b766cb8a62d4054b0f5ea45d74878bcf57356e567088300c', '82b410c949db1d81b3f197adbaaba7b82b6e497600cd9883150af2bb815caa19', '0eb73f51f3b491bd6d969a05acf2b527e6e2f09a460cb88266513ab952bd3fc6', '1076eab6753435c114e8a720c951b03da6d4e1bbbf1290f8d58ad7f97a0b8c64', '4ccf918f8b8ae99a769d89e0868a12e4af1536487652436b6c188bc99e14fdb6', '2a5cef1e9c76b52b9b56c6c021a857b0fa757897b6e3c96cc8170d5b73ba8dd8', '07267e696bfbb5af98da5a8efe2b8cf604bc9ab1ce95e4766f017473bfcd0de1', '82f56d4694c2ec964de0a4413954f87ca621628c63d7425944baeff9aa4b6dad', '01e1da53fe2751e7196114efc63dd70d9babc69b4b73c03d4b7528dcc10c05d3', 'fb8f3ca7fafc9c173404ce7f909038443a6078a0c278cb024639410e33f49f88', '44e497e2df0461bad9215c57918855022435eb6e28266916161de3f7902bb352', '84f5bc0e0be5d04b515e8e49efb393e4aec7189222b92c0555cc1be542e74549', '3195c90c03cf6a438b5684cc93128c53f794660a661e2aa85d043ca5ac7060b9', 'b5bacf05f766e143f6de9484b0b5a2d9655d62854368373bd77974b94cb722e6', '2442b9072d522cde54849b40cab26789e4af909f1dd81391cd8c87023515a21c', 'b03d79d1a547b36a28c6cba78f57b8244a4855f6b31003de3e617a5b5eddc070', 'e386562e3156c91934ceb045df46d7e847bb9afcad2794bda59be854f988befc', 'cc980749457292da3a6a4a3ce669ad487409ce72e20857e80c75741c83af7f0a', '75db9ae91b710fcf1df3553b8f9653b12d014f74ba1ee8f931870d2433e163f1', '0e313215df9694bc26777ba4ac347cb8ef73f8475d2bfed664aab722833589ae', '1094721b24c22ff67539ffeabab887f87e538bdd9ebe50b0b369de138d326802', 'fb2b9389e1455c6d64ae19158396d767d88969013b14075bcfdcc764f610108c', 'ae3bdd3a81d96e4aaa02f7d597a2684146f3af75b743bde8e31c3cf5883707db', '1b8137b4c60774716e4a492efec48060d48abd7308563d8cc76edf32d98bd759', '09732023af932d8c578c8a7ead49feb80cdb5c629cee6add2e24fcd7999c0309', '75b7020073ec0c8cedf517f1b56d554e2a5cfdf89d204633c30b863c42ed6f5f', '4be1dfb90ea542d5d84c23c0ba29b91db2491a39973839ee646eeec25c71adb4', 'c98d52f719106d13b14f27abde81ce00305cbf62889690b72da3e3ddc0286c02', '056859e4aa430e2eb983e93f08bb85d9afe9aec44f0e73263cf072df70b7c475', '870147c2dad0a0dda2dd0a9f85ef83b3c4de9a304fdff6d9fa9ccc4bde9d70c0', '26e942b0353fee8f5ac0a2c2e26c9b695c50b35c501eeb4bff343b1648b5cebc', '036168e918418eb807bc3efd361a8e66067192564da41e30e076d22be0f87935', 'a491df768673d76ae7dee4c9bf1ea1456e6c537a1f1683368d8bc6869cd89bf0', 'f6a8cfceb19b4cd796512223b8afd103c4aee7052247ebea8b50f743e9aa27b6', 'd135518ad4230c8f57a3510b3ddea8a99e2355363c9419a27340734427050729', 'cbe90e272b6be7696d3b8c171500847d2b0ae497f6911d0f9d5d8481101c4c1f', '249c961ea29438959ea2204728df24964ec80b8cd91c657715c47014f5e5a462', '1920ebb46d0cee2d379ef48c15f8f6abd01e2a183f316da235e0c3b7515feade', '6d1573b42d5f89f89b26b32cbbd32ff41660e0e8c3b3091f1cb278a42651e049', 'ec6878825845c61b3049ad5dd168197c84938e7f6d4fc938670da2528cf86317', '9829b13faebde69c2279c38cd54d524aa31acfdcc1cfba7910b9d69caa42e0dd', '2755ae7cda161df0c24e1fa9f1c3308bc9ef81a599d859668490484290ca72f4', '09d9dcfc1716808b0c62e47a771ff4d39ba71f22c8640776e65624747a995626', '71dfcd074b80de90c4955890bdbe127d12b249ed764c7c4ca23dc81c74fde71d', '3c1afbb156ee2d672ca131c7c966bc6875374a95d927848bafcc5a158edf67bb'] A "as is the case for detnet, a layer 2 network node such as a bridge may need to identify the specific detnet flow to which a packet belongs in order to provide the tsn/detnet qos for that packet. it also will likely need a cos marking, such as the priority field of an ieee std 802.1q vlan tag, to give the packet proper service." {79: 1, 130: 1, 54: 1, 52: 1, 98: 1, 6: 1, 8: 1, 64: 1, 99: 1, 24: 1, 90: 2, 51: 2, 62: 4, 85: 4, 68: 3, 35: 2, 110: 2, 91: 4, 114: 2, 97: 2, 31: 2, 13: 2, 67: 2, 38: 3, 26: 2, 124: 2, 127: 2, 96: 2, 30: 3, 61: 4, 55: 2, 27: 3, 15: 2, 129: 2, 115: 2, 84: 2, 76: 5, 87: 2, 131: 4, 102: 2, 113: 4, 36: 2, 72: 3} {4: 1, 24: 1, 59: 1, 111: 1, 136: 1, 156: 1, 206: 1, 215: 1, 220: 1, 221: 1, 235: 1, 241: 1, 242: 1, 314: 1, 329: 1, 334: 1, 354: 1, 366: 1, 376: 1, 1: 8, 9: 4, 10: 2, 15: 2, 25: 4, 26: 4, 27: 2, 39: 4, 43: 2, 49: 5, 50: 4, 58: 4, 64: 2, 69: 3, 81: 5, 82: 3, 86: 2, 96: 3, 97: 2, 100: 6, 108: 2, 109: 3, 110: 3, 114: 2, 115: 3, 116: 2, 118: 5, 119: 4, 120: 2, 121: 3, 122: 3, 123: 2, 124: 3, 128: 3, 129: 3, 130: 4, 132: 3, 145: 3, 147: 3, 151: 3, 152: 3, 154: 2, 161: 2, 162: 2, 165: 2, 168: 3, 169: 2, 172: 2, 180: 3, 184: 4, 187: 4, 188: 3, 191: 2, 194: 3, 202: 4, 203: 5, 207: 2, 217: 2, 218: 7, 222: 4, 224: 2, 227: 4, 229: 2, 234: 4, 243: 3, 244: 3, 245: 3, 248: 3, 250: 3, 258: 10, 262: 3, 263: 4, 264: 2, 267: 3, 270: 2, 272: 2, 273: 4, 287: 2, 289: 2, 291: 4, 299: 4, 300: 2, 304: 2, 309: 2, 315: 2, 320: 3, 323: 3, 327: 3, 328: 2, 330: 9, 335: 2, 341: 4, 342: 5, 347: 4, 348: 4, 350: 6, 351: 4, 352: 2, 353: 2, 358: 3, 365: 2, 371: 6, 372: 4, 384: 4, 385: 3, 386: 2, 387: 2, 392: 2, 393: 3, 396: 5, 397: 6, 398: 5, 402: 2} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 53 "Although the flow identification methods described in IEEE8021CB are flexible, and in fact, include IP 5-tuple identification methods, the baseline TSN standards assume that every Ethernet frame belonging to a TSN stream (i.e. DetNet flow) carries a multicast destination MAC address that is unique to that flow within the bridged network over which it is carried. Furthermore, IEEE8021CB describes three methods by which a packet sequence number can be encoded in an Ethernet frame." "Major clean up and simplification as data plane drafts can be referred for MPLS related details . TSN over DetNet MPLS follows the concept of RFC3985 . Description focus on Edge Nodes procedures and functions . Text covers the Edge Nodes components : ( 1 ) TSN functions ( in NSP block ) ; ( 2 ) DetNet Service Proxy ; and ( 3 ) DetNet sub - layers . Approving from teelcon review" 3486514b01b74d57f031bcf660311de328a6e0dc 3486514b01b74d57f031bcf660311de328a6e0dc draft-ietf-detnet-tsn-vpn-over-mpls 1094721b24c22ff67539ffeabab887f87e538bdd9ebe50b0b369de138d326802 ['e82e49a3c764c0ede490d9e8afe0d0a379ec1e2fb734910d7e42f179709f894c', '1b5276bed81725e3cab5fa8d2491ae7fc344c8638906d8e62ee7c31696edcb52', 'a6a4ee1a9211a2be0e24cf91f9742499a46567acff4c78f62b568b34e38c08de', '44d22f065218a14d5aa04288e7553c8a6d81bb222066c74ea38571bbe922a729', 'c757c3611002031d5ce1ac79d9984d826f392e6628a0657e045c348e52b7eda2', '8a105d9f9ffbf3e747a101e48de19122931cd0cce896dc27f57d16df9dbb75ac', 'a8ff14472a8fa48bacdc11d7089a9d1054c0a786f6152f510b5d4092c22e121f', 'e746630d4b45cf2b654a14e4daaa03ad634e33d92c29c489e3ef3fcd5620c311', '16375944152e6c3e73492437880fe39d7f0123a9292d062e8e9c7d317e4b878f', '42f5214bb177fd7faf01b7943e7f313a615b2490f9109d5cefa8b24101735c32', '5cc97b8f56cdeeb02e7c96183745dc53dd8ec3ec02424107d16eb438c2c9363c', 'a816e4d1392c9c85d398ee2c5116b5de849a9823bc552d322ac8725f7c9b859e', 'c7286f8983508fdd7d94ae798cdc3950cbf65865e905c00a76838a34eb79cf2c', '6924f7b3002e9f0dff9023b70bcc9d484e643c3a2d95b0d5c853c084ad3f68ab', '2d8fce3963de03360a5d98758067925a60474b5430fd8091fc72f3c50a9d38e5', '77f9aaec42bbb94079fae33b8c564cd7f64721106f615e11f22673310efaf01b', '09f8dc962fd9202d148a0b378c9a078ea850056b4b5c360c0914d4a1de6af454', '4826376633600232b766cb8a62d4054b0f5ea45d74878bcf57356e567088300c', '82b410c949db1d81b3f197adbaaba7b82b6e497600cd9883150af2bb815caa19', '0eb73f51f3b491bd6d969a05acf2b527e6e2f09a460cb88266513ab952bd3fc6', '1076eab6753435c114e8a720c951b03da6d4e1bbbf1290f8d58ad7f97a0b8c64', '4ccf918f8b8ae99a769d89e0868a12e4af1536487652436b6c188bc99e14fdb6', '2a5cef1e9c76b52b9b56c6c021a857b0fa757897b6e3c96cc8170d5b73ba8dd8', '07267e696bfbb5af98da5a8efe2b8cf604bc9ab1ce95e4766f017473bfcd0de1', '82f56d4694c2ec964de0a4413954f87ca621628c63d7425944baeff9aa4b6dad', '01e1da53fe2751e7196114efc63dd70d9babc69b4b73c03d4b7528dcc10c05d3', 'fb8f3ca7fafc9c173404ce7f909038443a6078a0c278cb024639410e33f49f88', '44e497e2df0461bad9215c57918855022435eb6e28266916161de3f7902bb352', '84f5bc0e0be5d04b515e8e49efb393e4aec7189222b92c0555cc1be542e74549', '3195c90c03cf6a438b5684cc93128c53f794660a661e2aa85d043ca5ac7060b9', 'b5bacf05f766e143f6de9484b0b5a2d9655d62854368373bd77974b94cb722e6', '2442b9072d522cde54849b40cab26789e4af909f1dd81391cd8c87023515a21c', 'b03d79d1a547b36a28c6cba78f57b8244a4855f6b31003de3e617a5b5eddc070', 'e386562e3156c91934ceb045df46d7e847bb9afcad2794bda59be854f988befc', 'cc980749457292da3a6a4a3ce669ad487409ce72e20857e80c75741c83af7f0a', '75db9ae91b710fcf1df3553b8f9653b12d014f74ba1ee8f931870d2433e163f1', '0e313215df9694bc26777ba4ac347cb8ef73f8475d2bfed664aab722833589ae', '1094721b24c22ff67539ffeabab887f87e538bdd9ebe50b0b369de138d326802', 'fb2b9389e1455c6d64ae19158396d767d88969013b14075bcfdcc764f610108c', 'ae3bdd3a81d96e4aaa02f7d597a2684146f3af75b743bde8e31c3cf5883707db', '1b8137b4c60774716e4a492efec48060d48abd7308563d8cc76edf32d98bd759', '09732023af932d8c578c8a7ead49feb80cdb5c629cee6add2e24fcd7999c0309', '75b7020073ec0c8cedf517f1b56d554e2a5cfdf89d204633c30b863c42ed6f5f', '4be1dfb90ea542d5d84c23c0ba29b91db2491a39973839ee646eeec25c71adb4', 'c98d52f719106d13b14f27abde81ce00305cbf62889690b72da3e3ddc0286c02', '056859e4aa430e2eb983e93f08bb85d9afe9aec44f0e73263cf072df70b7c475', '870147c2dad0a0dda2dd0a9f85ef83b3c4de9a304fdff6d9fa9ccc4bde9d70c0', '26e942b0353fee8f5ac0a2c2e26c9b695c50b35c501eeb4bff343b1648b5cebc', '036168e918418eb807bc3efd361a8e66067192564da41e30e076d22be0f87935', 'a491df768673d76ae7dee4c9bf1ea1456e6c537a1f1683368d8bc6869cd89bf0', 'f6a8cfceb19b4cd796512223b8afd103c4aee7052247ebea8b50f743e9aa27b6', 'd135518ad4230c8f57a3510b3ddea8a99e2355363c9419a27340734427050729', 'cbe90e272b6be7696d3b8c171500847d2b0ae497f6911d0f9d5d8481101c4c1f', '249c961ea29438959ea2204728df24964ec80b8cd91c657715c47014f5e5a462', '1920ebb46d0cee2d379ef48c15f8f6abd01e2a183f316da235e0c3b7515feade', '6d1573b42d5f89f89b26b32cbbd32ff41660e0e8c3b3091f1cb278a42651e049', 'ec6878825845c61b3049ad5dd168197c84938e7f6d4fc938670da2528cf86317', '9829b13faebde69c2279c38cd54d524aa31acfdcc1cfba7910b9d69caa42e0dd', '2755ae7cda161df0c24e1fa9f1c3308bc9ef81a599d859668490484290ca72f4', '09d9dcfc1716808b0c62e47a771ff4d39ba71f22c8640776e65624747a995626', '71dfcd074b80de90c4955890bdbe127d12b249ed764c7c4ca23dc81c74fde71d', '3c1afbb156ee2d672ca131c7c966bc6875374a95d927848bafcc5a158edf67bb'] A "although the flow identification methods described in ieee8021cb are flexible, and in fact, include ip 5-tuple identification methods, the baseline tsn standards assume that every ethernet frame belonging to a tsn stream (i.e. detnet flow) carries a multicast destination mac address that is unique to that flow within the bridged network over which it is carried. furthermore, ieee8021cb describes three methods by which a packet sequence number can be encoded in an ethernet frame." {79: 1, 130: 1, 54: 1, 52: 1, 98: 1, 6: 1, 8: 1, 64: 1, 99: 1, 24: 1, 90: 2, 51: 2, 62: 4, 85: 4, 68: 3, 35: 2, 110: 2, 91: 4, 114: 2, 97: 2, 31: 2, 13: 2, 67: 2, 38: 3, 26: 2, 124: 2, 127: 2, 96: 2, 30: 3, 61: 4, 55: 2, 27: 3, 15: 2, 129: 2, 115: 2, 84: 2, 76: 5, 87: 2, 131: 4, 102: 2, 113: 4, 36: 2, 72: 3} {4: 1, 24: 1, 59: 1, 111: 1, 136: 1, 156: 1, 206: 1, 215: 1, 220: 1, 221: 1, 235: 1, 241: 1, 242: 1, 314: 1, 329: 1, 334: 1, 354: 1, 366: 1, 376: 1, 1: 8, 9: 4, 10: 2, 15: 2, 25: 4, 26: 4, 27: 2, 39: 4, 43: 2, 49: 5, 50: 4, 58: 4, 64: 2, 69: 3, 81: 5, 82: 3, 86: 2, 96: 3, 97: 2, 100: 6, 108: 2, 109: 3, 110: 3, 114: 2, 115: 3, 116: 2, 118: 5, 119: 4, 120: 2, 121: 3, 122: 3, 123: 2, 124: 3, 128: 3, 129: 3, 130: 4, 132: 3, 145: 3, 147: 3, 151: 3, 152: 3, 154: 2, 161: 2, 162: 2, 165: 2, 168: 3, 169: 2, 172: 2, 180: 3, 184: 4, 187: 4, 188: 3, 191: 2, 194: 3, 202: 4, 203: 5, 207: 2, 217: 2, 218: 7, 222: 4, 224: 2, 227: 4, 229: 2, 234: 4, 243: 3, 244: 3, 245: 3, 248: 3, 250: 3, 258: 10, 262: 3, 263: 4, 264: 2, 267: 3, 270: 2, 272: 2, 273: 4, 287: 2, 289: 2, 291: 4, 299: 4, 300: 2, 304: 2, 309: 2, 315: 2, 320: 3, 323: 3, 327: 3, 328: 2, 330: 9, 335: 2, 341: 4, 342: 5, 347: 4, 348: 4, 350: 6, 351: 4, 352: 2, 353: 2, 358: 3, 365: 2, 371: 6, 372: 4, 384: 4, 385: 3, 386: 2, 387: 2, 392: 2, 393: 3, 396: 5, 397: 6, 398: 5, 402: 2} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 53 "Ensuring that the proper Ethernet VLAN tag priority and destination MAC address are used on a DetNet/TSN packet may require further clarification of the customary L2/L3 transformations carried out by routers and edge label switches. Edge nodes may also have to move sequence number fields among Layer 2, PW, and IP encapsulations." "Major clean up and simplification as data plane drafts can be referred for MPLS related details . TSN over DetNet MPLS follows the concept of RFC3985 . Description focus on Edge Nodes procedures and functions . Text covers the Edge Nodes components : ( 1 ) TSN functions ( in NSP block ) ; ( 2 ) DetNet Service Proxy ; and ( 3 ) DetNet sub - layers . Approving from teelcon review" 3486514b01b74d57f031bcf660311de328a6e0dc 3486514b01b74d57f031bcf660311de328a6e0dc draft-ietf-detnet-tsn-vpn-over-mpls b5bacf05f766e143f6de9484b0b5a2d9655d62854368373bd77974b94cb722e6 ['e82e49a3c764c0ede490d9e8afe0d0a379ec1e2fb734910d7e42f179709f894c', '1b5276bed81725e3cab5fa8d2491ae7fc344c8638906d8e62ee7c31696edcb52', 'a6a4ee1a9211a2be0e24cf91f9742499a46567acff4c78f62b568b34e38c08de', '44d22f065218a14d5aa04288e7553c8a6d81bb222066c74ea38571bbe922a729', 'c757c3611002031d5ce1ac79d9984d826f392e6628a0657e045c348e52b7eda2', '8a105d9f9ffbf3e747a101e48de19122931cd0cce896dc27f57d16df9dbb75ac', 'a8ff14472a8fa48bacdc11d7089a9d1054c0a786f6152f510b5d4092c22e121f', 'e746630d4b45cf2b654a14e4daaa03ad634e33d92c29c489e3ef3fcd5620c311', '16375944152e6c3e73492437880fe39d7f0123a9292d062e8e9c7d317e4b878f', '42f5214bb177fd7faf01b7943e7f313a615b2490f9109d5cefa8b24101735c32', '5cc97b8f56cdeeb02e7c96183745dc53dd8ec3ec02424107d16eb438c2c9363c', 'a816e4d1392c9c85d398ee2c5116b5de849a9823bc552d322ac8725f7c9b859e', 'c7286f8983508fdd7d94ae798cdc3950cbf65865e905c00a76838a34eb79cf2c', '6924f7b3002e9f0dff9023b70bcc9d484e643c3a2d95b0d5c853c084ad3f68ab', '2d8fce3963de03360a5d98758067925a60474b5430fd8091fc72f3c50a9d38e5', '77f9aaec42bbb94079fae33b8c564cd7f64721106f615e11f22673310efaf01b', '09f8dc962fd9202d148a0b378c9a078ea850056b4b5c360c0914d4a1de6af454', '4826376633600232b766cb8a62d4054b0f5ea45d74878bcf57356e567088300c', '82b410c949db1d81b3f197adbaaba7b82b6e497600cd9883150af2bb815caa19', '0eb73f51f3b491bd6d969a05acf2b527e6e2f09a460cb88266513ab952bd3fc6', '1076eab6753435c114e8a720c951b03da6d4e1bbbf1290f8d58ad7f97a0b8c64', '4ccf918f8b8ae99a769d89e0868a12e4af1536487652436b6c188bc99e14fdb6', '2a5cef1e9c76b52b9b56c6c021a857b0fa757897b6e3c96cc8170d5b73ba8dd8', '07267e696bfbb5af98da5a8efe2b8cf604bc9ab1ce95e4766f017473bfcd0de1', '82f56d4694c2ec964de0a4413954f87ca621628c63d7425944baeff9aa4b6dad', '01e1da53fe2751e7196114efc63dd70d9babc69b4b73c03d4b7528dcc10c05d3', 'fb8f3ca7fafc9c173404ce7f909038443a6078a0c278cb024639410e33f49f88', '44e497e2df0461bad9215c57918855022435eb6e28266916161de3f7902bb352', '84f5bc0e0be5d04b515e8e49efb393e4aec7189222b92c0555cc1be542e74549', '3195c90c03cf6a438b5684cc93128c53f794660a661e2aa85d043ca5ac7060b9', 'b5bacf05f766e143f6de9484b0b5a2d9655d62854368373bd77974b94cb722e6', '2442b9072d522cde54849b40cab26789e4af909f1dd81391cd8c87023515a21c', 'b03d79d1a547b36a28c6cba78f57b8244a4855f6b31003de3e617a5b5eddc070', 'e386562e3156c91934ceb045df46d7e847bb9afcad2794bda59be854f988befc', 'cc980749457292da3a6a4a3ce669ad487409ce72e20857e80c75741c83af7f0a', '75db9ae91b710fcf1df3553b8f9653b12d014f74ba1ee8f931870d2433e163f1', '0e313215df9694bc26777ba4ac347cb8ef73f8475d2bfed664aab722833589ae', '1094721b24c22ff67539ffeabab887f87e538bdd9ebe50b0b369de138d326802', 'fb2b9389e1455c6d64ae19158396d767d88969013b14075bcfdcc764f610108c', 'ae3bdd3a81d96e4aaa02f7d597a2684146f3af75b743bde8e31c3cf5883707db', '1b8137b4c60774716e4a492efec48060d48abd7308563d8cc76edf32d98bd759', '09732023af932d8c578c8a7ead49feb80cdb5c629cee6add2e24fcd7999c0309', '75b7020073ec0c8cedf517f1b56d554e2a5cfdf89d204633c30b863c42ed6f5f', '4be1dfb90ea542d5d84c23c0ba29b91db2491a39973839ee646eeec25c71adb4', 'c98d52f719106d13b14f27abde81ce00305cbf62889690b72da3e3ddc0286c02', '056859e4aa430e2eb983e93f08bb85d9afe9aec44f0e73263cf072df70b7c475', '870147c2dad0a0dda2dd0a9f85ef83b3c4de9a304fdff6d9fa9ccc4bde9d70c0', '26e942b0353fee8f5ac0a2c2e26c9b695c50b35c501eeb4bff343b1648b5cebc', '036168e918418eb807bc3efd361a8e66067192564da41e30e076d22be0f87935', 'a491df768673d76ae7dee4c9bf1ea1456e6c537a1f1683368d8bc6869cd89bf0', 'f6a8cfceb19b4cd796512223b8afd103c4aee7052247ebea8b50f743e9aa27b6', 'd135518ad4230c8f57a3510b3ddea8a99e2355363c9419a27340734427050729', 'cbe90e272b6be7696d3b8c171500847d2b0ae497f6911d0f9d5d8481101c4c1f', '249c961ea29438959ea2204728df24964ec80b8cd91c657715c47014f5e5a462', '1920ebb46d0cee2d379ef48c15f8f6abd01e2a183f316da235e0c3b7515feade', '6d1573b42d5f89f89b26b32cbbd32ff41660e0e8c3b3091f1cb278a42651e049', 'ec6878825845c61b3049ad5dd168197c84938e7f6d4fc938670da2528cf86317', '9829b13faebde69c2279c38cd54d524aa31acfdcc1cfba7910b9d69caa42e0dd', '2755ae7cda161df0c24e1fa9f1c3308bc9ef81a599d859668490484290ca72f4', '09d9dcfc1716808b0c62e47a771ff4d39ba71f22c8640776e65624747a995626', '71dfcd074b80de90c4955890bdbe127d12b249ed764c7c4ca23dc81c74fde71d', '3c1afbb156ee2d672ca131c7c966bc6875374a95d927848bafcc5a158edf67bb'] A "ensuring that the proper ethernet vlan tag priority and destination mac address are used on a detnet/tsn packet may require further clarification of the customary l2/l3 transformations carried out by routers and edge label switches. edge nodes may also have to move sequence number fields among layer 2, pw, and ip encapsulations." {79: 1, 130: 1, 54: 1, 52: 1, 98: 1, 6: 1, 8: 1, 64: 1, 99: 1, 24: 1, 90: 2, 51: 2, 62: 4, 85: 4, 68: 3, 35: 2, 110: 2, 91: 4, 114: 2, 97: 2, 31: 2, 13: 2, 67: 2, 38: 3, 26: 2, 124: 2, 127: 2, 96: 2, 30: 3, 61: 4, 55: 2, 27: 3, 15: 2, 129: 2, 115: 2, 84: 2, 76: 5, 87: 2, 131: 4, 102: 2, 113: 4, 36: 2, 72: 3} {4: 1, 24: 1, 59: 1, 111: 1, 136: 1, 156: 1, 206: 1, 215: 1, 220: 1, 221: 1, 235: 1, 241: 1, 242: 1, 314: 1, 329: 1, 334: 1, 354: 1, 366: 1, 376: 1, 1: 8, 9: 4, 10: 2, 15: 2, 25: 4, 26: 4, 27: 2, 39: 4, 43: 2, 49: 5, 50: 4, 58: 4, 64: 2, 69: 3, 81: 5, 82: 3, 86: 2, 96: 3, 97: 2, 100: 6, 108: 2, 109: 3, 110: 3, 114: 2, 115: 3, 116: 2, 118: 5, 119: 4, 120: 2, 121: 3, 122: 3, 123: 2, 124: 3, 128: 3, 129: 3, 130: 4, 132: 3, 145: 3, 147: 3, 151: 3, 152: 3, 154: 2, 161: 2, 162: 2, 165: 2, 168: 3, 169: 2, 172: 2, 180: 3, 184: 4, 187: 4, 188: 3, 191: 2, 194: 3, 202: 4, 203: 5, 207: 2, 217: 2, 218: 7, 222: 4, 224: 2, 227: 4, 229: 2, 234: 4, 243: 3, 244: 3, 245: 3, 248: 3, 250: 3, 258: 10, 262: 3, 263: 4, 264: 2, 267: 3, 270: 2, 272: 2, 273: 4, 287: 2, 289: 2, 291: 4, 299: 4, 300: 2, 304: 2, 309: 2, 315: 2, 320: 3, 323: 3, 327: 3, 328: 2, 330: 9, 335: 2, 341: 4, 342: 5, 347: 4, 348: 4, 350: 6, 351: 4, 352: 2, 353: 2, 358: 3, 365: 2, 371: 6, 372: 4, 384: 4, 385: 3, 386: 2, 387: 2, 392: 2, 393: 3, 396: 5, 397: 6, 398: 5, 402: 2} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 53 "The security considerations of DetNet in general are discussed in I- D.ietf-detnet-architecture and I-D.sdt-detnet-security. Other security considerations will be added in a future version of this draft." "Major clean up and simplification as data plane drafts can be referred for MPLS related details . TSN over DetNet MPLS follows the concept of RFC3985 . Description focus on Edge Nodes procedures and functions . Text covers the Edge Nodes components : ( 1 ) TSN functions ( in NSP block ) ; ( 2 ) DetNet Service Proxy ; and ( 3 ) DetNet sub - layers . Approving from teelcon review" 3486514b01b74d57f031bcf660311de328a6e0dc 3486514b01b74d57f031bcf660311de328a6e0dc draft-ietf-detnet-tsn-vpn-over-mpls 42f5214bb177fd7faf01b7943e7f313a615b2490f9109d5cefa8b24101735c32 ['e82e49a3c764c0ede490d9e8afe0d0a379ec1e2fb734910d7e42f179709f894c', '1b5276bed81725e3cab5fa8d2491ae7fc344c8638906d8e62ee7c31696edcb52', 'a6a4ee1a9211a2be0e24cf91f9742499a46567acff4c78f62b568b34e38c08de', '44d22f065218a14d5aa04288e7553c8a6d81bb222066c74ea38571bbe922a729', 'c757c3611002031d5ce1ac79d9984d826f392e6628a0657e045c348e52b7eda2', '8a105d9f9ffbf3e747a101e48de19122931cd0cce896dc27f57d16df9dbb75ac', 'a8ff14472a8fa48bacdc11d7089a9d1054c0a786f6152f510b5d4092c22e121f', 'e746630d4b45cf2b654a14e4daaa03ad634e33d92c29c489e3ef3fcd5620c311', '16375944152e6c3e73492437880fe39d7f0123a9292d062e8e9c7d317e4b878f', '42f5214bb177fd7faf01b7943e7f313a615b2490f9109d5cefa8b24101735c32', '5cc97b8f56cdeeb02e7c96183745dc53dd8ec3ec02424107d16eb438c2c9363c', 'a816e4d1392c9c85d398ee2c5116b5de849a9823bc552d322ac8725f7c9b859e', 'c7286f8983508fdd7d94ae798cdc3950cbf65865e905c00a76838a34eb79cf2c', '6924f7b3002e9f0dff9023b70bcc9d484e643c3a2d95b0d5c853c084ad3f68ab', '2d8fce3963de03360a5d98758067925a60474b5430fd8091fc72f3c50a9d38e5', '77f9aaec42bbb94079fae33b8c564cd7f64721106f615e11f22673310efaf01b', '09f8dc962fd9202d148a0b378c9a078ea850056b4b5c360c0914d4a1de6af454', '4826376633600232b766cb8a62d4054b0f5ea45d74878bcf57356e567088300c', '82b410c949db1d81b3f197adbaaba7b82b6e497600cd9883150af2bb815caa19', '0eb73f51f3b491bd6d969a05acf2b527e6e2f09a460cb88266513ab952bd3fc6', '1076eab6753435c114e8a720c951b03da6d4e1bbbf1290f8d58ad7f97a0b8c64', '4ccf918f8b8ae99a769d89e0868a12e4af1536487652436b6c188bc99e14fdb6', '2a5cef1e9c76b52b9b56c6c021a857b0fa757897b6e3c96cc8170d5b73ba8dd8', '07267e696bfbb5af98da5a8efe2b8cf604bc9ab1ce95e4766f017473bfcd0de1', '82f56d4694c2ec964de0a4413954f87ca621628c63d7425944baeff9aa4b6dad', '01e1da53fe2751e7196114efc63dd70d9babc69b4b73c03d4b7528dcc10c05d3', 'fb8f3ca7fafc9c173404ce7f909038443a6078a0c278cb024639410e33f49f88', '44e497e2df0461bad9215c57918855022435eb6e28266916161de3f7902bb352', '84f5bc0e0be5d04b515e8e49efb393e4aec7189222b92c0555cc1be542e74549', '3195c90c03cf6a438b5684cc93128c53f794660a661e2aa85d043ca5ac7060b9', 'b5bacf05f766e143f6de9484b0b5a2d9655d62854368373bd77974b94cb722e6', '2442b9072d522cde54849b40cab26789e4af909f1dd81391cd8c87023515a21c', 'b03d79d1a547b36a28c6cba78f57b8244a4855f6b31003de3e617a5b5eddc070', 'e386562e3156c91934ceb045df46d7e847bb9afcad2794bda59be854f988befc', 'cc980749457292da3a6a4a3ce669ad487409ce72e20857e80c75741c83af7f0a', '75db9ae91b710fcf1df3553b8f9653b12d014f74ba1ee8f931870d2433e163f1', '0e313215df9694bc26777ba4ac347cb8ef73f8475d2bfed664aab722833589ae', '1094721b24c22ff67539ffeabab887f87e538bdd9ebe50b0b369de138d326802', 'fb2b9389e1455c6d64ae19158396d767d88969013b14075bcfdcc764f610108c', 'ae3bdd3a81d96e4aaa02f7d597a2684146f3af75b743bde8e31c3cf5883707db', '1b8137b4c60774716e4a492efec48060d48abd7308563d8cc76edf32d98bd759', '09732023af932d8c578c8a7ead49feb80cdb5c629cee6add2e24fcd7999c0309', '75b7020073ec0c8cedf517f1b56d554e2a5cfdf89d204633c30b863c42ed6f5f', '4be1dfb90ea542d5d84c23c0ba29b91db2491a39973839ee646eeec25c71adb4', 'c98d52f719106d13b14f27abde81ce00305cbf62889690b72da3e3ddc0286c02', '056859e4aa430e2eb983e93f08bb85d9afe9aec44f0e73263cf072df70b7c475', '870147c2dad0a0dda2dd0a9f85ef83b3c4de9a304fdff6d9fa9ccc4bde9d70c0', '26e942b0353fee8f5ac0a2c2e26c9b695c50b35c501eeb4bff343b1648b5cebc', '036168e918418eb807bc3efd361a8e66067192564da41e30e076d22be0f87935', 'a491df768673d76ae7dee4c9bf1ea1456e6c537a1f1683368d8bc6869cd89bf0', 'f6a8cfceb19b4cd796512223b8afd103c4aee7052247ebea8b50f743e9aa27b6', 'd135518ad4230c8f57a3510b3ddea8a99e2355363c9419a27340734427050729', 'cbe90e272b6be7696d3b8c171500847d2b0ae497f6911d0f9d5d8481101c4c1f', '249c961ea29438959ea2204728df24964ec80b8cd91c657715c47014f5e5a462', '1920ebb46d0cee2d379ef48c15f8f6abd01e2a183f316da235e0c3b7515feade', '6d1573b42d5f89f89b26b32cbbd32ff41660e0e8c3b3091f1cb278a42651e049', 'ec6878825845c61b3049ad5dd168197c84938e7f6d4fc938670da2528cf86317', '9829b13faebde69c2279c38cd54d524aa31acfdcc1cfba7910b9d69caa42e0dd', '2755ae7cda161df0c24e1fa9f1c3308bc9ef81a599d859668490484290ca72f4', '09d9dcfc1716808b0c62e47a771ff4d39ba71f22c8640776e65624747a995626', '71dfcd074b80de90c4955890bdbe127d12b249ed764c7c4ca23dc81c74fde71d', '3c1afbb156ee2d672ca131c7c966bc6875374a95d927848bafcc5a158edf67bb'] A "the security considerations of detnet in general are discussed in i- d.ietf-detnet-architecture and i-d.sdt-detnet-security. other security considerations will be added in a future version of this draft." {79: 1, 130: 1, 54: 1, 52: 1, 98: 1, 6: 1, 8: 1, 64: 1, 99: 1, 24: 1, 90: 2, 51: 2, 62: 4, 85: 4, 68: 3, 35: 2, 110: 2, 91: 4, 114: 2, 97: 2, 31: 2, 13: 2, 67: 2, 38: 3, 26: 2, 124: 2, 127: 2, 96: 2, 30: 3, 61: 4, 55: 2, 27: 3, 15: 2, 129: 2, 115: 2, 84: 2, 76: 5, 87: 2, 131: 4, 102: 2, 113: 4, 36: 2, 72: 3} {4: 1, 24: 1, 59: 1, 111: 1, 136: 1, 156: 1, 206: 1, 215: 1, 220: 1, 221: 1, 235: 1, 241: 1, 242: 1, 314: 1, 329: 1, 334: 1, 354: 1, 366: 1, 376: 1, 1: 8, 9: 4, 10: 2, 15: 2, 25: 4, 26: 4, 27: 2, 39: 4, 43: 2, 49: 5, 50: 4, 58: 4, 64: 2, 69: 3, 81: 5, 82: 3, 86: 2, 96: 3, 97: 2, 100: 6, 108: 2, 109: 3, 110: 3, 114: 2, 115: 3, 116: 2, 118: 5, 119: 4, 120: 2, 121: 3, 122: 3, 123: 2, 124: 3, 128: 3, 129: 3, 130: 4, 132: 3, 145: 3, 147: 3, 151: 3, 152: 3, 154: 2, 161: 2, 162: 2, 165: 2, 168: 3, 169: 2, 172: 2, 180: 3, 184: 4, 187: 4, 188: 3, 191: 2, 194: 3, 202: 4, 203: 5, 207: 2, 217: 2, 218: 7, 222: 4, 224: 2, 227: 4, 229: 2, 234: 4, 243: 3, 244: 3, 245: 3, 248: 3, 250: 3, 258: 10, 262: 3, 263: 4, 264: 2, 267: 3, 270: 2, 272: 2, 273: 4, 287: 2, 289: 2, 291: 4, 299: 4, 300: 2, 304: 2, 309: 2, 315: 2, 320: 3, 323: 3, 327: 3, 328: 2, 330: 9, 335: 2, 341: 4, 342: 5, 347: 4, 348: 4, 350: 6, 351: 4, 352: 2, 353: 2, 358: 3, 365: 2, 371: 6, 372: 4, 384: 4, 385: 3, 386: 2, 387: 2, 392: 2, 393: 3, 396: 5, 397: 6, 398: 5, 402: 2} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 53 "to map TSN Streams into DetNet flows. The specific of this operation are discussed later in this document." "Major clean up and simplification as data plane drafts can be referred for MPLS related details . TSN over DetNet MPLS follows the concept of RFC3985 . Description focus on Edge Nodes procedures and functions . Text covers the Edge Nodes components : ( 1 ) TSN functions ( in NSP block ) ; ( 2 ) DetNet Service Proxy ; and ( 3 ) DetNet sub - layers . Approving from teelcon review" 3486514b01b74d57f031bcf660311de328a6e0dc 3486514b01b74d57f031bcf660311de328a6e0dc draft-ietf-detnet-tsn-vpn-over-mpls 4ccf918f8b8ae99a769d89e0868a12e4af1536487652436b6c188bc99e14fdb6 ['e82e49a3c764c0ede490d9e8afe0d0a379ec1e2fb734910d7e42f179709f894c', '1b5276bed81725e3cab5fa8d2491ae7fc344c8638906d8e62ee7c31696edcb52', 'a6a4ee1a9211a2be0e24cf91f9742499a46567acff4c78f62b568b34e38c08de', '44d22f065218a14d5aa04288e7553c8a6d81bb222066c74ea38571bbe922a729', 'c757c3611002031d5ce1ac79d9984d826f392e6628a0657e045c348e52b7eda2', '8a105d9f9ffbf3e747a101e48de19122931cd0cce896dc27f57d16df9dbb75ac', 'a8ff14472a8fa48bacdc11d7089a9d1054c0a786f6152f510b5d4092c22e121f', 'e746630d4b45cf2b654a14e4daaa03ad634e33d92c29c489e3ef3fcd5620c311', '16375944152e6c3e73492437880fe39d7f0123a9292d062e8e9c7d317e4b878f', '42f5214bb177fd7faf01b7943e7f313a615b2490f9109d5cefa8b24101735c32', '5cc97b8f56cdeeb02e7c96183745dc53dd8ec3ec02424107d16eb438c2c9363c', 'a816e4d1392c9c85d398ee2c5116b5de849a9823bc552d322ac8725f7c9b859e', 'c7286f8983508fdd7d94ae798cdc3950cbf65865e905c00a76838a34eb79cf2c', '6924f7b3002e9f0dff9023b70bcc9d484e643c3a2d95b0d5c853c084ad3f68ab', '2d8fce3963de03360a5d98758067925a60474b5430fd8091fc72f3c50a9d38e5', '77f9aaec42bbb94079fae33b8c564cd7f64721106f615e11f22673310efaf01b', '09f8dc962fd9202d148a0b378c9a078ea850056b4b5c360c0914d4a1de6af454', '4826376633600232b766cb8a62d4054b0f5ea45d74878bcf57356e567088300c', '82b410c949db1d81b3f197adbaaba7b82b6e497600cd9883150af2bb815caa19', '0eb73f51f3b491bd6d969a05acf2b527e6e2f09a460cb88266513ab952bd3fc6', '1076eab6753435c114e8a720c951b03da6d4e1bbbf1290f8d58ad7f97a0b8c64', '4ccf918f8b8ae99a769d89e0868a12e4af1536487652436b6c188bc99e14fdb6', '2a5cef1e9c76b52b9b56c6c021a857b0fa757897b6e3c96cc8170d5b73ba8dd8', '07267e696bfbb5af98da5a8efe2b8cf604bc9ab1ce95e4766f017473bfcd0de1', '82f56d4694c2ec964de0a4413954f87ca621628c63d7425944baeff9aa4b6dad', '01e1da53fe2751e7196114efc63dd70d9babc69b4b73c03d4b7528dcc10c05d3', 'fb8f3ca7fafc9c173404ce7f909038443a6078a0c278cb024639410e33f49f88', '44e497e2df0461bad9215c57918855022435eb6e28266916161de3f7902bb352', '84f5bc0e0be5d04b515e8e49efb393e4aec7189222b92c0555cc1be542e74549', '3195c90c03cf6a438b5684cc93128c53f794660a661e2aa85d043ca5ac7060b9', 'b5bacf05f766e143f6de9484b0b5a2d9655d62854368373bd77974b94cb722e6', '2442b9072d522cde54849b40cab26789e4af909f1dd81391cd8c87023515a21c', 'b03d79d1a547b36a28c6cba78f57b8244a4855f6b31003de3e617a5b5eddc070', 'e386562e3156c91934ceb045df46d7e847bb9afcad2794bda59be854f988befc', 'cc980749457292da3a6a4a3ce669ad487409ce72e20857e80c75741c83af7f0a', '75db9ae91b710fcf1df3553b8f9653b12d014f74ba1ee8f931870d2433e163f1', '0e313215df9694bc26777ba4ac347cb8ef73f8475d2bfed664aab722833589ae', '1094721b24c22ff67539ffeabab887f87e538bdd9ebe50b0b369de138d326802', 'fb2b9389e1455c6d64ae19158396d767d88969013b14075bcfdcc764f610108c', 'ae3bdd3a81d96e4aaa02f7d597a2684146f3af75b743bde8e31c3cf5883707db', '1b8137b4c60774716e4a492efec48060d48abd7308563d8cc76edf32d98bd759', '09732023af932d8c578c8a7ead49feb80cdb5c629cee6add2e24fcd7999c0309', '75b7020073ec0c8cedf517f1b56d554e2a5cfdf89d204633c30b863c42ed6f5f', '4be1dfb90ea542d5d84c23c0ba29b91db2491a39973839ee646eeec25c71adb4', 'c98d52f719106d13b14f27abde81ce00305cbf62889690b72da3e3ddc0286c02', '056859e4aa430e2eb983e93f08bb85d9afe9aec44f0e73263cf072df70b7c475', '870147c2dad0a0dda2dd0a9f85ef83b3c4de9a304fdff6d9fa9ccc4bde9d70c0', '26e942b0353fee8f5ac0a2c2e26c9b695c50b35c501eeb4bff343b1648b5cebc', '036168e918418eb807bc3efd361a8e66067192564da41e30e076d22be0f87935', 'a491df768673d76ae7dee4c9bf1ea1456e6c537a1f1683368d8bc6869cd89bf0', 'f6a8cfceb19b4cd796512223b8afd103c4aee7052247ebea8b50f743e9aa27b6', 'd135518ad4230c8f57a3510b3ddea8a99e2355363c9419a27340734427050729', 'cbe90e272b6be7696d3b8c171500847d2b0ae497f6911d0f9d5d8481101c4c1f', '249c961ea29438959ea2204728df24964ec80b8cd91c657715c47014f5e5a462', '1920ebb46d0cee2d379ef48c15f8f6abd01e2a183f316da235e0c3b7515feade', '6d1573b42d5f89f89b26b32cbbd32ff41660e0e8c3b3091f1cb278a42651e049', 'ec6878825845c61b3049ad5dd168197c84938e7f6d4fc938670da2528cf86317', '9829b13faebde69c2279c38cd54d524aa31acfdcc1cfba7910b9d69caa42e0dd', '2755ae7cda161df0c24e1fa9f1c3308bc9ef81a599d859668490484290ca72f4', '09d9dcfc1716808b0c62e47a771ff4d39ba71f22c8640776e65624747a995626', '71dfcd074b80de90c4955890bdbe127d12b249ed764c7c4ca23dc81c74fde71d', '3c1afbb156ee2d672ca131c7c966bc6875374a95d927848bafcc5a158edf67bb'] B "to map tsn streams into detnet flows. the specific of this operation are discussed later in this document." {79: 1, 130: 1, 54: 1, 52: 1, 98: 1, 6: 1, 8: 1, 64: 1, 99: 1, 24: 1, 90: 2, 51: 2, 62: 4, 85: 4, 68: 3, 35: 2, 110: 2, 91: 4, 114: 2, 97: 2, 31: 2, 13: 2, 67: 2, 38: 3, 26: 2, 124: 2, 127: 2, 96: 2, 30: 3, 61: 4, 55: 2, 27: 3, 15: 2, 129: 2, 115: 2, 84: 2, 76: 5, 87: 2, 131: 4, 102: 2, 113: 4, 36: 2, 72: 3} {4: 1, 24: 1, 59: 1, 111: 1, 136: 1, 156: 1, 206: 1, 215: 1, 220: 1, 221: 1, 235: 1, 241: 1, 242: 1, 314: 1, 329: 1, 334: 1, 354: 1, 366: 1, 376: 1, 1: 8, 9: 4, 10: 2, 15: 2, 25: 4, 26: 4, 27: 2, 39: 4, 43: 2, 49: 5, 50: 4, 58: 4, 64: 2, 69: 3, 81: 5, 82: 3, 86: 2, 96: 3, 97: 2, 100: 6, 108: 2, 109: 3, 110: 3, 114: 2, 115: 3, 116: 2, 118: 5, 119: 4, 120: 2, 121: 3, 122: 3, 123: 2, 124: 3, 128: 3, 129: 3, 130: 4, 132: 3, 145: 3, 147: 3, 151: 3, 152: 3, 154: 2, 161: 2, 162: 2, 165: 2, 168: 3, 169: 2, 172: 2, 180: 3, 184: 4, 187: 4, 188: 3, 191: 2, 194: 3, 202: 4, 203: 5, 207: 2, 217: 2, 218: 7, 222: 4, 224: 2, 227: 4, 229: 2, 234: 4, 243: 3, 244: 3, 245: 3, 248: 3, 250: 3, 258: 10, 262: 3, 263: 4, 264: 2, 267: 3, 270: 2, 272: 2, 273: 4, 287: 2, 289: 2, 291: 4, 299: 4, 300: 2, 304: 2, 309: 2, 315: 2, 320: 3, 323: 3, 327: 3, 328: 2, 330: 9, 335: 2, 341: 4, 342: 5, 347: 4, 348: 4, 350: 6, 351: 4, 352: 2, 353: 2, 358: 3, 365: 2, 371: 6, 372: 4, 384: 4, 385: 3, 386: 2, 387: 2, 392: 2, 393: 3, 396: 5, 397: 6, 398: 5, 402: 2} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 53 "In this example, edge nodes provide a service proxy function that ""associates"" the DetNet flows and native flows (i.e., TSN Streams) at the edge of the DetNet domain. This ensures that the DN Flow is properly served at the Edge node (and inside the domain)." "Major clean up and simplification as data plane drafts can be referred for MPLS related details . TSN over DetNet MPLS follows the concept of RFC3985 . Description focus on Edge Nodes procedures and functions . Text covers the Edge Nodes components : ( 1 ) TSN functions ( in NSP block ) ; ( 2 ) DetNet Service Proxy ; and ( 3 ) DetNet sub - layers . Approving from teelcon review" 3486514b01b74d57f031bcf660311de328a6e0dc 3486514b01b74d57f031bcf660311de328a6e0dc draft-ietf-detnet-tsn-vpn-over-mpls 75db9ae91b710fcf1df3553b8f9653b12d014f74ba1ee8f931870d2433e163f1 ['e82e49a3c764c0ede490d9e8afe0d0a379ec1e2fb734910d7e42f179709f894c', '1b5276bed81725e3cab5fa8d2491ae7fc344c8638906d8e62ee7c31696edcb52', 'a6a4ee1a9211a2be0e24cf91f9742499a46567acff4c78f62b568b34e38c08de', '44d22f065218a14d5aa04288e7553c8a6d81bb222066c74ea38571bbe922a729', 'c757c3611002031d5ce1ac79d9984d826f392e6628a0657e045c348e52b7eda2', '8a105d9f9ffbf3e747a101e48de19122931cd0cce896dc27f57d16df9dbb75ac', 'a8ff14472a8fa48bacdc11d7089a9d1054c0a786f6152f510b5d4092c22e121f', 'e746630d4b45cf2b654a14e4daaa03ad634e33d92c29c489e3ef3fcd5620c311', '16375944152e6c3e73492437880fe39d7f0123a9292d062e8e9c7d317e4b878f', '42f5214bb177fd7faf01b7943e7f313a615b2490f9109d5cefa8b24101735c32', '5cc97b8f56cdeeb02e7c96183745dc53dd8ec3ec02424107d16eb438c2c9363c', 'a816e4d1392c9c85d398ee2c5116b5de849a9823bc552d322ac8725f7c9b859e', 'c7286f8983508fdd7d94ae798cdc3950cbf65865e905c00a76838a34eb79cf2c', '6924f7b3002e9f0dff9023b70bcc9d484e643c3a2d95b0d5c853c084ad3f68ab', '2d8fce3963de03360a5d98758067925a60474b5430fd8091fc72f3c50a9d38e5', '77f9aaec42bbb94079fae33b8c564cd7f64721106f615e11f22673310efaf01b', '09f8dc962fd9202d148a0b378c9a078ea850056b4b5c360c0914d4a1de6af454', '4826376633600232b766cb8a62d4054b0f5ea45d74878bcf57356e567088300c', '82b410c949db1d81b3f197adbaaba7b82b6e497600cd9883150af2bb815caa19', '0eb73f51f3b491bd6d969a05acf2b527e6e2f09a460cb88266513ab952bd3fc6', '1076eab6753435c114e8a720c951b03da6d4e1bbbf1290f8d58ad7f97a0b8c64', '4ccf918f8b8ae99a769d89e0868a12e4af1536487652436b6c188bc99e14fdb6', '2a5cef1e9c76b52b9b56c6c021a857b0fa757897b6e3c96cc8170d5b73ba8dd8', '07267e696bfbb5af98da5a8efe2b8cf604bc9ab1ce95e4766f017473bfcd0de1', '82f56d4694c2ec964de0a4413954f87ca621628c63d7425944baeff9aa4b6dad', '01e1da53fe2751e7196114efc63dd70d9babc69b4b73c03d4b7528dcc10c05d3', 'fb8f3ca7fafc9c173404ce7f909038443a6078a0c278cb024639410e33f49f88', '44e497e2df0461bad9215c57918855022435eb6e28266916161de3f7902bb352', '84f5bc0e0be5d04b515e8e49efb393e4aec7189222b92c0555cc1be542e74549', '3195c90c03cf6a438b5684cc93128c53f794660a661e2aa85d043ca5ac7060b9', 'b5bacf05f766e143f6de9484b0b5a2d9655d62854368373bd77974b94cb722e6', '2442b9072d522cde54849b40cab26789e4af909f1dd81391cd8c87023515a21c', 'b03d79d1a547b36a28c6cba78f57b8244a4855f6b31003de3e617a5b5eddc070', 'e386562e3156c91934ceb045df46d7e847bb9afcad2794bda59be854f988befc', 'cc980749457292da3a6a4a3ce669ad487409ce72e20857e80c75741c83af7f0a', '75db9ae91b710fcf1df3553b8f9653b12d014f74ba1ee8f931870d2433e163f1', '0e313215df9694bc26777ba4ac347cb8ef73f8475d2bfed664aab722833589ae', '1094721b24c22ff67539ffeabab887f87e538bdd9ebe50b0b369de138d326802', 'fb2b9389e1455c6d64ae19158396d767d88969013b14075bcfdcc764f610108c', 'ae3bdd3a81d96e4aaa02f7d597a2684146f3af75b743bde8e31c3cf5883707db', '1b8137b4c60774716e4a492efec48060d48abd7308563d8cc76edf32d98bd759', '09732023af932d8c578c8a7ead49feb80cdb5c629cee6add2e24fcd7999c0309', '75b7020073ec0c8cedf517f1b56d554e2a5cfdf89d204633c30b863c42ed6f5f', '4be1dfb90ea542d5d84c23c0ba29b91db2491a39973839ee646eeec25c71adb4', 'c98d52f719106d13b14f27abde81ce00305cbf62889690b72da3e3ddc0286c02', '056859e4aa430e2eb983e93f08bb85d9afe9aec44f0e73263cf072df70b7c475', '870147c2dad0a0dda2dd0a9f85ef83b3c4de9a304fdff6d9fa9ccc4bde9d70c0', '26e942b0353fee8f5ac0a2c2e26c9b695c50b35c501eeb4bff343b1648b5cebc', '036168e918418eb807bc3efd361a8e66067192564da41e30e076d22be0f87935', 'a491df768673d76ae7dee4c9bf1ea1456e6c537a1f1683368d8bc6869cd89bf0', 'f6a8cfceb19b4cd796512223b8afd103c4aee7052247ebea8b50f743e9aa27b6', 'd135518ad4230c8f57a3510b3ddea8a99e2355363c9419a27340734427050729', 'cbe90e272b6be7696d3b8c171500847d2b0ae497f6911d0f9d5d8481101c4c1f', '249c961ea29438959ea2204728df24964ec80b8cd91c657715c47014f5e5a462', '1920ebb46d0cee2d379ef48c15f8f6abd01e2a183f316da235e0c3b7515feade', '6d1573b42d5f89f89b26b32cbbd32ff41660e0e8c3b3091f1cb278a42651e049', 'ec6878825845c61b3049ad5dd168197c84938e7f6d4fc938670da2528cf86317', '9829b13faebde69c2279c38cd54d524aa31acfdcc1cfba7910b9d69caa42e0dd', '2755ae7cda161df0c24e1fa9f1c3308bc9ef81a599d859668490484290ca72f4', '09d9dcfc1716808b0c62e47a771ff4d39ba71f22c8640776e65624747a995626', '71dfcd074b80de90c4955890bdbe127d12b249ed764c7c4ca23dc81c74fde71d', '3c1afbb156ee2d672ca131c7c966bc6875374a95d927848bafcc5a158edf67bb'] B "in this example, edge nodes provide a service proxy function that ""associates"" the detnet flows and native flows (i.e., tsn streams) at the edge of the detnet domain. this ensures that the dn flow is properly served at the edge node (and inside the domain)." {79: 1, 130: 1, 54: 1, 52: 1, 98: 1, 6: 1, 8: 1, 64: 1, 99: 1, 24: 1, 90: 2, 51: 2, 62: 4, 85: 4, 68: 3, 35: 2, 110: 2, 91: 4, 114: 2, 97: 2, 31: 2, 13: 2, 67: 2, 38: 3, 26: 2, 124: 2, 127: 2, 96: 2, 30: 3, 61: 4, 55: 2, 27: 3, 15: 2, 129: 2, 115: 2, 84: 2, 76: 5, 87: 2, 131: 4, 102: 2, 113: 4, 36: 2, 72: 3} {4: 1, 24: 1, 59: 1, 111: 1, 136: 1, 156: 1, 206: 1, 215: 1, 220: 1, 221: 1, 235: 1, 241: 1, 242: 1, 314: 1, 329: 1, 334: 1, 354: 1, 366: 1, 376: 1, 1: 8, 9: 4, 10: 2, 15: 2, 25: 4, 26: 4, 27: 2, 39: 4, 43: 2, 49: 5, 50: 4, 58: 4, 64: 2, 69: 3, 81: 5, 82: 3, 86: 2, 96: 3, 97: 2, 100: 6, 108: 2, 109: 3, 110: 3, 114: 2, 115: 3, 116: 2, 118: 5, 119: 4, 120: 2, 121: 3, 122: 3, 123: 2, 124: 3, 128: 3, 129: 3, 130: 4, 132: 3, 145: 3, 147: 3, 151: 3, 152: 3, 154: 2, 161: 2, 162: 2, 165: 2, 168: 3, 169: 2, 172: 2, 180: 3, 184: 4, 187: 4, 188: 3, 191: 2, 194: 3, 202: 4, 203: 5, 207: 2, 217: 2, 218: 7, 222: 4, 224: 2, 227: 4, 229: 2, 234: 4, 243: 3, 244: 3, 245: 3, 248: 3, 250: 3, 258: 10, 262: 3, 263: 4, 264: 2, 267: 3, 270: 2, 272: 2, 273: 4, 287: 2, 289: 2, 291: 4, 299: 4, 300: 2, 304: 2, 309: 2, 315: 2, 320: 3, 323: 3, 327: 3, 328: 2, 330: 9, 335: 2, 341: 4, 342: 5, 347: 4, 348: 4, 350: 6, 351: 4, 352: 2, 353: 2, 358: 3, 365: 2, 371: 6, 372: 4, 384: 4, 385: 3, 386: 2, 387: 2, 392: 2, 393: 3, 396: 5, 397: 6, 398: 5, 402: 2} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 53 "fig_8021_detnet illustrates how DetNet can provide services for IEEE 802.1 TSN end systems, CE1 and CE2, over a DetNet enabled MPLS network. Edge nodes, E1 and E2, insert and remove required DetNet data plane encapsulation. The 'X' in the edge nodes and relay node, R1, represent a potential DetNet compound flow packet replication and elimination point. This conceptually parallels L2VPN services, and could leverage existing related solutions as discussed below." "Major clean up and simplification as data plane drafts can be referred for MPLS related details . TSN over DetNet MPLS follows the concept of RFC3985 . Description focus on Edge Nodes procedures and functions . Text covers the Edge Nodes components : ( 1 ) TSN functions ( in NSP block ) ; ( 2 ) DetNet Service Proxy ; and ( 3 ) DetNet sub - layers . Approving from teelcon review" 3486514b01b74d57f031bcf660311de328a6e0dc 3486514b01b74d57f031bcf660311de328a6e0dc draft-ietf-detnet-tsn-vpn-over-mpls 4be1dfb90ea542d5d84c23c0ba29b91db2491a39973839ee646eeec25c71adb4 ['e82e49a3c764c0ede490d9e8afe0d0a379ec1e2fb734910d7e42f179709f894c', '1b5276bed81725e3cab5fa8d2491ae7fc344c8638906d8e62ee7c31696edcb52', 'a6a4ee1a9211a2be0e24cf91f9742499a46567acff4c78f62b568b34e38c08de', '44d22f065218a14d5aa04288e7553c8a6d81bb222066c74ea38571bbe922a729', 'c757c3611002031d5ce1ac79d9984d826f392e6628a0657e045c348e52b7eda2', '8a105d9f9ffbf3e747a101e48de19122931cd0cce896dc27f57d16df9dbb75ac', 'a8ff14472a8fa48bacdc11d7089a9d1054c0a786f6152f510b5d4092c22e121f', 'e746630d4b45cf2b654a14e4daaa03ad634e33d92c29c489e3ef3fcd5620c311', '16375944152e6c3e73492437880fe39d7f0123a9292d062e8e9c7d317e4b878f', '42f5214bb177fd7faf01b7943e7f313a615b2490f9109d5cefa8b24101735c32', '5cc97b8f56cdeeb02e7c96183745dc53dd8ec3ec02424107d16eb438c2c9363c', 'a816e4d1392c9c85d398ee2c5116b5de849a9823bc552d322ac8725f7c9b859e', 'c7286f8983508fdd7d94ae798cdc3950cbf65865e905c00a76838a34eb79cf2c', '6924f7b3002e9f0dff9023b70bcc9d484e643c3a2d95b0d5c853c084ad3f68ab', '2d8fce3963de03360a5d98758067925a60474b5430fd8091fc72f3c50a9d38e5', '77f9aaec42bbb94079fae33b8c564cd7f64721106f615e11f22673310efaf01b', '09f8dc962fd9202d148a0b378c9a078ea850056b4b5c360c0914d4a1de6af454', '4826376633600232b766cb8a62d4054b0f5ea45d74878bcf57356e567088300c', '82b410c949db1d81b3f197adbaaba7b82b6e497600cd9883150af2bb815caa19', '0eb73f51f3b491bd6d969a05acf2b527e6e2f09a460cb88266513ab952bd3fc6', '1076eab6753435c114e8a720c951b03da6d4e1bbbf1290f8d58ad7f97a0b8c64', '4ccf918f8b8ae99a769d89e0868a12e4af1536487652436b6c188bc99e14fdb6', '2a5cef1e9c76b52b9b56c6c021a857b0fa757897b6e3c96cc8170d5b73ba8dd8', '07267e696bfbb5af98da5a8efe2b8cf604bc9ab1ce95e4766f017473bfcd0de1', '82f56d4694c2ec964de0a4413954f87ca621628c63d7425944baeff9aa4b6dad', '01e1da53fe2751e7196114efc63dd70d9babc69b4b73c03d4b7528dcc10c05d3', 'fb8f3ca7fafc9c173404ce7f909038443a6078a0c278cb024639410e33f49f88', '44e497e2df0461bad9215c57918855022435eb6e28266916161de3f7902bb352', '84f5bc0e0be5d04b515e8e49efb393e4aec7189222b92c0555cc1be542e74549', '3195c90c03cf6a438b5684cc93128c53f794660a661e2aa85d043ca5ac7060b9', 'b5bacf05f766e143f6de9484b0b5a2d9655d62854368373bd77974b94cb722e6', '2442b9072d522cde54849b40cab26789e4af909f1dd81391cd8c87023515a21c', 'b03d79d1a547b36a28c6cba78f57b8244a4855f6b31003de3e617a5b5eddc070', 'e386562e3156c91934ceb045df46d7e847bb9afcad2794bda59be854f988befc', 'cc980749457292da3a6a4a3ce669ad487409ce72e20857e80c75741c83af7f0a', '75db9ae91b710fcf1df3553b8f9653b12d014f74ba1ee8f931870d2433e163f1', '0e313215df9694bc26777ba4ac347cb8ef73f8475d2bfed664aab722833589ae', '1094721b24c22ff67539ffeabab887f87e538bdd9ebe50b0b369de138d326802', 'fb2b9389e1455c6d64ae19158396d767d88969013b14075bcfdcc764f610108c', 'ae3bdd3a81d96e4aaa02f7d597a2684146f3af75b743bde8e31c3cf5883707db', '1b8137b4c60774716e4a492efec48060d48abd7308563d8cc76edf32d98bd759', '09732023af932d8c578c8a7ead49feb80cdb5c629cee6add2e24fcd7999c0309', '75b7020073ec0c8cedf517f1b56d554e2a5cfdf89d204633c30b863c42ed6f5f', '4be1dfb90ea542d5d84c23c0ba29b91db2491a39973839ee646eeec25c71adb4', 'c98d52f719106d13b14f27abde81ce00305cbf62889690b72da3e3ddc0286c02', '056859e4aa430e2eb983e93f08bb85d9afe9aec44f0e73263cf072df70b7c475', '870147c2dad0a0dda2dd0a9f85ef83b3c4de9a304fdff6d9fa9ccc4bde9d70c0', '26e942b0353fee8f5ac0a2c2e26c9b695c50b35c501eeb4bff343b1648b5cebc', '036168e918418eb807bc3efd361a8e66067192564da41e30e076d22be0f87935', 'a491df768673d76ae7dee4c9bf1ea1456e6c537a1f1683368d8bc6869cd89bf0', 'f6a8cfceb19b4cd796512223b8afd103c4aee7052247ebea8b50f743e9aa27b6', 'd135518ad4230c8f57a3510b3ddea8a99e2355363c9419a27340734427050729', 'cbe90e272b6be7696d3b8c171500847d2b0ae497f6911d0f9d5d8481101c4c1f', '249c961ea29438959ea2204728df24964ec80b8cd91c657715c47014f5e5a462', '1920ebb46d0cee2d379ef48c15f8f6abd01e2a183f316da235e0c3b7515feade', '6d1573b42d5f89f89b26b32cbbd32ff41660e0e8c3b3091f1cb278a42651e049', 'ec6878825845c61b3049ad5dd168197c84938e7f6d4fc938670da2528cf86317', '9829b13faebde69c2279c38cd54d524aa31acfdcc1cfba7910b9d69caa42e0dd', '2755ae7cda161df0c24e1fa9f1c3308bc9ef81a599d859668490484290ca72f4', '09d9dcfc1716808b0c62e47a771ff4d39ba71f22c8640776e65624747a995626', '71dfcd074b80de90c4955890bdbe127d12b249ed764c7c4ca23dc81c74fde71d', '3c1afbb156ee2d672ca131c7c966bc6875374a95d927848bafcc5a158edf67bb'] B "fig_8021_detnet illustrates how detnet can provide services for ieee 802.1 tsn end systems, ce1 and ce2, over a detnet enabled mpls network. edge nodes, e1 and e2, insert and remove required detnet data plane encapsulation. the 'x' in the edge nodes and relay node, r1, represent a potential detnet compound flow packet replication and elimination point. this conceptually parallels l2vpn services, and could leverage existing related solutions as discussed below." {79: 1, 130: 1, 54: 1, 52: 1, 98: 1, 6: 1, 8: 1, 64: 1, 99: 1, 24: 1, 90: 2, 51: 2, 62: 4, 85: 4, 68: 3, 35: 2, 110: 2, 91: 4, 114: 2, 97: 2, 31: 2, 13: 2, 67: 2, 38: 3, 26: 2, 124: 2, 127: 2, 96: 2, 30: 3, 61: 4, 55: 2, 27: 3, 15: 2, 129: 2, 115: 2, 84: 2, 76: 5, 87: 2, 131: 4, 102: 2, 113: 4, 36: 2, 72: 3} {4: 1, 24: 1, 59: 1, 111: 1, 136: 1, 156: 1, 206: 1, 215: 1, 220: 1, 221: 1, 235: 1, 241: 1, 242: 1, 314: 1, 329: 1, 334: 1, 354: 1, 366: 1, 376: 1, 1: 8, 9: 4, 10: 2, 15: 2, 25: 4, 26: 4, 27: 2, 39: 4, 43: 2, 49: 5, 50: 4, 58: 4, 64: 2, 69: 3, 81: 5, 82: 3, 86: 2, 96: 3, 97: 2, 100: 6, 108: 2, 109: 3, 110: 3, 114: 2, 115: 3, 116: 2, 118: 5, 119: 4, 120: 2, 121: 3, 122: 3, 123: 2, 124: 3, 128: 3, 129: 3, 130: 4, 132: 3, 145: 3, 147: 3, 151: 3, 152: 3, 154: 2, 161: 2, 162: 2, 165: 2, 168: 3, 169: 2, 172: 2, 180: 3, 184: 4, 187: 4, 188: 3, 191: 2, 194: 3, 202: 4, 203: 5, 207: 2, 217: 2, 218: 7, 222: 4, 224: 2, 227: 4, 229: 2, 234: 4, 243: 3, 244: 3, 245: 3, 248: 3, 250: 3, 258: 10, 262: 3, 263: 4, 264: 2, 267: 3, 270: 2, 272: 2, 273: 4, 287: 2, 289: 2, 291: 4, 299: 4, 300: 2, 304: 2, 309: 2, 315: 2, 320: 3, 323: 3, 327: 3, 328: 2, 330: 9, 335: 2, 341: 4, 342: 5, 347: 4, 348: 4, 350: 6, 351: 4, 352: 2, 353: 2, 358: 3, 365: 2, 371: 6, 372: 4, 384: 4, 385: 3, 386: 2, 387: 2, 392: 2, 393: 3, 396: 5, 397: 6, 398: 5, 402: 2} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 53 "The basic approach defined in I-D.ietf-detnet-mpls supports the DetNet service sub-layer based on existing pseudowire (PW) encapsulations and mechanisms, and supports the DetNet forwarding sub-layer based on existing MPLS Traffic Engineering encapsulations and mechanisms." "Major clean up and simplification as data plane drafts can be referred for MPLS related details . TSN over DetNet MPLS follows the concept of RFC3985 . Description focus on Edge Nodes procedures and functions . Text covers the Edge Nodes components : ( 1 ) TSN functions ( in NSP block ) ; ( 2 ) DetNet Service Proxy ; and ( 3 ) DetNet sub - layers . Approving from teelcon review" 3486514b01b74d57f031bcf660311de328a6e0dc 3486514b01b74d57f031bcf660311de328a6e0dc draft-ietf-detnet-tsn-vpn-over-mpls 2d8fce3963de03360a5d98758067925a60474b5430fd8091fc72f3c50a9d38e5 ['e82e49a3c764c0ede490d9e8afe0d0a379ec1e2fb734910d7e42f179709f894c', '1b5276bed81725e3cab5fa8d2491ae7fc344c8638906d8e62ee7c31696edcb52', 'a6a4ee1a9211a2be0e24cf91f9742499a46567acff4c78f62b568b34e38c08de', '44d22f065218a14d5aa04288e7553c8a6d81bb222066c74ea38571bbe922a729', 'c757c3611002031d5ce1ac79d9984d826f392e6628a0657e045c348e52b7eda2', '8a105d9f9ffbf3e747a101e48de19122931cd0cce896dc27f57d16df9dbb75ac', 'a8ff14472a8fa48bacdc11d7089a9d1054c0a786f6152f510b5d4092c22e121f', 'e746630d4b45cf2b654a14e4daaa03ad634e33d92c29c489e3ef3fcd5620c311', '16375944152e6c3e73492437880fe39d7f0123a9292d062e8e9c7d317e4b878f', '42f5214bb177fd7faf01b7943e7f313a615b2490f9109d5cefa8b24101735c32', '5cc97b8f56cdeeb02e7c96183745dc53dd8ec3ec02424107d16eb438c2c9363c', 'a816e4d1392c9c85d398ee2c5116b5de849a9823bc552d322ac8725f7c9b859e', 'c7286f8983508fdd7d94ae798cdc3950cbf65865e905c00a76838a34eb79cf2c', '6924f7b3002e9f0dff9023b70bcc9d484e643c3a2d95b0d5c853c084ad3f68ab', '2d8fce3963de03360a5d98758067925a60474b5430fd8091fc72f3c50a9d38e5', '77f9aaec42bbb94079fae33b8c564cd7f64721106f615e11f22673310efaf01b', '09f8dc962fd9202d148a0b378c9a078ea850056b4b5c360c0914d4a1de6af454', '4826376633600232b766cb8a62d4054b0f5ea45d74878bcf57356e567088300c', '82b410c949db1d81b3f197adbaaba7b82b6e497600cd9883150af2bb815caa19', '0eb73f51f3b491bd6d969a05acf2b527e6e2f09a460cb88266513ab952bd3fc6', '1076eab6753435c114e8a720c951b03da6d4e1bbbf1290f8d58ad7f97a0b8c64', '4ccf918f8b8ae99a769d89e0868a12e4af1536487652436b6c188bc99e14fdb6', '2a5cef1e9c76b52b9b56c6c021a857b0fa757897b6e3c96cc8170d5b73ba8dd8', '07267e696bfbb5af98da5a8efe2b8cf604bc9ab1ce95e4766f017473bfcd0de1', '82f56d4694c2ec964de0a4413954f87ca621628c63d7425944baeff9aa4b6dad', '01e1da53fe2751e7196114efc63dd70d9babc69b4b73c03d4b7528dcc10c05d3', 'fb8f3ca7fafc9c173404ce7f909038443a6078a0c278cb024639410e33f49f88', '44e497e2df0461bad9215c57918855022435eb6e28266916161de3f7902bb352', '84f5bc0e0be5d04b515e8e49efb393e4aec7189222b92c0555cc1be542e74549', '3195c90c03cf6a438b5684cc93128c53f794660a661e2aa85d043ca5ac7060b9', 'b5bacf05f766e143f6de9484b0b5a2d9655d62854368373bd77974b94cb722e6', '2442b9072d522cde54849b40cab26789e4af909f1dd81391cd8c87023515a21c', 'b03d79d1a547b36a28c6cba78f57b8244a4855f6b31003de3e617a5b5eddc070', 'e386562e3156c91934ceb045df46d7e847bb9afcad2794bda59be854f988befc', 'cc980749457292da3a6a4a3ce669ad487409ce72e20857e80c75741c83af7f0a', '75db9ae91b710fcf1df3553b8f9653b12d014f74ba1ee8f931870d2433e163f1', '0e313215df9694bc26777ba4ac347cb8ef73f8475d2bfed664aab722833589ae', '1094721b24c22ff67539ffeabab887f87e538bdd9ebe50b0b369de138d326802', 'fb2b9389e1455c6d64ae19158396d767d88969013b14075bcfdcc764f610108c', 'ae3bdd3a81d96e4aaa02f7d597a2684146f3af75b743bde8e31c3cf5883707db', '1b8137b4c60774716e4a492efec48060d48abd7308563d8cc76edf32d98bd759', '09732023af932d8c578c8a7ead49feb80cdb5c629cee6add2e24fcd7999c0309', '75b7020073ec0c8cedf517f1b56d554e2a5cfdf89d204633c30b863c42ed6f5f', '4be1dfb90ea542d5d84c23c0ba29b91db2491a39973839ee646eeec25c71adb4', 'c98d52f719106d13b14f27abde81ce00305cbf62889690b72da3e3ddc0286c02', '056859e4aa430e2eb983e93f08bb85d9afe9aec44f0e73263cf072df70b7c475', '870147c2dad0a0dda2dd0a9f85ef83b3c4de9a304fdff6d9fa9ccc4bde9d70c0', '26e942b0353fee8f5ac0a2c2e26c9b695c50b35c501eeb4bff343b1648b5cebc', '036168e918418eb807bc3efd361a8e66067192564da41e30e076d22be0f87935', 'a491df768673d76ae7dee4c9bf1ea1456e6c537a1f1683368d8bc6869cd89bf0', 'f6a8cfceb19b4cd796512223b8afd103c4aee7052247ebea8b50f743e9aa27b6', 'd135518ad4230c8f57a3510b3ddea8a99e2355363c9419a27340734427050729', 'cbe90e272b6be7696d3b8c171500847d2b0ae497f6911d0f9d5d8481101c4c1f', '249c961ea29438959ea2204728df24964ec80b8cd91c657715c47014f5e5a462', '1920ebb46d0cee2d379ef48c15f8f6abd01e2a183f316da235e0c3b7515feade', '6d1573b42d5f89f89b26b32cbbd32ff41660e0e8c3b3091f1cb278a42651e049', 'ec6878825845c61b3049ad5dd168197c84938e7f6d4fc938670da2528cf86317', '9829b13faebde69c2279c38cd54d524aa31acfdcc1cfba7910b9d69caa42e0dd', '2755ae7cda161df0c24e1fa9f1c3308bc9ef81a599d859668490484290ca72f4', '09d9dcfc1716808b0c62e47a771ff4d39ba71f22c8640776e65624747a995626', '71dfcd074b80de90c4955890bdbe127d12b249ed764c7c4ca23dc81c74fde71d', '3c1afbb156ee2d672ca131c7c966bc6875374a95d927848bafcc5a158edf67bb'] B "the basic approach defined in i-d.ietf-detnet-mpls supports the detnet service sub-layer based on existing pseudowire (pw) encapsulations and mechanisms, and supports the detnet forwarding sub-layer based on existing mpls traffic engineering encapsulations and mechanisms." {79: 1, 130: 1, 54: 1, 52: 1, 98: 1, 6: 1, 8: 1, 64: 1, 99: 1, 24: 1, 90: 2, 51: 2, 62: 4, 85: 4, 68: 3, 35: 2, 110: 2, 91: 4, 114: 2, 97: 2, 31: 2, 13: 2, 67: 2, 38: 3, 26: 2, 124: 2, 127: 2, 96: 2, 30: 3, 61: 4, 55: 2, 27: 3, 15: 2, 129: 2, 115: 2, 84: 2, 76: 5, 87: 2, 131: 4, 102: 2, 113: 4, 36: 2, 72: 3} {4: 1, 24: 1, 59: 1, 111: 1, 136: 1, 156: 1, 206: 1, 215: 1, 220: 1, 221: 1, 235: 1, 241: 1, 242: 1, 314: 1, 329: 1, 334: 1, 354: 1, 366: 1, 376: 1, 1: 8, 9: 4, 10: 2, 15: 2, 25: 4, 26: 4, 27: 2, 39: 4, 43: 2, 49: 5, 50: 4, 58: 4, 64: 2, 69: 3, 81: 5, 82: 3, 86: 2, 96: 3, 97: 2, 100: 6, 108: 2, 109: 3, 110: 3, 114: 2, 115: 3, 116: 2, 118: 5, 119: 4, 120: 2, 121: 3, 122: 3, 123: 2, 124: 3, 128: 3, 129: 3, 130: 4, 132: 3, 145: 3, 147: 3, 151: 3, 152: 3, 154: 2, 161: 2, 162: 2, 165: 2, 168: 3, 169: 2, 172: 2, 180: 3, 184: 4, 187: 4, 188: 3, 191: 2, 194: 3, 202: 4, 203: 5, 207: 2, 217: 2, 218: 7, 222: 4, 224: 2, 227: 4, 229: 2, 234: 4, 243: 3, 244: 3, 245: 3, 248: 3, 250: 3, 258: 10, 262: 3, 263: 4, 264: 2, 267: 3, 270: 2, 272: 2, 273: 4, 287: 2, 289: 2, 291: 4, 299: 4, 300: 2, 304: 2, 309: 2, 315: 2, 320: 3, 323: 3, 327: 3, 328: 2, 330: 9, 335: 2, 341: 4, 342: 5, 347: 4, 348: 4, 350: 6, 351: 4, 352: 2, 353: 2, 358: 3, 365: 2, 371: 6, 372: 4, 384: 4, 385: 3, 386: 2, 387: 2, 392: 2, 393: 3, 396: 5, 397: 6, 398: 5, 402: 2} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 53 "A node operating on a DetNet flow in the Detnet service sub-layer, i.e. a node processing a DetNet packet which has the S-Label as top of stack uses the local context associated with that S-Label, for example a received F-Label, to determine what local DetNet operation(s) are applied to that packet. An S-Label may be unique when taken from the platform label space RFC3031, which would enable correct DetNet flow identification regardless of which input interface or LSP the packet arrives on. The service sub-layer functions (i.e., PREOF) use a DetNet control word (d-CW)." "Major clean up and simplification as data plane drafts can be referred for MPLS related details . TSN over DetNet MPLS follows the concept of RFC3985 . Description focus on Edge Nodes procedures and functions . Text covers the Edge Nodes components : ( 1 ) TSN functions ( in NSP block ) ; ( 2 ) DetNet Service Proxy ; and ( 3 ) DetNet sub - layers . Approving from teelcon review" 3486514b01b74d57f031bcf660311de328a6e0dc 3486514b01b74d57f031bcf660311de328a6e0dc draft-ietf-detnet-tsn-vpn-over-mpls e746630d4b45cf2b654a14e4daaa03ad634e33d92c29c489e3ef3fcd5620c311 ['e82e49a3c764c0ede490d9e8afe0d0a379ec1e2fb734910d7e42f179709f894c', '1b5276bed81725e3cab5fa8d2491ae7fc344c8638906d8e62ee7c31696edcb52', 'a6a4ee1a9211a2be0e24cf91f9742499a46567acff4c78f62b568b34e38c08de', '44d22f065218a14d5aa04288e7553c8a6d81bb222066c74ea38571bbe922a729', 'c757c3611002031d5ce1ac79d9984d826f392e6628a0657e045c348e52b7eda2', '8a105d9f9ffbf3e747a101e48de19122931cd0cce896dc27f57d16df9dbb75ac', 'a8ff14472a8fa48bacdc11d7089a9d1054c0a786f6152f510b5d4092c22e121f', 'e746630d4b45cf2b654a14e4daaa03ad634e33d92c29c489e3ef3fcd5620c311', '16375944152e6c3e73492437880fe39d7f0123a9292d062e8e9c7d317e4b878f', '42f5214bb177fd7faf01b7943e7f313a615b2490f9109d5cefa8b24101735c32', '5cc97b8f56cdeeb02e7c96183745dc53dd8ec3ec02424107d16eb438c2c9363c', 'a816e4d1392c9c85d398ee2c5116b5de849a9823bc552d322ac8725f7c9b859e', 'c7286f8983508fdd7d94ae798cdc3950cbf65865e905c00a76838a34eb79cf2c', '6924f7b3002e9f0dff9023b70bcc9d484e643c3a2d95b0d5c853c084ad3f68ab', '2d8fce3963de03360a5d98758067925a60474b5430fd8091fc72f3c50a9d38e5', '77f9aaec42bbb94079fae33b8c564cd7f64721106f615e11f22673310efaf01b', '09f8dc962fd9202d148a0b378c9a078ea850056b4b5c360c0914d4a1de6af454', '4826376633600232b766cb8a62d4054b0f5ea45d74878bcf57356e567088300c', '82b410c949db1d81b3f197adbaaba7b82b6e497600cd9883150af2bb815caa19', '0eb73f51f3b491bd6d969a05acf2b527e6e2f09a460cb88266513ab952bd3fc6', '1076eab6753435c114e8a720c951b03da6d4e1bbbf1290f8d58ad7f97a0b8c64', '4ccf918f8b8ae99a769d89e0868a12e4af1536487652436b6c188bc99e14fdb6', '2a5cef1e9c76b52b9b56c6c021a857b0fa757897b6e3c96cc8170d5b73ba8dd8', '07267e696bfbb5af98da5a8efe2b8cf604bc9ab1ce95e4766f017473bfcd0de1', '82f56d4694c2ec964de0a4413954f87ca621628c63d7425944baeff9aa4b6dad', '01e1da53fe2751e7196114efc63dd70d9babc69b4b73c03d4b7528dcc10c05d3', 'fb8f3ca7fafc9c173404ce7f909038443a6078a0c278cb024639410e33f49f88', '44e497e2df0461bad9215c57918855022435eb6e28266916161de3f7902bb352', '84f5bc0e0be5d04b515e8e49efb393e4aec7189222b92c0555cc1be542e74549', '3195c90c03cf6a438b5684cc93128c53f794660a661e2aa85d043ca5ac7060b9', 'b5bacf05f766e143f6de9484b0b5a2d9655d62854368373bd77974b94cb722e6', '2442b9072d522cde54849b40cab26789e4af909f1dd81391cd8c87023515a21c', 'b03d79d1a547b36a28c6cba78f57b8244a4855f6b31003de3e617a5b5eddc070', 'e386562e3156c91934ceb045df46d7e847bb9afcad2794bda59be854f988befc', 'cc980749457292da3a6a4a3ce669ad487409ce72e20857e80c75741c83af7f0a', '75db9ae91b710fcf1df3553b8f9653b12d014f74ba1ee8f931870d2433e163f1', '0e313215df9694bc26777ba4ac347cb8ef73f8475d2bfed664aab722833589ae', '1094721b24c22ff67539ffeabab887f87e538bdd9ebe50b0b369de138d326802', 'fb2b9389e1455c6d64ae19158396d767d88969013b14075bcfdcc764f610108c', 'ae3bdd3a81d96e4aaa02f7d597a2684146f3af75b743bde8e31c3cf5883707db', '1b8137b4c60774716e4a492efec48060d48abd7308563d8cc76edf32d98bd759', '09732023af932d8c578c8a7ead49feb80cdb5c629cee6add2e24fcd7999c0309', '75b7020073ec0c8cedf517f1b56d554e2a5cfdf89d204633c30b863c42ed6f5f', '4be1dfb90ea542d5d84c23c0ba29b91db2491a39973839ee646eeec25c71adb4', 'c98d52f719106d13b14f27abde81ce00305cbf62889690b72da3e3ddc0286c02', '056859e4aa430e2eb983e93f08bb85d9afe9aec44f0e73263cf072df70b7c475', '870147c2dad0a0dda2dd0a9f85ef83b3c4de9a304fdff6d9fa9ccc4bde9d70c0', '26e942b0353fee8f5ac0a2c2e26c9b695c50b35c501eeb4bff343b1648b5cebc', '036168e918418eb807bc3efd361a8e66067192564da41e30e076d22be0f87935', 'a491df768673d76ae7dee4c9bf1ea1456e6c537a1f1683368d8bc6869cd89bf0', 'f6a8cfceb19b4cd796512223b8afd103c4aee7052247ebea8b50f743e9aa27b6', 'd135518ad4230c8f57a3510b3ddea8a99e2355363c9419a27340734427050729', 'cbe90e272b6be7696d3b8c171500847d2b0ae497f6911d0f9d5d8481101c4c1f', '249c961ea29438959ea2204728df24964ec80b8cd91c657715c47014f5e5a462', '1920ebb46d0cee2d379ef48c15f8f6abd01e2a183f316da235e0c3b7515feade', '6d1573b42d5f89f89b26b32cbbd32ff41660e0e8c3b3091f1cb278a42651e049', 'ec6878825845c61b3049ad5dd168197c84938e7f6d4fc938670da2528cf86317', '9829b13faebde69c2279c38cd54d524aa31acfdcc1cfba7910b9d69caa42e0dd', '2755ae7cda161df0c24e1fa9f1c3308bc9ef81a599d859668490484290ca72f4', '09d9dcfc1716808b0c62e47a771ff4d39ba71f22c8640776e65624747a995626', '71dfcd074b80de90c4955890bdbe127d12b249ed764c7c4ca23dc81c74fde71d', '3c1afbb156ee2d672ca131c7c966bc6875374a95d927848bafcc5a158edf67bb'] B "a node operating on a detnet flow in the detnet service sub-layer, i.e. a node processing a detnet packet which has the s-label as top of stack uses the local context associated with that s-label, for example a received f-label, to determine what local detnet operation(s) are applied to that packet. an s-label may be unique when taken from the platform label space rfc3031, which would enable correct detnet flow identification regardless of which input interface or lsp the packet arrives on. the service sub-layer functions (i.e., preof) use a detnet control word (d-cw)." {79: 1, 130: 1, 54: 1, 52: 1, 98: 1, 6: 1, 8: 1, 64: 1, 99: 1, 24: 1, 90: 2, 51: 2, 62: 4, 85: 4, 68: 3, 35: 2, 110: 2, 91: 4, 114: 2, 97: 2, 31: 2, 13: 2, 67: 2, 38: 3, 26: 2, 124: 2, 127: 2, 96: 2, 30: 3, 61: 4, 55: 2, 27: 3, 15: 2, 129: 2, 115: 2, 84: 2, 76: 5, 87: 2, 131: 4, 102: 2, 113: 4, 36: 2, 72: 3} {4: 1, 24: 1, 59: 1, 111: 1, 136: 1, 156: 1, 206: 1, 215: 1, 220: 1, 221: 1, 235: 1, 241: 1, 242: 1, 314: 1, 329: 1, 334: 1, 354: 1, 366: 1, 376: 1, 1: 8, 9: 4, 10: 2, 15: 2, 25: 4, 26: 4, 27: 2, 39: 4, 43: 2, 49: 5, 50: 4, 58: 4, 64: 2, 69: 3, 81: 5, 82: 3, 86: 2, 96: 3, 97: 2, 100: 6, 108: 2, 109: 3, 110: 3, 114: 2, 115: 3, 116: 2, 118: 5, 119: 4, 120: 2, 121: 3, 122: 3, 123: 2, 124: 3, 128: 3, 129: 3, 130: 4, 132: 3, 145: 3, 147: 3, 151: 3, 152: 3, 154: 2, 161: 2, 162: 2, 165: 2, 168: 3, 169: 2, 172: 2, 180: 3, 184: 4, 187: 4, 188: 3, 191: 2, 194: 3, 202: 4, 203: 5, 207: 2, 217: 2, 218: 7, 222: 4, 224: 2, 227: 4, 229: 2, 234: 4, 243: 3, 244: 3, 245: 3, 248: 3, 250: 3, 258: 10, 262: 3, 263: 4, 264: 2, 267: 3, 270: 2, 272: 2, 273: 4, 287: 2, 289: 2, 291: 4, 299: 4, 300: 2, 304: 2, 309: 2, 315: 2, 320: 3, 323: 3, 327: 3, 328: 2, 330: 9, 335: 2, 341: 4, 342: 5, 347: 4, 348: 4, 350: 6, 351: 4, 352: 2, 353: 2, 358: 3, 365: 2, 371: 6, 372: 4, 384: 4, 385: 3, 386: 2, 387: 2, 392: 2, 393: 3, 396: 5, 397: 6, 398: 5, 402: 2} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 53 "The DetNet MPLS data plane builds on MPLS Traffic Engineering encapsulations and mechanisms to provide a forwarding sub-layer that is responsible for providing resource allocation and explicit routes. The forwarding sub-layer is supported by one or more forwarding labels (F-Labels)." "Major clean up and simplification as data plane drafts can be referred for MPLS related details . TSN over DetNet MPLS follows the concept of RFC3985 . Description focus on Edge Nodes procedures and functions . Text covers the Edge Nodes components : ( 1 ) TSN functions ( in NSP block ) ; ( 2 ) DetNet Service Proxy ; and ( 3 ) DetNet sub - layers . Approving from teelcon review" 3486514b01b74d57f031bcf660311de328a6e0dc 3486514b01b74d57f031bcf660311de328a6e0dc draft-ietf-detnet-tsn-vpn-over-mpls d135518ad4230c8f57a3510b3ddea8a99e2355363c9419a27340734427050729 ['e82e49a3c764c0ede490d9e8afe0d0a379ec1e2fb734910d7e42f179709f894c', '1b5276bed81725e3cab5fa8d2491ae7fc344c8638906d8e62ee7c31696edcb52', 'a6a4ee1a9211a2be0e24cf91f9742499a46567acff4c78f62b568b34e38c08de', '44d22f065218a14d5aa04288e7553c8a6d81bb222066c74ea38571bbe922a729', 'c757c3611002031d5ce1ac79d9984d826f392e6628a0657e045c348e52b7eda2', '8a105d9f9ffbf3e747a101e48de19122931cd0cce896dc27f57d16df9dbb75ac', 'a8ff14472a8fa48bacdc11d7089a9d1054c0a786f6152f510b5d4092c22e121f', 'e746630d4b45cf2b654a14e4daaa03ad634e33d92c29c489e3ef3fcd5620c311', '16375944152e6c3e73492437880fe39d7f0123a9292d062e8e9c7d317e4b878f', '42f5214bb177fd7faf01b7943e7f313a615b2490f9109d5cefa8b24101735c32', '5cc97b8f56cdeeb02e7c96183745dc53dd8ec3ec02424107d16eb438c2c9363c', 'a816e4d1392c9c85d398ee2c5116b5de849a9823bc552d322ac8725f7c9b859e', 'c7286f8983508fdd7d94ae798cdc3950cbf65865e905c00a76838a34eb79cf2c', '6924f7b3002e9f0dff9023b70bcc9d484e643c3a2d95b0d5c853c084ad3f68ab', '2d8fce3963de03360a5d98758067925a60474b5430fd8091fc72f3c50a9d38e5', '77f9aaec42bbb94079fae33b8c564cd7f64721106f615e11f22673310efaf01b', '09f8dc962fd9202d148a0b378c9a078ea850056b4b5c360c0914d4a1de6af454', '4826376633600232b766cb8a62d4054b0f5ea45d74878bcf57356e567088300c', '82b410c949db1d81b3f197adbaaba7b82b6e497600cd9883150af2bb815caa19', '0eb73f51f3b491bd6d969a05acf2b527e6e2f09a460cb88266513ab952bd3fc6', '1076eab6753435c114e8a720c951b03da6d4e1bbbf1290f8d58ad7f97a0b8c64', '4ccf918f8b8ae99a769d89e0868a12e4af1536487652436b6c188bc99e14fdb6', '2a5cef1e9c76b52b9b56c6c021a857b0fa757897b6e3c96cc8170d5b73ba8dd8', '07267e696bfbb5af98da5a8efe2b8cf604bc9ab1ce95e4766f017473bfcd0de1', '82f56d4694c2ec964de0a4413954f87ca621628c63d7425944baeff9aa4b6dad', '01e1da53fe2751e7196114efc63dd70d9babc69b4b73c03d4b7528dcc10c05d3', 'fb8f3ca7fafc9c173404ce7f909038443a6078a0c278cb024639410e33f49f88', '44e497e2df0461bad9215c57918855022435eb6e28266916161de3f7902bb352', '84f5bc0e0be5d04b515e8e49efb393e4aec7189222b92c0555cc1be542e74549', '3195c90c03cf6a438b5684cc93128c53f794660a661e2aa85d043ca5ac7060b9', 'b5bacf05f766e143f6de9484b0b5a2d9655d62854368373bd77974b94cb722e6', '2442b9072d522cde54849b40cab26789e4af909f1dd81391cd8c87023515a21c', 'b03d79d1a547b36a28c6cba78f57b8244a4855f6b31003de3e617a5b5eddc070', 'e386562e3156c91934ceb045df46d7e847bb9afcad2794bda59be854f988befc', 'cc980749457292da3a6a4a3ce669ad487409ce72e20857e80c75741c83af7f0a', '75db9ae91b710fcf1df3553b8f9653b12d014f74ba1ee8f931870d2433e163f1', '0e313215df9694bc26777ba4ac347cb8ef73f8475d2bfed664aab722833589ae', '1094721b24c22ff67539ffeabab887f87e538bdd9ebe50b0b369de138d326802', 'fb2b9389e1455c6d64ae19158396d767d88969013b14075bcfdcc764f610108c', 'ae3bdd3a81d96e4aaa02f7d597a2684146f3af75b743bde8e31c3cf5883707db', '1b8137b4c60774716e4a492efec48060d48abd7308563d8cc76edf32d98bd759', '09732023af932d8c578c8a7ead49feb80cdb5c629cee6add2e24fcd7999c0309', '75b7020073ec0c8cedf517f1b56d554e2a5cfdf89d204633c30b863c42ed6f5f', '4be1dfb90ea542d5d84c23c0ba29b91db2491a39973839ee646eeec25c71adb4', 'c98d52f719106d13b14f27abde81ce00305cbf62889690b72da3e3ddc0286c02', '056859e4aa430e2eb983e93f08bb85d9afe9aec44f0e73263cf072df70b7c475', '870147c2dad0a0dda2dd0a9f85ef83b3c4de9a304fdff6d9fa9ccc4bde9d70c0', '26e942b0353fee8f5ac0a2c2e26c9b695c50b35c501eeb4bff343b1648b5cebc', '036168e918418eb807bc3efd361a8e66067192564da41e30e076d22be0f87935', 'a491df768673d76ae7dee4c9bf1ea1456e6c537a1f1683368d8bc6869cd89bf0', 'f6a8cfceb19b4cd796512223b8afd103c4aee7052247ebea8b50f743e9aa27b6', 'd135518ad4230c8f57a3510b3ddea8a99e2355363c9419a27340734427050729', 'cbe90e272b6be7696d3b8c171500847d2b0ae497f6911d0f9d5d8481101c4c1f', '249c961ea29438959ea2204728df24964ec80b8cd91c657715c47014f5e5a462', '1920ebb46d0cee2d379ef48c15f8f6abd01e2a183f316da235e0c3b7515feade', '6d1573b42d5f89f89b26b32cbbd32ff41660e0e8c3b3091f1cb278a42651e049', 'ec6878825845c61b3049ad5dd168197c84938e7f6d4fc938670da2528cf86317', '9829b13faebde69c2279c38cd54d524aa31acfdcc1cfba7910b9d69caa42e0dd', '2755ae7cda161df0c24e1fa9f1c3308bc9ef81a599d859668490484290ca72f4', '09d9dcfc1716808b0c62e47a771ff4d39ba71f22c8640776e65624747a995626', '71dfcd074b80de90c4955890bdbe127d12b249ed764c7c4ca23dc81c74fde71d', '3c1afbb156ee2d672ca131c7c966bc6875374a95d927848bafcc5a158edf67bb'] B "the detnet mpls data plane builds on mpls traffic engineering encapsulations and mechanisms to provide a forwarding sub-layer that is responsible for providing resource allocation and explicit routes. the forwarding sub-layer is supported by one or more forwarding labels (f-labels)." {79: 1, 130: 1, 54: 1, 52: 1, 98: 1, 6: 1, 8: 1, 64: 1, 99: 1, 24: 1, 90: 2, 51: 2, 62: 4, 85: 4, 68: 3, 35: 2, 110: 2, 91: 4, 114: 2, 97: 2, 31: 2, 13: 2, 67: 2, 38: 3, 26: 2, 124: 2, 127: 2, 96: 2, 30: 3, 61: 4, 55: 2, 27: 3, 15: 2, 129: 2, 115: 2, 84: 2, 76: 5, 87: 2, 131: 4, 102: 2, 113: 4, 36: 2, 72: 3} {4: 1, 24: 1, 59: 1, 111: 1, 136: 1, 156: 1, 206: 1, 215: 1, 220: 1, 221: 1, 235: 1, 241: 1, 242: 1, 314: 1, 329: 1, 334: 1, 354: 1, 366: 1, 376: 1, 1: 8, 9: 4, 10: 2, 15: 2, 25: 4, 26: 4, 27: 2, 39: 4, 43: 2, 49: 5, 50: 4, 58: 4, 64: 2, 69: 3, 81: 5, 82: 3, 86: 2, 96: 3, 97: 2, 100: 6, 108: 2, 109: 3, 110: 3, 114: 2, 115: 3, 116: 2, 118: 5, 119: 4, 120: 2, 121: 3, 122: 3, 123: 2, 124: 3, 128: 3, 129: 3, 130: 4, 132: 3, 145: 3, 147: 3, 151: 3, 152: 3, 154: 2, 161: 2, 162: 2, 165: 2, 168: 3, 169: 2, 172: 2, 180: 3, 184: 4, 187: 4, 188: 3, 191: 2, 194: 3, 202: 4, 203: 5, 207: 2, 217: 2, 218: 7, 222: 4, 224: 2, 227: 4, 229: 2, 234: 4, 243: 3, 244: 3, 245: 3, 248: 3, 250: 3, 258: 10, 262: 3, 263: 4, 264: 2, 267: 3, 270: 2, 272: 2, 273: 4, 287: 2, 289: 2, 291: 4, 299: 4, 300: 2, 304: 2, 309: 2, 315: 2, 320: 3, 323: 3, 327: 3, 328: 2, 330: 9, 335: 2, 341: 4, 342: 5, 347: 4, 348: 4, 350: 6, 351: 4, 352: 2, 353: 2, 358: 3, 365: 2, 371: 6, 372: 4, 384: 4, 385: 3, 386: 2, 387: 2, 392: 2, 393: 3, 396: 5, 397: 6, 398: 5, 402: 2} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 53 "DetNet edge/relay nodes are DetNet service sub-layer aware, understand the particular needs of DetNet flows and provide both DetNet service and forwarding sub-layer functions. They add, remove and process d-CWs, S-Labels and F-labels as needed. MPLS enabled DetNet nodes can enhance the reliability of delivery by enabling the replication of packets where multiple copies, possibly over multiple paths, are forwarded through the DetNet domain. They can also eliminate surplus previously replicated copies of DetNet packets. MPLS (DetNet) nodes also include DetNet forwarding sub-layer functions, support for notably explicit routes, and resources allocation to eliminate (or reduce) congestion loss and jitter." "Major clean up and simplification as data plane drafts can be referred for MPLS related details . TSN over DetNet MPLS follows the concept of RFC3985 . Description focus on Edge Nodes procedures and functions . Text covers the Edge Nodes components : ( 1 ) TSN functions ( in NSP block ) ; ( 2 ) DetNet Service Proxy ; and ( 3 ) DetNet sub - layers . Approving from teelcon review" 3486514b01b74d57f031bcf660311de328a6e0dc 3486514b01b74d57f031bcf660311de328a6e0dc draft-ietf-detnet-tsn-vpn-over-mpls 1076eab6753435c114e8a720c951b03da6d4e1bbbf1290f8d58ad7f97a0b8c64 ['e82e49a3c764c0ede490d9e8afe0d0a379ec1e2fb734910d7e42f179709f894c', '1b5276bed81725e3cab5fa8d2491ae7fc344c8638906d8e62ee7c31696edcb52', 'a6a4ee1a9211a2be0e24cf91f9742499a46567acff4c78f62b568b34e38c08de', '44d22f065218a14d5aa04288e7553c8a6d81bb222066c74ea38571bbe922a729', 'c757c3611002031d5ce1ac79d9984d826f392e6628a0657e045c348e52b7eda2', '8a105d9f9ffbf3e747a101e48de19122931cd0cce896dc27f57d16df9dbb75ac', 'a8ff14472a8fa48bacdc11d7089a9d1054c0a786f6152f510b5d4092c22e121f', 'e746630d4b45cf2b654a14e4daaa03ad634e33d92c29c489e3ef3fcd5620c311', '16375944152e6c3e73492437880fe39d7f0123a9292d062e8e9c7d317e4b878f', '42f5214bb177fd7faf01b7943e7f313a615b2490f9109d5cefa8b24101735c32', '5cc97b8f56cdeeb02e7c96183745dc53dd8ec3ec02424107d16eb438c2c9363c', 'a816e4d1392c9c85d398ee2c5116b5de849a9823bc552d322ac8725f7c9b859e', 'c7286f8983508fdd7d94ae798cdc3950cbf65865e905c00a76838a34eb79cf2c', '6924f7b3002e9f0dff9023b70bcc9d484e643c3a2d95b0d5c853c084ad3f68ab', '2d8fce3963de03360a5d98758067925a60474b5430fd8091fc72f3c50a9d38e5', '77f9aaec42bbb94079fae33b8c564cd7f64721106f615e11f22673310efaf01b', '09f8dc962fd9202d148a0b378c9a078ea850056b4b5c360c0914d4a1de6af454', '4826376633600232b766cb8a62d4054b0f5ea45d74878bcf57356e567088300c', '82b410c949db1d81b3f197adbaaba7b82b6e497600cd9883150af2bb815caa19', '0eb73f51f3b491bd6d969a05acf2b527e6e2f09a460cb88266513ab952bd3fc6', '1076eab6753435c114e8a720c951b03da6d4e1bbbf1290f8d58ad7f97a0b8c64', '4ccf918f8b8ae99a769d89e0868a12e4af1536487652436b6c188bc99e14fdb6', '2a5cef1e9c76b52b9b56c6c021a857b0fa757897b6e3c96cc8170d5b73ba8dd8', '07267e696bfbb5af98da5a8efe2b8cf604bc9ab1ce95e4766f017473bfcd0de1', '82f56d4694c2ec964de0a4413954f87ca621628c63d7425944baeff9aa4b6dad', '01e1da53fe2751e7196114efc63dd70d9babc69b4b73c03d4b7528dcc10c05d3', 'fb8f3ca7fafc9c173404ce7f909038443a6078a0c278cb024639410e33f49f88', '44e497e2df0461bad9215c57918855022435eb6e28266916161de3f7902bb352', '84f5bc0e0be5d04b515e8e49efb393e4aec7189222b92c0555cc1be542e74549', '3195c90c03cf6a438b5684cc93128c53f794660a661e2aa85d043ca5ac7060b9', 'b5bacf05f766e143f6de9484b0b5a2d9655d62854368373bd77974b94cb722e6', '2442b9072d522cde54849b40cab26789e4af909f1dd81391cd8c87023515a21c', 'b03d79d1a547b36a28c6cba78f57b8244a4855f6b31003de3e617a5b5eddc070', 'e386562e3156c91934ceb045df46d7e847bb9afcad2794bda59be854f988befc', 'cc980749457292da3a6a4a3ce669ad487409ce72e20857e80c75741c83af7f0a', '75db9ae91b710fcf1df3553b8f9653b12d014f74ba1ee8f931870d2433e163f1', '0e313215df9694bc26777ba4ac347cb8ef73f8475d2bfed664aab722833589ae', '1094721b24c22ff67539ffeabab887f87e538bdd9ebe50b0b369de138d326802', 'fb2b9389e1455c6d64ae19158396d767d88969013b14075bcfdcc764f610108c', 'ae3bdd3a81d96e4aaa02f7d597a2684146f3af75b743bde8e31c3cf5883707db', '1b8137b4c60774716e4a492efec48060d48abd7308563d8cc76edf32d98bd759', '09732023af932d8c578c8a7ead49feb80cdb5c629cee6add2e24fcd7999c0309', '75b7020073ec0c8cedf517f1b56d554e2a5cfdf89d204633c30b863c42ed6f5f', '4be1dfb90ea542d5d84c23c0ba29b91db2491a39973839ee646eeec25c71adb4', 'c98d52f719106d13b14f27abde81ce00305cbf62889690b72da3e3ddc0286c02', '056859e4aa430e2eb983e93f08bb85d9afe9aec44f0e73263cf072df70b7c475', '870147c2dad0a0dda2dd0a9f85ef83b3c4de9a304fdff6d9fa9ccc4bde9d70c0', '26e942b0353fee8f5ac0a2c2e26c9b695c50b35c501eeb4bff343b1648b5cebc', '036168e918418eb807bc3efd361a8e66067192564da41e30e076d22be0f87935', 'a491df768673d76ae7dee4c9bf1ea1456e6c537a1f1683368d8bc6869cd89bf0', 'f6a8cfceb19b4cd796512223b8afd103c4aee7052247ebea8b50f743e9aa27b6', 'd135518ad4230c8f57a3510b3ddea8a99e2355363c9419a27340734427050729', 'cbe90e272b6be7696d3b8c171500847d2b0ae497f6911d0f9d5d8481101c4c1f', '249c961ea29438959ea2204728df24964ec80b8cd91c657715c47014f5e5a462', '1920ebb46d0cee2d379ef48c15f8f6abd01e2a183f316da235e0c3b7515feade', '6d1573b42d5f89f89b26b32cbbd32ff41660e0e8c3b3091f1cb278a42651e049', 'ec6878825845c61b3049ad5dd168197c84938e7f6d4fc938670da2528cf86317', '9829b13faebde69c2279c38cd54d524aa31acfdcc1cfba7910b9d69caa42e0dd', '2755ae7cda161df0c24e1fa9f1c3308bc9ef81a599d859668490484290ca72f4', '09d9dcfc1716808b0c62e47a771ff4d39ba71f22c8640776e65624747a995626', '71dfcd074b80de90c4955890bdbe127d12b249ed764c7c4ca23dc81c74fde71d', '3c1afbb156ee2d672ca131c7c966bc6875374a95d927848bafcc5a158edf67bb'] B "detnet edge/relay nodes are detnet service sub-layer aware, understand the particular needs of detnet flows and provide both detnet service and forwarding sub-layer functions. they add, remove and process d-cws, s-labels and f-labels as needed. mpls enabled detnet nodes can enhance the reliability of delivery by enabling the replication of packets where multiple copies, possibly over multiple paths, are forwarded through the detnet domain. they can also eliminate surplus previously replicated copies of detnet packets. mpls (detnet) nodes also include detnet forwarding sub-layer functions, support for notably explicit routes, and resources allocation to eliminate (or reduce) congestion loss and jitter." {79: 1, 130: 1, 54: 1, 52: 1, 98: 1, 6: 1, 8: 1, 64: 1, 99: 1, 24: 1, 90: 2, 51: 2, 62: 4, 85: 4, 68: 3, 35: 2, 110: 2, 91: 4, 114: 2, 97: 2, 31: 2, 13: 2, 67: 2, 38: 3, 26: 2, 124: 2, 127: 2, 96: 2, 30: 3, 61: 4, 55: 2, 27: 3, 15: 2, 129: 2, 115: 2, 84: 2, 76: 5, 87: 2, 131: 4, 102: 2, 113: 4, 36: 2, 72: 3} {4: 1, 24: 1, 59: 1, 111: 1, 136: 1, 156: 1, 206: 1, 215: 1, 220: 1, 221: 1, 235: 1, 241: 1, 242: 1, 314: 1, 329: 1, 334: 1, 354: 1, 366: 1, 376: 1, 1: 8, 9: 4, 10: 2, 15: 2, 25: 4, 26: 4, 27: 2, 39: 4, 43: 2, 49: 5, 50: 4, 58: 4, 64: 2, 69: 3, 81: 5, 82: 3, 86: 2, 96: 3, 97: 2, 100: 6, 108: 2, 109: 3, 110: 3, 114: 2, 115: 3, 116: 2, 118: 5, 119: 4, 120: 2, 121: 3, 122: 3, 123: 2, 124: 3, 128: 3, 129: 3, 130: 4, 132: 3, 145: 3, 147: 3, 151: 3, 152: 3, 154: 2, 161: 2, 162: 2, 165: 2, 168: 3, 169: 2, 172: 2, 180: 3, 184: 4, 187: 4, 188: 3, 191: 2, 194: 3, 202: 4, 203: 5, 207: 2, 217: 2, 218: 7, 222: 4, 224: 2, 227: 4, 229: 2, 234: 4, 243: 3, 244: 3, 245: 3, 248: 3, 250: 3, 258: 10, 262: 3, 263: 4, 264: 2, 267: 3, 270: 2, 272: 2, 273: 4, 287: 2, 289: 2, 291: 4, 299: 4, 300: 2, 304: 2, 309: 2, 315: 2, 320: 3, 323: 3, 327: 3, 328: 2, 330: 9, 335: 2, 341: 4, 342: 5, 347: 4, 348: 4, 350: 6, 351: 4, 352: 2, 353: 2, 358: 3, 365: 2, 371: 6, 372: 4, 384: 4, 385: 3, 386: 2, 387: 2, 392: 2, 393: 3, 396: 5, 397: 6, 398: 5, 402: 2} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 53 "DetNet transit nodes reside wholly within a DetNet domain, and also provide DetNet forwarding sub-layer functions in accordance with the performance required by a DetNet flow carried over an LSP. Unlike other DetNet node types, transit nodes provide no service sub-layer processing." "Major clean up and simplification as data plane drafts can be referred for MPLS related details . TSN over DetNet MPLS follows the concept of RFC3985 . Description focus on Edge Nodes procedures and functions . Text covers the Edge Nodes components : ( 1 ) TSN functions ( in NSP block ) ; ( 2 ) DetNet Service Proxy ; and ( 3 ) DetNet sub - layers . Approving from teelcon review" 3486514b01b74d57f031bcf660311de328a6e0dc 3486514b01b74d57f031bcf660311de328a6e0dc draft-ietf-detnet-tsn-vpn-over-mpls 44e497e2df0461bad9215c57918855022435eb6e28266916161de3f7902bb352 ['e82e49a3c764c0ede490d9e8afe0d0a379ec1e2fb734910d7e42f179709f894c', '1b5276bed81725e3cab5fa8d2491ae7fc344c8638906d8e62ee7c31696edcb52', 'a6a4ee1a9211a2be0e24cf91f9742499a46567acff4c78f62b568b34e38c08de', '44d22f065218a14d5aa04288e7553c8a6d81bb222066c74ea38571bbe922a729', 'c757c3611002031d5ce1ac79d9984d826f392e6628a0657e045c348e52b7eda2', '8a105d9f9ffbf3e747a101e48de19122931cd0cce896dc27f57d16df9dbb75ac', 'a8ff14472a8fa48bacdc11d7089a9d1054c0a786f6152f510b5d4092c22e121f', 'e746630d4b45cf2b654a14e4daaa03ad634e33d92c29c489e3ef3fcd5620c311', '16375944152e6c3e73492437880fe39d7f0123a9292d062e8e9c7d317e4b878f', '42f5214bb177fd7faf01b7943e7f313a615b2490f9109d5cefa8b24101735c32', '5cc97b8f56cdeeb02e7c96183745dc53dd8ec3ec02424107d16eb438c2c9363c', 'a816e4d1392c9c85d398ee2c5116b5de849a9823bc552d322ac8725f7c9b859e', 'c7286f8983508fdd7d94ae798cdc3950cbf65865e905c00a76838a34eb79cf2c', '6924f7b3002e9f0dff9023b70bcc9d484e643c3a2d95b0d5c853c084ad3f68ab', '2d8fce3963de03360a5d98758067925a60474b5430fd8091fc72f3c50a9d38e5', '77f9aaec42bbb94079fae33b8c564cd7f64721106f615e11f22673310efaf01b', '09f8dc962fd9202d148a0b378c9a078ea850056b4b5c360c0914d4a1de6af454', '4826376633600232b766cb8a62d4054b0f5ea45d74878bcf57356e567088300c', '82b410c949db1d81b3f197adbaaba7b82b6e497600cd9883150af2bb815caa19', '0eb73f51f3b491bd6d969a05acf2b527e6e2f09a460cb88266513ab952bd3fc6', '1076eab6753435c114e8a720c951b03da6d4e1bbbf1290f8d58ad7f97a0b8c64', '4ccf918f8b8ae99a769d89e0868a12e4af1536487652436b6c188bc99e14fdb6', '2a5cef1e9c76b52b9b56c6c021a857b0fa757897b6e3c96cc8170d5b73ba8dd8', '07267e696bfbb5af98da5a8efe2b8cf604bc9ab1ce95e4766f017473bfcd0de1', '82f56d4694c2ec964de0a4413954f87ca621628c63d7425944baeff9aa4b6dad', '01e1da53fe2751e7196114efc63dd70d9babc69b4b73c03d4b7528dcc10c05d3', 'fb8f3ca7fafc9c173404ce7f909038443a6078a0c278cb024639410e33f49f88', '44e497e2df0461bad9215c57918855022435eb6e28266916161de3f7902bb352', '84f5bc0e0be5d04b515e8e49efb393e4aec7189222b92c0555cc1be542e74549', '3195c90c03cf6a438b5684cc93128c53f794660a661e2aa85d043ca5ac7060b9', 'b5bacf05f766e143f6de9484b0b5a2d9655d62854368373bd77974b94cb722e6', '2442b9072d522cde54849b40cab26789e4af909f1dd81391cd8c87023515a21c', 'b03d79d1a547b36a28c6cba78f57b8244a4855f6b31003de3e617a5b5eddc070', 'e386562e3156c91934ceb045df46d7e847bb9afcad2794bda59be854f988befc', 'cc980749457292da3a6a4a3ce669ad487409ce72e20857e80c75741c83af7f0a', '75db9ae91b710fcf1df3553b8f9653b12d014f74ba1ee8f931870d2433e163f1', '0e313215df9694bc26777ba4ac347cb8ef73f8475d2bfed664aab722833589ae', '1094721b24c22ff67539ffeabab887f87e538bdd9ebe50b0b369de138d326802', 'fb2b9389e1455c6d64ae19158396d767d88969013b14075bcfdcc764f610108c', 'ae3bdd3a81d96e4aaa02f7d597a2684146f3af75b743bde8e31c3cf5883707db', '1b8137b4c60774716e4a492efec48060d48abd7308563d8cc76edf32d98bd759', '09732023af932d8c578c8a7ead49feb80cdb5c629cee6add2e24fcd7999c0309', '75b7020073ec0c8cedf517f1b56d554e2a5cfdf89d204633c30b863c42ed6f5f', '4be1dfb90ea542d5d84c23c0ba29b91db2491a39973839ee646eeec25c71adb4', 'c98d52f719106d13b14f27abde81ce00305cbf62889690b72da3e3ddc0286c02', '056859e4aa430e2eb983e93f08bb85d9afe9aec44f0e73263cf072df70b7c475', '870147c2dad0a0dda2dd0a9f85ef83b3c4de9a304fdff6d9fa9ccc4bde9d70c0', '26e942b0353fee8f5ac0a2c2e26c9b695c50b35c501eeb4bff343b1648b5cebc', '036168e918418eb807bc3efd361a8e66067192564da41e30e076d22be0f87935', 'a491df768673d76ae7dee4c9bf1ea1456e6c537a1f1683368d8bc6869cd89bf0', 'f6a8cfceb19b4cd796512223b8afd103c4aee7052247ebea8b50f743e9aa27b6', 'd135518ad4230c8f57a3510b3ddea8a99e2355363c9419a27340734427050729', 'cbe90e272b6be7696d3b8c171500847d2b0ae497f6911d0f9d5d8481101c4c1f', '249c961ea29438959ea2204728df24964ec80b8cd91c657715c47014f5e5a462', '1920ebb46d0cee2d379ef48c15f8f6abd01e2a183f316da235e0c3b7515feade', '6d1573b42d5f89f89b26b32cbbd32ff41660e0e8c3b3091f1cb278a42651e049', 'ec6878825845c61b3049ad5dd168197c84938e7f6d4fc938670da2528cf86317', '9829b13faebde69c2279c38cd54d524aa31acfdcc1cfba7910b9d69caa42e0dd', '2755ae7cda161df0c24e1fa9f1c3308bc9ef81a599d859668490484290ca72f4', '09d9dcfc1716808b0c62e47a771ff4d39ba71f22c8640776e65624747a995626', '71dfcd074b80de90c4955890bdbe127d12b249ed764c7c4ca23dc81c74fde71d', '3c1afbb156ee2d672ca131c7c966bc6875374a95d927848bafcc5a158edf67bb'] B "detnet transit nodes reside wholly within a detnet domain, and also provide detnet forwarding sub-layer functions in accordance with the performance required by a detnet flow carried over an lsp. unlike other detnet node types, transit nodes provide no service sub-layer processing." {79: 1, 130: 1, 54: 1, 52: 1, 98: 1, 6: 1, 8: 1, 64: 1, 99: 1, 24: 1, 90: 2, 51: 2, 62: 4, 85: 4, 68: 3, 35: 2, 110: 2, 91: 4, 114: 2, 97: 2, 31: 2, 13: 2, 67: 2, 38: 3, 26: 2, 124: 2, 127: 2, 96: 2, 30: 3, 61: 4, 55: 2, 27: 3, 15: 2, 129: 2, 115: 2, 84: 2, 76: 5, 87: 2, 131: 4, 102: 2, 113: 4, 36: 2, 72: 3} {4: 1, 24: 1, 59: 1, 111: 1, 136: 1, 156: 1, 206: 1, 215: 1, 220: 1, 221: 1, 235: 1, 241: 1, 242: 1, 314: 1, 329: 1, 334: 1, 354: 1, 366: 1, 376: 1, 1: 8, 9: 4, 10: 2, 15: 2, 25: 4, 26: 4, 27: 2, 39: 4, 43: 2, 49: 5, 50: 4, 58: 4, 64: 2, 69: 3, 81: 5, 82: 3, 86: 2, 96: 3, 97: 2, 100: 6, 108: 2, 109: 3, 110: 3, 114: 2, 115: 3, 116: 2, 118: 5, 119: 4, 120: 2, 121: 3, 122: 3, 123: 2, 124: 3, 128: 3, 129: 3, 130: 4, 132: 3, 145: 3, 147: 3, 151: 3, 152: 3, 154: 2, 161: 2, 162: 2, 165: 2, 168: 3, 169: 2, 172: 2, 180: 3, 184: 4, 187: 4, 188: 3, 191: 2, 194: 3, 202: 4, 203: 5, 207: 2, 217: 2, 218: 7, 222: 4, 224: 2, 227: 4, 229: 2, 234: 4, 243: 3, 244: 3, 245: 3, 248: 3, 250: 3, 258: 10, 262: 3, 263: 4, 264: 2, 267: 3, 270: 2, 272: 2, 273: 4, 287: 2, 289: 2, 291: 4, 299: 4, 300: 2, 304: 2, 309: 2, 315: 2, 320: 3, 323: 3, 327: 3, 328: 2, 330: 9, 335: 2, 341: 4, 342: 5, 347: 4, 348: 4, 350: 6, 351: 4, 352: 2, 353: 2, 358: 3, 365: 2, 371: 6, 372: 4, 384: 4, 385: 3, 386: 2, 387: 2, 392: 2, 393: 3, 396: 5, 397: 6, 398: 5, 402: 2} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 53 "The basic encapsulation approach is to treat a TSN Stream as an app- flow from the DetNet MPLS perspective. The corresponding example shown in fig_tsn_mpls_ex." "Major clean up and simplification as data plane drafts can be referred for MPLS related details . TSN over DetNet MPLS follows the concept of RFC3985 . Description focus on Edge Nodes procedures and functions . Text covers the Edge Nodes components : ( 1 ) TSN functions ( in NSP block ) ; ( 2 ) DetNet Service Proxy ; and ( 3 ) DetNet sub - layers . Approving from teelcon review" 3486514b01b74d57f031bcf660311de328a6e0dc 3486514b01b74d57f031bcf660311de328a6e0dc draft-ietf-detnet-tsn-vpn-over-mpls 84f5bc0e0be5d04b515e8e49efb393e4aec7189222b92c0555cc1be542e74549 ['e82e49a3c764c0ede490d9e8afe0d0a379ec1e2fb734910d7e42f179709f894c', '1b5276bed81725e3cab5fa8d2491ae7fc344c8638906d8e62ee7c31696edcb52', 'a6a4ee1a9211a2be0e24cf91f9742499a46567acff4c78f62b568b34e38c08de', '44d22f065218a14d5aa04288e7553c8a6d81bb222066c74ea38571bbe922a729', 'c757c3611002031d5ce1ac79d9984d826f392e6628a0657e045c348e52b7eda2', '8a105d9f9ffbf3e747a101e48de19122931cd0cce896dc27f57d16df9dbb75ac', 'a8ff14472a8fa48bacdc11d7089a9d1054c0a786f6152f510b5d4092c22e121f', 'e746630d4b45cf2b654a14e4daaa03ad634e33d92c29c489e3ef3fcd5620c311', '16375944152e6c3e73492437880fe39d7f0123a9292d062e8e9c7d317e4b878f', '42f5214bb177fd7faf01b7943e7f313a615b2490f9109d5cefa8b24101735c32', '5cc97b8f56cdeeb02e7c96183745dc53dd8ec3ec02424107d16eb438c2c9363c', 'a816e4d1392c9c85d398ee2c5116b5de849a9823bc552d322ac8725f7c9b859e', 'c7286f8983508fdd7d94ae798cdc3950cbf65865e905c00a76838a34eb79cf2c', '6924f7b3002e9f0dff9023b70bcc9d484e643c3a2d95b0d5c853c084ad3f68ab', '2d8fce3963de03360a5d98758067925a60474b5430fd8091fc72f3c50a9d38e5', '77f9aaec42bbb94079fae33b8c564cd7f64721106f615e11f22673310efaf01b', '09f8dc962fd9202d148a0b378c9a078ea850056b4b5c360c0914d4a1de6af454', '4826376633600232b766cb8a62d4054b0f5ea45d74878bcf57356e567088300c', '82b410c949db1d81b3f197adbaaba7b82b6e497600cd9883150af2bb815caa19', '0eb73f51f3b491bd6d969a05acf2b527e6e2f09a460cb88266513ab952bd3fc6', '1076eab6753435c114e8a720c951b03da6d4e1bbbf1290f8d58ad7f97a0b8c64', '4ccf918f8b8ae99a769d89e0868a12e4af1536487652436b6c188bc99e14fdb6', '2a5cef1e9c76b52b9b56c6c021a857b0fa757897b6e3c96cc8170d5b73ba8dd8', '07267e696bfbb5af98da5a8efe2b8cf604bc9ab1ce95e4766f017473bfcd0de1', '82f56d4694c2ec964de0a4413954f87ca621628c63d7425944baeff9aa4b6dad', '01e1da53fe2751e7196114efc63dd70d9babc69b4b73c03d4b7528dcc10c05d3', 'fb8f3ca7fafc9c173404ce7f909038443a6078a0c278cb024639410e33f49f88', '44e497e2df0461bad9215c57918855022435eb6e28266916161de3f7902bb352', '84f5bc0e0be5d04b515e8e49efb393e4aec7189222b92c0555cc1be542e74549', '3195c90c03cf6a438b5684cc93128c53f794660a661e2aa85d043ca5ac7060b9', 'b5bacf05f766e143f6de9484b0b5a2d9655d62854368373bd77974b94cb722e6', '2442b9072d522cde54849b40cab26789e4af909f1dd81391cd8c87023515a21c', 'b03d79d1a547b36a28c6cba78f57b8244a4855f6b31003de3e617a5b5eddc070', 'e386562e3156c91934ceb045df46d7e847bb9afcad2794bda59be854f988befc', 'cc980749457292da3a6a4a3ce669ad487409ce72e20857e80c75741c83af7f0a', '75db9ae91b710fcf1df3553b8f9653b12d014f74ba1ee8f931870d2433e163f1', '0e313215df9694bc26777ba4ac347cb8ef73f8475d2bfed664aab722833589ae', '1094721b24c22ff67539ffeabab887f87e538bdd9ebe50b0b369de138d326802', 'fb2b9389e1455c6d64ae19158396d767d88969013b14075bcfdcc764f610108c', 'ae3bdd3a81d96e4aaa02f7d597a2684146f3af75b743bde8e31c3cf5883707db', '1b8137b4c60774716e4a492efec48060d48abd7308563d8cc76edf32d98bd759', '09732023af932d8c578c8a7ead49feb80cdb5c629cee6add2e24fcd7999c0309', '75b7020073ec0c8cedf517f1b56d554e2a5cfdf89d204633c30b863c42ed6f5f', '4be1dfb90ea542d5d84c23c0ba29b91db2491a39973839ee646eeec25c71adb4', 'c98d52f719106d13b14f27abde81ce00305cbf62889690b72da3e3ddc0286c02', '056859e4aa430e2eb983e93f08bb85d9afe9aec44f0e73263cf072df70b7c475', '870147c2dad0a0dda2dd0a9f85ef83b3c4de9a304fdff6d9fa9ccc4bde9d70c0', '26e942b0353fee8f5ac0a2c2e26c9b695c50b35c501eeb4bff343b1648b5cebc', '036168e918418eb807bc3efd361a8e66067192564da41e30e076d22be0f87935', 'a491df768673d76ae7dee4c9bf1ea1456e6c537a1f1683368d8bc6869cd89bf0', 'f6a8cfceb19b4cd796512223b8afd103c4aee7052247ebea8b50f743e9aa27b6', 'd135518ad4230c8f57a3510b3ddea8a99e2355363c9419a27340734427050729', 'cbe90e272b6be7696d3b8c171500847d2b0ae497f6911d0f9d5d8481101c4c1f', '249c961ea29438959ea2204728df24964ec80b8cd91c657715c47014f5e5a462', '1920ebb46d0cee2d379ef48c15f8f6abd01e2a183f316da235e0c3b7515feade', '6d1573b42d5f89f89b26b32cbbd32ff41660e0e8c3b3091f1cb278a42651e049', 'ec6878825845c61b3049ad5dd168197c84938e7f6d4fc938670da2528cf86317', '9829b13faebde69c2279c38cd54d524aa31acfdcc1cfba7910b9d69caa42e0dd', '2755ae7cda161df0c24e1fa9f1c3308bc9ef81a599d859668490484290ca72f4', '09d9dcfc1716808b0c62e47a771ff4d39ba71f22c8640776e65624747a995626', '71dfcd074b80de90c4955890bdbe127d12b249ed764c7c4ca23dc81c74fde71d', '3c1afbb156ee2d672ca131c7c966bc6875374a95d927848bafcc5a158edf67bb'] B "the basic encapsulation approach is to treat a tsn stream as an app- flow from the detnet mpls perspective. the corresponding example shown in fig_tsn_mpls_ex." {79: 1, 130: 1, 54: 1, 52: 1, 98: 1, 6: 1, 8: 1, 64: 1, 99: 1, 24: 1, 90: 2, 51: 2, 62: 4, 85: 4, 68: 3, 35: 2, 110: 2, 91: 4, 114: 2, 97: 2, 31: 2, 13: 2, 67: 2, 38: 3, 26: 2, 124: 2, 127: 2, 96: 2, 30: 3, 61: 4, 55: 2, 27: 3, 15: 2, 129: 2, 115: 2, 84: 2, 76: 5, 87: 2, 131: 4, 102: 2, 113: 4, 36: 2, 72: 3} {4: 1, 24: 1, 59: 1, 111: 1, 136: 1, 156: 1, 206: 1, 215: 1, 220: 1, 221: 1, 235: 1, 241: 1, 242: 1, 314: 1, 329: 1, 334: 1, 354: 1, 366: 1, 376: 1, 1: 8, 9: 4, 10: 2, 15: 2, 25: 4, 26: 4, 27: 2, 39: 4, 43: 2, 49: 5, 50: 4, 58: 4, 64: 2, 69: 3, 81: 5, 82: 3, 86: 2, 96: 3, 97: 2, 100: 6, 108: 2, 109: 3, 110: 3, 114: 2, 115: 3, 116: 2, 118: 5, 119: 4, 120: 2, 121: 3, 122: 3, 123: 2, 124: 3, 128: 3, 129: 3, 130: 4, 132: 3, 145: 3, 147: 3, 151: 3, 152: 3, 154: 2, 161: 2, 162: 2, 165: 2, 168: 3, 169: 2, 172: 2, 180: 3, 184: 4, 187: 4, 188: 3, 191: 2, 194: 3, 202: 4, 203: 5, 207: 2, 217: 2, 218: 7, 222: 4, 224: 2, 227: 4, 229: 2, 234: 4, 243: 3, 244: 3, 245: 3, 248: 3, 250: 3, 258: 10, 262: 3, 263: 4, 264: 2, 267: 3, 270: 2, 272: 2, 273: 4, 287: 2, 289: 2, 291: 4, 299: 4, 300: 2, 304: 2, 309: 2, 315: 2, 320: 3, 323: 3, 327: 3, 328: 2, 330: 9, 335: 2, 341: 4, 342: 5, 347: 4, 348: 4, 350: 6, 351: 4, 352: 2, 353: 2, 358: 3, 365: 2, 371: 6, 372: 4, 384: 4, 385: 3, 386: 2, 387: 2, 392: 2, 393: 3, 396: 5, 397: 6, 398: 5, 402: 2} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 53 "In the figure, ""Application"" indicates the application payload carried by the TSN network. ""MPLS App-Flow"" indicates that the TSN Stream is the payload from the perspective of the DetNet MPLS data plane defined in I-D.ietf-detnet-mpls. A single DetNet MPLS flow can aggregate multiple TSN Streams." "Major clean up and simplification as data plane drafts can be referred for MPLS related details . TSN over DetNet MPLS follows the concept of RFC3985 . Description focus on Edge Nodes procedures and functions . Text covers the Edge Nodes components : ( 1 ) TSN functions ( in NSP block ) ; ( 2 ) DetNet Service Proxy ; and ( 3 ) DetNet sub - layers . Approving from teelcon review" 3486514b01b74d57f031bcf660311de328a6e0dc 3486514b01b74d57f031bcf660311de328a6e0dc draft-ietf-detnet-tsn-vpn-over-mpls 1b8137b4c60774716e4a492efec48060d48abd7308563d8cc76edf32d98bd759 ['e82e49a3c764c0ede490d9e8afe0d0a379ec1e2fb734910d7e42f179709f894c', '1b5276bed81725e3cab5fa8d2491ae7fc344c8638906d8e62ee7c31696edcb52', 'a6a4ee1a9211a2be0e24cf91f9742499a46567acff4c78f62b568b34e38c08de', '44d22f065218a14d5aa04288e7553c8a6d81bb222066c74ea38571bbe922a729', 'c757c3611002031d5ce1ac79d9984d826f392e6628a0657e045c348e52b7eda2', '8a105d9f9ffbf3e747a101e48de19122931cd0cce896dc27f57d16df9dbb75ac', 'a8ff14472a8fa48bacdc11d7089a9d1054c0a786f6152f510b5d4092c22e121f', 'e746630d4b45cf2b654a14e4daaa03ad634e33d92c29c489e3ef3fcd5620c311', '16375944152e6c3e73492437880fe39d7f0123a9292d062e8e9c7d317e4b878f', '42f5214bb177fd7faf01b7943e7f313a615b2490f9109d5cefa8b24101735c32', '5cc97b8f56cdeeb02e7c96183745dc53dd8ec3ec02424107d16eb438c2c9363c', 'a816e4d1392c9c85d398ee2c5116b5de849a9823bc552d322ac8725f7c9b859e', 'c7286f8983508fdd7d94ae798cdc3950cbf65865e905c00a76838a34eb79cf2c', '6924f7b3002e9f0dff9023b70bcc9d484e643c3a2d95b0d5c853c084ad3f68ab', '2d8fce3963de03360a5d98758067925a60474b5430fd8091fc72f3c50a9d38e5', '77f9aaec42bbb94079fae33b8c564cd7f64721106f615e11f22673310efaf01b', '09f8dc962fd9202d148a0b378c9a078ea850056b4b5c360c0914d4a1de6af454', '4826376633600232b766cb8a62d4054b0f5ea45d74878bcf57356e567088300c', '82b410c949db1d81b3f197adbaaba7b82b6e497600cd9883150af2bb815caa19', '0eb73f51f3b491bd6d969a05acf2b527e6e2f09a460cb88266513ab952bd3fc6', '1076eab6753435c114e8a720c951b03da6d4e1bbbf1290f8d58ad7f97a0b8c64', '4ccf918f8b8ae99a769d89e0868a12e4af1536487652436b6c188bc99e14fdb6', '2a5cef1e9c76b52b9b56c6c021a857b0fa757897b6e3c96cc8170d5b73ba8dd8', '07267e696bfbb5af98da5a8efe2b8cf604bc9ab1ce95e4766f017473bfcd0de1', '82f56d4694c2ec964de0a4413954f87ca621628c63d7425944baeff9aa4b6dad', '01e1da53fe2751e7196114efc63dd70d9babc69b4b73c03d4b7528dcc10c05d3', 'fb8f3ca7fafc9c173404ce7f909038443a6078a0c278cb024639410e33f49f88', '44e497e2df0461bad9215c57918855022435eb6e28266916161de3f7902bb352', '84f5bc0e0be5d04b515e8e49efb393e4aec7189222b92c0555cc1be542e74549', '3195c90c03cf6a438b5684cc93128c53f794660a661e2aa85d043ca5ac7060b9', 'b5bacf05f766e143f6de9484b0b5a2d9655d62854368373bd77974b94cb722e6', '2442b9072d522cde54849b40cab26789e4af909f1dd81391cd8c87023515a21c', 'b03d79d1a547b36a28c6cba78f57b8244a4855f6b31003de3e617a5b5eddc070', 'e386562e3156c91934ceb045df46d7e847bb9afcad2794bda59be854f988befc', 'cc980749457292da3a6a4a3ce669ad487409ce72e20857e80c75741c83af7f0a', '75db9ae91b710fcf1df3553b8f9653b12d014f74ba1ee8f931870d2433e163f1', '0e313215df9694bc26777ba4ac347cb8ef73f8475d2bfed664aab722833589ae', '1094721b24c22ff67539ffeabab887f87e538bdd9ebe50b0b369de138d326802', 'fb2b9389e1455c6d64ae19158396d767d88969013b14075bcfdcc764f610108c', 'ae3bdd3a81d96e4aaa02f7d597a2684146f3af75b743bde8e31c3cf5883707db', '1b8137b4c60774716e4a492efec48060d48abd7308563d8cc76edf32d98bd759', '09732023af932d8c578c8a7ead49feb80cdb5c629cee6add2e24fcd7999c0309', '75b7020073ec0c8cedf517f1b56d554e2a5cfdf89d204633c30b863c42ed6f5f', '4be1dfb90ea542d5d84c23c0ba29b91db2491a39973839ee646eeec25c71adb4', 'c98d52f719106d13b14f27abde81ce00305cbf62889690b72da3e3ddc0286c02', '056859e4aa430e2eb983e93f08bb85d9afe9aec44f0e73263cf072df70b7c475', '870147c2dad0a0dda2dd0a9f85ef83b3c4de9a304fdff6d9fa9ccc4bde9d70c0', '26e942b0353fee8f5ac0a2c2e26c9b695c50b35c501eeb4bff343b1648b5cebc', '036168e918418eb807bc3efd361a8e66067192564da41e30e076d22be0f87935', 'a491df768673d76ae7dee4c9bf1ea1456e6c537a1f1683368d8bc6869cd89bf0', 'f6a8cfceb19b4cd796512223b8afd103c4aee7052247ebea8b50f743e9aa27b6', 'd135518ad4230c8f57a3510b3ddea8a99e2355363c9419a27340734427050729', 'cbe90e272b6be7696d3b8c171500847d2b0ae497f6911d0f9d5d8481101c4c1f', '249c961ea29438959ea2204728df24964ec80b8cd91c657715c47014f5e5a462', '1920ebb46d0cee2d379ef48c15f8f6abd01e2a183f316da235e0c3b7515feade', '6d1573b42d5f89f89b26b32cbbd32ff41660e0e8c3b3091f1cb278a42651e049', 'ec6878825845c61b3049ad5dd168197c84938e7f6d4fc938670da2528cf86317', '9829b13faebde69c2279c38cd54d524aa31acfdcc1cfba7910b9d69caa42e0dd', '2755ae7cda161df0c24e1fa9f1c3308bc9ef81a599d859668490484290ca72f4', '09d9dcfc1716808b0c62e47a771ff4d39ba71f22c8640776e65624747a995626', '71dfcd074b80de90c4955890bdbe127d12b249ed764c7c4ca23dc81c74fde71d', '3c1afbb156ee2d672ca131c7c966bc6875374a95d927848bafcc5a158edf67bb'] B "in the figure, ""application"" indicates the application payload carried by the tsn network. ""mpls app-flow"" indicates that the tsn stream is the payload from the perspective of the detnet mpls data plane defined in i-d.ietf-detnet-mpls. a single detnet mpls flow can aggregate multiple tsn streams." {79: 1, 130: 1, 54: 1, 52: 1, 98: 1, 6: 1, 8: 1, 64: 1, 99: 1, 24: 1, 90: 2, 51: 2, 62: 4, 85: 4, 68: 3, 35: 2, 110: 2, 91: 4, 114: 2, 97: 2, 31: 2, 13: 2, 67: 2, 38: 3, 26: 2, 124: 2, 127: 2, 96: 2, 30: 3, 61: 4, 55: 2, 27: 3, 15: 2, 129: 2, 115: 2, 84: 2, 76: 5, 87: 2, 131: 4, 102: 2, 113: 4, 36: 2, 72: 3} {4: 1, 24: 1, 59: 1, 111: 1, 136: 1, 156: 1, 206: 1, 215: 1, 220: 1, 221: 1, 235: 1, 241: 1, 242: 1, 314: 1, 329: 1, 334: 1, 354: 1, 366: 1, 376: 1, 1: 8, 9: 4, 10: 2, 15: 2, 25: 4, 26: 4, 27: 2, 39: 4, 43: 2, 49: 5, 50: 4, 58: 4, 64: 2, 69: 3, 81: 5, 82: 3, 86: 2, 96: 3, 97: 2, 100: 6, 108: 2, 109: 3, 110: 3, 114: 2, 115: 3, 116: 2, 118: 5, 119: 4, 120: 2, 121: 3, 122: 3, 123: 2, 124: 3, 128: 3, 129: 3, 130: 4, 132: 3, 145: 3, 147: 3, 151: 3, 152: 3, 154: 2, 161: 2, 162: 2, 165: 2, 168: 3, 169: 2, 172: 2, 180: 3, 184: 4, 187: 4, 188: 3, 191: 2, 194: 3, 202: 4, 203: 5, 207: 2, 217: 2, 218: 7, 222: 4, 224: 2, 227: 4, 229: 2, 234: 4, 243: 3, 244: 3, 245: 3, 248: 3, 250: 3, 258: 10, 262: 3, 263: 4, 264: 2, 267: 3, 270: 2, 272: 2, 273: 4, 287: 2, 289: 2, 291: 4, 299: 4, 300: 2, 304: 2, 309: 2, 315: 2, 320: 3, 323: 3, 327: 3, 328: 2, 330: 9, 335: 2, 341: 4, 342: 5, 347: 4, 348: 4, 350: 6, 351: 4, 352: 2, 353: 2, 358: 3, 365: 2, 371: 6, 372: 4, 384: 4, 385: 3, 386: 2, 387: 2, 392: 2, 393: 3, 396: 5, 397: 6, 398: 5, 402: 2} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 53 "The Time-Sensitive Networking (TSN) Task Group of the IEEE 802.1 Working Group have defined (and are defining) a number of amendments to IEEE8021Q that provide zero congestion loss and bounded latency in bridged networks. IEEE8021CB defines packet replication and elimination functions for a TSN network." "Major clean up and simplification as data plane drafts can be referred for MPLS related details . TSN over DetNet MPLS follows the concept of RFC3985 . Description focus on Edge Nodes procedures and functions . Text covers the Edge Nodes components : ( 1 ) TSN functions ( in NSP block ) ; ( 2 ) DetNet Service Proxy ; and ( 3 ) DetNet sub - layers . Approving from teelcon review" 3486514b01b74d57f031bcf660311de328a6e0dc 3486514b01b74d57f031bcf660311de328a6e0dc draft-ietf-detnet-tsn-vpn-over-mpls 77f9aaec42bbb94079fae33b8c564cd7f64721106f615e11f22673310efaf01b ['e82e49a3c764c0ede490d9e8afe0d0a379ec1e2fb734910d7e42f179709f894c', '1b5276bed81725e3cab5fa8d2491ae7fc344c8638906d8e62ee7c31696edcb52', 'a6a4ee1a9211a2be0e24cf91f9742499a46567acff4c78f62b568b34e38c08de', '44d22f065218a14d5aa04288e7553c8a6d81bb222066c74ea38571bbe922a729', 'c757c3611002031d5ce1ac79d9984d826f392e6628a0657e045c348e52b7eda2', '8a105d9f9ffbf3e747a101e48de19122931cd0cce896dc27f57d16df9dbb75ac', 'a8ff14472a8fa48bacdc11d7089a9d1054c0a786f6152f510b5d4092c22e121f', 'e746630d4b45cf2b654a14e4daaa03ad634e33d92c29c489e3ef3fcd5620c311', '16375944152e6c3e73492437880fe39d7f0123a9292d062e8e9c7d317e4b878f', '42f5214bb177fd7faf01b7943e7f313a615b2490f9109d5cefa8b24101735c32', '5cc97b8f56cdeeb02e7c96183745dc53dd8ec3ec02424107d16eb438c2c9363c', 'a816e4d1392c9c85d398ee2c5116b5de849a9823bc552d322ac8725f7c9b859e', 'c7286f8983508fdd7d94ae798cdc3950cbf65865e905c00a76838a34eb79cf2c', '6924f7b3002e9f0dff9023b70bcc9d484e643c3a2d95b0d5c853c084ad3f68ab', '2d8fce3963de03360a5d98758067925a60474b5430fd8091fc72f3c50a9d38e5', '77f9aaec42bbb94079fae33b8c564cd7f64721106f615e11f22673310efaf01b', '09f8dc962fd9202d148a0b378c9a078ea850056b4b5c360c0914d4a1de6af454', '4826376633600232b766cb8a62d4054b0f5ea45d74878bcf57356e567088300c', '82b410c949db1d81b3f197adbaaba7b82b6e497600cd9883150af2bb815caa19', '0eb73f51f3b491bd6d969a05acf2b527e6e2f09a460cb88266513ab952bd3fc6', '1076eab6753435c114e8a720c951b03da6d4e1bbbf1290f8d58ad7f97a0b8c64', '4ccf918f8b8ae99a769d89e0868a12e4af1536487652436b6c188bc99e14fdb6', '2a5cef1e9c76b52b9b56c6c021a857b0fa757897b6e3c96cc8170d5b73ba8dd8', '07267e696bfbb5af98da5a8efe2b8cf604bc9ab1ce95e4766f017473bfcd0de1', '82f56d4694c2ec964de0a4413954f87ca621628c63d7425944baeff9aa4b6dad', '01e1da53fe2751e7196114efc63dd70d9babc69b4b73c03d4b7528dcc10c05d3', 'fb8f3ca7fafc9c173404ce7f909038443a6078a0c278cb024639410e33f49f88', '44e497e2df0461bad9215c57918855022435eb6e28266916161de3f7902bb352', '84f5bc0e0be5d04b515e8e49efb393e4aec7189222b92c0555cc1be542e74549', '3195c90c03cf6a438b5684cc93128c53f794660a661e2aa85d043ca5ac7060b9', 'b5bacf05f766e143f6de9484b0b5a2d9655d62854368373bd77974b94cb722e6', '2442b9072d522cde54849b40cab26789e4af909f1dd81391cd8c87023515a21c', 'b03d79d1a547b36a28c6cba78f57b8244a4855f6b31003de3e617a5b5eddc070', 'e386562e3156c91934ceb045df46d7e847bb9afcad2794bda59be854f988befc', 'cc980749457292da3a6a4a3ce669ad487409ce72e20857e80c75741c83af7f0a', '75db9ae91b710fcf1df3553b8f9653b12d014f74ba1ee8f931870d2433e163f1', '0e313215df9694bc26777ba4ac347cb8ef73f8475d2bfed664aab722833589ae', '1094721b24c22ff67539ffeabab887f87e538bdd9ebe50b0b369de138d326802', 'fb2b9389e1455c6d64ae19158396d767d88969013b14075bcfdcc764f610108c', 'ae3bdd3a81d96e4aaa02f7d597a2684146f3af75b743bde8e31c3cf5883707db', '1b8137b4c60774716e4a492efec48060d48abd7308563d8cc76edf32d98bd759', '09732023af932d8c578c8a7ead49feb80cdb5c629cee6add2e24fcd7999c0309', '75b7020073ec0c8cedf517f1b56d554e2a5cfdf89d204633c30b863c42ed6f5f', '4be1dfb90ea542d5d84c23c0ba29b91db2491a39973839ee646eeec25c71adb4', 'c98d52f719106d13b14f27abde81ce00305cbf62889690b72da3e3ddc0286c02', '056859e4aa430e2eb983e93f08bb85d9afe9aec44f0e73263cf072df70b7c475', '870147c2dad0a0dda2dd0a9f85ef83b3c4de9a304fdff6d9fa9ccc4bde9d70c0', '26e942b0353fee8f5ac0a2c2e26c9b695c50b35c501eeb4bff343b1648b5cebc', '036168e918418eb807bc3efd361a8e66067192564da41e30e076d22be0f87935', 'a491df768673d76ae7dee4c9bf1ea1456e6c537a1f1683368d8bc6869cd89bf0', 'f6a8cfceb19b4cd796512223b8afd103c4aee7052247ebea8b50f743e9aa27b6', 'd135518ad4230c8f57a3510b3ddea8a99e2355363c9419a27340734427050729', 'cbe90e272b6be7696d3b8c171500847d2b0ae497f6911d0f9d5d8481101c4c1f', '249c961ea29438959ea2204728df24964ec80b8cd91c657715c47014f5e5a462', '1920ebb46d0cee2d379ef48c15f8f6abd01e2a183f316da235e0c3b7515feade', '6d1573b42d5f89f89b26b32cbbd32ff41660e0e8c3b3091f1cb278a42651e049', 'ec6878825845c61b3049ad5dd168197c84938e7f6d4fc938670da2528cf86317', '9829b13faebde69c2279c38cd54d524aa31acfdcc1cfba7910b9d69caa42e0dd', '2755ae7cda161df0c24e1fa9f1c3308bc9ef81a599d859668490484290ca72f4', '09d9dcfc1716808b0c62e47a771ff4d39ba71f22c8640776e65624747a995626', '71dfcd074b80de90c4955890bdbe127d12b249ed764c7c4ca23dc81c74fde71d', '3c1afbb156ee2d672ca131c7c966bc6875374a95d927848bafcc5a158edf67bb'] B "the time-sensitive networking (tsn) task group of the ieee 802.1 working group have defined (and are defining) a number of amendments to ieee8021q that provide zero congestion loss and bounded latency in bridged networks. ieee8021cb defines packet replication and elimination functions for a tsn network." {79: 1, 130: 1, 54: 1, 52: 1, 98: 1, 6: 1, 8: 1, 64: 1, 99: 1, 24: 1, 90: 2, 51: 2, 62: 4, 85: 4, 68: 3, 35: 2, 110: 2, 91: 4, 114: 2, 97: 2, 31: 2, 13: 2, 67: 2, 38: 3, 26: 2, 124: 2, 127: 2, 96: 2, 30: 3, 61: 4, 55: 2, 27: 3, 15: 2, 129: 2, 115: 2, 84: 2, 76: 5, 87: 2, 131: 4, 102: 2, 113: 4, 36: 2, 72: 3} {4: 1, 24: 1, 59: 1, 111: 1, 136: 1, 156: 1, 206: 1, 215: 1, 220: 1, 221: 1, 235: 1, 241: 1, 242: 1, 314: 1, 329: 1, 334: 1, 354: 1, 366: 1, 376: 1, 1: 8, 9: 4, 10: 2, 15: 2, 25: 4, 26: 4, 27: 2, 39: 4, 43: 2, 49: 5, 50: 4, 58: 4, 64: 2, 69: 3, 81: 5, 82: 3, 86: 2, 96: 3, 97: 2, 100: 6, 108: 2, 109: 3, 110: 3, 114: 2, 115: 3, 116: 2, 118: 5, 119: 4, 120: 2, 121: 3, 122: 3, 123: 2, 124: 3, 128: 3, 129: 3, 130: 4, 132: 3, 145: 3, 147: 3, 151: 3, 152: 3, 154: 2, 161: 2, 162: 2, 165: 2, 168: 3, 169: 2, 172: 2, 180: 3, 184: 4, 187: 4, 188: 3, 191: 2, 194: 3, 202: 4, 203: 5, 207: 2, 217: 2, 218: 7, 222: 4, 224: 2, 227: 4, 229: 2, 234: 4, 243: 3, 244: 3, 245: 3, 248: 3, 250: 3, 258: 10, 262: 3, 263: 4, 264: 2, 267: 3, 270: 2, 272: 2, 273: 4, 287: 2, 289: 2, 291: 4, 299: 4, 300: 2, 304: 2, 309: 2, 315: 2, 320: 3, 323: 3, 327: 3, 328: 2, 330: 9, 335: 2, 341: 4, 342: 5, 347: 4, 348: 4, 350: 6, 351: 4, 352: 2, 353: 2, 358: 3, 365: 2, 371: 6, 372: 4, 384: 4, 385: 3, 386: 2, 387: 2, 392: 2, 393: 3, 396: 5, 397: 6, 398: 5, 402: 2} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 53 "TSN specific functions are executed on the data received by the PE from the CE before presentation to the DetNet PW for transmission across the DetNet domain, or on the data received from a DetNet PW by a PE before it is output on the Attachment Circuit (AC)." "Major clean up and simplification as data plane drafts can be referred for MPLS related details . TSN over DetNet MPLS follows the concept of RFC3985 . Description focus on Edge Nodes procedures and functions . Text covers the Edge Nodes components : ( 1 ) TSN functions ( in NSP block ) ; ( 2 ) DetNet Service Proxy ; and ( 3 ) DetNet sub - layers . Approving from teelcon review" 3486514b01b74d57f031bcf660311de328a6e0dc 3486514b01b74d57f031bcf660311de328a6e0dc draft-ietf-detnet-tsn-vpn-over-mpls 5cc97b8f56cdeeb02e7c96183745dc53dd8ec3ec02424107d16eb438c2c9363c ['e82e49a3c764c0ede490d9e8afe0d0a379ec1e2fb734910d7e42f179709f894c', '1b5276bed81725e3cab5fa8d2491ae7fc344c8638906d8e62ee7c31696edcb52', 'a6a4ee1a9211a2be0e24cf91f9742499a46567acff4c78f62b568b34e38c08de', '44d22f065218a14d5aa04288e7553c8a6d81bb222066c74ea38571bbe922a729', 'c757c3611002031d5ce1ac79d9984d826f392e6628a0657e045c348e52b7eda2', '8a105d9f9ffbf3e747a101e48de19122931cd0cce896dc27f57d16df9dbb75ac', 'a8ff14472a8fa48bacdc11d7089a9d1054c0a786f6152f510b5d4092c22e121f', 'e746630d4b45cf2b654a14e4daaa03ad634e33d92c29c489e3ef3fcd5620c311', '16375944152e6c3e73492437880fe39d7f0123a9292d062e8e9c7d317e4b878f', '42f5214bb177fd7faf01b7943e7f313a615b2490f9109d5cefa8b24101735c32', '5cc97b8f56cdeeb02e7c96183745dc53dd8ec3ec02424107d16eb438c2c9363c', 'a816e4d1392c9c85d398ee2c5116b5de849a9823bc552d322ac8725f7c9b859e', 'c7286f8983508fdd7d94ae798cdc3950cbf65865e905c00a76838a34eb79cf2c', '6924f7b3002e9f0dff9023b70bcc9d484e643c3a2d95b0d5c853c084ad3f68ab', '2d8fce3963de03360a5d98758067925a60474b5430fd8091fc72f3c50a9d38e5', '77f9aaec42bbb94079fae33b8c564cd7f64721106f615e11f22673310efaf01b', '09f8dc962fd9202d148a0b378c9a078ea850056b4b5c360c0914d4a1de6af454', '4826376633600232b766cb8a62d4054b0f5ea45d74878bcf57356e567088300c', '82b410c949db1d81b3f197adbaaba7b82b6e497600cd9883150af2bb815caa19', '0eb73f51f3b491bd6d969a05acf2b527e6e2f09a460cb88266513ab952bd3fc6', '1076eab6753435c114e8a720c951b03da6d4e1bbbf1290f8d58ad7f97a0b8c64', '4ccf918f8b8ae99a769d89e0868a12e4af1536487652436b6c188bc99e14fdb6', '2a5cef1e9c76b52b9b56c6c021a857b0fa757897b6e3c96cc8170d5b73ba8dd8', '07267e696bfbb5af98da5a8efe2b8cf604bc9ab1ce95e4766f017473bfcd0de1', '82f56d4694c2ec964de0a4413954f87ca621628c63d7425944baeff9aa4b6dad', '01e1da53fe2751e7196114efc63dd70d9babc69b4b73c03d4b7528dcc10c05d3', 'fb8f3ca7fafc9c173404ce7f909038443a6078a0c278cb024639410e33f49f88', '44e497e2df0461bad9215c57918855022435eb6e28266916161de3f7902bb352', '84f5bc0e0be5d04b515e8e49efb393e4aec7189222b92c0555cc1be542e74549', '3195c90c03cf6a438b5684cc93128c53f794660a661e2aa85d043ca5ac7060b9', 'b5bacf05f766e143f6de9484b0b5a2d9655d62854368373bd77974b94cb722e6', '2442b9072d522cde54849b40cab26789e4af909f1dd81391cd8c87023515a21c', 'b03d79d1a547b36a28c6cba78f57b8244a4855f6b31003de3e617a5b5eddc070', 'e386562e3156c91934ceb045df46d7e847bb9afcad2794bda59be854f988befc', 'cc980749457292da3a6a4a3ce669ad487409ce72e20857e80c75741c83af7f0a', '75db9ae91b710fcf1df3553b8f9653b12d014f74ba1ee8f931870d2433e163f1', '0e313215df9694bc26777ba4ac347cb8ef73f8475d2bfed664aab722833589ae', '1094721b24c22ff67539ffeabab887f87e538bdd9ebe50b0b369de138d326802', 'fb2b9389e1455c6d64ae19158396d767d88969013b14075bcfdcc764f610108c', 'ae3bdd3a81d96e4aaa02f7d597a2684146f3af75b743bde8e31c3cf5883707db', '1b8137b4c60774716e4a492efec48060d48abd7308563d8cc76edf32d98bd759', '09732023af932d8c578c8a7ead49feb80cdb5c629cee6add2e24fcd7999c0309', '75b7020073ec0c8cedf517f1b56d554e2a5cfdf89d204633c30b863c42ed6f5f', '4be1dfb90ea542d5d84c23c0ba29b91db2491a39973839ee646eeec25c71adb4', 'c98d52f719106d13b14f27abde81ce00305cbf62889690b72da3e3ddc0286c02', '056859e4aa430e2eb983e93f08bb85d9afe9aec44f0e73263cf072df70b7c475', '870147c2dad0a0dda2dd0a9f85ef83b3c4de9a304fdff6d9fa9ccc4bde9d70c0', '26e942b0353fee8f5ac0a2c2e26c9b695c50b35c501eeb4bff343b1648b5cebc', '036168e918418eb807bc3efd361a8e66067192564da41e30e076d22be0f87935', 'a491df768673d76ae7dee4c9bf1ea1456e6c537a1f1683368d8bc6869cd89bf0', 'f6a8cfceb19b4cd796512223b8afd103c4aee7052247ebea8b50f743e9aa27b6', 'd135518ad4230c8f57a3510b3ddea8a99e2355363c9419a27340734427050729', 'cbe90e272b6be7696d3b8c171500847d2b0ae497f6911d0f9d5d8481101c4c1f', '249c961ea29438959ea2204728df24964ec80b8cd91c657715c47014f5e5a462', '1920ebb46d0cee2d379ef48c15f8f6abd01e2a183f316da235e0c3b7515feade', '6d1573b42d5f89f89b26b32cbbd32ff41660e0e8c3b3091f1cb278a42651e049', 'ec6878825845c61b3049ad5dd168197c84938e7f6d4fc938670da2528cf86317', '9829b13faebde69c2279c38cd54d524aa31acfdcc1cfba7910b9d69caa42e0dd', '2755ae7cda161df0c24e1fa9f1c3308bc9ef81a599d859668490484290ca72f4', '09d9dcfc1716808b0c62e47a771ff4d39ba71f22c8640776e65624747a995626', '71dfcd074b80de90c4955890bdbe127d12b249ed764c7c4ca23dc81c74fde71d', '3c1afbb156ee2d672ca131c7c966bc6875374a95d927848bafcc5a158edf67bb'] B "tsn specific functions are executed on the data received by the pe from the ce before presentation to the detnet pw for transmission across the detnet domain, or on the data received from a detnet pw by a pe before it is output on the attachment circuit (ac)." {79: 1, 130: 1, 54: 1, 52: 1, 98: 1, 6: 1, 8: 1, 64: 1, 99: 1, 24: 1, 90: 2, 51: 2, 62: 4, 85: 4, 68: 3, 35: 2, 110: 2, 91: 4, 114: 2, 97: 2, 31: 2, 13: 2, 67: 2, 38: 3, 26: 2, 124: 2, 127: 2, 96: 2, 30: 3, 61: 4, 55: 2, 27: 3, 15: 2, 129: 2, 115: 2, 84: 2, 76: 5, 87: 2, 131: 4, 102: 2, 113: 4, 36: 2, 72: 3} {4: 1, 24: 1, 59: 1, 111: 1, 136: 1, 156: 1, 206: 1, 215: 1, 220: 1, 221: 1, 235: 1, 241: 1, 242: 1, 314: 1, 329: 1, 334: 1, 354: 1, 366: 1, 376: 1, 1: 8, 9: 4, 10: 2, 15: 2, 25: 4, 26: 4, 27: 2, 39: 4, 43: 2, 49: 5, 50: 4, 58: 4, 64: 2, 69: 3, 81: 5, 82: 3, 86: 2, 96: 3, 97: 2, 100: 6, 108: 2, 109: 3, 110: 3, 114: 2, 115: 3, 116: 2, 118: 5, 119: 4, 120: 2, 121: 3, 122: 3, 123: 2, 124: 3, 128: 3, 129: 3, 130: 4, 132: 3, 145: 3, 147: 3, 151: 3, 152: 3, 154: 2, 161: 2, 162: 2, 165: 2, 168: 3, 169: 2, 172: 2, 180: 3, 184: 4, 187: 4, 188: 3, 191: 2, 194: 3, 202: 4, 203: 5, 207: 2, 217: 2, 218: 7, 222: 4, 224: 2, 227: 4, 229: 2, 234: 4, 243: 3, 244: 3, 245: 3, 248: 3, 250: 3, 258: 10, 262: 3, 263: 4, 264: 2, 267: 3, 270: 2, 272: 2, 273: 4, 287: 2, 289: 2, 291: 4, 299: 4, 300: 2, 304: 2, 309: 2, 315: 2, 320: 3, 323: 3, 327: 3, 328: 2, 330: 9, 335: 2, 341: 4, 342: 5, 347: 4, 348: 4, 350: 6, 351: 4, 352: 2, 353: 2, 358: 3, 365: 2, 371: 6, 372: 4, 384: 4, 385: 3, 386: 2, 387: 2, 392: 2, 393: 3, 396: 5, 397: 6, 398: 5, 402: 2} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 53 "TSN specific function(s) of Edge Nodes (T-PE) are belonging to the native service processing (NSP) RFC3985 block. This is similar to other functionalities being defined by standard bodies other than the IETF (for example in case of Ethernet: stripping, overwriting or adding VLAN tags, etc.). Depending on the TSN role of the Edge Node in the end-to-end TSN service selected TSN functions must be supported." "Major clean up and simplification as data plane drafts can be referred for MPLS related details . TSN over DetNet MPLS follows the concept of RFC3985 . Description focus on Edge Nodes procedures and functions . Text covers the Edge Nodes components : ( 1 ) TSN functions ( in NSP block ) ; ( 2 ) DetNet Service Proxy ; and ( 3 ) DetNet sub - layers . Approving from teelcon review" 3486514b01b74d57f031bcf660311de328a6e0dc 3486514b01b74d57f031bcf660311de328a6e0dc draft-ietf-detnet-tsn-vpn-over-mpls cbe90e272b6be7696d3b8c171500847d2b0ae497f6911d0f9d5d8481101c4c1f ['e82e49a3c764c0ede490d9e8afe0d0a379ec1e2fb734910d7e42f179709f894c', '1b5276bed81725e3cab5fa8d2491ae7fc344c8638906d8e62ee7c31696edcb52', 'a6a4ee1a9211a2be0e24cf91f9742499a46567acff4c78f62b568b34e38c08de', '44d22f065218a14d5aa04288e7553c8a6d81bb222066c74ea38571bbe922a729', 'c757c3611002031d5ce1ac79d9984d826f392e6628a0657e045c348e52b7eda2', '8a105d9f9ffbf3e747a101e48de19122931cd0cce896dc27f57d16df9dbb75ac', 'a8ff14472a8fa48bacdc11d7089a9d1054c0a786f6152f510b5d4092c22e121f', 'e746630d4b45cf2b654a14e4daaa03ad634e33d92c29c489e3ef3fcd5620c311', '16375944152e6c3e73492437880fe39d7f0123a9292d062e8e9c7d317e4b878f', '42f5214bb177fd7faf01b7943e7f313a615b2490f9109d5cefa8b24101735c32', '5cc97b8f56cdeeb02e7c96183745dc53dd8ec3ec02424107d16eb438c2c9363c', 'a816e4d1392c9c85d398ee2c5116b5de849a9823bc552d322ac8725f7c9b859e', 'c7286f8983508fdd7d94ae798cdc3950cbf65865e905c00a76838a34eb79cf2c', '6924f7b3002e9f0dff9023b70bcc9d484e643c3a2d95b0d5c853c084ad3f68ab', '2d8fce3963de03360a5d98758067925a60474b5430fd8091fc72f3c50a9d38e5', '77f9aaec42bbb94079fae33b8c564cd7f64721106f615e11f22673310efaf01b', '09f8dc962fd9202d148a0b378c9a078ea850056b4b5c360c0914d4a1de6af454', '4826376633600232b766cb8a62d4054b0f5ea45d74878bcf57356e567088300c', '82b410c949db1d81b3f197adbaaba7b82b6e497600cd9883150af2bb815caa19', '0eb73f51f3b491bd6d969a05acf2b527e6e2f09a460cb88266513ab952bd3fc6', '1076eab6753435c114e8a720c951b03da6d4e1bbbf1290f8d58ad7f97a0b8c64', '4ccf918f8b8ae99a769d89e0868a12e4af1536487652436b6c188bc99e14fdb6', '2a5cef1e9c76b52b9b56c6c021a857b0fa757897b6e3c96cc8170d5b73ba8dd8', '07267e696bfbb5af98da5a8efe2b8cf604bc9ab1ce95e4766f017473bfcd0de1', '82f56d4694c2ec964de0a4413954f87ca621628c63d7425944baeff9aa4b6dad', '01e1da53fe2751e7196114efc63dd70d9babc69b4b73c03d4b7528dcc10c05d3', 'fb8f3ca7fafc9c173404ce7f909038443a6078a0c278cb024639410e33f49f88', '44e497e2df0461bad9215c57918855022435eb6e28266916161de3f7902bb352', '84f5bc0e0be5d04b515e8e49efb393e4aec7189222b92c0555cc1be542e74549', '3195c90c03cf6a438b5684cc93128c53f794660a661e2aa85d043ca5ac7060b9', 'b5bacf05f766e143f6de9484b0b5a2d9655d62854368373bd77974b94cb722e6', '2442b9072d522cde54849b40cab26789e4af909f1dd81391cd8c87023515a21c', 'b03d79d1a547b36a28c6cba78f57b8244a4855f6b31003de3e617a5b5eddc070', 'e386562e3156c91934ceb045df46d7e847bb9afcad2794bda59be854f988befc', 'cc980749457292da3a6a4a3ce669ad487409ce72e20857e80c75741c83af7f0a', '75db9ae91b710fcf1df3553b8f9653b12d014f74ba1ee8f931870d2433e163f1', '0e313215df9694bc26777ba4ac347cb8ef73f8475d2bfed664aab722833589ae', '1094721b24c22ff67539ffeabab887f87e538bdd9ebe50b0b369de138d326802', 'fb2b9389e1455c6d64ae19158396d767d88969013b14075bcfdcc764f610108c', 'ae3bdd3a81d96e4aaa02f7d597a2684146f3af75b743bde8e31c3cf5883707db', '1b8137b4c60774716e4a492efec48060d48abd7308563d8cc76edf32d98bd759', '09732023af932d8c578c8a7ead49feb80cdb5c629cee6add2e24fcd7999c0309', '75b7020073ec0c8cedf517f1b56d554e2a5cfdf89d204633c30b863c42ed6f5f', '4be1dfb90ea542d5d84c23c0ba29b91db2491a39973839ee646eeec25c71adb4', 'c98d52f719106d13b14f27abde81ce00305cbf62889690b72da3e3ddc0286c02', '056859e4aa430e2eb983e93f08bb85d9afe9aec44f0e73263cf072df70b7c475', '870147c2dad0a0dda2dd0a9f85ef83b3c4de9a304fdff6d9fa9ccc4bde9d70c0', '26e942b0353fee8f5ac0a2c2e26c9b695c50b35c501eeb4bff343b1648b5cebc', '036168e918418eb807bc3efd361a8e66067192564da41e30e076d22be0f87935', 'a491df768673d76ae7dee4c9bf1ea1456e6c537a1f1683368d8bc6869cd89bf0', 'f6a8cfceb19b4cd796512223b8afd103c4aee7052247ebea8b50f743e9aa27b6', 'd135518ad4230c8f57a3510b3ddea8a99e2355363c9419a27340734427050729', 'cbe90e272b6be7696d3b8c171500847d2b0ae497f6911d0f9d5d8481101c4c1f', '249c961ea29438959ea2204728df24964ec80b8cd91c657715c47014f5e5a462', '1920ebb46d0cee2d379ef48c15f8f6abd01e2a183f316da235e0c3b7515feade', '6d1573b42d5f89f89b26b32cbbd32ff41660e0e8c3b3091f1cb278a42651e049', 'ec6878825845c61b3049ad5dd168197c84938e7f6d4fc938670da2528cf86317', '9829b13faebde69c2279c38cd54d524aa31acfdcc1cfba7910b9d69caa42e0dd', '2755ae7cda161df0c24e1fa9f1c3308bc9ef81a599d859668490484290ca72f4', '09d9dcfc1716808b0c62e47a771ff4d39ba71f22c8640776e65624747a995626', '71dfcd074b80de90c4955890bdbe127d12b249ed764c7c4ca23dc81c74fde71d', '3c1afbb156ee2d672ca131c7c966bc6875374a95d927848bafcc5a158edf67bb'] B "tsn specific function(s) of edge nodes (t-pe) are belonging to the native service processing (nsp) rfc3985 block. this is similar to other functionalities being defined by standard bodies other than the ietf (for example in case of ethernet: stripping, overwriting or adding vlan tags, etc.). depending on the tsn role of the edge node in the end-to-end tsn service selected tsn functions must be supported." {79: 1, 130: 1, 54: 1, 52: 1, 98: 1, 6: 1, 8: 1, 64: 1, 99: 1, 24: 1, 90: 2, 51: 2, 62: 4, 85: 4, 68: 3, 35: 2, 110: 2, 91: 4, 114: 2, 97: 2, 31: 2, 13: 2, 67: 2, 38: 3, 26: 2, 124: 2, 127: 2, 96: 2, 30: 3, 61: 4, 55: 2, 27: 3, 15: 2, 129: 2, 115: 2, 84: 2, 76: 5, 87: 2, 131: 4, 102: 2, 113: 4, 36: 2, 72: 3} {4: 1, 24: 1, 59: 1, 111: 1, 136: 1, 156: 1, 206: 1, 215: 1, 220: 1, 221: 1, 235: 1, 241: 1, 242: 1, 314: 1, 329: 1, 334: 1, 354: 1, 366: 1, 376: 1, 1: 8, 9: 4, 10: 2, 15: 2, 25: 4, 26: 4, 27: 2, 39: 4, 43: 2, 49: 5, 50: 4, 58: 4, 64: 2, 69: 3, 81: 5, 82: 3, 86: 2, 96: 3, 97: 2, 100: 6, 108: 2, 109: 3, 110: 3, 114: 2, 115: 3, 116: 2, 118: 5, 119: 4, 120: 2, 121: 3, 122: 3, 123: 2, 124: 3, 128: 3, 129: 3, 130: 4, 132: 3, 145: 3, 147: 3, 151: 3, 152: 3, 154: 2, 161: 2, 162: 2, 165: 2, 168: 3, 169: 2, 172: 2, 180: 3, 184: 4, 187: 4, 188: 3, 191: 2, 194: 3, 202: 4, 203: 5, 207: 2, 217: 2, 218: 7, 222: 4, 224: 2, 227: 4, 229: 2, 234: 4, 243: 3, 244: 3, 245: 3, 248: 3, 250: 3, 258: 10, 262: 3, 263: 4, 264: 2, 267: 3, 270: 2, 272: 2, 273: 4, 287: 2, 289: 2, 291: 4, 299: 4, 300: 2, 304: 2, 309: 2, 315: 2, 320: 3, 323: 3, 327: 3, 328: 2, 330: 9, 335: 2, 341: 4, 342: 5, 347: 4, 348: 4, 350: 6, 351: 4, 352: 2, 353: 2, 358: 3, 365: 2, 371: 6, 372: 4, 384: 4, 385: 3, 386: 2, 387: 2, 392: 2, 393: 3, 396: 5, 397: 6, 398: 5, 402: 2} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 53 "Implementations of this document SHALL use management and control information to ensure TSN specific functions of the Edge Node according to the expectations of the connected TSN network." "Major clean up and simplification as data plane drafts can be referred for MPLS related details . TSN over DetNet MPLS follows the concept of RFC3985 . Description focus on Edge Nodes procedures and functions . Text covers the Edge Nodes components : ( 1 ) TSN functions ( in NSP block ) ; ( 2 ) DetNet Service Proxy ; and ( 3 ) DetNet sub - layers . Approving from teelcon review" 3486514b01b74d57f031bcf660311de328a6e0dc 3486514b01b74d57f031bcf660311de328a6e0dc draft-ietf-detnet-tsn-vpn-over-mpls 09f8dc962fd9202d148a0b378c9a078ea850056b4b5c360c0914d4a1de6af454 ['e82e49a3c764c0ede490d9e8afe0d0a379ec1e2fb734910d7e42f179709f894c', '1b5276bed81725e3cab5fa8d2491ae7fc344c8638906d8e62ee7c31696edcb52', 'a6a4ee1a9211a2be0e24cf91f9742499a46567acff4c78f62b568b34e38c08de', '44d22f065218a14d5aa04288e7553c8a6d81bb222066c74ea38571bbe922a729', 'c757c3611002031d5ce1ac79d9984d826f392e6628a0657e045c348e52b7eda2', '8a105d9f9ffbf3e747a101e48de19122931cd0cce896dc27f57d16df9dbb75ac', 'a8ff14472a8fa48bacdc11d7089a9d1054c0a786f6152f510b5d4092c22e121f', 'e746630d4b45cf2b654a14e4daaa03ad634e33d92c29c489e3ef3fcd5620c311', '16375944152e6c3e73492437880fe39d7f0123a9292d062e8e9c7d317e4b878f', '42f5214bb177fd7faf01b7943e7f313a615b2490f9109d5cefa8b24101735c32', '5cc97b8f56cdeeb02e7c96183745dc53dd8ec3ec02424107d16eb438c2c9363c', 'a816e4d1392c9c85d398ee2c5116b5de849a9823bc552d322ac8725f7c9b859e', 'c7286f8983508fdd7d94ae798cdc3950cbf65865e905c00a76838a34eb79cf2c', '6924f7b3002e9f0dff9023b70bcc9d484e643c3a2d95b0d5c853c084ad3f68ab', '2d8fce3963de03360a5d98758067925a60474b5430fd8091fc72f3c50a9d38e5', '77f9aaec42bbb94079fae33b8c564cd7f64721106f615e11f22673310efaf01b', '09f8dc962fd9202d148a0b378c9a078ea850056b4b5c360c0914d4a1de6af454', '4826376633600232b766cb8a62d4054b0f5ea45d74878bcf57356e567088300c', '82b410c949db1d81b3f197adbaaba7b82b6e497600cd9883150af2bb815caa19', '0eb73f51f3b491bd6d969a05acf2b527e6e2f09a460cb88266513ab952bd3fc6', '1076eab6753435c114e8a720c951b03da6d4e1bbbf1290f8d58ad7f97a0b8c64', '4ccf918f8b8ae99a769d89e0868a12e4af1536487652436b6c188bc99e14fdb6', '2a5cef1e9c76b52b9b56c6c021a857b0fa757897b6e3c96cc8170d5b73ba8dd8', '07267e696bfbb5af98da5a8efe2b8cf604bc9ab1ce95e4766f017473bfcd0de1', '82f56d4694c2ec964de0a4413954f87ca621628c63d7425944baeff9aa4b6dad', '01e1da53fe2751e7196114efc63dd70d9babc69b4b73c03d4b7528dcc10c05d3', 'fb8f3ca7fafc9c173404ce7f909038443a6078a0c278cb024639410e33f49f88', '44e497e2df0461bad9215c57918855022435eb6e28266916161de3f7902bb352', '84f5bc0e0be5d04b515e8e49efb393e4aec7189222b92c0555cc1be542e74549', '3195c90c03cf6a438b5684cc93128c53f794660a661e2aa85d043ca5ac7060b9', 'b5bacf05f766e143f6de9484b0b5a2d9655d62854368373bd77974b94cb722e6', '2442b9072d522cde54849b40cab26789e4af909f1dd81391cd8c87023515a21c', 'b03d79d1a547b36a28c6cba78f57b8244a4855f6b31003de3e617a5b5eddc070', 'e386562e3156c91934ceb045df46d7e847bb9afcad2794bda59be854f988befc', 'cc980749457292da3a6a4a3ce669ad487409ce72e20857e80c75741c83af7f0a', '75db9ae91b710fcf1df3553b8f9653b12d014f74ba1ee8f931870d2433e163f1', '0e313215df9694bc26777ba4ac347cb8ef73f8475d2bfed664aab722833589ae', '1094721b24c22ff67539ffeabab887f87e538bdd9ebe50b0b369de138d326802', 'fb2b9389e1455c6d64ae19158396d767d88969013b14075bcfdcc764f610108c', 'ae3bdd3a81d96e4aaa02f7d597a2684146f3af75b743bde8e31c3cf5883707db', '1b8137b4c60774716e4a492efec48060d48abd7308563d8cc76edf32d98bd759', '09732023af932d8c578c8a7ead49feb80cdb5c629cee6add2e24fcd7999c0309', '75b7020073ec0c8cedf517f1b56d554e2a5cfdf89d204633c30b863c42ed6f5f', '4be1dfb90ea542d5d84c23c0ba29b91db2491a39973839ee646eeec25c71adb4', 'c98d52f719106d13b14f27abde81ce00305cbf62889690b72da3e3ddc0286c02', '056859e4aa430e2eb983e93f08bb85d9afe9aec44f0e73263cf072df70b7c475', '870147c2dad0a0dda2dd0a9f85ef83b3c4de9a304fdff6d9fa9ccc4bde9d70c0', '26e942b0353fee8f5ac0a2c2e26c9b695c50b35c501eeb4bff343b1648b5cebc', '036168e918418eb807bc3efd361a8e66067192564da41e30e076d22be0f87935', 'a491df768673d76ae7dee4c9bf1ea1456e6c537a1f1683368d8bc6869cd89bf0', 'f6a8cfceb19b4cd796512223b8afd103c4aee7052247ebea8b50f743e9aa27b6', 'd135518ad4230c8f57a3510b3ddea8a99e2355363c9419a27340734427050729', 'cbe90e272b6be7696d3b8c171500847d2b0ae497f6911d0f9d5d8481101c4c1f', '249c961ea29438959ea2204728df24964ec80b8cd91c657715c47014f5e5a462', '1920ebb46d0cee2d379ef48c15f8f6abd01e2a183f316da235e0c3b7515feade', '6d1573b42d5f89f89b26b32cbbd32ff41660e0e8c3b3091f1cb278a42651e049', 'ec6878825845c61b3049ad5dd168197c84938e7f6d4fc938670da2528cf86317', '9829b13faebde69c2279c38cd54d524aa31acfdcc1cfba7910b9d69caa42e0dd', '2755ae7cda161df0c24e1fa9f1c3308bc9ef81a599d859668490484290ca72f4', '09d9dcfc1716808b0c62e47a771ff4d39ba71f22c8640776e65624747a995626', '71dfcd074b80de90c4955890bdbe127d12b249ed764c7c4ca23dc81c74fde71d', '3c1afbb156ee2d672ca131c7c966bc6875374a95d927848bafcc5a158edf67bb'] B "implementations of this document shall use management and control information to ensure tsn specific functions of the edge node according to the expectations of the connected tsn network." {79: 1, 130: 1, 54: 1, 52: 1, 98: 1, 6: 1, 8: 1, 64: 1, 99: 1, 24: 1, 90: 2, 51: 2, 62: 4, 85: 4, 68: 3, 35: 2, 110: 2, 91: 4, 114: 2, 97: 2, 31: 2, 13: 2, 67: 2, 38: 3, 26: 2, 124: 2, 127: 2, 96: 2, 30: 3, 61: 4, 55: 2, 27: 3, 15: 2, 129: 2, 115: 2, 84: 2, 76: 5, 87: 2, 131: 4, 102: 2, 113: 4, 36: 2, 72: 3} {4: 1, 24: 1, 59: 1, 111: 1, 136: 1, 156: 1, 206: 1, 215: 1, 220: 1, 221: 1, 235: 1, 241: 1, 242: 1, 314: 1, 329: 1, 334: 1, 354: 1, 366: 1, 376: 1, 1: 8, 9: 4, 10: 2, 15: 2, 25: 4, 26: 4, 27: 2, 39: 4, 43: 2, 49: 5, 50: 4, 58: 4, 64: 2, 69: 3, 81: 5, 82: 3, 86: 2, 96: 3, 97: 2, 100: 6, 108: 2, 109: 3, 110: 3, 114: 2, 115: 3, 116: 2, 118: 5, 119: 4, 120: 2, 121: 3, 122: 3, 123: 2, 124: 3, 128: 3, 129: 3, 130: 4, 132: 3, 145: 3, 147: 3, 151: 3, 152: 3, 154: 2, 161: 2, 162: 2, 165: 2, 168: 3, 169: 2, 172: 2, 180: 3, 184: 4, 187: 4, 188: 3, 191: 2, 194: 3, 202: 4, 203: 5, 207: 2, 217: 2, 218: 7, 222: 4, 224: 2, 227: 4, 229: 2, 234: 4, 243: 3, 244: 3, 245: 3, 248: 3, 250: 3, 258: 10, 262: 3, 263: 4, 264: 2, 267: 3, 270: 2, 272: 2, 273: 4, 287: 2, 289: 2, 291: 4, 299: 4, 300: 2, 304: 2, 309: 2, 315: 2, 320: 3, 323: 3, 327: 3, 328: 2, 330: 9, 335: 2, 341: 4, 342: 5, 347: 4, 348: 4, 350: 6, 351: 4, 352: 2, 353: 2, 358: 3, 365: 2, 371: 6, 372: 4, 384: 4, 385: 3, 386: 2, 387: 2, 392: 2, 393: 3, 396: 5, 397: 6, 398: 5, 402: 2} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 53 "The Service Proxy function maps between App-flows and DetNet flows. It MUST support the TSN Stream identification functions and the related managed objects as defined in IEEE8021CB and IEEEP8021CBdb to recognize the App-flow related packets." "Major clean up and simplification as data plane drafts can be referred for MPLS related details . TSN over DetNet MPLS follows the concept of RFC3985 . Description focus on Edge Nodes procedures and functions . Text covers the Edge Nodes components : ( 1 ) TSN functions ( in NSP block ) ; ( 2 ) DetNet Service Proxy ; and ( 3 ) DetNet sub - layers . Approving from teelcon review" 3486514b01b74d57f031bcf660311de328a6e0dc 3486514b01b74d57f031bcf660311de328a6e0dc draft-ietf-detnet-tsn-vpn-over-mpls 1920ebb46d0cee2d379ef48c15f8f6abd01e2a183f316da235e0c3b7515feade ['e82e49a3c764c0ede490d9e8afe0d0a379ec1e2fb734910d7e42f179709f894c', '1b5276bed81725e3cab5fa8d2491ae7fc344c8638906d8e62ee7c31696edcb52', 'a6a4ee1a9211a2be0e24cf91f9742499a46567acff4c78f62b568b34e38c08de', '44d22f065218a14d5aa04288e7553c8a6d81bb222066c74ea38571bbe922a729', 'c757c3611002031d5ce1ac79d9984d826f392e6628a0657e045c348e52b7eda2', '8a105d9f9ffbf3e747a101e48de19122931cd0cce896dc27f57d16df9dbb75ac', 'a8ff14472a8fa48bacdc11d7089a9d1054c0a786f6152f510b5d4092c22e121f', 'e746630d4b45cf2b654a14e4daaa03ad634e33d92c29c489e3ef3fcd5620c311', '16375944152e6c3e73492437880fe39d7f0123a9292d062e8e9c7d317e4b878f', '42f5214bb177fd7faf01b7943e7f313a615b2490f9109d5cefa8b24101735c32', '5cc97b8f56cdeeb02e7c96183745dc53dd8ec3ec02424107d16eb438c2c9363c', 'a816e4d1392c9c85d398ee2c5116b5de849a9823bc552d322ac8725f7c9b859e', 'c7286f8983508fdd7d94ae798cdc3950cbf65865e905c00a76838a34eb79cf2c', '6924f7b3002e9f0dff9023b70bcc9d484e643c3a2d95b0d5c853c084ad3f68ab', '2d8fce3963de03360a5d98758067925a60474b5430fd8091fc72f3c50a9d38e5', '77f9aaec42bbb94079fae33b8c564cd7f64721106f615e11f22673310efaf01b', '09f8dc962fd9202d148a0b378c9a078ea850056b4b5c360c0914d4a1de6af454', '4826376633600232b766cb8a62d4054b0f5ea45d74878bcf57356e567088300c', '82b410c949db1d81b3f197adbaaba7b82b6e497600cd9883150af2bb815caa19', '0eb73f51f3b491bd6d969a05acf2b527e6e2f09a460cb88266513ab952bd3fc6', '1076eab6753435c114e8a720c951b03da6d4e1bbbf1290f8d58ad7f97a0b8c64', '4ccf918f8b8ae99a769d89e0868a12e4af1536487652436b6c188bc99e14fdb6', '2a5cef1e9c76b52b9b56c6c021a857b0fa757897b6e3c96cc8170d5b73ba8dd8', '07267e696bfbb5af98da5a8efe2b8cf604bc9ab1ce95e4766f017473bfcd0de1', '82f56d4694c2ec964de0a4413954f87ca621628c63d7425944baeff9aa4b6dad', '01e1da53fe2751e7196114efc63dd70d9babc69b4b73c03d4b7528dcc10c05d3', 'fb8f3ca7fafc9c173404ce7f909038443a6078a0c278cb024639410e33f49f88', '44e497e2df0461bad9215c57918855022435eb6e28266916161de3f7902bb352', '84f5bc0e0be5d04b515e8e49efb393e4aec7189222b92c0555cc1be542e74549', '3195c90c03cf6a438b5684cc93128c53f794660a661e2aa85d043ca5ac7060b9', 'b5bacf05f766e143f6de9484b0b5a2d9655d62854368373bd77974b94cb722e6', '2442b9072d522cde54849b40cab26789e4af909f1dd81391cd8c87023515a21c', 'b03d79d1a547b36a28c6cba78f57b8244a4855f6b31003de3e617a5b5eddc070', 'e386562e3156c91934ceb045df46d7e847bb9afcad2794bda59be854f988befc', 'cc980749457292da3a6a4a3ce669ad487409ce72e20857e80c75741c83af7f0a', '75db9ae91b710fcf1df3553b8f9653b12d014f74ba1ee8f931870d2433e163f1', '0e313215df9694bc26777ba4ac347cb8ef73f8475d2bfed664aab722833589ae', '1094721b24c22ff67539ffeabab887f87e538bdd9ebe50b0b369de138d326802', 'fb2b9389e1455c6d64ae19158396d767d88969013b14075bcfdcc764f610108c', 'ae3bdd3a81d96e4aaa02f7d597a2684146f3af75b743bde8e31c3cf5883707db', '1b8137b4c60774716e4a492efec48060d48abd7308563d8cc76edf32d98bd759', '09732023af932d8c578c8a7ead49feb80cdb5c629cee6add2e24fcd7999c0309', '75b7020073ec0c8cedf517f1b56d554e2a5cfdf89d204633c30b863c42ed6f5f', '4be1dfb90ea542d5d84c23c0ba29b91db2491a39973839ee646eeec25c71adb4', 'c98d52f719106d13b14f27abde81ce00305cbf62889690b72da3e3ddc0286c02', '056859e4aa430e2eb983e93f08bb85d9afe9aec44f0e73263cf072df70b7c475', '870147c2dad0a0dda2dd0a9f85ef83b3c4de9a304fdff6d9fa9ccc4bde9d70c0', '26e942b0353fee8f5ac0a2c2e26c9b695c50b35c501eeb4bff343b1648b5cebc', '036168e918418eb807bc3efd361a8e66067192564da41e30e076d22be0f87935', 'a491df768673d76ae7dee4c9bf1ea1456e6c537a1f1683368d8bc6869cd89bf0', 'f6a8cfceb19b4cd796512223b8afd103c4aee7052247ebea8b50f743e9aa27b6', 'd135518ad4230c8f57a3510b3ddea8a99e2355363c9419a27340734427050729', 'cbe90e272b6be7696d3b8c171500847d2b0ae497f6911d0f9d5d8481101c4c1f', '249c961ea29438959ea2204728df24964ec80b8cd91c657715c47014f5e5a462', '1920ebb46d0cee2d379ef48c15f8f6abd01e2a183f316da235e0c3b7515feade', '6d1573b42d5f89f89b26b32cbbd32ff41660e0e8c3b3091f1cb278a42651e049', 'ec6878825845c61b3049ad5dd168197c84938e7f6d4fc938670da2528cf86317', '9829b13faebde69c2279c38cd54d524aa31acfdcc1cfba7910b9d69caa42e0dd', '2755ae7cda161df0c24e1fa9f1c3308bc9ef81a599d859668490484290ca72f4', '09d9dcfc1716808b0c62e47a771ff4d39ba71f22c8640776e65624747a995626', '71dfcd074b80de90c4955890bdbe127d12b249ed764c7c4ca23dc81c74fde71d', '3c1afbb156ee2d672ca131c7c966bc6875374a95d927848bafcc5a158edf67bb'] B "the service proxy function maps between app-flows and detnet flows. it must support the tsn stream identification functions and the related managed objects as defined in ieee8021cb and ieeep8021cbdb to recognize the app-flow related packets." {79: 1, 130: 1, 54: 1, 52: 1, 98: 1, 6: 1, 8: 1, 64: 1, 99: 1, 24: 1, 90: 2, 51: 2, 62: 4, 85: 4, 68: 3, 35: 2, 110: 2, 91: 4, 114: 2, 97: 2, 31: 2, 13: 2, 67: 2, 38: 3, 26: 2, 124: 2, 127: 2, 96: 2, 30: 3, 61: 4, 55: 2, 27: 3, 15: 2, 129: 2, 115: 2, 84: 2, 76: 5, 87: 2, 131: 4, 102: 2, 113: 4, 36: 2, 72: 3} {4: 1, 24: 1, 59: 1, 111: 1, 136: 1, 156: 1, 206: 1, 215: 1, 220: 1, 221: 1, 235: 1, 241: 1, 242: 1, 314: 1, 329: 1, 334: 1, 354: 1, 366: 1, 376: 1, 1: 8, 9: 4, 10: 2, 15: 2, 25: 4, 26: 4, 27: 2, 39: 4, 43: 2, 49: 5, 50: 4, 58: 4, 64: 2, 69: 3, 81: 5, 82: 3, 86: 2, 96: 3, 97: 2, 100: 6, 108: 2, 109: 3, 110: 3, 114: 2, 115: 3, 116: 2, 118: 5, 119: 4, 120: 2, 121: 3, 122: 3, 123: 2, 124: 3, 128: 3, 129: 3, 130: 4, 132: 3, 145: 3, 147: 3, 151: 3, 152: 3, 154: 2, 161: 2, 162: 2, 165: 2, 168: 3, 169: 2, 172: 2, 180: 3, 184: 4, 187: 4, 188: 3, 191: 2, 194: 3, 202: 4, 203: 5, 207: 2, 217: 2, 218: 7, 222: 4, 224: 2, 227: 4, 229: 2, 234: 4, 243: 3, 244: 3, 245: 3, 248: 3, 250: 3, 258: 10, 262: 3, 263: 4, 264: 2, 267: 3, 270: 2, 272: 2, 273: 4, 287: 2, 289: 2, 291: 4, 299: 4, 300: 2, 304: 2, 309: 2, 315: 2, 320: 3, 323: 3, 327: 3, 328: 2, 330: 9, 335: 2, 341: 4, 342: 5, 347: 4, 348: 4, 350: 6, 351: 4, 352: 2, 353: 2, 358: 3, 365: 2, 371: 6, 372: 4, 384: 4, 385: 3, 386: 2, 387: 2, 392: 2, 393: 3, 396: 5, 397: 6, 398: 5, 402: 2} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 53 "Implementations of this document SHALL use management and control information to map a TSN Stream to a DetNet flow. N:1 mapping (aggregating TSN Streams in a single DetNet flow) SHALL be supported. The management or control function that provisions flow mapping SHALL ensure that adequate resources are allocated and configured to provide proper service requirements of the mapped flows." "Major clean up and simplification as data plane drafts can be referred for MPLS related details . TSN over DetNet MPLS follows the concept of RFC3985 . Description focus on Edge Nodes procedures and functions . Text covers the Edge Nodes components : ( 1 ) TSN functions ( in NSP block ) ; ( 2 ) DetNet Service Proxy ; and ( 3 ) DetNet sub - layers . Approving from teelcon review" 3486514b01b74d57f031bcf660311de328a6e0dc 3486514b01b74d57f031bcf660311de328a6e0dc draft-ietf-detnet-tsn-vpn-over-mpls 249c961ea29438959ea2204728df24964ec80b8cd91c657715c47014f5e5a462 ['e82e49a3c764c0ede490d9e8afe0d0a379ec1e2fb734910d7e42f179709f894c', '1b5276bed81725e3cab5fa8d2491ae7fc344c8638906d8e62ee7c31696edcb52', 'a6a4ee1a9211a2be0e24cf91f9742499a46567acff4c78f62b568b34e38c08de', '44d22f065218a14d5aa04288e7553c8a6d81bb222066c74ea38571bbe922a729', 'c757c3611002031d5ce1ac79d9984d826f392e6628a0657e045c348e52b7eda2', '8a105d9f9ffbf3e747a101e48de19122931cd0cce896dc27f57d16df9dbb75ac', 'a8ff14472a8fa48bacdc11d7089a9d1054c0a786f6152f510b5d4092c22e121f', 'e746630d4b45cf2b654a14e4daaa03ad634e33d92c29c489e3ef3fcd5620c311', '16375944152e6c3e73492437880fe39d7f0123a9292d062e8e9c7d317e4b878f', '42f5214bb177fd7faf01b7943e7f313a615b2490f9109d5cefa8b24101735c32', '5cc97b8f56cdeeb02e7c96183745dc53dd8ec3ec02424107d16eb438c2c9363c', 'a816e4d1392c9c85d398ee2c5116b5de849a9823bc552d322ac8725f7c9b859e', 'c7286f8983508fdd7d94ae798cdc3950cbf65865e905c00a76838a34eb79cf2c', '6924f7b3002e9f0dff9023b70bcc9d484e643c3a2d95b0d5c853c084ad3f68ab', '2d8fce3963de03360a5d98758067925a60474b5430fd8091fc72f3c50a9d38e5', '77f9aaec42bbb94079fae33b8c564cd7f64721106f615e11f22673310efaf01b', '09f8dc962fd9202d148a0b378c9a078ea850056b4b5c360c0914d4a1de6af454', '4826376633600232b766cb8a62d4054b0f5ea45d74878bcf57356e567088300c', '82b410c949db1d81b3f197adbaaba7b82b6e497600cd9883150af2bb815caa19', '0eb73f51f3b491bd6d969a05acf2b527e6e2f09a460cb88266513ab952bd3fc6', '1076eab6753435c114e8a720c951b03da6d4e1bbbf1290f8d58ad7f97a0b8c64', '4ccf918f8b8ae99a769d89e0868a12e4af1536487652436b6c188bc99e14fdb6', '2a5cef1e9c76b52b9b56c6c021a857b0fa757897b6e3c96cc8170d5b73ba8dd8', '07267e696bfbb5af98da5a8efe2b8cf604bc9ab1ce95e4766f017473bfcd0de1', '82f56d4694c2ec964de0a4413954f87ca621628c63d7425944baeff9aa4b6dad', '01e1da53fe2751e7196114efc63dd70d9babc69b4b73c03d4b7528dcc10c05d3', 'fb8f3ca7fafc9c173404ce7f909038443a6078a0c278cb024639410e33f49f88', '44e497e2df0461bad9215c57918855022435eb6e28266916161de3f7902bb352', '84f5bc0e0be5d04b515e8e49efb393e4aec7189222b92c0555cc1be542e74549', '3195c90c03cf6a438b5684cc93128c53f794660a661e2aa85d043ca5ac7060b9', 'b5bacf05f766e143f6de9484b0b5a2d9655d62854368373bd77974b94cb722e6', '2442b9072d522cde54849b40cab26789e4af909f1dd81391cd8c87023515a21c', 'b03d79d1a547b36a28c6cba78f57b8244a4855f6b31003de3e617a5b5eddc070', 'e386562e3156c91934ceb045df46d7e847bb9afcad2794bda59be854f988befc', 'cc980749457292da3a6a4a3ce669ad487409ce72e20857e80c75741c83af7f0a', '75db9ae91b710fcf1df3553b8f9653b12d014f74ba1ee8f931870d2433e163f1', '0e313215df9694bc26777ba4ac347cb8ef73f8475d2bfed664aab722833589ae', '1094721b24c22ff67539ffeabab887f87e538bdd9ebe50b0b369de138d326802', 'fb2b9389e1455c6d64ae19158396d767d88969013b14075bcfdcc764f610108c', 'ae3bdd3a81d96e4aaa02f7d597a2684146f3af75b743bde8e31c3cf5883707db', '1b8137b4c60774716e4a492efec48060d48abd7308563d8cc76edf32d98bd759', '09732023af932d8c578c8a7ead49feb80cdb5c629cee6add2e24fcd7999c0309', '75b7020073ec0c8cedf517f1b56d554e2a5cfdf89d204633c30b863c42ed6f5f', '4be1dfb90ea542d5d84c23c0ba29b91db2491a39973839ee646eeec25c71adb4', 'c98d52f719106d13b14f27abde81ce00305cbf62889690b72da3e3ddc0286c02', '056859e4aa430e2eb983e93f08bb85d9afe9aec44f0e73263cf072df70b7c475', '870147c2dad0a0dda2dd0a9f85ef83b3c4de9a304fdff6d9fa9ccc4bde9d70c0', '26e942b0353fee8f5ac0a2c2e26c9b695c50b35c501eeb4bff343b1648b5cebc', '036168e918418eb807bc3efd361a8e66067192564da41e30e076d22be0f87935', 'a491df768673d76ae7dee4c9bf1ea1456e6c537a1f1683368d8bc6869cd89bf0', 'f6a8cfceb19b4cd796512223b8afd103c4aee7052247ebea8b50f743e9aa27b6', 'd135518ad4230c8f57a3510b3ddea8a99e2355363c9419a27340734427050729', 'cbe90e272b6be7696d3b8c171500847d2b0ae497f6911d0f9d5d8481101c4c1f', '249c961ea29438959ea2204728df24964ec80b8cd91c657715c47014f5e5a462', '1920ebb46d0cee2d379ef48c15f8f6abd01e2a183f316da235e0c3b7515feade', '6d1573b42d5f89f89b26b32cbbd32ff41660e0e8c3b3091f1cb278a42651e049', 'ec6878825845c61b3049ad5dd168197c84938e7f6d4fc938670da2528cf86317', '9829b13faebde69c2279c38cd54d524aa31acfdcc1cfba7910b9d69caa42e0dd', '2755ae7cda161df0c24e1fa9f1c3308bc9ef81a599d859668490484290ca72f4', '09d9dcfc1716808b0c62e47a771ff4d39ba71f22c8640776e65624747a995626', '71dfcd074b80de90c4955890bdbe127d12b249ed764c7c4ca23dc81c74fde71d', '3c1afbb156ee2d672ca131c7c966bc6875374a95d927848bafcc5a158edf67bb'] B "implementations of this document shall use management and control information to map a tsn stream to a detnet flow. n:1 mapping (aggregating tsn streams in a single detnet flow) shall be supported. the management or control function that provisions flow mapping shall ensure that adequate resources are allocated and configured to provide proper service requirements of the mapped flows." {79: 1, 130: 1, 54: 1, 52: 1, 98: 1, 6: 1, 8: 1, 64: 1, 99: 1, 24: 1, 90: 2, 51: 2, 62: 4, 85: 4, 68: 3, 35: 2, 110: 2, 91: 4, 114: 2, 97: 2, 31: 2, 13: 2, 67: 2, 38: 3, 26: 2, 124: 2, 127: 2, 96: 2, 30: 3, 61: 4, 55: 2, 27: 3, 15: 2, 129: 2, 115: 2, 84: 2, 76: 5, 87: 2, 131: 4, 102: 2, 113: 4, 36: 2, 72: 3} {4: 1, 24: 1, 59: 1, 111: 1, 136: 1, 156: 1, 206: 1, 215: 1, 220: 1, 221: 1, 235: 1, 241: 1, 242: 1, 314: 1, 329: 1, 334: 1, 354: 1, 366: 1, 376: 1, 1: 8, 9: 4, 10: 2, 15: 2, 25: 4, 26: 4, 27: 2, 39: 4, 43: 2, 49: 5, 50: 4, 58: 4, 64: 2, 69: 3, 81: 5, 82: 3, 86: 2, 96: 3, 97: 2, 100: 6, 108: 2, 109: 3, 110: 3, 114: 2, 115: 3, 116: 2, 118: 5, 119: 4, 120: 2, 121: 3, 122: 3, 123: 2, 124: 3, 128: 3, 129: 3, 130: 4, 132: 3, 145: 3, 147: 3, 151: 3, 152: 3, 154: 2, 161: 2, 162: 2, 165: 2, 168: 3, 169: 2, 172: 2, 180: 3, 184: 4, 187: 4, 188: 3, 191: 2, 194: 3, 202: 4, 203: 5, 207: 2, 217: 2, 218: 7, 222: 4, 224: 2, 227: 4, 229: 2, 234: 4, 243: 3, 244: 3, 245: 3, 248: 3, 250: 3, 258: 10, 262: 3, 263: 4, 264: 2, 267: 3, 270: 2, 272: 2, 273: 4, 287: 2, 289: 2, 291: 4, 299: 4, 300: 2, 304: 2, 309: 2, 315: 2, 320: 3, 323: 3, 327: 3, 328: 2, 330: 9, 335: 2, 341: 4, 342: 5, 347: 4, 348: 4, 350: 6, 351: 4, 352: 2, 353: 2, 358: 3, 365: 2, 371: 6, 372: 4, 384: 4, 385: 3, 386: 2, 387: 2, 392: 2, 393: 3, 396: 5, 397: 6, 398: 5, 402: 2} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 53 "Due to the (intentional) similarities of the DetNet PREOF and TSN FRER functions service protection function interworking is possible between the TSN and the DetNet domains. Such service protection interworking scenarios MAY require to copy sequence number fields from TSN (L2) to PW (MPLS) encapsulation. However, such interworking is out-of-scope in this document and left for further study." "Major clean up and simplification as data plane drafts can be referred for MPLS related details . TSN over DetNet MPLS follows the concept of RFC3985 . Description focus on Edge Nodes procedures and functions . Text covers the Edge Nodes components : ( 1 ) TSN functions ( in NSP block ) ; ( 2 ) DetNet Service Proxy ; and ( 3 ) DetNet sub - layers . Approving from teelcon review" 3486514b01b74d57f031bcf660311de328a6e0dc 3486514b01b74d57f031bcf660311de328a6e0dc draft-ietf-detnet-tsn-vpn-over-mpls a816e4d1392c9c85d398ee2c5116b5de849a9823bc552d322ac8725f7c9b859e ['e82e49a3c764c0ede490d9e8afe0d0a379ec1e2fb734910d7e42f179709f894c', '1b5276bed81725e3cab5fa8d2491ae7fc344c8638906d8e62ee7c31696edcb52', 'a6a4ee1a9211a2be0e24cf91f9742499a46567acff4c78f62b568b34e38c08de', '44d22f065218a14d5aa04288e7553c8a6d81bb222066c74ea38571bbe922a729', 'c757c3611002031d5ce1ac79d9984d826f392e6628a0657e045c348e52b7eda2', '8a105d9f9ffbf3e747a101e48de19122931cd0cce896dc27f57d16df9dbb75ac', 'a8ff14472a8fa48bacdc11d7089a9d1054c0a786f6152f510b5d4092c22e121f', 'e746630d4b45cf2b654a14e4daaa03ad634e33d92c29c489e3ef3fcd5620c311', '16375944152e6c3e73492437880fe39d7f0123a9292d062e8e9c7d317e4b878f', '42f5214bb177fd7faf01b7943e7f313a615b2490f9109d5cefa8b24101735c32', '5cc97b8f56cdeeb02e7c96183745dc53dd8ec3ec02424107d16eb438c2c9363c', 'a816e4d1392c9c85d398ee2c5116b5de849a9823bc552d322ac8725f7c9b859e', 'c7286f8983508fdd7d94ae798cdc3950cbf65865e905c00a76838a34eb79cf2c', '6924f7b3002e9f0dff9023b70bcc9d484e643c3a2d95b0d5c853c084ad3f68ab', '2d8fce3963de03360a5d98758067925a60474b5430fd8091fc72f3c50a9d38e5', '77f9aaec42bbb94079fae33b8c564cd7f64721106f615e11f22673310efaf01b', '09f8dc962fd9202d148a0b378c9a078ea850056b4b5c360c0914d4a1de6af454', '4826376633600232b766cb8a62d4054b0f5ea45d74878bcf57356e567088300c', '82b410c949db1d81b3f197adbaaba7b82b6e497600cd9883150af2bb815caa19', '0eb73f51f3b491bd6d969a05acf2b527e6e2f09a460cb88266513ab952bd3fc6', '1076eab6753435c114e8a720c951b03da6d4e1bbbf1290f8d58ad7f97a0b8c64', '4ccf918f8b8ae99a769d89e0868a12e4af1536487652436b6c188bc99e14fdb6', '2a5cef1e9c76b52b9b56c6c021a857b0fa757897b6e3c96cc8170d5b73ba8dd8', '07267e696bfbb5af98da5a8efe2b8cf604bc9ab1ce95e4766f017473bfcd0de1', '82f56d4694c2ec964de0a4413954f87ca621628c63d7425944baeff9aa4b6dad', '01e1da53fe2751e7196114efc63dd70d9babc69b4b73c03d4b7528dcc10c05d3', 'fb8f3ca7fafc9c173404ce7f909038443a6078a0c278cb024639410e33f49f88', '44e497e2df0461bad9215c57918855022435eb6e28266916161de3f7902bb352', '84f5bc0e0be5d04b515e8e49efb393e4aec7189222b92c0555cc1be542e74549', '3195c90c03cf6a438b5684cc93128c53f794660a661e2aa85d043ca5ac7060b9', 'b5bacf05f766e143f6de9484b0b5a2d9655d62854368373bd77974b94cb722e6', '2442b9072d522cde54849b40cab26789e4af909f1dd81391cd8c87023515a21c', 'b03d79d1a547b36a28c6cba78f57b8244a4855f6b31003de3e617a5b5eddc070', 'e386562e3156c91934ceb045df46d7e847bb9afcad2794bda59be854f988befc', 'cc980749457292da3a6a4a3ce669ad487409ce72e20857e80c75741c83af7f0a', '75db9ae91b710fcf1df3553b8f9653b12d014f74ba1ee8f931870d2433e163f1', '0e313215df9694bc26777ba4ac347cb8ef73f8475d2bfed664aab722833589ae', '1094721b24c22ff67539ffeabab887f87e538bdd9ebe50b0b369de138d326802', 'fb2b9389e1455c6d64ae19158396d767d88969013b14075bcfdcc764f610108c', 'ae3bdd3a81d96e4aaa02f7d597a2684146f3af75b743bde8e31c3cf5883707db', '1b8137b4c60774716e4a492efec48060d48abd7308563d8cc76edf32d98bd759', '09732023af932d8c578c8a7ead49feb80cdb5c629cee6add2e24fcd7999c0309', '75b7020073ec0c8cedf517f1b56d554e2a5cfdf89d204633c30b863c42ed6f5f', '4be1dfb90ea542d5d84c23c0ba29b91db2491a39973839ee646eeec25c71adb4', 'c98d52f719106d13b14f27abde81ce00305cbf62889690b72da3e3ddc0286c02', '056859e4aa430e2eb983e93f08bb85d9afe9aec44f0e73263cf072df70b7c475', '870147c2dad0a0dda2dd0a9f85ef83b3c4de9a304fdff6d9fa9ccc4bde9d70c0', '26e942b0353fee8f5ac0a2c2e26c9b695c50b35c501eeb4bff343b1648b5cebc', '036168e918418eb807bc3efd361a8e66067192564da41e30e076d22be0f87935', 'a491df768673d76ae7dee4c9bf1ea1456e6c537a1f1683368d8bc6869cd89bf0', 'f6a8cfceb19b4cd796512223b8afd103c4aee7052247ebea8b50f743e9aa27b6', 'd135518ad4230c8f57a3510b3ddea8a99e2355363c9419a27340734427050729', 'cbe90e272b6be7696d3b8c171500847d2b0ae497f6911d0f9d5d8481101c4c1f', '249c961ea29438959ea2204728df24964ec80b8cd91c657715c47014f5e5a462', '1920ebb46d0cee2d379ef48c15f8f6abd01e2a183f316da235e0c3b7515feade', '6d1573b42d5f89f89b26b32cbbd32ff41660e0e8c3b3091f1cb278a42651e049', 'ec6878825845c61b3049ad5dd168197c84938e7f6d4fc938670da2528cf86317', '9829b13faebde69c2279c38cd54d524aa31acfdcc1cfba7910b9d69caa42e0dd', '2755ae7cda161df0c24e1fa9f1c3308bc9ef81a599d859668490484290ca72f4', '09d9dcfc1716808b0c62e47a771ff4d39ba71f22c8640776e65624747a995626', '71dfcd074b80de90c4955890bdbe127d12b249ed764c7c4ca23dc81c74fde71d', '3c1afbb156ee2d672ca131c7c966bc6875374a95d927848bafcc5a158edf67bb'] B "due to the (intentional) similarities of the detnet preof and tsn frer functions service protection function interworking is possible between the tsn and the detnet domains. such service protection interworking scenarios may require to copy sequence number fields from tsn (l2) to pw (mpls) encapsulation. however, such interworking is out-of-scope in this document and left for further study." {79: 1, 130: 1, 54: 1, 52: 1, 98: 1, 6: 1, 8: 1, 64: 1, 99: 1, 24: 1, 90: 2, 51: 2, 62: 4, 85: 4, 68: 3, 35: 2, 110: 2, 91: 4, 114: 2, 97: 2, 31: 2, 13: 2, 67: 2, 38: 3, 26: 2, 124: 2, 127: 2, 96: 2, 30: 3, 61: 4, 55: 2, 27: 3, 15: 2, 129: 2, 115: 2, 84: 2, 76: 5, 87: 2, 131: 4, 102: 2, 113: 4, 36: 2, 72: 3} {4: 1, 24: 1, 59: 1, 111: 1, 136: 1, 156: 1, 206: 1, 215: 1, 220: 1, 221: 1, 235: 1, 241: 1, 242: 1, 314: 1, 329: 1, 334: 1, 354: 1, 366: 1, 376: 1, 1: 8, 9: 4, 10: 2, 15: 2, 25: 4, 26: 4, 27: 2, 39: 4, 43: 2, 49: 5, 50: 4, 58: 4, 64: 2, 69: 3, 81: 5, 82: 3, 86: 2, 96: 3, 97: 2, 100: 6, 108: 2, 109: 3, 110: 3, 114: 2, 115: 3, 116: 2, 118: 5, 119: 4, 120: 2, 121: 3, 122: 3, 123: 2, 124: 3, 128: 3, 129: 3, 130: 4, 132: 3, 145: 3, 147: 3, 151: 3, 152: 3, 154: 2, 161: 2, 162: 2, 165: 2, 168: 3, 169: 2, 172: 2, 180: 3, 184: 4, 187: 4, 188: 3, 191: 2, 194: 3, 202: 4, 203: 5, 207: 2, 217: 2, 218: 7, 222: 4, 224: 2, 227: 4, 229: 2, 234: 4, 243: 3, 244: 3, 245: 3, 248: 3, 250: 3, 258: 10, 262: 3, 263: 4, 264: 2, 267: 3, 270: 2, 272: 2, 273: 4, 287: 2, 289: 2, 291: 4, 299: 4, 300: 2, 304: 2, 309: 2, 315: 2, 320: 3, 323: 3, 327: 3, 328: 2, 330: 9, 335: 2, 341: 4, 342: 5, 347: 4, 348: 4, 350: 6, 351: 4, 352: 2, 353: 2, 358: 3, 365: 2, 371: 6, 372: 4, 384: 4, 385: 3, 386: 2, 387: 2, 392: 2, 393: 3, 396: 5, 397: 6, 398: 5, 402: 2} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 53 "In the design of I-D.ietf-detnet-mpls an MPLS service label (the S-Label), similar to a pseudowire (PW) label RFC3985, is used to identify both the DetNet flow identity and the payload MPLS payload type. The DetNet sequence number is carried in the DetNet Control word (d-CW) which carries the Data/OAM discriminator as well. In I- D.ietf-detnet-mpls two sequence number sizes are supported: a 16 bit sequence number and a 28 bit sequence number." "Major clean up and simplification as data plane drafts can be referred for MPLS related details . TSN over DetNet MPLS follows the concept of RFC3985 . Description focus on Edge Nodes procedures and functions . Text covers the Edge Nodes components : ( 1 ) TSN functions ( in NSP block ) ; ( 2 ) DetNet Service Proxy ; and ( 3 ) DetNet sub - layers . Approving from teelcon review" 3486514b01b74d57f031bcf660311de328a6e0dc 3486514b01b74d57f031bcf660311de328a6e0dc draft-ietf-detnet-tsn-vpn-over-mpls ec6878825845c61b3049ad5dd168197c84938e7f6d4fc938670da2528cf86317 ['e82e49a3c764c0ede490d9e8afe0d0a379ec1e2fb734910d7e42f179709f894c', '1b5276bed81725e3cab5fa8d2491ae7fc344c8638906d8e62ee7c31696edcb52', 'a6a4ee1a9211a2be0e24cf91f9742499a46567acff4c78f62b568b34e38c08de', '44d22f065218a14d5aa04288e7553c8a6d81bb222066c74ea38571bbe922a729', 'c757c3611002031d5ce1ac79d9984d826f392e6628a0657e045c348e52b7eda2', '8a105d9f9ffbf3e747a101e48de19122931cd0cce896dc27f57d16df9dbb75ac', 'a8ff14472a8fa48bacdc11d7089a9d1054c0a786f6152f510b5d4092c22e121f', 'e746630d4b45cf2b654a14e4daaa03ad634e33d92c29c489e3ef3fcd5620c311', '16375944152e6c3e73492437880fe39d7f0123a9292d062e8e9c7d317e4b878f', '42f5214bb177fd7faf01b7943e7f313a615b2490f9109d5cefa8b24101735c32', '5cc97b8f56cdeeb02e7c96183745dc53dd8ec3ec02424107d16eb438c2c9363c', 'a816e4d1392c9c85d398ee2c5116b5de849a9823bc552d322ac8725f7c9b859e', 'c7286f8983508fdd7d94ae798cdc3950cbf65865e905c00a76838a34eb79cf2c', '6924f7b3002e9f0dff9023b70bcc9d484e643c3a2d95b0d5c853c084ad3f68ab', '2d8fce3963de03360a5d98758067925a60474b5430fd8091fc72f3c50a9d38e5', '77f9aaec42bbb94079fae33b8c564cd7f64721106f615e11f22673310efaf01b', '09f8dc962fd9202d148a0b378c9a078ea850056b4b5c360c0914d4a1de6af454', '4826376633600232b766cb8a62d4054b0f5ea45d74878bcf57356e567088300c', '82b410c949db1d81b3f197adbaaba7b82b6e497600cd9883150af2bb815caa19', '0eb73f51f3b491bd6d969a05acf2b527e6e2f09a460cb88266513ab952bd3fc6', '1076eab6753435c114e8a720c951b03da6d4e1bbbf1290f8d58ad7f97a0b8c64', '4ccf918f8b8ae99a769d89e0868a12e4af1536487652436b6c188bc99e14fdb6', '2a5cef1e9c76b52b9b56c6c021a857b0fa757897b6e3c96cc8170d5b73ba8dd8', '07267e696bfbb5af98da5a8efe2b8cf604bc9ab1ce95e4766f017473bfcd0de1', '82f56d4694c2ec964de0a4413954f87ca621628c63d7425944baeff9aa4b6dad', '01e1da53fe2751e7196114efc63dd70d9babc69b4b73c03d4b7528dcc10c05d3', 'fb8f3ca7fafc9c173404ce7f909038443a6078a0c278cb024639410e33f49f88', '44e497e2df0461bad9215c57918855022435eb6e28266916161de3f7902bb352', '84f5bc0e0be5d04b515e8e49efb393e4aec7189222b92c0555cc1be542e74549', '3195c90c03cf6a438b5684cc93128c53f794660a661e2aa85d043ca5ac7060b9', 'b5bacf05f766e143f6de9484b0b5a2d9655d62854368373bd77974b94cb722e6', '2442b9072d522cde54849b40cab26789e4af909f1dd81391cd8c87023515a21c', 'b03d79d1a547b36a28c6cba78f57b8244a4855f6b31003de3e617a5b5eddc070', 'e386562e3156c91934ceb045df46d7e847bb9afcad2794bda59be854f988befc', 'cc980749457292da3a6a4a3ce669ad487409ce72e20857e80c75741c83af7f0a', '75db9ae91b710fcf1df3553b8f9653b12d014f74ba1ee8f931870d2433e163f1', '0e313215df9694bc26777ba4ac347cb8ef73f8475d2bfed664aab722833589ae', '1094721b24c22ff67539ffeabab887f87e538bdd9ebe50b0b369de138d326802', 'fb2b9389e1455c6d64ae19158396d767d88969013b14075bcfdcc764f610108c', 'ae3bdd3a81d96e4aaa02f7d597a2684146f3af75b743bde8e31c3cf5883707db', '1b8137b4c60774716e4a492efec48060d48abd7308563d8cc76edf32d98bd759', '09732023af932d8c578c8a7ead49feb80cdb5c629cee6add2e24fcd7999c0309', '75b7020073ec0c8cedf517f1b56d554e2a5cfdf89d204633c30b863c42ed6f5f', '4be1dfb90ea542d5d84c23c0ba29b91db2491a39973839ee646eeec25c71adb4', 'c98d52f719106d13b14f27abde81ce00305cbf62889690b72da3e3ddc0286c02', '056859e4aa430e2eb983e93f08bb85d9afe9aec44f0e73263cf072df70b7c475', '870147c2dad0a0dda2dd0a9f85ef83b3c4de9a304fdff6d9fa9ccc4bde9d70c0', '26e942b0353fee8f5ac0a2c2e26c9b695c50b35c501eeb4bff343b1648b5cebc', '036168e918418eb807bc3efd361a8e66067192564da41e30e076d22be0f87935', 'a491df768673d76ae7dee4c9bf1ea1456e6c537a1f1683368d8bc6869cd89bf0', 'f6a8cfceb19b4cd796512223b8afd103c4aee7052247ebea8b50f743e9aa27b6', 'd135518ad4230c8f57a3510b3ddea8a99e2355363c9419a27340734427050729', 'cbe90e272b6be7696d3b8c171500847d2b0ae497f6911d0f9d5d8481101c4c1f', '249c961ea29438959ea2204728df24964ec80b8cd91c657715c47014f5e5a462', '1920ebb46d0cee2d379ef48c15f8f6abd01e2a183f316da235e0c3b7515feade', '6d1573b42d5f89f89b26b32cbbd32ff41660e0e8c3b3091f1cb278a42651e049', 'ec6878825845c61b3049ad5dd168197c84938e7f6d4fc938670da2528cf86317', '9829b13faebde69c2279c38cd54d524aa31acfdcc1cfba7910b9d69caa42e0dd', '2755ae7cda161df0c24e1fa9f1c3308bc9ef81a599d859668490484290ca72f4', '09d9dcfc1716808b0c62e47a771ff4d39ba71f22c8640776e65624747a995626', '71dfcd074b80de90c4955890bdbe127d12b249ed764c7c4ca23dc81c74fde71d', '3c1afbb156ee2d672ca131c7c966bc6875374a95d927848bafcc5a158edf67bb'] B "in the design of i-d.ietf-detnet-mpls an mpls service label (the s-label), similar to a pseudowire (pw) label rfc3985, is used to identify both the detnet flow identity and the payload mpls payload type. the detnet sequence number is carried in the detnet control word (d-cw) which carries the data/oam discriminator as well. in i- d.ietf-detnet-mpls two sequence number sizes are supported: a 16 bit sequence number and a 28 bit sequence number." {79: 1, 130: 1, 54: 1, 52: 1, 98: 1, 6: 1, 8: 1, 64: 1, 99: 1, 24: 1, 90: 2, 51: 2, 62: 4, 85: 4, 68: 3, 35: 2, 110: 2, 91: 4, 114: 2, 97: 2, 31: 2, 13: 2, 67: 2, 38: 3, 26: 2, 124: 2, 127: 2, 96: 2, 30: 3, 61: 4, 55: 2, 27: 3, 15: 2, 129: 2, 115: 2, 84: 2, 76: 5, 87: 2, 131: 4, 102: 2, 113: 4, 36: 2, 72: 3} {4: 1, 24: 1, 59: 1, 111: 1, 136: 1, 156: 1, 206: 1, 215: 1, 220: 1, 221: 1, 235: 1, 241: 1, 242: 1, 314: 1, 329: 1, 334: 1, 354: 1, 366: 1, 376: 1, 1: 8, 9: 4, 10: 2, 15: 2, 25: 4, 26: 4, 27: 2, 39: 4, 43: 2, 49: 5, 50: 4, 58: 4, 64: 2, 69: 3, 81: 5, 82: 3, 86: 2, 96: 3, 97: 2, 100: 6, 108: 2, 109: 3, 110: 3, 114: 2, 115: 3, 116: 2, 118: 5, 119: 4, 120: 2, 121: 3, 122: 3, 123: 2, 124: 3, 128: 3, 129: 3, 130: 4, 132: 3, 145: 3, 147: 3, 151: 3, 152: 3, 154: 2, 161: 2, 162: 2, 165: 2, 168: 3, 169: 2, 172: 2, 180: 3, 184: 4, 187: 4, 188: 3, 191: 2, 194: 3, 202: 4, 203: 5, 207: 2, 217: 2, 218: 7, 222: 4, 224: 2, 227: 4, 229: 2, 234: 4, 243: 3, 244: 3, 245: 3, 248: 3, 250: 3, 258: 10, 262: 3, 263: 4, 264: 2, 267: 3, 270: 2, 272: 2, 273: 4, 287: 2, 289: 2, 291: 4, 299: 4, 300: 2, 304: 2, 309: 2, 315: 2, 320: 3, 323: 3, 327: 3, 328: 2, 330: 9, 335: 2, 341: 4, 342: 5, 347: 4, 348: 4, 350: 6, 351: 4, 352: 2, 353: 2, 358: 3, 365: 2, 371: 6, 372: 4, 384: 4, 385: 3, 386: 2, 387: 2, 392: 2, 393: 3, 396: 5, 397: 6, 398: 5, 402: 2} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 53 "PREOF functions and the provided service recovery is available only within the DetNet domain as the DetNet flow-ID and the DetNet sequence number are not valid outside the DetNet network. MPLS (DetNet) Edge node terminates all related information elements encoded in the MPLS labels." "Major clean up and simplification as data plane drafts can be referred for MPLS related details . TSN over DetNet MPLS follows the concept of RFC3985 . Description focus on Edge Nodes procedures and functions . Text covers the Edge Nodes components : ( 1 ) TSN functions ( in NSP block ) ; ( 2 ) DetNet Service Proxy ; and ( 3 ) DetNet sub - layers . Approving from teelcon review" 3486514b01b74d57f031bcf660311de328a6e0dc 3486514b01b74d57f031bcf660311de328a6e0dc draft-ietf-detnet-tsn-vpn-over-mpls 0eb73f51f3b491bd6d969a05acf2b527e6e2f09a460cb88266513ab952bd3fc6 ['e82e49a3c764c0ede490d9e8afe0d0a379ec1e2fb734910d7e42f179709f894c', '1b5276bed81725e3cab5fa8d2491ae7fc344c8638906d8e62ee7c31696edcb52', 'a6a4ee1a9211a2be0e24cf91f9742499a46567acff4c78f62b568b34e38c08de', '44d22f065218a14d5aa04288e7553c8a6d81bb222066c74ea38571bbe922a729', 'c757c3611002031d5ce1ac79d9984d826f392e6628a0657e045c348e52b7eda2', '8a105d9f9ffbf3e747a101e48de19122931cd0cce896dc27f57d16df9dbb75ac', 'a8ff14472a8fa48bacdc11d7089a9d1054c0a786f6152f510b5d4092c22e121f', 'e746630d4b45cf2b654a14e4daaa03ad634e33d92c29c489e3ef3fcd5620c311', '16375944152e6c3e73492437880fe39d7f0123a9292d062e8e9c7d317e4b878f', '42f5214bb177fd7faf01b7943e7f313a615b2490f9109d5cefa8b24101735c32', '5cc97b8f56cdeeb02e7c96183745dc53dd8ec3ec02424107d16eb438c2c9363c', 'a816e4d1392c9c85d398ee2c5116b5de849a9823bc552d322ac8725f7c9b859e', 'c7286f8983508fdd7d94ae798cdc3950cbf65865e905c00a76838a34eb79cf2c', '6924f7b3002e9f0dff9023b70bcc9d484e643c3a2d95b0d5c853c084ad3f68ab', '2d8fce3963de03360a5d98758067925a60474b5430fd8091fc72f3c50a9d38e5', '77f9aaec42bbb94079fae33b8c564cd7f64721106f615e11f22673310efaf01b', '09f8dc962fd9202d148a0b378c9a078ea850056b4b5c360c0914d4a1de6af454', '4826376633600232b766cb8a62d4054b0f5ea45d74878bcf57356e567088300c', '82b410c949db1d81b3f197adbaaba7b82b6e497600cd9883150af2bb815caa19', '0eb73f51f3b491bd6d969a05acf2b527e6e2f09a460cb88266513ab952bd3fc6', '1076eab6753435c114e8a720c951b03da6d4e1bbbf1290f8d58ad7f97a0b8c64', '4ccf918f8b8ae99a769d89e0868a12e4af1536487652436b6c188bc99e14fdb6', '2a5cef1e9c76b52b9b56c6c021a857b0fa757897b6e3c96cc8170d5b73ba8dd8', '07267e696bfbb5af98da5a8efe2b8cf604bc9ab1ce95e4766f017473bfcd0de1', '82f56d4694c2ec964de0a4413954f87ca621628c63d7425944baeff9aa4b6dad', '01e1da53fe2751e7196114efc63dd70d9babc69b4b73c03d4b7528dcc10c05d3', 'fb8f3ca7fafc9c173404ce7f909038443a6078a0c278cb024639410e33f49f88', '44e497e2df0461bad9215c57918855022435eb6e28266916161de3f7902bb352', '84f5bc0e0be5d04b515e8e49efb393e4aec7189222b92c0555cc1be542e74549', '3195c90c03cf6a438b5684cc93128c53f794660a661e2aa85d043ca5ac7060b9', 'b5bacf05f766e143f6de9484b0b5a2d9655d62854368373bd77974b94cb722e6', '2442b9072d522cde54849b40cab26789e4af909f1dd81391cd8c87023515a21c', 'b03d79d1a547b36a28c6cba78f57b8244a4855f6b31003de3e617a5b5eddc070', 'e386562e3156c91934ceb045df46d7e847bb9afcad2794bda59be854f988befc', 'cc980749457292da3a6a4a3ce669ad487409ce72e20857e80c75741c83af7f0a', '75db9ae91b710fcf1df3553b8f9653b12d014f74ba1ee8f931870d2433e163f1', '0e313215df9694bc26777ba4ac347cb8ef73f8475d2bfed664aab722833589ae', '1094721b24c22ff67539ffeabab887f87e538bdd9ebe50b0b369de138d326802', 'fb2b9389e1455c6d64ae19158396d767d88969013b14075bcfdcc764f610108c', 'ae3bdd3a81d96e4aaa02f7d597a2684146f3af75b743bde8e31c3cf5883707db', '1b8137b4c60774716e4a492efec48060d48abd7308563d8cc76edf32d98bd759', '09732023af932d8c578c8a7ead49feb80cdb5c629cee6add2e24fcd7999c0309', '75b7020073ec0c8cedf517f1b56d554e2a5cfdf89d204633c30b863c42ed6f5f', '4be1dfb90ea542d5d84c23c0ba29b91db2491a39973839ee646eeec25c71adb4', 'c98d52f719106d13b14f27abde81ce00305cbf62889690b72da3e3ddc0286c02', '056859e4aa430e2eb983e93f08bb85d9afe9aec44f0e73263cf072df70b7c475', '870147c2dad0a0dda2dd0a9f85ef83b3c4de9a304fdff6d9fa9ccc4bde9d70c0', '26e942b0353fee8f5ac0a2c2e26c9b695c50b35c501eeb4bff343b1648b5cebc', '036168e918418eb807bc3efd361a8e66067192564da41e30e076d22be0f87935', 'a491df768673d76ae7dee4c9bf1ea1456e6c537a1f1683368d8bc6869cd89bf0', 'f6a8cfceb19b4cd796512223b8afd103c4aee7052247ebea8b50f743e9aa27b6', 'd135518ad4230c8f57a3510b3ddea8a99e2355363c9419a27340734427050729', 'cbe90e272b6be7696d3b8c171500847d2b0ae497f6911d0f9d5d8481101c4c1f', '249c961ea29438959ea2204728df24964ec80b8cd91c657715c47014f5e5a462', '1920ebb46d0cee2d379ef48c15f8f6abd01e2a183f316da235e0c3b7515feade', '6d1573b42d5f89f89b26b32cbbd32ff41660e0e8c3b3091f1cb278a42651e049', 'ec6878825845c61b3049ad5dd168197c84938e7f6d4fc938670da2528cf86317', '9829b13faebde69c2279c38cd54d524aa31acfdcc1cfba7910b9d69caa42e0dd', '2755ae7cda161df0c24e1fa9f1c3308bc9ef81a599d859668490484290ca72f4', '09d9dcfc1716808b0c62e47a771ff4d39ba71f22c8640776e65624747a995626', '71dfcd074b80de90c4955890bdbe127d12b249ed764c7c4ca23dc81c74fde71d', '3c1afbb156ee2d672ca131c7c966bc6875374a95d927848bafcc5a158edf67bb'] B "preof functions and the provided service recovery is available only within the detnet domain as the detnet flow-id and the detnet sequence number are not valid outside the detnet network. mpls (detnet) edge node terminates all related information elements encoded in the mpls labels." {79: 1, 130: 1, 54: 1, 52: 1, 98: 1, 6: 1, 8: 1, 64: 1, 99: 1, 24: 1, 90: 2, 51: 2, 62: 4, 85: 4, 68: 3, 35: 2, 110: 2, 91: 4, 114: 2, 97: 2, 31: 2, 13: 2, 67: 2, 38: 3, 26: 2, 124: 2, 127: 2, 96: 2, 30: 3, 61: 4, 55: 2, 27: 3, 15: 2, 129: 2, 115: 2, 84: 2, 76: 5, 87: 2, 131: 4, 102: 2, 113: 4, 36: 2, 72: 3} {4: 1, 24: 1, 59: 1, 111: 1, 136: 1, 156: 1, 206: 1, 215: 1, 220: 1, 221: 1, 235: 1, 241: 1, 242: 1, 314: 1, 329: 1, 334: 1, 354: 1, 366: 1, 376: 1, 1: 8, 9: 4, 10: 2, 15: 2, 25: 4, 26: 4, 27: 2, 39: 4, 43: 2, 49: 5, 50: 4, 58: 4, 64: 2, 69: 3, 81: 5, 82: 3, 86: 2, 96: 3, 97: 2, 100: 6, 108: 2, 109: 3, 110: 3, 114: 2, 115: 3, 116: 2, 118: 5, 119: 4, 120: 2, 121: 3, 122: 3, 123: 2, 124: 3, 128: 3, 129: 3, 130: 4, 132: 3, 145: 3, 147: 3, 151: 3, 152: 3, 154: 2, 161: 2, 162: 2, 165: 2, 168: 3, 169: 2, 172: 2, 180: 3, 184: 4, 187: 4, 188: 3, 191: 2, 194: 3, 202: 4, 203: 5, 207: 2, 217: 2, 218: 7, 222: 4, 224: 2, 227: 4, 229: 2, 234: 4, 243: 3, 244: 3, 245: 3, 248: 3, 250: 3, 258: 10, 262: 3, 263: 4, 264: 2, 267: 3, 270: 2, 272: 2, 273: 4, 287: 2, 289: 2, 291: 4, 299: 4, 300: 2, 304: 2, 309: 2, 315: 2, 320: 3, 323: 3, 327: 3, 328: 2, 330: 9, 335: 2, 341: 4, 342: 5, 347: 4, 348: 4, 350: 6, 351: 4, 352: 2, 353: 2, 358: 3, 365: 2, 371: 6, 372: 4, 384: 4, 385: 3, 386: 2, 387: 2, 392: 2, 393: 3, 396: 5, 397: 6, 398: 5, 402: 2} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 53 "The LSP used to forward the DetNet packet may be of any type (MPLS- LDP, MPLS-TE, MPLS-TP RFC5921, or MPLS-SR I-D.ietf-spring-segment- routing-mpls). The LSP (F-Label) label and/or the S-Label may be used to indicate the queue processing as well as the forwarding parameters." "Major clean up and simplification as data plane drafts can be referred for MPLS related details . TSN over DetNet MPLS follows the concept of RFC3985 . Description focus on Edge Nodes procedures and functions . Text covers the Edge Nodes components : ( 1 ) TSN functions ( in NSP block ) ; ( 2 ) DetNet Service Proxy ; and ( 3 ) DetNet sub - layers . Approving from teelcon review" 3486514b01b74d57f031bcf660311de328a6e0dc 3486514b01b74d57f031bcf660311de328a6e0dc draft-ietf-detnet-tsn-vpn-over-mpls 056859e4aa430e2eb983e93f08bb85d9afe9aec44f0e73263cf072df70b7c475 ['e82e49a3c764c0ede490d9e8afe0d0a379ec1e2fb734910d7e42f179709f894c', '1b5276bed81725e3cab5fa8d2491ae7fc344c8638906d8e62ee7c31696edcb52', 'a6a4ee1a9211a2be0e24cf91f9742499a46567acff4c78f62b568b34e38c08de', '44d22f065218a14d5aa04288e7553c8a6d81bb222066c74ea38571bbe922a729', 'c757c3611002031d5ce1ac79d9984d826f392e6628a0657e045c348e52b7eda2', '8a105d9f9ffbf3e747a101e48de19122931cd0cce896dc27f57d16df9dbb75ac', 'a8ff14472a8fa48bacdc11d7089a9d1054c0a786f6152f510b5d4092c22e121f', 'e746630d4b45cf2b654a14e4daaa03ad634e33d92c29c489e3ef3fcd5620c311', '16375944152e6c3e73492437880fe39d7f0123a9292d062e8e9c7d317e4b878f', '42f5214bb177fd7faf01b7943e7f313a615b2490f9109d5cefa8b24101735c32', '5cc97b8f56cdeeb02e7c96183745dc53dd8ec3ec02424107d16eb438c2c9363c', 'a816e4d1392c9c85d398ee2c5116b5de849a9823bc552d322ac8725f7c9b859e', 'c7286f8983508fdd7d94ae798cdc3950cbf65865e905c00a76838a34eb79cf2c', '6924f7b3002e9f0dff9023b70bcc9d484e643c3a2d95b0d5c853c084ad3f68ab', '2d8fce3963de03360a5d98758067925a60474b5430fd8091fc72f3c50a9d38e5', '77f9aaec42bbb94079fae33b8c564cd7f64721106f615e11f22673310efaf01b', '09f8dc962fd9202d148a0b378c9a078ea850056b4b5c360c0914d4a1de6af454', '4826376633600232b766cb8a62d4054b0f5ea45d74878bcf57356e567088300c', '82b410c949db1d81b3f197adbaaba7b82b6e497600cd9883150af2bb815caa19', '0eb73f51f3b491bd6d969a05acf2b527e6e2f09a460cb88266513ab952bd3fc6', '1076eab6753435c114e8a720c951b03da6d4e1bbbf1290f8d58ad7f97a0b8c64', '4ccf918f8b8ae99a769d89e0868a12e4af1536487652436b6c188bc99e14fdb6', '2a5cef1e9c76b52b9b56c6c021a857b0fa757897b6e3c96cc8170d5b73ba8dd8', '07267e696bfbb5af98da5a8efe2b8cf604bc9ab1ce95e4766f017473bfcd0de1', '82f56d4694c2ec964de0a4413954f87ca621628c63d7425944baeff9aa4b6dad', '01e1da53fe2751e7196114efc63dd70d9babc69b4b73c03d4b7528dcc10c05d3', 'fb8f3ca7fafc9c173404ce7f909038443a6078a0c278cb024639410e33f49f88', '44e497e2df0461bad9215c57918855022435eb6e28266916161de3f7902bb352', '84f5bc0e0be5d04b515e8e49efb393e4aec7189222b92c0555cc1be542e74549', '3195c90c03cf6a438b5684cc93128c53f794660a661e2aa85d043ca5ac7060b9', 'b5bacf05f766e143f6de9484b0b5a2d9655d62854368373bd77974b94cb722e6', '2442b9072d522cde54849b40cab26789e4af909f1dd81391cd8c87023515a21c', 'b03d79d1a547b36a28c6cba78f57b8244a4855f6b31003de3e617a5b5eddc070', 'e386562e3156c91934ceb045df46d7e847bb9afcad2794bda59be854f988befc', 'cc980749457292da3a6a4a3ce669ad487409ce72e20857e80c75741c83af7f0a', '75db9ae91b710fcf1df3553b8f9653b12d014f74ba1ee8f931870d2433e163f1', '0e313215df9694bc26777ba4ac347cb8ef73f8475d2bfed664aab722833589ae', '1094721b24c22ff67539ffeabab887f87e538bdd9ebe50b0b369de138d326802', 'fb2b9389e1455c6d64ae19158396d767d88969013b14075bcfdcc764f610108c', 'ae3bdd3a81d96e4aaa02f7d597a2684146f3af75b743bde8e31c3cf5883707db', '1b8137b4c60774716e4a492efec48060d48abd7308563d8cc76edf32d98bd759', '09732023af932d8c578c8a7ead49feb80cdb5c629cee6add2e24fcd7999c0309', '75b7020073ec0c8cedf517f1b56d554e2a5cfdf89d204633c30b863c42ed6f5f', '4be1dfb90ea542d5d84c23c0ba29b91db2491a39973839ee646eeec25c71adb4', 'c98d52f719106d13b14f27abde81ce00305cbf62889690b72da3e3ddc0286c02', '056859e4aa430e2eb983e93f08bb85d9afe9aec44f0e73263cf072df70b7c475', '870147c2dad0a0dda2dd0a9f85ef83b3c4de9a304fdff6d9fa9ccc4bde9d70c0', '26e942b0353fee8f5ac0a2c2e26c9b695c50b35c501eeb4bff343b1648b5cebc', '036168e918418eb807bc3efd361a8e66067192564da41e30e076d22be0f87935', 'a491df768673d76ae7dee4c9bf1ea1456e6c537a1f1683368d8bc6869cd89bf0', 'f6a8cfceb19b4cd796512223b8afd103c4aee7052247ebea8b50f743e9aa27b6', 'd135518ad4230c8f57a3510b3ddea8a99e2355363c9419a27340734427050729', 'cbe90e272b6be7696d3b8c171500847d2b0ae497f6911d0f9d5d8481101c4c1f', '249c961ea29438959ea2204728df24964ec80b8cd91c657715c47014f5e5a462', '1920ebb46d0cee2d379ef48c15f8f6abd01e2a183f316da235e0c3b7515feade', '6d1573b42d5f89f89b26b32cbbd32ff41660e0e8c3b3091f1cb278a42651e049', 'ec6878825845c61b3049ad5dd168197c84938e7f6d4fc938670da2528cf86317', '9829b13faebde69c2279c38cd54d524aa31acfdcc1cfba7910b9d69caa42e0dd', '2755ae7cda161df0c24e1fa9f1c3308bc9ef81a599d859668490484290ca72f4', '09d9dcfc1716808b0c62e47a771ff4d39ba71f22c8640776e65624747a995626', '71dfcd074b80de90c4955890bdbe127d12b249ed764c7c4ca23dc81c74fde71d', '3c1afbb156ee2d672ca131c7c966bc6875374a95d927848bafcc5a158edf67bb'] B "the lsp used to forward the detnet packet may be of any type (mpls- ldp, mpls-te, mpls-tp rfc5921, or mpls-sr i-d.ietf-spring-segment- routing-mpls). the lsp (f-label) label and/or the s-label may be used to indicate the queue processing as well as the forwarding parameters." {79: 1, 130: 1, 54: 1, 52: 1, 98: 1, 6: 1, 8: 1, 64: 1, 99: 1, 24: 1, 90: 2, 51: 2, 62: 4, 85: 4, 68: 3, 35: 2, 110: 2, 91: 4, 114: 2, 97: 2, 31: 2, 13: 2, 67: 2, 38: 3, 26: 2, 124: 2, 127: 2, 96: 2, 30: 3, 61: 4, 55: 2, 27: 3, 15: 2, 129: 2, 115: 2, 84: 2, 76: 5, 87: 2, 131: 4, 102: 2, 113: 4, 36: 2, 72: 3} {4: 1, 24: 1, 59: 1, 111: 1, 136: 1, 156: 1, 206: 1, 215: 1, 220: 1, 221: 1, 235: 1, 241: 1, 242: 1, 314: 1, 329: 1, 334: 1, 354: 1, 366: 1, 376: 1, 1: 8, 9: 4, 10: 2, 15: 2, 25: 4, 26: 4, 27: 2, 39: 4, 43: 2, 49: 5, 50: 4, 58: 4, 64: 2, 69: 3, 81: 5, 82: 3, 86: 2, 96: 3, 97: 2, 100: 6, 108: 2, 109: 3, 110: 3, 114: 2, 115: 3, 116: 2, 118: 5, 119: 4, 120: 2, 121: 3, 122: 3, 123: 2, 124: 3, 128: 3, 129: 3, 130: 4, 132: 3, 145: 3, 147: 3, 151: 3, 152: 3, 154: 2, 161: 2, 162: 2, 165: 2, 168: 3, 169: 2, 172: 2, 180: 3, 184: 4, 187: 4, 188: 3, 191: 2, 194: 3, 202: 4, 203: 5, 207: 2, 217: 2, 218: 7, 222: 4, 224: 2, 227: 4, 229: 2, 234: 4, 243: 3, 244: 3, 245: 3, 248: 3, 250: 3, 258: 10, 262: 3, 263: 4, 264: 2, 267: 3, 270: 2, 272: 2, 273: 4, 287: 2, 289: 2, 291: 4, 299: 4, 300: 2, 304: 2, 309: 2, 315: 2, 320: 3, 323: 3, 327: 3, 328: 2, 330: 9, 335: 2, 341: 4, 342: 5, 347: 4, 348: 4, 350: 6, 351: 4, 352: 2, 353: 2, 358: 3, 365: 2, 371: 6, 372: 4, 384: 4, 385: 3, 386: 2, 387: 2, 392: 2, 393: 3, 396: 5, 397: 6, 398: 5, 402: 2} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 53 For further details see I-D.ietf-detnet-mpls. "Major clean up and simplification as data plane drafts can be referred for MPLS related details . TSN over DetNet MPLS follows the concept of RFC3985 . Description focus on Edge Nodes procedures and functions . Text covers the Edge Nodes components : ( 1 ) TSN functions ( in NSP block ) ; ( 2 ) DetNet Service Proxy ; and ( 3 ) DetNet sub - layers . Approving from teelcon review" 3486514b01b74d57f031bcf660311de328a6e0dc 3486514b01b74d57f031bcf660311de328a6e0dc draft-ietf-detnet-tsn-vpn-over-mpls c7286f8983508fdd7d94ae798cdc3950cbf65865e905c00a76838a34eb79cf2c ['e82e49a3c764c0ede490d9e8afe0d0a379ec1e2fb734910d7e42f179709f894c', '1b5276bed81725e3cab5fa8d2491ae7fc344c8638906d8e62ee7c31696edcb52', 'a6a4ee1a9211a2be0e24cf91f9742499a46567acff4c78f62b568b34e38c08de', '44d22f065218a14d5aa04288e7553c8a6d81bb222066c74ea38571bbe922a729', 'c757c3611002031d5ce1ac79d9984d826f392e6628a0657e045c348e52b7eda2', '8a105d9f9ffbf3e747a101e48de19122931cd0cce896dc27f57d16df9dbb75ac', 'a8ff14472a8fa48bacdc11d7089a9d1054c0a786f6152f510b5d4092c22e121f', 'e746630d4b45cf2b654a14e4daaa03ad634e33d92c29c489e3ef3fcd5620c311', '16375944152e6c3e73492437880fe39d7f0123a9292d062e8e9c7d317e4b878f', '42f5214bb177fd7faf01b7943e7f313a615b2490f9109d5cefa8b24101735c32', '5cc97b8f56cdeeb02e7c96183745dc53dd8ec3ec02424107d16eb438c2c9363c', 'a816e4d1392c9c85d398ee2c5116b5de849a9823bc552d322ac8725f7c9b859e', 'c7286f8983508fdd7d94ae798cdc3950cbf65865e905c00a76838a34eb79cf2c', '6924f7b3002e9f0dff9023b70bcc9d484e643c3a2d95b0d5c853c084ad3f68ab', '2d8fce3963de03360a5d98758067925a60474b5430fd8091fc72f3c50a9d38e5', '77f9aaec42bbb94079fae33b8c564cd7f64721106f615e11f22673310efaf01b', '09f8dc962fd9202d148a0b378c9a078ea850056b4b5c360c0914d4a1de6af454', '4826376633600232b766cb8a62d4054b0f5ea45d74878bcf57356e567088300c', '82b410c949db1d81b3f197adbaaba7b82b6e497600cd9883150af2bb815caa19', '0eb73f51f3b491bd6d969a05acf2b527e6e2f09a460cb88266513ab952bd3fc6', '1076eab6753435c114e8a720c951b03da6d4e1bbbf1290f8d58ad7f97a0b8c64', '4ccf918f8b8ae99a769d89e0868a12e4af1536487652436b6c188bc99e14fdb6', '2a5cef1e9c76b52b9b56c6c021a857b0fa757897b6e3c96cc8170d5b73ba8dd8', '07267e696bfbb5af98da5a8efe2b8cf604bc9ab1ce95e4766f017473bfcd0de1', '82f56d4694c2ec964de0a4413954f87ca621628c63d7425944baeff9aa4b6dad', '01e1da53fe2751e7196114efc63dd70d9babc69b4b73c03d4b7528dcc10c05d3', 'fb8f3ca7fafc9c173404ce7f909038443a6078a0c278cb024639410e33f49f88', '44e497e2df0461bad9215c57918855022435eb6e28266916161de3f7902bb352', '84f5bc0e0be5d04b515e8e49efb393e4aec7189222b92c0555cc1be542e74549', '3195c90c03cf6a438b5684cc93128c53f794660a661e2aa85d043ca5ac7060b9', 'b5bacf05f766e143f6de9484b0b5a2d9655d62854368373bd77974b94cb722e6', '2442b9072d522cde54849b40cab26789e4af909f1dd81391cd8c87023515a21c', 'b03d79d1a547b36a28c6cba78f57b8244a4855f6b31003de3e617a5b5eddc070', 'e386562e3156c91934ceb045df46d7e847bb9afcad2794bda59be854f988befc', 'cc980749457292da3a6a4a3ce669ad487409ce72e20857e80c75741c83af7f0a', '75db9ae91b710fcf1df3553b8f9653b12d014f74ba1ee8f931870d2433e163f1', '0e313215df9694bc26777ba4ac347cb8ef73f8475d2bfed664aab722833589ae', '1094721b24c22ff67539ffeabab887f87e538bdd9ebe50b0b369de138d326802', 'fb2b9389e1455c6d64ae19158396d767d88969013b14075bcfdcc764f610108c', 'ae3bdd3a81d96e4aaa02f7d597a2684146f3af75b743bde8e31c3cf5883707db', '1b8137b4c60774716e4a492efec48060d48abd7308563d8cc76edf32d98bd759', '09732023af932d8c578c8a7ead49feb80cdb5c629cee6add2e24fcd7999c0309', '75b7020073ec0c8cedf517f1b56d554e2a5cfdf89d204633c30b863c42ed6f5f', '4be1dfb90ea542d5d84c23c0ba29b91db2491a39973839ee646eeec25c71adb4', 'c98d52f719106d13b14f27abde81ce00305cbf62889690b72da3e3ddc0286c02', '056859e4aa430e2eb983e93f08bb85d9afe9aec44f0e73263cf072df70b7c475', '870147c2dad0a0dda2dd0a9f85ef83b3c4de9a304fdff6d9fa9ccc4bde9d70c0', '26e942b0353fee8f5ac0a2c2e26c9b695c50b35c501eeb4bff343b1648b5cebc', '036168e918418eb807bc3efd361a8e66067192564da41e30e076d22be0f87935', 'a491df768673d76ae7dee4c9bf1ea1456e6c537a1f1683368d8bc6869cd89bf0', 'f6a8cfceb19b4cd796512223b8afd103c4aee7052247ebea8b50f743e9aa27b6', 'd135518ad4230c8f57a3510b3ddea8a99e2355363c9419a27340734427050729', 'cbe90e272b6be7696d3b8c171500847d2b0ae497f6911d0f9d5d8481101c4c1f', '249c961ea29438959ea2204728df24964ec80b8cd91c657715c47014f5e5a462', '1920ebb46d0cee2d379ef48c15f8f6abd01e2a183f316da235e0c3b7515feade', '6d1573b42d5f89f89b26b32cbbd32ff41660e0e8c3b3091f1cb278a42651e049', 'ec6878825845c61b3049ad5dd168197c84938e7f6d4fc938670da2528cf86317', '9829b13faebde69c2279c38cd54d524aa31acfdcc1cfba7910b9d69caa42e0dd', '2755ae7cda161df0c24e1fa9f1c3308bc9ef81a599d859668490484290ca72f4', '09d9dcfc1716808b0c62e47a771ff4d39ba71f22c8640776e65624747a995626', '71dfcd074b80de90c4955890bdbe127d12b249ed764c7c4ca23dc81c74fde71d', '3c1afbb156ee2d672ca131c7c966bc6875374a95d927848bafcc5a158edf67bb'] B for further details see i-d.ietf-detnet-mpls. {79: 1, 130: 1, 54: 1, 52: 1, 98: 1, 6: 1, 8: 1, 64: 1, 99: 1, 24: 1, 90: 2, 51: 2, 62: 4, 85: 4, 68: 3, 35: 2, 110: 2, 91: 4, 114: 2, 97: 2, 31: 2, 13: 2, 67: 2, 38: 3, 26: 2, 124: 2, 127: 2, 96: 2, 30: 3, 61: 4, 55: 2, 27: 3, 15: 2, 129: 2, 115: 2, 84: 2, 76: 5, 87: 2, 131: 4, 102: 2, 113: 4, 36: 2, 72: 3} {4: 1, 24: 1, 59: 1, 111: 1, 136: 1, 156: 1, 206: 1, 215: 1, 220: 1, 221: 1, 235: 1, 241: 1, 242: 1, 314: 1, 329: 1, 334: 1, 354: 1, 366: 1, 376: 1, 1: 8, 9: 4, 10: 2, 15: 2, 25: 4, 26: 4, 27: 2, 39: 4, 43: 2, 49: 5, 50: 4, 58: 4, 64: 2, 69: 3, 81: 5, 82: 3, 86: 2, 96: 3, 97: 2, 100: 6, 108: 2, 109: 3, 110: 3, 114: 2, 115: 3, 116: 2, 118: 5, 119: 4, 120: 2, 121: 3, 122: 3, 123: 2, 124: 3, 128: 3, 129: 3, 130: 4, 132: 3, 145: 3, 147: 3, 151: 3, 152: 3, 154: 2, 161: 2, 162: 2, 165: 2, 168: 3, 169: 2, 172: 2, 180: 3, 184: 4, 187: 4, 188: 3, 191: 2, 194: 3, 202: 4, 203: 5, 207: 2, 217: 2, 218: 7, 222: 4, 224: 2, 227: 4, 229: 2, 234: 4, 243: 3, 244: 3, 245: 3, 248: 3, 250: 3, 258: 10, 262: 3, 263: 4, 264: 2, 267: 3, 270: 2, 272: 2, 273: 4, 287: 2, 289: 2, 291: 4, 299: 4, 300: 2, 304: 2, 309: 2, 315: 2, 320: 3, 323: 3, 327: 3, 328: 2, 330: 9, 335: 2, 341: 4, 342: 5, 347: 4, 348: 4, 350: 6, 351: 4, 352: 2, 353: 2, 358: 3, 365: 2, 371: 6, 372: 4, 384: 4, 385: 3, 386: 2, 387: 2, 392: 2, 393: 3, 396: 5, 397: 6, 398: 5, 402: 2} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 53 "TSN Stream(s) to DetNet flow mapping related information are required only for the service proxy function of MPLS (DetNet) Edge nodes. From the Data Plane perspective there is no practical difference based on the origin of flow mapping related information (management plane or control plane)." "Major clean up and simplification as data plane drafts can be referred for MPLS related details . TSN over DetNet MPLS follows the concept of RFC3985 . Description focus on Edge Nodes procedures and functions . Text covers the Edge Nodes components : ( 1 ) TSN functions ( in NSP block ) ; ( 2 ) DetNet Service Proxy ; and ( 3 ) DetNet sub - layers . Approving from teelcon review" 3486514b01b74d57f031bcf660311de328a6e0dc 3486514b01b74d57f031bcf660311de328a6e0dc draft-ietf-detnet-tsn-vpn-over-mpls 07267e696bfbb5af98da5a8efe2b8cf604bc9ab1ce95e4766f017473bfcd0de1 ['e82e49a3c764c0ede490d9e8afe0d0a379ec1e2fb734910d7e42f179709f894c', '1b5276bed81725e3cab5fa8d2491ae7fc344c8638906d8e62ee7c31696edcb52', 'a6a4ee1a9211a2be0e24cf91f9742499a46567acff4c78f62b568b34e38c08de', '44d22f065218a14d5aa04288e7553c8a6d81bb222066c74ea38571bbe922a729', 'c757c3611002031d5ce1ac79d9984d826f392e6628a0657e045c348e52b7eda2', '8a105d9f9ffbf3e747a101e48de19122931cd0cce896dc27f57d16df9dbb75ac', 'a8ff14472a8fa48bacdc11d7089a9d1054c0a786f6152f510b5d4092c22e121f', 'e746630d4b45cf2b654a14e4daaa03ad634e33d92c29c489e3ef3fcd5620c311', '16375944152e6c3e73492437880fe39d7f0123a9292d062e8e9c7d317e4b878f', '42f5214bb177fd7faf01b7943e7f313a615b2490f9109d5cefa8b24101735c32', '5cc97b8f56cdeeb02e7c96183745dc53dd8ec3ec02424107d16eb438c2c9363c', 'a816e4d1392c9c85d398ee2c5116b5de849a9823bc552d322ac8725f7c9b859e', 'c7286f8983508fdd7d94ae798cdc3950cbf65865e905c00a76838a34eb79cf2c', '6924f7b3002e9f0dff9023b70bcc9d484e643c3a2d95b0d5c853c084ad3f68ab', '2d8fce3963de03360a5d98758067925a60474b5430fd8091fc72f3c50a9d38e5', '77f9aaec42bbb94079fae33b8c564cd7f64721106f615e11f22673310efaf01b', '09f8dc962fd9202d148a0b378c9a078ea850056b4b5c360c0914d4a1de6af454', '4826376633600232b766cb8a62d4054b0f5ea45d74878bcf57356e567088300c', '82b410c949db1d81b3f197adbaaba7b82b6e497600cd9883150af2bb815caa19', '0eb73f51f3b491bd6d969a05acf2b527e6e2f09a460cb88266513ab952bd3fc6', '1076eab6753435c114e8a720c951b03da6d4e1bbbf1290f8d58ad7f97a0b8c64', '4ccf918f8b8ae99a769d89e0868a12e4af1536487652436b6c188bc99e14fdb6', '2a5cef1e9c76b52b9b56c6c021a857b0fa757897b6e3c96cc8170d5b73ba8dd8', '07267e696bfbb5af98da5a8efe2b8cf604bc9ab1ce95e4766f017473bfcd0de1', '82f56d4694c2ec964de0a4413954f87ca621628c63d7425944baeff9aa4b6dad', '01e1da53fe2751e7196114efc63dd70d9babc69b4b73c03d4b7528dcc10c05d3', 'fb8f3ca7fafc9c173404ce7f909038443a6078a0c278cb024639410e33f49f88', '44e497e2df0461bad9215c57918855022435eb6e28266916161de3f7902bb352', '84f5bc0e0be5d04b515e8e49efb393e4aec7189222b92c0555cc1be542e74549', '3195c90c03cf6a438b5684cc93128c53f794660a661e2aa85d043ca5ac7060b9', 'b5bacf05f766e143f6de9484b0b5a2d9655d62854368373bd77974b94cb722e6', '2442b9072d522cde54849b40cab26789e4af909f1dd81391cd8c87023515a21c', 'b03d79d1a547b36a28c6cba78f57b8244a4855f6b31003de3e617a5b5eddc070', 'e386562e3156c91934ceb045df46d7e847bb9afcad2794bda59be854f988befc', 'cc980749457292da3a6a4a3ce669ad487409ce72e20857e80c75741c83af7f0a', '75db9ae91b710fcf1df3553b8f9653b12d014f74ba1ee8f931870d2433e163f1', '0e313215df9694bc26777ba4ac347cb8ef73f8475d2bfed664aab722833589ae', '1094721b24c22ff67539ffeabab887f87e538bdd9ebe50b0b369de138d326802', 'fb2b9389e1455c6d64ae19158396d767d88969013b14075bcfdcc764f610108c', 'ae3bdd3a81d96e4aaa02f7d597a2684146f3af75b743bde8e31c3cf5883707db', '1b8137b4c60774716e4a492efec48060d48abd7308563d8cc76edf32d98bd759', '09732023af932d8c578c8a7ead49feb80cdb5c629cee6add2e24fcd7999c0309', '75b7020073ec0c8cedf517f1b56d554e2a5cfdf89d204633c30b863c42ed6f5f', '4be1dfb90ea542d5d84c23c0ba29b91db2491a39973839ee646eeec25c71adb4', 'c98d52f719106d13b14f27abde81ce00305cbf62889690b72da3e3ddc0286c02', '056859e4aa430e2eb983e93f08bb85d9afe9aec44f0e73263cf072df70b7c475', '870147c2dad0a0dda2dd0a9f85ef83b3c4de9a304fdff6d9fa9ccc4bde9d70c0', '26e942b0353fee8f5ac0a2c2e26c9b695c50b35c501eeb4bff343b1648b5cebc', '036168e918418eb807bc3efd361a8e66067192564da41e30e076d22be0f87935', 'a491df768673d76ae7dee4c9bf1ea1456e6c537a1f1683368d8bc6869cd89bf0', 'f6a8cfceb19b4cd796512223b8afd103c4aee7052247ebea8b50f743e9aa27b6', 'd135518ad4230c8f57a3510b3ddea8a99e2355363c9419a27340734427050729', 'cbe90e272b6be7696d3b8c171500847d2b0ae497f6911d0f9d5d8481101c4c1f', '249c961ea29438959ea2204728df24964ec80b8cd91c657715c47014f5e5a462', '1920ebb46d0cee2d379ef48c15f8f6abd01e2a183f316da235e0c3b7515feade', '6d1573b42d5f89f89b26b32cbbd32ff41660e0e8c3b3091f1cb278a42651e049', 'ec6878825845c61b3049ad5dd168197c84938e7f6d4fc938670da2528cf86317', '9829b13faebde69c2279c38cd54d524aa31acfdcc1cfba7910b9d69caa42e0dd', '2755ae7cda161df0c24e1fa9f1c3308bc9ef81a599d859668490484290ca72f4', '09d9dcfc1716808b0c62e47a771ff4d39ba71f22c8640776e65624747a995626', '71dfcd074b80de90c4955890bdbe127d12b249ed764c7c4ca23dc81c74fde71d', '3c1afbb156ee2d672ca131c7c966bc6875374a95d927848bafcc5a158edf67bb'] B "tsn stream(s) to detnet flow mapping related information are required only for the service proxy function of mpls (detnet) edge nodes. from the data plane perspective there is no practical difference based on the origin of flow mapping related information (management plane or control plane)." {79: 1, 130: 1, 54: 1, 52: 1, 98: 1, 6: 1, 8: 1, 64: 1, 99: 1, 24: 1, 90: 2, 51: 2, 62: 4, 85: 4, 68: 3, 35: 2, 110: 2, 91: 4, 114: 2, 97: 2, 31: 2, 13: 2, 67: 2, 38: 3, 26: 2, 124: 2, 127: 2, 96: 2, 30: 3, 61: 4, 55: 2, 27: 3, 15: 2, 129: 2, 115: 2, 84: 2, 76: 5, 87: 2, 131: 4, 102: 2, 113: 4, 36: 2, 72: 3} {4: 1, 24: 1, 59: 1, 111: 1, 136: 1, 156: 1, 206: 1, 215: 1, 220: 1, 221: 1, 235: 1, 241: 1, 242: 1, 314: 1, 329: 1, 334: 1, 354: 1, 366: 1, 376: 1, 1: 8, 9: 4, 10: 2, 15: 2, 25: 4, 26: 4, 27: 2, 39: 4, 43: 2, 49: 5, 50: 4, 58: 4, 64: 2, 69: 3, 81: 5, 82: 3, 86: 2, 96: 3, 97: 2, 100: 6, 108: 2, 109: 3, 110: 3, 114: 2, 115: 3, 116: 2, 118: 5, 119: 4, 120: 2, 121: 3, 122: 3, 123: 2, 124: 3, 128: 3, 129: 3, 130: 4, 132: 3, 145: 3, 147: 3, 151: 3, 152: 3, 154: 2, 161: 2, 162: 2, 165: 2, 168: 3, 169: 2, 172: 2, 180: 3, 184: 4, 187: 4, 188: 3, 191: 2, 194: 3, 202: 4, 203: 5, 207: 2, 217: 2, 218: 7, 222: 4, 224: 2, 227: 4, 229: 2, 234: 4, 243: 3, 244: 3, 245: 3, 248: 3, 250: 3, 258: 10, 262: 3, 263: 4, 264: 2, 267: 3, 270: 2, 272: 2, 273: 4, 287: 2, 289: 2, 291: 4, 299: 4, 300: 2, 304: 2, 309: 2, 315: 2, 320: 3, 323: 3, 327: 3, 328: 2, 330: 9, 335: 2, 341: 4, 342: 5, 347: 4, 348: 4, 350: 6, 351: 4, 352: 2, 353: 2, 358: 3, 365: 2, 371: 6, 372: 4, 384: 4, 385: 3, 386: 2, 387: 2, 392: 2, 393: 3, 396: 5, 397: 6, 398: 5, 402: 2} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 53 "MPLS DetNet Edge nodes are member of both the DetNet domain and the connected TSN network. From the TSN network perspective the MPLS (DetNet) Edge node has a ""TSN relay node"" role, so TSN specific management and control plane functionalities must be implemented. There are many similarities in the management plane techniques used in DetNet and TSN, but that is not the case for the control plane protocols. For example, RSVP-TE and MSRP behaves differently. Therefore management and control plane design is an important aspect of scenarios, where mapping between DetNet and TSN is required." "Major clean up and simplification as data plane drafts can be referred for MPLS related details . TSN over DetNet MPLS follows the concept of RFC3985 . Description focus on Edge Nodes procedures and functions . Text covers the Edge Nodes components : ( 1 ) TSN functions ( in NSP block ) ; ( 2 ) DetNet Service Proxy ; and ( 3 ) DetNet sub - layers . Approving from teelcon review" 3486514b01b74d57f031bcf660311de328a6e0dc 3486514b01b74d57f031bcf660311de328a6e0dc draft-ietf-detnet-tsn-vpn-over-mpls e386562e3156c91934ceb045df46d7e847bb9afcad2794bda59be854f988befc ['e82e49a3c764c0ede490d9e8afe0d0a379ec1e2fb734910d7e42f179709f894c', '1b5276bed81725e3cab5fa8d2491ae7fc344c8638906d8e62ee7c31696edcb52', 'a6a4ee1a9211a2be0e24cf91f9742499a46567acff4c78f62b568b34e38c08de', '44d22f065218a14d5aa04288e7553c8a6d81bb222066c74ea38571bbe922a729', 'c757c3611002031d5ce1ac79d9984d826f392e6628a0657e045c348e52b7eda2', '8a105d9f9ffbf3e747a101e48de19122931cd0cce896dc27f57d16df9dbb75ac', 'a8ff14472a8fa48bacdc11d7089a9d1054c0a786f6152f510b5d4092c22e121f', 'e746630d4b45cf2b654a14e4daaa03ad634e33d92c29c489e3ef3fcd5620c311', '16375944152e6c3e73492437880fe39d7f0123a9292d062e8e9c7d317e4b878f', '42f5214bb177fd7faf01b7943e7f313a615b2490f9109d5cefa8b24101735c32', '5cc97b8f56cdeeb02e7c96183745dc53dd8ec3ec02424107d16eb438c2c9363c', 'a816e4d1392c9c85d398ee2c5116b5de849a9823bc552d322ac8725f7c9b859e', 'c7286f8983508fdd7d94ae798cdc3950cbf65865e905c00a76838a34eb79cf2c', '6924f7b3002e9f0dff9023b70bcc9d484e643c3a2d95b0d5c853c084ad3f68ab', '2d8fce3963de03360a5d98758067925a60474b5430fd8091fc72f3c50a9d38e5', '77f9aaec42bbb94079fae33b8c564cd7f64721106f615e11f22673310efaf01b', '09f8dc962fd9202d148a0b378c9a078ea850056b4b5c360c0914d4a1de6af454', '4826376633600232b766cb8a62d4054b0f5ea45d74878bcf57356e567088300c', '82b410c949db1d81b3f197adbaaba7b82b6e497600cd9883150af2bb815caa19', '0eb73f51f3b491bd6d969a05acf2b527e6e2f09a460cb88266513ab952bd3fc6', '1076eab6753435c114e8a720c951b03da6d4e1bbbf1290f8d58ad7f97a0b8c64', '4ccf918f8b8ae99a769d89e0868a12e4af1536487652436b6c188bc99e14fdb6', '2a5cef1e9c76b52b9b56c6c021a857b0fa757897b6e3c96cc8170d5b73ba8dd8', '07267e696bfbb5af98da5a8efe2b8cf604bc9ab1ce95e4766f017473bfcd0de1', '82f56d4694c2ec964de0a4413954f87ca621628c63d7425944baeff9aa4b6dad', '01e1da53fe2751e7196114efc63dd70d9babc69b4b73c03d4b7528dcc10c05d3', 'fb8f3ca7fafc9c173404ce7f909038443a6078a0c278cb024639410e33f49f88', '44e497e2df0461bad9215c57918855022435eb6e28266916161de3f7902bb352', '84f5bc0e0be5d04b515e8e49efb393e4aec7189222b92c0555cc1be542e74549', '3195c90c03cf6a438b5684cc93128c53f794660a661e2aa85d043ca5ac7060b9', 'b5bacf05f766e143f6de9484b0b5a2d9655d62854368373bd77974b94cb722e6', '2442b9072d522cde54849b40cab26789e4af909f1dd81391cd8c87023515a21c', 'b03d79d1a547b36a28c6cba78f57b8244a4855f6b31003de3e617a5b5eddc070', 'e386562e3156c91934ceb045df46d7e847bb9afcad2794bda59be854f988befc', 'cc980749457292da3a6a4a3ce669ad487409ce72e20857e80c75741c83af7f0a', '75db9ae91b710fcf1df3553b8f9653b12d014f74ba1ee8f931870d2433e163f1', '0e313215df9694bc26777ba4ac347cb8ef73f8475d2bfed664aab722833589ae', '1094721b24c22ff67539ffeabab887f87e538bdd9ebe50b0b369de138d326802', 'fb2b9389e1455c6d64ae19158396d767d88969013b14075bcfdcc764f610108c', 'ae3bdd3a81d96e4aaa02f7d597a2684146f3af75b743bde8e31c3cf5883707db', '1b8137b4c60774716e4a492efec48060d48abd7308563d8cc76edf32d98bd759', '09732023af932d8c578c8a7ead49feb80cdb5c629cee6add2e24fcd7999c0309', '75b7020073ec0c8cedf517f1b56d554e2a5cfdf89d204633c30b863c42ed6f5f', '4be1dfb90ea542d5d84c23c0ba29b91db2491a39973839ee646eeec25c71adb4', 'c98d52f719106d13b14f27abde81ce00305cbf62889690b72da3e3ddc0286c02', '056859e4aa430e2eb983e93f08bb85d9afe9aec44f0e73263cf072df70b7c475', '870147c2dad0a0dda2dd0a9f85ef83b3c4de9a304fdff6d9fa9ccc4bde9d70c0', '26e942b0353fee8f5ac0a2c2e26c9b695c50b35c501eeb4bff343b1648b5cebc', '036168e918418eb807bc3efd361a8e66067192564da41e30e076d22be0f87935', 'a491df768673d76ae7dee4c9bf1ea1456e6c537a1f1683368d8bc6869cd89bf0', 'f6a8cfceb19b4cd796512223b8afd103c4aee7052247ebea8b50f743e9aa27b6', 'd135518ad4230c8f57a3510b3ddea8a99e2355363c9419a27340734427050729', 'cbe90e272b6be7696d3b8c171500847d2b0ae497f6911d0f9d5d8481101c4c1f', '249c961ea29438959ea2204728df24964ec80b8cd91c657715c47014f5e5a462', '1920ebb46d0cee2d379ef48c15f8f6abd01e2a183f316da235e0c3b7515feade', '6d1573b42d5f89f89b26b32cbbd32ff41660e0e8c3b3091f1cb278a42651e049', 'ec6878825845c61b3049ad5dd168197c84938e7f6d4fc938670da2528cf86317', '9829b13faebde69c2279c38cd54d524aa31acfdcc1cfba7910b9d69caa42e0dd', '2755ae7cda161df0c24e1fa9f1c3308bc9ef81a599d859668490484290ca72f4', '09d9dcfc1716808b0c62e47a771ff4d39ba71f22c8640776e65624747a995626', '71dfcd074b80de90c4955890bdbe127d12b249ed764c7c4ca23dc81c74fde71d', '3c1afbb156ee2d672ca131c7c966bc6875374a95d927848bafcc5a158edf67bb'] B "mpls detnet edge nodes are member of both the detnet domain and the connected tsn network. from the tsn network perspective the mpls (detnet) edge node has a ""tsn relay node"" role, so tsn specific management and control plane functionalities must be implemented. there are many similarities in the management plane techniques used in detnet and tsn, but that is not the case for the control plane protocols. for example, rsvp-te and msrp behaves differently. therefore management and control plane design is an important aspect of scenarios, where mapping between detnet and tsn is required." {79: 1, 130: 1, 54: 1, 52: 1, 98: 1, 6: 1, 8: 1, 64: 1, 99: 1, 24: 1, 90: 2, 51: 2, 62: 4, 85: 4, 68: 3, 35: 2, 110: 2, 91: 4, 114: 2, 97: 2, 31: 2, 13: 2, 67: 2, 38: 3, 26: 2, 124: 2, 127: 2, 96: 2, 30: 3, 61: 4, 55: 2, 27: 3, 15: 2, 129: 2, 115: 2, 84: 2, 76: 5, 87: 2, 131: 4, 102: 2, 113: 4, 36: 2, 72: 3} {4: 1, 24: 1, 59: 1, 111: 1, 136: 1, 156: 1, 206: 1, 215: 1, 220: 1, 221: 1, 235: 1, 241: 1, 242: 1, 314: 1, 329: 1, 334: 1, 354: 1, 366: 1, 376: 1, 1: 8, 9: 4, 10: 2, 15: 2, 25: 4, 26: 4, 27: 2, 39: 4, 43: 2, 49: 5, 50: 4, 58: 4, 64: 2, 69: 3, 81: 5, 82: 3, 86: 2, 96: 3, 97: 2, 100: 6, 108: 2, 109: 3, 110: 3, 114: 2, 115: 3, 116: 2, 118: 5, 119: 4, 120: 2, 121: 3, 122: 3, 123: 2, 124: 3, 128: 3, 129: 3, 130: 4, 132: 3, 145: 3, 147: 3, 151: 3, 152: 3, 154: 2, 161: 2, 162: 2, 165: 2, 168: 3, 169: 2, 172: 2, 180: 3, 184: 4, 187: 4, 188: 3, 191: 2, 194: 3, 202: 4, 203: 5, 207: 2, 217: 2, 218: 7, 222: 4, 224: 2, 227: 4, 229: 2, 234: 4, 243: 3, 244: 3, 245: 3, 248: 3, 250: 3, 258: 10, 262: 3, 263: 4, 264: 2, 267: 3, 270: 2, 272: 2, 273: 4, 287: 2, 289: 2, 291: 4, 299: 4, 300: 2, 304: 2, 309: 2, 315: 2, 320: 3, 323: 3, 327: 3, 328: 2, 330: 9, 335: 2, 341: 4, 342: 5, 347: 4, 348: 4, 350: 6, 351: 4, 352: 2, 353: 2, 358: 3, 365: 2, 371: 6, 372: 4, 384: 4, 385: 3, 386: 2, 387: 2, 392: 2, 393: 3, 396: 5, 397: 6, 398: 5, 402: 2} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 53 "In order to use a DetNet network to interconnect TSN segments, TSN specific information must be converted to DetNet domain specific ones. TSN Stream ID(s) and stream(s) related parameters/requirements must be converted to a DetNet flow-ID and flow related parameters/ requirements. Note that, as the DetNet network is just a portion of the end2end TSN path (i.e., single hop from Ethernet perspective), some parameters (e.g., delay) may differ significantly. Other parameters (like bandwidth) also may have to be tuned due to the MPLS encapsulation used within the DetNet network." "Major clean up and simplification as data plane drafts can be referred for MPLS related details . TSN over DetNet MPLS follows the concept of RFC3985 . Description focus on Edge Nodes procedures and functions . Text covers the Edge Nodes components : ( 1 ) TSN functions ( in NSP block ) ; ( 2 ) DetNet Service Proxy ; and ( 3 ) DetNet sub - layers . Approving from teelcon review" 3486514b01b74d57f031bcf660311de328a6e0dc 3486514b01b74d57f031bcf660311de328a6e0dc draft-ietf-detnet-tsn-vpn-over-mpls b03d79d1a547b36a28c6cba78f57b8244a4855f6b31003de3e617a5b5eddc070 ['e82e49a3c764c0ede490d9e8afe0d0a379ec1e2fb734910d7e42f179709f894c', '1b5276bed81725e3cab5fa8d2491ae7fc344c8638906d8e62ee7c31696edcb52', 'a6a4ee1a9211a2be0e24cf91f9742499a46567acff4c78f62b568b34e38c08de', '44d22f065218a14d5aa04288e7553c8a6d81bb222066c74ea38571bbe922a729', 'c757c3611002031d5ce1ac79d9984d826f392e6628a0657e045c348e52b7eda2', '8a105d9f9ffbf3e747a101e48de19122931cd0cce896dc27f57d16df9dbb75ac', 'a8ff14472a8fa48bacdc11d7089a9d1054c0a786f6152f510b5d4092c22e121f', 'e746630d4b45cf2b654a14e4daaa03ad634e33d92c29c489e3ef3fcd5620c311', '16375944152e6c3e73492437880fe39d7f0123a9292d062e8e9c7d317e4b878f', '42f5214bb177fd7faf01b7943e7f313a615b2490f9109d5cefa8b24101735c32', '5cc97b8f56cdeeb02e7c96183745dc53dd8ec3ec02424107d16eb438c2c9363c', 'a816e4d1392c9c85d398ee2c5116b5de849a9823bc552d322ac8725f7c9b859e', 'c7286f8983508fdd7d94ae798cdc3950cbf65865e905c00a76838a34eb79cf2c', '6924f7b3002e9f0dff9023b70bcc9d484e643c3a2d95b0d5c853c084ad3f68ab', '2d8fce3963de03360a5d98758067925a60474b5430fd8091fc72f3c50a9d38e5', '77f9aaec42bbb94079fae33b8c564cd7f64721106f615e11f22673310efaf01b', '09f8dc962fd9202d148a0b378c9a078ea850056b4b5c360c0914d4a1de6af454', '4826376633600232b766cb8a62d4054b0f5ea45d74878bcf57356e567088300c', '82b410c949db1d81b3f197adbaaba7b82b6e497600cd9883150af2bb815caa19', '0eb73f51f3b491bd6d969a05acf2b527e6e2f09a460cb88266513ab952bd3fc6', '1076eab6753435c114e8a720c951b03da6d4e1bbbf1290f8d58ad7f97a0b8c64', '4ccf918f8b8ae99a769d89e0868a12e4af1536487652436b6c188bc99e14fdb6', '2a5cef1e9c76b52b9b56c6c021a857b0fa757897b6e3c96cc8170d5b73ba8dd8', '07267e696bfbb5af98da5a8efe2b8cf604bc9ab1ce95e4766f017473bfcd0de1', '82f56d4694c2ec964de0a4413954f87ca621628c63d7425944baeff9aa4b6dad', '01e1da53fe2751e7196114efc63dd70d9babc69b4b73c03d4b7528dcc10c05d3', 'fb8f3ca7fafc9c173404ce7f909038443a6078a0c278cb024639410e33f49f88', '44e497e2df0461bad9215c57918855022435eb6e28266916161de3f7902bb352', '84f5bc0e0be5d04b515e8e49efb393e4aec7189222b92c0555cc1be542e74549', '3195c90c03cf6a438b5684cc93128c53f794660a661e2aa85d043ca5ac7060b9', 'b5bacf05f766e143f6de9484b0b5a2d9655d62854368373bd77974b94cb722e6', '2442b9072d522cde54849b40cab26789e4af909f1dd81391cd8c87023515a21c', 'b03d79d1a547b36a28c6cba78f57b8244a4855f6b31003de3e617a5b5eddc070', 'e386562e3156c91934ceb045df46d7e847bb9afcad2794bda59be854f988befc', 'cc980749457292da3a6a4a3ce669ad487409ce72e20857e80c75741c83af7f0a', '75db9ae91b710fcf1df3553b8f9653b12d014f74ba1ee8f931870d2433e163f1', '0e313215df9694bc26777ba4ac347cb8ef73f8475d2bfed664aab722833589ae', '1094721b24c22ff67539ffeabab887f87e538bdd9ebe50b0b369de138d326802', 'fb2b9389e1455c6d64ae19158396d767d88969013b14075bcfdcc764f610108c', 'ae3bdd3a81d96e4aaa02f7d597a2684146f3af75b743bde8e31c3cf5883707db', '1b8137b4c60774716e4a492efec48060d48abd7308563d8cc76edf32d98bd759', '09732023af932d8c578c8a7ead49feb80cdb5c629cee6add2e24fcd7999c0309', '75b7020073ec0c8cedf517f1b56d554e2a5cfdf89d204633c30b863c42ed6f5f', '4be1dfb90ea542d5d84c23c0ba29b91db2491a39973839ee646eeec25c71adb4', 'c98d52f719106d13b14f27abde81ce00305cbf62889690b72da3e3ddc0286c02', '056859e4aa430e2eb983e93f08bb85d9afe9aec44f0e73263cf072df70b7c475', '870147c2dad0a0dda2dd0a9f85ef83b3c4de9a304fdff6d9fa9ccc4bde9d70c0', '26e942b0353fee8f5ac0a2c2e26c9b695c50b35c501eeb4bff343b1648b5cebc', '036168e918418eb807bc3efd361a8e66067192564da41e30e076d22be0f87935', 'a491df768673d76ae7dee4c9bf1ea1456e6c537a1f1683368d8bc6869cd89bf0', 'f6a8cfceb19b4cd796512223b8afd103c4aee7052247ebea8b50f743e9aa27b6', 'd135518ad4230c8f57a3510b3ddea8a99e2355363c9419a27340734427050729', 'cbe90e272b6be7696d3b8c171500847d2b0ae497f6911d0f9d5d8481101c4c1f', '249c961ea29438959ea2204728df24964ec80b8cd91c657715c47014f5e5a462', '1920ebb46d0cee2d379ef48c15f8f6abd01e2a183f316da235e0c3b7515feade', '6d1573b42d5f89f89b26b32cbbd32ff41660e0e8c3b3091f1cb278a42651e049', 'ec6878825845c61b3049ad5dd168197c84938e7f6d4fc938670da2528cf86317', '9829b13faebde69c2279c38cd54d524aa31acfdcc1cfba7910b9d69caa42e0dd', '2755ae7cda161df0c24e1fa9f1c3308bc9ef81a599d859668490484290ca72f4', '09d9dcfc1716808b0c62e47a771ff4d39ba71f22c8640776e65624747a995626', '71dfcd074b80de90c4955890bdbe127d12b249ed764c7c4ca23dc81c74fde71d', '3c1afbb156ee2d672ca131c7c966bc6875374a95d927848bafcc5a158edf67bb'] B "in order to use a detnet network to interconnect tsn segments, tsn specific information must be converted to detnet domain specific ones. tsn stream id(s) and stream(s) related parameters/requirements must be converted to a detnet flow-id and flow related parameters/ requirements. note that, as the detnet network is just a portion of the end2end tsn path (i.e., single hop from ethernet perspective), some parameters (e.g., delay) may differ significantly. other parameters (like bandwidth) also may have to be tuned due to the mpls encapsulation used within the detnet network." {79: 1, 130: 1, 54: 1, 52: 1, 98: 1, 6: 1, 8: 1, 64: 1, 99: 1, 24: 1, 90: 2, 51: 2, 62: 4, 85: 4, 68: 3, 35: 2, 110: 2, 91: 4, 114: 2, 97: 2, 31: 2, 13: 2, 67: 2, 38: 3, 26: 2, 124: 2, 127: 2, 96: 2, 30: 3, 61: 4, 55: 2, 27: 3, 15: 2, 129: 2, 115: 2, 84: 2, 76: 5, 87: 2, 131: 4, 102: 2, 113: 4, 36: 2, 72: 3} {4: 1, 24: 1, 59: 1, 111: 1, 136: 1, 156: 1, 206: 1, 215: 1, 220: 1, 221: 1, 235: 1, 241: 1, 242: 1, 314: 1, 329: 1, 334: 1, 354: 1, 366: 1, 376: 1, 1: 8, 9: 4, 10: 2, 15: 2, 25: 4, 26: 4, 27: 2, 39: 4, 43: 2, 49: 5, 50: 4, 58: 4, 64: 2, 69: 3, 81: 5, 82: 3, 86: 2, 96: 3, 97: 2, 100: 6, 108: 2, 109: 3, 110: 3, 114: 2, 115: 3, 116: 2, 118: 5, 119: 4, 120: 2, 121: 3, 122: 3, 123: 2, 124: 3, 128: 3, 129: 3, 130: 4, 132: 3, 145: 3, 147: 3, 151: 3, 152: 3, 154: 2, 161: 2, 162: 2, 165: 2, 168: 3, 169: 2, 172: 2, 180: 3, 184: 4, 187: 4, 188: 3, 191: 2, 194: 3, 202: 4, 203: 5, 207: 2, 217: 2, 218: 7, 222: 4, 224: 2, 227: 4, 229: 2, 234: 4, 243: 3, 244: 3, 245: 3, 248: 3, 250: 3, 258: 10, 262: 3, 263: 4, 264: 2, 267: 3, 270: 2, 272: 2, 273: 4, 287: 2, 289: 2, 291: 4, 299: 4, 300: 2, 304: 2, 309: 2, 315: 2, 320: 3, 323: 3, 327: 3, 328: 2, 330: 9, 335: 2, 341: 4, 342: 5, 347: 4, 348: 4, 350: 6, 351: 4, 352: 2, 353: 2, 358: 3, 365: 2, 371: 6, 372: 4, 384: 4, 385: 3, 386: 2, 387: 2, 392: 2, 393: 3, 396: 5, 397: 6, 398: 5, 402: 2} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 53 "In some case it may be challenging to determine some egress node related information. For example, it may be not trivial to locate the egress point/interface of a TSN Streams with a multicast destination MAC address. Such scenarios may require interaction between control and management plane functions and between DetNet and TSN domains." "Major clean up and simplification as data plane drafts can be referred for MPLS related details . TSN over DetNet MPLS follows the concept of RFC3985 . Description focus on Edge Nodes procedures and functions . Text covers the Edge Nodes components : ( 1 ) TSN functions ( in NSP block ) ; ( 2 ) DetNet Service Proxy ; and ( 3 ) DetNet sub - layers . Approving from teelcon review" 3486514b01b74d57f031bcf660311de328a6e0dc 3486514b01b74d57f031bcf660311de328a6e0dc draft-ietf-detnet-tsn-vpn-over-mpls 2442b9072d522cde54849b40cab26789e4af909f1dd81391cd8c87023515a21c ['e82e49a3c764c0ede490d9e8afe0d0a379ec1e2fb734910d7e42f179709f894c', '1b5276bed81725e3cab5fa8d2491ae7fc344c8638906d8e62ee7c31696edcb52', 'a6a4ee1a9211a2be0e24cf91f9742499a46567acff4c78f62b568b34e38c08de', '44d22f065218a14d5aa04288e7553c8a6d81bb222066c74ea38571bbe922a729', 'c757c3611002031d5ce1ac79d9984d826f392e6628a0657e045c348e52b7eda2', '8a105d9f9ffbf3e747a101e48de19122931cd0cce896dc27f57d16df9dbb75ac', 'a8ff14472a8fa48bacdc11d7089a9d1054c0a786f6152f510b5d4092c22e121f', 'e746630d4b45cf2b654a14e4daaa03ad634e33d92c29c489e3ef3fcd5620c311', '16375944152e6c3e73492437880fe39d7f0123a9292d062e8e9c7d317e4b878f', '42f5214bb177fd7faf01b7943e7f313a615b2490f9109d5cefa8b24101735c32', '5cc97b8f56cdeeb02e7c96183745dc53dd8ec3ec02424107d16eb438c2c9363c', 'a816e4d1392c9c85d398ee2c5116b5de849a9823bc552d322ac8725f7c9b859e', 'c7286f8983508fdd7d94ae798cdc3950cbf65865e905c00a76838a34eb79cf2c', '6924f7b3002e9f0dff9023b70bcc9d484e643c3a2d95b0d5c853c084ad3f68ab', '2d8fce3963de03360a5d98758067925a60474b5430fd8091fc72f3c50a9d38e5', '77f9aaec42bbb94079fae33b8c564cd7f64721106f615e11f22673310efaf01b', '09f8dc962fd9202d148a0b378c9a078ea850056b4b5c360c0914d4a1de6af454', '4826376633600232b766cb8a62d4054b0f5ea45d74878bcf57356e567088300c', '82b410c949db1d81b3f197adbaaba7b82b6e497600cd9883150af2bb815caa19', '0eb73f51f3b491bd6d969a05acf2b527e6e2f09a460cb88266513ab952bd3fc6', '1076eab6753435c114e8a720c951b03da6d4e1bbbf1290f8d58ad7f97a0b8c64', '4ccf918f8b8ae99a769d89e0868a12e4af1536487652436b6c188bc99e14fdb6', '2a5cef1e9c76b52b9b56c6c021a857b0fa757897b6e3c96cc8170d5b73ba8dd8', '07267e696bfbb5af98da5a8efe2b8cf604bc9ab1ce95e4766f017473bfcd0de1', '82f56d4694c2ec964de0a4413954f87ca621628c63d7425944baeff9aa4b6dad', '01e1da53fe2751e7196114efc63dd70d9babc69b4b73c03d4b7528dcc10c05d3', 'fb8f3ca7fafc9c173404ce7f909038443a6078a0c278cb024639410e33f49f88', '44e497e2df0461bad9215c57918855022435eb6e28266916161de3f7902bb352', '84f5bc0e0be5d04b515e8e49efb393e4aec7189222b92c0555cc1be542e74549', '3195c90c03cf6a438b5684cc93128c53f794660a661e2aa85d043ca5ac7060b9', 'b5bacf05f766e143f6de9484b0b5a2d9655d62854368373bd77974b94cb722e6', '2442b9072d522cde54849b40cab26789e4af909f1dd81391cd8c87023515a21c', 'b03d79d1a547b36a28c6cba78f57b8244a4855f6b31003de3e617a5b5eddc070', 'e386562e3156c91934ceb045df46d7e847bb9afcad2794bda59be854f988befc', 'cc980749457292da3a6a4a3ce669ad487409ce72e20857e80c75741c83af7f0a', '75db9ae91b710fcf1df3553b8f9653b12d014f74ba1ee8f931870d2433e163f1', '0e313215df9694bc26777ba4ac347cb8ef73f8475d2bfed664aab722833589ae', '1094721b24c22ff67539ffeabab887f87e538bdd9ebe50b0b369de138d326802', 'fb2b9389e1455c6d64ae19158396d767d88969013b14075bcfdcc764f610108c', 'ae3bdd3a81d96e4aaa02f7d597a2684146f3af75b743bde8e31c3cf5883707db', '1b8137b4c60774716e4a492efec48060d48abd7308563d8cc76edf32d98bd759', '09732023af932d8c578c8a7ead49feb80cdb5c629cee6add2e24fcd7999c0309', '75b7020073ec0c8cedf517f1b56d554e2a5cfdf89d204633c30b863c42ed6f5f', '4be1dfb90ea542d5d84c23c0ba29b91db2491a39973839ee646eeec25c71adb4', 'c98d52f719106d13b14f27abde81ce00305cbf62889690b72da3e3ddc0286c02', '056859e4aa430e2eb983e93f08bb85d9afe9aec44f0e73263cf072df70b7c475', '870147c2dad0a0dda2dd0a9f85ef83b3c4de9a304fdff6d9fa9ccc4bde9d70c0', '26e942b0353fee8f5ac0a2c2e26c9b695c50b35c501eeb4bff343b1648b5cebc', '036168e918418eb807bc3efd361a8e66067192564da41e30e076d22be0f87935', 'a491df768673d76ae7dee4c9bf1ea1456e6c537a1f1683368d8bc6869cd89bf0', 'f6a8cfceb19b4cd796512223b8afd103c4aee7052247ebea8b50f743e9aa27b6', 'd135518ad4230c8f57a3510b3ddea8a99e2355363c9419a27340734427050729', 'cbe90e272b6be7696d3b8c171500847d2b0ae497f6911d0f9d5d8481101c4c1f', '249c961ea29438959ea2204728df24964ec80b8cd91c657715c47014f5e5a462', '1920ebb46d0cee2d379ef48c15f8f6abd01e2a183f316da235e0c3b7515feade', '6d1573b42d5f89f89b26b32cbbd32ff41660e0e8c3b3091f1cb278a42651e049', 'ec6878825845c61b3049ad5dd168197c84938e7f6d4fc938670da2528cf86317', '9829b13faebde69c2279c38cd54d524aa31acfdcc1cfba7910b9d69caa42e0dd', '2755ae7cda161df0c24e1fa9f1c3308bc9ef81a599d859668490484290ca72f4', '09d9dcfc1716808b0c62e47a771ff4d39ba71f22c8640776e65624747a995626', '71dfcd074b80de90c4955890bdbe127d12b249ed764c7c4ca23dc81c74fde71d', '3c1afbb156ee2d672ca131c7c966bc6875374a95d927848bafcc5a158edf67bb'] B "in some case it may be challenging to determine some egress node related information. for example, it may be not trivial to locate the egress point/interface of a tsn streams with a multicast destination mac address. such scenarios may require interaction between control and management plane functions and between detnet and tsn domains." {79: 1, 130: 1, 54: 1, 52: 1, 98: 1, 6: 1, 8: 1, 64: 1, 99: 1, 24: 1, 90: 2, 51: 2, 62: 4, 85: 4, 68: 3, 35: 2, 110: 2, 91: 4, 114: 2, 97: 2, 31: 2, 13: 2, 67: 2, 38: 3, 26: 2, 124: 2, 127: 2, 96: 2, 30: 3, 61: 4, 55: 2, 27: 3, 15: 2, 129: 2, 115: 2, 84: 2, 76: 5, 87: 2, 131: 4, 102: 2, 113: 4, 36: 2, 72: 3} {4: 1, 24: 1, 59: 1, 111: 1, 136: 1, 156: 1, 206: 1, 215: 1, 220: 1, 221: 1, 235: 1, 241: 1, 242: 1, 314: 1, 329: 1, 334: 1, 354: 1, 366: 1, 376: 1, 1: 8, 9: 4, 10: 2, 15: 2, 25: 4, 26: 4, 27: 2, 39: 4, 43: 2, 49: 5, 50: 4, 58: 4, 64: 2, 69: 3, 81: 5, 82: 3, 86: 2, 96: 3, 97: 2, 100: 6, 108: 2, 109: 3, 110: 3, 114: 2, 115: 3, 116: 2, 118: 5, 119: 4, 120: 2, 121: 3, 122: 3, 123: 2, 124: 3, 128: 3, 129: 3, 130: 4, 132: 3, 145: 3, 147: 3, 151: 3, 152: 3, 154: 2, 161: 2, 162: 2, 165: 2, 168: 3, 169: 2, 172: 2, 180: 3, 184: 4, 187: 4, 188: 3, 191: 2, 194: 3, 202: 4, 203: 5, 207: 2, 217: 2, 218: 7, 222: 4, 224: 2, 227: 4, 229: 2, 234: 4, 243: 3, 244: 3, 245: 3, 248: 3, 250: 3, 258: 10, 262: 3, 263: 4, 264: 2, 267: 3, 270: 2, 272: 2, 273: 4, 287: 2, 289: 2, 291: 4, 299: 4, 300: 2, 304: 2, 309: 2, 315: 2, 320: 3, 323: 3, 327: 3, 328: 2, 330: 9, 335: 2, 341: 4, 342: 5, 347: 4, 348: 4, 350: 6, 351: 4, 352: 2, 353: 2, 358: 3, 365: 2, 371: 6, 372: 4, 384: 4, 385: 3, 386: 2, 387: 2, 392: 2, 393: 3, 396: 5, 397: 6, 398: 5, 402: 2} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 53 "Mapping between DetNet flow identifiers and TSN Stream identifiers, if not provided explicitly, can be done by the service proxy function of an MPLS (DetNet) Edge node locally based on information provided for configuration of the TSN Stream identification functions (e.g., Mask-and-Match Stream identification)." "Major clean up and simplification as data plane drafts can be referred for MPLS related details . TSN over DetNet MPLS follows the concept of RFC3985 . Description focus on Edge Nodes procedures and functions . Text covers the Edge Nodes components : ( 1 ) TSN functions ( in NSP block ) ; ( 2 ) DetNet Service Proxy ; and ( 3 ) DetNet sub - layers . Approving from teelcon review" 3486514b01b74d57f031bcf660311de328a6e0dc 3486514b01b74d57f031bcf660311de328a6e0dc draft-ietf-detnet-tsn-vpn-over-mpls 01e1da53fe2751e7196114efc63dd70d9babc69b4b73c03d4b7528dcc10c05d3 ['e82e49a3c764c0ede490d9e8afe0d0a379ec1e2fb734910d7e42f179709f894c', '1b5276bed81725e3cab5fa8d2491ae7fc344c8638906d8e62ee7c31696edcb52', 'a6a4ee1a9211a2be0e24cf91f9742499a46567acff4c78f62b568b34e38c08de', '44d22f065218a14d5aa04288e7553c8a6d81bb222066c74ea38571bbe922a729', 'c757c3611002031d5ce1ac79d9984d826f392e6628a0657e045c348e52b7eda2', '8a105d9f9ffbf3e747a101e48de19122931cd0cce896dc27f57d16df9dbb75ac', 'a8ff14472a8fa48bacdc11d7089a9d1054c0a786f6152f510b5d4092c22e121f', 'e746630d4b45cf2b654a14e4daaa03ad634e33d92c29c489e3ef3fcd5620c311', '16375944152e6c3e73492437880fe39d7f0123a9292d062e8e9c7d317e4b878f', '42f5214bb177fd7faf01b7943e7f313a615b2490f9109d5cefa8b24101735c32', '5cc97b8f56cdeeb02e7c96183745dc53dd8ec3ec02424107d16eb438c2c9363c', 'a816e4d1392c9c85d398ee2c5116b5de849a9823bc552d322ac8725f7c9b859e', 'c7286f8983508fdd7d94ae798cdc3950cbf65865e905c00a76838a34eb79cf2c', '6924f7b3002e9f0dff9023b70bcc9d484e643c3a2d95b0d5c853c084ad3f68ab', '2d8fce3963de03360a5d98758067925a60474b5430fd8091fc72f3c50a9d38e5', '77f9aaec42bbb94079fae33b8c564cd7f64721106f615e11f22673310efaf01b', '09f8dc962fd9202d148a0b378c9a078ea850056b4b5c360c0914d4a1de6af454', '4826376633600232b766cb8a62d4054b0f5ea45d74878bcf57356e567088300c', '82b410c949db1d81b3f197adbaaba7b82b6e497600cd9883150af2bb815caa19', '0eb73f51f3b491bd6d969a05acf2b527e6e2f09a460cb88266513ab952bd3fc6', '1076eab6753435c114e8a720c951b03da6d4e1bbbf1290f8d58ad7f97a0b8c64', '4ccf918f8b8ae99a769d89e0868a12e4af1536487652436b6c188bc99e14fdb6', '2a5cef1e9c76b52b9b56c6c021a857b0fa757897b6e3c96cc8170d5b73ba8dd8', '07267e696bfbb5af98da5a8efe2b8cf604bc9ab1ce95e4766f017473bfcd0de1', '82f56d4694c2ec964de0a4413954f87ca621628c63d7425944baeff9aa4b6dad', '01e1da53fe2751e7196114efc63dd70d9babc69b4b73c03d4b7528dcc10c05d3', 'fb8f3ca7fafc9c173404ce7f909038443a6078a0c278cb024639410e33f49f88', '44e497e2df0461bad9215c57918855022435eb6e28266916161de3f7902bb352', '84f5bc0e0be5d04b515e8e49efb393e4aec7189222b92c0555cc1be542e74549', '3195c90c03cf6a438b5684cc93128c53f794660a661e2aa85d043ca5ac7060b9', 'b5bacf05f766e143f6de9484b0b5a2d9655d62854368373bd77974b94cb722e6', '2442b9072d522cde54849b40cab26789e4af909f1dd81391cd8c87023515a21c', 'b03d79d1a547b36a28c6cba78f57b8244a4855f6b31003de3e617a5b5eddc070', 'e386562e3156c91934ceb045df46d7e847bb9afcad2794bda59be854f988befc', 'cc980749457292da3a6a4a3ce669ad487409ce72e20857e80c75741c83af7f0a', '75db9ae91b710fcf1df3553b8f9653b12d014f74ba1ee8f931870d2433e163f1', '0e313215df9694bc26777ba4ac347cb8ef73f8475d2bfed664aab722833589ae', '1094721b24c22ff67539ffeabab887f87e538bdd9ebe50b0b369de138d326802', 'fb2b9389e1455c6d64ae19158396d767d88969013b14075bcfdcc764f610108c', 'ae3bdd3a81d96e4aaa02f7d597a2684146f3af75b743bde8e31c3cf5883707db', '1b8137b4c60774716e4a492efec48060d48abd7308563d8cc76edf32d98bd759', '09732023af932d8c578c8a7ead49feb80cdb5c629cee6add2e24fcd7999c0309', '75b7020073ec0c8cedf517f1b56d554e2a5cfdf89d204633c30b863c42ed6f5f', '4be1dfb90ea542d5d84c23c0ba29b91db2491a39973839ee646eeec25c71adb4', 'c98d52f719106d13b14f27abde81ce00305cbf62889690b72da3e3ddc0286c02', '056859e4aa430e2eb983e93f08bb85d9afe9aec44f0e73263cf072df70b7c475', '870147c2dad0a0dda2dd0a9f85ef83b3c4de9a304fdff6d9fa9ccc4bde9d70c0', '26e942b0353fee8f5ac0a2c2e26c9b695c50b35c501eeb4bff343b1648b5cebc', '036168e918418eb807bc3efd361a8e66067192564da41e30e076d22be0f87935', 'a491df768673d76ae7dee4c9bf1ea1456e6c537a1f1683368d8bc6869cd89bf0', 'f6a8cfceb19b4cd796512223b8afd103c4aee7052247ebea8b50f743e9aa27b6', 'd135518ad4230c8f57a3510b3ddea8a99e2355363c9419a27340734427050729', 'cbe90e272b6be7696d3b8c171500847d2b0ae497f6911d0f9d5d8481101c4c1f', '249c961ea29438959ea2204728df24964ec80b8cd91c657715c47014f5e5a462', '1920ebb46d0cee2d379ef48c15f8f6abd01e2a183f316da235e0c3b7515feade', '6d1573b42d5f89f89b26b32cbbd32ff41660e0e8c3b3091f1cb278a42651e049', 'ec6878825845c61b3049ad5dd168197c84938e7f6d4fc938670da2528cf86317', '9829b13faebde69c2279c38cd54d524aa31acfdcc1cfba7910b9d69caa42e0dd', '2755ae7cda161df0c24e1fa9f1c3308bc9ef81a599d859668490484290ca72f4', '09d9dcfc1716808b0c62e47a771ff4d39ba71f22c8640776e65624747a995626', '71dfcd074b80de90c4955890bdbe127d12b249ed764c7c4ca23dc81c74fde71d', '3c1afbb156ee2d672ca131c7c966bc6875374a95d927848bafcc5a158edf67bb'] B "mapping between detnet flow identifiers and tsn stream identifiers, if not provided explicitly, can be done by the service proxy function of an mpls (detnet) edge node locally based on information provided for configuration of the tsn stream identification functions (e.g., mask-and-match stream identification)." {79: 1, 130: 1, 54: 1, 52: 1, 98: 1, 6: 1, 8: 1, 64: 1, 99: 1, 24: 1, 90: 2, 51: 2, 62: 4, 85: 4, 68: 3, 35: 2, 110: 2, 91: 4, 114: 2, 97: 2, 31: 2, 13: 2, 67: 2, 38: 3, 26: 2, 124: 2, 127: 2, 96: 2, 30: 3, 61: 4, 55: 2, 27: 3, 15: 2, 129: 2, 115: 2, 84: 2, 76: 5, 87: 2, 131: 4, 102: 2, 113: 4, 36: 2, 72: 3} {4: 1, 24: 1, 59: 1, 111: 1, 136: 1, 156: 1, 206: 1, 215: 1, 220: 1, 221: 1, 235: 1, 241: 1, 242: 1, 314: 1, 329: 1, 334: 1, 354: 1, 366: 1, 376: 1, 1: 8, 9: 4, 10: 2, 15: 2, 25: 4, 26: 4, 27: 2, 39: 4, 43: 2, 49: 5, 50: 4, 58: 4, 64: 2, 69: 3, 81: 5, 82: 3, 86: 2, 96: 3, 97: 2, 100: 6, 108: 2, 109: 3, 110: 3, 114: 2, 115: 3, 116: 2, 118: 5, 119: 4, 120: 2, 121: 3, 122: 3, 123: 2, 124: 3, 128: 3, 129: 3, 130: 4, 132: 3, 145: 3, 147: 3, 151: 3, 152: 3, 154: 2, 161: 2, 162: 2, 165: 2, 168: 3, 169: 2, 172: 2, 180: 3, 184: 4, 187: 4, 188: 3, 191: 2, 194: 3, 202: 4, 203: 5, 207: 2, 217: 2, 218: 7, 222: 4, 224: 2, 227: 4, 229: 2, 234: 4, 243: 3, 244: 3, 245: 3, 248: 3, 250: 3, 258: 10, 262: 3, 263: 4, 264: 2, 267: 3, 270: 2, 272: 2, 273: 4, 287: 2, 289: 2, 291: 4, 299: 4, 300: 2, 304: 2, 309: 2, 315: 2, 320: 3, 323: 3, 327: 3, 328: 2, 330: 9, 335: 2, 341: 4, 342: 5, 347: 4, 348: 4, 350: 6, 351: 4, 352: 2, 353: 2, 358: 3, 365: 2, 371: 6, 372: 4, 384: 4, 385: 3, 386: 2, 387: 2, 392: 2, 393: 3, 396: 5, 397: 6, 398: 5, 402: 2} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 53 "Triggering the setup/modification of a DetNet flow in the DetNet network is an example where management and/or control plane interactions are required between the DetNet and the TSN network." "Major clean up and simplification as data plane drafts can be referred for MPLS related details . TSN over DetNet MPLS follows the concept of RFC3985 . Description focus on Edge Nodes procedures and functions . Text covers the Edge Nodes components : ( 1 ) TSN functions ( in NSP block ) ; ( 2 ) DetNet Service Proxy ; and ( 3 ) DetNet sub - layers . Approving from teelcon review" 3486514b01b74d57f031bcf660311de328a6e0dc 3486514b01b74d57f031bcf660311de328a6e0dc draft-ietf-detnet-tsn-vpn-over-mpls 44d22f065218a14d5aa04288e7553c8a6d81bb222066c74ea38571bbe922a729 ['e82e49a3c764c0ede490d9e8afe0d0a379ec1e2fb734910d7e42f179709f894c', '1b5276bed81725e3cab5fa8d2491ae7fc344c8638906d8e62ee7c31696edcb52', 'a6a4ee1a9211a2be0e24cf91f9742499a46567acff4c78f62b568b34e38c08de', '44d22f065218a14d5aa04288e7553c8a6d81bb222066c74ea38571bbe922a729', 'c757c3611002031d5ce1ac79d9984d826f392e6628a0657e045c348e52b7eda2', '8a105d9f9ffbf3e747a101e48de19122931cd0cce896dc27f57d16df9dbb75ac', 'a8ff14472a8fa48bacdc11d7089a9d1054c0a786f6152f510b5d4092c22e121f', 'e746630d4b45cf2b654a14e4daaa03ad634e33d92c29c489e3ef3fcd5620c311', '16375944152e6c3e73492437880fe39d7f0123a9292d062e8e9c7d317e4b878f', '42f5214bb177fd7faf01b7943e7f313a615b2490f9109d5cefa8b24101735c32', '5cc97b8f56cdeeb02e7c96183745dc53dd8ec3ec02424107d16eb438c2c9363c', 'a816e4d1392c9c85d398ee2c5116b5de849a9823bc552d322ac8725f7c9b859e', 'c7286f8983508fdd7d94ae798cdc3950cbf65865e905c00a76838a34eb79cf2c', '6924f7b3002e9f0dff9023b70bcc9d484e643c3a2d95b0d5c853c084ad3f68ab', '2d8fce3963de03360a5d98758067925a60474b5430fd8091fc72f3c50a9d38e5', '77f9aaec42bbb94079fae33b8c564cd7f64721106f615e11f22673310efaf01b', '09f8dc962fd9202d148a0b378c9a078ea850056b4b5c360c0914d4a1de6af454', '4826376633600232b766cb8a62d4054b0f5ea45d74878bcf57356e567088300c', '82b410c949db1d81b3f197adbaaba7b82b6e497600cd9883150af2bb815caa19', '0eb73f51f3b491bd6d969a05acf2b527e6e2f09a460cb88266513ab952bd3fc6', '1076eab6753435c114e8a720c951b03da6d4e1bbbf1290f8d58ad7f97a0b8c64', '4ccf918f8b8ae99a769d89e0868a12e4af1536487652436b6c188bc99e14fdb6', '2a5cef1e9c76b52b9b56c6c021a857b0fa757897b6e3c96cc8170d5b73ba8dd8', '07267e696bfbb5af98da5a8efe2b8cf604bc9ab1ce95e4766f017473bfcd0de1', '82f56d4694c2ec964de0a4413954f87ca621628c63d7425944baeff9aa4b6dad', '01e1da53fe2751e7196114efc63dd70d9babc69b4b73c03d4b7528dcc10c05d3', 'fb8f3ca7fafc9c173404ce7f909038443a6078a0c278cb024639410e33f49f88', '44e497e2df0461bad9215c57918855022435eb6e28266916161de3f7902bb352', '84f5bc0e0be5d04b515e8e49efb393e4aec7189222b92c0555cc1be542e74549', '3195c90c03cf6a438b5684cc93128c53f794660a661e2aa85d043ca5ac7060b9', 'b5bacf05f766e143f6de9484b0b5a2d9655d62854368373bd77974b94cb722e6', '2442b9072d522cde54849b40cab26789e4af909f1dd81391cd8c87023515a21c', 'b03d79d1a547b36a28c6cba78f57b8244a4855f6b31003de3e617a5b5eddc070', 'e386562e3156c91934ceb045df46d7e847bb9afcad2794bda59be854f988befc', 'cc980749457292da3a6a4a3ce669ad487409ce72e20857e80c75741c83af7f0a', '75db9ae91b710fcf1df3553b8f9653b12d014f74ba1ee8f931870d2433e163f1', '0e313215df9694bc26777ba4ac347cb8ef73f8475d2bfed664aab722833589ae', '1094721b24c22ff67539ffeabab887f87e538bdd9ebe50b0b369de138d326802', 'fb2b9389e1455c6d64ae19158396d767d88969013b14075bcfdcc764f610108c', 'ae3bdd3a81d96e4aaa02f7d597a2684146f3af75b743bde8e31c3cf5883707db', '1b8137b4c60774716e4a492efec48060d48abd7308563d8cc76edf32d98bd759', '09732023af932d8c578c8a7ead49feb80cdb5c629cee6add2e24fcd7999c0309', '75b7020073ec0c8cedf517f1b56d554e2a5cfdf89d204633c30b863c42ed6f5f', '4be1dfb90ea542d5d84c23c0ba29b91db2491a39973839ee646eeec25c71adb4', 'c98d52f719106d13b14f27abde81ce00305cbf62889690b72da3e3ddc0286c02', '056859e4aa430e2eb983e93f08bb85d9afe9aec44f0e73263cf072df70b7c475', '870147c2dad0a0dda2dd0a9f85ef83b3c4de9a304fdff6d9fa9ccc4bde9d70c0', '26e942b0353fee8f5ac0a2c2e26c9b695c50b35c501eeb4bff343b1648b5cebc', '036168e918418eb807bc3efd361a8e66067192564da41e30e076d22be0f87935', 'a491df768673d76ae7dee4c9bf1ea1456e6c537a1f1683368d8bc6869cd89bf0', 'f6a8cfceb19b4cd796512223b8afd103c4aee7052247ebea8b50f743e9aa27b6', 'd135518ad4230c8f57a3510b3ddea8a99e2355363c9419a27340734427050729', 'cbe90e272b6be7696d3b8c171500847d2b0ae497f6911d0f9d5d8481101c4c1f', '249c961ea29438959ea2204728df24964ec80b8cd91c657715c47014f5e5a462', '1920ebb46d0cee2d379ef48c15f8f6abd01e2a183f316da235e0c3b7515feade', '6d1573b42d5f89f89b26b32cbbd32ff41660e0e8c3b3091f1cb278a42651e049', 'ec6878825845c61b3049ad5dd168197c84938e7f6d4fc938670da2528cf86317', '9829b13faebde69c2279c38cd54d524aa31acfdcc1cfba7910b9d69caa42e0dd', '2755ae7cda161df0c24e1fa9f1c3308bc9ef81a599d859668490484290ca72f4', '09d9dcfc1716808b0c62e47a771ff4d39ba71f22c8640776e65624747a995626', '71dfcd074b80de90c4955890bdbe127d12b249ed764c7c4ca23dc81c74fde71d', '3c1afbb156ee2d672ca131c7c966bc6875374a95d927848bafcc5a158edf67bb'] B "triggering the setup/modification of a detnet flow in the detnet network is an example where management and/or control plane interactions are required between the detnet and the tsn network." {79: 1, 130: 1, 54: 1, 52: 1, 98: 1, 6: 1, 8: 1, 64: 1, 99: 1, 24: 1, 90: 2, 51: 2, 62: 4, 85: 4, 68: 3, 35: 2, 110: 2, 91: 4, 114: 2, 97: 2, 31: 2, 13: 2, 67: 2, 38: 3, 26: 2, 124: 2, 127: 2, 96: 2, 30: 3, 61: 4, 55: 2, 27: 3, 15: 2, 129: 2, 115: 2, 84: 2, 76: 5, 87: 2, 131: 4, 102: 2, 113: 4, 36: 2, 72: 3} {4: 1, 24: 1, 59: 1, 111: 1, 136: 1, 156: 1, 206: 1, 215: 1, 220: 1, 221: 1, 235: 1, 241: 1, 242: 1, 314: 1, 329: 1, 334: 1, 354: 1, 366: 1, 376: 1, 1: 8, 9: 4, 10: 2, 15: 2, 25: 4, 26: 4, 27: 2, 39: 4, 43: 2, 49: 5, 50: 4, 58: 4, 64: 2, 69: 3, 81: 5, 82: 3, 86: 2, 96: 3, 97: 2, 100: 6, 108: 2, 109: 3, 110: 3, 114: 2, 115: 3, 116: 2, 118: 5, 119: 4, 120: 2, 121: 3, 122: 3, 123: 2, 124: 3, 128: 3, 129: 3, 130: 4, 132: 3, 145: 3, 147: 3, 151: 3, 152: 3, 154: 2, 161: 2, 162: 2, 165: 2, 168: 3, 169: 2, 172: 2, 180: 3, 184: 4, 187: 4, 188: 3, 191: 2, 194: 3, 202: 4, 203: 5, 207: 2, 217: 2, 218: 7, 222: 4, 224: 2, 227: 4, 229: 2, 234: 4, 243: 3, 244: 3, 245: 3, 248: 3, 250: 3, 258: 10, 262: 3, 263: 4, 264: 2, 267: 3, 270: 2, 272: 2, 273: 4, 287: 2, 289: 2, 291: 4, 299: 4, 300: 2, 304: 2, 309: 2, 315: 2, 320: 3, 323: 3, 327: 3, 328: 2, 330: 9, 335: 2, 341: 4, 342: 5, 347: 4, 348: 4, 350: 6, 351: 4, 352: 2, 353: 2, 358: 3, 365: 2, 371: 6, 372: 4, 384: 4, 385: 3, 386: 2, 387: 2, 392: 2, 393: 3, 396: 5, 397: 6, 398: 5, 402: 2} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 53 "Configuration of TSN specific functions (e.g., FRER) inside the TSN network is a TSN domain specific decision and may not be visible in the DetNet domain. Service protection interworking scenarios are left for further study." "Major clean up and simplification as data plane drafts can be referred for MPLS related details . TSN over DetNet MPLS follows the concept of RFC3985 . Description focus on Edge Nodes procedures and functions . Text covers the Edge Nodes components : ( 1 ) TSN functions ( in NSP block ) ; ( 2 ) DetNet Service Proxy ; and ( 3 ) DetNet sub - layers . Approving from teelcon review" 3486514b01b74d57f031bcf660311de328a6e0dc 3486514b01b74d57f031bcf660311de328a6e0dc draft-ietf-detnet-tsn-vpn-over-mpls 3c1afbb156ee2d672ca131c7c966bc6875374a95d927848bafcc5a158edf67bb ['e82e49a3c764c0ede490d9e8afe0d0a379ec1e2fb734910d7e42f179709f894c', '1b5276bed81725e3cab5fa8d2491ae7fc344c8638906d8e62ee7c31696edcb52', 'a6a4ee1a9211a2be0e24cf91f9742499a46567acff4c78f62b568b34e38c08de', '44d22f065218a14d5aa04288e7553c8a6d81bb222066c74ea38571bbe922a729', 'c757c3611002031d5ce1ac79d9984d826f392e6628a0657e045c348e52b7eda2', '8a105d9f9ffbf3e747a101e48de19122931cd0cce896dc27f57d16df9dbb75ac', 'a8ff14472a8fa48bacdc11d7089a9d1054c0a786f6152f510b5d4092c22e121f', 'e746630d4b45cf2b654a14e4daaa03ad634e33d92c29c489e3ef3fcd5620c311', '16375944152e6c3e73492437880fe39d7f0123a9292d062e8e9c7d317e4b878f', '42f5214bb177fd7faf01b7943e7f313a615b2490f9109d5cefa8b24101735c32', '5cc97b8f56cdeeb02e7c96183745dc53dd8ec3ec02424107d16eb438c2c9363c', 'a816e4d1392c9c85d398ee2c5116b5de849a9823bc552d322ac8725f7c9b859e', 'c7286f8983508fdd7d94ae798cdc3950cbf65865e905c00a76838a34eb79cf2c', '6924f7b3002e9f0dff9023b70bcc9d484e643c3a2d95b0d5c853c084ad3f68ab', '2d8fce3963de03360a5d98758067925a60474b5430fd8091fc72f3c50a9d38e5', '77f9aaec42bbb94079fae33b8c564cd7f64721106f615e11f22673310efaf01b', '09f8dc962fd9202d148a0b378c9a078ea850056b4b5c360c0914d4a1de6af454', '4826376633600232b766cb8a62d4054b0f5ea45d74878bcf57356e567088300c', '82b410c949db1d81b3f197adbaaba7b82b6e497600cd9883150af2bb815caa19', '0eb73f51f3b491bd6d969a05acf2b527e6e2f09a460cb88266513ab952bd3fc6', '1076eab6753435c114e8a720c951b03da6d4e1bbbf1290f8d58ad7f97a0b8c64', '4ccf918f8b8ae99a769d89e0868a12e4af1536487652436b6c188bc99e14fdb6', '2a5cef1e9c76b52b9b56c6c021a857b0fa757897b6e3c96cc8170d5b73ba8dd8', '07267e696bfbb5af98da5a8efe2b8cf604bc9ab1ce95e4766f017473bfcd0de1', '82f56d4694c2ec964de0a4413954f87ca621628c63d7425944baeff9aa4b6dad', '01e1da53fe2751e7196114efc63dd70d9babc69b4b73c03d4b7528dcc10c05d3', 'fb8f3ca7fafc9c173404ce7f909038443a6078a0c278cb024639410e33f49f88', '44e497e2df0461bad9215c57918855022435eb6e28266916161de3f7902bb352', '84f5bc0e0be5d04b515e8e49efb393e4aec7189222b92c0555cc1be542e74549', '3195c90c03cf6a438b5684cc93128c53f794660a661e2aa85d043ca5ac7060b9', 'b5bacf05f766e143f6de9484b0b5a2d9655d62854368373bd77974b94cb722e6', '2442b9072d522cde54849b40cab26789e4af909f1dd81391cd8c87023515a21c', 'b03d79d1a547b36a28c6cba78f57b8244a4855f6b31003de3e617a5b5eddc070', 'e386562e3156c91934ceb045df46d7e847bb9afcad2794bda59be854f988befc', 'cc980749457292da3a6a4a3ce669ad487409ce72e20857e80c75741c83af7f0a', '75db9ae91b710fcf1df3553b8f9653b12d014f74ba1ee8f931870d2433e163f1', '0e313215df9694bc26777ba4ac347cb8ef73f8475d2bfed664aab722833589ae', '1094721b24c22ff67539ffeabab887f87e538bdd9ebe50b0b369de138d326802', 'fb2b9389e1455c6d64ae19158396d767d88969013b14075bcfdcc764f610108c', 'ae3bdd3a81d96e4aaa02f7d597a2684146f3af75b743bde8e31c3cf5883707db', '1b8137b4c60774716e4a492efec48060d48abd7308563d8cc76edf32d98bd759', '09732023af932d8c578c8a7ead49feb80cdb5c629cee6add2e24fcd7999c0309', '75b7020073ec0c8cedf517f1b56d554e2a5cfdf89d204633c30b863c42ed6f5f', '4be1dfb90ea542d5d84c23c0ba29b91db2491a39973839ee646eeec25c71adb4', 'c98d52f719106d13b14f27abde81ce00305cbf62889690b72da3e3ddc0286c02', '056859e4aa430e2eb983e93f08bb85d9afe9aec44f0e73263cf072df70b7c475', '870147c2dad0a0dda2dd0a9f85ef83b3c4de9a304fdff6d9fa9ccc4bde9d70c0', '26e942b0353fee8f5ac0a2c2e26c9b695c50b35c501eeb4bff343b1648b5cebc', '036168e918418eb807bc3efd361a8e66067192564da41e30e076d22be0f87935', 'a491df768673d76ae7dee4c9bf1ea1456e6c537a1f1683368d8bc6869cd89bf0', 'f6a8cfceb19b4cd796512223b8afd103c4aee7052247ebea8b50f743e9aa27b6', 'd135518ad4230c8f57a3510b3ddea8a99e2355363c9419a27340734427050729', 'cbe90e272b6be7696d3b8c171500847d2b0ae497f6911d0f9d5d8481101c4c1f', '249c961ea29438959ea2204728df24964ec80b8cd91c657715c47014f5e5a462', '1920ebb46d0cee2d379ef48c15f8f6abd01e2a183f316da235e0c3b7515feade', '6d1573b42d5f89f89b26b32cbbd32ff41660e0e8c3b3091f1cb278a42651e049', 'ec6878825845c61b3049ad5dd168197c84938e7f6d4fc938670da2528cf86317', '9829b13faebde69c2279c38cd54d524aa31acfdcc1cfba7910b9d69caa42e0dd', '2755ae7cda161df0c24e1fa9f1c3308bc9ef81a599d859668490484290ca72f4', '09d9dcfc1716808b0c62e47a771ff4d39ba71f22c8640776e65624747a995626', '71dfcd074b80de90c4955890bdbe127d12b249ed764c7c4ca23dc81c74fde71d', '3c1afbb156ee2d672ca131c7c966bc6875374a95d927848bafcc5a158edf67bb'] B "configuration of tsn specific functions (e.g., frer) inside the tsn network is a tsn domain specific decision and may not be visible in the detnet domain. service protection interworking scenarios are left for further study." {79: 1, 130: 1, 54: 1, 52: 1, 98: 1, 6: 1, 8: 1, 64: 1, 99: 1, 24: 1, 90: 2, 51: 2, 62: 4, 85: 4, 68: 3, 35: 2, 110: 2, 91: 4, 114: 2, 97: 2, 31: 2, 13: 2, 67: 2, 38: 3, 26: 2, 124: 2, 127: 2, 96: 2, 30: 3, 61: 4, 55: 2, 27: 3, 15: 2, 129: 2, 115: 2, 84: 2, 76: 5, 87: 2, 131: 4, 102: 2, 113: 4, 36: 2, 72: 3} {4: 1, 24: 1, 59: 1, 111: 1, 136: 1, 156: 1, 206: 1, 215: 1, 220: 1, 221: 1, 235: 1, 241: 1, 242: 1, 314: 1, 329: 1, 334: 1, 354: 1, 366: 1, 376: 1, 1: 8, 9: 4, 10: 2, 15: 2, 25: 4, 26: 4, 27: 2, 39: 4, 43: 2, 49: 5, 50: 4, 58: 4, 64: 2, 69: 3, 81: 5, 82: 3, 86: 2, 96: 3, 97: 2, 100: 6, 108: 2, 109: 3, 110: 3, 114: 2, 115: 3, 116: 2, 118: 5, 119: 4, 120: 2, 121: 3, 122: 3, 123: 2, 124: 3, 128: 3, 129: 3, 130: 4, 132: 3, 145: 3, 147: 3, 151: 3, 152: 3, 154: 2, 161: 2, 162: 2, 165: 2, 168: 3, 169: 2, 172: 2, 180: 3, 184: 4, 187: 4, 188: 3, 191: 2, 194: 3, 202: 4, 203: 5, 207: 2, 217: 2, 218: 7, 222: 4, 224: 2, 227: 4, 229: 2, 234: 4, 243: 3, 244: 3, 245: 3, 248: 3, 250: 3, 258: 10, 262: 3, 263: 4, 264: 2, 267: 3, 270: 2, 272: 2, 273: 4, 287: 2, 289: 2, 291: 4, 299: 4, 300: 2, 304: 2, 309: 2, 315: 2, 320: 3, 323: 3, 327: 3, 328: 2, 330: 9, 335: 2, 341: 4, 342: 5, 347: 4, 348: 4, 350: 6, 351: 4, 352: 2, 353: 2, 358: 3, 365: 2, 371: 6, 372: 4, 384: 4, 385: 3, 386: 2, 387: 2, 392: 2, 393: 3, 396: 5, 397: 6, 398: 5, 402: 2} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 53 "The security considerations of DetNet in general are discussed in I- D.ietf-detnet-architecture and I-D.ietf-detnet-security. DetNet MPLS data plane specific considerations are summarized in I-D.ietf-detnet- mpls. Encryption may provided within the TSN network using MACSec IEEE802.1AE-2018." "Major clean up and simplification as data plane drafts can be referred for MPLS related details . TSN over DetNet MPLS follows the concept of RFC3985 . Description focus on Edge Nodes procedures and functions . Text covers the Edge Nodes components : ( 1 ) TSN functions ( in NSP block ) ; ( 2 ) DetNet Service Proxy ; and ( 3 ) DetNet sub - layers . Approving from teelcon review" 3486514b01b74d57f031bcf660311de328a6e0dc 3486514b01b74d57f031bcf660311de328a6e0dc draft-ietf-detnet-tsn-vpn-over-mpls 4826376633600232b766cb8a62d4054b0f5ea45d74878bcf57356e567088300c ['e82e49a3c764c0ede490d9e8afe0d0a379ec1e2fb734910d7e42f179709f894c', '1b5276bed81725e3cab5fa8d2491ae7fc344c8638906d8e62ee7c31696edcb52', 'a6a4ee1a9211a2be0e24cf91f9742499a46567acff4c78f62b568b34e38c08de', '44d22f065218a14d5aa04288e7553c8a6d81bb222066c74ea38571bbe922a729', 'c757c3611002031d5ce1ac79d9984d826f392e6628a0657e045c348e52b7eda2', '8a105d9f9ffbf3e747a101e48de19122931cd0cce896dc27f57d16df9dbb75ac', 'a8ff14472a8fa48bacdc11d7089a9d1054c0a786f6152f510b5d4092c22e121f', 'e746630d4b45cf2b654a14e4daaa03ad634e33d92c29c489e3ef3fcd5620c311', '16375944152e6c3e73492437880fe39d7f0123a9292d062e8e9c7d317e4b878f', '42f5214bb177fd7faf01b7943e7f313a615b2490f9109d5cefa8b24101735c32', '5cc97b8f56cdeeb02e7c96183745dc53dd8ec3ec02424107d16eb438c2c9363c', 'a816e4d1392c9c85d398ee2c5116b5de849a9823bc552d322ac8725f7c9b859e', 'c7286f8983508fdd7d94ae798cdc3950cbf65865e905c00a76838a34eb79cf2c', '6924f7b3002e9f0dff9023b70bcc9d484e643c3a2d95b0d5c853c084ad3f68ab', '2d8fce3963de03360a5d98758067925a60474b5430fd8091fc72f3c50a9d38e5', '77f9aaec42bbb94079fae33b8c564cd7f64721106f615e11f22673310efaf01b', '09f8dc962fd9202d148a0b378c9a078ea850056b4b5c360c0914d4a1de6af454', '4826376633600232b766cb8a62d4054b0f5ea45d74878bcf57356e567088300c', '82b410c949db1d81b3f197adbaaba7b82b6e497600cd9883150af2bb815caa19', '0eb73f51f3b491bd6d969a05acf2b527e6e2f09a460cb88266513ab952bd3fc6', '1076eab6753435c114e8a720c951b03da6d4e1bbbf1290f8d58ad7f97a0b8c64', '4ccf918f8b8ae99a769d89e0868a12e4af1536487652436b6c188bc99e14fdb6', '2a5cef1e9c76b52b9b56c6c021a857b0fa757897b6e3c96cc8170d5b73ba8dd8', '07267e696bfbb5af98da5a8efe2b8cf604bc9ab1ce95e4766f017473bfcd0de1', '82f56d4694c2ec964de0a4413954f87ca621628c63d7425944baeff9aa4b6dad', '01e1da53fe2751e7196114efc63dd70d9babc69b4b73c03d4b7528dcc10c05d3', 'fb8f3ca7fafc9c173404ce7f909038443a6078a0c278cb024639410e33f49f88', '44e497e2df0461bad9215c57918855022435eb6e28266916161de3f7902bb352', '84f5bc0e0be5d04b515e8e49efb393e4aec7189222b92c0555cc1be542e74549', '3195c90c03cf6a438b5684cc93128c53f794660a661e2aa85d043ca5ac7060b9', 'b5bacf05f766e143f6de9484b0b5a2d9655d62854368373bd77974b94cb722e6', '2442b9072d522cde54849b40cab26789e4af909f1dd81391cd8c87023515a21c', 'b03d79d1a547b36a28c6cba78f57b8244a4855f6b31003de3e617a5b5eddc070', 'e386562e3156c91934ceb045df46d7e847bb9afcad2794bda59be854f988befc', 'cc980749457292da3a6a4a3ce669ad487409ce72e20857e80c75741c83af7f0a', '75db9ae91b710fcf1df3553b8f9653b12d014f74ba1ee8f931870d2433e163f1', '0e313215df9694bc26777ba4ac347cb8ef73f8475d2bfed664aab722833589ae', '1094721b24c22ff67539ffeabab887f87e538bdd9ebe50b0b369de138d326802', 'fb2b9389e1455c6d64ae19158396d767d88969013b14075bcfdcc764f610108c', 'ae3bdd3a81d96e4aaa02f7d597a2684146f3af75b743bde8e31c3cf5883707db', '1b8137b4c60774716e4a492efec48060d48abd7308563d8cc76edf32d98bd759', '09732023af932d8c578c8a7ead49feb80cdb5c629cee6add2e24fcd7999c0309', '75b7020073ec0c8cedf517f1b56d554e2a5cfdf89d204633c30b863c42ed6f5f', '4be1dfb90ea542d5d84c23c0ba29b91db2491a39973839ee646eeec25c71adb4', 'c98d52f719106d13b14f27abde81ce00305cbf62889690b72da3e3ddc0286c02', '056859e4aa430e2eb983e93f08bb85d9afe9aec44f0e73263cf072df70b7c475', '870147c2dad0a0dda2dd0a9f85ef83b3c4de9a304fdff6d9fa9ccc4bde9d70c0', '26e942b0353fee8f5ac0a2c2e26c9b695c50b35c501eeb4bff343b1648b5cebc', '036168e918418eb807bc3efd361a8e66067192564da41e30e076d22be0f87935', 'a491df768673d76ae7dee4c9bf1ea1456e6c537a1f1683368d8bc6869cd89bf0', 'f6a8cfceb19b4cd796512223b8afd103c4aee7052247ebea8b50f743e9aa27b6', 'd135518ad4230c8f57a3510b3ddea8a99e2355363c9419a27340734427050729', 'cbe90e272b6be7696d3b8c171500847d2b0ae497f6911d0f9d5d8481101c4c1f', '249c961ea29438959ea2204728df24964ec80b8cd91c657715c47014f5e5a462', '1920ebb46d0cee2d379ef48c15f8f6abd01e2a183f316da235e0c3b7515feade', '6d1573b42d5f89f89b26b32cbbd32ff41660e0e8c3b3091f1cb278a42651e049', 'ec6878825845c61b3049ad5dd168197c84938e7f6d4fc938670da2528cf86317', '9829b13faebde69c2279c38cd54d524aa31acfdcc1cfba7910b9d69caa42e0dd', '2755ae7cda161df0c24e1fa9f1c3308bc9ef81a599d859668490484290ca72f4', '09d9dcfc1716808b0c62e47a771ff4d39ba71f22c8640776e65624747a995626', '71dfcd074b80de90c4955890bdbe127d12b249ed764c7c4ca23dc81c74fde71d', '3c1afbb156ee2d672ca131c7c966bc6875374a95d927848bafcc5a158edf67bb'] B "the security considerations of detnet in general are discussed in i- d.ietf-detnet-architecture and i-d.ietf-detnet-security. detnet mpls data plane specific considerations are summarized in i-d.ietf-detnet- mpls. encryption may provided within the tsn network using macsec ieee802.1ae-2018." {79: 1, 130: 1, 54: 1, 52: 1, 98: 1, 6: 1, 8: 1, 64: 1, 99: 1, 24: 1, 90: 2, 51: 2, 62: 4, 85: 4, 68: 3, 35: 2, 110: 2, 91: 4, 114: 2, 97: 2, 31: 2, 13: 2, 67: 2, 38: 3, 26: 2, 124: 2, 127: 2, 96: 2, 30: 3, 61: 4, 55: 2, 27: 3, 15: 2, 129: 2, 115: 2, 84: 2, 76: 5, 87: 2, 131: 4, 102: 2, 113: 4, 36: 2, 72: 3} {4: 1, 24: 1, 59: 1, 111: 1, 136: 1, 156: 1, 206: 1, 215: 1, 220: 1, 221: 1, 235: 1, 241: 1, 242: 1, 314: 1, 329: 1, 334: 1, 354: 1, 366: 1, 376: 1, 1: 8, 9: 4, 10: 2, 15: 2, 25: 4, 26: 4, 27: 2, 39: 4, 43: 2, 49: 5, 50: 4, 58: 4, 64: 2, 69: 3, 81: 5, 82: 3, 86: 2, 96: 3, 97: 2, 100: 6, 108: 2, 109: 3, 110: 3, 114: 2, 115: 3, 116: 2, 118: 5, 119: 4, 120: 2, 121: 3, 122: 3, 123: 2, 124: 3, 128: 3, 129: 3, 130: 4, 132: 3, 145: 3, 147: 3, 151: 3, 152: 3, 154: 2, 161: 2, 162: 2, 165: 2, 168: 3, 169: 2, 172: 2, 180: 3, 184: 4, 187: 4, 188: 3, 191: 2, 194: 3, 202: 4, 203: 5, 207: 2, 217: 2, 218: 7, 222: 4, 224: 2, 227: 4, 229: 2, 234: 4, 243: 3, 244: 3, 245: 3, 248: 3, 250: 3, 258: 10, 262: 3, 263: 4, 264: 2, 267: 3, 270: 2, 272: 2, 273: 4, 287: 2, 289: 2, 291: 4, 299: 4, 300: 2, 304: 2, 309: 2, 315: 2, 320: 3, 323: 3, 327: 3, 328: 2, 330: 9, 335: 2, 341: 4, 342: 5, 347: 4, 348: 4, 350: 6, 351: 4, 352: 2, 353: 2, 358: 3, 365: 2, 371: 6, 372: 4, 384: 4, 385: 3, 386: 2, 387: 2, 392: 2, 393: 3, 396: 5, 397: 6, 398: 5, 402: 2} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 52 "This document specifies the Deterministic Networking MPLS data plane when operating over a TSN network." Similar structure and changes as in IP over TSN . Service protection interworking is out - of - scope . d275ba154e2b7c82eb3ec9175d790214b0e60d3f d275ba154e2b7c82eb3ec9175d790214b0e60d3f draft-ietf-detnet-mpls-over-tsn e10c866957c1a77fb666db5a448282bd7c09996f31e3343d9023bdf992bbfa6d ['f27cd400f15b767c66b85f44128dca38137025888fc5c9762efbe1c927c792e7', 'e10c866957c1a77fb666db5a448282bd7c09996f31e3343d9023bdf992bbfa6d'] A "this document specifies the deterministic networking mpls data plane when operating over a tsn network." {124: 1, 64: 4, 67: 3, 130: 2} {158: 1, 133: 4, 268: 3, 269: 2, 305: 5} {133, 391, 268, 269, 305, 158} 52 "This document specifies the Deterministic Networking MPLS data plane when operating over a TSN sub-network." Similar structure and changes as in IP over TSN . Service protection interworking is out - of - scope . d275ba154e2b7c82eb3ec9175d790214b0e60d3f d275ba154e2b7c82eb3ec9175d790214b0e60d3f draft-ietf-detnet-mpls-over-tsn f27cd400f15b767c66b85f44128dca38137025888fc5c9762efbe1c927c792e7 ['f27cd400f15b767c66b85f44128dca38137025888fc5c9762efbe1c927c792e7', 'e10c866957c1a77fb666db5a448282bd7c09996f31e3343d9023bdf992bbfa6d'] B "this document specifies the deterministic networking mpls data plane when operating over a tsn sub-network." {124: 1, 64: 4, 67: 3, 130: 2} {158: 1, 133: 4, 268: 3, 269: 2, 305: 5} {133, 391, 268, 269, 305, 158} 52 "This document specifies the DetNet data plane operation and the on- wire encapsulation of DetNet flows over an MPLS-based Packet Switched Network (PSN). The specified encapsulation provides the building blocks to enable the DetNet service and forwarding sub-layer functions and supports flow identification as described in the DetNet Architecture. As part of the service sub-layer functions, this document describes DetNet node data plane operation. It also describes the function and operation of the Packet Replication (PRF) Packet Elimination (PEF) and Packet Ordering (POF) functions with an MPLS data plane. It also describes an MPLS-based DetNet forwarding sub-layer that eliminates (or reduces) contention loss and provides bounded latency for DetNet flows." Similar structure and changes as in IP over TSN . Service protection interworking is out - of - scope . d275ba154e2b7c82eb3ec9175d790214b0e60d3f d275ba154e2b7c82eb3ec9175d790214b0e60d3f draft-ietf-detnet-mpls-over-tsn 25ee4836e09adbe42070a7533a6d20b0131064d99d3a747938f99bda5927cf27 ['d3c07eef870b729834f306f06b1700c5b51b0ea2f10ce6d593c74c3b4085e08f', '25ee4836e09adbe42070a7533a6d20b0131064d99d3a747938f99bda5927cf27', 'df4a2592e3f4d009465c605122058e0a0b1ca3b7f1cd454becf4c34cbaca8076', '70fdbe977f021a970afa9f267bca8148f18713e22de2270b2b4b8a36115e346c'] A "this document specifies the detnet data plane operation and the on- wire encapsulation of detnet flows over an mpls-based packet switched network (psn). the specified encapsulation provides the building blocks to enable the detnet service and forwarding sub-layer functions and supports flow identification as described in the detnet architecture. as part of the service sub-layer functions, this document describes detnet node data plane operation. it also describes the function and operation of the packet replication (prf) packet elimination (pef) and packet ordering (pof) functions with an mpls data plane. it also describes an mpls-based detnet forwarding sub-layer that eliminates (or reduces) contention loss and provides bounded latency for detnet flows." {130: 1, 79: 4, 51: 4, 112: 5, 55: 5, 64: 4, 62: 5, 37: 4, 38: 5, 69: 4, 68: 4, 67: 2, 33: 4, 25: 4, 53: 4, 80: 4, 52: 3, 127: 6, 91: 5} {399: 1, 0: 5, 389: 4, 390: 4, 135: 5, 142: 5, 14: 4, 400: 5, 17: 4, 19: 5, 149: 5, 406: 4, 279: 4, 280: 4, 281: 5, 278: 4, 294: 4, 296: 5, 45: 5, 308: 4, 56: 4, 185: 4, 192: 4, 321: 3, 322: 4, 66: 2, 196: 7, 197: 6, 324: 5, 77: 5, 78: 5, 216: 5, 380: 4, 255: 5} {0, 389, 390, 135, 142, 14, 400, 17, 399, 19, 149, 406, 279, 280, 281, 278, 294, 296, 45, 308, 56, 185, 192, 321, 322, 66, 196, 197, 324, 77, 78, 337, 216, 380, 255} 52 "MPLS encapsulated DetNet flows can be carried over network technologies that can provide the DetNet required level of service. This document defines examples of such, specifically carrying DetNet MPLS flows over IEEE 802.1 TSN sub-networks, and over DetNet IP PSN." Similar structure and changes as in IP over TSN . Service protection interworking is out - of - scope . d275ba154e2b7c82eb3ec9175d790214b0e60d3f d275ba154e2b7c82eb3ec9175d790214b0e60d3f draft-ietf-detnet-mpls-over-tsn 70fdbe977f021a970afa9f267bca8148f18713e22de2270b2b4b8a36115e346c ['d3c07eef870b729834f306f06b1700c5b51b0ea2f10ce6d593c74c3b4085e08f', '25ee4836e09adbe42070a7533a6d20b0131064d99d3a747938f99bda5927cf27', 'df4a2592e3f4d009465c605122058e0a0b1ca3b7f1cd454becf4c34cbaca8076', '70fdbe977f021a970afa9f267bca8148f18713e22de2270b2b4b8a36115e346c'] A "mpls encapsulated detnet flows can be carried over network technologies that can provide the detnet required level of service. this document defines examples of such, specifically carrying detnet mpls flows over ieee 802.1 tsn sub-networks, and over detnet ip psn." {130: 1, 79: 4, 51: 4, 112: 5, 55: 5, 64: 4, 62: 5, 37: 4, 38: 5, 69: 4, 68: 4, 67: 2, 33: 4, 25: 4, 53: 4, 80: 4, 52: 3, 127: 6, 91: 5} {399: 1, 0: 5, 389: 4, 390: 4, 135: 5, 142: 5, 14: 4, 400: 5, 17: 4, 19: 5, 149: 5, 406: 4, 279: 4, 280: 4, 281: 5, 278: 4, 294: 4, 296: 5, 45: 5, 308: 4, 56: 4, 185: 4, 192: 4, 321: 3, 322: 4, 66: 2, 196: 7, 197: 6, 324: 5, 77: 5, 78: 5, 216: 5, 380: 4, 255: 5} {0, 389, 390, 135, 142, 14, 400, 17, 399, 19, 149, 406, 279, 280, 281, 278, 294, 296, 45, 308, 56, 185, 192, 321, 322, 66, 196, 197, 324, 77, 78, 337, 216, 380, 255} 52 "The intent is for this document to support different traffic types being mapped over DetNet MPLS, but this is out side the scope of this document. An example of such can be found in I-D.ietf-detnet-dp-sol- ip. This document also allows for, but does not define, associated controller plane and Operations, Administration, and Maintenance (OAM) functions." Similar structure and changes as in IP over TSN . Service protection interworking is out - of - scope . d275ba154e2b7c82eb3ec9175d790214b0e60d3f d275ba154e2b7c82eb3ec9175d790214b0e60d3f draft-ietf-detnet-mpls-over-tsn df4a2592e3f4d009465c605122058e0a0b1ca3b7f1cd454becf4c34cbaca8076 ['d3c07eef870b729834f306f06b1700c5b51b0ea2f10ce6d593c74c3b4085e08f', '25ee4836e09adbe42070a7533a6d20b0131064d99d3a747938f99bda5927cf27', 'df4a2592e3f4d009465c605122058e0a0b1ca3b7f1cd454becf4c34cbaca8076', '70fdbe977f021a970afa9f267bca8148f18713e22de2270b2b4b8a36115e346c'] A "the intent is for this document to support different traffic types being mapped over detnet mpls, but this is out side the scope of this document. an example of such can be found in i-d.ietf-detnet-dp-sol- ip. this document also allows for, but does not define, associated controller plane and operations, administration, and maintenance (oam) functions." {130: 1, 79: 4, 51: 4, 112: 5, 55: 5, 64: 4, 62: 5, 37: 4, 38: 5, 69: 4, 68: 4, 67: 2, 33: 4, 25: 4, 53: 4, 80: 4, 52: 3, 127: 6, 91: 5} {399: 1, 0: 5, 389: 4, 390: 4, 135: 5, 142: 5, 14: 4, 400: 5, 17: 4, 19: 5, 149: 5, 406: 4, 279: 4, 280: 4, 281: 5, 278: 4, 294: 4, 296: 5, 45: 5, 308: 4, 56: 4, 185: 4, 192: 4, 321: 3, 322: 4, 66: 2, 196: 7, 197: 6, 324: 5, 77: 5, 78: 5, 216: 5, 380: 4, 255: 5} {0, 389, 390, 135, 142, 14, 400, 17, 399, 19, 149, 406, 279, 280, 281, 278, 294, 296, 45, 308, 56, 185, 192, 321, 322, 66, 196, 197, 324, 77, 78, 337, 216, 380, 255} 52 "I-D.ietf-detnet-mpls specifies the DetNet data plane operation for MPLS-based Packet Switched Network (PSN). MPLS encapsulated DetNet flows can be carried over network technologies that can provide the DetNet required level of service. This document focuses on the scenario where MPLS (DetNet) nodes are interconnected by a IEEE 802.1 TSN sub-network." Similar structure and changes as in IP over TSN . Service protection interworking is out - of - scope . d275ba154e2b7c82eb3ec9175d790214b0e60d3f d275ba154e2b7c82eb3ec9175d790214b0e60d3f draft-ietf-detnet-mpls-over-tsn d3c07eef870b729834f306f06b1700c5b51b0ea2f10ce6d593c74c3b4085e08f ['d3c07eef870b729834f306f06b1700c5b51b0ea2f10ce6d593c74c3b4085e08f', '25ee4836e09adbe42070a7533a6d20b0131064d99d3a747938f99bda5927cf27', 'df4a2592e3f4d009465c605122058e0a0b1ca3b7f1cd454becf4c34cbaca8076', '70fdbe977f021a970afa9f267bca8148f18713e22de2270b2b4b8a36115e346c'] B "i-d.ietf-detnet-mpls specifies the detnet data plane operation for mpls-based packet switched network (psn). mpls encapsulated detnet flows can be carried over network technologies that can provide the detnet required level of service. this document focuses on the scenario where mpls (detnet) nodes are interconnected by a ieee 802.1 tsn sub-network." {130: 1, 79: 4, 51: 4, 112: 5, 55: 5, 64: 4, 62: 5, 37: 4, 38: 5, 69: 4, 68: 4, 67: 2, 33: 4, 25: 4, 53: 4, 80: 4, 52: 3, 127: 6, 91: 5} {399: 1, 0: 5, 389: 4, 390: 4, 135: 5, 142: 5, 14: 4, 400: 5, 17: 4, 19: 5, 149: 5, 406: 4, 279: 4, 280: 4, 281: 5, 278: 4, 294: 4, 296: 5, 45: 5, 308: 4, 56: 4, 185: 4, 192: 4, 321: 3, 322: 4, 66: 2, 196: 7, 197: 6, 324: 5, 77: 5, 78: 5, 216: 5, 380: 4, 255: 5} {0, 389, 390, 135, 142, 14, 400, 17, 399, 19, 149, 406, 279, 280, 281, 278, 294, 296, 45, 308, 56, 185, 192, 321, 322, 66, 196, 197, 324, 77, 78, 337, 216, 380, 255} 52 "This document uses the terminology established in the DetNet architecture I-D.ietf-detnet-architecture, and the reader is assumed to be familiar with that document and its terminology." Similar structure and changes as in IP over TSN . Service protection interworking is out - of - scope . d275ba154e2b7c82eb3ec9175d790214b0e60d3f d275ba154e2b7c82eb3ec9175d790214b0e60d3f draft-ietf-detnet-mpls-over-tsn cae70a041f2bb7a437801975d64fbc6aa981e51be14ad7536d6a022d294d2c70 ['cae70a041f2bb7a437801975d64fbc6aa981e51be14ad7536d6a022d294d2c70', '101d6488f0f475a04aa297b74fc9f2861a180e4eb1a083da451550a5788c81e8', 'b8d8f64f0f09d4c8fa40ff054a5f0e468afa79876dab10bea529c2c1e1430fbc', '798866c5ba6606c0230b5e31f7d949471ef699d268b844c3bf0c994e96864245', 'b205fa18b546a1f8079fdb24ae479d6824e7893fbc50608c283e46c6f8365253', 'c2441bad9168c35aef67c82d8c8ca1d32bfa5f2bd7b4e3fdcb0c74913367661f', '09f6b6a812132eee463de5625d44082094351e5e01c90e0e4dc14d2893ef6a38', '45bc601f4e7c8b80cc0c429fc5273808e88ddf7f6b0c7053a4c557e2c279a10d', '890a229745f78c3232f7d204d42fe7c17d51066efd5ca3f47c9011e956d120d6', '10f9a5c80140ddc029e2cc8bd11a50566e91cd86859e72018aaba5e3aa63710c', '0dd575583d4427fd1c98abc06595c8d3719b98bf537e86e8c3f332281f235909', 'bb194dc58a0eb7e52501603ff614fb1131422ca453ab5b879033dd20511649fb', '2a6155467d7734762edcbb115219fa2034b5155fbeebef9e57c2926f910375de', 'b4e58098ddc365c5552b862a0113a228a093c4d0e43777c907381a6a46a6e046', '18586b4a34af8afb3b19ff32c04e0b7b2f961021e15338b0a5a3ccafbea3e89f', 'eda485aa07899ce4cc9c22d814ca5a92456c0ba570795dc4ce791e8bb4e16f79', 'fcbb4b68ae78c4ce9cca6d03e0f62a1b8515b67ad1bc512e0d4857a6b428fb55', '4a07c00a2ef0ed6df53d67d4748692a7f5c92d154b8316731024f3bad52df550', 'f26b50ed804ba5111d76706f92b83072518815ec945b0054da2495f47279287a', '7c29d182df52ad8a912d64a1a9fa6feee494e1142ce6abeb5c37c626b5e5590f'] A "this document uses the terminology established in the detnet architecture i-d.ietf-detnet-architecture, and the reader is assumed to be familiar with that document and its terminology." {64: 1, 37: 1, 67: 1, 53: 1, 80: 1, 33: 1, 68: 1, 79: 1, 25: 1, 51: 1, 69: 1, 130: 2, 112: 2, 55: 2, 62: 2, 38: 2, 127: 3, 91: 2, 52: 3} {14: 1, 17: 1, 56: 1, 66: 1, 185: 1, 192: 1, 278: 1, 279: 1, 280: 1, 294: 1, 308: 1, 322: 1, 389: 1, 390: 1, 406: 1, 380: 1, 0: 2, 135: 2, 142: 2, 400: 2, 399: 2, 19: 2, 149: 2, 281: 2, 296: 2, 45: 2, 196: 4, 197: 3, 324: 2, 77: 2, 78: 2, 337: 3, 216: 2, 255: 2} {0, 389, 390, 135, 142, 14, 400, 17, 399, 19, 149, 406, 279, 280, 281, 278, 294, 296, 45, 308, 56, 185, 192, 321, 322, 66, 196, 197, 324, 77, 78, 337, 216, 380, 255} 52 "A Detnet ""forwarding"" label that identifies the LSP used to forward a DetNet flow across an MPLS PSN, e.g., a hop-by-hop label used between label switching routers (LSR)." Similar structure and changes as in IP over TSN . Service protection interworking is out - of - scope . d275ba154e2b7c82eb3ec9175d790214b0e60d3f d275ba154e2b7c82eb3ec9175d790214b0e60d3f draft-ietf-detnet-mpls-over-tsn 2a6155467d7734762edcbb115219fa2034b5155fbeebef9e57c2926f910375de ['cae70a041f2bb7a437801975d64fbc6aa981e51be14ad7536d6a022d294d2c70', '101d6488f0f475a04aa297b74fc9f2861a180e4eb1a083da451550a5788c81e8', 'b8d8f64f0f09d4c8fa40ff054a5f0e468afa79876dab10bea529c2c1e1430fbc', '798866c5ba6606c0230b5e31f7d949471ef699d268b844c3bf0c994e96864245', 'b205fa18b546a1f8079fdb24ae479d6824e7893fbc50608c283e46c6f8365253', 'c2441bad9168c35aef67c82d8c8ca1d32bfa5f2bd7b4e3fdcb0c74913367661f', '09f6b6a812132eee463de5625d44082094351e5e01c90e0e4dc14d2893ef6a38', '45bc601f4e7c8b80cc0c429fc5273808e88ddf7f6b0c7053a4c557e2c279a10d', '890a229745f78c3232f7d204d42fe7c17d51066efd5ca3f47c9011e956d120d6', '10f9a5c80140ddc029e2cc8bd11a50566e91cd86859e72018aaba5e3aa63710c', '0dd575583d4427fd1c98abc06595c8d3719b98bf537e86e8c3f332281f235909', 'bb194dc58a0eb7e52501603ff614fb1131422ca453ab5b879033dd20511649fb', '2a6155467d7734762edcbb115219fa2034b5155fbeebef9e57c2926f910375de', 'b4e58098ddc365c5552b862a0113a228a093c4d0e43777c907381a6a46a6e046', '18586b4a34af8afb3b19ff32c04e0b7b2f961021e15338b0a5a3ccafbea3e89f', 'eda485aa07899ce4cc9c22d814ca5a92456c0ba570795dc4ce791e8bb4e16f79', 'fcbb4b68ae78c4ce9cca6d03e0f62a1b8515b67ad1bc512e0d4857a6b428fb55', '4a07c00a2ef0ed6df53d67d4748692a7f5c92d154b8316731024f3bad52df550', 'f26b50ed804ba5111d76706f92b83072518815ec945b0054da2495f47279287a', '7c29d182df52ad8a912d64a1a9fa6feee494e1142ce6abeb5c37c626b5e5590f'] A "a detnet ""forwarding"" label that identifies the lsp used to forward a detnet flow across an mpls psn, e.g., a hop-by-hop label used between label switching routers (lsr)." {64: 1, 37: 1, 67: 1, 53: 1, 80: 1, 33: 1, 68: 1, 79: 1, 25: 1, 51: 1, 69: 1, 130: 2, 112: 2, 55: 2, 62: 2, 38: 2, 127: 3, 91: 2, 52: 3} {14: 1, 17: 1, 56: 1, 66: 1, 185: 1, 192: 1, 278: 1, 279: 1, 280: 1, 294: 1, 308: 1, 322: 1, 389: 1, 390: 1, 406: 1, 380: 1, 0: 2, 135: 2, 142: 2, 400: 2, 399: 2, 19: 2, 149: 2, 281: 2, 296: 2, 45: 2, 196: 4, 197: 3, 324: 2, 77: 2, 78: 2, 337: 3, 216: 2, 255: 2} {0, 389, 390, 135, 142, 14, 400, 17, 399, 19, 149, 406, 279, 280, 281, 278, 294, 296, 45, 308, 56, 185, 192, 321, 322, 66, 196, 197, 324, 77, 78, 337, 216, 380, 255} 52 "A DetNet ""service"" label that is used between DetNet nodes that implement also the DetNet service sub-layer functions. An S-Label is also used to identify a DetNet flow at DetNet service sub- layer." Similar structure and changes as in IP over TSN . Service protection interworking is out - of - scope . d275ba154e2b7c82eb3ec9175d790214b0e60d3f d275ba154e2b7c82eb3ec9175d790214b0e60d3f draft-ietf-detnet-mpls-over-tsn 101d6488f0f475a04aa297b74fc9f2861a180e4eb1a083da451550a5788c81e8 ['cae70a041f2bb7a437801975d64fbc6aa981e51be14ad7536d6a022d294d2c70', '101d6488f0f475a04aa297b74fc9f2861a180e4eb1a083da451550a5788c81e8', 'b8d8f64f0f09d4c8fa40ff054a5f0e468afa79876dab10bea529c2c1e1430fbc', '798866c5ba6606c0230b5e31f7d949471ef699d268b844c3bf0c994e96864245', 'b205fa18b546a1f8079fdb24ae479d6824e7893fbc50608c283e46c6f8365253', 'c2441bad9168c35aef67c82d8c8ca1d32bfa5f2bd7b4e3fdcb0c74913367661f', '09f6b6a812132eee463de5625d44082094351e5e01c90e0e4dc14d2893ef6a38', '45bc601f4e7c8b80cc0c429fc5273808e88ddf7f6b0c7053a4c557e2c279a10d', '890a229745f78c3232f7d204d42fe7c17d51066efd5ca3f47c9011e956d120d6', '10f9a5c80140ddc029e2cc8bd11a50566e91cd86859e72018aaba5e3aa63710c', '0dd575583d4427fd1c98abc06595c8d3719b98bf537e86e8c3f332281f235909', 'bb194dc58a0eb7e52501603ff614fb1131422ca453ab5b879033dd20511649fb', '2a6155467d7734762edcbb115219fa2034b5155fbeebef9e57c2926f910375de', 'b4e58098ddc365c5552b862a0113a228a093c4d0e43777c907381a6a46a6e046', '18586b4a34af8afb3b19ff32c04e0b7b2f961021e15338b0a5a3ccafbea3e89f', 'eda485aa07899ce4cc9c22d814ca5a92456c0ba570795dc4ce791e8bb4e16f79', 'fcbb4b68ae78c4ce9cca6d03e0f62a1b8515b67ad1bc512e0d4857a6b428fb55', '4a07c00a2ef0ed6df53d67d4748692a7f5c92d154b8316731024f3bad52df550', 'f26b50ed804ba5111d76706f92b83072518815ec945b0054da2495f47279287a', '7c29d182df52ad8a912d64a1a9fa6feee494e1142ce6abeb5c37c626b5e5590f'] A "a detnet ""service"" label that is used between detnet nodes that implement also the detnet service sub-layer functions. an s-label is also used to identify a detnet flow at detnet service sub- layer." {64: 1, 37: 1, 67: 1, 53: 1, 80: 1, 33: 1, 68: 1, 79: 1, 25: 1, 51: 1, 69: 1, 130: 2, 112: 2, 55: 2, 62: 2, 38: 2, 127: 3, 91: 2, 52: 3} {14: 1, 17: 1, 56: 1, 66: 1, 185: 1, 192: 1, 278: 1, 279: 1, 280: 1, 294: 1, 308: 1, 322: 1, 389: 1, 390: 1, 406: 1, 380: 1, 0: 2, 135: 2, 142: 2, 400: 2, 399: 2, 19: 2, 149: 2, 281: 2, 296: 2, 45: 2, 196: 4, 197: 3, 324: 2, 77: 2, 78: 2, 337: 3, 216: 2, 255: 2} {0, 389, 390, 135, 142, 14, 400, 17, 399, 19, 149, 406, 279, 280, 281, 278, 294, 296, 45, 308, 56, 185, 192, 321, 322, 66, 196, 197, 324, 77, 78, 337, 216, 380, 255} 52 "A DetNet Control Word (d-CW) is used for sequencing and identifying duplicate packets of a DetNet flow at the DetNet service sub-layer." Similar structure and changes as in IP over TSN . Service protection interworking is out - of - scope . d275ba154e2b7c82eb3ec9175d790214b0e60d3f d275ba154e2b7c82eb3ec9175d790214b0e60d3f draft-ietf-detnet-mpls-over-tsn b4e58098ddc365c5552b862a0113a228a093c4d0e43777c907381a6a46a6e046 ['cae70a041f2bb7a437801975d64fbc6aa981e51be14ad7536d6a022d294d2c70', '101d6488f0f475a04aa297b74fc9f2861a180e4eb1a083da451550a5788c81e8', 'b8d8f64f0f09d4c8fa40ff054a5f0e468afa79876dab10bea529c2c1e1430fbc', '798866c5ba6606c0230b5e31f7d949471ef699d268b844c3bf0c994e96864245', 'b205fa18b546a1f8079fdb24ae479d6824e7893fbc50608c283e46c6f8365253', 'c2441bad9168c35aef67c82d8c8ca1d32bfa5f2bd7b4e3fdcb0c74913367661f', '09f6b6a812132eee463de5625d44082094351e5e01c90e0e4dc14d2893ef6a38', '45bc601f4e7c8b80cc0c429fc5273808e88ddf7f6b0c7053a4c557e2c279a10d', '890a229745f78c3232f7d204d42fe7c17d51066efd5ca3f47c9011e956d120d6', '10f9a5c80140ddc029e2cc8bd11a50566e91cd86859e72018aaba5e3aa63710c', '0dd575583d4427fd1c98abc06595c8d3719b98bf537e86e8c3f332281f235909', 'bb194dc58a0eb7e52501603ff614fb1131422ca453ab5b879033dd20511649fb', '2a6155467d7734762edcbb115219fa2034b5155fbeebef9e57c2926f910375de', 'b4e58098ddc365c5552b862a0113a228a093c4d0e43777c907381a6a46a6e046', '18586b4a34af8afb3b19ff32c04e0b7b2f961021e15338b0a5a3ccafbea3e89f', 'eda485aa07899ce4cc9c22d814ca5a92456c0ba570795dc4ce791e8bb4e16f79', 'fcbb4b68ae78c4ce9cca6d03e0f62a1b8515b67ad1bc512e0d4857a6b428fb55', '4a07c00a2ef0ed6df53d67d4748692a7f5c92d154b8316731024f3bad52df550', 'f26b50ed804ba5111d76706f92b83072518815ec945b0054da2495f47279287a', '7c29d182df52ad8a912d64a1a9fa6feee494e1142ce6abeb5c37c626b5e5590f'] A "a detnet control word (d-cw) is used for sequencing and identifying duplicate packets of a detnet flow at the detnet service sub-layer." {64: 1, 37: 1, 67: 1, 53: 1, 80: 1, 33: 1, 68: 1, 79: 1, 25: 1, 51: 1, 69: 1, 130: 2, 112: 2, 55: 2, 62: 2, 38: 2, 127: 3, 91: 2, 52: 3} {14: 1, 17: 1, 56: 1, 66: 1, 185: 1, 192: 1, 278: 1, 279: 1, 280: 1, 294: 1, 308: 1, 322: 1, 389: 1, 390: 1, 406: 1, 380: 1, 0: 2, 135: 2, 142: 2, 400: 2, 399: 2, 19: 2, 149: 2, 281: 2, 296: 2, 45: 2, 196: 4, 197: 3, 324: 2, 77: 2, 78: 2, 337: 3, 216: 2, 255: 2} {0, 389, 390, 135, 142, 14, 400, 17, 399, 19, 149, 406, 279, 280, 281, 278, 294, 296, 45, 308, 56, 185, 192, 321, 322, 66, 196, 197, 324, 77, 78, 337, 216, 380, 255} 52 Attachment Circuit. Similar structure and changes as in IP over TSN . Service protection interworking is out - of - scope . d275ba154e2b7c82eb3ec9175d790214b0e60d3f d275ba154e2b7c82eb3ec9175d790214b0e60d3f draft-ietf-detnet-mpls-over-tsn 890a229745f78c3232f7d204d42fe7c17d51066efd5ca3f47c9011e956d120d6 ['cae70a041f2bb7a437801975d64fbc6aa981e51be14ad7536d6a022d294d2c70', '101d6488f0f475a04aa297b74fc9f2861a180e4eb1a083da451550a5788c81e8', 'b8d8f64f0f09d4c8fa40ff054a5f0e468afa79876dab10bea529c2c1e1430fbc', '798866c5ba6606c0230b5e31f7d949471ef699d268b844c3bf0c994e96864245', 'b205fa18b546a1f8079fdb24ae479d6824e7893fbc50608c283e46c6f8365253', 'c2441bad9168c35aef67c82d8c8ca1d32bfa5f2bd7b4e3fdcb0c74913367661f', '09f6b6a812132eee463de5625d44082094351e5e01c90e0e4dc14d2893ef6a38', '45bc601f4e7c8b80cc0c429fc5273808e88ddf7f6b0c7053a4c557e2c279a10d', '890a229745f78c3232f7d204d42fe7c17d51066efd5ca3f47c9011e956d120d6', '10f9a5c80140ddc029e2cc8bd11a50566e91cd86859e72018aaba5e3aa63710c', '0dd575583d4427fd1c98abc06595c8d3719b98bf537e86e8c3f332281f235909', 'bb194dc58a0eb7e52501603ff614fb1131422ca453ab5b879033dd20511649fb', '2a6155467d7734762edcbb115219fa2034b5155fbeebef9e57c2926f910375de', 'b4e58098ddc365c5552b862a0113a228a093c4d0e43777c907381a6a46a6e046', '18586b4a34af8afb3b19ff32c04e0b7b2f961021e15338b0a5a3ccafbea3e89f', 'eda485aa07899ce4cc9c22d814ca5a92456c0ba570795dc4ce791e8bb4e16f79', 'fcbb4b68ae78c4ce9cca6d03e0f62a1b8515b67ad1bc512e0d4857a6b428fb55', '4a07c00a2ef0ed6df53d67d4748692a7f5c92d154b8316731024f3bad52df550', 'f26b50ed804ba5111d76706f92b83072518815ec945b0054da2495f47279287a', '7c29d182df52ad8a912d64a1a9fa6feee494e1142ce6abeb5c37c626b5e5590f'] A attachment circuit. {64: 1, 37: 1, 67: 1, 53: 1, 80: 1, 33: 1, 68: 1, 79: 1, 25: 1, 51: 1, 69: 1, 130: 2, 112: 2, 55: 2, 62: 2, 38: 2, 127: 3, 91: 2, 52: 3} {14: 1, 17: 1, 56: 1, 66: 1, 185: 1, 192: 1, 278: 1, 279: 1, 280: 1, 294: 1, 308: 1, 322: 1, 389: 1, 390: 1, 406: 1, 380: 1, 0: 2, 135: 2, 142: 2, 400: 2, 399: 2, 19: 2, 149: 2, 281: 2, 296: 2, 45: 2, 196: 4, 197: 3, 324: 2, 77: 2, 78: 2, 337: 3, 216: 2, 255: 2} {0, 389, 390, 135, 142, 14, 400, 17, 399, 19, 149, 406, 279, 280, 281, 278, 294, 296, 45, 308, 56, 185, 192, 321, 322, 66, 196, 197, 324, 77, 78, 337, 216, 380, 255} 52 Customer Edge equipment. Similar structure and changes as in IP over TSN . Service protection interworking is out - of - scope . d275ba154e2b7c82eb3ec9175d790214b0e60d3f d275ba154e2b7c82eb3ec9175d790214b0e60d3f draft-ietf-detnet-mpls-over-tsn b205fa18b546a1f8079fdb24ae479d6824e7893fbc50608c283e46c6f8365253 ['cae70a041f2bb7a437801975d64fbc6aa981e51be14ad7536d6a022d294d2c70', '101d6488f0f475a04aa297b74fc9f2861a180e4eb1a083da451550a5788c81e8', 'b8d8f64f0f09d4c8fa40ff054a5f0e468afa79876dab10bea529c2c1e1430fbc', '798866c5ba6606c0230b5e31f7d949471ef699d268b844c3bf0c994e96864245', 'b205fa18b546a1f8079fdb24ae479d6824e7893fbc50608c283e46c6f8365253', 'c2441bad9168c35aef67c82d8c8ca1d32bfa5f2bd7b4e3fdcb0c74913367661f', '09f6b6a812132eee463de5625d44082094351e5e01c90e0e4dc14d2893ef6a38', '45bc601f4e7c8b80cc0c429fc5273808e88ddf7f6b0c7053a4c557e2c279a10d', '890a229745f78c3232f7d204d42fe7c17d51066efd5ca3f47c9011e956d120d6', '10f9a5c80140ddc029e2cc8bd11a50566e91cd86859e72018aaba5e3aa63710c', '0dd575583d4427fd1c98abc06595c8d3719b98bf537e86e8c3f332281f235909', 'bb194dc58a0eb7e52501603ff614fb1131422ca453ab5b879033dd20511649fb', '2a6155467d7734762edcbb115219fa2034b5155fbeebef9e57c2926f910375de', 'b4e58098ddc365c5552b862a0113a228a093c4d0e43777c907381a6a46a6e046', '18586b4a34af8afb3b19ff32c04e0b7b2f961021e15338b0a5a3ccafbea3e89f', 'eda485aa07899ce4cc9c22d814ca5a92456c0ba570795dc4ce791e8bb4e16f79', 'fcbb4b68ae78c4ce9cca6d03e0f62a1b8515b67ad1bc512e0d4857a6b428fb55', '4a07c00a2ef0ed6df53d67d4748692a7f5c92d154b8316731024f3bad52df550', 'f26b50ed804ba5111d76706f92b83072518815ec945b0054da2495f47279287a', '7c29d182df52ad8a912d64a1a9fa6feee494e1142ce6abeb5c37c626b5e5590f'] A customer edge equipment. {64: 1, 37: 1, 67: 1, 53: 1, 80: 1, 33: 1, 68: 1, 79: 1, 25: 1, 51: 1, 69: 1, 130: 2, 112: 2, 55: 2, 62: 2, 38: 2, 127: 3, 91: 2, 52: 3} {14: 1, 17: 1, 56: 1, 66: 1, 185: 1, 192: 1, 278: 1, 279: 1, 280: 1, 294: 1, 308: 1, 322: 1, 389: 1, 390: 1, 406: 1, 380: 1, 0: 2, 135: 2, 142: 2, 400: 2, 399: 2, 19: 2, 149: 2, 281: 2, 296: 2, 45: 2, 196: 4, 197: 3, 324: 2, 77: 2, 78: 2, 337: 3, 216: 2, 255: 2} {0, 389, 390, 135, 142, 14, 400, 17, 399, 19, 149, 406, 279, 280, 281, 278, 294, 296, 45, 308, 56, 185, 192, 321, 322, 66, 196, 197, 324, 77, 78, 337, 216, 380, 255} 52 Class of Service. Similar structure and changes as in IP over TSN . Service protection interworking is out - of - scope . d275ba154e2b7c82eb3ec9175d790214b0e60d3f d275ba154e2b7c82eb3ec9175d790214b0e60d3f draft-ietf-detnet-mpls-over-tsn f26b50ed804ba5111d76706f92b83072518815ec945b0054da2495f47279287a ['cae70a041f2bb7a437801975d64fbc6aa981e51be14ad7536d6a022d294d2c70', '101d6488f0f475a04aa297b74fc9f2861a180e4eb1a083da451550a5788c81e8', 'b8d8f64f0f09d4c8fa40ff054a5f0e468afa79876dab10bea529c2c1e1430fbc', '798866c5ba6606c0230b5e31f7d949471ef699d268b844c3bf0c994e96864245', 'b205fa18b546a1f8079fdb24ae479d6824e7893fbc50608c283e46c6f8365253', 'c2441bad9168c35aef67c82d8c8ca1d32bfa5f2bd7b4e3fdcb0c74913367661f', '09f6b6a812132eee463de5625d44082094351e5e01c90e0e4dc14d2893ef6a38', '45bc601f4e7c8b80cc0c429fc5273808e88ddf7f6b0c7053a4c557e2c279a10d', '890a229745f78c3232f7d204d42fe7c17d51066efd5ca3f47c9011e956d120d6', '10f9a5c80140ddc029e2cc8bd11a50566e91cd86859e72018aaba5e3aa63710c', '0dd575583d4427fd1c98abc06595c8d3719b98bf537e86e8c3f332281f235909', 'bb194dc58a0eb7e52501603ff614fb1131422ca453ab5b879033dd20511649fb', '2a6155467d7734762edcbb115219fa2034b5155fbeebef9e57c2926f910375de', 'b4e58098ddc365c5552b862a0113a228a093c4d0e43777c907381a6a46a6e046', '18586b4a34af8afb3b19ff32c04e0b7b2f961021e15338b0a5a3ccafbea3e89f', 'eda485aa07899ce4cc9c22d814ca5a92456c0ba570795dc4ce791e8bb4e16f79', 'fcbb4b68ae78c4ce9cca6d03e0f62a1b8515b67ad1bc512e0d4857a6b428fb55', '4a07c00a2ef0ed6df53d67d4748692a7f5c92d154b8316731024f3bad52df550', 'f26b50ed804ba5111d76706f92b83072518815ec945b0054da2495f47279287a', '7c29d182df52ad8a912d64a1a9fa6feee494e1142ce6abeb5c37c626b5e5590f'] A class of service. {64: 1, 37: 1, 67: 1, 53: 1, 80: 1, 33: 1, 68: 1, 79: 1, 25: 1, 51: 1, 69: 1, 130: 2, 112: 2, 55: 2, 62: 2, 38: 2, 127: 3, 91: 2, 52: 3} {14: 1, 17: 1, 56: 1, 66: 1, 185: 1, 192: 1, 278: 1, 279: 1, 280: 1, 294: 1, 308: 1, 322: 1, 389: 1, 390: 1, 406: 1, 380: 1, 0: 2, 135: 2, 142: 2, 400: 2, 399: 2, 19: 2, 149: 2, 281: 2, 296: 2, 45: 2, 196: 4, 197: 3, 324: 2, 77: 2, 78: 2, 337: 3, 216: 2, 255: 2} {0, 389, 390, 135, 142, 14, 400, 17, 399, 19, 149, 406, 279, 280, 281, 278, 294, 296, 45, 308, 56, 185, 192, 321, 322, 66, 196, 197, 324, 77, 78, 337, 216, 380, 255} 52 DetNet Inter-Working Function. Similar structure and changes as in IP over TSN . Service protection interworking is out - of - scope . d275ba154e2b7c82eb3ec9175d790214b0e60d3f d275ba154e2b7c82eb3ec9175d790214b0e60d3f draft-ietf-detnet-mpls-over-tsn 798866c5ba6606c0230b5e31f7d949471ef699d268b844c3bf0c994e96864245 ['cae70a041f2bb7a437801975d64fbc6aa981e51be14ad7536d6a022d294d2c70', '101d6488f0f475a04aa297b74fc9f2861a180e4eb1a083da451550a5788c81e8', 'b8d8f64f0f09d4c8fa40ff054a5f0e468afa79876dab10bea529c2c1e1430fbc', '798866c5ba6606c0230b5e31f7d949471ef699d268b844c3bf0c994e96864245', 'b205fa18b546a1f8079fdb24ae479d6824e7893fbc50608c283e46c6f8365253', 'c2441bad9168c35aef67c82d8c8ca1d32bfa5f2bd7b4e3fdcb0c74913367661f', '09f6b6a812132eee463de5625d44082094351e5e01c90e0e4dc14d2893ef6a38', '45bc601f4e7c8b80cc0c429fc5273808e88ddf7f6b0c7053a4c557e2c279a10d', '890a229745f78c3232f7d204d42fe7c17d51066efd5ca3f47c9011e956d120d6', '10f9a5c80140ddc029e2cc8bd11a50566e91cd86859e72018aaba5e3aa63710c', '0dd575583d4427fd1c98abc06595c8d3719b98bf537e86e8c3f332281f235909', 'bb194dc58a0eb7e52501603ff614fb1131422ca453ab5b879033dd20511649fb', '2a6155467d7734762edcbb115219fa2034b5155fbeebef9e57c2926f910375de', 'b4e58098ddc365c5552b862a0113a228a093c4d0e43777c907381a6a46a6e046', '18586b4a34af8afb3b19ff32c04e0b7b2f961021e15338b0a5a3ccafbea3e89f', 'eda485aa07899ce4cc9c22d814ca5a92456c0ba570795dc4ce791e8bb4e16f79', 'fcbb4b68ae78c4ce9cca6d03e0f62a1b8515b67ad1bc512e0d4857a6b428fb55', '4a07c00a2ef0ed6df53d67d4748692a7f5c92d154b8316731024f3bad52df550', 'f26b50ed804ba5111d76706f92b83072518815ec945b0054da2495f47279287a', '7c29d182df52ad8a912d64a1a9fa6feee494e1142ce6abeb5c37c626b5e5590f'] A detnet inter-working function. {64: 1, 37: 1, 67: 1, 53: 1, 80: 1, 33: 1, 68: 1, 79: 1, 25: 1, 51: 1, 69: 1, 130: 2, 112: 2, 55: 2, 62: 2, 38: 2, 127: 3, 91: 2, 52: 3} {14: 1, 17: 1, 56: 1, 66: 1, 185: 1, 192: 1, 278: 1, 279: 1, 280: 1, 294: 1, 308: 1, 322: 1, 389: 1, 390: 1, 406: 1, 380: 1, 0: 2, 135: 2, 142: 2, 400: 2, 399: 2, 19: 2, 149: 2, 281: 2, 296: 2, 45: 2, 196: 4, 197: 3, 324: 2, 77: 2, 78: 2, 337: 3, 216: 2, 255: 2} {0, 389, 390, 135, 142, 14, 400, 17, 399, 19, 149, 406, 279, 280, 281, 278, 294, 296, 45, 308, 56, 185, 192, 321, 322, 66, 196, 197, 324, 77, 78, 337, 216, 380, 255} 52 Layer 2 Virtual Private Network. Similar structure and changes as in IP over TSN . Service protection interworking is out - of - scope . d275ba154e2b7c82eb3ec9175d790214b0e60d3f d275ba154e2b7c82eb3ec9175d790214b0e60d3f draft-ietf-detnet-mpls-over-tsn 10f9a5c80140ddc029e2cc8bd11a50566e91cd86859e72018aaba5e3aa63710c ['cae70a041f2bb7a437801975d64fbc6aa981e51be14ad7536d6a022d294d2c70', '101d6488f0f475a04aa297b74fc9f2861a180e4eb1a083da451550a5788c81e8', 'b8d8f64f0f09d4c8fa40ff054a5f0e468afa79876dab10bea529c2c1e1430fbc', '798866c5ba6606c0230b5e31f7d949471ef699d268b844c3bf0c994e96864245', 'b205fa18b546a1f8079fdb24ae479d6824e7893fbc50608c283e46c6f8365253', 'c2441bad9168c35aef67c82d8c8ca1d32bfa5f2bd7b4e3fdcb0c74913367661f', '09f6b6a812132eee463de5625d44082094351e5e01c90e0e4dc14d2893ef6a38', '45bc601f4e7c8b80cc0c429fc5273808e88ddf7f6b0c7053a4c557e2c279a10d', '890a229745f78c3232f7d204d42fe7c17d51066efd5ca3f47c9011e956d120d6', '10f9a5c80140ddc029e2cc8bd11a50566e91cd86859e72018aaba5e3aa63710c', '0dd575583d4427fd1c98abc06595c8d3719b98bf537e86e8c3f332281f235909', 'bb194dc58a0eb7e52501603ff614fb1131422ca453ab5b879033dd20511649fb', '2a6155467d7734762edcbb115219fa2034b5155fbeebef9e57c2926f910375de', 'b4e58098ddc365c5552b862a0113a228a093c4d0e43777c907381a6a46a6e046', '18586b4a34af8afb3b19ff32c04e0b7b2f961021e15338b0a5a3ccafbea3e89f', 'eda485aa07899ce4cc9c22d814ca5a92456c0ba570795dc4ce791e8bb4e16f79', 'fcbb4b68ae78c4ce9cca6d03e0f62a1b8515b67ad1bc512e0d4857a6b428fb55', '4a07c00a2ef0ed6df53d67d4748692a7f5c92d154b8316731024f3bad52df550', 'f26b50ed804ba5111d76706f92b83072518815ec945b0054da2495f47279287a', '7c29d182df52ad8a912d64a1a9fa6feee494e1142ce6abeb5c37c626b5e5590f'] A layer 2 virtual private network. {64: 1, 37: 1, 67: 1, 53: 1, 80: 1, 33: 1, 68: 1, 79: 1, 25: 1, 51: 1, 69: 1, 130: 2, 112: 2, 55: 2, 62: 2, 38: 2, 127: 3, 91: 2, 52: 3} {14: 1, 17: 1, 56: 1, 66: 1, 185: 1, 192: 1, 278: 1, 279: 1, 280: 1, 294: 1, 308: 1, 322: 1, 389: 1, 390: 1, 406: 1, 380: 1, 0: 2, 135: 2, 142: 2, 400: 2, 399: 2, 19: 2, 149: 2, 281: 2, 296: 2, 45: 2, 196: 4, 197: 3, 324: 2, 77: 2, 78: 2, 337: 3, 216: 2, 255: 2} {0, 389, 390, 135, 142, 14, 400, 17, 399, 19, 149, 406, 279, 280, 281, 278, 294, 296, 45, 308, 56, 185, 192, 321, 322, 66, 196, 197, 324, 77, 78, 337, 216, 380, 255} 52 Multiprotocol Label Switching - Traffic Engineering. Similar structure and changes as in IP over TSN . Service protection interworking is out - of - scope . d275ba154e2b7c82eb3ec9175d790214b0e60d3f d275ba154e2b7c82eb3ec9175d790214b0e60d3f draft-ietf-detnet-mpls-over-tsn b8d8f64f0f09d4c8fa40ff054a5f0e468afa79876dab10bea529c2c1e1430fbc ['cae70a041f2bb7a437801975d64fbc6aa981e51be14ad7536d6a022d294d2c70', '101d6488f0f475a04aa297b74fc9f2861a180e4eb1a083da451550a5788c81e8', 'b8d8f64f0f09d4c8fa40ff054a5f0e468afa79876dab10bea529c2c1e1430fbc', '798866c5ba6606c0230b5e31f7d949471ef699d268b844c3bf0c994e96864245', 'b205fa18b546a1f8079fdb24ae479d6824e7893fbc50608c283e46c6f8365253', 'c2441bad9168c35aef67c82d8c8ca1d32bfa5f2bd7b4e3fdcb0c74913367661f', '09f6b6a812132eee463de5625d44082094351e5e01c90e0e4dc14d2893ef6a38', '45bc601f4e7c8b80cc0c429fc5273808e88ddf7f6b0c7053a4c557e2c279a10d', '890a229745f78c3232f7d204d42fe7c17d51066efd5ca3f47c9011e956d120d6', '10f9a5c80140ddc029e2cc8bd11a50566e91cd86859e72018aaba5e3aa63710c', '0dd575583d4427fd1c98abc06595c8d3719b98bf537e86e8c3f332281f235909', 'bb194dc58a0eb7e52501603ff614fb1131422ca453ab5b879033dd20511649fb', '2a6155467d7734762edcbb115219fa2034b5155fbeebef9e57c2926f910375de', 'b4e58098ddc365c5552b862a0113a228a093c4d0e43777c907381a6a46a6e046', '18586b4a34af8afb3b19ff32c04e0b7b2f961021e15338b0a5a3ccafbea3e89f', 'eda485aa07899ce4cc9c22d814ca5a92456c0ba570795dc4ce791e8bb4e16f79', 'fcbb4b68ae78c4ce9cca6d03e0f62a1b8515b67ad1bc512e0d4857a6b428fb55', '4a07c00a2ef0ed6df53d67d4748692a7f5c92d154b8316731024f3bad52df550', 'f26b50ed804ba5111d76706f92b83072518815ec945b0054da2495f47279287a', '7c29d182df52ad8a912d64a1a9fa6feee494e1142ce6abeb5c37c626b5e5590f'] A multiprotocol label switching - traffic engineering. {64: 1, 37: 1, 67: 1, 53: 1, 80: 1, 33: 1, 68: 1, 79: 1, 25: 1, 51: 1, 69: 1, 130: 2, 112: 2, 55: 2, 62: 2, 38: 2, 127: 3, 91: 2, 52: 3} {14: 1, 17: 1, 56: 1, 66: 1, 185: 1, 192: 1, 278: 1, 279: 1, 280: 1, 294: 1, 308: 1, 322: 1, 389: 1, 390: 1, 406: 1, 380: 1, 0: 2, 135: 2, 142: 2, 400: 2, 399: 2, 19: 2, 149: 2, 281: 2, 296: 2, 45: 2, 196: 4, 197: 3, 324: 2, 77: 2, 78: 2, 337: 3, 216: 2, 255: 2} {0, 389, 390, 135, 142, 14, 400, 17, 399, 19, 149, 406, 279, 280, 281, 278, 294, 296, 45, 308, 56, 185, 192, 321, 322, 66, 196, 197, 324, 77, 78, 337, 216, 380, 255} 52 Multiprotocol Label Switching - Transport Profile. Similar structure and changes as in IP over TSN . Service protection interworking is out - of - scope . d275ba154e2b7c82eb3ec9175d790214b0e60d3f d275ba154e2b7c82eb3ec9175d790214b0e60d3f draft-ietf-detnet-mpls-over-tsn 4a07c00a2ef0ed6df53d67d4748692a7f5c92d154b8316731024f3bad52df550 ['cae70a041f2bb7a437801975d64fbc6aa981e51be14ad7536d6a022d294d2c70', '101d6488f0f475a04aa297b74fc9f2861a180e4eb1a083da451550a5788c81e8', 'b8d8f64f0f09d4c8fa40ff054a5f0e468afa79876dab10bea529c2c1e1430fbc', '798866c5ba6606c0230b5e31f7d949471ef699d268b844c3bf0c994e96864245', 'b205fa18b546a1f8079fdb24ae479d6824e7893fbc50608c283e46c6f8365253', 'c2441bad9168c35aef67c82d8c8ca1d32bfa5f2bd7b4e3fdcb0c74913367661f', '09f6b6a812132eee463de5625d44082094351e5e01c90e0e4dc14d2893ef6a38', '45bc601f4e7c8b80cc0c429fc5273808e88ddf7f6b0c7053a4c557e2c279a10d', '890a229745f78c3232f7d204d42fe7c17d51066efd5ca3f47c9011e956d120d6', '10f9a5c80140ddc029e2cc8bd11a50566e91cd86859e72018aaba5e3aa63710c', '0dd575583d4427fd1c98abc06595c8d3719b98bf537e86e8c3f332281f235909', 'bb194dc58a0eb7e52501603ff614fb1131422ca453ab5b879033dd20511649fb', '2a6155467d7734762edcbb115219fa2034b5155fbeebef9e57c2926f910375de', 'b4e58098ddc365c5552b862a0113a228a093c4d0e43777c907381a6a46a6e046', '18586b4a34af8afb3b19ff32c04e0b7b2f961021e15338b0a5a3ccafbea3e89f', 'eda485aa07899ce4cc9c22d814ca5a92456c0ba570795dc4ce791e8bb4e16f79', 'fcbb4b68ae78c4ce9cca6d03e0f62a1b8515b67ad1bc512e0d4857a6b428fb55', '4a07c00a2ef0ed6df53d67d4748692a7f5c92d154b8316731024f3bad52df550', 'f26b50ed804ba5111d76706f92b83072518815ec945b0054da2495f47279287a', '7c29d182df52ad8a912d64a1a9fa6feee494e1142ce6abeb5c37c626b5e5590f'] A multiprotocol label switching - transport profile. {64: 1, 37: 1, 67: 1, 53: 1, 80: 1, 33: 1, 68: 1, 79: 1, 25: 1, 51: 1, 69: 1, 130: 2, 112: 2, 55: 2, 62: 2, 38: 2, 127: 3, 91: 2, 52: 3} {14: 1, 17: 1, 56: 1, 66: 1, 185: 1, 192: 1, 278: 1, 279: 1, 280: 1, 294: 1, 308: 1, 322: 1, 389: 1, 390: 1, 406: 1, 380: 1, 0: 2, 135: 2, 142: 2, 400: 2, 399: 2, 19: 2, 149: 2, 281: 2, 296: 2, 45: 2, 196: 4, 197: 3, 324: 2, 77: 2, 78: 2, 337: 3, 216: 2, 255: 2} {0, 389, 390, 135, 142, 14, 400, 17, 399, 19, 149, 406, 279, 280, 281, 278, 294, 296, 45, 308, 56, 185, 192, 321, 322, 66, 196, 197, 324, 77, 78, 337, 216, 380, 255} 52 Multi-Segment PseudoWire (MS-PW). Similar structure and changes as in IP over TSN . Service protection interworking is out - of - scope . d275ba154e2b7c82eb3ec9175d790214b0e60d3f d275ba154e2b7c82eb3ec9175d790214b0e60d3f draft-ietf-detnet-mpls-over-tsn c2441bad9168c35aef67c82d8c8ca1d32bfa5f2bd7b4e3fdcb0c74913367661f ['cae70a041f2bb7a437801975d64fbc6aa981e51be14ad7536d6a022d294d2c70', '101d6488f0f475a04aa297b74fc9f2861a180e4eb1a083da451550a5788c81e8', 'b8d8f64f0f09d4c8fa40ff054a5f0e468afa79876dab10bea529c2c1e1430fbc', '798866c5ba6606c0230b5e31f7d949471ef699d268b844c3bf0c994e96864245', 'b205fa18b546a1f8079fdb24ae479d6824e7893fbc50608c283e46c6f8365253', 'c2441bad9168c35aef67c82d8c8ca1d32bfa5f2bd7b4e3fdcb0c74913367661f', '09f6b6a812132eee463de5625d44082094351e5e01c90e0e4dc14d2893ef6a38', '45bc601f4e7c8b80cc0c429fc5273808e88ddf7f6b0c7053a4c557e2c279a10d', '890a229745f78c3232f7d204d42fe7c17d51066efd5ca3f47c9011e956d120d6', '10f9a5c80140ddc029e2cc8bd11a50566e91cd86859e72018aaba5e3aa63710c', '0dd575583d4427fd1c98abc06595c8d3719b98bf537e86e8c3f332281f235909', 'bb194dc58a0eb7e52501603ff614fb1131422ca453ab5b879033dd20511649fb', '2a6155467d7734762edcbb115219fa2034b5155fbeebef9e57c2926f910375de', 'b4e58098ddc365c5552b862a0113a228a093c4d0e43777c907381a6a46a6e046', '18586b4a34af8afb3b19ff32c04e0b7b2f961021e15338b0a5a3ccafbea3e89f', 'eda485aa07899ce4cc9c22d814ca5a92456c0ba570795dc4ce791e8bb4e16f79', 'fcbb4b68ae78c4ce9cca6d03e0f62a1b8515b67ad1bc512e0d4857a6b428fb55', '4a07c00a2ef0ed6df53d67d4748692a7f5c92d154b8316731024f3bad52df550', 'f26b50ed804ba5111d76706f92b83072518815ec945b0054da2495f47279287a', '7c29d182df52ad8a912d64a1a9fa6feee494e1142ce6abeb5c37c626b5e5590f'] A multi-segment pseudowire (ms-pw). {64: 1, 37: 1, 67: 1, 53: 1, 80: 1, 33: 1, 68: 1, 79: 1, 25: 1, 51: 1, 69: 1, 130: 2, 112: 2, 55: 2, 62: 2, 38: 2, 127: 3, 91: 2, 52: 3} {14: 1, 17: 1, 56: 1, 66: 1, 185: 1, 192: 1, 278: 1, 279: 1, 280: 1, 294: 1, 308: 1, 322: 1, 389: 1, 390: 1, 406: 1, 380: 1, 0: 2, 135: 2, 142: 2, 400: 2, 399: 2, 19: 2, 149: 2, 281: 2, 296: 2, 45: 2, 196: 4, 197: 3, 324: 2, 77: 2, 78: 2, 337: 3, 216: 2, 255: 2} {0, 389, 390, 135, 142, 14, 400, 17, 399, 19, 149, 406, 279, 280, 281, 278, 294, 296, 45, 308, 56, 185, 192, 321, 322, 66, 196, 197, 324, 77, 78, 337, 216, 380, 255} 52 Native Service Processing. Similar structure and changes as in IP over TSN . Service protection interworking is out - of - scope . d275ba154e2b7c82eb3ec9175d790214b0e60d3f d275ba154e2b7c82eb3ec9175d790214b0e60d3f draft-ietf-detnet-mpls-over-tsn eda485aa07899ce4cc9c22d814ca5a92456c0ba570795dc4ce791e8bb4e16f79 ['cae70a041f2bb7a437801975d64fbc6aa981e51be14ad7536d6a022d294d2c70', '101d6488f0f475a04aa297b74fc9f2861a180e4eb1a083da451550a5788c81e8', 'b8d8f64f0f09d4c8fa40ff054a5f0e468afa79876dab10bea529c2c1e1430fbc', '798866c5ba6606c0230b5e31f7d949471ef699d268b844c3bf0c994e96864245', 'b205fa18b546a1f8079fdb24ae479d6824e7893fbc50608c283e46c6f8365253', 'c2441bad9168c35aef67c82d8c8ca1d32bfa5f2bd7b4e3fdcb0c74913367661f', '09f6b6a812132eee463de5625d44082094351e5e01c90e0e4dc14d2893ef6a38', '45bc601f4e7c8b80cc0c429fc5273808e88ddf7f6b0c7053a4c557e2c279a10d', '890a229745f78c3232f7d204d42fe7c17d51066efd5ca3f47c9011e956d120d6', '10f9a5c80140ddc029e2cc8bd11a50566e91cd86859e72018aaba5e3aa63710c', '0dd575583d4427fd1c98abc06595c8d3719b98bf537e86e8c3f332281f235909', 'bb194dc58a0eb7e52501603ff614fb1131422ca453ab5b879033dd20511649fb', '2a6155467d7734762edcbb115219fa2034b5155fbeebef9e57c2926f910375de', 'b4e58098ddc365c5552b862a0113a228a093c4d0e43777c907381a6a46a6e046', '18586b4a34af8afb3b19ff32c04e0b7b2f961021e15338b0a5a3ccafbea3e89f', 'eda485aa07899ce4cc9c22d814ca5a92456c0ba570795dc4ce791e8bb4e16f79', 'fcbb4b68ae78c4ce9cca6d03e0f62a1b8515b67ad1bc512e0d4857a6b428fb55', '4a07c00a2ef0ed6df53d67d4748692a7f5c92d154b8316731024f3bad52df550', 'f26b50ed804ba5111d76706f92b83072518815ec945b0054da2495f47279287a', '7c29d182df52ad8a912d64a1a9fa6feee494e1142ce6abeb5c37c626b5e5590f'] A native service processing. {64: 1, 37: 1, 67: 1, 53: 1, 80: 1, 33: 1, 68: 1, 79: 1, 25: 1, 51: 1, 69: 1, 130: 2, 112: 2, 55: 2, 62: 2, 38: 2, 127: 3, 91: 2, 52: 3} {14: 1, 17: 1, 56: 1, 66: 1, 185: 1, 192: 1, 278: 1, 279: 1, 280: 1, 294: 1, 308: 1, 322: 1, 389: 1, 390: 1, 406: 1, 380: 1, 0: 2, 135: 2, 142: 2, 400: 2, 399: 2, 19: 2, 149: 2, 281: 2, 296: 2, 45: 2, 196: 4, 197: 3, 324: 2, 77: 2, 78: 2, 337: 3, 216: 2, 255: 2} {0, 389, 390, 135, 142, 14, 400, 17, 399, 19, 149, 406, 279, 280, 281, 278, 294, 296, 45, 308, 56, 185, 192, 321, 322, 66, 196, 197, 324, 77, 78, 337, 216, 380, 255} 52 Operations, Administration, and Maintenance. Similar structure and changes as in IP over TSN . Service protection interworking is out - of - scope . d275ba154e2b7c82eb3ec9175d790214b0e60d3f d275ba154e2b7c82eb3ec9175d790214b0e60d3f draft-ietf-detnet-mpls-over-tsn bb194dc58a0eb7e52501603ff614fb1131422ca453ab5b879033dd20511649fb ['cae70a041f2bb7a437801975d64fbc6aa981e51be14ad7536d6a022d294d2c70', '101d6488f0f475a04aa297b74fc9f2861a180e4eb1a083da451550a5788c81e8', 'b8d8f64f0f09d4c8fa40ff054a5f0e468afa79876dab10bea529c2c1e1430fbc', '798866c5ba6606c0230b5e31f7d949471ef699d268b844c3bf0c994e96864245', 'b205fa18b546a1f8079fdb24ae479d6824e7893fbc50608c283e46c6f8365253', 'c2441bad9168c35aef67c82d8c8ca1d32bfa5f2bd7b4e3fdcb0c74913367661f', '09f6b6a812132eee463de5625d44082094351e5e01c90e0e4dc14d2893ef6a38', '45bc601f4e7c8b80cc0c429fc5273808e88ddf7f6b0c7053a4c557e2c279a10d', '890a229745f78c3232f7d204d42fe7c17d51066efd5ca3f47c9011e956d120d6', '10f9a5c80140ddc029e2cc8bd11a50566e91cd86859e72018aaba5e3aa63710c', '0dd575583d4427fd1c98abc06595c8d3719b98bf537e86e8c3f332281f235909', 'bb194dc58a0eb7e52501603ff614fb1131422ca453ab5b879033dd20511649fb', '2a6155467d7734762edcbb115219fa2034b5155fbeebef9e57c2926f910375de', 'b4e58098ddc365c5552b862a0113a228a093c4d0e43777c907381a6a46a6e046', '18586b4a34af8afb3b19ff32c04e0b7b2f961021e15338b0a5a3ccafbea3e89f', 'eda485aa07899ce4cc9c22d814ca5a92456c0ba570795dc4ce791e8bb4e16f79', 'fcbb4b68ae78c4ce9cca6d03e0f62a1b8515b67ad1bc512e0d4857a6b428fb55', '4a07c00a2ef0ed6df53d67d4748692a7f5c92d154b8316731024f3bad52df550', 'f26b50ed804ba5111d76706f92b83072518815ec945b0054da2495f47279287a', '7c29d182df52ad8a912d64a1a9fa6feee494e1142ce6abeb5c37c626b5e5590f'] A operations, administration, and maintenance. {64: 1, 37: 1, 67: 1, 53: 1, 80: 1, 33: 1, 68: 1, 79: 1, 25: 1, 51: 1, 69: 1, 130: 2, 112: 2, 55: 2, 62: 2, 38: 2, 127: 3, 91: 2, 52: 3} {14: 1, 17: 1, 56: 1, 66: 1, 185: 1, 192: 1, 278: 1, 279: 1, 280: 1, 294: 1, 308: 1, 322: 1, 389: 1, 390: 1, 406: 1, 380: 1, 0: 2, 135: 2, 142: 2, 400: 2, 399: 2, 19: 2, 149: 2, 281: 2, 296: 2, 45: 2, 196: 4, 197: 3, 324: 2, 77: 2, 78: 2, 337: 3, 216: 2, 255: 2} {0, 389, 390, 135, 142, 14, 400, 17, 399, 19, 149, 406, 279, 280, 281, 278, 294, 296, 45, 308, 56, 185, 192, 321, 322, 66, 196, 197, 324, 77, 78, 337, 216, 380, 255} 52 Packet Elimination Function. Similar structure and changes as in IP over TSN . Service protection interworking is out - of - scope . d275ba154e2b7c82eb3ec9175d790214b0e60d3f d275ba154e2b7c82eb3ec9175d790214b0e60d3f draft-ietf-detnet-mpls-over-tsn 18586b4a34af8afb3b19ff32c04e0b7b2f961021e15338b0a5a3ccafbea3e89f ['cae70a041f2bb7a437801975d64fbc6aa981e51be14ad7536d6a022d294d2c70', '101d6488f0f475a04aa297b74fc9f2861a180e4eb1a083da451550a5788c81e8', 'b8d8f64f0f09d4c8fa40ff054a5f0e468afa79876dab10bea529c2c1e1430fbc', '798866c5ba6606c0230b5e31f7d949471ef699d268b844c3bf0c994e96864245', 'b205fa18b546a1f8079fdb24ae479d6824e7893fbc50608c283e46c6f8365253', 'c2441bad9168c35aef67c82d8c8ca1d32bfa5f2bd7b4e3fdcb0c74913367661f', '09f6b6a812132eee463de5625d44082094351e5e01c90e0e4dc14d2893ef6a38', '45bc601f4e7c8b80cc0c429fc5273808e88ddf7f6b0c7053a4c557e2c279a10d', '890a229745f78c3232f7d204d42fe7c17d51066efd5ca3f47c9011e956d120d6', '10f9a5c80140ddc029e2cc8bd11a50566e91cd86859e72018aaba5e3aa63710c', '0dd575583d4427fd1c98abc06595c8d3719b98bf537e86e8c3f332281f235909', 'bb194dc58a0eb7e52501603ff614fb1131422ca453ab5b879033dd20511649fb', '2a6155467d7734762edcbb115219fa2034b5155fbeebef9e57c2926f910375de', 'b4e58098ddc365c5552b862a0113a228a093c4d0e43777c907381a6a46a6e046', '18586b4a34af8afb3b19ff32c04e0b7b2f961021e15338b0a5a3ccafbea3e89f', 'eda485aa07899ce4cc9c22d814ca5a92456c0ba570795dc4ce791e8bb4e16f79', 