default_training_data.jsonl

{"dialog": ["Ok naman yung Bini, nakikinig din ako ng songs nila. Pero wag naman munang global superstar. Wala pa sila don.", "paano daw si global it girl, gabbi garcia? lol.", "Juskooo true bang may paganon?? HAHAHAHAH nakakaloka talaga dito sa pinas. Lahat na lang, global, international, asias kineme.  i mean, no hate kay gabbi kasi magaling naman syang host. Yung may pa-title holder lang."]}
{"dialog": ["Sobrang shunga kasi talaga ng management nila. Dapat mas dinamihan pa yung filipino songs eh para mas ma establish sila lalo. Akala nila porket may dalawang hit songs (pantropiko, at salamin salamin) eh ready na sila mag transition sa international audience pero hindi eh. Yung recent english songs nila parang mga rejected scrap songs lang ng kpop groups.", "rejects talaga ata ng twice mga yun kasi same producer daw", "Ooh kaya pala Zero Pressure reminds me of I Can't Stop Me, or may Twice Jap release vibes hehe", "Papasang magkapatid ang concepts nila actually \n\n\n1.\tDance the Night Away (Twice) = Karera (BINI)\n\n\n2.\tAlcohol-Free (Twice) = Pantropiko (BINI)\n\n\n3.\tScientist (Twice) = Blink Twice (BINI)\n\n\n4.\tI Cant Stop Me (Twice) = Zero Pressure (BINI)\n\n\n5.\tThe Feels Album (Twice) = Talaarawan (BINI)", "Karera is good thooo! Hindi siya tunog rejected song ng twice. Filipino songs are really their sounding talaga. Kung ipipilit talaga yung english songs pwede naman taglish. Yung \"Pit a Pat\" nila yun na pinaka magandang english song nila for me at it would have been better if yung chorus ay Filipino! I think it will be a hit", "Maganda yung Karera and I don't think TWICE reject siya. Pero yung mv niya, yung pinaka-first part, parang same ng DTNA na they were all wearing white, nagising sila sa beach na para bang nashipwreck sila. Parang nung una ko nakita yung mv ng Karera, DTNA agad naalala ko although nag-iba din naman yung mv sa later parts.", "Yeah and ang lamang naman ng BINI sa TWICE yung harmonies nila and pag utilize ng alto members nila. Hindi kagaya ng arrangements ni JYPapi na laging ang tataas key. Vocally, BINI reminds me more of SNSD+Mamamoo kaysa sa TWICE.", "sang ayon ako sa pag gamit ng vocals nila... kung tutuusin vocal placements nalang nila ang kinakapitan ko kaya umaasa parin ako na babalik sila sa acapella roots nila. sa dami ng ppop groups na sumulpot sila palang parin ang nakakagawa nun ng tama at makinis.\n\nthey are at their best pag \"real life pitch perfect girlies\" ang peg nila. they are at their worst pag \"twice copy-cats\" sila\n\nkung may gusto silang gayahin sa kpop, gayahin nila mamamoo nmixx fifty gfriend apink redvelvet\n\npero kung tutuusin hindi naman kailangan dahil pwede naman silang maging modern day smokey mountain or doremi o kung ano pa\n\nlagpas kalahati ng members ng bini kayang bumaba panic ng malinis sa mga vocal placements nila.. si colet at gwen palang ang lawak na ng sakop e, pano pa yung pag kagaya ng sa wish bus perf nila ng cherry on top na literal na nagpapasahan at nagsasaluhan sila ng vocal placements. napakalaking sayang kung magiging twice copy cats lang sila"]}
{"dialog": ["To be fair, K-Pop is just pre-loved Jpop 20 years ago. Nag evolve na lang sia into what it is now. Also, around 75% of Kpop releases are written by western composers na trinaslate sa korean, so the influenced are not really original.\n\nEven if may mga lapses sa P-pop scene na ganto, ang importante is we retain listeners to local music scene. This is the strongest era of OPM since the early 2000s so lets just enjoy the ride.", "Yes, KPop evolved from JPop. But now KPop has evolved so much, even the untrained ear can hear the difference between the songs of AKB48 and Blackpink.\n\nLahat ng bagay ngayon may foreign influence o \"industrial grade copy-paste\" ika nga ni OP. Bakit hindi sabihin na copycat lang ng McDo ang Jollibee? Na hindi original ang Chinese food ng Chowking at hindi Italian food ang Greenwich? Pati yung mga banda noong 90-2000's tulad ng Eraserheads bakit hindi sabihing \"gaya-gaya\" lang ng mga banda sa Amerika?\n\nNatural at mabenta ngayon ang KPop kaya gagayahin natin. Pero yung kinokopya natin nagiging Pinoy. Tignan mo ang Jollibee spaghetti. Ang original spaghetti ay maasim, tulad ng sa McDo at Sbarro. Pero ginawang matamis ng Jollibee, nilagyan pa ng hotdog. Magalit at maweirdohan man ang mga foreigner, Pero ang Jollibee spaghetti ang spaghetti ng Pinoy. Isauli mo ang birth certificate mo Pag hindi. Haha.", "Agreed about spaghetti. Flavor so distinct foreigners go there to get their fix. Proud to be shareholder", "Saka Ewan ko din sa Yumburger. Beef naman siya pero hi di yung beefy ng Burger King. Basta iba. Pag may nagbukas ng Yumburger sa aircon na sasakyan tulad ng van o bus, nakakainis! Sa inggit! Haha"]}
{"dialog": ["Well, P-pop and OPM are two different genres. P-pop is mainstream pop via manufactured groups or soloists. The OPM you are referring to are the bands of the 90s and early 2000s who had control over their sound.\n\nWe bought CDs and cassettes because we did not have streaming back then. Also, since there are no livestreams yet, if we want to see our favorite band, we have to hike it to wherever their gig is. I cant see that as us being more hardcore fans simply because we didnt actually have a lot of choices. If we want to see a band, we go to their gigs. Otherwise, well have to settle with FM radio. \n\nLastly, both cater to very different kinds of listeners. Bini may be churning out what some people may call musical garbage, but if the masses listen to it anyways, then we cant really argue with the results can we? Pretty sure the DJs who made money out of Budots music couldnt care less about what people think about it as long as they cash their checks.", "Wait, isn't OPM the general lterm for any music that originated in the Philippines? And P-pop is a more specific genre under it? Then the bands are pinoy rock music? Or ngayon ba hindi na acceptable na tawagin din na OPM ang P-pop?\n\nSorry, nalito ako sa terms mo hehe", "I'm late for the party pero na-observe ko na marami sa kanila ang tingin ay P-pop = boy/girl group. It's like the P-pop genre did not exist before maglabasan yung mga pop groups recently. Na parang sila ang dahilan kung bakit may p-pop ang OPM, ganun.", "Yeah, mukha ngang ito yun. Dati nga may discourse pa if Sarah Geronimo should be included sa p-pop genre because she is making pop music kaso hindi daw kasi solo ata siiya? Idk haha I don't want to be too strict sa terms kaso parang may air or superiority kasi minsan kapag ayaw gamitin yung OPM as a description haha"]}
{"dialog": ["Di lang naman Bini ang representative ng P-pop, dami pang ibang group dyan", "True, may SB19 at ibang groups dyan pero BINI lang ata napapansin ng iba when it comes to negative comments. Parang lahat naman din ata ng P-pop groups na nandito sa atin may formula at nagsimula sa pagiging kpop copy paste. Problem lang siguro sa case ni BINI is that nagsimula kasi sila na tagalog talaga yung kanta, makabuluhan, at representation sa realities ng pagihing Filipino. Now na sumikat na sila parang kinalimutan nila paano sila nagsimula", "Totoo namang kpop ang tinatahak na path ng bini e. Ang dami namang ppop group na hindi ganon, pero nadamay pa buong PPOP."]}
{"dialog": ["Pls exclude the other PPOP groups who are actually breaking out of the mold from this narrative", "with that said, please stream alamat's music", "ALAMAT"]}
{"dialog": ["Shagidi yung may ulo na nasa kubeta diba?", "Skibidi yun. \n\nShagidi Yung nag babasketball.", "Shagid O'Neal?"]}
{"dialog": ["Sorry but it is quite wrong to equate PPop as only BINI. \n\nI grew up with 90's to 2000's era ng OPM. I can say kahit noon pa man ay mayroong influence ang Filo music sa Japanese, Korean and mostly Western music. Mayroon talagang tendency ng paggaya ng style. Kaya ka lang siguro naaalibadbaran sa nangyayari ngayon OP is dahil sa sobrang trending ng KPop to a point na everyone is getting influenced by it. Let's be honest here though, noong sumabog ang BTS and Black Pink worldwide, it opened doors to a lot of artists too. One day, I also wish to see foreigners na inaaral at kinakanta ang Tagalog songs ng artists natin and even big foreign artists na makicollab tapos tanggap ang Tagalog sa lyrics. (Sana marami pang katulad ng Head Honcho nina Eminem at Ezmil)\n\nBut I totally do get your point. There is nothing wrong with getting inspiration from it sana, kaso nagiging cringe lang talaga if you embody it to a point na nawawala na identity mo kaya lumalabas na gaya- gaya. The p...", "Bano Ng alamat live at walang karisma. Good songs tho", "I haven't seen them personally na magperform live so I can't comment. Pero yea, their songs are good, even incorporating true Filipino culture. Kaya hindi pwedeng sabihin na porke ganoon ang Bini is un na lahat ng Ppop."]}
{"dialog": ["HAHAHAHAHAHA if they just stuck to their bubblegum \"pang-masa\" sound that made them great in the first place, may career pa sila.", "and talk less, especially on socmed.", "kulang talaga sa pr training. ang squammy sumagot HAHAHAHAHAHA"]}
{"dialog": ["Not even a fan of bini but ang oa nung \"nakakahiya na talaga kasi\" huhhh??? \n\nKpop draws a LOT from Western artists din naman. Ilang taon na nilang nirereheat nachos ni Tinashe, among others, yet wala namang \"nahihiya\" for them. Maski Charli xcx din.\n\nTsaka hindi naman first time na ginamit ang kids game for a song sooo? Ever heard of Duck Duck Goose by Cupcakke? Don't want to say it kasi I don't like her, pero Taguan by Moira?\n\nJust say you hate bini oh god.", "Masyadong nilalagay sa pedestal yung kpop. Lol", "Any any yung nagpost eh. Di naman nagrerespond sa mga nago-oppose sa kanya"]}
{"dialog": ["APT. derived from a Korean hand clap game, with melody allegedly sampled from \"Mickey\" (oh Mickey you're so fine...)\n\n\nShagidi derived from a Pinoy hand clap game. Anong melody kaya kokopyahin neto?", "Nag aaway once (twice fans) and blooms ngayon dahil sa beat. Turns out, isa sa mga producers ng Twice ang kinuha ulit ng starmagic kaya may similarity talaga sa beats hahahah", "Interesting homie. Daming pera para sa prod, walang magawa sa PR problems ng mga to"]}
{"dialog": ["Nasaan po yung chika dito", "Naging celebrity bashing subreddit nalang to eh.", "Yeah, pwede pa to sa r/PPOPcommunity. Pero baka need ni OP ng karma points, i-give na natin."]}
{"dialog": ["Tapos inaaway pa mg mga fans nila ang TWICE, haha", "Kahit gusto ko yun Bini, isa toh sa reason ko na naiirita ako sa fandom nila. Meron nun OA mag react nung may bata na nagdala ng candybong z sa isang concert nila. May papost pa sa X na disrespectful daw hanggang sa binweltahan siya nung kapatid nung bata. Yung Mamamoo nga winelcome lang NAMAN yung ibang fans ma umattend ng concert nila na ibang lightstick yung gamit.\n\nPano kasi, marami na din sa fans nila na mga blinks din...", "Hindi naman sya inaway dahil candybong yung dala nya. Inaway sya kasi harabas mag wagayway si fan. May full vid yun sa tiktok, dun ko yun unang napanood, and I think na-share din sa X, and na-settle yun with the siblings kasi misunderstood yung part na dahil sa candybong."]}
{"dialog": ["To be fair, diba Viva Hot Babes dati kumanta ng \"Bulaklak\" na isa sa nilalaro din natin nung bata pa. I know it's a different game pero, di rin naman kpop ang nauna na gumawa ng kanta based sa isang game.", "Downvoted ka kahit may sense naman sinabi mo. Hahaha.", "Ilang beses na rin akong nadownvote dito, lagi sinasabi ng mga nagrereply na pag may sense ang sasabihin mo about BINI, mas maraming downvotes talaga \nOk lang yun. Freedom of expression"]}
{"dialog": ["I am not a BINI fan but this is a stretch. Songs inspired from games isn't exclusive to KPOP, heck KPOP is also inspired by JPOP and western music. Also, as some other commenter pointed out, KPOP also gets producers from the west so these songs aren't KPOP exclusive.\n\n2003 Bulaklak by Viva Hot Babes with lyrics lifted from Filipino children's game/song\n\n2018 Darren Espanto had a song titled Nanay Tatay which is also a children's game\n\n2022 YGIG, a PPOP girl group, released SHABA SHABA with *Eeny, meeny, miny, moe* (game, not exclusive to filipinos)\n\nMusic evolves. You don't have to cage PPOP into distinct sound or genre.\n\nAlso POP music is popular music so it is broad.", "OP is most likely pertaining to the TIMING.\n\nNaglabas ng drinking game inspired song ang Kpop, few months later naglabas din sila ng similar concept."]}
{"dialog": ["Recent BINI releases sounded a lot like Twice. Gusto ko isipin na theyre taking inspiration pero minsan parang blatant copy na masyado. Especially yung Blink Twice from Twices Scientist - pati yung MV parang lower budget version.\n\nAng gaganda ng Tagalog songs nila before. Masyadong blinded yata ang management sa biglang fame kaya sinasakyan talaga yung wave by releasing English songs para mas dumami ang reach. I really wish they take example from SB19.", "Hindi lang management ang blinded pati bini members. Porket tanggap na ng mga fans nila twice vibe sila inabusado na nila, lahat na lang ng meron sa twice ginaya na nila. Kung nagbabalak sila mag international at wla sila original, puro copy paste na lang sa kpop style gagawin nila never nila mararating ang international na gusto nila."]}
{"dialog": ["At least APT has bruno mars to save that annoying song. Lol", "Actually..."]}
{"dialog": ["OP, any any na lang? Hindi pa nga narerelease yung kanta dami na agad sinasabi? Chika ba yan para ipost mo dito hahahaha", "HAHA. diba? Maka post kala mo narinig niya na e. Hahaha. Bini brainrot na yan te"]}
{"dialog": ["Agree. Pero lagot ka sa delulu blooms.", "Grooms ain't gonna like this"]}
{"dialog": ["The song hasn't been released though? Or has a snippet been released? /gen.\nDidn't Bini receive a ton of flak because people are saying their latest songs are not a good representation of Filipino culture/music because the songs are entirely sung in English? Now that they seem like they are back with music that is Filipino since the title is shagidi, y'all are still saying something. Most people who has heard apt doesn't even know it's a Korean game, the song did not become popular because it's a Korean game. It became popular because the song has reached the general public since Bruno Mars sang it too and it used a sampling from Hey Mickey.", "OP posting a PPop critique on an unreleased, not even a teaser, song of one PPop artist lol"]}
{"dialog": ["How come OP is not replying to comments that talk about music evolution? Bakit nagrereply ka lang dun sa same yung opinion sayo?", "Di ba? Says a lot about OP's purpose for posting his thinkpiece here. It's not even chika. Haha."]}