'fcbb4b68ae78c4ce9cca6d03e0f62a1b8515b67ad1bc512e0d4857a6b428fb55', '4a07c00a2ef0ed6df53d67d4748692a7f5c92d154b8316731024f3bad52df550', 'f26b50ed804ba5111d76706f92b83072518815ec945b0054da2495f47279287a', '7c29d182df52ad8a912d64a1a9fa6feee494e1142ce6abeb5c37c626b5e5590f'] A packet elimination function. {64: 1, 37: 1, 67: 1, 53: 1, 80: 1, 33: 1, 68: 1, 79: 1, 25: 1, 51: 1, 69: 1, 130: 2, 112: 2, 55: 2, 62: 2, 38: 2, 127: 3, 91: 2, 52: 3} {14: 1, 17: 1, 56: 1, 66: 1, 185: 1, 192: 1, 278: 1, 279: 1, 280: 1, 294: 1, 308: 1, 322: 1, 389: 1, 390: 1, 406: 1, 380: 1, 0: 2, 135: 2, 142: 2, 400: 2, 399: 2, 19: 2, 149: 2, 281: 2, 296: 2, 45: 2, 196: 4, 197: 3, 324: 2, 77: 2, 78: 2, 337: 3, 216: 2, 255: 2} {0, 389, 390, 135, 142, 14, 400, 17, 399, 19, 149, 406, 279, 280, 281, 278, 294, 296, 45, 308, 56, 185, 192, 321, 322, 66, 196, 197, 324, 77, 78, 337, 216, 380, 255} 52 Packet Replication Function. Similar structure and changes as in IP over TSN . Service protection interworking is out - of - scope . d275ba154e2b7c82eb3ec9175d790214b0e60d3f d275ba154e2b7c82eb3ec9175d790214b0e60d3f draft-ietf-detnet-mpls-over-tsn fcbb4b68ae78c4ce9cca6d03e0f62a1b8515b67ad1bc512e0d4857a6b428fb55 ['cae70a041f2bb7a437801975d64fbc6aa981e51be14ad7536d6a022d294d2c70', '101d6488f0f475a04aa297b74fc9f2861a180e4eb1a083da451550a5788c81e8', 'b8d8f64f0f09d4c8fa40ff054a5f0e468afa79876dab10bea529c2c1e1430fbc', '798866c5ba6606c0230b5e31f7d949471ef699d268b844c3bf0c994e96864245', 'b205fa18b546a1f8079fdb24ae479d6824e7893fbc50608c283e46c6f8365253', 'c2441bad9168c35aef67c82d8c8ca1d32bfa5f2bd7b4e3fdcb0c74913367661f', '09f6b6a812132eee463de5625d44082094351e5e01c90e0e4dc14d2893ef6a38', '45bc601f4e7c8b80cc0c429fc5273808e88ddf7f6b0c7053a4c557e2c279a10d', '890a229745f78c3232f7d204d42fe7c17d51066efd5ca3f47c9011e956d120d6', '10f9a5c80140ddc029e2cc8bd11a50566e91cd86859e72018aaba5e3aa63710c', '0dd575583d4427fd1c98abc06595c8d3719b98bf537e86e8c3f332281f235909', 'bb194dc58a0eb7e52501603ff614fb1131422ca453ab5b879033dd20511649fb', '2a6155467d7734762edcbb115219fa2034b5155fbeebef9e57c2926f910375de', 'b4e58098ddc365c5552b862a0113a228a093c4d0e43777c907381a6a46a6e046', '18586b4a34af8afb3b19ff32c04e0b7b2f961021e15338b0a5a3ccafbea3e89f', 'eda485aa07899ce4cc9c22d814ca5a92456c0ba570795dc4ce791e8bb4e16f79', 'fcbb4b68ae78c4ce9cca6d03e0f62a1b8515b67ad1bc512e0d4857a6b428fb55', '4a07c00a2ef0ed6df53d67d4748692a7f5c92d154b8316731024f3bad52df550', 'f26b50ed804ba5111d76706f92b83072518815ec945b0054da2495f47279287a', '7c29d182df52ad8a912d64a1a9fa6feee494e1142ce6abeb5c37c626b5e5590f'] A packet replication function. {64: 1, 37: 1, 67: 1, 53: 1, 80: 1, 33: 1, 68: 1, 79: 1, 25: 1, 51: 1, 69: 1, 130: 2, 112: 2, 55: 2, 62: 2, 38: 2, 127: 3, 91: 2, 52: 3} {14: 1, 17: 1, 56: 1, 66: 1, 185: 1, 192: 1, 278: 1, 279: 1, 280: 1, 294: 1, 308: 1, 322: 1, 389: 1, 390: 1, 406: 1, 380: 1, 0: 2, 135: 2, 142: 2, 400: 2, 399: 2, 19: 2, 149: 2, 281: 2, 296: 2, 45: 2, 196: 4, 197: 3, 324: 2, 77: 2, 78: 2, 337: 3, 216: 2, 255: 2} {0, 389, 390, 135, 142, 14, 400, 17, 399, 19, 149, 406, 279, 280, 281, 278, 294, 296, 45, 308, 56, 185, 192, 321, 322, 66, 196, 197, 324, 77, 78, 337, 216, 380, 255} 52 Packet Ordering Function. Similar structure and changes as in IP over TSN . Service protection interworking is out - of - scope . d275ba154e2b7c82eb3ec9175d790214b0e60d3f d275ba154e2b7c82eb3ec9175d790214b0e60d3f draft-ietf-detnet-mpls-over-tsn 45bc601f4e7c8b80cc0c429fc5273808e88ddf7f6b0c7053a4c557e2c279a10d ['cae70a041f2bb7a437801975d64fbc6aa981e51be14ad7536d6a022d294d2c70', '101d6488f0f475a04aa297b74fc9f2861a180e4eb1a083da451550a5788c81e8', 'b8d8f64f0f09d4c8fa40ff054a5f0e468afa79876dab10bea529c2c1e1430fbc', '798866c5ba6606c0230b5e31f7d949471ef699d268b844c3bf0c994e96864245', 'b205fa18b546a1f8079fdb24ae479d6824e7893fbc50608c283e46c6f8365253', 'c2441bad9168c35aef67c82d8c8ca1d32bfa5f2bd7b4e3fdcb0c74913367661f', '09f6b6a812132eee463de5625d44082094351e5e01c90e0e4dc14d2893ef6a38', '45bc601f4e7c8b80cc0c429fc5273808e88ddf7f6b0c7053a4c557e2c279a10d', '890a229745f78c3232f7d204d42fe7c17d51066efd5ca3f47c9011e956d120d6', '10f9a5c80140ddc029e2cc8bd11a50566e91cd86859e72018aaba5e3aa63710c', '0dd575583d4427fd1c98abc06595c8d3719b98bf537e86e8c3f332281f235909', 'bb194dc58a0eb7e52501603ff614fb1131422ca453ab5b879033dd20511649fb', '2a6155467d7734762edcbb115219fa2034b5155fbeebef9e57c2926f910375de', 'b4e58098ddc365c5552b862a0113a228a093c4d0e43777c907381a6a46a6e046', '18586b4a34af8afb3b19ff32c04e0b7b2f961021e15338b0a5a3ccafbea3e89f', 'eda485aa07899ce4cc9c22d814ca5a92456c0ba570795dc4ce791e8bb4e16f79', 'fcbb4b68ae78c4ce9cca6d03e0f62a1b8515b67ad1bc512e0d4857a6b428fb55', '4a07c00a2ef0ed6df53d67d4748692a7f5c92d154b8316731024f3bad52df550', 'f26b50ed804ba5111d76706f92b83072518815ec945b0054da2495f47279287a', '7c29d182df52ad8a912d64a1a9fa6feee494e1142ce6abeb5c37c626b5e5590f'] A packet ordering function. {64: 1, 37: 1, 67: 1, 53: 1, 80: 1, 33: 1, 68: 1, 79: 1, 25: 1, 51: 1, 69: 1, 130: 2, 112: 2, 55: 2, 62: 2, 38: 2, 127: 3, 91: 2, 52: 3} {14: 1, 17: 1, 56: 1, 66: 1, 185: 1, 192: 1, 278: 1, 279: 1, 280: 1, 294: 1, 308: 1, 322: 1, 389: 1, 390: 1, 406: 1, 380: 1, 0: 2, 135: 2, 142: 2, 400: 2, 399: 2, 19: 2, 149: 2, 281: 2, 296: 2, 45: 2, 196: 4, 197: 3, 324: 2, 77: 2, 78: 2, 337: 3, 216: 2, 255: 2} {0, 389, 390, 135, 142, 14, 400, 17, 399, 19, 149, 406, 279, 280, 281, 278, 294, 296, 45, 308, 56, 185, 192, 321, 322, 66, 196, 197, 324, 77, 78, 337, 216, 380, 255} 52 Quality of Service. Similar structure and changes as in IP over TSN . Service protection interworking is out - of - scope . d275ba154e2b7c82eb3ec9175d790214b0e60d3f d275ba154e2b7c82eb3ec9175d790214b0e60d3f draft-ietf-detnet-mpls-over-tsn 09f6b6a812132eee463de5625d44082094351e5e01c90e0e4dc14d2893ef6a38 ['cae70a041f2bb7a437801975d64fbc6aa981e51be14ad7536d6a022d294d2c70', '101d6488f0f475a04aa297b74fc9f2861a180e4eb1a083da451550a5788c81e8', 'b8d8f64f0f09d4c8fa40ff054a5f0e468afa79876dab10bea529c2c1e1430fbc', '798866c5ba6606c0230b5e31f7d949471ef699d268b844c3bf0c994e96864245', 'b205fa18b546a1f8079fdb24ae479d6824e7893fbc50608c283e46c6f8365253', 'c2441bad9168c35aef67c82d8c8ca1d32bfa5f2bd7b4e3fdcb0c74913367661f', '09f6b6a812132eee463de5625d44082094351e5e01c90e0e4dc14d2893ef6a38', '45bc601f4e7c8b80cc0c429fc5273808e88ddf7f6b0c7053a4c557e2c279a10d', '890a229745f78c3232f7d204d42fe7c17d51066efd5ca3f47c9011e956d120d6', '10f9a5c80140ddc029e2cc8bd11a50566e91cd86859e72018aaba5e3aa63710c', '0dd575583d4427fd1c98abc06595c8d3719b98bf537e86e8c3f332281f235909', 'bb194dc58a0eb7e52501603ff614fb1131422ca453ab5b879033dd20511649fb', '2a6155467d7734762edcbb115219fa2034b5155fbeebef9e57c2926f910375de', 'b4e58098ddc365c5552b862a0113a228a093c4d0e43777c907381a6a46a6e046', '18586b4a34af8afb3b19ff32c04e0b7b2f961021e15338b0a5a3ccafbea3e89f', 'eda485aa07899ce4cc9c22d814ca5a92456c0ba570795dc4ce791e8bb4e16f79', 'fcbb4b68ae78c4ce9cca6d03e0f62a1b8515b67ad1bc512e0d4857a6b428fb55', '4a07c00a2ef0ed6df53d67d4748692a7f5c92d154b8316731024f3bad52df550', 'f26b50ed804ba5111d76706f92b83072518815ec945b0054da2495f47279287a', '7c29d182df52ad8a912d64a1a9fa6feee494e1142ce6abeb5c37c626b5e5590f'] A quality of service. {64: 1, 37: 1, 67: 1, 53: 1, 80: 1, 33: 1, 68: 1, 79: 1, 25: 1, 51: 1, 69: 1, 130: 2, 112: 2, 55: 2, 62: 2, 38: 2, 127: 3, 91: 2, 52: 3} {14: 1, 17: 1, 56: 1, 66: 1, 185: 1, 192: 1, 278: 1, 279: 1, 280: 1, 294: 1, 308: 1, 322: 1, 389: 1, 390: 1, 406: 1, 380: 1, 0: 2, 135: 2, 142: 2, 400: 2, 399: 2, 19: 2, 149: 2, 281: 2, 296: 2, 45: 2, 196: 4, 197: 3, 324: 2, 77: 2, 78: 2, 337: 3, 216: 2, 255: 2} {0, 389, 390, 135, 142, 14, 400, 17, 399, 19, 149, 406, 279, 280, 281, 278, 294, 296, 45, 308, 56, 185, 192, 321, 322, 66, 196, 197, 324, 77, 78, 337, 216, 380, 255} 52 "This document uses the terminology established in the DetNet architecture I-D.ietf-detnet-architecture and I-D.ietf-detnet-mpls, and the reader is assumed to be familiar with that document and its terminology." Similar structure and changes as in IP over TSN . Service protection interworking is out - of - scope . d275ba154e2b7c82eb3ec9175d790214b0e60d3f d275ba154e2b7c82eb3ec9175d790214b0e60d3f draft-ietf-detnet-mpls-over-tsn 0dd575583d4427fd1c98abc06595c8d3719b98bf537e86e8c3f332281f235909 ['cae70a041f2bb7a437801975d64fbc6aa981e51be14ad7536d6a022d294d2c70', '101d6488f0f475a04aa297b74fc9f2861a180e4eb1a083da451550a5788c81e8', 'b8d8f64f0f09d4c8fa40ff054a5f0e468afa79876dab10bea529c2c1e1430fbc', '798866c5ba6606c0230b5e31f7d949471ef699d268b844c3bf0c994e96864245', 'b205fa18b546a1f8079fdb24ae479d6824e7893fbc50608c283e46c6f8365253', 'c2441bad9168c35aef67c82d8c8ca1d32bfa5f2bd7b4e3fdcb0c74913367661f', '09f6b6a812132eee463de5625d44082094351e5e01c90e0e4dc14d2893ef6a38', '45bc601f4e7c8b80cc0c429fc5273808e88ddf7f6b0c7053a4c557e2c279a10d', '890a229745f78c3232f7d204d42fe7c17d51066efd5ca3f47c9011e956d120d6', '10f9a5c80140ddc029e2cc8bd11a50566e91cd86859e72018aaba5e3aa63710c', '0dd575583d4427fd1c98abc06595c8d3719b98bf537e86e8c3f332281f235909', 'bb194dc58a0eb7e52501603ff614fb1131422ca453ab5b879033dd20511649fb', '2a6155467d7734762edcbb115219fa2034b5155fbeebef9e57c2926f910375de', 'b4e58098ddc365c5552b862a0113a228a093c4d0e43777c907381a6a46a6e046', '18586b4a34af8afb3b19ff32c04e0b7b2f961021e15338b0a5a3ccafbea3e89f', 'eda485aa07899ce4cc9c22d814ca5a92456c0ba570795dc4ce791e8bb4e16f79', 'fcbb4b68ae78c4ce9cca6d03e0f62a1b8515b67ad1bc512e0d4857a6b428fb55', '4a07c00a2ef0ed6df53d67d4748692a7f5c92d154b8316731024f3bad52df550', 'f26b50ed804ba5111d76706f92b83072518815ec945b0054da2495f47279287a', '7c29d182df52ad8a912d64a1a9fa6feee494e1142ce6abeb5c37c626b5e5590f'] B "this document uses the terminology established in the detnet architecture i-d.ietf-detnet-architecture and i-d.ietf-detnet-mpls, and the reader is assumed to be familiar with that document and its terminology." {64: 1, 37: 1, 67: 1, 53: 1, 80: 1, 33: 1, 68: 1, 79: 1, 25: 1, 51: 1, 69: 1, 130: 2, 112: 2, 55: 2, 62: 2, 38: 2, 127: 3, 91: 2, 52: 3} {14: 1, 17: 1, 56: 1, 66: 1, 185: 1, 192: 1, 278: 1, 279: 1, 280: 1, 294: 1, 308: 1, 322: 1, 389: 1, 390: 1, 406: 1, 380: 1, 0: 2, 135: 2, 142: 2, 400: 2, 399: 2, 19: 2, 149: 2, 281: 2, 296: 2, 45: 2, 196: 4, 197: 3, 324: 2, 77: 2, 78: 2, 337: 3, 216: 2, 255: 2} {0, 389, 390, 135, 142, 14, 400, 17, 399, 19, 149, 406, 279, 280, 281, 278, 294, 296, 45, 308, 56, 185, 192, 321, 322, 66, 196, 197, 324, 77, 78, 337, 216, 380, 255} 52 Frame Replication and Elimination for Redundancy (TSN function). Similar structure and changes as in IP over TSN . Service protection interworking is out - of - scope . d275ba154e2b7c82eb3ec9175d790214b0e60d3f d275ba154e2b7c82eb3ec9175d790214b0e60d3f draft-ietf-detnet-mpls-over-tsn 7c29d182df52ad8a912d64a1a9fa6feee494e1142ce6abeb5c37c626b5e5590f ['cae70a041f2bb7a437801975d64fbc6aa981e51be14ad7536d6a022d294d2c70', '101d6488f0f475a04aa297b74fc9f2861a180e4eb1a083da451550a5788c81e8', 'b8d8f64f0f09d4c8fa40ff054a5f0e468afa79876dab10bea529c2c1e1430fbc', '798866c5ba6606c0230b5e31f7d949471ef699d268b844c3bf0c994e96864245', 'b205fa18b546a1f8079fdb24ae479d6824e7893fbc50608c283e46c6f8365253', 'c2441bad9168c35aef67c82d8c8ca1d32bfa5f2bd7b4e3fdcb0c74913367661f', '09f6b6a812132eee463de5625d44082094351e5e01c90e0e4dc14d2893ef6a38', '45bc601f4e7c8b80cc0c429fc5273808e88ddf7f6b0c7053a4c557e2c279a10d', '890a229745f78c3232f7d204d42fe7c17d51066efd5ca3f47c9011e956d120d6', '10f9a5c80140ddc029e2cc8bd11a50566e91cd86859e72018aaba5e3aa63710c', '0dd575583d4427fd1c98abc06595c8d3719b98bf537e86e8c3f332281f235909', 'bb194dc58a0eb7e52501603ff614fb1131422ca453ab5b879033dd20511649fb', '2a6155467d7734762edcbb115219fa2034b5155fbeebef9e57c2926f910375de', 'b4e58098ddc365c5552b862a0113a228a093c4d0e43777c907381a6a46a6e046', '18586b4a34af8afb3b19ff32c04e0b7b2f961021e15338b0a5a3ccafbea3e89f', 'eda485aa07899ce4cc9c22d814ca5a92456c0ba570795dc4ce791e8bb4e16f79', 'fcbb4b68ae78c4ce9cca6d03e0f62a1b8515b67ad1bc512e0d4857a6b428fb55', '4a07c00a2ef0ed6df53d67d4748692a7f5c92d154b8316731024f3bad52df550', 'f26b50ed804ba5111d76706f92b83072518815ec945b0054da2495f47279287a', '7c29d182df52ad8a912d64a1a9fa6feee494e1142ce6abeb5c37c626b5e5590f'] B frame replication and elimination for redundancy (tsn function). {64: 1, 37: 1, 67: 1, 53: 1, 80: 1, 33: 1, 68: 1, 79: 1, 25: 1, 51: 1, 69: 1, 130: 2, 112: 2, 55: 2, 62: 2, 38: 2, 127: 3, 91: 2, 52: 3} {14: 1, 17: 1, 56: 1, 66: 1, 185: 1, 192: 1, 278: 1, 279: 1, 280: 1, 294: 1, 308: 1, 322: 1, 389: 1, 390: 1, 406: 1, 380: 1, 0: 2, 135: 2, 142: 2, 400: 2, 399: 2, 19: 2, 149: 2, 281: 2, 296: 2, 45: 2, 196: 4, 197: 3, 324: 2, 77: 2, 78: 2, 337: 3, 216: 2, 255: 2} {0, 389, 390, 135, 142, 14, 400, 17, 399, 19, 149, 406, 279, 280, 281, 278, 294, 296, 45, 308, 56, 185, 192, 321, 322, 66, 196, 197, 324, 77, 78, 337, 216, 380, 255} 52 "This document describes how DetNet flows are carried over MPLS networks. The DetNet Architecture, I-D.ietf-detnet-architecture, decomposes the DetNet data plane into two sub-layers: a service sub- layer and a forwarding sub-layer. The basic approach defined in this document supports the DetNet service sub-layer based on existing pseudowire (PW) encapsulations and mechanisms, and supports the DetNet forwarding sub-layer based on existing MPLS Traffic Engineering encapsulations and mechanisms. Background on PWs can be found in RFC3985 and RFC3031. Background on MPLS Traffic Engineering can be found in RFC3272 and RFC3209." Similar structure and changes as in IP over TSN . Service protection interworking is out - of - scope . d275ba154e2b7c82eb3ec9175d790214b0e60d3f d275ba154e2b7c82eb3ec9175d790214b0e60d3f draft-ietf-detnet-mpls-over-tsn 9537894e1c642eff3f099a1881c86799b556150edfa05ff44410285165129be2 ['e746630d4b45cf2b654a14e4daaa03ad634e33d92c29c489e3ef3fcd5620c311', '637ea1303af6b2ff10f9cfa757988a4357da6157d1fda71fd217c09910140ab0', '036924b2c261414b33a4346c3369255f44575217102da8df6432a73ec228d1b8', '9537894e1c642eff3f099a1881c86799b556150edfa05ff44410285165129be2', '2d8fce3963de03360a5d98758067925a60474b5430fd8091fc72f3c50a9d38e5'] A "this document describes how detnet flows are carried over mpls networks. the detnet architecture, i-d.ietf-detnet-architecture, decomposes the detnet data plane into two sub-layers: a service sub- layer and a forwarding sub-layer. the basic approach defined in this document supports the detnet service sub-layer based on existing pseudowire (pw) encapsulations and mechanisms, and supports the detnet forwarding sub-layer based on existing mpls traffic engineering encapsulations and mechanisms. background on pws can be found in rfc3985 and rfc3031. background on mpls traffic engineering can be found in rfc3272 and rfc3209." {130: 1, 53: 1, 6: 2, 79: 2, 90: 3, 51: 3, 62: 5, 85: 5, 68: 4, 35: 3, 110: 3, 91: 5, 114: 3, 97: 3, 31: 3, 13: 3, 67: 3, 38: 4, 26: 3, 124: 3, 98: 2, 54: 2, 127: 3, 8: 2, 96: 3, 64: 2, 30: 4, 61: 5, 55: 3, 27: 4, 15: 3, 52: 2, 129: 3, 115: 3, 84: 3, 76: 6, 87: 3, 131: 5, 102: 3, 113: 5, 99: 2, 36: 3, 24: 2, 72: 4} {241: 1, 369: 1, 1: 9, 4: 2, 9: 5, 10: 3, 15: 3, 24: 2, 25: 5, 26: 5, 27: 3, 39: 5, 43: 3, 49: 6, 50: 5, 58: 5, 59: 2, 64: 3, 69: 4, 81: 6, 82: 4, 86: 3, 96: 4, 97: 3, 100: 7, 108: 3, 109: 4, 110: 4, 111: 2, 114: 3, 115: 4, 116: 3, 118: 6, 119: 5, 120: 3, 121: 4, 122: 4, 123: 3, 124: 4, 128: 4, 129: 4, 130: 5, 132: 4, 136: 2, 145: 4, 147: 4, 151: 4, 152: 4, 154: 3, 156: 2, 161: 3, 162: 3, 165: 3, 168: 4, 169: 3, 172: 3, 180: 4, 184: 5, 187: 5, 188: 4, 191: 3, 194: 4, 202: 5, 203: 6, 206: 2, 207: 3, 215: 2, 217: 3, 218: 8, 220: 2, 221: 2, 222: 5, 224: 3, 227: 5, 229: 3, 234: 5, 235: 2, 242: 2, 243: 4, 244: 4, 245: 4, 248: 4, 250: 4, 258: 11, 262: 4, 263: 5, 264: 3, 267: 4, 270: 3, 272: 3, 273: 5, 287: 3, 289: 3, 291: 5, 299: 5, 300: 3, 304: 3, 309: 3, 314: 2, 315: 3, 320: 4, 323: 4, 327: 4, 328: 3, 329: 2, 330: 10, 334: 2, 335: 3, 341: 5, 342: 6, 347: 5, 348: 5, 350: 7, 351: 5, 352: 3, 353: 3, 354: 2, 358: 4, 365: 3, 371: 7, 372: 5, 376: 2, 384: 5, 385: 4, 386: 3, 387: 3, 392: 3, 393: 4, 396: 6, 397: 7, 398: 6, 402: 3} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 52 "The DetNet MPLS data plane approach defined in this document is shown in dn_mpls_dp_approach. The service sub-layer is supported by a DetNet control word (d-CW) which conforms to the Generic PW MPLS Control Word (PWMCW) defined in RFC4385. A d-CW identifying service label (S-Label) is also used." Similar structure and changes as in IP over TSN . Service protection interworking is out - of - scope . d275ba154e2b7c82eb3ec9175d790214b0e60d3f d275ba154e2b7c82eb3ec9175d790214b0e60d3f draft-ietf-detnet-mpls-over-tsn 036924b2c261414b33a4346c3369255f44575217102da8df6432a73ec228d1b8 ['e746630d4b45cf2b654a14e4daaa03ad634e33d92c29c489e3ef3fcd5620c311', '637ea1303af6b2ff10f9cfa757988a4357da6157d1fda71fd217c09910140ab0', '036924b2c261414b33a4346c3369255f44575217102da8df6432a73ec228d1b8', '9537894e1c642eff3f099a1881c86799b556150edfa05ff44410285165129be2', '2d8fce3963de03360a5d98758067925a60474b5430fd8091fc72f3c50a9d38e5'] A "the detnet mpls data plane approach defined in this document is shown in dn_mpls_dp_approach. the service sub-layer is supported by a detnet control word (d-cw) which conforms to the generic pw mpls control word (pwmcw) defined in rfc4385. a d-cw identifying service label (s-label) is also used." {130: 1, 53: 1, 6: 2, 79: 2, 90: 3, 51: 3, 62: 5, 85: 5, 68: 4, 35: 3, 110: 3, 91: 5, 114: 3, 97: 3, 31: 3, 13: 3, 67: 3, 38: 4, 26: 3, 124: 3, 98: 2, 54: 2, 127: 3, 8: 2, 96: 3, 64: 2, 30: 4, 61: 5, 55: 3, 27: 4, 15: 3, 52: 2, 129: 3, 115: 3, 84: 3, 76: 6, 87: 3, 131: 5, 102: 3, 113: 5, 99: 2, 36: 3, 24: 2, 72: 4} {241: 1, 369: 1, 1: 9, 4: 2, 9: 5, 10: 3, 15: 3, 24: 2, 25: 5, 26: 5, 27: 3, 39: 5, 43: 3, 49: 6, 50: 5, 58: 5, 59: 2, 64: 3, 69: 4, 81: 6, 82: 4, 86: 3, 96: 4, 97: 3, 100: 7, 108: 3, 109: 4, 110: 4, 111: 2, 114: 3, 115: 4, 116: 3, 118: 6, 119: 5, 120: 3, 121: 4, 122: 4, 123: 3, 124: 4, 128: 4, 129: 4, 130: 5, 132: 4, 136: 2, 145: 4, 147: 4, 151: 4, 152: 4, 154: 3, 156: 2, 161: 3, 162: 3, 165: 3, 168: 4, 169: 3, 172: 3, 180: 4, 184: 5, 187: 5, 188: 4, 191: 3, 194: 4, 202: 5, 203: 6, 206: 2, 207: 3, 215: 2, 217: 3, 218: 8, 220: 2, 221: 2, 222: 5, 224: 3, 227: 5, 229: 3, 234: 5, 235: 2, 242: 2, 243: 4, 244: 4, 245: 4, 248: 4, 250: 4, 258: 11, 262: 4, 263: 5, 264: 3, 267: 4, 270: 3, 272: 3, 273: 5, 287: 3, 289: 3, 291: 5, 299: 5, 300: 3, 304: 3, 309: 3, 314: 2, 315: 3, 320: 4, 323: 4, 327: 4, 328: 3, 329: 2, 330: 10, 334: 2, 335: 3, 341: 5, 342: 6, 347: 5, 348: 5, 350: 7, 351: 5, 352: 3, 353: 3, 354: 2, 358: 4, 365: 3, 371: 7, 372: 5, 376: 2, 384: 5, 385: 4, 386: 3, 387: 3, 392: 3, 393: 4, 396: 6, 397: 7, 398: 6, 402: 3} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 52 "A node operating on a DetNet flow in the Detnet service sub-layer, i.e. a node processing a DetNet packet which has the S-Label as top of stack uses the local context associated with that S-Label, for example a received F-Label, to determine what local DetNet operation(s) are applied to that packet. An S-Label may be unique when taken from the platform label space RFC3031, which would enable correct DetNet flow identification regardless of which input interface or LSP the packet arrives on." Similar structure and changes as in IP over TSN . Service protection interworking is out - of - scope . d275ba154e2b7c82eb3ec9175d790214b0e60d3f d275ba154e2b7c82eb3ec9175d790214b0e60d3f draft-ietf-detnet-mpls-over-tsn 637ea1303af6b2ff10f9cfa757988a4357da6157d1fda71fd217c09910140ab0 ['e746630d4b45cf2b654a14e4daaa03ad634e33d92c29c489e3ef3fcd5620c311', '637ea1303af6b2ff10f9cfa757988a4357da6157d1fda71fd217c09910140ab0', '036924b2c261414b33a4346c3369255f44575217102da8df6432a73ec228d1b8', '9537894e1c642eff3f099a1881c86799b556150edfa05ff44410285165129be2', '2d8fce3963de03360a5d98758067925a60474b5430fd8091fc72f3c50a9d38e5'] A "a node operating on a detnet flow in the detnet service sub-layer, i.e. a node processing a detnet packet which has the s-label as top of stack uses the local context associated with that s-label, for example a received f-label, to determine what local detnet operation(s) are applied to that packet. an s-label may be unique when taken from the platform label space rfc3031, which would enable correct detnet flow identification regardless of which input interface or lsp the packet arrives on." {130: 1, 53: 1, 6: 2, 79: 2, 90: 3, 51: 3, 62: 5, 85: 5, 68: 4, 35: 3, 110: 3, 91: 5, 114: 3, 97: 3, 31: 3, 13: 3, 67: 3, 38: 4, 26: 3, 124: 3, 98: 2, 54: 2, 127: 3, 8: 2, 96: 3, 64: 2, 30: 4, 61: 5, 55: 3, 27: 4, 15: 3, 52: 2, 129: 3, 115: 3, 84: 3, 76: 6, 87: 3, 131: 5, 102: 3, 113: 5, 99: 2, 36: 3, 24: 2, 72: 4} {241: 1, 369: 1, 1: 9, 4: 2, 9: 5, 10: 3, 15: 3, 24: 2, 25: 5, 26: 5, 27: 3, 39: 5, 43: 3, 49: 6, 50: 5, 58: 5, 59: 2, 64: 3, 69: 4, 81: 6, 82: 4, 86: 3, 96: 4, 97: 3, 100: 7, 108: 3, 109: 4, 110: 4, 111: 2, 114: 3, 115: 4, 116: 3, 118: 6, 119: 5, 120: 3, 121: 4, 122: 4, 123: 3, 124: 4, 128: 4, 129: 4, 130: 5, 132: 4, 136: 2, 145: 4, 147: 4, 151: 4, 152: 4, 154: 3, 156: 2, 161: 3, 162: 3, 165: 3, 168: 4, 169: 3, 172: 3, 180: 4, 184: 5, 187: 5, 188: 4, 191: 3, 194: 4, 202: 5, 203: 6, 206: 2, 207: 3, 215: 2, 217: 3, 218: 8, 220: 2, 221: 2, 222: 5, 224: 3, 227: 5, 229: 3, 234: 5, 235: 2, 242: 2, 243: 4, 244: 4, 245: 4, 248: 4, 250: 4, 258: 11, 262: 4, 263: 5, 264: 3, 267: 4, 270: 3, 272: 3, 273: 5, 287: 3, 289: 3, 291: 5, 299: 5, 300: 3, 304: 3, 309: 3, 314: 2, 315: 3, 320: 4, 323: 4, 327: 4, 328: 3, 329: 2, 330: 10, 334: 2, 335: 3, 341: 5, 342: 6, 347: 5, 348: 5, 350: 7, 351: 5, 352: 3, 353: 3, 354: 2, 358: 4, 365: 3, 371: 7, 372: 5, 376: 2, 384: 5, 385: 4, 386: 3, 387: 3, 392: 3, 393: 4, 396: 6, 397: 7, 398: 6, 402: 3} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 52 "The basic approach defined in I-D.ietf-detnet-mpls supports the DetNet service sub-layer based on existing pseudowire (PW) encapsulations and mechanisms, and supports the DetNet forwarding sub-layer based on existing MPLS Traffic Engineering encapsulations and mechanisms." Similar structure and changes as in IP over TSN . Service protection interworking is out - of - scope . d275ba154e2b7c82eb3ec9175d790214b0e60d3f d275ba154e2b7c82eb3ec9175d790214b0e60d3f draft-ietf-detnet-mpls-over-tsn 2d8fce3963de03360a5d98758067925a60474b5430fd8091fc72f3c50a9d38e5 ['e746630d4b45cf2b654a14e4daaa03ad634e33d92c29c489e3ef3fcd5620c311', '637ea1303af6b2ff10f9cfa757988a4357da6157d1fda71fd217c09910140ab0', '036924b2c261414b33a4346c3369255f44575217102da8df6432a73ec228d1b8', '9537894e1c642eff3f099a1881c86799b556150edfa05ff44410285165129be2', '2d8fce3963de03360a5d98758067925a60474b5430fd8091fc72f3c50a9d38e5'] B "the basic approach defined in i-d.ietf-detnet-mpls supports the detnet service sub-layer based on existing pseudowire (pw) encapsulations and mechanisms, and supports the detnet forwarding sub-layer based on existing mpls traffic engineering encapsulations and mechanisms." {130: 1, 53: 1, 6: 2, 79: 2, 90: 3, 51: 3, 62: 5, 85: 5, 68: 4, 35: 3, 110: 3, 91: 5, 114: 3, 97: 3, 31: 3, 13: 3, 67: 3, 38: 4, 26: 3, 124: 3, 98: 2, 54: 2, 127: 3, 8: 2, 96: 3, 64: 2, 30: 4, 61: 5, 55: 3, 27: 4, 15: 3, 52: 2, 129: 3, 115: 3, 84: 3, 76: 6, 87: 3, 131: 5, 102: 3, 113: 5, 99: 2, 36: 3, 24: 2, 72: 4} {241: 1, 369: 1, 1: 9, 4: 2, 9: 5, 10: 3, 15: 3, 24: 2, 25: 5, 26: 5, 27: 3, 39: 5, 43: 3, 49: 6, 50: 5, 58: 5, 59: 2, 64: 3, 69: 4, 81: 6, 82: 4, 86: 3, 96: 4, 97: 3, 100: 7, 108: 3, 109: 4, 110: 4, 111: 2, 114: 3, 115: 4, 116: 3, 118: 6, 119: 5, 120: 3, 121: 4, 122: 4, 123: 3, 124: 4, 128: 4, 129: 4, 130: 5, 132: 4, 136: 2, 145: 4, 147: 4, 151: 4, 152: 4, 154: 3, 156: 2, 161: 3, 162: 3, 165: 3, 168: 4, 169: 3, 172: 3, 180: 4, 184: 5, 187: 5, 188: 4, 191: 3, 194: 4, 202: 5, 203: 6, 206: 2, 207: 3, 215: 2, 217: 3, 218: 8, 220: 2, 221: 2, 222: 5, 224: 3, 227: 5, 229: 3, 234: 5, 235: 2, 242: 2, 243: 4, 244: 4, 245: 4, 248: 4, 250: 4, 258: 11, 262: 4, 263: 5, 264: 3, 267: 4, 270: 3, 272: 3, 273: 5, 287: 3, 289: 3, 291: 5, 299: 5, 300: 3, 304: 3, 309: 3, 314: 2, 315: 3, 320: 4, 323: 4, 327: 4, 328: 3, 329: 2, 330: 10, 334: 2, 335: 3, 341: 5, 342: 6, 347: 5, 348: 5, 350: 7, 351: 5, 352: 3, 353: 3, 354: 2, 358: 4, 365: 3, 371: 7, 372: 5, 376: 2, 384: 5, 385: 4, 386: 3, 387: 3, 392: 3, 393: 4, 396: 6, 397: 7, 398: 6, 402: 3} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 52 "A node operating on a DetNet flow in the Detnet service sub-layer, i.e. a node processing a DetNet packet which has the S-Label as top of stack uses the local context associated with that S-Label, for example a received F-Label, to determine what local DetNet operation(s) are applied to that packet. An S-Label may be unique when taken from the platform label space RFC3031, which would enable correct DetNet flow identification regardless of which input interface or LSP the packet arrives on. The service sub-layer functions (i.e., PREOF) use a DetNet control word (d-CW)." Similar structure and changes as in IP over TSN . Service protection interworking is out - of - scope . d275ba154e2b7c82eb3ec9175d790214b0e60d3f d275ba154e2b7c82eb3ec9175d790214b0e60d3f draft-ietf-detnet-mpls-over-tsn e746630d4b45cf2b654a14e4daaa03ad634e33d92c29c489e3ef3fcd5620c311 ['e746630d4b45cf2b654a14e4daaa03ad634e33d92c29c489e3ef3fcd5620c311', '637ea1303af6b2ff10f9cfa757988a4357da6157d1fda71fd217c09910140ab0', '036924b2c261414b33a4346c3369255f44575217102da8df6432a73ec228d1b8', '9537894e1c642eff3f099a1881c86799b556150edfa05ff44410285165129be2', '2d8fce3963de03360a5d98758067925a60474b5430fd8091fc72f3c50a9d38e5'] B "a node operating on a detnet flow in the detnet service sub-layer, i.e. a node processing a detnet packet which has the s-label as top of stack uses the local context associated with that s-label, for example a received f-label, to determine what local detnet operation(s) are applied to that packet. an s-label may be unique when taken from the platform label space rfc3031, which would enable correct detnet flow identification regardless of which input interface or lsp the packet arrives on. the service sub-layer functions (i.e., preof) use a detnet control word (d-cw)." {130: 1, 53: 1, 6: 2, 79: 2, 90: 3, 51: 3, 62: 5, 85: 5, 68: 4, 35: 3, 110: 3, 91: 5, 114: 3, 97: 3, 31: 3, 13: 3, 67: 3, 38: 4, 26: 3, 124: 3, 98: 2, 54: 2, 127: 3, 8: 2, 96: 3, 64: 2, 30: 4, 61: 5, 55: 3, 27: 4, 15: 3, 52: 2, 129: 3, 115: 3, 84: 3, 76: 6, 87: 3, 131: 5, 102: 3, 113: 5, 99: 2, 36: 3, 24: 2, 72: 4} {241: 1, 369: 1, 1: 9, 4: 2, 9: 5, 10: 3, 15: 3, 24: 2, 25: 5, 26: 5, 27: 3, 39: 5, 43: 3, 49: 6, 50: 5, 58: 5, 59: 2, 64: 3, 69: 4, 81: 6, 82: 4, 86: 3, 96: 4, 97: 3, 100: 7, 108: 3, 109: 4, 110: 4, 111: 2, 114: 3, 115: 4, 116: 3, 118: 6, 119: 5, 120: 3, 121: 4, 122: 4, 123: 3, 124: 4, 128: 4, 129: 4, 130: 5, 132: 4, 136: 2, 145: 4, 147: 4, 151: 4, 152: 4, 154: 3, 156: 2, 161: 3, 162: 3, 165: 3, 168: 4, 169: 3, 172: 3, 180: 4, 184: 5, 187: 5, 188: 4, 191: 3, 194: 4, 202: 5, 203: 6, 206: 2, 207: 3, 215: 2, 217: 3, 218: 8, 220: 2, 221: 2, 222: 5, 224: 3, 227: 5, 229: 3, 234: 5, 235: 2, 242: 2, 243: 4, 244: 4, 245: 4, 248: 4, 250: 4, 258: 11, 262: 4, 263: 5, 264: 3, 267: 4, 270: 3, 272: 3, 273: 5, 287: 3, 289: 3, 291: 5, 299: 5, 300: 3, 304: 3, 309: 3, 314: 2, 315: 3, 320: 4, 323: 4, 327: 4, 328: 3, 329: 2, 330: 10, 334: 2, 335: 3, 341: 5, 342: 6, 347: 5, 348: 5, 350: 7, 351: 5, 352: 3, 353: 3, 354: 2, 358: 4, 365: 3, 371: 7, 372: 5, 376: 2, 384: 5, 385: 4, 386: 3, 387: 3, 392: 3, 393: 4, 396: 6, 397: 7, 398: 6, 402: 3} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 52 "fig_dn_mpls_detnet illustrates a hypothetical DetNet MPLS-only network composed of DetNet aware MPLS enabled end systems, operating over a DetNet aware MPLS network. In this figure, relay nodes sit at MPLS LSP boundaries and transit nodes are LSRs." Similar structure and changes as in IP over TSN . Service protection interworking is out - of - scope . d275ba154e2b7c82eb3ec9175d790214b0e60d3f d275ba154e2b7c82eb3ec9175d790214b0e60d3f draft-ietf-detnet-mpls-over-tsn 0cf3a218420317d1ac2dbe66fe8b3fa5930ee4bfb0f9a25d7059f70b672356ee ['899fe49efb71ff0aa7ef3f05ac18bd5bfd87fffe13b5c1288db3416e022be147', 'ab93afb1ce53a91a86685ff579055185d9f7a6798d6effa52aec9838538bdf15', '42b1f3f30d1cae8db1fcb526de2f77c170c19e3508250cf37a94100514f567e6', '55bdece02c98962a77682e9b55671178537e5663507c4ff9c5409df14c7a69af', '438eb33c698936afb27ac820b5f68528ff155bd5a6927b63e6259a419be2e1a9', 'ed695265f24af924853cf42b909ea782e13659dd90448b1a4bc4800314d00f86', 'a8ff14472a8fa48bacdc11d7089a9d1054c0a786f6152f510b5d4092c22e121f', '16375944152e6c3e73492437880fe39d7f0123a9292d062e8e9c7d317e4b878f', '1076eab6753435c114e8a720c951b03da6d4e1bbbf1290f8d58ad7f97a0b8c64', '7f7e8733165742e4d8be8dacffe0453045841d70140ba0a9defc1c0d78e8d05c', '44e497e2df0461bad9215c57918855022435eb6e28266916161de3f7902bb352', '0cf3a218420317d1ac2dbe66fe8b3fa5930ee4bfb0f9a25d7059f70b672356ee', 'c2db650dc38549201f151a0fea9030968aca0fd468d0d6d3fe3d9b520ee551e6', '03d4609f1627eb905bc43957db60d2c0ce0b1cf99c6fa8617c936e7170195470', 'f07257d89bd36957d381df4c3d975b976581225d3b0e93b797f231549f809c45', 'cee8a70bcfc00996a87843150f50858ee830d692ae4678e50d5c074d43ff657c', 'b451f1bf9eed3bec2c5e20d4e9122ce6f31202fc68127f2881d2d860e9726365', '5c5fe7e7a382ebc21f89d163deb3520302620f0efe90cedb8592a80b5ef6a394', 'fb2b9389e1455c6d64ae19158396d767d88969013b14075bcfdcc764f610108c', '769d6aec4ab7308875a36f480f397628b2febffed4bc76dc77efd81374577a2f', '36330b0a2474d7598e4665a8ac8b8fbd2c0215a7c2971183879990c1948b22ae', 'ae3bdd3a81d96e4aaa02f7d597a2684146f3af75b743bde8e31c3cf5883707db', 'c63eee4f2d995789dc0fd3300a044e2c8d77d7fd6727e4e7a7bcc637c837d612', '564787d2556d259dabeaa6c5e2a64e9bdbfcf4ff124eb58795eebefb601fdb30', '5324bae9de9c301e9f6c475f9348fb2673813fe613070bb08ffd35c8a0e54204', 'f77d05a1e065348650e7579a3e2688468825cb7764599c8eb0f82836f4f3d9f3', 'a9668d2ded433c7b0eab698458e6b8fd13e4ddabe80417a884a66eda5893de8a', '75621d6a5adc1618337a02bf68856f7e1f8591c46fda003f39100f58bad112e3', '87cbb111ae00db5fad0458158af7d51a3ea8cb3e02e091c32f02ae366900eabb', '26e942b0353fee8f5ac0a2c2e26c9b695c50b35c501eeb4bff343b1648b5cebc', '036168e918418eb807bc3efd361a8e66067192564da41e30e076d22be0f87935', 'a6bd7b8f71e0d959503da2efa6fee412d7e71fb1f54e482a89a61c2a8d6bc691', '9829b13faebde69c2279c38cd54d524aa31acfdcc1cfba7910b9d69caa42e0dd', '2755ae7cda161df0c24e1fa9f1c3308bc9ef81a599d859668490484290ca72f4'] A "fig_dn_mpls_detnet illustrates a hypothetical detnet mpls-only network composed of detnet aware mpls enabled end systems, operating over a detnet aware mpls network. in this figure, relay nodes sit at mpls lsp boundaries and transit nodes are lsrs." {6: 1, 31: 1, 124: 1, 67: 1, 53: 1, 8: 1, 79: 2, 90: 3, 51: 3, 130: 2, 62: 4, 85: 4, 68: 3, 35: 3, 110: 3, 91: 5, 114: 3, 97: 3, 13: 3, 38: 4, 26: 3, 98: 2, 54: 2, 127: 3, 96: 3, 64: 2, 30: 4, 61: 5, 55: 2, 27: 2, 15: 3, 52: 2, 129: 3, 115: 3, 84: 2, 76: 4, 87: 3, 131: 5, 102: 3, 113: 5, 99: 2, 36: 3, 24: 2, 72: 4} {161: 1, 264: 1, 328: 1, 392: 1, 369: 1, 220: 1, 221: 1, 1: 8, 4: 2, 9: 3, 10: 3, 15: 3, 24: 2, 25: 4, 26: 4, 27: 3, 39: 4, 43: 3, 49: 6, 50: 5, 58: 5, 59: 2, 64: 3, 69: 2, 81: 5, 82: 4, 86: 3, 96: 4, 97: 3, 100: 7, 108: 3, 109: 4, 110: 4, 111: 2, 114: 3, 115: 4, 116: 3, 118: 5, 119: 4, 120: 3, 121: 3, 122: 4, 123: 3, 124: 3, 128: 4, 129: 4, 130: 5, 132: 2, 136: 2, 145: 2, 147: 4, 151: 4, 152: 4, 154: 3, 156: 2, 162: 2, 165: 3, 168: 4, 169: 3, 172: 3, 180: 4, 184: 3, 187: 5, 188: 4, 191: 3, 194: 2, 202: 3, 203: 4, 206: 2, 207: 3, 217: 3, 218: 7, 222: 4, 224: 3, 227: 5, 229: 3, 234: 5, 235: 2, 241: 2, 242: 2, 243: 2, 244: 4, 245: 2, 248: 4, 250: 4, 258: 10, 262: 4, 263: 5, 267: 3, 270: 3, 272: 3, 273: 3, 287: 3, 289: 3, 291: 5, 299: 5, 300: 3, 304: 3, 309: 2, 314: 2, 315: 3, 320: 3, 323: 2, 327: 4, 329: 2, 330: 9, 334: 2, 335: 3, 341: 5, 342: 6, 347: 5, 348: 5, 350: 5, 351: 5, 352: 3, 353: 3, 354: 2, 358: 3, 365: 3, 366: 2, 371: 7, 372: 5, 376: 2, 384: 5, 385: 4, 386: 3, 387: 3, 393: 2, 396: 6, 397: 6, 398: 5, 402: 3} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 52 "DetNet end system and relay nodes are DetNet service sub-layer aware, understand the particular needs of DetNet flows and provide both DetNet service and forwarding sub-layer functions. They add, remove and process d-CWs, S-Labels and F-labels as needed. MPLS enabled end system and relay nodes can enhance the reliability of delivery by enabling the replication of packets where multiple copies, possibly over multiple paths, are forwarded through the DetNet domain. They can also eliminate surplus previously replicated copies of DetNet packets. DetNet MPLS nodes provide functionality similar to T-PEs when they sit at the edge of an MPLS domain, and functionality similar to S-PEs when they are in the middle of an MPLS domain, see RFC6073. End system and relay nodes also include DetNet forwarding sub-layer functions, support for notably explicit routes, and resources allocation to eliminate (or reduce) congestion loss and jitter." Similar structure and changes as in IP over TSN . Service protection interworking is out - of - scope . d275ba154e2b7c82eb3ec9175d790214b0e60d3f d275ba154e2b7c82eb3ec9175d790214b0e60d3f draft-ietf-detnet-mpls-over-tsn 564787d2556d259dabeaa6c5e2a64e9bdbfcf4ff124eb58795eebefb601fdb30 ['899fe49efb71ff0aa7ef3f05ac18bd5bfd87fffe13b5c1288db3416e022be147', 'ab93afb1ce53a91a86685ff579055185d9f7a6798d6effa52aec9838538bdf15', '42b1f3f30d1cae8db1fcb526de2f77c170c19e3508250cf37a94100514f567e6', '55bdece02c98962a77682e9b55671178537e5663507c4ff9c5409df14c7a69af', '438eb33c698936afb27ac820b5f68528ff155bd5a6927b63e6259a419be2e1a9', 'ed695265f24af924853cf42b909ea782e13659dd90448b1a4bc4800314d00f86', 'a8ff14472a8fa48bacdc11d7089a9d1054c0a786f6152f510b5d4092c22e121f', '16375944152e6c3e73492437880fe39d7f0123a9292d062e8e9c7d317e4b878f', '1076eab6753435c114e8a720c951b03da6d4e1bbbf1290f8d58ad7f97a0b8c64', '7f7e8733165742e4d8be8dacffe0453045841d70140ba0a9defc1c0d78e8d05c', '44e497e2df0461bad9215c57918855022435eb6e28266916161de3f7902bb352', '0cf3a218420317d1ac2dbe66fe8b3fa5930ee4bfb0f9a25d7059f70b672356ee', 'c2db650dc38549201f151a0fea9030968aca0fd468d0d6d3fe3d9b520ee551e6', '03d4609f1627eb905bc43957db60d2c0ce0b1cf99c6fa8617c936e7170195470', 'f07257d89bd36957d381df4c3d975b976581225d3b0e93b797f231549f809c45', 'cee8a70bcfc00996a87843150f50858ee830d692ae4678e50d5c074d43ff657c', 'b451f1bf9eed3bec2c5e20d4e9122ce6f31202fc68127f2881d2d860e9726365', '5c5fe7e7a382ebc21f89d163deb3520302620f0efe90cedb8592a80b5ef6a394', 'fb2b9389e1455c6d64ae19158396d767d88969013b14075bcfdcc764f610108c', '769d6aec4ab7308875a36f480f397628b2febffed4bc76dc77efd81374577a2f', '36330b0a2474d7598e4665a8ac8b8fbd2c0215a7c2971183879990c1948b22ae', 'ae3bdd3a81d96e4aaa02f7d597a2684146f3af75b743bde8e31c3cf5883707db', 'c63eee4f2d995789dc0fd3300a044e2c8d77d7fd6727e4e7a7bcc637c837d612', '564787d2556d259dabeaa6c5e2a64e9bdbfcf4ff124eb58795eebefb601fdb30', '5324bae9de9c301e9f6c475f9348fb2673813fe613070bb08ffd35c8a0e54204', 'f77d05a1e065348650e7579a3e2688468825cb7764599c8eb0f82836f4f3d9f3', 'a9668d2ded433c7b0eab698458e6b8fd13e4ddabe80417a884a66eda5893de8a', '75621d6a5adc1618337a02bf68856f7e1f8591c46fda003f39100f58bad112e3', '87cbb111ae00db5fad0458158af7d51a3ea8cb3e02e091c32f02ae366900eabb', '26e942b0353fee8f5ac0a2c2e26c9b695c50b35c501eeb4bff343b1648b5cebc', '036168e918418eb807bc3efd361a8e66067192564da41e30e076d22be0f87935', 'a6bd7b8f71e0d959503da2efa6fee412d7e71fb1f54e482a89a61c2a8d6bc691', '9829b13faebde69c2279c38cd54d524aa31acfdcc1cfba7910b9d69caa42e0dd', '2755ae7cda161df0c24e1fa9f1c3308bc9ef81a599d859668490484290ca72f4'] A "detnet end system and relay nodes are detnet service sub-layer aware, understand the particular needs of detnet flows and provide both detnet service and forwarding sub-layer functions. they add, remove and process d-cws, s-labels and f-labels as needed. mpls enabled end system and relay nodes can enhance the reliability of delivery by enabling the replication of packets where multiple copies, possibly over multiple paths, are forwarded through the detnet domain. they can also eliminate surplus previously replicated copies of detnet packets. detnet mpls nodes provide functionality similar to t-pes when they sit at the edge of an mpls domain, and functionality similar to s-pes when they are in the middle of an mpls domain, see rfc6073. end system and relay nodes also include detnet forwarding sub-layer functions, support for notably explicit routes, and resources allocation to eliminate (or reduce) congestion loss and jitter." {6: 1, 31: 1, 124: 1, 67: 1, 53: 1, 8: 1, 79: 2, 90: 3, 51: 3, 130: 2, 62: 4, 85: 4, 68: 3, 35: 3, 110: 3, 91: 5, 114: 3, 97: 3, 13: 3, 38: 4, 26: 3, 98: 2, 54: 2, 127: 3, 96: 3, 64: 2, 30: 4, 61: 5, 55: 2, 27: 2, 15: 3, 52: 2, 129: 3, 115: 3, 84: 2, 76: 4, 87: 3, 131: 5, 102: 3, 113: 5, 99: 2, 36: 3, 24: 2, 72: 4} {161: 1, 264: 1, 328: 1, 392: 1, 369: 1, 220: 1, 221: 1, 1: 8, 4: 2, 9: 3, 10: 3, 15: 3, 24: 2, 25: 4, 26: 4, 27: 3, 39: 4, 43: 3, 49: 6, 50: 5, 58: 5, 59: 2, 64: 3, 69: 2, 81: 5, 82: 4, 86: 3, 96: 4, 97: 3, 100: 7, 108: 3, 109: 4, 110: 4, 111: 2, 114: 3, 115: 4, 116: 3, 118: 5, 119: 4, 120: 3, 121: 3, 122: 4, 123: 3, 124: 3, 128: 4, 129: 4, 130: 5, 132: 2, 136: 2, 145: 2, 147: 4, 151: 4, 152: 4, 154: 3, 156: 2, 162: 2, 165: 3, 168: 4, 169: 3, 172: 3, 180: 4, 184: 3, 187: 5, 188: 4, 191: 3, 194: 2, 202: 3, 203: 4, 206: 2, 207: 3, 217: 3, 218: 7, 222: 4, 224: 3, 227: 5, 229: 3, 234: 5, 235: 2, 241: 2, 242: 2, 243: 2, 244: 4, 245: 2, 248: 4, 250: 4, 258: 10, 262: 4, 263: 5, 267: 3, 270: 3, 272: 3, 273: 3, 287: 3, 289: 3, 291: 5, 299: 5, 300: 3, 304: 3, 309: 2, 314: 2, 315: 3, 320: 3, 323: 2, 327: 4, 329: 2, 330: 9, 334: 2, 335: 3, 341: 5, 342: 6, 347: 5, 348: 5, 350: 5, 351: 5, 352: 3, 353: 3, 354: 2, 358: 3, 365: 3, 366: 2, 371: 7, 372: 5, 376: 2, 384: 5, 385: 4, 386: 3, 387: 3, 393: 2, 396: 6, 397: 6, 398: 5, 402: 3} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 52 "DetNet transit nodes reside wholly within a DetNet domain, and also provide DetNet forwarding sub-layer functions in accordance with the performance required by a DetNet flow carried over an LSP. Unlike other DetNet node types, transit nodes provide no service sub-layer processing. In a DetNet MPLS network, transit nodes may be DetNet service aware or may be DetNet unaware MPLS Label Switching Routers (LSRs). In this latter case, such LSRs would be unaware of the special requirements of the DetNet service sub-layer, but would still provide traffic engineering services and the QoS need to ensure that the (TE) LSPs meet the service requirements of the carried DetNet flows." Similar structure and changes as in IP over TSN . Service protection interworking is out - of - scope . d275ba154e2b7c82eb3ec9175d790214b0e60d3f d275ba154e2b7c82eb3ec9175d790214b0e60d3f draft-ietf-detnet-mpls-over-tsn 87cbb111ae00db5fad0458158af7d51a3ea8cb3e02e091c32f02ae366900eabb ['899fe49efb71ff0aa7ef3f05ac18bd5bfd87fffe13b5c1288db3416e022be147', 'ab93afb1ce53a91a86685ff579055185d9f7a6798d6effa52aec9838538bdf15', '42b1f3f30d1cae8db1fcb526de2f77c170c19e3508250cf37a94100514f567e6', '55bdece02c98962a77682e9b55671178537e5663507c4ff9c5409df14c7a69af', '438eb33c698936afb27ac820b5f68528ff155bd5a6927b63e6259a419be2e1a9', 'ed695265f24af924853cf42b909ea782e13659dd90448b1a4bc4800314d00f86', 'a8ff14472a8fa48bacdc11d7089a9d1054c0a786f6152f510b5d4092c22e121f', '16375944152e6c3e73492437880fe39d7f0123a9292d062e8e9c7d317e4b878f', '1076eab6753435c114e8a720c951b03da6d4e1bbbf1290f8d58ad7f97a0b8c64', '7f7e8733165742e4d8be8dacffe0453045841d70140ba0a9defc1c0d78e8d05c', '44e497e2df0461bad9215c57918855022435eb6e28266916161de3f7902bb352', '0cf3a218420317d1ac2dbe66fe8b3fa5930ee4bfb0f9a25d7059f70b672356ee', 'c2db650dc38549201f151a0fea9030968aca0fd468d0d6d3fe3d9b520ee551e6', '03d4609f1627eb905bc43957db60d2c0ce0b1cf99c6fa8617c936e7170195470', 'f07257d89bd36957d381df4c3d975b976581225d3b0e93b797f231549f809c45', 'cee8a70bcfc00996a87843150f50858ee830d692ae4678e50d5c074d43ff657c', 'b451f1bf9eed3bec2c5e20d4e9122ce6f31202fc68127f2881d2d860e9726365', '5c5fe7e7a382ebc21f89d163deb3520302620f0efe90cedb8592a80b5ef6a394', 'fb2b9389e1455c6d64ae19158396d767d88969013b14075bcfdcc764f610108c', '769d6aec4ab7308875a36f480f397628b2febffed4bc76dc77efd81374577a2f', '36330b0a2474d7598e4665a8ac8b8fbd2c0215a7c2971183879990c1948b22ae', 'ae3bdd3a81d96e4aaa02f7d597a2684146f3af75b743bde8e31c3cf5883707db', 'c63eee4f2d995789dc0fd3300a044e2c8d77d7fd6727e4e7a7bcc637c837d612', '564787d2556d259dabeaa6c5e2a64e9bdbfcf4ff124eb58795eebefb601fdb30', '5324bae9de9c301e9f6c475f9348fb2673813fe613070bb08ffd35c8a0e54204', 'f77d05a1e065348650e7579a3e2688468825cb7764599c8eb0f82836f4f3d9f3', 'a9668d2ded433c7b0eab698458e6b8fd13e4ddabe80417a884a66eda5893de8a', '75621d6a5adc1618337a02bf68856f7e1f8591c46fda003f39100f58bad112e3', '87cbb111ae00db5fad0458158af7d51a3ea8cb3e02e091c32f02ae366900eabb', '26e942b0353fee8f5ac0a2c2e26c9b695c50b35c501eeb4bff343b1648b5cebc', '036168e918418eb807bc3efd361a8e66067192564da41e30e076d22be0f87935', 'a6bd7b8f71e0d959503da2efa6fee412d7e71fb1f54e482a89a61c2a8d6bc691', '9829b13faebde69c2279c38cd54d524aa31acfdcc1cfba7910b9d69caa42e0dd', '2755ae7cda161df0c24e1fa9f1c3308bc9ef81a599d859668490484290ca72f4'] A "detnet transit nodes reside wholly within a detnet domain, and also provide detnet forwarding sub-layer functions in accordance with the performance required by a detnet flow carried over an lsp. unlike other detnet node types, transit nodes provide no service sub-layer processing. in a detnet mpls network, transit nodes may be detnet service aware or may be detnet unaware mpls label switching routers (lsrs). in this latter case, such lsrs would be unaware of the special requirements of the detnet service sub-layer, but would still provide traffic engineering services and the qos need to ensure that the (te) lsps meet the service requirements of the carried detnet flows." {6: 1, 31: 1, 124: 1, 67: 1, 53: 1, 8: 1, 79: 2, 90: 3, 51: 3, 130: 2, 62: 4, 85: 4, 68: 3, 35: 3, 110: 3, 91: 5, 114: 3, 97: 3, 13: 3, 38: 4, 26: 3, 98: 2, 54: 2, 127: 3, 96: 3, 64: 2, 30: 4, 61: 5, 55: 2, 27: 2, 15: 3, 52: 2, 129: 3, 115: 3, 84: 2, 76: 4, 87: 3, 131: 5, 102: 3, 113: 5, 99: 2, 36: 3, 24: 2, 72: 4} {161: 1, 264: 1, 328: 1, 392: 1, 369: 1, 220: 1, 221: 1, 1: 8, 4: 2, 9: 3, 10: 3, 15: 3, 24: 2, 25: 4, 26: 4, 27: 3, 39: 4, 43: 3, 49: 6, 50: 5, 58: 5, 59: 2, 64: 3, 69: 2, 81: 5, 82: 4, 86: 3, 96: 4, 97: 3, 100: 7, 108: 3, 109: 4, 110: 4, 111: 2, 114: 3, 115: 4, 116: 3, 118: 5, 119: 4, 120: 3, 121: 3, 122: 4, 123: 3, 124: 3, 128: 4, 129: 4, 130: 5, 132: 2, 136: 2, 145: 2, 147: 4, 151: 4, 152: 4, 154: 3, 156: 2, 162: 2, 165: 3, 168: 4, 169: 3, 172: 3, 180: 4, 184: 3, 187: 5, 188: 4, 191: 3, 194: 2, 202: 3, 203: 4, 206: 2, 207: 3, 217: 3, 218: 7, 222: 4, 224: 3, 227: 5, 229: 3, 234: 5, 235: 2, 241: 2, 242: 2, 243: 2, 244: 4, 245: 2, 248: 4, 250: 4, 258: 10, 262: 4, 263: 5, 267: 3, 270: 3, 272: 3, 273: 3, 287: 3, 289: 3, 291: 5, 299: 5, 300: 3, 304: 3, 309: 2, 314: 2, 315: 3, 320: 3, 323: 2, 327: 4, 329: 2, 330: 9, 334: 2, 335: 3, 341: 5, 342: 6, 347: 5, 348: 5, 350: 5, 351: 5, 352: 3, 353: 3, 354: 2, 358: 3, 365: 3, 366: 2, 371: 7, 372: 5, 376: 2, 384: 5, 385: 4, 386: 3, 387: 3, 393: 2, 396: 6, 397: 6, 398: 5, 402: 3} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 52 "The LSPs may be provided by any MPLS controller method. For example they may be provisioned via a management plane, RSVP-TE, MPLS-TP, or MPLS Segment Routing (when extended to support resource allocation)." Similar structure and changes as in IP over TSN . Service protection interworking is out - of - scope . d275ba154e2b7c82eb3ec9175d790214b0e60d3f d275ba154e2b7c82eb3ec9175d790214b0e60d3f draft-ietf-detnet-mpls-over-tsn c63eee4f2d995789dc0fd3300a044e2c8d77d7fd6727e4e7a7bcc637c837d612 ['899fe49efb71ff0aa7ef3f05ac18bd5bfd87fffe13b5c1288db3416e022be147', 'ab93afb1ce53a91a86685ff579055185d9f7a6798d6effa52aec9838538bdf15', '42b1f3f30d1cae8db1fcb526de2f77c170c19e3508250cf37a94100514f567e6', '55bdece02c98962a77682e9b55671178537e5663507c4ff9c5409df14c7a69af', '438eb33c698936afb27ac820b5f68528ff155bd5a6927b63e6259a419be2e1a9', 'ed695265f24af924853cf42b909ea782e13659dd90448b1a4bc4800314d00f86', 'a8ff14472a8fa48bacdc11d7089a9d1054c0a786f6152f510b5d4092c22e121f', '16375944152e6c3e73492437880fe39d7f0123a9292d062e8e9c7d317e4b878f', '1076eab6753435c114e8a720c951b03da6d4e1bbbf1290f8d58ad7f97a0b8c64', '7f7e8733165742e4d8be8dacffe0453045841d70140ba0a9defc1c0d78e8d05c', '44e497e2df0461bad9215c57918855022435eb6e28266916161de3f7902bb352', '0cf3a218420317d1ac2dbe66fe8b3fa5930ee4bfb0f9a25d7059f70b672356ee', 'c2db650dc38549201f151a0fea9030968aca0fd468d0d6d3fe3d9b520ee551e6', '03d4609f1627eb905bc43957db60d2c0ce0b1cf99c6fa8617c936e7170195470', 'f07257d89bd36957d381df4c3d975b976581225d3b0e93b797f231549f809c45', 'cee8a70bcfc00996a87843150f50858ee830d692ae4678e50d5c074d43ff657c', 'b451f1bf9eed3bec2c5e20d4e9122ce6f31202fc68127f2881d2d860e9726365', '5c5fe7e7a382ebc21f89d163deb3520302620f0efe90cedb8592a80b5ef6a394', 'fb2b9389e1455c6d64ae19158396d767d88969013b14075bcfdcc764f610108c', '769d6aec4ab7308875a36f480f397628b2febffed4bc76dc77efd81374577a2f', '36330b0a2474d7598e4665a8ac8b8fbd2c0215a7c2971183879990c1948b22ae', 'ae3bdd3a81d96e4aaa02f7d597a2684146f3af75b743bde8e31c3cf5883707db', 'c63eee4f2d995789dc0fd3300a044e2c8d77d7fd6727e4e7a7bcc637c837d612', '564787d2556d259dabeaa6c5e2a64e9bdbfcf4ff124eb58795eebefb601fdb30', '5324bae9de9c301e9f6c475f9348fb2673813fe613070bb08ffd35c8a0e54204', 'f77d05a1e065348650e7579a3e2688468825cb7764599c8eb0f82836f4f3d9f3', 'a9668d2ded433c7b0eab698458e6b8fd13e4ddabe80417a884a66eda5893de8a', '75621d6a5adc1618337a02bf68856f7e1f8591c46fda003f39100f58bad112e3', '87cbb111ae00db5fad0458158af7d51a3ea8cb3e02e091c32f02ae366900eabb', '26e942b0353fee8f5ac0a2c2e26c9b695c50b35c501eeb4bff343b1648b5cebc', '036168e918418eb807bc3efd361a8e66067192564da41e30e076d22be0f87935', 'a6bd7b8f71e0d959503da2efa6fee412d7e71fb1f54e482a89a61c2a8d6bc691', '9829b13faebde69c2279c38cd54d524aa31acfdcc1cfba7910b9d69caa42e0dd', '2755ae7cda161df0c24e1fa9f1c3308bc9ef81a599d859668490484290ca72f4'] A "the lsps may be provided by any mpls controller method. for example they may be provisioned via a management plane, rsvp-te, mpls-tp, or mpls segment routing (when extended to support resource allocation)." {6: 1, 31: 1, 124: 1, 67: 1, 53: 1, 8: 1, 79: 2, 90: 3, 51: 3, 130: 2, 62: 4, 85: 4, 68: 3, 35: 3, 110: 3, 91: 5, 114: 3, 97: 3, 13: 3, 38: 4, 26: 3, 98: 2, 54: 2, 127: 3, 96: 3, 64: 2, 30: 4, 61: 5, 55: 2, 27: 2, 15: 3, 52: 2, 129: 3, 115: 3, 84: 2, 76: 4, 87: 3, 131: 5, 102: 3, 113: 5, 99: 2, 36: 3, 24: 2, 72: 4} {161: 1, 264: 1, 328: 1, 392: 1, 369: 1, 220: 1, 221: 1, 1: 8, 4: 2, 9: 3, 10: 3, 15: 3, 24: 2, 25: 4, 26: 4, 27: 3, 39: 4, 43: 3, 49: 6, 50: 5, 58: 5, 59: 2, 64: 3, 69: 2, 81: 5, 82: 4, 86: 3, 96: 4, 97: 3, 100: 7, 108: 3, 109: 4, 110: 4, 111: 2, 114: 3, 115: 4, 116: 3, 118: 5, 119: 4, 120: 3, 121: 3, 122: 4, 123: 3, 124: 3, 128: 4, 129: 4, 130: 5, 132: 2, 136: 2, 145: 2, 147: 4, 151: 4, 152: 4, 154: 3, 156: 2, 162: 2, 165: 3, 168: 4, 169: 3, 172: 3, 180: 4, 184: 3, 187: 5, 188: 4, 191: 3, 194: 2, 202: 3, 203: 4, 206: 2, 207: 3, 217: 3, 218: 7, 222: 4, 224: 3, 227: 5, 229: 3, 234: 5, 235: 2, 241: 2, 242: 2, 243: 2, 244: 4, 245: 2, 248: 4, 250: 4, 258: 10, 262: 4, 263: 5, 267: 3, 270: 3, 272: 3, 273: 3, 287: 3, 289: 3, 291: 5, 299: 5, 300: 3, 304: 3, 309: 2, 314: 2, 315: 3, 320: 3, 323: 2, 327: 4, 329: 2, 330: 9, 334: 2, 335: 3, 341: 5, 342: 6, 347: 5, 348: 5, 350: 5, 351: 5, 352: 3, 353: 3, 354: 2, 358: 3, 365: 3, 366: 2, 371: 7, 372: 5, 376: 2, 384: 5, 385: 4, 386: 3, 387: 3, 393: 2, 396: 6, 397: 6, 398: 5, 402: 3} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 52 "fig_pw_detnet illustrates how an end to end MPLS-based DetNet service is provided in a more detail. In this figure, the end systems, CE1 and CE2, are able to send and receive MPLS encapsulated DetNet flows, and R1, R2 and R3 are relay nodes as they sit in the middle of a DetNet network. The 'X' in the end systems, and relay nodes represents potential DetNet compound flow packet replication and elimination points. In this example, service protection is supported over four DetNet member flows and TE LSPs. For a unidirectional flow, R1 supports PRF, R2 supports PREOF and R3 supports PEF and POF. Note that the relay nodes may change the underlying forwarding sub- layer, for example tunneling MPLS over IEEE 802.1 TSN mpls-over-tsn, or simply over interconnect network links." Similar structure and changes as in IP over TSN . Service protection interworking is out - of - scope . d275ba154e2b7c82eb3ec9175d790214b0e60d3f d275ba154e2b7c82eb3ec9175d790214b0e60d3f draft-ietf-detnet-mpls-over-tsn ed695265f24af924853cf42b909ea782e13659dd90448b1a4bc4800314d00f86 ['899fe49efb71ff0aa7ef3f05ac18bd5bfd87fffe13b5c1288db3416e022be147', 'ab93afb1ce53a91a86685ff579055185d9f7a6798d6effa52aec9838538bdf15', '42b1f3f30d1cae8db1fcb526de2f77c170c19e3508250cf37a94100514f567e6', '55bdece02c98962a77682e9b55671178537e5663507c4ff9c5409df14c7a69af', '438eb33c698936afb27ac820b5f68528ff155bd5a6927b63e6259a419be2e1a9', 'ed695265f24af924853cf42b909ea782e13659dd90448b1a4bc4800314d00f86', 'a8ff14472a8fa48bacdc11d7089a9d1054c0a786f6152f510b5d4092c22e121f', '16375944152e6c3e73492437880fe39d7f0123a9292d062e8e9c7d317e4b878f', '1076eab6753435c114e8a720c951b03da6d4e1bbbf1290f8d58ad7f97a0b8c64', '7f7e8733165742e4d8be8dacffe0453045841d70140ba0a9defc1c0d78e8d05c', '44e497e2df0461bad9215c57918855022435eb6e28266916161de3f7902bb352', '0cf3a218420317d1ac2dbe66fe8b3fa5930ee4bfb0f9a25d7059f70b672356ee', 'c2db650dc38549201f151a0fea9030968aca0fd468d0d6d3fe3d9b520ee551e6', '03d4609f1627eb905bc43957db60d2c0ce0b1cf99c6fa8617c936e7170195470', 'f07257d89bd36957d381df4c3d975b976581225d3b0e93b797f231549f809c45', 'cee8a70bcfc00996a87843150f50858ee830d692ae4678e50d5c074d43ff657c', 'b451f1bf9eed3bec2c5e20d4e9122ce6f31202fc68127f2881d2d860e9726365', '5c5fe7e7a382ebc21f89d163deb3520302620f0efe90cedb8592a80b5ef6a394', 'fb2b9389e1455c6d64ae19158396d767d88969013b14075bcfdcc764f610108c', '769d6aec4ab7308875a36f480f397628b2febffed4bc76dc77efd81374577a2f', '36330b0a2474d7598e4665a8ac8b8fbd2c0215a7c2971183879990c1948b22ae', 'ae3bdd3a81d96e4aaa02f7d597a2684146f3af75b743bde8e31c3cf5883707db', 'c63eee4f2d995789dc0fd3300a044e2c8d77d7fd6727e4e7a7bcc637c837d612', '564787d2556d259dabeaa6c5e2a64e9bdbfcf4ff124eb58795eebefb601fdb30', '5324bae9de9c301e9f6c475f9348fb2673813fe613070bb08ffd35c8a0e54204', 'f77d05a1e065348650e7579a3e2688468825cb7764599c8eb0f82836f4f3d9f3', 'a9668d2ded433c7b0eab698458e6b8fd13e4ddabe80417a884a66eda5893de8a', '75621d6a5adc1618337a02bf68856f7e1f8591c46fda003f39100f58bad112e3', '87cbb111ae00db5fad0458158af7d51a3ea8cb3e02e091c32f02ae366900eabb', '26e942b0353fee8f5ac0a2c2e26c9b695c50b35c501eeb4bff343b1648b5cebc', '036168e918418eb807bc3efd361a8e66067192564da41e30e076d22be0f87935', 'a6bd7b8f71e0d959503da2efa6fee412d7e71fb1f54e482a89a61c2a8d6bc691', '9829b13faebde69c2279c38cd54d524aa31acfdcc1cfba7910b9d69caa42e0dd', '2755ae7cda161df0c24e1fa9f1c3308bc9ef81a599d859668490484290ca72f4'] A "fig_pw_detnet illustrates how an end to end mpls-based detnet service is provided in a more detail. in this figure, the end systems, ce1 and ce2, are able to send and receive mpls encapsulated detnet flows, and r1, r2 and r3 are relay nodes as they sit in the middle of a detnet network. the 'x' in the end systems, and relay nodes represents potential detnet compound flow packet replication and elimination points. in this example, service protection is supported over four detnet member flows and te lsps. for a unidirectional flow, r1 supports prf, r2 supports preof and r3 supports pef and pof. note that the relay nodes may change the underlying forwarding sub- layer, for example tunneling mpls over ieee 802.1 tsn mpls-over-tsn, or simply over interconnect network links." {6: 1, 31: 1, 124: 1, 67: 1, 53: 1, 8: 1, 79: 2, 90: 3, 51: 3, 130: 2, 62: 4, 85: 4, 68: 3, 35: 3, 110: 3, 91: 5, 114: 3, 97: 3, 13: 3, 38: 4, 26: 3, 98: 2, 54: 2, 127: 3, 96: 3, 64: 2, 30: 4, 61: 5, 55: 2, 27: 2, 15: 3, 52: 2, 129: 3, 115: 3, 84: 2, 76: 4, 87: 3, 131: 5, 102: 3, 113: 5, 99: 2, 36: 3, 24: 2, 72: 4} {161: 1, 264: 1, 328: 1, 392: 1, 369: 1, 220: 1, 221: 1, 1: 8, 4: 2, 9: 3, 10: 3, 15: 3, 24: 2, 25: 4, 26: 4, 27: 3, 39: 4, 43: 3, 49: 6, 50: 5, 58: 5, 59: 2, 64: 3, 69: 2, 81: 5, 82: 4, 86: 3, 96: 4, 97: 3, 100: 7, 108: 3, 109: 4, 110: 4, 111: 2, 114: 3, 115: 4, 116: 3, 118: 5, 119: 4, 120: 3, 121: 3, 122: 4, 123: 3, 124: 3, 128: 4, 129: 4, 130: 5, 132: 2, 136: 2, 145: 2, 147: 4, 151: 4, 152: 4, 154: 3, 156: 2, 162: 2, 165: 3, 168: 4, 169: 3, 172: 3, 180: 4, 184: 3, 187: 5, 188: 4, 191: 3, 194: 2, 202: 3, 203: 4, 206: 2, 207: 3, 217: 3, 218: 7, 222: 4, 224: 3, 227: 5, 229: 3, 234: 5, 235: 2, 241: 2, 242: 2, 243: 2, 244: 4, 245: 2, 248: 4, 250: 4, 258: 10, 262: 4, 263: 5, 267: 3, 270: 3, 272: 3, 273: 3, 287: 3, 289: 3, 291: 5, 299: 5, 300: 3, 304: 3, 309: 2, 314: 2, 315: 3, 320: 3, 323: 2, 327: 4, 329: 2, 330: 9, 334: 2, 335: 3, 341: 5, 342: 6, 347: 5, 348: 5, 350: 5, 351: 5, 352: 3, 353: 3, 354: 2, 358: 3, 365: 3, 366: 2, 371: 7, 372: 5, 376: 2, 384: 5, 385: 4, 386: 3, 387: 3, 393: 2, 396: 6, 397: 6, 398: 5, 402: 3} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 52 "As previously mentioned, this document specifies how MPLS is used to support DetNet flows using an MPLS data plane as well as how such can be mapped to IEEE 802.1 TSN and IP DetNet PSNs. An equally import scenario is when IP is supported over DetNet MPLS and this is covered in I-D.ietf-detnet-dp-sol-ip. Another important scenario is where an Ethernet Layer 2 service is supported over DetNet MPLS and this is covered in [TBD-TSN-OVER-DETNET]." Similar structure and changes as in IP over TSN . Service protection interworking is out - of - scope . d275ba154e2b7c82eb3ec9175d790214b0e60d3f d275ba154e2b7c82eb3ec9175d790214b0e60d3f draft-ietf-detnet-mpls-over-tsn a6bd7b8f71e0d959503da2efa6fee412d7e71fb1f54e482a89a61c2a8d6bc691 ['899fe49efb71ff0aa7ef3f05ac18bd5bfd87fffe13b5c1288db3416e022be147', 'ab93afb1ce53a91a86685ff579055185d9f7a6798d6effa52aec9838538bdf15', '42b1f3f30d1cae8db1fcb526de2f77c170c19e3508250cf37a94100514f567e6', '55bdece02c98962a77682e9b55671178537e5663507c4ff9c5409df14c7a69af', '438eb33c698936afb27ac820b5f68528ff155bd5a6927b63e6259a419be2e1a9', 'ed695265f24af924853cf42b909ea782e13659dd90448b1a4bc4800314d00f86', 'a8ff14472a8fa48bacdc11d7089a9d1054c0a786f6152f510b5d4092c22e121f', '16375944152e6c3e73492437880fe39d7f0123a9292d062e8e9c7d317e4b878f', '1076eab6753435c114e8a720c951b03da6d4e1bbbf1290f8d58ad7f97a0b8c64', '7f7e8733165742e4d8be8dacffe0453045841d70140ba0a9defc1c0d78e8d05c', '44e497e2df0461bad9215c57918855022435eb6e28266916161de3f7902bb352', '0cf3a218420317d1ac2dbe66fe8b3fa5930ee4bfb0f9a25d7059f70b672356ee', 'c2db650dc38549201f151a0fea9030968aca0fd468d0d6d3fe3d9b520ee551e6', '03d4609f1627eb905bc43957db60d2c0ce0b1cf99c6fa8617c936e7170195470', 'f07257d89bd36957d381df4c3d975b976581225d3b0e93b797f231549f809c45', 'cee8a70bcfc00996a87843150f50858ee830d692ae4678e50d5c074d43ff657c', 'b451f1bf9eed3bec2c5e20d4e9122ce6f31202fc68127f2881d2d860e9726365', '5c5fe7e7a382ebc21f89d163deb3520302620f0efe90cedb8592a80b5ef6a394', 'fb2b9389e1455c6d64ae19158396d767d88969013b14075bcfdcc764f610108c', '769d6aec4ab7308875a36f480f397628b2febffed4bc76dc77efd81374577a2f', '36330b0a2474d7598e4665a8ac8b8fbd2c0215a7c2971183879990c1948b22ae', 'ae3bdd3a81d96e4aaa02f7d597a2684146f3af75b743bde8e31c3cf5883707db', 'c63eee4f2d995789dc0fd3300a044e2c8d77d7fd6727e4e7a7bcc637c837d612', '564787d2556d259dabeaa6c5e2a64e9bdbfcf4ff124eb58795eebefb601fdb30', '5324bae9de9c301e9f6c475f9348fb2673813fe613070bb08ffd35c8a0e54204', 'f77d05a1e065348650e7579a3e2688468825cb7764599c8eb0f82836f4f3d9f3', 'a9668d2ded433c7b0eab698458e6b8fd13e4ddabe80417a884a66eda5893de8a', '75621d6a5adc1618337a02bf68856f7e1f8591c46fda003f39100f58bad112e3', '87cbb111ae00db5fad0458158af7d51a3ea8cb3e02e091c32f02ae366900eabb', '26e942b0353fee8f5ac0a2c2e26c9b695c50b35c501eeb4bff343b1648b5cebc', '036168e918418eb807bc3efd361a8e66067192564da41e30e076d22be0f87935', 'a6bd7b8f71e0d959503da2efa6fee412d7e71fb1f54e482a89a61c2a8d6bc691', '9829b13faebde69c2279c38cd54d524aa31acfdcc1cfba7910b9d69caa42e0dd', '2755ae7cda161df0c24e1fa9f1c3308bc9ef81a599d859668490484290ca72f4'] A "as previously mentioned, this document specifies how mpls is used to support detnet flows using an mpls data plane as well as how such can be mapped to ieee 802.1 tsn and ip detnet psns. an equally import scenario is when ip is supported over detnet mpls and this is covered in i-d.ietf-detnet-dp-sol-ip. another important scenario is where an ethernet layer 2 service is supported over detnet mpls and this is covered in [tbd-tsn-over-detnet]." {6: 1, 31: 1, 124: 1, 67: 1, 53: 1, 8: 1, 79: 2, 90: 3, 51: 3, 130: 2, 62: 4, 85: 4, 68: 3, 35: 3, 110: 3, 91: 5, 114: 3, 97: 3, 13: 3, 38: 4, 26: 3, 98: 2, 54: 2, 127: 3, 96: 3, 64: 2, 30: 4, 61: 5, 55: 2, 27: 2, 15: 3, 52: 2, 129: 3, 115: 3, 84: 2, 76: 4, 87: 3, 131: 5, 102: 3, 113: 5, 99: 2, 36: 3, 24: 2, 72: 4} {161: 1, 264: 1, 328: 1, 392: 1, 369: 1, 220: 1, 221: 1, 1: 8, 4: 2, 9: 3, 10: 3, 15: 3, 24: 2, 25: 4, 26: 4, 27: 3, 39: 4, 43: 3, 49: 6, 50: 5, 58: 5, 59: 2, 64: 3, 69: 2, 81: 5, 82: 4, 86: 3, 96: 4, 97: 3, 100: 7, 108: 3, 109: 4, 110: 4, 111: 2, 114: 3, 115: 4, 116: 3, 118: 5, 119: 4, 120: 3, 121: 3, 122: 4, 123: 3, 124: 3, 128: 4, 129: 4, 130: 5, 132: 2, 136: 2, 145: 2, 147: 4, 151: 4, 152: 4, 154: 3, 156: 2, 162: 2, 165: 3, 168: 4, 169: 3, 172: 3, 180: 4, 184: 3, 187: 5, 188: 4, 191: 3, 194: 2, 202: 3, 203: 4, 206: 2, 207: 3, 217: 3, 218: 7, 222: 4, 224: 3, 227: 5, 229: 3, 234: 5, 235: 2, 241: 2, 242: 2, 243: 2, 244: 4, 245: 2, 248: 4, 250: 4, 258: 10, 262: 4, 263: 5, 267: 3, 270: 3, 272: 3, 273: 3, 287: 3, 289: 3, 291: 5, 299: 5, 300: 3, 304: 3, 309: 2, 314: 2, 315: 3, 320: 3, 323: 2, 327: 4, 329: 2, 330: 9, 334: 2, 335: 3, 341: 5, 342: 6, 347: 5, 348: 5, 350: 5, 351: 5, 352: 3, 353: 3, 354: 2, 358: 3, 365: 3, 366: 2, 371: 7, 372: 5, 376: 2, 384: 5, 385: 4, 386: 3, 387: 3, 393: 2, 396: 6, 397: 6, 398: 5, 402: 3} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 52 "An example DetNet MPLS network fragment and packet flow is illustrated in fig_mpls_example." Similar structure and changes as in IP over TSN . Service protection interworking is out - of - scope . d275ba154e2b7c82eb3ec9175d790214b0e60d3f d275ba154e2b7c82eb3ec9175d790214b0e60d3f draft-ietf-detnet-mpls-over-tsn 03d4609f1627eb905bc43957db60d2c0ce0b1cf99c6fa8617c936e7170195470 ['899fe49efb71ff0aa7ef3f05ac18bd5bfd87fffe13b5c1288db3416e022be147', 'ab93afb1ce53a91a86685ff579055185d9f7a6798d6effa52aec9838538bdf15', '42b1f3f30d1cae8db1fcb526de2f77c170c19e3508250cf37a94100514f567e6', '55bdece02c98962a77682e9b55671178537e5663507c4ff9c5409df14c7a69af', '438eb33c698936afb27ac820b5f68528ff155bd5a6927b63e6259a419be2e1a9', 'ed695265f24af924853cf42b909ea782e13659dd90448b1a4bc4800314d00f86', 'a8ff14472a8fa48bacdc11d7089a9d1054c0a786f6152f510b5d4092c22e121f', '16375944152e6c3e73492437880fe39d7f0123a9292d062e8e9c7d317e4b878f', '1076eab6753435c114e8a720c951b03da6d4e1bbbf1290f8d58ad7f97a0b8c64', '7f7e8733165742e4d8be8dacffe0453045841d70140ba0a9defc1c0d78e8d05c', '44e497e2df0461bad9215c57918855022435eb6e28266916161de3f7902bb352', '0cf3a218420317d1ac2dbe66fe8b3fa5930ee4bfb0f9a25d7059f70b672356ee', 'c2db650dc38549201f151a0fea9030968aca0fd468d0d6d3fe3d9b520ee551e6', '03d4609f1627eb905bc43957db60d2c0ce0b1cf99c6fa8617c936e7170195470', 'f07257d89bd36957d381df4c3d975b976581225d3b0e93b797f231549f809c45', 'cee8a70bcfc00996a87843150f50858ee830d692ae4678e50d5c074d43ff657c', 'b451f1bf9eed3bec2c5e20d4e9122ce6f31202fc68127f2881d2d860e9726365', '5c5fe7e7a382ebc21f89d163deb3520302620f0efe90cedb8592a80b5ef6a394', 'fb2b9389e1455c6d64ae19158396d767d88969013b14075bcfdcc764f610108c', '769d6aec4ab7308875a36f480f397628b2febffed4bc76dc77efd81374577a2f', '36330b0a2474d7598e4665a8ac8b8fbd2c0215a7c2971183879990c1948b22ae', 'ae3bdd3a81d96e4aaa02f7d597a2684146f3af75b743bde8e31c3cf5883707db', 'c63eee4f2d995789dc0fd3300a044e2c8d77d7fd6727e4e7a7bcc637c837d612', '564787d2556d259dabeaa6c5e2a64e9bdbfcf4ff124eb58795eebefb601fdb30', '5324bae9de9c301e9f6c475f9348fb2673813fe613070bb08ffd35c8a0e54204', 'f77d05a1e065348650e7579a3e2688468825cb7764599c8eb0f82836f4f3d9f3', 'a9668d2ded433c7b0eab698458e6b8fd13e4ddabe80417a884a66eda5893de8a', '75621d6a5adc1618337a02bf68856f7e1f8591c46fda003f39100f58bad112e3', '87cbb111ae00db5fad0458158af7d51a3ea8cb3e02e091c32f02ae366900eabb', '26e942b0353fee8f5ac0a2c2e26c9b695c50b35c501eeb4bff343b1648b5cebc', '036168e918418eb807bc3efd361a8e66067192564da41e30e076d22be0f87935', 'a6bd7b8f71e0d959503da2efa6fee412d7e71fb1f54e482a89a61c2a8d6bc691', '9829b13faebde69c2279c38cd54d524aa31acfdcc1cfba7910b9d69caa42e0dd', '2755ae7cda161df0c24e1fa9f1c3308bc9ef81a599d859668490484290ca72f4'] A "an example detnet mpls network fragment and packet flow is illustrated in fig_mpls_example." {6: 1, 31: 1, 124: 1, 67: 1, 53: 1, 8: 1, 79: 2, 90: 3, 51: 3, 130: 2, 62: 4, 85: 4, 68: 3, 35: 3, 110: 3, 91: 5, 114: 3, 97: 3, 13: 3, 38: 4, 26: 3, 98: 2, 54: 2, 127: 3, 96: 3, 64: 2, 30: 4, 61: 5, 55: 2, 27: 2, 15: 3, 52: 2, 129: 3, 115: 3, 84: 2, 76: 4, 87: 3, 131: 5, 102: 3, 113: 5, 99: 2, 36: 3, 24: 2, 72: 4} {161: 1, 264: 1, 328: 1, 392: 1, 369: 1, 220: 1, 221: 1, 1: 8, 4: 2, 9: 3, 10: 3, 15: 3, 24: 2, 25: 4, 26: 4, 27: 3, 39: 4, 43: 3, 49: 6, 50: 5, 58: 5, 59: 2, 64: 3, 69: 2, 81: 5, 82: 4, 86: 3, 96: 4, 97: 3, 100: 7, 108: 3, 109: 4, 110: 4, 111: 2, 114: 3, 115: 4, 116: 3, 118: 5, 119: 4, 120: 3, 121: 3, 122: 4, 123: 3, 124: 3, 128: 4, 129: 4, 130: 5, 132: 2, 136: 2, 145: 2, 147: 4, 151: 4, 152: 4, 154: 3, 156: 2, 162: 2, 165: 3, 168: 4, 169: 3, 172: 3, 180: 4, 184: 3, 187: 5, 188: 4, 191: 3, 194: 2, 202: 3, 203: 4, 206: 2, 207: 3, 217: 3, 218: 7, 222: 4, 224: 3, 227: 5, 229: 3, 234: 5, 235: 2, 241: 2, 242: 2, 243: 2, 244: 4, 245: 2, 248: 4, 250: 4, 258: 10, 262: 4, 263: 5, 267: 3, 270: 3, 272: 3, 273: 3, 287: 3, 289: 3, 291: 5, 299: 5, 300: 3, 304: 3, 309: 2, 314: 2, 315: 3, 320: 3, 323: 2, 327: 4, 329: 2, 330: 9, 334: 2, 335: 3, 341: 5, 342: 6, 347: 5, 348: 5, 350: 5, 351: 5, 352: 3, 353: 3, 354: 2, 358: 3, 365: 3, 366: 2, 371: 7, 372: 5, 376: 2, 384: 5, 385: 4, 386: 3, 387: 3, 393: 2, 396: 6, 397: 6, 398: 5, 402: 3} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 52 "In fig_mpls_example the numbers are used to identify the instance of a packet. Packet 1 is the original packet, and packets 1.1, and 1.2 are two first generation copies of packet 1. Packet 1.2.1 is a second generation copy of packet 1.2 etc. Note that these numbers never appear in the packet, and are not to be confused with sequence numbers, labels or any other identifier that appears in the packet. They simply indicate the generation number of the original packet so that its passage through the network fragment can be identified to the reader." Similar structure and changes as in IP over TSN . Service protection interworking is out - of - scope . d275ba154e2b7c82eb3ec9175d790214b0e60d3f d275ba154e2b7c82eb3ec9175d790214b0e60d3f draft-ietf-detnet-mpls-over-tsn a9668d2ded433c7b0eab698458e6b8fd13e4ddabe80417a884a66eda5893de8a ['899fe49efb71ff0aa7ef3f05ac18bd5bfd87fffe13b5c1288db3416e022be147', 'ab93afb1ce53a91a86685ff579055185d9f7a6798d6effa52aec9838538bdf15', '42b1f3f30d1cae8db1fcb526de2f77c170c19e3508250cf37a94100514f567e6', '55bdece02c98962a77682e9b55671178537e5663507c4ff9c5409df14c7a69af', '438eb33c698936afb27ac820b5f68528ff155bd5a6927b63e6259a419be2e1a9', 'ed695265f24af924853cf42b909ea782e13659dd90448b1a4bc4800314d00f86', 'a8ff14472a8fa48bacdc11d7089a9d1054c0a786f6152f510b5d4092c22e121f', '16375944152e6c3e73492437880fe39d7f0123a9292d062e8e9c7d317e4b878f', '1076eab6753435c114e8a720c951b03da6d4e1bbbf1290f8d58ad7f97a0b8c64', '7f7e8733165742e4d8be8dacffe0453045841d70140ba0a9defc1c0d78e8d05c', '44e497e2df0461bad9215c57918855022435eb6e28266916161de3f7902bb352', '0cf3a218420317d1ac2dbe66fe8b3fa5930ee4bfb0f9a25d7059f70b672356ee', 'c2db650dc38549201f151a0fea9030968aca0fd468d0d6d3fe3d9b520ee551e6', '03d4609f1627eb905bc43957db60d2c0ce0b1cf99c6fa8617c936e7170195470', 'f07257d89bd36957d381df4c3d975b976581225d3b0e93b797f231549f809c45', 'cee8a70bcfc00996a87843150f50858ee830d692ae4678e50d5c074d43ff657c', 'b451f1bf9eed3bec2c5e20d4e9122ce6f31202fc68127f2881d2d860e9726365', '5c5fe7e7a382ebc21f89d163deb3520302620f0efe90cedb8592a80b5ef6a394', 'fb2b9389e1455c6d64ae19158396d767d88969013b14075bcfdcc764f610108c', '769d6aec4ab7308875a36f480f397628b2febffed4bc76dc77efd81374577a2f', '36330b0a2474d7598e4665a8ac8b8fbd2c0215a7c2971183879990c1948b22ae', 'ae3bdd3a81d96e4aaa02f7d597a2684146f3af75b743bde8e31c3cf5883707db', 'c63eee4f2d995789dc0fd3300a044e2c8d77d7fd6727e4e7a7bcc637c837d612', '564787d2556d259dabeaa6c5e2a64e9bdbfcf4ff124eb58795eebefb601fdb30', '5324bae9de9c301e9f6c475f9348fb2673813fe613070bb08ffd35c8a0e54204', 'f77d05a1e065348650e7579a3e2688468825cb7764599c8eb0f82836f4f3d9f3', 'a9668d2ded433c7b0eab698458e6b8fd13e4ddabe80417a884a66eda5893de8a', '75621d6a5adc1618337a02bf68856f7e1f8591c46fda003f39100f58bad112e3', '87cbb111ae00db5fad0458158af7d51a3ea8cb3e02e091c32f02ae366900eabb', '26e942b0353fee8f5ac0a2c2e26c9b695c50b35c501eeb4bff343b1648b5cebc', '036168e918418eb807bc3efd361a8e66067192564da41e30e076d22be0f87935', 'a6bd7b8f71e0d959503da2efa6fee412d7e71fb1f54e482a89a61c2a8d6bc691', '9829b13faebde69c2279c38cd54d524aa31acfdcc1cfba7910b9d69caa42e0dd', '2755ae7cda161df0c24e1fa9f1c3308bc9ef81a599d859668490484290ca72f4'] A "in fig_mpls_example the numbers are used to identify the instance of a packet. packet 1 is the original packet, and packets 1.1, and 1.2 are two first generation copies of packet 1. packet 1.2.1 is a second generation copy of packet 1.2 etc. note that these numbers never appear in the packet, and are not to be confused with sequence numbers, labels or any other identifier that appears in the packet. they simply indicate the generation number of the original packet so that its passage through the network fragment can be identified to the reader." {6: 1, 31: 1, 124: 1, 67: 1, 53: 1, 8: 1, 79: 2, 90: 3, 51: 3, 130: 2, 62: 4, 85: 4, 68: 3, 35: 3, 110: 3, 91: 5, 114: 3, 97: 3, 13: 3, 38: 4, 26: 3, 98: 2, 54: 2, 127: 3, 96: 3, 64: 2, 30: 4, 61: 5, 55: 2, 27: 2, 15: 3, 52: 2, 129: 3, 115: 3, 84: 2, 76: 4, 87: 3, 131: 5, 102: 3, 113: 5, 99: 2, 36: 3, 24: 2, 72: 4} {161: 1, 264: 1, 328: 1, 392: 1, 369: 1, 220: 1, 221: 1, 1: 8, 4: 2, 9: 3, 10: 3, 15: 3, 24: 2, 25: 4, 26: 4, 27: 3, 39: 4, 43: 3, 49: 6, 50: 5, 58: 5, 59: 2, 64: 3, 69: 2, 81: 5, 82: 4, 86: 3, 96: 4, 97: 3, 100: 7, 108: 3, 109: 4, 110: 4, 111: 2, 114: 3, 115: 4, 116: 3, 118: 5, 119: 4, 120: 3, 121: 3, 122: 4, 123: 3, 124: 3, 128: 4, 129: 4, 130: 5, 132: 2, 136: 2, 145: 2, 147: 4, 151: 4, 152: 4, 154: 3, 156: 2, 162: 2, 165: 3, 168: 4, 169: 3, 172: 3, 180: 4, 184: 3, 187: 5, 188: 4, 191: 3, 194: 2, 202: 3, 203: 4, 206: 2, 207: 3, 217: 3, 218: 7, 222: 4, 224: 3, 227: 5, 229: 3, 234: 5, 235: 2, 241: 2, 242: 2, 243: 2, 244: 4, 245: 2, 248: 4, 250: 4, 258: 10, 262: 4, 263: 5, 267: 3, 270: 3, 272: 3, 273: 3, 287: 3, 289: 3, 291: 5, 299: 5, 300: 3, 304: 3, 309: 2, 314: 2, 315: 3, 320: 3, 323: 2, 327: 4, 329: 2, 330: 9, 334: 2, 335: 3, 341: 5, 342: 6, 347: 5, 348: 5, 350: 5, 351: 5, 352: 3, 353: 3, 354: 2, 358: 3, 365: 3, 366: 2, 371: 7, 372: 5, 376: 2, 384: 5, 385: 4, 386: 3, 387: 3, 393: 2, 396: 6, 397: 6, 398: 5, 402: 3} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 52 "Customer Equipment CE1 sends a packet into the DetNet enabled MPLS network. This is packet (1). Edge Node EN1 encapsulates the packet as a DetNet Packet and sends it to Relay node R1 (packet 1.1). EN1 makes a copy of the packet (1.2), encapsulates it and sends this copy to Relay node R4." Similar structure and changes as in IP over TSN . Service protection interworking is out - of - scope . d275ba154e2b7c82eb3ec9175d790214b0e60d3f d275ba154e2b7c82eb3ec9175d790214b0e60d3f draft-ietf-detnet-mpls-over-tsn 36330b0a2474d7598e4665a8ac8b8fbd2c0215a7c2971183879990c1948b22ae ['899fe49efb71ff0aa7ef3f05ac18bd5bfd87fffe13b5c1288db3416e022be147', 'ab93afb1ce53a91a86685ff579055185d9f7a6798d6effa52aec9838538bdf15', '42b1f3f30d1cae8db1fcb526de2f77c170c19e3508250cf37a94100514f567e6', '55bdece02c98962a77682e9b55671178537e5663507c4ff9c5409df14c7a69af', '438eb33c698936afb27ac820b5f68528ff155bd5a6927b63e6259a419be2e1a9', 'ed695265f24af924853cf42b909ea782e13659dd90448b1a4bc4800314d00f86', 'a8ff14472a8fa48bacdc11d7089a9d1054c0a786f6152f510b5d4092c22e121f', '16375944152e6c3e73492437880fe39d7f0123a9292d062e8e9c7d317e4b878f', '1076eab6753435c114e8a720c951b03da6d4e1bbbf1290f8d58ad7f97a0b8c64', '7f7e8733165742e4d8be8dacffe0453045841d70140ba0a9defc1c0d78e8d05c', '44e497e2df0461bad9215c57918855022435eb6e28266916161de3f7902bb352', '0cf3a218420317d1ac2dbe66fe8b3fa5930ee4bfb0f9a25d7059f70b672356ee', 'c2db650dc38549201f151a0fea9030968aca0fd468d0d6d3fe3d9b520ee551e6', '03d4609f1627eb905bc43957db60d2c0ce0b1cf99c6fa8617c936e7170195470', 'f07257d89bd36957d381df4c3d975b976581225d3b0e93b797f231549f809c45', 'cee8a70bcfc00996a87843150f50858ee830d692ae4678e50d5c074d43ff657c', 'b451f1bf9eed3bec2c5e20d4e9122ce6f31202fc68127f2881d2d860e9726365', '5c5fe7e7a382ebc21f89d163deb3520302620f0efe90cedb8592a80b5ef6a394', 'fb2b9389e1455c6d64ae19158396d767d88969013b14075bcfdcc764f610108c', '769d6aec4ab7308875a36f480f397628b2febffed4bc76dc77efd81374577a2f', '36330b0a2474d7598e4665a8ac8b8fbd2c0215a7c2971183879990c1948b22ae', 'ae3bdd3a81d96e4aaa02f7d597a2684146f3af75b743bde8e31c3cf5883707db', 'c63eee4f2d995789dc0fd3300a044e2c8d77d7fd6727e4e7a7bcc637c837d612', '564787d2556d259dabeaa6c5e2a64e9bdbfcf4ff124eb58795eebefb601fdb30', '5324bae9de9c301e9f6c475f9348fb2673813fe613070bb08ffd35c8a0e54204', 'f77d05a1e065348650e7579a3e2688468825cb7764599c8eb0f82836f4f3d9f3', 'a9668d2ded433c7b0eab698458e6b8fd13e4ddabe80417a884a66eda5893de8a', '75621d6a5adc1618337a02bf68856f7e1f8591c46fda003f39100f58bad112e3', '87cbb111ae00db5fad0458158af7d51a3ea8cb3e02e091c32f02ae366900eabb', '26e942b0353fee8f5ac0a2c2e26c9b695c50b35c501eeb4bff343b1648b5cebc', '036168e918418eb807bc3efd361a8e66067192564da41e30e076d22be0f87935', 'a6bd7b8f71e0d959503da2efa6fee412d7e71fb1f54e482a89a61c2a8d6bc691', '9829b13faebde69c2279c38cd54d524aa31acfdcc1cfba7910b9d69caa42e0dd', '2755ae7cda161df0c24e1fa9f1c3308bc9ef81a599d859668490484290ca72f4'] A "customer equipment ce1 sends a packet into the detnet enabled mpls network. this is packet (1). edge node en1 encapsulates the packet as a detnet packet and sends it to relay node r1 (packet 1.1). en1 makes a copy of the packet (1.2), encapsulates it and sends this copy to relay node r4." {6: 1, 31: 1, 124: 1, 67: 1, 53: 1, 8: 1, 79: 2, 90: 3, 51: 3, 130: 2, 62: 4, 85: 4, 68: 3, 35: 3, 110: 3, 91: 5, 114: 3, 97: 3, 13: 3, 38: 4, 26: 3, 98: 2, 54: 2, 127: 3, 96: 3, 64: 2, 30: 4, 61: 5, 55: 2, 27: 2, 15: 3, 52: 2, 129: 3, 115: 3, 84: 2, 76: 4, 87: 3, 131: 5, 102: 3, 113: 5, 99: 2, 36: 3, 24: 2, 72: 4} {161: 1, 264: 1, 328: 1, 392: 1, 369: 1, 220: 1, 221: 1, 1: 8, 4: 2, 9: 3, 10: 3, 15: 3, 24: 2, 25: 4, 26: 4, 27: 3, 39: 4, 43: 3, 49: 6, 50: 5, 58: 5, 59: 2, 64: 3, 69: 2, 81: 5, 82: 4, 86: 3, 96: 4, 97: 3, 100: 7, 108: 3, 109: 4, 110: 4, 111: 2, 114: 3, 115: 4, 116: 3, 118: 5, 119: 4, 120: 3, 121: 3, 122: 4, 123: 3, 124: 3, 128: 4, 129: 4, 130: 5, 132: 2, 136: 2, 145: 2, 147: 4, 151: 4, 152: 4, 154: 3, 156: 2, 162: 2, 165: 3, 168: 4, 169: 3, 172: 3, 180: 4, 184: 3, 187: 5, 188: 4, 191: 3, 194: 2, 202: 3, 203: 4, 206: 2, 207: 3, 217: 3, 218: 7, 222: 4, 224: 3, 227: 5, 229: 3, 234: 5, 235: 2, 241: 2, 242: 2, 243: 2, 244: 4, 245: 2, 248: 4, 250: 4, 258: 10, 262: 4, 263: 5, 267: 3, 270: 3, 272: 3, 273: 3, 287: 3, 289: 3, 291: 5, 299: 5, 300: 3, 304: 3, 309: 2, 314: 2, 315: 3, 320: 3, 323: 2, 327: 4, 329: 2, 330: 9, 334: 2, 335: 3, 341: 5, 342: 6, 347: 5, 348: 5, 350: 5, 351: 5, 352: 3, 353: 3, 354: 2, 358: 3, 365: 3, 366: 2, 371: 7, 372: 5, 376: 2, 384: 5, 385: 4, 386: 3, 387: 3, 393: 2, 396: 6, 397: 6, 398: 5, 402: 3} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 52 "Note that along the MPLS path from EN1 to R1 there may be zero or more LSRs which, for clarity, are not shown. The same is true for any other path between two DetNet entities shown in fig_mpls_example." Similar structure and changes as in IP over TSN . Service protection interworking is out - of - scope . d275ba154e2b7c82eb3ec9175d790214b0e60d3f d275ba154e2b7c82eb3ec9175d790214b0e60d3f draft-ietf-detnet-mpls-over-tsn 7f7e8733165742e4d8be8dacffe0453045841d70140ba0a9defc1c0d78e8d05c ['899fe49efb71ff0aa7ef3f05ac18bd5bfd87fffe13b5c1288db3416e022be147', 'ab93afb1ce53a91a86685ff579055185d9f7a6798d6effa52aec9838538bdf15', '42b1f3f30d1cae8db1fcb526de2f77c170c19e3508250cf37a94100514f567e6', '55bdece02c98962a77682e9b55671178537e5663507c4ff9c5409df14c7a69af', '438eb33c698936afb27ac820b5f68528ff155bd5a6927b63e6259a419be2e1a9', 'ed695265f24af924853cf42b909ea782e13659dd90448b1a4bc4800314d00f86', 'a8ff14472a8fa48bacdc11d7089a9d1054c0a786f6152f510b5d4092c22e121f', '16375944152e6c3e73492437880fe39d7f0123a9292d062e8e9c7d317e4b878f', '1076eab6753435c114e8a720c951b03da6d4e1bbbf1290f8d58ad7f97a0b8c64', '7f7e8733165742e4d8be8dacffe0453045841d70140ba0a9defc1c0d78e8d05c', '44e497e2df0461bad9215c57918855022435eb6e28266916161de3f7902bb352', '0cf3a218420317d1ac2dbe66fe8b3fa5930ee4bfb0f9a25d7059f70b672356ee', 'c2db650dc38549201f151a0fea9030968aca0fd468d0d6d3fe3d9b520ee551e6', '03d4609f1627eb905bc43957db60d2c0ce0b1cf99c6fa8617c936e7170195470', 'f07257d89bd36957d381df4c3d975b976581225d3b0e93b797f231549f809c45', 'cee8a70bcfc00996a87843150f50858ee830d692ae4678e50d5c074d43ff657c', 'b451f1bf9eed3bec2c5e20d4e9122ce6f31202fc68127f2881d2d860e9726365', '5c5fe7e7a382ebc21f89d163deb3520302620f0efe90cedb8592a80b5ef6a394', 'fb2b9389e1455c6d64ae19158396d767d88969013b14075bcfdcc764f610108c', '769d6aec4ab7308875a36f480f397628b2febffed4bc76dc77efd81374577a2f', '36330b0a2474d7598e4665a8ac8b8fbd2c0215a7c2971183879990c1948b22ae', 'ae3bdd3a81d96e4aaa02f7d597a2684146f3af75b743bde8e31c3cf5883707db', 'c63eee4f2d995789dc0fd3300a044e2c8d77d7fd6727e4e7a7bcc637c837d612', '564787d2556d259dabeaa6c5e2a64e9bdbfcf4ff124eb58795eebefb601fdb30', '5324bae9de9c301e9f6c475f9348fb2673813fe613070bb08ffd35c8a0e54204', 'f77d05a1e065348650e7579a3e2688468825cb7764599c8eb0f82836f4f3d9f3', 'a9668d2ded433c7b0eab698458e6b8fd13e4ddabe80417a884a66eda5893de8a', '75621d6a5adc1618337a02bf68856f7e1f8591c46fda003f39100f58bad112e3', '87cbb111ae00db5fad0458158af7d51a3ea8cb3e02e091c32f02ae366900eabb', '26e942b0353fee8f5ac0a2c2e26c9b695c50b35c501eeb4bff343b1648b5cebc', '036168e918418eb807bc3efd361a8e66067192564da41e30e076d22be0f87935', 'a6bd7b8f71e0d959503da2efa6fee412d7e71fb1f54e482a89a61c2a8d6bc691', '9829b13faebde69c2279c38cd54d524aa31acfdcc1cfba7910b9d69caa42e0dd', '2755ae7cda161df0c24e1fa9f1c3308bc9ef81a599d859668490484290ca72f4'] A "note that along the mpls path from en1 to r1 there may be zero or more lsrs which, for clarity, are not shown. the same is true for any other path between two detnet entities shown in fig_mpls_example." {6: 1, 31: 1, 124: 1, 67: 1, 53: 1, 8: 1, 79: 2, 90: 3, 51: 3, 130: 2, 62: 4, 85: 4, 68: 3, 35: 3, 110: 3, 91: 5, 114: 3, 97: 3, 13: 3, 38: 4, 26: 3, 98: 2, 54: 2, 127: 3, 96: 3, 64: 2, 30: 4, 61: 5, 55: 2, 27: 2, 15: 3, 52: 2, 129: 3, 115: 3, 84: 2, 76: 4, 87: 3, 131: 5, 102: 3, 113: 5, 99: 2, 36: 3, 24: 2, 72: 4} {161: 1, 264: 1, 328: 1, 392: 1, 369: 1, 220: 1, 221: 1, 1: 8, 4: 2, 9: 3, 10: 3, 15: 3, 24: 2, 25: 4, 26: 4, 27: 3, 39: 4, 43: 3, 49: 6, 50: 5, 58: 5, 59: 2, 64: 3, 69: 2, 81: 5, 82: 4, 86: 3, 96: 4, 97: 3, 100: 7, 108: 3, 109: 4, 110: 4, 111: 2, 114: 3, 115: 4, 116: 3, 118: 5, 119: 4, 120: 3, 121: 3, 122: 4, 123: 3, 124: 3, 128: 4, 129: 4, 130: 5, 132: 2, 136: 2, 145: 2, 147: 4, 151: 4, 152: 4, 154: 3, 156: 2, 162: 2, 165: 3, 168: 4, 169: 3, 172: 3, 180: 4, 184: 3, 187: 5, 188: 4, 191: 3, 194: 2, 202: 3, 203: 4, 206: 2, 207: 3, 217: 3, 218: 7, 222: 4, 224: 3, 227: 5, 229: 3, 234: 5, 235: 2, 241: 2, 242: 2, 243: 2, 244: 4, 245: 2, 248: 4, 250: 4, 258: 10, 262: 4, 263: 5, 267: 3, 270: 3, 272: 3, 273: 3, 287: 3, 289: 3, 291: 5, 299: 5, 300: 3, 304: 3, 309: 2, 314: 2, 315: 3, 320: 3, 323: 2, 327: 4, 329: 2, 330: 9, 334: 2, 335: 3, 341: 5, 342: 6, 347: 5, 348: 5, 350: 5, 351: 5, 352: 3, 353: 3, 354: 2, 358: 3, 365: 3, 366: 2, 371: 7, 372: 5, 376: 2, 384: 5, 385: 4, 386: 3, 387: 3, 393: 2, 396: 6, 397: 6, 398: 5, 402: 3} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 52 "Relay node R4 has been configured to send one copy of the packet to Relay Node R2 (packet 1.2.1) and one copy to Edge Node EN2 (packet 1.2.2)." Similar structure and changes as in IP over TSN . Service protection interworking is out - of - scope . d275ba154e2b7c82eb3ec9175d790214b0e60d3f d275ba154e2b7c82eb3ec9175d790214b0e60d3f draft-ietf-detnet-mpls-over-tsn 438eb33c698936afb27ac820b5f68528ff155bd5a6927b63e6259a419be2e1a9 ['899fe49efb71ff0aa7ef3f05ac18bd5bfd87fffe13b5c1288db3416e022be147', 'ab93afb1ce53a91a86685ff579055185d9f7a6798d6effa52aec9838538bdf15', '42b1f3f30d1cae8db1fcb526de2f77c170c19e3508250cf37a94100514f567e6', '55bdece02c98962a77682e9b55671178537e5663507c4ff9c5409df14c7a69af', '438eb33c698936afb27ac820b5f68528ff155bd5a6927b63e6259a419be2e1a9', 'ed695265f24af924853cf42b909ea782e13659dd90448b1a4bc4800314d00f86', 'a8ff14472a8fa48bacdc11d7089a9d1054c0a786f6152f510b5d4092c22e121f', '16375944152e6c3e73492437880fe39d7f0123a9292d062e8e9c7d317e4b878f', '1076eab6753435c114e8a720c951b03da6d4e1bbbf1290f8d58ad7f97a0b8c64', '7f7e8733165742e4d8be8dacffe0453045841d70140ba0a9defc1c0d78e8d05c', '44e497e2df0461bad9215c57918855022435eb6e28266916161de3f7902bb352', '0cf3a218420317d1ac2dbe66fe8b3fa5930ee4bfb0f9a25d7059f70b672356ee', 'c2db650dc38549201f151a0fea9030968aca0fd468d0d6d3fe3d9b520ee551e6', '03d4609f1627eb905bc43957db60d2c0ce0b1cf99c6fa8617c936e7170195470', 'f07257d89bd36957d381df4c3d975b976581225d3b0e93b797f231549f809c45', 'cee8a70bcfc00996a87843150f50858ee830d692ae4678e50d5c074d43ff657c', 'b451f1bf9eed3bec2c5e20d4e9122ce6f31202fc68127f2881d2d860e9726365', '5c5fe7e7a382ebc21f89d163deb3520302620f0efe90cedb8592a80b5ef6a394', 'fb2b9389e1455c6d64ae19158396d767d88969013b14075bcfdcc764f610108c', '769d6aec4ab7308875a36f480f397628b2febffed4bc76dc77efd81374577a2f', '36330b0a2474d7598e4665a8ac8b8fbd2c0215a7c2971183879990c1948b22ae', 'ae3bdd3a81d96e4aaa02f7d597a2684146f3af75b743bde8e31c3cf5883707db', 'c63eee4f2d995789dc0fd3300a044e2c8d77d7fd6727e4e7a7bcc637c837d612', '564787d2556d259dabeaa6c5e2a64e9bdbfcf4ff124eb58795eebefb601fdb30', '5324bae9de9c301e9f6c475f9348fb2673813fe613070bb08ffd35c8a0e54204', 'f77d05a1e065348650e7579a3e2688468825cb7764599c8eb0f82836f4f3d9f3', 'a9668d2ded433c7b0eab698458e6b8fd13e4ddabe80417a884a66eda5893de8a', '75621d6a5adc1618337a02bf68856f7e1f8591c46fda003f39100f58bad112e3', '87cbb111ae00db5fad0458158af7d51a3ea8cb3e02e091c32f02ae366900eabb', '26e942b0353fee8f5ac0a2c2e26c9b695c50b35c501eeb4bff343b1648b5cebc', '036168e918418eb807bc3efd361a8e66067192564da41e30e076d22be0f87935', 'a6bd7b8f71e0d959503da2efa6fee412d7e71fb1f54e482a89a61c2a8d6bc691', '9829b13faebde69c2279c38cd54d524aa31acfdcc1cfba7910b9d69caa42e0dd', '2755ae7cda161df0c24e1fa9f1c3308bc9ef81a599d859668490484290ca72f4'] A "relay node r4 has been configured to send one copy of the packet to relay node r2 (packet 1.2.1) and one copy to edge node en2 (packet 1.2.2)." {6: 1, 31: 1, 124: 1, 67: 1, 53: 1, 8: 1, 79: 2, 90: 3, 51: 3, 130: 2, 62: 4, 85: 4, 68: 3, 35: 3, 110: 3, 91: 5, 114: 3, 97: 3, 13: 3, 38: 4, 26: 3, 98: 2, 54: 2, 127: 3, 96: 3, 64: 2, 30: 4, 61: 5, 55: 2, 27: 2, 15: 3, 52: 2, 129: 3, 115: 3, 84: 2, 76: 4, 87: 3, 131: 5, 102: 3, 113: 5, 99: 2, 36: 3, 24: 2, 72: 4} {161: 1, 264: 1, 328: 1, 392: 1, 369: 1, 220: 1, 221: 1, 1: 8, 4: 2, 9: 3, 10: 3, 15: 3, 24: 2, 25: 4, 26: 4, 27: 3, 39: 4, 43: 3, 49: 6, 50: 5, 58: 5, 59: 2, 64: 3, 69: 2, 81: 5, 82: 4, 86: 3, 96: 4, 97: 3, 100: 7, 108: 3, 109: 4, 110: 4, 111: 2, 114: 3, 115: 4, 116: 3, 118: 5, 119: 4, 120: 3, 121: 3, 122: 4, 123: 3, 124: 3, 128: 4, 129: 4, 130: 5, 132: 2, 136: 2, 145: 2, 147: 4, 151: 4, 152: 4, 154: 3, 156: 2, 162: 2, 165: 3, 168: 4, 169: 3, 172: 3, 180: 4, 184: 3, 187: 5, 188: 4, 191: 3, 194: 2, 202: 3, 203: 4, 206: 2, 207: 3, 217: 3, 218: 7, 222: 4, 224: 3, 227: 5, 229: 3, 234: 5, 235: 2, 241: 2, 242: 2, 243: 2, 244: 4, 245: 2, 248: 4, 250: 4, 258: 10, 262: 4, 263: 5, 267: 3, 270: 3, 272: 3, 273: 3, 287: 3, 289: 3, 291: 5, 299: 5, 300: 3, 304: 3, 309: 2, 314: 2, 315: 3, 320: 3, 323: 2, 327: 4, 329: 2, 330: 9, 334: 2, 335: 3, 341: 5, 342: 6, 347: 5, 348: 5, 350: 5, 351: 5, 352: 3, 353: 3, 354: 2, 358: 3, 365: 3, 366: 2, 371: 7, 372: 5, 376: 2, 384: 5, 385: 4, 386: 3, 387: 3, 393: 2, 396: 6, 397: 6, 398: 5, 402: 3} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 52 "R2 receives packet copy 1.2.1 before packet copy 1.1 arrives, and, having been configured to perform packet elimination on this DetNet flow, forwards packet 1.2.1 to Relay Node R3. Packet copy 1.1 is of no further use and so is discarded by R2." Similar structure and changes as in IP over TSN . Service protection interworking is out - of - scope . d275ba154e2b7c82eb3ec9175d790214b0e60d3f d275ba154e2b7c82eb3ec9175d790214b0e60d3f draft-ietf-detnet-mpls-over-tsn 5c5fe7e7a382ebc21f89d163deb3520302620f0efe90cedb8592a80b5ef6a394 ['899fe49efb71ff0aa7ef3f05ac18bd5bfd87fffe13b5c1288db3416e022be147', 'ab93afb1ce53a91a86685ff579055185d9f7a6798d6effa52aec9838538bdf15', '42b1f3f30d1cae8db1fcb526de2f77c170c19e3508250cf37a94100514f567e6', '55bdece02c98962a77682e9b55671178537e5663507c4ff9c5409df14c7a69af', '438eb33c698936afb27ac820b5f68528ff155bd5a6927b63e6259a419be2e1a9', 'ed695265f24af924853cf42b909ea782e13659dd90448b1a4bc4800314d00f86', 'a8ff14472a8fa48bacdc11d7089a9d1054c0a786f6152f510b5d4092c22e121f', '16375944152e6c3e73492437880fe39d7f0123a9292d062e8e9c7d317e4b878f', '1076eab6753435c114e8a720c951b03da6d4e1bbbf1290f8d58ad7f97a0b8c64', '7f7e8733165742e4d8be8dacffe0453045841d70140ba0a9defc1c0d78e8d05c', '44e497e2df0461bad9215c57918855022435eb6e28266916161de3f7902bb352', '0cf3a218420317d1ac2dbe66fe8b3fa5930ee4bfb0f9a25d7059f70b672356ee', 'c2db650dc38549201f151a0fea9030968aca0fd468d0d6d3fe3d9b520ee551e6', '03d4609f1627eb905bc43957db60d2c0ce0b1cf99c6fa8617c936e7170195470', 'f07257d89bd36957d381df4c3d975b976581225d3b0e93b797f231549f809c45', 'cee8a70bcfc00996a87843150f50858ee830d692ae4678e50d5c074d43ff657c', 'b451f1bf9eed3bec2c5e20d4e9122ce6f31202fc68127f2881d2d860e9726365', '5c5fe7e7a382ebc21f89d163deb3520302620f0efe90cedb8592a80b5ef6a394', 'fb2b9389e1455c6d64ae19158396d767d88969013b14075bcfdcc764f610108c', '769d6aec4ab7308875a36f480f397628b2febffed4bc76dc77efd81374577a2f', '36330b0a2474d7598e4665a8ac8b8fbd2c0215a7c2971183879990c1948b22ae', 'ae3bdd3a81d96e4aaa02f7d597a2684146f3af75b743bde8e31c3cf5883707db', 'c63eee4f2d995789dc0fd3300a044e2c8d77d7fd6727e4e7a7bcc637c837d612', '564787d2556d259dabeaa6c5e2a64e9bdbfcf4ff124eb58795eebefb601fdb30', '5324bae9de9c301e9f6c475f9348fb2673813fe613070bb08ffd35c8a0e54204', 'f77d05a1e065348650e7579a3e2688468825cb7764599c8eb0f82836f4f3d9f3', 'a9668d2ded433c7b0eab698458e6b8fd13e4ddabe80417a884a66eda5893de8a', '75621d6a5adc1618337a02bf68856f7e1f8591c46fda003f39100f58bad112e3', '87cbb111ae00db5fad0458158af7d51a3ea8cb3e02e091c32f02ae366900eabb', '26e942b0353fee8f5ac0a2c2e26c9b695c50b35c501eeb4bff343b1648b5cebc', '036168e918418eb807bc3efd361a8e66067192564da41e30e076d22be0f87935', 'a6bd7b8f71e0d959503da2efa6fee412d7e71fb1f54e482a89a61c2a8d6bc691', '9829b13faebde69c2279c38cd54d524aa31acfdcc1cfba7910b9d69caa42e0dd', '2755ae7cda161df0c24e1fa9f1c3308bc9ef81a599d859668490484290ca72f4'] A "r2 receives packet copy 1.2.1 before packet copy 1.1 arrives, and, having been configured to perform packet elimination on this detnet flow, forwards packet 1.2.1 to relay node r3. packet copy 1.1 is of no further use and so is discarded by r2." {6: 1, 31: 1, 124: 1, 67: 1, 53: 1, 8: 1, 79: 2, 90: 3, 51: 3, 130: 2, 62: 4, 85: 4, 68: 3, 35: 3, 110: 3, 91: 5, 114: 3, 97: 3, 13: 3, 38: 4, 26: 3, 98: 2, 54: 2, 127: 3, 96: 3, 64: 2, 30: 4, 61: 5, 55: 2, 27: 2, 15: 3, 52: 2, 129: 3, 115: 3, 84: 2, 76: 4, 87: 3, 131: 5, 102: 3, 113: 5, 99: 2, 36: 3, 24: 2, 72: 4} {161: 1, 264: 1, 328: 1, 392: 1, 369: 1, 220: 1, 221: 1, 1: 8, 4: 2, 9: 3, 10: 3, 15: 3, 24: 2, 25: 4, 26: 4, 27: 3, 39: 4, 43: 3, 49: 6, 50: 5, 58: 5, 59: 2, 64: 3, 69: 2, 81: 5, 82: 4, 86: 3, 96: 4, 97: 3, 100: 7, 108: 3, 109: 4, 110: 4, 111: 2, 114: 3, 115: 4, 116: 3, 118: 5, 119: 4, 120: 3, 121: 3, 122: 4, 123: 3, 124: 3, 128: 4, 129: 4, 130: 5, 132: 2, 136: 2, 145: 2, 147: 4, 151: 4, 152: 4, 154: 3, 156: 2, 162: 2, 165: 3, 168: 4, 169: 3, 172: 3, 180: 4, 184: 3, 187: 5, 188: 4, 191: 3, 194: 2, 202: 3, 203: 4, 206: 2, 207: 3, 217: 3, 218: 7, 222: 4, 224: 3, 227: 5, 229: 3, 234: 5, 235: 2, 241: 2, 242: 2, 243: 2, 244: 4, 245: 2, 248: 4, 250: 4, 258: 10, 262: 4, 263: 5, 267: 3, 270: 3, 272: 3, 273: 3, 287: 3, 289: 3, 291: 5, 299: 5, 300: 3, 304: 3, 309: 2, 314: 2, 315: 3, 320: 3, 323: 2, 327: 4, 329: 2, 330: 9, 334: 2, 335: 3, 341: 5, 342: 6, 347: 5, 348: 5, 350: 5, 351: 5, 352: 3, 353: 3, 354: 2, 358: 3, 365: 3, 366: 2, 371: 7, 372: 5, 376: 2, 384: 5, 385: 4, 386: 3, 387: 3, 393: 2, 396: 6, 397: 6, 398: 5, 402: 3} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 52 "Edge Node EN2 receives packet copy 1.2.2 from R4 before it receives packet copy 1.2.1 from R2 via relay Node R3. EN2 therefore strips any DetNet encapsulation from packet copy 1.2.2 and forwards the packet to CE2. When EN2 receives the later packet copy 1.2.1 this is discarded." Similar structure and changes as in IP over TSN . Service protection interworking is out - of - scope . d275ba154e2b7c82eb3ec9175d790214b0e60d3f d275ba154e2b7c82eb3ec9175d790214b0e60d3f draft-ietf-detnet-mpls-over-tsn 75621d6a5adc1618337a02bf68856f7e1f8591c46fda003f39100f58bad112e3 ['899fe49efb71ff0aa7ef3f05ac18bd5bfd87fffe13b5c1288db3416e022be147', 'ab93afb1ce53a91a86685ff579055185d9f7a6798d6effa52aec9838538bdf15', '42b1f3f30d1cae8db1fcb526de2f77c170c19e3508250cf37a94100514f567e6', '55bdece02c98962a77682e9b55671178537e5663507c4ff9c5409df14c7a69af', '438eb33c698936afb27ac820b5f68528ff155bd5a6927b63e6259a419be2e1a9', 'ed695265f24af924853cf42b909ea782e13659dd90448b1a4bc4800314d00f86', 'a8ff14472a8fa48bacdc11d7089a9d1054c0a786f6152f510b5d4092c22e121f', '16375944152e6c3e73492437880fe39d7f0123a9292d062e8e9c7d317e4b878f', '1076eab6753435c114e8a720c951b03da6d4e1bbbf1290f8d58ad7f97a0b8c64', '7f7e8733165742e4d8be8dacffe0453045841d70140ba0a9defc1c0d78e8d05c', '44e497e2df0461bad9215c57918855022435eb6e28266916161de3f7902bb352', '0cf3a218420317d1ac2dbe66fe8b3fa5930ee4bfb0f9a25d7059f70b672356ee', 'c2db650dc38549201f151a0fea9030968aca0fd468d0d6d3fe3d9b520ee551e6', '03d4609f1627eb905bc43957db60d2c0ce0b1cf99c6fa8617c936e7170195470', 'f07257d89bd36957d381df4c3d975b976581225d3b0e93b797f231549f809c45', 'cee8a70bcfc00996a87843150f50858ee830d692ae4678e50d5c074d43ff657c', 'b451f1bf9eed3bec2c5e20d4e9122ce6f31202fc68127f2881d2d860e9726365', '5c5fe7e7a382ebc21f89d163deb3520302620f0efe90cedb8592a80b5ef6a394', 'fb2b9389e1455c6d64ae19158396d767d88969013b14075bcfdcc764f610108c', '769d6aec4ab7308875a36f480f397628b2febffed4bc76dc77efd81374577a2f', '36330b0a2474d7598e4665a8ac8b8fbd2c0215a7c2971183879990c1948b22ae', 'ae3bdd3a81d96e4aaa02f7d597a2684146f3af75b743bde8e31c3cf5883707db', 'c63eee4f2d995789dc0fd3300a044e2c8d77d7fd6727e4e7a7bcc637c837d612', '564787d2556d259dabeaa6c5e2a64e9bdbfcf4ff124eb58795eebefb601fdb30', '5324bae9de9c301e9f6c475f9348fb2673813fe613070bb08ffd35c8a0e54204', 'f77d05a1e065348650e7579a3e2688468825cb7764599c8eb0f82836f4f3d9f3', 'a9668d2ded433c7b0eab698458e6b8fd13e4ddabe80417a884a66eda5893de8a', '75621d6a5adc1618337a02bf68856f7e1f8591c46fda003f39100f58bad112e3', '87cbb111ae00db5fad0458158af7d51a3ea8cb3e02e091c32f02ae366900eabb', '26e942b0353fee8f5ac0a2c2e26c9b695c50b35c501eeb4bff343b1648b5cebc', '036168e918418eb807bc3efd361a8e66067192564da41e30e076d22be0f87935', 'a6bd7b8f71e0d959503da2efa6fee412d7e71fb1f54e482a89a61c2a8d6bc691', '9829b13faebde69c2279c38cd54d524aa31acfdcc1cfba7910b9d69caa42e0dd', '2755ae7cda161df0c24e1fa9f1c3308bc9ef81a599d859668490484290ca72f4'] A "edge node en2 receives packet copy 1.2.2 from r4 before it receives packet copy 1.2.1 from r2 via relay node r3. en2 therefore strips any detnet encapsulation from packet copy 1.2.2 and forwards the packet to ce2. when en2 receives the later packet copy 1.2.1 this is discarded." {6: 1, 31: 1, 124: 1, 67: 1, 53: 1, 8: 1, 79: 2, 90: 3, 51: 3, 130: 2, 62: 4, 85: 4, 68: 3, 35: 3, 110: 3, 91: 5, 114: 3, 97: 3, 13: 3, 38: 4, 26: 3, 98: 2, 54: 2, 127: 3, 96: 3, 64: 2, 30: 4, 61: 5, 55: 2, 27: 2, 15: 3, 52: 2, 129: 3, 115: 3, 84: 2, 76: 4, 87: 3, 131: 5, 102: 3, 113: 5, 99: 2, 36: 3, 24: 2, 72: 4} {161: 1, 264: 1, 328: 1, 392: 1, 369: 1, 220: 1, 221: 1, 1: 8, 4: 2, 9: 3, 10: 3, 15: 3, 24: 2, 25: 4, 26: 4, 27: 3, 39: 4, 43: 3, 49: 6, 50: 5, 58: 5, 59: 2, 64: 3, 69: 2, 81: 5, 82: 4, 86: 3, 96: 4, 97: 3, 100: 7, 108: 3, 109: 4, 110: 4, 111: 2, 114: 3, 115: 4, 116: 3, 118: 5, 119: 4, 120: 3, 121: 3, 122: 4, 123: 3, 124: 3, 128: 4, 129: 4, 130: 5, 132: 2, 136: 2, 145: 2, 147: 4, 151: 4, 152: 4, 154: 3, 156: 2, 162: 2, 165: 3, 168: 4, 169: 3, 172: 3, 180: 4, 184: 3, 187: 5, 188: 4, 191: 3, 194: 2, 202: 3, 203: 4, 206: 2, 207: 3, 217: 3, 218: 7, 222: 4, 224: 3, 227: 5, 229: 3, 234: 5, 235: 2, 241: 2, 242: 2, 243: 2, 244: 4, 245: 2, 248: 4, 250: 4, 258: 10, 262: 4, 263: 5, 267: 3, 270: 3, 272: 3, 273: 3, 287: 3, 289: 3, 291: 5, 299: 5, 300: 3, 304: 3, 309: 2, 314: 2, 315: 3, 320: 3, 323: 2, 327: 4, 329: 2, 330: 9, 334: 2, 335: 3, 341: 5, 342: 6, 347: 5, 348: 5, 350: 5, 351: 5, 352: 3, 353: 3, 354: 2, 358: 3, 365: 3, 366: 2, 371: 7, 372: 5, 376: 2, 384: 5, 385: 4, 386: 3, 387: 3, 393: 2, 396: 6, 397: 6, 398: 5, 402: 3} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 52 "The above is of course illustrative of many network scenarios that can be configured. Between a pair of relay nodes there may be one or more transit nodes that simply forward the DetNet traffic, but these are omitted for clarity." Similar structure and changes as in IP over TSN . Service protection interworking is out - of - scope . d275ba154e2b7c82eb3ec9175d790214b0e60d3f d275ba154e2b7c82eb3ec9175d790214b0e60d3f draft-ietf-detnet-mpls-over-tsn ab93afb1ce53a91a86685ff579055185d9f7a6798d6effa52aec9838538bdf15 ['899fe49efb71ff0aa7ef3f05ac18bd5bfd87fffe13b5c1288db3416e022be147', 'ab93afb1ce53a91a86685ff579055185d9f7a6798d6effa52aec9838538bdf15', '42b1f3f30d1cae8db1fcb526de2f77c170c19e3508250cf37a94100514f567e6', '55bdece02c98962a77682e9b55671178537e5663507c4ff9c5409df14c7a69af', '438eb33c698936afb27ac820b5f68528ff155bd5a6927b63e6259a419be2e1a9', 'ed695265f24af924853cf42b909ea782e13659dd90448b1a4bc4800314d00f86', 'a8ff14472a8fa48bacdc11d7089a9d1054c0a786f6152f510b5d4092c22e121f', '16375944152e6c3e73492437880fe39d7f0123a9292d062e8e9c7d317e4b878f', '1076eab6753435c114e8a720c951b03da6d4e1bbbf1290f8d58ad7f97a0b8c64', '7f7e8733165742e4d8be8dacffe0453045841d70140ba0a9defc1c0d78e8d05c', '44e497e2df0461bad9215c57918855022435eb6e28266916161de3f7902bb352', '0cf3a218420317d1ac2dbe66fe8b3fa5930ee4bfb0f9a25d7059f70b672356ee', 'c2db650dc38549201f151a0fea9030968aca0fd468d0d6d3fe3d9b520ee551e6', '03d4609f1627eb905bc43957db60d2c0ce0b1cf99c6fa8617c936e7170195470', 'f07257d89bd36957d381df4c3d975b976581225d3b0e93b797f231549f809c45', 'cee8a70bcfc00996a87843150f50858ee830d692ae4678e50d5c074d43ff657c', 'b451f1bf9eed3bec2c5e20d4e9122ce6f31202fc68127f2881d2d860e9726365', '5c5fe7e7a382ebc21f89d163deb3520302620f0efe90cedb8592a80b5ef6a394', 'fb2b9389e1455c6d64ae19158396d767d88969013b14075bcfdcc764f610108c', '769d6aec4ab7308875a36f480f397628b2febffed4bc76dc77efd81374577a2f', '36330b0a2474d7598e4665a8ac8b8fbd2c0215a7c2971183879990c1948b22ae', 'ae3bdd3a81d96e4aaa02f7d597a2684146f3af75b743bde8e31c3cf5883707db', 'c63eee4f2d995789dc0fd3300a044e2c8d77d7fd6727e4e7a7bcc637c837d612', '564787d2556d259dabeaa6c5e2a64e9bdbfcf4ff124eb58795eebefb601fdb30', '5324bae9de9c301e9f6c475f9348fb2673813fe613070bb08ffd35c8a0e54204', 'f77d05a1e065348650e7579a3e2688468825cb7764599c8eb0f82836f4f3d9f3', 'a9668d2ded433c7b0eab698458e6b8fd13e4ddabe80417a884a66eda5893de8a', '75621d6a5adc1618337a02bf68856f7e1f8591c46fda003f39100f58bad112e3', '87cbb111ae00db5fad0458158af7d51a3ea8cb3e02e091c32f02ae366900eabb', '26e942b0353fee8f5ac0a2c2e26c9b695c50b35c501eeb4bff343b1648b5cebc', '036168e918418eb807bc3efd361a8e66067192564da41e30e076d22be0f87935', 'a6bd7b8f71e0d959503da2efa6fee412d7e71fb1f54e482a89a61c2a8d6bc691', '9829b13faebde69c2279c38cd54d524aa31acfdcc1cfba7910b9d69caa42e0dd', '2755ae7cda161df0c24e1fa9f1c3308bc9ef81a599d859668490484290ca72f4'] A "the above is of course illustrative of many network scenarios that can be configured. between a pair of relay nodes there may be one or more transit nodes that simply forward the detnet traffic, but these are omitted for clarity." {6: 1, 31: 1, 124: 1, 67: 1, 53: 1, 8: 1, 79: 2, 90: 3, 51: 3, 130: 2, 62: 4, 85: 4, 68: 3, 35: 3, 110: 3, 91: 5, 114: 3, 97: 3, 13: 3, 38: 4, 26: 3, 98: 2, 54: 2, 127: 3, 96: 3, 64: 2, 30: 4, 61: 5, 55: 2, 27: 2, 15: 3, 52: 2, 129: 3, 115: 3, 84: 2, 76: 4, 87: 3, 131: 5, 102: 3, 113: 5, 99: 2, 36: 3, 24: 2, 72: 4} {161: 1, 264: 1, 328: 1, 392: 1, 369: 1, 220: 1, 221: 1, 1: 8, 4: 2, 9: 3, 10: 3, 15: 3, 24: 2, 25: 4, 26: 4, 27: 3, 39: 4, 43: 3, 49: 6, 50: 5, 58: 5, 59: 2, 64: 3, 69: 2, 81: 5, 82: 4, 86: 3, 96: 4, 97: 3, 100: 7, 108: 3, 109: 4, 110: 4, 111: 2, 114: 3, 115: 4, 116: 3, 118: 5, 119: 4, 120: 3, 121: 3, 122: 4, 123: 3, 124: 3, 128: 4, 129: 4, 130: 5, 132: 2, 136: 2, 145: 2, 147: 4, 151: 4, 152: 4, 154: 3, 156: 2, 162: 2, 165: 3, 168: 4, 169: 3, 172: 3, 180: 4, 184: 3, 187: 5, 188: 4, 191: 3, 194: 2, 202: 3, 203: 4, 206: 2, 207: 3, 217: 3, 218: 7, 222: 4, 224: 3, 227: 5, 229: 3, 234: 5, 235: 2, 241: 2, 242: 2, 243: 2, 244: 4, 245: 2, 248: 4, 250: 4, 258: 10, 262: 4, 263: 5, 267: 3, 270: 3, 272: 3, 273: 3, 287: 3, 289: 3, 291: 5, 299: 5, 300: 3, 304: 3, 309: 2, 314: 2, 315: 3, 320: 3, 323: 2, 327: 4, 329: 2, 330: 9, 334: 2, 335: 3, 341: 5, 342: 6, 347: 5, 348: 5, 350: 5, 351: 5, 352: 3, 353: 3, 354: 2, 358: 3, 365: 3, 366: 2, 371: 7, 372: 5, 376: 2, 384: 5, 385: 4, 386: 3, 387: 3, 393: 2, 396: 6, 397: 6, 398: 5, 402: 3} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 52 "Use of allocated resources (queuing, policing, shaping) to ensure that the congestion-related loss and latency/jitter requirements of a DetNet flow are met." Similar structure and changes as in IP over TSN . Service protection interworking is out - of - scope . d275ba154e2b7c82eb3ec9175d790214b0e60d3f d275ba154e2b7c82eb3ec9175d790214b0e60d3f draft-ietf-detnet-mpls-over-tsn ae3bdd3a81d96e4aaa02f7d597a2684146f3af75b743bde8e31c3cf5883707db ['899fe49efb71ff0aa7ef3f05ac18bd5bfd87fffe13b5c1288db3416e022be147', 'ab93afb1ce53a91a86685ff579055185d9f7a6798d6effa52aec9838538bdf15', '42b1f3f30d1cae8db1fcb526de2f77c170c19e3508250cf37a94100514f567e6', '55bdece02c98962a77682e9b55671178537e5663507c4ff9c5409df14c7a69af', '438eb33c698936afb27ac820b5f68528ff155bd5a6927b63e6259a419be2e1a9', 'ed695265f24af924853cf42b909ea782e13659dd90448b1a4bc4800314d00f86', 'a8ff14472a8fa48bacdc11d7089a9d1054c0a786f6152f510b5d4092c22e121f', '16375944152e6c3e73492437880fe39d7f0123a9292d062e8e9c7d317e4b878f', '1076eab6753435c114e8a720c951b03da6d4e1bbbf1290f8d58ad7f97a0b8c64', '7f7e8733165742e4d8be8dacffe0453045841d70140ba0a9defc1c0d78e8d05c', '44e497e2df0461bad9215c57918855022435eb6e28266916161de3f7902bb352', '0cf3a218420317d1ac2dbe66fe8b3fa5930ee4bfb0f9a25d7059f70b672356ee', 'c2db650dc38549201f151a0fea9030968aca0fd468d0d6d3fe3d9b520ee551e6', '03d4609f1627eb905bc43957db60d2c0ce0b1cf99c6fa8617c936e7170195470', 'f07257d89bd36957d381df4c3d975b976581225d3b0e93b797f231549f809c45', 'cee8a70bcfc00996a87843150f50858ee830d692ae4678e50d5c074d43ff657c', 'b451f1bf9eed3bec2c5e20d4e9122ce6f31202fc68127f2881d2d860e9726365', '5c5fe7e7a382ebc21f89d163deb3520302620f0efe90cedb8592a80b5ef6a394', 'fb2b9389e1455c6d64ae19158396d767d88969013b14075bcfdcc764f610108c', '769d6aec4ab7308875a36f480f397628b2febffed4bc76dc77efd81374577a2f', '36330b0a2474d7598e4665a8ac8b8fbd2c0215a7c2971183879990c1948b22ae', 'ae3bdd3a81d96e4aaa02f7d597a2684146f3af75b743bde8e31c3cf5883707db', 'c63eee4f2d995789dc0fd3300a044e2c8d77d7fd6727e4e7a7bcc637c837d612', '564787d2556d259dabeaa6c5e2a64e9bdbfcf4ff124eb58795eebefb601fdb30', '5324bae9de9c301e9f6c475f9348fb2673813fe613070bb08ffd35c8a0e54204', 'f77d05a1e065348650e7579a3e2688468825cb7764599c8eb0f82836f4f3d9f3', 'a9668d2ded433c7b0eab698458e6b8fd13e4ddabe80417a884a66eda5893de8a', '75621d6a5adc1618337a02bf68856f7e1f8591c46fda003f39100f58bad112e3', '87cbb111ae00db5fad0458158af7d51a3ea8cb3e02e091c32f02ae366900eabb', '26e942b0353fee8f5ac0a2c2e26c9b695c50b35c501eeb4bff343b1648b5cebc', '036168e918418eb807bc3efd361a8e66067192564da41e30e076d22be0f87935', 'a6bd7b8f71e0d959503da2efa6fee412d7e71fb1f54e482a89a61c2a8d6bc691', '9829b13faebde69c2279c38cd54d524aa31acfdcc1cfba7910b9d69caa42e0dd', '2755ae7cda161df0c24e1fa9f1c3308bc9ef81a599d859668490484290ca72f4'] A "use of allocated resources (queuing, policing, shaping) to ensure that the congestion-related loss and latency/jitter requirements of a detnet flow are met." {6: 1, 31: 1, 124: 1, 67: 1, 53: 1, 8: 1, 79: 2, 90: 3, 51: 3, 130: 2, 62: 4, 85: 4, 68: 3, 35: 3, 110: 3, 91: 5, 114: 3, 97: 3, 13: 3, 38: 4, 26: 3, 98: 2, 54: 2, 127: 3, 96: 3, 64: 2, 30: 4, 61: 5, 55: 2, 27: 2, 15: 3, 52: 2, 129: 3, 115: 3, 84: 2, 76: 4, 87: 3, 131: 5, 102: 3, 113: 5, 99: 2, 36: 3, 24: 2, 72: 4} {161: 1, 264: 1, 328: 1, 392: 1, 369: 1, 220: 1, 221: 1, 1: 8, 4: 2, 9: 3, 10: 3, 15: 3, 24: 2, 25: 4, 26: 4, 27: 3, 39: 4, 43: 3, 49: 6, 50: 5, 58: 5, 59: 2, 64: 3, 69: 2, 81: 5, 82: 4, 86: 3, 96: 4, 97: 3, 100: 7, 108: 3, 109: 4, 110: 4, 111: 2, 114: 3, 115: 4, 116: 3, 118: 5, 119: 4, 120: 3, 121: 3, 122: 4, 123: 3, 124: 3, 128: 4, 129: 4, 130: 5, 132: 2, 136: 2, 145: 2, 147: 4, 151: 4, 152: 4, 154: 3, 156: 2, 162: 2, 165: 3, 168: 4, 169: 3, 172: 3, 180: 4, 184: 3, 187: 5, 188: 4, 191: 3, 194: 2, 202: 3, 203: 4, 206: 2, 207: 3, 217: 3, 218: 7, 222: 4, 224: 3, 227: 5, 229: 3, 234: 5, 235: 2, 241: 2, 242: 2, 243: 2, 244: 4, 245: 2, 248: 4, 250: 4, 258: 10, 262: 4, 263: 5, 267: 3, 270: 3, 272: 3, 273: 3, 287: 3, 289: 3, 291: 5, 299: 5, 300: 3, 304: 3, 309: 2, 314: 2, 315: 3, 320: 3, 323: 2, 327: 4, 329: 2, 330: 9, 334: 2, 335: 3, 341: 5, 342: 6, 347: 5, 348: 5, 350: 5, 351: 5, 352: 3, 353: 3, 354: 2, 358: 3, 365: 3, 366: 2, 371: 7, 372: 5, 376: 2, 384: 5, 385: 4, 386: 3, 387: 3, 393: 2, 396: 6, 397: 6, 398: 5, 402: 3} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 52 "Use of a specific path for a flow. This limits misordering and bounds latency." Similar structure and changes as in IP over TSN . Service protection interworking is out - of - scope . d275ba154e2b7c82eb3ec9175d790214b0e60d3f d275ba154e2b7c82eb3ec9175d790214b0e60d3f draft-ietf-detnet-mpls-over-tsn fb2b9389e1455c6d64ae19158396d767d88969013b14075bcfdcc764f610108c ['899fe49efb71ff0aa7ef3f05ac18bd5bfd87fffe13b5c1288db3416e022be147', 'ab93afb1ce53a91a86685ff579055185d9f7a6798d6effa52aec9838538bdf15', '42b1f3f30d1cae8db1fcb526de2f77c170c19e3508250cf37a94100514f567e6', '55bdece02c98962a77682e9b55671178537e5663507c4ff9c5409df14c7a69af', '438eb33c698936afb27ac820b5f68528ff155bd5a6927b63e6259a419be2e1a9', 'ed695265f24af924853cf42b909ea782e13659dd90448b1a4bc4800314d00f86', 'a8ff14472a8fa48bacdc11d7089a9d1054c0a786f6152f510b5d4092c22e121f', '16375944152e6c3e73492437880fe39d7f0123a9292d062e8e9c7d317e4b878f', '1076eab6753435c114e8a720c951b03da6d4e1bbbf1290f8d58ad7f97a0b8c64', '7f7e8733165742e4d8be8dacffe0453045841d70140ba0a9defc1c0d78e8d05c', '44e497e2df0461bad9215c57918855022435eb6e28266916161de3f7902bb352', '0cf3a218420317d1ac2dbe66fe8b3fa5930ee4bfb0f9a25d7059f70b672356ee', 'c2db650dc38549201f151a0fea9030968aca0fd468d0d6d3fe3d9b520ee551e6', '03d4609f1627eb905bc43957db60d2c0ce0b1cf99c6fa8617c936e7170195470', 'f07257d89bd36957d381df4c3d975b976581225d3b0e93b797f231549f809c45', 'cee8a70bcfc00996a87843150f50858ee830d692ae4678e50d5c074d43ff657c', 'b451f1bf9eed3bec2c5e20d4e9122ce6f31202fc68127f2881d2d860e9726365', '5c5fe7e7a382ebc21f89d163deb3520302620f0efe90cedb8592a80b5ef6a394', 'fb2b9389e1455c6d64ae19158396d767d88969013b14075bcfdcc764f610108c', '769d6aec4ab7308875a36f480f397628b2febffed4bc76dc77efd81374577a2f', '36330b0a2474d7598e4665a8ac8b8fbd2c0215a7c2971183879990c1948b22ae', 'ae3bdd3a81d96e4aaa02f7d597a2684146f3af75b743bde8e31c3cf5883707db', 'c63eee4f2d995789dc0fd3300a044e2c8d77d7fd6727e4e7a7bcc637c837d612', '564787d2556d259dabeaa6c5e2a64e9bdbfcf4ff124eb58795eebefb601fdb30', '5324bae9de9c301e9f6c475f9348fb2673813fe613070bb08ffd35c8a0e54204', 'f77d05a1e065348650e7579a3e2688468825cb7764599c8eb0f82836f4f3d9f3', 'a9668d2ded433c7b0eab698458e6b8fd13e4ddabe80417a884a66eda5893de8a', '75621d6a5adc1618337a02bf68856f7e1f8591c46fda003f39100f58bad112e3', '87cbb111ae00db5fad0458158af7d51a3ea8cb3e02e091c32f02ae366900eabb', '26e942b0353fee8f5ac0a2c2e26c9b695c50b35c501eeb4bff343b1648b5cebc', '036168e918418eb807bc3efd361a8e66067192564da41e30e076d22be0f87935', 'a6bd7b8f71e0d959503da2efa6fee412d7e71fb1f54e482a89a61c2a8d6bc691', '9829b13faebde69c2279c38cd54d524aa31acfdcc1cfba7910b9d69caa42e0dd', '2755ae7cda161df0c24e1fa9f1c3308bc9ef81a599d859668490484290ca72f4'] A "use of a specific path for a flow. this limits misordering and bounds latency." {6: 1, 31: 1, 124: 1, 67: 1, 53: 1, 8: 1, 79: 2, 90: 3, 51: 3, 130: 2, 62: 4, 85: 4, 68: 3, 35: 3, 110: 3, 91: 5, 114: 3, 97: 3, 13: 3, 38: 4, 26: 3, 98: 2, 54: 2, 127: 3, 96: 3, 64: 2, 30: 4, 61: 5, 55: 2, 27: 2, 15: 3, 52: 2, 129: 3, 115: 3, 84: 2, 76: 4, 87: 3, 131: 5, 102: 3, 113: 5, 99: 2, 36: 3, 24: 2, 72: 4} {161: 1, 264: 1, 328: 1, 392: 1, 369: 1, 220: 1, 221: 1, 1: 8, 4: 2, 9: 3, 10: 3, 15: 3, 24: 2, 25: 4, 26: 4, 27: 3, 39: 4, 43: 3, 49: 6, 50: 5, 58: 5, 59: 2, 64: 3, 69: 2, 81: 5, 82: 4, 86: 3, 96: 4, 97: 3, 100: 7, 108: 3, 109: 4, 110: 4, 111: 2, 114: 3, 115: 4, 116: 3, 118: 5, 119: 4, 120: 3, 121: 3, 122: 4, 123: 3, 124: 3, 128: 4, 129: 4, 130: 5, 132: 2, 136: 2, 145: 2, 147: 4, 151: 4, 152: 4, 154: 3, 156: 2, 162: 2, 165: 3, 168: 4, 169: 3, 172: 3, 180: 4, 184: 3, 187: 5, 188: 4, 191: 3, 194: 2, 202: 3, 203: 4, 206: 2, 207: 3, 217: 3, 218: 7, 222: 4, 224: 3, 227: 5, 229: 3, 234: 5, 235: 2, 241: 2, 242: 2, 243: 2, 244: 4, 245: 2, 248: 4, 250: 4, 258: 10, 262: 4, 263: 5, 267: 3, 270: 3, 272: 3, 273: 3, 287: 3, 289: 3, 291: 5, 299: 5, 300: 3, 304: 3, 309: 2, 314: 2, 315: 3, 320: 3, 323: 2, 327: 4, 329: 2, 330: 9, 334: 2, 335: 3, 341: 5, 342: 6, 347: 5, 348: 5, 350: 5, 351: 5, 352: 3, 353: 3, 354: 2, 358: 3, 365: 3, 366: 2, 371: 7, 372: 5, 376: 2, 384: 5, 385: 4, 386: 3, 387: 3, 393: 2, 396: 6, 397: 6, 398: 5, 402: 3} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 52 "Which in the case of this document primarily relates to replication and elimination. Changing the explicit path after a failure is detected in order to restore delivery of the required DetNet service characteristics is also possible. Path changes, even in the case of failure recovery, can lead to the out of order delivery of data." Similar structure and changes as in IP over TSN . Service protection interworking is out - of - scope . d275ba154e2b7c82eb3ec9175d790214b0e60d3f d275ba154e2b7c82eb3ec9175d790214b0e60d3f draft-ietf-detnet-mpls-over-tsn 9829b13faebde69c2279c38cd54d524aa31acfdcc1cfba7910b9d69caa42e0dd ['899fe49efb71ff0aa7ef3f05ac18bd5bfd87fffe13b5c1288db3416e022be147', 'ab93afb1ce53a91a86685ff579055185d9f7a6798d6effa52aec9838538bdf15', '42b1f3f30d1cae8db1fcb526de2f77c170c19e3508250cf37a94100514f567e6', '55bdece02c98962a77682e9b55671178537e5663507c4ff9c5409df14c7a69af', '438eb33c698936afb27ac820b5f68528ff155bd5a6927b63e6259a419be2e1a9', 'ed695265f24af924853cf42b909ea782e13659dd90448b1a4bc4800314d00f86', 'a8ff14472a8fa48bacdc11d7089a9d1054c0a786f6152f510b5d4092c22e121f', '16375944152e6c3e73492437880fe39d7f0123a9292d062e8e9c7d317e4b878f', '1076eab6753435c114e8a720c951b03da6d4e1bbbf1290f8d58ad7f97a0b8c64', '7f7e8733165742e4d8be8dacffe0453045841d70140ba0a9defc1c0d78e8d05c', '44e497e2df0461bad9215c57918855022435eb6e28266916161de3f7902bb352', '0cf3a218420317d1ac2dbe66fe8b3fa5930ee4bfb0f9a25d7059f70b672356ee', 'c2db650dc38549201f151a0fea9030968aca0fd468d0d6d3fe3d9b520ee551e6', '03d4609f1627eb905bc43957db60d2c0ce0b1cf99c6fa8617c936e7170195470', 'f07257d89bd36957d381df4c3d975b976581225d3b0e93b797f231549f809c45', 'cee8a70bcfc00996a87843150f50858ee830d692ae4678e50d5c074d43ff657c', 'b451f1bf9eed3bec2c5e20d4e9122ce6f31202fc68127f2881d2d860e9726365', '5c5fe7e7a382ebc21f89d163deb3520302620f0efe90cedb8592a80b5ef6a394', 'fb2b9389e1455c6d64ae19158396d767d88969013b14075bcfdcc764f610108c', '769d6aec4ab7308875a36f480f397628b2febffed4bc76dc77efd81374577a2f', '36330b0a2474d7598e4665a8ac8b8fbd2c0215a7c2971183879990c1948b22ae', 'ae3bdd3a81d96e4aaa02f7d597a2684146f3af75b743bde8e31c3cf5883707db', 'c63eee4f2d995789dc0fd3300a044e2c8d77d7fd6727e4e7a7bcc637c837d612', '564787d2556d259dabeaa6c5e2a64e9bdbfcf4ff124eb58795eebefb601fdb30', '5324bae9de9c301e9f6c475f9348fb2673813fe613070bb08ffd35c8a0e54204', 'f77d05a1e065348650e7579a3e2688468825cb7764599c8eb0f82836f4f3d9f3', 'a9668d2ded433c7b0eab698458e6b8fd13e4ddabe80417a884a66eda5893de8a', '75621d6a5adc1618337a02bf68856f7e1f8591c46fda003f39100f58bad112e3', '87cbb111ae00db5fad0458158af7d51a3ea8cb3e02e091c32f02ae366900eabb', '26e942b0353fee8f5ac0a2c2e26c9b695c50b35c501eeb4bff343b1648b5cebc', '036168e918418eb807bc3efd361a8e66067192564da41e30e076d22be0f87935', 'a6bd7b8f71e0d959503da2efa6fee412d7e71fb1f54e482a89a61c2a8d6bc691', '9829b13faebde69c2279c38cd54d524aa31acfdcc1cfba7910b9d69caa42e0dd', '2755ae7cda161df0c24e1fa9f1c3308bc9ef81a599d859668490484290ca72f4'] A "which in the case of this document primarily relates to replication and elimination. changing the explicit path after a failure is detected in order to restore delivery of the required detnet service characteristics is also possible. path changes, even in the case of failure recovery, can lead to the out of order delivery of data." {6: 1, 31: 1, 124: 1, 67: 1, 53: 1, 8: 1, 79: 2, 90: 3, 51: 3, 130: 2, 62: 4, 85: 4, 68: 3, 35: 3, 110: 3, 91: 5, 114: 3, 97: 3, 13: 3, 38: 4, 26: 3, 98: 2, 54: 2, 127: 3, 96: 3, 64: 2, 30: 4, 61: 5, 55: 2, 27: 2, 15: 3, 52: 2, 129: 3, 115: 3, 84: 2, 76: 4, 87: 3, 131: 5, 102: 3, 113: 5, 99: 2, 36: 3, 24: 2, 72: 4} {161: 1, 264: 1, 328: 1, 392: 1, 369: 1, 220: 1, 221: 1, 1: 8, 4: 2, 9: 3, 10: 3, 15: 3, 24: 2, 25: 4, 26: 4, 27: 3, 39: 4, 43: 3, 49: 6, 50: 5, 58: 5, 59: 2, 64: 3, 69: 2, 81: 5, 82: 4, 86: 3, 96: 4, 97: 3, 100: 7, 108: 3, 109: 4, 110: 4, 111: 2, 114: 3, 115: 4, 116: 3, 118: 5, 119: 4, 120: 3, 121: 3, 122: 4, 123: 3, 124: 3, 128: 4, 129: 4, 130: 5, 132: 2, 136: 2, 145: 2, 147: 4, 151: 4, 152: 4, 154: 3, 156: 2, 162: 2, 165: 3, 168: 4, 169: 3, 172: 3, 180: 4, 184: 3, 187: 5, 188: 4, 191: 3, 194: 2, 202: 3, 203: 4, 206: 2, 207: 3, 217: 3, 218: 7, 222: 4, 224: 3, 227: 5, 229: 3, 234: 5, 235: 2, 241: 2, 242: 2, 243: 2, 244: 4, 245: 2, 248: 4, 250: 4, 258: 10, 262: 4, 263: 5, 267: 3, 270: 3, 272: 3, 273: 3, 287: 3, 289: 3, 291: 5, 299: 5, 300: 3, 304: 3, 309: 2, 314: 2, 315: 3, 320: 3, 323: 2, 327: 4, 329: 2, 330: 9, 334: 2, 335: 3, 341: 5, 342: 6, 347: 5, 348: 5, 350: 5, 351: 5, 352: 3, 353: 3, 354: 2, 358: 3, 365: 3, 366: 2, 371: 7, 372: 5, 376: 2, 384: 5, 385: 4, 386: 3, 387: 3, 393: 2, 396: 6, 397: 6, 398: 5, 402: 3} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 52 "Generally, distributing packets of the same DetNet flow over multiple paths is not recommended. Such load sharing, e.g., via ECMP or UCMP, impacts ordering and possibly jitter." Similar structure and changes as in IP over TSN . Service protection interworking is out - of - scope . d275ba154e2b7c82eb3ec9175d790214b0e60d3f d275ba154e2b7c82eb3ec9175d790214b0e60d3f draft-ietf-detnet-mpls-over-tsn 26e942b0353fee8f5ac0a2c2e26c9b695c50b35c501eeb4bff343b1648b5cebc ['899fe49efb71ff0aa7ef3f05ac18bd5bfd87fffe13b5c1288db3416e022be147', 'ab93afb1ce53a91a86685ff579055185d9f7a6798d6effa52aec9838538bdf15', '42b1f3f30d1cae8db1fcb526de2f77c170c19e3508250cf37a94100514f567e6', '55bdece02c98962a77682e9b55671178537e5663507c4ff9c5409df14c7a69af', '438eb33c698936afb27ac820b5f68528ff155bd5a6927b63e6259a419be2e1a9', 'ed695265f24af924853cf42b909ea782e13659dd90448b1a4bc4800314d00f86', 'a8ff14472a8fa48bacdc11d7089a9d1054c0a786f6152f510b5d4092c22e121f', '16375944152e6c3e73492437880fe39d7f0123a9292d062e8e9c7d317e4b878f', '1076eab6753435c114e8a720c951b03da6d4e1bbbf1290f8d58ad7f97a0b8c64', '7f7e8733165742e4d8be8dacffe0453045841d70140ba0a9defc1c0d78e8d05c', '44e497e2df0461bad9215c57918855022435eb6e28266916161de3f7902bb352', '0cf3a218420317d1ac2dbe66fe8b3fa5930ee4bfb0f9a25d7059f70b672356ee', 'c2db650dc38549201f151a0fea9030968aca0fd468d0d6d3fe3d9b520ee551e6', '03d4609f1627eb905bc43957db60d2c0ce0b1cf99c6fa8617c936e7170195470', 'f07257d89bd36957d381df4c3d975b976581225d3b0e93b797f231549f809c45', 'cee8a70bcfc00996a87843150f50858ee830d692ae4678e50d5c074d43ff657c', 'b451f1bf9eed3bec2c5e20d4e9122ce6f31202fc68127f2881d2d860e9726365', '5c5fe7e7a382ebc21f89d163deb3520302620f0efe90cedb8592a80b5ef6a394', 'fb2b9389e1455c6d64ae19158396d767d88969013b14075bcfdcc764f610108c', '769d6aec4ab7308875a36f480f397628b2febffed4bc76dc77efd81374577a2f', '36330b0a2474d7598e4665a8ac8b8fbd2c0215a7c2971183879990c1948b22ae', 'ae3bdd3a81d96e4aaa02f7d597a2684146f3af75b743bde8e31c3cf5883707db', 'c63eee4f2d995789dc0fd3300a044e2c8d77d7fd6727e4e7a7bcc637c837d612', '564787d2556d259dabeaa6c5e2a64e9bdbfcf4ff124eb58795eebefb601fdb30', '5324bae9de9c301e9f6c475f9348fb2673813fe613070bb08ffd35c8a0e54204', 'f77d05a1e065348650e7579a3e2688468825cb7764599c8eb0f82836f4f3d9f3', 'a9668d2ded433c7b0eab698458e6b8fd13e4ddabe80417a884a66eda5893de8a', '75621d6a5adc1618337a02bf68856f7e1f8591c46fda003f39100f58bad112e3', '87cbb111ae00db5fad0458158af7d51a3ea8cb3e02e091c32f02ae366900eabb', '26e942b0353fee8f5ac0a2c2e26c9b695c50b35c501eeb4bff343b1648b5cebc', '036168e918418eb807bc3efd361a8e66067192564da41e30e076d22be0f87935', 'a6bd7b8f71e0d959503da2efa6fee412d7e71fb1f54e482a89a61c2a8d6bc691', '9829b13faebde69c2279c38cd54d524aa31acfdcc1cfba7910b9d69caa42e0dd', '2755ae7cda161df0c24e1fa9f1c3308bc9ef81a599d859668490484290ca72f4'] A "generally, distributing packets of the same detnet flow over multiple paths is not recommended. such load sharing, e.g., via ecmp or ucmp, impacts ordering and possibly jitter." {6: 1, 31: 1, 124: 1, 67: 1, 53: 1, 8: 1, 79: 2, 90: 3, 51: 3, 130: 2, 62: 4, 85: 4, 68: 3, 35: 3, 110: 3, 91: 5, 114: 3, 97: 3, 13: 3, 38: 4, 26: 3, 98: 2, 54: 2, 127: 3, 96: 3, 64: 2, 30: 4, 61: 5, 55: 2, 27: 2, 15: 3, 52: 2, 129: 3, 115: 3, 84: 2, 76: 4, 87: 3, 131: 5, 102: 3, 113: 5, 99: 2, 36: 3, 24: 2, 72: 4} {161: 1, 264: 1, 328: 1, 392: 1, 369: 1, 220: 1, 221: 1, 1: 8, 4: 2, 9: 3, 10: 3, 15: 3, 24: 2, 25: 4, 26: 4, 27: 3, 39: 4, 43: 3, 49: 6, 50: 5, 58: 5, 59: 2, 64: 3, 69: 2, 81: 5, 82: 4, 86: 3, 96: 4, 97: 3, 100: 7, 108: 3, 109: 4, 110: 4, 111: 2, 114: 3, 115: 4, 116: 3, 118: 5, 119: 4, 120: 3, 121: 3, 122: 4, 123: 3, 124: 3, 128: 4, 129: 4, 130: 5, 132: 2, 136: 2, 145: 2, 147: 4, 151: 4, 152: 4, 154: 3, 156: 2, 162: 2, 165: 3, 168: 4, 169: 3, 172: 3, 180: 4, 184: 3, 187: 5, 188: 4, 191: 3, 194: 2, 202: 3, 203: 4, 206: 2, 207: 3, 217: 3, 218: 7, 222: 4, 224: 3, 227: 5, 229: 3, 234: 5, 235: 2, 241: 2, 242: 2, 243: 2, 244: 4, 245: 2, 248: 4, 250: 4, 258: 10, 262: 4, 263: 5, 267: 3, 270: 3, 272: 3, 273: 3, 287: 3, 289: 3, 291: 5, 299: 5, 300: 3, 304: 3, 309: 2, 314: 2, 315: 3, 320: 3, 323: 2, 327: 4, 329: 2, 330: 9, 334: 2, 335: 3, 341: 5, 342: 6, 347: 5, 348: 5, 350: 5, 351: 5, 352: 3, 353: 3, 354: 2, 358: 3, 365: 3, 366: 2, 371: 7, 372: 5, 376: 2, 384: 5, 385: 4, 386: 3, 387: 3, 393: 2, 396: 6, 397: 6, 398: 5, 402: 3} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 52 For example, to support identification of misbehaving flows. Similar structure and changes as in IP over TSN . Service protection interworking is out - of - scope . d275ba154e2b7c82eb3ec9175d790214b0e60d3f d275ba154e2b7c82eb3ec9175d790214b0e60d3f draft-ietf-detnet-mpls-over-tsn 036168e918418eb807bc3efd361a8e66067192564da41e30e076d22be0f87935 ['899fe49efb71ff0aa7ef3f05ac18bd5bfd87fffe13b5c1288db3416e022be147', 'ab93afb1ce53a91a86685ff579055185d9f7a6798d6effa52aec9838538bdf15', '42b1f3f30d1cae8db1fcb526de2f77c170c19e3508250cf37a94100514f567e6', '55bdece02c98962a77682e9b55671178537e5663507c4ff9c5409df14c7a69af', '438eb33c698936afb27ac820b5f68528ff155bd5a6927b63e6259a419be2e1a9', 'ed695265f24af924853cf42b909ea782e13659dd90448b1a4bc4800314d00f86', 'a8ff14472a8fa48bacdc11d7089a9d1054c0a786f6152f510b5d4092c22e121f', '16375944152e6c3e73492437880fe39d7f0123a9292d062e8e9c7d317e4b878f', '1076eab6753435c114e8a720c951b03da6d4e1bbbf1290f8d58ad7f97a0b8c64', '7f7e8733165742e4d8be8dacffe0453045841d70140ba0a9defc1c0d78e8d05c', '44e497e2df0461bad9215c57918855022435eb6e28266916161de3f7902bb352', '0cf3a218420317d1ac2dbe66fe8b3fa5930ee4bfb0f9a25d7059f70b672356ee', 'c2db650dc38549201f151a0fea9030968aca0fd468d0d6d3fe3d9b520ee551e6', '03d4609f1627eb905bc43957db60d2c0ce0b1cf99c6fa8617c936e7170195470', 'f07257d89bd36957d381df4c3d975b976581225d3b0e93b797f231549f809c45', 'cee8a70bcfc00996a87843150f50858ee830d692ae4678e50d5c074d43ff657c', 'b451f1bf9eed3bec2c5e20d4e9122ce6f31202fc68127f2881d2d860e9726365', '5c5fe7e7a382ebc21f89d163deb3520302620f0efe90cedb8592a80b5ef6a394', 'fb2b9389e1455c6d64ae19158396d767d88969013b14075bcfdcc764f610108c', '769d6aec4ab7308875a36f480f397628b2febffed4bc76dc77efd81374577a2f', '36330b0a2474d7598e4665a8ac8b8fbd2c0215a7c2971183879990c1948b22ae', 'ae3bdd3a81d96e4aaa02f7d597a2684146f3af75b743bde8e31c3cf5883707db', 'c63eee4f2d995789dc0fd3300a044e2c8d77d7fd6727e4e7a7bcc637c837d612', '564787d2556d259dabeaa6c5e2a64e9bdbfcf4ff124eb58795eebefb601fdb30', '5324bae9de9c301e9f6c475f9348fb2673813fe613070bb08ffd35c8a0e54204', 'f77d05a1e065348650e7579a3e2688468825cb7764599c8eb0f82836f4f3d9f3', 'a9668d2ded433c7b0eab698458e6b8fd13e4ddabe80417a884a66eda5893de8a', '75621d6a5adc1618337a02bf68856f7e1f8591c46fda003f39100f58bad112e3', '87cbb111ae00db5fad0458158af7d51a3ea8cb3e02e091c32f02ae366900eabb', '26e942b0353fee8f5ac0a2c2e26c9b695c50b35c501eeb4bff343b1648b5cebc', '036168e918418eb807bc3efd361a8e66067192564da41e30e076d22be0f87935', 'a6bd7b8f71e0d959503da2efa6fee412d7e71fb1f54e482a89a61c2a8d6bc691', '9829b13faebde69c2279c38cd54d524aa31acfdcc1cfba7910b9d69caa42e0dd', '2755ae7cda161df0c24e1fa9f1c3308bc9ef81a599d859668490484290ca72f4'] A for example, to support identification of misbehaving flows. {6: 1, 31: 1, 124: 1, 67: 1, 53: 1, 8: 1, 79: 2, 90: 3, 51: 3, 130: 2, 62: 4, 85: 4, 68: 3, 35: 3, 110: 3, 91: 5, 114: 3, 97: 3, 13: 3, 38: 4, 26: 3, 98: 2, 54: 2, 127: 3, 96: 3, 64: 2, 30: 4, 61: 5, 55: 2, 27: 2, 15: 3, 52: 2, 129: 3, 115: 3, 84: 2, 76: 4, 87: 3, 131: 5, 102: 3, 113: 5, 99: 2, 36: 3, 24: 2, 72: 4} {161: 1, 264: 1, 328: 1, 392: 1, 369: 1, 220: 1, 221: 1, 1: 8, 4: 2, 9: 3, 10: 3, 15: 3, 24: 2, 25: 4, 26: 4, 27: 3, 39: 4, 43: 3, 49: 6, 50: 5, 58: 5, 59: 2, 64: 3, 69: 2, 81: 5, 82: 4, 86: 3, 96: 4, 97: 3, 100: 7, 108: 3, 109: 4, 110: 4, 111: 2, 114: 3, 115: 4, 116: 3, 118: 5, 119: 4, 120: 3, 121: 3, 122: 4, 123: 3, 124: 3, 128: 4, 129: 4, 130: 5, 132: 2, 136: 2, 145: 2, 147: 4, 151: 4, 152: 4, 154: 3, 156: 2, 162: 2, 165: 3, 168: 4, 169: 3, 172: 3, 180: 4, 184: 3, 187: 5, 188: 4, 191: 3, 194: 2, 202: 3, 203: 4, 206: 2, 207: 3, 217: 3, 218: 7, 222: 4, 224: 3, 227: 5, 229: 3, 234: 5, 235: 2, 241: 2, 242: 2, 243: 2, 244: 4, 245: 2, 248: 4, 250: 4, 258: 10, 262: 4, 263: 5, 267: 3, 270: 3, 272: 3, 273: 3, 287: 3, 289: 3, 291: 5, 299: 5, 300: 3, 304: 3, 309: 2, 314: 2, 315: 3, 320: 3, 323: 2, 327: 4, 329: 2, 330: 9, 334: 2, 335: 3, 341: 5, 342: 6, 347: 5, 348: 5, 350: 5, 351: 5, 352: 3, 353: 3, 354: 2, 358: 3, 365: 3, 366: 2, 371: 7, 372: 5, 376: 2, 384: 5, 385: 4, 386: 3, 387: 3, 393: 2, 396: 6, 397: 6, 398: 5, 402: 3} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 52 For example, increase counters. Similar structure and changes as in IP over TSN . Service protection interworking is out - of - scope . d275ba154e2b7c82eb3ec9175d790214b0e60d3f d275ba154e2b7c82eb3ec9175d790214b0e60d3f draft-ietf-detnet-mpls-over-tsn 2755ae7cda161df0c24e1fa9f1c3308bc9ef81a599d859668490484290ca72f4 ['899fe49efb71ff0aa7ef3f05ac18bd5bfd87fffe13b5c1288db3416e022be147', 'ab93afb1ce53a91a86685ff579055185d9f7a6798d6effa52aec9838538bdf15', '42b1f3f30d1cae8db1fcb526de2f77c170c19e3508250cf37a94100514f567e6', '55bdece02c98962a77682e9b55671178537e5663507c4ff9c5409df14c7a69af', '438eb33c698936afb27ac820b5f68528ff155bd5a6927b63e6259a419be2e1a9', 'ed695265f24af924853cf42b909ea782e13659dd90448b1a4bc4800314d00f86', 'a8ff14472a8fa48bacdc11d7089a9d1054c0a786f6152f510b5d4092c22e121f', '16375944152e6c3e73492437880fe39d7f0123a9292d062e8e9c7d317e4b878f', '1076eab6753435c114e8a720c951b03da6d4e1bbbf1290f8d58ad7f97a0b8c64', '7f7e8733165742e4d8be8dacffe0453045841d70140ba0a9defc1c0d78e8d05c', '44e497e2df0461bad9215c57918855022435eb6e28266916161de3f7902bb352', '0cf3a218420317d1ac2dbe66fe8b3fa5930ee4bfb0f9a25d7059f70b672356ee', 'c2db650dc38549201f151a0fea9030968aca0fd468d0d6d3fe3d9b520ee551e6', '03d4609f1627eb905bc43957db60d2c0ce0b1cf99c6fa8617c936e7170195470', 'f07257d89bd36957d381df4c3d975b976581225d3b0e93b797f231549f809c45', 'cee8a70bcfc00996a87843150f50858ee830d692ae4678e50d5c074d43ff657c', 'b451f1bf9eed3bec2c5e20d4e9122ce6f31202fc68127f2881d2d860e9726365', '5c5fe7e7a382ebc21f89d163deb3520302620f0efe90cedb8592a80b5ef6a394', 'fb2b9389e1455c6d64ae19158396d767d88969013b14075bcfdcc764f610108c', '769d6aec4ab7308875a36f480f397628b2febffed4bc76dc77efd81374577a2f', '36330b0a2474d7598e4665a8ac8b8fbd2c0215a7c2971183879990c1948b22ae', 'ae3bdd3a81d96e4aaa02f7d597a2684146f3af75b743bde8e31c3cf5883707db', 'c63eee4f2d995789dc0fd3300a044e2c8d77d7fd6727e4e7a7bcc637c837d612', '564787d2556d259dabeaa6c5e2a64e9bdbfcf4ff124eb58795eebefb601fdb30', '5324bae9de9c301e9f6c475f9348fb2673813fe613070bb08ffd35c8a0e54204', 'f77d05a1e065348650e7579a3e2688468825cb7764599c8eb0f82836f4f3d9f3', 'a9668d2ded433c7b0eab698458e6b8fd13e4ddabe80417a884a66eda5893de8a', '75621d6a5adc1618337a02bf68856f7e1f8591c46fda003f39100f58bad112e3', '87cbb111ae00db5fad0458158af7d51a3ea8cb3e02e091c32f02ae366900eabb', '26e942b0353fee8f5ac0a2c2e26c9b695c50b35c501eeb4bff343b1648b5cebc', '036168e918418eb807bc3efd361a8e66067192564da41e30e076d22be0f87935', 'a6bd7b8f71e0d959503da2efa6fee412d7e71fb1f54e482a89a61c2a8d6bc691', '9829b13faebde69c2279c38cd54d524aa31acfdcc1cfba7910b9d69caa42e0dd', '2755ae7cda161df0c24e1fa9f1c3308bc9ef81a599d859668490484290ca72f4'] A for example, increase counters. {6: 1, 31: 1, 124: 1, 67: 1, 53: 1, 8: 1, 79: 2, 90: 3, 51: 3, 130: 2, 62: 4, 85: 4, 68: 3, 35: 3, 110: 3, 91: 5, 114: 3, 97: 3, 13: 3, 38: 4, 26: 3, 98: 2, 54: 2, 127: 3, 96: 3, 64: 2, 30: 4, 61: 5, 55: 2, 27: 2, 15: 3, 52: 2, 129: 3, 115: 3, 84: 2, 76: 4, 87: 3, 131: 5, 102: 3, 113: 5, 99: 2, 36: 3, 24: 2, 72: 4} {161: 1, 264: 1, 328: 1, 392: 1, 369: 1, 220: 1, 221: 1, 1: 8, 4: 2, 9: 3, 10: 3, 15: 3, 24: 2, 25: 4, 26: 4, 27: 3, 39: 4, 43: 3, 49: 6, 50: 5, 58: 5, 59: 2, 64: 3, 69: 2, 81: 5, 82: 4, 86: 3, 96: 4, 97: 3, 100: 7, 108: 3, 109: 4, 110: 4, 111: 2, 114: 3, 115: 4, 116: 3, 118: 5, 119: 4, 120: 3, 121: 3, 122: 4, 123: 3, 124: 3, 128: 4, 129: 4, 130: 5, 132: 2, 136: 2, 145: 2, 147: 4, 151: 4, 152: 4, 154: 3, 156: 2, 162: 2, 165: 3, 168: 4, 169: 3, 172: 3, 180: 4, 184: 3, 187: 5, 188: 4, 191: 3, 194: 2, 202: 3, 203: 4, 206: 2, 207: 3, 217: 3, 218: 7, 222: 4, 224: 3, 227: 5, 229: 3, 234: 5, 235: 2, 241: 2, 242: 2, 243: 2, 244: 4, 245: 2, 248: 4, 250: 4, 258: 10, 262: 4, 263: 5, 267: 3, 270: 3, 272: 3, 273: 3, 287: 3, 289: 3, 291: 5, 299: 5, 300: 3, 304: 3, 309: 2, 314: 2, 315: 3, 320: 3, 323: 2, 327: 4, 329: 2, 330: 9, 334: 2, 335: 3, 341: 5, 342: 6, 347: 5, 348: 5, 350: 5, 351: 5, 352: 3, 353: 3, 354: 2, 358: 3, 365: 3, 366: 2, 371: 7, 372: 5, 376: 2, 384: 5, 385: 4, 386: 3, 387: 3, 393: 2, 396: 6, 397: 6, 398: 5, 402: 3} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 52 For example, unexpected loss. Similar structure and changes as in IP over TSN . Service protection interworking is out - of - scope . d275ba154e2b7c82eb3ec9175d790214b0e60d3f d275ba154e2b7c82eb3ec9175d790214b0e60d3f draft-ietf-detnet-mpls-over-tsn a8ff14472a8fa48bacdc11d7089a9d1054c0a786f6152f510b5d4092c22e121f ['899fe49efb71ff0aa7ef3f05ac18bd5bfd87fffe13b5c1288db3416e022be147', 'ab93afb1ce53a91a86685ff579055185d9f7a6798d6effa52aec9838538bdf15', '42b1f3f30d1cae8db1fcb526de2f77c170c19e3508250cf37a94100514f567e6', '55bdece02c98962a77682e9b55671178537e5663507c4ff9c5409df14c7a69af', '438eb33c698936afb27ac820b5f68528ff155bd5a6927b63e6259a419be2e1a9', 'ed695265f24af924853cf42b909ea782e13659dd90448b1a4bc4800314d00f86', 'a8ff14472a8fa48bacdc11d7089a9d1054c0a786f6152f510b5d4092c22e121f', '16375944152e6c3e73492437880fe39d7f0123a9292d062e8e9c7d317e4b878f', '1076eab6753435c114e8a720c951b03da6d4e1bbbf1290f8d58ad7f97a0b8c64', '7f7e8733165742e4d8be8dacffe0453045841d70140ba0a9defc1c0d78e8d05c', '44e497e2df0461bad9215c57918855022435eb6e28266916161de3f7902bb352', '0cf3a218420317d1ac2dbe66fe8b3fa5930ee4bfb0f9a25d7059f70b672356ee', 'c2db650dc38549201f151a0fea9030968aca0fd468d0d6d3fe3d9b520ee551e6', '03d4609f1627eb905bc43957db60d2c0ce0b1cf99c6fa8617c936e7170195470', 'f07257d89bd36957d381df4c3d975b976581225d3b0e93b797f231549f809c45', 'cee8a70bcfc00996a87843150f50858ee830d692ae4678e50d5c074d43ff657c', 'b451f1bf9eed3bec2c5e20d4e9122ce6f31202fc68127f2881d2d860e9726365', '5c5fe7e7a382ebc21f89d163deb3520302620f0efe90cedb8592a80b5ef6a394', 'fb2b9389e1455c6d64ae19158396d767d88969013b14075bcfdcc764f610108c', '769d6aec4ab7308875a36f480f397628b2febffed4bc76dc77efd81374577a2f', '36330b0a2474d7598e4665a8ac8b8fbd2c0215a7c2971183879990c1948b22ae', 'ae3bdd3a81d96e4aaa02f7d597a2684146f3af75b743bde8e31c3cf5883707db', 'c63eee4f2d995789dc0fd3300a044e2c8d77d7fd6727e4e7a7bcc637c837d612', '564787d2556d259dabeaa6c5e2a64e9bdbfcf4ff124eb58795eebefb601fdb30', '5324bae9de9c301e9f6c475f9348fb2673813fe613070bb08ffd35c8a0e54204', 'f77d05a1e065348650e7579a3e2688468825cb7764599c8eb0f82836f4f3d9f3', 'a9668d2ded433c7b0eab698458e6b8fd13e4ddabe80417a884a66eda5893de8a', '75621d6a5adc1618337a02bf68856f7e1f8591c46fda003f39100f58bad112e3', '87cbb111ae00db5fad0458158af7d51a3ea8cb3e02e091c32f02ae366900eabb', '26e942b0353fee8f5ac0a2c2e26c9b695c50b35c501eeb4bff343b1648b5cebc', '036168e918418eb807bc3efd361a8e66067192564da41e30e076d22be0f87935', 'a6bd7b8f71e0d959503da2efa6fee412d7e71fb1f54e482a89a61c2a8d6bc691', '9829b13faebde69c2279c38cd54d524aa31acfdcc1cfba7910b9d69caa42e0dd', '2755ae7cda161df0c24e1fa9f1c3308bc9ef81a599d859668490484290ca72f4'] A for example, unexpected loss. {6: 1, 31: 1, 124: 1, 67: 1, 53: 1, 8: 1, 79: 2, 90: 3, 51: 3, 130: 2, 62: 4, 85: 4, 68: 3, 35: 3, 110: 3, 91: 5, 114: 3, 97: 3, 13: 3, 38: 4, 26: 3, 98: 2, 54: 2, 127: 3, 96: 3, 64: 2, 30: 4, 61: 5, 55: 2, 27: 2, 15: 3, 52: 2, 129: 3, 115: 3, 84: 2, 76: 4, 87: 3, 131: 5, 102: 3, 113: 5, 99: 2, 36: 3, 24: 2, 72: 4} {161: 1, 264: 1, 328: 1, 392: 1, 369: 1, 220: 1, 221: 1, 1: 8, 4: 2, 9: 3, 10: 3, 15: 3, 24: 2, 25: 4, 26: 4, 27: 3, 39: 4, 43: 3, 49: 6, 50: 5, 58: 5, 59: 2, 64: 3, 69: 2, 81: 5, 82: 4, 86: 3, 96: 4, 97: 3, 100: 7, 108: 3, 109: 4, 110: 4, 111: 2, 114: 3, 115: 4, 116: 3, 118: 5, 119: 4, 120: 3, 121: 3, 122: 4, 123: 3, 124: 3, 128: 4, 129: 4, 130: 5, 132: 2, 136: 2, 145: 2, 147: 4, 151: 4, 152: 4, 154: 3, 156: 2, 162: 2, 165: 3, 168: 4, 169: 3, 172: 3, 180: 4, 184: 3, 187: 5, 188: 4, 191: 3, 194: 2, 202: 3, 203: 4, 206: 2, 207: 3, 217: 3, 218: 7, 222: 4, 224: 3, 227: 5, 229: 3, 234: 5, 235: 2, 241: 2, 242: 2, 243: 2, 244: 4, 245: 2, 248: 4, 250: 4, 258: 10, 262: 4, 263: 5, 267: 3, 270: 3, 272: 3, 273: 3, 287: 3, 289: 3, 291: 5, 299: 5, 300: 3, 304: 3, 309: 2, 314: 2, 315: 3, 320: 3, 323: 2, 327: 4, 329: 2, 330: 9, 334: 2, 335: 3, 341: 5, 342: 6, 347: 5, 348: 5, 350: 5, 351: 5, 352: 3, 353: 3, 354: 2, 358: 3, 365: 3, 366: 2, 371: 7, 372: 5, 376: 2, 384: 5, 385: 4, 386: 3, 387: 3, 393: 2, 396: 6, 397: 6, 398: 5, 402: 3} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 52 "The DetNet data plane also allows for the aggregation of DetNet flows, e.g., via MPLS hierarchical LSPs, to improved scaling. When DetNet flows are aggregated, transit nodes provide service to the aggregate and not on a per-DetNet flow basis. In this case, nodes performing aggregation will ensure that per-flow service requirements are achieved." Similar structure and changes as in IP over TSN . Service protection interworking is out - of - scope . d275ba154e2b7c82eb3ec9175d790214b0e60d3f d275ba154e2b7c82eb3ec9175d790214b0e60d3f draft-ietf-detnet-mpls-over-tsn 16375944152e6c3e73492437880fe39d7f0123a9292d062e8e9c7d317e4b878f ['899fe49efb71ff0aa7ef3f05ac18bd5bfd87fffe13b5c1288db3416e022be147', 'ab93afb1ce53a91a86685ff579055185d9f7a6798d6effa52aec9838538bdf15', '42b1f3f30d1cae8db1fcb526de2f77c170c19e3508250cf37a94100514f567e6', '55bdece02c98962a77682e9b55671178537e5663507c4ff9c5409df14c7a69af', '438eb33c698936afb27ac820b5f68528ff155bd5a6927b63e6259a419be2e1a9', 'ed695265f24af924853cf42b909ea782e13659dd90448b1a4bc4800314d00f86', 'a8ff14472a8fa48bacdc11d7089a9d1054c0a786f6152f510b5d4092c22e121f', '16375944152e6c3e73492437880fe39d7f0123a9292d062e8e9c7d317e4b878f', '1076eab6753435c114e8a720c951b03da6d4e1bbbf1290f8d58ad7f97a0b8c64', '7f7e8733165742e4d8be8dacffe0453045841d70140ba0a9defc1c0d78e8d05c', '44e497e2df0461bad9215c57918855022435eb6e28266916161de3f7902bb352', '0cf3a218420317d1ac2dbe66fe8b3fa5930ee4bfb0f9a25d7059f70b672356ee', 'c2db650dc38549201f151a0fea9030968aca0fd468d0d6d3fe3d9b520ee551e6', '03d4609f1627eb905bc43957db60d2c0ce0b1cf99c6fa8617c936e7170195470', 'f07257d89bd36957d381df4c3d975b976581225d3b0e93b797f231549f809c45', 'cee8a70bcfc00996a87843150f50858ee830d692ae4678e50d5c074d43ff657c', 'b451f1bf9eed3bec2c5e20d4e9122ce6f31202fc68127f2881d2d860e9726365', '5c5fe7e7a382ebc21f89d163deb3520302620f0efe90cedb8592a80b5ef6a394', 'fb2b9389e1455c6d64ae19158396d767d88969013b14075bcfdcc764f610108c', '769d6aec4ab7308875a36f480f397628b2febffed4bc76dc77efd81374577a2f', '36330b0a2474d7598e4665a8ac8b8fbd2c0215a7c2971183879990c1948b22ae', 'ae3bdd3a81d96e4aaa02f7d597a2684146f3af75b743bde8e31c3cf5883707db', 'c63eee4f2d995789dc0fd3300a044e2c8d77d7fd6727e4e7a7bcc637c837d612', '564787d2556d259dabeaa6c5e2a64e9bdbfcf4ff124eb58795eebefb601fdb30', '5324bae9de9c301e9f6c475f9348fb2673813fe613070bb08ffd35c8a0e54204', 'f77d05a1e065348650e7579a3e2688468825cb7764599c8eb0f82836f4f3d9f3', 'a9668d2ded433c7b0eab698458e6b8fd13e4ddabe80417a884a66eda5893de8a', '75621d6a5adc1618337a02bf68856f7e1f8591c46fda003f39100f58bad112e3', '87cbb111ae00db5fad0458158af7d51a3ea8cb3e02e091c32f02ae366900eabb', '26e942b0353fee8f5ac0a2c2e26c9b695c50b35c501eeb4bff343b1648b5cebc', '036168e918418eb807bc3efd361a8e66067192564da41e30e076d22be0f87935', 'a6bd7b8f71e0d959503da2efa6fee412d7e71fb1f54e482a89a61c2a8d6bc691', '9829b13faebde69c2279c38cd54d524aa31acfdcc1cfba7910b9d69caa42e0dd', '2755ae7cda161df0c24e1fa9f1c3308bc9ef81a599d859668490484290ca72f4'] A "the detnet data plane also allows for the aggregation of detnet flows, e.g., via mpls hierarchical lsps, to improved scaling. when detnet flows are aggregated, transit nodes provide service to the aggregate and not on a per-detnet flow basis. in this case, nodes performing aggregation will ensure that per-flow service requirements are achieved." {6: 1, 31: 1, 124: 1, 67: 1, 53: 1, 8: 1, 79: 2, 90: 3, 51: 3, 130: 2, 62: 4, 85: 4, 68: 3, 35: 3, 110: 3, 91: 5, 114: 3, 97: 3, 13: 3, 38: 4, 26: 3, 98: 2, 54: 2, 127: 3, 96: 3, 64: 2, 30: 4, 61: 5, 55: 2, 27: 2, 15: 3, 52: 2, 129: 3, 115: 3, 84: 2, 76: 4, 87: 3, 131: 5, 102: 3, 113: 5, 99: 2, 36: 3, 24: 2, 72: 4} {161: 1, 264: 1, 328: 1, 392: 1, 369: 1, 220: 1, 221: 1, 1: 8, 4: 2, 9: 3, 10: 3, 15: 3, 24: 2, 25: 4, 26: 4, 27: 3, 39: 4, 43: 3, 49: 6, 50: 5, 58: 5, 59: 2, 64: 3, 69: 2, 81: 5, 82: 4, 86: 3, 96: 4, 97: 3, 100: 7, 108: 3, 109: 4, 110: 4, 111: 2, 114: 3, 115: 4, 116: 3, 118: 5, 119: 4, 120: 3, 121: 3, 122: 4, 123: 3, 124: 3, 128: 4, 129: 4, 130: 5, 132: 2, 136: 2, 145: 2, 147: 4, 151: 4, 152: 4, 154: 3, 156: 2, 162: 2, 165: 3, 168: 4, 169: 3, 172: 3, 180: 4, 184: 3, 187: 5, 188: 4, 191: 3, 194: 2, 202: 3, 203: 4, 206: 2, 207: 3, 217: 3, 218: 7, 222: 4, 224: 3, 227: 5, 229: 3, 234: 5, 235: 2, 241: 2, 242: 2, 243: 2, 244: 4, 245: 2, 248: 4, 250: 4, 258: 10, 262: 4, 263: 5, 267: 3, 270: 3, 272: 3, 273: 3, 287: 3, 289: 3, 291: 5, 299: 5, 300: 3, 304: 3, 309: 2, 314: 2, 315: 3, 320: 3, 323: 2, 327: 4, 329: 2, 330: 9, 334: 2, 335: 3, 341: 5, 342: 6, 347: 5, 348: 5, 350: 5, 351: 5, 352: 3, 353: 3, 354: 2, 358: 3, 365: 3, 366: 2, 371: 7, 372: 5, 376: 2, 384: 5, 385: 4, 386: 3, 387: 3, 393: 2, 396: 6, 397: 6, 398: 5, 402: 3} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 52 "As shown in fig_dn_mpls_detnet, MPLS nodes are interconnected by different sub-network technologies, which may include point-to-point links. Each of these need to provide appropriate service to DetNet flows. In some cases, e.g., on dedicated point-to-point links or TDM technologies, all that is required is for a DetNet node to appropriately queue its output traffic. In other cases, DetNet nodes will need to map DetNet flows to the flow semantics (i.e., identifiers) and mechanisms used by an underlying sub-network technology. fig_dn_mpls_sn_ex shows several examples of header formats that can be used to carry DetNet MPLS flows over different sub-network technologies. L2 represent a generic layer-2 encapsulation that might be used on a point-to-point link. TSN represents the encapsulation used on an IEEE 802.1 TSN network, as described in mpls-over-tsn. UDP/IP represents the encapsulation used on a DetNet IP PSN." Similar structure and changes as in IP over TSN . Service protection interworking is out - of - scope . d275ba154e2b7c82eb3ec9175d790214b0e60d3f d275ba154e2b7c82eb3ec9175d790214b0e60d3f draft-ietf-detnet-mpls-over-tsn f77d05a1e065348650e7579a3e2688468825cb7764599c8eb0f82836f4f3d9f3 ['899fe49efb71ff0aa7ef3f05ac18bd5bfd87fffe13b5c1288db3416e022be147', 'ab93afb1ce53a91a86685ff579055185d9f7a6798d6effa52aec9838538bdf15', '42b1f3f30d1cae8db1fcb526de2f77c170c19e3508250cf37a94100514f567e6', '55bdece02c98962a77682e9b55671178537e5663507c4ff9c5409df14c7a69af', '438eb33c698936afb27ac820b5f68528ff155bd5a6927b63e6259a419be2e1a9', 'ed695265f24af924853cf42b909ea782e13659dd90448b1a4bc4800314d00f86', 'a8ff14472a8fa48bacdc11d7089a9d1054c0a786f6152f510b5d4092c22e121f', '16375944152e6c3e73492437880fe39d7f0123a9292d062e8e9c7d317e4b878f', '1076eab6753435c114e8a720c951b03da6d4e1bbbf1290f8d58ad7f97a0b8c64', '7f7e8733165742e4d8be8dacffe0453045841d70140ba0a9defc1c0d78e8d05c', '44e497e2df0461bad9215c57918855022435eb6e28266916161de3f7902bb352', '0cf3a218420317d1ac2dbe66fe8b3fa5930ee4bfb0f9a25d7059f70b672356ee', 'c2db650dc38549201f151a0fea9030968aca0fd468d0d6d3fe3d9b520ee551e6', '03d4609f1627eb905bc43957db60d2c0ce0b1cf99c6fa8617c936e7170195470', 'f07257d89bd36957d381df4c3d975b976581225d3b0e93b797f231549f809c45', 'cee8a70bcfc00996a87843150f50858ee830d692ae4678e50d5c074d43ff657c', 'b451f1bf9eed3bec2c5e20d4e9122ce6f31202fc68127f2881d2d860e9726365', '5c5fe7e7a382ebc21f89d163deb3520302620f0efe90cedb8592a80b5ef6a394', 'fb2b9389e1455c6d64ae19158396d767d88969013b14075bcfdcc764f610108c', '769d6aec4ab7308875a36f480f397628b2febffed4bc76dc77efd81374577a2f', '36330b0a2474d7598e4665a8ac8b8fbd2c0215a7c2971183879990c1948b22ae', 'ae3bdd3a81d96e4aaa02f7d597a2684146f3af75b743bde8e31c3cf5883707db', 'c63eee4f2d995789dc0fd3300a044e2c8d77d7fd6727e4e7a7bcc637c837d612', '564787d2556d259dabeaa6c5e2a64e9bdbfcf4ff124eb58795eebefb601fdb30', '5324bae9de9c301e9f6c475f9348fb2673813fe613070bb08ffd35c8a0e54204', 'f77d05a1e065348650e7579a3e2688468825cb7764599c8eb0f82836f4f3d9f3', 'a9668d2ded433c7b0eab698458e6b8fd13e4ddabe80417a884a66eda5893de8a', '75621d6a5adc1618337a02bf68856f7e1f8591c46fda003f39100f58bad112e3', '87cbb111ae00db5fad0458158af7d51a3ea8cb3e02e091c32f02ae366900eabb', '26e942b0353fee8f5ac0a2c2e26c9b695c50b35c501eeb4bff343b1648b5cebc', '036168e918418eb807bc3efd361a8e66067192564da41e30e076d22be0f87935', 'a6bd7b8f71e0d959503da2efa6fee412d7e71fb1f54e482a89a61c2a8d6bc691', '9829b13faebde69c2279c38cd54d524aa31acfdcc1cfba7910b9d69caa42e0dd', '2755ae7cda161df0c24e1fa9f1c3308bc9ef81a599d859668490484290ca72f4'] A "as shown in fig_dn_mpls_detnet, mpls nodes are interconnected by different sub-network technologies, which may include point-to-point links. each of these need to provide appropriate service to detnet flows. in some cases, e.g., on dedicated point-to-point links or tdm technologies, all that is required is for a detnet node to appropriately queue its output traffic. in other cases, detnet nodes will need to map detnet flows to the flow semantics (i.e., identifiers) and mechanisms used by an underlying sub-network technology. fig_dn_mpls_sn_ex shows several examples of header formats that can be used to carry detnet mpls flows over different sub-network technologies. l2 represent a generic layer-2 encapsulation that might be used on a point-to-point link. tsn represents the encapsulation used on an ieee 802.1 tsn network, as described in mpls-over-tsn. udp/ip represents the encapsulation used on a detnet ip psn." {6: 1, 31: 1, 124: 1, 67: 1, 53: 1, 8: 1, 79: 2, 90: 3, 51: 3, 130: 2, 62: 4, 85: 4, 68: 3, 35: 3, 110: 3, 91: 5, 114: 3, 97: 3, 13: 3, 38: 4, 26: 3, 98: 2, 54: 2, 127: 3, 96: 3, 64: 2, 30: 4, 61: 5, 55: 2, 27: 2, 15: 3, 52: 2, 129: 3, 115: 3, 84: 2, 76: 4, 87: 3, 131: 5, 102: 3, 113: 5, 99: 2, 36: 3, 24: 2, 72: 4} {161: 1, 264: 1, 328: 1, 392: 1, 369: 1, 220: 1, 221: 1, 1: 8, 4: 2, 9: 3, 10: 3, 15: 3, 24: 2, 25: 4, 26: 4, 27: 3, 39: 4, 43: 3, 49: 6, 50: 5, 58: 5, 59: 2, 64: 3, 69: 2, 81: 5, 82: 4, 86: 3, 96: 4, 97: 3, 100: 7, 108: 3, 109: 4, 110: 4, 111: 2, 114: 3, 115: 4, 116: 3, 118: 5, 119: 4, 120: 3, 121: 3, 122: 4, 123: 3, 124: 3, 128: 4, 129: 4, 130: 5, 132: 2, 136: 2, 145: 2, 147: 4, 151: 4, 152: 4, 154: 3, 156: 2, 162: 2, 165: 3, 168: 4, 169: 3, 172: 3, 180: 4, 184: 3, 187: 5, 188: 4, 191: 3, 194: 2, 202: 3, 203: 4, 206: 2, 207: 3, 217: 3, 218: 7, 222: 4, 224: 3, 227: 5, 229: 3, 234: 5, 235: 2, 241: 2, 242: 2, 243: 2, 244: 4, 245: 2, 248: 4, 250: 4, 258: 10, 262: 4, 263: 5, 267: 3, 270: 3, 272: 3, 273: 3, 287: 3, 289: 3, 291: 5, 299: 5, 300: 3, 304: 3, 309: 2, 314: 2, 315: 3, 320: 3, 323: 2, 327: 4, 329: 2, 330: 9, 334: 2, 335: 3, 341: 5, 342: 6, 347: 5, 348: 5, 350: 5, 351: 5, 352: 3, 353: 3, 354: 2, 358: 3, 365: 3, 366: 2, 371: 7, 372: 5, 376: 2, 384: 5, 385: 4, 386: 3, 387: 3, 393: 2, 396: 6, 397: 6, 398: 5, 402: 3} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 52 "This section covers how DetNet MPLS flows operate over an IEEE 802.1 TSN sub-network. fig_mpls_detnet_to_tsn illustrates such a scenario, where two MPLS (DetNet) nodes are interconnected by a TSN sub- network. Node-1 is single homed and Node-2 is dual-homed. MPLS nodes can be (1) DetNet MPLS End System, (2) DetNet MPLS Edge or Relay node or (3) MPLS Transit node." Similar structure and changes as in IP over TSN . Service protection interworking is out - of - scope . d275ba154e2b7c82eb3ec9175d790214b0e60d3f d275ba154e2b7c82eb3ec9175d790214b0e60d3f draft-ietf-detnet-mpls-over-tsn 55bdece02c98962a77682e9b55671178537e5663507c4ff9c5409df14c7a69af ['899fe49efb71ff0aa7ef3f05ac18bd5bfd87fffe13b5c1288db3416e022be147', 'ab93afb1ce53a91a86685ff579055185d9f7a6798d6effa52aec9838538bdf15', '42b1f3f30d1cae8db1fcb526de2f77c170c19e3508250cf37a94100514f567e6', '55bdece02c98962a77682e9b55671178537e5663507c4ff9c5409df14c7a69af', '438eb33c698936afb27ac820b5f68528ff155bd5a6927b63e6259a419be2e1a9', 'ed695265f24af924853cf42b909ea782e13659dd90448b1a4bc4800314d00f86', 'a8ff14472a8fa48bacdc11d7089a9d1054c0a786f6152f510b5d4092c22e121f', '16375944152e6c3e73492437880fe39d7f0123a9292d062e8e9c7d317e4b878f', '1076eab6753435c114e8a720c951b03da6d4e1bbbf1290f8d58ad7f97a0b8c64', '7f7e8733165742e4d8be8dacffe0453045841d70140ba0a9defc1c0d78e8d05c', '44e497e2df0461bad9215c57918855022435eb6e28266916161de3f7902bb352', '0cf3a218420317d1ac2dbe66fe8b3fa5930ee4bfb0f9a25d7059f70b672356ee', 'c2db650dc38549201f151a0fea9030968aca0fd468d0d6d3fe3d9b520ee551e6', '03d4609f1627eb905bc43957db60d2c0ce0b1cf99c6fa8617c936e7170195470', 'f07257d89bd36957d381df4c3d975b976581225d3b0e93b797f231549f809c45', 'cee8a70bcfc00996a87843150f50858ee830d692ae4678e50d5c074d43ff657c', 'b451f1bf9eed3bec2c5e20d4e9122ce6f31202fc68127f2881d2d860e9726365', '5c5fe7e7a382ebc21f89d163deb3520302620f0efe90cedb8592a80b5ef6a394', 'fb2b9389e1455c6d64ae19158396d767d88969013b14075bcfdcc764f610108c', '769d6aec4ab7308875a36f480f397628b2febffed4bc76dc77efd81374577a2f', '36330b0a2474d7598e4665a8ac8b8fbd2c0215a7c2971183879990c1948b22ae', 'ae3bdd3a81d96e4aaa02f7d597a2684146f3af75b743bde8e31c3cf5883707db', 'c63eee4f2d995789dc0fd3300a044e2c8d77d7fd6727e4e7a7bcc637c837d612', '564787d2556d259dabeaa6c5e2a64e9bdbfcf4ff124eb58795eebefb601fdb30', '5324bae9de9c301e9f6c475f9348fb2673813fe613070bb08ffd35c8a0e54204', 'f77d05a1e065348650e7579a3e2688468825cb7764599c8eb0f82836f4f3d9f3', 'a9668d2ded433c7b0eab698458e6b8fd13e4ddabe80417a884a66eda5893de8a', '75621d6a5adc1618337a02bf68856f7e1f8591c46fda003f39100f58bad112e3', '87cbb111ae00db5fad0458158af7d51a3ea8cb3e02e091c32f02ae366900eabb', '26e942b0353fee8f5ac0a2c2e26c9b695c50b35c501eeb4bff343b1648b5cebc', '036168e918418eb807bc3efd361a8e66067192564da41e30e076d22be0f87935', 'a6bd7b8f71e0d959503da2efa6fee412d7e71fb1f54e482a89a61c2a8d6bc691', '9829b13faebde69c2279c38cd54d524aa31acfdcc1cfba7910b9d69caa42e0dd', '2755ae7cda161df0c24e1fa9f1c3308bc9ef81a599d859668490484290ca72f4'] A "this section covers how detnet mpls flows operate over an ieee 802.1 tsn sub-network. fig_mpls_detnet_to_tsn illustrates such a scenario, where two mpls (detnet) nodes are interconnected by a tsn sub- network. node-1 is single homed and node-2 is dual-homed. mpls nodes can be (1) detnet mpls end system, (2) detnet mpls edge or relay node or (3) mpls transit node." {6: 1, 31: 1, 124: 1, 67: 1, 53: 1, 8: 1, 79: 2, 90: 3, 51: 3, 130: 2, 62: 4, 85: 4, 68: 3, 35: 3, 110: 3, 91: 5, 114: 3, 97: 3, 13: 3, 38: 4, 26: 3, 98: 2, 54: 2, 127: 3, 96: 3, 64: 2, 30: 4, 61: 5, 55: 2, 27: 2, 15: 3, 52: 2, 129: 3, 115: 3, 84: 2, 76: 4, 87: 3, 131: 5, 102: 3, 113: 5, 99: 2, 36: 3, 24: 2, 72: 4} {161: 1, 264: 1, 328: 1, 392: 1, 369: 1, 220: 1, 221: 1, 1: 8, 4: 2, 9: 3, 10: 3, 15: 3, 24: 2, 25: 4, 26: 4, 27: 3, 39: 4, 43: 3, 49: 6, 50: 5, 58: 5, 59: 2, 64: 3, 69: 2, 81: 5, 82: 4, 86: 3, 96: 4, 97: 3, 100: 7, 108: 3, 109: 4, 110: 4, 111: 2, 114: 3, 115: 4, 116: 3, 118: 5, 119: 4, 120: 3, 121: 3, 122: 4, 123: 3, 124: 3, 128: 4, 129: 4, 130: 5, 132: 2, 136: 2, 145: 2, 147: 4, 151: 4, 152: 4, 154: 3, 156: 2, 162: 2, 165: 3, 168: 4, 169: 3, 172: 3, 180: 4, 184: 3, 187: 5, 188: 4, 191: 3, 194: 2, 202: 3, 203: 4, 206: 2, 207: 3, 217: 3, 218: 7, 222: 4, 224: 3, 227: 5, 229: 3, 234: 5, 235: 2, 241: 2, 242: 2, 243: 2, 244: 4, 245: 2, 248: 4, 250: 4, 258: 10, 262: 4, 263: 5, 267: 3, 270: 3, 272: 3, 273: 3, 287: 3, 289: 3, 291: 5, 299: 5, 300: 3, 304: 3, 309: 2, 314: 2, 315: 3, 320: 3, 323: 2, 327: 4, 329: 2, 330: 9, 334: 2, 335: 3, 341: 5, 342: 6, 347: 5, 348: 5, 350: 5, 351: 5, 352: 3, 353: 3, 354: 2, 358: 3, 365: 3, 366: 2, 371: 7, 372: 5, 376: 2, 384: 5, 385: 4, 386: 3, 387: 3, 393: 2, 396: 6, 397: 6, 398: 5, 402: 3} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 52 "Note: in case of MPLS Transit node there is no DetNet Service sub- layer processing." Similar structure and changes as in IP over TSN . Service protection interworking is out - of - scope . d275ba154e2b7c82eb3ec9175d790214b0e60d3f d275ba154e2b7c82eb3ec9175d790214b0e60d3f draft-ietf-detnet-mpls-over-tsn f07257d89bd36957d381df4c3d975b976581225d3b0e93b797f231549f809c45 ['899fe49efb71ff0aa7ef3f05ac18bd5bfd87fffe13b5c1288db3416e022be147', 'ab93afb1ce53a91a86685ff579055185d9f7a6798d6effa52aec9838538bdf15', '42b1f3f30d1cae8db1fcb526de2f77c170c19e3508250cf37a94100514f567e6', '55bdece02c98962a77682e9b55671178537e5663507c4ff9c5409df14c7a69af', '438eb33c698936afb27ac820b5f68528ff155bd5a6927b63e6259a419be2e1a9', 'ed695265f24af924853cf42b909ea782e13659dd90448b1a4bc4800314d00f86', 'a8ff14472a8fa48bacdc11d7089a9d1054c0a786f6152f510b5d4092c22e121f', '16375944152e6c3e73492437880fe39d7f0123a9292d062e8e9c7d317e4b878f', '1076eab6753435c114e8a720c951b03da6d4e1bbbf1290f8d58ad7f97a0b8c64', '7f7e8733165742e4d8be8dacffe0453045841d70140ba0a9defc1c0d78e8d05c', '44e497e2df0461bad9215c57918855022435eb6e28266916161de3f7902bb352', '0cf3a218420317d1ac2dbe66fe8b3fa5930ee4bfb0f9a25d7059f70b672356ee', 'c2db650dc38549201f151a0fea9030968aca0fd468d0d6d3fe3d9b520ee551e6', '03d4609f1627eb905bc43957db60d2c0ce0b1cf99c6fa8617c936e7170195470', 'f07257d89bd36957d381df4c3d975b976581225d3b0e93b797f231549f809c45', 'cee8a70bcfc00996a87843150f50858ee830d692ae4678e50d5c074d43ff657c', 'b451f1bf9eed3bec2c5e20d4e9122ce6f31202fc68127f2881d2d860e9726365', '5c5fe7e7a382ebc21f89d163deb3520302620f0efe90cedb8592a80b5ef6a394', 'fb2b9389e1455c6d64ae19158396d767d88969013b14075bcfdcc764f610108c', '769d6aec4ab7308875a36f480f397628b2febffed4bc76dc77efd81374577a2f', '36330b0a2474d7598e4665a8ac8b8fbd2c0215a7c2971183879990c1948b22ae', 'ae3bdd3a81d96e4aaa02f7d597a2684146f3af75b743bde8e31c3cf5883707db', 'c63eee4f2d995789dc0fd3300a044e2c8d77d7fd6727e4e7a7bcc637c837d612', '564787d2556d259dabeaa6c5e2a64e9bdbfcf4ff124eb58795eebefb601fdb30', '5324bae9de9c301e9f6c475f9348fb2673813fe613070bb08ffd35c8a0e54204', 'f77d05a1e065348650e7579a3e2688468825cb7764599c8eb0f82836f4f3d9f3', 'a9668d2ded433c7b0eab698458e6b8fd13e4ddabe80417a884a66eda5893de8a', '75621d6a5adc1618337a02bf68856f7e1f8591c46fda003f39100f58bad112e3', '87cbb111ae00db5fad0458158af7d51a3ea8cb3e02e091c32f02ae366900eabb', '26e942b0353fee8f5ac0a2c2e26c9b695c50b35c501eeb4bff343b1648b5cebc', '036168e918418eb807bc3efd361a8e66067192564da41e30e076d22be0f87935', 'a6bd7b8f71e0d959503da2efa6fee412d7e71fb1f54e482a89a61c2a8d6bc691', '9829b13faebde69c2279c38cd54d524aa31acfdcc1cfba7910b9d69caa42e0dd', '2755ae7cda161df0c24e1fa9f1c3308bc9ef81a599d859668490484290ca72f4'] A "note: in case of mpls transit node there is no detnet service sub- layer processing." {6: 1, 31: 1, 124: 1, 67: 1, 53: 1, 8: 1, 79: 2, 90: 3, 51: 3, 130: 2, 62: 4, 85: 4, 68: 3, 35: 3, 110: 3, 91: 5, 114: 3, 97: 3, 13: 3, 38: 4, 26: 3, 98: 2, 54: 2, 127: 3, 96: 3, 64: 2, 30: 4, 61: 5, 55: 2, 27: 2, 15: 3, 52: 2, 129: 3, 115: 3, 84: 2, 76: 4, 87: 3, 131: 5, 102: 3, 113: 5, 99: 2, 36: 3, 24: 2, 72: 4} {161: 1, 264: 1, 328: 1, 392: 1, 369: 1, 220: 1, 221: 1, 1: 8, 4: 2, 9: 3, 10: 3, 15: 3, 24: 2, 25: 4, 26: 4, 27: 3, 39: 4, 43: 3, 49: 6, 50: 5, 58: 5, 59: 2, 64: 3, 69: 2, 81: 5, 82: 4, 86: 3, 96: 4, 97: 3, 100: 7, 108: 3, 109: 4, 110: 4, 111: 2, 114: 3, 115: 4, 116: 3, 118: 5, 119: 4, 120: 3, 121: 3, 122: 4, 123: 3, 124: 3, 128: 4, 129: 4, 130: 5, 132: 2, 136: 2, 145: 2, 147: 4, 151: 4, 152: 4, 154: 3, 156: 2, 162: 2, 165: 3, 168: 4, 169: 3, 172: 3, 180: 4, 184: 3, 187: 5, 188: 4, 191: 3, 194: 2, 202: 3, 203: 4, 206: 2, 207: 3, 217: 3, 218: 7, 222: 4, 224: 3, 227: 5, 229: 3, 234: 5, 235: 2, 241: 2, 242: 2, 243: 2, 244: 4, 245: 2, 248: 4, 250: 4, 258: 10, 262: 4, 263: 5, 267: 3, 270: 3, 272: 3, 273: 3, 287: 3, 289: 3, 291: 5, 299: 5, 300: 3, 304: 3, 309: 2, 314: 2, 315: 3, 320: 3, 323: 2, 327: 4, 329: 2, 330: 9, 334: 2, 335: 3, 341: 5, 342: 6, 347: 5, 348: 5, 350: 5, 351: 5, 352: 3, 353: 3, 354: 2, 358: 3, 365: 3, 366: 2, 371: 7, 372: 5, 376: 2, 384: 5, 385: 4, 386: 3, 387: 3, 393: 2, 396: 6, 397: 6, 398: 5, 402: 3} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 52 "fig_mpls_detnet_part illustrates an extract of a DetNet enabled MPLS network. Edge/relay nodes sit at MPLS LSP boundaries and transit nodes are LSRs. In this figure, two MPLS nodes (the edge node and the transit node) are interconnected by a TSN sub-network." Similar structure and changes as in IP over TSN . Service protection interworking is out - of - scope . d275ba154e2b7c82eb3ec9175d790214b0e60d3f d275ba154e2b7c82eb3ec9175d790214b0e60d3f draft-ietf-detnet-mpls-over-tsn cee8a70bcfc00996a87843150f50858ee830d692ae4678e50d5c074d43ff657c ['899fe49efb71ff0aa7ef3f05ac18bd5bfd87fffe13b5c1288db3416e022be147', 'ab93afb1ce53a91a86685ff579055185d9f7a6798d6effa52aec9838538bdf15', '42b1f3f30d1cae8db1fcb526de2f77c170c19e3508250cf37a94100514f567e6', '55bdece02c98962a77682e9b55671178537e5663507c4ff9c5409df14c7a69af', '438eb33c698936afb27ac820b5f68528ff155bd5a6927b63e6259a419be2e1a9', 'ed695265f24af924853cf42b909ea782e13659dd90448b1a4bc4800314d00f86', 'a8ff14472a8fa48bacdc11d7089a9d1054c0a786f6152f510b5d4092c22e121f', '16375944152e6c3e73492437880fe39d7f0123a9292d062e8e9c7d317e4b878f', '1076eab6753435c114e8a720c951b03da6d4e1bbbf1290f8d58ad7f97a0b8c64', '7f7e8733165742e4d8be8dacffe0453045841d70140ba0a9defc1c0d78e8d05c', '44e497e2df0461bad9215c57918855022435eb6e28266916161de3f7902bb352', '0cf3a218420317d1ac2dbe66fe8b3fa5930ee4bfb0f9a25d7059f70b672356ee', 'c2db650dc38549201f151a0fea9030968aca0fd468d0d6d3fe3d9b520ee551e6', '03d4609f1627eb905bc43957db60d2c0ce0b1cf99c6fa8617c936e7170195470', 'f07257d89bd36957d381df4c3d975b976581225d3b0e93b797f231549f809c45', 'cee8a70bcfc00996a87843150f50858ee830d692ae4678e50d5c074d43ff657c', 'b451f1bf9eed3bec2c5e20d4e9122ce6f31202fc68127f2881d2d860e9726365', '5c5fe7e7a382ebc21f89d163deb3520302620f0efe90cedb8592a80b5ef6a394', 'fb2b9389e1455c6d64ae19158396d767d88969013b14075bcfdcc764f610108c', '769d6aec4ab7308875a36f480f397628b2febffed4bc76dc77efd81374577a2f', '36330b0a2474d7598e4665a8ac8b8fbd2c0215a7c2971183879990c1948b22ae', 'ae3bdd3a81d96e4aaa02f7d597a2684146f3af75b743bde8e31c3cf5883707db', 'c63eee4f2d995789dc0fd3300a044e2c8d77d7fd6727e4e7a7bcc637c837d612', '564787d2556d259dabeaa6c5e2a64e9bdbfcf4ff124eb58795eebefb601fdb30', '5324bae9de9c301e9f6c475f9348fb2673813fe613070bb08ffd35c8a0e54204', 'f77d05a1e065348650e7579a3e2688468825cb7764599c8eb0f82836f4f3d9f3', 'a9668d2ded433c7b0eab698458e6b8fd13e4ddabe80417a884a66eda5893de8a', '75621d6a5adc1618337a02bf68856f7e1f8591c46fda003f39100f58bad112e3', '87cbb111ae00db5fad0458158af7d51a3ea8cb3e02e091c32f02ae366900eabb', '26e942b0353fee8f5ac0a2c2e26c9b695c50b35c501eeb4bff343b1648b5cebc', '036168e918418eb807bc3efd361a8e66067192564da41e30e076d22be0f87935', 'a6bd7b8f71e0d959503da2efa6fee412d7e71fb1f54e482a89a61c2a8d6bc691', '9829b13faebde69c2279c38cd54d524aa31acfdcc1cfba7910b9d69caa42e0dd', '2755ae7cda161df0c24e1fa9f1c3308bc9ef81a599d859668490484290ca72f4'] B "fig_mpls_detnet_part illustrates an extract of a detnet enabled mpls network. edge/relay nodes sit at mpls lsp boundaries and transit nodes are lsrs. in this figure, two mpls nodes (the edge node and the transit node) are interconnected by a tsn sub-network." {6: 1, 31: 1, 124: 1, 67: 1, 53: 1, 8: 1, 79: 2, 90: 3, 51: 3, 130: 2, 62: 4, 85: 4, 68: 3, 35: 3, 110: 3, 91: 5, 114: 3, 97: 3, 13: 3, 38: 4, 26: 3, 98: 2, 54: 2, 127: 3, 96: 3, 64: 2, 30: 4, 61: 5, 55: 2, 27: 2, 15: 3, 52: 2, 129: 3, 115: 3, 84: 2, 76: 4, 87: 3, 131: 5, 102: 3, 113: 5, 99: 2, 36: 3, 24: 2, 72: 4} {161: 1, 264: 1, 328: 1, 392: 1, 369: 1, 220: 1, 221: 1, 1: 8, 4: 2, 9: 3, 10: 3, 15: 3, 24: 2, 25: 4, 26: 4, 27: 3, 39: 4, 43: 3, 49: 6, 50: 5, 58: 5, 59: 2, 64: 3, 69: 2, 81: 5, 82: 4, 86: 3, 96: 4, 97: 3, 100: 7, 108: 3, 109: 4, 110: 4, 111: 2, 114: 3, 115: 4, 116: 3, 118: 5, 119: 4, 120: 3, 121: 3, 122: 4, 123: 3, 124: 3, 128: 4, 129: 4, 130: 5, 132: 2, 136: 2, 145: 2, 147: 4, 151: 4, 152: 4, 154: 3, 156: 2, 162: 2, 165: 3, 168: 4, 169: 3, 172: 3, 180: 4, 184: 3, 187: 5, 188: 4, 191: 3, 194: 2, 202: 3, 203: 4, 206: 2, 207: 3, 217: 3, 218: 7, 222: 4, 224: 3, 227: 5, 229: 3, 234: 5, 235: 2, 241: 2, 242: 2, 243: 2, 244: 4, 245: 2, 248: 4, 250: 4, 258: 10, 262: 4, 263: 5, 267: 3, 270: 3, 272: 3, 273: 3, 287: 3, 289: 3, 291: 5, 299: 5, 300: 3, 304: 3, 309: 2, 314: 2, 315: 3, 320: 3, 323: 2, 327: 4, 329: 2, 330: 9, 334: 2, 335: 3, 341: 5, 342: 6, 347: 5, 348: 5, 350: 5, 351: 5, 352: 3, 353: 3, 354: 2, 358: 3, 365: 3, 366: 2, 371: 7, 372: 5, 376: 2, 384: 5, 385: 4, 386: 3, 387: 3, 393: 2, 396: 6, 397: 6, 398: 5, 402: 3} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 52 "DetNet edge/relay nodes are DetNet service sub-layer aware, understand the particular needs of DetNet flows and provide both DetNet service and forwarding sub-layer functions. They add, remove and process d-CWs, S-Labels and F-labels as needed. MPLS enabled DetNet nodes can enhance the reliability of delivery by enabling the replication of packets where multiple copies, possibly over multiple paths, are forwarded through the DetNet domain. They can also eliminate surplus previously replicated copies of DetNet packets. MPLS (DetNet) nodes also include DetNet forwarding sub-layer functions, support for notably explicit routes, and resources allocation to eliminate (or reduce) congestion loss and jitter." Similar structure and changes as in IP over TSN . Service protection interworking is out - of - scope . d275ba154e2b7c82eb3ec9175d790214b0e60d3f d275ba154e2b7c82eb3ec9175d790214b0e60d3f draft-ietf-detnet-mpls-over-tsn 1076eab6753435c114e8a720c951b03da6d4e1bbbf1290f8d58ad7f97a0b8c64 ['899fe49efb71ff0aa7ef3f05ac18bd5bfd87fffe13b5c1288db3416e022be147', 'ab93afb1ce53a91a86685ff579055185d9f7a6798d6effa52aec9838538bdf15', '42b1f3f30d1cae8db1fcb526de2f77c170c19e3508250cf37a94100514f567e6', '55bdece02c98962a77682e9b55671178537e5663507c4ff9c5409df14c7a69af', '438eb33c698936afb27ac820b5f68528ff155bd5a6927b63e6259a419be2e1a9', 'ed695265f24af924853cf42b909ea782e13659dd90448b1a4bc4800314d00f86', 'a8ff14472a8fa48bacdc11d7089a9d1054c0a786f6152f510b5d4092c22e121f', '16375944152e6c3e73492437880fe39d7f0123a9292d062e8e9c7d317e4b878f', '1076eab6753435c114e8a720c951b03da6d4e1bbbf1290f8d58ad7f97a0b8c64', '7f7e8733165742e4d8be8dacffe0453045841d70140ba0a9defc1c0d78e8d05c', '44e497e2df0461bad9215c57918855022435eb6e28266916161de3f7902bb352', '0cf3a218420317d1ac2dbe66fe8b3fa5930ee4bfb0f9a25d7059f70b672356ee', 'c2db650dc38549201f151a0fea9030968aca0fd468d0d6d3fe3d9b520ee551e6', '03d4609f1627eb905bc43957db60d2c0ce0b1cf99c6fa8617c936e7170195470', 'f07257d89bd36957d381df4c3d975b976581225d3b0e93b797f231549f809c45', 'cee8a70bcfc00996a87843150f50858ee830d692ae4678e50d5c074d43ff657c', 'b451f1bf9eed3bec2c5e20d4e9122ce6f31202fc68127f2881d2d860e9726365', '5c5fe7e7a382ebc21f89d163deb3520302620f0efe90cedb8592a80b5ef6a394', 'fb2b9389e1455c6d64ae19158396d767d88969013b14075bcfdcc764f610108c', '769d6aec4ab7308875a36f480f397628b2febffed4bc76dc77efd81374577a2f', '36330b0a2474d7598e4665a8ac8b8fbd2c0215a7c2971183879990c1948b22ae', 'ae3bdd3a81d96e4aaa02f7d597a2684146f3af75b743bde8e31c3cf5883707db', 'c63eee4f2d995789dc0fd3300a044e2c8d77d7fd6727e4e7a7bcc637c837d612', '564787d2556d259dabeaa6c5e2a64e9bdbfcf4ff124eb58795eebefb601fdb30', '5324bae9de9c301e9f6c475f9348fb2673813fe613070bb08ffd35c8a0e54204', 'f77d05a1e065348650e7579a3e2688468825cb7764599c8eb0f82836f4f3d9f3', 'a9668d2ded433c7b0eab698458e6b8fd13e4ddabe80417a884a66eda5893de8a', '75621d6a5adc1618337a02bf68856f7e1f8591c46fda003f39100f58bad112e3', '87cbb111ae00db5fad0458158af7d51a3ea8cb3e02e091c32f02ae366900eabb', '26e942b0353fee8f5ac0a2c2e26c9b695c50b35c501eeb4bff343b1648b5cebc', '036168e918418eb807bc3efd361a8e66067192564da41e30e076d22be0f87935', 'a6bd7b8f71e0d959503da2efa6fee412d7e71fb1f54e482a89a61c2a8d6bc691', '9829b13faebde69c2279c38cd54d524aa31acfdcc1cfba7910b9d69caa42e0dd', '2755ae7cda161df0c24e1fa9f1c3308bc9ef81a599d859668490484290ca72f4'] B "detnet edge/relay nodes are detnet service sub-layer aware, understand the particular needs of detnet flows and provide both detnet service and forwarding sub-layer functions. they add, remove and process d-cws, s-labels and f-labels as needed. mpls enabled detnet nodes can enhance the reliability of delivery by enabling the replication of packets where multiple copies, possibly over multiple paths, are forwarded through the detnet domain. they can also eliminate surplus previously replicated copies of detnet packets. mpls (detnet) nodes also include detnet forwarding sub-layer functions, support for notably explicit routes, and resources allocation to eliminate (or reduce) congestion loss and jitter." {6: 1, 31: 1, 124: 1, 67: 1, 53: 1, 8: 1, 79: 2, 90: 3, 51: 3, 130: 2, 62: 4, 85: 4, 68: 3, 35: 3, 110: 3, 91: 5, 114: 3, 97: 3, 13: 3, 38: 4, 26: 3, 98: 2, 54: 2, 127: 3, 96: 3, 64: 2, 30: 4, 61: 5, 55: 2, 27: 2, 15: 3, 52: 2, 129: 3, 115: 3, 84: 2, 76: 4, 87: 3, 131: 5, 102: 3, 113: 5, 99: 2, 36: 3, 24: 2, 72: 4} {161: 1, 264: 1, 328: 1, 392: 1, 369: 1, 220: 1, 221: 1, 1: 8, 4: 2, 9: 3, 10: 3, 15: 3, 24: 2, 25: 4, 26: 4, 27: 3, 39: 4, 43: 3, 49: 6, 50: 5, 58: 5, 59: 2, 64: 3, 69: 2, 81: 5, 82: 4, 86: 3, 96: 4, 97: 3, 100: 7, 108: 3, 109: 4, 110: 4, 111: 2, 114: 3, 115: 4, 116: 3, 118: 5, 119: 4, 120: 3, 121: 3, 122: 4, 123: 3, 124: 3, 128: 4, 129: 4, 130: 5, 132: 2, 136: 2, 145: 2, 147: 4, 151: 4, 152: 4, 154: 3, 156: 2, 162: 2, 165: 3, 168: 4, 169: 3, 172: 3, 180: 4, 184: 3, 187: 5, 188: 4, 191: 3, 194: 2, 202: 3, 203: 4, 206: 2, 207: 3, 217: 3, 218: 7, 222: 4, 224: 3, 227: 5, 229: 3, 234: 5, 235: 2, 241: 2, 242: 2, 243: 2, 244: 4, 245: 2, 248: 4, 250: 4, 258: 10, 262: 4, 263: 5, 267: 3, 270: 3, 272: 3, 273: 3, 287: 3, 289: 3, 291: 5, 299: 5, 300: 3, 304: 3, 309: 2, 314: 2, 315: 3, 320: 3, 323: 2, 327: 4, 329: 2, 330: 9, 334: 2, 335: 3, 341: 5, 342: 6, 347: 5, 348: 5, 350: 5, 351: 5, 352: 3, 353: 3, 354: 2, 358: 3, 365: 3, 366: 2, 371: 7, 372: 5, 376: 2, 384: 5, 385: 4, 386: 3, 387: 3, 393: 2, 396: 6, 397: 6, 398: 5, 402: 3} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 52 "DetNet transit nodes reside wholly within a DetNet domain, and also provide DetNet forwarding sub-layer functions in accordance with the performance required by a DetNet flow carried over an LSP. Unlike other DetNet node types, transit nodes provide no service sub-layer processing." Similar structure and changes as in IP over TSN . Service protection interworking is out - of - scope . d275ba154e2b7c82eb3ec9175d790214b0e60d3f d275ba154e2b7c82eb3ec9175d790214b0e60d3f draft-ietf-detnet-mpls-over-tsn 44e497e2df0461bad9215c57918855022435eb6e28266916161de3f7902bb352 ['899fe49efb71ff0aa7ef3f05ac18bd5bfd87fffe13b5c1288db3416e022be147', 'ab93afb1ce53a91a86685ff579055185d9f7a6798d6effa52aec9838538bdf15', '42b1f3f30d1cae8db1fcb526de2f77c170c19e3508250cf37a94100514f567e6', '55bdece02c98962a77682e9b55671178537e5663507c4ff9c5409df14c7a69af', '438eb33c698936afb27ac820b5f68528ff155bd5a6927b63e6259a419be2e1a9', 'ed695265f24af924853cf42b909ea782e13659dd90448b1a4bc4800314d00f86', 'a8ff14472a8fa48bacdc11d7089a9d1054c0a786f6152f510b5d4092c22e121f', '16375944152e6c3e73492437880fe39d7f0123a9292d062e8e9c7d317e4b878f', '1076eab6753435c114e8a720c951b03da6d4e1bbbf1290f8d58ad7f97a0b8c64', '7f7e8733165742e4d8be8dacffe0453045841d70140ba0a9defc1c0d78e8d05c', '44e497e2df0461bad9215c57918855022435eb6e28266916161de3f7902bb352', '0cf3a218420317d1ac2dbe66fe8b3fa5930ee4bfb0f9a25d7059f70b672356ee', 'c2db650dc38549201f151a0fea9030968aca0fd468d0d6d3fe3d9b520ee551e6', '03d4609f1627eb905bc43957db60d2c0ce0b1cf99c6fa8617c936e7170195470', 'f07257d89bd36957d381df4c3d975b976581225d3b0e93b797f231549f809c45', 'cee8a70bcfc00996a87843150f50858ee830d692ae4678e50d5c074d43ff657c', 'b451f1bf9eed3bec2c5e20d4e9122ce6f31202fc68127f2881d2d860e9726365', '5c5fe7e7a382ebc21f89d163deb3520302620f0efe90cedb8592a80b5ef6a394', 'fb2b9389e1455c6d64ae19158396d767d88969013b14075bcfdcc764f610108c', '769d6aec4ab7308875a36f480f397628b2febffed4bc76dc77efd81374577a2f', '36330b0a2474d7598e4665a8ac8b8fbd2c0215a7c2971183879990c1948b22ae', 'ae3bdd3a81d96e4aaa02f7d597a2684146f3af75b743bde8e31c3cf5883707db', 'c63eee4f2d995789dc0fd3300a044e2c8d77d7fd6727e4e7a7bcc637c837d612', '564787d2556d259dabeaa6c5e2a64e9bdbfcf4ff124eb58795eebefb601fdb30', '5324bae9de9c301e9f6c475f9348fb2673813fe613070bb08ffd35c8a0e54204', 'f77d05a1e065348650e7579a3e2688468825cb7764599c8eb0f82836f4f3d9f3', 'a9668d2ded433c7b0eab698458e6b8fd13e4ddabe80417a884a66eda5893de8a', '75621d6a5adc1618337a02bf68856f7e1f8591c46fda003f39100f58bad112e3', '87cbb111ae00db5fad0458158af7d51a3ea8cb3e02e091c32f02ae366900eabb', '26e942b0353fee8f5ac0a2c2e26c9b695c50b35c501eeb4bff343b1648b5cebc', '036168e918418eb807bc3efd361a8e66067192564da41e30e076d22be0f87935', 'a6bd7b8f71e0d959503da2efa6fee412d7e71fb1f54e482a89a61c2a8d6bc691', '9829b13faebde69c2279c38cd54d524aa31acfdcc1cfba7910b9d69caa42e0dd', '2755ae7cda161df0c24e1fa9f1c3308bc9ef81a599d859668490484290ca72f4'] B "detnet transit nodes reside wholly within a detnet domain, and also provide detnet forwarding sub-layer functions in accordance with the performance required by a detnet flow carried over an lsp. unlike other detnet node types, transit nodes provide no service sub-layer processing." {6: 1, 31: 1, 124: 1, 67: 1, 53: 1, 8: 1, 79: 2, 90: 3, 51: 3, 130: 2, 62: 4, 85: 4, 68: 3, 35: 3, 110: 3, 91: 5, 114: 3, 97: 3, 13: 3, 38: 4, 26: 3, 98: 2, 54: 2, 127: 3, 96: 3, 64: 2, 30: 4, 61: 5, 55: 2, 27: 2, 15: 3, 52: 2, 129: 3, 115: 3, 84: 2, 76: 4, 87: 3, 131: 5, 102: 3, 113: 5, 99: 2, 36: 3, 24: 2, 72: 4} {161: 1, 264: 1, 328: 1, 392: 1, 369: 1, 220: 1, 221: 1, 1: 8, 4: 2, 9: 3, 10: 3, 15: 3, 24: 2, 25: 4, 26: 4, 27: 3, 39: 4, 43: 3, 49: 6, 50: 5, 58: 5, 59: 2, 64: 3, 69: 2, 81: 5, 82: 4, 86: 3, 96: 4, 97: 3, 100: 7, 108: 3, 109: 4, 110: 4, 111: 2, 114: 3, 115: 4, 116: 3, 118: 5, 119: 4, 120: 3, 121: 3, 122: 4, 123: 3, 124: 3, 128: 4, 129: 4, 130: 5, 132: 2, 136: 2, 145: 2, 147: 4, 151: 4, 152: 4, 154: 3, 156: 2, 162: 2, 165: 3, 168: 4, 169: 3, 172: 3, 180: 4, 184: 3, 187: 5, 188: 4, 191: 3, 194: 2, 202: 3, 203: 4, 206: 2, 207: 3, 217: 3, 218: 7, 222: 4, 224: 3, 227: 5, 229: 3, 234: 5, 235: 2, 241: 2, 242: 2, 243: 2, 244: 4, 245: 2, 248: 4, 250: 4, 258: 10, 262: 4, 263: 5, 267: 3, 270: 3, 272: 3, 273: 3, 287: 3, 289: 3, 291: 5, 299: 5, 300: 3, 304: 3, 309: 2, 314: 2, 315: 3, 320: 3, 323: 2, 327: 4, 329: 2, 330: 9, 334: 2, 335: 3, 341: 5, 342: 6, 347: 5, 348: 5, 350: 5, 351: 5, 352: 3, 353: 3, 354: 2, 358: 3, 365: 3, 366: 2, 371: 7, 372: 5, 376: 2, 384: 5, 385: 4, 386: 3, 387: 3, 393: 2, 396: 6, 397: 6, 398: 5, 402: 3} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 52 Service protection. Similar structure and changes as in IP over TSN . Service protection interworking is out - of - scope . d275ba154e2b7c82eb3ec9175d790214b0e60d3f d275ba154e2b7c82eb3ec9175d790214b0e60d3f draft-ietf-detnet-mpls-over-tsn b451f1bf9eed3bec2c5e20d4e9122ce6f31202fc68127f2881d2d860e9726365 ['899fe49efb71ff0aa7ef3f05ac18bd5bfd87fffe13b5c1288db3416e022be147', 'ab93afb1ce53a91a86685ff579055185d9f7a6798d6effa52aec9838538bdf15', '42b1f3f30d1cae8db1fcb526de2f77c170c19e3508250cf37a94100514f567e6', '55bdece02c98962a77682e9b55671178537e5663507c4ff9c5409df14c7a69af', '438eb33c698936afb27ac820b5f68528ff155bd5a6927b63e6259a419be2e1a9', 'ed695265f24af924853cf42b909ea782e13659dd90448b1a4bc4800314d00f86', 'a8ff14472a8fa48bacdc11d7089a9d1054c0a786f6152f510b5d4092c22e121f', '16375944152e6c3e73492437880fe39d7f0123a9292d062e8e9c7d317e4b878f', '1076eab6753435c114e8a720c951b03da6d4e1bbbf1290f8d58ad7f97a0b8c64', '7f7e8733165742e4d8be8dacffe0453045841d70140ba0a9defc1c0d78e8d05c', '44e497e2df0461bad9215c57918855022435eb6e28266916161de3f7902bb352', '0cf3a218420317d1ac2dbe66fe8b3fa5930ee4bfb0f9a25d7059f70b672356ee', 'c2db650dc38549201f151a0fea9030968aca0fd468d0d6d3fe3d9b520ee551e6', '03d4609f1627eb905bc43957db60d2c0ce0b1cf99c6fa8617c936e7170195470', 'f07257d89bd36957d381df4c3d975b976581225d3b0e93b797f231549f809c45', 'cee8a70bcfc00996a87843150f50858ee830d692ae4678e50d5c074d43ff657c', 'b451f1bf9eed3bec2c5e20d4e9122ce6f31202fc68127f2881d2d860e9726365', '5c5fe7e7a382ebc21f89d163deb3520302620f0efe90cedb8592a80b5ef6a394', 'fb2b9389e1455c6d64ae19158396d767d88969013b14075bcfdcc764f610108c', '769d6aec4ab7308875a36f480f397628b2febffed4bc76dc77efd81374577a2f', '36330b0a2474d7598e4665a8ac8b8fbd2c0215a7c2971183879990c1948b22ae', 'ae3bdd3a81d96e4aaa02f7d597a2684146f3af75b743bde8e31c3cf5883707db', 'c63eee4f2d995789dc0fd3300a044e2c8d77d7fd6727e4e7a7bcc637c837d612', '564787d2556d259dabeaa6c5e2a64e9bdbfcf4ff124eb58795eebefb601fdb30', '5324bae9de9c301e9f6c475f9348fb2673813fe613070bb08ffd35c8a0e54204', 'f77d05a1e065348650e7579a3e2688468825cb7764599c8eb0f82836f4f3d9f3', 'a9668d2ded433c7b0eab698458e6b8fd13e4ddabe80417a884a66eda5893de8a', '75621d6a5adc1618337a02bf68856f7e1f8591c46fda003f39100f58bad112e3', '87cbb111ae00db5fad0458158af7d51a3ea8cb3e02e091c32f02ae366900eabb', '26e942b0353fee8f5ac0a2c2e26c9b695c50b35c501eeb4bff343b1648b5cebc', '036168e918418eb807bc3efd361a8e66067192564da41e30e076d22be0f87935', 'a6bd7b8f71e0d959503da2efa6fee412d7e71fb1f54e482a89a61c2a8d6bc691', '9829b13faebde69c2279c38cd54d524aa31acfdcc1cfba7910b9d69caa42e0dd', '2755ae7cda161df0c24e1fa9f1c3308bc9ef81a599d859668490484290ca72f4'] B service protection. {6: 1, 31: 1, 124: 1, 67: 1, 53: 1, 8: 1, 79: 2, 90: 3, 51: 3, 130: 2, 62: 4, 85: 4, 68: 3, 35: 3, 110: 3, 91: 5, 114: 3, 97: 3, 13: 3, 38: 4, 26: 3, 98: 2, 54: 2, 127: 3, 96: 3, 64: 2, 30: 4, 61: 5, 55: 2, 27: 2, 15: 3, 52: 2, 129: 3, 115: 3, 84: 2, 76: 4, 87: 3, 131: 5, 102: 3, 113: 5, 99: 2, 36: 3, 24: 2, 72: 4} {161: 1, 264: 1, 328: 1, 392: 1, 369: 1, 220: 1, 221: 1, 1: 8, 4: 2, 9: 3, 10: 3, 15: 3, 24: 2, 25: 4, 26: 4, 27: 3, 39: 4, 43: 3, 49: 6, 50: 5, 58: 5, 59: 2, 64: 3, 69: 2, 81: 5, 82: 4, 86: 3, 96: 4, 97: 3, 100: 7, 108: 3, 109: 4, 110: 4, 111: 2, 114: 3, 115: 4, 116: 3, 118: 5, 119: 4, 120: 3, 121: 3, 122: 4, 123: 3, 124: 3, 128: 4, 129: 4, 130: 5, 132: 2, 136: 2, 145: 2, 147: 4, 151: 4, 152: 4, 154: 3, 156: 2, 162: 2, 165: 3, 168: 4, 169: 3, 172: 3, 180: 4, 184: 3, 187: 5, 188: 4, 191: 3, 194: 2, 202: 3, 203: 4, 206: 2, 207: 3, 217: 3, 218: 7, 222: 4, 224: 3, 227: 5, 229: 3, 234: 5, 235: 2, 241: 2, 242: 2, 243: 2, 244: 4, 245: 2, 248: 4, 250: 4, 258: 10, 262: 4, 263: 5, 267: 3, 270: 3, 272: 3, 273: 3, 287: 3, 289: 3, 291: 5, 299: 5, 300: 3, 304: 3, 309: 2, 314: 2, 315: 3, 320: 3, 323: 2, 327: 4, 329: 2, 330: 9, 334: 2, 335: 3, 341: 5, 342: 6, 347: 5, 348: 5, 350: 5, 351: 5, 352: 3, 353: 3, 354: 2, 358: 3, 365: 3, 366: 2, 371: 7, 372: 5, 376: 2, 384: 5, 385: 4, 386: 3, 387: 3, 393: 2, 396: 6, 397: 6, 398: 5, 402: 3} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 52 Resource allocation. Similar structure and changes as in IP over TSN . Service protection interworking is out - of - scope . d275ba154e2b7c82eb3ec9175d790214b0e60d3f d275ba154e2b7c82eb3ec9175d790214b0e60d3f draft-ietf-detnet-mpls-over-tsn 769d6aec4ab7308875a36f480f397628b2febffed4bc76dc77efd81374577a2f ['899fe49efb71ff0aa7ef3f05ac18bd5bfd87fffe13b5c1288db3416e022be147', 'ab93afb1ce53a91a86685ff579055185d9f7a6798d6effa52aec9838538bdf15', '42b1f3f30d1cae8db1fcb526de2f77c170c19e3508250cf37a94100514f567e6', '55bdece02c98962a77682e9b55671178537e5663507c4ff9c5409df14c7a69af', '438eb33c698936afb27ac820b5f68528ff155bd5a6927b63e6259a419be2e1a9', 'ed695265f24af924853cf42b909ea782e13659dd90448b1a4bc4800314d00f86', 'a8ff14472a8fa48bacdc11d7089a9d1054c0a786f6152f510b5d4092c22e121f', '16375944152e6c3e73492437880fe39d7f0123a9292d062e8e9c7d317e4b878f', '1076eab6753435c114e8a720c951b03da6d4e1bbbf1290f8d58ad7f97a0b8c64', '7f7e8733165742e4d8be8dacffe0453045841d70140ba0a9defc1c0d78e8d05c', '44e497e2df0461bad9215c57918855022435eb6e28266916161de3f7902bb352', '0cf3a218420317d1ac2dbe66fe8b3fa5930ee4bfb0f9a25d7059f70b672356ee', 'c2db650dc38549201f151a0fea9030968aca0fd468d0d6d3fe3d9b520ee551e6', '03d4609f1627eb905bc43957db60d2c0ce0b1cf99c6fa8617c936e7170195470', 'f07257d89bd36957d381df4c3d975b976581225d3b0e93b797f231549f809c45', 'cee8a70bcfc00996a87843150f50858ee830d692ae4678e50d5c074d43ff657c', 'b451f1bf9eed3bec2c5e20d4e9122ce6f31202fc68127f2881d2d860e9726365', '5c5fe7e7a382ebc21f89d163deb3520302620f0efe90cedb8592a80b5ef6a394', 'fb2b9389e1455c6d64ae19158396d767d88969013b14075bcfdcc764f610108c', '769d6aec4ab7308875a36f480f397628b2febffed4bc76dc77efd81374577a2f', '36330b0a2474d7598e4665a8ac8b8fbd2c0215a7c2971183879990c1948b22ae', 'ae3bdd3a81d96e4aaa02f7d597a2684146f3af75b743bde8e31c3cf5883707db', 'c63eee4f2d995789dc0fd3300a044e2c8d77d7fd6727e4e7a7bcc637c837d612', '564787d2556d259dabeaa6c5e2a64e9bdbfcf4ff124eb58795eebefb601fdb30', '5324bae9de9c301e9f6c475f9348fb2673813fe613070bb08ffd35c8a0e54204', 'f77d05a1e065348650e7579a3e2688468825cb7764599c8eb0f82836f4f3d9f3', 'a9668d2ded433c7b0eab698458e6b8fd13e4ddabe80417a884a66eda5893de8a', '75621d6a5adc1618337a02bf68856f7e1f8591c46fda003f39100f58bad112e3', '87cbb111ae00db5fad0458158af7d51a3ea8cb3e02e091c32f02ae366900eabb', '26e942b0353fee8f5ac0a2c2e26c9b695c50b35c501eeb4bff343b1648b5cebc', '036168e918418eb807bc3efd361a8e66067192564da41e30e076d22be0f87935', 'a6bd7b8f71e0d959503da2efa6fee412d7e71fb1f54e482a89a61c2a8d6bc691', '9829b13faebde69c2279c38cd54d524aa31acfdcc1cfba7910b9d69caa42e0dd', '2755ae7cda161df0c24e1fa9f1c3308bc9ef81a599d859668490484290ca72f4'] B resource allocation. {6: 1, 31: 1, 124: 1, 67: 1, 53: 1, 8: 1, 79: 2, 90: 3, 51: 3, 130: 2, 62: 4, 85: 4, 68: 3, 35: 3, 110: 3, 91: 5, 114: 3, 97: 3, 13: 3, 38: 4, 26: 3, 98: 2, 54: 2, 127: 3, 96: 3, 64: 2, 30: 4, 61: 5, 55: 2, 27: 2, 15: 3, 52: 2, 129: 3, 115: 3, 84: 2, 76: 4, 87: 3, 131: 5, 102: 3, 113: 5, 99: 2, 36: 3, 24: 2, 72: 4} {161: 1, 264: 1, 328: 1, 392: 1, 369: 1, 220: 1, 221: 1, 1: 8, 4: 2, 9: 3, 10: 3, 15: 3, 24: 2, 25: 4, 26: 4, 27: 3, 39: 4, 43: 3, 49: 6, 50: 5, 58: 5, 59: 2, 64: 3, 69: 2, 81: 5, 82: 4, 86: 3, 96: 4, 97: 3, 100: 7, 108: 3, 109: 4, 110: 4, 111: 2, 114: 3, 115: 4, 116: 3, 118: 5, 119: 4, 120: 3, 121: 3, 122: 4, 123: 3, 124: 3, 128: 4, 129: 4, 130: 5, 132: 2, 136: 2, 145: 2, 147: 4, 151: 4, 152: 4, 154: 3, 156: 2, 162: 2, 165: 3, 168: 4, 169: 3, 172: 3, 180: 4, 184: 3, 187: 5, 188: 4, 191: 3, 194: 2, 202: 3, 203: 4, 206: 2, 207: 3, 217: 3, 218: 7, 222: 4, 224: 3, 227: 5, 229: 3, 234: 5, 235: 2, 241: 2, 242: 2, 243: 2, 244: 4, 245: 2, 248: 4, 250: 4, 258: 10, 262: 4, 263: 5, 267: 3, 270: 3, 272: 3, 273: 3, 287: 3, 289: 3, 291: 5, 299: 5, 300: 3, 304: 3, 309: 2, 314: 2, 315: 3, 320: 3, 323: 2, 327: 4, 329: 2, 330: 9, 334: 2, 335: 3, 341: 5, 342: 6, 347: 5, 348: 5, 350: 5, 351: 5, 352: 3, 353: 3, 354: 2, 358: 3, 365: 3, 366: 2, 371: 7, 372: 5, 376: 2, 384: 5, 385: 4, 386: 3, 387: 3, 393: 2, 396: 6, 397: 6, 398: 5, 402: 3} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 52 Explicit routes. Similar structure and changes as in IP over TSN . Service protection interworking is out - of - scope . d275ba154e2b7c82eb3ec9175d790214b0e60d3f d275ba154e2b7c82eb3ec9175d790214b0e60d3f draft-ietf-detnet-mpls-over-tsn c2db650dc38549201f151a0fea9030968aca0fd468d0d6d3fe3d9b520ee551e6 ['899fe49efb71ff0aa7ef3f05ac18bd5bfd87fffe13b5c1288db3416e022be147', 'ab93afb1ce53a91a86685ff579055185d9f7a6798d6effa52aec9838538bdf15', '42b1f3f30d1cae8db1fcb526de2f77c170c19e3508250cf37a94100514f567e6', '55bdece02c98962a77682e9b55671178537e5663507c4ff9c5409df14c7a69af', '438eb33c698936afb27ac820b5f68528ff155bd5a6927b63e6259a419be2e1a9', 'ed695265f24af924853cf42b909ea782e13659dd90448b1a4bc4800314d00f86', 'a8ff14472a8fa48bacdc11d7089a9d1054c0a786f6152f510b5d4092c22e121f', '16375944152e6c3e73492437880fe39d7f0123a9292d062e8e9c7d317e4b878f', '1076eab6753435c114e8a720c951b03da6d4e1bbbf1290f8d58ad7f97a0b8c64', '7f7e8733165742e4d8be8dacffe0453045841d70140ba0a9defc1c0d78e8d05c', '44e497e2df0461bad9215c57918855022435eb6e28266916161de3f7902bb352', '0cf3a218420317d1ac2dbe66fe8b3fa5930ee4bfb0f9a25d7059f70b672356ee', 'c2db650dc38549201f151a0fea9030968aca0fd468d0d6d3fe3d9b520ee551e6', '03d4609f1627eb905bc43957db60d2c0ce0b1cf99c6fa8617c936e7170195470', 'f07257d89bd36957d381df4c3d975b976581225d3b0e93b797f231549f809c45', 'cee8a70bcfc00996a87843150f50858ee830d692ae4678e50d5c074d43ff657c', 'b451f1bf9eed3bec2c5e20d4e9122ce6f31202fc68127f2881d2d860e9726365', '5c5fe7e7a382ebc21f89d163deb3520302620f0efe90cedb8592a80b5ef6a394', 'fb2b9389e1455c6d64ae19158396d767d88969013b14075bcfdcc764f610108c', '769d6aec4ab7308875a36f480f397628b2febffed4bc76dc77efd81374577a2f', '36330b0a2474d7598e4665a8ac8b8fbd2c0215a7c2971183879990c1948b22ae', 'ae3bdd3a81d96e4aaa02f7d597a2684146f3af75b743bde8e31c3cf5883707db', 'c63eee4f2d995789dc0fd3300a044e2c8d77d7fd6727e4e7a7bcc637c837d612', '564787d2556d259dabeaa6c5e2a64e9bdbfcf4ff124eb58795eebefb601fdb30', '5324bae9de9c301e9f6c475f9348fb2673813fe613070bb08ffd35c8a0e54204', 'f77d05a1e065348650e7579a3e2688468825cb7764599c8eb0f82836f4f3d9f3', 'a9668d2ded433c7b0eab698458e6b8fd13e4ddabe80417a884a66eda5893de8a', '75621d6a5adc1618337a02bf68856f7e1f8591c46fda003f39100f58bad112e3', '87cbb111ae00db5fad0458158af7d51a3ea8cb3e02e091c32f02ae366900eabb', '26e942b0353fee8f5ac0a2c2e26c9b695c50b35c501eeb4bff343b1648b5cebc', '036168e918418eb807bc3efd361a8e66067192564da41e30e076d22be0f87935', 'a6bd7b8f71e0d959503da2efa6fee412d7e71fb1f54e482a89a61c2a8d6bc691', '9829b13faebde69c2279c38cd54d524aa31acfdcc1cfba7910b9d69caa42e0dd', '2755ae7cda161df0c24e1fa9f1c3308bc9ef81a599d859668490484290ca72f4'] B explicit routes. {6: 1, 31: 1, 124: 1, 67: 1, 53: 1, 8: 1, 79: 2, 90: 3, 51: 3, 130: 2, 62: 4, 85: 4, 68: 3, 35: 3, 110: 3, 91: 5, 114: 3, 97: 3, 13: 3, 38: 4, 26: 3, 98: 2, 54: 2, 127: 3, 96: 3, 64: 2, 30: 4, 61: 5, 55: 2, 27: 2, 15: 3, 52: 2, 129: 3, 115: 3, 84: 2, 76: 4, 87: 3, 131: 5, 102: 3, 113: 5, 99: 2, 36: 3, 24: 2, 72: 4} {161: 1, 264: 1, 328: 1, 392: 1, 369: 1, 220: 1, 221: 1, 1: 8, 4: 2, 9: 3, 10: 3, 15: 3, 24: 2, 25: 4, 26: 4, 27: 3, 39: 4, 43: 3, 49: 6, 50: 5, 58: 5, 59: 2, 64: 3, 69: 2, 81: 5, 82: 4, 86: 3, 96: 4, 97: 3, 100: 7, 108: 3, 109: 4, 110: 4, 111: 2, 114: 3, 115: 4, 116: 3, 118: 5, 119: 4, 120: 3, 121: 3, 122: 4, 123: 3, 124: 3, 128: 4, 129: 4, 130: 5, 132: 2, 136: 2, 145: 2, 147: 4, 151: 4, 152: 4, 154: 3, 156: 2, 162: 2, 165: 3, 168: 4, 169: 3, 172: 3, 180: 4, 184: 3, 187: 5, 188: 4, 191: 3, 194: 2, 202: 3, 203: 4, 206: 2, 207: 3, 217: 3, 218: 7, 222: 4, 224: 3, 227: 5, 229: 3, 234: 5, 235: 2, 241: 2, 242: 2, 243: 2, 244: 4, 245: 2, 248: 4, 250: 4, 258: 10, 262: 4, 263: 5, 267: 3, 270: 3, 272: 3, 273: 3, 287: 3, 289: 3, 291: 5, 299: 5, 300: 3, 304: 3, 309: 2, 314: 2, 315: 3, 320: 3, 323: 2, 327: 4, 329: 2, 330: 9, 334: 2, 335: 3, 341: 5, 342: 6, 347: 5, 348: 5, 350: 5, 351: 5, 352: 3, 353: 3, 354: 2, 358: 3, 365: 3, 366: 2, 371: 7, 372: 5, 376: 2, 384: 5, 385: 4, 386: 3, 387: 3, 393: 2, 396: 6, 397: 6, 398: 5, 402: 3} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 52 "As described in the DetNet architecture I-D.ietf-detnet-architecture and also illustrated here in fig_mpls_detnet_part a sub-network provides from MPLS perspective a single hop connection between MPLS (DetNet) nodes. Functions used for resource allocation and explicit routes are treated as domain internal functions and does not require function interworking across the DetNet MPLS network and the TSN sub- network." Similar structure and changes as in IP over TSN . Service protection interworking is out - of - scope . d275ba154e2b7c82eb3ec9175d790214b0e60d3f d275ba154e2b7c82eb3ec9175d790214b0e60d3f draft-ietf-detnet-mpls-over-tsn 5324bae9de9c301e9f6c475f9348fb2673813fe613070bb08ffd35c8a0e54204 ['899fe49efb71ff0aa7ef3f05ac18bd5bfd87fffe13b5c1288db3416e022be147', 'ab93afb1ce53a91a86685ff579055185d9f7a6798d6effa52aec9838538bdf15', '42b1f3f30d1cae8db1fcb526de2f77c170c19e3508250cf37a94100514f567e6', '55bdece02c98962a77682e9b55671178537e5663507c4ff9c5409df14c7a69af', '438eb33c698936afb27ac820b5f68528ff155bd5a6927b63e6259a419be2e1a9', 'ed695265f24af924853cf42b909ea782e13659dd90448b1a4bc4800314d00f86', 'a8ff14472a8fa48bacdc11d7089a9d1054c0a786f6152f510b5d4092c22e121f', '16375944152e6c3e73492437880fe39d7f0123a9292d062e8e9c7d317e4b878f', '1076eab6753435c114e8a720c951b03da6d4e1bbbf1290f8d58ad7f97a0b8c64', '7f7e8733165742e4d8be8dacffe0453045841d70140ba0a9defc1c0d78e8d05c', '44e497e2df0461bad9215c57918855022435eb6e28266916161de3f7902bb352', '0cf3a218420317d1ac2dbe66fe8b3fa5930ee4bfb0f9a25d7059f70b672356ee', 'c2db650dc38549201f151a0fea9030968aca0fd468d0d6d3fe3d9b520ee551e6', '03d4609f1627eb905bc43957db60d2c0ce0b1cf99c6fa8617c936e7170195470', 'f07257d89bd36957d381df4c3d975b976581225d3b0e93b797f231549f809c45', 'cee8a70bcfc00996a87843150f50858ee830d692ae4678e50d5c074d43ff657c', 'b451f1bf9eed3bec2c5e20d4e9122ce6f31202fc68127f2881d2d860e9726365', '5c5fe7e7a382ebc21f89d163deb3520302620f0efe90cedb8592a80b5ef6a394', 'fb2b9389e1455c6d64ae19158396d767d88969013b14075bcfdcc764f610108c', '769d6aec4ab7308875a36f480f397628b2febffed4bc76dc77efd81374577a2f', '36330b0a2474d7598e4665a8ac8b8fbd2c0215a7c2971183879990c1948b22ae', 'ae3bdd3a81d96e4aaa02f7d597a2684146f3af75b743bde8e31c3cf5883707db', 'c63eee4f2d995789dc0fd3300a044e2c8d77d7fd6727e4e7a7bcc637c837d612', '564787d2556d259dabeaa6c5e2a64e9bdbfcf4ff124eb58795eebefb601fdb30', '5324bae9de9c301e9f6c475f9348fb2673813fe613070bb08ffd35c8a0e54204', 'f77d05a1e065348650e7579a3e2688468825cb7764599c8eb0f82836f4f3d9f3', 'a9668d2ded433c7b0eab698458e6b8fd13e4ddabe80417a884a66eda5893de8a', '75621d6a5adc1618337a02bf68856f7e1f8591c46fda003f39100f58bad112e3', '87cbb111ae00db5fad0458158af7d51a3ea8cb3e02e091c32f02ae366900eabb', '26e942b0353fee8f5ac0a2c2e26c9b695c50b35c501eeb4bff343b1648b5cebc', '036168e918418eb807bc3efd361a8e66067192564da41e30e076d22be0f87935', 'a6bd7b8f71e0d959503da2efa6fee412d7e71fb1f54e482a89a61c2a8d6bc691', '9829b13faebde69c2279c38cd54d524aa31acfdcc1cfba7910b9d69caa42e0dd', '2755ae7cda161df0c24e1fa9f1c3308bc9ef81a599d859668490484290ca72f4'] B "as described in the detnet architecture i-d.ietf-detnet-architecture and also illustrated here in fig_mpls_detnet_part a sub-network provides from mpls perspective a single hop connection between mpls (detnet) nodes. functions used for resource allocation and explicit routes are treated as domain internal functions and does not require function interworking across the detnet mpls network and the tsn sub- network." {6: 1, 31: 1, 124: 1, 67: 1, 53: 1, 8: 1, 79: 2, 90: 3, 51: 3, 130: 2, 62: 4, 85: 4, 68: 3, 35: 3, 110: 3, 91: 5, 114: 3, 97: 3, 13: 3, 38: 4, 26: 3, 98: 2, 54: 2, 127: 3, 96: 3, 64: 2, 30: 4, 61: 5, 55: 2, 27: 2, 15: 3, 52: 2, 129: 3, 115: 3, 84: 2, 76: 4, 87: 3, 131: 5, 102: 3, 113: 5, 99: 2, 36: 3, 24: 2, 72: 4} {161: 1, 264: 1, 328: 1, 392: 1, 369: 1, 220: 1, 221: 1, 1: 8, 4: 2, 9: 3, 10: 3, 15: 3, 24: 2, 25: 4, 26: 4, 27: 3, 39: 4, 43: 3, 49: 6, 50: 5, 58: 5, 59: 2, 64: 3, 69: 2, 81: 5, 82: 4, 86: 3, 96: 4, 97: 3, 100: 7, 108: 3, 109: 4, 110: 4, 111: 2, 114: 3, 115: 4, 116: 3, 118: 5, 119: 4, 120: 3, 121: 3, 122: 4, 123: 3, 124: 3, 128: 4, 129: 4, 130: 5, 132: 2, 136: 2, 145: 2, 147: 4, 151: 4, 152: 4, 154: 3, 156: 2, 162: 2, 165: 3, 168: 4, 169: 3, 172: 3, 180: 4, 184: 3, 187: 5, 188: 4, 191: 3, 194: 2, 202: 3, 203: 4, 206: 2, 207: 3, 217: 3, 218: 7, 222: 4, 224: 3, 227: 5, 229: 3, 234: 5, 235: 2, 241: 2, 242: 2, 243: 2, 244: 4, 245: 2, 248: 4, 250: 4, 258: 10, 262: 4, 263: 5, 267: 3, 270: 3, 272: 3, 273: 3, 287: 3, 289: 3, 291: 5, 299: 5, 300: 3, 304: 3, 309: 2, 314: 2, 315: 3, 320: 3, 323: 2, 327: 4, 329: 2, 330: 9, 334: 2, 335: 3, 341: 5, 342: 6, 347: 5, 348: 5, 350: 5, 351: 5, 352: 3, 353: 3, 354: 2, 358: 3, 365: 3, 366: 2, 371: 7, 372: 5, 376: 2, 384: 5, 385: 4, 386: 3, 387: 3, 393: 2, 396: 6, 397: 6, 398: 5, 402: 3} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 52 "In case of the service protection function due to the similarities of the DetNet PREOF and TSN FRER functions some level of interworking is possible. However, such interworking is out-of-scope in this document and left for further study." Similar structure and changes as in IP over TSN . Service protection interworking is out - of - scope . d275ba154e2b7c82eb3ec9175d790214b0e60d3f d275ba154e2b7c82eb3ec9175d790214b0e60d3f draft-ietf-detnet-mpls-over-tsn 899fe49efb71ff0aa7ef3f05ac18bd5bfd87fffe13b5c1288db3416e022be147 ['899fe49efb71ff0aa7ef3f05ac18bd5bfd87fffe13b5c1288db3416e022be147', 'ab93afb1ce53a91a86685ff579055185d9f7a6798d6effa52aec9838538bdf15', '42b1f3f30d1cae8db1fcb526de2f77c170c19e3508250cf37a94100514f567e6', '55bdece02c98962a77682e9b55671178537e5663507c4ff9c5409df14c7a69af', '438eb33c698936afb27ac820b5f68528ff155bd5a6927b63e6259a419be2e1a9', 'ed695265f24af924853cf42b909ea782e13659dd90448b1a4bc4800314d00f86', 'a8ff14472a8fa48bacdc11d7089a9d1054c0a786f6152f510b5d4092c22e121f', '16375944152e6c3e73492437880fe39d7f0123a9292d062e8e9c7d317e4b878f', '1076eab6753435c114e8a720c951b03da6d4e1bbbf1290f8d58ad7f97a0b8c64', '7f7e8733165742e4d8be8dacffe0453045841d70140ba0a9defc1c0d78e8d05c', '44e497e2df0461bad9215c57918855022435eb6e28266916161de3f7902bb352', '0cf3a218420317d1ac2dbe66fe8b3fa5930ee4bfb0f9a25d7059f70b672356ee', 'c2db650dc38549201f151a0fea9030968aca0fd468d0d6d3fe3d9b520ee551e6', '03d4609f1627eb905bc43957db60d2c0ce0b1cf99c6fa8617c936e7170195470', 'f07257d89bd36957d381df4c3d975b976581225d3b0e93b797f231549f809c45', 'cee8a70bcfc00996a87843150f50858ee830d692ae4678e50d5c074d43ff657c', 'b451f1bf9eed3bec2c5e20d4e9122ce6f31202fc68127f2881d2d860e9726365', '5c5fe7e7a382ebc21f89d163deb3520302620f0efe90cedb8592a80b5ef6a394', 'fb2b9389e1455c6d64ae19158396d767d88969013b14075bcfdcc764f610108c', '769d6aec4ab7308875a36f480f397628b2febffed4bc76dc77efd81374577a2f', '36330b0a2474d7598e4665a8ac8b8fbd2c0215a7c2971183879990c1948b22ae', 'ae3bdd3a81d96e4aaa02f7d597a2684146f3af75b743bde8e31c3cf5883707db', 'c63eee4f2d995789dc0fd3300a044e2c8d77d7fd6727e4e7a7bcc637c837d612', '564787d2556d259dabeaa6c5e2a64e9bdbfcf4ff124eb58795eebefb601fdb30', '5324bae9de9c301e9f6c475f9348fb2673813fe613070bb08ffd35c8a0e54204', 'f77d05a1e065348650e7579a3e2688468825cb7764599c8eb0f82836f4f3d9f3', 'a9668d2ded433c7b0eab698458e6b8fd13e4ddabe80417a884a66eda5893de8a', '75621d6a5adc1618337a02bf68856f7e1f8591c46fda003f39100f58bad112e3', '87cbb111ae00db5fad0458158af7d51a3ea8cb3e02e091c32f02ae366900eabb', '26e942b0353fee8f5ac0a2c2e26c9b695c50b35c501eeb4bff343b1648b5cebc', '036168e918418eb807bc3efd361a8e66067192564da41e30e076d22be0f87935', 'a6bd7b8f71e0d959503da2efa6fee412d7e71fb1f54e482a89a61c2a8d6bc691', '9829b13faebde69c2279c38cd54d524aa31acfdcc1cfba7910b9d69caa42e0dd', '2755ae7cda161df0c24e1fa9f1c3308bc9ef81a599d859668490484290ca72f4'] B "in case of the service protection function due to the similarities of the detnet preof and tsn frer functions some level of interworking is possible. however, such interworking is out-of-scope in this document and left for further study." {6: 1, 31: 1, 124: 1, 67: 1, 53: 1, 8: 1, 79: 2, 90: 3, 51: 3, 130: 2, 62: 4, 85: 4, 68: 3, 35: 3, 110: 3, 91: 5, 114: 3, 97: 3, 13: 3, 38: 4, 26: 3, 98: 2, 54: 2, 127: 3, 96: 3, 64: 2, 30: 4, 61: 5, 55: 2, 27: 2, 15: 3, 52: 2, 129: 3, 115: 3, 84: 2, 76: 4, 87: 3, 131: 5, 102: 3, 113: 5, 99: 2, 36: 3, 24: 2, 72: 4} {161: 1, 264: 1, 328: 1, 392: 1, 369: 1, 220: 1, 221: 1, 1: 8, 4: 2, 9: 3, 10: 3, 15: 3, 24: 2, 25: 4, 26: 4, 27: 3, 39: 4, 43: 3, 49: 6, 50: 5, 58: 5, 59: 2, 64: 3, 69: 2, 81: 5, 82: 4, 86: 3, 96: 4, 97: 3, 100: 7, 108: 3, 109: 4, 110: 4, 111: 2, 114: 3, 115: 4, 116: 3, 118: 5, 119: 4, 120: 3, 121: 3, 122: 4, 123: 3, 124: 3, 128: 4, 129: 4, 130: 5, 132: 2, 136: 2, 145: 2, 147: 4, 151: 4, 152: 4, 154: 3, 156: 2, 162: 2, 165: 3, 168: 4, 169: 3, 172: 3, 180: 4, 184: 3, 187: 5, 188: 4, 191: 3, 194: 2, 202: 3, 203: 4, 206: 2, 207: 3, 217: 3, 218: 7, 222: 4, 224: 3, 227: 5, 229: 3, 234: 5, 235: 2, 241: 2, 242: 2, 243: 2, 244: 4, 245: 2, 248: 4, 250: 4, 258: 10, 262: 4, 263: 5, 267: 3, 270: 3, 272: 3, 273: 3, 287: 3, 289: 3, 291: 5, 299: 5, 300: 3, 304: 3, 309: 2, 314: 2, 315: 3, 320: 3, 323: 2, 327: 4, 329: 2, 330: 9, 334: 2, 335: 3, 341: 5, 342: 6, 347: 5, 348: 5, 350: 5, 351: 5, 352: 3, 353: 3, 354: 2, 358: 3, 365: 3, 366: 2, 371: 7, 372: 5, 376: 2, 384: 5, 385: 4, 386: 3, 387: 3, 393: 2, 396: 6, 397: 6, 398: 5, 402: 3} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 52 "fig_mpls_detnet_to_tsn illustrates a scenario, where two MPLS (DetNet) nodes are interconnected by a TSN sub-network. Node-1 is single homed and Node-2 is dual-homed to the TSN sub-network." Similar structure and changes as in IP over TSN . Service protection interworking is out - of - scope . d275ba154e2b7c82eb3ec9175d790214b0e60d3f d275ba154e2b7c82eb3ec9175d790214b0e60d3f draft-ietf-detnet-mpls-over-tsn 42b1f3f30d1cae8db1fcb526de2f77c170c19e3508250cf37a94100514f567e6 ['899fe49efb71ff0aa7ef3f05ac18bd5bfd87fffe13b5c1288db3416e022be147', 'ab93afb1ce53a91a86685ff579055185d9f7a6798d6effa52aec9838538bdf15', '42b1f3f30d1cae8db1fcb526de2f77c170c19e3508250cf37a94100514f567e6', '55bdece02c98962a77682e9b55671178537e5663507c4ff9c5409df14c7a69af', '438eb33c698936afb27ac820b5f68528ff155bd5a6927b63e6259a419be2e1a9', 'ed695265f24af924853cf42b909ea782e13659dd90448b1a4bc4800314d00f86', 'a8ff14472a8fa48bacdc11d7089a9d1054c0a786f6152f510b5d4092c22e121f', '16375944152e6c3e73492437880fe39d7f0123a9292d062e8e9c7d317e4b878f', '1076eab6753435c114e8a720c951b03da6d4e1bbbf1290f8d58ad7f97a0b8c64', '7f7e8733165742e4d8be8dacffe0453045841d70140ba0a9defc1c0d78e8d05c', '44e497e2df0461bad9215c57918855022435eb6e28266916161de3f7902bb352', '0cf3a218420317d1ac2dbe66fe8b3fa5930ee4bfb0f9a25d7059f70b672356ee', 'c2db650dc38549201f151a0fea9030968aca0fd468d0d6d3fe3d9b520ee551e6', '03d4609f1627eb905bc43957db60d2c0ce0b1cf99c6fa8617c936e7170195470', 'f07257d89bd36957d381df4c3d975b976581225d3b0e93b797f231549f809c45', 'cee8a70bcfc00996a87843150f50858ee830d692ae4678e50d5c074d43ff657c', 'b451f1bf9eed3bec2c5e20d4e9122ce6f31202fc68127f2881d2d860e9726365', '5c5fe7e7a382ebc21f89d163deb3520302620f0efe90cedb8592a80b5ef6a394', 'fb2b9389e1455c6d64ae19158396d767d88969013b14075bcfdcc764f610108c', '769d6aec4ab7308875a36f480f397628b2febffed4bc76dc77efd81374577a2f', '36330b0a2474d7598e4665a8ac8b8fbd2c0215a7c2971183879990c1948b22ae', 'ae3bdd3a81d96e4aaa02f7d597a2684146f3af75b743bde8e31c3cf5883707db', 'c63eee4f2d995789dc0fd3300a044e2c8d77d7fd6727e4e7a7bcc637c837d612', '564787d2556d259dabeaa6c5e2a64e9bdbfcf4ff124eb58795eebefb601fdb30', '5324bae9de9c301e9f6c475f9348fb2673813fe613070bb08ffd35c8a0e54204', 'f77d05a1e065348650e7579a3e2688468825cb7764599c8eb0f82836f4f3d9f3', 'a9668d2ded433c7b0eab698458e6b8fd13e4ddabe80417a884a66eda5893de8a', '75621d6a5adc1618337a02bf68856f7e1f8591c46fda003f39100f58bad112e3', '87cbb111ae00db5fad0458158af7d51a3ea8cb3e02e091c32f02ae366900eabb', '26e942b0353fee8f5ac0a2c2e26c9b695c50b35c501eeb4bff343b1648b5cebc', '036168e918418eb807bc3efd361a8e66067192564da41e30e076d22be0f87935', 'a6bd7b8f71e0d959503da2efa6fee412d7e71fb1f54e482a89a61c2a8d6bc691', '9829b13faebde69c2279c38cd54d524aa31acfdcc1cfba7910b9d69caa42e0dd', '2755ae7cda161df0c24e1fa9f1c3308bc9ef81a599d859668490484290ca72f4'] B "fig_mpls_detnet_to_tsn illustrates a scenario, where two mpls (detnet) nodes are interconnected by a tsn sub-network. node-1 is single homed and node-2 is dual-homed to the tsn sub-network." {6: 1, 31: 1, 124: 1, 67: 1, 53: 1, 8: 1, 79: 2, 90: 3, 51: 3, 130: 2, 62: 4, 85: 4, 68: 3, 35: 3, 110: 3, 91: 5, 114: 3, 97: 3, 13: 3, 38: 4, 26: 3, 98: 2, 54: 2, 127: 3, 96: 3, 64: 2, 30: 4, 61: 5, 55: 2, 27: 2, 15: 3, 52: 2, 129: 3, 115: 3, 84: 2, 76: 4, 87: 3, 131: 5, 102: 3, 113: 5, 99: 2, 36: 3, 24: 2, 72: 4} {161: 1, 264: 1, 328: 1, 392: 1, 369: 1, 220: 1, 221: 1, 1: 8, 4: 2, 9: 3, 10: 3, 15: 3, 24: 2, 25: 4, 26: 4, 27: 3, 39: 4, 43: 3, 49: 6, 50: 5, 58: 5, 59: 2, 64: 3, 69: 2, 81: 5, 82: 4, 86: 3, 96: 4, 97: 3, 100: 7, 108: 3, 109: 4, 110: 4, 111: 2, 114: 3, 115: 4, 116: 3, 118: 5, 119: 4, 120: 3, 121: 3, 122: 4, 123: 3, 124: 3, 128: 4, 129: 4, 130: 5, 132: 2, 136: 2, 145: 2, 147: 4, 151: 4, 152: 4, 154: 3, 156: 2, 162: 2, 165: 3, 168: 4, 169: 3, 172: 3, 180: 4, 184: 3, 187: 5, 188: 4, 191: 3, 194: 2, 202: 3, 203: 4, 206: 2, 207: 3, 217: 3, 218: 7, 222: 4, 224: 3, 227: 5, 229: 3, 234: 5, 235: 2, 241: 2, 242: 2, 243: 2, 244: 4, 245: 2, 248: 4, 250: 4, 258: 10, 262: 4, 263: 5, 267: 3, 270: 3, 272: 3, 273: 3, 287: 3, 289: 3, 291: 5, 299: 5, 300: 3, 304: 3, 309: 2, 314: 2, 315: 3, 320: 3, 323: 2, 327: 4, 329: 2, 330: 9, 334: 2, 335: 3, 341: 5, 342: 6, 347: 5, 348: 5, 350: 5, 351: 5, 352: 3, 353: 3, 354: 2, 358: 3, 365: 3, 366: 2, 371: 7, 372: 5, 376: 2, 384: 5, 385: 4, 386: 3, 387: 3, 393: 2, 396: 6, 397: 6, 398: 5, 402: 3} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 52 "As is the case for DetNet, a Layer 2 network node such as a bridge may need to identify the specific DetNet flow to which a packet belongs in order to provide the TSN/DetNet QoS for that packet. It also may need a CoS marking, such as the priority field of an IEEE Std 802.1Q VLAN tag, to give the packet proper service." Similar structure and changes as in IP over TSN . Service protection interworking is out - of - scope . d275ba154e2b7c82eb3ec9175d790214b0e60d3f d275ba154e2b7c82eb3ec9175d790214b0e60d3f draft-ietf-detnet-mpls-over-tsn e8ac6be9503fe785fadef60b06035db9bcfe02fde1de69193d9a4125a1399c60 ['630a7b3cd3eda2e026f158d16d3e4a4a2526a07124cf77aa8ed446ea760814d8', 'b03fd845058850bbf1a630e8c83fada6cba78982283c708236fd7388ffe9fc67', 'c47c152ac014e9bd75ed634d3b9e1c8bb57391b003cba836041c95b95a4c7fa1', 'c69a0fa2ea5f12373344fafbdd44dfb7bb6dbc1860b1c5990feae2a465de298d', '8a1dbabe711db86a26396c01597c528f5fcffb20f047620d5a97dc7303789634', 'e8ac6be9503fe785fadef60b06035db9bcfe02fde1de69193d9a4125a1399c60', '6a32f9bd776a29b7ce3eec373de6fa66bfd90fce56bad4e4eed60abba5aca087', '42f5214bb177fd7faf01b7943e7f313a615b2490f9109d5cefa8b24101735c32', '214810fe3ac0ef76db60e2d0623a8259b9bdf49040882a9e710901fe1eb32fde', '95e8b140a3153d24b8cc5b029501473ba4c08b0343d47a78892b1bad50321f66', 'c7011da30a42dd7b92a21132cfa295b31d66f42863c6a3414b5dbc0e9f38a1ce', 'ae45f508450dea10961ae41868df31a827a51caf984672ba7b53e43ba5e13140', '6808ff9c187a5808b263bc26ce9efc6509eedbd92aebf3bfa16a9ebbb5432f96', '3195c90c03cf6a438b5684cc93128c53f794660a661e2aa85d043ca5ac7060b9', '0246ffa7291c42bc165b0ac6acf1fc7285b5e41537731f44da530521ca5615d1', 'b5bacf05f766e143f6de9484b0b5a2d9655d62854368373bd77974b94cb722e6', '85d25c76743ed7e65b601d54f78150e74c3aa10e4c1b0b383304ba7887314a95', 'ae74a9a2a182dd5a01fd950e728caccd2600bef5390e5cc261e81037cf194a98', 'b94a431eeccea467fb994ae14c1161601ffad908f6fa54e35fd5f89256dacdea', '7ac09938faf2d97ce8bcc3b64b905bb5a585aeb30156506ee7abe2cd36825ed9', '601ac7ed7c06e522c784e0c0c3a976bc1cc9cccb10f550ee9cd153fa5cb3dcdc', '33a143d8274548ab7377f45f1204f1945e0cf20210af64fed99ac8028f48bac4', '1094721b24c22ff67539ffeabab887f87e538bdd9ebe50b0b369de138d326802', '19ad685cffba6309346c1ba7d6f642f0e69af09509b4f36f7ed87231855721a9', 'f34d1af51d3831ee49ed7f59e7135f955e977a1b93bb875be4c690b33a62450b', 'c53eb2c4fe199217644e8f623baca54cd8f18d0cf2746bad70b055d75f0faa23', '314017bb601d7806be2da63e51d3ee14147fa3ac35c6b85ba05825de7c5de742', '39820f7cb577ca0dcfb1bfa578ae13c25334acae03e89731064b0e3c300841de', '3703b0838ce47d992f259e22b20012a302240311d21f2d269cbb1414baec967f', '2605eb6691e33e75449ea67b2cc57cb2055976b481376bd77f71a937e30c3973', '8577e49f249e444a03b30a1f6f901d73d9fffc14ead45f0d56e8d2ff59c3301f', '8c5ca97b799230d82bd3e52e11118044d85a9f0dbf4f81934f31963b8f59d50c', 'ffe5de17213aa105e92776fd207a82f0ccefc1aa38407bb124b44f049f3dd1b8', '61b71fad4b4a688fc63731cab0845c3423c6935ea6d5c188047fbf047ef3a426', 'a491df768673d76ae7dee4c9bf1ea1456e6c537a1f1683368d8bc6869cd89bf0', '72c5a1f410983619d643ec9b1744e623d17c7eea2f68ac99d1881079601873cd', '139b8c43623bbe83d6e84c494389cef4e57e6816c2829cf9bcbb604af1f3bd70', '6de184d7411efde0440a2390c1009b5c1a251195a5c8bb05f6d64de2066a6d83', '7b6435e5d1cd5f5ef5156a6cb776bff4f493bdb11beead1f071fe87b93e78906', 'c5d808132e397aef8874ae2c056109762978e6c0fb6eee327f28541bd3886a04'] A "as is the case for detnet, a layer 2 network node such as a bridge may need to identify the specific detnet flow to which a packet belongs in order to provide the tsn/detnet qos for that packet. it also may need a cos marking, such as the priority field of an ieee std 802.1q vlan tag, to give the packet proper service." {51: 1, 97: 1, 96: 1, 24: 1, 130: 1, 53: 1, 6: 2, 79: 2, 90: 2, 62: 3, 85: 4, 68: 4, 35: 3, 110: 2, 91: 4, 114: 2, 31: 3, 13: 2, 67: 2, 38: 3, 26: 2, 124: 3, 98: 2, 54: 2, 127: 3, 8: 2, 64: 2, 30: 2, 61: 4, 55: 3, 27: 3, 15: 2, 129: 3, 115: 2, 84: 2, 76: 6, 52: 2, 87: 2, 131: 5, 102: 2, 113: 4, 99: 2, 36: 2, 72: 3} {15: 1, 27: 1, 64: 1, 116: 1, 123: 1, 354: 1, 387: 1, 300: 1, 270: 1, 304: 1, 335: 1, 369: 1, 1: 9, 4: 2, 9: 5, 10: 3, 24: 2, 25: 3, 26: 4, 39: 5, 43: 3, 49: 5, 50: 4, 58: 4, 59: 2, 69: 4, 81: 4, 82: 2, 86: 2, 96: 3, 97: 2, 100: 5, 108: 3, 109: 4, 110: 4, 111: 2, 114: 3, 115: 4, 118: 6, 119: 5, 120: 3, 121: 4, 122: 2, 124: 4, 128: 3, 129: 2, 130: 4, 132: 4, 136: 2, 145: 4, 147: 3, 151: 3, 152: 3, 154: 3, 161: 3, 162: 3, 165: 3, 168: 4, 169: 2, 172: 2, 180: 3, 184: 5, 187: 5, 188: 4, 191: 3, 194: 4, 202: 5, 203: 6, 206: 2, 207: 3, 215: 2, 217: 3, 218: 8, 220: 2, 221: 2, 222: 5, 224: 3, 227: 3, 229: 2, 234: 5, 235: 2, 241: 2, 242: 2, 243: 4, 244: 3, 245: 4, 248: 3, 250: 2, 258: 11, 262: 4, 263: 5, 264: 3, 267: 4, 272: 2, 273: 5, 287: 3, 289: 2, 291: 4, 299: 3, 309: 3, 314: 2, 315: 2, 320: 4, 323: 4, 327: 4, 328: 3, 329: 2, 330: 10, 334: 2, 341: 3, 342: 4, 347: 3, 348: 3, 350: 7, 351: 4, 352: 2, 353: 2, 358: 4, 365: 2, 366: 2, 371: 5, 372: 4, 376: 2, 384: 4, 385: 3, 386: 3, 392: 3, 393: 4, 396: 4, 397: 7, 398: 6, 402: 2} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 52 "The challange for MPLS DeNet flows is that the protocol interworking function defined in IEEE8021CB works only for IP flows. The aim of the protocol interworking function is to convert an ingress flow to use a specific multicast destination MAC address and VLAN, for example to direct the packets through a specific path inside the bridged network. A similar interworking pair at the other end of the TSN sub-network would restore the packet to its original destination MAC address and VLAN." Similar structure and changes as in IP over TSN . Service protection interworking is out - of - scope . d275ba154e2b7c82eb3ec9175d790214b0e60d3f d275ba154e2b7c82eb3ec9175d790214b0e60d3f draft-ietf-detnet-mpls-over-tsn c7011da30a42dd7b92a21132cfa295b31d66f42863c6a3414b5dbc0e9f38a1ce ['630a7b3cd3eda2e026f158d16d3e4a4a2526a07124cf77aa8ed446ea760814d8', 'b03fd845058850bbf1a630e8c83fada6cba78982283c708236fd7388ffe9fc67', 'c47c152ac014e9bd75ed634d3b9e1c8bb57391b003cba836041c95b95a4c7fa1', 'c69a0fa2ea5f12373344fafbdd44dfb7bb6dbc1860b1c5990feae2a465de298d', '8a1dbabe711db86a26396c01597c528f5fcffb20f047620d5a97dc7303789634', 'e8ac6be9503fe785fadef60b06035db9bcfe02fde1de69193d9a4125a1399c60', '6a32f9bd776a29b7ce3eec373de6fa66bfd90fce56bad4e4eed60abba5aca087', '42f5214bb177fd7faf01b7943e7f313a615b2490f9109d5cefa8b24101735c32', '214810fe3ac0ef76db60e2d0623a8259b9bdf49040882a9e710901fe1eb32fde', '95e8b140a3153d24b8cc5b029501473ba4c08b0343d47a78892b1bad50321f66', 'c7011da30a42dd7b92a21132cfa295b31d66f42863c6a3414b5dbc0e9f38a1ce', 'ae45f508450dea10961ae41868df31a827a51caf984672ba7b53e43ba5e13140', '6808ff9c187a5808b263bc26ce9efc6509eedbd92aebf3bfa16a9ebbb5432f96', '3195c90c03cf6a438b5684cc93128c53f794660a661e2aa85d043ca5ac7060b9', '0246ffa7291c42bc165b0ac6acf1fc7285b5e41537731f44da530521ca5615d1', 'b5bacf05f766e143f6de9484b0b5a2d9655d62854368373bd77974b94cb722e6', '85d25c76743ed7e65b601d54f78150e74c3aa10e4c1b0b383304ba7887314a95', 'ae74a9a2a182dd5a01fd950e728caccd2600bef5390e5cc261e81037cf194a98', 'b94a431eeccea467fb994ae14c1161601ffad908f6fa54e35fd5f89256dacdea', '7ac09938faf2d97ce8bcc3b64b905bb5a585aeb30156506ee7abe2cd36825ed9', '601ac7ed7c06e522c784e0c0c3a976bc1cc9cccb10f550ee9cd153fa5cb3dcdc', '33a143d8274548ab7377f45f1204f1945e0cf20210af64fed99ac8028f48bac4', '1094721b24c22ff67539ffeabab887f87e538bdd9ebe50b0b369de138d326802', '19ad685cffba6309346c1ba7d6f642f0e69af09509b4f36f7ed87231855721a9', 'f34d1af51d3831ee49ed7f59e7135f955e977a1b93bb875be4c690b33a62450b', 'c53eb2c4fe199217644e8f623baca54cd8f18d0cf2746bad70b055d75f0faa23', '314017bb601d7806be2da63e51d3ee14147fa3ac35c6b85ba05825de7c5de742', '39820f7cb577ca0dcfb1bfa578ae13c25334acae03e89731064b0e3c300841de', '3703b0838ce47d992f259e22b20012a302240311d21f2d269cbb1414baec967f', '2605eb6691e33e75449ea67b2cc57cb2055976b481376bd77f71a937e30c3973', '8577e49f249e444a03b30a1f6f901d73d9fffc14ead45f0d56e8d2ff59c3301f', '8c5ca97b799230d82bd3e52e11118044d85a9f0dbf4f81934f31963b8f59d50c', 'ffe5de17213aa105e92776fd207a82f0ccefc1aa38407bb124b44f049f3dd1b8', '61b71fad4b4a688fc63731cab0845c3423c6935ea6d5c188047fbf047ef3a426', 'a491df768673d76ae7dee4c9bf1ea1456e6c537a1f1683368d8bc6869cd89bf0', '72c5a1f410983619d643ec9b1744e623d17c7eea2f68ac99d1881079601873cd', '139b8c43623bbe83d6e84c494389cef4e57e6816c2829cf9bcbb604af1f3bd70', '6de184d7411efde0440a2390c1009b5c1a251195a5c8bb05f6d64de2066a6d83', '7b6435e5d1cd5f5ef5156a6cb776bff4f493bdb11beead1f071fe87b93e78906', 'c5d808132e397aef8874ae2c056109762978e6c0fb6eee327f28541bd3886a04'] A "the challange for mpls denet flows is that the protocol interworking function defined in ieee8021cb works only for ip flows. the aim of the protocol interworking function is to convert an ingress flow to use a specific multicast destination mac address and vlan, for example to direct the packets through a specific path inside the bridged network. a similar interworking pair at the other end of the tsn sub-network would restore the packet to its original destination mac address and vlan." {51: 1, 97: 1, 96: 1, 24: 1, 130: 1, 53: 1, 6: 2, 79: 2, 90: 2, 62: 3, 85: 4, 68: 4, 35: 3, 110: 2, 91: 4, 114: 2, 31: 3, 13: 2, 67: 2, 38: 3, 26: 2, 124: 3, 98: 2, 54: 2, 127: 3, 8: 2, 64: 2, 30: 2, 61: 4, 55: 3, 27: 3, 15: 2, 129: 3, 115: 2, 84: 2, 76: 6, 52: 2, 87: 2, 131: 5, 102: 2, 113: 4, 99: 2, 36: 2, 72: 3} {15: 1, 27: 1, 64: 1, 116: 1, 123: 1, 354: 1, 387: 1, 300: 1, 270: 1, 304: 1, 335: 1, 369: 1, 1: 9, 4: 2, 9: 5, 10: 3, 24: 2, 25: 3, 26: 4, 39: 5, 43: 3, 49: 5, 50: 4, 58: 4, 59: 2, 69: 4, 81: 4, 82: 2, 86: 2, 96: 3, 97: 2, 100: 5, 108: 3, 109: 4, 110: 4, 111: 2, 114: 3, 115: 4, 118: 6, 119: 5, 120: 3, 121: 4, 122: 2, 124: 4, 128: 3, 129: 2, 130: 4, 132: 4, 136: 2, 145: 4, 147: 3, 151: 3, 152: 3, 154: 3, 161: 3, 162: 3, 165: 3, 168: 4, 169: 2, 172: 2, 180: 3, 184: 5, 187: 5, 188: 4, 191: 3, 194: 4, 202: 5, 203: 6, 206: 2, 207: 3, 215: 2, 217: 3, 218: 8, 220: 2, 221: 2, 222: 5, 224: 3, 227: 3, 229: 2, 234: 5, 235: 2, 241: 2, 242: 2, 243: 4, 244: 3, 245: 4, 248: 3, 250: 2, 258: 11, 262: 4, 263: 5, 264: 3, 267: 4, 272: 2, 273: 5, 287: 3, 289: 2, 291: 4, 299: 3, 309: 3, 314: 2, 315: 2, 320: 4, 323: 4, 327: 4, 328: 3, 329: 2, 330: 10, 334: 2, 341: 3, 342: 4, 347: 3, 348: 3, 350: 7, 351: 4, 352: 2, 353: 2, 358: 4, 365: 2, 366: 2, 371: 5, 372: 4, 376: 2, 384: 4, 385: 3, 386: 3, 392: 3, 393: 4, 396: 4, 397: 7, 398: 6, 402: 2} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 52 "As protocol interworking function defined in IEEE8021CB does not work for MPLS labeled flows, the DetNet MPLS nodes MUST ensure proper TSN sub-network specific Ethernet encapsulation of the DetNet MPLS packets. For a given TSN Stream (i.e., DetNet flow) an MPLS (DetNet) node MUST behave as a TSN-aware Talker or a Listener inside the TSN sub-network." Similar structure and changes as in IP over TSN . Service protection interworking is out - of - scope . d275ba154e2b7c82eb3ec9175d790214b0e60d3f d275ba154e2b7c82eb3ec9175d790214b0e60d3f draft-ietf-detnet-mpls-over-tsn 33a143d8274548ab7377f45f1204f1945e0cf20210af64fed99ac8028f48bac4 ['630a7b3cd3eda2e026f158d16d3e4a4a2526a07124cf77aa8ed446ea760814d8', 'b03fd845058850bbf1a630e8c83fada6cba78982283c708236fd7388ffe9fc67', 'c47c152ac014e9bd75ed634d3b9e1c8bb57391b003cba836041c95b95a4c7fa1', 'c69a0fa2ea5f12373344fafbdd44dfb7bb6dbc1860b1c5990feae2a465de298d', '8a1dbabe711db86a26396c01597c528f5fcffb20f047620d5a97dc7303789634', 'e8ac6be9503fe785fadef60b06035db9bcfe02fde1de69193d9a4125a1399c60', '6a32f9bd776a29b7ce3eec373de6fa66bfd90fce56bad4e4eed60abba5aca087', '42f5214bb177fd7faf01b7943e7f313a615b2490f9109d5cefa8b24101735c32', '214810fe3ac0ef76db60e2d0623a8259b9bdf49040882a9e710901fe1eb32fde', '95e8b140a3153d24b8cc5b029501473ba4c08b0343d47a78892b1bad50321f66', 'c7011da30a42dd7b92a21132cfa295b31d66f42863c6a3414b5dbc0e9f38a1ce', 'ae45f508450dea10961ae41868df31a827a51caf984672ba7b53e43ba5e13140', '6808ff9c187a5808b263bc26ce9efc6509eedbd92aebf3bfa16a9ebbb5432f96', '3195c90c03cf6a438b5684cc93128c53f794660a661e2aa85d043ca5ac7060b9', '0246ffa7291c42bc165b0ac6acf1fc7285b5e41537731f44da530521ca5615d1', 'b5bacf05f766e143f6de9484b0b5a2d9655d62854368373bd77974b94cb722e6', '85d25c76743ed7e65b601d54f78150e74c3aa10e4c1b0b383304ba7887314a95', 'ae74a9a2a182dd5a01fd950e728caccd2600bef5390e5cc261e81037cf194a98', 'b94a431eeccea467fb994ae14c1161601ffad908f6fa54e35fd5f89256dacdea', '7ac09938faf2d97ce8bcc3b64b905bb5a585aeb30156506ee7abe2cd36825ed9', '601ac7ed7c06e522c784e0c0c3a976bc1cc9cccb10f550ee9cd153fa5cb3dcdc', '33a143d8274548ab7377f45f1204f1945e0cf20210af64fed99ac8028f48bac4', '1094721b24c22ff67539ffeabab887f87e538bdd9ebe50b0b369de138d326802', '19ad685cffba6309346c1ba7d6f642f0e69af09509b4f36f7ed87231855721a9', 'f34d1af51d3831ee49ed7f59e7135f955e977a1b93bb875be4c690b33a62450b', 'c53eb2c4fe199217644e8f623baca54cd8f18d0cf2746bad70b055d75f0faa23', '314017bb601d7806be2da63e51d3ee14147fa3ac35c6b85ba05825de7c5de742', '39820f7cb577ca0dcfb1bfa578ae13c25334acae03e89731064b0e3c300841de', '3703b0838ce47d992f259e22b20012a302240311d21f2d269cbb1414baec967f', '2605eb6691e33e75449ea67b2cc57cb2055976b481376bd77f71a937e30c3973', '8577e49f249e444a03b30a1f6f901d73d9fffc14ead45f0d56e8d2ff59c3301f', '8c5ca97b799230d82bd3e52e11118044d85a9f0dbf4f81934f31963b8f59d50c', 'ffe5de17213aa105e92776fd207a82f0ccefc1aa38407bb124b44f049f3dd1b8', '61b71fad4b4a688fc63731cab0845c3423c6935ea6d5c188047fbf047ef3a426', 'a491df768673d76ae7dee4c9bf1ea1456e6c537a1f1683368d8bc6869cd89bf0', '72c5a1f410983619d643ec9b1744e623d17c7eea2f68ac99d1881079601873cd', '139b8c43623bbe83d6e84c494389cef4e57e6816c2829cf9bcbb604af1f3bd70', '6de184d7411efde0440a2390c1009b5c1a251195a5c8bb05f6d64de2066a6d83', '7b6435e5d1cd5f5ef5156a6cb776bff4f493bdb11beead1f071fe87b93e78906', 'c5d808132e397aef8874ae2c056109762978e6c0fb6eee327f28541bd3886a04'] A "as protocol interworking function defined in ieee8021cb does not work for mpls labeled flows, the detnet mpls nodes must ensure proper tsn sub-network specific ethernet encapsulation of the detnet mpls packets. for a given tsn stream (i.e., detnet flow) an mpls (detnet) node must behave as a tsn-aware talker or a listener inside the tsn sub-network." {51: 1, 97: 1, 96: 1, 24: 1, 130: 1, 53: 1, 6: 2, 79: 2, 90: 2, 62: 3, 85: 4, 68: 4, 35: 3, 110: 2, 91: 4, 114: 2, 31: 3, 13: 2, 67: 2, 38: 3, 26: 2, 124: 3, 98: 2, 54: 2, 127: 3, 8: 2, 64: 2, 30: 2, 61: 4, 55: 3, 27: 3, 15: 2, 129: 3, 115: 2, 84: 2, 76: 6, 52: 2, 87: 2, 131: 5, 102: 2, 113: 4, 99: 2, 36: 2, 72: 3} {15: 1, 27: 1, 64: 1, 116: 1, 123: 1, 354: 1, 387: 1, 300: 1, 270: 1, 304: 1, 335: 1, 369: 1, 1: 9, 4: 2, 9: 5, 10: 3, 24: 2, 25: 3, 26: 4, 39: 5, 43: 3, 49: 5, 50: 4, 58: 4, 59: 2, 69: 4, 81: 4, 82: 2, 86: 2, 96: 3, 97: 2, 100: 5, 108: 3, 109: 4, 110: 4, 111: 2, 114: 3, 115: 4, 118: 6, 119: 5, 120: 3, 121: 4, 122: 2, 124: 4, 128: 3, 129: 2, 130: 4, 132: 4, 136: 2, 145: 4, 147: 3, 151: 3, 152: 3, 154: 3, 161: 3, 162: 3, 165: 3, 168: 4, 169: 2, 172: 2, 180: 3, 184: 5, 187: 5, 188: 4, 191: 3, 194: 4, 202: 5, 203: 6, 206: 2, 207: 3, 215: 2, 217: 3, 218: 8, 220: 2, 221: 2, 222: 5, 224: 3, 227: 3, 229: 2, 234: 5, 235: 2, 241: 2, 242: 2, 243: 4, 244: 3, 245: 4, 248: 3, 250: 2, 258: 11, 262: 4, 263: 5, 264: 3, 267: 4, 272: 2, 273: 5, 287: 3, 289: 2, 291: 4, 299: 3, 309: 3, 314: 2, 315: 2, 320: 4, 323: 4, 327: 4, 328: 3, 329: 2, 330: 10, 334: 2, 341: 3, 342: 4, 347: 3, 348: 3, 350: 7, 351: 4, 352: 2, 353: 2, 358: 4, 365: 2, 366: 2, 371: 5, 372: 4, 376: 2, 384: 4, 385: 3, 386: 3, 392: 3, 393: 4, 396: 4, 397: 7, 398: 6, 402: 2} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 52 "The Stream Identification and The Sequencing functions are slightly modified for frames passed down the protocol stack from the upper layers." Similar structure and changes as in IP over TSN . Service protection interworking is out - of - scope . d275ba154e2b7c82eb3ec9175d790214b0e60d3f d275ba154e2b7c82eb3ec9175d790214b0e60d3f draft-ietf-detnet-mpls-over-tsn c5d808132e397aef8874ae2c056109762978e6c0fb6eee327f28541bd3886a04 ['630a7b3cd3eda2e026f158d16d3e4a4a2526a07124cf77aa8ed446ea760814d8', 'b03fd845058850bbf1a630e8c83fada6cba78982283c708236fd7388ffe9fc67', 'c47c152ac014e9bd75ed634d3b9e1c8bb57391b003cba836041c95b95a4c7fa1', 'c69a0fa2ea5f12373344fafbdd44dfb7bb6dbc1860b1c5990feae2a465de298d', '8a1dbabe711db86a26396c01597c528f5fcffb20f047620d5a97dc7303789634', 'e8ac6be9503fe785fadef60b06035db9bcfe02fde1de69193d9a4125a1399c60', '6a32f9bd776a29b7ce3eec373de6fa66bfd90fce56bad4e4eed60abba5aca087', '42f5214bb177fd7faf01b7943e7f313a615b2490f9109d5cefa8b24101735c32', '214810fe3ac0ef76db60e2d0623a8259b9bdf49040882a9e710901fe1eb32fde', '95e8b140a3153d24b8cc5b029501473ba4c08b0343d47a78892b1bad50321f66', 'c7011da30a42dd7b92a21132cfa295b31d66f42863c6a3414b5dbc0e9f38a1ce', 'ae45f508450dea10961ae41868df31a827a51caf984672ba7b53e43ba5e13140', '6808ff9c187a5808b263bc26ce9efc6509eedbd92aebf3bfa16a9ebbb5432f96', '3195c90c03cf6a438b5684cc93128c53f794660a661e2aa85d043ca5ac7060b9', '0246ffa7291c42bc165b0ac6acf1fc7285b5e41537731f44da530521ca5615d1', 'b5bacf05f766e143f6de9484b0b5a2d9655d62854368373bd77974b94cb722e6', '85d25c76743ed7e65b601d54f78150e74c3aa10e4c1b0b383304ba7887314a95', 'ae74a9a2a182dd5a01fd950e728caccd2600bef5390e5cc261e81037cf194a98', 'b94a431eeccea467fb994ae14c1161601ffad908f6fa54e35fd5f89256dacdea', '7ac09938faf2d97ce8bcc3b64b905bb5a585aeb30156506ee7abe2cd36825ed9', '601ac7ed7c06e522c784e0c0c3a976bc1cc9cccb10f550ee9cd153fa5cb3dcdc', '33a143d8274548ab7377f45f1204f1945e0cf20210af64fed99ac8028f48bac4', '1094721b24c22ff67539ffeabab887f87e538bdd9ebe50b0b369de138d326802', '19ad685cffba6309346c1ba7d6f642f0e69af09509b4f36f7ed87231855721a9', 'f34d1af51d3831ee49ed7f59e7135f955e977a1b93bb875be4c690b33a62450b', 'c53eb2c4fe199217644e8f623baca54cd8f18d0cf2746bad70b055d75f0faa23', '314017bb601d7806be2da63e51d3ee14147fa3ac35c6b85ba05825de7c5de742', '39820f7cb577ca0dcfb1bfa578ae13c25334acae03e89731064b0e3c300841de', '3703b0838ce47d992f259e22b20012a302240311d21f2d269cbb1414baec967f', '2605eb6691e33e75449ea67b2cc57cb2055976b481376bd77f71a937e30c3973', '8577e49f249e444a03b30a1f6f901d73d9fffc14ead45f0d56e8d2ff59c3301f', '8c5ca97b799230d82bd3e52e11118044d85a9f0dbf4f81934f31963b8f59d50c', 'ffe5de17213aa105e92776fd207a82f0ccefc1aa38407bb124b44f049f3dd1b8', '61b71fad4b4a688fc63731cab0845c3423c6935ea6d5c188047fbf047ef3a426', 'a491df768673d76ae7dee4c9bf1ea1456e6c537a1f1683368d8bc6869cd89bf0', '72c5a1f410983619d643ec9b1744e623d17c7eea2f68ac99d1881079601873cd', '139b8c43623bbe83d6e84c494389cef4e57e6816c2829cf9bcbb604af1f3bd70', '6de184d7411efde0440a2390c1009b5c1a251195a5c8bb05f6d64de2066a6d83', '7b6435e5d1cd5f5ef5156a6cb776bff4f493bdb11beead1f071fe87b93e78906', 'c5d808132e397aef8874ae2c056109762978e6c0fb6eee327f28541bd3886a04'] A "the stream identification and the sequencing functions are slightly modified for frames passed down the protocol stack from the upper layers." {51: 1, 97: 1, 96: 1, 24: 1, 130: 1, 53: 1, 6: 2, 79: 2, 90: 2, 62: 3, 85: 4, 68: 4, 35: 3, 110: 2, 91: 4, 114: 2, 31: 3, 13: 2, 67: 2, 38: 3, 26: 2, 124: 3, 98: 2, 54: 2, 127: 3, 8: 2, 64: 2, 30: 2, 61: 4, 55: 3, 27: 3, 15: 2, 129: 3, 115: 2, 84: 2, 76: 6, 52: 2, 87: 2, 131: 5, 102: 2, 113: 4, 99: 2, 36: 2, 72: 3} {15: 1, 27: 1, 64: 1, 116: 1, 123: 1, 354: 1, 387: 1, 300: 1, 270: 1, 304: 1, 335: 1, 369: 1, 1: 9, 4: 2, 9: 5, 10: 3, 24: 2, 25: 3, 26: 4, 39: 5, 43: 3, 49: 5, 50: 4, 58: 4, 59: 2, 69: 4, 81: 4, 82: 2, 86: 2, 96: 3, 97: 2, 100: 5, 108: 3, 109: 4, 110: 4, 111: 2, 114: 3, 115: 4, 118: 6, 119: 5, 120: 3, 121: 4, 122: 2, 124: 4, 128: 3, 129: 2, 130: 4, 132: 4, 136: 2, 145: 4, 147: 3, 151: 3, 152: 3, 154: 3, 161: 3, 162: 3, 165: 3, 168: 4, 169: 2, 172: 2, 180: 3, 184: 5, 187: 5, 188: 4, 191: 3, 194: 4, 202: 5, 203: 6, 206: 2, 207: 3, 215: 2, 217: 3, 218: 8, 220: 2, 221: 2, 222: 5, 224: 3, 227: 3, 229: 2, 234: 5, 235: 2, 241: 2, 242: 2, 243: 4, 244: 3, 245: 4, 248: 3, 250: 2, 258: 11, 262: 4, 263: 5, 264: 3, 267: 4, 272: 2, 273: 5, 287: 3, 289: 2, 291: 4, 299: 3, 309: 3, 314: 2, 315: 2, 320: 4, 323: 4, 327: 4, 328: 3, 329: 2, 330: 10, 334: 2, 341: 3, 342: 4, 347: 3, 348: 3, 350: 7, 351: 4, 352: 2, 353: 2, 358: 4, 365: 2, 366: 2, 371: 5, 372: 4, 376: 2, 384: 4, 385: 3, 386: 3, 392: 3, 393: 4, 396: 4, 397: 7, 398: 6, 402: 2} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 52 "Stream Identification MUST pair MPLS flows and TSN Streams and encode that in data plane formats as well. The packet's stream_handle subparameter (see IEEE8021CB) inside the Talker/Listener is defined based on the Flow-ID used in the upper DetNet MPLS layer. Stream Identification function MUST encode Ethernet header fields namely (1) the destination MAC-address, (2) the VLAN-ID and (3) priority parameters with TSN sub-network specific values. Encoding is provided for the frame passed down the stack from the upper layers." Similar structure and changes as in IP over TSN . Service protection interworking is out - of - scope . d275ba154e2b7c82eb3ec9175d790214b0e60d3f d275ba154e2b7c82eb3ec9175d790214b0e60d3f draft-ietf-detnet-mpls-over-tsn b03fd845058850bbf1a630e8c83fada6cba78982283c708236fd7388ffe9fc67 ['630a7b3cd3eda2e026f158d16d3e4a4a2526a07124cf77aa8ed446ea760814d8', 'b03fd845058850bbf1a630e8c83fada6cba78982283c708236fd7388ffe9fc67', 'c47c152ac014e9bd75ed634d3b9e1c8bb57391b003cba836041c95b95a4c7fa1', 'c69a0fa2ea5f12373344fafbdd44dfb7bb6dbc1860b1c5990feae2a465de298d', '8a1dbabe711db86a26396c01597c528f5fcffb20f047620d5a97dc7303789634', 'e8ac6be9503fe785fadef60b06035db9bcfe02fde1de69193d9a4125a1399c60', '6a32f9bd776a29b7ce3eec373de6fa66bfd90fce56bad4e4eed60abba5aca087', '42f5214bb177fd7faf01b7943e7f313a615b2490f9109d5cefa8b24101735c32', '214810fe3ac0ef76db60e2d0623a8259b9bdf49040882a9e710901fe1eb32fde', '95e8b140a3153d24b8cc5b029501473ba4c08b0343d47a78892b1bad50321f66', 'c7011da30a42dd7b92a21132cfa295b31d66f42863c6a3414b5dbc0e9f38a1ce', 'ae45f508450dea10961ae41868df31a827a51caf984672ba7b53e43ba5e13140', '6808ff9c187a5808b263bc26ce9efc6509eedbd92aebf3bfa16a9ebbb5432f96', '3195c90c03cf6a438b5684cc93128c53f794660a661e2aa85d043ca5ac7060b9', '0246ffa7291c42bc165b0ac6acf1fc7285b5e41537731f44da530521ca5615d1', 'b5bacf05f766e143f6de9484b0b5a2d9655d62854368373bd77974b94cb722e6', '85d25c76743ed7e65b601d54f78150e74c3aa10e4c1b0b383304ba7887314a95', 'ae74a9a2a182dd5a01fd950e728caccd2600bef5390e5cc261e81037cf194a98', 'b94a431eeccea467fb994ae14c1161601ffad908f6fa54e35fd5f89256dacdea', '7ac09938faf2d97ce8bcc3b64b905bb5a585aeb30156506ee7abe2cd36825ed9', '601ac7ed7c06e522c784e0c0c3a976bc1cc9cccb10f550ee9cd153fa5cb3dcdc', '33a143d8274548ab7377f45f1204f1945e0cf20210af64fed99ac8028f48bac4', '1094721b24c22ff67539ffeabab887f87e538bdd9ebe50b0b369de138d326802', '19ad685cffba6309346c1ba7d6f642f0e69af09509b4f36f7ed87231855721a9', 'f34d1af51d3831ee49ed7f59e7135f955e977a1b93bb875be4c690b33a62450b', 'c53eb2c4fe199217644e8f623baca54cd8f18d0cf2746bad70b055d75f0faa23', '314017bb601d7806be2da63e51d3ee14147fa3ac35c6b85ba05825de7c5de742', '39820f7cb577ca0dcfb1bfa578ae13c25334acae03e89731064b0e3c300841de', '3703b0838ce47d992f259e22b20012a302240311d21f2d269cbb1414baec967f', '2605eb6691e33e75449ea67b2cc57cb2055976b481376bd77f71a937e30c3973', '8577e49f249e444a03b30a1f6f901d73d9fffc14ead45f0d56e8d2ff59c3301f', '8c5ca97b799230d82bd3e52e11118044d85a9f0dbf4f81934f31963b8f59d50c', 'ffe5de17213aa105e92776fd207a82f0ccefc1aa38407bb124b44f049f3dd1b8', '61b71fad4b4a688fc63731cab0845c3423c6935ea6d5c188047fbf047ef3a426', 'a491df768673d76ae7dee4c9bf1ea1456e6c537a1f1683368d8bc6869cd89bf0', '72c5a1f410983619d643ec9b1744e623d17c7eea2f68ac99d1881079601873cd', '139b8c43623bbe83d6e84c494389cef4e57e6816c2829cf9bcbb604af1f3bd70', '6de184d7411efde0440a2390c1009b5c1a251195a5c8bb05f6d64de2066a6d83', '7b6435e5d1cd5f5ef5156a6cb776bff4f493bdb11beead1f071fe87b93e78906', 'c5d808132e397aef8874ae2c056109762978e6c0fb6eee327f28541bd3886a04'] A "stream identification must pair mpls flows and tsn streams and encode that in data plane formats as well. the packet's stream_handle subparameter (see ieee8021cb) inside the talker/listener is defined based on the flow-id used in the upper detnet mpls layer. stream identification function must encode ethernet header fields namely (1) the destination mac-address, (2) the vlan-id and (3) priority parameters with tsn sub-network specific values. encoding is provided for the frame passed down the stack from the upper layers." {51: 1, 97: 1, 96: 1, 24: 1, 130: 1, 53: 1, 6: 2, 79: 2, 90: 2, 62: 3, 85: 4, 68: 4, 35: 3, 110: 2, 91: 4, 114: 2, 31: 3, 13: 2, 67: 2, 38: 3, 26: 2, 124: 3, 98: 2, 54: 2, 127: 3, 8: 2, 64: 2, 30: 2, 61: 4, 55: 3, 27: 3, 15: 2, 129: 3, 115: 2, 84: 2, 76: 6, 52: 2, 87: 2, 131: 5, 102: 2, 113: 4, 99: 2, 36: 2, 72: 3} {15: 1, 27: 1, 64: 1, 116: 1, 123: 1, 354: 1, 387: 1, 300: 1, 270: 1, 304: 1, 335: 1, 369: 1, 1: 9, 4: 2, 9: 5, 10: 3, 24: 2, 25: 3, 26: 4, 39: 5, 43: 3, 49: 5, 50: 4, 58: 4, 59: 2, 69: 4, 81: 4, 82: 2, 86: 2, 96: 3, 97: 2, 100: 5, 108: 3, 109: 4, 110: 4, 111: 2, 114: 3, 115: 4, 118: 6, 119: 5, 120: 3, 121: 4, 122: 2, 124: 4, 128: 3, 129: 2, 130: 4, 132: 4, 136: 2, 145: 4, 147: 3, 151: 3, 152: 3, 154: 3, 161: 3, 162: 3, 165: 3, 168: 4, 169: 2, 172: 2, 180: 3, 184: 5, 187: 5, 188: 4, 191: 3, 194: 4, 202: 5, 203: 6, 206: 2, 207: 3, 215: 2, 217: 3, 218: 8, 220: 2, 221: 2, 222: 5, 224: 3, 227: 3, 229: 2, 234: 5, 235: 2, 241: 2, 242: 2, 243: 4, 244: 3, 245: 4, 248: 3, 250: 2, 258: 11, 262: 4, 263: 5, 264: 3, 267: 4, 272: 2, 273: 5, 287: 3, 289: 2, 291: 4, 299: 3, 309: 3, 314: 2, 315: 2, 320: 4, 323: 4, 327: 4, 328: 3, 329: 2, 330: 10, 334: 2, 341: 3, 342: 4, 347: 3, 348: 3, 350: 7, 351: 4, 352: 2, 353: 2, 358: 4, 365: 2, 366: 2, 371: 5, 372: 4, 376: 2, 384: 4, 385: 3, 386: 3, 392: 3, 393: 4, 396: 4, 397: 7, 398: 6, 402: 2} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 52 "The sequence generation function resides in the Sequencing function. It generates a sequence_number subparameter for each packet of a Stream passed down to the lower layers. Sequencing function MUST copy sequence information from the MPLS d-CW of the packet to the sequence_number subparameter for the frame passed down the stack from the upper layers." Similar structure and changes as in IP over TSN . Service protection interworking is out - of - scope . d275ba154e2b7c82eb3ec9175d790214b0e60d3f d275ba154e2b7c82eb3ec9175d790214b0e60d3f draft-ietf-detnet-mpls-over-tsn 6a32f9bd776a29b7ce3eec373de6fa66bfd90fce56bad4e4eed60abba5aca087 ['630a7b3cd3eda2e026f158d16d3e4a4a2526a07124cf77aa8ed446ea760814d8', 'b03fd845058850bbf1a630e8c83fada6cba78982283c708236fd7388ffe9fc67', 'c47c152ac014e9bd75ed634d3b9e1c8bb57391b003cba836041c95b95a4c7fa1', 'c69a0fa2ea5f12373344fafbdd44dfb7bb6dbc1860b1c5990feae2a465de298d', '8a1dbabe711db86a26396c01597c528f5fcffb20f047620d5a97dc7303789634', 'e8ac6be9503fe785fadef60b06035db9bcfe02fde1de69193d9a4125a1399c60', '6a32f9bd776a29b7ce3eec373de6fa66bfd90fce56bad4e4eed60abba5aca087', '42f5214bb177fd7faf01b7943e7f313a615b2490f9109d5cefa8b24101735c32', '214810fe3ac0ef76db60e2d0623a8259b9bdf49040882a9e710901fe1eb32fde', '95e8b140a3153d24b8cc5b029501473ba4c08b0343d47a78892b1bad50321f66', 'c7011da30a42dd7b92a21132cfa295b31d66f42863c6a3414b5dbc0e9f38a1ce', 'ae45f508450dea10961ae41868df31a827a51caf984672ba7b53e43ba5e13140', '6808ff9c187a5808b263bc26ce9efc6509eedbd92aebf3bfa16a9ebbb5432f96', '3195c90c03cf6a438b5684cc93128c53f794660a661e2aa85d043ca5ac7060b9', '0246ffa7291c42bc165b0ac6acf1fc7285b5e41537731f44da530521ca5615d1', 'b5bacf05f766e143f6de9484b0b5a2d9655d62854368373bd77974b94cb722e6', '85d25c76743ed7e65b601d54f78150e74c3aa10e4c1b0b383304ba7887314a95', 'ae74a9a2a182dd5a01fd950e728caccd2600bef5390e5cc261e81037cf194a98', 'b94a431eeccea467fb994ae14c1161601ffad908f6fa54e35fd5f89256dacdea', '7ac09938faf2d97ce8bcc3b64b905bb5a585aeb30156506ee7abe2cd36825ed9', '601ac7ed7c06e522c784e0c0c3a976bc1cc9cccb10f550ee9cd153fa5cb3dcdc', '33a143d8274548ab7377f45f1204f1945e0cf20210af64fed99ac8028f48bac4', '1094721b24c22ff67539ffeabab887f87e538bdd9ebe50b0b369de138d326802', '19ad685cffba6309346c1ba7d6f642f0e69af09509b4f36f7ed87231855721a9', 'f34d1af51d3831ee49ed7f59e7135f955e977a1b93bb875be4c690b33a62450b', 'c53eb2c4fe199217644e8f623baca54cd8f18d0cf2746bad70b055d75f0faa23', '314017bb601d7806be2da63e51d3ee14147fa3ac35c6b85ba05825de7c5de742', '39820f7cb577ca0dcfb1bfa578ae13c25334acae03e89731064b0e3c300841de', '3703b0838ce47d992f259e22b20012a302240311d21f2d269cbb1414baec967f', '2605eb6691e33e75449ea67b2cc57cb2055976b481376bd77f71a937e30c3973', '8577e49f249e444a03b30a1f6f901d73d9fffc14ead45f0d56e8d2ff59c3301f', '8c5ca97b799230d82bd3e52e11118044d85a9f0dbf4f81934f31963b8f59d50c', 'ffe5de17213aa105e92776fd207a82f0ccefc1aa38407bb124b44f049f3dd1b8', '61b71fad4b4a688fc63731cab0845c3423c6935ea6d5c188047fbf047ef3a426', 'a491df768673d76ae7dee4c9bf1ea1456e6c537a1f1683368d8bc6869cd89bf0', '72c5a1f410983619d643ec9b1744e623d17c7eea2f68ac99d1881079601873cd', '139b8c43623bbe83d6e84c494389cef4e57e6816c2829cf9bcbb604af1f3bd70', '6de184d7411efde0440a2390c1009b5c1a251195a5c8bb05f6d64de2066a6d83', '7b6435e5d1cd5f5ef5156a6cb776bff4f493bdb11beead1f071fe87b93e78906', 'c5d808132e397aef8874ae2c056109762978e6c0fb6eee327f28541bd3886a04'] A "the sequence generation function resides in the sequencing function. it generates a sequence_number subparameter for each packet of a stream passed down to the lower layers. sequencing function must copy sequence information from the mpls d-cw of the packet to the sequence_number subparameter for the frame passed down the stack from the upper layers." {51: 1, 97: 1, 96: 1, 24: 1, 130: 1, 53: 1, 6: 2, 79: 2, 90: 2, 62: 3, 85: 4, 68: 4, 35: 3, 110: 2, 91: 4, 114: 2, 31: 3, 13: 2, 67: 2, 38: 3, 26: 2, 124: 3, 98: 2, 54: 2, 127: 3, 8: 2, 64: 2, 30: 2, 61: 4, 55: 3, 27: 3, 15: 2, 129: 3, 115: 2, 84: 2, 76: 6, 52: 2, 87: 2, 131: 5, 102: 2, 113: 4, 99: 2, 36: 2, 72: 3} {15: 1, 27: 1, 64: 1, 116: 1, 123: 1, 354: 1, 387: 1, 300: 1, 270: 1, 304: 1, 335: 1, 369: 1, 1: 9, 4: 2, 9: 5, 10: 3, 24: 2, 25: 3, 26: 4, 39: 5, 43: 3, 49: 5, 50: 4, 58: 4, 59: 2, 69: 4, 81: 4, 82: 2, 86: 2, 96: 3, 97: 2, 100: 5, 108: 3, 109: 4, 110: 4, 111: 2, 114: 3, 115: 4, 118: 6, 119: 5, 120: 3, 121: 4, 122: 2, 124: 4, 128: 3, 129: 2, 130: 4, 132: 4, 136: 2, 145: 4, 147: 3, 151: 3, 152: 3, 154: 3, 161: 3, 162: 3, 165: 3, 168: 4, 169: 2, 172: 2, 180: 3, 184: 5, 187: 5, 188: 4, 191: 3, 194: 4, 202: 5, 203: 6, 206: 2, 207: 3, 215: 2, 217: 3, 218: 8, 220: 2, 221: 2, 222: 5, 224: 3, 227: 3, 229: 2, 234: 5, 235: 2, 241: 2, 242: 2, 243: 4, 244: 3, 245: 4, 248: 3, 250: 2, 258: 11, 262: 4, 263: 5, 264: 3, 267: 4, 272: 2, 273: 5, 287: 3, 289: 2, 291: 4, 299: 3, 309: 3, 314: 2, 315: 2, 320: 4, 323: 4, 327: 4, 328: 3, 329: 2, 330: 10, 334: 2, 341: 3, 342: 4, 347: 3, 348: 3, 350: 7, 351: 4, 352: 2, 353: 2, 358: 4, 365: 2, 366: 2, 371: 5, 372: 4, 376: 2, 384: 4, 385: 3, 386: 3, 392: 3, 393: 4, 396: 4, 397: 7, 398: 6, 402: 2} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 52 "TSN Streams supporting DetNet flows may use Frame Replication and Elimination for Redundancy (FRER) [802.1CB] based on the loss service requirements of the TSN Stream, which is derived from the DetNet service requirements of the DetNet mapped flow. The specific operation of FRER is not modified by the use of DetNet and follows IEEE8021CB." Similar structure and changes as in IP over TSN . Service protection interworking is out - of - scope . d275ba154e2b7c82eb3ec9175d790214b0e60d3f d275ba154e2b7c82eb3ec9175d790214b0e60d3f draft-ietf-detnet-mpls-over-tsn 39820f7cb577ca0dcfb1bfa578ae13c25334acae03e89731064b0e3c300841de ['630a7b3cd3eda2e026f158d16d3e4a4a2526a07124cf77aa8ed446ea760814d8', 'b03fd845058850bbf1a630e8c83fada6cba78982283c708236fd7388ffe9fc67', 'c47c152ac014e9bd75ed634d3b9e1c8bb57391b003cba836041c95b95a4c7fa1', 'c69a0fa2ea5f12373344fafbdd44dfb7bb6dbc1860b1c5990feae2a465de298d', '8a1dbabe711db86a26396c01597c528f5fcffb20f047620d5a97dc7303789634', 'e8ac6be9503fe785fadef60b06035db9bcfe02fde1de69193d9a4125a1399c60', '6a32f9bd776a29b7ce3eec373de6fa66bfd90fce56bad4e4eed60abba5aca087', '42f5214bb177fd7faf01b7943e7f313a615b2490f9109d5cefa8b24101735c32', '214810fe3ac0ef76db60e2d0623a8259b9bdf49040882a9e710901fe1eb32fde', '95e8b140a3153d24b8cc5b029501473ba4c08b0343d47a78892b1bad50321f66', 'c7011da30a42dd7b92a21132cfa295b31d66f42863c6a3414b5dbc0e9f38a1ce', 'ae45f508450dea10961ae41868df31a827a51caf984672ba7b53e43ba5e13140', '6808ff9c187a5808b263bc26ce9efc6509eedbd92aebf3bfa16a9ebbb5432f96', '3195c90c03cf6a438b5684cc93128c53f794660a661e2aa85d043ca5ac7060b9', '0246ffa7291c42bc165b0ac6acf1fc7285b5e41537731f44da530521ca5615d1', 'b5bacf05f766e143f6de9484b0b5a2d9655d62854368373bd77974b94cb722e6', '85d25c76743ed7e65b601d54f78150e74c3aa10e4c1b0b383304ba7887314a95', 'ae74a9a2a182dd5a01fd950e728caccd2600bef5390e5cc261e81037cf194a98', 'b94a431eeccea467fb994ae14c1161601ffad908f6fa54e35fd5f89256dacdea', '7ac09938faf2d97ce8bcc3b64b905bb5a585aeb30156506ee7abe2cd36825ed9', '601ac7ed7c06e522c784e0c0c3a976bc1cc9cccb10f550ee9cd153fa5cb3dcdc', '33a143d8274548ab7377f45f1204f1945e0cf20210af64fed99ac8028f48bac4', '1094721b24c22ff67539ffeabab887f87e538bdd9ebe50b0b369de138d326802', '19ad685cffba6309346c1ba7d6f642f0e69af09509b4f36f7ed87231855721a9', 'f34d1af51d3831ee49ed7f59e7135f955e977a1b93bb875be4c690b33a62450b', 'c53eb2c4fe199217644e8f623baca54cd8f18d0cf2746bad70b055d75f0faa23', '314017bb601d7806be2da63e51d3ee14147fa3ac35c6b85ba05825de7c5de742', '39820f7cb577ca0dcfb1bfa578ae13c25334acae03e89731064b0e3c300841de', '3703b0838ce47d992f259e22b20012a302240311d21f2d269cbb1414baec967f', '2605eb6691e33e75449ea67b2cc57cb2055976b481376bd77f71a937e30c3973', '8577e49f249e444a03b30a1f6f901d73d9fffc14ead45f0d56e8d2ff59c3301f', '8c5ca97b799230d82bd3e52e11118044d85a9f0dbf4f81934f31963b8f59d50c', 'ffe5de17213aa105e92776fd207a82f0ccefc1aa38407bb124b44f049f3dd1b8', '61b71fad4b4a688fc63731cab0845c3423c6935ea6d5c188047fbf047ef3a426', 'a491df768673d76ae7dee4c9bf1ea1456e6c537a1f1683368d8bc6869cd89bf0', '72c5a1f410983619d643ec9b1744e623d17c7eea2f68ac99d1881079601873cd', '139b8c43623bbe83d6e84c494389cef4e57e6816c2829cf9bcbb604af1f3bd70', '6de184d7411efde0440a2390c1009b5c1a251195a5c8bb05f6d64de2066a6d83', '7b6435e5d1cd5f5ef5156a6cb776bff4f493bdb11beead1f071fe87b93e78906', 'c5d808132e397aef8874ae2c056109762978e6c0fb6eee327f28541bd3886a04'] A "tsn streams supporting detnet flows may use frame replication and elimination for redundancy (frer) [802.1cb] based on the loss service requirements of the tsn stream, which is derived from the detnet service requirements of the detnet mapped flow. the specific operation of frer is not modified by the use of detnet and follows ieee8021cb." {51: 1, 97: 1, 96: 1, 24: 1, 130: 1, 53: 1, 6: 2, 79: 2, 90: 2, 62: 3, 85: 4, 68: 4, 35: 3, 110: 2, 91: 4, 114: 2, 31: 3, 13: 2, 67: 2, 38: 3, 26: 2, 124: 3, 98: 2, 54: 2, 127: 3, 8: 2, 64: 2, 30: 2, 61: 4, 55: 3, 27: 3, 15: 2, 129: 3, 115: 2, 84: 2, 76: 6, 52: 2, 87: 2, 131: 5, 102: 2, 113: 4, 99: 2, 36: 2, 72: 3} {15: 1, 27: 1, 64: 1, 116: 1, 123: 1, 354: 1, 387: 1, 300: 1, 270: 1, 304: 1, 335: 1, 369: 1, 1: 9, 4: 2, 9: 5, 10: 3, 24: 2, 25: 3, 26: 4, 39: 5, 43: 3, 49: 5, 50: 4, 58: 4, 59: 2, 69: 4, 81: 4, 82: 2, 86: 2, 96: 3, 97: 2, 100: 5, 108: 3, 109: 4, 110: 4, 111: 2, 114: 3, 115: 4, 118: 6, 119: 5, 120: 3, 121: 4, 122: 2, 124: 4, 128: 3, 129: 2, 130: 4, 132: 4, 136: 2, 145: 4, 147: 3, 151: 3, 152: 3, 154: 3, 161: 3, 162: 3, 165: 3, 168: 4, 169: 2, 172: 2, 180: 3, 184: 5, 187: 5, 188: 4, 191: 3, 194: 4, 202: 5, 203: 6, 206: 2, 207: 3, 215: 2, 217: 3, 218: 8, 220: 2, 221: 2, 222: 5, 224: 3, 227: 3, 229: 2, 234: 5, 235: 2, 241: 2, 242: 2, 243: 4, 244: 3, 245: 4, 248: 3, 250: 2, 258: 11, 262: 4, 263: 5, 264: 3, 267: 4, 272: 2, 273: 5, 287: 3, 289: 2, 291: 4, 299: 3, 309: 3, 314: 2, 315: 2, 320: 4, 323: 4, 327: 4, 328: 3, 329: 2, 330: 10, 334: 2, 341: 3, 342: 4, 347: 3, 348: 3, 350: 7, 351: 4, 352: 2, 353: 2, 358: 4, 365: 2, 366: 2, 371: 5, 372: 4, 376: 2, 384: 4, 385: 3, 386: 3, 392: 3, 393: 4, 396: 4, 397: 7, 398: 6, 402: 2} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 52 "FRER function and the provided service recovery is available only within the TSN sub-network however as the Stream-ID and the TSN sequence number are paired with the MPLS flow parameters they can be combined with PREOF functions." Similar structure and changes as in IP over TSN . Service protection interworking is out - of - scope . d275ba154e2b7c82eb3ec9175d790214b0e60d3f d275ba154e2b7c82eb3ec9175d790214b0e60d3f draft-ietf-detnet-mpls-over-tsn 8a1dbabe711db86a26396c01597c528f5fcffb20f047620d5a97dc7303789634 ['630a7b3cd3eda2e026f158d16d3e4a4a2526a07124cf77aa8ed446ea760814d8', 'b03fd845058850bbf1a630e8c83fada6cba78982283c708236fd7388ffe9fc67', 'c47c152ac014e9bd75ed634d3b9e1c8bb57391b003cba836041c95b95a4c7fa1', 'c69a0fa2ea5f12373344fafbdd44dfb7bb6dbc1860b1c5990feae2a465de298d', '8a1dbabe711db86a26396c01597c528f5fcffb20f047620d5a97dc7303789634', 'e8ac6be9503fe785fadef60b06035db9bcfe02fde1de69193d9a4125a1399c60', '6a32f9bd776a29b7ce3eec373de6fa66bfd90fce56bad4e4eed60abba5aca087', '42f5214bb177fd7faf01b7943e7f313a615b2490f9109d5cefa8b24101735c32', '214810fe3ac0ef76db60e2d0623a8259b9bdf49040882a9e710901fe1eb32fde', '95e8b140a3153d24b8cc5b029501473ba4c08b0343d47a78892b1bad50321f66', 'c7011da30a42dd7b92a21132cfa295b31d66f42863c6a3414b5dbc0e9f38a1ce', 'ae45f508450dea10961ae41868df31a827a51caf984672ba7b53e43ba5e13140', '6808ff9c187a5808b263bc26ce9efc6509eedbd92aebf3bfa16a9ebbb5432f96', '3195c90c03cf6a438b5684cc93128c53f794660a661e2aa85d043ca5ac7060b9', '0246ffa7291c42bc165b0ac6acf1fc7285b5e41537731f44da530521ca5615d1', 'b5bacf05f766e143f6de9484b0b5a2d9655d62854368373bd77974b94cb722e6', '85d25c76743ed7e65b601d54f78150e74c3aa10e4c1b0b383304ba7887314a95', 'ae74a9a2a182dd5a01fd950e728caccd2600bef5390e5cc261e81037cf194a98', 'b94a431eeccea467fb994ae14c1161601ffad908f6fa54e35fd5f89256dacdea', '7ac09938faf2d97ce8bcc3b64b905bb5a585aeb30156506ee7abe2cd36825ed9', '601ac7ed7c06e522c784e0c0c3a976bc1cc9cccb10f550ee9cd153fa5cb3dcdc', '33a143d8274548ab7377f45f1204f1945e0cf20210af64fed99ac8028f48bac4', '1094721b24c22ff67539ffeabab887f87e538bdd9ebe50b0b369de138d326802', '19ad685cffba6309346c1ba7d6f642f0e69af09509b4f36f7ed87231855721a9', 'f34d1af51d3831ee49ed7f59e7135f955e977a1b93bb875be4c690b33a62450b', 'c53eb2c4fe199217644e8f623baca54cd8f18d0cf2746bad70b055d75f0faa23', '314017bb601d7806be2da63e51d3ee14147fa3ac35c6b85ba05825de7c5de742', '39820f7cb577ca0dcfb1bfa578ae13c25334acae03e89731064b0e3c300841de', '3703b0838ce47d992f259e22b20012a302240311d21f2d269cbb1414baec967f', '2605eb6691e33e75449ea67b2cc57cb2055976b481376bd77f71a937e30c3973', '8577e49f249e444a03b30a1f6f901d73d9fffc14ead45f0d56e8d2ff59c3301f', '8c5ca97b799230d82bd3e52e11118044d85a9f0dbf4f81934f31963b8f59d50c', 'ffe5de17213aa105e92776fd207a82f0ccefc1aa38407bb124b44f049f3dd1b8', '61b71fad4b4a688fc63731cab0845c3423c6935ea6d5c188047fbf047ef3a426', 'a491df768673d76ae7dee4c9bf1ea1456e6c537a1f1683368d8bc6869cd89bf0', '72c5a1f410983619d643ec9b1744e623d17c7eea2f68ac99d1881079601873cd', '139b8c43623bbe83d6e84c494389cef4e57e6816c2829cf9bcbb604af1f3bd70', '6de184d7411efde0440a2390c1009b5c1a251195a5c8bb05f6d64de2066a6d83', '7b6435e5d1cd5f5ef5156a6cb776bff4f493bdb11beead1f071fe87b93e78906', 'c5d808132e397aef8874ae2c056109762978e6c0fb6eee327f28541bd3886a04'] A "frer function and the provided service recovery is available only within the tsn sub-network however as the stream-id and the tsn sequence number are paired with the mpls flow parameters they can be combined with preof functions." {51: 1, 97: 1, 96: 1, 24: 1, 130: 1, 53: 1, 6: 2, 79: 2, 90: 2, 62: 3, 85: 4, 68: 4, 35: 3, 110: 2, 91: 4, 114: 2, 31: 3, 13: 2, 67: 2, 38: 3, 26: 2, 124: 3, 98: 2, 54: 2, 127: 3, 8: 2, 64: 2, 30: 2, 61: 4, 55: 3, 27: 3, 15: 2, 129: 3, 115: 2, 84: 2, 76: 6, 52: 2, 87: 2, 131: 5, 102: 2, 113: 4, 99: 2, 36: 2, 72: 3} {15: 1, 27: 1, 64: 1, 116: 1, 123: 1, 354: 1, 387: 1, 300: 1, 270: 1, 304: 1, 335: 1, 369: 1, 1: 9, 4: 2, 9: 5, 10: 3, 24: 2, 25: 3, 26: 4, 39: 5, 43: 3, 49: 5, 50: 4, 58: 4, 59: 2, 69: 4, 81: 4, 82: 2, 86: 2, 96: 3, 97: 2, 100: 5, 108: 3, 109: 4, 110: 4, 111: 2, 114: 3, 115: 4, 118: 6, 119: 5, 120: 3, 121: 4, 122: 2, 124: 4, 128: 3, 129: 2, 130: 4, 132: 4, 136: 2, 145: 4, 147: 3, 151: 3, 152: 3, 154: 3, 161: 3, 162: 3, 165: 3, 168: 4, 169: 2, 172: 2, 180: 3, 184: 5, 187: 5, 188: 4, 191: 3, 194: 4, 202: 5, 203: 6, 206: 2, 207: 3, 215: 2, 217: 3, 218: 8, 220: 2, 221: 2, 222: 5, 224: 3, 227: 3, 229: 2, 234: 5, 235: 2, 241: 2, 242: 2, 243: 4, 244: 3, 245: 4, 248: 3, 250: 2, 258: 11, 262: 4, 263: 5, 264: 3, 267: 4, 272: 2, 273: 5, 287: 3, 289: 2, 291: 4, 299: 3, 309: 3, 314: 2, 315: 2, 320: 4, 323: 4, 327: 4, 328: 3, 329: 2, 330: 10, 334: 2, 341: 3, 342: 4, 347: 3, 348: 3, 350: 7, 351: 4, 352: 2, 353: 2, 358: 4, 365: 2, 366: 2, 371: 5, 372: 4, 376: 2, 384: 4, 385: 3, 386: 3, 392: 3, 393: 4, 396: 4, 397: 7, 398: 6, 402: 2} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 52 "The Time-Sensitive Networking (TSN) Task Group of the IEEE 802.1 Working Group have defined (and are defining) a number of amendments to IEEE8021Q that provide zero congestion loss and bounded latency in bridged networks. IEEE8021CB defines packet replication and elimination functions that should prove both compatible with and useful to, DetNet networks." Similar structure and changes as in IP over TSN . Service protection interworking is out - of - scope . d275ba154e2b7c82eb3ec9175d790214b0e60d3f d275ba154e2b7c82eb3ec9175d790214b0e60d3f draft-ietf-detnet-mpls-over-tsn 3195c90c03cf6a438b5684cc93128c53f794660a661e2aa85d043ca5ac7060b9 ['630a7b3cd3eda2e026f158d16d3e4a4a2526a07124cf77aa8ed446ea760814d8', 'b03fd845058850bbf1a630e8c83fada6cba78982283c708236fd7388ffe9fc67', 'c47c152ac014e9bd75ed634d3b9e1c8bb57391b003cba836041c95b95a4c7fa1', 'c69a0fa2ea5f12373344fafbdd44dfb7bb6dbc1860b1c5990feae2a465de298d', '8a1dbabe711db86a26396c01597c528f5fcffb20f047620d5a97dc7303789634', 'e8ac6be9503fe785fadef60b06035db9bcfe02fde1de69193d9a4125a1399c60', '6a32f9bd776a29b7ce3eec373de6fa66bfd90fce56bad4e4eed60abba5aca087', '42f5214bb177fd7faf01b7943e7f313a615b2490f9109d5cefa8b24101735c32', '214810fe3ac0ef76db60e2d0623a8259b9bdf49040882a9e710901fe1eb32fde', '95e8b140a3153d24b8cc5b029501473ba4c08b0343d47a78892b1bad50321f66', 'c7011da30a42dd7b92a21132cfa295b31d66f42863c6a3414b5dbc0e9f38a1ce', 'ae45f508450dea10961ae41868df31a827a51caf984672ba7b53e43ba5e13140', '6808ff9c187a5808b263bc26ce9efc6509eedbd92aebf3bfa16a9ebbb5432f96', '3195c90c03cf6a438b5684cc93128c53f794660a661e2aa85d043ca5ac7060b9', '0246ffa7291c42bc165b0ac6acf1fc7285b5e41537731f44da530521ca5615d1', 'b5bacf05f766e143f6de9484b0b5a2d9655d62854368373bd77974b94cb722e6', '85d25c76743ed7e65b601d54f78150e74c3aa10e4c1b0b383304ba7887314a95', 'ae74a9a2a182dd5a01fd950e728caccd2600bef5390e5cc261e81037cf194a98', 'b94a431eeccea467fb994ae14c1161601ffad908f6fa54e35fd5f89256dacdea', '7ac09938faf2d97ce8bcc3b64b905bb5a585aeb30156506ee7abe2cd36825ed9', '601ac7ed7c06e522c784e0c0c3a976bc1cc9cccb10f550ee9cd153fa5cb3dcdc', '33a143d8274548ab7377f45f1204f1945e0cf20210af64fed99ac8028f48bac4', '1094721b24c22ff67539ffeabab887f87e538bdd9ebe50b0b369de138d326802', '19ad685cffba6309346c1ba7d6f642f0e69af09509b4f36f7ed87231855721a9', 'f34d1af51d3831ee49ed7f59e7135f955e977a1b93bb875be4c690b33a62450b', 'c53eb2c4fe199217644e8f623baca54cd8f18d0cf2746bad70b055d75f0faa23', '314017bb601d7806be2da63e51d3ee14147fa3ac35c6b85ba05825de7c5de742', '39820f7cb577ca0dcfb1bfa578ae13c25334acae03e89731064b0e3c300841de', '3703b0838ce47d992f259e22b20012a302240311d21f2d269cbb1414baec967f', '2605eb6691e33e75449ea67b2cc57cb2055976b481376bd77f71a937e30c3973', '8577e49f249e444a03b30a1f6f901d73d9fffc14ead45f0d56e8d2ff59c3301f', '8c5ca97b799230d82bd3e52e11118044d85a9f0dbf4f81934f31963b8f59d50c', 'ffe5de17213aa105e92776fd207a82f0ccefc1aa38407bb124b44f049f3dd1b8', '61b71fad4b4a688fc63731cab0845c3423c6935ea6d5c188047fbf047ef3a426', 'a491df768673d76ae7dee4c9bf1ea1456e6c537a1f1683368d8bc6869cd89bf0', '72c5a1f410983619d643ec9b1744e623d17c7eea2f68ac99d1881079601873cd', '139b8c43623bbe83d6e84c494389cef4e57e6816c2829cf9bcbb604af1f3bd70', '6de184d7411efde0440a2390c1009b5c1a251195a5c8bb05f6d64de2066a6d83', '7b6435e5d1cd5f5ef5156a6cb776bff4f493bdb11beead1f071fe87b93e78906', 'c5d808132e397aef8874ae2c056109762978e6c0fb6eee327f28541bd3886a04'] A "the time-sensitive networking (tsn) task group of the ieee 802.1 working group have defined (and are defining) a number of amendments to ieee8021q that provide zero congestion loss and bounded latency in bridged networks. ieee8021cb defines packet replication and elimination functions that should prove both compatible with and useful to, detnet networks." {51: 1, 97: 1, 96: 1, 24: 1, 130: 1, 53: 1, 6: 2, 79: 2, 90: 2, 62: 3, 85: 4, 68: 4, 35: 3, 110: 2, 91: 4, 114: 2, 31: 3, 13: 2, 67: 2, 38: 3, 26: 2, 124: 3, 98: 2, 54: 2, 127: 3, 8: 2, 64: 2, 30: 2, 61: 4, 55: 3, 27: 3, 15: 2, 129: 3, 115: 2, 84: 2, 76: 6, 52: 2, 87: 2, 131: 5, 102: 2, 113: 4, 99: 2, 36: 2, 72: 3} {15: 1, 27: 1, 64: 1, 116: 1, 123: 1, 354: 1, 387: 1, 300: 1, 270: 1, 304: 1, 335: 1, 369: 1, 1: 9, 4: 2, 9: 5, 10: 3, 24: 2, 25: 3, 26: 4, 39: 5, 43: 3, 49: 5, 50: 4, 58: 4, 59: 2, 69: 4, 81: 4, 82: 2, 86: 2, 96: 3, 97: 2, 100: 5, 108: 3, 109: 4, 110: 4, 111: 2, 114: 3, 115: 4, 118: 6, 119: 5, 120: 3, 121: 4, 122: 2, 124: 4, 128: 3, 129: 2, 130: 4, 132: 4, 136: 2, 145: 4, 147: 3, 151: 3, 152: 3, 154: 3, 161: 3, 162: 3, 165: 3, 168: 4, 169: 2, 172: 2, 180: 3, 184: 5, 187: 5, 188: 4, 191: 3, 194: 4, 202: 5, 203: 6, 206: 2, 207: 3, 215: 2, 217: 3, 218: 8, 220: 2, 221: 2, 222: 5, 224: 3, 227: 3, 229: 2, 234: 5, 235: 2, 241: 2, 242: 2, 243: 4, 244: 3, 245: 4, 248: 3, 250: 2, 258: 11, 262: 4, 263: 5, 264: 3, 267: 4, 272: 2, 273: 5, 287: 3, 289: 2, 291: 4, 299: 3, 309: 3, 314: 2, 315: 2, 320: 4, 323: 4, 327: 4, 328: 3, 329: 2, 330: 10, 334: 2, 341: 3, 342: 4, 347: 3, 348: 3, 350: 7, 351: 4, 352: 2, 353: 2, 358: 4, 365: 2, 366: 2, 371: 5, 372: 4, 376: 2, 384: 4, 385: 3, 386: 3, 392: 3, 393: 4, 396: 4, 397: 7, 398: 6, 402: 2} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 52 "As is the case for DetNet, a Layer 2 network node such as a bridge may need to identify the specific DetNet flow to which a packet belongs in order to provide the TSN/DetNet QoS for that packet. It also will likely need a CoS marking, such as the priority field of an IEEE Std 802.1Q VLAN tag, to give the packet proper service." Similar structure and changes as in IP over TSN . Service protection interworking is out - of - scope . d275ba154e2b7c82eb3ec9175d790214b0e60d3f d275ba154e2b7c82eb3ec9175d790214b0e60d3f draft-ietf-detnet-mpls-over-tsn a491df768673d76ae7dee4c9bf1ea1456e6c537a1f1683368d8bc6869cd89bf0 ['630a7b3cd3eda2e026f158d16d3e4a4a2526a07124cf77aa8ed446ea760814d8', 'b03fd845058850bbf1a630e8c83fada6cba78982283c708236fd7388ffe9fc67', 'c47c152ac014e9bd75ed634d3b9e1c8bb57391b003cba836041c95b95a4c7fa1', 'c69a0fa2ea5f12373344fafbdd44dfb7bb6dbc1860b1c5990feae2a465de298d', '8a1dbabe711db86a26396c01597c528f5fcffb20f047620d5a97dc7303789634', 'e8ac6be9503fe785fadef60b06035db9bcfe02fde1de69193d9a4125a1399c60', '6a32f9bd776a29b7ce3eec373de6fa66bfd90fce56bad4e4eed60abba5aca087', '42f5214bb177fd7faf01b7943e7f313a615b2490f9109d5cefa8b24101735c32', '214810fe3ac0ef76db60e2d0623a8259b9bdf49040882a9e710901fe1eb32fde', '95e8b140a3153d24b8cc5b029501473ba4c08b0343d47a78892b1bad50321f66', 'c7011da30a42dd7b92a21132cfa295b31d66f42863c6a3414b5dbc0e9f38a1ce', 'ae45f508450dea10961ae41868df31a827a51caf984672ba7b53e43ba5e13140', '6808ff9c187a5808b263bc26ce9efc6509eedbd92aebf3bfa16a9ebbb5432f96', '3195c90c03cf6a438b5684cc93128c53f794660a661e2aa85d043ca5ac7060b9', '0246ffa7291c42bc165b0ac6acf1fc7285b5e41537731f44da530521ca5615d1', 'b5bacf05f766e143f6de9484b0b5a2d9655d62854368373bd77974b94cb722e6', '85d25c76743ed7e65b601d54f78150e74c3aa10e4c1b0b383304ba7887314a95', 'ae74a9a2a182dd5a01fd950e728caccd2600bef5390e5cc261e81037cf194a98', 'b94a431eeccea467fb994ae14c1161601ffad908f6fa54e35fd5f89256dacdea', '7ac09938faf2d97ce8bcc3b64b905bb5a585aeb30156506ee7abe2cd36825ed9', '601ac7ed7c06e522c784e0c0c3a976bc1cc9cccb10f550ee9cd153fa5cb3dcdc', '33a143d8274548ab7377f45f1204f1945e0cf20210af64fed99ac8028f48bac4', '1094721b24c22ff67539ffeabab887f87e538bdd9ebe50b0b369de138d326802', '19ad685cffba6309346c1ba7d6f642f0e69af09509b4f36f7ed87231855721a9', 'f34d1af51d3831ee49ed7f59e7135f955e977a1b93bb875be4c690b33a62450b', 'c53eb2c4fe199217644e8f623baca54cd8f18d0cf2746bad70b055d75f0faa23', '314017bb601d7806be2da63e51d3ee14147fa3ac35c6b85ba05825de7c5de742', '39820f7cb577ca0dcfb1bfa578ae13c25334acae03e89731064b0e3c300841de', '3703b0838ce47d992f259e22b20012a302240311d21f2d269cbb1414baec967f', '2605eb6691e33e75449ea67b2cc57cb2055976b481376bd77f71a937e30c3973', '8577e49f249e444a03b30a1f6f901d73d9fffc14ead45f0d56e8d2ff59c3301f', '8c5ca97b799230d82bd3e52e11118044d85a9f0dbf4f81934f31963b8f59d50c', 'ffe5de17213aa105e92776fd207a82f0ccefc1aa38407bb124b44f049f3dd1b8', '61b71fad4b4a688fc63731cab0845c3423c6935ea6d5c188047fbf047ef3a426', 'a491df768673d76ae7dee4c9bf1ea1456e6c537a1f1683368d8bc6869cd89bf0', '72c5a1f410983619d643ec9b1744e623d17c7eea2f68ac99d1881079601873cd', '139b8c43623bbe83d6e84c494389cef4e57e6816c2829cf9bcbb604af1f3bd70', '6de184d7411efde0440a2390c1009b5c1a251195a5c8bb05f6d64de2066a6d83', '7b6435e5d1cd5f5ef5156a6cb776bff4f493bdb11beead1f071fe87b93e78906', 'c5d808132e397aef8874ae2c056109762978e6c0fb6eee327f28541bd3886a04'] A "as is the case for detnet, a layer 2 network node such as a bridge may need to identify the specific detnet flow to which a packet belongs in order to provide the tsn/detnet qos for that packet. it also will likely need a cos marking, such as the priority field of an ieee std 802.1q vlan tag, to give the packet proper service." {51: 1, 97: 1, 96: 1, 24: 1, 130: 1, 53: 1, 6: 2, 79: 2, 90: 2, 62: 3, 85: 4, 68: 4, 35: 3, 110: 2, 91: 4, 114: 2, 31: 3, 13: 2, 67: 2, 38: 3, 26: 2, 124: 3, 98: 2, 54: 2, 127: 3, 8: 2, 64: 2, 30: 2, 61: 4, 55: 3, 27: 3, 15: 2, 129: 3, 115: 2, 84: 2, 76: 6, 52: 2, 87: 2, 131: 5, 102: 2, 113: 4, 99: 2, 36: 2, 72: 3} {15: 1, 27: 1, 64: 1, 116: 1, 123: 1, 354: 1, 387: 1, 300: 1, 270: 1, 304: 1, 335: 1, 369: 1, 1: 9, 4: 2, 9: 5, 10: 3, 24: 2, 25: 3, 26: 4, 39: 5, 43: 3, 49: 5, 50: 4, 58: 4, 59: 2, 69: 4, 81: 4, 82: 2, 86: 2, 96: 3, 97: 2, 100: 5, 108: 3, 109: 4, 110: 4, 111: 2, 114: 3, 115: 4, 118: 6, 119: 5, 120: 3, 121: 4, 122: 2, 124: 4, 128: 3, 129: 2, 130: 4, 132: 4, 136: 2, 145: 4, 147: 3, 151: 3, 152: 3, 154: 3, 161: 3, 162: 3, 165: 3, 168: 4, 169: 2, 172: 2, 180: 3, 184: 5, 187: 5, 188: 4, 191: 3, 194: 4, 202: 5, 203: 6, 206: 2, 207: 3, 215: 2, 217: 3, 218: 8, 220: 2, 221: 2, 222: 5, 224: 3, 227: 3, 229: 2, 234: 5, 235: 2, 241: 2, 242: 2, 243: 4, 244: 3, 245: 4, 248: 3, 250: 2, 258: 11, 262: 4, 263: 5, 264: 3, 267: 4, 272: 2, 273: 5, 287: 3, 289: 2, 291: 4, 299: 3, 309: 3, 314: 2, 315: 2, 320: 4, 323: 4, 327: 4, 328: 3, 329: 2, 330: 10, 334: 2, 341: 3, 342: 4, 347: 3, 348: 3, 350: 7, 351: 4, 352: 2, 353: 2, 358: 4, 365: 2, 366: 2, 371: 5, 372: 4, 376: 2, 384: 4, 385: 3, 386: 3, 392: 3, 393: 4, 396: 4, 397: 7, 398: 6, 402: 2} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 52 "Although the flow identification methods described in IEEE8021CB are flexible, and in fact, include IP 5-tuple identification methods, the baseline TSN standards assume that every Ethernet frame belonging to a TSN stream (i.e. DetNet flow) carries a multicast destination MAC address that is unique to that flow within the bridged network over which it is carried. Furthermore, IEEE8021CB describes three methods by which a packet sequence number can be encoded in an Ethernet frame." Similar structure and changes as in IP over TSN . Service protection interworking is out - of - scope . d275ba154e2b7c82eb3ec9175d790214b0e60d3f d275ba154e2b7c82eb3ec9175d790214b0e60d3f draft-ietf-detnet-mpls-over-tsn 1094721b24c22ff67539ffeabab887f87e538bdd9ebe50b0b369de138d326802 ['630a7b3cd3eda2e026f158d16d3e4a4a2526a07124cf77aa8ed446ea760814d8', 'b03fd845058850bbf1a630e8c83fada6cba78982283c708236fd7388ffe9fc67', 'c47c152ac014e9bd75ed634d3b9e1c8bb57391b003cba836041c95b95a4c7fa1', 'c69a0fa2ea5f12373344fafbdd44dfb7bb6dbc1860b1c5990feae2a465de298d', '8a1dbabe711db86a26396c01597c528f5fcffb20f047620d5a97dc7303789634', 'e8ac6be9503fe785fadef60b06035db9bcfe02fde1de69193d9a4125a1399c60', '6a32f9bd776a29b7ce3eec373de6fa66bfd90fce56bad4e4eed60abba5aca087', '42f5214bb177fd7faf01b7943e7f313a615b2490f9109d5cefa8b24101735c32', '214810fe3ac0ef76db60e2d0623a8259b9bdf49040882a9e710901fe1eb32fde', '95e8b140a3153d24b8cc5b029501473ba4c08b0343d47a78892b1bad50321f66', 'c7011da30a42dd7b92a21132cfa295b31d66f42863c6a3414b5dbc0e9f38a1ce', 'ae45f508450dea10961ae41868df31a827a51caf984672ba7b53e43ba5e13140', '6808ff9c187a5808b263bc26ce9efc6509eedbd92aebf3bfa16a9ebbb5432f96', '3195c90c03cf6a438b5684cc93128c53f794660a661e2aa85d043ca5ac7060b9', '0246ffa7291c42bc165b0ac6acf1fc7285b5e41537731f44da530521ca5615d1', 'b5bacf05f766e143f6de9484b0b5a2d9655d62854368373bd77974b94cb722e6', '85d25c76743ed7e65b601d54f78150e74c3aa10e4c1b0b383304ba7887314a95', 'ae74a9a2a182dd5a01fd950e728caccd2600bef5390e5cc261e81037cf194a98', 'b94a431eeccea467fb994ae14c1161601ffad908f6fa54e35fd5f89256dacdea', '7ac09938faf2d97ce8bcc3b64b905bb5a585aeb30156506ee7abe2cd36825ed9', '601ac7ed7c06e522c784e0c0c3a976bc1cc9cccb10f550ee9cd153fa5cb3dcdc', '33a143d8274548ab7377f45f1204f1945e0cf20210af64fed99ac8028f48bac4', '1094721b24c22ff67539ffeabab887f87e538bdd9ebe50b0b369de138d326802', '19ad685cffba6309346c1ba7d6f642f0e69af09509b4f36f7ed87231855721a9', 'f34d1af51d3831ee49ed7f59e7135f955e977a1b93bb875be4c690b33a62450b', 'c53eb2c4fe199217644e8f623baca54cd8f18d0cf2746bad70b055d75f0faa23', '314017bb601d7806be2da63e51d3ee14147fa3ac35c6b85ba05825de7c5de742', '39820f7cb577ca0dcfb1bfa578ae13c25334acae03e89731064b0e3c300841de', '3703b0838ce47d992f259e22b20012a302240311d21f2d269cbb1414baec967f', '2605eb6691e33e75449ea67b2cc57cb2055976b481376bd77f71a937e30c3973', '8577e49f249e444a03b30a1f6f901d73d9fffc14ead45f0d56e8d2ff59c3301f', '8c5ca97b799230d82bd3e52e11118044d85a9f0dbf4f81934f31963b8f59d50c', 'ffe5de17213aa105e92776fd207a82f0ccefc1aa38407bb124b44f049f3dd1b8', '61b71fad4b4a688fc63731cab0845c3423c6935ea6d5c188047fbf047ef3a426', 'a491df768673d76ae7dee4c9bf1ea1456e6c537a1f1683368d8bc6869cd89bf0', '72c5a1f410983619d643ec9b1744e623d17c7eea2f68ac99d1881079601873cd', '139b8c43623bbe83d6e84c494389cef4e57e6816c2829cf9bcbb604af1f3bd70', '6de184d7411efde0440a2390c1009b5c1a251195a5c8bb05f6d64de2066a6d83', '7b6435e5d1cd5f5ef5156a6cb776bff4f493bdb11beead1f071fe87b93e78906', 'c5d808132e397aef8874ae2c056109762978e6c0fb6eee327f28541bd3886a04'] A "although the flow identification methods described in ieee8021cb are flexible, and in fact, include ip 5-tuple identification methods, the baseline tsn standards assume that every ethernet frame belonging to a tsn stream (i.e. detnet flow) carries a multicast destination mac address that is unique to that flow within the bridged network over which it is carried. furthermore, ieee8021cb describes three methods by which a packet sequence number can be encoded in an ethernet frame." {51: 1, 97: 1, 96: 1, 24: 1, 130: 1, 53: 1, 6: 2, 79: 2, 90: 2, 62: 3, 85: 4, 68: 4, 35: 3, 110: 2, 91: 4, 114: 2, 31: 3, 13: 2, 67: 2, 38: 3, 26: 2, 124: 3, 98: 2, 54: 2, 127: 3, 8: 2, 64: 2, 30: 2, 61: 4, 55: 3, 27: 3, 15: 2, 129: 3, 115: 2, 84: 2, 76: 6, 52: 2, 87: 2, 131: 5, 102: 2, 113: 4, 99: 2, 36: 2, 72: 3} {15: 1, 27: 1, 64: 1, 116: 1, 123: 1, 354: 1, 387: 1, 300: 1, 270: 1, 304: 1, 335: 1, 369: 1, 1: 9, 4: 2, 9: 5, 10: 3, 24: 2, 25: 3, 26: 4, 39: 5, 43: 3, 49: 5, 50: 4, 58: 4, 59: 2, 69: 4, 81: 4, 82: 2, 86: 2, 96: 3, 97: 2, 100: 5, 108: 3, 109: 4, 110: 4, 111: 2, 114: 3, 115: 4, 118: 6, 119: 5, 120: 3, 121: 4, 122: 2, 124: 4, 128: 3, 129: 2, 130: 4, 132: 4, 136: 2, 145: 4, 147: 3, 151: 3, 152: 3, 154: 3, 161: 3, 162: 3, 165: 3, 168: 4, 169: 2, 172: 2, 180: 3, 184: 5, 187: 5, 188: 4, 191: 3, 194: 4, 202: 5, 203: 6, 206: 2, 207: 3, 215: 2, 217: 3, 218: 8, 220: 2, 221: 2, 222: 5, 224: 3, 227: 3, 229: 2, 234: 5, 235: 2, 241: 2, 242: 2, 243: 4, 244: 3, 245: 4, 248: 3, 250: 2, 258: 11, 262: 4, 263: 5, 264: 3, 267: 4, 272: 2, 273: 5, 287: 3, 289: 2, 291: 4, 299: 3, 309: 3, 314: 2, 315: 2, 320: 4, 323: 4, 327: 4, 328: 3, 329: 2, 330: 10, 334: 2, 341: 3, 342: 4, 347: 3, 348: 3, 350: 7, 351: 4, 352: 2, 353: 2, 358: 4, 365: 2, 366: 2, 371: 5, 372: 4, 376: 2, 384: 4, 385: 3, 386: 3, 392: 3, 393: 4, 396: 4, 397: 7, 398: 6, 402: 2} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 52 "Ensuring that the proper Ethernet VLAN tag priority and destination MAC address are used on a DetNet/TSN packet may require further clarification of the customary L2/L3 transformations carried out by routers and edge label switches. Edge nodes may also have to move sequence number fields among Layer 2, PW, and IP encapsulations." Similar structure and changes as in IP over TSN . Service protection interworking is out - of - scope . d275ba154e2b7c82eb3ec9175d790214b0e60d3f d275ba154e2b7c82eb3ec9175d790214b0e60d3f draft-ietf-detnet-mpls-over-tsn b5bacf05f766e143f6de9484b0b5a2d9655d62854368373bd77974b94cb722e6 ['630a7b3cd3eda2e026f158d16d3e4a4a2526a07124cf77aa8ed446ea760814d8', 'b03fd845058850bbf1a630e8c83fada6cba78982283c708236fd7388ffe9fc67', 'c47c152ac014e9bd75ed634d3b9e1c8bb57391b003cba836041c95b95a4c7fa1', 'c69a0fa2ea5f12373344fafbdd44dfb7bb6dbc1860b1c5990feae2a465de298d', '8a1dbabe711db86a26396c01597c528f5fcffb20f047620d5a97dc7303789634', 'e8ac6be9503fe785fadef60b06035db9bcfe02fde1de69193d9a4125a1399c60', '6a32f9bd776a29b7ce3eec373de6fa66bfd90fce56bad4e4eed60abba5aca087', '42f5214bb177fd7faf01b7943e7f313a615b2490f9109d5cefa8b24101735c32', '214810fe3ac0ef76db60e2d0623a8259b9bdf49040882a9e710901fe1eb32fde', '95e8b140a3153d24b8cc5b029501473ba4c08b0343d47a78892b1bad50321f66', 'c7011da30a42dd7b92a21132cfa295b31d66f42863c6a3414b5dbc0e9f38a1ce', 'ae45f508450dea10961ae41868df31a827a51caf984672ba7b53e43ba5e13140', '6808ff9c187a5808b263bc26ce9efc6509eedbd92aebf3bfa16a9ebbb5432f96', '3195c90c03cf6a438b5684cc93128c53f794660a661e2aa85d043ca5ac7060b9', '0246ffa7291c42bc165b0ac6acf1fc7285b5e41537731f44da530521ca5615d1', 'b5bacf05f766e143f6de9484b0b5a2d9655d62854368373bd77974b94cb722e6', '85d25c76743ed7e65b601d54f78150e74c3aa10e4c1b0b383304ba7887314a95', 'ae74a9a2a182dd5a01fd950e728caccd2600bef5390e5cc261e81037cf194a98', 'b94a431eeccea467fb994ae14c1161601ffad908f6fa54e35fd5f89256dacdea', '7ac09938faf2d97ce8bcc3b64b905bb5a585aeb30156506ee7abe2cd36825ed9', '601ac7ed7c06e522c784e0c0c3a976bc1cc9cccb10f550ee9cd153fa5cb3dcdc', '33a143d8274548ab7377f45f1204f1945e0cf20210af64fed99ac8028f48bac4', '1094721b24c22ff67539ffeabab887f87e538bdd9ebe50b0b369de138d326802', '19ad685cffba6309346c1ba7d6f642f0e69af09509b4f36f7ed87231855721a9', 'f34d1af51d3831ee49ed7f59e7135f955e977a1b93bb875be4c690b33a62450b', 'c53eb2c4fe199217644e8f623baca54cd8f18d0cf2746bad70b055d75f0faa23', '314017bb601d7806be2da63e51d3ee14147fa3ac35c6b85ba05825de7c5de742', '39820f7cb577ca0dcfb1bfa578ae13c25334acae03e89731064b0e3c300841de', '3703b0838ce47d992f259e22b20012a302240311d21f2d269cbb1414baec967f', '2605eb6691e33e75449ea67b2cc57cb2055976b481376bd77f71a937e30c3973', '8577e49f249e444a03b30a1f6f901d73d9fffc14ead45f0d56e8d2ff59c3301f', '8c5ca97b799230d82bd3e52e11118044d85a9f0dbf4f81934f31963b8f59d50c', 'ffe5de17213aa105e92776fd207a82f0ccefc1aa38407bb124b44f049f3dd1b8', '61b71fad4b4a688fc63731cab0845c3423c6935ea6d5c188047fbf047ef3a426', 'a491df768673d76ae7dee4c9bf1ea1456e6c537a1f1683368d8bc6869cd89bf0', '72c5a1f410983619d643ec9b1744e623d17c7eea2f68ac99d1881079601873cd', '139b8c43623bbe83d6e84c494389cef4e57e6816c2829cf9bcbb604af1f3bd70', '6de184d7411efde0440a2390c1009b5c1a251195a5c8bb05f6d64de2066a6d83', '7b6435e5d1cd5f5ef5156a6cb776bff4f493bdb11beead1f071fe87b93e78906', 'c5d808132e397aef8874ae2c056109762978e6c0fb6eee327f28541bd3886a04'] A "ensuring that the proper ethernet vlan tag priority and destination mac address are used on a detnet/tsn packet may require further clarification of the customary l2/l3 transformations carried out by routers and edge label switches. edge nodes may also have to move sequence number fields among layer 2, pw, and ip encapsulations." {51: 1, 97: 1, 96: 1, 24: 1, 130: 1, 53: 1, 6: 2, 79: 2, 90: 2, 62: 3, 85: 4, 68: 4, 35: 3, 110: 2, 91: 4, 114: 2, 31: 3, 13: 2, 67: 2, 38: 3, 26: 2, 124: 3, 98: 2, 54: 2, 127: 3, 8: 2, 64: 2, 30: 2, 61: 4, 55: 3, 27: 3, 15: 2, 129: 3, 115: 2, 84: 2, 76: 6, 52: 2, 87: 2, 131: 5, 102: 2, 113: 4, 99: 2, 36: 2, 72: 3} {15: 1, 27: 1, 64: 1, 116: 1, 123: 1, 354: 1, 387: 1, 300: 1, 270: 1, 304: 1, 335: 1, 369: 1, 1: 9, 4: 2, 9: 5, 10: 3, 24: 2, 25: 3, 26: 4, 39: 5, 43: 3, 49: 5, 50: 4, 58: 4, 59: 2, 69: 4, 81: 4, 82: 2, 86: 2, 96: 3, 97: 2, 100: 5, 108: 3, 109: 4, 110: 4, 111: 2, 114: 3, 115: 4, 118: 6, 119: 5, 120: 3, 121: 4, 122: 2, 124: 4, 128: 3, 129: 2, 130: 4, 132: 4, 136: 2, 145: 4, 147: 3, 151: 3, 152: 3, 154: 3, 161: 3, 162: 3, 165: 3, 168: 4, 169: 2, 172: 2, 180: 3, 184: 5, 187: 5, 188: 4, 191: 3, 194: 4, 202: 5, 203: 6, 206: 2, 207: 3, 215: 2, 217: 3, 218: 8, 220: 2, 221: 2, 222: 5, 224: 3, 227: 3, 229: 2, 234: 5, 235: 2, 241: 2, 242: 2, 243: 4, 244: 3, 245: 4, 248: 3, 250: 2, 258: 11, 262: 4, 263: 5, 264: 3, 267: 4, 272: 2, 273: 5, 287: 3, 289: 2, 291: 4, 299: 3, 309: 3, 314: 2, 315: 2, 320: 4, 323: 4, 327: 4, 328: 3, 329: 2, 330: 10, 334: 2, 341: 3, 342: 4, 347: 3, 348: 3, 350: 7, 351: 4, 352: 2, 353: 2, 358: 4, 365: 2, 366: 2, 371: 5, 372: 4, 376: 2, 384: 4, 385: 3, 386: 3, 392: 3, 393: 4, 396: 4, 397: 7, 398: 6, 402: 2} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 52 "While management plane and control planes are traditionally considered separately, from the Data Plane perspective there is no practical difference based on the origin of flow provisioning information, and the DetNet architecture I-D.ietf-detnet-architecture refers to these collectively as the 'Controller Plane'. This document therefore does not distinguish between information provided by distributed control plane protocols, e.g., RSVP-TE RFC3209 and RFC3473, or by centralized network management mechanisms, e.g., RestConf RFC8040, YANG RFC7950, and the Path Computation Element Communication Protocol (PCEP) I-D.ietf-pce-pcep-extension-for-pce- controller or any combination thereof. Specific considerations and requirements for the DetNet Controller Plane are discussed below." Similar structure and changes as in IP over TSN . Service protection interworking is out - of - scope . d275ba154e2b7c82eb3ec9175d790214b0e60d3f d275ba154e2b7c82eb3ec9175d790214b0e60d3f draft-ietf-detnet-mpls-over-tsn 19ad685cffba6309346c1ba7d6f642f0e69af09509b4f36f7ed87231855721a9 ['630a7b3cd3eda2e026f158d16d3e4a4a2526a07124cf77aa8ed446ea760814d8', 'b03fd845058850bbf1a630e8c83fada6cba78982283c708236fd7388ffe9fc67', 'c47c152ac014e9bd75ed634d3b9e1c8bb57391b003cba836041c95b95a4c7fa1', 'c69a0fa2ea5f12373344fafbdd44dfb7bb6dbc1860b1c5990feae2a465de298d', '8a1dbabe711db86a26396c01597c528f5fcffb20f047620d5a97dc7303789634', 'e8ac6be9503fe785fadef60b06035db9bcfe02fde1de69193d9a4125a1399c60', '6a32f9bd776a29b7ce3eec373de6fa66bfd90fce56bad4e4eed60abba5aca087', '42f5214bb177fd7faf01b7943e7f313a615b2490f9109d5cefa8b24101735c32', '214810fe3ac0ef76db60e2d0623a8259b9bdf49040882a9e710901fe1eb32fde', '95e8b140a3153d24b8cc5b029501473ba4c08b0343d47a78892b1bad50321f66', 'c7011da30a42dd7b92a21132cfa295b31d66f42863c6a3414b5dbc0e9f38a1ce', 'ae45f508450dea10961ae41868df31a827a51caf984672ba7b53e43ba5e13140', '6808ff9c187a5808b263bc26ce9efc6509eedbd92aebf3bfa16a9ebbb5432f96', '3195c90c03cf6a438b5684cc93128c53f794660a661e2aa85d043ca5ac7060b9', '0246ffa7291c42bc165b0ac6acf1fc7285b5e41537731f44da530521ca5615d1', 'b5bacf05f766e143f6de9484b0b5a2d9655d62854368373bd77974b94cb722e6', '85d25c76743ed7e65b601d54f78150e74c3aa10e4c1b0b383304ba7887314a95', 'ae74a9a2a182dd5a01fd950e728caccd2600bef5390e5cc261e81037cf194a98', 'b94a431eeccea467fb994ae14c1161601ffad908f6fa54e35fd5f89256dacdea', '7ac09938faf2d97ce8bcc3b64b905bb5a585aeb30156506ee7abe2cd36825ed9', '601ac7ed7c06e522c784e0c0c3a976bc1cc9cccb10f550ee9cd153fa5cb3dcdc', '33a143d8274548ab7377f45f1204f1945e0cf20210af64fed99ac8028f48bac4', '1094721b24c22ff67539ffeabab887f87e538bdd9ebe50b0b369de138d326802', '19ad685cffba6309346c1ba7d6f642f0e69af09509b4f36f7ed87231855721a9', 'f34d1af51d3831ee49ed7f59e7135f955e977a1b93bb875be4c690b33a62450b', 'c53eb2c4fe199217644e8f623baca54cd8f18d0cf2746bad70b055d75f0faa23', '314017bb601d7806be2da63e51d3ee14147fa3ac35c6b85ba05825de7c5de742', '39820f7cb577ca0dcfb1bfa578ae13c25334acae03e89731064b0e3c300841de', '3703b0838ce47d992f259e22b20012a302240311d21f2d269cbb1414baec967f', '2605eb6691e33e75449ea67b2cc57cb2055976b481376bd77f71a937e30c3973', '8577e49f249e444a03b30a1f6f901d73d9fffc14ead45f0d56e8d2ff59c3301f', '8c5ca97b799230d82bd3e52e11118044d85a9f0dbf4f81934f31963b8f59d50c', 'ffe5de17213aa105e92776fd207a82f0ccefc1aa38407bb124b44f049f3dd1b8', '61b71fad4b4a688fc63731cab0845c3423c6935ea6d5c188047fbf047ef3a426', 'a491df768673d76ae7dee4c9bf1ea1456e6c537a1f1683368d8bc6869cd89bf0', '72c5a1f410983619d643ec9b1744e623d17c7eea2f68ac99d1881079601873cd', '139b8c43623bbe83d6e84c494389cef4e57e6816c2829cf9bcbb604af1f3bd70', '6de184d7411efde0440a2390c1009b5c1a251195a5c8bb05f6d64de2066a6d83', '7b6435e5d1cd5f5ef5156a6cb776bff4f493bdb11beead1f071fe87b93e78906', 'c5d808132e397aef8874ae2c056109762978e6c0fb6eee327f28541bd3886a04'] A "while management plane and control planes are traditionally considered separately, from the data plane perspective there is no practical difference based on the origin of flow provisioning information, and the detnet architecture i-d.ietf-detnet-architecture refers to these collectively as the 'controller plane'. this document therefore does not distinguish between information provided by distributed control plane protocols, e.g., rsvp-te rfc3209 and rfc3473, or by centralized network management mechanisms, e.g., restconf rfc8040, yang rfc7950, and the path computation element communication protocol (pcep) i-d.ietf-pce-pcep-extension-for-pce- controller or any combination thereof. specific considerations and requirements for the detnet controller plane are discussed below." {51: 1, 97: 1, 96: 1, 24: 1, 130: 1, 53: 1, 6: 2, 79: 2, 90: 2, 62: 3, 85: 4, 68: 4, 35: 3, 110: 2, 91: 4, 114: 2, 31: 3, 13: 2, 67: 2, 38: 3, 26: 2, 124: 3, 98: 2, 54: 2, 127: 3, 8: 2, 64: 2, 30: 2, 61: 4, 55: 3, 27: 3, 15: 2, 129: 3, 115: 2, 84: 2, 76: 6, 52: 2, 87: 2, 131: 5, 102: 2, 113: 4, 99: 2, 36: 2, 72: 3} {15: 1, 27: 1, 64: 1, 116: 1, 123: 1, 354: 1, 387: 1, 300: 1, 270: 1, 304: 1, 335: 1, 369: 1, 1: 9, 4: 2, 9: 5, 10: 3, 24: 2, 25: 3, 26: 4, 39: 5, 43: 3, 49: 5, 50: 4, 58: 4, 59: 2, 69: 4, 81: 4, 82: 2, 86: 2, 96: 3, 97: 2, 100: 5, 108: 3, 109: 4, 110: 4, 111: 2, 114: 3, 115: 4, 118: 6, 119: 5, 120: 3, 121: 4, 122: 2, 124: 4, 128: 3, 129: 2, 130: 4, 132: 4, 136: 2, 145: 4, 147: 3, 151: 3, 152: 3, 154: 3, 161: 3, 162: 3, 165: 3, 168: 4, 169: 2, 172: 2, 180: 3, 184: 5, 187: 5, 188: 4, 191: 3, 194: 4, 202: 5, 203: 6, 206: 2, 207: 3, 215: 2, 217: 3, 218: 8, 220: 2, 221: 2, 222: 5, 224: 3, 227: 3, 229: 2, 234: 5, 235: 2, 241: 2, 242: 2, 243: 4, 244: 3, 245: 4, 248: 3, 250: 2, 258: 11, 262: 4, 263: 5, 264: 3, 267: 4, 272: 2, 273: 5, 287: 3, 289: 2, 291: 4, 299: 3, 309: 3, 314: 2, 315: 2, 320: 4, 323: 4, 327: 4, 328: 3, 329: 2, 330: 10, 334: 2, 341: 3, 342: 4, 347: 3, 348: 3, 350: 7, 351: 4, 352: 2, 353: 2, 358: 4, 365: 2, 366: 2, 371: 5, 372: 4, 376: 2, 384: 4, 385: 3, 386: 3, 392: 3, 393: 4, 396: 4, 397: 7, 398: 6, 402: 2} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 52 "The security considerations of DetNet in general are discussed in I- D.ietf-detnet-architecture and I-D.sdt-detnet-security. Other security considerations will be added in a future version of this draft." Similar structure and changes as in IP over TSN . Service protection interworking is out - of - scope . d275ba154e2b7c82eb3ec9175d790214b0e60d3f d275ba154e2b7c82eb3ec9175d790214b0e60d3f draft-ietf-detnet-mpls-over-tsn 42f5214bb177fd7faf01b7943e7f313a615b2490f9109d5cefa8b24101735c32 ['630a7b3cd3eda2e026f158d16d3e4a4a2526a07124cf77aa8ed446ea760814d8', 'b03fd845058850bbf1a630e8c83fada6cba78982283c708236fd7388ffe9fc67', 'c47c152ac014e9bd75ed634d3b9e1c8bb57391b003cba836041c95b95a4c7fa1', 'c69a0fa2ea5f12373344fafbdd44dfb7bb6dbc1860b1c5990feae2a465de298d', '8a1dbabe711db86a26396c01597c528f5fcffb20f047620d5a97dc7303789634', 'e8ac6be9503fe785fadef60b06035db9bcfe02fde1de69193d9a4125a1399c60', '6a32f9bd776a29b7ce3eec373de6fa66bfd90fce56bad4e4eed60abba5aca087', '42f5214bb177fd7faf01b7943e7f313a615b2490f9109d5cefa8b24101735c32', '214810fe3ac0ef76db60e2d0623a8259b9bdf49040882a9e710901fe1eb32fde', '95e8b140a3153d24b8cc5b029501473ba4c08b0343d47a78892b1bad50321f66', 'c7011da30a42dd7b92a21132cfa295b31d66f42863c6a3414b5dbc0e9f38a1ce', 'ae45f508450dea10961ae41868df31a827a51caf984672ba7b53e43ba5e13140', '6808ff9c187a5808b263bc26ce9efc6509eedbd92aebf3bfa16a9ebbb5432f96', '3195c90c03cf6a438b5684cc93128c53f794660a661e2aa85d043ca5ac7060b9', '0246ffa7291c42bc165b0ac6acf1fc7285b5e41537731f44da530521ca5615d1', 'b5bacf05f766e143f6de9484b0b5a2d9655d62854368373bd77974b94cb722e6', '85d25c76743ed7e65b601d54f78150e74c3aa10e4c1b0b383304ba7887314a95', 'ae74a9a2a182dd5a01fd950e728caccd2600bef5390e5cc261e81037cf194a98', 'b94a431eeccea467fb994ae14c1161601ffad908f6fa54e35fd5f89256dacdea', '7ac09938faf2d97ce8bcc3b64b905bb5a585aeb30156506ee7abe2cd36825ed9', '601ac7ed7c06e522c784e0c0c3a976bc1cc9cccb10f550ee9cd153fa5cb3dcdc', '33a143d8274548ab7377f45f1204f1945e0cf20210af64fed99ac8028f48bac4', '1094721b24c22ff67539ffeabab887f87e538bdd9ebe50b0b369de138d326802', '19ad685cffba6309346c1ba7d6f642f0e69af09509b4f36f7ed87231855721a9', 'f34d1af51d3831ee49ed7f59e7135f955e977a1b93bb875be4c690b33a62450b', 'c53eb2c4fe199217644e8f623baca54cd8f18d0cf2746bad70b055d75f0faa23', '314017bb601d7806be2da63e51d3ee14147fa3ac35c6b85ba05825de7c5de742', '39820f7cb577ca0dcfb1bfa578ae13c25334acae03e89731064b0e3c300841de', '3703b0838ce47d992f259e22b20012a302240311d21f2d269cbb1414baec967f', '2605eb6691e33e75449ea67b2cc57cb2055976b481376bd77f71a937e30c3973', '8577e49f249e444a03b30a1f6f901d73d9fffc14ead45f0d56e8d2ff59c3301f', '8c5ca97b799230d82bd3e52e11118044d85a9f0dbf4f81934f31963b8f59d50c', 'ffe5de17213aa105e92776fd207a82f0ccefc1aa38407bb124b44f049f3dd1b8', '61b71fad4b4a688fc63731cab0845c3423c6935ea6d5c188047fbf047ef3a426', 'a491df768673d76ae7dee4c9bf1ea1456e6c537a1f1683368d8bc6869cd89bf0', '72c5a1f410983619d643ec9b1744e623d17c7eea2f68ac99d1881079601873cd', '139b8c43623bbe83d6e84c494389cef4e57e6816c2829cf9bcbb604af1f3bd70', '6de184d7411efde0440a2390c1009b5c1a251195a5c8bb05f6d64de2066a6d83', '7b6435e5d1cd5f5ef5156a6cb776bff4f493bdb11beead1f071fe87b93e78906', 'c5d808132e397aef8874ae2c056109762978e6c0fb6eee327f28541bd3886a04'] A "the security considerations of detnet in general are discussed in i- d.ietf-detnet-architecture and i-d.sdt-detnet-security. other security considerations will be added in a future version of this draft." {51: 1, 97: 1, 96: 1, 24: 1, 130: 1, 53: 1, 6: 2, 79: 2, 90: 2, 62: 3, 85: 4, 68: 4, 35: 3, 110: 2, 91: 4, 114: 2, 31: 3, 13: 2, 67: 2, 38: 3, 26: 2, 124: 3, 98: 2, 54: 2, 127: 3, 8: 2, 64: 2, 30: 2, 61: 4, 55: 3, 27: 3, 15: 2, 129: 3, 115: 2, 84: 2, 76: 6, 52: 2, 87: 2, 131: 5, 102: 2, 113: 4, 99: 2, 36: 2, 72: 3} {15: 1, 27: 1, 64: 1, 116: 1, 123: 1, 354: 1, 387: 1, 300: 1, 270: 1, 304: 1, 335: 1, 369: 1, 1: 9, 4: 2, 9: 5, 10: 3, 24: 2, 25: 3, 26: 4, 39: 5, 43: 3, 49: 5, 50: 4, 58: 4, 59: 2, 69: 4, 81: 4, 82: 2, 86: 2, 96: 3, 97: 2, 100: 5, 108: 3, 109: 4, 110: 4, 111: 2, 114: 3, 115: 4, 118: 6, 119: 5, 120: 3, 121: 4, 122: 2, 124: 4, 128: 3, 129: 2, 130: 4, 132: 4, 136: 2, 145: 4, 147: 3, 151: 3, 152: 3, 154: 3, 161: 3, 162: 3, 165: 3, 168: 4, 169: 2, 172: 2, 180: 3, 184: 5, 187: 5, 188: 4, 191: 3, 194: 4, 202: 5, 203: 6, 206: 2, 207: 3, 215: 2, 217: 3, 218: 8, 220: 2, 221: 2, 222: 5, 224: 3, 227: 3, 229: 2, 234: 5, 235: 2, 241: 2, 242: 2, 243: 4, 244: 3, 245: 4, 248: 3, 250: 2, 258: 11, 262: 4, 263: 5, 264: 3, 267: 4, 272: 2, 273: 5, 287: 3, 289: 2, 291: 4, 299: 3, 309: 3, 314: 2, 315: 2, 320: 4, 323: 4, 327: 4, 328: 3, 329: 2, 330: 10, 334: 2, 341: 3, 342: 4, 347: 3, 348: 3, 350: 7, 351: 4, 352: 2, 353: 2, 358: 4, 365: 2, 366: 2, 371: 5, 372: 4, 376: 2, 384: 4, 385: 3, 386: 3, 392: 3, 393: 4, 396: 4, 397: 7, 398: 6, 402: 2} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 52 "TSN capabilities of the TSN sub-network are made available for MPLS (DetNet) flows via the protocol interworking function defined in IEEE8021CB. For example, applied on the TSN edge port it can convert an ingress unicast MPLS (DetNet) flow to use a specific Layer-2 multicast destination MAC address and a VLAN, in order to direct the packet through a specific path inside the bridged network. A similar interworking function pair at the other end of the TSN sub-network would restore the packet to its original Layer-2 destination MAC address and VLAN." Similar structure and changes as in IP over TSN . Service protection interworking is out - of - scope . d275ba154e2b7c82eb3ec9175d790214b0e60d3f d275ba154e2b7c82eb3ec9175d790214b0e60d3f draft-ietf-detnet-mpls-over-tsn ae74a9a2a182dd5a01fd950e728caccd2600bef5390e5cc261e81037cf194a98 ['630a7b3cd3eda2e026f158d16d3e4a4a2526a07124cf77aa8ed446ea760814d8', 'b03fd845058850bbf1a630e8c83fada6cba78982283c708236fd7388ffe9fc67', 'c47c152ac014e9bd75ed634d3b9e1c8bb57391b003cba836041c95b95a4c7fa1', 'c69a0fa2ea5f12373344fafbdd44dfb7bb6dbc1860b1c5990feae2a465de298d', '8a1dbabe711db86a26396c01597c528f5fcffb20f047620d5a97dc7303789634', 'e8ac6be9503fe785fadef60b06035db9bcfe02fde1de69193d9a4125a1399c60', '6a32f9bd776a29b7ce3eec373de6fa66bfd90fce56bad4e4eed60abba5aca087', '42f5214bb177fd7faf01b7943e7f313a615b2490f9109d5cefa8b24101735c32', '214810fe3ac0ef76db60e2d0623a8259b9bdf49040882a9e710901fe1eb32fde', '95e8b140a3153d24b8cc5b029501473ba4c08b0343d47a78892b1bad50321f66', 'c7011da30a42dd7b92a21132cfa295b31d66f42863c6a3414b5dbc0e9f38a1ce', 'ae45f508450dea10961ae41868df31a827a51caf984672ba7b53e43ba5e13140', '6808ff9c187a5808b263bc26ce9efc6509eedbd92aebf3bfa16a9ebbb5432f96', '3195c90c03cf6a438b5684cc93128c53f794660a661e2aa85d043ca5ac7060b9', '0246ffa7291c42bc165b0ac6acf1fc7285b5e41537731f44da530521ca5615d1', 'b5bacf05f766e143f6de9484b0b5a2d9655d62854368373bd77974b94cb722e6', '85d25c76743ed7e65b601d54f78150e74c3aa10e4c1b0b383304ba7887314a95', 'ae74a9a2a182dd5a01fd950e728caccd2600bef5390e5cc261e81037cf194a98', 'b94a431eeccea467fb994ae14c1161601ffad908f6fa54e35fd5f89256dacdea', '7ac09938faf2d97ce8bcc3b64b905bb5a585aeb30156506ee7abe2cd36825ed9', '601ac7ed7c06e522c784e0c0c3a976bc1cc9cccb10f550ee9cd153fa5cb3dcdc', '33a143d8274548ab7377f45f1204f1945e0cf20210af64fed99ac8028f48bac4', '1094721b24c22ff67539ffeabab887f87e538bdd9ebe50b0b369de138d326802', '19ad685cffba6309346c1ba7d6f642f0e69af09509b4f36f7ed87231855721a9', 'f34d1af51d3831ee49ed7f59e7135f955e977a1b93bb875be4c690b33a62450b', 'c53eb2c4fe199217644e8f623baca54cd8f18d0cf2746bad70b055d75f0faa23', '314017bb601d7806be2da63e51d3ee14147fa3ac35c6b85ba05825de7c5de742', '39820f7cb577ca0dcfb1bfa578ae13c25334acae03e89731064b0e3c300841de', '3703b0838ce47d992f259e22b20012a302240311d21f2d269cbb1414baec967f', '2605eb6691e33e75449ea67b2cc57cb2055976b481376bd77f71a937e30c3973', '8577e49f249e444a03b30a1f6f901d73d9fffc14ead45f0d56e8d2ff59c3301f', '8c5ca97b799230d82bd3e52e11118044d85a9f0dbf4f81934f31963b8f59d50c', 'ffe5de17213aa105e92776fd207a82f0ccefc1aa38407bb124b44f049f3dd1b8', '61b71fad4b4a688fc63731cab0845c3423c6935ea6d5c188047fbf047ef3a426', 'a491df768673d76ae7dee4c9bf1ea1456e6c537a1f1683368d8bc6869cd89bf0', '72c5a1f410983619d643ec9b1744e623d17c7eea2f68ac99d1881079601873cd', '139b8c43623bbe83d6e84c494389cef4e57e6816c2829cf9bcbb604af1f3bd70', '6de184d7411efde0440a2390c1009b5c1a251195a5c8bb05f6d64de2066a6d83', '7b6435e5d1cd5f5ef5156a6cb776bff4f493bdb11beead1f071fe87b93e78906', 'c5d808132e397aef8874ae2c056109762978e6c0fb6eee327f28541bd3886a04'] B "tsn capabilities of the tsn sub-network are made available for mpls (detnet) flows via the protocol interworking function defined in ieee8021cb. for example, applied on the tsn edge port it can convert an ingress unicast mpls (detnet) flow to use a specific layer-2 multicast destination mac address and a vlan, in order to direct the packet through a specific path inside the bridged network. a similar interworking function pair at the other end of the tsn sub-network would restore the packet to its original layer-2 destination mac address and vlan." {51: 1, 97: 1, 96: 1, 24: 1, 130: 1, 53: 1, 6: 2, 79: 2, 90: 2, 62: 3, 85: 4, 68: 4, 35: 3, 110: 2, 91: 4, 114: 2, 31: 3, 13: 2, 67: 2, 38: 3, 26: 2, 124: 3, 98: 2, 54: 2, 127: 3, 8: 2, 64: 2, 30: 2, 61: 4, 55: 3, 27: 3, 15: 2, 129: 3, 115: 2, 84: 2, 76: 6, 52: 2, 87: 2, 131: 5, 102: 2, 113: 4, 99: 2, 36: 2, 72: 3} {15: 1, 27: 1, 64: 1, 116: 1, 123: 1, 354: 1, 387: 1, 300: 1, 270: 1, 304: 1, 335: 1, 369: 1, 1: 9, 4: 2, 9: 5, 10: 3, 24: 2, 25: 3, 26: 4, 39: 5, 43: 3, 49: 5, 50: 4, 58: 4, 59: 2, 69: 4, 81: 4, 82: 2, 86: 2, 96: 3, 97: 2, 100: 5, 108: 3, 109: 4, 110: 4, 111: 2, 114: 3, 115: 4, 118: 6, 119: 5, 120: 3, 121: 4, 122: 2, 124: 4, 128: 3, 129: 2, 130: 4, 132: 4, 136: 2, 145: 4, 147: 3, 151: 3, 152: 3, 154: 3, 161: 3, 162: 3, 165: 3, 168: 4, 169: 2, 172: 2, 180: 3, 184: 5, 187: 5, 188: 4, 191: 3, 194: 4, 202: 5, 203: 6, 206: 2, 207: 3, 215: 2, 217: 3, 218: 8, 220: 2, 221: 2, 222: 5, 224: 3, 227: 3, 229: 2, 234: 5, 235: 2, 241: 2, 242: 2, 243: 4, 244: 3, 245: 4, 248: 3, 250: 2, 258: 11, 262: 4, 263: 5, 264: 3, 267: 4, 272: 2, 273: 5, 287: 3, 289: 2, 291: 4, 299: 3, 309: 3, 314: 2, 315: 2, 320: 4, 323: 4, 327: 4, 328: 3, 329: 2, 330: 10, 334: 2, 341: 3, 342: 4, 347: 3, 348: 3, 350: 7, 351: 4, 352: 2, 353: 2, 358: 4, 365: 2, 366: 2, 371: 5, 372: 4, 376: 2, 384: 4, 385: 3, 386: 3, 392: 3, 393: 4, 396: 4, 397: 7, 398: 6, 402: 2} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 52 "Placement of TSN functions depends on the TSN capabilities of nodes. MPLS (DetNet) Nodes may or may not support TSN functions. For a given TSN Stream (i.e., DetNet flow) an MPLS (DetNet) node is treated as a Talker or a Listener inside the TSN sub-network." Similar structure and changes as in IP over TSN . Service protection interworking is out - of - scope . d275ba154e2b7c82eb3ec9175d790214b0e60d3f d275ba154e2b7c82eb3ec9175d790214b0e60d3f draft-ietf-detnet-mpls-over-tsn 3703b0838ce47d992f259e22b20012a302240311d21f2d269cbb1414baec967f ['630a7b3cd3eda2e026f158d16d3e4a4a2526a07124cf77aa8ed446ea760814d8', 'b03fd845058850bbf1a630e8c83fada6cba78982283c708236fd7388ffe9fc67', 'c47c152ac014e9bd75ed634d3b9e1c8bb57391b003cba836041c95b95a4c7fa1', 'c69a0fa2ea5f12373344fafbdd44dfb7bb6dbc1860b1c5990feae2a465de298d', '8a1dbabe711db86a26396c01597c528f5fcffb20f047620d5a97dc7303789634', 'e8ac6be9503fe785fadef60b06035db9bcfe02fde1de69193d9a4125a1399c60', '6a32f9bd776a29b7ce3eec373de6fa66bfd90fce56bad4e4eed60abba5aca087', '42f5214bb177fd7faf01b7943e7f313a615b2490f9109d5cefa8b24101735c32', '214810fe3ac0ef76db60e2d0623a8259b9bdf49040882a9e710901fe1eb32fde', '95e8b140a3153d24b8cc5b029501473ba4c08b0343d47a78892b1bad50321f66', 'c7011da30a42dd7b92a21132cfa295b31d66f42863c6a3414b5dbc0e9f38a1ce', 'ae45f508450dea10961ae41868df31a827a51caf984672ba7b53e43ba5e13140', '6808ff9c187a5808b263bc26ce9efc6509eedbd92aebf3bfa16a9ebbb5432f96', '3195c90c03cf6a438b5684cc93128c53f794660a661e2aa85d043ca5ac7060b9', '0246ffa7291c42bc165b0ac6acf1fc7285b5e41537731f44da530521ca5615d1', 'b5bacf05f766e143f6de9484b0b5a2d9655d62854368373bd77974b94cb722e6', '85d25c76743ed7e65b601d54f78150e74c3aa10e4c1b0b383304ba7887314a95', 'ae74a9a2a182dd5a01fd950e728caccd2600bef5390e5cc261e81037cf194a98', 'b94a431eeccea467fb994ae14c1161601ffad908f6fa54e35fd5f89256dacdea', '7ac09938faf2d97ce8bcc3b64b905bb5a585aeb30156506ee7abe2cd36825ed9', '601ac7ed7c06e522c784e0c0c3a976bc1cc9cccb10f550ee9cd153fa5cb3dcdc', '33a143d8274548ab7377f45f1204f1945e0cf20210af64fed99ac8028f48bac4', '1094721b24c22ff67539ffeabab887f87e538bdd9ebe50b0b369de138d326802', '19ad685cffba6309346c1ba7d6f642f0e69af09509b4f36f7ed87231855721a9', 'f34d1af51d3831ee49ed7f59e7135f955e977a1b93bb875be4c690b33a62450b', 'c53eb2c4fe199217644e8f623baca54cd8f18d0cf2746bad70b055d75f0faa23', '314017bb601d7806be2da63e51d3ee14147fa3ac35c6b85ba05825de7c5de742', '39820f7cb577ca0dcfb1bfa578ae13c25334acae03e89731064b0e3c300841de', '3703b0838ce47d992f259e22b20012a302240311d21f2d269cbb1414baec967f', '2605eb6691e33e75449ea67b2cc57cb2055976b481376bd77f71a937e30c3973', '8577e49f249e444a03b30a1f6f901d73d9fffc14ead45f0d56e8d2ff59c3301f', '8c5ca97b799230d82bd3e52e11118044d85a9f0dbf4f81934f31963b8f59d50c', 'ffe5de17213aa105e92776fd207a82f0ccefc1aa38407bb124b44f049f3dd1b8', '61b71fad4b4a688fc63731cab0845c3423c6935ea6d5c188047fbf047ef3a426', 'a491df768673d76ae7dee4c9bf1ea1456e6c537a1f1683368d8bc6869cd89bf0', '72c5a1f410983619d643ec9b1744e623d17c7eea2f68ac99d1881079601873cd', '139b8c43623bbe83d6e84c494389cef4e57e6816c2829cf9bcbb604af1f3bd70', '6de184d7411efde0440a2390c1009b5c1a251195a5c8bb05f6d64de2066a6d83', '7b6435e5d1cd5f5ef5156a6cb776bff4f493bdb11beead1f071fe87b93e78906', 'c5d808132e397aef8874ae2c056109762978e6c0fb6eee327f28541bd3886a04'] B "placement of tsn functions depends on the tsn capabilities of nodes. mpls (detnet) nodes may or may not support tsn functions. for a given tsn stream (i.e., detnet flow) an mpls (detnet) node is treated as a talker or a listener inside the tsn sub-network." {51: 1, 97: 1, 96: 1, 24: 1, 130: 1, 53: 1, 6: 2, 79: 2, 90: 2, 62: 3, 85: 4, 68: 4, 35: 3, 110: 2, 91: 4, 114: 2, 31: 3, 13: 2, 67: 2, 38: 3, 26: 2, 124: 3, 98: 2, 54: 2, 127: 3, 8: 2, 64: 2, 30: 2, 61: 4, 55: 3, 27: 3, 15: 2, 129: 3, 115: 2, 84: 2, 76: 6, 52: 2, 87: 2, 131: 5, 102: 2, 113: 4, 99: 2, 36: 2, 72: 3} {15: 1, 27: 1, 64: 1, 116: 1, 123: 1, 354: 1, 387: 1, 300: 1, 270: 1, 304: 1, 335: 1, 369: 1, 1: 9, 4: 2, 9: 5, 10: 3, 24: 2, 25: 3, 26: 4, 39: 5, 43: 3, 49: 5, 50: 4, 58: 4, 59: 2, 69: 4, 81: 4, 82: 2, 86: 2, 96: 3, 97: 2, 100: 5, 108: 3, 109: 4, 110: 4, 111: 2, 114: 3, 115: 4, 118: 6, 119: 5, 120: 3, 121: 4, 122: 2, 124: 4, 128: 3, 129: 2, 130: 4, 132: 4, 136: 2, 145: 4, 147: 3, 151: 3, 152: 3, 154: 3, 161: 3, 162: 3, 165: 3, 168: 4, 169: 2, 172: 2, 180: 3, 184: 5, 187: 5, 188: 4, 191: 3, 194: 4, 202: 5, 203: 6, 206: 2, 207: 3, 215: 2, 217: 3, 218: 8, 220: 2, 221: 2, 222: 5, 224: 3, 227: 3, 229: 2, 234: 5, 235: 2, 241: 2, 242: 2, 243: 4, 244: 3, 245: 4, 248: 3, 250: 2, 258: 11, 262: 4, 263: 5, 264: 3, 267: 4, 272: 2, 273: 5, 287: 3, 289: 2, 291: 4, 299: 3, 309: 3, 314: 2, 315: 2, 320: 4, 323: 4, 327: 4, 328: 3, 329: 2, 330: 10, 334: 2, 341: 3, 342: 4, 347: 3, 348: 3, 350: 7, 351: 4, 352: 2, 353: 2, 358: 4, 365: 2, 366: 2, 371: 5, 372: 4, 376: 2, 384: 4, 385: 3, 386: 3, 392: 3, 393: 4, 396: 4, 397: 7, 398: 6, 402: 2} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 52 "Mapping of a DetNet MPLS flow to a TSN Stream is provided via the combination of a passive and an active stream identification function that operate at the frame level. The passive stream identification function is used to catch the MPLS label(s) of a DetNet MPLS flow and the active stream identification function is used to modify the Ethernet header according to the ID of the mapped TSN Stream." Similar structure and changes as in IP over TSN . Service protection interworking is out - of - scope . d275ba154e2b7c82eb3ec9175d790214b0e60d3f d275ba154e2b7c82eb3ec9175d790214b0e60d3f draft-ietf-detnet-mpls-over-tsn 61b71fad4b4a688fc63731cab0845c3423c6935ea6d5c188047fbf047ef3a426 ['630a7b3cd3eda2e026f158d16d3e4a4a2526a07124cf77aa8ed446ea760814d8', 'b03fd845058850bbf1a630e8c83fada6cba78982283c708236fd7388ffe9fc67', 'c47c152ac014e9bd75ed634d3b9e1c8bb57391b003cba836041c95b95a4c7fa1', 'c69a0fa2ea5f12373344fafbdd44dfb7bb6dbc1860b1c5990feae2a465de298d', '8a1dbabe711db86a26396c01597c528f5fcffb20f047620d5a97dc7303789634', 'e8ac6be9503fe785fadef60b06035db9bcfe02fde1de69193d9a4125a1399c60', '6a32f9bd776a29b7ce3eec373de6fa66bfd90fce56bad4e4eed60abba5aca087', '42f5214bb177fd7faf01b7943e7f313a615b2490f9109d5cefa8b24101735c32', '214810fe3ac0ef76db60e2d0623a8259b9bdf49040882a9e710901fe1eb32fde', '95e8b140a3153d24b8cc5b029501473ba4c08b0343d47a78892b1bad50321f66', 