{"dialog": ["I feel that it's a management thing. I think That they have this constant pressure that they have to make their songs be a hit so they play safe with what already works - twice. Sobrang naalala ko twice sa mga color pallet Nila sa salamin. Tas puro English pa mga kanta, Atat mag global agad. Why not win over the locals before going overseas. Kita ko ung bts ng blink twice ba un? Puro mga kano mga song writer.\n\nNow I can't help but compare it to sb19. They're their own song writers, it comes sa sarili nilang minds and their own creativity and it shows sa output Nila. Going to another behind the scene sa moonlight Nila na kanta, now albeit English, they were just having fun sa dance Nila na di need ng deep meaning or whatever.\n\nBut I digress, di pa Naka tulong na nagka issue Ibang ladies ng bini. Sobrang sayang kasi they do have the potential naman.", "Agree with everything youve stated. I initially couldnt get into any kind of Filipino music. In high school/college, I had Sarah Geronimo, Nina, Parokya, Itchyworms, Hale, etc watched ASAP. Anything that ABS would try to produce and launch were copy and paste or artistas giving 45%. Cant blame them- theyre also hosting, doing shows, movies, road tours, etcand some of them didnt really have much talent (they were just pretty or mestiza). \n\nSB19 proved me so wrong in the best way. They really have control of everything, they have creativity/originality and it shows. I dont even want to put them in the P-pop category because theyre doing their own thing and can cover so many genres. Im also a fan of one k-pop group  and have started veering more towards esbi. Filipino talents utilized and done right. K-pop singing is basic Filipino singing at best. Some k-pop choreography is advanced cheerleading 101 or high school hip hop talent show. Filipinos can really sing, harmonize, rap, dance, cho..."]}
{"dialog": ["Wala pa nga yung song na judge na agad. Gustong-gusto natin sumikat ang p-pop worldwide pero mga Pinoy talaga hahanap at hahanap ng ikakabagsak ng mga rising p-pop groups. Also, you have to understand na wala tlgang appeal sa ibang lahi kung pure p-pop ang tunog nila, kaya kahit mga k-pop artists/group eh very westernized na ang music.", "kung rejected song lang namn sa kpop song wag na lang kakahiya ang pinas"]}
{"dialog": ["sorry pero parang twice wannabe na temu version ang BINI talaga :')", "True, yung mga fans lang nila di pa rin matanggap na wala originality idol nila"]}
{"dialog": ["No hate on Bini, but must say na yung bago nilang tracks are catchy. Yes, resembles ng KPop, pero I think halos ganon na talaga ang labanan. I believe they even collab on some composers \"siguro\" ng KPop, hence the similarity is there.\n\nKung Filipino type of song, baka di talaga masyado papatok. \n\nAlthough Bini are doing English songs atm, maybe to attract more sa INTERNATIONAL audience. Like Blink Twice Dos Veces remix with a known Mexican singer Belinda. Saw on comments na baka they wanted to gain LatAm followers, kasi malakas din ang fandom dun sa KPop.\n\nSome Koreans or KPop fans (based sa napapanuod ko reax vids) are satisfied naman with their voice quality, their dance, and MV, so feeling ko keri lang naman sa kanila.\n\nIf mga ocho-ocho or typical Pinoy novelty anh ipepeg ng Bini, baka wala na talaga makinig at manuod sa kanila. Hehe.", "They gained stardom bc of their Tagalog songs. Their half baked Kpop reject songs are not making noise anywhere."]}
{"dialog": ["Ang eme nung sa livestream nila, halatang hindi naman nila alam pano laruin yung shagidi shapopo and nahihiya rin sila sa pinaggagawa nila", "PLASTIC GIRLIES Talaga sila \nParang NAPIPILITAN na lang sila maging ganyan trabaho nila haha pagod na sila mag practice kaya mukha sila tanga at tamad tignan"]}
{"dialog": ["Copy paste lang din talent nila. Idk why sobrang hyped pa din nila pero ang tatamad and lame mag perform. Walang umpf or something that would really make them shine and standout as a group", "PLASTIC GIRLIES sila, Napipilitan na lang gawin ang trabaho na yan dahil marami sila pera makukuha, tamad na tamad na sila mag practice kaya ganyan na ka bulok ang performance nila. Bat pa ba sila mag effort kung alam nila marami sila BLIND FANS? Kahit ano gawin nila kagagahan at maging tamad pa sila tignan sa trabaho nila ay wala na sila pake, alam na alam nila marami na sila na scam at nagayuma na mga tao"]}
{"dialog": ["tara sa kasi sa g22", "Best Ppop GG. They have everything down except a huge network backing and mainstream success."]}
{"dialog": ["There used to be absolute metrics for popularity back then. Ngayon album sales, the streaming numbers, and video views can simply be pumped up by fans through bulk buying and mass streaming activities.", "BINI and SB19 have sold out both Araneta and Philippine Arena FOR MULTIPLE DAYS. No other OPM acts have accomplished that before. Hindi pa ba sapat yun na metrics? Ngi."]}
{"dialog": ["Parang tanga lang yung walang big screen", "Makinig nalang daw muna, for video, sa youtube nalang daw. Hha", "Parang puro pera lang nasa isip, walang pakielam sa experience ng fans.", "May nabasa ako sa r/bini na may say din daw mga girlies sa mga decisions ng management sa concerts, MV and etc. eto na yung patunay na wala talaga silang pake sa fans HAHAHAHAHAHAHAAHHA", "mga apologist yan mga anjan"]}
{"dialog": ["Worst concert ever. I've been attending concerts in Dubai, international or local artists man, the screens are there. Coca-Cola Arena is huge, last na nagconcert jan na Pinoy eh Rivermaya, walang problema sa audio and visuals. Bini's MGT really has to step up.", "yass!! watched rivermaya.. galing ng prod.. hinde man super bongga.. but screens were there.. and hello compare ticket cost ng rivermaya sa BINI.. and kita mo talaga sofer happy ng mga titos and titas umuwi.. wala din akong narinig na any complaints after sa socmed.. lahat talaga happy.. unlike sa BINI, wala pako nakitang magandang feedback.. lelz!!", "pop group pa naman sila, para necessary yung bonggang production vs. rivermaya", "zakli!!"]}
{"dialog": ["Ewan ko bakit may blooms na nagagalit eh consistent naman yung feedback na di nila naenjoy masyado nung mga umattend yung show dahil walang LED screens para sa mga nasa likod. Hindi nila makita yung Bini. May video evidence na nga, magcocomment pa na bitter at naninira lang. \n\nManagement should take note of this major issue para naman maayos yung next concert nila. Valid concern naman to.", "Kaya hindi mag iimprove yan. Ok naman pala yung ganyan eh. Blind followers, wala man lang criticism para mag improve sana.", "Mga baby bra warriors", "Hahahaha kainis nagising ako"]}
{"dialog": ["Lets be honest, di naman kase international level ang BINI at the moment. What made them think kaya na nila mag World Tour? Dahil lang nasama sila sa KCon? Ok sana kung bumwelo muna sila sa Pinas imbes na pinilit yung English releases, mas ok pa nga yung Salamin Salamin era nila compared sa ngayon.\n\nWala pa nga silang media training sinasabak na kaagad sa international.", "Sabak agad sa international, hindi pa nga sila makasagot nang maayos sa English interviews", "Maling basis na yata to for going international. Di naman basehan na dapat fluent mag-english. Kpop artists nga di mo maintindihan pag nag-english eh.", "I said that in the context of the international interviews they've been booking lately. Wala silang kinukuhang translators so you'd expect mag-eeffort sila sa interviews na inaaccept nila, but no, so... Their interviews are always empty, no substance, not engaging"]}
{"dialog": ["ahahaha..nanood brother ko sa dubai kasi pinilit sya ng gf nya!\n\nMagaling daw bini in fairness sa kanila pero un venue daw talaga parang tinipid. Tapos di daw organized. Me usap usapan din daw na madami sa nanood ay either half price or free ticket and sa case ng bother ko, super discounted un ticket nila and was bought as a group plus airport nagtrabaho gf nya kaya nakuha nila at lowest price.", "Typical na Pinoy production tubong lugaw. Malayo pa tlga tayo sa Hollywood and KPop.", "feel ko sa second generation pa ng ppop magiging mas maayos.\n\nyung mga ibang group kasi, managed by classic archaic companies dito sa pinas or failed korean companies.\n\ni'm looking forward sa magiging group na managed by ppop artists and other song writers.\n\nUpcoming ones will be yung group managed by sb19. Magkakaroon na rin ng group managed by FlipMusic (yung sumulat ng mga good songs ng bini)\n\nFeel ko yung mga talagang naka experience ng grind sa ppop yung makaka setup ng proper industry.", "Sacrificial lamb muna tong BINI. The moment na magrelease na ng ppop group tong SB19 dyan na mangangamote BINI at magcecater na yan sa mga fans HAHAHAHAHA"]}
{"dialog": ["But it's not Bini's fault na ganun ang nangyare. But the promoters at management nila. They shouldn't take the hit sa ganitong eksena. Low class nakuhang promoter. Di inintindi ng management nila. Kakainis, nakaka awa mga bata!", "Atcually, isa rin sa concern ng ibang attendees ay parang lack of energy.", "Di ko napansin. Di ko kase sila napanood. I saw some clips lang online. Wala din ba back up dancers, para mag hype?", "To be fair, extra gastos and logistics ang back up dancers. 8 naman sila so I think kaya nila ang prod amongst themselves."]}
{"dialog": ["Kung sino pa di nakapunta, sya pa nagpopost at nanggagatong. Crab mentality nga naman, pilipins.", "Pinupuna natin at nagagalit tayo sa mga politiko't opisyal na bare minimum na nga lang hindi pa magawa.\n\nTapos sa mga celebrity, \"crab mentality\" kapag pinuna ang mga pagkukulang?\n\nSa totoo lang, walang Pilipinong gustong mag-fail ang BINI dahil dala nila ang reputasyon ng PH entertainment, kaya nga ine-expect natin na at least man lang sasabay ang production sa quality at level ng Kpop, Jpop...\n\nMag-demand ka naman ng quality sa lahat ng sinusuportahan mo.", "Mukha nga nila di na quality, production pa kaya", "Grabe ka naman kay Stacey hahaha"]}
{"dialog": ["HAHAHAHAHA BARANGAY LEVEL PRODUCTION", "Parang fiesta.", "Buti pa nga sa fiesta, libre. Agahan mo lang para maganda view."]}
{"dialog": ["pag ang goal lang talaga ng management ay kumita, ganyan talaga mangyayari.  Kahit yung ph arena concert nila dito hindi worth it. masabi lang na nakapag ph arena.", "ginawa kasing for promotion yung PH Arena concert ng BINI, imbes na sa BINI naka focus e ilalabas yung KimPau o ibang newbie starlet ng ignacia para makilala, sabayan pa ng mga pa endorsement ng BINI like sa Jollibee", "Sinali mo pa KimPau dito as if may pakinabang ang concert na yun, Kim is a fan kaya nag agree sila sa Star Cinema to watch.\n\nWala namang pakinabang ang baby bra warriors. Nakaka 175M na by now ang movie because of KimPau fans na maraming mayayaman record breaking block screenings."]}
{"dialog": ["Jusmi! Ano ba nangyayari na sa kanila?imbis magpasikat kasi nasa ibang bansa eh ganyan Ang ginawa sa production?parang papuntang laos na ata Ang BINI", "di naman kasi ata talaga sold out yung concert nila kaya tipid tipid sa prod, kakabig pa yung management", "Fresh from GD concert and it was not sold out din po. But the production was INSANE. Visual feast kumbaga. All screens were opened in PH arena din. Yes, I know my disparity sa prices but fans deserve the best in every concert. Management should really step up."]}
{"dialog": ["Management talaga ng bini ang dahilan ng magiging downfall nila.", "noon oo, ngayon may extra effort din ibang members. \n\nDati nagpopost ako doon sa ppop sub na abs-cbn hihila pababa sa kanila pero recently combined effort silang dalawa haha", "Naniniwala na talaga ako na mas gusto nila yung nugu phase nila dati at naaannoy na sila sa fact na sobrang sikat na sila whahahahahahaha"]}
{"dialog": ["Inaway na ba siya nung isang member?", "PWEDENG MAG-WAIT KA?", "No album, no screens daw sabi ni madam!"]}
{"dialog": ["Tinipid na naman ng ABS-CBN Management. Akala yata nila gagana dito yung tubong lugaw strategy of their other talents world tours na kahit basura experience, mahal pa din sila ng fans nila.\n\nMaraming casual fans din na nanonood to see the actual performance and enjoy the experience. Hindi nagbabayad yang mga yan para sumigaw lang.\n\nStep up, ABS-CBN. Ang daming kapalpakan lately, di na ko magugulat if humina ang suporta sa kanila", "Humihina na nga eh HAHAHAHAH compared sa sudden rise of fame nila last year. Pagkatapos nitong World pag di pa sila nagrelease ng mala Salamin Salamin release malalaos na yang mga yan", "\"ah basta 8080 ka inggit ka lang sino ka ba crab mentality talaga pag sumisikat ang bini\" \n\n\\- repeat x 10 according to some Tiktok comment from a 10 year old fan"]}
{"dialog": ["Tapos kapag pinost mo sa r/biniph nang walang halong papuri sa performers sabihin basher ka. Sinasamba yung mga girls dun lalo na yung tatlong lokaret.", "Sabi nga nila A'TIN daw yung organizer sa dubai kaya nagkaganun gahahahha grabe mga imagination ng kabataan ngayon", "Kahit sino pa yun, sinong pipigil sa kanila magpalagay ng big screen diba?  Eh pag concert dapat matic na yun."]}
{"dialog": ["Usually problema siya ng mga OFW-based production sa ibang bansa. Medyo puchu-puchu talaga galawan.", "PNE sa dubai maganda naman production. EHeads ok lang. depende naman kasi yan sa team", "Yes tama. Sa bands, Id say mas low maintenance. Hindi ideal pero stage at gamit lang kailangan ng banda, makakatugtog yan. Kapag ganito kasi ibang level talaga ang production requirements."]}
{"dialog": ["A friend (not Pinoy) attended kasi curious siya and magaling daw based sa videos na pinanuod niya pero bad ang experience niya so napatanong siya na ito na daw ba ang standard quality ng Flipino artists and Filipino events", "Pag sinabi mo yan sa sub nila dami iiyak dun HAHAHA basher and hater kana agad."]}
{"dialog": ["\"Edi sana nagdala ka ng led\"\n\n-bini warrior", "HAHAHAHAHHA COLET BIAS NYAN"]}
{"dialog": ["World tour pero yung budget pang Mall tour. Hays, ABS-CBN management, galaw galaw naman!\n\nHalatang ginagatasan niyo nalang ang girls tapos ang stage, props, and production ang nagssuffer.\n\nNakakahiya kasi world tour 'to eh.", "Dibaa mabuti pa tuloy yung mga mall tour nalang!"]}
{"dialog": ["may nabasa nga akong comment sa tiktok bakit daw sa eras tour kahit restricted view yung seats wala daw nagrereklamo like ateccoh thats THE eras tour kahit sa bubong pa yung seats papatusin talaga yan ng mga tao", "ayy ngeee. taylor swift yun. di sila mgkalevel."]}
{"dialog": ["This happens when the people in charge is not an artist. Kapag mas nananaig ang business kesa sa art / music. Kawawa naman ang Bini, mukang may talent yung iba sakanila, kaso dahil sa management nila pati na yung mga fans nila na toxic, their name/s are being stained.", "Business-minded lang din yung members kaya double whammy. I remember when they called out their own fans na bumibili ng fan merch. Hindi ka raw \"real Blooms\" kapag hindi yung overpriced Divi quality official merch binili mo. Members din ang nasa frontline to defend the management kapag may criticism sa mga ganap nila. They enable that shit"]}