'c7011da30a42dd7b92a21132cfa295b31d66f42863c6a3414b5dbc0e9f38a1ce', 'ae45f508450dea10961ae41868df31a827a51caf984672ba7b53e43ba5e13140', '6808ff9c187a5808b263bc26ce9efc6509eedbd92aebf3bfa16a9ebbb5432f96', '3195c90c03cf6a438b5684cc93128c53f794660a661e2aa85d043ca5ac7060b9', '0246ffa7291c42bc165b0ac6acf1fc7285b5e41537731f44da530521ca5615d1', 'b5bacf05f766e143f6de9484b0b5a2d9655d62854368373bd77974b94cb722e6', '85d25c76743ed7e65b601d54f78150e74c3aa10e4c1b0b383304ba7887314a95', 'ae74a9a2a182dd5a01fd950e728caccd2600bef5390e5cc261e81037cf194a98', 'b94a431eeccea467fb994ae14c1161601ffad908f6fa54e35fd5f89256dacdea', '7ac09938faf2d97ce8bcc3b64b905bb5a585aeb30156506ee7abe2cd36825ed9', '601ac7ed7c06e522c784e0c0c3a976bc1cc9cccb10f550ee9cd153fa5cb3dcdc', '33a143d8274548ab7377f45f1204f1945e0cf20210af64fed99ac8028f48bac4', '1094721b24c22ff67539ffeabab887f87e538bdd9ebe50b0b369de138d326802', '19ad685cffba6309346c1ba7d6f642f0e69af09509b4f36f7ed87231855721a9', 'f34d1af51d3831ee49ed7f59e7135f955e977a1b93bb875be4c690b33a62450b', 'c53eb2c4fe199217644e8f623baca54cd8f18d0cf2746bad70b055d75f0faa23', '314017bb601d7806be2da63e51d3ee14147fa3ac35c6b85ba05825de7c5de742', '39820f7cb577ca0dcfb1bfa578ae13c25334acae03e89731064b0e3c300841de', '3703b0838ce47d992f259e22b20012a302240311d21f2d269cbb1414baec967f', '2605eb6691e33e75449ea67b2cc57cb2055976b481376bd77f71a937e30c3973', '8577e49f249e444a03b30a1f6f901d73d9fffc14ead45f0d56e8d2ff59c3301f', '8c5ca97b799230d82bd3e52e11118044d85a9f0dbf4f81934f31963b8f59d50c', 'ffe5de17213aa105e92776fd207a82f0ccefc1aa38407bb124b44f049f3dd1b8', '61b71fad4b4a688fc63731cab0845c3423c6935ea6d5c188047fbf047ef3a426', 'a491df768673d76ae7dee4c9bf1ea1456e6c537a1f1683368d8bc6869cd89bf0', '72c5a1f410983619d643ec9b1744e623d17c7eea2f68ac99d1881079601873cd', '139b8c43623bbe83d6e84c494389cef4e57e6816c2829cf9bcbb604af1f3bd70', '6de184d7411efde0440a2390c1009b5c1a251195a5c8bb05f6d64de2066a6d83', '7b6435e5d1cd5f5ef5156a6cb776bff4f493bdb11beead1f071fe87b93e78906', 'c5d808132e397aef8874ae2c056109762978e6c0fb6eee327f28541bd3886a04'] B "mapping of a detnet mpls flow to a tsn stream is provided via the combination of a passive and an active stream identification function that operate at the frame level. the passive stream identification function is used to catch the mpls label(s) of a detnet mpls flow and the active stream identification function is used to modify the ethernet header according to the id of the mapped tsn stream." {51: 1, 97: 1, 96: 1, 24: 1, 130: 1, 53: 1, 6: 2, 79: 2, 90: 2, 62: 3, 85: 4, 68: 4, 35: 3, 110: 2, 91: 4, 114: 2, 31: 3, 13: 2, 67: 2, 38: 3, 26: 2, 124: 3, 98: 2, 54: 2, 127: 3, 8: 2, 64: 2, 30: 2, 61: 4, 55: 3, 27: 3, 15: 2, 129: 3, 115: 2, 84: 2, 76: 6, 52: 2, 87: 2, 131: 5, 102: 2, 113: 4, 99: 2, 36: 2, 72: 3} {15: 1, 27: 1, 64: 1, 116: 1, 123: 1, 354: 1, 387: 1, 300: 1, 270: 1, 304: 1, 335: 1, 369: 1, 1: 9, 4: 2, 9: 5, 10: 3, 24: 2, 25: 3, 26: 4, 39: 5, 43: 3, 49: 5, 50: 4, 58: 4, 59: 2, 69: 4, 81: 4, 82: 2, 86: 2, 96: 3, 97: 2, 100: 5, 108: 3, 109: 4, 110: 4, 111: 2, 114: 3, 115: 4, 118: 6, 119: 5, 120: 3, 121: 4, 122: 2, 124: 4, 128: 3, 129: 2, 130: 4, 132: 4, 136: 2, 145: 4, 147: 3, 151: 3, 152: 3, 154: 3, 161: 3, 162: 3, 165: 3, 168: 4, 169: 2, 172: 2, 180: 3, 184: 5, 187: 5, 188: 4, 191: 3, 194: 4, 202: 5, 203: 6, 206: 2, 207: 3, 215: 2, 217: 3, 218: 8, 220: 2, 221: 2, 222: 5, 224: 3, 227: 3, 229: 2, 234: 5, 235: 2, 241: 2, 242: 2, 243: 4, 244: 3, 245: 4, 248: 3, 250: 2, 258: 11, 262: 4, 263: 5, 264: 3, 267: 4, 272: 2, 273: 5, 287: 3, 289: 2, 291: 4, 299: 3, 309: 3, 314: 2, 315: 2, 320: 4, 323: 4, 327: 4, 328: 3, 329: 2, 330: 10, 334: 2, 341: 3, 342: 4, 347: 3, 348: 3, 350: 7, 351: 4, 352: 2, 353: 2, 358: 4, 365: 2, 366: 2, 371: 5, 372: 4, 376: 2, 384: 4, 385: 3, 386: 3, 392: 3, 393: 4, 396: 4, 397: 7, 398: 6, 402: 2} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 52 "IEEEP8021CBdb defines a Mask-and-Match Stream identification function that can be used as a passive function for MPLS DetNet flows." Similar structure and changes as in IP over TSN . Service protection interworking is out - of - scope . d275ba154e2b7c82eb3ec9175d790214b0e60d3f d275ba154e2b7c82eb3ec9175d790214b0e60d3f draft-ietf-detnet-mpls-over-tsn 85d25c76743ed7e65b601d54f78150e74c3aa10e4c1b0b383304ba7887314a95 ['630a7b3cd3eda2e026f158d16d3e4a4a2526a07124cf77aa8ed446ea760814d8', 'b03fd845058850bbf1a630e8c83fada6cba78982283c708236fd7388ffe9fc67', 'c47c152ac014e9bd75ed634d3b9e1c8bb57391b003cba836041c95b95a4c7fa1', 'c69a0fa2ea5f12373344fafbdd44dfb7bb6dbc1860b1c5990feae2a465de298d', '8a1dbabe711db86a26396c01597c528f5fcffb20f047620d5a97dc7303789634', 'e8ac6be9503fe785fadef60b06035db9bcfe02fde1de69193d9a4125a1399c60', '6a32f9bd776a29b7ce3eec373de6fa66bfd90fce56bad4e4eed60abba5aca087', '42f5214bb177fd7faf01b7943e7f313a615b2490f9109d5cefa8b24101735c32', '214810fe3ac0ef76db60e2d0623a8259b9bdf49040882a9e710901fe1eb32fde', '95e8b140a3153d24b8cc5b029501473ba4c08b0343d47a78892b1bad50321f66', 'c7011da30a42dd7b92a21132cfa295b31d66f42863c6a3414b5dbc0e9f38a1ce', 'ae45f508450dea10961ae41868df31a827a51caf984672ba7b53e43ba5e13140', '6808ff9c187a5808b263bc26ce9efc6509eedbd92aebf3bfa16a9ebbb5432f96', '3195c90c03cf6a438b5684cc93128c53f794660a661e2aa85d043ca5ac7060b9', '0246ffa7291c42bc165b0ac6acf1fc7285b5e41537731f44da530521ca5615d1', 'b5bacf05f766e143f6de9484b0b5a2d9655d62854368373bd77974b94cb722e6', '85d25c76743ed7e65b601d54f78150e74c3aa10e4c1b0b383304ba7887314a95', 'ae74a9a2a182dd5a01fd950e728caccd2600bef5390e5cc261e81037cf194a98', 'b94a431eeccea467fb994ae14c1161601ffad908f6fa54e35fd5f89256dacdea', '7ac09938faf2d97ce8bcc3b64b905bb5a585aeb30156506ee7abe2cd36825ed9', '601ac7ed7c06e522c784e0c0c3a976bc1cc9cccb10f550ee9cd153fa5cb3dcdc', '33a143d8274548ab7377f45f1204f1945e0cf20210af64fed99ac8028f48bac4', '1094721b24c22ff67539ffeabab887f87e538bdd9ebe50b0b369de138d326802', '19ad685cffba6309346c1ba7d6f642f0e69af09509b4f36f7ed87231855721a9', 'f34d1af51d3831ee49ed7f59e7135f955e977a1b93bb875be4c690b33a62450b', 'c53eb2c4fe199217644e8f623baca54cd8f18d0cf2746bad70b055d75f0faa23', '314017bb601d7806be2da63e51d3ee14147fa3ac35c6b85ba05825de7c5de742', '39820f7cb577ca0dcfb1bfa578ae13c25334acae03e89731064b0e3c300841de', '3703b0838ce47d992f259e22b20012a302240311d21f2d269cbb1414baec967f', '2605eb6691e33e75449ea67b2cc57cb2055976b481376bd77f71a937e30c3973', '8577e49f249e444a03b30a1f6f901d73d9fffc14ead45f0d56e8d2ff59c3301f', '8c5ca97b799230d82bd3e52e11118044d85a9f0dbf4f81934f31963b8f59d50c', 'ffe5de17213aa105e92776fd207a82f0ccefc1aa38407bb124b44f049f3dd1b8', '61b71fad4b4a688fc63731cab0845c3423c6935ea6d5c188047fbf047ef3a426', 'a491df768673d76ae7dee4c9bf1ea1456e6c537a1f1683368d8bc6869cd89bf0', '72c5a1f410983619d643ec9b1744e623d17c7eea2f68ac99d1881079601873cd', '139b8c43623bbe83d6e84c494389cef4e57e6816c2829cf9bcbb604af1f3bd70', '6de184d7411efde0440a2390c1009b5c1a251195a5c8bb05f6d64de2066a6d83', '7b6435e5d1cd5f5ef5156a6cb776bff4f493bdb11beead1f071fe87b93e78906', 'c5d808132e397aef8874ae2c056109762978e6c0fb6eee327f28541bd3886a04'] B "ieeep8021cbdb defines a mask-and-match stream identification function that can be used as a passive function for mpls detnet flows." {51: 1, 97: 1, 96: 1, 24: 1, 130: 1, 53: 1, 6: 2, 79: 2, 90: 2, 62: 3, 85: 4, 68: 4, 35: 3, 110: 2, 91: 4, 114: 2, 31: 3, 13: 2, 67: 2, 38: 3, 26: 2, 124: 3, 98: 2, 54: 2, 127: 3, 8: 2, 64: 2, 30: 2, 61: 4, 55: 3, 27: 3, 15: 2, 129: 3, 115: 2, 84: 2, 76: 6, 52: 2, 87: 2, 131: 5, 102: 2, 113: 4, 99: 2, 36: 2, 72: 3} {15: 1, 27: 1, 64: 1, 116: 1, 123: 1, 354: 1, 387: 1, 300: 1, 270: 1, 304: 1, 335: 1, 369: 1, 1: 9, 4: 2, 9: 5, 10: 3, 24: 2, 25: 3, 26: 4, 39: 5, 43: 3, 49: 5, 50: 4, 58: 4, 59: 2, 69: 4, 81: 4, 82: 2, 86: 2, 96: 3, 97: 2, 100: 5, 108: 3, 109: 4, 110: 4, 111: 2, 114: 3, 115: 4, 118: 6, 119: 5, 120: 3, 121: 4, 122: 2, 124: 4, 128: 3, 129: 2, 130: 4, 132: 4, 136: 2, 145: 4, 147: 3, 151: 3, 152: 3, 154: 3, 161: 3, 162: 3, 165: 3, 168: 4, 169: 2, 172: 2, 180: 3, 184: 5, 187: 5, 188: 4, 191: 3, 194: 4, 202: 5, 203: 6, 206: 2, 207: 3, 215: 2, 217: 3, 218: 8, 220: 2, 221: 2, 222: 5, 224: 3, 227: 3, 229: 2, 234: 5, 235: 2, 241: 2, 242: 2, 243: 4, 244: 3, 245: 4, 248: 3, 250: 2, 258: 11, 262: 4, 263: 5, 264: 3, 267: 4, 272: 2, 273: 5, 287: 3, 289: 2, 291: 4, 299: 3, 309: 3, 314: 2, 315: 2, 320: 4, 323: 4, 327: 4, 328: 3, 329: 2, 330: 10, 334: 2, 341: 3, 342: 4, 347: 3, 348: 3, 350: 7, 351: 4, 352: 2, 353: 2, 358: 4, 365: 2, 366: 2, 371: 5, 372: 4, 376: 2, 384: 4, 385: 3, 386: 3, 392: 3, 393: 4, 396: 4, 397: 7, 398: 6, 402: 2} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 52 "IEEE8021CB defines an Active Destination MAC and VLAN Stream identification function, what can replace some Ethernet header fields namely (1) the destination MAC-address, (2) the VLAN-ID and (3) priority parameters with alternate values. Replacement is provided for the frame passed down the stack from the upper layers or up the stack from the lower layers." Similar structure and changes as in IP over TSN . Service protection interworking is out - of - scope . d275ba154e2b7c82eb3ec9175d790214b0e60d3f d275ba154e2b7c82eb3ec9175d790214b0e60d3f draft-ietf-detnet-mpls-over-tsn 630a7b3cd3eda2e026f158d16d3e4a4a2526a07124cf77aa8ed446ea760814d8 ['630a7b3cd3eda2e026f158d16d3e4a4a2526a07124cf77aa8ed446ea760814d8', 'b03fd845058850bbf1a630e8c83fada6cba78982283c708236fd7388ffe9fc67', 'c47c152ac014e9bd75ed634d3b9e1c8bb57391b003cba836041c95b95a4c7fa1', 'c69a0fa2ea5f12373344fafbdd44dfb7bb6dbc1860b1c5990feae2a465de298d', '8a1dbabe711db86a26396c01597c528f5fcffb20f047620d5a97dc7303789634', 'e8ac6be9503fe785fadef60b06035db9bcfe02fde1de69193d9a4125a1399c60', '6a32f9bd776a29b7ce3eec373de6fa66bfd90fce56bad4e4eed60abba5aca087', '42f5214bb177fd7faf01b7943e7f313a615b2490f9109d5cefa8b24101735c32', '214810fe3ac0ef76db60e2d0623a8259b9bdf49040882a9e710901fe1eb32fde', '95e8b140a3153d24b8cc5b029501473ba4c08b0343d47a78892b1bad50321f66', 'c7011da30a42dd7b92a21132cfa295b31d66f42863c6a3414b5dbc0e9f38a1ce', 'ae45f508450dea10961ae41868df31a827a51caf984672ba7b53e43ba5e13140', '6808ff9c187a5808b263bc26ce9efc6509eedbd92aebf3bfa16a9ebbb5432f96', '3195c90c03cf6a438b5684cc93128c53f794660a661e2aa85d043ca5ac7060b9', '0246ffa7291c42bc165b0ac6acf1fc7285b5e41537731f44da530521ca5615d1', 'b5bacf05f766e143f6de9484b0b5a2d9655d62854368373bd77974b94cb722e6', '85d25c76743ed7e65b601d54f78150e74c3aa10e4c1b0b383304ba7887314a95', 'ae74a9a2a182dd5a01fd950e728caccd2600bef5390e5cc261e81037cf194a98', 'b94a431eeccea467fb994ae14c1161601ffad908f6fa54e35fd5f89256dacdea', '7ac09938faf2d97ce8bcc3b64b905bb5a585aeb30156506ee7abe2cd36825ed9', '601ac7ed7c06e522c784e0c0c3a976bc1cc9cccb10f550ee9cd153fa5cb3dcdc', '33a143d8274548ab7377f45f1204f1945e0cf20210af64fed99ac8028f48bac4', '1094721b24c22ff67539ffeabab887f87e538bdd9ebe50b0b369de138d326802', '19ad685cffba6309346c1ba7d6f642f0e69af09509b4f36f7ed87231855721a9', 'f34d1af51d3831ee49ed7f59e7135f955e977a1b93bb875be4c690b33a62450b', 'c53eb2c4fe199217644e8f623baca54cd8f18d0cf2746bad70b055d75f0faa23', '314017bb601d7806be2da63e51d3ee14147fa3ac35c6b85ba05825de7c5de742', '39820f7cb577ca0dcfb1bfa578ae13c25334acae03e89731064b0e3c300841de', '3703b0838ce47d992f259e22b20012a302240311d21f2d269cbb1414baec967f', '2605eb6691e33e75449ea67b2cc57cb2055976b481376bd77f71a937e30c3973', '8577e49f249e444a03b30a1f6f901d73d9fffc14ead45f0d56e8d2ff59c3301f', '8c5ca97b799230d82bd3e52e11118044d85a9f0dbf4f81934f31963b8f59d50c', 'ffe5de17213aa105e92776fd207a82f0ccefc1aa38407bb124b44f049f3dd1b8', '61b71fad4b4a688fc63731cab0845c3423c6935ea6d5c188047fbf047ef3a426', 'a491df768673d76ae7dee4c9bf1ea1456e6c537a1f1683368d8bc6869cd89bf0', '72c5a1f410983619d643ec9b1744e623d17c7eea2f68ac99d1881079601873cd', '139b8c43623bbe83d6e84c494389cef4e57e6816c2829cf9bcbb604af1f3bd70', '6de184d7411efde0440a2390c1009b5c1a251195a5c8bb05f6d64de2066a6d83', '7b6435e5d1cd5f5ef5156a6cb776bff4f493bdb11beead1f071fe87b93e78906', 'c5d808132e397aef8874ae2c056109762978e6c0fb6eee327f28541bd3886a04'] B "ieee8021cb defines an active destination mac and vlan stream identification function, what can replace some ethernet header fields namely (1) the destination mac-address, (2) the vlan-id and (3) priority parameters with alternate values. replacement is provided for the frame passed down the stack from the upper layers or up the stack from the lower layers." {51: 1, 97: 1, 96: 1, 24: 1, 130: 1, 53: 1, 6: 2, 79: 2, 90: 2, 62: 3, 85: 4, 68: 4, 35: 3, 110: 2, 91: 4, 114: 2, 31: 3, 13: 2, 67: 2, 38: 3, 26: 2, 124: 3, 98: 2, 54: 2, 127: 3, 8: 2, 64: 2, 30: 2, 61: 4, 55: 3, 27: 3, 15: 2, 129: 3, 115: 2, 84: 2, 76: 6, 52: 2, 87: 2, 131: 5, 102: 2, 113: 4, 99: 2, 36: 2, 72: 3} {15: 1, 27: 1, 64: 1, 116: 1, 123: 1, 354: 1, 387: 1, 300: 1, 270: 1, 304: 1, 335: 1, 369: 1, 1: 9, 4: 2, 9: 5, 10: 3, 24: 2, 25: 3, 26: 4, 39: 5, 43: 3, 49: 5, 50: 4, 58: 4, 59: 2, 69: 4, 81: 4, 82: 2, 86: 2, 96: 3, 97: 2, 100: 5, 108: 3, 109: 4, 110: 4, 111: 2, 114: 3, 115: 4, 118: 6, 119: 5, 120: 3, 121: 4, 122: 2, 124: 4, 128: 3, 129: 2, 130: 4, 132: 4, 136: 2, 145: 4, 147: 3, 151: 3, 152: 3, 154: 3, 161: 3, 162: 3, 165: 3, 168: 4, 169: 2, 172: 2, 180: 3, 184: 5, 187: 5, 188: 4, 191: 3, 194: 4, 202: 5, 203: 6, 206: 2, 207: 3, 215: 2, 217: 3, 218: 8, 220: 2, 221: 2, 222: 5, 224: 3, 227: 3, 229: 2, 234: 5, 235: 2, 241: 2, 242: 2, 243: 4, 244: 3, 245: 4, 248: 3, 250: 2, 258: 11, 262: 4, 263: 5, 264: 3, 267: 4, 272: 2, 273: 5, 287: 3, 289: 2, 291: 4, 299: 3, 309: 3, 314: 2, 315: 2, 320: 4, 323: 4, 327: 4, 328: 3, 329: 2, 330: 10, 334: 2, 341: 3, 342: 4, 347: 3, 348: 3, 350: 7, 351: 4, 352: 2, 353: 2, 358: 4, 365: 2, 366: 2, 371: 5, 372: 4, 376: 2, 384: 4, 385: 3, 386: 3, 392: 3, 393: 4, 396: 4, 397: 7, 398: 6, 402: 2} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 52 "Active Destination MAC and VLAN Stream identification can be used within a Talker to set flow identity or a Listener to recover the original addressing information. It can be used also in a TSN bridge that is providing translation as a proxy service for an End System." Similar structure and changes as in IP over TSN . Service protection interworking is out - of - scope . d275ba154e2b7c82eb3ec9175d790214b0e60d3f d275ba154e2b7c82eb3ec9175d790214b0e60d3f draft-ietf-detnet-mpls-over-tsn 7ac09938faf2d97ce8bcc3b64b905bb5a585aeb30156506ee7abe2cd36825ed9 ['630a7b3cd3eda2e026f158d16d3e4a4a2526a07124cf77aa8ed446ea760814d8', 'b03fd845058850bbf1a630e8c83fada6cba78982283c708236fd7388ffe9fc67', 'c47c152ac014e9bd75ed634d3b9e1c8bb57391b003cba836041c95b95a4c7fa1', 'c69a0fa2ea5f12373344fafbdd44dfb7bb6dbc1860b1c5990feae2a465de298d', '8a1dbabe711db86a26396c01597c528f5fcffb20f047620d5a97dc7303789634', 'e8ac6be9503fe785fadef60b06035db9bcfe02fde1de69193d9a4125a1399c60', '6a32f9bd776a29b7ce3eec373de6fa66bfd90fce56bad4e4eed60abba5aca087', '42f5214bb177fd7faf01b7943e7f313a615b2490f9109d5cefa8b24101735c32', '214810fe3ac0ef76db60e2d0623a8259b9bdf49040882a9e710901fe1eb32fde', '95e8b140a3153d24b8cc5b029501473ba4c08b0343d47a78892b1bad50321f66', 'c7011da30a42dd7b92a21132cfa295b31d66f42863c6a3414b5dbc0e9f38a1ce', 'ae45f508450dea10961ae41868df31a827a51caf984672ba7b53e43ba5e13140', '6808ff9c187a5808b263bc26ce9efc6509eedbd92aebf3bfa16a9ebbb5432f96', '3195c90c03cf6a438b5684cc93128c53f794660a661e2aa85d043ca5ac7060b9', '0246ffa7291c42bc165b0ac6acf1fc7285b5e41537731f44da530521ca5615d1', 'b5bacf05f766e143f6de9484b0b5a2d9655d62854368373bd77974b94cb722e6', '85d25c76743ed7e65b601d54f78150e74c3aa10e4c1b0b383304ba7887314a95', 'ae74a9a2a182dd5a01fd950e728caccd2600bef5390e5cc261e81037cf194a98', 'b94a431eeccea467fb994ae14c1161601ffad908f6fa54e35fd5f89256dacdea', '7ac09938faf2d97ce8bcc3b64b905bb5a585aeb30156506ee7abe2cd36825ed9', '601ac7ed7c06e522c784e0c0c3a976bc1cc9cccb10f550ee9cd153fa5cb3dcdc', '33a143d8274548ab7377f45f1204f1945e0cf20210af64fed99ac8028f48bac4', '1094721b24c22ff67539ffeabab887f87e538bdd9ebe50b0b369de138d326802', '19ad685cffba6309346c1ba7d6f642f0e69af09509b4f36f7ed87231855721a9', 'f34d1af51d3831ee49ed7f59e7135f955e977a1b93bb875be4c690b33a62450b', 'c53eb2c4fe199217644e8f623baca54cd8f18d0cf2746bad70b055d75f0faa23', '314017bb601d7806be2da63e51d3ee14147fa3ac35c6b85ba05825de7c5de742', '39820f7cb577ca0dcfb1bfa578ae13c25334acae03e89731064b0e3c300841de', '3703b0838ce47d992f259e22b20012a302240311d21f2d269cbb1414baec967f', '2605eb6691e33e75449ea67b2cc57cb2055976b481376bd77f71a937e30c3973', '8577e49f249e444a03b30a1f6f901d73d9fffc14ead45f0d56e8d2ff59c3301f', '8c5ca97b799230d82bd3e52e11118044d85a9f0dbf4f81934f31963b8f59d50c', 'ffe5de17213aa105e92776fd207a82f0ccefc1aa38407bb124b44f049f3dd1b8', '61b71fad4b4a688fc63731cab0845c3423c6935ea6d5c188047fbf047ef3a426', 'a491df768673d76ae7dee4c9bf1ea1456e6c537a1f1683368d8bc6869cd89bf0', '72c5a1f410983619d643ec9b1744e623d17c7eea2f68ac99d1881079601873cd', '139b8c43623bbe83d6e84c494389cef4e57e6816c2829cf9bcbb604af1f3bd70', '6de184d7411efde0440a2390c1009b5c1a251195a5c8bb05f6d64de2066a6d83', '7b6435e5d1cd5f5ef5156a6cb776bff4f493bdb11beead1f071fe87b93e78906', 'c5d808132e397aef8874ae2c056109762978e6c0fb6eee327f28541bd3886a04'] B "active destination mac and vlan stream identification can be used within a talker to set flow identity or a listener to recover the original addressing information. it can be used also in a tsn bridge that is providing translation as a proxy service for an end system." {51: 1, 97: 1, 96: 1, 24: 1, 130: 1, 53: 1, 6: 2, 79: 2, 90: 2, 62: 3, 85: 4, 68: 4, 35: 3, 110: 2, 91: 4, 114: 2, 31: 3, 13: 2, 67: 2, 38: 3, 26: 2, 124: 3, 98: 2, 54: 2, 127: 3, 8: 2, 64: 2, 30: 2, 61: 4, 55: 3, 27: 3, 15: 2, 129: 3, 115: 2, 84: 2, 76: 6, 52: 2, 87: 2, 131: 5, 102: 2, 113: 4, 99: 2, 36: 2, 72: 3} {15: 1, 27: 1, 64: 1, 116: 1, 123: 1, 354: 1, 387: 1, 300: 1, 270: 1, 304: 1, 335: 1, 369: 1, 1: 9, 4: 2, 9: 5, 10: 3, 24: 2, 25: 3, 26: 4, 39: 5, 43: 3, 49: 5, 50: 4, 58: 4, 59: 2, 69: 4, 81: 4, 82: 2, 86: 2, 96: 3, 97: 2, 100: 5, 108: 3, 109: 4, 110: 4, 111: 2, 114: 3, 115: 4, 118: 6, 119: 5, 120: 3, 121: 4, 122: 2, 124: 4, 128: 3, 129: 2, 130: 4, 132: 4, 136: 2, 145: 4, 147: 3, 151: 3, 152: 3, 154: 3, 161: 3, 162: 3, 165: 3, 168: 4, 169: 2, 172: 2, 180: 3, 184: 5, 187: 5, 188: 4, 191: 3, 194: 4, 202: 5, 203: 6, 206: 2, 207: 3, 215: 2, 217: 3, 218: 8, 220: 2, 221: 2, 222: 5, 224: 3, 227: 3, 229: 2, 234: 5, 235: 2, 241: 2, 242: 2, 243: 4, 244: 3, 245: 4, 248: 3, 250: 2, 258: 11, 262: 4, 263: 5, 264: 3, 267: 4, 272: 2, 273: 5, 287: 3, 289: 2, 291: 4, 299: 3, 309: 3, 314: 2, 315: 2, 320: 4, 323: 4, 327: 4, 328: 3, 329: 2, 330: 10, 334: 2, 341: 3, 342: 4, 347: 3, 348: 3, 350: 7, 351: 4, 352: 2, 353: 2, 358: 4, 365: 2, 366: 2, 371: 5, 372: 4, 376: 2, 384: 4, 385: 3, 386: 3, 392: 3, 393: 4, 396: 4, 397: 7, 398: 6, 402: 2} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 52 "This section covers required behavior of a TSN-aware MPLS (DetNet) node using a TSN sub-network." Similar structure and changes as in IP over TSN . Service protection interworking is out - of - scope . d275ba154e2b7c82eb3ec9175d790214b0e60d3f d275ba154e2b7c82eb3ec9175d790214b0e60d3f draft-ietf-detnet-mpls-over-tsn 314017bb601d7806be2da63e51d3ee14147fa3ac35c6b85ba05825de7c5de742 ['630a7b3cd3eda2e026f158d16d3e4a4a2526a07124cf77aa8ed446ea760814d8', 'b03fd845058850bbf1a630e8c83fada6cba78982283c708236fd7388ffe9fc67', 'c47c152ac014e9bd75ed634d3b9e1c8bb57391b003cba836041c95b95a4c7fa1', 'c69a0fa2ea5f12373344fafbdd44dfb7bb6dbc1860b1c5990feae2a465de298d', '8a1dbabe711db86a26396c01597c528f5fcffb20f047620d5a97dc7303789634', 'e8ac6be9503fe785fadef60b06035db9bcfe02fde1de69193d9a4125a1399c60', '6a32f9bd776a29b7ce3eec373de6fa66bfd90fce56bad4e4eed60abba5aca087', '42f5214bb177fd7faf01b7943e7f313a615b2490f9109d5cefa8b24101735c32', '214810fe3ac0ef76db60e2d0623a8259b9bdf49040882a9e710901fe1eb32fde', '95e8b140a3153d24b8cc5b029501473ba4c08b0343d47a78892b1bad50321f66', 'c7011da30a42dd7b92a21132cfa295b31d66f42863c6a3414b5dbc0e9f38a1ce', 'ae45f508450dea10961ae41868df31a827a51caf984672ba7b53e43ba5e13140', '6808ff9c187a5808b263bc26ce9efc6509eedbd92aebf3bfa16a9ebbb5432f96', '3195c90c03cf6a438b5684cc93128c53f794660a661e2aa85d043ca5ac7060b9', '0246ffa7291c42bc165b0ac6acf1fc7285b5e41537731f44da530521ca5615d1', 'b5bacf05f766e143f6de9484b0b5a2d9655d62854368373bd77974b94cb722e6', '85d25c76743ed7e65b601d54f78150e74c3aa10e4c1b0b383304ba7887314a95', 'ae74a9a2a182dd5a01fd950e728caccd2600bef5390e5cc261e81037cf194a98', 'b94a431eeccea467fb994ae14c1161601ffad908f6fa54e35fd5f89256dacdea', '7ac09938faf2d97ce8bcc3b64b905bb5a585aeb30156506ee7abe2cd36825ed9', '601ac7ed7c06e522c784e0c0c3a976bc1cc9cccb10f550ee9cd153fa5cb3dcdc', '33a143d8274548ab7377f45f1204f1945e0cf20210af64fed99ac8028f48bac4', '1094721b24c22ff67539ffeabab887f87e538bdd9ebe50b0b369de138d326802', '19ad685cffba6309346c1ba7d6f642f0e69af09509b4f36f7ed87231855721a9', 'f34d1af51d3831ee49ed7f59e7135f955e977a1b93bb875be4c690b33a62450b', 'c53eb2c4fe199217644e8f623baca54cd8f18d0cf2746bad70b055d75f0faa23', '314017bb601d7806be2da63e51d3ee14147fa3ac35c6b85ba05825de7c5de742', '39820f7cb577ca0dcfb1bfa578ae13c25334acae03e89731064b0e3c300841de', '3703b0838ce47d992f259e22b20012a302240311d21f2d269cbb1414baec967f', '2605eb6691e33e75449ea67b2cc57cb2055976b481376bd77f71a937e30c3973', '8577e49f249e444a03b30a1f6f901d73d9fffc14ead45f0d56e8d2ff59c3301f', '8c5ca97b799230d82bd3e52e11118044d85a9f0dbf4f81934f31963b8f59d50c', 'ffe5de17213aa105e92776fd207a82f0ccefc1aa38407bb124b44f049f3dd1b8', '61b71fad4b4a688fc63731cab0845c3423c6935ea6d5c188047fbf047ef3a426', 'a491df768673d76ae7dee4c9bf1ea1456e6c537a1f1683368d8bc6869cd89bf0', '72c5a1f410983619d643ec9b1744e623d17c7eea2f68ac99d1881079601873cd', '139b8c43623bbe83d6e84c494389cef4e57e6816c2829cf9bcbb604af1f3bd70', '6de184d7411efde0440a2390c1009b5c1a251195a5c8bb05f6d64de2066a6d83', '7b6435e5d1cd5f5ef5156a6cb776bff4f493bdb11beead1f071fe87b93e78906', 'c5d808132e397aef8874ae2c056109762978e6c0fb6eee327f28541bd3886a04'] B "this section covers required behavior of a tsn-aware mpls (detnet) node using a tsn sub-network." {51: 1, 97: 1, 96: 1, 24: 1, 130: 1, 53: 1, 6: 2, 79: 2, 90: 2, 62: 3, 85: 4, 68: 4, 35: 3, 110: 2, 91: 4, 114: 2, 31: 3, 13: 2, 67: 2, 38: 3, 26: 2, 124: 3, 98: 2, 54: 2, 127: 3, 8: 2, 64: 2, 30: 2, 61: 4, 55: 3, 27: 3, 15: 2, 129: 3, 115: 2, 84: 2, 76: 6, 52: 2, 87: 2, 131: 5, 102: 2, 113: 4, 99: 2, 36: 2, 72: 3} {15: 1, 27: 1, 64: 1, 116: 1, 123: 1, 354: 1, 387: 1, 300: 1, 270: 1, 304: 1, 335: 1, 369: 1, 1: 9, 4: 2, 9: 5, 10: 3, 24: 2, 25: 3, 26: 4, 39: 5, 43: 3, 49: 5, 50: 4, 58: 4, 59: 2, 69: 4, 81: 4, 82: 2, 86: 2, 96: 3, 97: 2, 100: 5, 108: 3, 109: 4, 110: 4, 111: 2, 114: 3, 115: 4, 118: 6, 119: 5, 120: 3, 121: 4, 122: 2, 124: 4, 128: 3, 129: 2, 130: 4, 132: 4, 136: 2, 145: 4, 147: 3, 151: 3, 152: 3, 154: 3, 161: 3, 162: 3, 165: 3, 168: 4, 169: 2, 172: 2, 180: 3, 184: 5, 187: 5, 188: 4, 191: 3, 194: 4, 202: 5, 203: 6, 206: 2, 207: 3, 215: 2, 217: 3, 218: 8, 220: 2, 221: 2, 222: 5, 224: 3, 227: 3, 229: 2, 234: 5, 235: 2, 241: 2, 242: 2, 243: 4, 244: 3, 245: 4, 248: 3, 250: 2, 258: 11, 262: 4, 263: 5, 264: 3, 267: 4, 272: 2, 273: 5, 287: 3, 289: 2, 291: 4, 299: 3, 309: 3, 314: 2, 315: 2, 320: 4, 323: 4, 327: 4, 328: 3, 329: 2, 330: 10, 334: 2, 341: 3, 342: 4, 347: 3, 348: 3, 350: 7, 351: 4, 352: 2, 353: 2, 358: 4, 365: 2, 366: 2, 371: 5, 372: 4, 376: 2, 384: 4, 385: 3, 386: 3, 392: 3, 393: 4, 396: 4, 397: 7, 398: 6, 402: 2} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 52 "From the TSN sub-network perspective MPLS (DetNet) nodes are treated as Talker or Listener, that may be (1) TSN-unaware or (2) TSN-aware." Similar structure and changes as in IP over TSN . Service protection interworking is out - of - scope . d275ba154e2b7c82eb3ec9175d790214b0e60d3f d275ba154e2b7c82eb3ec9175d790214b0e60d3f draft-ietf-detnet-mpls-over-tsn 2605eb6691e33e75449ea67b2cc57cb2055976b481376bd77f71a937e30c3973 ['630a7b3cd3eda2e026f158d16d3e4a4a2526a07124cf77aa8ed446ea760814d8', 'b03fd845058850bbf1a630e8c83fada6cba78982283c708236fd7388ffe9fc67', 'c47c152ac014e9bd75ed634d3b9e1c8bb57391b003cba836041c95b95a4c7fa1', 'c69a0fa2ea5f12373344fafbdd44dfb7bb6dbc1860b1c5990feae2a465de298d', '8a1dbabe711db86a26396c01597c528f5fcffb20f047620d5a97dc7303789634', 'e8ac6be9503fe785fadef60b06035db9bcfe02fde1de69193d9a4125a1399c60', '6a32f9bd776a29b7ce3eec373de6fa66bfd90fce56bad4e4eed60abba5aca087', '42f5214bb177fd7faf01b7943e7f313a615b2490f9109d5cefa8b24101735c32', '214810fe3ac0ef76db60e2d0623a8259b9bdf49040882a9e710901fe1eb32fde', '95e8b140a3153d24b8cc5b029501473ba4c08b0343d47a78892b1bad50321f66', 'c7011da30a42dd7b92a21132cfa295b31d66f42863c6a3414b5dbc0e9f38a1ce', 'ae45f508450dea10961ae41868df31a827a51caf984672ba7b53e43ba5e13140', '6808ff9c187a5808b263bc26ce9efc6509eedbd92aebf3bfa16a9ebbb5432f96', '3195c90c03cf6a438b5684cc93128c53f794660a661e2aa85d043ca5ac7060b9', '0246ffa7291c42bc165b0ac6acf1fc7285b5e41537731f44da530521ca5615d1', 'b5bacf05f766e143f6de9484b0b5a2d9655d62854368373bd77974b94cb722e6', '85d25c76743ed7e65b601d54f78150e74c3aa10e4c1b0b383304ba7887314a95', 'ae74a9a2a182dd5a01fd950e728caccd2600bef5390e5cc261e81037cf194a98', 'b94a431eeccea467fb994ae14c1161601ffad908f6fa54e35fd5f89256dacdea', '7ac09938faf2d97ce8bcc3b64b905bb5a585aeb30156506ee7abe2cd36825ed9', '601ac7ed7c06e522c784e0c0c3a976bc1cc9cccb10f550ee9cd153fa5cb3dcdc', '33a143d8274548ab7377f45f1204f1945e0cf20210af64fed99ac8028f48bac4', '1094721b24c22ff67539ffeabab887f87e538bdd9ebe50b0b369de138d326802', '19ad685cffba6309346c1ba7d6f642f0e69af09509b4f36f7ed87231855721a9', 'f34d1af51d3831ee49ed7f59e7135f955e977a1b93bb875be4c690b33a62450b', 'c53eb2c4fe199217644e8f623baca54cd8f18d0cf2746bad70b055d75f0faa23', '314017bb601d7806be2da63e51d3ee14147fa3ac35c6b85ba05825de7c5de742', '39820f7cb577ca0dcfb1bfa578ae13c25334acae03e89731064b0e3c300841de', '3703b0838ce47d992f259e22b20012a302240311d21f2d269cbb1414baec967f', '2605eb6691e33e75449ea67b2cc57cb2055976b481376bd77f71a937e30c3973', '8577e49f249e444a03b30a1f6f901d73d9fffc14ead45f0d56e8d2ff59c3301f', '8c5ca97b799230d82bd3e52e11118044d85a9f0dbf4f81934f31963b8f59d50c', 'ffe5de17213aa105e92776fd207a82f0ccefc1aa38407bb124b44f049f3dd1b8', '61b71fad4b4a688fc63731cab0845c3423c6935ea6d5c188047fbf047ef3a426', 'a491df768673d76ae7dee4c9bf1ea1456e6c537a1f1683368d8bc6869cd89bf0', '72c5a1f410983619d643ec9b1744e623d17c7eea2f68ac99d1881079601873cd', '139b8c43623bbe83d6e84c494389cef4e57e6816c2829cf9bcbb604af1f3bd70', '6de184d7411efde0440a2390c1009b5c1a251195a5c8bb05f6d64de2066a6d83', '7b6435e5d1cd5f5ef5156a6cb776bff4f493bdb11beead1f071fe87b93e78906', 'c5d808132e397aef8874ae2c056109762978e6c0fb6eee327f28541bd3886a04'] B "from the tsn sub-network perspective mpls (detnet) nodes are treated as talker or listener, that may be (1) tsn-unaware or (2) tsn-aware." {51: 1, 97: 1, 96: 1, 24: 1, 130: 1, 53: 1, 6: 2, 79: 2, 90: 2, 62: 3, 85: 4, 68: 4, 35: 3, 110: 2, 91: 4, 114: 2, 31: 3, 13: 2, 67: 2, 38: 3, 26: 2, 124: 3, 98: 2, 54: 2, 127: 3, 8: 2, 64: 2, 30: 2, 61: 4, 55: 3, 27: 3, 15: 2, 129: 3, 115: 2, 84: 2, 76: 6, 52: 2, 87: 2, 131: 5, 102: 2, 113: 4, 99: 2, 36: 2, 72: 3} {15: 1, 27: 1, 64: 1, 116: 1, 123: 1, 354: 1, 387: 1, 300: 1, 270: 1, 304: 1, 335: 1, 369: 1, 1: 9, 4: 2, 9: 5, 10: 3, 24: 2, 25: 3, 26: 4, 39: 5, 43: 3, 49: 5, 50: 4, 58: 4, 59: 2, 69: 4, 81: 4, 82: 2, 86: 2, 96: 3, 97: 2, 100: 5, 108: 3, 109: 4, 110: 4, 111: 2, 114: 3, 115: 4, 118: 6, 119: 5, 120: 3, 121: 4, 122: 2, 124: 4, 128: 3, 129: 2, 130: 4, 132: 4, 136: 2, 145: 4, 147: 3, 151: 3, 152: 3, 154: 3, 161: 3, 162: 3, 165: 3, 168: 4, 169: 2, 172: 2, 180: 3, 184: 5, 187: 5, 188: 4, 191: 3, 194: 4, 202: 5, 203: 6, 206: 2, 207: 3, 215: 2, 217: 3, 218: 8, 220: 2, 221: 2, 222: 5, 224: 3, 227: 3, 229: 2, 234: 5, 235: 2, 241: 2, 242: 2, 243: 4, 244: 3, 245: 4, 248: 3, 250: 2, 258: 11, 262: 4, 263: 5, 264: 3, 267: 4, 272: 2, 273: 5, 287: 3, 289: 2, 291: 4, 299: 3, 309: 3, 314: 2, 315: 2, 320: 4, 323: 4, 327: 4, 328: 3, 329: 2, 330: 10, 334: 2, 341: 3, 342: 4, 347: 3, 348: 3, 350: 7, 351: 4, 352: 2, 353: 2, 358: 4, 365: 2, 366: 2, 371: 5, 372: 4, 376: 2, 384: 4, 385: 3, 386: 3, 392: 3, 393: 4, 396: 4, 397: 7, 398: 6, 402: 2} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 52 "In cases of TSN-unaware MPLS DetNet nodes the TSN relay nodes within the TSN sub-network must modify the Ethernet encapsulation of the DetNet MPLS flow (e.g., MAC translation, VLAN-ID setting, Sequence number addition, etc.) to allow proper TSN specific handling inside the sub-network. There are no requirements defined for TSN-unaware MPLS DetNet nodes in this document." Similar structure and changes as in IP over TSN . Service protection interworking is out - of - scope . d275ba154e2b7c82eb3ec9175d790214b0e60d3f d275ba154e2b7c82eb3ec9175d790214b0e60d3f draft-ietf-detnet-mpls-over-tsn 95e8b140a3153d24b8cc5b029501473ba4c08b0343d47a78892b1bad50321f66 ['630a7b3cd3eda2e026f158d16d3e4a4a2526a07124cf77aa8ed446ea760814d8', 'b03fd845058850bbf1a630e8c83fada6cba78982283c708236fd7388ffe9fc67', 'c47c152ac014e9bd75ed634d3b9e1c8bb57391b003cba836041c95b95a4c7fa1', 'c69a0fa2ea5f12373344fafbdd44dfb7bb6dbc1860b1c5990feae2a465de298d', '8a1dbabe711db86a26396c01597c528f5fcffb20f047620d5a97dc7303789634', 'e8ac6be9503fe785fadef60b06035db9bcfe02fde1de69193d9a4125a1399c60', '6a32f9bd776a29b7ce3eec373de6fa66bfd90fce56bad4e4eed60abba5aca087', '42f5214bb177fd7faf01b7943e7f313a615b2490f9109d5cefa8b24101735c32', '214810fe3ac0ef76db60e2d0623a8259b9bdf49040882a9e710901fe1eb32fde', '95e8b140a3153d24b8cc5b029501473ba4c08b0343d47a78892b1bad50321f66', 'c7011da30a42dd7b92a21132cfa295b31d66f42863c6a3414b5dbc0e9f38a1ce', 'ae45f508450dea10961ae41868df31a827a51caf984672ba7b53e43ba5e13140', '6808ff9c187a5808b263bc26ce9efc6509eedbd92aebf3bfa16a9ebbb5432f96', '3195c90c03cf6a438b5684cc93128c53f794660a661e2aa85d043ca5ac7060b9', '0246ffa7291c42bc165b0ac6acf1fc7285b5e41537731f44da530521ca5615d1', 'b5bacf05f766e143f6de9484b0b5a2d9655d62854368373bd77974b94cb722e6', '85d25c76743ed7e65b601d54f78150e74c3aa10e4c1b0b383304ba7887314a95', 'ae74a9a2a182dd5a01fd950e728caccd2600bef5390e5cc261e81037cf194a98', 'b94a431eeccea467fb994ae14c1161601ffad908f6fa54e35fd5f89256dacdea', '7ac09938faf2d97ce8bcc3b64b905bb5a585aeb30156506ee7abe2cd36825ed9', '601ac7ed7c06e522c784e0c0c3a976bc1cc9cccb10f550ee9cd153fa5cb3dcdc', '33a143d8274548ab7377f45f1204f1945e0cf20210af64fed99ac8028f48bac4', '1094721b24c22ff67539ffeabab887f87e538bdd9ebe50b0b369de138d326802', '19ad685cffba6309346c1ba7d6f642f0e69af09509b4f36f7ed87231855721a9', 'f34d1af51d3831ee49ed7f59e7135f955e977a1b93bb875be4c690b33a62450b', 'c53eb2c4fe199217644e8f623baca54cd8f18d0cf2746bad70b055d75f0faa23', '314017bb601d7806be2da63e51d3ee14147fa3ac35c6b85ba05825de7c5de742', '39820f7cb577ca0dcfb1bfa578ae13c25334acae03e89731064b0e3c300841de', '3703b0838ce47d992f259e22b20012a302240311d21f2d269cbb1414baec967f', '2605eb6691e33e75449ea67b2cc57cb2055976b481376bd77f71a937e30c3973', '8577e49f249e444a03b30a1f6f901d73d9fffc14ead45f0d56e8d2ff59c3301f', '8c5ca97b799230d82bd3e52e11118044d85a9f0dbf4f81934f31963b8f59d50c', 'ffe5de17213aa105e92776fd207a82f0ccefc1aa38407bb124b44f049f3dd1b8', '61b71fad4b4a688fc63731cab0845c3423c6935ea6d5c188047fbf047ef3a426', 'a491df768673d76ae7dee4c9bf1ea1456e6c537a1f1683368d8bc6869cd89bf0', '72c5a1f410983619d643ec9b1744e623d17c7eea2f68ac99d1881079601873cd', '139b8c43623bbe83d6e84c494389cef4e57e6816c2829cf9bcbb604af1f3bd70', '6de184d7411efde0440a2390c1009b5c1a251195a5c8bb05f6d64de2066a6d83', '7b6435e5d1cd5f5ef5156a6cb776bff4f493bdb11beead1f071fe87b93e78906', 'c5d808132e397aef8874ae2c056109762978e6c0fb6eee327f28541bd3886a04'] B "in cases of tsn-unaware mpls detnet nodes the tsn relay nodes within the tsn sub-network must modify the ethernet encapsulation of the detnet mpls flow (e.g., mac translation, vlan-id setting, sequence number addition, etc.) to allow proper tsn specific handling inside the sub-network. there are no requirements defined for tsn-unaware mpls detnet nodes in this document." {51: 1, 97: 1, 96: 1, 24: 1, 130: 1, 53: 1, 6: 2, 79: 2, 90: 2, 62: 3, 85: 4, 68: 4, 35: 3, 110: 2, 91: 4, 114: 2, 31: 3, 13: 2, 67: 2, 38: 3, 26: 2, 124: 3, 98: 2, 54: 2, 127: 3, 8: 2, 64: 2, 30: 2, 61: 4, 55: 3, 27: 3, 15: 2, 129: 3, 115: 2, 84: 2, 76: 6, 52: 2, 87: 2, 131: 5, 102: 2, 113: 4, 99: 2, 36: 2, 72: 3} {15: 1, 27: 1, 64: 1, 116: 1, 123: 1, 354: 1, 387: 1, 300: 1, 270: 1, 304: 1, 335: 1, 369: 1, 1: 9, 4: 2, 9: 5, 10: 3, 24: 2, 25: 3, 26: 4, 39: 5, 43: 3, 49: 5, 50: 4, 58: 4, 59: 2, 69: 4, 81: 4, 82: 2, 86: 2, 96: 3, 97: 2, 100: 5, 108: 3, 109: 4, 110: 4, 111: 2, 114: 3, 115: 4, 118: 6, 119: 5, 120: 3, 121: 4, 122: 2, 124: 4, 128: 3, 129: 2, 130: 4, 132: 4, 136: 2, 145: 4, 147: 3, 151: 3, 152: 3, 154: 3, 161: 3, 162: 3, 165: 3, 168: 4, 169: 2, 172: 2, 180: 3, 184: 5, 187: 5, 188: 4, 191: 3, 194: 4, 202: 5, 203: 6, 206: 2, 207: 3, 215: 2, 217: 3, 218: 8, 220: 2, 221: 2, 222: 5, 224: 3, 227: 3, 229: 2, 234: 5, 235: 2, 241: 2, 242: 2, 243: 4, 244: 3, 245: 4, 248: 3, 250: 2, 258: 11, 262: 4, 263: 5, 264: 3, 267: 4, 272: 2, 273: 5, 287: 3, 289: 2, 291: 4, 299: 3, 309: 3, 314: 2, 315: 2, 320: 4, 323: 4, 327: 4, 328: 3, 329: 2, 330: 10, 334: 2, 341: 3, 342: 4, 347: 3, 348: 3, 350: 7, 351: 4, 352: 2, 353: 2, 358: 4, 365: 2, 366: 2, 371: 5, 372: 4, 376: 2, 384: 4, 385: 3, 386: 3, 392: 3, 393: 4, 396: 4, 397: 7, 398: 6, 402: 2} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 52 "MPLS (DetNet) nodes being TSN-aware can be treated as a combination of a TSN-unaware Talker/Listener and a TSN-Relay, as shown in fig_mpls_with_tsn. In such cases the MPLS (DetNet) node must provide the TSN sub-network specific Ethernet encapsulation over the link(s) towards the sub-network." Similar structure and changes as in IP over TSN . Service protection interworking is out - of - scope . d275ba154e2b7c82eb3ec9175d790214b0e60d3f d275ba154e2b7c82eb3ec9175d790214b0e60d3f draft-ietf-detnet-mpls-over-tsn ae45f508450dea10961ae41868df31a827a51caf984672ba7b53e43ba5e13140 ['630a7b3cd3eda2e026f158d16d3e4a4a2526a07124cf77aa8ed446ea760814d8', 'b03fd845058850bbf1a630e8c83fada6cba78982283c708236fd7388ffe9fc67', 'c47c152ac014e9bd75ed634d3b9e1c8bb57391b003cba836041c95b95a4c7fa1', 'c69a0fa2ea5f12373344fafbdd44dfb7bb6dbc1860b1c5990feae2a465de298d', '8a1dbabe711db86a26396c01597c528f5fcffb20f047620d5a97dc7303789634', 'e8ac6be9503fe785fadef60b06035db9bcfe02fde1de69193d9a4125a1399c60', '6a32f9bd776a29b7ce3eec373de6fa66bfd90fce56bad4e4eed60abba5aca087', '42f5214bb177fd7faf01b7943e7f313a615b2490f9109d5cefa8b24101735c32', '214810fe3ac0ef76db60e2d0623a8259b9bdf49040882a9e710901fe1eb32fde', '95e8b140a3153d24b8cc5b029501473ba4c08b0343d47a78892b1bad50321f66', 'c7011da30a42dd7b92a21132cfa295b31d66f42863c6a3414b5dbc0e9f38a1ce', 'ae45f508450dea10961ae41868df31a827a51caf984672ba7b53e43ba5e13140', '6808ff9c187a5808b263bc26ce9efc6509eedbd92aebf3bfa16a9ebbb5432f96', '3195c90c03cf6a438b5684cc93128c53f794660a661e2aa85d043ca5ac7060b9', '0246ffa7291c42bc165b0ac6acf1fc7285b5e41537731f44da530521ca5615d1', 'b5bacf05f766e143f6de9484b0b5a2d9655d62854368373bd77974b94cb722e6', '85d25c76743ed7e65b601d54f78150e74c3aa10e4c1b0b383304ba7887314a95', 'ae74a9a2a182dd5a01fd950e728caccd2600bef5390e5cc261e81037cf194a98', 'b94a431eeccea467fb994ae14c1161601ffad908f6fa54e35fd5f89256dacdea', '7ac09938faf2d97ce8bcc3b64b905bb5a585aeb30156506ee7abe2cd36825ed9', '601ac7ed7c06e522c784e0c0c3a976bc1cc9cccb10f550ee9cd153fa5cb3dcdc', '33a143d8274548ab7377f45f1204f1945e0cf20210af64fed99ac8028f48bac4', '1094721b24c22ff67539ffeabab887f87e538bdd9ebe50b0b369de138d326802', '19ad685cffba6309346c1ba7d6f642f0e69af09509b4f36f7ed87231855721a9', 'f34d1af51d3831ee49ed7f59e7135f955e977a1b93bb875be4c690b33a62450b', 'c53eb2c4fe199217644e8f623baca54cd8f18d0cf2746bad70b055d75f0faa23', '314017bb601d7806be2da63e51d3ee14147fa3ac35c6b85ba05825de7c5de742', '39820f7cb577ca0dcfb1bfa578ae13c25334acae03e89731064b0e3c300841de', '3703b0838ce47d992f259e22b20012a302240311d21f2d269cbb1414baec967f', '2605eb6691e33e75449ea67b2cc57cb2055976b481376bd77f71a937e30c3973', '8577e49f249e444a03b30a1f6f901d73d9fffc14ead45f0d56e8d2ff59c3301f', '8c5ca97b799230d82bd3e52e11118044d85a9f0dbf4f81934f31963b8f59d50c', 'ffe5de17213aa105e92776fd207a82f0ccefc1aa38407bb124b44f049f3dd1b8', '61b71fad4b4a688fc63731cab0845c3423c6935ea6d5c188047fbf047ef3a426', 'a491df768673d76ae7dee4c9bf1ea1456e6c537a1f1683368d8bc6869cd89bf0', '72c5a1f410983619d643ec9b1744e623d17c7eea2f68ac99d1881079601873cd', '139b8c43623bbe83d6e84c494389cef4e57e6816c2829cf9bcbb604af1f3bd70', '6de184d7411efde0440a2390c1009b5c1a251195a5c8bb05f6d64de2066a6d83', '7b6435e5d1cd5f5ef5156a6cb776bff4f493bdb11beead1f071fe87b93e78906', 'c5d808132e397aef8874ae2c056109762978e6c0fb6eee327f28541bd3886a04'] B "mpls (detnet) nodes being tsn-aware can be treated as a combination of a tsn-unaware talker/listener and a tsn-relay, as shown in fig_mpls_with_tsn. in such cases the mpls (detnet) node must provide the tsn sub-network specific ethernet encapsulation over the link(s) towards the sub-network." {51: 1, 97: 1, 96: 1, 24: 1, 130: 1, 53: 1, 6: 2, 79: 2, 90: 2, 62: 3, 85: 4, 68: 4, 35: 3, 110: 2, 91: 4, 114: 2, 31: 3, 13: 2, 67: 2, 38: 3, 26: 2, 124: 3, 98: 2, 54: 2, 127: 3, 8: 2, 64: 2, 30: 2, 61: 4, 55: 3, 27: 3, 15: 2, 129: 3, 115: 2, 84: 2, 76: 6, 52: 2, 87: 2, 131: 5, 102: 2, 113: 4, 99: 2, 36: 2, 72: 3} {15: 1, 27: 1, 64: 1, 116: 1, 123: 1, 354: 1, 387: 1, 300: 1, 270: 1, 304: 1, 335: 1, 369: 1, 1: 9, 4: 2, 9: 5, 10: 3, 24: 2, 25: 3, 26: 4, 39: 5, 43: 3, 49: 5, 50: 4, 58: 4, 59: 2, 69: 4, 81: 4, 82: 2, 86: 2, 96: 3, 97: 2, 100: 5, 108: 3, 109: 4, 110: 4, 111: 2, 114: 3, 115: 4, 118: 6, 119: 5, 120: 3, 121: 4, 122: 2, 124: 4, 128: 3, 129: 2, 130: 4, 132: 4, 136: 2, 145: 4, 147: 3, 151: 3, 152: 3, 154: 3, 161: 3, 162: 3, 165: 3, 168: 4, 169: 2, 172: 2, 180: 3, 184: 5, 187: 5, 188: 4, 191: 3, 194: 4, 202: 5, 203: 6, 206: 2, 207: 3, 215: 2, 217: 3, 218: 8, 220: 2, 221: 2, 222: 5, 224: 3, 227: 3, 229: 2, 234: 5, 235: 2, 241: 2, 242: 2, 243: 4, 244: 3, 245: 4, 248: 3, 250: 2, 258: 11, 262: 4, 263: 5, 264: 3, 267: 4, 272: 2, 273: 5, 287: 3, 289: 2, 291: 4, 299: 3, 309: 3, 314: 2, 315: 2, 320: 4, 323: 4, 327: 4, 328: 3, 329: 2, 330: 10, 334: 2, 341: 3, 342: 4, 347: 3, 348: 3, 350: 7, 351: 4, 352: 2, 353: 2, 358: 4, 365: 2, 366: 2, 371: 5, 372: 4, 376: 2, 384: 4, 385: 3, 386: 3, 392: 3, 393: 4, 396: 4, 397: 7, 398: 6, 402: 2} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 52 "A TSN-aware MPLS (DetNet) node impementations MUST support the Stream Identification TSN component for recognizing flows." Similar structure and changes as in IP over TSN . Service protection interworking is out - of - scope . d275ba154e2b7c82eb3ec9175d790214b0e60d3f d275ba154e2b7c82eb3ec9175d790214b0e60d3f draft-ietf-detnet-mpls-over-tsn 7b6435e5d1cd5f5ef5156a6cb776bff4f493bdb11beead1f071fe87b93e78906 ['630a7b3cd3eda2e026f158d16d3e4a4a2526a07124cf77aa8ed446ea760814d8', 'b03fd845058850bbf1a630e8c83fada6cba78982283c708236fd7388ffe9fc67', 'c47c152ac014e9bd75ed634d3b9e1c8bb57391b003cba836041c95b95a4c7fa1', 'c69a0fa2ea5f12373344fafbdd44dfb7bb6dbc1860b1c5990feae2a465de298d', '8a1dbabe711db86a26396c01597c528f5fcffb20f047620d5a97dc7303789634', 'e8ac6be9503fe785fadef60b06035db9bcfe02fde1de69193d9a4125a1399c60', '6a32f9bd776a29b7ce3eec373de6fa66bfd90fce56bad4e4eed60abba5aca087', '42f5214bb177fd7faf01b7943e7f313a615b2490f9109d5cefa8b24101735c32', '214810fe3ac0ef76db60e2d0623a8259b9bdf49040882a9e710901fe1eb32fde', '95e8b140a3153d24b8cc5b029501473ba4c08b0343d47a78892b1bad50321f66', 'c7011da30a42dd7b92a21132cfa295b31d66f42863c6a3414b5dbc0e9f38a1ce', 'ae45f508450dea10961ae41868df31a827a51caf984672ba7b53e43ba5e13140', '6808ff9c187a5808b263bc26ce9efc6509eedbd92aebf3bfa16a9ebbb5432f96', '3195c90c03cf6a438b5684cc93128c53f794660a661e2aa85d043ca5ac7060b9', '0246ffa7291c42bc165b0ac6acf1fc7285b5e41537731f44da530521ca5615d1', 'b5bacf05f766e143f6de9484b0b5a2d9655d62854368373bd77974b94cb722e6', '85d25c76743ed7e65b601d54f78150e74c3aa10e4c1b0b383304ba7887314a95', 'ae74a9a2a182dd5a01fd950e728caccd2600bef5390e5cc261e81037cf194a98', 'b94a431eeccea467fb994ae14c1161601ffad908f6fa54e35fd5f89256dacdea', '7ac09938faf2d97ce8bcc3b64b905bb5a585aeb30156506ee7abe2cd36825ed9', '601ac7ed7c06e522c784e0c0c3a976bc1cc9cccb10f550ee9cd153fa5cb3dcdc', '33a143d8274548ab7377f45f1204f1945e0cf20210af64fed99ac8028f48bac4', '1094721b24c22ff67539ffeabab887f87e538bdd9ebe50b0b369de138d326802', '19ad685cffba6309346c1ba7d6f642f0e69af09509b4f36f7ed87231855721a9', 'f34d1af51d3831ee49ed7f59e7135f955e977a1b93bb875be4c690b33a62450b', 'c53eb2c4fe199217644e8f623baca54cd8f18d0cf2746bad70b055d75f0faa23', '314017bb601d7806be2da63e51d3ee14147fa3ac35c6b85ba05825de7c5de742', '39820f7cb577ca0dcfb1bfa578ae13c25334acae03e89731064b0e3c300841de', '3703b0838ce47d992f259e22b20012a302240311d21f2d269cbb1414baec967f', '2605eb6691e33e75449ea67b2cc57cb2055976b481376bd77f71a937e30c3973', '8577e49f249e444a03b30a1f6f901d73d9fffc14ead45f0d56e8d2ff59c3301f', '8c5ca97b799230d82bd3e52e11118044d85a9f0dbf4f81934f31963b8f59d50c', 'ffe5de17213aa105e92776fd207a82f0ccefc1aa38407bb124b44f049f3dd1b8', '61b71fad4b4a688fc63731cab0845c3423c6935ea6d5c188047fbf047ef3a426', 'a491df768673d76ae7dee4c9bf1ea1456e6c537a1f1683368d8bc6869cd89bf0', '72c5a1f410983619d643ec9b1744e623d17c7eea2f68ac99d1881079601873cd', '139b8c43623bbe83d6e84c494389cef4e57e6816c2829cf9bcbb604af1f3bd70', '6de184d7411efde0440a2390c1009b5c1a251195a5c8bb05f6d64de2066a6d83', '7b6435e5d1cd5f5ef5156a6cb776bff4f493bdb11beead1f071fe87b93e78906', 'c5d808132e397aef8874ae2c056109762978e6c0fb6eee327f28541bd3886a04'] B "a tsn-aware mpls (detnet) node impementations must support the stream identification tsn component for recognizing flows." {51: 1, 97: 1, 96: 1, 24: 1, 130: 1, 53: 1, 6: 2, 79: 2, 90: 2, 62: 3, 85: 4, 68: 4, 35: 3, 110: 2, 91: 4, 114: 2, 31: 3, 13: 2, 67: 2, 38: 3, 26: 2, 124: 3, 98: 2, 54: 2, 127: 3, 8: 2, 64: 2, 30: 2, 61: 4, 55: 3, 27: 3, 15: 2, 129: 3, 115: 2, 84: 2, 76: 6, 52: 2, 87: 2, 131: 5, 102: 2, 113: 4, 99: 2, 36: 2, 72: 3} {15: 1, 27: 1, 64: 1, 116: 1, 123: 1, 354: 1, 387: 1, 300: 1, 270: 1, 304: 1, 335: 1, 369: 1, 1: 9, 4: 2, 9: 5, 10: 3, 24: 2, 25: 3, 26: 4, 39: 5, 43: 3, 49: 5, 50: 4, 58: 4, 59: 2, 69: 4, 81: 4, 82: 2, 86: 2, 96: 3, 97: 2, 100: 5, 108: 3, 109: 4, 110: 4, 111: 2, 114: 3, 115: 4, 118: 6, 119: 5, 120: 3, 121: 4, 122: 2, 124: 4, 128: 3, 129: 2, 130: 4, 132: 4, 136: 2, 145: 4, 147: 3, 151: 3, 152: 3, 154: 3, 161: 3, 162: 3, 165: 3, 168: 4, 169: 2, 172: 2, 180: 3, 184: 5, 187: 5, 188: 4, 191: 3, 194: 4, 202: 5, 203: 6, 206: 2, 207: 3, 215: 2, 217: 3, 218: 8, 220: 2, 221: 2, 222: 5, 224: 3, 227: 3, 229: 2, 234: 5, 235: 2, 241: 2, 242: 2, 243: 4, 244: 3, 245: 4, 248: 3, 250: 2, 258: 11, 262: 4, 263: 5, 264: 3, 267: 4, 272: 2, 273: 5, 287: 3, 289: 2, 291: 4, 299: 3, 309: 3, 314: 2, 315: 2, 320: 4, 323: 4, 327: 4, 328: 3, 329: 2, 330: 10, 334: 2, 341: 3, 342: 4, 347: 3, 348: 3, 350: 7, 351: 4, 352: 2, 353: 2, 358: 4, 365: 2, 366: 2, 371: 5, 372: 4, 376: 2, 384: 4, 385: 3, 386: 3, 392: 3, 393: 4, 396: 4, 397: 7, 398: 6, 402: 2} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 52 "A Stream identification component MUST be able to instantiate the following functions (1) Active Destination MAC and VLAN Stream identification function, (2) Mask-and-Match Stream identification function and (3) the related managed objects in Clause 9 of IEEE8021CB and IEEEP8021CBdb." Similar structure and changes as in IP over TSN . Service protection interworking is out - of - scope . d275ba154e2b7c82eb3ec9175d790214b0e60d3f d275ba154e2b7c82eb3ec9175d790214b0e60d3f draft-ietf-detnet-mpls-over-tsn 72c5a1f410983619d643ec9b1744e623d17c7eea2f68ac99d1881079601873cd ['630a7b3cd3eda2e026f158d16d3e4a4a2526a07124cf77aa8ed446ea760814d8', 'b03fd845058850bbf1a630e8c83fada6cba78982283c708236fd7388ffe9fc67', 'c47c152ac014e9bd75ed634d3b9e1c8bb57391b003cba836041c95b95a4c7fa1', 'c69a0fa2ea5f12373344fafbdd44dfb7bb6dbc1860b1c5990feae2a465de298d', '8a1dbabe711db86a26396c01597c528f5fcffb20f047620d5a97dc7303789634', 'e8ac6be9503fe785fadef60b06035db9bcfe02fde1de69193d9a4125a1399c60', '6a32f9bd776a29b7ce3eec373de6fa66bfd90fce56bad4e4eed60abba5aca087', '42f5214bb177fd7faf01b7943e7f313a615b2490f9109d5cefa8b24101735c32', '214810fe3ac0ef76db60e2d0623a8259b9bdf49040882a9e710901fe1eb32fde', '95e8b140a3153d24b8cc5b029501473ba4c08b0343d47a78892b1bad50321f66', 'c7011da30a42dd7b92a21132cfa295b31d66f42863c6a3414b5dbc0e9f38a1ce', 'ae45f508450dea10961ae41868df31a827a51caf984672ba7b53e43ba5e13140', '6808ff9c187a5808b263bc26ce9efc6509eedbd92aebf3bfa16a9ebbb5432f96', '3195c90c03cf6a438b5684cc93128c53f794660a661e2aa85d043ca5ac7060b9', '0246ffa7291c42bc165b0ac6acf1fc7285b5e41537731f44da530521ca5615d1', 'b5bacf05f766e143f6de9484b0b5a2d9655d62854368373bd77974b94cb722e6', '85d25c76743ed7e65b601d54f78150e74c3aa10e4c1b0b383304ba7887314a95', 'ae74a9a2a182dd5a01fd950e728caccd2600bef5390e5cc261e81037cf194a98', 'b94a431eeccea467fb994ae14c1161601ffad908f6fa54e35fd5f89256dacdea', '7ac09938faf2d97ce8bcc3b64b905bb5a585aeb30156506ee7abe2cd36825ed9', '601ac7ed7c06e522c784e0c0c3a976bc1cc9cccb10f550ee9cd153fa5cb3dcdc', '33a143d8274548ab7377f45f1204f1945e0cf20210af64fed99ac8028f48bac4', '1094721b24c22ff67539ffeabab887f87e538bdd9ebe50b0b369de138d326802', '19ad685cffba6309346c1ba7d6f642f0e69af09509b4f36f7ed87231855721a9', 'f34d1af51d3831ee49ed7f59e7135f955e977a1b93bb875be4c690b33a62450b', 'c53eb2c4fe199217644e8f623baca54cd8f18d0cf2746bad70b055d75f0faa23', '314017bb601d7806be2da63e51d3ee14147fa3ac35c6b85ba05825de7c5de742', '39820f7cb577ca0dcfb1bfa578ae13c25334acae03e89731064b0e3c300841de', '3703b0838ce47d992f259e22b20012a302240311d21f2d269cbb1414baec967f', '2605eb6691e33e75449ea67b2cc57cb2055976b481376bd77f71a937e30c3973', '8577e49f249e444a03b30a1f6f901d73d9fffc14ead45f0d56e8d2ff59c3301f', '8c5ca97b799230d82bd3e52e11118044d85a9f0dbf4f81934f31963b8f59d50c', 'ffe5de17213aa105e92776fd207a82f0ccefc1aa38407bb124b44f049f3dd1b8', '61b71fad4b4a688fc63731cab0845c3423c6935ea6d5c188047fbf047ef3a426', 'a491df768673d76ae7dee4c9bf1ea1456e6c537a1f1683368d8bc6869cd89bf0', '72c5a1f410983619d643ec9b1744e623d17c7eea2f68ac99d1881079601873cd', '139b8c43623bbe83d6e84c494389cef4e57e6816c2829cf9bcbb604af1f3bd70', '6de184d7411efde0440a2390c1009b5c1a251195a5c8bb05f6d64de2066a6d83', '7b6435e5d1cd5f5ef5156a6cb776bff4f493bdb11beead1f071fe87b93e78906', 'c5d808132e397aef8874ae2c056109762978e6c0fb6eee327f28541bd3886a04'] B "a stream identification component must be able to instantiate the following functions (1) active destination mac and vlan stream identification function, (2) mask-and-match stream identification function and (3) the related managed objects in clause 9 of ieee8021cb and ieeep8021cbdb." {51: 1, 97: 1, 96: 1, 24: 1, 130: 1, 53: 1, 6: 2, 79: 2, 90: 2, 62: 3, 85: 4, 68: 4, 35: 3, 110: 2, 91: 4, 114: 2, 31: 3, 13: 2, 67: 2, 38: 3, 26: 2, 124: 3, 98: 2, 54: 2, 127: 3, 8: 2, 64: 2, 30: 2, 61: 4, 55: 3, 27: 3, 15: 2, 129: 3, 115: 2, 84: 2, 76: 6, 52: 2, 87: 2, 131: 5, 102: 2, 113: 4, 99: 2, 36: 2, 72: 3} {15: 1, 27: 1, 64: 1, 116: 1, 123: 1, 354: 1, 387: 1, 300: 1, 270: 1, 304: 1, 335: 1, 369: 1, 1: 9, 4: 2, 9: 5, 10: 3, 24: 2, 25: 3, 26: 4, 39: 5, 43: 3, 49: 5, 50: 4, 58: 4, 59: 2, 69: 4, 81: 4, 82: 2, 86: 2, 96: 3, 97: 2, 100: 5, 108: 3, 109: 4, 110: 4, 111: 2, 114: 3, 115: 4, 118: 6, 119: 5, 120: 3, 121: 4, 122: 2, 124: 4, 128: 3, 129: 2, 130: 4, 132: 4, 136: 2, 145: 4, 147: 3, 151: 3, 152: 3, 154: 3, 161: 3, 162: 3, 165: 3, 168: 4, 169: 2, 172: 2, 180: 3, 184: 5, 187: 5, 188: 4, 191: 3, 194: 4, 202: 5, 203: 6, 206: 2, 207: 3, 215: 2, 217: 3, 218: 8, 220: 2, 221: 2, 222: 5, 224: 3, 227: 3, 229: 2, 234: 5, 235: 2, 241: 2, 242: 2, 243: 4, 244: 3, 245: 4, 248: 3, 250: 2, 258: 11, 262: 4, 263: 5, 264: 3, 267: 4, 272: 2, 273: 5, 287: 3, 289: 2, 291: 4, 299: 3, 309: 3, 314: 2, 315: 2, 320: 4, 323: 4, 327: 4, 328: 3, 329: 2, 330: 10, 334: 2, 341: 3, 342: 4, 347: 3, 348: 3, 350: 7, 351: 4, 352: 2, 353: 2, 358: 4, 365: 2, 366: 2, 371: 5, 372: 4, 376: 2, 384: 4, 385: 3, 386: 3, 392: 3, 393: 4, 396: 4, 397: 7, 398: 6, 402: 2} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 52 "A TSN-aware MPLS (DetNet) node implementations MUST support the Sequencing function and the Sequence encode/decode function as defined in IEEE8021CB if FRER is used inside the TSN sub-network." Similar structure and changes as in IP over TSN . Service protection interworking is out - of - scope . d275ba154e2b7c82eb3ec9175d790214b0e60d3f d275ba154e2b7c82eb3ec9175d790214b0e60d3f draft-ietf-detnet-mpls-over-tsn 0246ffa7291c42bc165b0ac6acf1fc7285b5e41537731f44da530521ca5615d1 ['630a7b3cd3eda2e026f158d16d3e4a4a2526a07124cf77aa8ed446ea760814d8', 'b03fd845058850bbf1a630e8c83fada6cba78982283c708236fd7388ffe9fc67', 'c47c152ac014e9bd75ed634d3b9e1c8bb57391b003cba836041c95b95a4c7fa1', 'c69a0fa2ea5f12373344fafbdd44dfb7bb6dbc1860b1c5990feae2a465de298d', '8a1dbabe711db86a26396c01597c528f5fcffb20f047620d5a97dc7303789634', 'e8ac6be9503fe785fadef60b06035db9bcfe02fde1de69193d9a4125a1399c60', '6a32f9bd776a29b7ce3eec373de6fa66bfd90fce56bad4e4eed60abba5aca087', '42f5214bb177fd7faf01b7943e7f313a615b2490f9109d5cefa8b24101735c32', '214810fe3ac0ef76db60e2d0623a8259b9bdf49040882a9e710901fe1eb32fde', '95e8b140a3153d24b8cc5b029501473ba4c08b0343d47a78892b1bad50321f66', 'c7011da30a42dd7b92a21132cfa295b31d66f42863c6a3414b5dbc0e9f38a1ce', 'ae45f508450dea10961ae41868df31a827a51caf984672ba7b53e43ba5e13140', '6808ff9c187a5808b263bc26ce9efc6509eedbd92aebf3bfa16a9ebbb5432f96', '3195c90c03cf6a438b5684cc93128c53f794660a661e2aa85d043ca5ac7060b9', '0246ffa7291c42bc165b0ac6acf1fc7285b5e41537731f44da530521ca5615d1', 'b5bacf05f766e143f6de9484b0b5a2d9655d62854368373bd77974b94cb722e6', '85d25c76743ed7e65b601d54f78150e74c3aa10e4c1b0b383304ba7887314a95', 'ae74a9a2a182dd5a01fd950e728caccd2600bef5390e5cc261e81037cf194a98', 'b94a431eeccea467fb994ae14c1161601ffad908f6fa54e35fd5f89256dacdea', '7ac09938faf2d97ce8bcc3b64b905bb5a585aeb30156506ee7abe2cd36825ed9', '601ac7ed7c06e522c784e0c0c3a976bc1cc9cccb10f550ee9cd153fa5cb3dcdc', '33a143d8274548ab7377f45f1204f1945e0cf20210af64fed99ac8028f48bac4', '1094721b24c22ff67539ffeabab887f87e538bdd9ebe50b0b369de138d326802', '19ad685cffba6309346c1ba7d6f642f0e69af09509b4f36f7ed87231855721a9', 'f34d1af51d3831ee49ed7f59e7135f955e977a1b93bb875be4c690b33a62450b', 'c53eb2c4fe199217644e8f623baca54cd8f18d0cf2746bad70b055d75f0faa23', '314017bb601d7806be2da63e51d3ee14147fa3ac35c6b85ba05825de7c5de742', '39820f7cb577ca0dcfb1bfa578ae13c25334acae03e89731064b0e3c300841de', '3703b0838ce47d992f259e22b20012a302240311d21f2d269cbb1414baec967f', '2605eb6691e33e75449ea67b2cc57cb2055976b481376bd77f71a937e30c3973', '8577e49f249e444a03b30a1f6f901d73d9fffc14ead45f0d56e8d2ff59c3301f', '8c5ca97b799230d82bd3e52e11118044d85a9f0dbf4f81934f31963b8f59d50c', 'ffe5de17213aa105e92776fd207a82f0ccefc1aa38407bb124b44f049f3dd1b8', '61b71fad4b4a688fc63731cab0845c3423c6935ea6d5c188047fbf047ef3a426', 'a491df768673d76ae7dee4c9bf1ea1456e6c537a1f1683368d8bc6869cd89bf0', '72c5a1f410983619d643ec9b1744e623d17c7eea2f68ac99d1881079601873cd', '139b8c43623bbe83d6e84c494389cef4e57e6816c2829cf9bcbb604af1f3bd70', '6de184d7411efde0440a2390c1009b5c1a251195a5c8bb05f6d64de2066a6d83', '7b6435e5d1cd5f5ef5156a6cb776bff4f493bdb11beead1f071fe87b93e78906', 'c5d808132e397aef8874ae2c056109762978e6c0fb6eee327f28541bd3886a04'] B "a tsn-aware mpls (detnet) node implementations must support the sequencing function and the sequence encode/decode function as defined in ieee8021cb if frer is used inside the tsn sub-network." {51: 1, 97: 1, 96: 1, 24: 1, 130: 1, 53: 1, 6: 2, 79: 2, 90: 2, 62: 3, 85: 4, 68: 4, 35: 3, 110: 2, 91: 4, 114: 2, 31: 3, 13: 2, 67: 2, 38: 3, 26: 2, 124: 3, 98: 2, 54: 2, 127: 3, 8: 2, 64: 2, 30: 2, 61: 4, 55: 3, 27: 3, 15: 2, 129: 3, 115: 2, 84: 2, 76: 6, 52: 2, 87: 2, 131: 5, 102: 2, 113: 4, 99: 2, 36: 2, 72: 3} {15: 1, 27: 1, 64: 1, 116: 1, 123: 1, 354: 1, 387: 1, 300: 1, 270: 1, 304: 1, 335: 1, 369: 1, 1: 9, 4: 2, 9: 5, 10: 3, 24: 2, 25: 3, 26: 4, 39: 5, 43: 3, 49: 5, 50: 4, 58: 4, 59: 2, 69: 4, 81: 4, 82: 2, 86: 2, 96: 3, 97: 2, 100: 5, 108: 3, 109: 4, 110: 4, 111: 2, 114: 3, 115: 4, 118: 6, 119: 5, 120: 3, 121: 4, 122: 2, 124: 4, 128: 3, 129: 2, 130: 4, 132: 4, 136: 2, 145: 4, 147: 3, 151: 3, 152: 3, 154: 3, 161: 3, 162: 3, 165: 3, 168: 4, 169: 2, 172: 2, 180: 3, 184: 5, 187: 5, 188: 4, 191: 3, 194: 4, 202: 5, 203: 6, 206: 2, 207: 3, 215: 2, 217: 3, 218: 8, 220: 2, 221: 2, 222: 5, 224: 3, 227: 3, 229: 2, 234: 5, 235: 2, 241: 2, 242: 2, 243: 4, 244: 3, 245: 4, 248: 3, 250: 2, 258: 11, 262: 4, 263: 5, 264: 3, 267: 4, 272: 2, 273: 5, 287: 3, 289: 2, 291: 4, 299: 3, 309: 3, 314: 2, 315: 2, 320: 4, 323: 4, 327: 4, 328: 3, 329: 2, 330: 10, 334: 2, 341: 3, 342: 4, 347: 3, 348: 3, 350: 7, 351: 4, 352: 2, 353: 2, 358: 4, 365: 2, 366: 2, 371: 5, 372: 4, 376: 2, 384: 4, 385: 3, 386: 3, 392: 3, 393: 4, 396: 4, 397: 7, 398: 6, 402: 2} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 52 "A TSN-aware MPLS (DetNet) node implementations MUST support the Stream splitting function and the Individual recovery function as defined in IEEE8021CB when the node is a replication or elimination point for FRER." Similar structure and changes as in IP over TSN . Service protection interworking is out - of - scope . d275ba154e2b7c82eb3ec9175d790214b0e60d3f d275ba154e2b7c82eb3ec9175d790214b0e60d3f draft-ietf-detnet-mpls-over-tsn 139b8c43623bbe83d6e84c494389cef4e57e6816c2829cf9bcbb604af1f3bd70 ['630a7b3cd3eda2e026f158d16d3e4a4a2526a07124cf77aa8ed446ea760814d8', 'b03fd845058850bbf1a630e8c83fada6cba78982283c708236fd7388ffe9fc67', 'c47c152ac014e9bd75ed634d3b9e1c8bb57391b003cba836041c95b95a4c7fa1', 'c69a0fa2ea5f12373344fafbdd44dfb7bb6dbc1860b1c5990feae2a465de298d', '8a1dbabe711db86a26396c01597c528f5fcffb20f047620d5a97dc7303789634', 'e8ac6be9503fe785fadef60b06035db9bcfe02fde1de69193d9a4125a1399c60', '6a32f9bd776a29b7ce3eec373de6fa66bfd90fce56bad4e4eed60abba5aca087', '42f5214bb177fd7faf01b7943e7f313a615b2490f9109d5cefa8b24101735c32', '214810fe3ac0ef76db60e2d0623a8259b9bdf49040882a9e710901fe1eb32fde', '95e8b140a3153d24b8cc5b029501473ba4c08b0343d47a78892b1bad50321f66', 'c7011da30a42dd7b92a21132cfa295b31d66f42863c6a3414b5dbc0e9f38a1ce', 'ae45f508450dea10961ae41868df31a827a51caf984672ba7b53e43ba5e13140', '6808ff9c187a5808b263bc26ce9efc6509eedbd92aebf3bfa16a9ebbb5432f96', '3195c90c03cf6a438b5684cc93128c53f794660a661e2aa85d043ca5ac7060b9', '0246ffa7291c42bc165b0ac6acf1fc7285b5e41537731f44da530521ca5615d1', 'b5bacf05f766e143f6de9484b0b5a2d9655d62854368373bd77974b94cb722e6', '85d25c76743ed7e65b601d54f78150e74c3aa10e4c1b0b383304ba7887314a95', 'ae74a9a2a182dd5a01fd950e728caccd2600bef5390e5cc261e81037cf194a98', 'b94a431eeccea467fb994ae14c1161601ffad908f6fa54e35fd5f89256dacdea', '7ac09938faf2d97ce8bcc3b64b905bb5a585aeb30156506ee7abe2cd36825ed9', '601ac7ed7c06e522c784e0c0c3a976bc1cc9cccb10f550ee9cd153fa5cb3dcdc', '33a143d8274548ab7377f45f1204f1945e0cf20210af64fed99ac8028f48bac4', '1094721b24c22ff67539ffeabab887f87e538bdd9ebe50b0b369de138d326802', '19ad685cffba6309346c1ba7d6f642f0e69af09509b4f36f7ed87231855721a9', 'f34d1af51d3831ee49ed7f59e7135f955e977a1b93bb875be4c690b33a62450b', 'c53eb2c4fe199217644e8f623baca54cd8f18d0cf2746bad70b055d75f0faa23', '314017bb601d7806be2da63e51d3ee14147fa3ac35c6b85ba05825de7c5de742', '39820f7cb577ca0dcfb1bfa578ae13c25334acae03e89731064b0e3c300841de', '3703b0838ce47d992f259e22b20012a302240311d21f2d269cbb1414baec967f', '2605eb6691e33e75449ea67b2cc57cb2055976b481376bd77f71a937e30c3973', '8577e49f249e444a03b30a1f6f901d73d9fffc14ead45f0d56e8d2ff59c3301f', '8c5ca97b799230d82bd3e52e11118044d85a9f0dbf4f81934f31963b8f59d50c', 'ffe5de17213aa105e92776fd207a82f0ccefc1aa38407bb124b44f049f3dd1b8', '61b71fad4b4a688fc63731cab0845c3423c6935ea6d5c188047fbf047ef3a426', 'a491df768673d76ae7dee4c9bf1ea1456e6c537a1f1683368d8bc6869cd89bf0', '72c5a1f410983619d643ec9b1744e623d17c7eea2f68ac99d1881079601873cd', '139b8c43623bbe83d6e84c494389cef4e57e6816c2829cf9bcbb604af1f3bd70', '6de184d7411efde0440a2390c1009b5c1a251195a5c8bb05f6d64de2066a6d83', '7b6435e5d1cd5f5ef5156a6cb776bff4f493bdb11beead1f071fe87b93e78906', 'c5d808132e397aef8874ae2c056109762978e6c0fb6eee327f28541bd3886a04'] B "a tsn-aware mpls (detnet) node implementations must support the stream splitting function and the individual recovery function as defined in ieee8021cb when the node is a replication or elimination point for frer." {51: 1, 97: 1, 96: 1, 24: 1, 130: 1, 53: 1, 6: 2, 79: 2, 90: 2, 62: 3, 85: 4, 68: 4, 35: 3, 110: 2, 91: 4, 114: 2, 31: 3, 13: 2, 67: 2, 38: 3, 26: 2, 124: 3, 98: 2, 54: 2, 127: 3, 8: 2, 64: 2, 30: 2, 61: 4, 55: 3, 27: 3, 15: 2, 129: 3, 115: 2, 84: 2, 76: 6, 52: 2, 87: 2, 131: 5, 102: 2, 113: 4, 99: 2, 36: 2, 72: 3} {15: 1, 27: 1, 64: 1, 116: 1, 123: 1, 354: 1, 387: 1, 300: 1, 270: 1, 304: 1, 335: 1, 369: 1, 1: 9, 4: 2, 9: 5, 10: 3, 24: 2, 25: 3, 26: 4, 39: 5, 43: 3, 49: 5, 50: 4, 58: 4, 59: 2, 69: 4, 81: 4, 82: 2, 86: 2, 96: 3, 97: 2, 100: 5, 108: 3, 109: 4, 110: 4, 111: 2, 114: 3, 115: 4, 118: 6, 119: 5, 120: 3, 121: 4, 122: 2, 124: 4, 128: 3, 129: 2, 130: 4, 132: 4, 136: 2, 145: 4, 147: 3, 151: 3, 152: 3, 154: 3, 161: 3, 162: 3, 165: 3, 168: 4, 169: 2, 172: 2, 180: 3, 184: 5, 187: 5, 188: 4, 191: 3, 194: 4, 202: 5, 203: 6, 206: 2, 207: 3, 215: 2, 217: 3, 218: 8, 220: 2, 221: 2, 222: 5, 224: 3, 227: 3, 229: 2, 234: 5, 235: 2, 241: 2, 242: 2, 243: 4, 244: 3, 245: 4, 248: 3, 250: 2, 258: 11, 262: 4, 263: 5, 264: 3, 267: 4, 272: 2, 273: 5, 287: 3, 289: 2, 291: 4, 299: 3, 309: 3, 314: 2, 315: 2, 320: 4, 323: 4, 327: 4, 328: 3, 329: 2, 330: 10, 334: 2, 341: 3, 342: 4, 347: 3, 348: 3, 350: 7, 351: 4, 352: 2, 353: 2, 358: 4, 365: 2, 366: 2, 371: 5, 372: 4, 376: 2, 384: 4, 385: 3, 386: 3, 392: 3, 393: 4, 396: 4, 397: 7, 398: 6, 402: 2} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 52 "TSN Streams supporting DetNet flows may use Frame Replication and Elimination for Redundancy (FRER) as defined in IEEE8021CB based on the loss service requirements of the TSN Stream, which is derived from the DetNet service requirements of the DetNet mapped flow. The specific operation of FRER is not modified by the use of DetNet and follows IEEE8021CB." Similar structure and changes as in IP over TSN . Service protection interworking is out - of - scope . d275ba154e2b7c82eb3ec9175d790214b0e60d3f d275ba154e2b7c82eb3ec9175d790214b0e60d3f draft-ietf-detnet-mpls-over-tsn 214810fe3ac0ef76db60e2d0623a8259b9bdf49040882a9e710901fe1eb32fde ['630a7b3cd3eda2e026f158d16d3e4a4a2526a07124cf77aa8ed446ea760814d8', 'b03fd845058850bbf1a630e8c83fada6cba78982283c708236fd7388ffe9fc67', 'c47c152ac014e9bd75ed634d3b9e1c8bb57391b003cba836041c95b95a4c7fa1', 'c69a0fa2ea5f12373344fafbdd44dfb7bb6dbc1860b1c5990feae2a465de298d', '8a1dbabe711db86a26396c01597c528f5fcffb20f047620d5a97dc7303789634', 'e8ac6be9503fe785fadef60b06035db9bcfe02fde1de69193d9a4125a1399c60', '6a32f9bd776a29b7ce3eec373de6fa66bfd90fce56bad4e4eed60abba5aca087', '42f5214bb177fd7faf01b7943e7f313a615b2490f9109d5cefa8b24101735c32', '214810fe3ac0ef76db60e2d0623a8259b9bdf49040882a9e710901fe1eb32fde', '95e8b140a3153d24b8cc5b029501473ba4c08b0343d47a78892b1bad50321f66', 'c7011da30a42dd7b92a21132cfa295b31d66f42863c6a3414b5dbc0e9f38a1ce', 'ae45f508450dea10961ae41868df31a827a51caf984672ba7b53e43ba5e13140', '6808ff9c187a5808b263bc26ce9efc6509eedbd92aebf3bfa16a9ebbb5432f96', '3195c90c03cf6a438b5684cc93128c53f794660a661e2aa85d043ca5ac7060b9', '0246ffa7291c42bc165b0ac6acf1fc7285b5e41537731f44da530521ca5615d1', 'b5bacf05f766e143f6de9484b0b5a2d9655d62854368373bd77974b94cb722e6', '85d25c76743ed7e65b601d54f78150e74c3aa10e4c1b0b383304ba7887314a95', 'ae74a9a2a182dd5a01fd950e728caccd2600bef5390e5cc261e81037cf194a98', 'b94a431eeccea467fb994ae14c1161601ffad908f6fa54e35fd5f89256dacdea', '7ac09938faf2d97ce8bcc3b64b905bb5a585aeb30156506ee7abe2cd36825ed9', '601ac7ed7c06e522c784e0c0c3a976bc1cc9cccb10f550ee9cd153fa5cb3dcdc', '33a143d8274548ab7377f45f1204f1945e0cf20210af64fed99ac8028f48bac4', '1094721b24c22ff67539ffeabab887f87e538bdd9ebe50b0b369de138d326802', '19ad685cffba6309346c1ba7d6f642f0e69af09509b4f36f7ed87231855721a9', 'f34d1af51d3831ee49ed7f59e7135f955e977a1b93bb875be4c690b33a62450b', 'c53eb2c4fe199217644e8f623baca54cd8f18d0cf2746bad70b055d75f0faa23', '314017bb601d7806be2da63e51d3ee14147fa3ac35c6b85ba05825de7c5de742', '39820f7cb577ca0dcfb1bfa578ae13c25334acae03e89731064b0e3c300841de', '3703b0838ce47d992f259e22b20012a302240311d21f2d269cbb1414baec967f', '2605eb6691e33e75449ea67b2cc57cb2055976b481376bd77f71a937e30c3973', '8577e49f249e444a03b30a1f6f901d73d9fffc14ead45f0d56e8d2ff59c3301f', '8c5ca97b799230d82bd3e52e11118044d85a9f0dbf4f81934f31963b8f59d50c', 'ffe5de17213aa105e92776fd207a82f0ccefc1aa38407bb124b44f049f3dd1b8', '61b71fad4b4a688fc63731cab0845c3423c6935ea6d5c188047fbf047ef3a426', 'a491df768673d76ae7dee4c9bf1ea1456e6c537a1f1683368d8bc6869cd89bf0', '72c5a1f410983619d643ec9b1744e623d17c7eea2f68ac99d1881079601873cd', '139b8c43623bbe83d6e84c494389cef4e57e6816c2829cf9bcbb604af1f3bd70', '6de184d7411efde0440a2390c1009b5c1a251195a5c8bb05f6d64de2066a6d83', '7b6435e5d1cd5f5ef5156a6cb776bff4f493bdb11beead1f071fe87b93e78906', 'c5d808132e397aef8874ae2c056109762978e6c0fb6eee327f28541bd3886a04'] B "tsn streams supporting detnet flows may use frame replication and elimination for redundancy (frer) as defined in ieee8021cb based on the loss service requirements of the tsn stream, which is derived from the detnet service requirements of the detnet mapped flow. the specific operation of frer is not modified by the use of detnet and follows ieee8021cb." {51: 1, 97: 1, 96: 1, 24: 1, 130: 1, 53: 1, 6: 2, 79: 2, 90: 2, 62: 3, 85: 4, 68: 4, 35: 3, 110: 2, 91: 4, 114: 2, 31: 3, 13: 2, 67: 2, 38: 3, 26: 2, 124: 3, 98: 2, 54: 2, 127: 3, 8: 2, 64: 2, 30: 2, 61: 4, 55: 3, 27: 3, 15: 2, 129: 3, 115: 2, 84: 2, 76: 6, 52: 2, 87: 2, 131: 5, 102: 2, 113: 4, 99: 2, 36: 2, 72: 3} {15: 1, 27: 1, 64: 1, 116: 1, 123: 1, 354: 1, 387: 1, 300: 1, 270: 1, 304: 1, 335: 1, 369: 1, 1: 9, 4: 2, 9: 5, 10: 3, 24: 2, 25: 3, 26: 4, 39: 5, 43: 3, 49: 5, 50: 4, 58: 4, 59: 2, 69: 4, 81: 4, 82: 2, 86: 2, 96: 3, 97: 2, 100: 5, 108: 3, 109: 4, 110: 4, 111: 2, 114: 3, 115: 4, 118: 6, 119: 5, 120: 3, 121: 4, 122: 2, 124: 4, 128: 3, 129: 2, 130: 4, 132: 4, 136: 2, 145: 4, 147: 3, 151: 3, 152: 3, 154: 3, 161: 3, 162: 3, 165: 3, 168: 4, 169: 2, 172: 2, 180: 3, 184: 5, 187: 5, 188: 4, 191: 3, 194: 4, 202: 5, 203: 6, 206: 2, 207: 3, 215: 2, 217: 3, 218: 8, 220: 2, 221: 2, 222: 5, 224: 3, 227: 3, 229: 2, 234: 5, 235: 2, 241: 2, 242: 2, 243: 4, 244: 3, 245: 4, 248: 3, 250: 2, 258: 11, 262: 4, 263: 5, 264: 3, 267: 4, 272: 2, 273: 5, 287: 3, 289: 2, 291: 4, 299: 3, 309: 3, 314: 2, 315: 2, 320: 4, 323: 4, 327: 4, 328: 3, 329: 2, 330: 10, 334: 2, 341: 3, 342: 4, 347: 3, 348: 3, 350: 7, 351: 4, 352: 2, 353: 2, 358: 4, 365: 2, 366: 2, 371: 5, 372: 4, 376: 2, 384: 4, 385: 3, 386: 3, 392: 3, 393: 4, 396: 4, 397: 7, 398: 6, 402: 2} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 52 "FRER function and the provided service recovery is available only within the TSN sub-network as the TSN Stream-ID and the TSN sequence number are not valid outside the sub-network. An MPLS (DetNet) node represents a L3 border and as such it terminates all related information elements encoded in the L2 frames." Similar structure and changes as in IP over TSN . Service protection interworking is out - of - scope . d275ba154e2b7c82eb3ec9175d790214b0e60d3f d275ba154e2b7c82eb3ec9175d790214b0e60d3f draft-ietf-detnet-mpls-over-tsn ffe5de17213aa105e92776fd207a82f0ccefc1aa38407bb124b44f049f3dd1b8 ['630a7b3cd3eda2e026f158d16d3e4a4a2526a07124cf77aa8ed446ea760814d8', 'b03fd845058850bbf1a630e8c83fada6cba78982283c708236fd7388ffe9fc67', 'c47c152ac014e9bd75ed634d3b9e1c8bb57391b003cba836041c95b95a4c7fa1', 'c69a0fa2ea5f12373344fafbdd44dfb7bb6dbc1860b1c5990feae2a465de298d', '8a1dbabe711db86a26396c01597c528f5fcffb20f047620d5a97dc7303789634', 'e8ac6be9503fe785fadef60b06035db9bcfe02fde1de69193d9a4125a1399c60', '6a32f9bd776a29b7ce3eec373de6fa66bfd90fce56bad4e4eed60abba5aca087', '42f5214bb177fd7faf01b7943e7f313a615b2490f9109d5cefa8b24101735c32', '214810fe3ac0ef76db60e2d0623a8259b9bdf49040882a9e710901fe1eb32fde', '95e8b140a3153d24b8cc5b029501473ba4c08b0343d47a78892b1bad50321f66', 'c7011da30a42dd7b92a21132cfa295b31d66f42863c6a3414b5dbc0e9f38a1ce', 'ae45f508450dea10961ae41868df31a827a51caf984672ba7b53e43ba5e13140', '6808ff9c187a5808b263bc26ce9efc6509eedbd92aebf3bfa16a9ebbb5432f96', '3195c90c03cf6a438b5684cc93128c53f794660a661e2aa85d043ca5ac7060b9', '0246ffa7291c42bc165b0ac6acf1fc7285b5e41537731f44da530521ca5615d1', 'b5bacf05f766e143f6de9484b0b5a2d9655d62854368373bd77974b94cb722e6', '85d25c76743ed7e65b601d54f78150e74c3aa10e4c1b0b383304ba7887314a95', 'ae74a9a2a182dd5a01fd950e728caccd2600bef5390e5cc261e81037cf194a98', 'b94a431eeccea467fb994ae14c1161601ffad908f6fa54e35fd5f89256dacdea', '7ac09938faf2d97ce8bcc3b64b905bb5a585aeb30156506ee7abe2cd36825ed9', '601ac7ed7c06e522c784e0c0c3a976bc1cc9cccb10f550ee9cd153fa5cb3dcdc', '33a143d8274548ab7377f45f1204f1945e0cf20210af64fed99ac8028f48bac4', '1094721b24c22ff67539ffeabab887f87e538bdd9ebe50b0b369de138d326802', '19ad685cffba6309346c1ba7d6f642f0e69af09509b4f36f7ed87231855721a9', 'f34d1af51d3831ee49ed7f59e7135f955e977a1b93bb875be4c690b33a62450b', 'c53eb2c4fe199217644e8f623baca54cd8f18d0cf2746bad70b055d75f0faa23', '314017bb601d7806be2da63e51d3ee14147fa3ac35c6b85ba05825de7c5de742', '39820f7cb577ca0dcfb1bfa578ae13c25334acae03e89731064b0e3c300841de', '3703b0838ce47d992f259e22b20012a302240311d21f2d269cbb1414baec967f', '2605eb6691e33e75449ea67b2cc57cb2055976b481376bd77f71a937e30c3973', '8577e49f249e444a03b30a1f6f901d73d9fffc14ead45f0d56e8d2ff59c3301f', '8c5ca97b799230d82bd3e52e11118044d85a9f0dbf4f81934f31963b8f59d50c', 'ffe5de17213aa105e92776fd207a82f0ccefc1aa38407bb124b44f049f3dd1b8', '61b71fad4b4a688fc63731cab0845c3423c6935ea6d5c188047fbf047ef3a426', 'a491df768673d76ae7dee4c9bf1ea1456e6c537a1f1683368d8bc6869cd89bf0', '72c5a1f410983619d643ec9b1744e623d17c7eea2f68ac99d1881079601873cd', '139b8c43623bbe83d6e84c494389cef4e57e6816c2829cf9bcbb604af1f3bd70', '6de184d7411efde0440a2390c1009b5c1a251195a5c8bb05f6d64de2066a6d83', '7b6435e5d1cd5f5ef5156a6cb776bff4f493bdb11beead1f071fe87b93e78906', 'c5d808132e397aef8874ae2c056109762978e6c0fb6eee327f28541bd3886a04'] B "frer function and the provided service recovery is available only within the tsn sub-network as the tsn stream-id and the tsn sequence number are not valid outside the sub-network. an mpls (detnet) node represents a l3 border and as such it terminates all related information elements encoded in the l2 frames." {51: 1, 97: 1, 96: 1, 24: 1, 130: 1, 53: 1, 6: 2, 79: 2, 90: 2, 62: 3, 85: 4, 68: 4, 35: 3, 110: 2, 91: 4, 114: 2, 31: 3, 13: 2, 67: 2, 38: 3, 26: 2, 124: 3, 98: 2, 54: 2, 127: 3, 8: 2, 64: 2, 30: 2, 61: 4, 55: 3, 27: 3, 15: 2, 129: 3, 115: 2, 84: 2, 76: 6, 52: 2, 87: 2, 131: 5, 102: 2, 113: 4, 99: 2, 36: 2, 72: 3} {15: 1, 27: 1, 64: 1, 116: 1, 123: 1, 354: 1, 387: 1, 300: 1, 270: 1, 304: 1, 335: 1, 369: 1, 1: 9, 4: 2, 9: 5, 10: 3, 24: 2, 25: 3, 26: 4, 39: 5, 43: 3, 49: 5, 50: 4, 58: 4, 59: 2, 69: 4, 81: 4, 82: 2, 86: 2, 96: 3, 97: 2, 100: 5, 108: 3, 109: 4, 110: 4, 111: 2, 114: 3, 115: 4, 118: 6, 119: 5, 120: 3, 121: 4, 122: 2, 124: 4, 128: 3, 129: 2, 130: 4, 132: 4, 136: 2, 145: 4, 147: 3, 151: 3, 152: 3, 154: 3, 161: 3, 162: 3, 165: 3, 168: 4, 169: 2, 172: 2, 180: 3, 184: 5, 187: 5, 188: 4, 191: 3, 194: 4, 202: 5, 203: 6, 206: 2, 207: 3, 215: 2, 217: 3, 218: 8, 220: 2, 221: 2, 222: 5, 224: 3, 227: 3, 229: 2, 234: 5, 235: 2, 241: 2, 242: 2, 243: 4, 244: 3, 245: 4, 248: 3, 250: 2, 258: 11, 262: 4, 263: 5, 264: 3, 267: 4, 272: 2, 273: 5, 287: 3, 289: 2, 291: 4, 299: 3, 309: 3, 314: 2, 315: 2, 320: 4, 323: 4, 327: 4, 328: 3, 329: 2, 330: 10, 334: 2, 341: 3, 342: 4, 347: 3, 348: 3, 350: 7, 351: 4, 352: 2, 353: 2, 358: 4, 365: 2, 366: 2, 371: 5, 372: 4, 376: 2, 384: 4, 385: 3, 386: 3, 392: 3, 393: 4, 396: 4, 397: 7, 398: 6, 402: 2} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 52 "As the Stream-ID and the TSN sequence number are paired with the similar MPLS flow parameters, FRER can be combined with PREOF functions. Such service protection interworking scenarios may require to move sequence number fields among TSN (L2) and PW (MPLS) encapsulations and they are left for further study." Similar structure and changes as in IP over TSN . Service protection interworking is out - of - scope . d275ba154e2b7c82eb3ec9175d790214b0e60d3f d275ba154e2b7c82eb3ec9175d790214b0e60d3f draft-ietf-detnet-mpls-over-tsn 6de184d7411efde0440a2390c1009b5c1a251195a5c8bb05f6d64de2066a6d83 ['630a7b3cd3eda2e026f158d16d3e4a4a2526a07124cf77aa8ed446ea760814d8', 'b03fd845058850bbf1a630e8c83fada6cba78982283c708236fd7388ffe9fc67', 'c47c152ac014e9bd75ed634d3b9e1c8bb57391b003cba836041c95b95a4c7fa1', 'c69a0fa2ea5f12373344fafbdd44dfb7bb6dbc1860b1c5990feae2a465de298d', '8a1dbabe711db86a26396c01597c528f5fcffb20f047620d5a97dc7303789634', 'e8ac6be9503fe785fadef60b06035db9bcfe02fde1de69193d9a4125a1399c60', '6a32f9bd776a29b7ce3eec373de6fa66bfd90fce56bad4e4eed60abba5aca087', '42f5214bb177fd7faf01b7943e7f313a615b2490f9109d5cefa8b24101735c32', '214810fe3ac0ef76db60e2d0623a8259b9bdf49040882a9e710901fe1eb32fde', '95e8b140a3153d24b8cc5b029501473ba4c08b0343d47a78892b1bad50321f66', 'c7011da30a42dd7b92a21132cfa295b31d66f42863c6a3414b5dbc0e9f38a1ce', 'ae45f508450dea10961ae41868df31a827a51caf984672ba7b53e43ba5e13140', '6808ff9c187a5808b263bc26ce9efc6509eedbd92aebf3bfa16a9ebbb5432f96', '3195c90c03cf6a438b5684cc93128c53f794660a661e2aa85d043ca5ac7060b9', '0246ffa7291c42bc165b0ac6acf1fc7285b5e41537731f44da530521ca5615d1', 'b5bacf05f766e143f6de9484b0b5a2d9655d62854368373bd77974b94cb722e6', '85d25c76743ed7e65b601d54f78150e74c3aa10e4c1b0b383304ba7887314a95', 'ae74a9a2a182dd5a01fd950e728caccd2600bef5390e5cc261e81037cf194a98', 'b94a431eeccea467fb994ae14c1161601ffad908f6fa54e35fd5f89256dacdea', '7ac09938faf2d97ce8bcc3b64b905bb5a585aeb30156506ee7abe2cd36825ed9', '601ac7ed7c06e522c784e0c0c3a976bc1cc9cccb10f550ee9cd153fa5cb3dcdc', '33a143d8274548ab7377f45f1204f1945e0cf20210af64fed99ac8028f48bac4', '1094721b24c22ff67539ffeabab887f87e538bdd9ebe50b0b369de138d326802', '19ad685cffba6309346c1ba7d6f642f0e69af09509b4f36f7ed87231855721a9', 'f34d1af51d3831ee49ed7f59e7135f955e977a1b93bb875be4c690b33a62450b', 'c53eb2c4fe199217644e8f623baca54cd8f18d0cf2746bad70b055d75f0faa23', '314017bb601d7806be2da63e51d3ee14147fa3ac35c6b85ba05825de7c5de742', '39820f7cb577ca0dcfb1bfa578ae13c25334acae03e89731064b0e3c300841de', '3703b0838ce47d992f259e22b20012a302240311d21f2d269cbb1414baec967f', '2605eb6691e33e75449ea67b2cc57cb2055976b481376bd77f71a937e30c3973', '8577e49f249e444a03b30a1f6f901d73d9fffc14ead45f0d56e8d2ff59c3301f', '8c5ca97b799230d82bd3e52e11118044d85a9f0dbf4f81934f31963b8f59d50c', 'ffe5de17213aa105e92776fd207a82f0ccefc1aa38407bb124b44f049f3dd1b8', '61b71fad4b4a688fc63731cab0845c3423c6935ea6d5c188047fbf047ef3a426', 'a491df768673d76ae7dee4c9bf1ea1456e6c537a1f1683368d8bc6869cd89bf0', '72c5a1f410983619d643ec9b1744e623d17c7eea2f68ac99d1881079601873cd', '139b8c43623bbe83d6e84c494389cef4e57e6816c2829cf9bcbb604af1f3bd70', '6de184d7411efde0440a2390c1009b5c1a251195a5c8bb05f6d64de2066a6d83', '7b6435e5d1cd5f5ef5156a6cb776bff4f493bdb11beead1f071fe87b93e78906', 'c5d808132e397aef8874ae2c056109762978e6c0fb6eee327f28541bd3886a04'] B "as the stream-id and the tsn sequence number are paired with the similar mpls flow parameters, frer can be combined with preof functions. such service protection interworking scenarios may require to move sequence number fields among tsn (l2) and pw (mpls) encapsulations and they are left for further study." {51: 1, 97: 1, 96: 1, 24: 1, 130: 1, 53: 1, 6: 2, 79: 2, 90: 2, 62: 3, 85: 4, 68: 4, 35: 3, 110: 2, 91: 4, 114: 2, 31: 3, 13: 2, 67: 2, 38: 3, 26: 2, 124: 3, 98: 2, 54: 2, 127: 3, 8: 2, 64: 2, 30: 2, 61: 4, 55: 3, 27: 3, 15: 2, 129: 3, 115: 2, 84: 2, 76: 6, 52: 2, 87: 2, 131: 5, 102: 2, 113: 4, 99: 2, 36: 2, 72: 3} {15: 1, 27: 1, 64: 1, 116: 1, 123: 1, 354: 1, 387: 1, 300: 1, 270: 1, 304: 1, 335: 1, 369: 1, 1: 9, 4: 2, 9: 5, 10: 3, 24: 2, 25: 3, 26: 4, 39: 5, 43: 3, 49: 5, 50: 4, 58: 4, 59: 2, 69: 4, 81: 4, 82: 2, 86: 2, 96: 3, 97: 2, 100: 5, 108: 3, 109: 4, 110: 4, 111: 2, 114: 3, 115: 4, 118: 6, 119: 5, 120: 3, 121: 4, 122: 2, 124: 4, 128: 3, 129: 2, 130: 4, 132: 4, 136: 2, 145: 4, 147: 3, 151: 3, 152: 3, 154: 3, 161: 3, 162: 3, 165: 3, 168: 4, 169: 2, 172: 2, 180: 3, 184: 5, 187: 5, 188: 4, 191: 3, 194: 4, 202: 5, 203: 6, 206: 2, 207: 3, 215: 2, 217: 3, 218: 8, 220: 2, 221: 2, 222: 5, 224: 3, 227: 3, 229: 2, 234: 5, 235: 2, 241: 2, 242: 2, 243: 4, 244: 3, 245: 4, 248: 3, 250: 2, 258: 11, 262: 4, 263: 5, 264: 3, 267: 4, 272: 2, 273: 5, 287: 3, 289: 2, 291: 4, 299: 3, 309: 3, 314: 2, 315: 2, 320: 4, 323: 4, 327: 4, 328: 3, 329: 2, 330: 10, 334: 2, 341: 3, 342: 4, 347: 3, 348: 3, 350: 7, 351: 4, 352: 2, 353: 2, 358: 4, 365: 2, 366: 2, 371: 5, 372: 4, 376: 2, 384: 4, 385: 3, 386: 3, 392: 3, 393: 4, 396: 4, 397: 7, 398: 6, 402: 2} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 52 "Implementations of this document SHALL use management and control information to map a DetNet flow to a TSN Stream. N:1 mapping (aggregating DetNet flows in a single TSN Stream) SHALL be supported. The management or control function that provisions flow mapping SHALL ensure that adequate resources are allocated and configured to provide proper service requirements of the mapped flows." Similar structure and changes as in IP over TSN . Service protection interworking is out - of - scope . d275ba154e2b7c82eb3ec9175d790214b0e60d3f d275ba154e2b7c82eb3ec9175d790214b0e60d3f draft-ietf-detnet-mpls-over-tsn 6808ff9c187a5808b263bc26ce9efc6509eedbd92aebf3bfa16a9ebbb5432f96 ['630a7b3cd3eda2e026f158d16d3e4a4a2526a07124cf77aa8ed446ea760814d8', 'b03fd845058850bbf1a630e8c83fada6cba78982283c708236fd7388ffe9fc67', 'c47c152ac014e9bd75ed634d3b9e1c8bb57391b003cba836041c95b95a4c7fa1', 'c69a0fa2ea5f12373344fafbdd44dfb7bb6dbc1860b1c5990feae2a465de298d', '8a1dbabe711db86a26396c01597c528f5fcffb20f047620d5a97dc7303789634', 'e8ac6be9503fe785fadef60b06035db9bcfe02fde1de69193d9a4125a1399c60', '6a32f9bd776a29b7ce3eec373de6fa66bfd90fce56bad4e4eed60abba5aca087', '42f5214bb177fd7faf01b7943e7f313a615b2490f9109d5cefa8b24101735c32', '214810fe3ac0ef76db60e2d0623a8259b9bdf49040882a9e710901fe1eb32fde', '95e8b140a3153d24b8cc5b029501473ba4c08b0343d47a78892b1bad50321f66', 'c7011da30a42dd7b92a21132cfa295b31d66f42863c6a3414b5dbc0e9f38a1ce', 'ae45f508450dea10961ae41868df31a827a51caf984672ba7b53e43ba5e13140', '6808ff9c187a5808b263bc26ce9efc6509eedbd92aebf3bfa16a9ebbb5432f96', '3195c90c03cf6a438b5684cc93128c53f794660a661e2aa85d043ca5ac7060b9', '0246ffa7291c42bc165b0ac6acf1fc7285b5e41537731f44da530521ca5615d1', 'b5bacf05f766e143f6de9484b0b5a2d9655d62854368373bd77974b94cb722e6', '85d25c76743ed7e65b601d54f78150e74c3aa10e4c1b0b383304ba7887314a95', 'ae74a9a2a182dd5a01fd950e728caccd2600bef5390e5cc261e81037cf194a98', 'b94a431eeccea467fb994ae14c1161601ffad908f6fa54e35fd5f89256dacdea', '7ac09938faf2d97ce8bcc3b64b905bb5a585aeb30156506ee7abe2cd36825ed9', '601ac7ed7c06e522c784e0c0c3a976bc1cc9cccb10f550ee9cd153fa5cb3dcdc', '33a143d8274548ab7377f45f1204f1945e0cf20210af64fed99ac8028f48bac4', '1094721b24c22ff67539ffeabab887f87e538bdd9ebe50b0b369de138d326802', '19ad685cffba6309346c1ba7d6f642f0e69af09509b4f36f7ed87231855721a9', 'f34d1af51d3831ee49ed7f59e7135f955e977a1b93bb875be4c690b33a62450b', 'c53eb2c4fe199217644e8f623baca54cd8f18d0cf2746bad70b055d75f0faa23', '314017bb601d7806be2da63e51d3ee14147fa3ac35c6b85ba05825de7c5de742', '39820f7cb577ca0dcfb1bfa578ae13c25334acae03e89731064b0e3c300841de', '3703b0838ce47d992f259e22b20012a302240311d21f2d269cbb1414baec967f', '2605eb6691e33e75449ea67b2cc57cb2055976b481376bd77f71a937e30c3973', '8577e49f249e444a03b30a1f6f901d73d9fffc14ead45f0d56e8d2ff59c3301f', '8c5ca97b799230d82bd3e52e11118044d85a9f0dbf4f81934f31963b8f59d50c', 'ffe5de17213aa105e92776fd207a82f0ccefc1aa38407bb124b44f049f3dd1b8', '61b71fad4b4a688fc63731cab0845c3423c6935ea6d5c188047fbf047ef3a426', 'a491df768673d76ae7dee4c9bf1ea1456e6c537a1f1683368d8bc6869cd89bf0', '72c5a1f410983619d643ec9b1744e623d17c7eea2f68ac99d1881079601873cd', '139b8c43623bbe83d6e84c494389cef4e57e6816c2829cf9bcbb604af1f3bd70', '6de184d7411efde0440a2390c1009b5c1a251195a5c8bb05f6d64de2066a6d83', '7b6435e5d1cd5f5ef5156a6cb776bff4f493bdb11beead1f071fe87b93e78906', 'c5d808132e397aef8874ae2c056109762978e6c0fb6eee327f28541bd3886a04'] B "implementations of this document shall use management and control information to map a detnet flow to a tsn stream. n:1 mapping (aggregating detnet flows in a single tsn stream) shall be supported. the management or control function that provisions flow mapping shall ensure that adequate resources are allocated and configured to provide proper service requirements of the mapped flows." {51: 1, 97: 1, 96: 1, 24: 1, 130: 1, 53: 1, 6: 2, 79: 2, 90: 2, 62: 3, 85: 4, 68: 4, 35: 3, 110: 2, 91: 4, 114: 2, 31: 3, 13: 2, 67: 2, 38: 3, 26: 2, 124: 3, 98: 2, 54: 2, 127: 3, 8: 2, 64: 2, 30: 2, 61: 4, 55: 3, 27: 3, 15: 2, 129: 3, 115: 2, 84: 2, 76: 6, 52: 2, 87: 2, 131: 5, 102: 2, 113: 4, 99: 2, 36: 2, 72: 3} {15: 1, 27: 1, 64: 1, 116: 1, 123: 1, 354: 1, 387: 1, 300: 1, 270: 1, 304: 1, 335: 1, 369: 1, 1: 9, 4: 2, 9: 5, 10: 3, 24: 2, 25: 3, 26: 4, 39: 5, 43: 3, 49: 5, 50: 4, 58: 4, 59: 2, 69: 4, 81: 4, 82: 2, 86: 2, 96: 3, 97: 2, 100: 5, 108: 3, 109: 4, 110: 4, 111: 2, 114: 3, 115: 4, 118: 6, 119: 5, 120: 3, 121: 4, 122: 2, 124: 4, 128: 3, 129: 2, 130: 4, 132: 4, 136: 2, 145: 4, 147: 3, 151: 3, 152: 3, 154: 3, 161: 3, 162: 3, 165: 3, 168: 4, 169: 2, 172: 2, 180: 3, 184: 5, 187: 5, 188: 4, 191: 3, 194: 4, 202: 5, 203: 6, 206: 2, 207: 3, 215: 2, 217: 3, 218: 8, 220: 2, 221: 2, 222: 5, 224: 3, 227: 3, 229: 2, 234: 5, 235: 2, 241: 2, 242: 2, 243: 4, 244: 3, 245: 4, 248: 3, 250: 2, 258: 11, 262: 4, 263: 5, 264: 3, 267: 4, 272: 2, 273: 5, 287: 3, 289: 2, 291: 4, 299: 3, 309: 3, 314: 2, 315: 2, 320: 4, 323: 4, 327: 4, 328: 3, 329: 2, 330: 10, 334: 2, 341: 3, 342: 4, 347: 3, 348: 3, 350: 7, 351: 4, 352: 2, 353: 2, 358: 4, 365: 2, 366: 2, 371: 5, 372: 4, 376: 2, 384: 4, 385: 3, 386: 3, 392: 3, 393: 4, 396: 4, 397: 7, 398: 6, 402: 2} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 52 "DetNet flow and TSN Stream mapping related information are required only for TSN-aware MPLS (DetNet) nodes. From the Data Plane perspective there is no practical difference based on the origin of flow mapping related information (management plane or control plane)." Similar structure and changes as in IP over TSN . Service protection interworking is out - of - scope . d275ba154e2b7c82eb3ec9175d790214b0e60d3f d275ba154e2b7c82eb3ec9175d790214b0e60d3f draft-ietf-detnet-mpls-over-tsn 8577e49f249e444a03b30a1f6f901d73d9fffc14ead45f0d56e8d2ff59c3301f ['630a7b3cd3eda2e026f158d16d3e4a4a2526a07124cf77aa8ed446ea760814d8', 'b03fd845058850bbf1a630e8c83fada6cba78982283c708236fd7388ffe9fc67', 'c47c152ac014e9bd75ed634d3b9e1c8bb57391b003cba836041c95b95a4c7fa1', 'c69a0fa2ea5f12373344fafbdd44dfb7bb6dbc1860b1c5990feae2a465de298d', '8a1dbabe711db86a26396c01597c528f5fcffb20f047620d5a97dc7303789634', 'e8ac6be9503fe785fadef60b06035db9bcfe02fde1de69193d9a4125a1399c60', '6a32f9bd776a29b7ce3eec373de6fa66bfd90fce56bad4e4eed60abba5aca087', '42f5214bb177fd7faf01b7943e7f313a615b2490f9109d5cefa8b24101735c32', '214810fe3ac0ef76db60e2d0623a8259b9bdf49040882a9e710901fe1eb32fde', '95e8b140a3153d24b8cc5b029501473ba4c08b0343d47a78892b1bad50321f66', 'c7011da30a42dd7b92a21132cfa295b31d66f42863c6a3414b5dbc0e9f38a1ce', 'ae45f508450dea10961ae41868df31a827a51caf984672ba7b53e43ba5e13140', '6808ff9c187a5808b263bc26ce9efc6509eedbd92aebf3bfa16a9ebbb5432f96', '3195c90c03cf6a438b5684cc93128c53f794660a661e2aa85d043ca5ac7060b9', '0246ffa7291c42bc165b0ac6acf1fc7285b5e41537731f44da530521ca5615d1', 'b5bacf05f766e143f6de9484b0b5a2d9655d62854368373bd77974b94cb722e6', '85d25c76743ed7e65b601d54f78150e74c3aa10e4c1b0b383304ba7887314a95', 'ae74a9a2a182dd5a01fd950e728caccd2600bef5390e5cc261e81037cf194a98', 'b94a431eeccea467fb994ae14c1161601ffad908f6fa54e35fd5f89256dacdea', '7ac09938faf2d97ce8bcc3b64b905bb5a585aeb30156506ee7abe2cd36825ed9', '601ac7ed7c06e522c784e0c0c3a976bc1cc9cccb10f550ee9cd153fa5cb3dcdc', '33a143d8274548ab7377f45f1204f1945e0cf20210af64fed99ac8028f48bac4', '1094721b24c22ff67539ffeabab887f87e538bdd9ebe50b0b369de138d326802', '19ad685cffba6309346c1ba7d6f642f0e69af09509b4f36f7ed87231855721a9', 'f34d1af51d3831ee49ed7f59e7135f955e977a1b93bb875be4c690b33a62450b', 'c53eb2c4fe199217644e8f623baca54cd8f18d0cf2746bad70b055d75f0faa23', '314017bb601d7806be2da63e51d3ee14147fa3ac35c6b85ba05825de7c5de742', '39820f7cb577ca0dcfb1bfa578ae13c25334acae03e89731064b0e3c300841de', '3703b0838ce47d992f259e22b20012a302240311d21f2d269cbb1414baec967f', '2605eb6691e33e75449ea67b2cc57cb2055976b481376bd77f71a937e30c3973', '8577e49f249e444a03b30a1f6f901d73d9fffc14ead45f0d56e8d2ff59c3301f', '8c5ca97b799230d82bd3e52e11118044d85a9f0dbf4f81934f31963b8f59d50c', 'ffe5de17213aa105e92776fd207a82f0ccefc1aa38407bb124b44f049f3dd1b8', '61b71fad4b4a688fc63731cab0845c3423c6935ea6d5c188047fbf047ef3a426', 'a491df768673d76ae7dee4c9bf1ea1456e6c537a1f1683368d8bc6869cd89bf0', '72c5a1f410983619d643ec9b1744e623d17c7eea2f68ac99d1881079601873cd', '139b8c43623bbe83d6e84c494389cef4e57e6816c2829cf9bcbb604af1f3bd70', '6de184d7411efde0440a2390c1009b5c1a251195a5c8bb05f6d64de2066a6d83', '7b6435e5d1cd5f5ef5156a6cb776bff4f493bdb11beead1f071fe87b93e78906', 'c5d808132e397aef8874ae2c056109762978e6c0fb6eee327f28541bd3886a04'] B "detnet flow and tsn stream mapping related information are required only for tsn-aware mpls (detnet) nodes. from the data plane perspective there is no practical difference based on the origin of flow mapping related information (management plane or control plane)." {51: 1, 97: 1, 96: 1, 24: 1, 130: 1, 53: 1, 6: 2, 79: 2, 90: 2, 62: 3, 85: 4, 68: 4, 35: 3, 110: 2, 91: 4, 114: 2, 31: 3, 13: 2, 67: 2, 38: 3, 26: 2, 124: 3, 98: 2, 54: 2, 127: 3, 8: 2, 64: 2, 30: 2, 61: 4, 55: 3, 27: 3, 15: 2, 129: 3, 115: 2, 84: 2, 76: 6, 52: 2, 87: 2, 131: 5, 102: 2, 113: 4, 99: 2, 36: 2, 72: 3} {15: 1, 27: 1, 64: 1, 116: 1, 123: 1, 354: 1, 387: 1, 300: 1, 270: 1, 304: 1, 335: 1, 369: 1, 1: 9, 4: 2, 9: 5, 10: 3, 24: 2, 25: 3, 26: 4, 39: 5, 43: 3, 49: 5, 50: 4, 58: 4, 59: 2, 69: 4, 81: 4, 82: 2, 86: 2, 96: 3, 97: 2, 100: 5, 108: 3, 109: 4, 110: 4, 111: 2, 114: 3, 115: 4, 118: 6, 119: 5, 120: 3, 121: 4, 122: 2, 124: 4, 128: 3, 129: 2, 130: 4, 132: 4, 136: 2, 145: 4, 147: 3, 151: 3, 152: 3, 154: 3, 161: 3, 162: 3, 165: 3, 168: 4, 169: 2, 172: 2, 180: 3, 184: 5, 187: 5, 188: 4, 191: 3, 194: 4, 202: 5, 203: 6, 206: 2, 207: 3, 215: 2, 217: 3, 218: 8, 220: 2, 221: 2, 222: 5, 224: 3, 227: 3, 229: 2, 234: 5, 235: 2, 241: 2, 242: 2, 243: 4, 244: 3, 245: 4, 248: 3, 250: 2, 258: 11, 262: 4, 263: 5, 264: 3, 267: 4, 272: 2, 273: 5, 287: 3, 289: 2, 291: 4, 299: 3, 309: 3, 314: 2, 315: 2, 320: 4, 323: 4, 327: 4, 328: 3, 329: 2, 330: 10, 334: 2, 341: 3, 342: 4, 347: 3, 348: 3, 350: 7, 351: 4, 352: 2, 353: 2, 358: 4, 365: 2, 366: 2, 371: 5, 372: 4, 376: 2, 384: 4, 385: 3, 386: 3, 392: 3, 393: 4, 396: 4, 397: 7, 398: 6, 402: 2} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 52 "TSN-aware MPLS DetNet nodes are member of both the DetNet domain and the TSN sub-network. Within the TSN sub-network the TSN-aware MPLS (DetNet) node has a TSN-aware Talker/Listener role, so TSN specific management and control plane functionalities must be implemented. There are many similarities in the management plane techniques used in DetNet and TSN, but that is not the case for the control plane protocols. For example, RSVP-TE and MSRP behaves differently. Therefore management and control plane design is an important aspect of scenarios, where mapping between DetNet and TSN is required." Similar structure and changes as in IP over TSN . Service protection interworking is out - of - scope . d275ba154e2b7c82eb3ec9175d790214b0e60d3f d275ba154e2b7c82eb3ec9175d790214b0e60d3f draft-ietf-detnet-mpls-over-tsn 8c5ca97b799230d82bd3e52e11118044d85a9f0dbf4f81934f31963b8f59d50c ['630a7b3cd3eda2e026f158d16d3e4a4a2526a07124cf77aa8ed446ea760814d8', 'b03fd845058850bbf1a630e8c83fada6cba78982283c708236fd7388ffe9fc67', 'c47c152ac014e9bd75ed634d3b9e1c8bb57391b003cba836041c95b95a4c7fa1', 'c69a0fa2ea5f12373344fafbdd44dfb7bb6dbc1860b1c5990feae2a465de298d', '8a1dbabe711db86a26396c01597c528f5fcffb20f047620d5a97dc7303789634', 'e8ac6be9503fe785fadef60b06035db9bcfe02fde1de69193d9a4125a1399c60', '6a32f9bd776a29b7ce3eec373de6fa66bfd90fce56bad4e4eed60abba5aca087', '42f5214bb177fd7faf01b7943e7f313a615b2490f9109d5cefa8b24101735c32', '214810fe3ac0ef76db60e2d0623a8259b9bdf49040882a9e710901fe1eb32fde', '95e8b140a3153d24b8cc5b029501473ba4c08b0343d47a78892b1bad50321f66', 'c7011da30a42dd7b92a21132cfa295b31d66f42863c6a3414b5dbc0e9f38a1ce', 'ae45f508450dea10961ae41868df31a827a51caf984672ba7b53e43ba5e13140', '6808ff9c187a5808b263bc26ce9efc6509eedbd92aebf3bfa16a9ebbb5432f96', '3195c90c03cf6a438b5684cc93128c53f794660a661e2aa85d043ca5ac7060b9', '0246ffa7291c42bc165b0ac6acf1fc7285b5e41537731f44da530521ca5615d1', 'b5bacf05f766e143f6de9484b0b5a2d9655d62854368373bd77974b94cb722e6', '85d25c76743ed7e65b601d54f78150e74c3aa10e4c1b0b383304ba7887314a95', 'ae74a9a2a182dd5a01fd950e728caccd2600bef5390e5cc261e81037cf194a98', 'b94a431eeccea467fb994ae14c1161601ffad908f6fa54e35fd5f89256dacdea', '7ac09938faf2d97ce8bcc3b64b905bb5a585aeb30156506ee7abe2cd36825ed9', '601ac7ed7c06e522c784e0c0c3a976bc1cc9cccb10f550ee9cd153fa5cb3dcdc', '33a143d8274548ab7377f45f1204f1945e0cf20210af64fed99ac8028f48bac4', '1094721b24c22ff67539ffeabab887f87e538bdd9ebe50b0b369de138d326802', '19ad685cffba6309346c1ba7d6f642f0e69af09509b4f36f7ed87231855721a9', 'f34d1af51d3831ee49ed7f59e7135f955e977a1b93bb875be4c690b33a62450b', 'c53eb2c4fe199217644e8f623baca54cd8f18d0cf2746bad70b055d75f0faa23', '314017bb601d7806be2da63e51d3ee14147fa3ac35c6b85ba05825de7c5de742', '39820f7cb577ca0dcfb1bfa578ae13c25334acae03e89731064b0e3c300841de', '3703b0838ce47d992f259e22b20012a302240311d21f2d269cbb1414baec967f', '2605eb6691e33e75449ea67b2cc57cb2055976b481376bd77f71a937e30c3973', '8577e49f249e444a03b30a1f6f901d73d9fffc14ead45f0d56e8d2ff59c3301f', '8c5ca97b799230d82bd3e52e11118044d85a9f0dbf4f81934f31963b8f59d50c', 'ffe5de17213aa105e92776fd207a82f0ccefc1aa38407bb124b44f049f3dd1b8', '61b71fad4b4a688fc63731cab0845c3423c6935ea6d5c188047fbf047ef3a426', 'a491df768673d76ae7dee4c9bf1ea1456e6c537a1f1683368d8bc6869cd89bf0', '72c5a1f410983619d643ec9b1744e623d17c7eea2f68ac99d1881079601873cd', '139b8c43623bbe83d6e84c494389cef4e57e6816c2829cf9bcbb604af1f3bd70', '6de184d7411efde0440a2390c1009b5c1a251195a5c8bb05f6d64de2066a6d83', '7b6435e5d1cd5f5ef5156a6cb776bff4f493bdb11beead1f071fe87b93e78906', 'c5d808132e397aef8874ae2c056109762978e6c0fb6eee327f28541bd3886a04'] B "tsn-aware mpls detnet nodes are member of both the detnet domain and the tsn sub-network. within the tsn sub-network the tsn-aware mpls (detnet) node has a tsn-aware talker/listener role, so tsn specific management and control plane functionalities must be implemented. there are many similarities in the management plane techniques used in detnet and tsn, but that is not the case for the control plane protocols. for example, rsvp-te and msrp behaves differently. therefore management and control plane design is an important aspect of scenarios, where mapping between detnet and tsn is required." {51: 1, 97: 1, 96: 1, 24: 1, 130: 1, 53: 1, 6: 2, 79: 2, 90: 2, 62: 3, 85: 4, 68: 4, 35: 3, 110: 2, 91: 4, 114: 2, 31: 3, 13: 2, 67: 2, 38: 3, 26: 2, 124: 3, 98: 2, 54: 2, 127: 3, 8: 2, 64: 2, 30: 2, 61: 4, 55: 3, 27: 3, 15: 2, 129: 3, 115: 2, 84: 2, 76: 6, 52: 2, 87: 2, 131: 5, 102: 2, 113: 4, 99: 2, 36: 2, 72: 3} {15: 1, 27: 1, 64: 1, 116: 1, 123: 1, 354: 1, 387: 1, 300: 1, 270: 1, 304: 1, 335: 1, 369: 1, 1: 9, 4: 2, 9: 5, 10: 3, 24: 2, 25: 3, 26: 4, 39: 5, 43: 3, 49: 5, 50: 4, 58: 4, 59: 2, 69: 4, 81: 4, 82: 2, 86: 2, 96: 3, 97: 2, 100: 5, 108: 3, 109: 4, 110: 4, 111: 2, 114: 3, 115: 4, 118: 6, 119: 5, 120: 3, 121: 4, 122: 2, 124: 4, 128: 3, 129: 2, 130: 4, 132: 4, 136: 2, 145: 4, 147: 3, 151: 3, 152: 3, 154: 3, 161: 3, 162: 3, 165: 3, 168: 4, 169: 2, 172: 2, 180: 3, 184: 5, 187: 5, 188: 4, 191: 3, 194: 4, 202: 5, 203: 6, 206: 2, 207: 3, 215: 2, 217: 3, 218: 8, 220: 2, 221: 2, 222: 5, 224: 3, 227: 3, 229: 2, 234: 5, 235: 2, 241: 2, 242: 2, 243: 4, 244: 3, 245: 4, 248: 3, 250: 2, 258: 11, 262: 4, 263: 5, 264: 3, 267: 4, 272: 2, 273: 5, 287: 3, 289: 2, 291: 4, 299: 3, 309: 3, 314: 2, 315: 2, 320: 4, 323: 4, 327: 4, 328: 3, 329: 2, 330: 10, 334: 2, 341: 3, 342: 4, 347: 3, 348: 3, 350: 7, 351: 4, 352: 2, 353: 2, 358: 4, 365: 2, 366: 2, 371: 5, 372: 4, 376: 2, 384: 4, 385: 3, 386: 3, 392: 3, 393: 4, 396: 4, 397: 7, 398: 6, 402: 2} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 52 "In order to use a TSN sub-network between DetNet nodes, DetNet specific information must be converted to TSN sub-network specific ones. DetNet flow ID and flow related parameters/requirements must be converted to a TSN Stream ID and stream related parameters/ requirements. Note that, as the TSN sub-network is just a portion of the end2end DetNet path (i.e., single hop from MPLS perspective), some parameters (e.g., delay) may differ significantly. Other parameters (like bandwidth) also may have to be tuned due to the L2 encapsulation used within the TSN sub-network." Similar structure and changes as in IP over TSN . Service protection interworking is out - of - scope . d275ba154e2b7c82eb3ec9175d790214b0e60d3f d275ba154e2b7c82eb3ec9175d790214b0e60d3f draft-ietf-detnet-mpls-over-tsn c53eb2c4fe199217644e8f623baca54cd8f18d0cf2746bad70b055d75f0faa23 ['630a7b3cd3eda2e026f158d16d3e4a4a2526a07124cf77aa8ed446ea760814d8', 'b03fd845058850bbf1a630e8c83fada6cba78982283c708236fd7388ffe9fc67', 'c47c152ac014e9bd75ed634d3b9e1c8bb57391b003cba836041c95b95a4c7fa1', 'c69a0fa2ea5f12373344fafbdd44dfb7bb6dbc1860b1c5990feae2a465de298d', '8a1dbabe711db86a26396c01597c528f5fcffb20f047620d5a97dc7303789634', 'e8ac6be9503fe785fadef60b06035db9bcfe02fde1de69193d9a4125a1399c60', '6a32f9bd776a29b7ce3eec373de6fa66bfd90fce56bad4e4eed60abba5aca087', '42f5214bb177fd7faf01b7943e7f313a615b2490f9109d5cefa8b24101735c32', '214810fe3ac0ef76db60e2d0623a8259b9bdf49040882a9e710901fe1eb32fde', '95e8b140a3153d24b8cc5b029501473ba4c08b0343d47a78892b1bad50321f66', 'c7011da30a42dd7b92a21132cfa295b31d66f42863c6a3414b5dbc0e9f38a1ce', 'ae45f508450dea10961ae41868df31a827a51caf984672ba7b53e43ba5e13140', '6808ff9c187a5808b263bc26ce9efc6509eedbd92aebf3bfa16a9ebbb5432f96', '3195c90c03cf6a438b5684cc93128c53f794660a661e2aa85d043ca5ac7060b9', '0246ffa7291c42bc165b0ac6acf1fc7285b5e41537731f44da530521ca5615d1', 'b5bacf05f766e143f6de9484b0b5a2d9655d62854368373bd77974b94cb722e6', '85d25c76743ed7e65b601d54f78150e74c3aa10e4c1b0b383304ba7887314a95', 'ae74a9a2a182dd5a01fd950e728caccd2600bef5390e5cc261e81037cf194a98', 'b94a431eeccea467fb994ae14c1161601ffad908f6fa54e35fd5f89256dacdea', '7ac09938faf2d97ce8bcc3b64b905bb5a585aeb30156506ee7abe2cd36825ed9', '601ac7ed7c06e522c784e0c0c3a976bc1cc9cccb10f550ee9cd153fa5cb3dcdc', '33a143d8274548ab7377f45f1204f1945e0cf20210af64fed99ac8028f48bac4', '1094721b24c22ff67539ffeabab887f87e538bdd9ebe50b0b369de138d326802', '19ad685cffba6309346c1ba7d6f642f0e69af09509b4f36f7ed87231855721a9', 'f34d1af51d3831ee49ed7f59e7135f955e977a1b93bb875be4c690b33a62450b', 'c53eb2c4fe199217644e8f623baca54cd8f18d0cf2746bad70b055d75f0faa23', '314017bb601d7806be2da63e51d3ee14147fa3ac35c6b85ba05825de7c5de742', '39820f7cb577ca0dcfb1bfa578ae13c25334acae03e89731064b0e3c300841de', '3703b0838ce47d992f259e22b20012a302240311d21f2d269cbb1414baec967f', '2605eb6691e33e75449ea67b2cc57cb2055976b481376bd77f71a937e30c3973', '8577e49f249e444a03b30a1f6f901d73d9fffc14ead45f0d56e8d2ff59c3301f', '8c5ca97b799230d82bd3e52e11118044d85a9f0dbf4f81934f31963b8f59d50c', 'ffe5de17213aa105e92776fd207a82f0ccefc1aa38407bb124b44f049f3dd1b8', '61b71fad4b4a688fc63731cab0845c3423c6935ea6d5c188047fbf047ef3a426', 'a491df768673d76ae7dee4c9bf1ea1456e6c537a1f1683368d8bc6869cd89bf0', '72c5a1f410983619d643ec9b1744e623d17c7eea2f68ac99d1881079601873cd', '139b8c43623bbe83d6e84c494389cef4e57e6816c2829cf9bcbb604af1f3bd70', '6de184d7411efde0440a2390c1009b5c1a251195a5c8bb05f6d64de2066a6d83', '7b6435e5d1cd5f5ef5156a6cb776bff4f493bdb11beead1f071fe87b93e78906', 'c5d808132e397aef8874ae2c056109762978e6c0fb6eee327f28541bd3886a04'] B "in order to use a tsn sub-network between detnet nodes, detnet specific information must be converted to tsn sub-network specific ones. detnet flow id and flow related parameters/requirements must be converted to a tsn stream id and stream related parameters/ requirements. note that, as the tsn sub-network is just a portion of the end2end detnet path (i.e., single hop from mpls perspective), some parameters (e.g., delay) may differ significantly. other parameters (like bandwidth) also may have to be tuned due to the l2 encapsulation used within the tsn sub-network." {51: 1, 97: 1, 96: 1, 24: 1, 130: 1, 53: 1, 6: 2, 79: 2, 90: 2, 62: 3, 85: 4, 68: 4, 35: 3, 110: 2, 91: 4, 114: 2, 31: 3, 13: 2, 67: 2, 38: 3, 26: 2, 124: 3, 98: 2, 54: 2, 127: 3, 8: 2, 64: 2, 30: 2, 61: 4, 55: 3, 27: 3, 15: 2, 129: 3, 115: 2, 84: 2, 76: 6, 52: 2, 87: 2, 131: 5, 102: 2, 113: 4, 99: 2, 36: 2, 72: 3} {15: 1, 27: 1, 64: 1, 116: 1, 123: 1, 354: 1, 387: 1, 300: 1, 270: 1, 304: 1, 335: 1, 369: 1, 1: 9, 4: 2, 9: 5, 10: 3, 24: 2, 25: 3, 26: 4, 39: 5, 43: 3, 49: 5, 50: 4, 58: 4, 59: 2, 69: 4, 81: 4, 82: 2, 86: 2, 96: 3, 97: 2, 100: 5, 108: 3, 109: 4, 110: 4, 111: 2, 114: 3, 115: 4, 118: 6, 119: 5, 120: 3, 121: 4, 122: 2, 124: 4, 128: 3, 129: 2, 130: 4, 132: 4, 136: 2, 145: 4, 147: 3, 151: 3, 152: 3, 154: 3, 161: 3, 162: 3, 165: 3, 168: 4, 169: 2, 172: 2, 180: 3, 184: 5, 187: 5, 188: 4, 191: 3, 194: 4, 202: 5, 203: 6, 206: 2, 207: 3, 215: 2, 217: 3, 218: 8, 220: 2, 221: 2, 222: 5, 224: 3, 227: 3, 229: 2, 234: 5, 235: 2, 241: 2, 242: 2, 243: 4, 244: 3, 245: 4, 248: 3, 250: 2, 258: 11, 262: 4, 263: 5, 264: 3, 267: 4, 272: 2, 273: 5, 287: 3, 289: 2, 291: 4, 299: 3, 309: 3, 314: 2, 315: 2, 320: 4, 323: 4, 327: 4, 328: 3, 329: 2, 330: 10, 334: 2, 341: 3, 342: 4, 347: 3, 348: 3, 350: 7, 351: 4, 352: 2, 353: 2, 358: 4, 365: 2, 366: 2, 371: 5, 372: 4, 376: 2, 384: 4, 385: 3, 386: 3, 392: 3, 393: 4, 396: 4, 397: 7, 398: 6, 402: 2} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 52 "In some case it may be challenging to determine some TSN Stream related information. For example, on a TSN-aware MPLS (DetNet) node that acts as a Talker, it is quite obvious which DetNet node is the Listener of the mapped TSN stream (i.e., the MPLS Next-Hop). However it may be not trivial to locate the point/interface where that Listener is connected to the TSN sub-network. Such attributes may require interaction between control and management plane functions and between DetNet and TSN domains." Similar structure and changes as in IP over TSN . Service protection interworking is out - of - scope . d275ba154e2b7c82eb3ec9175d790214b0e60d3f d275ba154e2b7c82eb3ec9175d790214b0e60d3f draft-ietf-detnet-mpls-over-tsn b94a431eeccea467fb994ae14c1161601ffad908f6fa54e35fd5f89256dacdea ['630a7b3cd3eda2e026f158d16d3e4a4a2526a07124cf77aa8ed446ea760814d8', 'b03fd845058850bbf1a630e8c83fada6cba78982283c708236fd7388ffe9fc67', 'c47c152ac014e9bd75ed634d3b9e1c8bb57391b003cba836041c95b95a4c7fa1', 'c69a0fa2ea5f12373344fafbdd44dfb7bb6dbc1860b1c5990feae2a465de298d', '8a1dbabe711db86a26396c01597c528f5fcffb20f047620d5a97dc7303789634', 'e8ac6be9503fe785fadef60b06035db9bcfe02fde1de69193d9a4125a1399c60', '6a32f9bd776a29b7ce3eec373de6fa66bfd90fce56bad4e4eed60abba5aca087', '42f5214bb177fd7faf01b7943e7f313a615b2490f9109d5cefa8b24101735c32', '214810fe3ac0ef76db60e2d0623a8259b9bdf49040882a9e710901fe1eb32fde', '95e8b140a3153d24b8cc5b029501473ba4c08b0343d47a78892b1bad50321f66', 'c7011da30a42dd7b92a21132cfa295b31d66f42863c6a3414b5dbc0e9f38a1ce', 'ae45f508450dea10961ae41868df31a827a51caf984672ba7b53e43ba5e13140', '6808ff9c187a5808b263bc26ce9efc6509eedbd92aebf3bfa16a9ebbb5432f96', '3195c90c03cf6a438b5684cc93128c53f794660a661e2aa85d043ca5ac7060b9', '0246ffa7291c42bc165b0ac6acf1fc7285b5e41537731f44da530521ca5615d1', 'b5bacf05f766e143f6de9484b0b5a2d9655d62854368373bd77974b94cb722e6', '85d25c76743ed7e65b601d54f78150e74c3aa10e4c1b0b383304ba7887314a95', 'ae74a9a2a182dd5a01fd950e728caccd2600bef5390e5cc261e81037cf194a98', 'b94a431eeccea467fb994ae14c1161601ffad908f6fa54e35fd5f89256dacdea', '7ac09938faf2d97ce8bcc3b64b905bb5a585aeb30156506ee7abe2cd36825ed9', '601ac7ed7c06e522c784e0c0c3a976bc1cc9cccb10f550ee9cd153fa5cb3dcdc', '33a143d8274548ab7377f45f1204f1945e0cf20210af64fed99ac8028f48bac4', '1094721b24c22ff67539ffeabab887f87e538bdd9ebe50b0b369de138d326802', '19ad685cffba6309346c1ba7d6f642f0e69af09509b4f36f7ed87231855721a9', 'f34d1af51d3831ee49ed7f59e7135f955e977a1b93bb875be4c690b33a62450b', 'c53eb2c4fe199217644e8f623baca54cd8f18d0cf2746bad70b055d75f0faa23', '314017bb601d7806be2da63e51d3ee14147fa3ac35c6b85ba05825de7c5de742', '39820f7cb577ca0dcfb1bfa578ae13c25334acae03e89731064b0e3c300841de', '3703b0838ce47d992f259e22b20012a302240311d21f2d269cbb1414baec967f', '2605eb6691e33e75449ea67b2cc57cb2055976b481376bd77f71a937e30c3973', '8577e49f249e444a03b30a1f6f901d73d9fffc14ead45f0d56e8d2ff59c3301f', '8c5ca97b799230d82bd3e52e11118044d85a9f0dbf4f81934f31963b8f59d50c', 'ffe5de17213aa105e92776fd207a82f0ccefc1aa38407bb124b44f049f3dd1b8', '61b71fad4b4a688fc63731cab0845c3423c6935ea6d5c188047fbf047ef3a426', 'a491df768673d76ae7dee4c9bf1ea1456e6c537a1f1683368d8bc6869cd89bf0', '72c5a1f410983619d643ec9b1744e623d17c7eea2f68ac99d1881079601873cd', '139b8c43623bbe83d6e84c494389cef4e57e6816c2829cf9bcbb604af1f3bd70', '6de184d7411efde0440a2390c1009b5c1a251195a5c8bb05f6d64de2066a6d83', '7b6435e5d1cd5f5ef5156a6cb776bff4f493bdb11beead1f071fe87b93e78906', 'c5d808132e397aef8874ae2c056109762978e6c0fb6eee327f28541bd3886a04'] B "in some case it may be challenging to determine some tsn stream related information. for example, on a tsn-aware mpls (detnet) node that acts as a talker, it is quite obvious which detnet node is the listener of the mapped tsn stream (i.e., the mpls next-hop). however it may be not trivial to locate the point/interface where that listener is connected to the tsn sub-network. such attributes may require interaction between control and management plane functions and between detnet and tsn domains." {51: 1, 97: 1, 96: 1, 24: 1, 130: 1, 53: 1, 6: 2, 79: 2, 90: 2, 62: 3, 85: 4, 68: 4, 35: 3, 110: 2, 91: 4, 114: 2, 31: 3, 13: 2, 67: 2, 38: 3, 26: 2, 124: 3, 98: 2, 54: 2, 127: 3, 8: 2, 64: 2, 30: 2, 61: 4, 55: 3, 27: 3, 15: 2, 129: 3, 115: 2, 84: 2, 76: 6, 52: 2, 87: 2, 131: 5, 102: 2, 113: 4, 99: 2, 36: 2, 72: 3} {15: 1, 27: 1, 64: 1, 116: 1, 123: 1, 354: 1, 387: 1, 300: 1, 270: 1, 304: 1, 335: 1, 369: 1, 1: 9, 4: 2, 9: 5, 10: 3, 24: 2, 25: 3, 26: 4, 39: 5, 43: 3, 49: 5, 50: 4, 58: 4, 59: 2, 69: 4, 81: 4, 82: 2, 86: 2, 96: 3, 97: 2, 100: 5, 108: 3, 109: 4, 110: 4, 111: 2, 114: 3, 115: 4, 118: 6, 119: 5, 120: 3, 121: 4, 122: 2, 124: 4, 128: 3, 129: 2, 130: 4, 132: 4, 136: 2, 145: 4, 147: 3, 151: 3, 152: 3, 154: 3, 161: 3, 162: 3, 165: 3, 168: 4, 169: 2, 172: 2, 180: 3, 184: 5, 187: 5, 188: 4, 191: 3, 194: 4, 202: 5, 203: 6, 206: 2, 207: 3, 215: 2, 217: 3, 218: 8, 220: 2, 221: 2, 222: 5, 224: 3, 227: 3, 229: 2, 234: 5, 235: 2, 241: 2, 242: 2, 243: 4, 244: 3, 245: 4, 248: 3, 250: 2, 258: 11, 262: 4, 263: 5, 264: 3, 267: 4, 272: 2, 273: 5, 287: 3, 289: 2, 291: 4, 299: 3, 309: 3, 314: 2, 315: 2, 320: 4, 323: 4, 327: 4, 328: 3, 329: 2, 330: 10, 334: 2, 341: 3, 342: 4, 347: 3, 348: 3, 350: 7, 351: 4, 352: 2, 353: 2, 358: 4, 365: 2, 366: 2, 371: 5, 372: 4, 376: 2, 384: 4, 385: 3, 386: 3, 392: 3, 393: 4, 396: 4, 397: 7, 398: 6, 402: 2} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 52 "Mapping between DetNet flow identifiers and TSN Stream identifiers, if not provided explicitly, can be done by a TSN-aware MPLS (DetNet) node locally based on information provided for configuration of the TSN Stream identification functions (Mask-and-match Stream identification and active Stream identification function)." Similar structure and changes as in IP over TSN . Service protection interworking is out - of - scope . d275ba154e2b7c82eb3ec9175d790214b0e60d3f d275ba154e2b7c82eb3ec9175d790214b0e60d3f draft-ietf-detnet-mpls-over-tsn f34d1af51d3831ee49ed7f59e7135f955e977a1b93bb875be4c690b33a62450b ['630a7b3cd3eda2e026f158d16d3e4a4a2526a07124cf77aa8ed446ea760814d8', 'b03fd845058850bbf1a630e8c83fada6cba78982283c708236fd7388ffe9fc67', 'c47c152ac014e9bd75ed634d3b9e1c8bb57391b003cba836041c95b95a4c7fa1', 'c69a0fa2ea5f12373344fafbdd44dfb7bb6dbc1860b1c5990feae2a465de298d', '8a1dbabe711db86a26396c01597c528f5fcffb20f047620d5a97dc7303789634', 'e8ac6be9503fe785fadef60b06035db9bcfe02fde1de69193d9a4125a1399c60', '6a32f9bd776a29b7ce3eec373de6fa66bfd90fce56bad4e4eed60abba5aca087', '42f5214bb177fd7faf01b7943e7f313a615b2490f9109d5cefa8b24101735c32', '214810fe3ac0ef76db60e2d0623a8259b9bdf49040882a9e710901fe1eb32fde', '95e8b140a3153d24b8cc5b029501473ba4c08b0343d47a78892b1bad50321f66', 'c7011da30a42dd7b92a21132cfa295b31d66f42863c6a3414b5dbc0e9f38a1ce', 'ae45f508450dea10961ae41868df31a827a51caf984672ba7b53e43ba5e13140', '6808ff9c187a5808b263bc26ce9efc6509eedbd92aebf3bfa16a9ebbb5432f96', '3195c90c03cf6a438b5684cc93128c53f794660a661e2aa85d043ca5ac7060b9', '0246ffa7291c42bc165b0ac6acf1fc7285b5e41537731f44da530521ca5615d1', 'b5bacf05f766e143f6de9484b0b5a2d9655d62854368373bd77974b94cb722e6', '85d25c76743ed7e65b601d54f78150e74c3aa10e4c1b0b383304ba7887314a95', 'ae74a9a2a182dd5a01fd950e728caccd2600bef5390e5cc261e81037cf194a98', 'b94a431eeccea467fb994ae14c1161601ffad908f6fa54e35fd5f89256dacdea', '7ac09938faf2d97ce8bcc3b64b905bb5a585aeb30156506ee7abe2cd36825ed9', '601ac7ed7c06e522c784e0c0c3a976bc1cc9cccb10f550ee9cd153fa5cb3dcdc', '33a143d8274548ab7377f45f1204f1945e0cf20210af64fed99ac8028f48bac4', '1094721b24c22ff67539ffeabab887f87e538bdd9ebe50b0b369de138d326802', '19ad685cffba6309346c1ba7d6f642f0e69af09509b4f36f7ed87231855721a9', 'f34d1af51d3831ee49ed7f59e7135f955e977a1b93bb875be4c690b33a62450b', 'c53eb2c4fe199217644e8f623baca54cd8f18d0cf2746bad70b055d75f0faa23', '314017bb601d7806be2da63e51d3ee14147fa3ac35c6b85ba05825de7c5de742', '39820f7cb577ca0dcfb1bfa578ae13c25334acae03e89731064b0e3c300841de', '3703b0838ce47d992f259e22b20012a302240311d21f2d269cbb1414baec967f', '2605eb6691e33e75449ea67b2cc57cb2055976b481376bd77f71a937e30c3973', '8577e49f249e444a03b30a1f6f901d73d9fffc14ead45f0d56e8d2ff59c3301f', '8c5ca97b799230d82bd3e52e11118044d85a9f0dbf4f81934f31963b8f59d50c', 'ffe5de17213aa105e92776fd207a82f0ccefc1aa38407bb124b44f049f3dd1b8', '61b71fad4b4a688fc63731cab0845c3423c6935ea6d5c188047fbf047ef3a426', 'a491df768673d76ae7dee4c9bf1ea1456e6c537a1f1683368d8bc6869cd89bf0', '72c5a1f410983619d643ec9b1744e623d17c7eea2f68ac99d1881079601873cd', '139b8c43623bbe83d6e84c494389cef4e57e6816c2829cf9bcbb604af1f3bd70', '6de184d7411efde0440a2390c1009b5c1a251195a5c8bb05f6d64de2066a6d83', '7b6435e5d1cd5f5ef5156a6cb776bff4f493bdb11beead1f071fe87b93e78906', 'c5d808132e397aef8874ae2c056109762978e6c0fb6eee327f28541bd3886a04'] B "mapping between detnet flow identifiers and tsn stream identifiers, if not provided explicitly, can be done by a tsn-aware mpls (detnet) node locally based on information provided for configuration of the tsn stream identification functions (mask-and-match stream identification and active stream identification function)." {51: 1, 97: 1, 96: 1, 24: 1, 130: 1, 53: 1, 6: 2, 79: 2, 90: 2, 62: 3, 85: 4, 68: 4, 35: 3, 110: 2, 91: 4, 114: 2, 31: 3, 13: 2, 67: 2, 38: 3, 26: 2, 124: 3, 98: 2, 54: 2, 127: 3, 8: 2, 64: 2, 30: 2, 61: 4, 55: 3, 27: 3, 15: 2, 129: 3, 115: 2, 84: 2, 76: 6, 52: 2, 87: 2, 131: 5, 102: 2, 113: 4, 99: 2, 36: 2, 72: 3} {15: 1, 27: 1, 64: 1, 116: 1, 123: 1, 354: 1, 387: 1, 300: 1, 270: 1, 304: 1, 335: 1, 369: 1, 1: 9, 4: 2, 9: 5, 10: 3, 24: 2, 25: 3, 26: 4, 39: 5, 43: 3, 49: 5, 50: 4, 58: 4, 59: 2, 69: 4, 81: 4, 82: 2, 86: 2, 96: 3, 97: 2, 100: 5, 108: 3, 109: 4, 110: 4, 111: 2, 114: 3, 115: 4, 118: 6, 119: 5, 120: 3, 121: 4, 122: 2, 124: 4, 128: 3, 129: 2, 130: 4, 132: 4, 136: 2, 145: 4, 147: 3, 151: 3, 152: 3, 154: 3, 161: 3, 162: 3, 165: 3, 168: 4, 169: 2, 172: 2, 180: 3, 184: 5, 187: 5, 188: 4, 191: 3, 194: 4, 202: 5, 203: 6, 206: 2, 207: 3, 215: 2, 217: 3, 218: 8, 220: 2, 221: 2, 222: 5, 224: 3, 227: 3, 229: 2, 234: 5, 235: 2, 241: 2, 242: 2, 243: 4, 244: 3, 245: 4, 248: 3, 250: 2, 258: 11, 262: 4, 263: 5, 264: 3, 267: 4, 272: 2, 273: 5, 287: 3, 289: 2, 291: 4, 299: 3, 309: 3, 314: 2, 315: 2, 320: 4, 323: 4, 327: 4, 328: 3, 329: 2, 330: 10, 334: 2, 341: 3, 342: 4, 347: 3, 348: 3, 350: 7, 351: 4, 352: 2, 353: 2, 358: 4, 365: 2, 366: 2, 371: 5, 372: 4, 376: 2, 384: 4, 385: 3, 386: 3, 392: 3, 393: 4, 396: 4, 397: 7, 398: 6, 402: 2} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 52 "Triggering the setup/modification of a TSN Stream in the TSN sub- network is an example where management and/or control plane interactions are required between the DetNet and TSN sub-network. TSN-unaware MPLS (DetNet) nodes make such a triggering even more complicated as they are fully unaware of the sub-network and run independently." Similar structure and changes as in IP over TSN . Service protection interworking is out - of - scope . d275ba154e2b7c82eb3ec9175d790214b0e60d3f d275ba154e2b7c82eb3ec9175d790214b0e60d3f draft-ietf-detnet-mpls-over-tsn c47c152ac014e9bd75ed634d3b9e1c8bb57391b003cba836041c95b95a4c7fa1 ['630a7b3cd3eda2e026f158d16d3e4a4a2526a07124cf77aa8ed446ea760814d8', 'b03fd845058850bbf1a630e8c83fada6cba78982283c708236fd7388ffe9fc67', 'c47c152ac014e9bd75ed634d3b9e1c8bb57391b003cba836041c95b95a4c7fa1', 'c69a0fa2ea5f12373344fafbdd44dfb7bb6dbc1860b1c5990feae2a465de298d', '8a1dbabe711db86a26396c01597c528f5fcffb20f047620d5a97dc7303789634', 'e8ac6be9503fe785fadef60b06035db9bcfe02fde1de69193d9a4125a1399c60', '6a32f9bd776a29b7ce3eec373de6fa66bfd90fce56bad4e4eed60abba5aca087', '42f5214bb177fd7faf01b7943e7f313a615b2490f9109d5cefa8b24101735c32', '214810fe3ac0ef76db60e2d0623a8259b9bdf49040882a9e710901fe1eb32fde', '95e8b140a3153d24b8cc5b029501473ba4c08b0343d47a78892b1bad50321f66', 'c7011da30a42dd7b92a21132cfa295b31d66f42863c6a3414b5dbc0e9f38a1ce', 'ae45f508450dea10961ae41868df31a827a51caf984672ba7b53e43ba5e13140', '6808ff9c187a5808b263bc26ce9efc6509eedbd92aebf3bfa16a9ebbb5432f96', '3195c90c03cf6a438b5684cc93128c53f794660a661e2aa85d043ca5ac7060b9', '0246ffa7291c42bc165b0ac6acf1fc7285b5e41537731f44da530521ca5615d1', 'b5bacf05f766e143f6de9484b0b5a2d9655d62854368373bd77974b94cb722e6', '85d25c76743ed7e65b601d54f78150e74c3aa10e4c1b0b383304ba7887314a95', 'ae74a9a2a182dd5a01fd950e728caccd2600bef5390e5cc261e81037cf194a98', 'b94a431eeccea467fb994ae14c1161601ffad908f6fa54e35fd5f89256dacdea', '7ac09938faf2d97ce8bcc3b64b905bb5a585aeb30156506ee7abe2cd36825ed9', '601ac7ed7c06e522c784e0c0c3a976bc1cc9cccb10f550ee9cd153fa5cb3dcdc', '33a143d8274548ab7377f45f1204f1945e0cf20210af64fed99ac8028f48bac4', '1094721b24c22ff67539ffeabab887f87e538bdd9ebe50b0b369de138d326802', '19ad685cffba6309346c1ba7d6f642f0e69af09509b4f36f7ed87231855721a9', 'f34d1af51d3831ee49ed7f59e7135f955e977a1b93bb875be4c690b33a62450b', 'c53eb2c4fe199217644e8f623baca54cd8f18d0cf2746bad70b055d75f0faa23', '314017bb601d7806be2da63e51d3ee14147fa3ac35c6b85ba05825de7c5de742', '39820f7cb577ca0dcfb1bfa578ae13c25334acae03e89731064b0e3c300841de', '3703b0838ce47d992f259e22b20012a302240311d21f2d269cbb1414baec967f', '2605eb6691e33e75449ea67b2cc57cb2055976b481376bd77f71a937e30c3973', '8577e49f249e444a03b30a1f6f901d73d9fffc14ead45f0d56e8d2ff59c3301f', '8c5ca97b799230d82bd3e52e11118044d85a9f0dbf4f81934f31963b8f59d50c', 'ffe5de17213aa105e92776fd207a82f0ccefc1aa38407bb124b44f049f3dd1b8', '61b71fad4b4a688fc63731cab0845c3423c6935ea6d5c188047fbf047ef3a426', 'a491df768673d76ae7dee4c9bf1ea1456e6c537a1f1683368d8bc6869cd89bf0', '72c5a1f410983619d643ec9b1744e623d17c7eea2f68ac99d1881079601873cd', '139b8c43623bbe83d6e84c494389cef4e57e6816c2829cf9bcbb604af1f3bd70', '6de184d7411efde0440a2390c1009b5c1a251195a5c8bb05f6d64de2066a6d83', '7b6435e5d1cd5f5ef5156a6cb776bff4f493bdb11beead1f071fe87b93e78906', 'c5d808132e397aef8874ae2c056109762978e6c0fb6eee327f28541bd3886a04'] B "triggering the setup/modification of a tsn stream in the tsn sub- network is an example where management and/or control plane interactions are required between the detnet and tsn sub-network. tsn-unaware mpls (detnet) nodes make such a triggering even more complicated as they are fully unaware of the sub-network and run independently." {51: 1, 97: 1, 96: 1, 24: 1, 130: 1, 53: 1, 6: 2, 79: 2, 90: 2, 62: 3, 85: 4, 68: 4, 35: 3, 110: 2, 91: 4, 114: 2, 31: 3, 13: 2, 67: 2, 38: 3, 26: 2, 124: 3, 98: 2, 54: 2, 127: 3, 8: 2, 64: 2, 30: 2, 61: 4, 55: 3, 27: 3, 15: 2, 129: 3, 115: 2, 84: 2, 76: 6, 52: 2, 87: 2, 131: 5, 102: 2, 113: 4, 99: 2, 36: 2, 72: 3} {15: 1, 27: 1, 64: 1, 116: 1, 123: 1, 354: 1, 387: 1, 300: 1, 270: 1, 304: 1, 335: 1, 369: 1, 1: 9, 4: 2, 9: 5, 10: 3, 24: 2, 25: 3, 26: 4, 39: 5, 43: 3, 49: 5, 50: 4, 58: 4, 59: 2, 69: 4, 81: 4, 82: 2, 86: 2, 96: 3, 97: 2, 100: 5, 108: 3, 109: 4, 110: 4, 111: 2, 114: 3, 115: 4, 118: 6, 119: 5, 120: 3, 121: 4, 122: 2, 124: 4, 128: 3, 129: 2, 130: 4, 132: 4, 136: 2, 145: 4, 147: 3, 151: 3, 152: 3, 154: 3, 161: 3, 162: 3, 165: 3, 168: 4, 169: 2, 172: 2, 180: 3, 184: 5, 187: 5, 188: 4, 191: 3, 194: 4, 202: 5, 203: 6, 206: 2, 207: 3, 215: 2, 217: 3, 218: 8, 220: 2, 221: 2, 222: 5, 224: 3, 227: 3, 229: 2, 234: 5, 235: 2, 241: 2, 242: 2, 243: 4, 244: 3, 245: 4, 248: 3, 250: 2, 258: 11, 262: 4, 263: 5, 264: 3, 267: 4, 272: 2, 273: 5, 287: 3, 289: 2, 291: 4, 299: 3, 309: 3, 314: 2, 315: 2, 320: 4, 323: 4, 327: 4, 328: 3, 329: 2, 330: 10, 334: 2, 341: 3, 342: 4, 347: 3, 348: 3, 350: 7, 351: 4, 352: 2, 353: 2, 358: 4, 365: 2, 366: 2, 371: 5, 372: 4, 376: 2, 384: 4, 385: 3, 386: 3, 392: 3, 393: 4, 396: 4, 397: 7, 398: 6, 402: 2} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 52 "Configuration of TSN specific functions (e.g., FRER) inside the TSN sub-network is a TSN domain specific decision and may not be visible in the DetNet domain. Service protection interworking scenarios are left for further study." Similar structure and changes as in IP over TSN . Service protection interworking is out - of - scope . d275ba154e2b7c82eb3ec9175d790214b0e60d3f d275ba154e2b7c82eb3ec9175d790214b0e60d3f draft-ietf-detnet-mpls-over-tsn 601ac7ed7c06e522c784e0c0c3a976bc1cc9cccb10f550ee9cd153fa5cb3dcdc ['630a7b3cd3eda2e026f158d16d3e4a4a2526a07124cf77aa8ed446ea760814d8', 'b03fd845058850bbf1a630e8c83fada6cba78982283c708236fd7388ffe9fc67', 'c47c152ac014e9bd75ed634d3b9e1c8bb57391b003cba836041c95b95a4c7fa1', 'c69a0fa2ea5f12373344fafbdd44dfb7bb6dbc1860b1c5990feae2a465de298d', '8a1dbabe711db86a26396c01597c528f5fcffb20f047620d5a97dc7303789634', 'e8ac6be9503fe785fadef60b06035db9bcfe02fde1de69193d9a4125a1399c60', '6a32f9bd776a29b7ce3eec373de6fa66bfd90fce56bad4e4eed60abba5aca087', '42f5214bb177fd7faf01b7943e7f313a615b2490f9109d5cefa8b24101735c32', '214810fe3ac0ef76db60e2d0623a8259b9bdf49040882a9e710901fe1eb32fde', '95e8b140a3153d24b8cc5b029501473ba4c08b0343d47a78892b1bad50321f66', 'c7011da30a42dd7b92a21132cfa295b31d66f42863c6a3414b5dbc0e9f38a1ce', 'ae45f508450dea10961ae41868df31a827a51caf984672ba7b53e43ba5e13140', '6808ff9c187a5808b263bc26ce9efc6509eedbd92aebf3bfa16a9ebbb5432f96', '3195c90c03cf6a438b5684cc93128c53f794660a661e2aa85d043ca5ac7060b9', '0246ffa7291c42bc165b0ac6acf1fc7285b5e41537731f44da530521ca5615d1', 'b5bacf05f766e143f6de9484b0b5a2d9655d62854368373bd77974b94cb722e6', '85d25c76743ed7e65b601d54f78150e74c3aa10e4c1b0b383304ba7887314a95', 'ae74a9a2a182dd5a01fd950e728caccd2600bef5390e5cc261e81037cf194a98', 'b94a431eeccea467fb994ae14c1161601ffad908f6fa54e35fd5f89256dacdea', '7ac09938faf2d97ce8bcc3b64b905bb5a585aeb30156506ee7abe2cd36825ed9', '601ac7ed7c06e522c784e0c0c3a976bc1cc9cccb10f550ee9cd153fa5cb3dcdc', '33a143d8274548ab7377f45f1204f1945e0cf20210af64fed99ac8028f48bac4', '1094721b24c22ff67539ffeabab887f87e538bdd9ebe50b0b369de138d326802', '19ad685cffba6309346c1ba7d6f642f0e69af09509b4f36f7ed87231855721a9', 'f34d1af51d3831ee49ed7f59e7135f955e977a1b93bb875be4c690b33a62450b', 'c53eb2c4fe199217644e8f623baca54cd8f18d0cf2746bad70b055d75f0faa23', '314017bb601d7806be2da63e51d3ee14147fa3ac35c6b85ba05825de7c5de742', '39820f7cb577ca0dcfb1bfa578ae13c25334acae03e89731064b0e3c300841de', '3703b0838ce47d992f259e22b20012a302240311d21f2d269cbb1414baec967f', '2605eb6691e33e75449ea67b2cc57cb2055976b481376bd77f71a937e30c3973', '8577e49f249e444a03b30a1f6f901d73d9fffc14ead45f0d56e8d2ff59c3301f', '8c5ca97b799230d82bd3e52e11118044d85a9f0dbf4f81934f31963b8f59d50c', 'ffe5de17213aa105e92776fd207a82f0ccefc1aa38407bb124b44f049f3dd1b8', '61b71fad4b4a688fc63731cab0845c3423c6935ea6d5c188047fbf047ef3a426', 'a491df768673d76ae7dee4c9bf1ea1456e6c537a1f1683368d8bc6869cd89bf0', '72c5a1f410983619d643ec9b1744e623d17c7eea2f68ac99d1881079601873cd', '139b8c43623bbe83d6e84c494389cef4e57e6816c2829cf9bcbb604af1f3bd70', '6de184d7411efde0440a2390c1009b5c1a251195a5c8bb05f6d64de2066a6d83', '7b6435e5d1cd5f5ef5156a6cb776bff4f493bdb11beead1f071fe87b93e78906', 'c5d808132e397aef8874ae2c056109762978e6c0fb6eee327f28541bd3886a04'] B "configuration of tsn specific functions (e.g., frer) inside the tsn sub-network is a tsn domain specific decision and may not be visible in the detnet domain. service protection interworking scenarios are left for further study." {51: 1, 97: 1, 96: 1, 24: 1, 130: 1, 53: 1, 6: 2, 79: 2, 90: 2, 62: 3, 85: 4, 68: 4, 35: 3, 110: 2, 91: 4, 114: 2, 31: 3, 13: 2, 67: 2, 38: 3, 26: 2, 124: 3, 98: 2, 54: 2, 127: 3, 8: 2, 64: 2, 30: 2, 61: 4, 55: 3, 27: 3, 15: 2, 129: 3, 115: 2, 84: 2, 76: 6, 52: 2, 87: 2, 131: 5, 102: 2, 113: 4, 99: 2, 36: 2, 72: 3} {15: 1, 27: 1, 64: 1, 116: 1, 123: 1, 354: 1, 387: 1, 300: 1, 270: 1, 304: 1, 335: 1, 369: 1, 1: 9, 4: 2, 9: 5, 10: 3, 24: 2, 25: 3, 26: 4, 39: 5, 43: 3, 49: 5, 50: 4, 58: 4, 59: 2, 69: 4, 81: 4, 82: 2, 86: 2, 96: 3, 97: 2, 100: 5, 108: 3, 109: 4, 110: 4, 111: 2, 114: 3, 115: 4, 118: 6, 119: 5, 120: 3, 121: 4, 122: 2, 124: 4, 128: 3, 129: 2, 130: 4, 132: 4, 136: 2, 145: 4, 147: 3, 151: 3, 152: 3, 154: 3, 161: 3, 162: 3, 165: 3, 168: 4, 169: 2, 172: 2, 180: 3, 184: 5, 187: 5, 188: 4, 191: 3, 194: 4, 202: 5, 203: 6, 206: 2, 207: 3, 215: 2, 217: 3, 218: 8, 220: 2, 221: 2, 222: 5, 224: 3, 227: 3, 229: 2, 234: 5, 235: 2, 241: 2, 242: 2, 243: 4, 244: 3, 245: 4, 248: 3, 250: 2, 258: 11, 262: 4, 263: 5, 264: 3, 267: 4, 272: 2, 273: 5, 287: 3, 289: 2, 291: 4, 299: 3, 309: 3, 314: 2, 315: 2, 320: 4, 323: 4, 327: 4, 328: 3, 329: 2, 330: 10, 334: 2, 341: 3, 342: 4, 347: 3, 348: 3, 350: 7, 351: 4, 352: 2, 353: 2, 358: 4, 365: 2, 366: 2, 371: 5, 372: 4, 376: 2, 384: 4, 385: 3, 386: 3, 392: 3, 393: 4, 396: 4, 397: 7, 398: 6, 402: 2} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 52 "The security considerations of DetNet in general are discussed in I- D.ietf-detnet-architecture and I-D.ietf-detnet-security. DetNet IP data plane specific considerations are summarized in I-D.ietf-detnet- ip. Encryption may provided by an underlying sub-net using MACSec IEEE802.1AE-2018 for DetNet IP over TSN flows." Similar structure and changes as in IP over TSN . Service protection interworking is out - of - scope . d275ba154e2b7c82eb3ec9175d790214b0e60d3f d275ba154e2b7c82eb3ec9175d790214b0e60d3f draft-ietf-detnet-mpls-over-tsn c69a0fa2ea5f12373344fafbdd44dfb7bb6dbc1860b1c5990feae2a465de298d ['630a7b3cd3eda2e026f158d16d3e4a4a2526a07124cf77aa8ed446ea760814d8', 'b03fd845058850bbf1a630e8c83fada6cba78982283c708236fd7388ffe9fc67', 'c47c152ac014e9bd75ed634d3b9e1c8bb57391b003cba836041c95b95a4c7fa1', 'c69a0fa2ea5f12373344fafbdd44dfb7bb6dbc1860b1c5990feae2a465de298d', '8a1dbabe711db86a26396c01597c528f5fcffb20f047620d5a97dc7303789634', 'e8ac6be9503fe785fadef60b06035db9bcfe02fde1de69193d9a4125a1399c60', '6a32f9bd776a29b7ce3eec373de6fa66bfd90fce56bad4e4eed60abba5aca087', '42f5214bb177fd7faf01b7943e7f313a615b2490f9109d5cefa8b24101735c32', '214810fe3ac0ef76db60e2d0623a8259b9bdf49040882a9e710901fe1eb32fde', '95e8b140a3153d24b8cc5b029501473ba4c08b0343d47a78892b1bad50321f66', 'c7011da30a42dd7b92a21132cfa295b31d66f42863c6a3414b5dbc0e9f38a1ce', 'ae45f508450dea10961ae41868df31a827a51caf984672ba7b53e43ba5e13140', '6808ff9c187a5808b263bc26ce9efc6509eedbd92aebf3bfa16a9ebbb5432f96', '3195c90c03cf6a438b5684cc93128c53f794660a661e2aa85d043ca5ac7060b9', '0246ffa7291c42bc165b0ac6acf1fc7285b5e41537731f44da530521ca5615d1', 'b5bacf05f766e143f6de9484b0b5a2d9655d62854368373bd77974b94cb722e6', '85d25c76743ed7e65b601d54f78150e74c3aa10e4c1b0b383304ba7887314a95', 'ae74a9a2a182dd5a01fd950e728caccd2600bef5390e5cc261e81037cf194a98', 'b94a431eeccea467fb994ae14c1161601ffad908f6fa54e35fd5f89256dacdea', '7ac09938faf2d97ce8bcc3b64b905bb5a585aeb30156506ee7abe2cd36825ed9', '601ac7ed7c06e522c784e0c0c3a976bc1cc9cccb10f550ee9cd153fa5cb3dcdc', '33a143d8274548ab7377f45f1204f1945e0cf20210af64fed99ac8028f48bac4', '1094721b24c22ff67539ffeabab887f87e538bdd9ebe50b0b369de138d326802', '19ad685cffba6309346c1ba7d6f642f0e69af09509b4f36f7ed87231855721a9', 'f34d1af51d3831ee49ed7f59e7135f955e977a1b93bb875be4c690b33a62450b', 'c53eb2c4fe199217644e8f623baca54cd8f18d0cf2746bad70b055d75f0faa23', '314017bb601d7806be2da63e51d3ee14147fa3ac35c6b85ba05825de7c5de742', '39820f7cb577ca0dcfb1bfa578ae13c25334acae03e89731064b0e3c300841de', '3703b0838ce47d992f259e22b20012a302240311d21f2d269cbb1414baec967f', '2605eb6691e33e75449ea67b2cc57cb2055976b481376bd77f71a937e30c3973', '8577e49f249e444a03b30a1f6f901d73d9fffc14ead45f0d56e8d2ff59c3301f', '8c5ca97b799230d82bd3e52e11118044d85a9f0dbf4f81934f31963b8f59d50c', 'ffe5de17213aa105e92776fd207a82f0ccefc1aa38407bb124b44f049f3dd1b8', '61b71fad4b4a688fc63731cab0845c3423c6935ea6d5c188047fbf047ef3a426', 'a491df768673d76ae7dee4c9bf1ea1456e6c537a1f1683368d8bc6869cd89bf0', '72c5a1f410983619d643ec9b1744e623d17c7eea2f68ac99d1881079601873cd', '139b8c43623bbe83d6e84c494389cef4e57e6816c2829cf9bcbb604af1f3bd70', '6de184d7411efde0440a2390c1009b5c1a251195a5c8bb05f6d64de2066a6d83', '7b6435e5d1cd5f5ef5156a6cb776bff4f493bdb11beead1f071fe87b93e78906', 'c5d808132e397aef8874ae2c056109762978e6c0fb6eee327f28541bd3886a04'] B "the security considerations of detnet in general are discussed in i- d.ietf-detnet-architecture and i-d.ietf-detnet-security. detnet ip data plane specific considerations are summarized in i-d.ietf-detnet- ip. encryption may provided by an underlying sub-net using macsec ieee802.1ae-2018 for detnet ip over tsn flows." {51: 1, 97: 1, 96: 1, 24: 1, 130: 1, 53: 1, 6: 2, 79: 2, 90: 2, 62: 3, 85: 4, 68: 4, 35: 3, 110: 2, 91: 4, 114: 2, 31: 3, 13: 2, 67: 2, 38: 3, 26: 2, 124: 3, 98: 2, 54: 2, 127: 3, 8: 2, 64: 2, 30: 2, 61: 4, 55: 3, 27: 3, 15: 2, 129: 3, 115: 2, 84: 2, 76: 6, 52: 2, 87: 2, 131: 5, 102: 2, 113: 4, 99: 2, 36: 2, 72: 3} {15: 1, 27: 1, 64: 1, 116: 1, 123: 1, 354: 1, 387: 1, 300: 1, 270: 1, 304: 1, 335: 1, 369: 1, 1: 9, 4: 2, 9: 5, 10: 3, 24: 2, 25: 3, 26: 4, 39: 5, 43: 3, 49: 5, 50: 4, 58: 4, 59: 2, 69: 4, 81: 4, 82: 2, 86: 2, 96: 3, 97: 2, 100: 5, 108: 3, 109: 4, 110: 4, 111: 2, 114: 3, 115: 4, 118: 6, 119: 5, 120: 3, 121: 4, 122: 2, 124: 4, 128: 3, 129: 2, 130: 4, 132: 4, 136: 2, 145: 4, 147: 3, 151: 3, 152: 3, 154: 3, 161: 3, 162: 3, 165: 3, 168: 4, 169: 2, 172: 2, 180: 3, 184: 5, 187: 5, 188: 4, 191: 3, 194: 4, 202: 5, 203: 6, 206: 2, 207: 3, 215: 2, 217: 3, 218: 8, 220: 2, 221: 2, 222: 5, 224: 3, 227: 3, 229: 2, 234: 5, 235: 2, 241: 2, 242: 2, 243: 4, 244: 3, 245: 4, 248: 3, 250: 2, 258: 11, 262: 4, 263: 5, 264: 3, 267: 4, 272: 2, 273: 5, 287: 3, 289: 2, 291: 4, 299: 3, 309: 3, 314: 2, 315: 2, 320: 4, 323: 4, 327: 4, 328: 3, 329: 2, 330: 10, 334: 2, 341: 3, 342: 4, 347: 3, 348: 3, 350: 7, 351: 4, 352: 2, 353: 2, 358: 4, 365: 2, 366: 2, 371: 5, 372: 4, 376: 2, 384: 4, 385: 3, 386: 3, 392: 3, 393: 4, 396: 4, 397: 7, 398: 6, 402: 2} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 51 "This document specifies the Deterministic Networking IP data plane when operating over a TSN network." Reflecting the 9th September discussions . acd7cae2af60dfafe42acdd9936194decc735f93 acd7cae2af60dfafe42acdd9936194decc735f93 draft-ietf-detnet-ip-over-tsn a978cec3e657aee8f50076f0d3e649ed526264fb2ae6884696948c6e17f54e3a ['633ea70b163bc368a42e803fd948789b6ebb631f52b5222285fb6220c36d3a2b', 'a978cec3e657aee8f50076f0d3e649ed526264fb2ae6884696948c6e17f54e3a', '4ed65366e1610aef1bbab5151070f17233fbf8418f787aa49c98cedd2e0e1313', 'bd97bd1fd634bf411f742d25035278f5c722b62a7002bc355cf98f424056a295', 'ac4fad5ceade9e0da8c34db80976dcde72f39347c8a6bdc367ecb0fb2d711e70', 'fb0e6e35656f1cec19cf451b05ee4fda79a70c3051056c56c6054a7998ec2dbb'] A "this document specifies the deterministic networking ip data plane when operating over a tsn network." {124: 1, 127: 1, 30: 1} {22: 1, 131: 1, 254: 1} {131, 157, 22, 254} 51 "This document specifies the DetNet data plane operation for IP hosts and routers that provide DetNet service to IP encapsulated data. No DetNet specific encapsulation is defined to support IP flows, rather existing IP and higher layer protocol header information is used to support flow identification and DetNet service delivery." Reflecting the 9th September discussions . acd7cae2af60dfafe42acdd9936194decc735f93 acd7cae2af60dfafe42acdd9936194decc735f93 draft-ietf-detnet-ip-over-tsn 4ed65366e1610aef1bbab5151070f17233fbf8418f787aa49c98cedd2e0e1313 ['633ea70b163bc368a42e803fd948789b6ebb631f52b5222285fb6220c36d3a2b', 'a978cec3e657aee8f50076f0d3e649ed526264fb2ae6884696948c6e17f54e3a', '4ed65366e1610aef1bbab5151070f17233fbf8418f787aa49c98cedd2e0e1313', 'bd97bd1fd634bf411f742d25035278f5c722b62a7002bc355cf98f424056a295', 'ac4fad5ceade9e0da8c34db80976dcde72f39347c8a6bdc367ecb0fb2d711e70', 'fb0e6e35656f1cec19cf451b05ee4fda79a70c3051056c56c6054a7998ec2dbb'] A "this document specifies the detnet data plane operation for ip hosts and routers that provide detnet service to ip encapsulated data. no detnet specific encapsulation is defined to support ip flows, rather existing ip and higher layer protocol header information is used to support flow identification and detnet service delivery." {124: 1, 127: 1, 30: 1} {22: 1, 131: 1, 254: 1} {131, 157, 22, 254} 51 "The DetNet Architecture decomposes the DetNet related data plane functions into two sub-layers: a service sub-layer and a forwarding sub-layer. The service sub-layer is used to provide DetNet service protection and reordering. The forwarding sub-layer is used to provides congestion protection (low loss, assured latency, and limited reordering). As no DetNet specific headers are added to support DetNet IP flows, only the forwarding sub-layer functions are supported using the DetNet IP defined by this document. Service protection can be provided on a per sub-net basis using technologies such as MPLS I-D.ietf-detnet-dp-sol-mpls and IEEE802.1 TSN." Reflecting the 9th September discussions . acd7cae2af60dfafe42acdd9936194decc735f93 acd7cae2af60dfafe42acdd9936194decc735f93 draft-ietf-detnet-ip-over-tsn bd97bd1fd634bf411f742d25035278f5c722b62a7002bc355cf98f424056a295 ['633ea70b163bc368a42e803fd948789b6ebb631f52b5222285fb6220c36d3a2b', 'a978cec3e657aee8f50076f0d3e649ed526264fb2ae6884696948c6e17f54e3a', '4ed65366e1610aef1bbab5151070f17233fbf8418f787aa49c98cedd2e0e1313', 'bd97bd1fd634bf411f742d25035278f5c722b62a7002bc355cf98f424056a295', 'ac4fad5ceade9e0da8c34db80976dcde72f39347c8a6bdc367ecb0fb2d711e70', 'fb0e6e35656f1cec19cf451b05ee4fda79a70c3051056c56c6054a7998ec2dbb'] A "the detnet architecture decomposes the detnet related data plane functions into two sub-layers: a service sub-layer and a forwarding sub-layer. the service sub-layer is used to provide detnet service protection and reordering. the forwarding sub-layer is used to provides congestion protection (low loss, assured latency, and limited reordering). as no detnet specific headers are added to support detnet ip flows, only the forwarding sub-layer functions are supported using the detnet ip defined by this document. service protection can be provided on a per sub-net basis using technologies such as mpls i-d.ietf-detnet-dp-sol-mpls and ieee802.1 tsn." {124: 1, 127: 1, 30: 1} {22: 1, 131: 1, 254: 1} {131, 157, 22, 254} 51 "This document specifies the Deterministic Networking IP data plane when operating over a TSN sub-network." Reflecting the 9th September discussions . acd7cae2af60dfafe42acdd9936194decc735f93 acd7cae2af60dfafe42acdd9936194decc735f93 draft-ietf-detnet-ip-over-tsn ac4fad5ceade9e0da8c34db80976dcde72f39347c8a6bdc367ecb0fb2d711e70 ['633ea70b163bc368a42e803fd948789b6ebb631f52b5222285fb6220c36d3a2b', 'a978cec3e657aee8f50076f0d3e649ed526264fb2ae6884696948c6e17f54e3a', '4ed65366e1610aef1bbab5151070f17233fbf8418f787aa49c98cedd2e0e1313', 'bd97bd1fd634bf411f742d25035278f5c722b62a7002bc355cf98f424056a295', 'ac4fad5ceade9e0da8c34db80976dcde72f39347c8a6bdc367ecb0fb2d711e70', 'fb0e6e35656f1cec19cf451b05ee4fda79a70c3051056c56c6054a7998ec2dbb'] B "this document specifies the deterministic networking ip data plane when operating over a tsn sub-network." {124: 1, 127: 1, 30: 1} {22: 1, 131: 1, 254: 1} {131, 157, 22, 254} 51 "I-D.ietf-detnet-ip specifies the DetNet data plane operation for IP hosts and routers that provide DetNet service to IP encapsulated data. This document focuses on the scenario where DetNet IP nodes are interconnected by a TSN sub-network." Reflecting the 9th September discussions . acd7cae2af60dfafe42acdd9936194decc735f93 acd7cae2af60dfafe42acdd9936194decc735f93 draft-ietf-detnet-ip-over-tsn 633ea70b163bc368a42e803fd948789b6ebb631f52b5222285fb6220c36d3a2b ['633ea70b163bc368a42e803fd948789b6ebb631f52b5222285fb6220c36d3a2b', 'a978cec3e657aee8f50076f0d3e649ed526264fb2ae6884696948c6e17f54e3a', '4ed65366e1610aef1bbab5151070f17233fbf8418f787aa49c98cedd2e0e1313', 'bd97bd1fd634bf411f742d25035278f5c722b62a7002bc355cf98f424056a295', 'ac4fad5ceade9e0da8c34db80976dcde72f39347c8a6bdc367ecb0fb2d711e70', 'fb0e6e35656f1cec19cf451b05ee4fda79a70c3051056c56c6054a7998ec2dbb'] B "i-d.ietf-detnet-ip specifies the detnet data plane operation for ip hosts and routers that provide detnet service to ip encapsulated data. this document focuses on the scenario where detnet ip nodes are interconnected by a tsn sub-network." {124: 1, 127: 1, 30: 1} {22: 1, 131: 1, 254: 1} {131, 157, 22, 254} 51 "The DetNet Architecture decomposes the DetNet related data plane functions into two sub-layers: a service sub-layer and a forwarding sub-layer. The service sub-layer is used to provide DetNet service protection and reordering. The forwarding sub-layer is used to provides congestion protection (low loss, assured latency, and limited reordering). As described in I-D.ietf-detnet-ip no DetNet specific headers are added to support DetNet IP flows, only the forwarding sub-layer functions are supported inside the DetNet domain. Service protection can be provided on a per sub-network basis as shown here for the IEEE802.1 TSN sub-network scenario." Reflecting the 9th September discussions . acd7cae2af60dfafe42acdd9936194decc735f93 acd7cae2af60dfafe42acdd9936194decc735f93 draft-ietf-detnet-ip-over-tsn fb0e6e35656f1cec19cf451b05ee4fda79a70c3051056c56c6054a7998ec2dbb ['633ea70b163bc368a42e803fd948789b6ebb631f52b5222285fb6220c36d3a2b', 'a978cec3e657aee8f50076f0d3e649ed526264fb2ae6884696948c6e17f54e3a', '4ed65366e1610aef1bbab5151070f17233fbf8418f787aa49c98cedd2e0e1313', 'bd97bd1fd634bf411f742d25035278f5c722b62a7002bc355cf98f424056a295', 'ac4fad5ceade9e0da8c34db80976dcde72f39347c8a6bdc367ecb0fb2d711e70', 'fb0e6e35656f1cec19cf451b05ee4fda79a70c3051056c56c6054a7998ec2dbb'] B "the detnet architecture decomposes the detnet related data plane functions into two sub-layers: a service sub-layer and a forwarding sub-layer. the service sub-layer is used to provide detnet service protection and reordering. the forwarding sub-layer is used to provides congestion protection (low loss, assured latency, and limited reordering). as described in i-d.ietf-detnet-ip no detnet specific headers are added to support detnet ip flows, only the forwarding sub-layer functions are supported inside the detnet domain. service protection can be provided on a per sub-network basis as shown here for the ieee802.1 tsn sub-network scenario." {124: 1, 127: 1, 30: 1} {22: 1, 131: 1, 254: 1} {131, 157, 22, 254} 51 Customer Edge equipment. Reflecting the 9th September discussions . acd7cae2af60dfafe42acdd9936194decc735f93 acd7cae2af60dfafe42acdd9936194decc735f93 draft-ietf-detnet-ip-over-tsn b205fa18b546a1f8079fdb24ae479d6824e7893fbc50608c283e46c6f8365253 ['f26b50ed804ba5111d76706f92b83072518815ec945b0054da2495f47279287a', 'b205fa18b546a1f8079fdb24ae479d6824e7893fbc50608c283e46c6f8365253'] A customer edge equipment. {37: 1, 52: 1, 79: 1, 130: 3, 112: 3, 55: 3, 64: 2, 62: 3, 38: 3, 69: 2, 68: 2, 67: 2, 33: 2, 25: 2, 51: 2, 53: 2, 80: 2, 127: 4, 91: 3} {17: 1, 321: 1, 389: 1, 0: 3, 135: 3, 142: 3, 14: 2, 400: 3, 399: 3, 19: 3, 149: 3, 406: 2, 279: 2, 280: 2, 281: 3, 278: 2, 294: 2, 296: 3, 45: 3, 308: 2, 56: 2, 185: 2, 192: 2, 322: 2, 66: 2, 196: 5, 197: 4, 324: 3, 77: 3, 78: 3, 337: 4, 216: 3, 380: 2, 255: 3} {0, 389, 390, 135, 142, 14, 400, 17, 399, 19, 149, 406, 279, 280, 281, 278, 294, 296, 45, 308, 56, 185, 192, 321, 322, 66, 196, 197, 324, 77, 78, 337, 216, 380, 255} 51 Class of Service. Reflecting the 9th September discussions . acd7cae2af60dfafe42acdd9936194decc735f93 acd7cae2af60dfafe42acdd9936194decc735f93 draft-ietf-detnet-ip-over-tsn f26b50ed804ba5111d76706f92b83072518815ec945b0054da2495f47279287a ['f26b50ed804ba5111d76706f92b83072518815ec945b0054da2495f47279287a', 'b205fa18b546a1f8079fdb24ae479d6824e7893fbc50608c283e46c6f8365253'] A class of service. {37: 1, 52: 1, 79: 1, 130: 3, 112: 3, 55: 3, 64: 2, 62: 3, 38: 3, 69: 2, 68: 2, 67: 2, 33: 2, 25: 2, 51: 2, 53: 2, 80: 2, 127: 4, 91: 3} {17: 1, 321: 1, 389: 1, 0: 3, 135: 3, 142: 3, 14: 2, 400: 3, 399: 3, 19: 3, 149: 3, 406: 2, 279: 2, 280: 2, 281: 3, 278: 2, 294: 2, 296: 3, 45: 3, 308: 2, 56: 2, 185: 2, 192: 2, 322: 2, 66: 2, 196: 5, 197: 4, 324: 3, 77: 3, 78: 3, 337: 4, 216: 3, 380: 2, 255: 3} {0, 389, 390, 135, 142, 14, 400, 17, 399, 19, 149, 406, 279, 280, 281, 278, 294, 296, 45, 308, 56, 185, 192, 321, 322, 66, 196, 197, 324, 77, 78, 337, 216, 380, 255} 51 Label-switched path. Reflecting the 9th September discussions . acd7cae2af60dfafe42acdd9936194decc735f93 acd7cae2af60dfafe42acdd9936194decc735f93 draft-ietf-detnet-ip-over-tsn 691ca00fe04d56eb9f572ba28208d8b944975f2651c940a88bebfb3c02715f64 ['c4eb3cf36ad02a44f1e152d859058b6e744c4f9c62b2738602e0623d7870b6af', 'bb194dc58a0eb7e52501603ff614fb1131422ca453ab5b879033dd20511649fb', '5d1ba8eea8ba53e9a9d0a6d166225ec30fafe99cff8f1aa38baf7ba9ff273aa6', 'f2d0a35630b59810397c15fbd6b63a6fa717172e8c9faefcf6956253be4fc610', 'be783cb488ae6e1275dd4f9d7f0ff96f3649acbf22bd0a4f2c19de4bbaf5add7', 'b44b885a406cb9ec036bed7a2f808cd599fef92864f4ac305f6309a2fb37cb4d', '691ca00fe04d56eb9f572ba28208d8b944975f2651c940a88bebfb3c02715f64', '09f6b6a812132eee463de5625d44082094351e5e01c90e0e4dc14d2893ef6a38'] A label-switched path. {112: 1, 68: 1, 79: 1, 25: 1, 37: 1, 52: 1, 130: 3, 51: 2, 55: 2, 64: 2, 62: 3, 38: 2, 69: 2, 67: 2, 33: 2, 53: 2, 80: 2, 127: 4, 91: 2} {45: 1, 135: 1, 279: 1, 280: 1, 294: 1, 296: 1, 321: 1, 0: 3, 389: 2, 390: 2, 142: 2, 14: 2, 400: 3, 17: 2, 399: 3, 19: 3, 149: 2, 406: 2, 281: 3, 278: 2, 56: 2, 185: 2, 192: 2, 322: 2, 66: 2, 196: 5, 197: 4, 324: 2, 77: 2, 78: 2, 337: 4, 216: 2, 380: 2, 255: 3} {0, 389, 390, 135, 142, 14, 400, 17, 399, 19, 149, 406, 279, 280, 281, 278, 294, 296, 45, 308, 56, 185, 192, 321, 322, 66, 196, 197, 324, 77, 78, 337, 216, 380, 255} 51 Multiprotocol Label Switching. Reflecting the 9th September discussions . acd7cae2af60dfafe42acdd9936194decc735f93 acd7cae2af60dfafe42acdd9936194decc735f93 draft-ietf-detnet-ip-over-tsn 5d1ba8eea8ba53e9a9d0a6d166225ec30fafe99cff8f1aa38baf7ba9ff273aa6 ['c4eb3cf36ad02a44f1e152d859058b6e744c4f9c62b2738602e0623d7870b6af', 'bb194dc58a0eb7e52501603ff614fb1131422ca453ab5b879033dd20511649fb', '5d1ba8eea8ba53e9a9d0a6d166225ec30fafe99cff8f1aa38baf7ba9ff273aa6', 'f2d0a35630b59810397c15fbd6b63a6fa717172e8c9faefcf6956253be4fc610', 'be783cb488ae6e1275dd4f9d7f0ff96f3649acbf22bd0a4f2c19de4bbaf5add7', 'b44b885a406cb9ec036bed7a2f808cd599fef92864f4ac305f6309a2fb37cb4d', '691ca00fe04d56eb9f572ba28208d8b944975f2651c940a88bebfb3c02715f64', '09f6b6a812132eee463de5625d44082094351e5e01c90e0e4dc14d2893ef6a38'] A multiprotocol label switching. {112: 1, 68: 1, 79: 1, 25: 1, 37: 1, 52: 1, 130: 3, 51: 2, 55: 2, 64: 2, 62: 3, 38: 2, 69: 2, 67: 2, 33: 2, 53: 2, 80: 2, 127: 4, 91: 2} {45: 1, 135: 1, 279: 1, 280: 1, 294: 1, 296: 1, 321: 1, 0: 3, 389: 2, 390: 2, 142: 2, 14: 2, 400: 3, 17: 2, 399: 3, 19: 3, 149: 2, 406: 2, 281: 3, 278: 2, 56: 2, 185: 2, 192: 2, 322: 2, 66: 2, 196: 5, 197: 4, 324: 2, 77: 2, 78: 2, 337: 4, 216: 2, 380: 2, 255: 3} {0, 389, 390, 135, 142, 14, 400, 17, 399, 19, 149, 406, 279, 280, 281, 278, 294, 296, 45, 308, 56, 185, 192, 321, 322, 66, 196, 197, 324, 77, 78, 337, 216, 380, 255} 51 Operations, Administration, and Maintenance. Reflecting the 9th September discussions . acd7cae2af60dfafe42acdd9936194decc735f93 acd7cae2af60dfafe42acdd9936194decc735f93 draft-ietf-detnet-ip-over-tsn bb194dc58a0eb7e52501603ff614fb1131422ca453ab5b879033dd20511649fb ['c4eb3cf36ad02a44f1e152d859058b6e744c4f9c62b2738602e0623d7870b6af', 'bb194dc58a0eb7e52501603ff614fb1131422ca453ab5b879033dd20511649fb', '5d1ba8eea8ba53e9a9d0a6d166225ec30fafe99cff8f1aa38baf7ba9ff273aa6', 'f2d0a35630b59810397c15fbd6b63a6fa717172e8c9faefcf6956253be4fc610', 'be783cb488ae6e1275dd4f9d7f0ff96f3649acbf22bd0a4f2c19de4bbaf5add7', 'b44b885a406cb9ec036bed7a2f808cd599fef92864f4ac305f6309a2fb37cb4d', '691ca00fe04d56eb9f572ba28208d8b944975f2651c940a88bebfb3c02715f64', '09f6b6a812132eee463de5625d44082094351e5e01c90e0e4dc14d2893ef6a38'] A operations, administration, and maintenance. {112: 1, 68: 1, 79: 1, 25: 1, 37: 1, 52: 1, 130: 3, 51: 2, 55: 2, 64: 2, 62: 3, 38: 2, 69: 2, 67: 2, 33: 2, 53: 2, 80: 2, 127: 4, 91: 2} {45: 1, 135: 1, 279: 1, 280: 1, 294: 1, 296: 1, 321: 1, 0: 3, 389: 2, 390: 2, 142: 2, 14: 2, 400: 3, 17: 2, 399: 3, 19: 3, 149: 2, 406: 2, 281: 3, 278: 2, 56: 2, 185: 2, 192: 2, 322: 2, 66: 2, 196: 5, 197: 4, 324: 2, 77: 2, 78: 2, 337: 4, 216: 2, 380: 2, 255: 3} {0, 389, 390, 135, 142, 14, 400, 17, 399, 19, 149, 406, 279, 280, 281, 278, 294, 296, 45, 308, 56, 185, 192, 321, 322, 66, 196, 197, 324, 77, 78, 337, 216, 380, 255} 51 Provider Edge. Reflecting the 9th September discussions . acd7cae2af60dfafe42acdd9936194decc735f93 acd7cae2af60dfafe42acdd9936194decc735f93 draft-ietf-detnet-ip-over-tsn be783cb488ae6e1275dd4f9d7f0ff96f3649acbf22bd0a4f2c19de4bbaf5add7 ['c4eb3cf36ad02a44f1e152d859058b6e744c4f9c62b2738602e0623d7870b6af', 'bb194dc58a0eb7e52501603ff614fb1131422ca453ab5b879033dd20511649fb', '5d1ba8eea8ba53e9a9d0a6d166225ec30fafe99cff8f1aa38baf7ba9ff273aa6', 'f2d0a35630b59810397c15fbd6b63a6fa717172e8c9faefcf6956253be4fc610', 'be783cb488ae6e1275dd4f9d7f0ff96f3649acbf22bd0a4f2c19de4bbaf5add7', 'b44b885a406cb9ec036bed7a2f808cd599fef92864f4ac305f6309a2fb37cb4d', '691ca00fe04d56eb9f572ba28208d8b944975f2651c940a88bebfb3c02715f64', '09f6b6a812132eee463de5625d44082094351e5e01c90e0e4dc14d2893ef6a38'] A provider edge. {112: 1, 68: 1, 79: 1, 25: 1, 37: 1, 52: 1, 130: 3, 51: 2, 55: 2, 64: 2, 62: 3, 38: 2, 69: 2, 67: 2, 33: 2, 53: 2, 80: 2, 127: 4, 91: 2} {45: 1, 135: 1, 279: 1, 280: 1, 294: 1, 296: 1, 321: 1, 0: 3, 389: 2, 390: 2, 142: 2, 14: 2, 400: 3, 17: 2, 399: 3, 19: 3, 149: 2, 406: 2, 281: 3, 278: 2, 56: 2, 185: 2, 192: 2, 322: 2, 66: 2, 196: 5, 197: 4, 324: 2, 77: 2, 78: 2, 337: 4, 216: 2, 380: 2, 255: 3} {0, 389, 390, 135, 142, 14, 400, 17, 399, 19, 149, 406, 279, 280, 281, 278, 294, 296, 45, 308, 56, 185, 192, 321, 322, 66, 196, 197, 324, 77, 78, 337, 216, 380, 255} 51 Packet Switched Network. Reflecting the 9th September discussions . acd7cae2af60dfafe42acdd9936194decc735f93 acd7cae2af60dfafe42acdd9936194decc735f93 draft-ietf-detnet-ip-over-tsn b44b885a406cb9ec036bed7a2f808cd599fef92864f4ac305f6309a2fb37cb4d ['c4eb3cf36ad02a44f1e152d859058b6e744c4f9c62b2738602e0623d7870b6af', 'bb194dc58a0eb7e52501603ff614fb1131422ca453ab5b879033dd20511649fb', '5d1ba8eea8ba53e9a9d0a6d166225ec30fafe99cff8f1aa38baf7ba9ff273aa6', 'f2d0a35630b59810397c15fbd6b63a6fa717172e8c9faefcf6956253be4fc610', 'be783cb488ae6e1275dd4f9d7f0ff96f3649acbf22bd0a4f2c19de4bbaf5add7', 'b44b885a406cb9ec036bed7a2f808cd599fef92864f4ac305f6309a2fb37cb4d', '691ca00fe04d56eb9f572ba28208d8b944975f2651c940a88bebfb3c02715f64', '09f6b6a812132eee463de5625d44082094351e5e01c90e0e4dc14d2893ef6a38'] A packet switched network. {112: 1, 68: 1, 79: 1, 25: 1, 37: 1, 52: 1, 130: 3, 51: 2, 55: 2, 64: 2, 62: 3, 38: 2, 69: 2, 67: 2, 33: 2, 53: 2, 80: 2, 127: 4, 91: 2} {45: 1, 135: 1, 279: 1, 280: 1, 294: 1, 296: 1, 321: 1, 0: 3, 389: 2, 390: 2, 142: 2, 14: 2, 400: 3, 17: 2, 399: 3, 19: 3, 149: 2, 406: 2, 281: 3, 278: 2, 56: 2, 185: 2, 192: 2, 322: 2, 66: 2, 196: 5, 197: 4, 324: 2, 77: 2, 78: 2, 337: 4, 216: 2, 380: 2, 255: 3} {0, 389, 390, 135, 142, 14, 400, 17, 399, 19, 149, 406, 279, 280, 281, 278, 294, 296, 45, 308, 56, 185, 192, 321, 322, 66, 196, 197, 324, 77, 78, 337, 216, 380, 255} 51 Pseudowire. Reflecting the 9th September discussions . acd7cae2af60dfafe42acdd9936194decc735f93 acd7cae2af60dfafe42acdd9936194decc735f93 draft-ietf-detnet-ip-over-tsn f2d0a35630b59810397c15fbd6b63a6fa717172e8c9faefcf6956253be4fc610 ['c4eb3cf36ad02a44f1e152d859058b6e744c4f9c62b2738602e0623d7870b6af', 'bb194dc58a0eb7e52501603ff614fb1131422ca453ab5b879033dd20511649fb', '5d1ba8eea8ba53e9a9d0a6d166225ec30fafe99cff8f1aa38baf7ba9ff273aa6', 'f2d0a35630b59810397c15fbd6b63a6fa717172e8c9faefcf6956253be4fc610', 'be783cb488ae6e1275dd4f9d7f0ff96f3649acbf22bd0a4f2c19de4bbaf5add7', 'b44b885a406cb9ec036bed7a2f808cd599fef92864f4ac305f6309a2fb37cb4d', '691ca00fe04d56eb9f572ba28208d8b944975f2651c940a88bebfb3c02715f64', '09f6b6a812132eee463de5625d44082094351e5e01c90e0e4dc14d2893ef6a38'] A pseudowire. {112: 1, 68: 1, 79: 1, 25: 1, 37: 1, 52: 1, 130: 3, 51: 2, 55: 2, 64: 2, 62: 3, 38: 2, 69: 2, 67: 2, 33: 2, 53: 2, 80: 2, 127: 4, 91: 2} {45: 1, 135: 1, 279: 1, 280: 1, 294: 1, 296: 1, 321: 1, 0: 3, 389: 2, 390: 2, 142: 2, 14: 2, 400: 3, 17: 2, 399: 3, 19: 3, 149: 2, 406: 2, 281: 3, 278: 2, 56: 2, 185: 2, 192: 2, 322: 2, 66: 2, 196: 5, 197: 4, 324: 2, 77: 2, 78: 2, 337: 4, 216: 2, 380: 2, 255: 3} {0, 389, 390, 135, 142, 14, 400, 17, 399, 19, 149, 406, 279, 280, 281, 278, 294, 296, 45, 308, 56, 185, 192, 321, 322, 66, 196, 197, 324, 77, 78, 337, 216, 380, 255} 51 Quality of Service. Reflecting the 9th September discussions . acd7cae2af60dfafe42acdd9936194decc735f93 acd7cae2af60dfafe42acdd9936194decc735f93 draft-ietf-detnet-ip-over-tsn 09f6b6a812132eee463de5625d44082094351e5e01c90e0e4dc14d2893ef6a38 ['c4eb3cf36ad02a44f1e152d859058b6e744c4f9c62b2738602e0623d7870b6af', 'bb194dc58a0eb7e52501603ff614fb1131422ca453ab5b879033dd20511649fb', '5d1ba8eea8ba53e9a9d0a6d166225ec30fafe99cff8f1aa38baf7ba9ff273aa6', 'f2d0a35630b59810397c15fbd6b63a6fa717172e8c9faefcf6956253be4fc610', 'be783cb488ae6e1275dd4f9d7f0ff96f3649acbf22bd0a4f2c19de4bbaf5add7', 'b44b885a406cb9ec036bed7a2f808cd599fef92864f4ac305f6309a2fb37cb4d', '691ca00fe04d56eb9f572ba28208d8b944975f2651c940a88bebfb3c02715f64', '09f6b6a812132eee463de5625d44082094351e5e01c90e0e4dc14d2893ef6a38'] A quality of service. {112: 1, 68: 1, 79: 1, 25: 1, 37: 1, 52: 1, 130: 3, 51: 2, 55: 2, 64: 2, 62: 3, 38: 2, 69: 2, 67: 2, 33: 2, 53: 2, 80: 2, 127: 4, 91: 2} {45: 1, 135: 1, 279: 1, 280: 1, 294: 1, 296: 1, 321: 1, 0: 3, 389: 2, 390: 2, 142: 2, 14: 2, 400: 3, 17: 2, 399: 3, 19: 3, 149: 2, 406: 2, 281: 3, 278: 2, 56: 2, 185: 2, 192: 2, 322: 2, 66: 2, 196: 5, 197: 4, 324: 2, 77: 2, 78: 2, 337: 4, 216: 2, 380: 2, 255: 3} {0, 389, 390, 135, 142, 14, 400, 17, 399, 19, 149, 406, 279, 280, 281, 278, 294, 296, 45, 308, 56, 185, 192, 321, 322, 66, 196, 197, 324, 77, 78, 337, 216, 380, 255} 51 Traffic Engineering. Reflecting the 9th September discussions . acd7cae2af60dfafe42acdd9936194decc735f93 acd7cae2af60dfafe42acdd9936194decc735f93 draft-ietf-detnet-ip-over-tsn c4eb3cf36ad02a44f1e152d859058b6e744c4f9c62b2738602e0623d7870b6af ['c4eb3cf36ad02a44f1e152d859058b6e744c4f9c62b2738602e0623d7870b6af', 'bb194dc58a0eb7e52501603ff614fb1131422ca453ab5b879033dd20511649fb', '5d1ba8eea8ba53e9a9d0a6d166225ec30fafe99cff8f1aa38baf7ba9ff273aa6', 'f2d0a35630b59810397c15fbd6b63a6fa717172e8c9faefcf6956253be4fc610', 'be783cb488ae6e1275dd4f9d7f0ff96f3649acbf22bd0a4f2c19de4bbaf5add7', 'b44b885a406cb9ec036bed7a2f808cd599fef92864f4ac305f6309a2fb37cb4d', '691ca00fe04d56eb9f572ba28208d8b944975f2651c940a88bebfb3c02715f64', '09f6b6a812132eee463de5625d44082094351e5e01c90e0e4dc14d2893ef6a38'] A traffic engineering. {112: 1, 68: 1, 79: 1, 25: 1, 37: 1, 52: 1, 130: 3, 51: 2, 55: 2, 64: 2, 62: 3, 38: 2, 69: 2, 67: 2, 33: 2, 53: 2, 80: 2, 127: 4, 91: 2} {45: 1, 135: 1, 279: 1, 280: 1, 294: 1, 296: 1, 321: 1, 0: 3, 389: 2, 390: 2, 142: 2, 14: 2, 400: 3, 17: 2, 399: 3, 19: 3, 149: 2, 406: 2, 281: 3, 278: 2, 56: 2, 185: 2, 192: 2, 322: 2, 66: 2, 196: 5, 197: 4, 324: 2, 77: 2, 78: 2, 337: 4, 216: 2, 380: 2, 255: 3} {0, 389, 390, 135, 142, 14, 400, 17, 399, 19, 149, 406, 279, 280, 281, 278, 294, 296, 45, 308, 56, 185, 192, 321, 322, 66, 196, 197, 324, 77, 78, 337, 216, 380, 255} 51 "This document describes how IP is used by DetNet nodes, i.e., hosts and routers, to identify DetNet flows and provide a DetNet service. From a data plane perspective, an end-to-end IP model is followed. As mentioned above, existing IP and higher layer protocol header information is used to support flow identification and DetNet service delivery." Reflecting the 9th September discussions . acd7cae2af60dfafe42acdd9936194decc735f93 acd7cae2af60dfafe42acdd9936194decc735f93 draft-ietf-detnet-ip-over-tsn 3ae60bc3f6940127fe723db5325472330078e3e252c6589babfab35377bd72fc ['3ae60bc3f6940127fe723db5325472330078e3e252c6589babfab35377bd72fc', 'bc1030bab097fed8e658a389d5631afe19d7d25160b24de5c706fea451122eb5', 'ffe962a1522858cfb38db38e137a9571725732aa06512837018d7ce20e0cbcf6'] A "this document describes how ip is used by detnet nodes, i.e., hosts and routers, to identify detnet flows and provide a detnet service. from a data plane perspective, an end-to-end ip model is followed. as mentioned above, existing ip and higher layer protocol header information is used to support flow identification and detnet service delivery." {127: 1} {364: 1} {91, 364} 51 "DetNet uses ""6-tuple"" based flow identification, where ""6-tuple"" refers to information carried in IP and higher layer protocol headers. General background on the use of IP headers, and ""5-tuples"", to identify flows and support Quality of Service (QoS) can be found in RFC3670. RFC7657 also provides useful background on the delivery differentiated services (DiffServ) and ""6-tuple"" based flow identification." Reflecting the 9th September discussions . acd7cae2af60dfafe42acdd9936194decc735f93 acd7cae2af60dfafe42acdd9936194decc735f93 draft-ietf-detnet-ip-over-tsn bc1030bab097fed8e658a389d5631afe19d7d25160b24de5c706fea451122eb5 ['3ae60bc3f6940127fe723db5325472330078e3e252c6589babfab35377bd72fc', 'bc1030bab097fed8e658a389d5631afe19d7d25160b24de5c706fea451122eb5', 'ffe962a1522858cfb38db38e137a9571725732aa06512837018d7ce20e0cbcf6'] A "detnet uses ""6-tuple"" based flow identification, where ""6-tuple"" refers to information carried in ip and higher layer protocol headers. general background on the use of ip headers, and ""5-tuples"", to identify flows and support quality of service (qos) can be found in rfc3670. rfc7657 also provides useful background on the delivery differentiated services (diffserv) and ""6-tuple"" based flow identification." {127: 1} {364: 1} {91, 364} 51 "I-D.ietf-detnet-ip describes how IP is used by DetNet nodes, i.e., hosts and routers, to identify DetNet flows and provide a DetNet service. From a data plane perspective, an end-to-end IP model is followed. DetNet uses ""6-tuple"" based flow identification, where ""6-tuple"" refers to information carried in IP and higher layer protocol headers." Reflecting the 9th September discussions . acd7cae2af60dfafe42acdd9936194decc735f93 acd7cae2af60dfafe42acdd9936194decc735f93 draft-ietf-detnet-ip-over-tsn ffe962a1522858cfb38db38e137a9571725732aa06512837018d7ce20e0cbcf6 ['3ae60bc3f6940127fe723db5325472330078e3e252c6589babfab35377bd72fc', 'bc1030bab097fed8e658a389d5631afe19d7d25160b24de5c706fea451122eb5', 'ffe962a1522858cfb38db38e137a9571725732aa06512837018d7ce20e0cbcf6'] B "i-d.ietf-detnet-ip describes how ip is used by detnet nodes, i.e., hosts and routers, to identify detnet flows and provide a detnet service. from a data plane perspective, an end-to-end ip model is followed. detnet uses ""6-tuple"" based flow identification, where ""6-tuple"" refers to information carried in ip and higher layer protocol headers." {127: 1} {364: 1} {91, 364} 51 "fig_ip_detnet_simple illustrates a DetNet enabled IP network. The DetNet enabled end systems originate IP encapsulated traffic that is identified as DetNet flows, relay nodes understand the forwarding requirements of the DetNet flow and ensure that node, interface and sub-network resources are allocated to ensure DetNet service requirements. The dotted line around the Service component of the Relay Nodes indicates that the transit routers are DetNet service aware but do not perform any DetNet service sub-layer function, e.g., PREOF. IEEE 802.1 TSN is an example sub-network type which can provide support for DetNet flows and service. The mapping of DetNet IP flows to TSN streams and TSN protection mechanisms is covered in mapping-tsn." Reflecting the 9th September discussions . acd7cae2af60dfafe42acdd9936194decc735f93 acd7cae2af60dfafe42acdd9936194decc735f93 draft-ietf-detnet-ip-over-tsn 25d7c300f819c5d6a20cacc29a44393629d0b720acce8df0ad0b7adb4c86bcdd ['3897911ddc16e106cd2aefc65701e816a6d2a31a1055f6fd3ac0eb6c899b12d2', '25d7c300f819c5d6a20cacc29a44393629d0b720acce8df0ad0b7adb4c86bcdd', '62b524308c7eb98ad024dca1f2345d42c7d164c0c2df653514e755cead78cdb6', '4e26d4b73aeabbe456b8574eceb475840631aa5ff572588e9e8521eb55c3fc82', '9578df4f362f9cb7b01a0101133311aad5ba40c07927ff78f145186909ac5f2e', '756a947ada8cde75aebfcc9d674fcb06d5c3143ac9f8e40d01e6865d6b8559bc', 'e3b6496b036377dd09d23fec69cd8cae64e0b0b01936a564abc04076dcc55e71', '8090b6d14e467632f5876fb9da62cf017d0a0f609b7954197c60f826e83b1a8b', '2327f197493c9aeb867cb401b66068347b7d28ccc18c7b3206bc515002bbab69', '305c7722e6b3b59e9ffb631e06cb323c063d6d11b5282fd6a6664c1cb8d7ee91', '3c033b34f401247732f7c3c456fa364f5b59db321f46b995f84a3fc30106e78c', '9eae34a80d6c18174e433823135ec5765b2174c62c18b3a4bbbd2754dfbbb557', 'b3b276ab53d2bb9ff622f9b2ea7e7643e0598c3bed12033cbd25e47851d54961', '95b1cf1b9c1b8c110218f611eb22e4a9636010c316f7e3bd7eb262c3cadac5b7', 'fb33aedd1c9ed6cfe6ac52eb357b929114856a1761e4788e0e8ec3bf61c85d66', '31fb84facf4d109f79916db9667a246a641f6a1cf0ac5b8400d7a490f0f93126', 'ec02f75668ae82f22e79616c3d199ed8de8bc9e752bb4a05e8ed0503929be8f1', 'ca8ff5cafc8cf8fe21d5c32033e7eaf2d8d483ee895512f4cc26334b0eb890b8', 'd63c1e6a1bdf1cd69d4641cbe3a8e8fb76b4f85e02a3a5e5fbcc243f0b533a7a', 'f4b5bbc7f31d23db201e9c37bf8bd87f1e7c1a2e4706e438b9755468147aec98', '898ad8e8241a67be9e5e5dfe23d767306499ef91a57f4eca648b6f724c90351d', '09072dce85dbf3ba3c882b977ba54fae8f3b847aa227a9c1f86c33efa19918c0', 'c172b25efec8add4a39ce6b23f7baea5ff6f66e77a192b1363db0a53bf501b4e'] A "fig_ip_detnet_simple illustrates a detnet enabled ip network. the detnet enabled end systems originate ip encapsulated traffic that is identified as detnet flows, relay nodes understand the forwarding requirements of the detnet flow and ensure that node, interface and sub-network resources are allocated to ensure detnet service requirements. the dotted line around the service component of the relay nodes indicates that the transit routers are detnet service aware but do not perform any detnet service sub-layer function, e.g., preof. ieee 802.1 tsn is an example sub-network type which can provide support for detnet flows and service. the mapping of detnet ip flows to tsn streams and tsn protection mechanisms is covered in mapping-tsn." {62: 1, 13: 1, 130: 1, 124: 1, 96: 1, 6: 4, 79: 4, 90: 4, 51: 2, 85: 2, 68: 4, 35: 5, 110: 4, 91: 6, 114: 4, 97: 2, 31: 5, 67: 4, 38: 5, 26: 3, 98: 4, 54: 4, 127: 5, 8: 4, 64: 4, 30: 4, 61: 6, 55: 3, 27: 5, 15: 4, 52: 2, 129: 5, 115: 4, 84: 4, 76: 7, 87: 4, 131: 7, 102: 2, 113: 6, 99: 4, 36: 4, 24: 3, 53: 3, 72: 5} {25: 1, 227: 1, 299: 1, 347: 1, 341: 1, 123: 1, 348: 1, 1: 9, 4: 4, 9: 6, 10: 5, 15: 3, 24: 4, 26: 2, 27: 3, 39: 5, 43: 5, 49: 7, 50: 6, 58: 6, 59: 4, 64: 3, 69: 5, 81: 2, 86: 4, 96: 5, 97: 4, 100: 3, 108: 5, 109: 6, 110: 6, 111: 4, 114: 5, 115: 6, 116: 2, 118: 4, 119: 3, 120: 5, 121: 4, 122: 2, 124: 4, 128: 5, 129: 4, 130: 6, 132: 5, 136: 4, 145: 5, 147: 5, 151: 5, 152: 5, 154: 5, 156: 2, 161: 4, 162: 3, 165: 5, 168: 6, 169: 4, 172: 4, 180: 5, 184: 6, 187: 7, 188: 6, 191: 5, 194: 5, 202: 6, 203: 7, 206: 4, 207: 5, 215: 4, 217: 5, 218: 8, 220: 4, 221: 4, 222: 5, 224: 5, 229: 4, 234: 7, 235: 4, 241: 4, 242: 4, 243: 5, 244: 5, 245: 5, 248: 5, 250: 4, 258: 11, 262: 6, 263: 7, 264: 5, 267: 4, 270: 3, 272: 4, 273: 6, 287: 5, 289: 4, 291: 6, 300: 3, 304: 3, 309: 4, 314: 4, 315: 4, 320: 2, 323: 5, 327: 6, 328: 5, 329: 4, 330: 10, 334: 4, 335: 2, 342: 2, 350: 8, 351: 6, 352: 4, 353: 4, 354: 3, 358: 4, 365: 4, 366: 4, 369: 3, 371: 3, 372: 6, 376: 4, 384: 6, 385: 5, 386: 5, 387: 3, 392: 5, 393: 6, 396: 2, 397: 7, 398: 6, 402: 4} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 51 "Note: The sub-network can represent a TSN, MPLS or IP network segment." Reflecting the 9th September discussions . acd7cae2af60dfafe42acdd9936194decc735f93 acd7cae2af60dfafe42acdd9936194decc735f93 draft-ietf-detnet-ip-over-tsn 3897911ddc16e106cd2aefc65701e816a6d2a31a1055f6fd3ac0eb6c899b12d2 ['3897911ddc16e106cd2aefc65701e816a6d2a31a1055f6fd3ac0eb6c899b12d2', '25d7c300f819c5d6a20cacc29a44393629d0b720acce8df0ad0b7adb4c86bcdd', '62b524308c7eb98ad024dca1f2345d42c7d164c0c2df653514e755cead78cdb6', '4e26d4b73aeabbe456b8574eceb475840631aa5ff572588e9e8521eb55c3fc82', '9578df4f362f9cb7b01a0101133311aad5ba40c07927ff78f145186909ac5f2e', '756a947ada8cde75aebfcc9d674fcb06d5c3143ac9f8e40d01e6865d6b8559bc', 'e3b6496b036377dd09d23fec69cd8cae64e0b0b01936a564abc04076dcc55e71', '8090b6d14e467632f5876fb9da62cf017d0a0f609b7954197c60f826e83b1a8b', '2327f197493c9aeb867cb401b66068347b7d28ccc18c7b3206bc515002bbab69', '305c7722e6b3b59e9ffb631e06cb323c063d6d11b5282fd6a6664c1cb8d7ee91', '3c033b34f401247732f7c3c456fa364f5b59db321f46b995f84a3fc30106e78c', '9eae34a80d6c18174e433823135ec5765b2174c62c18b3a4bbbd2754dfbbb557', 'b3b276ab53d2bb9ff622f9b2ea7e7643e0598c3bed12033cbd25e47851d54961', '95b1cf1b9c1b8c110218f611eb22e4a9636010c316f7e3bd7eb262c3cadac5b7', 'fb33aedd1c9ed6cfe6ac52eb357b929114856a1761e4788e0e8ec3bf61c85d66', '31fb84facf4d109f79916db9667a246a641f6a1cf0ac5b8400d7a490f0f93126', 'ec02f75668ae82f22e79616c3d199ed8de8bc9e752bb4a05e8ed0503929be8f1', 'ca8ff5cafc8cf8fe21d5c32033e7eaf2d8d483ee895512f4cc26334b0eb890b8', 'd63c1e6a1bdf1cd69d4641cbe3a8e8fb76b4f85e02a3a5e5fbcc243f0b533a7a', 'f4b5bbc7f31d23db201e9c37bf8bd87f1e7c1a2e4706e438b9755468147aec98', '898ad8e8241a67be9e5e5dfe23d767306499ef91a57f4eca648b6f724c90351d', '09072dce85dbf3ba3c882b977ba54fae8f3b847aa227a9c1f86c33efa19918c0', 'c172b25efec8add4a39ce6b23f7baea5ff6f66e77a192b1363db0a53bf501b4e'] A "note: the sub-network can represent a tsn, mpls or ip network segment." {62: 1, 13: 1, 130: 1, 124: 1, 96: 1, 6: 4, 79: 4, 90: 4, 51: 2, 85: 2, 68: 4, 35: 5, 110: 4, 91: 6, 114: 4, 97: 2, 31: 5, 67: 4, 38: 5, 26: 3, 98: 4, 54: 4, 127: 5, 8: 4, 64: 4, 30: 4, 61: 6, 55: 3, 27: 5, 15: 4, 52: 2, 129: 5, 115: 4, 84: 4, 76: 7, 87: 4, 131: 7, 102: 2, 113: 6, 99: 4, 36: 4, 24: 3, 53: 3, 72: 5} {25: 1, 227: 1, 299: 1, 347: 1, 341: 1, 123: 1, 348: 1, 1: 9, 4: 4, 9: 6, 10: 5, 15: 3, 24: 4, 26: 2, 27: 3, 39: 5, 43: 5, 49: 7, 50: 6, 58: 6, 59: 4, 64: 3, 69: 5, 81: 2, 86: 4, 96: 5, 97: 4, 100: 3, 108: 5, 109: 6, 110: 6, 111: 4, 114: 5, 115: 6, 116: 2, 118: 4, 119: 3, 120: 5, 121: 4, 122: 2, 124: 4, 128: 5, 129: 4, 130: 6, 132: 5, 136: 4, 145: 5, 147: 5, 151: 5, 152: 5, 154: 5, 156: 2, 161: 4, 162: 3, 165: 5, 168: 6, 169: 4, 172: 4, 180: 5, 184: 6, 187: 7, 188: 6, 191: 5, 194: 5, 202: 6, 203: 7, 206: 4, 207: 5, 215: 4, 217: 5, 218: 8, 220: 4, 221: 4, 222: 5, 224: 5, 229: 4, 234: 7, 235: 4, 241: 4, 242: 4, 243: 5, 244: 5, 245: 5, 248: 5, 250: 4, 258: 11, 262: 6, 263: 7, 264: 5, 267: 4, 270: 3, 272: 4, 273: 6, 287: 5, 289: 4, 291: 6, 300: 3, 304: 3, 309: 4, 314: 4, 315: 4, 320: 2, 323: 5, 327: 6, 328: 5, 329: 4, 330: 10, 334: 4, 335: 2, 342: 2, 350: 8, 351: 6, 352: 4, 353: 4, 354: 3, 358: 4, 365: 4, 366: 4, 369: 3, 371: 3, 372: 6, 376: 4, 384: 6, 385: 5, 386: 5, 387: 3, 392: 5, 393: 6, 396: 2, 397: 7, 398: 6, 402: 4} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 51 "fig_ip_detnet illustrates a variant of fig_ip_detnet_simple, with an MPLS based DetNet network as a sub-network between the relay nodes. It shows a more complex DetNet enabled IP network where an IP flow is mapped to one or more PWs and MPLS (TE) LSPs. The end systems still originate IP encapsulated traffic that is identified as DetNet flows. The relay nodes follow procedures defined in RRR to map each DetNet flow to MPLS LSPs. While not shown, relay nodes can provide service sub-layer functions such as PREOF using DetNet over MPLS, and this is indicated by the solid line for the MPLS facing portion of the Service component. Note that the Transit node is MPLS (TE) LSP aware and performs switching based on MPLS labels, and need not have any specific knowledge of the DetNet service or the corresponding DetNet flow identification. See RRR for details on the mapping of IP flows to MPLS, and I-D.ietf-detnet-dp-sol-mpls for general support of DetNet services using MPLS." Reflecting the 9th September discussions . acd7cae2af60dfafe42acdd9936194decc735f93 acd7cae2af60dfafe42acdd9936194decc735f93 draft-ietf-detnet-ip-over-tsn ec02f75668ae82f22e79616c3d199ed8de8bc9e752bb4a05e8ed0503929be8f1 ['3897911ddc16e106cd2aefc65701e816a6d2a31a1055f6fd3ac0eb6c899b12d2', '25d7c300f819c5d6a20cacc29a44393629d0b720acce8df0ad0b7adb4c86bcdd', '62b524308c7eb98ad024dca1f2345d42c7d164c0c2df653514e755cead78cdb6', '4e26d4b73aeabbe456b8574eceb475840631aa5ff572588e9e8521eb55c3fc82', '9578df4f362f9cb7b01a0101133311aad5ba40c07927ff78f145186909ac5f2e', '756a947ada8cde75aebfcc9d674fcb06d5c3143ac9f8e40d01e6865d6b8559bc', 'e3b6496b036377dd09d23fec69cd8cae64e0b0b01936a564abc04076dcc55e71', '8090b6d14e467632f5876fb9da62cf017d0a0f609b7954197c60f826e83b1a8b', '2327f197493c9aeb867cb401b66068347b7d28ccc18c7b3206bc515002bbab69', '305c7722e6b3b59e9ffb631e06cb323c063d6d11b5282fd6a6664c1cb8d7ee91', '3c033b34f401247732f7c3c456fa364f5b59db321f46b995f84a3fc30106e78c', '9eae34a80d6c18174e433823135ec5765b2174c62c18b3a4bbbd2754dfbbb557', 'b3b276ab53d2bb9ff622f9b2ea7e7643e0598c3bed12033cbd25e47851d54961', '95b1cf1b9c1b8c110218f611eb22e4a9636010c316f7e3bd7eb262c3cadac5b7', 'fb33aedd1c9ed6cfe6ac52eb357b929114856a1761e4788e0e8ec3bf61c85d66', '31fb84facf4d109f79916db9667a246a641f6a1cf0ac5b8400d7a490f0f93126', 'ec02f75668ae82f22e79616c3d199ed8de8bc9e752bb4a05e8ed0503929be8f1', 'ca8ff5cafc8cf8fe21d5c32033e7eaf2d8d483ee895512f4cc26334b0eb890b8', 'd63c1e6a1bdf1cd69d4641cbe3a8e8fb76b4f85e02a3a5e5fbcc243f0b533a7a', 'f4b5bbc7f31d23db201e9c37bf8bd87f1e7c1a2e4706e438b9755468147aec98', '898ad8e8241a67be9e5e5dfe23d767306499ef91a57f4eca648b6f724c90351d', '09072dce85dbf3ba3c882b977ba54fae8f3b847aa227a9c1f86c33efa19918c0', 'c172b25efec8add4a39ce6b23f7baea5ff6f66e77a192b1363db0a53bf501b4e'] A "fig_ip_detnet illustrates a variant of fig_ip_detnet_simple, with an mpls based detnet network as a sub-network between the relay nodes. it shows a more complex detnet enabled ip network where an ip flow is mapped to one or more pws and mpls (te) lsps. the end systems still originate ip encapsulated traffic that is identified as detnet flows. the relay nodes follow procedures defined in rrr to map each detnet flow to mpls lsps. while not shown, relay nodes can provide service sub-layer functions such as preof using detnet over mpls, and this is indicated by the solid line for the mpls facing portion of the service component. note that the transit node is mpls (te) lsp aware and performs switching based on mpls labels, and need not have any specific knowledge of the detnet service or the corresponding detnet flow identification. see rrr for details on the mapping of ip flows to mpls, and i-d.ietf-detnet-dp-sol-mpls for general support of detnet services using mpls." {62: 1, 13: 1, 130: 1, 124: 1, 96: 1, 6: 4, 79: 4, 90: 4, 51: 2, 85: 2, 68: 4, 35: 5, 110: 4, 91: 6, 114: 4, 97: 2, 31: 5, 67: 4, 38: 5, 26: 3, 98: 4, 54: 4, 127: 5, 8: 4, 64: 4, 30: 4, 61: 6, 55: 3, 27: 5, 15: 4, 52: 2, 129: 5, 115: 4, 84: 4, 76: 7, 87: 4, 131: 7, 102: 2, 113: 6, 99: 4, 36: 4, 24: 3, 53: 3, 72: 5} {25: 1, 227: 1, 299: 1, 347: 1, 341: 1, 123: 1, 348: 1, 1: 9, 4: 4, 9: 6, 10: 5, 15: 3, 24: 4, 26: 2, 27: 3, 39: 5, 43: 5, 49: 7, 50: 6, 58: 6, 59: 4, 64: 3, 69: 5, 81: 2, 86: 4, 96: 5, 97: 4, 100: 3, 108: 5, 109: 6, 110: 6, 111: 4, 114: 5, 115: 6, 116: 2, 118: 4, 119: 3, 120: 5, 121: 4, 122: 2, 124: 4, 128: 5, 129: 4, 130: 6, 132: 5, 136: 4, 145: 5, 147: 5, 151: 5, 152: 5, 154: 5, 156: 2, 161: 4, 162: 3, 165: 5, 168: 6, 169: 4, 172: 4, 180: 5, 184: 6, 187: 7, 188: 6, 191: 5, 194: 5, 202: 6, 203: 7, 206: 4, 207: 5, 215: 4, 217: 5, 218: 8, 220: 4, 221: 4, 222: 5, 224: 5, 229: 4, 234: 7, 235: 4, 241: 4, 242: 4, 243: 5, 244: 5, 245: 5, 248: 5, 250: 4, 258: 11, 262: 6, 263: 7, 264: 5, 267: 4, 270: 3, 272: 4, 273: 6, 287: 5, 289: 4, 291: 6, 300: 3, 304: 3, 309: 4, 314: 4, 315: 4, 320: 2, 323: 5, 327: 6, 328: 5, 329: 4, 330: 10, 334: 4, 335: 2, 342: 2, 350: 8, 351: 6, 352: 4, 353: 4, 354: 3, 358: 4, 365: 4, 366: 4, 369: 3, 371: 3, 372: 6, 376: 4, 384: 6, 385: 5, 386: 5, 387: 3, 392: 5, 393: 6, 396: 2, 397: 7, 398: 6, 402: 4} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 51 "fig_non_detnet_ip illustrates another variant of fig_ip_detnet_simple where the end systems are not DetNet aware. In this case, edge nodes sit at the boundary of the DetNet domain and provide DetNet service proxies for the end applications by initiating and terminating DetNet service for the application's IP flows. The existing header information or an approach used for aggregation can be used to support DetNet flow identification." Reflecting the 9th September discussions . acd7cae2af60dfafe42acdd9936194decc735f93 acd7cae2af60dfafe42acdd9936194decc735f93 draft-ietf-detnet-ip-over-tsn 95b1cf1b9c1b8c110218f611eb22e4a9636010c316f7e3bd7eb262c3cadac5b7 ['3897911ddc16e106cd2aefc65701e816a6d2a31a1055f6fd3ac0eb6c899b12d2', '25d7c300f819c5d6a20cacc29a44393629d0b720acce8df0ad0b7adb4c86bcdd', '62b524308c7eb98ad024dca1f2345d42c7d164c0c2df653514e755cead78cdb6', '4e26d4b73aeabbe456b8574eceb475840631aa5ff572588e9e8521eb55c3fc82', '9578df4f362f9cb7b01a0101133311aad5ba40c07927ff78f145186909ac5f2e', '756a947ada8cde75aebfcc9d674fcb06d5c3143ac9f8e40d01e6865d6b8559bc', 'e3b6496b036377dd09d23fec69cd8cae64e0b0b01936a564abc04076dcc55e71', '8090b6d14e467632f5876fb9da62cf017d0a0f609b7954197c60f826e83b1a8b', '2327f197493c9aeb867cb401b66068347b7d28ccc18c7b3206bc515002bbab69', '305c7722e6b3b59e9ffb631e06cb323c063d6d11b5282fd6a6664c1cb8d7ee91', '3c033b34f401247732f7c3c456fa364f5b59db321f46b995f84a3fc30106e78c', '9eae34a80d6c18174e433823135ec5765b2174c62c18b3a4bbbd2754dfbbb557', 'b3b276ab53d2bb9ff622f9b2ea7e7643e0598c3bed12033cbd25e47851d54961', '95b1cf1b9c1b8c110218f611eb22e4a9636010c316f7e3bd7eb262c3cadac5b7', 'fb33aedd1c9ed6cfe6ac52eb357b929114856a1761e4788e0e8ec3bf61c85d66', '31fb84facf4d109f79916db9667a246a641f6a1cf0ac5b8400d7a490f0f93126', 'ec02f75668ae82f22e79616c3d199ed8de8bc9e752bb4a05e8ed0503929be8f1', 'ca8ff5cafc8cf8fe21d5c32033e7eaf2d8d483ee895512f4cc26334b0eb890b8', 'd63c1e6a1bdf1cd69d4641cbe3a8e8fb76b4f85e02a3a5e5fbcc243f0b533a7a', 'f4b5bbc7f31d23db201e9c37bf8bd87f1e7c1a2e4706e438b9755468147aec98', '898ad8e8241a67be9e5e5dfe23d767306499ef91a57f4eca648b6f724c90351d', '09072dce85dbf3ba3c882b977ba54fae8f3b847aa227a9c1f86c33efa19918c0', 'c172b25efec8add4a39ce6b23f7baea5ff6f66e77a192b1363db0a53bf501b4e'] A "fig_non_detnet_ip illustrates another variant of fig_ip_detnet_simple where the end systems are not detnet aware. in this case, edge nodes sit at the boundary of the detnet domain and provide detnet service proxies for the end applications by initiating and terminating detnet service for the application's ip flows. the existing header information or an approach used for aggregation can be used to support detnet flow identification." {62: 1, 13: 1, 130: 1, 124: 1, 96: 1, 6: 4, 79: 4, 90: 4, 51: 2, 85: 2, 68: 4, 35: 5, 110: 4, 91: 6, 114: 4, 97: 2, 31: 5, 67: 4, 38: 5, 26: 3, 98: 4, 54: 4, 127: 5, 8: 4, 64: 4, 30: 4, 61: 6, 55: 3, 27: 5, 15: 4, 52: 2, 129: 5, 115: 4, 84: 4, 76: 7, 87: 4, 131: 7, 102: 2, 113: 6, 99: 4, 36: 4, 24: 3, 53: 3, 72: 5} {25: 1, 227: 1, 299: 1, 347: 1, 341: 1, 123: 1, 348: 1, 1: 9, 4: 4, 9: 6, 10: 5, 15: 3, 24: 4, 26: 2, 27: 3, 39: 5, 43: 5, 49: 7, 50: 6, 58: 6, 59: 4, 64: 3, 69: 5, 81: 2, 86: 4, 96: 5, 97: 4, 100: 3, 108: 5, 109: 6, 110: 6, 111: 4, 114: 5, 115: 6, 116: 2, 118: 4, 119: 3, 120: 5, 121: 4, 122: 2, 124: 4, 128: 5, 129: 4, 130: 6, 132: 5, 136: 4, 145: 5, 147: 5, 151: 5, 152: 5, 154: 5, 156: 2, 161: 4, 162: 3, 165: 5, 168: 6, 169: 4, 172: 4, 180: 5, 184: 6, 187: 7, 188: 6, 191: 5, 194: 5, 202: 6, 203: 7, 206: 4, 207: 5, 215: 4, 217: 5, 218: 8, 220: 4, 221: 4, 222: 5, 224: 5, 229: 4, 234: 7, 235: 4, 241: 4, 242: 4, 243: 5, 244: 5, 245: 5, 248: 5, 250: 4, 258: 11, 262: 6, 263: 7, 264: 5, 267: 4, 270: 3, 272: 4, 273: 6, 287: 5, 289: 4, 291: 6, 300: 3, 304: 3, 309: 4, 314: 4, 315: 4, 320: 2, 323: 5, 327: 6, 328: 5, 329: 4, 330: 10, 334: 4, 335: 2, 342: 2, 350: 8, 351: 6, 352: 4, 353: 4, 354: 3, 358: 4, 365: 4, 366: 4, 369: 3, 371: 3, 372: 6, 376: 4, 384: 6, 385: 5, 386: 5, 387: 3, 392: 5, 393: 6, 396: 2, 397: 7, 398: 6, 402: 4} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 51 "Non-DetNet and DetNet IP packets are identical on the wire. From data plane perspective, the only difference is that there is flow- associated DetNet information on each DetNet node that defines the flow related characteristics and required forwarding behavior. As shown above, edge nodes provide a Service Proxy function that ""associates"" one or more IP flows with the appropriate DetNet flow- specific information and ensures that the receives the proper traffic treatment within the domain." Reflecting the 9th September discussions . acd7cae2af60dfafe42acdd9936194decc735f93 acd7cae2af60dfafe42acdd9936194decc735f93 draft-ietf-detnet-ip-over-tsn b3b276ab53d2bb9ff622f9b2ea7e7643e0598c3bed12033cbd25e47851d54961 ['3897911ddc16e106cd2aefc65701e816a6d2a31a1055f6fd3ac0eb6c899b12d2', '25d7c300f819c5d6a20cacc29a44393629d0b720acce8df0ad0b7adb4c86bcdd', '62b524308c7eb98ad024dca1f2345d42c7d164c0c2df653514e755cead78cdb6', '4e26d4b73aeabbe456b8574eceb475840631aa5ff572588e9e8521eb55c3fc82', '9578df4f362f9cb7b01a0101133311aad5ba40c07927ff78f145186909ac5f2e', '756a947ada8cde75aebfcc9d674fcb06d5c3143ac9f8e40d01e6865d6b8559bc', 'e3b6496b036377dd09d23fec69cd8cae64e0b0b01936a564abc04076dcc55e71', '8090b6d14e467632f5876fb9da62cf017d0a0f609b7954197c60f826e83b1a8b', '2327f197493c9aeb867cb401b66068347b7d28ccc18c7b3206bc515002bbab69', '305c7722e6b3b59e9ffb631e06cb323c063d6d11b5282fd6a6664c1cb8d7ee91', '3c033b34f401247732f7c3c456fa364f5b59db321f46b995f84a3fc30106e78c', '9eae34a80d6c18174e433823135ec5765b2174c62c18b3a4bbbd2754dfbbb557', 'b3b276ab53d2bb9ff622f9b2ea7e7643e0598c3bed12033cbd25e47851d54961', '95b1cf1b9c1b8c110218f611eb22e4a9636010c316f7e3bd7eb262c3cadac5b7', 'fb33aedd1c9ed6cfe6ac52eb357b929114856a1761e4788e0e8ec3bf61c85d66', '31fb84facf4d109f79916db9667a246a641f6a1cf0ac5b8400d7a490f0f93126', 'ec02f75668ae82f22e79616c3d199ed8de8bc9e752bb4a05e8ed0503929be8f1', 'ca8ff5cafc8cf8fe21d5c32033e7eaf2d8d483ee895512f4cc26334b0eb890b8', 'd63c1e6a1bdf1cd69d4641cbe3a8e8fb76b4f85e02a3a5e5fbcc243f0b533a7a', 'f4b5bbc7f31d23db201e9c37bf8bd87f1e7c1a2e4706e438b9755468147aec98', '898ad8e8241a67be9e5e5dfe23d767306499ef91a57f4eca648b6f724c90351d', '09072dce85dbf3ba3c882b977ba54fae8f3b847aa227a9c1f86c33efa19918c0', 'c172b25efec8add4a39ce6b23f7baea5ff6f66e77a192b1363db0a53bf501b4e'] A "non-detnet and detnet ip packets are identical on the wire. from data plane perspective, the only difference is that there is flow- associated detnet information on each detnet node that defines the flow related characteristics and required forwarding behavior. as shown above, edge nodes provide a service proxy function that ""associates"" one or more ip flows with the appropriate detnet flow- specific information and ensures that the receives the proper traffic treatment within the domain." {62: 1, 13: 1, 130: 1, 124: 1, 96: 1, 6: 4, 79: 4, 90: 4, 51: 2, 85: 2, 68: 4, 35: 5, 110: 4, 91: 6, 114: 4, 97: 2, 31: 5, 67: 4, 38: 5, 26: 3, 98: 4, 54: 4, 127: 5, 8: 4, 64: 4, 30: 4, 61: 6, 55: 3, 27: 5, 15: 4, 52: 2, 129: 5, 115: 4, 84: 4, 76: 7, 87: 4, 131: 7, 102: 2, 113: 6, 99: 4, 36: 4, 24: 3, 53: 3, 72: 5} {25: 1, 227: 1, 299: 1, 347: 1, 341: 1, 123: 1, 348: 1, 1: 9, 4: 4, 9: 6, 10: 5, 15: 3, 24: 4, 26: 2, 27: 3, 39: 5, 43: 5, 49: 7, 50: 6, 58: 6, 59: 4, 64: 3, 69: 5, 81: 2, 86: 4, 96: 5, 97: 4, 100: 3, 108: 5, 109: 6, 110: 6, 111: 4, 114: 5, 115: 6, 116: 2, 118: 4, 119: 3, 120: 5, 121: 4, 122: 2, 124: 4, 128: 5, 129: 4, 130: 6, 132: 5, 136: 4, 145: 5, 147: 5, 151: 5, 152: 5, 154: 5, 156: 2, 161: 4, 162: 3, 165: 5, 168: 6, 169: 4, 172: 4, 180: 5, 184: 6, 187: 7, 188: 6, 191: 5, 194: 5, 202: 6, 203: 7, 206: 4, 207: 5, 215: 4, 217: 5, 218: 8, 220: 4, 221: 4, 222: 5, 224: 5, 229: 4, 234: 7, 235: 4, 241: 4, 242: 4, 243: 5, 244: 5, 245: 5, 248: 5, 250: 4, 258: 11, 262: 6, 263: 7, 264: 5, 267: 4, 270: 3, 272: 4, 273: 6, 287: 5, 289: 4, 291: 6, 300: 3, 304: 3, 309: 4, 314: 4, 315: 4, 320: 2, 323: 5, 327: 6, 328: 5, 329: 4, 330: 10, 334: 4, 335: 2, 342: 2, 350: 8, 351: 6, 352: 4, 353: 4, 354: 3, 358: 4, 365: 4, 366: 4, 369: 3, 371: 3, 372: 6, 376: 4, 384: 6, 385: 5, 386: 5, 387: 3, 392: 5, 393: 6, 396: 2, 397: 7, 398: 6, 402: 4} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 51 "Note: The operation of IEEE802.1 TSN end systems over DetNet enabled IP networks is not described in this document. While TSN flows could be encapsulated in IP packets by an IP End System or DetNet Edge Node in order to produce DetNet IP flows, the details of such are out of scope of this document." Reflecting the 9th September discussions . acd7cae2af60dfafe42acdd9936194decc735f93 acd7cae2af60dfafe42acdd9936194decc735f93 draft-ietf-detnet-ip-over-tsn 756a947ada8cde75aebfcc9d674fcb06d5c3143ac9f8e40d01e6865d6b8559bc ['3897911ddc16e106cd2aefc65701e816a6d2a31a1055f6fd3ac0eb6c899b12d2', '25d7c300f819c5d6a20cacc29a44393629d0b720acce8df0ad0b7adb4c86bcdd', '62b524308c7eb98ad024dca1f2345d42c7d164c0c2df653514e755cead78cdb6', '4e26d4b73aeabbe456b8574eceb475840631aa5ff572588e9e8521eb55c3fc82', '9578df4f362f9cb7b01a0101133311aad5ba40c07927ff78f145186909ac5f2e', '756a947ada8cde75aebfcc9d674fcb06d5c3143ac9f8e40d01e6865d6b8559bc', 'e3b6496b036377dd09d23fec69cd8cae64e0b0b01936a564abc04076dcc55e71', '8090b6d14e467632f5876fb9da62cf017d0a0f609b7954197c60f826e83b1a8b', '2327f197493c9aeb867cb401b66068347b7d28ccc18c7b3206bc515002bbab69', '305c7722e6b3b59e9ffb631e06cb323c063d6d11b5282fd6a6664c1cb8d7ee91', '3c033b34f401247732f7c3c456fa364f5b59db321f46b995f84a3fc30106e78c', '9eae34a80d6c18174e433823135ec5765b2174c62c18b3a4bbbd2754dfbbb557', 'b3b276ab53d2bb9ff622f9b2ea7e7643e0598c3bed12033cbd25e47851d54961', '95b1cf1b9c1b8c110218f611eb22e4a9636010c316f7e3bd7eb262c3cadac5b7', 'fb33aedd1c9ed6cfe6ac52eb357b929114856a1761e4788e0e8ec3bf61c85d66', '31fb84facf4d109f79916db9667a246a641f6a1cf0ac5b8400d7a490f0f93126', 'ec02f75668ae82f22e79616c3d199ed8de8bc9e752bb4a05e8ed0503929be8f1', 'ca8ff5cafc8cf8fe21d5c32033e7eaf2d8d483ee895512f4cc26334b0eb890b8', 'd63c1e6a1bdf1cd69d4641cbe3a8e8fb76b4f85e02a3a5e5fbcc243f0b533a7a', 'f4b5bbc7f31d23db201e9c37bf8bd87f1e7c1a2e4706e438b9755468147aec98', '898ad8e8241a67be9e5e5dfe23d767306499ef91a57f4eca648b6f724c90351d', '09072dce85dbf3ba3c882b977ba54fae8f3b847aa227a9c1f86c33efa19918c0', 'c172b25efec8add4a39ce6b23f7baea5ff6f66e77a192b1363db0a53bf501b4e'] A "note: the operation of ieee802.1 tsn end systems over detnet enabled ip networks is not described in this document. while tsn flows could be encapsulated in ip packets by an ip end system or detnet edge node in order to produce detnet ip flows, the details of such are out of scope of this document." {62: 1, 13: 1, 130: 1, 124: 1, 96: 1, 6: 4, 79: 4, 90: 4, 51: 2, 85: 2, 68: 4, 35: 5, 110: 4, 91: 6, 114: 4, 97: 2, 31: 5, 67: 4, 38: 5, 26: 3, 98: 4, 54: 4, 127: 5, 8: 4, 64: 4, 30: 4, 61: 6, 55: 3, 27: 5, 15: 4, 52: 2, 129: 5, 115: 4, 84: 4, 76: 7, 87: 4, 131: 7, 102: 2, 113: 6, 99: 4, 36: 4, 24: 3, 53: 3, 72: 5} {25: 1, 227: 1, 299: 1, 347: 1, 341: 1, 123: 1, 348: 1, 1: 9, 4: 4, 9: 6, 10: 5, 15: 3, 24: 4, 26: 2, 27: 3, 39: 5, 43: 5, 49: 7, 50: 6, 58: 6, 59: 4, 64: 3, 69: 5, 81: 2, 86: 4, 96: 5, 97: 4, 100: 3, 108: 5, 109: 6, 110: 6, 111: 4, 114: 5, 115: 6, 116: 2, 118: 4, 119: 3, 120: 5, 121: 4, 122: 2, 124: 4, 128: 5, 129: 4, 130: 6, 132: 5, 136: 4, 145: 5, 147: 5, 151: 5, 152: 5, 154: 5, 156: 2, 161: 4, 162: 3, 165: 5, 168: 6, 169: 4, 172: 4, 180: 5, 184: 6, 187: 7, 188: 6, 191: 5, 194: 5, 202: 6, 203: 7, 206: 4, 207: 5, 215: 4, 217: 5, 218: 8, 220: 4, 221: 4, 222: 5, 224: 5, 229: 4, 234: 7, 235: 4, 241: 4, 242: 4, 243: 5, 244: 5, 245: 5, 248: 5, 250: 4, 258: 11, 262: 6, 263: 7, 264: 5, 267: 4, 270: 3, 272: 4, 273: 6, 287: 5, 289: 4, 291: 6, 300: 3, 304: 3, 309: 4, 314: 4, 315: 4, 320: 2, 323: 5, 327: 6, 328: 5, 329: 4, 330: 10, 334: 4, 335: 2, 342: 2, 350: 8, 351: 6, 352: 4, 353: 4, 354: 3, 358: 4, 365: 4, 366: 4, 369: 3, 371: 3, 372: 6, 376: 4, 384: 6, 385: 5, 386: 5, 387: 3, 392: 5, 393: 6, 396: 2, 397: 7, 398: 6, 402: 4} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 51 "Within a DetNet domain, the DetNet enabled IP Routers interconnect links and sub-networks to support end-to-end delivery of DetNet flows. From a DetNet architecture perspective, these routers are DetNet relays, as they must be DetNet service aware. Such routers identify DetNet flows based on the IP 6-tuple, and ensure that the DetNet service required traffic treatment is provided both on the node and on any attached sub-network." Reflecting the 9th September discussions . acd7cae2af60dfafe42acdd9936194decc735f93 acd7cae2af60dfafe42acdd9936194decc735f93 draft-ietf-detnet-ip-over-tsn 9578df4f362f9cb7b01a0101133311aad5ba40c07927ff78f145186909ac5f2e ['3897911ddc16e106cd2aefc65701e816a6d2a31a1055f6fd3ac0eb6c899b12d2', '25d7c300f819c5d6a20cacc29a44393629d0b720acce8df0ad0b7adb4c86bcdd', '62b524308c7eb98ad024dca1f2345d42c7d164c0c2df653514e755cead78cdb6', '4e26d4b73aeabbe456b8574eceb475840631aa5ff572588e9e8521eb55c3fc82', '9578df4f362f9cb7b01a0101133311aad5ba40c07927ff78f145186909ac5f2e', '756a947ada8cde75aebfcc9d674fcb06d5c3143ac9f8e40d01e6865d6b8559bc', 'e3b6496b036377dd09d23fec69cd8cae64e0b0b01936a564abc04076dcc55e71', '8090b6d14e467632f5876fb9da62cf017d0a0f609b7954197c60f826e83b1a8b', '2327f197493c9aeb867cb401b66068347b7d28ccc18c7b3206bc515002bbab69', '305c7722e6b3b59e9ffb631e06cb323c063d6d11b5282fd6a6664c1cb8d7ee91', '3c033b34f401247732f7c3c456fa364f5b59db321f46b995f84a3fc30106e78c', '9eae34a80d6c18174e433823135ec5765b2174c62c18b3a4bbbd2754dfbbb557', 'b3b276ab53d2bb9ff622f9b2ea7e7643e0598c3bed12033cbd25e47851d54961', '95b1cf1b9c1b8c110218f611eb22e4a9636010c316f7e3bd7eb262c3cadac5b7', 'fb33aedd1c9ed6cfe6ac52eb357b929114856a1761e4788e0e8ec3bf61c85d66', '31fb84facf4d109f79916db9667a246a641f6a1cf0ac5b8400d7a490f0f93126', 'ec02f75668ae82f22e79616c3d199ed8de8bc9e752bb4a05e8ed0503929be8f1', 'ca8ff5cafc8cf8fe21d5c32033e7eaf2d8d483ee895512f4cc26334b0eb890b8', 'd63c1e6a1bdf1cd69d4641cbe3a8e8fb76b4f85e02a3a5e5fbcc243f0b533a7a', 'f4b5bbc7f31d23db201e9c37bf8bd87f1e7c1a2e4706e438b9755468147aec98', '898ad8e8241a67be9e5e5dfe23d767306499ef91a57f4eca648b6f724c90351d', '09072dce85dbf3ba3c882b977ba54fae8f3b847aa227a9c1f86c33efa19918c0', 'c172b25efec8add4a39ce6b23f7baea5ff6f66e77a192b1363db0a53bf501b4e'] A "within a detnet domain, the detnet enabled ip routers interconnect links and sub-networks to support end-to-end delivery of detnet flows. from a detnet architecture perspective, these routers are detnet relays, as they must be detnet service aware. such routers identify detnet flows based on the ip 6-tuple, and ensure that the detnet service required traffic treatment is provided both on the node and on any attached sub-network." {62: 1, 13: 1, 130: 1, 124: 1, 96: 1, 6: 4, 79: 4, 90: 4, 51: 2, 85: 2, 68: 4, 35: 5, 110: 4, 91: 6, 114: 4, 97: 2, 31: 5, 67: 4, 38: 5, 26: 3, 98: 4, 54: 4, 127: 5, 8: 4, 64: 4, 30: 4, 61: 6, 55: 3, 27: 5, 15: 4, 52: 2, 129: 5, 115: 4, 84: 4, 76: 7, 87: 4, 131: 7, 102: 2, 113: 6, 99: 4, 36: 4, 24: 3, 53: 3, 72: 5} {25: 1, 227: 1, 299: 1, 347: 1, 341: 1, 123: 1, 348: 1, 1: 9, 4: 4, 9: 6, 10: 5, 15: 3, 24: 4, 26: 2, 27: 3, 39: 5, 43: 5, 49: 7, 50: 6, 58: 6, 59: 4, 64: 3, 69: 5, 81: 2, 86: 4, 96: 5, 97: 4, 100: 3, 108: 5, 109: 6, 110: 6, 111: 4, 114: 5, 115: 6, 116: 2, 118: 4, 119: 3, 120: 5, 121: 4, 122: 2, 124: 4, 128: 5, 129: 4, 130: 6, 132: 5, 136: 4, 145: 5, 147: 5, 151: 5, 152: 5, 154: 5, 156: 2, 161: 4, 162: 3, 165: 5, 168: 6, 169: 4, 172: 4, 180: 5, 184: 6, 187: 7, 188: 6, 191: 5, 194: 5, 202: 6, 203: 7, 206: 4, 207: 5, 215: 4, 217: 5, 218: 8, 220: 4, 221: 4, 222: 5, 224: 5, 229: 4, 234: 7, 235: 4, 241: 4, 242: 4, 243: 5, 244: 5, 245: 5, 248: 5, 250: 4, 258: 11, 262: 6, 263: 7, 264: 5, 267: 4, 270: 3, 272: 4, 273: 6, 287: 5, 289: 4, 291: 6, 300: 3, 304: 3, 309: 4, 314: 4, 315: 4, 320: 2, 323: 5, 327: 6, 328: 5, 329: 4, 330: 10, 334: 4, 335: 2, 342: 2, 350: 8, 351: 6, 352: 4, 353: 4, 354: 3, 358: 4, 365: 4, 366: 4, 369: 3, 371: 3, 372: 6, 376: 4, 384: 6, 385: 5, 386: 5, 387: 3, 392: 5, 393: 6, 396: 2, 397: 7, 398: 6, 402: 4} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 51 "This solution provides DetNet functions end to end, but does so on a per link and sub-network basis. Congestion protection and latency control and the resource allocation (queuing, policing, shaping) are supported using the underlying link / sub net specific mechanisms. However, service protections (packet replication and packet elimination functions) are not provided at the DetNet layer end to end. But such service protection can be provided on a per underlying L2 link and sub-network basis." Reflecting the 9th September discussions . acd7cae2af60dfafe42acdd9936194decc735f93 acd7cae2af60dfafe42acdd9936194decc735f93 draft-ietf-detnet-ip-over-tsn 62b524308c7eb98ad024dca1f2345d42c7d164c0c2df653514e755cead78cdb6 ['3897911ddc16e106cd2aefc65701e816a6d2a31a1055f6fd3ac0eb6c899b12d2', '25d7c300f819c5d6a20cacc29a44393629d0b720acce8df0ad0b7adb4c86bcdd', '62b524308c7eb98ad024dca1f2345d42c7d164c0c2df653514e755cead78cdb6', '4e26d4b73aeabbe456b8574eceb475840631aa5ff572588e9e8521eb55c3fc82', '9578df4f362f9cb7b01a0101133311aad5ba40c07927ff78f145186909ac5f2e', '756a947ada8cde75aebfcc9d674fcb06d5c3143ac9f8e40d01e6865d6b8559bc', 'e3b6496b036377dd09d23fec69cd8cae64e0b0b01936a564abc04076dcc55e71', '8090b6d14e467632f5876fb9da62cf017d0a0f609b7954197c60f826e83b1a8b', '2327f197493c9aeb867cb401b66068347b7d28ccc18c7b3206bc515002bbab69', '305c7722e6b3b59e9ffb631e06cb323c063d6d11b5282fd6a6664c1cb8d7ee91', '3c033b34f401247732f7c3c456fa364f5b59db321f46b995f84a3fc30106e78c', '9eae34a80d6c18174e433823135ec5765b2174c62c18b3a4bbbd2754dfbbb557', 'b3b276ab53d2bb9ff622f9b2ea7e7643e0598c3bed12033cbd25e47851d54961', '95b1cf1b9c1b8c110218f611eb22e4a9636010c316f7e3bd7eb262c3cadac5b7', 'fb33aedd1c9ed6cfe6ac52eb357b929114856a1761e4788e0e8ec3bf61c85d66', '31fb84facf4d109f79916db9667a246a641f6a1cf0ac5b8400d7a490f0f93126', 'ec02f75668ae82f22e79616c3d199ed8de8bc9e752bb4a05e8ed0503929be8f1', 'ca8ff5cafc8cf8fe21d5c32033e7eaf2d8d483ee895512f4cc26334b0eb890b8', 'd63c1e6a1bdf1cd69d4641cbe3a8e8fb76b4f85e02a3a5e5fbcc243f0b533a7a', 'f4b5bbc7f31d23db201e9c37bf8bd87f1e7c1a2e4706e438b9755468147aec98', '898ad8e8241a67be9e5e5dfe23d767306499ef91a57f4eca648b6f724c90351d', '09072dce85dbf3ba3c882b977ba54fae8f3b847aa227a9c1f86c33efa19918c0', 'c172b25efec8add4a39ce6b23f7baea5ff6f66e77a192b1363db0a53bf501b4e'] A "this solution provides detnet functions end to end, but does so on a per link and sub-network basis. congestion protection and latency control and the resource allocation (queuing, policing, shaping) are supported using the underlying link / sub net specific mechanisms. however, service protections (packet replication and packet elimination functions) are not provided at the detnet layer end to end. but such service protection can be provided on a per underlying l2 link and sub-network basis." {62: 1, 13: 1, 130: 1, 124: 1, 96: 1, 6: 4, 79: 4, 90: 4, 51: 2, 85: 2, 68: 4, 35: 5, 110: 4, 91: 6, 114: 4, 97: 2, 31: 5, 67: 4, 38: 5, 26: 3, 98: 4, 54: 4, 127: 5, 8: 4, 64: 4, 30: 4, 61: 6, 55: 3, 27: 5, 15: 4, 52: 2, 129: 5, 115: 4, 84: 4, 76: 7, 87: 4, 131: 7, 102: 2, 113: 6, 99: 4, 36: 4, 24: 3, 53: 3, 72: 5} {25: 1, 227: 1, 299: 1, 347: 1, 341: 1, 123: 1, 348: 1, 1: 9, 4: 4, 9: 6, 10: 5, 15: 3, 24: 4, 26: 2, 27: 3, 39: 5, 43: 5, 49: 7, 50: 6, 58: 6, 59: 4, 64: 3, 69: 5, 81: 2, 86: 4, 96: 5, 97: 4, 100: 3, 108: 5, 109: 6, 110: 6, 111: 4, 114: 5, 115: 6, 116: 2, 118: 4, 119: 3, 120: 5, 121: 4, 122: 2, 124: 4, 128: 5, 129: 4, 130: 6, 132: 5, 136: 4, 145: 5, 147: 5, 151: 5, 152: 5, 154: 5, 156: 2, 161: 4, 162: 3, 165: 5, 168: 6, 169: 4, 172: 4, 180: 5, 184: 6, 187: 7, 188: 6, 191: 5, 194: 5, 202: 6, 203: 7, 206: 4, 207: 5, 215: 4, 217: 5, 218: 8, 220: 4, 221: 4, 222: 5, 224: 5, 229: 4, 234: 7, 235: 4, 241: 4, 242: 4, 243: 5, 244: 5, 245: 5, 248: 5, 250: 4, 258: 11, 262: 6, 263: 7, 264: 5, 267: 4, 270: 3, 272: 4, 273: 6, 287: 5, 289: 4, 291: 6, 300: 3, 304: 3, 309: 4, 314: 4, 315: 4, 320: 2, 323: 5, 327: 6, 328: 5, 329: 4, 330: 10, 334: 4, 335: 2, 342: 2, 350: 8, 351: 6, 352: 4, 353: 4, 354: 3, 358: 4, 365: 4, 366: 4, 369: 3, 371: 3, 372: 6, 376: 4, 384: 6, 385: 5, 386: 5, 387: 3, 392: 5, 393: 6, 396: 2, 397: 7, 398: 6, 402: 4} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 51 "The DetNet Service Flow is mapped to the link / sub-network specific resources using an underlying system specific means. This implies each DetNet aware node on path looks into the forwarded DetNet Service Flow packet and utilize e.g., a 5- (or 6-) tuple to find out the required mapping within a node." Reflecting the 9th September discussions . acd7cae2af60dfafe42acdd9936194decc735f93 acd7cae2af60dfafe42acdd9936194decc735f93 draft-ietf-detnet-ip-over-tsn 09072dce85dbf3ba3c882b977ba54fae8f3b847aa227a9c1f86c33efa19918c0 ['3897911ddc16e106cd2aefc65701e816a6d2a31a1055f6fd3ac0eb6c899b12d2', '25d7c300f819c5d6a20cacc29a44393629d0b720acce8df0ad0b7adb4c86bcdd', '62b524308c7eb98ad024dca1f2345d42c7d164c0c2df653514e755cead78cdb6', '4e26d4b73aeabbe456b8574eceb475840631aa5ff572588e9e8521eb55c3fc82', '9578df4f362f9cb7b01a0101133311aad5ba40c07927ff78f145186909ac5f2e', '756a947ada8cde75aebfcc9d674fcb06d5c3143ac9f8e40d01e6865d6b8559bc', 'e3b6496b036377dd09d23fec69cd8cae64e0b0b01936a564abc04076dcc55e71', '8090b6d14e467632f5876fb9da62cf017d0a0f609b7954197c60f826e83b1a8b', '2327f197493c9aeb867cb401b66068347b7d28ccc18c7b3206bc515002bbab69', '305c7722e6b3b59e9ffb631e06cb323c063d6d11b5282fd6a6664c1cb8d7ee91', '3c033b34f401247732f7c3c456fa364f5b59db321f46b995f84a3fc30106e78c', '9eae34a80d6c18174e433823135ec5765b2174c62c18b3a4bbbd2754dfbbb557', 'b3b276ab53d2bb9ff622f9b2ea7e7643e0598c3bed12033cbd25e47851d54961', '95b1cf1b9c1b8c110218f611eb22e4a9636010c316f7e3bd7eb262c3cadac5b7', 'fb33aedd1c9ed6cfe6ac52eb357b929114856a1761e4788e0e8ec3bf61c85d66', '31fb84facf4d109f79916db9667a246a641f6a1cf0ac5b8400d7a490f0f93126', 'ec02f75668ae82f22e79616c3d199ed8de8bc9e752bb4a05e8ed0503929be8f1', 'ca8ff5cafc8cf8fe21d5c32033e7eaf2d8d483ee895512f4cc26334b0eb890b8', 'd63c1e6a1bdf1cd69d4641cbe3a8e8fb76b4f85e02a3a5e5fbcc243f0b533a7a', 'f4b5bbc7f31d23db201e9c37bf8bd87f1e7c1a2e4706e438b9755468147aec98', '898ad8e8241a67be9e5e5dfe23d767306499ef91a57f4eca648b6f724c90351d', '09072dce85dbf3ba3c882b977ba54fae8f3b847aa227a9c1f86c33efa19918c0', 'c172b25efec8add4a39ce6b23f7baea5ff6f66e77a192b1363db0a53bf501b4e'] A "the detnet service flow is mapped to the link / sub-network specific resources using an underlying system specific means. this implies each detnet aware node on path looks into the forwarded detnet service flow packet and utilize e.g., a 5- (or 6-) tuple to find out the required mapping within a node." {62: 1, 13: 1, 130: 1, 124: 1, 96: 1, 6: 4, 79: 4, 90: 4, 51: 2, 85: 2, 68: 4, 35: 5, 110: 4, 91: 6, 114: 4, 97: 2, 31: 5, 67: 4, 38: 5, 26: 3, 98: 4, 54: 4, 127: 5, 8: 4, 64: 4, 30: 4, 61: 6, 55: 3, 27: 5, 15: 4, 52: 2, 129: 5, 115: 4, 84: 4, 76: 7, 87: 4, 131: 7, 102: 2, 113: 6, 99: 4, 36: 4, 24: 3, 53: 3, 72: 5} {25: 1, 227: 1, 299: 1, 347: 1, 341: 1, 123: 1, 348: 1, 1: 9, 4: 4, 9: 6, 10: 5, 15: 3, 24: 4, 26: 2, 27: 3, 39: 5, 43: 5, 49: 7, 50: 6, 58: 6, 59: 4, 64: 3, 69: 5, 81: 2, 86: 4, 96: 5, 97: 4, 100: 3, 108: 5, 109: 6, 110: 6, 111: 4, 114: 5, 115: 6, 116: 2, 118: 4, 119: 3, 120: 5, 121: 4, 122: 2, 124: 4, 128: 5, 129: 4, 130: 6, 132: 5, 136: 4, 145: 5, 147: 5, 151: 5, 152: 5, 154: 5, 156: 2, 161: 4, 162: 3, 165: 5, 168: 6, 169: 4, 172: 4, 180: 5, 184: 6, 187: 7, 188: 6, 191: 5, 194: 5, 202: 6, 203: 7, 206: 4, 207: 5, 215: 4, 217: 5, 218: 8, 220: 4, 221: 4, 222: 5, 224: 5, 229: 4, 234: 7, 235: 4, 241: 4, 242: 4, 243: 5, 244: 5, 245: 5, 248: 5, 250: 4, 258: 11, 262: 6, 263: 7, 264: 5, 267: 4, 270: 3, 272: 4, 273: 6, 287: 5, 289: 4, 291: 6, 300: 3, 304: 3, 309: 4, 314: 4, 315: 4, 320: 2, 323: 5, 327: 6, 328: 5, 329: 4, 330: 10, 334: 4, 335: 2, 342: 2, 350: 8, 351: 6, 352: 4, 353: 4, 354: 3, 358: 4, 365: 4, 366: 4, 369: 3, 371: 3, 372: 6, 376: 4, 384: 6, 385: 5, 386: 5, 387: 3, 392: 5, 393: 6, 396: 2, 397: 7, 398: 6, 402: 4} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 51 "As noted earlier, the Service Protection is done within each link / sub-network independently using the domain specific mechanisms (due the lack of a unified end to end sequencing information that would be available for intermediate nodes). Therefore, service protection (if any) cannot be provided end-to-end, only within sub-networks. This is shown for a three sub-network scenario in fig_pref_in_subnets, where each sub-network can provide service protection between its borders." Reflecting the 9th September discussions . acd7cae2af60dfafe42acdd9936194decc735f93 acd7cae2af60dfafe42acdd9936194decc735f93 draft-ietf-detnet-ip-over-tsn 898ad8e8241a67be9e5e5dfe23d767306499ef91a57f4eca648b6f724c90351d ['3897911ddc16e106cd2aefc65701e816a6d2a31a1055f6fd3ac0eb6c899b12d2', '25d7c300f819c5d6a20cacc29a44393629d0b720acce8df0ad0b7adb4c86bcdd', '62b524308c7eb98ad024dca1f2345d42c7d164c0c2df653514e755cead78cdb6', '4e26d4b73aeabbe456b8574eceb475840631aa5ff572588e9e8521eb55c3fc82', '9578df4f362f9cb7b01a0101133311aad5ba40c07927ff78f145186909ac5f2e', '756a947ada8cde75aebfcc9d674fcb06d5c3143ac9f8e40d01e6865d6b8559bc', 'e3b6496b036377dd09d23fec69cd8cae64e0b0b01936a564abc04076dcc55e71', '8090b6d14e467632f5876fb9da62cf017d0a0f609b7954197c60f826e83b1a8b', '2327f197493c9aeb867cb401b66068347b7d28ccc18c7b3206bc515002bbab69', '305c7722e6b3b59e9ffb631e06cb323c063d6d11b5282fd6a6664c1cb8d7ee91', '3c033b34f401247732f7c3c456fa364f5b59db321f46b995f84a3fc30106e78c', '9eae34a80d6c18174e433823135ec5765b2174c62c18b3a4bbbd2754dfbbb557', 'b3b276ab53d2bb9ff622f9b2ea7e7643e0598c3bed12033cbd25e47851d54961', '95b1cf1b9c1b8c110218f611eb22e4a9636010c316f7e3bd7eb262c3cadac5b7', 'fb33aedd1c9ed6cfe6ac52eb357b929114856a1761e4788e0e8ec3bf61c85d66', '31fb84facf4d109f79916db9667a246a641f6a1cf0ac5b8400d7a490f0f93126', 'ec02f75668ae82f22e79616c3d199ed8de8bc9e752bb4a05e8ed0503929be8f1', 'ca8ff5cafc8cf8fe21d5c32033e7eaf2d8d483ee895512f4cc26334b0eb890b8', 'd63c1e6a1bdf1cd69d4641cbe3a8e8fb76b4f85e02a3a5e5fbcc243f0b533a7a', 'f4b5bbc7f31d23db201e9c37bf8bd87f1e7c1a2e4706e438b9755468147aec98', '898ad8e8241a67be9e5e5dfe23d767306499ef91a57f4eca648b6f724c90351d', '09072dce85dbf3ba3c882b977ba54fae8f3b847aa227a9c1f86c33efa19918c0', 'c172b25efec8add4a39ce6b23f7baea5ff6f66e77a192b1363db0a53bf501b4e'] A "as noted earlier, the service protection is done within each link / sub-network independently using the domain specific mechanisms (due the lack of a unified end to end sequencing information that would be available for intermediate nodes). therefore, service protection (if any) cannot be provided end-to-end, only within sub-networks. this is shown for a three sub-network scenario in fig_pref_in_subnets, where each sub-network can provide service protection between its borders." {62: 1, 13: 1, 130: 1, 124: 1, 96: 1, 6: 4, 79: 4, 90: 4, 51: 2, 85: 2, 68: 4, 35: 5, 110: 4, 91: 6, 114: 4, 97: 2, 31: 5, 67: 4, 38: 5, 26: 3, 98: 4, 54: 4, 127: 5, 8: 4, 64: 4, 30: 4, 61: 6, 55: 3, 27: 5, 15: 4, 52: 2, 129: 5, 115: 4, 84: 4, 76: 7, 87: 4, 131: 7, 102: 2, 113: 6, 99: 4, 36: 4, 24: 3, 53: 3, 72: 5} {25: 1, 227: 1, 299: 1, 347: 1, 341: 1, 123: 1, 348: 1, 1: 9, 4: 4, 9: 6, 10: 5, 15: 3, 24: 4, 26: 2, 27: 3, 39: 5, 43: 5, 49: 7, 50: 6, 58: 6, 59: 4, 64: 3, 69: 5, 81: 2, 86: 4, 96: 5, 97: 4, 100: 3, 108: 5, 109: 6, 110: 6, 111: 4, 114: 5, 115: 6, 116: 2, 118: 4, 119: 3, 120: 5, 121: 4, 122: 2, 124: 4, 128: 5, 129: 4, 130: 6, 132: 5, 136: 4, 145: 5, 147: 5, 151: 5, 152: 5, 154: 5, 156: 2, 161: 4, 162: 3, 165: 5, 168: 6, 169: 4, 172: 4, 180: 5, 184: 6, 187: 7, 188: 6, 191: 5, 194: 5, 202: 6, 203: 7, 206: 4, 207: 5, 215: 4, 217: 5, 218: 8, 220: 4, 221: 4, 222: 5, 224: 5, 229: 4, 234: 7, 235: 4, 241: 4, 242: 4, 243: 5, 244: 5, 245: 5, 248: 5, 250: 4, 258: 11, 262: 6, 263: 7, 264: 5, 267: 4, 270: 3, 272: 4, 273: 6, 287: 5, 289: 4, 291: 6, 300: 3, 304: 3, 309: 4, 314: 4, 315: 4, 320: 2, 323: 5, 327: 6, 328: 5, 329: 4, 330: 10, 334: 4, 335: 2, 342: 2, 350: 8, 351: 6, 352: 4, 353: 4, 354: 3, 358: 4, 365: 4, 366: 4, 369: 3, 371: 3, 372: 6, 376: 4, 384: 6, 385: 5, 386: 5, 387: 3, 392: 5, 393: 6, 396: 2, 397: 7, 398: 6, 402: 4} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 51 "If end to end service protection is desired that can be implemented, for example, by the DetNet end systems using Layer-4 (L4) transport protocols or application protocols. However, these are out of scope of this document." Reflecting the 9th September discussions . acd7cae2af60dfafe42acdd9936194decc735f93 acd7cae2af60dfafe42acdd9936194decc735f93 draft-ietf-detnet-ip-over-tsn c172b25efec8add4a39ce6b23f7baea5ff6f66e77a192b1363db0a53bf501b4e ['3897911ddc16e106cd2aefc65701e816a6d2a31a1055f6fd3ac0eb6c899b12d2', '25d7c300f819c5d6a20cacc29a44393629d0b720acce8df0ad0b7adb4c86bcdd', '62b524308c7eb98ad024dca1f2345d42c7d164c0c2df653514e755cead78cdb6', '4e26d4b73aeabbe456b8574eceb475840631aa5ff572588e9e8521eb55c3fc82', '9578df4f362f9cb7b01a0101133311aad5ba40c07927ff78f145186909ac5f2e', '756a947ada8cde75aebfcc9d674fcb06d5c3143ac9f8e40d01e6865d6b8559bc', 'e3b6496b036377dd09d23fec69cd8cae64e0b0b01936a564abc04076dcc55e71', '8090b6d14e467632f5876fb9da62cf017d0a0f609b7954197c60f826e83b1a8b', '2327f197493c9aeb867cb401b66068347b7d28ccc18c7b3206bc515002bbab69', '305c7722e6b3b59e9ffb631e06cb323c063d6d11b5282fd6a6664c1cb8d7ee91', '3c033b34f401247732f7c3c456fa364f5b59db321f46b995f84a3fc30106e78c', '9eae34a80d6c18174e433823135ec5765b2174c62c18b3a4bbbd2754dfbbb557', 'b3b276ab53d2bb9ff622f9b2ea7e7643e0598c3bed12033cbd25e47851d54961', '95b1cf1b9c1b8c110218f611eb22e4a9636010c316f7e3bd7eb262c3cadac5b7', 'fb33aedd1c9ed6cfe6ac52eb357b929114856a1761e4788e0e8ec3bf61c85d66', '31fb84facf4d109f79916db9667a246a641f6a1cf0ac5b8400d7a490f0f93126', 'ec02f75668ae82f22e79616c3d199ed8de8bc9e752bb4a05e8ed0503929be8f1', 'ca8ff5cafc8cf8fe21d5c32033e7eaf2d8d483ee895512f4cc26334b0eb890b8', 'd63c1e6a1bdf1cd69d4641cbe3a8e8fb76b4f85e02a3a5e5fbcc243f0b533a7a', 'f4b5bbc7f31d23db201e9c37bf8bd87f1e7c1a2e4706e438b9755468147aec98', '898ad8e8241a67be9e5e5dfe23d767306499ef91a57f4eca648b6f724c90351d', '09072dce85dbf3ba3c882b977ba54fae8f3b847aa227a9c1f86c33efa19918c0', 'c172b25efec8add4a39ce6b23f7baea5ff6f66e77a192b1363db0a53bf501b4e'] A "if end to end service protection is desired that can be implemented, for example, by the detnet end systems using layer-4 (l4) transport protocols or application protocols. however, these are out of scope of this document." {62: 1, 13: 1, 130: 1, 124: 1, 96: 1, 6: 4, 79: 4, 90: 4, 51: 2, 85: 2, 68: 4, 35: 5, 110: 4, 91: 6, 114: 4, 97: 2, 31: 5, 67: 4, 38: 5, 26: 3, 98: 4, 54: 4, 127: 5, 8: 4, 64: 4, 30: 4, 61: 6, 55: 3, 27: 5, 15: 4, 52: 2, 129: 5, 115: 4, 84: 4, 76: 7, 87: 4, 131: 7, 102: 2, 113: 6, 99: 4, 36: 4, 24: 3, 53: 3, 72: 5} {25: 1, 227: 1, 299: 1, 347: 1, 341: 1, 123: 1, 348: 1, 1: 9, 4: 4, 9: 6, 10: 5, 15: 3, 24: 4, 26: 2, 27: 3, 39: 5, 43: 5, 49: 7, 50: 6, 58: 6, 59: 4, 64: 3, 69: 5, 81: 2, 86: 4, 96: 5, 97: 4, 100: 3, 108: 5, 109: 6, 110: 6, 111: 4, 114: 5, 115: 6, 116: 2, 118: 4, 119: 3, 120: 5, 121: 4, 122: 2, 124: 4, 128: 5, 129: 4, 130: 6, 132: 5, 136: 4, 145: 5, 147: 5, 151: 5, 152: 5, 154: 5, 156: 2, 161: 4, 162: 3, 165: 5, 168: 6, 169: 4, 172: 4, 180: 5, 184: 6, 187: 7, 188: 6, 191: 5, 194: 5, 202: 6, 203: 7, 206: 4, 207: 5, 215: 4, 217: 5, 218: 8, 220: 4, 221: 4, 222: 5, 224: 5, 229: 4, 234: 7, 235: 4, 241: 4, 242: 4, 243: 5, 244: 5, 245: 5, 248: 5, 250: 4, 258: 11, 262: 6, 263: 7, 264: 5, 267: 4, 270: 3, 272: 4, 273: 6, 287: 5, 289: 4, 291: 6, 300: 3, 304: 3, 309: 4, 314: 4, 315: 4, 320: 2, 323: 5, 327: 6, 328: 5, 329: 4, 330: 10, 334: 4, 335: 2, 342: 2, 350: 8, 351: 6, 352: 4, 353: 4, 354: 3, 358: 4, 365: 4, 366: 4, 369: 3, 371: 3, 372: 6, 376: 4, 384: 6, 385: 5, 386: 5, 387: 3, 392: 5, 393: 6, 396: 2, 397: 7, 398: 6, 402: 4} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 51 "There are network scenarios, where the DetNet domain contains multiple technology segments (IEEE 802.1 TSN, MPLS) and all those segments are under the same administrative control (see fig_pref_xcrs_segments). Furthermore, DetNet nodes may be interconnected via TSN segments." Reflecting the 9th September discussions . acd7cae2af60dfafe42acdd9936194decc735f93 acd7cae2af60dfafe42acdd9936194decc735f93 draft-ietf-detnet-ip-over-tsn d63c1e6a1bdf1cd69d4641cbe3a8e8fb76b4f85e02a3a5e5fbcc243f0b533a7a ['3897911ddc16e106cd2aefc65701e816a6d2a31a1055f6fd3ac0eb6c899b12d2', '25d7c300f819c5d6a20cacc29a44393629d0b720acce8df0ad0b7adb4c86bcdd', '62b524308c7eb98ad024dca1f2345d42c7d164c0c2df653514e755cead78cdb6', '4e26d4b73aeabbe456b8574eceb475840631aa5ff572588e9e8521eb55c3fc82', '9578df4f362f9cb7b01a0101133311aad5ba40c07927ff78f145186909ac5f2e', '756a947ada8cde75aebfcc9d674fcb06d5c3143ac9f8e40d01e6865d6b8559bc', 'e3b6496b036377dd09d23fec69cd8cae64e0b0b01936a564abc04076dcc55e71', '8090b6d14e467632f5876fb9da62cf017d0a0f609b7954197c60f826e83b1a8b', '2327f197493c9aeb867cb401b66068347b7d28ccc18c7b3206bc515002bbab69', '305c7722e6b3b59e9ffb631e06cb323c063d6d11b5282fd6a6664c1cb8d7ee91', '3c033b34f401247732f7c3c456fa364f5b59db321f46b995f84a3fc30106e78c', '9eae34a80d6c18174e433823135ec5765b2174c62c18b3a4bbbd2754dfbbb557', 'b3b276ab53d2bb9ff622f9b2ea7e7643e0598c3bed12033cbd25e47851d54961', '95b1cf1b9c1b8c110218f611eb22e4a9636010c316f7e3bd7eb262c3cadac5b7', 'fb33aedd1c9ed6cfe6ac52eb357b929114856a1761e4788e0e8ec3bf61c85d66', '31fb84facf4d109f79916db9667a246a641f6a1cf0ac5b8400d7a490f0f93126', 'ec02f75668ae82f22e79616c3d199ed8de8bc9e752bb4a05e8ed0503929be8f1', 'ca8ff5cafc8cf8fe21d5c32033e7eaf2d8d483ee895512f4cc26334b0eb890b8', 'd63c1e6a1bdf1cd69d4641cbe3a8e8fb76b4f85e02a3a5e5fbcc243f0b533a7a', 'f4b5bbc7f31d23db201e9c37bf8bd87f1e7c1a2e4706e438b9755468147aec98', '898ad8e8241a67be9e5e5dfe23d767306499ef91a57f4eca648b6f724c90351d', '09072dce85dbf3ba3c882b977ba54fae8f3b847aa227a9c1f86c33efa19918c0', 'c172b25efec8add4a39ce6b23f7baea5ff6f66e77a192b1363db0a53bf501b4e'] A "there are network scenarios, where the detnet domain contains multiple technology segments (ieee 802.1 tsn, mpls) and all those segments are under the same administrative control (see fig_pref_xcrs_segments). furthermore, detnet nodes may be interconnected via tsn segments." {62: 1, 13: 1, 130: 1, 124: 1, 96: 1, 6: 4, 79: 4, 90: 4, 51: 2, 85: 2, 68: 4, 35: 5, 110: 4, 91: 6, 114: 4, 97: 2, 31: 5, 67: 4, 38: 5, 26: 3, 98: 4, 54: 4, 127: 5, 8: 4, 64: 4, 30: 4, 61: 6, 55: 3, 27: 5, 15: 4, 52: 2, 129: 5, 115: 4, 84: 4, 76: 7, 87: 4, 131: 7, 102: 2, 113: 6, 99: 4, 36: 4, 24: 3, 53: 3, 72: 5} {25: 1, 227: 1, 299: 1, 347: 1, 341: 1, 123: 1, 348: 1, 1: 9, 4: 4, 9: 6, 10: 5, 15: 3, 24: 4, 26: 2, 27: 3, 39: 5, 43: 5, 49: 7, 50: 6, 58: 6, 59: 4, 64: 3, 69: 5, 81: 2, 86: 4, 96: 5, 97: 4, 100: 3, 108: 5, 109: 6, 110: 6, 111: 4, 114: 5, 115: 6, 116: 2, 118: 4, 119: 3, 120: 5, 121: 4, 122: 2, 124: 4, 128: 5, 129: 4, 130: 6, 132: 5, 136: 4, 145: 5, 147: 5, 151: 5, 152: 5, 154: 5, 156: 2, 161: 4, 162: 3, 165: 5, 168: 6, 169: 4, 172: 4, 180: 5, 184: 6, 187: 7, 188: 6, 191: 5, 194: 5, 202: 6, 203: 7, 206: 4, 207: 5, 215: 4, 217: 5, 218: 8, 220: 4, 221: 4, 222: 5, 224: 5, 229: 4, 234: 7, 235: 4, 241: 4, 242: 4, 243: 5, 244: 5, 245: 5, 248: 5, 250: 4, 258: 11, 262: 6, 263: 7, 264: 5, 267: 4, 270: 3, 272: 4, 273: 6, 287: 5, 289: 4, 291: 6, 300: 3, 304: 3, 309: 4, 314: 4, 315: 4, 320: 2, 323: 5, 327: 6, 328: 5, 329: 4, 330: 10, 334: 4, 335: 2, 342: 2, 350: 8, 351: 6, 352: 4, 353: 4, 354: 3, 358: 4, 365: 4, 366: 4, 369: 3, 371: 3, 372: 6, 376: 4, 384: 6, 385: 5, 386: 5, 387: 3, 392: 5, 393: 6, 396: 2, 397: 7, 398: 6, 402: 4} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 51 "DetNet routers ensure that detnet service requirements are met per hop by allocating local resources, both receive and transmit, and by mapping the service requirements of each flow to appropriate sub- network mechanisms. Such mapping is sub-network technology specific. The mapping of DetNet IP Flows to MPLS is covered RRR . The mapping of IP DetNet Flows to IEEE 802.1 TSN is covered in mapping-tsn." Reflecting the 9th September discussions . acd7cae2af60dfafe42acdd9936194decc735f93 acd7cae2af60dfafe42acdd9936194decc735f93 draft-ietf-detnet-ip-over-tsn 3c033b34f401247732f7c3c456fa364f5b59db321f46b995f84a3fc30106e78c ['3897911ddc16e106cd2aefc65701e816a6d2a31a1055f6fd3ac0eb6c899b12d2', '25d7c300f819c5d6a20cacc29a44393629d0b720acce8df0ad0b7adb4c86bcdd', '62b524308c7eb98ad024dca1f2345d42c7d164c0c2df653514e755cead78cdb6', '4e26d4b73aeabbe456b8574eceb475840631aa5ff572588e9e8521eb55c3fc82', '9578df4f362f9cb7b01a0101133311aad5ba40c07927ff78f145186909ac5f2e', '756a947ada8cde75aebfcc9d674fcb06d5c3143ac9f8e40d01e6865d6b8559bc', 'e3b6496b036377dd09d23fec69cd8cae64e0b0b01936a564abc04076dcc55e71', '8090b6d14e467632f5876fb9da62cf017d0a0f609b7954197c60f826e83b1a8b', '2327f197493c9aeb867cb401b66068347b7d28ccc18c7b3206bc515002bbab69', '305c7722e6b3b59e9ffb631e06cb323c063d6d11b5282fd6a6664c1cb8d7ee91', '3c033b34f401247732f7c3c456fa364f5b59db321f46b995f84a3fc30106e78c', '9eae34a80d6c18174e433823135ec5765b2174c62c18b3a4bbbd2754dfbbb557', 'b3b276ab53d2bb9ff622f9b2ea7e7643e0598c3bed12033cbd25e47851d54961', '95b1cf1b9c1b8c110218f611eb22e4a9636010c316f7e3bd7eb262c3cadac5b7', 'fb33aedd1c9ed6cfe6ac52eb357b929114856a1761e4788e0e8ec3bf61c85d66', '31fb84facf4d109f79916db9667a246a641f6a1cf0ac5b8400d7a490f0f93126', 'ec02f75668ae82f22e79616c3d199ed8de8bc9e752bb4a05e8ed0503929be8f1', 'ca8ff5cafc8cf8fe21d5c32033e7eaf2d8d483ee895512f4cc26334b0eb890b8', 'd63c1e6a1bdf1cd69d4641cbe3a8e8fb76b4f85e02a3a5e5fbcc243f0b533a7a', 'f4b5bbc7f31d23db201e9c37bf8bd87f1e7c1a2e4706e438b9755468147aec98', '898ad8e8241a67be9e5e5dfe23d767306499ef91a57f4eca648b6f724c90351d', '09072dce85dbf3ba3c882b977ba54fae8f3b847aa227a9c1f86c33efa19918c0', 'c172b25efec8add4a39ce6b23f7baea5ff6f66e77a192b1363db0a53bf501b4e'] A "detnet routers ensure that detnet service requirements are met per hop by allocating local resources, both receive and transmit, and by mapping the service requirements of each flow to appropriate sub- network mechanisms. such mapping is sub-network technology specific. the mapping of detnet ip flows to mpls is covered rrr . the mapping of ip detnet flows to ieee 802.1 tsn is covered in mapping-tsn." {62: 1, 13: 1, 130: 1, 124: 1, 96: 1, 6: 4, 79: 4, 90: 4, 51: 2, 85: 2, 68: 4, 35: 5, 110: 4, 91: 6, 114: 4, 97: 2, 31: 5, 67: 4, 38: 5, 26: 3, 98: 4, 54: 4, 127: 5, 8: 4, 64: 4, 30: 4, 61: 6, 55: 3, 27: 5, 15: 4, 52: 2, 129: 5, 115: 4, 84: 4, 76: 7, 87: 4, 131: 7, 102: 2, 113: 6, 99: 4, 36: 4, 24: 3, 53: 3, 72: 5} {25: 1, 227: 1, 299: 1, 347: 1, 341: 1, 123: 1, 348: 1, 1: 9, 4: 4, 9: 6, 10: 5, 15: 3, 24: 4, 26: 2, 27: 3, 39: 5, 43: 5, 49: 7, 50: 6, 58: 6, 59: 4, 64: 3, 69: 5, 81: 2, 86: 4, 96: 5, 97: 4, 100: 3, 108: 5, 109: 6, 110: 6, 111: 4, 114: 5, 115: 6, 116: 2, 118: 4, 119: 3, 120: 5, 121: 4, 122: 2, 124: 4, 128: 5, 129: 4, 130: 6, 132: 5, 136: 4, 145: 5, 147: 5, 151: 5, 152: 5, 154: 5, 156: 2, 161: 4, 162: 3, 165: 5, 168: 6, 169: 4, 172: 4, 180: 5, 184: 6, 187: 7, 188: 6, 191: 5, 194: 5, 202: 6, 203: 7, 206: 4, 207: 5, 215: 4, 217: 5, 218: 8, 220: 4, 221: 4, 222: 5, 224: 5, 229: 4, 234: 7, 235: 4, 241: 4, 242: 4, 243: 5, 244: 5, 245: 5, 248: 5, 250: 4, 258: 11, 262: 6, 263: 7, 264: 5, 267: 4, 270: 3, 272: 4, 273: 6, 287: 5, 289: 4, 291: 6, 300: 3, 304: 3, 309: 4, 314: 4, 315: 4, 320: 2, 323: 5, 327: 6, 328: 5, 329: 4, 330: 10, 334: 4, 335: 2, 342: 2, 350: 8, 351: 6, 352: 4, 353: 4, 354: 3, 358: 4, 365: 4, 366: 4, 369: 3, 371: 3, 372: 6, 376: 4, 384: 6, 385: 5, 386: 5, 387: 3, 392: 5, 393: 6, 396: 2, 397: 7, 398: 6, 402: 4} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 51 "This section covers how DetNet IP flows operate over an IEEE 802.1 TSN sub-network. fig_ip_detnet_to_tsn illustrates such a scenario, where two IP (DetNet) nodes are interconnected by a TSN sub-network. Node-1 is single homed and Node-2 is dual-homed. IP nodes can be (1) DetNet IP End System, (2) DetNet IP Edge or Relay node or (3) IP End System." Reflecting the 9th September discussions . acd7cae2af60dfafe42acdd9936194decc735f93 acd7cae2af60dfafe42acdd9936194decc735f93 draft-ietf-detnet-ip-over-tsn e3b6496b036377dd09d23fec69cd8cae64e0b0b01936a564abc04076dcc55e71 ['3897911ddc16e106cd2aefc65701e816a6d2a31a1055f6fd3ac0eb6c899b12d2', '25d7c300f819c5d6a20cacc29a44393629d0b720acce8df0ad0b7adb4c86bcdd', '62b524308c7eb98ad024dca1f2345d42c7d164c0c2df653514e755cead78cdb6', '4e26d4b73aeabbe456b8574eceb475840631aa5ff572588e9e8521eb55c3fc82', '9578df4f362f9cb7b01a0101133311aad5ba40c07927ff78f145186909ac5f2e', '756a947ada8cde75aebfcc9d674fcb06d5c3143ac9f8e40d01e6865d6b8559bc', 'e3b6496b036377dd09d23fec69cd8cae64e0b0b01936a564abc04076dcc55e71', '8090b6d14e467632f5876fb9da62cf017d0a0f609b7954197c60f826e83b1a8b', '2327f197493c9aeb867cb401b66068347b7d28ccc18c7b3206bc515002bbab69', '305c7722e6b3b59e9ffb631e06cb323c063d6d11b5282fd6a6664c1cb8d7ee91', '3c033b34f401247732f7c3c456fa364f5b59db321f46b995f84a3fc30106e78c', '9eae34a80d6c18174e433823135ec5765b2174c62c18b3a4bbbd2754dfbbb557', 'b3b276ab53d2bb9ff622f9b2ea7e7643e0598c3bed12033cbd25e47851d54961', '95b1cf1b9c1b8c110218f611eb22e4a9636010c316f7e3bd7eb262c3cadac5b7', 'fb33aedd1c9ed6cfe6ac52eb357b929114856a1761e4788e0e8ec3bf61c85d66', '31fb84facf4d109f79916db9667a246a641f6a1cf0ac5b8400d7a490f0f93126', 'ec02f75668ae82f22e79616c3d199ed8de8bc9e752bb4a05e8ed0503929be8f1', 'ca8ff5cafc8cf8fe21d5c32033e7eaf2d8d483ee895512f4cc26334b0eb890b8', 'd63c1e6a1bdf1cd69d4641cbe3a8e8fb76b4f85e02a3a5e5fbcc243f0b533a7a', 'f4b5bbc7f31d23db201e9c37bf8bd87f1e7c1a2e4706e438b9755468147aec98', '898ad8e8241a67be9e5e5dfe23d767306499ef91a57f4eca648b6f724c90351d', '09072dce85dbf3ba3c882b977ba54fae8f3b847aa227a9c1f86c33efa19918c0', 'c172b25efec8add4a39ce6b23f7baea5ff6f66e77a192b1363db0a53bf501b4e'] A "this section covers how detnet ip flows operate over an ieee 802.1 tsn sub-network. fig_ip_detnet_to_tsn illustrates such a scenario, where two ip (detnet) nodes are interconnected by a tsn sub-network. node-1 is single homed and node-2 is dual-homed. ip nodes can be (1) detnet ip end system, (2) detnet ip edge or relay node or (3) ip end system." {62: 1, 13: 1, 130: 1, 124: 1, 96: 1, 6: 4, 79: 4, 90: 4, 51: 2, 85: 2, 68: 4, 35: 5, 110: 4, 91: 6, 114: 4, 97: 2, 31: 5, 67: 4, 38: 5, 26: 3, 98: 4, 54: 4, 127: 5, 8: 4, 64: 4, 30: 4, 61: 6, 55: 3, 27: 5, 15: 4, 52: 2, 129: 5, 115: 4, 84: 4, 76: 7, 87: 4, 131: 7, 102: 2, 113: 6, 99: 4, 36: 4, 24: 3, 53: 3, 72: 5} {25: 1, 227: 1, 299: 1, 347: 1, 341: 1, 123: 1, 348: 1, 1: 9, 4: 4, 9: 6, 10: 5, 15: 3, 24: 4, 26: 2, 27: 3, 39: 5, 43: 5, 49: 7, 50: 6, 58: 6, 59: 4, 64: 3, 69: 5, 81: 2, 86: 4, 96: 5, 97: 4, 100: 3, 108: 5, 109: 6, 110: 6, 111: 4, 114: 5, 115: 6, 116: 2, 118: 4, 119: 3, 120: 5, 121: 4, 122: 2, 124: 4, 128: 5, 129: 4, 130: 6, 132: 5, 136: 4, 145: 5, 147: 5, 151: 5, 152: 5, 154: 5, 156: 2, 161: 4, 162: 3, 165: 5, 168: 6, 169: 4, 172: 4, 180: 5, 184: 6, 187: 7, 188: 6, 191: 5, 194: 5, 202: 6, 203: 7, 206: 4, 207: 5, 215: 4, 217: 5, 218: 8, 220: 4, 221: 4, 222: 5, 224: 5, 229: 4, 234: 7, 235: 4, 241: 4, 242: 4, 243: 5, 244: 5, 245: 5, 248: 5, 250: 4, 258: 11, 262: 6, 263: 7, 264: 5, 267: 4, 270: 3, 272: 4, 273: 6, 287: 5, 289: 4, 291: 6, 300: 3, 304: 3, 309: 4, 314: 4, 315: 4, 320: 2, 323: 5, 327: 6, 328: 5, 329: 4, 330: 10, 334: 4, 335: 2, 342: 2, 350: 8, 351: 6, 352: 4, 353: 4, 354: 3, 358: 4, 365: 4, 366: 4, 369: 3, 371: 3, 372: 6, 376: 4, 384: 6, 385: 5, 386: 5, 387: 3, 392: 5, 393: 6, 396: 2, 397: 7, 398: 6, 402: 4} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 51 "The Time-Sensitive Networking (TSN) Task Group of the IEEE 802.1 Working Group have defined (and are defining) a number of amendments to IEEE8021Q that provide zero congestion loss and bounded latency in bridged networks. Furthermore IEEE8021CB defines frame replication and elimination functions for reliability that should prove both compatible with and useful to, DetNet networks. All these functions have to identify flows those require TSN treatment." Reflecting the 9th September discussions . acd7cae2af60dfafe42acdd9936194decc735f93 acd7cae2af60dfafe42acdd9936194decc735f93 draft-ietf-detnet-ip-over-tsn 9eae34a80d6c18174e433823135ec5765b2174c62c18b3a4bbbd2754dfbbb557 ['3897911ddc16e106cd2aefc65701e816a6d2a31a1055f6fd3ac0eb6c899b12d2', '25d7c300f819c5d6a20cacc29a44393629d0b720acce8df0ad0b7adb4c86bcdd', '62b524308c7eb98ad024dca1f2345d42c7d164c0c2df653514e755cead78cdb6', '4e26d4b73aeabbe456b8574eceb475840631aa5ff572588e9e8521eb55c3fc82', '9578df4f362f9cb7b01a0101133311aad5ba40c07927ff78f145186909ac5f2e', '756a947ada8cde75aebfcc9d674fcb06d5c3143ac9f8e40d01e6865d6b8559bc', 'e3b6496b036377dd09d23fec69cd8cae64e0b0b01936a564abc04076dcc55e71', '8090b6d14e467632f5876fb9da62cf017d0a0f609b7954197c60f826e83b1a8b', '2327f197493c9aeb867cb401b66068347b7d28ccc18c7b3206bc515002bbab69', '305c7722e6b3b59e9ffb631e06cb323c063d6d11b5282fd6a6664c1cb8d7ee91', '3c033b34f401247732f7c3c456fa364f5b59db321f46b995f84a3fc30106e78c', '9eae34a80d6c18174e433823135ec5765b2174c62c18b3a4bbbd2754dfbbb557', 'b3b276ab53d2bb9ff622f9b2ea7e7643e0598c3bed12033cbd25e47851d54961', '95b1cf1b9c1b8c110218f611eb22e4a9636010c316f7e3bd7eb262c3cadac5b7', 'fb33aedd1c9ed6cfe6ac52eb357b929114856a1761e4788e0e8ec3bf61c85d66', '31fb84facf4d109f79916db9667a246a641f6a1cf0ac5b8400d7a490f0f93126', 'ec02f75668ae82f22e79616c3d199ed8de8bc9e752bb4a05e8ed0503929be8f1', 'ca8ff5cafc8cf8fe21d5c32033e7eaf2d8d483ee895512f4cc26334b0eb890b8', 'd63c1e6a1bdf1cd69d4641cbe3a8e8fb76b4f85e02a3a5e5fbcc243f0b533a7a', 'f4b5bbc7f31d23db201e9c37bf8bd87f1e7c1a2e4706e438b9755468147aec98', '898ad8e8241a67be9e5e5dfe23d767306499ef91a57f4eca648b6f724c90351d', '09072dce85dbf3ba3c882b977ba54fae8f3b847aa227a9c1f86c33efa19918c0', 'c172b25efec8add4a39ce6b23f7baea5ff6f66e77a192b1363db0a53bf501b4e'] A "the time-sensitive networking (tsn) task group of the ieee 802.1 working group have defined (and are defining) a number of amendments to ieee8021q that provide zero congestion loss and bounded latency in bridged networks. furthermore ieee8021cb defines frame replication and elimination functions for reliability that should prove both compatible with and useful to, detnet networks. all these functions have to identify flows those require tsn treatment." {62: 1, 13: 1, 130: 1, 124: 1, 96: 1, 6: 4, 79: 4, 90: 4, 51: 2, 85: 2, 68: 4, 35: 5, 110: 4, 91: 6, 114: 4, 97: 2, 31: 5, 67: 4, 38: 5, 26: 3, 98: 4, 54: 4, 127: 5, 8: 4, 64: 4, 30: 4, 61: 6, 55: 3, 27: 5, 15: 4, 52: 2, 129: 5, 115: 4, 84: 4, 76: 7, 87: 4, 131: 7, 102: 2, 113: 6, 99: 4, 36: 4, 24: 3, 53: 3, 72: 5} {25: 1, 227: 1, 299: 1, 347: 1, 341: 1, 123: 1, 348: 1, 1: 9, 4: 4, 9: 6, 10: 5, 15: 3, 24: 4, 26: 2, 27: 3, 39: 5, 43: 5, 49: 7, 50: 6, 58: 6, 59: 4, 64: 3, 69: 5, 81: 2, 86: 4, 96: 5, 97: 4, 100: 3, 108: 5, 109: 6, 110: 6, 111: 4, 114: 5, 115: 6, 116: 2, 118: 4, 119: 3, 120: 5, 121: 4, 122: 2, 124: 4, 128: 5, 129: 4, 130: 6, 132: 5, 136: 4, 145: 5, 147: 5, 151: 5, 152: 5, 154: 5, 156: 2, 161: 4, 162: 3, 165: 5, 168: 6, 169: 4, 172: 4, 180: 5, 184: 6, 187: 7, 188: 6, 191: 5, 194: 5, 202: 6, 203: 7, 206: 4, 207: 5, 215: 4, 217: 5, 218: 8, 220: 4, 221: 4, 222: 5, 224: 5, 229: 4, 234: 7, 235: 4, 241: 4, 242: 4, 243: 5, 244: 5, 245: 5, 248: 5, 250: 4, 258: 11, 262: 6, 263: 7, 264: 5, 267: 4, 270: 3, 272: 4, 273: 6, 287: 5, 289: 4, 291: 6, 300: 3, 304: 3, 309: 4, 314: 4, 315: 4, 320: 2, 323: 5, 327: 6, 328: 5, 329: 4, 330: 10, 334: 4, 335: 2, 342: 2, 350: 8, 351: 6, 352: 4, 353: 4, 354: 3, 358: 4, 365: 4, 366: 4, 369: 3, 371: 3, 372: 6, 376: 4, 384: 6, 385: 5, 386: 5, 387: 3, 392: 5, 393: 6, 396: 2, 397: 7, 398: 6, 402: 4} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 51 "As is the case for DetNet, a Layer 2 network node such as a bridge may need to identify the specific DetNet flow to which a packet belongs in order to provide the TSN/DetNet QoS for that packet. It also may need additional marking, such as the priority field of an IEEE Std 802.1Q VLAN tag, to give the packet proper service." Reflecting the 9th September discussions . acd7cae2af60dfafe42acdd9936194decc735f93 acd7cae2af60dfafe42acdd9936194decc735f93 draft-ietf-detnet-ip-over-tsn f4b5bbc7f31d23db201e9c37bf8bd87f1e7c1a2e4706e438b9755468147aec98 ['3897911ddc16e106cd2aefc65701e816a6d2a31a1055f6fd3ac0eb6c899b12d2', '25d7c300f819c5d6a20cacc29a44393629d0b720acce8df0ad0b7adb4c86bcdd', '62b524308c7eb98ad024dca1f2345d42c7d164c0c2df653514e755cead78cdb6', '4e26d4b73aeabbe456b8574eceb475840631aa5ff572588e9e8521eb55c3fc82', '9578df4f362f9cb7b01a0101133311aad5ba40c07927ff78f145186909ac5f2e', '756a947ada8cde75aebfcc9d674fcb06d5c3143ac9f8e40d01e6865d6b8559bc', 'e3b6496b036377dd09d23fec69cd8cae64e0b0b01936a564abc04076dcc55e71', '8090b6d14e467632f5876fb9da62cf017d0a0f609b7954197c60f826e83b1a8b', '2327f197493c9aeb867cb401b66068347b7d28ccc18c7b3206bc515002bbab69', '305c7722e6b3b59e9ffb631e06cb323c063d6d11b5282fd6a6664c1cb8d7ee91', '3c033b34f401247732f7c3c456fa364f5b59db321f46b995f84a3fc30106e78c', '9eae34a80d6c18174e433823135ec5765b2174c62c18b3a4bbbd2754dfbbb557', 'b3b276ab53d2bb9ff622f9b2ea7e7643e0598c3bed12033cbd25e47851d54961', '95b1cf1b9c1b8c110218f611eb22e4a9636010c316f7e3bd7eb262c3cadac5b7', 'fb33aedd1c9ed6cfe6ac52eb357b929114856a1761e4788e0e8ec3bf61c85d66', '31fb84facf4d109f79916db9667a246a641f6a1cf0ac5b8400d7a490f0f93126', 'ec02f75668ae82f22e79616c3d199ed8de8bc9e752bb4a05e8ed0503929be8f1', 'ca8ff5cafc8cf8fe21d5c32033e7eaf2d8d483ee895512f4cc26334b0eb890b8', 'd63c1e6a1bdf1cd69d4641cbe3a8e8fb76b4f85e02a3a5e5fbcc243f0b533a7a', 'f4b5bbc7f31d23db201e9c37bf8bd87f1e7c1a2e4706e438b9755468147aec98', '898ad8e8241a67be9e5e5dfe23d767306499ef91a57f4eca648b6f724c90351d', '09072dce85dbf3ba3c882b977ba54fae8f3b847aa227a9c1f86c33efa19918c0', 'c172b25efec8add4a39ce6b23f7baea5ff6f66e77a192b1363db0a53bf501b4e'] A "as is the case for detnet, a layer 2 network node such as a bridge may need to identify the specific detnet flow to which a packet belongs in order to provide the tsn/detnet qos for that packet. it also may need additional marking, such as the priority field of an ieee std 802.1q vlan tag, to give the packet proper service." {62: 1, 13: 1, 130: 1, 124: 1, 96: 1, 6: 4, 79: 4, 90: 4, 51: 2, 85: 2, 68: 4, 35: 5, 110: 4, 91: 6, 114: 4, 97: 2, 31: 5, 67: 4, 38: 5, 26: 3, 98: 4, 54: 4, 127: 5, 8: 4, 64: 4, 30: 4, 61: 6, 55: 3, 27: 5, 15: 4, 52: 2, 129: 5, 115: 4, 84: 4, 76: 7, 87: 4, 131: 7, 102: 2, 113: 6, 99: 4, 36: 4, 24: 3, 53: 3, 72: 5} {25: 1, 227: 1, 299: 1, 347: 1, 341: 1, 123: 1, 348: 1, 1: 9, 4: 4, 9: 6, 10: 5, 15: 3, 24: 4, 26: 2, 27: 3, 39: 5, 43: 5, 49: 7, 50: 6, 58: 6, 59: 4, 64: 3, 69: 5, 81: 2, 86: 4, 96: 5, 97: 4, 100: 3, 108: 5, 109: 6, 110: 6, 111: 4, 114: 5, 115: 6, 116: 2, 118: 4, 119: 3, 120: 5, 121: 4, 122: 2, 124: 4, 128: 5, 129: 4, 130: 6, 132: 5, 136: 4, 145: 5, 147: 5, 151: 5, 152: 5, 154: 5, 156: 2, 161: 4, 162: 3, 165: 5, 168: 6, 169: 4, 172: 4, 180: 5, 184: 6, 187: 7, 188: 6, 191: 5, 194: 5, 202: 6, 203: 7, 206: 4, 207: 5, 215: 4, 217: 5, 218: 8, 220: 4, 221: 4, 222: 5, 224: 5, 229: 4, 234: 7, 235: 4, 241: 4, 242: 4, 243: 5, 244: 5, 245: 5, 248: 5, 250: 4, 258: 11, 262: 6, 263: 7, 264: 5, 267: 4, 270: 3, 272: 4, 273: 6, 287: 5, 289: 4, 291: 6, 300: 3, 304: 3, 309: 4, 314: 4, 315: 4, 320: 2, 323: 5, 327: 6, 328: 5, 329: 4, 330: 10, 334: 4, 335: 2, 342: 2, 350: 8, 351: 6, 352: 4, 353: 4, 354: 3, 358: 4, 365: 4, 366: 4, 369: 3, 371: 3, 372: 6, 376: 4, 384: 6, 385: 5, 386: 5, 387: 3, 392: 5, 393: 6, 396: 2, 397: 7, 398: 6, 402: 4} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 51 "TSN capabilities of the TSN sub-network are made available for IP (DetNet) flows via the protocol interworking function defined in IEEE8021CB. For example, applied on the TSN edge port connected to the IP (DetNet) node it can convert an ingress unicast IP (DetNet) flow to use a specific multicast destination MAC address and VLAN, in order to direct the packet through a specific path inside the bridged network. A similar interworking pair at the other end of the TSN sub-network would restore the packet to its original destination MAC address and VLAN." Reflecting the 9th September discussions . acd7cae2af60dfafe42acdd9936194decc735f93 acd7cae2af60dfafe42acdd9936194decc735f93 draft-ietf-detnet-ip-over-tsn fb33aedd1c9ed6cfe6ac52eb357b929114856a1761e4788e0e8ec3bf61c85d66 ['3897911ddc16e106cd2aefc65701e816a6d2a31a1055f6fd3ac0eb6c899b12d2', '25d7c300f819c5d6a20cacc29a44393629d0b720acce8df0ad0b7adb4c86bcdd', '62b524308c7eb98ad024dca1f2345d42c7d164c0c2df653514e755cead78cdb6', '4e26d4b73aeabbe456b8574eceb475840631aa5ff572588e9e8521eb55c3fc82', '9578df4f362f9cb7b01a0101133311aad5ba40c07927ff78f145186909ac5f2e', '756a947ada8cde75aebfcc9d674fcb06d5c3143ac9f8e40d01e6865d6b8559bc', 'e3b6496b036377dd09d23fec69cd8cae64e0b0b01936a564abc04076dcc55e71', '8090b6d14e467632f5876fb9da62cf017d0a0f609b7954197c60f826e83b1a8b', '2327f197493c9aeb867cb401b66068347b7d28ccc18c7b3206bc515002bbab69', '305c7722e6b3b59e9ffb631e06cb323c063d6d11b5282fd6a6664c1cb8d7ee91', '3c033b34f401247732f7c3c456fa364f5b59db321f46b995f84a3fc30106e78c', '9eae34a80d6c18174e433823135ec5765b2174c62c18b3a4bbbd2754dfbbb557', 'b3b276ab53d2bb9ff622f9b2ea7e7643e0598c3bed12033cbd25e47851d54961', '95b1cf1b9c1b8c110218f611eb22e4a9636010c316f7e3bd7eb262c3cadac5b7', 'fb33aedd1c9ed6cfe6ac52eb357b929114856a1761e4788e0e8ec3bf61c85d66', '31fb84facf4d109f79916db9667a246a641f6a1cf0ac5b8400d7a490f0f93126', 'ec02f75668ae82f22e79616c3d199ed8de8bc9e752bb4a05e8ed0503929be8f1', 'ca8ff5cafc8cf8fe21d5c32033e7eaf2d8d483ee895512f4cc26334b0eb890b8', 'd63c1e6a1bdf1cd69d4641cbe3a8e8fb76b4f85e02a3a5e5fbcc243f0b533a7a', 'f4b5bbc7f31d23db201e9c37bf8bd87f1e7c1a2e4706e438b9755468147aec98', '898ad8e8241a67be9e5e5dfe23d767306499ef91a57f4eca648b6f724c90351d', '09072dce85dbf3ba3c882b977ba54fae8f3b847aa227a9c1f86c33efa19918c0', 'c172b25efec8add4a39ce6b23f7baea5ff6f66e77a192b1363db0a53bf501b4e'] A "tsn capabilities of the tsn sub-network are made available for ip (detnet) flows via the protocol interworking function defined in ieee8021cb. for example, applied on the tsn edge port connected to the ip (detnet) node it can convert an ingress unicast ip (detnet) flow to use a specific multicast destination mac address and vlan, in order to direct the packet through a specific path inside the bridged network. a similar interworking pair at the other end of the tsn sub-network would restore the packet to its original destination mac address and vlan." {62: 1, 13: 1, 130: 1, 124: 1, 96: 1, 6: 4, 79: 4, 90: 4, 51: 2, 85: 2, 68: 4, 35: 5, 110: 4, 91: 6, 114: 4, 97: 2, 31: 5, 67: 4, 38: 5, 26: 3, 98: 4, 54: 4, 127: 5, 8: 4, 64: 4, 30: 4, 61: 6, 55: 3, 27: 5, 15: 4, 52: 2, 129: 5, 115: 4, 84: 4, 76: 7, 87: 4, 131: 7, 102: 2, 113: 6, 99: 4, 36: 4, 24: 3, 53: 3, 72: 5} {25: 1, 227: 1, 299: 1, 347: 1, 341: 1, 123: 1, 348: 1, 1: 9, 4: 4, 9: 6, 10: 5, 15: 3, 24: 4, 26: 2, 27: 3, 39: 5, 43: 5, 49: 7, 50: 6, 58: 6, 59: 4, 64: 3, 69: 5, 81: 2, 86: 4, 96: 5, 97: 4, 100: 3, 108: 5, 109: 6, 110: 6, 111: 4, 114: 5, 115: 6, 116: 2, 118: 4, 119: 3, 120: 5, 121: 4, 122: 2, 124: 4, 128: 5, 129: 4, 130: 6, 132: 5, 136: 4, 145: 5, 147: 5, 151: 5, 152: 5, 154: 5, 156: 2, 161: 4, 162: 3, 165: 5, 168: 6, 169: 4, 172: 4, 180: 5, 184: 6, 187: 7, 188: 6, 191: 5, 194: 5, 202: 6, 203: 7, 206: 4, 207: 5, 215: 4, 217: 5, 218: 8, 220: 4, 221: 4, 222: 5, 224: 5, 229: 4, 234: 7, 235: 4, 241: 4, 242: 4, 243: 5, 244: 5, 245: 5, 248: 5, 250: 4, 258: 11, 262: 6, 263: 7, 264: 5, 267: 4, 270: 3, 272: 4, 273: 6, 287: 5, 289: 4, 291: 6, 300: 3, 304: 3, 309: 4, 314: 4, 315: 4, 320: 2, 323: 5, 327: 6, 328: 5, 329: 4, 330: 10, 334: 4, 335: 2, 342: 2, 350: 8, 351: 6, 352: 4, 353: 4, 354: 3, 358: 4, 365: 4, 366: 4, 369: 3, 371: 3, 372: 6, 376: 4, 384: 6, 385: 5, 386: 5, 387: 3, 392: 5, 393: 6, 396: 2, 397: 7, 398: 6, 402: 4} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 51 "Congestion protection, latency control and the resource allocation (queuing, policing, shaping) are supported using the underlying link / sub-net specific mechanisms. Service protections (packet replication and packet elimination functions) are not provided at the DetNet layer end to end due the lack of a unified end to end sequencing information that would be available for intermediate nodes. However, such service protection can be provided on a per underlying L2 link and sub-network basis." Reflecting the 9th September discussions . acd7cae2af60dfafe42acdd9936194decc735f93 acd7cae2af60dfafe42acdd9936194decc735f93 draft-ietf-detnet-ip-over-tsn 4e26d4b73aeabbe456b8574eceb475840631aa5ff572588e9e8521eb55c3fc82 ['3897911ddc16e106cd2aefc65701e816a6d2a31a1055f6fd3ac0eb6c899b12d2', '25d7c300f819c5d6a20cacc29a44393629d0b720acce8df0ad0b7adb4c86bcdd', '62b524308c7eb98ad024dca1f2345d42c7d164c0c2df653514e755cead78cdb6', '4e26d4b73aeabbe456b8574eceb475840631aa5ff572588e9e8521eb55c3fc82', '9578df4f362f9cb7b01a0101133311aad5ba40c07927ff78f145186909ac5f2e', '756a947ada8cde75aebfcc9d674fcb06d5c3143ac9f8e40d01e6865d6b8559bc', 'e3b6496b036377dd09d23fec69cd8cae64e0b0b01936a564abc04076dcc55e71', '8090b6d14e467632f5876fb9da62cf017d0a0f609b7954197c60f826e83b1a8b', '2327f197493c9aeb867cb401b66068347b7d28ccc18c7b3206bc515002bbab69', '305c7722e6b3b59e9ffb631e06cb323c063d6d11b5282fd6a6664c1cb8d7ee91', '3c033b34f401247732f7c3c456fa364f5b59db321f46b995f84a3fc30106e78c', '9eae34a80d6c18174e433823135ec5765b2174c62c18b3a4bbbd2754dfbbb557', 'b3b276ab53d2bb9ff622f9b2ea7e7643e0598c3bed12033cbd25e47851d54961', '95b1cf1b9c1b8c110218f611eb22e4a9636010c316f7e3bd7eb262c3cadac5b7', 'fb33aedd1c9ed6cfe6ac52eb357b929114856a1761e4788e0e8ec3bf61c85d66', '31fb84facf4d109f79916db9667a246a641f6a1cf0ac5b8400d7a490f0f93126', 'ec02f75668ae82f22e79616c3d199ed8de8bc9e752bb4a05e8ed0503929be8f1', 'ca8ff5cafc8cf8fe21d5c32033e7eaf2d8d483ee895512f4cc26334b0eb890b8', 'd63c1e6a1bdf1cd69d4641cbe3a8e8fb76b4f85e02a3a5e5fbcc243f0b533a7a', 'f4b5bbc7f31d23db201e9c37bf8bd87f1e7c1a2e4706e438b9755468147aec98', '898ad8e8241a67be9e5e5dfe23d767306499ef91a57f4eca648b6f724c90351d', '09072dce85dbf3ba3c882b977ba54fae8f3b847aa227a9c1f86c33efa19918c0', 'c172b25efec8add4a39ce6b23f7baea5ff6f66e77a192b1363db0a53bf501b4e'] B "congestion protection, latency control and the resource allocation (queuing, policing, shaping) are supported using the underlying link / sub-net specific mechanisms. service protections (packet replication and packet elimination functions) are not provided at the detnet layer end to end due the lack of a unified end to end sequencing information that would be available for intermediate nodes. however, such service protection can be provided on a per underlying l2 link and sub-network basis." {62: 1, 13: 1, 130: 1, 124: 1, 96: 1, 6: 4, 79: 4, 90: 4, 51: 2, 85: 2, 68: 4, 35: 5, 110: 4, 91: 6, 114: 4, 97: 2, 31: 5, 67: 4, 38: 5, 26: 3, 98: 4, 54: 4, 127: 5, 8: 4, 64: 4, 30: 4, 61: 6, 55: 3, 27: 5, 15: 4, 52: 2, 129: 5, 115: 4, 84: 4, 76: 7, 87: 4, 131: 7, 102: 2, 113: 6, 99: 4, 36: 4, 24: 3, 53: 3, 72: 5} {25: 1, 227: 1, 299: 1, 347: 1, 341: 1, 123: 1, 348: 1, 1: 9, 4: 4, 9: 6, 10: 5, 15: 3, 24: 4, 26: 2, 27: 3, 39: 5, 43: 5, 49: 7, 50: 6, 58: 6, 59: 4, 64: 3, 69: 5, 81: 2, 86: 4, 96: 5, 97: 4, 100: 3, 108: 5, 109: 6, 110: 6, 111: 4, 114: 5, 115: 6, 116: 2, 118: 4, 119: 3, 120: 5, 121: 4, 122: 2, 124: 4, 128: 5, 129: 4, 130: 6, 132: 5, 136: 4, 145: 5, 147: 5, 151: 5, 152: 5, 154: 5, 156: 2, 161: 4, 162: 3, 165: 5, 168: 6, 169: 4, 172: 4, 180: 5, 184: 6, 187: 7, 188: 6, 191: 5, 194: 5, 202: 6, 203: 7, 206: 4, 207: 5, 215: 4, 217: 5, 218: 8, 220: 4, 221: 4, 222: 5, 224: 5, 229: 4, 234: 7, 235: 4, 241: 4, 242: 4, 243: 5, 244: 5, 245: 5, 248: 5, 250: 4, 258: 11, 262: 6, 263: 7, 264: 5, 267: 4, 270: 3, 272: 4, 273: 6, 287: 5, 289: 4, 291: 6, 300: 3, 304: 3, 309: 4, 314: 4, 315: 4, 320: 2, 323: 5, 327: 6, 328: 5, 329: 4, 330: 10, 334: 4, 335: 2, 342: 2, 350: 8, 351: 6, 352: 4, 353: 4, 354: 3, 358: 4, 365: 4, 366: 4, 369: 3, 371: 3, 372: 6, 376: 4, 384: 6, 385: 5, 386: 5, 387: 3, 392: 5, 393: 6, 396: 2, 397: 7, 398: 6, 402: 4} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 51 "fig_ip_detnet_part illustrates an extract of a DetNet enabled IP network, that uses a TSN sub-network as interconnection between two DetNet Nodes. In this figure, an Edge Node sits at the boundary of the DetNet domain and provide DetNet service proxies for the end applications by initiating and terminating DetNet service for the application's IP flows. Node and interface resources are allocated to ensure DetNet service requirements. Dotted lines around the Service components of the Edge and Relay Nodes indicate that they are DetNet service aware but do not perform any DetNet service sub-layer function, e.g., PREOF (Packet Replication, Elimination, and Ordering Functions). In this example the Edge Node and the Transit Node are interconnected by a TSN sub-network, being the primary focus of this document." Reflecting the 9th September discussions . acd7cae2af60dfafe42acdd9936194decc735f93 acd7cae2af60dfafe42acdd9936194decc735f93 draft-ietf-detnet-ip-over-tsn 2327f197493c9aeb867cb401b66068347b7d28ccc18c7b3206bc515002bbab69 ['3897911ddc16e106cd2aefc65701e816a6d2a31a1055f6fd3ac0eb6c899b12d2', '25d7c300f819c5d6a20cacc29a44393629d0b720acce8df0ad0b7adb4c86bcdd', '62b524308c7eb98ad024dca1f2345d42c7d164c0c2df653514e755cead78cdb6', '4e26d4b73aeabbe456b8574eceb475840631aa5ff572588e9e8521eb55c3fc82', '9578df4f362f9cb7b01a0101133311aad5ba40c07927ff78f145186909ac5f2e', '756a947ada8cde75aebfcc9d674fcb06d5c3143ac9f8e40d01e6865d6b8559bc', 'e3b6496b036377dd09d23fec69cd8cae64e0b0b01936a564abc04076dcc55e71', '8090b6d14e467632f5876fb9da62cf017d0a0f609b7954197c60f826e83b1a8b', '2327f197493c9aeb867cb401b66068347b7d28ccc18c7b3206bc515002bbab69', '305c7722e6b3b59e9ffb631e06cb323c063d6d11b5282fd6a6664c1cb8d7ee91', '3c033b34f401247732f7c3c456fa364f5b59db321f46b995f84a3fc30106e78c', '9eae34a80d6c18174e433823135ec5765b2174c62c18b3a4bbbd2754dfbbb557', 'b3b276ab53d2bb9ff622f9b2ea7e7643e0598c3bed12033cbd25e47851d54961', '95b1cf1b9c1b8c110218f611eb22e4a9636010c316f7e3bd7eb262c3cadac5b7', 'fb33aedd1c9ed6cfe6ac52eb357b929114856a1761e4788e0e8ec3bf61c85d66', '31fb84facf4d109f79916db9667a246a641f6a1cf0ac5b8400d7a490f0f93126', 'ec02f75668ae82f22e79616c3d199ed8de8bc9e752bb4a05e8ed0503929be8f1', 'ca8ff5cafc8cf8fe21d5c32033e7eaf2d8d483ee895512f4cc26334b0eb890b8', 'd63c1e6a1bdf1cd69d4641cbe3a8e8fb76b4f85e02a3a5e5fbcc243f0b533a7a', 'f4b5bbc7f31d23db201e9c37bf8bd87f1e7c1a2e4706e438b9755468147aec98', '898ad8e8241a67be9e5e5dfe23d767306499ef91a57f4eca648b6f724c90351d', '09072dce85dbf3ba3c882b977ba54fae8f3b847aa227a9c1f86c33efa19918c0', 'c172b25efec8add4a39ce6b23f7baea5ff6f66e77a192b1363db0a53bf501b4e'] B "fig_ip_detnet_part illustrates an extract of a detnet enabled ip network, that uses a tsn sub-network as interconnection between two detnet nodes. in this figure, an edge node sits at the boundary of the detnet domain and provide detnet service proxies for the end applications by initiating and terminating detnet service for the application's ip flows. node and interface resources are allocated to ensure detnet service requirements. dotted lines around the service components of the edge and relay nodes indicate that they are detnet service aware but do not perform any detnet service sub-layer function, e.g., preof (packet replication, elimination, and ordering functions). in this example the edge node and the transit node are interconnected by a tsn sub-network, being the primary focus of this document." {62: 1, 13: 1, 130: 1, 124: 1, 96: 1, 6: 4, 79: 4, 90: 4, 51: 2, 85: 2, 68: 4, 35: 5, 110: 4, 91: 6, 114: 4, 97: 2, 31: 5, 67: 4, 38: 5, 26: 3, 98: 4, 54: 4, 127: 5, 8: 4, 64: 4, 30: 4, 61: 6, 55: 3, 27: 5, 15: 4, 52: 2, 129: 5, 115: 4, 84: 4, 76: 7, 87: 4, 131: 7, 102: 2, 113: 6, 99: 4, 36: 4, 24: 3, 53: 3, 72: 5} {25: 1, 227: 1, 299: 1, 347: 1, 341: 1, 123: 1, 348: 1, 1: 9, 4: 4, 9: 6, 10: 5, 15: 3, 24: 4, 26: 2, 27: 3, 39: 5, 43: 5, 49: 7, 50: 6, 58: 6, 59: 4, 64: 3, 69: 5, 81: 2, 86: 4, 96: 5, 97: 4, 100: 3, 108: 5, 109: 6, 110: 6, 111: 4, 114: 5, 115: 6, 116: 2, 118: 4, 119: 3, 120: 5, 121: 4, 122: 2, 124: 4, 128: 5, 129: 4, 130: 6, 132: 5, 136: 4, 145: 5, 147: 5, 151: 5, 152: 5, 154: 5, 156: 2, 161: 4, 162: 3, 165: 5, 168: 6, 169: 4, 172: 4, 180: 5, 184: 6, 187: 7, 188: 6, 191: 5, 194: 5, 202: 6, 203: 7, 206: 4, 207: 5, 215: 4, 217: 5, 218: 8, 220: 4, 221: 4, 222: 5, 224: 5, 229: 4, 234: 7, 235: 4, 241: 4, 242: 4, 243: 5, 244: 5, 245: 5, 248: 5, 250: 4, 258: 11, 262: 6, 263: 7, 264: 5, 267: 4, 270: 3, 272: 4, 273: 6, 287: 5, 289: 4, 291: 6, 300: 3, 304: 3, 309: 4, 314: 4, 315: 4, 320: 2, 323: 5, 327: 6, 328: 5, 329: 4, 330: 10, 334: 4, 335: 2, 342: 2, 350: 8, 351: 6, 352: 4, 353: 4, 354: 3, 358: 4, 365: 4, 366: 4, 369: 3, 371: 3, 372: 6, 376: 4, 384: 6, 385: 5, 386: 5, 387: 3, 392: 5, 393: 6, 396: 2, 397: 7, 398: 6, 402: 4} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 51 "DetNet routers ensure that detnet service requirements are met per hop by allocating local resources, both receive and transmit, and by mapping the service requirements of each flow to appropriate sub- network mechanisms. Such mappings are sub-network technology specific. The mapping of DetNet IP flows to TSN streams and TSN protection mechanisms are covered in mapping-tsn." Reflecting the 9th September discussions . acd7cae2af60dfafe42acdd9936194decc735f93 acd7cae2af60dfafe42acdd9936194decc735f93 draft-ietf-detnet-ip-over-tsn 31fb84facf4d109f79916db9667a246a641f6a1cf0ac5b8400d7a490f0f93126 ['3897911ddc16e106cd2aefc65701e816a6d2a31a1055f6fd3ac0eb6c899b12d2', '25d7c300f819c5d6a20cacc29a44393629d0b720acce8df0ad0b7adb4c86bcdd', '62b524308c7eb98ad024dca1f2345d42c7d164c0c2df653514e755cead78cdb6', '4e26d4b73aeabbe456b8574eceb475840631aa5ff572588e9e8521eb55c3fc82', '9578df4f362f9cb7b01a0101133311aad5ba40c07927ff78f145186909ac5f2e', '756a947ada8cde75aebfcc9d674fcb06d5c3143ac9f8e40d01e6865d6b8559bc', 'e3b6496b036377dd09d23fec69cd8cae64e0b0b01936a564abc04076dcc55e71', '8090b6d14e467632f5876fb9da62cf017d0a0f609b7954197c60f826e83b1a8b', '2327f197493c9aeb867cb401b66068347b7d28ccc18c7b3206bc515002bbab69', '305c7722e6b3b59e9ffb631e06cb323c063d6d11b5282fd6a6664c1cb8d7ee91', '3c033b34f401247732f7c3c456fa364f5b59db321f46b995f84a3fc30106e78c', '9eae34a80d6c18174e433823135ec5765b2174c62c18b3a4bbbd2754dfbbb557', 'b3b276ab53d2bb9ff622f9b2ea7e7643e0598c3bed12033cbd25e47851d54961', '95b1cf1b9c1b8c110218f611eb22e4a9636010c316f7e3bd7eb262c3cadac5b7', 'fb33aedd1c9ed6cfe6ac52eb357b929114856a1761e4788e0e8ec3bf61c85d66', '31fb84facf4d109f79916db9667a246a641f6a1cf0ac5b8400d7a490f0f93126', 'ec02f75668ae82f22e79616c3d199ed8de8bc9e752bb4a05e8ed0503929be8f1', 'ca8ff5cafc8cf8fe21d5c32033e7eaf2d8d483ee895512f4cc26334b0eb890b8', 'd63c1e6a1bdf1cd69d4641cbe3a8e8fb76b4f85e02a3a5e5fbcc243f0b533a7a', 'f4b5bbc7f31d23db201e9c37bf8bd87f1e7c1a2e4706e438b9755468147aec98', '898ad8e8241a67be9e5e5dfe23d767306499ef91a57f4eca648b6f724c90351d', '09072dce85dbf3ba3c882b977ba54fae8f3b847aa227a9c1f86c33efa19918c0', 'c172b25efec8add4a39ce6b23f7baea5ff6f66e77a192b1363db0a53bf501b4e'] B "detnet routers ensure that detnet service requirements are met per hop by allocating local resources, both receive and transmit, and by mapping the service requirements of each flow to appropriate sub- network mechanisms. such mappings are sub-network technology specific. the mapping of detnet ip flows to tsn streams and tsn protection mechanisms are covered in mapping-tsn." {62: 1, 13: 1, 130: 1, 124: 1, 96: 1, 6: 4, 79: 4, 90: 4, 51: 2, 85: 2, 68: 4, 35: 5, 110: 4, 91: 6, 114: 4, 97: 2, 31: 5, 67: 4, 38: 5, 26: 3, 98: 4, 54: 4, 127: 5, 8: 4, 64: 4, 30: 4, 61: 6, 55: 3, 27: 5, 15: 4, 52: 2, 129: 5, 115: 4, 84: 4, 76: 7, 87: 4, 131: 7, 102: 2, 113: 6, 99: 4, 36: 4, 24: 3, 53: 3, 72: 5} {25: 1, 227: 1, 299: 1, 347: 1, 341: 1, 123: 1, 348: 1, 1: 9, 4: 4, 9: 6, 10: 5, 15: 3, 24: 4, 26: 2, 27: 3, 39: 5, 43: 5, 49: 7, 50: 6, 58: 6, 59: 4, 64: 3, 69: 5, 81: 2, 86: 4, 96: 5, 97: 4, 100: 3, 108: 5, 109: 6, 110: 6, 111: 4, 114: 5, 115: 6, 116: 2, 118: 4, 119: 3, 120: 5, 121: 4, 122: 2, 124: 4, 128: 5, 129: 4, 130: 6, 132: 5, 136: 4, 145: 5, 147: 5, 151: 5, 152: 5, 154: 5, 156: 2, 161: 4, 162: 3, 165: 5, 168: 6, 169: 4, 172: 4, 180: 5, 184: 6, 187: 7, 188: 6, 191: 5, 194: 5, 202: 6, 203: 7, 206: 4, 207: 5, 215: 4, 217: 5, 218: 8, 220: 4, 221: 4, 222: 5, 224: 5, 229: 4, 234: 7, 235: 4, 241: 4, 242: 4, 243: 5, 244: 5, 245: 5, 248: 5, 250: 4, 258: 11, 262: 6, 263: 7, 264: 5, 267: 4, 270: 3, 272: 4, 273: 6, 287: 5, 289: 4, 291: 6, 300: 3, 304: 3, 309: 4, 314: 4, 315: 4, 320: 2, 323: 5, 327: 6, 328: 5, 329: 4, 330: 10, 334: 4, 335: 2, 342: 2, 350: 8, 351: 6, 352: 4, 353: 4, 354: 3, 358: 4, 365: 4, 366: 4, 369: 3, 371: 3, 372: 6, 376: 4, 384: 6, 385: 5, 386: 5, 387: 3, 392: 5, 393: 6, 396: 2, 397: 7, 398: 6, 402: 4} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 51 "This section covers how DetNet IP flows operate over an IEEE 802.1 TSN sub-network. fig_ip_detnet_to_tsn illustrates such a scenario, where two IP (DetNet) nodes are interconnected by a TSN sub-network. Node-1 is single homed and Node-2 is dual-homed to the TSN sub- network." Reflecting the 9th September discussions . acd7cae2af60dfafe42acdd9936194decc735f93 acd7cae2af60dfafe42acdd9936194decc735f93 draft-ietf-detnet-ip-over-tsn ca8ff5cafc8cf8fe21d5c32033e7eaf2d8d483ee895512f4cc26334b0eb890b8 ['3897911ddc16e106cd2aefc65701e816a6d2a31a1055f6fd3ac0eb6c899b12d2', '25d7c300f819c5d6a20cacc29a44393629d0b720acce8df0ad0b7adb4c86bcdd', '62b524308c7eb98ad024dca1f2345d42c7d164c0c2df653514e755cead78cdb6', '4e26d4b73aeabbe456b8574eceb475840631aa5ff572588e9e8521eb55c3fc82', '9578df4f362f9cb7b01a0101133311aad5ba40c07927ff78f145186909ac5f2e', '756a947ada8cde75aebfcc9d674fcb06d5c3143ac9f8e40d01e6865d6b8559bc', 'e3b6496b036377dd09d23fec69cd8cae64e0b0b01936a564abc04076dcc55e71', '8090b6d14e467632f5876fb9da62cf017d0a0f609b7954197c60f826e83b1a8b', '2327f197493c9aeb867cb401b66068347b7d28ccc18c7b3206bc515002bbab69', '305c7722e6b3b59e9ffb631e06cb323c063d6d11b5282fd6a6664c1cb8d7ee91', '3c033b34f401247732f7c3c456fa364f5b59db321f46b995f84a3fc30106e78c', '9eae34a80d6c18174e433823135ec5765b2174c62c18b3a4bbbd2754dfbbb557', 'b3b276ab53d2bb9ff622f9b2ea7e7643e0598c3bed12033cbd25e47851d54961', '95b1cf1b9c1b8c110218f611eb22e4a9636010c316f7e3bd7eb262c3cadac5b7', 'fb33aedd1c9ed6cfe6ac52eb357b929114856a1761e4788e0e8ec3bf61c85d66', '31fb84facf4d109f79916db9667a246a641f6a1cf0ac5b8400d7a490f0f93126', 'ec02f75668ae82f22e79616c3d199ed8de8bc9e752bb4a05e8ed0503929be8f1', 'ca8ff5cafc8cf8fe21d5c32033e7eaf2d8d483ee895512f4cc26334b0eb890b8', 'd63c1e6a1bdf1cd69d4641cbe3a8e8fb76b4f85e02a3a5e5fbcc243f0b533a7a', 'f4b5bbc7f31d23db201e9c37bf8bd87f1e7c1a2e4706e438b9755468147aec98', '898ad8e8241a67be9e5e5dfe23d767306499ef91a57f4eca648b6f724c90351d', '09072dce85dbf3ba3c882b977ba54fae8f3b847aa227a9c1f86c33efa19918c0', 'c172b25efec8add4a39ce6b23f7baea5ff6f66e77a192b1363db0a53bf501b4e'] B "this section covers how detnet ip flows operate over an ieee 802.1 tsn sub-network. fig_ip_detnet_to_tsn illustrates such a scenario, where two ip (detnet) nodes are interconnected by a tsn sub-network. node-1 is single homed and node-2 is dual-homed to the tsn sub- network." {62: 1, 13: 1, 130: 1, 124: 1, 96: 1, 6: 4, 79: 4, 90: 4, 51: 2, 85: 2, 68: 4, 35: 5, 110: 4, 91: 6, 114: 4, 97: 2, 31: 5, 67: 4, 38: 5, 26: 3, 98: 4, 54: 4, 127: 5, 8: 4, 64: 4, 30: 4, 61: 6, 55: 3, 27: 5, 15: 4, 52: 2, 129: 5, 115: 4, 84: 4, 76: 7, 87: 4, 131: 7, 102: 2, 113: 6, 99: 4, 36: 4, 24: 3, 53: 3, 72: 5} {25: 1, 227: 1, 299: 1, 347: 1, 341: 1, 123: 1, 348: 1, 1: 9, 4: 4, 9: 6, 10: 5, 15: 3, 24: 4, 26: 2, 27: 3, 39: 5, 43: 5, 49: 7, 50: 6, 58: 6, 59: 4, 64: 3, 69: 5, 81: 2, 86: 4, 96: 5, 97: 4, 100: 3, 108: 5, 109: 6, 110: 6, 111: 4, 114: 5, 115: 6, 116: 2, 118: 4, 119: 3, 120: 5, 121: 4, 122: 2, 124: 4, 128: 5, 129: 4, 130: 6, 132: 5, 136: 4, 145: 5, 147: 5, 151: 5, 152: 5, 154: 5, 156: 2, 161: 4, 162: 3, 165: 5, 168: 6, 169: 4, 172: 4, 180: 5, 184: 6, 187: 7, 188: 6, 191: 5, 194: 5, 202: 6, 203: 7, 206: 4, 207: 5, 215: 4, 217: 5, 218: 8, 220: 4, 221: 4, 222: 5, 224: 5, 229: 4, 234: 7, 235: 4, 241: 4, 242: 4, 243: 5, 244: 5, 245: 5, 248: 5, 250: 4, 258: 11, 262: 6, 263: 7, 264: 5, 267: 4, 270: 3, 272: 4, 273: 6, 287: 5, 289: 4, 291: 6, 300: 3, 304: 3, 309: 4, 314: 4, 315: 4, 320: 2, 323: 5, 327: 6, 328: 5, 329: 4, 330: 10, 334: 4, 335: 2, 342: 2, 350: 8, 351: 6, 352: 4, 353: 4, 354: 3, 358: 4, 365: 4, 366: 4, 369: 3, 371: 3, 372: 6, 376: 4, 384: 6, 385: 5, 386: 5, 387: 3, 392: 5, 393: 6, 396: 2, 397: 7, 398: 6, 402: 4} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 51 "The Time-Sensitive Networking (TSN) Task Group of the IEEE 802.1 Working Group have defined (and are defining) a number of amendments to IEEE8021Q that provide zero congestion loss and bounded latency in bridged networks. Furthermore IEEE8021CB defines frame replication and elimination functions for reliability that should prove both compatible with and useful to DetNet networks. All these functions have to identify flows that require TSN treatment." Reflecting the 9th September discussions . acd7cae2af60dfafe42acdd9936194decc735f93 acd7cae2af60dfafe42acdd9936194decc735f93 draft-ietf-detnet-ip-over-tsn 8090b6d14e467632f5876fb9da62cf017d0a0f609b7954197c60f826e83b1a8b ['3897911ddc16e106cd2aefc65701e816a6d2a31a1055f6fd3ac0eb6c899b12d2', '25d7c300f819c5d6a20cacc29a44393629d0b720acce8df0ad0b7adb4c86bcdd', '62b524308c7eb98ad024dca1f2345d42c7d164c0c2df653514e755cead78cdb6', '4e26d4b73aeabbe456b8574eceb475840631aa5ff572588e9e8521eb55c3fc82', '9578df4f362f9cb7b01a0101133311aad5ba40c07927ff78f145186909ac5f2e', '756a947ada8cde75aebfcc9d674fcb06d5c3143ac9f8e40d01e6865d6b8559bc', 'e3b6496b036377dd09d23fec69cd8cae64e0b0b01936a564abc04076dcc55e71', '8090b6d14e467632f5876fb9da62cf017d0a0f609b7954197c60f826e83b1a8b', '2327f197493c9aeb867cb401b66068347b7d28ccc18c7b3206bc515002bbab69', '305c7722e6b3b59e9ffb631e06cb323c063d6d11b5282fd6a6664c1cb8d7ee91', '3c033b34f401247732f7c3c456fa364f5b59db321f46b995f84a3fc30106e78c', '9eae34a80d6c18174e433823135ec5765b2174c62c18b3a4bbbd2754dfbbb557', 'b3b276ab53d2bb9ff622f9b2ea7e7643e0598c3bed12033cbd25e47851d54961', '95b1cf1b9c1b8c110218f611eb22e4a9636010c316f7e3bd7eb262c3cadac5b7', 'fb33aedd1c9ed6cfe6ac52eb357b929114856a1761e4788e0e8ec3bf61c85d66', '31fb84facf4d109f79916db9667a246a641f6a1cf0ac5b8400d7a490f0f93126', 'ec02f75668ae82f22e79616c3d199ed8de8bc9e752bb4a05e8ed0503929be8f1', 'ca8ff5cafc8cf8fe21d5c32033e7eaf2d8d483ee895512f4cc26334b0eb890b8', 'd63c1e6a1bdf1cd69d4641cbe3a8e8fb76b4f85e02a3a5e5fbcc243f0b533a7a', 'f4b5bbc7f31d23db201e9c37bf8bd87f1e7c1a2e4706e438b9755468147aec98', '898ad8e8241a67be9e5e5dfe23d767306499ef91a57f4eca648b6f724c90351d', '09072dce85dbf3ba3c882b977ba54fae8f3b847aa227a9c1f86c33efa19918c0', 'c172b25efec8add4a39ce6b23f7baea5ff6f66e77a192b1363db0a53bf501b4e'] B "the time-sensitive networking (tsn) task group of the ieee 802.1 working group have defined (and are defining) a number of amendments to ieee8021q that provide zero congestion loss and bounded latency in bridged networks. furthermore ieee8021cb defines frame replication and elimination functions for reliability that should prove both compatible with and useful to detnet networks. all these functions have to identify flows that require tsn treatment." {62: 1, 13: 1, 130: 1, 124: 1, 96: 1, 6: 4, 79: 4, 90: 4, 51: 2, 85: 2, 68: 4, 35: 5, 110: 4, 91: 6, 114: 4, 97: 2, 31: 5, 67: 4, 38: 5, 26: 3, 98: 4, 54: 4, 127: 5, 8: 4, 64: 4, 30: 4, 61: 6, 55: 3, 27: 5, 15: 4, 52: 2, 129: 5, 115: 4, 84: 4, 76: 7, 87: 4, 131: 7, 102: 2, 113: 6, 99: 4, 36: 4, 24: 3, 53: 3, 72: 5} {25: 1, 227: 1, 299: 1, 347: 1, 341: 1, 123: 1, 348: 1, 1: 9, 4: 4, 9: 6, 10: 5, 15: 3, 24: 4, 26: 2, 27: 3, 39: 5, 43: 5, 49: 7, 50: 6, 58: 6, 59: 4, 64: 3, 69: 5, 81: 2, 86: 4, 96: 5, 97: 4, 100: 3, 108: 5, 109: 6, 110: 6, 111: 4, 114: 5, 115: 6, 116: 2, 118: 4, 119: 3, 120: 5, 121: 4, 122: 2, 124: 4, 128: 5, 129: 4, 130: 6, 132: 5, 136: 4, 145: 5, 147: 5, 151: 5, 152: 5, 154: 5, 156: 2, 161: 4, 162: 3, 165: 5, 168: 6, 169: 4, 172: 4, 180: 5, 184: 6, 187: 7, 188: 6, 191: 5, 194: 5, 202: 6, 203: 7, 206: 4, 207: 5, 215: 4, 217: 5, 218: 8, 220: 4, 221: 4, 222: 5, 224: 5, 229: 4, 234: 7, 235: 4, 241: 4, 242: 4, 243: 5, 244: 5, 245: 5, 248: 5, 250: 4, 258: 11, 262: 6, 263: 7, 264: 5, 267: 4, 270: 3, 272: 4, 273: 6, 287: 5, 289: 4, 291: 6, 300: 3, 304: 3, 309: 4, 314: 4, 315: 4, 320: 2, 323: 5, 327: 6, 328: 5, 329: 4, 330: 10, 334: 4, 335: 2, 342: 2, 350: 8, 351: 6, 352: 4, 353: 4, 354: 3, 358: 4, 365: 4, 366: 4, 369: 3, 371: 3, 372: 6, 376: 4, 384: 6, 385: 5, 386: 5, 387: 3, 392: 5, 393: 6, 396: 2, 397: 7, 398: 6, 402: 4} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 51 "TSN capabilities of the TSN sub-network are made available for IP (DetNet) flows via the protocol interworking function defined in IEEE8021CB. For example, applied on the TSN edge port it can convert an ingress unicast IP (DetNet) flow to use a specific Layer-2 multicast destination MAC address and a VLAN, in order to direct the packet through a specific path inside the bridged network. A similar interworking function pair at the other end of the TSN sub-network would restore the packet to its original Layer-2 destination MAC address and VLAN." Reflecting the 9th September discussions . acd7cae2af60dfafe42acdd9936194decc735f93 acd7cae2af60dfafe42acdd9936194decc735f93 draft-ietf-detnet-ip-over-tsn 305c7722e6b3b59e9ffb631e06cb323c063d6d11b5282fd6a6664c1cb8d7ee91 ['3897911ddc16e106cd2aefc65701e816a6d2a31a1055f6fd3ac0eb6c899b12d2', '25d7c300f819c5d6a20cacc29a44393629d0b720acce8df0ad0b7adb4c86bcdd', '62b524308c7eb98ad024dca1f2345d42c7d164c0c2df653514e755cead78cdb6', '4e26d4b73aeabbe456b8574eceb475840631aa5ff572588e9e8521eb55c3fc82', '9578df4f362f9cb7b01a0101133311aad5ba40c07927ff78f145186909ac5f2e', '756a947ada8cde75aebfcc9d674fcb06d5c3143ac9f8e40d01e6865d6b8559bc', 'e3b6496b036377dd09d23fec69cd8cae64e0b0b01936a564abc04076dcc55e71', '8090b6d14e467632f5876fb9da62cf017d0a0f609b7954197c60f826e83b1a8b', '2327f197493c9aeb867cb401b66068347b7d28ccc18c7b3206bc515002bbab69', '305c7722e6b3b59e9ffb631e06cb323c063d6d11b5282fd6a6664c1cb8d7ee91', '3c033b34f401247732f7c3c456fa364f5b59db321f46b995f84a3fc30106e78c', '9eae34a80d6c18174e433823135ec5765b2174c62c18b3a4bbbd2754dfbbb557', 'b3b276ab53d2bb9ff622f9b2ea7e7643e0598c3bed12033cbd25e47851d54961', '95b1cf1b9c1b8c110218f611eb22e4a9636010c316f7e3bd7eb262c3cadac5b7', 'fb33aedd1c9ed6cfe6ac52eb357b929114856a1761e4788e0e8ec3bf61c85d66', '31fb84facf4d109f79916db9667a246a641f6a1cf0ac5b8400d7a490f0f93126', 'ec02f75668ae82f22e79616c3d199ed8de8bc9e752bb4a05e8ed0503929be8f1', 'ca8ff5cafc8cf8fe21d5c32033e7eaf2d8d483ee895512f4cc26334b0eb890b8', 'd63c1e6a1bdf1cd69d4641cbe3a8e8fb76b4f85e02a3a5e5fbcc243f0b533a7a', 'f4b5bbc7f31d23db201e9c37bf8bd87f1e7c1a2e4706e438b9755468147aec98', '898ad8e8241a67be9e5e5dfe23d767306499ef91a57f4eca648b6f724c90351d', '09072dce85dbf3ba3c882b977ba54fae8f3b847aa227a9c1f86c33efa19918c0', 'c172b25efec8add4a39ce6b23f7baea5ff6f66e77a192b1363db0a53bf501b4e'] B "tsn capabilities of the tsn sub-network are made available for ip (detnet) flows via the protocol interworking function defined in ieee8021cb. for example, applied on the tsn edge port it can convert an ingress unicast ip (detnet) flow to use a specific layer-2 multicast destination mac address and a vlan, in order to direct the packet through a specific path inside the bridged network. a similar interworking function pair at the other end of the tsn sub-network would restore the packet to its original layer-2 destination mac address and vlan." {62: 1, 13: 1, 130: 1, 124: 1, 96: 1, 6: 4, 79: 4, 90: 4, 51: 2, 85: 2, 68: 4, 35: 5, 110: 4, 91: 6, 114: 4, 97: 2, 31: 5, 67: 4, 38: 5, 26: 3, 98: 4, 54: 4, 127: 5, 8: 4, 64: 4, 30: 4, 61: 6, 55: 3, 27: 5, 15: 4, 52: 2, 129: 5, 115: 4, 84: 4, 76: 7, 87: 4, 131: 7, 102: 2, 113: 6, 99: 4, 36: 4, 24: 3, 53: 3, 72: 5} {25: 1, 227: 1, 299: 1, 347: 1, 341: 1, 123: 1, 348: 1, 1: 9, 4: 4, 9: 6, 10: 5, 15: 3, 24: 4, 26: 2, 27: 3, 39: 5, 43: 5, 49: 7, 50: 6, 58: 6, 59: 4, 64: 3, 69: 5, 81: 2, 86: 4, 96: 5, 97: 4, 100: 3, 108: 5, 109: 6, 110: 6, 111: 4, 114: 5, 115: 6, 116: 2, 118: 4, 119: 3, 120: 5, 121: 4, 122: 2, 124: 4, 128: 5, 129: 4, 130: 6, 132: 5, 136: 4, 145: 5, 147: 5, 151: 5, 152: 5, 154: 5, 156: 2, 161: 4, 162: 3, 165: 5, 168: 6, 169: 4, 172: 4, 180: 5, 184: 6, 187: 7, 188: 6, 191: 5, 194: 5, 202: 6, 203: 7, 206: 4, 207: 5, 215: 4, 217: 5, 218: 8, 220: 4, 221: 4, 222: 5, 224: 5, 229: 4, 234: 7, 235: 4, 241: 4, 242: 4, 243: 5, 244: 5, 245: 5, 248: 5, 250: 4, 258: 11, 262: 6, 263: 7, 264: 5, 267: 4, 270: 3, 272: 4, 273: 6, 287: 5, 289: 4, 291: 6, 300: 3, 304: 3, 309: 4, 314: 4, 315: 4, 320: 2, 323: 5, 327: 6, 328: 5, 329: 4, 330: 10, 334: 4, 335: 2, 342: 2, 350: 8, 351: 6, 352: 4, 353: 4, 354: 3, 358: 4, 365: 4, 366: 4, 369: 3, 371: 3, 372: 6, 376: 4, 384: 6, 385: 5, 386: 5, 387: 3, 392: 5, 393: 6, 396: 2, 397: 7, 398: 6, 402: 4} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 51 "DetNet IP Flow and TSN Stream mapping is based on the active Stream Identification function, that operates at the frame level. IEEE8021CB defines an Active Destination MAC and VLAN Stream identification function, what can replace some Ethernet header fields namely (1) the destination MAC-address, (2) the VLAN-ID and (3) priority parameters with alternate values. Replacement is provided for the frame passed down the stack from the upper layers or up the stack from the lower layers." Reflecting the 9th September discussions . acd7cae2af60dfafe42acdd9936194decc735f93 acd7cae2af60dfafe42acdd9936194decc735f93 draft-ietf-detnet-ip-over-tsn ddeb80d43af1f9680d16d5f8e222fce25fbcb188448414eeae6547c4d2c3173e ['4921d6589b1c7097e9863f5b0ed1aa0c4c4f3db46278b3c4d98973dabdda583c', 'fe1fc1f847582eeb8a35d700bf8f4be6b97b56b4536f0164f4d5fb089f66b2ab', '630a7b3cd3eda2e026f158d16d3e4a4a2526a07124cf77aa8ed446ea760814d8', 'ddeb80d43af1f9680d16d5f8e222fce25fbcb188448414eeae6547c4d2c3173e'] A "detnet ip flow and tsn stream mapping is based on the active stream identification function, that operates at the frame level. ieee8021cb defines an active destination mac and vlan stream identification function, what can replace some ethernet header fields namely (1) the destination mac-address, (2) the vlan-id and (3) priority parameters with alternate values. replacement is provided for the frame passed down the stack from the upper layers or up the stack from the lower layers." {96: 1, 52: 1, 97: 1, 6: 3, 79: 3, 90: 3, 51: 2, 130: 2, 62: 3, 85: 4, 68: 5, 35: 4, 110: 3, 91: 5, 114: 3, 31: 4, 13: 3, 67: 3, 38: 4, 26: 3, 124: 3, 98: 3, 54: 3, 127: 4, 8: 3, 64: 3, 30: 3, 61: 5, 55: 4, 27: 4, 15: 3, 129: 4, 115: 3, 84: 3, 76: 7, 87: 3, 131: 6, 102: 3, 113: 5, 99: 3, 36: 3, 24: 2, 53: 2, 72: 4} {123: 1, 156: 1, 335: 1, 1: 10, 4: 3, 9: 6, 10: 4, 15: 2, 24: 3, 25: 3, 26: 4, 27: 2, 39: 6, 43: 4, 49: 6, 50: 5, 58: 5, 59: 3, 64: 2, 69: 5, 81: 4, 82: 2, 86: 3, 96: 4, 97: 3, 100: 5, 108: 4, 109: 5, 110: 5, 111: 3, 114: 4, 115: 5, 118: 6, 119: 5, 120: 4, 121: 5, 122: 2, 124: 5, 128: 4, 129: 3, 130: 5, 132: 5, 136: 3, 145: 5, 147: 4, 151: 4, 152: 4, 154: 4, 161: 4, 162: 4, 165: 4, 168: 5, 169: 3, 172: 3, 180: 4, 184: 6, 187: 6, 188: 5, 191: 4, 194: 5, 202: 6, 203: 7, 206: 3, 207: 4, 215: 3, 217: 4, 218: 9, 220: 3, 221: 3, 222: 6, 224: 4, 227: 3, 229: 3, 234: 6, 235: 3, 241: 3, 242: 3, 243: 5, 244: 4, 245: 5, 248: 4, 250: 3, 258: 12, 262: 5, 263: 6, 264: 4, 267: 5, 270: 2, 272: 3, 273: 6, 287: 4, 289: 3, 291: 5, 299: 3, 300: 2, 304: 2, 309: 4, 314: 3, 315: 3, 320: 4, 323: 5, 327: 5, 328: 4, 329: 3, 330: 11, 334: 3, 341: 3, 342: 4, 347: 3, 348: 3, 350: 8, 351: 5, 352: 3, 353: 3, 354: 2, 358: 5, 365: 3, 366: 3, 369: 2, 371: 5, 372: 5, 376: 3, 384: 5, 385: 4, 386: 4, 387: 2, 392: 4, 393: 5, 396: 4, 397: 8, 398: 7, 402: 3} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 51 "Mapping of a DetNet IP flow to a TSN Stream is provided via the combination of a passive and an active stream identification function that operate at the frame level. The passive stream identification function is used to catch the 6-tuple of a DetNet IP flow and the active stream identification function is used to modify the Ethernet header according to ID of the mapped TSN Stream." Reflecting the 9th September discussions . acd7cae2af60dfafe42acdd9936194decc735f93 acd7cae2af60dfafe42acdd9936194decc735f93 draft-ietf-detnet-ip-over-tsn 4921d6589b1c7097e9863f5b0ed1aa0c4c4f3db46278b3c4d98973dabdda583c ['4921d6589b1c7097e9863f5b0ed1aa0c4c4f3db46278b3c4d98973dabdda583c', 'fe1fc1f847582eeb8a35d700bf8f4be6b97b56b4536f0164f4d5fb089f66b2ab', '630a7b3cd3eda2e026f158d16d3e4a4a2526a07124cf77aa8ed446ea760814d8', 'ddeb80d43af1f9680d16d5f8e222fce25fbcb188448414eeae6547c4d2c3173e'] B "mapping of a detnet ip flow to a tsn stream is provided via the combination of a passive and an active stream identification function that operate at the frame level. the passive stream identification function is used to catch the 6-tuple of a detnet ip flow and the active stream identification function is used to modify the ethernet header according to id of the mapped tsn stream." {96: 1, 52: 1, 97: 1, 6: 3, 79: 3, 90: 3, 51: 2, 130: 2, 62: 3, 85: 4, 68: 5, 35: 4, 110: 3, 91: 5, 114: 3, 31: 4, 13: 3, 67: 3, 38: 4, 26: 3, 124: 3, 98: 3, 54: 3, 127: 4, 8: 3, 64: 3, 30: 3, 61: 5, 55: 4, 27: 4, 15: 3, 129: 4, 115: 3, 84: 3, 76: 7, 87: 3, 131: 6, 102: 3, 113: 5, 99: 3, 36: 3, 24: 2, 53: 2, 72: 4} {123: 1, 156: 1, 335: 1, 1: 10, 4: 3, 9: 6, 10: 4, 15: 2, 24: 3, 25: 3, 26: 4, 27: 2, 39: 6, 43: 4, 49: 6, 50: 5, 58: 5, 59: 3, 64: 2, 69: 5, 81: 4, 82: 2, 86: 3, 96: 4, 97: 3, 100: 5, 108: 4, 109: 5, 110: 5, 111: 3, 114: 4, 115: 5, 118: 6, 119: 5, 120: 4, 121: 5, 122: 2, 124: 5, 128: 4, 129: 3, 130: 5, 132: 5, 136: 3, 145: 5, 147: 4, 151: 4, 152: 4, 154: 4, 161: 4, 162: 4, 165: 4, 168: 5, 169: 3, 172: 3, 180: 4, 184: 6, 187: 6, 188: 5, 191: 4, 194: 5, 202: 6, 203: 7, 206: 3, 207: 4, 215: 3, 217: 4, 218: 9, 220: 3, 221: 3, 222: 6, 224: 4, 227: 3, 229: 3, 234: 6, 235: 3, 241: 3, 242: 3, 243: 5, 244: 4, 245: 5, 248: 4, 250: 3, 258: 12, 262: 5, 263: 6, 264: 4, 267: 5, 270: 2, 272: 3, 273: 6, 287: 4, 289: 3, 291: 5, 299: 3, 300: 2, 304: 2, 309: 4, 314: 3, 315: 3, 320: 4, 323: 5, 327: 5, 328: 4, 329: 3, 330: 11, 334: 3, 341: 3, 342: 4, 347: 3, 348: 3, 350: 8, 351: 5, 352: 3, 353: 3, 354: 2, 358: 5, 365: 3, 366: 3, 369: 2, 371: 5, 372: 5, 376: 3, 384: 5, 385: 4, 386: 4, 387: 2, 392: 4, 393: 5, 396: 4, 397: 8, 398: 7, 402: 3} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 51 "IEEE8021CB defines an IP Stream identification function that can be used as a passive function for IP DetNet flows using UDP or TCP. IEEEP8021CBdb defines a Mask-and-Match Stream identification function that can be used as a passive function for any IP DetNet flows." Reflecting the 9th September discussions . acd7cae2af60dfafe42acdd9936194decc735f93 acd7cae2af60dfafe42acdd9936194decc735f93 draft-ietf-detnet-ip-over-tsn fe1fc1f847582eeb8a35d700bf8f4be6b97b56b4536f0164f4d5fb089f66b2ab ['4921d6589b1c7097e9863f5b0ed1aa0c4c4f3db46278b3c4d98973dabdda583c', 'fe1fc1f847582eeb8a35d700bf8f4be6b97b56b4536f0164f4d5fb089f66b2ab', '630a7b3cd3eda2e026f158d16d3e4a4a2526a07124cf77aa8ed446ea760814d8', 'ddeb80d43af1f9680d16d5f8e222fce25fbcb188448414eeae6547c4d2c3173e'] B "ieee8021cb defines an ip stream identification function that can be used as a passive function for ip detnet flows using udp or tcp. ieeep8021cbdb defines a mask-and-match stream identification function that can be used as a passive function for any ip detnet flows." {96: 1, 52: 1, 97: 1, 6: 3, 79: 3, 90: 3, 51: 2, 130: 2, 62: 3, 85: 4, 68: 5, 35: 4, 110: 3, 91: 5, 114: 3, 31: 4, 13: 3, 67: 3, 38: 4, 26: 3, 124: 3, 98: 3, 54: 3, 127: 4, 8: 3, 64: 3, 30: 3, 61: 5, 55: 4, 27: 4, 15: 3, 129: 4, 115: 3, 84: 3, 76: 7, 87: 3, 131: 6, 102: 3, 113: 5, 99: 3, 36: 3, 24: 2, 53: 2, 72: 4} {123: 1, 156: 1, 335: 1, 1: 10, 4: 3, 9: 6, 10: 4, 15: 2, 24: 3, 25: 3, 26: 4, 27: 2, 39: 6, 43: 4, 49: 6, 50: 5, 58: 5, 59: 3, 64: 2, 69: 5, 81: 4, 82: 2, 86: 3, 96: 4, 97: 3, 100: 5, 108: 4, 109: 5, 110: 5, 111: 3, 114: 4, 115: 5, 118: 6, 119: 5, 120: 4, 121: 5, 122: 2, 124: 5, 128: 4, 129: 3, 130: 5, 132: 5, 136: 3, 145: 5, 147: 4, 151: 4, 152: 4, 154: 4, 161: 4, 162: 4, 165: 4, 168: 5, 169: 3, 172: 3, 180: 4, 184: 6, 187: 6, 188: 5, 191: 4, 194: 5, 202: 6, 203: 7, 206: 3, 207: 4, 215: 3, 217: 4, 218: 9, 220: 3, 221: 3, 222: 6, 224: 4, 227: 3, 229: 3, 234: 6, 235: 3, 241: 3, 242: 3, 243: 5, 244: 4, 245: 5, 248: 4, 250: 3, 258: 12, 262: 5, 263: 6, 264: 4, 267: 5, 270: 2, 272: 3, 273: 6, 287: 4, 289: 3, 291: 5, 299: 3, 300: 2, 304: 2, 309: 4, 314: 3, 315: 3, 320: 4, 323: 5, 327: 5, 328: 4, 329: 3, 330: 11, 334: 3, 341: 3, 342: 4, 347: 3, 348: 3, 350: 8, 351: 5, 352: 3, 353: 3, 354: 2, 358: 5, 365: 3, 366: 3, 369: 2, 371: 5, 372: 5, 376: 3, 384: 5, 385: 4, 386: 4, 387: 2, 392: 4, 393: 5, 396: 4, 397: 8, 398: 7, 402: 3} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 51 "IEEE8021CB defines an Active Destination MAC and VLAN Stream identification function, what can replace some Ethernet header fields namely (1) the destination MAC-address, (2) the VLAN-ID and (3) priority parameters with alternate values. Replacement is provided for the frame passed down the stack from the upper layers or up the stack from the lower layers." Reflecting the 9th September discussions . acd7cae2af60dfafe42acdd9936194decc735f93 acd7cae2af60dfafe42acdd9936194decc735f93 draft-ietf-detnet-ip-over-tsn 630a7b3cd3eda2e026f158d16d3e4a4a2526a07124cf77aa8ed446ea760814d8 ['4921d6589b1c7097e9863f5b0ed1aa0c4c4f3db46278b3c4d98973dabdda583c', 'fe1fc1f847582eeb8a35d700bf8f4be6b97b56b4536f0164f4d5fb089f66b2ab', '630a7b3cd3eda2e026f158d16d3e4a4a2526a07124cf77aa8ed446ea760814d8', 'ddeb80d43af1f9680d16d5f8e222fce25fbcb188448414eeae6547c4d2c3173e'] B "ieee8021cb defines an active destination mac and vlan stream identification function, what can replace some ethernet header fields namely (1) the destination mac-address, (2) the vlan-id and (3) priority parameters with alternate values. replacement is provided for the frame passed down the stack from the upper layers or up the stack from the lower layers." {96: 1, 52: 1, 97: 1, 6: 3, 79: 3, 90: 3, 51: 2, 130: 2, 62: 3, 85: 4, 68: 5, 35: 4, 110: 3, 91: 5, 114: 3, 31: 4, 13: 3, 67: 3, 38: 4, 26: 3, 124: 3, 98: 3, 54: 3, 127: 4, 8: 3, 64: 3, 30: 3, 61: 5, 55: 4, 27: 4, 15: 3, 129: 4, 115: 3, 84: 3, 76: 7, 87: 3, 131: 6, 102: 3, 113: 5, 99: 3, 36: 3, 24: 2, 53: 2, 72: 4} {123: 1, 156: 1, 335: 1, 1: 10, 4: 3, 9: 6, 10: 4, 15: 2, 24: 3, 25: 3, 26: 4, 27: 2, 39: 6, 43: 4, 49: 6, 50: 5, 58: 5, 59: 3, 64: 2, 69: 5, 81: 4, 82: 2, 86: 3, 96: 4, 97: 3, 100: 5, 108: 4, 109: 5, 110: 5, 111: 3, 114: 4, 115: 5, 118: 6, 119: 5, 120: 4, 121: 5, 122: 2, 124: 5, 128: 4, 129: 3, 130: 5, 132: 5, 136: 3, 145: 5, 147: 4, 151: 4, 152: 4, 154: 4, 161: 4, 162: 4, 165: 4, 168: 5, 169: 3, 172: 3, 180: 4, 184: 6, 187: 6, 188: 5, 191: 4, 194: 5, 202: 6, 203: 7, 206: 3, 207: 4, 215: 3, 217: 4, 218: 9, 220: 3, 221: 3, 222: 6, 224: 4, 227: 3, 229: 3, 234: 6, 235: 3, 241: 3, 242: 3, 243: 5, 244: 4, 245: 5, 248: 4, 250: 3, 258: 12, 262: 5, 263: 6, 264: 4, 267: 5, 270: 2, 272: 3, 273: 6, 287: 4, 289: 3, 291: 5, 299: 3, 300: 2, 304: 2, 309: 4, 314: 3, 315: 3, 320: 4, 323: 5, 327: 5, 328: 4, 329: 3, 330: 11, 334: 3, 341: 3, 342: 4, 347: 3, 348: 3, 350: 8, 351: 5, 352: 3, 353: 3, 354: 2, 358: 5, 365: 3, 366: 3, 369: 2, 371: 5, 372: 5, 376: 3, 384: 5, 385: 4, 386: 4, 387: 2, 392: 4, 393: 5, 396: 4, 397: 8, 398: 7, 402: 3} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 51 "Active Destination MAC and VLAN Stream identification can be used within a Talker to set flow identity or a Listener to recover the original addressing information. It can be used also in a TSN bridge that is providing translation as a proxy service for an End System. As a result IP (DetNet) flows can be mapped to use a particular {MAC- address, VLAN} pair to match the Stream in the TSN sub-network." Reflecting the 9th September discussions . acd7cae2af60dfafe42acdd9936194decc735f93 acd7cae2af60dfafe42acdd9936194decc735f93 draft-ietf-detnet-ip-over-tsn ca3de1300d25dd0c427db1bee2c3a07497192c2ee0569af5a2680a011f0260af ['1053f835fa0c23e5e0be64388d587c7cc201a77844a8fbb716d720640b0549ab', '417df728e954576101d7177ca52e701a308b2bf91f77a2aa663245aed41302a4', '7ac09938faf2d97ce8bcc3b64b905bb5a585aeb30156506ee7abe2cd36825ed9', '6e1359ed3e65e5e9f120654940828dc13452a32a8a4acfab11d893c994ec8b09', '428996c63c0b3d28c52c4558b1e40faa72088ca53cf822a696698c62118ed646', '39820f7cb577ca0dcfb1bfa578ae13c25334acae03e89731064b0e3c300841de', '892d2555f9a89a54f020e44c71d17881727e9c245d0c7a7054f24fb2bfd083c9', '16cc4d5093d5406483d5c6813be03012581eb426cf71f79764772640049f731b', '214810fe3ac0ef76db60e2d0623a8259b9bdf49040882a9e710901fe1eb32fde', '32f367c0df09e73fbac0f227a892fe94f0bf481c36bcaec69b0c9ae7d9198747', 'ca3de1300d25dd0c427db1bee2c3a07497192c2ee0569af5a2680a011f0260af', '73fe0d9e382eeb3be060393606b0decefb645e4461ed9f78dcdbd50d5904e4ee', '58f02544b08a4f310a4b8b24c67191e59419583141684e5268fc094eae9b43c9', 'e5264c09892e29645048ef86c987f95a814e2e01c98332d2d8809eed04a0b5d2', '8e1ef1f3845546bfbed884c94f51a19cee8ebfdc977f4c9091a1008026c540af', '9e47f9c49d4ffb131be31e7b5676a91050b375d823d18009e9fff94ec9b38956', '2f07ef13fb197dfbb24335dba11708eeddc61cae0c297c3eb842636965aba642', 'e30e0920d1ef0023a63ec84cdaaee8fad200ac339db4ef1aeb0762ec6171e227'] A "active destination mac and vlan stream identification can be used within a talker to set flow identity or a listener to recover the original addressing information. it can be used also in a tsn bridge that is providing translation as a proxy service for an end system. as a result ip (detnet) flows can be mapped to use a particular {mac- address, vlan} pair to match the stream in the tsn sub-network." {96: 1, 97: 1, 52: 1, 6: 3, 79: 3, 90: 3, 130: 2, 62: 4, 85: 5, 51: 2, 68: 5, 35: 4, 110: 3, 91: 5, 114: 3, 31: 4, 13: 3, 67: 3, 38: 4, 26: 3, 124: 4, 98: 3, 54: 3, 127: 4, 8: 3, 64: 3, 30: 3, 61: 5, 55: 4, 27: 4, 15: 3, 129: 4, 115: 3, 84: 3, 76: 7, 87: 3, 131: 6, 102: 3, 113: 5, 99: 3, 36: 3, 24: 2, 53: 2, 72: 4} {250: 1, 387: 1, 156: 1, 300: 1, 1: 10, 4: 3, 9: 6, 10: 4, 24: 3, 25: 4, 26: 5, 27: 2, 39: 6, 43: 4, 49: 6, 50: 5, 58: 5, 59: 3, 64: 2, 69: 5, 81: 5, 82: 3, 86: 3, 96: 4, 97: 3, 100: 6, 108: 4, 109: 5, 110: 5, 111: 3, 114: 4, 115: 5, 116: 2, 118: 7, 119: 6, 120: 4, 121: 5, 122: 3, 123: 2, 124: 5, 128: 4, 129: 3, 130: 5, 132: 5, 136: 3, 145: 5, 147: 4, 151: 4, 152: 4, 154: 4, 161: 4, 162: 4, 165: 4, 168: 5, 169: 3, 172: 3, 180: 4, 184: 6, 187: 6, 188: 5, 191: 4, 194: 5, 202: 6, 203: 7, 206: 3, 207: 4, 215: 3, 217: 4, 218: 9, 220: 3, 221: 3, 222: 6, 224: 4, 227: 4, 229: 3, 234: 6, 235: 3, 241: 3, 242: 3, 243: 5, 244: 4, 245: 5, 248: 4, 258: 12, 262: 5, 263: 6, 264: 4, 267: 5, 270: 2, 272: 3, 273: 6, 287: 4, 289: 3, 291: 5, 299: 4, 304: 2, 309: 4, 314: 3, 315: 3, 320: 5, 323: 5, 327: 5, 328: 4, 329: 3, 330: 11, 334: 3, 335: 2, 341: 4, 342: 5, 347: 4, 348: 4, 350: 8, 351: 5, 352: 3, 353: 3, 354: 2, 358: 5, 365: 3, 366: 3, 369: 2, 371: 6, 372: 5, 376: 3, 384: 5, 385: 4, 386: 4, 392: 4, 393: 5, 396: 5, 397: 8, 398: 7, 402: 3} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 51 "From the TSN sub-network perspective DetNet IP nodes without any TSN functions can be treated as TSN-unaware Talker or Listener. In such cases relay nodes in the TSN sub-network MUST modify the Ethernet encapsulation of the DetNet IP flow (e.g., MAC translation, VLAN-ID setting, Sequence number addition, etc.) to allow proper TSN specific handling of the flow inside the sub-network. This is illustrated in fig_ip_without_tsn." Reflecting the 9th September discussions . acd7cae2af60dfafe42acdd9936194decc735f93 acd7cae2af60dfafe42acdd9936194decc735f93 draft-ietf-detnet-ip-over-tsn 8e1ef1f3845546bfbed884c94f51a19cee8ebfdc977f4c9091a1008026c540af ['1053f835fa0c23e5e0be64388d587c7cc201a77844a8fbb716d720640b0549ab', '417df728e954576101d7177ca52e701a308b2bf91f77a2aa663245aed41302a4', '7ac09938faf2d97ce8bcc3b64b905bb5a585aeb30156506ee7abe2cd36825ed9', '6e1359ed3e65e5e9f120654940828dc13452a32a8a4acfab11d893c994ec8b09', '428996c63c0b3d28c52c4558b1e40faa72088ca53cf822a696698c62118ed646', '39820f7cb577ca0dcfb1bfa578ae13c25334acae03e89731064b0e3c300841de', '892d2555f9a89a54f020e44c71d17881727e9c245d0c7a7054f24fb2bfd083c9', '16cc4d5093d5406483d5c6813be03012581eb426cf71f79764772640049f731b', '214810fe3ac0ef76db60e2d0623a8259b9bdf49040882a9e710901fe1eb32fde', '32f367c0df09e73fbac0f227a892fe94f0bf481c36bcaec69b0c9ae7d9198747', 'ca3de1300d25dd0c427db1bee2c3a07497192c2ee0569af5a2680a011f0260af', '73fe0d9e382eeb3be060393606b0decefb645e4461ed9f78dcdbd50d5904e4ee', '58f02544b08a4f310a4b8b24c67191e59419583141684e5268fc094eae9b43c9', 'e5264c09892e29645048ef86c987f95a814e2e01c98332d2d8809eed04a0b5d2', '8e1ef1f3845546bfbed884c94f51a19cee8ebfdc977f4c9091a1008026c540af', '9e47f9c49d4ffb131be31e7b5676a91050b375d823d18009e9fff94ec9b38956', '2f07ef13fb197dfbb24335dba11708eeddc61cae0c297c3eb842636965aba642', 'e30e0920d1ef0023a63ec84cdaaee8fad200ac339db4ef1aeb0762ec6171e227'] A "from the tsn sub-network perspective detnet ip nodes without any tsn functions can be treated as tsn-unaware talker or listener. in such cases relay nodes in the tsn sub-network must modify the ethernet encapsulation of the detnet ip flow (e.g., mac translation, vlan-id setting, sequence number addition, etc.) to allow proper tsn specific handling of the flow inside the sub-network. this is illustrated in fig_ip_without_tsn." {96: 1, 97: 1, 52: 1, 6: 3, 79: 3, 90: 3, 130: 2, 62: 4, 85: 5, 51: 2, 68: 5, 35: 4, 110: 3, 91: 5, 114: 3, 31: 4, 13: 3, 67: 3, 38: 4, 26: 3, 124: 4, 98: 3, 54: 3, 127: 4, 8: 3, 64: 3, 30: 3, 61: 5, 55: 4, 27: 4, 15: 3, 129: 4, 115: 3, 84: 3, 76: 7, 87: 3, 131: 6, 102: 3, 113: 5, 99: 3, 36: 3, 24: 2, 53: 2, 72: 4} {250: 1, 387: 1, 156: 1, 300: 1, 1: 10, 4: 3, 9: 6, 10: 4, 24: 3, 25: 4, 26: 5, 27: 2, 39: 6, 43: 4, 49: 6, 50: 5, 58: 5, 59: 3, 64: 2, 69: 5, 81: 5, 82: 3, 86: 3, 96: 4, 97: 3, 100: 6, 108: 4, 109: 5, 110: 5, 111: 3, 114: 4, 115: 5, 116: 2, 118: 7, 119: 6, 120: 4, 121: 5, 122: 3, 123: 2, 124: 5, 128: 4, 129: 3, 130: 5, 132: 5, 136: 3, 145: 5, 147: 4, 151: 4, 152: 4, 154: 4, 161: 4, 162: 4, 165: 4, 168: 5, 169: 3, 172: 3, 180: 4, 184: 6, 187: 6, 188: 5, 191: 4, 194: 5, 202: 6, 203: 7, 206: 3, 207: 4, 215: 3, 217: 4, 218: 9, 220: 3, 221: 3, 222: 6, 224: 4, 227: 4, 229: 3, 234: 6, 235: 3, 241: 3, 242: 3, 243: 5, 244: 4, 245: 5, 248: 4, 258: 12, 262: 5, 263: 6, 264: 4, 267: 5, 270: 2, 272: 3, 273: 6, 287: 4, 289: 3, 291: 5, 299: 4, 304: 2, 309: 4, 314: 3, 315: 3, 320: 5, 323: 5, 327: 5, 328: 4, 329: 3, 330: 11, 334: 3, 335: 2, 341: 4, 342: 5, 347: 4, 348: 4, 350: 8, 351: 5, 352: 3, 353: 3, 354: 2, 358: 5, 365: 3, 366: 3, 369: 2, 371: 6, 372: 5, 376: 3, 384: 5, 385: 4, 386: 4, 392: 4, 393: 5, 396: 5, 397: 8, 398: 7, 402: 3} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 51 "A Stream identification component MUST be able to instantiate the following functions (1) Active Destination MAC and VLAN Stream identification function, (2) IP Stream identification function and (3) the related managed objects in Clause 9 of IEEE8021CB. IP Stream identification function provides a 6-tuple match." Reflecting the 9th September discussions . acd7cae2af60dfafe42acdd9936194decc735f93 acd7cae2af60dfafe42acdd9936194decc735f93 draft-ietf-detnet-ip-over-tsn 1053f835fa0c23e5e0be64388d587c7cc201a77844a8fbb716d720640b0549ab ['1053f835fa0c23e5e0be64388d587c7cc201a77844a8fbb716d720640b0549ab', '417df728e954576101d7177ca52e701a308b2bf91f77a2aa663245aed41302a4', '7ac09938faf2d97ce8bcc3b64b905bb5a585aeb30156506ee7abe2cd36825ed9', '6e1359ed3e65e5e9f120654940828dc13452a32a8a4acfab11d893c994ec8b09', '428996c63c0b3d28c52c4558b1e40faa72088ca53cf822a696698c62118ed646', '39820f7cb577ca0dcfb1bfa578ae13c25334acae03e89731064b0e3c300841de', '892d2555f9a89a54f020e44c71d17881727e9c245d0c7a7054f24fb2bfd083c9', '16cc4d5093d5406483d5c6813be03012581eb426cf71f79764772640049f731b', '214810fe3ac0ef76db60e2d0623a8259b9bdf49040882a9e710901fe1eb32fde', '32f367c0df09e73fbac0f227a892fe94f0bf481c36bcaec69b0c9ae7d9198747', 'ca3de1300d25dd0c427db1bee2c3a07497192c2ee0569af5a2680a011f0260af', '73fe0d9e382eeb3be060393606b0decefb645e4461ed9f78dcdbd50d5904e4ee', '58f02544b08a4f310a4b8b24c67191e59419583141684e5268fc094eae9b43c9', 'e5264c09892e29645048ef86c987f95a814e2e01c98332d2d8809eed04a0b5d2', '8e1ef1f3845546bfbed884c94f51a19cee8ebfdc977f4c9091a1008026c540af', '9e47f9c49d4ffb131be31e7b5676a91050b375d823d18009e9fff94ec9b38956', '2f07ef13fb197dfbb24335dba11708eeddc61cae0c297c3eb842636965aba642', 'e30e0920d1ef0023a63ec84cdaaee8fad200ac339db4ef1aeb0762ec6171e227'] A "a stream identification component must be able to instantiate the following functions (1) active destination mac and vlan stream identification function, (2) ip stream identification function and (3) the related managed objects in clause 9 of ieee8021cb. ip stream identification function provides a 6-tuple match." {96: 1, 97: 1, 52: 1, 6: 3, 79: 3, 90: 3, 130: 2, 62: 4, 85: 5, 51: 2, 68: 5, 35: 4, 110: 3, 91: 5, 114: 3, 31: 4, 13: 3, 67: 3, 38: 4, 26: 3, 124: 4, 98: 3, 54: 3, 127: 4, 8: 3, 64: 3, 30: 3, 61: 5, 55: 4, 27: 4, 15: 3, 129: 4, 115: 3, 84: 3, 76: 7, 87: 3, 131: 6, 102: 3, 113: 5, 99: 3, 36: 3, 24: 2, 53: 2, 72: 4} {250: 1, 387: 1, 156: 1, 300: 1, 1: 10, 4: 3, 9: 6, 10: 4, 24: 3, 25: 4, 26: 5, 27: 2, 39: 6, 43: 4, 49: 6, 50: 5, 58: 5, 59: 3, 64: 2, 69: 5, 81: 5, 82: 3, 86: 3, 96: 4, 97: 3, 100: 6, 108: 4, 109: 5, 110: 5, 111: 3, 114: 4, 115: 5, 116: 2, 118: 7, 119: 6, 120: 4, 121: 5, 122: 3, 123: 2, 124: 5, 128: 4, 129: 3, 130: 5, 132: 5, 136: 3, 145: 5, 147: 4, 151: 4, 152: 4, 154: 4, 161: 4, 162: 4, 165: 4, 168: 5, 169: 3, 172: 3, 180: 4, 184: 6, 187: 6, 188: 5, 191: 4, 194: 5, 202: 6, 203: 7, 206: 3, 207: 4, 215: 3, 217: 4, 218: 9, 220: 3, 221: 3, 222: 6, 224: 4, 227: 4, 229: 3, 234: 6, 235: 3, 241: 3, 242: 3, 243: 5, 244: 4, 245: 5, 248: 4, 258: 12, 262: 5, 263: 6, 264: 4, 267: 5, 270: 2, 272: 3, 273: 6, 287: 4, 289: 3, 291: 5, 299: 4, 304: 2, 309: 4, 314: 3, 315: 3, 320: 5, 323: 5, 327: 5, 328: 4, 329: 3, 330: 11, 334: 3, 335: 2, 341: 4, 342: 5, 347: 4, 348: 4, 350: 8, 351: 5, 352: 3, 353: 3, 354: 2, 358: 5, 365: 3, 366: 3, 369: 2, 371: 6, 372: 5, 376: 3, 384: 5, 385: 4, 386: 4, 392: 4, 393: 5, 396: 5, 397: 8, 398: 7, 402: 3} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 51 "TSN Streams supporting DetNet flows may use Frame Replication and Elimination for Redundancy (FRER) [802.1CB] based on the loss service requirements of the TSN Stream, which is derived from the DetNet service requirements of the DetNet mapped flow. The specific operation of FRER is not modified by the use of DetNet and follows IEEE8021CB." Reflecting the 9th September discussions . acd7cae2af60dfafe42acdd9936194decc735f93 acd7cae2af60dfafe42acdd9936194decc735f93 draft-ietf-detnet-ip-over-tsn 39820f7cb577ca0dcfb1bfa578ae13c25334acae03e89731064b0e3c300841de ['1053f835fa0c23e5e0be64388d587c7cc201a77844a8fbb716d720640b0549ab', '417df728e954576101d7177ca52e701a308b2bf91f77a2aa663245aed41302a4', '7ac09938faf2d97ce8bcc3b64b905bb5a585aeb30156506ee7abe2cd36825ed9', '6e1359ed3e65e5e9f120654940828dc13452a32a8a4acfab11d893c994ec8b09', '428996c63c0b3d28c52c4558b1e40faa72088ca53cf822a696698c62118ed646', '39820f7cb577ca0dcfb1bfa578ae13c25334acae03e89731064b0e3c300841de', '892d2555f9a89a54f020e44c71d17881727e9c245d0c7a7054f24fb2bfd083c9', '16cc4d5093d5406483d5c6813be03012581eb426cf71f79764772640049f731b', '214810fe3ac0ef76db60e2d0623a8259b9bdf49040882a9e710901fe1eb32fde', '32f367c0df09e73fbac0f227a892fe94f0bf481c36bcaec69b0c9ae7d9198747', 'ca3de1300d25dd0c427db1bee2c3a07497192c2ee0569af5a2680a011f0260af', '73fe0d9e382eeb3be060393606b0decefb645e4461ed9f78dcdbd50d5904e4ee', '58f02544b08a4f310a4b8b24c67191e59419583141684e5268fc094eae9b43c9', 'e5264c09892e29645048ef86c987f95a814e2e01c98332d2d8809eed04a0b5d2', '8e1ef1f3845546bfbed884c94f51a19cee8ebfdc977f4c9091a1008026c540af', '9e47f9c49d4ffb131be31e7b5676a91050b375d823d18009e9fff94ec9b38956', '2f07ef13fb197dfbb24335dba11708eeddc61cae0c297c3eb842636965aba642', 'e30e0920d1ef0023a63ec84cdaaee8fad200ac339db4ef1aeb0762ec6171e227'] A "tsn streams supporting detnet flows may use frame replication and elimination for redundancy (frer) [802.1cb] based on the loss service requirements of the tsn stream, which is derived from the detnet service requirements of the detnet mapped flow. the specific operation of frer is not modified by the use of detnet and follows ieee8021cb." {96: 1, 97: 1, 52: 1, 6: 3, 79: 3, 90: 3, 130: 2, 62: 4, 85: 5, 51: 2, 68: 5, 35: 4, 110: 3, 91: 5, 114: 3, 31: 4, 13: 3, 67: 3, 38: 4, 26: 3, 124: 4, 98: 3, 54: 3, 127: 4, 8: 3, 64: 3, 30: 3, 61: 5, 55: 4, 27: 4, 15: 3, 129: 4, 115: 3, 84: 3, 76: 7, 87: 3, 131: 6, 102: 3, 113: 5, 99: 3, 36: 3, 24: 2, 53: 2, 72: 4} {250: 1, 387: 1, 156: 1, 300: 1, 1: 10, 4: 3, 9: 6, 10: 4, 24: 3, 25: 4, 26: 5, 27: 2, 39: 6, 43: 4, 49: 6, 50: 5, 58: 5, 59: 3, 64: 2, 69: 5, 81: 5, 82: 3, 86: 3, 96: 4, 97: 3, 100: 6, 108: 4, 109: 5, 110: 5, 111: 3, 114: 4, 115: 5, 116: 2, 118: 7, 119: 6, 120: 4, 121: 5, 122: 3, 123: 2, 124: 5, 128: 4, 129: 3, 130: 5, 132: 5, 136: 3, 145: 5, 147: 4, 151: 4, 152: 4, 154: 4, 161: 4, 162: 4, 165: 4, 168: 5, 169: 3, 172: 3, 180: 4, 184: 6, 187: 6, 188: 5, 191: 4, 194: 5, 202: 6, 203: 7, 206: 3, 207: 4, 215: 3, 217: 4, 218: 9, 220: 3, 221: 3, 222: 6, 224: 4, 227: 4, 229: 3, 234: 6, 235: 3, 241: 3, 242: 3, 243: 5, 244: 4, 245: 5, 248: 4, 258: 12, 262: 5, 263: 6, 264: 4, 267: 5, 270: 2, 272: 3, 273: 6, 287: 4, 289: 3, 291: 5, 299: 4, 304: 2, 309: 4, 314: 3, 315: 3, 320: 5, 323: 5, 327: 5, 328: 4, 329: 3, 330: 11, 334: 3, 335: 2, 341: 4, 342: 5, 347: 4, 348: 4, 350: 8, 351: 5, 352: 3, 353: 3, 354: 2, 358: 5, 365: 3, 366: 3, 369: 2, 371: 6, 372: 5, 376: 3, 384: 5, 385: 4, 386: 4, 392: 4, 393: 5, 396: 5, 397: 8, 398: 7, 402: 3} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 51 "FRER function and the provided service recovery is available only within the TSN sub-network (as shown in fig_pref_in_subnets) as the Stream-ID and the TSN sequence number are not valid outside the sub- network. An IP (DetNet) node represents a L3 border and as such it terminates all related information elements encoded in the L2 frames." Reflecting the 9th September discussions . acd7cae2af60dfafe42acdd9936194decc735f93 acd7cae2af60dfafe42acdd9936194decc735f93 draft-ietf-detnet-ip-over-tsn 73fe0d9e382eeb3be060393606b0decefb645e4461ed9f78dcdbd50d5904e4ee ['1053f835fa0c23e5e0be64388d587c7cc201a77844a8fbb716d720640b0549ab', '417df728e954576101d7177ca52e701a308b2bf91f77a2aa663245aed41302a4', '7ac09938faf2d97ce8bcc3b64b905bb5a585aeb30156506ee7abe2cd36825ed9', '6e1359ed3e65e5e9f120654940828dc13452a32a8a4acfab11d893c994ec8b09', '428996c63c0b3d28c52c4558b1e40faa72088ca53cf822a696698c62118ed646', '39820f7cb577ca0dcfb1bfa578ae13c25334acae03e89731064b0e3c300841de', '892d2555f9a89a54f020e44c71d17881727e9c245d0c7a7054f24fb2bfd083c9', '16cc4d5093d5406483d5c6813be03012581eb426cf71f79764772640049f731b', '214810fe3ac0ef76db60e2d0623a8259b9bdf49040882a9e710901fe1eb32fde', '32f367c0df09e73fbac0f227a892fe94f0bf481c36bcaec69b0c9ae7d9198747', 'ca3de1300d25dd0c427db1bee2c3a07497192c2ee0569af5a2680a011f0260af', '73fe0d9e382eeb3be060393606b0decefb645e4461ed9f78dcdbd50d5904e4ee', '58f02544b08a4f310a4b8b24c67191e59419583141684e5268fc094eae9b43c9', 'e5264c09892e29645048ef86c987f95a814e2e01c98332d2d8809eed04a0b5d2', '8e1ef1f3845546bfbed884c94f51a19cee8ebfdc977f4c9091a1008026c540af', '9e47f9c49d4ffb131be31e7b5676a91050b375d823d18009e9fff94ec9b38956', '2f07ef13fb197dfbb24335dba11708eeddc61cae0c297c3eb842636965aba642', 'e30e0920d1ef0023a63ec84cdaaee8fad200ac339db4ef1aeb0762ec6171e227'] A "frer function and the provided service recovery is available only within the tsn sub-network (as shown in fig_pref_in_subnets) as the stream-id and the tsn sequence number are not valid outside the sub- network. an ip (detnet) node represents a l3 border and as such it terminates all related information elements encoded in the l2 frames." {96: 1, 97: 1, 52: 1, 6: 3, 79: 3, 90: 3, 130: 2, 62: 4, 85: 5, 51: 2, 68: 5, 35: 4, 110: 3, 91: 5, 114: 3, 31: 4, 13: 3, 67: 3, 38: 4, 26: 3, 124: 4, 98: 3, 54: 3, 127: 4, 8: 3, 64: 3, 30: 3, 61: 5, 55: 4, 27: 4, 15: 3, 129: 4, 115: 3, 84: 3, 76: 7, 87: 3, 131: 6, 102: 3, 113: 5, 99: 3, 36: 3, 24: 2, 53: 2, 72: 4} {250: 1, 387: 1, 156: 1, 300: 1, 1: 10, 4: 3, 9: 6, 10: 4, 24: 3, 25: 4, 26: 5, 27: 2, 39: 6, 43: 4, 49: 6, 50: 5, 58: 5, 59: 3, 64: 2, 69: 5, 81: 5, 82: 3, 86: 3, 96: 4, 97: 3, 100: 6, 108: 4, 109: 5, 110: 5, 111: 3, 114: 4, 115: 5, 116: 2, 118: 7, 119: 6, 120: 4, 121: 5, 122: 3, 123: 2, 124: 5, 128: 4, 129: 3, 130: 5, 132: 5, 136: 3, 145: 5, 147: 4, 151: 4, 152: 4, 154: 4, 161: 4, 162: 4, 165: 4, 168: 5, 169: 3, 172: 3, 180: 4, 184: 6, 187: 6, 188: 5, 191: 4, 194: 5, 202: 6, 203: 7, 206: 3, 207: 4, 215: 3, 217: 4, 218: 9, 220: 3, 221: 3, 222: 6, 224: 4, 227: 4, 229: 3, 234: 6, 235: 3, 241: 3, 242: 3, 243: 5, 244: 4, 245: 5, 248: 4, 258: 12, 262: 5, 263: 6, 264: 4, 267: 5, 270: 2, 272: 3, 273: 6, 287: 4, 289: 3, 291: 5, 299: 4, 304: 2, 309: 4, 314: 3, 315: 3, 320: 5, 323: 5, 327: 5, 328: 4, 329: 3, 330: 11, 334: 3, 335: 2, 341: 4, 342: 5, 347: 4, 348: 4, 350: 8, 351: 5, 352: 3, 353: 3, 354: 2, 358: 5, 365: 3, 366: 3, 369: 2, 371: 6, 372: 5, 376: 3, 384: 5, 385: 4, 386: 4, 392: 4, 393: 5, 396: 5, 397: 8, 398: 7, 402: 3} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 51 "This section provides DetNet IP data plane procedures to interwork with a TSN underlay sub-network when the IP (DetNet) node acts as a TSN-aware Talker or Listener (see fig_ip_with_tsn). These procedures have been divided into the following areas: flow identification, mapping of a DetNet flow to a TSN Stream and ensure proper TSN encapsulation." Reflecting the 9th September discussions . acd7cae2af60dfafe42acdd9936194decc735f93 acd7cae2af60dfafe42acdd9936194decc735f93 draft-ietf-detnet-ip-over-tsn