{"dialog": ["As usual walang say yung leader. Kunwari walang alam nalang hahaha lol. Kakasad na love ko panaman si jhoana dati ngayon? Pota ang bitch pala ng attitude.", "Playoff dropper energy :( Akala ko pa naman may energy siya na pang-clutch player"]}
{"dialog": ["IMO they should get John Prats as concert director. Iba talaga siya mag dala ng prod.", "true!"]}
{"dialog": ["Sana mag pa workshop ang management nila sa 1Z kung paano ang tamang pag manage. Talo pa sila ng small company.", "Ang gagaling ng bini girls tapos ganito ang gagawin sa kanila. Mga di na nahiya."]}
{"dialog": ["Ilang days na lumipas di man nila to inaddress?", "Di na yan maaddress kasi todo ngiti na BINI members sa London hahahahahhaah"]}
{"dialog": ["yup sa germany kung saan nanood din si sara duterte", "Legit ba??? Sa Munich din ako nanood eras tour last year."]}
{"dialog": ["Sorry. Not the big screen. The screens all around the stadiums werent lit unlike other concerts held there. Only the ones in front were used.", "Yun na nga po. Yan po tinutukoy ko. Yung sa BINI meron po bang big screen sa likod? Diba wala po?"]}
{"dialog": ["If may friends kayo sa ABS CBN, ask nyo sila. Last concert ng Bini dito sa Pinas, pinamimigay lang yung mahal na tickets para maubos. Namimigay last time yung friend ko", "ganyan talaga sila, yung pinsan ko na dating employee ng ABS madalas my free tickets ng concert ng kapam artist", "May mga bini fanatics dito na di matanggap katotohanan. Lol. Welcome to the real world  sayang wala silang kakilala sa ABS, eh di libre sana sila.", "True naman talagang may mga namimigay ng ticket ng last minute. Yung eheads nga dito nag buy 1 take 1 eh", "Yun pa kamong concert ni Toni Gonazaga years ago, sold out daw pero higit 50% eh pinamimigay lang  may navideohan pa na namimigay sa harapan mismo nung entrace ng venue haha", "Hoy naalala ko yan. Haha", "Ako yung nahiya para kay Toni nung panahon na yan haha. Tapos naka-announce nun sa tv eh sold out daw haha"]}
{"dialog": ["Yung #5, OP, common paandar naman yan sa concerts.  Almost always, may encore.\n\nNext time, huwag maniniwala sa artist kapag sinabing last song. Hehe!", "Hahahaha I will take note.", "Sa Kpop concerts, ang rule of thumb ay kapag hindi pa sila nagperform ng naka-merch wardrobe, hindi pa yon ang tunay na last set.", "Yep. As an ARMY na ilang Bangtan con na ang na-attendan, verified eto haha.", "Apobangpo!"]}
{"dialog": ["Sabi ng friend ko na may friend sa ABS, laki daw ininvest na pera sa BINI ng ABS.", "For sure. Kaya gagawin nila lahat mabalik yung money na ininvest. Add ko lang super mahal ng merch nila. \n\n400 Aed for hoodie\n250 aed for tshirt \n500 aed for light stick", "Grabe yung aed 500 light stick hahahahahahaahahahahha", "Yan din yung sinabi ko. So yung isang set ng photocatd nalang binili ng husbans ko eh. 150 AED", "Blackpink yarn HAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAH kaloka ang lake ng 500 satin! Dami ng mangyayari hahahahahha"]}
{"dialog": ["ang di ko matanggap yung ka same nila ang ticket ng offlimits: to think more than 10 artists sa offlimits and One republic and Ed Sheeran ang headliners.. may kasama pang Ben and ben and a lot others.. and DJs every interval.. tas party til 3AM.. hahahaha!! all that kasama sa same ticket..", "Agree, I think mas mura pa nga namin nakuha yung offlimits. So nagulat ako bakit ang mahal nang tickets ng bini. Then pagka kita ko nga sa Dubai groups, ang daming disappointed.", "dibaaaaa?!??!?! ang lala lang!! imaginin mo yung artists sa offlimits.. like kumpara naman ghurl!! kaya shookt ako nung lumabas tix ng bini.. like what the F talaga.. hahahaha!! and the big screen sa offlimits ang lala din sa laki.. half nga ng performance ni Ed lumipat na kme sa likod.. kse may friend kme na nagsabi mas maganda daw sound system dun.. true enough mas na naenjoy namin.. less crowded pa dun.. tas no major diff dahil sa screen..", "Haha same! Nasa harapan kami nung una, halos di na makahinga haha. Tapos lumipat kami sa likod luwal pa pala. \n\nGulat din ako sa price ng bini. Kasi nanood na din naman kami sa cocacola, mas mura din. Tapos malalaki din yung screens. So kala ko basic na yung ganung setup. Bakit kaya wala man lang screen?", "nagwatch din ako rivermaya sa coca cola, okay naman.. may 2 screens sa gilid tas sa gitna minsan effects minsan yung live vids.. magkano lang ticket ng rivermaya.. tas sofer enjoy kmeng mga millennials.. hahahaha!! wala kong reklamong narinig lahat umuwi ng sofer saya.."]}
{"dialog": ["Baka kulang sa sponsor? surf? pure gold? etc etc. lol Kuya wil?", "HAHHAA WALANG ADS PERFORMANCE SA CONCERT KAYA NAGING LOW QUALITY TULOY YUNG CONCERT NILA \n\n\nMUKHA PINALABAS RIN SOLD OUT ANG TICKET GAYA NG GINAWA NILA SA PH ARENA KAYA DUN NAPUNTA ANG BUDGET SA PAG SOLD OUT NG TICKET\n\n\nNAKAKAPAGTAKA SAN NAPUNTA ANG PERA NG TICKETS KUNG SOLD OUT TAS GANYAN KINALABASAN NG CONCERT NILA? LOW QUALITY HANEPP YAN", "Tanggapin na natin na yung world tour nila, hindi talaga target yung international audiences. Yung pakay talaga nila is yung mga OFWs at kapwa pinoy na nadiscover yung bini. \n\nBaka walang LED screen kasi nga walang ads? Paano nga naman kikita yung surf, payless etc etc.", "Nakakaloka din na minamaliit ng fans ng Bini yung SB19 na OFWs LANG naman ang nanonood sa SB19 pag nagconcert sila abroad. Pero ganito dinadanas ng OFW sa concert ng idol nila, puro palpak."]}
{"dialog": ["Honest question. Maikli ba talaga yung 2 hour-concert for an idol group?\n\nTsaka naka-ilan ba silang kanta?", "Medyo... kasi ung usual con if idol group kaya 3 to 4 hrs plus ung setlist aabot naman 10 songs plus spiels pa may dance breaks pa...pangit pag may dead air kaya minsan may sub units para makapahinga din ung iba", "Wait, what? 3 to 4 hours, tapos 10 songs lang?", "I think they meant this concert umabot ng just over 10 songs. (14 ata ang total). Pero typically nga mga 20+ songs tapos 3+ hours kasi bukod sa whole albums worth, may old songs and may solo/subunit songs pa."]}
{"dialog": ["Baka problema sa Coca-Cola Arena. Nanood rin kami noon nung sila KZ pa ang nag-perform hindi rin gaano maayos; wala ring matinong visuals.\n\nSiguro nakadagdag pa yung biglang pagka-injury ni Aiah sa pagkawala nila sa momentum. Maganda naman kasi yung simula nila.", "Magaling naman talaga sila. Kaso naisip ko din pagdating nilasa Dubai sunod sunod agad promotions nila. Punta ng consulate, restaurants, lahat na. Kaya siguro medyo mid lang yunh performance nila.", "OP yun sound issue is sa Coca-cola arena mismo kasi yan din napansin namin nun The corrs concert panget ng sounds sabog.", "Siguro depende san ka naka-pwesto. Okay naman sounds samin nung The Corrs. :/"]}
{"dialog": ["Kahit ano'ng fandom pa yan. Basta concert, kahit ano'ng network or producer pa yan madami talaga laging pa-free lalo na mga VIP seats. Concert ni Klarisse na nga lang nakakuha kami ng free noon. Haha. Hanap kasi sila ng friends sa management para may free rin sila.", "Curious lng, you think ganito dn sb19? Pero nagka-Day 2 Kasi ung concert nila and 45k tix sold n for day 2..does that mean n tunay ung sold out Ng tix for the Day 1?", "For sure ay tunay na sold out yung day 1 ng sb19. Halos 1 year and a half sila walang con after pagtatag tour so sabik mga fans. Pero kung mangyaring like bini may natirang 900 ticks a day before the concert, for sure sb19 would rather buy those out too via proxies. Tho ang naaalala ko, mga gen ad nlang mostly yung unsold nun sa bini con. So yung mga mahal na tickets pinamigay daw di ko lam sn nkuha. If may pinamigay tlga mga murang tickets yun.", "> may natirang 900 ticks a day before the concert, for sure sb19 would rather buy those out too via proxies\n\n\nbased on their previous concerts (including world tour stops), hindi nila binibili. They just post few hrs before the actual con na tickets are still available and pwede mag walk-in.\n\n\nand I hope they won't do this ever just for the optics na \"sold out\". magbabago talaga ang tingin ko sakanila"]}
{"dialog": ["Wait what, no LED screen for closeups?? Di ba basic yun? So ano pag malayo ka sa stage nagbayad ka para makakita ng langgam at makarinig ng basag na tunog?", "Seats namin nasa bronze,. di mo sila kita. They looked like ants, di mo ma appreciate performances nila kasi di mo nman kita yung ginagawa nila, di mo makita mga mukha nila. Mostly ng mga tao yun ang reklamo, tapos nakakahilo pa yung lights and visuals na nagpaplay sa screen. Buti yung kasama ko malakas camera ng phone nya kaya sa phone nlang kami nanood haha", "Hahahahaha para pala kayong team bahay na sa tiktok lang nanood"]}
{"dialog": ["Dubai is their best-selling stop pero tinipid. Paano na lang sa stops na hirap na hirap silang ibenta? Naging fanmeet vibes na lang. Poor fans", "DESERVE ng mga BLIND GROOMS makatanggap ng BARE MINIMUM GALING SA PROBLEMATIC GROUP NA SINUSUPPORT NILA \n\n\nFOREVER NA BARE MINIMUM ENJOYER ANG MGA GROOMS \n\n\nLagi ksi nila tinatanggap ang bare minimum ng problematic bini kaya pati live performance ay hindi na nag eeffort masyado ang problematic bini members, bakit pa mag effort ang problematic bini members kung blind namn mga fans nila", "Wag ka tuwang tuwa at proud na proud mga blooms sa subreddit nila at sa twitter. Sobrang abusado na management. Tinitipid fans tas ung mga tickets at merch overpriced. LED screen is bare minimum sa concerts. Grabe sa kapal muka ng management para di mag provide ng LED screen"]}
{"dialog": ["Walo sila pero andaming dead air. It's good when artists are comfortable on stage pero ang Bini masyadong kumportable tamad na tamad sila magsalita yung iba kapag talk segment. Parang sila sila lang mag-uusap tapos di kasali audience.\n\nNafifeel ko na ang cringe sa US leg. Pagtatawanan lang nila accent ng bawat isa or something", "At somepoint di ko naiintindihan yung banter nila sa isat-isa. Kaya naguguluhan ako sa mga sinasabi nila.", "Sa cooking show lang ako nanood and it was bad. Imagine being there live tapos walang LED screens. I'd be frustrated too"]}
{"dialog": ["I was there last night too, and same sentiment. Wasn't satisfied overall. Medjo pricey din nang ticket, kaya we expected more. Walang LED, yan talaga main criticism. Andaming tao, sold out and mahal nang ticket. Di man lang napalagyan ng ABS-CBN nang LED para makita nang nasa malayo ang performances? Ang basic din ng stage set-up, di rin nila nilagyan extension para atleast makaabot sila sa may unahan and makita nang mas marami ang girls. Concert also was 2 hrs, pero ang konti nang kinanta nila. There was a long pause nung c Aiah had to exit the stage dahil sa leg cramps nya kaya overall di talaga umabot nang 2 hrs yung performances. Pansin ko rin parang the girls were tired or di nakapag pahinga ng maayos? Their dances di ganun ka pulido compared sa ibang performance nila previously.", "Ang haba din nung pause nila nung nagexit si Aiah kaya parang ang less nung performances nila. Tapos fans are expecting na sana may individual performances or subunit man lang. kaso wala din", "I was expecting na may solo or duo kagaya nang sa Ph concert pero wala. During the long pause, yung katabi namin dalawang babae, umalis sila. Akala namin nag CR lang, pero di na bumalik. Di nila tinapos yung concert. Cguro mga casual fans lang yun, and nainip kaya di na tinapos."]}
{"dialog": ["Yung stage parang nag mall show lang. Mas may prod design pa ata yung mall shows.", "I didnt watch the con. Wala b kahit pausok manlang?", "Didnt watch it too. Im just basing it solely on the attached photo. Yung itsura kasi ng stage parang rehearsal lang :("]}
{"dialog": ["Nag world tour na pala ang BiNi? Akala ko start muna sila sa Asia.", "First stop nila ang Dubai. Next ata yung London.", "Yes dito sila by May 25"]}
{"dialog": ["May space naman pala. Bat kaya di nalagyan LED lols", "Di din namin alam haha kaya nagulat kami di namin makita unless i-zoom", "Kala mo ikakahirap nila maglagay ng LED e no hahaha"]}
{"dialog": ["ang expensive ng ticket para sa mukhang low budget stage ha. nahiya ticket nina taylor swift", "Medyo expensive din talaga. Fan pit diamond is 545 aed and gold is 345."]}
{"dialog": ["Sold out ba talga? Parang ang daming vacant seats", "Lagi namn pinapalabas sold out para di mapahiya ang problematic bini, sa kaka sold out nila naging low quality ang concert dahil napunta ang budget sa sinold out na ticket"]}
{"dialog": ["Ang basic nung close up LED para hindi mailagay, especially sa prices nung tickets. Parang at this point niloloko na lang talaga ng management yung mga fans ng Bini. Tapos yung basag yung sound sys? When yung venue is well known venue naman for cons sa dubai? Nakaka bastos na sa fans yung issues nila sa mga concerts. Ang tingin talaga nila sa mga nagbabayad ay \"basta bini, money ready\". Tapos cash cows naman tingin nila sa bini members. \n\nHonestly, they need to flop para magtanda yung management. NAKAKABASTOS!", "I hope properly compensated ang mga girls dahil sa laki ng kinikita nila. Kasi napaka unfair naman na kasalanan ng production team tapos yung mga members ang nababash."]}
{"dialog": ["I posted yesterday here with photo around 8:00 at 8:30 simula ng performance nila not to bash BINI kasi hindi pa puno yung venue. I had to remove it kasi bumababa ang karma ko. Hahahaha! So actually, ang point ko is, may enough space pa ang mga standing mapa-fanpit at GA during the event mismo pero nag-open sila ng seated days before kasi sold out na nga daw at syempre, expensive na naman yung ticket na inopen nila. Then walang big screen. Had to use my phone throughout just to see their faces kasi nasa left suite kami na box. \n\nPerformance wise, aliw ako sa BINI. \nOrganizer, big NO. \n\nGatas na gatas talaga nila ang BINI.", "True. Talagang gatas na gatas nila ang Bini. Maganda performances nila but yung organizers is a big no. Mukhang bago palang din yung organizers eh."]}
{"dialog": ["We need to know who the organizer are, para ma note down in the future", "All things live middle east"]}
{"dialog": ["Sa dami ng issues, ang generous mo pa sa 7/10.", "Because yung performances naman nila is really okay. As a casual viewer, hindi ko ineexpect na ganun sila. Magagaling yung mga bata. Nagkamali lang talaga yung production and management nila."]}
{"dialog": ["Husband, Bini fan?\n\nTeh magduda ka na", "Mi naman! Hahaha hayaan mo na."]}
{"dialog": ["The hate theyre getting is absolutely overblown because of their recent issue. 7/10 is still pretty good. Nung nag con XG dito wala ding led di naman binash. Unfortunate yung nangyari kay Aiah kasi kumain ng 30mins. Pero most comments ive seen from non fans who attendee the con good naman daw performance nila.", "Magaling naman talaga sila. Kumbaga if performances lang pag uusapan sulit bayad mo. Pero since ang tagal ng dead air dahil sa nangyari kay Aiah, then walang LED screen and another factors, ayun. Kaya nadisappoint yung mga tao."]}