e5264c09892e29645048ef86c987f95a814e2e01c98332d2d8809eed04a0b5d2 ['1053f835fa0c23e5e0be64388d587c7cc201a77844a8fbb716d720640b0549ab', '417df728e954576101d7177ca52e701a308b2bf91f77a2aa663245aed41302a4', '7ac09938faf2d97ce8bcc3b64b905bb5a585aeb30156506ee7abe2cd36825ed9', '6e1359ed3e65e5e9f120654940828dc13452a32a8a4acfab11d893c994ec8b09', '428996c63c0b3d28c52c4558b1e40faa72088ca53cf822a696698c62118ed646', '39820f7cb577ca0dcfb1bfa578ae13c25334acae03e89731064b0e3c300841de', '892d2555f9a89a54f020e44c71d17881727e9c245d0c7a7054f24fb2bfd083c9', '16cc4d5093d5406483d5c6813be03012581eb426cf71f79764772640049f731b', '214810fe3ac0ef76db60e2d0623a8259b9bdf49040882a9e710901fe1eb32fde', '32f367c0df09e73fbac0f227a892fe94f0bf481c36bcaec69b0c9ae7d9198747', 'ca3de1300d25dd0c427db1bee2c3a07497192c2ee0569af5a2680a011f0260af', '73fe0d9e382eeb3be060393606b0decefb645e4461ed9f78dcdbd50d5904e4ee', '58f02544b08a4f310a4b8b24c67191e59419583141684e5268fc094eae9b43c9', 'e5264c09892e29645048ef86c987f95a814e2e01c98332d2d8809eed04a0b5d2', '8e1ef1f3845546bfbed884c94f51a19cee8ebfdc977f4c9091a1008026c540af', '9e47f9c49d4ffb131be31e7b5676a91050b375d823d18009e9fff94ec9b38956', '2f07ef13fb197dfbb24335dba11708eeddc61cae0c297c3eb842636965aba642', 'e30e0920d1ef0023a63ec84cdaaee8fad200ac339db4ef1aeb0762ec6171e227'] A "this section provides detnet ip data plane procedures to interwork with a tsn underlay sub-network when the ip (detnet) node acts as a tsn-aware talker or listener (see fig_ip_with_tsn). these procedures have been divided into the following areas: flow identification, mapping of a detnet flow to a tsn stream and ensure proper tsn encapsulation." {96: 1, 97: 1, 52: 1, 6: 3, 79: 3, 90: 3, 130: 2, 62: 4, 85: 5, 51: 2, 68: 5, 35: 4, 110: 3, 91: 5, 114: 3, 31: 4, 13: 3, 67: 3, 38: 4, 26: 3, 124: 4, 98: 3, 54: 3, 127: 4, 8: 3, 64: 3, 30: 3, 61: 5, 55: 4, 27: 4, 15: 3, 129: 4, 115: 3, 84: 3, 76: 7, 87: 3, 131: 6, 102: 3, 113: 5, 99: 3, 36: 3, 24: 2, 53: 2, 72: 4} {250: 1, 387: 1, 156: 1, 300: 1, 1: 10, 4: 3, 9: 6, 10: 4, 24: 3, 25: 4, 26: 5, 27: 2, 39: 6, 43: 4, 49: 6, 50: 5, 58: 5, 59: 3, 64: 2, 69: 5, 81: 5, 82: 3, 86: 3, 96: 4, 97: 3, 100: 6, 108: 4, 109: 5, 110: 5, 111: 3, 114: 4, 115: 5, 116: 2, 118: 7, 119: 6, 120: 4, 121: 5, 122: 3, 123: 2, 124: 5, 128: 4, 129: 3, 130: 5, 132: 5, 136: 3, 145: 5, 147: 4, 151: 4, 152: 4, 154: 4, 161: 4, 162: 4, 165: 4, 168: 5, 169: 3, 172: 3, 180: 4, 184: 6, 187: 6, 188: 5, 191: 4, 194: 5, 202: 6, 203: 7, 206: 3, 207: 4, 215: 3, 217: 4, 218: 9, 220: 3, 221: 3, 222: 6, 224: 4, 227: 4, 229: 3, 234: 6, 235: 3, 241: 3, 242: 3, 243: 5, 244: 4, 245: 5, 248: 4, 258: 12, 262: 5, 263: 6, 264: 4, 267: 5, 270: 2, 272: 3, 273: 6, 287: 4, 289: 3, 291: 5, 299: 4, 304: 2, 309: 4, 314: 3, 315: 3, 320: 5, 323: 5, 327: 5, 328: 4, 329: 3, 330: 11, 334: 3, 335: 2, 341: 4, 342: 5, 347: 4, 348: 4, 350: 8, 351: 5, 352: 3, 353: 3, 354: 2, 358: 5, 365: 3, 366: 3, 369: 2, 371: 6, 372: 5, 376: 3, 384: 5, 385: 4, 386: 4, 392: 4, 393: 5, 396: 5, 397: 8, 398: 7, 402: 3} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 51 "Flow identification procedures are described in RRR . A TSN-aware IP (DetNet) node SHALL support the Stream Identification TSN components as per IEEE8021CB." Reflecting the 9th September discussions . acd7cae2af60dfafe42acdd9936194decc735f93 acd7cae2af60dfafe42acdd9936194decc735f93 draft-ietf-detnet-ip-over-tsn e30e0920d1ef0023a63ec84cdaaee8fad200ac339db4ef1aeb0762ec6171e227 ['1053f835fa0c23e5e0be64388d587c7cc201a77844a8fbb716d720640b0549ab', '417df728e954576101d7177ca52e701a308b2bf91f77a2aa663245aed41302a4', '7ac09938faf2d97ce8bcc3b64b905bb5a585aeb30156506ee7abe2cd36825ed9', '6e1359ed3e65e5e9f120654940828dc13452a32a8a4acfab11d893c994ec8b09', '428996c63c0b3d28c52c4558b1e40faa72088ca53cf822a696698c62118ed646', '39820f7cb577ca0dcfb1bfa578ae13c25334acae03e89731064b0e3c300841de', '892d2555f9a89a54f020e44c71d17881727e9c245d0c7a7054f24fb2bfd083c9', '16cc4d5093d5406483d5c6813be03012581eb426cf71f79764772640049f731b', '214810fe3ac0ef76db60e2d0623a8259b9bdf49040882a9e710901fe1eb32fde', '32f367c0df09e73fbac0f227a892fe94f0bf481c36bcaec69b0c9ae7d9198747', 'ca3de1300d25dd0c427db1bee2c3a07497192c2ee0569af5a2680a011f0260af', '73fe0d9e382eeb3be060393606b0decefb645e4461ed9f78dcdbd50d5904e4ee', '58f02544b08a4f310a4b8b24c67191e59419583141684e5268fc094eae9b43c9', 'e5264c09892e29645048ef86c987f95a814e2e01c98332d2d8809eed04a0b5d2', '8e1ef1f3845546bfbed884c94f51a19cee8ebfdc977f4c9091a1008026c540af', '9e47f9c49d4ffb131be31e7b5676a91050b375d823d18009e9fff94ec9b38956', '2f07ef13fb197dfbb24335dba11708eeddc61cae0c297c3eb842636965aba642', 'e30e0920d1ef0023a63ec84cdaaee8fad200ac339db4ef1aeb0762ec6171e227'] A "flow identification procedures are described in rrr . a tsn-aware ip (detnet) node shall support the stream identification tsn components as per ieee8021cb." {96: 1, 97: 1, 52: 1, 6: 3, 79: 3, 90: 3, 130: 2, 62: 4, 85: 5, 51: 2, 68: 5, 35: 4, 110: 3, 91: 5, 114: 3, 31: 4, 13: 3, 67: 3, 38: 4, 26: 3, 124: 4, 98: 3, 54: 3, 127: 4, 8: 3, 64: 3, 30: 3, 61: 5, 55: 4, 27: 4, 15: 3, 129: 4, 115: 3, 84: 3, 76: 7, 87: 3, 131: 6, 102: 3, 113: 5, 99: 3, 36: 3, 24: 2, 53: 2, 72: 4} {250: 1, 387: 1, 156: 1, 300: 1, 1: 10, 4: 3, 9: 6, 10: 4, 24: 3, 25: 4, 26: 5, 27: 2, 39: 6, 43: 4, 49: 6, 50: 5, 58: 5, 59: 3, 64: 2, 69: 5, 81: 5, 82: 3, 86: 3, 96: 4, 97: 3, 100: 6, 108: 4, 109: 5, 110: 5, 111: 3, 114: 4, 115: 5, 116: 2, 118: 7, 119: 6, 120: 4, 121: 5, 122: 3, 123: 2, 124: 5, 128: 4, 129: 3, 130: 5, 132: 5, 136: 3, 145: 5, 147: 4, 151: 4, 152: 4, 154: 4, 161: 4, 162: 4, 165: 4, 168: 5, 169: 3, 172: 3, 180: 4, 184: 6, 187: 6, 188: 5, 191: 4, 194: 5, 202: 6, 203: 7, 206: 3, 207: 4, 215: 3, 217: 4, 218: 9, 220: 3, 221: 3, 222: 6, 224: 4, 227: 4, 229: 3, 234: 6, 235: 3, 241: 3, 242: 3, 243: 5, 244: 4, 245: 5, 248: 4, 258: 12, 262: 5, 263: 6, 264: 4, 267: 5, 270: 2, 272: 3, 273: 6, 287: 4, 289: 3, 291: 5, 299: 4, 304: 2, 309: 4, 314: 3, 315: 3, 320: 5, 323: 5, 327: 5, 328: 4, 329: 3, 330: 11, 334: 3, 335: 2, 341: 4, 342: 5, 347: 4, 348: 4, 350: 8, 351: 5, 352: 3, 353: 3, 354: 2, 358: 5, 365: 3, 366: 3, 369: 2, 371: 6, 372: 5, 376: 3, 384: 5, 385: 4, 386: 4, 392: 4, 393: 5, 396: 5, 397: 8, 398: 7, 402: 3} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 51 "Active Destination MAC and VLAN Stream identification can be used within a Talker to set flow identity or a Listener to recover the original addressing information. It can be used also in a TSN bridge that is providing translation as a proxy service for an End System." Reflecting the 9th September discussions . acd7cae2af60dfafe42acdd9936194decc735f93 acd7cae2af60dfafe42acdd9936194decc735f93 draft-ietf-detnet-ip-over-tsn 7ac09938faf2d97ce8bcc3b64b905bb5a585aeb30156506ee7abe2cd36825ed9 ['1053f835fa0c23e5e0be64388d587c7cc201a77844a8fbb716d720640b0549ab', '417df728e954576101d7177ca52e701a308b2bf91f77a2aa663245aed41302a4', '7ac09938faf2d97ce8bcc3b64b905bb5a585aeb30156506ee7abe2cd36825ed9', '6e1359ed3e65e5e9f120654940828dc13452a32a8a4acfab11d893c994ec8b09', '428996c63c0b3d28c52c4558b1e40faa72088ca53cf822a696698c62118ed646', '39820f7cb577ca0dcfb1bfa578ae13c25334acae03e89731064b0e3c300841de', '892d2555f9a89a54f020e44c71d17881727e9c245d0c7a7054f24fb2bfd083c9', '16cc4d5093d5406483d5c6813be03012581eb426cf71f79764772640049f731b', '214810fe3ac0ef76db60e2d0623a8259b9bdf49040882a9e710901fe1eb32fde', '32f367c0df09e73fbac0f227a892fe94f0bf481c36bcaec69b0c9ae7d9198747', 'ca3de1300d25dd0c427db1bee2c3a07497192c2ee0569af5a2680a011f0260af', '73fe0d9e382eeb3be060393606b0decefb645e4461ed9f78dcdbd50d5904e4ee', '58f02544b08a4f310a4b8b24c67191e59419583141684e5268fc094eae9b43c9', 'e5264c09892e29645048ef86c987f95a814e2e01c98332d2d8809eed04a0b5d2', '8e1ef1f3845546bfbed884c94f51a19cee8ebfdc977f4c9091a1008026c540af', '9e47f9c49d4ffb131be31e7b5676a91050b375d823d18009e9fff94ec9b38956', '2f07ef13fb197dfbb24335dba11708eeddc61cae0c297c3eb842636965aba642', 'e30e0920d1ef0023a63ec84cdaaee8fad200ac339db4ef1aeb0762ec6171e227'] B "active destination mac and vlan stream identification can be used within a talker to set flow identity or a listener to recover the original addressing information. it can be used also in a tsn bridge that is providing translation as a proxy service for an end system." {96: 1, 97: 1, 52: 1, 6: 3, 79: 3, 90: 3, 130: 2, 62: 4, 85: 5, 51: 2, 68: 5, 35: 4, 110: 3, 91: 5, 114: 3, 31: 4, 13: 3, 67: 3, 38: 4, 26: 3, 124: 4, 98: 3, 54: 3, 127: 4, 8: 3, 64: 3, 30: 3, 61: 5, 55: 4, 27: 4, 15: 3, 129: 4, 115: 3, 84: 3, 76: 7, 87: 3, 131: 6, 102: 3, 113: 5, 99: 3, 36: 3, 24: 2, 53: 2, 72: 4} {250: 1, 387: 1, 156: 1, 300: 1, 1: 10, 4: 3, 9: 6, 10: 4, 24: 3, 25: 4, 26: 5, 27: 2, 39: 6, 43: 4, 49: 6, 50: 5, 58: 5, 59: 3, 64: 2, 69: 5, 81: 5, 82: 3, 86: 3, 96: 4, 97: 3, 100: 6, 108: 4, 109: 5, 110: 5, 111: 3, 114: 4, 115: 5, 116: 2, 118: 7, 119: 6, 120: 4, 121: 5, 122: 3, 123: 2, 124: 5, 128: 4, 129: 3, 130: 5, 132: 5, 136: 3, 145: 5, 147: 4, 151: 4, 152: 4, 154: 4, 161: 4, 162: 4, 165: 4, 168: 5, 169: 3, 172: 3, 180: 4, 184: 6, 187: 6, 188: 5, 191: 4, 194: 5, 202: 6, 203: 7, 206: 3, 207: 4, 215: 3, 217: 4, 218: 9, 220: 3, 221: 3, 222: 6, 224: 4, 227: 4, 229: 3, 234: 6, 235: 3, 241: 3, 242: 3, 243: 5, 244: 4, 245: 5, 248: 4, 258: 12, 262: 5, 263: 6, 264: 4, 267: 5, 270: 2, 272: 3, 273: 6, 287: 4, 289: 3, 291: 5, 299: 4, 304: 2, 309: 4, 314: 3, 315: 3, 320: 5, 323: 5, 327: 5, 328: 4, 329: 3, 330: 11, 334: 3, 335: 2, 341: 4, 342: 5, 347: 4, 348: 4, 350: 8, 351: 5, 352: 3, 353: 3, 354: 2, 358: 5, 365: 3, 366: 3, 369: 2, 371: 6, 372: 5, 376: 3, 384: 5, 385: 4, 386: 4, 392: 4, 393: 5, 396: 5, 397: 8, 398: 7, 402: 3} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 51 "This section covers required behavior of a TSN-aware DetNet node using a TSN sub-network." Reflecting the 9th September discussions . acd7cae2af60dfafe42acdd9936194decc735f93 acd7cae2af60dfafe42acdd9936194decc735f93 draft-ietf-detnet-ip-over-tsn 32f367c0df09e73fbac0f227a892fe94f0bf481c36bcaec69b0c9ae7d9198747 ['1053f835fa0c23e5e0be64388d587c7cc201a77844a8fbb716d720640b0549ab', '417df728e954576101d7177ca52e701a308b2bf91f77a2aa663245aed41302a4', '7ac09938faf2d97ce8bcc3b64b905bb5a585aeb30156506ee7abe2cd36825ed9', '6e1359ed3e65e5e9f120654940828dc13452a32a8a4acfab11d893c994ec8b09', '428996c63c0b3d28c52c4558b1e40faa72088ca53cf822a696698c62118ed646', '39820f7cb577ca0dcfb1bfa578ae13c25334acae03e89731064b0e3c300841de', '892d2555f9a89a54f020e44c71d17881727e9c245d0c7a7054f24fb2bfd083c9', '16cc4d5093d5406483d5c6813be03012581eb426cf71f79764772640049f731b', '214810fe3ac0ef76db60e2d0623a8259b9bdf49040882a9e710901fe1eb32fde', '32f367c0df09e73fbac0f227a892fe94f0bf481c36bcaec69b0c9ae7d9198747', 'ca3de1300d25dd0c427db1bee2c3a07497192c2ee0569af5a2680a011f0260af', '73fe0d9e382eeb3be060393606b0decefb645e4461ed9f78dcdbd50d5904e4ee', '58f02544b08a4f310a4b8b24c67191e59419583141684e5268fc094eae9b43c9', 'e5264c09892e29645048ef86c987f95a814e2e01c98332d2d8809eed04a0b5d2', '8e1ef1f3845546bfbed884c94f51a19cee8ebfdc977f4c9091a1008026c540af', '9e47f9c49d4ffb131be31e7b5676a91050b375d823d18009e9fff94ec9b38956', '2f07ef13fb197dfbb24335dba11708eeddc61cae0c297c3eb842636965aba642', 'e30e0920d1ef0023a63ec84cdaaee8fad200ac339db4ef1aeb0762ec6171e227'] B "this section covers required behavior of a tsn-aware detnet node using a tsn sub-network." {96: 1, 97: 1, 52: 1, 6: 3, 79: 3, 90: 3, 130: 2, 62: 4, 85: 5, 51: 2, 68: 5, 35: 4, 110: 3, 91: 5, 114: 3, 31: 4, 13: 3, 67: 3, 38: 4, 26: 3, 124: 4, 98: 3, 54: 3, 127: 4, 8: 3, 64: 3, 30: 3, 61: 5, 55: 4, 27: 4, 15: 3, 129: 4, 115: 3, 84: 3, 76: 7, 87: 3, 131: 6, 102: 3, 113: 5, 99: 3, 36: 3, 24: 2, 53: 2, 72: 4} {250: 1, 387: 1, 156: 1, 300: 1, 1: 10, 4: 3, 9: 6, 10: 4, 24: 3, 25: 4, 26: 5, 27: 2, 39: 6, 43: 4, 49: 6, 50: 5, 58: 5, 59: 3, 64: 2, 69: 5, 81: 5, 82: 3, 86: 3, 96: 4, 97: 3, 100: 6, 108: 4, 109: 5, 110: 5, 111: 3, 114: 4, 115: 5, 116: 2, 118: 7, 119: 6, 120: 4, 121: 5, 122: 3, 123: 2, 124: 5, 128: 4, 129: 3, 130: 5, 132: 5, 136: 3, 145: 5, 147: 4, 151: 4, 152: 4, 154: 4, 161: 4, 162: 4, 165: 4, 168: 5, 169: 3, 172: 3, 180: 4, 184: 6, 187: 6, 188: 5, 191: 4, 194: 5, 202: 6, 203: 7, 206: 3, 207: 4, 215: 3, 217: 4, 218: 9, 220: 3, 221: 3, 222: 6, 224: 4, 227: 4, 229: 3, 234: 6, 235: 3, 241: 3, 242: 3, 243: 5, 244: 4, 245: 5, 248: 4, 258: 12, 262: 5, 263: 6, 264: 4, 267: 5, 270: 2, 272: 3, 273: 6, 287: 4, 289: 3, 291: 5, 299: 4, 304: 2, 309: 4, 314: 3, 315: 3, 320: 5, 323: 5, 327: 5, 328: 4, 329: 3, 330: 11, 334: 3, 335: 2, 341: 4, 342: 5, 347: 4, 348: 4, 350: 8, 351: 5, 352: 3, 353: 3, 354: 2, 358: 5, 365: 3, 366: 3, 369: 2, 371: 6, 372: 5, 376: 3, 384: 5, 385: 4, 386: 4, 392: 4, 393: 5, 396: 5, 397: 8, 398: 7, 402: 3} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 51 "From the TSN sub-network perspective DetNet IP nodes are treated as Talker or Listener, that may be (1) TSN-unaware or (2) TSN-aware." Reflecting the 9th September discussions . acd7cae2af60dfafe42acdd9936194decc735f93 acd7cae2af60dfafe42acdd9936194decc735f93 draft-ietf-detnet-ip-over-tsn 9e47f9c49d4ffb131be31e7b5676a91050b375d823d18009e9fff94ec9b38956 ['1053f835fa0c23e5e0be64388d587c7cc201a77844a8fbb716d720640b0549ab', '417df728e954576101d7177ca52e701a308b2bf91f77a2aa663245aed41302a4', '7ac09938faf2d97ce8bcc3b64b905bb5a585aeb30156506ee7abe2cd36825ed9', '6e1359ed3e65e5e9f120654940828dc13452a32a8a4acfab11d893c994ec8b09', '428996c63c0b3d28c52c4558b1e40faa72088ca53cf822a696698c62118ed646', '39820f7cb577ca0dcfb1bfa578ae13c25334acae03e89731064b0e3c300841de', '892d2555f9a89a54f020e44c71d17881727e9c245d0c7a7054f24fb2bfd083c9', '16cc4d5093d5406483d5c6813be03012581eb426cf71f79764772640049f731b', '214810fe3ac0ef76db60e2d0623a8259b9bdf49040882a9e710901fe1eb32fde', '32f367c0df09e73fbac0f227a892fe94f0bf481c36bcaec69b0c9ae7d9198747', 'ca3de1300d25dd0c427db1bee2c3a07497192c2ee0569af5a2680a011f0260af', '73fe0d9e382eeb3be060393606b0decefb645e4461ed9f78dcdbd50d5904e4ee', '58f02544b08a4f310a4b8b24c67191e59419583141684e5268fc094eae9b43c9', 'e5264c09892e29645048ef86c987f95a814e2e01c98332d2d8809eed04a0b5d2', '8e1ef1f3845546bfbed884c94f51a19cee8ebfdc977f4c9091a1008026c540af', '9e47f9c49d4ffb131be31e7b5676a91050b375d823d18009e9fff94ec9b38956', '2f07ef13fb197dfbb24335dba11708eeddc61cae0c297c3eb842636965aba642', 'e30e0920d1ef0023a63ec84cdaaee8fad200ac339db4ef1aeb0762ec6171e227'] B "from the tsn sub-network perspective detnet ip nodes are treated as talker or listener, that may be (1) tsn-unaware or (2) tsn-aware." {96: 1, 97: 1, 52: 1, 6: 3, 79: 3, 90: 3, 130: 2, 62: 4, 85: 5, 51: 2, 68: 5, 35: 4, 110: 3, 91: 5, 114: 3, 31: 4, 13: 3, 67: 3, 38: 4, 26: 3, 124: 4, 98: 3, 54: 3, 127: 4, 8: 3, 64: 3, 30: 3, 61: 5, 55: 4, 27: 4, 15: 3, 129: 4, 115: 3, 84: 3, 76: 7, 87: 3, 131: 6, 102: 3, 113: 5, 99: 3, 36: 3, 24: 2, 53: 2, 72: 4} {250: 1, 387: 1, 156: 1, 300: 1, 1: 10, 4: 3, 9: 6, 10: 4, 24: 3, 25: 4, 26: 5, 27: 2, 39: 6, 43: 4, 49: 6, 50: 5, 58: 5, 59: 3, 64: 2, 69: 5, 81: 5, 82: 3, 86: 3, 96: 4, 97: 3, 100: 6, 108: 4, 109: 5, 110: 5, 111: 3, 114: 4, 115: 5, 116: 2, 118: 7, 119: 6, 120: 4, 121: 5, 122: 3, 123: 2, 124: 5, 128: 4, 129: 3, 130: 5, 132: 5, 136: 3, 145: 5, 147: 4, 151: 4, 152: 4, 154: 4, 161: 4, 162: 4, 165: 4, 168: 5, 169: 3, 172: 3, 180: 4, 184: 6, 187: 6, 188: 5, 191: 4, 194: 5, 202: 6, 203: 7, 206: 3, 207: 4, 215: 3, 217: 4, 218: 9, 220: 3, 221: 3, 222: 6, 224: 4, 227: 4, 229: 3, 234: 6, 235: 3, 241: 3, 242: 3, 243: 5, 244: 4, 245: 5, 248: 4, 258: 12, 262: 5, 263: 6, 264: 4, 267: 5, 270: 2, 272: 3, 273: 6, 287: 4, 289: 3, 291: 5, 299: 4, 304: 2, 309: 4, 314: 3, 315: 3, 320: 5, 323: 5, 327: 5, 328: 4, 329: 3, 330: 11, 334: 3, 335: 2, 341: 4, 342: 5, 347: 4, 348: 4, 350: 8, 351: 5, 352: 3, 353: 3, 354: 2, 358: 5, 365: 3, 366: 3, 369: 2, 371: 6, 372: 5, 376: 3, 384: 5, 385: 4, 386: 4, 392: 4, 393: 5, 396: 5, 397: 8, 398: 7, 402: 3} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 51 "In cases of TSN-unaware IP DetNet nodes the TSN relay nodes within the TSN sub-network must modify the Ethernet encapsulation of the DetNet IP flow (e.g., MAC translation, VLAN-ID setting, Sequence number addition, etc.) to allow proper TSN specific handling inside the sub-network. There are no requirements defined for TSN-unaware IP DetNet nodes in this document." Reflecting the 9th September discussions . acd7cae2af60dfafe42acdd9936194decc735f93 acd7cae2af60dfafe42acdd9936194decc735f93 draft-ietf-detnet-ip-over-tsn 6e1359ed3e65e5e9f120654940828dc13452a32a8a4acfab11d893c994ec8b09 ['1053f835fa0c23e5e0be64388d587c7cc201a77844a8fbb716d720640b0549ab', '417df728e954576101d7177ca52e701a308b2bf91f77a2aa663245aed41302a4', '7ac09938faf2d97ce8bcc3b64b905bb5a585aeb30156506ee7abe2cd36825ed9', '6e1359ed3e65e5e9f120654940828dc13452a32a8a4acfab11d893c994ec8b09', '428996c63c0b3d28c52c4558b1e40faa72088ca53cf822a696698c62118ed646', '39820f7cb577ca0dcfb1bfa578ae13c25334acae03e89731064b0e3c300841de', '892d2555f9a89a54f020e44c71d17881727e9c245d0c7a7054f24fb2bfd083c9', '16cc4d5093d5406483d5c6813be03012581eb426cf71f79764772640049f731b', '214810fe3ac0ef76db60e2d0623a8259b9bdf49040882a9e710901fe1eb32fde', '32f367c0df09e73fbac0f227a892fe94f0bf481c36bcaec69b0c9ae7d9198747', 'ca3de1300d25dd0c427db1bee2c3a07497192c2ee0569af5a2680a011f0260af', '73fe0d9e382eeb3be060393606b0decefb645e4461ed9f78dcdbd50d5904e4ee', '58f02544b08a4f310a4b8b24c67191e59419583141684e5268fc094eae9b43c9', 'e5264c09892e29645048ef86c987f95a814e2e01c98332d2d8809eed04a0b5d2', '8e1ef1f3845546bfbed884c94f51a19cee8ebfdc977f4c9091a1008026c540af', '9e47f9c49d4ffb131be31e7b5676a91050b375d823d18009e9fff94ec9b38956', '2f07ef13fb197dfbb24335dba11708eeddc61cae0c297c3eb842636965aba642', 'e30e0920d1ef0023a63ec84cdaaee8fad200ac339db4ef1aeb0762ec6171e227'] B "in cases of tsn-unaware ip detnet nodes the tsn relay nodes within the tsn sub-network must modify the ethernet encapsulation of the detnet ip flow (e.g., mac translation, vlan-id setting, sequence number addition, etc.) to allow proper tsn specific handling inside the sub-network. there are no requirements defined for tsn-unaware ip detnet nodes in this document." {96: 1, 97: 1, 52: 1, 6: 3, 79: 3, 90: 3, 130: 2, 62: 4, 85: 5, 51: 2, 68: 5, 35: 4, 110: 3, 91: 5, 114: 3, 31: 4, 13: 3, 67: 3, 38: 4, 26: 3, 124: 4, 98: 3, 54: 3, 127: 4, 8: 3, 64: 3, 30: 3, 61: 5, 55: 4, 27: 4, 15: 3, 129: 4, 115: 3, 84: 3, 76: 7, 87: 3, 131: 6, 102: 3, 113: 5, 99: 3, 36: 3, 24: 2, 53: 2, 72: 4} {250: 1, 387: 1, 156: 1, 300: 1, 1: 10, 4: 3, 9: 6, 10: 4, 24: 3, 25: 4, 26: 5, 27: 2, 39: 6, 43: 4, 49: 6, 50: 5, 58: 5, 59: 3, 64: 2, 69: 5, 81: 5, 82: 3, 86: 3, 96: 4, 97: 3, 100: 6, 108: 4, 109: 5, 110: 5, 111: 3, 114: 4, 115: 5, 116: 2, 118: 7, 119: 6, 120: 4, 121: 5, 122: 3, 123: 2, 124: 5, 128: 4, 129: 3, 130: 5, 132: 5, 136: 3, 145: 5, 147: 4, 151: 4, 152: 4, 154: 4, 161: 4, 162: 4, 165: 4, 168: 5, 169: 3, 172: 3, 180: 4, 184: 6, 187: 6, 188: 5, 191: 4, 194: 5, 202: 6, 203: 7, 206: 3, 207: 4, 215: 3, 217: 4, 218: 9, 220: 3, 221: 3, 222: 6, 224: 4, 227: 4, 229: 3, 234: 6, 235: 3, 241: 3, 242: 3, 243: 5, 244: 4, 245: 5, 248: 4, 258: 12, 262: 5, 263: 6, 264: 4, 267: 5, 270: 2, 272: 3, 273: 6, 287: 4, 289: 3, 291: 5, 299: 4, 304: 2, 309: 4, 314: 3, 315: 3, 320: 5, 323: 5, 327: 5, 328: 4, 329: 3, 330: 11, 334: 3, 335: 2, 341: 4, 342: 5, 347: 4, 348: 4, 350: 8, 351: 5, 352: 3, 353: 3, 354: 2, 358: 5, 365: 3, 366: 3, 369: 2, 371: 6, 372: 5, 376: 3, 384: 5, 385: 4, 386: 4, 392: 4, 393: 5, 396: 5, 397: 8, 398: 7, 402: 3} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 51 "IP (DetNet) nodes being TSN-aware can be treated as a combination of a TSN-unaware Talker/Listener and a TSN-Relay, as shown in fig_ip_with_tsn. In such cases the IP (DetNet) node must provide the TSN sub-network specific Ethernet encapsulation over the link(s) towards the sub-network." Reflecting the 9th September discussions . acd7cae2af60dfafe42acdd9936194decc735f93 acd7cae2af60dfafe42acdd9936194decc735f93 draft-ietf-detnet-ip-over-tsn 16cc4d5093d5406483d5c6813be03012581eb426cf71f79764772640049f731b ['1053f835fa0c23e5e0be64388d587c7cc201a77844a8fbb716d720640b0549ab', '417df728e954576101d7177ca52e701a308b2bf91f77a2aa663245aed41302a4', '7ac09938faf2d97ce8bcc3b64b905bb5a585aeb30156506ee7abe2cd36825ed9', '6e1359ed3e65e5e9f120654940828dc13452a32a8a4acfab11d893c994ec8b09', '428996c63c0b3d28c52c4558b1e40faa72088ca53cf822a696698c62118ed646', '39820f7cb577ca0dcfb1bfa578ae13c25334acae03e89731064b0e3c300841de', '892d2555f9a89a54f020e44c71d17881727e9c245d0c7a7054f24fb2bfd083c9', '16cc4d5093d5406483d5c6813be03012581eb426cf71f79764772640049f731b', '214810fe3ac0ef76db60e2d0623a8259b9bdf49040882a9e710901fe1eb32fde', '32f367c0df09e73fbac0f227a892fe94f0bf481c36bcaec69b0c9ae7d9198747', 'ca3de1300d25dd0c427db1bee2c3a07497192c2ee0569af5a2680a011f0260af', '73fe0d9e382eeb3be060393606b0decefb645e4461ed9f78dcdbd50d5904e4ee', '58f02544b08a4f310a4b8b24c67191e59419583141684e5268fc094eae9b43c9', 'e5264c09892e29645048ef86c987f95a814e2e01c98332d2d8809eed04a0b5d2', '8e1ef1f3845546bfbed884c94f51a19cee8ebfdc977f4c9091a1008026c540af', '9e47f9c49d4ffb131be31e7b5676a91050b375d823d18009e9fff94ec9b38956', '2f07ef13fb197dfbb24335dba11708eeddc61cae0c297c3eb842636965aba642', 'e30e0920d1ef0023a63ec84cdaaee8fad200ac339db4ef1aeb0762ec6171e227'] B "ip (detnet) nodes being tsn-aware can be treated as a combination of a tsn-unaware talker/listener and a tsn-relay, as shown in fig_ip_with_tsn. in such cases the ip (detnet) node must provide the tsn sub-network specific ethernet encapsulation over the link(s) towards the sub-network." {96: 1, 97: 1, 52: 1, 6: 3, 79: 3, 90: 3, 130: 2, 62: 4, 85: 5, 51: 2, 68: 5, 35: 4, 110: 3, 91: 5, 114: 3, 31: 4, 13: 3, 67: 3, 38: 4, 26: 3, 124: 4, 98: 3, 54: 3, 127: 4, 8: 3, 64: 3, 30: 3, 61: 5, 55: 4, 27: 4, 15: 3, 129: 4, 115: 3, 84: 3, 76: 7, 87: 3, 131: 6, 102: 3, 113: 5, 99: 3, 36: 3, 24: 2, 53: 2, 72: 4} {250: 1, 387: 1, 156: 1, 300: 1, 1: 10, 4: 3, 9: 6, 10: 4, 24: 3, 25: 4, 26: 5, 27: 2, 39: 6, 43: 4, 49: 6, 50: 5, 58: 5, 59: 3, 64: 2, 69: 5, 81: 5, 82: 3, 86: 3, 96: 4, 97: 3, 100: 6, 108: 4, 109: 5, 110: 5, 111: 3, 114: 4, 115: 5, 116: 2, 118: 7, 119: 6, 120: 4, 121: 5, 122: 3, 123: 2, 124: 5, 128: 4, 129: 3, 130: 5, 132: 5, 136: 3, 145: 5, 147: 4, 151: 4, 152: 4, 154: 4, 161: 4, 162: 4, 165: 4, 168: 5, 169: 3, 172: 3, 180: 4, 184: 6, 187: 6, 188: 5, 191: 4, 194: 5, 202: 6, 203: 7, 206: 3, 207: 4, 215: 3, 217: 4, 218: 9, 220: 3, 221: 3, 222: 6, 224: 4, 227: 4, 229: 3, 234: 6, 235: 3, 241: 3, 242: 3, 243: 5, 244: 4, 245: 5, 248: 4, 258: 12, 262: 5, 263: 6, 264: 4, 267: 5, 270: 2, 272: 3, 273: 6, 287: 4, 289: 3, 291: 5, 299: 4, 304: 2, 309: 4, 314: 3, 315: 3, 320: 5, 323: 5, 327: 5, 328: 4, 329: 3, 330: 11, 334: 3, 335: 2, 341: 4, 342: 5, 347: 4, 348: 4, 350: 8, 351: 5, 352: 3, 353: 3, 354: 2, 358: 5, 365: 3, 366: 3, 369: 2, 371: 6, 372: 5, 376: 3, 384: 5, 385: 4, 386: 4, 392: 4, 393: 5, 396: 5, 397: 8, 398: 7, 402: 3} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 51 "A TSN-aware IP (DetNet) node impementations MUST support the Stream Identification TSN component for recognizing flows." Reflecting the 9th September discussions . acd7cae2af60dfafe42acdd9936194decc735f93 acd7cae2af60dfafe42acdd9936194decc735f93 draft-ietf-detnet-ip-over-tsn 428996c63c0b3d28c52c4558b1e40faa72088ca53cf822a696698c62118ed646 ['1053f835fa0c23e5e0be64388d587c7cc201a77844a8fbb716d720640b0549ab', '417df728e954576101d7177ca52e701a308b2bf91f77a2aa663245aed41302a4', '7ac09938faf2d97ce8bcc3b64b905bb5a585aeb30156506ee7abe2cd36825ed9', '6e1359ed3e65e5e9f120654940828dc13452a32a8a4acfab11d893c994ec8b09', '428996c63c0b3d28c52c4558b1e40faa72088ca53cf822a696698c62118ed646', '39820f7cb577ca0dcfb1bfa578ae13c25334acae03e89731064b0e3c300841de', '892d2555f9a89a54f020e44c71d17881727e9c245d0c7a7054f24fb2bfd083c9', '16cc4d5093d5406483d5c6813be03012581eb426cf71f79764772640049f731b', '214810fe3ac0ef76db60e2d0623a8259b9bdf49040882a9e710901fe1eb32fde', '32f367c0df09e73fbac0f227a892fe94f0bf481c36bcaec69b0c9ae7d9198747', 'ca3de1300d25dd0c427db1bee2c3a07497192c2ee0569af5a2680a011f0260af', '73fe0d9e382eeb3be060393606b0decefb645e4461ed9f78dcdbd50d5904e4ee', '58f02544b08a4f310a4b8b24c67191e59419583141684e5268fc094eae9b43c9', 'e5264c09892e29645048ef86c987f95a814e2e01c98332d2d8809eed04a0b5d2', '8e1ef1f3845546bfbed884c94f51a19cee8ebfdc977f4c9091a1008026c540af', '9e47f9c49d4ffb131be31e7b5676a91050b375d823d18009e9fff94ec9b38956', '2f07ef13fb197dfbb24335dba11708eeddc61cae0c297c3eb842636965aba642', 'e30e0920d1ef0023a63ec84cdaaee8fad200ac339db4ef1aeb0762ec6171e227'] B "a tsn-aware ip (detnet) node impementations must support the stream identification tsn component for recognizing flows." {96: 1, 97: 1, 52: 1, 6: 3, 79: 3, 90: 3, 130: 2, 62: 4, 85: 5, 51: 2, 68: 5, 35: 4, 110: 3, 91: 5, 114: 3, 31: 4, 13: 3, 67: 3, 38: 4, 26: 3, 124: 4, 98: 3, 54: 3, 127: 4, 8: 3, 64: 3, 30: 3, 61: 5, 55: 4, 27: 4, 15: 3, 129: 4, 115: 3, 84: 3, 76: 7, 87: 3, 131: 6, 102: 3, 113: 5, 99: 3, 36: 3, 24: 2, 53: 2, 72: 4} {250: 1, 387: 1, 156: 1, 300: 1, 1: 10, 4: 3, 9: 6, 10: 4, 24: 3, 25: 4, 26: 5, 27: 2, 39: 6, 43: 4, 49: 6, 50: 5, 58: 5, 59: 3, 64: 2, 69: 5, 81: 5, 82: 3, 86: 3, 96: 4, 97: 3, 100: 6, 108: 4, 109: 5, 110: 5, 111: 3, 114: 4, 115: 5, 116: 2, 118: 7, 119: 6, 120: 4, 121: 5, 122: 3, 123: 2, 124: 5, 128: 4, 129: 3, 130: 5, 132: 5, 136: 3, 145: 5, 147: 4, 151: 4, 152: 4, 154: 4, 161: 4, 162: 4, 165: 4, 168: 5, 169: 3, 172: 3, 180: 4, 184: 6, 187: 6, 188: 5, 191: 4, 194: 5, 202: 6, 203: 7, 206: 3, 207: 4, 215: 3, 217: 4, 218: 9, 220: 3, 221: 3, 222: 6, 224: 4, 227: 4, 229: 3, 234: 6, 235: 3, 241: 3, 242: 3, 243: 5, 244: 4, 245: 5, 248: 4, 258: 12, 262: 5, 263: 6, 264: 4, 267: 5, 270: 2, 272: 3, 273: 6, 287: 4, 289: 3, 291: 5, 299: 4, 304: 2, 309: 4, 314: 3, 315: 3, 320: 5, 323: 5, 327: 5, 328: 4, 329: 3, 330: 11, 334: 3, 335: 2, 341: 4, 342: 5, 347: 4, 348: 4, 350: 8, 351: 5, 352: 3, 353: 3, 354: 2, 358: 5, 365: 3, 366: 3, 369: 2, 371: 6, 372: 5, 376: 3, 384: 5, 385: 4, 386: 4, 392: 4, 393: 5, 396: 5, 397: 8, 398: 7, 402: 3} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 51 "A Stream identification component MUST be able to instantiate the following functions (1) Active Destination MAC and VLAN Stream identification function, (2) IP Stream identification function, (3) Mask-and-Match Stream identification function and (4) the related managed objects in Clause 9 of IEEE8021CB and IEEEP8021CBdb." Reflecting the 9th September discussions . acd7cae2af60dfafe42acdd9936194decc735f93 acd7cae2af60dfafe42acdd9936194decc735f93 draft-ietf-detnet-ip-over-tsn 58f02544b08a4f310a4b8b24c67191e59419583141684e5268fc094eae9b43c9 ['1053f835fa0c23e5e0be64388d587c7cc201a77844a8fbb716d720640b0549ab', '417df728e954576101d7177ca52e701a308b2bf91f77a2aa663245aed41302a4', '7ac09938faf2d97ce8bcc3b64b905bb5a585aeb30156506ee7abe2cd36825ed9', '6e1359ed3e65e5e9f120654940828dc13452a32a8a4acfab11d893c994ec8b09', '428996c63c0b3d28c52c4558b1e40faa72088ca53cf822a696698c62118ed646', '39820f7cb577ca0dcfb1bfa578ae13c25334acae03e89731064b0e3c300841de', '892d2555f9a89a54f020e44c71d17881727e9c245d0c7a7054f24fb2bfd083c9', '16cc4d5093d5406483d5c6813be03012581eb426cf71f79764772640049f731b', '214810fe3ac0ef76db60e2d0623a8259b9bdf49040882a9e710901fe1eb32fde', '32f367c0df09e73fbac0f227a892fe94f0bf481c36bcaec69b0c9ae7d9198747', 'ca3de1300d25dd0c427db1bee2c3a07497192c2ee0569af5a2680a011f0260af', '73fe0d9e382eeb3be060393606b0decefb645e4461ed9f78dcdbd50d5904e4ee', '58f02544b08a4f310a4b8b24c67191e59419583141684e5268fc094eae9b43c9', 'e5264c09892e29645048ef86c987f95a814e2e01c98332d2d8809eed04a0b5d2', '8e1ef1f3845546bfbed884c94f51a19cee8ebfdc977f4c9091a1008026c540af', '9e47f9c49d4ffb131be31e7b5676a91050b375d823d18009e9fff94ec9b38956', '2f07ef13fb197dfbb24335dba11708eeddc61cae0c297c3eb842636965aba642', 'e30e0920d1ef0023a63ec84cdaaee8fad200ac339db4ef1aeb0762ec6171e227'] B "a stream identification component must be able to instantiate the following functions (1) active destination mac and vlan stream identification function, (2) ip stream identification function, (3) mask-and-match stream identification function and (4) the related managed objects in clause 9 of ieee8021cb and ieeep8021cbdb." {96: 1, 97: 1, 52: 1, 6: 3, 79: 3, 90: 3, 130: 2, 62: 4, 85: 5, 51: 2, 68: 5, 35: 4, 110: 3, 91: 5, 114: 3, 31: 4, 13: 3, 67: 3, 38: 4, 26: 3, 124: 4, 98: 3, 54: 3, 127: 4, 8: 3, 64: 3, 30: 3, 61: 5, 55: 4, 27: 4, 15: 3, 129: 4, 115: 3, 84: 3, 76: 7, 87: 3, 131: 6, 102: 3, 113: 5, 99: 3, 36: 3, 24: 2, 53: 2, 72: 4} {250: 1, 387: 1, 156: 1, 300: 1, 1: 10, 4: 3, 9: 6, 10: 4, 24: 3, 25: 4, 26: 5, 27: 2, 39: 6, 43: 4, 49: 6, 50: 5, 58: 5, 59: 3, 64: 2, 69: 5, 81: 5, 82: 3, 86: 3, 96: 4, 97: 3, 100: 6, 108: 4, 109: 5, 110: 5, 111: 3, 114: 4, 115: 5, 116: 2, 118: 7, 119: 6, 120: 4, 121: 5, 122: 3, 123: 2, 124: 5, 128: 4, 129: 3, 130: 5, 132: 5, 136: 3, 145: 5, 147: 4, 151: 4, 152: 4, 154: 4, 161: 4, 162: 4, 165: 4, 168: 5, 169: 3, 172: 3, 180: 4, 184: 6, 187: 6, 188: 5, 191: 4, 194: 5, 202: 6, 203: 7, 206: 3, 207: 4, 215: 3, 217: 4, 218: 9, 220: 3, 221: 3, 222: 6, 224: 4, 227: 4, 229: 3, 234: 6, 235: 3, 241: 3, 242: 3, 243: 5, 244: 4, 245: 5, 248: 4, 258: 12, 262: 5, 263: 6, 264: 4, 267: 5, 270: 2, 272: 3, 273: 6, 287: 4, 289: 3, 291: 5, 299: 4, 304: 2, 309: 4, 314: 3, 315: 3, 320: 5, 323: 5, 327: 5, 328: 4, 329: 3, 330: 11, 334: 3, 335: 2, 341: 4, 342: 5, 347: 4, 348: 4, 350: 8, 351: 5, 352: 3, 353: 3, 354: 2, 358: 5, 365: 3, 366: 3, 369: 2, 371: 6, 372: 5, 376: 3, 384: 5, 385: 4, 386: 4, 392: 4, 393: 5, 396: 5, 397: 8, 398: 7, 402: 3} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 51 "A TSN-aware IP (DetNet) node implementations MUST support the Sequencing function and the Sequence encode/decode function as defined in IEEE8021CB if FRER is used inside the TSN sub-network." Reflecting the 9th September discussions . acd7cae2af60dfafe42acdd9936194decc735f93 acd7cae2af60dfafe42acdd9936194decc735f93 draft-ietf-detnet-ip-over-tsn 892d2555f9a89a54f020e44c71d17881727e9c245d0c7a7054f24fb2bfd083c9 ['1053f835fa0c23e5e0be64388d587c7cc201a77844a8fbb716d720640b0549ab', '417df728e954576101d7177ca52e701a308b2bf91f77a2aa663245aed41302a4', '7ac09938faf2d97ce8bcc3b64b905bb5a585aeb30156506ee7abe2cd36825ed9', '6e1359ed3e65e5e9f120654940828dc13452a32a8a4acfab11d893c994ec8b09', '428996c63c0b3d28c52c4558b1e40faa72088ca53cf822a696698c62118ed646', '39820f7cb577ca0dcfb1bfa578ae13c25334acae03e89731064b0e3c300841de', '892d2555f9a89a54f020e44c71d17881727e9c245d0c7a7054f24fb2bfd083c9', '16cc4d5093d5406483d5c6813be03012581eb426cf71f79764772640049f731b', '214810fe3ac0ef76db60e2d0623a8259b9bdf49040882a9e710901fe1eb32fde', '32f367c0df09e73fbac0f227a892fe94f0bf481c36bcaec69b0c9ae7d9198747', 'ca3de1300d25dd0c427db1bee2c3a07497192c2ee0569af5a2680a011f0260af', '73fe0d9e382eeb3be060393606b0decefb645e4461ed9f78dcdbd50d5904e4ee', '58f02544b08a4f310a4b8b24c67191e59419583141684e5268fc094eae9b43c9', 'e5264c09892e29645048ef86c987f95a814e2e01c98332d2d8809eed04a0b5d2', '8e1ef1f3845546bfbed884c94f51a19cee8ebfdc977f4c9091a1008026c540af', '9e47f9c49d4ffb131be31e7b5676a91050b375d823d18009e9fff94ec9b38956', '2f07ef13fb197dfbb24335dba11708eeddc61cae0c297c3eb842636965aba642', 'e30e0920d1ef0023a63ec84cdaaee8fad200ac339db4ef1aeb0762ec6171e227'] B "a tsn-aware ip (detnet) node implementations must support the sequencing function and the sequence encode/decode function as defined in ieee8021cb if frer is used inside the tsn sub-network." {96: 1, 97: 1, 52: 1, 6: 3, 79: 3, 90: 3, 130: 2, 62: 4, 85: 5, 51: 2, 68: 5, 35: 4, 110: 3, 91: 5, 114: 3, 31: 4, 13: 3, 67: 3, 38: 4, 26: 3, 124: 4, 98: 3, 54: 3, 127: 4, 8: 3, 64: 3, 30: 3, 61: 5, 55: 4, 27: 4, 15: 3, 129: 4, 115: 3, 84: 3, 76: 7, 87: 3, 131: 6, 102: 3, 113: 5, 99: 3, 36: 3, 24: 2, 53: 2, 72: 4} {250: 1, 387: 1, 156: 1, 300: 1, 1: 10, 4: 3, 9: 6, 10: 4, 24: 3, 25: 4, 26: 5, 27: 2, 39: 6, 43: 4, 49: 6, 50: 5, 58: 5, 59: 3, 64: 2, 69: 5, 81: 5, 82: 3, 86: 3, 96: 4, 97: 3, 100: 6, 108: 4, 109: 5, 110: 5, 111: 3, 114: 4, 115: 5, 116: 2, 118: 7, 119: 6, 120: 4, 121: 5, 122: 3, 123: 2, 124: 5, 128: 4, 129: 3, 130: 5, 132: 5, 136: 3, 145: 5, 147: 4, 151: 4, 152: 4, 154: 4, 161: 4, 162: 4, 165: 4, 168: 5, 169: 3, 172: 3, 180: 4, 184: 6, 187: 6, 188: 5, 191: 4, 194: 5, 202: 6, 203: 7, 206: 3, 207: 4, 215: 3, 217: 4, 218: 9, 220: 3, 221: 3, 222: 6, 224: 4, 227: 4, 229: 3, 234: 6, 235: 3, 241: 3, 242: 3, 243: 5, 244: 4, 245: 5, 248: 4, 258: 12, 262: 5, 263: 6, 264: 4, 267: 5, 270: 2, 272: 3, 273: 6, 287: 4, 289: 3, 291: 5, 299: 4, 304: 2, 309: 4, 314: 3, 315: 3, 320: 5, 323: 5, 327: 5, 328: 4, 329: 3, 330: 11, 334: 3, 335: 2, 341: 4, 342: 5, 347: 4, 348: 4, 350: 8, 351: 5, 352: 3, 353: 3, 354: 2, 358: 5, 365: 3, 366: 3, 369: 2, 371: 6, 372: 5, 376: 3, 384: 5, 385: 4, 386: 4, 392: 4, 393: 5, 396: 5, 397: 8, 398: 7, 402: 3} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 51 "A TSN-aware IP (DetNet) node implementations MUST support the Stream splitting function and the Individual recovery function as defined in IEEE8021CB when the node is a replication or elimination point for FRER." Reflecting the 9th September discussions . acd7cae2af60dfafe42acdd9936194decc735f93 acd7cae2af60dfafe42acdd9936194decc735f93 draft-ietf-detnet-ip-over-tsn 2f07ef13fb197dfbb24335dba11708eeddc61cae0c297c3eb842636965aba642 ['1053f835fa0c23e5e0be64388d587c7cc201a77844a8fbb716d720640b0549ab', '417df728e954576101d7177ca52e701a308b2bf91f77a2aa663245aed41302a4', '7ac09938faf2d97ce8bcc3b64b905bb5a585aeb30156506ee7abe2cd36825ed9', '6e1359ed3e65e5e9f120654940828dc13452a32a8a4acfab11d893c994ec8b09', '428996c63c0b3d28c52c4558b1e40faa72088ca53cf822a696698c62118ed646', '39820f7cb577ca0dcfb1bfa578ae13c25334acae03e89731064b0e3c300841de', '892d2555f9a89a54f020e44c71d17881727e9c245d0c7a7054f24fb2bfd083c9', '16cc4d5093d5406483d5c6813be03012581eb426cf71f79764772640049f731b', '214810fe3ac0ef76db60e2d0623a8259b9bdf49040882a9e710901fe1eb32fde', '32f367c0df09e73fbac0f227a892fe94f0bf481c36bcaec69b0c9ae7d9198747', 'ca3de1300d25dd0c427db1bee2c3a07497192c2ee0569af5a2680a011f0260af', '73fe0d9e382eeb3be060393606b0decefb645e4461ed9f78dcdbd50d5904e4ee', '58f02544b08a4f310a4b8b24c67191e59419583141684e5268fc094eae9b43c9', 'e5264c09892e29645048ef86c987f95a814e2e01c98332d2d8809eed04a0b5d2', '8e1ef1f3845546bfbed884c94f51a19cee8ebfdc977f4c9091a1008026c540af', '9e47f9c49d4ffb131be31e7b5676a91050b375d823d18009e9fff94ec9b38956', '2f07ef13fb197dfbb24335dba11708eeddc61cae0c297c3eb842636965aba642', 'e30e0920d1ef0023a63ec84cdaaee8fad200ac339db4ef1aeb0762ec6171e227'] B "a tsn-aware ip (detnet) node implementations must support the stream splitting function and the individual recovery function as defined in ieee8021cb when the node is a replication or elimination point for frer." {96: 1, 97: 1, 52: 1, 6: 3, 79: 3, 90: 3, 130: 2, 62: 4, 85: 5, 51: 2, 68: 5, 35: 4, 110: 3, 91: 5, 114: 3, 31: 4, 13: 3, 67: 3, 38: 4, 26: 3, 124: 4, 98: 3, 54: 3, 127: 4, 8: 3, 64: 3, 30: 3, 61: 5, 55: 4, 27: 4, 15: 3, 129: 4, 115: 3, 84: 3, 76: 7, 87: 3, 131: 6, 102: 3, 113: 5, 99: 3, 36: 3, 24: 2, 53: 2, 72: 4} {250: 1, 387: 1, 156: 1, 300: 1, 1: 10, 4: 3, 9: 6, 10: 4, 24: 3, 25: 4, 26: 5, 27: 2, 39: 6, 43: 4, 49: 6, 50: 5, 58: 5, 59: 3, 64: 2, 69: 5, 81: 5, 82: 3, 86: 3, 96: 4, 97: 3, 100: 6, 108: 4, 109: 5, 110: 5, 111: 3, 114: 4, 115: 5, 116: 2, 118: 7, 119: 6, 120: 4, 121: 5, 122: 3, 123: 2, 124: 5, 128: 4, 129: 3, 130: 5, 132: 5, 136: 3, 145: 5, 147: 4, 151: 4, 152: 4, 154: 4, 161: 4, 162: 4, 165: 4, 168: 5, 169: 3, 172: 3, 180: 4, 184: 6, 187: 6, 188: 5, 191: 4, 194: 5, 202: 6, 203: 7, 206: 3, 207: 4, 215: 3, 217: 4, 218: 9, 220: 3, 221: 3, 222: 6, 224: 4, 227: 4, 229: 3, 234: 6, 235: 3, 241: 3, 242: 3, 243: 5, 244: 4, 245: 5, 248: 4, 258: 12, 262: 5, 263: 6, 264: 4, 267: 5, 270: 2, 272: 3, 273: 6, 287: 4, 289: 3, 291: 5, 299: 4, 304: 2, 309: 4, 314: 3, 315: 3, 320: 5, 323: 5, 327: 5, 328: 4, 329: 3, 330: 11, 334: 3, 335: 2, 341: 4, 342: 5, 347: 4, 348: 4, 350: 8, 351: 5, 352: 3, 353: 3, 354: 2, 358: 5, 365: 3, 366: 3, 369: 2, 371: 6, 372: 5, 376: 3, 384: 5, 385: 4, 386: 4, 392: 4, 393: 5, 396: 5, 397: 8, 398: 7, 402: 3} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 51 "TSN Streams supporting DetNet flows may use Frame Replication and Elimination for Redundancy (FRER) as defined in IEEE8021CB based on the loss service requirements of the TSN Stream, which is derived from the DetNet service requirements of the DetNet mapped flow. The specific operation of FRER is not modified by the use of DetNet and follows IEEE8021CB." Reflecting the 9th September discussions . acd7cae2af60dfafe42acdd9936194decc735f93 acd7cae2af60dfafe42acdd9936194decc735f93 draft-ietf-detnet-ip-over-tsn 214810fe3ac0ef76db60e2d0623a8259b9bdf49040882a9e710901fe1eb32fde ['1053f835fa0c23e5e0be64388d587c7cc201a77844a8fbb716d720640b0549ab', '417df728e954576101d7177ca52e701a308b2bf91f77a2aa663245aed41302a4', '7ac09938faf2d97ce8bcc3b64b905bb5a585aeb30156506ee7abe2cd36825ed9', '6e1359ed3e65e5e9f120654940828dc13452a32a8a4acfab11d893c994ec8b09', '428996c63c0b3d28c52c4558b1e40faa72088ca53cf822a696698c62118ed646', '39820f7cb577ca0dcfb1bfa578ae13c25334acae03e89731064b0e3c300841de', '892d2555f9a89a54f020e44c71d17881727e9c245d0c7a7054f24fb2bfd083c9', '16cc4d5093d5406483d5c6813be03012581eb426cf71f79764772640049f731b', '214810fe3ac0ef76db60e2d0623a8259b9bdf49040882a9e710901fe1eb32fde', '32f367c0df09e73fbac0f227a892fe94f0bf481c36bcaec69b0c9ae7d9198747', 'ca3de1300d25dd0c427db1bee2c3a07497192c2ee0569af5a2680a011f0260af', '73fe0d9e382eeb3be060393606b0decefb645e4461ed9f78dcdbd50d5904e4ee', '58f02544b08a4f310a4b8b24c67191e59419583141684e5268fc094eae9b43c9', 'e5264c09892e29645048ef86c987f95a814e2e01c98332d2d8809eed04a0b5d2', '8e1ef1f3845546bfbed884c94f51a19cee8ebfdc977f4c9091a1008026c540af', '9e47f9c49d4ffb131be31e7b5676a91050b375d823d18009e9fff94ec9b38956', '2f07ef13fb197dfbb24335dba11708eeddc61cae0c297c3eb842636965aba642', 'e30e0920d1ef0023a63ec84cdaaee8fad200ac339db4ef1aeb0762ec6171e227'] B "tsn streams supporting detnet flows may use frame replication and elimination for redundancy (frer) as defined in ieee8021cb based on the loss service requirements of the tsn stream, which is derived from the detnet service requirements of the detnet mapped flow. the specific operation of frer is not modified by the use of detnet and follows ieee8021cb." {96: 1, 97: 1, 52: 1, 6: 3, 79: 3, 90: 3, 130: 2, 62: 4, 85: 5, 51: 2, 68: 5, 35: 4, 110: 3, 91: 5, 114: 3, 31: 4, 13: 3, 67: 3, 38: 4, 26: 3, 124: 4, 98: 3, 54: 3, 127: 4, 8: 3, 64: 3, 30: 3, 61: 5, 55: 4, 27: 4, 15: 3, 129: 4, 115: 3, 84: 3, 76: 7, 87: 3, 131: 6, 102: 3, 113: 5, 99: 3, 36: 3, 24: 2, 53: 2, 72: 4} {250: 1, 387: 1, 156: 1, 300: 1, 1: 10, 4: 3, 9: 6, 10: 4, 24: 3, 25: 4, 26: 5, 27: 2, 39: 6, 43: 4, 49: 6, 50: 5, 58: 5, 59: 3, 64: 2, 69: 5, 81: 5, 82: 3, 86: 3, 96: 4, 97: 3, 100: 6, 108: 4, 109: 5, 110: 5, 111: 3, 114: 4, 115: 5, 116: 2, 118: 7, 119: 6, 120: 4, 121: 5, 122: 3, 123: 2, 124: 5, 128: 4, 129: 3, 130: 5, 132: 5, 136: 3, 145: 5, 147: 4, 151: 4, 152: 4, 154: 4, 161: 4, 162: 4, 165: 4, 168: 5, 169: 3, 172: 3, 180: 4, 184: 6, 187: 6, 188: 5, 191: 4, 194: 5, 202: 6, 203: 7, 206: 3, 207: 4, 215: 3, 217: 4, 218: 9, 220: 3, 221: 3, 222: 6, 224: 4, 227: 4, 229: 3, 234: 6, 235: 3, 241: 3, 242: 3, 243: 5, 244: 4, 245: 5, 248: 4, 258: 12, 262: 5, 263: 6, 264: 4, 267: 5, 270: 2, 272: 3, 273: 6, 287: 4, 289: 3, 291: 5, 299: 4, 304: 2, 309: 4, 314: 3, 315: 3, 320: 5, 323: 5, 327: 5, 328: 4, 329: 3, 330: 11, 334: 3, 335: 2, 341: 4, 342: 5, 347: 4, 348: 4, 350: 8, 351: 5, 352: 3, 353: 3, 354: 2, 358: 5, 365: 3, 366: 3, 369: 2, 371: 6, 372: 5, 376: 3, 384: 5, 385: 4, 386: 4, 392: 4, 393: 5, 396: 5, 397: 8, 398: 7, 402: 3} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 51 "FRER function and the provided service recovery is available only within the TSN sub-network as the TSN Stream-ID and the TSN sequence number are not valid outside the sub-network. An IP (DetNet) node represents a L3 border and as such it terminates all related information elements encoded in the L2 frames." Reflecting the 9th September discussions . acd7cae2af60dfafe42acdd9936194decc735f93 acd7cae2af60dfafe42acdd9936194decc735f93 draft-ietf-detnet-ip-over-tsn 417df728e954576101d7177ca52e701a308b2bf91f77a2aa663245aed41302a4 ['1053f835fa0c23e5e0be64388d587c7cc201a77844a8fbb716d720640b0549ab', '417df728e954576101d7177ca52e701a308b2bf91f77a2aa663245aed41302a4', '7ac09938faf2d97ce8bcc3b64b905bb5a585aeb30156506ee7abe2cd36825ed9', '6e1359ed3e65e5e9f120654940828dc13452a32a8a4acfab11d893c994ec8b09', '428996c63c0b3d28c52c4558b1e40faa72088ca53cf822a696698c62118ed646', '39820f7cb577ca0dcfb1bfa578ae13c25334acae03e89731064b0e3c300841de', '892d2555f9a89a54f020e44c71d17881727e9c245d0c7a7054f24fb2bfd083c9', '16cc4d5093d5406483d5c6813be03012581eb426cf71f79764772640049f731b', '214810fe3ac0ef76db60e2d0623a8259b9bdf49040882a9e710901fe1eb32fde', '32f367c0df09e73fbac0f227a892fe94f0bf481c36bcaec69b0c9ae7d9198747', 'ca3de1300d25dd0c427db1bee2c3a07497192c2ee0569af5a2680a011f0260af', '73fe0d9e382eeb3be060393606b0decefb645e4461ed9f78dcdbd50d5904e4ee', '58f02544b08a4f310a4b8b24c67191e59419583141684e5268fc094eae9b43c9', 'e5264c09892e29645048ef86c987f95a814e2e01c98332d2d8809eed04a0b5d2', '8e1ef1f3845546bfbed884c94f51a19cee8ebfdc977f4c9091a1008026c540af', '9e47f9c49d4ffb131be31e7b5676a91050b375d823d18009e9fff94ec9b38956', '2f07ef13fb197dfbb24335dba11708eeddc61cae0c297c3eb842636965aba642', 'e30e0920d1ef0023a63ec84cdaaee8fad200ac339db4ef1aeb0762ec6171e227'] B "frer function and the provided service recovery is available only within the tsn sub-network as the tsn stream-id and the tsn sequence number are not valid outside the sub-network. an ip (detnet) node represents a l3 border and as such it terminates all related information elements encoded in the l2 frames." {96: 1, 97: 1, 52: 1, 6: 3, 79: 3, 90: 3, 130: 2, 62: 4, 85: 5, 51: 2, 68: 5, 35: 4, 110: 3, 91: 5, 114: 3, 31: 4, 13: 3, 67: 3, 38: 4, 26: 3, 124: 4, 98: 3, 54: 3, 127: 4, 8: 3, 64: 3, 30: 3, 61: 5, 55: 4, 27: 4, 15: 3, 129: 4, 115: 3, 84: 3, 76: 7, 87: 3, 131: 6, 102: 3, 113: 5, 99: 3, 36: 3, 24: 2, 53: 2, 72: 4} {250: 1, 387: 1, 156: 1, 300: 1, 1: 10, 4: 3, 9: 6, 10: 4, 24: 3, 25: 4, 26: 5, 27: 2, 39: 6, 43: 4, 49: 6, 50: 5, 58: 5, 59: 3, 64: 2, 69: 5, 81: 5, 82: 3, 86: 3, 96: 4, 97: 3, 100: 6, 108: 4, 109: 5, 110: 5, 111: 3, 114: 4, 115: 5, 116: 2, 118: 7, 119: 6, 120: 4, 121: 5, 122: 3, 123: 2, 124: 5, 128: 4, 129: 3, 130: 5, 132: 5, 136: 3, 145: 5, 147: 4, 151: 4, 152: 4, 154: 4, 161: 4, 162: 4, 165: 4, 168: 5, 169: 3, 172: 3, 180: 4, 184: 6, 187: 6, 188: 5, 191: 4, 194: 5, 202: 6, 203: 7, 206: 3, 207: 4, 215: 3, 217: 4, 218: 9, 220: 3, 221: 3, 222: 6, 224: 4, 227: 4, 229: 3, 234: 6, 235: 3, 241: 3, 242: 3, 243: 5, 244: 4, 245: 5, 248: 4, 258: 12, 262: 5, 263: 6, 264: 4, 267: 5, 270: 2, 272: 3, 273: 6, 287: 4, 289: 3, 291: 5, 299: 4, 304: 2, 309: 4, 314: 3, 315: 3, 320: 5, 323: 5, 327: 5, 328: 4, 329: 3, 330: 11, 334: 3, 335: 2, 341: 4, 342: 5, 347: 4, 348: 4, 350: 8, 351: 5, 352: 3, 353: 3, 354: 2, 358: 5, 365: 3, 366: 3, 369: 2, 371: 6, 372: 5, 376: 3, 384: 5, 385: 4, 386: 4, 392: 4, 393: 5, 396: 5, 397: 8, 398: 7, 402: 3} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 51 "For proper TSN encapsulation implementations of this document SHALL support active Stream Identification function as defined in chapter 6.6 in IEEE8021CB." Reflecting the 9th September discussions . acd7cae2af60dfafe42acdd9936194decc735f93 acd7cae2af60dfafe42acdd9936194decc735f93 draft-ietf-detnet-ip-over-tsn 4d81362b78d452c235ccc0398e33ba81fad70511dc44186441431eb216c22368 ['4d81362b78d452c235ccc0398e33ba81fad70511dc44186441431eb216c22368', 'c25d7d5894d0374522bf58d66c10a9c1ba974ff5043f6d8b3531bc8883488140', 'e08788806a5626d8da77d16a15c773b129f99d7929408222aa00e07dd394cdf0', 'a110e1206de9a96b4501765703558dfacb256c0b94278aa9369a9143a6f87b6d', 'e492152684d01da2bd800711f0448dfb3089f876da2d7013b3a3489cda83ec11'] A "for proper tsn encapsulation implementations of this document shall support active stream identification function as defined in chapter 6.6 in ieee8021cb." {} {} {} 51 "A TSN-aware IP (DetNet) node SHALL support Ethernet encapsulation with Redundancy tag (R-TAG) as per chapter 7.8 in IEEE8021CB." Reflecting the 9th September discussions . acd7cae2af60dfafe42acdd9936194decc735f93 acd7cae2af60dfafe42acdd9936194decc735f93 draft-ietf-detnet-ip-over-tsn a110e1206de9a96b4501765703558dfacb256c0b94278aa9369a9143a6f87b6d ['4d81362b78d452c235ccc0398e33ba81fad70511dc44186441431eb216c22368', 'c25d7d5894d0374522bf58d66c10a9c1ba974ff5043f6d8b3531bc8883488140', 'e08788806a5626d8da77d16a15c773b129f99d7929408222aa00e07dd394cdf0', 'a110e1206de9a96b4501765703558dfacb256c0b94278aa9369a9143a6f87b6d', 'e492152684d01da2bd800711f0448dfb3089f876da2d7013b3a3489cda83ec11'] A "a tsn-aware ip (detnet) node shall support ethernet encapsulation with redundancy tag (r-tag) as per chapter 7.8 in ieee8021cb." {} {} {} 51 "Depending whether FRER functions are used in the TSN sub-network to serve the mapped TSN Stream, a TSN-aware IP (DetNet) node SHALL support Sequencing function and Sequence encode/decode function as per chapter 7.4 and 7.6 in IEEE8021CB. Furthermore when a TSN-aware IP (DetNet) node acting as a replication or elimination point for FRER it SHALL implement the Stream splitting function and the Individual recovery function as per chapter 7.7 and 7.5 in IEEE8021CB." Reflecting the 9th September discussions . acd7cae2af60dfafe42acdd9936194decc735f93 acd7cae2af60dfafe42acdd9936194decc735f93 draft-ietf-detnet-ip-over-tsn c25d7d5894d0374522bf58d66c10a9c1ba974ff5043f6d8b3531bc8883488140 ['4d81362b78d452c235ccc0398e33ba81fad70511dc44186441431eb216c22368', 'c25d7d5894d0374522bf58d66c10a9c1ba974ff5043f6d8b3531bc8883488140', 'e08788806a5626d8da77d16a15c773b129f99d7929408222aa00e07dd394cdf0', 'a110e1206de9a96b4501765703558dfacb256c0b94278aa9369a9143a6f87b6d', 'e492152684d01da2bd800711f0448dfb3089f876da2d7013b3a3489cda83ec11'] A "depending whether frer functions are used in the tsn sub-network to serve the mapped tsn stream, a tsn-aware ip (detnet) node shall support sequencing function and sequence encode/decode function as per chapter 7.4 and 7.6 in ieee8021cb. furthermore when a tsn-aware ip (detnet) node acting as a replication or elimination point for frer it shall implement the stream splitting function and the individual recovery function as per chapter 7.7 and 7.5 in ieee8021cb." {} {} {} 51 "TSN-aware DetNet IP nodes are member of both the DetNet domain and the TSN sub-network. Within the TSN sub-network the TSN-aware IP (DetNet) node has a TSM-aware Talker/Listener role, so TSN specific management and control plane functionalities must be implemented. There are many similarities in the management plane techniques used in DetNet and TSN, but that is not the case for the control plane protocols. For example, RSVP-TE and MSRP behaves differently. Therefore management and control plane design is an important aspect of scenarios, where mapping between DetNet and TSN is required." Reflecting the 9th September discussions . acd7cae2af60dfafe42acdd9936194decc735f93 acd7cae2af60dfafe42acdd9936194decc735f93 draft-ietf-detnet-ip-over-tsn e08788806a5626d8da77d16a15c773b129f99d7929408222aa00e07dd394cdf0 ['4d81362b78d452c235ccc0398e33ba81fad70511dc44186441431eb216c22368', 'c25d7d5894d0374522bf58d66c10a9c1ba974ff5043f6d8b3531bc8883488140', 'e08788806a5626d8da77d16a15c773b129f99d7929408222aa00e07dd394cdf0', 'a110e1206de9a96b4501765703558dfacb256c0b94278aa9369a9143a6f87b6d', 'e492152684d01da2bd800711f0448dfb3089f876da2d7013b3a3489cda83ec11'] A "tsn-aware detnet ip nodes are member of both the detnet domain and the tsn sub-network. within the tsn sub-network the tsn-aware ip (detnet) node has a tsm-aware talker/listener role, so tsn specific management and control plane functionalities must be implemented. there are many similarities in the management plane techniques used in detnet and tsn, but that is not the case for the control plane protocols. for example, rsvp-te and msrp behaves differently. therefore management and control plane design is an important aspect of scenarios, where mapping between detnet and tsn is required." {} {} {} 51 "TSN-aware IP DetNet nodes are member of both the DetNet domain and the TSN sub-network. Within the TSN sub-network the TSN-aware IP (DetNet) node has a TSN-aware Talker/Listener role, so TSN specific management and control plane functionalities must be implemented. There are many similarities in the management plane techniques used in DetNet and TSN, but that is not the case for the control plane protocols. For example, RSVP-TE and MSRP behaves differently. Therefore management and control plane design is an important aspect of scenarios, where mapping between DetNet and TSN is required." Reflecting the 9th September discussions . acd7cae2af60dfafe42acdd9936194decc735f93 acd7cae2af60dfafe42acdd9936194decc735f93 draft-ietf-detnet-ip-over-tsn e492152684d01da2bd800711f0448dfb3089f876da2d7013b3a3489cda83ec11 ['4d81362b78d452c235ccc0398e33ba81fad70511dc44186441431eb216c22368', 'c25d7d5894d0374522bf58d66c10a9c1ba974ff5043f6d8b3531bc8883488140', 'e08788806a5626d8da77d16a15c773b129f99d7929408222aa00e07dd394cdf0', 'a110e1206de9a96b4501765703558dfacb256c0b94278aa9369a9143a6f87b6d', 'e492152684d01da2bd800711f0448dfb3089f876da2d7013b3a3489cda83ec11'] B "tsn-aware ip detnet nodes are member of both the detnet domain and the tsn sub-network. within the tsn sub-network the tsn-aware ip (detnet) node has a tsn-aware talker/listener role, so tsn specific management and control plane functionalities must be implemented. there are many similarities in the management plane techniques used in detnet and tsn, but that is not the case for the control plane protocols. for example, rsvp-te and msrp behaves differently. therefore management and control plane design is an important aspect of scenarios, where mapping between detnet and tsn is required." {} {} {} 51 "In order to use a TSN sub-network between DetNet nodes, DetNet specific information must be converted to TSN sub-network specific ones. DetNet flow ID and flow related parameters/requirements must be converted to a TSN Stream ID and stream related parameters/ requirements. Note that, as the TSN sub-network is just a portion of the end2end DetNet path (i.e., single hop from IP perspective), some parameters (e.g., delay) may differ significantly. Other parameters (like bandwidth) also may have to be tuned due to the L2 encapsulation used in the TSN sub-network." Reflecting the 9th September discussions . acd7cae2af60dfafe42acdd9936194decc735f93 acd7cae2af60dfafe42acdd9936194decc735f93 draft-ietf-detnet-ip-over-tsn 6bad715d29dce1f68968ab6d027828967e6701eac4bc37a2e3b77d2d00ceb078 ['56f46f99aca1a85f26619e8380573a5f86ae014ec60ab1b5158a0967a0d4441a', 'f5a60a13bb46b3cce44df618c86626539a52d7da653dba2927f41e2f8ea94431', '8f1929ba526ebf5bf53f2b0a2ac0a68ed4d215f39a4f4ea342aca6978f723ff9', '6bad715d29dce1f68968ab6d027828967e6701eac4bc37a2e3b77d2d00ceb078'] A "in order to use a tsn sub-network between detnet nodes, detnet specific information must be converted to tsn sub-network specific ones. detnet flow id and flow related parameters/requirements must be converted to a tsn stream id and stream related parameters/ requirements. note that, as the tsn sub-network is just a portion of the end2end detnet path (i.e., single hop from ip perspective), some parameters (e.g., delay) may differ significantly. other parameters (like bandwidth) also may have to be tuned due to the l2 encapsulation used in the tsn sub-network." {96: 1} {394: 1} {137, 394} 51 "In some case it may be challenging to determine some TSN Stream related information. For example on a TSN-aware IP (DetNet) node that acts as a Talker, it is quite obvious which DetNet node is the Listener of the mapped TSN stream (i.e., the IP Next-Hop). However it may be not trivial to locate the point/interface where that Listener is connected to the TSN sub-network. Such attributes may require interaction between control and management plane functions and between DetNet and TSN domains." Reflecting the 9th September discussions . acd7cae2af60dfafe42acdd9936194decc735f93 acd7cae2af60dfafe42acdd9936194decc735f93 draft-ietf-detnet-ip-over-tsn 8f1929ba526ebf5bf53f2b0a2ac0a68ed4d215f39a4f4ea342aca6978f723ff9 ['56f46f99aca1a85f26619e8380573a5f86ae014ec60ab1b5158a0967a0d4441a', 'f5a60a13bb46b3cce44df618c86626539a52d7da653dba2927f41e2f8ea94431', '8f1929ba526ebf5bf53f2b0a2ac0a68ed4d215f39a4f4ea342aca6978f723ff9', '6bad715d29dce1f68968ab6d027828967e6701eac4bc37a2e3b77d2d00ceb078'] A "in some case it may be challenging to determine some tsn stream related information. for example on a tsn-aware ip (detnet) node that acts as a talker, it is quite obvious which detnet node is the listener of the mapped tsn stream (i.e., the ip next-hop). however it may be not trivial to locate the point/interface where that listener is connected to the tsn sub-network. such attributes may require interaction between control and management plane functions and between detnet and tsn domains." {96: 1} {394: 1} {137, 394} 51 "In order to use a TSN sub-network between DetNet nodes, DetNet specific information must be converted to TSN sub-network specific ones. DetNet flow ID and flow related parameters/requirements must be converted to a TSN Stream ID and stream related parameters/ requirements. Note that, as the TSN sub-network is just a portion of the end2end DetNet path (i.e., single hop from IP perspective), some parameters (e.g., delay) may differ significantly. Other parameters (like bandwidth) also may have to be tuned due to the L2 encapsulation used within the TSN sub-network." Reflecting the 9th September discussions . acd7cae2af60dfafe42acdd9936194decc735f93 acd7cae2af60dfafe42acdd9936194decc735f93 draft-ietf-detnet-ip-over-tsn f5a60a13bb46b3cce44df618c86626539a52d7da653dba2927f41e2f8ea94431 ['56f46f99aca1a85f26619e8380573a5f86ae014ec60ab1b5158a0967a0d4441a', 'f5a60a13bb46b3cce44df618c86626539a52d7da653dba2927f41e2f8ea94431', '8f1929ba526ebf5bf53f2b0a2ac0a68ed4d215f39a4f4ea342aca6978f723ff9', '6bad715d29dce1f68968ab6d027828967e6701eac4bc37a2e3b77d2d00ceb078'] B "in order to use a tsn sub-network between detnet nodes, detnet specific information must be converted to tsn sub-network specific ones. detnet flow id and flow related parameters/requirements must be converted to a tsn stream id and stream related parameters/ requirements. note that, as the tsn sub-network is just a portion of the end2end detnet path (i.e., single hop from ip perspective), some parameters (e.g., delay) may differ significantly. other parameters (like bandwidth) also may have to be tuned due to the l2 encapsulation used within the tsn sub-network." {96: 1} {394: 1} {137, 394} 51 "In some case it may be challenging to determine some TSN Stream related information. For example, on a TSN-aware IP (DetNet) node that acts as a Talker, it is quite obvious which DetNet node is the Listener of the mapped TSN stream (i.e., the IP Next-Hop). However it may be not trivial to locate the point/interface where that Listener is connected to the TSN sub-network. Such attributes may require interaction between control and management plane functions and between DetNet and TSN domains." Reflecting the 9th September discussions . acd7cae2af60dfafe42acdd9936194decc735f93 acd7cae2af60dfafe42acdd9936194decc735f93 draft-ietf-detnet-ip-over-tsn 56f46f99aca1a85f26619e8380573a5f86ae014ec60ab1b5158a0967a0d4441a ['56f46f99aca1a85f26619e8380573a5f86ae014ec60ab1b5158a0967a0d4441a', 'f5a60a13bb46b3cce44df618c86626539a52d7da653dba2927f41e2f8ea94431', '8f1929ba526ebf5bf53f2b0a2ac0a68ed4d215f39a4f4ea342aca6978f723ff9', '6bad715d29dce1f68968ab6d027828967e6701eac4bc37a2e3b77d2d00ceb078'] B "in some case it may be challenging to determine some tsn stream related information. for example, on a tsn-aware ip (detnet) node that acts as a talker, it is quite obvious which detnet node is the listener of the mapped tsn stream (i.e., the ip next-hop). however it may be not trivial to locate the point/interface where that listener is connected to the tsn sub-network. such attributes may require interaction between control and management plane functions and between detnet and tsn domains." {96: 1} {394: 1} {137, 394} 51 "Mapping between DetNet flow identifiers and TSN Stream identifiers, if not provided explicitly, can be done by a TSN-aware IP (DetNet) node locally based on information provided for configuration of the TSN Stream identification functions (IP Stream identification and active Stream identification function)." Reflecting the 9th September discussions . acd7cae2af60dfafe42acdd9936194decc735f93 acd7cae2af60dfafe42acdd9936194decc735f93 draft-ietf-detnet-ip-over-tsn a295fe6e2d2503ddb2fc088917ba708d5169b8dbd95b8b2119bf925e4d4e39e2 ['a6bc7f3590ea628ade6e20cded358a300ff02a21e007aef1e4e22d4f0f2720bf', 'a295fe6e2d2503ddb2fc088917ba708d5169b8dbd95b8b2119bf925e4d4e39e2'] A "mapping between detnet flow identifiers and tsn stream identifiers, if not provided explicitly, can be done by a tsn-aware ip (detnet) node locally based on information provided for configuration of the tsn stream identification functions (ip stream identification and active stream identification function)." {} {} {} 51 "Mapping between DetNet flow identifiers and TSN Stream identifiers, if not provided explicitly, can be done by a TSN-aware IP (DetNet) node locally based on information provided for configuration of the TSN Stream identification functions (IP Stream identification, Mask- and-match Stream identification and active Stream identification function)." Reflecting the 9th September discussions . acd7cae2af60dfafe42acdd9936194decc735f93 acd7cae2af60dfafe42acdd9936194decc735f93 draft-ietf-detnet-ip-over-tsn a6bc7f3590ea628ade6e20cded358a300ff02a21e007aef1e4e22d4f0f2720bf ['a6bc7f3590ea628ade6e20cded358a300ff02a21e007aef1e4e22d4f0f2720bf', 'a295fe6e2d2503ddb2fc088917ba708d5169b8dbd95b8b2119bf925e4d4e39e2'] B "mapping between detnet flow identifiers and tsn stream identifiers, if not provided explicitly, can be done by a tsn-aware ip (detnet) node locally based on information provided for configuration of the tsn stream identification functions (ip stream identification, mask- and-match stream identification and active stream identification function)." {} {} {} 51 "Configuration of TSN specific functions (e.g., FRER) inside the TSN sub-network is a TSN specific decision and may not be visible in the DetNet domain." Reflecting the 9th September discussions . acd7cae2af60dfafe42acdd9936194decc735f93 acd7cae2af60dfafe42acdd9936194decc735f93 draft-ietf-detnet-ip-over-tsn 55d3df35d2a157e4274d9780ae3d59f30b5de1717dbbce46356996fd3a023de1 ['1a29b2af61888dcdf879c5b1658a76611aa2473aef9d4616dea8b73aea0cfa52', 'c69a0fa2ea5f12373344fafbdd44dfb7bb6dbc1860b1c5990feae2a465de298d', '55d3df35d2a157e4274d9780ae3d59f30b5de1717dbbce46356996fd3a023de1', 'bef1c83b3620d0cfd78ac49fdd158a63bffc682797718f741ee084306124fcf2'] A "configuration of tsn specific functions (e.g., frer) inside the tsn sub-network is a tsn specific decision and may not be visible in the detnet domain." {30: 1, 13: 1, 52: 1, 6: 3, 79: 3, 90: 2, 51: 2, 130: 2, 62: 4, 85: 5, 68: 5, 35: 4, 110: 3, 91: 4, 114: 3, 97: 2, 31: 3, 67: 3, 38: 4, 26: 3, 124: 4, 98: 3, 54: 3, 127: 4, 8: 3, 96: 2, 64: 2, 61: 5, 55: 4, 27: 4, 15: 2, 129: 4, 115: 2, 84: 3, 76: 7, 87: 3, 131: 6, 102: 2, 113: 5, 99: 3, 36: 2, 24: 2, 53: 2, 72: 4} {129: 1, 315: 1, 156: 1, 1: 10, 4: 3, 9: 6, 10: 4, 15: 2, 24: 3, 25: 4, 26: 5, 39: 6, 43: 4, 49: 5, 50: 4, 58: 5, 59: 3, 64: 2, 69: 5, 81: 5, 82: 3, 86: 3, 96: 4, 97: 3, 100: 6, 108: 4, 109: 5, 110: 5, 111: 3, 114: 4, 115: 5, 116: 2, 118: 7, 119: 6, 120: 4, 121: 5, 122: 3, 123: 2, 124: 5, 128: 2, 130: 5, 132: 5, 136: 3, 145: 5, 147: 4, 151: 2, 152: 3, 154: 4, 161: 4, 162: 4, 165: 4, 168: 5, 169: 2, 172: 3, 180: 3, 184: 6, 187: 6, 188: 5, 191: 4, 194: 5, 202: 6, 203: 7, 206: 3, 207: 4, 215: 3, 217: 4, 218: 9, 220: 3, 221: 3, 222: 6, 224: 4, 227: 4, 229: 3, 234: 6, 235: 3, 241: 3, 242: 3, 243: 5, 244: 3, 245: 5, 248: 3, 250: 3, 258: 12, 262: 5, 263: 6, 264: 4, 267: 5, 270: 2, 272: 2, 273: 6, 287: 4, 289: 3, 291: 5, 299: 4, 300: 2, 304: 2, 309: 4, 314: 3, 320: 5, 323: 5, 327: 5, 328: 4, 329: 3, 330: 11, 334: 3, 335: 2, 341: 4, 342: 5, 347: 4, 348: 4, 350: 8, 351: 4, 352: 2, 353: 2, 354: 2, 358: 5, 365: 3, 366: 3, 369: 2, 371: 6, 372: 5, 376: 3, 384: 5, 385: 4, 386: 4, 387: 2, 392: 4, 393: 5, 396: 5, 397: 8, 398: 7, 402: 2} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 51 "The security considerations of DetNet in general are discussed in I- D.ietf-detnet-architecture and I-D.ietf-detnet-security. Other security considerations will be added in a future version of this draft." Reflecting the 9th September discussions . acd7cae2af60dfafe42acdd9936194decc735f93 acd7cae2af60dfafe42acdd9936194decc735f93 draft-ietf-detnet-ip-over-tsn bef1c83b3620d0cfd78ac49fdd158a63bffc682797718f741ee084306124fcf2 ['1a29b2af61888dcdf879c5b1658a76611aa2473aef9d4616dea8b73aea0cfa52', 'c69a0fa2ea5f12373344fafbdd44dfb7bb6dbc1860b1c5990feae2a465de298d', '55d3df35d2a157e4274d9780ae3d59f30b5de1717dbbce46356996fd3a023de1', 'bef1c83b3620d0cfd78ac49fdd158a63bffc682797718f741ee084306124fcf2'] A "the security considerations of detnet in general are discussed in i- d.ietf-detnet-architecture and i-d.ietf-detnet-security. other security considerations will be added in a future version of this draft." {30: 1, 13: 1, 52: 1, 6: 3, 79: 3, 90: 2, 51: 2, 130: 2, 62: 4, 85: 5, 68: 5, 35: 4, 110: 3, 91: 4, 114: 3, 97: 2, 31: 3, 67: 3, 38: 4, 26: 3, 124: 4, 98: 3, 54: 3, 127: 4, 8: 3, 96: 2, 64: 2, 61: 5, 55: 4, 27: 4, 15: 2, 129: 4, 115: 2, 84: 3, 76: 7, 87: 3, 131: 6, 102: 2, 113: 5, 99: 3, 36: 2, 24: 2, 53: 2, 72: 4} {129: 1, 315: 1, 156: 1, 1: 10, 4: 3, 9: 6, 10: 4, 15: 2, 24: 3, 25: 4, 26: 5, 39: 6, 43: 4, 49: 5, 50: 4, 58: 5, 59: 3, 64: 2, 69: 5, 81: 5, 82: 3, 86: 3, 96: 4, 97: 3, 100: 6, 108: 4, 109: 5, 110: 5, 111: 3, 114: 4, 115: 5, 116: 2, 118: 7, 119: 6, 120: 4, 121: 5, 122: 3, 123: 2, 124: 5, 128: 2, 130: 5, 132: 5, 136: 3, 145: 5, 147: 4, 151: 2, 152: 3, 154: 4, 161: 4, 162: 4, 165: 4, 168: 5, 169: 2, 172: 3, 180: 3, 184: 6, 187: 6, 188: 5, 191: 4, 194: 5, 202: 6, 203: 7, 206: 3, 207: 4, 215: 3, 217: 4, 218: 9, 220: 3, 221: 3, 222: 6, 224: 4, 227: 4, 229: 3, 234: 6, 235: 3, 241: 3, 242: 3, 243: 5, 244: 3, 245: 5, 248: 3, 250: 3, 258: 12, 262: 5, 263: 6, 264: 4, 267: 5, 270: 2, 272: 2, 273: 6, 287: 4, 289: 3, 291: 5, 299: 4, 300: 2, 304: 2, 309: 4, 314: 3, 320: 5, 323: 5, 327: 5, 328: 4, 329: 3, 330: 11, 334: 3, 335: 2, 341: 4, 342: 5, 347: 4, 348: 4, 350: 8, 351: 4, 352: 2, 353: 2, 354: 2, 358: 5, 365: 3, 366: 3, 369: 2, 371: 6, 372: 5, 376: 3, 384: 5, 385: 4, 386: 4, 387: 2, 392: 4, 393: 5, 396: 5, 397: 8, 398: 7, 402: 2} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 51 "Configuration of TSN specific functions (e.g., FRER) inside the TSN sub-network is a TSN domain specific decision and may not be visible in the DetNet domain." Reflecting the 9th September discussions . acd7cae2af60dfafe42acdd9936194decc735f93 acd7cae2af60dfafe42acdd9936194decc735f93 draft-ietf-detnet-ip-over-tsn 1a29b2af61888dcdf879c5b1658a76611aa2473aef9d4616dea8b73aea0cfa52 ['1a29b2af61888dcdf879c5b1658a76611aa2473aef9d4616dea8b73aea0cfa52', 'c69a0fa2ea5f12373344fafbdd44dfb7bb6dbc1860b1c5990feae2a465de298d', '55d3df35d2a157e4274d9780ae3d59f30b5de1717dbbce46356996fd3a023de1', 'bef1c83b3620d0cfd78ac49fdd158a63bffc682797718f741ee084306124fcf2'] B "configuration of tsn specific functions (e.g., frer) inside the tsn sub-network is a tsn domain specific decision and may not be visible in the detnet domain." {30: 1, 13: 1, 52: 1, 6: 3, 79: 3, 90: 2, 51: 2, 130: 2, 62: 4, 85: 5, 68: 5, 35: 4, 110: 3, 91: 4, 114: 3, 97: 2, 31: 3, 67: 3, 38: 4, 26: 3, 124: 4, 98: 3, 54: 3, 127: 4, 8: 3, 96: 2, 64: 2, 61: 5, 55: 4, 27: 4, 15: 2, 129: 4, 115: 2, 84: 3, 76: 7, 87: 3, 131: 6, 102: 2, 113: 5, 99: 3, 36: 2, 24: 2, 53: 2, 72: 4} {129: 1, 315: 1, 156: 1, 1: 10, 4: 3, 9: 6, 10: 4, 15: 2, 24: 3, 25: 4, 26: 5, 39: 6, 43: 4, 49: 5, 50: 4, 58: 5, 59: 3, 64: 2, 69: 5, 81: 5, 82: 3, 86: 3, 96: 4, 97: 3, 100: 6, 108: 4, 109: 5, 110: 5, 111: 3, 114: 4, 115: 5, 116: 2, 118: 7, 119: 6, 120: 4, 121: 5, 122: 3, 123: 2, 124: 5, 128: 2, 130: 5, 132: 5, 136: 3, 145: 5, 147: 4, 151: 2, 152: 3, 154: 4, 161: 4, 162: 4, 165: 4, 168: 5, 169: 2, 172: 3, 180: 3, 184: 6, 187: 6, 188: 5, 191: 4, 194: 5, 202: 6, 203: 7, 206: 3, 207: 4, 215: 3, 217: 4, 218: 9, 220: 3, 221: 3, 222: 6, 224: 4, 227: 4, 229: 3, 234: 6, 235: 3, 241: 3, 242: 3, 243: 5, 244: 3, 245: 5, 248: 3, 250: 3, 258: 12, 262: 5, 263: 6, 264: 4, 267: 5, 270: 2, 272: 2, 273: 6, 287: 4, 289: 3, 291: 5, 299: 4, 300: 2, 304: 2, 309: 4, 314: 3, 320: 5, 323: 5, 327: 5, 328: 4, 329: 3, 330: 11, 334: 3, 335: 2, 341: 4, 342: 5, 347: 4, 348: 4, 350: 8, 351: 4, 352: 2, 353: 2, 354: 2, 358: 5, 365: 3, 366: 3, 369: 2, 371: 6, 372: 5, 376: 3, 384: 5, 385: 4, 386: 4, 387: 2, 392: 4, 393: 5, 396: 5, 397: 8, 398: 7, 402: 2} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 51 "The security considerations of DetNet in general are discussed in I- D.ietf-detnet-architecture and I-D.ietf-detnet-security. DetNet IP data plane specific considerations are summarized in I-D.ietf-detnet- ip. Encryption may provided by an underlying sub-net using MACSec IEEE802.1AE-2018 for DetNet IP over TSN flows." Reflecting the 9th September discussions . acd7cae2af60dfafe42acdd9936194decc735f93 acd7cae2af60dfafe42acdd9936194decc735f93 draft-ietf-detnet-ip-over-tsn c69a0fa2ea5f12373344fafbdd44dfb7bb6dbc1860b1c5990feae2a465de298d ['1a29b2af61888dcdf879c5b1658a76611aa2473aef9d4616dea8b73aea0cfa52', 'c69a0fa2ea5f12373344fafbdd44dfb7bb6dbc1860b1c5990feae2a465de298d', '55d3df35d2a157e4274d9780ae3d59f30b5de1717dbbce46356996fd3a023de1', 'bef1c83b3620d0cfd78ac49fdd158a63bffc682797718f741ee084306124fcf2'] B "the security considerations of detnet in general are discussed in i- d.ietf-detnet-architecture and i-d.ietf-detnet-security. detnet ip data plane specific considerations are summarized in i-d.ietf-detnet- ip. encryption may provided by an underlying sub-net using macsec ieee802.1ae-2018 for detnet ip over tsn flows." {30: 1, 13: 1, 52: 1, 6: 3, 79: 3, 90: 2, 51: 2, 130: 2, 62: 4, 85: 5, 68: 5, 35: 4, 110: 3, 91: 4, 114: 3, 97: 2, 31: 3, 67: 3, 38: 4, 26: 3, 124: 4, 98: 3, 54: 3, 127: 4, 8: 3, 96: 2, 64: 2, 61: 5, 55: 4, 27: 4, 15: 2, 129: 4, 115: 2, 84: 3, 76: 7, 87: 3, 131: 6, 102: 2, 113: 5, 99: 3, 36: 2, 24: 2, 53: 2, 72: 4} {129: 1, 315: 1, 156: 1, 1: 10, 4: 3, 9: 6, 10: 4, 15: 2, 24: 3, 25: 4, 26: 5, 39: 6, 43: 4, 49: 5, 50: 4, 58: 5, 59: 3, 64: 2, 69: 5, 81: 5, 82: 3, 86: 3, 96: 4, 97: 3, 100: 6, 108: 4, 109: 5, 110: 5, 111: 3, 114: 4, 115: 5, 116: 2, 118: 7, 119: 6, 120: 4, 121: 5, 122: 3, 123: 2, 124: 5, 128: 2, 130: 5, 132: 5, 136: 3, 145: 5, 147: 4, 151: 2, 152: 3, 154: 4, 161: 4, 162: 4, 165: 4, 168: 5, 169: 2, 172: 3, 180: 3, 184: 6, 187: 6, 188: 5, 191: 4, 194: 5, 202: 6, 203: 7, 206: 3, 207: 4, 215: 3, 217: 4, 218: 9, 220: 3, 221: 3, 222: 6, 224: 4, 227: 4, 229: 3, 234: 6, 235: 3, 241: 3, 242: 3, 243: 5, 244: 3, 245: 5, 248: 3, 250: 3, 258: 12, 262: 5, 263: 6, 264: 4, 267: 5, 270: 2, 272: 2, 273: 6, 287: 4, 289: 3, 291: 5, 299: 4, 300: 2, 304: 2, 309: 4, 314: 3, 320: 5, 323: 5, 327: 5, 328: 4, 329: 3, 330: 11, 334: 3, 335: 2, 341: 4, 342: 5, 347: 4, 348: 4, 350: 8, 351: 4, 352: 2, 353: 2, 354: 2, 358: 5, 365: 3, 366: 3, 369: 2, 371: 6, 372: 5, 376: 3, 384: 5, 385: 4, 386: 4, 387: 2, 392: 4, 393: 5, 396: 5, 397: 8, 398: 7, 402: 2} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 38 "A DetNet relay node (ingress T-PE) that sends a DetNet IP flow over a DetNet MPLS network MUST map that single DetNet IP flow into a single MPLS DetNet flow and MUST process it in accordance to the procedures defined in I-D.ietf-detnet-mpls Section 6.1. PRF MAY be supported for DetNet IP flows sent over an DetNet MPLS network. Aggregation MAY be supported as defined in I-D.ietf-detnet-mpls Section 5.4. Aggregation considerations in I-D.ietf-detnet-ip MAY be used to identify an individual DetNet IP flow. The provisioning of the mapping of DetNet IP flows to DetNet MPLS flows MUST be supported via configuration, e.g., via the controller plane." mpls - over - ip : minor tweaks ipOmpls : Section 6 , Management and Control Information Summary mpls : editorial changes , refactoring of section 5 for clarity and completeness white space cleanup ( remove tabs and trailing spaces ) 6eef101c3c863f944da82ed2f9cc38205de8aa61 6eef101c3c863f944da82ed2f9cc38205de8aa61 draft-ietf-detnet-ip-over-mpls ffd22f695a795e8de8863948886b4b3a104567e08c2619b39373d17862a6caa1 ['ffd22f695a795e8de8863948886b4b3a104567e08c2619b39373d17862a6caa1', '761b1f644f5fd8372e1b54b441e473a079c1cc3b5d9682281bfa60336852a64e'] A "a detnet relay node (ingress t-pe) that sends a detnet ip flow over a detnet mpls network must map that single detnet ip flow into a single mpls detnet flow and must process it in accordance to the procedures defined in i-d.ietf-detnet-mpls section 6.1. prf may be supported for detnet ip flows sent over an detnet mpls network. aggregation may be supported as defined in i-d.ietf-detnet-mpls section 5.4. aggregation considerations in i-d.ietf-detnet-ip may be used to identify an individual detnet ip flow. the provisioning of the mapping of detnet ip flows to detnet mpls flows must be supported via configuration, e.g., via the controller plane." {30: 1, 69: 1, 63: 2, 38: 2, 118: 3} {103: 1, 401: 1, 102: 2, 175: 2, 407: 3, 62: 3} {414, 102, 103, 175, 401, 407, 62} 38 "A DetNet relay node (ingress T-PE) that sends a DetNet IP flow over a DetNet MPLS network MUST map a DetNet IP flow, as identified in I- D.ietf-detnet-ip into a single MPLS DetNet flow and MUST process it in accordance to the procedures defined in I-D.ietf-detnet-mpls Section 6.1. PRF MAY be supported at the MPLS level for DetNet IP flows sent over an DetNet MPLS network. Aggregation MAY be supported as defined in I-D.ietf-detnet-mpls Section 5.4. Aggregation considerations in I-D.ietf-detnet-ip MAY be used to identify an individual DetNet IP flow. The provisioning of the mapping of DetNet IP flows to DetNet MPLS flows MUST be supported via configuration, e.g., via the controller plane." mpls - over - ip : minor tweaks ipOmpls : Section 6 , Management and Control Information Summary mpls : editorial changes , refactoring of section 5 for clarity and completeness white space cleanup ( remove tabs and trailing spaces ) 6eef101c3c863f944da82ed2f9cc38205de8aa61 6eef101c3c863f944da82ed2f9cc38205de8aa61 draft-ietf-detnet-ip-over-mpls 761b1f644f5fd8372e1b54b441e473a079c1cc3b5d9682281bfa60336852a64e ['ffd22f695a795e8de8863948886b4b3a104567e08c2619b39373d17862a6caa1', '761b1f644f5fd8372e1b54b441e473a079c1cc3b5d9682281bfa60336852a64e'] B "a detnet relay node (ingress t-pe) that sends a detnet ip flow over a detnet mpls network must map a detnet ip flow, as identified in i- d.ietf-detnet-ip into a single mpls detnet flow and must process it in accordance to the procedures defined in i-d.ietf-detnet-mpls section 6.1. prf may be supported at the mpls level for detnet ip flows sent over an detnet mpls network. aggregation may be supported as defined in i-d.ietf-detnet-mpls section 5.4. aggregation considerations in i-d.ietf-detnet-ip may be used to identify an individual detnet ip flow. the provisioning of the mapping of detnet ip flows to detnet mpls flows must be supported via configuration, e.g., via the controller plane." {30: 1, 69: 1, 63: 2, 38: 2, 118: 3} {103: 1, 401: 1, 102: 2, 175: 2, 407: 3, 62: 3} {414, 102, 103, 175, 401, 407, 62} 38 "A DetNet relay node (egress T-PE) MAY be provisioned to handle packets received via the DetNet MPLS data plane as DetNet IP flows. A single incoming DetNet MPLS flow MAY be treated as a single DetNet IP flow, without examination of IP headers. Alternatively, packets received via the DetNet MPLS data plane MAY follow the normal DetNet IP flow identification procedures defined in I-D.ietf-detnet-ip Section 7.1. An implementation MUST support the provisioning for handling any received DetNet MPLS data plane as DetNet IP flows via configuration. Note that such configuration MAY include support from PEOF on the incoming DetNet MPLS flow." mpls - over - ip : minor tweaks ipOmpls : Section 6 , Management and Control Information Summary mpls : editorial changes , refactoring of section 5 for clarity and completeness white space cleanup ( remove tabs and trailing spaces ) 6eef101c3c863f944da82ed2f9cc38205de8aa61 6eef101c3c863f944da82ed2f9cc38205de8aa61 draft-ietf-detnet-ip-over-mpls 6f2f124c450ca96906041a92399b6f8e16cb4a3f86db153a7678aec0d7537634 ['6f2f124c450ca96906041a92399b6f8e16cb4a3f86db153a7678aec0d7537634', '48021bb0dc65be3a24f669cc5d3b055b74a408d0225c7294bceafb6b3299b4c3', '45bad6139846a5f50679742f54023cff55efc88bca3176c14f972e49165457f7'] A "a detnet relay node (egress t-pe) may be provisioned to handle packets received via the detnet mpls data plane as detnet ip flows. a single incoming detnet mpls flow may be treated as a single detnet ip flow, without examination of ip headers. alternatively, packets received via the detnet mpls data plane may follow the normal detnet ip flow identification procedures defined in i-d.ietf-detnet-ip section 7.1. an implementation must support the provisioning for handling any received detnet mpls data plane as detnet ip flows via configuration. note that such configuration may include support from peof on the incoming detnet mpls flow." {63: 1, 30: 1, 69: 1, 38: 2, 118: 2} {102: 1, 103: 1, 407: 1, 414: 2, 401: 3, 62: 2} {414, 102, 103, 175, 401, 407, 62} 38 "A DetNet relay node (egress T-PE) MAY be provisioned to handle packets received via the DetNet MPLS data plane as DetNet IP flows. A single incoming DetNet MPLS flow MAY be treated as a single DetNet IP flow, without examination of IP headers. Alternatively, packets received via the DetNet MPLS data plane MAY follow the normal DetNet IP flow identification procedures defined in I-D.ietf-detnet-ip Section 7.1." mpls - over - ip : minor tweaks ipOmpls : Section 6 , Management and Control Information Summary mpls : editorial changes , refactoring of section 5 for clarity and completeness white space cleanup ( remove tabs and trailing spaces ) 6eef101c3c863f944da82ed2f9cc38205de8aa61 6eef101c3c863f944da82ed2f9cc38205de8aa61 draft-ietf-detnet-ip-over-mpls 45bad6139846a5f50679742f54023cff55efc88bca3176c14f972e49165457f7 ['6f2f124c450ca96906041a92399b6f8e16cb4a3f86db153a7678aec0d7537634', '48021bb0dc65be3a24f669cc5d3b055b74a408d0225c7294bceafb6b3299b4c3', '45bad6139846a5f50679742f54023cff55efc88bca3176c14f972e49165457f7'] B "a detnet relay node (egress t-pe) may be provisioned to handle packets received via the detnet mpls data plane as detnet ip flows. a single incoming detnet mpls flow may be treated as a single detnet ip flow, without examination of ip headers. alternatively, packets received via the detnet mpls data plane may follow the normal detnet ip flow identification procedures defined in i-d.ietf-detnet-ip section 7.1." {63: 1, 30: 1, 69: 1, 38: 2, 118: 2} {102: 1, 103: 1, 407: 1, 414: 2, 401: 3, 62: 2} {414, 102, 103, 175, 401, 407, 62} 38 "An implementation MUST support the provisioning for handling any received DetNet MPLS data plane as DetNet IP flows via configuration. Note that such configuration MAY include support from PEOF on the incoming DetNet MPLS flow." mpls - over - ip : minor tweaks ipOmpls : Section 6 , Management and Control Information Summary mpls : editorial changes , refactoring of section 5 for clarity and completeness white space cleanup ( remove tabs and trailing spaces ) 6eef101c3c863f944da82ed2f9cc38205de8aa61 6eef101c3c863f944da82ed2f9cc38205de8aa61 draft-ietf-detnet-ip-over-mpls 48021bb0dc65be3a24f669cc5d3b055b74a408d0225c7294bceafb6b3299b4c3 ['6f2f124c450ca96906041a92399b6f8e16cb4a3f86db153a7678aec0d7537634', '48021bb0dc65be3a24f669cc5d3b055b74a408d0225c7294bceafb6b3299b4c3', '45bad6139846a5f50679742f54023cff55efc88bca3176c14f972e49165457f7'] B "an implementation must support the provisioning for handling any received detnet mpls data plane as detnet ip flows via configuration. note that such configuration may include support from peof on the incoming detnet mpls flow." {63: 1, 30: 1, 69: 1, 38: 2, 118: 2} {102: 1, 103: 1, 407: 1, 414: 2, 401: 3, 62: 2} {414, 102, 103, 175, 401, 407, 62} 38 "Each MPLS App-Flow is identified using the IP flow identification information as defined in I-D.ietf-detnet-ip. The information is summarized in Section 6 of that document, and includes all wildcards, port ranges and ability to ignore specific IP fields." mpls - over - ip : minor tweaks ipOmpls : Section 6 , Management and Control Information Summary mpls : editorial changes , refactoring of section 5 for clarity and completeness white space cleanup ( remove tabs and trailing spaces ) 6eef101c3c863f944da82ed2f9cc38205de8aa61 6eef101c3c863f944da82ed2f9cc38205de8aa61 draft-ietf-detnet-ip-over-mpls 9a91fa91ba6f43a82ddbc51a7f55cbcb68b1bc3b9a29e883764f4b8d92c2587c ['9a91fa91ba6f43a82ddbc51a7f55cbcb68b1bc3b9a29e883764f4b8d92c2587c', '2d3604634df02aaed8f0295157bc9d0fb95d22f60d687e2de089f06a75c49189', 'd0403b23d4b8741cc42d72b22fa4a6a47b0933cefbb68a8c0c8d1fa5027cae00', '0f117588fdc21825cb3c8b18e8c2f35be3b4616416784fa6a551a38ba5d6966b'] B "each mpls app-flow is identified using the ip flow identification information as defined in i-d.ietf-detnet-ip. the information is summarized in section 6 of that document, and includes all wildcards, port ranges and ability to ignore specific ip fields." {63: 1} {240: 1} {240, 239} 38 "The DetNet MPLS service that is to be used to send the matching IP traffic. Logically this is a pointer to the information provided in I-D.ietf-detnet-mpls Section 5.1, and includes both service and traffic delivery information." mpls - over - ip : minor tweaks ipOmpls : Section 6 , Management and Control Information Summary mpls : editorial changes , refactoring of section 5 for clarity and completeness white space cleanup ( remove tabs and trailing spaces ) 6eef101c3c863f944da82ed2f9cc38205de8aa61 6eef101c3c863f944da82ed2f9cc38205de8aa61 draft-ietf-detnet-ip-over-mpls 0f117588fdc21825cb3c8b18e8c2f35be3b4616416784fa6a551a38ba5d6966b ['9a91fa91ba6f43a82ddbc51a7f55cbcb68b1bc3b9a29e883764f4b8d92c2587c', '2d3604634df02aaed8f0295157bc9d0fb95d22f60d687e2de089f06a75c49189', 'd0403b23d4b8741cc42d72b22fa4a6a47b0933cefbb68a8c0c8d1fa5027cae00', '0f117588fdc21825cb3c8b18e8c2f35be3b4616416784fa6a551a38ba5d6966b'] B "the detnet mpls service that is to be used to send the matching ip traffic. logically this is a pointer to the information provided in i-d.ietf-detnet-mpls section 5.1, and includes both service and traffic delivery information." {63: 1} {240: 1} {240, 239} 38 "S-Label values that are carrying MPLS over IP encapsulated traffic." mpls - over - ip : minor tweaks ipOmpls : Section 6 , Management and Control Information Summary mpls : editorial changes , refactoring of section 5 for clarity and completeness white space cleanup ( remove tabs and trailing spaces ) 6eef101c3c863f944da82ed2f9cc38205de8aa61 6eef101c3c863f944da82ed2f9cc38205de8aa61 draft-ietf-detnet-ip-over-mpls 2d3604634df02aaed8f0295157bc9d0fb95d22f60d687e2de089f06a75c49189 ['9a91fa91ba6f43a82ddbc51a7f55cbcb68b1bc3b9a29e883764f4b8d92c2587c', '2d3604634df02aaed8f0295157bc9d0fb95d22f60d687e2de089f06a75c49189', 'd0403b23d4b8741cc42d72b22fa4a6a47b0933cefbb68a8c0c8d1fa5027cae00', '0f117588fdc21825cb3c8b18e8c2f35be3b4616416784fa6a551a38ba5d6966b'] B "s-label values that are carrying mpls over ip encapsulated traffic." {63: 1} {240: 1} {240, 239} 38 "For each S-Label, how the received traffic is to be handled. The traffic may be processed according as any other DetNet IP traffic as defined in this document or in I-D.ietf-detnet-ip, or the traffic may be directly treated as an MPLS App-flow for additional processing according to I-D.ietf-detnet-mpls." mpls - over - ip : minor tweaks ipOmpls : Section 6 , Management and Control Information Summary mpls : editorial changes , refactoring of section 5 for clarity and completeness white space cleanup ( remove tabs and trailing spaces ) 6eef101c3c863f944da82ed2f9cc38205de8aa61 6eef101c3c863f944da82ed2f9cc38205de8aa61 draft-ietf-detnet-ip-over-mpls d0403b23d4b8741cc42d72b22fa4a6a47b0933cefbb68a8c0c8d1fa5027cae00 ['9a91fa91ba6f43a82ddbc51a7f55cbcb68b1bc3b9a29e883764f4b8d92c2587c', '2d3604634df02aaed8f0295157bc9d0fb95d22f60d687e2de089f06a75c49189', 'd0403b23d4b8741cc42d72b22fa4a6a47b0933cefbb68a8c0c8d1fa5027cae00', '0f117588fdc21825cb3c8b18e8c2f35be3b4616416784fa6a551a38ba5d6966b'] B "for each s-label, how the received traffic is to be handled. the traffic may be processed according as any other detnet ip traffic as defined in this document or in i-d.ietf-detnet-ip, or the traffic may be directly treated as an mpls app-flow for additional processing according to i-d.ietf-detnet-mpls." {63: 1} {240: 1} {240, 239} 38 "This document specifies the MPLS Deterministic Networking data plane operation and encapsulation over an IP network. The approach is modeled on the operation of MPLS and PseudoWires (PW) over IP." mpls - over - ip : minor tweaks ipOmpls : Section 6 , Management and Control Information Summary mpls : editorial changes , refactoring of section 5 for clarity and completeness white space cleanup ( remove tabs and trailing spaces ) 6eef101c3c863f944da82ed2f9cc38205de8aa61 6eef101c3c863f944da82ed2f9cc38205de8aa61 draft-ietf-detnet-mpls-over-udp-ip 723973bab0efbf13e560b6b4207070af1b06215ce1c224acb878ea83734b6da2 ['33554b9bc0f2b69c37913c3670f608d02603f8976f7d043fff518b56c3cd70bc', '723973bab0efbf13e560b6b4207070af1b06215ce1c224acb878ea83734b6da2'] A "this document specifies the mpls deterministic networking data plane operation and encapsulation over an ip network. the approach is modeled on the operation of mpls and pseudowires (pw) over ip." {129: 1} {70: 1} {70, 71} 38 "This document specifies the MPLS Deterministic Networking data plane operation and encapsulation over an IP network. The approach is modeled on the operation of MPLS and over UDP/IP packet switched networks." mpls - over - ip : minor tweaks ipOmpls : Section 6 , Management and Control Information Summary mpls : editorial changes , refactoring of section 5 for clarity and completeness white space cleanup ( remove tabs and trailing spaces ) 6eef101c3c863f944da82ed2f9cc38205de8aa61 6eef101c3c863f944da82ed2f9cc38205de8aa61 draft-ietf-detnet-mpls-over-udp-ip 33554b9bc0f2b69c37913c3670f608d02603f8976f7d043fff518b56c3cd70bc ['33554b9bc0f2b69c37913c3670f608d02603f8976f7d043fff518b56c3cd70bc', '723973bab0efbf13e560b6b4207070af1b06215ce1c224acb878ea83734b6da2'] B "this document specifies the mpls deterministic networking data plane operation and encapsulation over an ip network. the approach is modeled on the operation of mpls and over udp/ip packet switched networks." {129: 1} {70: 1} {70, 71} 38 "This document specifies use of the MPLS DetNet encapsulation over an IP network. The approach is modeled on the operation of MPLS and PseudoWires (PW) over an IP Packet Switched Network (PSN) RFC7510. It maps the MPLS data plane encapsulation described in I-D.ietf- detnet-mpls to the DetNet IP data plane defined in I-D.ietf-detnet- ip." mpls - over - ip : minor tweaks ipOmpls : Section 6 , Management and Control Information Summary mpls : editorial changes , refactoring of section 5 for clarity and completeness white space cleanup ( remove tabs and trailing spaces ) 6eef101c3c863f944da82ed2f9cc38205de8aa61 6eef101c3c863f944da82ed2f9cc38205de8aa61 draft-ietf-detnet-mpls-over-udp-ip 775508da03eabfde1a3fbbe5e0ae5164e014309e39cbc27545ba1408574dfe65 ['775508da03eabfde1a3fbbe5e0ae5164e014309e39cbc27545ba1408574dfe65', '48cb8e0d4b6adf68b1c0c3cd327de49d6ab17e6cd3422b8bcfb4361cf040e7d2'] A "this document specifies use of the mpls detnet encapsulation over an ip network. the approach is modeled on the operation of mpls and pseudowires (pw) over an ip packet switched network (psn) rfc7510. it maps the mpls data plane encapsulation described in i-d.ietf- detnet-mpls to the detnet ip data plane defined in i-d.ietf-detnet- ip." {} {} {} 38 "This document specifies use of the MPLS DetNet encapsulation over an IP network. The approach is modeled on the operation of MPLS over an IP Packet Switched Network (PSN) RFC7510. It maps the MPLS data plane encapsulation described in I-D.ietf-detnet-mpls to the DetNet IP data plane defined in I-D.ietf-detnet-ip." mpls - over - ip : minor tweaks ipOmpls : Section 6 , Management and Control Information Summary mpls : editorial changes , refactoring of section 5 for clarity and completeness white space cleanup ( remove tabs and trailing spaces ) 6eef101c3c863f944da82ed2f9cc38205de8aa61 6eef101c3c863f944da82ed2f9cc38205de8aa61 draft-ietf-detnet-mpls-over-udp-ip 48cb8e0d4b6adf68b1c0c3cd327de49d6ab17e6cd3422b8bcfb4361cf040e7d2 ['775508da03eabfde1a3fbbe5e0ae5164e014309e39cbc27545ba1408574dfe65', '48cb8e0d4b6adf68b1c0c3cd327de49d6ab17e6cd3422b8bcfb4361cf040e7d2'] B "this document specifies use of the mpls detnet encapsulation over an ip network. the approach is modeled on the operation of mpls over an ip packet switched network (psn) rfc7510. it maps the mpls data plane encapsulation described in i-d.ietf-detnet-mpls to the detnet ip data plane defined in i-d.ietf-detnet-ip." {} {} {} 38 PseudoWire. mpls - over - ip : minor tweaks ipOmpls : Section 6 , Management and Control Information Summary mpls : editorial changes , refactoring of section 5 for clarity and completeness white space cleanup ( remove tabs and trailing spaces ) 6eef101c3c863f944da82ed2f9cc38205de8aa61 6eef101c3c863f944da82ed2f9cc38205de8aa61 draft-ietf-detnet-mpls-over-udp-ip 5da7ebc4953e83090f06af6e486dc3a244576cd2b94ec353133be3ced3251dcd ['5da7ebc4953e83090f06af6e486dc3a244576cd2b94ec353133be3ced3251dcd'] A pseudowire. {68: 1, 130: 4, 79: 2, 51: 2, 112: 2, 55: 2, 64: 2, 62: 3, 37: 2, 38: 3, 69: 2, 67: 3, 33: 2, 25: 2, 53: 3, 80: 3, 52: 2, 127: 5, 91: 2} {279: 1, 0: 4, 389: 3, 390: 3, 135: 2, 142: 2, 14: 2, 400: 3, 17: 2, 399: 4, 19: 3, 406: 2, 280: 2, 281: 4, 278: 2, 294: 2, 296: 2, 45: 3, 308: 2, 56: 3, 185: 3, 192: 3, 321: 2, 322: 3, 66: 3, 196: 6, 197: 5, 324: 2, 77: 2, 78: 2, 337: 5, 216: 2, 380: 3, 255: 4} {0, 389, 390, 135, 142, 14, 400, 17, 399, 19, 149, 406, 279, 280, 281, 278, 294, 296, 45, 308, 56, 185, 192, 321, 322, 66, 196, 197, 324, 77, 78, 337, 216, 380, 255} 38 "d-CW and and S-Labels are used as defined in I-D.ietf-detnet-mpls and are not modified by this document. In case of aggregates the A-Label is treated as an S-Label and it is not modified as well." mpls - over - ip : minor tweaks ipOmpls : Section 6 , Management and Control Information Summary mpls : editorial changes , refactoring of section 5 for clarity and completeness white space cleanup ( remove tabs and trailing spaces ) 6eef101c3c863f944da82ed2f9cc38205de8aa61 6eef101c3c863f944da82ed2f9cc38205de8aa61 draft-ietf-detnet-mpls-over-udp-ip de2bfc728b108f6557f3d6959cec4db6d9e50adedb70a22939a16f29cf1e241b ['87a3de23bdd1c53a746e7a7cfa7e3580fd250a5617cc917dab59828f4f4ebc50', 'de2bfc728b108f6557f3d6959cec4db6d9e50adedb70a22939a16f29cf1e241b', '9d16780139ac5a5bcc5887b86d737bec08525c621de153cecbe258b0f310cab1', 'd5b29348bd685f249f0739f769413f01a84804f106345439899be82b4b06c21d', '651e341460abb4f56484b2921abfc1e41250a07075e5c89fa4decd74cfa782be', '75e1b9b6b6c2e723fb5593a62465d328747fe29245449a4233a49cd981a5e16d'] A "d-cw and and s-labels are used as defined in i-d.ietf-detnet-mpls and are not modified by this document. in case of aggregates the a-label is treated as an s-label and it is not modified as well." {33: 1, 71: 1, 64: 1, 60: 3, 56: 2, 102: 2, 62: 3, 26: 2, 32: 2, 83: 3, 113: 2, 38: 2, 126: 2, 112: 2, 85: 3, 129: 2} {31: 1, 377: 1, 339: 1, 343: 1, 260: 3, 261: 2, 274: 2, 283: 3, 286: 2, 32: 2, 33: 2, 163: 3, 228: 2, 357: 2, 166: 2, 231: 2, 298: 2, 363: 3, 46: 2} {260, 261, 274, 283, 286, 31, 32, 33, 163, 166, 298, 46, 339, 212, 343, 228, 357, 231, 363, 377} 38 "To support outgoing DetNet MPLS over UDP/IP, an implementation MUST support the provisioning of UDP/IP header information in addition or in place of F-Label(s). The headers for each outgoing packet MUST be based on the configuration information and as defined in RFC7510, with one exception. The one exception is that the UDP Source Port value MUST be set to uniquely identify the DetNet flow. The packet MUST then be handed as a DetNet IP packet, per I-D.ietf-detnet-ip." mpls - over - ip : minor tweaks ipOmpls : Section 6 , Management and Control Information Summary mpls : editorial changes , refactoring of section 5 for clarity and completeness white space cleanup ( remove tabs and trailing spaces ) 6eef101c3c863f944da82ed2f9cc38205de8aa61 6eef101c3c863f944da82ed2f9cc38205de8aa61 draft-ietf-detnet-mpls-over-udp-ip 87a3de23bdd1c53a746e7a7cfa7e3580fd250a5617cc917dab59828f4f4ebc50 ['87a3de23bdd1c53a746e7a7cfa7e3580fd250a5617cc917dab59828f4f4ebc50', 'de2bfc728b108f6557f3d6959cec4db6d9e50adedb70a22939a16f29cf1e241b', '9d16780139ac5a5bcc5887b86d737bec08525c621de153cecbe258b0f310cab1', 'd5b29348bd685f249f0739f769413f01a84804f106345439899be82b4b06c21d', '651e341460abb4f56484b2921abfc1e41250a07075e5c89fa4decd74cfa782be', '75e1b9b6b6c2e723fb5593a62465d328747fe29245449a4233a49cd981a5e16d'] A "to support outgoing detnet mpls over udp/ip, an implementation must support the provisioning of udp/ip header information in addition or in place of f-label(s). the headers for each outgoing packet must be based on the configuration information and as defined in rfc7510, with one exception. the one exception is that the udp source port value must be set to uniquely identify the detnet flow. the packet must then be handed as a detnet ip packet, per i-d.ietf-detnet-ip." {33: 1, 71: 1, 64: 1, 60: 3, 56: 2, 102: 2, 62: 3, 26: 2, 32: 2, 83: 3, 113: 2, 38: 2, 126: 2, 112: 2, 85: 3, 129: 2} {31: 1, 377: 1, 339: 1, 343: 1, 260: 3, 261: 2, 274: 2, 283: 3, 286: 2, 32: 2, 33: 2, 163: 3, 228: 2, 357: 2, 166: 2, 231: 2, 298: 2, 363: 3, 46: 2} {260, 261, 274, 283, 286, 31, 32, 33, 163, 166, 298, 46, 339, 212, 343, 228, 357, 231, 363, 377} 38 "To support receive processing an implementation MUST also support the provisioning of received UDP/IP header information. The provisioned information MUST be used to identify incoming app-flows based on the combination of S-Label and incoming IP/UDP header. Normal receive processing, including PEF and POF can then take place." mpls - over - ip : minor tweaks ipOmpls : Section 6 , Management and Control Information Summary mpls : editorial changes , refactoring of section 5 for clarity and completeness white space cleanup ( remove tabs and trailing spaces ) 6eef101c3c863f944da82ed2f9cc38205de8aa61 6eef101c3c863f944da82ed2f9cc38205de8aa61 draft-ietf-detnet-mpls-over-udp-ip 651e341460abb4f56484b2921abfc1e41250a07075e5c89fa4decd74cfa782be ['87a3de23bdd1c53a746e7a7cfa7e3580fd250a5617cc917dab59828f4f4ebc50', 'de2bfc728b108f6557f3d6959cec4db6d9e50adedb70a22939a16f29cf1e241b', '9d16780139ac5a5bcc5887b86d737bec08525c621de153cecbe258b0f310cab1', 'd5b29348bd685f249f0739f769413f01a84804f106345439899be82b4b06c21d', '651e341460abb4f56484b2921abfc1e41250a07075e5c89fa4decd74cfa782be', '75e1b9b6b6c2e723fb5593a62465d328747fe29245449a4233a49cd981a5e16d'] A "to support receive processing an implementation must also support the provisioning of received udp/ip header information. the provisioned information must be used to identify incoming app-flows based on the combination of s-label and incoming ip/udp header. normal receive processing, including pef and pof can then take place." {33: 1, 71: 1, 64: 1, 60: 3, 56: 2, 102: 2, 62: 3, 26: 2, 32: 2, 83: 3, 113: 2, 38: 2, 126: 2, 112: 2, 85: 3, 129: 2} {31: 1, 377: 1, 339: 1, 343: 1, 260: 3, 261: 2, 274: 2, 283: 3, 286: 2, 32: 2, 33: 2, 163: 3, 228: 2, 357: 2, 166: 2, 231: 2, 298: 2, 363: 3, 46: 2} {260, 261, 274, 283, 286, 31, 32, 33, 163, 166, 298, 46, 339, 212, 343, 228, 357, 231, 363, 377} 38 "d-CW, S-Labels and zero or more F-Labels are used as defined in I- D.ietf-detnet-mpls and are not modified by this document. In case of aggregates the A-Label is treated as an S-Label and it too is not modified." mpls - over - ip : minor tweaks ipOmpls : Section 6 , Management and Control Information Summary mpls : editorial changes , refactoring of section 5 for clarity and completeness white space cleanup ( remove tabs and trailing spaces ) 6eef101c3c863f944da82ed2f9cc38205de8aa61 6eef101c3c863f944da82ed2f9cc38205de8aa61 draft-ietf-detnet-mpls-over-udp-ip d5b29348bd685f249f0739f769413f01a84804f106345439899be82b4b06c21d ['87a3de23bdd1c53a746e7a7cfa7e3580fd250a5617cc917dab59828f4f4ebc50', 'de2bfc728b108f6557f3d6959cec4db6d9e50adedb70a22939a16f29cf1e241b', '9d16780139ac5a5bcc5887b86d737bec08525c621de153cecbe258b0f310cab1', 'd5b29348bd685f249f0739f769413f01a84804f106345439899be82b4b06c21d', '651e341460abb4f56484b2921abfc1e41250a07075e5c89fa4decd74cfa782be', '75e1b9b6b6c2e723fb5593a62465d328747fe29245449a4233a49cd981a5e16d'] B "d-cw, s-labels and zero or more f-labels are used as defined in i- d.ietf-detnet-mpls and are not modified by this document. in case of aggregates the a-label is treated as an s-label and it too is not modified." {33: 1, 71: 1, 64: 1, 60: 3, 56: 2, 102: 2, 62: 3, 26: 2, 32: 2, 83: 3, 113: 2, 38: 2, 126: 2, 112: 2, 85: 3, 129: 2} {31: 1, 377: 1, 339: 1, 343: 1, 260: 3, 261: 2, 274: 2, 283: 3, 286: 2, 32: 2, 33: 2, 163: 3, 228: 2, 357: 2, 166: 2, 231: 2, 298: 2, 363: 3, 46: 2} {260, 261, 274, 283, 286, 31, 32, 33, 163, 166, 298, 46, 339, 212, 343, 228, 357, 231, 363, 377} 38 "To support outgoing DetNet MPLS over UDP/IP encapsulation, an implementation MUST support the provisioning of UDP and IP header information in addition or in place of F-Label(s). Note, when PRF is performed at the MPLS service sub-layer, there will be multiple member flows, and each member flow will require the provisioning of their own UDP and IP header information. The headers for each outgoing packet MUST be formatted on the configuration information and as defined in RFC7510, with one exception. Note that the UDP Source Port value MUST be set to uniquely identify the DetNet flow. The packet MUST then be handed as a DetNet IP packet, per I-D.ietf- detnet-ip. This includes QoS related traffic treatment." mpls - over - ip : minor tweaks ipOmpls : Section 6 , Management and Control Information Summary mpls : editorial changes , refactoring of section 5 for clarity and completeness white space cleanup ( remove tabs and trailing spaces ) 6eef101c3c863f944da82ed2f9cc38205de8aa61 6eef101c3c863f944da82ed2f9cc38205de8aa61 draft-ietf-detnet-mpls-over-udp-ip 75e1b9b6b6c2e723fb5593a62465d328747fe29245449a4233a49cd981a5e16d ['87a3de23bdd1c53a746e7a7cfa7e3580fd250a5617cc917dab59828f4f4ebc50', 'de2bfc728b108f6557f3d6959cec4db6d9e50adedb70a22939a16f29cf1e241b', '9d16780139ac5a5bcc5887b86d737bec08525c621de153cecbe258b0f310cab1', 'd5b29348bd685f249f0739f769413f01a84804f106345439899be82b4b06c21d', '651e341460abb4f56484b2921abfc1e41250a07075e5c89fa4decd74cfa782be', '75e1b9b6b6c2e723fb5593a62465d328747fe29245449a4233a49cd981a5e16d'] B "to support outgoing detnet mpls over udp/ip encapsulation, an implementation must support the provisioning of udp and ip header information in addition or in place of f-label(s). note, when prf is performed at the mpls service sub-layer, there will be multiple member flows, and each member flow will require the provisioning of their own udp and ip header information. the headers for each outgoing packet must be formatted on the configuration information and as defined in rfc7510, with one exception. note that the udp source port value must be set to uniquely identify the detnet flow. the packet must then be handed as a detnet ip packet, per i-d.ietf- detnet-ip. this includes qos related traffic treatment." {33: 1, 71: 1, 64: 1, 60: 3, 56: 2, 102: 2, 62: 3, 26: 2, 32: 2, 83: 3, 113: 2, 38: 2, 126: 2, 112: 2, 85: 3, 129: 2} {31: 1, 377: 1, 339: 1, 343: 1, 260: 3, 261: 2, 274: 2, 283: 3, 286: 2, 32: 2, 33: 2, 163: 3, 228: 2, 357: 2, 166: 2, 231: 2, 298: 2, 363: 3, 46: 2} {260, 261, 274, 283, 286, 31, 32, 33, 163, 166, 298, 46, 339, 212, 343, 228, 357, 231, 363, 377} 38 "To support receive processing an implementation MUST also support the provisioning of received UDP and IP header information. The provisioned information MUST be used to identify incoming app-flows based on the combination of S-Label and incoming encapsulation header information. Normal receive processing as defined in I-D.ietf- detnet-mpls, including PEF and POF, can then take place." mpls - over - ip : minor tweaks ipOmpls : Section 6 , Management and Control Information Summary mpls : editorial changes , refactoring of section 5 for clarity and completeness white space cleanup ( remove tabs and trailing spaces ) 6eef101c3c863f944da82ed2f9cc38205de8aa61 6eef101c3c863f944da82ed2f9cc38205de8aa61 draft-ietf-detnet-mpls-over-udp-ip 9d16780139ac5a5bcc5887b86d737bec08525c621de153cecbe258b0f310cab1 ['87a3de23bdd1c53a746e7a7cfa7e3580fd250a5617cc917dab59828f4f4ebc50', 'de2bfc728b108f6557f3d6959cec4db6d9e50adedb70a22939a16f29cf1e241b', '9d16780139ac5a5bcc5887b86d737bec08525c621de153cecbe258b0f310cab1', 'd5b29348bd685f249f0739f769413f01a84804f106345439899be82b4b06c21d', '651e341460abb4f56484b2921abfc1e41250a07075e5c89fa4decd74cfa782be', '75e1b9b6b6c2e723fb5593a62465d328747fe29245449a4233a49cd981a5e16d'] B "to support receive processing an implementation must also support the provisioning of received udp and ip header information. the provisioned information must be used to identify incoming app-flows based on the combination of s-label and incoming encapsulation header information. normal receive processing as defined in i-d.ietf- detnet-mpls, including pef and pof, can then take place." {33: 1, 71: 1, 64: 1, 60: 3, 56: 2, 102: 2, 62: 3, 26: 2, 32: 2, 83: 3, 113: 2, 38: 2, 126: 2, 112: 2, 85: 3, 129: 2} {31: 1, 377: 1, 339: 1, 343: 1, 260: 3, 261: 2, 274: 2, 283: 3, 286: 2, 32: 2, 33: 2, 163: 3, 228: 2, 357: 2, 166: 2, 231: 2, 298: 2, 363: 3, 46: 2} {260, 261, 274, 283, 286, 31, 32, 33, 163, 166, 298, 46, 339, 212, 343, 228, 357, 231, 363, 377} 38 "Label information (S-label or F-label) to be mapped to UDP/IP flow." mpls - over - ip : minor tweaks ipOmpls : Section 6 , Management and Control Information Summary mpls : editorial changes , refactoring of section 5 for clarity and completeness white space cleanup ( remove tabs and trailing spaces ) 6eef101c3c863f944da82ed2f9cc38205de8aa61 6eef101c3c863f944da82ed2f9cc38205de8aa61 draft-ietf-detnet-mpls-over-udp-ip 4a95be10c5590a4fe0ad4da58a231ea010ff214e7dc04107bb1c6ec8b9a8b734 ['de516a625ab93a18f079c2aff17323130e255b2973920908021f63c9cda0caeb', '4a95be10c5590a4fe0ad4da58a231ea010ff214e7dc04107bb1c6ec8b9a8b734', '0c4e4992cda8f30f80cc2363443762dbc93e76b6cc2de75eaa96840d9a83694d', 'e017b1a97c1a28146e0d9bf9ccc4f8ee912af0403ef57166df5480ff49b8b833'] A "label information (s-label or f-label) to be mapped to udp/ip flow." {33: 1, 71: 1, 60: 3, 56: 2, 102: 2, 64: 2, 38: 2, 62: 3, 26: 2, 32: 2, 83: 3, 113: 2, 126: 2, 112: 2, 85: 3, 129: 2} {31: 1, 377: 1, 260: 3, 261: 2, 274: 2, 339: 3, 212: 2, 343: 2, 283: 3, 286: 4, 32: 2, 33: 2, 163: 3, 228: 2, 166: 2, 231: 2, 298: 2, 363: 3, 46: 2} {260, 261, 274, 283, 286, 31, 32, 33, 163, 166, 298, 46, 339, 212, 343, 228, 357, 231, 363, 377} 38 IPv4 protocol field. Only UDP is allowed. mpls - over - ip : minor tweaks ipOmpls : Section 6 , Management and Control Information Summary mpls : editorial changes , refactoring of section 5 for clarity and completeness white space cleanup ( remove tabs and trailing spaces ) 6eef101c3c863f944da82ed2f9cc38205de8aa61 6eef101c3c863f944da82ed2f9cc38205de8aa61 draft-ietf-detnet-mpls-over-udp-ip 0c4e4992cda8f30f80cc2363443762dbc93e76b6cc2de75eaa96840d9a83694d ['de516a625ab93a18f079c2aff17323130e255b2973920908021f63c9cda0caeb', '4a95be10c5590a4fe0ad4da58a231ea010ff214e7dc04107bb1c6ec8b9a8b734', '0c4e4992cda8f30f80cc2363443762dbc93e76b6cc2de75eaa96840d9a83694d', 'e017b1a97c1a28146e0d9bf9ccc4f8ee912af0403ef57166df5480ff49b8b833'] A ipv4 protocol field. only udp is allowed. {33: 1, 71: 1, 60: 3, 56: 2, 102: 2, 64: 2, 38: 2, 62: 3, 26: 2, 32: 2, 83: 3, 113: 2, 126: 2, 112: 2, 85: 3, 129: 2} {31: 1, 377: 1, 260: 3, 261: 2, 274: 2, 339: 3, 212: 2, 343: 2, 283: 3, 286: 4, 32: 2, 33: 2, 163: 3, 228: 2, 166: 2, 231: 2, 298: 2, 363: 3, 46: 2} {260, 261, 274, 283, 286, 31, 32, 33, 163, 166, 298, 46, 339, 212, 343, 228, 357, 231, 363, 377} 38 IPv6 next header field. Only UDP is allowed. mpls - over - ip : minor tweaks ipOmpls : Section 6 , Management and Control Information Summary mpls : editorial changes , refactoring of section 5 for clarity and completeness white space cleanup ( remove tabs and trailing spaces ) 6eef101c3c863f944da82ed2f9cc38205de8aa61 6eef101c3c863f944da82ed2f9cc38205de8aa61 draft-ietf-detnet-mpls-over-udp-ip de516a625ab93a18f079c2aff17323130e255b2973920908021f63c9cda0caeb ['de516a625ab93a18f079c2aff17323130e255b2973920908021f63c9cda0caeb', '4a95be10c5590a4fe0ad4da58a231ea010ff214e7dc04107bb1c6ec8b9a8b734', '0c4e4992cda8f30f80cc2363443762dbc93e76b6cc2de75eaa96840d9a83694d', 'e017b1a97c1a28146e0d9bf9ccc4f8ee912af0403ef57166df5480ff49b8b833'] A ipv6 next header field. only udp is allowed. {33: 1, 71: 1, 60: 3, 56: 2, 102: 2, 64: 2, 38: 2, 62: 3, 26: 2, 32: 2, 83: 3, 113: 2, 126: 2, 112: 2, 85: 3, 129: 2} {31: 1, 377: 1, 260: 3, 261: 2, 274: 2, 339: 3, 212: 2, 343: 2, 283: 3, 286: 4, 32: 2, 33: 2, 163: 3, 228: 2, 166: 2, 231: 2, 298: 2, 363: 3, 46: 2} {260, 261, 274, 283, 286, 31, 32, 33, 163, 166, 298, 46, 339, 212, 343, 228, 357, 231, 363, 377} 38 "Label information (S-label or F-label) to be mapped to UDP/IP flow. Note that a single S-Label can map to multiple sets of UPD/ IP information when PREOF is used." mpls - over - ip : minor tweaks ipOmpls : Section 6 , Management and Control Information Summary mpls : editorial changes , refactoring of section 5 for clarity and completeness white space cleanup ( remove tabs and trailing spaces ) 6eef101c3c863f944da82ed2f9cc38205de8aa61 6eef101c3c863f944da82ed2f9cc38205de8aa61 draft-ietf-detnet-mpls-over-udp-ip e017b1a97c1a28146e0d9bf9ccc4f8ee912af0403ef57166df5480ff49b8b833 ['de516a625ab93a18f079c2aff17323130e255b2973920908021f63c9cda0caeb', '4a95be10c5590a4fe0ad4da58a231ea010ff214e7dc04107bb1c6ec8b9a8b734', '0c4e4992cda8f30f80cc2363443762dbc93e76b6cc2de75eaa96840d9a83694d', 'e017b1a97c1a28146e0d9bf9ccc4f8ee912af0403ef57166df5480ff49b8b833'] B "label information (s-label or f-label) to be mapped to udp/ip flow. note that a single s-label can map to multiple sets of upd/ ip information when preof is used." {33: 1, 71: 1, 60: 3, 56: 2, 102: 2, 64: 2, 38: 2, 62: 3, 26: 2, 32: 2, 83: 3, 113: 2, 126: 2, 112: 2, 85: 3, 129: 2} {31: 1, 377: 1, 260: 3, 261: 2, 274: 2, 339: 3, 212: 2, 343: 2, 283: 3, 286: 4, 32: 2, 33: 2, 163: 3, 228: 2, 166: 2, 231: 2, 298: 2, 363: 3, 46: 2} {260, 261, 274, 283, 286, 31, 32, 33, 163, 166, 298, 46, 339, 212, 343, 228, 357, 231, 363, 377} 38 "A special case of an S-Label, whose properties are known only at the aggregation and deaggregation end-points." mpls - over - ip : minor tweaks ipOmpls : Section 6 , Management and Control Information Summary mpls : editorial changes , refactoring of section 5 for clarity and completeness white space cleanup ( remove tabs and trailing spaces ) 6eef101c3c863f944da82ed2f9cc38205de8aa61 6eef101c3c863f944da82ed2f9cc38205de8aa61 draft-ietf-detnet-mpls 1507524e19dbc5cd9e5814a4311ddc473dfc60d77d76c658cb6bc7d196bfbc9a ['1507524e19dbc5cd9e5814a4311ddc473dfc60d77d76c658cb6bc7d196bfbc9a', '8a430bda65967f28a5a763374c58b3ed80b78b34a61bacf6624b569c674ce8be'] A "a special case of an s-label, whose properties are known only at the aggregation and deaggregation end-points." {33: 1, 130: 3, 79: 3, 51: 3, 112: 3, 55: 3, 64: 3, 62: 4, 37: 3, 38: 3, 69: 3, 68: 2, 67: 3, 25: 3, 53: 2, 80: 3, 52: 2, 127: 4, 91: 3} {278: 1, 0: 3, 389: 3, 390: 3, 135: 3, 142: 3, 14: 3, 400: 4, 17: 3, 399: 4, 149: 3, 406: 3, 279: 2, 280: 3, 281: 3, 294: 3, 296: 3, 45: 4, 308: 3, 56: 3, 185: 3, 192: 3, 321: 2, 322: 2, 66: 3, 196: 5, 197: 4, 324: 3, 77: 3, 78: 3, 337: 5, 216: 3, 380: 3, 255: 3} {0, 389, 390, 135, 142, 14, 400, 17, 399, 19, 149, 406, 279, 280, 281, 278, 294, 296, 45, 308, 56, 185, 192, 321, 322, 66, 196, 197, 324, 77, 78, 337, 216, 380, 255} 38 "A special case of an S-Label, whose aggregation properties are known only at the aggregation and deaggregation end-points." mpls - over - ip : minor tweaks ipOmpls : Section 6 , Management and Control Information Summary mpls : editorial changes , refactoring of section 5 for clarity and completeness white space cleanup ( remove tabs and trailing spaces ) 6eef101c3c863f944da82ed2f9cc38205de8aa61 6eef101c3c863f944da82ed2f9cc38205de8aa61 draft-ietf-detnet-mpls 8a430bda65967f28a5a763374c58b3ed80b78b34a61bacf6624b569c674ce8be ['1507524e19dbc5cd9e5814a4311ddc473dfc60d77d76c658cb6bc7d196bfbc9a', '8a430bda65967f28a5a763374c58b3ed80b78b34a61bacf6624b569c674ce8be'] B "a special case of an s-label, whose aggregation properties are known only at the aggregation and deaggregation end-points." {33: 1, 130: 3, 79: 3, 51: 3, 112: 3, 55: 3, 64: 3, 62: 4, 37: 3, 38: 3, 69: 3, 68: 2, 67: 3, 25: 3, 53: 2, 80: 3, 52: 2, 127: 4, 91: 3} {278: 1, 0: 3, 389: 3, 390: 3, 135: 3, 142: 3, 14: 3, 400: 4, 17: 3, 399: 4, 149: 3, 406: 3, 279: 2, 280: 3, 281: 3, 294: 3, 296: 3, 45: 4, 308: 3, 56: 3, 185: 3, 192: 3, 321: 2, 322: 2, 66: 3, 196: 5, 197: 4, 324: 3, 77: 3, 78: 3, 337: 5, 216: 3, 380: 3, 255: 3} {0, 389, 390, 135, 142, 14, 400, 17, 399, 19, 149, 406, 279, 280, 281, 278, 294, 296, 45, 308, 56, 185, 192, 321, 322, 66, 196, 197, 324, 77, 78, 337, 216, 380, 255} 38 "DetNet end system and relay nodes understand the particular needs of DetNet flows and provide both DetNet service and forwarding sub-layer functions. In the case of MPLS, DetNet nodes add, remove and process d-CWs, S-Labels and F-labels as needed. DetNet MPLS nodes provide functionality analogous to T-PEs when they sit at the edge of an MPLS domain, and S-PEs when they are in the middle of an MPLS domain, see RFC6073." mpls - over - ip : minor tweaks ipOmpls : Section 6 , Management and Control Information Summary mpls : editorial changes , refactoring of section 5 for clarity and completeness white space cleanup ( remove tabs and trailing spaces ) 6eef101c3c863f944da82ed2f9cc38205de8aa61 6eef101c3c863f944da82ed2f9cc38205de8aa61 draft-ietf-detnet-mpls 08d8edf3c2fc0dbdec453515a94e6778ee77f480b156e0c6231d07ec068a5f22 ['64574a0f6024907ea798ff25e5ab99c2791ce432511f5daa7ecf704aa901ba35', '08d8edf3c2fc0dbdec453515a94e6778ee77f480b156e0c6231d07ec068a5f22'] A "detnet end system and relay nodes understand the particular needs of detnet flows and provide both detnet service and forwarding sub-layer functions. in the case of mpls, detnet nodes add, remove and process d-cws, s-labels and f-labels as needed. detnet mpls nodes provide functionality analogous to t-pes when they sit at the edge of an mpls domain, and s-pes when they are in the middle of an mpls domain, see rfc6073." {} {} {} 38 "DetNet end system and relay nodes understand the particular needs of DetNet flows and provide both DetNet service and forwarding sub-layer functions. In the case of MPLS, DetNet service-aware nodes add, remove and process d-CWs, S-Labels and F-labels as needed. DetNet MPLS nodes provide functionality analogous to T-PEs when they sit at the edge of an MPLS domain, and S-PEs when they are in the middle of an MPLS domain, see RFC6073." mpls - over - ip : minor tweaks ipOmpls : Section 6 , Management and Control Information Summary mpls : editorial changes , refactoring of section 5 for clarity and completeness white space cleanup ( remove tabs and trailing spaces ) 6eef101c3c863f944da82ed2f9cc38205de8aa61 6eef101c3c863f944da82ed2f9cc38205de8aa61 draft-ietf-detnet-mpls 64574a0f6024907ea798ff25e5ab99c2791ce432511f5daa7ecf704aa901ba35 ['64574a0f6024907ea798ff25e5ab99c2791ce432511f5daa7ecf704aa901ba35', '08d8edf3c2fc0dbdec453515a94e6778ee77f480b156e0c6231d07ec068a5f22'] B "detnet end system and relay nodes understand the particular needs of detnet flows and provide both detnet service and forwarding sub-layer functions. in the case of mpls, detnet service-aware nodes add, remove and process d-cws, s-labels and f-labels as needed. detnet mpls nodes provide functionality analogous to t-pes when they sit at the edge of an mpls domain, and s-pes when they are in the middle of an mpls domain, see rfc6073." {} {} {} 38 "The sequence number length MUST be provisioned (configured) on a per app-flow basis via configuration, e.g., the controller plane described in I-D.ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework." mpls - over - ip : minor tweaks ipOmpls : Section 6 , Management and Control Information Summary mpls : editorial changes , refactoring of section 5 for clarity and completeness white space cleanup ( remove tabs and trailing spaces ) 6eef101c3c863f944da82ed2f9cc38205de8aa61 6eef101c3c863f944da82ed2f9cc38205de8aa61 draft-ietf-detnet-mpls 9971201e12b75dadc2eef291bf266b7fe8e3ccfa7ced5a897f9dda226922d370 ['9971201e12b75dadc2eef291bf266b7fe8e3ccfa7ced5a897f9dda226922d370', 'c4cabfb8460d144f4ac45fa3ccf92ba87a8fb2f9602f9cee6a8ae14924ae411b'] A "the sequence number length must be provisioned (configured) on a per app-flow basis via configuration, e.g., the controller plane described in i-d.ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework." {} {} {} 38 "The sequence number length MUST be provisioned on a per app-flow basis via configuration, i.e., via the controller plane described in I-D.ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework." mpls - over - ip : minor tweaks ipOmpls : Section 6 , Management and Control Information Summary mpls : editorial changes , refactoring of section 5 for clarity and completeness white space cleanup ( remove tabs and trailing spaces ) 6eef101c3c863f944da82ed2f9cc38205de8aa61 6eef101c3c863f944da82ed2f9cc38205de8aa61 draft-ietf-detnet-mpls c4cabfb8460d144f4ac45fa3ccf92ba87a8fb2f9602f9cee6a8ae14924ae411b ['9971201e12b75dadc2eef291bf266b7fe8e3ccfa7ced5a897f9dda226922d370', 'c4cabfb8460d144f4ac45fa3ccf92ba87a8fb2f9602f9cee6a8ae14924ae411b'] B "the sequence number length must be provisioned on a per app-flow basis via configuration, i.e., via the controller plane described in i-d.ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework." {} {} {} 38 "When the sequence number field length is 16 or 28 bits for a flow, the sequence number MUST be incremented by one for each new app-flow packet sent. When the field length is 16 bits, d-CW bits 4 to 15 MUST be set to zero (0). This values carried in this field can wrap and it is important to note that zero (0) is a valid field value. For example, were the sequence number size is 16 bits, the sequence will contain: 65535, 0, 1. In this case, zero (0) is an ordinary sequence number. This differs from RFC4448 where a sequence number of zero (0) does not indicate that no sequence number field value is in use." mpls - over - ip : minor tweaks ipOmpls : Section 6 , Management and Control Information Summary mpls : editorial changes , refactoring of section 5 for clarity and completeness white space cleanup ( remove tabs and trailing spaces ) 6eef101c3c863f944da82ed2f9cc38205de8aa61 6eef101c3c863f944da82ed2f9cc38205de8aa61 draft-ietf-detnet-mpls 7d0114363f61f4f0ff7ee9d25e76e87dada99c9b66127461f6d38b3e4cd631d2 ['7d0114363f61f4f0ff7ee9d25e76e87dada99c9b66127461f6d38b3e4cd631d2', '6d7ab6393f61f074f755e5a9dd65269b554f82f124566d0c343bb84611d6df18', 'd73388a6492672859f5629b96c526455fb0da16a9fdb44cf7c178152e9778812'] A "when the sequence number field length is 16 or 28 bits for a flow, the sequence number must be incremented by one for each new app-flow packet sent. when the field length is 16 bits, d-cw bits 4 to 15 must be set to zero (0). this values carried in this field can wrap and it is important to note that zero (0) is a valid field value. for example, were the sequence number size is 16 bits, the sequence will contain: 65535, 0, 1. in this case, zero (0) is an ordinary sequence number. this differs from rfc4448 where a sequence number of zero (0) does not indicate that no sequence number field value is in use." {113: 1} {174: 1} {195, 174} 38 "When the sequence number field length is 16 or 28 bits for a flow, the sequence number MUST be incremented by one for each new app-flow packet sent. When the field length is 16 bits, d-CW bits 4 to 15 MUST be set to zero (0). The values carried in this field can wrap and it is important to note that zero (0) is a valid field value. For example, were the sequence number size is 16 bits, the sequence will contain: 65535, 0, 1, where zero (0) is an ordinary sequence number." mpls - over - ip : minor tweaks ipOmpls : Section 6 , Management and Control Information Summary mpls : editorial changes , refactoring of section 5 for clarity and completeness white space cleanup ( remove tabs and trailing spaces ) 6eef101c3c863f944da82ed2f9cc38205de8aa61 6eef101c3c863f944da82ed2f9cc38205de8aa61 draft-ietf-detnet-mpls 6d7ab6393f61f074f755e5a9dd65269b554f82f124566d0c343bb84611d6df18 ['7d0114363f61f4f0ff7ee9d25e76e87dada99c9b66127461f6d38b3e4cd631d2', '6d7ab6393f61f074f755e5a9dd65269b554f82f124566d0c343bb84611d6df18', 'd73388a6492672859f5629b96c526455fb0da16a9fdb44cf7c178152e9778812'] B "when the sequence number field length is 16 or 28 bits for a flow, the sequence number must be incremented by one for each new app-flow packet sent. when the field length is 16 bits, d-cw bits 4 to 15 must be set to zero (0). the values carried in this field can wrap and it is important to note that zero (0) is a valid field value. for example, were the sequence number size is 16 bits, the sequence will contain: 65535, 0, 1, where zero (0) is an ordinary sequence number." {113: 1} {174: 1} {195, 174} 38 "It is important to note that this document differs from RFC4448 where a sequence number of zero (0) is used to indicate that the sequence number check algorithm is not used." mpls - over - ip : minor tweaks ipOmpls : Section 6 , Management and Control Information Summary mpls : editorial changes , refactoring of section 5 for clarity and completeness white space cleanup ( remove tabs and trailing spaces ) 6eef101c3c863f944da82ed2f9cc38205de8aa61 6eef101c3c863f944da82ed2f9cc38205de8aa61 draft-ietf-detnet-mpls d73388a6492672859f5629b96c526455fb0da16a9fdb44cf7c178152e9778812 ['7d0114363f61f4f0ff7ee9d25e76e87dada99c9b66127461f6d38b3e4cd631d2', '6d7ab6393f61f074f755e5a9dd65269b554f82f124566d0c343bb84611d6df18', 'd73388a6492672859f5629b96c526455fb0da16a9fdb44cf7c178152e9778812'] B "it is important to note that this document differs from rfc4448 where a sequence number of zero (0) is used to indicate that the sequence number check algorithm is not used." {113: 1} {174: 1} {195, 174} 38 "App-flow identification at a DetNet service sub-layer is realized by an S-Label. Each app-flow MUST be sent by the node that adds a d-CW with a single specific S-Label value. MPLS-aware DetNet end systems and edge nodes, which are by definition MPLS ingress and egress nodes, MUST add and remove the d-CW and S-Label. Relay nodes MAY swap S-Label values when processing an app-flow." mpls - over - ip : minor tweaks ipOmpls : Section 6 , Management and Control Information Summary mpls : editorial changes , refactoring of section 5 for clarity and completeness white space cleanup ( remove tabs and trailing spaces ) 6eef101c3c863f944da82ed2f9cc38205de8aa61 6eef101c3c863f944da82ed2f9cc38205de8aa61 draft-ietf-detnet-mpls 176e6ad4f1afd57ce33e1b50f568cd3c811da38c280261192ee116beaa68d64f ['8fe37d8d2057e3adb997358117b9b919fb8a46707f1a5a764c2f1af0c361a844', '176e6ad4f1afd57ce33e1b50f568cd3c811da38c280261192ee116beaa68d64f'] A "app-flow identification at a detnet service sub-layer is realized by an s-label. each app-flow must be sent by the node that adds a d-cw with a single specific s-label value. mpls-aware detnet end systems and edge nodes, which are by definition mpls ingress and egress nodes, must add and remove the d-cw and s-label. relay nodes may swap s-label values when processing an app-flow." {} {} {} 38 "App-flow identification at a DetNet service sub-layer is realized by an S-Label. MPLS-aware DetNet end systems and edge nodes, which are by definition MPLS ingress and egress nodes, MUST add and remove an app-flow specific d-CW and S-Label. Relay nodes MAY swap S-Label values when processing an app-flow." mpls - over - ip : minor tweaks ipOmpls : Section 6 , Management and Control Information Summary mpls : editorial changes , refactoring of section 5 for clarity and completeness white space cleanup ( remove tabs and trailing spaces ) 6eef101c3c863f944da82ed2f9cc38205de8aa61 6eef101c3c863f944da82ed2f9cc38205de8aa61 draft-ietf-detnet-mpls 8fe37d8d2057e3adb997358117b9b919fb8a46707f1a5a764c2f1af0c361a844 ['8fe37d8d2057e3adb997358117b9b919fb8a46707f1a5a764c2f1af0c361a844', '176e6ad4f1afd57ce33e1b50f568cd3c811da38c280261192ee116beaa68d64f'] B "app-flow identification at a detnet service sub-layer is realized by an s-label. mpls-aware detnet end systems and edge nodes, which are by definition mpls ingress and egress nodes, must add and remove an app-flow specific d-cw and s-label. relay nodes may swap s-label values when processing an app-flow." {} {} {} 38 "When receiving a DetNet MPLS flow, an implementation MUST identify the app-flow associated with the incoming packet based on the S-Label. When a node is using platform labels for S-Labels, no additional information is needed as the S-label uniquely identifies the app-flow. In the case where platform labels are not used, one or more F-Labels proceeding the S-Label MUST be used together with the S-Label to uniquely identify the incoming app-flows. When PHP is used, the incoming interface MAY also be used to together with any present F-Label(s) and the S-Label to uniquely identify an incoming app-flows. Note that choice to use platform label space for S-Label or S-Label plus one or more F-Labels to identify app flows is a local implementation choice, with one caveat. When one or more F-labels, or incoming interface, is needed together with an S-Label to uniquely identify, the controller plane MUST ensure that incoming DetNet MPLS packets arrive with the needed information (F-label(s) and/or incoming interface); the details of such are outside the scope of this document." mpls - over - ip : minor tweaks ipOmpls : Section 6 , Management and Control Information Summary mpls : editorial changes , refactoring of section 5 for clarity and completeness white space cleanup ( remove tabs and trailing spaces ) 6eef101c3c863f944da82ed2f9cc38205de8aa61 6eef101c3c863f944da82ed2f9cc38205de8aa61 draft-ietf-detnet-mpls 89da08eefaece751b1c6520a386ba73e52bd714477e49c6fd07bfbd0d63d60bf ['a238774b54c80880f28ec6a35d747294bc2b70905313f69db2215a69c6e4317f', '89da08eefaece751b1c6520a386ba73e52bd714477e49c6fd07bfbd0d63d60bf'] A "when receiving a detnet mpls flow, an implementation must identify the app-flow associated with the incoming packet based on the s-label. when a node is using platform labels for s-labels, no additional information is needed as the s-label uniquely identifies the app-flow. in the case where platform labels are not used, one or more f-labels proceeding the s-label must be used together with the s-label to uniquely identify the incoming app-flows. when php is used, the incoming interface may also be used to together with any present f-label(s) and the s-label to uniquely identify an incoming app-flows. note that choice to use platform label space for s-label or s-label plus one or more f-labels to identify app flows is a local implementation choice, with one caveat. when one or more f-labels, or incoming interface, is needed together with an s-label to uniquely identify, the controller plane must ensure that incoming detnet mpls packets arrive with the needed information (f-label(s) and/or incoming interface); the details of such are outside the scope of this document." {} {} {} 38 "When receiving a DetNet MPLS flow, an implementation MUST identify the app-flow associated with the incoming packet based on the S-Label. When a node is using platform labels for S-Labels, no additional information is needed as the S-label uniquely identifies the app-flow. In the case where platform labels are not used, zero or more F-Labels and optionally, the incoming interface, proceeding the S-Label MUST be used together with the S-Label to uniquely identify the app-flows associated with a received packet. The incoming interface MAY also be used to together with any present F-Label(s) and the S-Label to uniquely identify an incoming app- flows, for example, to in the case where PHP is used. Note that choice to use platform label space for S-Label or S-Label plus one or more F-Labels to identify app flows is a local implementation choice, with one caveat. When one or more F-labels, or incoming interface, is needed together with an S-Label to uniquely identify, the controller plane MUST ensure that incoming DetNet MPLS packets arrive with the needed information (F-label(s) and/or incoming interface); the details of such are outside the scope of this document." mpls - over - ip : minor tweaks ipOmpls : Section 6 , Management and Control Information Summary mpls : editorial changes , refactoring of section 5 for clarity and completeness white space cleanup ( remove tabs and trailing spaces ) 6eef101c3c863f944da82ed2f9cc38205de8aa61 6eef101c3c863f944da82ed2f9cc38205de8aa61 draft-ietf-detnet-mpls a238774b54c80880f28ec6a35d747294bc2b70905313f69db2215a69c6e4317f ['a238774b54c80880f28ec6a35d747294bc2b70905313f69db2215a69c6e4317f', '89da08eefaece751b1c6520a386ba73e52bd714477e49c6fd07bfbd0d63d60bf'] B "when receiving a detnet mpls flow, an implementation must identify the app-flow associated with the incoming packet based on the s-label. when a node is using platform labels for s-labels, no additional information is needed as the s-label uniquely identifies the app-flow. in the case where platform labels are not used, zero or more f-labels and optionally, the incoming interface, proceeding the s-label must be used together with the s-label to uniquely identify the app-flows associated with a received packet. the incoming interface may also be used to together with any present f-label(s) and the s-label to uniquely identify an incoming app- flows, for example, to in the case where php is used. note that choice to use platform label space for s-label or s-label plus one or more f-labels to identify app flows is a local implementation choice, with one caveat. when one or more f-labels, or incoming interface, is needed together with an s-label to uniquely identify, the controller plane must ensure that incoming detnet mpls packets arrive with the needed information (f-label(s) and/or incoming interface); the details of such are outside the scope of this document." {} {} {} 38 "After an app-flow is identified for a received DetNet MPLS packet, as described above, an implementation MUST check if PEF is configured for that app-flow. When configured the implementation MUST track the sequence number contained in received d-CWs and MUST ensure that duplicate (replicated) instances of a particular sequence number are discarded. The specific mechanisms used for an implementation to identify which received packets are duplicates and which are new is an implementation choice. Note that per dn-sn the sequence number field length may be 16 or 28 bits, and the field value can wrap." mpls - over - ip : minor tweaks ipOmpls : Section 6 , Management and Control Information Summary mpls : editorial changes , refactoring of section 5 for clarity and completeness white space cleanup ( remove tabs and trailing spaces ) 6eef101c3c863f944da82ed2f9cc38205de8aa61 6eef101c3c863f944da82ed2f9cc38205de8aa61 draft-ietf-detnet-mpls 19e54d87e1ab6fd6a9f92ace290257e064b995654551b33701bd4520bde95965 ['19e54d87e1ab6fd6a9f92ace290257e064b995654551b33701bd4520bde95965', '37df335184ef4b8be029314caddca69ee42907d7c034f3488460929db79b0fc7'] A "after an app-flow is identified for a received detnet mpls packet, as described above, an implementation must check if pef is configured for that app-flow. when configured the implementation must track the sequence number contained in received d-cws and must ensure that duplicate (replicated) instances of a particular sequence number are discarded. the specific mechanisms used for an implementation to identify which received packets are duplicates and which are new is an implementation choice. note that per dn-sn the sequence number field length may be 16 or 28 bits, and the field value can wrap." {} {} {} 38 "After an app-flow is identified for a received DetNet MPLS packet, as described above, an implementation MUST check if PEF is configured for that app-flow. When configured, the implementation MUST track the sequence number contained in received d-CWs and MUST ensure that duplicate (replicated) instances of a particular sequence number are discarded. The specific mechanisms used for an implementation to identify which received packets are duplicates and which are new is an implementation choice. Note that per dn-sn the sequence number field length may be 16 or 28 bits, and the field value can wrap." mpls - over - ip : minor tweaks ipOmpls : Section 6 , Management and Control Information Summary mpls : editorial changes , refactoring of section 5 for clarity and completeness white space cleanup ( remove tabs and trailing spaces ) 6eef101c3c863f944da82ed2f9cc38205de8aa61 6eef101c3c863f944da82ed2f9cc38205de8aa61 draft-ietf-detnet-mpls 37df335184ef4b8be029314caddca69ee42907d7c034f3488460929db79b0fc7 ['19e54d87e1ab6fd6a9f92ace290257e064b995654551b33701bd4520bde95965', '37df335184ef4b8be029314caddca69ee42907d7c034f3488460929db79b0fc7'] B "after an app-flow is identified for a received detnet mpls packet, as described above, an implementation must check if pef is configured for that app-flow. when configured, the implementation must track the sequence number contained in received d-cws and must ensure that duplicate (replicated) instances of a particular sequence number are discarded. the specific mechanisms used for an implementation to identify which received packets are duplicates and which are new is an implementation choice. note that per dn-sn the sequence number field length may be 16 or 28 bits, and the field value can wrap." {} {} {} 38 "After an app-flow is identified for a received DetNet MPLS packet, as described above, an implementation MUST check if POF is configured for that app-flow. When configured the implementation MUST track the sequence number contained in received d-CWs and MUST ensure that packets are processed in the order indicated in the received d-CW sequence number field, which may not be in the order the packets are received. As defined in dn-sn the sequence number field length may be 16 or 28 bits, is incremented by one (1) for each new app-flow packet sent, and the field value can wrap. The specific mechanisms used for an implementation to identify the order of received packets is an implementation choice." mpls - over - ip : minor tweaks ipOmpls : Section 6 , Management and Control Information Summary mpls : editorial changes , refactoring of section 5 for clarity and completeness white space cleanup ( remove tabs and trailing spaces ) 6eef101c3c863f944da82ed2f9cc38205de8aa61 6eef101c3c863f944da82ed2f9cc38205de8aa61 draft-ietf-detnet-mpls a7d3e802785c3e78950c249c5b80ba755c70a23047ed552a84fba1d12ea6c5cb ['52fa63cf211ecd2d2c4586fc3f46782329eeaeb9e87618d146fd103349dd8321', 'a7d3e802785c3e78950c249c5b80ba755c70a23047ed552a84fba1d12ea6c5cb'] A "after an app-flow is identified for a received detnet mpls packet, as described above, an implementation must check if pof is configured for that app-flow. when configured the implementation must track the sequence number contained in received d-cws and must ensure that packets are processed in the order indicated in the received d-cw sequence number field, which may not be in the order the packets are received. as defined in dn-sn the sequence number field length may be 16 or 28 bits, is incremented by one (1) for each new app-flow packet sent, and the field value can wrap. the specific mechanisms used for an implementation to identify the order of received packets is an implementation choice." {} {} {} 38 "After an app-flow is identified for a received DetNet MPLS packet, as described above, an implementation MUST check if POF is configured for that app-flow. When configured, the implementation MUST track the sequence number contained in received d-CWs and MUST ensure that packets are processed in the order indicated in the received d-CW sequence number field, which may not be in the order the packets are received. As defined in dn-sn the sequence number field length may be 16 or 28 bits, is incremented by one (1) for each new app-flow packet sent, and the field value can wrap. The specific mechanisms used for an implementation to identify the order of received packets is an implementation choice." mpls - over - ip : minor tweaks ipOmpls : Section 6 , Management and Control Information Summary mpls : editorial changes , refactoring of section 5 for clarity and completeness white space cleanup ( remove tabs and trailing spaces ) 6eef101c3c863f944da82ed2f9cc38205de8aa61 6eef101c3c863f944da82ed2f9cc38205de8aa61 draft-ietf-detnet-mpls 52fa63cf211ecd2d2c4586fc3f46782329eeaeb9e87618d146fd103349dd8321 ['52fa63cf211ecd2d2c4586fc3f46782329eeaeb9e87618d146fd103349dd8321', 'a7d3e802785c3e78950c249c5b80ba755c70a23047ed552a84fba1d12ea6c5cb'] B "after an app-flow is identified for a received detnet mpls packet, as described above, an implementation must check if pof is configured for that app-flow. when configured, the implementation must track the sequence number contained in received d-cws and must ensure that packets are processed in the order indicated in the received d-cw sequence number field, which may not be in the order the packets are received. as defined in dn-sn the sequence number field length may be 16 or 28 bits, is incremented by one (1) for each new app-flow packet sent, and the field value can wrap. the specific mechanisms used for an implementation to identify the order of received packets is an implementation choice." {} {} {} 38 "When sending a DetNet flow, Zero or more F-Labels MAY be added on top of an S-Label by the node pushing an S-Label. The F-Labels to be pushed when sending a particular app-flow MUST be provisioned per app-flow via configuration, e.g., via the controller plane discussed in I-D.ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework. F-Labels can also provide context for an S-Label. To allow for the omission of F-Labels, an implementation SHOULD also allow an outgoing interface to be provisioned." mpls - over - ip : minor tweaks ipOmpls : Section 6 , Management and Control Information Summary mpls : editorial changes , refactoring of section 5 for clarity and completeness white space cleanup ( remove tabs and trailing spaces ) 6eef101c3c863f944da82ed2f9cc38205de8aa61 6eef101c3c863f944da82ed2f9cc38205de8aa61 draft-ietf-detnet-mpls 2f823e24b4100f16f9512657b8dd9bfaa8a10665e129568218c4b861255365c9 ['2adba20f450d7586b69d4ae547e491a0180addd98cc096c3cbb9df6b9aad6c12', '759d7826a4276fff5ed1c4618e87eee76f34ae5126f73c80360d0ecaeff35fd8', '0e0c4f2c3dde9391a8fb20dbb48a8042f2fa3ac4702f7432580ac8405d73e051', '2f823e24b4100f16f9512657b8dd9bfaa8a10665e129568218c4b861255365c9'] A "when sending a detnet flow, zero or more f-labels may be added on top of an s-label by the node pushing an s-label. the f-labels to be pushed when sending a particular app-flow must be provisioned per app-flow via configuration, e.g., via the controller plane discussed in i-d.ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework. f-labels can also provide context for an s-label. to allow for the omission of f-labels, an implementation should also allow an outgoing interface to be provisioned." {35: 1} {18: 1} {57, 18} 38 "The Packet Replication Function (PRF) function MAY be supported by an implementation for outgoing DetNet flows. When replication is supported, the same app-flow data will be sent over multiple outgoing forwarding sub-layer LSPs. To support PRF an implementation MUST support the setting of different sets of F-Labels. Therefore, to allow for the omission of F-Labels, an implementation SHOULD also allow multiple outgoing interfaces to be provisioned. PRF MUST NOT be used with app-flows configured with a d-CW sequence number field length of 0 bits." mpls - over - ip : minor tweaks ipOmpls : Section 6 , Management and Control Information Summary mpls : editorial changes , refactoring of section 5 for clarity and completeness white space cleanup ( remove tabs and trailing spaces ) 6eef101c3c863f944da82ed2f9cc38205de8aa61 6eef101c3c863f944da82ed2f9cc38205de8aa61 draft-ietf-detnet-mpls 2adba20f450d7586b69d4ae547e491a0180addd98cc096c3cbb9df6b9aad6c12 ['2adba20f450d7586b69d4ae547e491a0180addd98cc096c3cbb9df6b9aad6c12', '759d7826a4276fff5ed1c4618e87eee76f34ae5126f73c80360d0ecaeff35fd8', '0e0c4f2c3dde9391a8fb20dbb48a8042f2fa3ac4702f7432580ac8405d73e051', '2f823e24b4100f16f9512657b8dd9bfaa8a10665e129568218c4b861255365c9'] A "the packet replication function (prf) function may be supported by an implementation for outgoing detnet flows. when replication is supported, the same app-flow data will be sent over multiple outgoing forwarding sub-layer lsps. to support prf an implementation must support the setting of different sets of f-labels. therefore, to allow for the omission of f-labels, an implementation should also allow multiple outgoing interfaces to be provisioned. prf must not be used with app-flows configured with a d-cw sequence number field length of 0 bits." {35: 1} {18: 1} {57, 18} 38 "When sending a DetNet flow, zero or more F-Labels MAY be pushed on top of an S-Label by the node pushing an S-Label. The F-Labels to be pushed when sending a particular app-flow MUST be provisioned per app-flow via configuration, e.g., via the controller plane discussed in I-D.ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework. F-Labels can also provide context for an S-Label. To allow for the omission of F-Labels, an implementation SHOULD also allow an outgoing interface to be used." mpls - over - ip : minor tweaks ipOmpls : Section 6 , Management and Control Information Summary mpls : editorial changes , refactoring of section 5 for clarity and completeness white space cleanup ( remove tabs and trailing spaces ) 6eef101c3c863f944da82ed2f9cc38205de8aa61 6eef101c3c863f944da82ed2f9cc38205de8aa61 draft-ietf-detnet-mpls 0e0c4f2c3dde9391a8fb20dbb48a8042f2fa3ac4702f7432580ac8405d73e051 ['2adba20f450d7586b69d4ae547e491a0180addd98cc096c3cbb9df6b9aad6c12', '759d7826a4276fff5ed1c4618e87eee76f34ae5126f73c80360d0ecaeff35fd8', '0e0c4f2c3dde9391a8fb20dbb48a8042f2fa3ac4702f7432580ac8405d73e051', '2f823e24b4100f16f9512657b8dd9bfaa8a10665e129568218c4b861255365c9'] B "when sending a detnet flow, zero or more f-labels may be pushed on top of an s-label by the node pushing an s-label. the f-labels to be pushed when sending a particular app-flow must be provisioned per app-flow via configuration, e.g., via the controller plane discussed in i-d.ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework. f-labels can also provide context for an s-label. to allow for the omission of f-labels, an implementation should also allow an outgoing interface to be used." {35: 1} {18: 1} {57, 18} 38 "The Packet Replication Function (PRF) function MAY be supported by an implementation for outgoing DetNet flows. When replication is supported, the same app-flow data will be sent over multiple outgoing forwarding sub-layer LSPs. To support PRF an implementation MUST support the setting of different sets of F-Labels. To allow for the omission of F-Labels, an implementation SHOULD also allow multiple outgoing interfaces to be provisioned. PRF MUST NOT be used with app-flows configured with a d-CW sequence number field length of 0 bits." mpls - over - ip : minor tweaks ipOmpls : Section 6 , Management and Control Information Summary mpls : editorial changes , refactoring of section 5 for clarity and completeness white space cleanup ( remove tabs and trailing spaces ) 6eef101c3c863f944da82ed2f9cc38205de8aa61 6eef101c3c863f944da82ed2f9cc38205de8aa61 draft-ietf-detnet-mpls 759d7826a4276fff5ed1c4618e87eee76f34ae5126f73c80360d0ecaeff35fd8 ['2adba20f450d7586b69d4ae547e491a0180addd98cc096c3cbb9df6b9aad6c12', '759d7826a4276fff5ed1c4618e87eee76f34ae5126f73c80360d0ecaeff35fd8', '0e0c4f2c3dde9391a8fb20dbb48a8042f2fa3ac4702f7432580ac8405d73e051', '2f823e24b4100f16f9512657b8dd9bfaa8a10665e129568218c4b861255365c9'] B "the packet replication function (prf) function may be supported by an implementation for outgoing detnet flows. when replication is supported, the same app-flow data will be sent over multiple outgoing forwarding sub-layer lsps. to support prf an implementation must support the setting of different sets of f-labels. to allow for the omission of f-labels, an implementation should also allow multiple outgoing interfaces to be provisioned. prf must not be used with app-flows configured with a d-cw sequence number field length of 0 bits." {35: 1} {18: 1} {57, 18} 38 "As described in the previous section, when receiving a DetNet MPLS flow, an implementation identifies the app-flow associated with the incoming packet based on the S-Label. When a node is using platform labels for S-Labels, any F-Labels can be popped and the S-label uniquely identifies the app-flow. In the case where platform labels are not used, F-Label(s) MUST also be provisioned for incoming app- flows. When PHP is used, incoming interface MUST be provisioned. The provisioned information MUST then be used to identify incoming app-flows based on the combination of S-Label and F-Label(s) or incoming interface." mpls - over - ip : minor tweaks ipOmpls : Section 6 , Management and Control Information Summary mpls : editorial changes , refactoring of section 5 for clarity and completeness white space cleanup ( remove tabs and trailing spaces ) 6eef101c3c863f944da82ed2f9cc38205de8aa61 6eef101c3c863f944da82ed2f9cc38205de8aa61 draft-ietf-detnet-mpls c10478663e1a3196a2479bd2b9750a30c0f61d207aceaf4c772ee0096d0645a0 ['c10478663e1a3196a2479bd2b9750a30c0f61d207aceaf4c772ee0096d0645a0', 'cc92ec706c4f1e51286b5199cf24e041c36c03dde91bb5ea228175700678126f'] A "as described in the previous section, when receiving a detnet mpls flow, an implementation identifies the app-flow associated with the incoming packet based on the s-label. when a node is using platform labels for s-labels, any f-labels can be popped and the s-label uniquely identifies the app-flow. in the case where platform labels are not used, f-label(s) must also be provisioned for incoming app- flows. when php is used, incoming interface must be provisioned. the provisioned information must then be used to identify incoming app-flows based on the combination of s-label and f-label(s) or incoming interface." {} {} {} 38 "As described in the previous section, when receiving a DetNet MPLS flow, an implementation identifies the app-flow associated with the incoming packet based on the S-Label. When a node is using platform labels for S-Labels, any F-Labels can be popped and the S-label uniquely identifies the app-flow. In the case where platform labels are not used, F-Label(s) and, optionally, the incoming interface MUST also be provisioned for incoming app-flows. The provisioned information MUST then be used to identify incoming app-flows based on the combination of S-Label and F-Label(s) or incoming interface." mpls - over - ip : minor tweaks ipOmpls : Section 6 , Management and Control Information Summary mpls : editorial changes , refactoring of section 5 for clarity and completeness white space cleanup ( remove tabs and trailing spaces ) 6eef101c3c863f944da82ed2f9cc38205de8aa61 6eef101c3c863f944da82ed2f9cc38205de8aa61 draft-ietf-detnet-mpls cc92ec706c4f1e51286b5199cf24e041c36c03dde91bb5ea228175700678126f ['c10478663e1a3196a2479bd2b9750a30c0f61d207aceaf4c772ee0096d0645a0', 'cc92ec706c4f1e51286b5199cf24e041c36c03dde91bb5ea228175700678126f'] B "as described in the previous section, when receiving a detnet mpls flow, an implementation identifies the app-flow associated with the incoming packet based on the s-label. when a node is using platform labels for s-labels, any f-labels can be popped and the s-label uniquely identifies the app-flow. in the case where platform labels are not used, f-label(s) and, optionally, the incoming interface must also be provisioned for incoming app-flows. the provisioned information must then be used to identify incoming app-flows based on the combination of s-label and f-label(s) or incoming interface." {} {} {} 38 "All DetNet aware MPLS nodes process F-Labels as needed to meet the service requirements of the DetNet flow or flows carried in the LSPs represented by the F-Labels. This includes normal push, pop and swap operations. Such processing is essentially the same type of processing enabled for TE LSPs, although the specific service parameters, or traffic specification, can differ. When the DetNet service parameters of the app-flow or flows carried in an LSP represented by an F-Label can be met by an exiting TE mechanism, the forwarding sub-layer processing node MAY be a DetNet unaware, i.e., standard, MPLS LSR. Such TE LSPs may provide LSP forwarding service as defined in, but not limited to, RFC3209, RFC3270, RFC3272, RFC3473, RFC4875, RFC5440, and RFC6006." mpls - over - ip : minor tweaks ipOmpls : Section 6 , Management and Control Information Summary mpls : editorial changes , refactoring of section 5 for clarity and completeness white space cleanup ( remove tabs and trailing spaces ) 6eef101c3c863f944da82ed2f9cc38205de8aa61 6eef101c3c863f944da82ed2f9cc38205de8aa61 draft-ietf-detnet-mpls 693e30f5c0748ba4c662f0416168aa9fa7de30f072f5990310b4927f255e838a ['693e30f5c0748ba4c662f0416168aa9fa7de30f072f5990310b4927f255e838a', '8c100cb102ce42f0d77427483c979319235c14c04999e5e67ddcc9e1c827c53a'] A "all detnet aware mpls nodes process f-labels as needed to meet the service requirements of the detnet flow or flows carried in the lsps represented by the f-labels. this includes normal push, pop and swap operations. such processing is essentially the same type of processing enabled for te lsps, although the specific service parameters, or traffic specification, can differ. when the detnet service parameters of the app-flow or flows carried in an lsp represented by an f-label can be met by an exiting te mechanism, the forwarding sub-layer processing node may be a detnet unaware, i.e., standard, mpls lsr. such te lsps may provide lsp forwarding service as defined in, but not limited to, rfc3209, rfc3270, rfc3272, rfc3473, rfc4875, rfc5440, and rfc6006." {} {} {} 38 "All DetNet aware MPLS nodes process F-Labels as needed to meet the service requirements of the DetNet flow or flows carried in the LSPs represented by the F-Labels. This includes normal push, pop and swap operations. Such processing is essentially the same type of processing provided for TE LSPs, although the specific service parameters, or traffic specification, can differ. When the DetNet service parameters of the app-flow or flows carried in an LSP represented by an F-Label can be met by an exiting TE mechanism, the forwarding sub-layer processing node MAY be a DetNet unaware, i.e., standard, MPLS LSR. Such TE LSPs may provide LSP forwarding service as defined in, but not limited to, RFC3209, RFC3270, RFC3272, RFC3473, RFC4875, RFC5440, and RFC6006." mpls - over - ip : minor tweaks ipOmpls : Section 6 , Management and Control Information Summary mpls : editorial changes , refactoring of section 5 for clarity and completeness white space cleanup ( remove tabs and trailing spaces ) 6eef101c3c863f944da82ed2f9cc38205de8aa61 6eef101c3c863f944da82ed2f9cc38205de8aa61 draft-ietf-detnet-mpls 8c100cb102ce42f0d77427483c979319235c14c04999e5e67ddcc9e1c827c53a ['693e30f5c0748ba4c662f0416168aa9fa7de30f072f5990310b4927f255e838a', '8c100cb102ce42f0d77427483c979319235c14c04999e5e67ddcc9e1c827c53a'] B "all detnet aware mpls nodes process f-labels as needed to meet the service requirements of the detnet flow or flows carried in the lsps represented by the f-labels. this includes normal push, pop and swap operations. such processing is essentially the same type of processing provided for te lsps, although the specific service parameters, or traffic specification, can differ. when the detnet service parameters of the app-flow or flows carried in an lsp represented by an f-label can be met by an exiting te mechanism, the forwarding sub-layer processing node may be a detnet unaware, i.e., standard, mpls lsr. such te lsps may provide lsp forwarding service as defined in, but not limited to, rfc3209, rfc3270, rfc3272, rfc3473, rfc4875, rfc5440, and rfc6006." {} {} {} 38 "More specifically, as mentioned above, the DetNet forwarding sub- layer provides explicit routes and allocated resources, and F-Labels are used to map to each. Explicit routes are supported based on the topmost (outermost) F-Label that is pushed or swapped and the LSP that corresponds to this label. This topmost (outgoing) label MUST be associated with a provisioned outgoing interface and, for non- point-to-point outgoing interfaces, a next hop LSR. Note that this information MUST be provisioned via configuration or the controller plane. In the previously mentioned special case where there is no added F-labels and the outgoing interface is not a point-to-point interface, the outgoing interface MUST also be associated with a next hop LSR." mpls - over - ip : minor tweaks ipOmpls : Section 6 , Management and Control Information Summary mpls : editorial changes , refactoring of section 5 for clarity and completeness white space cleanup ( remove tabs and trailing spaces ) 6eef101c3c863f944da82ed2f9cc38205de8aa61 6eef101c3c863f944da82ed2f9cc38205de8aa61 draft-ietf-detnet-mpls 34b04e48babb04e1ee24ebbce523cbcf3c3fe37017fabbc344b92bc2807aa794 ['34b04e48babb04e1ee24ebbce523cbcf3c3fe37017fabbc344b92bc2807aa794', '63543d87bb99727a1de3e03bbf97fac042977733fffa823b4481b5845b008b34'] A "more specifically, as mentioned above, the detnet forwarding sub- layer provides explicit routes and allocated resources, and f-labels are used to map to each. explicit routes are supported based on the topmost (outermost) f-label that is pushed or swapped and the lsp that corresponds to this label. this topmost (outgoing) label must be associated with a provisioned outgoing interface and, for non- point-to-point outgoing interfaces, a next hop lsr. note that this information must be provisioned via configuration or the controller plane. in the previously mentioned special case where there is no added f-labels and the outgoing interface is not a point-to-point interface, the outgoing interface must also be associated with a next hop lsr." {} {} {} 38 "More specifically, as mentioned above, the DetNet forwarding sub- layer provides explicit routes and allocated resources, and F-Labels are used to map to each. Explicit routes are supported based on the topmost (outermost) F-Label that is pushed or swapped and the LSP that corresponds to this label. This topmost (outgoing) label MUST be associated with a provisioned outgoing interface and, for non- point-to-point outgoing interfaces, a next hop LSR. Note that this information MUST be provisioned via configuration or the controller plane. In the previously mentioned special case where there are no added F-labels and the outgoing interface is not a point-to-point interface, the outgoing interface MUST also be associated with a next hop LSR." mpls - over - ip : minor tweaks ipOmpls : Section 6 , Management and Control Information Summary mpls : editorial changes , refactoring of section 5 for clarity and completeness white space cleanup ( remove tabs and trailing spaces ) 6eef101c3c863f944da82ed2f9cc38205de8aa61 6eef101c3c863f944da82ed2f9cc38205de8aa61 draft-ietf-detnet-mpls 63543d87bb99727a1de3e03bbf97fac042977733fffa823b4481b5845b008b34 ['34b04e48babb04e1ee24ebbce523cbcf3c3fe37017fabbc344b92bc2807aa794', '63543d87bb99727a1de3e03bbf97fac042977733fffa823b4481b5845b008b34'] B "more specifically, as mentioned above, the detnet forwarding sub- layer provides explicit routes and allocated resources, and f-labels are used to map to each. explicit routes are supported based on the topmost (outermost) f-label that is pushed or swapped and the lsp that corresponds to this label. this topmost (outgoing) label must be associated with a provisioned outgoing interface and, for non- point-to-point outgoing interfaces, a next hop lsr. note that this information must be provisioned via configuration or the controller plane. in the previously mentioned special case where there are no added f-labels and the outgoing interface is not a point-to-point interface, the outgoing interface must also be associated with a next hop lsr." {} {} {} 38 "Resources may be allocated in a hierarchical fashion per LSP that is represented by each F-Label. Each LSP MAY be provisioned with a service parameters that dictates the specific traffic treatment to be received by the traffic carried over that LSP. Implementations of this document MUST ensure that traffic carried over each LSP represented by an F-Label receives the traffic treatment provisioned for that LSP. Typical mechanisms used to provide different treatment to different flows includes the allocation of system resources (such as queues and buffers) and provisioning or related parameters (such as shaping, and policing). Support can also be provided via an underlying network technology such IEEE802.1 TSN I-D.ietf-detnet- mpls-over-tsn. Other than in the TSN case, the specific mechanisms used by a DetNet node to ensure DetNet service delivery requirements are met for supported DetNet flows is outside the scope of this document." mpls - over - ip : minor tweaks ipOmpls : Section 6 , Management and Control Information Summary mpls : editorial changes , refactoring of section 5 for clarity and completeness white space cleanup ( remove tabs and trailing spaces ) 6eef101c3c863f944da82ed2f9cc38205de8aa61 6eef101c3c863f944da82ed2f9cc38205de8aa61 draft-ietf-detnet-mpls 48dc35a86f58045dbd57a59d871a64cfdc5ceac7810cf7ab53c92f22d4f1acd6 ['842770263fc5af2e84a18aa14c1ac7935bffba0a1f44b44545e9af93dd61262f', '48dc35a86f58045dbd57a59d871a64cfdc5ceac7810cf7ab53c92f22d4f1acd6'] A "resources may be allocated in a hierarchical fashion per lsp that is represented by each f-label. each lsp may be provisioned with a service parameters that dictates the specific traffic treatment to be received by the traffic carried over that lsp. implementations of this document must ensure that traffic carried over each lsp represented by an f-label receives the traffic treatment provisioned for that lsp. typical mechanisms used to provide different treatment to different flows includes the allocation of system resources (such as queues and buffers) and provisioning or related parameters (such as shaping, and policing). support can also be provided via an underlying network technology such ieee802.1 tsn i-d.ietf-detnet- mpls-over-tsn. other than in the tsn case, the specific mechanisms used by a detnet node to ensure detnet service delivery requirements are met for supported detnet flows is outside the scope of this document." {} {} {} 38 "Resources may be allocated in a hierarchical fashion per LSP that is represented by each F-Label. Each LSP MAY be provisioned with a service parameters that dictates the specific traffic treatment to be received by the traffic carried over that LSP. Implementations of this document MUST ensure that traffic carried over each LSP represented by one or more F-Labels receives the traffic treatment provisioned for that LSP. Typical mechanisms used to provide different treatment to different flows includes the allocation of system resources (such as queues and buffers) and provisioning or related parameters (such as shaping, and policing). Support can also be provided via an underlying network technology such IEEE802.1 TSN I-D.ietf-detnet-mpls-over-tsn. The specific mechanisms used by a DetNet node to ensure DetNet service delivery requirements are met for supported DetNet flows is outside the scope of this document." mpls - over - ip : minor tweaks ipOmpls : Section 6 , Management and Control Information Summary mpls : editorial changes , refactoring of section 5 for clarity and completeness white space cleanup ( remove tabs and trailing spaces ) 6eef101c3c863f944da82ed2f9cc38205de8aa61 6eef101c3c863f944da82ed2f9cc38205de8aa61 draft-ietf-detnet-mpls 842770263fc5af2e84a18aa14c1ac7935bffba0a1f44b44545e9af93dd61262f ['842770263fc5af2e84a18aa14c1ac7935bffba0a1f44b44545e9af93dd61262f', '48dc35a86f58045dbd57a59d871a64cfdc5ceac7810cf7ab53c92f22d4f1acd6'] B "resources may be allocated in a hierarchical fashion per lsp that is represented by each f-label. each lsp may be provisioned with a service parameters that dictates the specific traffic treatment to be received by the traffic carried over that lsp. implementations of this document must ensure that traffic carried over each lsp represented by one or more f-labels receives the traffic treatment provisioned for that lsp. typical mechanisms used to provide different treatment to different flows includes the allocation of system resources (such as queues and buffers) and provisioning or related parameters (such as shaping, and policing). support can also be provided via an underlying network technology such ieee802.1 tsn i-d.ietf-detnet-mpls-over-tsn. the specific mechanisms used by a detnet node to ensure detnet service delivery requirements are met for supported detnet flows is outside the scope of this document." {} {} {} 38 "The resource control and management aspects of aggregation (including the configuration of queuing, shaping, and policing) are the responsibility of the DetNet controller plane and will be covered in other documents. It is also the responsibility of the controller plane to ensure that consistent aggregation methods are used." mpls - over - ip : minor tweaks ipOmpls : Section 6 , Management and Control Information Summary mpls : editorial changes , refactoring of section 5 for clarity and completeness white space cleanup ( remove tabs and trailing spaces ) 6eef101c3c863f944da82ed2f9cc38205de8aa61 6eef101c3c863f944da82ed2f9cc38205de8aa61 draft-ietf-detnet-mpls 0da0c7cd9a41758799f48ce4e17324be8f7daae22b9bbe17eda29548d594638e ['0da0c7cd9a41758799f48ce4e17324be8f7daae22b9bbe17eda29548d594638e', '5062938d3cfa6ca5f81dcb964f7722534662500f32861401df28602074da8b80'] A "the resource control and management aspects of aggregation (including the configuration of queuing, shaping, and policing) are the responsibility of the detnet controller plane and will be covered in other documents. it is also the responsibility of the controller plane to ensure that consistent aggregation methods are used." {27: 1, 26: 2} {7: 1, 313: 2} {313, 6, 7} 38 "The resource control and management aspects of aggregation (including the configuration of queuing, shaping, and policing) are the responsibility of the DetNet controller plane and is out of scope of this documents. It is also the responsibility of the controller plane to ensure that consistent aggregation methods are used." mpls - over - ip : minor tweaks ipOmpls : Section 6 , Management and Control Information Summary mpls : editorial changes , refactoring of section 5 for clarity and completeness white space cleanup ( remove tabs and trailing spaces ) 6eef101c3c863f944da82ed2f9cc38205de8aa61 6eef101c3c863f944da82ed2f9cc38205de8aa61 draft-ietf-detnet-mpls 5062938d3cfa6ca5f81dcb964f7722534662500f32861401df28602074da8b80 ['0da0c7cd9a41758799f48ce4e17324be8f7daae22b9bbe17eda29548d594638e', '5062938d3cfa6ca5f81dcb964f7722534662500f32861401df28602074da8b80'] B "the resource control and management aspects of aggregation (including the configuration of queuing, shaping, and policing) are the responsibility of the detnet controller plane and is out of scope of this documents. it is also the responsibility of the controller plane to ensure that consistent aggregation methods are used." {27: 1, 26: 2} {7: 1, 313: 2} {313, 6, 7} 38 "Both the aggregation label, or A-Label, and the individual flow's S-Label have their MPLS S bit set indicating bottom of stack, and the d-CW allows the PREOF to work. An A-Label is a special case of an S-Label, whose properties are known only at the aggregation and deaggregation end-points." mpls - over - ip : minor tweaks ipOmpls : Section 6 , Management and Control Information Summary mpls : editorial changes , refactoring of section 5 for clarity and completeness white space cleanup ( remove tabs and trailing spaces ) 6eef101c3c863f944da82ed2f9cc38205de8aa61 6eef101c3c863f944da82ed2f9cc38205de8aa61 draft-ietf-detnet-mpls a538cfc7a38ec764b699e862926ceb51deda81a94d16906065a652c480896a31 ['81615ee3624b6a3c678cfdd15cca8ee21d3770c729a390fd26826a942b6859aa', 'a538cfc7a38ec764b699e862926ceb51deda81a94d16906065a652c480896a31'] A "both the aggregation label, or a-label, and the individual flow's s-label have their mpls s bit set indicating bottom of stack, and the d-cw allows the preof to work. an a-label is a special case of an s-label, whose properties are known only at the aggregation and deaggregation end-points." {27: 1, 26: 2, 35: 2, 113: 3} {266: 1, 265: 2, 94: 2, 95: 3} {265, 266, 205, 94, 95} 38 "Both the aggregation label, which is referred to as an A-Label, and the individual flow's S-Label have their MPLS S bit set indicating bottom of stack, and the d-CW allows the PREOF to work. An A-Label is a special case of an S-Label, whose properties are known only at the aggregation and deaggregation end-points." mpls - over - ip : minor tweaks ipOmpls : Section 6 , Management and Control Information Summary mpls : editorial changes , refactoring of section 5 for clarity and completeness white space cleanup ( remove tabs and trailing spaces ) 6eef101c3c863f944da82ed2f9cc38205de8aa61 6eef101c3c863f944da82ed2f9cc38205de8aa61 draft-ietf-detnet-mpls 81615ee3624b6a3c678cfdd15cca8ee21d3770c729a390fd26826a942b6859aa ['81615ee3624b6a3c678cfdd15cca8ee21d3770c729a390fd26826a942b6859aa', 'a538cfc7a38ec764b699e862926ceb51deda81a94d16906065a652c480896a31'] B "both the aggregation label, which is referred to as an a-label, and the individual flow's s-label have their mpls s bit set indicating bottom of stack, and the d-cw allows the preof to work. an a-label is a special case of an s-label, whose properties are known only at the aggregation and deaggregation end-points." {27: 1, 26: 2, 35: 2, 113: 3} {266: 1, 265: 2, 94: 2, 95: 3} {265, 266, 205, 94, 95} 38 "It is important that the DetNet layer is configured such that a DetNet node never receives its own replicated packets. If it were to receive such packets the replication function would make the loop more destructive of bandwidth than a conventional unicast loop. Ultimately the TTL in the S-Label will cause the packet to die during a transient loop, but given the sensitivity of applications to packet latency the impact on the DetNet application would be severe." mpls - over - ip : minor tweaks ipOmpls : Section 6 , Management and Control Information Summary mpls : editorial changes , refactoring of section 5 for clarity and completeness white space cleanup ( remove tabs and trailing spaces ) 6eef101c3c863f944da82ed2f9cc38205de8aa61 6eef101c3c863f944da82ed2f9cc38205de8aa61 draft-ietf-detnet-mpls e2878c8000645508a1cfb216784cbfdceec326efe6bed8381fdb1d86d3372d01 ['672772ef07a21c7198304f59703257e15e7e53de50678bebf9c2d7c0289dc4b4', 'e2878c8000645508a1cfb216784cbfdceec326efe6bed8381fdb1d86d3372d01'] A "it is important that the detnet layer is configured such that a detnet node never receives its own replicated packets. if it were to receive such packets the replication function would make the loop more destructive of bandwidth than a conventional unicast loop. ultimately the ttl in the s-label will cause the packet to die during a transient loop, but given the sensitivity of applications to packet latency the impact on the detnet application would be severe." {} {} {} 38 "It is important that the DetNet layer is configured such that a DetNet node never receives its own replicated packets. If it were to receive such packets the replication function would make the loop more destructive of bandwidth than a conventional unicast loop. Ultimately the TTL in the S-Label will cause the packet to die during a transient loop, but given the sensitivity of applications to packet latency the impact on the DetNet application would be severe. To avoid the problem of a transient forwarding loop, changes to an LSP supporting DetNet MUST be loop-free." mpls - over - ip : minor tweaks ipOmpls : Section 6 , Management and Control Information Summary mpls : editorial changes , refactoring of section 5 for clarity and completeness white space cleanup ( remove tabs and trailing spaces ) 6eef101c3c863f944da82ed2f9cc38205de8aa61 6eef101c3c863f944da82ed2f9cc38205de8aa61 draft-ietf-detnet-mpls 672772ef07a21c7198304f59703257e15e7e53de50678bebf9c2d7c0289dc4b4 ['672772ef07a21c7198304f59703257e15e7e53de50678bebf9c2d7c0289dc4b4', 'e2878c8000645508a1cfb216784cbfdceec326efe6bed8381fdb1d86d3372d01'] B "it is important that the detnet layer is configured such that a detnet node never receives its own replicated packets. if it were to receive such packets the replication function would make the loop more destructive of bandwidth than a conventional unicast loop. ultimately the ttl in the s-label will cause the packet to die during a transient loop, but given the sensitivity of applications to packet latency the impact on the detnet application would be severe. to avoid the problem of a transient forwarding loop, changes to an lsp supporting detnet must be loop-free." {} {} {} 38 Each flow's service parameters and S-Label. mpls - over - ip : minor tweaks ipOmpls : Section 6 , Management and Control Information Summary mpls : editorial changes , refactoring of section 5 for clarity and completeness white space cleanup ( remove tabs and trailing spaces ) 6eef101c3c863f944da82ed2f9cc38205de8aa61 6eef101c3c863f944da82ed2f9cc38205de8aa61 draft-ietf-detnet-mpls 5bbe3d686024848f24fe238d32a57ce72d50b8fbeebade01a3437d75950aab78 ['3ef84f782267c0e0e968196f92f0e857d46f4f9ba7afbddce796cc8c50975a16', '2e08e5d79759a80040647153ce3fa7819f0612da07f964d940457940ee32eefb', 'd645de25ddd5a17db4ac8e4152ab9f48880b0362f999693b780b953092b4818b', '5afe7b6130289b07fae3f2293f0b50942f6484999592ab78deeb684af0961b90', '5496f74277f5150125eda22755e4e5935e4d30373ae21b9d251791bb3af70771', 'e0272e86b037d5f460db4807aede2c02c9d02cb129d656c91aa723e14be8738c', 'e88833dfc4793019fd0d380a39254338e0e1620775d4f0f64ba50f65f6304990', '2e1188e3ae68f9645fceeb16885fb2558ac488250197b0dac87311b7f9fc7ba3', '236b9ded3b3585aca0a348dc8cf9b49717f1a76ca847c280134ba2cafca9e2bf', 'c99484d301684eba379e2eaab522e22872390f584d0977611a9b71cd4e36e2a9', 'd4d0f5b26265d5747482d4c8c93706edd735ad6b653327445de5a09a5dcc5c2b', '3ad381ce14d392b11bc71c7f84aec9aa4faec501b897070e8cad5dfe435f09ff', '75d8fb6c0eaa04ce99a6045642bc5e15246a22b21f752b965c428b1072c46889', '959f68af8dfd80b8f76ac61803f842c5d5465c96fe9a54320df01a59d427bc74', 'ab1acdf4e7456e3c0c48ecf2a80771c96f1006cd94d541736e1432d7df837fff', 'f584b276947e0b5979b2a9dc3254f10386b70b330438a9e2550d507641ada606', '274b6784d8b0e783b41d9ab3fb59f83a07021384d77a8301c21ba682ca514f8e', '3d36d1a44dc7d02361253be531685a7847ff919030e830b3b7d33da323864bba', '5bbe3d686024848f24fe238d32a57ce72d50b8fbeebade01a3437d75950aab78', '29ea94d06c6751fb47652496c82e1e9d54be60eb454edad2d4cc70305b7e7f6e', 'e19a400eccb294099834cd56397edb9329d003e8e7f8394c8510ecb4ff2e9d49', '0c083cb2dbd6e02c5070ac69ebd99deb41243b9c86516b946c30254bc9ccdfa3', '3e1ecc54327242ce7149d3b94e40a827984e34f421957d76e724befb47850aea', 'fad466a738de01a3d36eccbe586f4d8fc8e0e794e6bc9a207ec1dfbc50cfc690', '11750e495d361a550d77d6e936bd58a2696b27b9dd7d52475b2bc378ab46e66a', '9207956b1757a8ef10e8b8533004f05c18df92096f40432e53657c80998e21d0', 'b863dd515fc616b5f20d11da86ec171c6d64e3cdd1fecce3d9201a8f011ed918', 'da347c609aa36f0a6fe6d9365f7d3f5ef3502894bbb295f976fd4029d2dbed7c', '6e504eddc254b4618c44e3887d0b3f48b87c3f8b7253974cc0ffc04032bd0eef', 'ab4458406f2073e0bb0cbb77d0c295e95a669935cc2eb6d6f9ad03fb919856f1', '2a2e824a93c12293bd306cfff5b94f9aa2d149e4b03e04b44ad5d10090ab59c1', 'f4580b2be48d5ff6900dff6228fd62d66670888dae4c7128179d74de159d034a', '196c688b79a90f8cf628b79d0930ce6b3ff72fb8c443b7225899a0d1fdc0acad', '41c131676852283c2ee7fed18fd9381091897a583dc88fc9141a5038c73ed594'] A each flow's service parameters and s-label. {114: 1, 26: 1, 61: 1, 113: 1, 27: 1, 6: 4, 79: 4, 90: 3, 51: 4, 130: 4, 62: 6, 85: 7, 68: 6, 35: 5, 110: 3, 91: 5, 97: 4, 31: 4, 13: 3, 67: 3, 124: 5, 98: 4, 54: 4, 127: 5, 8: 4, 96: 4, 64: 4, 30: 4, 55: 5, 15: 3, 52: 3, 129: 5, 115: 3, 84: 3, 76: 8, 87: 3, 131: 7, 102: 3, 99: 4, 36: 3, 24: 2, 53: 3, 72: 4} {58: 1, 97: 1, 130: 1, 291: 1, 147: 1, 372: 1, 1: 11, 4: 4, 9: 7, 10: 5, 15: 4, 24: 4, 25: 6, 26: 7, 27: 4, 39: 7, 43: 5, 49: 6, 50: 5, 59: 4, 64: 4, 69: 6, 81: 7, 82: 5, 86: 3, 100: 8, 108: 5, 109: 6, 110: 6, 111: 4, 114: 5, 115: 6, 116: 4, 118: 8, 119: 7, 120: 5, 121: 6, 122: 5, 123: 4, 124: 6, 128: 4, 129: 4, 132: 6, 136: 4, 145: 6, 151: 4, 152: 4, 154: 5, 156: 3, 161: 5, 162: 5, 165: 5, 168: 6, 169: 3, 172: 3, 180: 4, 184: 7, 187: 7, 188: 6, 191: 5, 194: 6, 202: 7, 203: 8, 206: 4, 207: 5, 215: 4, 217: 5, 218: 10, 220: 4, 221: 4, 222: 7, 224: 5, 227: 6, 229: 3, 234: 7, 235: 4, 241: 4, 242: 4, 243: 6, 244: 4, 245: 6, 248: 4, 250: 5, 258: 13, 262: 6, 263: 7, 264: 5, 267: 6, 270: 4, 272: 3, 273: 7, 287: 5, 289: 3, 299: 6, 300: 4, 304: 4, 309: 5, 314: 4, 315: 3, 320: 6, 323: 6, 327: 6, 328: 5, 329: 4, 330: 12, 334: 4, 335: 4, 341: 6, 342: 7, 347: 6, 348: 6, 350: 9, 351: 5, 352: 3, 353: 3, 354: 2, 358: 6, 365: 3, 366: 4, 369: 3, 371: 8, 376: 4, 384: 5, 385: 4, 386: 5, 387: 4, 392: 5, 393: 6, 396: 7, 397: 9, 398: 8, 402: 3} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 38 The PREOF functions to be supported for each S-Label. mpls - over - ip : minor tweaks ipOmpls : Section 6 , Management and Control Information Summary mpls : editorial changes , refactoring of section 5 for clarity and completeness white space cleanup ( remove tabs and trailing spaces ) 6eef101c3c863f944da82ed2f9cc38205de8aa61 6eef101c3c863f944da82ed2f9cc38205de8aa61 draft-ietf-detnet-mpls 3ef84f782267c0e0e968196f92f0e857d46f4f9ba7afbddce796cc8c50975a16 ['3ef84f782267c0e0e968196f92f0e857d46f4f9ba7afbddce796cc8c50975a16', '2e08e5d79759a80040647153ce3fa7819f0612da07f964d940457940ee32eefb', 'd645de25ddd5a17db4ac8e4152ab9f48880b0362f999693b780b953092b4818b', '5afe7b6130289b07fae3f2293f0b50942f6484999592ab78deeb684af0961b90', '5496f74277f5150125eda22755e4e5935e4d30373ae21b9d251791bb3af70771', 'e0272e86b037d5f460db4807aede2c02c9d02cb129d656c91aa723e14be8738c', 'e88833dfc4793019fd0d380a39254338e0e1620775d4f0f64ba50f65f6304990', '2e1188e3ae68f9645fceeb16885fb2558ac488250197b0dac87311b7f9fc7ba3', '236b9ded3b3585aca0a348dc8cf9b49717f1a76ca847c280134ba2cafca9e2bf', 'c99484d301684eba379e2eaab522e22872390f584d0977611a9b71cd4e36e2a9', 'd4d0f5b26265d5747482d4c8c93706edd735ad6b653327445de5a09a5dcc5c2b', '3ad381ce14d392b11bc71c7f84aec9aa4faec501b897070e8cad5dfe435f09ff', '75d8fb6c0eaa04ce99a6045642bc5e15246a22b21f752b965c428b1072c46889', '959f68af8dfd80b8f76ac61803f842c5d5465c96fe9a54320df01a59d427bc74', 'ab1acdf4e7456e3c0c48ecf2a80771c96f1006cd94d541736e1432d7df837fff', 'f584b276947e0b5979b2a9dc3254f10386b70b330438a9e2550d507641ada606', '274b6784d8b0e783b41d9ab3fb59f83a07021384d77a8301c21ba682ca514f8e', '3d36d1a44dc7d02361253be531685a7847ff919030e830b3b7d33da323864bba', '5bbe3d686024848f24fe238d32a57ce72d50b8fbeebade01a3437d75950aab78', '29ea94d06c6751fb47652496c82e1e9d54be60eb454edad2d4cc70305b7e7f6e', 'e19a400eccb294099834cd56397edb9329d003e8e7f8394c8510ecb4ff2e9d49', '0c083cb2dbd6e02c5070ac69ebd99deb41243b9c86516b946c30254bc9ccdfa3', '3e1ecc54327242ce7149d3b94e40a827984e34f421957d76e724befb47850aea', 'fad466a738de01a3d36eccbe586f4d8fc8e0e794e6bc9a207ec1dfbc50cfc690', '11750e495d361a550d77d6e936bd58a2696b27b9dd7d52475b2bc378ab46e66a', '9207956b1757a8ef10e8b8533004f05c18df92096f40432e53657c80998e21d0', 'b863dd515fc616b5f20d11da86ec171c6d64e3cdd1fecce3d9201a8f011ed918', 'da347c609aa36f0a6fe6d9365f7d3f5ef3502894bbb295f976fd4029d2dbed7c', '6e504eddc254b4618c44e3887d0b3f48b87c3f8b7253974cc0ffc04032bd0eef', 'ab4458406f2073e0bb0cbb77d0c295e95a669935cc2eb6d6f9ad03fb919856f1', '2a2e824a93c12293bd306cfff5b94f9aa2d149e4b03e04b44ad5d10090ab59c1', 'f4580b2be48d5ff6900dff6228fd62d66670888dae4c7128179d74de159d034a', '196c688b79a90f8cf628b79d0930ce6b3ff72fb8c443b7225899a0d1fdc0acad', '41c131676852283c2ee7fed18fd9381091897a583dc88fc9141a5038c73ed594'] A the preof functions to be supported for each s-label. {114: 1, 26: 1, 61: 1, 113: 1, 27: 1, 6: 4, 79: 4, 90: 3, 51: 4, 130: 4, 62: 6, 85: 7, 68: 6, 35: 5, 110: 3, 91: 5, 97: 4, 31: 4, 13: 3, 67: 3, 124: 5, 98: 4, 54: 4, 127: 5, 8: 4, 96: 4, 64: 4, 30: 4, 55: 5, 15: 3, 52: 3, 129: 5, 115: 3, 84: 3, 76: 8, 87: 3, 131: 7, 102: 3, 99: 4, 36: 3, 24: 2, 53: 3, 72: 4} {58: 1, 97: 1, 130: 1, 291: 1, 147: 1, 372: 1, 1: 11, 4: 4, 9: 7, 10: 5, 15: 4, 24: 4, 25: 6, 26: 7, 27: 4, 39: 7, 43: 5, 49: 6, 50: 5, 59: 4, 64: 4, 69: 6, 81: 7, 82: 5, 86: 3, 100: 8, 108: 5, 109: 6, 110: 6, 111: 4, 114: 5, 115: 6, 116: 4, 118: 8, 119: 7, 120: 5, 121: 6, 122: 5, 123: 4, 124: 6, 128: 4, 129: 4, 132: 6, 136: 4, 145: 6, 151: 4, 152: 4, 154: 5, 156: 3, 161: 5, 162: 5, 165: 5, 168: 6, 169: 3, 172: 3, 180: 4, 184: 7, 187: 7, 188: 6, 191: 5, 194: 6, 202: 7, 203: 8, 206: 4, 207: 5, 215: 4, 217: 5, 218: 10, 220: 4, 221: 4, 222: 7, 224: 5, 227: 6, 229: 3, 234: 7, 235: 4, 241: 4, 242: 4, 243: 6, 244: 4, 245: 6, 248: 4, 250: 5, 258: 13, 262: 6, 263: 7, 264: 5, 267: 6, 270: 4, 272: 3, 273: 7, 287: 5, 289: 3, 299: 6, 300: 4, 304: 4, 309: 5, 314: 4, 315: 3, 320: 6, 323: 6, 327: 6, 328: 5, 329: 4, 330: 12, 334: 4, 335: 4, 341: 6, 342: 7, 347: 6, 348: 6, 350: 9, 351: 5, 352: 3, 353: 3, 354: 2, 358: 6, 365: 3, 366: 4, 369: 3, 371: 8, 376: 4, 384: 5, 385: 4, 386: 5, 387: 4, 392: 5, 393: 6, 396: 7, 397: 9, 398: 8, 402: 3} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 38 The mapping of each S-Label to an F-Label stack. mpls - over - ip : minor tweaks ipOmpls : Section 6 , Management and Control Information Summary mpls : editorial changes , refactoring of section 5 for clarity and completeness white space cleanup ( remove tabs and trailing spaces ) 6eef101c3c863f944da82ed2f9cc38205de8aa61 6eef101c3c863f944da82ed2f9cc38205de8aa61 draft-ietf-detnet-mpls d4d0f5b26265d5747482d4c8c93706edd735ad6b653327445de5a09a5dcc5c2b ['3ef84f782267c0e0e968196f92f0e857d46f4f9ba7afbddce796cc8c50975a16', '2e08e5d79759a80040647153ce3fa7819f0612da07f964d940457940ee32eefb', 'd645de25ddd5a17db4ac8e4152ab9f48880b0362f999693b780b953092b4818b', '5afe7b6130289b07fae3f2293f0b50942f6484999592ab78deeb684af0961b90', '5496f74277f5150125eda22755e4e5935e4d30373ae21b9d251791bb3af70771', 'e0272e86b037d5f460db4807aede2c02c9d02cb129d656c91aa723e14be8738c', 'e88833dfc4793019fd0d380a39254338e0e1620775d4f0f64ba50f65f6304990', '2e1188e3ae68f9645fceeb16885fb2558ac488250197b0dac87311b7f9fc7ba3', '236b9ded3b3585aca0a348dc8cf9b49717f1a76ca847c280134ba2cafca9e2bf', 'c99484d301684eba379e2eaab522e22872390f584d0977611a9b71cd4e36e2a9', 'd4d0f5b26265d5747482d4c8c93706edd735ad6b653327445de5a09a5dcc5c2b', '3ad381ce14d392b11bc71c7f84aec9aa4faec501b897070e8cad5dfe435f09ff', '75d8fb6c0eaa04ce99a6045642bc5e15246a22b21f752b965c428b1072c46889', '959f68af8dfd80b8f76ac61803f842c5d5465c96fe9a54320df01a59d427bc74', 'ab1acdf4e7456e3c0c48ecf2a80771c96f1006cd94d541736e1432d7df837fff', 'f584b276947e0b5979b2a9dc3254f10386b70b330438a9e2550d507641ada606', '274b6784d8b0e783b41d9ab3fb59f83a07021384d77a8301c21ba682ca514f8e', '3d36d1a44dc7d02361253be531685a7847ff919030e830b3b7d33da323864bba', '5bbe3d686024848f24fe238d32a57ce72d50b8fbeebade01a3437d75950aab78', '29ea94d06c6751fb47652496c82e1e9d54be60eb454edad2d4cc70305b7e7f6e', 'e19a400eccb294099834cd56397edb9329d003e8e7f8394c8510ecb4ff2e9d49', '0c083cb2dbd6e02c5070ac69ebd99deb41243b9c86516b946c30254bc9ccdfa3', '3e1ecc54327242ce7149d3b94e40a827984e34f421957d76e724befb47850aea', 'fad466a738de01a3d36eccbe586f4d8fc8e0e794e6bc9a207ec1dfbc50cfc690', '11750e495d361a550d77d6e936bd58a2696b27b9dd7d52475b2bc378ab46e66a', '9207956b1757a8ef10e8b8533004f05c18df92096f40432e53657c80998e21d0', 'b863dd515fc616b5f20d11da86ec171c6d64e3cdd1fecce3d9201a8f011ed918', 'da347c609aa36f0a6fe6d9365f7d3f5ef3502894bbb295f976fd4029d2dbed7c', '6e504eddc254b4618c44e3887d0b3f48b87c3f8b7253974cc0ffc04032bd0eef', 'ab4458406f2073e0bb0cbb77d0c295e95a669935cc2eb6d6f9ad03fb919856f1', '2a2e824a93c12293bd306cfff5b94f9aa2d149e4b03e04b44ad5d10090ab59c1', 'f4580b2be48d5ff6900dff6228fd62d66670888dae4c7128179d74de159d034a', '196c688b79a90f8cf628b79d0930ce6b3ff72fb8c443b7225899a0d1fdc0acad', '41c131676852283c2ee7fed18fd9381091897a583dc88fc9141a5038c73ed594'] A the mapping of each s-label to an f-label stack. {114: 1, 26: 1, 61: 1, 113: 1, 27: 1, 6: 4, 79: 4, 90: 3, 51: 4, 130: 4, 62: 6, 85: 7, 68: 6, 35: 5, 110: 3, 91: 5, 97: 4, 31: 4, 13: 3, 67: 3, 124: 5, 98: 4, 54: 4, 127: 5, 8: 4, 96: 4, 64: 4, 30: 4, 55: 5, 15: 3, 52: 3, 129: 5, 115: 3, 84: 3, 76: 8, 87: 3, 131: 7, 102: 3, 99: 4, 36: 3, 24: 2, 53: 3, 72: 4} {58: 1, 97: 1, 130: 1, 291: 1, 147: 1, 372: 1, 1: 11, 4: 4, 9: 7, 10: 5, 15: 4, 24: 4, 25: 6, 26: 7, 27: 4, 39: 7, 43: 5, 49: 6, 50: 5, 59: 4, 64: 4, 69: 6, 81: 7, 82: 5, 86: 3, 100: 8, 108: 5, 109: 6, 110: 6, 111: 4, 114: 5, 115: 6, 116: 4, 118: 8, 119: 7, 120: 5, 121: 6, 122: 5, 123: 4, 124: 6, 128: 4, 129: 4, 132: 6, 136: 4, 145: 6, 151: 4, 152: 4, 154: 5, 156: 3, 161: 5, 162: 5, 165: 5, 168: 6, 169: 3, 172: 3, 180: 4, 184: 7, 187: 7, 188: 6, 191: 5, 194: 6, 202: 7, 203: 8, 206: 4, 207: 5, 215: 4, 217: 5, 218: 10, 220: 4, 221: 4, 222: 7, 224: 5, 227: 6, 229: 3, 234: 7, 235: 4, 241: 4, 242: 4, 243: 6, 244: 4, 245: 6, 248: 4, 250: 5, 258: 13, 262: 6, 263: 7, 264: 5, 267: 6, 270: 4, 272: 3, 273: 7, 287: 5, 289: 3, 299: 6, 300: 4, 304: 4, 309: 5, 314: 4, 315: 3, 320: 6, 323: 6, 327: 6, 328: 5, 329: 4, 330: 12, 334: 4, 335: 4, 341: 6, 342: 7, 347: 6, 348: 6, 350: 9, 351: 5, 352: 3, 353: 3, 354: 2, 358: 6, 365: 3, 366: 4, 369: 3, 371: 8, 376: 4, 384: 5, 385: 4, 386: 5, 387: 4, 392: 5, 393: 6, 396: 7, 397: 9, 398: 8, 402: 3} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 38 S-Labels to A-Label mappings. mpls - over - ip : minor tweaks ipOmpls : Section 6 , Management and Control Information Summary mpls : editorial changes , refactoring of section 5 for clarity and completeness white space cleanup ( remove tabs and trailing spaces ) 6eef101c3c863f944da82ed2f9cc38205de8aa61 6eef101c3c863f944da82ed2f9cc38205de8aa61 draft-ietf-detnet-mpls 959f68af8dfd80b8f76ac61803f842c5d5465c96fe9a54320df01a59d427bc74 ['3ef84f782267c0e0e968196f92f0e857d46f4f9ba7afbddce796cc8c50975a16', '2e08e5d79759a80040647153ce3fa7819f0612da07f964d940457940ee32eefb', 'd645de25ddd5a17db4ac8e4152ab9f48880b0362f999693b780b953092b4818b', '5afe7b6130289b07fae3f2293f0b50942f6484999592ab78deeb684af0961b90', '5496f74277f5150125eda22755e4e5935e4d30373ae21b9d251791bb3af70771', 'e0272e86b037d5f460db4807aede2c02c9d02cb129d656c91aa723e14be8738c', 'e88833dfc4793019fd0d380a39254338e0e1620775d4f0f64ba50f65f6304990', '2e1188e3ae68f9645fceeb16885fb2558ac488250197b0dac87311b7f9fc7ba3', '236b9ded3b3585aca0a348dc8cf9b49717f1a76ca847c280134ba2cafca9e2bf', 'c99484d301684eba379e2eaab522e22872390f584d0977611a9b71cd4e36e2a9', 'd4d0f5b26265d5747482d4c8c93706edd735ad6b653327445de5a09a5dcc5c2b', '3ad381ce14d392b11bc71c7f84aec9aa4faec501b897070e8cad5dfe435f09ff', '75d8fb6c0eaa04ce99a6045642bc5e15246a22b21f752b965c428b1072c46889', '959f68af8dfd80b8f76ac61803f842c5d5465c96fe9a54320df01a59d427bc74', 'ab1acdf4e7456e3c0c48ecf2a80771c96f1006cd94d541736e1432d7df837fff', 'f584b276947e0b5979b2a9dc3254f10386b70b330438a9e2550d507641ada606', '274b6784d8b0e783b41d9ab3fb59f83a07021384d77a8301c21ba682ca514f8e', '3d36d1a44dc7d02361253be531685a7847ff919030e830b3b7d33da323864bba', '5bbe3d686024848f24fe238d32a57ce72d50b8fbeebade01a3437d75950aab78', '29ea94d06c6751fb47652496c82e1e9d54be60eb454edad2d4cc70305b7e7f6e', 'e19a400eccb294099834cd56397edb9329d003e8e7f8394c8510ecb4ff2e9d49', '0c083cb2dbd6e02c5070ac69ebd99deb41243b9c86516b946c30254bc9ccdfa3', '3e1ecc54327242ce7149d3b94e40a827984e34f421957d76e724befb47850aea', 'fad466a738de01a3d36eccbe586f4d8fc8e0e794e6bc9a207ec1dfbc50cfc690', '11750e495d361a550d77d6e936bd58a2696b27b9dd7d52475b2bc378ab46e66a', '9207956b1757a8ef10e8b8533004f05c18df92096f40432e53657c80998e21d0', 'b863dd515fc616b5f20d11da86ec171c6d64e3cdd1fecce3d9201a8f011ed918', 'da347c609aa36f0a6fe6d9365f7d3f5ef3502894bbb295f976fd4029d2dbed7c', '6e504eddc254b4618c44e3887d0b3f48b87c3f8b7253974cc0ffc04032bd0eef', 'ab4458406f2073e0bb0cbb77d0c295e95a669935cc2eb6d6f9ad03fb919856f1', '2a2e824a93c12293bd306cfff5b94f9aa2d149e4b03e04b44ad5d10090ab59c1', 'f4580b2be48d5ff6900dff6228fd62d66670888dae4c7128179d74de159d034a', '196c688b79a90f8cf628b79d0930ce6b3ff72fb8c443b7225899a0d1fdc0acad', '41c131676852283c2ee7fed18fd9381091897a583dc88fc9141a5038c73ed594'] A s-labels to a-label mappings. {114: 1, 26: 1, 61: 1, 113: 1, 27: 1, 6: 4, 79: 4, 90: 3, 51: 4, 130: 4, 62: 6, 85: 7, 68: 6, 35: 5, 110: 3, 91: 5, 97: 4, 31: 4, 13: 3, 67: 3, 124: 5, 98: 4, 54: 4, 127: 5, 8: 4, 96: 4, 64: 4, 30: 4, 55: 5, 15: 3, 52: 3, 129: 5, 115: 3, 84: 3, 76: 8, 87: 3, 131: 7, 102: 3, 99: 4, 36: 3, 24: 2, 53: 3, 72: 4} {58: 1, 97: 1, 130: 1, 291: 1, 147: 1, 372: 1, 1: 11, 4: 4, 9: 7, 10: 5, 15: 4, 24: 4, 25: 6, 26: 7, 27: 4, 39: 7, 43: 5, 49: 6, 50: 5, 59: 4, 64: 4, 69: 6, 81: 7, 82: 5, 86: 3, 100: 8, 108: 5, 109: 6, 110: 6, 111: 4, 114: 5, 115: 6, 116: 4, 118: 8, 119: 7, 120: 5, 121: 6, 122: 5, 123: 4, 124: 6, 128: 4, 129: 4, 132: 6, 136: 4, 145: 6, 151: 4, 152: 4, 154: 5, 156: 3, 161: 5, 162: 5, 165: 5, 168: 6, 169: 3, 172: 3, 180: 4, 184: 7, 187: 7, 188: 6, 191: 5, 194: 6, 202: 7, 203: 8, 206: 4, 207: 5, 215: 4, 217: 5, 218: 10, 220: 4, 221: 4, 222: 7, 224: 5, 227: 6, 229: 3, 234: 7, 235: 4, 241: 4, 242: 4, 243: 6, 244: 4, 245: 6, 248: 4, 250: 5, 258: 13, 262: 6, 263: 7, 264: 5, 267: 6, 270: 4, 272: 3, 273: 7, 287: 5, 289: 3, 299: 6, 300: 4, 304: 4, 309: 5, 314: 4, 315: 3, 320: 6, 323: 6, 327: 6, 328: 5, 329: 4, 330: 12, 334: 4, 335: 4, 341: 6, 342: 7, 347: 6, 348: 6, 350: 9, 351: 5, 352: 3, 353: 3, 354: 2, 358: 6, 365: 3, 366: 4, 369: 3, 371: 8, 376: 4, 384: 5, 385: 4, 386: 5, 387: 4, 392: 5, 393: 6, 396: 7, 397: 9, 398: 8, 402: 3} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 38 A-Label values and service parameters. mpls - over - ip : minor tweaks ipOmpls : Section 6 , Management and Control Information Summary mpls : editorial changes , refactoring of section 5 for clarity and completeness white space cleanup ( remove tabs and trailing spaces ) 6eef101c3c863f944da82ed2f9cc38205de8aa61 6eef101c3c863f944da82ed2f9cc38205de8aa61 draft-ietf-detnet-mpls da347c609aa36f0a6fe6d9365f7d3f5ef3502894bbb295f976fd4029d2dbed7c ['3ef84f782267c0e0e968196f92f0e857d46f4f9ba7afbddce796cc8c50975a16', '2e08e5d79759a80040647153ce3fa7819f0612da07f964d940457940ee32eefb', 'd645de25ddd5a17db4ac8e4152ab9f48880b0362f999693b780b953092b4818b', '5afe7b6130289b07fae3f2293f0b50942f6484999592ab78deeb684af0961b90', '5496f74277f5150125eda22755e4e5935e4d30373ae21b9d251791bb3af70771', 'e0272e86b037d5f460db4807aede2c02c9d02cb129d656c91aa723e14be8738c', 'e88833dfc4793019fd0d380a39254338e0e1620775d4f0f64ba50f65f6304990', '2e1188e3ae68f9645fceeb16885fb2558ac488250197b0dac87311b7f9fc7ba3', '236b9ded3b3585aca0a348dc8cf9b49717f1a76ca847c280134ba2cafca9e2bf', 'c99484d301684eba379e2eaab522e22872390f584d0977611a9b71cd4e36e2a9', 'd4d0f5b26265d5747482d4c8c93706edd735ad6b653327445de5a09a5dcc5c2b', '3ad381ce14d392b11bc71c7f84aec9aa4faec501b897070e8cad5dfe435f09ff', '75d8fb6c0eaa04ce99a6045642bc5e15246a22b21f752b965c428b1072c46889', '959f68af8dfd80b8f76ac61803f842c5d5465c96fe9a54320df01a59d427bc74', 'ab1acdf4e7456e3c0c48ecf2a80771c96f1006cd94d541736e1432d7df837fff', 'f584b276947e0b5979b2a9dc3254f10386b70b330438a9e2550d507641ada606', '274b6784d8b0e783b41d9ab3fb59f83a07021384d77a8301c21ba682ca514f8e', '3d36d1a44dc7d02361253be531685a7847ff919030e830b3b7d33da323864bba', '5bbe3d686024848f24fe238d32a57ce72d50b8fbeebade01a3437d75950aab78', '29ea94d06c6751fb47652496c82e1e9d54be60eb454edad2d4cc70305b7e7f6e', 'e19a400eccb294099834cd56397edb9329d003e8e7f8394c8510ecb4ff2e9d49', '0c083cb2dbd6e02c5070ac69ebd99deb41243b9c86516b946c30254bc9ccdfa3', '3e1ecc54327242ce7149d3b94e40a827984e34f421957d76e724befb47850aea', 'fad466a738de01a3d36eccbe586f4d8fc8e0e794e6bc9a207ec1dfbc50cfc690', '11750e495d361a550d77d6e936bd58a2696b27b9dd7d52475b2bc378ab46e66a', '9207956b1757a8ef10e8b8533004f05c18df92096f40432e53657c80998e21d0', 'b863dd515fc616b5f20d11da86ec171c6d64e3cdd1fecce3d9201a8f011ed918', 'da347c609aa36f0a6fe6d9365f7d3f5ef3502894bbb295f976fd4029d2dbed7c', '6e504eddc254b4618c44e3887d0b3f48b87c3f8b7253974cc0ffc04032bd0eef', 'ab4458406f2073e0bb0cbb77d0c295e95a669935cc2eb6d6f9ad03fb919856f1', '2a2e824a93c12293bd306cfff5b94f9aa2d149e4b03e04b44ad5d10090ab59c1', 'f4580b2be48d5ff6900dff6228fd62d66670888dae4c7128179d74de159d034a', '196c688b79a90f8cf628b79d0930ce6b3ff72fb8c443b7225899a0d1fdc0acad', '41c131676852283c2ee7fed18fd9381091897a583dc88fc9141a5038c73ed594'] A a-label values and service parameters. {114: 1, 26: 1, 61: 1, 113: 1, 27: 1, 6: 4, 79: 4, 90: 3, 51: 4, 130: 4, 62: 6, 85: 7, 68: 6, 35: 5, 110: 3, 91: 5, 97: 4, 31: 4, 13: 3, 67: 3, 124: 5, 98: 4, 54: 4, 127: 5, 8: 4, 96: 4, 64: 4, 30: 4, 55: 5, 15: 3, 52: 3, 129: 5, 115: 3, 84: 3, 76: 8, 87: 3, 131: 7, 102: 3, 99: 4, 36: 3, 24: 2, 53: 3, 72: 4} {58: 1, 97: 1, 130: 1, 291: 1, 147: 1, 372: 1, 1: 11, 4: 4, 9: 7, 10: 5, 15: 4, 24: 4, 25: 6, 26: 7, 27: 4, 39: 7, 43: 5, 49: 6, 50: 5, 59: 4, 64: 4, 69: 6, 81: 7, 82: 5, 86: 3, 100: 8, 108: 5, 109: 6, 110: 6, 111: 4, 114: 5, 115: 6, 116: 4, 118: 8, 119: 7, 120: 5, 121: 6, 122: 5, 123: 4, 124: 6, 128: 4, 129: 4, 132: 6, 136: 4, 145: 6, 151: 4, 152: 4, 154: 5, 156: 3, 161: 5, 162: 5, 165: 5, 168: 6, 169: 3, 172: 3, 180: 4, 184: 7, 187: 7, 188: 6, 191: 5, 194: 6, 202: 7, 203: 8, 206: 4, 207: 5, 215: 4, 217: 5, 218: 10, 220: 4, 221: 4, 222: 7, 224: 5, 227: 6, 229: 3, 234: 7, 235: 4, 241: 4, 242: 4, 243: 6, 244: 4, 245: 6, 248: 4, 250: 5, 258: 13, 262: 6, 263: 7, 264: 5, 267: 6, 270: 4, 272: 3, 273: 7, 287: 5, 289: 3, 299: 6, 300: 4, 304: 4, 309: 5, 314: 4, 315: 3, 320: 6, 323: 6, 327: 6, 328: 5, 329: 4, 330: 12, 334: 4, 335: 4, 341: 6, 342: 7, 347: 6, 348: 6, 350: 9, 351: 5, 352: 3, 353: 3, 354: 2, 358: 6, 365: 3, 366: 4, 369: 3, 371: 8, 376: 4, 384: 5, 385: 4, 386: 5, 387: 4, 392: 5, 393: 6, 396: 7, 397: 9, 398: 8, 402: 3} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 38 Each DetNet F-Label value and associated traffic parameters. mpls - over - ip : minor tweaks ipOmpls : Section 6 , Management and Control Information Summary mpls : editorial changes , refactoring of section 5 for clarity and completeness white space cleanup ( remove tabs and trailing spaces ) 6eef101c3c863f944da82ed2f9cc38205de8aa61 6eef101c3c863f944da82ed2f9cc38205de8aa61 draft-ietf-detnet-mpls c99484d301684eba379e2eaab522e22872390f584d0977611a9b71cd4e36e2a9 ['3ef84f782267c0e0e968196f92f0e857d46f4f9ba7afbddce796cc8c50975a16', '2e08e5d79759a80040647153ce3fa7819f0612da07f964d940457940ee32eefb', 'd645de25ddd5a17db4ac8e4152ab9f48880b0362f999693b780b953092b4818b', '5afe7b6130289b07fae3f2293f0b50942f6484999592ab78deeb684af0961b90', '5496f74277f5150125eda22755e4e5935e4d30373ae21b9d251791bb3af70771', 'e0272e86b037d5f460db4807aede2c02c9d02cb129d656c91aa723e14be8738c', 'e88833dfc4793019fd0d380a39254338e0e1620775d4f0f64ba50f65f6304990', '2e1188e3ae68f9645fceeb16885fb2558ac488250197b0dac87311b7f9fc7ba3', '236b9ded3b3585aca0a348dc8cf9b49717f1a76ca847c280134ba2cafca9e2bf', 'c99484d301684eba379e2eaab522e22872390f584d0977611a9b71cd4e36e2a9', 'd4d0f5b26265d5747482d4c8c93706edd735ad6b653327445de5a09a5dcc5c2b', '3ad381ce14d392b11bc71c7f84aec9aa4faec501b897070e8cad5dfe435f09ff', '75d8fb6c0eaa04ce99a6045642bc5e15246a22b21f752b965c428b1072c46889', '959f68af8dfd80b8f76ac61803f842c5d5465c96fe9a54320df01a59d427bc74', 'ab1acdf4e7456e3c0c48ecf2a80771c96f1006cd94d541736e1432d7df837fff', 'f584b276947e0b5979b2a9dc3254f10386b70b330438a9e2550d507641ada606', '274b6784d8b0e783b41d9ab3fb59f83a07021384d77a8301c21ba682ca514f8e', '3d36d1a44dc7d02361253be531685a7847ff919030e830b3b7d33da323864bba', '5bbe3d686024848f24fe238d32a57ce72d50b8fbeebade01a3437d75950aab78', '29ea94d06c6751fb47652496c82e1e9d54be60eb454edad2d4cc70305b7e7f6e', 'e19a400eccb294099834cd56397edb9329d003e8e7f8394c8510ecb4ff2e9d49', '0c083cb2dbd6e02c5070ac69ebd99deb41243b9c86516b946c30254bc9ccdfa3', '3e1ecc54327242ce7149d3b94e40a827984e34f421957d76e724befb47850aea', 'fad466a738de01a3d36eccbe586f4d8fc8e0e794e6bc9a207ec1dfbc50cfc690', '11750e495d361a550d77d6e936bd58a2696b27b9dd7d52475b2bc378ab46e66a', '9207956b1757a8ef10e8b8533004f05c18df92096f40432e53657c80998e21d0', 'b863dd515fc616b5f20d11da86ec171c6d64e3cdd1fecce3d9201a8f011ed918', 'da347c609aa36f0a6fe6d9365f7d3f5ef3502894bbb295f976fd4029d2dbed7c', '6e504eddc254b4618c44e3887d0b3f48b87c3f8b7253974cc0ffc04032bd0eef', 'ab4458406f2073e0bb0cbb77d0c295e95a669935cc2eb6d6f9ad03fb919856f1', '2a2e824a93c12293bd306cfff5b94f9aa2d149e4b03e04b44ad5d10090ab59c1', 'f4580b2be48d5ff6900dff6228fd62d66670888dae4c7128179d74de159d034a', '196c688b79a90f8cf628b79d0930ce6b3ff72fb8c443b7225899a0d1fdc0acad', '41c131676852283c2ee7fed18fd9381091897a583dc88fc9141a5038c73ed594'] A each detnet f-label value and associated traffic parameters. {114: 1, 26: 1, 61: 1, 113: 1, 27: 1, 6: 4, 79: 4, 90: 3, 51: 4, 130: 4, 62: 6, 85: 7, 68: 6, 35: 5, 110: 3, 91: 5, 97: 4, 31: 4, 13: 3, 67: 3, 124: 5, 98: 4, 54: 4, 127: 5, 8: 4, 96: 4, 64: 4, 30: 4, 55: 5, 15: 3, 52: 3, 129: 5, 115: 3, 84: 3, 76: 8, 87: 3, 131: 7, 102: 3, 99: 4, 36: 3, 24: 2, 53: 3, 72: 4} {58: 1, 97: 1, 130: 1, 291: 1, 147: 1, 372: 1, 1: 11, 4: 4, 9: 7, 10: 5, 15: 4, 24: 4, 25: 6, 26: 7, 27: 4, 39: 7, 43: 5, 49: 6, 50: 5, 59: 4, 64: 4, 69: 6, 81: 7, 82: 5, 86: 3, 100: 8, 108: 5, 109: 6, 110: 6, 111: 4, 114: 5, 115: 6, 116: 4, 118: 8, 119: 7, 120: 5, 121: 6, 122: 5, 123: 4, 124: 6, 128: 4, 129: 4, 132: 6, 136: 4, 145: 6, 151: 4, 152: 4, 154: 5, 156: 3, 161: 5, 162: 5, 165: 5, 168: 6, 169: 3, 172: 3, 180: 4, 184: 7, 187: 7, 188: 6, 191: 5, 194: 6, 202: 7, 203: 8, 206: 4, 207: 5, 215: 4, 217: 5, 218: 10, 220: 4, 221: 4, 222: 7, 224: 5, 227: 6, 229: 3, 234: 7, 235: 4, 241: 4, 242: 4, 243: 6, 244: 4, 245: 6, 248: 4, 250: 5, 258: 13, 262: 6, 263: 7, 264: 5, 267: 6, 270: 4, 272: 3, 273: 7, 287: 5, 289: 3, 299: 6, 300: 4, 304: 4, 309: 5, 314: 4, 315: 3, 320: 6, 323: 6, 327: 6, 328: 5, 329: 4, 330: 12, 334: 4, 335: 4, 341: 6, 342: 7, 347: 6, 348: 6, 350: 9, 351: 5, 352: 3, 353: 3, 354: 2, 358: 6, 365: 3, 366: 4, 369: 3, 371: 8, 376: 4, 384: 5, 385: 4, 386: 5, 387: 4, 392: 5, 393: 6, 396: 7, 397: 9, 398: 8, 402: 3} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 38 F-Label to H-LSP mappings. mpls - over - ip : minor tweaks ipOmpls : Section 6 , Management and Control Information Summary mpls : editorial changes , refactoring of section 5 for clarity and completeness white space cleanup ( remove tabs and trailing spaces ) 6eef101c3c863f944da82ed2f9cc38205de8aa61 6eef101c3c863f944da82ed2f9cc38205de8aa61 draft-ietf-detnet-mpls e0272e86b037d5f460db4807aede2c02c9d02cb129d656c91aa723e14be8738c ['3ef84f782267c0e0e968196f92f0e857d46f4f9ba7afbddce796cc8c50975a16', '2e08e5d79759a80040647153ce3fa7819f0612da07f964d940457940ee32eefb', 'd645de25ddd5a17db4ac8e4152ab9f48880b0362f999693b780b953092b4818b', '5afe7b6130289b07fae3f2293f0b50942f6484999592ab78deeb684af0961b90', '5496f74277f5150125eda22755e4e5935e4d30373ae21b9d251791bb3af70771', 'e0272e86b037d5f460db4807aede2c02c9d02cb129d656c91aa723e14be8738c', 'e88833dfc4793019fd0d380a39254338e0e1620775d4f0f64ba50f65f6304990', '2e1188e3ae68f9645fceeb16885fb2558ac488250197b0dac87311b7f9fc7ba3', '236b9ded3b3585aca0a348dc8cf9b49717f1a76ca847c280134ba2cafca9e2bf', 'c99484d301684eba379e2eaab522e22872390f584d0977611a9b71cd4e36e2a9', 'd4d0f5b26265d5747482d4c8c93706edd735ad6b653327445de5a09a5dcc5c2b', '3ad381ce14d392b11bc71c7f84aec9aa4faec501b897070e8cad5dfe435f09ff', '75d8fb6c0eaa04ce99a6045642bc5e15246a22b21f752b965c428b1072c46889', '959f68af8dfd80b8f76ac61803f842c5d5465c96fe9a54320df01a59d427bc74', 'ab1acdf4e7456e3c0c48ecf2a80771c96f1006cd94d541736e1432d7df837fff', 'f584b276947e0b5979b2a9dc3254f10386b70b330438a9e2550d507641ada606', '274b6784d8b0e783b41d9ab3fb59f83a07021384d77a8301c21ba682ca514f8e', '3d36d1a44dc7d02361253be531685a7847ff919030e830b3b7d33da323864bba', '5bbe3d686024848f24fe238d32a57ce72d50b8fbeebade01a3437d75950aab78', '29ea94d06c6751fb47652496c82e1e9d54be60eb454edad2d4cc70305b7e7f6e', 'e19a400eccb294099834cd56397edb9329d003e8e7f8394c8510ecb4ff2e9d49', '0c083cb2dbd6e02c5070ac69ebd99deb41243b9c86516b946c30254bc9ccdfa3', '3e1ecc54327242ce7149d3b94e40a827984e34f421957d76e724befb47850aea', 'fad466a738de01a3d36eccbe586f4d8fc8e0e794e6bc9a207ec1dfbc50cfc690', '11750e495d361a550d77d6e936bd58a2696b27b9dd7d52475b2bc378ab46e66a', '9207956b1757a8ef10e8b8533004f05c18df92096f40432e53657c80998e21d0', 'b863dd515fc616b5f20d11da86ec171c6d64e3cdd1fecce3d9201a8f011ed918', 'da347c609aa36f0a6fe6d9365f7d3f5ef3502894bbb295f976fd4029d2dbed7c', '6e504eddc254b4618c44e3887d0b3f48b87c3f8b7253974cc0ffc04032bd0eef', 'ab4458406f2073e0bb0cbb77d0c295e95a669935cc2eb6d6f9ad03fb919856f1', '2a2e824a93c12293bd306cfff5b94f9aa2d149e4b03e04b44ad5d10090ab59c1', 'f4580b2be48d5ff6900dff6228fd62d66670888dae4c7128179d74de159d034a', '196c688b79a90f8cf628b79d0930ce6b3ff72fb8c443b7225899a0d1fdc0acad', '41c131676852283c2ee7fed18fd9381091897a583dc88fc9141a5038c73ed594'] A f-label to h-lsp mappings. {114: 1, 26: 1, 61: 1, 113: 1, 27: 1, 6: 4, 79: 4, 90: 3, 51: 4, 130: 4, 62: 6, 85: 7, 68: 6, 35: 5, 110: 3, 91: 5, 97: 4, 31: 4, 13: 3, 67: 3, 124: 5, 98: 4, 54: 4, 127: 5, 8: 4, 96: 4, 64: 4, 30: 4, 55: 5, 15: 3, 52: 3, 129: 5, 115: 3, 84: 3, 76: 8, 87: 3, 131: 7, 102: 3, 99: 4, 36: 3, 24: 2, 53: 3, 72: 4} {58: 1, 97: 1, 130: 1, 291: 1, 147: 1, 372: 1, 1: 11, 4: 4, 9: 7, 10: 5, 15: 4, 24: 4, 25: 6, 26: 7, 27: 4, 39: 7, 43: 5, 49: 6, 50: 5, 59: 4, 64: 4, 69: 6, 81: 7, 82: 5, 86: 3, 100: 8, 108: 5, 109: 6, 110: 6, 111: 4, 114: 5, 115: 6, 116: 4, 118: 8, 119: 7, 120: 5, 121: 6, 122: 5, 123: 4, 124: 6, 128: 4, 129: 4, 132: 6, 136: 4, 145: 6, 151: 4, 152: 4, 154: 5, 156: 3, 161: 5, 162: 5, 165: 5, 168: 6, 169: 3, 172: 3, 180: 4, 184: 7, 187: 7, 188: 6, 191: 5, 194: 6, 202: 7, 203: 8, 206: 4, 207: 5, 215: 4, 217: 5, 218: 10, 220: 4, 221: 4, 222: 7, 224: 5, 227: 6, 229: 3, 234: 7, 235: 4, 241: 4, 242: 4, 243: 6, 244: 4, 245: 6, 248: 4, 250: 5, 258: 13, 262: 6, 263: 7, 264: 5, 267: 6, 270: 4, 272: 3, 273: 7, 287: 5, 289: 3, 299: 6, 300: 4, 304: 4, 309: 5, 314: 4, 315: 3, 320: 6, 323: 6, 327: 6, 328: 5, 329: 4, 330: 12, 334: 4, 335: 4, 341: 6, 342: 7, 347: 6, 348: 6, 350: 9, 351: 5, 352: 3, 353: 3, 354: 2, 358: 6, 365: 3, 366: 4, 369: 3, 371: 8, 376: 4, 384: 5, 385: 4, 386: 5, 387: 4, 392: 5, 393: 6, 396: 7, 397: 9, 398: 8, 402: 3} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 38 H-LSP label values and associated parameters. mpls - over - ip : minor tweaks ipOmpls : Section 6 , Management and Control Information Summary mpls : editorial changes , refactoring of section 5 for clarity and completeness white space cleanup ( remove tabs and trailing spaces ) 6eef101c3c863f944da82ed2f9cc38205de8aa61 6eef101c3c863f944da82ed2f9cc38205de8aa61 draft-ietf-detnet-mpls 29ea94d06c6751fb47652496c82e1e9d54be60eb454edad2d4cc70305b7e7f6e ['3ef84f782267c0e0e968196f92f0e857d46f4f9ba7afbddce796cc8c50975a16', '2e08e5d79759a80040647153ce3fa7819f0612da07f964d940457940ee32eefb', 'd645de25ddd5a17db4ac8e4152ab9f48880b0362f999693b780b953092b4818b', '5afe7b6130289b07fae3f2293f0b50942f6484999592ab78deeb684af0961b90', '5496f74277f5150125eda22755e4e5935e4d30373ae21b9d251791bb3af70771', 'e0272e86b037d5f460db4807aede2c02c9d02cb129d656c91aa723e14be8738c', 'e88833dfc4793019fd0d380a39254338e0e1620775d4f0f64ba50f65f6304990', '2e1188e3ae68f9645fceeb16885fb2558ac488250197b0dac87311b7f9fc7ba3', '236b9ded3b3585aca0a348dc8cf9b49717f1a76ca847c280134ba2cafca9e2bf', 'c99484d301684eba379e2eaab522e22872390f584d0977611a9b71cd4e36e2a9', 'd4d0f5b26265d5747482d4c8c93706edd735ad6b653327445de5a09a5dcc5c2b', '3ad381ce14d392b11bc71c7f84aec9aa4faec501b897070e8cad5dfe435f09ff', '75d8fb6c0eaa04ce99a6045642bc5e15246a22b21f752b965c428b1072c46889', '959f68af8dfd80b8f76ac61803f842c5d5465c96fe9a54320df01a59d427bc74', 'ab1acdf4e7456e3c0c48ecf2a80771c96f1006cd94d541736e1432d7df837fff', 'f584b276947e0b5979b2a9dc3254f10386b70b330438a9e2550d507641ada606', '274b6784d8b0e783b41d9ab3fb59f83a07021384d77a8301c21ba682ca514f8e', '3d36d1a44dc7d02361253be531685a7847ff919030e830b3b7d33da323864bba', '5bbe3d686024848f24fe238d32a57ce72d50b8fbeebade01a3437d75950aab78', '29ea94d06c6751fb47652496c82e1e9d54be60eb454edad2d4cc70305b7e7f6e', 'e19a400eccb294099834cd56397edb9329d003e8e7f8394c8510ecb4ff2e9d49', '0c083cb2dbd6e02c5070ac69ebd99deb41243b9c86516b946c30254bc9ccdfa3', '3e1ecc54327242ce7149d3b94e40a827984e34f421957d76e724befb47850aea', 'fad466a738de01a3d36eccbe586f4d8fc8e0e794e6bc9a207ec1dfbc50cfc690', '11750e495d361a550d77d6e936bd58a2696b27b9dd7d52475b2bc378ab46e66a', '9207956b1757a8ef10e8b8533004f05c18df92096f40432e53657c80998e21d0', 'b863dd515fc616b5f20d11da86ec171c6d64e3cdd1fecce3d9201a8f011ed918', 'da347c609aa36f0a6fe6d9365f7d3f5ef3502894bbb295f976fd4029d2dbed7c', '6e504eddc254b4618c44e3887d0b3f48b87c3f8b7253974cc0ffc04032bd0eef', 'ab4458406f2073e0bb0cbb77d0c295e95a669935cc2eb6d6f9ad03fb919856f1', '2a2e824a93c12293bd306cfff5b94f9aa2d149e4b03e04b44ad5d10090ab59c1', 'f4580b2be48d5ff6900dff6228fd62d66670888dae4c7128179d74de159d034a', '196c688b79a90f8cf628b79d0930ce6b3ff72fb8c443b7225899a0d1fdc0acad', '41c131676852283c2ee7fed18fd9381091897a583dc88fc9141a5038c73ed594'] A h-lsp label values and associated parameters. {114: 1, 26: 1, 61: 1, 113: 1, 27: 1, 6: 4, 79: 4, 90: 3, 51: 4, 130: 4, 62: 6, 85: 7, 68: 6, 35: 5, 110: 3, 91: 5, 97: 4, 31: 4, 13: 3, 67: 3, 124: 5, 98: 4, 54: 4, 127: 5, 8: 4, 96: 4, 64: 4, 30: 4, 55: 5, 15: 3, 52: 3, 129: 5, 115: 3, 84: 3, 76: 8, 87: 3, 131: 7, 102: 3, 99: 4, 36: 3, 24: 2, 53: 3, 72: 4} {58: 1, 97: 1, 130: 1, 291: 1, 147: 1, 372: 1, 1: 11, 4: 4, 9: 7, 10: 5, 15: 4, 24: 4, 25: 6, 26: 7, 27: 4, 39: 7, 43: 5, 49: 6, 50: 5, 59: 4, 64: 4, 69: 6, 81: 7, 82: 5, 86: 3, 100: 8, 108: 5, 109: 6, 110: 6, 111: 4, 114: 5, 115: 6, 116: 4, 118: 8, 119: 7, 120: 5, 121: 6, 122: 5, 123: 4, 124: 6, 128: 4, 129: 4, 132: 6, 136: 4, 145: 6, 151: 4, 152: 4, 154: 5, 156: 3, 161: 5, 162: 5, 165: 5, 168: 6, 169: 3, 172: 3, 180: 4, 184: 7, 187: 7, 188: 6, 191: 5, 194: 6, 202: 7, 203: 8, 206: 4, 207: 5, 215: 4, 217: 5, 218: 10, 220: 4, 221: 4, 222: 7, 224: 5, 227: 6, 229: 3, 234: 7, 235: 4, 241: 4, 242: 4, 243: 6, 244: 4, 245: 6, 248: 4, 250: 5, 258: 13, 262: 6, 263: 7, 264: 5, 267: 6, 270: 4, 272: 3, 273: 7, 287: 5, 289: 3, 299: 6, 300: 4, 304: 4, 309: 5, 314: 4, 315: 3, 320: 6, 323: 6, 327: 6, 328: 5, 329: 4, 330: 12, 334: 4, 335: 4, 341: 6, 342: 7, 347: 6, 348: 6, 350: 9, 351: 5, 352: 3, 353: 3, 354: 2, 358: 6, 365: 3, 366: 4, 369: 3, 371: 8, 376: 4, 384: 5, 385: 4, 386: 5, 387: 4, 392: 5, 393: 6, 396: 7, 397: 9, 398: 8, 402: 3} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 38 "Outgoing interface, next hop, and sub-network parameters on a technology specific basis." mpls - over - ip : minor tweaks ipOmpls : Section 6 , Management and Control Information Summary mpls : editorial changes , refactoring of section 5 for clarity and completeness white space cleanup ( remove tabs and trailing spaces ) 6eef101c3c863f944da82ed2f9cc38205de8aa61 6eef101c3c863f944da82ed2f9cc38205de8aa61 draft-ietf-detnet-mpls f4580b2be48d5ff6900dff6228fd62d66670888dae4c7128179d74de159d034a ['3ef84f782267c0e0e968196f92f0e857d46f4f9ba7afbddce796cc8c50975a16', '2e08e5d79759a80040647153ce3fa7819f0612da07f964d940457940ee32eefb', 'd645de25ddd5a17db4ac8e4152ab9f48880b0362f999693b780b953092b4818b', '5afe7b6130289b07fae3f2293f0b50942f6484999592ab78deeb684af0961b90', '5496f74277f5150125eda22755e4e5935e4d30373ae21b9d251791bb3af70771', 'e0272e86b037d5f460db4807aede2c02c9d02cb129d656c91aa723e14be8738c', 'e88833dfc4793019fd0d380a39254338e0e1620775d4f0f64ba50f65f6304990', '2e1188e3ae68f9645fceeb16885fb2558ac488250197b0dac87311b7f9fc7ba3', '236b9ded3b3585aca0a348dc8cf9b49717f1a76ca847c280134ba2cafca9e2bf', 'c99484d301684eba379e2eaab522e22872390f584d0977611a9b71cd4e36e2a9', 'd4d0f5b26265d5747482d4c8c93706edd735ad6b653327445de5a09a5dcc5c2b', '3ad381ce14d392b11bc71c7f84aec9aa4faec501b897070e8cad5dfe435f09ff', '75d8fb6c0eaa04ce99a6045642bc5e15246a22b21f752b965c428b1072c46889', '959f68af8dfd80b8f76ac61803f842c5d5465c96fe9a54320df01a59d427bc74', 'ab1acdf4e7456e3c0c48ecf2a80771c96f1006cd94d541736e1432d7df837fff', 'f584b276947e0b5979b2a9dc3254f10386b70b330438a9e2550d507641ada606', '274b6784d8b0e783b41d9ab3fb59f83a07021384d77a8301c21ba682ca514f8e', '3d36d1a44dc7d02361253be531685a7847ff919030e830b3b7d33da323864bba', '5bbe3d686024848f24fe238d32a57ce72d50b8fbeebade01a3437d75950aab78', '29ea94d06c6751fb47652496c82e1e9d54be60eb454edad2d4cc70305b7e7f6e', 'e19a400eccb294099834cd56397edb9329d003e8e7f8394c8510ecb4ff2e9d49', '0c083cb2dbd6e02c5070ac69ebd99deb41243b9c86516b946c30254bc9ccdfa3', '3e1ecc54327242ce7149d3b94e40a827984e34f421957d76e724befb47850aea', 'fad466a738de01a3d36eccbe586f4d8fc8e0e794e6bc9a207ec1dfbc50cfc690', '11750e495d361a550d77d6e936bd58a2696b27b9dd7d52475b2bc378ab46e66a', '9207956b1757a8ef10e8b8533004f05c18df92096f40432e53657c80998e21d0', 'b863dd515fc616b5f20d11da86ec171c6d64e3cdd1fecce3d9201a8f011ed918', 'da347c609aa36f0a6fe6d9365f7d3f5ef3502894bbb295f976fd4029d2dbed7c', '6e504eddc254b4618c44e3887d0b3f48b87c3f8b7253974cc0ffc04032bd0eef', 'ab4458406f2073e0bb0cbb77d0c295e95a669935cc2eb6d6f9ad03fb919856f1', '2a2e824a93c12293bd306cfff5b94f9aa2d149e4b03e04b44ad5d10090ab59c1', 'f4580b2be48d5ff6900dff6228fd62d66670888dae4c7128179d74de159d034a', '196c688b79a90f8cf628b79d0930ce6b3ff72fb8c443b7225899a0d1fdc0acad', '41c131676852283c2ee7fed18fd9381091897a583dc88fc9141a5038c73ed594'] A "outgoing interface, next hop, and sub-network parameters on a technology specific basis." {114: 1, 26: 1, 61: 1, 113: 1, 27: 1, 6: 4, 79: 4, 90: 3, 51: 4, 130: 4, 62: 6, 85: 7, 68: 6, 35: 5, 110: 3, 91: 5, 97: 4, 31: 4, 13: 3, 67: 3, 124: 5, 98: 4, 54: 4, 127: 5, 8: 4, 96: 4, 64: 4, 30: 4, 55: 5, 15: 3, 52: 3, 129: 5, 115: 3, 84: 3, 76: 8, 87: 3, 131: 7, 102: 3, 99: 4, 36: 3, 24: 2, 53: 3, 72: 4} {58: 1, 97: 1, 130: 1, 291: 1, 147: 1, 372: 1, 1: 11, 4: 4, 9: 7, 10: 5, 15: 4, 24: 4, 25: 6, 26: 7, 27: 4, 39: 7, 43: 5, 49: 6, 50: 5, 59: 4, 64: 4, 69: 6, 81: 7, 82: 5, 86: 3, 100: 8, 108: 5, 109: 6, 110: 6, 111: 4, 114: 5, 115: 6, 116: 4, 118: 8, 119: 7, 120: 5, 121: 6, 122: 5, 123: 4, 124: 6, 128: 4, 129: 4, 132: 6, 136: 4, 145: 6, 151: 4, 152: 4, 154: 5, 156: 3, 161: 5, 162: 5, 165: 5, 168: 6, 169: 3, 172: 3, 180: 4, 184: 7, 187: 7, 188: 6, 191: 5, 194: 6, 202: 7, 203: 8, 206: 4, 207: 5, 215: 4, 217: 5, 218: 10, 220: 4, 221: 4, 222: 7, 224: 5, 227: 6, 229: 3, 234: 7, 235: 4, 241: 4, 242: 4, 243: 6, 244: 4, 245: 6, 248: 4, 250: 5, 258: 13, 262: 6, 263: 7, 264: 5, 267: 6, 270: 4, 272: 3, 273: 7, 287: 5, 289: 3, 299: 6, 300: 4, 304: 4, 309: 5, 314: 4, 315: 3, 320: 6, 323: 6, 327: 6, 328: 5, 329: 4, 330: 12, 334: 4, 335: 4, 341: 6, 342: 7, 347: 6, 348: 6, 350: 9, 351: 5, 352: 3, 353: 3, 354: 2, 358: 6, 365: 3, 366: 4, 369: 3, 371: 8, 376: 4, 384: 5, 385: 4, 386: 5, 387: 4, 392: 5, 393: 6, 396: 7, 397: 9, 398: 8, 402: 3} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 38 "The path could be explicitly set up by a controller which calculates the path and explicitly configures each node along that path with the appropriate forwarding and resource allocation information." mpls - over - ip : minor tweaks ipOmpls : Section 6 , Management and Control Information Summary mpls : editorial changes , refactoring of section 5 for clarity and completeness white space cleanup ( remove tabs and trailing spaces ) 6eef101c3c863f944da82ed2f9cc38205de8aa61 6eef101c3c863f944da82ed2f9cc38205de8aa61 draft-ietf-detnet-mpls 274b6784d8b0e783b41d9ab3fb59f83a07021384d77a8301c21ba682ca514f8e ['3ef84f782267c0e0e968196f92f0e857d46f4f9ba7afbddce796cc8c50975a16', '2e08e5d79759a80040647153ce3fa7819f0612da07f964d940457940ee32eefb', 'd645de25ddd5a17db4ac8e4152ab9f48880b0362f999693b780b953092b4818b', '5afe7b6130289b07fae3f2293f0b50942f6484999592ab78deeb684af0961b90', '5496f74277f5150125eda22755e4e5935e4d30373ae21b9d251791bb3af70771', 'e0272e86b037d5f460db4807aede2c02c9d02cb129d656c91aa723e14be8738c', 'e88833dfc4793019fd0d380a39254338e0e1620775d4f0f64ba50f65f6304990', '2e1188e3ae68f9645fceeb16885fb2558ac488250197b0dac87311b7f9fc7ba3', '236b9ded3b3585aca0a348dc8cf9b49717f1a76ca847c280134ba2cafca9e2bf', 'c99484d301684eba379e2eaab522e22872390f584d0977611a9b71cd4e36e2a9', 'd4d0f5b26265d5747482d4c8c93706edd735ad6b653327445de5a09a5dcc5c2b', '3ad381ce14d392b11bc71c7f84aec9aa4faec501b897070e8cad5dfe435f09ff', '75d8fb6c0eaa04ce99a6045642bc5e15246a22b21f752b965c428b1072c46889', '959f68af8dfd80b8f76ac61803f842c5d5465c96fe9a54320df01a59d427bc74', 'ab1acdf4e7456e3c0c48ecf2a80771c96f1006cd94d541736e1432d7df837fff', 'f584b276947e0b5979b2a9dc3254f10386b70b330438a9e2550d507641ada606', '274b6784d8b0e783b41d9ab3fb59f83a07021384d77a8301c21ba682ca514f8e', '3d36d1a44dc7d02361253be531685a7847ff919030e830b3b7d33da323864bba', '5bbe3d686024848f24fe238d32a57ce72d50b8fbeebade01a3437d75950aab78', '29ea94d06c6751fb47652496c82e1e9d54be60eb454edad2d4cc70305b7e7f6e', 'e19a400eccb294099834cd56397edb9329d003e8e7f8394c8510ecb4ff2e9d49', '0c083cb2dbd6e02c5070ac69ebd99deb41243b9c86516b946c30254bc9ccdfa3', '3e1ecc54327242ce7149d3b94e40a827984e34f421957d76e724befb47850aea', 'fad466a738de01a3d36eccbe586f4d8fc8e0e794e6bc9a207ec1dfbc50cfc690', '11750e495d361a550d77d6e936bd58a2696b27b9dd7d52475b2bc378ab46e66a', '9207956b1757a8ef10e8b8533004f05c18df92096f40432e53657c80998e21d0', 'b863dd515fc616b5f20d11da86ec171c6d64e3cdd1fecce3d9201a8f011ed918', 'da347c609aa36f0a6fe6d9365f7d3f5ef3502894bbb295f976fd4029d2dbed7c', '6e504eddc254b4618c44e3887d0b3f48b87c3f8b7253974cc0ffc04032bd0eef', 'ab4458406f2073e0bb0cbb77d0c295e95a669935cc2eb6d6f9ad03fb919856f1', '2a2e824a93c12293bd306cfff5b94f9aa2d149e4b03e04b44ad5d10090ab59c1', 'f4580b2be48d5ff6900dff6228fd62d66670888dae4c7128179d74de159d034a', '196c688b79a90f8cf628b79d0930ce6b3ff72fb8c443b7225899a0d1fdc0acad', '41c131676852283c2ee7fed18fd9381091897a583dc88fc9141a5038c73ed594'] A "the path could be explicitly set up by a controller which calculates the path and explicitly configures each node along that path with the appropriate forwarding and resource allocation information." {114: 1, 26: 1, 61: 1, 113: 1, 27: 1, 6: 4, 79: 4, 90: 3, 51: 4, 130: 4, 62: 6, 85: 7, 68: 6, 35: 5, 110: 3, 91: 5, 97: 4, 31: 4, 13: 3, 67: 3, 124: 5, 98: 4, 54: 4, 127: 5, 8: 4, 96: 4, 64: 4, 30: 4, 55: 5, 15: 3, 52: 3, 129: 5, 115: 3, 84: 3, 76: 8, 87: 3, 131: 7, 102: 3, 99: 4, 36: 3, 24: 2, 53: 3, 72: 4} {58: 1, 97: 1, 130: 1, 291: 1, 147: 1, 372: 1, 1: 11, 4: 4, 9: 7, 10: 5, 15: 4, 24: 4, 25: 6, 26: 7, 27: 4, 39: 7, 43: 5, 49: 6, 50: 5, 59: 4, 64: 4, 69: 6, 81: 7, 82: 5, 86: 3, 100: 8, 108: 5, 109: 6, 110: 6, 111: 4, 114: 5, 115: 6, 116: 4, 118: 8, 119: 7, 120: 5, 121: 6, 122: 5, 123: 4, 124: 6, 128: 4, 129: 4, 132: 6, 136: 4, 145: 6, 151: 4, 152: 4, 154: 5, 156: 3, 161: 5, 162: 5, 165: 5, 168: 6, 169: 3, 172: 3, 180: 4, 184: 7, 187: 7, 188: 6, 191: 5, 194: 6, 202: 7, 203: 8, 206: 4, 207: 5, 215: 4, 217: 5, 218: 10, 220: 4, 221: 4, 222: 7, 224: 5, 227: 6, 229: 3, 234: 7, 235: 4, 241: 4, 242: 4, 243: 6, 244: 4, 245: 6, 248: 4, 250: 5, 258: 13, 262: 6, 263: 7, 264: 5, 267: 6, 270: 4, 272: 3, 273: 7, 287: 5, 289: 3, 299: 6, 300: 4, 304: 4, 309: 5, 314: 4, 315: 3, 320: 6, 323: 6, 327: 6, 328: 5, 329: 4, 330: 12, 334: 4, 335: 4, 341: 6, 342: 7, 347: 6, 348: 6, 350: 9, 351: 5, 352: 3, 353: 3, 354: 2, 358: 6, 365: 3, 366: 4, 369: 3, 371: 8, 376: 4, 384: 5, 385: 4, 386: 5, 387: 4, 392: 5, 393: 6, 396: 7, 397: 9, 398: 8, 402: 3} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 38 The path could be set up using RSVP-TE signaling. mpls - over - ip : minor tweaks ipOmpls : Section 6 , Management and Control Information Summary mpls : editorial changes , refactoring of section 5 for clarity and completeness white space cleanup ( remove tabs and trailing spaces ) 6eef101c3c863f944da82ed2f9cc38205de8aa61 6eef101c3c863f944da82ed2f9cc38205de8aa61 draft-ietf-detnet-mpls e19a400eccb294099834cd56397edb9329d003e8e7f8394c8510ecb4ff2e9d49 ['3ef84f782267c0e0e968196f92f0e857d46f4f9ba7afbddce796cc8c50975a16', '2e08e5d79759a80040647153ce3fa7819f0612da07f964d940457940ee32eefb', 'd645de25ddd5a17db4ac8e4152ab9f48880b0362f999693b780b953092b4818b', '5afe7b6130289b07fae3f2293f0b50942f6484999592ab78deeb684af0961b90', '5496f74277f5150125eda22755e4e5935e4d30373ae21b9d251791bb3af70771', 'e0272e86b037d5f460db4807aede2c02c9d02cb129d656c91aa723e14be8738c', 'e88833dfc4793019fd0d380a39254338e0e1620775d4f0f64ba50f65f6304990', '2e1188e3ae68f9645fceeb16885fb2558ac488250197b0dac87311b7f9fc7ba3', '236b9ded3b3585aca0a348dc8cf9b49717f1a76ca847c280134ba2cafca9e2bf', 'c99484d301684eba379e2eaab522e22872390f584d0977611a9b71cd4e36e2a9', 'd4d0f5b26265d5747482d4c8c93706edd735ad6b653327445de5a09a5dcc5c2b', '3ad381ce14d392b11bc71c7f84aec9aa4faec501b897070e8cad5dfe435f09ff', '75d8fb6c0eaa04ce99a6045642bc5e15246a22b21f752b965c428b1072c46889', '959f68af8dfd80b8f76ac61803f842c5d5465c96fe9a54320df01a59d427bc74', 'ab1acdf4e7456e3c0c48ecf2a80771c96f1006cd94d541736e1432d7df837fff', 'f584b276947e0b5979b2a9dc3254f10386b70b330438a9e2550d507641ada606', '274b6784d8b0e783b41d9ab3fb59f83a07021384d77a8301c21ba682ca514f8e', '3d36d1a44dc7d02361253be531685a7847ff919030e830b3b7d33da323864bba', '5bbe3d686024848f24fe238d32a57ce72d50b8fbeebade01a3437d75950aab78', '29ea94d06c6751fb47652496c82e1e9d54be60eb454edad2d4cc70305b7e7f6e', 'e19a400eccb294099834cd56397edb9329d003e8e7f8394c8510ecb4ff2e9d49', '0c083cb2dbd6e02c5070ac69ebd99deb41243b9c86516b946c30254bc9ccdfa3', '3e1ecc54327242ce7149d3b94e40a827984e34f421957d76e724befb47850aea', 'fad466a738de01a3d36eccbe586f4d8fc8e0e794e6bc9a207ec1dfbc50cfc690', '11750e495d361a550d77d6e936bd58a2696b27b9dd7d52475b2bc378ab46e66a', '9207956b1757a8ef10e8b8533004f05c18df92096f40432e53657c80998e21d0', 'b863dd515fc616b5f20d11da86ec171c6d64e3cdd1fecce3d9201a8f011ed918', 'da347c609aa36f0a6fe6d9365f7d3f5ef3502894bbb295f976fd4029d2dbed7c', '6e504eddc254b4618c44e3887d0b3f48b87c3f8b7253974cc0ffc04032bd0eef', 'ab4458406f2073e0bb0cbb77d0c295e95a669935cc2eb6d6f9ad03fb919856f1', '2a2e824a93c12293bd306cfff5b94f9aa2d149e4b03e04b44ad5d10090ab59c1', 'f4580b2be48d5ff6900dff6228fd62d66670888dae4c7128179d74de159d034a', '196c688b79a90f8cf628b79d0930ce6b3ff72fb8c443b7225899a0d1fdc0acad', '41c131676852283c2ee7fed18fd9381091897a583dc88fc9141a5038c73ed594'] A the path could be set up using rsvp-te signaling. {114: 1, 26: 1, 61: 1, 113: 1, 27: 1, 6: 4, 79: 4, 90: 3, 51: 4, 130: 4, 62: 6, 85: 7, 68: 6, 35: 5, 110: 3, 91: 5, 97: 4, 31: 4, 13: 3, 67: 3, 124: 5, 98: 4, 54: 4, 127: 5, 8: 4, 96: 4, 64: 4, 30: 4, 55: 5, 15: 3, 52: 3, 129: 5, 115: 3, 84: 3, 76: 8, 87: 3, 131: 7, 102: 3, 99: 4, 36: 3, 24: 2, 53: 3, 72: 4} {58: 1, 97: 1, 130: 1, 291: 1, 147: 1, 372: 1, 1: 11, 4: 4, 9: 7, 10: 5, 15: 4, 24: 4, 25: 6, 26: 7, 27: 4, 39: 7, 43: 5, 49: 6, 50: 5, 59: 4, 64: 4, 69: 6, 81: 7, 82: 5, 86: 3, 100: 8, 108: 5, 109: 6, 110: 6, 111: 4, 114: 5, 115: 6, 116: 4, 118: 8, 119: 7, 120: 5, 121: 6, 122: 5, 123: 4, 124: 6, 128: 4, 129: 4, 132: 6, 136: 4, 145: 6, 151: 4, 152: 4, 154: 5, 156: 3, 161: 5, 162: 5, 165: 5, 168: 6, 169: 3, 172: 3, 180: 4, 184: 7, 187: 7, 188: 6, 191: 5, 194: 6, 202: 7, 203: 8, 206: 4, 207: 5, 215: 4, 217: 5, 218: 10, 220: 4, 221: 4, 222: 7, 224: 5, 227: 6, 229: 3, 234: 7, 235: 4, 241: 4, 242: 4, 243: 6, 244: 4, 245: 6, 248: 4, 250: 5, 258: 13, 262: 6, 263: 7, 264: 5, 267: 6, 270: 4, 272: 3, 273: 7, 287: 5, 289: 3, 299: 6, 300: 4, 304: 4, 309: 5, 314: 4, 315: 3, 320: 6, 323: 6, 327: 6, 328: 5, 329: 4, 330: 12, 334: 4, 335: 4, 341: 6, 342: 7, 347: 6, 348: 6, 350: 9, 351: 5, 352: 3, 353: 3, 354: 2, 358: 6, 365: 3, 366: 4, 369: 3, 371: 8, 376: 4, 384: 5, 385: 4, 386: 5, 387: 4, 392: 5, 393: 6, 396: 7, 397: 9, 398: 8, 402: 3} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 38 "The path could be implemented using MPLS-based segment routing when extended to support resource allocation." mpls - over - ip : minor tweaks ipOmpls : Section 6 , Management and Control Information Summary mpls : editorial changes , refactoring of section 5 for clarity and completeness white space cleanup ( remove tabs and trailing spaces ) 6eef101c3c863f944da82ed2f9cc38205de8aa61 6eef101c3c863f944da82ed2f9cc38205de8aa61 draft-ietf-detnet-mpls ab4458406f2073e0bb0cbb77d0c295e95a669935cc2eb6d6f9ad03fb919856f1 ['3ef84f782267c0e0e968196f92f0e857d46f4f9ba7afbddce796cc8c50975a16', '2e08e5d79759a80040647153ce3fa7819f0612da07f964d940457940ee32eefb', 'd645de25ddd5a17db4ac8e4152ab9f48880b0362f999693b780b953092b4818b', '5afe7b6130289b07fae3f2293f0b50942f6484999592ab78deeb684af0961b90', '5496f74277f5150125eda22755e4e5935e4d30373ae21b9d251791bb3af70771', 'e0272e86b037d5f460db4807aede2c02c9d02cb129d656c91aa723e14be8738c', 'e88833dfc4793019fd0d380a39254338e0e1620775d4f0f64ba50f65f6304990', '2e1188e3ae68f9645fceeb16885fb2558ac488250197b0dac87311b7f9fc7ba3', '236b9ded3b3585aca0a348dc8cf9b49717f1a76ca847c280134ba2cafca9e2bf', 'c99484d301684eba379e2eaab522e22872390f584d0977611a9b71cd4e36e2a9', 'd4d0f5b26265d5747482d4c8c93706edd735ad6b653327445de5a09a5dcc5c2b', '3ad381ce14d392b11bc71c7f84aec9aa4faec501b897070e8cad5dfe435f09ff', '75d8fb6c0eaa04ce99a6045642bc5e15246a22b21f752b965c428b1072c46889', '959f68af8dfd80b8f76ac61803f842c5d5465c96fe9a54320df01a59d427bc74', 'ab1acdf4e7456e3c0c48ecf2a80771c96f1006cd94d541736e1432d7df837fff', 'f584b276947e0b5979b2a9dc3254f10386b70b330438a9e2550d507641ada606', '274b6784d8b0e783b41d9ab3fb59f83a07021384d77a8301c21ba682ca514f8e', '3d36d1a44dc7d02361253be531685a7847ff919030e830b3b7d33da323864bba', '5bbe3d686024848f24fe238d32a57ce72d50b8fbeebade01a3437d75950aab78', '29ea94d06c6751fb47652496c82e1e9d54be60eb454edad2d4cc70305b7e7f6e', 'e19a400eccb294099834cd56397edb9329d003e8e7f8394c8510ecb4ff2e9d49', '0c083cb2dbd6e02c5070ac69ebd99deb41243b9c86516b946c30254bc9ccdfa3', '3e1ecc54327242ce7149d3b94e40a827984e34f421957d76e724befb47850aea', 'fad466a738de01a3d36eccbe586f4d8fc8e0e794e6bc9a207ec1dfbc50cfc690', '11750e495d361a550d77d6e936bd58a2696b27b9dd7d52475b2bc378ab46e66a', '9207956b1757a8ef10e8b8533004f05c18df92096f40432e53657c80998e21d0', 'b863dd515fc616b5f20d11da86ec171c6d64e3cdd1fecce3d9201a8f011ed918', 'da347c609aa36f0a6fe6d9365f7d3f5ef3502894bbb295f976fd4029d2dbed7c', '6e504eddc254b4618c44e3887d0b3f48b87c3f8b7253974cc0ffc04032bd0eef', 'ab4458406f2073e0bb0cbb77d0c295e95a669935cc2eb6d6f9ad03fb919856f1', '2a2e824a93c12293bd306cfff5b94f9aa2d149e4b03e04b44ad5d10090ab59c1', 'f4580b2be48d5ff6900dff6228fd62d66670888dae4c7128179d74de159d034a', '196c688b79a90f8cf628b79d0930ce6b3ff72fb8c443b7225899a0d1fdc0acad', '41c131676852283c2ee7fed18fd9381091897a583dc88fc9141a5038c73ed594'] A "the path could be implemented using mpls-based segment routing when extended to support resource allocation." {114: 1, 26: 1, 61: 1, 113: 1, 27: 1, 6: 4, 79: 4, 90: 3, 51: 4, 130: 4, 62: 6, 85: 7, 68: 6, 35: 5, 110: 3, 91: 5, 97: 4, 31: 4, 13: 3, 67: 3, 124: 5, 98: 4, 54: 4, 127: 5, 8: 4, 96: 4, 64: 4, 30: 4, 55: 5, 15: 3, 52: 3, 129: 5, 115: 3, 84: 3, 76: 8, 87: 3, 131: 7, 102: 3, 99: 4, 36: 3, 24: 2, 53: 3, 72: 4} {58: 1, 97: 1, 130: 1, 291: 1, 147: 1, 372: 1, 1: 11, 4: 4, 9: 7, 10: 5, 15: 4, 24: 4, 25: 6, 26: 7, 27: 4, 39: 7, 43: 5, 49: 6, 50: 5, 59: 4, 64: 4, 69: 6, 81: 7, 82: 5, 86: 3, 100: 8, 108: 5, 109: 6, 110: 6, 111: 4, 114: 5, 115: 6, 116: 4, 118: 8, 119: 7, 120: 5, 121: 6, 122: 5, 123: 4, 124: 6, 128: 4, 129: 4, 132: 6, 136: 4, 145: 6, 151: 4, 152: 4, 154: 5, 156: 3, 161: 5, 162: 5, 165: 5, 168: 6, 169: 3, 172: 3, 180: 4, 184: 7, 187: 7, 188: 6, 191: 5, 194: 6, 202: 7, 203: 8, 206: 4, 207: 5, 215: 4, 217: 5, 218: 10, 220: 4, 221: 4, 222: 7, 224: 5, 227: 6, 229: 3, 234: 7, 235: 4, 241: 4, 242: 4, 243: 6, 244: 4, 245: 6, 248: 4, 250: 5, 258: 13, 262: 6, 263: 7, 264: 5, 267: 6, 270: 4, 272: 3, 273: 7, 287: 5, 289: 3, 299: 6, 300: 4, 304: 4, 309: 5, 314: 4, 315: 3, 320: 6, 323: 6, 327: 6, 328: 5, 329: 4, 330: 12, 334: 4, 335: 4, 341: 6, 342: 7, 347: 6, 348: 6, 350: 9, 351: 5, 352: 3, 353: 3, 354: 2, 358: 6, 365: 3, 366: 4, 369: 3, 371: 8, 376: 4, 384: 5, 385: 4, 386: 5, 387: 4, 392: 5, 393: 6, 396: 7, 397: 9, 398: 8, 402: 3} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 38 "The specific information needed for the processing of each DetNet service depends on the DetNet node type and the functions being provided on the node. This section summarizes based on the DetNet sub-layer and if the DetNet traffic is being sent or received. All DetNet node types are DetNet forwarding sub-layer aware, while all but transit nodes are service sub-layer aware. This is shown in fig_dn_mpls_detnet." mpls - over - ip : minor tweaks ipOmpls : Section 6 , Management and Control Information Summary mpls : editorial changes , refactoring of section 5 for clarity and completeness white space cleanup ( remove tabs and trailing spaces ) 6eef101c3c863f944da82ed2f9cc38205de8aa61 6eef101c3c863f944da82ed2f9cc38205de8aa61 draft-ietf-detnet-mpls fad466a738de01a3d36eccbe586f4d8fc8e0e794e6bc9a207ec1dfbc50cfc690 ['3ef84f782267c0e0e968196f92f0e857d46f4f9ba7afbddce796cc8c50975a16', '2e08e5d79759a80040647153ce3fa7819f0612da07f964d940457940ee32eefb', 'd645de25ddd5a17db4ac8e4152ab9f48880b0362f999693b780b953092b4818b', '5afe7b6130289b07fae3f2293f0b50942f6484999592ab78deeb684af0961b90', '5496f74277f5150125eda22755e4e5935e4d30373ae21b9d251791bb3af70771', 'e0272e86b037d5f460db4807aede2c02c9d02cb129d656c91aa723e14be8738c', 'e88833dfc4793019fd0d380a39254338e0e1620775d4f0f64ba50f65f6304990', '2e1188e3ae68f9645fceeb16885fb2558ac488250197b0dac87311b7f9fc7ba3', '236b9ded3b3585aca0a348dc8cf9b49717f1a76ca847c280134ba2cafca9e2bf', 'c99484d301684eba379e2eaab522e22872390f584d0977611a9b71cd4e36e2a9', 'd4d0f5b26265d5747482d4c8c93706edd735ad6b653327445de5a09a5dcc5c2b', '3ad381ce14d392b11bc71c7f84aec9aa4faec501b897070e8cad5dfe435f09ff', '75d8fb6c0eaa04ce99a6045642bc5e15246a22b21f752b965c428b1072c46889', '959f68af8dfd80b8f76ac61803f842c5d5465c96fe9a54320df01a59d427bc74', 'ab1acdf4e7456e3c0c48ecf2a80771c96f1006cd94d541736e1432d7df837fff', 'f584b276947e0b5979b2a9dc3254f10386b70b330438a9e2550d507641ada606', '274b6784d8b0e783b41d9ab3fb59f83a07021384d77a8301c21ba682ca514f8e', '3d36d1a44dc7d02361253be531685a7847ff919030e830b3b7d33da323864bba', '5bbe3d686024848f24fe238d32a57ce72d50b8fbeebade01a3437d75950aab78', '29ea94d06c6751fb47652496c82e1e9d54be60eb454edad2d4cc70305b7e7f6e', 'e19a400eccb294099834cd56397edb9329d003e8e7f8394c8510ecb4ff2e9d49', '0c083cb2dbd6e02c5070ac69ebd99deb41243b9c86516b946c30254bc9ccdfa3', '3e1ecc54327242ce7149d3b94e40a827984e34f421957d76e724befb47850aea', 'fad466a738de01a3d36eccbe586f4d8fc8e0e794e6bc9a207ec1dfbc50cfc690', '11750e495d361a550d77d6e936bd58a2696b27b9dd7d52475b2bc378ab46e66a', '9207956b1757a8ef10e8b8533004f05c18df92096f40432e53657c80998e21d0', 'b863dd515fc616b5f20d11da86ec171c6d64e3cdd1fecce3d9201a8f011ed918', 'da347c609aa36f0a6fe6d9365f7d3f5ef3502894bbb295f976fd4029d2dbed7c', '6e504eddc254b4618c44e3887d0b3f48b87c3f8b7253974cc0ffc04032bd0eef', 'ab4458406f2073e0bb0cbb77d0c295e95a669935cc2eb6d6f9ad03fb919856f1', '2a2e824a93c12293bd306cfff5b94f9aa2d149e4b03e04b44ad5d10090ab59c1', 'f4580b2be48d5ff6900dff6228fd62d66670888dae4c7128179d74de159d034a', '196c688b79a90f8cf628b79d0930ce6b3ff72fb8c443b7225899a0d1fdc0acad', '41c131676852283c2ee7fed18fd9381091897a583dc88fc9141a5038c73ed594'] B "the specific information needed for the processing of each detnet service depends on the detnet node type and the functions being provided on the node. this section summarizes based on the detnet sub-layer and if the detnet traffic is being sent or received. all detnet node types are detnet forwarding sub-layer aware, while all but transit nodes are service sub-layer aware. this is shown in fig_dn_mpls_detnet." {114: 1, 26: 1, 61: 1, 113: 1, 27: 1, 6: 4, 79: 4, 90: 3, 51: 4, 130: 4, 62: 6, 85: 7, 68: 6, 35: 5, 110: 3, 91: 5, 97: 4, 31: 4, 13: 3, 67: 3, 124: 5, 98: 4, 54: 4, 127: 5, 8: 4, 96: 4, 64: 4, 30: 4, 55: 5, 15: 3, 52: 3, 129: 5, 115: 3, 84: 3, 76: 8, 87: 3, 131: 7, 102: 3, 99: 4, 36: 3, 24: 2, 53: 3, 72: 4} {58: 1, 97: 1, 130: 1, 291: 1, 147: 1, 372: 1, 1: 11, 4: 4, 9: 7, 10: 5, 15: 4, 24: 4, 25: 6, 26: 7, 27: 4, 39: 7, 43: 5, 49: 6, 50: 5, 59: 4, 64: 4, 69: 6, 81: 7, 82: 5, 86: 3, 100: 8, 108: 5, 109: 6, 110: 6, 111: 4, 114: 5, 115: 6, 116: 4, 118: 8, 119: 7, 120: 5, 121: 6, 122: 5, 123: 4, 124: 6, 128: 4, 129: 4, 132: 6, 136: 4, 145: 6, 151: 4, 152: 4, 154: 5, 156: 3, 161: 5, 162: 5, 165: 5, 168: 6, 169: 3, 172: 3, 180: 4, 184: 7, 187: 7, 188: 6, 191: 5, 194: 6, 202: 7, 203: 8, 206: 4, 207: 5, 215: 4, 217: 5, 218: 10, 220: 4, 221: 4, 222: 7, 224: 5, 227: 6, 229: 3, 234: 7, 235: 4, 241: 4, 242: 4, 243: 6, 244: 4, 245: 6, 248: 4, 250: 5, 258: 13, 262: 6, 263: 7, 264: 5, 267: 6, 270: 4, 272: 3, 273: 7, 287: 5, 289: 3, 299: 6, 300: 4, 304: 4, 309: 5, 314: 4, 315: 3, 320: 6, 323: 6, 327: 6, 328: 5, 329: 4, 330: 12, 334: 4, 335: 4, 341: 6, 342: 7, 347: 6, 348: 6, 350: 9, 351: 5, 352: 3, 353: 3, 354: 2, 358: 6, 365: 3, 366: 4, 369: 3, 371: 8, 376: 4, 384: 5, 385: 4, 386: 5, 387: 4, 392: 5, 393: 6, 396: 7, 397: 9, 398: 8, 402: 3} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 38 "App-Flow identification information, e.g., an incoming service on a relay node or IP information as defined in I-D.ietf-detnet-ip- over-mpls." mpls - over - ip : minor tweaks ipOmpls : Section 6 , Management and Control Information Summary mpls : editorial changes , refactoring of section 5 for clarity and completeness white space cleanup ( remove tabs and trailing spaces ) 6eef101c3c863f944da82ed2f9cc38205de8aa61 6eef101c3c863f944da82ed2f9cc38205de8aa61 draft-ietf-detnet-mpls 6e504eddc254b4618c44e3887d0b3f48b87c3f8b7253974cc0ffc04032bd0eef ['3ef84f782267c0e0e968196f92f0e857d46f4f9ba7afbddce796cc8c50975a16', '2e08e5d79759a80040647153ce3fa7819f0612da07f964d940457940ee32eefb', 'd645de25ddd5a17db4ac8e4152ab9f48880b0362f999693b780b953092b4818b', '5afe7b6130289b07fae3f2293f0b50942f6484999592ab78deeb684af0961b90', '5496f74277f5150125eda22755e4e5935e4d30373ae21b9d251791bb3af70771', 'e0272e86b037d5f460db4807aede2c02c9d02cb129d656c91aa723e14be8738c', 'e88833dfc4793019fd0d380a39254338e0e1620775d4f0f64ba50f65f6304990', '2e1188e3ae68f9645fceeb16885fb2558ac488250197b0dac87311b7f9fc7ba3', '236b9ded3b3585aca0a348dc8cf9b49717f1a76ca847c280134ba2cafca9e2bf', 'c99484d301684eba379e2eaab522e22872390f584d0977611a9b71cd4e36e2a9', 'd4d0f5b26265d5747482d4c8c93706edd735ad6b653327445de5a09a5dcc5c2b', '3ad381ce14d392b11bc71c7f84aec9aa4faec501b897070e8cad5dfe435f09ff', '75d8fb6c0eaa04ce99a6045642bc5e15246a22b21f752b965c428b1072c46889', '959f68af8dfd80b8f76ac61803f842c5d5465c96fe9a54320df01a59d427bc74', 'ab1acdf4e7456e3c0c48ecf2a80771c96f1006cd94d541736e1432d7df837fff', 'f584b276947e0b5979b2a9dc3254f10386b70b330438a9e2550d507641ada606', '274b6784d8b0e783b41d9ab3fb59f83a07021384d77a8301c21ba682ca514f8e', '3d36d1a44dc7d02361253be531685a7847ff919030e830b3b7d33da323864bba', '5bbe3d686024848f24fe238d32a57ce72d50b8fbeebade01a3437d75950aab78', '29ea94d06c6751fb47652496c82e1e9d54be60eb454edad2d4cc70305b7e7f6e', 'e19a400eccb294099834cd56397edb9329d003e8e7f8394c8510ecb4ff2e9d49', '0c083cb2dbd6e02c5070ac69ebd99deb41243b9c86516b946c30254bc9ccdfa3', '3e1ecc54327242ce7149d3b94e40a827984e34f421957d76e724befb47850aea', 'fad466a738de01a3d36eccbe586f4d8fc8e0e794e6bc9a207ec1dfbc50cfc690', '11750e495d361a550d77d6e936bd58a2696b27b9dd7d52475b2bc378ab46e66a', '9207956b1757a8ef10e8b8533004f05c18df92096f40432e53657c80998e21d0', 'b863dd515fc616b5f20d11da86ec171c6d64e3cdd1fecce3d9201a8f011ed918', 'da347c609aa36f0a6fe6d9365f7d3f5ef3502894bbb295f976fd4029d2dbed7c', '6e504eddc254b4618c44e3887d0b3f48b87c3f8b7253974cc0ffc04032bd0eef', 'ab4458406f2073e0bb0cbb77d0c295e95a669935cc2eb6d6f9ad03fb919856f1', '2a2e824a93c12293bd306cfff5b94f9aa2d149e4b03e04b44ad5d10090ab59c1', 'f4580b2be48d5ff6900dff6228fd62d66670888dae4c7128179d74de159d034a', '196c688b79a90f8cf628b79d0930ce6b3ff72fb8c443b7225899a0d1fdc0acad', '41c131676852283c2ee7fed18fd9381091897a583dc88fc9141a5038c73ed594'] B "app-flow identification information, e.g., an incoming service on a relay node or ip information as defined in i-d.ietf-detnet-ip- over-mpls." {114: 1, 26: 1, 61: 1, 113: 1, 27: 1, 6: 4, 79: 4, 90: 3, 51: 4, 130: 4, 62: 6, 85: 7, 68: 6, 35: 5, 110: 3, 91: 5, 97: 4, 31: 4, 13: 3, 67: 3, 124: 5, 98: 4, 54: 4, 127: 5, 8: 4, 96: 4, 64: 4, 30: 4, 55: 5, 15: 3, 52: 3, 129: 5, 115: 3, 84: 3, 76: 8, 87: 3, 131: 7, 102: 3, 99: 4, 36: 3, 24: 2, 53: 3, 72: 4} {58: 1, 97: 1, 130: 1, 291: 1, 147: 1, 372: 1, 1: 11, 4: 4, 9: 7, 10: 5, 15: 4, 24: 4, 25: 6, 26: 7, 27: 4, 39: 7, 43: 5, 49: 6, 50: 5, 59: 4, 64: 4, 69: 6, 81: 7, 82: 5, 86: 3, 100: 8, 108: 5, 109: 6, 110: 6, 111: 4, 114: 5, 115: 6, 116: 4, 118: 8, 119: 7, 120: 5, 121: 6, 122: 5, 123: 4, 124: 6, 128: 4, 129: 4, 132: 6, 136: 4, 145: 6, 151: 4, 152: 4, 154: 5, 156: 3, 161: 5, 162: 5, 165: 5, 168: 6, 169: 3, 172: 3, 180: 4, 184: 7, 187: 7, 188: 6, 191: 5, 194: 6, 202: 7, 203: 8, 206: 4, 207: 5, 215: 4, 217: 5, 218: 10, 220: 4, 221: 4, 222: 7, 224: 5, 227: 6, 229: 3, 234: 7, 235: 4, 241: 4, 242: 4, 243: 6, 244: 4, 245: 6, 248: 4, 250: 5, 258: 13, 262: 6, 263: 7, 264: 5, 267: 6, 270: 4, 272: 3, 273: 7, 287: 5, 289: 3, 299: 6, 300: 4, 304: 4, 309: 5, 314: 4, 315: 3, 320: 6, 323: 6, 327: 6, 328: 5, 329: 4, 330: 12, 334: 4, 335: 4, 341: 6, 342: 7, 347: 6, 348: 6, 350: 9, 351: 5, 352: 3, 353: 3, 354: 2, 358: 6, 365: 3, 366: 4, 369: 3, 371: 8, 376: 4, 384: 5, 385: 4, 386: 5, 387: 4, 392: 5, 393: 6, 396: 7, 397: 9, 398: 8, 402: 3} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 38 "The sequence number length to be used for the service. Valid values included 0, 16 and 28 bits. 0 bits cannot be used when PRF is configured for the service." mpls - over - ip : minor tweaks ipOmpls : Section 6 , Management and Control Information Summary mpls : editorial changes , refactoring of section 5 for clarity and completeness white space cleanup ( remove tabs and trailing spaces ) 6eef101c3c863f944da82ed2f9cc38205de8aa61 6eef101c3c863f944da82ed2f9cc38205de8aa61 draft-ietf-detnet-mpls 2e08e5d79759a80040647153ce3fa7819f0612da07f964d940457940ee32eefb ['3ef84f782267c0e0e968196f92f0e857d46f4f9ba7afbddce796cc8c50975a16', '2e08e5d79759a80040647153ce3fa7819f0612da07f964d940457940ee32eefb', 'd645de25ddd5a17db4ac8e4152ab9f48880b0362f999693b780b953092b4818b', '5afe7b6130289b07fae3f2293f0b50942f6484999592ab78deeb684af0961b90', '5496f74277f5150125eda22755e4e5935e4d30373ae21b9d251791bb3af70771', 'e0272e86b037d5f460db4807aede2c02c9d02cb129d656c91aa723e14be8738c', 'e88833dfc4793019fd0d380a39254338e0e1620775d4f0f64ba50f65f6304990', '2e1188e3ae68f9645fceeb16885fb2558ac488250197b0dac87311b7f9fc7ba3', '236b9ded3b3585aca0a348dc8cf9b49717f1a76ca847c280134ba2cafca9e2bf', 'c99484d301684eba379e2eaab522e22872390f584d0977611a9b71cd4e36e2a9', 'd4d0f5b26265d5747482d4c8c93706edd735ad6b653327445de5a09a5dcc5c2b', '3ad381ce14d392b11bc71c7f84aec9aa4faec501b897070e8cad5dfe435f09ff', '75d8fb6c0eaa04ce99a6045642bc5e15246a22b21f752b965c428b1072c46889', '959f68af8dfd80b8f76ac61803f842c5d5465c96fe9a54320df01a59d427bc74', 'ab1acdf4e7456e3c0c48ecf2a80771c96f1006cd94d541736e1432d7df837fff', 'f584b276947e0b5979b2a9dc3254f10386b70b330438a9e2550d507641ada606', '274b6784d8b0e783b41d9ab3fb59f83a07021384d77a8301c21ba682ca514f8e', '3d36d1a44dc7d02361253be531685a7847ff919030e830b3b7d33da323864bba', '5bbe3d686024848f24fe238d32a57ce72d50b8fbeebade01a3437d75950aab78', '29ea94d06c6751fb47652496c82e1e9d54be60eb454edad2d4cc70305b7e7f6e', 'e19a400eccb294099834cd56397edb9329d003e8e7f8394c8510ecb4ff2e9d49', '0c083cb2dbd6e02c5070ac69ebd99deb41243b9c86516b946c30254bc9ccdfa3', '3e1ecc54327242ce7149d3b94e40a827984e34f421957d76e724befb47850aea', 'fad466a738de01a3d36eccbe586f4d8fc8e0e794e6bc9a207ec1dfbc50cfc690', '11750e495d361a550d77d6e936bd58a2696b27b9dd7d52475b2bc378ab46e66a', '9207956b1757a8ef10e8b8533004f05c18df92096f40432e53657c80998e21d0', 'b863dd515fc616b5f20d11da86ec171c6d64e3cdd1fecce3d9201a8f011ed918', 'da347c609aa36f0a6fe6d9365f7d3f5ef3502894bbb295f976fd4029d2dbed7c', '6e504eddc254b4618c44e3887d0b3f48b87c3f8b7253974cc0ffc04032bd0eef', 'ab4458406f2073e0bb0cbb77d0c295e95a669935cc2eb6d6f9ad03fb919856f1', '2a2e824a93c12293bd306cfff5b94f9aa2d149e4b03e04b44ad5d10090ab59c1', 'f4580b2be48d5ff6900dff6228fd62d66670888dae4c7128179d74de159d034a', '196c688b79a90f8cf628b79d0930ce6b3ff72fb8c443b7225899a0d1fdc0acad', '41c131676852283c2ee7fed18fd9381091897a583dc88fc9141a5038c73ed594'] B "the sequence number length to be used for the service. valid values included 0, 16 and 28 bits. 0 bits cannot be used when prf is configured for the service." {114: 1, 26: 1, 61: 1, 113: 1, 27: 1, 6: 4, 79: 4, 90: 3, 51: 4, 130: 4, 62: 6, 85: 7, 68: 6, 35: 5, 110: 3, 91: 5, 97: 4, 31: 4, 13: 3, 67: 3, 124: 5, 98: 4, 54: 4, 127: 5, 8: 4, 96: 4, 64: 4, 30: 4, 55: 5, 15: 3, 52: 3, 129: 5, 115: 3, 84: 3, 76: 8, 87: 3, 131: 7, 102: 3, 99: 4, 36: 3, 24: 2, 53: 3, 72: 4} {58: 1, 97: 1, 130: 1, 291: 1, 147: 1, 372: 1, 1: 11, 4: 4, 9: 7, 10: 5, 15: 4, 24: 4, 25: 6, 26: 7, 27: 4, 39: 7, 43: 5, 49: 6, 50: 5, 59: 4, 64: 4, 69: 6, 81: 7, 82: 5, 86: 3, 100: 8, 108: 5, 109: 6, 110: 6, 111: 4, 114: 5, 115: 6, 116: 4, 118: 8, 119: 7, 120: 5, 121: 6, 122: 5, 123: 4, 124: 6, 128: 4, 129: 4, 132: 6, 136: 4, 145: 6, 151: 4, 152: 4, 154: 5, 156: 3, 161: 5, 162: 5, 165: 5, 168: 6, 169: 3, 172: 3, 180: 4, 184: 7, 187: 7, 188: 6, 191: 5, 194: 6, 202: 7, 203: 8, 206: 4, 207: 5, 215: 4, 217: 5, 218: 10, 220: 4, 221: 4, 222: 7, 224: 5, 227: 6, 229: 3, 234: 7, 235: 4, 241: 4, 242: 4, 243: 6, 244: 4, 245: 6, 248: 4, 250: 5, 258: 13, 262: 6, 263: 7, 264: 5, 267: 6, 270: 4, 272: 3, 273: 7, 287: 5, 289: 3, 299: 6, 300: 4, 304: 4, 309: 5, 314: 4, 315: 3, 320: 6, 323: 6, 327: 6, 328: 5, 329: 4, 330: 12, 334: 4, 335: 4, 341: 6, 342: 7, 347: 6, 348: 6, 350: 9, 351: 5, 352: 3, 353: 3, 354: 2, 358: 6, 365: 3, 366: 4, 369: 3, 371: 8, 376: 4, 384: 5, 385: 4, 386: 5, 387: 4, 392: 5, 393: 6, 396: 7, 397: 9, 398: 8, 402: 3} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 38 The S-Label for the service. mpls - over - ip : minor tweaks ipOmpls : Section 6 , Management and Control Information Summary mpls : editorial changes , refactoring of section 5 for clarity and completeness white space cleanup ( remove tabs and trailing spaces ) 6eef101c3c863f944da82ed2f9cc38205de8aa61 6eef101c3c863f944da82ed2f9cc38205de8aa61 draft-ietf-detnet-mpls 236b9ded3b3585aca0a348dc8cf9b49717f1a76ca847c280134ba2cafca9e2bf ['3ef84f782267c0e0e968196f92f0e857d46f4f9ba7afbddce796cc8c50975a16', '2e08e5d79759a80040647153ce3fa7819f0612da07f964d940457940ee32eefb', 'd645de25ddd5a17db4ac8e4152ab9f48880b0362f999693b780b953092b4818b', '5afe7b6130289b07fae3f2293f0b50942f6484999592ab78deeb684af0961b90', '5496f74277f5150125eda22755e4e5935e4d30373ae21b9d251791bb3af70771', 'e0272e86b037d5f460db4807aede2c02c9d02cb129d656c91aa723e14be8738c', 'e88833dfc4793019fd0d380a39254338e0e1620775d4f0f64ba50f65f6304990', '2e1188e3ae68f9645fceeb16885fb2558ac488250197b0dac87311b7f9fc7ba3', '236b9ded3b3585aca0a348dc8cf9b49717f1a76ca847c280134ba2cafca9e2bf', 'c99484d301684eba379e2eaab522e22872390f584d0977611a9b71cd4e36e2a9', 'd4d0f5b26265d5747482d4c8c93706edd735ad6b653327445de5a09a5dcc5c2b', '3ad381ce14d392b11bc71c7f84aec9aa4faec501b897070e8cad5dfe435f09ff', '75d8fb6c0eaa04ce99a6045642bc5e15246a22b21f752b965c428b1072c46889', '959f68af8dfd80b8f76ac61803f842c5d5465c96fe9a54320df01a59d427bc74', 'ab1acdf4e7456e3c0c48ecf2a80771c96f1006cd94d541736e1432d7df837fff', 'f584b276947e0b5979b2a9dc3254f10386b70b330438a9e2550d507641ada606', '274b6784d8b0e783b41d9ab3fb59f83a07021384d77a8301c21ba682ca514f8e', '3d36d1a44dc7d02361253be531685a7847ff919030e830b3b7d33da323864bba', '5bbe3d686024848f24fe238d32a57ce72d50b8fbeebade01a3437d75950aab78', '29ea94d06c6751fb47652496c82e1e9d54be60eb454edad2d4cc70305b7e7f6e', 'e19a400eccb294099834cd56397edb9329d003e8e7f8394c8510ecb4ff2e9d49', '0c083cb2dbd6e02c5070ac69ebd99deb41243b9c86516b946c30254bc9ccdfa3', '3e1ecc54327242ce7149d3b94e40a827984e34f421957d76e724befb47850aea', 'fad466a738de01a3d36eccbe586f4d8fc8e0e794e6bc9a207ec1dfbc50cfc690', '11750e495d361a550d77d6e936bd58a2696b27b9dd7d52475b2bc378ab46e66a', '9207956b1757a8ef10e8b8533004f05c18df92096f40432e53657c80998e21d0', 'b863dd515fc616b5f20d11da86ec171c6d64e3cdd1fecce3d9201a8f011ed918', 'da347c609aa36f0a6fe6d9365f7d3f5ef3502894bbb295f976fd4029d2dbed7c', '6e504eddc254b4618c44e3887d0b3f48b87c3f8b7253974cc0ffc04032bd0eef', 'ab4458406f2073e0bb0cbb77d0c295e95a669935cc2eb6d6f9ad03fb919856f1', '2a2e824a93c12293bd306cfff5b94f9aa2d149e4b03e04b44ad5d10090ab59c1', 'f4580b2be48d5ff6900dff6228fd62d66670888dae4c7128179d74de159d034a', '196c688b79a90f8cf628b79d0930ce6b3ff72fb8c443b7225899a0d1fdc0acad', '41c131676852283c2ee7fed18fd9381091897a583dc88fc9141a5038c73ed594'] B the s-label for the service. {114: 1, 26: 1, 61: 1, 113: 1, 27: 1, 6: 4, 79: 4, 90: 3, 51: 4, 130: 4, 62: 6, 85: 7, 68: 6, 35: 5, 110: 3, 91: 5, 97: 4, 31: 4, 13: 3, 67: 3, 124: 5, 98: 4, 54: 4, 127: 5, 8: 4, 96: 4, 64: 4, 30: 4, 55: 5, 15: 3, 52: 3, 129: 5, 115: 3, 84: 3, 76: 8, 87: 3, 131: 7, 102: 3, 99: 4, 36: 3, 24: 2, 53: 3, 72: 4} {58: 1, 97: 1, 130: 1, 291: 1, 147: 1, 372: 1, 1: 11, 4: 4, 9: 7, 10: 5, 15: 4, 24: 4, 25: 6, 26: 7, 27: 4, 39: 7, 43: 5, 49: 6, 50: 5, 59: 4, 64: 4, 69: 6, 81: 7, 82: 5, 86: 3, 100: 8, 108: 5, 109: 6, 110: 6, 111: 4, 114: 5, 115: 6, 116: 4, 118: 8, 119: 7, 120: 5, 121: 6, 122: 5, 123: 4, 124: 6, 128: 4, 129: 4, 132: 6, 136: 4, 145: 6, 151: 4, 152: 4, 154: 5, 156: 3, 161: 5, 162: 5, 165: 5, 168: 6, 169: 3, 172: 3, 180: 4, 184: 7, 187: 7, 188: 6, 191: 5, 194: 6, 202: 7, 203: 8, 206: 4, 207: 5, 215: 4, 217: 5, 218: 10, 220: 4, 221: 4, 222: 7, 224: 5, 227: 6, 229: 3, 234: 7, 235: 4, 241: 4, 242: 4, 243: 6, 244: 4, 245: 6, 248: 4, 250: 5, 258: 13, 262: 6, 263: 7, 264: 5, 267: 6, 270: 4, 272: 3, 273: 7, 287: 5, 289: 3, 299: 6, 300: 4, 304: 4, 309: 5, 314: 4, 315: 3, 320: 6, 323: 6, 327: 6, 328: 5, 329: 4, 330: 12, 334: 4, 335: 4, 341: 6, 342: 7, 347: 6, 348: 6, 350: 9, 351: 5, 352: 3, 353: 3, 354: 2, 358: 6, 365: 3, 366: 4, 369: 3, 371: 8, 376: 4, 384: 5, 385: 4, 386: 5, 387: 4, 392: 5, 393: 6, 396: 7, 397: 9, 398: 8, 402: 3} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 38 If PRF is to be provided for the service. mpls - over - ip : minor tweaks ipOmpls : Section 6 , Management and Control Information Summary mpls : editorial changes , refactoring of section 5 for clarity and completeness white space cleanup ( remove tabs and trailing spaces ) 6eef101c3c863f944da82ed2f9cc38205de8aa61 6eef101c3c863f944da82ed2f9cc38205de8aa61 draft-ietf-detnet-mpls 75d8fb6c0eaa04ce99a6045642bc5e15246a22b21f752b965c428b1072c46889 ['3ef84f782267c0e0e968196f92f0e857d46f4f9ba7afbddce796cc8c50975a16', '2e08e5d79759a80040647153ce3fa7819f0612da07f964d940457940ee32eefb', 'd645de25ddd5a17db4ac8e4152ab9f48880b0362f999693b780b953092b4818b', '5afe7b6130289b07fae3f2293f0b50942f6484999592ab78deeb684af0961b90', '5496f74277f5150125eda22755e4e5935e4d30373ae21b9d251791bb3af70771', 'e0272e86b037d5f460db4807aede2c02c9d02cb129d656c91aa723e14be8738c', 'e88833dfc4793019fd0d380a39254338e0e1620775d4f0f64ba50f65f6304990', '2e1188e3ae68f9645fceeb16885fb2558ac488250197b0dac87311b7f9fc7ba3', '236b9ded3b3585aca0a348dc8cf9b49717f1a76ca847c280134ba2cafca9e2bf', 'c99484d301684eba379e2eaab522e22872390f584d0977611a9b71cd4e36e2a9', 'd4d0f5b26265d5747482d4c8c93706edd735ad6b653327445de5a09a5dcc5c2b', '3ad381ce14d392b11bc71c7f84aec9aa4faec501b897070e8cad5dfe435f09ff', '75d8fb6c0eaa04ce99a6045642bc5e15246a22b21f752b965c428b1072c46889', '959f68af8dfd80b8f76ac61803f842c5d5465c96fe9a54320df01a59d427bc74', 'ab1acdf4e7456e3c0c48ecf2a80771c96f1006cd94d541736e1432d7df837fff', 'f584b276947e0b5979b2a9dc3254f10386b70b330438a9e2550d507641ada606', '274b6784d8b0e783b41d9ab3fb59f83a07021384d77a8301c21ba682ca514f8e', '3d36d1a44dc7d02361253be531685a7847ff919030e830b3b7d33da323864bba', '5bbe3d686024848f24fe238d32a57ce72d50b8fbeebade01a3437d75950aab78', '29ea94d06c6751fb47652496c82e1e9d54be60eb454edad2d4cc70305b7e7f6e', 'e19a400eccb294099834cd56397edb9329d003e8e7f8394c8510ecb4ff2e9d49', '0c083cb2dbd6e02c5070ac69ebd99deb41243b9c86516b946c30254bc9ccdfa3', '3e1ecc54327242ce7149d3b94e40a827984e34f421957d76e724befb47850aea', 'fad466a738de01a3d36eccbe586f4d8fc8e0e794e6bc9a207ec1dfbc50cfc690', '11750e495d361a550d77d6e936bd58a2696b27b9dd7d52475b2bc378ab46e66a', '9207956b1757a8ef10e8b8533004f05c18df92096f40432e53657c80998e21d0', 'b863dd515fc616b5f20d11da86ec171c6d64e3cdd1fecce3d9201a8f011ed918', 'da347c609aa36f0a6fe6d9365f7d3f5ef3502894bbb295f976fd4029d2dbed7c', '6e504eddc254b4618c44e3887d0b3f48b87c3f8b7253974cc0ffc04032bd0eef', 'ab4458406f2073e0bb0cbb77d0c295e95a669935cc2eb6d6f9ad03fb919856f1', '2a2e824a93c12293bd306cfff5b94f9aa2d149e4b03e04b44ad5d10090ab59c1', 'f4580b2be48d5ff6900dff6228fd62d66670888dae4c7128179d74de159d034a', '196c688b79a90f8cf628b79d0930ce6b3ff72fb8c443b7225899a0d1fdc0acad', '41c131676852283c2ee7fed18fd9381091897a583dc88fc9141a5038c73ed594'] B if prf is to be provided for the service. {114: 1, 26: 1, 61: 1, 113: 1, 27: 1, 6: 4, 79: 4, 90: 3, 51: 4, 130: 4, 62: 6, 85: 7, 68: 6, 35: 5, 110: 3, 91: 5, 97: 4, 31: 4, 13: 3, 67: 3, 124: 5, 98: 4, 54: 4, 127: 5, 8: 4, 96: 4, 64: 4, 30: 4, 55: 5, 15: 3, 52: 3, 129: 5, 115: 3, 84: 3, 76: 8, 87: 3, 131: 7, 102: 3, 99: 4, 36: 3, 24: 2, 53: 3, 72: 4} {58: 1, 97: 1, 130: 1, 291: 1, 147: 1, 372: 1, 1: 11, 4: 4, 9: 7, 10: 5, 15: 4, 24: 4, 25: 6, 26: 7, 27: 4, 39: 7, 43: 5, 49: 6, 50: 5, 59: 4, 64: 4, 69: 6, 81: 7, 82: 5, 86: 3, 100: 8, 108: 5, 109: 6, 110: 6, 111: 4, 114: 5, 115: 6, 116: 4, 118: 8, 119: 7, 120: 5, 121: 6, 122: 5, 123: 4, 124: 6, 128: 4, 129: 4, 132: 6, 136: 4, 145: 6, 151: 4, 152: 4, 154: 5, 156: 3, 161: 5, 162: 5, 165: 5, 168: 6, 169: 3, 172: 3, 180: 4, 184: 7, 187: 7, 188: 6, 191: 5, 194: 6, 202: 7, 203: 8, 206: 4, 207: 5, 215: 4, 217: 5, 218: 10, 220: 4, 221: 4, 222: 7, 224: 5, 227: 6, 229: 3, 234: 7, 235: 4, 241: 4, 242: 4, 243: 6, 244: 4, 245: 6, 248: 4, 250: 5, 258: 13, 262: 6, 263: 7, 264: 5, 267: 6, 270: 4, 272: 3, 273: 7, 287: 5, 289: 3, 299: 6, 300: 4, 304: 4, 309: 5, 314: 4, 315: 3, 320: 6, 323: 6, 327: 6, 328: 5, 329: 4, 330: 12, 334: 4, 335: 4, 341: 6, 342: 7, 347: 6, 348: 6, 350: 9, 351: 5, 352: 3, 353: 3, 354: 2, 358: 6, 365: 3, 366: 4, 369: 3, 371: 8, 376: 4, 384: 5, 385: 4, 386: 5, 387: 4, 392: 5, 393: 6, 396: 7, 397: 9, 398: 8, 402: 3} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 38 "The forwarding sub-layer information associated with the output of the service sub-layer. Note that when the PRF function is provisioned, this information is per DetNet member flow. Logically this is a pointer to details provided below for transmission of Detnet flows at the forwarding sub-layer." mpls - over - ip : minor tweaks ipOmpls : Section 6 , Management and Control Information Summary mpls : editorial changes , refactoring of section 5 for clarity and completeness white space cleanup ( remove tabs and trailing spaces ) 6eef101c3c863f944da82ed2f9cc38205de8aa61 6eef101c3c863f944da82ed2f9cc38205de8aa61 draft-ietf-detnet-mpls e88833dfc4793019fd0d380a39254338e0e1620775d4f0f64ba50f65f6304990 ['3ef84f782267c0e0e968196f92f0e857d46f4f9ba7afbddce796cc8c50975a16', '2e08e5d79759a80040647153ce3fa7819f0612da07f964d940457940ee32eefb', 'd645de25ddd5a17db4ac8e4152ab9f48880b0362f999693b780b953092b4818b', '5afe7b6130289b07fae3f2293f0b50942f6484999592ab78deeb684af0961b90', '5496f74277f5150125eda22755e4e5935e4d30373ae21b9d251791bb3af70771', 'e0272e86b037d5f460db4807aede2c02c9d02cb129d656c91aa723e14be8738c', 'e88833dfc4793019fd0d380a39254338e0e1620775d4f0f64ba50f65f6304990', '2e1188e3ae68f9645fceeb16885fb2558ac488250197b0dac87311b7f9fc7ba3', '236b9ded3b3585aca0a348dc8cf9b49717f1a76ca847c280134ba2cafca9e2bf', 'c99484d301684eba379e2eaab522e22872390f584d0977611a9b71cd4e36e2a9', 'd4d0f5b26265d5747482d4c8c93706edd735ad6b653327445de5a09a5dcc5c2b', '3ad381ce14d392b11bc71c7f84aec9aa4faec501b897070e8cad5dfe435f09ff', '75d8fb6c0eaa04ce99a6045642bc5e15246a22b21f752b965c428b1072c46889', '959f68af8dfd80b8f76ac61803f842c5d5465c96fe9a54320df01a59d427bc74', 'ab1acdf4e7456e3c0c48ecf2a80771c96f1006cd94d541736e1432d7df837fff', 'f584b276947e0b5979b2a9dc3254f10386b70b330438a9e2550d507641ada606', '274b6784d8b0e783b41d9ab3fb59f83a07021384d77a8301c21ba682ca514f8e', '3d36d1a44dc7d02361253be531685a7847ff919030e830b3b7d33da323864bba', '5bbe3d686024848f24fe238d32a57ce72d50b8fbeebade01a3437d75950aab78', '29ea94d06c6751fb47652496c82e1e9d54be60eb454edad2d4cc70305b7e7f6e', 'e19a400eccb294099834cd56397edb9329d003e8e7f8394c8510ecb4ff2e9d49', '0c083cb2dbd6e02c5070ac69ebd99deb41243b9c86516b946c30254bc9ccdfa3', '3e1ecc54327242ce7149d3b94e40a827984e34f421957d76e724befb47850aea', 'fad466a738de01a3d36eccbe586f4d8fc8e0e794e6bc9a207ec1dfbc50cfc690', '11750e495d361a550d77d6e936bd58a2696b27b9dd7d52475b2bc378ab46e66a', '9207956b1757a8ef10e8b8533004f05c18df92096f40432e53657c80998e21d0', 'b863dd515fc616b5f20d11da86ec171c6d64e3cdd1fecce3d9201a8f011ed918', 'da347c609aa36f0a6fe6d9365f7d3f5ef3502894bbb295f976fd4029d2dbed7c', '6e504eddc254b4618c44e3887d0b3f48b87c3f8b7253974cc0ffc04032bd0eef', 'ab4458406f2073e0bb0cbb77d0c295e95a669935cc2eb6d6f9ad03fb919856f1', '2a2e824a93c12293bd306cfff5b94f9aa2d149e4b03e04b44ad5d10090ab59c1', 'f4580b2be48d5ff6900dff6228fd62d66670888dae4c7128179d74de159d034a', '196c688b79a90f8cf628b79d0930ce6b3ff72fb8c443b7225899a0d1fdc0acad', '41c131676852283c2ee7fed18fd9381091897a583dc88fc9141a5038c73ed594'] B "the forwarding sub-layer information associated with the output of the service sub-layer. note that when the prf function is provisioned, this information is per detnet member flow. logically this is a pointer to details provided below for transmission of detnet flows at the forwarding sub-layer." {114: 1, 26: 1, 61: 1, 113: 1, 27: 1, 6: 4, 79: 4, 90: 3, 51: 4, 130: 4, 62: 6, 85: 7, 68: 6, 35: 5, 110: 3, 91: 5, 97: 4, 31: 4, 13: 3, 67: 3, 124: 5, 98: 4, 54: 4, 127: 5, 8: 4, 96: 4, 64: 4, 30: 4, 55: 5, 15: 3, 52: 3, 129: 5, 115: 3, 84: 3, 76: 8, 87: 3, 131: 7, 102: 3, 99: 4, 36: 3, 24: 2, 53: 3, 72: 4} {58: 1, 97: 1, 130: 1, 291: 1, 147: 1, 372: 1, 1: 11, 4: 4, 9: 7, 10: 5, 15: 4, 24: 4, 25: 6, 26: 7, 27: 4, 39: 7, 43: 5, 49: 6, 50: 5, 59: 4, 64: 4, 69: 6, 81: 7, 82: 5, 86: 3, 100: 8, 108: 5, 109: 6, 110: 6, 111: 4, 114: 5, 115: 6, 116: 4, 118: 8, 119: 7, 120: 5, 121: 6, 122: 5, 123: 4, 124: 6, 128: 4, 129: 4, 132: 6, 136: 4, 145: 6, 151: 4, 152: 4, 154: 5, 156: 3, 161: 5, 162: 5, 165: 5, 168: 6, 169: 3, 172: 3, 180: 4, 184: 7, 187: 7, 188: 6, 191: 5, 194: 6, 202: 7, 203: 8, 206: 4, 207: 5, 215: 4, 217: 5, 218: 10, 220: 4, 221: 4, 222: 7, 224: 5, 227: 6, 229: 3, 234: 7, 235: 4, 241: 4, 242: 4, 243: 6, 244: 4, 245: 6, 248: 4, 250: 5, 258: 13, 262: 6, 263: 7, 264: 5, 267: 6, 270: 4, 272: 3, 273: 7, 287: 5, 289: 3, 299: 6, 300: 4, 304: 4, 309: 5, 314: 4, 315: 3, 320: 6, 323: 6, 327: 6, 328: 5, 329: 4, 330: 12, 334: 4, 335: 4, 341: 6, 342: 7, 347: 6, 348: 6, 350: 9, 351: 5, 352: 3, 353: 3, 354: 2, 358: 6, 365: 3, 366: 4, 369: 3, 371: 8, 376: 4, 384: 5, 385: 4, 386: 5, 387: 4, 392: 5, 393: 6, 396: 7, 397: 9, 398: 8, 402: 3} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 38 "The forwarding sub-layer information associated with the input of the service sub-layer. Note that when the PEF function is provisioned, this information is per DetNet member flow. Logically this is a pointer to details provided below related to the reception of Detnet flows at the forwarding sub-layer or A-Label." mpls - over - ip : minor tweaks ipOmpls : Section 6 , Management and Control Information Summary mpls : editorial changes , refactoring of section 5 for clarity and completeness white space cleanup ( remove tabs and trailing spaces ) 6eef101c3c863f944da82ed2f9cc38205de8aa61 6eef101c3c863f944da82ed2f9cc38205de8aa61 draft-ietf-detnet-mpls 3ad381ce14d392b11bc71c7f84aec9aa4faec501b897070e8cad5dfe435f09ff ['3ef84f782267c0e0e968196f92f0e857d46f4f9ba7afbddce796cc8c50975a16', '2e08e5d79759a80040647153ce3fa7819f0612da07f964d940457940ee32eefb', 'd645de25ddd5a17db4ac8e4152ab9f48880b0362f999693b780b953092b4818b', '5afe7b6130289b07fae3f2293f0b50942f6484999592ab78deeb684af0961b90', '5496f74277f5150125eda22755e4e5935e4d30373ae21b9d251791bb3af70771', 'e0272e86b037d5f460db4807aede2c02c9d02cb129d656c91aa723e14be8738c', 'e88833dfc4793019fd0d380a39254338e0e1620775d4f0f64ba50f65f6304990', '2e1188e3ae68f9645fceeb16885fb2558ac488250197b0dac87311b7f9fc7ba3', '236b9ded3b3585aca0a348dc8cf9b49717f1a76ca847c280134ba2cafca9e2bf', 'c99484d301684eba379e2eaab522e22872390f584d0977611a9b71cd4e36e2a9', 'd4d0f5b26265d5747482d4c8c93706edd735ad6b653327445de5a09a5dcc5c2b', '3ad381ce14d392b11bc71c7f84aec9aa4faec501b897070e8cad5dfe435f09ff', '75d8fb6c0eaa04ce99a6045642bc5e15246a22b21f752b965c428b1072c46889', '959f68af8dfd80b8f76ac61803f842c5d5465c96fe9a54320df01a59d427bc74', 'ab1acdf4e7456e3c0c48ecf2a80771c96f1006cd94d541736e1432d7df837fff', 'f584b276947e0b5979b2a9dc3254f10386b70b330438a9e2550d507641ada606', '274b6784d8b0e783b41d9ab3fb59f83a07021384d77a8301c21ba682ca514f8e', '3d36d1a44dc7d02361253be531685a7847ff919030e830b3b7d33da323864bba', '5bbe3d686024848f24fe238d32a57ce72d50b8fbeebade01a3437d75950aab78', '29ea94d06c6751fb47652496c82e1e9d54be60eb454edad2d4cc70305b7e7f6e', 'e19a400eccb294099834cd56397edb9329d003e8e7f8394c8510ecb4ff2e9d49', '0c083cb2dbd6e02c5070ac69ebd99deb41243b9c86516b946c30254bc9ccdfa3', '3e1ecc54327242ce7149d3b94e40a827984e34f421957d76e724befb47850aea', 'fad466a738de01a3d36eccbe586f4d8fc8e0e794e6bc9a207ec1dfbc50cfc690', '11750e495d361a550d77d6e936bd58a2696b27b9dd7d52475b2bc378ab46e66a', '9207956b1757a8ef10e8b8533004f05c18df92096f40432e53657c80998e21d0', 'b863dd515fc616b5f20d11da86ec171c6d64e3cdd1fecce3d9201a8f011ed918', 'da347c609aa36f0a6fe6d9365f7d3f5ef3502894bbb295f976fd4029d2dbed7c', '6e504eddc254b4618c44e3887d0b3f48b87c3f8b7253974cc0ffc04032bd0eef', 'ab4458406f2073e0bb0cbb77d0c295e95a669935cc2eb6d6f9ad03fb919856f1', '2a2e824a93c12293bd306cfff5b94f9aa2d149e4b03e04b44ad5d10090ab59c1', 'f4580b2be48d5ff6900dff6228fd62d66670888dae4c7128179d74de159d034a', '196c688b79a90f8cf628b79d0930ce6b3ff72fb8c443b7225899a0d1fdc0acad', '41c131676852283c2ee7fed18fd9381091897a583dc88fc9141a5038c73ed594'] B "the forwarding sub-layer information associated with the input of the service sub-layer. note that when the pef function is provisioned, this information is per detnet member flow. logically this is a pointer to details provided below related to the reception of detnet flows at the forwarding sub-layer or a-label." {114: 1, 26: 1, 61: 1, 113: 1, 27: 1, 6: 4, 79: 4, 90: 3, 51: 4, 130: 4, 62: 6, 85: 7, 68: 6, 35: 5, 110: 3, 91: 5, 97: 4, 31: 4, 13: 3, 67: 3, 124: 5, 98: 4, 54: 4, 127: 5, 8: 4, 96: 4, 64: 4, 30: 4, 55: 5, 15: 3, 52: 3, 129: 5, 115: 3, 84: 3, 76: 8, 87: 3, 131: 7, 102: 3, 99: 4, 36: 3, 24: 2, 53: 3, 72: 4} {58: 1, 97: 1, 130: 1, 291: 1, 147: 1, 372: 1, 1: 11, 4: 4, 9: 7, 10: 5, 15: 4, 24: 4, 25: 6, 26: 7, 27: 4, 39: 7, 43: 5, 49: 6, 50: 5, 59: 4, 64: 4, 69: 6, 81: 7, 82: 5, 86: 3, 100: 8, 108: 5, 109: 6, 110: 6, 111: 4, 114: 5, 115: 6, 116: 4, 118: 8, 119: 7, 120: 5, 121: 6, 122: 5, 123: 4, 124: 6, 128: 4, 129: 4, 132: 6, 136: 4, 145: 6, 151: 4, 152: 4, 154: 5, 156: 3, 161: 5, 162: 5, 165: 5, 168: 6, 169: 3, 172: 3, 180: 4, 184: 7, 187: 7, 188: 6, 191: 5, 194: 6, 202: 7, 203: 8, 206: 4, 207: 5, 215: 4, 217: 5, 218: 10, 220: 4, 221: 4, 222: 7, 224: 5, 227: 6, 229: 3, 234: 7, 235: 4, 241: 4, 242: 4, 243: 6, 244: 4, 245: 6, 248: 4, 250: 5, 258: 13, 262: 6, 263: 7, 264: 5, 267: 6, 270: 4, 272: 3, 273: 7, 287: 5, 289: 3, 299: 6, 300: 4, 304: 4, 309: 5, 314: 4, 315: 3, 320: 6, 323: 6, 327: 6, 328: 5, 329: 4, 330: 12, 334: 4, 335: 4, 341: 6, 342: 7, 347: 6, 348: 6, 350: 9, 351: 5, 352: 3, 353: 3, 354: 2, 358: 6, 365: 3, 366: 4, 369: 3, 371: 8, 376: 4, 384: 5, 385: 4, 386: 5, 387: 4, 392: 5, 393: 6, 396: 7, 397: 9, 398: 8, 402: 3} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 38 The S-Label for the received service. mpls - over - ip : minor tweaks ipOmpls : Section 6 , Management and Control Information Summary mpls : editorial changes , refactoring of section 5 for clarity and completeness white space cleanup ( remove tabs and trailing spaces ) 6eef101c3c863f944da82ed2f9cc38205de8aa61 6eef101c3c863f944da82ed2f9cc38205de8aa61 draft-ietf-detnet-mpls 5afe7b6130289b07fae3f2293f0b50942f6484999592ab78deeb684af0961b90 ['3ef84f782267c0e0e968196f92f0e857d46f4f9ba7afbddce796cc8c50975a16', '2e08e5d79759a80040647153ce3fa7819f0612da07f964d940457940ee32eefb', 'd645de25ddd5a17db4ac8e4152ab9f48880b0362f999693b780b953092b4818b', '5afe7b6130289b07fae3f2293f0b50942f6484999592ab78deeb684af0961b90', '5496f74277f5150125eda22755e4e5935e4d30373ae21b9d251791bb3af70771', 'e0272e86b037d5f460db4807aede2c02c9d02cb129d656c91aa723e14be8738c', 'e88833dfc4793019fd0d380a39254338e0e1620775d4f0f64ba50f65f6304990', '2e1188e3ae68f9645fceeb16885fb2558ac488250197b0dac87311b7f9fc7ba3', '236b9ded3b3585aca0a348dc8cf9b49717f1a76ca847c280134ba2cafca9e2bf', 'c99484d301684eba379e2eaab522e22872390f584d0977611a9b71cd4e36e2a9', 'd4d0f5b26265d5747482d4c8c93706edd735ad6b653327445de5a09a5dcc5c2b', '3ad381ce14d392b11bc71c7f84aec9aa4faec501b897070e8cad5dfe435f09ff', '75d8fb6c0eaa04ce99a6045642bc5e15246a22b21f752b965c428b1072c46889', '959f68af8dfd80b8f76ac61803f842c5d5465c96fe9a54320df01a59d427bc74', 'ab1acdf4e7456e3c0c48ecf2a80771c96f1006cd94d541736e1432d7df837fff', 'f584b276947e0b5979b2a9dc3254f10386b70b330438a9e2550d507641ada606', '274b6784d8b0e783b41d9ab3fb59f83a07021384d77a8301c21ba682ca514f8e', '3d36d1a44dc7d02361253be531685a7847ff919030e830b3b7d33da323864bba', '5bbe3d686024848f24fe238d32a57ce72d50b8fbeebade01a3437d75950aab78', '29ea94d06c6751fb47652496c82e1e9d54be60eb454edad2d4cc70305b7e7f6e', 'e19a400eccb294099834cd56397edb9329d003e8e7f8394c8510ecb4ff2e9d49', '0c083cb2dbd6e02c5070ac69ebd99deb41243b9c86516b946c30254bc9ccdfa3', '3e1ecc54327242ce7149d3b94e40a827984e34f421957d76e724befb47850aea', 'fad466a738de01a3d36eccbe586f4d8fc8e0e794e6bc9a207ec1dfbc50cfc690', '11750e495d361a550d77d6e936bd58a2696b27b9dd7d52475b2bc378ab46e66a', '9207956b1757a8ef10e8b8533004f05c18df92096f40432e53657c80998e21d0', 'b863dd515fc616b5f20d11da86ec171c6d64e3cdd1fecce3d9201a8f011ed918', 'da347c609aa36f0a6fe6d9365f7d3f5ef3502894bbb295f976fd4029d2dbed7c', '6e504eddc254b4618c44e3887d0b3f48b87c3f8b7253974cc0ffc04032bd0eef', 'ab4458406f2073e0bb0cbb77d0c295e95a669935cc2eb6d6f9ad03fb919856f1', '2a2e824a93c12293bd306cfff5b94f9aa2d149e4b03e04b44ad5d10090ab59c1', 'f4580b2be48d5ff6900dff6228fd62d66670888dae4c7128179d74de159d034a', '196c688b79a90f8cf628b79d0930ce6b3ff72fb8c443b7225899a0d1fdc0acad', '41c131676852283c2ee7fed18fd9381091897a583dc88fc9141a5038c73ed594'] B the s-label for the received service. {114: 1, 26: 1, 61: 1, 113: 1, 27: 1, 6: 4, 79: 4, 90: 3, 51: 4, 130: 4, 62: 6, 85: 7, 68: 6, 35: 5, 110: 3, 91: 5, 97: 4, 31: 4, 13: 3, 67: 3, 124: 5, 98: 4, 54: 4, 127: 5, 8: 4, 96: 4, 64: 4, 30: 4, 55: 5, 15: 3, 52: 3, 129: 5, 115: 3, 84: 3, 76: 8, 87: 3, 131: 7, 102: 3, 99: 4, 36: 3, 24: 2, 53: 3, 72: 4} {58: 1, 97: 1, 130: 1, 291: 1, 147: 1, 372: 1, 1: 11, 4: 4, 9: 7, 10: 5, 15: 4, 24: 4, 25: 6, 26: 7, 27: 4, 39: 7, 43: 5, 49: 6, 50: 5, 59: 4, 64: 4, 69: 6, 81: 7, 82: 5, 86: 3, 100: 8, 108: 5, 109: 6, 110: 6, 111: 4, 114: 5, 115: 6, 116: 4, 118: 8, 119: 7, 120: 5, 121: 6, 122: 5, 123: 4, 124: 6, 128: 4, 129: 4, 132: 6, 136: 4, 145: 6, 151: 4, 152: 4, 154: 5, 156: 3, 161: 5, 162: 5, 165: 5, 168: 6, 169: 3, 172: 3, 180: 4, 184: 7, 187: 7, 188: 6, 191: 5, 194: 6, 202: 7, 203: 8, 206: 4, 207: 5, 215: 4, 217: 5, 218: 10, 220: 4, 221: 4, 222: 7, 224: 5, 227: 6, 229: 3, 234: 7, 235: 4, 241: 4, 242: 4, 243: 6, 244: 4, 245: 6, 248: 4, 250: 5, 258: 13, 262: 6, 263: 7, 264: 5, 267: 6, 270: 4, 272: 3, 273: 7, 287: 5, 289: 3, 299: 6, 300: 4, 304: 4, 309: 5, 314: 4, 315: 3, 320: 6, 323: 6, 327: 6, 328: 5, 329: 4, 330: 12, 334: 4, 335: 4, 341: 6, 342: 7, 347: 6, 348: 6, 350: 9, 351: 5, 352: 3, 353: 3, 354: 2, 358: 6, 365: 3, 366: 4, 369: 3, 371: 8, 376: 4, 384: 5, 385: 4, 386: 5, 387: 4, 392: 5, 393: 6, 396: 7, 397: 9, 398: 8, 402: 3} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 38 If PEF or POF is to be provided for the service. mpls - over - ip : minor tweaks ipOmpls : Section 6 , Management and Control Information Summary mpls : editorial changes , refactoring of section 5 for clarity and completeness white space cleanup ( remove tabs and trailing spaces ) 6eef101c3c863f944da82ed2f9cc38205de8aa61 6eef101c3c863f944da82ed2f9cc38205de8aa61 draft-ietf-detnet-mpls 9207956b1757a8ef10e8b8533004f05c18df92096f40432e53657c80998e21d0 ['3ef84f782267c0e0e968196f92f0e857d46f4f9ba7afbddce796cc8c50975a16', '2e08e5d79759a80040647153ce3fa7819f0612da07f964d940457940ee32eefb', 'd645de25ddd5a17db4ac8e4152ab9f48880b0362f999693b780b953092b4818b', '5afe7b6130289b07fae3f2293f0b50942f6484999592ab78deeb684af0961b90', '5496f74277f5150125eda22755e4e5935e4d30373ae21b9d251791bb3af70771', 'e0272e86b037d5f460db4807aede2c02c9d02cb129d656c91aa723e14be8738c', 'e88833dfc4793019fd0d380a39254338e0e1620775d4f0f64ba50f65f6304990', '2e1188e3ae68f9645fceeb16885fb2558ac488250197b0dac87311b7f9fc7ba3', '236b9ded3b3585aca0a348dc8cf9b49717f1a76ca847c280134ba2cafca9e2bf', 'c99484d301684eba379e2eaab522e22872390f584d0977611a9b71cd4e36e2a9', 'd4d0f5b26265d5747482d4c8c93706edd735ad6b653327445de5a09a5dcc5c2b', '3ad381ce14d392b11bc71c7f84aec9aa4faec501b897070e8cad5dfe435f09ff', '75d8fb6c0eaa04ce99a6045642bc5e15246a22b21f752b965c428b1072c46889', '959f68af8dfd80b8f76ac61803f842c5d5465c96fe9a54320df01a59d427bc74', 'ab1acdf4e7456e3c0c48ecf2a80771c96f1006cd94d541736e1432d7df837fff', 'f584b276947e0b5979b2a9dc3254f10386b70b330438a9e2550d507641ada606', '274b6784d8b0e783b41d9ab3fb59f83a07021384d77a8301c21ba682ca514f8e', '3d36d1a44dc7d02361253be531685a7847ff919030e830b3b7d33da323864bba', '5bbe3d686024848f24fe238d32a57ce72d50b8fbeebade01a3437d75950aab78', '29ea94d06c6751fb47652496c82e1e9d54be60eb454edad2d4cc70305b7e7f6e', 'e19a400eccb294099834cd56397edb9329d003e8e7f8394c8510ecb4ff2e9d49', '0c083cb2dbd6e02c5070ac69ebd99deb41243b9c86516b946c30254bc9ccdfa3', '3e1ecc54327242ce7149d3b94e40a827984e34f421957d76e724befb47850aea', 'fad466a738de01a3d36eccbe586f4d8fc8e0e794e6bc9a207ec1dfbc50cfc690', '11750e495d361a550d77d6e936bd58a2696b27b9dd7d52475b2bc378ab46e66a', '9207956b1757a8ef10e8b8533004f05c18df92096f40432e53657c80998e21d0', 'b863dd515fc616b5f20d11da86ec171c6d64e3cdd1fecce3d9201a8f011ed918', 'da347c609aa36f0a6fe6d9365f7d3f5ef3502894bbb295f976fd4029d2dbed7c', '6e504eddc254b4618c44e3887d0b3f48b87c3f8b7253974cc0ffc04032bd0eef', 'ab4458406f2073e0bb0cbb77d0c295e95a669935cc2eb6d6f9ad03fb919856f1', '2a2e824a93c12293bd306cfff5b94f9aa2d149e4b03e04b44ad5d10090ab59c1', 'f4580b2be48d5ff6900dff6228fd62d66670888dae4c7128179d74de159d034a', '196c688b79a90f8cf628b79d0930ce6b3ff72fb8c443b7225899a0d1fdc0acad', '41c131676852283c2ee7fed18fd9381091897a583dc88fc9141a5038c73ed594'] B if pef or pof is to be provided for the service. {114: 1, 26: 1, 61: 1, 113: 1, 27: 1, 6: 4, 79: 4, 90: 3, 51: 4, 130: 4, 62: 6, 85: 7, 68: 6, 35: 5, 110: 3, 91: 5, 97: 4, 31: 4, 13: 3, 67: 3, 124: 5, 98: 4, 54: 4, 127: 5, 8: 4, 96: 4, 64: 4, 30: 4, 55: 5, 15: 3, 52: 3, 129: 5, 115: 3, 84: 3, 76: 8, 87: 3, 131: 7, 102: 3, 99: 4, 36: 3, 24: 2, 53: 3, 72: 4} {58: 1, 97: 1, 130: 1, 291: 1, 147: 1, 372: 1, 1: 11, 4: 4, 9: 7, 10: 5, 15: 4, 24: 4, 25: 6, 26: 7, 27: 4, 39: 7, 43: 5, 49: 6, 50: 5, 59: 4, 64: 4, 69: 6, 81: 7, 82: 5, 86: 3, 100: 8, 108: 5, 109: 6, 110: 6, 111: 4, 114: 5, 115: 6, 116: 4, 118: 8, 119: 7, 120: 5, 121: 6, 122: 5, 123: 4, 124: 6, 128: 4, 129: 4, 132: 6, 136: 4, 145: 6, 151: 4, 152: 4, 154: 5, 156: 3, 161: 5, 162: 5, 165: 5, 168: 6, 169: 3, 172: 3, 180: 4, 184: 7, 187: 7, 188: 6, 191: 5, 194: 6, 202: 7, 203: 8, 206: 4, 207: 5, 215: 4, 217: 5, 218: 10, 220: 4, 221: 4, 222: 7, 224: 5, 227: 6, 229: 3, 234: 7, 235: 4, 241: 4, 242: 4, 243: 6, 244: 4, 245: 6, 248: 4, 250: 5, 258: 13, 262: 6, 263: 7, 264: 5, 267: 6, 270: 4, 272: 3, 273: 7, 287: 5, 289: 3, 299: 6, 300: 4, 304: 4, 309: 5, 314: 4, 315: 3, 320: 6, 323: 6, 327: 6, 328: 5, 329: 4, 330: 12, 334: 4, 335: 4, 341: 6, 342: 7, 347: 6, 348: 6, 350: 9, 351: 5, 352: 3, 353: 3, 354: 2, 358: 6, 365: 3, 366: 4, 369: 3, 371: 8, 376: 4, 384: 5, 385: 4, 386: 5, 387: 4, 392: 5, 393: 6, 396: 7, 397: 9, 398: 8, 402: 3} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 38 "The sequence number length to be used for the service. Valid values included 0, 16 and 28 bits. 0 bits cannot be used when PEF or POF are configured for the service." mpls - over - ip : minor tweaks ipOmpls : Section 6 , Management and Control Information Summary mpls : editorial changes , refactoring of section 5 for clarity and completeness white space cleanup ( remove tabs and trailing spaces ) 6eef101c3c863f944da82ed2f9cc38205de8aa61 6eef101c3c863f944da82ed2f9cc38205de8aa61 draft-ietf-detnet-mpls 0c083cb2dbd6e02c5070ac69ebd99deb41243b9c86516b946c30254bc9ccdfa3 ['3ef84f782267c0e0e968196f92f0e857d46f4f9ba7afbddce796cc8c50975a16', '2e08e5d79759a80040647153ce3fa7819f0612da07f964d940457940ee32eefb', 'd645de25ddd5a17db4ac8e4152ab9f48880b0362f999693b780b953092b4818b', '5afe7b6130289b07fae3f2293f0b50942f6484999592ab78deeb684af0961b90', '5496f74277f5150125eda22755e4e5935e4d30373ae21b9d251791bb3af70771', 'e0272e86b037d5f460db4807aede2c02c9d02cb129d656c91aa723e14be8738c', 'e88833dfc4793019fd0d380a39254338e0e1620775d4f0f64ba50f65f6304990', '2e1188e3ae68f9645fceeb16885fb2558ac488250197b0dac87311b7f9fc7ba3', '236b9ded3b3585aca0a348dc8cf9b49717f1a76ca847c280134ba2cafca9e2bf', 'c99484d301684eba379e2eaab522e22872390f584d0977611a9b71cd4e36e2a9', 'd4d0f5b26265d5747482d4c8c93706edd735ad6b653327445de5a09a5dcc5c2b', '3ad381ce14d392b11bc71c7f84aec9aa4faec501b897070e8cad5dfe435f09ff', '75d8fb6c0eaa04ce99a6045642bc5e15246a22b21f752b965c428b1072c46889', '959f68af8dfd80b8f76ac61803f842c5d5465c96fe9a54320df01a59d427bc74', 'ab1acdf4e7456e3c0c48ecf2a80771c96f1006cd94d541736e1432d7df837fff', 'f584b276947e0b5979b2a9dc3254f10386b70b330438a9e2550d507641ada606', '274b6784d8b0e783b41d9ab3fb59f83a07021384d77a8301c21ba682ca514f8e', '3d36d1a44dc7d02361253be531685a7847ff919030e830b3b7d33da323864bba', '5bbe3d686024848f24fe238d32a57ce72d50b8fbeebade01a3437d75950aab78', '29ea94d06c6751fb47652496c82e1e9d54be60eb454edad2d4cc70305b7e7f6e', 'e19a400eccb294099834cd56397edb9329d003e8e7f8394c8510ecb4ff2e9d49', '0c083cb2dbd6e02c5070ac69ebd99deb41243b9c86516b946c30254bc9ccdfa3', '3e1ecc54327242ce7149d3b94e40a827984e34f421957d76e724befb47850aea', 'fad466a738de01a3d36eccbe586f4d8fc8e0e794e6bc9a207ec1dfbc50cfc690', '11750e495d361a550d77d6e936bd58a2696b27b9dd7d52475b2bc378ab46e66a', '9207956b1757a8ef10e8b8533004f05c18df92096f40432e53657c80998e21d0', 'b863dd515fc616b5f20d11da86ec171c6d64e3cdd1fecce3d9201a8f011ed918', 'da347c609aa36f0a6fe6d9365f7d3f5ef3502894bbb295f976fd4029d2dbed7c', '6e504eddc254b4618c44e3887d0b3f48b87c3f8b7253974cc0ffc04032bd0eef', 'ab4458406f2073e0bb0cbb77d0c295e95a669935cc2eb6d6f9ad03fb919856f1', '2a2e824a93c12293bd306cfff5b94f9aa2d149e4b03e04b44ad5d10090ab59c1', 'f4580b2be48d5ff6900dff6228fd62d66670888dae4c7128179d74de159d034a', '196c688b79a90f8cf628b79d0930ce6b3ff72fb8c443b7225899a0d1fdc0acad', '41c131676852283c2ee7fed18fd9381091897a583dc88fc9141a5038c73ed594'] B "the sequence number length to be used for the service. valid values included 0, 16 and 28 bits. 0 bits cannot be used when pef or pof are configured for the service." {114: 1, 26: 1, 61: 1, 113: 1, 27: 1, 6: 4, 79: 4, 90: 3, 51: 4, 130: 4, 62: 6, 85: 7, 68: 6, 35: 5, 110: 3, 91: 5, 97: 4, 31: 4, 13: 3, 67: 3, 124: 5, 98: 4, 54: 4, 127: 5, 8: 4, 96: 4, 64: 4, 30: 4, 55: 5, 15: 3, 52: 3, 129: 5, 115: 3, 84: 3, 76: 8, 87: 3, 131: 7, 102: 3, 99: 4, 36: 3, 24: 2, 53: 3, 72: 4} {58: 1, 97: 1, 130: 1, 291: 1, 147: 1, 372: 1, 1: 11, 4: 4, 9: 7, 10: 5, 15: 4, 24: 4, 25: 6, 26: 7, 27: 4, 39: 7, 43: 5, 49: 6, 50: 5, 59: 4, 64: 4, 69: 6, 81: 7, 82: 5, 86: 3, 100: 8, 108: 5, 109: 6, 110: 6, 111: 4, 114: 5, 115: 6, 116: 4, 118: 8, 119: 7, 120: 5, 121: 6, 122: 5, 123: 4, 124: 6, 128: 4, 129: 4, 132: 6, 136: 4, 145: 6, 151: 4, 152: 4, 154: 5, 156: 3, 161: 5, 162: 5, 165: 5, 168: 6, 169: 3, 172: 3, 180: 4, 184: 7, 187: 7, 188: 6, 191: 5, 194: 6, 202: 7, 203: 8, 206: 4, 207: 5, 215: 4, 217: 5, 218: 10, 220: 4, 221: 4, 222: 7, 224: 5, 227: 6, 229: 3, 234: 7, 235: 4, 241: 4, 242: 4, 243: 6, 244: 4, 245: 6, 248: 4, 250: 5, 258: 13, 262: 6, 263: 7, 264: 5, 267: 6, 270: 4, 272: 3, 273: 7, 287: 5, 289: 3, 299: 6, 300: 4, 304: 4, 309: 5, 314: 4, 315: 3, 320: 6, 323: 6, 327: 6, 328: 5, 329: 4, 330: 12, 334: 4, 335: 4, 341: 6, 342: 7, 347: 6, 348: 6, 350: 9, 351: 5, 352: 3, 353: 3, 354: 2, 358: 6, 365: 3, 366: 4, 369: 3, 371: 8, 376: 4, 384: 5, 385: 4, 386: 5, 387: 4, 392: 5, 393: 6, 396: 7, 397: 9, 398: 8, 402: 3} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 38 "Nodes performing aggregation using A-Labels, per Section aggregating- detnet-flows-as-a-new-detnet-flow, require the additional information summarized in this section." mpls - over - ip : minor tweaks ipOmpls : Section 6 , Management and Control Information Summary mpls : editorial changes , refactoring of section 5 for clarity and completeness white space cleanup ( remove tabs and trailing spaces ) 6eef101c3c863f944da82ed2f9cc38205de8aa61 6eef101c3c863f944da82ed2f9cc38205de8aa61 draft-ietf-detnet-mpls 11750e495d361a550d77d6e936bd58a2696b27b9dd7d52475b2bc378ab46e66a ['3ef84f782267c0e0e968196f92f0e857d46f4f9ba7afbddce796cc8c50975a16', '2e08e5d79759a80040647153ce3fa7819f0612da07f964d940457940ee32eefb', 'd645de25ddd5a17db4ac8e4152ab9f48880b0362f999693b780b953092b4818b', '5afe7b6130289b07fae3f2293f0b50942f6484999592ab78deeb684af0961b90', '5496f74277f5150125eda22755e4e5935e4d30373ae21b9d251791bb3af70771', 'e0272e86b037d5f460db4807aede2c02c9d02cb129d656c91aa723e14be8738c', 'e88833dfc4793019fd0d380a39254338e0e1620775d4f0f64ba50f65f6304990', '2e1188e3ae68f9645fceeb16885fb2558ac488250197b0dac87311b7f9fc7ba3', '236b9ded3b3585aca0a348dc8cf9b49717f1a76ca847c280134ba2cafca9e2bf', 'c99484d301684eba379e2eaab522e22872390f584d0977611a9b71cd4e36e2a9', 'd4d0f5b26265d5747482d4c8c93706edd735ad6b653327445de5a09a5dcc5c2b', '3ad381ce14d392b11bc71c7f84aec9aa4faec501b897070e8cad5dfe435f09ff', '75d8fb6c0eaa04ce99a6045642bc5e15246a22b21f752b965c428b1072c46889', '959f68af8dfd80b8f76ac61803f842c5d5465c96fe9a54320df01a59d427bc74', 'ab1acdf4e7456e3c0c48ecf2a80771c96f1006cd94d541736e1432d7df837fff', 'f584b276947e0b5979b2a9dc3254f10386b70b330438a9e2550d507641ada606', '274b6784d8b0e783b41d9ab3fb59f83a07021384d77a8301c21ba682ca514f8e', '3d36d1a44dc7d02361253be531685a7847ff919030e830b3b7d33da323864bba', '5bbe3d686024848f24fe238d32a57ce72d50b8fbeebade01a3437d75950aab78', '29ea94d06c6751fb47652496c82e1e9d54be60eb454edad2d4cc70305b7e7f6e', 'e19a400eccb294099834cd56397edb9329d003e8e7f8394c8510ecb4ff2e9d49', '0c083cb2dbd6e02c5070ac69ebd99deb41243b9c86516b946c30254bc9ccdfa3', '3e1ecc54327242ce7149d3b94e40a827984e34f421957d76e724befb47850aea', 'fad466a738de01a3d36eccbe586f4d8fc8e0e794e6bc9a207ec1dfbc50cfc690', '11750e495d361a550d77d6e936bd58a2696b27b9dd7d52475b2bc378ab46e66a', '9207956b1757a8ef10e8b8533004f05c18df92096f40432e53657c80998e21d0', 'b863dd515fc616b5f20d11da86ec171c6d64e3cdd1fecce3d9201a8f011ed918', 'da347c609aa36f0a6fe6d9365f7d3f5ef3502894bbb295f976fd4029d2dbed7c', '6e504eddc254b4618c44e3887d0b3f48b87c3f8b7253974cc0ffc04032bd0eef', 'ab4458406f2073e0bb0cbb77d0c295e95a669935cc2eb6d6f9ad03fb919856f1', '2a2e824a93c12293bd306cfff5b94f9aa2d149e4b03e04b44ad5d10090ab59c1', 'f4580b2be48d5ff6900dff6228fd62d66670888dae4c7128179d74de159d034a', '196c688b79a90f8cf628b79d0930ce6b3ff72fb8c443b7225899a0d1fdc0acad', '41c131676852283c2ee7fed18fd9381091897a583dc88fc9141a5038c73ed594'] B "nodes performing aggregation using a-labels, per section aggregating- detnet-flows-as-a-new-detnet-flow, require the additional information summarized in this section." {114: 1, 26: 1, 61: 1, 113: 1, 27: 1, 6: 4, 79: 4, 90: 3, 51: 4, 130: 4, 62: 6, 85: 7, 68: 6, 35: 5, 110: 3, 91: 5, 97: 4, 31: 4, 13: 3, 67: 3, 124: 5, 98: 4, 54: 4, 127: 5, 8: 4, 96: 4, 64: 4, 30: 4, 55: 5, 15: 3, 52: 3, 129: 5, 115: 3, 84: 3, 76: 8, 87: 3, 131: 7, 102: 3, 99: 4, 36: 3, 24: 2, 53: 3, 72: 4} {58: 1, 97: 1, 130: 1, 291: 1, 147: 1, 372: 1, 1: 11, 4: 4, 9: 7, 10: 5, 15: 4, 24: 4, 25: 6, 26: 7, 27: 4, 39: 7, 43: 5, 49: 6, 50: 5, 59: 4, 64: 4, 69: 6, 81: 7, 82: 5, 86: 3, 100: 8, 108: 5, 109: 6, 110: 6, 111: 4, 114: 5, 115: 6, 116: 4, 118: 8, 119: 7, 120: 5, 121: 6, 122: 5, 123: 4, 124: 6, 128: 4, 129: 4, 132: 6, 136: 4, 145: 6, 151: 4, 152: 4, 154: 5, 156: 3, 161: 5, 162: 5, 165: 5, 168: 6, 169: 3, 172: 3, 180: 4, 184: 7, 187: 7, 188: 6, 191: 5, 194: 6, 202: 7, 203: 8, 206: 4, 207: 5, 215: 4, 217: 5, 218: 10, 220: 4, 221: 4, 222: 7, 224: 5, 227: 6, 229: 3, 234: 7, 235: 4, 241: 4, 242: 4, 243: 6, 244: 4, 245: 6, 248: 4, 250: 5, 258: 13, 262: 6, 263: 7, 264: 5, 267: 6, 270: 4, 272: 3, 273: 7, 287: 5, 289: 3, 299: 6, 300: 4, 304: 4, 309: 5, 314: 4, 315: 3, 320: 6, 323: 6, 327: 6, 328: 5, 329: 4, 330: 12, 334: 4, 335: 4, 341: 6, 342: 7, 347: 6, 348: 6, 350: 9, 351: 5, 352: 3, 353: 3, 354: 2, 358: 6, 365: 3, 366: 4, 369: 3, 371: 8, 376: 4, 384: 5, 385: 4, 386: 5, 387: 4, 392: 5, 393: 6, 396: 7, 397: 9, 398: 8, 402: 3} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 38 "The S-Labels or F-Labels that are to be carried over each aggregated service." mpls - over - ip : minor tweaks ipOmpls : Section 6 , Management and Control Information Summary mpls : editorial changes , refactoring of section 5 for clarity and completeness white space cleanup ( remove tabs and trailing spaces ) 6eef101c3c863f944da82ed2f9cc38205de8aa61 6eef101c3c863f944da82ed2f9cc38205de8aa61 draft-ietf-detnet-mpls 2a2e824a93c12293bd306cfff5b94f9aa2d149e4b03e04b44ad5d10090ab59c1 ['3ef84f782267c0e0e968196f92f0e857d46f4f9ba7afbddce796cc8c50975a16', '2e08e5d79759a80040647153ce3fa7819f0612da07f964d940457940ee32eefb', 'd645de25ddd5a17db4ac8e4152ab9f48880b0362f999693b780b953092b4818b', '5afe7b6130289b07fae3f2293f0b50942f6484999592ab78deeb684af0961b90', '5496f74277f5150125eda22755e4e5935e4d30373ae21b9d251791bb3af70771', 'e0272e86b037d5f460db4807aede2c02c9d02cb129d656c91aa723e14be8738c', 'e88833dfc4793019fd0d380a39254338e0e1620775d4f0f64ba50f65f6304990', '2e1188e3ae68f9645fceeb16885fb2558ac488250197b0dac87311b7f9fc7ba3', '236b9ded3b3585aca0a348dc8cf9b49717f1a76ca847c280134ba2cafca9e2bf', 'c99484d301684eba379e2eaab522e22872390f584d0977611a9b71cd4e36e2a9', 'd4d0f5b26265d5747482d4c8c93706edd735ad6b653327445de5a09a5dcc5c2b', '3ad381ce14d392b11bc71c7f84aec9aa4faec501b897070e8cad5dfe435f09ff', '75d8fb6c0eaa04ce99a6045642bc5e15246a22b21f752b965c428b1072c46889', '959f68af8dfd80b8f76ac61803f842c5d5465c96fe9a54320df01a59d427bc74', 'ab1acdf4e7456e3c0c48ecf2a80771c96f1006cd94d541736e1432d7df837fff', 'f584b276947e0b5979b2a9dc3254f10386b70b330438a9e2550d507641ada606', '274b6784d8b0e783b41d9ab3fb59f83a07021384d77a8301c21ba682ca514f8e', '3d36d1a44dc7d02361253be531685a7847ff919030e830b3b7d33da323864bba', '5bbe3d686024848f24fe238d32a57ce72d50b8fbeebade01a3437d75950aab78', '29ea94d06c6751fb47652496c82e1e9d54be60eb454edad2d4cc70305b7e7f6e', 'e19a400eccb294099834cd56397edb9329d003e8e7f8394c8510ecb4ff2e9d49', '0c083cb2dbd6e02c5070ac69ebd99deb41243b9c86516b946c30254bc9ccdfa3', '3e1ecc54327242ce7149d3b94e40a827984e34f421957d76e724befb47850aea', 'fad466a738de01a3d36eccbe586f4d8fc8e0e794e6bc9a207ec1dfbc50cfc690', '11750e495d361a550d77d6e936bd58a2696b27b9dd7d52475b2bc378ab46e66a', '9207956b1757a8ef10e8b8533004f05c18df92096f40432e53657c80998e21d0', 'b863dd515fc616b5f20d11da86ec171c6d64e3cdd1fecce3d9201a8f011ed918', 'da347c609aa36f0a6fe6d9365f7d3f5ef3502894bbb295f976fd4029d2dbed7c', '6e504eddc254b4618c44e3887d0b3f48b87c3f8b7253974cc0ffc04032bd0eef', 'ab4458406f2073e0bb0cbb77d0c295e95a669935cc2eb6d6f9ad03fb919856f1', '2a2e824a93c12293bd306cfff5b94f9aa2d149e4b03e04b44ad5d10090ab59c1', 'f4580b2be48d5ff6900dff6228fd62d66670888dae4c7128179d74de159d034a', '196c688b79a90f8cf628b79d0930ce6b3ff72fb8c443b7225899a0d1fdc0acad', '41c131676852283c2ee7fed18fd9381091897a583dc88fc9141a5038c73ed594'] B "the s-labels or f-labels that are to be carried over each aggregated service." {114: 1, 26: 1, 61: 1, 113: 1, 27: 1, 6: 4, 79: 4, 90: 3, 51: 4, 130: 4, 62: 6, 85: 7, 68: 6, 35: 5, 110: 3, 91: 5, 97: 4, 31: 4, 13: 3, 67: 3, 124: 5, 98: 4, 54: 4, 127: 5, 8: 4, 96: 4, 64: 4, 30: 4, 55: 5, 15: 3, 52: 3, 129: 5, 115: 3, 84: 3, 76: 8, 87: 3, 131: 7, 102: 3, 99: 4, 36: 3, 24: 2, 53: 3, 72: 4} {58: 1, 97: 1, 130: 1, 291: 1, 147: 1, 372: 1, 1: 11, 4: 4, 9: 7, 10: 5, 15: 4, 24: 4, 25: 6, 26: 7, 27: 4, 39: 7, 43: 5, 49: 6, 50: 5, 59: 4, 64: 4, 69: 6, 81: 7, 82: 5, 86: 3, 100: 8, 108: 5, 109: 6, 110: 6, 111: 4, 114: 5, 115: 6, 116: 4, 118: 8, 119: 7, 120: 5, 121: 6, 122: 5, 123: 4, 124: 6, 128: 4, 129: 4, 132: 6, 136: 4, 145: 6, 151: 4, 152: 4, 154: 5, 156: 3, 161: 5, 162: 5, 165: 5, 168: 6, 169: 3, 172: 3, 180: 4, 184: 7, 187: 7, 188: 6, 191: 5, 194: 6, 202: 7, 203: 8, 206: 4, 207: 5, 215: 4, 217: 5, 218: 10, 220: 4, 221: 4, 222: 7, 224: 5, 227: 6, 229: 3, 234: 7, 235: 4, 241: 4, 242: 4, 243: 6, 244: 4, 245: 6, 248: 4, 250: 5, 258: 13, 262: 6, 263: 7, 264: 5, 267: 6, 270: 4, 272: 3, 273: 7, 287: 5, 289: 3, 299: 6, 300: 4, 304: 4, 309: 5, 314: 4, 315: 3, 320: 6, 323: 6, 327: 6, 328: 5, 329: 4, 330: 12, 334: 4, 335: 4, 341: 6, 342: 7, 347: 6, 348: 6, 350: 9, 351: 5, 352: 3, 353: 3, 354: 2, 358: 6, 365: 3, 366: 4, 369: 3, 371: 8, 376: 4, 384: 5, 385: 4, 386: 5, 387: 4, 392: 5, 393: 6, 396: 7, 397: 9, 398: 8, 402: 3} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 38 The A-Label associated with each aggregated service. mpls - over - ip : minor tweaks ipOmpls : Section 6 , Management and Control Information Summary mpls : editorial changes , refactoring of section 5 for clarity and completeness white space cleanup ( remove tabs and trailing spaces ) 6eef101c3c863f944da82ed2f9cc38205de8aa61 6eef101c3c863f944da82ed2f9cc38205de8aa61 draft-ietf-detnet-mpls ab1acdf4e7456e3c0c48ecf2a80771c96f1006cd94d541736e1432d7df837fff ['3ef84f782267c0e0e968196f92f0e857d46f4f9ba7afbddce796cc8c50975a16', '2e08e5d79759a80040647153ce3fa7819f0612da07f964d940457940ee32eefb', 'd645de25ddd5a17db4ac8e4152ab9f48880b0362f999693b780b953092b4818b', '5afe7b6130289b07fae3f2293f0b50942f6484999592ab78deeb684af0961b90', '5496f74277f5150125eda22755e4e5935e4d30373ae21b9d251791bb3af70771', 'e0272e86b037d5f460db4807aede2c02c9d02cb129d656c91aa723e14be8738c', 