{"dialog": ["ohmygod ang liit ng stage parang New Frontier Theater lang ano ba yan", "Ganyan lang talaga ang stage sa Coca-cola arena. Hindi nila minomodify kahit sino pa ang mag-concert."]}
{"dialog": ["Ano po theme ng outfit kasi parang ang gulo nila sa mata", "Modern Maria clara eme haha"]}
{"dialog": ["Mas magaganda yung outfit nila nung di pa sila gaanong sikat, sa totoo lang. Hindi naman ako fashion expert pero mas eye candy yung pormahan nila dati.", "Naguguluhan din ako sa mga suot nila jan sa poto."]}
{"dialog": ["How a year flies. Last year, bias ko si Jho sa Bini - like mahal ko siya\n\nI cant say the same right now :(\n\nInaddress ni Irene yung gapjil niya before at nagsorry sa personal account. Why cant any of the 3 do the same?", "100% as much as I hate to compare them to KPOP - pero gets ko kung bakit tlaga need hand written letter and in the person's personal account.\n\nBecause it gives a sense of accountability and sincerity, no matter how pretentious it may seem and even kahit hindi naman tlaga sincere yung idol behind close doors but still it's a great PR move. And a management apology post is just not it.\n\nI'm a Luvie din and what Irene did was actually a smart PR move na ang bilis. Ang bilis ng personal apology to those involved  as soon as the issue came out, a handwritten apology letter to the fans and public with no excuses made, and stayed off social media.\n\nWhich is why Irene is still able to reclaim her fans trust. But the fact na ang tagal tlaga nila to even release a statement/apology about it, not until that account gave them a deadline, makes me think they really don't want to address the issue in the first place.", "Around 10 months din siya nawala sa social media, tas nawalan din siya ng endorsements like Prada at Clinique\n\nPano na lang endorsements ng grupo? May portion na for sure di magrerenew dahil sa controversy nung tatlo", "true malaki tlaga consequences sa korean industry, ganun sila ka bilis mag cancel. but look at Irene now, she's slowly still able to come back with an I&S comeback, even had a solo album, and have new endorsements.\n\nFor Bini's endorsements, I don't think it would be that much affected.\n\nHindi naman uso msyado dito yung dropping endorsements due to issues. First time siguro nangyari lang I think is Maris? but after time passed parang wala lang din naman and may bago na siyang endorsements\n\nBINI will for sure survive financially. Ang may naging lamat lang talaga is yung reputation nila and probably their advocacies. It made a dent eh - now everytime the 3 will appear palagi nang may mag bring up ng issue na to even after many years have passed because hindi nakakalimot ang tao.", "Lets see siguro later this year.\n\nHay Jhoanna :( parte ng pagiging leader ang accountability\n\nDi talaga sapat yung group apology.", "lider lang sya pag magpe-perform sila pero yung latest issue ang nag expose sa kanya. she has no leader aura and mentality", "Sakit. Playoff dropper mentality :(\n\nKala ko pa naman mala-playoff riser siya"]}
{"dialog": ["Naalala ko lang- 'di ba may socmed account na nagsabi na iisa- isahin nyang ilabas ung mga issue ng Bini? san na sya?", "Wala for the clout lang yun. Sus", "unless he was paid off? hmm", "Yung inispill nya naman galing lang din kay colet. So outsider sya."]}
{"dialog": ["They're testing the water. Obv silence is their way to bury the issue. That's honestly sad for the women and children who are mostly their fans", "Ganyan naman galawan ng abs, lahat ng may issue noon from anne curtis-mahal na mahal na sya ng tao ngayon...maris rascal-patuloy pa rin ang mga palabas and many others", "Eh.. the Anne Curtis coke rant towards sila John Lloyd and Maria Racal cheating issue were messed up but not joking about the SA of a minor level of messed-up."]}
{"dialog": ["Ang disappointing na they can freely express themselves sa sariling accounts nila pero cant apologize? Kailangan sa BINI official account lang?", "Kung mag apologize sila late na at hindi na mag mumukhang sincere", "Di naman ata sila nagsisisi sa ginawa nila eh. Si Jhoanna mej pa kasi mapapansan mo talaga pagiging matamlay non. Pero sila Stakku at Colet? Wala nang pag-asa yan. Abot tenga pa nga ngiti ni Stacey dun sa recent airport pics nila eh"]}
{"dialog": ["Tagal naman nilang pindutin si anger . Dati G na G sumagot sa mga bashers ngayon di man lang nila mapagtanggol sarili nila", "Wala na silang tatlo. Nerfed down na sila kapag may hawak na mic. Di na nila mauulit yung dating paandar nila lalo na si staku at colet.", "Neutered na rin yung pagiging politically aware ni Jhoanna at hindi na din seseryosohin ng mga tao yung mga sasabihin nya in the future. Si Aiah na lang gawin nilang spokesperson tutal sa kanya naman nagtatago yang BINI tuwing nagkaka-issue sila"]}
{"dialog": ["Amg lakas ng backup, walang nag pullout ng endorsement  To think na ang daming bata na umiidolo sa mga 'yan.", "Very disappointing lalo na sa Jollibee na yung target market mga bata.", "Wala tayo magagawa hahaha bulag mga fans ng bini"]}
{"dialog": ["Grabe sobrang fan ako ni Jho kasi i thought woman of substance siya pero damn this is beyond low yung ganitong behavior na parang wala lang??? Antayin niyo nalang downfall niyo bini dahil sa tatlong members niyo na walang accountability. Kung pwede OT5 nalang.", "Ang bilis nasira ng credibility nya as a leader no? Hahahahahaah baka nga mag full blown T-ARA yang mga yan at ilipat nila kay Aiah yung leadership eh", "True dat. Mas bagah kay Aiah maging leader. Ewan ko ba jan sa tatlong yan. Sa lahat ng members sila lang yung nakikipag barkada kanikanino lang like wtf? Lalo nayang si colet. Her anger personality was cute for me before kasi i thought sinasadya niya yun pero turns out squammy pala talaga siya ngayon asan n tapang niya? Pati si Stacey siya pinaka waterloo sa grupo nakipag jowa pa ng maacm. Kawawa yung limang nananahimik."]}
{"dialog": ["Did you watch the video or you just lack basic comprehension?\n\nAlso read my reply again. SLOWLY.", "Already did both, it really has nothing to do with bini, Forbes 30 under 30 has destroyed its reputation many times already. Mga literal na criminal yang mga nilalagay nila.", "It has. I never said they're infallible. I said that there's a moneymaking operation behind the scenes but you can't explicitly buy your way onto the list. It has been explained on the first video you shared too."]}
{"dialog": ["they had interviews nga sa airport before flying for their concert and I thought they will address the issue and atleast apologize but sadly no.", "Pansin ko theyre active again sa socmed tapos puro positive yung comments. Feel ko yung strategy ng PR team is to just drown out the negative feedback. May nga nagsulputan ding thinkpiece-style posts dito trying to spin the backlash into some kind of society just want to hate on women narrative. (Which I think is an oversimplification because the boys got some flak too, it just so happens na hindi lang talaga sikat.) May nagsasabi pa na the 13 year old daw they were referring to was the one of the guys in the video. Can someone confirm kung totoo to?\n\nAnd as a former casual fan na bias si Stacey, disappointing sya. The 3 girls couldve offered a sincere apology from their own accounts,  pero their management just chose to release a PR statement na dinamay pa yung rest of the girls."]}
{"dialog": ["Paid awards naman yang sa Forbes hahaha magkano kaya binayad ng management", "yung sa pbb 20k per seat paldo na yun"]}
{"dialog": ["Siguro the best option na dapat gawin nila is apologize and be accountable sa actions nila.  Plus gusto ko din makita yung magsorry yung tatlo na nagstart ng issue  sa ibang member ng bini kasi nadamay sila.", "not enough (for me).\n\ni want those dumbasses, maski yung mga lalake, to sit in a room of survivors of SA and child abuse, and explain what was funny about the joke.\n\nin return, each attendee can tell them a story of what happened to them, and tell them exactly why it was not funny.\n\nit is telling of their character and cuts through everything they stand for."]}
{"dialog": ["Ang saya ng reaction ng public sa result ng election so nawawala na attention sa issue ng bini. Baka nakikisakay lang yung PR sa positivity", "Saya na may halong bad trip\ntanginang mangga at crimewater nakapasok amp"]}
{"dialog": ["yaan mo na, exposed naman na kung anong ugali meron sila hahahaha lets just wait kung anong kaaciman na naman ilalabas nila (except aiah) in the coming months ngayon na unti-unti na silang nilalamon ng fame", "True mga fans lang namn nila kawawa sa kakatanggol sa problematic idol nila. Hintayin lang ng bini members magsawa mga fans nila MAGTANGGOL sa kanila"]}
{"dialog": ["As someone na may exposure sa mga SA children, inis na inis ako na downplayed yung ngyari. 13 years old na bata yung pnaguusapan nila. In unison pa sila lahat na kilala nila yung topic. Tapos sa apologies nila prang hndi sya nag eexist. \n\nPlease nman medyo luminaw na mga mata natin sa politicians, sana pati mga \"IDOLS\"", "Who are these people downvoting you??"]}
{"dialog": ["Ni hindi nga binalita ng ABS yung issue. Ang tanging balita lang about them ay nagpa-misa bago sila lumipad for their world tour, at yung pagpost ni Ariana Grande sa IG niya.", "Hahaa about achievement lang pinopost ng abs kapag issue ng bini ikahihiya nila"]}
{"dialog": ["Yaan niyo malalaos na din yan bini na yan.", "True darating din ang PANAHON magsasawa mga fans nila MAGTANGGOL sa kaaciman ginagawa ng bini"]}
{"dialog": ["Kaya dapat tigilan na ng blooms support mga yan hahahahaha kitang kita naman na walang pake sainyo tapos lagi pa kayo inaaway hahahahh", "na scam ng malala ang mga blooms sa wholesome images ng bini kaya kahit na eexposed na ang tunay na ugali ng bini bulag bulagan lang sila"]}
{"dialog": ["nasa kalagitnaan na talaga ng downfall nila ang bini. I think deserve?!", "Same thoughts. I'm a fan ever before Pantropiko, and mas lalo ako naging fan after that. But now? Parang wala ng shine. Not sure if affected ba view ko ng recent issue nila, pero parang nawala yung star factor. Partly dahil din siguro puro English na yung kanta nila now. Iba talaga dating nung Tagalog songs nila.\n\nSana maayos na nila recent issue nila and hopefully maibalik nila yung dating sila."]}
{"dialog": ["Well thats what PR is for? May taga linis naman talaga ng kalat. Hindi naman pwede forever stuck sa issues.", "May tamang approach kasi, kung may sensible at conscientious na PR sila hindi lang simpleng post at statement yan.\n\nMabigat ang responsibilidad ng BINI, kahit sabihing entertainer lang sila, obligado silang magtaguyod ng tamang values sa mga tagapakinig lalo sa mga batang fans nila dahil may inangkin silang advocacy, whether facade lang o totoo. Dapat isinama ng PR nila yan sa pag-iisip kung paano ia-address ang issue nila.\n\nSa ibang bansa yan, nagpa-presscon na agad ang agency kinabukasan, pinagbasa ng prepared na official statement, pinayuko bilang tanda ng pagpapakumbaba at yung manager ang sasagot para sa mga talent at sasabihin ang susunod na hakbang. May upcoming activity? Pwede namang ituloy, pero pagkatapos ay magre-reflect sila.\n\nE wala, Hollywood approach ang sinusunod ng talent at management dito sa atin, yung papatahimikin lang yung talent in the hopes na mamamatay nang kusa ang issue. Nakalimutan nila na iba ang kultura nating mga Asian na hindi basta-basta nakakalimot pag..."]}
{"dialog": ["Ill probably get downvoted for this, but I genuinely find it ironic that some of you are demanding an apology.\n\nYes, the situation is disappointing  but lets not forget, theyre human, not goddesses.\n\nWhen Maris made a mistake, she publicly addressed it, yet people still criticized her and dismissed it as just a PR move. No matter how sincere or well-delivered an apology is  written or spoken  for some, its never going to be enough.\n\nSo please, cut the chase when it comes to asking for a personal apology from these girls. Lets be real  even if they did personally apologize, I 100% bet most of you would just mock it and say, The damage is done.", "Syempre downvoted ka din ng mga closeminded at mga anak ni Lucifer  Even before di nila gusto ung BINI eh ngayon nakahanap ng way para mas ibash ung mga to. Kawawa puro hate sa puso."]}
{"dialog": ["So ano po ba ang dapat nilang gawin?", "Mag apologize using their personal accounts at wag magtago sa likod ng official bini account na nadamay ang ibang members. And after that, isapuso yung mga advocacy nila kasi parang eme eme lang eh..."]}
{"dialog": ["They spent too much money on them to let them burn. Especially may concert sila upcoming. \n\nThe Philippines isn't lacking in talent, so idk why they try to keep them. Like even people like Kathryn, Vice, Nadine, Coco, Piolo, etc. Yeah, they're good, but come on.... gatas na gatas na. Where are the fresh faces? Is this really the best they can do? \n\nDaming talented sa pinas. Guaranteed they'll be better for PR too.", "You already answered your own question for The PH isnt lacking talent so why try to keep them? with your very first sentence. ABS investment on these girls are deep.\n\nI mean for sure Star Hunt is always active on searching the right talent; they never stopped at BINI. Pero when it comes to forming groups it takes more than just looks or talent. Lahat ng members need to weight a certain way, similar physique, height, age. Napakaraming factors that goes into account. Hindi lang basta basta marunong kumanta at sumaway eh pwede ng ilabas as girl group and will be guaranteed successful.\n\n\nABS tried to release multiple groups kita mo sa Showtime palang, but none of them peaked like BINI did. And tbh, Abs was pushing BGYO more than Bini when they debuted. It took years for BINI before having that one big break. \n\nBut yeah, my whole point is - it is very difficult to form a successful PPop group. It can take years and its never guaranteed na kakagatin ng masses."]}
{"dialog": ["Alam ko, hate na hate niyo ang BINI, pero sobrang bobo at braindead ng comment na to. Ang Forbes Asia Top 30 ay editorial pick, meaning may mga judges yan sa Forbes at pagbobotohan nila kung sino-sino ang pasok sa Top 30. May 4,500+ nominees at BINI lang girl group sa list while 2 BGs representing K-pop. Tapos sasabihin niyong bayad? Nasaan ba utak niyo?\n\nDownvote niyo na ko dali  para patunayan niyong bobo kayo. Editorial pick yan. I-search niyo kung ano ibig sabihin nun para naman matuto ang mga bobong katulad niyo at hindi lang puro chismis.", "Kaya mo yan, te"]}
{"dialog": ["Forbes 30 under 30 is a scam. It's a paid advert. This has been exposed several times.", "Lol........parang yung kumakalat dito palagi na \"Asia's......most eme eme award\" thingy, but on an international stage.", "Yes the one where Whamos paid 100k for a couple award haha", "Ang mura nman ng 100k", "Hindi din naman kasi sobrang matunog yung awards night na yun. Parang networking something haha"]}