'e88833dfc4793019fd0d380a39254338e0e1620775d4f0f64ba50f65f6304990', '2e1188e3ae68f9645fceeb16885fb2558ac488250197b0dac87311b7f9fc7ba3', '236b9ded3b3585aca0a348dc8cf9b49717f1a76ca847c280134ba2cafca9e2bf', 'c99484d301684eba379e2eaab522e22872390f584d0977611a9b71cd4e36e2a9', 'd4d0f5b26265d5747482d4c8c93706edd735ad6b653327445de5a09a5dcc5c2b', '3ad381ce14d392b11bc71c7f84aec9aa4faec501b897070e8cad5dfe435f09ff', '75d8fb6c0eaa04ce99a6045642bc5e15246a22b21f752b965c428b1072c46889', '959f68af8dfd80b8f76ac61803f842c5d5465c96fe9a54320df01a59d427bc74', 'ab1acdf4e7456e3c0c48ecf2a80771c96f1006cd94d541736e1432d7df837fff', 'f584b276947e0b5979b2a9dc3254f10386b70b330438a9e2550d507641ada606', '274b6784d8b0e783b41d9ab3fb59f83a07021384d77a8301c21ba682ca514f8e', '3d36d1a44dc7d02361253be531685a7847ff919030e830b3b7d33da323864bba', '5bbe3d686024848f24fe238d32a57ce72d50b8fbeebade01a3437d75950aab78', '29ea94d06c6751fb47652496c82e1e9d54be60eb454edad2d4cc70305b7e7f6e', 'e19a400eccb294099834cd56397edb9329d003e8e7f8394c8510ecb4ff2e9d49', '0c083cb2dbd6e02c5070ac69ebd99deb41243b9c86516b946c30254bc9ccdfa3', '3e1ecc54327242ce7149d3b94e40a827984e34f421957d76e724befb47850aea', 'fad466a738de01a3d36eccbe586f4d8fc8e0e794e6bc9a207ec1dfbc50cfc690', '11750e495d361a550d77d6e936bd58a2696b27b9dd7d52475b2bc378ab46e66a', '9207956b1757a8ef10e8b8533004f05c18df92096f40432e53657c80998e21d0', 'b863dd515fc616b5f20d11da86ec171c6d64e3cdd1fecce3d9201a8f011ed918', 'da347c609aa36f0a6fe6d9365f7d3f5ef3502894bbb295f976fd4029d2dbed7c', '6e504eddc254b4618c44e3887d0b3f48b87c3f8b7253974cc0ffc04032bd0eef', 'ab4458406f2073e0bb0cbb77d0c295e95a669935cc2eb6d6f9ad03fb919856f1', '2a2e824a93c12293bd306cfff5b94f9aa2d149e4b03e04b44ad5d10090ab59c1', 'f4580b2be48d5ff6900dff6228fd62d66670888dae4c7128179d74de159d034a', '196c688b79a90f8cf628b79d0930ce6b3ff72fb8c443b7225899a0d1fdc0acad', '41c131676852283c2ee7fed18fd9381091897a583dc88fc9141a5038c73ed594'] B the a-label associated with each aggregated service. {114: 1, 26: 1, 61: 1, 113: 1, 27: 1, 6: 4, 79: 4, 90: 3, 51: 4, 130: 4, 62: 6, 85: 7, 68: 6, 35: 5, 110: 3, 91: 5, 97: 4, 31: 4, 13: 3, 67: 3, 124: 5, 98: 4, 54: 4, 127: 5, 8: 4, 96: 4, 64: 4, 30: 4, 55: 5, 15: 3, 52: 3, 129: 5, 115: 3, 84: 3, 76: 8, 87: 3, 131: 7, 102: 3, 99: 4, 36: 3, 24: 2, 53: 3, 72: 4} {58: 1, 97: 1, 130: 1, 291: 1, 147: 1, 372: 1, 1: 11, 4: 4, 9: 7, 10: 5, 15: 4, 24: 4, 25: 6, 26: 7, 27: 4, 39: 7, 43: 5, 49: 6, 50: 5, 59: 4, 64: 4, 69: 6, 81: 7, 82: 5, 86: 3, 100: 8, 108: 5, 109: 6, 110: 6, 111: 4, 114: 5, 115: 6, 116: 4, 118: 8, 119: 7, 120: 5, 121: 6, 122: 5, 123: 4, 124: 6, 128: 4, 129: 4, 132: 6, 136: 4, 145: 6, 151: 4, 152: 4, 154: 5, 156: 3, 161: 5, 162: 5, 165: 5, 168: 6, 169: 3, 172: 3, 180: 4, 184: 7, 187: 7, 188: 6, 191: 5, 194: 6, 202: 7, 203: 8, 206: 4, 207: 5, 215: 4, 217: 5, 218: 10, 220: 4, 221: 4, 222: 7, 224: 5, 227: 6, 229: 3, 234: 7, 235: 4, 241: 4, 242: 4, 243: 6, 244: 4, 245: 6, 248: 4, 250: 5, 258: 13, 262: 6, 263: 7, 264: 5, 267: 6, 270: 4, 272: 3, 273: 7, 287: 5, 289: 3, 299: 6, 300: 4, 304: 4, 309: 5, 314: 4, 315: 3, 320: 6, 323: 6, 327: 6, 328: 5, 329: 4, 330: 12, 334: 4, 335: 4, 341: 6, 342: 7, 347: 6, 348: 6, 350: 9, 351: 5, 352: 3, 353: 3, 354: 2, 358: 6, 365: 3, 366: 4, 369: 3, 371: 8, 376: 4, 384: 5, 385: 4, 386: 5, 387: 4, 392: 5, 393: 6, 396: 7, 397: 9, 398: 8, 402: 3} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 38 The other S-Label information summarized above. mpls - over - ip : minor tweaks ipOmpls : Section 6 , Management and Control Information Summary mpls : editorial changes , refactoring of section 5 for clarity and completeness white space cleanup ( remove tabs and trailing spaces ) 6eef101c3c863f944da82ed2f9cc38205de8aa61 6eef101c3c863f944da82ed2f9cc38205de8aa61 draft-ietf-detnet-mpls f584b276947e0b5979b2a9dc3254f10386b70b330438a9e2550d507641ada606 ['3ef84f782267c0e0e968196f92f0e857d46f4f9ba7afbddce796cc8c50975a16', '2e08e5d79759a80040647153ce3fa7819f0612da07f964d940457940ee32eefb', 'd645de25ddd5a17db4ac8e4152ab9f48880b0362f999693b780b953092b4818b', '5afe7b6130289b07fae3f2293f0b50942f6484999592ab78deeb684af0961b90', '5496f74277f5150125eda22755e4e5935e4d30373ae21b9d251791bb3af70771', 'e0272e86b037d5f460db4807aede2c02c9d02cb129d656c91aa723e14be8738c', 'e88833dfc4793019fd0d380a39254338e0e1620775d4f0f64ba50f65f6304990', '2e1188e3ae68f9645fceeb16885fb2558ac488250197b0dac87311b7f9fc7ba3', '236b9ded3b3585aca0a348dc8cf9b49717f1a76ca847c280134ba2cafca9e2bf', 'c99484d301684eba379e2eaab522e22872390f584d0977611a9b71cd4e36e2a9', 'd4d0f5b26265d5747482d4c8c93706edd735ad6b653327445de5a09a5dcc5c2b', '3ad381ce14d392b11bc71c7f84aec9aa4faec501b897070e8cad5dfe435f09ff', '75d8fb6c0eaa04ce99a6045642bc5e15246a22b21f752b965c428b1072c46889', '959f68af8dfd80b8f76ac61803f842c5d5465c96fe9a54320df01a59d427bc74', 'ab1acdf4e7456e3c0c48ecf2a80771c96f1006cd94d541736e1432d7df837fff', 'f584b276947e0b5979b2a9dc3254f10386b70b330438a9e2550d507641ada606', '274b6784d8b0e783b41d9ab3fb59f83a07021384d77a8301c21ba682ca514f8e', '3d36d1a44dc7d02361253be531685a7847ff919030e830b3b7d33da323864bba', '5bbe3d686024848f24fe238d32a57ce72d50b8fbeebade01a3437d75950aab78', '29ea94d06c6751fb47652496c82e1e9d54be60eb454edad2d4cc70305b7e7f6e', 'e19a400eccb294099834cd56397edb9329d003e8e7f8394c8510ecb4ff2e9d49', '0c083cb2dbd6e02c5070ac69ebd99deb41243b9c86516b946c30254bc9ccdfa3', '3e1ecc54327242ce7149d3b94e40a827984e34f421957d76e724befb47850aea', 'fad466a738de01a3d36eccbe586f4d8fc8e0e794e6bc9a207ec1dfbc50cfc690', '11750e495d361a550d77d6e936bd58a2696b27b9dd7d52475b2bc378ab46e66a', '9207956b1757a8ef10e8b8533004f05c18df92096f40432e53657c80998e21d0', 'b863dd515fc616b5f20d11da86ec171c6d64e3cdd1fecce3d9201a8f011ed918', 'da347c609aa36f0a6fe6d9365f7d3f5ef3502894bbb295f976fd4029d2dbed7c', '6e504eddc254b4618c44e3887d0b3f48b87c3f8b7253974cc0ffc04032bd0eef', 'ab4458406f2073e0bb0cbb77d0c295e95a669935cc2eb6d6f9ad03fb919856f1', '2a2e824a93c12293bd306cfff5b94f9aa2d149e4b03e04b44ad5d10090ab59c1', 'f4580b2be48d5ff6900dff6228fd62d66670888dae4c7128179d74de159d034a', '196c688b79a90f8cf628b79d0930ce6b3ff72fb8c443b7225899a0d1fdc0acad', '41c131676852283c2ee7fed18fd9381091897a583dc88fc9141a5038c73ed594'] B the other s-label information summarized above. {114: 1, 26: 1, 61: 1, 113: 1, 27: 1, 6: 4, 79: 4, 90: 3, 51: 4, 130: 4, 62: 6, 85: 7, 68: 6, 35: 5, 110: 3, 91: 5, 97: 4, 31: 4, 13: 3, 67: 3, 124: 5, 98: 4, 54: 4, 127: 5, 8: 4, 96: 4, 64: 4, 30: 4, 55: 5, 15: 3, 52: 3, 129: 5, 115: 3, 84: 3, 76: 8, 87: 3, 131: 7, 102: 3, 99: 4, 36: 3, 24: 2, 53: 3, 72: 4} {58: 1, 97: 1, 130: 1, 291: 1, 147: 1, 372: 1, 1: 11, 4: 4, 9: 7, 10: 5, 15: 4, 24: 4, 25: 6, 26: 7, 27: 4, 39: 7, 43: 5, 49: 6, 50: 5, 59: 4, 64: 4, 69: 6, 81: 7, 82: 5, 86: 3, 100: 8, 108: 5, 109: 6, 110: 6, 111: 4, 114: 5, 115: 6, 116: 4, 118: 8, 119: 7, 120: 5, 121: 6, 122: 5, 123: 4, 124: 6, 128: 4, 129: 4, 132: 6, 136: 4, 145: 6, 151: 4, 152: 4, 154: 5, 156: 3, 161: 5, 162: 5, 165: 5, 168: 6, 169: 3, 172: 3, 180: 4, 184: 7, 187: 7, 188: 6, 191: 5, 194: 6, 202: 7, 203: 8, 206: 4, 207: 5, 215: 4, 217: 5, 218: 10, 220: 4, 221: 4, 222: 7, 224: 5, 227: 6, 229: 3, 234: 7, 235: 4, 241: 4, 242: 4, 243: 6, 244: 4, 245: 6, 248: 4, 250: 5, 258: 13, 262: 6, 263: 7, 264: 5, 267: 6, 270: 4, 272: 3, 273: 7, 287: 5, 289: 3, 299: 6, 300: 4, 304: 4, 309: 5, 314: 4, 315: 3, 320: 6, 323: 6, 327: 6, 328: 5, 329: 4, 330: 12, 334: 4, 335: 4, 341: 6, 342: 7, 347: 6, 348: 6, 350: 9, 351: 5, 352: 3, 353: 3, 354: 2, 358: 6, 365: 3, 366: 4, 369: 3, 371: 8, 376: 4, 384: 5, 385: 4, 386: 5, 387: 4, 392: 5, 393: 6, 396: 7, 397: 9, 398: 8, 402: 3} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 38 "On the receiving node, the A-Label provides the forwarding context of an incoming interface or an F-Label and is used in subsequent service or forwarding sub-layer receive processing, as appropriated. The related addition configuration that may be provided discussed elsewhere in this section." mpls - over - ip : minor tweaks ipOmpls : Section 6 , Management and Control Information Summary mpls : editorial changes , refactoring of section 5 for clarity and completeness white space cleanup ( remove tabs and trailing spaces ) 6eef101c3c863f944da82ed2f9cc38205de8aa61 6eef101c3c863f944da82ed2f9cc38205de8aa61 draft-ietf-detnet-mpls b863dd515fc616b5f20d11da86ec171c6d64e3cdd1fecce3d9201a8f011ed918 ['3ef84f782267c0e0e968196f92f0e857d46f4f9ba7afbddce796cc8c50975a16', '2e08e5d79759a80040647153ce3fa7819f0612da07f964d940457940ee32eefb', 'd645de25ddd5a17db4ac8e4152ab9f48880b0362f999693b780b953092b4818b', '5afe7b6130289b07fae3f2293f0b50942f6484999592ab78deeb684af0961b90', '5496f74277f5150125eda22755e4e5935e4d30373ae21b9d251791bb3af70771', 'e0272e86b037d5f460db4807aede2c02c9d02cb129d656c91aa723e14be8738c', 'e88833dfc4793019fd0d380a39254338e0e1620775d4f0f64ba50f65f6304990', '2e1188e3ae68f9645fceeb16885fb2558ac488250197b0dac87311b7f9fc7ba3', '236b9ded3b3585aca0a348dc8cf9b49717f1a76ca847c280134ba2cafca9e2bf', 'c99484d301684eba379e2eaab522e22872390f584d0977611a9b71cd4e36e2a9', 'd4d0f5b26265d5747482d4c8c93706edd735ad6b653327445de5a09a5dcc5c2b', '3ad381ce14d392b11bc71c7f84aec9aa4faec501b897070e8cad5dfe435f09ff', '75d8fb6c0eaa04ce99a6045642bc5e15246a22b21f752b965c428b1072c46889', '959f68af8dfd80b8f76ac61803f842c5d5465c96fe9a54320df01a59d427bc74', 'ab1acdf4e7456e3c0c48ecf2a80771c96f1006cd94d541736e1432d7df837fff', 'f584b276947e0b5979b2a9dc3254f10386b70b330438a9e2550d507641ada606', '274b6784d8b0e783b41d9ab3fb59f83a07021384d77a8301c21ba682ca514f8e', '3d36d1a44dc7d02361253be531685a7847ff919030e830b3b7d33da323864bba', '5bbe3d686024848f24fe238d32a57ce72d50b8fbeebade01a3437d75950aab78', '29ea94d06c6751fb47652496c82e1e9d54be60eb454edad2d4cc70305b7e7f6e', 'e19a400eccb294099834cd56397edb9329d003e8e7f8394c8510ecb4ff2e9d49', '0c083cb2dbd6e02c5070ac69ebd99deb41243b9c86516b946c30254bc9ccdfa3', '3e1ecc54327242ce7149d3b94e40a827984e34f421957d76e724befb47850aea', 'fad466a738de01a3d36eccbe586f4d8fc8e0e794e6bc9a207ec1dfbc50cfc690', '11750e495d361a550d77d6e936bd58a2696b27b9dd7d52475b2bc378ab46e66a', '9207956b1757a8ef10e8b8533004f05c18df92096f40432e53657c80998e21d0', 'b863dd515fc616b5f20d11da86ec171c6d64e3cdd1fecce3d9201a8f011ed918', 'da347c609aa36f0a6fe6d9365f7d3f5ef3502894bbb295f976fd4029d2dbed7c', '6e504eddc254b4618c44e3887d0b3f48b87c3f8b7253974cc0ffc04032bd0eef', 'ab4458406f2073e0bb0cbb77d0c295e95a669935cc2eb6d6f9ad03fb919856f1', '2a2e824a93c12293bd306cfff5b94f9aa2d149e4b03e04b44ad5d10090ab59c1', 'f4580b2be48d5ff6900dff6228fd62d66670888dae4c7128179d74de159d034a', '196c688b79a90f8cf628b79d0930ce6b3ff72fb8c443b7225899a0d1fdc0acad', '41c131676852283c2ee7fed18fd9381091897a583dc88fc9141a5038c73ed594'] B "on the receiving node, the a-label provides the forwarding context of an incoming interface or an f-label and is used in subsequent service or forwarding sub-layer receive processing, as appropriated. the related addition configuration that may be provided discussed elsewhere in this section." {114: 1, 26: 1, 61: 1, 113: 1, 27: 1, 6: 4, 79: 4, 90: 3, 51: 4, 130: 4, 62: 6, 85: 7, 68: 6, 35: 5, 110: 3, 91: 5, 97: 4, 31: 4, 13: 3, 67: 3, 124: 5, 98: 4, 54: 4, 127: 5, 8: 4, 96: 4, 64: 4, 30: 4, 55: 5, 15: 3, 52: 3, 129: 5, 115: 3, 84: 3, 76: 8, 87: 3, 131: 7, 102: 3, 99: 4, 36: 3, 24: 2, 53: 3, 72: 4} {58: 1, 97: 1, 130: 1, 291: 1, 147: 1, 372: 1, 1: 11, 4: 4, 9: 7, 10: 5, 15: 4, 24: 4, 25: 6, 26: 7, 27: 4, 39: 7, 43: 5, 49: 6, 50: 5, 59: 4, 64: 4, 69: 6, 81: 7, 82: 5, 86: 3, 100: 8, 108: 5, 109: 6, 110: 6, 111: 4, 114: 5, 115: 6, 116: 4, 118: 8, 119: 7, 120: 5, 121: 6, 122: 5, 123: 4, 124: 6, 128: 4, 129: 4, 132: 6, 136: 4, 145: 6, 151: 4, 152: 4, 154: 5, 156: 3, 161: 5, 162: 5, 165: 5, 168: 6, 169: 3, 172: 3, 180: 4, 184: 7, 187: 7, 188: 6, 191: 5, 194: 6, 202: 7, 203: 8, 206: 4, 207: 5, 215: 4, 217: 5, 218: 10, 220: 4, 221: 4, 222: 7, 224: 5, 227: 6, 229: 3, 234: 7, 235: 4, 241: 4, 242: 4, 243: 6, 244: 4, 245: 6, 248: 4, 250: 5, 258: 13, 262: 6, 263: 7, 264: 5, 267: 6, 270: 4, 272: 3, 273: 7, 287: 5, 289: 3, 299: 6, 300: 4, 304: 4, 309: 5, 314: 4, 315: 3, 320: 6, 323: 6, 327: 6, 328: 5, 329: 4, 330: 12, 334: 4, 335: 4, 341: 6, 342: 7, 347: 6, 348: 6, 350: 9, 351: 5, 352: 3, 353: 3, 354: 2, 358: 6, 365: 3, 366: 4, 369: 3, 371: 8, 376: 4, 384: 5, 385: 4, 386: 5, 387: 4, 392: 5, 393: 6, 396: 7, 397: 9, 398: 8, 402: 3} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 38 "The outgoing F-Label stack to be pushed. The stack may include H-LSP labels." mpls - over - ip : minor tweaks ipOmpls : Section 6 , Management and Control Information Summary mpls : editorial changes , refactoring of section 5 for clarity and completeness white space cleanup ( remove tabs and trailing spaces ) 6eef101c3c863f944da82ed2f9cc38205de8aa61 6eef101c3c863f944da82ed2f9cc38205de8aa61 draft-ietf-detnet-mpls d645de25ddd5a17db4ac8e4152ab9f48880b0362f999693b780b953092b4818b ['3ef84f782267c0e0e968196f92f0e857d46f4f9ba7afbddce796cc8c50975a16', '2e08e5d79759a80040647153ce3fa7819f0612da07f964d940457940ee32eefb', 'd645de25ddd5a17db4ac8e4152ab9f48880b0362f999693b780b953092b4818b', '5afe7b6130289b07fae3f2293f0b50942f6484999592ab78deeb684af0961b90', '5496f74277f5150125eda22755e4e5935e4d30373ae21b9d251791bb3af70771', 'e0272e86b037d5f460db4807aede2c02c9d02cb129d656c91aa723e14be8738c', 'e88833dfc4793019fd0d380a39254338e0e1620775d4f0f64ba50f65f6304990', '2e1188e3ae68f9645fceeb16885fb2558ac488250197b0dac87311b7f9fc7ba3', '236b9ded3b3585aca0a348dc8cf9b49717f1a76ca847c280134ba2cafca9e2bf', 'c99484d301684eba379e2eaab522e22872390f584d0977611a9b71cd4e36e2a9', 'd4d0f5b26265d5747482d4c8c93706edd735ad6b653327445de5a09a5dcc5c2b', '3ad381ce14d392b11bc71c7f84aec9aa4faec501b897070e8cad5dfe435f09ff', '75d8fb6c0eaa04ce99a6045642bc5e15246a22b21f752b965c428b1072c46889', '959f68af8dfd80b8f76ac61803f842c5d5465c96fe9a54320df01a59d427bc74', 'ab1acdf4e7456e3c0c48ecf2a80771c96f1006cd94d541736e1432d7df837fff', 'f584b276947e0b5979b2a9dc3254f10386b70b330438a9e2550d507641ada606', '274b6784d8b0e783b41d9ab3fb59f83a07021384d77a8301c21ba682ca514f8e', '3d36d1a44dc7d02361253be531685a7847ff919030e830b3b7d33da323864bba', '5bbe3d686024848f24fe238d32a57ce72d50b8fbeebade01a3437d75950aab78', '29ea94d06c6751fb47652496c82e1e9d54be60eb454edad2d4cc70305b7e7f6e', 'e19a400eccb294099834cd56397edb9329d003e8e7f8394c8510ecb4ff2e9d49', '0c083cb2dbd6e02c5070ac69ebd99deb41243b9c86516b946c30254bc9ccdfa3', '3e1ecc54327242ce7149d3b94e40a827984e34f421957d76e724befb47850aea', 'fad466a738de01a3d36eccbe586f4d8fc8e0e794e6bc9a207ec1dfbc50cfc690', '11750e495d361a550d77d6e936bd58a2696b27b9dd7d52475b2bc378ab46e66a', '9207956b1757a8ef10e8b8533004f05c18df92096f40432e53657c80998e21d0', 'b863dd515fc616b5f20d11da86ec171c6d64e3cdd1fecce3d9201a8f011ed918', 'da347c609aa36f0a6fe6d9365f7d3f5ef3502894bbb295f976fd4029d2dbed7c', '6e504eddc254b4618c44e3887d0b3f48b87c3f8b7253974cc0ffc04032bd0eef', 'ab4458406f2073e0bb0cbb77d0c295e95a669935cc2eb6d6f9ad03fb919856f1', '2a2e824a93c12293bd306cfff5b94f9aa2d149e4b03e04b44ad5d10090ab59c1', 'f4580b2be48d5ff6900dff6228fd62d66670888dae4c7128179d74de159d034a', '196c688b79a90f8cf628b79d0930ce6b3ff72fb8c443b7225899a0d1fdc0acad', '41c131676852283c2ee7fed18fd9381091897a583dc88fc9141a5038c73ed594'] B "the outgoing f-label stack to be pushed. the stack may include h-lsp labels." {114: 1, 26: 1, 61: 1, 113: 1, 27: 1, 6: 4, 79: 4, 90: 3, 51: 4, 130: 4, 62: 6, 85: 7, 68: 6, 35: 5, 110: 3, 91: 5, 97: 4, 31: 4, 13: 3, 67: 3, 124: 5, 98: 4, 54: 4, 127: 5, 8: 4, 96: 4, 64: 4, 30: 4, 55: 5, 15: 3, 52: 3, 129: 5, 115: 3, 84: 3, 76: 8, 87: 3, 131: 7, 102: 3, 99: 4, 36: 3, 24: 2, 53: 3, 72: 4} {58: 1, 97: 1, 130: 1, 291: 1, 147: 1, 372: 1, 1: 11, 4: 4, 9: 7, 10: 5, 15: 4, 24: 4, 25: 6, 26: 7, 27: 4, 39: 7, 43: 5, 49: 6, 50: 5, 59: 4, 64: 4, 69: 6, 81: 7, 82: 5, 86: 3, 100: 8, 108: 5, 109: 6, 110: 6, 111: 4, 114: 5, 115: 6, 116: 4, 118: 8, 119: 7, 120: 5, 121: 6, 122: 5, 123: 4, 124: 6, 128: 4, 129: 4, 132: 6, 136: 4, 145: 6, 151: 4, 152: 4, 154: 5, 156: 3, 161: 5, 162: 5, 165: 5, 168: 6, 169: 3, 172: 3, 180: 4, 184: 7, 187: 7, 188: 6, 191: 5, 194: 6, 202: 7, 203: 8, 206: 4, 207: 5, 215: 4, 217: 5, 218: 10, 220: 4, 221: 4, 222: 7, 224: 5, 227: 6, 229: 3, 234: 7, 235: 4, 241: 4, 242: 4, 243: 6, 244: 4, 245: 6, 248: 4, 250: 5, 258: 13, 262: 6, 263: 7, 264: 5, 267: 6, 270: 4, 272: 3, 273: 7, 287: 5, 289: 3, 299: 6, 300: 4, 304: 4, 309: 5, 314: 4, 315: 3, 320: 6, 323: 6, 327: 6, 328: 5, 329: 4, 330: 12, 334: 4, 335: 4, 341: 6, 342: 7, 347: 6, 348: 6, 350: 9, 351: 5, 352: 3, 353: 3, 354: 2, 358: 6, 365: 3, 366: 4, 369: 3, 371: 8, 376: 4, 384: 5, 385: 4, 386: 5, 387: 4, 392: 5, 393: 6, 396: 7, 397: 9, 398: 8, 402: 3} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 38 "The traffic parameters associated with a specific label in the stack. Note that there may be multiple sets of traffic paramters associated with specific labels in the stack, e.g., when H-LSPs are used." mpls - over - ip : minor tweaks ipOmpls : Section 6 , Management and Control Information Summary mpls : editorial changes , refactoring of section 5 for clarity and completeness white space cleanup ( remove tabs and trailing spaces ) 6eef101c3c863f944da82ed2f9cc38205de8aa61 6eef101c3c863f944da82ed2f9cc38205de8aa61 draft-ietf-detnet-mpls 2e1188e3ae68f9645fceeb16885fb2558ac488250197b0dac87311b7f9fc7ba3 ['3ef84f782267c0e0e968196f92f0e857d46f4f9ba7afbddce796cc8c50975a16', '2e08e5d79759a80040647153ce3fa7819f0612da07f964d940457940ee32eefb', 'd645de25ddd5a17db4ac8e4152ab9f48880b0362f999693b780b953092b4818b', '5afe7b6130289b07fae3f2293f0b50942f6484999592ab78deeb684af0961b90', '5496f74277f5150125eda22755e4e5935e4d30373ae21b9d251791bb3af70771', 'e0272e86b037d5f460db4807aede2c02c9d02cb129d656c91aa723e14be8738c', 'e88833dfc4793019fd0d380a39254338e0e1620775d4f0f64ba50f65f6304990', '2e1188e3ae68f9645fceeb16885fb2558ac488250197b0dac87311b7f9fc7ba3', '236b9ded3b3585aca0a348dc8cf9b49717f1a76ca847c280134ba2cafca9e2bf', 'c99484d301684eba379e2eaab522e22872390f584d0977611a9b71cd4e36e2a9', 'd4d0f5b26265d5747482d4c8c93706edd735ad6b653327445de5a09a5dcc5c2b', '3ad381ce14d392b11bc71c7f84aec9aa4faec501b897070e8cad5dfe435f09ff', '75d8fb6c0eaa04ce99a6045642bc5e15246a22b21f752b965c428b1072c46889', '959f68af8dfd80b8f76ac61803f842c5d5465c96fe9a54320df01a59d427bc74', 'ab1acdf4e7456e3c0c48ecf2a80771c96f1006cd94d541736e1432d7df837fff', 'f584b276947e0b5979b2a9dc3254f10386b70b330438a9e2550d507641ada606', '274b6784d8b0e783b41d9ab3fb59f83a07021384d77a8301c21ba682ca514f8e', '3d36d1a44dc7d02361253be531685a7847ff919030e830b3b7d33da323864bba', '5bbe3d686024848f24fe238d32a57ce72d50b8fbeebade01a3437d75950aab78', '29ea94d06c6751fb47652496c82e1e9d54be60eb454edad2d4cc70305b7e7f6e', 'e19a400eccb294099834cd56397edb9329d003e8e7f8394c8510ecb4ff2e9d49', '0c083cb2dbd6e02c5070ac69ebd99deb41243b9c86516b946c30254bc9ccdfa3', '3e1ecc54327242ce7149d3b94e40a827984e34f421957d76e724befb47850aea', 'fad466a738de01a3d36eccbe586f4d8fc8e0e794e6bc9a207ec1dfbc50cfc690', '11750e495d361a550d77d6e936bd58a2696b27b9dd7d52475b2bc378ab46e66a', '9207956b1757a8ef10e8b8533004f05c18df92096f40432e53657c80998e21d0', 'b863dd515fc616b5f20d11da86ec171c6d64e3cdd1fecce3d9201a8f011ed918', 'da347c609aa36f0a6fe6d9365f7d3f5ef3502894bbb295f976fd4029d2dbed7c', '6e504eddc254b4618c44e3887d0b3f48b87c3f8b7253974cc0ffc04032bd0eef', 'ab4458406f2073e0bb0cbb77d0c295e95a669935cc2eb6d6f9ad03fb919856f1', '2a2e824a93c12293bd306cfff5b94f9aa2d149e4b03e04b44ad5d10090ab59c1', 'f4580b2be48d5ff6900dff6228fd62d66670888dae4c7128179d74de159d034a', '196c688b79a90f8cf628b79d0930ce6b3ff72fb8c443b7225899a0d1fdc0acad', '41c131676852283c2ee7fed18fd9381091897a583dc88fc9141a5038c73ed594'] B "the traffic parameters associated with a specific label in the stack. note that there may be multiple sets of traffic paramters associated with specific labels in the stack, e.g., when h-lsps are used." {114: 1, 26: 1, 61: 1, 113: 1, 27: 1, 6: 4, 79: 4, 90: 3, 51: 4, 130: 4, 62: 6, 85: 7, 68: 6, 35: 5, 110: 3, 91: 5, 97: 4, 31: 4, 13: 3, 67: 3, 124: 5, 98: 4, 54: 4, 127: 5, 8: 4, 96: 4, 64: 4, 30: 4, 55: 5, 15: 3, 52: 3, 129: 5, 115: 3, 84: 3, 76: 8, 87: 3, 131: 7, 102: 3, 99: 4, 36: 3, 24: 2, 53: 3, 72: 4} {58: 1, 97: 1, 130: 1, 291: 1, 147: 1, 372: 1, 1: 11, 4: 4, 9: 7, 10: 5, 15: 4, 24: 4, 25: 6, 26: 7, 27: 4, 39: 7, 43: 5, 49: 6, 50: 5, 59: 4, 64: 4, 69: 6, 81: 7, 82: 5, 86: 3, 100: 8, 108: 5, 109: 6, 110: 6, 111: 4, 114: 5, 115: 6, 116: 4, 118: 8, 119: 7, 120: 5, 121: 6, 122: 5, 123: 4, 124: 6, 128: 4, 129: 4, 132: 6, 136: 4, 145: 6, 151: 4, 152: 4, 154: 5, 156: 3, 161: 5, 162: 5, 165: 5, 168: 6, 169: 3, 172: 3, 180: 4, 184: 7, 187: 7, 188: 6, 191: 5, 194: 6, 202: 7, 203: 8, 206: 4, 207: 5, 215: 4, 217: 5, 218: 10, 220: 4, 221: 4, 222: 7, 224: 5, 227: 6, 229: 3, 234: 7, 235: 4, 241: 4, 242: 4, 243: 6, 244: 4, 245: 6, 248: 4, 250: 5, 258: 13, 262: 6, 263: 7, 264: 5, 267: 6, 270: 4, 272: 3, 273: 7, 287: 5, 289: 3, 299: 6, 300: 4, 304: 4, 309: 5, 314: 4, 315: 3, 320: 6, 323: 6, 327: 6, 328: 5, 329: 4, 330: 12, 334: 4, 335: 4, 341: 6, 342: 7, 347: 6, 348: 6, 350: 9, 351: 5, 352: 3, 353: 3, 354: 2, 358: 6, 365: 3, 366: 4, 369: 3, 371: 8, 376: 4, 384: 5, 385: 4, 386: 5, 387: 4, 392: 5, 393: 6, 396: 7, 397: 9, 398: 8, 402: 3} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 38 "Outgoing interface and, for unicast traffic, the next hop information." mpls - over - ip : minor tweaks ipOmpls : Section 6 , Management and Control Information Summary mpls : editorial changes , refactoring of section 5 for clarity and completeness white space cleanup ( remove tabs and trailing spaces ) 6eef101c3c863f944da82ed2f9cc38205de8aa61 6eef101c3c863f944da82ed2f9cc38205de8aa61 draft-ietf-detnet-mpls 3e1ecc54327242ce7149d3b94e40a827984e34f421957d76e724befb47850aea ['3ef84f782267c0e0e968196f92f0e857d46f4f9ba7afbddce796cc8c50975a16', '2e08e5d79759a80040647153ce3fa7819f0612da07f964d940457940ee32eefb', 'd645de25ddd5a17db4ac8e4152ab9f48880b0362f999693b780b953092b4818b', '5afe7b6130289b07fae3f2293f0b50942f6484999592ab78deeb684af0961b90', '5496f74277f5150125eda22755e4e5935e4d30373ae21b9d251791bb3af70771', 'e0272e86b037d5f460db4807aede2c02c9d02cb129d656c91aa723e14be8738c', 'e88833dfc4793019fd0d380a39254338e0e1620775d4f0f64ba50f65f6304990', '2e1188e3ae68f9645fceeb16885fb2558ac488250197b0dac87311b7f9fc7ba3', '236b9ded3b3585aca0a348dc8cf9b49717f1a76ca847c280134ba2cafca9e2bf', 'c99484d301684eba379e2eaab522e22872390f584d0977611a9b71cd4e36e2a9', 'd4d0f5b26265d5747482d4c8c93706edd735ad6b653327445de5a09a5dcc5c2b', '3ad381ce14d392b11bc71c7f84aec9aa4faec501b897070e8cad5dfe435f09ff', '75d8fb6c0eaa04ce99a6045642bc5e15246a22b21f752b965c428b1072c46889', '959f68af8dfd80b8f76ac61803f842c5d5465c96fe9a54320df01a59d427bc74', 'ab1acdf4e7456e3c0c48ecf2a80771c96f1006cd94d541736e1432d7df837fff', 'f584b276947e0b5979b2a9dc3254f10386b70b330438a9e2550d507641ada606', '274b6784d8b0e783b41d9ab3fb59f83a07021384d77a8301c21ba682ca514f8e', '3d36d1a44dc7d02361253be531685a7847ff919030e830b3b7d33da323864bba', '5bbe3d686024848f24fe238d32a57ce72d50b8fbeebade01a3437d75950aab78', '29ea94d06c6751fb47652496c82e1e9d54be60eb454edad2d4cc70305b7e7f6e', 'e19a400eccb294099834cd56397edb9329d003e8e7f8394c8510ecb4ff2e9d49', '0c083cb2dbd6e02c5070ac69ebd99deb41243b9c86516b946c30254bc9ccdfa3', '3e1ecc54327242ce7149d3b94e40a827984e34f421957d76e724befb47850aea', 'fad466a738de01a3d36eccbe586f4d8fc8e0e794e6bc9a207ec1dfbc50cfc690', '11750e495d361a550d77d6e936bd58a2696b27b9dd7d52475b2bc378ab46e66a', '9207956b1757a8ef10e8b8533004f05c18df92096f40432e53657c80998e21d0', 'b863dd515fc616b5f20d11da86ec171c6d64e3cdd1fecce3d9201a8f011ed918', 'da347c609aa36f0a6fe6d9365f7d3f5ef3502894bbb295f976fd4029d2dbed7c', '6e504eddc254b4618c44e3887d0b3f48b87c3f8b7253974cc0ffc04032bd0eef', 'ab4458406f2073e0bb0cbb77d0c295e95a669935cc2eb6d6f9ad03fb919856f1', '2a2e824a93c12293bd306cfff5b94f9aa2d149e4b03e04b44ad5d10090ab59c1', 'f4580b2be48d5ff6900dff6228fd62d66670888dae4c7128179d74de159d034a', '196c688b79a90f8cf628b79d0930ce6b3ff72fb8c443b7225899a0d1fdc0acad', '41c131676852283c2ee7fed18fd9381091897a583dc88fc9141a5038c73ed594'] B "outgoing interface and, for unicast traffic, the next hop information." {114: 1, 26: 1, 61: 1, 113: 1, 27: 1, 6: 4, 79: 4, 90: 3, 51: 4, 130: 4, 62: 6, 85: 7, 68: 6, 35: 5, 110: 3, 91: 5, 97: 4, 31: 4, 13: 3, 67: 3, 124: 5, 98: 4, 54: 4, 127: 5, 8: 4, 96: 4, 64: 4, 30: 4, 55: 5, 15: 3, 52: 3, 129: 5, 115: 3, 84: 3, 76: 8, 87: 3, 131: 7, 102: 3, 99: 4, 36: 3, 24: 2, 53: 3, 72: 4} {58: 1, 97: 1, 130: 1, 291: 1, 147: 1, 372: 1, 1: 11, 4: 4, 9: 7, 10: 5, 15: 4, 24: 4, 25: 6, 26: 7, 27: 4, 39: 7, 43: 5, 49: 6, 50: 5, 59: 4, 64: 4, 69: 6, 81: 7, 82: 5, 86: 3, 100: 8, 108: 5, 109: 6, 110: 6, 111: 4, 114: 5, 115: 6, 116: 4, 118: 8, 119: 7, 120: 5, 121: 6, 122: 5, 123: 4, 124: 6, 128: 4, 129: 4, 132: 6, 136: 4, 145: 6, 151: 4, 152: 4, 154: 5, 156: 3, 161: 5, 162: 5, 165: 5, 168: 6, 169: 3, 172: 3, 180: 4, 184: 7, 187: 7, 188: 6, 191: 5, 194: 6, 202: 7, 203: 8, 206: 4, 207: 5, 215: 4, 217: 5, 218: 10, 220: 4, 221: 4, 222: 7, 224: 5, 227: 6, 229: 3, 234: 7, 235: 4, 241: 4, 242: 4, 243: 6, 244: 4, 245: 6, 248: 4, 250: 5, 258: 13, 262: 6, 263: 7, 264: 5, 267: 6, 270: 4, 272: 3, 273: 7, 287: 5, 289: 3, 299: 6, 300: 4, 304: 4, 309: 5, 314: 4, 315: 3, 320: 6, 323: 6, 327: 6, 328: 5, 329: 4, 330: 12, 334: 4, 335: 4, 341: 6, 342: 7, 347: 6, 348: 6, 350: 9, 351: 5, 352: 3, 353: 3, 354: 2, 358: 6, 365: 3, 366: 4, 369: 3, 371: 8, 376: 4, 384: 5, 385: 4, 386: 5, 387: 4, 392: 5, 393: 6, 396: 7, 397: 9, 398: 8, 402: 3} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 38 "Sub-network specific parameters on a technology specific basis. For example, see I-D.ietf-detnet-mpls-over-tsn." mpls - over - ip : minor tweaks ipOmpls : Section 6 , Management and Control Information Summary mpls : editorial changes , refactoring of section 5 for clarity and completeness white space cleanup ( remove tabs and trailing spaces ) 6eef101c3c863f944da82ed2f9cc38205de8aa61 6eef101c3c863f944da82ed2f9cc38205de8aa61 draft-ietf-detnet-mpls 196c688b79a90f8cf628b79d0930ce6b3ff72fb8c443b7225899a0d1fdc0acad ['3ef84f782267c0e0e968196f92f0e857d46f4f9ba7afbddce796cc8c50975a16', '2e08e5d79759a80040647153ce3fa7819f0612da07f964d940457940ee32eefb', 'd645de25ddd5a17db4ac8e4152ab9f48880b0362f999693b780b953092b4818b', '5afe7b6130289b07fae3f2293f0b50942f6484999592ab78deeb684af0961b90', '5496f74277f5150125eda22755e4e5935e4d30373ae21b9d251791bb3af70771', 'e0272e86b037d5f460db4807aede2c02c9d02cb129d656c91aa723e14be8738c', 'e88833dfc4793019fd0d380a39254338e0e1620775d4f0f64ba50f65f6304990', '2e1188e3ae68f9645fceeb16885fb2558ac488250197b0dac87311b7f9fc7ba3', '236b9ded3b3585aca0a348dc8cf9b49717f1a76ca847c280134ba2cafca9e2bf', 'c99484d301684eba379e2eaab522e22872390f584d0977611a9b71cd4e36e2a9', 'd4d0f5b26265d5747482d4c8c93706edd735ad6b653327445de5a09a5dcc5c2b', '3ad381ce14d392b11bc71c7f84aec9aa4faec501b897070e8cad5dfe435f09ff', '75d8fb6c0eaa04ce99a6045642bc5e15246a22b21f752b965c428b1072c46889', '959f68af8dfd80b8f76ac61803f842c5d5465c96fe9a54320df01a59d427bc74', 'ab1acdf4e7456e3c0c48ecf2a80771c96f1006cd94d541736e1432d7df837fff', 'f584b276947e0b5979b2a9dc3254f10386b70b330438a9e2550d507641ada606', '274b6784d8b0e783b41d9ab3fb59f83a07021384d77a8301c21ba682ca514f8e', '3d36d1a44dc7d02361253be531685a7847ff919030e830b3b7d33da323864bba', '5bbe3d686024848f24fe238d32a57ce72d50b8fbeebade01a3437d75950aab78', '29ea94d06c6751fb47652496c82e1e9d54be60eb454edad2d4cc70305b7e7f6e', 'e19a400eccb294099834cd56397edb9329d003e8e7f8394c8510ecb4ff2e9d49', '0c083cb2dbd6e02c5070ac69ebd99deb41243b9c86516b946c30254bc9ccdfa3', '3e1ecc54327242ce7149d3b94e40a827984e34f421957d76e724befb47850aea', 'fad466a738de01a3d36eccbe586f4d8fc8e0e794e6bc9a207ec1dfbc50cfc690', '11750e495d361a550d77d6e936bd58a2696b27b9dd7d52475b2bc378ab46e66a', '9207956b1757a8ef10e8b8533004f05c18df92096f40432e53657c80998e21d0', 'b863dd515fc616b5f20d11da86ec171c6d64e3cdd1fecce3d9201a8f011ed918', 'da347c609aa36f0a6fe6d9365f7d3f5ef3502894bbb295f976fd4029d2dbed7c', '6e504eddc254b4618c44e3887d0b3f48b87c3f8b7253974cc0ffc04032bd0eef', 'ab4458406f2073e0bb0cbb77d0c295e95a669935cc2eb6d6f9ad03fb919856f1', '2a2e824a93c12293bd306cfff5b94f9aa2d149e4b03e04b44ad5d10090ab59c1', 'f4580b2be48d5ff6900dff6228fd62d66670888dae4c7128179d74de159d034a', '196c688b79a90f8cf628b79d0930ce6b3ff72fb8c443b7225899a0d1fdc0acad', '41c131676852283c2ee7fed18fd9381091897a583dc88fc9141a5038c73ed594'] B "sub-network specific parameters on a technology specific basis. for example, see i-d.ietf-detnet-mpls-over-tsn." {114: 1, 26: 1, 61: 1, 113: 1, 27: 1, 6: 4, 79: 4, 90: 3, 51: 4, 130: 4, 62: 6, 85: 7, 68: 6, 35: 5, 110: 3, 91: 5, 97: 4, 31: 4, 13: 3, 67: 3, 124: 5, 98: 4, 54: 4, 127: 5, 8: 4, 96: 4, 64: 4, 30: 4, 55: 5, 15: 3, 52: 3, 129: 5, 115: 3, 84: 3, 76: 8, 87: 3, 131: 7, 102: 3, 99: 4, 36: 3, 24: 2, 53: 3, 72: 4} {58: 1, 97: 1, 130: 1, 291: 1, 147: 1, 372: 1, 1: 11, 4: 4, 9: 7, 10: 5, 15: 4, 24: 4, 25: 6, 26: 7, 27: 4, 39: 7, 43: 5, 49: 6, 50: 5, 59: 4, 64: 4, 69: 6, 81: 7, 82: 5, 86: 3, 100: 8, 108: 5, 109: 6, 110: 6, 111: 4, 114: 5, 115: 6, 116: 4, 118: 8, 119: 7, 120: 5, 121: 6, 122: 5, 123: 4, 124: 6, 128: 4, 129: 4, 132: 6, 136: 4, 145: 6, 151: 4, 152: 4, 154: 5, 156: 3, 161: 5, 162: 5, 165: 5, 168: 6, 169: 3, 172: 3, 180: 4, 184: 7, 187: 7, 188: 6, 191: 5, 194: 6, 202: 7, 203: 8, 206: 4, 207: 5, 215: 4, 217: 5, 218: 10, 220: 4, 221: 4, 222: 7, 224: 5, 227: 6, 229: 3, 234: 7, 235: 4, 241: 4, 242: 4, 243: 6, 244: 4, 245: 6, 248: 4, 250: 5, 258: 13, 262: 6, 263: 7, 264: 5, 267: 6, 270: 4, 272: 3, 273: 7, 287: 5, 289: 3, 299: 6, 300: 4, 304: 4, 309: 5, 314: 4, 315: 3, 320: 6, 323: 6, 327: 6, 328: 5, 329: 4, 330: 12, 334: 4, 335: 4, 341: 6, 342: 7, 347: 6, 348: 6, 350: 9, 351: 5, 352: 3, 353: 3, 354: 2, 358: 6, 365: 3, 366: 4, 369: 3, 371: 8, 376: 4, 384: 5, 385: 4, 386: 5, 387: 4, 392: 5, 393: 6, 396: 7, 397: 9, 398: 8, 402: 3} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 38 "The incoming interface. For some implementations and deployment scenarios, this information may not be needed." mpls - over - ip : minor tweaks ipOmpls : Section 6 , Management and Control Information Summary mpls : editorial changes , refactoring of section 5 for clarity and completeness white space cleanup ( remove tabs and trailing spaces ) 6eef101c3c863f944da82ed2f9cc38205de8aa61 6eef101c3c863f944da82ed2f9cc38205de8aa61 draft-ietf-detnet-mpls 41c131676852283c2ee7fed18fd9381091897a583dc88fc9141a5038c73ed594 ['3ef84f782267c0e0e968196f92f0e857d46f4f9ba7afbddce796cc8c50975a16', '2e08e5d79759a80040647153ce3fa7819f0612da07f964d940457940ee32eefb', 'd645de25ddd5a17db4ac8e4152ab9f48880b0362f999693b780b953092b4818b', '5afe7b6130289b07fae3f2293f0b50942f6484999592ab78deeb684af0961b90', '5496f74277f5150125eda22755e4e5935e4d30373ae21b9d251791bb3af70771', 'e0272e86b037d5f460db4807aede2c02c9d02cb129d656c91aa723e14be8738c', 'e88833dfc4793019fd0d380a39254338e0e1620775d4f0f64ba50f65f6304990', '2e1188e3ae68f9645fceeb16885fb2558ac488250197b0dac87311b7f9fc7ba3', '236b9ded3b3585aca0a348dc8cf9b49717f1a76ca847c280134ba2cafca9e2bf', 'c99484d301684eba379e2eaab522e22872390f584d0977611a9b71cd4e36e2a9', 'd4d0f5b26265d5747482d4c8c93706edd735ad6b653327445de5a09a5dcc5c2b', '3ad381ce14d392b11bc71c7f84aec9aa4faec501b897070e8cad5dfe435f09ff', '75d8fb6c0eaa04ce99a6045642bc5e15246a22b21f752b965c428b1072c46889', '959f68af8dfd80b8f76ac61803f842c5d5465c96fe9a54320df01a59d427bc74', 'ab1acdf4e7456e3c0c48ecf2a80771c96f1006cd94d541736e1432d7df837fff', 'f584b276947e0b5979b2a9dc3254f10386b70b330438a9e2550d507641ada606', '274b6784d8b0e783b41d9ab3fb59f83a07021384d77a8301c21ba682ca514f8e', '3d36d1a44dc7d02361253be531685a7847ff919030e830b3b7d33da323864bba', '5bbe3d686024848f24fe238d32a57ce72d50b8fbeebade01a3437d75950aab78', '29ea94d06c6751fb47652496c82e1e9d54be60eb454edad2d4cc70305b7e7f6e', 'e19a400eccb294099834cd56397edb9329d003e8e7f8394c8510ecb4ff2e9d49', '0c083cb2dbd6e02c5070ac69ebd99deb41243b9c86516b946c30254bc9ccdfa3', '3e1ecc54327242ce7149d3b94e40a827984e34f421957d76e724befb47850aea', 'fad466a738de01a3d36eccbe586f4d8fc8e0e794e6bc9a207ec1dfbc50cfc690', '11750e495d361a550d77d6e936bd58a2696b27b9dd7d52475b2bc378ab46e66a', '9207956b1757a8ef10e8b8533004f05c18df92096f40432e53657c80998e21d0', 'b863dd515fc616b5f20d11da86ec171c6d64e3cdd1fecce3d9201a8f011ed918', 'da347c609aa36f0a6fe6d9365f7d3f5ef3502894bbb295f976fd4029d2dbed7c', '6e504eddc254b4618c44e3887d0b3f48b87c3f8b7253974cc0ffc04032bd0eef', 'ab4458406f2073e0bb0cbb77d0c295e95a669935cc2eb6d6f9ad03fb919856f1', '2a2e824a93c12293bd306cfff5b94f9aa2d149e4b03e04b44ad5d10090ab59c1', 'f4580b2be48d5ff6900dff6228fd62d66670888dae4c7128179d74de159d034a', '196c688b79a90f8cf628b79d0930ce6b3ff72fb8c443b7225899a0d1fdc0acad', '41c131676852283c2ee7fed18fd9381091897a583dc88fc9141a5038c73ed594'] B "the incoming interface. for some implementations and deployment scenarios, this information may not be needed." {114: 1, 26: 1, 61: 1, 113: 1, 27: 1, 6: 4, 79: 4, 90: 3, 51: 4, 130: 4, 62: 6, 85: 7, 68: 6, 35: 5, 110: 3, 91: 5, 97: 4, 31: 4, 13: 3, 67: 3, 124: 5, 98: 4, 54: 4, 127: 5, 8: 4, 96: 4, 64: 4, 30: 4, 55: 5, 15: 3, 52: 3, 129: 5, 115: 3, 84: 3, 76: 8, 87: 3, 131: 7, 102: 3, 99: 4, 36: 3, 24: 2, 53: 3, 72: 4} {58: 1, 97: 1, 130: 1, 291: 1, 147: 1, 372: 1, 1: 11, 4: 4, 9: 7, 10: 5, 15: 4, 24: 4, 25: 6, 26: 7, 27: 4, 39: 7, 43: 5, 49: 6, 50: 5, 59: 4, 64: 4, 69: 6, 81: 7, 82: 5, 86: 3, 100: 8, 108: 5, 109: 6, 110: 6, 111: 4, 114: 5, 115: 6, 116: 4, 118: 8, 119: 7, 120: 5, 121: 6, 122: 5, 123: 4, 124: 6, 128: 4, 129: 4, 132: 6, 136: 4, 145: 6, 151: 4, 152: 4, 154: 5, 156: 3, 161: 5, 162: 5, 165: 5, 168: 6, 169: 3, 172: 3, 180: 4, 184: 7, 187: 7, 188: 6, 191: 5, 194: 6, 202: 7, 203: 8, 206: 4, 207: 5, 215: 4, 217: 5, 218: 10, 220: 4, 221: 4, 222: 7, 224: 5, 227: 6, 229: 3, 234: 7, 235: 4, 241: 4, 242: 4, 243: 6, 244: 4, 245: 6, 248: 4, 250: 5, 258: 13, 262: 6, 263: 7, 264: 5, 267: 6, 270: 4, 272: 3, 273: 7, 287: 5, 289: 3, 299: 6, 300: 4, 304: 4, 309: 5, 314: 4, 315: 3, 320: 6, 323: 6, 327: 6, 328: 5, 329: 4, 330: 12, 334: 4, 335: 4, 341: 6, 342: 7, 347: 6, 348: 6, 350: 9, 351: 5, 352: 3, 353: 3, 354: 2, 358: 6, 365: 3, 366: 4, 369: 3, 371: 8, 376: 4, 384: 5, 385: 4, 386: 5, 387: 4, 392: 5, 393: 6, 396: 7, 397: 9, 398: 8, 402: 3} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 38 "The incoming F-Label stack to be popped. The stack may include H-LSP labels." mpls - over - ip : minor tweaks ipOmpls : Section 6 , Management and Control Information Summary mpls : editorial changes , refactoring of section 5 for clarity and completeness white space cleanup ( remove tabs and trailing spaces ) 6eef101c3c863f944da82ed2f9cc38205de8aa61 6eef101c3c863f944da82ed2f9cc38205de8aa61 draft-ietf-detnet-mpls 3d36d1a44dc7d02361253be531685a7847ff919030e830b3b7d33da323864bba ['3ef84f782267c0e0e968196f92f0e857d46f4f9ba7afbddce796cc8c50975a16', '2e08e5d79759a80040647153ce3fa7819f0612da07f964d940457940ee32eefb', 'd645de25ddd5a17db4ac8e4152ab9f48880b0362f999693b780b953092b4818b', '5afe7b6130289b07fae3f2293f0b50942f6484999592ab78deeb684af0961b90', '5496f74277f5150125eda22755e4e5935e4d30373ae21b9d251791bb3af70771', 'e0272e86b037d5f460db4807aede2c02c9d02cb129d656c91aa723e14be8738c', 'e88833dfc4793019fd0d380a39254338e0e1620775d4f0f64ba50f65f6304990', '2e1188e3ae68f9645fceeb16885fb2558ac488250197b0dac87311b7f9fc7ba3', '236b9ded3b3585aca0a348dc8cf9b49717f1a76ca847c280134ba2cafca9e2bf', 'c99484d301684eba379e2eaab522e22872390f584d0977611a9b71cd4e36e2a9', 'd4d0f5b26265d5747482d4c8c93706edd735ad6b653327445de5a09a5dcc5c2b', '3ad381ce14d392b11bc71c7f84aec9aa4faec501b897070e8cad5dfe435f09ff', '75d8fb6c0eaa04ce99a6045642bc5e15246a22b21f752b965c428b1072c46889', '959f68af8dfd80b8f76ac61803f842c5d5465c96fe9a54320df01a59d427bc74', 'ab1acdf4e7456e3c0c48ecf2a80771c96f1006cd94d541736e1432d7df837fff', 'f584b276947e0b5979b2a9dc3254f10386b70b330438a9e2550d507641ada606', '274b6784d8b0e783b41d9ab3fb59f83a07021384d77a8301c21ba682ca514f8e', '3d36d1a44dc7d02361253be531685a7847ff919030e830b3b7d33da323864bba', '5bbe3d686024848f24fe238d32a57ce72d50b8fbeebade01a3437d75950aab78', '29ea94d06c6751fb47652496c82e1e9d54be60eb454edad2d4cc70305b7e7f6e', 'e19a400eccb294099834cd56397edb9329d003e8e7f8394c8510ecb4ff2e9d49', '0c083cb2dbd6e02c5070ac69ebd99deb41243b9c86516b946c30254bc9ccdfa3', '3e1ecc54327242ce7149d3b94e40a827984e34f421957d76e724befb47850aea', 'fad466a738de01a3d36eccbe586f4d8fc8e0e794e6bc9a207ec1dfbc50cfc690', '11750e495d361a550d77d6e936bd58a2696b27b9dd7d52475b2bc378ab46e66a', '9207956b1757a8ef10e8b8533004f05c18df92096f40432e53657c80998e21d0', 'b863dd515fc616b5f20d11da86ec171c6d64e3cdd1fecce3d9201a8f011ed918', 'da347c609aa36f0a6fe6d9365f7d3f5ef3502894bbb295f976fd4029d2dbed7c', '6e504eddc254b4618c44e3887d0b3f48b87c3f8b7253974cc0ffc04032bd0eef', 'ab4458406f2073e0bb0cbb77d0c295e95a669935cc2eb6d6f9ad03fb919856f1', '2a2e824a93c12293bd306cfff5b94f9aa2d149e4b03e04b44ad5d10090ab59c1', 'f4580b2be48d5ff6900dff6228fd62d66670888dae4c7128179d74de159d034a', '196c688b79a90f8cf628b79d0930ce6b3ff72fb8c443b7225899a0d1fdc0acad', '41c131676852283c2ee7fed18fd9381091897a583dc88fc9141a5038c73ed594'] B "the incoming f-label stack to be popped. the stack may include h-lsp labels." {114: 1, 26: 1, 61: 1, 113: 1, 27: 1, 6: 4, 79: 4, 90: 3, 51: 4, 130: 4, 62: 6, 85: 7, 68: 6, 35: 5, 110: 3, 91: 5, 97: 4, 31: 4, 13: 3, 67: 3, 124: 5, 98: 4, 54: 4, 127: 5, 8: 4, 96: 4, 64: 4, 30: 4, 55: 5, 15: 3, 52: 3, 129: 5, 115: 3, 84: 3, 76: 8, 87: 3, 131: 7, 102: 3, 99: 4, 36: 3, 24: 2, 53: 3, 72: 4} {58: 1, 97: 1, 130: 1, 291: 1, 147: 1, 372: 1, 1: 11, 4: 4, 9: 7, 10: 5, 15: 4, 24: 4, 25: 6, 26: 7, 27: 4, 39: 7, 43: 5, 49: 6, 50: 5, 59: 4, 64: 4, 69: 6, 81: 7, 82: 5, 86: 3, 100: 8, 108: 5, 109: 6, 110: 6, 111: 4, 114: 5, 115: 6, 116: 4, 118: 8, 119: 7, 120: 5, 121: 6, 122: 5, 123: 4, 124: 6, 128: 4, 129: 4, 132: 6, 136: 4, 145: 6, 151: 4, 152: 4, 154: 5, 156: 3, 161: 5, 162: 5, 165: 5, 168: 6, 169: 3, 172: 3, 180: 4, 184: 7, 187: 7, 188: 6, 191: 5, 194: 6, 202: 7, 203: 8, 206: 4, 207: 5, 215: 4, 217: 5, 218: 10, 220: 4, 221: 4, 222: 7, 224: 5, 227: 6, 229: 3, 234: 7, 235: 4, 241: 4, 242: 4, 243: 6, 244: 4, 245: 6, 248: 4, 250: 5, 258: 13, 262: 6, 263: 7, 264: 5, 267: 6, 270: 4, 272: 3, 273: 7, 287: 5, 289: 3, 299: 6, 300: 4, 304: 4, 309: 5, 314: 4, 315: 3, 320: 6, 323: 6, 327: 6, 328: 5, 329: 4, 330: 12, 334: 4, 335: 4, 341: 6, 342: 7, 347: 6, 348: 6, 350: 9, 351: 5, 352: 3, 353: 3, 354: 2, 358: 6, 365: 3, 366: 4, 369: 3, 371: 8, 376: 4, 384: 5, 385: 4, 386: 5, 387: 4, 392: 5, 393: 6, 396: 7, 397: 9, 398: 8, 402: 3} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 38 "How the incoming forwarding sub-layer flow is to be handled, i.e., forwarded as a transit node, or provided to the service sub-layer." mpls - over - ip : minor tweaks ipOmpls : Section 6 , Management and Control Information Summary mpls : editorial changes , refactoring of section 5 for clarity and completeness white space cleanup ( remove tabs and trailing spaces ) 6eef101c3c863f944da82ed2f9cc38205de8aa61 6eef101c3c863f944da82ed2f9cc38205de8aa61 draft-ietf-detnet-mpls 5496f74277f5150125eda22755e4e5935e4d30373ae21b9d251791bb3af70771 ['3ef84f782267c0e0e968196f92f0e857d46f4f9ba7afbddce796cc8c50975a16', '2e08e5d79759a80040647153ce3fa7819f0612da07f964d940457940ee32eefb', 'd645de25ddd5a17db4ac8e4152ab9f48880b0362f999693b780b953092b4818b', '5afe7b6130289b07fae3f2293f0b50942f6484999592ab78deeb684af0961b90', '5496f74277f5150125eda22755e4e5935e4d30373ae21b9d251791bb3af70771', 'e0272e86b037d5f460db4807aede2c02c9d02cb129d656c91aa723e14be8738c', 'e88833dfc4793019fd0d380a39254338e0e1620775d4f0f64ba50f65f6304990', '2e1188e3ae68f9645fceeb16885fb2558ac488250197b0dac87311b7f9fc7ba3', '236b9ded3b3585aca0a348dc8cf9b49717f1a76ca847c280134ba2cafca9e2bf', 'c99484d301684eba379e2eaab522e22872390f584d0977611a9b71cd4e36e2a9', 'd4d0f5b26265d5747482d4c8c93706edd735ad6b653327445de5a09a5dcc5c2b', '3ad381ce14d392b11bc71c7f84aec9aa4faec501b897070e8cad5dfe435f09ff', '75d8fb6c0eaa04ce99a6045642bc5e15246a22b21f752b965c428b1072c46889', '959f68af8dfd80b8f76ac61803f842c5d5465c96fe9a54320df01a59d427bc74', 'ab1acdf4e7456e3c0c48ecf2a80771c96f1006cd94d541736e1432d7df837fff', 'f584b276947e0b5979b2a9dc3254f10386b70b330438a9e2550d507641ada606', '274b6784d8b0e783b41d9ab3fb59f83a07021384d77a8301c21ba682ca514f8e', '3d36d1a44dc7d02361253be531685a7847ff919030e830b3b7d33da323864bba', '5bbe3d686024848f24fe238d32a57ce72d50b8fbeebade01a3437d75950aab78', '29ea94d06c6751fb47652496c82e1e9d54be60eb454edad2d4cc70305b7e7f6e', 'e19a400eccb294099834cd56397edb9329d003e8e7f8394c8510ecb4ff2e9d49', '0c083cb2dbd6e02c5070ac69ebd99deb41243b9c86516b946c30254bc9ccdfa3', '3e1ecc54327242ce7149d3b94e40a827984e34f421957d76e724befb47850aea', 'fad466a738de01a3d36eccbe586f4d8fc8e0e794e6bc9a207ec1dfbc50cfc690', '11750e495d361a550d77d6e936bd58a2696b27b9dd7d52475b2bc378ab46e66a', '9207956b1757a8ef10e8b8533004f05c18df92096f40432e53657c80998e21d0', 'b863dd515fc616b5f20d11da86ec171c6d64e3cdd1fecce3d9201a8f011ed918', 'da347c609aa36f0a6fe6d9365f7d3f5ef3502894bbb295f976fd4029d2dbed7c', '6e504eddc254b4618c44e3887d0b3f48b87c3f8b7253974cc0ffc04032bd0eef', 'ab4458406f2073e0bb0cbb77d0c295e95a669935cc2eb6d6f9ad03fb919856f1', '2a2e824a93c12293bd306cfff5b94f9aa2d149e4b03e04b44ad5d10090ab59c1', 'f4580b2be48d5ff6900dff6228fd62d66670888dae4c7128179d74de159d034a', '196c688b79a90f8cf628b79d0930ce6b3ff72fb8c443b7225899a0d1fdc0acad', '41c131676852283c2ee7fed18fd9381091897a583dc88fc9141a5038c73ed594'] B "how the incoming forwarding sub-layer flow is to be handled, i.e., forwarded as a transit node, or provided to the service sub-layer." {114: 1, 26: 1, 61: 1, 113: 1, 27: 1, 6: 4, 79: 4, 90: 3, 51: 4, 130: 4, 62: 6, 85: 7, 68: 6, 35: 5, 110: 3, 91: 5, 97: 4, 31: 4, 13: 3, 67: 3, 124: 5, 98: 4, 54: 4, 127: 5, 8: 4, 96: 4, 64: 4, 30: 4, 55: 5, 15: 3, 52: 3, 129: 5, 115: 3, 84: 3, 76: 8, 87: 3, 131: 7, 102: 3, 99: 4, 36: 3, 24: 2, 53: 3, 72: 4} {58: 1, 97: 1, 130: 1, 291: 1, 147: 1, 372: 1, 1: 11, 4: 4, 9: 7, 10: 5, 15: 4, 24: 4, 25: 6, 26: 7, 27: 4, 39: 7, 43: 5, 49: 6, 50: 5, 59: 4, 64: 4, 69: 6, 81: 7, 82: 5, 86: 3, 100: 8, 108: 5, 109: 6, 110: 6, 111: 4, 114: 5, 115: 6, 116: 4, 118: 8, 119: 7, 120: 5, 121: 6, 122: 5, 123: 4, 124: 6, 128: 4, 129: 4, 132: 6, 136: 4, 145: 6, 151: 4, 152: 4, 154: 5, 156: 3, 161: 5, 162: 5, 165: 5, 168: 6, 169: 3, 172: 3, 180: 4, 184: 7, 187: 7, 188: 6, 191: 5, 194: 6, 202: 7, 203: 8, 206: 4, 207: 5, 215: 4, 217: 5, 218: 10, 220: 4, 221: 4, 222: 7, 224: 5, 227: 6, 229: 3, 234: 7, 235: 4, 241: 4, 242: 4, 243: 6, 244: 4, 245: 6, 248: 4, 250: 5, 258: 13, 262: 6, 263: 7, 264: 5, 267: 6, 270: 4, 272: 3, 273: 7, 287: 5, 289: 3, 299: 6, 300: 4, 304: 4, 309: 5, 314: 4, 315: 3, 320: 6, 323: 6, 327: 6, 328: 5, 329: 4, 330: 12, 334: 4, 335: 4, 341: 6, 342: 7, 347: 6, 348: 6, 350: 9, 351: 5, 352: 3, 353: 3, 354: 2, 358: 6, 365: 3, 366: 4, 369: 3, 371: 8, 376: 4, 384: 5, 385: 4, 386: 5, 387: 4, 392: 5, 393: 6, 396: 7, 397: 9, 398: 8, 402: 3} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 37 Attachment Circuit. Removing unused abbreviations . ddac06ad0cb7cd5845cf8a1c67128462cbfd5731 ddac06ad0cb7cd5845cf8a1c67128462cbfd5731 draft-ietf-detnet-mpls 890a229745f78c3232f7d204d42fe7c17d51066efd5ca3f47c9011e956d120d6 ['10f9a5c80140ddc029e2cc8bd11a50566e91cd86859e72018aaba5e3aa63710c', 'a184301bc923b0823b4be340e0397e937ea18ee4f0e63d9c9bda52358269721c', '798866c5ba6606c0230b5e31f7d949471ef699d268b844c3bf0c994e96864245', 'b205fa18b546a1f8079fdb24ae479d6824e7893fbc50608c283e46c6f8365253', 'fbd65fcc0d0f9ad86d6d5325108bfa20666e204194e86fcb51198d7a8116037d', '890a229745f78c3232f7d204d42fe7c17d51066efd5ca3f47c9011e956d120d6', '97c985aeb00a2b45cdc26ddc7cc9e5e08475164523c7e555feb34c739c6a3ec7'] A attachment circuit. {52: 1, 53: 1, 51: 1, 68: 1, 130: 3, 79: 2, 112: 2, 55: 2, 64: 2, 62: 3, 38: 2, 69: 2, 67: 2, 33: 2, 25: 2, 37: 2, 80: 2, 127: 4, 91: 2} {321: 1, 185: 1, 390: 1, 279: 1, 0: 3, 389: 2, 135: 2, 142: 2, 14: 2, 400: 3, 399: 3, 19: 3, 149: 2, 406: 2, 280: 2, 281: 3, 278: 2, 294: 2, 296: 2, 45: 3, 308: 2, 56: 2, 192: 2, 322: 2, 66: 2, 196: 5, 197: 4, 324: 2, 77: 2, 78: 2, 337: 4, 216: 2, 380: 2, 255: 3} {0, 389, 390, 135, 142, 14, 400, 17, 399, 19, 149, 406, 279, 280, 281, 278, 294, 296, 45, 308, 56, 185, 192, 321, 322, 66, 196, 197, 324, 77, 78, 337, 216, 380, 255} 37 Customer Edge equipment. Removing unused abbreviations . ddac06ad0cb7cd5845cf8a1c67128462cbfd5731 ddac06ad0cb7cd5845cf8a1c67128462cbfd5731 draft-ietf-detnet-mpls b205fa18b546a1f8079fdb24ae479d6824e7893fbc50608c283e46c6f8365253 ['10f9a5c80140ddc029e2cc8bd11a50566e91cd86859e72018aaba5e3aa63710c', 'a184301bc923b0823b4be340e0397e937ea18ee4f0e63d9c9bda52358269721c', '798866c5ba6606c0230b5e31f7d949471ef699d268b844c3bf0c994e96864245', 'b205fa18b546a1f8079fdb24ae479d6824e7893fbc50608c283e46c6f8365253', 'fbd65fcc0d0f9ad86d6d5325108bfa20666e204194e86fcb51198d7a8116037d', '890a229745f78c3232f7d204d42fe7c17d51066efd5ca3f47c9011e956d120d6', '97c985aeb00a2b45cdc26ddc7cc9e5e08475164523c7e555feb34c739c6a3ec7'] A customer edge equipment. {52: 1, 53: 1, 51: 1, 68: 1, 130: 3, 79: 2, 112: 2, 55: 2, 64: 2, 62: 3, 38: 2, 69: 2, 67: 2, 33: 2, 25: 2, 37: 2, 80: 2, 127: 4, 91: 2} {321: 1, 185: 1, 390: 1, 279: 1, 0: 3, 389: 2, 135: 2, 142: 2, 14: 2, 400: 3, 399: 3, 19: 3, 149: 2, 406: 2, 280: 2, 281: 3, 278: 2, 294: 2, 296: 2, 45: 3, 308: 2, 56: 2, 192: 2, 322: 2, 66: 2, 196: 5, 197: 4, 324: 2, 77: 2, 78: 2, 337: 4, 216: 2, 380: 2, 255: 3} {0, 389, 390, 135, 142, 14, 400, 17, 399, 19, 149, 406, 279, 280, 281, 278, 294, 296, 45, 308, 56, 185, 192, 321, 322, 66, 196, 197, 324, 77, 78, 337, 216, 380, 255} 37 DetNet Flow. Removing unused abbreviations . ddac06ad0cb7cd5845cf8a1c67128462cbfd5731 ddac06ad0cb7cd5845cf8a1c67128462cbfd5731 draft-ietf-detnet-mpls fbd65fcc0d0f9ad86d6d5325108bfa20666e204194e86fcb51198d7a8116037d ['10f9a5c80140ddc029e2cc8bd11a50566e91cd86859e72018aaba5e3aa63710c', 'a184301bc923b0823b4be340e0397e937ea18ee4f0e63d9c9bda52358269721c', '798866c5ba6606c0230b5e31f7d949471ef699d268b844c3bf0c994e96864245', 'b205fa18b546a1f8079fdb24ae479d6824e7893fbc50608c283e46c6f8365253', 'fbd65fcc0d0f9ad86d6d5325108bfa20666e204194e86fcb51198d7a8116037d', '890a229745f78c3232f7d204d42fe7c17d51066efd5ca3f47c9011e956d120d6', '97c985aeb00a2b45cdc26ddc7cc9e5e08475164523c7e555feb34c739c6a3ec7'] A detnet flow. {52: 1, 53: 1, 51: 1, 68: 1, 130: 3, 79: 2, 112: 2, 55: 2, 64: 2, 62: 3, 38: 2, 69: 2, 67: 2, 33: 2, 25: 2, 37: 2, 80: 2, 127: 4, 91: 2} {321: 1, 185: 1, 390: 1, 279: 1, 0: 3, 389: 2, 135: 2, 142: 2, 14: 2, 400: 3, 399: 3, 19: 3, 149: 2, 406: 2, 280: 2, 281: 3, 278: 2, 294: 2, 296: 2, 45: 3, 308: 2, 56: 2, 192: 2, 322: 2, 66: 2, 196: 5, 197: 4, 324: 2, 77: 2, 78: 2, 337: 4, 216: 2, 380: 2, 255: 3} {0, 389, 390, 135, 142, 14, 400, 17, 399, 19, 149, 406, 279, 280, 281, 278, 294, 296, 45, 308, 56, 185, 192, 321, 322, 66, 196, 197, 324, 77, 78, 337, 216, 380, 255} 37 DetNet Inter-Working Function. Removing unused abbreviations . ddac06ad0cb7cd5845cf8a1c67128462cbfd5731 ddac06ad0cb7cd5845cf8a1c67128462cbfd5731 draft-ietf-detnet-mpls 798866c5ba6606c0230b5e31f7d949471ef699d268b844c3bf0c994e96864245 ['10f9a5c80140ddc029e2cc8bd11a50566e91cd86859e72018aaba5e3aa63710c', 'a184301bc923b0823b4be340e0397e937ea18ee4f0e63d9c9bda52358269721c', '798866c5ba6606c0230b5e31f7d949471ef699d268b844c3bf0c994e96864245', 'b205fa18b546a1f8079fdb24ae479d6824e7893fbc50608c283e46c6f8365253', 'fbd65fcc0d0f9ad86d6d5325108bfa20666e204194e86fcb51198d7a8116037d', '890a229745f78c3232f7d204d42fe7c17d51066efd5ca3f47c9011e956d120d6', '97c985aeb00a2b45cdc26ddc7cc9e5e08475164523c7e555feb34c739c6a3ec7'] A detnet inter-working function. {52: 1, 53: 1, 51: 1, 68: 1, 130: 3, 79: 2, 112: 2, 55: 2, 64: 2, 62: 3, 38: 2, 69: 2, 67: 2, 33: 2, 25: 2, 37: 2, 80: 2, 127: 4, 91: 2} {321: 1, 185: 1, 390: 1, 279: 1, 0: 3, 389: 2, 135: 2, 142: 2, 14: 2, 400: 3, 399: 3, 19: 3, 149: 2, 406: 2, 280: 2, 281: 3, 278: 2, 294: 2, 296: 2, 45: 3, 308: 2, 56: 2, 192: 2, 322: 2, 66: 2, 196: 5, 197: 4, 324: 2, 77: 2, 78: 2, 337: 4, 216: 2, 380: 2, 255: 3} {0, 389, 390, 135, 142, 14, 400, 17, 399, 19, 149, 406, 279, 280, 281, 278, 294, 296, 45, 308, 56, 185, 192, 321, 322, 66, 196, 197, 324, 77, 78, 337, 216, 380, 255} 37 Layer 2. Removing unused abbreviations . ddac06ad0cb7cd5845cf8a1c67128462cbfd5731 ddac06ad0cb7cd5845cf8a1c67128462cbfd5731 draft-ietf-detnet-mpls 97c985aeb00a2b45cdc26ddc7cc9e5e08475164523c7e555feb34c739c6a3ec7 ['10f9a5c80140ddc029e2cc8bd11a50566e91cd86859e72018aaba5e3aa63710c', 'a184301bc923b0823b4be340e0397e937ea18ee4f0e63d9c9bda52358269721c', '798866c5ba6606c0230b5e31f7d949471ef699d268b844c3bf0c994e96864245', 'b205fa18b546a1f8079fdb24ae479d6824e7893fbc50608c283e46c6f8365253', 'fbd65fcc0d0f9ad86d6d5325108bfa20666e204194e86fcb51198d7a8116037d', '890a229745f78c3232f7d204d42fe7c17d51066efd5ca3f47c9011e956d120d6', '97c985aeb00a2b45cdc26ddc7cc9e5e08475164523c7e555feb34c739c6a3ec7'] A layer 2. {52: 1, 53: 1, 51: 1, 68: 1, 130: 3, 79: 2, 112: 2, 55: 2, 64: 2, 62: 3, 38: 2, 69: 2, 67: 2, 33: 2, 25: 2, 37: 2, 80: 2, 127: 4, 91: 2} {321: 1, 185: 1, 390: 1, 279: 1, 0: 3, 389: 2, 135: 2, 142: 2, 14: 2, 400: 3, 399: 3, 19: 3, 149: 2, 406: 2, 280: 2, 281: 3, 278: 2, 294: 2, 296: 2, 45: 3, 308: 2, 56: 2, 192: 2, 322: 2, 66: 2, 196: 5, 197: 4, 324: 2, 77: 2, 78: 2, 337: 4, 216: 2, 380: 2, 255: 3} {0, 389, 390, 135, 142, 14, 400, 17, 399, 19, 149, 406, 279, 280, 281, 278, 294, 296, 45, 308, 56, 185, 192, 321, 322, 66, 196, 197, 324, 77, 78, 337, 216, 380, 255} 37 Layer 2 Virtual Private Network. Removing unused abbreviations . ddac06ad0cb7cd5845cf8a1c67128462cbfd5731 ddac06ad0cb7cd5845cf8a1c67128462cbfd5731 draft-ietf-detnet-mpls 10f9a5c80140ddc029e2cc8bd11a50566e91cd86859e72018aaba5e3aa63710c ['10f9a5c80140ddc029e2cc8bd11a50566e91cd86859e72018aaba5e3aa63710c', 'a184301bc923b0823b4be340e0397e937ea18ee4f0e63d9c9bda52358269721c', '798866c5ba6606c0230b5e31f7d949471ef699d268b844c3bf0c994e96864245', 'b205fa18b546a1f8079fdb24ae479d6824e7893fbc50608c283e46c6f8365253', 'fbd65fcc0d0f9ad86d6d5325108bfa20666e204194e86fcb51198d7a8116037d', '890a229745f78c3232f7d204d42fe7c17d51066efd5ca3f47c9011e956d120d6', '97c985aeb00a2b45cdc26ddc7cc9e5e08475164523c7e555feb34c739c6a3ec7'] A layer 2 virtual private network. {52: 1, 53: 1, 51: 1, 68: 1, 130: 3, 79: 2, 112: 2, 55: 2, 64: 2, 62: 3, 38: 2, 69: 2, 67: 2, 33: 2, 25: 2, 37: 2, 80: 2, 127: 4, 91: 2} {321: 1, 185: 1, 390: 1, 279: 1, 0: 3, 389: 2, 135: 2, 142: 2, 14: 2, 400: 3, 399: 3, 19: 3, 149: 2, 406: 2, 280: 2, 281: 3, 278: 2, 294: 2, 296: 2, 45: 3, 308: 2, 56: 2, 192: 2, 322: 2, 66: 2, 196: 5, 197: 4, 324: 2, 77: 2, 78: 2, 337: 4, 216: 2, 380: 2, 255: 3} {0, 389, 390, 135, 142, 14, 400, 17, 399, 19, 149, 406, 279, 280, 281, 278, 294, 296, 45, 308, 56, 185, 192, 321, 322, 66, 196, 197, 324, 77, 78, 337, 216, 380, 255} 37 Layer 3. Removing unused abbreviations . ddac06ad0cb7cd5845cf8a1c67128462cbfd5731 ddac06ad0cb7cd5845cf8a1c67128462cbfd5731 draft-ietf-detnet-mpls a184301bc923b0823b4be340e0397e937ea18ee4f0e63d9c9bda52358269721c ['10f9a5c80140ddc029e2cc8bd11a50566e91cd86859e72018aaba5e3aa63710c', 'a184301bc923b0823b4be340e0397e937ea18ee4f0e63d9c9bda52358269721c', '798866c5ba6606c0230b5e31f7d949471ef699d268b844c3bf0c994e96864245', 'b205fa18b546a1f8079fdb24ae479d6824e7893fbc50608c283e46c6f8365253', 'fbd65fcc0d0f9ad86d6d5325108bfa20666e204194e86fcb51198d7a8116037d', '890a229745f78c3232f7d204d42fe7c17d51066efd5ca3f47c9011e956d120d6', '97c985aeb00a2b45cdc26ddc7cc9e5e08475164523c7e555feb34c739c6a3ec7'] A layer 3. {52: 1, 53: 1, 51: 1, 68: 1, 130: 3, 79: 2, 112: 2, 55: 2, 64: 2, 62: 3, 38: 2, 69: 2, 67: 2, 33: 2, 25: 2, 37: 2, 80: 2, 127: 4, 91: 2} {321: 1, 185: 1, 390: 1, 279: 1, 0: 3, 389: 2, 135: 2, 142: 2, 14: 2, 400: 3, 399: 3, 19: 3, 149: 2, 406: 2, 280: 2, 281: 3, 278: 2, 294: 2, 296: 2, 45: 3, 308: 2, 56: 2, 192: 2, 322: 2, 66: 2, 196: 5, 197: 4, 324: 2, 77: 2, 78: 2, 337: 4, 216: 2, 380: 2, 255: 3} {0, 389, 390, 135, 142, 14, 400, 17, 399, 19, 149, 406, 279, 280, 281, 278, 294, 296, 45, 308, 56, 185, 192, 321, 322, 66, 196, 197, 324, 77, 78, 337, 216, 380, 255} 37 Multi-Segment PseudoWire (MS-PW). Removing unused abbreviations . ddac06ad0cb7cd5845cf8a1c67128462cbfd5731 ddac06ad0cb7cd5845cf8a1c67128462cbfd5731 draft-ietf-detnet-mpls c2441bad9168c35aef67c82d8c8ca1d32bfa5f2bd7b4e3fdcb0c74913367661f ['eda485aa07899ce4cc9c22d814ca5a92456c0ba570795dc4ce791e8bb4e16f79', 'c2441bad9168c35aef67c82d8c8ca1d32bfa5f2bd7b4e3fdcb0c74913367661f'] A multi-segment pseudowire (ms-pw). {79: 1, 52: 1, 130: 3, 51: 2, 112: 2, 55: 3, 64: 2, 62: 3, 37: 2, 38: 3, 69: 2, 68: 2, 67: 2, 33: 2, 25: 2, 53: 2, 80: 2, 127: 4, 91: 3} {280: 1, 321: 1, 0: 3, 389: 2, 390: 2, 135: 2, 142: 3, 14: 2, 400: 3, 17: 2, 399: 3, 19: 3, 149: 3, 406: 2, 279: 2, 281: 3, 278: 2, 294: 2, 296: 2, 45: 3, 308: 2, 56: 2, 185: 2, 192: 2, 322: 2, 66: 2, 196: 5, 197: 4, 324: 3, 77: 3, 78: 3, 337: 4, 216: 3, 255: 3} {0, 389, 390, 135, 142, 14, 400, 17, 399, 19, 149, 406, 279, 280, 281, 278, 294, 296, 45, 308, 56, 185, 192, 321, 322, 66, 196, 197, 324, 77, 78, 337, 216, 380, 255} 37 Native Service Processing. Removing unused abbreviations . ddac06ad0cb7cd5845cf8a1c67128462cbfd5731 ddac06ad0cb7cd5845cf8a1c67128462cbfd5731 draft-ietf-detnet-mpls eda485aa07899ce4cc9c22d814ca5a92456c0ba570795dc4ce791e8bb4e16f79 ['eda485aa07899ce4cc9c22d814ca5a92456c0ba570795dc4ce791e8bb4e16f79', 'c2441bad9168c35aef67c82d8c8ca1d32bfa5f2bd7b4e3fdcb0c74913367661f'] A native service processing. {79: 1, 52: 1, 130: 3, 51: 2, 112: 2, 55: 3, 64: 2, 62: 3, 37: 2, 38: 3, 69: 2, 68: 2, 67: 2, 33: 2, 25: 2, 53: 2, 80: 2, 127: 4, 91: 3} {280: 1, 321: 1, 0: 3, 389: 2, 390: 2, 135: 2, 142: 3, 14: 2, 400: 3, 17: 2, 399: 3, 19: 3, 149: 3, 406: 2, 279: 2, 281: 3, 278: 2, 294: 2, 296: 2, 45: 3, 308: 2, 56: 2, 185: 2, 192: 2, 322: 2, 66: 2, 196: 5, 197: 4, 324: 3, 77: 3, 78: 3, 337: 4, 216: 3, 255: 3} {0, 389, 390, 135, 142, 14, 400, 17, 399, 19, 149, 406, 279, 280, 281, 278, 294, 296, 45, 308, 56, 185, 192, 321, 322, 66, 196, 197, 324, 77, 78, 337, 216, 380, 255} 37 Provider Edge. Removing unused abbreviations . ddac06ad0cb7cd5845cf8a1c67128462cbfd5731 ddac06ad0cb7cd5845cf8a1c67128462cbfd5731 draft-ietf-detnet-ip be783cb488ae6e1275dd4f9d7f0ff96f3649acbf22bd0a4f2c19de4bbaf5add7 ['be783cb488ae6e1275dd4f9d7f0ff96f3649acbf22bd0a4f2c19de4bbaf5add7', 'b44b885a406cb9ec036bed7a2f808cd599fef92864f4ac305f6309a2fb37cb4d', 'c4eb3cf36ad02a44f1e152d859058b6e744c4f9c62b2738602e0623d7870b6af'] A provider edge. {112: 1, 68: 1, 79: 1, 51: 1, 130: 4, 55: 2, 64: 2, 62: 3, 37: 2, 38: 2, 69: 2, 67: 3, 33: 2, 25: 2, 53: 3, 80: 3, 52: 2, 127: 5, 91: 2} {45: 1, 135: 1, 279: 1, 280: 1, 308: 1, 0: 4, 389: 3, 390: 3, 142: 2, 14: 2, 400: 3, 17: 2, 399: 4, 19: 3, 149: 2, 406: 2, 281: 4, 278: 2, 294: 2, 56: 3, 185: 3, 192: 3, 321: 2, 322: 3, 66: 3, 196: 6, 197: 5, 324: 2, 77: 2, 78: 2, 337: 5, 216: 2, 380: 2, 255: 4} {0, 389, 390, 135, 142, 14, 400, 17, 399, 19, 149, 406, 279, 280, 281, 278, 294, 296, 45, 308, 56, 185, 192, 321, 322, 66, 196, 197, 324, 77, 78, 337, 216, 380, 255} 37 Packet Switched Network. Removing unused abbreviations . ddac06ad0cb7cd5845cf8a1c67128462cbfd5731 ddac06ad0cb7cd5845cf8a1c67128462cbfd5731 draft-ietf-detnet-ip b44b885a406cb9ec036bed7a2f808cd599fef92864f4ac305f6309a2fb37cb4d ['be783cb488ae6e1275dd4f9d7f0ff96f3649acbf22bd0a4f2c19de4bbaf5add7', 'b44b885a406cb9ec036bed7a2f808cd599fef92864f4ac305f6309a2fb37cb4d', 'c4eb3cf36ad02a44f1e152d859058b6e744c4f9c62b2738602e0623d7870b6af'] A packet switched network. {112: 1, 68: 1, 79: 1, 51: 1, 130: 4, 55: 2, 64: 2, 62: 3, 37: 2, 38: 2, 69: 2, 67: 3, 33: 2, 25: 2, 53: 3, 80: 3, 52: 2, 127: 5, 91: 2} {45: 1, 135: 1, 279: 1, 280: 1, 308: 1, 0: 4, 389: 3, 390: 3, 142: 2, 14: 2, 400: 3, 17: 2, 399: 4, 19: 3, 149: 2, 406: 2, 281: 4, 278: 2, 294: 2, 56: 3, 185: 3, 192: 3, 321: 2, 322: 3, 66: 3, 196: 6, 197: 5, 324: 2, 77: 2, 78: 2, 337: 5, 216: 2, 380: 2, 255: 4} {0, 389, 390, 135, 142, 14, 400, 17, 399, 19, 149, 406, 279, 280, 281, 278, 294, 296, 45, 308, 56, 185, 192, 321, 322, 66, 196, 197, 324, 77, 78, 337, 216, 380, 255} 37 Traffic Engineering. Removing unused abbreviations . ddac06ad0cb7cd5845cf8a1c67128462cbfd5731 ddac06ad0cb7cd5845cf8a1c67128462cbfd5731 draft-ietf-detnet-ip c4eb3cf36ad02a44f1e152d859058b6e744c4f9c62b2738602e0623d7870b6af ['be783cb488ae6e1275dd4f9d7f0ff96f3649acbf22bd0a4f2c19de4bbaf5add7', 'b44b885a406cb9ec036bed7a2f808cd599fef92864f4ac305f6309a2fb37cb4d', 'c4eb3cf36ad02a44f1e152d859058b6e744c4f9c62b2738602e0623d7870b6af'] A traffic engineering. {112: 1, 68: 1, 79: 1, 51: 1, 130: 4, 55: 2, 64: 2, 62: 3, 37: 2, 38: 2, 69: 2, 67: 3, 33: 2, 25: 2, 53: 3, 80: 3, 52: 2, 127: 5, 91: 2} {45: 1, 135: 1, 279: 1, 280: 1, 308: 1, 0: 4, 389: 3, 390: 3, 142: 2, 14: 2, 400: 3, 17: 2, 399: 4, 19: 3, 149: 2, 406: 2, 281: 4, 278: 2, 294: 2, 56: 3, 185: 3, 192: 3, 321: 2, 322: 3, 66: 3, 196: 6, 197: 5, 324: 2, 77: 2, 78: 2, 337: 5, 216: 2, 380: 2, 255: 4} {0, 389, 390, 135, 142, 14, 400, 17, 399, 19, 149, 406, 279, 280, 281, 278, 294, 296, 45, 308, 56, 185, 192, 321, 322, 66, 196, 197, 324, 77, 78, 337, 216, 380, 255} 36 An example use of DetNet IP over DetNet MPLS follows below. IP over MPLS changes to be reviewed . 1929aee4fba0f7f843ae1dc5476f20555a0a40d6 1929aee4fba0f7f843ae1dc5476f20555a0a40d6 draft-ietf-detnet-ip-over-mpls 04d4d47ee5530763bb4330bcdd6372ca8eb2219e1b39f5c06d455c1a38ddd1fa ['d0c99b712d781b6359b2fe1767b3baaf9b56308f6a7a2547c29e2651a7678193', '04d4d47ee5530763bb4330bcdd6372ca8eb2219e1b39f5c06d455c1a38ddd1fa', '3c71b5b0244ef9900782a209a9ef4e60534a872cd58ffa5058851668c4854151', '211048506af6d220962ef631d6bfb563431346cbf9e29565310d2cb67aa97549'] A an example use of detnet ip over detnet mpls follows below. {30: 1, 63: 1, 110: 2} {3: 1, 332: 1, 186: 2} {186, 331, 3, 332} 36 "fig_dn_ip_mpls_detnet illustrates DetNet enabled End Systems (hosts), connected to DetNet (DN) enabled IP networks, operating over a DetNet aware MPLS network. In this figure, Relay nodes sit at the boundary of the MPLS domain since the non-MPLS domain is DetNet aware. This figure is very similar to the DetNet MPLS Network figure in I-D.ietf- detnet-mpls. The primary difference is that the Relay nodes are at the edges of the MPLS domain and therefore function as T-PEs, and that service sub-layer functions are not provided over the DetNet IP network. The transit node functions show above are identical to those described in I-D.ietf-detnet-mpls." IP over MPLS changes to be reviewed . 1929aee4fba0f7f843ae1dc5476f20555a0a40d6 1929aee4fba0f7f843ae1dc5476f20555a0a40d6 draft-ietf-detnet-ip-over-mpls 211048506af6d220962ef631d6bfb563431346cbf9e29565310d2cb67aa97549 ['d0c99b712d781b6359b2fe1767b3baaf9b56308f6a7a2547c29e2651a7678193', '04d4d47ee5530763bb4330bcdd6372ca8eb2219e1b39f5c06d455c1a38ddd1fa', '3c71b5b0244ef9900782a209a9ef4e60534a872cd58ffa5058851668c4854151', '211048506af6d220962ef631d6bfb563431346cbf9e29565310d2cb67aa97549'] A "fig_dn_ip_mpls_detnet illustrates detnet enabled end systems (hosts), connected to detnet (dn) enabled ip networks, operating over a detnet aware mpls network. in this figure, relay nodes sit at the boundary of the mpls domain since the non-mpls domain is detnet aware. this figure is very similar to the detnet mpls network figure in i-d.ietf- detnet-mpls. the primary difference is that the relay nodes are at the edges of the mpls domain and therefore function as t-pes, and that service sub-layer functions are not provided over the detnet ip network. the transit node functions show above are identical to those described in i-d.ietf-detnet-mpls." {30: 1, 63: 1, 110: 2} {3: 1, 332: 1, 186: 2} {186, 331, 3, 332} 36 An example use of DetNet IP over DetNet MPLS is presented here. IP over MPLS changes to be reviewed . 1929aee4fba0f7f843ae1dc5476f20555a0a40d6 1929aee4fba0f7f843ae1dc5476f20555a0a40d6 draft-ietf-detnet-ip-over-mpls 3c71b5b0244ef9900782a209a9ef4e60534a872cd58ffa5058851668c4854151 ['d0c99b712d781b6359b2fe1767b3baaf9b56308f6a7a2547c29e2651a7678193', '04d4d47ee5530763bb4330bcdd6372ca8eb2219e1b39f5c06d455c1a38ddd1fa', '3c71b5b0244ef9900782a209a9ef4e60534a872cd58ffa5058851668c4854151', '211048506af6d220962ef631d6bfb563431346cbf9e29565310d2cb67aa97549'] B an example use of detnet ip over detnet mpls is presented here. {30: 1, 63: 1, 110: 2} {3: 1, 332: 1, 186: 2} {186, 331, 3, 332} 36 "fig_ip_detnet illustrated DetNet enabled End Systems (hosts), connected to DetNet (DN) enabled IP networks, operating over a DetNet aware MPLS network. iUsing this figure we can have a case where the Relay nodes act as T-PEs and sit at the boundary of the MPLS domain since the non-MPLS domain is DetNet aware. This case is very similar to the DetNet MPLS Network figure 2 in I-D.ietf-detnet-mpls. However in I-D.ietf-detnet-mpls figure 2 the T-PEs are located at the end syetem and MPLS spans the whole DetNet service. The primary difference in this document is that the Relay nodes are at the edges of the MPLS domain and therefore function as T-PEs, and that iMPLS service sub-layer functions are not provided over the DetNet IP network. The transit node functions show above are identical to those described in I-D.ietf-detnet-mpls." IP over MPLS changes to be reviewed . 1929aee4fba0f7f843ae1dc5476f20555a0a40d6 1929aee4fba0f7f843ae1dc5476f20555a0a40d6 draft-ietf-detnet-ip-over-mpls d0c99b712d781b6359b2fe1767b3baaf9b56308f6a7a2547c29e2651a7678193 ['d0c99b712d781b6359b2fe1767b3baaf9b56308f6a7a2547c29e2651a7678193', '04d4d47ee5530763bb4330bcdd6372ca8eb2219e1b39f5c06d455c1a38ddd1fa', '3c71b5b0244ef9900782a209a9ef4e60534a872cd58ffa5058851668c4854151', '211048506af6d220962ef631d6bfb563431346cbf9e29565310d2cb67aa97549'] B "fig_ip_detnet illustrated detnet enabled end systems (hosts), connected to detnet (dn) enabled ip networks, operating over a detnet aware mpls network. iusing this figure we can have a case where the relay nodes act as t-pes and sit at the boundary of the mpls domain since the non-mpls domain is detnet aware. this case is very similar to the detnet mpls network figure 2 in i-d.ietf-detnet-mpls. however in i-d.ietf-detnet-mpls figure 2 the t-pes are located at the end syetem and mpls spans the whole detnet service. the primary difference in this document is that the relay nodes are at the edges of the mpls domain and therefore function as t-pes, and that impls service sub-layer functions are not provided over the detnet ip network. the transit node functions show above are identical to those described in i-d.ietf-detnet-mpls." {30: 1, 63: 1, 110: 2} {3: 1, 332: 1, 186: 2} {186, 331, 3, 332} 36 "fig_ip_mpls_detnet illustrates non-DetNet enabled End Systems (hosts), connected to DetNet (DN) enabled MPLS network. It differs from fig_dn_ip_mpls_detnet in that the hosts and edge IP networks are not DetNet aware. In this case, edge nodes sit at the boundary of the MPLS domain since it is also a DetNet domain boundary. The edge nodes provide DetNet service proxies for the end applications by initiating and terminating DetNet service for the application's IP flows. While the node types differ, there is essentially no difference in data plane processing between relay and edges. There are likely to be differences in controller plane operation, particularly when distributed control plane protocols are used." IP over MPLS changes to be reviewed . 1929aee4fba0f7f843ae1dc5476f20555a0a40d6 1929aee4fba0f7f843ae1dc5476f20555a0a40d6 draft-ietf-detnet-ip-over-mpls 411823e8ccfe42adb006309c82ad64e080b90efc8230a3107a95d708e8197611 ['b9d3772ed35ae1221961bcd5c98363c10a419ac6a8b8696322db56f713e00158', 'bc3c588a20062a32882138688b070d3e22c82848397ebfb1a98cef2708481224', '7f7392ff2f0b6588a9167305ba0eccfa64509738c00edee63fa3900150d2f7f6', '411823e8ccfe42adb006309c82ad64e080b90efc8230a3107a95d708e8197611'] A "fig_ip_mpls_detnet illustrates non-detnet enabled end systems (hosts), connected to detnet (dn) enabled mpls network. it differs from fig_dn_ip_mpls_detnet in that the hosts and edge ip networks are not detnet aware. in this case, edge nodes sit at the boundary of the mpls domain since it is also a detnet domain boundary. the edge nodes provide detnet service proxies for the end applications by initiating and terminating detnet service for the application's ip flows. while the node types differ, there is essentially no difference in data plane processing between relay and edges. there are likely to be differences in controller plane operation, particularly when distributed control plane protocols are used." {63: 1, 110: 2} {290: 1, 170: 2, 51: 2} {170, 290, 51, 293} 36 "fig_pw_detnet2 illustrates how it is still possible to provided DetNet service protection for non-DetNet aware end systems. This figures is basically the same as fig_ip_pw_detnet, with the exception that CE1 and CE2 are non-DetNet aware end systems and E1 and E3 are edge nodes that replace the relay nodes R1 and R3." IP over MPLS changes to be reviewed . 1929aee4fba0f7f843ae1dc5476f20555a0a40d6 1929aee4fba0f7f843ae1dc5476f20555a0a40d6 draft-ietf-detnet-ip-over-mpls bc3c588a20062a32882138688b070d3e22c82848397ebfb1a98cef2708481224 ['b9d3772ed35ae1221961bcd5c98363c10a419ac6a8b8696322db56f713e00158', 'bc3c588a20062a32882138688b070d3e22c82848397ebfb1a98cef2708481224', '7f7392ff2f0b6588a9167305ba0eccfa64509738c00edee63fa3900150d2f7f6', '411823e8ccfe42adb006309c82ad64e080b90efc8230a3107a95d708e8197611'] A "fig_pw_detnet2 illustrates how it is still possible to provided detnet service protection for non-detnet aware end systems. this figures is basically the same as fig_ip_pw_detnet, with the exception that ce1 and ce2 are non-detnet aware end systems and e1 and e3 are edge nodes that replace the relay nodes r1 and r3." {63: 1, 110: 2} {290: 1, 170: 2, 51: 2} {170, 290, 51, 293} 36 "fig_ip_detnet illustrates DetNet enabled End Systems (hosts), connected to DetNet (DN) enabled MPLS network. A similar situation occurs when end systems are are not DetNet aware. In this case, edge nodes sit at the boundary of the MPLS domain since it is also a DetNet domain boundary. The edge nodes provide DetNet service proxies for the end applications by initiating and terminating DetNet service for the application's IP flows. While the node types differ, there is essentially no difference in data plane processing between relay and edges. There are likely to be differences in controller plane operation, particularly when distributed control plane protocols are used." IP over MPLS changes to be reviewed . 1929aee4fba0f7f843ae1dc5476f20555a0a40d6 1929aee4fba0f7f843ae1dc5476f20555a0a40d6 draft-ietf-detnet-ip-over-mpls 7f7392ff2f0b6588a9167305ba0eccfa64509738c00edee63fa3900150d2f7f6 ['b9d3772ed35ae1221961bcd5c98363c10a419ac6a8b8696322db56f713e00158', 'bc3c588a20062a32882138688b070d3e22c82848397ebfb1a98cef2708481224', '7f7392ff2f0b6588a9167305ba0eccfa64509738c00edee63fa3900150d2f7f6', '411823e8ccfe42adb006309c82ad64e080b90efc8230a3107a95d708e8197611'] B "fig_ip_detnet illustrates detnet enabled end systems (hosts), connected to detnet (dn) enabled mpls network. a similar situation occurs when end systems are are not detnet aware. in this case, edge nodes sit at the boundary of the mpls domain since it is also a detnet domain boundary. the edge nodes provide detnet service proxies for the end applications by initiating and terminating detnet service for the application's ip flows. while the node types differ, there is essentially no difference in data plane processing between relay and edges. there are likely to be differences in controller plane operation, particularly when distributed control plane protocols are used." {63: 1, 110: 2} {290: 1, 170: 2, 51: 2} {170, 290, 51, 293} 36 "It is still possible to provided DetNet service protection for non- DetNet aware end systems. case is basically the same as fig_ip_pw_detnet, with the exception that CE1 and CE2 are non-DetNet aware end systems and R1 and R3 become edge nodes." IP over MPLS changes to be reviewed . 1929aee4fba0f7f843ae1dc5476f20555a0a40d6 1929aee4fba0f7f843ae1dc5476f20555a0a40d6 draft-ietf-detnet-ip-over-mpls b9d3772ed35ae1221961bcd5c98363c10a419ac6a8b8696322db56f713e00158 ['b9d3772ed35ae1221961bcd5c98363c10a419ac6a8b8696322db56f713e00158', 'bc3c588a20062a32882138688b070d3e22c82848397ebfb1a98cef2708481224', '7f7392ff2f0b6588a9167305ba0eccfa64509738c00edee63fa3900150d2f7f6', '411823e8ccfe42adb006309c82ad64e080b90efc8230a3107a95d708e8197611'] B "it is still possible to provided detnet service protection for non- detnet aware end systems. case is basically the same as fig_ip_pw_detnet, with the exception that ce1 and ce2 are non-detnet aware end systems and r1 and r3 become edge nodes." {63: 1, 110: 2} {290: 1, 170: 2, 51: 2} {170, 290, 51, 293} 36 "As shown in fig_ip_mpls_detnet, DetNet relay nodes are responsible for the mapping of a DetNet flow, at the service sub-layer, from the IP to MPLS DetNet data planes and back again. Their related DetNet IP over DetNet MPLS data plane operation is comprised of two sets of procedures: the mapping of flow identifiers; and ensuring proper traffic treatment." IP over MPLS changes to be reviewed . 1929aee4fba0f7f843ae1dc5476f20555a0a40d6 1929aee4fba0f7f843ae1dc5476f20555a0a40d6 draft-ietf-detnet-ip-over-mpls 6297fbdf8520a6cb98f9d53b579f7cc5365b041c77bb49fc8b1904c51802994c ['d2110b86acf572e0194460f6eafffa6032a44789a0222d08159595dfdfd35657', '6297fbdf8520a6cb98f9d53b579f7cc5365b041c77bb49fc8b1904c51802994c', '117b368427deaeb78c79a6100ddbe167ef4f180ae58f9f1417f6479c7a9ba601'] A "as shown in fig_ip_mpls_detnet, detnet relay nodes are responsible for the mapping of a detnet flow, at the service sub-layer, from the ip to mpls detnet data planes and back again. their related detnet ip over detnet mpls data plane operation is comprised of two sets of procedures: the mapping of flow identifiers; and ensuring proper traffic treatment." {63: 1, 30: 2, 91: 2, 56: 2, 110: 3} {395: 1, 356: 2, 134: 2, 75: 2, 346: 3} {356, 134, 75, 395, 333, 346} 36 "As shown in fig_ip_pw_detnet, DetNet relay nodes are responsible for the mapping of a DetNet flow, at the service sub-layer, from the IP to MPLS DetNet data planes and back again. Their related DetNet IP over DetNet MPLS data plane operation is comprised of two sets of procedures: the mapping of flow identifiers; and ensuring proper traffic treatment." IP over MPLS changes to be reviewed . 1929aee4fba0f7f843ae1dc5476f20555a0a40d6 1929aee4fba0f7f843ae1dc5476f20555a0a40d6 draft-ietf-detnet-ip-over-mpls 117b368427deaeb78c79a6100ddbe167ef4f180ae58f9f1417f6479c7a9ba601 ['d2110b86acf572e0194460f6eafffa6032a44789a0222d08159595dfdfd35657', '6297fbdf8520a6cb98f9d53b579f7cc5365b041c77bb49fc8b1904c51802994c', '117b368427deaeb78c79a6100ddbe167ef4f180ae58f9f1417f6479c7a9ba601'] B "as shown in fig_ip_pw_detnet, detnet relay nodes are responsible for the mapping of a detnet flow, at the service sub-layer, from the ip to mpls detnet data planes and back again. their related detnet ip over detnet mpls data plane operation is comprised of two sets of procedures: the mapping of flow identifiers; and ensuring proper traffic treatment." {63: 1, 30: 2, 91: 2, 56: 2, 110: 3} {395: 1, 356: 2, 134: 2, 75: 2, 346: 3} {356, 134, 75, 395, 333, 346} 36 "Mapping of IP to the MPLS Detnet is similar for IP Detnet flows and IP flows. The six-tuple of IP is mapped to the S-Label in both cases. The various fields may be mapped or ignored when going from IP to MPLS." IP over MPLS changes to be reviewed . 1929aee4fba0f7f843ae1dc5476f20555a0a40d6 1929aee4fba0f7f843ae1dc5476f20555a0a40d6 draft-ietf-detnet-ip-over-mpls d2110b86acf572e0194460f6eafffa6032a44789a0222d08159595dfdfd35657 ['d2110b86acf572e0194460f6eafffa6032a44789a0222d08159595dfdfd35657', '6297fbdf8520a6cb98f9d53b579f7cc5365b041c77bb49fc8b1904c51802994c', '117b368427deaeb78c79a6100ddbe167ef4f180ae58f9f1417f6479c7a9ba601'] B "mapping of ip to the mpls detnet is similar for ip detnet flows and ip flows. the six-tuple of ip is mapped to the s-label in both cases. the various fields may be mapped or ignored when going from ip to mpls." {63: 1, 30: 2, 91: 2, 56: 2, 110: 3} {395: 1, 356: 2, 134: 2, 75: 2, 346: 3} {356, 134, 75, 395, 333, 346} 36 "The security considerations of DetNet in general are discussed in I- D.ietf-detnet-architecture and I-D.ietf-detnet-security. MPLS and IP specific security considerations are described in I-D.ietf-detnet- mpls and I-D.ietf-detnet-ip. This draft does not have additional security considerations." IP over MPLS changes to be reviewed . 1929aee4fba0f7f843ae1dc5476f20555a0a40d6 1929aee4fba0f7f843ae1dc5476f20555a0a40d6 draft-ietf-detnet-ip-over-mpls 5024c49f483b8d46eb4017736cd7ced5b578f170328bf15ff1060aa0235be4b8 ['dbba5d27f625b2298f88e8cf65fe9b3584fb8078028e7996f70d1ba2980b8375', '7562688d7a135b11e38770a6d49690faf2cb7a0f8c5fa58478c102540a5ec84c', '5024c49f483b8d46eb4017736cd7ced5b578f170328bf15ff1060aa0235be4b8', 'e30afecfc76617a262182c81ea5ad3d36ff6cb97f12269ce22b2831c27cb3ab3', 'fa6534a2fea10c93739f34a3a3ebc956aa92d44a1990ef9c3f8c57af2882f9cd', '9660729dcccf51d5b146b7b549f874e0feac220bda1c96d69e1fcfab2efbb95f', '6d1c378f6ab7bd6ae836d4ac295f0de5a2664c0064bd50ab47c1dde2a64665c8'] A "the security considerations of detnet in general are discussed in i- d.ietf-detnet-architecture and i-d.ietf-detnet-security. mpls and ip specific security considerations are described in i-d.ietf-detnet- mpls and i-d.ietf-detnet-ip. this draft does not have additional security considerations." {64: 1, 30: 1, 115: 1, 110: 1, 67: 1, 87: 1, 102: 1, 84: 1, 13: 1, 15: 1, 24: 1, 114: 1, 90: 1, 6: 3, 79: 3, 51: 2, 130: 3, 62: 5, 85: 6, 68: 5, 35: 4, 91: 2, 97: 3, 31: 2, 38: 3, 26: 2, 124: 4, 98: 3, 54: 3, 127: 4, 8: 3, 96: 3, 61: 4, 55: 4, 27: 3, 52: 2, 129: 4, 76: 7, 131: 6, 113: 4, 99: 3, 53: 2, 72: 3} {128: 1, 129: 1, 169: 1, 172: 1, 180: 1, 229: 1, 272: 1, 289: 1, 315: 1, 352: 1, 354: 1, 365: 1, 402: 1, 1: 10, 4: 3, 9: 6, 10: 4, 15: 3, 24: 3, 25: 5, 26: 6, 27: 2, 39: 6, 43: 4, 49: 3, 50: 2, 58: 4, 59: 3, 64: 3, 69: 5, 81: 6, 82: 4, 86: 2, 96: 3, 97: 2, 100: 7, 108: 4, 109: 5, 110: 5, 111: 3, 114: 4, 115: 5, 116: 3, 118: 7, 119: 6, 120: 4, 121: 5, 122: 4, 123: 3, 124: 5, 130: 4, 132: 5, 136: 3, 145: 5, 147: 3, 151: 2, 152: 2, 154: 4, 156: 2, 161: 4, 162: 4, 165: 4, 168: 5, 184: 6, 187: 6, 188: 5, 191: 4, 194: 5, 202: 6, 203: 7, 206: 3, 207: 4, 215: 3, 217: 4, 218: 9, 220: 3, 221: 3, 222: 6, 224: 4, 227: 5, 234: 6, 235: 3, 241: 3, 242: 3, 243: 5, 244: 2, 245: 5, 248: 2, 250: 4, 258: 12, 262: 5, 263: 6, 264: 4, 267: 5, 270: 3, 273: 6, 287: 4, 291: 4, 299: 5, 300: 3, 304: 3, 309: 4, 314: 3, 320: 5, 323: 5, 327: 5, 328: 4, 329: 3, 330: 11, 334: 3, 335: 3, 341: 5, 342: 6, 347: 5, 348: 5, 350: 8, 351: 3, 358: 5, 366: 3, 369: 2, 371: 7, 372: 4, 376: 3, 384: 4, 385: 3, 386: 4, 387: 3, 392: 4, 393: 5, 396: 6, 397: 8, 398: 7} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 36 "This draft does not have additional security considerations. Security considerations for DetNet are described in detail in I- D.ietf-detnet-security. General security considerations are described in I-D.ietf-detnet-architecture. MPLS and IP specific considerations are described in I-D.ietf-detnet-mpls and I-D.ietf- detnet-ip." IP over MPLS changes to be reviewed . 1929aee4fba0f7f843ae1dc5476f20555a0a40d6 1929aee4fba0f7f843ae1dc5476f20555a0a40d6 draft-ietf-detnet-ip-over-mpls 7562688d7a135b11e38770a6d49690faf2cb7a0f8c5fa58478c102540a5ec84c ['dbba5d27f625b2298f88e8cf65fe9b3584fb8078028e7996f70d1ba2980b8375', '7562688d7a135b11e38770a6d49690faf2cb7a0f8c5fa58478c102540a5ec84c', '5024c49f483b8d46eb4017736cd7ced5b578f170328bf15ff1060aa0235be4b8', 'e30afecfc76617a262182c81ea5ad3d36ff6cb97f12269ce22b2831c27cb3ab3', 'fa6534a2fea10c93739f34a3a3ebc956aa92d44a1990ef9c3f8c57af2882f9cd', '9660729dcccf51d5b146b7b549f874e0feac220bda1c96d69e1fcfab2efbb95f', '6d1c378f6ab7bd6ae836d4ac295f0de5a2664c0064bd50ab47c1dde2a64665c8'] B "this draft does not have additional security considerations. security considerations for detnet are described in detail in i- d.ietf-detnet-security. general security considerations are described in i-d.ietf-detnet-architecture. mpls and ip specific considerations are described in i-d.ietf-detnet-mpls and i-d.ietf- detnet-ip." {64: 1, 30: 1, 115: 1, 110: 1, 67: 1, 87: 1, 102: 1, 84: 1, 13: 1, 15: 1, 24: 1, 114: 1, 90: 1, 6: 3, 79: 3, 51: 2, 130: 3, 62: 5, 85: 6, 68: 5, 35: 4, 91: 2, 97: 3, 31: 2, 38: 3, 26: 2, 124: 4, 98: 3, 54: 3, 127: 4, 8: 3, 96: 3, 61: 4, 55: 4, 27: 3, 52: 2, 129: 4, 76: 7, 131: 6, 113: 4, 99: 3, 53: 2, 72: 3} {128: 1, 129: 1, 169: 1, 172: 1, 180: 1, 229: 1, 272: 1, 289: 1, 315: 1, 352: 1, 354: 1, 365: 1, 402: 1, 1: 10, 4: 3, 9: 6, 10: 4, 15: 3, 24: 3, 25: 5, 26: 6, 27: 2, 39: 6, 43: 4, 49: 3, 50: 2, 58: 4, 59: 3, 64: 3, 69: 5, 81: 6, 82: 4, 86: 2, 96: 3, 97: 2, 100: 7, 108: 4, 109: 5, 110: 5, 111: 3, 114: 4, 115: 5, 116: 3, 118: 7, 119: 6, 120: 4, 121: 5, 122: 4, 123: 3, 124: 5, 130: 4, 132: 5, 136: 3, 145: 5, 147: 3, 151: 2, 152: 2, 154: 4, 156: 2, 161: 4, 162: 4, 165: 4, 168: 5, 184: 6, 187: 6, 188: 5, 191: 4, 194: 5, 202: 6, 203: 7, 206: 3, 207: 4, 215: 3, 217: 4, 218: 9, 220: 3, 221: 3, 222: 6, 224: 4, 227: 5, 234: 6, 235: 3, 241: 3, 242: 3, 243: 5, 244: 2, 245: 5, 248: 2, 250: 4, 258: 12, 262: 5, 263: 6, 264: 4, 267: 5, 270: 3, 273: 6, 287: 4, 291: 4, 299: 5, 300: 3, 304: 3, 309: 4, 314: 3, 320: 5, 323: 5, 327: 5, 328: 4, 329: 3, 330: 11, 334: 3, 335: 3, 341: 5, 342: 6, 347: 5, 348: 5, 350: 8, 351: 3, 358: 5, 366: 3, 369: 2, 371: 7, 372: 4, 376: 3, 384: 4, 385: 3, 386: 4, 387: 3, 392: 4, 393: 5, 396: 6, 397: 8, 398: 7} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 36 "Security aspects which are unique to DetNet are those whose aim is to provide the specific quality of service aspects of DetNet, which are primarily to deliver data flows with extremely low packet loss rates and bounded end-to-end delivery latency." IP over MPLS changes to be reviewed . 1929aee4fba0f7f843ae1dc5476f20555a0a40d6 1929aee4fba0f7f843ae1dc5476f20555a0a40d6 draft-ietf-detnet-ip-over-mpls fa6534a2fea10c93739f34a3a3ebc956aa92d44a1990ef9c3f8c57af2882f9cd ['dbba5d27f625b2298f88e8cf65fe9b3584fb8078028e7996f70d1ba2980b8375', '7562688d7a135b11e38770a6d49690faf2cb7a0f8c5fa58478c102540a5ec84c', '5024c49f483b8d46eb4017736cd7ced5b578f170328bf15ff1060aa0235be4b8', 'e30afecfc76617a262182c81ea5ad3d36ff6cb97f12269ce22b2831c27cb3ab3', 'fa6534a2fea10c93739f34a3a3ebc956aa92d44a1990ef9c3f8c57af2882f9cd', '9660729dcccf51d5b146b7b549f874e0feac220bda1c96d69e1fcfab2efbb95f', '6d1c378f6ab7bd6ae836d4ac295f0de5a2664c0064bd50ab47c1dde2a64665c8'] B "security aspects which are unique to detnet are those whose aim is to provide the specific quality of service aspects of detnet, which are primarily to deliver data flows with extremely low packet loss rates and bounded end-to-end delivery latency." {64: 1, 30: 1, 115: 1, 110: 1, 67: 1, 87: 1, 102: 1, 84: 1, 13: 1, 15: 1, 24: 1, 114: 1, 90: 1, 6: 3, 79: 3, 51: 2, 130: 3, 62: 5, 85: 6, 68: 5, 35: 4, 91: 2, 97: 3, 31: 2, 38: 3, 26: 2, 124: 4, 98: 3, 54: 3, 127: 4, 8: 3, 96: 3, 61: 4, 55: 4, 27: 3, 52: 2, 129: 4, 76: 7, 131: 6, 113: 4, 99: 3, 53: 2, 72: 3} {128: 1, 129: 1, 169: 1, 172: 1, 180: 1, 229: 1, 272: 1, 289: 1, 315: 1, 352: 1, 354: 1, 365: 1, 402: 1, 1: 10, 4: 3, 9: 6, 10: 4, 15: 3, 24: 3, 25: 5, 26: 6, 27: 2, 39: 6, 43: 4, 49: 3, 50: 2, 58: 4, 59: 3, 64: 3, 69: 5, 81: 6, 82: 4, 86: 2, 96: 3, 97: 2, 100: 7, 108: 4, 109: 5, 110: 5, 111: 3, 114: 4, 115: 5, 116: 3, 118: 7, 119: 6, 120: 4, 121: 5, 122: 4, 123: 3, 124: 5, 130: 4, 132: 5, 136: 3, 145: 5, 147: 3, 151: 2, 152: 2, 154: 4, 156: 2, 161: 4, 162: 4, 165: 4, 168: 5, 184: 6, 187: 6, 188: 5, 191: 4, 194: 5, 202: 6, 203: 7, 206: 3, 207: 4, 215: 3, 217: 4, 218: 9, 220: 3, 221: 3, 222: 6, 224: 4, 227: 5, 234: 6, 235: 3, 241: 3, 242: 3, 243: 5, 244: 2, 245: 5, 248: 2, 250: 4, 258: 12, 262: 5, 263: 6, 264: 4, 267: 5, 270: 3, 273: 6, 287: 4, 291: 4, 299: 5, 300: 3, 304: 3, 309: 4, 314: 3, 320: 5, 323: 5, 327: 5, 328: 4, 329: 3, 330: 11, 334: 3, 335: 3, 341: 5, 342: 6, 347: 5, 348: 5, 350: 8, 351: 3, 358: 5, 366: 3, 369: 2, 371: 7, 372: 4, 376: 3, 384: 4, 385: 3, 386: 4, 387: 3, 392: 4, 393: 5, 396: 6, 397: 8, 398: 7} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 36 "The primary considerations for the data plane is to maintain integrity of data and delivery of the associated DetNet service traversing the DetNet network. Application flows can be protected through whatever means is provided by the underlying technology. For example, encryption may be used, such as that provided by IPSec RFC4301 for IP flows and/or by an underlying sub-net using MACSec IEEE802.1AE-2018 for IP over Ethernet (Layer-2) flows." IP over MPLS changes to be reviewed . 1929aee4fba0f7f843ae1dc5476f20555a0a40d6 1929aee4fba0f7f843ae1dc5476f20555a0a40d6 draft-ietf-detnet-ip-over-mpls 6d1c378f6ab7bd6ae836d4ac295f0de5a2664c0064bd50ab47c1dde2a64665c8 ['dbba5d27f625b2298f88e8cf65fe9b3584fb8078028e7996f70d1ba2980b8375', '7562688d7a135b11e38770a6d49690faf2cb7a0f8c5fa58478c102540a5ec84c', '5024c49f483b8d46eb4017736cd7ced5b578f170328bf15ff1060aa0235be4b8', 'e30afecfc76617a262182c81ea5ad3d36ff6cb97f12269ce22b2831c27cb3ab3', 'fa6534a2fea10c93739f34a3a3ebc956aa92d44a1990ef9c3f8c57af2882f9cd', '9660729dcccf51d5b146b7b549f874e0feac220bda1c96d69e1fcfab2efbb95f', '6d1c378f6ab7bd6ae836d4ac295f0de5a2664c0064bd50ab47c1dde2a64665c8'] B "the primary considerations for the data plane is to maintain integrity of data and delivery of the associated detnet service traversing the detnet network. application flows can be protected through whatever means is provided by the underlying technology. for example, encryption may be used, such as that provided by ipsec rfc4301 for ip flows and/or by an underlying sub-net using macsec ieee802.1ae-2018 for ip over ethernet (layer-2) flows." {64: 1, 30: 1, 115: 1, 110: 1, 67: 1, 87: 1, 102: 1, 84: 1, 13: 1, 15: 1, 24: 1, 114: 1, 90: 1, 6: 3, 79: 3, 51: 2, 130: 3, 62: 5, 85: 6, 68: 5, 35: 4, 91: 2, 97: 3, 31: 2, 38: 3, 26: 2, 124: 4, 98: 3, 54: 3, 127: 4, 8: 3, 96: 3, 61: 4, 55: 4, 27: 3, 52: 2, 129: 4, 76: 7, 131: 6, 113: 4, 99: 3, 53: 2, 72: 3} {128: 1, 129: 1, 169: 1, 172: 1, 180: 1, 229: 1, 272: 1, 289: 1, 315: 1, 352: 1, 354: 1, 365: 1, 402: 1, 1: 10, 4: 3, 9: 6, 10: 4, 15: 3, 24: 3, 25: 5, 26: 6, 27: 2, 39: 6, 43: 4, 49: 3, 50: 2, 58: 4, 59: 3, 64: 3, 69: 5, 81: 6, 82: 4, 86: 2, 96: 3, 97: 2, 100: 7, 108: 4, 109: 5, 110: 5, 111: 3, 114: 4, 115: 5, 116: 3, 118: 7, 119: 6, 120: 4, 121: 5, 122: 4, 123: 3, 124: 5, 130: 4, 132: 5, 136: 3, 145: 5, 147: 3, 151: 2, 152: 2, 154: 4, 156: 2, 161: 4, 162: 4, 165: 4, 168: 5, 184: 6, 187: 6, 188: 5, 191: 4, 194: 5, 202: 6, 203: 7, 206: 3, 207: 4, 215: 3, 217: 4, 218: 9, 220: 3, 221: 3, 222: 6, 224: 4, 227: 5, 234: 6, 235: 3, 241: 3, 242: 3, 243: 5, 244: 2, 245: 5, 248: 2, 250: 4, 258: 12, 262: 5, 263: 6, 264: 4, 267: 5, 270: 3, 273: 6, 287: 4, 291: 4, 299: 5, 300: 3, 304: 3, 309: 4, 314: 3, 320: 5, 323: 5, 327: 5, 328: 4, 329: 3, 330: 11, 334: 3, 335: 3, 341: 5, 342: 6, 347: 5, 348: 5, 350: 8, 351: 3, 358: 5, 366: 3, 369: 2, 371: 7, 372: 4, 376: 3, 384: 4, 385: 3, 386: 4, 387: 3, 392: 4, 393: 5, 396: 6, 397: 8, 398: 7} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 36 "From a data plane perspective this document does not add or modify any header information." IP over MPLS changes to be reviewed . 1929aee4fba0f7f843ae1dc5476f20555a0a40d6 1929aee4fba0f7f843ae1dc5476f20555a0a40d6 draft-ietf-detnet-ip-over-mpls e30afecfc76617a262182c81ea5ad3d36ff6cb97f12269ce22b2831c27cb3ab3 ['dbba5d27f625b2298f88e8cf65fe9b3584fb8078028e7996f70d1ba2980b8375', '7562688d7a135b11e38770a6d49690faf2cb7a0f8c5fa58478c102540a5ec84c', '5024c49f483b8d46eb4017736cd7ced5b578f170328bf15ff1060aa0235be4b8', 'e30afecfc76617a262182c81ea5ad3d36ff6cb97f12269ce22b2831c27cb3ab3', 'fa6534a2fea10c93739f34a3a3ebc956aa92d44a1990ef9c3f8c57af2882f9cd', '9660729dcccf51d5b146b7b549f874e0feac220bda1c96d69e1fcfab2efbb95f', '6d1c378f6ab7bd6ae836d4ac295f0de5a2664c0064bd50ab47c1dde2a64665c8'] B "from a data plane perspective this document does not add or modify any header information." {64: 1, 30: 1, 115: 1, 110: 1, 67: 1, 87: 1, 102: 1, 84: 1, 13: 1, 15: 1, 24: 1, 114: 1, 90: 1, 6: 3, 79: 3, 51: 2, 130: 3, 62: 5, 85: 6, 68: 5, 35: 4, 91: 2, 97: 3, 31: 2, 38: 3, 26: 2, 124: 4, 98: 3, 54: 3, 127: 4, 8: 3, 96: 3, 61: 4, 55: 4, 27: 3, 52: 2, 129: 4, 76: 7, 131: 6, 113: 4, 99: 3, 53: 2, 72: 3} {128: 1, 129: 1, 169: 1, 172: 1, 180: 1, 229: 1, 272: 1, 289: 1, 315: 1, 352: 1, 354: 1, 365: 1, 402: 1, 1: 10, 4: 3, 9: 6, 10: 4, 15: 3, 24: 3, 25: 5, 26: 6, 27: 2, 39: 6, 43: 4, 49: 3, 50: 2, 58: 4, 59: 3, 64: 3, 69: 5, 81: 6, 82: 4, 86: 2, 96: 3, 97: 2, 100: 7, 108: 4, 109: 5, 110: 5, 111: 3, 114: 4, 115: 5, 116: 3, 118: 7, 119: 6, 120: 4, 121: 5, 122: 4, 123: 3, 124: 5, 130: 4, 132: 5, 136: 3, 145: 5, 147: 3, 151: 2, 152: 2, 154: 4, 156: 2, 161: 4, 162: 4, 165: 4, 168: 5, 184: 6, 187: 6, 188: 5, 191: 4, 194: 5, 202: 6, 203: 7, 206: 3, 207: 4, 215: 3, 217: 4, 218: 9, 220: 3, 221: 3, 222: 6, 224: 4, 227: 5, 234: 6, 235: 3, 241: 3, 242: 3, 243: 5, 244: 2, 245: 5, 248: 2, 250: 4, 258: 12, 262: 5, 263: 6, 264: 4, 267: 5, 270: 3, 273: 6, 287: 4, 291: 4, 299: 5, 300: 3, 304: 3, 309: 4, 314: 3, 320: 5, 323: 5, 327: 5, 328: 4, 329: 3, 330: 11, 334: 3, 335: 3, 341: 5, 342: 6, 347: 5, 348: 5, 350: 8, 351: 3, 358: 5, 366: 3, 369: 2, 371: 7, 372: 4, 376: 3, 384: 4, 385: 3, 386: 4, 387: 3, 392: 4, 393: 5, 396: 6, 397: 8, 398: 7} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 36 "At the management and control level DetNet flows are identified on a per-flow basis, which may provide controller plane attackers with additional information about the data flows (when compared to controller planes that do not include per-flow identification). This is an inherent property of DetNet which has security implications that should be considered when determining if DetNet is a suitable technology for any given use case." IP over MPLS changes to be reviewed . 1929aee4fba0f7f843ae1dc5476f20555a0a40d6 1929aee4fba0f7f843ae1dc5476f20555a0a40d6 draft-ietf-detnet-ip-over-mpls dbba5d27f625b2298f88e8cf65fe9b3584fb8078028e7996f70d1ba2980b8375 ['dbba5d27f625b2298f88e8cf65fe9b3584fb8078028e7996f70d1ba2980b8375', '7562688d7a135b11e38770a6d49690faf2cb7a0f8c5fa58478c102540a5ec84c', '5024c49f483b8d46eb4017736cd7ced5b578f170328bf15ff1060aa0235be4b8', 'e30afecfc76617a262182c81ea5ad3d36ff6cb97f12269ce22b2831c27cb3ab3', 'fa6534a2fea10c93739f34a3a3ebc956aa92d44a1990ef9c3f8c57af2882f9cd', '9660729dcccf51d5b146b7b549f874e0feac220bda1c96d69e1fcfab2efbb95f', '6d1c378f6ab7bd6ae836d4ac295f0de5a2664c0064bd50ab47c1dde2a64665c8'] B "at the management and control level detnet flows are identified on a per-flow basis, which may provide controller plane attackers with additional information about the data flows (when compared to controller planes that do not include per-flow identification). this is an inherent property of detnet which has security implications that should be considered when determining if detnet is a suitable technology for any given use case." {64: 1, 30: 1, 115: 1, 110: 1, 67: 1, 87: 1, 102: 1, 84: 1, 13: 1, 15: 1, 24: 1, 114: 1, 90: 1, 6: 3, 79: 3, 51: 2, 130: 3, 62: 5, 85: 6, 68: 5, 35: 4, 91: 2, 97: 3, 31: 2, 38: 3, 26: 2, 124: 4, 98: 3, 54: 3, 127: 4, 8: 3, 96: 3, 61: 4, 55: 4, 27: 3, 52: 2, 129: 4, 76: 7, 131: 6, 113: 4, 99: 3, 53: 2, 72: 3} {128: 1, 129: 1, 169: 1, 172: 1, 180: 1, 229: 1, 272: 1, 289: 1, 315: 1, 352: 1, 354: 1, 365: 1, 402: 1, 1: 10, 4: 3, 9: 6, 10: 4, 15: 3, 24: 3, 25: 5, 26: 6, 27: 2, 39: 6, 43: 4, 49: 3, 50: 2, 58: 4, 59: 3, 64: 3, 69: 5, 81: 6, 82: 4, 86: 2, 96: 3, 97: 2, 100: 7, 108: 4, 109: 5, 110: 5, 111: 3, 114: 4, 115: 5, 116: 3, 118: 7, 119: 6, 120: 4, 121: 5, 122: 4, 123: 3, 124: 5, 130: 4, 132: 5, 136: 3, 145: 5, 147: 3, 151: 2, 152: 2, 154: 4, 156: 2, 161: 4, 162: 4, 165: 4, 168: 5, 184: 6, 187: 6, 188: 5, 191: 4, 194: 5, 202: 6, 203: 7, 206: 3, 207: 4, 215: 3, 217: 4, 218: 9, 220: 3, 221: 3, 222: 6, 224: 4, 227: 5, 234: 6, 235: 3, 241: 3, 242: 3, 243: 5, 244: 2, 245: 5, 248: 2, 250: 4, 258: 12, 262: 5, 263: 6, 264: 4, 267: 5, 270: 3, 273: 6, 287: 4, 291: 4, 299: 5, 300: 3, 304: 3, 309: 4, 314: 3, 320: 5, 323: 5, 327: 5, 328: 4, 329: 3, 330: 11, 334: 3, 335: 3, 341: 5, 342: 6, 347: 5, 348: 5, 350: 8, 351: 3, 358: 5, 366: 3, 369: 2, 371: 7, 372: 4, 376: 3, 384: 4, 385: 3, 386: 4, 387: 3, 392: 4, 393: 5, 396: 6, 397: 8, 398: 7} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 36 "To provide uninterrupted availability of the DetNet service, provisions can be made against DOS attacks and delay attacks. To protect against DOS attacks, excess traffic due to malicious or malfunctioning devices can be prevented or mitigated, for example through the use of existing mechanism such as policing and shaping applied at the input of a DetNet domain. To prevent DetNet packets from being delayed by an entity external to a DetNet domain, DetNet technology definition can allow for the mitigation of Man-In-The- Middle attacks, for example through use of authentication and authorization of devices within the DetNet domain." IP over MPLS changes to be reviewed . 1929aee4fba0f7f843ae1dc5476f20555a0a40d6 1929aee4fba0f7f843ae1dc5476f20555a0a40d6 draft-ietf-detnet-ip-over-mpls 9660729dcccf51d5b146b7b549f874e0feac220bda1c96d69e1fcfab2efbb95f ['dbba5d27f625b2298f88e8cf65fe9b3584fb8078028e7996f70d1ba2980b8375', '7562688d7a135b11e38770a6d49690faf2cb7a0f8c5fa58478c102540a5ec84c', '5024c49f483b8d46eb4017736cd7ced5b578f170328bf15ff1060aa0235be4b8', 'e30afecfc76617a262182c81ea5ad3d36ff6cb97f12269ce22b2831c27cb3ab3', 'fa6534a2fea10c93739f34a3a3ebc956aa92d44a1990ef9c3f8c57af2882f9cd', '9660729dcccf51d5b146b7b549f874e0feac220bda1c96d69e1fcfab2efbb95f', '6d1c378f6ab7bd6ae836d4ac295f0de5a2664c0064bd50ab47c1dde2a64665c8'] B "to provide uninterrupted availability of the detnet service, provisions can be made against dos attacks and delay attacks. to protect against dos attacks, excess traffic due to malicious or malfunctioning devices can be prevented or mitigated, for example through the use of existing mechanism such as policing and shaping applied at the input of a detnet domain. to prevent detnet packets from being delayed by an entity external to a detnet domain, detnet technology definition can allow for the mitigation of man-in-the- middle attacks, for example through use of authentication and authorization of devices within the detnet domain." {64: 1, 30: 1, 115: 1, 110: 1, 67: 1, 87: 1, 102: 1, 84: 1, 13: 1, 15: 1, 24: 1, 114: 1, 90: 1, 6: 3, 79: 3, 51: 2, 130: 3, 62: 5, 85: 6, 68: 5, 35: 4, 91: 2, 97: 3, 31: 2, 38: 3, 26: 2, 124: 4, 98: 3, 54: 3, 127: 4, 8: 3, 96: 3, 61: 4, 55: 4, 27: 3, 52: 2, 129: 4, 76: 7, 131: 6, 113: 4, 99: 3, 53: 2, 72: 3} {128: 1, 129: 1, 169: 1, 172: 1, 180: 1, 229: 1, 272: 1, 289: 1, 315: 1, 352: 1, 354: 1, 365: 1, 402: 1, 1: 10, 4: 3, 9: 6, 10: 4, 15: 3, 24: 3, 25: 5, 26: 6, 27: 2, 39: 6, 43: 4, 49: 3, 50: 2, 58: 4, 59: 3, 64: 3, 69: 5, 81: 6, 82: 4, 86: 2, 96: 3, 97: 2, 100: 7, 108: 4, 109: 5, 110: 5, 111: 3, 114: 4, 115: 5, 116: 3, 118: 7, 119: 6, 120: 4, 121: 5, 122: 4, 123: 3, 124: 5, 130: 4, 132: 5, 136: 3, 145: 5, 147: 3, 151: 2, 152: 2, 154: 4, 156: 2, 161: 4, 162: 4, 165: 4, 168: 5, 184: 6, 187: 6, 188: 5, 191: 4, 194: 5, 202: 6, 203: 7, 206: 3, 207: 4, 215: 3, 217: 4, 218: 9, 220: 3, 221: 3, 222: 6, 224: 4, 227: 5, 234: 6, 235: 3, 241: 3, 242: 3, 243: 5, 244: 2, 245: 5, 248: 2, 250: 4, 258: 12, 262: 5, 263: 6, 264: 4, 267: 5, 270: 3, 273: 6, 287: 4, 291: 4, 299: 5, 300: 3, 304: 3, 309: 4, 314: 3, 320: 5, 323: 5, 327: 5, 328: 4, 329: 3, 330: 11, 334: 3, 335: 3, 341: 5, 342: 6, 347: 5, 348: 5, 350: 8, 351: 3, 358: 5, 366: 3, 369: 2, 371: 7, 372: 4, 376: 3, 384: 4, 385: 3, 386: 4, 387: 3, 392: 4, 393: 5, 396: 6, 397: 8, 398: 7} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 35 "The DetNet MPLS data plane representation is illustrated in dn_mpls_dp_approach. The service sub-layer includes a DetNet control word (d-CW) and a identifying service label (S-Label). The DetNet control word (d-CW) conforms to the Generic PW MPLS Control Word (PWMCW) defined in RFC4385." Some more cleanup for next submission . 5e7461cf218b43b022912df5912ba587d833025f 5e7461cf218b43b022912df5912ba587d833025f draft-ietf-detnet-mpls e81a40e65df6fd4dfca58d7731acc006b47b1feb272465210f00d12dfe6ea004 ['e81a40e65df6fd4dfca58d7731acc006b47b1feb272465210f00d12dfe6ea004', 'd19fc89182c5c2ffd2d5cc58c11cd3a5fa7c9ea57fefe987b2cdd0b624683805'] A "the detnet mpls data plane representation is illustrated in dn_mpls_dp_approach. the service sub-layer includes a detnet control word (d-cw) and a identifying service label (s-label). the detnet control word (d-cw) conforms to the generic pw mpls control word (pwmcw) defined in rfc4385." {} {} {} 35 "The DetNet MPLS data plane representation is illustrated in dn_mpls_dp_approach. The service sub-layer includes a DetNet control word (d-CW) and a identifying service label (S-Label). The DetNet control word (d-CW) conforms to the Generic PW MPLS Control Word (PWMCW) defined in RFC4385. An aggregation label (A-Label) is a special case of S-Label used for aggregation." Some more cleanup for next submission . 5e7461cf218b43b022912df5912ba587d833025f 5e7461cf218b43b022912df5912ba587d833025f draft-ietf-detnet-mpls d19fc89182c5c2ffd2d5cc58c11cd3a5fa7c9ea57fefe987b2cdd0b624683805 ['e81a40e65df6fd4dfca58d7731acc006b47b1feb272465210f00d12dfe6ea004', 'd19fc89182c5c2ffd2d5cc58c11cd3a5fa7c9ea57fefe987b2cdd0b624683805'] B "the detnet mpls data plane representation is illustrated in dn_mpls_dp_approach. the service sub-layer includes a detnet control word (d-cw) and a identifying service label (s-label). the detnet control word (d-cw) conforms to the generic pw mpls control word (pwmcw) defined in rfc4385. an aggregation label (a-label) is a special case of s-label used for aggregation." {} {} {} 35 "The S-Label value MUST be provisioned per app-flow via configuration, e.g., via the controller plane described in I-D.ietf-detnet-data- plane-framework. Note that S-Labels provide app-flow identification at the downstream DetNet service sub-layer receiver, not the sender. As such, S-Labels MUST be allocated by the entity that controls the service sub-layer receiving node's label space, and MAY be allocated from the platform label space RFC3031." Some more cleanup for next submission . 5e7461cf218b43b022912df5912ba587d833025f 5e7461cf218b43b022912df5912ba587d833025f draft-ietf-detnet-mpls f4f311534cfeb74815f47dc64bab65ff103c6376875917aa72f899a51518b566 ['f4f311534cfeb74815f47dc64bab65ff103c6376875917aa72f899a51518b566', 'c6dc9ca352c38237800b1e60e98bf795260dc878147358ea22472d996ef2cb2b'] A "the s-label value must be provisioned per app-flow via configuration, e.g., via the controller plane described in i-d.ietf-detnet-data- plane-framework. note that s-labels provide app-flow identification at the downstream detnet service sub-layer receiver, not the sender. as such, s-labels must be allocated by the entity that controls the service sub-layer receiving node's label space, and may be allocated from the platform label space rfc3031." {} {} {} 35 "The S-Label value MUST be provisioned per app-flow via configuration, e.g., via the controller plane described in I-D.ietf-detnet-data- plane-framework. Note that S-Labels provide app-flow identification at the downstream DetNet service sub-layer receiver, not the sender. As such, S-Labels MUST be allocated by the entity that controls the service sub-layer receiving node's label space, and MAY be allocated from the platform label space RFC3031. Because S-Labels are local to each node rather than being a global identifier within a domain, they must be advertised to their upstream DetNet service-aware peer nodes (e.g., a DetNet MPLS End System or a DetNet Relay or Edge Node and interpreted in the context of their received F-Label." Some more cleanup for next submission . 5e7461cf218b43b022912df5912ba587d833025f 5e7461cf218b43b022912df5912ba587d833025f draft-ietf-detnet-mpls c6dc9ca352c38237800b1e60e98bf795260dc878147358ea22472d996ef2cb2b ['f4f311534cfeb74815f47dc64bab65ff103c6376875917aa72f899a51518b566', 'c6dc9ca352c38237800b1e60e98bf795260dc878147358ea22472d996ef2cb2b'] B "the s-label value must be provisioned per app-flow via configuration, e.g., via the controller plane described in i-d.ietf-detnet-data- plane-framework. note that s-labels provide app-flow identification at the downstream detnet service sub-layer receiver, not the sender. as such, s-labels must be allocated by the entity that controls the service sub-layer receiving node's label space, and may be allocated from the platform label space rfc3031. because s-labels are local to each node rather than being a global identifier within a domain, they must be advertised to their upstream detnet service-aware peer nodes (e.g., a detnet mpls end system or a detnet relay or edge node and interpreted in the context of their received f-label." {} {} {} 35 "When sending a DetNet flow, Zero or more F-Labels MAY be added on top of an S-Label by the node pushing an S-Label. The F-Labels to be pushed when sending a particular app-flow MUST be provisioned per app-flow via configuration, e.g., via the controller plane discussed in I-D.ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework. To allow for the omission of F-Labels, an implementation SHOULD also allow an outgoing interface to be provisioned." Some more cleanup for next submission . 5e7461cf218b43b022912df5912ba587d833025f 5e7461cf218b43b022912df5912ba587d833025f draft-ietf-detnet-mpls 12a9e0431fa866e9d2e10c4b475db6a02316f08be94a04bd1bdf36d8ebab3e28 ['12a9e0431fa866e9d2e10c4b475db6a02316f08be94a04bd1bdf36d8ebab3e28', '2f823e24b4100f16f9512657b8dd9bfaa8a10665e129568218c4b861255365c9'] A "when sending a detnet flow, zero or more f-labels may be added on top of an s-label by the node pushing an s-label. the f-labels to be pushed when sending a particular app-flow must be provisioned per app-flow via configuration, e.g., via the controller plane discussed in i-d.ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework. to allow for the omission of f-labels, an implementation should also allow an outgoing interface to be provisioned." {38: 1} {57: 1} {57, 18} 35 "When sending a DetNet flow, Zero or more F-Labels MAY be added on top of an S-Label by the node pushing an S-Label. The F-Labels to be pushed when sending a particular app-flow MUST be provisioned per app-flow via configuration, e.g., via the controller plane discussed in I-D.ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework. F-Labels can also provide context for an S-Label. To allow for the omission of F-Labels, an implementation SHOULD also allow an outgoing interface to be provisioned." Some more cleanup for next submission . 5e7461cf218b43b022912df5912ba587d833025f 5e7461cf218b43b022912df5912ba587d833025f draft-ietf-detnet-mpls 2f823e24b4100f16f9512657b8dd9bfaa8a10665e129568218c4b861255365c9 ['12a9e0431fa866e9d2e10c4b475db6a02316f08be94a04bd1bdf36d8ebab3e28', '2f823e24b4100f16f9512657b8dd9bfaa8a10665e129568218c4b861255365c9'] B "when sending a detnet flow, zero or more f-labels may be added on top of an s-label by the node pushing an s-label. the f-labels to be pushed when sending a particular app-flow must be provisioned per app-flow via configuration, e.g., via the controller plane discussed in i-d.ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework. f-labels can also provide context for an s-label. to allow for the omission of f-labels, an implementation should also allow an outgoing interface to be provisioned." {38: 1} {57: 1} {57, 18} 35 "DetNet flows forwarded via MPLS can leverage MPLS-TE's existing support for hierarchical LSPs (H-LSPs), see RFC4206. H-LSPs are typically used to aggregate control and resources, they may also be used to provide OAM or protection for the aggregated LSPs. Arbitrary levels of aggregation naturally falls out of the definition for hierarchy and the MPLS label stack RFC3032. DetNet nodes which support aggregation (LSP hierarchy) map one or more LSPs (labels) into and from an H-LSP. Both carried LSPs and H-LSPs may or may not use the TC field, i.e., L-LSPs or E-LSPs. Such nodes will need to ensure that individual LSPs and H-LSPs receive the traffic treatement required to ensure the required DetNet service is preserved." Some more cleanup for next submission . 5e7461cf218b43b022912df5912ba587d833025f 5e7461cf218b43b022912df5912ba587d833025f draft-ietf-detnet-mpls 815c465678ffee373129a89e02f702fc577a7383644437fddfba89f7f7e19d64 ['815c465678ffee373129a89e02f702fc577a7383644437fddfba89f7f7e19d64', '983d649ff42bfa47769c86c09f9048affd7cfac6c278d860f1071cdda1c15646'] A "detnet flows forwarded via mpls can leverage mpls-te's existing support for hierarchical lsps (h-lsps), see rfc4206. h-lsps are typically used to aggregate control and resources, they may also be used to provide oam or protection for the aggregated lsps. arbitrary levels of aggregation naturally falls out of the definition for hierarchy and the mpls label stack rfc3032. detnet nodes which support aggregation (lsp hierarchy) map one or more lsps (labels) into and from an h-lsp. both carried lsps and h-lsps may or may not use the tc field, i.e., l-lsps or e-lsps. such nodes will need to ensure that individual lsps and h-lsps receive the traffic treatement required to ensure the required detnet service is preserved." {27: 1, 114: 1, 26: 2} {307: 1, 326: 1, 306: 2} {306, 307, 204, 326} 35 "DetNet flows forwarded via MPLS can leverage MPLS-TE's existing support for hierarchical LSPs (H-LSPs), see RFC4206. H-LSPs are typically used to aggregate control and resources, they may also be used to provide OAM or protection for the aggregated LSPs. Arbitrary levels of aggregation naturally falls out of the definition for hierarchy and the MPLS label stack RFC3032. DetNet nodes which support aggregation (LSP hierarchy) map one or more LSPs (labels) into and from an H-LSP. Both carried LSPs and H-LSPs may or may not use the TC field, i.e., L-LSPs or E-LSPs. Such nodes will need to ensure that individual LSPs and H-LSPs receive the traffic treatment required to ensure the required DetNet service is preserved." Some more cleanup for next submission . 5e7461cf218b43b022912df5912ba587d833025f 5e7461cf218b43b022912df5912ba587d833025f draft-ietf-detnet-mpls 983d649ff42bfa47769c86c09f9048affd7cfac6c278d860f1071cdda1c15646 ['815c465678ffee373129a89e02f702fc577a7383644437fddfba89f7f7e19d64', '983d649ff42bfa47769c86c09f9048affd7cfac6c278d860f1071cdda1c15646'] B "detnet flows forwarded via mpls can leverage mpls-te's existing support for hierarchical lsps (h-lsps), see rfc4206. h-lsps are typically used to aggregate control and resources, they may also be used to provide oam or protection for the aggregated lsps. arbitrary levels of aggregation naturally falls out of the definition for hierarchy and the mpls label stack rfc3032. detnet nodes which support aggregation (lsp hierarchy) map one or more lsps (labels) into and from an h-lsp. both carried lsps and h-lsps may or may not use the tc field, i.e., l-lsps or e-lsps. such nodes will need to ensure that individual lsps and h-lsps receive the traffic treatment required to ensure the required detnet service is preserved." {27: 1, 114: 1, 26: 2} {307: 1, 326: 1, 306: 2} {306, 307, 204, 326} 35 "As in the previous section, nodes supporting this type of aggregetation will need to ensure that individual and aggregated flows receive the traffic treatement required to ensure the required DetNet service is preserved. Also, it is the controller plane's responsibility to to ensure that the service required on the aggregate flow are properly provisioned." Some more cleanup for next submission . 5e7461cf218b43b022912df5912ba587d833025f 5e7461cf218b43b022912df5912ba587d833025f draft-ietf-detnet-mpls 09515ad60af35357e40873e0c49f1790730b0faa6a251814275eabc8883f58eb ['3e2590a5211de13c242382f078170e00e1e0cbc1547061da76b076c4612786bb', '09515ad60af35357e40873e0c49f1790730b0faa6a251814275eabc8883f58eb'] A "as in the previous section, nodes supporting this type of aggregetation will need to ensure that individual and aggregated flows receive the traffic treatement required to ensure the required detnet service is preserved. also, it is the controller plane's responsibility to to ensure that the service required on the aggregate flow are properly provisioned." {27: 1, 113: 1, 26: 2, 38: 2} {266: 1, 95: 1, 265: 2, 205: 2} {265, 266, 205, 94, 95} 35 "As in the previous section, nodes supporting this type of aggregation will need to ensure that individual and aggregated flows receive the traffic treatment required to ensure the required DetNet service is preserved. Also, it is the controller plane's responsibility to to ensure that the service required on the aggregate flow are properly provisioned." Some more cleanup for next submission . 5e7461cf218b43b022912df5912ba587d833025f 5e7461cf218b43b022912df5912ba587d833025f draft-ietf-detnet-mpls 3e2590a5211de13c242382f078170e00e1e0cbc1547061da76b076c4612786bb ['3e2590a5211de13c242382f078170e00e1e0cbc1547061da76b076c4612786bb', '09515ad60af35357e40873e0c49f1790730b0faa6a251814275eabc8883f58eb'] B "as in the previous section, nodes supporting this type of aggregation will need to ensure that individual and aggregated flows receive the traffic treatment required to ensure the required detnet service is preserved. also, it is the controller plane's responsibility to to ensure that the service required on the aggregate flow are properly provisioned." {27: 1, 113: 1, 26: 2, 38: 2} {266: 1, 95: 1, 265: 2, 205: 2} {265, 266, 205, 94, 95} 35 "A DetNet Relay node operates in the DetNet forwarding sub-layer . For DetNet using MPLS this processing is performed on the F-Label. This processing is done within an extended forwarder function. Whether an ingress DetNet member flow receives DetNet specific processing depends on how the forwarding is programmed. Some relay nodes may be DetNet service aware, while others may be unmodified LSRs that only understand how to swicth MPLS-TE LSPs." Some more cleanup for next submission . 5e7461cf218b43b022912df5912ba587d833025f 5e7461cf218b43b022912df5912ba587d833025f draft-ietf-detnet-mpls 2a45ba122e30215dc8b0118f88f92e202fd9124cfb12a39787feba55f312037c ['200fc77171ce0224e61968428de9b5cf36ae83b94a6c11a8e8d67ae042f2922e', '2a45ba122e30215dc8b0118f88f92e202fd9124cfb12a39787feba55f312037c'] A "a detnet relay node operates in the detnet forwarding sub-layer . for detnet using mpls this processing is performed on the f-label. this processing is done within an extended forwarder function. whether an ingress detnet member flow receives detnet specific processing depends on how the forwarding is programmed. some relay nodes may be detnet service aware, while others may be unmodified lsrs that only understand how to swicth mpls-te lsps." {99: 1, 6: 3, 79: 3, 90: 4, 51: 4, 130: 3, 62: 6, 85: 6, 68: 5, 110: 4, 91: 6, 114: 4, 97: 4, 31: 4, 13: 4, 67: 4, 38: 5, 26: 4, 124: 4, 98: 3, 54: 3, 127: 4, 8: 3, 96: 4, 64: 3, 30: 5, 61: 6, 55: 4, 27: 5, 15: 4, 52: 3, 129: 4, 115: 4, 84: 4, 76: 7, 87: 4, 131: 6, 102: 4, 113: 6, 36: 4, 24: 3, 53: 2, 72: 5} {334: 1, 1: 10, 4: 3, 9: 6, 10: 4, 15: 4, 24: 3, 25: 6, 26: 6, 27: 4, 39: 6, 49: 7, 50: 6, 58: 6, 59: 3, 64: 4, 69: 5, 81: 7, 82: 5, 86: 4, 96: 5, 97: 4, 100: 8, 108: 4, 109: 5, 110: 5, 111: 3, 114: 4, 115: 5, 116: 4, 118: 7, 119: 6, 120: 4, 121: 5, 122: 5, 123: 4, 124: 5, 128: 5, 129: 5, 130: 6, 132: 5, 136: 3, 145: 5, 147: 5, 151: 5, 152: 5, 154: 4, 156: 3, 161: 4, 162: 4, 165: 4, 168: 5, 169: 4, 172: 4, 180: 5, 184: 6, 187: 6, 188: 5, 191: 4, 194: 5, 202: 6, 203: 7, 206: 3, 207: 4, 215: 3, 217: 4, 218: 9, 220: 3, 221: 3, 222: 6, 224: 4, 227: 6, 229: 4, 234: 6, 235: 3, 241: 3, 242: 3, 243: 5, 244: 5, 245: 5, 248: 5, 250: 5, 258: 12, 262: 5, 263: 6, 264: 4, 267: 5, 270: 4, 272: 4, 273: 6, 287: 4, 289: 4, 291: 6, 299: 6, 300: 4, 304: 4, 309: 4, 314: 3, 315: 4, 320: 5, 323: 5, 327: 5, 328: 4, 329: 3, 330: 11, 335: 4, 341: 6, 342: 7, 347: 6, 348: 6, 350: 8, 351: 6, 352: 4, 353: 4, 354: 3, 358: 5, 365: 4, 366: 3, 369: 2, 371: 8, 372: 6, 376: 3, 384: 6, 385: 5, 386: 4, 387: 4, 392: 4, 393: 5, 396: 7, 397: 8, 398: 7, 402: 4} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 35 "A DetNet Relay node operates in the DetNet forwarding sub-layer . For DetNet using MPLS this processing is performed on the F-Label. This processing is done within an extended forwarder function. Whether an ingress DetNet member flow receives DetNet specific processing depends on how the forwarding is programmed. Some relay nodes may be DetNet service aware, while others may be unmodified LSRs that only understand how to switch MPLS-TE LSPs." Some more cleanup for next submission . 5e7461cf218b43b022912df5912ba587d833025f 5e7461cf218b43b022912df5912ba587d833025f draft-ietf-detnet-mpls 200fc77171ce0224e61968428de9b5cf36ae83b94a6c11a8e8d67ae042f2922e ['200fc77171ce0224e61968428de9b5cf36ae83b94a6c11a8e8d67ae042f2922e', '2a45ba122e30215dc8b0118f88f92e202fd9124cfb12a39787feba55f312037c'] B "a detnet relay node operates in the detnet forwarding sub-layer . for detnet using mpls this processing is performed on the f-label. this processing is done within an extended forwarder function. whether an ingress detnet member flow receives detnet specific processing depends on how the forwarding is programmed. some relay nodes may be detnet service aware, while others may be unmodified lsrs that only understand how to switch mpls-te lsps." {99: 1, 6: 3, 79: 3, 90: 4, 51: 4, 130: 3, 62: 6, 85: 6, 68: 5, 110: 4, 91: 6, 114: 4, 97: 4, 31: 4, 13: 4, 67: 4, 38: 5, 26: 4, 124: 4, 98: 3, 54: 3, 127: 4, 8: 3, 96: 4, 64: 3, 30: 5, 61: 6, 55: 4, 27: 5, 15: 4, 52: 3, 129: 4, 115: 4, 84: 4, 76: 7, 87: 4, 131: 6, 102: 4, 113: 6, 36: 4, 24: 3, 53: 2, 72: 5} {334: 1, 1: 10, 4: 3, 9: 6, 10: 4, 15: 4, 24: 3, 25: 6, 26: 6, 27: 4, 39: 6, 49: 7, 50: 6, 58: 6, 59: 3, 64: 4, 69: 5, 81: 7, 82: 5, 86: 4, 96: 5, 97: 4, 100: 8, 108: 4, 109: 5, 110: 5, 111: 3, 114: 4, 115: 5, 116: 4, 118: 7, 119: 6, 120: 4, 121: 5, 122: 5, 123: 4, 124: 5, 128: 5, 129: 5, 130: 6, 132: 5, 136: 3, 145: 5, 147: 5, 151: 5, 152: 5, 154: 4, 156: 3, 161: 4, 162: 4, 165: 4, 168: 5, 169: 4, 172: 4, 180: 5, 184: 6, 187: 6, 188: 5, 191: 4, 194: 5, 202: 6, 203: 7, 206: 3, 207: 4, 215: 3, 217: 4, 218: 9, 220: 3, 221: 3, 222: 6, 224: 4, 227: 6, 229: 4, 234: 6, 235: 3, 241: 3, 242: 3, 243: 5, 244: 5, 245: 5, 248: 5, 250: 5, 258: 12, 262: 5, 263: 6, 264: 4, 267: 5, 270: 4, 272: 4, 273: 6, 287: 4, 289: 4, 291: 6, 299: 6, 300: 4, 304: 4, 309: 4, 314: 3, 315: 4, 320: 5, 323: 5, 327: 5, 328: 4, 329: 3, 330: 11, 335: 4, 341: 6, 342: 7, 347: 6, 348: 6, 350: 8, 351: 6, 352: 4, 353: 4, 354: 3, 358: 5, 365: 4, 366: 3, 369: 2, 371: 8, 372: 6, 376: 3, 384: 6, 385: 5, 386: 4, 387: 4, 392: 4, 393: 5, 396: 7, 397: 8, 398: 7, 402: 4} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 35 "This section covers MPLS data plane specific control plane considerations." Some more cleanup for next submission . 5e7461cf218b43b022912df5912ba587d833025f 5e7461cf218b43b022912df5912ba587d833025f draft-ietf-detnet-mpls 2446cb21b9c834ba9f3bccd4c55ee7d0ead47e11e955b82d3467e4c6087127f6 ['2446cb21b9c834ba9f3bccd4c55ee7d0ead47e11e955b82d3467e4c6087127f6', '61ea2f83dde7ec8db5d3a78aaaec6ca7e527ef0610485ba50f183a5f26186a91', 'e2153b2e4b820623b01650845088c69eff7527fe2fc9d80ea69dd7a3f222b46b', 'af83d948c4a6447a1db32ef7f725432e0e303bbb59a5d0b09f4aa1826a8cdbcd'] A "this section covers mpls data plane specific control plane considerations." {31: 1, 8: 2, 6: 3} {362: 1, 251: 1, 340: 1, 144: 4, 177: 2, 54: 3, 55: 2} {362, 48, 144, 177, 340, 54, 55, 251} 35 "S-Labels are expected to be allocated in the same manner as any other service labels. S-Labels uniquely identify a particular DetNet flow, and are local to the node on which the label is allocated. In the DetNet service sub-layer the explicit route consists of the set of Relay Nodes that the DetNet flow must traverse. S-Labels can be used to identify the DetNet flow that a packet belongs to as it traverses a particular node in a DetNet domain. Because S-Labels are local to each node rather than being a global identifier within a domain, they must be advertised to their upstream DetNet service-aware peer nodes (e.g., a DetNet MPLS End System or a DetNet Relay or Edge Node and interpreted in the context of their received F-Label." Some more cleanup for next submission . 5e7461cf218b43b022912df5912ba587d833025f 5e7461cf218b43b022912df5912ba587d833025f draft-ietf-detnet-mpls e2153b2e4b820623b01650845088c69eff7527fe2fc9d80ea69dd7a3f222b46b ['2446cb21b9c834ba9f3bccd4c55ee7d0ead47e11e955b82d3467e4c6087127f6', '61ea2f83dde7ec8db5d3a78aaaec6ca7e527ef0610485ba50f183a5f26186a91', 'e2153b2e4b820623b01650845088c69eff7527fe2fc9d80ea69dd7a3f222b46b', 'af83d948c4a6447a1db32ef7f725432e0e303bbb59a5d0b09f4aa1826a8cdbcd'] A "s-labels are expected to be allocated in the same manner as any other service labels. s-labels uniquely identify a particular detnet flow, and are local to the node on which the label is allocated. in the detnet service sub-layer the explicit route consists of the set of relay nodes that the detnet flow must traverse. s-labels can be used to identify the detnet flow that a packet belongs to as it traverses a particular node in a detnet domain. because s-labels are local to each node rather than being a global identifier within a domain, they must be advertised to their upstream detnet service-aware peer nodes (e.g., a detnet mpls end system or a detnet relay or edge node and interpreted in the context of their received f-label." {31: 1, 8: 2, 6: 3} {362: 1, 251: 1, 340: 1, 144: 4, 177: 2, 54: 3, 55: 2} {362, 48, 144, 177, 340, 54, 55, 251} 35 "As discussed in sec_dt_dp, the forwarding sub-layer uses one or more F-Labels to forward DetNet packets between DetNet service-aware nodes along explicitly defined routes at the DetNet forwarding sub-layer, which in the context of this document is MPLS. F-Labels can also provide context for an S-Label. In the DetNet Forwarding (MPLS) sub- layer the explicit route consists of the set of DetNet nodes which are LSRs, links, and possibly link bundle members and queues that the DetNet packets flow must traverse between nodes in the DetNet service sub-layer (i.e. between a specific Edge Node and the next hop Relay Node, between specific Relay Nodes, and between a specific Relay node and the egress Edge Node. Resource allocation corresponding to the set of Services supported over the forwarding sub-layer, which may or may not include aggregation, is required at this sub-layer. Explicit routes are used to ensure that packets are routed through the resources that have been reserved for them, and hence provide the DetNet application with the required service. Multiple F-Labels may be pushed after an S-Label and there is no requirement for all F-Labels to be controlled via the same controller mechanisms. For example in EVPN, some labels are distributed using BGP while others are distributed using LDP or RSVP." Some more cleanup for next submission . 5e7461cf218b43b022912df5912ba587d833025f 5e7461cf218b43b022912df5912ba587d833025f draft-ietf-detnet-mpls af83d948c4a6447a1db32ef7f725432e0e303bbb59a5d0b09f4aa1826a8cdbcd ['2446cb21b9c834ba9f3bccd4c55ee7d0ead47e11e955b82d3467e4c6087127f6', '61ea2f83dde7ec8db5d3a78aaaec6ca7e527ef0610485ba50f183a5f26186a91', 'e2153b2e4b820623b01650845088c69eff7527fe2fc9d80ea69dd7a3f222b46b', 'af83d948c4a6447a1db32ef7f725432e0e303bbb59a5d0b09f4aa1826a8cdbcd'] A "as discussed in sec_dt_dp, the forwarding sub-layer uses one or more f-labels to forward detnet packets between detnet service-aware nodes along explicitly defined routes at the detnet forwarding sub-layer, which in the context of this document is mpls. f-labels can also provide context for an s-label. in the detnet forwarding (mpls) sub- layer the explicit route consists of the set of detnet nodes which are lsrs, links, and possibly link bundle members and queues that the detnet packets flow must traverse between nodes in the detnet service sub-layer (i.e. between a specific edge node and the next hop relay node, between specific relay nodes, and between a specific relay node and the egress edge node. resource allocation corresponding to the set of services supported over the forwarding sub-layer, which may or may not include aggregation, is required at this sub-layer. explicit routes are used to ensure that packets are routed through the resources that have been reserved for them, and hence provide the detnet application with the required service. multiple f-labels may be pushed after an s-label and there is no requirement for all f-labels to be controlled via the same controller mechanisms. for example in evpn, some labels are distributed using bgp while others are distributed using ldp or rsvp." {31: 1, 8: 2, 6: 3} {362: 1, 251: 1, 340: 1, 144: 4, 177: 2, 54: 3, 55: 2} {362, 48, 144, 177, 340, 54, 55, 251} 35 "Whether configuring, calculating and instantiating these routes is a single-stage or multi-stage process, or in a centralized or distributed manner, is out of scope of this document." Some more cleanup for next submission . 5e7461cf218b43b022912df5912ba587d833025f 5e7461cf218b43b022912df5912ba587d833025f draft-ietf-detnet-mpls 61ea2f83dde7ec8db5d3a78aaaec6ca7e527ef0610485ba50f183a5f26186a91 ['2446cb21b9c834ba9f3bccd4c55ee7d0ead47e11e955b82d3467e4c6087127f6', '61ea2f83dde7ec8db5d3a78aaaec6ca7e527ef0610485ba50f183a5f26186a91', 'e2153b2e4b820623b01650845088c69eff7527fe2fc9d80ea69dd7a3f222b46b', 'af83d948c4a6447a1db32ef7f725432e0e303bbb59a5d0b09f4aa1826a8cdbcd'] A "whether configuring, calculating and instantiating these routes is a single-stage or multi-stage process, or in a centralized or distributed manner, is out of scope of this document." {31: 1, 8: 2, 6: 3} {362: 1, 251: 1, 340: 1, 144: 4, 177: 2, 54: 3, 55: 2} {362, 48, 144, 177, 340, 54, 55, 251} 33 "These requirements are satisfied by the DetNet over MPLS Encapsulation described in I-D.ietf-detnet-mpls." Based on 06.24 discussions . Also some editorial clean up done . b6b19cc971008a58640a284b24d40e3993c1c42e b6b19cc971008a58640a284b24d40e3993c1c42e draft-ietf-detnet-mpls-over-udp-ip f38bf1c7c702044a92ba0a6f2b986227176b9f1331a2aec0f224f089ddb64f0d ['f38bf1c7c702044a92ba0a6f2b986227176b9f1331a2aec0f224f089ddb64f0d'] A "these requirements are satisfied by the detnet over mpls encapsulation described in i-d.ietf-detnet-mpls." {} {} {} 33 Control Word. Based on 06.24 discussions . Also some editorial clean up done . b6b19cc971008a58640a284b24d40e3993c1c42e b6b19cc971008a58640a284b24d40e3993c1c42e draft-ietf-detnet-mpls-over-udp-ip 0af69069e9963489a014eb853d2a6ecda9ae7da34113cf3389c1167163e82dcf ['b3713da5dc7b1531fd348079a30e2f5ac724e78c334f13dcd3da81aefb4a647d', '4dd46522781e90832ed10121ae247cda1e85f4852404007404c6aca57ef40f34', '2a6155467d7734762edcbb115219fa2034b5155fbeebef9e57c2926f910375de', '1507524e19dbc5cd9e5814a4311ddc473dfc60d77d76c658cb6bc7d196bfbc9a', '0af69069e9963489a014eb853d2a6ecda9ae7da34113cf3389c1167163e82dcf'] A control word. {38: 1, 52: 1, 53: 1, 68: 1, 130: 2, 79: 2, 51: 2, 112: 2, 55: 2, 64: 2, 62: 3, 37: 2, 69: 2, 67: 2, 25: 2, 80: 2, 127: 3, 33: 2, 91: 2} {19: 1, 321: 1, 322: 1, 279: 1, 0: 2, 389: 2, 390: 2, 135: 2, 142: 2, 14: 2, 400: 3, 17: 2, 399: 3, 149: 2, 406: 2, 280: 2, 281: 2, 294: 2, 296: 2, 45: 3, 308: 2, 56: 2, 185: 2, 192: 2, 66: 2, 196: 4, 197: 3, 324: 2, 77: 2, 78: 2, 337: 4, 216: 2, 380: 2, 255: 2} {0, 389, 390, 135, 142, 14, 400, 17, 399, 19, 149, 406, 279, 280, 281, 278, 294, 296, 45, 308, 56, 185, 192, 321, 322, 66, 196, 197, 324, 77, 78, 337, 216, 380, 255} 33 "A Detnet ""forwarding"" label that identifies the LSP used to forward a DetNet flow across an MPLS PSN, e.g., a hop-by-hop label used between label switching routers (LSR)." Based on 06.24 discussions . Also some editorial clean up done . b6b19cc971008a58640a284b24d40e3993c1c42e b6b19cc971008a58640a284b24d40e3993c1c42e draft-ietf-detnet-mpls-over-udp-ip 2a6155467d7734762edcbb115219fa2034b5155fbeebef9e57c2926f910375de ['b3713da5dc7b1531fd348079a30e2f5ac724e78c334f13dcd3da81aefb4a647d', '4dd46522781e90832ed10121ae247cda1e85f4852404007404c6aca57ef40f34', '2a6155467d7734762edcbb115219fa2034b5155fbeebef9e57c2926f910375de', '1507524e19dbc5cd9e5814a4311ddc473dfc60d77d76c658cb6bc7d196bfbc9a', '0af69069e9963489a014eb853d2a6ecda9ae7da34113cf3389c1167163e82dcf'] A "a detnet ""forwarding"" label that identifies the lsp used to forward a detnet flow across an mpls psn, e.g., a hop-by-hop label used between label switching routers (lsr)." {38: 1, 52: 1, 53: 1, 68: 1, 130: 2, 79: 2, 51: 2, 112: 2, 55: 2, 64: 2, 62: 3, 37: 2, 69: 2, 67: 2, 25: 2, 80: 2, 127: 3, 33: 2, 91: 2} {19: 1, 321: 1, 322: 1, 279: 1, 0: 2, 389: 2, 390: 2, 135: 2, 142: 2, 14: 2, 400: 3, 17: 2, 399: 3, 149: 2, 406: 2, 280: 2, 281: 2, 294: 2, 296: 2, 45: 3, 308: 2, 56: 2, 185: 2, 192: 2, 66: 2, 196: 4, 197: 3, 324: 2, 77: 2, 78: 2, 337: 4, 216: 2, 380: 2, 255: 2} {0, 389, 390, 135, 142, 14, 400, 17, 399, 19, 149, 406, 279, 280, 281, 278, 294, 296, 45, 308, 56, 185, 192, 321, 322, 66, 196, 197, 324, 77, 78, 337, 216, 380, 255} 33 Label Switching Router. Based on 06.24 discussions . Also some editorial clean up done . b6b19cc971008a58640a284b24d40e3993c1c42e b6b19cc971008a58640a284b24d40e3993c1c42e draft-ietf-detnet-mpls-over-udp-ip b3713da5dc7b1531fd348079a30e2f5ac724e78c334f13dcd3da81aefb4a647d ['b3713da5dc7b1531fd348079a30e2f5ac724e78c334f13dcd3da81aefb4a647d', '4dd46522781e90832ed10121ae247cda1e85f4852404007404c6aca57ef40f34', '2a6155467d7734762edcbb115219fa2034b5155fbeebef9e57c2926f910375de', '1507524e19dbc5cd9e5814a4311ddc473dfc60d77d76c658cb6bc7d196bfbc9a', '0af69069e9963489a014eb853d2a6ecda9ae7da34113cf3389c1167163e82dcf'] A label switching router. {38: 1, 52: 1, 53: 1, 68: 1, 130: 2, 79: 2, 51: 2, 112: 2, 55: 2, 64: 2, 62: 3, 37: 2, 69: 2, 67: 2, 25: 2, 80: 2, 127: 3, 33: 2, 91: 2} {19: 1, 321: 1, 322: 1, 279: 1, 0: 2, 389: 2, 390: 2, 135: 2, 142: 2, 14: 2, 400: 3, 17: 2, 399: 3, 149: 2, 406: 2, 280: 2, 281: 2, 294: 2, 296: 2, 45: 3, 308: 2, 56: 2, 185: 2, 192: 2, 66: 2, 196: 4, 197: 3, 324: 2, 77: 2, 78: 2, 337: 4, 216: 2, 380: 2, 255: 2} {0, 389, 390, 135, 142, 14, 400, 17, 399, 19, 149, 406, 279, 280, 281, 278, 294, 296, 45, 308, 56, 185, 192, 321, 322, 66, 196, 197, 324, 77, 78, 337, 216, 380, 255} 33 "A special case of an S-Label, whose properties are known only at the aggregation and deaggregation end-points." Based on 06.24 discussions . Also some editorial clean up done . b6b19cc971008a58640a284b24d40e3993c1c42e b6b19cc971008a58640a284b24d40e3993c1c42e draft-ietf-detnet-mpls-over-udp-ip 1507524e19dbc5cd9e5814a4311ddc473dfc60d77d76c658cb6bc7d196bfbc9a ['b3713da5dc7b1531fd348079a30e2f5ac724e78c334f13dcd3da81aefb4a647d', '4dd46522781e90832ed10121ae247cda1e85f4852404007404c6aca57ef40f34', '2a6155467d7734762edcbb115219fa2034b5155fbeebef9e57c2926f910375de', '1507524e19dbc5cd9e5814a4311ddc473dfc60d77d76c658cb6bc7d196bfbc9a', '0af69069e9963489a014eb853d2a6ecda9ae7da34113cf3389c1167163e82dcf'] B "a special case of an s-label, whose properties are known only at the aggregation and deaggregation end-points." {38: 1, 52: 1, 53: 1, 68: 1, 130: 2, 79: 2, 51: 2, 112: 2, 55: 2, 64: 2, 62: 3, 37: 2, 69: 2, 67: 2, 25: 2, 80: 2, 127: 3, 33: 2, 91: 2} {19: 1, 321: 1, 322: 1, 279: 1, 0: 2, 389: 2, 390: 2, 135: 2, 142: 2, 14: 2, 400: 3, 17: 2, 399: 3, 149: 2, 406: 2, 280: 2, 281: 2, 294: 2, 296: 2, 45: 3, 308: 2, 56: 2, 185: 2, 192: 2, 66: 2, 196: 4, 197: 3, 324: 2, 77: 2, 78: 2, 337: 4, 216: 2, 380: 2, 255: 2} {0, 389, 390, 135, 142, 14, 400, 17, 399, 19, 149, 406, 279, 280, 281, 278, 294, 296, 45, 308, 56, 185, 192, 321, 322, 66, 196, 197, 324, 77, 78, 337, 216, 380, 255} 33 "A Detnet ""forwarding"" label that identifies the LSP used to forward a DetNet flow across an MPLS PSN, e.g., a hop-by-hop label used between label switching routers." Based on 06.24 discussions . Also some editorial clean up done . b6b19cc971008a58640a284b24d40e3993c1c42e b6b19cc971008a58640a284b24d40e3993c1c42e draft-ietf-detnet-mpls-over-udp-ip 4dd46522781e90832ed10121ae247cda1e85f4852404007404c6aca57ef40f34 ['b3713da5dc7b1531fd348079a30e2f5ac724e78c334f13dcd3da81aefb4a647d', '4dd46522781e90832ed10121ae247cda1e85f4852404007404c6aca57ef40f34', '2a6155467d7734762edcbb115219fa2034b5155fbeebef9e57c2926f910375de', '1507524e19dbc5cd9e5814a4311ddc473dfc60d77d76c658cb6bc7d196bfbc9a', '0af69069e9963489a014eb853d2a6ecda9ae7da34113cf3389c1167163e82dcf'] B "a detnet ""forwarding"" label that identifies the lsp used to forward a detnet flow across an mpls psn, e.g., a hop-by-hop label used between label switching routers." {38: 1, 52: 1, 53: 1, 68: 1, 130: 2, 79: 2, 51: 2, 112: 2, 55: 2, 64: 2, 62: 3, 37: 2, 69: 2, 67: 2, 25: 2, 80: 2, 127: 3, 33: 2, 91: 2} {19: 1, 321: 1, 322: 1, 279: 1, 0: 2, 389: 2, 390: 2, 135: 2, 142: 2, 14: 2, 400: 3, 17: 2, 399: 3, 149: 2, 406: 2, 280: 2, 281: 2, 294: 2, 296: 2, 45: 3, 308: 2, 56: 2, 185: 2, 192: 2, 66: 2, 196: 4, 197: 3, 324: 2, 77: 2, 78: 2, 337: 4, 216: 2, 380: 2, 255: 2} {0, 389, 390, 135, 142, 14, 400, 17, 399, 19, 149, 406, 279, 280, 281, 278, 294, 296, 45, 308, 56, 185, 192, 321, 322, 66, 196, 197, 324, 77, 78, 337, 216, 380, 255} 33 Packet Replication, Elimination and Ordering Functions. Based on 06.24 discussions . Also some editorial clean up done . b6b19cc971008a58640a284b24d40e3993c1c42e b6b19cc971008a58640a284b24d40e3993c1c42e draft-ietf-detnet-mpls-over-udp-ip cdc15b05d37b640ea4b7794cf9a229c6c28f8a1b7491f0460010ab5fcc44ff69 ['cdc15b05d37b640ea4b7794cf9a229c6c28f8a1b7491f0460010ab5fcc44ff69'] A packet replication, elimination and ordering functions. {64: 1, 68: 1, 69: 1, 130: 3, 79: 2, 51: 2, 112: 2, 55: 2, 62: 2, 37: 2, 38: 2, 67: 3, 33: 2, 25: 2, 53: 2, 80: 3, 52: 2, 127: 4, 91: 2} {14: 1, 279: 1, 406: 1, 0: 3, 389: 3, 390: 3, 135: 2, 142: 2, 400: 2, 17: 2, 399: 4, 19: 3, 149: 2, 280: 2, 281: 3, 278: 2, 294: 2, 296: 2, 45: 3, 308: 2, 56: 3, 185: 3, 192: 3, 321: 2, 322: 2, 66: 3, 196: 5, 197: 4, 77: 2, 78: 2, 337: 5, 216: 2, 380: 3, 255: 3} {0, 389, 390, 135, 142, 14, 400, 17, 399, 19, 149, 406, 279, 280, 281, 278, 294, 296, 45, 308, 56, 185, 192, 321, 322, 66, 196, 197, 324, 77, 78, 337, 216, 380, 255} 33 "This document builds on the specification of MPLS over UDP and IP defined in RFC7510. It may replace partly or entirely the F-Label(s) used in I-D.ietf-detnet-mpls with UDP and IP headers. The UDP and IP header information is used to identify DetNet flows, including member flows, per I-D.ietf-detnet-ip. The resulting encapsulation is shown in IP-encap-dn. There may be zero or more F-label(s) between the S-label and the UDP header." Based on 06.24 discussions . Also some editorial clean up done . b6b19cc971008a58640a284b24d40e3993c1c42e b6b19cc971008a58640a284b24d40e3993c1c42e draft-ietf-detnet-mpls-over-udp-ip ffc3e5ff3f5d3eed0ec6f14260b6af8f36659d90264c1ca79b7e77b96fe58964 ['ffc3e5ff3f5d3eed0ec6f14260b6af8f36659d90264c1ca79b7e77b96fe58964', '99ea38720101b27b09b45d3f7fdf0361687e52cedc06f1b35d56747661c4d7ce'] A "this document builds on the specification of mpls over udp and ip defined in rfc7510. it may replace partly or entirely the f-label(s) used in i-d.ietf-detnet-mpls with udp and ip headers. the udp and ip header information is used to identify detnet flows, including member flows, per i-d.ietf-detnet-ip. the resulting encapsulation is shown in ip-encap-dn. there may be zero or more f-label(s) between the s-label and the udp header." {32: 1} {412: 1} {412, 413} 33 "This document builds on the specification of MPLS over UDP defined in RFC7510. It may replace partly or entirely the F-Label(s) used in I- D.ietf-detnet-mpls with UDP and IP headers. The UDP and IP header information is used to identify DetNet flows, including member flows, per I-D.ietf-detnet-ip. The resulting encapsulation is shown in IP- encap-dn. There may be zero or more F-label(s) between the S-label and the UDP header." Based on 06.24 discussions . Also some editorial clean up done . b6b19cc971008a58640a284b24d40e3993c1c42e b6b19cc971008a58640a284b24d40e3993c1c42e draft-ietf-detnet-mpls-over-udp-ip 99ea38720101b27b09b45d3f7fdf0361687e52cedc06f1b35d56747661c4d7ce ['ffc3e5ff3f5d3eed0ec6f14260b6af8f36659d90264c1ca79b7e77b96fe58964', '99ea38720101b27b09b45d3f7fdf0361687e52cedc06f1b35d56747661c4d7ce'] B "this document builds on the specification of mpls over udp defined in rfc7510. it may replace partly or entirely the f-label(s) used in i- d.ietf-detnet-mpls with udp and ip headers. the udp and ip header information is used to identify detnet flows, including member flows, per i-d.ietf-detnet-ip. the resulting encapsulation is shown in ip- encap-dn. there may be zero or more f-label(s) between the s-label and the udp header." {32: 1} {412: 1} {412, 413} 33 "To support outgoing DetNet MPLS over UDP/IP, an implementation MUST support the provisioning of UDP/IP header information in addition or in place of sets of F-Label(s). Note that multiple sets of F-Labels can be provisioned to support PRF on transmitted DetNet MPLS flows and therefore, when PRF is supported, multiple UDP/IP headers MAY be provisioned." Based on 06.24 discussions . Also some editorial clean up done . b6b19cc971008a58640a284b24d40e3993c1c42e b6b19cc971008a58640a284b24d40e3993c1c42e draft-ietf-detnet-mpls-over-udp-ip f36d8fba41a9d248c0828a919f5732c36e25a2809cec7f86b8c2a43ad967ca09 ['1c461fe81d5bcf71073032237c90a364fe0acc907c86f9c6b7bdd0239e4a6516', '4a95be10c5590a4fe0ad4da58a231ea010ff214e7dc04107bb1c6ec8b9a8b734', '64c967bf314cd115ae548ad25ff1ac315b8ebae80114c1e6c2cdd1b18c87d311', '77f52e3a27231622bf5419787da9d00710542ed8febd34f0fcf41a407f253254', 'e36f8694636db0304245e6df97b64ed089292f19180d858c0a08452501634022', '651e341460abb4f56484b2921abfc1e41250a07075e5c89fa4decd74cfa782be', '96f49870b665021906e0a8c8967651ea74672ff4f2c95e90f16fb1b6558d8ba3', '658ec33f8cad649513db3a623c44949b0ada07e7b8ea99d6f071aefb52786790', '4838fa3a84bff003216011b4f2c570eba0e5f2b9054e8b8617863ed3fb8e08a9', 'fb473c32d1641464c5377775c886a6ac46a55ab70007e126b180e444120e9206', '87a3de23bdd1c53a746e7a7cfa7e3580fd250a5617cc917dab59828f4f4ebc50', '387497881925e27e3bd09668877e8c2b9a5e4041dcb0108c2e9ef352d1e2c5a5', 'de516a625ab93a18f079c2aff17323130e255b2973920908021f63c9cda0caeb', '0c4e4992cda8f30f80cc2363443762dbc93e76b6cc2de75eaa96840d9a83694d', 'ecf3baef3232eab1bf969290ca738f19d1bb31becf8a7243045e8b6417582b48', 'f36d8fba41a9d248c0828a919f5732c36e25a2809cec7f86b8c2a43ad967ca09', 'e7c612bbe379289bbe432edbe6a3a5fdc3297cf68e0672b4a8a9bed556dab403', 'c5286e5f2f650dc15466adcf108165abf439ed3a89340a782042fe713c6de8ac'] A "to support outgoing detnet mpls over udp/ip, an implementation must support the provisioning of udp/ip header information in addition or in place of sets of f-label(s). note that multiple sets of f-labels can be provisioned to support prf on transmitted detnet mpls flows and therefore, when prf is supported, multiple udp/ip headers may be provisioned." {26: 1, 32: 1, 56: 1, 38: 1, 102: 1, 60: 2, 64: 2, 62: 2, 71: 2, 83: 2, 113: 2, 126: 3, 112: 2, 85: 2, 129: 3} {32: 1, 33: 1, 261: 1, 357: 1, 274: 1, 212: 1, 260: 2, 339: 2, 343: 2, 283: 2, 286: 3, 163: 2, 228: 2, 166: 3, 231: 2, 298: 2, 363: 2, 46: 3, 377: 2} {260, 261, 274, 283, 286, 31, 32, 33, 163, 166, 298, 46, 339, 212, 343, 228, 357, 231, 363, 377} 33 "When multiple UDP/IP headers are provisioned for a particular outgoing DetNet IP flow, a copy of the outgoing packet, including the pushed S-Label (and optional F-label(s)), MUST be made for each. The headers for each outgoing packet MUST be based on the configuration information and as defined in RFC7510, with one exception. The one exception is that the UDP Source Port value MUST be set to uniquely identify the DetNet (forwarding sub-layer) flow. The packet MUST then be handed as a DetNet IP packet, per I-D.ietf-detnet-ip." Based on 06.24 discussions . Also some editorial clean up done . b6b19cc971008a58640a284b24d40e3993c1c42e b6b19cc971008a58640a284b24d40e3993c1c42e draft-ietf-detnet-mpls-over-udp-ip e36f8694636db0304245e6df97b64ed089292f19180d858c0a08452501634022 ['1c461fe81d5bcf71073032237c90a364fe0acc907c86f9c6b7bdd0239e4a6516', '4a95be10c5590a4fe0ad4da58a231ea010ff214e7dc04107bb1c6ec8b9a8b734', '64c967bf314cd115ae548ad25ff1ac315b8ebae80114c1e6c2cdd1b18c87d311', '77f52e3a27231622bf5419787da9d00710542ed8febd34f0fcf41a407f253254', 'e36f8694636db0304245e6df97b64ed089292f19180d858c0a08452501634022', '651e341460abb4f56484b2921abfc1e41250a07075e5c89fa4decd74cfa782be', '96f49870b665021906e0a8c8967651ea74672ff4f2c95e90f16fb1b6558d8ba3', '658ec33f8cad649513db3a623c44949b0ada07e7b8ea99d6f071aefb52786790', '4838fa3a84bff003216011b4f2c570eba0e5f2b9054e8b8617863ed3fb8e08a9', 'fb473c32d1641464c5377775c886a6ac46a55ab70007e126b180e444120e9206', '87a3de23bdd1c53a746e7a7cfa7e3580fd250a5617cc917dab59828f4f4ebc50', '387497881925e27e3bd09668877e8c2b9a5e4041dcb0108c2e9ef352d1e2c5a5', 'de516a625ab93a18f079c2aff17323130e255b2973920908021f63c9cda0caeb', '0c4e4992cda8f30f80cc2363443762dbc93e76b6cc2de75eaa96840d9a83694d', 'ecf3baef3232eab1bf969290ca738f19d1bb31becf8a7243045e8b6417582b48', 'f36d8fba41a9d248c0828a919f5732c36e25a2809cec7f86b8c2a43ad967ca09', 'e7c612bbe379289bbe432edbe6a3a5fdc3297cf68e0672b4a8a9bed556dab403', 'c5286e5f2f650dc15466adcf108165abf439ed3a89340a782042fe713c6de8ac'] A "when multiple udp/ip headers are provisioned for a particular outgoing detnet ip flow, a copy of the outgoing packet, including the pushed s-label (and optional f-label(s)), must be made for each. the headers for each outgoing packet must be based on the configuration information and as defined in rfc7510, with one exception. the one exception is that the udp source port value must be set to uniquely identify the detnet (forwarding sub-layer) flow. the packet must then be handed as a detnet ip packet, per i-d.ietf-detnet-ip." {26: 1, 32: 1, 56: 1, 38: 1, 102: 1, 60: 2, 64: 2, 62: 2, 71: 2, 83: 2, 113: 2, 126: 3, 112: 2, 85: 2, 129: 3} {32: 1, 33: 1, 261: 1, 357: 1, 274: 1, 212: 1, 260: 2, 339: 2, 343: 2, 283: 2, 286: 3, 163: 2, 228: 2, 166: 3, 231: 2, 298: 2, 363: 2, 46: 3, 377: 2} {260, 261, 274, 283, 286, 31, 32, 33, 163, 166, 298, 46, 339, 212, 343, 228, 357, 231, 363, 377} 33 "To support receive processing an implementation MUST also support the provisioning of received UDP/IP header information." Based on 06.24 discussions . Also some editorial clean up done . b6b19cc971008a58640a284b24d40e3993c1c42e b6b19cc971008a58640a284b24d40e3993c1c42e draft-ietf-detnet-mpls-over-udp-ip 4838fa3a84bff003216011b4f2c570eba0e5f2b9054e8b8617863ed3fb8e08a9 ['1c461fe81d5bcf71073032237c90a364fe0acc907c86f9c6b7bdd0239e4a6516', '4a95be10c5590a4fe0ad4da58a231ea010ff214e7dc04107bb1c6ec8b9a8b734', '64c967bf314cd115ae548ad25ff1ac315b8ebae80114c1e6c2cdd1b18c87d311', '77f52e3a27231622bf5419787da9d00710542ed8febd34f0fcf41a407f253254', 'e36f8694636db0304245e6df97b64ed089292f19180d858c0a08452501634022', '651e341460abb4f56484b2921abfc1e41250a07075e5c89fa4decd74cfa782be', '96f49870b665021906e0a8c8967651ea74672ff4f2c95e90f16fb1b6558d8ba3', '658ec33f8cad649513db3a623c44949b0ada07e7b8ea99d6f071aefb52786790', '4838fa3a84bff003216011b4f2c570eba0e5f2b9054e8b8617863ed3fb8e08a9', 'fb473c32d1641464c5377775c886a6ac46a55ab70007e126b180e444120e9206', '87a3de23bdd1c53a746e7a7cfa7e3580fd250a5617cc917dab59828f4f4ebc50', '387497881925e27e3bd09668877e8c2b9a5e4041dcb0108c2e9ef352d1e2c5a5', 'de516a625ab93a18f079c2aff17323130e255b2973920908021f63c9cda0caeb', '0c4e4992cda8f30f80cc2363443762dbc93e76b6cc2de75eaa96840d9a83694d', 'ecf3baef3232eab1bf969290ca738f19d1bb31becf8a7243045e8b6417582b48', 'f36d8fba41a9d248c0828a919f5732c36e25a2809cec7f86b8c2a43ad967ca09', 'e7c612bbe379289bbe432edbe6a3a5fdc3297cf68e0672b4a8a9bed556dab403', 'c5286e5f2f650dc15466adcf108165abf439ed3a89340a782042fe713c6de8ac'] A "to support receive processing an implementation must also support the provisioning of received udp/ip header information." {26: 1, 32: 1, 56: 1, 38: 1, 102: 1, 60: 2, 64: 2, 62: 2, 71: 2, 83: 2, 113: 2, 126: 3, 112: 2, 85: 2, 129: 3} {32: 1, 33: 1, 261: 1, 357: 1, 274: 1, 212: 1, 260: 2, 339: 2, 343: 2, 283: 2, 286: 3, 163: 2, 228: 2, 166: 3, 231: 2, 298: 2, 363: 2, 46: 3, 377: 2} {260, 261, 274, 283, 286, 31, 32, 33, 163, 166, 298, 46, 339, 212, 343, 228, 357, 231, 363, 377} 33 "When S-Labels are taken from platform label space, all that is required is to provision that receiving UDP/IP encapsulated DetNet MPLS packets is permitted. Once the UDP/IP header is stripped, the S-label uniquely identifies the app-flow. When S-Labels are not taken from platform label space, UDP/IP header information MUST be provisioned. The provisioned information MUST then be used to identify incoming app-flows based on the combination of S-Label and incoming IP/UDP header. Normal receive processing, including PEOF can then take place." Based on 06.24 discussions . Also some editorial clean up done . b6b19cc971008a58640a284b24d40e3993c1c42e b6b19cc971008a58640a284b24d40e3993c1c42e draft-ietf-detnet-mpls-over-udp-ip 77f52e3a27231622bf5419787da9d00710542ed8febd34f0fcf41a407f253254 ['1c461fe81d5bcf71073032237c90a364fe0acc907c86f9c6b7bdd0239e4a6516', '4a95be10c5590a4fe0ad4da58a231ea010ff214e7dc04107bb1c6ec8b9a8b734', '64c967bf314cd115ae548ad25ff1ac315b8ebae80114c1e6c2cdd1b18c87d311', '77f52e3a27231622bf5419787da9d00710542ed8febd34f0fcf41a407f253254', 'e36f8694636db0304245e6df97b64ed089292f19180d858c0a08452501634022', '651e341460abb4f56484b2921abfc1e41250a07075e5c89fa4decd74cfa782be', '96f49870b665021906e0a8c8967651ea74672ff4f2c95e90f16fb1b6558d8ba3', '658ec33f8cad649513db3a623c44949b0ada07e7b8ea99d6f071aefb52786790', '4838fa3a84bff003216011b4f2c570eba0e5f2b9054e8b8617863ed3fb8e08a9', 'fb473c32d1641464c5377775c886a6ac46a55ab70007e126b180e444120e9206', '87a3de23bdd1c53a746e7a7cfa7e3580fd250a5617cc917dab59828f4f4ebc50', '387497881925e27e3bd09668877e8c2b9a5e4041dcb0108c2e9ef352d1e2c5a5', 'de516a625ab93a18f079c2aff17323130e255b2973920908021f63c9cda0caeb', '0c4e4992cda8f30f80cc2363443762dbc93e76b6cc2de75eaa96840d9a83694d', 'ecf3baef3232eab1bf969290ca738f19d1bb31becf8a7243045e8b6417582b48', 'f36d8fba41a9d248c0828a919f5732c36e25a2809cec7f86b8c2a43ad967ca09', 'e7c612bbe379289bbe432edbe6a3a5fdc3297cf68e0672b4a8a9bed556dab403', 'c5286e5f2f650dc15466adcf108165abf439ed3a89340a782042fe713c6de8ac'] A "when s-labels are taken from platform label space, all that is required is to provision that receiving udp/ip encapsulated detnet mpls packets is permitted. once the udp/ip header is stripped, the s-label uniquely identifies the app-flow. when s-labels are not taken from platform label space, udp/ip header information must be provisioned. the provisioned information must then be used to identify incoming app-flows based on the combination of s-label and incoming ip/udp header. normal receive processing, including peof can then take place." {26: 1, 32: 1, 56: 1, 38: 1, 102: 1, 60: 2, 64: 2, 62: 2, 71: 2, 83: 2, 113: 2, 126: 3, 112: 2, 85: 2, 129: 3} {32: 1, 33: 1, 261: 1, 357: 1, 274: 1, 212: 1, 260: 2, 339: 2, 343: 2, 283: 2, 286: 3, 163: 2, 228: 2, 166: 3, 231: 2, 298: 2, 363: 2, 46: 3, 377: 2} {260, 261, 274, 283, 286, 31, 32, 33, 163, 166, 298, 46, 339, 212, 343, 228, 357, 231, 363, 377} 33 "IPv4 and IPv6 source address prefix length, where a zero (0) value effectively means that the address field is ignored." Based on 06.24 discussions . Also some editorial clean up done . b6b19cc971008a58640a284b24d40e3993c1c42e b6b19cc971008a58640a284b24d40e3993c1c42e draft-ietf-detnet-mpls-over-udp-ip fb473c32d1641464c5377775c886a6ac46a55ab70007e126b180e444120e9206 ['1c461fe81d5bcf71073032237c90a364fe0acc907c86f9c6b7bdd0239e4a6516', '4a95be10c5590a4fe0ad4da58a231ea010ff214e7dc04107bb1c6ec8b9a8b734', '64c967bf314cd115ae548ad25ff1ac315b8ebae80114c1e6c2cdd1b18c87d311', '77f52e3a27231622bf5419787da9d00710542ed8febd34f0fcf41a407f253254', 'e36f8694636db0304245e6df97b64ed089292f19180d858c0a08452501634022', '651e341460abb4f56484b2921abfc1e41250a07075e5c89fa4decd74cfa782be', '96f49870b665021906e0a8c8967651ea74672ff4f2c95e90f16fb1b6558d8ba3', '658ec33f8cad649513db3a623c44949b0ada07e7b8ea99d6f071aefb52786790', '4838fa3a84bff003216011b4f2c570eba0e5f2b9054e8b8617863ed3fb8e08a9', 'fb473c32d1641464c5377775c886a6ac46a55ab70007e126b180e444120e9206', '87a3de23bdd1c53a746e7a7cfa7e3580fd250a5617cc917dab59828f4f4ebc50', '387497881925e27e3bd09668877e8c2b9a5e4041dcb0108c2e9ef352d1e2c5a5', 'de516a625ab93a18f079c2aff17323130e255b2973920908021f63c9cda0caeb', '0c4e4992cda8f30f80cc2363443762dbc93e76b6cc2de75eaa96840d9a83694d', 'ecf3baef3232eab1bf969290ca738f19d1bb31becf8a7243045e8b6417582b48', 'f36d8fba41a9d248c0828a919f5732c36e25a2809cec7f86b8c2a43ad967ca09', 'e7c612bbe379289bbe432edbe6a3a5fdc3297cf68e0672b4a8a9bed556dab403', 'c5286e5f2f650dc15466adcf108165abf439ed3a89340a782042fe713c6de8ac'] A "ipv4 and ipv6 source address prefix length, where a zero (0) value effectively means that the address field is ignored." {26: 1, 32: 1, 56: 1, 38: 1, 102: 1, 60: 2, 64: 2, 62: 2, 71: 2, 83: 2, 113: 2, 126: 3, 112: 2, 85: 2, 129: 3} {32: 1, 33: 1, 261: 1, 357: 1, 274: 1, 212: 1, 260: 2, 339: 2, 343: 2, 283: 2, 286: 3, 163: 2, 228: 2, 166: 3, 231: 2, 298: 2, 363: 2, 46: 3, 377: 2} {260, 261, 274, 283, 286, 31, 32, 33, 163, 166, 298, 46, 339, 212, 343, 228, 357, 231, 363, 377} 33 "IPv4 and IPv6 destination address prefix length, where a zero (0) effectively means that the address field is ignored." Based on 06.24 discussions . Also some editorial clean up done . b6b19cc971008a58640a284b24d40e3993c1c42e b6b19cc971008a58640a284b24d40e3993c1c42e draft-ietf-detnet-mpls-over-udp-ip ecf3baef3232eab1bf969290ca738f19d1bb31becf8a7243045e8b6417582b48 ['1c461fe81d5bcf71073032237c90a364fe0acc907c86f9c6b7bdd0239e4a6516', '4a95be10c5590a4fe0ad4da58a231ea010ff214e7dc04107bb1c6ec8b9a8b734', '64c967bf314cd115ae548ad25ff1ac315b8ebae80114c1e6c2cdd1b18c87d311', '77f52e3a27231622bf5419787da9d00710542ed8febd34f0fcf41a407f253254', 'e36f8694636db0304245e6df97b64ed089292f19180d858c0a08452501634022', '651e341460abb4f56484b2921abfc1e41250a07075e5c89fa4decd74cfa782be', '96f49870b665021906e0a8c8967651ea74672ff4f2c95e90f16fb1b6558d8ba3', '658ec33f8cad649513db3a623c44949b0ada07e7b8ea99d6f071aefb52786790', '4838fa3a84bff003216011b4f2c570eba0e5f2b9054e8b8617863ed3fb8e08a9', 'fb473c32d1641464c5377775c886a6ac46a55ab70007e126b180e444120e9206', '87a3de23bdd1c53a746e7a7cfa7e3580fd250a5617cc917dab59828f4f4ebc50', '387497881925e27e3bd09668877e8c2b9a5e4041dcb0108c2e9ef352d1e2c5a5', 'de516a625ab93a18f079c2aff17323130e255b2973920908021f63c9cda0caeb', '0c4e4992cda8f30f80cc2363443762dbc93e76b6cc2de75eaa96840d9a83694d', 'ecf3baef3232eab1bf969290ca738f19d1bb31becf8a7243045e8b6417582b48', 'f36d8fba41a9d248c0828a919f5732c36e25a2809cec7f86b8c2a43ad967ca09', 'e7c612bbe379289bbe432edbe6a3a5fdc3297cf68e0672b4a8a9bed556dab403', 'c5286e5f2f650dc15466adcf108165abf439ed3a89340a782042fe713c6de8ac'] A "ipv4 and ipv6 destination address prefix length, where a zero (0) effectively means that the address field is ignored." {26: 1, 32: 1, 56: 1, 38: 1, 102: 1, 60: 2, 64: 2, 62: 2, 71: 2, 83: 2, 113: 2, 126: 3, 112: 2, 85: 2, 129: 3} {32: 1, 33: 1, 261: 1, 357: 1, 274: 1, 212: 1, 260: 2, 339: 2, 343: 2, 283: 2, 286: 3, 163: 2, 228: 2, 166: 3, 231: 2, 298: 2, 363: 2, 46: 3, 377: 2} {260, 261, 274, 283, 286, 31, 32, 33, 163, 166, 298, 46, 339, 212, 343, 228, 357, 231, 363, 377} 33 "IPv4 protocol field. Only UDP is allowed, and the ability to ignore this field, e.g., via configuration of the value zero (0), is desirable." Based on 06.24 discussions . Also some editorial clean up done . b6b19cc971008a58640a284b24d40e3993c1c42e b6b19cc971008a58640a284b24d40e3993c1c42e draft-ietf-detnet-mpls-over-udp-ip 96f49870b665021906e0a8c8967651ea74672ff4f2c95e90f16fb1b6558d8ba3 ['1c461fe81d5bcf71073032237c90a364fe0acc907c86f9c6b7bdd0239e4a6516', '4a95be10c5590a4fe0ad4da58a231ea010ff214e7dc04107bb1c6ec8b9a8b734', '64c967bf314cd115ae548ad25ff1ac315b8ebae80114c1e6c2cdd1b18c87d311', '77f52e3a27231622bf5419787da9d00710542ed8febd34f0fcf41a407f253254', 'e36f8694636db0304245e6df97b64ed089292f19180d858c0a08452501634022', '651e341460abb4f56484b2921abfc1e41250a07075e5c89fa4decd74cfa782be', '96f49870b665021906e0a8c8967651ea74672ff4f2c95e90f16fb1b6558d8ba3', '658ec33f8cad649513db3a623c44949b0ada07e7b8ea99d6f071aefb52786790', '4838fa3a84bff003216011b4f2c570eba0e5f2b9054e8b8617863ed3fb8e08a9', 'fb473c32d1641464c5377775c886a6ac46a55ab70007e126b180e444120e9206', '87a3de23bdd1c53a746e7a7cfa7e3580fd250a5617cc917dab59828f4f4ebc50', '387497881925e27e3bd09668877e8c2b9a5e4041dcb0108c2e9ef352d1e2c5a5', 'de516a625ab93a18f079c2aff17323130e255b2973920908021f63c9cda0caeb', '0c4e4992cda8f30f80cc2363443762dbc93e76b6cc2de75eaa96840d9a83694d', 'ecf3baef3232eab1bf969290ca738f19d1bb31becf8a7243045e8b6417582b48', 'f36d8fba41a9d248c0828a919f5732c36e25a2809cec7f86b8c2a43ad967ca09', 'e7c612bbe379289bbe432edbe6a3a5fdc3297cf68e0672b4a8a9bed556dab403', 'c5286e5f2f650dc15466adcf108165abf439ed3a89340a782042fe713c6de8ac'] A "ipv4 protocol field. only udp is allowed, and the ability to ignore this field, e.g., via configuration of the value zero (0), is desirable." {26: 1, 32: 1, 56: 1, 38: 1, 102: 1, 60: 2, 64: 2, 62: 2, 71: 2, 83: 2, 113: 2, 126: 3, 112: 2, 85: 2, 129: 3} {32: 1, 33: 1, 261: 1, 357: 1, 274: 1, 212: 1, 260: 2, 339: 2, 343: 2, 283: 2, 286: 3, 163: 2, 228: 2, 166: 3, 231: 2, 298: 2, 363: 2, 46: 3, 377: 2} {260, 261, 274, 283, 286, 31, 32, 33, 163, 166, 298, 46, 339, 212, 343, 228, 357, 231, 363, 377} 33 "IPv6 next header field. Only UDP is allowed, and the ability to ignore this field, e.g., via configuration of the value zero (0), is desirable." Based on 06.24 discussions . Also some editorial clean up done . b6b19cc971008a58640a284b24d40e3993c1c42e b6b19cc971008a58640a284b24d40e3993c1c42e draft-ietf-detnet-mpls-over-udp-ip 64c967bf314cd115ae548ad25ff1ac315b8ebae80114c1e6c2cdd1b18c87d311 ['1c461fe81d5bcf71073032237c90a364fe0acc907c86f9c6b7bdd0239e4a6516', '4a95be10c5590a4fe0ad4da58a231ea010ff214e7dc04107bb1c6ec8b9a8b734', '64c967bf314cd115ae548ad25ff1ac315b8ebae80114c1e6c2cdd1b18c87d311', '77f52e3a27231622bf5419787da9d00710542ed8febd34f0fcf41a407f253254', 'e36f8694636db0304245e6df97b64ed089292f19180d858c0a08452501634022', '651e341460abb4f56484b2921abfc1e41250a07075e5c89fa4decd74cfa782be', '96f49870b665021906e0a8c8967651ea74672ff4f2c95e90f16fb1b6558d8ba3', '658ec33f8cad649513db3a623c44949b0ada07e7b8ea99d6f071aefb52786790', '4838fa3a84bff003216011b4f2c570eba0e5f2b9054e8b8617863ed3fb8e08a9', 'fb473c32d1641464c5377775c886a6ac46a55ab70007e126b180e444120e9206', '87a3de23bdd1c53a746e7a7cfa7e3580fd250a5617cc917dab59828f4f4ebc50', '387497881925e27e3bd09668877e8c2b9a5e4041dcb0108c2e9ef352d1e2c5a5', 'de516a625ab93a18f079c2aff17323130e255b2973920908021f63c9cda0caeb', '0c4e4992cda8f30f80cc2363443762dbc93e76b6cc2de75eaa96840d9a83694d', 'ecf3baef3232eab1bf969290ca738f19d1bb31becf8a7243045e8b6417582b48', 'f36d8fba41a9d248c0828a919f5732c36e25a2809cec7f86b8c2a43ad967ca09', 'e7c612bbe379289bbe432edbe6a3a5fdc3297cf68e0672b4a8a9bed556dab403', 'c5286e5f2f650dc15466adcf108165abf439ed3a89340a782042fe713c6de8ac'] A "ipv6 next header field. only udp is allowed, and the ability to ignore this field, e.g., via configuration of the value zero (0), is desirable." {26: 1, 32: 1, 56: 1, 38: 1, 102: 1, 60: 2, 64: 2, 62: 2, 71: 2, 83: 2, 113: 2, 126: 3, 112: 2, 85: 2, 129: 3} {32: 1, 33: 1, 261: 1, 357: 1, 274: 1, 212: 1, 260: 2, 339: 2, 343: 2, 283: 2, 286: 3, 163: 2, 228: 2, 166: 3, 231: 2, 298: 2, 363: 2, 46: 3, 377: 2} {260, 261, 274, 283, 286, 31, 32, 33, 163, 166, 298, 46, 339, 212, 343, 228, 357, 231, 363, 377} 33 "IPv4 Type of Service and IPv6 Traffic Class Field Bitmask, where a zero (0) effectively means that theses fields are ignored." Based on 06.24 discussions . Also some editorial clean up done . b6b19cc971008a58640a284b24d40e3993c1c42e b6b19cc971008a58640a284b24d40e3993c1c42e draft-ietf-detnet-mpls-over-udp-ip c5286e5f2f650dc15466adcf108165abf439ed3a89340a782042fe713c6de8ac ['1c461fe81d5bcf71073032237c90a364fe0acc907c86f9c6b7bdd0239e4a6516', '4a95be10c5590a4fe0ad4da58a231ea010ff214e7dc04107bb1c6ec8b9a8b734', '64c967bf314cd115ae548ad25ff1ac315b8ebae80114c1e6c2cdd1b18c87d311', '77f52e3a27231622bf5419787da9d00710542ed8febd34f0fcf41a407f253254', 'e36f8694636db0304245e6df97b64ed089292f19180d858c0a08452501634022', '651e341460abb4f56484b2921abfc1e41250a07075e5c89fa4decd74cfa782be', '96f49870b665021906e0a8c8967651ea74672ff4f2c95e90f16fb1b6558d8ba3', '658ec33f8cad649513db3a623c44949b0ada07e7b8ea99d6f071aefb52786790', '4838fa3a84bff003216011b4f2c570eba0e5f2b9054e8b8617863ed3fb8e08a9', 'fb473c32d1641464c5377775c886a6ac46a55ab70007e126b180e444120e9206', '87a3de23bdd1c53a746e7a7cfa7e3580fd250a5617cc917dab59828f4f4ebc50', '387497881925e27e3bd09668877e8c2b9a5e4041dcb0108c2e9ef352d1e2c5a5', 'de516a625ab93a18f079c2aff17323130e255b2973920908021f63c9cda0caeb', '0c4e4992cda8f30f80cc2363443762dbc93e76b6cc2de75eaa96840d9a83694d', 'ecf3baef3232eab1bf969290ca738f19d1bb31becf8a7243045e8b6417582b48', 'f36d8fba41a9d248c0828a919f5732c36e25a2809cec7f86b8c2a43ad967ca09', 'e7c612bbe379289bbe432edbe6a3a5fdc3297cf68e0672b4a8a9bed556dab403', 'c5286e5f2f650dc15466adcf108165abf439ed3a89340a782042fe713c6de8ac'] A "ipv4 type of service and ipv6 traffic class field bitmask, where a zero (0) effectively means that theses fields are ignored." {26: 1, 32: 1, 56: 1, 38: 1, 102: 1, 60: 2, 64: 2, 62: 2, 71: 2, 83: 2, 113: 2, 126: 3, 112: 2, 85: 2, 129: 3} {32: 1, 33: 1, 261: 1, 357: 1, 274: 1, 212: 1, 260: 2, 339: 2, 343: 2, 283: 2, 286: 3, 163: 2, 228: 2, 166: 3, 231: 2, 298: 2, 363: 2, 46: 3, 377: 2} {260, 261, 274, 283, 286, 31, 32, 33, 163, 166, 298, 46, 339, 212, 343, 228, 357, 231, 363, 377} 33 "UDP Source Port. Exact and wildcard matching is required. Port ranges can optionally be used." Based on 06.24 discussions . Also some editorial clean up done . b6b19cc971008a58640a284b24d40e3993c1c42e b6b19cc971008a58640a284b24d40e3993c1c42e draft-ietf-detnet-mpls-over-udp-ip 658ec33f8cad649513db3a623c44949b0ada07e7b8ea99d6f071aefb52786790 ['1c461fe81d5bcf71073032237c90a364fe0acc907c86f9c6b7bdd0239e4a6516', '4a95be10c5590a4fe0ad4da58a231ea010ff214e7dc04107bb1c6ec8b9a8b734', '64c967bf314cd115ae548ad25ff1ac315b8ebae80114c1e6c2cdd1b18c87d311', '77f52e3a27231622bf5419787da9d00710542ed8febd34f0fcf41a407f253254', 'e36f8694636db0304245e6df97b64ed089292f19180d858c0a08452501634022', '651e341460abb4f56484b2921abfc1e41250a07075e5c89fa4decd74cfa782be', '96f49870b665021906e0a8c8967651ea74672ff4f2c95e90f16fb1b6558d8ba3', '658ec33f8cad649513db3a623c44949b0ada07e7b8ea99d6f071aefb52786790', '4838fa3a84bff003216011b4f2c570eba0e5f2b9054e8b8617863ed3fb8e08a9', 'fb473c32d1641464c5377775c886a6ac46a55ab70007e126b180e444120e9206', '87a3de23bdd1c53a746e7a7cfa7e3580fd250a5617cc917dab59828f4f4ebc50', '387497881925e27e3bd09668877e8c2b9a5e4041dcb0108c2e9ef352d1e2c5a5', 'de516a625ab93a18f079c2aff17323130e255b2973920908021f63c9cda0caeb', '0c4e4992cda8f30f80cc2363443762dbc93e76b6cc2de75eaa96840d9a83694d', 'ecf3baef3232eab1bf969290ca738f19d1bb31becf8a7243045e8b6417582b48', 'f36d8fba41a9d248c0828a919f5732c36e25a2809cec7f86b8c2a43ad967ca09', 'e7c612bbe379289bbe432edbe6a3a5fdc3297cf68e0672b4a8a9bed556dab403', 'c5286e5f2f650dc15466adcf108165abf439ed3a89340a782042fe713c6de8ac'] A "udp source port. exact and wildcard matching is required. port ranges can optionally be used." {26: 1, 32: 1, 56: 1, 38: 1, 102: 1, 60: 2, 64: 2, 62: 2, 71: 2, 83: 2, 113: 2, 126: 3, 112: 2, 85: 2, 129: 3} {32: 1, 33: 1, 261: 1, 357: 1, 274: 1, 212: 1, 260: 2, 339: 2, 343: 2, 283: 2, 286: 3, 163: 2, 228: 2, 166: 3, 231: 2, 298: 2, 363: 2, 46: 3, 377: 2} {260, 261, 274, 283, 286, 31, 32, 33, 163, 166, 298, 46, 339, 212, 343, 228, 357, 231, 363, 377} 33 "Information identifying a DetNet flow is ordered and implementations use the first match. This can, for example, be used to provide a DetNet service for a specific UDP flow, with unique Source and Destination Port field values, while providing a different service for the aggregate of all other flows with that same UDP Destination Port value." Based on 06.24 discussions . Also some editorial clean up done . b6b19cc971008a58640a284b24d40e3993c1c42e b6b19cc971008a58640a284b24d40e3993c1c42e draft-ietf-detnet-mpls-over-udp-ip 1c461fe81d5bcf71073032237c90a364fe0acc907c86f9c6b7bdd0239e4a6516 ['1c461fe81d5bcf71073032237c90a364fe0acc907c86f9c6b7bdd0239e4a6516', '4a95be10c5590a4fe0ad4da58a231ea010ff214e7dc04107bb1c6ec8b9a8b734', '64c967bf314cd115ae548ad25ff1ac315b8ebae80114c1e6c2cdd1b18c87d311', '77f52e3a27231622bf5419787da9d00710542ed8febd34f0fcf41a407f253254', 'e36f8694636db0304245e6df97b64ed089292f19180d858c0a08452501634022', '651e341460abb4f56484b2921abfc1e41250a07075e5c89fa4decd74cfa782be', '96f49870b665021906e0a8c8967651ea74672ff4f2c95e90f16fb1b6558d8ba3', '658ec33f8cad649513db3a623c44949b0ada07e7b8ea99d6f071aefb52786790', '4838fa3a84bff003216011b4f2c570eba0e5f2b9054e8b8617863ed3fb8e08a9', 'fb473c32d1641464c5377775c886a6ac46a55ab70007e126b180e444120e9206', '87a3de23bdd1c53a746e7a7cfa7e3580fd250a5617cc917dab59828f4f4ebc50', '387497881925e27e3bd09668877e8c2b9a5e4041dcb0108c2e9ef352d1e2c5a5', 'de516a625ab93a18f079c2aff17323130e255b2973920908021f63c9cda0caeb', '0c4e4992cda8f30f80cc2363443762dbc93e76b6cc2de75eaa96840d9a83694d', 'ecf3baef3232eab1bf969290ca738f19d1bb31becf8a7243045e8b6417582b48', 'f36d8fba41a9d248c0828a919f5732c36e25a2809cec7f86b8c2a43ad967ca09', 'e7c612bbe379289bbe432edbe6a3a5fdc3297cf68e0672b4a8a9bed556dab403', 'c5286e5f2f650dc15466adcf108165abf439ed3a89340a782042fe713c6de8ac'] A "information identifying a detnet flow is ordered and implementations use the first match. this can, for example, be used to provide a detnet service for a specific udp flow, with unique source and destination port field values, while providing a different service for the aggregate of all other flows with that same udp destination port value." {26: 1, 32: 1, 56: 1, 38: 1, 102: 1, 60: 2, 64: 2, 62: 2, 71: 2, 83: 2, 113: 2, 126: 3, 112: 2, 85: 2, 129: 3} {32: 1, 33: 1, 261: 1, 357: 1, 274: 1, 212: 1, 260: 2, 339: 2, 343: 2, 283: 2, 286: 3, 163: 2, 228: 2, 166: 3, 231: 2, 298: 2, 363: 2, 46: 3, 377: 2} {260, 261, 274, 283, 286, 31, 32, 33, 163, 166, 298, 46, 339, 212, 343, 228, 357, 231, 363, 377} 33 "To support outgoing DetNet MPLS over UDP/IP, an implementation MUST support the provisioning of UDP/IP header information in addition or in place of F-Label(s). The headers for each outgoing packet MUST be based on the configuration information and as defined in RFC7510, with one exception. The one exception is that the UDP Source Port value MUST be set to uniquely identify the DetNet flow. The packet MUST then be handed as a DetNet IP packet, per I-D.ietf-detnet-ip." Based on 06.24 discussions . Also some editorial clean up done . b6b19cc971008a58640a284b24d40e3993c1c42e b6b19cc971008a58640a284b24d40e3993c1c42e draft-ietf-detnet-mpls-over-udp-ip 87a3de23bdd1c53a746e7a7cfa7e3580fd250a5617cc917dab59828f4f4ebc50 ['1c461fe81d5bcf71073032237c90a364fe0acc907c86f9c6b7bdd0239e4a6516', '4a95be10c5590a4fe0ad4da58a231ea010ff214e7dc04107bb1c6ec8b9a8b734', '64c967bf314cd115ae548ad25ff1ac315b8ebae80114c1e6c2cdd1b18c87d311', '77f52e3a27231622bf5419787da9d00710542ed8febd34f0fcf41a407f253254', 'e36f8694636db0304245e6df97b64ed089292f19180d858c0a08452501634022', '651e341460abb4f56484b2921abfc1e41250a07075e5c89fa4decd74cfa782be', '96f49870b665021906e0a8c8967651ea74672ff4f2c95e90f16fb1b6558d8ba3', '658ec33f8cad649513db3a623c44949b0ada07e7b8ea99d6f071aefb52786790', '4838fa3a84bff003216011b4f2c570eba0e5f2b9054e8b8617863ed3fb8e08a9', 'fb473c32d1641464c5377775c886a6ac46a55ab70007e126b180e444120e9206', '87a3de23bdd1c53a746e7a7cfa7e3580fd250a5617cc917dab59828f4f4ebc50', '387497881925e27e3bd09668877e8c2b9a5e4041dcb0108c2e9ef352d1e2c5a5', 'de516a625ab93a18f079c2aff17323130e255b2973920908021f63c9cda0caeb', '0c4e4992cda8f30f80cc2363443762dbc93e76b6cc2de75eaa96840d9a83694d', 'ecf3baef3232eab1bf969290ca738f19d1bb31becf8a7243045e8b6417582b48', 'f36d8fba41a9d248c0828a919f5732c36e25a2809cec7f86b8c2a43ad967ca09', 'e7c612bbe379289bbe432edbe6a3a5fdc3297cf68e0672b4a8a9bed556dab403', 'c5286e5f2f650dc15466adcf108165abf439ed3a89340a782042fe713c6de8ac'] B "to support outgoing detnet mpls over udp/ip, an implementation must support the provisioning of udp/ip header information in addition or in place of f-label(s). the headers for each outgoing packet must be based on the configuration information and as defined in rfc7510, with one exception. the one exception is that the udp source port value must be set to uniquely identify the detnet flow. the packet must then be handed as a detnet ip packet, per i-d.ietf-detnet-ip." {26: 1, 32: 1, 56: 1, 38: 1, 102: 1, 60: 2, 64: 2, 62: 2, 71: 2, 83: 2, 113: 2, 126: 3, 112: 2, 85: 2, 129: 3} {32: 1, 33: 1, 261: 1, 357: 1, 274: 1, 212: 1, 260: 2, 339: 2, 343: 2, 283: 2, 286: 3, 163: 2, 228: 2, 166: 3, 231: 2, 298: 2, 363: 2, 46: 3, 377: 2} {260, 261, 274, 283, 286, 31, 32, 33, 163, 166, 298, 46, 339, 212, 343, 228, 357, 231, 363, 377} 33 "To support receive processing an implementation MUST also support the provisioning of received UDP/IP header information. The provisioned information MUST be used to identify incoming app-flows based on the combination of S-Label and incoming IP/UDP header. Normal receive processing, including PEF and POF can then take place." Based on 06.24 discussions . Also some editorial clean up done . b6b19cc971008a58640a284b24d40e3993c1c42e b6b19cc971008a58640a284b24d40e3993c1c42e draft-ietf-detnet-mpls-over-udp-ip 651e341460abb4f56484b2921abfc1e41250a07075e5c89fa4decd74cfa782be ['1c461fe81d5bcf71073032237c90a364fe0acc907c86f9c6b7bdd0239e4a6516', '4a95be10c5590a4fe0ad4da58a231ea010ff214e7dc04107bb1c6ec8b9a8b734', '64c967bf314cd115ae548ad25ff1ac315b8ebae80114c1e6c2cdd1b18c87d311', '77f52e3a27231622bf5419787da9d00710542ed8febd34f0fcf41a407f253254', 'e36f8694636db0304245e6df97b64ed089292f19180d858c0a08452501634022', '651e341460abb4f56484b2921abfc1e41250a07075e5c89fa4decd74cfa782be', '96f49870b665021906e0a8c8967651ea74672ff4f2c95e90f16fb1b6558d8ba3', '658ec33f8cad649513db3a623c44949b0ada07e7b8ea99d6f071aefb52786790', '4838fa3a84bff003216011b4f2c570eba0e5f2b9054e8b8617863ed3fb8e08a9', 'fb473c32d1641464c5377775c886a6ac46a55ab70007e126b180e444120e9206', '87a3de23bdd1c53a746e7a7cfa7e3580fd250a5617cc917dab59828f4f4ebc50', '387497881925e27e3bd09668877e8c2b9a5e4041dcb0108c2e9ef352d1e2c5a5', 'de516a625ab93a18f079c2aff17323130e255b2973920908021f63c9cda0caeb', '0c4e4992cda8f30f80cc2363443762dbc93e76b6cc2de75eaa96840d9a83694d', 'ecf3baef3232eab1bf969290ca738f19d1bb31becf8a7243045e8b6417582b48', 'f36d8fba41a9d248c0828a919f5732c36e25a2809cec7f86b8c2a43ad967ca09', 'e7c612bbe379289bbe432edbe6a3a5fdc3297cf68e0672b4a8a9bed556dab403', 'c5286e5f2f650dc15466adcf108165abf439ed3a89340a782042fe713c6de8ac'] B "to support receive processing an implementation must also support the provisioning of received udp/ip header information. the provisioned information must be used to identify incoming app-flows based on the combination of s-label and incoming ip/udp header. normal receive processing, including pef and pof can then take place." {26: 1, 32: 1, 56: 1, 38: 1, 102: 1, 60: 2, 64: 2, 62: 2, 71: 2, 83: 2, 113: 2, 126: 3, 112: 2, 85: 2, 129: 3} {32: 1, 33: 1, 261: 1, 357: 1, 274: 1, 212: 1, 260: 2, 339: 2, 343: 2, 283: 2, 286: 3, 163: 2, 228: 2, 166: 3, 231: 2, 298: 2, 363: 2, 46: 3, 377: 2} {260, 261, 274, 283, 286, 31, 32, 33, 163, 166, 298, 46, 339, 212, 343, 228, 357, 231, 363, 377} 33 "Label information (S-label or F-label) to be mapped to UDP/IP flow." Based on 06.24 discussions . Also some editorial clean up done . b6b19cc971008a58640a284b24d40e3993c1c42e b6b19cc971008a58640a284b24d40e3993c1c42e draft-ietf-detnet-mpls-over-udp-ip 4a95be10c5590a4fe0ad4da58a231ea010ff214e7dc04107bb1c6ec8b9a8b734 ['1c461fe81d5bcf71073032237c90a364fe0acc907c86f9c6b7bdd0239e4a6516', '4a95be10c5590a4fe0ad4da58a231ea010ff214e7dc04107bb1c6ec8b9a8b734', '64c967bf314cd115ae548ad25ff1ac315b8ebae80114c1e6c2cdd1b18c87d311', '77f52e3a27231622bf5419787da9d00710542ed8febd34f0fcf41a407f253254', 'e36f8694636db0304245e6df97b64ed089292f19180d858c0a08452501634022', '651e341460abb4f56484b2921abfc1e41250a07075e5c89fa4decd74cfa782be', '96f49870b665021906e0a8c8967651ea74672ff4f2c95e90f16fb1b6558d8ba3', '658ec33f8cad649513db3a623c44949b0ada07e7b8ea99d6f071aefb52786790', '4838fa3a84bff003216011b4f2c570eba0e5f2b9054e8b8617863ed3fb8e08a9', 'fb473c32d1641464c5377775c886a6ac46a55ab70007e126b180e444120e9206', '87a3de23bdd1c53a746e7a7cfa7e3580fd250a5617cc917dab59828f4f4ebc50', '387497881925e27e3bd09668877e8c2b9a5e4041dcb0108c2e9ef352d1e2c5a5', 'de516a625ab93a18f079c2aff17323130e255b2973920908021f63c9cda0caeb', '0c4e4992cda8f30f80cc2363443762dbc93e76b6cc2de75eaa96840d9a83694d', 'ecf3baef3232eab1bf969290ca738f19d1bb31becf8a7243045e8b6417582b48', 'f36d8fba41a9d248c0828a919f5732c36e25a2809cec7f86b8c2a43ad967ca09', 'e7c612bbe379289bbe432edbe6a3a5fdc3297cf68e0672b4a8a9bed556dab403', 'c5286e5f2f650dc15466adcf108165abf439ed3a89340a782042fe713c6de8ac'] B "label information (s-label or f-label) to be mapped to udp/ip flow." {26: 1, 32: 1, 56: 1, 38: 1, 102: 1, 60: 2, 64: 2, 62: 2, 71: 2, 83: 2, 113: 2, 126: 3, 112: 2, 85: 2, 129: 3} {32: 1, 33: 1, 261: 1, 357: 1, 274: 1, 212: 1, 260: 2, 339: 2, 343: 2, 283: 2, 286: 3, 163: 2, 228: 2, 166: 3, 231: 2, 298: 2, 363: 2, 46: 3, 377: 2} {260, 261, 274, 283, 286, 31, 32, 33, 163, 166, 298, 46, 339, 212, 343, 228, 357, 231, 363, 377} 33 IPv4 protocol field. Only UDP is allowed. Based on 06.24 discussions . Also some editorial clean up done . b6b19cc971008a58640a284b24d40e3993c1c42e b6b19cc971008a58640a284b24d40e3993c1c42e draft-ietf-detnet-mpls-over-udp-ip 0c4e4992cda8f30f80cc2363443762dbc93e76b6cc2de75eaa96840d9a83694d ['1c461fe81d5bcf71073032237c90a364fe0acc907c86f9c6b7bdd0239e4a6516', '4a95be10c5590a4fe0ad4da58a231ea010ff214e7dc04107bb1c6ec8b9a8b734', '64c967bf314cd115ae548ad25ff1ac315b8ebae80114c1e6c2cdd1b18c87d311', '77f52e3a27231622bf5419787da9d00710542ed8febd34f0fcf41a407f253254', 'e36f8694636db0304245e6df97b64ed089292f19180d858c0a08452501634022', '651e341460abb4f56484b2921abfc1e41250a07075e5c89fa4decd74cfa782be', '96f49870b665021906e0a8c8967651ea74672ff4f2c95e90f16fb1b6558d8ba3', '658ec33f8cad649513db3a623c44949b0ada07e7b8ea99d6f071aefb52786790', '4838fa3a84bff003216011b4f2c570eba0e5f2b9054e8b8617863ed3fb8e08a9', 'fb473c32d1641464c5377775c886a6ac46a55ab70007e126b180e444120e9206', '87a3de23bdd1c53a746e7a7cfa7e3580fd250a5617cc917dab59828f4f4ebc50', '387497881925e27e3bd09668877e8c2b9a5e4041dcb0108c2e9ef352d1e2c5a5', 'de516a625ab93a18f079c2aff17323130e255b2973920908021f63c9cda0caeb', '0c4e4992cda8f30f80cc2363443762dbc93e76b6cc2de75eaa96840d9a83694d', 'ecf3baef3232eab1bf969290ca738f19d1bb31becf8a7243045e8b6417582b48', 'f36d8fba41a9d248c0828a919f5732c36e25a2809cec7f86b8c2a43ad967ca09', 'e7c612bbe379289bbe432edbe6a3a5fdc3297cf68e0672b4a8a9bed556dab403', 'c5286e5f2f650dc15466adcf108165abf439ed3a89340a782042fe713c6de8ac'] B ipv4 protocol field. only udp is allowed. {26: 1, 32: 1, 56: 1, 38: 1, 102: 1, 60: 2, 64: 2, 62: 2, 71: 2, 83: 2, 113: 2, 126: 3, 112: 2, 85: 2, 129: 3} {32: 1, 33: 1, 261: 1, 357: 1, 274: 1, 212: 1, 260: 2, 339: 2, 343: 2, 283: 2, 286: 3, 163: 2, 228: 2, 166: 3, 231: 2, 298: 2, 363: 2, 46: 3, 377: 2} {260, 261, 274, 283, 286, 31, 32, 33, 163, 166, 298, 46, 339, 212, 343, 228, 357, 231, 363, 377} 33 IPv6 next header field. Only UDP is allowed. Based on 06.24 discussions . Also some editorial clean up done . b6b19cc971008a58640a284b24d40e3993c1c42e b6b19cc971008a58640a284b24d40e3993c1c42e draft-ietf-detnet-mpls-over-udp-ip de516a625ab93a18f079c2aff17323130e255b2973920908021f63c9cda0caeb ['1c461fe81d5bcf71073032237c90a364fe0acc907c86f9c6b7bdd0239e4a6516', '4a95be10c5590a4fe0ad4da58a231ea010ff214e7dc04107bb1c6ec8b9a8b734', '64c967bf314cd115ae548ad25ff1ac315b8ebae80114c1e6c2cdd1b18c87d311', '77f52e3a27231622bf5419787da9d00710542ed8febd34f0fcf41a407f253254', 'e36f8694636db0304245e6df97b64ed089292f19180d858c0a08452501634022', '651e341460abb4f56484b2921abfc1e41250a07075e5c89fa4decd74cfa782be', '96f49870b665021906e0a8c8967651ea74672ff4f2c95e90f16fb1b6558d8ba3', '658ec33f8cad649513db3a623c44949b0ada07e7b8ea99d6f071aefb52786790', '4838fa3a84bff003216011b4f2c570eba0e5f2b9054e8b8617863ed3fb8e08a9', 'fb473c32d1641464c5377775c886a6ac46a55ab70007e126b180e444120e9206', '87a3de23bdd1c53a746e7a7cfa7e3580fd250a5617cc917dab59828f4f4ebc50', '387497881925e27e3bd09668877e8c2b9a5e4041dcb0108c2e9ef352d1e2c5a5', 'de516a625ab93a18f079c2aff17323130e255b2973920908021f63c9cda0caeb', '0c4e4992cda8f30f80cc2363443762dbc93e76b6cc2de75eaa96840d9a83694d', 'ecf3baef3232eab1bf969290ca738f19d1bb31becf8a7243045e8b6417582b48', 'f36d8fba41a9d248c0828a919f5732c36e25a2809cec7f86b8c2a43ad967ca09', 'e7c612bbe379289bbe432edbe6a3a5fdc3297cf68e0672b4a8a9bed556dab403', 'c5286e5f2f650dc15466adcf108165abf439ed3a89340a782042fe713c6de8ac'] B ipv6 next header field. only udp is allowed. {26: 1, 32: 1, 56: 1, 38: 1, 102: 1, 60: 2, 64: 2, 62: 2, 71: 2, 83: 2, 113: 2, 126: 3, 112: 2, 85: 2, 129: 3} {32: 1, 33: 1, 261: 1, 357: 1, 274: 1, 212: 1, 260: 2, 339: 2, 343: 2, 283: 2, 286: 3, 163: 2, 228: 2, 166: 3, 231: 2, 298: 2, 363: 2, 46: 3, 377: 2} {260, 261, 274, 283, 286, 31, 32, 33, 163, 166, 298, 46, 339, 212, 343, 228, 357, 231, 363, 377} 33 UDP Source Port. Based on 06.24 discussions . Also some editorial clean up done . b6b19cc971008a58640a284b24d40e3993c1c42e b6b19cc971008a58640a284b24d40e3993c1c42e draft-ietf-detnet-mpls-over-udp-ip e7c612bbe379289bbe432edbe6a3a5fdc3297cf68e0672b4a8a9bed556dab403 ['1c461fe81d5bcf71073032237c90a364fe0acc907c86f9c6b7bdd0239e4a6516', '4a95be10c5590a4fe0ad4da58a231ea010ff214e7dc04107bb1c6ec8b9a8b734', '64c967bf314cd115ae548ad25ff1ac315b8ebae80114c1e6c2cdd1b18c87d311', '77f52e3a27231622bf5419787da9d00710542ed8febd34f0fcf41a407f253254', 'e36f8694636db0304245e6df97b64ed089292f19180d858c0a08452501634022', '651e341460abb4f56484b2921abfc1e41250a07075e5c89fa4decd74cfa782be', '96f49870b665021906e0a8c8967651ea74672ff4f2c95e90f16fb1b6558d8ba3', '658ec33f8cad649513db3a623c44949b0ada07e7b8ea99d6f071aefb52786790', '4838fa3a84bff003216011b4f2c570eba0e5f2b9054e8b8617863ed3fb8e08a9', 'fb473c32d1641464c5377775c886a6ac46a55ab70007e126b180e444120e9206', '87a3de23bdd1c53a746e7a7cfa7e3580fd250a5617cc917dab59828f4f4ebc50', '387497881925e27e3bd09668877e8c2b9a5e4041dcb0108c2e9ef352d1e2c5a5', 'de516a625ab93a18f079c2aff17323130e255b2973920908021f63c9cda0caeb', '0c4e4992cda8f30f80cc2363443762dbc93e76b6cc2de75eaa96840d9a83694d', 'ecf3baef3232eab1bf969290ca738f19d1bb31becf8a7243045e8b6417582b48', 'f36d8fba41a9d248c0828a919f5732c36e25a2809cec7f86b8c2a43ad967ca09', 'e7c612bbe379289bbe432edbe6a3a5fdc3297cf68e0672b4a8a9bed556dab403', 'c5286e5f2f650dc15466adcf108165abf439ed3a89340a782042fe713c6de8ac'] B udp source port. {26: 1, 32: 1, 56: 1, 38: 1, 102: 1, 60: 2, 64: 2, 62: 2, 71: 2, 83: 2, 113: 2, 126: 3, 112: 2, 85: 2, 129: 3} {32: 1, 33: 1, 261: 1, 357: 1, 274: 1, 212: 1, 260: 2, 339: 2, 343: 2, 283: 2, 286: 3, 163: 2, 228: 2, 166: 3, 231: 2, 298: 2, 363: 2, 46: 3, 377: 2} {260, 261, 274, 283, 286, 31, 32, 33, 163, 166, 298, 46, 339, 212, 343, 228, 357, 231, 363, 377} 33 UDP Destination Port. Based on 06.24 discussions . Also some editorial clean up done . b6b19cc971008a58640a284b24d40e3993c1c42e b6b19cc971008a58640a284b24d40e3993c1c42e draft-ietf-detnet-mpls-over-udp-ip 387497881925e27e3bd09668877e8c2b9a5e4041dcb0108c2e9ef352d1e2c5a5 ['1c461fe81d5bcf71073032237c90a364fe0acc907c86f9c6b7bdd0239e4a6516', '4a95be10c5590a4fe0ad4da58a231ea010ff214e7dc04107bb1c6ec8b9a8b734', '64c967bf314cd115ae548ad25ff1ac315b8ebae80114c1e6c2cdd1b18c87d311', '77f52e3a27231622bf5419787da9d00710542ed8febd34f0fcf41a407f253254', 'e36f8694636db0304245e6df97b64ed089292f19180d858c0a08452501634022', '651e341460abb4f56484b2921abfc1e41250a07075e5c89fa4decd74cfa782be', '96f49870b665021906e0a8c8967651ea74672ff4f2c95e90f16fb1b6558d8ba3', '658ec33f8cad649513db3a623c44949b0ada07e7b8ea99d6f071aefb52786790', '4838fa3a84bff003216011b4f2c570eba0e5f2b9054e8b8617863ed3fb8e08a9', 'fb473c32d1641464c5377775c886a6ac46a55ab70007e126b180e444120e9206', '87a3de23bdd1c53a746e7a7cfa7e3580fd250a5617cc917dab59828f4f4ebc50', '387497881925e27e3bd09668877e8c2b9a5e4041dcb0108c2e9ef352d1e2c5a5', 'de516a625ab93a18f079c2aff17323130e255b2973920908021f63c9cda0caeb', '0c4e4992cda8f30f80cc2363443762dbc93e76b6cc2de75eaa96840d9a83694d', 'ecf3baef3232eab1bf969290ca738f19d1bb31becf8a7243045e8b6417582b48', 'f36d8fba41a9d248c0828a919f5732c36e25a2809cec7f86b8c2a43ad967ca09', 'e7c612bbe379289bbe432edbe6a3a5fdc3297cf68e0672b4a8a9bed556dab403', 'c5286e5f2f650dc15466adcf108165abf439ed3a89340a782042fe713c6de8ac'] B udp destination port. {26: 1, 32: 1, 56: 1, 38: 1, 102: 1, 60: 2, 64: 2, 62: 2, 71: 2, 83: 2, 113: 2, 126: 3, 112: 2, 85: 2, 129: 3} {32: 1, 33: 1, 261: 1, 357: 1, 274: 1, 212: 1, 260: 2, 339: 2, 343: 2, 283: 2, 286: 3, 163: 2, 228: 2, 166: 3, 231: 2, 298: 2, 363: 2, 46: 3, 377: 2} {260, 261, 274, 283, 286, 31, 32, 33, 163, 166, 298, 46, 339, 212, 343, 228, 357, 231, 363, 377} 32 "This document builds on the specification of MPLS over UDP and IP defined in RFC7510. It replaces the F-Label(s) used in I-D.ietf- detnet-mpls with UDP and IP headers. The UDP and IP header information is used to identify DetNet flows, including member flows, per I-D.ietf-detnet-ip. The resulting encapsulation is shown in IP- encap-dn." "Based on 06.17 discussions . F - lables(s ) to Fig1 and text fixed . Adding procedures sections . Multiple notes for clarifications . Adding controller plane section . reviewed in Jun 24 meeting" c3a02ebab509385544d23fbbc8adf8bccb46e274 c3a02ebab509385544d23fbbc8adf8bccb46e274 draft-ietf-detnet-mpls-over-udp-ip 8243889a2fb62c35424a6acec73aa33fe9242ee50d212c3a83ad80ba4b2ebe96 ['ffc3e5ff3f5d3eed0ec6f14260b6af8f36659d90264c1ca79b7e77b96fe58964', '8243889a2fb62c35424a6acec73aa33fe9242ee50d212c3a83ad80ba4b2ebe96'] A "this document builds on the specification of mpls over udp and ip defined in rfc7510. it replaces the f-label(s) used in i-d.ietf- detnet-mpls with udp and ip headers. the udp and ip header information is used to identify detnet flows, including member flows, per i-d.ietf-detnet-ip. the resulting encapsulation is shown in ip- encap-dn." {33: 1} {413: 1} {412, 413} 32 "This document builds on the specification of MPLS over UDP and IP defined in RFC7510. It may replace partly or entirely the F-Label(s) used in I-D.ietf-detnet-mpls with UDP and IP headers. The UDP and IP header information is used to identify DetNet flows, including member flows, per I-D.ietf-detnet-ip. The resulting encapsulation is shown in IP-encap-dn. There may be zero or more F-label(s) between the S-label and the UDP header." "Based on 06.17 discussions . F - lables(s ) to Fig1 and text fixed . Adding procedures sections . Multiple notes for clarifications . Adding controller plane section . reviewed in Jun 24 meeting" c3a02ebab509385544d23fbbc8adf8bccb46e274 c3a02ebab509385544d23fbbc8adf8bccb46e274 draft-ietf-detnet-mpls-over-udp-ip ffc3e5ff3f5d3eed0ec6f14260b6af8f36659d90264c1ca79b7e77b96fe58964 ['ffc3e5ff3f5d3eed0ec6f14260b6af8f36659d90264c1ca79b7e77b96fe58964', '8243889a2fb62c35424a6acec73aa33fe9242ee50d212c3a83ad80ba4b2ebe96'] B "this document builds on the specification of mpls over udp and ip defined in rfc7510. it may replace partly or entirely the f-label(s) used in i-d.ietf-detnet-mpls with udp and ip headers. the udp and ip header information is used to identify detnet flows, including member flows, per i-d.ietf-detnet-ip. the resulting encapsulation is shown in ip-encap-dn. there may be zero or more f-label(s) between the s-label and the udp header." {33: 1} {413: 1} {412, 413} 32 "To support outgoing DetNet MPLS over IP, an implementation MUST support the provisioning of IP/UDP header information in place of sets of F-Labels. Note that multiple sets of F-Labels can be provisioned to support PRF on transmitted DetNet flows and therefore, when PRF is supported, multiple IP/UDP headers MAY be provisioned. When multiple IP/UDP headers are provisioned for a particular outgoing DetNet IP flow, a copy of the outgoing packet, including the pushed S-Label, MUST be made for each. The headers for each outgoing packet MUST be based on the configuration information and as defined in RFC7510, with one exception. The one exception is that the UDP Source Port value MUST be set to uniquely identify the DetNet (forwarding sub-layer) flow. The packet MUST then be handed as a DetNet IP packet, per I-D.ietf-detnet-ip." "Based on 06.17 discussions . F - lables(s ) to Fig1 and text fixed . Adding procedures sections . Multiple notes for clarifications . Adding controller plane section . reviewed in Jun 24 meeting" c3a02ebab509385544d23fbbc8adf8bccb46e274 c3a02ebab509385544d23fbbc8adf8bccb46e274 draft-ietf-detnet-mpls-over-udp-ip b1798f9c8aa638befd15d3315aae7511395c774ff90235dbe1947dc162d80ed9 ['1c461fe81d5bcf71073032237c90a364fe0acc907c86f9c6b7bdd0239e4a6516', '64c967bf314cd115ae548ad25ff1ac315b8ebae80114c1e6c2cdd1b18c87d311', 'ed421dfbc499208b19c13c14f07492fc0a6d8112c65bed9315f7f3d2b27f8234', '77f52e3a27231622bf5419787da9d00710542ed8febd34f0fcf41a407f253254', '78e5c37125916ed96a19fc61f4632c7048556a2d27efd6661850cdb5dff8b0de', 'e36f8694636db0304245e6df97b64ed089292f19180d858c0a08452501634022', 'b1798f9c8aa638befd15d3315aae7511395c774ff90235dbe1947dc162d80ed9', '96f49870b665021906e0a8c8967651ea74672ff4f2c95e90f16fb1b6558d8ba3', 'e7f225ef9a06fd47806688cd089056e54cd35ac274590842e03d9353d81d6c78', '4f7a168d3aabe87035387dd5ed5d34faa28fab189b0c1b7473456086f1761fc8', '658ec33f8cad649513db3a623c44949b0ada07e7b8ea99d6f071aefb52786790', '4838fa3a84bff003216011b4f2c570eba0e5f2b9054e8b8617863ed3fb8e08a9', 'c5286e5f2f650dc15466adcf108165abf439ed3a89340a782042fe713c6de8ac', 'fb473c32d1641464c5377775c886a6ac46a55ab70007e126b180e444120e9206', 'ecf3baef3232eab1bf969290ca738f19d1bb31becf8a7243045e8b6417582b48', 'f36d8fba41a9d248c0828a919f5732c36e25a2809cec7f86b8c2a43ad967ca09', '9342ca6d50ed2fbe47d699d8ce2e5c82fe69e8aa2ace8cc64d89f65a7d7257cf', 'bc79ce01a05be22183c6aa6db4fbc2c25eb19cc11ddba3f100f412ecb7d49863'] A "to support outgoing detnet mpls over ip, an implementation must support the provisioning of ip/udp header information in place of sets of f-labels. note that multiple sets of f-labels can be provisioned to support prf on transmitted detnet flows and therefore, when prf is supported, multiple ip/udp headers may be provisioned. when multiple ip/udp headers are provisioned for a particular outgoing detnet ip flow, a copy of the outgoing packet, including the pushed s-label, must be made for each. the headers for each outgoing packet must be based on the configuration information and as defined in rfc7510, with one exception. the one exception is that the udp source port value must be set to uniquely identify the detnet (forwarding sub-layer) flow. the packet must then be handed as a detnet ip packet, per i-d.ietf-detnet-ip." {33: 1, 26: 1, 113: 1, 56: 1, 64: 1, 112: 1, 102: 1, 71: 1, 60: 2, 38: 2, 62: 2, 83: 2, 126: 2, 85: 2, 129: 2} {31: 1, 32: 1, 228: 1, 261: 1, 231: 1, 298: 1, 274: 1, 377: 1, 260: 2, 339: 3, 212: 2, 343: 2, 283: 2, 286: 4, 163: 2, 357: 2, 166: 2, 363: 2, 46: 2} {260, 261, 274, 283, 286, 31, 32, 33, 163, 166, 298, 46, 339, 212, 343, 228, 357, 231, 363, 377} 32 "To support receive processing an implementation MUST also support the provisioning of received IP/UDP header information. When S-Labels are taken from platform label space, all that is required is to provision that receiving IP/UDP encapsulated DetNet MPLS packets is permitted. Once the IP/UDP header is stripped, the S-label uniquely identifies the app-flow. When S-Labels are not taken from platform label space, IP/UDP header information MUST be provisioned. The provisioned information MUST then be used to identify incoming app- flows based on the combination of S-Label and incoming IP/UDP header. Normal receive processing, including PEOF can then take place." "Based on 06.17 discussions . F - lables(s ) to Fig1 and text fixed . Adding procedures sections . Multiple notes for clarifications . Adding controller plane section . reviewed in Jun 24 meeting" c3a02ebab509385544d23fbbc8adf8bccb46e274 c3a02ebab509385544d23fbbc8adf8bccb46e274 draft-ietf-detnet-mpls-over-udp-ip e7f225ef9a06fd47806688cd089056e54cd35ac274590842e03d9353d81d6c78 ['1c461fe81d5bcf71073032237c90a364fe0acc907c86f9c6b7bdd0239e4a6516', '64c967bf314cd115ae548ad25ff1ac315b8ebae80114c1e6c2cdd1b18c87d311', 'ed421dfbc499208b19c13c14f07492fc0a6d8112c65bed9315f7f3d2b27f8234', '77f52e3a27231622bf5419787da9d00710542ed8febd34f0fcf41a407f253254', '78e5c37125916ed96a19fc61f4632c7048556a2d27efd6661850cdb5dff8b0de', 'e36f8694636db0304245e6df97b64ed089292f19180d858c0a08452501634022', 'b1798f9c8aa638befd15d3315aae7511395c774ff90235dbe1947dc162d80ed9', '96f49870b665021906e0a8c8967651ea74672ff4f2c95e90f16fb1b6558d8ba3', 'e7f225ef9a06fd47806688cd089056e54cd35ac274590842e03d9353d81d6c78', '4f7a168d3aabe87035387dd5ed5d34faa28fab189b0c1b7473456086f1761fc8', '658ec33f8cad649513db3a623c44949b0ada07e7b8ea99d6f071aefb52786790', '4838fa3a84bff003216011b4f2c570eba0e5f2b9054e8b8617863ed3fb8e08a9', 'c5286e5f2f650dc15466adcf108165abf439ed3a89340a782042fe713c6de8ac', 'fb473c32d1641464c5377775c886a6ac46a55ab70007e126b180e444120e9206', 'ecf3baef3232eab1bf969290ca738f19d1bb31becf8a7243045e8b6417582b48', 'f36d8fba41a9d248c0828a919f5732c36e25a2809cec7f86b8c2a43ad967ca09', '9342ca6d50ed2fbe47d699d8ce2e5c82fe69e8aa2ace8cc64d89f65a7d7257cf', 'bc79ce01a05be22183c6aa6db4fbc2c25eb19cc11ddba3f100f412ecb7d49863'] A "to support receive processing an implementation must also support the provisioning of received ip/udp header information. when s-labels are taken from platform label space, all that is required is to provision that receiving ip/udp encapsulated detnet mpls packets is permitted. once the ip/udp header is stripped, the s-label uniquely identifies the app-flow. when s-labels are not taken from platform label space, ip/udp header information must be provisioned. the provisioned information must then be used to identify incoming app- flows based on the combination of s-label and incoming ip/udp header. normal receive processing, including peof can then take place." {33: 1, 26: 1, 113: 1, 56: 1, 64: 1, 112: 1, 102: 1, 71: 1, 60: 2, 38: 2, 62: 2, 83: 2, 126: 2, 85: 2, 129: 2} {31: 1, 32: 1, 228: 1, 261: 1, 231: 1, 298: 1, 274: 1, 377: 1, 260: 2, 339: 3, 212: 2, 343: 2, 283: 2, 286: 4, 163: 2, 357: 2, 166: 2, 363: 2, 46: 2} {260, 261, 274, 283, 286, 31, 32, 33, 163, 166, 298, 46, 339, 212, 343, 228, 357, 231, 363, 377} 32 "To support outgoing DetNet MPLS over UDP/IP, an implementation MUST support the provisioning of UDP/IP header information in addition or in place of sets of F-Label(s). Note that multiple sets of F-Labels can be provisioned to support PRF on transmitted DetNet MPLS flows and therefore, when PRF is supported, multiple UDP/IP headers MAY be provisioned." "Based on 06.17 discussions . F - lables(s ) to Fig1 and text fixed . Adding procedures sections . Multiple notes for clarifications . Adding controller plane section . reviewed in Jun 24 meeting" c3a02ebab509385544d23fbbc8adf8bccb46e274 c3a02ebab509385544d23fbbc8adf8bccb46e274 draft-ietf-detnet-mpls-over-udp-ip f36d8fba41a9d248c0828a919f5732c36e25a2809cec7f86b8c2a43ad967ca09 ['1c461fe81d5bcf71073032237c90a364fe0acc907c86f9c6b7bdd0239e4a6516', '64c967bf314cd115ae548ad25ff1ac315b8ebae80114c1e6c2cdd1b18c87d311', 'ed421dfbc499208b19c13c14f07492fc0a6d8112c65bed9315f7f3d2b27f8234', '77f52e3a27231622bf5419787da9d00710542ed8febd34f0fcf41a407f253254', '78e5c37125916ed96a19fc61f4632c7048556a2d27efd6661850cdb5dff8b0de', 'e36f8694636db0304245e6df97b64ed089292f19180d858c0a08452501634022', 'b1798f9c8aa638befd15d3315aae7511395c774ff90235dbe1947dc162d80ed9', '96f49870b665021906e0a8c8967651ea74672ff4f2c95e90f16fb1b6558d8ba3', 'e7f225ef9a06fd47806688cd089056e54cd35ac274590842e03d9353d81d6c78', '4f7a168d3aabe87035387dd5ed5d34faa28fab189b0c1b7473456086f1761fc8', '658ec33f8cad649513db3a623c44949b0ada07e7b8ea99d6f071aefb52786790', '4838fa3a84bff003216011b4f2c570eba0e5f2b9054e8b8617863ed3fb8e08a9', 'c5286e5f2f650dc15466adcf108165abf439ed3a89340a782042fe713c6de8ac', 'fb473c32d1641464c5377775c886a6ac46a55ab70007e126b180e444120e9206', 'ecf3baef3232eab1bf969290ca738f19d1bb31becf8a7243045e8b6417582b48', 'f36d8fba41a9d248c0828a919f5732c36e25a2809cec7f86b8c2a43ad967ca09', '9342ca6d50ed2fbe47d699d8ce2e5c82fe69e8aa2ace8cc64d89f65a7d7257cf', 'bc79ce01a05be22183c6aa6db4fbc2c25eb19cc11ddba3f100f412ecb7d49863'] B "to support outgoing detnet mpls over udp/ip, an implementation must support the provisioning of udp/ip header information in addition or in place of sets of f-label(s). note that multiple sets of f-labels can be provisioned to support prf on transmitted detnet mpls flows and therefore, when prf is supported, multiple udp/ip headers may be provisioned." {33: 1, 26: 1, 113: 1, 56: 1, 64: 1, 112: 1, 102: 1, 71: 1, 60: 2, 38: 2, 62: 2, 83: 2, 126: 2, 85: 2, 129: 2} {31: 1, 32: 1, 228: 1, 261: 1, 231: 1, 298: 1, 274: 1, 377: 1, 260: 2, 339: 3, 212: 2, 343: 2, 283: 2, 286: 4, 163: 2, 357: 2, 166: 2, 363: 2, 46: 2} {260, 261, 274, 283, 286, 31, 32, 33, 163, 166, 298, 46, 339, 212, 343, 228, 357, 231, 363, 377} 32 "When multiple UDP/IP headers are provisioned for a particular outgoing DetNet IP flow, a copy of the outgoing packet, including the pushed S-Label (and optional F-label(s)), MUST be made for each. The headers for each outgoing packet MUST be based on the configuration information and as defined in RFC7510, with one exception. The one exception is that the UDP Source Port value MUST be set to uniquely identify the DetNet (forwarding sub-layer) flow. The packet MUST then be handed as a DetNet IP packet, per I-D.ietf-detnet-ip." "Based on 06.17 discussions . F - lables(s ) to Fig1 and text fixed . Adding procedures sections . Multiple notes for clarifications . Adding controller plane section . reviewed in Jun 24 meeting" c3a02ebab509385544d23fbbc8adf8bccb46e274 c3a02ebab509385544d23fbbc8adf8bccb46e274 draft-ietf-detnet-mpls-over-udp-ip e36f8694636db0304245e6df97b64ed089292f19180d858c0a08452501634022 ['1c461fe81d5bcf71073032237c90a364fe0acc907c86f9c6b7bdd0239e4a6516', '64c967bf314cd115ae548ad25ff1ac315b8ebae80114c1e6c2cdd1b18c87d311', 'ed421dfbc499208b19c13c14f07492fc0a6d8112c65bed9315f7f3d2b27f8234', '77f52e3a27231622bf5419787da9d00710542ed8febd34f0fcf41a407f253254', '78e5c37125916ed96a19fc61f4632c7048556a2d27efd6661850cdb5dff8b0de', 'e36f8694636db0304245e6df97b64ed089292f19180d858c0a08452501634022', 'b1798f9c8aa638befd15d3315aae7511395c774ff90235dbe1947dc162d80ed9', '96f49870b665021906e0a8c8967651ea74672ff4f2c95e90f16fb1b6558d8ba3', 'e7f225ef9a06fd47806688cd089056e54cd35ac274590842e03d9353d81d6c78', '4f7a168d3aabe87035387dd5ed5d34faa28fab189b0c1b7473456086f1761fc8', '658ec33f8cad649513db3a623c44949b0ada07e7b8ea99d6f071aefb52786790', '4838fa3a84bff003216011b4f2c570eba0e5f2b9054e8b8617863ed3fb8e08a9', 'c5286e5f2f650dc15466adcf108165abf439ed3a89340a782042fe713c6de8ac', 'fb473c32d1641464c5377775c886a6ac46a55ab70007e126b180e444120e9206', 'ecf3baef3232eab1bf969290ca738f19d1bb31becf8a7243045e8b6417582b48', 'f36d8fba41a9d248c0828a919f5732c36e25a2809cec7f86b8c2a43ad967ca09', '9342ca6d50ed2fbe47d699d8ce2e5c82fe69e8aa2ace8cc64d89f65a7d7257cf', 'bc79ce01a05be22183c6aa6db4fbc2c25eb19cc11ddba3f100f412ecb7d49863'] B "when multiple udp/ip headers are provisioned for a particular outgoing detnet ip flow, a copy of the outgoing packet, including the pushed s-label (and optional f-label(s)), must be made for each. the headers for each outgoing packet must be based on the configuration information and as defined in rfc7510, with one exception. the one exception is that the udp source port value must be set to uniquely identify the detnet (forwarding sub-layer) flow. the packet must then be handed as a detnet ip packet, per i-d.ietf-detnet-ip." {33: 1, 26: 1, 113: 1, 56: 1, 64: 1, 112: 1, 102: 1, 71: 1, 60: 2, 38: 2, 62: 2, 83: 2, 126: 2, 85: 2, 129: 2} {31: 1, 32: 1, 228: 1, 261: 1, 231: 1, 298: 1, 274: 1, 377: 1, 260: 2, 339: 3, 212: 2, 343: 2, 283: 2, 286: 4, 163: 2, 357: 2, 166: 2, 363: 2, 46: 2} {260, 261, 274, 283, 286, 31, 32, 33, 163, 166, 298, 46, 339, 212, 343, 228, 357, 231, 363, 377} 32 "To support receive processing an implementation MUST also support the provisioning of received UDP/IP header information." "Based on 06.17 discussions . F - lables(s ) to Fig1 and text fixed . Adding procedures sections . Multiple notes for clarifications . Adding controller plane section . reviewed in Jun 24 meeting" c3a02ebab509385544d23fbbc8adf8bccb46e274 c3a02ebab509385544d23fbbc8adf8bccb46e274 draft-ietf-detnet-mpls-over-udp-ip 4838fa3a84bff003216011b4f2c570eba0e5f2b9054e8b8617863ed3fb8e08a9 ['1c461fe81d5bcf71073032237c90a364fe0acc907c86f9c6b7bdd0239e4a6516', '64c967bf314cd115ae548ad25ff1ac315b8ebae80114c1e6c2cdd1b18c87d311', 'ed421dfbc499208b19c13c14f07492fc0a6d8112c65bed9315f7f3d2b27f8234', '77f52e3a27231622bf5419787da9d00710542ed8febd34f0fcf41a407f253254', '78e5c37125916ed96a19fc61f4632c7048556a2d27efd6661850cdb5dff8b0de', 'e36f8694636db0304245e6df97b64ed089292f19180d858c0a08452501634022', 'b1798f9c8aa638befd15d3315aae7511395c774ff90235dbe1947dc162d80ed9', '96f49870b665021906e0a8c8967651ea74672ff4f2c95e90f16fb1b6558d8ba3', 'e7f225ef9a06fd47806688cd089056e54cd35ac274590842e03d9353d81d6c78', '4f7a168d3aabe87035387dd5ed5d34faa28fab189b0c1b7473456086f1761fc8', '658ec33f8cad649513db3a623c44949b0ada07e7b8ea99d6f071aefb52786790', '4838fa3a84bff003216011b4f2c570eba0e5f2b9054e8b8617863ed3fb8e08a9', 'c5286e5f2f650dc15466adcf108165abf439ed3a89340a782042fe713c6de8ac', 'fb473c32d1641464c5377775c886a6ac46a55ab70007e126b180e444120e9206', 'ecf3baef3232eab1bf969290ca738f19d1bb31becf8a7243045e8b6417582b48', 'f36d8fba41a9d248c0828a919f5732c36e25a2809cec7f86b8c2a43ad967ca09', '9342ca6d50ed2fbe47d699d8ce2e5c82fe69e8aa2ace8cc64d89f65a7d7257cf', 'bc79ce01a05be22183c6aa6db4fbc2c25eb19cc11ddba3f100f412ecb7d49863'] B "to support receive processing an implementation must also support the provisioning of received udp/ip header information." {33: 1, 26: 1, 113: 1, 56: 1, 64: 1, 112: 1, 102: 1, 71: 1, 60: 2, 38: 2, 62: 2, 83: 2, 126: 2, 85: 2, 129: 2} {31: 1, 32: 1, 228: 1, 261: 1, 231: 1, 298: 1, 274: 1, 377: 1, 260: 2, 339: 3, 212: 2, 343: 2, 283: 2, 286: 4, 163: 2, 357: 2, 166: 2, 363: 2, 46: 2} {260, 261, 274, 283, 286, 31, 32, 33, 163, 166, 298, 46, 339, 212, 343, 228, 357, 231, 363, 377} 32 "When S-Labels are taken from platform label space, all that is required is to provision that receiving UDP/IP encapsulated DetNet MPLS packets is permitted. Once the UDP/IP header is stripped, the S-label uniquely identifies the app-flow. When S-Labels are not taken from platform label space, UDP/IP header information MUST be provisioned. The provisioned information MUST then be used to identify incoming app-flows based on the combination of S-Label and incoming IP/UDP header. Normal receive processing, including PEOF can then take place." "Based on 06.17 discussions . F - lables(s ) to Fig1 and text fixed . Adding procedures sections . Multiple notes for clarifications . Adding controller plane section . reviewed in Jun 24 meeting" c3a02ebab509385544d23fbbc8adf8bccb46e274 c3a02ebab509385544d23fbbc8adf8bccb46e274 draft-ietf-detnet-mpls-over-udp-ip 77f52e3a27231622bf5419787da9d00710542ed8febd34f0fcf41a407f253254 ['1c461fe81d5bcf71073032237c90a364fe0acc907c86f9c6b7bdd0239e4a6516', '64c967bf314cd115ae548ad25ff1ac315b8ebae80114c1e6c2cdd1b18c87d311', 'ed421dfbc499208b19c13c14f07492fc0a6d8112c65bed9315f7f3d2b27f8234', '77f52e3a27231622bf5419787da9d00710542ed8febd34f0fcf41a407f253254', '78e5c37125916ed96a19fc61f4632c7048556a2d27efd6661850cdb5dff8b0de', 'e36f8694636db0304245e6df97b64ed089292f19180d858c0a08452501634022', 'b1798f9c8aa638befd15d3315aae7511395c774ff90235dbe1947dc162d80ed9', '96f49870b665021906e0a8c8967651ea74672ff4f2c95e90f16fb1b6558d8ba3', 'e7f225ef9a06fd47806688cd089056e54cd35ac274590842e03d9353d81d6c78', '4f7a168d3aabe87035387dd5ed5d34faa28fab189b0c1b7473456086f1761fc8', '658ec33f8cad649513db3a623c44949b0ada07e7b8ea99d6f071aefb52786790', '4838fa3a84bff003216011b4f2c570eba0e5f2b9054e8b8617863ed3fb8e08a9', 'c5286e5f2f650dc15466adcf108165abf439ed3a89340a782042fe713c6de8ac', 'fb473c32d1641464c5377775c886a6ac46a55ab70007e126b180e444120e9206', 'ecf3baef3232eab1bf969290ca738f19d1bb31becf8a7243045e8b6417582b48', 'f36d8fba41a9d248c0828a919f5732c36e25a2809cec7f86b8c2a43ad967ca09', '9342ca6d50ed2fbe47d699d8ce2e5c82fe69e8aa2ace8cc64d89f65a7d7257cf', 'bc79ce01a05be22183c6aa6db4fbc2c25eb19cc11ddba3f100f412ecb7d49863'] B "when s-labels are taken from platform label space, all that is required is to provision that receiving udp/ip encapsulated detnet mpls packets is permitted. once the udp/ip header is stripped, the s-label uniquely identifies the app-flow. when s-labels are not taken from platform label space, udp/ip header information must be provisioned. the provisioned information must then be used to identify incoming app-flows based on the combination of s-label and incoming ip/udp header. normal receive processing, including peof can then take place." {33: 1, 26: 1, 113: 1, 56: 1, 64: 1, 112: 1, 102: 1, 71: 1, 60: 2, 38: 2, 62: 2, 83: 2, 126: 2, 85: 2, 129: 2} {31: 1, 32: 1, 228: 1, 261: 1, 231: 1, 298: 1, 274: 1, 377: 1, 260: 2, 339: 3, 212: 2, 343: 2, 283: 2, 286: 4, 163: 2, 357: 2, 166: 2, 363: 2, 46: 2} {260, 261, 274, 283, 286, 31, 32, 33, 163, 166, 298, 46, 339, 212, 343, 228, 357, 231, 363, 377} 32 IPv4 and IPv6 source address field. "Based on 06.17 discussions . F - lables(s ) to Fig1 and text fixed . Adding procedures sections . Multiple notes for clarifications . Adding controller plane section . reviewed in Jun 24 meeting" c3a02ebab509385544d23fbbc8adf8bccb46e274 c3a02ebab509385544d23fbbc8adf8bccb46e274 draft-ietf-detnet-mpls-over-udp-ip 9342ca6d50ed2fbe47d699d8ce2e5c82fe69e8aa2ace8cc64d89f65a7d7257cf ['1c461fe81d5bcf71073032237c90a364fe0acc907c86f9c6b7bdd0239e4a6516', '64c967bf314cd115ae548ad25ff1ac315b8ebae80114c1e6c2cdd1b18c87d311', 'ed421dfbc499208b19c13c14f07492fc0a6d8112c65bed9315f7f3d2b27f8234', '77f52e3a27231622bf5419787da9d00710542ed8febd34f0fcf41a407f253254', '78e5c37125916ed96a19fc61f4632c7048556a2d27efd6661850cdb5dff8b0de', 'e36f8694636db0304245e6df97b64ed089292f19180d858c0a08452501634022', 'b1798f9c8aa638befd15d3315aae7511395c774ff90235dbe1947dc162d80ed9', '96f49870b665021906e0a8c8967651ea74672ff4f2c95e90f16fb1b6558d8ba3', 'e7f225ef9a06fd47806688cd089056e54cd35ac274590842e03d9353d81d6c78', '4f7a168d3aabe87035387dd5ed5d34faa28fab189b0c1b7473456086f1761fc8', '658ec33f8cad649513db3a623c44949b0ada07e7b8ea99d6f071aefb52786790', '4838fa3a84bff003216011b4f2c570eba0e5f2b9054e8b8617863ed3fb8e08a9', 'c5286e5f2f650dc15466adcf108165abf439ed3a89340a782042fe713c6de8ac', 'fb473c32d1641464c5377775c886a6ac46a55ab70007e126b180e444120e9206', 'ecf3baef3232eab1bf969290ca738f19d1bb31becf8a7243045e8b6417582b48', 'f36d8fba41a9d248c0828a919f5732c36e25a2809cec7f86b8c2a43ad967ca09', '9342ca6d50ed2fbe47d699d8ce2e5c82fe69e8aa2ace8cc64d89f65a7d7257cf', 'bc79ce01a05be22183c6aa6db4fbc2c25eb19cc11ddba3f100f412ecb7d49863'] B ipv4 and ipv6 source address field. {33: 1, 26: 1, 113: 1, 56: 1, 64: 1, 112: 1, 102: 1, 71: 1, 60: 2, 38: 2, 62: 2, 83: 2, 126: 2, 85: 2, 129: 2} {31: 1, 32: 1, 228: 1, 261: 1, 231: 1, 298: 1, 274: 1, 377: 1, 260: 2, 339: 3, 212: 2, 343: 2, 283: 2, 286: 4, 163: 2, 357: 2, 166: 2, 363: 2, 46: 2} {260, 261, 274, 283, 286, 31, 32, 33, 163, 166, 298, 46, 339, 212, 343, 228, 357, 231, 363, 377} 32 "IPv4 and IPv6 source address prefix length, where a zero (0) value effectively means that the address field is ignored." "Based on 06.17 discussions . F - lables(s ) to Fig1 and text fixed . Adding procedures sections . Multiple notes for clarifications . Adding controller plane section . reviewed in Jun 24 meeting" c3a02ebab509385544d23fbbc8adf8bccb46e274 c3a02ebab509385544d23fbbc8adf8bccb46e274 draft-ietf-detnet-mpls-over-udp-ip fb473c32d1641464c5377775c886a6ac46a55ab70007e126b180e444120e9206 ['1c461fe81d5bcf71073032237c90a364fe0acc907c86f9c6b7bdd0239e4a6516', '64c967bf314cd115ae548ad25ff1ac315b8ebae80114c1e6c2cdd1b18c87d311', 'ed421dfbc499208b19c13c14f07492fc0a6d8112c65bed9315f7f3d2b27f8234', '77f52e3a27231622bf5419787da9d00710542ed8febd34f0fcf41a407f253254', '78e5c37125916ed96a19fc61f4632c7048556a2d27efd6661850cdb5dff8b0de', 'e36f8694636db0304245e6df97b64ed089292f19180d858c0a08452501634022', 'b1798f9c8aa638befd15d3315aae7511395c774ff90235dbe1947dc162d80ed9', '96f49870b665021906e0a8c8967651ea74672ff4f2c95e90f16fb1b6558d8ba3', 'e7f225ef9a06fd47806688cd089056e54cd35ac274590842e03d9353d81d6c78', '4f7a168d3aabe87035387dd5ed5d34faa28fab189b0c1b7473456086f1761fc8', '658ec33f8cad649513db3a623c44949b0ada07e7b8ea99d6f071aefb52786790', '4838fa3a84bff003216011b4f2c570eba0e5f2b9054e8b8617863ed3fb8e08a9', 'c5286e5f2f650dc15466adcf108165abf439ed3a89340a782042fe713c6de8ac', 'fb473c32d1641464c5377775c886a6ac46a55ab70007e126b180e444120e9206', 'ecf3baef3232eab1bf969290ca738f19d1bb31becf8a7243045e8b6417582b48', 'f36d8fba41a9d248c0828a919f5732c36e25a2809cec7f86b8c2a43ad967ca09', '9342ca6d50ed2fbe47d699d8ce2e5c82fe69e8aa2ace8cc64d89f65a7d7257cf', 'bc79ce01a05be22183c6aa6db4fbc2c25eb19cc11ddba3f100f412ecb7d49863'] B "ipv4 and ipv6 source address prefix length, where a zero (0) value effectively means that the address field is ignored." {33: 1, 26: 1, 113: 1, 56: 1, 64: 1, 112: 1, 102: 1, 71: 1, 60: 2, 38: 2, 62: 2, 83: 2, 126: 2, 85: 2, 129: 2} {31: 1, 32: 1, 228: 1, 261: 1, 231: 1, 298: 1, 274: 1, 377: 1, 260: 2, 339: 3, 212: 2, 343: 2, 283: 2, 286: 4, 163: 2, 357: 2, 166: 2, 363: 2, 46: 2} {260, 261, 274, 283, 286, 31, 32, 33, 163, 166, 298, 46, 339, 212, 343, 228, 357, 231, 363, 377} 32 IPv4 and IPv6 destination address field. "Based on 06.17 discussions . F - lables(s ) to Fig1 and text fixed . Adding procedures sections . Multiple notes for clarifications . Adding controller plane section . reviewed in Jun 24 meeting" c3a02ebab509385544d23fbbc8adf8bccb46e274 c3a02ebab509385544d23fbbc8adf8bccb46e274 draft-ietf-detnet-mpls-over-udp-ip bc79ce01a05be22183c6aa6db4fbc2c25eb19cc11ddba3f100f412ecb7d49863 ['1c461fe81d5bcf71073032237c90a364fe0acc907c86f9c6b7bdd0239e4a6516', '64c967bf314cd115ae548ad25ff1ac315b8ebae80114c1e6c2cdd1b18c87d311', 'ed421dfbc499208b19c13c14f07492fc0a6d8112c65bed9315f7f3d2b27f8234', '77f52e3a27231622bf5419787da9d00710542ed8febd34f0fcf41a407f253254', '78e5c37125916ed96a19fc61f4632c7048556a2d27efd6661850cdb5dff8b0de', 'e36f8694636db0304245e6df97b64ed089292f19180d858c0a08452501634022', 'b1798f9c8aa638befd15d3315aae7511395c774ff90235dbe1947dc162d80ed9', '96f49870b665021906e0a8c8967651ea74672ff4f2c95e90f16fb1b6558d8ba3', 'e7f225ef9a06fd47806688cd089056e54cd35ac274590842e03d9353d81d6c78', '4f7a168d3aabe87035387dd5ed5d34faa28fab189b0c1b7473456086f1761fc8', '658ec33f8cad649513db3a623c44949b0ada07e7b8ea99d6f071aefb52786790', '4838fa3a84bff003216011b4f2c570eba0e5f2b9054e8b8617863ed3fb8e08a9', 'c5286e5f2f650dc15466adcf108165abf439ed3a89340a782042fe713c6de8ac', 'fb473c32d1641464c5377775c886a6ac46a55ab70007e126b180e444120e9206', 'ecf3baef3232eab1bf969290ca738f19d1bb31becf8a7243045e8b6417582b48', 'f36d8fba41a9d248c0828a919f5732c36e25a2809cec7f86b8c2a43ad967ca09', '9342ca6d50ed2fbe47d699d8ce2e5c82fe69e8aa2ace8cc64d89f65a7d7257cf', 'bc79ce01a05be22183c6aa6db4fbc2c25eb19cc11ddba3f100f412ecb7d49863'] B ipv4 and ipv6 destination address field. {33: 1, 26: 1, 113: 1, 56: 1, 64: 1, 112: 1, 102: 1, 71: 1, 60: 2, 38: 2, 62: 2, 83: 2, 126: 2, 85: 2, 129: 2} {31: 1, 32: 1, 228: 1, 261: 1, 231: 1, 298: 1, 274: 1, 377: 1, 260: 2, 339: 3, 212: 2, 343: 2, 283: 2, 286: 4, 163: 2, 357: 2, 166: 2, 363: 2, 46: 2} {260, 261, 274, 283, 286, 31, 32, 33, 163, 166, 298, 46, 339, 212, 343, 228, 357, 231, 363, 377} 32 "IPv4 and IPv6 destination address prefix length, where a zero (0) effectively means that the address field is ignored." "Based on 06.17 discussions . F - lables(s ) to Fig1 and text fixed . Adding procedures sections . Multiple notes for clarifications . Adding controller plane section . reviewed in Jun 24 meeting" c3a02ebab509385544d23fbbc8adf8bccb46e274 c3a02ebab509385544d23fbbc8adf8bccb46e274 draft-ietf-detnet-mpls-over-udp-ip ecf3baef3232eab1bf969290ca738f19d1bb31becf8a7243045e8b6417582b48 ['1c461fe81d5bcf71073032237c90a364fe0acc907c86f9c6b7bdd0239e4a6516', '64c967bf314cd115ae548ad25ff1ac315b8ebae80114c1e6c2cdd1b18c87d311', 'ed421dfbc499208b19c13c14f07492fc0a6d8112c65bed9315f7f3d2b27f8234', '77f52e3a27231622bf5419787da9d00710542ed8febd34f0fcf41a407f253254', '78e5c37125916ed96a19fc61f4632c7048556a2d27efd6661850cdb5dff8b0de', 'e36f8694636db0304245e6df97b64ed089292f19180d858c0a08452501634022', 'b1798f9c8aa638befd15d3315aae7511395c774ff90235dbe1947dc162d80ed9', '96f49870b665021906e0a8c8967651ea74672ff4f2c95e90f16fb1b6558d8ba3', 'e7f225ef9a06fd47806688cd089056e54cd35ac274590842e03d9353d81d6c78', '4f7a168d3aabe87035387dd5ed5d34faa28fab189b0c1b7473456086f1761fc8', '658ec33f8cad649513db3a623c44949b0ada07e7b8ea99d6f071aefb52786790', '4838fa3a84bff003216011b4f2c570eba0e5f2b9054e8b8617863ed3fb8e08a9', 'c5286e5f2f650dc15466adcf108165abf439ed3a89340a782042fe713c6de8ac', 'fb473c32d1641464c5377775c886a6ac46a55ab70007e126b180e444120e9206', 'ecf3baef3232eab1bf969290ca738f19d1bb31becf8a7243045e8b6417582b48', 'f36d8fba41a9d248c0828a919f5732c36e25a2809cec7f86b8c2a43ad967ca09', '9342ca6d50ed2fbe47d699d8ce2e5c82fe69e8aa2ace8cc64d89f65a7d7257cf', 'bc79ce01a05be22183c6aa6db4fbc2c25eb19cc11ddba3f100f412ecb7d49863'] B "ipv4 and ipv6 destination address prefix length, where a zero (0) effectively means that the address field is ignored." {33: 1, 26: 1, 113: 1, 56: 1, 64: 1, 112: 1, 102: 1, 71: 1, 60: 2, 38: 2, 62: 2, 83: 2, 126: 2, 85: 2, 129: 2} {31: 1, 32: 1, 228: 1, 261: 1, 231: 1, 298: 1, 274: 1, 377: 1, 260: 2, 339: 3, 212: 2, 343: 2, 283: 2, 286: 4, 163: 2, 357: 2, 166: 2, 363: 2, 46: 2} {260, 261, 274, 283, 286, 31, 32, 33, 163, 166, 298, 46, 339, 212, 343, 228, 357, 231, 363, 377} 32 "IPv4 protocol field. Only UDP is allowed, and the ability to ignore this field, e.g., via configuration of the value zero (0), is desirable." "Based on 06.17 discussions . F - lables(s ) to Fig1 and text fixed . Adding procedures sections . Multiple notes for clarifications . Adding controller plane section . reviewed in Jun 24 meeting" c3a02ebab509385544d23fbbc8adf8bccb46e274 c3a02ebab509385544d23fbbc8adf8bccb46e274 draft-ietf-detnet-mpls-over-udp-ip 96f49870b665021906e0a8c8967651ea74672ff4f2c95e90f16fb1b6558d8ba3 ['1c461fe81d5bcf71073032237c90a364fe0acc907c86f9c6b7bdd0239e4a6516', '64c967bf314cd115ae548ad25ff1ac315b8ebae80114c1e6c2cdd1b18c87d311', 'ed421dfbc499208b19c13c14f07492fc0a6d8112c65bed9315f7f3d2b27f8234', '77f52e3a27231622bf5419787da9d00710542ed8febd34f0fcf41a407f253254', '78e5c37125916ed96a19fc61f4632c7048556a2d27efd6661850cdb5dff8b0de', 'e36f8694636db0304245e6df97b64ed089292f19180d858c0a08452501634022', 'b1798f9c8aa638befd15d3315aae7511395c774ff90235dbe1947dc162d80ed9', '96f49870b665021906e0a8c8967651ea74672ff4f2c95e90f16fb1b6558d8ba3', 'e7f225ef9a06fd47806688cd089056e54cd35ac274590842e03d9353d81d6c78', '4f7a168d3aabe87035387dd5ed5d34faa28fab189b0c1b7473456086f1761fc8', '658ec33f8cad649513db3a623c44949b0ada07e7b8ea99d6f071aefb52786790', '4838fa3a84bff003216011b4f2c570eba0e5f2b9054e8b8617863ed3fb8e08a9', 'c5286e5f2f650dc15466adcf108165abf439ed3a89340a782042fe713c6de8ac', 'fb473c32d1641464c5377775c886a6ac46a55ab70007e126b180e444120e9206', 'ecf3baef3232eab1bf969290ca738f19d1bb31becf8a7243045e8b6417582b48', 'f36d8fba41a9d248c0828a919f5732c36e25a2809cec7f86b8c2a43ad967ca09', '9342ca6d50ed2fbe47d699d8ce2e5c82fe69e8aa2ace8cc64d89f65a7d7257cf', 'bc79ce01a05be22183c6aa6db4fbc2c25eb19cc11ddba3f100f412ecb7d49863'] B "ipv4 protocol field. only udp is allowed, and the ability to ignore this field, e.g., via configuration of the value zero (0), is desirable." {33: 1, 26: 1, 113: 1, 56: 1, 64: 1, 112: 1, 102: 1, 71: 1, 60: 2, 38: 2, 62: 2, 83: 2, 126: 2, 85: 2, 129: 2} {31: 1, 32: 1, 228: 1, 261: 1, 231: 1, 298: 1, 274: 1, 377: 1, 260: 2, 339: 3, 212: 2, 343: 2, 283: 2, 286: 4, 163: 2, 357: 2, 166: 2, 363: 2, 46: 2} {260, 261, 274, 283, 286, 31, 32, 33, 163, 166, 298, 46, 339, 212, 343, 228, 357, 231, 363, 377} 32 "IPv6 next header field. Only UDP is allowed, and the ability to ignore this field, e.g., via configuration of the value zero (0), is desirable." "Based on 06.17 discussions . F - lables(s ) to Fig1 and text fixed . Adding procedures sections . Multiple notes for clarifications . Adding controller plane section . reviewed in Jun 24 meeting" c3a02ebab509385544d23fbbc8adf8bccb46e274 c3a02ebab509385544d23fbbc8adf8bccb46e274 draft-ietf-detnet-mpls-over-udp-ip 64c967bf314cd115ae548ad25ff1ac315b8ebae80114c1e6c2cdd1b18c87d311 ['1c461fe81d5bcf71073032237c90a364fe0acc907c86f9c6b7bdd0239e4a6516', '64c967bf314cd115ae548ad25ff1ac315b8ebae80114c1e6c2cdd1b18c87d311', 'ed421dfbc499208b19c13c14f07492fc0a6d8112c65bed9315f7f3d2b27f8234', '77f52e3a27231622bf5419787da9d00710542ed8febd34f0fcf41a407f253254', '78e5c37125916ed96a19fc61f4632c7048556a2d27efd6661850cdb5dff8b0de', 'e36f8694636db0304245e6df97b64ed089292f19180d858c0a08452501634022', 'b1798f9c8aa638befd15d3315aae7511395c774ff90235dbe1947dc162d80ed9', '96f49870b665021906e0a8c8967651ea74672ff4f2c95e90f16fb1b6558d8ba3', 'e7f225ef9a06fd47806688cd089056e54cd35ac274590842e03d9353d81d6c78', '4f7a168d3aabe87035387dd5ed5d34faa28fab189b0c1b7473456086f1761fc8', '658ec33f8cad649513db3a623c44949b0ada07e7b8ea99d6f071aefb52786790', '4838fa3a84bff003216011b4f2c570eba0e5f2b9054e8b8617863ed3fb8e08a9', 'c5286e5f2f650dc15466adcf108165abf439ed3a89340a782042fe713c6de8ac', 'fb473c32d1641464c5377775c886a6ac46a55ab70007e126b180e444120e9206', 'ecf3baef3232eab1bf969290ca738f19d1bb31becf8a7243045e8b6417582b48', 'f36d8fba41a9d248c0828a919f5732c36e25a2809cec7f86b8c2a43ad967ca09', '9342ca6d50ed2fbe47d699d8ce2e5c82fe69e8aa2ace8cc64d89f65a7d7257cf', 'bc79ce01a05be22183c6aa6db4fbc2c25eb19cc11ddba3f100f412ecb7d49863'] B "ipv6 next header field. only udp is allowed, and the ability to ignore this field, e.g., via configuration of the value zero (0), is desirable." {33: 1, 26: 1, 113: 1, 56: 1, 64: 1, 112: 1, 102: 1, 71: 1, 60: 2, 38: 2, 62: 2, 83: 2, 126: 2, 85: 2, 129: 2} {31: 1, 32: 1, 228: 1, 261: 1, 231: 1, 298: 1, 274: 1, 377: 1, 260: 2, 339: 3, 212: 2, 343: 2, 283: 2, 286: 4, 163: 2, 357: 2, 166: 2, 363: 2, 46: 2} {260, 261, 274, 283, 286, 31, 32, 33, 163, 166, 298, 46, 339, 212, 343, 228, 357, 231, 363, 377} 32 IPv4 Type of Service and IPv6 Traffic Class Fields. "Based on 06.17 discussions . F - lables(s ) to Fig1 and text fixed . Adding procedures sections . Multiple notes for clarifications . Adding controller plane section . reviewed in Jun 24 meeting" c3a02ebab509385544d23fbbc8adf8bccb46e274 c3a02ebab509385544d23fbbc8adf8bccb46e274 draft-ietf-detnet-mpls-over-udp-ip 4f7a168d3aabe87035387dd5ed5d34faa28fab189b0c1b7473456086f1761fc8 ['1c461fe81d5bcf71073032237c90a364fe0acc907c86f9c6b7bdd0239e4a6516', '64c967bf314cd115ae548ad25ff1ac315b8ebae80114c1e6c2cdd1b18c87d311', 'ed421dfbc499208b19c13c14f07492fc0a6d8112c65bed9315f7f3d2b27f8234', '77f52e3a27231622bf5419787da9d00710542ed8febd34f0fcf41a407f253254', '78e5c37125916ed96a19fc61f4632c7048556a2d27efd6661850cdb5dff8b0de', 'e36f8694636db0304245e6df97b64ed089292f19180d858c0a08452501634022', 'b1798f9c8aa638befd15d3315aae7511395c774ff90235dbe1947dc162d80ed9', '96f49870b665021906e0a8c8967651ea74672ff4f2c95e90f16fb1b6558d8ba3', 'e7f225ef9a06fd47806688cd089056e54cd35ac274590842e03d9353d81d6c78', '4f7a168d3aabe87035387dd5ed5d34faa28fab189b0c1b7473456086f1761fc8', '658ec33f8cad649513db3a623c44949b0ada07e7b8ea99d6f071aefb52786790', '4838fa3a84bff003216011b4f2c570eba0e5f2b9054e8b8617863ed3fb8e08a9', 'c5286e5f2f650dc15466adcf108165abf439ed3a89340a782042fe713c6de8ac', 'fb473c32d1641464c5377775c886a6ac46a55ab70007e126b180e444120e9206', 'ecf3baef3232eab1bf969290ca738f19d1bb31becf8a7243045e8b6417582b48', 'f36d8fba41a9d248c0828a919f5732c36e25a2809cec7f86b8c2a43ad967ca09', '9342ca6d50ed2fbe47d699d8ce2e5c82fe69e8aa2ace8cc64d89f65a7d7257cf', 'bc79ce01a05be22183c6aa6db4fbc2c25eb19cc11ddba3f100f412ecb7d49863'] B ipv4 type of service and ipv6 traffic class fields. {33: 1, 26: 1, 113: 1, 56: 1, 64: 1, 112: 1, 102: 1, 71: 1, 60: 2, 38: 2, 62: 2, 83: 2, 126: 2, 85: 2, 129: 2} {31: 1, 32: 1, 228: 1, 261: 1, 231: 1, 298: 1, 274: 1, 377: 1, 260: 2, 339: 3, 212: 2, 343: 2, 283: 2, 286: 4, 163: 2, 357: 2, 166: 2, 363: 2, 46: 2} {260, 261, 274, 283, 286, 31, 32, 33, 163, 166, 298, 46, 339, 212, 343, 228, 357, 231, 363, 377} 32 "IPv4 Type of Service and IPv6 Traffic Class Field Bitmask, where a zero (0) effectively means that theses fields are ignored." "Based on 06.17 discussions . F - lables(s ) to Fig1 and text fixed . Adding procedures sections . Multiple notes for clarifications . Adding controller plane section . reviewed in Jun 24 meeting" c3a02ebab509385544d23fbbc8adf8bccb46e274 c3a02ebab509385544d23fbbc8adf8bccb46e274 draft-ietf-detnet-mpls-over-udp-ip c5286e5f2f650dc15466adcf108165abf439ed3a89340a782042fe713c6de8ac ['1c461fe81d5bcf71073032237c90a364fe0acc907c86f9c6b7bdd0239e4a6516', '64c967bf314cd115ae548ad25ff1ac315b8ebae80114c1e6c2cdd1b18c87d311', 'ed421dfbc499208b19c13c14f07492fc0a6d8112c65bed9315f7f3d2b27f8234', '77f52e3a27231622bf5419787da9d00710542ed8febd34f0fcf41a407f253254', '78e5c37125916ed96a19fc61f4632c7048556a2d27efd6661850cdb5dff8b0de', 'e36f8694636db0304245e6df97b64ed089292f19180d858c0a08452501634022', 'b1798f9c8aa638befd15d3315aae7511395c774ff90235dbe1947dc162d80ed9', '96f49870b665021906e0a8c8967651ea74672ff4f2c95e90f16fb1b6558d8ba3', 'e7f225ef9a06fd47806688cd089056e54cd35ac274590842e03d9353d81d6c78', '4f7a168d3aabe87035387dd5ed5d34faa28fab189b0c1b7473456086f1761fc8', '658ec33f8cad649513db3a623c44949b0ada07e7b8ea99d6f071aefb52786790', '4838fa3a84bff003216011b4f2c570eba0e5f2b9054e8b8617863ed3fb8e08a9', 'c5286e5f2f650dc15466adcf108165abf439ed3a89340a782042fe713c6de8ac', 'fb473c32d1641464c5377775c886a6ac46a55ab70007e126b180e444120e9206', 'ecf3baef3232eab1bf969290ca738f19d1bb31becf8a7243045e8b6417582b48', 'f36d8fba41a9d248c0828a919f5732c36e25a2809cec7f86b8c2a43ad967ca09', '9342ca6d50ed2fbe47d699d8ce2e5c82fe69e8aa2ace8cc64d89f65a7d7257cf', 'bc79ce01a05be22183c6aa6db4fbc2c25eb19cc11ddba3f100f412ecb7d49863'] B "ipv4 type of service and ipv6 traffic class field bitmask, where a zero (0) effectively means that theses fields are ignored." {33: 1, 26: 1, 113: 1, 56: 1, 64: 1, 112: 1, 102: 1, 71: 1, 60: 2, 38: 2, 62: 2, 83: 2, 126: 2, 85: 2, 129: 2} {31: 1, 32: 1, 228: 1, 261: 1, 231: 1, 298: 1, 274: 1, 377: 1, 260: 2, 339: 3, 212: 2, 343: 2, 283: 2, 286: 4, 163: 2, 357: 2, 166: 2, 363: 2, 46: 2} {260, 261, 274, 283, 286, 31, 32, 33, 163, 166, 298, 46, 339, 212, 343, 228, 357, 231, 363, 377} 32 "UDP Source Port. Exact and wildcard matching is required. Port ranges can optionally be used." "Based on 06.17 discussions . F - lables(s ) to Fig1 and text fixed . Adding procedures sections . Multiple notes for clarifications . Adding controller plane section . reviewed in Jun 24 meeting" c3a02ebab509385544d23fbbc8adf8bccb46e274 c3a02ebab509385544d23fbbc8adf8bccb46e274 draft-ietf-detnet-mpls-over-udp-ip 658ec33f8cad649513db3a623c44949b0ada07e7b8ea99d6f071aefb52786790 ['1c461fe81d5bcf71073032237c90a364fe0acc907c86f9c6b7bdd0239e4a6516', '64c967bf314cd115ae548ad25ff1ac315b8ebae80114c1e6c2cdd1b18c87d311', 'ed421dfbc499208b19c13c14f07492fc0a6d8112c65bed9315f7f3d2b27f8234', '77f52e3a27231622bf5419787da9d00710542ed8febd34f0fcf41a407f253254', '78e5c37125916ed96a19fc61f4632c7048556a2d27efd6661850cdb5dff8b0de', 'e36f8694636db0304245e6df97b64ed089292f19180d858c0a08452501634022', 'b1798f9c8aa638befd15d3315aae7511395c774ff90235dbe1947dc162d80ed9', '96f49870b665021906e0a8c8967651ea74672ff4f2c95e90f16fb1b6558d8ba3', 'e7f225ef9a06fd47806688cd089056e54cd35ac274590842e03d9353d81d6c78', '4f7a168d3aabe87035387dd5ed5d34faa28fab189b0c1b7473456086f1761fc8', '658ec33f8cad649513db3a623c44949b0ada07e7b8ea99d6f071aefb52786790', '4838fa3a84bff003216011b4f2c570eba0e5f2b9054e8b8617863ed3fb8e08a9', 'c5286e5f2f650dc15466adcf108165abf439ed3a89340a782042fe713c6de8ac', 'fb473c32d1641464c5377775c886a6ac46a55ab70007e126b180e444120e9206', 'ecf3baef3232eab1bf969290ca738f19d1bb31becf8a7243045e8b6417582b48', 'f36d8fba41a9d248c0828a919f5732c36e25a2809cec7f86b8c2a43ad967ca09', '9342ca6d50ed2fbe47d699d8ce2e5c82fe69e8aa2ace8cc64d89f65a7d7257cf', 'bc79ce01a05be22183c6aa6db4fbc2c25eb19cc11ddba3f100f412ecb7d49863'] B "udp source port. exact and wildcard matching is required. port ranges can optionally be used." {33: 1, 26: 1, 113: 1, 56: 1, 64: 1, 112: 1, 102: 1, 71: 1, 60: 2, 38: 2, 62: 2, 83: 2, 126: 2, 85: 2, 129: 2} {31: 1, 32: 1, 228: 1, 261: 1, 231: 1, 298: 1, 274: 1, 377: 1, 260: 2, 339: 3, 212: 2, 343: 2, 283: 2, 286: 4, 163: 2, 357: 2, 166: 2, 363: 2, 46: 2} {260, 261, 274, 283, 286, 31, 32, 33, 163, 166, 298, 46, 339, 212, 343, 228, 357, 231, 363, 377} 32 "This information MUST be provisioned per DetNet flow via configuration, e.g., via the controller or management plane." "Based on 06.17 discussions . F - lables(s ) to Fig1 and text fixed . Adding procedures sections . Multiple notes for clarifications . Adding controller plane section . reviewed in Jun 24 meeting" c3a02ebab509385544d23fbbc8adf8bccb46e274 c3a02ebab509385544d23fbbc8adf8bccb46e274 draft-ietf-detnet-mpls-over-udp-ip 78e5c37125916ed96a19fc61f4632c7048556a2d27efd6661850cdb5dff8b0de ['1c461fe81d5bcf71073032237c90a364fe0acc907c86f9c6b7bdd0239e4a6516', '64c967bf314cd115ae548ad25ff1ac315b8ebae80114c1e6c2cdd1b18c87d311', 'ed421dfbc499208b19c13c14f07492fc0a6d8112c65bed9315f7f3d2b27f8234', '77f52e3a27231622bf5419787da9d00710542ed8febd34f0fcf41a407f253254', '78e5c37125916ed96a19fc61f4632c7048556a2d27efd6661850cdb5dff8b0de', 'e36f8694636db0304245e6df97b64ed089292f19180d858c0a08452501634022', 'b1798f9c8aa638befd15d3315aae7511395c774ff90235dbe1947dc162d80ed9', '96f49870b665021906e0a8c8967651ea74672ff4f2c95e90f16fb1b6558d8ba3', 'e7f225ef9a06fd47806688cd089056e54cd35ac274590842e03d9353d81d6c78', '4f7a168d3aabe87035387dd5ed5d34faa28fab189b0c1b7473456086f1761fc8', '658ec33f8cad649513db3a623c44949b0ada07e7b8ea99d6f071aefb52786790', '4838fa3a84bff003216011b4f2c570eba0e5f2b9054e8b8617863ed3fb8e08a9', 'c5286e5f2f650dc15466adcf108165abf439ed3a89340a782042fe713c6de8ac', 'fb473c32d1641464c5377775c886a6ac46a55ab70007e126b180e444120e9206', 'ecf3baef3232eab1bf969290ca738f19d1bb31becf8a7243045e8b6417582b48', 'f36d8fba41a9d248c0828a919f5732c36e25a2809cec7f86b8c2a43ad967ca09', '9342ca6d50ed2fbe47d699d8ce2e5c82fe69e8aa2ace8cc64d89f65a7d7257cf', 'bc79ce01a05be22183c6aa6db4fbc2c25eb19cc11ddba3f100f412ecb7d49863'] B "this information must be provisioned per detnet flow via configuration, e.g., via the controller or management plane." {33: 1, 26: 1, 113: 1, 56: 1, 64: 1, 112: 1, 102: 1, 71: 1, 60: 2, 38: 2, 62: 2, 83: 2, 126: 2, 85: 2, 129: 2} {31: 1, 32: 1, 228: 1, 261: 1, 231: 1, 298: 1, 274: 1, 377: 1, 260: 2, 339: 3, 212: 2, 343: 2, 283: 2, 286: 4, 163: 2, 357: 2, 166: 2, 363: 2, 46: 2} {260, 261, 274, 283, 286, 31, 32, 33, 163, 166, 298, 46, 339, 212, 343, 228, 357, 231, 363, 377} 32 "Information identifying a DetNet flow is ordered and implementations use the first match. This can, for example, be used to provide a DetNet service for a specific UDP flow, with unique Source and Destination Port field values, while providing a different service for the aggregate of all other flows with that same UDP Destination Port value." "Based on 06.17 discussions . F - lables(s ) to Fig1 and text fixed . Adding procedures sections . Multiple notes for clarifications . Adding controller plane section . reviewed in Jun 24 meeting" c3a02ebab509385544d23fbbc8adf8bccb46e274 c3a02ebab509385544d23fbbc8adf8bccb46e274 draft-ietf-detnet-mpls-over-udp-ip 1c461fe81d5bcf71073032237c90a364fe0acc907c86f9c6b7bdd0239e4a6516 ['1c461fe81d5bcf71073032237c90a364fe0acc907c86f9c6b7bdd0239e4a6516', '64c967bf314cd115ae548ad25ff1ac315b8ebae80114c1e6c2cdd1b18c87d311', 'ed421dfbc499208b19c13c14f07492fc0a6d8112c65bed9315f7f3d2b27f8234', '77f52e3a27231622bf5419787da9d00710542ed8febd34f0fcf41a407f253254', '78e5c37125916ed96a19fc61f4632c7048556a2d27efd6661850cdb5dff8b0de', 'e36f8694636db0304245e6df97b64ed089292f19180d858c0a08452501634022', 'b1798f9c8aa638befd15d3315aae7511395c774ff90235dbe1947dc162d80ed9', '96f49870b665021906e0a8c8967651ea74672ff4f2c95e90f16fb1b6558d8ba3', 'e7f225ef9a06fd47806688cd089056e54cd35ac274590842e03d9353d81d6c78', '4f7a168d3aabe87035387dd5ed5d34faa28fab189b0c1b7473456086f1761fc8', '658ec33f8cad649513db3a623c44949b0ada07e7b8ea99d6f071aefb52786790', '4838fa3a84bff003216011b4f2c570eba0e5f2b9054e8b8617863ed3fb8e08a9', 'c5286e5f2f650dc15466adcf108165abf439ed3a89340a782042fe713c6de8ac', 'fb473c32d1641464c5377775c886a6ac46a55ab70007e126b180e444120e9206', 'ecf3baef3232eab1bf969290ca738f19d1bb31becf8a7243045e8b6417582b48', 'f36d8fba41a9d248c0828a919f5732c36e25a2809cec7f86b8c2a43ad967ca09', '9342ca6d50ed2fbe47d699d8ce2e5c82fe69e8aa2ace8cc64d89f65a7d7257cf', 'bc79ce01a05be22183c6aa6db4fbc2c25eb19cc11ddba3f100f412ecb7d49863'] B "information identifying a detnet flow is ordered and implementations use the first match. this can, for example, be used to provide a detnet service for a specific udp flow, with unique source and destination port field values, while providing a different service for the aggregate of all other flows with that same udp destination port value." {33: 1, 26: 1, 113: 1, 56: 1, 64: 1, 112: 1, 102: 1, 71: 1, 60: 2, 38: 2, 62: 2, 83: 2, 126: 2, 85: 2, 129: 2} {31: 1, 32: 1, 228: 1, 261: 1, 231: 1, 298: 1, 274: 1, 377: 1, 260: 2, 339: 3, 212: 2, 343: 2, 283: 2, 286: 4, 163: 2, 357: 2, 166: 2, 363: 2, 46: 2} {260, 261, 274, 283, 286, 31, 32, 33, 163, 166, 298, 46, 339, 212, 343, 228, 357, 231, 363, 377} 32 "It is the responsibility of the DetNet controller plane to properly provision both flow identification information and the flow specific resources needed to provided the traffic treatment needed to meet each flow's service requirements. This applies for aggregated and individual flows." "Based on 06.17 discussions . F - lables(s ) to Fig1 and text fixed . Adding procedures sections . Multiple notes for clarifications . Adding controller plane section . reviewed in Jun 24 meeting" c3a02ebab509385544d23fbbc8adf8bccb46e274 c3a02ebab509385544d23fbbc8adf8bccb46e274 draft-ietf-detnet-mpls-over-udp-ip ed421dfbc499208b19c13c14f07492fc0a6d8112c65bed9315f7f3d2b27f8234 ['1c461fe81d5bcf71073032237c90a364fe0acc907c86f9c6b7bdd0239e4a6516', '64c967bf314cd115ae548ad25ff1ac315b8ebae80114c1e6c2cdd1b18c87d311', 'ed421dfbc499208b19c13c14f07492fc0a6d8112c65bed9315f7f3d2b27f8234', '77f52e3a27231622bf5419787da9d00710542ed8febd34f0fcf41a407f253254', '78e5c37125916ed96a19fc61f4632c7048556a2d27efd6661850cdb5dff8b0de', 'e36f8694636db0304245e6df97b64ed089292f19180d858c0a08452501634022', 'b1798f9c8aa638befd15d3315aae7511395c774ff90235dbe1947dc162d80ed9', '96f49870b665021906e0a8c8967651ea74672ff4f2c95e90f16fb1b6558d8ba3', 'e7f225ef9a06fd47806688cd089056e54cd35ac274590842e03d9353d81d6c78', '4f7a168d3aabe87035387dd5ed5d34faa28fab189b0c1b7473456086f1761fc8', '658ec33f8cad649513db3a623c44949b0ada07e7b8ea99d6f071aefb52786790', '4838fa3a84bff003216011b4f2c570eba0e5f2b9054e8b8617863ed3fb8e08a9', 'c5286e5f2f650dc15466adcf108165abf439ed3a89340a782042fe713c6de8ac', 'fb473c32d1641464c5377775c886a6ac46a55ab70007e126b180e444120e9206', 'ecf3baef3232eab1bf969290ca738f19d1bb31becf8a7243045e8b6417582b48', 'f36d8fba41a9d248c0828a919f5732c36e25a2809cec7f86b8c2a43ad967ca09', '9342ca6d50ed2fbe47d699d8ce2e5c82fe69e8aa2ace8cc64d89f65a7d7257cf', 'bc79ce01a05be22183c6aa6db4fbc2c25eb19cc11ddba3f100f412ecb7d49863'] B "it is the responsibility of the detnet controller plane to properly provision both flow identification information and the flow specific resources needed to provided the traffic treatment needed to meet each flow's service requirements. this applies for aggregated and individual flows." {33: 1, 26: 1, 113: 1, 56: 1, 64: 1, 112: 1, 102: 1, 71: 1, 60: 2, 38: 2, 62: 2, 83: 2, 126: 2, 85: 2, 129: 2} {31: 1, 32: 1, 228: 1, 261: 1, 231: 1, 298: 1, 274: 1, 377: 1, 260: 2, 339: 3, 212: 2, 343: 2, 283: 2, 286: 4, 163: 2, 357: 2, 166: 2, 363: 2, 46: 2} {260, 261, 274, 283, 286, 31, 32, 33, 163, 166, 298, 46, 339, 212, 343, 228, 357, 231, 363, 377} 31 "The service sub-layer provides additional support beyond the connectivity function of the forwarding sub-layer. An example of this is Packet Replication, Elimination, and Ordering (PREOF) function see PREOF." "Hi Did a pass through the Framework . Clean up some text . There are still some identified areas in the document where it calls for more detail . Also there is a open reference . reviewed in jun 24 call" 51ad457a7ec49f981e3aac0813060e3636219f53 51ad457a7ec49f981e3aac0813060e3636219f53 draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework 9046ed7f0f3054b0af7e329e67511332b0c0f05e1c3ed420ea5707de95cc0ba0 ['ae8fa4d819a308bedba82353bb058a7322212cce6eed6c2f0519be327173936b', 'e5d666435c4ada60f396bc49ecc362afbdce3a1a8f09e51c583470b2f4fb9984', 'a8257679538d2605f8cf2daf79ae6430c498dce55baebacdc872069a206c9aa6', '9046ed7f0f3054b0af7e329e67511332b0c0f05e1c3ed420ea5707de95cc0ba0', '153808cd3a8d91c08971b6c93d42cabfc65d73c0cfee9f3009d68264305facb7', '476829343a7368258bd0b6541be45e0dab3bd0e611a6d198fbf60eff1f60bd53'] A "the service sub-layer provides additional support beyond the connectivity function of the forwarding sub-layer. an example of this is packet replication, elimination, and ordering (preof) function see preof." {8: 1, 55: 1, 6: 2, 68: 2, 31: 3, 67: 3, 90: 2, 84: 2} {74: 1, 247: 1, 256: 2, 2: 3, 5: 2, 8: 3, 209: 3, 83: 3, 20: 2, 21: 3, 277: 2, 276: 3, 88: 3, 233: 4, 236: 2, 302: 4, 47: 4, 303: 3, 112: 3, 126: 4, 127: 3} {256, 2, 5, 8, 271, 20, 21, 277, 276, 302, 47, 303, 74, 209, 83, 88, 233, 236, 112, 247, 126, 127} 31 "The method of instantiating each of the layers is specific to the particular DetNet data plane method. There may be more than approach that is applicable to a given bearer network type." "Hi Did a pass through the Framework . Clean up some text . There are still some identified areas in the document where it calls for more detail . Also there is a open reference . reviewed in jun 24 call" 51ad457a7ec49f981e3aac0813060e3636219f53 51ad457a7ec49f981e3aac0813060e3636219f53 draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework 153808cd3a8d91c08971b6c93d42cabfc65d73c0cfee9f3009d68264305facb7 ['ae8fa4d819a308bedba82353bb058a7322212cce6eed6c2f0519be327173936b', 'e5d666435c4ada60f396bc49ecc362afbdce3a1a8f09e51c583470b2f4fb9984', 'a8257679538d2605f8cf2daf79ae6430c498dce55baebacdc872069a206c9aa6', '9046ed7f0f3054b0af7e329e67511332b0c0f05e1c3ed420ea5707de95cc0ba0', '153808cd3a8d91c08971b6c93d42cabfc65d73c0cfee9f3009d68264305facb7', '476829343a7368258bd0b6541be45e0dab3bd0e611a6d198fbf60eff1f60bd53'] A "the method of instantiating each of the layers is specific to the particular detnet data plane method. there may be more than approach that is applicable to a given bearer network type." {8: 1, 55: 1, 6: 2, 68: 2, 31: 3, 67: 3, 90: 2, 84: 2} {74: 1, 247: 1, 256: 2, 2: 3, 5: 2, 8: 3, 209: 3, 83: 3, 20: 2, 21: 3, 277: 2, 276: 3, 88: 3, 233: 4, 236: 2, 302: 4, 47: 4, 303: 3, 112: 3, 126: 4, 127: 3} {256, 2, 5, 8, 271, 20, 21, 277, 276, 302, 47, 303, 74, 209, 83, 88, 233, 236, 112, 247, 126, 127} 31 "How the data plane is constructed: The DetNet service sub-layer provides its functions for the DetNet application flows by using or applying existing standardized headers and/or encapsulations. The Detnet forwarding sub-layer may provide capabilities leveraging that same header or encapsulation technology e.g. dn_svcs or it may be achieved by other standardized technologies e.g. dn_svc_encaps." "Hi Did a pass through the Framework . Clean up some text . There are still some identified areas in the document where it calls for more detail . Also there is a open reference . reviewed in jun 24 call" 51ad457a7ec49f981e3aac0813060e3636219f53 51ad457a7ec49f981e3aac0813060e3636219f53 draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework 476829343a7368258bd0b6541be45e0dab3bd0e611a6d198fbf60eff1f60bd53 ['ae8fa4d819a308bedba82353bb058a7322212cce6eed6c2f0519be327173936b', 'e5d666435c4ada60f396bc49ecc362afbdce3a1a8f09e51c583470b2f4fb9984', 'a8257679538d2605f8cf2daf79ae6430c498dce55baebacdc872069a206c9aa6', '9046ed7f0f3054b0af7e329e67511332b0c0f05e1c3ed420ea5707de95cc0ba0', '153808cd3a8d91c08971b6c93d42cabfc65d73c0cfee9f3009d68264305facb7', '476829343a7368258bd0b6541be45e0dab3bd0e611a6d198fbf60eff1f60bd53'] A "how the data plane is constructed: the detnet service sub-layer provides its functions for the detnet application flows by using or applying existing standardized headers and/or encapsulations. the detnet forwarding sub-layer may provide capabilities leveraging that same header or encapsulation technology e.g. dn_svcs or it may be achieved by other standardized technologies e.g. dn_svc_encaps." {8: 1, 55: 1, 6: 2, 68: 2, 31: 3, 67: 3, 90: 2, 84: 2} {74: 1, 247: 1, 256: 2, 2: 3, 5: 2, 8: 3, 209: 3, 83: 3, 20: 2, 21: 3, 277: 2, 276: 3, 88: 3, 233: 4, 236: 2, 302: 4, 47: 4, 303: 3, 112: 3, 126: 4, 127: 3} {256, 2, 5, 8, 271, 20, 21, 277, 276, 302, 47, 303, 74, 209, 83, 88, 233, 236, 112, 247, 126, 127} 31 "The service sub-layer provides additional support beyond the connectivity function of the forwarding sub-layer. An example of this is Packet Replication, Elimination, and Ordering (PREOF) functions see PREOF." "Hi Did a pass through the Framework . Clean up some text . There are still some identified areas in the document where it calls for more detail . Also there is a open reference . reviewed in jun 24 call" 51ad457a7ec49f981e3aac0813060e3636219f53 51ad457a7ec49f981e3aac0813060e3636219f53 draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework e5d666435c4ada60f396bc49ecc362afbdce3a1a8f09e51c583470b2f4fb9984 ['ae8fa4d819a308bedba82353bb058a7322212cce6eed6c2f0519be327173936b', 'e5d666435c4ada60f396bc49ecc362afbdce3a1a8f09e51c583470b2f4fb9984', 'a8257679538d2605f8cf2daf79ae6430c498dce55baebacdc872069a206c9aa6', '9046ed7f0f3054b0af7e329e67511332b0c0f05e1c3ed420ea5707de95cc0ba0', '153808cd3a8d91c08971b6c93d42cabfc65d73c0cfee9f3009d68264305facb7', '476829343a7368258bd0b6541be45e0dab3bd0e611a6d198fbf60eff1f60bd53'] B "the service sub-layer provides additional support beyond the connectivity function of the forwarding sub-layer. an example of this is packet replication, elimination, and ordering (preof) functions see preof." {8: 1, 55: 1, 6: 2, 68: 2, 31: 3, 67: 3, 90: 2, 84: 2} {74: 1, 247: 1, 256: 2, 2: 3, 5: 2, 8: 3, 209: 3, 83: 3, 20: 2, 21: 3, 277: 2, 276: 3, 88: 3, 233: 4, 236: 2, 302: 4, 47: 4, 303: 3, 112: 3, 126: 4, 127: 3} {256, 2, 5, 8, 271, 20, 21, 277, 276, 302, 47, 303, 74, 209, 83, 88, 233, 236, 112, 247, 126, 127} 31 "The method of instantiating each of the layers is specific to the particular DetNet data plane method. There may be more than one approach that is applicable to a given bearer network type." "Hi Did a pass through the Framework . Clean up some text . There are still some identified areas in the document where it calls for more detail . Also there is a open reference . reviewed in jun 24 call" 51ad457a7ec49f981e3aac0813060e3636219f53 51ad457a7ec49f981e3aac0813060e3636219f53 draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework ae8fa4d819a308bedba82353bb058a7322212cce6eed6c2f0519be327173936b ['ae8fa4d819a308bedba82353bb058a7322212cce6eed6c2f0519be327173936b', 'e5d666435c4ada60f396bc49ecc362afbdce3a1a8f09e51c583470b2f4fb9984', 'a8257679538d2605f8cf2daf79ae6430c498dce55baebacdc872069a206c9aa6', '9046ed7f0f3054b0af7e329e67511332b0c0f05e1c3ed420ea5707de95cc0ba0', '153808cd3a8d91c08971b6c93d42cabfc65d73c0cfee9f3009d68264305facb7', '476829343a7368258bd0b6541be45e0dab3bd0e611a6d198fbf60eff1f60bd53'] B "the method of instantiating each of the layers is specific to the particular detnet data plane method. there may be more than one approach that is applicable to a given bearer network type." {8: 1, 55: 1, 6: 2, 68: 2, 31: 3, 67: 3, 90: 2, 84: 2} {74: 1, 247: 1, 256: 2, 2: 3, 5: 2, 8: 3, 209: 3, 83: 3, 20: 2, 21: 3, 277: 2, 276: 3, 88: 3, 233: 4, 236: 2, 302: 4, 47: 4, 303: 3, 112: 3, 126: 4, 127: 3} {256, 2, 5, 8, 271, 20, 21, 277, 276, 302, 47, 303, 74, 209, 83, 88, 233, 236, 112, 247, 126, 127} 31 "Data plane construction: The DetNet service sub-layer provides its functions for the DetNet application flows by using or applying existing standardized headers and/or encapsulations. The Detnet forwarding sub-layer may provide capabilities leveraging that same header or encapsulation technology e.g. dn_svcs or it may be achieved by other standardized technologies e.g. dn_svc_encaps." "Hi Did a pass through the Framework . Clean up some text . There are still some identified areas in the document where it calls for more detail . Also there is a open reference . reviewed in jun 24 call" 51ad457a7ec49f981e3aac0813060e3636219f53 51ad457a7ec49f981e3aac0813060e3636219f53 draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework a8257679538d2605f8cf2daf79ae6430c498dce55baebacdc872069a206c9aa6 ['ae8fa4d819a308bedba82353bb058a7322212cce6eed6c2f0519be327173936b', 'e5d666435c4ada60f396bc49ecc362afbdce3a1a8f09e51c583470b2f4fb9984', 'a8257679538d2605f8cf2daf79ae6430c498dce55baebacdc872069a206c9aa6', '9046ed7f0f3054b0af7e329e67511332b0c0f05e1c3ed420ea5707de95cc0ba0', '153808cd3a8d91c08971b6c93d42cabfc65d73c0cfee9f3009d68264305facb7', '476829343a7368258bd0b6541be45e0dab3bd0e611a6d198fbf60eff1f60bd53'] B "data plane construction: the detnet service sub-layer provides its functions for the detnet application flows by using or applying existing standardized headers and/or encapsulations. the detnet forwarding sub-layer may provide capabilities leveraging that same header or encapsulation technology e.g. dn_svcs or it may be achieved by other standardized technologies e.g. dn_svc_encaps." {8: 1, 55: 1, 6: 2, 68: 2, 31: 3, 67: 3, 90: 2, 84: 2} {74: 1, 247: 1, 256: 2, 2: 3, 5: 2, 8: 3, 209: 3, 83: 3, 20: 2, 21: 3, 277: 2, 276: 3, 88: 3, 233: 4, 236: 2, 302: 4, 47: 4, 303: 3, 112: 3, 126: 4, 127: 3} {256, 2, 5, 8, 271, 20, 21, 277, 276, 302, 47, 303, 74, 209, 83, 88, 233, 236, 112, 247, 126, 127} 31 "Explicit inclusion of metadata in an IP packet is also possible through the inclusion of an MPLS label stack and the MPLS DetNet Control Word using one of the methods for carrying MPLS over IP I- D.mpls-over-udp-ip. This is described in more detail in subnet_considerations." "Hi Did a pass through the Framework . Clean up some text . There are still some identified areas in the document where it calls for more detail . Also there is a open reference . reviewed in jun 24 call" 51ad457a7ec49f981e3aac0813060e3636219f53 51ad457a7ec49f981e3aac0813060e3636219f53 draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework 71858e7d8f9c9e07448f67a7ba9b100aa687095fb2db4f32f99aff4d8a110bc6 ['0dbf6fca1a39a3eaa2c4ce6b874c15fc98d2826644ab76edfb9d77e1bbfeeecf', 'f1777b990287ac7f2e61d91352d291a407bc26390295452e09cd5542d6cad388', '71858e7d8f9c9e07448f67a7ba9b100aa687095fb2db4f32f99aff4d8a110bc6', '488067d315c616e2d21a1dc9378ccffefa1f9f5f754724632d56eba7300bb7a6'] A "explicit inclusion of metadata in an ip packet is also possible through the inclusion of an mpls label stack and the mpls detnet control word using one of the methods for carrying mpls over ip i- d.mpls-over-udp-ip. this is described in more detail in subnet_considerations." {8: 1, 6: 1, 68: 5, 31: 3, 67: 2, 90: 3, 84: 3, 55: 2} {112: 1, 256: 1, 2: 2, 5: 5, 74: 2, 271: 3, 209: 2, 83: 6, 20: 5, 21: 6, 277: 5, 276: 6, 88: 2, 233: 3, 236: 5, 302: 3, 47: 3, 303: 6, 247: 4, 126: 3, 127: 2} {256, 2, 5, 8, 271, 20, 21, 277, 276, 302, 47, 303, 74, 209, 83, 88, 233, 236, 112, 247, 126, 127} 31 "Implicit metadata can be included through the use of the network programming paradigm I-D.spring-srv6-network-programming in which the suffix of an IPv6 address is used to encode additional information for use by the network of the receiving host. Examples of such information include the sequence number for use by the PREOF function, or even all the essential information being included into the DetNet over MPLS label stack (the DetNet Control Word and the DetNet Service label)." "Hi Did a pass through the Framework . Clean up some text . There are still some identified areas in the document where it calls for more detail . Also there is a open reference . reviewed in jun 24 call" 51ad457a7ec49f981e3aac0813060e3636219f53 51ad457a7ec49f981e3aac0813060e3636219f53 draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework 488067d315c616e2d21a1dc9378ccffefa1f9f5f754724632d56eba7300bb7a6 ['0dbf6fca1a39a3eaa2c4ce6b874c15fc98d2826644ab76edfb9d77e1bbfeeecf', 'f1777b990287ac7f2e61d91352d291a407bc26390295452e09cd5542d6cad388', '71858e7d8f9c9e07448f67a7ba9b100aa687095fb2db4f32f99aff4d8a110bc6', '488067d315c616e2d21a1dc9378ccffefa1f9f5f754724632d56eba7300bb7a6'] A "implicit metadata can be included through the use of the network programming paradigm i-d.spring-srv6-network-programming in which the suffix of an ipv6 address is used to encode additional information for use by the network of the receiving host. examples of such information include the sequence number for use by the preof function, or even all the essential information being included into the detnet over mpls label stack (the detnet control word and the detnet service label)." {8: 1, 6: 1, 68: 5, 31: 3, 67: 2, 90: 3, 84: 3, 55: 2} {112: 1, 256: 1, 2: 2, 5: 5, 74: 2, 271: 3, 209: 2, 83: 6, 20: 5, 21: 6, 277: 5, 276: 6, 88: 2, 233: 3, 236: 5, 302: 3, 47: 3, 303: 6, 247: 4, 126: 3, 127: 2} {256, 2, 5, 8, 271, 20, 21, 277, 276, 302, 47, 303, 74, 209, 83, 88, 233, 236, 112, 247, 126, 127} 31 "Explicit inclusion of metadata in an IP packet is also possible through the inclusion of an MPLS label stack and the MPLS DetNet Control Word using one of the methods for carrying MPLS over IP I- D.ietf-detnet-mpls-over-udp-ip. This is described in more detail in subnet_considerations." "Hi Did a pass through the Framework . Clean up some text . There are still some identified areas in the document where it calls for more detail . Also there is a open reference . reviewed in jun 24 call" 51ad457a7ec49f981e3aac0813060e3636219f53 51ad457a7ec49f981e3aac0813060e3636219f53 draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework f1777b990287ac7f2e61d91352d291a407bc26390295452e09cd5542d6cad388 ['0dbf6fca1a39a3eaa2c4ce6b874c15fc98d2826644ab76edfb9d77e1bbfeeecf', 'f1777b990287ac7f2e61d91352d291a407bc26390295452e09cd5542d6cad388', '71858e7d8f9c9e07448f67a7ba9b100aa687095fb2db4f32f99aff4d8a110bc6', '488067d315c616e2d21a1dc9378ccffefa1f9f5f754724632d56eba7300bb7a6'] B "explicit inclusion of metadata in an ip packet is also possible through the inclusion of an mpls label stack and the mpls detnet control word using one of the methods for carrying mpls over ip i- d.ietf-detnet-mpls-over-udp-ip. this is described in more detail in subnet_considerations." {8: 1, 6: 1, 68: 5, 31: 3, 67: 2, 90: 3, 84: 3, 55: 2} {112: 1, 256: 1, 2: 2, 5: 5, 74: 2, 271: 3, 209: 2, 83: 6, 20: 5, 21: 6, 277: 5, 276: 6, 88: 2, 233: 3, 236: 5, 302: 3, 47: 3, 303: 6, 247: 4, 126: 3, 127: 2} {256, 2, 5, 8, 271, 20, 21, 277, 276, 302, 47, 303, 74, 209, 83, 88, 233, 236, 112, 247, 126, 127} 31 "Implicit metadata can be included through the use of the network programming paradigm I-D.ietf-spring-srv6-network-programming in which the suffix of an IPv6 address is used to encode additional information for use by the network of the receiving host. Examples of such information include the sequence number for use by the PREOF function, or even all the essential information being included into the DetNet over MPLS label stack (the DetNet Control Word and the DetNet Service label)." "Hi Did a pass through the Framework . Clean up some text . There are still some identified areas in the document where it calls for more detail . Also there is a open reference . reviewed in jun 24 call" 51ad457a7ec49f981e3aac0813060e3636219f53 51ad457a7ec49f981e3aac0813060e3636219f53 draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework 0dbf6fca1a39a3eaa2c4ce6b874c15fc98d2826644ab76edfb9d77e1bbfeeecf ['0dbf6fca1a39a3eaa2c4ce6b874c15fc98d2826644ab76edfb9d77e1bbfeeecf', 'f1777b990287ac7f2e61d91352d291a407bc26390295452e09cd5542d6cad388', '71858e7d8f9c9e07448f67a7ba9b100aa687095fb2db4f32f99aff4d8a110bc6', '488067d315c616e2d21a1dc9378ccffefa1f9f5f754724632d56eba7300bb7a6'] B "implicit metadata can be included through the use of the network programming paradigm i-d.ietf-spring-srv6-network-programming in which the suffix of an ipv6 address is used to encode additional information for use by the network of the receiving host. examples of such information include the sequence number for use by the preof function, or even all the essential information being included into the detnet over mpls label stack (the detnet control word and the detnet service label)." {8: 1, 6: 1, 68: 5, 31: 3, 67: 2, 90: 3, 84: 3, 55: 2} {112: 1, 256: 1, 2: 2, 5: 5, 74: 2, 271: 3, 209: 2, 83: 6, 20: 5, 21: 6, 277: 5, 276: 6, 88: 2, 233: 3, 236: 5, 302: 3, 47: 3, 303: 6, 247: 4, 126: 3, 127: 2} {256, 2, 5, 8, 271, 20, 21, 277, 276, 302, 47, 303, 74, 209, 83, 88, 233, 236, 112, 247, 126, 127} 31 "In cases where metadata is needed to process an MPLS encapsulated packet at the service sub-layer, this has been been provided through the use of a shim layer also called a control word (CW) RFC4385. Although such CWs are frequently 32 bits long, there is no architectural constraint on its size of this structure, only the requirement that it is fully understood by all parties operating on it in the DetNet service sub-layer. The operation of this method is described in detail in I-D.ietf-detnet-mpls." "Hi Did a pass through the Framework . Clean up some text . There are still some identified areas in the document where it calls for more detail . Also there is a open reference . reviewed in jun 24 call" 51ad457a7ec49f981e3aac0813060e3636219f53 51ad457a7ec49f981e3aac0813060e3636219f53 draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework b1ff68903ac6e0b8543e21f49db921c33e25559d9a9e6a3d6f7d04ca0e93291c ['f71f75d35dcc2acd07fda08a3fb81b53c376a734ccbbfc6a11ca7d42b1e06d5c', '30ef44fce6c96208d23b0da408dc19eb429d22d490947c0bdef4bcef48d02ead', 'b1ff68903ac6e0b8543e21f49db921c33e25559d9a9e6a3d6f7d04ca0e93291c'] A "in cases where metadata is needed to process an mpls encapsulated packet at the service sub-layer, this has been been provided through the use of a shim layer also called a control word (cw) rfc4385. although such cws are frequently 32 bits long, there is no architectural constraint on its size of this structure, only the requirement that it is fully understood by all parties operating on it in the detnet service sub-layer. the operation of this method is described in detail in i-d.ietf-detnet-mpls." {8: 1, 55: 1, 6: 2, 79: 7, 90: 5, 51: 7, 130: 7, 62: 6, 85: 6, 68: 2, 35: 8, 110: 8, 91: 10, 114: 8, 97: 8, 31: 6, 13: 7, 67: 7, 38: 9, 26: 6, 124: 7, 98: 7, 54: 7, 127: 8, 96: 8, 64: 7, 30: 9, 61: 10, 27: 6, 15: 8, 52: 6, 129: 8, 115: 8, 84: 3, 76: 8, 87: 8, 131: 10, 102: 5, 113: 10, 99: 7, 36: 8, 24: 7, 53: 6, 72: 9} {218: 1, 398: 1, 1: 2, 4: 7, 9: 7, 10: 8, 15: 8, 24: 7, 25: 6, 26: 6, 27: 8, 39: 2, 43: 8, 49: 11, 50: 10, 58: 10, 59: 7, 64: 8, 69: 6, 81: 7, 82: 7, 86: 8, 96: 9, 97: 8, 100: 10, 108: 8, 109: 9, 110: 9, 111: 7, 114: 8, 115: 9, 116: 8, 118: 7, 119: 6, 120: 8, 121: 5, 122: 9, 123: 8, 124: 4, 128: 9, 129: 9, 130: 10, 132: 6, 136: 7, 145: 6, 147: 9, 151: 9, 152: 9, 154: 8, 156: 7, 161: 5, 162: 4, 165: 8, 168: 9, 169: 8, 172: 8, 180: 9, 184: 7, 187: 10, 188: 9, 191: 8, 194: 6, 202: 7, 203: 8, 206: 7, 207: 8, 215: 6, 217: 8, 220: 5, 221: 5, 222: 4, 224: 8, 227: 8, 229: 8, 234: 10, 235: 7, 241: 7, 242: 7, 243: 6, 244: 9, 245: 6, 248: 9, 250: 9, 258: 4, 262: 9, 263: 10, 264: 6, 267: 5, 270: 8, 272: 8, 273: 7, 287: 8, 289: 8, 291: 10, 299: 8, 300: 8, 304: 8, 309: 5, 314: 7, 315: 8, 320: 5, 323: 6, 327: 9, 328: 7, 329: 7, 330: 3, 334: 7, 335: 8, 341: 8, 342: 9, 347: 8, 348: 8, 350: 9, 351: 10, 352: 8, 353: 8, 354: 7, 358: 3, 365: 8, 366: 7, 369: 6, 371: 10, 372: 10, 376: 7, 384: 10, 385: 9, 386: 8, 387: 8, 392: 7, 393: 8, 396: 9, 402: 8} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 31 This section needs further work. "Hi Did a pass through the Framework . Clean up some text . There are still some identified areas in the document where it calls for more detail . Also there is a open reference . reviewed in jun 24 call" 51ad457a7ec49f981e3aac0813060e3636219f53 51ad457a7ec49f981e3aac0813060e3636219f53 draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework 30ef44fce6c96208d23b0da408dc19eb429d22d490947c0bdef4bcef48d02ead ['f71f75d35dcc2acd07fda08a3fb81b53c376a734ccbbfc6a11ca7d42b1e06d5c', '30ef44fce6c96208d23b0da408dc19eb429d22d490947c0bdef4bcef48d02ead', 'b1ff68903ac6e0b8543e21f49db921c33e25559d9a9e6a3d6f7d04ca0e93291c'] A this section needs further work. {8: 1, 55: 1, 6: 2, 79: 7, 90: 5, 51: 7, 130: 7, 62: 6, 85: 6, 68: 2, 35: 8, 110: 8, 91: 10, 114: 8, 97: 8, 31: 6, 13: 7, 67: 7, 38: 9, 26: 6, 124: 7, 98: 7, 54: 7, 127: 8, 96: 8, 64: 7, 30: 9, 61: 10, 27: 6, 15: 8, 52: 6, 129: 8, 115: 8, 84: 3, 76: 8, 87: 8, 131: 10, 102: 5, 113: 10, 99: 7, 36: 8, 24: 7, 53: 6, 72: 9} {218: 1, 398: 1, 1: 2, 4: 7, 9: 7, 10: 8, 15: 8, 24: 7, 25: 6, 26: 6, 27: 8, 39: 2, 43: 8, 49: 11, 50: 10, 58: 10, 59: 7, 64: 8, 69: 6, 81: 7, 82: 7, 86: 8, 96: 9, 97: 8, 100: 10, 108: 8, 109: 9, 110: 9, 111: 7, 114: 8, 115: 9, 116: 8, 118: 7, 119: 6, 120: 8, 121: 5, 122: 9, 123: 8, 124: 4, 128: 9, 129: 9, 130: 10, 132: 6, 136: 7, 145: 6, 147: 9, 151: 9, 152: 9, 154: 8, 156: 7, 161: 5, 162: 4, 165: 8, 168: 9, 169: 8, 172: 8, 180: 9, 184: 7, 187: 10, 188: 9, 191: 8, 194: 6, 202: 7, 203: 8, 206: 7, 207: 8, 215: 6, 217: 8, 220: 5, 221: 5, 222: 4, 224: 8, 227: 8, 229: 8, 234: 10, 235: 7, 241: 7, 242: 7, 243: 6, 244: 9, 245: 6, 248: 9, 250: 9, 258: 4, 262: 9, 263: 10, 264: 6, 267: 5, 270: 8, 272: 8, 273: 7, 287: 8, 289: 8, 291: 10, 299: 8, 300: 8, 304: 8, 309: 5, 314: 7, 315: 8, 320: 5, 323: 6, 327: 9, 328: 7, 329: 7, 330: 3, 334: 7, 335: 8, 341: 8, 342: 9, 347: 8, 348: 8, 350: 9, 351: 10, 352: 8, 353: 8, 354: 7, 358: 3, 365: 8, 366: 7, 369: 6, 371: 10, 372: 10, 376: 7, 384: 10, 385: 9, 386: 8, 387: 8, 392: 7, 393: 8, 396: 9, 402: 8} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 31 "In cases where metadata is needed to process an MPLS encapsulated packet at the service sub-layer, a shim layer also called a control word (CW) RFC4385 can be used. Although such CWs are frequently 32 bits long, there is no architectural constraint on its size of this structure, only the requirement that it is fully understood by all parties operating on it in the DetNet service sub-layer. The operation of this method is described in detail in I-D.ietf-detnet- mpls." "Hi Did a pass through the Framework . Clean up some text . There are still some identified areas in the document where it calls for more detail . Also there is a open reference . reviewed in jun 24 call" 51ad457a7ec49f981e3aac0813060e3636219f53 51ad457a7ec49f981e3aac0813060e3636219f53 draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework f71f75d35dcc2acd07fda08a3fb81b53c376a734ccbbfc6a11ca7d42b1e06d5c ['f71f75d35dcc2acd07fda08a3fb81b53c376a734ccbbfc6a11ca7d42b1e06d5c', '30ef44fce6c96208d23b0da408dc19eb429d22d490947c0bdef4bcef48d02ead', 'b1ff68903ac6e0b8543e21f49db921c33e25559d9a9e6a3d6f7d04ca0e93291c'] B "in cases where metadata is needed to process an mpls encapsulated packet at the service sub-layer, a shim layer also called a control word (cw) rfc4385 can be used. although such cws are frequently 32 bits long, there is no architectural constraint on its size of this structure, only the requirement that it is fully understood by all parties operating on it in the detnet service sub-layer. the operation of this method is described in detail in i-d.ietf-detnet- mpls." {8: 1, 55: 1, 6: 2, 79: 7, 90: 5, 51: 7, 130: 7, 62: 6, 85: 6, 68: 2, 35: 8, 110: 8, 91: 10, 114: 8, 97: 8, 31: 6, 13: 7, 67: 7, 38: 9, 26: 6, 124: 7, 98: 7, 54: 7, 127: 8, 96: 8, 64: 7, 30: 9, 61: 10, 27: 6, 15: 8, 52: 6, 129: 8, 115: 8, 84: 3, 76: 8, 87: 8, 131: 10, 102: 5, 113: 10, 99: 7, 36: 8, 24: 7, 53: 6, 72: 9} {218: 1, 398: 1, 1: 2, 4: 7, 9: 7, 10: 8, 15: 8, 24: 7, 25: 6, 26: 6, 27: 8, 39: 2, 43: 8, 49: 11, 50: 10, 58: 10, 59: 7, 64: 8, 69: 6, 81: 7, 82: 7, 86: 8, 96: 9, 97: 8, 100: 10, 108: 8, 109: 9, 110: 9, 111: 7, 114: 8, 115: 9, 116: 8, 118: 7, 119: 6, 120: 8, 121: 5, 122: 9, 123: 8, 124: 4, 128: 9, 129: 9, 130: 10, 132: 6, 136: 7, 145: 6, 147: 9, 151: 9, 152: 9, 154: 8, 156: 7, 161: 5, 162: 4, 165: 8, 168: 9, 169: 8, 172: 8, 180: 9, 184: 7, 187: 10, 188: 9, 191: 8, 194: 6, 202: 7, 203: 8, 206: 7, 207: 8, 215: 6, 217: 8, 220: 5, 221: 5, 222: 4, 224: 8, 227: 8, 229: 8, 234: 10, 235: 7, 241: 7, 242: 7, 243: 6, 244: 9, 245: 6, 248: 9, 250: 9, 258: 4, 262: 9, 263: 10, 264: 6, 267: 5, 270: 8, 272: 8, 273: 7, 287: 8, 289: 8, 291: 10, 299: 8, 300: 8, 304: 8, 309: 5, 314: 7, 315: 8, 320: 5, 323: 6, 327: 9, 328: 7, 329: 7, 330: 3, 334: 7, 335: 8, 341: 8, 342: 9, 347: 8, 348: 8, 350: 9, 351: 10, 352: 8, 353: 8, 354: 7, 358: 3, 365: 8, 366: 7, 369: 6, 371: 10, 372: 10, 376: 7, 384: 10, 385: 9, 386: 8, 387: 8, 392: 7, 393: 8, 396: 9, 402: 8} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 31 "The above is of course illustrative of many network scenarios that can be configured. Between a pair of relay nodes there may be one or more transit nodes that simply forward the DetNet traffic, but these are omitted for clarity." "Hi Did a pass through the Framework . Clean up some text . There are still some identified areas in the document where it calls for more detail . Also there is a open reference . reviewed in jun 24 call" 51ad457a7ec49f981e3aac0813060e3636219f53 51ad457a7ec49f981e3aac0813060e3636219f53 draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework ab93afb1ce53a91a86685ff579055185d9f7a6798d6effa52aec9838538bdf15 ['ab93afb1ce53a91a86685ff579055185d9f7a6798d6effa52aec9838538bdf15', '16a03048c953cef363cd6d95e32e6eb26356557a189bbfd0a19ba6a65e82a562'] A "the above is of course illustrative of many network scenarios that can be configured. between a pair of relay nodes there may be one or more transit nodes that simply forward the detnet traffic, but these are omitted for clarity." {6: 1, 52: 1, 79: 3, 90: 3, 51: 4, 130: 3, 62: 4, 85: 4, 68: 3, 35: 4, 110: 4, 91: 6, 114: 4, 97: 4, 31: 2, 13: 4, 67: 2, 38: 5, 26: 4, 124: 2, 98: 3, 54: 3, 127: 4, 8: 2, 96: 4, 64: 3, 30: 5, 61: 6, 55: 2, 27: 2, 15: 4, 129: 4, 115: 4, 84: 2, 76: 4, 87: 4, 131: 6, 102: 3, 113: 6, 99: 3, 36: 4, 24: 3, 53: 2, 72: 5} {161: 1, 215: 1, 1: 8, 4: 3, 9: 3, 10: 4, 15: 4, 24: 3, 25: 4, 26: 4, 27: 4, 39: 4, 43: 4, 49: 7, 50: 6, 58: 6, 59: 3, 64: 4, 69: 2, 81: 5, 82: 5, 86: 4, 96: 5, 97: 4, 100: 8, 108: 4, 109: 5, 110: 5, 111: 3, 114: 4, 115: 5, 116: 4, 118: 5, 119: 4, 120: 4, 121: 3, 122: 5, 123: 4, 124: 3, 128: 5, 129: 5, 130: 6, 132: 2, 136: 3, 145: 2, 147: 5, 151: 5, 152: 5, 154: 4, 156: 3, 162: 2, 165: 4, 168: 5, 169: 4, 172: 4, 180: 5, 184: 3, 187: 6, 188: 5, 191: 4, 194: 2, 202: 3, 203: 4, 206: 3, 207: 4, 217: 4, 218: 7, 220: 2, 221: 2, 222: 4, 224: 4, 227: 6, 229: 4, 234: 6, 235: 3, 241: 3, 242: 3, 243: 2, 244: 5, 245: 2, 248: 5, 250: 5, 258: 10, 262: 5, 263: 6, 267: 3, 270: 4, 272: 4, 273: 3, 287: 4, 289: 4, 291: 6, 299: 6, 300: 4, 304: 4, 309: 3, 314: 3, 315: 4, 320: 3, 323: 2, 327: 5, 328: 2, 329: 3, 330: 9, 334: 3, 335: 4, 341: 6, 342: 7, 347: 6, 348: 6, 350: 5, 351: 6, 352: 4, 353: 4, 354: 3, 358: 3, 365: 4, 366: 3, 369: 2, 371: 8, 372: 6, 376: 3, 384: 6, 385: 5, 386: 4, 387: 4, 392: 2, 393: 3, 396: 7, 397: 6, 398: 5, 402: 4} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 31 "The above is of course illustrative of many network scenarios that can be configured." "Hi Did a pass through the Framework . Clean up some text . There are still some identified areas in the document where it calls for more detail . Also there is a open reference . reviewed in jun 24 call" 51ad457a7ec49f981e3aac0813060e3636219f53 51ad457a7ec49f981e3aac0813060e3636219f53 draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework 16a03048c953cef363cd6d95e32e6eb26356557a189bbfd0a19ba6a65e82a562 ['ab93afb1ce53a91a86685ff579055185d9f7a6798d6effa52aec9838538bdf15', '16a03048c953cef363cd6d95e32e6eb26356557a189bbfd0a19ba6a65e82a562'] B "the above is of course illustrative of many network scenarios that can be configured." {6: 1, 52: 1, 79: 3, 90: 3, 51: 4, 130: 3, 62: 4, 85: 4, 68: 3, 35: 4, 110: 4, 91: 6, 114: 4, 97: 4, 31: 2, 13: 4, 67: 2, 38: 5, 26: 4, 124: 2, 98: 3, 54: 3, 127: 4, 8: 2, 96: 4, 64: 3, 30: 5, 61: 6, 55: 2, 27: 2, 15: 4, 129: 4, 115: 4, 84: 2, 76: 4, 87: 4, 131: 6, 102: 3, 113: 6, 99: 3, 36: 4, 24: 3, 53: 2, 72: 5} {161: 1, 215: 1, 1: 8, 4: 3, 9: 3, 10: 4, 15: 4, 24: 3, 25: 4, 26: 4, 27: 4, 39: 4, 43: 4, 49: 7, 50: 6, 58: 6, 59: 3, 64: 4, 69: 2, 81: 5, 82: 5, 86: 4, 96: 5, 97: 4, 100: 8, 108: 4, 109: 5, 110: 5, 111: 3, 114: 4, 115: 5, 116: 4, 118: 5, 119: 4, 120: 4, 121: 3, 122: 5, 123: 4, 124: 3, 128: 5, 129: 5, 130: 6, 132: 2, 136: 3, 145: 2, 147: 5, 151: 5, 152: 5, 154: 4, 156: 3, 162: 2, 165: 4, 168: 5, 169: 4, 172: 4, 180: 5, 184: 3, 187: 6, 188: 5, 191: 4, 194: 2, 202: 3, 203: 4, 206: 3, 207: 4, 217: 4, 218: 7, 220: 2, 221: 2, 222: 4, 224: 4, 227: 6, 229: 4, 234: 6, 235: 3, 241: 3, 242: 3, 243: 2, 244: 5, 245: 2, 248: 5, 250: 5, 258: 10, 262: 5, 263: 6, 267: 3, 270: 4, 272: 4, 273: 3, 287: 4, 289: 4, 291: 6, 299: 6, 300: 4, 304: 4, 309: 3, 314: 3, 315: 4, 320: 3, 323: 2, 327: 5, 328: 2, 329: 3, 330: 9, 334: 3, 335: 4, 341: 6, 342: 7, 347: 6, 348: 6, 350: 5, 351: 6, 352: 4, 353: 4, 354: 3, 358: 3, 365: 4, 366: 3, 369: 2, 371: 8, 372: 6, 376: 3, 384: 6, 385: 5, 386: 4, 387: 4, 392: 2, 393: 3, 396: 7, 397: 6, 398: 5, 402: 4} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 31 "The DetNet data plane also allows for the aggregation of DetNet flows, to improved scaling by reducing the state per hop. How this is done is data plane or control plane dependent. When DetNet flows are aggregated, transit nodes provide service to the aggregate and not on a per-DetNet flow basis. When aggregating DetNet flows the flows should be compatible i.e. the same or very similar QoS and CoS characteristics. In this case, nodes performing aggregation will ensure that per-flow service requirements are achieved." "Hi Did a pass through the Framework . Clean up some text . There are still some identified areas in the document where it calls for more detail . Also there is a open reference . reviewed in jun 24 call" 51ad457a7ec49f981e3aac0813060e3636219f53 51ad457a7ec49f981e3aac0813060e3636219f53 draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework 9f3e9e766fee6f9a75b58bf2c2c777ce55644ad43d69d63665d0083617a38b97 ['9f3e9e766fee6f9a75b58bf2c2c777ce55644ad43d69d63665d0083617a38b97', '61014e6e8d3f5344f8f3c8c5674b189d6fbe221923e2f7afdda5acb8e3f89aa7'] A "the detnet data plane also allows for the aggregation of detnet flows, to improved scaling by reducing the state per hop. how this is done is data plane or control plane dependent. when detnet flows are aggregated, transit nodes provide service to the aggregate and not on a per-detnet flow basis. when aggregating detnet flows the flows should be compatible i.e. the same or very similar qos and cos characteristics. in this case, nodes performing aggregation will ensure that per-flow service requirements are achieved." {6: 1, 55: 1, 79: 4, 90: 3, 51: 5, 130: 4, 62: 4, 85: 4, 68: 3, 35: 5, 110: 5, 91: 7, 114: 5, 97: 5, 31: 2, 13: 5, 67: 3, 38: 6, 26: 4, 124: 3, 98: 4, 54: 4, 127: 5, 8: 2, 96: 5, 64: 4, 30: 6, 61: 7, 27: 2, 15: 5, 52: 2, 129: 5, 115: 5, 84: 2, 76: 3, 87: 5, 131: 7, 102: 3, 113: 7, 99: 4, 36: 5, 24: 4, 53: 3, 72: 6} {161: 1, 243: 1, 1: 8, 4: 4, 9: 3, 10: 5, 15: 5, 24: 4, 25: 4, 26: 4, 27: 5, 39: 4, 43: 5, 49: 8, 50: 7, 58: 7, 59: 4, 64: 5, 69: 2, 81: 5, 82: 5, 86: 5, 96: 6, 97: 5, 100: 8, 108: 5, 109: 6, 110: 6, 111: 4, 114: 5, 115: 6, 116: 5, 118: 5, 119: 4, 120: 5, 121: 3, 122: 6, 123: 5, 124: 3, 128: 6, 129: 6, 130: 7, 132: 2, 136: 4, 145: 2, 147: 6, 151: 6, 152: 6, 154: 5, 156: 4, 162: 2, 165: 5, 168: 6, 169: 5, 172: 5, 180: 6, 184: 3, 187: 7, 188: 6, 191: 5, 194: 2, 202: 2, 203: 3, 206: 4, 207: 5, 215: 2, 217: 5, 218: 7, 220: 3, 221: 3, 222: 4, 224: 5, 227: 6, 229: 5, 234: 7, 235: 4, 241: 4, 242: 4, 244: 6, 248: 6, 250: 6, 258: 10, 262: 6, 263: 7, 264: 2, 267: 3, 270: 5, 272: 5, 273: 2, 287: 5, 289: 5, 291: 7, 299: 6, 300: 5, 304: 5, 309: 3, 314: 4, 315: 5, 320: 3, 323: 2, 327: 6, 328: 3, 329: 4, 330: 9, 334: 4, 335: 5, 341: 6, 342: 7, 347: 6, 348: 6, 350: 4, 351: 7, 352: 5, 353: 5, 354: 4, 358: 3, 365: 5, 366: 4, 369: 3, 371: 8, 372: 7, 376: 4, 384: 7, 385: 6, 386: 5, 387: 5, 392: 3, 393: 4, 396: 7, 397: 6, 398: 5, 402: 5} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 31 "The DetNet data plane also allows for the aggregation of DetNet flows, to improved scaling by reducing the state per hop. How this is accomplished is data plane or control plane dependent. When DetNet flows are aggregated, transit nodes provide service to the aggregate and not on a per-DetNet flow basis. When aggregating DetNet flows the flows should be compatible i.e. the same or very similar QoS and CoS characteristics. In this case, nodes performing aggregation will ensure that per-flow service requirements are achieved." "Hi Did a pass through the Framework . Clean up some text . There are still some identified areas in the document where it calls for more detail . Also there is a open reference . reviewed in jun 24 call" 51ad457a7ec49f981e3aac0813060e3636219f53 51ad457a7ec49f981e3aac0813060e3636219f53 draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework 61014e6e8d3f5344f8f3c8c5674b189d6fbe221923e2f7afdda5acb8e3f89aa7 ['9f3e9e766fee6f9a75b58bf2c2c777ce55644ad43d69d63665d0083617a38b97', '61014e6e8d3f5344f8f3c8c5674b189d6fbe221923e2f7afdda5acb8e3f89aa7'] B "the detnet data plane also allows for the aggregation of detnet flows, to improved scaling by reducing the state per hop. how this is accomplished is data plane or control plane dependent. when detnet flows are aggregated, transit nodes provide service to the aggregate and not on a per-detnet flow basis. when aggregating detnet flows the flows should be compatible i.e. the same or very similar qos and cos characteristics. in this case, nodes performing aggregation will ensure that per-flow service requirements are achieved." {6: 1, 55: 1, 79: 4, 90: 3, 51: 5, 130: 4, 62: 4, 85: 4, 68: 3, 35: 5, 110: 5, 91: 7, 114: 5, 97: 5, 31: 2, 13: 5, 67: 3, 38: 6, 26: 4, 124: 3, 98: 4, 54: 4, 127: 5, 8: 2, 96: 5, 64: 4, 30: 6, 61: 7, 27: 2, 15: 5, 52: 2, 129: 5, 115: 5, 84: 2, 76: 3, 87: 5, 131: 7, 102: 3, 113: 7, 99: 4, 36: 5, 24: 4, 53: 3, 72: 6} {161: 1, 243: 1, 1: 8, 4: 4, 9: 3, 10: 5, 15: 5, 24: 4, 25: 4, 26: 4, 27: 5, 39: 4, 43: 5, 49: 8, 50: 7, 58: 7, 59: 4, 64: 5, 69: 2, 81: 5, 82: 5, 86: 5, 96: 6, 97: 5, 100: 8, 108: 5, 109: 6, 110: 6, 111: 4, 114: 5, 115: 6, 116: 5, 118: 5, 119: 4, 120: 5, 121: 3, 122: 6, 123: 5, 124: 3, 128: 6, 129: 6, 130: 7, 132: 2, 136: 4, 145: 2, 147: 6, 151: 6, 152: 6, 154: 5, 156: 4, 162: 2, 165: 5, 168: 6, 169: 5, 172: 5, 180: 6, 184: 3, 187: 7, 188: 6, 191: 5, 194: 2, 202: 2, 203: 3, 206: 4, 207: 5, 215: 2, 217: 5, 218: 7, 220: 3, 221: 3, 222: 4, 224: 5, 227: 6, 229: 5, 234: 7, 235: 4, 241: 4, 242: 4, 244: 6, 248: 6, 250: 6, 258: 10, 262: 6, 263: 7, 264: 2, 267: 3, 270: 5, 272: 5, 273: 2, 287: 5, 289: 5, 291: 7, 299: 6, 300: 5, 304: 5, 309: 3, 314: 4, 315: 5, 320: 3, 323: 2, 327: 6, 328: 3, 329: 4, 330: 9, 334: 4, 335: 5, 341: 6, 342: 7, 347: 6, 348: 6, 350: 4, 351: 7, 352: 5, 353: 5, 354: 4, 358: 3, 365: 5, 366: 4, 369: 3, 371: 8, 372: 7, 376: 4, 384: 7, 385: 6, 386: 5, 387: 5, 392: 3, 393: 4, 396: 7, 397: 6, 398: 5, 402: 5} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 31 "DetNet encapsulation is a data plane mechanism that can be used to aggregate traffic. Encapsulation can either be in the same service type or in a different service type see dn_svc_encaps for examples. When an encapsulation is used the choice of reserving a maximum resource level and then tracking the services in the aggregated service or adjusting the aggregated resources as the services are added is implementation and technology specific." "Hi Did a pass through the Framework . Clean up some text . There are still some identified areas in the document where it calls for more detail . Also there is a open reference . reviewed in jun 24 call" 51ad457a7ec49f981e3aac0813060e3636219f53 51ad457a7ec49f981e3aac0813060e3636219f53 draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework 32c06de60bfb9a32a4964f8ff36fd6c68613588e0780c615ffba4c9345430550 ['32c06de60bfb9a32a4964f8ff36fd6c68613588e0780c615ffba4c9345430550', '17c7b257bc9a74ada3610b169a11c651dffd113a06ac432f686bf57e04743c29'] A "detnet encapsulation is a data plane mechanism that can be used to aggregate traffic. encapsulation can either be in the same service type or in a different service type see dn_svc_encaps for examples. when an encapsulation is used the choice of reserving a maximum resource level and then tracking the services in the aggregated service or adjusting the aggregated resources as the services are added is implementation and technology specific." {6: 1, 55: 1, 79: 4, 90: 3, 51: 5, 130: 4, 62: 4, 85: 4, 68: 3, 35: 5, 110: 5, 91: 7, 114: 5, 97: 5, 13: 5, 67: 3, 38: 6, 26: 4, 124: 3, 98: 4, 54: 4, 127: 5, 8: 2, 96: 5, 64: 4, 30: 6, 61: 7, 27: 2, 15: 5, 52: 2, 129: 5, 115: 5, 31: 2, 84: 2, 76: 3, 87: 5, 131: 7, 102: 3, 113: 7, 99: 4, 36: 5, 24: 4, 53: 3, 72: 6} {161: 1, 243: 1, 1: 8, 4: 4, 9: 3, 10: 5, 15: 5, 24: 4, 25: 4, 26: 4, 27: 5, 39: 4, 43: 5, 49: 8, 50: 7, 58: 7, 59: 4, 64: 5, 81: 5, 82: 5, 86: 5, 96: 6, 97: 5, 100: 8, 108: 5, 109: 6, 110: 6, 111: 4, 114: 5, 115: 6, 116: 5, 118: 5, 119: 4, 120: 5, 121: 3, 122: 6, 123: 5, 124: 3, 128: 6, 129: 6, 130: 7, 132: 2, 136: 4, 145: 2, 147: 6, 151: 6, 152: 6, 154: 5, 156: 4, 162: 2, 165: 5, 168: 6, 169: 5, 172: 5, 180: 6, 184: 3, 187: 7, 188: 6, 191: 5, 194: 2, 202: 2, 203: 3, 206: 4, 207: 5, 215: 2, 217: 5, 218: 7, 220: 3, 221: 3, 222: 4, 224: 5, 227: 6, 229: 5, 234: 7, 235: 4, 241: 4, 242: 4, 244: 6, 245: 2, 248: 6, 250: 6, 258: 10, 262: 6, 263: 7, 264: 2, 267: 3, 270: 5, 272: 5, 273: 2, 287: 5, 289: 5, 291: 7, 299: 6, 300: 5, 304: 5, 309: 3, 314: 4, 315: 5, 320: 3, 323: 2, 327: 6, 328: 3, 329: 4, 330: 9, 334: 4, 335: 5, 341: 6, 342: 7, 347: 6, 348: 6, 350: 4, 351: 7, 352: 5, 353: 5, 354: 4, 358: 3, 365: 5, 366: 4, 369: 3, 371: 8, 372: 7, 376: 4, 384: 7, 385: 6, 386: 5, 387: 5, 392: 3, 393: 4, 396: 7, 397: 6, 398: 5, 402: 5} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 31 "DetNet encapsulation is a data plane mechanism that can be used to aggregate traffic. Encapsulation can either be in the same service type or in a different service type see dn_svc_encaps for example. When an encapsulation is used the choice of reserving a maximum resource level and then tracking the services in the aggregated service or adjusting the aggregated resources as the services are added is implementation and technology specific." "Hi Did a pass through the Framework . Clean up some text . There are still some identified areas in the document where it calls for more detail . Also there is a open reference . reviewed in jun 24 call" 51ad457a7ec49f981e3aac0813060e3636219f53 51ad457a7ec49f981e3aac0813060e3636219f53 draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework 17c7b257bc9a74ada3610b169a11c651dffd113a06ac432f686bf57e04743c29 ['32c06de60bfb9a32a4964f8ff36fd6c68613588e0780c615ffba4c9345430550', '17c7b257bc9a74ada3610b169a11c651dffd113a06ac432f686bf57e04743c29'] B "detnet encapsulation is a data plane mechanism that can be used to aggregate traffic. encapsulation can either be in the same service type or in a different service type see dn_svc_encaps for example. when an encapsulation is used the choice of reserving a maximum resource level and then tracking the services in the aggregated service or adjusting the aggregated resources as the services are added is implementation and technology specific." {6: 1, 55: 1, 79: 4, 90: 3, 51: 5, 130: 4, 62: 4, 85: 4, 68: 3, 35: 5, 110: 5, 91: 7, 114: 5, 97: 5, 13: 5, 67: 3, 38: 6, 26: 4, 124: 3, 98: 4, 54: 4, 127: 5, 8: 2, 96: 5, 64: 4, 30: 6, 61: 7, 27: 2, 15: 5, 52: 2, 129: 5, 115: 5, 31: 2, 84: 2, 76: 3, 87: 5, 131: 7, 102: 3, 113: 7, 99: 4, 36: 5, 24: 4, 53: 3, 72: 6} {161: 1, 243: 1, 1: 8, 4: 4, 9: 3, 10: 5, 15: 5, 24: 4, 25: 4, 26: 4, 27: 5, 39: 4, 43: 5, 49: 8, 50: 7, 58: 7, 59: 4, 64: 5, 81: 5, 82: 5, 86: 5, 96: 6, 97: 5, 100: 8, 108: 5, 109: 6, 110: 6, 111: 4, 114: 5, 115: 6, 116: 5, 118: 5, 119: 4, 120: 5, 121: 3, 122: 6, 123: 5, 124: 3, 128: 6, 129: 6, 130: 7, 132: 2, 136: 4, 145: 2, 147: 6, 151: 6, 152: 6, 154: 5, 156: 4, 162: 2, 165: 5, 168: 6, 169: 5, 172: 5, 180: 6, 184: 3, 187: 7, 188: 6, 191: 5, 194: 2, 202: 2, 203: 3, 206: 4, 207: 5, 215: 2, 217: 5, 218: 7, 220: 3, 221: 3, 222: 4, 224: 5, 227: 6, 229: 5, 234: 7, 235: 4, 241: 4, 242: 4, 244: 6, 245: 2, 248: 6, 250: 6, 258: 10, 262: 6, 263: 7, 264: 2, 267: 3, 270: 5, 272: 5, 273: 2, 287: 5, 289: 5, 291: 7, 299: 6, 300: 5, 304: 5, 309: 3, 314: 4, 315: 5, 320: 3, 323: 2, 327: 6, 328: 3, 329: 4, 330: 9, 334: 4, 335: 5, 341: 6, 342: 7, 347: 6, 348: 6, 350: 4, 351: 7, 352: 5, 353: 5, 354: 4, 358: 3, 365: 5, 366: 4, 369: 3, 371: 8, 372: 7, 376: 4, 384: 7, 385: 6, 386: 5, 387: 5, 392: 3, 393: 4, 396: 7, 397: 6, 398: 5, 402: 5} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 31 "Data-flows requiring DetNet service are generated and terminated on end-systems. Encapsulation depends on application and its preferences. For example, a DetNet MPLS domain the DN functions use the d-CWs, S-Labels and F-Labels to provide DetNet services. However, an application may exchange further flow related parameters (e.g., time-stamp), which are not provided by DN functions." "Hi Did a pass through the Framework . Clean up some text . There are still some identified areas in the document where it calls for more detail . Also there is a open reference . reviewed in jun 24 call" 51ad457a7ec49f981e3aac0813060e3636219f53 51ad457a7ec49f981e3aac0813060e3636219f53 draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework 3d286d6a8fe603e20f43496c1426df42910a9edc03c9fb38c8c3259467ebdc44 ['792b6cb16ba1a98b61881cf7634e377446c537dede9fcdd334103fb79c2e7dce', '3d286d6a8fe603e20f43496c1426df42910a9edc03c9fb38c8c3259467ebdc44'] A "data-flows requiring detnet service are generated and terminated on end-systems. encapsulation depends on application and its preferences. for example, a detnet mpls domain the dn functions use the d-cws, s-labels and f-labels to provide detnet services. however, an application may exchange further flow related parameters (e.g., time-stamp), which are not provided by dn functions." {55: 1, 6: 2, 79: 5, 90: 2, 51: 6, 130: 5, 62: 5, 85: 5, 68: 4, 35: 6, 110: 6, 91: 8, 114: 6, 97: 6, 31: 3, 13: 6, 67: 4, 38: 7, 26: 5, 124: 4, 98: 5, 54: 5, 127: 6, 8: 2, 96: 6, 64: 5, 30: 7, 61: 8, 27: 3, 15: 6, 52: 3, 129: 6, 115: 6, 84: 3, 76: 5, 87: 6, 131: 8, 102: 4, 113: 8, 99: 5, 36: 6, 24: 5, 53: 4, 72: 7} {145: 1, 1: 9, 4: 5, 9: 2, 10: 6, 15: 6, 24: 5, 25: 5, 26: 5, 27: 6, 39: 5, 43: 6, 49: 9, 50: 8, 58: 8, 59: 5, 64: 6, 69: 3, 81: 6, 82: 6, 86: 6, 96: 7, 97: 6, 100: 9, 108: 6, 109: 7, 110: 7, 111: 5, 114: 6, 115: 7, 116: 6, 118: 6, 119: 5, 120: 6, 121: 4, 122: 7, 123: 6, 124: 4, 128: 7, 129: 7, 130: 8, 132: 2, 136: 5, 147: 7, 151: 7, 152: 7, 154: 6, 156: 5, 161: 2, 162: 3, 165: 6, 168: 7, 169: 6, 172: 6, 180: 7, 187: 8, 188: 7, 191: 6, 194: 3, 202: 4, 203: 5, 206: 5, 207: 6, 215: 3, 217: 6, 218: 8, 220: 4, 221: 4, 222: 5, 224: 6, 227: 7, 229: 6, 234: 8, 235: 5, 241: 5, 242: 5, 243: 3, 244: 7, 245: 3, 248: 7, 250: 7, 258: 11, 262: 7, 263: 8, 264: 3, 267: 4, 270: 6, 272: 6, 273: 4, 287: 6, 289: 6, 291: 8, 299: 7, 300: 6, 304: 6, 309: 4, 314: 5, 315: 6, 320: 4, 323: 3, 327: 7, 328: 4, 329: 5, 330: 10, 334: 5, 335: 6, 341: 7, 342: 8, 347: 7, 348: 7, 350: 6, 351: 8, 352: 6, 353: 6, 354: 5, 358: 4, 365: 6, 366: 5, 369: 4, 371: 9, 372: 8, 376: 5, 384: 8, 385: 7, 386: 6, 387: 6, 392: 4, 393: 5, 396: 8, 397: 7, 398: 6, 402: 6} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 31 "Data-flows requiring DetNet service are generated and terminated on end-systems. Encapsulation depends on the application and its preferences. For example, a DetNet MPLS domain the DN functions use the d-CWs, S-Labels and F-Labels to provide DetNet services. However, an application may exchange further flow related parameters (e.g., time-stamp), which are not provided by DN functions." "Hi Did a pass through the Framework . Clean up some text . There are still some identified areas in the document where it calls for more detail . Also there is a open reference . reviewed in jun 24 call" 51ad457a7ec49f981e3aac0813060e3636219f53 51ad457a7ec49f981e3aac0813060e3636219f53 draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework 792b6cb16ba1a98b61881cf7634e377446c537dede9fcdd334103fb79c2e7dce ['792b6cb16ba1a98b61881cf7634e377446c537dede9fcdd334103fb79c2e7dce', '3d286d6a8fe603e20f43496c1426df42910a9edc03c9fb38c8c3259467ebdc44'] B "data-flows requiring detnet service are generated and terminated on end-systems. encapsulation depends on the application and its preferences. for example, a detnet mpls domain the dn functions use the d-cws, s-labels and f-labels to provide detnet services. however, an application may exchange further flow related parameters (e.g., time-stamp), which are not provided by dn functions." {55: 1, 6: 2, 79: 5, 90: 2, 51: 6, 130: 5, 62: 5, 85: 5, 68: 4, 35: 6, 110: 6, 91: 8, 114: 6, 97: 6, 31: 3, 13: 6, 67: 4, 38: 7, 26: 5, 124: 4, 98: 5, 54: 5, 127: 6, 8: 2, 96: 6, 64: 5, 30: 7, 61: 8, 27: 3, 15: 6, 52: 3, 129: 6, 115: 6, 84: 3, 76: 5, 87: 6, 131: 8, 102: 4, 113: 8, 99: 5, 36: 6, 24: 5, 53: 4, 72: 7} {145: 1, 1: 9, 4: 5, 9: 2, 10: 6, 15: 6, 24: 5, 25: 5, 26: 5, 27: 6, 39: 5, 43: 6, 49: 9, 50: 8, 58: 8, 59: 5, 64: 6, 69: 3, 81: 6, 82: 6, 86: 6, 96: 7, 97: 6, 100: 9, 108: 6, 109: 7, 110: 7, 111: 5, 114: 6, 115: 7, 116: 6, 118: 6, 119: 5, 120: 6, 121: 4, 122: 7, 123: 6, 124: 4, 128: 7, 129: 7, 130: 8, 132: 2, 136: 5, 147: 7, 151: 7, 152: 7, 154: 6, 156: 5, 161: 2, 162: 3, 165: 6, 168: 7, 169: 6, 172: 6, 180: 7, 187: 8, 188: 7, 191: 6, 194: 3, 202: 4, 203: 5, 206: 5, 207: 6, 215: 3, 217: 6, 218: 8, 220: 4, 221: 4, 222: 5, 224: 6, 227: 7, 229: 6, 234: 8, 235: 5, 241: 5, 242: 5, 243: 3, 244: 7, 245: 3, 248: 7, 250: 7, 258: 11, 262: 7, 263: 8, 264: 3, 267: 4, 270: 6, 272: 6, 273: 4, 287: 6, 289: 6, 291: 8, 299: 7, 300: 6, 304: 6, 309: 4, 314: 5, 315: 6, 320: 4, 323: 3, 327: 7, 328: 4, 329: 5, 330: 10, 334: 5, 335: 6, 341: 7, 342: 8, 347: 7, 348: 7, 350: 6, 351: 8, 352: 6, 353: 6, 354: 5, 358: 4, 365: 6, 366: 5, 369: 4, 371: 9, 372: 8, 376: 5, 384: 8, 385: 7, 386: 6, 387: 6, 392: 4, 393: 5, 396: 8, 397: 7, 398: 6, 402: 6} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 31 "described in I-D.mpls-over-tsn. UDP/IP represents the encapsulation used on a DetNet IP PSN, as described in I-D.mpls-over-udp-ip." "Hi Did a pass through the Framework . Clean up some text . There are still some identified areas in the document where it calls for more detail . Also there is a open reference . reviewed in jun 24 call" 51ad457a7ec49f981e3aac0813060e3636219f53 51ad457a7ec49f981e3aac0813060e3636219f53 draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework a1c3b6ed7da92ed7da0049d463adeecc8912e7d3d024a8b4166d8c9296326688 ['c455b489a240aceec39933a3f0a849e1edb59ec6e941ef6e5ae29eb9b5e5a2ea', 'a1c3b6ed7da92ed7da0049d463adeecc8912e7d3d024a8b4166d8c9296326688'] A "described in i-d.mpls-over-tsn. udp/ip represents the encapsulation used on a detnet ip psn, as described in i-d.mpls-over-udp-ip." {} {} {} 31 "described in I-D.ietf-detnet-mpls-over-tsn. UDP/IP represents the encapsulation used on a DetNet IP PSN, as described in I-D.ietf- detnet-mpls-over-udp-ip." "Hi Did a pass through the Framework . Clean up some text . There are still some identified areas in the document where it calls for more detail . Also there is a open reference . reviewed in jun 24 call" 51ad457a7ec49f981e3aac0813060e3636219f53 51ad457a7ec49f981e3aac0813060e3636219f53 draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework c455b489a240aceec39933a3f0a849e1edb59ec6e941ef6e5ae29eb9b5e5a2ea ['c455b489a240aceec39933a3f0a849e1edb59ec6e941ef6e5ae29eb9b5e5a2ea', 'a1c3b6ed7da92ed7da0049d463adeecc8912e7d3d024a8b4166d8c9296326688'] B "described in i-d.ietf-detnet-mpls-over-tsn. udp/ip represents the encapsulation used on a detnet ip psn, as described in i-d.ietf- detnet-mpls-over-udp-ip." {} {} {} 31 "In the case of MPLS Manage DetNet S-Label and F-Label allocation and distribution, where the DetNet MPLS encapsulation is in use see mpls_cp_considerations." "Hi Did a pass through the Framework . Clean up some text . There are still some identified areas in the document where it calls for more detail . Also there is a open reference . reviewed in jun 24 call" 51ad457a7ec49f981e3aac0813060e3636219f53 51ad457a7ec49f981e3aac0813060e3636219f53 draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework 35a05496fb2ca4f3140d51e84bfcf5e48622258574814599c5dc87ad85f0cc1f ['924c994c341583043e2888bb077b82b40079299a4ef4b1310ad60b4d4eecbf27', '3f57a612c795a3b3cb773330b10ffed1e9c3d85ee15ee559013dfc7d19565c4d', '5ddad1f32bf8b0d56c9a65fdd9727cf7dce98a76f125ef116d277bfb33169112', '35a05496fb2ca4f3140d51e84bfcf5e48622258574814599c5dc87ad85f0cc1f'] A "in the case of mpls manage detnet s-label and f-label allocation and distribution, where the detnet mpls encapsulation is in use see mpls_cp_considerations." {6: 1, 79: 3, 90: 4, 51: 4, 130: 3, 62: 6, 85: 6, 68: 5, 35: 4, 110: 4, 91: 6, 114: 4, 97: 4, 31: 4, 13: 4, 67: 4, 38: 5, 26: 4, 124: 4, 98: 3, 54: 3, 127: 4, 8: 2, 96: 4, 64: 3, 30: 5, 61: 6, 55: 4, 27: 5, 15: 4, 52: 3, 129: 4, 115: 4, 84: 4, 76: 7, 87: 4, 131: 6, 102: 4, 113: 6, 99: 3, 36: 4, 24: 3, 53: 2, 72: 5} {376: 1, 1: 10, 4: 3, 9: 6, 10: 4, 15: 4, 24: 3, 25: 6, 26: 6, 27: 4, 39: 6, 43: 4, 49: 7, 50: 6, 58: 6, 59: 3, 64: 4, 69: 5, 81: 7, 82: 5, 86: 4, 96: 5, 97: 4, 100: 8, 108: 4, 109: 5, 110: 5, 111: 3, 114: 4, 115: 5, 116: 4, 118: 7, 119: 6, 120: 2, 121: 5, 122: 5, 123: 4, 124: 5, 128: 5, 129: 5, 130: 6, 132: 5, 136: 3, 145: 5, 147: 5, 151: 5, 152: 5, 154: 2, 156: 3, 161: 4, 162: 4, 165: 4, 168: 5, 169: 4, 172: 4, 180: 5, 184: 6, 187: 6, 188: 5, 191: 4, 194: 5, 202: 6, 203: 7, 206: 3, 207: 4, 215: 3, 217: 4, 218: 9, 220: 3, 221: 3, 222: 6, 227: 6, 229: 4, 234: 6, 235: 3, 241: 3, 242: 3, 243: 5, 244: 5, 245: 5, 248: 5, 250: 5, 258: 12, 262: 5, 263: 6, 264: 4, 267: 5, 270: 4, 272: 4, 273: 6, 287: 4, 289: 4, 291: 6, 299: 6, 300: 4, 304: 4, 309: 4, 314: 3, 315: 4, 320: 5, 323: 5, 327: 5, 328: 4, 329: 3, 330: 11, 334: 3, 335: 4, 341: 6, 342: 7, 347: 6, 348: 6, 350: 8, 351: 6, 352: 4, 353: 4, 354: 3, 358: 5, 365: 4, 366: 3, 369: 2, 371: 8, 372: 6, 384: 6, 385: 5, 386: 4, 387: 4, 392: 4, 393: 5, 396: 7, 397: 8, 398: 7, 402: 4} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 31 The ability to support DetNet flow aggregation. "Hi Did a pass through the Framework . Clean up some text . There are still some identified areas in the document where it calls for more detail . Also there is a open reference . reviewed in jun 24 call" 51ad457a7ec49f981e3aac0813060e3636219f53 51ad457a7ec49f981e3aac0813060e3636219f53 draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework 5ddad1f32bf8b0d56c9a65fdd9727cf7dce98a76f125ef116d277bfb33169112 ['924c994c341583043e2888bb077b82b40079299a4ef4b1310ad60b4d4eecbf27', '3f57a612c795a3b3cb773330b10ffed1e9c3d85ee15ee559013dfc7d19565c4d', '5ddad1f32bf8b0d56c9a65fdd9727cf7dce98a76f125ef116d277bfb33169112', '35a05496fb2ca4f3140d51e84bfcf5e48622258574814599c5dc87ad85f0cc1f'] A the ability to support detnet flow aggregation. {6: 1, 79: 3, 90: 4, 51: 4, 130: 3, 62: 6, 85: 6, 68: 5, 35: 4, 110: 4, 91: 6, 114: 4, 97: 4, 31: 4, 13: 4, 67: 4, 38: 5, 26: 4, 124: 4, 98: 3, 54: 3, 127: 4, 8: 2, 96: 4, 64: 3, 30: 5, 61: 6, 55: 4, 27: 5, 15: 4, 52: 3, 129: 4, 115: 4, 84: 4, 76: 7, 87: 4, 131: 6, 102: 4, 113: 6, 99: 3, 36: 4, 24: 3, 53: 2, 72: 5} {376: 1, 1: 10, 4: 3, 9: 6, 10: 4, 15: 4, 24: 3, 25: 6, 26: 6, 27: 4, 39: 6, 43: 4, 49: 7, 50: 6, 58: 6, 59: 3, 64: 4, 69: 5, 81: 7, 82: 5, 86: 4, 96: 5, 97: 4, 100: 8, 108: 4, 109: 5, 110: 5, 111: 3, 114: 4, 115: 5, 116: 4, 118: 7, 119: 6, 120: 2, 121: 5, 122: 5, 123: 4, 124: 5, 128: 5, 129: 5, 130: 6, 132: 5, 136: 3, 145: 5, 147: 5, 151: 5, 152: 5, 154: 2, 156: 3, 161: 4, 162: 4, 165: 4, 168: 5, 169: 4, 172: 4, 180: 5, 184: 6, 187: 6, 188: 5, 191: 4, 194: 5, 202: 6, 203: 7, 206: 3, 207: 4, 215: 3, 217: 4, 218: 9, 220: 3, 221: 3, 222: 6, 227: 6, 229: 4, 234: 6, 235: 3, 241: 3, 242: 3, 243: 5, 244: 5, 245: 5, 248: 5, 250: 5, 258: 12, 262: 5, 263: 6, 264: 4, 267: 5, 270: 4, 272: 4, 273: 6, 287: 4, 289: 4, 291: 6, 299: 6, 300: 4, 304: 4, 309: 4, 314: 3, 315: 4, 320: 5, 323: 5, 327: 5, 328: 4, 329: 3, 330: 11, 334: 3, 335: 4, 341: 6, 342: 7, 347: 6, 348: 6, 350: 8, 351: 6, 352: 4, 353: 4, 354: 3, 358: 5, 365: 4, 366: 3, 369: 2, 371: 8, 372: 6, 384: 6, 385: 5, 386: 4, 387: 4, 392: 4, 393: 5, 396: 7, 397: 8, 398: 7, 402: 4} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 31 "In the case of MPLS, manage DetNet S-Label and F-Label allocation and distribution, where the DetNet MPLS encapsulation is in use see mpls_cp_considerations." "Hi Did a pass through the Framework . Clean up some text . There are still some identified areas in the document where it calls for more detail . Also there is a open reference . reviewed in jun 24 call" 51ad457a7ec49f981e3aac0813060e3636219f53 51ad457a7ec49f981e3aac0813060e3636219f53 draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework 3f57a612c795a3b3cb773330b10ffed1e9c3d85ee15ee559013dfc7d19565c4d ['924c994c341583043e2888bb077b82b40079299a4ef4b1310ad60b4d4eecbf27', '3f57a612c795a3b3cb773330b10ffed1e9c3d85ee15ee559013dfc7d19565c4d', '5ddad1f32bf8b0d56c9a65fdd9727cf7dce98a76f125ef116d277bfb33169112', '35a05496fb2ca4f3140d51e84bfcf5e48622258574814599c5dc87ad85f0cc1f'] B "in the case of mpls, manage detnet s-label and f-label allocation and distribution, where the detnet mpls encapsulation is in use see mpls_cp_considerations." {6: 1, 79: 3, 90: 4, 51: 4, 130: 3, 62: 6, 85: 6, 68: 5, 35: 4, 110: 4, 91: 6, 114: 4, 97: 4, 31: 4, 13: 4, 67: 4, 38: 5, 26: 4, 124: 4, 98: 3, 54: 3, 127: 4, 8: 2, 96: 4, 64: 3, 30: 5, 61: 6, 55: 4, 27: 5, 15: 4, 52: 3, 129: 4, 115: 4, 84: 4, 76: 7, 87: 4, 131: 6, 102: 4, 113: 6, 99: 3, 36: 4, 24: 3, 53: 2, 72: 5} {376: 1, 1: 10, 4: 3, 9: 6, 10: 4, 15: 4, 24: 3, 25: 6, 26: 6, 27: 4, 39: 6, 43: 4, 49: 7, 50: 6, 58: 6, 59: 3, 64: 4, 69: 5, 81: 7, 82: 5, 86: 4, 96: 5, 97: 4, 100: 8, 108: 4, 109: 5, 110: 5, 111: 3, 114: 4, 115: 5, 116: 4, 118: 7, 119: 6, 120: 2, 121: 5, 122: 5, 123: 4, 124: 5, 128: 5, 129: 5, 130: 6, 132: 5, 136: 3, 145: 5, 147: 5, 151: 5, 152: 5, 154: 2, 156: 3, 161: 4, 162: 4, 165: 4, 168: 5, 169: 4, 172: 4, 180: 5, 184: 6, 187: 6, 188: 5, 191: 4, 194: 5, 202: 6, 203: 7, 206: 3, 207: 4, 215: 3, 217: 4, 218: 9, 220: 3, 221: 3, 222: 6, 227: 6, 229: 4, 234: 6, 235: 3, 241: 3, 242: 3, 243: 5, 244: 5, 245: 5, 248: 5, 250: 5, 258: 12, 262: 5, 263: 6, 264: 4, 267: 5, 270: 4, 272: 4, 273: 6, 287: 4, 289: 4, 291: 6, 299: 6, 300: 4, 304: 4, 309: 4, 314: 3, 315: 4, 320: 5, 323: 5, 327: 5, 328: 4, 329: 3, 330: 11, 334: 3, 335: 4, 341: 6, 342: 7, 347: 6, 348: 6, 350: 8, 351: 6, 352: 4, 353: 4, 354: 3, 358: 5, 365: 4, 366: 3, 369: 2, 371: 8, 372: 6, 384: 6, 385: 5, 386: 4, 387: 4, 392: 4, 393: 5, 396: 7, 397: 8, 398: 7, 402: 4} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 31 Support DetNet flow aggregation. "Hi Did a pass through the Framework . Clean up some text . There are still some identified areas in the document where it calls for more detail . Also there is a open reference . reviewed in jun 24 call" 51ad457a7ec49f981e3aac0813060e3636219f53 51ad457a7ec49f981e3aac0813060e3636219f53 draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework 924c994c341583043e2888bb077b82b40079299a4ef4b1310ad60b4d4eecbf27 ['924c994c341583043e2888bb077b82b40079299a4ef4b1310ad60b4d4eecbf27', '3f57a612c795a3b3cb773330b10ffed1e9c3d85ee15ee559013dfc7d19565c4d', '5ddad1f32bf8b0d56c9a65fdd9727cf7dce98a76f125ef116d277bfb33169112', '35a05496fb2ca4f3140d51e84bfcf5e48622258574814599c5dc87ad85f0cc1f'] B support detnet flow aggregation. {6: 1, 79: 3, 90: 4, 51: 4, 130: 3, 62: 6, 85: 6, 68: 5, 35: 4, 110: 4, 91: 6, 114: 4, 97: 4, 31: 4, 13: 4, 67: 4, 38: 5, 26: 4, 124: 4, 98: 3, 54: 3, 127: 4, 8: 2, 96: 4, 64: 3, 30: 5, 61: 6, 55: 4, 27: 5, 15: 4, 52: 3, 129: 4, 115: 4, 84: 4, 76: 7, 87: 4, 131: 6, 102: 4, 113: 6, 99: 3, 36: 4, 24: 3, 53: 2, 72: 5} {376: 1, 1: 10, 4: 3, 9: 6, 10: 4, 15: 4, 24: 3, 25: 6, 26: 6, 27: 4, 39: 6, 43: 4, 49: 7, 50: 6, 58: 6, 59: 3, 64: 4, 69: 5, 81: 7, 82: 5, 86: 4, 96: 5, 97: 4, 100: 8, 108: 4, 109: 5, 110: 5, 111: 3, 114: 4, 115: 5, 116: 4, 118: 7, 119: 6, 120: 2, 121: 5, 122: 5, 123: 4, 124: 5, 128: 5, 129: 5, 130: 6, 132: 5, 136: 3, 145: 5, 147: 5, 151: 5, 152: 5, 154: 2, 156: 3, 161: 4, 162: 4, 165: 4, 168: 5, 169: 4, 172: 4, 180: 5, 184: 6, 187: 6, 188: 5, 191: 4, 194: 5, 202: 6, 203: 7, 206: 3, 207: 4, 215: 3, 217: 4, 218: 9, 220: 3, 221: 3, 222: 6, 227: 6, 229: 4, 234: 6, 235: 3, 241: 3, 242: 3, 243: 5, 244: 5, 245: 5, 248: 5, 250: 5, 258: 12, 262: 5, 263: 6, 264: 4, 267: 5, 270: 4, 272: 4, 273: 6, 287: 4, 289: 4, 291: 6, 299: 6, 300: 4, 304: 4, 309: 4, 314: 3, 315: 4, 320: 5, 323: 5, 327: 5, 328: 4, 329: 3, 330: 11, 334: 3, 335: 4, 341: 6, 342: 7, 347: 6, 348: 6, 350: 8, 351: 6, 352: 4, 353: 4, 354: 3, 358: 5, 365: 4, 366: 3, 369: 2, 371: 8, 372: 6, 384: 6, 385: 5, 386: 4, 387: 4, 392: 4, 393: 5, 396: 7, 397: 8, 398: 7, 402: 4} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 31 "Flow aggregation includes aggregation accomplished through the use of hierarchical LSPs in MPLS and tunnels, in the case of IP, MPLS and TSN, both of which aggregate multiple DetNet flows into a single new DetNet flow. It can also be grouping of IP flows that share 5-tuple of 6-tuple attributes or flow identifiers at the DetNet sub-layer." "Hi Did a pass through the Framework . Clean up some text . There are still some identified areas in the document where it calls for more detail . Also there is a open reference . reviewed in jun 24 call" 51ad457a7ec49f981e3aac0813060e3636219f53 51ad457a7ec49f981e3aac0813060e3636219f53 draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework e1d570de810b6f9b530e5198daada3cd78c2c9bcfc29d279b25276abcd676983 ['4630e889091de9b6e791b67c0127efe0cd507226a0ec83caf00c35f5fddebcdb', 'e1d570de810b6f9b530e5198daada3cd78c2c9bcfc29d279b25276abcd676983'] A "flow aggregation includes aggregation accomplished through the use of hierarchical lsps in mpls and tunnels, in the case of ip, mpls and tsn, both of which aggregate multiple detnet flows into a single new detnet flow. it can also be grouping of ip flows that share 5-tuple of 6-tuple attributes or flow identifiers at the detnet sub-layer." {8: 1, 90: 5, 6: 2, 84: 4, 55: 4, 31: 4} {89: 1, 226: 3, 101: 5, 360: 2, 409: 4, 138: 3, 338: 4, 211: 4} {226, 101, 360, 409, 107, 138, 338, 211, 89} 31 "Flow aggregation includes aggregation accomplished through the use of hierarchical LSPs in MPLS and tunnels, in the case of IP, MPLS and TSN, both of which aggregate multiple DetNet flows into a single new DetNet flow. It can also be grouping of IP flows that share 5-tuple or 6-tuple attributes or flow identifiers at the DetNet sub-layer." "Hi Did a pass through the Framework . Clean up some text . There are still some identified areas in the document where it calls for more detail . Also there is a open reference . reviewed in jun 24 call" 51ad457a7ec49f981e3aac0813060e3636219f53 51ad457a7ec49f981e3aac0813060e3636219f53 draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework 4630e889091de9b6e791b67c0127efe0cd507226a0ec83caf00c35f5fddebcdb ['4630e889091de9b6e791b67c0127efe0cd507226a0ec83caf00c35f5fddebcdb', 'e1d570de810b6f9b530e5198daada3cd78c2c9bcfc29d279b25276abcd676983'] B "flow aggregation includes aggregation accomplished through the use of hierarchical lsps in mpls and tunnels, in the case of ip, mpls and tsn, both of which aggregate multiple detnet flows into a single new detnet flow. it can also be grouping of ip flows that share 5-tuple or 6-tuple attributes or flow identifiers at the detnet sub-layer." {8: 1, 90: 5, 6: 2, 84: 4, 55: 4, 31: 4} {89: 1, 226: 3, 101: 5, 360: 2, 409: 4, 138: 3, 338: 4, 211: 4} {226, 101, 360, 409, 107, 138, 338, 211, 89} 31 "Explicit routes are used to ensure that packets are routed through the resources that have been reserved for them, and hence provide the DetNet application with the required service. A requirement for the DetNet Controller Plane will be the ability to assign a particular identified DetNet IP flow to a path through the DetNet domain that has been assigned the required nodal resources. This provides the appropriate traffic treatment for the flow and also includes particular links as a part of the path that are able to support the DetNet flow. For example, by using IEEE 802.1 TSN links (as discussed in I-D.mpls-over-tsn ) DetNet parameters can be maintained. Further considerations and requirements for the DetNet Controller Plane are discussed in control-management-requirements." "Hi Did a pass through the Framework . Clean up some text . There are still some identified areas in the document where it calls for more detail . Also there is a open reference . reviewed in jun 24 call" 51ad457a7ec49f981e3aac0813060e3636219f53 51ad457a7ec49f981e3aac0813060e3636219f53 draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework 26b7bb9f86869cc432f24e56d9182cbac465940c3cc7173b7388e18ff8e98312 ['86b1f8609f0801a7f87967d7fc11492a8dfc742571effaabbdd314fed4b87785', '26b7bb9f86869cc432f24e56d9182cbac465940c3cc7173b7388e18ff8e98312'] A "explicit routes are used to ensure that packets are routed through the resources that have been reserved for them, and hence provide the detnet application with the required service. a requirement for the detnet controller plane will be the ability to assign a particular identified detnet ip flow to a path through the detnet domain that has been assigned the required nodal resources. this provides the appropriate traffic treatment for the flow and also includes particular links as a part of the path that are able to support the detnet flow. for example, by using ieee 802.1 tsn links (as discussed in i-d.mpls-over-tsn ) detnet parameters can be maintained. further considerations and requirements for the detnet controller plane are discussed in control-management-requirements." {90: 1, 8: 1, 6: 2, 84: 4, 31: 4, 55: 4} {101: 1, 138: 1, 226: 3, 360: 2, 409: 4, 107: 4, 338: 4, 89: 3} {226, 101, 360, 409, 107, 138, 338, 211, 89} 31 "Explicit routes are used to ensure that packets are routed through the resources that have been reserved for them, and hence provide the DetNet application with the required service. A requirement for the DetNet Controller Plane will be the ability to assign a particular identified DetNet IP flow to a path through the DetNet domain that has been assigned the required nodal resources. This provides the appropriate traffic treatment for the flow and also includes particular links as a part of the path that are able to support the DetNet flow. For example, by using IEEE 802.1 TSN links (as discussed in I-D.ietf-detnet-mpls-over-tsn ) DetNet parameters can be maintained. Further considerations and requirements for the DetNet Controller Plane are discussed in control-management-requirements." "Hi Did a pass through the Framework . Clean up some text . There are still some identified areas in the document where it calls for more detail . Also there is a open reference . reviewed in jun 24 call" 51ad457a7ec49f981e3aac0813060e3636219f53 51ad457a7ec49f981e3aac0813060e3636219f53 draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework 86b1f8609f0801a7f87967d7fc11492a8dfc742571effaabbdd314fed4b87785 ['86b1f8609f0801a7f87967d7fc11492a8dfc742571effaabbdd314fed4b87785', '26b7bb9f86869cc432f24e56d9182cbac465940c3cc7173b7388e18ff8e98312'] B "explicit routes are used to ensure that packets are routed through the resources that have been reserved for them, and hence provide the detnet application with the required service. a requirement for the detnet controller plane will be the ability to assign a particular identified detnet ip flow to a path through the detnet domain that has been assigned the required nodal resources. this provides the appropriate traffic treatment for the flow and also includes particular links as a part of the path that are able to support the detnet flow. for example, by using ieee 802.1 tsn links (as discussed in i-d.ietf-detnet-mpls-over-tsn ) detnet parameters can be maintained. further considerations and requirements for the detnet controller plane are discussed in control-management-requirements." {90: 1, 8: 1, 6: 2, 84: 4, 31: 4, 55: 4} {101: 1, 138: 1, 226: 3, 360: 2, 409: 4, 107: 4, 338: 4, 89: 3} {226, 101, 360, 409, 107, 138, 338, 211, 89} 31 "Control and management mechanisms need to support bidirectional flows, but the specification of such mechanisms are out of scope of this document. An example control plane solution for MPLS can be found in . Related control plan mechanisms have been defined in RFC3473 , RFC6387 and RFC7551." "Hi Did a pass through the Framework . Clean up some text . There are still some identified areas in the document where it calls for more detail . Also there is a open reference . reviewed in jun 24 call" 51ad457a7ec49f981e3aac0813060e3636219f53 51ad457a7ec49f981e3aac0813060e3636219f53 draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework 111151f984afd417c07e79a2c402dbba1832e057180c016ee22ca424c456da84 ['58b38f9b39f1690b4719ff18b1d0962beef5c529b5c4b495036ea7328be3b453', '111151f984afd417c07e79a2c402dbba1832e057180c016ee22ca424c456da84'] A "control and management mechanisms need to support bidirectional flows, but the specification of such mechanisms are out of scope of this document. an example control plane solution for mpls can be found in . related control plan mechanisms have been defined in rfc3473 , rfc6387 and rfc7551." {6: 1, 31: 3, 35: 4, 8: 2} {54: 1, 362: 5, 48: 4, 177: 6, 340: 3, 55: 2, 251: 5} {362, 48, 144, 177, 340, 54, 55, 251} 31 "Control and management mechanisms need to support bidirectional flows, but the specification of such mechanisms are out of scope of this document. An example control plane solution for MPLS can be found in ???. Related control plan mechanisms have been defined in RFC3473 , RFC6387 and RFC7551." "Hi Did a pass through the Framework . Clean up some text . There are still some identified areas in the document where it calls for more detail . Also there is a open reference . reviewed in jun 24 call" 51ad457a7ec49f981e3aac0813060e3636219f53 51ad457a7ec49f981e3aac0813060e3636219f53 draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework 58b38f9b39f1690b4719ff18b1d0962beef5c529b5c4b495036ea7328be3b453 ['58b38f9b39f1690b4719ff18b1d0962beef5c529b5c4b495036ea7328be3b453', '111151f984afd417c07e79a2c402dbba1832e057180c016ee22ca424c456da84'] B "control and management mechanisms need to support bidirectional flows, but the specification of such mechanisms are out of scope of this document. an example control plane solution for mpls can be found in ???. related control plan mechanisms have been defined in rfc3473 , rfc6387 and rfc7551." {6: 1, 31: 3, 35: 4, 8: 2} {54: 1, 362: 5, 48: 4, 177: 6, 340: 3, 55: 2, 251: 5} {362, 48, 144, 177, 340, 54, 55, 251} 31 "sec_dt_dp discussed the use of the IP ""6-tuple"" for flow identification, and goes on to discuss how identified flows use specific QoS mechanisms for flow-specific traffic treatment, including path control and resource allocation. I-D.ietf-detnet-ip contains detailed DetNet IP flow identification procedures. Flow identification will play an important role for the DetNet controller plane." "Hi Did a pass through the Framework . Clean up some text . There are still some identified areas in the document where it calls for more detail . Also there is a open reference . reviewed in jun 24 call" 51ad457a7ec49f981e3aac0813060e3636219f53 51ad457a7ec49f981e3aac0813060e3636219f53 draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework 1b90f8a07b781e94d70bcf784f4b0e91b3c281655f8c893e6ace4d4877446ca5 ['d72d4ba50e7c17386f65556b7c81107a0503b156254c9f642cd768cef7daefd7', '568fd54d1e9042034b5f0dee50329ea115933adaf58a7b2c02fb6a625317f934', '995540460bd17d9ee18165857fbe75e51af3b32c4d1ec61ef155c63187a5525a', '1b90f8a07b781e94d70bcf784f4b0e91b3c281655f8c893e6ace4d4877446ca5', '507e0d518a66ed33aeadf48553eba471724848455642c095364b4b70f68ef0ce', '2446cb21b9c834ba9f3bccd4c55ee7d0ead47e11e955b82d3467e4c6087127f6'] A "sec_dt_dp discussed the use of the ip ""6-tuple"" for flow identification, and goes on to discuss how identified flows use specific qos mechanisms for flow-specific traffic treatment, including path control and resource allocation. i-d.ietf-detnet-ip contains detailed detnet ip flow identification procedures. flow identification will play an important role for the detnet controller plane." {35: 1, 8: 1, 31: 2, 6: 2} {48: 1, 55: 1, 362: 2, 144: 3, 177: 3, 54: 2, 251: 2} {362, 48, 144, 177, 340, 54, 55, 251} 31 "aggregation and ip-agg discuss the use of flow aggregation in DetNet. Flow aggregation can be accomplished using any of the 6-tuple fields defined in I-D.ietf-detnet-ip , using a DSCP identified traffic class or other field. It will be the responsibility of the DetNet controller plane to be able to properly provision the use of these aggregation mechanisms. These requirements are included in control- management-requirements." "Hi Did a pass through the Framework . Clean up some text . There are still some identified areas in the document where it calls for more detail . Also there is a open reference . reviewed in jun 24 call" 51ad457a7ec49f981e3aac0813060e3636219f53 51ad457a7ec49f981e3aac0813060e3636219f53 draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework 507e0d518a66ed33aeadf48553eba471724848455642c095364b4b70f68ef0ce ['d72d4ba50e7c17386f65556b7c81107a0503b156254c9f642cd768cef7daefd7', '568fd54d1e9042034b5f0dee50329ea115933adaf58a7b2c02fb6a625317f934', '995540460bd17d9ee18165857fbe75e51af3b32c4d1ec61ef155c63187a5525a', '1b90f8a07b781e94d70bcf784f4b0e91b3c281655f8c893e6ace4d4877446ca5', '507e0d518a66ed33aeadf48553eba471724848455642c095364b4b70f68ef0ce', '2446cb21b9c834ba9f3bccd4c55ee7d0ead47e11e955b82d3467e4c6087127f6'] A "aggregation and ip-agg discuss the use of flow aggregation in detnet. flow aggregation can be accomplished using any of the 6-tuple fields defined in i-d.ietf-detnet-ip , using a dscp identified traffic class or other field. it will be the responsibility of the detnet controller plane to be able to properly provision the use of these aggregation mechanisms. these requirements are included in control- management-requirements." {35: 1, 8: 1, 31: 2, 6: 2} {48: 1, 55: 1, 362: 2, 144: 3, 177: 3, 54: 2, 251: 2} {362, 48, 144, 177, 340, 54, 55, 251} 31 "This section covers MPLS data plane specific control plane considerations. This section needs generalizing." "Hi Did a pass through the Framework . Clean up some text . There are still some identified areas in the document where it calls for more detail . Also there is a open reference . reviewed in jun 24 call" 51ad457a7ec49f981e3aac0813060e3636219f53 51ad457a7ec49f981e3aac0813060e3636219f53 draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework d72d4ba50e7c17386f65556b7c81107a0503b156254c9f642cd768cef7daefd7 ['d72d4ba50e7c17386f65556b7c81107a0503b156254c9f642cd768cef7daefd7', '568fd54d1e9042034b5f0dee50329ea115933adaf58a7b2c02fb6a625317f934', '995540460bd17d9ee18165857fbe75e51af3b32c4d1ec61ef155c63187a5525a', '1b90f8a07b781e94d70bcf784f4b0e91b3c281655f8c893e6ace4d4877446ca5', '507e0d518a66ed33aeadf48553eba471724848455642c095364b4b70f68ef0ce', '2446cb21b9c834ba9f3bccd4c55ee7d0ead47e11e955b82d3467e4c6087127f6'] A "this section covers mpls data plane specific control plane considerations. this section needs generalizing." {35: 1, 8: 1, 31: 2, 6: 2} {48: 1, 55: 1, 362: 2, 144: 3, 177: 3, 54: 2, 251: 2} {362, 48, 144, 177, 340, 54, 55, 251} 31 "sec_dt_dp discussed the use of the IP ""6-tuple"" for flow identification, and goes on to discuss how identified flows use specific QoS mechanisms for flow-specific traffic treatment, including path control and resource allocation. I-D.ietf-detnet-ip contains detailed DetNet IP flow identification procedures. Flow identification plays an important role for the DetNet controller plane." "Hi Did a pass through the Framework . Clean up some text . There are still some identified areas in the document where it calls for more detail . Also there is a open reference . reviewed in jun 24 call" 51ad457a7ec49f981e3aac0813060e3636219f53 51ad457a7ec49f981e3aac0813060e3636219f53 draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework 995540460bd17d9ee18165857fbe75e51af3b32c4d1ec61ef155c63187a5525a ['d72d4ba50e7c17386f65556b7c81107a0503b156254c9f642cd768cef7daefd7', '568fd54d1e9042034b5f0dee50329ea115933adaf58a7b2c02fb6a625317f934', '995540460bd17d9ee18165857fbe75e51af3b32c4d1ec61ef155c63187a5525a', '1b90f8a07b781e94d70bcf784f4b0e91b3c281655f8c893e6ace4d4877446ca5', '507e0d518a66ed33aeadf48553eba471724848455642c095364b4b70f68ef0ce', '2446cb21b9c834ba9f3bccd4c55ee7d0ead47e11e955b82d3467e4c6087127f6'] B "sec_dt_dp discussed the use of the ip ""6-tuple"" for flow identification, and goes on to discuss how identified flows use specific qos mechanisms for flow-specific traffic treatment, including path control and resource allocation. i-d.ietf-detnet-ip contains detailed detnet ip flow identification procedures. flow identification plays an important role for the detnet controller plane." {35: 1, 8: 1, 31: 2, 6: 2} {48: 1, 55: 1, 362: 2, 144: 3, 177: 3, 54: 2, 251: 2} {362, 48, 144, 177, 340, 54, 55, 251} 31 "aggregation and ip-agg discuss the use of flow aggregation in DetNet. Flow aggregation can be accomplished using any of the 6-tuple fields defined in I-D.ietf-detnet-ip , using a DSCP identified traffic class or other field. It is the responsibility of the DetNet controller plane to be able to properly provision the use of these aggregation mechanisms. These requirements are included in control-management- requirements." "Hi Did a pass through the Framework . Clean up some text . There are still some identified areas in the document where it calls for more detail . Also there is a open reference . reviewed in jun 24 call" 51ad457a7ec49f981e3aac0813060e3636219f53 51ad457a7ec49f981e3aac0813060e3636219f53 draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework 568fd54d1e9042034b5f0dee50329ea115933adaf58a7b2c02fb6a625317f934 ['d72d4ba50e7c17386f65556b7c81107a0503b156254c9f642cd768cef7daefd7', '568fd54d1e9042034b5f0dee50329ea115933adaf58a7b2c02fb6a625317f934', '995540460bd17d9ee18165857fbe75e51af3b32c4d1ec61ef155c63187a5525a', '1b90f8a07b781e94d70bcf784f4b0e91b3c281655f8c893e6ace4d4877446ca5', '507e0d518a66ed33aeadf48553eba471724848455642c095364b4b70f68ef0ce', '2446cb21b9c834ba9f3bccd4c55ee7d0ead47e11e955b82d3467e4c6087127f6'] B "aggregation and ip-agg discuss the use of flow aggregation in detnet. flow aggregation can be accomplished using any of the 6-tuple fields defined in i-d.ietf-detnet-ip , using a dscp identified traffic class or other field. it is the responsibility of the detnet controller plane to be able to properly provision the use of these aggregation mechanisms. these requirements are included in control-management- requirements." {35: 1, 8: 1, 31: 2, 6: 2} {48: 1, 55: 1, 362: 2, 144: 3, 177: 3, 54: 2, 251: 2} {362, 48, 144, 177, 340, 54, 55, 251} 31 "This section covers MPLS data plane specific control plane considerations." "Hi Did a pass through the Framework . Clean up some text . There are still some identified areas in the document where it calls for more detail . Also there is a open reference . reviewed in jun 24 call" 51ad457a7ec49f981e3aac0813060e3636219f53 51ad457a7ec49f981e3aac0813060e3636219f53 draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework 2446cb21b9c834ba9f3bccd4c55ee7d0ead47e11e955b82d3467e4c6087127f6 ['d72d4ba50e7c17386f65556b7c81107a0503b156254c9f642cd768cef7daefd7', '568fd54d1e9042034b5f0dee50329ea115933adaf58a7b2c02fb6a625317f934', '995540460bd17d9ee18165857fbe75e51af3b32c4d1ec61ef155c63187a5525a', '1b90f8a07b781e94d70bcf784f4b0e91b3c281655f8c893e6ace4d4877446ca5', '507e0d518a66ed33aeadf48553eba471724848455642c095364b4b70f68ef0ce', '2446cb21b9c834ba9f3bccd4c55ee7d0ead47e11e955b82d3467e4c6087127f6'] B "this section covers mpls data plane specific control plane considerations." {35: 1, 8: 1, 31: 2, 6: 2} {48: 1, 55: 1, 362: 2, 144: 3, 177: 3, 54: 2, 251: 2} {362, 48, 144, 177, 340, 54, 55, 251} 31 "S-Labels are expected to be allocated in the same manner as any other service labels. S-Labels uniquely identify a particular DetNet flow, and are local to the node on which the label is allocated. In the DetNet service sub-layer the explicit route consists of the set of Relay Nodes that the DetNet flow must traverse. They can be used to identify the DetNet flow that a packet belongs to as it traverses a particular node in a DetNet domain. Because labels are local to each node rather than being a global identifier within a domain, they must be advertised to their upstream DetNet service-aware peer nodes (e.g., a DetNet MPLS End System or a DetNet Relay or Edge Node and interpreted in the context of their received F-Label." "Hi Did a pass through the Framework . Clean up some text . There are still some identified areas in the document where it calls for more detail . Also there is a open reference . reviewed in jun 24 call" 51ad457a7ec49f981e3aac0813060e3636219f53 51ad457a7ec49f981e3aac0813060e3636219f53 draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework ed20302d1ba5a30881fde0793bde802701d9d6e6dc8e941649e8aab7292106d5 ['e2153b2e4b820623b01650845088c69eff7527fe2fc9d80ea69dd7a3f222b46b', 'ed20302d1ba5a30881fde0793bde802701d9d6e6dc8e941649e8aab7292106d5'] A "s-labels are expected to be allocated in the same manner as any other service labels. s-labels uniquely identify a particular detnet flow, and are local to the node on which the label is allocated. in the detnet service sub-layer the explicit route consists of the set of relay nodes that the detnet flow must traverse. they can be used to identify the detnet flow that a packet belongs to as it traverses a particular node in a detnet domain. because labels are local to each node rather than being a global identifier within a domain, they must be advertised to their upstream detnet service-aware peer nodes (e.g., a detnet mpls end system or a detnet relay or edge node and interpreted in the context of their received f-label." {35: 1, 8: 1, 31: 2, 6: 4} {48: 1, 177: 1, 144: 5, 340: 2, 54: 4, 55: 3, 251: 2} {362, 48, 144, 177, 340, 54, 55, 251} 31 "S-Labels are expected to be allocated in the same manner as any other service labels. S-Labels uniquely identify a particular DetNet flow, and are local to the node on which the label is allocated. In the DetNet service sub-layer the explicit route consists of the set of Relay Nodes that the DetNet flow must traverse. S-Labels can be used to identify the DetNet flow that a packet belongs to as it traverses a particular node in a DetNet domain. Because S-Labels are local to each node rather than being a global identifier within a domain, they must be advertised to their upstream DetNet service-aware peer nodes (e.g., a DetNet MPLS End System or a DetNet Relay or Edge Node and interpreted in the context of their received F-Label." "Hi Did a pass through the Framework . Clean up some text . There are still some identified areas in the document where it calls for more detail . Also there is a open reference . reviewed in jun 24 call" 51ad457a7ec49f981e3aac0813060e3636219f53 51ad457a7ec49f981e3aac0813060e3636219f53 draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework e2153b2e4b820623b01650845088c69eff7527fe2fc9d80ea69dd7a3f222b46b ['e2153b2e4b820623b01650845088c69eff7527fe2fc9d80ea69dd7a3f222b46b', 'ed20302d1ba5a30881fde0793bde802701d9d6e6dc8e941649e8aab7292106d5'] B "s-labels are expected to be allocated in the same manner as any other service labels. s-labels uniquely identify a particular detnet flow, and are local to the node on which the label is allocated. in the detnet service sub-layer the explicit route consists of the set of relay nodes that the detnet flow must traverse. s-labels can be used to identify the detnet flow that a packet belongs to as it traverses a particular node in a detnet domain. because s-labels are local to each node rather than being a global identifier within a domain, they must be advertised to their upstream detnet service-aware peer nodes (e.g., a detnet mpls end system or a detnet relay or edge node and interpreted in the context of their received f-label." {35: 1, 8: 1, 31: 2, 6: 4} {48: 1, 177: 1, 144: 5, 340: 2, 54: 4, 55: 3, 251: 2} {362, 48, 144, 177, 340, 54, 55, 251} 31 "As discussed in sec_dt_dp, the forwarding sub-layer uses one or more F-Labels to forward DetNet packets between DetNet service-aware nodes along explicitly defined routes at the DetNet forwarding sub-layer, which in the context of this document is MPLS. F-Labels can also provide context for an S-Label. In the DetNet Forwarding (MPLS) sub- layer the explicit route consists of the set of DetNet nodes which are LSRs, links, and possibly link bundle members and queues that the DetNet packets of a flow must traverse between nodes in the DetNet service sub-layer (i.e. between a specific Edge Node and the next hop Relay Node, between specific Relay Nodes, and between a specific Relay node and the egress Edge Node. Resource allocation corresponding to the set of Services supported over the forwarding sub-layer, which may or may not include aggregation, is required at this sub-layer. Explicit routes are used to ensure that packets are routed through the resources that have been reserved for them, and hence provide the DetNet application with the required service. Multiple F-Labels may be pushed after an S-Label and there is no requirement for all F-Labels to be controlled via the same controller mechanisms. For example in EVPN, some labels are distributed using BGP while others are distributed using LDP or RSVP." "Hi Did a pass through the Framework . Clean up some text . There are still some identified areas in the document where it calls for more detail . Also there is a open reference . reviewed in jun 24 call" 51ad457a7ec49f981e3aac0813060e3636219f53 51ad457a7ec49f981e3aac0813060e3636219f53 draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework a13bacead369ce97a675dfd9501934cd6bc2092302664485ef6052694a322fc0 ['a13bacead369ce97a675dfd9501934cd6bc2092302664485ef6052694a322fc0', 'af83d948c4a6447a1db32ef7f725432e0e303bbb59a5d0b09f4aa1826a8cdbcd'] A "as discussed in sec_dt_dp, the forwarding sub-layer uses one or more f-labels to forward detnet packets between detnet service-aware nodes along explicitly defined routes at the detnet forwarding sub-layer, which in the context of this document is mpls. f-labels can also provide context for an s-label. in the detnet forwarding (mpls) sub- layer the explicit route consists of the set of detnet nodes which are lsrs, links, and possibly link bundle members and queues that the detnet packets of a flow must traverse between nodes in the detnet service sub-layer (i.e. between a specific edge node and the next hop relay node, between specific relay nodes, and between a specific relay node and the egress edge node. resource allocation corresponding to the set of services supported over the forwarding sub-layer, which may or may not include aggregation, is required at this sub-layer. explicit routes are used to ensure that packets are routed through the resources that have been reserved for them, and hence provide the detnet application with the required service. multiple f-labels may be pushed after an s-label and there is no requirement for all f-labels to be controlled via the same controller mechanisms. for example in evpn, some labels are distributed using bgp while others are distributed using ldp or rsvp." {35: 1, 8: 1, 31: 2, 6: 4} {48: 1, 177: 1, 362: 2, 144: 5, 340: 2, 54: 4, 55: 3} {362, 48, 144, 177, 340, 54, 55, 251} 31 "As discussed in sec_dt_dp, the forwarding sub-layer uses one or more F-Labels to forward DetNet packets between DetNet service-aware nodes along explicitly defined routes at the DetNet forwarding sub-layer, which in the context of this document is MPLS. F-Labels can also provide context for an S-Label. In the DetNet Forwarding (MPLS) sub- layer the explicit route consists of the set of DetNet nodes which are LSRs, links, and possibly link bundle members and queues that the DetNet packets flow must traverse between nodes in the DetNet service sub-layer (i.e. between a specific Edge Node and the next hop Relay Node, between specific Relay Nodes, and between a specific Relay node and the egress Edge Node. Resource allocation corresponding to the set of Services supported over the forwarding sub-layer, which may or may not include aggregation, is required at this sub-layer. Explicit routes are used to ensure that packets are routed through the resources that have been reserved for them, and hence provide the DetNet application with the required service. Multiple F-Labels may be pushed after an S-Label and there is no requirement for all F-Labels to be controlled via the same controller mechanisms. For example in EVPN, some labels are distributed using BGP while others are distributed using LDP or RSVP." "Hi Did a pass through the Framework . Clean up some text . There are still some identified areas in the document where it calls for more detail . Also there is a open reference . reviewed in jun 24 call" 51ad457a7ec49f981e3aac0813060e3636219f53 51ad457a7ec49f981e3aac0813060e3636219f53 draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework af83d948c4a6447a1db32ef7f725432e0e303bbb59a5d0b09f4aa1826a8cdbcd ['a13bacead369ce97a675dfd9501934cd6bc2092302664485ef6052694a322fc0', 'af83d948c4a6447a1db32ef7f725432e0e303bbb59a5d0b09f4aa1826a8cdbcd'] B "as discussed in sec_dt_dp, the forwarding sub-layer uses one or more f-labels to forward detnet packets between detnet service-aware nodes along explicitly defined routes at the detnet forwarding sub-layer, which in the context of this document is mpls. f-labels can also provide context for an s-label. in the detnet forwarding (mpls) sub- layer the explicit route consists of the set of detnet nodes which are lsrs, links, and possibly link bundle members and queues that the detnet packets flow must traverse between nodes in the detnet service sub-layer (i.e. between a specific edge node and the next hop relay node, between specific relay nodes, and between a specific relay node and the egress edge node. resource allocation corresponding to the set of services supported over the forwarding sub-layer, which may or may not include aggregation, is required at this sub-layer. explicit routes are used to ensure that packets are routed through the resources that have been reserved for them, and hence provide the detnet application with the required service. multiple f-labels may be pushed after an s-label and there is no requirement for all f-labels to be controlled via the same controller mechanisms. for example in evpn, some labels are distributed using bgp while others are distributed using ldp or rsvp." {35: 1, 8: 1, 31: 2, 6: 4} {48: 1, 177: 1, 362: 2, 144: 5, 340: 2, 54: 4, 55: 3} {362, 48, 144, 177, 340, 54, 55, 251} 31 "The controller plane protocol solution required for managing the PREOF processing is outside the scope of this document. That said, it should be noted that the ability to determine, for a particular flow, optimal packet replication and elimination points in the DetNet domain requires explicit support. There are be capabilities that can be used, or extended, for example GMPLS end-to-end recovery RFC4872 and GMPLS segment recovery RFC4873." "Hi Did a pass through the Framework . Clean up some text . There are still some identified areas in the document where it calls for more detail . Also there is a open reference . reviewed in jun 24 call" 51ad457a7ec49f981e3aac0813060e3636219f53 51ad457a7ec49f981e3aac0813060e3636219f53 draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework a0c10c0e94899284de5ae6fd97478fe1ad539e66d3ce9b3afdff338a867b8ee2 ['a0c10c0e94899284de5ae6fd97478fe1ad539e66d3ce9b3afdff338a867b8ee2', '6f8a54e6f6734a36a420cf878551c05649012f1442f53a45ee63ba45cffb33f5'] A "the controller plane protocol solution required for managing the preof processing is outside the scope of this document. that said, it should be noted that the ability to determine, for a particular flow, optimal packet replication and elimination points in the detnet domain requires explicit support. there are be capabilities that can be used, or extended, for example gmpls end-to-end recovery rfc4872 and gmpls segment recovery rfc4873." {90: 1, 6: 4, 79: 4, 51: 3, 130: 4, 62: 6, 85: 7, 68: 6, 35: 5, 110: 3, 91: 4, 114: 3, 97: 4, 31: 5, 13: 2, 67: 3, 38: 4, 26: 3, 124: 5, 98: 4, 54: 4, 127: 5, 8: 4, 96: 4, 64: 3, 30: 3, 61: 5, 55: 5, 27: 4, 15: 3, 52: 3, 129: 5, 115: 2, 84: 2, 76: 8, 87: 3, 131: 7, 102: 2, 113: 5, 99: 4, 36: 2, 24: 2, 53: 3, 72: 4} {402: 1, 1: 11, 4: 4, 9: 7, 10: 5, 15: 4, 24: 4, 25: 6, 26: 7, 27: 3, 39: 7, 43: 5, 49: 5, 50: 4, 58: 5, 59: 4, 64: 4, 69: 6, 81: 7, 82: 5, 86: 3, 96: 4, 97: 3, 100: 8, 108: 5, 109: 6, 110: 6, 111: 4, 114: 5, 115: 6, 116: 4, 118: 8, 119: 7, 120: 5, 121: 6, 122: 5, 123: 4, 124: 6, 128: 3, 129: 3, 130: 5, 132: 6, 136: 4, 145: 6, 147: 4, 151: 3, 152: 3, 154: 5, 156: 3, 161: 5, 162: 5, 165: 5, 168: 6, 169: 2, 172: 3, 180: 3, 184: 7, 187: 7, 188: 6, 191: 5, 194: 6, 202: 7, 203: 8, 206: 4, 207: 5, 215: 4, 217: 5, 218: 10, 220: 4, 221: 4, 222: 7, 224: 5, 227: 6, 229: 3, 234: 7, 235: 4, 241: 4, 242: 4, 243: 6, 244: 2, 245: 6, 250: 5, 258: 13, 262: 6, 263: 7, 264: 5, 267: 6, 270: 4, 272: 2, 273: 7, 287: 5, 289: 3, 291: 5, 299: 6, 300: 4, 304: 4, 309: 5, 314: 4, 315: 2, 320: 6, 323: 6, 327: 6, 328: 5, 329: 4, 330: 12, 334: 4, 335: 4, 341: 6, 342: 7, 347: 6, 348: 6, 350: 9, 351: 3, 352: 3, 353: 2, 354: 2, 358: 6, 365: 3, 366: 4, 369: 3, 371: 8, 372: 5, 376: 4, 384: 5, 385: 4, 386: 5, 387: 4, 392: 5, 393: 6, 396: 7, 397: 9, 398: 8} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 31 "The controller plane protocol solution required for managing the PREOF processing is outside the scope of this document. That said, it should be noted that the ability to determine, for a particular flow, optimal packet replication and elimination points in the DetNet domain requires explicit support. There may be capabilities that can be used, or extended, for example GMPLS end-to-end recovery RFC4872 and GMPLS segment recovery RFC4873." "Hi Did a pass through the Framework . Clean up some text . There are still some identified areas in the document where it calls for more detail . Also there is a open reference . reviewed in jun 24 call" 51ad457a7ec49f981e3aac0813060e3636219f53 51ad457a7ec49f981e3aac0813060e3636219f53 draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework 6f8a54e6f6734a36a420cf878551c05649012f1442f53a45ee63ba45cffb33f5 ['a0c10c0e94899284de5ae6fd97478fe1ad539e66d3ce9b3afdff338a867b8ee2', '6f8a54e6f6734a36a420cf878551c05649012f1442f53a45ee63ba45cffb33f5'] B "the controller plane protocol solution required for managing the preof processing is outside the scope of this document. that said, it should be noted that the ability to determine, for a particular flow, optimal packet replication and elimination points in the detnet domain requires explicit support. there may be capabilities that can be used, or extended, for example gmpls end-to-end recovery rfc4872 and gmpls segment recovery rfc4873." {90: 1, 6: 4, 79: 4, 51: 3, 130: 4, 62: 6, 85: 7, 68: 6, 35: 5, 110: 3, 91: 4, 114: 3, 97: 4, 31: 5, 13: 2, 67: 3, 38: 4, 26: 3, 124: 5, 98: 4, 54: 4, 127: 5, 8: 4, 96: 4, 64: 3, 30: 3, 61: 5, 55: 5, 27: 4, 15: 3, 52: 3, 129: 5, 115: 2, 84: 2, 76: 8, 87: 3, 131: 7, 102: 2, 113: 5, 99: 4, 36: 2, 24: 2, 53: 3, 72: 4} {402: 1, 1: 11, 4: 4, 9: 7, 10: 5, 15: 4, 24: 4, 25: 6, 26: 7, 27: 3, 39: 7, 43: 5, 49: 5, 50: 4, 58: 5, 59: 4, 64: 4, 69: 6, 81: 7, 82: 5, 86: 3, 96: 4, 97: 3, 100: 8, 108: 5, 109: 6, 110: 6, 111: 4, 114: 5, 115: 6, 116: 4, 118: 8, 119: 7, 120: 5, 121: 6, 122: 5, 123: 4, 124: 6, 128: 3, 129: 3, 130: 5, 132: 6, 136: 4, 145: 6, 147: 4, 151: 3, 152: 3, 154: 5, 156: 3, 161: 5, 162: 5, 165: 5, 168: 6, 169: 2, 172: 3, 180: 3, 184: 7, 187: 7, 188: 6, 191: 5, 194: 6, 202: 7, 203: 8, 206: 4, 207: 5, 215: 4, 217: 5, 218: 10, 220: 4, 221: 4, 222: 7, 224: 5, 227: 6, 229: 3, 234: 7, 235: 4, 241: 4, 242: 4, 243: 6, 244: 2, 245: 6, 250: 5, 258: 13, 262: 6, 263: 7, 264: 5, 267: 6, 270: 4, 272: 2, 273: 7, 287: 5, 289: 3, 291: 5, 299: 6, 300: 4, 304: 4, 309: 5, 314: 4, 315: 2, 320: 6, 323: 6, 327: 6, 328: 5, 329: 4, 330: 12, 334: 4, 335: 4, 341: 6, 342: 7, 347: 6, 348: 6, 350: 9, 351: 3, 352: 3, 353: 2, 354: 2, 358: 6, 365: 3, 366: 4, 369: 3, 371: 8, 372: 5, 376: 4, 384: 5, 385: 4, 386: 5, 387: 4, 392: 5, 393: 6, 396: 7, 397: 9, 398: 8} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 30 "This document specifies the DetNet data plane operation for IP hosts and routers that provide DetNet service to IP encapsulated data. No DetNet specific encapsulation is defined to support IP flows, rather existing IP and higher layer protocol header information is used to support flow identification and DetNet service delivery." Looks good to me . 346e7aa14e7bc8d5ae2ee2fd928c802470d8a036 346e7aa14e7bc8d5ae2ee2fd928c802470d8a036 draft-ietf-detnet-ip-over-mpls 4ed65366e1610aef1bbab5151070f17233fbf8418f787aa49c98cedd2e0e1313 ['a2f06703923f28a6b36fc4dac8b72ddcbb6f6b2c822dd0776d5facb7be4adbc2', '8eae36418000195647c49055e0e262ab8d87f610aa9712c822f1acbcbd6235dc', '11719a495fea2c43a0e625e3b81fb01f768705f4403e7303a84cbac2f530f10f', '4ed65366e1610aef1bbab5151070f17233fbf8418f787aa49c98cedd2e0e1313'] A "this document specifies the detnet data plane operation for ip hosts and routers that provide detnet service to ip encapsulated data. no detnet specific encapsulation is defined to support ip flows, rather existing ip and higher layer protocol header information is used to support flow identification and detnet service delivery." {51: 1, 127: 2, 124: 2} {157: 1, 131: 2, 22: 2} {131, 157, 22, 254} 30 "The DetNet Architecture decomposes the DetNet related data plane functions into two sub-layers: a service sub-layer and a forwarding sub-layer. The service sub-layer is used to provide DetNet service protection and reordering. The forwarding sub-layer is used to provides congestion protection (low loss, assured latency, and limited reordering). Since no DetNet specific headers are added to support DetNet IP flows, only the forwarding sub-layer functions are supported using the DetNet IP defined by this document. Service protection can be provided on a per sub-net basis using technologies such as MPLS I-D.ietf-detnet-mpls and IEEE802.1 TSN." Looks good to me . 346e7aa14e7bc8d5ae2ee2fd928c802470d8a036 346e7aa14e7bc8d5ae2ee2fd928c802470d8a036 draft-ietf-detnet-ip-over-mpls 8eae36418000195647c49055e0e262ab8d87f610aa9712c822f1acbcbd6235dc ['a2f06703923f28a6b36fc4dac8b72ddcbb6f6b2c822dd0776d5facb7be4adbc2', '8eae36418000195647c49055e0e262ab8d87f610aa9712c822f1acbcbd6235dc', '11719a495fea2c43a0e625e3b81fb01f768705f4403e7303a84cbac2f530f10f', '4ed65366e1610aef1bbab5151070f17233fbf8418f787aa49c98cedd2e0e1313'] A "the detnet architecture decomposes the detnet related data plane functions into two sub-layers: a service sub-layer and a forwarding sub-layer. the service sub-layer is used to provide detnet service protection and reordering. the forwarding sub-layer is used to provides congestion protection (low loss, assured latency, and limited reordering). since no detnet specific headers are added to support detnet ip flows, only the forwarding sub-layer functions are supported using the detnet ip defined by this document. service protection can be provided on a per sub-net basis using technologies such as mpls i-d.ietf-detnet-mpls and ieee802.1 tsn." {51: 1, 127: 2, 124: 2} {157: 1, 131: 2, 22: 2} {131, 157, 22, 254} 30 "This document provides an overview of the DetNet IP data plane over MPLS." Looks good to me . 346e7aa14e7bc8d5ae2ee2fd928c802470d8a036 346e7aa14e7bc8d5ae2ee2fd928c802470d8a036 draft-ietf-detnet-ip-over-mpls 11719a495fea2c43a0e625e3b81fb01f768705f4403e7303a84cbac2f530f10f ['a2f06703923f28a6b36fc4dac8b72ddcbb6f6b2c822dd0776d5facb7be4adbc2', '8eae36418000195647c49055e0e262ab8d87f610aa9712c822f1acbcbd6235dc', '11719a495fea2c43a0e625e3b81fb01f768705f4403e7303a84cbac2f530f10f', '4ed65366e1610aef1bbab5151070f17233fbf8418f787aa49c98cedd2e0e1313'] A "this document provides an overview of the detnet ip data plane over mpls." {51: 1, 127: 2, 124: 2} {157: 1, 131: 2, 22: 2} {131, 157, 22, 254} 30 "This document specifies use of the IP DetNet encapsulation over an MPLS network. It maps the IP data plane encapsulation described in I-D.ietf-detnet-ip to the DetNet MPLS data plane defined in I-D.ietf- detnet-mpls." Looks good to me . 346e7aa14e7bc8d5ae2ee2fd928c802470d8a036 346e7aa14e7bc8d5ae2ee2fd928c802470d8a036 draft-ietf-detnet-ip-over-mpls a2f06703923f28a6b36fc4dac8b72ddcbb6f6b2c822dd0776d5facb7be4adbc2 ['a2f06703923f28a6b36fc4dac8b72ddcbb6f6b2c822dd0776d5facb7be4adbc2', '8eae36418000195647c49055e0e262ab8d87f610aa9712c822f1acbcbd6235dc', '11719a495fea2c43a0e625e3b81fb01f768705f4403e7303a84cbac2f530f10f', '4ed65366e1610aef1bbab5151070f17233fbf8418f787aa49c98cedd2e0e1313'] B "this document specifies use of the ip detnet encapsulation over an mpls network. it maps the ip data plane encapsulation described in i-d.ietf-detnet-ip to the detnet mpls data plane defined in i-d.ietf- detnet-mpls." {51: 1, 127: 2, 124: 2} {157: 1, 131: 2, 22: 2} {131, 157, 22, 254} 30 An example use of IP over DetNet MPLS follows below. Looks good to me . 346e7aa14e7bc8d5ae2ee2fd928c802470d8a036 346e7aa14e7bc8d5ae2ee2fd928c802470d8a036 draft-ietf-detnet-ip-over-mpls 5ce00a22e424d703da0d8ca90d10be247b0af579343986464cf3b8cb060a3e8f ['04d4d47ee5530763bb4330bcdd6372ca8eb2219e1b39f5c06d455c1a38ddd1fa', '5ce00a22e424d703da0d8ca90d10be247b0af579343986464cf3b8cb060a3e8f'] A an example use of ip over detnet mpls follows below. {36: 1, 110: 3, 63: 2} {331: 1, 186: 3, 332: 2} {186, 331, 3, 332} 30 An example use of DetNet IP over DetNet MPLS follows below. Looks good to me . 346e7aa14e7bc8d5ae2ee2fd928c802470d8a036 346e7aa14e7bc8d5ae2ee2fd928c802470d8a036 draft-ietf-detnet-ip-over-mpls 04d4d47ee5530763bb4330bcdd6372ca8eb2219e1b39f5c06d455c1a38ddd1fa ['04d4d47ee5530763bb4330bcdd6372ca8eb2219e1b39f5c06d455c1a38ddd1fa', '5ce00a22e424d703da0d8ca90d10be247b0af579343986464cf3b8cb060a3e8f'] B an example use of detnet ip over detnet mpls follows below. {36: 1, 110: 3, 63: 2} {331: 1, 186: 3, 332: 2} {186, 331, 3, 332} 30 "The basic encapsulation approach is to treat a DetNet IP flow as an app-flow from the DetNet MPLS app perspective. The corresponding example DetNet Sub-Network format is shown in fig_dn_ip_mpls_sn_ex." Looks good to me . 346e7aa14e7bc8d5ae2ee2fd928c802470d8a036 346e7aa14e7bc8d5ae2ee2fd928c802470d8a036 draft-ietf-detnet-ip-over-mpls d72120d23b73bc4c4af1b192c6336c665190354409ca968210bf0425aeffcc1a ['dd48531922eea7b0e7a3cd48dde0fb0d58a8d0783c63d68ee6378ecd19243976', 'f5ddd9ef16285ed7fd98d3046dec38979acca9d003e847aa25e5018b536be9f0', '24a747c276fc1b48776e1c579918c36f6e77c5fa21b2f856913009ee68ee92a1', 'd72120d23b73bc4c4af1b192c6336c665190354409ca968210bf0425aeffcc1a'] A "the basic encapsulation approach is to treat a detnet ip flow as an app-flow from the detnet mpls app perspective. the corresponding example detnet sub-network format is shown in fig_dn_ip_mpls_sn_ex." {63: 1, 91: 2, 56: 2, 36: 2, 110: 3} {395: 1, 134: 2, 75: 2, 333: 2, 346: 3} {356, 134, 75, 395, 333, 346} 30 "In the figure, ""IP App-Flow"" indicates the payload carried by the DetNet IP data plane. ""IP"" and ""NProto"" indicate the fields described in Section 7.1.1. IP Header Information and Section 7.1.2. Other Protocol Header Information in I-D.ietf-detnet-ip, respectively. ""MPLS App-Flow"" indicates that an individual DetNet IP flow is the payload from the perspective of the DetNet MPLS data plane defined in I-D.ietf-detnet-mpls." Looks good to me . 346e7aa14e7bc8d5ae2ee2fd928c802470d8a036 346e7aa14e7bc8d5ae2ee2fd928c802470d8a036 draft-ietf-detnet-ip-over-mpls dd48531922eea7b0e7a3cd48dde0fb0d58a8d0783c63d68ee6378ecd19243976 ['dd48531922eea7b0e7a3cd48dde0fb0d58a8d0783c63d68ee6378ecd19243976', 'f5ddd9ef16285ed7fd98d3046dec38979acca9d003e847aa25e5018b536be9f0', '24a747c276fc1b48776e1c579918c36f6e77c5fa21b2f856913009ee68ee92a1', 'd72120d23b73bc4c4af1b192c6336c665190354409ca968210bf0425aeffcc1a'] A "in the figure, ""ip app-flow"" indicates the payload carried by the detnet ip data plane. ""ip"" and ""nproto"" indicate the fields described in section 7.1.1. ip header information and section 7.1.2. other protocol header information in i-d.ietf-detnet-ip, respectively. ""mpls app-flow"" indicates that an individual detnet ip flow is the payload from the perspective of the detnet mpls data plane defined in i-d.ietf-detnet-mpls." {63: 1, 91: 2, 56: 2, 36: 2, 110: 3} {395: 1, 134: 2, 75: 2, 333: 2, 346: 3} {356, 134, 75, 395, 333, 346} 30 "The basic encapsulation approach is to treat a DetNet IP flow as an app-flow from the DetNet MPLS perspective. The corresponding example DetNet Sub-Network format is shown in fig_dn_ip_mpls_sn_ex." Looks good to me . 346e7aa14e7bc8d5ae2ee2fd928c802470d8a036 346e7aa14e7bc8d5ae2ee2fd928c802470d8a036 draft-ietf-detnet-ip-over-mpls 24a747c276fc1b48776e1c579918c36f6e77c5fa21b2f856913009ee68ee92a1 ['dd48531922eea7b0e7a3cd48dde0fb0d58a8d0783c63d68ee6378ecd19243976', 'f5ddd9ef16285ed7fd98d3046dec38979acca9d003e847aa25e5018b536be9f0', '24a747c276fc1b48776e1c579918c36f6e77c5fa21b2f856913009ee68ee92a1', 'd72120d23b73bc4c4af1b192c6336c665190354409ca968210bf0425aeffcc1a'] B "the basic encapsulation approach is to treat a detnet ip flow as an app-flow from the detnet mpls perspective. the corresponding example detnet sub-network format is shown in fig_dn_ip_mpls_sn_ex." {63: 1, 91: 2, 56: 2, 36: 2, 110: 3} {395: 1, 134: 2, 75: 2, 333: 2, 346: 3} {356, 134, 75, 395, 333, 346} 30 "In the figure, ""App-Flow"" indicates the payload carried by the DetNet IP data plane. ""IP"" and ""NProto"" indicate the fields described in Section 7.1.1. IP Header Information and Section 7.1.2. Other Protocol Header Information in I-D.ietf-detnet-ip, respectively. ""MPLS App-Flow"" indicates that an individual DetNet IP flow is the payload from the perspective of the DetNet MPLS data plane defined in I-D.ietf-detnet-mpls." Looks good to me . 346e7aa14e7bc8d5ae2ee2fd928c802470d8a036 346e7aa14e7bc8d5ae2ee2fd928c802470d8a036 draft-ietf-detnet-ip-over-mpls f5ddd9ef16285ed7fd98d3046dec38979acca9d003e847aa25e5018b536be9f0 ['dd48531922eea7b0e7a3cd48dde0fb0d58a8d0783c63d68ee6378ecd19243976', 'f5ddd9ef16285ed7fd98d3046dec38979acca9d003e847aa25e5018b536be9f0', '24a747c276fc1b48776e1c579918c36f6e77c5fa21b2f856913009ee68ee92a1', 'd72120d23b73bc4c4af1b192c6336c665190354409ca968210bf0425aeffcc1a'] B "in the figure, ""app-flow"" indicates the payload carried by the detnet ip data plane. ""ip"" and ""nproto"" indicate the fields described in section 7.1.1. ip header information and section 7.1.2. other protocol header information in i-d.ietf-detnet-ip, respectively. ""mpls app-flow"" indicates that an individual detnet ip flow is the payload from the perspective of the detnet mpls data plane defined in i-d.ietf-detnet-mpls." {63: 1, 91: 2, 56: 2, 36: 2, 110: 3} {395: 1, 134: 2, 75: 2, 333: 2, 346: 3} {356, 134, 75, 395, 333, 346} 30 "A relay node that sends a DetNet IP flow over a DetNet MPLS network MUST map that single DetNet IP flow into a single app-flow and MUST process that app-flow in accordance to the procedures defined in I- D.ietf-detnet-mpls Section 6.1. PRF MAY be supported for DetNet IP flows sent over an DetNet MPLS network. Aggregation MAY be supported as defined in I-D.ietf-detnet-mpls Section 5.4. Aggregation Considerations in I-D.ietf-detnet-ip MAY be used to identify an individual DetNet IP flow. The provisioning of the mapping of DetNet IP flows to DetNet MPLS app-flows MUST be supported via configuration, e.g., via the controller plane." Looks good to me . 346e7aa14e7bc8d5ae2ee2fd928c802470d8a036 346e7aa14e7bc8d5ae2ee2fd928c802470d8a036 draft-ietf-detnet-ip-over-mpls db48957fc3f7b9aca5abe6ed371ed41df34a6791fcb6b8bf4ccd02b41aae1af7 ['44de7b78d6ed4dcd01617ba5ecccd7da26f06e9624d990776ecbc1bf3941bc44', '4f492525c312bb7b073653f4e4dc857b8122bacc6f30b6f0cd610e6430c404f3', 'de606a910ff16abedcbee99df8520e0a7cbbddf5ac8f2f76d80b95916acb4019', '6f2f124c450ca96906041a92399b6f8e16cb4a3f86db153a7678aec0d7537634', 'db48957fc3f7b9aca5abe6ed371ed41df34a6791fcb6b8bf4ccd02b41aae1af7', 'ffd22f695a795e8de8863948886b4b3a104567e08c2619b39373d17862a6caa1'] A "a relay node that sends a detnet ip flow over a detnet mpls network must map that single detnet ip flow into a single app-flow and must process that app-flow in accordance to the procedures defined in i- d.ietf-detnet-mpls section 6.1. prf may be supported for detnet ip flows sent over an detnet mpls network. aggregation may be supported as defined in i-d.ietf-detnet-mpls section 5.4. aggregation considerations in i-d.ietf-detnet-ip may be used to identify an individual detnet ip flow. the provisioning of the mapping of detnet ip flows to detnet mpls app-flows must be supported via configuration, e.g., via the controller plane." {63: 1, 38: 1, 69: 2, 118: 2} {102: 1, 414: 1, 175: 1, 401: 2, 407: 2, 62: 2} {414, 102, 103, 175, 401, 407, 62} 30 "A relay node MAY be provisioned to handle packets received via the DetNet MPLS data plane as DetNet IP flows. A single incoming MPLS app-flow MAY be treated as a single DetNet IP flow, without examination of IP headers. Alternatively, packets received via the DetNet MPLS data plane MAY follow the normal DetNet IP flow identification procedures defined in I-D.ietf-detnet-ip Section 7.1. An implementation MUST support the provisioning for handling any received DetNet MPLS data plane as DetNet IP flows via configuration. Note that such configuration MAY include support from PEOF on the incoming DetNet MPLS flow." Looks good to me . 346e7aa14e7bc8d5ae2ee2fd928c802470d8a036 346e7aa14e7bc8d5ae2ee2fd928c802470d8a036 draft-ietf-detnet-ip-over-mpls 4f492525c312bb7b073653f4e4dc857b8122bacc6f30b6f0cd610e6430c404f3 ['44de7b78d6ed4dcd01617ba5ecccd7da26f06e9624d990776ecbc1bf3941bc44', '4f492525c312bb7b073653f4e4dc857b8122bacc6f30b6f0cd610e6430c404f3', 'de606a910ff16abedcbee99df8520e0a7cbbddf5ac8f2f76d80b95916acb4019', '6f2f124c450ca96906041a92399b6f8e16cb4a3f86db153a7678aec0d7537634', 'db48957fc3f7b9aca5abe6ed371ed41df34a6791fcb6b8bf4ccd02b41aae1af7', 'ffd22f695a795e8de8863948886b4b3a104567e08c2619b39373d17862a6caa1'] A "a relay node may be provisioned to handle packets received via the detnet mpls data plane as detnet ip flows. a single incoming mpls app-flow may be treated as a single detnet ip flow, without examination of ip headers. alternatively, packets received via the detnet mpls data plane may follow the normal detnet ip flow identification procedures defined in i-d.ietf-detnet-ip section 7.1. an implementation must support the provisioning for handling any received detnet mpls data plane as detnet ip flows via configuration. note that such configuration may include support from peof on the incoming detnet mpls flow." {63: 1, 38: 1, 69: 2, 118: 2} {102: 1, 414: 1, 175: 1, 401: 2, 407: 2, 62: 2} {414, 102, 103, 175, 401, 407, 62} 30 "The traffic treatment required for a particular DetNet IP flow is provisioned via configuration or the controller plane. When an DetNet IP flow is sent over DetNet MPLS, a relay node MUST ensure that the provisioned DetNet IP traffic treatment is provided at the forwarding sub-layer as described in I-D.ietf-detnet-mpls Section 5.2. Note that the PRF function MAY be utilized when sending IP over MPLS." Looks good to me . 346e7aa14e7bc8d5ae2ee2fd928c802470d8a036 346e7aa14e7bc8d5ae2ee2fd928c802470d8a036 draft-ietf-detnet-ip-over-mpls de606a910ff16abedcbee99df8520e0a7cbbddf5ac8f2f76d80b95916acb4019 ['44de7b78d6ed4dcd01617ba5ecccd7da26f06e9624d990776ecbc1bf3941bc44', '4f492525c312bb7b073653f4e4dc857b8122bacc6f30b6f0cd610e6430c404f3', 'de606a910ff16abedcbee99df8520e0a7cbbddf5ac8f2f76d80b95916acb4019', '6f2f124c450ca96906041a92399b6f8e16cb4a3f86db153a7678aec0d7537634', 'db48957fc3f7b9aca5abe6ed371ed41df34a6791fcb6b8bf4ccd02b41aae1af7', 'ffd22f695a795e8de8863948886b4b3a104567e08c2619b39373d17862a6caa1'] A "the traffic treatment required for a particular detnet ip flow is provisioned via configuration or the controller plane. when an detnet ip flow is sent over detnet mpls, a relay node must ensure that the provisioned detnet ip traffic treatment is provided at the forwarding sub-layer as described in i-d.ietf-detnet-mpls section 5.2. note that the prf function may be utilized when sending ip over mpls." {63: 1, 38: 1, 69: 2, 118: 2} {102: 1, 414: 1, 175: 1, 401: 2, 407: 2, 62: 2} {414, 102, 103, 175, 401, 407, 62} 30 "A DetNet relay node (ingress T-PE) that sends a DetNet IP flow over a DetNet MPLS network MUST map that single DetNet IP flow into a single MPLS DetNet flow and MUST process it in accordance to the procedures defined in I-D.ietf-detnet-mpls Section 6.1. PRF MAY be supported for DetNet IP flows sent over an DetNet MPLS network. Aggregation MAY be supported as defined in I-D.ietf-detnet-mpls Section 5.4. Aggregation considerations in I-D.ietf-detnet-ip MAY be used to identify an individual DetNet IP flow. The provisioning of the mapping of DetNet IP flows to DetNet MPLS flows MUST be supported via configuration, e.g., via the controller plane." Looks good to me . 346e7aa14e7bc8d5ae2ee2fd928c802470d8a036 346e7aa14e7bc8d5ae2ee2fd928c802470d8a036 draft-ietf-detnet-ip-over-mpls ffd22f695a795e8de8863948886b4b3a104567e08c2619b39373d17862a6caa1 ['44de7b78d6ed4dcd01617ba5ecccd7da26f06e9624d990776ecbc1bf3941bc44', '4f492525c312bb7b073653f4e4dc857b8122bacc6f30b6f0cd610e6430c404f3', 'de606a910ff16abedcbee99df8520e0a7cbbddf5ac8f2f76d80b95916acb4019', '6f2f124c450ca96906041a92399b6f8e16cb4a3f86db153a7678aec0d7537634', 'db48957fc3f7b9aca5abe6ed371ed41df34a6791fcb6b8bf4ccd02b41aae1af7', 'ffd22f695a795e8de8863948886b4b3a104567e08c2619b39373d17862a6caa1'] B "a detnet relay node (ingress t-pe) that sends a detnet ip flow over a detnet mpls network must map that single detnet ip flow into a single mpls detnet flow and must process it in accordance to the procedures defined in i-d.ietf-detnet-mpls section 6.1. prf may be supported for detnet ip flows sent over an detnet mpls network. aggregation may be supported as defined in i-d.ietf-detnet-mpls section 5.4. aggregation considerations in i-d.ietf-detnet-ip may be used to identify an individual detnet ip flow. the provisioning of the mapping of detnet ip flows to detnet mpls flows must be supported via configuration, e.g., via the controller plane." {63: 1, 38: 1, 69: 2, 118: 2} {102: 1, 414: 1, 175: 1, 401: 2, 407: 2, 62: 2} {414, 102, 103, 175, 401, 407, 62} 30 "A DetNet relay node (egress T-PE) MAY be provisioned to handle packets received via the DetNet MPLS data plane as DetNet IP flows. A single incoming DetNet MPLS flow MAY be treated as a single DetNet IP flow, without examination of IP headers. Alternatively, packets received via the DetNet MPLS data plane MAY follow the normal DetNet IP flow identification procedures defined in I-D.ietf-detnet-ip Section 7.1. An implementation MUST support the provisioning for handling any received DetNet MPLS data plane as DetNet IP flows via configuration. Note that such configuration MAY include support from PEOF on the incoming DetNet MPLS flow." Looks good to me . 346e7aa14e7bc8d5ae2ee2fd928c802470d8a036 346e7aa14e7bc8d5ae2ee2fd928c802470d8a036 draft-ietf-detnet-ip-over-mpls 6f2f124c450ca96906041a92399b6f8e16cb4a3f86db153a7678aec0d7537634 ['44de7b78d6ed4dcd01617ba5ecccd7da26f06e9624d990776ecbc1bf3941bc44', '4f492525c312bb7b073653f4e4dc857b8122bacc6f30b6f0cd610e6430c404f3', 'de606a910ff16abedcbee99df8520e0a7cbbddf5ac8f2f76d80b95916acb4019', '6f2f124c450ca96906041a92399b6f8e16cb4a3f86db153a7678aec0d7537634', 'db48957fc3f7b9aca5abe6ed371ed41df34a6791fcb6b8bf4ccd02b41aae1af7', 'ffd22f695a795e8de8863948886b4b3a104567e08c2619b39373d17862a6caa1'] B "a detnet relay node (egress t-pe) may be provisioned to handle packets received via the detnet mpls data plane as detnet ip flows. a single incoming detnet mpls flow may be treated as a single detnet ip flow, without examination of ip headers. alternatively, packets received via the detnet mpls data plane may follow the normal detnet ip flow identification procedures defined in i-d.ietf-detnet-ip section 7.1. an implementation must support the provisioning for handling any received detnet mpls data plane as detnet ip flows via configuration. note that such configuration may include support from peof on the incoming detnet mpls flow." {63: 1, 38: 1, 69: 2, 118: 2} {102: 1, 414: 1, 175: 1, 401: 2, 407: 2, 62: 2} {414, 102, 103, 175, 401, 407, 62} 30 "The traffic treatment required for a particular DetNet IP flow is provisioned via configuration or the controller plane. When an DetNet IP flow is sent over DetNet MPLS, a DetNet relay node MUST ensure that the provisioned DetNet IP traffic treatment is provided at the forwarding sub-layer as described in I-D.ietf-detnet-mpls Section 5.2. Note that the PRF function MAY be utilized when sending IP over MPLS." Looks good to me . 346e7aa14e7bc8d5ae2ee2fd928c802470d8a036 346e7aa14e7bc8d5ae2ee2fd928c802470d8a036 draft-ietf-detnet-ip-over-mpls 44de7b78d6ed4dcd01617ba5ecccd7da26f06e9624d990776ecbc1bf3941bc44 ['44de7b78d6ed4dcd01617ba5ecccd7da26f06e9624d990776ecbc1bf3941bc44', '4f492525c312bb7b073653f4e4dc857b8122bacc6f30b6f0cd610e6430c404f3', 'de606a910ff16abedcbee99df8520e0a7cbbddf5ac8f2f76d80b95916acb4019', '6f2f124c450ca96906041a92399b6f8e16cb4a3f86db153a7678aec0d7537634', 'db48957fc3f7b9aca5abe6ed371ed41df34a6791fcb6b8bf4ccd02b41aae1af7', 'ffd22f695a795e8de8863948886b4b3a104567e08c2619b39373d17862a6caa1'] B "the traffic treatment required for a particular detnet ip flow is provisioned via configuration or the controller plane. when an detnet ip flow is sent over detnet mpls, a detnet relay node must ensure that the provisioned detnet ip traffic treatment is provided at the forwarding sub-layer as described in i-d.ietf-detnet-mpls section 5.2. note that the prf function may be utilized when sending ip over mpls." {63: 1, 38: 1, 69: 2, 118: 2} {102: 1, 414: 1, 175: 1, 401: 2, 407: 2, 62: 2} {414, 102, 103, 175, 401, 407, 62} 30 "The security considerations of DetNet in general are discussed in I- D.ietf-detnet-architecture and I-D.ietf-detnet-security. Other security considerations will be added in a future version of this draft." Looks good to me . 346e7aa14e7bc8d5ae2ee2fd928c802470d8a036 346e7aa14e7bc8d5ae2ee2fd928c802470d8a036 draft-ietf-detnet-ip-over-mpls bef1c83b3620d0cfd78ac49fdd158a63bffc682797718f741ee084306124fcf2 ['5024c49f483b8d46eb4017736cd7ced5b578f170328bf15ff1060aa0235be4b8', 'bef1c83b3620d0cfd78ac49fdd158a63bffc682797718f741ee084306124fcf2'] A "the security considerations of detnet in general are discussed in i- d.ietf-detnet-architecture and i-d.ietf-detnet-security. other security considerations will be added in a future version of this draft." {51: 1, 64: 1, 13: 1, 36: 1, 6: 4, 79: 4, 90: 2, 130: 3, 62: 5, 85: 6, 68: 6, 35: 5, 110: 2, 91: 3, 114: 2, 97: 3, 31: 3, 67: 2, 38: 4, 26: 3, 124: 5, 98: 4, 54: 4, 127: 5, 8: 4, 96: 3, 61: 5, 55: 5, 27: 4, 15: 2, 52: 2, 129: 5, 115: 2, 84: 2, 76: 8, 87: 2, 131: 7, 102: 2, 113: 5, 99: 4, 24: 2, 53: 3, 72: 4} {27: 1, 128: 1, 315: 1, 353: 1, 1: 11, 4: 4, 9: 7, 10: 5, 15: 3, 24: 4, 25: 5, 26: 6, 39: 7, 43: 5, 49: 4, 50: 3, 58: 5, 59: 4, 64: 3, 69: 6, 81: 6, 82: 4, 86: 3, 96: 4, 97: 3, 100: 7, 108: 5, 109: 6, 110: 6, 111: 4, 114: 5, 115: 6, 116: 3, 118: 8, 119: 7, 120: 5, 121: 6, 122: 4, 123: 3, 124: 6, 130: 5, 132: 6, 136: 4, 145: 6, 147: 4, 151: 2, 152: 3, 154: 5, 156: 2, 161: 5, 162: 5, 165: 5, 168: 6, 169: 2, 172: 2, 180: 2, 184: 7, 187: 7, 188: 6, 191: 5, 194: 6, 202: 7, 203: 8, 206: 4, 207: 5, 215: 4, 217: 5, 218: 10, 220: 4, 221: 4, 222: 7, 224: 5, 227: 5, 229: 2, 234: 7, 235: 4, 241: 4, 242: 4, 243: 6, 244: 3, 245: 6, 248: 3, 250: 4, 258: 13, 262: 6, 263: 7, 264: 5, 267: 6, 270: 3, 272: 2, 273: 7, 287: 5, 289: 2, 291: 5, 299: 5, 300: 3, 304: 3, 309: 5, 314: 4, 320: 6, 323: 6, 327: 6, 328: 5, 329: 4, 330: 12, 334: 4, 335: 3, 341: 5, 342: 6, 347: 5, 348: 5, 350: 9, 351: 4, 352: 2, 354: 2, 358: 6, 365: 2, 366: 4, 369: 3, 371: 7, 372: 5, 376: 4, 384: 5, 385: 4, 386: 5, 387: 3, 392: 5, 393: 6, 396: 6, 397: 9, 398: 8, 402: 2} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 30 "The security considerations of DetNet in general are discussed in I- D.ietf-detnet-architecture and I-D.ietf-detnet-security. MPLS and IP specific security considerations are described in I-D.ietf-detnet- mpls and I-D.ietf-detnet-ip. This draft does not have additional security considerations." Looks good to me . 346e7aa14e7bc8d5ae2ee2fd928c802470d8a036 346e7aa14e7bc8d5ae2ee2fd928c802470d8a036 draft-ietf-detnet-ip-over-mpls 5024c49f483b8d46eb4017736cd7ced5b578f170328bf15ff1060aa0235be4b8 ['5024c49f483b8d46eb4017736cd7ced5b578f170328bf15ff1060aa0235be4b8', 'bef1c83b3620d0cfd78ac49fdd158a63bffc682797718f741ee084306124fcf2'] B "the security considerations of detnet in general are discussed in i- d.ietf-detnet-architecture and i-d.ietf-detnet-security. mpls and ip specific security considerations are described in i-d.ietf-detnet- mpls and i-d.ietf-detnet-ip. this draft does not have additional security considerations." {51: 1, 64: 1, 13: 1, 36: 1, 6: 4, 79: 4, 90: 2, 130: 3, 62: 5, 85: 6, 68: 6, 35: 5, 110: 2, 91: 3, 114: 2, 97: 3, 31: 3, 67: 2, 38: 4, 26: 3, 124: 5, 98: 4, 54: 4, 127: 5, 8: 4, 96: 3, 61: 5, 55: 5, 27: 4, 15: 2, 52: 2, 129: 5, 115: 2, 84: 2, 76: 8, 87: 2, 131: 7, 102: 2, 113: 5, 99: 4, 24: 2, 53: 3, 72: 4} {27: 1, 128: 1, 315: 1, 353: 1, 1: 11, 4: 4, 9: 7, 10: 5, 15: 3, 24: 4, 25: 5, 26: 6, 39: 7, 43: 5, 49: 4, 50: 3, 58: 5, 59: 4, 64: 3, 69: 6, 81: 6, 82: 4, 86: 3, 96: 4, 97: 3, 100: 7, 108: 5, 109: 6, 110: 6, 111: 4, 114: 5, 115: 6, 116: 3, 118: 8, 119: 7, 120: 5, 121: 6, 122: 4, 123: 3, 124: 6, 130: 5, 132: 6, 136: 4, 145: 6, 147: 4, 151: 2, 152: 3, 154: 5, 156: 2, 161: 5, 162: 5, 165: 5, 168: 6, 169: 2, 172: 2, 180: 2, 184: 7, 187: 7, 188: 6, 191: 5, 194: 6, 202: 7, 203: 8, 206: 4, 207: 5, 215: 4, 217: 5, 218: 10, 220: 4, 221: 4, 222: 7, 224: 5, 227: 5, 229: 2, 234: 7, 235: 4, 241: 4, 242: 4, 243: 6, 244: 3, 245: 6, 248: 3, 250: 4, 258: 13, 262: 6, 263: 7, 264: 5, 267: 6, 270: 3, 272: 2, 273: 7, 287: 5, 289: 2, 291: 5, 299: 5, 300: 3, 304: 3, 309: 5, 314: 4, 320: 6, 323: 6, 327: 6, 328: 5, 329: 4, 330: 12, 334: 4, 335: 3, 341: 5, 342: 6, 347: 5, 348: 5, 350: 9, 351: 4, 352: 2, 354: 2, 358: 6, 365: 2, 366: 4, 369: 3, 371: 7, 372: 5, 376: 4, 384: 5, 385: 4, 386: 5, 387: 3, 392: 5, 393: 6, 396: 6, 397: 9, 398: 8, 402: 2} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 27 "The DetNet forwarding sub-layer is supported by one or more forwarding labels (F-Labels). MPLS Traffic Engineering encapsulations and mechanisms can be utilized to provide a forwarding sub-layer that is responsible for providing resource allocation and explicit routes." "… flows OK ." b1a2789778493d7f985c44fa3950beda5685bd13 b1a2789778493d7f985c44fa3950beda5685bd13 draft-ietf-detnet-mpls 7d23c67a5795ad79d97d3e3d211f17173b16991b3fd44516da926a33df2eb2ce ['b58d7df1c5dd9cb37fc1b17fe0720b1fc8a5f267f04b540efff27c0389c9f87c', '7d23c67a5795ad79d97d3e3d211f17173b16991b3fd44516da926a33df2eb2ce'] A "the detnet forwarding sub-layer is supported by one or more forwarding labels (f-labels). mpls traffic engineering encapsulations and mechanisms can be utilized to provide a forwarding sub-layer that is responsible for providing resource allocation and explicit routes." {} {} {} 27 "The DetNet forwarding sub-layer is supported by zero or more forwarding labels (F-Labels). MPLS Traffic Engineering encapsulations and mechanisms can be utilized to provide a forwarding sub-layer that is responsible for providing resource allocation and explicit routes." "… flows OK ." b1a2789778493d7f985c44fa3950beda5685bd13 b1a2789778493d7f985c44fa3950beda5685bd13 draft-ietf-detnet-mpls b58d7df1c5dd9cb37fc1b17fe0720b1fc8a5f267f04b540efff27c0389c9f87c ['b58d7df1c5dd9cb37fc1b17fe0720b1fc8a5f267f04b540efff27c0389c9f87c', '7d23c67a5795ad79d97d3e3d211f17173b16991b3fd44516da926a33df2eb2ce'] B "the detnet forwarding sub-layer is supported by zero or more forwarding labels (f-labels). mpls traffic engineering encapsulations and mechanisms can be utilized to provide a forwarding sub-layer that is responsible for providing resource allocation and explicit routes." {} {} {} 27 "The resource control and management aspects of aggregation (including the configuration of queuing, shaping, and policing) is the responsibility of the DetNet controller plane and will be covered in other documents. It is also the responsibility of the controller plane to ensure that consistent aggregation methods are used." "… flows OK ." b1a2789778493d7f985c44fa3950beda5685bd13 b1a2789778493d7f985c44fa3950beda5685bd13 draft-ietf-detnet-mpls 956926fe9f219ce702d3df24ad963a7a1894a1cd3f525da82fae2da329af8778 ['0da0c7cd9a41758799f48ce4e17324be8f7daae22b9bbe17eda29548d594638e', '956926fe9f219ce702d3df24ad963a7a1894a1cd3f525da82fae2da329af8778'] A "the resource control and management aspects of aggregation (including the configuration of queuing, shaping, and policing) is the responsibility of the detnet controller plane and will be covered in other documents. it is also the responsibility of the controller plane to ensure that consistent aggregation methods are used." {38: 1, 26: 1} {6: 1, 313: 1} {313, 6, 7} 27 "The resource control and management aspects of aggregation (including the configuration of queuing, shaping, and policing) are the responsibility of the DetNet controller plane and will be covered in other documents. It is also the responsibility of the controller plane to ensure that consistent aggregation methods are used." "… flows OK ." b1a2789778493d7f985c44fa3950beda5685bd13 b1a2789778493d7f985c44fa3950beda5685bd13 draft-ietf-detnet-mpls 0da0c7cd9a41758799f48ce4e17324be8f7daae22b9bbe17eda29548d594638e ['0da0c7cd9a41758799f48ce4e17324be8f7daae22b9bbe17eda29548d594638e', '956926fe9f219ce702d3df24ad963a7a1894a1cd3f525da82fae2da329af8778'] B "the resource control and management aspects of aggregation (including the configuration of queuing, shaping, and policing) are the responsibility of the detnet controller plane and will be covered in other documents. it is also the responsibility of the controller plane to ensure that consistent aggregation methods are used." {38: 1, 26: 1} {6: 1, 313: 1} {313, 6, 7} 27 "DetNet flows forwarded via MPLS can leverage MPLS-TE's existing support for hierarchical LSPs (H-LSPs), see RFC4206. H-LSPs are typically used to aggregate control and resources, they may also be used to provide OAM or protection for the aggregated LSPs. Arbitrary levels of aggregation naturally falls out of the definition for hierarchy and the MPLS label stack RFC3032. DetNet nodes which support aggregation (LSP hierarchy) map one or more LSPs (labels) into and from an H-LSP. Both carried LSPs and H-LSPs may or may not use the TC field, i.e., L-LSPs or E-LSPs. Such nodes will need to ensure that component LSPs and H-LSPs receive the traffic treatement required to ensure the required DetNet service is preserved." "… flows OK ." b1a2789778493d7f985c44fa3950beda5685bd13 b1a2789778493d7f985c44fa3950beda5685bd13 draft-ietf-detnet-mpls c3d59bc9317889968221c7e0e8add8619dfa7d3b2d0377a1ee7474f423ecb6af ['c3d59bc9317889968221c7e0e8add8619dfa7d3b2d0377a1ee7474f423ecb6af', '815c465678ffee373129a89e02f702fc577a7383644437fddfba89f7f7e19d64'] A "detnet flows forwarded via mpls can leverage mpls-te's existing support for hierarchical lsps (h-lsps), see rfc4206. h-lsps are typically used to aggregate control and resources, they may also be used to provide oam or protection for the aggregated lsps. arbitrary levels of aggregation naturally falls out of the definition for hierarchy and the mpls label stack rfc3032. detnet nodes which support aggregation (lsp hierarchy) map one or more lsps (labels) into and from an h-lsp. both carried lsps and h-lsps may or may not use the tc field, i.e., l-lsps or e-lsps. such nodes will need to ensure that component lsps and h-lsps receive the traffic treatement required to ensure the required detnet service is preserved." {35: 1, 26: 1, 114: 2} {204: 1, 306: 1, 326: 2} {306, 307, 204, 326} 27 "DetNet flows forwarded via MPLS can leverage MPLS-TE's existing support for hierarchical LSPs (H-LSPs), see RFC4206. H-LSPs are typically used to aggregate control and resources, they may also be used to provide OAM or protection for the aggregated LSPs. Arbitrary levels of aggregation naturally falls out of the definition for hierarchy and the MPLS label stack RFC3032. DetNet nodes which support aggregation (LSP hierarchy) map one or more LSPs (labels) into and from an H-LSP. Both carried LSPs and H-LSPs may or may not use the TC field, i.e., L-LSPs or E-LSPs. Such nodes will need to ensure that individual LSPs and H-LSPs receive the traffic treatement required to ensure the required DetNet service is preserved." "… flows OK ." b1a2789778493d7f985c44fa3950beda5685bd13 b1a2789778493d7f985c44fa3950beda5685bd13 draft-ietf-detnet-mpls 815c465678ffee373129a89e02f702fc577a7383644437fddfba89f7f7e19d64 ['c3d59bc9317889968221c7e0e8add8619dfa7d3b2d0377a1ee7474f423ecb6af', '815c465678ffee373129a89e02f702fc577a7383644437fddfba89f7f7e19d64'] B "detnet flows forwarded via mpls can leverage mpls-te's existing support for hierarchical lsps (h-lsps), see rfc4206. h-lsps are typically used to aggregate control and resources, they may also be used to provide oam or protection for the aggregated lsps. arbitrary levels of aggregation naturally falls out of the definition for hierarchy and the mpls label stack rfc3032. detnet nodes which support aggregation (lsp hierarchy) map one or more lsps (labels) into and from an h-lsp. both carried lsps and h-lsps may or may not use the tc field, i.e., l-lsps or e-lsps. such nodes will need to ensure that individual lsps and h-lsps receive the traffic treatement required to ensure the required detnet service is preserved." {35: 1, 26: 1, 114: 2} {204: 1, 306: 1, 326: 2} {306, 307, 204, 326} 27 "Both the Aggregation (A) label and the S-Label have their MPLS S bit set indicating bottom of stack, and the d-CW allows the PREOF to work." "… flows OK ." b1a2789778493d7f985c44fa3950beda5685bd13 b1a2789778493d7f985c44fa3950beda5685bd13 draft-ietf-detnet-mpls 8dad2084f98108f78196664e1e250cfc4b8430db4131ccb060d95ff9b4abc03a ['abdc17c67745b4083db271e1502a303aa02277aeb8cd4f15c74b57faf93c7fe2', '823ce8572661a4551b1a61376e04ab936637113b89175d0742f1a2bb796119f0', '09515ad60af35357e40873e0c49f1790730b0faa6a251814275eabc8883f58eb', 'a538cfc7a38ec764b699e862926ceb51deda81a94d16906065a652c480896a31', 'f0f21eb5d2863d29c746414aa12d83c0b46e3622506a8b24fb9da38fbcd6dee0', '8dad2084f98108f78196664e1e250cfc4b8430db4131ccb060d95ff9b4abc03a'] A "both the aggregation (a) label and the s-label have their mpls s bit set indicating bottom of stack, and the d-cw allows the preof to work." {35: 1, 38: 1, 26: 1, 113: 2} {94: 1, 205: 1, 265: 1, 95: 2} {265, 266, 205, 94, 95} 27 "It is a property of the A-label that what follows is d-CW followed by an S-Label. A relay node processing the A-label would not know the underlying payload type. This would only be known to a node that was a peer of the node imposing the S-Label. However there is no real need for it to know the payload type during aggregation processing." "… flows OK ." b1a2789778493d7f985c44fa3950beda5685bd13 b1a2789778493d7f985c44fa3950beda5685bd13 draft-ietf-detnet-mpls f0f21eb5d2863d29c746414aa12d83c0b46e3622506a8b24fb9da38fbcd6dee0 ['abdc17c67745b4083db271e1502a303aa02277aeb8cd4f15c74b57faf93c7fe2', '823ce8572661a4551b1a61376e04ab936637113b89175d0742f1a2bb796119f0', '09515ad60af35357e40873e0c49f1790730b0faa6a251814275eabc8883f58eb', 'a538cfc7a38ec764b699e862926ceb51deda81a94d16906065a652c480896a31', 'f0f21eb5d2863d29c746414aa12d83c0b46e3622506a8b24fb9da38fbcd6dee0', '8dad2084f98108f78196664e1e250cfc4b8430db4131ccb060d95ff9b4abc03a'] A "it is a property of the a-label that what follows is d-cw followed by an s-label. a relay node processing the a-label would not know the underlying payload type. this would only be known to a node that was a peer of the node imposing the s-label. however there is no real need for it to know the payload type during aggregation processing." {35: 1, 38: 1, 26: 1, 113: 2} {94: 1, 205: 1, 265: 1, 95: 2} {265, 266, 205, 94, 95} 27 "As in the previous section, nodes supporting this type of aggregetation will need to ensure that component and aggregated flows receive the traffic treatement required to ensure the required DetNet service is preserved. Also, it is the controller plane's responsibility to to ensure that the service required on the aggregate flow are properly provisioned." "… flows OK ." b1a2789778493d7f985c44fa3950beda5685bd13 b1a2789778493d7f985c44fa3950beda5685bd13 draft-ietf-detnet-mpls abdc17c67745b4083db271e1502a303aa02277aeb8cd4f15c74b57faf93c7fe2 ['abdc17c67745b4083db271e1502a303aa02277aeb8cd4f15c74b57faf93c7fe2', '823ce8572661a4551b1a61376e04ab936637113b89175d0742f1a2bb796119f0', '09515ad60af35357e40873e0c49f1790730b0faa6a251814275eabc8883f58eb', 'a538cfc7a38ec764b699e862926ceb51deda81a94d16906065a652c480896a31', 'f0f21eb5d2863d29c746414aa12d83c0b46e3622506a8b24fb9da38fbcd6dee0', '8dad2084f98108f78196664e1e250cfc4b8430db4131ccb060d95ff9b4abc03a'] A "as in the previous section, nodes supporting this type of aggregetation will need to ensure that component and aggregated flows receive the traffic treatement required to ensure the required detnet service is preserved. also, it is the controller plane's responsibility to to ensure that the service required on the aggregate flow are properly provisioned." {35: 1, 38: 1, 26: 1, 113: 2} {94: 1, 205: 1, 265: 1, 95: 2} {265, 266, 205, 94, 95} 27 "Both the aggregation label, or A-Label, and the individual flow's S-Label have their MPLS S bit set indicating bottom of stack, and the d-CW allows the PREOF to work. An A-Label is a special case of an S-Label, whose properties are known only at the aggregation and deaggregation end-points." "… flows OK ." b1a2789778493d7f985c44fa3950beda5685bd13 b1a2789778493d7f985c44fa3950beda5685bd13 draft-ietf-detnet-mpls a538cfc7a38ec764b699e862926ceb51deda81a94d16906065a652c480896a31 ['abdc17c67745b4083db271e1502a303aa02277aeb8cd4f15c74b57faf93c7fe2', '823ce8572661a4551b1a61376e04ab936637113b89175d0742f1a2bb796119f0', '09515ad60af35357e40873e0c49f1790730b0faa6a251814275eabc8883f58eb', 'a538cfc7a38ec764b699e862926ceb51deda81a94d16906065a652c480896a31', 'f0f21eb5d2863d29c746414aa12d83c0b46e3622506a8b24fb9da38fbcd6dee0', '8dad2084f98108f78196664e1e250cfc4b8430db4131ccb060d95ff9b4abc03a'] B "both the aggregation label, or a-label, and the individual flow's s-label have their mpls s bit set indicating bottom of stack, and the d-cw allows the preof to work. an a-label is a special case of an s-label, whose properties are known only at the aggregation and deaggregation end-points." {35: 1, 38: 1, 26: 1, 113: 2} {94: 1, 205: 1, 265: 1, 95: 2} {265, 266, 205, 94, 95} 27 "It is a property of the A-Label that what follows is a d-CW followed by an MPLS label stack. A relay node processing the A-Label would not know the underlying payload type, and the A-Label would be process as a normal S-Label. This would only be known to a node that was a peer of the node imposing the S-Label. However there is no real need for it to know the payload type during aggregation processing." "… flows OK ." b1a2789778493d7f985c44fa3950beda5685bd13 b1a2789778493d7f985c44fa3950beda5685bd13 draft-ietf-detnet-mpls 823ce8572661a4551b1a61376e04ab936637113b89175d0742f1a2bb796119f0 ['abdc17c67745b4083db271e1502a303aa02277aeb8cd4f15c74b57faf93c7fe2', '823ce8572661a4551b1a61376e04ab936637113b89175d0742f1a2bb796119f0', '09515ad60af35357e40873e0c49f1790730b0faa6a251814275eabc8883f58eb', 'a538cfc7a38ec764b699e862926ceb51deda81a94d16906065a652c480896a31', 'f0f21eb5d2863d29c746414aa12d83c0b46e3622506a8b24fb9da38fbcd6dee0', '8dad2084f98108f78196664e1e250cfc4b8430db4131ccb060d95ff9b4abc03a'] B "it is a property of the a-label that what follows is a d-cw followed by an mpls label stack. a relay node processing the a-label would not know the underlying payload type, and the a-label would be process as a normal s-label. this would only be known to a node that was a peer of the node imposing the s-label. however there is no real need for it to know the payload type during aggregation processing." {35: 1, 38: 1, 26: 1, 113: 2} {94: 1, 205: 1, 265: 1, 95: 2} {265, 266, 205, 94, 95} 27 "As in the previous section, nodes supporting this type of aggregetation will need to ensure that individual and aggregated flows receive the traffic treatement required to ensure the required DetNet service is preserved. Also, it is the controller plane's responsibility to to ensure that the service required on the aggregate flow are properly provisioned." "… flows OK ." b1a2789778493d7f985c44fa3950beda5685bd13 b1a2789778493d7f985c44fa3950beda5685bd13 draft-ietf-detnet-mpls 09515ad60af35357e40873e0c49f1790730b0faa6a251814275eabc8883f58eb ['abdc17c67745b4083db271e1502a303aa02277aeb8cd4f15c74b57faf93c7fe2', '823ce8572661a4551b1a61376e04ab936637113b89175d0742f1a2bb796119f0', '09515ad60af35357e40873e0c49f1790730b0faa6a251814275eabc8883f58eb', 'a538cfc7a38ec764b699e862926ceb51deda81a94d16906065a652c480896a31', 'f0f21eb5d2863d29c746414aa12d83c0b46e3622506a8b24fb9da38fbcd6dee0', '8dad2084f98108f78196664e1e250cfc4b8430db4131ccb060d95ff9b4abc03a'] B "as in the previous section, nodes supporting this type of aggregetation will need to ensure that individual and aggregated flows receive the traffic treatement required to ensure the required detnet service is preserved. also, it is the controller plane's responsibility to to ensure that the service required on the aggregate flow are properly provisioned." {35: 1, 38: 1, 26: 1, 113: 2} {94: 1, 205: 1, 265: 1, 95: 2} {265, 266, 205, 94, 95} 27 F-Label to H-LSP/Label mappings. "… flows OK ." b1a2789778493d7f985c44fa3950beda5685bd13 b1a2789778493d7f985c44fa3950beda5685bd13 draft-ietf-detnet-mpls 5b4633e7421bdcaf006fbab7560895ed013741152128081e90f940a2d441b284 ['5b4633e7421bdcaf006fbab7560895ed013741152128081e90f940a2d441b284', 'e0272e86b037d5f460db4807aede2c02c9d02cb129d656c91aa723e14be8738c', 'c86b82b03c7ea6b5c48792faeda1ebc0f006b6443f53f2e1ebc75f77800e953a', '29ea94d06c6751fb47652496c82e1e9d54be60eb454edad2d4cc70305b7e7f6e'] A f-label to h-lsp/label mappings. {38: 1, 26: 1, 6: 4, 79: 4, 90: 3, 51: 4, 130: 4, 62: 6, 85: 7, 68: 6, 35: 5, 110: 3, 91: 5, 114: 2, 97: 4, 31: 4, 13: 3, 67: 3, 124: 5, 98: 4, 54: 4, 127: 5, 8: 4, 96: 4, 64: 4, 30: 4, 61: 2, 55: 5, 15: 3, 52: 3, 129: 5, 115: 3, 84: 3, 76: 8, 87: 3, 131: 7, 102: 3, 113: 2, 27: 6, 99: 4, 36: 3, 24: 2, 53: 3, 72: 4} {96: 1, 97: 1, 1: 11, 4: 4, 9: 7, 10: 5, 15: 4, 24: 4, 25: 6, 26: 7, 27: 4, 39: 7, 43: 5, 49: 6, 50: 5, 58: 2, 59: 4, 64: 4, 69: 6, 81: 7, 82: 5, 86: 3, 100: 8, 108: 5, 109: 6, 110: 6, 111: 4, 114: 5, 115: 6, 116: 4, 118: 8, 119: 7, 120: 5, 121: 6, 122: 5, 123: 4, 124: 6, 128: 4, 129: 4, 130: 2, 132: 6, 136: 4, 145: 6, 151: 4, 152: 4, 154: 5, 156: 3, 161: 5, 162: 5, 165: 5, 168: 6, 169: 3, 172: 3, 180: 4, 184: 7, 187: 7, 188: 6, 191: 5, 194: 6, 202: 7, 203: 8, 206: 4, 207: 5, 215: 4, 217: 5, 218: 10, 220: 4, 221: 4, 222: 7, 224: 5, 227: 6, 229: 3, 234: 7, 235: 4, 241: 4, 242: 4, 243: 6, 244: 4, 245: 6, 248: 4, 250: 5, 258: 13, 262: 6, 263: 7, 264: 5, 267: 6, 270: 4, 272: 3, 273: 7, 287: 5, 289: 3, 291: 2, 299: 6, 300: 4, 304: 4, 309: 5, 314: 4, 315: 3, 320: 6, 323: 6, 327: 6, 328: 5, 329: 4, 330: 12, 334: 4, 335: 4, 341: 6, 342: 7, 347: 6, 348: 6, 350: 9, 351: 5, 352: 3, 353: 3, 354: 2, 358: 6, 365: 3, 366: 4, 369: 3, 371: 8, 372: 2, 376: 4, 384: 5, 385: 4, 386: 5, 387: 4, 392: 5, 393: 6, 396: 7, 397: 9, 398: 8, 402: 3} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 27 H-Label values and service parameters. "… flows OK ." b1a2789778493d7f985c44fa3950beda5685bd13 b1a2789778493d7f985c44fa3950beda5685bd13 draft-ietf-detnet-mpls c86b82b03c7ea6b5c48792faeda1ebc0f006b6443f53f2e1ebc75f77800e953a ['5b4633e7421bdcaf006fbab7560895ed013741152128081e90f940a2d441b284', 'e0272e86b037d5f460db4807aede2c02c9d02cb129d656c91aa723e14be8738c', 'c86b82b03c7ea6b5c48792faeda1ebc0f006b6443f53f2e1ebc75f77800e953a', '29ea94d06c6751fb47652496c82e1e9d54be60eb454edad2d4cc70305b7e7f6e'] A h-label values and service parameters. {38: 1, 26: 1, 6: 4, 79: 4, 90: 3, 51: 4, 130: 4, 62: 6, 85: 7, 68: 6, 35: 5, 110: 3, 91: 5, 114: 2, 97: 4, 31: 4, 13: 3, 67: 3, 124: 5, 98: 4, 54: 4, 127: 5, 8: 4, 96: 4, 64: 4, 30: 4, 61: 2, 55: 5, 15: 3, 52: 3, 129: 5, 115: 3, 84: 3, 76: 8, 87: 3, 131: 7, 102: 3, 113: 2, 27: 6, 99: 4, 36: 3, 24: 2, 53: 3, 72: 4} {96: 1, 97: 1, 1: 11, 4: 4, 9: 7, 10: 5, 15: 4, 24: 4, 25: 6, 26: 7, 27: 4, 39: 7, 43: 5, 49: 6, 50: 5, 58: 2, 59: 4, 64: 4, 69: 6, 81: 7, 82: 5, 86: 3, 100: 8, 108: 5, 109: 6, 110: 6, 111: 4, 114: 5, 115: 6, 116: 4, 118: 8, 119: 7, 120: 5, 121: 6, 122: 5, 123: 4, 124: 6, 128: 4, 129: 4, 130: 2, 132: 6, 136: 4, 145: 6, 151: 4, 152: 4, 154: 5, 156: 3, 161: 5, 162: 5, 165: 5, 168: 6, 169: 3, 172: 3, 180: 4, 184: 7, 187: 7, 188: 6, 191: 5, 194: 6, 202: 7, 203: 8, 206: 4, 207: 5, 215: 4, 217: 5, 218: 10, 220: 4, 221: 4, 222: 7, 224: 5, 227: 6, 229: 3, 234: 7, 235: 4, 241: 4, 242: 4, 243: 6, 244: 4, 245: 6, 248: 4, 250: 5, 258: 13, 262: 6, 263: 7, 264: 5, 267: 6, 270: 4, 272: 3, 273: 7, 287: 5, 289: 3, 291: 2, 299: 6, 300: 4, 304: 4, 309: 5, 314: 4, 315: 3, 320: 6, 323: 6, 327: 6, 328: 5, 329: 4, 330: 12, 334: 4, 335: 4, 341: 6, 342: 7, 347: 6, 348: 6, 350: 9, 351: 5, 352: 3, 353: 3, 354: 2, 358: 6, 365: 3, 366: 4, 369: 3, 371: 8, 372: 2, 376: 4, 384: 5, 385: 4, 386: 5, 387: 4, 392: 5, 393: 6, 396: 7, 397: 9, 398: 8, 402: 3} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 27 F-Label to H-LSP mappings. "… flows OK ." b1a2789778493d7f985c44fa3950beda5685bd13 b1a2789778493d7f985c44fa3950beda5685bd13 draft-ietf-detnet-mpls e0272e86b037d5f460db4807aede2c02c9d02cb129d656c91aa723e14be8738c ['5b4633e7421bdcaf006fbab7560895ed013741152128081e90f940a2d441b284', 'e0272e86b037d5f460db4807aede2c02c9d02cb129d656c91aa723e14be8738c', 'c86b82b03c7ea6b5c48792faeda1ebc0f006b6443f53f2e1ebc75f77800e953a', '29ea94d06c6751fb47652496c82e1e9d54be60eb454edad2d4cc70305b7e7f6e'] B f-label to h-lsp mappings. {38: 1, 26: 1, 6: 4, 79: 4, 90: 3, 51: 4, 130: 4, 62: 6, 85: 7, 68: 6, 35: 5, 110: 3, 91: 5, 114: 2, 97: 4, 31: 4, 13: 3, 67: 3, 124: 5, 98: 4, 54: 4, 127: 5, 8: 4, 96: 4, 64: 4, 30: 4, 61: 2, 55: 5, 15: 3, 52: 3, 129: 5, 115: 3, 84: 3, 76: 8, 87: 3, 131: 7, 102: 3, 113: 2, 27: 6, 99: 4, 36: 3, 24: 2, 53: 3, 72: 4} {96: 1, 97: 1, 1: 11, 4: 4, 9: 7, 10: 5, 15: 4, 24: 4, 25: 6, 26: 7, 27: 4, 39: 7, 43: 5, 49: 6, 50: 5, 58: 2, 59: 4, 64: 4, 69: 6, 81: 7, 82: 5, 86: 3, 100: 8, 108: 5, 109: 6, 110: 6, 111: 4, 114: 5, 115: 6, 116: 4, 118: 8, 119: 7, 120: 5, 121: 6, 122: 5, 123: 4, 124: 6, 128: 4, 129: 4, 130: 2, 132: 6, 136: 4, 145: 6, 151: 4, 152: 4, 154: 5, 156: 3, 161: 5, 162: 5, 165: 5, 168: 6, 169: 3, 172: 3, 180: 4, 184: 7, 187: 7, 188: 6, 191: 5, 194: 6, 202: 7, 203: 8, 206: 4, 207: 5, 215: 4, 217: 5, 218: 10, 220: 4, 221: 4, 222: 7, 224: 5, 227: 6, 229: 3, 234: 7, 235: 4, 241: 4, 242: 4, 243: 6, 244: 4, 245: 6, 248: 4, 250: 5, 258: 13, 262: 6, 263: 7, 264: 5, 267: 6, 270: 4, 272: 3, 273: 7, 287: 5, 289: 3, 291: 2, 299: 6, 300: 4, 304: 4, 309: 5, 314: 4, 315: 3, 320: 6, 323: 6, 327: 6, 328: 5, 329: 4, 330: 12, 334: 4, 335: 4, 341: 6, 342: 7, 347: 6, 348: 6, 350: 9, 351: 5, 352: 3, 353: 3, 354: 2, 358: 6, 365: 3, 366: 4, 369: 3, 371: 8, 372: 2, 376: 4, 384: 5, 385: 4, 386: 5, 387: 4, 392: 5, 393: 6, 396: 7, 397: 9, 398: 8, 402: 3} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 27 H-LSP label values and associated parameters. "… flows OK ." b1a2789778493d7f985c44fa3950beda5685bd13 b1a2789778493d7f985c44fa3950beda5685bd13 draft-ietf-detnet-mpls 29ea94d06c6751fb47652496c82e1e9d54be60eb454edad2d4cc70305b7e7f6e ['5b4633e7421bdcaf006fbab7560895ed013741152128081e90f940a2d441b284', 'e0272e86b037d5f460db4807aede2c02c9d02cb129d656c91aa723e14be8738c', 'c86b82b03c7ea6b5c48792faeda1ebc0f006b6443f53f2e1ebc75f77800e953a', '29ea94d06c6751fb47652496c82e1e9d54be60eb454edad2d4cc70305b7e7f6e'] B h-lsp label values and associated parameters. {38: 1, 26: 1, 6: 4, 79: 4, 90: 3, 51: 4, 130: 4, 62: 6, 85: 7, 68: 6, 35: 5, 110: 3, 91: 5, 114: 2, 97: 4, 31: 4, 13: 3, 67: 3, 124: 5, 98: 4, 54: 4, 127: 5, 8: 4, 96: 4, 64: 4, 30: 4, 61: 2, 55: 5, 15: 3, 52: 3, 129: 5, 115: 3, 84: 3, 76: 8, 87: 3, 131: 7, 102: 3, 113: 2, 27: 6, 99: 4, 36: 3, 24: 2, 53: 3, 72: 4} {96: 1, 97: 1, 1: 11, 4: 4, 9: 7, 10: 5, 15: 4, 24: 4, 25: 6, 26: 7, 27: 4, 39: 7, 43: 5, 49: 6, 50: 5, 58: 2, 59: 4, 64: 4, 69: 6, 81: 7, 82: 5, 86: 3, 100: 8, 108: 5, 109: 6, 110: 6, 111: 4, 114: 5, 115: 6, 116: 4, 118: 8, 119: 7, 120: 5, 121: 6, 122: 5, 123: 4, 124: 6, 128: 4, 129: 4, 130: 2, 132: 6, 136: 4, 145: 6, 151: 4, 152: 4, 154: 5, 156: 3, 161: 5, 162: 5, 165: 5, 168: 6, 169: 3, 172: 3, 180: 4, 184: 7, 187: 7, 188: 6, 191: 5, 194: 6, 202: 7, 203: 8, 206: 4, 207: 5, 215: 4, 217: 5, 218: 10, 220: 4, 221: 4, 222: 7, 224: 5, 227: 6, 229: 3, 234: 7, 235: 4, 241: 4, 242: 4, 243: 6, 244: 4, 245: 6, 248: 4, 250: 5, 258: 13, 262: 6, 263: 7, 264: 5, 267: 6, 270: 4, 272: 3, 273: 7, 287: 5, 289: 3, 291: 2, 299: 6, 300: 4, 304: 4, 309: 5, 314: 4, 315: 3, 320: 6, 323: 6, 327: 6, 328: 5, 329: 4, 330: 12, 334: 4, 335: 4, 341: 6, 342: 7, 347: 6, 348: 6, 350: 9, 351: 5, 352: 3, 353: 3, 354: 2, 358: 6, 365: 3, 366: 4, 369: 3, 371: 8, 372: 2, 376: 4, 384: 5, 385: 4, 386: 5, 387: 4, 392: 5, 393: 6, 396: 7, 397: 9, 398: 8, 402: 3} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 27 "If bandwidth reservations are used, the sum of the reservations should be the sum of all the individual reservations, in other words, the reservations should not create an over subscription of bandwidth reservation. If maximum delay bounds are used the system should ensure that the aggregate does not exceed the delay bounds of the component flows." "… flows OK ." b1a2789778493d7f985c44fa3950beda5685bd13 b1a2789778493d7f985c44fa3950beda5685bd13 draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework cb0a896212775790b72c6ab166cdad1e0451e7d5ea431da0ea0860916cda581a ['cb0a896212775790b72c6ab166cdad1e0451e7d5ea431da0ea0860916cda581a', '5a0d2766b652539bb9b04ed20679fff09a69e02d22e250fa0a177db3d886ff2b'] A "if bandwidth reservations are used, the sum of the reservations should be the sum of all the individual reservations, in other words, the reservations should not create an over subscription of bandwidth reservation. if maximum delay bounds are used the system should ensure that the aggregate does not exceed the delay bounds of the component flows." {6: 1, 55: 1, 79: 4, 90: 3, 51: 5, 130: 4, 62: 4, 85: 4, 68: 3, 35: 5, 110: 5, 91: 7, 114: 5, 97: 5, 31: 2, 13: 5, 67: 3, 38: 6, 26: 4, 124: 3, 98: 4, 54: 4, 127: 5, 8: 2, 96: 5, 64: 4, 30: 6, 61: 7, 27: 6, 15: 5, 52: 2, 129: 5, 115: 5, 84: 2, 76: 3, 87: 5, 131: 7, 102: 3, 113: 7, 99: 4, 36: 5, 24: 4, 53: 3, 72: 6} {161: 1, 243: 1, 1: 8, 4: 4, 9: 3, 10: 5, 15: 5, 24: 4, 25: 4, 26: 4, 27: 5, 39: 4, 43: 5, 49: 8, 50: 7, 58: 7, 59: 4, 64: 5, 69: 2, 81: 5, 82: 5, 86: 5, 96: 6, 97: 5, 100: 8, 108: 5, 109: 6, 110: 6, 111: 4, 114: 5, 115: 6, 116: 5, 118: 5, 119: 4, 120: 5, 121: 3, 122: 6, 123: 5, 124: 3, 128: 6, 129: 6, 130: 7, 132: 2, 136: 4, 145: 2, 147: 6, 151: 6, 152: 6, 154: 5, 156: 4, 162: 2, 165: 5, 168: 6, 169: 5, 172: 5, 180: 6, 184: 3, 187: 7, 188: 6, 191: 5, 194: 2, 202: 2, 203: 3, 206: 4, 207: 5, 215: 2, 217: 5, 218: 7, 220: 3, 221: 3, 222: 4, 224: 5, 227: 6, 229: 5, 234: 7, 235: 4, 241: 4, 242: 4, 244: 6, 245: 2, 248: 6, 250: 6, 258: 10, 262: 6, 263: 7, 264: 2, 267: 3, 270: 5, 272: 5, 273: 2, 287: 5, 289: 5, 291: 7, 299: 6, 300: 5, 304: 5, 309: 3, 314: 4, 315: 5, 320: 3, 327: 6, 328: 3, 329: 4, 330: 9, 334: 4, 335: 5, 341: 6, 342: 7, 347: 6, 348: 6, 350: 4, 351: 7, 352: 5, 353: 5, 354: 4, 358: 3, 365: 5, 366: 4, 369: 3, 371: 8, 372: 7, 376: 4, 384: 7, 385: 6, 386: 5, 387: 5, 392: 3, 393: 4, 396: 7, 397: 6, 398: 5, 402: 5} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 27 "If bandwidth reservations are used, the sum of the reservations should be the sum of all the individual reservations, in other words, the reservations should not create an over subscription of bandwidth reservation. If maximum delay bounds are used the system should ensure that the aggregate does not exceed the delay bounds of the individual flows." "… flows OK ." b1a2789778493d7f985c44fa3950beda5685bd13 b1a2789778493d7f985c44fa3950beda5685bd13 draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework 5a0d2766b652539bb9b04ed20679fff09a69e02d22e250fa0a177db3d886ff2b ['cb0a896212775790b72c6ab166cdad1e0451e7d5ea431da0ea0860916cda581a', '5a0d2766b652539bb9b04ed20679fff09a69e02d22e250fa0a177db3d886ff2b'] B "if bandwidth reservations are used, the sum of the reservations should be the sum of all the individual reservations, in other words, the reservations should not create an over subscription of bandwidth reservation. if maximum delay bounds are used the system should ensure that the aggregate does not exceed the delay bounds of the individual flows." {6: 1, 55: 1, 79: 4, 90: 3, 51: 5, 130: 4, 62: 4, 85: 4, 68: 3, 35: 5, 110: 5, 91: 7, 114: 5, 97: 5, 31: 2, 13: 5, 67: 3, 38: 6, 26: 4, 124: 3, 98: 4, 54: 4, 127: 5, 8: 2, 96: 5, 64: 4, 30: 6, 61: 7, 27: 6, 15: 5, 52: 2, 129: 5, 115: 5, 84: 2, 76: 3, 87: 5, 131: 7, 102: 3, 113: 7, 99: 4, 36: 5, 24: 4, 53: 3, 72: 6} {161: 1, 243: 1, 1: 8, 4: 4, 9: 3, 10: 5, 15: 5, 24: 4, 25: 4, 26: 4, 27: 5, 39: 4, 43: 5, 49: 8, 50: 7, 58: 7, 59: 4, 64: 5, 69: 2, 81: 5, 82: 5, 86: 5, 96: 6, 97: 5, 100: 8, 108: 5, 109: 6, 110: 6, 111: 4, 114: 5, 115: 6, 116: 5, 118: 5, 119: 4, 120: 5, 121: 3, 122: 6, 123: 5, 124: 3, 128: 6, 129: 6, 130: 7, 132: 2, 136: 4, 145: 2, 147: 6, 151: 6, 152: 6, 154: 5, 156: 4, 162: 2, 165: 5, 168: 6, 169: 5, 172: 5, 180: 6, 184: 3, 187: 7, 188: 6, 191: 5, 194: 2, 202: 2, 203: 3, 206: 4, 207: 5, 215: 2, 217: 5, 218: 7, 220: 3, 221: 3, 222: 4, 224: 5, 227: 6, 229: 5, 234: 7, 235: 4, 241: 4, 242: 4, 244: 6, 245: 2, 248: 6, 250: 6, 258: 10, 262: 6, 263: 7, 264: 2, 267: 3, 270: 5, 272: 5, 273: 2, 287: 5, 289: 5, 291: 7, 299: 6, 300: 5, 304: 5, 309: 3, 314: 4, 315: 5, 320: 3, 327: 6, 328: 3, 329: 4, 330: 9, 334: 4, 335: 5, 341: 6, 342: 7, 347: 6, 348: 6, 350: 4, 351: 7, 352: 5, 353: 5, 354: 4, 358: 3, 365: 5, 366: 4, 369: 3, 371: 8, 372: 7, 376: 4, 384: 7, 385: 6, 386: 5, 387: 5, 392: 3, 393: 4, 396: 7, 397: 6, 398: 5, 402: 5} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 27 "As described in I-D.ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework, the ability to aggregate individual flows, and their associated resource control, into a larger aggregate is an important technique for improving scaling by reducing the state per hop. DetNet IP data plane aggregation can take place within a single node, when that node maintains state about both the aggregated and component flows. It can also take place between nodes, where one node maintains state about only flow aggregates while the other node maintains state on all or a portion of the component flows. In either case, the management or control function that provisions the aggregate flows must ensure that adequate resources are allocated and configured to provide combined service requirements of the component flows. As DetNet is concerned about latency and jitter, more than just bandwidth needs to be considered." "… flows OK ." b1a2789778493d7f985c44fa3950beda5685bd13 b1a2789778493d7f985c44fa3950beda5685bd13 draft-ietf-detnet-ip a93634933fb52dfa43ad6798c0097118296fc629320f5073107b27671ece2332 ['a93634933fb52dfa43ad6798c0097118296fc629320f5073107b27671ece2332', '0a30f3fcf7564f1db82c6bd6c5060cde7e88b4e4b12ef4a85cdadfa14404b230'] A "as described in i-d.ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework, the ability to aggregate individual flows, and their associated resource control, into a larger aggregate is an important technique for improving scaling by reducing the state per hop. detnet ip data plane aggregation can take place within a single node, when that node maintains state about both the aggregated and component flows. it can also take place between nodes, where one node maintains state about only flow aggregates while the other node maintains state on all or a portion of the component flows. in either case, the management or control function that provisions the aggregate flows must ensure that adequate resources are allocated and configured to provide combined service requirements of the component flows. as detnet is concerned about latency and jitter, more than just bandwidth needs to be considered." {26: 1, 102: 2, 62: 4, 60: 3, 85: 3, 13: 2, 56: 2} {160: 1, 359: 2, 370: 4, 52: 3, 246: 3, 284: 2, 159: 2} {160, 259, 359, 370, 52, 246, 284, 159} 27 "As described in I-D.ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework, the ability to aggregate individual flows, and their associated resource control, into a larger aggregate is an important technique for improving scaling by reducing the state per hop. DetNet IP data plane aggregation can take place within a single node, when that node maintains state about both the aggregated and individual flows. It can also take place between nodes, where one node maintains state about only flow aggregates while the other node maintains state on all or a portion of the component flows. In either case, the management or control function that provisions the aggregate flows must ensure that adequate resources are allocated and configured to provide combined service requirements of the individual flows. As DetNet is concerned about latency and jitter, more than just bandwidth needs to be considered." "… flows OK ." b1a2789778493d7f985c44fa3950beda5685bd13 b1a2789778493d7f985c44fa3950beda5685bd13 draft-ietf-detnet-ip 0a30f3fcf7564f1db82c6bd6c5060cde7e88b4e4b12ef4a85cdadfa14404b230 ['a93634933fb52dfa43ad6798c0097118296fc629320f5073107b27671ece2332', '0a30f3fcf7564f1db82c6bd6c5060cde7e88b4e4b12ef4a85cdadfa14404b230'] B "as described in i-d.ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework, the ability to aggregate individual flows, and their associated resource control, into a larger aggregate is an important technique for improving scaling by reducing the state per hop. detnet ip data plane aggregation can take place within a single node, when that node maintains state about both the aggregated and individual flows. it can also take place between nodes, where one node maintains state about only flow aggregates while the other node maintains state on all or a portion of the component flows. in either case, the management or control function that provisions the aggregate flows must ensure that adequate resources are allocated and configured to provide combined service requirements of the individual flows. as detnet is concerned about latency and jitter, more than just bandwidth needs to be considered." {26: 1, 102: 2, 62: 4, 60: 3, 85: 3, 13: 2, 56: 2} {160: 1, 359: 2, 370: 4, 52: 3, 246: 3, 284: 2, 159: 2} {160, 259, 359, 370, 52, 246, 284, 159} 26 "The resource control and management aspects of aggregation (including the queuing/shaping/ policing implications) will be covered in other documents." "ip : references ip : untab and whitespace cleanup to keep xml2rfc happy ip : revise aggregation section , add alloc to sec 6 Let 's discuss these comments" 1033bab4058636b1c8e37b1e9eb27bab8fe98c1c 1033bab4058636b1c8e37b1e9eb27bab8fe98c1c draft-ietf-detnet-mpls c755e42b07c51d4cb69736f900ba2421799b10d6054d7497bafecb849ad0e6fd ['c755e42b07c51d4cb69736f900ba2421799b10d6054d7497bafecb849ad0e6fd', 'd72ba59586c35c7df47fff2a43ee9d3df7e899d449048f18a0e97529b4361622', '956926fe9f219ce702d3df24ad963a7a1894a1cd3f525da82fae2da329af8778'] A "the resource control and management aspects of aggregation (including the queuing/shaping/ policing implications) will be covered in other documents." {27: 1, 38: 2} {7: 1, 6: 2} {313, 6, 7} 26 "The ability to aggregate individual flows, and their associated resource control, into a larger aggregate is an important technique for improving scaling of control in the data, management and control planes. The DetNet data plane allows for the aggregation of DetNet flows, to improved scaling. There are two methods of supporting flow aggregation covered in this section." "ip : references ip : untab and whitespace cleanup to keep xml2rfc happy ip : revise aggregation section , add alloc to sec 6 Let 's discuss these comments" 1033bab4058636b1c8e37b1e9eb27bab8fe98c1c 1033bab4058636b1c8e37b1e9eb27bab8fe98c1c draft-ietf-detnet-mpls d72ba59586c35c7df47fff2a43ee9d3df7e899d449048f18a0e97529b4361622 ['c755e42b07c51d4cb69736f900ba2421799b10d6054d7497bafecb849ad0e6fd', 'd72ba59586c35c7df47fff2a43ee9d3df7e899d449048f18a0e97529b4361622', '956926fe9f219ce702d3df24ad963a7a1894a1cd3f525da82fae2da329af8778'] B "the ability to aggregate individual flows, and their associated resource control, into a larger aggregate is an important technique for improving scaling of control in the data, management and control planes. the detnet data plane allows for the aggregation of detnet flows, to improved scaling. there are two methods of supporting flow aggregation covered in this section." {27: 1, 38: 2} {7: 1, 6: 2} {313, 6, 7} 26 "The resource control and management aspects of aggregation (including the configuration of queuing, shaping, and policing) is the responsibility of the DetNet controller plane and will be covered in other documents. It is also the responsibility of the controller plane to ensure that consistent aggregation methods are used." "ip : references ip : untab and whitespace cleanup to keep xml2rfc happy ip : revise aggregation section , add alloc to sec 6 Let 's discuss these comments" 1033bab4058636b1c8e37b1e9eb27bab8fe98c1c 1033bab4058636b1c8e37b1e9eb27bab8fe98c1c draft-ietf-detnet-mpls 956926fe9f219ce702d3df24ad963a7a1894a1cd3f525da82fae2da329af8778 ['c755e42b07c51d4cb69736f900ba2421799b10d6054d7497bafecb849ad0e6fd', 'd72ba59586c35c7df47fff2a43ee9d3df7e899d449048f18a0e97529b4361622', '956926fe9f219ce702d3df24ad963a7a1894a1cd3f525da82fae2da329af8778'] B "the resource control and management aspects of aggregation (including the configuration of queuing, shaping, and policing) is the responsibility of the detnet controller plane and will be covered in other documents. it is also the responsibility of the controller plane to ensure that consistent aggregation methods are used." {27: 1, 38: 2} {7: 1, 6: 2} {313, 6, 7} 26 "DetNet flows forwarded via MPLS can leverage MPLS-TE's existing support for hierarchical LSPs (H-LSPs), see RFC4206. H-LSPs are typically used to aggregate control and resources, they may also be used to provide OAM or protection for the aggregated LSPs. Arbitrary levels of aggregation naturally falls out of the definition for hierarchy and the MPLS label stack RFC3032. DetNet nodes which support aggregation (LSP hierarchy) map one or more LSPs (labels) into and from an H-LSP. Both carried LSPs and H-LSPs may or may not use the TC field, i.e., L-LSPs or E-LSPs. Such nodes will need to ensure that traffic from aggregated LSPs are placed (shaped/policed/ enqueued) onto the H-LSPs in a fashion that ensures the required DetNet service is preserved." "ip : references ip : untab and whitespace cleanup to keep xml2rfc happy ip : revise aggregation section , add alloc to sec 6 Let 's discuss these comments" 1033bab4058636b1c8e37b1e9eb27bab8fe98c1c 1033bab4058636b1c8e37b1e9eb27bab8fe98c1c draft-ietf-detnet-mpls 47f9e0d14259d4102134fa631e45d474474ce97cf3feb46a04363c2ff7dcf729 ['c3d59bc9317889968221c7e0e8add8619dfa7d3b2d0377a1ee7474f423ecb6af', '47f9e0d14259d4102134fa631e45d474474ce97cf3feb46a04363c2ff7dcf729', '2f250535b5a29776950a0634b192b1717bd483132ba22f485429cb0467d15b89', '2c5e6f9e47d0429abfc8e3b6c34de6e8ed0b0fcc7fd8f86258b139592e5c1eec'] A "detnet flows forwarded via mpls can leverage mpls-te's existing support for hierarchical lsps (h-lsps), see rfc4206. h-lsps are typically used to aggregate control and resources, they may also be used to provide oam or protection for the aggregated lsps. arbitrary levels of aggregation naturally falls out of the definition for hierarchy and the mpls label stack rfc3032. detnet nodes which support aggregation (lsp hierarchy) map one or more lsps (labels) into and from an h-lsp. both carried lsps and h-lsps may or may not use the tc field, i.e., l-lsps or e-lsps. such nodes will need to ensure that traffic from aggregated lsps are placed (shaped/policed/ enqueued) onto the h-lsps in a fashion that ensures the required detnet service is preserved." {27: 1, 35: 2, 114: 3} {307: 1, 204: 2, 326: 3} {306, 307, 204, 326} 26 "Additional details of the traffic control capabilities needed at a DetNet-aware node may be covered in the new service descriptions mentioned above or in separate future documents. Controller plane mechanisms will also need to ensure that the service required on the aggregate flow (H-LSP or DSCP) are provided, which may include the discarding or remarking mentioned in the previous sections." "ip : references ip : untab and whitespace cleanup to keep xml2rfc happy ip : revise aggregation section , add alloc to sec 6 Let 's discuss these comments" 1033bab4058636b1c8e37b1e9eb27bab8fe98c1c 1033bab4058636b1c8e37b1e9eb27bab8fe98c1c draft-ietf-detnet-mpls 2c5e6f9e47d0429abfc8e3b6c34de6e8ed0b0fcc7fd8f86258b139592e5c1eec ['c3d59bc9317889968221c7e0e8add8619dfa7d3b2d0377a1ee7474f423ecb6af', '47f9e0d14259d4102134fa631e45d474474ce97cf3feb46a04363c2ff7dcf729', '2f250535b5a29776950a0634b192b1717bd483132ba22f485429cb0467d15b89', '2c5e6f9e47d0429abfc8e3b6c34de6e8ed0b0fcc7fd8f86258b139592e5c1eec'] A "additional details of the traffic control capabilities needed at a detnet-aware node may be covered in the new service descriptions mentioned above or in separate future documents. controller plane mechanisms will also need to ensure that the service required on the aggregate flow (h-lsp or dscp) are provided, which may include the discarding or remarking mentioned in the previous sections." {27: 1, 35: 2, 114: 3} {307: 1, 204: 2, 326: 3} {306, 307, 204, 326} 26 "DetNet flows forwarded via MPLS can leverage MPLS-TE's existing support for hierarchical LSPs (H-LSPs), see RFC4206. H-LSPs are typically used to aggregate control and resources, they may also be used to provide OAM or protection for the aggregated LSPs. Arbitrary levels of aggregation naturally falls out of the definition for hierarchy and the MPLS label stack RFC3032. DetNet nodes which support aggregation (LSP hierarchy) map one or more LSPs (labels) into and from an H-LSP. Both carried LSPs and H-LSPs may or may not use the TC field, i.e., L-LSPs or E-LSPs. Such nodes will need to ensure that component LSPs and H-LSPs receive the traffic treatement required to ensure the required DetNet service is preserved." "ip : references ip : untab and whitespace cleanup to keep xml2rfc happy ip : revise aggregation section , add alloc to sec 6 Let 's discuss these comments" 1033bab4058636b1c8e37b1e9eb27bab8fe98c1c 1033bab4058636b1c8e37b1e9eb27bab8fe98c1c draft-ietf-detnet-mpls c3d59bc9317889968221c7e0e8add8619dfa7d3b2d0377a1ee7474f423ecb6af ['c3d59bc9317889968221c7e0e8add8619dfa7d3b2d0377a1ee7474f423ecb6af', '47f9e0d14259d4102134fa631e45d474474ce97cf3feb46a04363c2ff7dcf729', '2f250535b5a29776950a0634b192b1717bd483132ba22f485429cb0467d15b89', '2c5e6f9e47d0429abfc8e3b6c34de6e8ed0b0fcc7fd8f86258b139592e5c1eec'] B "detnet flows forwarded via mpls can leverage mpls-te's existing support for hierarchical lsps (h-lsps), see rfc4206. h-lsps are typically used to aggregate control and resources, they may also be used to provide oam or protection for the aggregated lsps. arbitrary levels of aggregation naturally falls out of the definition for hierarchy and the mpls label stack rfc3032. detnet nodes which support aggregation (lsp hierarchy) map one or more lsps (labels) into and from an h-lsp. both carried lsps and h-lsps may or may not use the tc field, i.e., l-lsps or e-lsps. such nodes will need to ensure that component lsps and h-lsps receive the traffic treatement required to ensure the required detnet service is preserved." {27: 1, 35: 2, 114: 3} {307: 1, 204: 2, 326: 3} {306, 307, 204, 326} 26 "Additional details of the traffic control capabilities needed at a DetNet-aware node may be covered in the new service definitions mentioned above or in separate future documents. Controller plane mechanisms will also need to ensure that the service required on the aggregate flow are provided, which may include the discarding or remarking mentioned in the previous sections." "ip : references ip : untab and whitespace cleanup to keep xml2rfc happy ip : revise aggregation section , add alloc to sec 6 Let 's discuss these comments" 1033bab4058636b1c8e37b1e9eb27bab8fe98c1c 1033bab4058636b1c8e37b1e9eb27bab8fe98c1c draft-ietf-detnet-mpls 2f250535b5a29776950a0634b192b1717bd483132ba22f485429cb0467d15b89 ['c3d59bc9317889968221c7e0e8add8619dfa7d3b2d0377a1ee7474f423ecb6af', '47f9e0d14259d4102134fa631e45d474474ce97cf3feb46a04363c2ff7dcf729', '2f250535b5a29776950a0634b192b1717bd483132ba22f485429cb0467d15b89', '2c5e6f9e47d0429abfc8e3b6c34de6e8ed0b0fcc7fd8f86258b139592e5c1eec'] B "additional details of the traffic control capabilities needed at a detnet-aware node may be covered in the new service definitions mentioned above or in separate future documents. controller plane mechanisms will also need to ensure that the service required on the aggregate flow are provided, which may include the discarding or remarking mentioned in the previous sections." {27: 1, 35: 2, 114: 3} {307: 1, 204: 2, 326: 3} {306, 307, 204, 326} 26 "Another approach would be not to include a d-CW for the aggregated flow. This would be functionally similar to aggregation at the forwarding sub-layer using H-LSPs, but would confine knowledge of the aggregation to the DetNet layer. Such an approach shares the disadvantage that PREOF operations would not be possible. OAM operation in this mode is for further study." "ip : references ip : untab and whitespace cleanup to keep xml2rfc happy ip : revise aggregation section , add alloc to sec 6 Let 's discuss these comments" 1033bab4058636b1c8e37b1e9eb27bab8fe98c1c 1033bab4058636b1c8e37b1e9eb27bab8fe98c1c draft-ietf-detnet-mpls 3d821593154295730cbc7f149f9b11bf118e933e3c3872e431a76e6e6155623c ['abdc17c67745b4083db271e1502a303aa02277aeb8cd4f15c74b57faf93c7fe2', '3d821593154295730cbc7f149f9b11bf118e933e3c3872e431a76e6e6155623c'] A "another approach would be not to include a d-cw for the aggregated flow. this would be functionally similar to aggregation at the forwarding sub-layer using h-lsps, but would confine knowledge of the aggregation to the detnet layer. such an approach shares the disadvantage that preof operations would not be possible. oam operation in this mode is for further study." {27: 1, 38: 2, 35: 2, 113: 3} {266: 1, 205: 2, 94: 2, 95: 3} {265, 266, 205, 94, 95} 26 "As in the previous section, nodes supporting this type of aggregetation will need to ensure that component and aggregated flows receive the traffic treatement required to ensure the required DetNet service is preserved. Also, it is the controller plane's responsibility to to ensure that the service required on the aggregate flow are properly provisioned." "ip : references ip : untab and whitespace cleanup to keep xml2rfc happy ip : revise aggregation section , add alloc to sec 6 Let 's discuss these comments" 1033bab4058636b1c8e37b1e9eb27bab8fe98c1c 1033bab4058636b1c8e37b1e9eb27bab8fe98c1c draft-ietf-detnet-mpls abdc17c67745b4083db271e1502a303aa02277aeb8cd4f15c74b57faf93c7fe2 ['abdc17c67745b4083db271e1502a303aa02277aeb8cd4f15c74b57faf93c7fe2', '3d821593154295730cbc7f149f9b11bf118e933e3c3872e431a76e6e6155623c'] B "as in the previous section, nodes supporting this type of aggregetation will need to ensure that component and aggregated flows receive the traffic treatement required to ensure the required detnet service is preserved. also, it is the controller plane's responsibility to to ensure that the service required on the aggregate flow are properly provisioned." {27: 1, 38: 2, 35: 2, 113: 3} {266: 1, 205: 2, 94: 2, 95: 3} {265, 266, 205, 94, 95} 26 MPLS Service Label and d-CW labels at a DetNet end system. "ip : references ip : untab and whitespace cleanup to keep xml2rfc happy ip : revise aggregation section , add alloc to sec 6 Let 's discuss these comments" 1033bab4058636b1c8e37b1e9eb27bab8fe98c1c 1033bab4058636b1c8e37b1e9eb27bab8fe98c1c draft-ietf-detnet-mpls b6eb9b27803f3286e83df0b11c06a5f220e5d913bbabc9d230793dc4ee281aa3 ['3ef84f782267c0e0e968196f92f0e857d46f4f9ba7afbddce796cc8c50975a16', 'c86b82b03c7ea6b5c48792faeda1ebc0f006b6443f53f2e1ebc75f77800e953a', 'a27b19ebc5ff088972123df588cb54d27a8b2814df66c48326738a5967fce4f7', '5bbe3d686024848f24fe238d32a57ce72d50b8fbeebade01a3437d75950aab78', '133fcdd7e6b5af96f140855c428ebc7639ace6eecf3d1593f5a24b675e96214f', '959f68af8dfd80b8f76ac61803f842c5d5465c96fe9a54320df01a59d427bc74', 'da347c609aa36f0a6fe6d9365f7d3f5ef3502894bbb295f976fd4029d2dbed7c', '5b4633e7421bdcaf006fbab7560895ed013741152128081e90f940a2d441b284', 'f4580b2be48d5ff6900dff6228fd62d66670888dae4c7128179d74de159d034a', 'c99484d301684eba379e2eaab522e22872390f584d0977611a9b71cd4e36e2a9', 'd4d0f5b26265d5747482d4c8c93706edd735ad6b653327445de5a09a5dcc5c2b', 'b6eb9b27803f3286e83df0b11c06a5f220e5d913bbabc9d230793dc4ee281aa3', 'aaa439e1d7bff43da825ea3503724aec00bcdfe7bc48704ec73d2c25140399b4'] A mpls service label and d-cw labels at a detnet end system. {38: 1, 24: 1, 27: 1, 6: 3, 79: 3, 90: 2, 51: 3, 130: 3, 62: 5, 85: 6, 68: 5, 35: 4, 110: 2, 91: 4, 114: 2, 97: 3, 31: 3, 13: 2, 67: 2, 124: 4, 98: 3, 54: 3, 127: 4, 26: 6, 8: 3, 96: 3, 64: 3, 30: 3, 61: 2, 55: 4, 15: 2, 52: 2, 129: 4, 115: 2, 84: 2, 76: 7, 87: 2, 131: 6, 102: 2, 113: 2, 99: 3, 36: 2, 53: 2, 72: 3} {96: 1, 354: 1, 147: 1, 1: 10, 4: 3, 9: 6, 10: 4, 15: 3, 24: 3, 25: 5, 26: 6, 27: 3, 39: 6, 43: 4, 49: 5, 50: 4, 58: 2, 59: 3, 64: 3, 69: 5, 81: 6, 82: 4, 86: 2, 100: 7, 108: 4, 109: 5, 110: 5, 111: 3, 114: 4, 115: 5, 116: 3, 118: 7, 119: 6, 120: 4, 121: 5, 122: 4, 123: 3, 124: 5, 128: 3, 129: 3, 130: 2, 132: 5, 136: 3, 145: 5, 151: 3, 152: 3, 154: 4, 156: 2, 161: 4, 162: 4, 165: 4, 168: 5, 169: 2, 172: 2, 180: 3, 184: 6, 187: 6, 188: 5, 191: 4, 194: 5, 202: 6, 203: 7, 206: 3, 207: 4, 215: 3, 217: 4, 218: 9, 220: 3, 221: 3, 222: 6, 224: 4, 227: 5, 229: 2, 234: 6, 235: 3, 241: 3, 242: 3, 243: 5, 244: 3, 245: 5, 248: 3, 250: 4, 258: 12, 262: 5, 263: 6, 264: 4, 267: 5, 270: 3, 272: 2, 273: 6, 287: 4, 289: 2, 291: 2, 299: 5, 300: 3, 304: 3, 309: 4, 314: 3, 315: 2, 320: 5, 323: 5, 327: 5, 328: 4, 329: 3, 330: 11, 334: 3, 335: 3, 341: 5, 342: 6, 347: 5, 348: 5, 350: 8, 351: 4, 352: 2, 353: 2, 358: 5, 365: 2, 366: 3, 369: 2, 371: 7, 372: 2, 376: 3, 384: 4, 385: 3, 386: 4, 387: 3, 392: 4, 393: 5, 396: 6, 397: 8, 398: 7, 402: 2} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 26 "MPLS Service Label and d-CW in the context of one or more MPLS Forwarding Labels at any DetNet aware device along the path." "ip : references ip : untab and whitespace cleanup to keep xml2rfc happy ip : revise aggregation section , add alloc to sec 6 Let 's discuss these comments" 1033bab4058636b1c8e37b1e9eb27bab8fe98c1c 1033bab4058636b1c8e37b1e9eb27bab8fe98c1c draft-ietf-detnet-mpls a27b19ebc5ff088972123df588cb54d27a8b2814df66c48326738a5967fce4f7 ['3ef84f782267c0e0e968196f92f0e857d46f4f9ba7afbddce796cc8c50975a16', 'c86b82b03c7ea6b5c48792faeda1ebc0f006b6443f53f2e1ebc75f77800e953a', 'a27b19ebc5ff088972123df588cb54d27a8b2814df66c48326738a5967fce4f7', '5bbe3d686024848f24fe238d32a57ce72d50b8fbeebade01a3437d75950aab78', '133fcdd7e6b5af96f140855c428ebc7639ace6eecf3d1593f5a24b675e96214f', '959f68af8dfd80b8f76ac61803f842c5d5465c96fe9a54320df01a59d427bc74', 'da347c609aa36f0a6fe6d9365f7d3f5ef3502894bbb295f976fd4029d2dbed7c', '5b4633e7421bdcaf006fbab7560895ed013741152128081e90f940a2d441b284', 'f4580b2be48d5ff6900dff6228fd62d66670888dae4c7128179d74de159d034a', 'c99484d301684eba379e2eaab522e22872390f584d0977611a9b71cd4e36e2a9', 'd4d0f5b26265d5747482d4c8c93706edd735ad6b653327445de5a09a5dcc5c2b', 'b6eb9b27803f3286e83df0b11c06a5f220e5d913bbabc9d230793dc4ee281aa3', 'aaa439e1d7bff43da825ea3503724aec00bcdfe7bc48704ec73d2c25140399b4'] A "mpls service label and d-cw in the context of one or more mpls forwarding labels at any detnet aware device along the path." {38: 1, 24: 1, 27: 1, 6: 3, 79: 3, 90: 2, 51: 3, 130: 3, 62: 5, 85: 6, 68: 5, 35: 4, 110: 2, 91: 4, 114: 2, 97: 3, 31: 3, 13: 2, 67: 2, 124: 4, 98: 3, 54: 3, 127: 4, 26: 6, 8: 3, 96: 3, 64: 3, 30: 3, 61: 2, 55: 4, 15: 2, 52: 2, 129: 4, 115: 2, 84: 2, 76: 7, 87: 2, 131: 6, 102: 2, 113: 2, 99: 3, 36: 2, 53: 2, 72: 3} {96: 1, 354: 1, 147: 1, 1: 10, 4: 3, 9: 6, 10: 4, 15: 3, 24: 3, 25: 5, 26: 6, 27: 3, 39: 6, 43: 4, 49: 5, 50: 4, 58: 2, 59: 3, 64: 3, 69: 5, 81: 6, 82: 4, 86: 2, 100: 7, 108: 4, 109: 5, 110: 5, 111: 3, 114: 4, 115: 5, 116: 3, 118: 7, 119: 6, 120: 4, 121: 5, 122: 4, 123: 3, 124: 5, 128: 3, 129: 3, 130: 2, 132: 5, 136: 3, 145: 5, 151: 3, 152: 3, 154: 4, 156: 2, 161: 4, 162: 4, 165: 4, 168: 5, 169: 2, 172: 2, 180: 3, 184: 6, 187: 6, 188: 5, 191: 4, 194: 5, 202: 6, 203: 7, 206: 3, 207: 4, 215: 3, 217: 4, 218: 9, 220: 3, 221: 3, 222: 6, 224: 4, 227: 5, 229: 2, 234: 6, 235: 3, 241: 3, 242: 3, 243: 5, 244: 3, 245: 5, 248: 3, 250: 4, 258: 12, 262: 5, 263: 6, 264: 4, 267: 5, 270: 3, 272: 2, 273: 6, 287: 4, 289: 2, 291: 2, 299: 5, 300: 3, 304: 3, 309: 4, 314: 3, 315: 2, 320: 5, 323: 5, 327: 5, 328: 4, 329: 3, 330: 11, 334: 3, 335: 3, 341: 5, 342: 6, 347: 5, 348: 5, 350: 8, 351: 4, 352: 2, 353: 2, 358: 5, 365: 2, 366: 3, 369: 2, 371: 7, 372: 2, 376: 3, 384: 4, 385: 3, 386: 4, 387: 3, 392: 4, 393: 5, 396: 6, 397: 8, 398: 7, 402: 2} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 26 "Any aggregate flow by one or more MPLS Forwarding Labels at any DetNet aware device along the path." "ip : references ip : untab and whitespace cleanup to keep xml2rfc happy ip : revise aggregation section , add alloc to sec 6 Let 's discuss these comments" 1033bab4058636b1c8e37b1e9eb27bab8fe98c1c 1033bab4058636b1c8e37b1e9eb27bab8fe98c1c draft-ietf-detnet-mpls aaa439e1d7bff43da825ea3503724aec00bcdfe7bc48704ec73d2c25140399b4 ['3ef84f782267c0e0e968196f92f0e857d46f4f9ba7afbddce796cc8c50975a16', 'c86b82b03c7ea6b5c48792faeda1ebc0f006b6443f53f2e1ebc75f77800e953a', 'a27b19ebc5ff088972123df588cb54d27a8b2814df66c48326738a5967fce4f7', '5bbe3d686024848f24fe238d32a57ce72d50b8fbeebade01a3437d75950aab78', '133fcdd7e6b5af96f140855c428ebc7639ace6eecf3d1593f5a24b675e96214f', '959f68af8dfd80b8f76ac61803f842c5d5465c96fe9a54320df01a59d427bc74', 'da347c609aa36f0a6fe6d9365f7d3f5ef3502894bbb295f976fd4029d2dbed7c', '5b4633e7421bdcaf006fbab7560895ed013741152128081e90f940a2d441b284', 'f4580b2be48d5ff6900dff6228fd62d66670888dae4c7128179d74de159d034a', 'c99484d301684eba379e2eaab522e22872390f584d0977611a9b71cd4e36e2a9', 'd4d0f5b26265d5747482d4c8c93706edd735ad6b653327445de5a09a5dcc5c2b', 'b6eb9b27803f3286e83df0b11c06a5f220e5d913bbabc9d230793dc4ee281aa3', 'aaa439e1d7bff43da825ea3503724aec00bcdfe7bc48704ec73d2c25140399b4'] A "any aggregate flow by one or more mpls forwarding labels at any detnet aware device along the path." {38: 1, 24: 1, 27: 1, 6: 3, 79: 3, 90: 2, 51: 3, 130: 3, 62: 5, 85: 6, 68: 5, 35: 4, 110: 2, 91: 4, 114: 2, 97: 3, 31: 3, 13: 2, 67: 2, 124: 4, 98: 3, 54: 3, 127: 4, 26: 6, 8: 3, 96: 3, 64: 3, 30: 3, 61: 2, 55: 4, 15: 2, 52: 2, 129: 4, 115: 2, 84: 2, 76: 7, 87: 2, 131: 6, 102: 2, 113: 2, 99: 3, 36: 2, 53: 2, 72: 3} {96: 1, 354: 1, 147: 1, 1: 10, 4: 3, 9: 6, 10: 4, 15: 3, 24: 3, 25: 5, 26: 6, 27: 3, 39: 6, 43: 4, 49: 5, 50: 4, 58: 2, 59: 3, 64: 3, 69: 5, 81: 6, 82: 4, 86: 2, 100: 7, 108: 4, 109: 5, 110: 5, 111: 3, 114: 4, 115: 5, 116: 3, 118: 7, 119: 6, 120: 4, 121: 5, 122: 4, 123: 3, 124: 5, 128: 3, 129: 3, 130: 2, 132: 5, 136: 3, 145: 5, 151: 3, 152: 3, 154: 4, 156: 2, 161: 4, 162: 4, 165: 4, 168: 5, 169: 2, 172: 2, 180: 3, 184: 6, 187: 6, 188: 5, 191: 4, 194: 5, 202: 6, 203: 7, 206: 3, 207: 4, 215: 3, 217: 4, 218: 9, 220: 3, 221: 3, 222: 6, 224: 4, 227: 5, 229: 2, 234: 6, 235: 3, 241: 3, 242: 3, 243: 5, 244: 3, 245: 5, 248: 3, 250: 4, 258: 12, 262: 5, 263: 6, 264: 4, 267: 5, 270: 3, 272: 2, 273: 6, 287: 4, 289: 2, 291: 2, 299: 5, 300: 3, 304: 3, 309: 4, 314: 3, 315: 2, 320: 5, 323: 5, 327: 5, 328: 4, 329: 3, 330: 11, 334: 3, 335: 3, 341: 5, 342: 6, 347: 5, 348: 5, 350: 8, 351: 4, 352: 2, 353: 2, 358: 5, 365: 2, 366: 3, 369: 2, 371: 7, 372: 2, 376: 3, 384: 4, 385: 3, 386: 4, 387: 3, 392: 4, 393: 5, 396: 6, 397: 8, 398: 7, 402: 2} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 26 "Any other DetNet flow information for example IP Flow Identification beyond the MPLS service label as specified in I- D.ietf-detnet-ip at a DetNet aware device." "ip : references ip : untab and whitespace cleanup to keep xml2rfc happy ip : revise aggregation section , add alloc to sec 6 Let 's discuss these comments" 1033bab4058636b1c8e37b1e9eb27bab8fe98c1c 1033bab4058636b1c8e37b1e9eb27bab8fe98c1c draft-ietf-detnet-mpls 133fcdd7e6b5af96f140855c428ebc7639ace6eecf3d1593f5a24b675e96214f ['3ef84f782267c0e0e968196f92f0e857d46f4f9ba7afbddce796cc8c50975a16', 'c86b82b03c7ea6b5c48792faeda1ebc0f006b6443f53f2e1ebc75f77800e953a', 'a27b19ebc5ff088972123df588cb54d27a8b2814df66c48326738a5967fce4f7', '5bbe3d686024848f24fe238d32a57ce72d50b8fbeebade01a3437d75950aab78', '133fcdd7e6b5af96f140855c428ebc7639ace6eecf3d1593f5a24b675e96214f', '959f68af8dfd80b8f76ac61803f842c5d5465c96fe9a54320df01a59d427bc74', 'da347c609aa36f0a6fe6d9365f7d3f5ef3502894bbb295f976fd4029d2dbed7c', '5b4633e7421bdcaf006fbab7560895ed013741152128081e90f940a2d441b284', 'f4580b2be48d5ff6900dff6228fd62d66670888dae4c7128179d74de159d034a', 'c99484d301684eba379e2eaab522e22872390f584d0977611a9b71cd4e36e2a9', 'd4d0f5b26265d5747482d4c8c93706edd735ad6b653327445de5a09a5dcc5c2b', 'b6eb9b27803f3286e83df0b11c06a5f220e5d913bbabc9d230793dc4ee281aa3', 'aaa439e1d7bff43da825ea3503724aec00bcdfe7bc48704ec73d2c25140399b4'] A "any other detnet flow information for example ip flow identification beyond the mpls service label as specified in i- d.ietf-detnet-ip at a detnet aware device." {38: 1, 24: 1, 27: 1, 6: 3, 79: 3, 90: 2, 51: 3, 130: 3, 62: 5, 85: 6, 68: 5, 35: 4, 110: 2, 91: 4, 114: 2, 97: 3, 31: 3, 13: 2, 67: 2, 124: 4, 98: 3, 54: 3, 127: 4, 26: 6, 8: 3, 96: 3, 64: 3, 30: 3, 61: 2, 55: 4, 15: 2, 52: 2, 129: 4, 115: 2, 84: 2, 76: 7, 87: 2, 131: 6, 102: 2, 113: 2, 99: 3, 36: 2, 53: 2, 72: 3} {96: 1, 354: 1, 147: 1, 1: 10, 4: 3, 9: 6, 10: 4, 15: 3, 24: 3, 25: 5, 26: 6, 27: 3, 39: 6, 43: 4, 49: 5, 50: 4, 58: 2, 59: 3, 64: 3, 69: 5, 81: 6, 82: 4, 86: 2, 100: 7, 108: 4, 109: 5, 110: 5, 111: 3, 114: 4, 115: 5, 116: 3, 118: 7, 119: 6, 120: 4, 121: 5, 122: 4, 123: 3, 124: 5, 128: 3, 129: 3, 130: 2, 132: 5, 136: 3, 145: 5, 151: 3, 152: 3, 154: 4, 156: 2, 161: 4, 162: 4, 165: 4, 168: 5, 169: 2, 172: 2, 180: 3, 184: 6, 187: 6, 188: 5, 191: 4, 194: 5, 202: 6, 203: 7, 206: 3, 207: 4, 215: 3, 217: 4, 218: 9, 220: 3, 221: 3, 222: 6, 224: 4, 227: 5, 229: 2, 234: 6, 235: 3, 241: 3, 242: 3, 243: 5, 244: 3, 245: 5, 248: 3, 250: 4, 258: 12, 262: 5, 263: 6, 264: 4, 267: 5, 270: 3, 272: 2, 273: 6, 287: 4, 289: 2, 291: 2, 299: 5, 300: 3, 304: 3, 309: 4, 314: 3, 315: 2, 320: 5, 323: 5, 327: 5, 328: 4, 329: 3, 330: 11, 334: 3, 335: 3, 341: 5, 342: 6, 347: 5, 348: 5, 350: 8, 351: 4, 352: 2, 353: 2, 358: 5, 365: 2, 366: 3, 369: 2, 371: 7, 372: 2, 376: 3, 384: 4, 385: 3, 386: 4, 387: 3, 392: 4, 393: 5, 396: 6, 397: 8, 398: 7, 402: 2} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 26 Each flow's service parameters and S-Label. "ip : references ip : untab and whitespace cleanup to keep xml2rfc happy ip : revise aggregation section , add alloc to sec 6 Let 's discuss these comments" 1033bab4058636b1c8e37b1e9eb27bab8fe98c1c 1033bab4058636b1c8e37b1e9eb27bab8fe98c1c draft-ietf-detnet-mpls 5bbe3d686024848f24fe238d32a57ce72d50b8fbeebade01a3437d75950aab78 ['3ef84f782267c0e0e968196f92f0e857d46f4f9ba7afbddce796cc8c50975a16', 'c86b82b03c7ea6b5c48792faeda1ebc0f006b6443f53f2e1ebc75f77800e953a', 'a27b19ebc5ff088972123df588cb54d27a8b2814df66c48326738a5967fce4f7', '5bbe3d686024848f24fe238d32a57ce72d50b8fbeebade01a3437d75950aab78', '133fcdd7e6b5af96f140855c428ebc7639ace6eecf3d1593f5a24b675e96214f', '959f68af8dfd80b8f76ac61803f842c5d5465c96fe9a54320df01a59d427bc74', 'da347c609aa36f0a6fe6d9365f7d3f5ef3502894bbb295f976fd4029d2dbed7c', '5b4633e7421bdcaf006fbab7560895ed013741152128081e90f940a2d441b284', 'f4580b2be48d5ff6900dff6228fd62d66670888dae4c7128179d74de159d034a', 'c99484d301684eba379e2eaab522e22872390f584d0977611a9b71cd4e36e2a9', 'd4d0f5b26265d5747482d4c8c93706edd735ad6b653327445de5a09a5dcc5c2b', 'b6eb9b27803f3286e83df0b11c06a5f220e5d913bbabc9d230793dc4ee281aa3', 'aaa439e1d7bff43da825ea3503724aec00bcdfe7bc48704ec73d2c25140399b4'] B each flow's service parameters and s-label. {38: 1, 24: 1, 27: 1, 6: 3, 79: 3, 90: 2, 51: 3, 130: 3, 62: 5, 85: 6, 68: 5, 35: 4, 110: 2, 91: 4, 114: 2, 97: 3, 31: 3, 13: 2, 67: 2, 124: 4, 98: 3, 54: 3, 127: 4, 26: 6, 8: 3, 96: 3, 64: 3, 30: 3, 61: 2, 55: 4, 15: 2, 52: 2, 129: 4, 115: 2, 84: 2, 76: 7, 87: 2, 131: 6, 102: 2, 113: 2, 99: 3, 36: 2, 53: 2, 72: 3} {96: 1, 354: 1, 147: 1, 1: 10, 4: 3, 9: 6, 10: 4, 15: 3, 24: 3, 25: 5, 26: 6, 27: 3, 39: 6, 43: 4, 49: 5, 50: 4, 58: 2, 59: 3, 64: 3, 69: 5, 81: 6, 82: 4, 86: 2, 100: 7, 108: 4, 109: 5, 110: 5, 111: 3, 114: 4, 115: 5, 116: 3, 118: 7, 119: 6, 120: 4, 121: 5, 122: 4, 123: 3, 124: 5, 128: 3, 129: 3, 130: 2, 132: 5, 136: 3, 145: 5, 151: 3, 152: 3, 154: 4, 156: 2, 161: 4, 162: 4, 165: 4, 168: 5, 169: 2, 172: 2, 180: 3, 184: 6, 187: 6, 188: 5, 191: 4, 194: 5, 202: 6, 203: 7, 206: 3, 207: 4, 215: 3, 217: 4, 218: 9, 220: 3, 221: 3, 222: 6, 224: 4, 227: 5, 229: 2, 234: 6, 235: 3, 241: 3, 242: 3, 243: 5, 244: 3, 245: 5, 248: 3, 250: 4, 258: 12, 262: 5, 263: 6, 264: 4, 267: 5, 270: 3, 272: 2, 273: 6, 287: 4, 289: 2, 291: 2, 299: 5, 300: 3, 304: 3, 309: 4, 314: 3, 315: 2, 320: 5, 323: 5, 327: 5, 328: 4, 329: 3, 330: 11, 334: 3, 335: 3, 341: 5, 342: 6, 347: 5, 348: 5, 350: 8, 351: 4, 352: 2, 353: 2, 358: 5, 365: 2, 366: 3, 369: 2, 371: 7, 372: 2, 376: 3, 384: 4, 385: 3, 386: 4, 387: 3, 392: 4, 393: 5, 396: 6, 397: 8, 398: 7, 402: 2} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 26 The PREOF functions to be supported for each S-Label. "ip : references ip : untab and whitespace cleanup to keep xml2rfc happy ip : revise aggregation section , add alloc to sec 6 Let 's discuss these comments" 1033bab4058636b1c8e37b1e9eb27bab8fe98c1c 1033bab4058636b1c8e37b1e9eb27bab8fe98c1c draft-ietf-detnet-mpls 3ef84f782267c0e0e968196f92f0e857d46f4f9ba7afbddce796cc8c50975a16 ['3ef84f782267c0e0e968196f92f0e857d46f4f9ba7afbddce796cc8c50975a16', 'c86b82b03c7ea6b5c48792faeda1ebc0f006b6443f53f2e1ebc75f77800e953a', 'a27b19ebc5ff088972123df588cb54d27a8b2814df66c48326738a5967fce4f7', '5bbe3d686024848f24fe238d32a57ce72d50b8fbeebade01a3437d75950aab78', '133fcdd7e6b5af96f140855c428ebc7639ace6eecf3d1593f5a24b675e96214f', '959f68af8dfd80b8f76ac61803f842c5d5465c96fe9a54320df01a59d427bc74', 'da347c609aa36f0a6fe6d9365f7d3f5ef3502894bbb295f976fd4029d2dbed7c', '5b4633e7421bdcaf006fbab7560895ed013741152128081e90f940a2d441b284', 'f4580b2be48d5ff6900dff6228fd62d66670888dae4c7128179d74de159d034a', 'c99484d301684eba379e2eaab522e22872390f584d0977611a9b71cd4e36e2a9', 'd4d0f5b26265d5747482d4c8c93706edd735ad6b653327445de5a09a5dcc5c2b', 'b6eb9b27803f3286e83df0b11c06a5f220e5d913bbabc9d230793dc4ee281aa3', 'aaa439e1d7bff43da825ea3503724aec00bcdfe7bc48704ec73d2c25140399b4'] B the preof functions to be supported for each s-label. {38: 1, 24: 1, 27: 1, 6: 3, 79: 3, 90: 2, 51: 3, 130: 3, 62: 5, 85: 6, 68: 5, 35: 4, 110: 2, 91: 4, 114: 2, 97: 3, 31: 3, 13: 2, 67: 2, 124: 4, 98: 3, 54: 3, 127: 4, 26: 6, 8: 3, 96: 3, 64: 3, 30: 3, 61: 2, 55: 4, 15: 2, 52: 2, 129: 4, 115: 2, 84: 2, 76: 7, 87: 2, 131: 6, 102: 2, 113: 2, 99: 3, 36: 2, 53: 2, 72: 3} {96: 1, 354: 1, 147: 1, 1: 10, 4: 3, 9: 6, 10: 4, 15: 3, 24: 3, 25: 5, 26: 6, 27: 3, 39: 6, 43: 4, 49: 5, 50: 4, 58: 2, 59: 3, 64: 3, 69: 5, 81: 6, 82: 4, 86: 2, 100: 7, 108: 4, 109: 5, 110: 5, 111: 3, 114: 4, 115: 5, 116: 3, 118: 7, 119: 6, 120: 4, 121: 5, 122: 4, 123: 3, 124: 5, 128: 3, 129: 3, 130: 2, 132: 5, 136: 3, 145: 5, 151: 3, 152: 3, 154: 4, 156: 2, 161: 4, 162: 4, 165: 4, 168: 5, 169: 2, 172: 2, 180: 3, 184: 6, 187: 6, 188: 5, 191: 4, 194: 5, 202: 6, 203: 7, 206: 3, 207: 4, 215: 3, 217: 4, 218: 9, 220: 3, 221: 3, 222: 6, 224: 4, 227: 5, 229: 2, 234: 6, 235: 3, 241: 3, 242: 3, 243: 5, 244: 3, 245: 5, 248: 3, 250: 4, 258: 12, 262: 5, 263: 6, 264: 4, 267: 5, 270: 3, 272: 2, 273: 6, 287: 4, 289: 2, 291: 2, 299: 5, 300: 3, 304: 3, 309: 4, 314: 3, 315: 2, 320: 5, 323: 5, 327: 5, 328: 4, 329: 3, 330: 11, 334: 3, 335: 3, 341: 5, 342: 6, 347: 5, 348: 5, 350: 8, 351: 4, 352: 2, 353: 2, 358: 5, 365: 2, 366: 3, 369: 2, 371: 7, 372: 2, 376: 3, 384: 4, 385: 3, 386: 4, 387: 3, 392: 4, 393: 5, 396: 6, 397: 8, 398: 7, 402: 2} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 26 The mapping of each S-Label to an F-Label stack. "ip : references ip : untab and whitespace cleanup to keep xml2rfc happy ip : revise aggregation section , add alloc to sec 6 Let 's discuss these comments" 1033bab4058636b1c8e37b1e9eb27bab8fe98c1c 1033bab4058636b1c8e37b1e9eb27bab8fe98c1c draft-ietf-detnet-mpls d4d0f5b26265d5747482d4c8c93706edd735ad6b653327445de5a09a5dcc5c2b ['3ef84f782267c0e0e968196f92f0e857d46f4f9ba7afbddce796cc8c50975a16', 'c86b82b03c7ea6b5c48792faeda1ebc0f006b6443f53f2e1ebc75f77800e953a', 'a27b19ebc5ff088972123df588cb54d27a8b2814df66c48326738a5967fce4f7', '5bbe3d686024848f24fe238d32a57ce72d50b8fbeebade01a3437d75950aab78', '133fcdd7e6b5af96f140855c428ebc7639ace6eecf3d1593f5a24b675e96214f', '959f68af8dfd80b8f76ac61803f842c5d5465c96fe9a54320df01a59d427bc74', 'da347c609aa36f0a6fe6d9365f7d3f5ef3502894bbb295f976fd4029d2dbed7c', '5b4633e7421bdcaf006fbab7560895ed013741152128081e90f940a2d441b284', 'f4580b2be48d5ff6900dff6228fd62d66670888dae4c7128179d74de159d034a', 'c99484d301684eba379e2eaab522e22872390f584d0977611a9b71cd4e36e2a9', 'd4d0f5b26265d5747482d4c8c93706edd735ad6b653327445de5a09a5dcc5c2b', 'b6eb9b27803f3286e83df0b11c06a5f220e5d913bbabc9d230793dc4ee281aa3', 'aaa439e1d7bff43da825ea3503724aec00bcdfe7bc48704ec73d2c25140399b4'] B the mapping of each s-label to an f-label stack. {38: 1, 24: 1, 27: 1, 6: 3, 79: 3, 90: 2, 51: 3, 130: 3, 62: 5, 85: 6, 68: 5, 35: 4, 110: 2, 91: 4, 114: 2, 97: 3, 31: 3, 13: 2, 67: 2, 124: 4, 98: 3, 54: 3, 127: 4, 26: 6, 8: 3, 96: 3, 64: 3, 30: 3, 61: 2, 55: 4, 15: 2, 52: 2, 129: 4, 115: 2, 84: 2, 76: 7, 87: 2, 131: 6, 102: 2, 113: 2, 99: 3, 36: 2, 53: 2, 72: 3} {96: 1, 354: 1, 147: 1, 1: 10, 4: 3, 9: 6, 10: 4, 15: 3, 24: 3, 25: 5, 26: 6, 27: 3, 39: 6, 43: 4, 49: 5, 50: 4, 58: 2, 59: 3, 64: 3, 69: 5, 81: 6, 82: 4, 86: 2, 100: 7, 108: 4, 109: 5, 110: 5, 111: 3, 114: 4, 115: 5, 116: 3, 118: 7, 119: 6, 120: 4, 121: 5, 122: 4, 123: 3, 124: 5, 128: 3, 129: 3, 130: 2, 132: 5, 136: 3, 145: 5, 151: 3, 152: 3, 154: 4, 156: 2, 161: 4, 162: 4, 165: 4, 168: 5, 169: 2, 172: 2, 180: 3, 184: 6, 187: 6, 188: 5, 191: 4, 194: 5, 202: 6, 203: 7, 206: 3, 207: 4, 215: 3, 217: 4, 218: 9, 220: 3, 221: 3, 222: 6, 224: 4, 227: 5, 229: 2, 234: 6, 235: 3, 241: 3, 242: 3, 243: 5, 244: 3, 245: 5, 248: 3, 250: 4, 258: 12, 262: 5, 263: 6, 264: 4, 267: 5, 270: 3, 272: 2, 273: 6, 287: 4, 289: 2, 291: 2, 299: 5, 300: 3, 304: 3, 309: 4, 314: 3, 315: 2, 320: 5, 323: 5, 327: 5, 328: 4, 329: 3, 330: 11, 334: 3, 335: 3, 341: 5, 342: 6, 347: 5, 348: 5, 350: 8, 351: 4, 352: 2, 353: 2, 358: 5, 365: 2, 366: 3, 369: 2, 371: 7, 372: 2, 376: 3, 384: 4, 385: 3, 386: 4, 387: 3, 392: 4, 393: 5, 396: 6, 397: 8, 398: 7, 402: 2} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 26 S-Labels to A-Label mappings. "ip : references ip : untab and whitespace cleanup to keep xml2rfc happy ip : revise aggregation section , add alloc to sec 6 Let 's discuss these comments" 1033bab4058636b1c8e37b1e9eb27bab8fe98c1c 1033bab4058636b1c8e37b1e9eb27bab8fe98c1c draft-ietf-detnet-mpls 959f68af8dfd80b8f76ac61803f842c5d5465c96fe9a54320df01a59d427bc74 ['3ef84f782267c0e0e968196f92f0e857d46f4f9ba7afbddce796cc8c50975a16', 'c86b82b03c7ea6b5c48792faeda1ebc0f006b6443f53f2e1ebc75f77800e953a', 'a27b19ebc5ff088972123df588cb54d27a8b2814df66c48326738a5967fce4f7', '5bbe3d686024848f24fe238d32a57ce72d50b8fbeebade01a3437d75950aab78', '133fcdd7e6b5af96f140855c428ebc7639ace6eecf3d1593f5a24b675e96214f', '959f68af8dfd80b8f76ac61803f842c5d5465c96fe9a54320df01a59d427bc74', 'da347c609aa36f0a6fe6d9365f7d3f5ef3502894bbb295f976fd4029d2dbed7c', '5b4633e7421bdcaf006fbab7560895ed013741152128081e90f940a2d441b284', 'f4580b2be48d5ff6900dff6228fd62d66670888dae4c7128179d74de159d034a', 'c99484d301684eba379e2eaab522e22872390f584d0977611a9b71cd4e36e2a9', 'd4d0f5b26265d5747482d4c8c93706edd735ad6b653327445de5a09a5dcc5c2b', 'b6eb9b27803f3286e83df0b11c06a5f220e5d913bbabc9d230793dc4ee281aa3', 'aaa439e1d7bff43da825ea3503724aec00bcdfe7bc48704ec73d2c25140399b4'] B s-labels to a-label mappings. {38: 1, 24: 1, 27: 1, 6: 3, 79: 3, 90: 2, 51: 3, 130: 3, 62: 5, 85: 6, 68: 5, 35: 4, 110: 2, 91: 4, 114: 2, 97: 3, 31: 3, 13: 2, 67: 2, 124: 4, 98: 3, 54: 3, 127: 4, 26: 6, 8: 3, 96: 3, 64: 3, 30: 3, 61: 2, 55: 4, 15: 2, 52: 2, 129: 4, 115: 2, 84: 2, 76: 7, 87: 2, 131: 6, 102: 2, 113: 2, 99: 3, 36: 2, 53: 2, 72: 3} {96: 1, 354: 1, 147: 1, 1: 10, 4: 3, 9: 6, 10: 4, 15: 3, 24: 3, 25: 5, 26: 6, 27: 3, 39: 6, 43: 4, 49: 5, 50: 4, 58: 2, 59: 3, 64: 3, 69: 5, 81: 6, 82: 4, 86: 2, 100: 7, 108: 4, 109: 5, 110: 5, 111: 3, 114: 4, 115: 5, 116: 3, 118: 7, 119: 6, 120: 4, 121: 5, 122: 4, 123: 3, 124: 5, 128: 3, 129: 3, 130: 2, 132: 5, 136: 3, 145: 5, 151: 3, 152: 3, 154: 4, 156: 2, 161: 4, 162: 4, 165: 4, 168: 5, 169: 2, 172: 2, 180: 3, 184: 6, 187: 6, 188: 5, 191: 4, 194: 5, 202: 6, 203: 7, 206: 3, 207: 4, 215: 3, 217: 4, 218: 9, 220: 3, 221: 3, 222: 6, 224: 4, 227: 5, 229: 2, 234: 6, 235: 3, 241: 3, 242: 3, 243: 5, 244: 3, 245: 5, 248: 3, 250: 4, 258: 12, 262: 5, 263: 6, 264: 4, 267: 5, 270: 3, 272: 2, 273: 6, 287: 4, 289: 2, 291: 2, 299: 5, 300: 3, 304: 3, 309: 4, 314: 3, 315: 2, 320: 5, 323: 5, 327: 5, 328: 4, 329: 3, 330: 11, 334: 3, 335: 3, 341: 5, 342: 6, 347: 5, 348: 5, 350: 8, 351: 4, 352: 2, 353: 2, 358: 5, 365: 2, 366: 3, 369: 2, 371: 7, 372: 2, 376: 3, 384: 4, 385: 3, 386: 4, 387: 3, 392: 4, 393: 5, 396: 6, 397: 8, 398: 7, 402: 2} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 26 A-Label values and service parameters. "ip : references ip : untab and whitespace cleanup to keep xml2rfc happy ip : revise aggregation section , add alloc to sec 6 Let 's discuss these comments" 1033bab4058636b1c8e37b1e9eb27bab8fe98c1c 1033bab4058636b1c8e37b1e9eb27bab8fe98c1c draft-ietf-detnet-mpls da347c609aa36f0a6fe6d9365f7d3f5ef3502894bbb295f976fd4029d2dbed7c ['3ef84f782267c0e0e968196f92f0e857d46f4f9ba7afbddce796cc8c50975a16', 'c86b82b03c7ea6b5c48792faeda1ebc0f006b6443f53f2e1ebc75f77800e953a', 'a27b19ebc5ff088972123df588cb54d27a8b2814df66c48326738a5967fce4f7', '5bbe3d686024848f24fe238d32a57ce72d50b8fbeebade01a3437d75950aab78', '133fcdd7e6b5af96f140855c428ebc7639ace6eecf3d1593f5a24b675e96214f', '959f68af8dfd80b8f76ac61803f842c5d5465c96fe9a54320df01a59d427bc74', 'da347c609aa36f0a6fe6d9365f7d3f5ef3502894bbb295f976fd4029d2dbed7c', '5b4633e7421bdcaf006fbab7560895ed013741152128081e90f940a2d441b284', 'f4580b2be48d5ff6900dff6228fd62d66670888dae4c7128179d74de159d034a', 'c99484d301684eba379e2eaab522e22872390f584d0977611a9b71cd4e36e2a9', 'd4d0f5b26265d5747482d4c8c93706edd735ad6b653327445de5a09a5dcc5c2b', 'b6eb9b27803f3286e83df0b11c06a5f220e5d913bbabc9d230793dc4ee281aa3', 'aaa439e1d7bff43da825ea3503724aec00bcdfe7bc48704ec73d2c25140399b4'] B a-label values and service parameters. {38: 1, 24: 1, 27: 1, 6: 3, 79: 3, 90: 2, 51: 3, 130: 3, 62: 5, 85: 6, 68: 5, 35: 4, 110: 2, 91: 4, 114: 2, 97: 3, 31: 3, 13: 2, 67: 2, 124: 4, 98: 3, 54: 3, 127: 4, 26: 6, 8: 3, 96: 3, 64: 3, 30: 3, 61: 2, 55: 4, 15: 2, 52: 2, 129: 4, 115: 2, 84: 2, 76: 7, 87: 2, 131: 6, 102: 2, 113: 2, 99: 3, 36: 2, 53: 2, 72: 3} {96: 1, 354: 1, 147: 1, 1: 10, 4: 3, 9: 6, 10: 4, 15: 3, 24: 3, 25: 5, 26: 6, 27: 3, 39: 6, 43: 4, 49: 5, 50: 4, 58: 2, 59: 3, 64: 3, 69: 5, 81: 6, 82: 4, 86: 2, 100: 7, 108: 4, 109: 5, 110: 5, 111: 3, 114: 4, 115: 5, 116: 3, 118: 7, 119: 6, 120: 4, 121: 5, 122: 4, 123: 3, 124: 5, 128: 3, 129: 3, 130: 2, 132: 5, 136: 3, 145: 5, 151: 3, 152: 3, 154: 4, 156: 2, 161: 4, 162: 4, 165: 4, 168: 5, 169: 2, 172: 2, 180: 3, 184: 6, 187: 6, 188: 5, 191: 4, 194: 5, 202: 6, 203: 7, 206: 3, 207: 4, 215: 3, 217: 4, 218: 9, 220: 3, 221: 3, 222: 6, 224: 4, 227: 5, 229: 2, 234: 6, 235: 3, 241: 3, 242: 3, 243: 5, 244: 3, 245: 5, 248: 3, 250: 4, 258: 12, 262: 5, 263: 6, 264: 4, 267: 5, 270: 3, 272: 2, 273: 6, 287: 4, 289: 2, 291: 2, 299: 5, 300: 3, 304: 3, 309: 4, 314: 3, 315: 2, 320: 5, 323: 5, 327: 5, 328: 4, 329: 3, 330: 11, 334: 3, 335: 3, 341: 5, 342: 6, 347: 5, 348: 5, 350: 8, 351: 4, 352: 2, 353: 2, 358: 5, 365: 2, 366: 3, 369: 2, 371: 7, 372: 2, 376: 3, 384: 4, 385: 3, 386: 4, 387: 3, 392: 4, 393: 5, 396: 6, 397: 8, 398: 7, 402: 2} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 26 Each DetNet F-Label value and associated traffic parameters. "ip : references ip : untab and whitespace cleanup to keep xml2rfc happy ip : revise aggregation section , add alloc to sec 6 Let 's discuss these comments" 1033bab4058636b1c8e37b1e9eb27bab8fe98c1c 1033bab4058636b1c8e37b1e9eb27bab8fe98c1c draft-ietf-detnet-mpls c99484d301684eba379e2eaab522e22872390f584d0977611a9b71cd4e36e2a9 ['3ef84f782267c0e0e968196f92f0e857d46f4f9ba7afbddce796cc8c50975a16', 'c86b82b03c7ea6b5c48792faeda1ebc0f006b6443f53f2e1ebc75f77800e953a', 'a27b19ebc5ff088972123df588cb54d27a8b2814df66c48326738a5967fce4f7', '5bbe3d686024848f24fe238d32a57ce72d50b8fbeebade01a3437d75950aab78', '133fcdd7e6b5af96f140855c428ebc7639ace6eecf3d1593f5a24b675e96214f', '959f68af8dfd80b8f76ac61803f842c5d5465c96fe9a54320df01a59d427bc74', 'da347c609aa36f0a6fe6d9365f7d3f5ef3502894bbb295f976fd4029d2dbed7c', '5b4633e7421bdcaf006fbab7560895ed013741152128081e90f940a2d441b284', 'f4580b2be48d5ff6900dff6228fd62d66670888dae4c7128179d74de159d034a', 'c99484d301684eba379e2eaab522e22872390f584d0977611a9b71cd4e36e2a9', 'd4d0f5b26265d5747482d4c8c93706edd735ad6b653327445de5a09a5dcc5c2b', 'b6eb9b27803f3286e83df0b11c06a5f220e5d913bbabc9d230793dc4ee281aa3', 'aaa439e1d7bff43da825ea3503724aec00bcdfe7bc48704ec73d2c25140399b4'] B each detnet f-label value and associated traffic parameters. {38: 1, 24: 1, 27: 1, 6: 3, 79: 3, 90: 2, 51: 3, 130: 3, 62: 5, 85: 6, 68: 5, 35: 4, 110: 2, 91: 4, 114: 2, 97: 3, 31: 3, 13: 2, 67: 2, 124: 4, 98: 3, 54: 3, 127: 4, 26: 6, 8: 3, 96: 3, 64: 3, 30: 3, 61: 2, 55: 4, 15: 2, 52: 2, 129: 4, 115: 2, 84: 2, 76: 7, 87: 2, 131: 6, 102: 2, 113: 2, 99: 3, 36: 2, 53: 2, 72: 3} {96: 1, 354: 1, 147: 1, 1: 10, 4: 3, 9: 6, 10: 4, 15: 3, 24: 3, 25: 5, 26: 6, 27: 3, 39: 6, 43: 4, 49: 5, 50: 4, 58: 2, 59: 3, 64: 3, 69: 5, 81: 6, 82: 4, 86: 2, 100: 7, 108: 4, 109: 5, 110: 5, 111: 3, 114: 4, 115: 5, 116: 3, 118: 7, 119: 6, 120: 4, 121: 5, 122: 4, 123: 3, 124: 5, 128: 3, 129: 3, 130: 2, 132: 5, 136: 3, 145: 5, 151: 3, 152: 3, 154: 4, 156: 2, 161: 4, 162: 4, 165: 4, 168: 5, 169: 2, 172: 2, 180: 3, 184: 6, 187: 6, 188: 5, 191: 4, 194: 5, 202: 6, 203: 7, 206: 3, 207: 4, 215: 3, 217: 4, 218: 9, 220: 3, 221: 3, 222: 6, 224: 4, 227: 5, 229: 2, 234: 6, 235: 3, 241: 3, 242: 3, 243: 5, 244: 3, 245: 5, 248: 3, 250: 4, 258: 12, 262: 5, 263: 6, 264: 4, 267: 5, 270: 3, 272: 2, 273: 6, 287: 4, 289: 2, 291: 2, 299: 5, 300: 3, 304: 3, 309: 4, 314: 3, 315: 2, 320: 5, 323: 5, 327: 5, 328: 4, 329: 3, 330: 11, 334: 3, 335: 3, 341: 5, 342: 6, 347: 5, 348: 5, 350: 8, 351: 4, 352: 2, 353: 2, 358: 5, 365: 2, 366: 3, 369: 2, 371: 7, 372: 2, 376: 3, 384: 4, 385: 3, 386: 4, 387: 3, 392: 4, 393: 5, 396: 6, 397: 8, 398: 7, 402: 2} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 26 F-Label to H-LSP/Label mappings. "ip : references ip : untab and whitespace cleanup to keep xml2rfc happy ip : revise aggregation section , add alloc to sec 6 Let 's discuss these comments" 1033bab4058636b1c8e37b1e9eb27bab8fe98c1c 1033bab4058636b1c8e37b1e9eb27bab8fe98c1c draft-ietf-detnet-mpls 5b4633e7421bdcaf006fbab7560895ed013741152128081e90f940a2d441b284 ['3ef84f782267c0e0e968196f92f0e857d46f4f9ba7afbddce796cc8c50975a16', 'c86b82b03c7ea6b5c48792faeda1ebc0f006b6443f53f2e1ebc75f77800e953a', 'a27b19ebc5ff088972123df588cb54d27a8b2814df66c48326738a5967fce4f7', '5bbe3d686024848f24fe238d32a57ce72d50b8fbeebade01a3437d75950aab78', '133fcdd7e6b5af96f140855c428ebc7639ace6eecf3d1593f5a24b675e96214f', '959f68af8dfd80b8f76ac61803f842c5d5465c96fe9a54320df01a59d427bc74', 'da347c609aa36f0a6fe6d9365f7d3f5ef3502894bbb295f976fd4029d2dbed7c', '5b4633e7421bdcaf006fbab7560895ed013741152128081e90f940a2d441b284', 'f4580b2be48d5ff6900dff6228fd62d66670888dae4c7128179d74de159d034a', 'c99484d301684eba379e2eaab522e22872390f584d0977611a9b71cd4e36e2a9', 'd4d0f5b26265d5747482d4c8c93706edd735ad6b653327445de5a09a5dcc5c2b', 'b6eb9b27803f3286e83df0b11c06a5f220e5d913bbabc9d230793dc4ee281aa3', 'aaa439e1d7bff43da825ea3503724aec00bcdfe7bc48704ec73d2c25140399b4'] B f-label to h-lsp/label mappings. {38: 1, 24: 1, 27: 1, 6: 3, 79: 3, 90: 2, 51: 3, 130: 3, 62: 5, 85: 6, 68: 5, 35: 4, 110: 2, 91: 4, 114: 2, 97: 3, 31: 3, 13: 2, 67: 2, 124: 4, 98: 3, 54: 3, 127: 4, 26: 6, 8: 3, 96: 3, 64: 3, 30: 3, 61: 2, 55: 4, 15: 2, 52: 2, 129: 4, 115: 2, 84: 2, 76: 7, 87: 2, 131: 6, 102: 2, 113: 2, 99: 3, 36: 2, 53: 2, 72: 3} {96: 1, 354: 1, 147: 1, 1: 10, 4: 3, 9: 6, 10: 4, 15: 3, 24: 3, 25: 5, 26: 6, 27: 3, 39: 6, 43: 4, 49: 5, 50: 4, 58: 2, 59: 3, 64: 3, 69: 5, 81: 6, 82: 4, 86: 2, 100: 7, 108: 4, 109: 5, 110: 5, 111: 3, 114: 4, 115: 5, 116: 3, 118: 7, 119: 6, 120: 4, 121: 5, 122: 4, 123: 3, 124: 5, 128: 3, 129: 3, 130: 2, 132: 5, 136: 3, 145: 5, 151: 3, 152: 3, 154: 4, 156: 2, 161: 4, 162: 4, 165: 4, 168: 5, 169: 2, 172: 2, 180: 3, 184: 6, 187: 6, 188: 5, 191: 4, 194: 5, 202: 6, 203: 7, 206: 3, 207: 4, 215: 3, 217: 4, 218: 9, 220: 3, 221: 3, 222: 6, 224: 4, 227: 5, 229: 2, 234: 6, 235: 3, 241: 3, 242: 3, 243: 5, 244: 3, 245: 5, 248: 3, 250: 4, 258: 12, 262: 5, 263: 6, 264: 4, 267: 5, 270: 3, 272: 2, 273: 6, 287: 4, 289: 2, 291: 2, 299: 5, 300: 3, 304: 3, 309: 4, 314: 3, 315: 2, 320: 5, 323: 5, 327: 5, 328: 4, 329: 3, 330: 11, 334: 3, 335: 3, 341: 5, 342: 6, 347: 5, 348: 5, 350: 8, 351: 4, 352: 2, 353: 2, 358: 5, 365: 2, 366: 3, 369: 2, 371: 7, 372: 2, 376: 3, 384: 4, 385: 3, 386: 4, 387: 3, 392: 4, 393: 5, 396: 6, 397: 8, 398: 7, 402: 2} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 26 H-Label values and service parameters. "ip : references ip : untab and whitespace cleanup to keep xml2rfc happy ip : revise aggregation section , add alloc to sec 6 Let 's discuss these comments" 1033bab4058636b1c8e37b1e9eb27bab8fe98c1c 1033bab4058636b1c8e37b1e9eb27bab8fe98c1c draft-ietf-detnet-mpls c86b82b03c7ea6b5c48792faeda1ebc0f006b6443f53f2e1ebc75f77800e953a ['3ef84f782267c0e0e968196f92f0e857d46f4f9ba7afbddce796cc8c50975a16', 'c86b82b03c7ea6b5c48792faeda1ebc0f006b6443f53f2e1ebc75f77800e953a', 'a27b19ebc5ff088972123df588cb54d27a8b2814df66c48326738a5967fce4f7', '5bbe3d686024848f24fe238d32a57ce72d50b8fbeebade01a3437d75950aab78', '133fcdd7e6b5af96f140855c428ebc7639ace6eecf3d1593f5a24b675e96214f', '959f68af8dfd80b8f76ac61803f842c5d5465c96fe9a54320df01a59d427bc74', 'da347c609aa36f0a6fe6d9365f7d3f5ef3502894bbb295f976fd4029d2dbed7c', '5b4633e7421bdcaf006fbab7560895ed013741152128081e90f940a2d441b284', 'f4580b2be48d5ff6900dff6228fd62d66670888dae4c7128179d74de159d034a', 'c99484d301684eba379e2eaab522e22872390f584d0977611a9b71cd4e36e2a9', 'd4d0f5b26265d5747482d4c8c93706edd735ad6b653327445de5a09a5dcc5c2b', 'b6eb9b27803f3286e83df0b11c06a5f220e5d913bbabc9d230793dc4ee281aa3', 'aaa439e1d7bff43da825ea3503724aec00bcdfe7bc48704ec73d2c25140399b4'] B h-label values and service parameters. {38: 1, 24: 1, 27: 1, 6: 3, 79: 3, 90: 2, 51: 3, 130: 3, 62: 5, 85: 6, 68: 5, 35: 4, 110: 2, 91: 4, 114: 2, 97: 3, 31: 3, 13: 2, 67: 2, 124: 4, 98: 3, 54: 3, 127: 4, 26: 6, 8: 3, 96: 3, 64: 3, 30: 3, 61: 2, 55: 4, 15: 2, 52: 2, 129: 4, 115: 2, 84: 2, 76: 7, 87: 2, 131: 6, 102: 2, 113: 2, 99: 3, 36: 2, 53: 2, 72: 3} {96: 1, 354: 1, 147: 1, 1: 10, 4: 3, 9: 6, 10: 4, 15: 3, 24: 3, 25: 5, 26: 6, 27: 3, 39: 6, 43: 4, 49: 5, 50: 4, 58: 2, 59: 3, 64: 3, 69: 5, 81: 6, 82: 4, 86: 2, 100: 7, 108: 4, 109: 5, 110: 5, 111: 3, 114: 4, 115: 5, 116: 3, 118: 7, 119: 6, 120: 4, 121: 5, 122: 4, 123: 3, 124: 5, 128: 3, 129: 3, 130: 2, 132: 5, 136: 3, 145: 5, 151: 3, 152: 3, 154: 4, 156: 2, 161: 4, 162: 4, 165: 4, 168: 5, 169: 2, 172: 2, 180: 3, 184: 6, 187: 6, 188: 5, 191: 4, 194: 5, 202: 6, 203: 7, 206: 3, 207: 4, 215: 3, 217: 4, 218: 9, 220: 3, 221: 3, 222: 6, 224: 4, 227: 5, 229: 2, 234: 6, 235: 3, 241: 3, 242: 3, 243: 5, 244: 3, 245: 5, 248: 3, 250: 4, 258: 12, 262: 5, 263: 6, 264: 4, 267: 5, 270: 3, 272: 2, 273: 6, 287: 4, 289: 2, 291: 2, 299: 5, 300: 3, 304: 3, 309: 4, 314: 3, 315: 2, 320: 5, 323: 5, 327: 5, 328: 4, 329: 3, 330: 11, 334: 3, 335: 3, 341: 5, 342: 6, 347: 5, 348: 5, 350: 8, 351: 4, 352: 2, 353: 2, 358: 5, 365: 2, 366: 3, 369: 2, 371: 7, 372: 2, 376: 3, 384: 4, 385: 3, 386: 4, 387: 3, 392: 4, 393: 5, 396: 6, 397: 8, 398: 7, 402: 2} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 26 "Outgoing interface, next hop, and sub-network parameters on a technology specific basis." "ip : references ip : untab and whitespace cleanup to keep xml2rfc happy ip : revise aggregation section , add alloc to sec 6 Let 's discuss these comments" 1033bab4058636b1c8e37b1e9eb27bab8fe98c1c 1033bab4058636b1c8e37b1e9eb27bab8fe98c1c draft-ietf-detnet-mpls f4580b2be48d5ff6900dff6228fd62d66670888dae4c7128179d74de159d034a ['3ef84f782267c0e0e968196f92f0e857d46f4f9ba7afbddce796cc8c50975a16', 'c86b82b03c7ea6b5c48792faeda1ebc0f006b6443f53f2e1ebc75f77800e953a', 'a27b19ebc5ff088972123df588cb54d27a8b2814df66c48326738a5967fce4f7', '5bbe3d686024848f24fe238d32a57ce72d50b8fbeebade01a3437d75950aab78', '133fcdd7e6b5af96f140855c428ebc7639ace6eecf3d1593f5a24b675e96214f', '959f68af8dfd80b8f76ac61803f842c5d5465c96fe9a54320df01a59d427bc74', 'da347c609aa36f0a6fe6d9365f7d3f5ef3502894bbb295f976fd4029d2dbed7c', '5b4633e7421bdcaf006fbab7560895ed013741152128081e90f940a2d441b284', 'f4580b2be48d5ff6900dff6228fd62d66670888dae4c7128179d74de159d034a', 'c99484d301684eba379e2eaab522e22872390f584d0977611a9b71cd4e36e2a9', 'd4d0f5b26265d5747482d4c8c93706edd735ad6b653327445de5a09a5dcc5c2b', 'b6eb9b27803f3286e83df0b11c06a5f220e5d913bbabc9d230793dc4ee281aa3', 'aaa439e1d7bff43da825ea3503724aec00bcdfe7bc48704ec73d2c25140399b4'] B "outgoing interface, next hop, and sub-network parameters on a technology specific basis." {38: 1, 24: 1, 27: 1, 6: 3, 79: 3, 90: 2, 51: 3, 130: 3, 62: 5, 85: 6, 68: 5, 35: 4, 110: 2, 91: 4, 114: 2, 97: 3, 31: 3, 13: 2, 67: 2, 124: 4, 98: 3, 54: 3, 127: 4, 26: 6, 8: 3, 96: 3, 64: 3, 30: 3, 61: 2, 55: 4, 15: 2, 52: 2, 129: 4, 115: 2, 84: 2, 76: 7, 87: 2, 131: 6, 102: 2, 113: 2, 99: 3, 36: 2, 53: 2, 72: 3} {96: 1, 354: 1, 147: 1, 1: 10, 4: 3, 9: 6, 10: 4, 15: 3, 24: 3, 25: 5, 26: 6, 27: 3, 39: 6, 43: 4, 49: 5, 50: 4, 58: 2, 59: 3, 64: 3, 69: 5, 81: 6, 82: 4, 86: 2, 100: 7, 108: 4, 109: 5, 110: 5, 111: 3, 114: 4, 115: 5, 116: 3, 118: 7, 119: 6, 120: 4, 121: 5, 122: 4, 123: 3, 124: 5, 128: 3, 129: 3, 130: 2, 132: 5, 136: 3, 145: 5, 151: 3, 152: 3, 154: 4, 156: 2, 161: 4, 162: 4, 165: 4, 168: 5, 169: 2, 172: 2, 180: 3, 184: 6, 187: 6, 188: 5, 191: 4, 194: 5, 202: 6, 203: 7, 206: 3, 207: 4, 215: 3, 217: 4, 218: 9, 220: 3, 221: 3, 222: 6, 224: 4, 227: 5, 229: 2, 234: 6, 235: 3, 241: 3, 242: 3, 243: 5, 244: 3, 245: 5, 248: 3, 250: 4, 258: 12, 262: 5, 263: 6, 264: 4, 267: 5, 270: 3, 272: 2, 273: 6, 287: 4, 289: 2, 291: 2, 299: 5, 300: 3, 304: 3, 309: 4, 314: 3, 315: 2, 320: 5, 323: 5, 327: 5, 328: 4, 329: 3, 330: 11, 334: 3, 335: 3, 341: 5, 342: 6, 347: 5, 348: 5, 350: 8, 351: 4, 352: 2, 353: 2, 358: 5, 365: 2, 366: 3, 369: 2, 371: 7, 372: 2, 376: 3, 384: 4, 385: 3, 386: 4, 387: 3, 392: 4, 393: 5, 396: 6, 397: 8, 398: 7, 402: 2} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 26 "This document specifies the DetNet data plane operation for IP hosts and routers that provide DetNet service to IP encapsulated data. No DetNet specific encapsulation is defined to support IP flows, instead the existing IP and higher layer protocol header information is used to support flow identification and DetNet service delivery. Common data plane procedures and control information for all DetNet data planes can be found in the I-D.ietf-detnet-framework." "ip : references ip : untab and whitespace cleanup to keep xml2rfc happy ip : revise aggregation section , add alloc to sec 6 Let 's discuss these comments" 1033bab4058636b1c8e37b1e9eb27bab8fe98c1c 1033bab4058636b1c8e37b1e9eb27bab8fe98c1c draft-ietf-detnet-ip 7e11dc6d3440e410884cf721ca7e2bcaf010d21763060bbacc6e4245a2f94852 ['7e11dc6d3440e410884cf721ca7e2bcaf010d21763060bbacc6e4245a2f94852', 'd834df81950974f39bdbcd4a82eb893fdfa1af68224b90c51cb289da163fd869'] A "this document specifies the detnet data plane operation for ip hosts and routers that provide detnet service to ip encapsulated data. no detnet specific encapsulation is defined to support ip flows, instead the existing ip and higher layer protocol header information is used to support flow identification and detnet service delivery. common data plane procedures and control information for all detnet data planes can be found in the i-d.ietf-detnet-framework." {6: 1, 62: 1, 13: 2, 102: 2} {198: 1, 325: 1, 65: 2, 238: 2, 155: 3} {65, 325, 198, 199, 238, 155} 26 "This document specifies the DetNet data plane operation for IP hosts and routers that provide DetNet service to IP encapsulated data. No DetNet specific encapsulation is defined to support IP flows, instead the existing IP and higher layer protocol header information is used to support flow identification and DetNet service delivery. Common data plane procedures and control information for all DetNet data planes can be found in the I-D.ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework." "ip : references ip : untab and whitespace cleanup to keep xml2rfc happy ip : revise aggregation section , add alloc to sec 6 Let 's discuss these comments" 1033bab4058636b1c8e37b1e9eb27bab8fe98c1c 1033bab4058636b1c8e37b1e9eb27bab8fe98c1c draft-ietf-detnet-ip d834df81950974f39bdbcd4a82eb893fdfa1af68224b90c51cb289da163fd869 ['7e11dc6d3440e410884cf721ca7e2bcaf010d21763060bbacc6e4245a2f94852', 'd834df81950974f39bdbcd4a82eb893fdfa1af68224b90c51cb289da163fd869'] B "this document specifies the detnet data plane operation for ip hosts and routers that provide detnet service to ip encapsulated data. no detnet specific encapsulation is defined to support ip flows, instead the existing ip and higher layer protocol header information is used to support flow identification and detnet service delivery. common data plane procedures and control information for all detnet data planes can be found in the i-d.ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework." {6: 1, 62: 1, 13: 2, 102: 2} {198: 1, 325: 1, 65: 2, 238: 2, 155: 3} {65, 325, 198, 199, 238, 155} 26 "This document describes how IP is used by DetNet nodes, i.e., hosts and routers, identify DetNet flows and provide a DetNet service using an IP data plane. From a data plane perspective, an end-to-end IP model is followed. As mentioned above, existing IP and higher layer protocol header information is used to support flow identification and DetNet service delivery. Common data plane procedures and control information for all DetNet data planes can be found in the I- D.ietf-detnet-framework." "ip : references ip : untab and whitespace cleanup to keep xml2rfc happy ip : revise aggregation section , add alloc to sec 6 Let 's discuss these comments" 1033bab4058636b1c8e37b1e9eb27bab8fe98c1c 1033bab4058636b1c8e37b1e9eb27bab8fe98c1c draft-ietf-detnet-ip 5f960081b6f39804777325a5dcd0c4ca717ee12b4ae1bb43de1f6173902dcc76 ['7f94aafb335769dcfafc14037eed1da59f73de88a52916bf0395cb4da015df44', '5f960081b6f39804777325a5dcd0c4ca717ee12b4ae1bb43de1f6173902dcc76'] A "this document describes how ip is used by detnet nodes, i.e., hosts and routers, identify detnet flows and provide a detnet service using an ip data plane. from a data plane perspective, an end-to-end ip model is followed. as mentioned above, existing ip and higher layer protocol header information is used to support flow identification and detnet service delivery. common data plane procedures and control information for all detnet data planes can be found in the i- d.ietf-detnet-framework." {6: 1, 62: 1, 102: 2} {11: 1, 99: 1, 23: 2} {99, 201, 11, 23} 26 "This document describes how IP is used by DetNet nodes, i.e., hosts and routers, identify DetNet flows and provide a DetNet service using an IP data plane. From a data plane perspective, an end-to-end IP model is followed. As mentioned above, existing IP and higher layer protocol header information is used to support flow identification and DetNet service delivery. Common data plane procedures and control information for all DetNet data planes can be found in the I- D.ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework." "ip : references ip : untab and whitespace cleanup to keep xml2rfc happy ip : revise aggregation section , add alloc to sec 6 Let 's discuss these comments" 1033bab4058636b1c8e37b1e9eb27bab8fe98c1c 1033bab4058636b1c8e37b1e9eb27bab8fe98c1c draft-ietf-detnet-ip 7f94aafb335769dcfafc14037eed1da59f73de88a52916bf0395cb4da015df44 ['7f94aafb335769dcfafc14037eed1da59f73de88a52916bf0395cb4da015df44', '5f960081b6f39804777325a5dcd0c4ca717ee12b4ae1bb43de1f6173902dcc76'] B "this document describes how ip is used by detnet nodes, i.e., hosts and routers, identify detnet flows and provide a detnet service using an ip data plane. from a data plane perspective, an end-to-end ip model is followed. as mentioned above, existing ip and higher layer protocol header information is used to support flow identification and detnet service delivery. common data plane procedures and control information for all detnet data planes can be found in the i- d.ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework." {6: 1, 62: 1, 102: 2} {11: 1, 99: 1, 23: 2} {99, 201, 11, 23} 26 "Note: The operation of IEEE802.1 TSN end systems over DetNet enabled IP networks is not described in this document. TSN over MPLS is discribed in I-D.ietf-detnet-tsn-over-mpls." "ip : references ip : untab and whitespace cleanup to keep xml2rfc happy ip : revise aggregation section , add alloc to sec 6 Let 's discuss these comments" 1033bab4058636b1c8e37b1e9eb27bab8fe98c1c 1033bab4058636b1c8e37b1e9eb27bab8fe98c1c draft-ietf-detnet-ip 4a0fbcfc5bf233eed040d86902d09758720488ef5f57faa81ba95c6fcaab39a6 ['4a0fbcfc5bf233eed040d86902d09758720488ef5f57faa81ba95c6fcaab39a6', 'ca80e8882c3b1b7b43e7b4db56253a8c875d3703aa7f93577f17a05919cd0a5e'] A "note: the operation of ieee802.1 tsn end systems over detnet enabled ip networks is not described in this document. tsn over mpls is discribed in i-d.ietf-detnet-tsn-over-mpls." {6: 1, 102: 1, 79: 5, 90: 3, 51: 3, 130: 4, 62: 2, 85: 2, 68: 3, 35: 6, 110: 6, 91: 8, 114: 6, 97: 5, 31: 4, 13: 3, 67: 5, 38: 7, 26: 6, 124: 4, 98: 5, 54: 5, 127: 6, 8: 3, 96: 4, 64: 5, 30: 7, 61: 8, 55: 2, 27: 4, 15: 6, 52: 4, 129: 6, 115: 6, 84: 3, 76: 6, 87: 6, 131: 8, 113: 8, 99: 5, 36: 6, 24: 5, 53: 4, 72: 7} {118: 1, 320: 1, 1: 8, 4: 5, 9: 5, 10: 6, 15: 6, 24: 5, 25: 2, 26: 2, 27: 6, 39: 4, 43: 6, 49: 9, 50: 8, 58: 8, 59: 5, 64: 6, 69: 4, 81: 3, 82: 3, 86: 6, 96: 7, 97: 6, 100: 6, 108: 6, 109: 7, 110: 7, 111: 5, 114: 6, 115: 7, 116: 5, 120: 6, 121: 3, 122: 5, 123: 4, 124: 3, 128: 7, 129: 7, 130: 8, 132: 4, 136: 5, 145: 4, 147: 7, 151: 7, 152: 7, 154: 6, 156: 5, 161: 3, 162: 2, 165: 6, 168: 7, 169: 6, 172: 6, 180: 7, 184: 5, 187: 8, 188: 7, 191: 6, 194: 4, 202: 5, 203: 6, 206: 5, 207: 6, 215: 4, 217: 6, 218: 7, 220: 3, 221: 3, 222: 4, 224: 6, 227: 4, 229: 6, 234: 8, 235: 5, 241: 5, 242: 5, 243: 4, 244: 7, 245: 4, 248: 7, 250: 7, 258: 10, 262: 7, 263: 8, 264: 4, 267: 3, 270: 6, 272: 6, 273: 5, 287: 6, 289: 6, 291: 8, 299: 4, 300: 6, 304: 6, 309: 3, 314: 5, 315: 6, 323: 4, 327: 7, 328: 5, 329: 5, 330: 9, 334: 5, 335: 5, 341: 4, 342: 5, 347: 4, 348: 4, 350: 7, 351: 8, 352: 6, 353: 6, 354: 5, 358: 3, 365: 6, 366: 5, 369: 4, 371: 6, 372: 8, 376: 5, 384: 8, 385: 7, 386: 6, 387: 6, 392: 5, 393: 6, 396: 5, 397: 6, 398: 5, 402: 6} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 26 "Note: The operation of IEEE802.1 TSN end systems over DetNet enabled IP networks is not described in this document. TSN over MPLS is discribed in I-D.ietf-detnet-tsn-vpn-over-mpls." "ip : references ip : untab and whitespace cleanup to keep xml2rfc happy ip : revise aggregation section , add alloc to sec 6 Let 's discuss these comments" 1033bab4058636b1c8e37b1e9eb27bab8fe98c1c 1033bab4058636b1c8e37b1e9eb27bab8fe98c1c draft-ietf-detnet-ip ca80e8882c3b1b7b43e7b4db56253a8c875d3703aa7f93577f17a05919cd0a5e ['4a0fbcfc5bf233eed040d86902d09758720488ef5f57faa81ba95c6fcaab39a6', 'ca80e8882c3b1b7b43e7b4db56253a8c875d3703aa7f93577f17a05919cd0a5e'] B "note: the operation of ieee802.1 tsn end systems over detnet enabled ip networks is not described in this document. tsn over mpls is discribed in i-d.ietf-detnet-tsn-vpn-over-mpls." {6: 1, 102: 1, 79: 5, 90: 3, 51: 3, 130: 4, 62: 2, 85: 2, 68: 3, 35: 6, 110: 6, 91: 8, 114: 6, 97: 5, 31: 4, 13: 3, 67: 5, 38: 7, 26: 6, 124: 4, 98: 5, 54: 5, 127: 6, 8: 3, 96: 4, 64: 5, 30: 7, 61: 8, 55: 2, 27: 4, 15: 6, 52: 4, 129: 6, 115: 6, 84: 3, 76: 6, 87: 6, 131: 8, 113: 8, 99: 5, 36: 6, 24: 5, 53: 4, 72: 7} {118: 1, 320: 1, 1: 8, 4: 5, 9: 5, 10: 6, 15: 6, 24: 5, 25: 2, 26: 2, 27: 6, 39: 4, 43: 6, 49: 9, 50: 8, 58: 8, 59: 5, 64: 6, 69: 4, 81: 3, 82: 3, 86: 6, 96: 7, 97: 6, 100: 6, 108: 6, 109: 7, 110: 7, 111: 5, 114: 6, 115: 7, 116: 5, 120: 6, 121: 3, 122: 5, 123: 4, 124: 3, 128: 7, 129: 7, 130: 8, 132: 4, 136: 5, 145: 4, 147: 7, 151: 7, 152: 7, 154: 6, 156: 5, 161: 3, 162: 2, 165: 6, 168: 7, 169: 6, 172: 6, 180: 7, 184: 5, 187: 8, 188: 7, 191: 6, 194: 4, 202: 5, 203: 6, 206: 5, 207: 6, 215: 4, 217: 6, 218: 7, 220: 3, 221: 3, 222: 4, 224: 6, 227: 4, 229: 6, 234: 8, 235: 5, 241: 5, 242: 5, 243: 4, 244: 7, 245: 4, 248: 7, 250: 7, 258: 10, 262: 7, 263: 8, 264: 4, 267: 3, 270: 6, 272: 6, 273: 5, 287: 6, 289: 6, 291: 8, 299: 4, 300: 6, 304: 6, 309: 3, 314: 5, 315: 6, 323: 4, 327: 7, 328: 5, 329: 5, 330: 9, 334: 5, 335: 5, 341: 4, 342: 5, 347: 4, 348: 4, 350: 7, 351: 8, 352: 6, 353: 6, 354: 5, 358: 3, 365: 6, 366: 5, 369: 4, 371: 6, 372: 8, 376: 5, 384: 8, 385: 7, 386: 6, 387: 6, 392: 5, 393: 6, 396: 5, 397: 6, 398: 5, 402: 6} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 26 "sec_dt_dp introduces the use of the IP ""6-tuple"" for flow identification, and QoS goes on to discuss how identified flows use specific QoS mechanisms for flow-specific traffic treatment, including path control and resource allocation. ip-flow-id contains detailed DetNet IP flow identification procedures. Flow identification plays an important role for the DetNet controller plane." "ip : references ip : untab and whitespace cleanup to keep xml2rfc happy ip : revise aggregation section , add alloc to sec 6 Let 's discuss these comments" 1033bab4058636b1c8e37b1e9eb27bab8fe98c1c 1033bab4058636b1c8e37b1e9eb27bab8fe98c1c draft-ietf-detnet-ip fbfe0a44094cbd5d24fba2ce598ff839f404d0b65da68feaf76bc3faaa664210 ['662aa0d783f701117ae9f6c23ee467f7f8526a1989762db6050bdf9b769ebfbf', 'b5becb32cc74f88e3de7590f1e3c7e1da144ef6d91d76a490a5398611728902a', 'b9f3477c814a131af659143e53d74ecd7cc0c290043358ad22afe332711ffb61', 'fbfe0a44094cbd5d24fba2ce598ff839f404d0b65da68feaf76bc3faaa664210', 'a93634933fb52dfa43ad6798c0097118296fc629320f5073107b27671ece2332', '1719acc1335a93b75945a721e6f3472735a0f5c2c862a94913af997266b39ab7', '6170a5d3b8e653785199be80d4bb4bf0a83e946b99b77412ebd908662e5fa45e', 'ac4ae24402ca9286fcdbe4570e54b692051c93342d1e6ba0450afc23503fa923', 'fb3b14f0c3981fd4e8e444846529675d3b163bd9ebfa231a905779e19a024934'] A "sec_dt_dp introduces the use of the ip ""6-tuple"" for flow identification, and qos goes on to discuss how identified flows use specific qos mechanisms for flow-specific traffic treatment, including path control and resource allocation. ip-flow-id contains detailed detnet ip flow identification procedures. flow identification plays an important role for the detnet controller plane." {56: 1, 27: 1, 13: 1, 102: 1, 62: 3, 60: 2, 85: 2} {159: 1, 259: 1, 284: 1, 359: 1, 370: 3, 52: 2, 246: 2} {160, 259, 359, 370, 52, 246, 284, 159} 26 "Flow aggregation can be accomplished using any of the 6-tuple fields defined in ip-flow-id, using a DSCP identified traffic class or other field. It will be the responsibility of the DetNet controller plane to be able to properly provision the use of these aggregation mechanisms." "ip : references ip : untab and whitespace cleanup to keep xml2rfc happy ip : revise aggregation section , add alloc to sec 6 Let 's discuss these comments" 1033bab4058636b1c8e37b1e9eb27bab8fe98c1c 1033bab4058636b1c8e37b1e9eb27bab8fe98c1c draft-ietf-detnet-ip b9f3477c814a131af659143e53d74ecd7cc0c290043358ad22afe332711ffb61 ['662aa0d783f701117ae9f6c23ee467f7f8526a1989762db6050bdf9b769ebfbf', 'b5becb32cc74f88e3de7590f1e3c7e1da144ef6d91d76a490a5398611728902a', 'b9f3477c814a131af659143e53d74ecd7cc0c290043358ad22afe332711ffb61', 'fbfe0a44094cbd5d24fba2ce598ff839f404d0b65da68feaf76bc3faaa664210', 'a93634933fb52dfa43ad6798c0097118296fc629320f5073107b27671ece2332', '1719acc1335a93b75945a721e6f3472735a0f5c2c862a94913af997266b39ab7', '6170a5d3b8e653785199be80d4bb4bf0a83e946b99b77412ebd908662e5fa45e', 'ac4ae24402ca9286fcdbe4570e54b692051c93342d1e6ba0450afc23503fa923', 'fb3b14f0c3981fd4e8e444846529675d3b163bd9ebfa231a905779e19a024934'] A "flow aggregation can be accomplished using any of the 6-tuple fields defined in ip-flow-id, using a dscp identified traffic class or other field. it will be the responsibility of the detnet controller plane to be able to properly provision the use of these aggregation mechanisms." {56: 1, 27: 1, 13: 1, 102: 1, 62: 3, 60: 2, 85: 2} {159: 1, 259: 1, 284: 1, 359: 1, 370: 3, 52: 2, 246: 2} {160, 259, 359, 370, 52, 246, 284, 159} 26 "The use of prefixes, wildcards, bitmasks, and port ranges allows a DetNet node to aggregate DetNet flows. This aggregation can take place within a single node, when that node maintains state about both the aggregated and component flows. It can also take place between nodes, where one node maintains state about only flow aggregates while the other node maintains state on all or a portion of the component flows. In either case, the management or control function that provisions the aggregate flows must ensure that adequate resources are allocated and configured to provide combined service requirements of the component flows. As DetNet is concerned about latency and jitter, more than just bandwidth needs to be considered." "ip : references ip : untab and whitespace cleanup to keep xml2rfc happy ip : revise aggregation section , add alloc to sec 6 Let 's discuss these comments" 1033bab4058636b1c8e37b1e9eb27bab8fe98c1c 1033bab4058636b1c8e37b1e9eb27bab8fe98c1c draft-ietf-detnet-ip fb3b14f0c3981fd4e8e444846529675d3b163bd9ebfa231a905779e19a024934 ['662aa0d783f701117ae9f6c23ee467f7f8526a1989762db6050bdf9b769ebfbf', 'b5becb32cc74f88e3de7590f1e3c7e1da144ef6d91d76a490a5398611728902a', 'b9f3477c814a131af659143e53d74ecd7cc0c290043358ad22afe332711ffb61', 'fbfe0a44094cbd5d24fba2ce598ff839f404d0b65da68feaf76bc3faaa664210', 'a93634933fb52dfa43ad6798c0097118296fc629320f5073107b27671ece2332', '1719acc1335a93b75945a721e6f3472735a0f5c2c862a94913af997266b39ab7', '6170a5d3b8e653785199be80d4bb4bf0a83e946b99b77412ebd908662e5fa45e', 'ac4ae24402ca9286fcdbe4570e54b692051c93342d1e6ba0450afc23503fa923', 'fb3b14f0c3981fd4e8e444846529675d3b163bd9ebfa231a905779e19a024934'] A "the use of prefixes, wildcards, bitmasks, and port ranges allows a detnet node to aggregate detnet flows. this aggregation can take place within a single node, when that node maintains state about both the aggregated and component flows. it can also take place between nodes, where one node maintains state about only flow aggregates while the other node maintains state on all or a portion of the component flows. in either case, the management or control function that provisions the aggregate flows must ensure that adequate resources are allocated and configured to provide combined service requirements of the component flows. as detnet is concerned about latency and jitter, more than just bandwidth needs to be considered." {56: 1, 27: 1, 13: 1, 102: 1, 62: 3, 60: 2, 85: 2} {159: 1, 259: 1, 284: 1, 359: 1, 370: 3, 52: 2, 246: 2} {160, 259, 359, 370, 52, 246, 284, 159} 26 "The ability to aggregate individual flows, and their associated resource control, into a larger aggregate is an important technique for improving scaling of messaging in the data, management and control planes. The resource control and management aspects of aggregation (including the queuing/shaping/policing implications) will be covered in other documents. The data plane implications of aggregation are independent of encapsulation formats." "ip : references ip : untab and whitespace cleanup to keep xml2rfc happy ip : revise aggregation section , add alloc to sec 6 Let 's discuss these comments" 1033bab4058636b1c8e37b1e9eb27bab8fe98c1c 1033bab4058636b1c8e37b1e9eb27bab8fe98c1c draft-ietf-detnet-ip 6170a5d3b8e653785199be80d4bb4bf0a83e946b99b77412ebd908662e5fa45e ['662aa0d783f701117ae9f6c23ee467f7f8526a1989762db6050bdf9b769ebfbf', 'b5becb32cc74f88e3de7590f1e3c7e1da144ef6d91d76a490a5398611728902a', 'b9f3477c814a131af659143e53d74ecd7cc0c290043358ad22afe332711ffb61', 'fbfe0a44094cbd5d24fba2ce598ff839f404d0b65da68feaf76bc3faaa664210', 'a93634933fb52dfa43ad6798c0097118296fc629320f5073107b27671ece2332', '1719acc1335a93b75945a721e6f3472735a0f5c2c862a94913af997266b39ab7', '6170a5d3b8e653785199be80d4bb4bf0a83e946b99b77412ebd908662e5fa45e', 'ac4ae24402ca9286fcdbe4570e54b692051c93342d1e6ba0450afc23503fa923', 'fb3b14f0c3981fd4e8e444846529675d3b163bd9ebfa231a905779e19a024934'] A "the ability to aggregate individual flows, and their associated resource control, into a larger aggregate is an important technique for improving scaling of messaging in the data, management and control planes. the resource control and management aspects of aggregation (including the queuing/shaping/policing implications) will be covered in other documents. the data plane implications of aggregation are independent of encapsulation formats." {56: 1, 27: 1, 13: 1, 102: 1, 62: 3, 60: 2, 85: 2} {159: 1, 259: 1, 284: 1, 359: 1, 370: 3, 52: 2, 246: 2} {160, 259, 359, 370, 52, 246, 284, 159} 26 "DetNet flows forwarded via IP have more limited aggregation options, due to the available traffic flow identification fields of the IP solution. One available approach is to manage the resources associated with a DSCP identified traffic class and to map (remark) individually controlled DetNet flows onto that traffic class. This approach also requires that nodes support aggregation ensure that traffic from aggregated flows are placed (shaped/policed/enqueued) in a fashion that ensures the required DetNet service is preserved." "ip : references ip : untab and whitespace cleanup to keep xml2rfc happy ip : revise aggregation section , add alloc to sec 6 Let 's discuss these comments" 1033bab4058636b1c8e37b1e9eb27bab8fe98c1c 1033bab4058636b1c8e37b1e9eb27bab8fe98c1c draft-ietf-detnet-ip b5becb32cc74f88e3de7590f1e3c7e1da144ef6d91d76a490a5398611728902a ['662aa0d783f701117ae9f6c23ee467f7f8526a1989762db6050bdf9b769ebfbf', 'b5becb32cc74f88e3de7590f1e3c7e1da144ef6d91d76a490a5398611728902a', 'b9f3477c814a131af659143e53d74ecd7cc0c290043358ad22afe332711ffb61', 'fbfe0a44094cbd5d24fba2ce598ff839f404d0b65da68feaf76bc3faaa664210', 'a93634933fb52dfa43ad6798c0097118296fc629320f5073107b27671ece2332', '1719acc1335a93b75945a721e6f3472735a0f5c2c862a94913af997266b39ab7', '6170a5d3b8e653785199be80d4bb4bf0a83e946b99b77412ebd908662e5fa45e', 'ac4ae24402ca9286fcdbe4570e54b692051c93342d1e6ba0450afc23503fa923', 'fb3b14f0c3981fd4e8e444846529675d3b163bd9ebfa231a905779e19a024934'] A "detnet flows forwarded via ip have more limited aggregation options, due to the available traffic flow identification fields of the ip solution. one available approach is to manage the resources associated with a dscp identified traffic class and to map (remark) individually controlled detnet flows onto that traffic class. this approach also requires that nodes support aggregation ensure that traffic from aggregated flows are placed (shaped/policed/enqueued) in a fashion that ensures the required detnet service is preserved." {56: 1, 27: 1, 13: 1, 102: 1, 62: 3, 60: 2, 85: 2} {159: 1, 259: 1, 284: 1, 359: 1, 370: 3, 52: 2, 246: 2} {160, 259, 359, 370, 52, 246, 284, 159} 26 "Additional details of the traffic control capabilities needed at a DetNet-aware node may be covered in separate future documents. Management and control plane mechanisms will also need to ensure that the service required on the aggregate flow are provided, which may include the discarding or remarking mentioned in the previous sections." "ip : references ip : untab and whitespace cleanup to keep xml2rfc happy ip : revise aggregation section , add alloc to sec 6 Let 's discuss these comments" 1033bab4058636b1c8e37b1e9eb27bab8fe98c1c 1033bab4058636b1c8e37b1e9eb27bab8fe98c1c draft-ietf-detnet-ip 1719acc1335a93b75945a721e6f3472735a0f5c2c862a94913af997266b39ab7 ['662aa0d783f701117ae9f6c23ee467f7f8526a1989762db6050bdf9b769ebfbf', 'b5becb32cc74f88e3de7590f1e3c7e1da144ef6d91d76a490a5398611728902a', 'b9f3477c814a131af659143e53d74ecd7cc0c290043358ad22afe332711ffb61', 'fbfe0a44094cbd5d24fba2ce598ff839f404d0b65da68feaf76bc3faaa664210', 'a93634933fb52dfa43ad6798c0097118296fc629320f5073107b27671ece2332', '1719acc1335a93b75945a721e6f3472735a0f5c2c862a94913af997266b39ab7', '6170a5d3b8e653785199be80d4bb4bf0a83e946b99b77412ebd908662e5fa45e', 'ac4ae24402ca9286fcdbe4570e54b692051c93342d1e6ba0450afc23503fa923', 'fb3b14f0c3981fd4e8e444846529675d3b163bd9ebfa231a905779e19a024934'] A "additional details of the traffic control capabilities needed at a detnet-aware node may be covered in separate future documents. management and control plane mechanisms will also need to ensure that the service required on the aggregate flow are provided, which may include the discarding or remarking mentioned in the previous sections." {56: 1, 27: 1, 13: 1, 102: 1, 62: 3, 60: 2, 85: 2} {159: 1, 259: 1, 284: 1, 359: 1, 370: 3, 52: 2, 246: 2} {160, 259, 359, 370, 52, 246, 284, 159} 26 "As described in I-D.ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework, the ability to aggregate individual flows, and their associated resource control, into a larger aggregate is an important technique for improving scaling by reducing the state per hop. DetNet IP data plane aggregation can take place within a single node, when that node maintains state about both the aggregated and component flows. It can also take place between nodes, where one node maintains state about only flow aggregates while the other node maintains state on all or a portion of the component flows. In either case, the management or control function that provisions the aggregate flows must ensure that adequate resources are allocated and configured to provide combined service requirements of the component flows. As DetNet is concerned about latency and jitter, more than just bandwidth needs to be considered." "ip : references ip : untab and whitespace cleanup to keep xml2rfc happy ip : revise aggregation section , add alloc to sec 6 Let 's discuss these comments" 1033bab4058636b1c8e37b1e9eb27bab8fe98c1c 1033bab4058636b1c8e37b1e9eb27bab8fe98c1c draft-ietf-detnet-ip a93634933fb52dfa43ad6798c0097118296fc629320f5073107b27671ece2332 ['662aa0d783f701117ae9f6c23ee467f7f8526a1989762db6050bdf9b769ebfbf', 'b5becb32cc74f88e3de7590f1e3c7e1da144ef6d91d76a490a5398611728902a', 'b9f3477c814a131af659143e53d74ecd7cc0c290043358ad22afe332711ffb61', 'fbfe0a44094cbd5d24fba2ce598ff839f404d0b65da68feaf76bc3faaa664210', 'a93634933fb52dfa43ad6798c0097118296fc629320f5073107b27671ece2332', '1719acc1335a93b75945a721e6f3472735a0f5c2c862a94913af997266b39ab7', '6170a5d3b8e653785199be80d4bb4bf0a83e946b99b77412ebd908662e5fa45e', 'ac4ae24402ca9286fcdbe4570e54b692051c93342d1e6ba0450afc23503fa923', 'fb3b14f0c3981fd4e8e444846529675d3b163bd9ebfa231a905779e19a024934'] B "as described in i-d.ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework, the ability to aggregate individual flows, and their associated resource control, into a larger aggregate is an important technique for improving scaling by reducing the state per hop. detnet ip data plane aggregation can take place within a single node, when that node maintains state about both the aggregated and component flows. it can also take place between nodes, where one node maintains state about only flow aggregates while the other node maintains state on all or a portion of the component flows. in either case, the management or control function that provisions the aggregate flows must ensure that adequate resources are allocated and configured to provide combined service requirements of the component flows. as detnet is concerned about latency and jitter, more than just bandwidth needs to be considered." {56: 1, 27: 1, 13: 1, 102: 1, 62: 3, 60: 2, 85: 2} {159: 1, 259: 1, 284: 1, 359: 1, 370: 3, 52: 2, 246: 2} {160, 259, 359, 370, 52, 246, 284, 159} 26 "From a single node perspective, the aggregation of IP flows impacts DetNet IP data plane flow identification and resource allocation. As discussed above, IP flow identification uses the IP ""6-tuple"" for flow identification. DetNet IP flows can be aggregated using any of the 6-tuple fields defined in ip-flow-id. The use of prefixes, wildcards, bitmasks, and value ranges allows a DetNet node to identify aggregate DetNet flows. From a resource allocation perspective, DetNet nodes must provide service to a aggregate and not on a component flow basis." "ip : references ip : untab and whitespace cleanup to keep xml2rfc happy ip : revise aggregation section , add alloc to sec 6 Let 's discuss these comments" 1033bab4058636b1c8e37b1e9eb27bab8fe98c1c 1033bab4058636b1c8e37b1e9eb27bab8fe98c1c draft-ietf-detnet-ip 662aa0d783f701117ae9f6c23ee467f7f8526a1989762db6050bdf9b769ebfbf ['662aa0d783f701117ae9f6c23ee467f7f8526a1989762db6050bdf9b769ebfbf', 'b5becb32cc74f88e3de7590f1e3c7e1da144ef6d91d76a490a5398611728902a', 'b9f3477c814a131af659143e53d74ecd7cc0c290043358ad22afe332711ffb61', 'fbfe0a44094cbd5d24fba2ce598ff839f404d0b65da68feaf76bc3faaa664210', 'a93634933fb52dfa43ad6798c0097118296fc629320f5073107b27671ece2332', '1719acc1335a93b75945a721e6f3472735a0f5c2c862a94913af997266b39ab7', '6170a5d3b8e653785199be80d4bb4bf0a83e946b99b77412ebd908662e5fa45e', 'ac4ae24402ca9286fcdbe4570e54b692051c93342d1e6ba0450afc23503fa923', 'fb3b14f0c3981fd4e8e444846529675d3b163bd9ebfa231a905779e19a024934'] B "from a single node perspective, the aggregation of ip flows impacts detnet ip data plane flow identification and resource allocation. as discussed above, ip flow identification uses the ip ""6-tuple"" for flow identification. detnet ip flows can be aggregated using any of the 6-tuple fields defined in ip-flow-id. the use of prefixes, wildcards, bitmasks, and value ranges allows a detnet node to identify aggregate detnet flows. from a resource allocation perspective, detnet nodes must provide service to a aggregate and not on a component flow basis." {56: 1, 27: 1, 13: 1, 102: 1, 62: 3, 60: 2, 85: 2} {159: 1, 259: 1, 284: 1, 359: 1, 370: 3, 52: 2, 246: 2} {160, 259, 359, 370, 52, 246, 284, 159} 26 "It is the responsibility of the DetNet controller plane to properly provision the use of these aggregation mechanisms. This includes ensuring that aggregated flows have compatible e.g., the same or very similar QoS and/or CoS characteristics, see QoS. It also includes ensuring that per component-flow service requirements are satisfied by the aggregate, see ip-svc." "ip : references ip : untab and whitespace cleanup to keep xml2rfc happy ip : revise aggregation section , add alloc to sec 6 Let 's discuss these comments" 1033bab4058636b1c8e37b1e9eb27bab8fe98c1c 1033bab4058636b1c8e37b1e9eb27bab8fe98c1c draft-ietf-detnet-ip ac4ae24402ca9286fcdbe4570e54b692051c93342d1e6ba0450afc23503fa923 ['662aa0d783f701117ae9f6c23ee467f7f8526a1989762db6050bdf9b769ebfbf', 'b5becb32cc74f88e3de7590f1e3c7e1da144ef6d91d76a490a5398611728902a', 'b9f3477c814a131af659143e53d74ecd7cc0c290043358ad22afe332711ffb61', 'fbfe0a44094cbd5d24fba2ce598ff839f404d0b65da68feaf76bc3faaa664210', 'a93634933fb52dfa43ad6798c0097118296fc629320f5073107b27671ece2332', '1719acc1335a93b75945a721e6f3472735a0f5c2c862a94913af997266b39ab7', '6170a5d3b8e653785199be80d4bb4bf0a83e946b99b77412ebd908662e5fa45e', 'ac4ae24402ca9286fcdbe4570e54b692051c93342d1e6ba0450afc23503fa923', 'fb3b14f0c3981fd4e8e444846529675d3b163bd9ebfa231a905779e19a024934'] B "it is the responsibility of the detnet controller plane to properly provision the use of these aggregation mechanisms. this includes ensuring that aggregated flows have compatible e.g., the same or very similar qos and/or cos characteristics, see qos. it also includes ensuring that per component-flow service requirements are satisfied by the aggregate, see ip-svc." {56: 1, 27: 1, 13: 1, 102: 1, 62: 3, 60: 2, 85: 2} {159: 1, 259: 1, 284: 1, 359: 1, 370: 3, 52: 2, 246: 2} {160, 259, 359, 370, 52, 246, 284, 159} 26 "D.ietf-ip-over-tsn. Other than in the TSN case, the specific mechanisms used by a DetNet node to ensure DetNet service delivery requirements are met for supported DetNet flows is outside the scope of this document." "ip : references ip : untab and whitespace cleanup to keep xml2rfc happy ip : revise aggregation section , add alloc to sec 6 Let 's discuss these comments" 1033bab4058636b1c8e37b1e9eb27bab8fe98c1c 1033bab4058636b1c8e37b1e9eb27bab8fe98c1c draft-ietf-detnet-ip faa359db82605b77f2f169ffe9db6caa94a78ea93530d3c788a4ea6dc4b77537 ['faa359db82605b77f2f169ffe9db6caa94a78ea93530d3c788a4ea6dc4b77537', 'fe2e248574220caf6890e9808b86b66ca70248f74d96fbaeaecb5978d0d7108b'] A "d.ietf-ip-over-tsn. other than in the tsn case, the specific mechanisms used by a detnet node to ensure detnet service delivery requirements are met for supported detnet flows is outside the scope of this document." {} {} {} 26 "D.ietf-detnet-ip-over-tsn. Other than in the TSN case, the specific mechanisms used by a DetNet node to ensure DetNet service delivery requirements are met for supported DetNet flows is outside the scope of this document." "ip : references ip : untab and whitespace cleanup to keep xml2rfc happy ip : revise aggregation section , add alloc to sec 6 Let 's discuss these comments" 1033bab4058636b1c8e37b1e9eb27bab8fe98c1c 1033bab4058636b1c8e37b1e9eb27bab8fe98c1c draft-ietf-detnet-ip fe2e248574220caf6890e9808b86b66ca70248f74d96fbaeaecb5978d0d7108b ['faa359db82605b77f2f169ffe9db6caa94a78ea93530d3c788a4ea6dc4b77537', 'fe2e248574220caf6890e9808b86b66ca70248f74d96fbaeaecb5978d0d7108b'] B "d.ietf-detnet-ip-over-tsn. other than in the tsn case, the specific mechanisms used by a detnet node to ensure detnet service delivery requirements are met for supported detnet flows is outside the scope of this document." {} {} {} 26 "Information identifying a DetNet flow is ordered and implementations use the first match. This can, for example, be used to provide a DetNet service for a specific UDP flow, with unique Source and Destination Port field values, while providing a different service for all other flows with that same UDP Destination Port value." "ip : references ip : untab and whitespace cleanup to keep xml2rfc happy ip : revise aggregation section , add alloc to sec 6 Let 's discuss these comments" 1033bab4058636b1c8e37b1e9eb27bab8fe98c1c 1033bab4058636b1c8e37b1e9eb27bab8fe98c1c draft-ietf-detnet-ip 54d2dbdc12f5c591bad2438f3e10b9cade1fee4553b731185de8bf3cc5b7fde8 ['1c461fe81d5bcf71073032237c90a364fe0acc907c86f9c6b7bdd0239e4a6516', '54d2dbdc12f5c591bad2438f3e10b9cade1fee4553b731185de8bf3cc5b7fde8'] A "information identifying a detnet flow is ordered and implementations use the first match. this can, for example, be used to provide a detnet service for a specific udp flow, with unique source and destination port field values, while providing a different service for all other flows with that same udp destination port value." {33: 1, 32: 1, 102: 1, 60: 3, 56: 2, 64: 2, 38: 2, 62: 2, 71: 2, 83: 3, 113: 2, 126: 3, 112: 2, 85: 3, 129: 3} {31: 1, 33: 1, 274: 1, 260: 3, 261: 2, 339: 3, 212: 2, 343: 3, 283: 2, 286: 4, 163: 3, 228: 2, 357: 2, 166: 3, 231: 2, 298: 2, 363: 3, 46: 3, 377: 2} {260, 261, 274, 283, 286, 31, 32, 33, 163, 166, 298, 46, 339, 212, 343, 228, 357, 231, 363, 377} 26 "Information identifying a DetNet flow is ordered and implementations use the first match. This can, for example, be used to provide a DetNet service for a specific UDP flow, with unique Source and Destination Port field values, while providing a different service for the aggregate of all other flows with that same UDP Destination Port value." "ip : references ip : untab and whitespace cleanup to keep xml2rfc happy ip : revise aggregation section , add alloc to sec 6 Let 's discuss these comments" 1033bab4058636b1c8e37b1e9eb27bab8fe98c1c 1033bab4058636b1c8e37b1e9eb27bab8fe98c1c draft-ietf-detnet-ip 1c461fe81d5bcf71073032237c90a364fe0acc907c86f9c6b7bdd0239e4a6516 ['1c461fe81d5bcf71073032237c90a364fe0acc907c86f9c6b7bdd0239e4a6516', '54d2dbdc12f5c591bad2438f3e10b9cade1fee4553b731185de8bf3cc5b7fde8'] B "information identifying a detnet flow is ordered and implementations use the first match. this can, for example, be used to provide a detnet service for a specific udp flow, with unique source and destination port field values, while providing a different service for the aggregate of all other flows with that same udp destination port value." {33: 1, 32: 1, 102: 1, 60: 3, 56: 2, 64: 2, 38: 2, 62: 2, 71: 2, 83: 3, 113: 2, 126: 3, 112: 2, 85: 3, 129: 3} {31: 1, 33: 1, 274: 1, 260: 3, 261: 2, 339: 3, 212: 2, 343: 3, 283: 2, 286: 4, 163: 3, 228: 2, 357: 2, 166: 3, 231: 2, 298: 2, 363: 3, 46: 3, 377: 2} {260, 261, 274, 283, 286, 31, 32, 33, 163, 166, 298, 46, 339, 212, 343, 228, 357, 231, 363, 377} 25 Operations, Administration, and Maintenance. Cleaning up Draft Nits from Make 1cbf52182894f48f1887906399da9378a008f336 1cbf52182894f48f1887906399da9378a008f336 draft-ietf-detnet-ip bb194dc58a0eb7e52501603ff614fb1131422ca453ab5b879033dd20511649fb ['bb194dc58a0eb7e52501603ff614fb1131422ca453ab5b879033dd20511649fb'] A operations, administration, and maintenance. {68: 1, 52: 1, 51: 1, 130: 3, 79: 2, 112: 2, 55: 2, 64: 2, 62: 3, 37: 2, 38: 2, 69: 2, 67: 2, 33: 2, 53: 2, 80: 2, 127: 4, 91: 2} {279: 1, 321: 1, 308: 1, 0: 3, 389: 2, 390: 2, 135: 2, 142: 2, 14: 2, 400: 3, 17: 2, 399: 3, 19: 3, 149: 2, 406: 2, 280: 2, 281: 3, 278: 2, 296: 2, 45: 2, 56: 2, 185: 2, 192: 2, 322: 2, 66: 2, 196: 5, 197: 4, 324: 2, 77: 2, 78: 2, 337: 4, 216: 2, 380: 2, 255: 3} {0, 389, 390, 135, 142, 14, 400, 17, 399, 19, 149, 406, 279, 280, 281, 278, 294, 296, 45, 308, 56, 185, 192, 321, 322, 66, 196, 197, 324, 77, 78, 337, 216, 380, 255} 25 OAM consideration are out-of-scope in this document. Cleaning up Draft Nits from Make 1cbf52182894f48f1887906399da9378a008f336 1cbf52182894f48f1887906399da9378a008f336 draft-ietf-detnet-ip ed60e11fda2de3343baf8e6d58b6c5d0120d4b48f20144da8cae6a668c220367 ['ed60e11fda2de3343baf8e6d58b6c5d0120d4b48f20144da8cae6a668c220367'] A oam consideration are out-of-scope in this document. {} {} {379} 24 "The security considerations of DetNet in general are discussed in I- D.ietf-detnet-architecture and I-D.sdt-detnet-security. Other security considerations will be added in a future version of this draft." "Fixing up MPLS draft as agreed . Also fixing some Warnings in other drafts from doing a full make . LGTM" 0b21ca85c6044156ca532a685e356d3753af13ae 0b21ca85c6044156ca532a685e356d3753af13ae draft-ietf-detnet-mpls 42f5214bb177fd7faf01b7943e7f313a615b2490f9109d5cefa8b24101735c32 ['dbba5d27f625b2298f88e8cf65fe9b3584fb8078028e7996f70d1ba2980b8375', 'e30afecfc76617a262182c81ea5ad3d36ff6cb97f12269ce22b2831c27cb3ab3', 'fa6534a2fea10c93739f34a3a3ebc956aa92d44a1990ef9c3f8c57af2882f9cd', 'a27b19ebc5ff088972123df588cb54d27a8b2814df66c48326738a5967fce4f7', '6d1c378f6ab7bd6ae836d4ac295f0de5a2664c0064bd50ab47c1dde2a64665c8', '3951ac678b26e62e013f5f8c59ef14ad8700f7dd165471e101a3a7c0ccb8bc5f', '133fcdd7e6b5af96f140855c428ebc7639ace6eecf3d1593f5a24b675e96214f', '42f5214bb177fd7faf01b7943e7f313a615b2490f9109d5cefa8b24101735c32', '9660729dcccf51d5b146b7b549f874e0feac220bda1c96d69e1fcfab2efbb95f', 'b6eb9b27803f3286e83df0b11c06a5f220e5d913bbabc9d230793dc4ee281aa3', 'aaa439e1d7bff43da825ea3503724aec00bcdfe7bc48704ec73d2c25140399b4'] A "the security considerations of detnet in general are discussed in i- d.ietf-detnet-architecture and i-d.sdt-detnet-security. other security considerations will be added in a future version of this draft." {67: 1, 26: 1, 52: 1, 115: 1, 110: 1, 87: 1, 102: 1, 84: 1, 13: 1, 15: 1, 36: 1, 114: 1, 53: 1, 90: 1, 6: 2, 79: 2, 51: 2, 130: 2, 62: 4, 85: 5, 68: 4, 35: 3, 91: 3, 97: 2, 31: 2, 38: 2, 124: 3, 98: 2, 54: 2, 127: 3, 8: 2, 96: 2, 64: 2, 30: 2, 61: 3, 55: 3, 27: 2, 129: 3, 76: 6, 131: 5, 113: 3, 99: 2, 72: 2} {86: 1, 97: 1, 156: 1, 169: 1, 172: 1, 229: 1, 272: 1, 289: 1, 315: 1, 352: 1, 353: 1, 365: 1, 369: 1, 402: 1, 1: 9, 4: 2, 9: 5, 10: 3, 15: 2, 24: 2, 25: 4, 26: 5, 27: 2, 39: 5, 43: 3, 49: 4, 50: 3, 58: 3, 59: 2, 64: 2, 69: 4, 81: 5, 82: 3, 96: 2, 100: 6, 108: 3, 109: 4, 110: 4, 111: 2, 114: 3, 115: 4, 116: 2, 118: 6, 119: 5, 120: 3, 121: 4, 122: 3, 123: 2, 124: 4, 128: 2, 129: 2, 130: 3, 132: 4, 136: 2, 145: 4, 147: 2, 151: 2, 152: 2, 154: 3, 161: 3, 162: 3, 165: 3, 168: 4, 180: 2, 184: 5, 187: 5, 188: 4, 191: 3, 194: 4, 202: 5, 203: 6, 206: 2, 207: 3, 215: 2, 217: 3, 218: 8, 220: 2, 221: 2, 222: 5, 224: 3, 227: 4, 234: 5, 235: 2, 241: 2, 242: 2, 243: 4, 244: 2, 245: 4, 248: 2, 250: 3, 258: 11, 262: 4, 263: 5, 264: 3, 267: 4, 270: 2, 273: 5, 287: 3, 291: 3, 299: 4, 300: 2, 304: 2, 309: 3, 314: 2, 320: 4, 323: 4, 327: 4, 328: 3, 329: 2, 330: 10, 334: 2, 335: 2, 341: 4, 342: 5, 347: 4, 348: 4, 350: 7, 351: 3, 358: 4, 366: 2, 371: 6, 372: 3, 376: 2, 384: 3, 385: 2, 386: 3, 387: 2, 392: 3, 393: 4, 396: 5, 397: 7, 398: 6} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 24 MPLS Service Label and d-CW labels at a DetNet end system. "Fixing up MPLS draft as agreed . Also fixing some Warnings in other drafts from doing a full make . LGTM" 0b21ca85c6044156ca532a685e356d3753af13ae 0b21ca85c6044156ca532a685e356d3753af13ae draft-ietf-detnet-mpls b6eb9b27803f3286e83df0b11c06a5f220e5d913bbabc9d230793dc4ee281aa3 ['dbba5d27f625b2298f88e8cf65fe9b3584fb8078028e7996f70d1ba2980b8375', 'e30afecfc76617a262182c81ea5ad3d36ff6cb97f12269ce22b2831c27cb3ab3', 'fa6534a2fea10c93739f34a3a3ebc956aa92d44a1990ef9c3f8c57af2882f9cd', 'a27b19ebc5ff088972123df588cb54d27a8b2814df66c48326738a5967fce4f7', '6d1c378f6ab7bd6ae836d4ac295f0de5a2664c0064bd50ab47c1dde2a64665c8', '3951ac678b26e62e013f5f8c59ef14ad8700f7dd165471e101a3a7c0ccb8bc5f', '133fcdd7e6b5af96f140855c428ebc7639ace6eecf3d1593f5a24b675e96214f', '42f5214bb177fd7faf01b7943e7f313a615b2490f9109d5cefa8b24101735c32', '9660729dcccf51d5b146b7b549f874e0feac220bda1c96d69e1fcfab2efbb95f', 'b6eb9b27803f3286e83df0b11c06a5f220e5d913bbabc9d230793dc4ee281aa3', 'aaa439e1d7bff43da825ea3503724aec00bcdfe7bc48704ec73d2c25140399b4'] B mpls service label and d-cw labels at a detnet end system. {67: 1, 26: 1, 52: 1, 115: 1, 110: 1, 87: 1, 102: 1, 84: 1, 13: 1, 15: 1, 36: 1, 114: 1, 53: 1, 90: 1, 6: 2, 79: 2, 51: 2, 130: 2, 62: 4, 85: 5, 68: 4, 35: 3, 91: 3, 97: 2, 31: 2, 38: 2, 124: 3, 98: 2, 54: 2, 127: 3, 8: 2, 96: 2, 64: 2, 30: 2, 61: 3, 55: 3, 27: 2, 129: 3, 76: 6, 131: 5, 113: 3, 99: 2, 72: 2} {86: 1, 97: 1, 156: 1, 169: 1, 172: 1, 229: 1, 272: 1, 289: 1, 315: 1, 352: 1, 353: 1, 365: 1, 369: 1, 402: 1, 1: 9, 4: 2, 9: 5, 10: 3, 15: 2, 24: 2, 25: 4, 26: 5, 27: 2, 39: 5, 43: 3, 49: 4, 50: 3, 58: 3, 59: 2, 64: 2, 69: 4, 81: 5, 82: 3, 96: 2, 100: 6, 108: 3, 109: 4, 110: 4, 111: 2, 114: 3, 115: 4, 116: 2, 118: 6, 119: 5, 120: 3, 121: 4, 122: 3, 123: 2, 124: 4, 128: 2, 129: 2, 130: 3, 132: 4, 136: 2, 145: 4, 147: 2, 151: 2, 152: 2, 154: 3, 161: 3, 162: 3, 165: 3, 168: 4, 180: 2, 184: 5, 187: 5, 188: 4, 191: 3, 194: 4, 202: 5, 203: 6, 206: 2, 207: 3, 215: 2, 217: 3, 218: 8, 220: 2, 221: 2, 222: 5, 224: 3, 227: 4, 234: 5, 235: 2, 241: 2, 242: 2, 243: 4, 244: 2, 245: 4, 248: 2, 250: 3, 258: 11, 262: 4, 263: 5, 264: 3, 267: 4, 270: 2, 273: 5, 287: 3, 291: 3, 299: 4, 300: 2, 304: 2, 309: 3, 314: 2, 320: 4, 323: 4, 327: 4, 328: 3, 329: 2, 330: 10, 334: 2, 335: 2, 341: 4, 342: 5, 347: 4, 348: 4, 350: 7, 351: 3, 358: 4, 366: 2, 371: 6, 372: 3, 376: 2, 384: 3, 385: 2, 386: 3, 387: 2, 392: 3, 393: 4, 396: 5, 397: 7, 398: 6} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 24 "MPLS Service Label and d-CW in the context of one or more MPLS Forwarding Labels at any DetNet aware device along the path." "Fixing up MPLS draft as agreed . Also fixing some Warnings in other drafts from doing a full make . LGTM" 0b21ca85c6044156ca532a685e356d3753af13ae 0b21ca85c6044156ca532a685e356d3753af13ae draft-ietf-detnet-mpls a27b19ebc5ff088972123df588cb54d27a8b2814df66c48326738a5967fce4f7 ['dbba5d27f625b2298f88e8cf65fe9b3584fb8078028e7996f70d1ba2980b8375', 'e30afecfc76617a262182c81ea5ad3d36ff6cb97f12269ce22b2831c27cb3ab3', 'fa6534a2fea10c93739f34a3a3ebc956aa92d44a1990ef9c3f8c57af2882f9cd', 'a27b19ebc5ff088972123df588cb54d27a8b2814df66c48326738a5967fce4f7', '6d1c378f6ab7bd6ae836d4ac295f0de5a2664c0064bd50ab47c1dde2a64665c8', '3951ac678b26e62e013f5f8c59ef14ad8700f7dd165471e101a3a7c0ccb8bc5f', '133fcdd7e6b5af96f140855c428ebc7639ace6eecf3d1593f5a24b675e96214f', '42f5214bb177fd7faf01b7943e7f313a615b2490f9109d5cefa8b24101735c32', '9660729dcccf51d5b146b7b549f874e0feac220bda1c96d69e1fcfab2efbb95f', 'b6eb9b27803f3286e83df0b11c06a5f220e5d913bbabc9d230793dc4ee281aa3', 'aaa439e1d7bff43da825ea3503724aec00bcdfe7bc48704ec73d2c25140399b4'] B "mpls service label and d-cw in the context of one or more mpls forwarding labels at any detnet aware device along the path." {67: 1, 26: 1, 52: 1, 115: 1, 110: 1, 87: 1, 102: 1, 84: 1, 13: 1, 15: 1, 36: 1, 114: 1, 53: 1, 90: 1, 6: 2, 79: 2, 51: 2, 130: 2, 62: 4, 85: 5, 68: 4, 35: 3, 91: 3, 97: 2, 31: 2, 38: 2, 124: 3, 98: 2, 54: 2, 127: 3, 8: 2, 96: 2, 64: 2, 30: 2, 61: 3, 55: 3, 27: 2, 129: 3, 76: 6, 131: 5, 113: 3, 99: 2, 72: 2} {86: 1, 97: 1, 156: 1, 169: 1, 172: 1, 229: 1, 272: 1, 289: 1, 315: 1, 352: 1, 353: 1, 365: 1, 369: 1, 402: 1, 1: 9, 4: 2, 9: 5, 10: 3, 15: 2, 24: 2, 25: 4, 26: 5, 27: 2, 39: 5, 43: 3, 49: 4, 50: 3, 58: 3, 59: 2, 64: 2, 69: 4, 81: 5, 82: 3, 96: 2, 100: 6, 108: 3, 109: 4, 110: 4, 111: 2, 114: 3, 115: 4, 116: 2, 118: 6, 119: 5, 120: 3, 121: 4, 122: 3, 123: 2, 124: 4, 128: 2, 129: 2, 130: 3, 132: 4, 136: 2, 145: 4, 147: 2, 151: 2, 152: 2, 154: 3, 161: 3, 162: 3, 165: 3, 168: 4, 180: 2, 184: 5, 187: 5, 188: 4, 191: 3, 194: 4, 202: 5, 203: 6, 206: 2, 207: 3, 215: 2, 217: 3, 218: 8, 220: 2, 221: 2, 222: 5, 224: 3, 227: 4, 234: 5, 235: 2, 241: 2, 242: 2, 243: 4, 244: 2, 245: 4, 248: 2, 250: 3, 258: 11, 262: 4, 263: 5, 264: 3, 267: 4, 270: 2, 273: 5, 287: 3, 291: 3, 299: 4, 300: 2, 304: 2, 309: 3, 314: 2, 320: 4, 323: 4, 327: 4, 328: 3, 329: 2, 330: 10, 334: 2, 335: 2, 341: 4, 342: 5, 347: 4, 348: 4, 350: 7, 351: 3, 358: 4, 366: 2, 371: 6, 372: 3, 376: 2, 384: 3, 385: 2, 386: 3, 387: 2, 392: 3, 393: 4, 396: 5, 397: 7, 398: 6} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 24 "Any aggregate flow by one or more MPLS Forwarding Labels at any DetNet aware device along the path." "Fixing up MPLS draft as agreed . Also fixing some Warnings in other drafts from doing a full make . LGTM" 0b21ca85c6044156ca532a685e356d3753af13ae 0b21ca85c6044156ca532a685e356d3753af13ae draft-ietf-detnet-mpls aaa439e1d7bff43da825ea3503724aec00bcdfe7bc48704ec73d2c25140399b4 ['dbba5d27f625b2298f88e8cf65fe9b3584fb8078028e7996f70d1ba2980b8375', 'e30afecfc76617a262182c81ea5ad3d36ff6cb97f12269ce22b2831c27cb3ab3', 'fa6534a2fea10c93739f34a3a3ebc956aa92d44a1990ef9c3f8c57af2882f9cd', 'a27b19ebc5ff088972123df588cb54d27a8b2814df66c48326738a5967fce4f7', '6d1c378f6ab7bd6ae836d4ac295f0de5a2664c0064bd50ab47c1dde2a64665c8', '3951ac678b26e62e013f5f8c59ef14ad8700f7dd165471e101a3a7c0ccb8bc5f', '133fcdd7e6b5af96f140855c428ebc7639ace6eecf3d1593f5a24b675e96214f', '42f5214bb177fd7faf01b7943e7f313a615b2490f9109d5cefa8b24101735c32', '9660729dcccf51d5b146b7b549f874e0feac220bda1c96d69e1fcfab2efbb95f', 'b6eb9b27803f3286e83df0b11c06a5f220e5d913bbabc9d230793dc4ee281aa3', 'aaa439e1d7bff43da825ea3503724aec00bcdfe7bc48704ec73d2c25140399b4'] B "any aggregate flow by one or more mpls forwarding labels at any detnet aware device along the path." {67: 1, 26: 1, 52: 1, 115: 1, 110: 1, 87: 1, 102: 1, 84: 1, 13: 1, 15: 1, 36: 1, 114: 1, 53: 1, 90: 1, 6: 2, 79: 2, 51: 2, 130: 2, 62: 4, 85: 5, 68: 4, 35: 3, 91: 3, 97: 2, 31: 2, 38: 2, 124: 3, 98: 2, 54: 2, 127: 3, 8: 2, 96: 2, 64: 2, 30: 2, 61: 3, 55: 3, 27: 2, 129: 3, 76: 6, 131: 5, 113: 3, 99: 2, 72: 2} {86: 1, 97: 1, 156: 1, 169: 1, 172: 1, 229: 1, 272: 1, 289: 1, 315: 1, 352: 1, 353: 1, 365: 1, 369: 1, 402: 1, 1: 9, 4: 2, 9: 5, 10: 3, 15: 2, 24: 2, 25: 4, 26: 5, 27: 2, 39: 5, 43: 3, 49: 4, 50: 3, 58: 3, 59: 2, 64: 2, 69: 4, 81: 5, 82: 3, 96: 2, 100: 6, 108: 3, 109: 4, 110: 4, 111: 2, 114: 3, 115: 4, 116: 2, 118: 6, 119: 5, 120: 3, 121: 4, 122: 3, 123: 2, 124: 4, 128: 2, 129: 2, 130: 3, 132: 4, 136: 2, 145: 4, 147: 2, 151: 2, 152: 2, 154: 3, 161: 3, 162: 3, 165: 3, 168: 4, 180: 2, 184: 5, 187: 5, 188: 4, 191: 3, 194: 4, 202: 5, 203: 6, 206: 2, 207: 3, 215: 2, 217: 3, 218: 8, 220: 2, 221: 2, 222: 5, 224: 3, 227: 4, 234: 5, 235: 2, 241: 2, 242: 2, 243: 4, 244: 2, 245: 4, 248: 2, 250: 3, 258: 11, 262: 4, 263: 5, 264: 3, 267: 4, 270: 2, 273: 5, 287: 3, 291: 3, 299: 4, 300: 2, 304: 2, 309: 3, 314: 2, 320: 4, 323: 4, 327: 4, 328: 3, 329: 2, 330: 10, 334: 2, 335: 2, 341: 4, 342: 5, 347: 4, 348: 4, 350: 7, 351: 3, 358: 4, 366: 2, 371: 6, 372: 3, 376: 2, 384: 3, 385: 2, 386: 3, 387: 2, 392: 3, 393: 4, 396: 5, 397: 7, 398: 6} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 24 "Any other DetNet flow information for example IP Flow Identification beyond the MPLS service label as specified in I- D.ietf-detnet-ip at a DetNet aware device." "Fixing up MPLS draft as agreed . Also fixing some Warnings in other drafts from doing a full make . LGTM" 0b21ca85c6044156ca532a685e356d3753af13ae 0b21ca85c6044156ca532a685e356d3753af13ae draft-ietf-detnet-mpls 133fcdd7e6b5af96f140855c428ebc7639ace6eecf3d1593f5a24b675e96214f ['dbba5d27f625b2298f88e8cf65fe9b3584fb8078028e7996f70d1ba2980b8375', 'e30afecfc76617a262182c81ea5ad3d36ff6cb97f12269ce22b2831c27cb3ab3', 'fa6534a2fea10c93739f34a3a3ebc956aa92d44a1990ef9c3f8c57af2882f9cd', 'a27b19ebc5ff088972123df588cb54d27a8b2814df66c48326738a5967fce4f7', '6d1c378f6ab7bd6ae836d4ac295f0de5a2664c0064bd50ab47c1dde2a64665c8', '3951ac678b26e62e013f5f8c59ef14ad8700f7dd165471e101a3a7c0ccb8bc5f', '133fcdd7e6b5af96f140855c428ebc7639ace6eecf3d1593f5a24b675e96214f', '42f5214bb177fd7faf01b7943e7f313a615b2490f9109d5cefa8b24101735c32', '9660729dcccf51d5b146b7b549f874e0feac220bda1c96d69e1fcfab2efbb95f', 'b6eb9b27803f3286e83df0b11c06a5f220e5d913bbabc9d230793dc4ee281aa3', 'aaa439e1d7bff43da825ea3503724aec00bcdfe7bc48704ec73d2c25140399b4'] B "any other detnet flow information for example ip flow identification beyond the mpls service label as specified in i- d.ietf-detnet-ip at a detnet aware device." {67: 1, 26: 1, 52: 1, 115: 1, 110: 1, 87: 1, 102: 1, 84: 1, 13: 1, 15: 1, 36: 1, 114: 1, 53: 1, 90: 1, 6: 2, 79: 2, 51: 2, 130: 2, 62: 4, 85: 5, 68: 4, 35: 3, 91: 3, 97: 2, 31: 2, 38: 2, 124: 3, 98: 2, 54: 2, 127: 3, 8: 2, 96: 2, 64: 2, 30: 2, 61: 3, 55: 3, 27: 2, 129: 3, 76: 6, 131: 5, 113: 3, 99: 2, 72: 2} {86: 1, 97: 1, 156: 1, 169: 1, 172: 1, 229: 1, 272: 1, 289: 1, 315: 1, 352: 1, 353: 1, 365: 1, 369: 1, 402: 1, 1: 9, 4: 2, 9: 5, 10: 3, 15: 2, 24: 2, 25: 4, 26: 5, 27: 2, 39: 5, 43: 3, 49: 4, 50: 3, 58: 3, 59: 2, 64: 2, 69: 4, 81: 5, 82: 3, 96: 2, 100: 6, 108: 3, 109: 4, 110: 4, 111: 2, 114: 3, 115: 4, 116: 2, 118: 6, 119: 5, 120: 3, 121: 4, 122: 3, 123: 2, 124: 4, 128: 2, 129: 2, 130: 3, 132: 4, 136: 2, 145: 4, 147: 2, 151: 2, 152: 2, 154: 3, 161: 3, 162: 3, 165: 3, 168: 4, 180: 2, 184: 5, 187: 5, 188: 4, 191: 3, 194: 4, 202: 5, 203: 6, 206: 2, 207: 3, 215: 2, 217: 3, 218: 8, 220: 2, 221: 2, 222: 5, 224: 3, 227: 4, 234: 5, 235: 2, 241: 2, 242: 2, 243: 4, 244: 2, 245: 4, 248: 2, 250: 3, 258: 11, 262: 4, 263: 5, 264: 3, 267: 4, 270: 2, 273: 5, 287: 3, 291: 3, 299: 4, 300: 2, 304: 2, 309: 3, 314: 2, 320: 4, 323: 4, 327: 4, 328: 3, 329: 2, 330: 10, 334: 2, 335: 2, 341: 4, 342: 5, 347: 4, 348: 4, 350: 7, 351: 3, 358: 4, 366: 2, 371: 6, 372: 3, 376: 2, 384: 3, 385: 2, 386: 3, 387: 2, 392: 3, 393: 4, 396: 5, 397: 7, 398: 6} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 24 "Security considerations for DetNet are described in detail in I- D.ietf-detnet-security. General security considerations are described in I-D.ietf-detnet-architecture. This section considers exclusively security considerations which are specific to the DetNet MPLS data plane." "Fixing up MPLS draft as agreed . Also fixing some Warnings in other drafts from doing a full make . LGTM" 0b21ca85c6044156ca532a685e356d3753af13ae 0b21ca85c6044156ca532a685e356d3753af13ae draft-ietf-detnet-mpls 3951ac678b26e62e013f5f8c59ef14ad8700f7dd165471e101a3a7c0ccb8bc5f ['dbba5d27f625b2298f88e8cf65fe9b3584fb8078028e7996f70d1ba2980b8375', 'e30afecfc76617a262182c81ea5ad3d36ff6cb97f12269ce22b2831c27cb3ab3', 'fa6534a2fea10c93739f34a3a3ebc956aa92d44a1990ef9c3f8c57af2882f9cd', 'a27b19ebc5ff088972123df588cb54d27a8b2814df66c48326738a5967fce4f7', '6d1c378f6ab7bd6ae836d4ac295f0de5a2664c0064bd50ab47c1dde2a64665c8', '3951ac678b26e62e013f5f8c59ef14ad8700f7dd165471e101a3a7c0ccb8bc5f', '133fcdd7e6b5af96f140855c428ebc7639ace6eecf3d1593f5a24b675e96214f', '42f5214bb177fd7faf01b7943e7f313a615b2490f9109d5cefa8b24101735c32', '9660729dcccf51d5b146b7b549f874e0feac220bda1c96d69e1fcfab2efbb95f', 'b6eb9b27803f3286e83df0b11c06a5f220e5d913bbabc9d230793dc4ee281aa3', 'aaa439e1d7bff43da825ea3503724aec00bcdfe7bc48704ec73d2c25140399b4'] B "security considerations for detnet are described in detail in i- d.ietf-detnet-security. general security considerations are described in i-d.ietf-detnet-architecture. this section considers exclusively security considerations which are specific to the detnet mpls data plane." {67: 1, 26: 1, 52: 1, 115: 1, 110: 1, 87: 1, 102: 1, 84: 1, 13: 1, 15: 1, 36: 1, 114: 1, 53: 1, 90: 1, 6: 2, 79: 2, 51: 2, 130: 2, 62: 4, 85: 5, 68: 4, 35: 3, 91: 3, 97: 2, 31: 2, 38: 2, 124: 3, 98: 2, 54: 2, 127: 3, 8: 2, 96: 2, 64: 2, 30: 2, 61: 3, 55: 3, 27: 2, 129: 3, 76: 6, 131: 5, 113: 3, 99: 2, 72: 2} {86: 1, 97: 1, 156: 1, 169: 1, 172: 1, 229: 1, 272: 1, 289: 1, 315: 1, 352: 1, 353: 1, 365: 1, 369: 1, 402: 1, 1: 9, 4: 2, 9: 5, 10: 3, 15: 2, 24: 2, 25: 4, 26: 5, 27: 2, 39: 5, 43: 3, 49: 4, 50: 3, 58: 3, 59: 2, 64: 2, 69: 4, 81: 5, 82: 3, 96: 2, 100: 6, 108: 3, 109: 4, 110: 4, 111: 2, 114: 3, 115: 4, 116: 2, 118: 6, 119: 5, 120: 3, 121: 4, 122: 3, 123: 2, 124: 4, 128: 2, 129: 2, 130: 3, 132: 4, 136: 2, 145: 4, 147: 2, 151: 2, 152: 2, 154: 3, 161: 3, 162: 3, 165: 3, 168: 4, 180: 2, 184: 5, 187: 5, 188: 4, 191: 3, 194: 4, 202: 5, 203: 6, 206: 2, 207: 3, 215: 2, 217: 3, 218: 8, 220: 2, 221: 2, 222: 5, 224: 3, 227: 4, 234: 5, 235: 2, 241: 2, 242: 2, 243: 4, 244: 2, 245: 4, 248: 2, 250: 3, 258: 11, 262: 4, 263: 5, 264: 3, 267: 4, 270: 2, 273: 5, 287: 3, 291: 3, 299: 4, 300: 2, 304: 2, 309: 3, 314: 2, 320: 4, 323: 4, 327: 4, 328: 3, 329: 2, 330: 10, 334: 2, 335: 2, 341: 4, 342: 5, 347: 4, 348: 4, 350: 7, 351: 3, 358: 4, 366: 2, 371: 6, 372: 3, 376: 2, 384: 3, 385: 2, 386: 3, 387: 2, 392: 3, 393: 4, 396: 5, 397: 7, 398: 6} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 24 "Security aspects which are unique to DetNet are those whose aim is to provide the specific quality of service aspects of DetNet, which are primarily to deliver data flows with extremely low packet loss rates and bounded end-to-end delivery latency." "Fixing up MPLS draft as agreed . Also fixing some Warnings in other drafts from doing a full make . LGTM" 0b21ca85c6044156ca532a685e356d3753af13ae 0b21ca85c6044156ca532a685e356d3753af13ae draft-ietf-detnet-mpls fa6534a2fea10c93739f34a3a3ebc956aa92d44a1990ef9c3f8c57af2882f9cd ['dbba5d27f625b2298f88e8cf65fe9b3584fb8078028e7996f70d1ba2980b8375', 'e30afecfc76617a262182c81ea5ad3d36ff6cb97f12269ce22b2831c27cb3ab3', 'fa6534a2fea10c93739f34a3a3ebc956aa92d44a1990ef9c3f8c57af2882f9cd', 'a27b19ebc5ff088972123df588cb54d27a8b2814df66c48326738a5967fce4f7', '6d1c378f6ab7bd6ae836d4ac295f0de5a2664c0064bd50ab47c1dde2a64665c8', '3951ac678b26e62e013f5f8c59ef14ad8700f7dd165471e101a3a7c0ccb8bc5f', '133fcdd7e6b5af96f140855c428ebc7639ace6eecf3d1593f5a24b675e96214f', '42f5214bb177fd7faf01b7943e7f313a615b2490f9109d5cefa8b24101735c32', '9660729dcccf51d5b146b7b549f874e0feac220bda1c96d69e1fcfab2efbb95f', 'b6eb9b27803f3286e83df0b11c06a5f220e5d913bbabc9d230793dc4ee281aa3', 'aaa439e1d7bff43da825ea3503724aec00bcdfe7bc48704ec73d2c25140399b4'] B "security aspects which are unique to detnet are those whose aim is to provide the specific quality of service aspects of detnet, which are primarily to deliver data flows with extremely low packet loss rates and bounded end-to-end delivery latency." {67: 1, 26: 1, 52: 1, 115: 1, 110: 1, 87: 1, 102: 1, 84: 1, 13: 1, 15: 1, 36: 1, 114: 1, 53: 1, 90: 1, 6: 2, 79: 2, 51: 2, 130: 2, 62: 4, 85: 5, 68: 4, 35: 3, 91: 3, 97: 2, 31: 2, 38: 2, 124: 3, 98: 2, 54: 2, 127: 3, 8: 2, 96: 2, 64: 2, 30: 2, 61: 3, 55: 3, 27: 2, 129: 3, 76: 6, 131: 5, 113: 3, 99: 2, 72: 2} {86: 1, 97: 1, 156: 1, 169: 1, 172: 1, 229: 1, 272: 1, 289: 1, 315: 1, 352: 1, 353: 1, 365: 1, 369: 1, 402: 1, 1: 9, 4: 2, 9: 5, 10: 3, 15: 2, 24: 2, 25: 4, 26: 5, 27: 2, 39: 5, 43: 3, 49: 4, 50: 3, 58: 3, 59: 2, 64: 2, 69: 4, 81: 5, 82: 3, 96: 2, 100: 6, 108: 3, 109: 4, 110: 4, 111: 2, 114: 3, 115: 4, 116: 2, 118: 6, 119: 5, 120: 3, 121: 4, 122: 3, 123: 2, 124: 4, 128: 2, 129: 2, 130: 3, 132: 4, 136: 2, 145: 4, 147: 2, 151: 2, 152: 2, 154: 3, 161: 3, 162: 3, 165: 3, 168: 4, 180: 2, 184: 5, 187: 5, 188: 4, 191: 3, 194: 4, 202: 5, 203: 6, 206: 2, 207: 3, 215: 2, 217: 3, 218: 8, 220: 2, 221: 2, 222: 5, 224: 3, 227: 4, 234: 5, 235: 2, 241: 2, 242: 2, 243: 4, 244: 2, 245: 4, 248: 2, 250: 3, 258: 11, 262: 4, 263: 5, 264: 3, 267: 4, 270: 2, 273: 5, 287: 3, 291: 3, 299: 4, 300: 2, 304: 2, 309: 3, 314: 2, 320: 4, 323: 4, 327: 4, 328: 3, 329: 2, 330: 10, 334: 2, 335: 2, 341: 4, 342: 5, 347: 4, 348: 4, 350: 7, 351: 3, 358: 4, 366: 2, 371: 6, 372: 3, 376: 2, 384: 3, 385: 2, 386: 3, 387: 2, 392: 3, 393: 4, 396: 5, 397: 7, 398: 6} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 24 "The primary considerations for the data plane is to maintain integrity of data and delivery of the associated DetNet service traversing the DetNet network. Application flows can be protected through whatever means is provided by the underlying technology. For example, encryption may be used, such as that provided by IPSec RFC4301 for IP flows and/or by an underlying sub-net using MACSec IEEE802.1AE-2018 for IP over Ethernet (Layer-2) flows." "Fixing up MPLS draft as agreed . Also fixing some Warnings in other drafts from doing a full make . LGTM" 0b21ca85c6044156ca532a685e356d3753af13ae 0b21ca85c6044156ca532a685e356d3753af13ae draft-ietf-detnet-mpls 6d1c378f6ab7bd6ae836d4ac295f0de5a2664c0064bd50ab47c1dde2a64665c8 ['dbba5d27f625b2298f88e8cf65fe9b3584fb8078028e7996f70d1ba2980b8375', 'e30afecfc76617a262182c81ea5ad3d36ff6cb97f12269ce22b2831c27cb3ab3', 'fa6534a2fea10c93739f34a3a3ebc956aa92d44a1990ef9c3f8c57af2882f9cd', 'a27b19ebc5ff088972123df588cb54d27a8b2814df66c48326738a5967fce4f7', '6d1c378f6ab7bd6ae836d4ac295f0de5a2664c0064bd50ab47c1dde2a64665c8', '3951ac678b26e62e013f5f8c59ef14ad8700f7dd165471e101a3a7c0ccb8bc5f', '133fcdd7e6b5af96f140855c428ebc7639ace6eecf3d1593f5a24b675e96214f', '42f5214bb177fd7faf01b7943e7f313a615b2490f9109d5cefa8b24101735c32', '9660729dcccf51d5b146b7b549f874e0feac220bda1c96d69e1fcfab2efbb95f', 'b6eb9b27803f3286e83df0b11c06a5f220e5d913bbabc9d230793dc4ee281aa3', 'aaa439e1d7bff43da825ea3503724aec00bcdfe7bc48704ec73d2c25140399b4'] B "the primary considerations for the data plane is to maintain integrity of data and delivery of the associated detnet service traversing the detnet network. application flows can be protected through whatever means is provided by the underlying technology. for example, encryption may be used, such as that provided by ipsec rfc4301 for ip flows and/or by an underlying sub-net using macsec ieee802.1ae-2018 for ip over ethernet (layer-2) flows." {67: 1, 26: 1, 52: 1, 115: 1, 110: 1, 87: 1, 102: 1, 84: 1, 13: 1, 15: 1, 36: 1, 114: 1, 53: 1, 90: 1, 6: 2, 79: 2, 51: 2, 130: 2, 62: 4, 85: 5, 68: 4, 35: 3, 91: 3, 97: 2, 31: 2, 38: 2, 124: 3, 98: 2, 54: 2, 127: 3, 8: 2, 96: 2, 64: 2, 30: 2, 61: 3, 55: 3, 27: 2, 129: 3, 76: 6, 131: 5, 113: 3, 99: 2, 72: 2} {86: 1, 97: 1, 156: 1, 169: 1, 172: 1, 229: 1, 272: 1, 289: 1, 315: 1, 352: 1, 353: 1, 365: 1, 369: 1, 402: 1, 1: 9, 4: 2, 9: 5, 10: 3, 15: 2, 24: 2, 25: 4, 26: 5, 27: 2, 39: 5, 43: 3, 49: 4, 50: 3, 58: 3, 59: 2, 64: 2, 69: 4, 81: 5, 82: 3, 96: 2, 100: 6, 108: 3, 109: 4, 110: 4, 111: 2, 114: 3, 115: 4, 116: 2, 118: 6, 119: 5, 120: 3, 121: 4, 122: 3, 123: 2, 124: 4, 128: 2, 129: 2, 130: 3, 132: 4, 136: 2, 145: 4, 147: 2, 151: 2, 152: 2, 154: 3, 161: 3, 162: 3, 165: 3, 168: 4, 180: 2, 184: 5, 187: 5, 188: 4, 191: 3, 194: 4, 202: 5, 203: 6, 206: 2, 207: 3, 215: 2, 217: 3, 218: 8, 220: 2, 221: 2, 222: 5, 224: 3, 227: 4, 234: 5, 235: 2, 241: 2, 242: 2, 243: 4, 244: 2, 245: 4, 248: 2, 250: 3, 258: 11, 262: 4, 263: 5, 264: 3, 267: 4, 270: 2, 273: 5, 287: 3, 291: 3, 299: 4, 300: 2, 304: 2, 309: 3, 314: 2, 320: 4, 323: 4, 327: 4, 328: 3, 329: 2, 330: 10, 334: 2, 335: 2, 341: 4, 342: 5, 347: 4, 348: 4, 350: 7, 351: 3, 358: 4, 366: 2, 371: 6, 372: 3, 376: 2, 384: 3, 385: 2, 386: 3, 387: 2, 392: 3, 393: 4, 396: 5, 397: 7, 398: 6} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 24 "From a data plane perspective this document does not add or modify any header information." "Fixing up MPLS draft as agreed . Also fixing some Warnings in other drafts from doing a full make . LGTM" 0b21ca85c6044156ca532a685e356d3753af13ae 0b21ca85c6044156ca532a685e356d3753af13ae draft-ietf-detnet-mpls e30afecfc76617a262182c81ea5ad3d36ff6cb97f12269ce22b2831c27cb3ab3 ['dbba5d27f625b2298f88e8cf65fe9b3584fb8078028e7996f70d1ba2980b8375', 'e30afecfc76617a262182c81ea5ad3d36ff6cb97f12269ce22b2831c27cb3ab3', 'fa6534a2fea10c93739f34a3a3ebc956aa92d44a1990ef9c3f8c57af2882f9cd', 'a27b19ebc5ff088972123df588cb54d27a8b2814df66c48326738a5967fce4f7', '6d1c378f6ab7bd6ae836d4ac295f0de5a2664c0064bd50ab47c1dde2a64665c8', '3951ac678b26e62e013f5f8c59ef14ad8700f7dd165471e101a3a7c0ccb8bc5f', '133fcdd7e6b5af96f140855c428ebc7639ace6eecf3d1593f5a24b675e96214f', '42f5214bb177fd7faf01b7943e7f313a615b2490f9109d5cefa8b24101735c32', '9660729dcccf51d5b146b7b549f874e0feac220bda1c96d69e1fcfab2efbb95f', 'b6eb9b27803f3286e83df0b11c06a5f220e5d913bbabc9d230793dc4ee281aa3', 'aaa439e1d7bff43da825ea3503724aec00bcdfe7bc48704ec73d2c25140399b4'] B "from a data plane perspective this document does not add or modify any header information." {67: 1, 26: 1, 52: 1, 115: 1, 110: 1, 87: 1, 102: 1, 84: 1, 13: 1, 15: 1, 36: 1, 114: 1, 53: 1, 90: 1, 6: 2, 79: 2, 51: 2, 130: 2, 62: 4, 85: 5, 68: 4, 35: 3, 91: 3, 97: 2, 31: 2, 38: 2, 124: 3, 98: 2, 54: 2, 127: 3, 8: 2, 96: 2, 64: 2, 30: 2, 61: 3, 55: 3, 27: 2, 129: 3, 76: 6, 131: 5, 113: 3, 99: 2, 72: 2} {86: 1, 97: 1, 156: 1, 169: 1, 172: 1, 229: 1, 272: 1, 289: 1, 315: 1, 352: 1, 353: 1, 365: 1, 369: 1, 402: 1, 1: 9, 4: 2, 9: 5, 10: 3, 15: 2, 24: 2, 25: 4, 26: 5, 27: 2, 39: 5, 43: 3, 49: 4, 50: 3, 58: 3, 59: 2, 64: 2, 69: 4, 81: 5, 82: 3, 96: 2, 100: 6, 108: 3, 109: 4, 110: 4, 111: 2, 114: 3, 115: 4, 116: 2, 118: 6, 119: 5, 120: 3, 121: 4, 122: 3, 123: 2, 124: 4, 128: 2, 129: 2, 130: 3, 132: 4, 136: 2, 145: 4, 147: 2, 151: 2, 152: 2, 154: 3, 161: 3, 162: 3, 165: 3, 168: 4, 180: 2, 184: 5, 187: 5, 188: 4, 191: 3, 194: 4, 202: 5, 203: 6, 206: 2, 207: 3, 215: 2, 217: 3, 218: 8, 220: 2, 221: 2, 222: 5, 224: 3, 227: 4, 234: 5, 235: 2, 241: 2, 242: 2, 243: 4, 244: 2, 245: 4, 248: 2, 250: 3, 258: 11, 262: 4, 263: 5, 264: 3, 267: 4, 270: 2, 273: 5, 287: 3, 291: 3, 299: 4, 300: 2, 304: 2, 309: 3, 314: 2, 320: 4, 323: 4, 327: 4, 328: 3, 329: 2, 330: 10, 334: 2, 335: 2, 341: 4, 342: 5, 347: 4, 348: 4, 350: 7, 351: 3, 358: 4, 366: 2, 371: 6, 372: 3, 376: 2, 384: 3, 385: 2, 386: 3, 387: 2, 392: 3, 393: 4, 396: 5, 397: 7, 398: 6} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 24 "At the management and control level DetNet flows are identified on a per-flow basis, which may provide controller plane attackers with additional information about the data flows (when compared to controller planes that do not include per-flow identification). This is an inherent property of DetNet which has security implications that should be considered when determining if DetNet is a suitable technology for any given use case." "Fixing up MPLS draft as agreed . Also fixing some Warnings in other drafts from doing a full make . LGTM" 0b21ca85c6044156ca532a685e356d3753af13ae 0b21ca85c6044156ca532a685e356d3753af13ae draft-ietf-detnet-mpls dbba5d27f625b2298f88e8cf65fe9b3584fb8078028e7996f70d1ba2980b8375 ['dbba5d27f625b2298f88e8cf65fe9b3584fb8078028e7996f70d1ba2980b8375', 'e30afecfc76617a262182c81ea5ad3d36ff6cb97f12269ce22b2831c27cb3ab3', 'fa6534a2fea10c93739f34a3a3ebc956aa92d44a1990ef9c3f8c57af2882f9cd', 'a27b19ebc5ff088972123df588cb54d27a8b2814df66c48326738a5967fce4f7', '6d1c378f6ab7bd6ae836d4ac295f0de5a2664c0064bd50ab47c1dde2a64665c8', '3951ac678b26e62e013f5f8c59ef14ad8700f7dd165471e101a3a7c0ccb8bc5f', '133fcdd7e6b5af96f140855c428ebc7639ace6eecf3d1593f5a24b675e96214f', '42f5214bb177fd7faf01b7943e7f313a615b2490f9109d5cefa8b24101735c32', '9660729dcccf51d5b146b7b549f874e0feac220bda1c96d69e1fcfab2efbb95f', 'b6eb9b27803f3286e83df0b11c06a5f220e5d913bbabc9d230793dc4ee281aa3', 'aaa439e1d7bff43da825ea3503724aec00bcdfe7bc48704ec73d2c25140399b4'] B "at the management and control level detnet flows are identified on a per-flow basis, which may provide controller plane attackers with additional information about the data flows (when compared to controller planes that do not include per-flow identification). this is an inherent property of detnet which has security implications that should be considered when determining if detnet is a suitable technology for any given use case." {67: 1, 26: 1, 52: 1, 115: 1, 110: 1, 87: 1, 102: 1, 84: 1, 13: 1, 15: 1, 36: 1, 114: 1, 53: 1, 90: 1, 6: 2, 79: 2, 51: 2, 130: 2, 62: 4, 85: 5, 68: 4, 35: 3, 91: 3, 97: 2, 31: 2, 38: 2, 124: 3, 98: 2, 54: 2, 127: 3, 8: 2, 96: 2, 64: 2, 30: 2, 61: 3, 55: 3, 27: 2, 129: 3, 76: 6, 131: 5, 113: 3, 99: 2, 72: 2} {86: 1, 97: 1, 156: 1, 169: 1, 172: 1, 229: 1, 272: 1, 289: 1, 315: 1, 352: 1, 353: 1, 365: 1, 369: 1, 402: 1, 1: 9, 4: 2, 9: 5, 10: 3, 15: 2, 24: 2, 25: 4, 26: 5, 27: 2, 39: 5, 43: 3, 49: 4, 50: 3, 58: 3, 59: 2, 64: 2, 69: 4, 81: 5, 82: 3, 96: 2, 100: 6, 108: 3, 109: 4, 110: 4, 111: 2, 114: 3, 115: 4, 116: 2, 118: 6, 119: 5, 120: 3, 121: 4, 122: 3, 123: 2, 124: 4, 128: 2, 129: 2, 130: 3, 132: 4, 136: 2, 145: 4, 147: 2, 151: 2, 152: 2, 154: 3, 161: 3, 162: 3, 165: 3, 168: 4, 180: 2, 184: 5, 187: 5, 188: 4, 191: 3, 194: 4, 202: 5, 203: 6, 206: 2, 207: 3, 215: 2, 217: 3, 218: 8, 220: 2, 221: 2, 222: 5, 224: 3, 227: 4, 234: 5, 235: 2, 241: 2, 242: 2, 243: 4, 244: 2, 245: 4, 248: 2, 250: 3, 258: 11, 262: 4, 263: 5, 264: 3, 267: 4, 270: 2, 273: 5, 287: 3, 291: 3, 299: 4, 300: 2, 304: 2, 309: 3, 314: 2, 320: 4, 323: 4, 327: 4, 328: 3, 329: 2, 330: 10, 334: 2, 335: 2, 341: 4, 342: 5, 347: 4, 348: 4, 350: 7, 351: 3, 358: 4, 366: 2, 371: 6, 372: 3, 376: 2, 384: 3, 385: 2, 386: 3, 387: 2, 392: 3, 393: 4, 396: 5, 397: 7, 398: 6} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 24 "To provide uninterrupted availability of the DetNet service, provisions can be made against DOS attacks and delay attacks. To protect against DOS attacks, excess traffic due to malicious or malfunctioning devices can be prevented or mitigated, for example through the use of existing mechanism such as policing and shaping applied at the input of a DetNet domain. To prevent DetNet packets from being delayed by an entity external to a DetNet domain, DetNet technology definition can allow for the mitigation of Man-In-The- Middle attacks, for example through use of authentication and authorization of devices within the DetNet domain." "Fixing up MPLS draft as agreed . Also fixing some Warnings in other drafts from doing a full make . LGTM" 0b21ca85c6044156ca532a685e356d3753af13ae 0b21ca85c6044156ca532a685e356d3753af13ae draft-ietf-detnet-mpls 9660729dcccf51d5b146b7b549f874e0feac220bda1c96d69e1fcfab2efbb95f ['dbba5d27f625b2298f88e8cf65fe9b3584fb8078028e7996f70d1ba2980b8375', 'e30afecfc76617a262182c81ea5ad3d36ff6cb97f12269ce22b2831c27cb3ab3', 'fa6534a2fea10c93739f34a3a3ebc956aa92d44a1990ef9c3f8c57af2882f9cd', 'a27b19ebc5ff088972123df588cb54d27a8b2814df66c48326738a5967fce4f7', '6d1c378f6ab7bd6ae836d4ac295f0de5a2664c0064bd50ab47c1dde2a64665c8', '3951ac678b26e62e013f5f8c59ef14ad8700f7dd165471e101a3a7c0ccb8bc5f', '133fcdd7e6b5af96f140855c428ebc7639ace6eecf3d1593f5a24b675e96214f', '42f5214bb177fd7faf01b7943e7f313a615b2490f9109d5cefa8b24101735c32', '9660729dcccf51d5b146b7b549f874e0feac220bda1c96d69e1fcfab2efbb95f', 'b6eb9b27803f3286e83df0b11c06a5f220e5d913bbabc9d230793dc4ee281aa3', 'aaa439e1d7bff43da825ea3503724aec00bcdfe7bc48704ec73d2c25140399b4'] B "to provide uninterrupted availability of the detnet service, provisions can be made against dos attacks and delay attacks. to protect against dos attacks, excess traffic due to malicious or malfunctioning devices can be prevented or mitigated, for example through the use of existing mechanism such as policing and shaping applied at the input of a detnet domain. to prevent detnet packets from being delayed by an entity external to a detnet domain, detnet technology definition can allow for the mitigation of man-in-the- middle attacks, for example through use of authentication and authorization of devices within the detnet domain." {67: 1, 26: 1, 52: 1, 115: 1, 110: 1, 87: 1, 102: 1, 84: 1, 13: 1, 15: 1, 36: 1, 114: 1, 53: 1, 90: 1, 6: 2, 79: 2, 51: 2, 130: 2, 62: 4, 85: 5, 68: 4, 35: 3, 91: 3, 97: 2, 31: 2, 38: 2, 124: 3, 98: 2, 54: 2, 127: 3, 8: 2, 96: 2, 64: 2, 30: 2, 61: 3, 55: 3, 27: 2, 129: 3, 76: 6, 131: 5, 113: 3, 99: 2, 72: 2} {86: 1, 97: 1, 156: 1, 169: 1, 172: 1, 229: 1, 272: 1, 289: 1, 315: 1, 352: 1, 353: 1, 365: 1, 369: 1, 402: 1, 1: 9, 4: 2, 9: 5, 10: 3, 15: 2, 24: 2, 25: 4, 26: 5, 27: 2, 39: 5, 43: 3, 49: 4, 50: 3, 58: 3, 59: 2, 64: 2, 69: 4, 81: 5, 82: 3, 96: 2, 100: 6, 108: 3, 109: 4, 110: 4, 111: 2, 114: 3, 115: 4, 116: 2, 118: 6, 119: 5, 120: 3, 121: 4, 122: 3, 123: 2, 124: 4, 128: 2, 129: 2, 130: 3, 132: 4, 136: 2, 145: 4, 147: 2, 151: 2, 152: 2, 154: 3, 161: 3, 162: 3, 165: 3, 168: 4, 180: 2, 184: 5, 187: 5, 188: 4, 191: 3, 194: 4, 202: 5, 203: 6, 206: 2, 207: 3, 215: 2, 217: 3, 218: 8, 220: 2, 221: 2, 222: 5, 224: 3, 227: 4, 234: 5, 235: 2, 241: 2, 242: 2, 243: 4, 244: 2, 245: 4, 248: 2, 250: 3, 258: 11, 262: 4, 263: 5, 264: 3, 267: 4, 270: 2, 273: 5, 287: 3, 291: 3, 299: 4, 300: 2, 304: 2, 309: 3, 314: 2, 320: 4, 323: 4, 327: 4, 328: 3, 329: 2, 330: 10, 334: 2, 335: 2, 341: 4, 342: 5, 347: 4, 348: 4, 350: 7, 351: 3, 358: 4, 366: 2, 371: 6, 372: 3, 376: 2, 384: 3, 385: 2, 386: 3, 387: 2, 392: 3, 393: 4, 396: 5, 397: 7, 398: 6} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 15 "Security considerations for DetNet are described in detail in I- D.ietf-detnet-security. This section considers exclusively security considerations which are specific to the DetNet data plane." Sorry , now it is uploaded to the right folder . Simple accept pull request . Thx Bala'zs 13e6a4040b5ee178ec427163555ef49bc73addbb 13e6a4040b5ee178ec427163555ef49bc73addbb draft-ietf-detnet-ip 003417ac9c913b228d19e5d11bf5645308f0f32a8c98b8299585c638d9421191 ['5fb337c0ea74cb1ccd64478106e7c2651e41470c7d941503b9db8f2960086545', '003417ac9c913b228d19e5d11bf5645308f0f32a8c98b8299585c638d9421191'] A "security considerations for detnet are described in detail in i- d.ietf-detnet-security. this section considers exclusively security considerations which are specific to the detnet data plane." {67: 1, 13: 1, 6: 4, 79: 4, 90: 2, 51: 2, 130: 4, 62: 6, 85: 7, 68: 6, 35: 5, 110: 3, 91: 4, 114: 3, 97: 4, 31: 3, 38: 4, 26: 3, 124: 5, 98: 4, 54: 4, 127: 5, 8: 4, 96: 4, 64: 3, 30: 2, 61: 5, 55: 5, 27: 4, 52: 3, 129: 5, 115: 2, 84: 3, 76: 8, 87: 3, 131: 7, 102: 2, 113: 5, 99: 4, 15: 2, 36: 2, 24: 2, 53: 3, 72: 4} {152: 1, 315: 1, 1: 11, 4: 4, 9: 7, 10: 5, 15: 4, 24: 4, 25: 6, 26: 7, 27: 2, 39: 7, 43: 5, 49: 5, 50: 4, 58: 5, 59: 4, 64: 4, 69: 6, 81: 7, 82: 5, 86: 3, 96: 4, 97: 3, 100: 8, 108: 5, 109: 6, 110: 6, 111: 4, 114: 5, 115: 6, 116: 4, 118: 8, 119: 7, 120: 5, 121: 6, 122: 5, 123: 4, 124: 6, 128: 3, 129: 2, 130: 5, 132: 6, 136: 4, 145: 6, 147: 4, 154: 5, 156: 3, 161: 5, 162: 5, 165: 5, 168: 6, 169: 2, 172: 3, 180: 3, 184: 7, 187: 7, 188: 6, 191: 5, 194: 6, 202: 7, 203: 8, 206: 4, 207: 5, 215: 4, 217: 5, 218: 10, 220: 4, 221: 4, 222: 7, 224: 5, 227: 6, 229: 3, 234: 7, 235: 4, 241: 4, 242: 4, 243: 6, 244: 3, 245: 6, 248: 3, 250: 5, 258: 13, 262: 6, 263: 7, 264: 5, 267: 6, 270: 4, 272: 2, 273: 7, 287: 5, 289: 3, 291: 5, 299: 6, 300: 4, 304: 4, 309: 5, 314: 4, 320: 6, 323: 6, 327: 6, 328: 5, 329: 4, 330: 12, 334: 4, 335: 4, 341: 6, 342: 7, 347: 6, 348: 6, 350: 9, 351: 4, 352: 2, 353: 2, 354: 2, 358: 6, 365: 3, 366: 4, 369: 3, 371: 8, 372: 5, 376: 4, 384: 5, 385: 4, 386: 5, 387: 4, 392: 5, 393: 6, 396: 7, 397: 9, 398: 8, 402: 2} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 15 "Security considerations for DetNet are described in detail in I- D.ietf-detnet-security. General security considerations are described in I-D.ietf-detnet-architecture. This section considers exclusively security considerations which are specific to the DetNet IP data plane." Sorry , now it is uploaded to the right folder . Simple accept pull request . Thx Bala'zs 13e6a4040b5ee178ec427163555ef49bc73addbb 13e6a4040b5ee178ec427163555ef49bc73addbb draft-ietf-detnet-ip 5fb337c0ea74cb1ccd64478106e7c2651e41470c7d941503b9db8f2960086545 ['5fb337c0ea74cb1ccd64478106e7c2651e41470c7d941503b9db8f2960086545', '003417ac9c913b228d19e5d11bf5645308f0f32a8c98b8299585c638d9421191'] B "security considerations for detnet are described in detail in i- d.ietf-detnet-security. general security considerations are described in i-d.ietf-detnet-architecture. this section considers exclusively security considerations which are specific to the detnet ip data plane." {67: 1, 13: 1, 6: 4, 79: 4, 90: 2, 51: 2, 130: 4, 62: 6, 85: 7, 68: 6, 35: 5, 110: 3, 91: 4, 114: 3, 97: 4, 31: 3, 38: 4, 26: 3, 124: 5, 98: 4, 54: 4, 127: 5, 8: 4, 96: 4, 64: 3, 30: 2, 61: 5, 55: 5, 27: 4, 52: 3, 129: 5, 115: 2, 84: 3, 76: 8, 87: 3, 131: 7, 102: 2, 113: 5, 99: 4, 15: 2, 36: 2, 24: 2, 53: 3, 72: 4} {152: 1, 315: 1, 1: 11, 4: 4, 9: 7, 10: 5, 15: 4, 24: 4, 25: 6, 26: 7, 27: 2, 39: 7, 43: 5, 49: 5, 50: 4, 58: 5, 59: 4, 64: 4, 69: 6, 81: 7, 82: 5, 86: 3, 96: 4, 97: 3, 100: 8, 108: 5, 109: 6, 110: 6, 111: 4, 114: 5, 115: 6, 116: 4, 118: 8, 119: 7, 120: 5, 121: 6, 122: 5, 123: 4, 124: 6, 128: 3, 129: 2, 130: 5, 132: 6, 136: 4, 145: 6, 147: 4, 154: 5, 156: 3, 161: 5, 162: 5, 165: 5, 168: 6, 169: 2, 172: 3, 180: 3, 184: 7, 187: 7, 188: 6, 191: 5, 194: 6, 202: 7, 203: 8, 206: 4, 207: 5, 215: 4, 217: 5, 218: 10, 220: 4, 221: 4, 222: 7, 224: 5, 227: 6, 229: 3, 234: 7, 235: 4, 241: 4, 242: 4, 243: 6, 244: 3, 245: 6, 248: 3, 250: 5, 258: 13, 262: 6, 263: 7, 264: 5, 267: 6, 270: 4, 272: 2, 273: 7, 287: 5, 289: 3, 291: 5, 299: 6, 300: 4, 304: 4, 309: 5, 314: 4, 320: 6, 323: 6, 327: 6, 328: 5, 329: 4, 330: 12, 334: 4, 335: 4, 341: 6, 342: 7, 347: 6, 348: 6, 350: 9, 351: 4, 352: 2, 353: 2, 354: 2, 358: 6, 365: 3, 366: 4, 369: 3, 371: 8, 372: 5, 376: 4, 384: 5, 385: 4, 386: 5, 387: 4, 392: 5, 393: 6, 396: 7, 397: 9, 398: 8, 402: 2} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 15 "The primary considerations for the data plane is to maintain confidentiality of data traversing the DetNet network, application flows can be protected through whatever means is provided by the underlying technology. For example, encryption may be used, such as that provided by IPSec RFC4301 for IP flows and by MACSec IEEE802.1AE-2018 for Ethernet (Layer-2) flows." Sorry , now it is uploaded to the right folder . Simple accept pull request . Thx Bala'zs 13e6a4040b5ee178ec427163555ef49bc73addbb 13e6a4040b5ee178ec427163555ef49bc73addbb draft-ietf-detnet-ip 411bab8931d489563f977381e3894cd0e25732a1b7b48a8a12cd2c9e73861d63 ['dbba5d27f625b2298f88e8cf65fe9b3584fb8078028e7996f70d1ba2980b8375', '411bab8931d489563f977381e3894cd0e25732a1b7b48a8a12cd2c9e73861d63', '1b81d0fe069e37f43fed41972f277c89b8af99a31ef2ade21122ccc3858575eb', 'e30afecfc76617a262182c81ea5ad3d36ff6cb97f12269ce22b2831c27cb3ab3', '6d1c378f6ab7bd6ae836d4ac295f0de5a2664c0064bd50ab47c1dde2a64665c8', 'c94b8af475141e8e80f0a566a4992152bf7e976170d401ce52917ccef07d1727', '9660729dcccf51d5b146b7b549f874e0feac220bda1c96d69e1fcfab2efbb95f', '15ff22f9bc26e370df616e5fea201eedd1eb8cb603c7d43d869f305816cda39b'] A "the primary considerations for the data plane is to maintain confidentiality of data traversing the detnet network, application flows can be protected through whatever means is provided by the underlying technology. for example, encryption may be used, such as that provided by ipsec rfc4301 for ip flows and by macsec ieee802.1ae-2018 for ethernet (layer-2) flows." {110: 1, 87: 1, 102: 1, 84: 1, 13: 1, 36: 1, 24: 1, 114: 1, 6: 3, 79: 3, 90: 2, 51: 2, 130: 3, 62: 5, 85: 6, 68: 5, 35: 4, 91: 3, 97: 3, 31: 3, 67: 2, 38: 3, 26: 2, 124: 4, 98: 3, 54: 3, 127: 4, 8: 3, 96: 3, 64: 2, 30: 2, 61: 4, 55: 4, 27: 3, 15: 2, 52: 2, 129: 4, 115: 2, 76: 7, 131: 6, 113: 4, 99: 3, 53: 2, 72: 3} {172: 1, 229: 1, 272: 1, 289: 1, 315: 1, 353: 1, 354: 1, 365: 1, 1: 10, 4: 3, 9: 6, 10: 4, 15: 3, 24: 3, 25: 5, 26: 6, 27: 2, 39: 6, 43: 4, 49: 4, 50: 3, 58: 4, 59: 3, 64: 3, 69: 5, 81: 6, 82: 4, 86: 2, 96: 3, 97: 2, 100: 7, 108: 4, 109: 5, 110: 5, 111: 3, 114: 4, 115: 5, 116: 3, 118: 7, 119: 6, 120: 4, 121: 5, 122: 4, 123: 3, 124: 5, 128: 2, 129: 2, 130: 4, 132: 5, 136: 3, 145: 5, 147: 3, 151: 2, 152: 2, 154: 4, 156: 2, 161: 4, 162: 4, 165: 4, 168: 5, 169: 2, 180: 2, 184: 6, 187: 6, 188: 5, 191: 4, 194: 5, 202: 6, 203: 7, 206: 3, 207: 4, 215: 3, 217: 4, 218: 9, 220: 3, 221: 3, 222: 6, 224: 4, 227: 5, 234: 6, 235: 3, 241: 3, 242: 3, 243: 5, 244: 3, 245: 5, 248: 3, 250: 4, 258: 12, 262: 5, 263: 6, 264: 4, 267: 5, 270: 3, 273: 6, 287: 4, 291: 4, 299: 5, 300: 3, 304: 3, 309: 4, 314: 3, 320: 5, 323: 5, 327: 5, 328: 4, 329: 3, 330: 11, 334: 3, 335: 3, 341: 5, 342: 6, 347: 5, 348: 5, 350: 8, 351: 4, 358: 5, 366: 3, 369: 2, 371: 7, 372: 4, 376: 3, 384: 4, 385: 3, 386: 4, 387: 3, 392: 4, 393: 5, 396: 6, 397: 8, 398: 7, 402: 2} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 15 "DetNet flows are identified on a per-flow basis, which may provide attackers with additional information about the data flows (when compared to networks that do not include per-flow identification). This is an inherent property of DetNet which has security implications that should be considered when determining if DetNet is a suitable technology for any given use case." Sorry , now it is uploaded to the right folder . Simple accept pull request . Thx Bala'zs 13e6a4040b5ee178ec427163555ef49bc73addbb 13e6a4040b5ee178ec427163555ef49bc73addbb draft-ietf-detnet-ip 15ff22f9bc26e370df616e5fea201eedd1eb8cb603c7d43d869f305816cda39b ['dbba5d27f625b2298f88e8cf65fe9b3584fb8078028e7996f70d1ba2980b8375', '411bab8931d489563f977381e3894cd0e25732a1b7b48a8a12cd2c9e73861d63', '1b81d0fe069e37f43fed41972f277c89b8af99a31ef2ade21122ccc3858575eb', 'e30afecfc76617a262182c81ea5ad3d36ff6cb97f12269ce22b2831c27cb3ab3', '6d1c378f6ab7bd6ae836d4ac295f0de5a2664c0064bd50ab47c1dde2a64665c8', 'c94b8af475141e8e80f0a566a4992152bf7e976170d401ce52917ccef07d1727', '9660729dcccf51d5b146b7b549f874e0feac220bda1c96d69e1fcfab2efbb95f', '15ff22f9bc26e370df616e5fea201eedd1eb8cb603c7d43d869f305816cda39b'] A "detnet flows are identified on a per-flow basis, which may provide attackers with additional information about the data flows (when compared to networks that do not include per-flow identification). this is an inherent property of detnet which has security implications that should be considered when determining if detnet is a suitable technology for any given use case." {110: 1, 87: 1, 102: 1, 84: 1, 13: 1, 36: 1, 24: 1, 114: 1, 6: 3, 79: 3, 90: 2, 51: 2, 130: 3, 62: 5, 85: 6, 68: 5, 35: 4, 91: 3, 97: 3, 31: 3, 67: 2, 38: 3, 26: 2, 124: 4, 98: 3, 54: 3, 127: 4, 8: 3, 96: 3, 64: 2, 30: 2, 61: 4, 55: 4, 27: 3, 15: 2, 52: 2, 129: 4, 115: 2, 76: 7, 131: 6, 113: 4, 99: 3, 53: 2, 72: 3} {172: 1, 229: 1, 272: 1, 289: 1, 315: 1, 353: 1, 354: 1, 365: 1, 1: 10, 4: 3, 9: 6, 10: 4, 15: 3, 24: 3, 25: 5, 26: 6, 27: 2, 39: 6, 43: 4, 49: 4, 50: 3, 58: 4, 59: 3, 64: 3, 69: 5, 81: 6, 82: 4, 86: 2, 96: 3, 97: 2, 100: 7, 108: 4, 109: 5, 110: 5, 111: 3, 114: 4, 115: 5, 116: 3, 118: 7, 119: 6, 120: 4, 121: 5, 122: 4, 123: 3, 124: 5, 128: 2, 129: 2, 130: 4, 132: 5, 136: 3, 145: 5, 147: 3, 151: 2, 152: 2, 154: 4, 156: 2, 161: 4, 162: 4, 165: 4, 168: 5, 169: 2, 180: 2, 184: 6, 187: 6, 188: 5, 191: 4, 194: 5, 202: 6, 203: 7, 206: 3, 207: 4, 215: 3, 217: 4, 218: 9, 220: 3, 221: 3, 222: 6, 224: 4, 227: 5, 234: 6, 235: 3, 241: 3, 242: 3, 243: 5, 244: 3, 245: 5, 248: 3, 250: 4, 258: 12, 262: 5, 263: 6, 264: 4, 267: 5, 270: 3, 273: 6, 287: 4, 291: 4, 299: 5, 300: 3, 304: 3, 309: 4, 314: 3, 320: 5, 323: 5, 327: 5, 328: 4, 329: 3, 330: 11, 334: 3, 335: 3, 341: 5, 342: 6, 347: 5, 348: 5, 350: 8, 351: 4, 358: 5, 366: 3, 369: 2, 371: 7, 372: 4, 376: 3, 384: 4, 385: 3, 386: 4, 387: 3, 392: 4, 393: 5, 396: 6, 397: 8, 398: 7, 402: 2} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 15 "To provide uninterrupted availability of the DetNet quality of service, provisions can be made against DOS attacks and delay attacks. To protect against DOS attacks, excess traffic due to malicious or malfunctioning devices can be prevented or mitigated, for example through the use of traffic admission control applied at the input of a DetNet domain. To prevent DetNet packets from being delayed by an entityexternal to a DetNet domain, DetNet technology definition can allow for the mitigation of Man-In-The-Middle attacks, for example through use of authentication and authorization of devices within the DetNet domain." Sorry , now it is uploaded to the right folder . Simple accept pull request . Thx Bala'zs 13e6a4040b5ee178ec427163555ef49bc73addbb 13e6a4040b5ee178ec427163555ef49bc73addbb draft-ietf-detnet-ip 1b81d0fe069e37f43fed41972f277c89b8af99a31ef2ade21122ccc3858575eb ['dbba5d27f625b2298f88e8cf65fe9b3584fb8078028e7996f70d1ba2980b8375', '411bab8931d489563f977381e3894cd0e25732a1b7b48a8a12cd2c9e73861d63', '1b81d0fe069e37f43fed41972f277c89b8af99a31ef2ade21122ccc3858575eb', 'e30afecfc76617a262182c81ea5ad3d36ff6cb97f12269ce22b2831c27cb3ab3', '6d1c378f6ab7bd6ae836d4ac295f0de5a2664c0064bd50ab47c1dde2a64665c8', 'c94b8af475141e8e80f0a566a4992152bf7e976170d401ce52917ccef07d1727', '9660729dcccf51d5b146b7b549f874e0feac220bda1c96d69e1fcfab2efbb95f', '15ff22f9bc26e370df616e5fea201eedd1eb8cb603c7d43d869f305816cda39b'] A "to provide uninterrupted availability of the detnet quality of service, provisions can be made against dos attacks and delay attacks. to protect against dos attacks, excess traffic due to malicious or malfunctioning devices can be prevented or mitigated, for example through the use of traffic admission control applied at the input of a detnet domain. to prevent detnet packets from being delayed by an entityexternal to a detnet domain, detnet technology definition can allow for the mitigation of man-in-the-middle attacks, for example through use of authentication and authorization of devices within the detnet domain." {110: 1, 87: 1, 102: 1, 84: 1, 13: 1, 36: 1, 24: 1, 114: 1, 6: 3, 79: 3, 90: 2, 51: 2, 130: 3, 62: 5, 85: 6, 68: 5, 35: 4, 91: 3, 97: 3, 31: 3, 67: 2, 38: 3, 26: 2, 124: 4, 98: 3, 54: 3, 127: 4, 8: 3, 96: 3, 64: 2, 30: 2, 61: 4, 55: 4, 27: 3, 15: 2, 52: 2, 129: 4, 115: 2, 76: 7, 131: 6, 113: 4, 99: 3, 53: 2, 72: 3} {172: 1, 229: 1, 272: 1, 289: 1, 315: 1, 353: 1, 354: 1, 365: 1, 1: 10, 4: 3, 9: 6, 10: 4, 15: 3, 24: 3, 25: 5, 26: 6, 27: 2, 39: 6, 43: 4, 49: 4, 50: 3, 58: 4, 59: 3, 64: 3, 69: 5, 81: 6, 82: 4, 86: 2, 96: 3, 97: 2, 100: 7, 108: 4, 109: 5, 110: 5, 111: 3, 114: 4, 115: 5, 116: 3, 118: 7, 119: 6, 120: 4, 121: 5, 122: 4, 123: 3, 124: 5, 128: 2, 129: 2, 130: 4, 132: 5, 136: 3, 145: 5, 147: 3, 151: 2, 152: 2, 154: 4, 156: 2, 161: 4, 162: 4, 165: 4, 168: 5, 169: 2, 180: 2, 184: 6, 187: 6, 188: 5, 191: 4, 194: 5, 202: 6, 203: 7, 206: 3, 207: 4, 215: 3, 217: 4, 218: 9, 220: 3, 221: 3, 222: 6, 224: 4, 227: 5, 234: 6, 235: 3, 241: 3, 242: 3, 243: 5, 244: 3, 245: 5, 248: 3, 250: 4, 258: 12, 262: 5, 263: 6, 264: 4, 267: 5, 270: 3, 273: 6, 287: 4, 291: 4, 299: 5, 300: 3, 304: 3, 309: 4, 314: 3, 320: 5, 323: 5, 327: 5, 328: 4, 329: 3, 330: 11, 334: 3, 335: 3, 341: 5, 342: 6, 347: 5, 348: 5, 350: 8, 351: 4, 358: 5, 366: 3, 369: 2, 371: 7, 372: 4, 376: 3, 384: 4, 385: 3, 386: 4, 387: 3, 392: 4, 393: 5, 396: 6, 397: 8, 398: 7, 402: 2} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 15 "Because DetNet mechanisms or applications that rely on DetNet can make heavy use of methods that require precise time synchronization, the accuracy, availability, and integrity of time synchronization is of critical importance. Extensive discussion of this topic can be found in RFC7384." Sorry , now it is uploaded to the right folder . Simple accept pull request . Thx Bala'zs 13e6a4040b5ee178ec427163555ef49bc73addbb 13e6a4040b5ee178ec427163555ef49bc73addbb draft-ietf-detnet-ip c94b8af475141e8e80f0a566a4992152bf7e976170d401ce52917ccef07d1727 ['dbba5d27f625b2298f88e8cf65fe9b3584fb8078028e7996f70d1ba2980b8375', '411bab8931d489563f977381e3894cd0e25732a1b7b48a8a12cd2c9e73861d63', '1b81d0fe069e37f43fed41972f277c89b8af99a31ef2ade21122ccc3858575eb', 'e30afecfc76617a262182c81ea5ad3d36ff6cb97f12269ce22b2831c27cb3ab3', '6d1c378f6ab7bd6ae836d4ac295f0de5a2664c0064bd50ab47c1dde2a64665c8', 'c94b8af475141e8e80f0a566a4992152bf7e976170d401ce52917ccef07d1727', '9660729dcccf51d5b146b7b549f874e0feac220bda1c96d69e1fcfab2efbb95f', '15ff22f9bc26e370df616e5fea201eedd1eb8cb603c7d43d869f305816cda39b'] A "because detnet mechanisms or applications that rely on detnet can make heavy use of methods that require precise time synchronization, the accuracy, availability, and integrity of time synchronization is of critical importance. extensive discussion of this topic can be found in rfc7384." {110: 1, 87: 1, 102: 1, 84: 1, 13: 1, 36: 1, 24: 1, 114: 1, 6: 3, 79: 3, 90: 2, 51: 2, 130: 3, 62: 5, 85: 6, 68: 5, 35: 4, 91: 3, 97: 3, 31: 3, 67: 2, 38: 3, 26: 2, 124: 4, 98: 3, 54: 3, 127: 4, 8: 3, 96: 3, 64: 2, 30: 2, 61: 4, 55: 4, 27: 3, 15: 2, 52: 2, 129: 4, 115: 2, 76: 7, 131: 6, 113: 4, 99: 3, 53: 2, 72: 3} {172: 1, 229: 1, 272: 1, 289: 1, 315: 1, 353: 1, 354: 1, 365: 1, 1: 10, 4: 3, 9: 6, 10: 4, 15: 3, 24: 3, 25: 5, 26: 6, 27: 2, 39: 6, 43: 4, 49: 4, 50: 3, 58: 4, 59: 3, 64: 3, 69: 5, 81: 6, 82: 4, 86: 2, 96: 3, 97: 2, 100: 7, 108: 4, 109: 5, 110: 5, 111: 3, 114: 4, 115: 5, 116: 3, 118: 7, 119: 6, 120: 4, 121: 5, 122: 4, 123: 3, 124: 5, 128: 2, 129: 2, 130: 4, 132: 5, 136: 3, 145: 5, 147: 3, 151: 2, 152: 2, 154: 4, 156: 2, 161: 4, 162: 4, 165: 4, 168: 5, 169: 2, 180: 2, 184: 6, 187: 6, 188: 5, 191: 4, 194: 5, 202: 6, 203: 7, 206: 3, 207: 4, 215: 3, 217: 4, 218: 9, 220: 3, 221: 3, 222: 6, 224: 4, 227: 5, 234: 6, 235: 3, 241: 3, 242: 3, 243: 5, 244: 3, 245: 5, 248: 3, 250: 4, 258: 12, 262: 5, 263: 6, 264: 4, 267: 5, 270: 3, 273: 6, 287: 4, 291: 4, 299: 5, 300: 3, 304: 3, 309: 4, 314: 3, 320: 5, 323: 5, 327: 5, 328: 4, 329: 3, 330: 11, 334: 3, 335: 3, 341: 5, 342: 6, 347: 5, 348: 5, 350: 8, 351: 4, 358: 5, 366: 3, 369: 2, 371: 7, 372: 4, 376: 3, 384: 4, 385: 3, 386: 4, 387: 3, 392: 4, 393: 5, 396: 6, 397: 8, 398: 7, 402: 2} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 15 "The primary considerations for the data plane is to maintain integrity of data and delivery of the associated DetNet service traversing the DetNet network. Application flows can be protected through whatever means is provided by the underlying technology. For example, encryption may be used, such as that provided by IPSec RFC4301 for IP flows and/or by an underlying sub-net using MACSec IEEE802.1AE-2018 for IP over Ethernet (Layer-2) flows." Sorry , now it is uploaded to the right folder . Simple accept pull request . Thx Bala'zs 13e6a4040b5ee178ec427163555ef49bc73addbb 13e6a4040b5ee178ec427163555ef49bc73addbb draft-ietf-detnet-ip 6d1c378f6ab7bd6ae836d4ac295f0de5a2664c0064bd50ab47c1dde2a64665c8 ['dbba5d27f625b2298f88e8cf65fe9b3584fb8078028e7996f70d1ba2980b8375', '411bab8931d489563f977381e3894cd0e25732a1b7b48a8a12cd2c9e73861d63', '1b81d0fe069e37f43fed41972f277c89b8af99a31ef2ade21122ccc3858575eb', 'e30afecfc76617a262182c81ea5ad3d36ff6cb97f12269ce22b2831c27cb3ab3', '6d1c378f6ab7bd6ae836d4ac295f0de5a2664c0064bd50ab47c1dde2a64665c8', 'c94b8af475141e8e80f0a566a4992152bf7e976170d401ce52917ccef07d1727', '9660729dcccf51d5b146b7b549f874e0feac220bda1c96d69e1fcfab2efbb95f', '15ff22f9bc26e370df616e5fea201eedd1eb8cb603c7d43d869f305816cda39b'] B "the primary considerations for the data plane is to maintain integrity of data and delivery of the associated detnet service traversing the detnet network. application flows can be protected through whatever means is provided by the underlying technology. for example, encryption may be used, such as that provided by ipsec rfc4301 for ip flows and/or by an underlying sub-net using macsec ieee802.1ae-2018 for ip over ethernet (layer-2) flows." {110: 1, 87: 1, 102: 1, 84: 1, 13: 1, 36: 1, 24: 1, 114: 1, 6: 3, 79: 3, 90: 2, 51: 2, 130: 3, 62: 5, 85: 6, 68: 5, 35: 4, 91: 3, 97: 3, 31: 3, 67: 2, 38: 3, 26: 2, 124: 4, 98: 3, 54: 3, 127: 4, 8: 3, 96: 3, 64: 2, 30: 2, 61: 4, 55: 4, 27: 3, 15: 2, 52: 2, 129: 4, 115: 2, 76: 7, 131: 6, 113: 4, 99: 3, 53: 2, 72: 3} {172: 1, 229: 1, 272: 1, 289: 1, 315: 1, 353: 1, 354: 1, 365: 1, 1: 10, 4: 3, 9: 6, 10: 4, 15: 3, 24: 3, 25: 5, 26: 6, 27: 2, 39: 6, 43: 4, 49: 4, 50: 3, 58: 4, 59: 3, 64: 3, 69: 5, 81: 6, 82: 4, 86: 2, 96: 3, 97: 2, 100: 7, 108: 4, 109: 5, 110: 5, 111: 3, 114: 4, 115: 5, 116: 3, 118: 7, 119: 6, 120: 4, 121: 5, 122: 4, 123: 3, 124: 5, 128: 2, 129: 2, 130: 4, 132: 5, 136: 3, 145: 5, 147: 3, 151: 2, 152: 2, 154: 4, 156: 2, 161: 4, 162: 4, 165: 4, 168: 5, 169: 2, 180: 2, 184: 6, 187: 6, 188: 5, 191: 4, 194: 5, 202: 6, 203: 7, 206: 3, 207: 4, 215: 3, 217: 4, 218: 9, 220: 3, 221: 3, 222: 6, 224: 4, 227: 5, 234: 6, 235: 3, 241: 3, 242: 3, 243: 5, 244: 3, 245: 5, 248: 3, 250: 4, 258: 12, 262: 5, 263: 6, 264: 4, 267: 5, 270: 3, 273: 6, 287: 4, 291: 4, 299: 5, 300: 3, 304: 3, 309: 4, 314: 3, 320: 5, 323: 5, 327: 5, 328: 4, 329: 3, 330: 11, 334: 3, 335: 3, 341: 5, 342: 6, 347: 5, 348: 5, 350: 8, 351: 4, 358: 5, 366: 3, 369: 2, 371: 7, 372: 4, 376: 3, 384: 4, 385: 3, 386: 4, 387: 3, 392: 4, 393: 5, 396: 6, 397: 8, 398: 7, 402: 2} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 15 "From a data plane perspective this document does not add or modify any header information." Sorry , now it is uploaded to the right folder . Simple accept pull request . Thx Bala'zs 13e6a4040b5ee178ec427163555ef49bc73addbb 13e6a4040b5ee178ec427163555ef49bc73addbb draft-ietf-detnet-ip e30afecfc76617a262182c81ea5ad3d36ff6cb97f12269ce22b2831c27cb3ab3 ['dbba5d27f625b2298f88e8cf65fe9b3584fb8078028e7996f70d1ba2980b8375', '411bab8931d489563f977381e3894cd0e25732a1b7b48a8a12cd2c9e73861d63', '1b81d0fe069e37f43fed41972f277c89b8af99a31ef2ade21122ccc3858575eb', 'e30afecfc76617a262182c81ea5ad3d36ff6cb97f12269ce22b2831c27cb3ab3', '6d1c378f6ab7bd6ae836d4ac295f0de5a2664c0064bd50ab47c1dde2a64665c8', 'c94b8af475141e8e80f0a566a4992152bf7e976170d401ce52917ccef07d1727', '9660729dcccf51d5b146b7b549f874e0feac220bda1c96d69e1fcfab2efbb95f', '15ff22f9bc26e370df616e5fea201eedd1eb8cb603c7d43d869f305816cda39b'] B "from a data plane perspective this document does not add or modify any header information." {110: 1, 87: 1, 102: 1, 84: 1, 13: 1, 36: 1, 24: 1, 114: 1, 6: 3, 79: 3, 90: 2, 51: 2, 130: 3, 62: 5, 85: 6, 68: 5, 35: 4, 91: 3, 97: 3, 31: 3, 67: 2, 38: 3, 26: 2, 124: 4, 98: 3, 54: 3, 127: 4, 8: 3, 96: 3, 64: 2, 30: 2, 61: 4, 55: 4, 27: 3, 15: 2, 52: 2, 129: 4, 115: 2, 76: 7, 131: 6, 113: 4, 99: 3, 53: 2, 72: 3} {172: 1, 229: 1, 272: 1, 289: 1, 315: 1, 353: 1, 354: 1, 365: 1, 1: 10, 4: 3, 9: 6, 10: 4, 15: 3, 24: 3, 25: 5, 26: 6, 27: 2, 39: 6, 43: 4, 49: 4, 50: 3, 58: 4, 59: 3, 64: 3, 69: 5, 81: 6, 82: 4, 86: 2, 96: 3, 97: 2, 100: 7, 108: 4, 109: 5, 110: 5, 111: 3, 114: 4, 115: 5, 116: 3, 118: 7, 119: 6, 120: 4, 121: 5, 122: 4, 123: 3, 124: 5, 128: 2, 129: 2, 130: 4, 132: 5, 136: 3, 145: 5, 147: 3, 151: 2, 152: 2, 154: 4, 156: 2, 161: 4, 162: 4, 165: 4, 168: 5, 169: 2, 180: 2, 184: 6, 187: 6, 188: 5, 191: 4, 194: 5, 202: 6, 203: 7, 206: 3, 207: 4, 215: 3, 217: 4, 218: 9, 220: 3, 221: 3, 222: 6, 224: 4, 227: 5, 234: 6, 235: 3, 241: 3, 242: 3, 243: 5, 244: 3, 245: 5, 248: 3, 250: 4, 258: 12, 262: 5, 263: 6, 264: 4, 267: 5, 270: 3, 273: 6, 287: 4, 291: 4, 299: 5, 300: 3, 304: 3, 309: 4, 314: 3, 320: 5, 323: 5, 327: 5, 328: 4, 329: 3, 330: 11, 334: 3, 335: 3, 341: 5, 342: 6, 347: 5, 348: 5, 350: 8, 351: 4, 358: 5, 366: 3, 369: 2, 371: 7, 372: 4, 376: 3, 384: 4, 385: 3, 386: 4, 387: 3, 392: 4, 393: 5, 396: 6, 397: 8, 398: 7, 402: 2} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 15 "At the management and control level DetNet flows are identified on a per-flow basis, which may provide controller plane attackers with additional information about the data flows (when compared to controller planes that do not include per-flow identification). This is an inherent property of DetNet which has security implications that should be considered when determining if DetNet is a suitable technology for any given use case." Sorry , now it is uploaded to the right folder . Simple accept pull request . Thx Bala'zs 13e6a4040b5ee178ec427163555ef49bc73addbb 13e6a4040b5ee178ec427163555ef49bc73addbb draft-ietf-detnet-ip dbba5d27f625b2298f88e8cf65fe9b3584fb8078028e7996f70d1ba2980b8375 ['dbba5d27f625b2298f88e8cf65fe9b3584fb8078028e7996f70d1ba2980b8375', '411bab8931d489563f977381e3894cd0e25732a1b7b48a8a12cd2c9e73861d63', '1b81d0fe069e37f43fed41972f277c89b8af99a31ef2ade21122ccc3858575eb', 'e30afecfc76617a262182c81ea5ad3d36ff6cb97f12269ce22b2831c27cb3ab3', '6d1c378f6ab7bd6ae836d4ac295f0de5a2664c0064bd50ab47c1dde2a64665c8', 'c94b8af475141e8e80f0a566a4992152bf7e976170d401ce52917ccef07d1727', '9660729dcccf51d5b146b7b549f874e0feac220bda1c96d69e1fcfab2efbb95f', '15ff22f9bc26e370df616e5fea201eedd1eb8cb603c7d43d869f305816cda39b'] B "at the management and control level detnet flows are identified on a per-flow basis, which may provide controller plane attackers with additional information about the data flows (when compared to controller planes that do not include per-flow identification). this is an inherent property of detnet which has security implications that should be considered when determining if detnet is a suitable technology for any given use case." {110: 1, 87: 1, 102: 1, 84: 1, 13: 1, 36: 1, 24: 1, 114: 1, 6: 3, 79: 3, 90: 2, 51: 2, 130: 3, 62: 5, 85: 6, 68: 5, 35: 4, 91: 3, 97: 3, 31: 3, 67: 2, 38: 3, 26: 2, 124: 4, 98: 3, 54: 3, 127: 4, 8: 3, 96: 3, 64: 2, 30: 2, 61: 4, 55: 4, 27: 3, 15: 2, 52: 2, 129: 4, 115: 2, 76: 7, 131: 6, 113: 4, 99: 3, 53: 2, 72: 3} {172: 1, 229: 1, 272: 1, 289: 1, 315: 1, 353: 1, 354: 1, 365: 1, 1: 10, 4: 3, 9: 6, 10: 4, 15: 3, 24: 3, 25: 5, 26: 6, 27: 2, 39: 6, 43: 4, 49: 4, 50: 3, 58: 4, 59: 3, 64: 3, 69: 5, 81: 6, 82: 4, 86: 2, 96: 3, 97: 2, 100: 7, 108: 4, 109: 5, 110: 5, 111: 3, 114: 4, 115: 5, 116: 3, 118: 7, 119: 6, 120: 4, 121: 5, 122: 4, 123: 3, 124: 5, 128: 2, 129: 2, 130: 4, 132: 5, 136: 3, 145: 5, 147: 3, 151: 2, 152: 2, 154: 4, 156: 2, 161: 4, 162: 4, 165: 4, 168: 5, 169: 2, 180: 2, 184: 6, 187: 6, 188: 5, 191: 4, 194: 5, 202: 6, 203: 7, 206: 3, 207: 4, 215: 3, 217: 4, 218: 9, 220: 3, 221: 3, 222: 6, 224: 4, 227: 5, 234: 6, 235: 3, 241: 3, 242: 3, 243: 5, 244: 3, 245: 5, 248: 3, 250: 4, 258: 12, 262: 5, 263: 6, 264: 4, 267: 5, 270: 3, 273: 6, 287: 4, 291: 4, 299: 5, 300: 3, 304: 3, 309: 4, 314: 3, 320: 5, 323: 5, 327: 5, 328: 4, 329: 3, 330: 11, 334: 3, 335: 3, 341: 5, 342: 6, 347: 5, 348: 5, 350: 8, 351: 4, 358: 5, 366: 3, 369: 2, 371: 7, 372: 4, 376: 3, 384: 4, 385: 3, 386: 4, 387: 3, 392: 4, 393: 5, 396: 6, 397: 8, 398: 7, 402: 2} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 15 "To provide uninterrupted availability of the DetNet service, provisions can be made against DOS attacks and delay attacks. To protect against DOS attacks, excess traffic due to malicious or malfunctioning devices can be prevented or mitigated, for example through the use of existing mechanism such as policing and shaping applied at the input of a DetNet domain. To prevent DetNet packets from being delayed by an entity external to a DetNet domain, DetNet technology definition can allow for the mitigation of Man-In-The- Middle attacks, for example through use of authentication and authorization of devices within the DetNet domain." Sorry , now it is uploaded to the right folder . Simple accept pull request . Thx Bala'zs 13e6a4040b5ee178ec427163555ef49bc73addbb 13e6a4040b5ee178ec427163555ef49bc73addbb draft-ietf-detnet-ip 9660729dcccf51d5b146b7b549f874e0feac220bda1c96d69e1fcfab2efbb95f ['dbba5d27f625b2298f88e8cf65fe9b3584fb8078028e7996f70d1ba2980b8375', '411bab8931d489563f977381e3894cd0e25732a1b7b48a8a12cd2c9e73861d63', '1b81d0fe069e37f43fed41972f277c89b8af99a31ef2ade21122ccc3858575eb', 'e30afecfc76617a262182c81ea5ad3d36ff6cb97f12269ce22b2831c27cb3ab3', '6d1c378f6ab7bd6ae836d4ac295f0de5a2664c0064bd50ab47c1dde2a64665c8', 'c94b8af475141e8e80f0a566a4992152bf7e976170d401ce52917ccef07d1727', '9660729dcccf51d5b146b7b549f874e0feac220bda1c96d69e1fcfab2efbb95f', '15ff22f9bc26e370df616e5fea201eedd1eb8cb603c7d43d869f305816cda39b'] B "to provide uninterrupted availability of the detnet service, provisions can be made against dos attacks and delay attacks. to protect against dos attacks, excess traffic due to malicious or malfunctioning devices can be prevented or mitigated, for example through the use of existing mechanism such as policing and shaping applied at the input of a detnet domain. to prevent detnet packets from being delayed by an entity external to a detnet domain, detnet technology definition can allow for the mitigation of man-in-the- middle attacks, for example through use of authentication and authorization of devices within the detnet domain." {110: 1, 87: 1, 102: 1, 84: 1, 13: 1, 36: 1, 24: 1, 114: 1, 6: 3, 79: 3, 90: 2, 51: 2, 130: 3, 62: 5, 85: 6, 68: 5, 35: 4, 91: 3, 97: 3, 31: 3, 67: 2, 38: 3, 26: 2, 124: 4, 98: 3, 54: 3, 127: 4, 8: 3, 96: 3, 64: 2, 30: 2, 61: 4, 55: 4, 27: 3, 15: 2, 52: 2, 129: 4, 115: 2, 76: 7, 131: 6, 113: 4, 99: 3, 53: 2, 72: 3} {172: 1, 229: 1, 272: 1, 289: 1, 315: 1, 353: 1, 354: 1, 365: 1, 1: 10, 4: 3, 9: 6, 10: 4, 15: 3, 24: 3, 25: 5, 26: 6, 27: 2, 39: 6, 43: 4, 49: 4, 50: 3, 58: 4, 59: 3, 64: 3, 69: 5, 81: 6, 82: 4, 86: 2, 96: 3, 97: 2, 100: 7, 108: 4, 109: 5, 110: 5, 111: 3, 114: 4, 115: 5, 116: 3, 118: 7, 119: 6, 120: 4, 121: 5, 122: 4, 123: 3, 124: 5, 128: 2, 129: 2, 130: 4, 132: 5, 136: 3, 145: 5, 147: 3, 151: 2, 152: 2, 154: 4, 156: 2, 161: 4, 162: 4, 165: 4, 168: 5, 169: 2, 180: 2, 184: 6, 187: 6, 188: 5, 191: 4, 194: 5, 202: 6, 203: 7, 206: 3, 207: 4, 215: 3, 217: 4, 218: 9, 220: 3, 221: 3, 222: 6, 224: 4, 227: 5, 234: 6, 235: 3, 241: 3, 242: 3, 243: 5, 244: 3, 245: 5, 248: 3, 250: 4, 258: 12, 262: 5, 263: 6, 264: 4, 267: 5, 270: 3, 273: 6, 287: 4, 291: 4, 299: 5, 300: 3, 304: 3, 309: 4, 314: 3, 320: 5, 323: 5, 327: 5, 328: 4, 329: 3, 330: 11, 334: 3, 335: 3, 341: 5, 342: 6, 347: 5, 348: 5, 350: 8, 351: 4, 358: 5, 366: 3, 369: 2, 371: 7, 372: 4, 376: 3, 384: 4, 385: 3, 386: 4, 387: 3, 392: 4, 393: 5, 396: 6, 397: 8, 398: 7, 402: 2} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 13 "The DetNet Architecture models the DetNet related data plane functions decomposed into two sub-layers: functions into two sub- layers: a service sub-layer and a forwarding sub-layer. The service sub-layer is used to provide DetNet service protection and reordering. The forwarding sub-layer is used to provides congestion protection (low loss, assured latency, and limited reordering). Since no DetNet specific headers are added to support DetNet IP flows, only the forwarding sub-layer functions are supported using the DetNet IP defined by this document. Service protection can be provided on a per sub-net basis using technologies such as MPLS I- D.ietf-detnet-dp-sol-mpls and Ethernet as specified in the IEEE 802.1 TSN task group(referred to in this document simply as IEEE802.1 TSN)." "Changes according to the discussion based on the circulated PDF comments . Reviewed by group" 5cc9cb3b55840f9d5a5c1e83f114f76bf6791e75 5cc9cb3b55840f9d5a5c1e83f114f76bf6791e75 draft-ietf-detnet-ip d48d5082004f0b3cc9cdc3987d69fccf3693d29cf87b8cd0a1356b1ec39cb214 ['316e3b80647bc71dc0da99d282304f8befdde49acd8476b6e9ccc825259f5f37', '60d927ad7ea9b7c651b1128fa99ba39149525a5c0b98cf31de613296a37297f9', 'd48d5082004f0b3cc9cdc3987d69fccf3693d29cf87b8cd0a1356b1ec39cb214', 'd7e5b51625dd0f10006a75fc7c52364f4d76e07f67d4911e2dfe02da3dd04d5b'] A "the detnet architecture models the detnet related data plane functions decomposed into two sub-layers: functions into two sub- layers: a service sub-layer and a forwarding sub-layer. the service sub-layer is used to provide detnet service protection and reordering. the forwarding sub-layer is used to provides congestion protection (low loss, assured latency, and limited reordering). since no detnet specific headers are added to support detnet ip flows, only the forwarding sub-layer functions are supported using the detnet ip defined by this document. service protection can be provided on a per sub-net basis using technologies such as mpls i- d.ietf-detnet-dp-sol-mpls and ethernet as specified in the ieee 802.1 tsn task group(referred to in this document simply as ieee802.1 tsn)." {102: 1, 62: 1, 6: 3, 26: 2} {155: 1, 325: 1, 198: 3, 199: 2, 238: 2} {65, 325, 198, 199, 238, 155} 13 "This document provides an overview of the DetNet IP data plane in sec_dt_dp, considerations that apply to providing DetNet services via the DetNet IP data plane in dn-gen-encap-solution. ip-procs provides the procedures for hosts and routers that support IP-based DetNet services." "Changes according to the discussion based on the circulated PDF comments . Reviewed by group" 5cc9cb3b55840f9d5a5c1e83f114f76bf6791e75 5cc9cb3b55840f9d5a5c1e83f114f76bf6791e75 draft-ietf-detnet-ip 316e3b80647bc71dc0da99d282304f8befdde49acd8476b6e9ccc825259f5f37 ['316e3b80647bc71dc0da99d282304f8befdde49acd8476b6e9ccc825259f5f37', '60d927ad7ea9b7c651b1128fa99ba39149525a5c0b98cf31de613296a37297f9', 'd48d5082004f0b3cc9cdc3987d69fccf3693d29cf87b8cd0a1356b1ec39cb214', 'd7e5b51625dd0f10006a75fc7c52364f4d76e07f67d4911e2dfe02da3dd04d5b'] A "this document provides an overview of the detnet ip data plane in sec_dt_dp, considerations that apply to providing detnet services via the detnet ip data plane in dn-gen-encap-solution. ip-procs provides the procedures for hosts and routers that support ip-based detnet services." {102: 1, 62: 1, 6: 3, 26: 2} {155: 1, 325: 1, 198: 3, 199: 2, 238: 2} {65, 325, 198, 199, 238, 155} 13 "The DetNet Architecture models the DetNet related data plane functions decomposed into two sub-layers: functions into two sub- layers: a service sub-layer and a forwarding sub-layer. The service sub-layer is used to provide DetNet service protection and reordering. The forwarding sub-layer is used to provides congestion protection (low loss, assured latency, and limited out-of-order delivery). Since no DetNet specific headers are added to support DetNet IP flows, only the forwarding sub-layer functions are supported using the DetNet IP defined by this document. Service protection can be provided on a per sub-net basis using technologies such as MPLS I-D.ietf-detnet-dp-sol-mpls and Ethernet as specified in the IEEE 802.1 TSN task group(referred to in this document simply as IEEE802.1 TSN)." "Changes according to the discussion based on the circulated PDF comments . Reviewed by group" 5cc9cb3b55840f9d5a5c1e83f114f76bf6791e75 5cc9cb3b55840f9d5a5c1e83f114f76bf6791e75 draft-ietf-detnet-ip d7e5b51625dd0f10006a75fc7c52364f4d76e07f67d4911e2dfe02da3dd04d5b ['316e3b80647bc71dc0da99d282304f8befdde49acd8476b6e9ccc825259f5f37', '60d927ad7ea9b7c651b1128fa99ba39149525a5c0b98cf31de613296a37297f9', 'd48d5082004f0b3cc9cdc3987d69fccf3693d29cf87b8cd0a1356b1ec39cb214', 'd7e5b51625dd0f10006a75fc7c52364f4d76e07f67d4911e2dfe02da3dd04d5b'] B "the detnet architecture models the detnet related data plane functions decomposed into two sub-layers: functions into two sub- layers: a service sub-layer and a forwarding sub-layer. the service sub-layer is used to provide detnet service protection and reordering. the forwarding sub-layer is used to provides congestion protection (low loss, assured latency, and limited out-of-order delivery). since no detnet specific headers are added to support detnet ip flows, only the forwarding sub-layer functions are supported using the detnet ip defined by this document. service protection can be provided on a per sub-net basis using technologies such as mpls i-d.ietf-detnet-dp-sol-mpls and ethernet as specified in the ieee 802.1 tsn task group(referred to in this document simply as ieee802.1 tsn)." {102: 1, 62: 1, 6: 3, 26: 2} {155: 1, 325: 1, 198: 3, 199: 2, 238: 2} {65, 325, 198, 199, 238, 155} 13 "This document provides an overview of the DetNet IP data plane in sec_dt_dp, considerations that apply to providing DetNet services via the DetNet IP data plane in dn-gen-encap-solution. ip-procs provides the procedures for hosts and routers that support IP-based DetNet services. ip-flow-id-info summarizes the set of information that is needed to identify an individual DetNet flow." "Changes according to the discussion based on the circulated PDF comments . Reviewed by group" 5cc9cb3b55840f9d5a5c1e83f114f76bf6791e75 5cc9cb3b55840f9d5a5c1e83f114f76bf6791e75 draft-ietf-detnet-ip 60d927ad7ea9b7c651b1128fa99ba39149525a5c0b98cf31de613296a37297f9 ['316e3b80647bc71dc0da99d282304f8befdde49acd8476b6e9ccc825259f5f37', '60d927ad7ea9b7c651b1128fa99ba39149525a5c0b98cf31de613296a37297f9', 'd48d5082004f0b3cc9cdc3987d69fccf3693d29cf87b8cd0a1356b1ec39cb214', 'd7e5b51625dd0f10006a75fc7c52364f4d76e07f67d4911e2dfe02da3dd04d5b'] B "this document provides an overview of the detnet ip data plane in sec_dt_dp, considerations that apply to providing detnet services via the detnet ip data plane in dn-gen-encap-solution. ip-procs provides the procedures for hosts and routers that support ip-based detnet services. ip-flow-id-info summarizes the set of information that is needed to identify an individual detnet flow." {102: 1, 62: 1, 6: 3, 26: 2} {155: 1, 325: 1, 198: 3, 199: 2, 238: 2} {65, 325, 198, 199, 238, 155} 13 "Note, that fig_ip_detnet_simple and fig_non_detnet_ip can be combined, so IP DetNet End Systems can communicate over DetNet IP network with IP End System." "Changes according to the discussion based on the circulated PDF comments . Reviewed by group" 5cc9cb3b55840f9d5a5c1e83f114f76bf6791e75 5cc9cb3b55840f9d5a5c1e83f114f76bf6791e75 draft-ietf-detnet-ip 37f4a84181adc18c68a964f05858e06e668480d1faccf666c278810df368396f ['37f4a84181adc18c68a964f05858e06e668480d1faccf666c278810df368396f'] B "note, that fig_ip_detnet_simple and fig_non_detnet_ip can be combined, so ip detnet end systems can communicate over detnet ip network with ip end system." {62: 1, 6: 4, 79: 6, 90: 4, 51: 2, 130: 3, 85: 2, 68: 4, 35: 7, 110: 6, 91: 8, 114: 6, 97: 4, 31: 5, 67: 6, 38: 7, 26: 3, 13: 3, 124: 3, 98: 6, 54: 6, 127: 7, 8: 4, 96: 3, 64: 6, 30: 6, 61: 8, 55: 3, 27: 5, 15: 6, 52: 4, 129: 7, 115: 6, 84: 4, 76: 7, 87: 6, 131: 9, 102: 2, 113: 8, 99: 6, 36: 6, 24: 5, 53: 5, 72: 7} {25: 1, 1: 9, 4: 6, 9: 6, 10: 7, 15: 5, 24: 6, 26: 2, 27: 5, 39: 5, 43: 7, 49: 9, 50: 8, 58: 8, 59: 6, 64: 5, 69: 5, 82: 2, 86: 6, 96: 7, 97: 6, 100: 5, 108: 7, 109: 8, 110: 8, 111: 6, 114: 7, 115: 8, 116: 4, 118: 4, 119: 3, 120: 7, 121: 4, 122: 4, 123: 3, 124: 4, 128: 7, 129: 6, 130: 8, 132: 5, 136: 6, 145: 5, 147: 7, 151: 7, 152: 7, 154: 7, 156: 4, 161: 4, 162: 3, 165: 7, 168: 8, 169: 6, 172: 6, 180: 7, 184: 6, 187: 9, 188: 8, 191: 7, 194: 5, 202: 6, 203: 7, 206: 6, 207: 7, 215: 5, 217: 7, 218: 8, 220: 4, 221: 4, 222: 5, 224: 7, 227: 3, 229: 6, 234: 9, 235: 6, 241: 6, 242: 6, 243: 5, 244: 7, 245: 5, 248: 7, 250: 6, 258: 11, 262: 8, 263: 9, 264: 5, 267: 4, 270: 5, 272: 6, 273: 6, 287: 7, 289: 6, 291: 8, 299: 3, 300: 5, 304: 5, 309: 4, 314: 6, 315: 6, 320: 2, 323: 5, 327: 8, 328: 6, 329: 6, 330: 10, 334: 6, 335: 4, 341: 3, 342: 4, 347: 3, 348: 3, 350: 8, 351: 8, 352: 6, 353: 6, 354: 5, 358: 4, 365: 6, 366: 6, 369: 5, 371: 5, 372: 8, 376: 6, 384: 8, 385: 7, 386: 7, 387: 5, 392: 6, 393: 7, 396: 4, 397: 7, 398: 6, 402: 6} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 13 "End systems need to ensure that DetNet service requirements are met when processing packets associated with a DetNet flow. When forwarding packets, this means that packets are appropriately shaped on transmission and received appropriate traffic treatment on the connected sub-network, see QoS and detrouting for more details. When receiving packets, this means that there are appropriate local node resources, e.g., buffers, to receive and process a DetNet flow packets." "Changes according to the discussion based on the circulated PDF comments . Reviewed by group" 5cc9cb3b55840f9d5a5c1e83f114f76bf6791e75 5cc9cb3b55840f9d5a5c1e83f114f76bf6791e75 draft-ietf-detnet-ip a10125e9bfeb49d05daeb4c9c4f673564eb3355f441229c3e0033f87237f5799 ['91fc5823dabd2169348ad98ddd941b03f82dfb8a2bf5cd175898b5eb2c9f786c', 'a10125e9bfeb49d05daeb4c9c4f673564eb3355f441229c3e0033f87237f5799'] A "end systems need to ensure that detnet service requirements are met when processing packets associated with a detnet flow. when forwarding packets, this means that packets are appropriately shaped on transmission and received appropriate traffic treatment on the connected sub-network, see qos and detrouting for more details. when receiving packets, this means that there are appropriate local node resources, e.g., buffers, to receive and process a detnet flow packets." {62: 1, 67: 2, 56: 2, 102: 2} {171: 1, 200: 2, 141: 2, 295: 2} {295, 200, 171, 141, 223} 13 "End systems need to ensure that DetNet service requirements are met when processing packets associated with a DetNet flow. When forwarding packets, this means that packets are appropriately shaped on transmission and received appropriate traffic treatment on the connected sub-network, see QoS and dn_dom_spec_cons for more details. When receiving packets, this means that there are appropriate local node resources, e.g., buffers, to receive and process a DetNet flow packets." "Changes according to the discussion based on the circulated PDF comments . Reviewed by group" 5cc9cb3b55840f9d5a5c1e83f114f76bf6791e75 5cc9cb3b55840f9d5a5c1e83f114f76bf6791e75 draft-ietf-detnet-ip 91fc5823dabd2169348ad98ddd941b03f82dfb8a2bf5cd175898b5eb2c9f786c ['91fc5823dabd2169348ad98ddd941b03f82dfb8a2bf5cd175898b5eb2c9f786c', 'a10125e9bfeb49d05daeb4c9c4f673564eb3355f441229c3e0033f87237f5799'] B "end systems need to ensure that detnet service requirements are met when processing packets associated with a detnet flow. when forwarding packets, this means that packets are appropriately shaped on transmission and received appropriate traffic treatment on the connected sub-network, see qos and dn_dom_spec_cons for more details. when receiving packets, this means that there are appropriate local node resources, e.g., buffers, to receive and process a detnet flow packets." {62: 1, 67: 2, 56: 2, 102: 2} {171: 1, 200: 2, 141: 2, 295: 2} {295, 200, 171, 141, 223} 13 "Within a DetNet domain, the DetNet enabled IP Routers interconnect links and sub-networks to support end-to-end delivery of DetNet flows. From a DetNet architecture perspective, these routers are DetNet relays, as they must be DetNet service aware. Such routers identify DetNet flows based on the IP 6-tuple, and ensure that the DetNet service required traffic treatment is provided both on the node and on any attached sub-network." "Changes according to the discussion based on the circulated PDF comments . Reviewed by group" 5cc9cb3b55840f9d5a5c1e83f114f76bf6791e75 5cc9cb3b55840f9d5a5c1e83f114f76bf6791e75 draft-ietf-detnet-ip 9578df4f362f9cb7b01a0101133311aad5ba40c07927ff78f145186909ac5f2e ['9578df4f362f9cb7b01a0101133311aad5ba40c07927ff78f145186909ac5f2e', '0fb620bfff4797e39e9a464415d6a923a665213722fa4b2caf11d03679f72f2d'] A "within a detnet domain, the detnet enabled ip routers interconnect links and sub-networks to support end-to-end delivery of detnet flows. from a detnet architecture perspective, these routers are detnet relays, as they must be detnet service aware. such routers identify detnet flows based on the ip 6-tuple, and ensure that the detnet service required traffic treatment is provided both on the node and on any attached sub-network." {51: 1, 62: 1, 6: 5, 79: 5, 90: 5, 130: 2, 85: 3, 68: 5, 35: 6, 110: 5, 91: 7, 114: 5, 97: 3, 31: 6, 13: 2, 67: 5, 38: 6, 26: 4, 124: 2, 98: 5, 54: 5, 127: 6, 8: 5, 96: 2, 64: 5, 30: 5, 61: 7, 55: 4, 27: 6, 15: 5, 52: 3, 129: 6, 115: 5, 84: 5, 76: 8, 87: 5, 131: 8, 102: 3, 113: 7, 99: 5, 36: 5, 24: 4, 53: 4, 72: 6} {82: 1, 396: 1, 1: 10, 4: 5, 9: 7, 10: 6, 15: 4, 24: 5, 25: 2, 26: 3, 27: 4, 39: 6, 43: 6, 49: 8, 50: 7, 58: 7, 59: 5, 64: 4, 69: 6, 81: 3, 86: 5, 96: 6, 97: 5, 100: 4, 108: 6, 109: 7, 110: 7, 111: 5, 114: 6, 115: 7, 116: 3, 118: 5, 119: 4, 120: 6, 121: 5, 122: 3, 123: 2, 124: 5, 128: 6, 129: 5, 130: 7, 132: 6, 136: 5, 145: 6, 147: 6, 151: 6, 152: 6, 154: 6, 156: 3, 161: 5, 162: 4, 165: 6, 168: 7, 169: 5, 172: 5, 180: 6, 184: 7, 187: 8, 188: 7, 191: 6, 194: 6, 202: 7, 203: 8, 206: 5, 207: 6, 215: 5, 217: 6, 218: 9, 220: 5, 221: 5, 222: 6, 224: 6, 229: 5, 234: 8, 235: 5, 241: 5, 242: 5, 243: 6, 244: 6, 245: 6, 248: 6, 250: 5, 258: 12, 262: 7, 263: 8, 264: 6, 267: 5, 270: 4, 272: 5, 273: 7, 287: 6, 289: 5, 291: 7, 299: 2, 300: 4, 304: 4, 309: 5, 314: 5, 315: 5, 320: 3, 323: 6, 327: 7, 328: 6, 329: 5, 330: 11, 334: 5, 335: 3, 341: 2, 342: 3, 347: 2, 348: 2, 350: 9, 351: 7, 352: 5, 353: 5, 354: 4, 358: 5, 365: 5, 366: 5, 369: 4, 371: 4, 372: 7, 376: 5, 384: 7, 385: 6, 386: 6, 387: 4, 392: 6, 393: 7, 397: 8, 398: 7, 402: 5} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 13 "Within a DetNet domain, the DetNet enabled IP Routers are interconnected by links and sub-networks to support end-to-end delivery of DetNet flows. From a DetNet architecture perspective, these routers are DetNet relays, as they must be DetNet service aware. Such routers identify DetNet flows based on the IP 6-tuple, and ensure that the DetNet service required traffic treatment is provided both on the node and on any attached sub-network." "Changes according to the discussion based on the circulated PDF comments . Reviewed by group" 5cc9cb3b55840f9d5a5c1e83f114f76bf6791e75 5cc9cb3b55840f9d5a5c1e83f114f76bf6791e75 draft-ietf-detnet-ip 0fb620bfff4797e39e9a464415d6a923a665213722fa4b2caf11d03679f72f2d ['9578df4f362f9cb7b01a0101133311aad5ba40c07927ff78f145186909ac5f2e', '0fb620bfff4797e39e9a464415d6a923a665213722fa4b2caf11d03679f72f2d'] B "within a detnet domain, the detnet enabled ip routers are interconnected by links and sub-networks to support end-to-end delivery of detnet flows. from a detnet architecture perspective, these routers are detnet relays, as they must be detnet service aware. such routers identify detnet flows based on the ip 6-tuple, and ensure that the detnet service required traffic treatment is provided both on the node and on any attached sub-network." {51: 1, 62: 1, 6: 5, 79: 5, 90: 5, 130: 2, 85: 3, 68: 5, 35: 6, 110: 5, 91: 7, 114: 5, 97: 3, 31: 6, 13: 2, 67: 5, 38: 6, 26: 4, 124: 2, 98: 5, 54: 5, 127: 6, 8: 5, 96: 2, 64: 5, 30: 5, 61: 7, 55: 4, 27: 6, 15: 5, 52: 3, 129: 6, 115: 5, 84: 5, 76: 8, 87: 5, 131: 8, 102: 3, 113: 7, 99: 5, 36: 5, 24: 4, 53: 4, 72: 6} {82: 1, 396: 1, 1: 10, 4: 5, 9: 7, 10: 6, 15: 4, 24: 5, 25: 2, 26: 3, 27: 4, 39: 6, 43: 6, 49: 8, 50: 7, 58: 7, 59: 5, 64: 4, 69: 6, 81: 3, 86: 5, 96: 6, 97: 5, 100: 4, 108: 6, 109: 7, 110: 7, 111: 5, 114: 6, 115: 7, 116: 3, 118: 5, 119: 4, 120: 6, 121: 5, 122: 3, 123: 2, 124: 5, 128: 6, 129: 5, 130: 7, 132: 6, 136: 5, 145: 6, 147: 6, 151: 6, 152: 6, 154: 6, 156: 3, 161: 5, 162: 4, 165: 6, 168: 7, 169: 5, 172: 5, 180: 6, 184: 7, 187: 8, 188: 7, 191: 6, 194: 6, 202: 7, 203: 8, 206: 5, 207: 6, 215: 5, 217: 6, 218: 9, 220: 5, 221: 5, 222: 6, 224: 6, 229: 5, 234: 8, 235: 5, 241: 5, 242: 5, 243: 6, 244: 6, 245: 6, 248: 6, 250: 5, 258: 12, 262: 7, 263: 8, 264: 6, 267: 5, 270: 4, 272: 5, 273: 7, 287: 6, 289: 5, 291: 7, 299: 2, 300: 4, 304: 4, 309: 5, 314: 5, 315: 5, 320: 3, 323: 6, 327: 7, 328: 6, 329: 5, 330: 11, 334: 5, 335: 3, 341: 2, 342: 3, 347: 2, 348: 2, 350: 9, 351: 7, 352: 5, 353: 5, 354: 4, 358: 5, 365: 5, 366: 5, 369: 4, 371: 4, 372: 7, 376: 5, 384: 7, 385: 6, 386: 6, 387: 4, 392: 6, 393: 7, 397: 8, 398: 7, 402: 5} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 13 "The DetNet Service Flow is mapped to the link / sub-network specific resources using an underlying system specific means. This implies each DetNet aware node on path looks into the forwarded DetNet Service Flow packet and utilize e.g., a 5- (or 6-) tuple to find out the required mapping within a node." "Changes according to the discussion based on the circulated PDF comments . Reviewed by group" 5cc9cb3b55840f9d5a5c1e83f114f76bf6791e75 5cc9cb3b55840f9d5a5c1e83f114f76bf6791e75 draft-ietf-detnet-ip 09072dce85dbf3ba3c882b977ba54fae8f3b847aa227a9c1f86c33efa19918c0 ['d80ec058522c8cd1260ab4fe31e58a0dad2982c6160fc0431750fcca5967776b', '09072dce85dbf3ba3c882b977ba54fae8f3b847aa227a9c1f86c33efa19918c0'] A "the detnet service flow is mapped to the link / sub-network specific resources using an underlying system specific means. this implies each detnet aware node on path looks into the forwarded detnet service flow packet and utilize e.g., a 5- (or 6-) tuple to find out the required mapping within a node." {51: 1, 62: 1, 6: 5, 79: 5, 90: 5, 130: 2, 85: 3, 68: 5, 35: 6, 110: 5, 91: 7, 114: 5, 97: 3, 31: 6, 13: 2, 67: 5, 38: 6, 26: 4, 124: 2, 98: 5, 54: 5, 127: 6, 8: 5, 96: 2, 64: 5, 30: 5, 61: 7, 55: 4, 27: 6, 15: 5, 52: 3, 129: 6, 115: 5, 84: 5, 76: 8, 87: 5, 131: 8, 102: 2, 113: 7, 99: 5, 36: 5, 24: 4, 53: 4, 72: 6} {82: 1, 342: 1, 1: 10, 4: 5, 9: 7, 10: 6, 15: 4, 24: 5, 25: 2, 26: 3, 27: 4, 39: 6, 43: 6, 49: 8, 50: 7, 58: 7, 59: 5, 64: 4, 69: 6, 81: 3, 86: 5, 96: 6, 97: 5, 100: 2, 108: 6, 109: 7, 110: 7, 111: 5, 114: 6, 115: 7, 116: 3, 118: 5, 119: 4, 120: 6, 121: 5, 122: 3, 123: 2, 124: 5, 128: 6, 129: 5, 130: 7, 132: 6, 136: 5, 145: 6, 147: 6, 151: 6, 152: 6, 154: 6, 156: 3, 161: 5, 162: 4, 165: 6, 168: 7, 169: 5, 172: 5, 180: 6, 184: 7, 187: 8, 188: 7, 191: 6, 194: 6, 202: 7, 203: 8, 206: 5, 207: 6, 215: 5, 217: 6, 218: 9, 220: 5, 221: 5, 222: 6, 224: 6, 227: 2, 229: 5, 234: 8, 235: 5, 241: 5, 242: 5, 243: 6, 244: 6, 245: 6, 248: 6, 250: 5, 258: 12, 262: 7, 263: 8, 264: 6, 267: 5, 270: 4, 272: 5, 273: 7, 287: 6, 289: 5, 291: 7, 299: 2, 300: 4, 304: 4, 309: 5, 314: 5, 315: 5, 320: 3, 323: 6, 327: 7, 328: 6, 329: 5, 330: 11, 334: 5, 335: 3, 347: 2, 348: 2, 350: 9, 351: 7, 352: 5, 353: 5, 354: 4, 358: 5, 365: 5, 366: 5, 369: 4, 371: 2, 372: 7, 376: 5, 384: 7, 385: 6, 386: 6, 387: 4, 392: 6, 393: 7, 396: 3, 397: 8, 398: 7, 402: 5} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 13 "The DetNet Service Flow is mapped to the link / sub-network specific resources using an underlying system specific means. This implies each DetNet aware node on path looks into the forwarded DetNet Service Flow packet and utilize e.g., a 6-tuple to find out the required mapping within a node." "Changes according to the discussion based on the circulated PDF comments . Reviewed by group" 5cc9cb3b55840f9d5a5c1e83f114f76bf6791e75 5cc9cb3b55840f9d5a5c1e83f114f76bf6791e75 draft-ietf-detnet-ip d80ec058522c8cd1260ab4fe31e58a0dad2982c6160fc0431750fcca5967776b ['d80ec058522c8cd1260ab4fe31e58a0dad2982c6160fc0431750fcca5967776b', '09072dce85dbf3ba3c882b977ba54fae8f3b847aa227a9c1f86c33efa19918c0'] B "the detnet service flow is mapped to the link / sub-network specific resources using an underlying system specific means. this implies each detnet aware node on path looks into the forwarded detnet service flow packet and utilize e.g., a 6-tuple to find out the required mapping within a node." {51: 1, 62: 1, 6: 5, 79: 5, 90: 5, 130: 2, 85: 3, 68: 5, 35: 6, 110: 5, 91: 7, 114: 5, 97: 3, 31: 6, 13: 2, 67: 5, 38: 6, 26: 4, 124: 2, 98: 5, 54: 5, 127: 6, 8: 5, 96: 2, 64: 5, 30: 5, 61: 7, 55: 4, 27: 6, 15: 5, 52: 3, 129: 6, 115: 5, 84: 5, 76: 8, 87: 5, 131: 8, 102: 2, 113: 7, 99: 5, 36: 5, 24: 4, 53: 4, 72: 6} {82: 1, 342: 1, 1: 10, 4: 5, 9: 7, 10: 6, 15: 4, 24: 5, 25: 2, 26: 3, 27: 4, 39: 6, 43: 6, 49: 8, 50: 7, 58: 7, 59: 5, 64: 4, 69: 6, 81: 3, 86: 5, 96: 6, 97: 5, 100: 2, 108: 6, 109: 7, 110: 7, 111: 5, 114: 6, 115: 7, 116: 3, 118: 5, 119: 4, 120: 6, 121: 5, 122: 3, 123: 2, 124: 5, 128: 6, 129: 5, 130: 7, 132: 6, 136: 5, 145: 6, 147: 6, 151: 6, 152: 6, 154: 6, 156: 3, 161: 5, 162: 4, 165: 6, 168: 7, 169: 5, 172: 5, 180: 6, 184: 7, 187: 8, 188: 7, 191: 6, 194: 6, 202: 7, 203: 8, 206: 5, 207: 6, 215: 5, 217: 6, 218: 9, 220: 5, 221: 5, 222: 6, 224: 6, 227: 2, 229: 5, 234: 8, 235: 5, 241: 5, 242: 5, 243: 6, 244: 6, 245: 6, 248: 6, 250: 5, 258: 12, 262: 7, 263: 8, 264: 6, 267: 5, 270: 4, 272: 5, 273: 7, 287: 6, 289: 5, 291: 7, 299: 2, 300: 4, 304: 4, 309: 5, 314: 5, 315: 5, 320: 3, 323: 6, 327: 7, 328: 6, 329: 5, 330: 11, 334: 5, 335: 3, 347: 2, 348: 2, 350: 9, 351: 7, 352: 5, 353: 5, 354: 4, 358: 5, 365: 5, 366: 5, 369: 4, 371: 2, 372: 7, 376: 5, 384: 7, 385: 6, 386: 6, 387: 4, 392: 6, 393: 7, 396: 3, 397: 8, 398: 7, 402: 5} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 13 "As noted earlier, the Service Protection is done within each link / sub-network independently using the domain specific mechanisms (due the lack of a unified end to end sequencing information that would be available for intermediate nodes). Therefore, service protection (if enabled) cannot be provided end-to-end, only within sub-networks. This is shown for a three sub-network scenario in fig_pref_in_subnets, where each sub-network can provide service protection between its borders." "Changes according to the discussion based on the circulated PDF comments . Reviewed by group" 5cc9cb3b55840f9d5a5c1e83f114f76bf6791e75 5cc9cb3b55840f9d5a5c1e83f114f76bf6791e75 draft-ietf-detnet-ip 4129127e8383f83f7ce1cbc667d11f3ea516853818add3155e98b065ad3a0728 ['4129127e8383f83f7ce1cbc667d11f3ea516853818add3155e98b065ad3a0728', '49ceb4d132b698dd26ed6e731d5ac52b7409063abcff006e4793492e7b6220a4'] A "as noted earlier, the service protection is done within each link / sub-network independently using the domain specific mechanisms (due the lack of a unified end to end sequencing information that would be available for intermediate nodes). therefore, service protection (if enabled) cannot be provided end-to-end, only within sub-networks. this is shown for a three sub-network scenario in fig_pref_in_subnets, where each sub-network can provide service protection between its borders." {62: 1, 6: 7, 79: 7, 90: 7, 51: 3, 130: 4, 85: 5, 68: 7, 35: 8, 110: 7, 91: 9, 114: 7, 97: 5, 31: 8, 13: 2, 67: 7, 38: 8, 26: 6, 124: 4, 98: 7, 54: 7, 127: 8, 8: 7, 96: 4, 64: 7, 30: 7, 61: 9, 55: 6, 27: 8, 15: 7, 52: 5, 129: 8, 115: 7, 84: 7, 76: 10, 87: 7, 131: 10, 102: 2, 113: 9, 99: 7, 36: 7, 24: 6, 53: 6, 72: 8} {342: 1, 1: 12, 4: 7, 9: 9, 10: 8, 15: 6, 24: 7, 25: 4, 26: 5, 27: 6, 39: 8, 43: 8, 49: 10, 50: 9, 58: 9, 59: 7, 64: 6, 69: 8, 81: 5, 82: 3, 86: 7, 96: 8, 97: 7, 108: 8, 109: 9, 110: 9, 111: 7, 114: 8, 115: 9, 116: 5, 118: 7, 119: 6, 120: 8, 121: 7, 122: 5, 123: 4, 124: 7, 128: 8, 129: 7, 130: 9, 132: 8, 136: 7, 145: 8, 147: 8, 151: 8, 152: 8, 154: 8, 156: 5, 161: 7, 162: 6, 165: 8, 168: 9, 169: 7, 172: 7, 180: 8, 184: 9, 187: 10, 188: 9, 191: 8, 194: 8, 202: 9, 203: 10, 206: 7, 207: 8, 215: 7, 217: 8, 218: 11, 220: 7, 221: 7, 222: 8, 224: 8, 227: 4, 229: 7, 234: 10, 235: 7, 241: 7, 242: 7, 243: 8, 244: 8, 245: 8, 248: 8, 250: 7, 258: 14, 262: 9, 263: 10, 264: 8, 267: 7, 270: 6, 272: 7, 273: 9, 287: 8, 289: 7, 291: 9, 299: 4, 300: 6, 304: 6, 309: 7, 314: 7, 315: 7, 320: 5, 323: 8, 327: 9, 328: 8, 329: 7, 330: 13, 334: 7, 335: 5, 341: 2, 347: 4, 348: 4, 350: 11, 351: 9, 352: 7, 353: 7, 354: 6, 358: 7, 365: 7, 366: 7, 369: 6, 371: 2, 372: 9, 376: 7, 384: 9, 385: 8, 386: 8, 387: 6, 392: 8, 393: 9, 396: 5, 397: 10, 398: 9, 402: 7} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 13 "As noted earlier, the Service Protection is done within each link / sub-network independently using the domain specific mechanisms (due the lack of a unified end to end sequencing information that would be available for intermediate nodes). Therefore, service protection (if enabled) cannot be provided end-to-end, only within sub-networks. This is shown for a three sub-network scenario in fig_pref_in_subnets, where each sub-network can provide service protection between its borders. ""R"" and ""E"" denotes replication and elimination points within the sub-network." "Changes according to the discussion based on the circulated PDF comments . Reviewed by group" 5cc9cb3b55840f9d5a5c1e83f114f76bf6791e75 5cc9cb3b55840f9d5a5c1e83f114f76bf6791e75 draft-ietf-detnet-ip 49ceb4d132b698dd26ed6e731d5ac52b7409063abcff006e4793492e7b6220a4 ['4129127e8383f83f7ce1cbc667d11f3ea516853818add3155e98b065ad3a0728', '49ceb4d132b698dd26ed6e731d5ac52b7409063abcff006e4793492e7b6220a4'] B "as noted earlier, the service protection is done within each link / sub-network independently using the domain specific mechanisms (due the lack of a unified end to end sequencing information that would be available for intermediate nodes). therefore, service protection (if enabled) cannot be provided end-to-end, only within sub-networks. this is shown for a three sub-network scenario in fig_pref_in_subnets, where each sub-network can provide service protection between its borders. ""r"" and ""e"" denotes replication and elimination points within the sub-network." {62: 1, 6: 7, 79: 7, 90: 7, 51: 3, 130: 4, 85: 5, 68: 7, 35: 8, 110: 7, 91: 9, 114: 7, 97: 5, 31: 8, 13: 2, 67: 7, 38: 8, 26: 6, 124: 4, 98: 7, 54: 7, 127: 8, 8: 7, 96: 4, 64: 7, 30: 7, 61: 9, 55: 6, 27: 8, 15: 7, 52: 5, 129: 8, 115: 7, 84: 7, 76: 10, 87: 7, 131: 10, 102: 2, 113: 9, 99: 7, 36: 7, 24: 6, 53: 6, 72: 8} {342: 1, 1: 12, 4: 7, 9: 9, 10: 8, 15: 6, 24: 7, 25: 4, 26: 5, 27: 6, 39: 8, 43: 8, 49: 10, 50: 9, 58: 9, 59: 7, 64: 6, 69: 8, 81: 5, 82: 3, 86: 7, 96: 8, 97: 7, 108: 8, 109: 9, 110: 9, 111: 7, 114: 8, 115: 9, 116: 5, 118: 7, 119: 6, 120: 8, 121: 7, 122: 5, 123: 4, 124: 7, 128: 8, 129: 7, 130: 9, 132: 8, 136: 7, 145: 8, 147: 8, 151: 8, 152: 8, 154: 8, 156: 5, 161: 7, 162: 6, 165: 8, 168: 9, 169: 7, 172: 7, 180: 8, 184: 9, 187: 10, 188: 9, 191: 8, 194: 8, 202: 9, 203: 10, 206: 7, 207: 8, 215: 7, 217: 8, 218: 11, 220: 7, 221: 7, 222: 8, 224: 8, 227: 4, 229: 7, 234: 10, 235: 7, 241: 7, 242: 7, 243: 8, 244: 8, 245: 8, 248: 8, 250: 7, 258: 14, 262: 9, 263: 10, 264: 8, 267: 7, 270: 6, 272: 7, 273: 9, 287: 8, 289: 7, 291: 9, 299: 4, 300: 6, 304: 6, 309: 7, 314: 7, 315: 7, 320: 5, 323: 8, 327: 9, 328: 8, 329: 7, 330: 13, 334: 7, 335: 5, 341: 2, 347: 4, 348: 4, 350: 11, 351: 9, 352: 7, 353: 7, 354: 6, 358: 7, 365: 7, 366: 7, 369: 6, 371: 2, 372: 9, 376: 7, 384: 9, 385: 8, 386: 8, 387: 6, 392: 8, 393: 9, 396: 5, 397: 10, 398: 9, 402: 7} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 13 OAM consideration are out-of-scope in this document. "Changes according to the discussion based on the circulated PDF comments . Reviewed by group" 5cc9cb3b55840f9d5a5c1e83f114f76bf6791e75 5cc9cb3b55840f9d5a5c1e83f114f76bf6791e75 draft-ietf-detnet-ip ed60e11fda2de3343baf8e6d58b6c5d0120d4b48f20144da8cae6a668c220367 ['ed60e11fda2de3343baf8e6d58b6c5d0120d4b48f20144da8cae6a668c220367'] B oam consideration are out-of-scope in this document. {} {} {379} 13 "The ability to aggregate individual flows, and their associated resource control, into a larger aggregate is an important technique for improving scaling of messaging in the data, management and control planes. This document identifies the traffic identification related aspects of aggregation of DetNet flows. The resource control and management aspects of aggregation (including the queuing/shaping/ policing implications) will be covered in other documents. The data plane implications of aggregation are independent for PW/MPLS and IP encapsulated DetNet flows." "Changes according to the discussion based on the circulated PDF comments . Reviewed by group" 5cc9cb3b55840f9d5a5c1e83f114f76bf6791e75 5cc9cb3b55840f9d5a5c1e83f114f76bf6791e75 draft-ietf-detnet-ip 5dc15ce4e90c8801006560a546275c5f97b627324333d7aab5a064b36ca3c12e ['86c1a729c0b3b18534e29d8675b2aae157133b5c773f29e8954d86e79d7f94e6', 'd2f4d4a415e7b603e7703cf64efe524048a90087a3468b6e21ce56a0a05a489d', '5dc15ce4e90c8801006560a546275c5f97b627324333d7aab5a064b36ca3c12e'] A "the ability to aggregate individual flows, and their associated resource control, into a larger aggregate is an important technique for improving scaling of messaging in the data, management and control planes. this document identifies the traffic identification related aspects of aggregation of detnet flows. the resource control and management aspects of aggregation (including the queuing/shaping/ policing implications) will be covered in other documents. the data plane implications of aggregation are independent for pw/mpls and ip encapsulated detnet flows." {} {} {} 13 "DetNet flows forwarded via IP have more limited aggregation options, due to the available traffic flow identification fields of the IP solution. One available approach is to manage the resources associated with a DSCP identified traffic class and to map (remark) individually controlled DetNet flows onto that traffic class. This approach also requires that nodes support aggregation ensure that traffic from aggregated LSPs are placed (shaped/policed/enqueued) in a fashion that ensures the required DetNet service is preserved." "Changes according to the discussion based on the circulated PDF comments . Reviewed by group" 5cc9cb3b55840f9d5a5c1e83f114f76bf6791e75 5cc9cb3b55840f9d5a5c1e83f114f76bf6791e75 draft-ietf-detnet-ip d2f4d4a415e7b603e7703cf64efe524048a90087a3468b6e21ce56a0a05a489d ['86c1a729c0b3b18534e29d8675b2aae157133b5c773f29e8954d86e79d7f94e6', 'd2f4d4a415e7b603e7703cf64efe524048a90087a3468b6e21ce56a0a05a489d', '5dc15ce4e90c8801006560a546275c5f97b627324333d7aab5a064b36ca3c12e'] A "detnet flows forwarded via ip have more limited aggregation options, due to the available traffic flow identification fields of the ip solution. one available approach is to manage the resources associated with a dscp identified traffic class and to map (remark) individually controlled detnet flows onto that traffic class. this approach also requires that nodes support aggregation ensure that traffic from aggregated lsps are placed (shaped/policed/enqueued) in a fashion that ensures the required detnet service is preserved." {} {} {} 13 "In both the MPLS and IP cases, additional details of the traffic control capabilities needed at a DetNet-aware node may be covered in the new service descriptions mentioned above or in separate future documents. Management and control plane mechanisms will also need to ensure that the service required on the aggregate flow (H-LSP or DSCP) are provided, which may include the discarding or remarking mentioned in the previous sections." "Changes according to the discussion based on the circulated PDF comments . Reviewed by group" 5cc9cb3b55840f9d5a5c1e83f114f76bf6791e75 5cc9cb3b55840f9d5a5c1e83f114f76bf6791e75 draft-ietf-detnet-ip 86c1a729c0b3b18534e29d8675b2aae157133b5c773f29e8954d86e79d7f94e6 ['86c1a729c0b3b18534e29d8675b2aae157133b5c773f29e8954d86e79d7f94e6', 'd2f4d4a415e7b603e7703cf64efe524048a90087a3468b6e21ce56a0a05a489d', '5dc15ce4e90c8801006560a546275c5f97b627324333d7aab5a064b36ca3c12e'] A "in both the mpls and ip cases, additional details of the traffic control capabilities needed at a detnet-aware node may be covered in the new service descriptions mentioned above or in separate future documents. management and control plane mechanisms will also need to ensure that the service required on the aggregate flow (h-lsp or dscp) are provided, which may include the discarding or remarking mentioned in the previous sections." {} {} {} 13 "aggregation and ip-agg discuss the use of flow aggregation in DetNet. Flow aggregation can be accomplished using any of the 6-tuple fields defined in ip-flow-id, using a DSCP identified traffic class or other field. It will be the responsibility of the DetNet controller plane to be able to properly provision the use of these aggregation mechanisms." "Changes according to the discussion based on the circulated PDF comments . Reviewed by group" 5cc9cb3b55840f9d5a5c1e83f114f76bf6791e75 5cc9cb3b55840f9d5a5c1e83f114f76bf6791e75 draft-ietf-detnet-ip c3f5878a0ab9884f6c15399fc76ae56c834fd6f6fb0c6b9937fc7bb1e0f6fc7a ['b5becb32cc74f88e3de7590f1e3c7e1da144ef6d91d76a490a5398611728902a', 'b9f3477c814a131af659143e53d74ecd7cc0c290043358ad22afe332711ffb61', '1719acc1335a93b75945a721e6f3472735a0f5c2c862a94913af997266b39ab7', 'c3f5878a0ab9884f6c15399fc76ae56c834fd6f6fb0c6b9937fc7bb1e0f6fc7a', '6170a5d3b8e653785199be80d4bb4bf0a83e946b99b77412ebd908662e5fa45e'] A "aggregation and ip-agg discuss the use of flow aggregation in detnet. flow aggregation can be accomplished using any of the 6-tuple fields defined in ip-flow-id, using a dscp identified traffic class or other field. it will be the responsibility of the detnet controller plane to be able to properly provision the use of these aggregation mechanisms." {26: 1, 27: 2, 102: 2, 62: 4, 60: 3, 85: 3, 56: 2} {160: 1, 259: 2, 359: 2, 370: 4, 52: 3, 246: 3, 159: 2} {160, 259, 359, 370, 52, 246, 284, 159} 13 "Flow aggregation can be accomplished using any of the 6-tuple fields defined in ip-flow-id, using a DSCP identified traffic class or other field. It will be the responsibility of the DetNet controller plane to be able to properly provision the use of these aggregation mechanisms." "Changes according to the discussion based on the circulated PDF comments . Reviewed by group" 5cc9cb3b55840f9d5a5c1e83f114f76bf6791e75 5cc9cb3b55840f9d5a5c1e83f114f76bf6791e75 draft-ietf-detnet-ip b9f3477c814a131af659143e53d74ecd7cc0c290043358ad22afe332711ffb61 ['b5becb32cc74f88e3de7590f1e3c7e1da144ef6d91d76a490a5398611728902a', 'b9f3477c814a131af659143e53d74ecd7cc0c290043358ad22afe332711ffb61', '1719acc1335a93b75945a721e6f3472735a0f5c2c862a94913af997266b39ab7', 'c3f5878a0ab9884f6c15399fc76ae56c834fd6f6fb0c6b9937fc7bb1e0f6fc7a', '6170a5d3b8e653785199be80d4bb4bf0a83e946b99b77412ebd908662e5fa45e'] B "flow aggregation can be accomplished using any of the 6-tuple fields defined in ip-flow-id, using a dscp identified traffic class or other field. it will be the responsibility of the detnet controller plane to be able to properly provision the use of these aggregation mechanisms." {26: 1, 27: 2, 102: 2, 62: 4, 60: 3, 85: 3, 56: 2} {160: 1, 259: 2, 359: 2, 370: 4, 52: 3, 246: 3, 159: 2} {160, 259, 359, 370, 52, 246, 284, 159} 13 "The ability to aggregate individual flows, and their associated resource control, into a larger aggregate is an important technique for improving scaling of messaging in the data, management and control planes. The resource control and management aspects of aggregation (including the queuing/shaping/policing implications) will be covered in other documents. The data plane implications of aggregation are independent of encapsulation formats." "Changes according to the discussion based on the circulated PDF comments . Reviewed by group" 5cc9cb3b55840f9d5a5c1e83f114f76bf6791e75 5cc9cb3b55840f9d5a5c1e83f114f76bf6791e75 draft-ietf-detnet-ip 6170a5d3b8e653785199be80d4bb4bf0a83e946b99b77412ebd908662e5fa45e ['b5becb32cc74f88e3de7590f1e3c7e1da144ef6d91d76a490a5398611728902a', 'b9f3477c814a131af659143e53d74ecd7cc0c290043358ad22afe332711ffb61', '1719acc1335a93b75945a721e6f3472735a0f5c2c862a94913af997266b39ab7', 'c3f5878a0ab9884f6c15399fc76ae56c834fd6f6fb0c6b9937fc7bb1e0f6fc7a', '6170a5d3b8e653785199be80d4bb4bf0a83e946b99b77412ebd908662e5fa45e'] B "the ability to aggregate individual flows, and their associated resource control, into a larger aggregate is an important technique for improving scaling of messaging in the data, management and control planes. the resource control and management aspects of aggregation (including the queuing/shaping/policing implications) will be covered in other documents. the data plane implications of aggregation are independent of encapsulation formats." {26: 1, 27: 2, 102: 2, 62: 4, 60: 3, 85: 3, 56: 2} {160: 1, 259: 2, 359: 2, 370: 4, 52: 3, 246: 3, 159: 2} {160, 259, 359, 370, 52, 246, 284, 159} 13 "DetNet flows forwarded via IP have more limited aggregation options, due to the available traffic flow identification fields of the IP solution. One available approach is to manage the resources associated with a DSCP identified traffic class and to map (remark) individually controlled DetNet flows onto that traffic class. This approach also requires that nodes support aggregation ensure that traffic from aggregated flows are placed (shaped/policed/enqueued) in a fashion that ensures the required DetNet service is preserved." "Changes according to the discussion based on the circulated PDF comments . Reviewed by group" 5cc9cb3b55840f9d5a5c1e83f114f76bf6791e75 5cc9cb3b55840f9d5a5c1e83f114f76bf6791e75 draft-ietf-detnet-ip b5becb32cc74f88e3de7590f1e3c7e1da144ef6d91d76a490a5398611728902a ['b5becb32cc74f88e3de7590f1e3c7e1da144ef6d91d76a490a5398611728902a', 'b9f3477c814a131af659143e53d74ecd7cc0c290043358ad22afe332711ffb61', '1719acc1335a93b75945a721e6f3472735a0f5c2c862a94913af997266b39ab7', 'c3f5878a0ab9884f6c15399fc76ae56c834fd6f6fb0c6b9937fc7bb1e0f6fc7a', '6170a5d3b8e653785199be80d4bb4bf0a83e946b99b77412ebd908662e5fa45e'] B "detnet flows forwarded via ip have more limited aggregation options, due to the available traffic flow identification fields of the ip solution. one available approach is to manage the resources associated with a dscp identified traffic class and to map (remark) individually controlled detnet flows onto that traffic class. this approach also requires that nodes support aggregation ensure that traffic from aggregated flows are placed (shaped/policed/enqueued) in a fashion that ensures the required detnet service is preserved." {26: 1, 27: 2, 102: 2, 62: 4, 60: 3, 85: 3, 56: 2} {160: 1, 259: 2, 359: 2, 370: 4, 52: 3, 246: 3, 159: 2} {160, 259, 359, 370, 52, 246, 284, 159} 13 "Additional details of the traffic control capabilities needed at a DetNet-aware node may be covered in separate future documents. Management and control plane mechanisms will also need to ensure that the service required on the aggregate flow are provided, which may include the discarding or remarking mentioned in the previous sections." "Changes according to the discussion based on the circulated PDF comments . Reviewed by group" 5cc9cb3b55840f9d5a5c1e83f114f76bf6791e75 5cc9cb3b55840f9d5a5c1e83f114f76bf6791e75 draft-ietf-detnet-ip 1719acc1335a93b75945a721e6f3472735a0f5c2c862a94913af997266b39ab7 ['b5becb32cc74f88e3de7590f1e3c7e1da144ef6d91d76a490a5398611728902a', 'b9f3477c814a131af659143e53d74ecd7cc0c290043358ad22afe332711ffb61', '1719acc1335a93b75945a721e6f3472735a0f5c2c862a94913af997266b39ab7', 'c3f5878a0ab9884f6c15399fc76ae56c834fd6f6fb0c6b9937fc7bb1e0f6fc7a', '6170a5d3b8e653785199be80d4bb4bf0a83e946b99b77412ebd908662e5fa45e'] B "additional details of the traffic control capabilities needed at a detnet-aware node may be covered in separate future documents. management and control plane mechanisms will also need to ensure that the service required on the aggregate flow are provided, which may include the discarding or remarking mentioned in the previous sections." {26: 1, 27: 2, 102: 2, 62: 4, 60: 3, 85: 3, 56: 2} {160: 1, 259: 2, 359: 2, 370: 4, 52: 3, 246: 3, 159: 2} {160, 259, 359, 370, 52, 246, 284, 159} 13 "DetNet IP data plane establishment and operational procedures also have requirements on the control and management systems for DetNet flows and these are covered in this section. Specifically this section identifies a number of information elements that require support via the management and control interfaces supported by a DetNet node. The specific mechanism used for such support is out of the scope of this document. A summary of the requirements for management and control related information is included. Conformance language is not used in the summary since applies to future mechanisms such as those that may be provided in YANG models [YANG- REF-TBD]." "Changes according to the discussion based on the circulated PDF comments . Reviewed by group" 5cc9cb3b55840f9d5a5c1e83f114f76bf6791e75 5cc9cb3b55840f9d5a5c1e83f114f76bf6791e75 draft-ietf-detnet-ip b5d7ec111ced61c54870f2611316a63dfdde8fe686e2d71b225138d031513893 ['b5d7ec111ced61c54870f2611316a63dfdde8fe686e2d71b225138d031513893', 'c051e448752705e60dfb2ff59cd3fcc726a5b73594c382fd38ba1b106dc7110b'] A "detnet ip data plane establishment and operational procedures also have requirements on the control and management systems for detnet flows and these are covered in this section. specifically this section identifies a number of information elements that require support via the management and control interfaces supported by a detnet node. the specific mechanism used for such support is out of the scope of this document. a summary of the requirements for management and control related information is included. conformance language is not used in the summary since applies to future mechanisms such as those that may be provided in yang models [yang- ref-tbd]." {85: 1} {30: 1} {285, 30} 13 "DetNet IP data plane establishment and operational procedures also have requirements on the control and management systems for DetNet flows and these are referred in this section. Specifically this section identifies a number of information elements that require support via the management and control interfaces supported by a DetNet node. The specific mechanism used for such support is out of the scope of this document. A summary of the requirements for management and control related information is included. Conformance language is not used in the summary since applies to future mechanisms such as those that may be provided in YANG models I- D.ietf-detnet-yang." "Changes according to the discussion based on the circulated PDF comments . Reviewed by group" 5cc9cb3b55840f9d5a5c1e83f114f76bf6791e75 5cc9cb3b55840f9d5a5c1e83f114f76bf6791e75 draft-ietf-detnet-ip c051e448752705e60dfb2ff59cd3fcc726a5b73594c382fd38ba1b106dc7110b ['b5d7ec111ced61c54870f2611316a63dfdde8fe686e2d71b225138d031513893', 'c051e448752705e60dfb2ff59cd3fcc726a5b73594c382fd38ba1b106dc7110b'] B "detnet ip data plane establishment and operational procedures also have requirements on the control and management systems for detnet flows and these are referred in this section. specifically this section identifies a number of information elements that require support via the management and control interfaces supported by a detnet node. the specific mechanism used for such support is out of the scope of this document. a summary of the requirements for management and control related information is included. conformance language is not used in the summary since applies to future mechanisms such as those that may be provided in yang models i- d.ietf-detnet-yang." {85: 1} {30: 1} {285, 30} 13 "The above implies that management and control functions will be defined to support this requirement, e.g., see [YANG-REF-TBD]." "Changes according to the discussion based on the circulated PDF comments . Reviewed by group" 5cc9cb3b55840f9d5a5c1e83f114f76bf6791e75 5cc9cb3b55840f9d5a5c1e83f114f76bf6791e75 draft-ietf-detnet-ip 9842989da491b36e86361f8f29907e85fa8ccfa6eb83e85dbc75c5da8d4718dc ['da1bfdba30c5c5367ba4129a2d5ee5cd8243608d6a540babd618d73ca4152aee', '9842989da491b36e86361f8f29907e85fa8ccfa6eb83e85dbc75c5da8d4718dc', '506629db2ed0ef867cb64274a29c3ff30df2a4aedaf62bc71065dfddeaa86033', 'dc49a2a92afc2679a6ea391c558a81b06fbf9b34c80af693ffb57f19da552c76'] A "the above implies that management and control functions will be defined to support this requirement, e.g., see [yang-ref-tbd]." {6: 1} {355: 1} {355, 349} 13 "Implementations if this document MUST ensure that a DetNet flow receives the traffic treatment that is provisioned for it via configuration or the controller plane, e.g., via [YANG-REF-TBD]. General information on DetNet service can be found in I-D.ietf- detnet-flow-information-model. Typical mechanisms used to provide different treatment to different flows includes the allocation of system resources (such as queues and buffers) and provisioning or related parameters (such as shaping, and policing). Support can also be provided via an underlying network technology such as MPLS I- D.ietf-detnet-ip-over-mpls. and IEEE802.1 TSN I-D.ietf-ip-over-tsn. Other than in the TSN case, the specific mechanisms used by a DetNet node to ensure DetNet service delivery requirements are met for supported DetNet flows is outside the scope of this document." "Changes according to the discussion based on the circulated PDF comments . Reviewed by group" 5cc9cb3b55840f9d5a5c1e83f114f76bf6791e75 5cc9cb3b55840f9d5a5c1e83f114f76bf6791e75 draft-ietf-detnet-ip dc49a2a92afc2679a6ea391c558a81b06fbf9b34c80af693ffb57f19da552c76 ['da1bfdba30c5c5367ba4129a2d5ee5cd8243608d6a540babd618d73ca4152aee', '9842989da491b36e86361f8f29907e85fa8ccfa6eb83e85dbc75c5da8d4718dc', '506629db2ed0ef867cb64274a29c3ff30df2a4aedaf62bc71065dfddeaa86033', 'dc49a2a92afc2679a6ea391c558a81b06fbf9b34c80af693ffb57f19da552c76'] A "implementations if this document must ensure that a detnet flow receives the traffic treatment that is provisioned for it via configuration or the controller plane, e.g., via [yang-ref-tbd]. general information on detnet service can be found in i-d.ietf- detnet-flow-information-model. typical mechanisms used to provide different treatment to different flows includes the allocation of system resources (such as queues and buffers) and provisioning or related parameters (such as shaping, and policing). support can also be provided via an underlying network technology such as mpls i- d.ietf-detnet-ip-over-mpls. and ieee802.1 tsn i-d.ietf-ip-over-tsn. other than in the tsn case, the specific mechanisms used by a detnet node to ensure detnet service delivery requirements are met for supported detnet flows is outside the scope of this document." {6: 1} {355: 1} {355, 349} 13 "The above implies that management and control functions will be defined to support this requirement, e.g., see I-D.ietf-detnet-yang." "Changes according to the discussion based on the circulated PDF comments . Reviewed by group" 5cc9cb3b55840f9d5a5c1e83f114f76bf6791e75 5cc9cb3b55840f9d5a5c1e83f114f76bf6791e75 draft-ietf-detnet-ip da1bfdba30c5c5367ba4129a2d5ee5cd8243608d6a540babd618d73ca4152aee ['da1bfdba30c5c5367ba4129a2d5ee5cd8243608d6a540babd618d73ca4152aee', '9842989da491b36e86361f8f29907e85fa8ccfa6eb83e85dbc75c5da8d4718dc', '506629db2ed0ef867cb64274a29c3ff30df2a4aedaf62bc71065dfddeaa86033', 'dc49a2a92afc2679a6ea391c558a81b06fbf9b34c80af693ffb57f19da552c76'] B "the above implies that management and control functions will be defined to support this requirement, e.g., see i-d.ietf-detnet-yang." {6: 1} {355: 1} {355, 349} 13 "Implementations if this document MUST ensure that a DetNet flow receives the traffic treatment that is provisioned for it via configuration or the controller plane, e.g., via I-D.ietf-detnet- yang. General information on DetNet service can be found in I- D.ietf-detnet-flow-information-model. Typical mechanisms used to provide different treatment to different flows includes the allocation of system resources (such as queues and buffers) and provisioning or related parameters (such as shaping, and policing). Support can also be provided via an underlying network technology such as MPLS I-D.ietf-detnet-ip-over-mpls. and IEEE802.1 TSN I- D.ietf-ip-over-tsn. Other than in the TSN case, the specific mechanisms used by a DetNet node to ensure DetNet service delivery requirements are met for supported DetNet flows is outside the scope of this document." "Changes according to the discussion based on the circulated PDF comments . Reviewed by group" 5cc9cb3b55840f9d5a5c1e83f114f76bf6791e75 5cc9cb3b55840f9d5a5c1e83f114f76bf6791e75 draft-ietf-detnet-ip 506629db2ed0ef867cb64274a29c3ff30df2a4aedaf62bc71065dfddeaa86033 ['da1bfdba30c5c5367ba4129a2d5ee5cd8243608d6a540babd618d73ca4152aee', '9842989da491b36e86361f8f29907e85fa8ccfa6eb83e85dbc75c5da8d4718dc', '506629db2ed0ef867cb64274a29c3ff30df2a4aedaf62bc71065dfddeaa86033', 'dc49a2a92afc2679a6ea391c558a81b06fbf9b34c80af693ffb57f19da552c76'] B "implementations if this document must ensure that a detnet flow receives the traffic treatment that is provisioned for it via configuration or the controller plane, e.g., via i-d.ietf-detnet- yang. general information on detnet service can be found in i- d.ietf-detnet-flow-information-model. typical mechanisms used to provide different treatment to different flows includes the allocation of system resources (such as queues and buffers) and provisioning or related parameters (such as shaping, and policing). support can also be provided via an underlying network technology such as mpls i-d.ietf-detnet-ip-over-mpls. and ieee802.1 tsn i- d.ietf-ip-over-tsn. other than in the tsn case, the specific mechanisms used by a detnet node to ensure detnet service delivery requirements are met for supported detnet flows is outside the scope of this document." {6: 1} {355: 1} {355, 349} 13 IPsec Header SPI field. Exact matching is required. "Changes according to the discussion based on the circulated PDF comments . Reviewed by group" 5cc9cb3b55840f9d5a5c1e83f114f76bf6791e75 5cc9cb3b55840f9d5a5c1e83f114f76bf6791e75 draft-ietf-detnet-ip a6f05aafd4996bb8e56e1e0f7f907b8cf657c4d7631c0c93d638cfce30798835 ['a6f05aafd4996bb8e56e1e0f7f907b8cf657c4d7631c0c93d638cfce30798835'] B ipsec header spi field. exact matching is required. {83: 1} {336: 1} {336, 257} 13 "The security considerations of DetNet in general are discussed in I- D.ietf-detnet-architecture and I-D.ietf-detnet-security. Other security considerations will be added in a future version of this draft." "Changes according to the discussion based on the circulated PDF comments . Reviewed by group" 5cc9cb3b55840f9d5a5c1e83f114f76bf6791e75 5cc9cb3b55840f9d5a5c1e83f114f76bf6791e75 draft-ietf-detnet-ip bef1c83b3620d0cfd78ac49fdd158a63bffc682797718f741ee084306124fcf2 ['c94b8af475141e8e80f0a566a4992152bf7e976170d401ce52917ccef07d1727', '411bab8931d489563f977381e3894cd0e25732a1b7b48a8a12cd2c9e73861d63', '003417ac9c913b228d19e5d11bf5645308f0f32a8c98b8299585c638d9421191', 'fa6534a2fea10c93739f34a3a3ebc956aa92d44a1990ef9c3f8c57af2882f9cd', '1b81d0fe069e37f43fed41972f277c89b8af99a31ef2ade21122ccc3858575eb', '15ff22f9bc26e370df616e5fea201eedd1eb8cb603c7d43d869f305816cda39b', 'bef1c83b3620d0cfd78ac49fdd158a63bffc682797718f741ee084306124fcf2'] A "the security considerations of detnet in general are discussed in i- d.ietf-detnet-architecture and i-d.ietf-detnet-security. other security considerations will be added in a future version of this draft." {51: 1, 30: 1, 15: 1, 115: 1, 102: 1, 36: 1, 24: 1, 90: 1, 6: 3, 79: 3, 130: 3, 62: 5, 85: 6, 68: 5, 35: 4, 110: 2, 91: 3, 114: 2, 97: 3, 31: 2, 13: 5, 67: 2, 38: 3, 26: 2, 124: 4, 98: 3, 54: 3, 127: 4, 8: 3, 96: 3, 64: 2, 61: 4, 55: 4, 27: 3, 52: 2, 129: 4, 84: 2, 76: 7, 87: 2, 131: 6, 113: 4, 99: 3, 53: 2, 72: 3} {27: 1, 129: 1, 151: 1, 169: 1, 272: 1, 352: 1, 353: 1, 354: 1, 402: 1, 1: 10, 4: 3, 9: 6, 10: 4, 15: 3, 24: 3, 25: 5, 26: 6, 39: 6, 43: 4, 49: 4, 50: 3, 58: 4, 59: 3, 64: 3, 69: 5, 81: 6, 82: 4, 86: 2, 96: 3, 97: 2, 100: 7, 108: 4, 109: 5, 110: 5, 111: 3, 114: 4, 115: 5, 116: 3, 118: 7, 119: 6, 120: 4, 121: 5, 122: 4, 123: 3, 124: 5, 128: 2, 130: 4, 132: 5, 136: 3, 145: 5, 147: 3, 152: 2, 154: 4, 156: 2, 161: 4, 162: 4, 165: 4, 168: 5, 172: 2, 180: 2, 184: 6, 187: 6, 188: 5, 191: 4, 194: 5, 202: 6, 203: 7, 206: 3, 207: 4, 215: 3, 217: 4, 218: 9, 220: 3, 221: 3, 222: 6, 224: 4, 227: 5, 229: 2, 234: 6, 235: 3, 241: 3, 242: 3, 243: 5, 244: 2, 245: 5, 248: 2, 250: 4, 258: 12, 262: 5, 263: 6, 264: 4, 267: 5, 270: 3, 273: 6, 287: 4, 289: 2, 291: 4, 299: 5, 300: 3, 304: 3, 309: 4, 314: 3, 320: 5, 323: 5, 327: 5, 328: 4, 329: 3, 330: 11, 334: 3, 335: 3, 341: 5, 342: 6, 347: 5, 348: 5, 350: 8, 351: 3, 358: 5, 365: 2, 366: 3, 369: 2, 371: 7, 372: 4, 376: 3, 384: 4, 385: 3, 386: 4, 387: 3, 392: 4, 393: 5, 396: 6, 397: 8, 398: 7} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 13 "Security considerations for DetNet are described in detail in I- D.ietf-detnet-security. This section considers exclusively security considerations which are specific to the DetNet data plane." "Changes according to the discussion based on the circulated PDF comments . Reviewed by group" 5cc9cb3b55840f9d5a5c1e83f114f76bf6791e75 5cc9cb3b55840f9d5a5c1e83f114f76bf6791e75 draft-ietf-detnet-ip 003417ac9c913b228d19e5d11bf5645308f0f32a8c98b8299585c638d9421191 ['c94b8af475141e8e80f0a566a4992152bf7e976170d401ce52917ccef07d1727', '411bab8931d489563f977381e3894cd0e25732a1b7b48a8a12cd2c9e73861d63', '003417ac9c913b228d19e5d11bf5645308f0f32a8c98b8299585c638d9421191', 'fa6534a2fea10c93739f34a3a3ebc956aa92d44a1990ef9c3f8c57af2882f9cd', '1b81d0fe069e37f43fed41972f277c89b8af99a31ef2ade21122ccc3858575eb', '15ff22f9bc26e370df616e5fea201eedd1eb8cb603c7d43d869f305816cda39b', 'bef1c83b3620d0cfd78ac49fdd158a63bffc682797718f741ee084306124fcf2'] B "security considerations for detnet are described in detail in i- d.ietf-detnet-security. this section considers exclusively security considerations which are specific to the detnet data plane." {51: 1, 30: 1, 15: 1, 115: 1, 102: 1, 36: 1, 24: 1, 90: 1, 6: 3, 79: 3, 130: 3, 62: 5, 85: 6, 68: 5, 35: 4, 110: 2, 91: 3, 114: 2, 97: 3, 31: 2, 13: 5, 67: 2, 38: 3, 26: 2, 124: 4, 98: 3, 54: 3, 127: 4, 8: 3, 96: 3, 64: 2, 61: 4, 55: 4, 27: 3, 52: 2, 129: 4, 84: 2, 76: 7, 87: 2, 131: 6, 113: 4, 99: 3, 53: 2, 72: 3} {27: 1, 129: 1, 151: 1, 169: 1, 272: 1, 352: 1, 353: 1, 354: 1, 402: 1, 1: 10, 4: 3, 9: 6, 10: 4, 15: 3, 24: 3, 25: 5, 26: 6, 39: 6, 43: 4, 49: 4, 50: 3, 58: 4, 59: 3, 64: 3, 69: 5, 81: 6, 82: 4, 86: 2, 96: 3, 97: 2, 100: 7, 108: 4, 109: 5, 110: 5, 111: 3, 114: 4, 115: 5, 116: 3, 118: 7, 119: 6, 120: 4, 121: 5, 122: 4, 123: 3, 124: 5, 128: 2, 130: 4, 132: 5, 136: 3, 145: 5, 147: 3, 152: 2, 154: 4, 156: 2, 161: 4, 162: 4, 165: 4, 168: 5, 172: 2, 180: 2, 184: 6, 187: 6, 188: 5, 191: 4, 194: 5, 202: 6, 203: 7, 206: 3, 207: 4, 215: 3, 217: 4, 218: 9, 220: 3, 221: 3, 222: 6, 224: 4, 227: 5, 229: 2, 234: 6, 235: 3, 241: 3, 242: 3, 243: 5, 244: 2, 245: 5, 248: 2, 250: 4, 258: 12, 262: 5, 263: 6, 264: 4, 267: 5, 270: 3, 273: 6, 287: 4, 289: 2, 291: 4, 299: 5, 300: 3, 304: 3, 309: 4, 314: 3, 320: 5, 323: 5, 327: 5, 328: 4, 329: 3, 330: 11, 334: 3, 335: 3, 341: 5, 342: 6, 347: 5, 348: 5, 350: 8, 351: 3, 358: 5, 365: 2, 366: 3, 369: 2, 371: 7, 372: 4, 376: 3, 384: 4, 385: 3, 386: 4, 387: 3, 392: 4, 393: 5, 396: 6, 397: 8, 398: 7} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 13 "Security aspects which are unique to DetNet are those whose aim is to provide the specific quality of service aspects of DetNet, which are primarily to deliver data flows with extremely low packet loss rates and bounded end-to-end delivery latency." "Changes according to the discussion based on the circulated PDF comments . Reviewed by group" 5cc9cb3b55840f9d5a5c1e83f114f76bf6791e75 5cc9cb3b55840f9d5a5c1e83f114f76bf6791e75 draft-ietf-detnet-ip fa6534a2fea10c93739f34a3a3ebc956aa92d44a1990ef9c3f8c57af2882f9cd ['c94b8af475141e8e80f0a566a4992152bf7e976170d401ce52917ccef07d1727', '411bab8931d489563f977381e3894cd0e25732a1b7b48a8a12cd2c9e73861d63', '003417ac9c913b228d19e5d11bf5645308f0f32a8c98b8299585c638d9421191', 'fa6534a2fea10c93739f34a3a3ebc956aa92d44a1990ef9c3f8c57af2882f9cd', '1b81d0fe069e37f43fed41972f277c89b8af99a31ef2ade21122ccc3858575eb', '15ff22f9bc26e370df616e5fea201eedd1eb8cb603c7d43d869f305816cda39b', 'bef1c83b3620d0cfd78ac49fdd158a63bffc682797718f741ee084306124fcf2'] B "security aspects which are unique to detnet are those whose aim is to provide the specific quality of service aspects of detnet, which are primarily to deliver data flows with extremely low packet loss rates and bounded end-to-end delivery latency." {51: 1, 30: 1, 15: 1, 115: 1, 102: 1, 36: 1, 24: 1, 90: 1, 6: 3, 79: 3, 130: 3, 62: 5, 85: 6, 68: 5, 35: 4, 110: 2, 91: 3, 114: 2, 97: 3, 31: 2, 13: 5, 67: 2, 38: 3, 26: 2, 124: 4, 98: 3, 54: 3, 127: 4, 8: 3, 96: 3, 64: 2, 61: 4, 55: 4, 27: 3, 52: 2, 129: 4, 84: 2, 76: 7, 87: 2, 131: 6, 113: 4, 99: 3, 53: 2, 72: 3} {27: 1, 129: 1, 151: 1, 169: 1, 272: 1, 352: 1, 353: 1, 354: 1, 402: 1, 1: 10, 4: 3, 9: 6, 10: 4, 15: 3, 24: 3, 25: 5, 26: 6, 39: 6, 43: 4, 49: 4, 50: 3, 58: 4, 59: 3, 64: 3, 69: 5, 81: 6, 82: 4, 86: 2, 96: 3, 97: 2, 100: 7, 108: 4, 109: 5, 110: 5, 111: 3, 114: 4, 115: 5, 116: 3, 118: 7, 119: 6, 120: 4, 121: 5, 122: 4, 123: 3, 124: 5, 128: 2, 130: 4, 132: 5, 136: 3, 145: 5, 147: 3, 152: 2, 154: 4, 156: 2, 161: 4, 162: 4, 165: 4, 168: 5, 172: 2, 180: 2, 184: 6, 187: 6, 188: 5, 191: 4, 194: 5, 202: 6, 203: 7, 206: 3, 207: 4, 215: 3, 217: 4, 218: 9, 220: 3, 221: 3, 222: 6, 224: 4, 227: 5, 229: 2, 234: 6, 235: 3, 241: 3, 242: 3, 243: 5, 244: 2, 245: 5, 248: 2, 250: 4, 258: 12, 262: 5, 263: 6, 264: 4, 267: 5, 270: 3, 273: 6, 287: 4, 289: 2, 291: 4, 299: 5, 300: 3, 304: 3, 309: 4, 314: 3, 320: 5, 323: 5, 327: 5, 328: 4, 329: 3, 330: 11, 334: 3, 335: 3, 341: 5, 342: 6, 347: 5, 348: 5, 350: 8, 351: 3, 358: 5, 365: 2, 366: 3, 369: 2, 371: 7, 372: 4, 376: 3, 384: 4, 385: 3, 386: 4, 387: 3, 392: 4, 393: 5, 396: 6, 397: 8, 398: 7} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 13 "The primary considerations for the data plane is to maintain confidentiality of data traversing the DetNet network, application flows can be protected through whatever means is provided by the underlying technology. For example, encryption may be used, such as that provided by IPSec RFC4301 for IP flows and by MACSec IEEE802.1AE-2018 for Ethernet (Layer-2) flows." "Changes according to the discussion based on the circulated PDF comments . Reviewed by group" 5cc9cb3b55840f9d5a5c1e83f114f76bf6791e75 5cc9cb3b55840f9d5a5c1e83f114f76bf6791e75 draft-ietf-detnet-ip 411bab8931d489563f977381e3894cd0e25732a1b7b48a8a12cd2c9e73861d63 ['c94b8af475141e8e80f0a566a4992152bf7e976170d401ce52917ccef07d1727', '411bab8931d489563f977381e3894cd0e25732a1b7b48a8a12cd2c9e73861d63', '003417ac9c913b228d19e5d11bf5645308f0f32a8c98b8299585c638d9421191', 'fa6534a2fea10c93739f34a3a3ebc956aa92d44a1990ef9c3f8c57af2882f9cd', '1b81d0fe069e37f43fed41972f277c89b8af99a31ef2ade21122ccc3858575eb', '15ff22f9bc26e370df616e5fea201eedd1eb8cb603c7d43d869f305816cda39b', 'bef1c83b3620d0cfd78ac49fdd158a63bffc682797718f741ee084306124fcf2'] B "the primary considerations for the data plane is to maintain confidentiality of data traversing the detnet network, application flows can be protected through whatever means is provided by the underlying technology. for example, encryption may be used, such as that provided by ipsec rfc4301 for ip flows and by macsec ieee802.1ae-2018 for ethernet (layer-2) flows." {51: 1, 30: 1, 15: 1, 115: 1, 102: 1, 36: 1, 24: 1, 90: 1, 6: 3, 79: 3, 130: 3, 62: 5, 85: 6, 68: 5, 35: 4, 110: 2, 91: 3, 114: 2, 97: 3, 31: 2, 13: 5, 67: 2, 38: 3, 26: 2, 124: 4, 98: 3, 54: 3, 127: 4, 8: 3, 96: 3, 64: 2, 61: 4, 55: 4, 27: 3, 52: 2, 129: 4, 84: 2, 76: 7, 87: 2, 131: 6, 113: 4, 99: 3, 53: 2, 72: 3} {27: 1, 129: 1, 151: 1, 169: 1, 272: 1, 352: 1, 353: 1, 354: 1, 402: 1, 1: 10, 4: 3, 9: 6, 10: 4, 15: 3, 24: 3, 25: 5, 26: 6, 39: 6, 43: 4, 49: 4, 50: 3, 58: 4, 59: 3, 64: 3, 69: 5, 81: 6, 82: 4, 86: 2, 96: 3, 97: 2, 100: 7, 108: 4, 109: 5, 110: 5, 111: 3, 114: 4, 115: 5, 116: 3, 118: 7, 119: 6, 120: 4, 121: 5, 122: 4, 123: 3, 124: 5, 128: 2, 130: 4, 132: 5, 136: 3, 145: 5, 147: 3, 152: 2, 154: 4, 156: 2, 161: 4, 162: 4, 165: 4, 168: 5, 172: 2, 180: 2, 184: 6, 187: 6, 188: 5, 191: 4, 194: 5, 202: 6, 203: 7, 206: 3, 207: 4, 215: 3, 217: 4, 218: 9, 220: 3, 221: 3, 222: 6, 224: 4, 227: 5, 229: 2, 234: 6, 235: 3, 241: 3, 242: 3, 243: 5, 244: 2, 245: 5, 248: 2, 250: 4, 258: 12, 262: 5, 263: 6, 264: 4, 267: 5, 270: 3, 273: 6, 287: 4, 289: 2, 291: 4, 299: 5, 300: 3, 304: 3, 309: 4, 314: 3, 320: 5, 323: 5, 327: 5, 328: 4, 329: 3, 330: 11, 334: 3, 335: 3, 341: 5, 342: 6, 347: 5, 348: 5, 350: 8, 351: 3, 358: 5, 365: 2, 366: 3, 369: 2, 371: 7, 372: 4, 376: 3, 384: 4, 385: 3, 386: 4, 387: 3, 392: 4, 393: 5, 396: 6, 397: 8, 398: 7} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 13 "DetNet flows are identified on a per-flow basis, which may provide attackers with additional information about the data flows (when compared to networks that do not include per-flow identification). This is an inherent property of DetNet which has security implications that should be considered when determining if DetNet is a suitable technology for any given use case." "Changes according to the discussion based on the circulated PDF comments . Reviewed by group" 5cc9cb3b55840f9d5a5c1e83f114f76bf6791e75 5cc9cb3b55840f9d5a5c1e83f114f76bf6791e75 draft-ietf-detnet-ip 15ff22f9bc26e370df616e5fea201eedd1eb8cb603c7d43d869f305816cda39b ['c94b8af475141e8e80f0a566a4992152bf7e976170d401ce52917ccef07d1727', '411bab8931d489563f977381e3894cd0e25732a1b7b48a8a12cd2c9e73861d63', '003417ac9c913b228d19e5d11bf5645308f0f32a8c98b8299585c638d9421191', 'fa6534a2fea10c93739f34a3a3ebc956aa92d44a1990ef9c3f8c57af2882f9cd', '1b81d0fe069e37f43fed41972f277c89b8af99a31ef2ade21122ccc3858575eb', '15ff22f9bc26e370df616e5fea201eedd1eb8cb603c7d43d869f305816cda39b', 'bef1c83b3620d0cfd78ac49fdd158a63bffc682797718f741ee084306124fcf2'] B "detnet flows are identified on a per-flow basis, which may provide attackers with additional information about the data flows (when compared to networks that do not include per-flow identification). this is an inherent property of detnet which has security implications that should be considered when determining if detnet is a suitable technology for any given use case." {51: 1, 30: 1, 15: 1, 115: 1, 102: 1, 36: 1, 24: 1, 90: 1, 6: 3, 79: 3, 130: 3, 62: 5, 85: 6, 68: 5, 35: 4, 110: 2, 91: 3, 114: 2, 97: 3, 31: 2, 13: 5, 67: 2, 38: 3, 26: 2, 124: 4, 98: 3, 54: 3, 127: 4, 8: 3, 96: 3, 64: 2, 61: 4, 55: 4, 27: 3, 52: 2, 129: 4, 84: 2, 76: 7, 87: 2, 131: 6, 113: 4, 99: 3, 53: 2, 72: 3} {27: 1, 129: 1, 151: 1, 169: 1, 272: 1, 352: 1, 353: 1, 354: 1, 402: 1, 1: 10, 4: 3, 9: 6, 10: 4, 15: 3, 24: 3, 25: 5, 26: 6, 39: 6, 43: 4, 49: 4, 50: 3, 58: 4, 59: 3, 64: 3, 69: 5, 81: 6, 82: 4, 86: 2, 96: 3, 97: 2, 100: 7, 108: 4, 109: 5, 110: 5, 111: 3, 114: 4, 115: 5, 116: 3, 118: 7, 119: 6, 120: 4, 121: 5, 122: 4, 123: 3, 124: 5, 128: 2, 130: 4, 132: 5, 136: 3, 145: 5, 147: 3, 152: 2, 154: 4, 156: 2, 161: 4, 162: 4, 165: 4, 168: 5, 172: 2, 180: 2, 184: 6, 187: 6, 188: 5, 191: 4, 194: 5, 202: 6, 203: 7, 206: 3, 207: 4, 215: 3, 217: 4, 218: 9, 220: 3, 221: 3, 222: 6, 224: 4, 227: 5, 229: 2, 234: 6, 235: 3, 241: 3, 242: 3, 243: 5, 244: 2, 245: 5, 248: 2, 250: 4, 258: 12, 262: 5, 263: 6, 264: 4, 267: 5, 270: 3, 273: 6, 287: 4, 289: 2, 291: 4, 299: 5, 300: 3, 304: 3, 309: 4, 314: 3, 320: 5, 323: 5, 327: 5, 328: 4, 329: 3, 330: 11, 334: 3, 335: 3, 341: 5, 342: 6, 347: 5, 348: 5, 350: 8, 351: 3, 358: 5, 365: 2, 366: 3, 369: 2, 371: 7, 372: 4, 376: 3, 384: 4, 385: 3, 386: 4, 387: 3, 392: 4, 393: 5, 396: 6, 397: 8, 398: 7} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 13 "To provide uninterrupted availability of the DetNet quality of service, provisions can be made against DOS attacks and delay attacks. To protect against DOS attacks, excess traffic due to malicious or malfunctioning devices can be prevented or mitigated, for example through the use of traffic admission control applied at the input of a DetNet domain. To prevent DetNet packets from being delayed by an entityexternal to a DetNet domain, DetNet technology definition can allow for the mitigation of Man-In-The-Middle attacks, for example through use of authentication and authorization of devices within the DetNet domain." "Changes according to the discussion based on the circulated PDF comments . Reviewed by group" 5cc9cb3b55840f9d5a5c1e83f114f76bf6791e75 5cc9cb3b55840f9d5a5c1e83f114f76bf6791e75 draft-ietf-detnet-ip 1b81d0fe069e37f43fed41972f277c89b8af99a31ef2ade21122ccc3858575eb ['c94b8af475141e8e80f0a566a4992152bf7e976170d401ce52917ccef07d1727', '411bab8931d489563f977381e3894cd0e25732a1b7b48a8a12cd2c9e73861d63', '003417ac9c913b228d19e5d11bf5645308f0f32a8c98b8299585c638d9421191', 'fa6534a2fea10c93739f34a3a3ebc956aa92d44a1990ef9c3f8c57af2882f9cd', '1b81d0fe069e37f43fed41972f277c89b8af99a31ef2ade21122ccc3858575eb', '15ff22f9bc26e370df616e5fea201eedd1eb8cb603c7d43d869f305816cda39b', 'bef1c83b3620d0cfd78ac49fdd158a63bffc682797718f741ee084306124fcf2'] B "to provide uninterrupted availability of the detnet quality of service, provisions can be made against dos attacks and delay attacks. to protect against dos attacks, excess traffic due to malicious or malfunctioning devices can be prevented or mitigated, for example through the use of traffic admission control applied at the input of a detnet domain. to prevent detnet packets from being delayed by an entityexternal to a detnet domain, detnet technology definition can allow for the mitigation of man-in-the-middle attacks, for example through use of authentication and authorization of devices within the detnet domain." {51: 1, 30: 1, 15: 1, 115: 1, 102: 1, 36: 1, 24: 1, 90: 1, 6: 3, 79: 3, 130: 3, 62: 5, 85: 6, 68: 5, 35: 4, 110: 2, 91: 3, 114: 2, 97: 3, 31: 2, 13: 5, 67: 2, 38: 3, 26: 2, 124: 4, 98: 3, 54: 3, 127: 4, 8: 3, 96: 3, 64: 2, 61: 4, 55: 4, 27: 3, 52: 2, 129: 4, 84: 2, 76: 7, 87: 2, 131: 6, 113: 4, 99: 3, 53: 2, 72: 3} {27: 1, 129: 1, 151: 1, 169: 1, 272: 1, 352: 1, 353: 1, 354: 1, 402: 1, 1: 10, 4: 3, 9: 6, 10: 4, 15: 3, 24: 3, 25: 5, 26: 6, 39: 6, 43: 4, 49: 4, 50: 3, 58: 4, 59: 3, 64: 3, 69: 5, 81: 6, 82: 4, 86: 2, 96: 3, 97: 2, 100: 7, 108: 4, 109: 5, 110: 5, 111: 3, 114: 4, 115: 5, 116: 3, 118: 7, 119: 6, 120: 4, 121: 5, 122: 4, 123: 3, 124: 5, 128: 2, 130: 4, 132: 5, 136: 3, 145: 5, 147: 3, 152: 2, 154: 4, 156: 2, 161: 4, 162: 4, 165: 4, 168: 5, 172: 2, 180: 2, 184: 6, 187: 6, 188: 5, 191: 4, 194: 5, 202: 6, 203: 7, 206: 3, 207: 4, 215: 3, 217: 4, 218: 9, 220: 3, 221: 3, 222: 6, 224: 4, 227: 5, 229: 2, 234: 6, 235: 3, 241: 3, 242: 3, 243: 5, 244: 2, 245: 5, 248: 2, 250: 4, 258: 12, 262: 5, 263: 6, 264: 4, 267: 5, 270: 3, 273: 6, 287: 4, 289: 2, 291: 4, 299: 5, 300: 3, 304: 3, 309: 4, 314: 3, 320: 5, 323: 5, 327: 5, 328: 4, 329: 3, 330: 11, 334: 3, 335: 3, 341: 5, 342: 6, 347: 5, 348: 5, 350: 8, 351: 3, 358: 5, 365: 2, 366: 3, 369: 2, 371: 7, 372: 4, 376: 3, 384: 4, 385: 3, 386: 4, 387: 3, 392: 4, 393: 5, 396: 6, 397: 8, 398: 7} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 13 "Because DetNet mechanisms or applications that rely on DetNet can make heavy use of methods that require precise time synchronization, the accuracy, availability, and integrity of time synchronization is of critical importance. Extensive discussion of this topic can be found in RFC7384." "Changes according to the discussion based on the circulated PDF comments . Reviewed by group" 5cc9cb3b55840f9d5a5c1e83f114f76bf6791e75 5cc9cb3b55840f9d5a5c1e83f114f76bf6791e75 draft-ietf-detnet-ip c94b8af475141e8e80f0a566a4992152bf7e976170d401ce52917ccef07d1727 ['c94b8af475141e8e80f0a566a4992152bf7e976170d401ce52917ccef07d1727', '411bab8931d489563f977381e3894cd0e25732a1b7b48a8a12cd2c9e73861d63', '003417ac9c913b228d19e5d11bf5645308f0f32a8c98b8299585c638d9421191', 'fa6534a2fea10c93739f34a3a3ebc956aa92d44a1990ef9c3f8c57af2882f9cd', '1b81d0fe069e37f43fed41972f277c89b8af99a31ef2ade21122ccc3858575eb', '15ff22f9bc26e370df616e5fea201eedd1eb8cb603c7d43d869f305816cda39b', 'bef1c83b3620d0cfd78ac49fdd158a63bffc682797718f741ee084306124fcf2'] B "because detnet mechanisms or applications that rely on detnet can make heavy use of methods that require precise time synchronization, the accuracy, availability, and integrity of time synchronization is of critical importance. extensive discussion of this topic can be found in rfc7384." {51: 1, 30: 1, 15: 1, 115: 1, 102: 1, 36: 1, 24: 1, 90: 1, 6: 3, 79: 3, 130: 3, 62: 5, 85: 6, 68: 5, 35: 4, 110: 2, 91: 3, 114: 2, 97: 3, 31: 2, 13: 5, 67: 2, 38: 3, 26: 2, 124: 4, 98: 3, 54: 3, 127: 4, 8: 3, 96: 3, 64: 2, 61: 4, 55: 4, 27: 3, 52: 2, 129: 4, 84: 2, 76: 7, 87: 2, 131: 6, 113: 4, 99: 3, 53: 2, 72: 3} {27: 1, 129: 1, 151: 1, 169: 1, 272: 1, 352: 1, 353: 1, 354: 1, 402: 1, 1: 10, 4: 3, 9: 6, 10: 4, 15: 3, 24: 3, 25: 5, 26: 6, 39: 6, 43: 4, 49: 4, 50: 3, 58: 4, 59: 3, 64: 3, 69: 5, 81: 6, 82: 4, 86: 2, 96: 3, 97: 2, 100: 7, 108: 4, 109: 5, 110: 5, 111: 3, 114: 4, 115: 5, 116: 3, 118: 7, 119: 6, 120: 4, 121: 5, 122: 4, 123: 3, 124: 5, 128: 2, 130: 4, 132: 5, 136: 3, 145: 5, 147: 3, 152: 2, 154: 4, 156: 2, 161: 4, 162: 4, 165: 4, 168: 5, 172: 2, 180: 2, 184: 6, 187: 6, 188: 5, 191: 4, 194: 5, 202: 6, 203: 7, 206: 3, 207: 4, 215: 3, 217: 4, 218: 9, 220: 3, 221: 3, 222: 6, 224: 4, 227: 5, 229: 2, 234: 6, 235: 3, 241: 3, 242: 3, 243: 5, 244: 2, 245: 5, 248: 2, 250: 4, 258: 12, 262: 5, 263: 6, 264: 4, 267: 5, 270: 3, 273: 6, 287: 4, 289: 2, 291: 4, 299: 5, 300: 3, 304: 3, 309: 4, 314: 3, 320: 5, 323: 5, 327: 5, 328: 4, 329: 3, 330: 11, 334: 3, 335: 3, 341: 5, 342: 6, 347: 5, 348: 5, 350: 8, 351: 3, 358: 5, 365: 2, 366: 3, 369: 2, 371: 7, 372: 4, 376: 3, 384: 4, 385: 3, 386: 4, 387: 3, 392: 4, 393: 5, 396: 6, 397: 8, 398: 7} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 8 "Deterministic Networking (DetNet) is a service that can be offered by a network to DetNet flows. DetNet provides these flows with extremely low packet loss rates and assured maximum end-to-end delivery latency. A description of the general background and concepts of DetNet can be found in I-D.ietf-detnet-architecture." "Updates from today 's meeting plus a bit of cleanup - references - spelling - addressing some clarifications from I have checked all the diffs and they look good ." e24f0e46970c4e1014284609644c366e8a23138c e24f0e46970c4e1014284609644c366e8a23138c draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework 48b1d5a85a046650499d2dc3b101a8d5ad07836be83dcc1b331c952fcfb50df3 ['30ae1549030b97583f33f7f53045c22dc52d45e745e519d0c21886cedd3953b4', '48b1d5a85a046650499d2dc3b101a8d5ad07836be83dcc1b331c952fcfb50df3'] A "deterministic networking (detnet) is a service that can be offered by a network to detnet flows. detnet provides these flows with extremely low packet loss rates and assured maximum end-to-end delivery latency. a description of the general background and concepts of detnet can be found in i-d.ietf-detnet-architecture." {6: 1, 55: 1, 90: 2, 67: 2} {113: 1, 61: 1, 106: 2, 375: 2} {106, 113, 375, 60, 61} 8 "Deterministic Networking (DetNet) provides a capability to carry specified unicast or multicast data flows for real-time applications with extremely low packet loss rates and assured maximum end-to-end delivery latency. A description of the general background and concepts of DetNet can be found in I-D.ietf-detnet-architecture." "Updates from today 's meeting plus a bit of cleanup - references - spelling - addressing some clarifications from I have checked all the diffs and they look good ." e24f0e46970c4e1014284609644c366e8a23138c e24f0e46970c4e1014284609644c366e8a23138c draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework 30ae1549030b97583f33f7f53045c22dc52d45e745e519d0c21886cedd3953b4 ['30ae1549030b97583f33f7f53045c22dc52d45e745e519d0c21886cedd3953b4', '48b1d5a85a046650499d2dc3b101a8d5ad07836be83dcc1b331c952fcfb50df3'] B "deterministic networking (detnet) provides a capability to carry specified unicast or multicast data flows for real-time applications with extremely low packet loss rates and assured maximum end-to-end delivery latency. a description of the general background and concepts of detnet can be found in i-d.ietf-detnet-architecture." {6: 1, 55: 1, 90: 2, 67: 2} {113: 1, 61: 1, 106: 2, 375: 2} {106, 113, 375, 60, 61} 8 "The DetNet forwarding sub-layer may be directly provided by the DetNet service layer, for example by IP, MPLS or IEEE 802.1 TSN IEEE802.1TSNTG. Alternatively an overlay approach may be used in which the packet is natively carried between key nodes within the DetNet network (say between PREOF nodes) and a sublayer is used to provide the information needed to reach the next hop in the overlay." "Updates from today 's meeting plus a bit of cleanup - references - spelling - addressing some clarifications from I have checked all the diffs and they look good ." e24f0e46970c4e1014284609644c366e8a23138c e24f0e46970c4e1014284609644c366e8a23138c draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework 33858cbbef2a9574bcad804cc1f70f34cd44dc691c0b8787320df7500c2f1679 ['33cb020069591d01e5a599374d4c9070450a06b1052b7a27196c884675fa4d39', '33858cbbef2a9574bcad804cc1f70f34cd44dc691c0b8787320df7500c2f1679', '0a21a95d3d21591097a795de075d155661aefb39903f30d3cbc9c0c8912539a8', 'd33a3b62f4be8a1559484e70225cec9b142336c000fce800cd399ba392525ba3', '6ef19b361dfb7c4949ae0368a21553831d8691e19bb5cd2942cc273d99993600', '9046ed7f0f3054b0af7e329e67511332b0c0f05e1c3ed420ea5707de95cc0ba0'] A "the detnet forwarding sub-layer may be directly provided by the detnet service layer, for example by ip, mpls or ieee 802.1 tsn ieee802.1tsntg. alternatively an overlay approach may be used in which the packet is natively carried between key nodes within the detnet network (say between preof nodes) and a sublayer is used to provide the information needed to reach the next hop in the overlay." {6: 1, 31: 1, 8: 2, 68: 3, 67: 2, 90: 3, 84: 3, 55: 2} {256: 1, 271: 1, 2: 2, 5: 3, 8: 2, 209: 2, 83: 4, 20: 3, 21: 4, 277: 3, 276: 4, 88: 2, 233: 3, 236: 3, 302: 3, 47: 3, 303: 4, 112: 2, 247: 2, 126: 3, 127: 2} {256, 2, 5, 8, 271, 20, 21, 277, 276, 302, 47, 303, 74, 209, 83, 88, 233, 236, 112, 247, 126, 127} 8 "This forwarding layer provides the quality underpin needed by the DetNet Service layer. It may do this directly through the use of queuing techniques and traffic engineering methods, or it may do this through the assistance of its underlying connectivity. For example it may call upon Ethernet TSN capabilities defined in IEEE 802.1 TSN IEEE802.1TSNTG." "Updates from today 's meeting plus a bit of cleanup - references - spelling - addressing some clarifications from I have checked all the diffs and they look good ." e24f0e46970c4e1014284609644c366e8a23138c e24f0e46970c4e1014284609644c366e8a23138c draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework 0a21a95d3d21591097a795de075d155661aefb39903f30d3cbc9c0c8912539a8 ['33cb020069591d01e5a599374d4c9070450a06b1052b7a27196c884675fa4d39', '33858cbbef2a9574bcad804cc1f70f34cd44dc691c0b8787320df7500c2f1679', '0a21a95d3d21591097a795de075d155661aefb39903f30d3cbc9c0c8912539a8', 'd33a3b62f4be8a1559484e70225cec9b142336c000fce800cd399ba392525ba3', '6ef19b361dfb7c4949ae0368a21553831d8691e19bb5cd2942cc273d99993600', '9046ed7f0f3054b0af7e329e67511332b0c0f05e1c3ed420ea5707de95cc0ba0'] A "this forwarding layer provides the quality underpin needed by the detnet service layer. it may do this directly through the use of queuing techniques and traffic engineering methods, or it may do this through the assistance of its underlying connectivity. for example it may call upon ethernet tsn capabilities defined in ieee 802.1 tsn ieee802.1tsntg." {6: 1, 31: 1, 8: 2, 68: 3, 67: 2, 90: 3, 84: 3, 55: 2} {256: 1, 271: 1, 2: 2, 5: 3, 8: 2, 209: 2, 83: 4, 20: 3, 21: 4, 277: 3, 276: 4, 88: 2, 233: 3, 236: 3, 302: 3, 47: 3, 303: 4, 112: 2, 247: 2, 126: 3, 127: 2} {256, 2, 5, 8, 271, 20, 21, 277, 276, 302, 47, 303, 74, 209, 83, 88, 233, 236, 112, 247, 126, 127} 8 "The service layer provides additional support beyond the connectivity function of the forwarding layer. An example of this is Packet Replication, Elimination, and Ordering (PREOF) function see PREOF." "Updates from today 's meeting plus a bit of cleanup - references - spelling - addressing some clarifications from I have checked all the diffs and they look good ." e24f0e46970c4e1014284609644c366e8a23138c e24f0e46970c4e1014284609644c366e8a23138c draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework 33cb020069591d01e5a599374d4c9070450a06b1052b7a27196c884675fa4d39 ['33cb020069591d01e5a599374d4c9070450a06b1052b7a27196c884675fa4d39', '33858cbbef2a9574bcad804cc1f70f34cd44dc691c0b8787320df7500c2f1679', '0a21a95d3d21591097a795de075d155661aefb39903f30d3cbc9c0c8912539a8', 'd33a3b62f4be8a1559484e70225cec9b142336c000fce800cd399ba392525ba3', '6ef19b361dfb7c4949ae0368a21553831d8691e19bb5cd2942cc273d99993600', '9046ed7f0f3054b0af7e329e67511332b0c0f05e1c3ed420ea5707de95cc0ba0'] A "the service layer provides additional support beyond the connectivity function of the forwarding layer. an example of this is packet replication, elimination, and ordering (preof) function see preof." {6: 1, 31: 1, 8: 2, 68: 3, 67: 2, 90: 3, 84: 3, 55: 2} {256: 1, 271: 1, 2: 2, 5: 3, 8: 2, 209: 2, 83: 4, 20: 3, 21: 4, 277: 3, 276: 4, 88: 2, 233: 3, 236: 3, 302: 3, 47: 3, 303: 4, 112: 2, 247: 2, 126: 3, 127: 2} {256, 2, 5, 8, 271, 20, 21, 277, 276, 302, 47, 303, 74, 209, 83, 88, 233, 236, 112, 247, 126, 127} 8 "The DetNet forwarding sub-layer may be directly provided by the DetNet service sub-layer, for example by IP or MPLS. Alternatively an overlay approach may be used in which the packet is natively carried between key nodes within the DetNet network (say between PREOF nodes) and a sub-layer is used to provide the information needed to reach the next hop in the overlay." "Updates from today 's meeting plus a bit of cleanup - references - spelling - addressing some clarifications from I have checked all the diffs and they look good ." e24f0e46970c4e1014284609644c366e8a23138c e24f0e46970c4e1014284609644c366e8a23138c draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework 6ef19b361dfb7c4949ae0368a21553831d8691e19bb5cd2942cc273d99993600 ['33cb020069591d01e5a599374d4c9070450a06b1052b7a27196c884675fa4d39', '33858cbbef2a9574bcad804cc1f70f34cd44dc691c0b8787320df7500c2f1679', '0a21a95d3d21591097a795de075d155661aefb39903f30d3cbc9c0c8912539a8', 'd33a3b62f4be8a1559484e70225cec9b142336c000fce800cd399ba392525ba3', '6ef19b361dfb7c4949ae0368a21553831d8691e19bb5cd2942cc273d99993600', '9046ed7f0f3054b0af7e329e67511332b0c0f05e1c3ed420ea5707de95cc0ba0'] B "the detnet forwarding sub-layer may be directly provided by the detnet service sub-layer, for example by ip or mpls. alternatively an overlay approach may be used in which the packet is natively carried between key nodes within the detnet network (say between preof nodes) and a sub-layer is used to provide the information needed to reach the next hop in the overlay." {6: 1, 31: 1, 8: 2, 68: 3, 67: 2, 90: 3, 84: 3, 55: 2} {256: 1, 271: 1, 2: 2, 5: 3, 8: 2, 209: 2, 83: 4, 20: 3, 21: 4, 277: 3, 276: 4, 88: 2, 233: 3, 236: 3, 302: 3, 47: 3, 303: 4, 112: 2, 247: 2, 126: 3, 127: 2} {256, 2, 5, 8, 271, 20, 21, 277, 276, 302, 47, 303, 74, 209, 83, 88, 233, 236, 112, 247, 126, 127} 8 "This forwarding sub-layer provides the quality underpin needed by the DetNet Service sub-layer. It may do this directly through the use of queuing techniques and traffic engineering methods, or it may do this through the assistance of its underlying connectivity. For example it may call upon Ethernet TSN capabilities defined in IEEE 802.1 TSN IEEE802.1TSNTG." "Updates from today 's meeting plus a bit of cleanup - references - spelling - addressing some clarifications from I have checked all the diffs and they look good ." e24f0e46970c4e1014284609644c366e8a23138c e24f0e46970c4e1014284609644c366e8a23138c draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework d33a3b62f4be8a1559484e70225cec9b142336c000fce800cd399ba392525ba3 ['33cb020069591d01e5a599374d4c9070450a06b1052b7a27196c884675fa4d39', '33858cbbef2a9574bcad804cc1f70f34cd44dc691c0b8787320df7500c2f1679', '0a21a95d3d21591097a795de075d155661aefb39903f30d3cbc9c0c8912539a8', 'd33a3b62f4be8a1559484e70225cec9b142336c000fce800cd399ba392525ba3', '6ef19b361dfb7c4949ae0368a21553831d8691e19bb5cd2942cc273d99993600', '9046ed7f0f3054b0af7e329e67511332b0c0f05e1c3ed420ea5707de95cc0ba0'] B "this forwarding sub-layer provides the quality underpin needed by the detnet service sub-layer. it may do this directly through the use of queuing techniques and traffic engineering methods, or it may do this through the assistance of its underlying connectivity. for example it may call upon ethernet tsn capabilities defined in ieee 802.1 tsn ieee802.1tsntg." {6: 1, 31: 1, 8: 2, 68: 3, 67: 2, 90: 3, 84: 3, 55: 2} {256: 1, 271: 1, 2: 2, 5: 3, 8: 2, 209: 2, 83: 4, 20: 3, 21: 4, 277: 3, 276: 4, 88: 2, 233: 3, 236: 3, 302: 3, 47: 3, 303: 4, 112: 2, 247: 2, 126: 3, 127: 2} {256, 2, 5, 8, 271, 20, 21, 277, 276, 302, 47, 303, 74, 209, 83, 88, 233, 236, 112, 247, 126, 127} 8 "The service sub-layer provides additional support beyond the connectivity function of the forwarding sub-layer. An example of this is Packet Replication, Elimination, and Ordering (PREOF) function see PREOF." "Updates from today 's meeting plus a bit of cleanup - references - spelling - addressing some clarifications from I have checked all the diffs and they look good ." e24f0e46970c4e1014284609644c366e8a23138c e24f0e46970c4e1014284609644c366e8a23138c draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework 9046ed7f0f3054b0af7e329e67511332b0c0f05e1c3ed420ea5707de95cc0ba0 ['33cb020069591d01e5a599374d4c9070450a06b1052b7a27196c884675fa4d39', '33858cbbef2a9574bcad804cc1f70f34cd44dc691c0b8787320df7500c2f1679', '0a21a95d3d21591097a795de075d155661aefb39903f30d3cbc9c0c8912539a8', 'd33a3b62f4be8a1559484e70225cec9b142336c000fce800cd399ba392525ba3', '6ef19b361dfb7c4949ae0368a21553831d8691e19bb5cd2942cc273d99993600', '9046ed7f0f3054b0af7e329e67511332b0c0f05e1c3ed420ea5707de95cc0ba0'] B "the service sub-layer provides additional support beyond the connectivity function of the forwarding sub-layer. an example of this is packet replication, elimination, and ordering (preof) function see preof." {6: 1, 31: 1, 8: 2, 68: 3, 67: 2, 90: 3, 84: 3, 55: 2} {256: 1, 271: 1, 2: 2, 5: 3, 8: 2, 209: 2, 83: 4, 20: 3, 21: 4, 277: 3, 276: 4, 88: 2, 233: 3, 236: 3, 302: 3, 47: 3, 303: 4, 112: 2, 247: 2, 126: 3, 127: 2} {256, 2, 5, 8, 271, 20, 21, 277, 276, 302, 47, 303, 74, 209, 83, 88, 233, 236, 112, 247, 126, 127} 8 "Whether the DetNet flows are carried in there native form across the DetNet network, or whether they are encapsulated. dn_svcs and dn_svc_encaps contrast native services and the encapsulation of services." "Updates from today 's meeting plus a bit of cleanup - references - spelling - addressing some clarifications from I have checked all the diffs and they look good ." e24f0e46970c4e1014284609644c366e8a23138c e24f0e46970c4e1014284609644c366e8a23138c draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework 79c51cb70fa0c71271628fddbe5f7d366b84024367517e776bdbcd3f2cbef99f ['3a3b30755697b8b84b4e957a75941b10a26d7684be2bb19820f593b4c40cef3c', 'a4c40e2a5d94a62408a33afebd53500dc73254bd15c3f1f40c39915d5c8d7e77', '7395ae0f777dcbfda92414d5c902b30189abf963306df8456a415e9c3942c01c', '79c51cb70fa0c71271628fddbe5f7d366b84024367517e776bdbcd3f2cbef99f', 'e272a85afcca5a5a4bc6143311efe118919c5e39790d66e46d87aea800afbd1f', 'ff35c63d87ee290acdcaf50e9a9826cbe16c289ba5e61a157ce1c32b84fd5c8f'] A "whether the detnet flows are carried in there native form across the detnet network, or whether they are encapsulated. dn_svcs and dn_svc_encaps contrast native services and the encapsulation of services." {6: 1, 8: 2, 68: 5, 31: 2, 67: 2, 90: 3, 84: 3, 55: 2} {256: 1, 2: 2, 5: 5, 8: 2, 74: 2, 271: 3, 209: 2, 83: 6, 20: 5, 21: 6, 277: 5, 276: 6, 233: 3, 236: 5, 302: 3, 47: 3, 303: 6, 112: 2, 247: 4, 126: 3, 127: 2} {256, 2, 5, 8, 271, 20, 21, 277, 276, 302, 47, 303, 74, 209, 83, 88, 233, 236, 112, 247, 126, 127} 8 "Whether or not the DetNet data plane includes the facility to carry additional information (metadata) that can be used to provide an enhanced service to the DetNet packet." "Updates from today 's meeting plus a bit of cleanup - references - spelling - addressing some clarifications from I have checked all the diffs and they look good ." e24f0e46970c4e1014284609644c366e8a23138c e24f0e46970c4e1014284609644c366e8a23138c draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework 3a3b30755697b8b84b4e957a75941b10a26d7684be2bb19820f593b4c40cef3c ['3a3b30755697b8b84b4e957a75941b10a26d7684be2bb19820f593b4c40cef3c', 'a4c40e2a5d94a62408a33afebd53500dc73254bd15c3f1f40c39915d5c8d7e77', '7395ae0f777dcbfda92414d5c902b30189abf963306df8456a415e9c3942c01c', '79c51cb70fa0c71271628fddbe5f7d366b84024367517e776bdbcd3f2cbef99f', 'e272a85afcca5a5a4bc6143311efe118919c5e39790d66e46d87aea800afbd1f', 'ff35c63d87ee290acdcaf50e9a9826cbe16c289ba5e61a157ce1c32b84fd5c8f'] A "whether or not the detnet data plane includes the facility to carry additional information (metadata) that can be used to provide an enhanced service to the detnet packet." {6: 1, 8: 2, 68: 5, 31: 2, 67: 2, 90: 3, 84: 3, 55: 2} {256: 1, 2: 2, 5: 5, 8: 2, 74: 2, 271: 3, 209: 2, 83: 6, 20: 5, 21: 6, 277: 5, 276: 6, 233: 3, 236: 5, 302: 3, 47: 3, 303: 6, 112: 2, 247: 4, 126: 3, 127: 2} {256, 2, 5, 8, 271, 20, 21, 277, 276, 302, 47, 303, 74, 209, 83, 88, 233, 236, 112, 247, 126, 127} 8 "The encapsulation of the DetNet flows allows them to be sent over a data plane of a type other than their native type. Encapsulation is essential if, for example, it is required to send Ethernet DetNet flows over a data plane such as MPLS. dn_svc_encaps illustrates some encapsulation combinations." "Updates from today 's meeting plus a bit of cleanup - references - spelling - addressing some clarifications from I have checked all the diffs and they look good ." e24f0e46970c4e1014284609644c366e8a23138c e24f0e46970c4e1014284609644c366e8a23138c draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework a4c40e2a5d94a62408a33afebd53500dc73254bd15c3f1f40c39915d5c8d7e77 ['3a3b30755697b8b84b4e957a75941b10a26d7684be2bb19820f593b4c40cef3c', 'a4c40e2a5d94a62408a33afebd53500dc73254bd15c3f1f40c39915d5c8d7e77', '7395ae0f777dcbfda92414d5c902b30189abf963306df8456a415e9c3942c01c', '79c51cb70fa0c71271628fddbe5f7d366b84024367517e776bdbcd3f2cbef99f', 'e272a85afcca5a5a4bc6143311efe118919c5e39790d66e46d87aea800afbd1f', 'ff35c63d87ee290acdcaf50e9a9826cbe16c289ba5e61a157ce1c32b84fd5c8f'] A "the encapsulation of the detnet flows allows them to be sent over a data plane of a type other than their native type. encapsulation is essential if, for example, it is required to send ethernet detnet flows over a data plane such as mpls. dn_svc_encaps illustrates some encapsulation combinations." {6: 1, 8: 2, 68: 5, 31: 2, 67: 2, 90: 3, 84: 3, 55: 2} {256: 1, 2: 2, 5: 5, 8: 2, 74: 2, 271: 3, 209: 2, 83: 6, 20: 5, 21: 6, 277: 5, 276: 6, 233: 3, 236: 5, 302: 3, 47: 3, 303: 6, 112: 2, 247: 4, 126: 3, 127: 2} {256, 2, 5, 8, 271, 20, 21, 277, 276, 302, 47, 303, 74, 209, 83, 88, 233, 236, 112, 247, 126, 127} 8 "How the data plane is constructed: The DetNet service sub-layer provides for the DetNet application flows by using or applying existing standardized headers and/or encapsulations. The Detnet forwarding sub-layer may provide capabilities leveraging that same header or encapsulation technology e.g. dn_svcs or it may be achieved by other standardized technologies e.g. dn_svc_encaps." "Updates from today 's meeting plus a bit of cleanup - references - spelling - addressing some clarifications from I have checked all the diffs and they look good ." e24f0e46970c4e1014284609644c366e8a23138c e24f0e46970c4e1014284609644c366e8a23138c draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework ff35c63d87ee290acdcaf50e9a9826cbe16c289ba5e61a157ce1c32b84fd5c8f ['3a3b30755697b8b84b4e957a75941b10a26d7684be2bb19820f593b4c40cef3c', 'a4c40e2a5d94a62408a33afebd53500dc73254bd15c3f1f40c39915d5c8d7e77', '7395ae0f777dcbfda92414d5c902b30189abf963306df8456a415e9c3942c01c', '79c51cb70fa0c71271628fddbe5f7d366b84024367517e776bdbcd3f2cbef99f', 'e272a85afcca5a5a4bc6143311efe118919c5e39790d66e46d87aea800afbd1f', 'ff35c63d87ee290acdcaf50e9a9826cbe16c289ba5e61a157ce1c32b84fd5c8f'] B "how the data plane is constructed: the detnet service sub-layer provides for the detnet application flows by using or applying existing standardized headers and/or encapsulations. the detnet forwarding sub-layer may provide capabilities leveraging that same header or encapsulation technology e.g. dn_svcs or it may be achieved by other standardized technologies e.g. dn_svc_encaps." {6: 1, 8: 2, 68: 5, 31: 2, 67: 2, 90: 3, 84: 3, 55: 2} {256: 1, 2: 2, 5: 5, 8: 2, 74: 2, 271: 3, 209: 2, 83: 6, 20: 5, 21: 6, 277: 5, 276: 6, 233: 3, 236: 5, 302: 3, 47: 3, 303: 6, 112: 2, 247: 4, 126: 3, 127: 2} {256, 2, 5, 8, 271, 20, 21, 277, 276, 302, 47, 303, 74, 209, 83, 88, 233, 236, 112, 247, 126, 127} 8 "Extensibility of that Data Plane: Whether or not the DetNet data plane includes the facility to carry additional information (metadata) that can be used to provide an enhanced service to the DetNet packet." "Updates from today 's meeting plus a bit of cleanup - references - spelling - addressing some clarifications from I have checked all the diffs and they look good ." e24f0e46970c4e1014284609644c366e8a23138c e24f0e46970c4e1014284609644c366e8a23138c draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework 7395ae0f777dcbfda92414d5c902b30189abf963306df8456a415e9c3942c01c ['3a3b30755697b8b84b4e957a75941b10a26d7684be2bb19820f593b4c40cef3c', 'a4c40e2a5d94a62408a33afebd53500dc73254bd15c3f1f40c39915d5c8d7e77', '7395ae0f777dcbfda92414d5c902b30189abf963306df8456a415e9c3942c01c', '79c51cb70fa0c71271628fddbe5f7d366b84024367517e776bdbcd3f2cbef99f', 'e272a85afcca5a5a4bc6143311efe118919c5e39790d66e46d87aea800afbd1f', 'ff35c63d87ee290acdcaf50e9a9826cbe16c289ba5e61a157ce1c32b84fd5c8f'] B "extensibility of that data plane: whether or not the detnet data plane includes the facility to carry additional information (metadata) that can be used to provide an enhanced service to the detnet packet." {6: 1, 8: 2, 68: 5, 31: 2, 67: 2, 90: 3, 84: 3, 55: 2} {256: 1, 2: 2, 5: 5, 8: 2, 74: 2, 271: 3, 209: 2, 83: 6, 20: 5, 21: 6, 277: 5, 276: 6, 233: 3, 236: 5, 302: 3, 47: 3, 303: 6, 112: 2, 247: 4, 126: 3, 127: 2} {256, 2, 5, 8, 271, 20, 21, 277, 276, 302, 47, 303, 74, 209, 83, 88, 233, 236, 112, 247, 126, 127} 8 "The encapsulation of the DetNet flows allows them to be sent over a data plane of a type other than their native type. Encapsulation is essential if, for example, it is required to send Ethernet TSN stream as a DetNet Application over a data plane such as MPLS. dn_svc_encaps illustrates some encapsulation combinations." "Updates from today 's meeting plus a bit of cleanup - references - spelling - addressing some clarifications from I have checked all the diffs and they look good ." e24f0e46970c4e1014284609644c366e8a23138c e24f0e46970c4e1014284609644c366e8a23138c draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework e272a85afcca5a5a4bc6143311efe118919c5e39790d66e46d87aea800afbd1f ['3a3b30755697b8b84b4e957a75941b10a26d7684be2bb19820f593b4c40cef3c', 'a4c40e2a5d94a62408a33afebd53500dc73254bd15c3f1f40c39915d5c8d7e77', '7395ae0f777dcbfda92414d5c902b30189abf963306df8456a415e9c3942c01c', '79c51cb70fa0c71271628fddbe5f7d366b84024367517e776bdbcd3f2cbef99f', 'e272a85afcca5a5a4bc6143311efe118919c5e39790d66e46d87aea800afbd1f', 'ff35c63d87ee290acdcaf50e9a9826cbe16c289ba5e61a157ce1c32b84fd5c8f'] B "the encapsulation of the detnet flows allows them to be sent over a data plane of a type other than their native type. encapsulation is essential if, for example, it is required to send ethernet tsn stream as a detnet application over a data plane such as mpls. dn_svc_encaps illustrates some encapsulation combinations." {6: 1, 8: 2, 68: 5, 31: 2, 67: 2, 90: 3, 84: 3, 55: 2} {256: 1, 2: 2, 5: 5, 8: 2, 74: 2, 271: 3, 209: 2, 83: 6, 20: 5, 21: 6, 277: 5, 276: 6, 233: 3, 236: 5, 302: 3, 47: 3, 303: 6, 112: 2, 247: 4, 126: 3, 127: 2} {256, 2, 5, 8, 271, 20, 21, 277, 276, 302, 47, 303, 74, 209, 83, 88, 233, 236, 112, 247, 126, 127} 8 "Encapsulation is also needed if the DetNet flow or aggregate flow is not easily recognised from from its native encapsulation." "Updates from today 's meeting plus a bit of cleanup - references - spelling - addressing some clarifications from I have checked all the diffs and they look good ." e24f0e46970c4e1014284609644c366e8a23138c e24f0e46970c4e1014284609644c366e8a23138c draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework 04b2534a78e7187612148ad001c00b31f44944f83982ddbbbae3a58beb3fd06b ['04b2534a78e7187612148ad001c00b31f44944f83982ddbbbae3a58beb3fd06b', '00bf810a627f4f3f9bee5911b58122850f4a780df8c244ef9f9cffa24cb14be5'] A "encapsulation is also needed if the detnet flow or aggregate flow is not easily recognised from from its native encapsulation." {6: 1, 68: 5, 31: 2, 8: 2, 67: 2, 90: 3, 84: 3, 55: 2} {256: 1, 5: 5, 8: 2, 74: 2, 271: 3, 209: 2, 83: 6, 20: 5, 21: 6, 277: 5, 276: 6, 88: 2, 233: 3, 236: 5, 302: 3, 47: 3, 303: 6, 112: 2, 247: 4, 126: 3, 127: 2} {256, 2, 5, 8, 271, 20, 21, 277, 276, 302, 47, 303, 74, 209, 83, 88, 233, 236, 112, 247, 126, 127} 8 "Encapsulation is also needed if the DetNet flow or aggregate flow is not easily recognised from its encapsulation." "Updates from today 's meeting plus a bit of cleanup - references - spelling - addressing some clarifications from I have checked all the diffs and they look good ." e24f0e46970c4e1014284609644c366e8a23138c e24f0e46970c4e1014284609644c366e8a23138c draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework 00bf810a627f4f3f9bee5911b58122850f4a780df8c244ef9f9cffa24cb14be5 ['04b2534a78e7187612148ad001c00b31f44944f83982ddbbbae3a58beb3fd06b', '00bf810a627f4f3f9bee5911b58122850f4a780df8c244ef9f9cffa24cb14be5'] B "encapsulation is also needed if the detnet flow or aggregate flow is not easily recognised from its encapsulation." {6: 1, 68: 5, 31: 2, 8: 2, 67: 2, 90: 3, 84: 3, 55: 2} {256: 1, 5: 5, 8: 2, 74: 2, 271: 3, 209: 2, 83: 6, 20: 5, 21: 6, 277: 5, 276: 6, 88: 2, 233: 3, 236: 5, 302: 3, 47: 3, 303: 6, 112: 2, 247: 4, 126: 3, 127: 2} {256, 2, 5, 8, 271, 20, 21, 277, 276, 302, 47, 303, 74, 209, 83, 88, 233, 236, 112, 247, 126, 127} 8 "Implicit metadata can be included through the use of the network programming paradigm I-D.spring-srv6-network-programming in which the suffix of an IPv6 address is used to encode additional information for use by the network of the receiving host. Examples of such information include the sequence number for use by the PREOF function, or even all the essential information being deigned into the DetNet over MPLS label stack (the DetNet Control Word and the DetNet Service label)." "Updates from today 's meeting plus a bit of cleanup - references - spelling - addressing some clarifications from I have checked all the diffs and they look good ." e24f0e46970c4e1014284609644c366e8a23138c e24f0e46970c4e1014284609644c366e8a23138c draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework 080077b619457d38c4225448a13df8b767d438a5c0d60832154eeecb05f5fc47 ['488067d315c616e2d21a1dc9378ccffefa1f9f5f754724632d56eba7300bb7a6', '080077b619457d38c4225448a13df8b767d438a5c0d60832154eeecb05f5fc47'] A "implicit metadata can be included through the use of the network programming paradigm i-d.spring-srv6-network-programming in which the suffix of an ipv6 address is used to encode additional information for use by the network of the receiving host. examples of such information include the sequence number for use by the preof function, or even all the essential information being deigned into the detnet over mpls label stack (the detnet control word and the detnet service label)." {31: 1, 6: 1, 8: 2, 68: 5, 67: 2, 90: 3, 84: 3, 55: 2} {8: 1, 256: 1, 2: 2, 5: 5, 74: 2, 271: 3, 209: 2, 83: 6, 20: 5, 21: 6, 277: 5, 276: 6, 88: 2, 233: 3, 236: 5, 302: 3, 47: 3, 303: 6, 247: 4, 126: 3, 127: 2} {256, 2, 5, 8, 271, 20, 21, 277, 276, 302, 47, 303, 74, 209, 83, 88, 233, 236, 112, 247, 126, 127} 8 "Implicit metadata can be included through the use of the network programming paradigm I-D.spring-srv6-network-programming in which the suffix of an IPv6 address is used to encode additional information for use by the network of the receiving host. Examples of such information include the sequence number for use by the PREOF function, or even all the essential information being included into the DetNet over MPLS label stack (the DetNet Control Word and the DetNet Service label)." "Updates from today 's meeting plus a bit of cleanup - references - spelling - addressing some clarifications from I have checked all the diffs and they look good ." e24f0e46970c4e1014284609644c366e8a23138c e24f0e46970c4e1014284609644c366e8a23138c draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework 488067d315c616e2d21a1dc9378ccffefa1f9f5f754724632d56eba7300bb7a6 ['488067d315c616e2d21a1dc9378ccffefa1f9f5f754724632d56eba7300bb7a6', '080077b619457d38c4225448a13df8b767d438a5c0d60832154eeecb05f5fc47'] B "implicit metadata can be included through the use of the network programming paradigm i-d.spring-srv6-network-programming in which the suffix of an ipv6 address is used to encode additional information for use by the network of the receiving host. examples of such information include the sequence number for use by the preof function, or even all the essential information being included into the detnet over mpls label stack (the detnet control word and the detnet service label)." {31: 1, 6: 1, 8: 2, 68: 5, 67: 2, 90: 3, 84: 3, 55: 2} {8: 1, 256: 1, 2: 2, 5: 5, 74: 2, 271: 3, 209: 2, 83: 6, 20: 5, 21: 6, 277: 5, 276: 6, 88: 2, 233: 3, 236: 5, 302: 3, 47: 3, 303: 6, 247: 4, 126: 3, 127: 2} {256, 2, 5, 8, 271, 20, 21, 277, 276, 302, 47, 303, 74, 209, 83, 88, 233, 236, 112, 247, 126, 127} 8 "MPLS provides the ability to forward traffic over implicit and explicit paths to the point in the network where the next DetNet service layer action needs to take place. It does this through the use of a stack of one or more labels with various forwarding semantics." "Updates from today 's meeting plus a bit of cleanup - references - spelling - addressing some clarifications from I have checked all the diffs and they look good ." e24f0e46970c4e1014284609644c366e8a23138c e24f0e46970c4e1014284609644c366e8a23138c draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework d0bcc637bfa20f222ac98b878a724978687152e9aeb24cd06c2f2a3d57d9efd5 ['d0bcc637bfa20f222ac98b878a724978687152e9aeb24cd06c2f2a3d57d9efd5', '86156bf77b4f5f7977d5e1684a269e01270045775780cc2cc759d55f97c1a38e'] A "mpls provides the ability to forward traffic over implicit and explicit paths to the point in the network where the next detnet service layer action needs to take place. it does this through the use of a stack of one or more labels with various forwarding semantics." {6: 1, 68: 1, 79: 10, 90: 8, 51: 10, 130: 10, 62: 9, 85: 9, 35: 11, 110: 11, 91: 13, 114: 11, 97: 11, 31: 3, 13: 10, 67: 10, 38: 12, 26: 9, 124: 10, 98: 10, 54: 10, 127: 11, 8: 2, 96: 11, 64: 10, 30: 12, 61: 13, 55: 4, 27: 9, 15: 11, 52: 9, 129: 11, 115: 11, 84: 6, 76: 11, 87: 11, 131: 13, 102: 8, 113: 13, 99: 10, 36: 11, 24: 10, 53: 9, 72: 12} {1: 1, 258: 1, 4: 10, 9: 10, 10: 11, 15: 11, 24: 10, 25: 9, 26: 9, 27: 11, 39: 5, 43: 11, 49: 14, 50: 13, 58: 13, 59: 10, 64: 11, 69: 9, 81: 10, 82: 10, 86: 11, 96: 12, 97: 11, 100: 13, 108: 11, 109: 12, 110: 12, 111: 10, 114: 11, 115: 12, 116: 11, 118: 10, 119: 9, 120: 11, 121: 8, 122: 12, 123: 11, 124: 7, 128: 12, 129: 12, 130: 13, 132: 9, 136: 10, 145: 9, 147: 12, 151: 12, 152: 12, 154: 11, 156: 10, 161: 8, 162: 7, 165: 11, 168: 12, 169: 11, 172: 11, 180: 12, 184: 10, 187: 13, 188: 12, 191: 11, 194: 9, 202: 10, 203: 11, 206: 10, 207: 11, 215: 9, 217: 11, 218: 2, 220: 8, 221: 8, 222: 7, 224: 11, 227: 11, 229: 11, 234: 13, 235: 10, 241: 10, 242: 10, 243: 9, 244: 12, 245: 9, 248: 12, 250: 12, 262: 12, 263: 13, 264: 9, 267: 8, 270: 11, 272: 11, 273: 10, 287: 11, 289: 11, 291: 13, 299: 11, 300: 11, 304: 11, 309: 8, 314: 10, 315: 11, 320: 8, 323: 9, 327: 12, 328: 10, 329: 10, 334: 10, 335: 11, 341: 11, 342: 12, 347: 11, 348: 11, 350: 12, 351: 13, 352: 11, 353: 11, 354: 10, 358: 6, 365: 11, 366: 10, 369: 9, 371: 13, 372: 13, 376: 10, 384: 13, 385: 12, 386: 11, 387: 11, 392: 10, 393: 11, 396: 12, 397: 3, 398: 4, 402: 11} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 8 "MPLS provides the ability to forward traffic over implicit and explicit paths to the point in the network where the next DetNet service sub-layer action needs to take place. It does this through the use of a stack of one or more labels with various forwarding semantics." "Updates from today 's meeting plus a bit of cleanup - references - spelling - addressing some clarifications from I have checked all the diffs and they look good ." e24f0e46970c4e1014284609644c366e8a23138c e24f0e46970c4e1014284609644c366e8a23138c draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework 86156bf77b4f5f7977d5e1684a269e01270045775780cc2cc759d55f97c1a38e ['d0bcc637bfa20f222ac98b878a724978687152e9aeb24cd06c2f2a3d57d9efd5', '86156bf77b4f5f7977d5e1684a269e01270045775780cc2cc759d55f97c1a38e'] B "mpls provides the ability to forward traffic over implicit and explicit paths to the point in the network where the next detnet service sub-layer action needs to take place. it does this through the use of a stack of one or more labels with various forwarding semantics." {6: 1, 68: 1, 79: 10, 90: 8, 51: 10, 130: 10, 62: 9, 85: 9, 35: 11, 110: 11, 91: 13, 114: 11, 97: 11, 31: 3, 13: 10, 67: 10, 38: 12, 26: 9, 124: 10, 98: 10, 54: 10, 127: 11, 8: 2, 96: 11, 64: 10, 30: 12, 61: 13, 55: 4, 27: 9, 15: 11, 52: 9, 129: 11, 115: 11, 84: 6, 76: 11, 87: 11, 131: 13, 102: 8, 113: 13, 99: 10, 36: 11, 24: 10, 53: 9, 72: 12} {1: 1, 258: 1, 4: 10, 9: 10, 10: 11, 15: 11, 24: 10, 25: 9, 26: 9, 27: 11, 39: 5, 43: 11, 49: 14, 50: 13, 58: 13, 59: 10, 64: 11, 69: 9, 81: 10, 82: 10, 86: 11, 96: 12, 97: 11, 100: 13, 108: 11, 109: 12, 110: 12, 111: 10, 114: 11, 115: 12, 116: 11, 118: 10, 119: 9, 120: 11, 121: 8, 122: 12, 123: 11, 124: 7, 128: 12, 129: 12, 130: 13, 132: 9, 136: 10, 145: 9, 147: 12, 151: 12, 152: 12, 154: 11, 156: 10, 161: 8, 162: 7, 165: 11, 168: 12, 169: 11, 172: 11, 180: 12, 184: 10, 187: 13, 188: 12, 191: 11, 194: 9, 202: 10, 203: 11, 206: 10, 207: 11, 215: 9, 217: 11, 218: 2, 220: 8, 221: 8, 222: 7, 224: 11, 227: 11, 229: 11, 234: 13, 235: 10, 241: 10, 242: 10, 243: 9, 244: 12, 245: 9, 248: 12, 250: 12, 262: 12, 263: 13, 264: 9, 267: 8, 270: 11, 272: 11, 273: 10, 287: 11, 289: 11, 291: 13, 299: 11, 300: 11, 304: 11, 309: 8, 314: 10, 315: 11, 320: 8, 323: 9, 327: 12, 328: 10, 329: 10, 334: 10, 335: 11, 341: 11, 342: 12, 347: 11, 348: 11, 350: 12, 351: 13, 352: 11, 353: 11, 354: 10, 358: 6, 365: 11, 366: 10, 369: 9, 371: 13, 372: 13, 376: 10, 384: 13, 385: 12, 386: 11, 387: 11, 392: 10, 393: 11, 396: 12, 397: 3, 398: 4, 402: 11} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 8 "In cases where metadata is needed to process an MPLS encapsulated packet at the service layer, this has been been provided through the use of a shim layer also called a control word (CW) RFC4385. Although such CWs are frequently 32 bits long, there is no architectural constraint on its size of this structure, only the requirement that it is fully understood by all parties operating on it in the DetNet service layer. The operation of this method is described in detail in I-D.ietf-detnet-mpls." "Updates from today 's meeting plus a bit of cleanup - references - spelling - addressing some clarifications from I have checked all the diffs and they look good ." e24f0e46970c4e1014284609644c366e8a23138c e24f0e46970c4e1014284609644c366e8a23138c draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework 8c6d08b2077f63af242b017cc8f33cd6eb524769fc73b1f6bbd818077d449078 ['8c6d08b2077f63af242b017cc8f33cd6eb524769fc73b1f6bbd818077d449078', 'b1ff68903ac6e0b8543e21f49db921c33e25559d9a9e6a3d6f7d04ca0e93291c'] A "in cases where metadata is needed to process an mpls encapsulated packet at the service layer, this has been been provided through the use of a shim layer also called a control word (cw) rfc4385. although such cws are frequently 32 bits long, there is no architectural constraint on its size of this structure, only the requirement that it is fully understood by all parties operating on it in the detnet service layer. the operation of this method is described in detail in i-d.ietf-detnet-mpls." {6: 1, 31: 1, 79: 8, 90: 6, 51: 8, 130: 8, 62: 7, 85: 7, 68: 3, 35: 9, 110: 9, 91: 11, 114: 9, 97: 9, 13: 8, 67: 8, 38: 10, 26: 7, 124: 8, 98: 8, 54: 8, 127: 9, 8: 2, 96: 9, 64: 8, 30: 10, 61: 11, 55: 2, 27: 7, 15: 9, 52: 7, 129: 9, 115: 9, 84: 4, 76: 9, 87: 9, 131: 11, 102: 6, 113: 11, 99: 8, 36: 9, 24: 8, 53: 7, 72: 10} {1: 1, 397: 1, 4: 8, 9: 8, 10: 9, 15: 9, 24: 8, 25: 7, 26: 7, 27: 9, 39: 3, 43: 9, 49: 12, 50: 11, 58: 11, 59: 8, 64: 9, 69: 7, 81: 8, 82: 8, 86: 9, 96: 10, 97: 9, 100: 11, 108: 9, 109: 10, 110: 10, 111: 8, 114: 9, 115: 10, 116: 9, 118: 8, 119: 7, 120: 9, 121: 6, 122: 10, 123: 9, 124: 5, 128: 10, 129: 10, 130: 11, 132: 7, 136: 8, 145: 7, 147: 10, 151: 10, 152: 10, 154: 9, 156: 8, 161: 6, 162: 5, 165: 9, 168: 10, 169: 9, 172: 9, 180: 10, 184: 8, 187: 11, 188: 10, 191: 9, 194: 7, 202: 8, 203: 9, 206: 8, 207: 9, 215: 7, 217: 9, 220: 6, 221: 6, 222: 5, 224: 9, 227: 9, 229: 9, 234: 11, 235: 8, 241: 8, 242: 8, 243: 7, 244: 10, 245: 7, 248: 10, 250: 10, 258: 3, 262: 10, 263: 11, 264: 7, 267: 6, 270: 9, 272: 9, 273: 8, 287: 9, 289: 9, 291: 11, 299: 9, 300: 9, 304: 9, 309: 6, 314: 8, 315: 9, 320: 6, 323: 7, 327: 10, 328: 8, 329: 8, 330: 2, 334: 8, 335: 9, 341: 9, 342: 10, 347: 9, 348: 9, 350: 10, 351: 11, 352: 9, 353: 9, 354: 8, 358: 4, 365: 9, 366: 8, 369: 7, 371: 11, 372: 11, 376: 8, 384: 11, 385: 10, 386: 9, 387: 9, 392: 8, 393: 9, 396: 10, 398: 2, 402: 9} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 8 "In cases where metadata is needed to process an MPLS encapsulated packet at the service sub-layer, this has been been provided through the use of a shim layer also called a control word (CW) RFC4385. Although such CWs are frequently 32 bits long, there is no architectural constraint on its size of this structure, only the requirement that it is fully understood by all parties operating on it in the DetNet service sub-layer. The operation of this method is described in detail in I-D.ietf-detnet-mpls." "Updates from today 's meeting plus a bit of cleanup - references - spelling - addressing some clarifications from I have checked all the diffs and they look good ." e24f0e46970c4e1014284609644c366e8a23138c e24f0e46970c4e1014284609644c366e8a23138c draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework b1ff68903ac6e0b8543e21f49db921c33e25559d9a9e6a3d6f7d04ca0e93291c ['8c6d08b2077f63af242b017cc8f33cd6eb524769fc73b1f6bbd818077d449078', 'b1ff68903ac6e0b8543e21f49db921c33e25559d9a9e6a3d6f7d04ca0e93291c'] B "in cases where metadata is needed to process an mpls encapsulated packet at the service sub-layer, this has been been provided through the use of a shim layer also called a control word (cw) rfc4385. although such cws are frequently 32 bits long, there is no architectural constraint on its size of this structure, only the requirement that it is fully understood by all parties operating on it in the detnet service sub-layer. the operation of this method is described in detail in i-d.ietf-detnet-mpls." {6: 1, 31: 1, 79: 8, 90: 6, 51: 8, 130: 8, 62: 7, 85: 7, 68: 3, 35: 9, 110: 9, 91: 11, 114: 9, 97: 9, 13: 8, 67: 8, 38: 10, 26: 7, 124: 8, 98: 8, 54: 8, 127: 9, 8: 2, 96: 9, 64: 8, 30: 10, 61: 11, 55: 2, 27: 7, 15: 9, 52: 7, 129: 9, 115: 9, 84: 4, 76: 9, 87: 9, 131: 11, 102: 6, 113: 11, 99: 8, 36: 9, 24: 8, 53: 7, 72: 10} {1: 1, 397: 1, 4: 8, 9: 8, 10: 9, 15: 9, 24: 8, 25: 7, 26: 7, 27: 9, 39: 3, 43: 9, 49: 12, 50: 11, 58: 11, 59: 8, 64: 9, 69: 7, 81: 8, 82: 8, 86: 9, 96: 10, 97: 9, 100: 11, 108: 9, 109: 10, 110: 10, 111: 8, 114: 9, 115: 10, 116: 9, 118: 8, 119: 7, 120: 9, 121: 6, 122: 10, 123: 9, 124: 5, 128: 10, 129: 10, 130: 11, 132: 7, 136: 8, 145: 7, 147: 10, 151: 10, 152: 10, 154: 9, 156: 8, 161: 6, 162: 5, 165: 9, 168: 10, 169: 9, 172: 9, 180: 10, 184: 8, 187: 11, 188: 10, 191: 9, 194: 7, 202: 8, 203: 9, 206: 8, 207: 9, 215: 7, 217: 9, 220: 6, 221: 6, 222: 5, 224: 9, 227: 9, 229: 9, 234: 11, 235: 8, 241: 8, 242: 8, 243: 7, 244: 10, 245: 7, 248: 10, 250: 10, 258: 3, 262: 10, 263: 11, 264: 7, 267: 6, 270: 9, 272: 9, 273: 8, 287: 9, 289: 9, 291: 11, 299: 9, 300: 9, 304: 9, 309: 6, 314: 8, 315: 9, 320: 6, 323: 7, 327: 10, 328: 8, 329: 8, 330: 2, 334: 8, 335: 9, 341: 9, 342: 10, 347: 9, 348: 9, 350: 10, 351: 11, 352: 9, 353: 9, 354: 8, 358: 4, 365: 9, 366: 8, 369: 7, 371: 11, 372: 11, 376: 8, 384: 11, 385: 10, 386: 9, 387: 9, 392: 8, 393: 9, 396: 10, 398: 2, 402: 9} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 8 "Use of a specific path for a flow. This allows control of the network delay by steering the packet with the ability to influence the physical path. Explicit routes complement reservation by ensuring that a consistent path can be associated with its resources for the duration of that path. Coupled with the traffic mechanism, this limits misordering and bounds latency." "Updates from today 's meeting plus a bit of cleanup - references - spelling - addressing some clarifications from I have checked all the diffs and they look good ." e24f0e46970c4e1014284609644c366e8a23138c e24f0e46970c4e1014284609644c366e8a23138c draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework 1ee64e328112b4bbc4ce29ee2d99c3a7d17221bef5cd89708782d6dfff492351 ['c5585816f0df6bac1e8561d23945939d704941f0bc9b379d59f610db1feeae52', '1ee64e328112b4bbc4ce29ee2d99c3a7d17221bef5cd89708782d6dfff492351'] A "use of a specific path for a flow. this allows control of the network delay by steering the packet with the ability to influence the physical path. explicit routes complement reservation by ensuring that a consistent path can be associated with its resources for the duration of that path. coupled with the traffic mechanism, this limits misordering and bounds latency." {55: 1, 6: 1, 79: 3, 90: 2, 51: 4, 130: 3, 62: 3, 85: 3, 68: 2, 35: 4, 110: 4, 91: 6, 114: 4, 97: 4, 31: 3, 13: 4, 67: 3, 38: 5, 26: 3, 124: 3, 98: 3, 54: 3, 127: 4, 8: 2, 96: 4, 64: 3, 30: 5, 61: 6, 27: 3, 15: 4, 52: 2, 129: 4, 115: 4, 84: 2, 76: 5, 87: 4, 131: 6, 102: 2, 113: 6, 99: 3, 36: 4, 24: 3, 53: 2, 72: 5} {162: 1, 220: 1, 1: 7, 4: 3, 9: 4, 10: 4, 15: 4, 24: 3, 25: 3, 26: 3, 27: 4, 39: 3, 43: 4, 49: 7, 50: 6, 58: 6, 59: 3, 64: 4, 69: 3, 81: 4, 82: 4, 86: 4, 96: 5, 97: 4, 100: 7, 108: 4, 109: 5, 110: 5, 111: 3, 114: 4, 115: 5, 116: 4, 118: 4, 119: 3, 120: 4, 121: 2, 122: 5, 123: 4, 124: 2, 128: 5, 129: 5, 130: 6, 132: 3, 136: 3, 145: 3, 147: 5, 151: 5, 152: 5, 154: 4, 156: 3, 161: 2, 165: 4, 168: 5, 169: 4, 172: 4, 180: 5, 184: 4, 187: 6, 188: 5, 191: 4, 194: 3, 202: 4, 203: 5, 206: 3, 207: 4, 215: 2, 217: 4, 218: 6, 221: 2, 222: 3, 224: 4, 227: 5, 229: 4, 234: 6, 235: 3, 241: 3, 242: 3, 243: 3, 244: 5, 245: 3, 248: 5, 250: 5, 258: 9, 262: 5, 263: 6, 264: 3, 267: 2, 270: 4, 272: 4, 273: 4, 287: 4, 289: 4, 291: 6, 299: 5, 300: 4, 304: 4, 314: 3, 315: 4, 320: 2, 323: 3, 327: 5, 328: 3, 329: 3, 330: 8, 334: 3, 335: 4, 341: 5, 342: 6, 347: 5, 348: 5, 350: 6, 351: 6, 352: 4, 353: 4, 354: 3, 358: 2, 365: 4, 366: 3, 369: 2, 371: 7, 372: 6, 376: 3, 384: 6, 385: 5, 386: 4, 387: 4, 392: 3, 393: 4, 396: 6, 397: 5, 398: 4, 402: 4} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 8 "Use of a specific path for a flow. This allows control of the network delay by steering the packet with the ability to influence the physical path. Explicit routes complement reservation by ensuring that a consistent path can be associated with its resources for the duration of that path. Coupled with the traffic mechanism, this limits misordering and bounds latency. Explicit route computation can encompass a wide set of constraints and optimize the path for a certain characteristic e.g. highest bandwidth or lowest jitter. In these cases the ""best"" path for any set of characteristics may not be a shortest path. The selection of path can take into account multiple network metrics. Some of these metrics are measured and distributed by the routing system as traffic engineering metrics." "Updates from today 's meeting plus a bit of cleanup - references - spelling - addressing some clarifications from I have checked all the diffs and they look good ." e24f0e46970c4e1014284609644c366e8a23138c e24f0e46970c4e1014284609644c366e8a23138c draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework c5585816f0df6bac1e8561d23945939d704941f0bc9b379d59f610db1feeae52 ['c5585816f0df6bac1e8561d23945939d704941f0bc9b379d59f610db1feeae52', '1ee64e328112b4bbc4ce29ee2d99c3a7d17221bef5cd89708782d6dfff492351'] B "use of a specific path for a flow. this allows control of the network delay by steering the packet with the ability to influence the physical path. explicit routes complement reservation by ensuring that a consistent path can be associated with its resources for the duration of that path. coupled with the traffic mechanism, this limits misordering and bounds latency. explicit route computation can encompass a wide set of constraints and optimize the path for a certain characteristic e.g. highest bandwidth or lowest jitter. in these cases the ""best"" path for any set of characteristics may not be a shortest path. the selection of path can take into account multiple network metrics. some of these metrics are measured and distributed by the routing system as traffic engineering metrics." {55: 1, 6: 1, 79: 3, 90: 2, 51: 4, 130: 3, 62: 3, 85: 3, 68: 2, 35: 4, 110: 4, 91: 6, 114: 4, 97: 4, 31: 3, 13: 4, 67: 3, 38: 5, 26: 3, 124: 3, 98: 3, 54: 3, 127: 4, 8: 2, 96: 4, 64: 3, 30: 5, 61: 6, 27: 3, 15: 4, 52: 2, 129: 4, 115: 4, 84: 2, 76: 5, 87: 4, 131: 6, 102: 2, 113: 6, 99: 3, 36: 4, 24: 3, 53: 2, 72: 5} {162: 1, 220: 1, 1: 7, 4: 3, 9: 4, 10: 4, 15: 4, 24: 3, 25: 3, 26: 3, 27: 4, 39: 3, 43: 4, 49: 7, 50: 6, 58: 6, 59: 3, 64: 4, 69: 3, 81: 4, 82: 4, 86: 4, 96: 5, 97: 4, 100: 7, 108: 4, 109: 5, 110: 5, 111: 3, 114: 4, 115: 5, 116: 4, 118: 4, 119: 3, 120: 4, 121: 2, 122: 5, 123: 4, 124: 2, 128: 5, 129: 5, 130: 6, 132: 3, 136: 3, 145: 3, 147: 5, 151: 5, 152: 5, 154: 4, 156: 3, 161: 2, 165: 4, 168: 5, 169: 4, 172: 4, 180: 5, 184: 4, 187: 6, 188: 5, 191: 4, 194: 3, 202: 4, 203: 5, 206: 3, 207: 4, 215: 2, 217: 4, 218: 6, 221: 2, 222: 3, 224: 4, 227: 5, 229: 4, 234: 6, 235: 3, 241: 3, 242: 3, 243: 3, 244: 5, 245: 3, 248: 5, 250: 5, 258: 9, 262: 5, 263: 6, 264: 3, 267: 2, 270: 4, 272: 4, 273: 4, 287: 4, 289: 4, 291: 6, 299: 5, 300: 4, 304: 4, 314: 3, 315: 4, 320: 2, 323: 3, 327: 5, 328: 3, 329: 3, 330: 8, 334: 3, 335: 4, 341: 5, 342: 6, 347: 5, 348: 5, 350: 6, 351: 6, 352: 4, 353: 4, 354: 3, 358: 2, 365: 4, 366: 3, 369: 2, 371: 7, 372: 6, 376: 3, 384: 6, 385: 5, 386: 4, 387: 4, 392: 3, 393: 4, 396: 6, 397: 5, 398: 4, 402: 4} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 8 "Use of network coding to improve a network's throughput, efficiency, latency, and scalability, as well as resilience to partition, attacks, and eavesdropping, as compared to traditional methods. Network coding is another technique that uses multiple paths typically with very similar delays and capacity. Network coding is often applied in wireless networks." "Updates from today 's meeting plus a bit of cleanup - references - spelling - addressing some clarifications from I have checked all the diffs and they look good ." e24f0e46970c4e1014284609644c366e8a23138c e24f0e46970c4e1014284609644c366e8a23138c draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework 4602f1e91bf42736704aa4b5deb973b3d0f537735bfefb88c02344a9e3c4f421 ['8d33f4dbbf7ab8899b8d7fe2858e2bd54d3076e1c21cd4da634f86caec05d13a', '48d8a67306a5b7377d474058a02289ef5b0d47c7b426e70ca86c86fbaacd1c90', '036168e918418eb807bc3efd361a8e66067192564da41e30e076d22be0f87935', '30d108135e5d5ca29f1851710d998b43e17cf658cb0bf7a20218abc345bf0b4e', 'a8ff14472a8fa48bacdc11d7089a9d1054c0a786f6152f510b5d4092c22e121f', '09338bff4c055a4fa57185ce910ed41cd32622051fe170615aabadb84e10faa4', '2755ae7cda161df0c24e1fa9f1c3308bc9ef81a599d859668490484290ca72f4', '4602f1e91bf42736704aa4b5deb973b3d0f537735bfefb88c02344a9e3c4f421', '595ccef56e4f3f92cf6c8157968607922c16102040d858595d47562c1a6e672a', 'b9bbfabb58957652f3a296054fff42678c08ff84156bc8d94d3610e121e772bf'] A "use of network coding to improve a network's throughput, efficiency, latency, and scalability, as well as resilience to partition, attacks, and eavesdropping, as compared to traditional methods. network coding is another technique that uses multiple paths typically with very similar delays and capacity. network coding is often applied in wireless networks." {55: 1, 52: 1, 6: 1, 53: 1, 79: 2, 90: 2, 51: 3, 130: 2, 62: 3, 85: 3, 68: 2, 35: 3, 110: 3, 91: 5, 114: 3, 97: 3, 31: 2, 13: 3, 67: 2, 38: 4, 26: 3, 124: 2, 98: 2, 54: 2, 127: 3, 8: 2, 96: 3, 64: 2, 30: 4, 61: 5, 27: 3, 15: 3, 129: 3, 115: 3, 84: 2, 76: 5, 87: 3, 131: 5, 102: 2, 113: 5, 99: 2, 36: 3, 24: 2, 72: 4} {162: 1, 215: 1, 220: 1, 369: 1, 1: 7, 4: 2, 9: 4, 10: 3, 15: 3, 24: 2, 25: 3, 26: 3, 27: 3, 39: 3, 43: 3, 49: 6, 50: 5, 58: 5, 59: 2, 64: 3, 69: 3, 81: 4, 82: 4, 86: 3, 96: 4, 97: 3, 100: 7, 108: 3, 109: 4, 110: 4, 111: 2, 114: 3, 115: 4, 116: 3, 118: 4, 119: 3, 120: 3, 121: 2, 122: 4, 123: 3, 124: 2, 128: 4, 129: 4, 130: 5, 132: 3, 136: 2, 145: 3, 147: 4, 151: 4, 152: 4, 154: 3, 156: 2, 161: 2, 165: 3, 168: 4, 169: 3, 172: 3, 180: 4, 184: 4, 187: 5, 188: 4, 191: 3, 194: 3, 202: 4, 203: 5, 206: 2, 207: 3, 217: 3, 218: 6, 222: 3, 224: 3, 227: 5, 229: 3, 234: 5, 235: 2, 241: 2, 242: 2, 243: 3, 244: 4, 245: 3, 248: 4, 250: 4, 258: 9, 262: 4, 263: 5, 264: 2, 267: 2, 270: 3, 272: 3, 273: 4, 287: 3, 289: 3, 291: 5, 299: 5, 300: 3, 304: 3, 309: 2, 314: 2, 315: 3, 320: 2, 323: 3, 327: 4, 328: 2, 329: 2, 330: 8, 334: 2, 335: 3, 341: 5, 342: 6, 347: 5, 348: 5, 350: 6, 351: 5, 352: 3, 353: 3, 354: 2, 358: 2, 365: 3, 366: 2, 371: 7, 372: 5, 376: 2, 384: 5, 385: 4, 386: 3, 387: 3, 392: 2, 393: 3, 396: 6, 397: 5, 398: 4, 402: 3} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 8 "Use of packet by packet distribution of the same DetNet flow over multiple paths is not recommended. Such load sharing, e.g., via ECMP or UCMP, impacts ordering and possibly jitter." "Updates from today 's meeting plus a bit of cleanup - references - spelling - addressing some clarifications from I have checked all the diffs and they look good ." e24f0e46970c4e1014284609644c366e8a23138c e24f0e46970c4e1014284609644c366e8a23138c draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework 8d33f4dbbf7ab8899b8d7fe2858e2bd54d3076e1c21cd4da634f86caec05d13a ['8d33f4dbbf7ab8899b8d7fe2858e2bd54d3076e1c21cd4da634f86caec05d13a', '48d8a67306a5b7377d474058a02289ef5b0d47c7b426e70ca86c86fbaacd1c90', '036168e918418eb807bc3efd361a8e66067192564da41e30e076d22be0f87935', '30d108135e5d5ca29f1851710d998b43e17cf658cb0bf7a20218abc345bf0b4e', 'a8ff14472a8fa48bacdc11d7089a9d1054c0a786f6152f510b5d4092c22e121f', '09338bff4c055a4fa57185ce910ed41cd32622051fe170615aabadb84e10faa4', '2755ae7cda161df0c24e1fa9f1c3308bc9ef81a599d859668490484290ca72f4', '4602f1e91bf42736704aa4b5deb973b3d0f537735bfefb88c02344a9e3c4f421', '595ccef56e4f3f92cf6c8157968607922c16102040d858595d47562c1a6e672a', 'b9bbfabb58957652f3a296054fff42678c08ff84156bc8d94d3610e121e772bf'] A "use of packet by packet distribution of the same detnet flow over multiple paths is not recommended. such load sharing, e.g., via ecmp or ucmp, impacts ordering and possibly jitter." {55: 1, 52: 1, 6: 1, 53: 1, 79: 2, 90: 2, 51: 3, 130: 2, 62: 3, 85: 3, 68: 2, 35: 3, 110: 3, 91: 5, 114: 3, 97: 3, 31: 2, 13: 3, 67: 2, 38: 4, 26: 3, 124: 2, 98: 2, 54: 2, 127: 3, 8: 2, 96: 3, 64: 2, 30: 4, 61: 5, 27: 3, 15: 3, 129: 3, 115: 3, 84: 2, 76: 5, 87: 3, 131: 5, 102: 2, 113: 5, 99: 2, 36: 3, 24: 2, 72: 4} {162: 1, 215: 1, 220: 1, 369: 1, 1: 7, 4: 2, 9: 4, 10: 3, 15: 3, 24: 2, 25: 3, 26: 3, 27: 3, 39: 3, 43: 3, 49: 6, 50: 5, 58: 5, 59: 2, 64: 3, 69: 3, 81: 4, 82: 4, 86: 3, 96: 4, 97: 3, 100: 7, 108: 3, 109: 4, 110: 4, 111: 2, 114: 3, 115: 4, 116: 3, 118: 4, 119: 3, 120: 3, 121: 2, 122: 4, 123: 3, 124: 2, 128: 4, 129: 4, 130: 5, 132: 3, 136: 2, 145: 3, 147: 4, 151: 4, 152: 4, 154: 3, 156: 2, 161: 2, 165: 3, 168: 4, 169: 3, 172: 3, 180: 4, 184: 4, 187: 5, 188: 4, 191: 3, 194: 3, 202: 4, 203: 5, 206: 2, 207: 3, 217: 3, 218: 6, 222: 3, 224: 3, 227: 5, 229: 3, 234: 5, 235: 2, 241: 2, 242: 2, 243: 3, 244: 4, 245: 3, 248: 4, 250: 4, 258: 9, 262: 4, 263: 5, 264: 2, 267: 2, 270: 3, 272: 3, 273: 4, 287: 3, 289: 3, 291: 5, 299: 5, 300: 3, 304: 3, 309: 2, 314: 2, 315: 3, 320: 2, 323: 3, 327: 4, 328: 2, 329: 2, 330: 8, 334: 2, 335: 3, 341: 5, 342: 6, 347: 5, 348: 5, 350: 6, 351: 5, 352: 3, 353: 3, 354: 2, 358: 2, 365: 3, 366: 2, 371: 7, 372: 5, 376: 2, 384: 5, 385: 4, 386: 3, 387: 3, 392: 2, 393: 3, 396: 6, 397: 5, 398: 4, 402: 3} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 8 For example, to support identification of misbehaving flows. "Updates from today 's meeting plus a bit of cleanup - references - spelling - addressing some clarifications from I have checked all the diffs and they look good ." e24f0e46970c4e1014284609644c366e8a23138c e24f0e46970c4e1014284609644c366e8a23138c draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework 036168e918418eb807bc3efd361a8e66067192564da41e30e076d22be0f87935 ['8d33f4dbbf7ab8899b8d7fe2858e2bd54d3076e1c21cd4da634f86caec05d13a', '48d8a67306a5b7377d474058a02289ef5b0d47c7b426e70ca86c86fbaacd1c90', '036168e918418eb807bc3efd361a8e66067192564da41e30e076d22be0f87935', '30d108135e5d5ca29f1851710d998b43e17cf658cb0bf7a20218abc345bf0b4e', 'a8ff14472a8fa48bacdc11d7089a9d1054c0a786f6152f510b5d4092c22e121f', '09338bff4c055a4fa57185ce910ed41cd32622051fe170615aabadb84e10faa4', '2755ae7cda161df0c24e1fa9f1c3308bc9ef81a599d859668490484290ca72f4', '4602f1e91bf42736704aa4b5deb973b3d0f537735bfefb88c02344a9e3c4f421', '595ccef56e4f3f92cf6c8157968607922c16102040d858595d47562c1a6e672a', 'b9bbfabb58957652f3a296054fff42678c08ff84156bc8d94d3610e121e772bf'] A for example, to support identification of misbehaving flows. {55: 1, 52: 1, 6: 1, 53: 1, 79: 2, 90: 2, 51: 3, 130: 2, 62: 3, 85: 3, 68: 2, 35: 3, 110: 3, 91: 5, 114: 3, 97: 3, 31: 2, 13: 3, 67: 2, 38: 4, 26: 3, 124: 2, 98: 2, 54: 2, 127: 3, 8: 2, 96: 3, 64: 2, 30: 4, 61: 5, 27: 3, 15: 3, 129: 3, 115: 3, 84: 2, 76: 5, 87: 3, 131: 5, 102: 2, 113: 5, 99: 2, 36: 3, 24: 2, 72: 4} {162: 1, 215: 1, 220: 1, 369: 1, 1: 7, 4: 2, 9: 4, 10: 3, 15: 3, 24: 2, 25: 3, 26: 3, 27: 3, 39: 3, 43: 3, 49: 6, 50: 5, 58: 5, 59: 2, 64: 3, 69: 3, 81: 4, 82: 4, 86: 3, 96: 4, 97: 3, 100: 7, 108: 3, 109: 4, 110: 4, 111: 2, 114: 3, 115: 4, 116: 3, 118: 4, 119: 3, 120: 3, 121: 2, 122: 4, 123: 3, 124: 2, 128: 4, 129: 4, 130: 5, 132: 3, 136: 2, 145: 3, 147: 4, 151: 4, 152: 4, 154: 3, 156: 2, 161: 2, 165: 3, 168: 4, 169: 3, 172: 3, 180: 4, 184: 4, 187: 5, 188: 4, 191: 3, 194: 3, 202: 4, 203: 5, 206: 2, 207: 3, 217: 3, 218: 6, 222: 3, 224: 3, 227: 5, 229: 3, 234: 5, 235: 2, 241: 2, 242: 2, 243: 3, 244: 4, 245: 3, 248: 4, 250: 4, 258: 9, 262: 4, 263: 5, 264: 2, 267: 2, 270: 3, 272: 3, 273: 4, 287: 3, 289: 3, 291: 5, 299: 5, 300: 3, 304: 3, 309: 2, 314: 2, 315: 3, 320: 2, 323: 3, 327: 4, 328: 2, 329: 2, 330: 8, 334: 2, 335: 3, 341: 5, 342: 6, 347: 5, 348: 5, 350: 6, 351: 5, 352: 3, 353: 3, 354: 2, 358: 2, 365: 3, 366: 2, 371: 7, 372: 5, 376: 2, 384: 5, 385: 4, 386: 3, 387: 3, 392: 2, 393: 3, 396: 6, 397: 5, 398: 4, 402: 3} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 8 For example, increase counters. "Updates from today 's meeting plus a bit of cleanup - references - spelling - addressing some clarifications from I have checked all the diffs and they look good ." e24f0e46970c4e1014284609644c366e8a23138c e24f0e46970c4e1014284609644c366e8a23138c draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework 2755ae7cda161df0c24e1fa9f1c3308bc9ef81a599d859668490484290ca72f4 ['8d33f4dbbf7ab8899b8d7fe2858e2bd54d3076e1c21cd4da634f86caec05d13a', '48d8a67306a5b7377d474058a02289ef5b0d47c7b426e70ca86c86fbaacd1c90', '036168e918418eb807bc3efd361a8e66067192564da41e30e076d22be0f87935', '30d108135e5d5ca29f1851710d998b43e17cf658cb0bf7a20218abc345bf0b4e', 'a8ff14472a8fa48bacdc11d7089a9d1054c0a786f6152f510b5d4092c22e121f', '09338bff4c055a4fa57185ce910ed41cd32622051fe170615aabadb84e10faa4', '2755ae7cda161df0c24e1fa9f1c3308bc9ef81a599d859668490484290ca72f4', '4602f1e91bf42736704aa4b5deb973b3d0f537735bfefb88c02344a9e3c4f421', '595ccef56e4f3f92cf6c8157968607922c16102040d858595d47562c1a6e672a', 'b9bbfabb58957652f3a296054fff42678c08ff84156bc8d94d3610e121e772bf'] A for example, increase counters. {55: 1, 52: 1, 6: 1, 53: 1, 79: 2, 90: 2, 51: 3, 130: 2, 62: 3, 85: 3, 68: 2, 35: 3, 110: 3, 91: 5, 114: 3, 97: 3, 31: 2, 13: 3, 67: 2, 38: 4, 26: 3, 124: 2, 98: 2, 54: 2, 127: 3, 8: 2, 96: 3, 64: 2, 30: 4, 61: 5, 27: 3, 15: 3, 129: 3, 115: 3, 84: 2, 76: 5, 87: 3, 131: 5, 102: 2, 113: 5, 99: 2, 36: 3, 24: 2, 72: 4} {162: 1, 215: 1, 220: 1, 369: 1, 1: 7, 4: 2, 9: 4, 10: 3, 15: 3, 24: 2, 25: 3, 26: 3, 27: 3, 39: 3, 43: 3, 49: 6, 50: 5, 58: 5, 59: 2, 64: 3, 69: 3, 81: 4, 82: 4, 86: 3, 96: 4, 97: 3, 100: 7, 108: 3, 109: 4, 110: 4, 111: 2, 114: 3, 115: 4, 116: 3, 118: 4, 119: 3, 120: 3, 121: 2, 122: 4, 123: 3, 124: 2, 128: 4, 129: 4, 130: 5, 132: 3, 136: 2, 145: 3, 147: 4, 151: 4, 152: 4, 154: 3, 156: 2, 161: 2, 165: 3, 168: 4, 169: 3, 172: 3, 180: 4, 184: 4, 187: 5, 188: 4, 191: 3, 194: 3, 202: 4, 203: 5, 206: 2, 207: 3, 217: 3, 218: 6, 222: 3, 224: 3, 227: 5, 229: 3, 234: 5, 235: 2, 241: 2, 242: 2, 243: 3, 244: 4, 245: 3, 248: 4, 250: 4, 258: 9, 262: 4, 263: 5, 264: 2, 267: 2, 270: 3, 272: 3, 273: 4, 287: 3, 289: 3, 291: 5, 299: 5, 300: 3, 304: 3, 309: 2, 314: 2, 315: 3, 320: 2, 323: 3, 327: 4, 328: 2, 329: 2, 330: 8, 334: 2, 335: 3, 341: 5, 342: 6, 347: 5, 348: 5, 350: 6, 351: 5, 352: 3, 353: 3, 354: 2, 358: 2, 365: 3, 366: 2, 371: 7, 372: 5, 376: 2, 384: 5, 385: 4, 386: 3, 387: 3, 392: 2, 393: 3, 396: 6, 397: 5, 398: 4, 402: 3} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 8 For example, unexpected loss. "Updates from today 's meeting plus a bit of cleanup - references - spelling - addressing some clarifications from I have checked all the diffs and they look good ." e24f0e46970c4e1014284609644c366e8a23138c e24f0e46970c4e1014284609644c366e8a23138c draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework a8ff14472a8fa48bacdc11d7089a9d1054c0a786f6152f510b5d4092c22e121f ['8d33f4dbbf7ab8899b8d7fe2858e2bd54d3076e1c21cd4da634f86caec05d13a', '48d8a67306a5b7377d474058a02289ef5b0d47c7b426e70ca86c86fbaacd1c90', '036168e918418eb807bc3efd361a8e66067192564da41e30e076d22be0f87935', '30d108135e5d5ca29f1851710d998b43e17cf658cb0bf7a20218abc345bf0b4e', 'a8ff14472a8fa48bacdc11d7089a9d1054c0a786f6152f510b5d4092c22e121f', '09338bff4c055a4fa57185ce910ed41cd32622051fe170615aabadb84e10faa4', '2755ae7cda161df0c24e1fa9f1c3308bc9ef81a599d859668490484290ca72f4', '4602f1e91bf42736704aa4b5deb973b3d0f537735bfefb88c02344a9e3c4f421', '595ccef56e4f3f92cf6c8157968607922c16102040d858595d47562c1a6e672a', 'b9bbfabb58957652f3a296054fff42678c08ff84156bc8d94d3610e121e772bf'] A for example, unexpected loss. {55: 1, 52: 1, 6: 1, 53: 1, 79: 2, 90: 2, 51: 3, 130: 2, 62: 3, 85: 3, 68: 2, 35: 3, 110: 3, 91: 5, 114: 3, 97: 3, 31: 2, 13: 3, 67: 2, 38: 4, 26: 3, 124: 2, 98: 2, 54: 2, 127: 3, 8: 2, 96: 3, 64: 2, 30: 4, 61: 5, 27: 3, 15: 3, 129: 3, 115: 3, 84: 2, 76: 5, 87: 3, 131: 5, 102: 2, 113: 5, 99: 2, 36: 3, 24: 2, 72: 4} {162: 1, 215: 1, 220: 1, 369: 1, 1: 7, 4: 2, 9: 4, 10: 3, 15: 3, 24: 2, 25: 3, 26: 3, 27: 3, 39: 3, 43: 3, 49: 6, 50: 5, 58: 5, 59: 2, 64: 3, 69: 3, 81: 4, 82: 4, 86: 3, 96: 4, 97: 3, 100: 7, 108: 3, 109: 4, 110: 4, 111: 2, 114: 3, 115: 4, 116: 3, 118: 4, 119: 3, 120: 3, 121: 2, 122: 4, 123: 3, 124: 2, 128: 4, 129: 4, 130: 5, 132: 3, 136: 2, 145: 3, 147: 4, 151: 4, 152: 4, 154: 3, 156: 2, 161: 2, 165: 3, 168: 4, 169: 3, 172: 3, 180: 4, 184: 4, 187: 5, 188: 4, 191: 3, 194: 3, 202: 4, 203: 5, 206: 2, 207: 3, 217: 3, 218: 6, 222: 3, 224: 3, 227: 5, 229: 3, 234: 5, 235: 2, 241: 2, 242: 2, 243: 3, 244: 4, 245: 3, 248: 4, 250: 4, 258: 9, 262: 4, 263: 5, 264: 2, 267: 2, 270: 3, 272: 3, 273: 4, 287: 3, 289: 3, 291: 5, 299: 5, 300: 3, 304: 3, 309: 2, 314: 2, 315: 3, 320: 2, 323: 3, 327: 4, 328: 2, 329: 2, 330: 8, 334: 2, 335: 3, 341: 5, 342: 6, 347: 5, 348: 5, 350: 6, 351: 5, 352: 3, 353: 3, 354: 2, 358: 2, 365: 3, 366: 2, 371: 7, 372: 5, 376: 2, 384: 5, 385: 4, 386: 3, 387: 3, 392: 2, 393: 3, 396: 6, 397: 5, 398: 4, 402: 3} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 8 "Network Coding, not to be confused with network programming, comprises several techniques where multiple data flows are encoded. These resulting flows can then be sent on different paths. The encoding operation can combine flows and error recovery information. When the encoded flows are decoded and recombined the original flows can be recovered. Note that Network coding uses an alternative to packet by packet PREOF. Therefore, for certain network topologies and traffic loads, Network Coding can be used to improve a network's throughput, efficiency, latency, and scalability, as well as resilience to partition, attacks, and eavesdropping, as compared to traditional methods. DetNet could utilized Network coding as an alternative to other protection means. Network coding is often applied in wireless networks and is being explored for other network types." "Updates from today 's meeting plus a bit of cleanup - references - spelling - addressing some clarifications from I have checked all the diffs and they look good ." e24f0e46970c4e1014284609644c366e8a23138c e24f0e46970c4e1014284609644c366e8a23138c draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework 595ccef56e4f3f92cf6c8157968607922c16102040d858595d47562c1a6e672a ['8d33f4dbbf7ab8899b8d7fe2858e2bd54d3076e1c21cd4da634f86caec05d13a', '48d8a67306a5b7377d474058a02289ef5b0d47c7b426e70ca86c86fbaacd1c90', '036168e918418eb807bc3efd361a8e66067192564da41e30e076d22be0f87935', '30d108135e5d5ca29f1851710d998b43e17cf658cb0bf7a20218abc345bf0b4e', 'a8ff14472a8fa48bacdc11d7089a9d1054c0a786f6152f510b5d4092c22e121f', '09338bff4c055a4fa57185ce910ed41cd32622051fe170615aabadb84e10faa4', '2755ae7cda161df0c24e1fa9f1c3308bc9ef81a599d859668490484290ca72f4', '4602f1e91bf42736704aa4b5deb973b3d0f537735bfefb88c02344a9e3c4f421', '595ccef56e4f3f92cf6c8157968607922c16102040d858595d47562c1a6e672a', 'b9bbfabb58957652f3a296054fff42678c08ff84156bc8d94d3610e121e772bf'] B "network coding, not to be confused with network programming, comprises several techniques where multiple data flows are encoded. these resulting flows can then be sent on different paths. the encoding operation can combine flows and error recovery information. when the encoded flows are decoded and recombined the original flows can be recovered. note that network coding uses an alternative to packet by packet preof. therefore, for certain network topologies and traffic loads, network coding can be used to improve a network's throughput, efficiency, latency, and scalability, as well as resilience to partition, attacks, and eavesdropping, as compared to traditional methods. detnet could utilized network coding as an alternative to other protection means. network coding is often applied in wireless networks and is being explored for other network types." {55: 1, 52: 1, 6: 1, 53: 1, 79: 2, 90: 2, 51: 3, 130: 2, 62: 3, 85: 3, 68: 2, 35: 3, 110: 3, 91: 5, 114: 3, 97: 3, 31: 2, 13: 3, 67: 2, 38: 4, 26: 3, 124: 2, 98: 2, 54: 2, 127: 3, 8: 2, 96: 3, 64: 2, 30: 4, 61: 5, 27: 3, 15: 3, 129: 3, 115: 3, 84: 2, 76: 5, 87: 3, 131: 5, 102: 2, 113: 5, 99: 2, 36: 3, 24: 2, 72: 4} {162: 1, 215: 1, 220: 1, 369: 1, 1: 7, 4: 2, 9: 4, 10: 3, 15: 3, 24: 2, 25: 3, 26: 3, 27: 3, 39: 3, 43: 3, 49: 6, 50: 5, 58: 5, 59: 2, 64: 3, 69: 3, 81: 4, 82: 4, 86: 3, 96: 4, 97: 3, 100: 7, 108: 3, 109: 4, 110: 4, 111: 2, 114: 3, 115: 4, 116: 3, 118: 4, 119: 3, 120: 3, 121: 2, 122: 4, 123: 3, 124: 2, 128: 4, 129: 4, 130: 5, 132: 3, 136: 2, 145: 3, 147: 4, 151: 4, 152: 4, 154: 3, 156: 2, 161: 2, 165: 3, 168: 4, 169: 3, 172: 3, 180: 4, 184: 4, 187: 5, 188: 4, 191: 3, 194: 3, 202: 4, 203: 5, 206: 2, 207: 3, 217: 3, 218: 6, 222: 3, 224: 3, 227: 5, 229: 3, 234: 5, 235: 2, 241: 2, 242: 2, 243: 3, 244: 4, 245: 3, 248: 4, 250: 4, 258: 9, 262: 4, 263: 5, 264: 2, 267: 2, 270: 3, 272: 3, 273: 4, 287: 3, 289: 3, 291: 5, 299: 5, 300: 3, 304: 3, 309: 2, 314: 2, 315: 3, 320: 2, 323: 3, 327: 4, 328: 2, 329: 2, 330: 8, 334: 2, 335: 3, 341: 5, 342: 6, 347: 5, 348: 5, 350: 6, 351: 5, 352: 3, 353: 3, 354: 2, 358: 2, 365: 3, 366: 2, 371: 7, 372: 5, 376: 2, 384: 5, 385: 4, 386: 3, 387: 3, 392: 2, 393: 3, 396: 6, 397: 5, 398: 4, 402: 3} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 8 "Use of packet by packet distribution of the same DetNet flow over multiple paths is not recommended except for the cases listed above where PREOF is utilized to improve protection of traffic and maintain order. Packet by packet load sharing, e.g., via ECMP or UCMP, impacts ordering and possibly jitter." "Updates from today 's meeting plus a bit of cleanup - references - spelling - addressing some clarifications from I have checked all the diffs and they look good ." e24f0e46970c4e1014284609644c366e8a23138c e24f0e46970c4e1014284609644c366e8a23138c draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework 30d108135e5d5ca29f1851710d998b43e17cf658cb0bf7a20218abc345bf0b4e ['8d33f4dbbf7ab8899b8d7fe2858e2bd54d3076e1c21cd4da634f86caec05d13a', '48d8a67306a5b7377d474058a02289ef5b0d47c7b426e70ca86c86fbaacd1c90', '036168e918418eb807bc3efd361a8e66067192564da41e30e076d22be0f87935', '30d108135e5d5ca29f1851710d998b43e17cf658cb0bf7a20218abc345bf0b4e', 'a8ff14472a8fa48bacdc11d7089a9d1054c0a786f6152f510b5d4092c22e121f', '09338bff4c055a4fa57185ce910ed41cd32622051fe170615aabadb84e10faa4', '2755ae7cda161df0c24e1fa9f1c3308bc9ef81a599d859668490484290ca72f4', '4602f1e91bf42736704aa4b5deb973b3d0f537735bfefb88c02344a9e3c4f421', '595ccef56e4f3f92cf6c8157968607922c16102040d858595d47562c1a6e672a', 'b9bbfabb58957652f3a296054fff42678c08ff84156bc8d94d3610e121e772bf'] B "use of packet by packet distribution of the same detnet flow over multiple paths is not recommended except for the cases listed above where preof is utilized to improve protection of traffic and maintain order. packet by packet load sharing, e.g., via ecmp or ucmp, impacts ordering and possibly jitter." {55: 1, 52: 1, 6: 1, 53: 1, 79: 2, 90: 2, 51: 3, 130: 2, 62: 3, 85: 3, 68: 2, 35: 3, 110: 3, 91: 5, 114: 3, 97: 3, 31: 2, 13: 3, 67: 2, 38: 4, 26: 3, 124: 2, 98: 2, 54: 2, 127: 3, 8: 2, 96: 3, 64: 2, 30: 4, 61: 5, 27: 3, 15: 3, 129: 3, 115: 3, 84: 2, 76: 5, 87: 3, 131: 5, 102: 2, 113: 5, 99: 2, 36: 3, 24: 2, 72: 4} {162: 1, 215: 1, 220: 1, 369: 1, 1: 7, 4: 2, 9: 4, 10: 3, 15: 3, 24: 2, 25: 3, 26: 3, 27: 3, 39: 3, 43: 3, 49: 6, 50: 5, 58: 5, 59: 2, 64: 3, 69: 3, 81: 4, 82: 4, 86: 3, 96: 4, 97: 3, 100: 7, 108: 3, 109: 4, 110: 4, 111: 2, 114: 3, 115: 4, 116: 3, 118: 4, 119: 3, 120: 3, 121: 2, 122: 4, 123: 3, 124: 2, 128: 4, 129: 4, 130: 5, 132: 3, 136: 2, 145: 3, 147: 4, 151: 4, 152: 4, 154: 3, 156: 2, 161: 2, 165: 3, 168: 4, 169: 3, 172: 3, 180: 4, 184: 4, 187: 5, 188: 4, 191: 3, 194: 3, 202: 4, 203: 5, 206: 2, 207: 3, 217: 3, 218: 6, 222: 3, 224: 3, 227: 5, 229: 3, 234: 5, 235: 2, 241: 2, 242: 2, 243: 3, 244: 4, 245: 3, 248: 4, 250: 4, 258: 9, 262: 4, 263: 5, 264: 2, 267: 2, 270: 3, 272: 3, 273: 4, 287: 3, 289: 3, 291: 5, 299: 5, 300: 3, 304: 3, 309: 2, 314: 2, 315: 3, 320: 2, 323: 3, 327: 4, 328: 2, 329: 2, 330: 8, 334: 2, 335: 3, 341: 5, 342: 6, 347: 5, 348: 5, 350: 6, 351: 5, 352: 3, 353: 3, 354: 2, 358: 2, 365: 3, 366: 2, 371: 7, 372: 5, 376: 2, 384: 5, 385: 4, 386: 3, 387: 3, 392: 2, 393: 3, 396: 6, 397: 5, 398: 4, 402: 3} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 8 "Since Detnet leverages many different forwarding sub-layers, those technologies also support a number of tools to troubleshoot connectivity for example, to support identification of misbehaving flows. At the service layer again there are existing mechanisms to troubleshoot or monitor flows. Many of these mechanisms exist for IP and MPLS networks. A client of a DetNet service can introduce any monitoring applications which can detect and monitor delay and loss." "Updates from today 's meeting plus a bit of cleanup - references - spelling - addressing some clarifications from I have checked all the diffs and they look good ." e24f0e46970c4e1014284609644c366e8a23138c e24f0e46970c4e1014284609644c366e8a23138c draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework 09338bff4c055a4fa57185ce910ed41cd32622051fe170615aabadb84e10faa4 ['8d33f4dbbf7ab8899b8d7fe2858e2bd54d3076e1c21cd4da634f86caec05d13a', '48d8a67306a5b7377d474058a02289ef5b0d47c7b426e70ca86c86fbaacd1c90', '036168e918418eb807bc3efd361a8e66067192564da41e30e076d22be0f87935', '30d108135e5d5ca29f1851710d998b43e17cf658cb0bf7a20218abc345bf0b4e', 'a8ff14472a8fa48bacdc11d7089a9d1054c0a786f6152f510b5d4092c22e121f', '09338bff4c055a4fa57185ce910ed41cd32622051fe170615aabadb84e10faa4', '2755ae7cda161df0c24e1fa9f1c3308bc9ef81a599d859668490484290ca72f4', '4602f1e91bf42736704aa4b5deb973b3d0f537735bfefb88c02344a9e3c4f421', '595ccef56e4f3f92cf6c8157968607922c16102040d858595d47562c1a6e672a', 'b9bbfabb58957652f3a296054fff42678c08ff84156bc8d94d3610e121e772bf'] B "since detnet leverages many different forwarding sub-layers, those technologies also support a number of tools to troubleshoot connectivity for example, to support identification of misbehaving flows. at the service layer again there are existing mechanisms to troubleshoot or monitor flows. many of these mechanisms exist for ip and mpls networks. a client of a detnet service can introduce any monitoring applications which can detect and monitor delay and loss." {55: 1, 52: 1, 6: 1, 53: 1, 79: 2, 90: 2, 51: 3, 130: 2, 62: 3, 85: 3, 68: 2, 35: 3, 110: 3, 91: 5, 114: 3, 97: 3, 31: 2, 13: 3, 67: 2, 38: 4, 26: 3, 124: 2, 98: 2, 54: 2, 127: 3, 8: 2, 96: 3, 64: 2, 30: 4, 61: 5, 27: 3, 15: 3, 129: 3, 115: 3, 84: 2, 76: 5, 87: 3, 131: 5, 102: 2, 113: 5, 99: 2, 36: 3, 24: 2, 72: 4} {162: 1, 215: 1, 220: 1, 369: 1, 1: 7, 4: 2, 9: 4, 10: 3, 15: 3, 24: 2, 25: 3, 26: 3, 27: 3, 39: 3, 43: 3, 49: 6, 50: 5, 58: 5, 59: 2, 64: 3, 69: 3, 81: 4, 82: 4, 86: 3, 96: 4, 97: 3, 100: 7, 108: 3, 109: 4, 110: 4, 111: 2, 114: 3, 115: 4, 116: 3, 118: 4, 119: 3, 120: 3, 121: 2, 122: 4, 123: 3, 124: 2, 128: 4, 129: 4, 130: 5, 132: 3, 136: 2, 145: 3, 147: 4, 151: 4, 152: 4, 154: 3, 156: 2, 161: 2, 165: 3, 168: 4, 169: 3, 172: 3, 180: 4, 184: 4, 187: 5, 188: 4, 191: 3, 194: 3, 202: 4, 203: 5, 206: 2, 207: 3, 217: 3, 218: 6, 222: 3, 224: 3, 227: 5, 229: 3, 234: 5, 235: 2, 241: 2, 242: 2, 243: 3, 244: 4, 245: 3, 248: 4, 250: 4, 258: 9, 262: 4, 263: 5, 264: 2, 267: 2, 270: 3, 272: 3, 273: 4, 287: 3, 289: 3, 291: 5, 299: 5, 300: 3, 304: 3, 309: 2, 314: 2, 315: 3, 320: 2, 323: 3, 327: 4, 328: 2, 329: 2, 330: 8, 334: 2, 335: 3, 341: 5, 342: 6, 347: 5, 348: 5, 350: 6, 351: 5, 352: 3, 353: 3, 354: 2, 358: 2, 365: 3, 366: 2, 371: 7, 372: 5, 376: 2, 384: 5, 385: 4, 386: 3, 387: 3, 392: 2, 393: 3, 396: 6, 397: 5, 398: 4, 402: 3} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 8 "To a large degree this follows the logic in the previous section. Analytics can be inherited from the two sub-layers. At the DetNet service edge packet and bit counters e.g. sent, received, dropped, and out of sequence are maintained." "Updates from today 's meeting plus a bit of cleanup - references - spelling - addressing some clarifications from I have checked all the diffs and they look good ." e24f0e46970c4e1014284609644c366e8a23138c e24f0e46970c4e1014284609644c366e8a23138c draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework 48d8a67306a5b7377d474058a02289ef5b0d47c7b426e70ca86c86fbaacd1c90 ['8d33f4dbbf7ab8899b8d7fe2858e2bd54d3076e1c21cd4da634f86caec05d13a', '48d8a67306a5b7377d474058a02289ef5b0d47c7b426e70ca86c86fbaacd1c90', '036168e918418eb807bc3efd361a8e66067192564da41e30e076d22be0f87935', '30d108135e5d5ca29f1851710d998b43e17cf658cb0bf7a20218abc345bf0b4e', 'a8ff14472a8fa48bacdc11d7089a9d1054c0a786f6152f510b5d4092c22e121f', '09338bff4c055a4fa57185ce910ed41cd32622051fe170615aabadb84e10faa4', '2755ae7cda161df0c24e1fa9f1c3308bc9ef81a599d859668490484290ca72f4', '4602f1e91bf42736704aa4b5deb973b3d0f537735bfefb88c02344a9e3c4f421', '595ccef56e4f3f92cf6c8157968607922c16102040d858595d47562c1a6e672a', 'b9bbfabb58957652f3a296054fff42678c08ff84156bc8d94d3610e121e772bf'] B "to a large degree this follows the logic in the previous section. analytics can be inherited from the two sub-layers. at the detnet service edge packet and bit counters e.g. sent, received, dropped, and out of sequence are maintained." {55: 1, 52: 1, 6: 1, 53: 1, 79: 2, 90: 2, 51: 3, 130: 2, 62: 3, 85: 3, 68: 2, 35: 3, 110: 3, 91: 5, 114: 3, 97: 3, 31: 2, 13: 3, 67: 2, 38: 4, 26: 3, 124: 2, 98: 2, 54: 2, 127: 3, 8: 2, 96: 3, 64: 2, 30: 4, 61: 5, 27: 3, 15: 3, 129: 3, 115: 3, 84: 2, 76: 5, 87: 3, 131: 5, 102: 2, 113: 5, 99: 2, 36: 3, 24: 2, 72: 4} {162: 1, 215: 1, 220: 1, 369: 1, 1: 7, 4: 2, 9: 4, 10: 3, 15: 3, 24: 2, 25: 3, 26: 3, 27: 3, 39: 3, 43: 3, 49: 6, 50: 5, 58: 5, 59: 2, 64: 3, 69: 3, 81: 4, 82: 4, 86: 3, 96: 4, 97: 3, 100: 7, 108: 3, 109: 4, 110: 4, 111: 2, 114: 3, 115: 4, 116: 3, 118: 4, 119: 3, 120: 3, 121: 2, 122: 4, 123: 3, 124: 2, 128: 4, 129: 4, 130: 5, 132: 3, 136: 2, 145: 3, 147: 4, 151: 4, 152: 4, 154: 3, 156: 2, 161: 2, 165: 3, 168: 4, 169: 3, 172: 3, 180: 4, 184: 4, 187: 5, 188: 4, 191: 3, 194: 3, 202: 4, 203: 5, 206: 2, 207: 3, 217: 3, 218: 6, 222: 3, 224: 3, 227: 5, 229: 3, 234: 5, 235: 2, 241: 2, 242: 2, 243: 3, 244: 4, 245: 3, 248: 4, 250: 4, 258: 9, 262: 4, 263: 5, 264: 2, 267: 2, 270: 3, 272: 3, 273: 4, 287: 3, 289: 3, 291: 5, 299: 5, 300: 3, 304: 3, 309: 2, 314: 2, 315: 3, 320: 2, 323: 3, 327: 4, 328: 2, 329: 2, 330: 8, 334: 2, 335: 3, 341: 5, 342: 6, 347: 5, 348: 5, 350: 6, 351: 5, 352: 3, 353: 3, 354: 2, 358: 2, 365: 3, 366: 2, 371: 7, 372: 5, 376: 2, 384: 5, 385: 4, 386: 3, 387: 3, 392: 2, 393: 3, 396: 6, 397: 5, 398: 4, 402: 3} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 8 "The provider of a DetNet service may allow other capabilities to monitor flows such as more detail loss statistics and time stamping of events. The details of these capabilities are currently out of scope for this document." "Updates from today 's meeting plus a bit of cleanup - references - spelling - addressing some clarifications from I have checked all the diffs and they look good ." e24f0e46970c4e1014284609644c366e8a23138c e24f0e46970c4e1014284609644c366e8a23138c draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework b9bbfabb58957652f3a296054fff42678c08ff84156bc8d94d3610e121e772bf ['8d33f4dbbf7ab8899b8d7fe2858e2bd54d3076e1c21cd4da634f86caec05d13a', '48d8a67306a5b7377d474058a02289ef5b0d47c7b426e70ca86c86fbaacd1c90', '036168e918418eb807bc3efd361a8e66067192564da41e30e076d22be0f87935', '30d108135e5d5ca29f1851710d998b43e17cf658cb0bf7a20218abc345bf0b4e', 'a8ff14472a8fa48bacdc11d7089a9d1054c0a786f6152f510b5d4092c22e121f', '09338bff4c055a4fa57185ce910ed41cd32622051fe170615aabadb84e10faa4', '2755ae7cda161df0c24e1fa9f1c3308bc9ef81a599d859668490484290ca72f4', '4602f1e91bf42736704aa4b5deb973b3d0f537735bfefb88c02344a9e3c4f421', '595ccef56e4f3f92cf6c8157968607922c16102040d858595d47562c1a6e672a', 'b9bbfabb58957652f3a296054fff42678c08ff84156bc8d94d3610e121e772bf'] B "the provider of a detnet service may allow other capabilities to monitor flows such as more detail loss statistics and time stamping of events. the details of these capabilities are currently out of scope for this document." {55: 1, 52: 1, 6: 1, 53: 1, 79: 2, 90: 2, 51: 3, 130: 2, 62: 3, 85: 3, 68: 2, 35: 3, 110: 3, 91: 5, 114: 3, 97: 3, 31: 2, 13: 3, 67: 2, 38: 4, 26: 3, 124: 2, 98: 2, 54: 2, 127: 3, 8: 2, 96: 3, 64: 2, 30: 4, 61: 5, 27: 3, 15: 3, 129: 3, 115: 3, 84: 2, 76: 5, 87: 3, 131: 5, 102: 2, 113: 5, 99: 2, 36: 3, 24: 2, 72: 4} {162: 1, 215: 1, 220: 1, 369: 1, 1: 7, 4: 2, 9: 4, 10: 3, 15: 3, 24: 2, 25: 3, 26: 3, 27: 3, 39: 3, 43: 3, 49: 6, 50: 5, 58: 5, 59: 2, 64: 3, 69: 3, 81: 4, 82: 4, 86: 3, 96: 4, 97: 3, 100: 7, 108: 3, 109: 4, 110: 4, 111: 2, 114: 3, 115: 4, 116: 3, 118: 4, 119: 3, 120: 3, 121: 2, 122: 4, 123: 3, 124: 2, 128: 4, 129: 4, 130: 5, 132: 3, 136: 2, 145: 3, 147: 4, 151: 4, 152: 4, 154: 3, 156: 2, 161: 2, 165: 3, 168: 4, 169: 3, 172: 3, 180: 4, 184: 4, 187: 5, 188: 4, 191: 3, 194: 3, 202: 4, 203: 5, 206: 2, 207: 3, 217: 3, 218: 6, 222: 3, 224: 3, 227: 5, 229: 3, 234: 5, 235: 2, 241: 2, 242: 2, 243: 3, 244: 4, 245: 3, 248: 4, 250: 4, 258: 9, 262: 4, 263: 5, 264: 2, 267: 2, 270: 3, 272: 3, 273: 4, 287: 3, 289: 3, 291: 5, 299: 5, 300: 3, 304: 3, 309: 2, 314: 2, 315: 3, 320: 2, 323: 3, 327: 4, 328: 2, 329: 2, 330: 8, 334: 2, 335: 3, 341: 5, 342: 6, 347: 5, 348: 5, 350: 6, 351: 5, 352: 3, 353: 3, 354: 2, 358: 2, 365: 3, 366: 2, 371: 7, 372: 5, 376: 2, 384: 5, 385: 4, 386: 3, 387: 3, 392: 2, 393: 3, 396: 6, 397: 5, 398: 4, 402: 3} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 8 "IP aggreggation has both data plane and controller plane aspects. For the dataplane flows may be aggregated for treatment based on shared charateristice such as 5-tuple. Alternatively, an IP encapsualtion may be used to tunnel an aggregate number of DetNet Flows between relay nodes." "Updates from today 's meeting plus a bit of cleanup - references - spelling - addressing some clarifications from I have checked all the diffs and they look good ." e24f0e46970c4e1014284609644c366e8a23138c e24f0e46970c4e1014284609644c366e8a23138c draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework 629c77ae73bd5bfa3198c993b2ee5bf42d1053919c44a7bfbd4a52ce7fa0cfbc ['51c123deb4e5f529482b4f48ca2ab139a551eea5280677f4a018cff4d9d13a79', '4a1f8d94a306d844766f5ea77194480640792e8c0875ae9667b948e8fefe47bc', '629c77ae73bd5bfa3198c993b2ee5bf42d1053919c44a7bfbd4a52ce7fa0cfbc', 'a6402401c31bbef50b804dc1d0bc35132bb6974c0b295c9ae1779371bc52776a'] A "ip aggreggation has both data plane and controller plane aspects. for the dataplane flows may be aggregated for treatment based on shared charateristice such as 5-tuple. alternatively, an ip encapsualtion may be used to tunnel an aggregate number of detnet flows between relay nodes." {55: 1, 6: 1, 79: 4, 90: 2, 51: 5, 130: 4, 62: 4, 85: 4, 68: 3, 35: 5, 110: 5, 91: 7, 114: 5, 97: 5, 31: 2, 13: 5, 67: 3, 38: 6, 26: 4, 124: 3, 98: 4, 54: 4, 127: 5, 8: 3, 96: 5, 64: 4, 30: 6, 61: 7, 27: 2, 15: 5, 52: 2, 129: 5, 115: 5, 84: 2, 76: 4, 87: 5, 131: 7, 102: 3, 113: 7, 99: 4, 36: 5, 24: 4, 53: 3, 72: 6} {145: 1, 161: 1, 1: 8, 4: 4, 9: 2, 10: 5, 15: 5, 24: 4, 25: 4, 26: 4, 27: 5, 39: 4, 43: 5, 49: 8, 50: 7, 58: 7, 59: 4, 64: 5, 69: 2, 81: 5, 82: 5, 86: 5, 96: 6, 97: 5, 100: 8, 108: 5, 109: 6, 110: 6, 111: 4, 114: 5, 115: 6, 116: 5, 118: 5, 119: 4, 120: 5, 121: 3, 122: 6, 123: 5, 124: 3, 128: 6, 129: 6, 130: 7, 136: 4, 147: 6, 151: 6, 152: 6, 154: 5, 156: 4, 162: 2, 165: 5, 168: 6, 169: 5, 172: 5, 180: 6, 184: 2, 187: 7, 188: 6, 191: 5, 194: 2, 202: 3, 203: 4, 206: 4, 207: 5, 215: 2, 217: 5, 218: 7, 220: 3, 221: 3, 222: 4, 224: 5, 227: 6, 229: 5, 234: 7, 235: 4, 241: 4, 242: 4, 243: 2, 244: 6, 245: 2, 248: 6, 250: 6, 258: 10, 262: 6, 263: 7, 264: 2, 267: 3, 270: 5, 272: 5, 273: 3, 287: 5, 289: 5, 291: 7, 299: 6, 300: 5, 304: 5, 309: 3, 314: 4, 315: 5, 320: 3, 323: 2, 327: 6, 328: 3, 329: 4, 330: 9, 334: 4, 335: 5, 341: 6, 342: 7, 347: 6, 348: 6, 350: 5, 351: 7, 352: 5, 353: 5, 354: 4, 358: 3, 365: 5, 366: 4, 369: 3, 371: 8, 372: 7, 376: 4, 384: 7, 385: 6, 386: 5, 387: 5, 392: 3, 393: 4, 396: 7, 397: 6, 398: 5, 402: 5} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 8 "MPLS aggragation similarly has data plane and controller plane aspects. In the case of MPLS flows are often tunneled in a forwarding sublayer and reservation is associated with that MPLS tunnel." "Updates from today 's meeting plus a bit of cleanup - references - spelling - addressing some clarifications from I have checked all the diffs and they look good ." e24f0e46970c4e1014284609644c366e8a23138c e24f0e46970c4e1014284609644c366e8a23138c draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework 4a1f8d94a306d844766f5ea77194480640792e8c0875ae9667b948e8fefe47bc ['51c123deb4e5f529482b4f48ca2ab139a551eea5280677f4a018cff4d9d13a79', '4a1f8d94a306d844766f5ea77194480640792e8c0875ae9667b948e8fefe47bc', '629c77ae73bd5bfa3198c993b2ee5bf42d1053919c44a7bfbd4a52ce7fa0cfbc', 'a6402401c31bbef50b804dc1d0bc35132bb6974c0b295c9ae1779371bc52776a'] A "mpls aggragation similarly has data plane and controller plane aspects. in the case of mpls flows are often tunneled in a forwarding sublayer and reservation is associated with that mpls tunnel." {55: 1, 6: 1, 79: 4, 90: 2, 51: 5, 130: 4, 62: 4, 85: 4, 68: 3, 35: 5, 110: 5, 91: 7, 114: 5, 97: 5, 31: 2, 13: 5, 67: 3, 38: 6, 26: 4, 124: 3, 98: 4, 54: 4, 127: 5, 8: 3, 96: 5, 64: 4, 30: 6, 61: 7, 27: 2, 15: 5, 52: 2, 129: 5, 115: 5, 84: 2, 76: 4, 87: 5, 131: 7, 102: 3, 113: 7, 99: 4, 36: 5, 24: 4, 53: 3, 72: 6} {145: 1, 161: 1, 1: 8, 4: 4, 9: 2, 10: 5, 15: 5, 24: 4, 25: 4, 26: 4, 27: 5, 39: 4, 43: 5, 49: 8, 50: 7, 58: 7, 59: 4, 64: 5, 69: 2, 81: 5, 82: 5, 86: 5, 96: 6, 97: 5, 100: 8, 108: 5, 109: 6, 110: 6, 111: 4, 114: 5, 115: 6, 116: 5, 118: 5, 119: 4, 120: 5, 121: 3, 122: 6, 123: 5, 124: 3, 128: 6, 129: 6, 130: 7, 136: 4, 147: 6, 151: 6, 152: 6, 154: 5, 156: 4, 162: 2, 165: 5, 168: 6, 169: 5, 172: 5, 180: 6, 184: 2, 187: 7, 188: 6, 191: 5, 194: 2, 202: 3, 203: 4, 206: 4, 207: 5, 215: 2, 217: 5, 218: 7, 220: 3, 221: 3, 222: 4, 224: 5, 227: 6, 229: 5, 234: 7, 235: 4, 241: 4, 242: 4, 243: 2, 244: 6, 245: 2, 248: 6, 250: 6, 258: 10, 262: 6, 263: 7, 264: 2, 267: 3, 270: 5, 272: 5, 273: 3, 287: 5, 289: 5, 291: 7, 299: 6, 300: 5, 304: 5, 309: 3, 314: 4, 315: 5, 320: 3, 323: 2, 327: 6, 328: 3, 329: 4, 330: 9, 334: 4, 335: 5, 341: 6, 342: 7, 347: 6, 348: 6, 350: 5, 351: 7, 352: 5, 353: 5, 354: 4, 358: 3, 365: 5, 366: 4, 369: 3, 371: 8, 372: 7, 376: 4, 384: 7, 385: 6, 386: 5, 387: 5, 392: 3, 393: 4, 396: 7, 397: 6, 398: 5, 402: 5} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 8 "IP aggregation has both data plane and controller plane aspects. For the data plane flows may be aggregated for treatment based on shared characteristics such as 5-tuple. Alternatively, an IP encapsulation may be used to tunnel an aggregate number of DetNet Flows between relay nodes." "Updates from today 's meeting plus a bit of cleanup - references - spelling - addressing some clarifications from I have checked all the diffs and they look good ." e24f0e46970c4e1014284609644c366e8a23138c e24f0e46970c4e1014284609644c366e8a23138c draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework 51c123deb4e5f529482b4f48ca2ab139a551eea5280677f4a018cff4d9d13a79 ['51c123deb4e5f529482b4f48ca2ab139a551eea5280677f4a018cff4d9d13a79', '4a1f8d94a306d844766f5ea77194480640792e8c0875ae9667b948e8fefe47bc', '629c77ae73bd5bfa3198c993b2ee5bf42d1053919c44a7bfbd4a52ce7fa0cfbc', 'a6402401c31bbef50b804dc1d0bc35132bb6974c0b295c9ae1779371bc52776a'] B "ip aggregation has both data plane and controller plane aspects. for the data plane flows may be aggregated for treatment based on shared characteristics such as 5-tuple. alternatively, an ip encapsulation may be used to tunnel an aggregate number of detnet flows between relay nodes." {55: 1, 6: 1, 79: 4, 90: 2, 51: 5, 130: 4, 62: 4, 85: 4, 68: 3, 35: 5, 110: 5, 91: 7, 114: 5, 97: 5, 31: 2, 13: 5, 67: 3, 38: 6, 26: 4, 124: 3, 98: 4, 54: 4, 127: 5, 8: 3, 96: 5, 64: 4, 30: 6, 61: 7, 27: 2, 15: 5, 52: 2, 129: 5, 115: 5, 84: 2, 76: 4, 87: 5, 131: 7, 102: 3, 113: 7, 99: 4, 36: 5, 24: 4, 53: 3, 72: 6} {145: 1, 161: 1, 1: 8, 4: 4, 9: 2, 10: 5, 15: 5, 24: 4, 25: 4, 26: 4, 27: 5, 39: 4, 43: 5, 49: 8, 50: 7, 58: 7, 59: 4, 64: 5, 69: 2, 81: 5, 82: 5, 86: 5, 96: 6, 97: 5, 100: 8, 108: 5, 109: 6, 110: 6, 111: 4, 114: 5, 115: 6, 116: 5, 118: 5, 119: 4, 120: 5, 121: 3, 122: 6, 123: 5, 124: 3, 128: 6, 129: 6, 130: 7, 136: 4, 147: 6, 151: 6, 152: 6, 154: 5, 156: 4, 162: 2, 165: 5, 168: 6, 169: 5, 172: 5, 180: 6, 184: 2, 187: 7, 188: 6, 191: 5, 194: 2, 202: 3, 203: 4, 206: 4, 207: 5, 215: 2, 217: 5, 218: 7, 220: 3, 221: 3, 222: 4, 224: 5, 227: 6, 229: 5, 234: 7, 235: 4, 241: 4, 242: 4, 243: 2, 244: 6, 245: 2, 248: 6, 250: 6, 258: 10, 262: 6, 263: 7, 264: 2, 267: 3, 270: 5, 272: 5, 273: 3, 287: 5, 289: 5, 291: 7, 299: 6, 300: 5, 304: 5, 309: 3, 314: 4, 315: 5, 320: 3, 323: 2, 327: 6, 328: 3, 329: 4, 330: 9, 334: 4, 335: 5, 341: 6, 342: 7, 347: 6, 348: 6, 350: 5, 351: 7, 352: 5, 353: 5, 354: 4, 358: 3, 365: 5, 366: 4, 369: 3, 371: 8, 372: 7, 376: 4, 384: 7, 385: 6, 386: 5, 387: 5, 392: 3, 393: 4, 396: 7, 397: 6, 398: 5, 402: 5} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 8 "MPLS aggregation similarly has data plane and controller plane aspects. In the case of MPLS flows are often tunneled in a forwarding sub-layer and reservation is associated with that MPLS tunnel." "Updates from today 's meeting plus a bit of cleanup - references - spelling - addressing some clarifications from I have checked all the diffs and they look good ." e24f0e46970c4e1014284609644c366e8a23138c e24f0e46970c4e1014284609644c366e8a23138c draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework a6402401c31bbef50b804dc1d0bc35132bb6974c0b295c9ae1779371bc52776a ['51c123deb4e5f529482b4f48ca2ab139a551eea5280677f4a018cff4d9d13a79', '4a1f8d94a306d844766f5ea77194480640792e8c0875ae9667b948e8fefe47bc', '629c77ae73bd5bfa3198c993b2ee5bf42d1053919c44a7bfbd4a52ce7fa0cfbc', 'a6402401c31bbef50b804dc1d0bc35132bb6974c0b295c9ae1779371bc52776a'] B "mpls aggregation similarly has data plane and controller plane aspects. in the case of mpls flows are often tunneled in a forwarding sub-layer and reservation is associated with that mpls tunnel." {55: 1, 6: 1, 79: 4, 90: 2, 51: 5, 130: 4, 62: 4, 85: 4, 68: 3, 35: 5, 110: 5, 91: 7, 114: 5, 97: 5, 31: 2, 13: 5, 67: 3, 38: 6, 26: 4, 124: 3, 98: 4, 54: 4, 127: 5, 8: 3, 96: 5, 64: 4, 30: 6, 61: 7, 27: 2, 15: 5, 52: 2, 129: 5, 115: 5, 84: 2, 76: 4, 87: 5, 131: 7, 102: 3, 113: 7, 99: 4, 36: 5, 24: 4, 53: 3, 72: 6} {145: 1, 161: 1, 1: 8, 4: 4, 9: 2, 10: 5, 15: 5, 24: 4, 25: 4, 26: 4, 27: 5, 39: 4, 43: 5, 49: 8, 50: 7, 58: 7, 59: 4, 64: 5, 69: 2, 81: 5, 82: 5, 86: 5, 96: 6, 97: 5, 100: 8, 108: 5, 109: 6, 110: 6, 111: 4, 114: 5, 115: 6, 116: 5, 118: 5, 119: 4, 120: 5, 121: 3, 122: 6, 123: 5, 124: 3, 128: 6, 129: 6, 130: 7, 136: 4, 147: 6, 151: 6, 152: 6, 154: 5, 156: 4, 162: 2, 165: 5, 168: 6, 169: 5, 172: 5, 180: 6, 184: 2, 187: 7, 188: 6, 191: 5, 194: 2, 202: 3, 203: 4, 206: 4, 207: 5, 215: 2, 217: 5, 218: 7, 220: 3, 221: 3, 222: 4, 224: 5, 227: 6, 229: 5, 234: 7, 235: 4, 241: 4, 242: 4, 243: 2, 244: 6, 245: 2, 248: 6, 250: 6, 258: 10, 262: 6, 263: 7, 264: 2, 267: 3, 270: 5, 272: 5, 273: 3, 287: 5, 289: 5, 291: 7, 299: 6, 300: 5, 304: 5, 309: 3, 314: 4, 315: 5, 320: 3, 323: 2, 327: 6, 328: 3, 329: 4, 330: 9, 334: 4, 335: 5, 341: 6, 342: 7, 347: 6, 348: 6, 350: 5, 351: 7, 352: 5, 353: 5, 354: 4, 358: 3, 365: 5, 366: 4, 369: 3, 371: 8, 372: 7, 376: 4, 384: 7, 385: 6, 386: 5, 387: 5, 392: 3, 393: 4, 396: 7, 397: 6, 398: 5, 402: 5} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 8 "Any of the DetNet native service types may be transported by another DetNet service. MPLS nodes may interconnected by different sub- network technologies, which may include point-to-point links. Each of these sub-network technologies need to provide appropriate service to DetNet flows. In some cases, e.g., on dedicated point-to-point links or TDM technologies, all that is required is for a DetNet node to appropriately queue its output traffic. In other cases, DetNet nodes will need to map DetNet flows to the flow semantics (i.e., identifiers) and mechanisms used by an underlying sub-network technology. fig_dn_mpls_sn_ex shows several examples of header formats that can be used to carry DetNet MPLS flows over different sub-network technologies. L2 represent a generic layer-2 encapsulation that might be used on a point-to-point link. TSN represents the encapsulation used on an IEEE 802.1 TSN network, as described in I-D.mpls-over-tsn. UDP/IP represents the encapsulation used on a DetNet IP PSN, as described in I-D.mpls-over-udp-ip." "Updates from today 's meeting plus a bit of cleanup - references - spelling - addressing some clarifications from I have checked all the diffs and they look good ." e24f0e46970c4e1014284609644c366e8a23138c e24f0e46970c4e1014284609644c366e8a23138c draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework 4a231ab7500e5c2b585abd87b038cb6ad2cb7a4854e98101c4b0c516b6eab72e ['4a231ab7500e5c2b585abd87b038cb6ad2cb7a4854e98101c4b0c516b6eab72e', 'da7ba88ecbaea52eb10a9534c46cb81ccd96f260c06cbd5cffa80a030b3748ae'] A "any of the detnet native service types may be transported by another detnet service. mpls nodes may interconnected by different sub- network technologies, which may include point-to-point links. each of these sub-network technologies need to provide appropriate service to detnet flows. in some cases, e.g., on dedicated point-to-point links or tdm technologies, all that is required is for a detnet node to appropriately queue its output traffic. in other cases, detnet nodes will need to map detnet flows to the flow semantics (i.e., identifiers) and mechanisms used by an underlying sub-network technology. fig_dn_mpls_sn_ex shows several examples of header formats that can be used to carry detnet mpls flows over different sub-network technologies. l2 represent a generic layer-2 encapsulation that might be used on a point-to-point link. tsn represents the encapsulation used on an ieee 802.1 tsn network, as described in i-d.mpls-over-tsn. udp/ip represents the encapsulation used on a detnet ip psn, as described in i-d.mpls-over-udp-ip." {6: 1, 79: 3, 90: 4, 51: 4, 130: 3, 62: 6, 85: 6, 68: 5, 35: 4, 110: 4, 91: 6, 114: 4, 97: 4, 31: 2, 13: 4, 67: 4, 38: 5, 26: 4, 124: 4, 98: 3, 54: 3, 127: 4, 96: 4, 64: 3, 30: 5, 61: 6, 8: 2, 55: 4, 27: 5, 15: 4, 52: 3, 129: 4, 115: 4, 84: 4, 76: 7, 87: 4, 131: 6, 102: 4, 113: 6, 99: 3, 36: 4, 24: 3, 53: 2, 72: 5} {376: 1, 1: 10, 4: 3, 9: 6, 10: 4, 15: 4, 24: 3, 25: 6, 26: 6, 27: 4, 39: 6, 43: 4, 49: 7, 50: 6, 58: 6, 59: 3, 64: 4, 69: 5, 81: 7, 82: 5, 86: 4, 96: 5, 97: 4, 100: 8, 108: 4, 109: 5, 110: 5, 111: 3, 114: 4, 115: 5, 116: 4, 118: 7, 119: 6, 121: 5, 122: 5, 123: 4, 124: 5, 128: 5, 129: 5, 130: 6, 132: 5, 136: 3, 145: 5, 147: 5, 151: 5, 152: 5, 154: 2, 156: 3, 161: 4, 162: 4, 165: 4, 168: 5, 169: 4, 172: 4, 180: 5, 184: 6, 187: 6, 188: 5, 191: 4, 194: 5, 202: 6, 203: 7, 206: 3, 207: 4, 215: 3, 217: 4, 218: 9, 220: 3, 221: 3, 222: 6, 224: 2, 227: 6, 229: 4, 234: 6, 235: 3, 241: 3, 242: 3, 243: 5, 244: 5, 245: 5, 248: 5, 250: 5, 258: 12, 262: 5, 263: 6, 264: 4, 267: 5, 270: 4, 272: 4, 273: 6, 287: 4, 289: 4, 291: 6, 299: 6, 300: 4, 304: 4, 309: 4, 314: 3, 315: 4, 320: 5, 323: 5, 327: 5, 328: 4, 329: 3, 330: 11, 334: 3, 335: 4, 341: 6, 342: 7, 347: 6, 348: 6, 350: 8, 351: 6, 352: 4, 353: 4, 354: 3, 358: 5, 365: 4, 366: 3, 369: 2, 371: 8, 372: 6, 384: 6, 385: 5, 386: 4, 387: 4, 392: 4, 393: 5, 396: 7, 397: 8, 398: 7, 402: 4} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 8 "Any of the DetNet service types may be transported by another DetNet service. MPLS nodes may interconnected by different sub-network technologies, which may include point-to-point links. Each of these sub-network technologies need to provide appropriate service to DetNet flows. In some cases, e.g., on dedicated point-to-point links or TDM technologies, all that is required is for a DetNet node to appropriately queue its output traffic. In other cases, DetNet nodes will need to map DetNet flows to the flow semantics (i.e., identifiers) and mechanisms used by an underlying sub-network technology. fig_dn_mpls_sn_ex shows several examples of header formats that can be used to carry DetNet MPLS flows over different sub-network technologies. L2 represent a generic layer-2 encapsulation that might be used on a point-to-point link. TSN represents the encapsulation used on an IEEE 802.1 TSN network, as described in I-D.mpls-over-tsn. UDP/IP represents the encapsulation used on a DetNet IP PSN, as described in I-D.mpls-over-udp-ip." "Updates from today 's meeting plus a bit of cleanup - references - spelling - addressing some clarifications from I have checked all the diffs and they look good ." e24f0e46970c4e1014284609644c366e8a23138c e24f0e46970c4e1014284609644c366e8a23138c draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework da7ba88ecbaea52eb10a9534c46cb81ccd96f260c06cbd5cffa80a030b3748ae ['4a231ab7500e5c2b585abd87b038cb6ad2cb7a4854e98101c4b0c516b6eab72e', 'da7ba88ecbaea52eb10a9534c46cb81ccd96f260c06cbd5cffa80a030b3748ae'] B "any of the detnet service types may be transported by another detnet service. mpls nodes may interconnected by different sub-network technologies, which may include point-to-point links. each of these sub-network technologies need to provide appropriate service to detnet flows. in some cases, e.g., on dedicated point-to-point links or tdm technologies, all that is required is for a detnet node to appropriately queue its output traffic. in other cases, detnet nodes will need to map detnet flows to the flow semantics (i.e., identifiers) and mechanisms used by an underlying sub-network technology. fig_dn_mpls_sn_ex shows several examples of header formats that can be used to carry detnet mpls flows over different sub-network technologies. l2 represent a generic layer-2 encapsulation that might be used on a point-to-point link. tsn represents the encapsulation used on an ieee 802.1 tsn network, as described in i-d.mpls-over-tsn. udp/ip represents the encapsulation used on a detnet ip psn, as described in i-d.mpls-over-udp-ip." {6: 1, 79: 3, 90: 4, 51: 4, 130: 3, 62: 6, 85: 6, 68: 5, 35: 4, 110: 4, 91: 6, 114: 4, 97: 4, 31: 2, 13: 4, 67: 4, 38: 5, 26: 4, 124: 4, 98: 3, 54: 3, 127: 4, 96: 4, 64: 3, 30: 5, 61: 6, 8: 2, 55: 4, 27: 5, 15: 4, 52: 3, 129: 4, 115: 4, 84: 4, 76: 7, 87: 4, 131: 6, 102: 4, 113: 6, 99: 3, 36: 4, 24: 3, 53: 2, 72: 5} {376: 1, 1: 10, 4: 3, 9: 6, 10: 4, 15: 4, 24: 3, 25: 6, 26: 6, 27: 4, 39: 6, 43: 4, 49: 7, 50: 6, 58: 6, 59: 3, 64: 4, 69: 5, 81: 7, 82: 5, 86: 4, 96: 5, 97: 4, 100: 8, 108: 4, 109: 5, 110: 5, 111: 3, 114: 4, 115: 5, 116: 4, 118: 7, 119: 6, 121: 5, 122: 5, 123: 4, 124: 5, 128: 5, 129: 5, 130: 6, 132: 5, 136: 3, 145: 5, 147: 5, 151: 5, 152: 5, 154: 2, 156: 3, 161: 4, 162: 4, 165: 4, 168: 5, 169: 4, 172: 4, 180: 5, 184: 6, 187: 6, 188: 5, 191: 4, 194: 5, 202: 6, 203: 7, 206: 3, 207: 4, 215: 3, 217: 4, 218: 9, 220: 3, 221: 3, 222: 6, 224: 2, 227: 6, 229: 4, 234: 6, 235: 3, 241: 3, 242: 3, 243: 5, 244: 5, 245: 5, 248: 5, 250: 5, 258: 12, 262: 5, 263: 6, 264: 4, 267: 5, 270: 4, 272: 4, 273: 6, 287: 4, 289: 4, 291: 6, 299: 6, 300: 4, 304: 4, 309: 4, 314: 3, 315: 4, 320: 5, 323: 5, 327: 5, 328: 4, 329: 3, 330: 11, 334: 3, 335: 4, 341: 6, 342: 7, 347: 6, 348: 6, 350: 8, 351: 6, 352: 4, 353: 4, 354: 3, 358: 5, 365: 4, 366: 3, 369: 2, 371: 8, 372: 6, 384: 6, 385: 5, 386: 4, 387: 4, 392: 4, 393: 5, 396: 7, 397: 8, 398: 7, 402: 4} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 8 "In the abstract, the results of either distributed signaling or centralized provisioning are equivalent from a DetNet data plane perspective - flows are instantiated, explicit routes are determined, resources are reserved, and packets are forwarded through the domain using the DetNet native data plane." "Updates from today 's meeting plus a bit of cleanup - references - spelling - addressing some clarifications from I have checked all the diffs and they look good ." e24f0e46970c4e1014284609644c366e8a23138c e24f0e46970c4e1014284609644c366e8a23138c draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework 06fe2000420d480393da592c2653f7f98d7c0f36878b8b325f2d68dea40f01d7 ['60795e12e8b17ec60c2ab74efa70ababb61cb0b8445f91cf02ef8382c7344238', '06fe2000420d480393da592c2653f7f98d7c0f36878b8b325f2d68dea40f01d7'] A "in the abstract, the results of either distributed signaling or centralized provisioning are equivalent from a detnet data plane perspective - flows are instantiated, explicit routes are determined, resources are reserved, and packets are forwarded through the domain using the detnet native data plane." {6: 1, 79: 3, 90: 4, 51: 4, 130: 3, 62: 6, 85: 6, 68: 5, 35: 4, 110: 4, 91: 6, 114: 4, 97: 4, 31: 2, 13: 4, 67: 4, 38: 5, 26: 4, 124: 4, 98: 3, 54: 3, 127: 4, 8: 2, 96: 4, 64: 3, 30: 5, 61: 6, 55: 4, 27: 5, 15: 4, 52: 3, 129: 4, 115: 4, 84: 4, 76: 7, 87: 4, 131: 6, 102: 4, 113: 6, 99: 3, 36: 4, 24: 3, 53: 2, 72: 5} {376: 1, 1: 10, 4: 3, 9: 6, 10: 4, 15: 4, 24: 3, 25: 6, 26: 6, 27: 4, 39: 6, 43: 4, 49: 7, 50: 6, 58: 6, 59: 3, 64: 4, 69: 5, 81: 7, 82: 5, 86: 4, 96: 5, 97: 4, 100: 8, 108: 4, 109: 5, 110: 5, 111: 3, 114: 4, 115: 5, 116: 4, 118: 7, 119: 6, 120: 2, 121: 5, 122: 5, 123: 4, 124: 5, 128: 5, 129: 5, 130: 6, 132: 5, 136: 3, 145: 5, 147: 5, 151: 5, 152: 5, 156: 3, 161: 4, 162: 4, 165: 4, 168: 5, 169: 4, 172: 4, 180: 5, 184: 6, 187: 6, 188: 5, 191: 4, 194: 5, 202: 6, 203: 7, 206: 3, 207: 4, 215: 3, 217: 4, 218: 9, 220: 3, 221: 3, 222: 6, 224: 2, 227: 6, 229: 4, 234: 6, 235: 3, 241: 3, 242: 3, 243: 5, 244: 5, 245: 5, 248: 5, 250: 5, 258: 12, 262: 5, 263: 6, 264: 4, 267: 5, 270: 4, 272: 4, 273: 6, 287: 4, 289: 4, 291: 6, 299: 6, 300: 4, 304: 4, 309: 4, 314: 3, 315: 4, 320: 5, 323: 5, 327: 5, 328: 4, 329: 3, 330: 11, 334: 3, 335: 4, 341: 6, 342: 7, 347: 6, 348: 6, 350: 8, 351: 6, 352: 4, 353: 4, 354: 3, 358: 5, 365: 4, 366: 3, 369: 2, 371: 8, 372: 6, 384: 6, 385: 5, 386: 4, 387: 4, 392: 4, 393: 5, 396: 7, 397: 8, 398: 7, 402: 4} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 8 "In the abstract, the results of either distributed signaling or centralized provisioning are equivalent from a DetNet data plane perspective - flows are instantiated, explicit routes are determined, resources are reserved, and packets are forwarded through the domain using the DetNet data plane." "Updates from today 's meeting plus a bit of cleanup - references - spelling - addressing some clarifications from I have checked all the diffs and they look good ." e24f0e46970c4e1014284609644c366e8a23138c e24f0e46970c4e1014284609644c366e8a23138c draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework 60795e12e8b17ec60c2ab74efa70ababb61cb0b8445f91cf02ef8382c7344238 ['60795e12e8b17ec60c2ab74efa70ababb61cb0b8445f91cf02ef8382c7344238', '06fe2000420d480393da592c2653f7f98d7c0f36878b8b325f2d68dea40f01d7'] B "in the abstract, the results of either distributed signaling or centralized provisioning are equivalent from a detnet data plane perspective - flows are instantiated, explicit routes are determined, resources are reserved, and packets are forwarded through the domain using the detnet data plane." {6: 1, 79: 3, 90: 4, 51: 4, 130: 3, 62: 6, 85: 6, 68: 5, 35: 4, 110: 4, 91: 6, 114: 4, 97: 4, 31: 2, 13: 4, 67: 4, 38: 5, 26: 4, 124: 4, 98: 3, 54: 3, 127: 4, 8: 2, 96: 4, 64: 3, 30: 5, 61: 6, 55: 4, 27: 5, 15: 4, 52: 3, 129: 4, 115: 4, 84: 4, 76: 7, 87: 4, 131: 6, 102: 4, 113: 6, 99: 3, 36: 4, 24: 3, 53: 2, 72: 5} {376: 1, 1: 10, 4: 3, 9: 6, 10: 4, 15: 4, 24: 3, 25: 6, 26: 6, 27: 4, 39: 6, 43: 4, 49: 7, 50: 6, 58: 6, 59: 3, 64: 4, 69: 5, 81: 7, 82: 5, 86: 4, 96: 5, 97: 4, 100: 8, 108: 4, 109: 5, 110: 5, 111: 3, 114: 4, 115: 5, 116: 4, 118: 7, 119: 6, 120: 2, 121: 5, 122: 5, 123: 4, 124: 5, 128: 5, 129: 5, 130: 6, 132: 5, 136: 3, 145: 5, 147: 5, 151: 5, 152: 5, 156: 3, 161: 4, 162: 4, 165: 4, 168: 5, 169: 4, 172: 4, 180: 5, 184: 6, 187: 6, 188: 5, 191: 4, 194: 5, 202: 6, 203: 7, 206: 3, 207: 4, 215: 3, 217: 4, 218: 9, 220: 3, 221: 3, 222: 6, 224: 2, 227: 6, 229: 4, 234: 6, 235: 3, 241: 3, 242: 3, 243: 5, 244: 5, 245: 5, 248: 5, 250: 5, 258: 12, 262: 5, 263: 6, 264: 4, 267: 5, 270: 4, 272: 4, 273: 6, 287: 4, 289: 4, 291: 6, 299: 6, 300: 4, 304: 4, 309: 4, 314: 3, 315: 4, 320: 5, 323: 5, 327: 5, 328: 4, 329: 3, 330: 11, 334: 3, 335: 4, 341: 6, 342: 7, 347: 6, 348: 6, 350: 8, 351: 6, 352: 4, 353: 4, 354: 3, 358: 5, 365: 4, 366: 3, 369: 2, 371: 8, 372: 6, 384: 6, 385: 5, 386: 4, 387: 4, 392: 4, 393: 5, 396: 7, 397: 8, 398: 7, 402: 4} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 8 "Flow aggregation includes aggregation accomplished through the use of hierarchical LSPs in MPLS and tunnels, in the case of IP, MPLS and TSN, both of which aggregate multiple DetNet flows into a single new DetNet flow. It can also be grouping of IP flows that share 5-tuple of 6-tuple attributes or flow identifiers at the DetNet layer." "Updates from today 's meeting plus a bit of cleanup - references - spelling - addressing some clarifications from I have checked all the diffs and they look good ." e24f0e46970c4e1014284609644c366e8a23138c e24f0e46970c4e1014284609644c366e8a23138c draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework 3aa4a2a90ebad10aea6bac0e1dcaae561f6f9322c3aa66bc7cf6182ca5325f98 ['3aa4a2a90ebad10aea6bac0e1dcaae561f6f9322c3aa66bc7cf6182ca5325f98', 'e1d570de810b6f9b530e5198daada3cd78c2c9bcfc29d279b25276abcd676983'] A "flow aggregation includes aggregation accomplished through the use of hierarchical lsps in mpls and tunnels, in the case of ip, mpls and tsn, both of which aggregate multiple detnet flows into a single new detnet flow. it can also be grouping of ip flows that share 5-tuple of 6-tuple attributes or flow identifiers at the detnet layer." {6: 1, 31: 1, 8: 2, 90: 4, 84: 3, 55: 3} {360: 1, 107: 1, 226: 2, 101: 4, 409: 3, 138: 2, 338: 3, 211: 3} {226, 101, 360, 409, 107, 138, 338, 211, 89} 8 "Flow aggregation includes aggregation accomplished through the use of hierarchical LSPs in MPLS and tunnels, in the case of IP, MPLS and TSN, both of which aggregate multiple DetNet flows into a single new DetNet flow. It can also be grouping of IP flows that share 5-tuple of 6-tuple attributes or flow identifiers at the DetNet sub-layer." "Updates from today 's meeting plus a bit of cleanup - references - spelling - addressing some clarifications from I have checked all the diffs and they look good ." e24f0e46970c4e1014284609644c366e8a23138c e24f0e46970c4e1014284609644c366e8a23138c draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework e1d570de810b6f9b530e5198daada3cd78c2c9bcfc29d279b25276abcd676983 ['3aa4a2a90ebad10aea6bac0e1dcaae561f6f9322c3aa66bc7cf6182ca5325f98', 'e1d570de810b6f9b530e5198daada3cd78c2c9bcfc29d279b25276abcd676983'] B "flow aggregation includes aggregation accomplished through the use of hierarchical lsps in mpls and tunnels, in the case of ip, mpls and tsn, both of which aggregate multiple detnet flows into a single new detnet flow. it can also be grouping of ip flows that share 5-tuple of 6-tuple attributes or flow identifiers at the detnet sub-layer." {6: 1, 31: 1, 8: 2, 90: 4, 84: 3, 55: 3} {360: 1, 107: 1, 226: 2, 101: 4, 409: 3, 138: 2, 338: 3, 211: 3} {226, 101, 360, 409, 107, 138, 338, 211, 89} 8 "When DetNet services are provisioned or requested one or more paths meeting the requirements are selected and the resources verified and if successful recorded in the databases." "Updates from today 's meeting plus a bit of cleanup - references - spelling - addressing some clarifications from I have checked all the diffs and they look good ." e24f0e46970c4e1014284609644c366e8a23138c e24f0e46970c4e1014284609644c366e8a23138c draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework 5577ff2e6cd333fe14d9a81dbd205ba9fefb3a2cf6e4f292211c12566f66f5f7 ['95195c806d913e2e5ad01052ab1f35351e629d84a855d01fa2389c8df8d3bded', 'd496f59b691217221c3b8b412e850321136fe8a9e4371d9188fb7f5f23814b87', '261f5b4a758c447bdb1af815a4821f55f8d5e0402b55333766adbd5a0a5e2d21', 'd564daf1a9dc26ca896eedca786a6bfca02e9b99ddc05e4dcb39eb9cecde2400', '5577ff2e6cd333fe14d9a81dbd205ba9fefb3a2cf6e4f292211c12566f66f5f7', '67af30b1ae114f932f547be0c6e4b7e6cc3a155b9c279a4a0168de58401688c5'] A "when detnet services are provisioned or requested one or more paths meeting the requirements are selected and the resources verified and if successful recorded in the databases." {6: 1, 84: 1, 55: 1, 90: 4, 31: 3, 8: 2} {360: 1, 409: 1, 338: 1, 101: 4, 107: 3, 138: 2, 211: 3, 89: 2} {226, 101, 360, 409, 107, 138, 338, 211, 89} 8 "The assignment of resources depends on the technology and it includes assignment of specific links and coordination of the queuing and other traffic management capabilities." "Updates from today 's meeting plus a bit of cleanup - references - spelling - addressing some clarifications from I have checked all the diffs and they look good ." e24f0e46970c4e1014284609644c366e8a23138c e24f0e46970c4e1014284609644c366e8a23138c draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework 67af30b1ae114f932f547be0c6e4b7e6cc3a155b9c279a4a0168de58401688c5 ['95195c806d913e2e5ad01052ab1f35351e629d84a855d01fa2389c8df8d3bded', 'd496f59b691217221c3b8b412e850321136fe8a9e4371d9188fb7f5f23814b87', '261f5b4a758c447bdb1af815a4821f55f8d5e0402b55333766adbd5a0a5e2d21', 'd564daf1a9dc26ca896eedca786a6bfca02e9b99ddc05e4dcb39eb9cecde2400', '5577ff2e6cd333fe14d9a81dbd205ba9fefb3a2cf6e4f292211c12566f66f5f7', '67af30b1ae114f932f547be0c6e4b7e6cc3a155b9c279a4a0168de58401688c5'] A "the assignment of resources depends on the technology and it includes assignment of specific links and coordination of the queuing and other traffic management capabilities." {6: 1, 84: 1, 55: 1, 90: 4, 31: 3, 8: 2} {360: 1, 409: 1, 338: 1, 101: 4, 107: 3, 138: 2, 211: 3, 89: 2} {226, 101, 360, 409, 107, 138, 338, 211, 89} 8 "Depending on the specific technology the assigned resources are updated in the databases preventing oversubscription." "Updates from today 's meeting plus a bit of cleanup - references - spelling - addressing some clarifications from I have checked all the diffs and they look good ." e24f0e46970c4e1014284609644c366e8a23138c e24f0e46970c4e1014284609644c366e8a23138c draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework 261f5b4a758c447bdb1af815a4821f55f8d5e0402b55333766adbd5a0a5e2d21 ['95195c806d913e2e5ad01052ab1f35351e629d84a855d01fa2389c8df8d3bded', 'd496f59b691217221c3b8b412e850321136fe8a9e4371d9188fb7f5f23814b87', '261f5b4a758c447bdb1af815a4821f55f8d5e0402b55333766adbd5a0a5e2d21', 'd564daf1a9dc26ca896eedca786a6bfca02e9b99ddc05e4dcb39eb9cecde2400', '5577ff2e6cd333fe14d9a81dbd205ba9fefb3a2cf6e4f292211c12566f66f5f7', '67af30b1ae114f932f547be0c6e4b7e6cc3a155b9c279a4a0168de58401688c5'] A "depending on the specific technology the assigned resources are updated in the databases preventing oversubscription." {6: 1, 84: 1, 55: 1, 90: 4, 31: 3, 8: 2} {360: 1, 409: 1, 338: 1, 101: 4, 107: 3, 138: 2, 211: 3, 89: 2} {226, 101, 360, 409, 107, 138, 338, 211, 89} 8 "When DetNet services are provisioned or requested one or more paths meeting the requirements are selected and the resources verified and recorded." "Updates from today 's meeting plus a bit of cleanup - references - spelling - addressing some clarifications from I have checked all the diffs and they look good ." e24f0e46970c4e1014284609644c366e8a23138c e24f0e46970c4e1014284609644c366e8a23138c draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework d496f59b691217221c3b8b412e850321136fe8a9e4371d9188fb7f5f23814b87 ['95195c806d913e2e5ad01052ab1f35351e629d84a855d01fa2389c8df8d3bded', 'd496f59b691217221c3b8b412e850321136fe8a9e4371d9188fb7f5f23814b87', '261f5b4a758c447bdb1af815a4821f55f8d5e0402b55333766adbd5a0a5e2d21', 'd564daf1a9dc26ca896eedca786a6bfca02e9b99ddc05e4dcb39eb9cecde2400', '5577ff2e6cd333fe14d9a81dbd205ba9fefb3a2cf6e4f292211c12566f66f5f7', '67af30b1ae114f932f547be0c6e4b7e6cc3a155b9c279a4a0168de58401688c5'] B "when detnet services are provisioned or requested one or more paths meeting the requirements are selected and the resources verified and recorded." {6: 1, 84: 1, 55: 1, 90: 4, 31: 3, 8: 2} {360: 1, 409: 1, 338: 1, 101: 4, 107: 3, 138: 2, 211: 3, 89: 2} {226, 101, 360, 409, 107, 138, 338, 211, 89} 8 "The assignment of resources along the path depends on the technology and it includes assignment of specific links and coordination of the queuing and other traffic management capabilities." "Updates from today 's meeting plus a bit of cleanup - references - spelling - addressing some clarifications from I have checked all the diffs and they look good ." e24f0e46970c4e1014284609644c366e8a23138c e24f0e46970c4e1014284609644c366e8a23138c draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework 95195c806d913e2e5ad01052ab1f35351e629d84a855d01fa2389c8df8d3bded ['95195c806d913e2e5ad01052ab1f35351e629d84a855d01fa2389c8df8d3bded', 'd496f59b691217221c3b8b412e850321136fe8a9e4371d9188fb7f5f23814b87', '261f5b4a758c447bdb1af815a4821f55f8d5e0402b55333766adbd5a0a5e2d21', 'd564daf1a9dc26ca896eedca786a6bfca02e9b99ddc05e4dcb39eb9cecde2400', '5577ff2e6cd333fe14d9a81dbd205ba9fefb3a2cf6e4f292211c12566f66f5f7', '67af30b1ae114f932f547be0c6e4b7e6cc3a155b9c279a4a0168de58401688c5'] B "the assignment of resources along the path depends on the technology and it includes assignment of specific links and coordination of the queuing and other traffic management capabilities." {6: 1, 84: 1, 55: 1, 90: 4, 31: 3, 8: 2} {360: 1, 409: 1, 338: 1, 101: 4, 107: 3, 138: 2, 211: 3, 89: 2} {226, 101, 360, 409, 107, 138, 338, 211, 89} 8 "Depending on the specific technology the assigned resources are updated and distributed in the databases preventing over subscription." "Updates from today 's meeting plus a bit of cleanup - references - spelling - addressing some clarifications from I have checked all the diffs and they look good ." e24f0e46970c4e1014284609644c366e8a23138c e24f0e46970c4e1014284609644c366e8a23138c draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework d564daf1a9dc26ca896eedca786a6bfca02e9b99ddc05e4dcb39eb9cecde2400 ['95195c806d913e2e5ad01052ab1f35351e629d84a855d01fa2389c8df8d3bded', 'd496f59b691217221c3b8b412e850321136fe8a9e4371d9188fb7f5f23814b87', '261f5b4a758c447bdb1af815a4821f55f8d5e0402b55333766adbd5a0a5e2d21', 'd564daf1a9dc26ca896eedca786a6bfca02e9b99ddc05e4dcb39eb9cecde2400', '5577ff2e6cd333fe14d9a81dbd205ba9fefb3a2cf6e4f292211c12566f66f5f7', '67af30b1ae114f932f547be0c6e4b7e6cc3a155b9c279a4a0168de58401688c5'] B "depending on the specific technology the assigned resources are updated and distributed in the databases preventing over subscription." {6: 1, 84: 1, 55: 1, 90: 4, 31: 3, 8: 2} {360: 1, 409: 1, 338: 1, 101: 4, 107: 3, 138: 2, 211: 3, 89: 2} {226, 101, 360, 409, 107, 138, 338, 211, 89} 8 "Explicit routes are used to ensure that packets are routed through the resources that have been reserved for them, and hence provide the DetNet application with the required service. A requirement for the DetNet Controller Plane will be the ability to assign a particular identified DetNet IP flow to a path through the DetNet domain that has been assigned the required nodal resources. This provides the appropriate traffic treatment for the flow and also includes particular links as a part of the path that are able to support the DetNet flow. For example, by using IEEE 802.1 TSN links (as discussed in XXX ) DetNet parameters can be maintained. Further considerations and requirements for the DetNet Controller Plane are discussed in control-management-requirements." "Updates from today 's meeting plus a bit of cleanup - references - spelling - addressing some clarifications from I have checked all the diffs and they look good ." e24f0e46970c4e1014284609644c366e8a23138c e24f0e46970c4e1014284609644c366e8a23138c draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework 571384dfef68c1334e9c77647556a20dc5c98909cda47416a73c4a95e4490b63 ['571384dfef68c1334e9c77647556a20dc5c98909cda47416a73c4a95e4490b63', '26b7bb9f86869cc432f24e56d9182cbac465940c3cc7173b7388e18ff8e98312'] A "explicit routes are used to ensure that packets are routed through the resources that have been reserved for them, and hence provide the detnet application with the required service. a requirement for the detnet controller plane will be the ability to assign a particular identified detnet ip flow to a path through the detnet domain that has been assigned the required nodal resources. this provides the appropriate traffic treatment for the flow and also includes particular links as a part of the path that are able to support the detnet flow. for example, by using ieee 802.1 tsn links (as discussed in xxx ) detnet parameters can be maintained. further considerations and requirements for the detnet controller plane are discussed in control-management-requirements." {6: 1, 31: 1, 8: 2, 90: 2, 84: 3, 55: 3} {360: 1, 211: 1, 226: 2, 101: 2, 409: 3, 107: 3, 338: 3, 89: 2} {226, 101, 360, 409, 107, 138, 338, 211, 89} 8 "Explicit routes are used to ensure that packets are routed through the resources that have been reserved for them, and hence provide the DetNet application with the required service. A requirement for the DetNet Controller Plane will be the ability to assign a particular identified DetNet IP flow to a path through the DetNet domain that has been assigned the required nodal resources. This provides the appropriate traffic treatment for the flow and also includes particular links as a part of the path that are able to support the DetNet flow. For example, by using IEEE 802.1 TSN links (as discussed in I-D.mpls-over-tsn ) DetNet parameters can be maintained. Further considerations and requirements for the DetNet Controller Plane are discussed in control-management-requirements." "Updates from today 's meeting plus a bit of cleanup - references - spelling - addressing some clarifications from I have checked all the diffs and they look good ." e24f0e46970c4e1014284609644c366e8a23138c e24f0e46970c4e1014284609644c366e8a23138c draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework 26b7bb9f86869cc432f24e56d9182cbac465940c3cc7173b7388e18ff8e98312 ['571384dfef68c1334e9c77647556a20dc5c98909cda47416a73c4a95e4490b63', '26b7bb9f86869cc432f24e56d9182cbac465940c3cc7173b7388e18ff8e98312'] B "explicit routes are used to ensure that packets are routed through the resources that have been reserved for them, and hence provide the detnet application with the required service. a requirement for the detnet controller plane will be the ability to assign a particular identified detnet ip flow to a path through the detnet domain that has been assigned the required nodal resources. this provides the appropriate traffic treatment for the flow and also includes particular links as a part of the path that are able to support the detnet flow. for example, by using ieee 802.1 tsn links (as discussed in i-d.mpls-over-tsn ) detnet parameters can be maintained. further considerations and requirements for the detnet controller plane are discussed in control-management-requirements." {6: 1, 31: 1, 8: 2, 90: 2, 84: 3, 55: 3} {360: 1, 211: 1, 226: 2, 101: 2, 409: 3, 107: 3, 338: 3, 89: 2} {226, 101, 360, 409, 107, 138, 338, 211, 89} 8 "As discussed in sec_intro, this document does not specify the mechanisms needed to eliminate packet contention, packet loss or reduce jitter for DetNet flows at the DetNet forwarding sub-layer. The ability to manage node and link resources to be able to provide these functions is a necessary part of the DetNet controller plane. It is also necessary to be able to control the required queuing mechanisms used to provide these functions along a flow's path through the network. See XXX and control-management-requirements for further discussion of these requirements." "Updates from today 's meeting plus a bit of cleanup - references - spelling - addressing some clarifications from I have checked all the diffs and they look good ." e24f0e46970c4e1014284609644c366e8a23138c e24f0e46970c4e1014284609644c366e8a23138c draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework dcc7b98c8bedb18fdf3e2a9055c82a6d629724e0bb0b589d6472a6eb1b1bacf1 ['5cccb78a89ff99cfcd1571feee9f23465ead9e3a23aca048876b063038519b97', 'dcc7b98c8bedb18fdf3e2a9055c82a6d629724e0bb0b589d6472a6eb1b1bacf1'] A "as discussed in sec_intro, this document does not specify the mechanisms needed to eliminate packet contention, packet loss or reduce jitter for detnet flows at the detnet forwarding sub-layer. the ability to manage node and link resources to be able to provide these functions is a necessary part of the detnet controller plane. it is also necessary to be able to control the required queuing mechanisms used to provide these functions along a flow's path through the network. see xxx and control-management-requirements for further discussion of these requirements." {6: 1, 68: 2} {301: 1, 98: 2} {98, 148, 301} 8 "As discussed in sec_intro, this document does not specify the mechanisms needed to eliminate packet contention, packet loss or reduce jitter for DetNet flows at the DetNet forwarding sub-layer. The ability to manage node and link resources to be able to provide these functions is a necessary part of the DetNet controller plane. It is also necessary to be able to control the required queuing mechanisms used to provide these functions along a flow's path through the network. See I-D.ietf-detnet-ip --> and control- management-requirements for further discussion of these requirements." "Updates from today 's meeting plus a bit of cleanup - references - spelling - addressing some clarifications from I have checked all the diffs and they look good ." e24f0e46970c4e1014284609644c366e8a23138c e24f0e46970c4e1014284609644c366e8a23138c draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework 5cccb78a89ff99cfcd1571feee9f23465ead9e3a23aca048876b063038519b97 ['5cccb78a89ff99cfcd1571feee9f23465ead9e3a23aca048876b063038519b97', 'dcc7b98c8bedb18fdf3e2a9055c82a6d629724e0bb0b589d6472a6eb1b1bacf1'] B "as discussed in sec_intro, this document does not specify the mechanisms needed to eliminate packet contention, packet loss or reduce jitter for detnet flows at the detnet forwarding sub-layer. the ability to manage node and link resources to be able to provide these functions is a necessary part of the detnet controller plane. it is also necessary to be able to control the required queuing mechanisms used to provide these functions along a flow's path through the network. see i-d.ietf-detnet-ip --> and control- management-requirements for further discussion of these requirements." {6: 1, 68: 2} {301: 1, 98: 2} {98, 148, 301} 8 "sec_dt_dp discussed the use of the IP ""6-tuple"" for flow identification, and goes on to discuss how identified flows use specific QoS mechanisms for flow-specific traffic treatment, including path control and resource allocation. XXX contains detailed DetNet IP flow identification procedures. Flow identification will play an important role for the DetNet controller plane." "Updates from today 's meeting plus a bit of cleanup - references - spelling - addressing some clarifications from I have checked all the diffs and they look good ." e24f0e46970c4e1014284609644c366e8a23138c e24f0e46970c4e1014284609644c366e8a23138c draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework f324bf058c84826da1efc203ac93e10f18bc0fa32d40e5c35a418912306bc147 ['2620263efce58dc9f5fe6736a2ae2284c5a7be9197bdcf799f2006df778020cb', 'f324bf058c84826da1efc203ac93e10f18bc0fa32d40e5c35a418912306bc147', 'd72d4ba50e7c17386f65556b7c81107a0503b156254c9f642cd768cef7daefd7', 'ee163c4a579661943fadb8ff29943ccdd2f10f68d6d81bcd80e94a72d29a381a', 'f49cf97801e24dfe0572c7555cf8153d94755cf8a358541a4867ed1b201b40be', 'e9b9d25173109a906c32bc389b5f6f5c5abf1764379d3f00f7977c10d067ff5e', '1b90f8a07b781e94d70bcf784f4b0e91b3c281655f8c893e6ace4d4877446ca5', '507e0d518a66ed33aeadf48553eba471724848455642c095364b4b70f68ef0ce'] A "sec_dt_dp discussed the use of the ip ""6-tuple"" for flow identification, and goes on to discuss how identified flows use specific qos mechanisms for flow-specific traffic treatment, including path control and resource allocation. xxx contains detailed detnet ip flow identification procedures. flow identification will play an important role for the detnet controller plane." {6: 1, 31: 1, 35: 2, 8: 4} {54: 1, 340: 1, 362: 3, 48: 2, 144: 2, 177: 4, 251: 3} {362, 48, 144, 177, 340, 54, 55, 251} 8 "aggregation and ip-agg discuss the use of flow aggregation in DetNet. Flow aggregation can be accomplished using any of the 6-tuple fields defined in XXX , using a DSCP identified traffic class or other field. It will be the responsibility of the DetNet controller plane to be able to properly provision the use of these aggregation mechanisms. These requirements are included in control-management- requirements." "Updates from today 's meeting plus a bit of cleanup - references - spelling - addressing some clarifications from I have checked all the diffs and they look good ." e24f0e46970c4e1014284609644c366e8a23138c e24f0e46970c4e1014284609644c366e8a23138c draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework 2620263efce58dc9f5fe6736a2ae2284c5a7be9197bdcf799f2006df778020cb ['2620263efce58dc9f5fe6736a2ae2284c5a7be9197bdcf799f2006df778020cb', 'f324bf058c84826da1efc203ac93e10f18bc0fa32d40e5c35a418912306bc147', 'd72d4ba50e7c17386f65556b7c81107a0503b156254c9f642cd768cef7daefd7', 'ee163c4a579661943fadb8ff29943ccdd2f10f68d6d81bcd80e94a72d29a381a', 'f49cf97801e24dfe0572c7555cf8153d94755cf8a358541a4867ed1b201b40be', 'e9b9d25173109a906c32bc389b5f6f5c5abf1764379d3f00f7977c10d067ff5e', '1b90f8a07b781e94d70bcf784f4b0e91b3c281655f8c893e6ace4d4877446ca5', '507e0d518a66ed33aeadf48553eba471724848455642c095364b4b70f68ef0ce'] A "aggregation and ip-agg discuss the use of flow aggregation in detnet. flow aggregation can be accomplished using any of the 6-tuple fields defined in xxx , using a dscp identified traffic class or other field. it will be the responsibility of the detnet controller plane to be able to properly provision the use of these aggregation mechanisms. these requirements are included in control-management- requirements." {6: 1, 31: 1, 35: 2, 8: 4} {54: 1, 340: 1, 362: 3, 48: 2, 144: 2, 177: 4, 251: 3} {362, 48, 144, 177, 340, 54, 55, 251} 8 "This section covers MPLS data plane specific control plane considerations. This section needs generallizing." "Updates from today 's meeting plus a bit of cleanup - references - spelling - addressing some clarifications from I have checked all the diffs and they look good ." e24f0e46970c4e1014284609644c366e8a23138c e24f0e46970c4e1014284609644c366e8a23138c draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework e9b9d25173109a906c32bc389b5f6f5c5abf1764379d3f00f7977c10d067ff5e ['2620263efce58dc9f5fe6736a2ae2284c5a7be9197bdcf799f2006df778020cb', 'f324bf058c84826da1efc203ac93e10f18bc0fa32d40e5c35a418912306bc147', 'd72d4ba50e7c17386f65556b7c81107a0503b156254c9f642cd768cef7daefd7', 'ee163c4a579661943fadb8ff29943ccdd2f10f68d6d81bcd80e94a72d29a381a', 'f49cf97801e24dfe0572c7555cf8153d94755cf8a358541a4867ed1b201b40be', 'e9b9d25173109a906c32bc389b5f6f5c5abf1764379d3f00f7977c10d067ff5e', '1b90f8a07b781e94d70bcf784f4b0e91b3c281655f8c893e6ace4d4877446ca5', '507e0d518a66ed33aeadf48553eba471724848455642c095364b4b70f68ef0ce'] A "this section covers mpls data plane specific control plane considerations. this section needs generallizing." {6: 1, 31: 1, 35: 2, 8: 4} {54: 1, 340: 1, 362: 3, 48: 2, 144: 2, 177: 4, 251: 3} {362, 48, 144, 177, 340, 54, 55, 251} 8 "DetNet S-Labels (see XXX for their definition) are similar to other MPLS service labels that denote the contents of the MPLS packet payload such as a layer 2 pseudowire, an IP packet that is routed in a VPN context with a private address, or an Ethernet virtual private network (EVPN) service." "Updates from today 's meeting plus a bit of cleanup - references - spelling - addressing some clarifications from I have checked all the diffs and they look good ." e24f0e46970c4e1014284609644c366e8a23138c e24f0e46970c4e1014284609644c366e8a23138c draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework ee163c4a579661943fadb8ff29943ccdd2f10f68d6d81bcd80e94a72d29a381a ['2620263efce58dc9f5fe6736a2ae2284c5a7be9197bdcf799f2006df778020cb', 'f324bf058c84826da1efc203ac93e10f18bc0fa32d40e5c35a418912306bc147', 'd72d4ba50e7c17386f65556b7c81107a0503b156254c9f642cd768cef7daefd7', 'ee163c4a579661943fadb8ff29943ccdd2f10f68d6d81bcd80e94a72d29a381a', 'f49cf97801e24dfe0572c7555cf8153d94755cf8a358541a4867ed1b201b40be', 'e9b9d25173109a906c32bc389b5f6f5c5abf1764379d3f00f7977c10d067ff5e', '1b90f8a07b781e94d70bcf784f4b0e91b3c281655f8c893e6ace4d4877446ca5', '507e0d518a66ed33aeadf48553eba471724848455642c095364b4b70f68ef0ce'] A "detnet s-labels (see xxx for their definition) are similar to other mpls service labels that denote the contents of the mpls packet payload such as a layer 2 pseudowire, an ip packet that is routed in a vpn context with a private address, or an ethernet virtual private network (evpn) service." {6: 1, 31: 1, 35: 2, 8: 4} {54: 1, 340: 1, 362: 3, 48: 2, 144: 2, 177: 4, 251: 3} {362, 48, 144, 177, 340, 54, 55, 251} 8 "sec_dt_dp discussed the use of the IP ""6-tuple"" for flow identification, and goes on to discuss how identified flows use specific QoS mechanisms for flow-specific traffic treatment, including path control and resource allocation. I-D.ietf-detnet-ip contains detailed DetNet IP flow identification procedures. Flow identification will play an important role for the DetNet controller plane." "Updates from today 's meeting plus a bit of cleanup - references - spelling - addressing some clarifications from I have checked all the diffs and they look good ." e24f0e46970c4e1014284609644c366e8a23138c e24f0e46970c4e1014284609644c366e8a23138c draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework 1b90f8a07b781e94d70bcf784f4b0e91b3c281655f8c893e6ace4d4877446ca5 ['2620263efce58dc9f5fe6736a2ae2284c5a7be9197bdcf799f2006df778020cb', 'f324bf058c84826da1efc203ac93e10f18bc0fa32d40e5c35a418912306bc147', 'd72d4ba50e7c17386f65556b7c81107a0503b156254c9f642cd768cef7daefd7', 'ee163c4a579661943fadb8ff29943ccdd2f10f68d6d81bcd80e94a72d29a381a', 'f49cf97801e24dfe0572c7555cf8153d94755cf8a358541a4867ed1b201b40be', 'e9b9d25173109a906c32bc389b5f6f5c5abf1764379d3f00f7977c10d067ff5e', '1b90f8a07b781e94d70bcf784f4b0e91b3c281655f8c893e6ace4d4877446ca5', '507e0d518a66ed33aeadf48553eba471724848455642c095364b4b70f68ef0ce'] B "sec_dt_dp discussed the use of the ip ""6-tuple"" for flow identification, and goes on to discuss how identified flows use specific qos mechanisms for flow-specific traffic treatment, including path control and resource allocation. i-d.ietf-detnet-ip contains detailed detnet ip flow identification procedures. flow identification will play an important role for the detnet controller plane." {6: 1, 31: 1, 35: 2, 8: 4} {54: 1, 340: 1, 362: 3, 48: 2, 144: 2, 177: 4, 251: 3} {362, 48, 144, 177, 340, 54, 55, 251} 8 "aggregation and ip-agg discuss the use of flow aggregation in DetNet. Flow aggregation can be accomplished using any of the 6-tuple fields defined in I-D.ietf-detnet-ip , using a DSCP identified traffic class or other field. It will be the responsibility of the DetNet controller plane to be able to properly provision the use of these aggregation mechanisms. These requirements are included in control- management-requirements." "Updates from today 's meeting plus a bit of cleanup - references - spelling - addressing some clarifications from I have checked all the diffs and they look good ." e24f0e46970c4e1014284609644c366e8a23138c e24f0e46970c4e1014284609644c366e8a23138c draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework 507e0d518a66ed33aeadf48553eba471724848455642c095364b4b70f68ef0ce ['2620263efce58dc9f5fe6736a2ae2284c5a7be9197bdcf799f2006df778020cb', 'f324bf058c84826da1efc203ac93e10f18bc0fa32d40e5c35a418912306bc147', 'd72d4ba50e7c17386f65556b7c81107a0503b156254c9f642cd768cef7daefd7', 'ee163c4a579661943fadb8ff29943ccdd2f10f68d6d81bcd80e94a72d29a381a', 'f49cf97801e24dfe0572c7555cf8153d94755cf8a358541a4867ed1b201b40be', 'e9b9d25173109a906c32bc389b5f6f5c5abf1764379d3f00f7977c10d067ff5e', '1b90f8a07b781e94d70bcf784f4b0e91b3c281655f8c893e6ace4d4877446ca5', '507e0d518a66ed33aeadf48553eba471724848455642c095364b4b70f68ef0ce'] B "aggregation and ip-agg discuss the use of flow aggregation in detnet. flow aggregation can be accomplished using any of the 6-tuple fields defined in i-d.ietf-detnet-ip , using a dscp identified traffic class or other field. it will be the responsibility of the detnet controller plane to be able to properly provision the use of these aggregation mechanisms. these requirements are included in control- management-requirements." {6: 1, 31: 1, 35: 2, 8: 4} {54: 1, 340: 1, 362: 3, 48: 2, 144: 2, 177: 4, 251: 3} {362, 48, 144, 177, 340, 54, 55, 251} 8 "This section covers MPLS data plane specific control plane considerations. This section needs generalizing." "Updates from today 's meeting plus a bit of cleanup - references - spelling - addressing some clarifications from I have checked all the diffs and they look good ." e24f0e46970c4e1014284609644c366e8a23138c e24f0e46970c4e1014284609644c366e8a23138c draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework d72d4ba50e7c17386f65556b7c81107a0503b156254c9f642cd768cef7daefd7 ['2620263efce58dc9f5fe6736a2ae2284c5a7be9197bdcf799f2006df778020cb', 'f324bf058c84826da1efc203ac93e10f18bc0fa32d40e5c35a418912306bc147', 'd72d4ba50e7c17386f65556b7c81107a0503b156254c9f642cd768cef7daefd7', 'ee163c4a579661943fadb8ff29943ccdd2f10f68d6d81bcd80e94a72d29a381a', 'f49cf97801e24dfe0572c7555cf8153d94755cf8a358541a4867ed1b201b40be', 'e9b9d25173109a906c32bc389b5f6f5c5abf1764379d3f00f7977c10d067ff5e', '1b90f8a07b781e94d70bcf784f4b0e91b3c281655f8c893e6ace4d4877446ca5', '507e0d518a66ed33aeadf48553eba471724848455642c095364b4b70f68ef0ce'] B "this section covers mpls data plane specific control plane considerations. this section needs generalizing." {6: 1, 31: 1, 35: 2, 8: 4} {54: 1, 340: 1, 362: 3, 48: 2, 144: 2, 177: 4, 251: 3} {362, 48, 144, 177, 340, 54, 55, 251} 8 "DetNet S-Labels I-D.ietf-detnet-mpls for their definition) are similar to other MPLS service labels that denote the contents of the MPLS packet payload such as a layer 2 pseudowire, an IP packet that is routed in a VPN context with a private address, or an Ethernet virtual private network (EVPN) service." "Updates from today 's meeting plus a bit of cleanup - references - spelling - addressing some clarifications from I have checked all the diffs and they look good ." e24f0e46970c4e1014284609644c366e8a23138c e24f0e46970c4e1014284609644c366e8a23138c draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework f49cf97801e24dfe0572c7555cf8153d94755cf8a358541a4867ed1b201b40be ['2620263efce58dc9f5fe6736a2ae2284c5a7be9197bdcf799f2006df778020cb', 'f324bf058c84826da1efc203ac93e10f18bc0fa32d40e5c35a418912306bc147', 'd72d4ba50e7c17386f65556b7c81107a0503b156254c9f642cd768cef7daefd7', 'ee163c4a579661943fadb8ff29943ccdd2f10f68d6d81bcd80e94a72d29a381a', 'f49cf97801e24dfe0572c7555cf8153d94755cf8a358541a4867ed1b201b40be', 'e9b9d25173109a906c32bc389b5f6f5c5abf1764379d3f00f7977c10d067ff5e', '1b90f8a07b781e94d70bcf784f4b0e91b3c281655f8c893e6ace4d4877446ca5', '507e0d518a66ed33aeadf48553eba471724848455642c095364b4b70f68ef0ce'] B "detnet s-labels i-d.ietf-detnet-mpls for their definition) are similar to other mpls service labels that denote the contents of the mpls packet payload such as a layer 2 pseudowire, an ip packet that is routed in a vpn context with a private address, or an ethernet virtual private network (evpn) service." {6: 1, 31: 1, 35: 2, 8: 4} {54: 1, 340: 1, 362: 3, 48: 2, 144: 2, 177: 4, 251: 3} {362, 48, 144, 177, 340, 54, 55, 251} 8 "S-Labels are expected to be allocated in the same manner as any other service labels. S-Labels uniquely identify a particular DetNet flow, and are local to the node on which the label is allocated. In the DetNet service sub-layer the explicit route consists of the set of Relay Nodes that the DetNet flow must traverse. They can be used to identify the DetNet flow that a packet belongs to as it traverses a particular node in a DetNet domain. Because labels are local to each node rather than being a global identifier within a domain, they must be advertised to their upstream DetNet service-aware peer nodes (e.g., a DetNet MPLS End System as shown in XXX , or a DetNet Relay or Edge Node as shown in XXX ) and interpreted in the context of their received F-Label." "Updates from today 's meeting plus a bit of cleanup - references - spelling - addressing some clarifications from I have checked all the diffs and they look good ." e24f0e46970c4e1014284609644c366e8a23138c e24f0e46970c4e1014284609644c366e8a23138c draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework 5c90a3e3999ad576f49b7c6dabfac38162417f26370a9f93580b3659def29a8e ['7152a136808a778772790e5f90e7957b2499f612dcbd023d6de13efce492c92e', 'a13bacead369ce97a675dfd9501934cd6bc2092302664485ef6052694a322fc0', '5c90a3e3999ad576f49b7c6dabfac38162417f26370a9f93580b3659def29a8e', 'ed20302d1ba5a30881fde0793bde802701d9d6e6dc8e941649e8aab7292106d5'] A "s-labels are expected to be allocated in the same manner as any other service labels. s-labels uniquely identify a particular detnet flow, and are local to the node on which the label is allocated. in the detnet service sub-layer the explicit route consists of the set of relay nodes that the detnet flow must traverse. they can be used to identify the detnet flow that a packet belongs to as it traverses a particular node in a detnet domain. because labels are local to each node rather than being a global identifier within a domain, they must be advertised to their upstream detnet service-aware peer nodes (e.g., a detnet mpls end system as shown in xxx , or a detnet relay or edge node as shown in xxx ) and interpreted in the context of their received f-label." {31: 1, 35: 2, 6: 5, 8: 4} {362: 1, 251: 1, 48: 2, 144: 6, 340: 3, 54: 5, 55: 4} {362, 48, 144, 177, 340, 54, 55, 251} 8 "As discussed in sec_dt_dp, the forwarding sub-layer uses one or more F-Labels to forward DetNet packets between DetNet service-aware nodes along explicitly defined routes at the DetNet forwarding sub-layer, which in the context of this document is the MPLS layer. F-Labels can also provide context for an S-Label. In the DetNet Forwarding (MPLS) sub-layer the explicit route consists of the set of DetNet nodes which are LSRs, links, and possibly link bundle members and queues that the DetNet packets of a flow must traverse between nodes in the DetNet service sub-layer (i.e. between a specific Edge Node and the next hop Relay Node, between specific Relay Nodes, and between a specific Relay node and the egress Edge Node. Resource allocation corresponding to the set of Services supported over the forwarding sub-layer, which may or may not include aggregation, is required at this sub-layer. Explicit routes are used to ensure that packets are routed through the resources that have been reserved for them, and hence provide the DetNet application with the required service. Multiple F-Labels may be pushed after an S-Label and there is no requirement for all F-Labels to be controlled via the same controller mechanisms. For example in EVPN, some labels are distributed using BGP while others are distributed using LDP or RSVP." "Updates from today 's meeting plus a bit of cleanup - references - spelling - addressing some clarifications from I have checked all the diffs and they look good ." e24f0e46970c4e1014284609644c366e8a23138c e24f0e46970c4e1014284609644c366e8a23138c draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework 7152a136808a778772790e5f90e7957b2499f612dcbd023d6de13efce492c92e ['7152a136808a778772790e5f90e7957b2499f612dcbd023d6de13efce492c92e', 'a13bacead369ce97a675dfd9501934cd6bc2092302664485ef6052694a322fc0', '5c90a3e3999ad576f49b7c6dabfac38162417f26370a9f93580b3659def29a8e', 'ed20302d1ba5a30881fde0793bde802701d9d6e6dc8e941649e8aab7292106d5'] A "as discussed in sec_dt_dp, the forwarding sub-layer uses one or more f-labels to forward detnet packets between detnet service-aware nodes along explicitly defined routes at the detnet forwarding sub-layer, which in the context of this document is the mpls layer. f-labels can also provide context for an s-label. in the detnet forwarding (mpls) sub-layer the explicit route consists of the set of detnet nodes which are lsrs, links, and possibly link bundle members and queues that the detnet packets of a flow must traverse between nodes in the detnet service sub-layer (i.e. between a specific edge node and the next hop relay node, between specific relay nodes, and between a specific relay node and the egress edge node. resource allocation corresponding to the set of services supported over the forwarding sub-layer, which may or may not include aggregation, is required at this sub-layer. explicit routes are used to ensure that packets are routed through the resources that have been reserved for them, and hence provide the detnet application with the required service. multiple f-labels may be pushed after an s-label and there is no requirement for all f-labels to be controlled via the same controller mechanisms. for example in evpn, some labels are distributed using bgp while others are distributed using ldp or rsvp." {31: 1, 35: 2, 6: 5, 8: 4} {362: 1, 251: 1, 48: 2, 144: 6, 340: 3, 54: 5, 55: 4} {362, 48, 144, 177, 340, 54, 55, 251} 8 "S-Labels are expected to be allocated in the same manner as any other service labels. S-Labels uniquely identify a particular DetNet flow, and are local to the node on which the label is allocated. In the DetNet service sub-layer the explicit route consists of the set of Relay Nodes that the DetNet flow must traverse. They can be used to identify the DetNet flow that a packet belongs to as it traverses a particular node in a DetNet domain. Because labels are local to each node rather than being a global identifier within a domain, they must be advertised to their upstream DetNet service-aware peer nodes (e.g., a DetNet MPLS End System or a DetNet Relay or Edge Node and interpreted in the context of their received F-Label." "Updates from today 's meeting plus a bit of cleanup - references - spelling - addressing some clarifications from I have checked all the diffs and they look good ." e24f0e46970c4e1014284609644c366e8a23138c e24f0e46970c4e1014284609644c366e8a23138c draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework ed20302d1ba5a30881fde0793bde802701d9d6e6dc8e941649e8aab7292106d5 ['7152a136808a778772790e5f90e7957b2499f612dcbd023d6de13efce492c92e', 'a13bacead369ce97a675dfd9501934cd6bc2092302664485ef6052694a322fc0', '5c90a3e3999ad576f49b7c6dabfac38162417f26370a9f93580b3659def29a8e', 'ed20302d1ba5a30881fde0793bde802701d9d6e6dc8e941649e8aab7292106d5'] B "s-labels are expected to be allocated in the same manner as any other service labels. s-labels uniquely identify a particular detnet flow, and are local to the node on which the label is allocated. in the detnet service sub-layer the explicit route consists of the set of relay nodes that the detnet flow must traverse. they can be used to identify the detnet flow that a packet belongs to as it traverses a particular node in a detnet domain. because labels are local to each node rather than being a global identifier within a domain, they must be advertised to their upstream detnet service-aware peer nodes (e.g., a detnet mpls end system or a detnet relay or edge node and interpreted in the context of their received f-label." {31: 1, 35: 2, 6: 5, 8: 4} {362: 1, 251: 1, 48: 2, 144: 6, 340: 3, 54: 5, 55: 4} {362, 48, 144, 177, 340, 54, 55, 251} 8 "As discussed in sec_dt_dp, the forwarding sub-layer uses one or more F-Labels to forward DetNet packets between DetNet service-aware nodes along explicitly defined routes at the DetNet forwarding sub-layer, which in the context of this document is MPLS. F-Labels can also provide context for an S-Label. In the DetNet Forwarding (MPLS) sub- layer the explicit route consists of the set of DetNet nodes which are LSRs, links, and possibly link bundle members and queues that the DetNet packets of a flow must traverse between nodes in the DetNet service sub-layer (i.e. between a specific Edge Node and the next hop Relay Node, between specific Relay Nodes, and between a specific Relay node and the egress Edge Node. Resource allocation corresponding to the set of Services supported over the forwarding sub-layer, which may or may not include aggregation, is required at this sub-layer. Explicit routes are used to ensure that packets are routed through the resources that have been reserved for them, and hence provide the DetNet application with the required service. Multiple F-Labels may be pushed after an S-Label and there is no requirement for all F-Labels to be controlled via the same controller mechanisms. For example in EVPN, some labels are distributed using BGP while others are distributed using LDP or RSVP." "Updates from today 's meeting plus a bit of cleanup - references - spelling - addressing some clarifications from I have checked all the diffs and they look good ." e24f0e46970c4e1014284609644c366e8a23138c e24f0e46970c4e1014284609644c366e8a23138c draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework a13bacead369ce97a675dfd9501934cd6bc2092302664485ef6052694a322fc0 ['7152a136808a778772790e5f90e7957b2499f612dcbd023d6de13efce492c92e', 'a13bacead369ce97a675dfd9501934cd6bc2092302664485ef6052694a322fc0', '5c90a3e3999ad576f49b7c6dabfac38162417f26370a9f93580b3659def29a8e', 'ed20302d1ba5a30881fde0793bde802701d9d6e6dc8e941649e8aab7292106d5'] B "as discussed in sec_dt_dp, the forwarding sub-layer uses one or more f-labels to forward detnet packets between detnet service-aware nodes along explicitly defined routes at the detnet forwarding sub-layer, which in the context of this document is mpls. f-labels can also provide context for an s-label. in the detnet forwarding (mpls) sub- layer the explicit route consists of the set of detnet nodes which are lsrs, links, and possibly link bundle members and queues that the detnet packets of a flow must traverse between nodes in the detnet service sub-layer (i.e. between a specific edge node and the next hop relay node, between specific relay nodes, and between a specific relay node and the egress edge node. resource allocation corresponding to the set of services supported over the forwarding sub-layer, which may or may not include aggregation, is required at this sub-layer. explicit routes are used to ensure that packets are routed through the resources that have been reserved for them, and hence provide the detnet application with the required service. multiple f-labels may be pushed after an s-label and there is no requirement for all f-labels to be controlled via the same controller mechanisms. for example in evpn, some labels are distributed using bgp while others are distributed using ldp or rsvp." {31: 1, 35: 2, 6: 5, 8: 4} {362: 1, 251: 1, 48: 2, 144: 6, 340: 3, 54: 5, 55: 4} {362, 48, 144, 177, 340, 54, 55, 251} 6 "Deterministic Networking (DetNet) is a service that can be offered by a network to DetNet flows. DetNet provides these flows with low packet loss rates and assured maximum end-to-end delivery latency. A description of the general background and concepts of DetNet can be found in I-D.ietf-detnet-architecture." "Branch for review Merge it ! Changes look good - clicking correct button this time" 215d293ca11d1a96b10664fe5db5be2326ffc8d9 215d293ca11d1a96b10664fe5db5be2326ffc8d9 draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework ea750873474b4d0718a885ebcba287e5e25309bdb432902595ba344ba99fd8fb ['48b1d5a85a046650499d2dc3b101a8d5ad07836be83dcc1b331c952fcfb50df3', 'ea750873474b4d0718a885ebcba287e5e25309bdb432902595ba344ba99fd8fb'] A "deterministic networking (detnet) is a service that can be offered by a network to detnet flows. detnet provides these flows with low packet loss rates and assured maximum end-to-end delivery latency. a description of the general background and concepts of detnet can be found in i-d.ietf-detnet-architecture." {8: 1, 90: 3, 55: 2, 67: 3} {60: 1, 106: 3, 61: 2, 375: 3} {106, 113, 375, 60, 61} 6 "Deterministic Networking (DetNet) is a service that can be offered by a network to DetNet flows. DetNet provides these flows with extremely low packet loss rates and assured maximum end-to-end delivery latency. A description of the general background and concepts of DetNet can be found in I-D.ietf-detnet-architecture." "Branch for review Merge it ! Changes look good - clicking correct button this time" 215d293ca11d1a96b10664fe5db5be2326ffc8d9 215d293ca11d1a96b10664fe5db5be2326ffc8d9 draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework 48b1d5a85a046650499d2dc3b101a8d5ad07836be83dcc1b331c952fcfb50df3 ['48b1d5a85a046650499d2dc3b101a8d5ad07836be83dcc1b331c952fcfb50df3', 'ea750873474b4d0718a885ebcba287e5e25309bdb432902595ba344ba99fd8fb'] B "deterministic networking (detnet) is a service that can be offered by a network to detnet flows. detnet provides these flows with extremely low packet loss rates and assured maximum end-to-end delivery latency. a description of the general background and concepts of detnet can be found in i-d.ietf-detnet-architecture." {8: 1, 90: 3, 55: 2, 67: 3} {60: 1, 106: 3, 61: 2, 375: 3} {106, 113, 375, 60, 61} 6 "The DetNet Architecture decomposes the DetNet related data plane functions into two sub-layers: a service sub-layer and a forwarding sub-layer. The service sub-layer is used to provide DetNet service protection and reordering. The forwarding sub-layer is used to provide congestion protection (low loss, assured latency, and limited reordering) and leverages Traffic Engineering mechanisms." "Branch for review Merge it ! Changes look good - clicking correct button this time" 215d293ca11d1a96b10664fe5db5be2326ffc8d9 215d293ca11d1a96b10664fe5db5be2326ffc8d9 draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework 9ff2b5da604db48cbd469b33c4dd8bb38e786881dc91d94437ec0bfd16053aae ['9ff2b5da604db48cbd469b33c4dd8bb38e786881dc91d94437ec0bfd16053aae', '128ec2cc0d2b4419f64f4de91e877ed6ba797cdc471568303ffdcae2f23d3ea6'] A "the detnet architecture decomposes the detnet related data plane functions into two sub-layers: a service sub-layer and a forwarding sub-layer. the service sub-layer is used to provide detnet service protection and reordering. the forwarding sub-layer is used to provide congestion protection (low loss, assured latency, and limited reordering) and leverages traffic engineering mechanisms." {} {} {} 6 "The DetNet Architecture models the DetNet related data plane functions decomposed into two sub-layers: a service sub-layer and a forwarding sub-layer. The service sub-layer is used to provide DetNet service protection and reordering. The forwarding sub-layer is used to provide congestion protection (low loss, assured latency, and limited reordering) and leverages Traffic Engineering mechanisms." "Branch for review Merge it ! Changes look good - clicking correct button this time" 215d293ca11d1a96b10664fe5db5be2326ffc8d9 215d293ca11d1a96b10664fe5db5be2326ffc8d9 draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework 128ec2cc0d2b4419f64f4de91e877ed6ba797cdc471568303ffdcae2f23d3ea6 ['9ff2b5da604db48cbd469b33c4dd8bb38e786881dc91d94437ec0bfd16053aae', '128ec2cc0d2b4419f64f4de91e877ed6ba797cdc471568303ffdcae2f23d3ea6'] B "the detnet architecture models the detnet related data plane functions decomposed into two sub-layers: a service sub-layer and a forwarding sub-layer. the service sub-layer is used to provide detnet service protection and reordering. the forwarding sub-layer is used to provide congestion protection (low loss, assured latency, and limited reordering) and leverages traffic engineering mechanisms." {} {} {} 6 "DetNet flows may be carried over network technologies that can provide the DetNet required level of service. For example, DetNet MPLS flows can be carried over IEEE 802.1 Time Sensitive Network (TSN) sub-networks. However, IEEE 802.1 TSN support is not required and some of the DetNet benefits can be gained by running over a data link layer that has not been specificaly enhanced to support TSN." "Branch for review Merge it ! Changes look good - clicking correct button this time" 215d293ca11d1a96b10664fe5db5be2326ffc8d9 215d293ca11d1a96b10664fe5db5be2326ffc8d9 draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework ac733e21b3c99f468b6678c77e79c651050d158b78fde95459cb018448544f1a ['96e3396a6ba90a6f8d6fe9a23e2899d410bbe178b3a70745d16e9ffbe10bc047', 'ac733e21b3c99f468b6678c77e79c651050d158b78fde95459cb018448544f1a', 'b364f3ed7d4ba720c42afe45cd6fadcd470139c51ea1f3eab26f3482469b4cc7', '91c4aaa2d7c7dd6cd66ef63aa507c75eaaa634881e652f02b9c7337ea31f045e'] A "detnet flows may be carried over network technologies that can provide the detnet required level of service. for example, detnet mpls flows can be carried over ieee 802.1 time sensitive network (tsn) sub-networks. however, ieee 802.1 tsn support is not required and some of the detnet benefits can be gained by running over a data link layer that has not been specificaly enhanced to support tsn." {55: 1, 90: 3, 68: 2, 84: 2} {87: 1, 37: 5, 173: 2, 373: 2, 182: 3, 181: 4, 374: 3, 53: 3} {37, 232, 173, 373, 182, 87, 181, 374, 53} 6 "Different traffic types, or application flows, can be mapped on top of DetNet. DetNet can optionally reuse header information provided by, or shared with, applications. An example of such can be found in I-D.ietf-detnet-ip." "Branch for review Merge it ! Changes look good - clicking correct button this time" 215d293ca11d1a96b10664fe5db5be2326ffc8d9 215d293ca11d1a96b10664fe5db5be2326ffc8d9 draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework 96e3396a6ba90a6f8d6fe9a23e2899d410bbe178b3a70745d16e9ffbe10bc047 ['96e3396a6ba90a6f8d6fe9a23e2899d410bbe178b3a70745d16e9ffbe10bc047', 'ac733e21b3c99f468b6678c77e79c651050d158b78fde95459cb018448544f1a', 'b364f3ed7d4ba720c42afe45cd6fadcd470139c51ea1f3eab26f3482469b4cc7', '91c4aaa2d7c7dd6cd66ef63aa507c75eaaa634881e652f02b9c7337ea31f045e'] A "different traffic types, or application flows, can be mapped on top of detnet. detnet can optionally reuse header information provided by, or shared with, applications. an example of such can be found in i-d.ietf-detnet-ip." {55: 1, 90: 3, 68: 2, 84: 2} {87: 1, 37: 5, 173: 2, 373: 2, 182: 3, 181: 4, 374: 3, 53: 3} {37, 232, 173, 373, 182, 87, 181, 374, 53} 6 "DetNet flows may be carried over network technologies that can provide the DetNet required level of service. For example, DetNet MPLS flows can be carried over IEEE 802.1 Time Sensitive Network (TSN) IEEE802.1TSNTG sub-networks. However, IEEE 802.1 TSN support is not required and some of the DetNet benefits can be gained by running over a data link layer that has not been specifically enhanced to support TSN." "Branch for review Merge it ! Changes look good - clicking correct button this time" 215d293ca11d1a96b10664fe5db5be2326ffc8d9 215d293ca11d1a96b10664fe5db5be2326ffc8d9 draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework 91c4aaa2d7c7dd6cd66ef63aa507c75eaaa634881e652f02b9c7337ea31f045e ['96e3396a6ba90a6f8d6fe9a23e2899d410bbe178b3a70745d16e9ffbe10bc047', 'ac733e21b3c99f468b6678c77e79c651050d158b78fde95459cb018448544f1a', 'b364f3ed7d4ba720c42afe45cd6fadcd470139c51ea1f3eab26f3482469b4cc7', '91c4aaa2d7c7dd6cd66ef63aa507c75eaaa634881e652f02b9c7337ea31f045e'] B "detnet flows may be carried over network technologies that can provide the detnet required level of service. for example, detnet mpls flows can be carried over ieee 802.1 time sensitive network (tsn) ieee802.1tsntg sub-networks. however, ieee 802.1 tsn support is not required and some of the detnet benefits can be gained by running over a data link layer that has not been specifically enhanced to support tsn." {55: 1, 90: 3, 68: 2, 84: 2} {87: 1, 37: 5, 173: 2, 373: 2, 182: 3, 181: 4, 374: 3, 53: 3} {37, 232, 173, 373, 182, 87, 181, 374, 53} 6 "Different traffic types, or application flows, can be mapped on top of DetNet. DetNet can optionally reuse header information provided by, or shared with, applications. An example of shared header fields can be found in I-D.ietf-detnet-ip." "Branch for review Merge it ! Changes look good - clicking correct button this time" 215d293ca11d1a96b10664fe5db5be2326ffc8d9 215d293ca11d1a96b10664fe5db5be2326ffc8d9 draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework b364f3ed7d4ba720c42afe45cd6fadcd470139c51ea1f3eab26f3482469b4cc7 ['96e3396a6ba90a6f8d6fe9a23e2899d410bbe178b3a70745d16e9ffbe10bc047', 'ac733e21b3c99f468b6678c77e79c651050d158b78fde95459cb018448544f1a', 'b364f3ed7d4ba720c42afe45cd6fadcd470139c51ea1f3eab26f3482469b4cc7', '91c4aaa2d7c7dd6cd66ef63aa507c75eaaa634881e652f02b9c7337ea31f045e'] B "different traffic types, or application flows, can be mapped on top of detnet. detnet can optionally reuse header information provided by, or shared with, applications. an example of shared header fields can be found in i-d.ietf-detnet-ip." {55: 1, 90: 3, 68: 2, 84: 2} {87: 1, 37: 5, 173: 2, 373: 2, 182: 3, 181: 4, 374: 3, 53: 3} {37, 232, 173, 373, 182, 87, 181, 374, 53} 6 "The DetNet forwarding layer may be directly provided by the DetNet forwarding layer, for example by IP or MPLS. Alternatively an overlay approach may be used in which the packet is natively carried between key nodes within the DetNet network (say between PREOF nodes) and a sublayer is used to provide the information needed to reach the next hop in the overlay." "Branch for review Merge it ! Changes look good - clicking correct button this time" 215d293ca11d1a96b10664fe5db5be2326ffc8d9 215d293ca11d1a96b10664fe5db5be2326ffc8d9 draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework 5bbb61692ccc94d9f0d50e7a8ee728ae5b4c3d6441b4d1d515d4939a507af3cd ['a4c40e2a5d94a62408a33afebd53500dc73254bd15c3f1f40c39915d5c8d7e77', '5bbb61692ccc94d9f0d50e7a8ee728ae5b4c3d6441b4d1d515d4939a507af3cd', '0a21a95d3d21591097a795de075d155661aefb39903f30d3cbc9c0c8912539a8', '4cfb0cd56680c1522e69fce8424d452078f0eb25ae42663f206678ff97f0de94', '080077b619457d38c4225448a13df8b767d438a5c0d60832154eeecb05f5fc47', '42b7f0eb04cc9027a788d8aacf23bf9cdce1090e6770cf63c64bf16ebd7b186a', '0853c80510efdb5ecae37f42b545181aad0fe7b945aac3bf00a4544d4d9e0150', '719f8e9e5c42f854a1057606072b0627541bda75126a5245d94ddbf2bc08744e', 'a628ceea3891cecb967fbe79e4d50701327e32076119c479bc72a39edba9faaf', '7e7dec911c00319bad5cdf3c8c280cb53c569582e1ffb985eda6b28a10987910', '2ed740e09baffec6d02ad15665a2f0965cba2585f948d3d6f8f89571545f1b42', '3a3b30755697b8b84b4e957a75941b10a26d7684be2bb19820f593b4c40cef3c', '870363eeac69cfc2a518eb7879b0390bfabca022a2d1e3ee07d0afe1ba3b62b4', '23c22bd41ee91be2f20b9a5c46c459f4b9141ba7edae75b01f02b5e8a31aa44e', '687231a0f9396168df5ba20756e1be77542cfd33f8509725ab49f6d7c8b98675', '9512a48bee1b79f09c156aa1a835c08fdb734066df9f8b4ec678e558370a53ad', '04b2534a78e7187612148ad001c00b31f44944f83982ddbbbae3a58beb3fd06b', '71858e7d8f9c9e07448f67a7ba9b100aa687095fb2db4f32f99aff4d8a110bc6', '33cb020069591d01e5a599374d4c9070450a06b1052b7a27196c884675fa4d39', '79c51cb70fa0c71271628fddbe5f7d366b84024367517e776bdbcd3f2cbef99f', '33858cbbef2a9574bcad804cc1f70f34cd44dc691c0b8787320df7500c2f1679', '30e9bacc175aa1fc623cfaad062fb946f16a33ff5dc44760a9ff368dcc471809', '266ad13530bb69b52f9d4f397c68f056d63fd701bb6f80c8c93d14dbc6ff4714', '67bcab913606484adbdc53cdceb9a65649199b73010dee55e97b9960ac2b967d'] A "the detnet forwarding layer may be directly provided by the detnet forwarding layer, for example by ip or mpls. alternatively an overlay approach may be used in which the packet is natively carried between key nodes within the detnet network (say between preof nodes) and a sublayer is used to provide the information needed to reach the next hop in the overlay." {8: 1, 31: 1, 55: 1, 67: 1, 68: 4, 90: 2, 84: 2} {2: 1, 8: 1, 74: 1, 88: 1, 112: 1, 127: 1, 209: 1, 5: 4, 271: 2, 83: 5, 20: 4, 21: 5, 277: 4, 276: 5, 233: 2, 236: 4, 302: 2, 47: 2, 303: 5, 247: 3, 126: 2} {256, 2, 5, 8, 271, 20, 21, 277, 276, 302, 47, 303, 74, 209, 83, 88, 233, 236, 112, 247, 126, 127} 6 "This forwarding layer provides the quality underpin needed by the DetNet Service layer. It may do this directly through the use of queuing techniques and traffic engineering methods, or it may do this through the assistance of its underlying connectivity. For example it may call upon IEEE 802.1 TSN [NEEDS REFERENCE]." "Branch for review Merge it ! Changes look good - clicking correct button this time" 215d293ca11d1a96b10664fe5db5be2326ffc8d9 215d293ca11d1a96b10664fe5db5be2326ffc8d9 draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework 42b7f0eb04cc9027a788d8aacf23bf9cdce1090e6770cf63c64bf16ebd7b186a ['a4c40e2a5d94a62408a33afebd53500dc73254bd15c3f1f40c39915d5c8d7e77', '5bbb61692ccc94d9f0d50e7a8ee728ae5b4c3d6441b4d1d515d4939a507af3cd', '0a21a95d3d21591097a795de075d155661aefb39903f30d3cbc9c0c8912539a8', '4cfb0cd56680c1522e69fce8424d452078f0eb25ae42663f206678ff97f0de94', '080077b619457d38c4225448a13df8b767d438a5c0d60832154eeecb05f5fc47', '42b7f0eb04cc9027a788d8aacf23bf9cdce1090e6770cf63c64bf16ebd7b186a', '0853c80510efdb5ecae37f42b545181aad0fe7b945aac3bf00a4544d4d9e0150', '719f8e9e5c42f854a1057606072b0627541bda75126a5245d94ddbf2bc08744e', 'a628ceea3891cecb967fbe79e4d50701327e32076119c479bc72a39edba9faaf', '7e7dec911c00319bad5cdf3c8c280cb53c569582e1ffb985eda6b28a10987910', '2ed740e09baffec6d02ad15665a2f0965cba2585f948d3d6f8f89571545f1b42', '3a3b30755697b8b84b4e957a75941b10a26d7684be2bb19820f593b4c40cef3c', '870363eeac69cfc2a518eb7879b0390bfabca022a2d1e3ee07d0afe1ba3b62b4', '23c22bd41ee91be2f20b9a5c46c459f4b9141ba7edae75b01f02b5e8a31aa44e', '687231a0f9396168df5ba20756e1be77542cfd33f8509725ab49f6d7c8b98675', '9512a48bee1b79f09c156aa1a835c08fdb734066df9f8b4ec678e558370a53ad', '04b2534a78e7187612148ad001c00b31f44944f83982ddbbbae3a58beb3fd06b', '71858e7d8f9c9e07448f67a7ba9b100aa687095fb2db4f32f99aff4d8a110bc6', '33cb020069591d01e5a599374d4c9070450a06b1052b7a27196c884675fa4d39', '79c51cb70fa0c71271628fddbe5f7d366b84024367517e776bdbcd3f2cbef99f', '33858cbbef2a9574bcad804cc1f70f34cd44dc691c0b8787320df7500c2f1679', '30e9bacc175aa1fc623cfaad062fb946f16a33ff5dc44760a9ff368dcc471809', '266ad13530bb69b52f9d4f397c68f056d63fd701bb6f80c8c93d14dbc6ff4714', '67bcab913606484adbdc53cdceb9a65649199b73010dee55e97b9960ac2b967d'] A "this forwarding layer provides the quality underpin needed by the detnet service layer. it may do this directly through the use of queuing techniques and traffic engineering methods, or it may do this through the assistance of its underlying connectivity. for example it may call upon ieee 802.1 tsn [needs reference]." {8: 1, 31: 1, 55: 1, 67: 1, 68: 4, 90: 2, 84: 2} {2: 1, 8: 1, 74: 1, 88: 1, 112: 1, 127: 1, 209: 1, 5: 4, 271: 2, 83: 5, 20: 4, 21: 5, 277: 4, 276: 5, 233: 2, 236: 4, 302: 2, 47: 2, 303: 5, 247: 3, 126: 2} {256, 2, 5, 8, 271, 20, 21, 277, 276, 302, 47, 303, 74, 209, 83, 88, 233, 236, 112, 247, 126, 127} 6 "The service layer provides additional support beyond the connectivity function of the forwarding layer. An example of this is Packet Replication, Elimination, and Ordering (PREOF) function [ADD REF]." "Branch for review Merge it ! Changes look good - clicking correct button this time" 215d293ca11d1a96b10664fe5db5be2326ffc8d9 215d293ca11d1a96b10664fe5db5be2326ffc8d9 draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework 9512a48bee1b79f09c156aa1a835c08fdb734066df9f8b4ec678e558370a53ad ['a4c40e2a5d94a62408a33afebd53500dc73254bd15c3f1f40c39915d5c8d7e77', '5bbb61692ccc94d9f0d50e7a8ee728ae5b4c3d6441b4d1d515d4939a507af3cd', '0a21a95d3d21591097a795de075d155661aefb39903f30d3cbc9c0c8912539a8', '4cfb0cd56680c1522e69fce8424d452078f0eb25ae42663f206678ff97f0de94', '080077b619457d38c4225448a13df8b767d438a5c0d60832154eeecb05f5fc47', '42b7f0eb04cc9027a788d8aacf23bf9cdce1090e6770cf63c64bf16ebd7b186a', '0853c80510efdb5ecae37f42b545181aad0fe7b945aac3bf00a4544d4d9e0150', '719f8e9e5c42f854a1057606072b0627541bda75126a5245d94ddbf2bc08744e', 'a628ceea3891cecb967fbe79e4d50701327e32076119c479bc72a39edba9faaf', '7e7dec911c00319bad5cdf3c8c280cb53c569582e1ffb985eda6b28a10987910', '2ed740e09baffec6d02ad15665a2f0965cba2585f948d3d6f8f89571545f1b42', '3a3b30755697b8b84b4e957a75941b10a26d7684be2bb19820f593b4c40cef3c', '870363eeac69cfc2a518eb7879b0390bfabca022a2d1e3ee07d0afe1ba3b62b4', '23c22bd41ee91be2f20b9a5c46c459f4b9141ba7edae75b01f02b5e8a31aa44e', '687231a0f9396168df5ba20756e1be77542cfd33f8509725ab49f6d7c8b98675', '9512a48bee1b79f09c156aa1a835c08fdb734066df9f8b4ec678e558370a53ad', '04b2534a78e7187612148ad001c00b31f44944f83982ddbbbae3a58beb3fd06b', '71858e7d8f9c9e07448f67a7ba9b100aa687095fb2db4f32f99aff4d8a110bc6', '33cb020069591d01e5a599374d4c9070450a06b1052b7a27196c884675fa4d39', '79c51cb70fa0c71271628fddbe5f7d366b84024367517e776bdbcd3f2cbef99f', '33858cbbef2a9574bcad804cc1f70f34cd44dc691c0b8787320df7500c2f1679', '30e9bacc175aa1fc623cfaad062fb946f16a33ff5dc44760a9ff368dcc471809', '266ad13530bb69b52f9d4f397c68f056d63fd701bb6f80c8c93d14dbc6ff4714', '67bcab913606484adbdc53cdceb9a65649199b73010dee55e97b9960ac2b967d'] A "the service layer provides additional support beyond the connectivity function of the forwarding layer. an example of this is packet replication, elimination, and ordering (preof) function [add ref]." {8: 1, 31: 1, 55: 1, 67: 1, 68: 4, 90: 2, 84: 2} {2: 1, 8: 1, 74: 1, 88: 1, 112: 1, 127: 1, 209: 1, 5: 4, 271: 2, 83: 5, 20: 4, 21: 5, 277: 4, 276: 5, 233: 2, 236: 4, 302: 2, 47: 2, 303: 5, 247: 3, 126: 2} {256, 2, 5, 8, 271, 20, 21, 277, 276, 302, 47, 303, 74, 209, 83, 88, 233, 236, 112, 247, 126, 127} 6 "Whether the DetNet flows are carried in there native form across the DetNet network, or whether they are encapsulated." "Branch for review Merge it ! Changes look good - clicking correct button this time" 215d293ca11d1a96b10664fe5db5be2326ffc8d9 215d293ca11d1a96b10664fe5db5be2326ffc8d9 draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework 4cfb0cd56680c1522e69fce8424d452078f0eb25ae42663f206678ff97f0de94 ['a4c40e2a5d94a62408a33afebd53500dc73254bd15c3f1f40c39915d5c8d7e77', '5bbb61692ccc94d9f0d50e7a8ee728ae5b4c3d6441b4d1d515d4939a507af3cd', '0a21a95d3d21591097a795de075d155661aefb39903f30d3cbc9c0c8912539a8', '4cfb0cd56680c1522e69fce8424d452078f0eb25ae42663f206678ff97f0de94', '080077b619457d38c4225448a13df8b767d438a5c0d60832154eeecb05f5fc47', '42b7f0eb04cc9027a788d8aacf23bf9cdce1090e6770cf63c64bf16ebd7b186a', '0853c80510efdb5ecae37f42b545181aad0fe7b945aac3bf00a4544d4d9e0150', '719f8e9e5c42f854a1057606072b0627541bda75126a5245d94ddbf2bc08744e', 'a628ceea3891cecb967fbe79e4d50701327e32076119c479bc72a39edba9faaf', '7e7dec911c00319bad5cdf3c8c280cb53c569582e1ffb985eda6b28a10987910', '2ed740e09baffec6d02ad15665a2f0965cba2585f948d3d6f8f89571545f1b42', '3a3b30755697b8b84b4e957a75941b10a26d7684be2bb19820f593b4c40cef3c', '870363eeac69cfc2a518eb7879b0390bfabca022a2d1e3ee07d0afe1ba3b62b4', '23c22bd41ee91be2f20b9a5c46c459f4b9141ba7edae75b01f02b5e8a31aa44e', '687231a0f9396168df5ba20756e1be77542cfd33f8509725ab49f6d7c8b98675', '9512a48bee1b79f09c156aa1a835c08fdb734066df9f8b4ec678e558370a53ad', '04b2534a78e7187612148ad001c00b31f44944f83982ddbbbae3a58beb3fd06b', '71858e7d8f9c9e07448f67a7ba9b100aa687095fb2db4f32f99aff4d8a110bc6', '33cb020069591d01e5a599374d4c9070450a06b1052b7a27196c884675fa4d39', '79c51cb70fa0c71271628fddbe5f7d366b84024367517e776bdbcd3f2cbef99f', '33858cbbef2a9574bcad804cc1f70f34cd44dc691c0b8787320df7500c2f1679', '30e9bacc175aa1fc623cfaad062fb946f16a33ff5dc44760a9ff368dcc471809', '266ad13530bb69b52f9d4f397c68f056d63fd701bb6f80c8c93d14dbc6ff4714', '67bcab913606484adbdc53cdceb9a65649199b73010dee55e97b9960ac2b967d'] A "whether the detnet flows are carried in there native form across the detnet network, or whether they are encapsulated." {8: 1, 31: 1, 55: 1, 67: 1, 68: 4, 90: 2, 84: 2} {2: 1, 8: 1, 74: 1, 88: 1, 112: 1, 127: 1, 209: 1, 5: 4, 271: 2, 83: 5, 20: 4, 21: 5, 277: 4, 276: 5, 233: 2, 236: 4, 302: 2, 47: 2, 303: 5, 247: 3, 126: 2} {256, 2, 5, 8, 271, 20, 21, 277, 276, 302, 47, 303, 74, 209, 83, 88, 233, 236, 112, 247, 126, 127} 6 "Whether or not the DetNet data plane incudes the facility to carry additional information (metadata) that can be used to provide an enhanced service to the DetNet packet." "Branch for review Merge it ! Changes look good - clicking correct button this time" 215d293ca11d1a96b10664fe5db5be2326ffc8d9 215d293ca11d1a96b10664fe5db5be2326ffc8d9 draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework a628ceea3891cecb967fbe79e4d50701327e32076119c479bc72a39edba9faaf ['a4c40e2a5d94a62408a33afebd53500dc73254bd15c3f1f40c39915d5c8d7e77', '5bbb61692ccc94d9f0d50e7a8ee728ae5b4c3d6441b4d1d515d4939a507af3cd', '0a21a95d3d21591097a795de075d155661aefb39903f30d3cbc9c0c8912539a8', '4cfb0cd56680c1522e69fce8424d452078f0eb25ae42663f206678ff97f0de94', '080077b619457d38c4225448a13df8b767d438a5c0d60832154eeecb05f5fc47', '42b7f0eb04cc9027a788d8aacf23bf9cdce1090e6770cf63c64bf16ebd7b186a', '0853c80510efdb5ecae37f42b545181aad0fe7b945aac3bf00a4544d4d9e0150', '719f8e9e5c42f854a1057606072b0627541bda75126a5245d94ddbf2bc08744e', 'a628ceea3891cecb967fbe79e4d50701327e32076119c479bc72a39edba9faaf', '7e7dec911c00319bad5cdf3c8c280cb53c569582e1ffb985eda6b28a10987910', '2ed740e09baffec6d02ad15665a2f0965cba2585f948d3d6f8f89571545f1b42', '3a3b30755697b8b84b4e957a75941b10a26d7684be2bb19820f593b4c40cef3c', '870363eeac69cfc2a518eb7879b0390bfabca022a2d1e3ee07d0afe1ba3b62b4', '23c22bd41ee91be2f20b9a5c46c459f4b9141ba7edae75b01f02b5e8a31aa44e', '687231a0f9396168df5ba20756e1be77542cfd33f8509725ab49f6d7c8b98675', '9512a48bee1b79f09c156aa1a835c08fdb734066df9f8b4ec678e558370a53ad', '04b2534a78e7187612148ad001c00b31f44944f83982ddbbbae3a58beb3fd06b', '71858e7d8f9c9e07448f67a7ba9b100aa687095fb2db4f32f99aff4d8a110bc6', '33cb020069591d01e5a599374d4c9070450a06b1052b7a27196c884675fa4d39', '79c51cb70fa0c71271628fddbe5f7d366b84024367517e776bdbcd3f2cbef99f', '33858cbbef2a9574bcad804cc1f70f34cd44dc691c0b8787320df7500c2f1679', '30e9bacc175aa1fc623cfaad062fb946f16a33ff5dc44760a9ff368dcc471809', '266ad13530bb69b52f9d4f397c68f056d63fd701bb6f80c8c93d14dbc6ff4714', '67bcab913606484adbdc53cdceb9a65649199b73010dee55e97b9960ac2b967d'] A "whether or not the detnet data plane incudes the facility to carry additional information (metadata) that can be used to provide an enhanced service to the detnet packet." {8: 1, 31: 1, 55: 1, 67: 1, 68: 4, 90: 2, 84: 2} {2: 1, 8: 1, 74: 1, 88: 1, 112: 1, 127: 1, 209: 1, 5: 4, 271: 2, 83: 5, 20: 4, 21: 5, 277: 4, 276: 5, 233: 2, 236: 4, 302: 2, 47: 2, 303: 5, 247: 3, 126: 2} {256, 2, 5, 8, 271, 20, 21, 277, 276, 302, 47, 303, 74, 209, 83, 88, 233, 236, 112, 247, 126, 127} 6 "The encapsulation of the DetNet flows allows them to be sent over a data plane of a type other than their native type. Encapsulation is essential if, for example, it is required to sent Ethernet DetNet flows over a data plane such as MPLS." "Branch for review Merge it ! Changes look good - clicking correct button this time" 215d293ca11d1a96b10664fe5db5be2326ffc8d9 215d293ca11d1a96b10664fe5db5be2326ffc8d9 draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework 870363eeac69cfc2a518eb7879b0390bfabca022a2d1e3ee07d0afe1ba3b62b4 ['a4c40e2a5d94a62408a33afebd53500dc73254bd15c3f1f40c39915d5c8d7e77', '5bbb61692ccc94d9f0d50e7a8ee728ae5b4c3d6441b4d1d515d4939a507af3cd', '0a21a95d3d21591097a795de075d155661aefb39903f30d3cbc9c0c8912539a8', '4cfb0cd56680c1522e69fce8424d452078f0eb25ae42663f206678ff97f0de94', '080077b619457d38c4225448a13df8b767d438a5c0d60832154eeecb05f5fc47', '42b7f0eb04cc9027a788d8aacf23bf9cdce1090e6770cf63c64bf16ebd7b186a', '0853c80510efdb5ecae37f42b545181aad0fe7b945aac3bf00a4544d4d9e0150', '719f8e9e5c42f854a1057606072b0627541bda75126a5245d94ddbf2bc08744e', 'a628ceea3891cecb967fbe79e4d50701327e32076119c479bc72a39edba9faaf', '7e7dec911c00319bad5cdf3c8c280cb53c569582e1ffb985eda6b28a10987910', '2ed740e09baffec6d02ad15665a2f0965cba2585f948d3d6f8f89571545f1b42', '3a3b30755697b8b84b4e957a75941b10a26d7684be2bb19820f593b4c40cef3c', '870363eeac69cfc2a518eb7879b0390bfabca022a2d1e3ee07d0afe1ba3b62b4', '23c22bd41ee91be2f20b9a5c46c459f4b9141ba7edae75b01f02b5e8a31aa44e', '687231a0f9396168df5ba20756e1be77542cfd33f8509725ab49f6d7c8b98675', '9512a48bee1b79f09c156aa1a835c08fdb734066df9f8b4ec678e558370a53ad', '04b2534a78e7187612148ad001c00b31f44944f83982ddbbbae3a58beb3fd06b', '71858e7d8f9c9e07448f67a7ba9b100aa687095fb2db4f32f99aff4d8a110bc6', '33cb020069591d01e5a599374d4c9070450a06b1052b7a27196c884675fa4d39', '79c51cb70fa0c71271628fddbe5f7d366b84024367517e776bdbcd3f2cbef99f', '33858cbbef2a9574bcad804cc1f70f34cd44dc691c0b8787320df7500c2f1679', '30e9bacc175aa1fc623cfaad062fb946f16a33ff5dc44760a9ff368dcc471809', '266ad13530bb69b52f9d4f397c68f056d63fd701bb6f80c8c93d14dbc6ff4714', '67bcab913606484adbdc53cdceb9a65649199b73010dee55e97b9960ac2b967d'] A "the encapsulation of the detnet flows allows them to be sent over a data plane of a type other than their native type. encapsulation is essential if, for example, it is required to sent ethernet detnet flows over a data plane such as mpls." {8: 1, 31: 1, 55: 1, 67: 1, 68: 4, 90: 2, 84: 2} {2: 1, 8: 1, 74: 1, 88: 1, 112: 1, 127: 1, 209: 1, 5: 4, 271: 2, 83: 5, 20: 4, 21: 5, 277: 4, 276: 5, 233: 2, 236: 4, 302: 2, 47: 2, 303: 5, 247: 3, 126: 2} {256, 2, 5, 8, 271, 20, 21, 277, 276, 302, 47, 303, 74, 209, 83, 88, 233, 236, 112, 247, 126, 127} 6 "The use of encapsulation is also required if additional information (meta-data) is needed by the DetNet data plane and their is either no ability to include it in the client data packet, or the specification of the client data plane do not permit the modification of the packet to include additional data. An example of such meta-data is the inclusion of a sequence number required by the PREOF function." "Branch for review Merge it ! Changes look good - clicking correct button this time" 215d293ca11d1a96b10664fe5db5be2326ffc8d9 215d293ca11d1a96b10664fe5db5be2326ffc8d9 draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework 67bcab913606484adbdc53cdceb9a65649199b73010dee55e97b9960ac2b967d ['a4c40e2a5d94a62408a33afebd53500dc73254bd15c3f1f40c39915d5c8d7e77', '5bbb61692ccc94d9f0d50e7a8ee728ae5b4c3d6441b4d1d515d4939a507af3cd', '0a21a95d3d21591097a795de075d155661aefb39903f30d3cbc9c0c8912539a8', '4cfb0cd56680c1522e69fce8424d452078f0eb25ae42663f206678ff97f0de94', '080077b619457d38c4225448a13df8b767d438a5c0d60832154eeecb05f5fc47', '42b7f0eb04cc9027a788d8aacf23bf9cdce1090e6770cf63c64bf16ebd7b186a', '0853c80510efdb5ecae37f42b545181aad0fe7b945aac3bf00a4544d4d9e0150', '719f8e9e5c42f854a1057606072b0627541bda75126a5245d94ddbf2bc08744e', 'a628ceea3891cecb967fbe79e4d50701327e32076119c479bc72a39edba9faaf', '7e7dec911c00319bad5cdf3c8c280cb53c569582e1ffb985eda6b28a10987910', '2ed740e09baffec6d02ad15665a2f0965cba2585f948d3d6f8f89571545f1b42', '3a3b30755697b8b84b4e957a75941b10a26d7684be2bb19820f593b4c40cef3c', '870363eeac69cfc2a518eb7879b0390bfabca022a2d1e3ee07d0afe1ba3b62b4', '23c22bd41ee91be2f20b9a5c46c459f4b9141ba7edae75b01f02b5e8a31aa44e', '687231a0f9396168df5ba20756e1be77542cfd33f8509725ab49f6d7c8b98675', '9512a48bee1b79f09c156aa1a835c08fdb734066df9f8b4ec678e558370a53ad', '04b2534a78e7187612148ad001c00b31f44944f83982ddbbbae3a58beb3fd06b', '71858e7d8f9c9e07448f67a7ba9b100aa687095fb2db4f32f99aff4d8a110bc6', '33cb020069591d01e5a599374d4c9070450a06b1052b7a27196c884675fa4d39', '79c51cb70fa0c71271628fddbe5f7d366b84024367517e776bdbcd3f2cbef99f', '33858cbbef2a9574bcad804cc1f70f34cd44dc691c0b8787320df7500c2f1679', '30e9bacc175aa1fc623cfaad062fb946f16a33ff5dc44760a9ff368dcc471809', '266ad13530bb69b52f9d4f397c68f056d63fd701bb6f80c8c93d14dbc6ff4714', '67bcab913606484adbdc53cdceb9a65649199b73010dee55e97b9960ac2b967d'] A "the use of encapsulation is also required if additional information (meta-data) is needed by the detnet data plane and their is either no ability to include it in the client data packet, or the specification of the client data plane do not permit the modification of the packet to include additional data. an example of such meta-data is the inclusion of a sequence number required by the preof function." {8: 1, 31: 1, 55: 1, 67: 1, 68: 4, 90: 2, 84: 2} {2: 1, 8: 1, 74: 1, 88: 1, 112: 1, 127: 1, 209: 1, 5: 4, 271: 2, 83: 5, 20: 4, 21: 5, 277: 4, 276: 5, 233: 2, 236: 4, 302: 2, 47: 2, 303: 5, 247: 3, 126: 2} {256, 2, 5, 8, 271, 20, 21, 277, 276, 302, 47, 303, 74, 209, 83, 88, 233, 236, 112, 247, 126, 127} 6 "Encalsulation is also needed if the DetNet flow or agregate flow is not easily recognised from from its native encapsulation." "Branch for review Merge it ! Changes look good - clicking correct button this time" 215d293ca11d1a96b10664fe5db5be2326ffc8d9 215d293ca11d1a96b10664fe5db5be2326ffc8d9 draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework 30e9bacc175aa1fc623cfaad062fb946f16a33ff5dc44760a9ff368dcc471809 ['a4c40e2a5d94a62408a33afebd53500dc73254bd15c3f1f40c39915d5c8d7e77', '5bbb61692ccc94d9f0d50e7a8ee728ae5b4c3d6441b4d1d515d4939a507af3cd', '0a21a95d3d21591097a795de075d155661aefb39903f30d3cbc9c0c8912539a8', '4cfb0cd56680c1522e69fce8424d452078f0eb25ae42663f206678ff97f0de94', '080077b619457d38c4225448a13df8b767d438a5c0d60832154eeecb05f5fc47', '42b7f0eb04cc9027a788d8aacf23bf9cdce1090e6770cf63c64bf16ebd7b186a', '0853c80510efdb5ecae37f42b545181aad0fe7b945aac3bf00a4544d4d9e0150', '719f8e9e5c42f854a1057606072b0627541bda75126a5245d94ddbf2bc08744e', 'a628ceea3891cecb967fbe79e4d50701327e32076119c479bc72a39edba9faaf', '7e7dec911c00319bad5cdf3c8c280cb53c569582e1ffb985eda6b28a10987910', '2ed740e09baffec6d02ad15665a2f0965cba2585f948d3d6f8f89571545f1b42', '3a3b30755697b8b84b4e957a75941b10a26d7684be2bb19820f593b4c40cef3c', '870363eeac69cfc2a518eb7879b0390bfabca022a2d1e3ee07d0afe1ba3b62b4', '23c22bd41ee91be2f20b9a5c46c459f4b9141ba7edae75b01f02b5e8a31aa44e', '687231a0f9396168df5ba20756e1be77542cfd33f8509725ab49f6d7c8b98675', '9512a48bee1b79f09c156aa1a835c08fdb734066df9f8b4ec678e558370a53ad', '04b2534a78e7187612148ad001c00b31f44944f83982ddbbbae3a58beb3fd06b', '71858e7d8f9c9e07448f67a7ba9b100aa687095fb2db4f32f99aff4d8a110bc6', '33cb020069591d01e5a599374d4c9070450a06b1052b7a27196c884675fa4d39', '79c51cb70fa0c71271628fddbe5f7d366b84024367517e776bdbcd3f2cbef99f', '33858cbbef2a9574bcad804cc1f70f34cd44dc691c0b8787320df7500c2f1679', '30e9bacc175aa1fc623cfaad062fb946f16a33ff5dc44760a9ff368dcc471809', '266ad13530bb69b52f9d4f397c68f056d63fd701bb6f80c8c93d14dbc6ff4714', '67bcab913606484adbdc53cdceb9a65649199b73010dee55e97b9960ac2b967d'] A "encalsulation is also needed if the detnet flow or agregate flow is not easily recognised from from its native encapsulation." {8: 1, 31: 1, 55: 1, 67: 1, 68: 4, 90: 2, 84: 2} {2: 1, 8: 1, 74: 1, 88: 1, 112: 1, 127: 1, 209: 1, 5: 4, 271: 2, 83: 5, 20: 4, 21: 5, 277: 4, 276: 5, 233: 2, 236: 4, 302: 2, 47: 2, 303: 5, 247: 3, 126: 2} {256, 2, 5, 8, 271, 20, 21, 277, 276, 302, 47, 303, 74, 209, 83, 88, 233, 236, 112, 247, 126, 127} 6 "Metadata can be a useful way of identifying packets that need to be treated as a flow or flow agregate. It is also useful as a way of including a sequence number the packet for use by the PREOF function or as a place to carry OAM indications or OAM information to instrument DetNet data plane operation." "Branch for review Merge it ! Changes look good - clicking correct button this time" 215d293ca11d1a96b10664fe5db5be2326ffc8d9 215d293ca11d1a96b10664fe5db5be2326ffc8d9 draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework 687231a0f9396168df5ba20756e1be77542cfd33f8509725ab49f6d7c8b98675 ['a4c40e2a5d94a62408a33afebd53500dc73254bd15c3f1f40c39915d5c8d7e77', '5bbb61692ccc94d9f0d50e7a8ee728ae5b4c3d6441b4d1d515d4939a507af3cd', '0a21a95d3d21591097a795de075d155661aefb39903f30d3cbc9c0c8912539a8', '4cfb0cd56680c1522e69fce8424d452078f0eb25ae42663f206678ff97f0de94', '080077b619457d38c4225448a13df8b767d438a5c0d60832154eeecb05f5fc47', '42b7f0eb04cc9027a788d8aacf23bf9cdce1090e6770cf63c64bf16ebd7b186a', '0853c80510efdb5ecae37f42b545181aad0fe7b945aac3bf00a4544d4d9e0150', '719f8e9e5c42f854a1057606072b0627541bda75126a5245d94ddbf2bc08744e', 'a628ceea3891cecb967fbe79e4d50701327e32076119c479bc72a39edba9faaf', '7e7dec911c00319bad5cdf3c8c280cb53c569582e1ffb985eda6b28a10987910', '2ed740e09baffec6d02ad15665a2f0965cba2585f948d3d6f8f89571545f1b42', '3a3b30755697b8b84b4e957a75941b10a26d7684be2bb19820f593b4c40cef3c', '870363eeac69cfc2a518eb7879b0390bfabca022a2d1e3ee07d0afe1ba3b62b4', '23c22bd41ee91be2f20b9a5c46c459f4b9141ba7edae75b01f02b5e8a31aa44e', '687231a0f9396168df5ba20756e1be77542cfd33f8509725ab49f6d7c8b98675', '9512a48bee1b79f09c156aa1a835c08fdb734066df9f8b4ec678e558370a53ad', '04b2534a78e7187612148ad001c00b31f44944f83982ddbbbae3a58beb3fd06b', '71858e7d8f9c9e07448f67a7ba9b100aa687095fb2db4f32f99aff4d8a110bc6', '33cb020069591d01e5a599374d4c9070450a06b1052b7a27196c884675fa4d39', '79c51cb70fa0c71271628fddbe5f7d366b84024367517e776bdbcd3f2cbef99f', '33858cbbef2a9574bcad804cc1f70f34cd44dc691c0b8787320df7500c2f1679', '30e9bacc175aa1fc623cfaad062fb946f16a33ff5dc44760a9ff368dcc471809', '266ad13530bb69b52f9d4f397c68f056d63fd701bb6f80c8c93d14dbc6ff4714', '67bcab913606484adbdc53cdceb9a65649199b73010dee55e97b9960ac2b967d'] A "metadata can be a useful way of identifying packets that need to be treated as a flow or flow agregate. it is also useful as a way of including a sequence number the packet for use by the preof function or as a place to carry oam indications or oam information to instrument detnet data plane operation." {8: 1, 31: 1, 55: 1, 67: 1, 68: 4, 90: 2, 84: 2} {2: 1, 8: 1, 74: 1, 88: 1, 112: 1, 127: 1, 209: 1, 5: 4, 271: 2, 83: 5, 20: 4, 21: 5, 277: 4, 276: 5, 233: 2, 236: 4, 302: 2, 47: 2, 303: 5, 247: 3, 126: 2} {256, 2, 5, 8, 271, 20, 21, 277, 276, 302, 47, 303, 74, 209, 83, 88, 233, 236, 112, 247, 126, 127} 6 "An IP data plane may operate natively or through the use of an encapsulation. There are many IP encapsulations that may be interposed between the DetNet data plane IP header and the DetNet payload, and it is anticipated that more than one encapulation may be deployed." "Branch for review Merge it ! Changes look good - clicking correct button this time" 215d293ca11d1a96b10664fe5db5be2326ffc8d9 215d293ca11d1a96b10664fe5db5be2326ffc8d9 draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework 7e7dec911c00319bad5cdf3c8c280cb53c569582e1ffb985eda6b28a10987910 ['a4c40e2a5d94a62408a33afebd53500dc73254bd15c3f1f40c39915d5c8d7e77', '5bbb61692ccc94d9f0d50e7a8ee728ae5b4c3d6441b4d1d515d4939a507af3cd', '0a21a95d3d21591097a795de075d155661aefb39903f30d3cbc9c0c8912539a8', '4cfb0cd56680c1522e69fce8424d452078f0eb25ae42663f206678ff97f0de94', '080077b619457d38c4225448a13df8b767d438a5c0d60832154eeecb05f5fc47', '42b7f0eb04cc9027a788d8aacf23bf9cdce1090e6770cf63c64bf16ebd7b186a', '0853c80510efdb5ecae37f42b545181aad0fe7b945aac3bf00a4544d4d9e0150', '719f8e9e5c42f854a1057606072b0627541bda75126a5245d94ddbf2bc08744e', 'a628ceea3891cecb967fbe79e4d50701327e32076119c479bc72a39edba9faaf', '7e7dec911c00319bad5cdf3c8c280cb53c569582e1ffb985eda6b28a10987910', '2ed740e09baffec6d02ad15665a2f0965cba2585f948d3d6f8f89571545f1b42', '3a3b30755697b8b84b4e957a75941b10a26d7684be2bb19820f593b4c40cef3c', '870363eeac69cfc2a518eb7879b0390bfabca022a2d1e3ee07d0afe1ba3b62b4', '23c22bd41ee91be2f20b9a5c46c459f4b9141ba7edae75b01f02b5e8a31aa44e', '687231a0f9396168df5ba20756e1be77542cfd33f8509725ab49f6d7c8b98675', '9512a48bee1b79f09c156aa1a835c08fdb734066df9f8b4ec678e558370a53ad', '04b2534a78e7187612148ad001c00b31f44944f83982ddbbbae3a58beb3fd06b', '71858e7d8f9c9e07448f67a7ba9b100aa687095fb2db4f32f99aff4d8a110bc6', '33cb020069591d01e5a599374d4c9070450a06b1052b7a27196c884675fa4d39', '79c51cb70fa0c71271628fddbe5f7d366b84024367517e776bdbcd3f2cbef99f', '33858cbbef2a9574bcad804cc1f70f34cd44dc691c0b8787320df7500c2f1679', '30e9bacc175aa1fc623cfaad062fb946f16a33ff5dc44760a9ff368dcc471809', '266ad13530bb69b52f9d4f397c68f056d63fd701bb6f80c8c93d14dbc6ff4714', '67bcab913606484adbdc53cdceb9a65649199b73010dee55e97b9960ac2b967d'] A "an ip data plane may operate natively or through the use of an encapsulation. there are many ip encapsulations that may be interposed between the detnet data plane ip header and the detnet payload, and it is anticipated that more than one encapulation may be deployed." {8: 1, 31: 1, 55: 1, 67: 1, 68: 4, 90: 2, 84: 2} {2: 1, 8: 1, 74: 1, 88: 1, 112: 1, 127: 1, 209: 1, 5: 4, 271: 2, 83: 5, 20: 4, 21: 5, 277: 4, 276: 5, 233: 2, 236: 4, 302: 2, 47: 2, 303: 5, 247: 3, 126: 2} {256, 2, 5, 8, 271, 20, 21, 277, 276, 302, 47, 303, 74, 209, 83, 88, 233, 236, 112, 247, 126, 127} 6 "ProtStack1 reproduced from the I-D.ietf-detnet-architecture,shows a logical DetNet service with the two sub-layers." "Branch for review Merge it ! Changes look good - clicking correct button this time" 215d293ca11d1a96b10664fe5db5be2326ffc8d9 215d293ca11d1a96b10664fe5db5be2326ffc8d9 draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework 719f8e9e5c42f854a1057606072b0627541bda75126a5245d94ddbf2bc08744e ['a4c40e2a5d94a62408a33afebd53500dc73254bd15c3f1f40c39915d5c8d7e77', '5bbb61692ccc94d9f0d50e7a8ee728ae5b4c3d6441b4d1d515d4939a507af3cd', '0a21a95d3d21591097a795de075d155661aefb39903f30d3cbc9c0c8912539a8', '4cfb0cd56680c1522e69fce8424d452078f0eb25ae42663f206678ff97f0de94', '080077b619457d38c4225448a13df8b767d438a5c0d60832154eeecb05f5fc47', '42b7f0eb04cc9027a788d8aacf23bf9cdce1090e6770cf63c64bf16ebd7b186a', '0853c80510efdb5ecae37f42b545181aad0fe7b945aac3bf00a4544d4d9e0150', '719f8e9e5c42f854a1057606072b0627541bda75126a5245d94ddbf2bc08744e', 'a628ceea3891cecb967fbe79e4d50701327e32076119c479bc72a39edba9faaf', '7e7dec911c00319bad5cdf3c8c280cb53c569582e1ffb985eda6b28a10987910', '2ed740e09baffec6d02ad15665a2f0965cba2585f948d3d6f8f89571545f1b42', '3a3b30755697b8b84b4e957a75941b10a26d7684be2bb19820f593b4c40cef3c', '870363eeac69cfc2a518eb7879b0390bfabca022a2d1e3ee07d0afe1ba3b62b4', '23c22bd41ee91be2f20b9a5c46c459f4b9141ba7edae75b01f02b5e8a31aa44e', '687231a0f9396168df5ba20756e1be77542cfd33f8509725ab49f6d7c8b98675', '9512a48bee1b79f09c156aa1a835c08fdb734066df9f8b4ec678e558370a53ad', '04b2534a78e7187612148ad001c00b31f44944f83982ddbbbae3a58beb3fd06b', '71858e7d8f9c9e07448f67a7ba9b100aa687095fb2db4f32f99aff4d8a110bc6', '33cb020069591d01e5a599374d4c9070450a06b1052b7a27196c884675fa4d39', '79c51cb70fa0c71271628fddbe5f7d366b84024367517e776bdbcd3f2cbef99f', '33858cbbef2a9574bcad804cc1f70f34cd44dc691c0b8787320df7500c2f1679', '30e9bacc175aa1fc623cfaad062fb946f16a33ff5dc44760a9ff368dcc471809', '266ad13530bb69b52f9d4f397c68f056d63fd701bb6f80c8c93d14dbc6ff4714', '67bcab913606484adbdc53cdceb9a65649199b73010dee55e97b9960ac2b967d'] B "protstack1 reproduced from the i-d.ietf-detnet-architecture,shows a logical detnet service with the two sub-layers." {8: 1, 31: 1, 55: 1, 67: 1, 68: 4, 90: 2, 84: 2} {2: 1, 8: 1, 74: 1, 88: 1, 112: 1, 127: 1, 209: 1, 5: 4, 271: 2, 83: 5, 20: 4, 21: 5, 277: 4, 276: 5, 233: 2, 236: 4, 302: 2, 47: 2, 303: 5, 247: 3, 126: 2} {256, 2, 5, 8, 271, 20, 21, 277, 276, 302, 47, 303, 74, 209, 83, 88, 233, 236, 112, 247, 126, 127} 6 "The DetNet forwarding sub-layer may be directly provided by the DetNet service layer, for example by IP, MPLS or IEEE 802.1 TSN IEEE802.1TSNTG. Alternatively an overlay approach may be used in which the packet is natively carried between key nodes within the DetNet network (say between PREOF nodes) and a sublayer is used to provide the information needed to reach the next hop in the overlay." "Branch for review Merge it ! Changes look good - clicking correct button this time" 215d293ca11d1a96b10664fe5db5be2326ffc8d9 215d293ca11d1a96b10664fe5db5be2326ffc8d9 draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework 33858cbbef2a9574bcad804cc1f70f34cd44dc691c0b8787320df7500c2f1679 ['a4c40e2a5d94a62408a33afebd53500dc73254bd15c3f1f40c39915d5c8d7e77', '5bbb61692ccc94d9f0d50e7a8ee728ae5b4c3d6441b4d1d515d4939a507af3cd', '0a21a95d3d21591097a795de075d155661aefb39903f30d3cbc9c0c8912539a8', '4cfb0cd56680c1522e69fce8424d452078f0eb25ae42663f206678ff97f0de94', '080077b619457d38c4225448a13df8b767d438a5c0d60832154eeecb05f5fc47', '42b7f0eb04cc9027a788d8aacf23bf9cdce1090e6770cf63c64bf16ebd7b186a', '0853c80510efdb5ecae37f42b545181aad0fe7b945aac3bf00a4544d4d9e0150', '719f8e9e5c42f854a1057606072b0627541bda75126a5245d94ddbf2bc08744e', 'a628ceea3891cecb967fbe79e4d50701327e32076119c479bc72a39edba9faaf', '7e7dec911c00319bad5cdf3c8c280cb53c569582e1ffb985eda6b28a10987910', '2ed740e09baffec6d02ad15665a2f0965cba2585f948d3d6f8f89571545f1b42', '3a3b30755697b8b84b4e957a75941b10a26d7684be2bb19820f593b4c40cef3c', '870363eeac69cfc2a518eb7879b0390bfabca022a2d1e3ee07d0afe1ba3b62b4', '23c22bd41ee91be2f20b9a5c46c459f4b9141ba7edae75b01f02b5e8a31aa44e', '687231a0f9396168df5ba20756e1be77542cfd33f8509725ab49f6d7c8b98675', '9512a48bee1b79f09c156aa1a835c08fdb734066df9f8b4ec678e558370a53ad', '04b2534a78e7187612148ad001c00b31f44944f83982ddbbbae3a58beb3fd06b', '71858e7d8f9c9e07448f67a7ba9b100aa687095fb2db4f32f99aff4d8a110bc6', '33cb020069591d01e5a599374d4c9070450a06b1052b7a27196c884675fa4d39', '79c51cb70fa0c71271628fddbe5f7d366b84024367517e776bdbcd3f2cbef99f', '33858cbbef2a9574bcad804cc1f70f34cd44dc691c0b8787320df7500c2f1679', '30e9bacc175aa1fc623cfaad062fb946f16a33ff5dc44760a9ff368dcc471809', '266ad13530bb69b52f9d4f397c68f056d63fd701bb6f80c8c93d14dbc6ff4714', '67bcab913606484adbdc53cdceb9a65649199b73010dee55e97b9960ac2b967d'] B "the detnet forwarding sub-layer may be directly provided by the detnet service layer, for example by ip, mpls or ieee 802.1 tsn ieee802.1tsntg. alternatively an overlay approach may be used in which the packet is natively carried between key nodes within the detnet network (say between preof nodes) and a sublayer is used to provide the information needed to reach the next hop in the overlay." {8: 1, 31: 1, 55: 1, 67: 1, 68: 4, 90: 2, 84: 2} {2: 1, 8: 1, 74: 1, 88: 1, 112: 1, 127: 1, 209: 1, 5: 4, 271: 2, 83: 5, 20: 4, 21: 5, 277: 4, 276: 5, 233: 2, 236: 4, 302: 2, 47: 2, 303: 5, 247: 3, 126: 2} {256, 2, 5, 8, 271, 20, 21, 277, 276, 302, 47, 303, 74, 209, 83, 88, 233, 236, 112, 247, 126, 127} 6 "This forwarding layer provides the quality underpin needed by the DetNet Service layer. It may do this directly through the use of queuing techniques and traffic engineering methods, or it may do this through the assistance of its underlying connectivity. For example it may call upon Ethernet TSN capabilities defined in IEEE 802.1 TSN IEEE802.1TSNTG." "Branch for review Merge it ! Changes look good - clicking correct button this time" 215d293ca11d1a96b10664fe5db5be2326ffc8d9 215d293ca11d1a96b10664fe5db5be2326ffc8d9 draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework 0a21a95d3d21591097a795de075d155661aefb39903f30d3cbc9c0c8912539a8 ['a4c40e2a5d94a62408a33afebd53500dc73254bd15c3f1f40c39915d5c8d7e77', '5bbb61692ccc94d9f0d50e7a8ee728ae5b4c3d6441b4d1d515d4939a507af3cd', '0a21a95d3d21591097a795de075d155661aefb39903f30d3cbc9c0c8912539a8', '4cfb0cd56680c1522e69fce8424d452078f0eb25ae42663f206678ff97f0de94', '080077b619457d38c4225448a13df8b767d438a5c0d60832154eeecb05f5fc47', '42b7f0eb04cc9027a788d8aacf23bf9cdce1090e6770cf63c64bf16ebd7b186a', '0853c80510efdb5ecae37f42b545181aad0fe7b945aac3bf00a4544d4d9e0150', '719f8e9e5c42f854a1057606072b0627541bda75126a5245d94ddbf2bc08744e', 'a628ceea3891cecb967fbe79e4d50701327e32076119c479bc72a39edba9faaf', '7e7dec911c00319bad5cdf3c8c280cb53c569582e1ffb985eda6b28a10987910', '2ed740e09baffec6d02ad15665a2f0965cba2585f948d3d6f8f89571545f1b42', '3a3b30755697b8b84b4e957a75941b10a26d7684be2bb19820f593b4c40cef3c', '870363eeac69cfc2a518eb7879b0390bfabca022a2d1e3ee07d0afe1ba3b62b4', '23c22bd41ee91be2f20b9a5c46c459f4b9141ba7edae75b01f02b5e8a31aa44e', '687231a0f9396168df5ba20756e1be77542cfd33f8509725ab49f6d7c8b98675', '9512a48bee1b79f09c156aa1a835c08fdb734066df9f8b4ec678e558370a53ad', '04b2534a78e7187612148ad001c00b31f44944f83982ddbbbae3a58beb3fd06b', '71858e7d8f9c9e07448f67a7ba9b100aa687095fb2db4f32f99aff4d8a110bc6', '33cb020069591d01e5a599374d4c9070450a06b1052b7a27196c884675fa4d39', '79c51cb70fa0c71271628fddbe5f7d366b84024367517e776bdbcd3f2cbef99f', '33858cbbef2a9574bcad804cc1f70f34cd44dc691c0b8787320df7500c2f1679', '30e9bacc175aa1fc623cfaad062fb946f16a33ff5dc44760a9ff368dcc471809', '266ad13530bb69b52f9d4f397c68f056d63fd701bb6f80c8c93d14dbc6ff4714', '67bcab913606484adbdc53cdceb9a65649199b73010dee55e97b9960ac2b967d'] B "this forwarding layer provides the quality underpin needed by the detnet service layer. it may do this directly through the use of queuing techniques and traffic engineering methods, or it may do this through the assistance of its underlying connectivity. for example it may call upon ethernet tsn capabilities defined in ieee 802.1 tsn ieee802.1tsntg." {8: 1, 31: 1, 55: 1, 67: 1, 68: 4, 90: 2, 84: 2} {2: 1, 8: 1, 74: 1, 88: 1, 112: 1, 127: 1, 209: 1, 5: 4, 271: 2, 83: 5, 20: 4, 21: 5, 277: 4, 276: 5, 233: 2, 236: 4, 302: 2, 47: 2, 303: 5, 247: 3, 126: 2} {256, 2, 5, 8, 271, 20, 21, 277, 276, 302, 47, 303, 74, 209, 83, 88, 233, 236, 112, 247, 126, 127} 6 "The service layer provides additional support beyond the connectivity function of the forwarding layer. An example of this is Packet Replication, Elimination, and Ordering (PREOF) function see PREOF." "Branch for review Merge it ! Changes look good - clicking correct button this time" 215d293ca11d1a96b10664fe5db5be2326ffc8d9 215d293ca11d1a96b10664fe5db5be2326ffc8d9 draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework 33cb020069591d01e5a599374d4c9070450a06b1052b7a27196c884675fa4d39 ['a4c40e2a5d94a62408a33afebd53500dc73254bd15c3f1f40c39915d5c8d7e77', '5bbb61692ccc94d9f0d50e7a8ee728ae5b4c3d6441b4d1d515d4939a507af3cd', '0a21a95d3d21591097a795de075d155661aefb39903f30d3cbc9c0c8912539a8', '4cfb0cd56680c1522e69fce8424d452078f0eb25ae42663f206678ff97f0de94', '080077b619457d38c4225448a13df8b767d438a5c0d60832154eeecb05f5fc47', '42b7f0eb04cc9027a788d8aacf23bf9cdce1090e6770cf63c64bf16ebd7b186a', '0853c80510efdb5ecae37f42b545181aad0fe7b945aac3bf00a4544d4d9e0150', '719f8e9e5c42f854a1057606072b0627541bda75126a5245d94ddbf2bc08744e', 'a628ceea3891cecb967fbe79e4d50701327e32076119c479bc72a39edba9faaf', '7e7dec911c00319bad5cdf3c8c280cb53c569582e1ffb985eda6b28a10987910', '2ed740e09baffec6d02ad15665a2f0965cba2585f948d3d6f8f89571545f1b42', '3a3b30755697b8b84b4e957a75941b10a26d7684be2bb19820f593b4c40cef3c', '870363eeac69cfc2a518eb7879b0390bfabca022a2d1e3ee07d0afe1ba3b62b4', '23c22bd41ee91be2f20b9a5c46c459f4b9141ba7edae75b01f02b5e8a31aa44e', '687231a0f9396168df5ba20756e1be77542cfd33f8509725ab49f6d7c8b98675', '9512a48bee1b79f09c156aa1a835c08fdb734066df9f8b4ec678e558370a53ad', '04b2534a78e7187612148ad001c00b31f44944f83982ddbbbae3a58beb3fd06b', '71858e7d8f9c9e07448f67a7ba9b100aa687095fb2db4f32f99aff4d8a110bc6', '33cb020069591d01e5a599374d4c9070450a06b1052b7a27196c884675fa4d39', '79c51cb70fa0c71271628fddbe5f7d366b84024367517e776bdbcd3f2cbef99f', '33858cbbef2a9574bcad804cc1f70f34cd44dc691c0b8787320df7500c2f1679', '30e9bacc175aa1fc623cfaad062fb946f16a33ff5dc44760a9ff368dcc471809', '266ad13530bb69b52f9d4f397c68f056d63fd701bb6f80c8c93d14dbc6ff4714', '67bcab913606484adbdc53cdceb9a65649199b73010dee55e97b9960ac2b967d'] B "the service layer provides additional support beyond the connectivity function of the forwarding layer. an example of this is packet replication, elimination, and ordering (preof) function see preof." {8: 1, 31: 1, 55: 1, 67: 1, 68: 4, 90: 2, 84: 2} {2: 1, 8: 1, 74: 1, 88: 1, 112: 1, 127: 1, 209: 1, 5: 4, 271: 2, 83: 5, 20: 4, 21: 5, 277: 4, 276: 5, 233: 2, 236: 4, 302: 2, 47: 2, 303: 5, 247: 3, 126: 2} {256, 2, 5, 8, 271, 20, 21, 277, 276, 302, 47, 303, 74, 209, 83, 88, 233, 236, 112, 247, 126, 127} 6 "Whether the DetNet flows are carried in there native form across the DetNet network, or whether they are encapsulated. dn_svcs and dn_svc_encaps contrast native services and the encapsulation of services." "Branch for review Merge it ! Changes look good - clicking correct button this time" 215d293ca11d1a96b10664fe5db5be2326ffc8d9 215d293ca11d1a96b10664fe5db5be2326ffc8d9 draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework 79c51cb70fa0c71271628fddbe5f7d366b84024367517e776bdbcd3f2cbef99f ['a4c40e2a5d94a62408a33afebd53500dc73254bd15c3f1f40c39915d5c8d7e77', '5bbb61692ccc94d9f0d50e7a8ee728ae5b4c3d6441b4d1d515d4939a507af3cd', '0a21a95d3d21591097a795de075d155661aefb39903f30d3cbc9c0c8912539a8', '4cfb0cd56680c1522e69fce8424d452078f0eb25ae42663f206678ff97f0de94', '080077b619457d38c4225448a13df8b767d438a5c0d60832154eeecb05f5fc47', '42b7f0eb04cc9027a788d8aacf23bf9cdce1090e6770cf63c64bf16ebd7b186a', '0853c80510efdb5ecae37f42b545181aad0fe7b945aac3bf00a4544d4d9e0150', '719f8e9e5c42f854a1057606072b0627541bda75126a5245d94ddbf2bc08744e', 'a628ceea3891cecb967fbe79e4d50701327e32076119c479bc72a39edba9faaf', '7e7dec911c00319bad5cdf3c8c280cb53c569582e1ffb985eda6b28a10987910', '2ed740e09baffec6d02ad15665a2f0965cba2585f948d3d6f8f89571545f1b42', '3a3b30755697b8b84b4e957a75941b10a26d7684be2bb19820f593b4c40cef3c', '870363eeac69cfc2a518eb7879b0390bfabca022a2d1e3ee07d0afe1ba3b62b4', '23c22bd41ee91be2f20b9a5c46c459f4b9141ba7edae75b01f02b5e8a31aa44e', '687231a0f9396168df5ba20756e1be77542cfd33f8509725ab49f6d7c8b98675', '9512a48bee1b79f09c156aa1a835c08fdb734066df9f8b4ec678e558370a53ad', '04b2534a78e7187612148ad001c00b31f44944f83982ddbbbae3a58beb3fd06b', '71858e7d8f9c9e07448f67a7ba9b100aa687095fb2db4f32f99aff4d8a110bc6', '33cb020069591d01e5a599374d4c9070450a06b1052b7a27196c884675fa4d39', '79c51cb70fa0c71271628fddbe5f7d366b84024367517e776bdbcd3f2cbef99f', '33858cbbef2a9574bcad804cc1f70f34cd44dc691c0b8787320df7500c2f1679', '30e9bacc175aa1fc623cfaad062fb946f16a33ff5dc44760a9ff368dcc471809', '266ad13530bb69b52f9d4f397c68f056d63fd701bb6f80c8c93d14dbc6ff4714', '67bcab913606484adbdc53cdceb9a65649199b73010dee55e97b9960ac2b967d'] B "whether the detnet flows are carried in there native form across the detnet network, or whether they are encapsulated. dn_svcs and dn_svc_encaps contrast native services and the encapsulation of services." {8: 1, 31: 1, 55: 1, 67: 1, 68: 4, 90: 2, 84: 2} {2: 1, 8: 1, 74: 1, 88: 1, 112: 1, 127: 1, 209: 1, 5: 4, 271: 2, 83: 5, 20: 4, 21: 5, 277: 4, 276: 5, 233: 2, 236: 4, 302: 2, 47: 2, 303: 5, 247: 3, 126: 2} {256, 2, 5, 8, 271, 20, 21, 277, 276, 302, 47, 303, 74, 209, 83, 88, 233, 236, 112, 247, 126, 127} 6 "Whether or not the DetNet data plane includes the facility to carry additional information (metadata) that can be used to provide an enhanced service to the DetNet packet." "Branch for review Merge it ! Changes look good - clicking correct button this time" 215d293ca11d1a96b10664fe5db5be2326ffc8d9 215d293ca11d1a96b10664fe5db5be2326ffc8d9 draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework 3a3b30755697b8b84b4e957a75941b10a26d7684be2bb19820f593b4c40cef3c ['a4c40e2a5d94a62408a33afebd53500dc73254bd15c3f1f40c39915d5c8d7e77', '5bbb61692ccc94d9f0d50e7a8ee728ae5b4c3d6441b4d1d515d4939a507af3cd', '0a21a95d3d21591097a795de075d155661aefb39903f30d3cbc9c0c8912539a8', '4cfb0cd56680c1522e69fce8424d452078f0eb25ae42663f206678ff97f0de94', '080077b619457d38c4225448a13df8b767d438a5c0d60832154eeecb05f5fc47', '42b7f0eb04cc9027a788d8aacf23bf9cdce1090e6770cf63c64bf16ebd7b186a', '0853c80510efdb5ecae37f42b545181aad0fe7b945aac3bf00a4544d4d9e0150', '719f8e9e5c42f854a1057606072b0627541bda75126a5245d94ddbf2bc08744e', 'a628ceea3891cecb967fbe79e4d50701327e32076119c479bc72a39edba9faaf', '7e7dec911c00319bad5cdf3c8c280cb53c569582e1ffb985eda6b28a10987910', '2ed740e09baffec6d02ad15665a2f0965cba2585f948d3d6f8f89571545f1b42', '3a3b30755697b8b84b4e957a75941b10a26d7684be2bb19820f593b4c40cef3c', '870363eeac69cfc2a518eb7879b0390bfabca022a2d1e3ee07d0afe1ba3b62b4', '23c22bd41ee91be2f20b9a5c46c459f4b9141ba7edae75b01f02b5e8a31aa44e', '687231a0f9396168df5ba20756e1be77542cfd33f8509725ab49f6d7c8b98675', '9512a48bee1b79f09c156aa1a835c08fdb734066df9f8b4ec678e558370a53ad', '04b2534a78e7187612148ad001c00b31f44944f83982ddbbbae3a58beb3fd06b', '71858e7d8f9c9e07448f67a7ba9b100aa687095fb2db4f32f99aff4d8a110bc6', '33cb020069591d01e5a599374d4c9070450a06b1052b7a27196c884675fa4d39', '79c51cb70fa0c71271628fddbe5f7d366b84024367517e776bdbcd3f2cbef99f', '33858cbbef2a9574bcad804cc1f70f34cd44dc691c0b8787320df7500c2f1679', '30e9bacc175aa1fc623cfaad062fb946f16a33ff5dc44760a9ff368dcc471809', '266ad13530bb69b52f9d4f397c68f056d63fd701bb6f80c8c93d14dbc6ff4714', '67bcab913606484adbdc53cdceb9a65649199b73010dee55e97b9960ac2b967d'] B "whether or not the detnet data plane includes the facility to carry additional information (metadata) that can be used to provide an enhanced service to the detnet packet." {8: 1, 31: 1, 55: 1, 67: 1, 68: 4, 90: 2, 84: 2} {2: 1, 8: 1, 74: 1, 88: 1, 112: 1, 127: 1, 209: 1, 5: 4, 271: 2, 83: 5, 20: 4, 21: 5, 277: 4, 276: 5, 233: 2, 236: 4, 302: 2, 47: 2, 303: 5, 247: 3, 126: 2} {256, 2, 5, 8, 271, 20, 21, 277, 276, 302, 47, 303, 74, 209, 83, 88, 233, 236, 112, 247, 126, 127} 6 "The encapsulation of the DetNet flows allows them to be sent over a data plane of a type other than their native type. Encapsulation is essential if, for example, it is required to send Ethernet DetNet flows over a data plane such as MPLS. dn_svc_encaps illustrates some encapsulation combinations." "Branch for review Merge it ! Changes look good - clicking correct button this time" 215d293ca11d1a96b10664fe5db5be2326ffc8d9 215d293ca11d1a96b10664fe5db5be2326ffc8d9 draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework a4c40e2a5d94a62408a33afebd53500dc73254bd15c3f1f40c39915d5c8d7e77 ['a4c40e2a5d94a62408a33afebd53500dc73254bd15c3f1f40c39915d5c8d7e77', '5bbb61692ccc94d9f0d50e7a8ee728ae5b4c3d6441b4d1d515d4939a507af3cd', '0a21a95d3d21591097a795de075d155661aefb39903f30d3cbc9c0c8912539a8', '4cfb0cd56680c1522e69fce8424d452078f0eb25ae42663f206678ff97f0de94', '080077b619457d38c4225448a13df8b767d438a5c0d60832154eeecb05f5fc47', '42b7f0eb04cc9027a788d8aacf23bf9cdce1090e6770cf63c64bf16ebd7b186a', '0853c80510efdb5ecae37f42b545181aad0fe7b945aac3bf00a4544d4d9e0150', '719f8e9e5c42f854a1057606072b0627541bda75126a5245d94ddbf2bc08744e', 'a628ceea3891cecb967fbe79e4d50701327e32076119c479bc72a39edba9faaf', '7e7dec911c00319bad5cdf3c8c280cb53c569582e1ffb985eda6b28a10987910', '2ed740e09baffec6d02ad15665a2f0965cba2585f948d3d6f8f89571545f1b42', '3a3b30755697b8b84b4e957a75941b10a26d7684be2bb19820f593b4c40cef3c', '870363eeac69cfc2a518eb7879b0390bfabca022a2d1e3ee07d0afe1ba3b62b4', '23c22bd41ee91be2f20b9a5c46c459f4b9141ba7edae75b01f02b5e8a31aa44e', '687231a0f9396168df5ba20756e1be77542cfd33f8509725ab49f6d7c8b98675', '9512a48bee1b79f09c156aa1a835c08fdb734066df9f8b4ec678e558370a53ad', '04b2534a78e7187612148ad001c00b31f44944f83982ddbbbae3a58beb3fd06b', '71858e7d8f9c9e07448f67a7ba9b100aa687095fb2db4f32f99aff4d8a110bc6', '33cb020069591d01e5a599374d4c9070450a06b1052b7a27196c884675fa4d39', '79c51cb70fa0c71271628fddbe5f7d366b84024367517e776bdbcd3f2cbef99f', '33858cbbef2a9574bcad804cc1f70f34cd44dc691c0b8787320df7500c2f1679', '30e9bacc175aa1fc623cfaad062fb946f16a33ff5dc44760a9ff368dcc471809', '266ad13530bb69b52f9d4f397c68f056d63fd701bb6f80c8c93d14dbc6ff4714', '67bcab913606484adbdc53cdceb9a65649199b73010dee55e97b9960ac2b967d'] B "the encapsulation of the detnet flows allows them to be sent over a data plane of a type other than their native type. encapsulation is essential if, for example, it is required to send ethernet detnet flows over a data plane such as mpls. dn_svc_encaps illustrates some encapsulation combinations." {8: 1, 31: 1, 55: 1, 67: 1, 68: 4, 90: 2, 84: 2} {2: 1, 8: 1, 74: 1, 88: 1, 112: 1, 127: 1, 209: 1, 5: 4, 271: 2, 83: 5, 20: 4, 21: 5, 277: 4, 276: 5, 233: 2, 236: 4, 302: 2, 47: 2, 303: 5, 247: 3, 126: 2} {256, 2, 5, 8, 271, 20, 21, 277, 276, 302, 47, 303, 74, 209, 83, 88, 233, 236, 112, 247, 126, 127} 6 "The use of encapsulation is also required if additional information (meta-data) is needed by the DetNet data plane and their is either no ability to include it in the client data packet, or the specification of the client data plane does not permit the modification of the packet to include additional data. An example of such meta-data is the inclusion of a sequence number required by the PREOF function." "Branch for review Merge it ! Changes look good - clicking correct button this time" 215d293ca11d1a96b10664fe5db5be2326ffc8d9 215d293ca11d1a96b10664fe5db5be2326ffc8d9 draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework 23c22bd41ee91be2f20b9a5c46c459f4b9141ba7edae75b01f02b5e8a31aa44e ['a4c40e2a5d94a62408a33afebd53500dc73254bd15c3f1f40c39915d5c8d7e77', '5bbb61692ccc94d9f0d50e7a8ee728ae5b4c3d6441b4d1d515d4939a507af3cd', '0a21a95d3d21591097a795de075d155661aefb39903f30d3cbc9c0c8912539a8', '4cfb0cd56680c1522e69fce8424d452078f0eb25ae42663f206678ff97f0de94', '080077b619457d38c4225448a13df8b767d438a5c0d60832154eeecb05f5fc47', '42b7f0eb04cc9027a788d8aacf23bf9cdce1090e6770cf63c64bf16ebd7b186a', '0853c80510efdb5ecae37f42b545181aad0fe7b945aac3bf00a4544d4d9e0150', '719f8e9e5c42f854a1057606072b0627541bda75126a5245d94ddbf2bc08744e', 'a628ceea3891cecb967fbe79e4d50701327e32076119c479bc72a39edba9faaf', '7e7dec911c00319bad5cdf3c8c280cb53c569582e1ffb985eda6b28a10987910', '2ed740e09baffec6d02ad15665a2f0965cba2585f948d3d6f8f89571545f1b42', '3a3b30755697b8b84b4e957a75941b10a26d7684be2bb19820f593b4c40cef3c', '870363eeac69cfc2a518eb7879b0390bfabca022a2d1e3ee07d0afe1ba3b62b4', '23c22bd41ee91be2f20b9a5c46c459f4b9141ba7edae75b01f02b5e8a31aa44e', '687231a0f9396168df5ba20756e1be77542cfd33f8509725ab49f6d7c8b98675', '9512a48bee1b79f09c156aa1a835c08fdb734066df9f8b4ec678e558370a53ad', '04b2534a78e7187612148ad001c00b31f44944f83982ddbbbae3a58beb3fd06b', '71858e7d8f9c9e07448f67a7ba9b100aa687095fb2db4f32f99aff4d8a110bc6', '33cb020069591d01e5a599374d4c9070450a06b1052b7a27196c884675fa4d39', '79c51cb70fa0c71271628fddbe5f7d366b84024367517e776bdbcd3f2cbef99f', '33858cbbef2a9574bcad804cc1f70f34cd44dc691c0b8787320df7500c2f1679', '30e9bacc175aa1fc623cfaad062fb946f16a33ff5dc44760a9ff368dcc471809', '266ad13530bb69b52f9d4f397c68f056d63fd701bb6f80c8c93d14dbc6ff4714', '67bcab913606484adbdc53cdceb9a65649199b73010dee55e97b9960ac2b967d'] B "the use of encapsulation is also required if additional information (meta-data) is needed by the detnet data plane and their is either no ability to include it in the client data packet, or the specification of the client data plane does not permit the modification of the packet to include additional data. an example of such meta-data is the inclusion of a sequence number required by the preof function." {8: 1, 31: 1, 55: 1, 67: 1, 68: 4, 90: 2, 84: 2} {2: 1, 8: 1, 74: 1, 88: 1, 112: 1, 127: 1, 209: 1, 5: 4, 271: 2, 83: 5, 20: 4, 21: 5, 277: 4, 276: 5, 233: 2, 236: 4, 302: 2, 47: 2, 303: 5, 247: 3, 126: 2} {256, 2, 5, 8, 271, 20, 21, 277, 276, 302, 47, 303, 74, 209, 83, 88, 233, 236, 112, 247, 126, 127} 6 "Encapsulation is also needed if the DetNet flow or aggregate flow is not easily recognised from from its native encapsulation." "Branch for review Merge it ! Changes look good - clicking correct button this time" 215d293ca11d1a96b10664fe5db5be2326ffc8d9 215d293ca11d1a96b10664fe5db5be2326ffc8d9 draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework 04b2534a78e7187612148ad001c00b31f44944f83982ddbbbae3a58beb3fd06b ['a4c40e2a5d94a62408a33afebd53500dc73254bd15c3f1f40c39915d5c8d7e77', '5bbb61692ccc94d9f0d50e7a8ee728ae5b4c3d6441b4d1d515d4939a507af3cd', '0a21a95d3d21591097a795de075d155661aefb39903f30d3cbc9c0c8912539a8', '4cfb0cd56680c1522e69fce8424d452078f0eb25ae42663f206678ff97f0de94', '080077b619457d38c4225448a13df8b767d438a5c0d60832154eeecb05f5fc47', '42b7f0eb04cc9027a788d8aacf23bf9cdce1090e6770cf63c64bf16ebd7b186a', '0853c80510efdb5ecae37f42b545181aad0fe7b945aac3bf00a4544d4d9e0150', '719f8e9e5c42f854a1057606072b0627541bda75126a5245d94ddbf2bc08744e', 'a628ceea3891cecb967fbe79e4d50701327e32076119c479bc72a39edba9faaf', '7e7dec911c00319bad5cdf3c8c280cb53c569582e1ffb985eda6b28a10987910', '2ed740e09baffec6d02ad15665a2f0965cba2585f948d3d6f8f89571545f1b42', '3a3b30755697b8b84b4e957a75941b10a26d7684be2bb19820f593b4c40cef3c', '870363eeac69cfc2a518eb7879b0390bfabca022a2d1e3ee07d0afe1ba3b62b4', '23c22bd41ee91be2f20b9a5c46c459f4b9141ba7edae75b01f02b5e8a31aa44e', '687231a0f9396168df5ba20756e1be77542cfd33f8509725ab49f6d7c8b98675', '9512a48bee1b79f09c156aa1a835c08fdb734066df9f8b4ec678e558370a53ad', '04b2534a78e7187612148ad001c00b31f44944f83982ddbbbae3a58beb3fd06b', '71858e7d8f9c9e07448f67a7ba9b100aa687095fb2db4f32f99aff4d8a110bc6', '33cb020069591d01e5a599374d4c9070450a06b1052b7a27196c884675fa4d39', '79c51cb70fa0c71271628fddbe5f7d366b84024367517e776bdbcd3f2cbef99f', '33858cbbef2a9574bcad804cc1f70f34cd44dc691c0b8787320df7500c2f1679', '30e9bacc175aa1fc623cfaad062fb946f16a33ff5dc44760a9ff368dcc471809', '266ad13530bb69b52f9d4f397c68f056d63fd701bb6f80c8c93d14dbc6ff4714', '67bcab913606484adbdc53cdceb9a65649199b73010dee55e97b9960ac2b967d'] B "encapsulation is also needed if the detnet flow or aggregate flow is not easily recognised from from its native encapsulation." {8: 1, 31: 1, 55: 1, 67: 1, 68: 4, 90: 2, 84: 2} {2: 1, 8: 1, 74: 1, 88: 1, 112: 1, 127: 1, 209: 1, 5: 4, 271: 2, 83: 5, 20: 4, 21: 5, 277: 4, 276: 5, 233: 2, 236: 4, 302: 2, 47: 2, 303: 5, 247: 3, 126: 2} {256, 2, 5, 8, 271, 20, 21, 277, 276, 302, 47, 303, 74, 209, 83, 88, 233, 236, 112, 247, 126, 127} 6 "Metadata can be a useful way of identifying packets that need to be treated as a flow or flow aggregate. It is also useful as a way of including a sequence number the packet for use by the PREOF function or as a place to carry OAM indications or OAM information to instrument DetNet data plane operation." "Branch for review Merge it ! Changes look good - clicking correct button this time" 215d293ca11d1a96b10664fe5db5be2326ffc8d9 215d293ca11d1a96b10664fe5db5be2326ffc8d9 draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework 0853c80510efdb5ecae37f42b545181aad0fe7b945aac3bf00a4544d4d9e0150 ['a4c40e2a5d94a62408a33afebd53500dc73254bd15c3f1f40c39915d5c8d7e77', '5bbb61692ccc94d9f0d50e7a8ee728ae5b4c3d6441b4d1d515d4939a507af3cd', '0a21a95d3d21591097a795de075d155661aefb39903f30d3cbc9c0c8912539a8', '4cfb0cd56680c1522e69fce8424d452078f0eb25ae42663f206678ff97f0de94', '080077b619457d38c4225448a13df8b767d438a5c0d60832154eeecb05f5fc47', '42b7f0eb04cc9027a788d8aacf23bf9cdce1090e6770cf63c64bf16ebd7b186a', '0853c80510efdb5ecae37f42b545181aad0fe7b945aac3bf00a4544d4d9e0150', '719f8e9e5c42f854a1057606072b0627541bda75126a5245d94ddbf2bc08744e', 'a628ceea3891cecb967fbe79e4d50701327e32076119c479bc72a39edba9faaf', '7e7dec911c00319bad5cdf3c8c280cb53c569582e1ffb985eda6b28a10987910', '2ed740e09baffec6d02ad15665a2f0965cba2585f948d3d6f8f89571545f1b42', '3a3b30755697b8b84b4e957a75941b10a26d7684be2bb19820f593b4c40cef3c', '870363eeac69cfc2a518eb7879b0390bfabca022a2d1e3ee07d0afe1ba3b62b4', '23c22bd41ee91be2f20b9a5c46c459f4b9141ba7edae75b01f02b5e8a31aa44e', '687231a0f9396168df5ba20756e1be77542cfd33f8509725ab49f6d7c8b98675', '9512a48bee1b79f09c156aa1a835c08fdb734066df9f8b4ec678e558370a53ad', '04b2534a78e7187612148ad001c00b31f44944f83982ddbbbae3a58beb3fd06b', '71858e7d8f9c9e07448f67a7ba9b100aa687095fb2db4f32f99aff4d8a110bc6', '33cb020069591d01e5a599374d4c9070450a06b1052b7a27196c884675fa4d39', '79c51cb70fa0c71271628fddbe5f7d366b84024367517e776bdbcd3f2cbef99f', '33858cbbef2a9574bcad804cc1f70f34cd44dc691c0b8787320df7500c2f1679', '30e9bacc175aa1fc623cfaad062fb946f16a33ff5dc44760a9ff368dcc471809', '266ad13530bb69b52f9d4f397c68f056d63fd701bb6f80c8c93d14dbc6ff4714', '67bcab913606484adbdc53cdceb9a65649199b73010dee55e97b9960ac2b967d'] B "metadata can be a useful way of identifying packets that need to be treated as a flow or flow aggregate. it is also useful as a way of including a sequence number the packet for use by the preof function or as a place to carry oam indications or oam information to instrument detnet data plane operation." {8: 1, 31: 1, 55: 1, 67: 1, 68: 4, 90: 2, 84: 2} {2: 1, 8: 1, 74: 1, 88: 1, 112: 1, 127: 1, 209: 1, 5: 4, 271: 2, 83: 5, 20: 4, 21: 5, 277: 4, 276: 5, 233: 2, 236: 4, 302: 2, 47: 2, 303: 5, 247: 3, 126: 2} {256, 2, 5, 8, 271, 20, 21, 277, 276, 302, 47, 303, 74, 209, 83, 88, 233, 236, 112, 247, 126, 127} 6 "Explicit inclusion of metadata is possible through the use of IP options or IP extension headers. New IP options are almost impossible to get standardized or to deploy in an operational network and will not be discussed further in this text. IPv6 extensions headers are finding popularity in current IPv6 development work, particularly in connection with Segment Routing of IPv6 (SRv6) and IP OAM. The design of a new IPv6 extension header or the modification of an existing one is a technique available in the tool box of the DetNet IP data plane designer." "Branch for review Merge it ! Changes look good - clicking correct button this time" 215d293ca11d1a96b10664fe5db5be2326ffc8d9 215d293ca11d1a96b10664fe5db5be2326ffc8d9 draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework 266ad13530bb69b52f9d4f397c68f056d63fd701bb6f80c8c93d14dbc6ff4714 ['a4c40e2a5d94a62408a33afebd53500dc73254bd15c3f1f40c39915d5c8d7e77', '5bbb61692ccc94d9f0d50e7a8ee728ae5b4c3d6441b4d1d515d4939a507af3cd', '0a21a95d3d21591097a795de075d155661aefb39903f30d3cbc9c0c8912539a8', '4cfb0cd56680c1522e69fce8424d452078f0eb25ae42663f206678ff97f0de94', '080077b619457d38c4225448a13df8b767d438a5c0d60832154eeecb05f5fc47', '42b7f0eb04cc9027a788d8aacf23bf9cdce1090e6770cf63c64bf16ebd7b186a', '0853c80510efdb5ecae37f42b545181aad0fe7b945aac3bf00a4544d4d9e0150', '719f8e9e5c42f854a1057606072b0627541bda75126a5245d94ddbf2bc08744e', 'a628ceea3891cecb967fbe79e4d50701327e32076119c479bc72a39edba9faaf', '7e7dec911c00319bad5cdf3c8c280cb53c569582e1ffb985eda6b28a10987910', '2ed740e09baffec6d02ad15665a2f0965cba2585f948d3d6f8f89571545f1b42', '3a3b30755697b8b84b4e957a75941b10a26d7684be2bb19820f593b4c40cef3c', '870363eeac69cfc2a518eb7879b0390bfabca022a2d1e3ee07d0afe1ba3b62b4', '23c22bd41ee91be2f20b9a5c46c459f4b9141ba7edae75b01f02b5e8a31aa44e', '687231a0f9396168df5ba20756e1be77542cfd33f8509725ab49f6d7c8b98675', '9512a48bee1b79f09c156aa1a835c08fdb734066df9f8b4ec678e558370a53ad', '04b2534a78e7187612148ad001c00b31f44944f83982ddbbbae3a58beb3fd06b', '71858e7d8f9c9e07448f67a7ba9b100aa687095fb2db4f32f99aff4d8a110bc6', '33cb020069591d01e5a599374d4c9070450a06b1052b7a27196c884675fa4d39', '79c51cb70fa0c71271628fddbe5f7d366b84024367517e776bdbcd3f2cbef99f', '33858cbbef2a9574bcad804cc1f70f34cd44dc691c0b8787320df7500c2f1679', '30e9bacc175aa1fc623cfaad062fb946f16a33ff5dc44760a9ff368dcc471809', '266ad13530bb69b52f9d4f397c68f056d63fd701bb6f80c8c93d14dbc6ff4714', '67bcab913606484adbdc53cdceb9a65649199b73010dee55e97b9960ac2b967d'] B "explicit inclusion of metadata is possible through the use of ip options or ip extension headers. new ip options are almost impossible to get standardized or to deploy in an operational network and will not be discussed further in this text. ipv6 extensions headers are finding popularity in current ipv6 development work, particularly in connection with segment routing of ipv6 (srv6) and ip oam. the design of a new ipv6 extension header or the modification of an existing one is a technique available in the tool box of the detnet ip data plane designer." {8: 1, 31: 1, 55: 1, 67: 1, 68: 4, 90: 2, 84: 2} {2: 1, 8: 1, 74: 1, 88: 1, 112: 1, 127: 1, 209: 1, 5: 4, 271: 2, 83: 5, 20: 4, 21: 5, 277: 4, 276: 5, 233: 2, 236: 4, 302: 2, 47: 2, 303: 5, 247: 3, 126: 2} {256, 2, 5, 8, 271, 20, 21, 277, 276, 302, 47, 303, 74, 209, 83, 88, 233, 236, 112, 247, 126, 127} 6 "Explicit inclusion of metadata in an IP packet is also possible through the inclusion of an MPLS label stack and the MPLS DetNet Control Word using one of the methods for carrying MPLS over IP I- D.mpls-over-udp-ip. This is described in more detail in subnet_considerations." "Branch for review Merge it ! Changes look good - clicking correct button this time" 215d293ca11d1a96b10664fe5db5be2326ffc8d9 215d293ca11d1a96b10664fe5db5be2326ffc8d9 draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework 71858e7d8f9c9e07448f67a7ba9b100aa687095fb2db4f32f99aff4d8a110bc6 ['a4c40e2a5d94a62408a33afebd53500dc73254bd15c3f1f40c39915d5c8d7e77', '5bbb61692ccc94d9f0d50e7a8ee728ae5b4c3d6441b4d1d515d4939a507af3cd', '0a21a95d3d21591097a795de075d155661aefb39903f30d3cbc9c0c8912539a8', '4cfb0cd56680c1522e69fce8424d452078f0eb25ae42663f206678ff97f0de94', '080077b619457d38c4225448a13df8b767d438a5c0d60832154eeecb05f5fc47', '42b7f0eb04cc9027a788d8aacf23bf9cdce1090e6770cf63c64bf16ebd7b186a', '0853c80510efdb5ecae37f42b545181aad0fe7b945aac3bf00a4544d4d9e0150', '719f8e9e5c42f854a1057606072b0627541bda75126a5245d94ddbf2bc08744e', 'a628ceea3891cecb967fbe79e4d50701327e32076119c479bc72a39edba9faaf', '7e7dec911c00319bad5cdf3c8c280cb53c569582e1ffb985eda6b28a10987910', '2ed740e09baffec6d02ad15665a2f0965cba2585f948d3d6f8f89571545f1b42', '3a3b30755697b8b84b4e957a75941b10a26d7684be2bb19820f593b4c40cef3c', '870363eeac69cfc2a518eb7879b0390bfabca022a2d1e3ee07d0afe1ba3b62b4', '23c22bd41ee91be2f20b9a5c46c459f4b9141ba7edae75b01f02b5e8a31aa44e', '687231a0f9396168df5ba20756e1be77542cfd33f8509725ab49f6d7c8b98675', '9512a48bee1b79f09c156aa1a835c08fdb734066df9f8b4ec678e558370a53ad', '04b2534a78e7187612148ad001c00b31f44944f83982ddbbbae3a58beb3fd06b', '71858e7d8f9c9e07448f67a7ba9b100aa687095fb2db4f32f99aff4d8a110bc6', '33cb020069591d01e5a599374d4c9070450a06b1052b7a27196c884675fa4d39', '79c51cb70fa0c71271628fddbe5f7d366b84024367517e776bdbcd3f2cbef99f', '33858cbbef2a9574bcad804cc1f70f34cd44dc691c0b8787320df7500c2f1679', '30e9bacc175aa1fc623cfaad062fb946f16a33ff5dc44760a9ff368dcc471809', '266ad13530bb69b52f9d4f397c68f056d63fd701bb6f80c8c93d14dbc6ff4714', '67bcab913606484adbdc53cdceb9a65649199b73010dee55e97b9960ac2b967d'] B "explicit inclusion of metadata in an ip packet is also possible through the inclusion of an mpls label stack and the mpls detnet control word using one of the methods for carrying mpls over ip i- d.mpls-over-udp-ip. this is described in more detail in subnet_considerations." {8: 1, 31: 1, 55: 1, 67: 1, 68: 4, 90: 2, 84: 2} {2: 1, 8: 1, 74: 1, 88: 1, 112: 1, 127: 1, 209: 1, 5: 4, 271: 2, 83: 5, 20: 4, 21: 5, 277: 4, 276: 5, 233: 2, 236: 4, 302: 2, 47: 2, 303: 5, 247: 3, 126: 2} {256, 2, 5, 8, 271, 20, 21, 277, 276, 302, 47, 303, 74, 209, 83, 88, 233, 236, 112, 247, 126, 127} 6 "Implicit metadata can be included through the use of the network programming paradigm I-D.spring-srv6-network-programming in which the suffix of an IPv6 address is used to encode additional information for use by the network of the receiving host. Examples of such information include the sequence number for use by the PREOF function, or even all the essential information being deigned into the DetNet over MPLS label stack (the DetNet Control Word and the DetNet Service label)." "Branch for review Merge it ! Changes look good - clicking correct button this time" 215d293ca11d1a96b10664fe5db5be2326ffc8d9 215d293ca11d1a96b10664fe5db5be2326ffc8d9 draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework 080077b619457d38c4225448a13df8b767d438a5c0d60832154eeecb05f5fc47 ['a4c40e2a5d94a62408a33afebd53500dc73254bd15c3f1f40c39915d5c8d7e77', '5bbb61692ccc94d9f0d50e7a8ee728ae5b4c3d6441b4d1d515d4939a507af3cd', '0a21a95d3d21591097a795de075d155661aefb39903f30d3cbc9c0c8912539a8', '4cfb0cd56680c1522e69fce8424d452078f0eb25ae42663f206678ff97f0de94', '080077b619457d38c4225448a13df8b767d438a5c0d60832154eeecb05f5fc47', '42b7f0eb04cc9027a788d8aacf23bf9cdce1090e6770cf63c64bf16ebd7b186a', '0853c80510efdb5ecae37f42b545181aad0fe7b945aac3bf00a4544d4d9e0150', '719f8e9e5c42f854a1057606072b0627541bda75126a5245d94ddbf2bc08744e', 'a628ceea3891cecb967fbe79e4d50701327e32076119c479bc72a39edba9faaf', '7e7dec911c00319bad5cdf3c8c280cb53c569582e1ffb985eda6b28a10987910', '2ed740e09baffec6d02ad15665a2f0965cba2585f948d3d6f8f89571545f1b42', '3a3b30755697b8b84b4e957a75941b10a26d7684be2bb19820f593b4c40cef3c', '870363eeac69cfc2a518eb7879b0390bfabca022a2d1e3ee07d0afe1ba3b62b4', '23c22bd41ee91be2f20b9a5c46c459f4b9141ba7edae75b01f02b5e8a31aa44e', '687231a0f9396168df5ba20756e1be77542cfd33f8509725ab49f6d7c8b98675', '9512a48bee1b79f09c156aa1a835c08fdb734066df9f8b4ec678e558370a53ad', '04b2534a78e7187612148ad001c00b31f44944f83982ddbbbae3a58beb3fd06b', '71858e7d8f9c9e07448f67a7ba9b100aa687095fb2db4f32f99aff4d8a110bc6', '33cb020069591d01e5a599374d4c9070450a06b1052b7a27196c884675fa4d39', '79c51cb70fa0c71271628fddbe5f7d366b84024367517e776bdbcd3f2cbef99f', '33858cbbef2a9574bcad804cc1f70f34cd44dc691c0b8787320df7500c2f1679', '30e9bacc175aa1fc623cfaad062fb946f16a33ff5dc44760a9ff368dcc471809', '266ad13530bb69b52f9d4f397c68f056d63fd701bb6f80c8c93d14dbc6ff4714', '67bcab913606484adbdc53cdceb9a65649199b73010dee55e97b9960ac2b967d'] B "implicit metadata can be included through the use of the network programming paradigm i-d.spring-srv6-network-programming in which the suffix of an ipv6 address is used to encode additional information for use by the network of the receiving host. examples of such information include the sequence number for use by the preof function, or even all the essential information being deigned into the detnet over mpls label stack (the detnet control word and the detnet service label)." {8: 1, 31: 1, 55: 1, 67: 1, 68: 4, 90: 2, 84: 2} {2: 1, 8: 1, 74: 1, 88: 1, 112: 1, 127: 1, 209: 1, 5: 4, 271: 2, 83: 5, 20: 4, 21: 5, 277: 4, 276: 5, 233: 2, 236: 4, 302: 2, 47: 2, 303: 5, 247: 3, 126: 2} {256, 2, 5, 8, 271, 20, 21, 277, 276, 302, 47, 303, 74, 209, 83, 88, 233, 236, 112, 247, 126, 127} 6 "An IP data plane may operate natively or through the use of an encapsulation. There are many IP encapsulations that may be interposed between the DetNet data plane IP header and the DetNet payload, and it is anticipated that more than one encapsulation may be deployed." "Branch for review Merge it ! Changes look good - clicking correct button this time" 215d293ca11d1a96b10664fe5db5be2326ffc8d9 215d293ca11d1a96b10664fe5db5be2326ffc8d9 draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework 2ed740e09baffec6d02ad15665a2f0965cba2585f948d3d6f8f89571545f1b42 ['a4c40e2a5d94a62408a33afebd53500dc73254bd15c3f1f40c39915d5c8d7e77', '5bbb61692ccc94d9f0d50e7a8ee728ae5b4c3d6441b4d1d515d4939a507af3cd', '0a21a95d3d21591097a795de075d155661aefb39903f30d3cbc9c0c8912539a8', '4cfb0cd56680c1522e69fce8424d452078f0eb25ae42663f206678ff97f0de94', '080077b619457d38c4225448a13df8b767d438a5c0d60832154eeecb05f5fc47', '42b7f0eb04cc9027a788d8aacf23bf9cdce1090e6770cf63c64bf16ebd7b186a', '0853c80510efdb5ecae37f42b545181aad0fe7b945aac3bf00a4544d4d9e0150', '719f8e9e5c42f854a1057606072b0627541bda75126a5245d94ddbf2bc08744e', 