{"dialog": ["Bini Josh Giddey era\n\npero imbis na under-18, 13 years old\n\nAlso, Ive seen a lot of Colet = Jeongyeon when hinahalintulad ang Bini sa Twice: which is offensive kay Jeongyeon kasi di siya magaspang at patolera\n\nSayang talaga si Jho - nagbago image niya overnight", "True. Nakakaiinis kapag kimukumpara sila sa Twice.", "Lol. May PR training pa Twice"]}

{"dialog": ["We made it ate Maris! Char lungs.", "Unfair. Hindi work ng Star Magic PR yung international festival tour and awards ng movie ni Maris dahil hindi under ABS yung movie. Kahit yung song na nilabas niya under an indie label. Kahit paglilinis ng kalat sariling sikap si Maris", "Yung Maris sa tiktok tintutukoy ko Mhie"]}

{"dialog": ["kaya sana yung tatlo na wag na masyadong palaban yung branding tapos sila pa yung magiging dahilan ng mga issue", "especially Colet. problematic talaga siya ever since. tas mga fans nila tuwang tuwa pa sakanya kapag pinapatulan niya yung mga bashers at nagsusungit siya. lagi nilang sinasabi napindot na naman si anger si ante kinareer ang pagiging problematic  isa pa yan si Stacey at Jhoanna, parang mga nasa loob ang kulo. pasweet ang image pero ibang iba pala offcam. jeez"]}

{"dialog": ["Galing naman ni Kempee De Leon", "ANG GALING NI KEMPEE (4x)"]}

{"dialog": ["Parang matagal na yan na expose na people pay to get featured on that. Not all naman pero it's not as credible", "Ever since na-feature si Kylie sa cover nila nawala na credibility nila for me"]}

{"dialog": ["Damage control  Magkano kaya binayad sa Forbes ?", "Alam na this"]}

{"dialog": ["Forbes Asia? Bakit wala si Asias Superstar with her billion movie", "Buset Ka hahahahah"]}

{"dialog": ["Great now they should get a PR team", "They have a PR team tho. Yung lagi sila napopost sa Popbase at Popcrave, international magazine features like this and Billboard are all thanks to their PR team"]}

{"dialog": ["Jhoannaaaa bakit kasi dyan ka pa sumama. Dapat si maloi na lang nasa video e. At least di masakit. Hahaha hayst", "pinatitibok mo ang aking puso at aking manoy, oh maloi"]}

{"dialog": ["Kapag si Aiah nagka-issue..Wala na talaga.", "Si Gwen ba meron na?", "Wala. Her only issue was the tinapay issue in pbb BAHAHHAHA", "Anong tinapay issue?", "Since tipid sa pbb so tig 2 slice lang ata dapat sila pero si gwen 3 or 4 slice kanya. LT lang yung time na yun pero kasi ang bata pa no Gwen nun hahaha", "Buwisit yun lang pala haha", "Mahalaga yung count ng tinapay kasi limited lang pwede kainin per tao. Kahit ako mag-aamok pag inubusan ng tinapay. Hahahahaha"]}