'a628ceea3891cecb967fbe79e4d50701327e32076119c479bc72a39edba9faaf', '7e7dec911c00319bad5cdf3c8c280cb53c569582e1ffb985eda6b28a10987910', '2ed740e09baffec6d02ad15665a2f0965cba2585f948d3d6f8f89571545f1b42', '3a3b30755697b8b84b4e957a75941b10a26d7684be2bb19820f593b4c40cef3c', '870363eeac69cfc2a518eb7879b0390bfabca022a2d1e3ee07d0afe1ba3b62b4', '23c22bd41ee91be2f20b9a5c46c459f4b9141ba7edae75b01f02b5e8a31aa44e', '687231a0f9396168df5ba20756e1be77542cfd33f8509725ab49f6d7c8b98675', '9512a48bee1b79f09c156aa1a835c08fdb734066df9f8b4ec678e558370a53ad', '04b2534a78e7187612148ad001c00b31f44944f83982ddbbbae3a58beb3fd06b', '71858e7d8f9c9e07448f67a7ba9b100aa687095fb2db4f32f99aff4d8a110bc6', '33cb020069591d01e5a599374d4c9070450a06b1052b7a27196c884675fa4d39', '79c51cb70fa0c71271628fddbe5f7d366b84024367517e776bdbcd3f2cbef99f', '33858cbbef2a9574bcad804cc1f70f34cd44dc691c0b8787320df7500c2f1679', '30e9bacc175aa1fc623cfaad062fb946f16a33ff5dc44760a9ff368dcc471809', '266ad13530bb69b52f9d4f397c68f056d63fd701bb6f80c8c93d14dbc6ff4714', '67bcab913606484adbdc53cdceb9a65649199b73010dee55e97b9960ac2b967d'] B "an ip data plane may operate natively or through the use of an encapsulation. there are many ip encapsulations that may be interposed between the detnet data plane ip header and the detnet payload, and it is anticipated that more than one encapsulation may be deployed." {8: 1, 31: 1, 55: 1, 67: 1, 68: 4, 90: 2, 84: 2} {2: 1, 8: 1, 74: 1, 88: 1, 112: 1, 127: 1, 209: 1, 5: 4, 271: 2, 83: 5, 20: 4, 21: 5, 277: 4, 276: 5, 233: 2, 236: 4, 302: 2, 47: 2, 303: 5, 247: 3, 126: 2} {256, 2, 5, 8, 271, 20, 21, 277, 276, 302, 47, 303, 74, 209, 83, 88, 233, 236, 112, 247, 126, 127} 6 "One method of operating an IP DetNet data plane without encapsulation is to use ""6-tuple"" based flow identification, where ""6-tuple"" refers to information carried in IP and higher layer protocol headers. General background on the use of IP headers, and ""5-tuples"", to identify flows and support Quality of Service (QoS) can be found in RFC3670. RFC7657 also provides useful background on the delivery differentiated services (DiffServ) and ""6-tuple"" based flow identification. DetNet flow aggregation may be enabled via the use of wildcards, masks, prefixes and ranges. The operation of this method is described in detail in [ID.ietf-detnet-ip]." "Branch for review Merge it ! Changes look good - clicking correct button this time" 215d293ca11d1a96b10664fe5db5be2326ffc8d9 215d293ca11d1a96b10664fe5db5be2326ffc8d9 draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework f18684001a1fff593e10b1bf9355a982468c2a0c39067b978ca670f996abc812 ['023f961d619971c6f51af4be85aa80ec6148a5573fc27824d42b1f0d62a1a888', '067d9859172cde5eacf03abfc795fad05c27315c3d877321a836289497410bf5', 'abf026ee8a31a9f2648f2b58fbc4f713ca6dcbfdd0bba66fea03ecd28ea90332', '11ad0e3d084e84d0f894abcc3f46f35b920669c902de0fd0c1c0b70b5a277503', 'd75a171663a1ff923d830df8dea16b22f884b2af11dbe9e73f8ed147123783d9', '2774d0351348728e076d27562ba4835d550b613b2092435ce2b73b72b1bbf04d', '7f196d71ae3dd553e6306aad4f0e7f0515bbcf2696b05eed10292049a0413c74', 'd0bcc637bfa20f222ac98b878a724978687152e9aeb24cd06c2f2a3d57d9efd5', 'f18684001a1fff593e10b1bf9355a982468c2a0c39067b978ca670f996abc812', 'b7e4ce467d4406a06a4bcffed356d40bc68aa391b3f641ca58f2c49a28d5d72d', 'c0c46a44c439b6c63bd7bfbf690de81f100f1e797d4f1a1daf4cb2e4f9f87129', '8c6d08b2077f63af242b017cc8f33cd6eb524769fc73b1f6bbd818077d449078', '6ca6d19228d672f558c97be9cf7514386bcc666768700a0a9697e6ac657b8621', '1ae09bae308713aec5b1fdccd6eea1c9de1834329c0a092a309ce2b0a147778b'] A "one method of operating an ip detnet data plane without encapsulation is to use ""6-tuple"" based flow identification, where ""6-tuple"" refers to information carried in ip and higher layer protocol headers. general background on the use of ip headers, and ""5-tuples"", to identify flows and support quality of service (qos) can be found in rfc3670. rfc7657 also provides useful background on the delivery differentiated services (diffserv) and ""6-tuple"" based flow identification. detnet flow aggregation may be enabled via the use of wildcards, masks, prefixes and ranges. the operation of this method is described in detail in [id.ietf-detnet-ip]." {8: 1, 79: 9, 90: 7, 51: 9, 130: 9, 62: 8, 85: 8, 68: 2, 35: 10, 110: 10, 91: 12, 114: 10, 97: 10, 31: 2, 13: 9, 67: 9, 38: 11, 26: 8, 124: 9, 98: 9, 54: 9, 127: 10, 6: 7, 96: 10, 64: 9, 30: 11, 61: 12, 55: 3, 27: 8, 15: 10, 52: 8, 129: 10, 115: 10, 84: 5, 76: 10, 87: 10, 131: 12, 102: 7, 113: 12, 99: 9, 36: 10, 24: 9, 53: 8, 72: 11} {218: 1, 330: 1, 4: 9, 9: 9, 10: 10, 15: 10, 24: 9, 25: 8, 26: 8, 27: 10, 39: 4, 43: 10, 49: 13, 50: 12, 58: 12, 59: 9, 64: 10, 69: 8, 81: 9, 82: 9, 86: 10, 96: 11, 97: 10, 100: 12, 108: 10, 109: 11, 110: 11, 111: 9, 114: 10, 115: 11, 116: 10, 118: 9, 119: 8, 120: 10, 121: 7, 122: 11, 123: 10, 124: 6, 128: 11, 129: 11, 130: 12, 132: 8, 136: 9, 145: 8, 147: 11, 151: 11, 152: 11, 154: 10, 156: 9, 161: 7, 162: 6, 165: 10, 168: 11, 169: 10, 172: 10, 180: 11, 184: 9, 187: 12, 188: 11, 191: 10, 194: 8, 202: 9, 203: 10, 206: 9, 207: 10, 215: 8, 217: 10, 220: 7, 221: 7, 222: 6, 224: 10, 227: 10, 229: 10, 234: 12, 235: 9, 241: 9, 242: 9, 243: 8, 244: 11, 245: 8, 248: 11, 250: 11, 258: 2, 262: 11, 263: 12, 264: 8, 267: 7, 270: 10, 272: 10, 273: 9, 287: 10, 289: 10, 291: 12, 299: 10, 300: 10, 304: 10, 309: 7, 314: 9, 315: 10, 320: 7, 323: 8, 327: 11, 328: 9, 329: 9, 334: 9, 335: 10, 341: 10, 342: 11, 347: 10, 348: 10, 350: 11, 351: 12, 352: 10, 353: 10, 354: 9, 358: 5, 365: 10, 366: 9, 369: 8, 371: 12, 372: 12, 376: 9, 384: 12, 385: 11, 386: 10, 387: 10, 392: 9, 393: 10, 396: 11, 397: 2, 398: 3, 402: 10} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 6 "The DetNet forwarding plane may use explict route cabability and traffic engineering capabilities to provide a forwarding sub-layer that is responsible for providing resource allocation and explicit routes. It is possible to include metadata in a native IP packet explicitly, or implicitly." "Branch for review Merge it ! Changes look good - clicking correct button this time" 215d293ca11d1a96b10664fe5db5be2326ffc8d9 215d293ca11d1a96b10664fe5db5be2326ffc8d9 draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework 067d9859172cde5eacf03abfc795fad05c27315c3d877321a836289497410bf5 ['023f961d619971c6f51af4be85aa80ec6148a5573fc27824d42b1f0d62a1a888', '067d9859172cde5eacf03abfc795fad05c27315c3d877321a836289497410bf5', 'abf026ee8a31a9f2648f2b58fbc4f713ca6dcbfdd0bba66fea03ecd28ea90332', '11ad0e3d084e84d0f894abcc3f46f35b920669c902de0fd0c1c0b70b5a277503', 'd75a171663a1ff923d830df8dea16b22f884b2af11dbe9e73f8ed147123783d9', '2774d0351348728e076d27562ba4835d550b613b2092435ce2b73b72b1bbf04d', '7f196d71ae3dd553e6306aad4f0e7f0515bbcf2696b05eed10292049a0413c74', 'd0bcc637bfa20f222ac98b878a724978687152e9aeb24cd06c2f2a3d57d9efd5', 'f18684001a1fff593e10b1bf9355a982468c2a0c39067b978ca670f996abc812', 'b7e4ce467d4406a06a4bcffed356d40bc68aa391b3f641ca58f2c49a28d5d72d', 'c0c46a44c439b6c63bd7bfbf690de81f100f1e797d4f1a1daf4cb2e4f9f87129', '8c6d08b2077f63af242b017cc8f33cd6eb524769fc73b1f6bbd818077d449078', '6ca6d19228d672f558c97be9cf7514386bcc666768700a0a9697e6ac657b8621', '1ae09bae308713aec5b1fdccd6eea1c9de1834329c0a092a309ce2b0a147778b'] A "the detnet forwarding plane may use explict route cabability and traffic engineering capabilities to provide a forwarding sub-layer that is responsible for providing resource allocation and explicit routes. it is possible to include metadata in a native ip packet explicitly, or implicitly." {8: 1, 79: 9, 90: 7, 51: 9, 130: 9, 62: 8, 85: 8, 68: 2, 35: 10, 110: 10, 91: 12, 114: 10, 97: 10, 31: 2, 13: 9, 67: 9, 38: 11, 26: 8, 124: 9, 98: 9, 54: 9, 127: 10, 6: 7, 96: 10, 64: 9, 30: 11, 61: 12, 55: 3, 27: 8, 15: 10, 52: 8, 129: 10, 115: 10, 84: 5, 76: 10, 87: 10, 131: 12, 102: 7, 113: 12, 99: 9, 36: 10, 24: 9, 53: 8, 72: 11} {218: 1, 330: 1, 4: 9, 9: 9, 10: 10, 15: 10, 24: 9, 25: 8, 26: 8, 27: 10, 39: 4, 43: 10, 49: 13, 50: 12, 58: 12, 59: 9, 64: 10, 69: 8, 81: 9, 82: 9, 86: 10, 96: 11, 97: 10, 100: 12, 108: 10, 109: 11, 110: 11, 111: 9, 114: 10, 115: 11, 116: 10, 118: 9, 119: 8, 120: 10, 121: 7, 122: 11, 123: 10, 124: 6, 128: 11, 129: 11, 130: 12, 132: 8, 136: 9, 145: 8, 147: 11, 151: 11, 152: 11, 154: 10, 156: 9, 161: 7, 162: 6, 165: 10, 168: 11, 169: 10, 172: 10, 180: 11, 184: 9, 187: 12, 188: 11, 191: 10, 194: 8, 202: 9, 203: 10, 206: 9, 207: 10, 215: 8, 217: 10, 220: 7, 221: 7, 222: 6, 224: 10, 227: 10, 229: 10, 234: 12, 235: 9, 241: 9, 242: 9, 243: 8, 244: 11, 245: 8, 248: 11, 250: 11, 258: 2, 262: 11, 263: 12, 264: 8, 267: 7, 270: 10, 272: 10, 273: 9, 287: 10, 289: 10, 291: 12, 299: 10, 300: 10, 304: 10, 309: 7, 314: 9, 315: 10, 320: 7, 323: 8, 327: 11, 328: 9, 329: 9, 334: 9, 335: 10, 341: 10, 342: 11, 347: 10, 348: 10, 350: 11, 351: 12, 352: 10, 353: 10, 354: 9, 358: 5, 365: 10, 366: 9, 369: 8, 371: 12, 372: 12, 376: 9, 384: 12, 385: 11, 386: 10, 387: 10, 392: 9, 393: 10, 396: 11, 397: 2, 398: 3, 402: 10} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 6 "Explicit inclusion of metadata is possible through the use of IP options or IP extension headers. New IP options are almost impossible to get standardized or to deploy in an operational network and will not be discussed further in this text. IPv6 extensions headers are finding popularity in current IPv6 development work, particularly in connection with Segment Routing of IPv6 (SRv6) and IOAM. The design of a new IPv6 extension header or the modification of an existing one is a technique in the tool box of the DetNet IP data plane designer." "Branch for review Merge it ! Changes look good - clicking correct button this time" 215d293ca11d1a96b10664fe5db5be2326ffc8d9 215d293ca11d1a96b10664fe5db5be2326ffc8d9 draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework 6ca6d19228d672f558c97be9cf7514386bcc666768700a0a9697e6ac657b8621 ['023f961d619971c6f51af4be85aa80ec6148a5573fc27824d42b1f0d62a1a888', '067d9859172cde5eacf03abfc795fad05c27315c3d877321a836289497410bf5', 'abf026ee8a31a9f2648f2b58fbc4f713ca6dcbfdd0bba66fea03ecd28ea90332', '11ad0e3d084e84d0f894abcc3f46f35b920669c902de0fd0c1c0b70b5a277503', 'd75a171663a1ff923d830df8dea16b22f884b2af11dbe9e73f8ed147123783d9', '2774d0351348728e076d27562ba4835d550b613b2092435ce2b73b72b1bbf04d', '7f196d71ae3dd553e6306aad4f0e7f0515bbcf2696b05eed10292049a0413c74', 'd0bcc637bfa20f222ac98b878a724978687152e9aeb24cd06c2f2a3d57d9efd5', 'f18684001a1fff593e10b1bf9355a982468c2a0c39067b978ca670f996abc812', 'b7e4ce467d4406a06a4bcffed356d40bc68aa391b3f641ca58f2c49a28d5d72d', 'c0c46a44c439b6c63bd7bfbf690de81f100f1e797d4f1a1daf4cb2e4f9f87129', '8c6d08b2077f63af242b017cc8f33cd6eb524769fc73b1f6bbd818077d449078', '6ca6d19228d672f558c97be9cf7514386bcc666768700a0a9697e6ac657b8621', '1ae09bae308713aec5b1fdccd6eea1c9de1834329c0a092a309ce2b0a147778b'] A "explicit inclusion of metadata is possible through the use of ip options or ip extension headers. new ip options are almost impossible to get standardized or to deploy in an operational network and will not be discussed further in this text. ipv6 extensions headers are finding popularity in current ipv6 development work, particularly in connection with segment routing of ipv6 (srv6) and ioam. the design of a new ipv6 extension header or the modification of an existing one is a technique in the tool box of the detnet ip data plane designer." {8: 1, 79: 9, 90: 7, 51: 9, 130: 9, 62: 8, 85: 8, 68: 2, 35: 10, 110: 10, 91: 12, 114: 10, 97: 10, 31: 2, 13: 9, 67: 9, 38: 11, 26: 8, 124: 9, 98: 9, 54: 9, 127: 10, 6: 7, 96: 10, 64: 9, 30: 11, 61: 12, 55: 3, 27: 8, 15: 10, 52: 8, 129: 10, 115: 10, 84: 5, 76: 10, 87: 10, 131: 12, 102: 7, 113: 12, 99: 9, 36: 10, 24: 9, 53: 8, 72: 11} {218: 1, 330: 1, 4: 9, 9: 9, 10: 10, 15: 10, 24: 9, 25: 8, 26: 8, 27: 10, 39: 4, 43: 10, 49: 13, 50: 12, 58: 12, 59: 9, 64: 10, 69: 8, 81: 9, 82: 9, 86: 10, 96: 11, 97: 10, 100: 12, 108: 10, 109: 11, 110: 11, 111: 9, 114: 10, 115: 11, 116: 10, 118: 9, 119: 8, 120: 10, 121: 7, 122: 11, 123: 10, 124: 6, 128: 11, 129: 11, 130: 12, 132: 8, 136: 9, 145: 8, 147: 11, 151: 11, 152: 11, 154: 10, 156: 9, 161: 7, 162: 6, 165: 10, 168: 11, 169: 10, 172: 10, 180: 11, 184: 9, 187: 12, 188: 11, 191: 10, 194: 8, 202: 9, 203: 10, 206: 9, 207: 10, 215: 8, 217: 10, 220: 7, 221: 7, 222: 6, 224: 10, 227: 10, 229: 10, 234: 12, 235: 9, 241: 9, 242: 9, 243: 8, 244: 11, 245: 8, 248: 11, 250: 11, 258: 2, 262: 11, 263: 12, 264: 8, 267: 7, 270: 10, 272: 10, 273: 9, 287: 10, 289: 10, 291: 12, 299: 10, 300: 10, 304: 10, 309: 7, 314: 9, 315: 10, 320: 7, 323: 8, 327: 11, 328: 9, 329: 9, 334: 9, 335: 10, 341: 10, 342: 11, 347: 10, 348: 10, 350: 11, 351: 12, 352: 10, 353: 10, 354: 9, 358: 5, 365: 10, 366: 9, 369: 8, 371: 12, 372: 12, 376: 9, 384: 12, 385: 11, 386: 10, 387: 10, 392: 9, 393: 10, 396: 11, 397: 2, 398: 3, 402: 10} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 6 "Explicit inclusion of metadata in an IP packet is also possible through the inclusion of an MPLS label stack and the MPLS DetNet Control Word using one of the methods for carrying MPLS over IP [NEED REFERENCES]. This is described in more detail in [NEED REFERENCE]." "Branch for review Merge it ! Changes look good - clicking correct button this time" 215d293ca11d1a96b10664fe5db5be2326ffc8d9 215d293ca11d1a96b10664fe5db5be2326ffc8d9 draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework 11ad0e3d084e84d0f894abcc3f46f35b920669c902de0fd0c1c0b70b5a277503 ['023f961d619971c6f51af4be85aa80ec6148a5573fc27824d42b1f0d62a1a888', '067d9859172cde5eacf03abfc795fad05c27315c3d877321a836289497410bf5', 'abf026ee8a31a9f2648f2b58fbc4f713ca6dcbfdd0bba66fea03ecd28ea90332', '11ad0e3d084e84d0f894abcc3f46f35b920669c902de0fd0c1c0b70b5a277503', 'd75a171663a1ff923d830df8dea16b22f884b2af11dbe9e73f8ed147123783d9', '2774d0351348728e076d27562ba4835d550b613b2092435ce2b73b72b1bbf04d', '7f196d71ae3dd553e6306aad4f0e7f0515bbcf2696b05eed10292049a0413c74', 'd0bcc637bfa20f222ac98b878a724978687152e9aeb24cd06c2f2a3d57d9efd5', 'f18684001a1fff593e10b1bf9355a982468c2a0c39067b978ca670f996abc812', 'b7e4ce467d4406a06a4bcffed356d40bc68aa391b3f641ca58f2c49a28d5d72d', 'c0c46a44c439b6c63bd7bfbf690de81f100f1e797d4f1a1daf4cb2e4f9f87129', '8c6d08b2077f63af242b017cc8f33cd6eb524769fc73b1f6bbd818077d449078', '6ca6d19228d672f558c97be9cf7514386bcc666768700a0a9697e6ac657b8621', '1ae09bae308713aec5b1fdccd6eea1c9de1834329c0a092a309ce2b0a147778b'] A "explicit inclusion of metadata in an ip packet is also possible through the inclusion of an mpls label stack and the mpls detnet control word using one of the methods for carrying mpls over ip [need references]. this is described in more detail in [need reference]." {8: 1, 79: 9, 90: 7, 51: 9, 130: 9, 62: 8, 85: 8, 68: 2, 35: 10, 110: 10, 91: 12, 114: 10, 97: 10, 31: 2, 13: 9, 67: 9, 38: 11, 26: 8, 124: 9, 98: 9, 54: 9, 127: 10, 6: 7, 96: 10, 64: 9, 30: 11, 61: 12, 55: 3, 27: 8, 15: 10, 52: 8, 129: 10, 115: 10, 84: 5, 76: 10, 87: 10, 131: 12, 102: 7, 113: 12, 99: 9, 36: 10, 24: 9, 53: 8, 72: 11} {218: 1, 330: 1, 4: 9, 9: 9, 10: 10, 15: 10, 24: 9, 25: 8, 26: 8, 27: 10, 39: 4, 43: 10, 49: 13, 50: 12, 58: 12, 59: 9, 64: 10, 69: 8, 81: 9, 82: 9, 86: 10, 96: 11, 97: 10, 100: 12, 108: 10, 109: 11, 110: 11, 111: 9, 114: 10, 115: 11, 116: 10, 118: 9, 119: 8, 120: 10, 121: 7, 122: 11, 123: 10, 124: 6, 128: 11, 129: 11, 130: 12, 132: 8, 136: 9, 145: 8, 147: 11, 151: 11, 152: 11, 154: 10, 156: 9, 161: 7, 162: 6, 165: 10, 168: 11, 169: 10, 172: 10, 180: 11, 184: 9, 187: 12, 188: 11, 191: 10, 194: 8, 202: 9, 203: 10, 206: 9, 207: 10, 215: 8, 217: 10, 220: 7, 221: 7, 222: 6, 224: 10, 227: 10, 229: 10, 234: 12, 235: 9, 241: 9, 242: 9, 243: 8, 244: 11, 245: 8, 248: 11, 250: 11, 258: 2, 262: 11, 263: 12, 264: 8, 267: 7, 270: 10, 272: 10, 273: 9, 287: 10, 289: 10, 291: 12, 299: 10, 300: 10, 304: 10, 309: 7, 314: 9, 315: 10, 320: 7, 323: 8, 327: 11, 328: 9, 329: 9, 334: 9, 335: 10, 341: 10, 342: 11, 347: 10, 348: 10, 350: 11, 351: 12, 352: 10, 353: 10, 354: 9, 358: 5, 365: 10, 366: 9, 369: 8, 371: 12, 372: 12, 376: 9, 384: 12, 385: 11, 386: 10, 387: 10, 392: 9, 393: 10, 396: 11, 397: 2, 398: 3, 402: 10} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 6 "Implicit metadata can be included through the use of the network programming paradygm [NEED REFERENCE] in which the suffix of an IPv6 address is used to encode additional information for use by the network of the receiving host. Examples of such information include the sequence number for use by the PREOF function, or indeed the whole of the essential information being deigned into the DetNet over MPLS label stack (the DetNet Control Word and the DetNet Service lable)." "Branch for review Merge it ! Changes look good - clicking correct button this time" 215d293ca11d1a96b10664fe5db5be2326ffc8d9 215d293ca11d1a96b10664fe5db5be2326ffc8d9 draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework 2774d0351348728e076d27562ba4835d550b613b2092435ce2b73b72b1bbf04d ['023f961d619971c6f51af4be85aa80ec6148a5573fc27824d42b1f0d62a1a888', '067d9859172cde5eacf03abfc795fad05c27315c3d877321a836289497410bf5', 'abf026ee8a31a9f2648f2b58fbc4f713ca6dcbfdd0bba66fea03ecd28ea90332', '11ad0e3d084e84d0f894abcc3f46f35b920669c902de0fd0c1c0b70b5a277503', 'd75a171663a1ff923d830df8dea16b22f884b2af11dbe9e73f8ed147123783d9', '2774d0351348728e076d27562ba4835d550b613b2092435ce2b73b72b1bbf04d', '7f196d71ae3dd553e6306aad4f0e7f0515bbcf2696b05eed10292049a0413c74', 'd0bcc637bfa20f222ac98b878a724978687152e9aeb24cd06c2f2a3d57d9efd5', 'f18684001a1fff593e10b1bf9355a982468c2a0c39067b978ca670f996abc812', 'b7e4ce467d4406a06a4bcffed356d40bc68aa391b3f641ca58f2c49a28d5d72d', 'c0c46a44c439b6c63bd7bfbf690de81f100f1e797d4f1a1daf4cb2e4f9f87129', '8c6d08b2077f63af242b017cc8f33cd6eb524769fc73b1f6bbd818077d449078', '6ca6d19228d672f558c97be9cf7514386bcc666768700a0a9697e6ac657b8621', '1ae09bae308713aec5b1fdccd6eea1c9de1834329c0a092a309ce2b0a147778b'] A "implicit metadata can be included through the use of the network programming paradygm [need reference] in which the suffix of an ipv6 address is used to encode additional information for use by the network of the receiving host. examples of such information include the sequence number for use by the preof function, or indeed the whole of the essential information being deigned into the detnet over mpls label stack (the detnet control word and the detnet service lable)." {8: 1, 79: 9, 90: 7, 51: 9, 130: 9, 62: 8, 85: 8, 68: 2, 35: 10, 110: 10, 91: 12, 114: 10, 97: 10, 31: 2, 13: 9, 67: 9, 38: 11, 26: 8, 124: 9, 98: 9, 54: 9, 127: 10, 6: 7, 96: 10, 64: 9, 30: 11, 61: 12, 55: 3, 27: 8, 15: 10, 52: 8, 129: 10, 115: 10, 84: 5, 76: 10, 87: 10, 131: 12, 102: 7, 113: 12, 99: 9, 36: 10, 24: 9, 53: 8, 72: 11} {218: 1, 330: 1, 4: 9, 9: 9, 10: 10, 15: 10, 24: 9, 25: 8, 26: 8, 27: 10, 39: 4, 43: 10, 49: 13, 50: 12, 58: 12, 59: 9, 64: 10, 69: 8, 81: 9, 82: 9, 86: 10, 96: 11, 97: 10, 100: 12, 108: 10, 109: 11, 110: 11, 111: 9, 114: 10, 115: 11, 116: 10, 118: 9, 119: 8, 120: 10, 121: 7, 122: 11, 123: 10, 124: 6, 128: 11, 129: 11, 130: 12, 132: 8, 136: 9, 145: 8, 147: 11, 151: 11, 152: 11, 154: 10, 156: 9, 161: 7, 162: 6, 165: 10, 168: 11, 169: 10, 172: 10, 180: 11, 184: 9, 187: 12, 188: 11, 191: 10, 194: 8, 202: 9, 203: 10, 206: 9, 207: 10, 215: 8, 217: 10, 220: 7, 221: 7, 222: 6, 224: 10, 227: 10, 229: 10, 234: 12, 235: 9, 241: 9, 242: 9, 243: 8, 244: 11, 245: 8, 248: 11, 250: 11, 258: 2, 262: 11, 263: 12, 264: 8, 267: 7, 270: 10, 272: 10, 273: 9, 287: 10, 289: 10, 291: 12, 299: 10, 300: 10, 304: 10, 309: 7, 314: 9, 315: 10, 320: 7, 323: 8, 327: 11, 328: 9, 329: 9, 334: 9, 335: 10, 341: 10, 342: 11, 347: 10, 348: 10, 350: 11, 351: 12, 352: 10, 353: 10, 354: 9, 358: 5, 365: 10, 366: 9, 369: 8, 371: 12, 372: 12, 376: 9, 384: 12, 385: 11, 386: 10, 387: 10, 392: 9, 393: 10, 396: 11, 397: 2, 398: 3, 402: 10} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 6 "dn_fmwrk_stacks illustrates the service stack combinations for DetNet. At the service layer IP, MPLS and TSN (as an L2 VPN) offer detnet services. (TSN is also a native L2 DetNet Service covered in IEEE8021Q.) These services can be stacked as illustrated. For example, IP DetNet can be delivered purely as an IP service. Or IP DetNet can leverage MPLS for service and forwarding or just MPLS forwaring. As a result IP DenNet can have acces to MPLS traffic Engineering. Alternatively IP DetNet can leverage TSN by leveraging Ethenret with TSN. The diagram shows several common permutations." "Branch for review Merge it ! Changes look good - clicking correct button this time" 215d293ca11d1a96b10664fe5db5be2326ffc8d9 215d293ca11d1a96b10664fe5db5be2326ffc8d9 draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework c0c46a44c439b6c63bd7bfbf690de81f100f1e797d4f1a1daf4cb2e4f9f87129 ['023f961d619971c6f51af4be85aa80ec6148a5573fc27824d42b1f0d62a1a888', '067d9859172cde5eacf03abfc795fad05c27315c3d877321a836289497410bf5', 'abf026ee8a31a9f2648f2b58fbc4f713ca6dcbfdd0bba66fea03ecd28ea90332', '11ad0e3d084e84d0f894abcc3f46f35b920669c902de0fd0c1c0b70b5a277503', 'd75a171663a1ff923d830df8dea16b22f884b2af11dbe9e73f8ed147123783d9', '2774d0351348728e076d27562ba4835d550b613b2092435ce2b73b72b1bbf04d', '7f196d71ae3dd553e6306aad4f0e7f0515bbcf2696b05eed10292049a0413c74', 'd0bcc637bfa20f222ac98b878a724978687152e9aeb24cd06c2f2a3d57d9efd5', 'f18684001a1fff593e10b1bf9355a982468c2a0c39067b978ca670f996abc812', 'b7e4ce467d4406a06a4bcffed356d40bc68aa391b3f641ca58f2c49a28d5d72d', 'c0c46a44c439b6c63bd7bfbf690de81f100f1e797d4f1a1daf4cb2e4f9f87129', '8c6d08b2077f63af242b017cc8f33cd6eb524769fc73b1f6bbd818077d449078', '6ca6d19228d672f558c97be9cf7514386bcc666768700a0a9697e6ac657b8621', '1ae09bae308713aec5b1fdccd6eea1c9de1834329c0a092a309ce2b0a147778b'] A "dn_fmwrk_stacks illustrates the service stack combinations for detnet. at the service layer ip, mpls and tsn (as an l2 vpn) offer detnet services. (tsn is also a native l2 detnet service covered in ieee8021q.) these services can be stacked as illustrated. for example, ip detnet can be delivered purely as an ip service. or ip detnet can leverage mpls for service and forwarding or just mpls forwaring. as a result ip dennet can have acces to mpls traffic engineering. alternatively ip detnet can leverage tsn by leveraging ethenret with tsn. the diagram shows several common permutations." {8: 1, 79: 9, 90: 7, 51: 9, 130: 9, 62: 8, 85: 8, 68: 2, 35: 10, 110: 10, 91: 12, 114: 10, 97: 10, 31: 2, 13: 9, 67: 9, 38: 11, 26: 8, 124: 9, 98: 9, 54: 9, 127: 10, 6: 7, 96: 10, 64: 9, 30: 11, 61: 12, 55: 3, 27: 8, 15: 10, 52: 8, 129: 10, 115: 10, 84: 5, 76: 10, 87: 10, 131: 12, 102: 7, 113: 12, 99: 9, 36: 10, 24: 9, 53: 8, 72: 11} {218: 1, 330: 1, 4: 9, 9: 9, 10: 10, 15: 10, 24: 9, 25: 8, 26: 8, 27: 10, 39: 4, 43: 10, 49: 13, 50: 12, 58: 12, 59: 9, 64: 10, 69: 8, 81: 9, 82: 9, 86: 10, 96: 11, 97: 10, 100: 12, 108: 10, 109: 11, 110: 11, 111: 9, 114: 10, 115: 11, 116: 10, 118: 9, 119: 8, 120: 10, 121: 7, 122: 11, 123: 10, 124: 6, 128: 11, 129: 11, 130: 12, 132: 8, 136: 9, 145: 8, 147: 11, 151: 11, 152: 11, 154: 10, 156: 9, 161: 7, 162: 6, 165: 10, 168: 11, 169: 10, 172: 10, 180: 11, 184: 9, 187: 12, 188: 11, 191: 10, 194: 8, 202: 9, 203: 10, 206: 9, 207: 10, 215: 8, 217: 10, 220: 7, 221: 7, 222: 6, 224: 10, 227: 10, 229: 10, 234: 12, 235: 9, 241: 9, 242: 9, 243: 8, 244: 11, 245: 8, 248: 11, 250: 11, 258: 2, 262: 11, 263: 12, 264: 8, 267: 7, 270: 10, 272: 10, 273: 9, 287: 10, 289: 10, 291: 12, 299: 10, 300: 10, 304: 10, 309: 7, 314: 9, 315: 10, 320: 7, 323: 8, 327: 11, 328: 9, 329: 9, 334: 9, 335: 10, 341: 10, 342: 11, 347: 10, 348: 10, 350: 11, 351: 12, 352: 10, 353: 10, 354: 9, 358: 5, 365: 10, 366: 9, 369: 8, 371: 12, 372: 12, 376: 9, 384: 12, 385: 11, 386: 10, 387: 10, 392: 9, 393: 10, 396: 11, 397: 2, 398: 3, 402: 10} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 6 "MPLS provides the abbility to forward traffic over implicit and explicit paths to the point in the network where the next DetNet service layer action needs to take place. It does this through the use of a stack of one or more labels with various forwarding semantics." "Branch for review Merge it ! Changes look good - clicking correct button this time" 215d293ca11d1a96b10664fe5db5be2326ffc8d9 215d293ca11d1a96b10664fe5db5be2326ffc8d9 draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework b7e4ce467d4406a06a4bcffed356d40bc68aa391b3f641ca58f2c49a28d5d72d ['023f961d619971c6f51af4be85aa80ec6148a5573fc27824d42b1f0d62a1a888', '067d9859172cde5eacf03abfc795fad05c27315c3d877321a836289497410bf5', 'abf026ee8a31a9f2648f2b58fbc4f713ca6dcbfdd0bba66fea03ecd28ea90332', '11ad0e3d084e84d0f894abcc3f46f35b920669c902de0fd0c1c0b70b5a277503', 'd75a171663a1ff923d830df8dea16b22f884b2af11dbe9e73f8ed147123783d9', '2774d0351348728e076d27562ba4835d550b613b2092435ce2b73b72b1bbf04d', '7f196d71ae3dd553e6306aad4f0e7f0515bbcf2696b05eed10292049a0413c74', 'd0bcc637bfa20f222ac98b878a724978687152e9aeb24cd06c2f2a3d57d9efd5', 'f18684001a1fff593e10b1bf9355a982468c2a0c39067b978ca670f996abc812', 'b7e4ce467d4406a06a4bcffed356d40bc68aa391b3f641ca58f2c49a28d5d72d', 'c0c46a44c439b6c63bd7bfbf690de81f100f1e797d4f1a1daf4cb2e4f9f87129', '8c6d08b2077f63af242b017cc8f33cd6eb524769fc73b1f6bbd818077d449078', '6ca6d19228d672f558c97be9cf7514386bcc666768700a0a9697e6ac657b8621', '1ae09bae308713aec5b1fdccd6eea1c9de1834329c0a092a309ce2b0a147778b'] A "mpls provides the abbility to forward traffic over implicit and explicit paths to the point in the network where the next detnet service layer action needs to take place. it does this through the use of a stack of one or more labels with various forwarding semantics." {8: 1, 79: 9, 90: 7, 51: 9, 130: 9, 62: 8, 85: 8, 68: 2, 35: 10, 110: 10, 91: 12, 114: 10, 97: 10, 31: 2, 13: 9, 67: 9, 38: 11, 26: 8, 124: 9, 98: 9, 54: 9, 127: 10, 6: 7, 96: 10, 64: 9, 30: 11, 61: 12, 55: 3, 27: 8, 15: 10, 52: 8, 129: 10, 115: 10, 84: 5, 76: 10, 87: 10, 131: 12, 102: 7, 113: 12, 99: 9, 36: 10, 24: 9, 53: 8, 72: 11} {218: 1, 330: 1, 4: 9, 9: 9, 10: 10, 15: 10, 24: 9, 25: 8, 26: 8, 27: 10, 39: 4, 43: 10, 49: 13, 50: 12, 58: 12, 59: 9, 64: 10, 69: 8, 81: 9, 82: 9, 86: 10, 96: 11, 97: 10, 100: 12, 108: 10, 109: 11, 110: 11, 111: 9, 114: 10, 115: 11, 116: 10, 118: 9, 119: 8, 120: 10, 121: 7, 122: 11, 123: 10, 124: 6, 128: 11, 129: 11, 130: 12, 132: 8, 136: 9, 145: 8, 147: 11, 151: 11, 152: 11, 154: 10, 156: 9, 161: 7, 162: 6, 165: 10, 168: 11, 169: 10, 172: 10, 180: 11, 184: 9, 187: 12, 188: 11, 191: 10, 194: 8, 202: 9, 203: 10, 206: 9, 207: 10, 215: 8, 217: 10, 220: 7, 221: 7, 222: 6, 224: 10, 227: 10, 229: 10, 234: 12, 235: 9, 241: 9, 242: 9, 243: 8, 244: 11, 245: 8, 248: 11, 250: 11, 258: 2, 262: 11, 263: 12, 264: 8, 267: 7, 270: 10, 272: 10, 273: 9, 287: 10, 289: 10, 291: 12, 299: 10, 300: 10, 304: 10, 309: 7, 314: 9, 315: 10, 320: 7, 323: 8, 327: 11, 328: 9, 329: 9, 334: 9, 335: 10, 341: 10, 342: 11, 347: 10, 348: 10, 350: 11, 351: 12, 352: 10, 353: 10, 354: 9, 358: 5, 365: 10, 366: 9, 369: 8, 371: 12, 372: 12, 376: 9, 384: 12, 385: 11, 386: 10, 387: 10, 392: 9, 393: 10, 396: 11, 397: 2, 398: 3, 402: 10} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 6 "MPLS also provides the ability to identify a service instance that is to process the packet through the use of a label that maps the packet to a service instance." "Branch for review Merge it ! Changes look good - clicking correct button this time" 215d293ca11d1a96b10664fe5db5be2326ffc8d9 215d293ca11d1a96b10664fe5db5be2326ffc8d9 draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework abf026ee8a31a9f2648f2b58fbc4f713ca6dcbfdd0bba66fea03ecd28ea90332 ['023f961d619971c6f51af4be85aa80ec6148a5573fc27824d42b1f0d62a1a888', '067d9859172cde5eacf03abfc795fad05c27315c3d877321a836289497410bf5', 'abf026ee8a31a9f2648f2b58fbc4f713ca6dcbfdd0bba66fea03ecd28ea90332', '11ad0e3d084e84d0f894abcc3f46f35b920669c902de0fd0c1c0b70b5a277503', 'd75a171663a1ff923d830df8dea16b22f884b2af11dbe9e73f8ed147123783d9', '2774d0351348728e076d27562ba4835d550b613b2092435ce2b73b72b1bbf04d', '7f196d71ae3dd553e6306aad4f0e7f0515bbcf2696b05eed10292049a0413c74', 'd0bcc637bfa20f222ac98b878a724978687152e9aeb24cd06c2f2a3d57d9efd5', 'f18684001a1fff593e10b1bf9355a982468c2a0c39067b978ca670f996abc812', 'b7e4ce467d4406a06a4bcffed356d40bc68aa391b3f641ca58f2c49a28d5d72d', 'c0c46a44c439b6c63bd7bfbf690de81f100f1e797d4f1a1daf4cb2e4f9f87129', '8c6d08b2077f63af242b017cc8f33cd6eb524769fc73b1f6bbd818077d449078', '6ca6d19228d672f558c97be9cf7514386bcc666768700a0a9697e6ac657b8621', '1ae09bae308713aec5b1fdccd6eea1c9de1834329c0a092a309ce2b0a147778b'] A "mpls also provides the ability to identify a service instance that is to process the packet through the use of a label that maps the packet to a service instance." {8: 1, 79: 9, 90: 7, 51: 9, 130: 9, 62: 8, 85: 8, 68: 2, 35: 10, 110: 10, 91: 12, 114: 10, 97: 10, 31: 2, 13: 9, 67: 9, 38: 11, 26: 8, 124: 9, 98: 9, 54: 9, 127: 10, 6: 7, 96: 10, 64: 9, 30: 11, 61: 12, 55: 3, 27: 8, 15: 10, 52: 8, 129: 10, 115: 10, 84: 5, 76: 10, 87: 10, 131: 12, 102: 7, 113: 12, 99: 9, 36: 10, 24: 9, 53: 8, 72: 11} {218: 1, 330: 1, 4: 9, 9: 9, 10: 10, 15: 10, 24: 9, 25: 8, 26: 8, 27: 10, 39: 4, 43: 10, 49: 13, 50: 12, 58: 12, 59: 9, 64: 10, 69: 8, 81: 9, 82: 9, 86: 10, 96: 11, 97: 10, 100: 12, 108: 10, 109: 11, 110: 11, 111: 9, 114: 10, 115: 11, 116: 10, 118: 9, 119: 8, 120: 10, 121: 7, 122: 11, 123: 10, 124: 6, 128: 11, 129: 11, 130: 12, 132: 8, 136: 9, 145: 8, 147: 11, 151: 11, 152: 11, 154: 10, 156: 9, 161: 7, 162: 6, 165: 10, 168: 11, 169: 10, 172: 10, 180: 11, 184: 9, 187: 12, 188: 11, 191: 10, 194: 8, 202: 9, 203: 10, 206: 9, 207: 10, 215: 8, 217: 10, 220: 7, 221: 7, 222: 6, 224: 10, 227: 10, 229: 10, 234: 12, 235: 9, 241: 9, 242: 9, 243: 8, 244: 11, 245: 8, 248: 11, 250: 11, 258: 2, 262: 11, 263: 12, 264: 8, 267: 7, 270: 10, 272: 10, 273: 9, 287: 10, 289: 10, 291: 12, 299: 10, 300: 10, 304: 10, 309: 7, 314: 9, 315: 10, 320: 7, 323: 8, 327: 11, 328: 9, 329: 9, 334: 9, 335: 10, 341: 10, 342: 11, 347: 10, 348: 10, 350: 11, 351: 12, 352: 10, 353: 10, 354: 9, 358: 5, 365: 10, 366: 9, 369: 8, 371: 12, 372: 12, 376: 9, 384: 12, 385: 11, 386: 10, 387: 10, 392: 9, 393: 10, 396: 11, 397: 2, 398: 3, 402: 10} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 6 "In cases where metadata is needed to process an MPLS encapsulated packet at the service layer, this has been been provided through the use of a shim layer also called a control word (CW) RFC4385. Although such CWs are requently 32 bits long, there is no architectural constraint on its size of this structure, only the requirement that it is fully understood by all parties operating on it in the DetNet service layer." "Branch for review Merge it ! Changes look good - clicking correct button this time" 215d293ca11d1a96b10664fe5db5be2326ffc8d9 215d293ca11d1a96b10664fe5db5be2326ffc8d9 draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework 7f196d71ae3dd553e6306aad4f0e7f0515bbcf2696b05eed10292049a0413c74 ['023f961d619971c6f51af4be85aa80ec6148a5573fc27824d42b1f0d62a1a888', '067d9859172cde5eacf03abfc795fad05c27315c3d877321a836289497410bf5', 'abf026ee8a31a9f2648f2b58fbc4f713ca6dcbfdd0bba66fea03ecd28ea90332', '11ad0e3d084e84d0f894abcc3f46f35b920669c902de0fd0c1c0b70b5a277503', 'd75a171663a1ff923d830df8dea16b22f884b2af11dbe9e73f8ed147123783d9', '2774d0351348728e076d27562ba4835d550b613b2092435ce2b73b72b1bbf04d', '7f196d71ae3dd553e6306aad4f0e7f0515bbcf2696b05eed10292049a0413c74', 'd0bcc637bfa20f222ac98b878a724978687152e9aeb24cd06c2f2a3d57d9efd5', 'f18684001a1fff593e10b1bf9355a982468c2a0c39067b978ca670f996abc812', 'b7e4ce467d4406a06a4bcffed356d40bc68aa391b3f641ca58f2c49a28d5d72d', 'c0c46a44c439b6c63bd7bfbf690de81f100f1e797d4f1a1daf4cb2e4f9f87129', '8c6d08b2077f63af242b017cc8f33cd6eb524769fc73b1f6bbd818077d449078', '6ca6d19228d672f558c97be9cf7514386bcc666768700a0a9697e6ac657b8621', '1ae09bae308713aec5b1fdccd6eea1c9de1834329c0a092a309ce2b0a147778b'] A "in cases where metadata is needed to process an mpls encapsulated packet at the service layer, this has been been provided through the use of a shim layer also called a control word (cw) rfc4385. although such cws are requently 32 bits long, there is no architectural constraint on its size of this structure, only the requirement that it is fully understood by all parties operating on it in the detnet service layer." {8: 1, 79: 9, 90: 7, 51: 9, 130: 9, 62: 8, 85: 8, 68: 2, 35: 10, 110: 10, 91: 12, 114: 10, 97: 10, 31: 2, 13: 9, 67: 9, 38: 11, 26: 8, 124: 9, 98: 9, 54: 9, 127: 10, 6: 7, 96: 10, 64: 9, 30: 11, 61: 12, 55: 3, 27: 8, 15: 10, 52: 8, 129: 10, 115: 10, 84: 5, 76: 10, 87: 10, 131: 12, 102: 7, 113: 12, 99: 9, 36: 10, 24: 9, 53: 8, 72: 11} {218: 1, 330: 1, 4: 9, 9: 9, 10: 10, 15: 10, 24: 9, 25: 8, 26: 8, 27: 10, 39: 4, 43: 10, 49: 13, 50: 12, 58: 12, 59: 9, 64: 10, 69: 8, 81: 9, 82: 9, 86: 10, 96: 11, 97: 10, 100: 12, 108: 10, 109: 11, 110: 11, 111: 9, 114: 10, 115: 11, 116: 10, 118: 9, 119: 8, 120: 10, 121: 7, 122: 11, 123: 10, 124: 6, 128: 11, 129: 11, 130: 12, 132: 8, 136: 9, 145: 8, 147: 11, 151: 11, 152: 11, 154: 10, 156: 9, 161: 7, 162: 6, 165: 10, 168: 11, 169: 10, 172: 10, 180: 11, 184: 9, 187: 12, 188: 11, 191: 10, 194: 8, 202: 9, 203: 10, 206: 9, 207: 10, 215: 8, 217: 10, 220: 7, 221: 7, 222: 6, 224: 10, 227: 10, 229: 10, 234: 12, 235: 9, 241: 9, 242: 9, 243: 8, 244: 11, 245: 8, 248: 11, 250: 11, 258: 2, 262: 11, 263: 12, 264: 8, 267: 7, 270: 10, 272: 10, 273: 9, 287: 10, 289: 10, 291: 12, 299: 10, 300: 10, 304: 10, 309: 7, 314: 9, 315: 10, 320: 7, 323: 8, 327: 11, 328: 9, 329: 9, 334: 9, 335: 10, 341: 10, 342: 11, 347: 10, 348: 10, 350: 11, 351: 12, 352: 10, 353: 10, 354: 9, 358: 5, 365: 10, 366: 9, 369: 8, 371: 12, 372: 12, 376: 9, 384: 12, 385: 11, 386: 10, 387: 10, 392: 9, 393: 10, 396: 11, 397: 2, 398: 3, 402: 10} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 6 "One method of operating an IP DetNet data plane without encapsulation is to use ""6-tuple"" based flow identification, where ""6-tuple"" refers to information carried in IP and higher layer protocol headers. General background on the use of IP headers, and ""5-tuples"", to identify flows and support Quality of Service (QoS) can be found in RFC3670. RFC7657 also provides useful background on the delivery differentiated services (DiffServ) and ""tuple"" based flow identification. DetNet flow aggregation may be enabled via the use of wildcards, masks, prefixes and ranges. The operation of this method is described in detail in I-D.ietf-detnet-ip." "Branch for review Merge it ! Changes look good - clicking correct button this time" 215d293ca11d1a96b10664fe5db5be2326ffc8d9 215d293ca11d1a96b10664fe5db5be2326ffc8d9 draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework 023f961d619971c6f51af4be85aa80ec6148a5573fc27824d42b1f0d62a1a888 ['023f961d619971c6f51af4be85aa80ec6148a5573fc27824d42b1f0d62a1a888', '067d9859172cde5eacf03abfc795fad05c27315c3d877321a836289497410bf5', 'abf026ee8a31a9f2648f2b58fbc4f713ca6dcbfdd0bba66fea03ecd28ea90332', '11ad0e3d084e84d0f894abcc3f46f35b920669c902de0fd0c1c0b70b5a277503', 'd75a171663a1ff923d830df8dea16b22f884b2af11dbe9e73f8ed147123783d9', '2774d0351348728e076d27562ba4835d550b613b2092435ce2b73b72b1bbf04d', '7f196d71ae3dd553e6306aad4f0e7f0515bbcf2696b05eed10292049a0413c74', 'd0bcc637bfa20f222ac98b878a724978687152e9aeb24cd06c2f2a3d57d9efd5', 'f18684001a1fff593e10b1bf9355a982468c2a0c39067b978ca670f996abc812', 'b7e4ce467d4406a06a4bcffed356d40bc68aa391b3f641ca58f2c49a28d5d72d', 'c0c46a44c439b6c63bd7bfbf690de81f100f1e797d4f1a1daf4cb2e4f9f87129', '8c6d08b2077f63af242b017cc8f33cd6eb524769fc73b1f6bbd818077d449078', '6ca6d19228d672f558c97be9cf7514386bcc666768700a0a9697e6ac657b8621', '1ae09bae308713aec5b1fdccd6eea1c9de1834329c0a092a309ce2b0a147778b'] B "one method of operating an ip detnet data plane without encapsulation is to use ""6-tuple"" based flow identification, where ""6-tuple"" refers to information carried in ip and higher layer protocol headers. general background on the use of ip headers, and ""5-tuples"", to identify flows and support quality of service (qos) can be found in rfc3670. rfc7657 also provides useful background on the delivery differentiated services (diffserv) and ""tuple"" based flow identification. detnet flow aggregation may be enabled via the use of wildcards, masks, prefixes and ranges. the operation of this method is described in detail in i-d.ietf-detnet-ip." {8: 1, 79: 9, 90: 7, 51: 9, 130: 9, 62: 8, 85: 8, 68: 2, 35: 10, 110: 10, 91: 12, 114: 10, 97: 10, 31: 2, 13: 9, 67: 9, 38: 11, 26: 8, 124: 9, 98: 9, 54: 9, 127: 10, 6: 7, 96: 10, 64: 9, 30: 11, 61: 12, 55: 3, 27: 8, 15: 10, 52: 8, 129: 10, 115: 10, 84: 5, 76: 10, 87: 10, 131: 12, 102: 7, 113: 12, 99: 9, 36: 10, 24: 9, 53: 8, 72: 11} {218: 1, 330: 1, 4: 9, 9: 9, 10: 10, 15: 10, 24: 9, 25: 8, 26: 8, 27: 10, 39: 4, 43: 10, 49: 13, 50: 12, 58: 12, 59: 9, 64: 10, 69: 8, 81: 9, 82: 9, 86: 10, 96: 11, 97: 10, 100: 12, 108: 10, 109: 11, 110: 11, 111: 9, 114: 10, 115: 11, 116: 10, 118: 9, 119: 8, 120: 10, 121: 7, 122: 11, 123: 10, 124: 6, 128: 11, 129: 11, 130: 12, 132: 8, 136: 9, 145: 8, 147: 11, 151: 11, 152: 11, 154: 10, 156: 9, 161: 7, 162: 6, 165: 10, 168: 11, 169: 10, 172: 10, 180: 11, 184: 9, 187: 12, 188: 11, 191: 10, 194: 8, 202: 9, 203: 10, 206: 9, 207: 10, 215: 8, 217: 10, 220: 7, 221: 7, 222: 6, 224: 10, 227: 10, 229: 10, 234: 12, 235: 9, 241: 9, 242: 9, 243: 8, 244: 11, 245: 8, 248: 11, 250: 11, 258: 2, 262: 11, 263: 12, 264: 8, 267: 7, 270: 10, 272: 10, 273: 9, 287: 10, 289: 10, 291: 12, 299: 10, 300: 10, 304: 10, 309: 7, 314: 9, 315: 10, 320: 7, 323: 8, 327: 11, 328: 9, 329: 9, 334: 9, 335: 10, 341: 10, 342: 11, 347: 10, 348: 10, 350: 11, 351: 12, 352: 10, 353: 10, 354: 9, 358: 5, 365: 10, 366: 9, 369: 8, 371: 12, 372: 12, 376: 9, 384: 12, 385: 11, 386: 10, 387: 10, 392: 9, 393: 10, 396: 11, 397: 2, 398: 3, 402: 10} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 6 "The DetNet forwarding plane may use explicit route capabilities and traffic engineering capabilities to provide a forwarding sub-layer that is responsible for providing resource allocation and explicit routes. It is possible to include metadata in a native IP packet explicitly, or implicitly." "Branch for review Merge it ! Changes look good - clicking correct button this time" 215d293ca11d1a96b10664fe5db5be2326ffc8d9 215d293ca11d1a96b10664fe5db5be2326ffc8d9 draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework d75a171663a1ff923d830df8dea16b22f884b2af11dbe9e73f8ed147123783d9 ['023f961d619971c6f51af4be85aa80ec6148a5573fc27824d42b1f0d62a1a888', '067d9859172cde5eacf03abfc795fad05c27315c3d877321a836289497410bf5', 'abf026ee8a31a9f2648f2b58fbc4f713ca6dcbfdd0bba66fea03ecd28ea90332', '11ad0e3d084e84d0f894abcc3f46f35b920669c902de0fd0c1c0b70b5a277503', 'd75a171663a1ff923d830df8dea16b22f884b2af11dbe9e73f8ed147123783d9', '2774d0351348728e076d27562ba4835d550b613b2092435ce2b73b72b1bbf04d', '7f196d71ae3dd553e6306aad4f0e7f0515bbcf2696b05eed10292049a0413c74', 'd0bcc637bfa20f222ac98b878a724978687152e9aeb24cd06c2f2a3d57d9efd5', 'f18684001a1fff593e10b1bf9355a982468c2a0c39067b978ca670f996abc812', 'b7e4ce467d4406a06a4bcffed356d40bc68aa391b3f641ca58f2c49a28d5d72d', 'c0c46a44c439b6c63bd7bfbf690de81f100f1e797d4f1a1daf4cb2e4f9f87129', '8c6d08b2077f63af242b017cc8f33cd6eb524769fc73b1f6bbd818077d449078', '6ca6d19228d672f558c97be9cf7514386bcc666768700a0a9697e6ac657b8621', '1ae09bae308713aec5b1fdccd6eea1c9de1834329c0a092a309ce2b0a147778b'] B "the detnet forwarding plane may use explicit route capabilities and traffic engineering capabilities to provide a forwarding sub-layer that is responsible for providing resource allocation and explicit routes. it is possible to include metadata in a native ip packet explicitly, or implicitly." {8: 1, 79: 9, 90: 7, 51: 9, 130: 9, 62: 8, 85: 8, 68: 2, 35: 10, 110: 10, 91: 12, 114: 10, 97: 10, 31: 2, 13: 9, 67: 9, 38: 11, 26: 8, 124: 9, 98: 9, 54: 9, 127: 10, 6: 7, 96: 10, 64: 9, 30: 11, 61: 12, 55: 3, 27: 8, 15: 10, 52: 8, 129: 10, 115: 10, 84: 5, 76: 10, 87: 10, 131: 12, 102: 7, 113: 12, 99: 9, 36: 10, 24: 9, 53: 8, 72: 11} {218: 1, 330: 1, 4: 9, 9: 9, 10: 10, 15: 10, 24: 9, 25: 8, 26: 8, 27: 10, 39: 4, 43: 10, 49: 13, 50: 12, 58: 12, 59: 9, 64: 10, 69: 8, 81: 9, 82: 9, 86: 10, 96: 11, 97: 10, 100: 12, 108: 10, 109: 11, 110: 11, 111: 9, 114: 10, 115: 11, 116: 10, 118: 9, 119: 8, 120: 10, 121: 7, 122: 11, 123: 10, 124: 6, 128: 11, 129: 11, 130: 12, 132: 8, 136: 9, 145: 8, 147: 11, 151: 11, 152: 11, 154: 10, 156: 9, 161: 7, 162: 6, 165: 10, 168: 11, 169: 10, 172: 10, 180: 11, 184: 9, 187: 12, 188: 11, 191: 10, 194: 8, 202: 9, 203: 10, 206: 9, 207: 10, 215: 8, 217: 10, 220: 7, 221: 7, 222: 6, 224: 10, 227: 10, 229: 10, 234: 12, 235: 9, 241: 9, 242: 9, 243: 8, 244: 11, 245: 8, 248: 11, 250: 11, 258: 2, 262: 11, 263: 12, 264: 8, 267: 7, 270: 10, 272: 10, 273: 9, 287: 10, 289: 10, 291: 12, 299: 10, 300: 10, 304: 10, 309: 7, 314: 9, 315: 10, 320: 7, 323: 8, 327: 11, 328: 9, 329: 9, 334: 9, 335: 10, 341: 10, 342: 11, 347: 10, 348: 10, 350: 11, 351: 12, 352: 10, 353: 10, 354: 9, 358: 5, 365: 10, 366: 9, 369: 8, 371: 12, 372: 12, 376: 9, 384: 12, 385: 11, 386: 10, 387: 10, 392: 9, 393: 10, 396: 11, 397: 2, 398: 3, 402: 10} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 6 "MPLS provides the ability to forward traffic over implicit and explicit paths to the point in the network where the next DetNet service layer action needs to take place. It does this through the use of a stack of one or more labels with various forwarding semantics." "Branch for review Merge it ! Changes look good - clicking correct button this time" 215d293ca11d1a96b10664fe5db5be2326ffc8d9 215d293ca11d1a96b10664fe5db5be2326ffc8d9 draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework d0bcc637bfa20f222ac98b878a724978687152e9aeb24cd06c2f2a3d57d9efd5 ['023f961d619971c6f51af4be85aa80ec6148a5573fc27824d42b1f0d62a1a888', '067d9859172cde5eacf03abfc795fad05c27315c3d877321a836289497410bf5', 'abf026ee8a31a9f2648f2b58fbc4f713ca6dcbfdd0bba66fea03ecd28ea90332', '11ad0e3d084e84d0f894abcc3f46f35b920669c902de0fd0c1c0b70b5a277503', 'd75a171663a1ff923d830df8dea16b22f884b2af11dbe9e73f8ed147123783d9', '2774d0351348728e076d27562ba4835d550b613b2092435ce2b73b72b1bbf04d', '7f196d71ae3dd553e6306aad4f0e7f0515bbcf2696b05eed10292049a0413c74', 'd0bcc637bfa20f222ac98b878a724978687152e9aeb24cd06c2f2a3d57d9efd5', 'f18684001a1fff593e10b1bf9355a982468c2a0c39067b978ca670f996abc812', 'b7e4ce467d4406a06a4bcffed356d40bc68aa391b3f641ca58f2c49a28d5d72d', 'c0c46a44c439b6c63bd7bfbf690de81f100f1e797d4f1a1daf4cb2e4f9f87129', '8c6d08b2077f63af242b017cc8f33cd6eb524769fc73b1f6bbd818077d449078', '6ca6d19228d672f558c97be9cf7514386bcc666768700a0a9697e6ac657b8621', '1ae09bae308713aec5b1fdccd6eea1c9de1834329c0a092a309ce2b0a147778b'] B "mpls provides the ability to forward traffic over implicit and explicit paths to the point in the network where the next detnet service layer action needs to take place. it does this through the use of a stack of one or more labels with various forwarding semantics." {8: 1, 79: 9, 90: 7, 51: 9, 130: 9, 62: 8, 85: 8, 68: 2, 35: 10, 110: 10, 91: 12, 114: 10, 97: 10, 31: 2, 13: 9, 67: 9, 38: 11, 26: 8, 124: 9, 98: 9, 54: 9, 127: 10, 6: 7, 96: 10, 64: 9, 30: 11, 61: 12, 55: 3, 27: 8, 15: 10, 52: 8, 129: 10, 115: 10, 84: 5, 76: 10, 87: 10, 131: 12, 102: 7, 113: 12, 99: 9, 36: 10, 24: 9, 53: 8, 72: 11} {218: 1, 330: 1, 4: 9, 9: 9, 10: 10, 15: 10, 24: 9, 25: 8, 26: 8, 27: 10, 39: 4, 43: 10, 49: 13, 50: 12, 58: 12, 59: 9, 64: 10, 69: 8, 81: 9, 82: 9, 86: 10, 96: 11, 97: 10, 100: 12, 108: 10, 109: 11, 110: 11, 111: 9, 114: 10, 115: 11, 116: 10, 118: 9, 119: 8, 120: 10, 121: 7, 122: 11, 123: 10, 124: 6, 128: 11, 129: 11, 130: 12, 132: 8, 136: 9, 145: 8, 147: 11, 151: 11, 152: 11, 154: 10, 156: 9, 161: 7, 162: 6, 165: 10, 168: 11, 169: 10, 172: 10, 180: 11, 184: 9, 187: 12, 188: 11, 191: 10, 194: 8, 202: 9, 203: 10, 206: 9, 207: 10, 215: 8, 217: 10, 220: 7, 221: 7, 222: 6, 224: 10, 227: 10, 229: 10, 234: 12, 235: 9, 241: 9, 242: 9, 243: 8, 244: 11, 245: 8, 248: 11, 250: 11, 258: 2, 262: 11, 263: 12, 264: 8, 267: 7, 270: 10, 272: 10, 273: 9, 287: 10, 289: 10, 291: 12, 299: 10, 300: 10, 304: 10, 309: 7, 314: 9, 315: 10, 320: 7, 323: 8, 327: 11, 328: 9, 329: 9, 334: 9, 335: 10, 341: 10, 342: 11, 347: 10, 348: 10, 350: 11, 351: 12, 352: 10, 353: 10, 354: 9, 358: 5, 365: 10, 366: 9, 369: 8, 371: 12, 372: 12, 376: 9, 384: 12, 385: 11, 386: 10, 387: 10, 392: 9, 393: 10, 396: 11, 397: 2, 398: 3, 402: 10} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 6 "MPLS also provides the ability to identify a service instance that is used to process the packet through the use of a label that maps the packet to a service instance." "Branch for review Merge it ! Changes look good - clicking correct button this time" 215d293ca11d1a96b10664fe5db5be2326ffc8d9 215d293ca11d1a96b10664fe5db5be2326ffc8d9 draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework 1ae09bae308713aec5b1fdccd6eea1c9de1834329c0a092a309ce2b0a147778b ['023f961d619971c6f51af4be85aa80ec6148a5573fc27824d42b1f0d62a1a888', '067d9859172cde5eacf03abfc795fad05c27315c3d877321a836289497410bf5', 'abf026ee8a31a9f2648f2b58fbc4f713ca6dcbfdd0bba66fea03ecd28ea90332', '11ad0e3d084e84d0f894abcc3f46f35b920669c902de0fd0c1c0b70b5a277503', 'd75a171663a1ff923d830df8dea16b22f884b2af11dbe9e73f8ed147123783d9', '2774d0351348728e076d27562ba4835d550b613b2092435ce2b73b72b1bbf04d', '7f196d71ae3dd553e6306aad4f0e7f0515bbcf2696b05eed10292049a0413c74', 'd0bcc637bfa20f222ac98b878a724978687152e9aeb24cd06c2f2a3d57d9efd5', 'f18684001a1fff593e10b1bf9355a982468c2a0c39067b978ca670f996abc812', 'b7e4ce467d4406a06a4bcffed356d40bc68aa391b3f641ca58f2c49a28d5d72d', 'c0c46a44c439b6c63bd7bfbf690de81f100f1e797d4f1a1daf4cb2e4f9f87129', '8c6d08b2077f63af242b017cc8f33cd6eb524769fc73b1f6bbd818077d449078', '6ca6d19228d672f558c97be9cf7514386bcc666768700a0a9697e6ac657b8621', '1ae09bae308713aec5b1fdccd6eea1c9de1834329c0a092a309ce2b0a147778b'] B "mpls also provides the ability to identify a service instance that is used to process the packet through the use of a label that maps the packet to a service instance." {8: 1, 79: 9, 90: 7, 51: 9, 130: 9, 62: 8, 85: 8, 68: 2, 35: 10, 110: 10, 91: 12, 114: 10, 97: 10, 31: 2, 13: 9, 67: 9, 38: 11, 26: 8, 124: 9, 98: 9, 54: 9, 127: 10, 6: 7, 96: 10, 64: 9, 30: 11, 61: 12, 55: 3, 27: 8, 15: 10, 52: 8, 129: 10, 115: 10, 84: 5, 76: 10, 87: 10, 131: 12, 102: 7, 113: 12, 99: 9, 36: 10, 24: 9, 53: 8, 72: 11} {218: 1, 330: 1, 4: 9, 9: 9, 10: 10, 15: 10, 24: 9, 25: 8, 26: 8, 27: 10, 39: 4, 43: 10, 49: 13, 50: 12, 58: 12, 59: 9, 64: 10, 69: 8, 81: 9, 82: 9, 86: 10, 96: 11, 97: 10, 100: 12, 108: 10, 109: 11, 110: 11, 111: 9, 114: 10, 115: 11, 116: 10, 118: 9, 119: 8, 120: 10, 121: 7, 122: 11, 123: 10, 124: 6, 128: 11, 129: 11, 130: 12, 132: 8, 136: 9, 145: 8, 147: 11, 151: 11, 152: 11, 154: 10, 156: 9, 161: 7, 162: 6, 165: 10, 168: 11, 169: 10, 172: 10, 180: 11, 184: 9, 187: 12, 188: 11, 191: 10, 194: 8, 202: 9, 203: 10, 206: 9, 207: 10, 215: 8, 217: 10, 220: 7, 221: 7, 222: 6, 224: 10, 227: 10, 229: 10, 234: 12, 235: 9, 241: 9, 242: 9, 243: 8, 244: 11, 245: 8, 248: 11, 250: 11, 258: 2, 262: 11, 263: 12, 264: 8, 267: 7, 270: 10, 272: 10, 273: 9, 287: 10, 289: 10, 291: 12, 299: 10, 300: 10, 304: 10, 309: 7, 314: 9, 315: 10, 320: 7, 323: 8, 327: 11, 328: 9, 329: 9, 334: 9, 335: 10, 341: 10, 342: 11, 347: 10, 348: 10, 350: 11, 351: 12, 352: 10, 353: 10, 354: 9, 358: 5, 365: 10, 366: 9, 369: 8, 371: 12, 372: 12, 376: 9, 384: 12, 385: 11, 386: 10, 387: 10, 392: 9, 393: 10, 396: 11, 397: 2, 398: 3, 402: 10} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 6 "In cases where metadata is needed to process an MPLS encapsulated packet at the service layer, this has been been provided through the use of a shim layer also called a control word (CW) RFC4385. Although such CWs are frequently 32 bits long, there is no architectural constraint on its size of this structure, only the requirement that it is fully understood by all parties operating on it in the DetNet service layer. The operation of this method is described in detail in I-D.ietf-detnet-mpls." "Branch for review Merge it ! Changes look good - clicking correct button this time" 215d293ca11d1a96b10664fe5db5be2326ffc8d9 215d293ca11d1a96b10664fe5db5be2326ffc8d9 draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework 8c6d08b2077f63af242b017cc8f33cd6eb524769fc73b1f6bbd818077d449078 ['023f961d619971c6f51af4be85aa80ec6148a5573fc27824d42b1f0d62a1a888', '067d9859172cde5eacf03abfc795fad05c27315c3d877321a836289497410bf5', 'abf026ee8a31a9f2648f2b58fbc4f713ca6dcbfdd0bba66fea03ecd28ea90332', '11ad0e3d084e84d0f894abcc3f46f35b920669c902de0fd0c1c0b70b5a277503', 'd75a171663a1ff923d830df8dea16b22f884b2af11dbe9e73f8ed147123783d9', '2774d0351348728e076d27562ba4835d550b613b2092435ce2b73b72b1bbf04d', '7f196d71ae3dd553e6306aad4f0e7f0515bbcf2696b05eed10292049a0413c74', 'd0bcc637bfa20f222ac98b878a724978687152e9aeb24cd06c2f2a3d57d9efd5', 'f18684001a1fff593e10b1bf9355a982468c2a0c39067b978ca670f996abc812', 'b7e4ce467d4406a06a4bcffed356d40bc68aa391b3f641ca58f2c49a28d5d72d', 'c0c46a44c439b6c63bd7bfbf690de81f100f1e797d4f1a1daf4cb2e4f9f87129', '8c6d08b2077f63af242b017cc8f33cd6eb524769fc73b1f6bbd818077d449078', '6ca6d19228d672f558c97be9cf7514386bcc666768700a0a9697e6ac657b8621', '1ae09bae308713aec5b1fdccd6eea1c9de1834329c0a092a309ce2b0a147778b'] B "in cases where metadata is needed to process an mpls encapsulated packet at the service layer, this has been been provided through the use of a shim layer also called a control word (cw) rfc4385. although such cws are frequently 32 bits long, there is no architectural constraint on its size of this structure, only the requirement that it is fully understood by all parties operating on it in the detnet service layer. the operation of this method is described in detail in i-d.ietf-detnet-mpls." {8: 1, 79: 9, 90: 7, 51: 9, 130: 9, 62: 8, 85: 8, 68: 2, 35: 10, 110: 10, 91: 12, 114: 10, 97: 10, 31: 2, 13: 9, 67: 9, 38: 11, 26: 8, 124: 9, 98: 9, 54: 9, 127: 10, 6: 7, 96: 10, 64: 9, 30: 11, 61: 12, 55: 3, 27: 8, 15: 10, 52: 8, 129: 10, 115: 10, 84: 5, 76: 10, 87: 10, 131: 12, 102: 7, 113: 12, 99: 9, 36: 10, 24: 9, 53: 8, 72: 11} {218: 1, 330: 1, 4: 9, 9: 9, 10: 10, 15: 10, 24: 9, 25: 8, 26: 8, 27: 10, 39: 4, 43: 10, 49: 13, 50: 12, 58: 12, 59: 9, 64: 10, 69: 8, 81: 9, 82: 9, 86: 10, 96: 11, 97: 10, 100: 12, 108: 10, 109: 11, 110: 11, 111: 9, 114: 10, 115: 11, 116: 10, 118: 9, 119: 8, 120: 10, 121: 7, 122: 11, 123: 10, 124: 6, 128: 11, 129: 11, 130: 12, 132: 8, 136: 9, 145: 8, 147: 11, 151: 11, 152: 11, 154: 10, 156: 9, 161: 7, 162: 6, 165: 10, 168: 11, 169: 10, 172: 10, 180: 11, 184: 9, 187: 12, 188: 11, 191: 10, 194: 8, 202: 9, 203: 10, 206: 9, 207: 10, 215: 8, 217: 10, 220: 7, 221: 7, 222: 6, 224: 10, 227: 10, 229: 10, 234: 12, 235: 9, 241: 9, 242: 9, 243: 8, 244: 11, 245: 8, 248: 11, 250: 11, 258: 2, 262: 11, 263: 12, 264: 8, 267: 7, 270: 10, 272: 10, 273: 9, 287: 10, 289: 10, 291: 12, 299: 10, 300: 10, 304: 10, 309: 7, 314: 9, 315: 10, 320: 7, 323: 8, 327: 11, 328: 9, 329: 9, 334: 9, 335: 10, 341: 10, 342: 11, 347: 10, 348: 10, 350: 11, 351: 12, 352: 10, 353: 10, 354: 9, 358: 5, 365: 10, 366: 9, 369: 8, 371: 12, 372: 12, 376: 9, 384: 12, 385: 11, 386: 10, 387: 10, 392: 9, 393: 10, 396: 11, 397: 2, 398: 3, 402: 10} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 6 "Use of allocated resources (queuing, policing, shaping) to ensure that the congestion-related loss and latency/jitter requirements of a DetNet flow are met." "Branch for review Merge it ! Changes look good - clicking correct button this time" 215d293ca11d1a96b10664fe5db5be2326ffc8d9 215d293ca11d1a96b10664fe5db5be2326ffc8d9 draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework ae3bdd3a81d96e4aaa02f7d597a2684146f3af75b743bde8e31c3cf5883707db ['8d33f4dbbf7ab8899b8d7fe2858e2bd54d3076e1c21cd4da634f86caec05d13a', '26e942b0353fee8f5ac0a2c2e26c9b695c50b35c501eeb4bff343b1648b5cebc', '1d461b45ddd8d23bc4da82c7319696451df56fdf43af8bec67d483088c4ccd80', 'e47790a464b2b6fa4e36eb885764e56e0a6c3b85f522fa954647c6c9daa37f18', 'fb2b9389e1455c6d64ae19158396d767d88969013b14075bcfdcc764f610108c', 'ae3bdd3a81d96e4aaa02f7d597a2684146f3af75b743bde8e31c3cf5883707db', '9829b13faebde69c2279c38cd54d524aa31acfdcc1cfba7910b9d69caa42e0dd', '4602f1e91bf42736704aa4b5deb973b3d0f537735bfefb88c02344a9e3c4f421', '1ee64e328112b4bbc4ce29ee2d99c3a7d17221bef5cd89708782d6dfff492351'] A "use of allocated resources (queuing, policing, shaping) to ensure that the congestion-related loss and latency/jitter requirements of a detnet flow are met." {55: 1, 52: 1, 53: 1, 8: 1, 6: 2, 79: 2, 90: 2, 51: 3, 130: 2, 62: 3, 85: 3, 68: 2, 35: 3, 110: 3, 91: 5, 114: 3, 97: 3, 31: 2, 13: 3, 67: 2, 38: 4, 26: 3, 124: 2, 98: 2, 54: 2, 127: 3, 96: 3, 64: 2, 30: 4, 61: 5, 27: 3, 15: 3, 129: 3, 115: 3, 84: 2, 76: 5, 87: 3, 131: 5, 102: 2, 113: 5, 99: 2, 36: 3, 24: 2, 72: 4} {162: 1, 215: 1, 369: 1, 309: 1, 221: 1, 1: 7, 4: 2, 9: 4, 10: 3, 15: 3, 24: 2, 25: 3, 26: 3, 27: 3, 39: 3, 43: 3, 49: 6, 50: 5, 58: 5, 59: 2, 64: 3, 69: 3, 81: 4, 82: 4, 86: 3, 96: 4, 97: 3, 100: 7, 108: 3, 109: 4, 110: 4, 111: 2, 114: 3, 115: 4, 116: 3, 118: 4, 119: 3, 120: 3, 121: 2, 122: 4, 123: 3, 124: 2, 128: 4, 129: 4, 130: 5, 132: 3, 136: 2, 145: 3, 147: 4, 151: 4, 152: 4, 154: 3, 156: 2, 161: 2, 165: 3, 168: 4, 169: 3, 172: 3, 180: 4, 184: 4, 187: 5, 188: 4, 191: 3, 194: 3, 202: 4, 203: 5, 206: 2, 207: 3, 217: 3, 218: 6, 222: 3, 224: 3, 227: 5, 229: 3, 234: 5, 235: 2, 241: 2, 242: 2, 243: 3, 244: 4, 245: 3, 248: 4, 250: 4, 258: 9, 262: 4, 263: 5, 264: 2, 267: 2, 270: 3, 272: 3, 273: 4, 287: 3, 289: 3, 291: 5, 299: 5, 300: 3, 304: 3, 314: 2, 315: 3, 320: 2, 323: 3, 327: 4, 328: 2, 329: 2, 330: 8, 334: 2, 335: 3, 341: 5, 342: 6, 347: 5, 348: 5, 350: 6, 351: 5, 352: 3, 353: 3, 354: 2, 358: 2, 365: 3, 366: 2, 371: 7, 372: 5, 376: 2, 384: 5, 385: 4, 386: 3, 387: 3, 392: 2, 393: 3, 396: 6, 397: 5, 398: 4, 402: 3} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 6 "Use of a specific path for a flow. This limits misordering and bounds latency." "Branch for review Merge it ! Changes look good - clicking correct button this time" 215d293ca11d1a96b10664fe5db5be2326ffc8d9 215d293ca11d1a96b10664fe5db5be2326ffc8d9 draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework fb2b9389e1455c6d64ae19158396d767d88969013b14075bcfdcc764f610108c ['8d33f4dbbf7ab8899b8d7fe2858e2bd54d3076e1c21cd4da634f86caec05d13a', '26e942b0353fee8f5ac0a2c2e26c9b695c50b35c501eeb4bff343b1648b5cebc', '1d461b45ddd8d23bc4da82c7319696451df56fdf43af8bec67d483088c4ccd80', 'e47790a464b2b6fa4e36eb885764e56e0a6c3b85f522fa954647c6c9daa37f18', 'fb2b9389e1455c6d64ae19158396d767d88969013b14075bcfdcc764f610108c', 'ae3bdd3a81d96e4aaa02f7d597a2684146f3af75b743bde8e31c3cf5883707db', '9829b13faebde69c2279c38cd54d524aa31acfdcc1cfba7910b9d69caa42e0dd', '4602f1e91bf42736704aa4b5deb973b3d0f537735bfefb88c02344a9e3c4f421', '1ee64e328112b4bbc4ce29ee2d99c3a7d17221bef5cd89708782d6dfff492351'] A "use of a specific path for a flow. this limits misordering and bounds latency." {55: 1, 52: 1, 53: 1, 8: 1, 6: 2, 79: 2, 90: 2, 51: 3, 130: 2, 62: 3, 85: 3, 68: 2, 35: 3, 110: 3, 91: 5, 114: 3, 97: 3, 31: 2, 13: 3, 67: 2, 38: 4, 26: 3, 124: 2, 98: 2, 54: 2, 127: 3, 96: 3, 64: 2, 30: 4, 61: 5, 27: 3, 15: 3, 129: 3, 115: 3, 84: 2, 76: 5, 87: 3, 131: 5, 102: 2, 113: 5, 99: 2, 36: 3, 24: 2, 72: 4} {162: 1, 215: 1, 369: 1, 309: 1, 221: 1, 1: 7, 4: 2, 9: 4, 10: 3, 15: 3, 24: 2, 25: 3, 26: 3, 27: 3, 39: 3, 43: 3, 49: 6, 50: 5, 58: 5, 59: 2, 64: 3, 69: 3, 81: 4, 82: 4, 86: 3, 96: 4, 97: 3, 100: 7, 108: 3, 109: 4, 110: 4, 111: 2, 114: 3, 115: 4, 116: 3, 118: 4, 119: 3, 120: 3, 121: 2, 122: 4, 123: 3, 124: 2, 128: 4, 129: 4, 130: 5, 132: 3, 136: 2, 145: 3, 147: 4, 151: 4, 152: 4, 154: 3, 156: 2, 161: 2, 165: 3, 168: 4, 169: 3, 172: 3, 180: 4, 184: 4, 187: 5, 188: 4, 191: 3, 194: 3, 202: 4, 203: 5, 206: 2, 207: 3, 217: 3, 218: 6, 222: 3, 224: 3, 227: 5, 229: 3, 234: 5, 235: 2, 241: 2, 242: 2, 243: 3, 244: 4, 245: 3, 248: 4, 250: 4, 258: 9, 262: 4, 263: 5, 264: 2, 267: 2, 270: 3, 272: 3, 273: 4, 287: 3, 289: 3, 291: 5, 299: 5, 300: 3, 304: 3, 314: 2, 315: 3, 320: 2, 323: 3, 327: 4, 328: 2, 329: 2, 330: 8, 334: 2, 335: 3, 341: 5, 342: 6, 347: 5, 348: 5, 350: 6, 351: 5, 352: 3, 353: 3, 354: 2, 358: 2, 365: 3, 366: 2, 371: 7, 372: 5, 376: 2, 384: 5, 385: 4, 386: 3, 387: 3, 392: 2, 393: 3, 396: 6, 397: 5, 398: 4, 402: 3} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 6 "Which in the case of this document primarily relates to replication and elimination. Changing the explicit path after a failure is detected in order to restore delivery of the required DetNet service characteristics is also possible. Path changes, even in the case of failure recovery, can lead to the out of order delivery of data." "Branch for review Merge it ! Changes look good - clicking correct button this time" 215d293ca11d1a96b10664fe5db5be2326ffc8d9 215d293ca11d1a96b10664fe5db5be2326ffc8d9 draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework 9829b13faebde69c2279c38cd54d524aa31acfdcc1cfba7910b9d69caa42e0dd ['8d33f4dbbf7ab8899b8d7fe2858e2bd54d3076e1c21cd4da634f86caec05d13a', '26e942b0353fee8f5ac0a2c2e26c9b695c50b35c501eeb4bff343b1648b5cebc', '1d461b45ddd8d23bc4da82c7319696451df56fdf43af8bec67d483088c4ccd80', 'e47790a464b2b6fa4e36eb885764e56e0a6c3b85f522fa954647c6c9daa37f18', 'fb2b9389e1455c6d64ae19158396d767d88969013b14075bcfdcc764f610108c', 'ae3bdd3a81d96e4aaa02f7d597a2684146f3af75b743bde8e31c3cf5883707db', '9829b13faebde69c2279c38cd54d524aa31acfdcc1cfba7910b9d69caa42e0dd', '4602f1e91bf42736704aa4b5deb973b3d0f537735bfefb88c02344a9e3c4f421', '1ee64e328112b4bbc4ce29ee2d99c3a7d17221bef5cd89708782d6dfff492351'] A "which in the case of this document primarily relates to replication and elimination. changing the explicit path after a failure is detected in order to restore delivery of the required detnet service characteristics is also possible. path changes, even in the case of failure recovery, can lead to the out of order delivery of data." {55: 1, 52: 1, 53: 1, 8: 1, 6: 2, 79: 2, 90: 2, 51: 3, 130: 2, 62: 3, 85: 3, 68: 2, 35: 3, 110: 3, 91: 5, 114: 3, 97: 3, 31: 2, 13: 3, 67: 2, 38: 4, 26: 3, 124: 2, 98: 2, 54: 2, 127: 3, 96: 3, 64: 2, 30: 4, 61: 5, 27: 3, 15: 3, 129: 3, 115: 3, 84: 2, 76: 5, 87: 3, 131: 5, 102: 2, 113: 5, 99: 2, 36: 3, 24: 2, 72: 4} {162: 1, 215: 1, 369: 1, 309: 1, 221: 1, 1: 7, 4: 2, 9: 4, 10: 3, 15: 3, 24: 2, 25: 3, 26: 3, 27: 3, 39: 3, 43: 3, 49: 6, 50: 5, 58: 5, 59: 2, 64: 3, 69: 3, 81: 4, 82: 4, 86: 3, 96: 4, 97: 3, 100: 7, 108: 3, 109: 4, 110: 4, 111: 2, 114: 3, 115: 4, 116: 3, 118: 4, 119: 3, 120: 3, 121: 2, 122: 4, 123: 3, 124: 2, 128: 4, 129: 4, 130: 5, 132: 3, 136: 2, 145: 3, 147: 4, 151: 4, 152: 4, 154: 3, 156: 2, 161: 2, 165: 3, 168: 4, 169: 3, 172: 3, 180: 4, 184: 4, 187: 5, 188: 4, 191: 3, 194: 3, 202: 4, 203: 5, 206: 2, 207: 3, 217: 3, 218: 6, 222: 3, 224: 3, 227: 5, 229: 3, 234: 5, 235: 2, 241: 2, 242: 2, 243: 3, 244: 4, 245: 3, 248: 4, 250: 4, 258: 9, 262: 4, 263: 5, 264: 2, 267: 2, 270: 3, 272: 3, 273: 4, 287: 3, 289: 3, 291: 5, 299: 5, 300: 3, 304: 3, 314: 2, 315: 3, 320: 2, 323: 3, 327: 4, 328: 2, 329: 2, 330: 8, 334: 2, 335: 3, 341: 5, 342: 6, 347: 5, 348: 5, 350: 6, 351: 5, 352: 3, 353: 3, 354: 2, 358: 2, 365: 3, 366: 2, 371: 7, 372: 5, 376: 2, 384: 5, 385: 4, 386: 3, 387: 3, 392: 2, 393: 3, 396: 6, 397: 5, 398: 4, 402: 3} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 6 "Generally, distributing packets of the same DetNet flow over multiple paths is not recommended. Such load sharing, e.g., via ECMP or UCMP, impacts ordering and possibly jitter." "Branch for review Merge it ! Changes look good - clicking correct button this time" 215d293ca11d1a96b10664fe5db5be2326ffc8d9 215d293ca11d1a96b10664fe5db5be2326ffc8d9 draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework 26e942b0353fee8f5ac0a2c2e26c9b695c50b35c501eeb4bff343b1648b5cebc ['8d33f4dbbf7ab8899b8d7fe2858e2bd54d3076e1c21cd4da634f86caec05d13a', '26e942b0353fee8f5ac0a2c2e26c9b695c50b35c501eeb4bff343b1648b5cebc', '1d461b45ddd8d23bc4da82c7319696451df56fdf43af8bec67d483088c4ccd80', 'e47790a464b2b6fa4e36eb885764e56e0a6c3b85f522fa954647c6c9daa37f18', 'fb2b9389e1455c6d64ae19158396d767d88969013b14075bcfdcc764f610108c', 'ae3bdd3a81d96e4aaa02f7d597a2684146f3af75b743bde8e31c3cf5883707db', '9829b13faebde69c2279c38cd54d524aa31acfdcc1cfba7910b9d69caa42e0dd', '4602f1e91bf42736704aa4b5deb973b3d0f537735bfefb88c02344a9e3c4f421', '1ee64e328112b4bbc4ce29ee2d99c3a7d17221bef5cd89708782d6dfff492351'] A "generally, distributing packets of the same detnet flow over multiple paths is not recommended. such load sharing, e.g., via ecmp or ucmp, impacts ordering and possibly jitter." {55: 1, 52: 1, 53: 1, 8: 1, 6: 2, 79: 2, 90: 2, 51: 3, 130: 2, 62: 3, 85: 3, 68: 2, 35: 3, 110: 3, 91: 5, 114: 3, 97: 3, 31: 2, 13: 3, 67: 2, 38: 4, 26: 3, 124: 2, 98: 2, 54: 2, 127: 3, 96: 3, 64: 2, 30: 4, 61: 5, 27: 3, 15: 3, 129: 3, 115: 3, 84: 2, 76: 5, 87: 3, 131: 5, 102: 2, 113: 5, 99: 2, 36: 3, 24: 2, 72: 4} {162: 1, 215: 1, 369: 1, 309: 1, 221: 1, 1: 7, 4: 2, 9: 4, 10: 3, 15: 3, 24: 2, 25: 3, 26: 3, 27: 3, 39: 3, 43: 3, 49: 6, 50: 5, 58: 5, 59: 2, 64: 3, 69: 3, 81: 4, 82: 4, 86: 3, 96: 4, 97: 3, 100: 7, 108: 3, 109: 4, 110: 4, 111: 2, 114: 3, 115: 4, 116: 3, 118: 4, 119: 3, 120: 3, 121: 2, 122: 4, 123: 3, 124: 2, 128: 4, 129: 4, 130: 5, 132: 3, 136: 2, 145: 3, 147: 4, 151: 4, 152: 4, 154: 3, 156: 2, 161: 2, 165: 3, 168: 4, 169: 3, 172: 3, 180: 4, 184: 4, 187: 5, 188: 4, 191: 3, 194: 3, 202: 4, 203: 5, 206: 2, 207: 3, 217: 3, 218: 6, 222: 3, 224: 3, 227: 5, 229: 3, 234: 5, 235: 2, 241: 2, 242: 2, 243: 3, 244: 4, 245: 3, 248: 4, 250: 4, 258: 9, 262: 4, 263: 5, 264: 2, 267: 2, 270: 3, 272: 3, 273: 4, 287: 3, 289: 3, 291: 5, 299: 5, 300: 3, 304: 3, 314: 2, 315: 3, 320: 2, 323: 3, 327: 4, 328: 2, 329: 2, 330: 8, 334: 2, 335: 3, 341: 5, 342: 6, 347: 5, 348: 5, 350: 6, 351: 5, 352: 3, 353: 3, 354: 2, 358: 2, 365: 3, 366: 2, 371: 7, 372: 5, 376: 2, 384: 5, 385: 4, 386: 3, 387: 3, 392: 2, 393: 3, 396: 6, 397: 5, 398: 4, 402: 3} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 6 "Reservation of resources can allocate resources to specific DetNet flows. This can eliminate packet contention and loss for DetNet traffic. This also can reduce jitter for the DetNet traffic. DetNet flows are assumed to behave with respect to the reserved traffic profile. If other traffic shares the link resources, the use of (queuing, policing, shaping) policies can be used to ensure that the allocation of resources reserved for DetNet is met. Queuing and shaping of DetNet traffic could be required to ensure that DetNet traffic does not exceed its reserved profile but this would impact the DetNet service characteristics." "Branch for review Merge it ! Changes look good - clicking correct button this time" 215d293ca11d1a96b10664fe5db5be2326ffc8d9 215d293ca11d1a96b10664fe5db5be2326ffc8d9 draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework 1d461b45ddd8d23bc4da82c7319696451df56fdf43af8bec67d483088c4ccd80 ['8d33f4dbbf7ab8899b8d7fe2858e2bd54d3076e1c21cd4da634f86caec05d13a', '26e942b0353fee8f5ac0a2c2e26c9b695c50b35c501eeb4bff343b1648b5cebc', '1d461b45ddd8d23bc4da82c7319696451df56fdf43af8bec67d483088c4ccd80', 'e47790a464b2b6fa4e36eb885764e56e0a6c3b85f522fa954647c6c9daa37f18', 'fb2b9389e1455c6d64ae19158396d767d88969013b14075bcfdcc764f610108c', 'ae3bdd3a81d96e4aaa02f7d597a2684146f3af75b743bde8e31c3cf5883707db', '9829b13faebde69c2279c38cd54d524aa31acfdcc1cfba7910b9d69caa42e0dd', '4602f1e91bf42736704aa4b5deb973b3d0f537735bfefb88c02344a9e3c4f421', '1ee64e328112b4bbc4ce29ee2d99c3a7d17221bef5cd89708782d6dfff492351'] B "reservation of resources can allocate resources to specific detnet flows. this can eliminate packet contention and loss for detnet traffic. this also can reduce jitter for the detnet traffic. detnet flows are assumed to behave with respect to the reserved traffic profile. if other traffic shares the link resources, the use of (queuing, policing, shaping) policies can be used to ensure that the allocation of resources reserved for detnet is met. queuing and shaping of detnet traffic could be required to ensure that detnet traffic does not exceed its reserved profile but this would impact the detnet service characteristics." {55: 1, 52: 1, 53: 1, 8: 1, 6: 2, 79: 2, 90: 2, 51: 3, 130: 2, 62: 3, 85: 3, 68: 2, 35: 3, 110: 3, 91: 5, 114: 3, 97: 3, 31: 2, 13: 3, 67: 2, 38: 4, 26: 3, 124: 2, 98: 2, 54: 2, 127: 3, 96: 3, 64: 2, 30: 4, 61: 5, 27: 3, 15: 3, 129: 3, 115: 3, 84: 2, 76: 5, 87: 3, 131: 5, 102: 2, 113: 5, 99: 2, 36: 3, 24: 2, 72: 4} {162: 1, 215: 1, 369: 1, 309: 1, 221: 1, 1: 7, 4: 2, 9: 4, 10: 3, 15: 3, 24: 2, 25: 3, 26: 3, 27: 3, 39: 3, 43: 3, 49: 6, 50: 5, 58: 5, 59: 2, 64: 3, 69: 3, 81: 4, 82: 4, 86: 3, 96: 4, 97: 3, 100: 7, 108: 3, 109: 4, 110: 4, 111: 2, 114: 3, 115: 4, 116: 3, 118: 4, 119: 3, 120: 3, 121: 2, 122: 4, 123: 3, 124: 2, 128: 4, 129: 4, 130: 5, 132: 3, 136: 2, 145: 3, 147: 4, 151: 4, 152: 4, 154: 3, 156: 2, 161: 2, 165: 3, 168: 4, 169: 3, 172: 3, 180: 4, 184: 4, 187: 5, 188: 4, 191: 3, 194: 3, 202: 4, 203: 5, 206: 2, 207: 3, 217: 3, 218: 6, 222: 3, 224: 3, 227: 5, 229: 3, 234: 5, 235: 2, 241: 2, 242: 2, 243: 3, 244: 4, 245: 3, 248: 4, 250: 4, 258: 9, 262: 4, 263: 5, 264: 2, 267: 2, 270: 3, 272: 3, 273: 4, 287: 3, 289: 3, 291: 5, 299: 5, 300: 3, 304: 3, 314: 2, 315: 3, 320: 2, 323: 3, 327: 4, 328: 2, 329: 2, 330: 8, 334: 2, 335: 3, 341: 5, 342: 6, 347: 5, 348: 5, 350: 6, 351: 5, 352: 3, 353: 3, 354: 2, 358: 2, 365: 3, 366: 2, 371: 7, 372: 5, 376: 2, 384: 5, 385: 4, 386: 3, 387: 3, 392: 2, 393: 3, 396: 6, 397: 5, 398: 4, 402: 3} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 6 "Use of a specific path for a flow. This allows control of the network delay by steering the packet with the ability to influence the physical path. Explicit routes complement reservation by ensuring that a consistent path can be associated with its resources for the duration of that path. Coupled with the traffic mechanism, this limits misordering and bounds latency." "Branch for review Merge it ! Changes look good - clicking correct button this time" 215d293ca11d1a96b10664fe5db5be2326ffc8d9 215d293ca11d1a96b10664fe5db5be2326ffc8d9 draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework 1ee64e328112b4bbc4ce29ee2d99c3a7d17221bef5cd89708782d6dfff492351 ['8d33f4dbbf7ab8899b8d7fe2858e2bd54d3076e1c21cd4da634f86caec05d13a', '26e942b0353fee8f5ac0a2c2e26c9b695c50b35c501eeb4bff343b1648b5cebc', '1d461b45ddd8d23bc4da82c7319696451df56fdf43af8bec67d483088c4ccd80', 'e47790a464b2b6fa4e36eb885764e56e0a6c3b85f522fa954647c6c9daa37f18', 'fb2b9389e1455c6d64ae19158396d767d88969013b14075bcfdcc764f610108c', 'ae3bdd3a81d96e4aaa02f7d597a2684146f3af75b743bde8e31c3cf5883707db', '9829b13faebde69c2279c38cd54d524aa31acfdcc1cfba7910b9d69caa42e0dd', '4602f1e91bf42736704aa4b5deb973b3d0f537735bfefb88c02344a9e3c4f421', '1ee64e328112b4bbc4ce29ee2d99c3a7d17221bef5cd89708782d6dfff492351'] B "use of a specific path for a flow. this allows control of the network delay by steering the packet with the ability to influence the physical path. explicit routes complement reservation by ensuring that a consistent path can be associated with its resources for the duration of that path. coupled with the traffic mechanism, this limits misordering and bounds latency." {55: 1, 52: 1, 53: 1, 8: 1, 6: 2, 79: 2, 90: 2, 51: 3, 130: 2, 62: 3, 85: 3, 68: 2, 35: 3, 110: 3, 91: 5, 114: 3, 97: 3, 31: 2, 13: 3, 67: 2, 38: 4, 26: 3, 124: 2, 98: 2, 54: 2, 127: 3, 96: 3, 64: 2, 30: 4, 61: 5, 27: 3, 15: 3, 129: 3, 115: 3, 84: 2, 76: 5, 87: 3, 131: 5, 102: 2, 113: 5, 99: 2, 36: 3, 24: 2, 72: 4} {162: 1, 215: 1, 369: 1, 309: 1, 221: 1, 1: 7, 4: 2, 9: 4, 10: 3, 15: 3, 24: 2, 25: 3, 26: 3, 27: 3, 39: 3, 43: 3, 49: 6, 50: 5, 58: 5, 59: 2, 64: 3, 69: 3, 81: 4, 82: 4, 86: 3, 96: 4, 97: 3, 100: 7, 108: 3, 109: 4, 110: 4, 111: 2, 114: 3, 115: 4, 116: 3, 118: 4, 119: 3, 120: 3, 121: 2, 122: 4, 123: 3, 124: 2, 128: 4, 129: 4, 130: 5, 132: 3, 136: 2, 145: 3, 147: 4, 151: 4, 152: 4, 154: 3, 156: 2, 161: 2, 165: 3, 168: 4, 169: 3, 172: 3, 180: 4, 184: 4, 187: 5, 188: 4, 191: 3, 194: 3, 202: 4, 203: 5, 206: 2, 207: 3, 217: 3, 218: 6, 222: 3, 224: 3, 227: 5, 229: 3, 234: 5, 235: 2, 241: 2, 242: 2, 243: 3, 244: 4, 245: 3, 248: 4, 250: 4, 258: 9, 262: 4, 263: 5, 264: 2, 267: 2, 270: 3, 272: 3, 273: 4, 287: 3, 289: 3, 291: 5, 299: 5, 300: 3, 304: 3, 314: 2, 315: 3, 320: 2, 323: 3, 327: 4, 328: 2, 329: 2, 330: 8, 334: 2, 335: 3, 341: 5, 342: 6, 347: 5, 348: 5, 350: 6, 351: 5, 352: 3, 353: 3, 354: 2, 358: 2, 365: 3, 366: 2, 371: 7, 372: 5, 376: 2, 384: 5, 385: 4, 386: 3, 387: 3, 392: 2, 393: 3, 396: 6, 397: 5, 398: 4, 402: 3} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 6 "Use of multiple packet streams using multiple paths, for example 1+1 or 1:1 linear protection. For DetNet this primarily relates to packet replication and elimination capabilities. Changing the explicit path after a failure is detected to an already established path in order to restore delivery of the required DetNet service characteristics is another protection mechanism for example MPLS hitless protection. Path changes, even in the case of failure recovery, can lead to the out of order delivery of data requiring packet ordering functions either within the DetNet service or at a high layer in the application traffic. Establishment of new paths after a failure is out of scope for DetNet services." "Branch for review Merge it ! Changes look good - clicking correct button this time" 215d293ca11d1a96b10664fe5db5be2326ffc8d9 215d293ca11d1a96b10664fe5db5be2326ffc8d9 draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework e47790a464b2b6fa4e36eb885764e56e0a6c3b85f522fa954647c6c9daa37f18 ['8d33f4dbbf7ab8899b8d7fe2858e2bd54d3076e1c21cd4da634f86caec05d13a', '26e942b0353fee8f5ac0a2c2e26c9b695c50b35c501eeb4bff343b1648b5cebc', '1d461b45ddd8d23bc4da82c7319696451df56fdf43af8bec67d483088c4ccd80', 'e47790a464b2b6fa4e36eb885764e56e0a6c3b85f522fa954647c6c9daa37f18', 'fb2b9389e1455c6d64ae19158396d767d88969013b14075bcfdcc764f610108c', 'ae3bdd3a81d96e4aaa02f7d597a2684146f3af75b743bde8e31c3cf5883707db', '9829b13faebde69c2279c38cd54d524aa31acfdcc1cfba7910b9d69caa42e0dd', '4602f1e91bf42736704aa4b5deb973b3d0f537735bfefb88c02344a9e3c4f421', '1ee64e328112b4bbc4ce29ee2d99c3a7d17221bef5cd89708782d6dfff492351'] B "use of multiple packet streams using multiple paths, for example 1+1 or 1:1 linear protection. for detnet this primarily relates to packet replication and elimination capabilities. changing the explicit path after a failure is detected to an already established path in order to restore delivery of the required detnet service characteristics is another protection mechanism for example mpls hitless protection. path changes, even in the case of failure recovery, can lead to the out of order delivery of data requiring packet ordering functions either within the detnet service or at a high layer in the application traffic. establishment of new paths after a failure is out of scope for detnet services." {55: 1, 52: 1, 53: 1, 8: 1, 6: 2, 79: 2, 90: 2, 51: 3, 130: 2, 62: 3, 85: 3, 68: 2, 35: 3, 110: 3, 91: 5, 114: 3, 97: 3, 31: 2, 13: 3, 67: 2, 38: 4, 26: 3, 124: 2, 98: 2, 54: 2, 127: 3, 96: 3, 64: 2, 30: 4, 61: 5, 27: 3, 15: 3, 129: 3, 115: 3, 84: 2, 76: 5, 87: 3, 131: 5, 102: 2, 113: 5, 99: 2, 36: 3, 24: 2, 72: 4} {162: 1, 215: 1, 369: 1, 309: 1, 221: 1, 1: 7, 4: 2, 9: 4, 10: 3, 15: 3, 24: 2, 25: 3, 26: 3, 27: 3, 39: 3, 43: 3, 49: 6, 50: 5, 58: 5, 59: 2, 64: 3, 69: 3, 81: 4, 82: 4, 86: 3, 96: 4, 97: 3, 100: 7, 108: 3, 109: 4, 110: 4, 111: 2, 114: 3, 115: 4, 116: 3, 118: 4, 119: 3, 120: 3, 121: 2, 122: 4, 123: 3, 124: 2, 128: 4, 129: 4, 130: 5, 132: 3, 136: 2, 145: 3, 147: 4, 151: 4, 152: 4, 154: 3, 156: 2, 161: 2, 165: 3, 168: 4, 169: 3, 172: 3, 180: 4, 184: 4, 187: 5, 188: 4, 191: 3, 194: 3, 202: 4, 203: 5, 206: 2, 207: 3, 217: 3, 218: 6, 222: 3, 224: 3, 227: 5, 229: 3, 234: 5, 235: 2, 241: 2, 242: 2, 243: 3, 244: 4, 245: 3, 248: 4, 250: 4, 258: 9, 262: 4, 263: 5, 264: 2, 267: 2, 270: 3, 272: 3, 273: 4, 287: 3, 289: 3, 291: 5, 299: 5, 300: 3, 304: 3, 314: 2, 315: 3, 320: 2, 323: 3, 327: 4, 328: 2, 329: 2, 330: 8, 334: 2, 335: 3, 341: 5, 342: 6, 347: 5, 348: 5, 350: 6, 351: 5, 352: 3, 353: 3, 354: 2, 358: 2, 365: 3, 366: 2, 371: 7, 372: 5, 376: 2, 384: 5, 385: 4, 386: 3, 387: 3, 392: 2, 393: 3, 396: 6, 397: 5, 398: 4, 402: 3} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 6 "Use of network coding to improve a network's throughput, efficiency, latency, and scalability, as well as resilience to partition, attacks, and eavesdropping, as compared to traditional methods. Network coding is another technique that uses multiple paths typically with very similar delays and capacity. Network coding is often applied in wireless networks." "Branch for review Merge it ! Changes look good - clicking correct button this time" 215d293ca11d1a96b10664fe5db5be2326ffc8d9 215d293ca11d1a96b10664fe5db5be2326ffc8d9 draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework 4602f1e91bf42736704aa4b5deb973b3d0f537735bfefb88c02344a9e3c4f421 ['8d33f4dbbf7ab8899b8d7fe2858e2bd54d3076e1c21cd4da634f86caec05d13a', '26e942b0353fee8f5ac0a2c2e26c9b695c50b35c501eeb4bff343b1648b5cebc', '1d461b45ddd8d23bc4da82c7319696451df56fdf43af8bec67d483088c4ccd80', 'e47790a464b2b6fa4e36eb885764e56e0a6c3b85f522fa954647c6c9daa37f18', 'fb2b9389e1455c6d64ae19158396d767d88969013b14075bcfdcc764f610108c', 'ae3bdd3a81d96e4aaa02f7d597a2684146f3af75b743bde8e31c3cf5883707db', '9829b13faebde69c2279c38cd54d524aa31acfdcc1cfba7910b9d69caa42e0dd', '4602f1e91bf42736704aa4b5deb973b3d0f537735bfefb88c02344a9e3c4f421', '1ee64e328112b4bbc4ce29ee2d99c3a7d17221bef5cd89708782d6dfff492351'] B "use of network coding to improve a network's throughput, efficiency, latency, and scalability, as well as resilience to partition, attacks, and eavesdropping, as compared to traditional methods. network coding is another technique that uses multiple paths typically with very similar delays and capacity. network coding is often applied in wireless networks." {55: 1, 52: 1, 53: 1, 8: 1, 6: 2, 79: 2, 90: 2, 51: 3, 130: 2, 62: 3, 85: 3, 68: 2, 35: 3, 110: 3, 91: 5, 114: 3, 97: 3, 31: 2, 13: 3, 67: 2, 38: 4, 26: 3, 124: 2, 98: 2, 54: 2, 127: 3, 96: 3, 64: 2, 30: 4, 61: 5, 27: 3, 15: 3, 129: 3, 115: 3, 84: 2, 76: 5, 87: 3, 131: 5, 102: 2, 113: 5, 99: 2, 36: 3, 24: 2, 72: 4} {162: 1, 215: 1, 369: 1, 309: 1, 221: 1, 1: 7, 4: 2, 9: 4, 10: 3, 15: 3, 24: 2, 25: 3, 26: 3, 27: 3, 39: 3, 43: 3, 49: 6, 50: 5, 58: 5, 59: 2, 64: 3, 69: 3, 81: 4, 82: 4, 86: 3, 96: 4, 97: 3, 100: 7, 108: 3, 109: 4, 110: 4, 111: 2, 114: 3, 115: 4, 116: 3, 118: 4, 119: 3, 120: 3, 121: 2, 122: 4, 123: 3, 124: 2, 128: 4, 129: 4, 130: 5, 132: 3, 136: 2, 145: 3, 147: 4, 151: 4, 152: 4, 154: 3, 156: 2, 161: 2, 165: 3, 168: 4, 169: 3, 172: 3, 180: 4, 184: 4, 187: 5, 188: 4, 191: 3, 194: 3, 202: 4, 203: 5, 206: 2, 207: 3, 217: 3, 218: 6, 222: 3, 224: 3, 227: 5, 229: 3, 234: 5, 235: 2, 241: 2, 242: 2, 243: 3, 244: 4, 245: 3, 248: 4, 250: 4, 258: 9, 262: 4, 263: 5, 264: 2, 267: 2, 270: 3, 272: 3, 273: 4, 287: 3, 289: 3, 291: 5, 299: 5, 300: 3, 304: 3, 314: 2, 315: 3, 320: 2, 323: 3, 327: 4, 328: 2, 329: 2, 330: 8, 334: 2, 335: 3, 341: 5, 342: 6, 347: 5, 348: 5, 350: 6, 351: 5, 352: 3, 353: 3, 354: 2, 358: 2, 365: 3, 366: 2, 371: 7, 372: 5, 376: 2, 384: 5, 385: 4, 386: 3, 387: 3, 392: 2, 393: 3, 396: 6, 397: 5, 398: 4, 402: 3} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 6 "Use of packet by packet distribution of the same DetNet flow over multiple paths is not recommended. Such load sharing, e.g., via ECMP or UCMP, impacts ordering and possibly jitter." "Branch for review Merge it ! Changes look good - clicking correct button this time" 215d293ca11d1a96b10664fe5db5be2326ffc8d9 215d293ca11d1a96b10664fe5db5be2326ffc8d9 draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework 8d33f4dbbf7ab8899b8d7fe2858e2bd54d3076e1c21cd4da634f86caec05d13a ['8d33f4dbbf7ab8899b8d7fe2858e2bd54d3076e1c21cd4da634f86caec05d13a', '26e942b0353fee8f5ac0a2c2e26c9b695c50b35c501eeb4bff343b1648b5cebc', '1d461b45ddd8d23bc4da82c7319696451df56fdf43af8bec67d483088c4ccd80', 'e47790a464b2b6fa4e36eb885764e56e0a6c3b85f522fa954647c6c9daa37f18', 'fb2b9389e1455c6d64ae19158396d767d88969013b14075bcfdcc764f610108c', 'ae3bdd3a81d96e4aaa02f7d597a2684146f3af75b743bde8e31c3cf5883707db', '9829b13faebde69c2279c38cd54d524aa31acfdcc1cfba7910b9d69caa42e0dd', '4602f1e91bf42736704aa4b5deb973b3d0f537735bfefb88c02344a9e3c4f421', '1ee64e328112b4bbc4ce29ee2d99c3a7d17221bef5cd89708782d6dfff492351'] B "use of packet by packet distribution of the same detnet flow over multiple paths is not recommended. such load sharing, e.g., via ecmp or ucmp, impacts ordering and possibly jitter." {55: 1, 52: 1, 53: 1, 8: 1, 6: 2, 79: 2, 90: 2, 51: 3, 130: 2, 62: 3, 85: 3, 68: 2, 35: 3, 110: 3, 91: 5, 114: 3, 97: 3, 31: 2, 13: 3, 67: 2, 38: 4, 26: 3, 124: 2, 98: 2, 54: 2, 127: 3, 96: 3, 64: 2, 30: 4, 61: 5, 27: 3, 15: 3, 129: 3, 115: 3, 84: 2, 76: 5, 87: 3, 131: 5, 102: 2, 113: 5, 99: 2, 36: 3, 24: 2, 72: 4} {162: 1, 215: 1, 369: 1, 309: 1, 221: 1, 1: 7, 4: 2, 9: 4, 10: 3, 15: 3, 24: 2, 25: 3, 26: 3, 27: 3, 39: 3, 43: 3, 49: 6, 50: 5, 58: 5, 59: 2, 64: 3, 69: 3, 81: 4, 82: 4, 86: 3, 96: 4, 97: 3, 100: 7, 108: 3, 109: 4, 110: 4, 111: 2, 114: 3, 115: 4, 116: 3, 118: 4, 119: 3, 120: 3, 121: 2, 122: 4, 123: 3, 124: 2, 128: 4, 129: 4, 130: 5, 132: 3, 136: 2, 145: 3, 147: 4, 151: 4, 152: 4, 154: 3, 156: 2, 161: 2, 165: 3, 168: 4, 169: 3, 172: 3, 180: 4, 184: 4, 187: 5, 188: 4, 191: 3, 194: 3, 202: 4, 203: 5, 206: 2, 207: 3, 217: 3, 218: 6, 222: 3, 224: 3, 227: 5, 229: 3, 234: 5, 235: 2, 241: 2, 242: 2, 243: 3, 244: 4, 245: 3, 248: 4, 250: 4, 258: 9, 262: 4, 263: 5, 264: 2, 267: 2, 270: 3, 272: 3, 273: 4, 287: 3, 289: 3, 291: 5, 299: 5, 300: 3, 304: 3, 314: 2, 315: 3, 320: 2, 323: 3, 327: 4, 328: 2, 329: 2, 330: 8, 334: 2, 335: 3, 341: 5, 342: 6, 347: 5, 348: 5, 350: 6, 351: 5, 352: 3, 353: 3, 354: 2, 358: 2, 365: 3, 366: 2, 371: 7, 372: 5, 376: 2, 384: 5, 385: 4, 386: 3, 387: 3, 392: 2, 393: 3, 396: 6, 397: 5, 398: 4, 402: 3} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 6 "The DetNet data plane also allows for the aggregation of DetNet flows, to improved scaling. How this is done is data plane dependent. When DetNet flows are aggregated, transit nodes provide service to the aggregate and not on a per-DetNet flow basis. In this case, nodes performing aggregation will ensure that per-flow service requirements are achieved." "Branch for review Merge it ! Changes look good - clicking correct button this time" 215d293ca11d1a96b10664fe5db5be2326ffc8d9 215d293ca11d1a96b10664fe5db5be2326ffc8d9 draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework b8e0b075e142ae2f1aa069488f8000d04b0bedb759e534b4f3f4faa3fb768540 ['6a0240a7089e9eb5374ec83c67aef29bce159a2350fae0b9675eca23103d04c7', 'ab93afb1ce53a91a86685ff579055185d9f7a6798d6effa52aec9838538bdf15', '5c5fe7e7a382ebc21f89d163deb3520302620f0efe90cedb8592a80b5ef6a394', '9f3e9e766fee6f9a75b58bf2c2c777ce55644ad43d69d63665d0083617a38b97', '438eb33c698936afb27ac820b5f68528ff155bd5a6927b63e6259a419be2e1a9', '685699140cefd1e1e66aa17dc3988b9e5199f0b20725eaff95c5fb402dd99ab1', '629c77ae73bd5bfa3198c993b2ee5bf42d1053919c44a7bfbd4a52ce7fa0cfbc', '32c06de60bfb9a32a4964f8ff36fd6c68613588e0780c615ffba4c9345430550', 'f5c444ddb56e26611d44ad7330c283ece50e6e047425343d3e45921bc79408f4', '7af2de76ac8144b79b38e6811634ac733b49a0fd1ba8ffd5deb0ce8fc5d59f64', '83839a4b6f00a98b672d7d42db0e734dfc50262a09e90121413fa7e8f02a1fa3', '75621d6a5adc1618337a02bf68856f7e1f8591c46fda003f39100f58bad112e3', 'cb0a896212775790b72c6ab166cdad1e0451e7d5ea431da0ea0860916cda581a', '9283a73ca025c686c922c33dd2ed832d8ee84f73c4d6ebb8f5a0fccc7689e4d2', '7c4efe66437cfbee01a00d61df6ef4d030ed30bb5727f73bcac50e7cd171243e', '4a1f8d94a306d844766f5ea77194480640792e8c0875ae9667b948e8fefe47bc', 'b8e0b075e142ae2f1aa069488f8000d04b0bedb759e534b4f3f4faa3fb768540', '6edcb9ad2f12872c1be8bc6fab00a31577544fdce451800abeb75dddd6b6c7df', 'be6ce6588c15ac0a77f3d62ef229d6d3440b7f6f4a670090aa9767094cb6dcd3'] A "the detnet data plane also allows for the aggregation of detnet flows, to improved scaling. how this is done is data plane dependent. when detnet flows are aggregated, transit nodes provide service to the aggregate and not on a per-detnet flow basis. in this case, nodes performing aggregation will ensure that per-flow service requirements are achieved." {31: 1, 8: 1, 55: 1, 84: 1, 27: 1, 52: 1, 6: 2, 79: 3, 90: 2, 51: 4, 130: 3, 62: 3, 85: 3, 68: 2, 35: 4, 110: 4, 91: 6, 114: 4, 97: 4, 13: 4, 67: 2, 38: 5, 26: 3, 124: 2, 98: 3, 54: 3, 127: 4, 96: 4, 64: 3, 30: 5, 61: 6, 15: 4, 129: 4, 115: 4, 76: 3, 87: 4, 131: 6, 102: 2, 113: 6, 99: 3, 36: 4, 24: 3, 53: 2, 72: 5} {69: 1, 132: 1, 145: 1, 162: 1, 194: 1, 323: 1, 264: 1, 243: 1, 245: 1, 215: 1, 1: 7, 4: 3, 9: 2, 10: 4, 15: 4, 24: 3, 25: 3, 26: 3, 27: 4, 39: 3, 43: 4, 49: 7, 50: 6, 58: 6, 59: 3, 64: 4, 81: 4, 82: 4, 86: 4, 96: 5, 97: 4, 100: 7, 108: 4, 109: 5, 110: 5, 111: 3, 114: 4, 115: 5, 116: 4, 118: 4, 119: 3, 120: 4, 121: 2, 122: 5, 123: 4, 124: 2, 128: 5, 129: 5, 130: 6, 136: 3, 147: 5, 151: 5, 152: 5, 154: 4, 156: 3, 165: 4, 168: 5, 169: 4, 172: 4, 180: 5, 184: 2, 187: 6, 188: 5, 191: 4, 202: 2, 203: 3, 206: 3, 207: 4, 217: 4, 218: 6, 220: 2, 221: 2, 222: 3, 224: 4, 227: 5, 229: 4, 234: 6, 235: 3, 241: 3, 242: 3, 244: 5, 248: 5, 250: 5, 258: 9, 262: 5, 263: 6, 267: 2, 270: 4, 272: 4, 273: 2, 287: 4, 289: 4, 291: 6, 299: 5, 300: 4, 304: 4, 309: 2, 314: 3, 315: 4, 320: 2, 327: 5, 328: 2, 329: 3, 330: 8, 334: 3, 335: 4, 341: 5, 342: 6, 347: 5, 348: 5, 350: 4, 351: 6, 352: 4, 353: 4, 354: 3, 358: 2, 365: 4, 366: 3, 369: 2, 371: 7, 372: 6, 376: 3, 384: 6, 385: 5, 386: 4, 387: 4, 392: 2, 393: 3, 396: 6, 397: 5, 398: 4, 402: 4} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 6 Several of these capabilities are expanded upon in more detail below. "Branch for review Merge it ! Changes look good - clicking correct button this time" 215d293ca11d1a96b10664fe5db5be2326ffc8d9 215d293ca11d1a96b10664fe5db5be2326ffc8d9 draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework 83839a4b6f00a98b672d7d42db0e734dfc50262a09e90121413fa7e8f02a1fa3 ['6a0240a7089e9eb5374ec83c67aef29bce159a2350fae0b9675eca23103d04c7', 'ab93afb1ce53a91a86685ff579055185d9f7a6798d6effa52aec9838538bdf15', '5c5fe7e7a382ebc21f89d163deb3520302620f0efe90cedb8592a80b5ef6a394', '9f3e9e766fee6f9a75b58bf2c2c777ce55644ad43d69d63665d0083617a38b97', '438eb33c698936afb27ac820b5f68528ff155bd5a6927b63e6259a419be2e1a9', '685699140cefd1e1e66aa17dc3988b9e5199f0b20725eaff95c5fb402dd99ab1', '629c77ae73bd5bfa3198c993b2ee5bf42d1053919c44a7bfbd4a52ce7fa0cfbc', '32c06de60bfb9a32a4964f8ff36fd6c68613588e0780c615ffba4c9345430550', 'f5c444ddb56e26611d44ad7330c283ece50e6e047425343d3e45921bc79408f4', '7af2de76ac8144b79b38e6811634ac733b49a0fd1ba8ffd5deb0ce8fc5d59f64', '83839a4b6f00a98b672d7d42db0e734dfc50262a09e90121413fa7e8f02a1fa3', '75621d6a5adc1618337a02bf68856f7e1f8591c46fda003f39100f58bad112e3', 'cb0a896212775790b72c6ab166cdad1e0451e7d5ea431da0ea0860916cda581a', '9283a73ca025c686c922c33dd2ed832d8ee84f73c4d6ebb8f5a0fccc7689e4d2', '7c4efe66437cfbee01a00d61df6ef4d030ed30bb5727f73bcac50e7cd171243e', '4a1f8d94a306d844766f5ea77194480640792e8c0875ae9667b948e8fefe47bc', 'b8e0b075e142ae2f1aa069488f8000d04b0bedb759e534b4f3f4faa3fb768540', '6edcb9ad2f12872c1be8bc6fab00a31577544fdce451800abeb75dddd6b6c7df', 'be6ce6588c15ac0a77f3d62ef229d6d3440b7f6f4a670090aa9767094cb6dcd3'] B several of these capabilities are expanded upon in more detail below. {31: 1, 8: 1, 55: 1, 84: 1, 27: 1, 52: 1, 6: 2, 79: 3, 90: 2, 51: 4, 130: 3, 62: 3, 85: 3, 68: 2, 35: 4, 110: 4, 91: 6, 114: 4, 97: 4, 13: 4, 67: 2, 38: 5, 26: 3, 124: 2, 98: 3, 54: 3, 127: 4, 96: 4, 64: 3, 30: 5, 61: 6, 15: 4, 129: 4, 115: 4, 76: 3, 87: 4, 131: 6, 102: 2, 113: 6, 99: 3, 36: 4, 24: 3, 53: 2, 72: 5} {69: 1, 132: 1, 145: 1, 162: 1, 194: 1, 323: 1, 264: 1, 243: 1, 245: 1, 215: 1, 1: 7, 4: 3, 9: 2, 10: 4, 15: 4, 24: 3, 25: 3, 26: 3, 27: 4, 39: 3, 43: 4, 49: 7, 50: 6, 58: 6, 59: 3, 64: 4, 81: 4, 82: 4, 86: 4, 96: 5, 97: 4, 100: 7, 108: 4, 109: 5, 110: 5, 111: 3, 114: 4, 115: 5, 116: 4, 118: 4, 119: 3, 120: 4, 121: 2, 122: 5, 123: 4, 124: 2, 128: 5, 129: 5, 130: 6, 136: 3, 147: 5, 151: 5, 152: 5, 154: 4, 156: 3, 165: 4, 168: 5, 169: 4, 172: 4, 180: 5, 184: 2, 187: 6, 188: 5, 191: 4, 202: 2, 203: 3, 206: 3, 207: 4, 217: 4, 218: 6, 220: 2, 221: 2, 222: 3, 224: 4, 227: 5, 229: 4, 234: 6, 235: 3, 241: 3, 242: 3, 244: 5, 248: 5, 250: 5, 258: 9, 262: 5, 263: 6, 267: 2, 270: 4, 272: 4, 273: 2, 287: 4, 289: 4, 291: 6, 299: 5, 300: 4, 304: 4, 309: 2, 314: 3, 315: 4, 320: 2, 327: 5, 328: 2, 329: 3, 330: 8, 334: 3, 335: 4, 341: 5, 342: 6, 347: 5, 348: 5, 350: 4, 351: 6, 352: 4, 353: 4, 354: 3, 358: 2, 365: 4, 366: 3, 369: 2, 371: 7, 372: 6, 376: 3, 384: 6, 385: 5, 386: 4, 387: 4, 392: 2, 393: 3, 396: 6, 397: 5, 398: 4, 402: 4} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 6 "Service protection allow DetNet services to increase reliability and maintain a DetNet Service Assurance in the case of network congestion or some failures. Detnet relies on the underlying technology capabilities for various protection schemes. Protection schemes enable partial or complete coverage of the network paths and active protection with combinations of PRF, PRE, and POF." "Branch for review Merge it ! Changes look good - clicking correct button this time" 215d293ca11d1a96b10664fe5db5be2326ffc8d9 215d293ca11d1a96b10664fe5db5be2326ffc8d9 draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework 6a0240a7089e9eb5374ec83c67aef29bce159a2350fae0b9675eca23103d04c7 ['6a0240a7089e9eb5374ec83c67aef29bce159a2350fae0b9675eca23103d04c7', 'ab93afb1ce53a91a86685ff579055185d9f7a6798d6effa52aec9838538bdf15', '5c5fe7e7a382ebc21f89d163deb3520302620f0efe90cedb8592a80b5ef6a394', '9f3e9e766fee6f9a75b58bf2c2c777ce55644ad43d69d63665d0083617a38b97', '438eb33c698936afb27ac820b5f68528ff155bd5a6927b63e6259a419be2e1a9', '685699140cefd1e1e66aa17dc3988b9e5199f0b20725eaff95c5fb402dd99ab1', '629c77ae73bd5bfa3198c993b2ee5bf42d1053919c44a7bfbd4a52ce7fa0cfbc', '32c06de60bfb9a32a4964f8ff36fd6c68613588e0780c615ffba4c9345430550', 'f5c444ddb56e26611d44ad7330c283ece50e6e047425343d3e45921bc79408f4', '7af2de76ac8144b79b38e6811634ac733b49a0fd1ba8ffd5deb0ce8fc5d59f64', '83839a4b6f00a98b672d7d42db0e734dfc50262a09e90121413fa7e8f02a1fa3', '75621d6a5adc1618337a02bf68856f7e1f8591c46fda003f39100f58bad112e3', 'cb0a896212775790b72c6ab166cdad1e0451e7d5ea431da0ea0860916cda581a', '9283a73ca025c686c922c33dd2ed832d8ee84f73c4d6ebb8f5a0fccc7689e4d2', '7c4efe66437cfbee01a00d61df6ef4d030ed30bb5727f73bcac50e7cd171243e', '4a1f8d94a306d844766f5ea77194480640792e8c0875ae9667b948e8fefe47bc', 'b8e0b075e142ae2f1aa069488f8000d04b0bedb759e534b4f3f4faa3fb768540', '6edcb9ad2f12872c1be8bc6fab00a31577544fdce451800abeb75dddd6b6c7df', 'be6ce6588c15ac0a77f3d62ef229d6d3440b7f6f4a670090aa9767094cb6dcd3'] B "service protection allow detnet services to increase reliability and maintain a detnet service assurance in the case of network congestion or some failures. detnet relies on the underlying technology capabilities for various protection schemes. protection schemes enable partial or complete coverage of the network paths and active protection with combinations of prf, pre, and pof." {31: 1, 8: 1, 55: 1, 84: 1, 27: 1, 52: 1, 6: 2, 79: 3, 90: 2, 51: 4, 130: 3, 62: 3, 85: 3, 68: 2, 35: 4, 110: 4, 91: 6, 114: 4, 97: 4, 13: 4, 67: 2, 38: 5, 26: 3, 124: 2, 98: 3, 54: 3, 127: 4, 96: 4, 64: 3, 30: 5, 61: 6, 15: 4, 129: 4, 115: 4, 76: 3, 87: 4, 131: 6, 102: 2, 113: 6, 99: 3, 36: 4, 24: 3, 53: 2, 72: 5} {69: 1, 132: 1, 145: 1, 162: 1, 194: 1, 323: 1, 264: 1, 243: 1, 245: 1, 215: 1, 1: 7, 4: 3, 9: 2, 10: 4, 15: 4, 24: 3, 25: 3, 26: 3, 27: 4, 39: 3, 43: 4, 49: 7, 50: 6, 58: 6, 59: 3, 64: 4, 81: 4, 82: 4, 86: 4, 96: 5, 97: 4, 100: 7, 108: 4, 109: 5, 110: 5, 111: 3, 114: 4, 115: 5, 116: 4, 118: 4, 119: 3, 120: 4, 121: 2, 122: 5, 123: 4, 124: 2, 128: 5, 129: 5, 130: 6, 136: 3, 147: 5, 151: 5, 152: 5, 154: 4, 156: 3, 165: 4, 168: 5, 169: 4, 172: 4, 180: 5, 184: 2, 187: 6, 188: 5, 191: 4, 202: 2, 203: 3, 206: 3, 207: 4, 217: 4, 218: 6, 220: 2, 221: 2, 222: 3, 224: 4, 227: 5, 229: 4, 234: 6, 235: 3, 241: 3, 242: 3, 244: 5, 248: 5, 250: 5, 258: 9, 262: 5, 263: 6, 267: 2, 270: 4, 272: 4, 273: 2, 287: 4, 289: 4, 291: 6, 299: 5, 300: 4, 304: 4, 309: 2, 314: 3, 315: 4, 320: 2, 327: 5, 328: 2, 329: 3, 330: 8, 334: 3, 335: 4, 341: 5, 342: 6, 347: 5, 348: 5, 350: 4, 351: 6, 352: 4, 353: 4, 354: 3, 358: 2, 365: 4, 366: 3, 369: 2, 371: 7, 372: 6, 376: 3, 384: 6, 385: 5, 386: 4, 387: 4, 392: 2, 393: 3, 396: 6, 397: 5, 398: 4, 402: 4} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 6 "An example DetNet MPLS network fragment and packet flow is illustrated in dn_protection_flow." "Branch for review Merge it ! Changes look good - clicking correct button this time" 215d293ca11d1a96b10664fe5db5be2326ffc8d9 215d293ca11d1a96b10664fe5db5be2326ffc8d9 draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework 7af2de76ac8144b79b38e6811634ac733b49a0fd1ba8ffd5deb0ce8fc5d59f64 ['6a0240a7089e9eb5374ec83c67aef29bce159a2350fae0b9675eca23103d04c7', 'ab93afb1ce53a91a86685ff579055185d9f7a6798d6effa52aec9838538bdf15', '5c5fe7e7a382ebc21f89d163deb3520302620f0efe90cedb8592a80b5ef6a394', '9f3e9e766fee6f9a75b58bf2c2c777ce55644ad43d69d63665d0083617a38b97', '438eb33c698936afb27ac820b5f68528ff155bd5a6927b63e6259a419be2e1a9', '685699140cefd1e1e66aa17dc3988b9e5199f0b20725eaff95c5fb402dd99ab1', '629c77ae73bd5bfa3198c993b2ee5bf42d1053919c44a7bfbd4a52ce7fa0cfbc', '32c06de60bfb9a32a4964f8ff36fd6c68613588e0780c615ffba4c9345430550', 'f5c444ddb56e26611d44ad7330c283ece50e6e047425343d3e45921bc79408f4', '7af2de76ac8144b79b38e6811634ac733b49a0fd1ba8ffd5deb0ce8fc5d59f64', '83839a4b6f00a98b672d7d42db0e734dfc50262a09e90121413fa7e8f02a1fa3', '75621d6a5adc1618337a02bf68856f7e1f8591c46fda003f39100f58bad112e3', 'cb0a896212775790b72c6ab166cdad1e0451e7d5ea431da0ea0860916cda581a', '9283a73ca025c686c922c33dd2ed832d8ee84f73c4d6ebb8f5a0fccc7689e4d2', '7c4efe66437cfbee01a00d61df6ef4d030ed30bb5727f73bcac50e7cd171243e', '4a1f8d94a306d844766f5ea77194480640792e8c0875ae9667b948e8fefe47bc', 'b8e0b075e142ae2f1aa069488f8000d04b0bedb759e534b4f3f4faa3fb768540', '6edcb9ad2f12872c1be8bc6fab00a31577544fdce451800abeb75dddd6b6c7df', 'be6ce6588c15ac0a77f3d62ef229d6d3440b7f6f4a670090aa9767094cb6dcd3'] B "an example detnet mpls network fragment and packet flow is illustrated in dn_protection_flow." {31: 1, 8: 1, 55: 1, 84: 1, 27: 1, 52: 1, 6: 2, 79: 3, 90: 2, 51: 4, 130: 3, 62: 3, 85: 3, 68: 2, 35: 4, 110: 4, 91: 6, 114: 4, 97: 4, 13: 4, 67: 2, 38: 5, 26: 3, 124: 2, 98: 3, 54: 3, 127: 4, 96: 4, 64: 3, 30: 5, 61: 6, 15: 4, 129: 4, 115: 4, 76: 3, 87: 4, 131: 6, 102: 2, 113: 6, 99: 3, 36: 4, 24: 3, 53: 2, 72: 5} {69: 1, 132: 1, 145: 1, 162: 1, 194: 1, 323: 1, 264: 1, 243: 1, 245: 1, 215: 1, 1: 7, 4: 3, 9: 2, 10: 4, 15: 4, 24: 3, 25: 3, 26: 3, 27: 4, 39: 3, 43: 4, 49: 7, 50: 6, 58: 6, 59: 3, 64: 4, 81: 4, 82: 4, 86: 4, 96: 5, 97: 4, 100: 7, 108: 4, 109: 5, 110: 5, 111: 3, 114: 4, 115: 5, 116: 4, 118: 4, 119: 3, 120: 4, 121: 2, 122: 5, 123: 4, 124: 2, 128: 5, 129: 5, 130: 6, 136: 3, 147: 5, 151: 5, 152: 5, 154: 4, 156: 3, 165: 4, 168: 5, 169: 4, 172: 4, 180: 5, 184: 2, 187: 6, 188: 5, 191: 4, 202: 2, 203: 3, 206: 3, 207: 4, 217: 4, 218: 6, 220: 2, 221: 2, 222: 3, 224: 4, 227: 5, 229: 4, 234: 6, 235: 3, 241: 3, 242: 3, 244: 5, 248: 5, 250: 5, 258: 9, 262: 5, 263: 6, 267: 2, 270: 4, 272: 4, 273: 2, 287: 4, 289: 4, 291: 6, 299: 5, 300: 4, 304: 4, 309: 2, 314: 3, 315: 4, 320: 2, 327: 5, 328: 2, 329: 3, 330: 8, 334: 3, 335: 4, 341: 5, 342: 6, 347: 5, 348: 5, 350: 4, 351: 6, 352: 4, 353: 4, 354: 3, 358: 2, 365: 4, 366: 3, 369: 2, 371: 7, 372: 6, 376: 3, 384: 6, 385: 5, 386: 4, 387: 4, 392: 2, 393: 3, 396: 6, 397: 5, 398: 4, 402: 4} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 6 "In dn_protection_flow the numbers are used to identify the instance of a packet. Packet 1 is the original packet, and packets 1.1, and 1.2 are two first generation copies of packet 1. Packet 1.2.1 is a second generation copy of packet 1.2 etc. Note that these numbers never appear in the packet, and are not to be confused with sequence numbers, labels or any other identifier that appears in the packet. They simply indicate the generation number of the original packet so that its passage through the network fragment can be identified to the reader." "Branch for review Merge it ! Changes look good - clicking correct button this time" 215d293ca11d1a96b10664fe5db5be2326ffc8d9 215d293ca11d1a96b10664fe5db5be2326ffc8d9 draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework 6edcb9ad2f12872c1be8bc6fab00a31577544fdce451800abeb75dddd6b6c7df ['6a0240a7089e9eb5374ec83c67aef29bce159a2350fae0b9675eca23103d04c7', 'ab93afb1ce53a91a86685ff579055185d9f7a6798d6effa52aec9838538bdf15', '5c5fe7e7a382ebc21f89d163deb3520302620f0efe90cedb8592a80b5ef6a394', '9f3e9e766fee6f9a75b58bf2c2c777ce55644ad43d69d63665d0083617a38b97', '438eb33c698936afb27ac820b5f68528ff155bd5a6927b63e6259a419be2e1a9', '685699140cefd1e1e66aa17dc3988b9e5199f0b20725eaff95c5fb402dd99ab1', '629c77ae73bd5bfa3198c993b2ee5bf42d1053919c44a7bfbd4a52ce7fa0cfbc', '32c06de60bfb9a32a4964f8ff36fd6c68613588e0780c615ffba4c9345430550', 'f5c444ddb56e26611d44ad7330c283ece50e6e047425343d3e45921bc79408f4', '7af2de76ac8144b79b38e6811634ac733b49a0fd1ba8ffd5deb0ce8fc5d59f64', '83839a4b6f00a98b672d7d42db0e734dfc50262a09e90121413fa7e8f02a1fa3', '75621d6a5adc1618337a02bf68856f7e1f8591c46fda003f39100f58bad112e3', 'cb0a896212775790b72c6ab166cdad1e0451e7d5ea431da0ea0860916cda581a', '9283a73ca025c686c922c33dd2ed832d8ee84f73c4d6ebb8f5a0fccc7689e4d2', '7c4efe66437cfbee01a00d61df6ef4d030ed30bb5727f73bcac50e7cd171243e', '4a1f8d94a306d844766f5ea77194480640792e8c0875ae9667b948e8fefe47bc', 'b8e0b075e142ae2f1aa069488f8000d04b0bedb759e534b4f3f4faa3fb768540', '6edcb9ad2f12872c1be8bc6fab00a31577544fdce451800abeb75dddd6b6c7df', 'be6ce6588c15ac0a77f3d62ef229d6d3440b7f6f4a670090aa9767094cb6dcd3'] B "in dn_protection_flow the numbers are used to identify the instance of a packet. packet 1 is the original packet, and packets 1.1, and 1.2 are two first generation copies of packet 1. packet 1.2.1 is a second generation copy of packet 1.2 etc. note that these numbers never appear in the packet, and are not to be confused with sequence numbers, labels or any other identifier that appears in the packet. they simply indicate the generation number of the original packet so that its passage through the network fragment can be identified to the reader." {31: 1, 8: 1, 55: 1, 84: 1, 27: 1, 52: 1, 6: 2, 79: 3, 90: 2, 51: 4, 130: 3, 62: 3, 85: 3, 68: 2, 35: 4, 110: 4, 91: 6, 114: 4, 97: 4, 13: 4, 67: 2, 38: 5, 26: 3, 124: 2, 98: 3, 54: 3, 127: 4, 96: 4, 64: 3, 30: 5, 61: 6, 15: 4, 129: 4, 115: 4, 76: 3, 87: 4, 131: 6, 102: 2, 113: 6, 99: 3, 36: 4, 24: 3, 53: 2, 72: 5} {69: 1, 132: 1, 145: 1, 162: 1, 194: 1, 323: 1, 264: 1, 243: 1, 245: 1, 215: 1, 1: 7, 4: 3, 9: 2, 10: 4, 15: 4, 24: 3, 25: 3, 26: 3, 27: 4, 39: 3, 43: 4, 49: 7, 50: 6, 58: 6, 59: 3, 64: 4, 81: 4, 82: 4, 86: 4, 96: 5, 97: 4, 100: 7, 108: 4, 109: 5, 110: 5, 111: 3, 114: 4, 115: 5, 116: 4, 118: 4, 119: 3, 120: 4, 121: 2, 122: 5, 123: 4, 124: 2, 128: 5, 129: 5, 130: 6, 136: 3, 147: 5, 151: 5, 152: 5, 154: 4, 156: 3, 165: 4, 168: 5, 169: 4, 172: 4, 180: 5, 184: 2, 187: 6, 188: 5, 191: 4, 202: 2, 203: 3, 206: 3, 207: 4, 217: 4, 218: 6, 220: 2, 221: 2, 222: 3, 224: 4, 227: 5, 229: 4, 234: 6, 235: 3, 241: 3, 242: 3, 244: 5, 248: 5, 250: 5, 258: 9, 262: 5, 263: 6, 267: 2, 270: 4, 272: 4, 273: 2, 287: 4, 289: 4, 291: 6, 299: 5, 300: 4, 304: 4, 309: 2, 314: 3, 315: 4, 320: 2, 327: 5, 328: 2, 329: 3, 330: 8, 334: 3, 335: 4, 341: 5, 342: 6, 347: 5, 348: 5, 350: 4, 351: 6, 352: 4, 353: 4, 354: 3, 358: 2, 365: 4, 366: 3, 369: 2, 371: 7, 372: 6, 376: 3, 384: 6, 385: 5, 386: 4, 387: 4, 392: 2, 393: 3, 396: 6, 397: 5, 398: 4, 402: 4} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 6 "Customer Equipment CE1 sends a packet into the DetNet enabled network. This is packet (1). Edge Node EN1 encapsulates the packet as a DetNet Packet and sends it to Relay node R1 (packet 1.1). EN1 makes a copy of the packet (1.2), encapsulates it and sends this copy to Relay node R4." "Branch for review Merge it ! Changes look good - clicking correct button this time" 215d293ca11d1a96b10664fe5db5be2326ffc8d9 215d293ca11d1a96b10664fe5db5be2326ffc8d9 draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework f5c444ddb56e26611d44ad7330c283ece50e6e047425343d3e45921bc79408f4 ['6a0240a7089e9eb5374ec83c67aef29bce159a2350fae0b9675eca23103d04c7', 'ab93afb1ce53a91a86685ff579055185d9f7a6798d6effa52aec9838538bdf15', '5c5fe7e7a382ebc21f89d163deb3520302620f0efe90cedb8592a80b5ef6a394', '9f3e9e766fee6f9a75b58bf2c2c777ce55644ad43d69d63665d0083617a38b97', '438eb33c698936afb27ac820b5f68528ff155bd5a6927b63e6259a419be2e1a9', '685699140cefd1e1e66aa17dc3988b9e5199f0b20725eaff95c5fb402dd99ab1', '629c77ae73bd5bfa3198c993b2ee5bf42d1053919c44a7bfbd4a52ce7fa0cfbc', '32c06de60bfb9a32a4964f8ff36fd6c68613588e0780c615ffba4c9345430550', 'f5c444ddb56e26611d44ad7330c283ece50e6e047425343d3e45921bc79408f4', '7af2de76ac8144b79b38e6811634ac733b49a0fd1ba8ffd5deb0ce8fc5d59f64', '83839a4b6f00a98b672d7d42db0e734dfc50262a09e90121413fa7e8f02a1fa3', '75621d6a5adc1618337a02bf68856f7e1f8591c46fda003f39100f58bad112e3', 'cb0a896212775790b72c6ab166cdad1e0451e7d5ea431da0ea0860916cda581a', '9283a73ca025c686c922c33dd2ed832d8ee84f73c4d6ebb8f5a0fccc7689e4d2', '7c4efe66437cfbee01a00d61df6ef4d030ed30bb5727f73bcac50e7cd171243e', '4a1f8d94a306d844766f5ea77194480640792e8c0875ae9667b948e8fefe47bc', 'b8e0b075e142ae2f1aa069488f8000d04b0bedb759e534b4f3f4faa3fb768540', '6edcb9ad2f12872c1be8bc6fab00a31577544fdce451800abeb75dddd6b6c7df', 'be6ce6588c15ac0a77f3d62ef229d6d3440b7f6f4a670090aa9767094cb6dcd3'] B "customer equipment ce1 sends a packet into the detnet enabled network. this is packet (1). edge node en1 encapsulates the packet as a detnet packet and sends it to relay node r1 (packet 1.1). en1 makes a copy of the packet (1.2), encapsulates it and sends this copy to relay node r4." {31: 1, 8: 1, 55: 1, 84: 1, 27: 1, 52: 1, 6: 2, 79: 3, 90: 2, 51: 4, 130: 3, 62: 3, 85: 3, 68: 2, 35: 4, 110: 4, 91: 6, 114: 4, 97: 4, 13: 4, 67: 2, 38: 5, 26: 3, 124: 2, 98: 3, 54: 3, 127: 4, 96: 4, 64: 3, 30: 5, 61: 6, 15: 4, 129: 4, 115: 4, 76: 3, 87: 4, 131: 6, 102: 2, 113: 6, 99: 3, 36: 4, 24: 3, 53: 2, 72: 5} {69: 1, 132: 1, 145: 1, 162: 1, 194: 1, 323: 1, 264: 1, 243: 1, 245: 1, 215: 1, 1: 7, 4: 3, 9: 2, 10: 4, 15: 4, 24: 3, 25: 3, 26: 3, 27: 4, 39: 3, 43: 4, 49: 7, 50: 6, 58: 6, 59: 3, 64: 4, 81: 4, 82: 4, 86: 4, 96: 5, 97: 4, 100: 7, 108: 4, 109: 5, 110: 5, 111: 3, 114: 4, 115: 5, 116: 4, 118: 4, 119: 3, 120: 4, 121: 2, 122: 5, 123: 4, 124: 2, 128: 5, 129: 5, 130: 6, 136: 3, 147: 5, 151: 5, 152: 5, 154: 4, 156: 3, 165: 4, 168: 5, 169: 4, 172: 4, 180: 5, 184: 2, 187: 6, 188: 5, 191: 4, 202: 2, 203: 3, 206: 3, 207: 4, 217: 4, 218: 6, 220: 2, 221: 2, 222: 3, 224: 4, 227: 5, 229: 4, 234: 6, 235: 3, 241: 3, 242: 3, 244: 5, 248: 5, 250: 5, 258: 9, 262: 5, 263: 6, 267: 2, 270: 4, 272: 4, 273: 2, 287: 4, 289: 4, 291: 6, 299: 5, 300: 4, 304: 4, 309: 2, 314: 3, 315: 4, 320: 2, 327: 5, 328: 2, 329: 3, 330: 8, 334: 3, 335: 4, 341: 5, 342: 6, 347: 5, 348: 5, 350: 4, 351: 6, 352: 4, 353: 4, 354: 3, 358: 2, 365: 4, 366: 3, 369: 2, 371: 7, 372: 6, 376: 3, 384: 6, 385: 5, 386: 4, 387: 4, 392: 2, 393: 3, 396: 6, 397: 5, 398: 4, 402: 4} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 6 "Note that along the path from EN1 to R1 there may be zero or more nodes which, for clarity, are not shown. The same is true for any other path between two DetNet entities shown in dn_protection_flow ." "Branch for review Merge it ! Changes look good - clicking correct button this time" 215d293ca11d1a96b10664fe5db5be2326ffc8d9 215d293ca11d1a96b10664fe5db5be2326ffc8d9 draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework 7c4efe66437cfbee01a00d61df6ef4d030ed30bb5727f73bcac50e7cd171243e ['6a0240a7089e9eb5374ec83c67aef29bce159a2350fae0b9675eca23103d04c7', 'ab93afb1ce53a91a86685ff579055185d9f7a6798d6effa52aec9838538bdf15', '5c5fe7e7a382ebc21f89d163deb3520302620f0efe90cedb8592a80b5ef6a394', '9f3e9e766fee6f9a75b58bf2c2c777ce55644ad43d69d63665d0083617a38b97', '438eb33c698936afb27ac820b5f68528ff155bd5a6927b63e6259a419be2e1a9', '685699140cefd1e1e66aa17dc3988b9e5199f0b20725eaff95c5fb402dd99ab1', '629c77ae73bd5bfa3198c993b2ee5bf42d1053919c44a7bfbd4a52ce7fa0cfbc', '32c06de60bfb9a32a4964f8ff36fd6c68613588e0780c615ffba4c9345430550', 'f5c444ddb56e26611d44ad7330c283ece50e6e047425343d3e45921bc79408f4', '7af2de76ac8144b79b38e6811634ac733b49a0fd1ba8ffd5deb0ce8fc5d59f64', '83839a4b6f00a98b672d7d42db0e734dfc50262a09e90121413fa7e8f02a1fa3', '75621d6a5adc1618337a02bf68856f7e1f8591c46fda003f39100f58bad112e3', 'cb0a896212775790b72c6ab166cdad1e0451e7d5ea431da0ea0860916cda581a', '9283a73ca025c686c922c33dd2ed832d8ee84f73c4d6ebb8f5a0fccc7689e4d2', '7c4efe66437cfbee01a00d61df6ef4d030ed30bb5727f73bcac50e7cd171243e', '4a1f8d94a306d844766f5ea77194480640792e8c0875ae9667b948e8fefe47bc', 'b8e0b075e142ae2f1aa069488f8000d04b0bedb759e534b4f3f4faa3fb768540', '6edcb9ad2f12872c1be8bc6fab00a31577544fdce451800abeb75dddd6b6c7df', 'be6ce6588c15ac0a77f3d62ef229d6d3440b7f6f4a670090aa9767094cb6dcd3'] B "note that along the path from en1 to r1 there may be zero or more nodes which, for clarity, are not shown. the same is true for any other path between two detnet entities shown in dn_protection_flow ." {31: 1, 8: 1, 55: 1, 84: 1, 27: 1, 52: 1, 6: 2, 79: 3, 90: 2, 51: 4, 130: 3, 62: 3, 85: 3, 68: 2, 35: 4, 110: 4, 91: 6, 114: 4, 97: 4, 13: 4, 67: 2, 38: 5, 26: 3, 124: 2, 98: 3, 54: 3, 127: 4, 96: 4, 64: 3, 30: 5, 61: 6, 15: 4, 129: 4, 115: 4, 76: 3, 87: 4, 131: 6, 102: 2, 113: 6, 99: 3, 36: 4, 24: 3, 53: 2, 72: 5} {69: 1, 132: 1, 145: 1, 162: 1, 194: 1, 323: 1, 264: 1, 243: 1, 245: 1, 215: 1, 1: 7, 4: 3, 9: 2, 10: 4, 15: 4, 24: 3, 25: 3, 26: 3, 27: 4, 39: 3, 43: 4, 49: 7, 50: 6, 58: 6, 59: 3, 64: 4, 81: 4, 82: 4, 86: 4, 96: 5, 97: 4, 100: 7, 108: 4, 109: 5, 110: 5, 111: 3, 114: 4, 115: 5, 116: 4, 118: 4, 119: 3, 120: 4, 121: 2, 122: 5, 123: 4, 124: 2, 128: 5, 129: 5, 130: 6, 136: 3, 147: 5, 151: 5, 152: 5, 154: 4, 156: 3, 165: 4, 168: 5, 169: 4, 172: 4, 180: 5, 184: 2, 187: 6, 188: 5, 191: 4, 202: 2, 203: 3, 206: 3, 207: 4, 217: 4, 218: 6, 220: 2, 221: 2, 222: 3, 224: 4, 227: 5, 229: 4, 234: 6, 235: 3, 241: 3, 242: 3, 244: 5, 248: 5, 250: 5, 258: 9, 262: 5, 263: 6, 267: 2, 270: 4, 272: 4, 273: 2, 287: 4, 289: 4, 291: 6, 299: 5, 300: 4, 304: 4, 309: 2, 314: 3, 315: 4, 320: 2, 327: 5, 328: 2, 329: 3, 330: 8, 334: 3, 335: 4, 341: 5, 342: 6, 347: 5, 348: 5, 350: 4, 351: 6, 352: 4, 353: 4, 354: 3, 358: 2, 365: 4, 366: 3, 369: 2, 371: 7, 372: 6, 376: 3, 384: 6, 385: 5, 386: 4, 387: 4, 392: 2, 393: 3, 396: 6, 397: 5, 398: 4, 402: 4} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 6 "Relay node R4 has been configured to send one copy of the packet to Relay Node R2 (packet 1.2.1) and one copy to Edge Node EN2 (packet 1.2.2)." "Branch for review Merge it ! Changes look good - clicking correct button this time" 215d293ca11d1a96b10664fe5db5be2326ffc8d9 215d293ca11d1a96b10664fe5db5be2326ffc8d9 draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework 438eb33c698936afb27ac820b5f68528ff155bd5a6927b63e6259a419be2e1a9 ['6a0240a7089e9eb5374ec83c67aef29bce159a2350fae0b9675eca23103d04c7', 'ab93afb1ce53a91a86685ff579055185d9f7a6798d6effa52aec9838538bdf15', '5c5fe7e7a382ebc21f89d163deb3520302620f0efe90cedb8592a80b5ef6a394', '9f3e9e766fee6f9a75b58bf2c2c777ce55644ad43d69d63665d0083617a38b97', '438eb33c698936afb27ac820b5f68528ff155bd5a6927b63e6259a419be2e1a9', '685699140cefd1e1e66aa17dc3988b9e5199f0b20725eaff95c5fb402dd99ab1', '629c77ae73bd5bfa3198c993b2ee5bf42d1053919c44a7bfbd4a52ce7fa0cfbc', '32c06de60bfb9a32a4964f8ff36fd6c68613588e0780c615ffba4c9345430550', 'f5c444ddb56e26611d44ad7330c283ece50e6e047425343d3e45921bc79408f4', '7af2de76ac8144b79b38e6811634ac733b49a0fd1ba8ffd5deb0ce8fc5d59f64', '83839a4b6f00a98b672d7d42db0e734dfc50262a09e90121413fa7e8f02a1fa3', '75621d6a5adc1618337a02bf68856f7e1f8591c46fda003f39100f58bad112e3', 'cb0a896212775790b72c6ab166cdad1e0451e7d5ea431da0ea0860916cda581a', '9283a73ca025c686c922c33dd2ed832d8ee84f73c4d6ebb8f5a0fccc7689e4d2', '7c4efe66437cfbee01a00d61df6ef4d030ed30bb5727f73bcac50e7cd171243e', '4a1f8d94a306d844766f5ea77194480640792e8c0875ae9667b948e8fefe47bc', 'b8e0b075e142ae2f1aa069488f8000d04b0bedb759e534b4f3f4faa3fb768540', '6edcb9ad2f12872c1be8bc6fab00a31577544fdce451800abeb75dddd6b6c7df', 'be6ce6588c15ac0a77f3d62ef229d6d3440b7f6f4a670090aa9767094cb6dcd3'] B "relay node r4 has been configured to send one copy of the packet to relay node r2 (packet 1.2.1) and one copy to edge node en2 (packet 1.2.2)." {31: 1, 8: 1, 55: 1, 84: 1, 27: 1, 52: 1, 6: 2, 79: 3, 90: 2, 51: 4, 130: 3, 62: 3, 85: 3, 68: 2, 35: 4, 110: 4, 91: 6, 114: 4, 97: 4, 13: 4, 67: 2, 38: 5, 26: 3, 124: 2, 98: 3, 54: 3, 127: 4, 96: 4, 64: 3, 30: 5, 61: 6, 15: 4, 129: 4, 115: 4, 76: 3, 87: 4, 131: 6, 102: 2, 113: 6, 99: 3, 36: 4, 24: 3, 53: 2, 72: 5} {69: 1, 132: 1, 145: 1, 162: 1, 194: 1, 323: 1, 264: 1, 243: 1, 245: 1, 215: 1, 1: 7, 4: 3, 9: 2, 10: 4, 15: 4, 24: 3, 25: 3, 26: 3, 27: 4, 39: 3, 43: 4, 49: 7, 50: 6, 58: 6, 59: 3, 64: 4, 81: 4, 82: 4, 86: 4, 96: 5, 97: 4, 100: 7, 108: 4, 109: 5, 110: 5, 111: 3, 114: 4, 115: 5, 116: 4, 118: 4, 119: 3, 120: 4, 121: 2, 122: 5, 123: 4, 124: 2, 128: 5, 129: 5, 130: 6, 136: 3, 147: 5, 151: 5, 152: 5, 154: 4, 156: 3, 165: 4, 168: 5, 169: 4, 172: 4, 180: 5, 184: 2, 187: 6, 188: 5, 191: 4, 202: 2, 203: 3, 206: 3, 207: 4, 217: 4, 218: 6, 220: 2, 221: 2, 222: 3, 224: 4, 227: 5, 229: 4, 234: 6, 235: 3, 241: 3, 242: 3, 244: 5, 248: 5, 250: 5, 258: 9, 262: 5, 263: 6, 267: 2, 270: 4, 272: 4, 273: 2, 287: 4, 289: 4, 291: 6, 299: 5, 300: 4, 304: 4, 309: 2, 314: 3, 315: 4, 320: 2, 327: 5, 328: 2, 329: 3, 330: 8, 334: 3, 335: 4, 341: 5, 342: 6, 347: 5, 348: 5, 350: 4, 351: 6, 352: 4, 353: 4, 354: 3, 358: 2, 365: 4, 366: 3, 369: 2, 371: 7, 372: 6, 376: 3, 384: 6, 385: 5, 386: 4, 387: 4, 392: 2, 393: 3, 396: 6, 397: 5, 398: 4, 402: 4} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 6 "R2 receives packet copy 1.2.1 before packet copy 1.1 arrives, and, having been configured to perform packet elimination on this DetNet flow, forwards packet 1.2.1 to Relay Node R3. Packet copy 1.1 is of no further use and so is discarded by R2." "Branch for review Merge it ! Changes look good - clicking correct button this time" 215d293ca11d1a96b10664fe5db5be2326ffc8d9 215d293ca11d1a96b10664fe5db5be2326ffc8d9 draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework 5c5fe7e7a382ebc21f89d163deb3520302620f0efe90cedb8592a80b5ef6a394 ['6a0240a7089e9eb5374ec83c67aef29bce159a2350fae0b9675eca23103d04c7', 'ab93afb1ce53a91a86685ff579055185d9f7a6798d6effa52aec9838538bdf15', '5c5fe7e7a382ebc21f89d163deb3520302620f0efe90cedb8592a80b5ef6a394', '9f3e9e766fee6f9a75b58bf2c2c777ce55644ad43d69d63665d0083617a38b97', '438eb33c698936afb27ac820b5f68528ff155bd5a6927b63e6259a419be2e1a9', '685699140cefd1e1e66aa17dc3988b9e5199f0b20725eaff95c5fb402dd99ab1', '629c77ae73bd5bfa3198c993b2ee5bf42d1053919c44a7bfbd4a52ce7fa0cfbc', '32c06de60bfb9a32a4964f8ff36fd6c68613588e0780c615ffba4c9345430550', 'f5c444ddb56e26611d44ad7330c283ece50e6e047425343d3e45921bc79408f4', '7af2de76ac8144b79b38e6811634ac733b49a0fd1ba8ffd5deb0ce8fc5d59f64', '83839a4b6f00a98b672d7d42db0e734dfc50262a09e90121413fa7e8f02a1fa3', '75621d6a5adc1618337a02bf68856f7e1f8591c46fda003f39100f58bad112e3', 'cb0a896212775790b72c6ab166cdad1e0451e7d5ea431da0ea0860916cda581a', '9283a73ca025c686c922c33dd2ed832d8ee84f73c4d6ebb8f5a0fccc7689e4d2', '7c4efe66437cfbee01a00d61df6ef4d030ed30bb5727f73bcac50e7cd171243e', '4a1f8d94a306d844766f5ea77194480640792e8c0875ae9667b948e8fefe47bc', 'b8e0b075e142ae2f1aa069488f8000d04b0bedb759e534b4f3f4faa3fb768540', '6edcb9ad2f12872c1be8bc6fab00a31577544fdce451800abeb75dddd6b6c7df', 'be6ce6588c15ac0a77f3d62ef229d6d3440b7f6f4a670090aa9767094cb6dcd3'] B "r2 receives packet copy 1.2.1 before packet copy 1.1 arrives, and, having been configured to perform packet elimination on this detnet flow, forwards packet 1.2.1 to relay node r3. packet copy 1.1 is of no further use and so is discarded by r2." {31: 1, 8: 1, 55: 1, 84: 1, 27: 1, 52: 1, 6: 2, 79: 3, 90: 2, 51: 4, 130: 3, 62: 3, 85: 3, 68: 2, 35: 4, 110: 4, 91: 6, 114: 4, 97: 4, 13: 4, 67: 2, 38: 5, 26: 3, 124: 2, 98: 3, 54: 3, 127: 4, 96: 4, 64: 3, 30: 5, 61: 6, 15: 4, 129: 4, 115: 4, 76: 3, 87: 4, 131: 6, 102: 2, 113: 6, 99: 3, 36: 4, 24: 3, 53: 2, 72: 5} {69: 1, 132: 1, 145: 1, 162: 1, 194: 1, 323: 1, 264: 1, 243: 1, 245: 1, 215: 1, 1: 7, 4: 3, 9: 2, 10: 4, 15: 4, 24: 3, 25: 3, 26: 3, 27: 4, 39: 3, 43: 4, 49: 7, 50: 6, 58: 6, 59: 3, 64: 4, 81: 4, 82: 4, 86: 4, 96: 5, 97: 4, 100: 7, 108: 4, 109: 5, 110: 5, 111: 3, 114: 4, 115: 5, 116: 4, 118: 4, 119: 3, 120: 4, 121: 2, 122: 5, 123: 4, 124: 2, 128: 5, 129: 5, 130: 6, 136: 3, 147: 5, 151: 5, 152: 5, 154: 4, 156: 3, 165: 4, 168: 5, 169: 4, 172: 4, 180: 5, 184: 2, 187: 6, 188: 5, 191: 4, 202: 2, 203: 3, 206: 3, 207: 4, 217: 4, 218: 6, 220: 2, 221: 2, 222: 3, 224: 4, 227: 5, 229: 4, 234: 6, 235: 3, 241: 3, 242: 3, 244: 5, 248: 5, 250: 5, 258: 9, 262: 5, 263: 6, 267: 2, 270: 4, 272: 4, 273: 2, 287: 4, 289: 4, 291: 6, 299: 5, 300: 4, 304: 4, 309: 2, 314: 3, 315: 4, 320: 2, 327: 5, 328: 2, 329: 3, 330: 8, 334: 3, 335: 4, 341: 5, 342: 6, 347: 5, 348: 5, 350: 4, 351: 6, 352: 4, 353: 4, 354: 3, 358: 2, 365: 4, 366: 3, 369: 2, 371: 7, 372: 6, 376: 3, 384: 6, 385: 5, 386: 4, 387: 4, 392: 2, 393: 3, 396: 6, 397: 5, 398: 4, 402: 4} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 6 "Edge Node EN2 receives packet copy 1.2.2 from R4 before it receives packet copy 1.2.1 from R2 via relay Node R3. EN2 therefore strips any DetNet encapsulation from packet copy 1.2.2 and forwards the packet to CE2. When EN2 receives the later packet copy 1.2.1 this is discarded." "Branch for review Merge it ! Changes look good - clicking correct button this time" 215d293ca11d1a96b10664fe5db5be2326ffc8d9 215d293ca11d1a96b10664fe5db5be2326ffc8d9 draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework 75621d6a5adc1618337a02bf68856f7e1f8591c46fda003f39100f58bad112e3 ['6a0240a7089e9eb5374ec83c67aef29bce159a2350fae0b9675eca23103d04c7', 'ab93afb1ce53a91a86685ff579055185d9f7a6798d6effa52aec9838538bdf15', '5c5fe7e7a382ebc21f89d163deb3520302620f0efe90cedb8592a80b5ef6a394', '9f3e9e766fee6f9a75b58bf2c2c777ce55644ad43d69d63665d0083617a38b97', '438eb33c698936afb27ac820b5f68528ff155bd5a6927b63e6259a419be2e1a9', '685699140cefd1e1e66aa17dc3988b9e5199f0b20725eaff95c5fb402dd99ab1', '629c77ae73bd5bfa3198c993b2ee5bf42d1053919c44a7bfbd4a52ce7fa0cfbc', '32c06de60bfb9a32a4964f8ff36fd6c68613588e0780c615ffba4c9345430550', 'f5c444ddb56e26611d44ad7330c283ece50e6e047425343d3e45921bc79408f4', '7af2de76ac8144b79b38e6811634ac733b49a0fd1ba8ffd5deb0ce8fc5d59f64', '83839a4b6f00a98b672d7d42db0e734dfc50262a09e90121413fa7e8f02a1fa3', '75621d6a5adc1618337a02bf68856f7e1f8591c46fda003f39100f58bad112e3', 'cb0a896212775790b72c6ab166cdad1e0451e7d5ea431da0ea0860916cda581a', '9283a73ca025c686c922c33dd2ed832d8ee84f73c4d6ebb8f5a0fccc7689e4d2', '7c4efe66437cfbee01a00d61df6ef4d030ed30bb5727f73bcac50e7cd171243e', '4a1f8d94a306d844766f5ea77194480640792e8c0875ae9667b948e8fefe47bc', 'b8e0b075e142ae2f1aa069488f8000d04b0bedb759e534b4f3f4faa3fb768540', '6edcb9ad2f12872c1be8bc6fab00a31577544fdce451800abeb75dddd6b6c7df', 'be6ce6588c15ac0a77f3d62ef229d6d3440b7f6f4a670090aa9767094cb6dcd3'] B "edge node en2 receives packet copy 1.2.2 from r4 before it receives packet copy 1.2.1 from r2 via relay node r3. en2 therefore strips any detnet encapsulation from packet copy 1.2.2 and forwards the packet to ce2. when en2 receives the later packet copy 1.2.1 this is discarded." {31: 1, 8: 1, 55: 1, 84: 1, 27: 1, 52: 1, 6: 2, 79: 3, 90: 2, 51: 4, 130: 3, 62: 3, 85: 3, 68: 2, 35: 4, 110: 4, 91: 6, 114: 4, 97: 4, 13: 4, 67: 2, 38: 5, 26: 3, 124: 2, 98: 3, 54: 3, 127: 4, 96: 4, 64: 3, 30: 5, 61: 6, 15: 4, 129: 4, 115: 4, 76: 3, 87: 4, 131: 6, 102: 2, 113: 6, 99: 3, 36: 4, 24: 3, 53: 2, 72: 5} {69: 1, 132: 1, 145: 1, 162: 1, 194: 1, 323: 1, 264: 1, 243: 1, 245: 1, 215: 1, 1: 7, 4: 3, 9: 2, 10: 4, 15: 4, 24: 3, 25: 3, 26: 3, 27: 4, 39: 3, 43: 4, 49: 7, 50: 6, 58: 6, 59: 3, 64: 4, 81: 4, 82: 4, 86: 4, 96: 5, 97: 4, 100: 7, 108: 4, 109: 5, 110: 5, 111: 3, 114: 4, 115: 5, 116: 4, 118: 4, 119: 3, 120: 4, 121: 2, 122: 5, 123: 4, 124: 2, 128: 5, 129: 5, 130: 6, 136: 3, 147: 5, 151: 5, 152: 5, 154: 4, 156: 3, 165: 4, 168: 5, 169: 4, 172: 4, 180: 5, 184: 2, 187: 6, 188: 5, 191: 4, 202: 2, 203: 3, 206: 3, 207: 4, 217: 4, 218: 6, 220: 2, 221: 2, 222: 3, 224: 4, 227: 5, 229: 4, 234: 6, 235: 3, 241: 3, 242: 3, 244: 5, 248: 5, 250: 5, 258: 9, 262: 5, 263: 6, 267: 2, 270: 4, 272: 4, 273: 2, 287: 4, 289: 4, 291: 6, 299: 5, 300: 4, 304: 4, 309: 2, 314: 3, 315: 4, 320: 2, 327: 5, 328: 2, 329: 3, 330: 8, 334: 3, 335: 4, 341: 5, 342: 6, 347: 5, 348: 5, 350: 4, 351: 6, 352: 4, 353: 4, 354: 3, 358: 2, 365: 4, 366: 3, 369: 2, 371: 7, 372: 6, 376: 3, 384: 6, 385: 5, 386: 4, 387: 4, 392: 2, 393: 3, 396: 6, 397: 5, 398: 4, 402: 4} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 6 "The above is of course illustrative of many network scenarios that can be configured. Between a pair of relay nodes there may be one or more transit nodes that simply forward the DetNet traffic, but these are omitted for clarity." "Branch for review Merge it ! Changes look good - clicking correct button this time" 215d293ca11d1a96b10664fe5db5be2326ffc8d9 215d293ca11d1a96b10664fe5db5be2326ffc8d9 draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework ab93afb1ce53a91a86685ff579055185d9f7a6798d6effa52aec9838538bdf15 ['6a0240a7089e9eb5374ec83c67aef29bce159a2350fae0b9675eca23103d04c7', 'ab93afb1ce53a91a86685ff579055185d9f7a6798d6effa52aec9838538bdf15', '5c5fe7e7a382ebc21f89d163deb3520302620f0efe90cedb8592a80b5ef6a394', '9f3e9e766fee6f9a75b58bf2c2c777ce55644ad43d69d63665d0083617a38b97', '438eb33c698936afb27ac820b5f68528ff155bd5a6927b63e6259a419be2e1a9', '685699140cefd1e1e66aa17dc3988b9e5199f0b20725eaff95c5fb402dd99ab1', '629c77ae73bd5bfa3198c993b2ee5bf42d1053919c44a7bfbd4a52ce7fa0cfbc', '32c06de60bfb9a32a4964f8ff36fd6c68613588e0780c615ffba4c9345430550', 'f5c444ddb56e26611d44ad7330c283ece50e6e047425343d3e45921bc79408f4', '7af2de76ac8144b79b38e6811634ac733b49a0fd1ba8ffd5deb0ce8fc5d59f64', '83839a4b6f00a98b672d7d42db0e734dfc50262a09e90121413fa7e8f02a1fa3', '75621d6a5adc1618337a02bf68856f7e1f8591c46fda003f39100f58bad112e3', 'cb0a896212775790b72c6ab166cdad1e0451e7d5ea431da0ea0860916cda581a', '9283a73ca025c686c922c33dd2ed832d8ee84f73c4d6ebb8f5a0fccc7689e4d2', '7c4efe66437cfbee01a00d61df6ef4d030ed30bb5727f73bcac50e7cd171243e', '4a1f8d94a306d844766f5ea77194480640792e8c0875ae9667b948e8fefe47bc', 'b8e0b075e142ae2f1aa069488f8000d04b0bedb759e534b4f3f4faa3fb768540', '6edcb9ad2f12872c1be8bc6fab00a31577544fdce451800abeb75dddd6b6c7df', 'be6ce6588c15ac0a77f3d62ef229d6d3440b7f6f4a670090aa9767094cb6dcd3'] B "the above is of course illustrative of many network scenarios that can be configured. between a pair of relay nodes there may be one or more transit nodes that simply forward the detnet traffic, but these are omitted for clarity." {31: 1, 8: 1, 55: 1, 84: 1, 27: 1, 52: 1, 6: 2, 79: 3, 90: 2, 51: 4, 130: 3, 62: 3, 85: 3, 68: 2, 35: 4, 110: 4, 91: 6, 114: 4, 97: 4, 13: 4, 67: 2, 38: 5, 26: 3, 124: 2, 98: 3, 54: 3, 127: 4, 96: 4, 64: 3, 30: 5, 61: 6, 15: 4, 129: 4, 115: 4, 76: 3, 87: 4, 131: 6, 102: 2, 113: 6, 99: 3, 36: 4, 24: 3, 53: 2, 72: 5} {69: 1, 132: 1, 145: 1, 162: 1, 194: 1, 323: 1, 264: 1, 243: 1, 245: 1, 215: 1, 1: 7, 4: 3, 9: 2, 10: 4, 15: 4, 24: 3, 25: 3, 26: 3, 27: 4, 39: 3, 43: 4, 49: 7, 50: 6, 58: 6, 59: 3, 64: 4, 81: 4, 82: 4, 86: 4, 96: 5, 97: 4, 100: 7, 108: 4, 109: 5, 110: 5, 111: 3, 114: 4, 115: 5, 116: 4, 118: 4, 119: 3, 120: 4, 121: 2, 122: 5, 123: 4, 124: 2, 128: 5, 129: 5, 130: 6, 136: 3, 147: 5, 151: 5, 152: 5, 154: 4, 156: 3, 165: 4, 168: 5, 169: 4, 172: 4, 180: 5, 184: 2, 187: 6, 188: 5, 191: 4, 202: 2, 203: 3, 206: 3, 207: 4, 217: 4, 218: 6, 220: 2, 221: 2, 222: 3, 224: 4, 227: 5, 229: 4, 234: 6, 235: 3, 241: 3, 242: 3, 244: 5, 248: 5, 250: 5, 258: 9, 262: 5, 263: 6, 267: 2, 270: 4, 272: 4, 273: 2, 287: 4, 289: 4, 291: 6, 299: 5, 300: 4, 304: 4, 309: 2, 314: 3, 315: 4, 320: 2, 327: 5, 328: 2, 329: 3, 330: 8, 334: 3, 335: 4, 341: 5, 342: 6, 347: 5, 348: 5, 350: 4, 351: 6, 352: 4, 353: 4, 354: 3, 358: 2, 365: 4, 366: 3, 369: 2, 371: 7, 372: 6, 376: 3, 384: 6, 385: 5, 386: 4, 387: 4, 392: 2, 393: 3, 396: 6, 397: 5, 398: 4, 402: 4} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 6 "This example also illustrates 1:1 protection scheme meaning there is traffic and path for each segment of the end to end path. Local DetNet relay nodes determine which packets are eliminated and which packets are forwarded. A 1+1 scheme where only one path is used for traffic at a time, could use the same topology. In this case there is no PRF function and traffic is switched upon detection of failure. An OAM scheme that monitors the paths detects the loss of path or traffic is required to initiate the switch. A POF may still be used in this case to prevent misordering of packets. In both cases the protection paths are established and maintained for the duration of the DetNet service." "Branch for review Merge it ! Changes look good - clicking correct button this time" 215d293ca11d1a96b10664fe5db5be2326ffc8d9 215d293ca11d1a96b10664fe5db5be2326ffc8d9 draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework 9283a73ca025c686c922c33dd2ed832d8ee84f73c4d6ebb8f5a0fccc7689e4d2 ['6a0240a7089e9eb5374ec83c67aef29bce159a2350fae0b9675eca23103d04c7', 'ab93afb1ce53a91a86685ff579055185d9f7a6798d6effa52aec9838538bdf15', '5c5fe7e7a382ebc21f89d163deb3520302620f0efe90cedb8592a80b5ef6a394', '9f3e9e766fee6f9a75b58bf2c2c777ce55644ad43d69d63665d0083617a38b97', '438eb33c698936afb27ac820b5f68528ff155bd5a6927b63e6259a419be2e1a9', '685699140cefd1e1e66aa17dc3988b9e5199f0b20725eaff95c5fb402dd99ab1', '629c77ae73bd5bfa3198c993b2ee5bf42d1053919c44a7bfbd4a52ce7fa0cfbc', '32c06de60bfb9a32a4964f8ff36fd6c68613588e0780c615ffba4c9345430550', 'f5c444ddb56e26611d44ad7330c283ece50e6e047425343d3e45921bc79408f4', '7af2de76ac8144b79b38e6811634ac733b49a0fd1ba8ffd5deb0ce8fc5d59f64', '83839a4b6f00a98b672d7d42db0e734dfc50262a09e90121413fa7e8f02a1fa3', '75621d6a5adc1618337a02bf68856f7e1f8591c46fda003f39100f58bad112e3', 'cb0a896212775790b72c6ab166cdad1e0451e7d5ea431da0ea0860916cda581a', '9283a73ca025c686c922c33dd2ed832d8ee84f73c4d6ebb8f5a0fccc7689e4d2', '7c4efe66437cfbee01a00d61df6ef4d030ed30bb5727f73bcac50e7cd171243e', '4a1f8d94a306d844766f5ea77194480640792e8c0875ae9667b948e8fefe47bc', 'b8e0b075e142ae2f1aa069488f8000d04b0bedb759e534b4f3f4faa3fb768540', '6edcb9ad2f12872c1be8bc6fab00a31577544fdce451800abeb75dddd6b6c7df', 'be6ce6588c15ac0a77f3d62ef229d6d3440b7f6f4a670090aa9767094cb6dcd3'] B "this example also illustrates 1:1 protection scheme meaning there is traffic and path for each segment of the end to end path. local detnet relay nodes determine which packets are eliminated and which packets are forwarded. a 1+1 scheme where only one path is used for traffic at a time, could use the same topology. in this case there is no prf function and traffic is switched upon detection of failure. an oam scheme that monitors the paths detects the loss of path or traffic is required to initiate the switch. a pof may still be used in this case to prevent misordering of packets. in both cases the protection paths are established and maintained for the duration of the detnet service." {31: 1, 8: 1, 55: 1, 84: 1, 27: 1, 52: 1, 6: 2, 79: 3, 90: 2, 51: 4, 130: 3, 62: 3, 85: 3, 68: 2, 35: 4, 110: 4, 91: 6, 114: 4, 97: 4, 13: 4, 67: 2, 38: 5, 26: 3, 124: 2, 98: 3, 54: 3, 127: 4, 96: 4, 64: 3, 30: 5, 61: 6, 15: 4, 129: 4, 115: 4, 76: 3, 87: 4, 131: 6, 102: 2, 113: 6, 99: 3, 36: 4, 24: 3, 53: 2, 72: 5} {69: 1, 132: 1, 145: 1, 162: 1, 194: 1, 323: 1, 264: 1, 243: 1, 245: 1, 215: 1, 1: 7, 4: 3, 9: 2, 10: 4, 15: 4, 24: 3, 25: 3, 26: 3, 27: 4, 39: 3, 43: 4, 49: 7, 50: 6, 58: 6, 59: 3, 64: 4, 81: 4, 82: 4, 86: 4, 96: 5, 97: 4, 100: 7, 108: 4, 109: 5, 110: 5, 111: 3, 114: 4, 115: 5, 116: 4, 118: 4, 119: 3, 120: 4, 121: 2, 122: 5, 123: 4, 124: 2, 128: 5, 129: 5, 130: 6, 136: 3, 147: 5, 151: 5, 152: 5, 154: 4, 156: 3, 165: 4, 168: 5, 169: 4, 172: 4, 180: 5, 184: 2, 187: 6, 188: 5, 191: 4, 202: 2, 203: 3, 206: 3, 207: 4, 217: 4, 218: 6, 220: 2, 221: 2, 222: 3, 224: 4, 227: 5, 229: 4, 234: 6, 235: 3, 241: 3, 242: 3, 244: 5, 248: 5, 250: 5, 258: 9, 262: 5, 263: 6, 267: 2, 270: 4, 272: 4, 273: 2, 287: 4, 289: 4, 291: 6, 299: 5, 300: 4, 304: 4, 309: 2, 314: 3, 315: 4, 320: 2, 327: 5, 328: 2, 329: 3, 330: 8, 334: 3, 335: 4, 341: 5, 342: 6, 347: 5, 348: 5, 350: 4, 351: 6, 352: 4, 353: 4, 354: 3, 358: 2, 365: 4, 366: 3, 369: 2, 371: 7, 372: 6, 376: 3, 384: 6, 385: 5, 386: 4, 387: 4, 392: 2, 393: 3, 396: 6, 397: 5, 398: 4, 402: 4} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 6 "Ring protection may also be supported if the underlying technology supports it. Many of the same concepts apply however Rings are normally 1+1 protection for data efficiency reasons. RFC8227 is an example of MPLS-TP data plane that supports Ring protection." "Branch for review Merge it ! Changes look good - clicking correct button this time" 215d293ca11d1a96b10664fe5db5be2326ffc8d9 215d293ca11d1a96b10664fe5db5be2326ffc8d9 draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework be6ce6588c15ac0a77f3d62ef229d6d3440b7f6f4a670090aa9767094cb6dcd3 ['6a0240a7089e9eb5374ec83c67aef29bce159a2350fae0b9675eca23103d04c7', 'ab93afb1ce53a91a86685ff579055185d9f7a6798d6effa52aec9838538bdf15', '5c5fe7e7a382ebc21f89d163deb3520302620f0efe90cedb8592a80b5ef6a394', '9f3e9e766fee6f9a75b58bf2c2c777ce55644ad43d69d63665d0083617a38b97', '438eb33c698936afb27ac820b5f68528ff155bd5a6927b63e6259a419be2e1a9', '685699140cefd1e1e66aa17dc3988b9e5199f0b20725eaff95c5fb402dd99ab1', '629c77ae73bd5bfa3198c993b2ee5bf42d1053919c44a7bfbd4a52ce7fa0cfbc', '32c06de60bfb9a32a4964f8ff36fd6c68613588e0780c615ffba4c9345430550', 'f5c444ddb56e26611d44ad7330c283ece50e6e047425343d3e45921bc79408f4', '7af2de76ac8144b79b38e6811634ac733b49a0fd1ba8ffd5deb0ce8fc5d59f64', '83839a4b6f00a98b672d7d42db0e734dfc50262a09e90121413fa7e8f02a1fa3', '75621d6a5adc1618337a02bf68856f7e1f8591c46fda003f39100f58bad112e3', 'cb0a896212775790b72c6ab166cdad1e0451e7d5ea431da0ea0860916cda581a', '9283a73ca025c686c922c33dd2ed832d8ee84f73c4d6ebb8f5a0fccc7689e4d2', '7c4efe66437cfbee01a00d61df6ef4d030ed30bb5727f73bcac50e7cd171243e', '4a1f8d94a306d844766f5ea77194480640792e8c0875ae9667b948e8fefe47bc', 'b8e0b075e142ae2f1aa069488f8000d04b0bedb759e534b4f3f4faa3fb768540', '6edcb9ad2f12872c1be8bc6fab00a31577544fdce451800abeb75dddd6b6c7df', 'be6ce6588c15ac0a77f3d62ef229d6d3440b7f6f4a670090aa9767094cb6dcd3'] B "ring protection may also be supported if the underlying technology supports it. many of the same concepts apply however rings are normally 1+1 protection for data efficiency reasons. rfc8227 is an example of mpls-tp data plane that supports ring protection." {31: 1, 8: 1, 55: 1, 84: 1, 27: 1, 52: 1, 6: 2, 79: 3, 90: 2, 51: 4, 130: 3, 62: 3, 85: 3, 68: 2, 35: 4, 110: 4, 91: 6, 114: 4, 97: 4, 13: 4, 67: 2, 38: 5, 26: 3, 124: 2, 98: 3, 54: 3, 127: 4, 96: 4, 64: 3, 30: 5, 61: 6, 15: 4, 129: 4, 115: 4, 76: 3, 87: 4, 131: 6, 102: 2, 113: 6, 99: 3, 36: 4, 24: 3, 53: 2, 72: 5} {69: 1, 132: 1, 145: 1, 162: 1, 194: 1, 323: 1, 264: 1, 243: 1, 245: 1, 215: 1, 1: 7, 4: 3, 9: 2, 10: 4, 15: 4, 24: 3, 25: 3, 26: 3, 27: 4, 39: 3, 43: 4, 49: 7, 50: 6, 58: 6, 59: 3, 64: 4, 81: 4, 82: 4, 86: 4, 96: 5, 97: 4, 100: 7, 108: 4, 109: 5, 110: 5, 111: 3, 114: 4, 115: 5, 116: 4, 118: 4, 119: 3, 120: 4, 121: 2, 122: 5, 123: 4, 124: 2, 128: 5, 129: 5, 130: 6, 136: 3, 147: 5, 151: 5, 152: 5, 154: 4, 156: 3, 165: 4, 168: 5, 169: 4, 172: 4, 180: 5, 184: 2, 187: 6, 188: 5, 191: 4, 202: 2, 203: 3, 206: 3, 207: 4, 217: 4, 218: 6, 220: 2, 221: 2, 222: 3, 224: 4, 227: 5, 229: 4, 234: 6, 235: 3, 241: 3, 242: 3, 244: 5, 248: 5, 250: 5, 258: 9, 262: 5, 263: 6, 267: 2, 270: 4, 272: 4, 273: 2, 287: 4, 289: 4, 291: 6, 299: 5, 300: 4, 304: 4, 309: 2, 314: 3, 315: 4, 320: 2, 327: 5, 328: 2, 329: 3, 330: 8, 334: 3, 335: 4, 341: 5, 342: 6, 347: 5, 348: 5, 350: 4, 351: 6, 352: 4, 353: 4, 354: 3, 358: 2, 365: 4, 366: 3, 369: 2, 371: 7, 372: 6, 376: 3, 384: 6, 385: 5, 386: 4, 387: 4, 392: 2, 393: 3, 396: 6, 397: 5, 398: 4, 402: 4} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 6 "The DetNet data plane also allows for the aggregation of DetNet flows, to improved scaling by reducing the state per hop. How this is done is data plane or control plane dependent. When DetNet flows are aggregated, transit nodes provide service to the aggregate and not on a per-DetNet flow basis. When aggregating DetNet flows the flows should be compatible i.e. the same or very similar QoS and CoS characteristics. In this case, nodes performing aggregation will ensure that per-flow service requirements are achieved." "Branch for review Merge it ! Changes look good - clicking correct button this time" 215d293ca11d1a96b10664fe5db5be2326ffc8d9 215d293ca11d1a96b10664fe5db5be2326ffc8d9 draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework 9f3e9e766fee6f9a75b58bf2c2c777ce55644ad43d69d63665d0083617a38b97 ['6a0240a7089e9eb5374ec83c67aef29bce159a2350fae0b9675eca23103d04c7', 'ab93afb1ce53a91a86685ff579055185d9f7a6798d6effa52aec9838538bdf15', '5c5fe7e7a382ebc21f89d163deb3520302620f0efe90cedb8592a80b5ef6a394', '9f3e9e766fee6f9a75b58bf2c2c777ce55644ad43d69d63665d0083617a38b97', '438eb33c698936afb27ac820b5f68528ff155bd5a6927b63e6259a419be2e1a9', '685699140cefd1e1e66aa17dc3988b9e5199f0b20725eaff95c5fb402dd99ab1', '629c77ae73bd5bfa3198c993b2ee5bf42d1053919c44a7bfbd4a52ce7fa0cfbc', '32c06de60bfb9a32a4964f8ff36fd6c68613588e0780c615ffba4c9345430550', 'f5c444ddb56e26611d44ad7330c283ece50e6e047425343d3e45921bc79408f4', '7af2de76ac8144b79b38e6811634ac733b49a0fd1ba8ffd5deb0ce8fc5d59f64', '83839a4b6f00a98b672d7d42db0e734dfc50262a09e90121413fa7e8f02a1fa3', '75621d6a5adc1618337a02bf68856f7e1f8591c46fda003f39100f58bad112e3', 'cb0a896212775790b72c6ab166cdad1e0451e7d5ea431da0ea0860916cda581a', '9283a73ca025c686c922c33dd2ed832d8ee84f73c4d6ebb8f5a0fccc7689e4d2', '7c4efe66437cfbee01a00d61df6ef4d030ed30bb5727f73bcac50e7cd171243e', '4a1f8d94a306d844766f5ea77194480640792e8c0875ae9667b948e8fefe47bc', 'b8e0b075e142ae2f1aa069488f8000d04b0bedb759e534b4f3f4faa3fb768540', '6edcb9ad2f12872c1be8bc6fab00a31577544fdce451800abeb75dddd6b6c7df', 'be6ce6588c15ac0a77f3d62ef229d6d3440b7f6f4a670090aa9767094cb6dcd3'] B "the detnet data plane also allows for the aggregation of detnet flows, to improved scaling by reducing the state per hop. how this is done is data plane or control plane dependent. when detnet flows are aggregated, transit nodes provide service to the aggregate and not on a per-detnet flow basis. when aggregating detnet flows the flows should be compatible i.e. the same or very similar qos and cos characteristics. in this case, nodes performing aggregation will ensure that per-flow service requirements are achieved." {31: 1, 8: 1, 55: 1, 84: 1, 27: 1, 52: 1, 6: 2, 79: 3, 90: 2, 51: 4, 130: 3, 62: 3, 85: 3, 68: 2, 35: 4, 110: 4, 91: 6, 114: 4, 97: 4, 13: 4, 67: 2, 38: 5, 26: 3, 124: 2, 98: 3, 54: 3, 127: 4, 96: 4, 64: 3, 30: 5, 61: 6, 15: 4, 129: 4, 115: 4, 76: 3, 87: 4, 131: 6, 102: 2, 113: 6, 99: 3, 36: 4, 24: 3, 53: 2, 72: 5} {69: 1, 132: 1, 145: 1, 162: 1, 194: 1, 323: 1, 264: 1, 243: 1, 245: 1, 215: 1, 1: 7, 4: 3, 9: 2, 10: 4, 15: 4, 24: 3, 25: 3, 26: 3, 27: 4, 39: 3, 43: 4, 49: 7, 50: 6, 58: 6, 59: 3, 64: 4, 81: 4, 82: 4, 86: 4, 96: 5, 97: 4, 100: 7, 108: 4, 109: 5, 110: 5, 111: 3, 114: 4, 115: 5, 116: 4, 118: 4, 119: 3, 120: 4, 121: 2, 122: 5, 123: 4, 124: 2, 128: 5, 129: 5, 130: 6, 136: 3, 147: 5, 151: 5, 152: 5, 154: 4, 156: 3, 165: 4, 168: 5, 169: 4, 172: 4, 180: 5, 184: 2, 187: 6, 188: 5, 191: 4, 202: 2, 203: 3, 206: 3, 207: 4, 217: 4, 218: 6, 220: 2, 221: 2, 222: 3, 224: 4, 227: 5, 229: 4, 234: 6, 235: 3, 241: 3, 242: 3, 244: 5, 248: 5, 250: 5, 258: 9, 262: 5, 263: 6, 267: 2, 270: 4, 272: 4, 273: 2, 287: 4, 289: 4, 291: 6, 299: 5, 300: 4, 304: 4, 309: 2, 314: 3, 315: 4, 320: 2, 327: 5, 328: 2, 329: 3, 330: 8, 334: 3, 335: 4, 341: 5, 342: 6, 347: 5, 348: 5, 350: 4, 351: 6, 352: 4, 353: 4, 354: 3, 358: 2, 365: 4, 366: 3, 369: 2, 371: 7, 372: 6, 376: 3, 384: 6, 385: 5, 386: 4, 387: 4, 392: 2, 393: 3, 396: 6, 397: 5, 398: 4, 402: 4} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 6 "If bandwidth reservations are used, the sum of the reservations should be the sum of all the individual reservations, in other words, the reservations should not create an over subscription of bandwidth reservation. If maximum delay bounds are used the system should ensure that the aggregate does not exceed the delay bounds of the component flows." "Branch for review Merge it ! Changes look good - clicking correct button this time" 215d293ca11d1a96b10664fe5db5be2326ffc8d9 215d293ca11d1a96b10664fe5db5be2326ffc8d9 draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework cb0a896212775790b72c6ab166cdad1e0451e7d5ea431da0ea0860916cda581a ['6a0240a7089e9eb5374ec83c67aef29bce159a2350fae0b9675eca23103d04c7', 'ab93afb1ce53a91a86685ff579055185d9f7a6798d6effa52aec9838538bdf15', '5c5fe7e7a382ebc21f89d163deb3520302620f0efe90cedb8592a80b5ef6a394', '9f3e9e766fee6f9a75b58bf2c2c777ce55644ad43d69d63665d0083617a38b97', '438eb33c698936afb27ac820b5f68528ff155bd5a6927b63e6259a419be2e1a9', '685699140cefd1e1e66aa17dc3988b9e5199f0b20725eaff95c5fb402dd99ab1', '629c77ae73bd5bfa3198c993b2ee5bf42d1053919c44a7bfbd4a52ce7fa0cfbc', '32c06de60bfb9a32a4964f8ff36fd6c68613588e0780c615ffba4c9345430550', 'f5c444ddb56e26611d44ad7330c283ece50e6e047425343d3e45921bc79408f4', '7af2de76ac8144b79b38e6811634ac733b49a0fd1ba8ffd5deb0ce8fc5d59f64', '83839a4b6f00a98b672d7d42db0e734dfc50262a09e90121413fa7e8f02a1fa3', '75621d6a5adc1618337a02bf68856f7e1f8591c46fda003f39100f58bad112e3', 'cb0a896212775790b72c6ab166cdad1e0451e7d5ea431da0ea0860916cda581a', '9283a73ca025c686c922c33dd2ed832d8ee84f73c4d6ebb8f5a0fccc7689e4d2', '7c4efe66437cfbee01a00d61df6ef4d030ed30bb5727f73bcac50e7cd171243e', '4a1f8d94a306d844766f5ea77194480640792e8c0875ae9667b948e8fefe47bc', 'b8e0b075e142ae2f1aa069488f8000d04b0bedb759e534b4f3f4faa3fb768540', '6edcb9ad2f12872c1be8bc6fab00a31577544fdce451800abeb75dddd6b6c7df', 'be6ce6588c15ac0a77f3d62ef229d6d3440b7f6f4a670090aa9767094cb6dcd3'] B "if bandwidth reservations are used, the sum of the reservations should be the sum of all the individual reservations, in other words, the reservations should not create an over subscription of bandwidth reservation. if maximum delay bounds are used the system should ensure that the aggregate does not exceed the delay bounds of the component flows." {31: 1, 8: 1, 55: 1, 84: 1, 27: 1, 52: 1, 6: 2, 79: 3, 90: 2, 51: 4, 130: 3, 62: 3, 85: 3, 68: 2, 35: 4, 110: 4, 91: 6, 114: 4, 97: 4, 13: 4, 67: 2, 38: 5, 26: 3, 124: 2, 98: 3, 54: 3, 127: 4, 96: 4, 64: 3, 30: 5, 61: 6, 15: 4, 129: 4, 115: 4, 76: 3, 87: 4, 131: 6, 102: 2, 113: 6, 99: 3, 36: 4, 24: 3, 53: 2, 72: 5} {69: 1, 132: 1, 145: 1, 162: 1, 194: 1, 323: 1, 264: 1, 243: 1, 245: 1, 215: 1, 1: 7, 4: 3, 9: 2, 10: 4, 15: 4, 24: 3, 25: 3, 26: 3, 27: 4, 39: 3, 43: 4, 49: 7, 50: 6, 58: 6, 59: 3, 64: 4, 81: 4, 82: 4, 86: 4, 96: 5, 97: 4, 100: 7, 108: 4, 109: 5, 110: 5, 111: 3, 114: 4, 115: 5, 116: 4, 118: 4, 119: 3, 120: 4, 121: 2, 122: 5, 123: 4, 124: 2, 128: 5, 129: 5, 130: 6, 136: 3, 147: 5, 151: 5, 152: 5, 154: 4, 156: 3, 165: 4, 168: 5, 169: 4, 172: 4, 180: 5, 184: 2, 187: 6, 188: 5, 191: 4, 202: 2, 203: 3, 206: 3, 207: 4, 217: 4, 218: 6, 220: 2, 221: 2, 222: 3, 224: 4, 227: 5, 229: 4, 234: 6, 235: 3, 241: 3, 242: 3, 244: 5, 248: 5, 250: 5, 258: 9, 262: 5, 263: 6, 267: 2, 270: 4, 272: 4, 273: 2, 287: 4, 289: 4, 291: 6, 299: 5, 300: 4, 304: 4, 309: 2, 314: 3, 315: 4, 320: 2, 327: 5, 328: 2, 329: 3, 330: 8, 334: 3, 335: 4, 341: 5, 342: 6, 347: 5, 348: 5, 350: 4, 351: 6, 352: 4, 353: 4, 354: 3, 358: 2, 365: 4, 366: 3, 369: 2, 371: 7, 372: 6, 376: 3, 384: 6, 385: 5, 386: 4, 387: 4, 392: 2, 393: 3, 396: 6, 397: 5, 398: 4, 402: 4} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 6 "DetNet encapsulation is a data plane mechanism that can be used to aggregate traffic. Encapsulation can either be in the same service type or in a different service type see dn_svc_encaps for examples. When an encapsulation is used the choice of reserving a maximum resource level and then tracking the services in the aggregated service or adjusting the aggregated resources as the services are added is implementation and technology specific." "Branch for review Merge it ! Changes look good - clicking correct button this time" 215d293ca11d1a96b10664fe5db5be2326ffc8d9 215d293ca11d1a96b10664fe5db5be2326ffc8d9 draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework 32c06de60bfb9a32a4964f8ff36fd6c68613588e0780c615ffba4c9345430550 ['6a0240a7089e9eb5374ec83c67aef29bce159a2350fae0b9675eca23103d04c7', 'ab93afb1ce53a91a86685ff579055185d9f7a6798d6effa52aec9838538bdf15', '5c5fe7e7a382ebc21f89d163deb3520302620f0efe90cedb8592a80b5ef6a394', '9f3e9e766fee6f9a75b58bf2c2c777ce55644ad43d69d63665d0083617a38b97', '438eb33c698936afb27ac820b5f68528ff155bd5a6927b63e6259a419be2e1a9', '685699140cefd1e1e66aa17dc3988b9e5199f0b20725eaff95c5fb402dd99ab1', '629c77ae73bd5bfa3198c993b2ee5bf42d1053919c44a7bfbd4a52ce7fa0cfbc', '32c06de60bfb9a32a4964f8ff36fd6c68613588e0780c615ffba4c9345430550', 'f5c444ddb56e26611d44ad7330c283ece50e6e047425343d3e45921bc79408f4', '7af2de76ac8144b79b38e6811634ac733b49a0fd1ba8ffd5deb0ce8fc5d59f64', '83839a4b6f00a98b672d7d42db0e734dfc50262a09e90121413fa7e8f02a1fa3', '75621d6a5adc1618337a02bf68856f7e1f8591c46fda003f39100f58bad112e3', 'cb0a896212775790b72c6ab166cdad1e0451e7d5ea431da0ea0860916cda581a', '9283a73ca025c686c922c33dd2ed832d8ee84f73c4d6ebb8f5a0fccc7689e4d2', '7c4efe66437cfbee01a00d61df6ef4d030ed30bb5727f73bcac50e7cd171243e', '4a1f8d94a306d844766f5ea77194480640792e8c0875ae9667b948e8fefe47bc', 'b8e0b075e142ae2f1aa069488f8000d04b0bedb759e534b4f3f4faa3fb768540', '6edcb9ad2f12872c1be8bc6fab00a31577544fdce451800abeb75dddd6b6c7df', 'be6ce6588c15ac0a77f3d62ef229d6d3440b7f6f4a670090aa9767094cb6dcd3'] B "detnet encapsulation is a data plane mechanism that can be used to aggregate traffic. encapsulation can either be in the same service type or in a different service type see dn_svc_encaps for examples. when an encapsulation is used the choice of reserving a maximum resource level and then tracking the services in the aggregated service or adjusting the aggregated resources as the services are added is implementation and technology specific." {31: 1, 8: 1, 55: 1, 84: 1, 27: 1, 52: 1, 6: 2, 79: 3, 90: 2, 51: 4, 130: 3, 62: 3, 85: 3, 68: 2, 35: 4, 110: 4, 91: 6, 114: 4, 97: 4, 13: 4, 67: 2, 38: 5, 26: 3, 124: 2, 98: 3, 54: 3, 127: 4, 96: 4, 64: 3, 30: 5, 61: 6, 15: 4, 129: 4, 115: 4, 76: 3, 87: 4, 131: 6, 102: 2, 113: 6, 99: 3, 36: 4, 24: 3, 53: 2, 72: 5} {69: 1, 132: 1, 145: 1, 162: 1, 194: 1, 323: 1, 264: 1, 243: 1, 245: 1, 215: 1, 1: 7, 4: 3, 9: 2, 10: 4, 15: 4, 24: 3, 25: 3, 26: 3, 27: 4, 39: 3, 43: 4, 49: 7, 50: 6, 58: 6, 59: 3, 64: 4, 81: 4, 82: 4, 86: 4, 96: 5, 97: 4, 100: 7, 108: 4, 109: 5, 110: 5, 111: 3, 114: 4, 115: 5, 116: 4, 118: 4, 119: 3, 120: 4, 121: 2, 122: 5, 123: 4, 124: 2, 128: 5, 129: 5, 130: 6, 136: 3, 147: 5, 151: 5, 152: 5, 154: 4, 156: 3, 165: 4, 168: 5, 169: 4, 172: 4, 180: 5, 184: 2, 187: 6, 188: 5, 191: 4, 202: 2, 203: 3, 206: 3, 207: 4, 217: 4, 218: 6, 220: 2, 221: 2, 222: 3, 224: 4, 227: 5, 229: 4, 234: 6, 235: 3, 241: 3, 242: 3, 244: 5, 248: 5, 250: 5, 258: 9, 262: 5, 263: 6, 267: 2, 270: 4, 272: 4, 273: 2, 287: 4, 289: 4, 291: 6, 299: 5, 300: 4, 304: 4, 309: 2, 314: 3, 315: 4, 320: 2, 327: 5, 328: 2, 329: 3, 330: 8, 334: 3, 335: 4, 341: 5, 342: 6, 347: 5, 348: 5, 350: 4, 351: 6, 352: 4, 353: 4, 354: 3, 358: 2, 365: 4, 366: 3, 369: 2, 371: 7, 372: 6, 376: 3, 384: 6, 385: 5, 386: 4, 387: 4, 392: 2, 393: 3, 396: 6, 397: 5, 398: 4, 402: 4} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 6 "DetNet flows at edges must be able to handle rejection to an aggregation group due to lack of resources as well as conditions where general requirements are not satisfied." "Branch for review Merge it ! Changes look good - clicking correct button this time" 215d293ca11d1a96b10664fe5db5be2326ffc8d9 215d293ca11d1a96b10664fe5db5be2326ffc8d9 draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework 685699140cefd1e1e66aa17dc3988b9e5199f0b20725eaff95c5fb402dd99ab1 ['6a0240a7089e9eb5374ec83c67aef29bce159a2350fae0b9675eca23103d04c7', 'ab93afb1ce53a91a86685ff579055185d9f7a6798d6effa52aec9838538bdf15', '5c5fe7e7a382ebc21f89d163deb3520302620f0efe90cedb8592a80b5ef6a394', '9f3e9e766fee6f9a75b58bf2c2c777ce55644ad43d69d63665d0083617a38b97', '438eb33c698936afb27ac820b5f68528ff155bd5a6927b63e6259a419be2e1a9', '685699140cefd1e1e66aa17dc3988b9e5199f0b20725eaff95c5fb402dd99ab1', '629c77ae73bd5bfa3198c993b2ee5bf42d1053919c44a7bfbd4a52ce7fa0cfbc', '32c06de60bfb9a32a4964f8ff36fd6c68613588e0780c615ffba4c9345430550', 'f5c444ddb56e26611d44ad7330c283ece50e6e047425343d3e45921bc79408f4', '7af2de76ac8144b79b38e6811634ac733b49a0fd1ba8ffd5deb0ce8fc5d59f64', '83839a4b6f00a98b672d7d42db0e734dfc50262a09e90121413fa7e8f02a1fa3', '75621d6a5adc1618337a02bf68856f7e1f8591c46fda003f39100f58bad112e3', 'cb0a896212775790b72c6ab166cdad1e0451e7d5ea431da0ea0860916cda581a', '9283a73ca025c686c922c33dd2ed832d8ee84f73c4d6ebb8f5a0fccc7689e4d2', '7c4efe66437cfbee01a00d61df6ef4d030ed30bb5727f73bcac50e7cd171243e', '4a1f8d94a306d844766f5ea77194480640792e8c0875ae9667b948e8fefe47bc', 'b8e0b075e142ae2f1aa069488f8000d04b0bedb759e534b4f3f4faa3fb768540', '6edcb9ad2f12872c1be8bc6fab00a31577544fdce451800abeb75dddd6b6c7df', 'be6ce6588c15ac0a77f3d62ef229d6d3440b7f6f4a670090aa9767094cb6dcd3'] B "detnet flows at edges must be able to handle rejection to an aggregation group due to lack of resources as well as conditions where general requirements are not satisfied." {31: 1, 8: 1, 55: 1, 84: 1, 27: 1, 52: 1, 6: 2, 79: 3, 90: 2, 51: 4, 130: 3, 62: 3, 85: 3, 68: 2, 35: 4, 110: 4, 91: 6, 114: 4, 97: 4, 13: 4, 67: 2, 38: 5, 26: 3, 124: 2, 98: 3, 54: 3, 127: 4, 96: 4, 64: 3, 30: 5, 61: 6, 15: 4, 129: 4, 115: 4, 76: 3, 87: 4, 131: 6, 102: 2, 113: 6, 99: 3, 36: 4, 24: 3, 53: 2, 72: 5} {69: 1, 132: 1, 145: 1, 162: 1, 194: 1, 323: 1, 264: 1, 243: 1, 245: 1, 215: 1, 1: 7, 4: 3, 9: 2, 10: 4, 15: 4, 24: 3, 25: 3, 26: 3, 27: 4, 39: 3, 43: 4, 49: 7, 50: 6, 58: 6, 59: 3, 64: 4, 81: 4, 82: 4, 86: 4, 96: 5, 97: 4, 100: 7, 108: 4, 109: 5, 110: 5, 111: 3, 114: 4, 115: 5, 116: 4, 118: 4, 119: 3, 120: 4, 121: 2, 122: 5, 123: 4, 124: 2, 128: 5, 129: 5, 130: 6, 136: 3, 147: 5, 151: 5, 152: 5, 154: 4, 156: 3, 165: 4, 168: 5, 169: 4, 172: 4, 180: 5, 184: 2, 187: 6, 188: 5, 191: 4, 202: 2, 203: 3, 206: 3, 207: 4, 217: 4, 218: 6, 220: 2, 221: 2, 222: 3, 224: 4, 227: 5, 229: 4, 234: 6, 235: 3, 241: 3, 242: 3, 244: 5, 248: 5, 250: 5, 258: 9, 262: 5, 263: 6, 267: 2, 270: 4, 272: 4, 273: 2, 287: 4, 289: 4, 291: 6, 299: 5, 300: 4, 304: 4, 309: 2, 314: 3, 315: 4, 320: 2, 327: 5, 328: 2, 329: 3, 330: 8, 334: 3, 335: 4, 341: 5, 342: 6, 347: 5, 348: 5, 350: 4, 351: 6, 352: 4, 353: 4, 354: 3, 358: 2, 365: 4, 366: 3, 369: 2, 371: 7, 372: 6, 376: 3, 384: 6, 385: 5, 386: 4, 387: 4, 392: 2, 393: 3, 396: 6, 397: 5, 398: 4, 402: 4} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 6 "IP aggreggation has both data plane and controller plane aspects. For the dataplane flows may be aggregated for treatment based on shared charateristice such as 5-tuple. Alternatively, an IP encapsualtion may be used to tunnel an aggregate number of DetNet Flows between relay nodes." "Branch for review Merge it ! Changes look good - clicking correct button this time" 215d293ca11d1a96b10664fe5db5be2326ffc8d9 215d293ca11d1a96b10664fe5db5be2326ffc8d9 draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework 629c77ae73bd5bfa3198c993b2ee5bf42d1053919c44a7bfbd4a52ce7fa0cfbc ['6a0240a7089e9eb5374ec83c67aef29bce159a2350fae0b9675eca23103d04c7', 'ab93afb1ce53a91a86685ff579055185d9f7a6798d6effa52aec9838538bdf15', '5c5fe7e7a382ebc21f89d163deb3520302620f0efe90cedb8592a80b5ef6a394', '9f3e9e766fee6f9a75b58bf2c2c777ce55644ad43d69d63665d0083617a38b97', '438eb33c698936afb27ac820b5f68528ff155bd5a6927b63e6259a419be2e1a9', '685699140cefd1e1e66aa17dc3988b9e5199f0b20725eaff95c5fb402dd99ab1', '629c77ae73bd5bfa3198c993b2ee5bf42d1053919c44a7bfbd4a52ce7fa0cfbc', '32c06de60bfb9a32a4964f8ff36fd6c68613588e0780c615ffba4c9345430550', 'f5c444ddb56e26611d44ad7330c283ece50e6e047425343d3e45921bc79408f4', '7af2de76ac8144b79b38e6811634ac733b49a0fd1ba8ffd5deb0ce8fc5d59f64', '83839a4b6f00a98b672d7d42db0e734dfc50262a09e90121413fa7e8f02a1fa3', '75621d6a5adc1618337a02bf68856f7e1f8591c46fda003f39100f58bad112e3', 'cb0a896212775790b72c6ab166cdad1e0451e7d5ea431da0ea0860916cda581a', '9283a73ca025c686c922c33dd2ed832d8ee84f73c4d6ebb8f5a0fccc7689e4d2', '7c4efe66437cfbee01a00d61df6ef4d030ed30bb5727f73bcac50e7cd171243e', '4a1f8d94a306d844766f5ea77194480640792e8c0875ae9667b948e8fefe47bc', 'b8e0b075e142ae2f1aa069488f8000d04b0bedb759e534b4f3f4faa3fb768540', '6edcb9ad2f12872c1be8bc6fab00a31577544fdce451800abeb75dddd6b6c7df', 'be6ce6588c15ac0a77f3d62ef229d6d3440b7f6f4a670090aa9767094cb6dcd3'] B "ip aggreggation has both data plane and controller plane aspects. for the dataplane flows may be aggregated for treatment based on shared charateristice such as 5-tuple. alternatively, an ip encapsualtion may be used to tunnel an aggregate number of detnet flows between relay nodes." {31: 1, 8: 1, 55: 1, 84: 1, 27: 1, 52: 1, 6: 2, 79: 3, 90: 2, 51: 4, 130: 3, 62: 3, 85: 3, 68: 2, 35: 4, 110: 4, 91: 6, 114: 4, 97: 4, 13: 4, 67: 2, 38: 5, 26: 3, 124: 2, 98: 3, 54: 3, 127: 4, 96: 4, 64: 3, 30: 5, 61: 6, 15: 4, 129: 4, 115: 4, 76: 3, 87: 4, 131: 6, 102: 2, 113: 6, 99: 3, 36: 4, 24: 3, 53: 2, 72: 5} {69: 1, 132: 1, 145: 1, 162: 1, 194: 1, 323: 1, 264: 1, 243: 1, 245: 1, 215: 1, 1: 7, 4: 3, 9: 2, 10: 4, 15: 4, 24: 3, 25: 3, 26: 3, 27: 4, 39: 3, 43: 4, 49: 7, 50: 6, 58: 6, 59: 3, 64: 4, 81: 4, 82: 4, 86: 4, 96: 5, 97: 4, 100: 7, 108: 4, 109: 5, 110: 5, 111: 3, 114: 4, 115: 5, 116: 4, 118: 4, 119: 3, 120: 4, 121: 2, 122: 5, 123: 4, 124: 2, 128: 5, 129: 5, 130: 6, 136: 3, 147: 5, 151: 5, 152: 5, 154: 4, 156: 3, 165: 4, 168: 5, 169: 4, 172: 4, 180: 5, 184: 2, 187: 6, 188: 5, 191: 4, 202: 2, 203: 3, 206: 3, 207: 4, 217: 4, 218: 6, 220: 2, 221: 2, 222: 3, 224: 4, 227: 5, 229: 4, 234: 6, 235: 3, 241: 3, 242: 3, 244: 5, 248: 5, 250: 5, 258: 9, 262: 5, 263: 6, 267: 2, 270: 4, 272: 4, 273: 2, 287: 4, 289: 4, 291: 6, 299: 5, 300: 4, 304: 4, 309: 2, 314: 3, 315: 4, 320: 2, 327: 5, 328: 2, 329: 3, 330: 8, 334: 3, 335: 4, 341: 5, 342: 6, 347: 5, 348: 5, 350: 4, 351: 6, 352: 4, 353: 4, 354: 3, 358: 2, 365: 4, 366: 3, 369: 2, 371: 7, 372: 6, 376: 3, 384: 6, 385: 5, 386: 4, 387: 4, 392: 2, 393: 3, 396: 6, 397: 5, 398: 4, 402: 4} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 6 "MPLS aggragation similarly has data plane and controller plane aspects. In the case of MPLS flows are often tunneled in a forwarding sublayer and reservation is associated with that MPLS tunnel." "Branch for review Merge it ! Changes look good - clicking correct button this time" 215d293ca11d1a96b10664fe5db5be2326ffc8d9 215d293ca11d1a96b10664fe5db5be2326ffc8d9 draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework 4a1f8d94a306d844766f5ea77194480640792e8c0875ae9667b948e8fefe47bc ['6a0240a7089e9eb5374ec83c67aef29bce159a2350fae0b9675eca23103d04c7', 'ab93afb1ce53a91a86685ff579055185d9f7a6798d6effa52aec9838538bdf15', '5c5fe7e7a382ebc21f89d163deb3520302620f0efe90cedb8592a80b5ef6a394', '9f3e9e766fee6f9a75b58bf2c2c777ce55644ad43d69d63665d0083617a38b97', '438eb33c698936afb27ac820b5f68528ff155bd5a6927b63e6259a419be2e1a9', '685699140cefd1e1e66aa17dc3988b9e5199f0b20725eaff95c5fb402dd99ab1', '629c77ae73bd5bfa3198c993b2ee5bf42d1053919c44a7bfbd4a52ce7fa0cfbc', '32c06de60bfb9a32a4964f8ff36fd6c68613588e0780c615ffba4c9345430550', 'f5c444ddb56e26611d44ad7330c283ece50e6e047425343d3e45921bc79408f4', '7af2de76ac8144b79b38e6811634ac733b49a0fd1ba8ffd5deb0ce8fc5d59f64', '83839a4b6f00a98b672d7d42db0e734dfc50262a09e90121413fa7e8f02a1fa3', '75621d6a5adc1618337a02bf68856f7e1f8591c46fda003f39100f58bad112e3', 'cb0a896212775790b72c6ab166cdad1e0451e7d5ea431da0ea0860916cda581a', '9283a73ca025c686c922c33dd2ed832d8ee84f73c4d6ebb8f5a0fccc7689e4d2', '7c4efe66437cfbee01a00d61df6ef4d030ed30bb5727f73bcac50e7cd171243e', '4a1f8d94a306d844766f5ea77194480640792e8c0875ae9667b948e8fefe47bc', 'b8e0b075e142ae2f1aa069488f8000d04b0bedb759e534b4f3f4faa3fb768540', '6edcb9ad2f12872c1be8bc6fab00a31577544fdce451800abeb75dddd6b6c7df', 'be6ce6588c15ac0a77f3d62ef229d6d3440b7f6f4a670090aa9767094cb6dcd3'] B "mpls aggragation similarly has data plane and controller plane aspects. in the case of mpls flows are often tunneled in a forwarding sublayer and reservation is associated with that mpls tunnel." {31: 1, 8: 1, 55: 1, 84: 1, 27: 1, 52: 1, 6: 2, 79: 3, 90: 2, 51: 4, 130: 3, 62: 3, 85: 3, 68: 2, 35: 4, 110: 4, 91: 6, 114: 4, 97: 4, 13: 4, 67: 2, 38: 5, 26: 3, 124: 2, 98: 3, 54: 3, 127: 4, 96: 4, 64: 3, 30: 5, 61: 6, 15: 4, 129: 4, 115: 4, 76: 3, 87: 4, 131: 6, 102: 2, 113: 6, 99: 3, 36: 4, 24: 3, 53: 2, 72: 5} {69: 1, 132: 1, 145: 1, 162: 1, 194: 1, 323: 1, 264: 1, 243: 1, 245: 1, 215: 1, 1: 7, 4: 3, 9: 2, 10: 4, 15: 4, 24: 3, 25: 3, 26: 3, 27: 4, 39: 3, 43: 4, 49: 7, 50: 6, 58: 6, 59: 3, 64: 4, 81: 4, 82: 4, 86: 4, 96: 5, 97: 4, 100: 7, 108: 4, 109: 5, 110: 5, 111: 3, 114: 4, 115: 5, 116: 4, 118: 4, 119: 3, 120: 4, 121: 2, 122: 5, 123: 4, 124: 2, 128: 5, 129: 5, 130: 6, 136: 3, 147: 5, 151: 5, 152: 5, 154: 4, 156: 3, 165: 4, 168: 5, 169: 4, 172: 4, 180: 5, 184: 2, 187: 6, 188: 5, 191: 4, 202: 2, 203: 3, 206: 3, 207: 4, 217: 4, 218: 6, 220: 2, 221: 2, 222: 3, 224: 4, 227: 5, 229: 4, 234: 6, 235: 3, 241: 3, 242: 3, 244: 5, 248: 5, 250: 5, 258: 9, 262: 5, 263: 6, 267: 2, 270: 4, 272: 4, 273: 2, 287: 4, 289: 4, 291: 6, 299: 5, 300: 4, 304: 4, 309: 2, 314: 3, 315: 4, 320: 2, 327: 5, 328: 2, 329: 3, 330: 8, 334: 3, 335: 4, 341: 5, 342: 6, 347: 5, 348: 5, 350: 4, 351: 6, 352: 4, 353: 4, 354: 3, 358: 2, 365: 4, 366: 3, 369: 2, 371: 7, 372: 6, 376: 3, 384: 6, 385: 5, 386: 4, 387: 4, 392: 2, 393: 3, 396: 6, 397: 5, 398: 4, 402: 4} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 6 "Specifics related to non-MPLS DetNet end station behavior are out side the scope of this document. For example, details on support for DetNet IP data flows can be found in I-D.ietf-detnet-ip. This document is also useful for end stations that map IP flows to DetNet flows." "Branch for review Merge it ! Changes look good - clicking correct button this time" 215d293ca11d1a96b10664fe5db5be2326ffc8d9 215d293ca11d1a96b10664fe5db5be2326ffc8d9 draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework b3c79c333e47859d7a67139de9f5f889c30424df8e7b3f629712649df38292f3 ['eb15bedf6c9fcf82726e5190d9320b0300d5f7eecbe2a3517e7a9edcbb5a44ef', '9668b20321bdb23cd40fbb966469ce0126f928d1f2da7167288c51db9621e4b5', '4a231ab7500e5c2b585abd87b038cb6ad2cb7a4854e98101c4b0c516b6eab72e', '06fe2000420d480393da592c2653f7f98d7c0f36878b8b325f2d68dea40f01d7', 'b834d3cd9d9bf25950ef1aeacca30077c00c5a3e4d8f4a6545b4a46126fd6065', '9ef3cabc128f32e0ef6fc1a66d6c56656a92fb160aad577f3ed1bbd6b7e797f6', '35a05496fb2ca4f3140d51e84bfcf5e48622258574814599c5dc87ad85f0cc1f', '5ddad1f32bf8b0d56c9a65fdd9727cf7dce98a76f125ef116d277bfb33169112', 'b3c79c333e47859d7a67139de9f5f889c30424df8e7b3f629712649df38292f3', '4ba0f06073bb720e9caf4edfb97ead6da456d0a63e88705743ab3006b21c224c', 'c98d52f719106d13b14f27abde81ce00305cbf62889690b72da3e3ddc0286c02'] A "specifics related to non-mpls detnet end station behavior are out side the scope of this document. for example, details on support for detnet ip data flows can be found in i-d.ietf-detnet-ip. this document is also useful for end stations that map ip flows to detnet flows." {8: 1, 31: 1, 53: 1, 6: 2, 79: 2, 90: 3, 51: 3, 130: 2, 62: 5, 85: 5, 68: 4, 35: 3, 110: 3, 91: 5, 114: 3, 97: 3, 13: 3, 67: 3, 38: 4, 26: 3, 124: 3, 98: 2, 54: 2, 127: 3, 96: 3, 64: 2, 30: 4, 61: 5, 55: 3, 27: 4, 15: 3, 52: 2, 129: 3, 115: 3, 84: 3, 76: 6, 87: 3, 131: 5, 102: 3, 113: 5, 99: 2, 36: 3, 24: 2, 72: 4} {120: 1, 154: 1, 224: 1, 369: 1, 1: 9, 4: 2, 9: 5, 10: 3, 15: 3, 24: 2, 25: 5, 26: 5, 27: 3, 39: 5, 43: 3, 49: 6, 50: 5, 58: 5, 59: 2, 64: 3, 69: 4, 81: 6, 82: 4, 86: 3, 96: 4, 97: 3, 100: 7, 108: 3, 109: 4, 110: 4, 111: 2, 114: 3, 115: 4, 116: 3, 118: 6, 119: 5, 121: 4, 122: 4, 123: 3, 124: 4, 128: 4, 129: 4, 130: 5, 132: 4, 136: 2, 145: 4, 147: 4, 151: 4, 152: 4, 156: 2, 161: 3, 162: 3, 165: 3, 168: 4, 169: 3, 172: 3, 180: 4, 184: 5, 187: 5, 188: 4, 191: 3, 194: 4, 202: 5, 203: 6, 206: 2, 207: 3, 215: 2, 217: 3, 218: 8, 220: 2, 221: 2, 222: 5, 227: 5, 229: 3, 234: 5, 235: 2, 241: 2, 242: 2, 243: 4, 244: 4, 245: 4, 248: 4, 250: 4, 258: 11, 262: 4, 263: 5, 264: 3, 267: 4, 270: 3, 272: 3, 273: 5, 287: 3, 289: 3, 291: 5, 299: 5, 300: 3, 304: 3, 309: 3, 314: 2, 315: 3, 320: 4, 323: 4, 327: 4, 328: 3, 329: 2, 330: 10, 334: 2, 335: 3, 341: 5, 342: 6, 347: 5, 348: 5, 350: 7, 351: 5, 352: 3, 353: 3, 354: 2, 358: 4, 365: 3, 366: 2, 371: 7, 372: 5, 384: 5, 385: 4, 386: 3, 387: 3, 392: 3, 393: 4, 396: 6, 397: 7, 398: 6, 402: 3} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 6 "As a general rule, DetNet MPLS domains are capable of forwarding any DetNet MPLS flows and the DetNet domain does not mandate the end- system or edge system encapsulation format. Unless there is a proxy of some form present, end-systems peer with similar end-systems using the same application encapsulation format. For example, as shown in fig_es_connect, IP applications peer with IP applications and Ethernet L2VPN applications peer with Ethernet L2VPN applications." "Branch for review Merge it ! Changes look good - clicking correct button this time" 215d293ca11d1a96b10664fe5db5be2326ffc8d9 215d293ca11d1a96b10664fe5db5be2326ffc8d9 draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework c98d52f719106d13b14f27abde81ce00305cbf62889690b72da3e3ddc0286c02 ['eb15bedf6c9fcf82726e5190d9320b0300d5f7eecbe2a3517e7a9edcbb5a44ef', '9668b20321bdb23cd40fbb966469ce0126f928d1f2da7167288c51db9621e4b5', '4a231ab7500e5c2b585abd87b038cb6ad2cb7a4854e98101c4b0c516b6eab72e', '06fe2000420d480393da592c2653f7f98d7c0f36878b8b325f2d68dea40f01d7', 'b834d3cd9d9bf25950ef1aeacca30077c00c5a3e4d8f4a6545b4a46126fd6065', '9ef3cabc128f32e0ef6fc1a66d6c56656a92fb160aad577f3ed1bbd6b7e797f6', '35a05496fb2ca4f3140d51e84bfcf5e48622258574814599c5dc87ad85f0cc1f', '5ddad1f32bf8b0d56c9a65fdd9727cf7dce98a76f125ef116d277bfb33169112', 'b3c79c333e47859d7a67139de9f5f889c30424df8e7b3f629712649df38292f3', '4ba0f06073bb720e9caf4edfb97ead6da456d0a63e88705743ab3006b21c224c', 'c98d52f719106d13b14f27abde81ce00305cbf62889690b72da3e3ddc0286c02'] A "as a general rule, detnet mpls domains are capable of forwarding any detnet mpls flows and the detnet domain does not mandate the end- system or edge system encapsulation format. unless there is a proxy of some form present, end-systems peer with similar end-systems using the same application encapsulation format. for example, as shown in fig_es_connect, ip applications peer with ip applications and ethernet l2vpn applications peer with ethernet l2vpn applications." {8: 1, 31: 1, 53: 1, 6: 2, 79: 2, 90: 3, 51: 3, 130: 2, 62: 5, 85: 5, 68: 4, 35: 3, 110: 3, 91: 5, 114: 3, 97: 3, 13: 3, 67: 3, 38: 4, 26: 3, 124: 3, 98: 2, 54: 2, 127: 3, 96: 3, 64: 2, 30: 4, 61: 5, 55: 3, 27: 4, 15: 3, 52: 2, 129: 3, 115: 3, 84: 3, 76: 6, 87: 3, 131: 5, 102: 3, 113: 5, 99: 2, 36: 3, 24: 2, 72: 4} {120: 1, 154: 1, 224: 1, 369: 1, 1: 9, 4: 2, 9: 5, 10: 3, 15: 3, 24: 2, 25: 5, 26: 5, 27: 3, 39: 5, 43: 3, 49: 6, 50: 5, 58: 5, 59: 2, 64: 3, 69: 4, 81: 6, 82: 4, 86: 3, 96: 4, 97: 3, 100: 7, 108: 3, 109: 4, 110: 4, 111: 2, 114: 3, 115: 4, 116: 3, 118: 6, 119: 5, 121: 4, 122: 4, 123: 3, 124: 4, 128: 4, 129: 4, 130: 5, 132: 4, 136: 2, 145: 4, 147: 4, 151: 4, 152: 4, 156: 2, 161: 3, 162: 3, 165: 3, 168: 4, 169: 3, 172: 3, 180: 4, 184: 5, 187: 5, 188: 4, 191: 3, 194: 4, 202: 5, 203: 6, 206: 2, 207: 3, 215: 2, 217: 3, 218: 8, 220: 2, 221: 2, 222: 5, 227: 5, 229: 3, 234: 5, 235: 2, 241: 2, 242: 2, 243: 4, 244: 4, 245: 4, 248: 4, 250: 4, 258: 11, 262: 4, 263: 5, 264: 3, 267: 4, 270: 3, 272: 3, 273: 5, 287: 3, 289: 3, 291: 5, 299: 5, 300: 3, 304: 3, 309: 3, 314: 2, 315: 3, 320: 4, 323: 4, 327: 4, 328: 3, 329: 2, 330: 10, 334: 2, 335: 3, 341: 5, 342: 6, 347: 5, 348: 5, 350: 7, 351: 5, 352: 3, 353: 3, 354: 2, 358: 4, 365: 3, 366: 2, 371: 7, 372: 5, 384: 5, 385: 4, 386: 3, 387: 3, 392: 3, 393: 4, 396: 6, 397: 7, 398: 6, 402: 3} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 6 "As shown in , MPLS nodes are interconnected by different sub-network technologies, which may include point-to-point links. Each of these need to provide appropriate service to DetNet flows. In some cases, e.g., on dedicated point-to-point links or TDM technologies, all that is required is for a DetNet node to appropriately queue its output traffic. In other cases, DetNet nodes will need to map DetNet flows to the flow semantics (i.e., identifiers) and mechanisms used by an underlying sub-network technology. shows several examples of header formats that can be used to carry DetNet MPLS flows over different sub-network technologies. L2 represent a generic layer-2 encapsulation that might be used on a point-to-point link. TSN represents the encapsulation used on an IEEE 802.1 TSN network, as described in . UDP/IP represents the encapsulation used on a DetNet IP PSN, as described in ." "Branch for review Merge it ! Changes look good - clicking correct button this time" 215d293ca11d1a96b10664fe5db5be2326ffc8d9 215d293ca11d1a96b10664fe5db5be2326ffc8d9 draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework 9668b20321bdb23cd40fbb966469ce0126f928d1f2da7167288c51db9621e4b5 ['eb15bedf6c9fcf82726e5190d9320b0300d5f7eecbe2a3517e7a9edcbb5a44ef', '9668b20321bdb23cd40fbb966469ce0126f928d1f2da7167288c51db9621e4b5', '4a231ab7500e5c2b585abd87b038cb6ad2cb7a4854e98101c4b0c516b6eab72e', '06fe2000420d480393da592c2653f7f98d7c0f36878b8b325f2d68dea40f01d7', 'b834d3cd9d9bf25950ef1aeacca30077c00c5a3e4d8f4a6545b4a46126fd6065', '9ef3cabc128f32e0ef6fc1a66d6c56656a92fb160aad577f3ed1bbd6b7e797f6', '35a05496fb2ca4f3140d51e84bfcf5e48622258574814599c5dc87ad85f0cc1f', '5ddad1f32bf8b0d56c9a65fdd9727cf7dce98a76f125ef116d277bfb33169112', 'b3c79c333e47859d7a67139de9f5f889c30424df8e7b3f629712649df38292f3', '4ba0f06073bb720e9caf4edfb97ead6da456d0a63e88705743ab3006b21c224c', 'c98d52f719106d13b14f27abde81ce00305cbf62889690b72da3e3ddc0286c02'] A "as shown in , mpls nodes are interconnected by different sub-network technologies, which may include point-to-point links. each of these need to provide appropriate service to detnet flows. in some cases, e.g., on dedicated point-to-point links or tdm technologies, all that is required is for a detnet node to appropriately queue its output traffic. in other cases, detnet nodes will need to map detnet flows to the flow semantics (i.e., identifiers) and mechanisms used by an underlying sub-network technology. shows several examples of header formats that can be used to carry detnet mpls flows over different sub-network technologies. l2 represent a generic layer-2 encapsulation that might be used on a point-to-point link. tsn represents the encapsulation used on an ieee 802.1 tsn network, as described in . udp/ip represents the encapsulation used on a detnet ip psn, as described in ." {8: 1, 31: 1, 53: 1, 6: 2, 79: 2, 90: 3, 51: 3, 130: 2, 62: 5, 85: 5, 68: 4, 35: 3, 110: 3, 91: 5, 114: 3, 97: 3, 13: 3, 67: 3, 38: 4, 26: 3, 124: 3, 98: 2, 54: 2, 127: 3, 96: 3, 64: 2, 30: 4, 61: 5, 55: 3, 27: 4, 15: 3, 52: 2, 129: 3, 115: 3, 84: 3, 76: 6, 87: 3, 131: 5, 102: 3, 113: 5, 99: 2, 36: 3, 24: 2, 72: 4} {120: 1, 154: 1, 224: 1, 369: 1, 1: 9, 4: 2, 9: 5, 10: 3, 15: 3, 24: 2, 25: 5, 26: 5, 27: 3, 39: 5, 43: 3, 49: 6, 50: 5, 58: 5, 59: 2, 64: 3, 69: 4, 81: 6, 82: 4, 86: 3, 96: 4, 97: 3, 100: 7, 108: 3, 109: 4, 110: 4, 111: 2, 114: 3, 115: 4, 116: 3, 118: 6, 119: 5, 121: 4, 122: 4, 123: 3, 124: 4, 128: 4, 129: 4, 130: 5, 132: 4, 136: 2, 145: 4, 147: 4, 151: 4, 152: 4, 156: 2, 161: 3, 162: 3, 165: 3, 168: 4, 169: 3, 172: 3, 180: 4, 184: 5, 187: 5, 188: 4, 191: 3, 194: 4, 202: 5, 203: 6, 206: 2, 207: 3, 215: 2, 217: 3, 218: 8, 220: 2, 221: 2, 222: 5, 227: 5, 229: 3, 234: 5, 235: 2, 241: 2, 242: 2, 243: 4, 244: 4, 245: 4, 248: 4, 250: 4, 258: 11, 262: 4, 263: 5, 264: 3, 267: 4, 270: 3, 272: 3, 273: 5, 287: 3, 289: 3, 291: 5, 299: 5, 300: 3, 304: 3, 309: 3, 314: 2, 315: 3, 320: 4, 323: 4, 327: 4, 328: 3, 329: 2, 330: 10, 334: 2, 335: 3, 341: 5, 342: 6, 347: 5, 348: 5, 350: 7, 351: 5, 352: 3, 353: 3, 354: 2, 358: 4, 365: 3, 366: 2, 371: 7, 372: 5, 384: 5, 385: 4, 386: 3, 387: 3, 392: 3, 393: 4, 396: 6, 397: 7, 398: 6, 402: 3} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 6 "As a general rule, DetNet domains are capable of forwarding any DetNet flows and the DetNet domain does not mandate the end-system or edge system encapsulation format. Unless there is a proxy of some form present, end-systems peer with similar end-systems using the same application encapsulation format. For example, as shown in fig_es_connect, IP applications peer with IP applications and Ethernet L2VPN applications peer with Ethernet L2VPN applications." "Branch for review Merge it ! Changes look good - clicking correct button this time" 215d293ca11d1a96b10664fe5db5be2326ffc8d9 215d293ca11d1a96b10664fe5db5be2326ffc8d9 draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework eb15bedf6c9fcf82726e5190d9320b0300d5f7eecbe2a3517e7a9edcbb5a44ef ['eb15bedf6c9fcf82726e5190d9320b0300d5f7eecbe2a3517e7a9edcbb5a44ef', '9668b20321bdb23cd40fbb966469ce0126f928d1f2da7167288c51db9621e4b5', '4a231ab7500e5c2b585abd87b038cb6ad2cb7a4854e98101c4b0c516b6eab72e', '06fe2000420d480393da592c2653f7f98d7c0f36878b8b325f2d68dea40f01d7', 'b834d3cd9d9bf25950ef1aeacca30077c00c5a3e4d8f4a6545b4a46126fd6065', '9ef3cabc128f32e0ef6fc1a66d6c56656a92fb160aad577f3ed1bbd6b7e797f6', '35a05496fb2ca4f3140d51e84bfcf5e48622258574814599c5dc87ad85f0cc1f', '5ddad1f32bf8b0d56c9a65fdd9727cf7dce98a76f125ef116d277bfb33169112', 'b3c79c333e47859d7a67139de9f5f889c30424df8e7b3f629712649df38292f3', '4ba0f06073bb720e9caf4edfb97ead6da456d0a63e88705743ab3006b21c224c', 'c98d52f719106d13b14f27abde81ce00305cbf62889690b72da3e3ddc0286c02'] B "as a general rule, detnet domains are capable of forwarding any detnet flows and the detnet domain does not mandate the end-system or edge system encapsulation format. unless there is a proxy of some form present, end-systems peer with similar end-systems using the same application encapsulation format. for example, as shown in fig_es_connect, ip applications peer with ip applications and ethernet l2vpn applications peer with ethernet l2vpn applications." {8: 1, 31: 1, 53: 1, 6: 2, 79: 2, 90: 3, 51: 3, 130: 2, 62: 5, 85: 5, 68: 4, 35: 3, 110: 3, 91: 5, 114: 3, 97: 3, 13: 3, 67: 3, 38: 4, 26: 3, 124: 3, 98: 2, 54: 2, 127: 3, 96: 3, 64: 2, 30: 4, 61: 5, 55: 3, 27: 4, 15: 3, 52: 2, 129: 3, 115: 3, 84: 3, 76: 6, 87: 3, 131: 5, 102: 3, 113: 5, 99: 2, 36: 3, 24: 2, 72: 4} {120: 1, 154: 1, 224: 1, 369: 1, 1: 9, 4: 2, 9: 5, 10: 3, 15: 3, 24: 2, 25: 5, 26: 5, 27: 3, 39: 5, 43: 3, 49: 6, 50: 5, 58: 5, 59: 2, 64: 3, 69: 4, 81: 6, 82: 4, 86: 3, 96: 4, 97: 3, 100: 7, 108: 3, 109: 4, 110: 4, 111: 2, 114: 3, 115: 4, 116: 3, 118: 6, 119: 5, 121: 4, 122: 4, 123: 3, 124: 4, 128: 4, 129: 4, 130: 5, 132: 4, 136: 2, 145: 4, 147: 4, 151: 4, 152: 4, 156: 2, 161: 3, 162: 3, 165: 3, 168: 4, 169: 3, 172: 3, 180: 4, 184: 5, 187: 5, 188: 4, 191: 3, 194: 4, 202: 5, 203: 6, 206: 2, 207: 3, 215: 2, 217: 3, 218: 8, 220: 2, 221: 2, 222: 5, 227: 5, 229: 3, 234: 5, 235: 2, 241: 2, 242: 2, 243: 4, 244: 4, 245: 4, 248: 4, 250: 4, 258: 11, 262: 4, 263: 5, 264: 3, 267: 4, 270: 3, 272: 3, 273: 5, 287: 3, 289: 3, 291: 5, 299: 5, 300: 3, 304: 3, 309: 3, 314: 2, 315: 3, 320: 4, 323: 4, 327: 4, 328: 3, 329: 2, 330: 10, 334: 2, 335: 3, 341: 5, 342: 6, 347: 5, 348: 5, 350: 7, 351: 5, 352: 3, 353: 3, 354: 2, 358: 4, 365: 3, 366: 2, 371: 7, 372: 5, 384: 5, 385: 4, 386: 3, 387: 3, 392: 3, 393: 4, 396: 6, 397: 7, 398: 6, 402: 3} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 6 "Any of the DetNet native service types may be transported by another DetNet service. MPLS nodes may interconnected by different sub- network technologies, which may include point-to-point links. Each of these sub-network technologies need to provide appropriate service to DetNet flows. In some cases, e.g., on dedicated point-to-point links or TDM technologies, all that is required is for a DetNet node to appropriately queue its output traffic. In other cases, DetNet nodes will need to map DetNet flows to the flow semantics (i.e., identifiers) and mechanisms used by an underlying sub-network technology. fig_dn_mpls_sn_ex shows several examples of header formats that can be used to carry DetNet MPLS flows over different sub-network technologies. L2 represent a generic layer-2 encapsulation that might be used on a point-to-point link. TSN represents the encapsulation used on an IEEE 802.1 TSN network, as described in I-D.mpls-over-tsn. UDP/IP represents the encapsulation used on a DetNet IP PSN, as described in I-D.mpls-over-udp-ip." "Branch for review Merge it ! Changes look good - clicking correct button this time" 215d293ca11d1a96b10664fe5db5be2326ffc8d9 215d293ca11d1a96b10664fe5db5be2326ffc8d9 draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework 4a231ab7500e5c2b585abd87b038cb6ad2cb7a4854e98101c4b0c516b6eab72e ['eb15bedf6c9fcf82726e5190d9320b0300d5f7eecbe2a3517e7a9edcbb5a44ef', '9668b20321bdb23cd40fbb966469ce0126f928d1f2da7167288c51db9621e4b5', '4a231ab7500e5c2b585abd87b038cb6ad2cb7a4854e98101c4b0c516b6eab72e', '06fe2000420d480393da592c2653f7f98d7c0f36878b8b325f2d68dea40f01d7', 'b834d3cd9d9bf25950ef1aeacca30077c00c5a3e4d8f4a6545b4a46126fd6065', '9ef3cabc128f32e0ef6fc1a66d6c56656a92fb160aad577f3ed1bbd6b7e797f6', '35a05496fb2ca4f3140d51e84bfcf5e48622258574814599c5dc87ad85f0cc1f', '5ddad1f32bf8b0d56c9a65fdd9727cf7dce98a76f125ef116d277bfb33169112', 'b3c79c333e47859d7a67139de9f5f889c30424df8e7b3f629712649df38292f3', '4ba0f06073bb720e9caf4edfb97ead6da456d0a63e88705743ab3006b21c224c', 'c98d52f719106d13b14f27abde81ce00305cbf62889690b72da3e3ddc0286c02'] B "any of the detnet native service types may be transported by another detnet service. mpls nodes may interconnected by different sub- network technologies, which may include point-to-point links. each of these sub-network technologies need to provide appropriate service to detnet flows. in some cases, e.g., on dedicated point-to-point links or tdm technologies, all that is required is for a detnet node to appropriately queue its output traffic. in other cases, detnet nodes will need to map detnet flows to the flow semantics (i.e., identifiers) and mechanisms used by an underlying sub-network technology. fig_dn_mpls_sn_ex shows several examples of header formats that can be used to carry detnet mpls flows over different sub-network technologies. l2 represent a generic layer-2 encapsulation that might be used on a point-to-point link. tsn represents the encapsulation used on an ieee 802.1 tsn network, as described in i-d.mpls-over-tsn. udp/ip represents the encapsulation used on a detnet ip psn, as described in i-d.mpls-over-udp-ip." {8: 1, 31: 1, 53: 1, 6: 2, 79: 2, 90: 3, 51: 3, 130: 2, 62: 5, 85: 5, 68: 4, 35: 3, 110: 3, 91: 5, 114: 3, 97: 3, 13: 3, 67: 3, 38: 4, 26: 3, 124: 3, 98: 2, 54: 2, 127: 3, 96: 3, 64: 2, 30: 4, 61: 5, 55: 3, 27: 4, 15: 3, 52: 2, 129: 3, 115: 3, 84: 3, 76: 6, 87: 3, 131: 5, 102: 3, 113: 5, 99: 2, 36: 3, 24: 2, 72: 4} {120: 1, 154: 1, 224: 1, 369: 1, 1: 9, 4: 2, 9: 5, 10: 3, 15: 3, 24: 2, 25: 5, 26: 5, 27: 3, 39: 5, 43: 3, 49: 6, 50: 5, 58: 5, 59: 2, 64: 3, 69: 4, 81: 6, 82: 4, 86: 3, 96: 4, 97: 3, 100: 7, 108: 3, 109: 4, 110: 4, 111: 2, 114: 3, 115: 4, 116: 3, 118: 6, 119: 5, 121: 4, 122: 4, 123: 3, 124: 4, 128: 4, 129: 4, 130: 5, 132: 4, 136: 2, 145: 4, 147: 4, 151: 4, 152: 4, 156: 2, 161: 3, 162: 3, 165: 3, 168: 4, 169: 3, 172: 3, 180: 4, 184: 5, 187: 5, 188: 4, 191: 3, 194: 4, 202: 5, 203: 6, 206: 2, 207: 3, 215: 2, 217: 3, 218: 8, 220: 2, 221: 2, 222: 5, 227: 5, 229: 3, 234: 5, 235: 2, 241: 2, 242: 2, 243: 4, 244: 4, 245: 4, 248: 4, 250: 4, 258: 11, 262: 4, 263: 5, 264: 3, 267: 4, 270: 3, 272: 3, 273: 5, 287: 3, 289: 3, 291: 5, 299: 5, 300: 3, 304: 3, 309: 3, 314: 2, 315: 3, 320: 4, 323: 4, 327: 4, 328: 3, 329: 2, 330: 10, 334: 2, 335: 3, 341: 5, 342: 6, 347: 5, 348: 5, 350: 7, 351: 5, 352: 3, 353: 3, 354: 2, 358: 4, 365: 3, 366: 2, 371: 7, 372: 5, 384: 5, 385: 4, 386: 3, 387: 3, 392: 3, 393: 4, 396: 6, 397: 7, 398: 6, 402: 3} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 6 "In the case of MPLS Manage DetNet S-Label and F-Label allocation and distribution, where the DetNet MPLS encapsulation is in use see mpls_cp_considerations." "Branch for review Merge it ! Changes look good - clicking correct button this time" 215d293ca11d1a96b10664fe5db5be2326ffc8d9 215d293ca11d1a96b10664fe5db5be2326ffc8d9 draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework 35a05496fb2ca4f3140d51e84bfcf5e48622258574814599c5dc87ad85f0cc1f ['eb15bedf6c9fcf82726e5190d9320b0300d5f7eecbe2a3517e7a9edcbb5a44ef', '9668b20321bdb23cd40fbb966469ce0126f928d1f2da7167288c51db9621e4b5', '4a231ab7500e5c2b585abd87b038cb6ad2cb7a4854e98101c4b0c516b6eab72e', '06fe2000420d480393da592c2653f7f98d7c0f36878b8b325f2d68dea40f01d7', 'b834d3cd9d9bf25950ef1aeacca30077c00c5a3e4d8f4a6545b4a46126fd6065', '9ef3cabc128f32e0ef6fc1a66d6c56656a92fb160aad577f3ed1bbd6b7e797f6', '35a05496fb2ca4f3140d51e84bfcf5e48622258574814599c5dc87ad85f0cc1f', '5ddad1f32bf8b0d56c9a65fdd9727cf7dce98a76f125ef116d277bfb33169112', 'b3c79c333e47859d7a67139de9f5f889c30424df8e7b3f629712649df38292f3', '4ba0f06073bb720e9caf4edfb97ead6da456d0a63e88705743ab3006b21c224c', 'c98d52f719106d13b14f27abde81ce00305cbf62889690b72da3e3ddc0286c02'] B "in the case of mpls manage detnet s-label and f-label allocation and distribution, where the detnet mpls encapsulation is in use see mpls_cp_considerations." {8: 1, 31: 1, 53: 1, 6: 2, 79: 2, 90: 3, 51: 3, 130: 2, 62: 5, 85: 5, 68: 4, 35: 3, 110: 3, 91: 5, 114: 3, 97: 3, 13: 3, 67: 3, 38: 4, 26: 3, 124: 3, 98: 2, 54: 2, 127: 3, 96: 3, 64: 2, 30: 4, 61: 5, 55: 3, 27: 4, 15: 3, 52: 2, 129: 3, 115: 3, 84: 3, 76: 6, 87: 3, 131: 5, 102: 3, 113: 5, 99: 2, 36: 3, 24: 2, 72: 4} {120: 1, 154: 1, 224: 1, 369: 1, 1: 9, 4: 2, 9: 5, 10: 3, 15: 3, 24: 2, 25: 5, 26: 5, 27: 3, 39: 5, 43: 3, 49: 6, 50: 5, 58: 5, 59: 2, 64: 3, 69: 4, 81: 6, 82: 4, 86: 3, 96: 4, 97: 3, 100: 7, 108: 3, 109: 4, 110: 4, 111: 2, 114: 3, 115: 4, 116: 3, 118: 6, 119: 5, 121: 4, 122: 4, 123: 3, 124: 4, 128: 4, 129: 4, 130: 5, 132: 4, 136: 2, 145: 4, 147: 4, 151: 4, 152: 4, 156: 2, 161: 3, 162: 3, 165: 3, 168: 4, 169: 3, 172: 3, 180: 4, 184: 5, 187: 5, 188: 4, 191: 3, 194: 4, 202: 5, 203: 6, 206: 2, 207: 3, 215: 2, 217: 3, 218: 8, 220: 2, 221: 2, 222: 5, 227: 5, 229: 3, 234: 5, 235: 2, 241: 2, 242: 2, 243: 4, 244: 4, 245: 4, 248: 4, 250: 4, 258: 11, 262: 4, 263: 5, 264: 3, 267: 4, 270: 3, 272: 3, 273: 5, 287: 3, 289: 3, 291: 5, 299: 5, 300: 3, 304: 3, 309: 3, 314: 2, 315: 3, 320: 4, 323: 4, 327: 4, 328: 3, 329: 2, 330: 10, 334: 2, 335: 3, 341: 5, 342: 6, 347: 5, 348: 5, 350: 7, 351: 5, 352: 3, 353: 3, 354: 2, 358: 4, 365: 3, 366: 2, 371: 7, 372: 5, 384: 5, 385: 4, 386: 3, 387: 3, 392: 3, 393: 4, 396: 6, 397: 7, 398: 6, 402: 3} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 6 The ability to support DetNet flow aggregation. "Branch for review Merge it ! Changes look good - clicking correct button this time" 215d293ca11d1a96b10664fe5db5be2326ffc8d9 215d293ca11d1a96b10664fe5db5be2326ffc8d9 draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework 5ddad1f32bf8b0d56c9a65fdd9727cf7dce98a76f125ef116d277bfb33169112 ['eb15bedf6c9fcf82726e5190d9320b0300d5f7eecbe2a3517e7a9edcbb5a44ef', '9668b20321bdb23cd40fbb966469ce0126f928d1f2da7167288c51db9621e4b5', '4a231ab7500e5c2b585abd87b038cb6ad2cb7a4854e98101c4b0c516b6eab72e', '06fe2000420d480393da592c2653f7f98d7c0f36878b8b325f2d68dea40f01d7', 'b834d3cd9d9bf25950ef1aeacca30077c00c5a3e4d8f4a6545b4a46126fd6065', '9ef3cabc128f32e0ef6fc1a66d6c56656a92fb160aad577f3ed1bbd6b7e797f6', '35a05496fb2ca4f3140d51e84bfcf5e48622258574814599c5dc87ad85f0cc1f', '5ddad1f32bf8b0d56c9a65fdd9727cf7dce98a76f125ef116d277bfb33169112', 'b3c79c333e47859d7a67139de9f5f889c30424df8e7b3f629712649df38292f3', '4ba0f06073bb720e9caf4edfb97ead6da456d0a63e88705743ab3006b21c224c', 'c98d52f719106d13b14f27abde81ce00305cbf62889690b72da3e3ddc0286c02'] B the ability to support detnet flow aggregation. {8: 1, 31: 1, 53: 1, 6: 2, 79: 2, 90: 3, 51: 3, 130: 2, 62: 5, 85: 5, 68: 4, 35: 3, 110: 3, 91: 5, 114: 3, 97: 3, 13: 3, 67: 3, 38: 4, 26: 3, 124: 3, 98: 2, 54: 2, 127: 3, 96: 3, 64: 2, 30: 4, 61: 5, 55: 3, 27: 4, 15: 3, 52: 2, 129: 3, 115: 3, 84: 3, 76: 6, 87: 3, 131: 5, 102: 3, 113: 5, 99: 2, 36: 3, 24: 2, 72: 4} {120: 1, 154: 1, 224: 1, 369: 1, 1: 9, 4: 2, 9: 5, 10: 3, 15: 3, 24: 2, 25: 5, 26: 5, 27: 3, 39: 5, 43: 3, 49: 6, 50: 5, 58: 5, 59: 2, 64: 3, 69: 4, 81: 6, 82: 4, 86: 3, 96: 4, 97: 3, 100: 7, 108: 3, 109: 4, 110: 4, 111: 2, 114: 3, 115: 4, 116: 3, 118: 6, 119: 5, 121: 4, 122: 4, 123: 3, 124: 4, 128: 4, 129: 4, 130: 5, 132: 4, 136: 2, 145: 4, 147: 4, 151: 4, 152: 4, 156: 2, 161: 3, 162: 3, 165: 3, 168: 4, 169: 3, 172: 3, 180: 4, 184: 5, 187: 5, 188: 4, 191: 3, 194: 4, 202: 5, 203: 6, 206: 2, 207: 3, 215: 2, 217: 3, 218: 8, 220: 2, 221: 2, 222: 5, 227: 5, 229: 3, 234: 5, 235: 2, 241: 2, 242: 2, 243: 4, 244: 4, 245: 4, 248: 4, 250: 4, 258: 11, 262: 4, 263: 5, 264: 3, 267: 4, 270: 3, 272: 3, 273: 5, 287: 3, 289: 3, 291: 5, 299: 5, 300: 3, 304: 3, 309: 3, 314: 2, 315: 3, 320: 4, 323: 4, 327: 4, 328: 3, 329: 2, 330: 10, 334: 2, 335: 3, 341: 5, 342: 6, 347: 5, 348: 5, 350: 7, 351: 5, 352: 3, 353: 3, 354: 2, 358: 4, 365: 3, 366: 2, 371: 7, 372: 5, 384: 5, 385: 4, 386: 3, 387: 3, 392: 3, 393: 4, 396: 6, 397: 7, 398: 6, 402: 3} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 6 "Advertise static and dynamic node and link resources such as capabilities and adjacencies to other network nodes (for dynamic signaling approaches) or to network controllers (for centralized approaches)." "Branch for review Merge it ! Changes look good - clicking correct button this time" 215d293ca11d1a96b10664fe5db5be2326ffc8d9 215d293ca11d1a96b10664fe5db5be2326ffc8d9 draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework b834d3cd9d9bf25950ef1aeacca30077c00c5a3e4d8f4a6545b4a46126fd6065 ['eb15bedf6c9fcf82726e5190d9320b0300d5f7eecbe2a3517e7a9edcbb5a44ef', '9668b20321bdb23cd40fbb966469ce0126f928d1f2da7167288c51db9621e4b5', '4a231ab7500e5c2b585abd87b038cb6ad2cb7a4854e98101c4b0c516b6eab72e', '06fe2000420d480393da592c2653f7f98d7c0f36878b8b325f2d68dea40f01d7', 'b834d3cd9d9bf25950ef1aeacca30077c00c5a3e4d8f4a6545b4a46126fd6065', '9ef3cabc128f32e0ef6fc1a66d6c56656a92fb160aad577f3ed1bbd6b7e797f6', '35a05496fb2ca4f3140d51e84bfcf5e48622258574814599c5dc87ad85f0cc1f', '5ddad1f32bf8b0d56c9a65fdd9727cf7dce98a76f125ef116d277bfb33169112', 'b3c79c333e47859d7a67139de9f5f889c30424df8e7b3f629712649df38292f3', '4ba0f06073bb720e9caf4edfb97ead6da456d0a63e88705743ab3006b21c224c', 'c98d52f719106d13b14f27abde81ce00305cbf62889690b72da3e3ddc0286c02'] B "advertise static and dynamic node and link resources such as capabilities and adjacencies to other network nodes (for dynamic signaling approaches) or to network controllers (for centralized approaches)." {8: 1, 31: 1, 53: 1, 6: 2, 79: 2, 90: 3, 51: 3, 130: 2, 62: 5, 85: 5, 68: 4, 35: 3, 110: 3, 91: 5, 114: 3, 97: 3, 13: 3, 67: 3, 38: 4, 26: 3, 124: 3, 98: 2, 54: 2, 127: 3, 96: 3, 64: 2, 30: 4, 61: 5, 55: 3, 27: 4, 15: 3, 52: 2, 129: 3, 115: 3, 84: 3, 76: 6, 87: 3, 131: 5, 102: 3, 113: 5, 99: 2, 36: 3, 24: 2, 72: 4} {120: 1, 154: 1, 224: 1, 369: 1, 1: 9, 4: 2, 9: 5, 10: 3, 15: 3, 24: 2, 25: 5, 26: 5, 27: 3, 39: 5, 43: 3, 49: 6, 50: 5, 58: 5, 59: 2, 64: 3, 69: 4, 81: 6, 82: 4, 86: 3, 96: 4, 97: 3, 100: 7, 108: 3, 109: 4, 110: 4, 111: 2, 114: 3, 115: 4, 116: 3, 118: 6, 119: 5, 121: 4, 122: 4, 123: 3, 124: 4, 128: 4, 129: 4, 130: 5, 132: 4, 136: 2, 145: 4, 147: 4, 151: 4, 152: 4, 156: 2, 161: 3, 162: 3, 165: 3, 168: 4, 169: 3, 172: 3, 180: 4, 184: 5, 187: 5, 188: 4, 191: 3, 194: 4, 202: 5, 203: 6, 206: 2, 207: 3, 215: 2, 217: 3, 218: 8, 220: 2, 221: 2, 222: 5, 227: 5, 229: 3, 234: 5, 235: 2, 241: 2, 242: 2, 243: 4, 244: 4, 245: 4, 248: 4, 250: 4, 258: 11, 262: 4, 263: 5, 264: 3, 267: 4, 270: 3, 272: 3, 273: 5, 287: 3, 289: 3, 291: 5, 299: 5, 300: 3, 304: 3, 309: 3, 314: 2, 315: 3, 320: 4, 323: 4, 327: 4, 328: 3, 329: 2, 330: 10, 334: 2, 335: 3, 341: 5, 342: 6, 347: 5, 348: 5, 350: 7, 351: 5, 352: 3, 353: 3, 354: 2, 358: 4, 365: 3, 366: 2, 371: 7, 372: 5, 384: 5, 385: 4, 386: 3, 387: 3, 392: 3, 393: 4, 396: 6, 397: 7, 398: 6, 402: 3} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 6 "Scale to handle the number of DetNet flows expected in a domain (which may require per-flow signaling or provisioning)." "Branch for review Merge it ! Changes look good - clicking correct button this time" 215d293ca11d1a96b10664fe5db5be2326ffc8d9 215d293ca11d1a96b10664fe5db5be2326ffc8d9 draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework 9ef3cabc128f32e0ef6fc1a66d6c56656a92fb160aad577f3ed1bbd6b7e797f6 ['eb15bedf6c9fcf82726e5190d9320b0300d5f7eecbe2a3517e7a9edcbb5a44ef', '9668b20321bdb23cd40fbb966469ce0126f928d1f2da7167288c51db9621e4b5', '4a231ab7500e5c2b585abd87b038cb6ad2cb7a4854e98101c4b0c516b6eab72e', '06fe2000420d480393da592c2653f7f98d7c0f36878b8b325f2d68dea40f01d7', 'b834d3cd9d9bf25950ef1aeacca30077c00c5a3e4d8f4a6545b4a46126fd6065', '9ef3cabc128f32e0ef6fc1a66d6c56656a92fb160aad577f3ed1bbd6b7e797f6', '35a05496fb2ca4f3140d51e84bfcf5e48622258574814599c5dc87ad85f0cc1f', '5ddad1f32bf8b0d56c9a65fdd9727cf7dce98a76f125ef116d277bfb33169112', 'b3c79c333e47859d7a67139de9f5f889c30424df8e7b3f629712649df38292f3', '4ba0f06073bb720e9caf4edfb97ead6da456d0a63e88705743ab3006b21c224c', 'c98d52f719106d13b14f27abde81ce00305cbf62889690b72da3e3ddc0286c02'] B "scale to handle the number of detnet flows expected in a domain (which may require per-flow signaling or provisioning)." {8: 1, 31: 1, 53: 1, 6: 2, 79: 2, 90: 3, 51: 3, 130: 2, 62: 5, 85: 5, 68: 4, 35: 3, 110: 3, 91: 5, 114: 3, 97: 3, 13: 3, 67: 3, 38: 4, 26: 3, 124: 3, 98: 2, 54: 2, 127: 3, 96: 3, 64: 2, 30: 4, 61: 5, 55: 3, 27: 4, 15: 3, 52: 2, 129: 3, 115: 3, 84: 3, 76: 6, 87: 3, 131: 5, 102: 3, 113: 5, 99: 2, 36: 3, 24: 2, 72: 4} {120: 1, 154: 1, 224: 1, 369: 1, 1: 9, 4: 2, 9: 5, 10: 3, 15: 3, 24: 2, 25: 5, 26: 5, 27: 3, 39: 5, 43: 3, 49: 6, 50: 5, 58: 5, 59: 2, 64: 3, 69: 4, 81: 6, 82: 4, 86: 3, 96: 4, 97: 3, 100: 7, 108: 3, 109: 4, 110: 4, 111: 2, 114: 3, 115: 4, 116: 3, 118: 6, 119: 5, 121: 4, 122: 4, 123: 3, 124: 4, 128: 4, 129: 4, 130: 5, 132: 4, 136: 2, 145: 4, 147: 4, 151: 4, 152: 4, 156: 2, 161: 3, 162: 3, 165: 3, 168: 4, 169: 3, 172: 3, 180: 4, 184: 5, 187: 5, 188: 4, 191: 3, 194: 4, 202: 5, 203: 6, 206: 2, 207: 3, 215: 2, 217: 3, 218: 8, 220: 2, 221: 2, 222: 5, 227: 5, 229: 3, 234: 5, 235: 2, 241: 2, 242: 2, 243: 4, 244: 4, 245: 4, 248: 4, 250: 4, 258: 11, 262: 4, 263: 5, 264: 3, 267: 4, 270: 3, 272: 3, 273: 5, 287: 3, 289: 3, 291: 5, 299: 5, 300: 3, 304: 3, 309: 3, 314: 2, 315: 3, 320: 4, 323: 4, 327: 4, 328: 3, 329: 2, 330: 10, 334: 2, 335: 3, 341: 5, 342: 6, 347: 5, 348: 5, 350: 7, 351: 5, 352: 3, 353: 3, 354: 2, 358: 4, 365: 3, 366: 2, 371: 7, 372: 5, 384: 5, 385: 4, 386: 3, 387: 3, 392: 3, 393: 4, 396: 6, 397: 7, 398: 6, 402: 3} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 6 "Provision flow identification information at each of the nodes along the path. Flow identification may differ depending on the location in the network and the DetNet functionality (e.g. transit node vs. relay node)." "Branch for review Merge it ! Changes look good - clicking correct button this time" 215d293ca11d1a96b10664fe5db5be2326ffc8d9 215d293ca11d1a96b10664fe5db5be2326ffc8d9 draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework 4ba0f06073bb720e9caf4edfb97ead6da456d0a63e88705743ab3006b21c224c ['eb15bedf6c9fcf82726e5190d9320b0300d5f7eecbe2a3517e7a9edcbb5a44ef', '9668b20321bdb23cd40fbb966469ce0126f928d1f2da7167288c51db9621e4b5', '4a231ab7500e5c2b585abd87b038cb6ad2cb7a4854e98101c4b0c516b6eab72e', '06fe2000420d480393da592c2653f7f98d7c0f36878b8b325f2d68dea40f01d7', 'b834d3cd9d9bf25950ef1aeacca30077c00c5a3e4d8f4a6545b4a46126fd6065', '9ef3cabc128f32e0ef6fc1a66d6c56656a92fb160aad577f3ed1bbd6b7e797f6', '35a05496fb2ca4f3140d51e84bfcf5e48622258574814599c5dc87ad85f0cc1f', '5ddad1f32bf8b0d56c9a65fdd9727cf7dce98a76f125ef116d277bfb33169112', 'b3c79c333e47859d7a67139de9f5f889c30424df8e7b3f629712649df38292f3', '4ba0f06073bb720e9caf4edfb97ead6da456d0a63e88705743ab3006b21c224c', 'c98d52f719106d13b14f27abde81ce00305cbf62889690b72da3e3ddc0286c02'] B "provision flow identification information at each of the nodes along the path. flow identification may differ depending on the location in the network and the detnet functionality (e.g. transit node vs. relay node)." {8: 1, 31: 1, 53: 1, 6: 2, 79: 2, 90: 3, 51: 3, 130: 2, 62: 5, 85: 5, 68: 4, 35: 3, 110: 3, 91: 5, 114: 3, 97: 3, 13: 3, 67: 3, 38: 4, 26: 3, 124: 3, 98: 2, 54: 2, 127: 3, 96: 3, 64: 2, 30: 4, 61: 5, 55: 3, 27: 4, 15: 3, 52: 2, 129: 3, 115: 3, 84: 3, 76: 6, 87: 3, 131: 5, 102: 3, 113: 5, 99: 2, 36: 3, 24: 2, 72: 4} {120: 1, 154: 1, 224: 1, 369: 1, 1: 9, 4: 2, 9: 5, 10: 3, 15: 3, 24: 2, 25: 5, 26: 5, 27: 3, 39: 5, 43: 3, 49: 6, 50: 5, 58: 5, 59: 2, 64: 3, 69: 4, 81: 6, 82: 4, 86: 3, 96: 4, 97: 3, 100: 7, 108: 3, 109: 4, 110: 4, 111: 2, 114: 3, 115: 4, 116: 3, 118: 6, 119: 5, 121: 4, 122: 4, 123: 3, 124: 4, 128: 4, 129: 4, 130: 5, 132: 4, 136: 2, 145: 4, 147: 4, 151: 4, 152: 4, 156: 2, 161: 3, 162: 3, 165: 3, 168: 4, 169: 3, 172: 3, 180: 4, 184: 5, 187: 5, 188: 4, 191: 3, 194: 4, 202: 5, 203: 6, 206: 2, 207: 3, 215: 2, 217: 3, 218: 8, 220: 2, 221: 2, 222: 5, 227: 5, 229: 3, 234: 5, 235: 2, 241: 2, 242: 2, 243: 4, 244: 4, 245: 4, 248: 4, 250: 4, 258: 11, 262: 4, 263: 5, 264: 3, 267: 4, 270: 3, 272: 3, 273: 5, 287: 3, 289: 3, 291: 5, 299: 5, 300: 3, 304: 3, 309: 3, 314: 2, 315: 3, 320: 4, 323: 4, 327: 4, 328: 3, 329: 2, 330: 10, 334: 2, 335: 3, 341: 5, 342: 6, 347: 5, 348: 5, 350: 7, 351: 5, 352: 3, 353: 3, 354: 2, 358: 4, 365: 3, 366: 2, 371: 7, 372: 5, 384: 5, 385: 4, 386: 3, 387: 3, 392: 3, 393: 4, 396: 6, 397: 7, 398: 6, 402: 3} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 6 "In the abstract, the results of either distributed signaling or centralized provisioning are equivalent from a DetNet data plane perspective - flows are instantiated, explicit routes are determined, resources are reserved, and packets are forwarded through the domain using the DetNet native data plane." "Branch for review Merge it ! Changes look good - clicking correct button this time" 215d293ca11d1a96b10664fe5db5be2326ffc8d9 215d293ca11d1a96b10664fe5db5be2326ffc8d9 draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework 06fe2000420d480393da592c2653f7f98d7c0f36878b8b325f2d68dea40f01d7 ['eb15bedf6c9fcf82726e5190d9320b0300d5f7eecbe2a3517e7a9edcbb5a44ef', '9668b20321bdb23cd40fbb966469ce0126f928d1f2da7167288c51db9621e4b5', '4a231ab7500e5c2b585abd87b038cb6ad2cb7a4854e98101c4b0c516b6eab72e', '06fe2000420d480393da592c2653f7f98d7c0f36878b8b325f2d68dea40f01d7', 'b834d3cd9d9bf25950ef1aeacca30077c00c5a3e4d8f4a6545b4a46126fd6065', '9ef3cabc128f32e0ef6fc1a66d6c56656a92fb160aad577f3ed1bbd6b7e797f6', '35a05496fb2ca4f3140d51e84bfcf5e48622258574814599c5dc87ad85f0cc1f', '5ddad1f32bf8b0d56c9a65fdd9727cf7dce98a76f125ef116d277bfb33169112', 'b3c79c333e47859d7a67139de9f5f889c30424df8e7b3f629712649df38292f3', '4ba0f06073bb720e9caf4edfb97ead6da456d0a63e88705743ab3006b21c224c', 'c98d52f719106d13b14f27abde81ce00305cbf62889690b72da3e3ddc0286c02'] B "in the abstract, the results of either distributed signaling or centralized provisioning are equivalent from a detnet data plane perspective - flows are instantiated, explicit routes are determined, resources are reserved, and packets are forwarded through the domain using the detnet native data plane." {8: 1, 31: 1, 53: 1, 6: 2, 79: 2, 90: 3, 51: 3, 130: 2, 62: 5, 85: 5, 68: 4, 35: 3, 110: 3, 91: 5, 114: 3, 97: 3, 13: 3, 67: 3, 38: 4, 26: 3, 124: 3, 98: 2, 54: 2, 127: 3, 96: 3, 64: 2, 30: 4, 61: 5, 55: 3, 27: 4, 15: 3, 52: 2, 129: 3, 115: 3, 84: 3, 76: 6, 87: 3, 131: 5, 102: 3, 113: 5, 99: 2, 36: 3, 24: 2, 72: 4} {120: 1, 154: 1, 224: 1, 369: 1, 1: 9, 4: 2, 9: 5, 10: 3, 15: 3, 24: 2, 25: 5, 26: 5, 27: 3, 39: 5, 43: 3, 49: 6, 50: 5, 58: 5, 59: 2, 64: 3, 69: 4, 81: 6, 82: 4, 86: 3, 96: 4, 97: 3, 100: 7, 108: 3, 109: 4, 110: 4, 111: 2, 114: 3, 115: 4, 116: 3, 118: 6, 119: 5, 121: 4, 122: 4, 123: 3, 124: 4, 128: 4, 129: 4, 130: 5, 132: 4, 136: 2, 145: 4, 147: 4, 151: 4, 152: 4, 156: 2, 161: 3, 162: 3, 165: 3, 168: 4, 169: 3, 172: 3, 180: 4, 184: 5, 187: 5, 188: 4, 191: 3, 194: 4, 202: 5, 203: 6, 206: 2, 207: 3, 215: 2, 217: 3, 218: 8, 220: 2, 221: 2, 222: 5, 227: 5, 229: 3, 234: 5, 235: 2, 241: 2, 242: 2, 243: 4, 244: 4, 245: 4, 248: 4, 250: 4, 258: 11, 262: 4, 263: 5, 264: 3, 267: 4, 270: 3, 272: 3, 273: 5, 287: 3, 289: 3, 291: 5, 299: 5, 300: 3, 304: 3, 309: 3, 314: 2, 315: 3, 320: 4, 323: 4, 327: 4, 328: 3, 329: 2, 330: 10, 334: 2, 335: 3, 341: 5, 342: 6, 347: 5, 348: 5, 350: 7, 351: 5, 352: 3, 353: 3, 354: 2, 358: 4, 365: 3, 366: 2, 371: 7, 372: 5, 384: 5, 385: 4, 386: 3, 387: 3, 392: 3, 393: 4, 396: 6, 397: 7, 398: 6, 402: 3} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 6 "sec_dt_dp introduces the use of the IP ""6-tuple"" for flow identification, and goes on to discuss how identified flows use specific QoS mechanisms for flow-specific traffic treatment, including path control and resource allocation. XXX contains detailed DetNet IP flow identification procedures. Flow identification will play an important role for the DetNet controller plane." "Branch for review Merge it ! Changes look good - clicking correct button this time" 215d293ca11d1a96b10664fe5db5be2326ffc8d9 215d293ca11d1a96b10664fe5db5be2326ffc8d9 draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework a115768876068db59e90a07e4e3ec97070d132d15469b911e099eda942811a0a ['dfcc76a78254ff5a85ebf0849a9ff913a148bf395612b587cf05437802854848', 'a115768876068db59e90a07e4e3ec97070d132d15469b911e099eda942811a0a', 'cb31aed3689ff20cfbfe39008b9fdc1b470296aa4ddc52ce115f00911c07da10', 'f88064cffabc89fb4e6ef3f38019f6344961042aa315894ebe2f758b3d5ca818', '261f5b4a758c447bdb1af815a4821f55f8d5e0402b55333766adbd5a0a5e2d21', '5577ff2e6cd333fe14d9a81dbd205ba9fefb3a2cf6e4f292211c12566f66f5f7', '3aa4a2a90ebad10aea6bac0e1dcaae561f6f9322c3aa66bc7cf6182ca5325f98', '571384dfef68c1334e9c77647556a20dc5c98909cda47416a73c4a95e4490b63', '67af30b1ae114f932f547be0c6e4b7e6cc3a155b9c279a4a0168de58401688c5'] A "sec_dt_dp introduces the use of the ip ""6-tuple"" for flow identification, and goes on to discuss how identified flows use specific qos mechanisms for flow-specific traffic treatment, including path control and resource allocation. xxx contains detailed detnet ip flow identification procedures. flow identification will play an important role for the detnet controller plane." {8: 1, 90: 3, 84: 2, 31: 2, 55: 2} {89: 1, 138: 1, 226: 1, 101: 3, 409: 2, 107: 2, 338: 2, 211: 2} {226, 101, 360, 409, 107, 138, 338, 211, 89} 6 "XXX and YYY discuss the use of flow aggregation in DetNet. Flow aggregation can be accomplished using any of the 6-tuple fields defined in XXX , using a DSCP identified traffic class or other field. It will be the responsibility of the DetNet controller plane to be able to properly provision the use of these aggregation mechanisms. These requirements are included in control-management- requirements." "Branch for review Merge it ! Changes look good - clicking correct button this time" 215d293ca11d1a96b10664fe5db5be2326ffc8d9 215d293ca11d1a96b10664fe5db5be2326ffc8d9 draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework dfcc76a78254ff5a85ebf0849a9ff913a148bf395612b587cf05437802854848 ['dfcc76a78254ff5a85ebf0849a9ff913a148bf395612b587cf05437802854848', 'a115768876068db59e90a07e4e3ec97070d132d15469b911e099eda942811a0a', 'cb31aed3689ff20cfbfe39008b9fdc1b470296aa4ddc52ce115f00911c07da10', 'f88064cffabc89fb4e6ef3f38019f6344961042aa315894ebe2f758b3d5ca818', '261f5b4a758c447bdb1af815a4821f55f8d5e0402b55333766adbd5a0a5e2d21', '5577ff2e6cd333fe14d9a81dbd205ba9fefb3a2cf6e4f292211c12566f66f5f7', '3aa4a2a90ebad10aea6bac0e1dcaae561f6f9322c3aa66bc7cf6182ca5325f98', '571384dfef68c1334e9c77647556a20dc5c98909cda47416a73c4a95e4490b63', '67af30b1ae114f932f547be0c6e4b7e6cc3a155b9c279a4a0168de58401688c5'] A "xxx and yyy discuss the use of flow aggregation in detnet. flow aggregation can be accomplished using any of the 6-tuple fields defined in xxx , using a dscp identified traffic class or other field. it will be the responsibility of the detnet controller plane to be able to properly provision the use of these aggregation mechanisms. these requirements are included in control-management- requirements." {8: 1, 90: 3, 84: 2, 31: 2, 55: 2} {89: 1, 138: 1, 226: 1, 101: 3, 409: 2, 107: 2, 338: 2, 211: 2} {226, 101, 360, 409, 107, 138, 338, 211, 89} 6 "Explicit routes are used to ensure that packets are routed through the resources that have been reserved for them, and hence provide the DetNet application with the required service. A requirement for the DetNet Controller Plane will be the ability to assign a particular identified DetNet IP flow to a path through the DetNet domain that has been assigned the required nodal resources to provide the appropriate traffic treatment for the flow, and also to include particular links as a part of the path that are able to support the DetNet flow, for example by using IEEE 802.1 TSN links (as discussed in XXX ). Further considerations and requirements for the DetNet Controller Plane are discussed in control-management-requirements." "Branch for review Merge it ! Changes look good - clicking correct button this time" 215d293ca11d1a96b10664fe5db5be2326ffc8d9 215d293ca11d1a96b10664fe5db5be2326ffc8d9 draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework f88064cffabc89fb4e6ef3f38019f6344961042aa315894ebe2f758b3d5ca818 ['dfcc76a78254ff5a85ebf0849a9ff913a148bf395612b587cf05437802854848', 'a115768876068db59e90a07e4e3ec97070d132d15469b911e099eda942811a0a', 'cb31aed3689ff20cfbfe39008b9fdc1b470296aa4ddc52ce115f00911c07da10', 'f88064cffabc89fb4e6ef3f38019f6344961042aa315894ebe2f758b3d5ca818', '261f5b4a758c447bdb1af815a4821f55f8d5e0402b55333766adbd5a0a5e2d21', '5577ff2e6cd333fe14d9a81dbd205ba9fefb3a2cf6e4f292211c12566f66f5f7', '3aa4a2a90ebad10aea6bac0e1dcaae561f6f9322c3aa66bc7cf6182ca5325f98', '571384dfef68c1334e9c77647556a20dc5c98909cda47416a73c4a95e4490b63', '67af30b1ae114f932f547be0c6e4b7e6cc3a155b9c279a4a0168de58401688c5'] A "explicit routes are used to ensure that packets are routed through the resources that have been reserved for them, and hence provide the detnet application with the required service. a requirement for the detnet controller plane will be the ability to assign a particular identified detnet ip flow to a path through the detnet domain that has been assigned the required nodal resources to provide the appropriate traffic treatment for the flow, and also to include particular links as a part of the path that are able to support the detnet flow, for example by using ieee 802.1 tsn links (as discussed in xxx ). further considerations and requirements for the detnet controller plane are discussed in control-management-requirements." {8: 1, 90: 3, 84: 2, 31: 2, 55: 2} {89: 1, 138: 1, 226: 1, 101: 3, 409: 2, 107: 2, 338: 2, 211: 2} {226, 101, 360, 409, 107, 138, 338, 211, 89} 6 "Flow aggregation includes aggregation accomplished through the use of hierarchical LSPs in MPLS and tunnels, in the case of IP, MPLS and TSN, both of which aggregate multiple DetNet flows into a single new DetNet flow. It can also be grouping of IP flows that share 5-tuple of 6-tuple attributes or flow identifiers at the DetNet layer." "Branch for review Merge it ! Changes look good - clicking correct button this time" 215d293ca11d1a96b10664fe5db5be2326ffc8d9 215d293ca11d1a96b10664fe5db5be2326ffc8d9 draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework 3aa4a2a90ebad10aea6bac0e1dcaae561f6f9322c3aa66bc7cf6182ca5325f98 ['dfcc76a78254ff5a85ebf0849a9ff913a148bf395612b587cf05437802854848', 'a115768876068db59e90a07e4e3ec97070d132d15469b911e099eda942811a0a', 'cb31aed3689ff20cfbfe39008b9fdc1b470296aa4ddc52ce115f00911c07da10', 'f88064cffabc89fb4e6ef3f38019f6344961042aa315894ebe2f758b3d5ca818', '261f5b4a758c447bdb1af815a4821f55f8d5e0402b55333766adbd5a0a5e2d21', '5577ff2e6cd333fe14d9a81dbd205ba9fefb3a2cf6e4f292211c12566f66f5f7', '3aa4a2a90ebad10aea6bac0e1dcaae561f6f9322c3aa66bc7cf6182ca5325f98', '571384dfef68c1334e9c77647556a20dc5c98909cda47416a73c4a95e4490b63', '67af30b1ae114f932f547be0c6e4b7e6cc3a155b9c279a4a0168de58401688c5'] B "flow aggregation includes aggregation accomplished through the use of hierarchical lsps in mpls and tunnels, in the case of ip, mpls and tsn, both of which aggregate multiple detnet flows into a single new detnet flow. it can also be grouping of ip flows that share 5-tuple of 6-tuple attributes or flow identifiers at the detnet layer." {8: 1, 90: 3, 84: 2, 31: 2, 55: 2} {89: 1, 138: 1, 226: 1, 101: 3, 409: 2, 107: 2, 338: 2, 211: 2} {226, 101, 360, 409, 107, 138, 338, 211, 89} 6 "Available resources are tracked through control plane or management plane databases and distributed amongst controllers or nodes that can manage resources." "Branch for review Merge it ! Changes look good - clicking correct button this time" 215d293ca11d1a96b10664fe5db5be2326ffc8d9 215d293ca11d1a96b10664fe5db5be2326ffc8d9 draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework cb31aed3689ff20cfbfe39008b9fdc1b470296aa4ddc52ce115f00911c07da10 ['dfcc76a78254ff5a85ebf0849a9ff913a148bf395612b587cf05437802854848', 'a115768876068db59e90a07e4e3ec97070d132d15469b911e099eda942811a0a', 'cb31aed3689ff20cfbfe39008b9fdc1b470296aa4ddc52ce115f00911c07da10', 'f88064cffabc89fb4e6ef3f38019f6344961042aa315894ebe2f758b3d5ca818', '261f5b4a758c447bdb1af815a4821f55f8d5e0402b55333766adbd5a0a5e2d21', '5577ff2e6cd333fe14d9a81dbd205ba9fefb3a2cf6e4f292211c12566f66f5f7', '3aa4a2a90ebad10aea6bac0e1dcaae561f6f9322c3aa66bc7cf6182ca5325f98', '571384dfef68c1334e9c77647556a20dc5c98909cda47416a73c4a95e4490b63', '67af30b1ae114f932f547be0c6e4b7e6cc3a155b9c279a4a0168de58401688c5'] B "available resources are tracked through control plane or management plane databases and distributed amongst controllers or nodes that can manage resources." {8: 1, 90: 3, 84: 2, 31: 2, 55: 2} {89: 1, 138: 1, 226: 1, 101: 3, 409: 2, 107: 2, 338: 2, 211: 2} {226, 101, 360, 409, 107, 138, 338, 211, 89} 6 "When DetNet services are provisioned or requested one or more paths meeting the requirements are selected and the resources verified and if successful recorded in the databases." "Branch for review Merge it ! Changes look good - clicking correct button this time" 215d293ca11d1a96b10664fe5db5be2326ffc8d9 215d293ca11d1a96b10664fe5db5be2326ffc8d9 draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework 5577ff2e6cd333fe14d9a81dbd205ba9fefb3a2cf6e4f292211c12566f66f5f7 ['dfcc76a78254ff5a85ebf0849a9ff913a148bf395612b587cf05437802854848', 'a115768876068db59e90a07e4e3ec97070d132d15469b911e099eda942811a0a', 'cb31aed3689ff20cfbfe39008b9fdc1b470296aa4ddc52ce115f00911c07da10', 'f88064cffabc89fb4e6ef3f38019f6344961042aa315894ebe2f758b3d5ca818', '261f5b4a758c447bdb1af815a4821f55f8d5e0402b55333766adbd5a0a5e2d21', '5577ff2e6cd333fe14d9a81dbd205ba9fefb3a2cf6e4f292211c12566f66f5f7', '3aa4a2a90ebad10aea6bac0e1dcaae561f6f9322c3aa66bc7cf6182ca5325f98', '571384dfef68c1334e9c77647556a20dc5c98909cda47416a73c4a95e4490b63', '67af30b1ae114f932f547be0c6e4b7e6cc3a155b9c279a4a0168de58401688c5'] B "when detnet services are provisioned or requested one or more paths meeting the requirements are selected and the resources verified and if successful recorded in the databases." {8: 1, 90: 3, 84: 2, 31: 2, 55: 2} {89: 1, 138: 1, 226: 1, 101: 3, 409: 2, 107: 2, 338: 2, 211: 2} {226, 101, 360, 409, 107, 138, 338, 211, 89} 6 "The assignment of resources depends on the technology and it includes assignment of specific links and coordination of the queuing and other traffic management capabilities." "Branch for review Merge it ! Changes look good - clicking correct button this time" 215d293ca11d1a96b10664fe5db5be2326ffc8d9 215d293ca11d1a96b10664fe5db5be2326ffc8d9 draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework 67af30b1ae114f932f547be0c6e4b7e6cc3a155b9c279a4a0168de58401688c5 ['dfcc76a78254ff5a85ebf0849a9ff913a148bf395612b587cf05437802854848', 'a115768876068db59e90a07e4e3ec97070d132d15469b911e099eda942811a0a', 'cb31aed3689ff20cfbfe39008b9fdc1b470296aa4ddc52ce115f00911c07da10', 'f88064cffabc89fb4e6ef3f38019f6344961042aa315894ebe2f758b3d5ca818', '261f5b4a758c447bdb1af815a4821f55f8d5e0402b55333766adbd5a0a5e2d21', '5577ff2e6cd333fe14d9a81dbd205ba9fefb3a2cf6e4f292211c12566f66f5f7', '3aa4a2a90ebad10aea6bac0e1dcaae561f6f9322c3aa66bc7cf6182ca5325f98', '571384dfef68c1334e9c77647556a20dc5c98909cda47416a73c4a95e4490b63', '67af30b1ae114f932f547be0c6e4b7e6cc3a155b9c279a4a0168de58401688c5'] B "the assignment of resources depends on the technology and it includes assignment of specific links and coordination of the queuing and other traffic management capabilities." {8: 1, 90: 3, 84: 2, 31: 2, 55: 2} {89: 1, 138: 1, 226: 1, 101: 3, 409: 2, 107: 2, 338: 2, 211: 2} {226, 101, 360, 409, 107, 138, 338, 211, 89} 6 "Depending on the specific technology the assigned resources are updated in the databases preventing oversubscription." "Branch for review Merge it ! Changes look good - clicking correct button this time" 215d293ca11d1a96b10664fe5db5be2326ffc8d9 215d293ca11d1a96b10664fe5db5be2326ffc8d9 draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework 261f5b4a758c447bdb1af815a4821f55f8d5e0402b55333766adbd5a0a5e2d21 ['dfcc76a78254ff5a85ebf0849a9ff913a148bf395612b587cf05437802854848', 'a115768876068db59e90a07e4e3ec97070d132d15469b911e099eda942811a0a', 'cb31aed3689ff20cfbfe39008b9fdc1b470296aa4ddc52ce115f00911c07da10', 'f88064cffabc89fb4e6ef3f38019f6344961042aa315894ebe2f758b3d5ca818', '261f5b4a758c447bdb1af815a4821f55f8d5e0402b55333766adbd5a0a5e2d21', '5577ff2e6cd333fe14d9a81dbd205ba9fefb3a2cf6e4f292211c12566f66f5f7', '3aa4a2a90ebad10aea6bac0e1dcaae561f6f9322c3aa66bc7cf6182ca5325f98', '571384dfef68c1334e9c77647556a20dc5c98909cda47416a73c4a95e4490b63', '67af30b1ae114f932f547be0c6e4b7e6cc3a155b9c279a4a0168de58401688c5'] B "depending on the specific technology the assigned resources are updated in the databases preventing oversubscription." {8: 1, 90: 3, 84: 2, 31: 2, 55: 2} {89: 1, 138: 1, 226: 1, 101: 3, 409: 2, 107: 2, 338: 2, 211: 2} {226, 101, 360, 409, 107, 138, 338, 211, 89} 6 "Explicit routes are used to ensure that packets are routed through the resources that have been reserved for them, and hence provide the DetNet application with the required service. A requirement for the DetNet Controller Plane will be the ability to assign a particular identified DetNet IP flow to a path through the DetNet domain that has been assigned the required nodal resources. This provides the appropriate traffic treatment for the flow and also includes particular links as a part of the path that are able to support the DetNet flow. For example, by using IEEE 802.1 TSN links (as discussed in XXX ) DetNet parameters can be maintained. Further considerations and requirements for the DetNet Controller Plane are discussed in control-management-requirements." "Branch for review Merge it ! Changes look good - clicking correct button this time" 215d293ca11d1a96b10664fe5db5be2326ffc8d9 215d293ca11d1a96b10664fe5db5be2326ffc8d9 draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework 571384dfef68c1334e9c77647556a20dc5c98909cda47416a73c4a95e4490b63 ['dfcc76a78254ff5a85ebf0849a9ff913a148bf395612b587cf05437802854848', 'a115768876068db59e90a07e4e3ec97070d132d15469b911e099eda942811a0a', 'cb31aed3689ff20cfbfe39008b9fdc1b470296aa4ddc52ce115f00911c07da10', 'f88064cffabc89fb4e6ef3f38019f6344961042aa315894ebe2f758b3d5ca818', '261f5b4a758c447bdb1af815a4821f55f8d5e0402b55333766adbd5a0a5e2d21', '5577ff2e6cd333fe14d9a81dbd205ba9fefb3a2cf6e4f292211c12566f66f5f7', '3aa4a2a90ebad10aea6bac0e1dcaae561f6f9322c3aa66bc7cf6182ca5325f98', '571384dfef68c1334e9c77647556a20dc5c98909cda47416a73c4a95e4490b63', '67af30b1ae114f932f547be0c6e4b7e6cc3a155b9c279a4a0168de58401688c5'] B "explicit routes are used to ensure that packets are routed through the resources that have been reserved for them, and hence provide the detnet application with the required service. a requirement for the detnet controller plane will be the ability to assign a particular identified detnet ip flow to a path through the detnet domain that has been assigned the required nodal resources. this provides the appropriate traffic treatment for the flow and also includes particular links as a part of the path that are able to support the detnet flow. for example, by using ieee 802.1 tsn links (as discussed in xxx ) detnet parameters can be maintained. further considerations and requirements for the detnet controller plane are discussed in control-management-requirements." {8: 1, 90: 3, 84: 2, 31: 2, 55: 2} {89: 1, 138: 1, 226: 1, 101: 3, 409: 2, 107: 2, 338: 2, 211: 2} {226, 101, 360, 409, 107, 138, 338, 211, 89} 6 "The path could be used a distributed control plane such as RFC2205 or RSVP-TE RFC3473 extended to support DetNet IP flows." "Branch for review Merge it ! Changes look good - clicking correct button this time" 215d293ca11d1a96b10664fe5db5be2326ffc8d9 215d293ca11d1a96b10664fe5db5be2326ffc8d9 draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework df8cfa560d5e0957ca76388bdc8153de40bfba6f6424a56ef64ca498c045e64b ['df8cfa560d5e0957ca76388bdc8153de40bfba6f6424a56ef64ca498c045e64b', '0f3ffa0cef26929b24288a7a11d191368182ba9a981709e25cf9a543e799f3aa'] A "the path could be used a distributed control plane such as rfc2205 or rsvp-te rfc3473 extended to support detnet ip flows." {} {} {} 6 "The path could use a distributed control plane such as RFC2205 or RSVP-TE RFC3473 extended to support DetNet IP flows." "Branch for review Merge it ! Changes look good - clicking correct button this time" 215d293ca11d1a96b10664fe5db5be2326ffc8d9 215d293ca11d1a96b10664fe5db5be2326ffc8d9 draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework 0f3ffa0cef26929b24288a7a11d191368182ba9a981709e25cf9a543e799f3aa ['df8cfa560d5e0957ca76388bdc8153de40bfba6f6424a56ef64ca498c045e64b', '0f3ffa0cef26929b24288a7a11d191368182ba9a981709e25cf9a543e799f3aa'] B "the path could use a distributed control plane such as rfc2205 or rsvp-te rfc3473 extended to support detnet ip flows." {} {} {} 6 "As discussed in sec_intro, this document does not specify the mechanisms needed to eliminate contention loss or reduce jitter for DetNet flows at the DetNet forwarding sub-layer. The ability to manage node and link resources to be able to provide these functions will be a necessary part of the DetNet controller plane. It will also be necessary to be able to control the required queuing mechanisms used to provide these functions along a flow's path through the network. See XXX and control-management-requirements for further discussion of these requirements." "Branch for review Merge it ! Changes look good - clicking correct button this time" 215d293ca11d1a96b10664fe5db5be2326ffc8d9 215d293ca11d1a96b10664fe5db5be2326ffc8d9 draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework 307f36c610eacd60ea90cf1540859331d0d04730dbc28d7c9a1cbaa746d780e5 ['c17efa863a8efd1106e92fd2a304456fe1964f3cdfc9d34f7d3aece6237b85cb', '307f36c610eacd60ea90cf1540859331d0d04730dbc28d7c9a1cbaa746d780e5', 'dcc7b98c8bedb18fdf3e2a9055c82a6d629724e0bb0b589d6472a6eb1b1bacf1', '3dbc3f101d3d88b68be774bbd790b9cd13a3f496a24f88d083c53c304583e595'] A "as discussed in sec_intro, this document does not specify the mechanisms needed to eliminate contention loss or reduce jitter for detnet flows at the detnet forwarding sub-layer. the ability to manage node and link resources to be able to provide these functions will be a necessary part of the detnet controller plane. it will also be necessary to be able to control the required queuing mechanisms used to provide these functions along a flow's path through the network. see xxx and control-management-requirements for further discussion of these requirements." {68: 1, 8: 1} {98: 1, 148: 1} {98, 148, 301} 6 "Some DetNet applications generate bidirectional traffic. Although this document discusses the DetNet IP data plane, MPLS definitions RFC5654 are useful to illustrate terms such as associated bidirectional flows and co-routed bidirectional flows. MPLS defines a point-to-point associated bidirectional LSP as consisting of two unidirectional point-to-point LSPs, one from A to B and the other from B to A, which are regarded as providing a single logical bidirectional forwarding path. This is analogous to standard IP routing. MPLS defines a point-to-point co-routed bidirectional LSP as an associated bidirectional LSP which satisfies the additional constraint that its two unidirectional component LSPs follow the same path (in terms of both nodes and links) in both directions. An important property of co-routed bidirectional LSPs is that their unidirectional component LSPs share fate. In both types of bidirectional LSPs, resource reservations may differ in each direction. The concepts of associated bidirectional flows and co- routed bidirectional flows can also be applied to DetNet IP flows." "Branch for review Merge it ! Changes look good - clicking correct button this time" 215d293ca11d1a96b10664fe5db5be2326ffc8d9 215d293ca11d1a96b10664fe5db5be2326ffc8d9 draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework 3dbc3f101d3d88b68be774bbd790b9cd13a3f496a24f88d083c53c304583e595 ['c17efa863a8efd1106e92fd2a304456fe1964f3cdfc9d34f7d3aece6237b85cb', '307f36c610eacd60ea90cf1540859331d0d04730dbc28d7c9a1cbaa746d780e5', 'dcc7b98c8bedb18fdf3e2a9055c82a6d629724e0bb0b589d6472a6eb1b1bacf1', '3dbc3f101d3d88b68be774bbd790b9cd13a3f496a24f88d083c53c304583e595'] A "some detnet applications generate bidirectional traffic. although this document discusses the detnet ip data plane, mpls definitions rfc5654 are useful to illustrate terms such as associated bidirectional flows and co-routed bidirectional flows. mpls defines a point-to-point associated bidirectional lsp as consisting of two unidirectional point-to-point lsps, one from a to b and the other from b to a, which are regarded as providing a single logical bidirectional forwarding path. this is analogous to standard ip routing. mpls defines a point-to-point co-routed bidirectional lsp as an associated bidirectional lsp which satisfies the additional constraint that its two unidirectional component lsps follow the same path (in terms of both nodes and links) in both directions. an important property of co-routed bidirectional lsps is that their unidirectional component lsps share fate. in both types of bidirectional lsps, resource reservations may differ in each direction. the concepts of associated bidirectional flows and co- routed bidirectional flows can also be applied to detnet ip flows." {68: 1, 8: 1} {98: 1, 148: 1} {98, 148, 301} 6 "As discussed in sec_intro, this document does not specify the mechanisms needed to eliminate packet contention, packet loss or reduce jitter for DetNet flows at the DetNet forwarding sub-layer. The ability to manage node and link resources to be able to provide these functions is a necessary part of the DetNet controller plane. It is also necessary to be able to control the required queuing mechanisms used to provide these functions along a flow's path through the network. See XXX and control-management-requirements for further discussion of these requirements." "Branch for review Merge it ! Changes look good - clicking correct button this time" 215d293ca11d1a96b10664fe5db5be2326ffc8d9 215d293ca11d1a96b10664fe5db5be2326ffc8d9 draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework dcc7b98c8bedb18fdf3e2a9055c82a6d629724e0bb0b589d6472a6eb1b1bacf1 ['c17efa863a8efd1106e92fd2a304456fe1964f3cdfc9d34f7d3aece6237b85cb', '307f36c610eacd60ea90cf1540859331d0d04730dbc28d7c9a1cbaa746d780e5', 'dcc7b98c8bedb18fdf3e2a9055c82a6d629724e0bb0b589d6472a6eb1b1bacf1', '3dbc3f101d3d88b68be774bbd790b9cd13a3f496a24f88d083c53c304583e595'] B "as discussed in sec_intro, this document does not specify the mechanisms needed to eliminate packet contention, packet loss or reduce jitter for detnet flows at the detnet forwarding sub-layer. the ability to manage node and link resources to be able to provide these functions is a necessary part of the detnet controller plane. it is also necessary to be able to control the required queuing mechanisms used to provide these functions along a flow's path through the network. see xxx and control-management-requirements for further discussion of these requirements." {68: 1, 8: 1} {98: 1, 148: 1} {98, 148, 301} 6 "DetNet applications typically generate bidirectional traffic. IP and MPLS typically treat each direction separately and do not force interdependence of each direction. MPLS has considered bidirectional traffic requirements and the MPLS definitions from RFC5654 are useful to illustrate terms such as associated bidirectional flows and co- routed bidirectional flows. MPLS defines a point-to-point associated bidirectional LSP as consisting of two unidirectional point-to-point LSPs, one from A to B and the other from B to A, which are regarded as providing a single logical bidirectional forwarding path. This is analogous to standard IP routing. MPLS defines a point-to-point co- routed bidirectional LSP as an associated bidirectional LSP which satisfies the additional constraint that its two unidirectional component LSPs follow the same path (in terms of both nodes and links) in both directions. An important property of co-routed bidirectional LSPs is that their unidirectional component LSPs share fate. In both types of bidirectional LSPs, resource reservations may differ in each direction. The concepts of associated bidirectional flows and co-routed bidirectional flows can also be applied to DetNet IP flows." "Branch for review Merge it ! Changes look good - clicking correct button this time" 215d293ca11d1a96b10664fe5db5be2326ffc8d9 215d293ca11d1a96b10664fe5db5be2326ffc8d9 draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework c17efa863a8efd1106e92fd2a304456fe1964f3cdfc9d34f7d3aece6237b85cb ['c17efa863a8efd1106e92fd2a304456fe1964f3cdfc9d34f7d3aece6237b85cb', '307f36c610eacd60ea90cf1540859331d0d04730dbc28d7c9a1cbaa746d780e5', 'dcc7b98c8bedb18fdf3e2a9055c82a6d629724e0bb0b589d6472a6eb1b1bacf1', '3dbc3f101d3d88b68be774bbd790b9cd13a3f496a24f88d083c53c304583e595'] B "detnet applications typically generate bidirectional traffic. ip and mpls typically treat each direction separately and do not force interdependence of each direction. mpls has considered bidirectional traffic requirements and the mpls definitions from rfc5654 are useful to illustrate terms such as associated bidirectional flows and co- routed bidirectional flows. mpls defines a point-to-point associated bidirectional lsp as consisting of two unidirectional point-to-point lsps, one from a to b and the other from b to a, which are regarded as providing a single logical bidirectional forwarding path. this is analogous to standard ip routing. mpls defines a point-to-point co- routed bidirectional lsp as an associated bidirectional lsp which satisfies the additional constraint that its two unidirectional component lsps follow the same path (in terms of both nodes and links) in both directions. an important property of co-routed bidirectional lsps is that their unidirectional component lsps share fate. in both types of bidirectional lsps, resource reservations may differ in each direction. the concepts of associated bidirectional flows and co-routed bidirectional flows can also be applied to detnet ip flows." {68: 1, 8: 1} {98: 1, 148: 1} {98, 148, 301} 6 "While the DetNet IP data plane must support bidirectional DetNet flows, there are no special bidirectional features with respect to the data plane other than the need for the two directions of a co- routed bidirectional flow to take the same path. That is to say that bidirectional DetNet flows are solely represented at the management and control plane levels, without specific support or knowledge within the DetNet data plane. Fate sharing and associated vs. co- routed bidirectional flows can be managed at the control level." "Branch for review Merge it ! Changes look good - clicking correct button this time" 215d293ca11d1a96b10664fe5db5be2326ffc8d9 215d293ca11d1a96b10664fe5db5be2326ffc8d9 draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework c50bdf09feb03ee8697f9c1765cc2036e122232be76434cd066f0f7829870bc6 ['2620263efce58dc9f5fe6736a2ae2284c5a7be9197bdcf799f2006df778020cb', '111151f984afd417c07e79a2c402dbba1832e057180c016ee22ca424c456da84', 'b7eec96f31ece03c832a8aa1ab4d4646ed055bfd86431893cb04ee5d0fb39332', 'c7c8a6ab1eecd50b92d6ed4a58ca6eabc241b9411ba5f0410b565a747aa481c9', 'eff158a7b9cde0fc2d07ede643f827e3f3a7ef0fc50b2442b55fa0352f659fe0', 'f324bf058c84826da1efc203ac93e10f18bc0fa32d40e5c35a418912306bc147', '9b8a5cc2cc27133f357e4a3daba603a992dd4592af13518ce58c981c7754bd44', 'fb0c731bd7571377301c09758c816f7a3d551f34216c72a7f74c3e0d1d555d87', 'd31679020e398f425f776f09c20dd0ca64c3e67081c00a8176e405ce4a7f2b9e', 'c50bdf09feb03ee8697f9c1765cc2036e122232be76434cd066f0f7829870bc6'] A "while the detnet ip data plane must support bidirectional detnet flows, there are no special bidirectional features with respect to the data plane other than the need for the two directions of a co- routed bidirectional flow to take the same path. that is to say that bidirectional detnet flows are solely represented at the management and control plane levels, without specific support or knowledge within the detnet data plane. fate sharing and associated vs. co- routed bidirectional flows can be managed at the control level." {31: 1, 8: 1, 35: 3} {144: 1, 55: 1, 362: 4, 48: 3, 177: 5, 340: 2, 251: 4} {362, 48, 144, 177, 340, 54, 55, 251} 6 "Control and management mechanisms will need to support bidirectional flows, but the specification of such mechanisms are out of scope of this document. An example control plane solution for MPLS can be found in RFC7551." "Branch for review Merge it ! Changes look good - clicking correct button this time" 215d293ca11d1a96b10664fe5db5be2326ffc8d9 215d293ca11d1a96b10664fe5db5be2326ffc8d9 draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework eff158a7b9cde0fc2d07ede643f827e3f3a7ef0fc50b2442b55fa0352f659fe0 ['2620263efce58dc9f5fe6736a2ae2284c5a7be9197bdcf799f2006df778020cb', '111151f984afd417c07e79a2c402dbba1832e057180c016ee22ca424c456da84', 'b7eec96f31ece03c832a8aa1ab4d4646ed055bfd86431893cb04ee5d0fb39332', 'c7c8a6ab1eecd50b92d6ed4a58ca6eabc241b9411ba5f0410b565a747aa481c9', 'eff158a7b9cde0fc2d07ede643f827e3f3a7ef0fc50b2442b55fa0352f659fe0', 'f324bf058c84826da1efc203ac93e10f18bc0fa32d40e5c35a418912306bc147', '9b8a5cc2cc27133f357e4a3daba603a992dd4592af13518ce58c981c7754bd44', 'fb0c731bd7571377301c09758c816f7a3d551f34216c72a7f74c3e0d1d555d87', 'd31679020e398f425f776f09c20dd0ca64c3e67081c00a8176e405ce4a7f2b9e', 'c50bdf09feb03ee8697f9c1765cc2036e122232be76434cd066f0f7829870bc6'] A "control and management mechanisms will need to support bidirectional flows, but the specification of such mechanisms are out of scope of this document. an example control plane solution for mpls can be found in rfc7551." {31: 1, 8: 1, 35: 3} {144: 1, 55: 1, 362: 4, 48: 3, 177: 5, 340: 2, 251: 4} {362, 48, 144, 177, 340, 54, 55, 251} 6 "Provision flow identification information at each of the nodes along the path, and it may differ depending on the location in the network and the DetNet functionality." "Branch for review Merge it ! Changes look good - clicking correct button this time" 215d293ca11d1a96b10664fe5db5be2326ffc8d9 215d293ca11d1a96b10664fe5db5be2326ffc8d9 draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework c7c8a6ab1eecd50b92d6ed4a58ca6eabc241b9411ba5f0410b565a747aa481c9 ['2620263efce58dc9f5fe6736a2ae2284c5a7be9197bdcf799f2006df778020cb', '111151f984afd417c07e79a2c402dbba1832e057180c016ee22ca424c456da84', 'b7eec96f31ece03c832a8aa1ab4d4646ed055bfd86431893cb04ee5d0fb39332', 'c7c8a6ab1eecd50b92d6ed4a58ca6eabc241b9411ba5f0410b565a747aa481c9', 'eff158a7b9cde0fc2d07ede643f827e3f3a7ef0fc50b2442b55fa0352f659fe0', 'f324bf058c84826da1efc203ac93e10f18bc0fa32d40e5c35a418912306bc147', '9b8a5cc2cc27133f357e4a3daba603a992dd4592af13518ce58c981c7754bd44', 'fb0c731bd7571377301c09758c816f7a3d551f34216c72a7f74c3e0d1d555d87', 'd31679020e398f425f776f09c20dd0ca64c3e67081c00a8176e405ce4a7f2b9e', 'c50bdf09feb03ee8697f9c1765cc2036e122232be76434cd066f0f7829870bc6'] A "provision flow identification information at each of the nodes along the path, and it may differ depending on the location in the network and the detnet functionality." {31: 1, 8: 1, 35: 3} {144: 1, 55: 1, 362: 4, 48: 3, 177: 5, 340: 2, 251: 4} {362, 48, 144, 177, 340, 54, 55, 251} 6 "These requirements, as stated earlier, could be satisfied using distributed control protocol signaling, centralized network management provisioning mechanisms, or hybrid combinations of the two, and could also make use of IPv6-based segment routing." "Branch for review Merge it ! Changes look good - clicking correct button this time" 215d293ca11d1a96b10664fe5db5be2326ffc8d9 215d293ca11d1a96b10664fe5db5be2326ffc8d9 draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework fb0c731bd7571377301c09758c816f7a3d551f34216c72a7f74c3e0d1d555d87 ['2620263efce58dc9f5fe6736a2ae2284c5a7be9197bdcf799f2006df778020cb', '111151f984afd417c07e79a2c402dbba1832e057180c016ee22ca424c456da84', 'b7eec96f31ece03c832a8aa1ab4d4646ed055bfd86431893cb04ee5d0fb39332', 'c7c8a6ab1eecd50b92d6ed4a58ca6eabc241b9411ba5f0410b565a747aa481c9', 'eff158a7b9cde0fc2d07ede643f827e3f3a7ef0fc50b2442b55fa0352f659fe0', 'f324bf058c84826da1efc203ac93e10f18bc0fa32d40e5c35a418912306bc147', '9b8a5cc2cc27133f357e4a3daba603a992dd4592af13518ce58c981c7754bd44', 'fb0c731bd7571377301c09758c816f7a3d551f34216c72a7f74c3e0d1d555d87', 'd31679020e398f425f776f09c20dd0ca64c3e67081c00a8176e405ce4a7f2b9e', 'c50bdf09feb03ee8697f9c1765cc2036e122232be76434cd066f0f7829870bc6'] A "these requirements, as stated earlier, could be satisfied using distributed control protocol signaling, centralized network management provisioning mechanisms, or hybrid combinations of the two, and could also make use of ipv6-based segment routing." {31: 1, 8: 1, 35: 3} {144: 1, 55: 1, 362: 4, 48: 3, 177: 5, 340: 2, 251: 4} {362, 48, 144, 177, 340, 54, 55, 251} 6 "In the abstract, the results of either distributed signaling or centralized provisioning are equivalent from a DetNet data plane perspective - flows are instantiated, explicit routes are determined, resources are reserved, and packets are forwarded through the domain using the IP data plane." "Branch for review Merge it ! Changes look good - clicking correct button this time" 215d293ca11d1a96b10664fe5db5be2326ffc8d9 215d293ca11d1a96b10664fe5db5be2326ffc8d9 draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework d31679020e398f425f776f09c20dd0ca64c3e67081c00a8176e405ce4a7f2b9e ['2620263efce58dc9f5fe6736a2ae2284c5a7be9197bdcf799f2006df778020cb', '111151f984afd417c07e79a2c402dbba1832e057180c016ee22ca424c456da84', 'b7eec96f31ece03c832a8aa1ab4d4646ed055bfd86431893cb04ee5d0fb39332', 'c7c8a6ab1eecd50b92d6ed4a58ca6eabc241b9411ba5f0410b565a747aa481c9', 'eff158a7b9cde0fc2d07ede643f827e3f3a7ef0fc50b2442b55fa0352f659fe0', 'f324bf058c84826da1efc203ac93e10f18bc0fa32d40e5c35a418912306bc147', '9b8a5cc2cc27133f357e4a3daba603a992dd4592af13518ce58c981c7754bd44', 'fb0c731bd7571377301c09758c816f7a3d551f34216c72a7f74c3e0d1d555d87', 'd31679020e398f425f776f09c20dd0ca64c3e67081c00a8176e405ce4a7f2b9e', 'c50bdf09feb03ee8697f9c1765cc2036e122232be76434cd066f0f7829870bc6'] A "in the abstract, the results of either distributed signaling or centralized provisioning are equivalent from a detnet data plane perspective - flows are instantiated, explicit routes are determined, resources are reserved, and packets are forwarded through the domain using the ip data plane." {31: 1, 8: 1, 35: 3} {144: 1, 55: 1, 362: 4, 48: 3, 177: 5, 340: 2, 251: 4} {362, 48, 144, 177, 340, 54, 55, 251} 6 "While the DetNet IP data plane must support bidirectional DetNet flows, there are no special bidirectional features with respect to the data plane other than the need for the two directions of a co- routed bidirectional flow to take the same path. That is to say that bidirectional DetNet flows are solely represented at the management and control plane levels, without specific support or knowledge within the DetNet data plane. Fate sharing and associated or co- routed bidirectional flows, can be managed at the control level." "Branch for review Merge it ! Changes look good - clicking correct button this time" 215d293ca11d1a96b10664fe5db5be2326ffc8d9 215d293ca11d1a96b10664fe5db5be2326ffc8d9 draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework 9b8a5cc2cc27133f357e4a3daba603a992dd4592af13518ce58c981c7754bd44 ['2620263efce58dc9f5fe6736a2ae2284c5a7be9197bdcf799f2006df778020cb', '111151f984afd417c07e79a2c402dbba1832e057180c016ee22ca424c456da84', 'b7eec96f31ece03c832a8aa1ab4d4646ed055bfd86431893cb04ee5d0fb39332', 'c7c8a6ab1eecd50b92d6ed4a58ca6eabc241b9411ba5f0410b565a747aa481c9', 'eff158a7b9cde0fc2d07ede643f827e3f3a7ef0fc50b2442b55fa0352f659fe0', 'f324bf058c84826da1efc203ac93e10f18bc0fa32d40e5c35a418912306bc147', '9b8a5cc2cc27133f357e4a3daba603a992dd4592af13518ce58c981c7754bd44', 'fb0c731bd7571377301c09758c816f7a3d551f34216c72a7f74c3e0d1d555d87', 'd31679020e398f425f776f09c20dd0ca64c3e67081c00a8176e405ce4a7f2b9e', 'c50bdf09feb03ee8697f9c1765cc2036e122232be76434cd066f0f7829870bc6'] B "while the detnet ip data plane must support bidirectional detnet flows, there are no special bidirectional features with respect to the data plane other than the need for the two directions of a co- routed bidirectional flow to take the same path. that is to say that bidirectional detnet flows are solely represented at the management and control plane levels, without specific support or knowledge within the detnet data plane. fate sharing and associated or co- routed bidirectional flows, can be managed at the control level." {31: 1, 8: 1, 35: 3} {144: 1, 55: 1, 362: 4, 48: 3, 177: 5, 340: 2, 251: 4} {362, 48, 144, 177, 340, 54, 55, 251} 6 "DetNet's use of PREOF may increase the complexity of using co-routing bidirectional flows, since if PREOF is used, then the replication points in one direction would have to match the elimination points in the other direction, and vice versa, and the optimal points for these functions in one direction may not match the optimal points in the other subsequent to the network and traffic constraints." "Branch for review Merge it ! Changes look good - clicking correct button this time" 215d293ca11d1a96b10664fe5db5be2326ffc8d9 215d293ca11d1a96b10664fe5db5be2326ffc8d9 draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework b7eec96f31ece03c832a8aa1ab4d4646ed055bfd86431893cb04ee5d0fb39332 ['2620263efce58dc9f5fe6736a2ae2284c5a7be9197bdcf799f2006df778020cb', '111151f984afd417c07e79a2c402dbba1832e057180c016ee22ca424c456da84', 'b7eec96f31ece03c832a8aa1ab4d4646ed055bfd86431893cb04ee5d0fb39332', 'c7c8a6ab1eecd50b92d6ed4a58ca6eabc241b9411ba5f0410b565a747aa481c9', 'eff158a7b9cde0fc2d07ede643f827e3f3a7ef0fc50b2442b55fa0352f659fe0', 'f324bf058c84826da1efc203ac93e10f18bc0fa32d40e5c35a418912306bc147', '9b8a5cc2cc27133f357e4a3daba603a992dd4592af13518ce58c981c7754bd44', 'fb0c731bd7571377301c09758c816f7a3d551f34216c72a7f74c3e0d1d555d87', 'd31679020e398f425f776f09c20dd0ca64c3e67081c00a8176e405ce4a7f2b9e', 'c50bdf09feb03ee8697f9c1765cc2036e122232be76434cd066f0f7829870bc6'] B "detnet's use of preof may increase the complexity of using co-routing bidirectional flows, since if preof is used, then the replication points in one direction would have to match the elimination points in the other direction, and vice versa, and the optimal points for these functions in one direction may not match the optimal points in the other subsequent to the network and traffic constraints." {31: 1, 8: 1, 35: 3} {144: 1, 55: 1, 362: 4, 48: 3, 177: 5, 340: 2, 251: 4} {362, 48, 144, 177, 340, 54, 55, 251} 6 "Control and management mechanisms need to support bidirectional flows, but the specification of such mechanisms are out of scope of this document. An example control plane solution for MPLS can be found in . Related control plan mechanisms have been defined in RFC3473 , RFC6387 and RFC7551." "Branch for review Merge it ! Changes look good - clicking correct button this time" 215d293ca11d1a96b10664fe5db5be2326ffc8d9 215d293ca11d1a96b10664fe5db5be2326ffc8d9 draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework 111151f984afd417c07e79a2c402dbba1832e057180c016ee22ca424c456da84 ['2620263efce58dc9f5fe6736a2ae2284c5a7be9197bdcf799f2006df778020cb', '111151f984afd417c07e79a2c402dbba1832e057180c016ee22ca424c456da84', 'b7eec96f31ece03c832a8aa1ab4d4646ed055bfd86431893cb04ee5d0fb39332', 'c7c8a6ab1eecd50b92d6ed4a58ca6eabc241b9411ba5f0410b565a747aa481c9', 'eff158a7b9cde0fc2d07ede643f827e3f3a7ef0fc50b2442b55fa0352f659fe0', 'f324bf058c84826da1efc203ac93e10f18bc0fa32d40e5c35a418912306bc147', '9b8a5cc2cc27133f357e4a3daba603a992dd4592af13518ce58c981c7754bd44', 'fb0c731bd7571377301c09758c816f7a3d551f34216c72a7f74c3e0d1d555d87', 'd31679020e398f425f776f09c20dd0ca64c3e67081c00a8176e405ce4a7f2b9e', 'c50bdf09feb03ee8697f9c1765cc2036e122232be76434cd066f0f7829870bc6'] B "control and management mechanisms need to support bidirectional flows, but the specification of such mechanisms are out of scope of this document. an example control plane solution for mpls can be found in . related control plan mechanisms have been defined in rfc3473 , rfc6387 and rfc7551." {31: 1, 8: 1, 35: 3} {144: 1, 55: 1, 362: 4, 48: 3, 177: 5, 340: 2, 251: 4} {362, 48, 144, 177, 340, 54, 55, 251} 6 "sec_dt_dp discussed the use of the IP ""6-tuple"" for flow identification, and goes on to discuss how identified flows use specific QoS mechanisms for flow-specific traffic treatment, including path control and resource allocation. XXX contains detailed DetNet IP flow identification procedures. Flow identification will play an important role for the DetNet controller plane." "Branch for review Merge it ! Changes look good - clicking correct button this time" 215d293ca11d1a96b10664fe5db5be2326ffc8d9 215d293ca11d1a96b10664fe5db5be2326ffc8d9 draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework f324bf058c84826da1efc203ac93e10f18bc0fa32d40e5c35a418912306bc147 ['2620263efce58dc9f5fe6736a2ae2284c5a7be9197bdcf799f2006df778020cb', '111151f984afd417c07e79a2c402dbba1832e057180c016ee22ca424c456da84', 'b7eec96f31ece03c832a8aa1ab4d4646ed055bfd86431893cb04ee5d0fb39332', 'c7c8a6ab1eecd50b92d6ed4a58ca6eabc241b9411ba5f0410b565a747aa481c9', 'eff158a7b9cde0fc2d07ede643f827e3f3a7ef0fc50b2442b55fa0352f659fe0', 'f324bf058c84826da1efc203ac93e10f18bc0fa32d40e5c35a418912306bc147', '9b8a5cc2cc27133f357e4a3daba603a992dd4592af13518ce58c981c7754bd44', 'fb0c731bd7571377301c09758c816f7a3d551f34216c72a7f74c3e0d1d555d87', 'd31679020e398f425f776f09c20dd0ca64c3e67081c00a8176e405ce4a7f2b9e', 'c50bdf09feb03ee8697f9c1765cc2036e122232be76434cd066f0f7829870bc6'] B "sec_dt_dp discussed the use of the ip ""6-tuple"" for flow identification, and goes on to discuss how identified flows use specific qos mechanisms for flow-specific traffic treatment, including path control and resource allocation. xxx contains detailed detnet ip flow identification procedures. flow identification will play an important role for the detnet controller plane." {31: 1, 8: 1, 35: 3} {144: 1, 55: 1, 362: 4, 48: 3, 177: 5, 340: 2, 251: 4} {362, 48, 144, 177, 340, 54, 55, 251} 6 "aggregation and ip-agg discuss the use of flow aggregation in DetNet. Flow aggregation can be accomplished using any of the 6-tuple fields defined in XXX , using a DSCP identified traffic class or other field. It will be the responsibility of the DetNet controller plane to be able to properly provision the use of these aggregation mechanisms. These requirements are included in control-management- requirements." "Branch for review Merge it ! Changes look good - clicking correct button this time" 215d293ca11d1a96b10664fe5db5be2326ffc8d9 215d293ca11d1a96b10664fe5db5be2326ffc8d9 draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework 2620263efce58dc9f5fe6736a2ae2284c5a7be9197bdcf799f2006df778020cb ['2620263efce58dc9f5fe6736a2ae2284c5a7be9197bdcf799f2006df778020cb', '111151f984afd417c07e79a2c402dbba1832e057180c016ee22ca424c456da84', 'b7eec96f31ece03c832a8aa1ab4d4646ed055bfd86431893cb04ee5d0fb39332', 'c7c8a6ab1eecd50b92d6ed4a58ca6eabc241b9411ba5f0410b565a747aa481c9', 'eff158a7b9cde0fc2d07ede643f827e3f3a7ef0fc50b2442b55fa0352f659fe0', 'f324bf058c84826da1efc203ac93e10f18bc0fa32d40e5c35a418912306bc147', '9b8a5cc2cc27133f357e4a3daba603a992dd4592af13518ce58c981c7754bd44', 'fb0c731bd7571377301c09758c816f7a3d551f34216c72a7f74c3e0d1d555d87', 'd31679020e398f425f776f09c20dd0ca64c3e67081c00a8176e405ce4a7f2b9e', 'c50bdf09feb03ee8697f9c1765cc2036e122232be76434cd066f0f7829870bc6'] B "aggregation and ip-agg discuss the use of flow aggregation in detnet. flow aggregation can be accomplished using any of the 6-tuple fields defined in xxx , using a dscp identified traffic class or other field. it will be the responsibility of the detnet controller plane to be able to properly provision the use of these aggregation mechanisms. these requirements are included in control-management- requirements." {31: 1, 8: 1, 35: 3} {144: 1, 55: 1, 362: 4, 48: 3, 177: 5, 340: 2, 251: 4} {362, 48, 144, 177, 340, 54, 55, 251} 6 "See mpls-control-management-requirements for further discussion of these alternatives." "Branch for review Merge it ! Changes look good - clicking correct button this time" 215d293ca11d1a96b10664fe5db5be2326ffc8d9 215d293ca11d1a96b10664fe5db5be2326ffc8d9 draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework 59a5efa234ce06803127a8494862891012409de7f9c7f283620bd65194ce5194 ['59a5efa234ce06803127a8494862891012409de7f9c7f283620bd65194ce5194'] A "see mpls-control-management-requirements for further discussion of these alternatives." {} {} {} 6 "Much like other MPLS labels, there are a number of alternatives available for DetNet S-Label and F-Label advertisement to an upstream peer node. These include distributed signaling protocols such as RSVP-TE, centralized label distribution via a controller that manages both the sender and the receiver using NETCONF/YANG, BGP, PCEP, etc., and hybrid combinations of the two. The details of the controller plane solution required for the label distribution and the management of the label number space are out of scope of this document, but as mentioned above, there are particular DetNet considerations and requirements that are discussed in mpls-control-management- requirements." "Branch for review Merge it ! Changes look good - clicking correct button this time" 215d293ca11d1a96b10664fe5db5be2326ffc8d9 215d293ca11d1a96b10664fe5db5be2326ffc8d9 draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework 62eac0ddf665ecae06f67410996b03951ba028d4043bc6c7731f6190642e569b ['838d6995de75202dfbb5dc645f97f15ce1ab507e7b77e143e9270761c6435bab', '62eac0ddf665ecae06f67410996b03951ba028d4043bc6c7731f6190642e569b'] A "much like other mpls labels, there are a number of alternatives available for detnet s-label and f-label advertisement to an upstream peer node. these include distributed signaling protocols such as rsvp-te, centralized label distribution via a controller that manages both the sender and the receiver using netconf/yang, bgp, pcep, etc., and hybrid combinations of the two. the details of the controller plane solution required for the label distribution and the management of the label number space are out of scope of this document, but as mentioned above, there are particular detnet considerations and requirements that are discussed in mpls-control-management- requirements." {} {} {} 6 "Much like other MPLS labels, there are a number of alternatives available for DetNet S-Label and F-Label advertisement to an upstream peer node. These include distributed signaling protocols such as RSVP-TE, centralized label distribution via a controller that manages both the sender and the receiver using NETCONF/YANG, BGP, PCEP, etc., and hybrid combinations of the two. The details of the controller plane solution required for the label distribution and the management of the label number space are out of scope of this document, but as mentioned above, there are particular DetNet considerations and requirements that are discussed in control-management-requirements." "Branch for review Merge it ! Changes look good - clicking correct button this time" 215d293ca11d1a96b10664fe5db5be2326ffc8d9 215d293ca11d1a96b10664fe5db5be2326ffc8d9 draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework 838d6995de75202dfbb5dc645f97f15ce1ab507e7b77e143e9270761c6435bab ['838d6995de75202dfbb5dc645f97f15ce1ab507e7b77e143e9270761c6435bab', '62eac0ddf665ecae06f67410996b03951ba028d4043bc6c7731f6190642e569b'] B "much like other mpls labels, there are a number of alternatives available for detnet s-label and f-label advertisement to an upstream peer node. these include distributed signaling protocols such as rsvp-te, centralized label distribution via a controller that manages both the sender and the receiver using netconf/yang, bgp, pcep, etc., and hybrid combinations of the two. the details of the controller plane solution required for the label distribution and the management of the label number space are out of scope of this document, but as mentioned above, there are particular detnet considerations and requirements that are discussed in control-management-requirements." {} {} {} 6 "through the network. See mpls-control-management-requirements for further discussion of these requirements." "Branch for review Merge it ! Changes look good - clicking correct button this time" 215d293ca11d1a96b10664fe5db5be2326ffc8d9 215d293ca11d1a96b10664fe5db5be2326ffc8d9 draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework d09382e429d6543f3683cc296aa3ad0a219f3f3590bf0563de588beb2d7f2373 ['d09382e429d6543f3683cc296aa3ad0a219f3f3590bf0563de588beb2d7f2373', 'e70f533a3e2b0a7fb7ea434b60883ac4cf28cb8120e29e86b49e9c4e4695f4be', 'df74b5643929ab3df88d284c4d25ac2cd3316bde08346c8b65420dc19a10bcb8', 'a0fe7dc24179010b2b0b4ec056bab6084d61a3ce4263406b181fb6cbb33d3e17', 'a04e07cac5c42185835082fe4b6bf9ae3c4e5af4bc1f32572878fafbdff3b70e', '71e29460eff988f6cf1fbddf850fd8e41ff9623ff4e87692f20b85400d3819d2', '9b9f9f1880d846f1a5b1affe56a6e5156ebfe57c964772c4a00332d1ef28515e', '401a90b238fec6aa223407cacba08c4bb54aa980d55894b483dc18e33f3e8a4c', 'd5288dc4ebe3ccaf22ae57edfb130c411e3e173cc9cfac0bd3ba87f85578af6c', '1b1d55d3d12bcd2148a9c545224f50fed57aef2aaca1f4753ebd07ccda2bba10', '26f572f54291ddf4522e8442305e61cee773f69e115cc0ccd324fe6eb3d5ed55', 'ed7f2afec011f1065396d9b1ac7edca70b228d0b2097aa29bbae62a07524ff9d'] A "through the network. see mpls-control-management-requirements for further discussion of these requirements." {} {} {} 6 There are still two bidirectional sections that need to be merged. "Branch for review Merge it ! Changes look good - clicking correct button this time" 215d293ca11d1a96b10664fe5db5be2326ffc8d9 215d293ca11d1a96b10664fe5db5be2326ffc8d9 draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework a04e07cac5c42185835082fe4b6bf9ae3c4e5af4bc1f32572878fafbdff3b70e ['d09382e429d6543f3683cc296aa3ad0a219f3f3590bf0563de588beb2d7f2373', 'e70f533a3e2b0a7fb7ea434b60883ac4cf28cb8120e29e86b49e9c4e4695f4be', 'df74b5643929ab3df88d284c4d25ac2cd3316bde08346c8b65420dc19a10bcb8', 'a0fe7dc24179010b2b0b4ec056bab6084d61a3ce4263406b181fb6cbb33d3e17', 'a04e07cac5c42185835082fe4b6bf9ae3c4e5af4bc1f32572878fafbdff3b70e', '71e29460eff988f6cf1fbddf850fd8e41ff9623ff4e87692f20b85400d3819d2', '9b9f9f1880d846f1a5b1affe56a6e5156ebfe57c964772c4a00332d1ef28515e', '401a90b238fec6aa223407cacba08c4bb54aa980d55894b483dc18e33f3e8a4c', 'd5288dc4ebe3ccaf22ae57edfb130c411e3e173cc9cfac0bd3ba87f85578af6c', '1b1d55d3d12bcd2148a9c545224f50fed57aef2aaca1f4753ebd07ccda2bba10', '26f572f54291ddf4522e8442305e61cee773f69e115cc0ccd324fe6eb3d5ed55', 'ed7f2afec011f1065396d9b1ac7edca70b228d0b2097aa29bbae62a07524ff9d'] A there are still two bidirectional sections that need to be merged. {} {} {} 6 "Some DetNet applications generate bidirectional traffic. Using MPLS definitions RFC5654 there are associated bidirectional flows, and co- routed bidirectional flows. MPLS defines a point-to-point associated bidirectional LSP as consisting of two unidirectional point-to-point LSPs, one from A to B and the other from B to A, which are regarded as providing a single logical bidirectional forwarding path. This would be analogous of standard IP routing, or PWs running over two reciprocal unidirection LSPs. MPLS defines a point-to-point co- routed bidirectional LSP as an associated bidirectional LSP which satisfies the additional constraint that its two unidirectional component LSPs follow the same path (in terms of both nodes and links) in both directions. An important property of co-routed bidirectional LSPs is that their unidirectional component LSPs share fate. In both types of bidirectional LSPs, resource reservations may differ in each direction. The concepts of associated bidirectional flows and co-routed bidirectional flows can be applied to DetNet flows." "Branch for review Merge it ! Changes look good - clicking correct button this time" 215d293ca11d1a96b10664fe5db5be2326ffc8d9 215d293ca11d1a96b10664fe5db5be2326ffc8d9 draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework 71e29460eff988f6cf1fbddf850fd8e41ff9623ff4e87692f20b85400d3819d2 ['d09382e429d6543f3683cc296aa3ad0a219f3f3590bf0563de588beb2d7f2373', 'e70f533a3e2b0a7fb7ea434b60883ac4cf28cb8120e29e86b49e9c4e4695f4be', 'df74b5643929ab3df88d284c4d25ac2cd3316bde08346c8b65420dc19a10bcb8', 'a0fe7dc24179010b2b0b4ec056bab6084d61a3ce4263406b181fb6cbb33d3e17', 'a04e07cac5c42185835082fe4b6bf9ae3c4e5af4bc1f32572878fafbdff3b70e', '71e29460eff988f6cf1fbddf850fd8e41ff9623ff4e87692f20b85400d3819d2', '9b9f9f1880d846f1a5b1affe56a6e5156ebfe57c964772c4a00332d1ef28515e', '401a90b238fec6aa223407cacba08c4bb54aa980d55894b483dc18e33f3e8a4c', 'd5288dc4ebe3ccaf22ae57edfb130c411e3e173cc9cfac0bd3ba87f85578af6c', '1b1d55d3d12bcd2148a9c545224f50fed57aef2aaca1f4753ebd07ccda2bba10', '26f572f54291ddf4522e8442305e61cee773f69e115cc0ccd324fe6eb3d5ed55', 'ed7f2afec011f1065396d9b1ac7edca70b228d0b2097aa29bbae62a07524ff9d'] A "some detnet applications generate bidirectional traffic. using mpls definitions rfc5654 there are associated bidirectional flows, and co- routed bidirectional flows. mpls defines a point-to-point associated bidirectional lsp as consisting of two unidirectional point-to-point lsps, one from a to b and the other from b to a, which are regarded as providing a single logical bidirectional forwarding path. this would be analogous of standard ip routing, or pws running over two reciprocal unidirection lsps. mpls defines a point-to-point co- routed bidirectional lsp as an associated bidirectional lsp which satisfies the additional constraint that its two unidirectional component lsps follow the same path (in terms of both nodes and links) in both directions. an important property of co-routed bidirectional lsps is that their unidirectional component lsps share fate. in both types of bidirectional lsps, resource reservations may differ in each direction. the concepts of associated bidirectional flows and co-routed bidirectional flows can be applied to detnet flows." {} {} {} 6 "While the MPLS data plane must support bidirectional DetNet flows, there are no special bidirectional features with respect to the data plane other than the need for the two directions of a co-routed bidirectional flow to take the same path. Fate sharing and associated vs co-routed bidirectional flows can be managed at the control level. Note that there is no stated requirement for bidirectional DetNet flows to be supported using the same MPLS Labels in each direction." "Branch for review Merge it ! Changes look good - clicking correct button this time" 215d293ca11d1a96b10664fe5db5be2326ffc8d9 215d293ca11d1a96b10664fe5db5be2326ffc8d9 draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework 26f572f54291ddf4522e8442305e61cee773f69e115cc0ccd324fe6eb3d5ed55 ['d09382e429d6543f3683cc296aa3ad0a219f3f3590bf0563de588beb2d7f2373', 'e70f533a3e2b0a7fb7ea434b60883ac4cf28cb8120e29e86b49e9c4e4695f4be', 'df74b5643929ab3df88d284c4d25ac2cd3316bde08346c8b65420dc19a10bcb8', 'a0fe7dc24179010b2b0b4ec056bab6084d61a3ce4263406b181fb6cbb33d3e17', 'a04e07cac5c42185835082fe4b6bf9ae3c4e5af4bc1f32572878fafbdff3b70e', '71e29460eff988f6cf1fbddf850fd8e41ff9623ff4e87692f20b85400d3819d2', '9b9f9f1880d846f1a5b1affe56a6e5156ebfe57c964772c4a00332d1ef28515e', '401a90b238fec6aa223407cacba08c4bb54aa980d55894b483dc18e33f3e8a4c', 'd5288dc4ebe3ccaf22ae57edfb130c411e3e173cc9cfac0bd3ba87f85578af6c', '1b1d55d3d12bcd2148a9c545224f50fed57aef2aaca1f4753ebd07ccda2bba10', '26f572f54291ddf4522e8442305e61cee773f69e115cc0ccd324fe6eb3d5ed55', 'ed7f2afec011f1065396d9b1ac7edca70b228d0b2097aa29bbae62a07524ff9d'] A "while the mpls data plane must support bidirectional detnet flows, there are no special bidirectional features with respect to the data plane other than the need for the two directions of a co-routed bidirectional flow to take the same path. fate sharing and associated vs co-routed bidirectional flows can be managed at the control level. note that there is no stated requirement for bidirectional detnet flows to be supported using the same mpls labels in each direction." {} {} {} 6 "DetNet's use of PREOF may increase the complexity of using co-routing bidirectional flows, since if PREOF is used, then the replication points in one direction would have to match the elimination points in the other direction, and vice versa, and the optimal points for these functions in one direction may not match the optimal points in the other." "Branch for review Merge it ! Changes look good - clicking correct button this time" 215d293ca11d1a96b10664fe5db5be2326ffc8d9 215d293ca11d1a96b10664fe5db5be2326ffc8d9 draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework d5288dc4ebe3ccaf22ae57edfb130c411e3e173cc9cfac0bd3ba87f85578af6c ['d09382e429d6543f3683cc296aa3ad0a219f3f3590bf0563de588beb2d7f2373', 'e70f533a3e2b0a7fb7ea434b60883ac4cf28cb8120e29e86b49e9c4e4695f4be', 'df74b5643929ab3df88d284c4d25ac2cd3316bde08346c8b65420dc19a10bcb8', 'a0fe7dc24179010b2b0b4ec056bab6084d61a3ce4263406b181fb6cbb33d3e17', 'a04e07cac5c42185835082fe4b6bf9ae3c4e5af4bc1f32572878fafbdff3b70e', '71e29460eff988f6cf1fbddf850fd8e41ff9623ff4e87692f20b85400d3819d2', '9b9f9f1880d846f1a5b1affe56a6e5156ebfe57c964772c4a00332d1ef28515e', '401a90b238fec6aa223407cacba08c4bb54aa980d55894b483dc18e33f3e8a4c', 'd5288dc4ebe3ccaf22ae57edfb130c411e3e173cc9cfac0bd3ba87f85578af6c', '1b1d55d3d12bcd2148a9c545224f50fed57aef2aaca1f4753ebd07ccda2bba10', '26f572f54291ddf4522e8442305e61cee773f69e115cc0ccd324fe6eb3d5ed55', 'ed7f2afec011f1065396d9b1ac7edca70b228d0b2097aa29bbae62a07524ff9d'] A "detnet's use of preof may increase the complexity of using co-routing bidirectional flows, since if preof is used, then the replication points in one direction would have to match the elimination points in the other direction, and vice versa, and the optimal points for these functions in one direction may not match the optimal points in the other." {} {} {} 6 "Control and management mechanisms will need to support bidirectional flows, but the specification of such mechanisms are out of scope of this document. Related control plan mechanisms have been defined in RFC3473, RFC6387 and RFC7551." "Branch for review Merge it ! Changes look good - clicking correct button this time" 215d293ca11d1a96b10664fe5db5be2326ffc8d9 215d293ca11d1a96b10664fe5db5be2326ffc8d9 draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework 9b9f9f1880d846f1a5b1affe56a6e5156ebfe57c964772c4a00332d1ef28515e ['d09382e429d6543f3683cc296aa3ad0a219f3f3590bf0563de588beb2d7f2373', 'e70f533a3e2b0a7fb7ea434b60883ac4cf28cb8120e29e86b49e9c4e4695f4be', 'df74b5643929ab3df88d284c4d25ac2cd3316bde08346c8b65420dc19a10bcb8', 'a0fe7dc24179010b2b0b4ec056bab6084d61a3ce4263406b181fb6cbb33d3e17', 'a04e07cac5c42185835082fe4b6bf9ae3c4e5af4bc1f32572878fafbdff3b70e', '71e29460eff988f6cf1fbddf850fd8e41ff9623ff4e87692f20b85400d3819d2', '9b9f9f1880d846f1a5b1affe56a6e5156ebfe57c964772c4a00332d1ef28515e', '401a90b238fec6aa223407cacba08c4bb54aa980d55894b483dc18e33f3e8a4c', 'd5288dc4ebe3ccaf22ae57edfb130c411e3e173cc9cfac0bd3ba87f85578af6c', '1b1d55d3d12bcd2148a9c545224f50fed57aef2aaca1f4753ebd07ccda2bba10', '26f572f54291ddf4522e8442305e61cee773f69e115cc0ccd324fe6eb3d5ed55', 'ed7f2afec011f1065396d9b1ac7edca70b228d0b2097aa29bbae62a07524ff9d'] A "control and management mechanisms will need to support bidirectional flows, but the specification of such mechanisms are out of scope of this document. related control plan mechanisms have been defined in rfc3473, rfc6387 and rfc7551." {} {} {} 6 This is further discussed in mpls-control-management-requirements. "Branch for review Merge it ! Changes look good - clicking correct button this time" 215d293ca11d1a96b10664fe5db5be2326ffc8d9 215d293ca11d1a96b10664fe5db5be2326ffc8d9 draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework df74b5643929ab3df88d284c4d25ac2cd3316bde08346c8b65420dc19a10bcb8 ['d09382e429d6543f3683cc296aa3ad0a219f3f3590bf0563de588beb2d7f2373', 'e70f533a3e2b0a7fb7ea434b60883ac4cf28cb8120e29e86b49e9c4e4695f4be', 'df74b5643929ab3df88d284c4d25ac2cd3316bde08346c8b65420dc19a10bcb8', 'a0fe7dc24179010b2b0b4ec056bab6084d61a3ce4263406b181fb6cbb33d3e17', 'a04e07cac5c42185835082fe4b6bf9ae3c4e5af4bc1f32572878fafbdff3b70e', '71e29460eff988f6cf1fbddf850fd8e41ff9623ff4e87692f20b85400d3819d2', '9b9f9f1880d846f1a5b1affe56a6e5156ebfe57c964772c4a00332d1ef28515e', '401a90b238fec6aa223407cacba08c4bb54aa980d55894b483dc18e33f3e8a4c', 'd5288dc4ebe3ccaf22ae57edfb130c411e3e173cc9cfac0bd3ba87f85578af6c', '1b1d55d3d12bcd2148a9c545224f50fed57aef2aaca1f4753ebd07ccda2bba10', '26f572f54291ddf4522e8442305e61cee773f69e115cc0ccd324fe6eb3d5ed55', 'ed7f2afec011f1065396d9b1ac7edca70b228d0b2097aa29bbae62a07524ff9d'] A this is further discussed in mpls-control-management-requirements. {} {} {} 6 "XXX discusses the use of flow aggregation in DetNet. It includes flow aggregation accomplished through the use of hierarchical LSPs, aggregating multiple DetNet flows into a single new DetNet flow, and simple aggregation at the DetNet layer. It will be the responsibility of the DetNet controller plane to be able to properly provision the use of these mechanisms. These requirements are included in the next section." "Branch for review Merge it ! Changes look good - clicking correct button this time" 215d293ca11d1a96b10664fe5db5be2326ffc8d9 215d293ca11d1a96b10664fe5db5be2326ffc8d9 draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework 1b1d55d3d12bcd2148a9c545224f50fed57aef2aaca1f4753ebd07ccda2bba10 ['d09382e429d6543f3683cc296aa3ad0a219f3f3590bf0563de588beb2d7f2373', 'e70f533a3e2b0a7fb7ea434b60883ac4cf28cb8120e29e86b49e9c4e4695f4be', 'df74b5643929ab3df88d284c4d25ac2cd3316bde08346c8b65420dc19a10bcb8', 'a0fe7dc24179010b2b0b4ec056bab6084d61a3ce4263406b181fb6cbb33d3e17', 'a04e07cac5c42185835082fe4b6bf9ae3c4e5af4bc1f32572878fafbdff3b70e', '71e29460eff988f6cf1fbddf850fd8e41ff9623ff4e87692f20b85400d3819d2', '9b9f9f1880d846f1a5b1affe56a6e5156ebfe57c964772c4a00332d1ef28515e', '401a90b238fec6aa223407cacba08c4bb54aa980d55894b483dc18e33f3e8a4c', 'd5288dc4ebe3ccaf22ae57edfb130c411e3e173cc9cfac0bd3ba87f85578af6c', '1b1d55d3d12bcd2148a9c545224f50fed57aef2aaca1f4753ebd07ccda2bba10', '26f572f54291ddf4522e8442305e61cee773f69e115cc0ccd324fe6eb3d5ed55', 'ed7f2afec011f1065396d9b1ac7edca70b228d0b2097aa29bbae62a07524ff9d'] A "xxx discusses the use of flow aggregation in detnet. it includes flow aggregation accomplished through the use of hierarchical lsps, aggregating multiple detnet flows into a single new detnet flow, and simple aggregation at the detnet layer. it will be the responsibility of the detnet controller plane to be able to properly provision the use of these mechanisms. these requirements are included in the next section." {} {} {} 6 "Instantiate DetNet flows in a DetNet domain (which may include some or all of explicit path and PREOF replication and elimination node determination, link bandwidth reservations, node buffer anad other resource reservations, specification of required queuing disciplines along the path, ability to manage bidirectional flows, etc.) as needed for a flow." "Branch for review Merge it ! Changes look good - clicking correct button this time" 215d293ca11d1a96b10664fe5db5be2326ffc8d9 215d293ca11d1a96b10664fe5db5be2326ffc8d9 draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework 401a90b238fec6aa223407cacba08c4bb54aa980d55894b483dc18e33f3e8a4c ['d09382e429d6543f3683cc296aa3ad0a219f3f3590bf0563de588beb2d7f2373', 'e70f533a3e2b0a7fb7ea434b60883ac4cf28cb8120e29e86b49e9c4e4695f4be', 'df74b5643929ab3df88d284c4d25ac2cd3316bde08346c8b65420dc19a10bcb8', 'a0fe7dc24179010b2b0b4ec056bab6084d61a3ce4263406b181fb6cbb33d3e17', 'a04e07cac5c42185835082fe4b6bf9ae3c4e5af4bc1f32572878fafbdff3b70e', '71e29460eff988f6cf1fbddf850fd8e41ff9623ff4e87692f20b85400d3819d2', '9b9f9f1880d846f1a5b1affe56a6e5156ebfe57c964772c4a00332d1ef28515e', '401a90b238fec6aa223407cacba08c4bb54aa980d55894b483dc18e33f3e8a4c', 'd5288dc4ebe3ccaf22ae57edfb130c411e3e173cc9cfac0bd3ba87f85578af6c', '1b1d55d3d12bcd2148a9c545224f50fed57aef2aaca1f4753ebd07ccda2bba10', '26f572f54291ddf4522e8442305e61cee773f69e115cc0ccd324fe6eb3d5ed55', 'ed7f2afec011f1065396d9b1ac7edca70b228d0b2097aa29bbae62a07524ff9d'] A "instantiate detnet flows in a detnet domain (which may include some or all of explicit path and preof replication and elimination node determination, link bandwidth reservations, node buffer anad other resource reservations, specification of required queuing disciplines along the path, ability to manage bidirectional flows, etc.) as needed for a flow." {} {} {} 6 "Provision flow identification information at each of the nodes along the path, and it may differ depending on the location in the network and the DetNet functionality (e.g. transit node vs. relay node)." "Branch for review Merge it ! Changes look good - clicking correct button this time" 215d293ca11d1a96b10664fe5db5be2326ffc8d9 215d293ca11d1a96b10664fe5db5be2326ffc8d9 draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework a0fe7dc24179010b2b0b4ec056bab6084d61a3ce4263406b181fb6cbb33d3e17 ['d09382e429d6543f3683cc296aa3ad0a219f3f3590bf0563de588beb2d7f2373', 'e70f533a3e2b0a7fb7ea434b60883ac4cf28cb8120e29e86b49e9c4e4695f4be', 'df74b5643929ab3df88d284c4d25ac2cd3316bde08346c8b65420dc19a10bcb8', 'a0fe7dc24179010b2b0b4ec056bab6084d61a3ce4263406b181fb6cbb33d3e17', 'a04e07cac5c42185835082fe4b6bf9ae3c4e5af4bc1f32572878fafbdff3b70e', '71e29460eff988f6cf1fbddf850fd8e41ff9623ff4e87692f20b85400d3819d2', '9b9f9f1880d846f1a5b1affe56a6e5156ebfe57c964772c4a00332d1ef28515e', '401a90b238fec6aa223407cacba08c4bb54aa980d55894b483dc18e33f3e8a4c', 'd5288dc4ebe3ccaf22ae57edfb130c411e3e173cc9cfac0bd3ba87f85578af6c', '1b1d55d3d12bcd2148a9c545224f50fed57aef2aaca1f4753ebd07ccda2bba10', '26f572f54291ddf4522e8442305e61cee773f69e115cc0ccd324fe6eb3d5ed55', 'ed7f2afec011f1065396d9b1ac7edca70b228d0b2097aa29bbae62a07524ff9d'] A "provision flow identification information at each of the nodes along the path, and it may differ depending on the location in the network and the detnet functionality (e.g. transit node vs. relay node)." {} {} {} 6 "In the abstract, the results of either distributed signaling or centralized provisioning are equivalent from a DetNet data plane perspective - flows are instantiated, explicit routes are determined, resources are reserved, and packets are forwarded through the domain using the MPLS data plane." "Branch for review Merge it ! Changes look good - clicking correct button this time" 215d293ca11d1a96b10664fe5db5be2326ffc8d9 215d293ca11d1a96b10664fe5db5be2326ffc8d9 draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework e70f533a3e2b0a7fb7ea434b60883ac4cf28cb8120e29e86b49e9c4e4695f4be ['d09382e429d6543f3683cc296aa3ad0a219f3f3590bf0563de588beb2d7f2373', 'e70f533a3e2b0a7fb7ea434b60883ac4cf28cb8120e29e86b49e9c4e4695f4be', 'df74b5643929ab3df88d284c4d25ac2cd3316bde08346c8b65420dc19a10bcb8', 'a0fe7dc24179010b2b0b4ec056bab6084d61a3ce4263406b181fb6cbb33d3e17', 'a04e07cac5c42185835082fe4b6bf9ae3c4e5af4bc1f32572878fafbdff3b70e', '71e29460eff988f6cf1fbddf850fd8e41ff9623ff4e87692f20b85400d3819d2', '9b9f9f1880d846f1a5b1affe56a6e5156ebfe57c964772c4a00332d1ef28515e', '401a90b238fec6aa223407cacba08c4bb54aa980d55894b483dc18e33f3e8a4c', 'd5288dc4ebe3ccaf22ae57edfb130c411e3e173cc9cfac0bd3ba87f85578af6c', '1b1d55d3d12bcd2148a9c545224f50fed57aef2aaca1f4753ebd07ccda2bba10', '26f572f54291ddf4522e8442305e61cee773f69e115cc0ccd324fe6eb3d5ed55', 'ed7f2afec011f1065396d9b1ac7edca70b228d0b2097aa29bbae62a07524ff9d'] A "in the abstract, the results of either distributed signaling or centralized provisioning are equivalent from a detnet data plane perspective - flows are instantiated, explicit routes are determined, resources are reserved, and packets are forwarded through the domain using the mpls data plane." {} {} {} 6 "through the network. See control-management-requirements for further discussion of these requirements." "Branch for review Merge it ! Changes look good - clicking correct button this time" 215d293ca11d1a96b10664fe5db5be2326ffc8d9 215d293ca11d1a96b10664fe5db5be2326ffc8d9 draft-ietf-detnet-data-plane-framework ed7f2afec011f1065396d9b1ac7edca70b228d0b2097aa29bbae62a07524ff9d ['d09382e429d6543f3683cc296aa3ad0a219f3f3590bf0563de588beb2d7f2373', 'e70f533a3e2b0a7fb7ea434b60883ac4cf28cb8120e29e86b49e9c4e4695f4be', 'df74b5643929ab3df88d284c4d25ac2cd3316bde08346c8b65420dc19a10bcb8', 'a0fe7dc24179010b2b0b4ec056bab6084d61a3ce4263406b181fb6cbb33d3e17', 'a04e07cac5c42185835082fe4b6bf9ae3c4e5af4bc1f32572878fafbdff3b70e', '71e29460eff988f6cf1fbddf850fd8e41ff9623ff4e87692f20b85400d3819d2', '9b9f9f1880d846f1a5b1affe56a6e5156ebfe57c964772c4a00332d1ef28515e', '401a90b238fec6aa223407cacba08c4bb54aa980d55894b483dc18e33f3e8a4c', 'd5288dc4ebe3ccaf22ae57edfb130c411e3e173cc9cfac0bd3ba87f85578af6c', '1b1d55d3d12bcd2148a9c545224f50fed57aef2aaca1f4753ebd07ccda2bba10', '26f572f54291ddf4522e8442305e61cee773f69e115cc0ccd324fe6eb3d5ed55', 'ed7f2afec011f1065396d9b1ac7edca70b228d0b2097aa29bbae62a07524ff9d'] B "through the network. see control-management-requirements for further discussion of these requirements." {} {} {} 6 "This document specifies the DetNet data plane operation for IP hosts and routers that provide DetNet service to IP encapsulated data. No DetNet specific encapsulation is defined to support IP flows, instead the existing IP and higher layer protocol header information is used to support flow identification and DetNet service delivery." "Branch for review Merge it ! Changes look good - clicking correct button this time" 215d293ca11d1a96b10664fe5db5be2326ffc8d9 215d293ca11d1a96b10664fe5db5be2326ffc8d9 draft-ietf-detnet-ip 21bfd5ca703fca029bdab5a607031dec8404b215dfcb63d99403ae9ff6fa6672 ['7e11dc6d3440e410884cf721ca7e2bcaf010d21763060bbacc6e4245a2f94852', '21bfd5ca703fca029bdab5a607031dec8404b215dfcb63d99403ae9ff6fa6672'] A "this document specifies the detnet data plane operation for ip hosts and routers that provide detnet service to ip encapsulated data. no detnet specific encapsulation is defined to support ip flows, instead the existing ip and higher layer protocol header information is used to support flow identification and detnet service delivery." {26: 1, 13: 3, 62: 2, 102: 3} {199: 1, 65: 3, 325: 2, 238: 3, 155: 4} {65, 325, 198, 199, 238, 155} 6 "This document specifies the DetNet data plane operation for IP hosts and routers that provide DetNet service to IP encapsulated data. No DetNet specific encapsulation is defined to support IP flows, instead the existing IP and higher layer protocol header information is used to support flow identification and DetNet service delivery. Common data plane procedures and control information for all DetNet data planes can be found in the I-D.ietf-detnet-framework." "Branch for review Merge it ! Changes look good - clicking correct button this time" 215d293ca11d1a96b10664fe5db5be2326ffc8d9 215d293ca11d1a96b10664fe5db5be2326ffc8d9 draft-ietf-detnet-ip 7e11dc6d3440e410884cf721ca7e2bcaf010d21763060bbacc6e4245a2f94852 ['7e11dc6d3440e410884cf721ca7e2bcaf010d21763060bbacc6e4245a2f94852', '21bfd5ca703fca029bdab5a607031dec8404b215dfcb63d99403ae9ff6fa6672'] B "this document specifies the detnet data plane operation for ip hosts and routers that provide detnet service to ip encapsulated data. no detnet specific encapsulation is defined to support ip flows, instead the existing ip and higher layer protocol header information is used to support flow identification and detnet service delivery. common data plane procedures and control information for all detnet data planes can be found in the i-d.ietf-detnet-framework." {26: 1, 13: 3, 62: 2, 102: 3} {199: 1, 65: 3, 325: 2, 238: 3, 155: 4} {65, 325, 198, 199, 238, 155} 6 "This document describes how IP is used by DetNet nodes, i.e., hosts and routers, identify DetNet flows and provide a DetNet service using an IP data plane. From a data plane perspective, an end-to-end IP model is followed. As mentioned above, existing IP and higher layer protocol header information is used to support flow identification and DetNet service delivery." "Branch for review Merge it ! Changes look good - clicking correct button this time" 215d293ca11d1a96b10664fe5db5be2326ffc8d9 215d293ca11d1a96b10664fe5db5be2326ffc8d9 draft-ietf-detnet-ip 0f63c019ff0ee430b407521552c18a5cb51664de2c2eb0c3f1217002e44c5a34 ['0f63c019ff0ee430b407521552c18a5cb51664de2c2eb0c3f1217002e44c5a34', '5f960081b6f39804777325a5dcd0c4ca717ee12b4ae1bb43de1f6173902dcc76', '07312eda1faec32b32f3c54d97ff5f70ffb9dcbc35a24f10c0e92081a5675c2e', '7f7614eeecaa8561809d9ad8fa8c0f40c19a9c01410f0897d7ff94722cbefad3'] A "this document describes how ip is used by detnet nodes, i.e., hosts and routers, identify detnet flows and provide a detnet service using an ip data plane. from a data plane perspective, an end-to-end ip model is followed. as mentioned above, existing ip and higher layer protocol header information is used to support flow identification and detnet service delivery." {26: 1, 62: 2, 102: 3} {201: 1, 99: 2, 23: 3} {99, 201, 11, 23} 6 "The DetNet IP dataplane uses ""6-tuple"" based flow identification," "Branch for review Merge it ! Changes look good - clicking correct button this time" 215d293ca11d1a96b10664fe5db5be2326ffc8d9 215d293ca11d1a96b10664fe5db5be2326ffc8d9 draft-ietf-detnet-ip 07312eda1faec32b32f3c54d97ff5f70ffb9dcbc35a24f10c0e92081a5675c2e ['0f63c019ff0ee430b407521552c18a5cb51664de2c2eb0c3f1217002e44c5a34', '5f960081b6f39804777325a5dcd0c4ca717ee12b4ae1bb43de1f6173902dcc76', '07312eda1faec32b32f3c54d97ff5f70ffb9dcbc35a24f10c0e92081a5675c2e', '7f7614eeecaa8561809d9ad8fa8c0f40c19a9c01410f0897d7ff94722cbefad3'] A "the detnet ip dataplane uses ""6-tuple"" based flow identification," {26: 1, 62: 2, 102: 3} {201: 1, 99: 2, 23: 3} {99, 201, 11, 23} 6 "This document describes how IP is used by DetNet nodes, i.e., hosts and routers, identify DetNet flows and provide a DetNet service using an IP data plane. From a data plane perspective, an end-to-end IP model is followed. As mentioned above, existing IP and higher layer protocol header information is used to support flow identification and DetNet service delivery. Common data plane procedures and control information for all DetNet data planes can be found in the I- D.ietf-detnet-framework." "Branch for review Merge it ! Changes look good - clicking correct button this time" 215d293ca11d1a96b10664fe5db5be2326ffc8d9 215d293ca11d1a96b10664fe5db5be2326ffc8d9 draft-ietf-detnet-ip 5f960081b6f39804777325a5dcd0c4ca717ee12b4ae1bb43de1f6173902dcc76 ['0f63c019ff0ee430b407521552c18a5cb51664de2c2eb0c3f1217002e44c5a34', '5f960081b6f39804777325a5dcd0c4ca717ee12b4ae1bb43de1f6173902dcc76', '07312eda1faec32b32f3c54d97ff5f70ffb9dcbc35a24f10c0e92081a5675c2e', '7f7614eeecaa8561809d9ad8fa8c0f40c19a9c01410f0897d7ff94722cbefad3'] B "this document describes how ip is used by detnet nodes, i.e., hosts and routers, identify detnet flows and provide a detnet service using an ip data plane. from a data plane perspective, an end-to-end ip model is followed. as mentioned above, existing ip and higher layer protocol header information is used to support flow identification and detnet service delivery. common data plane procedures and control information for all detnet data planes can be found in the i- d.ietf-detnet-framework." {26: 1, 62: 2, 102: 3} {201: 1, 99: 2, 23: 3} {99, 201, 11, 23} 6 "The DetNet IP data plane uses ""6-tuple"" based flow identification," "Branch for review Merge it ! Changes look good - clicking correct button this time" 215d293ca11d1a96b10664fe5db5be2326ffc8d9 215d293ca11d1a96b10664fe5db5be2326ffc8d9 draft-ietf-detnet-ip 7f7614eeecaa8561809d9ad8fa8c0f40c19a9c01410f0897d7ff94722cbefad3 ['0f63c019ff0ee430b407521552c18a5cb51664de2c2eb0c3f1217002e44c5a34', '5f960081b6f39804777325a5dcd0c4ca717ee12b4ae1bb43de1f6173902dcc76', '07312eda1faec32b32f3c54d97ff5f70ffb9dcbc35a24f10c0e92081a5675c2e', '7f7614eeecaa8561809d9ad8fa8c0f40c19a9c01410f0897d7ff94722cbefad3'] B "the detnet ip data plane uses ""6-tuple"" based flow identification," {26: 1, 62: 2, 102: 3} {201: 1, 99: 2, 23: 3} {99, 201, 11, 23} 6 "Note: The operation of IEEE802.1 TSN end systems over DetNet enabled IP networks is not described in this document." "Branch for review Merge it ! Changes look good - clicking correct button this time" 215d293ca11d1a96b10664fe5db5be2326ffc8d9 215d293ca11d1a96b10664fe5db5be2326ffc8d9 draft-ietf-detnet-ip 275c6e237948c91eb43cccf2aa76d83a2aa594f95719e678600c19f1461e3a0b ['4a0fbcfc5bf233eed040d86902d09758720488ef5f57faa81ba95c6fcaab39a6', '275c6e237948c91eb43cccf2aa76d83a2aa594f95719e678600c19f1461e3a0b'] A "note: the operation of ieee802.1 tsn end systems over detnet enabled ip networks is not described in this document." {26: 1, 6: 4, 79: 6, 90: 4, 51: 4, 130: 5, 62: 3, 85: 3, 68: 4, 35: 7, 110: 7, 91: 9, 114: 7, 97: 6, 31: 5, 13: 4, 67: 6, 38: 8, 124: 5, 98: 6, 54: 6, 127: 7, 8: 4, 96: 5, 64: 6, 30: 8, 61: 9, 55: 3, 27: 5, 15: 7, 52: 5, 129: 7, 115: 7, 84: 4, 76: 7, 87: 7, 131: 9, 102: 2, 113: 9, 99: 6, 36: 7, 24: 6, 53: 5, 72: 8} {119: 1, 1: 9, 4: 6, 9: 6, 10: 7, 15: 7, 24: 6, 25: 3, 26: 3, 27: 7, 39: 5, 43: 7, 49: 10, 50: 9, 58: 9, 59: 6, 64: 7, 69: 5, 81: 4, 82: 4, 86: 7, 96: 8, 97: 7, 100: 7, 108: 7, 109: 8, 110: 8, 111: 6, 114: 7, 115: 8, 116: 6, 120: 7, 121: 4, 122: 6, 123: 5, 124: 4, 128: 8, 129: 8, 130: 9, 132: 5, 136: 6, 145: 5, 147: 8, 151: 8, 152: 8, 154: 7, 156: 6, 161: 4, 162: 3, 165: 7, 168: 8, 169: 7, 172: 7, 180: 8, 184: 6, 187: 9, 188: 8, 191: 7, 194: 5, 202: 6, 203: 7, 206: 6, 207: 7, 215: 5, 217: 7, 218: 8, 220: 4, 221: 4, 222: 5, 224: 7, 227: 5, 229: 7, 234: 9, 235: 6, 241: 6, 242: 6, 243: 5, 244: 8, 245: 5, 248: 8, 250: 8, 258: 11, 262: 8, 263: 9, 264: 5, 267: 4, 270: 7, 272: 7, 273: 6, 287: 7, 289: 7, 291: 9, 299: 5, 300: 7, 304: 7, 309: 4, 314: 6, 315: 7, 320: 2, 323: 5, 327: 8, 328: 6, 329: 6, 330: 10, 334: 6, 335: 6, 341: 5, 342: 6, 347: 5, 348: 5, 350: 8, 351: 9, 352: 7, 353: 7, 354: 6, 358: 4, 365: 7, 366: 6, 369: 5, 371: 7, 372: 9, 376: 6, 384: 9, 385: 8, 386: 7, 387: 7, 392: 6, 393: 7, 396: 6, 397: 7, 398: 6, 402: 7} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 6 "Note: The operation of IEEE802.1 TSN end systems over DetNet enabled IP networks is not described in this document. TSN over MPLS is discribed in I-D.ietf-detnet-tsn-over-mpls." "Branch for review Merge it ! Changes look good - clicking correct button this time" 215d293ca11d1a96b10664fe5db5be2326ffc8d9 215d293ca11d1a96b10664fe5db5be2326ffc8d9 draft-ietf-detnet-ip 4a0fbcfc5bf233eed040d86902d09758720488ef5f57faa81ba95c6fcaab39a6 ['4a0fbcfc5bf233eed040d86902d09758720488ef5f57faa81ba95c6fcaab39a6', '275c6e237948c91eb43cccf2aa76d83a2aa594f95719e678600c19f1461e3a0b'] B "note: the operation of ieee802.1 tsn end systems over detnet enabled ip networks is not described in this document. tsn over mpls is discribed in i-d.ietf-detnet-tsn-over-mpls." {26: 1, 6: 4, 79: 6, 90: 4, 51: 4, 130: 5, 62: 3, 85: 3, 68: 4, 35: 7, 110: 7, 91: 9, 114: 7, 97: 6, 31: 5, 13: 4, 67: 6, 38: 8, 124: 5, 98: 6, 54: 6, 127: 7, 8: 4, 96: 5, 64: 6, 30: 8, 61: 9, 55: 3, 27: 5, 15: 7, 52: 5, 129: 7, 115: 7, 84: 4, 76: 7, 87: 7, 131: 9, 102: 2, 113: 9, 99: 6, 36: 7, 24: 6, 53: 5, 72: 8} {119: 1, 1: 9, 4: 6, 9: 6, 10: 7, 15: 7, 24: 6, 25: 3, 26: 3, 27: 7, 39: 5, 43: 7, 49: 10, 50: 9, 58: 9, 59: 6, 64: 7, 69: 5, 81: 4, 82: 4, 86: 7, 96: 8, 97: 7, 100: 7, 108: 7, 109: 8, 110: 8, 111: 6, 114: 7, 115: 8, 116: 6, 120: 7, 121: 4, 122: 6, 123: 5, 124: 4, 128: 8, 129: 8, 130: 9, 132: 5, 136: 6, 145: 5, 147: 8, 151: 8, 152: 8, 154: 7, 156: 6, 161: 4, 162: 3, 165: 7, 168: 8, 169: 7, 172: 7, 180: 8, 184: 6, 187: 9, 188: 8, 191: 7, 194: 5, 202: 6, 203: 7, 206: 6, 207: 7, 215: 5, 217: 7, 218: 8, 220: 4, 221: 4, 222: 5, 224: 7, 227: 5, 229: 7, 234: 9, 235: 6, 241: 6, 242: 6, 243: 5, 244: 8, 245: 5, 248: 8, 250: 8, 258: 11, 262: 8, 263: 9, 264: 5, 267: 4, 270: 7, 272: 7, 273: 6, 287: 7, 289: 7, 291: 9, 299: 5, 300: 7, 304: 7, 309: 4, 314: 6, 315: 7, 320: 2, 323: 5, 327: 8, 328: 6, 329: 6, 330: 10, 334: 6, 335: 6, 341: 5, 342: 6, 347: 5, 348: 5, 350: 8, 351: 9, 352: 7, 353: 7, 354: 6, 358: 4, 365: 7, 366: 6, 369: 5, 371: 7, 372: 9, 376: 6, 384: 9, 385: 8, 386: 7, 387: 7, 392: 6, 393: 7, 396: 6, 397: 7, 398: 6, 402: 7} {1, 4, 9, 10, 15, 24, 25, 26, 27, 39, 43, 49, 50, 58, 59, 64, 69, 81, 82, 86, 96, 97, 100, 108, 109, 110, 111, 114, 115, 116, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 128, 129, 130, 132, 136, 145, 147, 151, 152, 154, 156, 161, 162, 165, 168, 169, 172, 180, 184, 187, 188, 191, 194, 202, 203, 206, 207, 215, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 224, 227, 229, 234, 235, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 248, 250, 258, 262, 263, 264, 267, 270, 272, 273, 287, 289, 291, 299, 300, 304, 309, 314, 315, 320, 323, 327, 328, 329, 330, 334, 335, 341, 342, 347, 348, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 358, 365, 366, 369, 371, 372, 376, 384, 385, 386, 387, 392, 393, 396, 397, 398, 402} 6 "Implementations if this document MUST ensure that a DetNet flow receives the traffic treatment that is provisioned for it via configuration or the controller plane, e.g., via [YANG-REF-TBD]. General information on DetNet service can be found in I-D.ietf- detnet-flow-information-model. Typical mechanisms used to provide different treatment to different flows includes the allocation of system resources (such as queues and buffers) and provisioning or related parameters (such as shaping, and policing). Support can also be provided via an underlying network technology such as MPLS I- D.ietf-ip-over-mpls. and IEEE802.1 TSN I-D.ietf-ip-over-tsn. Other than in the TSN case, the specific mechanisms used by a DetNet node to ensure DetNet service delivery requirements are met for supported DetNet flows is outside the scope of this document." "Branch for review Merge it ! Changes look good - clicking correct button this time" 215d293ca11d1a96b10664fe5db5be2326ffc8d9 215d293ca11d1a96b10664fe5db5be2326ffc8d9 draft-ietf-detnet-ip 55093df2cc6c28144413f4b01c0f1298e659834758549daeb54f90f2ad216830 ['dc49a2a92afc2679a6ea391c558a81b06fbf9b34c80af693ffb57f19da552c76', '55093df2cc6c28144413f4b01c0f1298e659834758549daeb54f90f2ad216830'] A "implementations if this document must ensure that a detnet flow receives the traffic treatment that is provisioned for it via configuration or the controller plane, e.g., via [yang-ref-tbd]. general information on detnet service can be found in i-d.ietf- detnet-flow-information-model. typical mechanisms used to provide different treatment to different flows includes the allocation of system resources (such as queues and buffers) and provisioning or related parameters (such as shaping, and policing). support can also be provided via an underlying network technology such as mpls i- d.ietf-ip-over-mpls. and ieee802.1 tsn i-d.ietf-ip-over-tsn. other than in the tsn case, the specific mechanisms used by a detnet node to ensure detnet service delivery requirements are met for supported detnet flows is outside the scope of this document." {13: 1} {349: 1} {355, 349} 6 "Implementations if this document MUST ensure that a DetNet flow receives the traffic treatment that is provisioned for it via configuration or the controller plane, e.g., via [YANG-REF-TBD]. General information on DetNet service can be found in I-D.ietf- detnet-flow-information-model. Typical mechanisms used to provide different treatment to different flows includes the allocation of system resources (such as queues and buffers) and provisioning or related parameters (such as shaping, and policing). Support can also be provided via an underlying network technology such as MPLS I- D.ietf-detnet-ip-over-mpls. and IEEE802.1 TSN I-D.ietf-ip-over-tsn. Other than in the TSN case, the specific mechanisms used by a DetNet node to ensure DetNet service delivery requirements are met for supported DetNet flows is outside the scope of this document." "Branch for review Merge it ! Changes look good - clicking correct button this time" 215d293ca11d1a96b10664fe5db5be2326ffc8d9 215d293ca11d1a96b10664fe5db5be2326ffc8d9 draft-ietf-detnet-ip dc49a2a92afc2679a6ea391c558a81b06fbf9b34c80af693ffb57f19da552c76 ['dc49a2a92afc2679a6ea391c558a81b06fbf9b34c80af693ffb57f19da552c76', '55093df2cc6c28144413f4b01c0f1298e659834758549daeb54f90f2ad216830'] B "implementations if this document must ensure that a detnet flow receives the traffic treatment that is provisioned for it via configuration or the controller plane, e.g., via [yang-ref-tbd]. general information on detnet service can be found in i-d.ietf- detnet-flow-information-model. typical mechanisms used to provide different treatment to different flows includes the allocation of system resources (such as queues and buffers) and provisioning or related parameters (such as shaping, and policing). support can also be provided via an underlying network technology such as mpls i- d.ietf-detnet-ip-over-mpls. and ieee802.1 tsn i-d.ietf-ip-over-tsn. other than in the tsn case, the specific mechanisms used by a detnet node to ensure detnet service delivery requirements are met for supported detnet flows is outside the scope of this document." {13: 1} {349: 1} {355, 349}