{"dialog": ["Tahimik pa ba si Colet?", "Hindi na nga umiimik sa X. Na pipe na ata dahil sa issue nila, walang accountability  weeew", "Pag sya ung may issue tahimik. Pag tayo may issue sa kanila like how they answer sa mga fans - kala mo inapi eh. Colet asan accountability??", "Wala e. Squammy talaga galawan. Tapang tapangan lang pala si atecco", "Pati fanbase n'yan squammy!"]}

{"dialog": ["Picture lang naman ito noh pero di ko bet yung aura talaga nung Colet. Nayayabangan ako sa kanya.", "Napanood ko compilation ng Angry mode nyan sa Tiktok. Clips sa performance, SS ng mga reply nya sa fans sa X at mga live nya. Ang damiii! Totoo ngang inugali nya pagiging anger nya.", "Beastmode yan pag yung audience naghahanap ng Mikhaiah layag. Ayaw masapawan ni Ateng.", "ay wehh totoo? So possible totoo ang hula na may inggitan mangyayari sa members kaya hindi rin magtatagal ang group nila. Vibes palang ni colet ay bida bida ang aura at attention seeker sa pagiging beast mode", "Halata diba? Yung tipong bida-bida at gusto niya sa kanya ang attention."]}

{"dialog": ["Aiah & Mikha - gaan ng aura sa always  \nStacy - halos mabura na mukha sa make up  \nMaloi - hanggang sa simbahan nakalabas yung tiyan", "> hanggang sa simbahan nakalabas yung tiyan \n\n  gagii tumaas lang yata yung shirt Hahah naka akbay kasi kay sheena", "Ay tumaas lang ba wahahaha lagi kasi naka crop top + low waist bottoms kahit saan eh", "Haha I get youuu.  Tbf naman for her, shes only in her early 20s. I think its normal lang mag experiment ng kung ano mang style.", "Yuh and it's okay naman regardless of any age to experiment. I just thought na naka ganun na outfit sya even inside the church hence I called it out."]}

{"dialog": ["Si Aiah and Mikha ang ganda ng aura.", "Silang dalawa namn talaga Legit na maganda since debut nila, kahit di kagandahan make up nila nung debut days nila maganda talaga", "Enhanced na rin ilong ni mikha", "Enhanced pala yun? Kaya pala"]}

{"dialog": ["Pa-religious na sila forda goody image", "??\n\n Lagi pong merong send-off mass ang BINI, regardless kung saan sila pupunta.", "Ang galing mag downvote ng mga tao dito kahit totoo naman sinasabi. Eh talaga naman laging may mass pag may big ganap ang bini. Gets naman na hindi nyo sila gusto. Pero pag tama naman ang sagot, wag nyo idownvote. Feeling high and mighty mga tao dito. Ayaw na itatama sila. Kala ko ba uso mag fact check dito sa reddit?\n\nLast time may nagcomment sa isang bini post na ang bastos daw ni sheena kase sinabi nya na amoy epep daw si colet hahahh. Napakadaming upvotes. Tapos may nag correct na epep ay pangalan ng inaanak ni colet na nakatira sa condo nya. Ayun sandamakmak ang downvotes hahaha.", "Ano pang aasahan mo mga tao dito sa sub na ito, makapanglait na ng itsura wagas eh kahit other celebrities na hindi naman problematic. Matatapang lang naman yan kasi anonymous dito baka pagnakita mo pa personally sila pa itong mga mukhang dugyot."]}

{"dialog": ["Pinaka nabago tlga image for me is Jhoanna", "agree since leader siya ng group tapos siya payung kitang kitang tumatawa sa nagkakandyutan sa harap niya bwak bwak bwak", "hahaha yung nagkakadyutang mga V@kL@ sa viral video???? hahahha"]}

{"dialog": ["Di tlga magandang tignan yung mapagpatol na image ni colet. Dalawang (Kollete & colet + fyang) ang ganun sa abs.\n\n\nEdit: Minsan, okay lang yung pagpatol/call out nya sa mga fans dhil may mga fans din nman na sumosubra na pero minsan nakakainis na palagi na lang syang pumapatol sa mga fans. Nagfefeeling si P.A ba sya? Di pa sya/sila umaabot sa star status ni P.A para maggaganyan.", "Ok lang naman I guess to call out fans when they step out of line. Like I saw a reply from one member of SB19 (I forgot who!) saying he does not tolerate their behavior and to stop what they're doing. Parang scolding father lang ang dating, inaayos mga anak na umasta nang tama. Yung problema kay Colet eh mayabang, rude at palengkera ang dating. Sarcastic at arrogante sa sariling fans. Sino ba naman di matu-turn off sa gano'n. Yung management naman nila, di man lang kino-correct yung gano'ng behavior. Kapwa at fault.", "Si SB19 Pablo ba 'to nung time na na-bash ang A'TIN and SB19 ng mga taga-volleyball community?"]}

{"dialog": ["for me lang ah, if it wasn't for Maloi's distinct powerful voice, ang waley nila as a ppop group. sa beauty naman, Mikha at Aiah talaga periodt", "Powerful? Pwede. Distinct? I dont think so. Halos magkakasame vocal color nga sila e.", "Dahil sa singing style niya siguro, like siya yung in-charge sa runs. Kung power, si Colet. Kung vocal agility si Maloi"]}

{"dialog": ["Could it be na purposely pinagtabi tabi silang tatlo + Aiah para matakpan yung issue na nag leave sa gc si Aiah", "Lagi ginagawa damage control si aiah  Si aiah dati na nag post ng pic nung bata pa sya para ma segway ang issue ng ibang members nya at mapunta ang attention sa kanya lol", "Deserve nya yung mga solo travels nya kasi buhat na buhat nya yung PR ng BINI whahahahaha"]}

{"dialog": ["nagtabi pa talaga ang tatlo", "Buti hindi sila dumulo, maka-crop sila"]}

{"dialog": ["Aiah and Mikha yun ganda nla pang leading lady. Si Gwen maganda din sya lalo na sa editorial na photos pang model ganern", "Agree, I think na if hindi BINI or hindi nag work out, Gwen can have a successful run as a model."]}

{"dialog": ["Nagtabi tabi pa nga. Char!", "Sinama pa si aiah para matakpan baho ng awra nila"]}

{"dialog": ["they look so different without their stage make-up", "They look so normal no? Parang lalagpasan mo lang sa daan pag nakasalubong mo."]}

{"dialog": ["Can someone ID them from left to right please thanks", "Aiah Stacey Colet Jhoanna Mikha Gwen Maloi Sheena"]}

{"dialog": ["Idk pero bat parang pilit ngiti nila", "Ganyan talaga kapag FAKE SA HARAP NG CAMERA  Pilit na plit mga FEMINIST yun pala balahura ang ugali sa kapwa babae kapag wala fans na nasa paligid"]}

{"dialog": ["Hindi dasal ang need nila tbh hahaha", "Divine intervention yata ang need hahaha"]}

{"dialog": ["Si aiah nalang talaga fina-follow ko sa bini. Pati yung group acc unfollowed ko na", "Good job ses"]}

{"dialog": ["Dapat sinama na nila dyan pedo friends ng tatlo.", "Yung pedo friends ang kailangang mabuhusan ng holy water"]}

{"dialog": ["So ako lang talaga nagagandahan kay maloi?? Ewan bat I find her pretty huhuhu", "Ganda nga nya dyan!"]}

{"dialog": ["I may be wrong, pero yung mata ni Colet parang galing sa iyak.", "same kay jhoanna mukha nasermunan ng pari sa kalaswaan nila"]}

{"dialog": ["Pati pagsimba need pa ipost  para matakpan ung issue na bago? Lol", "Dati na sila ganyan kapag mag coconcert sila lagi may simba post para ipakita sa mga fans na mga angel kuno sila. Pilit na pilit ksi pa wholesome image nila tas di pala kayang panindigan ng ibang members"]}

{"dialog": ["Can someone make a list ng issue per member? Hahaha", "From the top of my head lang after becoming a Bloom last year.\n\nAiah - no problematic issue. Madalas lang malink sa guy friends niya.\n\nStacey, Colet, Jhoanna - yung recent issue nila.\n\nMikha - no problematic issue. Pinupuna ng iba na mahilig mag-bar. (I don't see it as an issue though.)\n\nGwen - no problematic issue. Yung tinapay issue niya lang sa PBB.\n\nMaloi - tumawa (react) sa isang tiktok video na sumasayaw na parang ginagaya sumayaw ang isang PWD. She immediately apologized. Apologized on her own account though not from the Bini PH account. 2nd is in a relationship daw kay Zild na isang cheater/red flag. Never proven though. They say they're always seen together, but to be fair they're always seen together with their other friends not just them.\n\nSheena - Naglike ng isang troll post nung 2020 or 2021 about an SB19 member's retoke. (not sure if retoke or yung face) This one I think has been patched up though. Sheena probably apologized in person kasi they seem ok..."]}

{"dialog": ["Whos who? Hindi ko kasi talaga kilala Bini. Tapos iba pa face nila kapag walang makeup.", "will try my best. Left to right: Ayah, stacy, kolet, Joana, si father, mika, gwen, maloi, sheena"]}

{"dialog": ["HOY HAHAH dapat sa dulo sila hahah or foreshadowing ba na aalis din si aiah with them charot", "Wag"]}

{"dialog": ["They aren't on that level yet to be performing in this type of capacity nor selling such price. Lbr they are only locally known, they haven't amassed any international fandom outside of YT baiters that will spend money to see them. \n\nEven Kpop acts are stuggling to sell out venues. \n\nYou can't solely rely on the Filipino community abroad who are mostly millennials and working class. \n\nManman is way too ambitious. \n\n\nTho nothing wrong with setting ambitions but as per Nina \"iStep by istep bago ka sumakses\" like they need to realize there is no shortcuts.", "nahihiwagaan din talaga ako kung bakit push na push yung management nila na mapenetrate yung international scene when in fact hindi pa naman sila ganun ka-stable (idk if this is the right term) locally. \n\nyung ibang kpop acts na kakadebut lang, paulit ulit na nagrerelease ng kpop songs, tapos small scale fan meetings, hanggang sa mga small tours. pag pumupunta dito sa pinas, nft muna, tapos next na balik, araneta naman, tapos next balik, moa naman.\n\nhindi rin naka-help sa girls yung pagrelease nila ng english songs kasi imagine, nag peak yung salamin, salamin. then after that, hindi na nasundan. tapos ganun pa umasta sa soc meds. eh sa kpop idols, bibihira lang talaga yung nakikipag away sa fans, kapag mga napika na lang sa sasaeng. \n\nsana ginawang stable muna yung popularity & pinalaki muna yung fandom organically before penetrating the international scene. achievement yung nakapag kcon la sila pero what happens after that? parang nawawala yung momentum. :(", "parang recent songs nila jennie at lisa. lost their hook sa actual fans and audience nila.", "Damay na naman yung dalawa when both their albums are doing great in their own ways. All their songs actually suit their personality, and the genre isnt even surprising. Who are these fans? The blinks who are always critical with whatever the members release? Fans who always rally about letting the members be given artistic freedom, and yet the moment the girls do something theyve been talking about wanting to try, nauuna fans in criticizing them? The publics reception sa songs nila is fine. Stop taking haters opinion as facts.", "stop taking opinion as hate.\nor better, give us a script so we can copy paste it and comment it to every post na involved ang music nila.", "Kaya mo nga sila i-bring up sa topic na hindi sila involved, specially on a post that literally has nothing to do with them or their music in general, hihingi ka pa script.\n\nI didnt even take your comment as hate, and was generally just talking about the actual fans and audience you mentioned. Actual fans seem to be taking their music well. So who are these youre talking about and why do you speak about their opinion as facts? Majority of those who talks about their songs not being taken nicely are mostly haters who poses as fans and gen public. So ano ka dyan, since you seem to be familiar enough about their opinion to talk? Kaya nga sinabi ko stop taking haters opinions as facts", "haaayy kaya di ako sumasali sa mga fandom na yan eh. hirap"]}

{"dialog": ["Masyado sila nagmadali for a world tour. Bini is super sikat here sa pinas pero world wide they are not as known.", "this is true! ginatasan talaga. to think, nag-die down na din talaga hype with bini since hindi nasundan yung pantropiko fever", "True. Flop yung recent EP nila hindi nagcchart locally. Hindi din relatable sa Pinoy unlike nung Pantropiko at Salamin. Sadly, nawala na din masyado hype nila. Walang kakaibang promotion, walang eye catching na content, walang viral na anything bukod sa mga negative issues ng ilang members recently.", "Puro kase pera ang management ehh, look at their live streams, dati naman libre lang sa Kumu, ngayon may membership na\n\nTheir merch is low qual even though sobrang mahal, okay lang sana kung abot kaya ng masa kaso hindi ehh\n\nThey also abandoned Tagalog songs in pursuit of international fame pero sa totoo lang yung recent releases nila sound weak, parang AI generated yung lyrics, I think may issue din yung producer ng recent English songs nila, nagka issue ata don sa SB19 na parang panget din kinalabasan not sure", "\\>nagka issue ata don sa SB19 na parang panget din kinalabasan not sure\n\nCan you expound this? afaik, sb19 is not in any way related sa producers ng gg (idk who their producers are). recently lang naman kumuha ng ibang producer ang group for Simula at Wakas EP. Si August Rigo and Simon Servida lang ang previous nila na nakawork.", "Yeah, I checked the Biniverse track list and there is not a single producer there that SB19 has worked with.  Which makes sense since their sounds are so vastly different, its doubtful there would be much crossover."]}

{"dialog": ["How old are they as a group? Meron ba talaga silang solid fanbase abroad who will be willing to watch their concerts? Parang sumikat sila after a couple of songs and then nag-overestimate yung management na because they sold out Philippine Arena, they can sold out venues in other countries, too\n\n\nSobrang mahal ng concert tickets ngayon. If even Beyonce can't sell out full stadiums anymore, you know there's something wrong talaga.", "Correct me if Im wrong, hindi naman nila na sold out talaga ang PH Arena. Naka black curtains yong mga unsold sections/seats.", "kahit nung sa Aurora music fest ang tamlay din ng crowd sa kanila (tho last performer sila at umuulan na) buti pa nung si TJ nag perform e, at yung cup of joe nung 2nd day kahit umuulan hype yung crowd", "Heto rin sabi ng friend ko. Andami raw dead air sa Bini. Kulang rin stage presence lalo na in between songs. Di marunong makipagusap sa crowd.", "I'm not an expert pero di ba 8 members sila sa group, bakit may isang backup singer pa sila on the side? Twice ko na napansin to.", "A lot of the girls just double the other girls (when they have to dance) kasi lbr ilan lang talaga sa kanila ang strong vocally. They dont have complex harmonies by themselves. So the backup singer covers some other harmonies/adlibs to fill out the sound. If theyre doing sit down perfs or acapellas, theyre fine, though."]}

{"dialog": ["Black curtains are waving", "Ano ibig sabihin nyan", "last concert nila sa Philippine arena maraming black curtains kahit ang sabi ay sold out daw", "kaya nag taka ako nung inannounce na sold out hahahaha. gusto kasi sila first as a ph act sa phil arena", "Goal yata nila is angkinin nga ang title na first Filipino performers na nag-PH Arena.\n\nKaya may rumors na natunugan na mag-PH Arena ang SB19, kaya inunahan nila kahit katatapos lang ng major concert nila. Bali, nag-major concert ulit na halos walang bagong release kaya nag-reklamo ang fans na pinatulan nila sa Twitter lol.", "Haha true. Sunod sunod concert last year tas wala namang bago. Sayang lang pera. Ung sa New Frontier Theater lang talaga yung maayos na concert para sakin kasi 1st time. The rest is meh, puro recycled acts nalang."]}

{"dialog": ["Looks like the seating capacity here is 3x the one for SB19's concert (Pickering Arena). Too bad for me, SB19's sold out, resale tickets remaining.", "SB19, I guess, tinetest pa din nila yung fanbase nila outside PH and they are also thinking yung magiging price ng ticket. As much as possible they want the price to be as affordable as possible", "They had their Pagtatag concert in the same venue in 2023. I was thinking they'd be a bigger act now, but I guess they're taking the more conservative route.", "Yes. Ayaw pa din nila mag risk. Hopefully next world tour mas malaki na yung venue. They deserve it din naman.", "Yeah, would've loved to see them live!"]}

{"dialog": ["to think na One Ok Rock is doing a concert on a smaller venue, THE One Ok Rock. Masyado talagang ambitious yung management. The bigger the venue pa naman, the higher the price of the rent for the stadium, tsk. Management talaga magpapabagsak sa girls e.", "si Dyogi kasi parang my gusto patunayan, yung mga pinapasikat nya kasi ngayon flop sa casual viewers, yung BINI lang talaga nagustuhan ng fans kaya masyadong ginatasan kaya parang my umay na", "Sino ba pinasikat nyan? Eh si Kim chiu lang din naman kaya nung may award si bawal lumabas andun din sya to take credit", "si Kim Chiu na pag walang loveteam irrelevant, magaling naman si Kim kaya lang di maiangat ni Dyogi ng solo artist", "Hirap na hirap si Vice tulongan yan sa Showtime ano ano nalang sinasabi eh"]}

{"dialog": ["I really believe masyadong malaki at sobrang dami nilang kinuhang venues sa NA tour nila. Outside Filipinos kasi and mangilan ngilang foreign listeners, sobrang niche ng Ppop sa NA. I'm a Bini fan pero they should've gone with smaller venues like what SB19 opted for. Like test the waters lang muna.   \n  \nThough hindi naman kailangan sold out para mag generate ng profit ang isang concert especially if may sponsors. Typically madaming bumibili lang ng tickets very near the concert date, pero for sure may effect dito yung recent issue nila.", "Speaking of sb, mukhang di rin nila maso-sold out SG! Siguro iniisip ng producers na ito lang yung SEA stop, pupuntahan ng ibang SEA countries/jp/china. Sayang! Sana mag small venues din sila sa jp and Indo.", "kelan nga ang SG ng esbi? More than 50% sold na last time I checked sa X. Possibly bibilis ang ticket sales after kickoff kapag may vid na ng performances.\n\n\nMay Japan (no announcement yet of date and tix selling) and Taiwan (sold out) stops sila tho. They'll even be performing sa Hito Awards Taiwan prior to that.\n\n\nProblem ko with Singapore is the lack of promotion. Fanbases ang kayod magpromote together with the producer sa small gatherings. I hope may bigger platform sila like radio/channel/big socmed accounts and group na ma utilize to promote the con.\n\n\nedit: even the announcement of global fan package was posted by the fanbase's admin. I wonder if may official account ang producer and may own following like Pulp/LNPH/Applewood here sa PH.", "Natumbok mo. Also just checked, and august 24 ang SG. May time pa."]}

{"dialog": ["nauumay nako sa bini totoo lang.\ntheyre not songwriters.\nonly a few of them could REALLY sing.\n\n\nproblematic pa morales.\nsaw a live performance of SB19-- yun talaga yung TALENT.", "1st sentence, tell that also to kpop groups.", "i only know blackpink. sorry. yung recent magkakamukha lang din kasi", "Natawa ako dito hahaha"]}

{"dialog": ["I wonder kung mayuwi sa kasuhan yan with the sponsors.  Its not just because walang gustong manood, but because may nangyari kasi that could have led to low sales.", "Pero matagal nang open yung ticket selling. This week lang naman nagkaissue.", "I wonder kung pababa na yung hype ng Bini.", "Naging laughing stock na nga yung tatlo eh ahhaha kaya bababa talaga hype sa kanila, yung mga casual viewers hindi na sila seseryosohin katulad kay maris na issue pa rin ang binibring up sa kanya sa sochmed. Basta may nakakadiri issue hindi na yun maalis sa pangalan ng tatlo bini"]}

{"dialog": ["No idea why they thought they were on this level. XG which is alot better than them are gradually growing their fan base. \n\nThey just did Coachella. Theyre working the circuit in Korea and are swinging to Latin America. \n\nThis looks to be greed.", "It's also easy to love XG because their members have this Japanese politeness in front of the camera. I can't say the same for some of the BINI girls.", "For sure. If you saw the documentary, Simon instilled this in them. \n\nThere was a clip where Simpn told them to close their social media accounts. Something to the effect of do you want to post something that youll regret later? \n\nVery much relevant at this moment. \n\nThe girls are sweethearts. Theyve been unproblematic as talented as they are. \n\nSo far anwyay. I hope it stays that way."]}

{"dialog": ["Mas gugustohin iba na mag work kesa manood ng concert. Ang mahal ng ticket nila!", "truee, saka baka ibenta na lang din ng iba yung tickets nila dahil sa issue", "No problem dyan kasi pasok na sa producer yung pera."]}

{"dialog": ["to be fair ang laki din kasi ng capacity ng venue nila, eh first time palang naman nila mag concert diyan.", "Ang bilis din kasi ma sold out nung last North America concert nila, akala sguro nila pag nag concert ulit sila mabilis ulit ma sold out. \n\nChineck ko din yung sa Vancouver and sobrang dami pang available na tickets. Luging lugi sila kung lahat ng north america nila ay hindi mag sold out. Sana inuna muna nila ang Pilipinas", "That may be one of the issues. Hindi kase talaga sila engaging sa live performances. Wala silang vocal stability talaga when singing live kaya madalas para silang pumipiyok. Not to mention obvious na hinhingal sila pag nagpe-perform. They rely mainly sa backing track. Sa Pinas they can get away with this especially since may back-up singers din silang sumasalo. So yung ibang mga nakapanood sa kanila before sa North America probably realized they won't get their money's worth kaya di na uulit."]}

{"dialog": ["They should have just gotten a smaller venue then if there's a demand for more tickets then they could either upgrade the venue to a bigger one or book a second night on the same venue, this is what small rock bands do when they perform for the first time in a new market to see if the demand is there.", "Overestimation siguro to. Canada din ata yung inupgrade nila na venue last time. Nilakihan venue kasi sold out na pero may demand pa. Ito ata masyado naman malaki.", "Yeah, mas maganda sana imarket na pag maliit yung venue ilalagay nila pag na sold out ang isang venue na either **sold out**, **upgraded venue** or **added date**, para mamarket nila na may demand sila sa ibang bansa."]}

{"dialog": ["I fear baka di na sila makapag world tour after this. Baka sasabay na lang sa ASAP para makapagshow outside PH.", "Balik BGYO level", "I wish them well, though. Di lang talaga ako bilib sa venue picks. Mas malaking venue kasi mas mahal ang production cost. And kapag di nakapagROI, most likely di na makaulit. Iniisip ko na lang na magiging good outcome eh magiging inclined ang management na ifocus ang promotions nila sa PH since andito naman yung solid fanbase nila. And makakapag nationwide tour na sila sa mga provinces na di nila napuntahan last year."]}

{"dialog": ["i went to their concert last year dito sa toronto (which is actually sa oshawa lol) and madami talagang seats na hindi occupied pero pinapalabas nila sa socmed na sold out daw. this was around august ata last year, tapos babalik sila with just 1 new song so wrong move talaga.\n\nyung blackpink nga na years ago pa last nag concert dito hindi pa nasosold out yung tickets eh, sila pa kaya?", "They have more than one new song. They have a whole new EP and (allegedly) a second one waiting for release.  But the fact that you (and many others) dont know about the new EP is part of the problem. I cant tell if its just lack of interest or wrong promotional tactics by their management.", "oh righttt i totally forgot about that, yun yung puro english songs. medyo forgettable kasi yung EP na yun for me huhu sorry"]}

{"dialog": ["There is a cost of living crisis where everyone is living paycheck to paycheck. Di afford ng tao and di enough ang disposable income.", "Prices have gone up since pandemic pero nung nag-concert ang Eheads in 2023 sa Hamilton, Ontario marami pa rin ang nanuod. Parang di naman ramdam ang paycheck to paycheck living condition. I just dont think ganon kasikat ang BINI internationally.", "Yup, madami silang casual listeners especially Pantropiko and salamin salamin era, and maybe they keep coming back to those songs, but not everyone are fan enough to spend $50 (yan yata pinakamura ticket price) or give a few hours of their time just to watch them. Hindi priority kumbaga."]}

{"dialog": ["Oooh di kaya sinadya ilabas yung pdf video para may reason to cancel or postpone the concert? Para hindi masyado mapahiya dahil ang totoo, hindi talaga bumenta ang tickets? Oh my Hahahaha mas masakit sa pride yun kaysa sabihing may questionable attitude ang 3 members", "hala possible totoo theory mo na yan, or kung hindi man sadya ilabas yung video, i think may maganda dulot din sa kanila ang video na yun, may magagamit sila rason kung bakit hindi sila naka sold out. Nakakahiya ksi kapag nalamn na hindi nila nagawa mag sold out outside Philippines, sa Philippine arena nga binili na lng ng management ang ticket para masabi sold out, kaya pala grabe ang ads ng concert nila na yun pati sa led screen naka display ang ads yun pala para makabawi sa mga ticket na hindi nabenta", "Tama. Also, parang mas malaki ang impact if malaman ng mga tao na hindi sold out ang tickets or halos walang bumibili dahil *palaos na or wala ng hype*. Kasi mas magtuloy-tuloy yan and ma condition ang mind ng mga tao na wala na talaga silang appeal. Hanggang dun lang sila sa Pantropiko days. Yes nakakahiya yun dahil pride nila yan. Sana di muna nila tinarget ang international music scene. Nagfocus muna sila dito. Mga catchy na tagalog songs muna."]}

{"dialog": ["Hold on, mga mhie. If you were to ask yung mga CASUAL LISTENERS ng BINI parang apat lang yata yung kanya nilang sobrang sumikat  Gatas na gatas naman", "Tbh salamin at pantropiko lang alam ko", "true  those saka yung Cherry then Karera"]}

{"dialog": ["Akala cguro ka level sila ng BTS", "Jhope and Suga nga maliit lang na arena ang venue tpos nag theater pa ata si Suga na venue to think na sila superstar talaga."]}

{"dialog": ["Mahirap na daw kasi ang buhay sa Toronto, Canada. Pinoys would rather work na lang daw.", "Lol or di lang sila kilala. My white washed pinoy cousins dont even know them"]}

{"dialog": ["More! More! Para magtanda yang mga BINI members na hindi sila nakakaangat porket sikat. Dito lang naman sila sikat. Lumaki na mga ulo lalo na yang Colet, anger anger pa nalalaman gusto magpaka edgy. Bumalik sana sila sa kangkungan ng malaman nila ang responsableng paghandle ng fame. Andiyan na ang SB19, hindi pa humingi ng tips.", "true maging starlet sana sila ulit para hindi na sila magrereklamo sa privacy nila, Tutal gigil na gigil sila sa mga tao dinudumog sila, after nila magpapansin sa tiktok bigla ayaw pala nila pansinin sila kapag nakita sila sa public"]}

{"dialog": ["Bro they don't have the discography or the pull for things like this. I remember someone said \"Full album Muna Bago concert\" tapos parang nagalet hahaha", "PWEDENG MAG WAIT KA??? \n\nHAHAHAHA"]}

{"dialog": ["OA naman niyan. Ayaw ba nila mag start sa small venues?", "Ambisyoso masyado ang management nila eh."]}

{"dialog": ["Tapos pang asap performance lang yung ipapakita.  kaloka! Taas ng pangarap.", "Dagdag mo may mga ADS PERFORMANCE pa  kakahiya sila kapag dinala pa nila ang mga ads na yan dyan sa world tour nila"]}

{"dialog": ["Gatas na gatas kasi sila. Umay din yung sunod sunod concert nila.", "I think ABS-CBN is a terrible management agency when it comes to this.\n\nThey only know how to cover up issues but not maintain popularity."]}

{"dialog": ["Tbf naman with Bini, di pa sila talaga makakapuno ng world tour levels talaga. They're not that big yet internationally.", "Ambitious lang talaga yung manman. Sana tinest lang muna nila how big their fanbase for next World tour. Siguro sold out yung con nila since matagal na din nag ticket selling."]}

{"dialog": ["Kahit last Canada concert nila ay ilang beses na-move ang sched ang venue. Tsaka madalas nagpapa 70% off discount ang abs near the event kapag hindi pa rin puno ang venue. Afaik, ganun ginawa last time kaya naging sold out", "Lol kahit yung recently concluded na SMtown concert sa Mexico ganun din ginawa para ma-sold out lang tickets."]}

{"dialog": ["Yung mga Filipino sa East Coast have not heard of Bini, unlike sa West Coast na medyo kilala sila. Ok naman yung sales ng Pechanga Resort and sa San Francisco. Pero daming bakante sa Chicago and NY venues. \n\nAng daming factors ang dapat i-consider if you are going to watch a Filipino act like Bini. People who live far would have to travel, and they have to spend money on hotels and in- city transpo. Hindi na biro yung gastos, so it would have been better is nag-concentrate sila sa Asian region then grow from there.", "This is true. I know them because theyre one of the Pop groups that first popped up with MNL48. But majority no one really listens and knows them. Should have started small before going big."]}

{"dialog": ["Parang hindi pang long term goal ng management nila which could lead to their downfall nga. \n\nAs a huge fan of Itzy, sad to say baka yung hirap ng pagretain ng hype nila ay mangyari rin sa BINI, to think management din ang may kagagawan kung bakit. Kaibahan nga lang nila may social media training ang KPOP group.", "Cherry on Top = Sneakers"]}

{"dialog": ["what if mapuno yan may masabi pa din ang pinoy  pinoy nga naman hilaan pababa crab mentality", "Philippine arena nga hindi na sold out, impossible na kaya pa bilhin ng management ang mga ticket hindi na benta para lang masabi sold out katulad ng ginawa nila sa Philippine arena"]}

{"dialog": ["Daming nagmamagaling dito. Have you guys ever thought that maybe the agenda is not to sell out? Maybe its building credibility or Filipino fanbase around the world - a build-up move. Maybe its as simple as wanting to perform for the Filipino fans outside of PH. You guys assume that their target even extend beyond pinoys when obviously that is not the case, so what is even the significance of telling they are not ready for the global stage, when they are not even trying to perform in a global stage. Do you see them marketing Bini outside of the filipino fanbase? I dont think so!! \n\nhaha seriously I get the issue and everything but people here are nagmamagaling and honestly just assuming shit because they are playing abroad. there are some happy-go-lucky filipinos out there who would spend for this to get out of their busy lives and maybe get a taste of ph culture. so go place your analysis somewhere else!! not ready for the global stage my ass, they arent even marketing for the global s...", "Do you really think they would rent out more expensive venues (mas malaki, mas higher cost) kung wala silang expectation? You all always reason out na \"business is business\" kapag may questionable decisions ang management nila, but suddenly it's not and they just wanna treat their fans? Bobo haha"]}

{"dialog": ["Pwede ba makita yung sa OOR? Kami dito hintay lang sa pinas muna kung kailan.", "Huy sama if ever bumalik sila"]}

{"dialog": ["Ilan daliri mo te? Naka 3 album/ep na sila. Tig 3 songs each lang ba laman per album?", "So bakit halos ad jingles laman ng setlist nila?"]}

{"dialog": ["**Sa Pinas, kahit may scandal ang celeb, parang walang nangyari. Basta marunong umiyak sa TV at magpost ng hugot apology, back to regular programming na ulit. Mabilis makalimot ang tao, lalo na pag may bagong issue. And lets be honest, as long as youre still benta sa masa, kebs na si brand, pera pa rin ang habol.Redemption arc is life, at minsan pa nga, mas sumisikat pa after the chismis. Maris, Coco, Tumbong, and others are saying hi**", "Never na cancel si Coco Martin at late na rin na realize ng tao na groomer pala yun pero too late na. Si Daniel Padilla mga 1 year walang project yun habang si Kathryn patuloy pa rin. Si Maris nakabawi pero yung \"Happy Skin\" na endorsement niya nagisa kaya di talaga nalimutan ng tuluyan\n\nSa Bini kasi fresh talaga saka yung sila Coco Martin, etc. ay di naman mga \"women empowerment\" advocates na malaki ang fanbase sa mga bata kaya yari ang BINI dito kahit pa makabawi sila", "Si tumbz nawala sa kfc, pepsi, at bpi. Not sure kung emperador pa rin sya pero wala na rin alam ko. Buti na lang medyo ok ang incognito nila.", "Yung Emperador Coffee lang naman ang profuct endorsement ni Tumbong with Emperador."]}

{"dialog": ["Ang may malaking fanbase sa Bini na casuals ay si Mikha and Aiah. Makikita mo yan sa sigawan sa mga events nila. \n\nAng may pinaka dedicated na active fanbase ay si Maloi. Her fanbase group actively sponsors Bini events. Ang yaman ng fanbase nya. \n\nThe three? Asa gitna si Jho at Colet. Least popular si Stacey.", "I remember nung lumabas yung photocards nila sa jabee nagiiyakan yung mga bata when they didnt get Stacey. All the little kids wanted her! Anyare? Sa mga bata lang yata siya popular. I get it tho, personally she ranks the least among the members for me", "Kasi Stacey ang yung girly and princess ata hahaha"]}

{"dialog": ["Let's be honest, yung tatlong involved is nasa mid/low popularity. Their endorsements and projects will start getting affected kapag yung top members ang nagka-issue na malala. I think Aiah and Mikha are the most popular, maybe Maloi din pero ilang buwan na siya di nilulubayan ng issue with zild pero wala naman effect sa popularity nila.", "Kaya nga buti nagrelease sila ng statement dahil kundi may bagong video daw na irerelease na involve naman yung top members ng Bini", "Naaah. Feeling ko bluff na lang yang video na yan. Kung totoong feeling nya ay Garosero sya ng Pinas, maglalapag at maglalapag yan ng videos and receipts ng baho ng bini. Lalo na ngayon na nagrelease ng statement and not everyone sides with the group, eto talaga chance nya magexpose. Pero asan na? Naghanap lang yan ng clout sa true lang."]}

{"dialog": ["Baka magpull out jollibee. Or nagpull out na. They do it so quietly", "Sadly oo. Malamang hindi na sila irerenew knowing na pambata ang theme ng Jolibee. Imagine may new ads ang bini tapos makikita mo sa com sec yung mga issues na binabato sa kanila. Kung ako jolibee iiwas ako sa ganto.", "Jollibee is notorious with dropping endorsers agad basta may scandal. Kasama sa contract nila yun tapos need bayaran yung contract/nagastos ng buo. Yung kay maris and anthony, para hindi magbayad ng buo, pinalitan nila for fyang. Buti nga pumayag jollibee corp eh."]}

{"dialog": ["at this point feeling ko talaga di naman kayo galit sa bini dahil sa issue nung tatlo, hate niyo lang talaga ang bini. asal hater lang eh", "It was the perfect opportunity to pin them down.\n\nYung isa ngang madalas mag-post dito, avid fan ng ibang group. He was literally bashing BINI in older comments for their talents, which has nothing to do with the gravity of the offense in the leaked video. \n\n\nHindi ko sinasabi na hindi valid ang uproar, pero meron at merong nakikisakay na hater lang talaga.", "mga nagtatago yan dati na mga haters. naghihintay lang ng timing para maging valid ang hate nila sa bini kahit nadamay lang namn ang 5 dahil sa tatlo and at least callout the men too. very obvious talaga sila"]}

{"dialog": ["Sobrang tagal na po kasi nangyari yan at nag-apologize na rin sila. Hindi pa rin ba maka-move on? Endorsers know better.", "maasim na blooms spotted HAHAHHAHAHAHA", "*grooms"]}

{"dialog": ["Parang wala na sila sa Samsung. Lately open na sila sa pagflex ng iphone nila", "nagka commercial ba ang bini for Samsung? parang product placement lang namn ang nangyayari nuon haha"]}

{"dialog": ["From someone who used to work for Marketing, their issue is too small to pull out. Nagpupull pa rin naman sila ng sales. Also, mejo nagdie down na yung issue. Sadyang dito na lang ata sa reddit at x maingay. Plus, theyre currently out of the country na. Wala na sila masyadong ganap in the next 1-2 mos dito. So wala. Makakalimutan na ng karamihan yang issue na yan.", "Which is sad"]}

{"dialog": ["Im still disappointed kay Jhoanna, Colet, Stacey. Hindi na nakaka-good vibes whenever I think of BINI. And to think my underage niece is fangirling over them. Nakaka-disappoint.", "Ilayo mo sa BINI ang underage niece mo. Pagbebembang sa isang 13 years old ginawa lang katatawanan kahit sa inuman or private conversations with green jokes hindi normal yan."]}

{"dialog": ["All these endorsements pero never naisip ng Kopiko sumali...\n\nSa isla nag kopiko.\nnag kopiko nag kopiko", "Nescafe endorsers sla e"]}

{"dialog": ["NGL this is the reason why Star Magic Artists has better showbiz careers than any of its competitors. I mean grabeng scandal to and for them to control this. Imagine if Campaign Strategist mo ang Star Magic gurl baka maipanalo ka nila sa pagkapangulo.", "Kaya rin siguro naging Star Magic artist na si Ivana? Mahusay kasi PR control wahaha", "Uyyy. Kaya siguro ang tahimik ng pangalan nya ngayon", "Lakas makapabango ng image yung short stint niya as pbb houseguest."]}

{"dialog": ["Totoong walo hanggang dulo kasi kahit yung mga hindi naman kasali sa issue eh nadamay", "Ang off talaga non. Kung ako yun, alis na ako hahahahaha. Biruin mo di mo naman kasalanan tapos nasama pa name mo sa apology statement LOL nakakabastos fr", "After ng apology na yan, nagsilabasan yung mga solo stans kasi nagrereklamo kung bakit nadamay yung bias nila na di kasali. Tapos meron din ot5..", "Ganyan talaga kapag grupo. Di maiiwasan na may solo stans. Baka mas naging comfortable lang sila maging vocal after niyan kasi nga naman, nakakainis yung nangyaring damay damay."]}

{"dialog": ["never tlga ako naniniwala sa mga ganitong gawain yay, lalo ang gumagawa ay my issue", "wala pang issue nung nag viral yang pag tulong niya na yan pero hanep ng mga fans ginamit at pinagmukha na ngayon niya ginawa yan HAHAHA", "So meaning noon palang performative na, noted hahahhaa grabi grooms Ngayon ah"]}

{"dialog": ["Even before the issue, medyo na-ooff na ko pag nag gaganyan sila eh, para kasing di sincere sa pakiramdam ganon or maybe its just me idk", "Careful. Genuine daw yang charity work ng Bini according to fans. Masama ka daw na tao if di ka naniwala na genuinely good people sila.", "I mean mababait naman sila siguro (still doesn't excuse the jokes) pero baket kase kailangan pang videohan  ang pagtulong. That shit screams performative"]}

{"dialog": ["Months ago na po yang pagbigay po niya ng food. Not after the issue po.", "Yes pero yung post is recently lang. Bale they used old photos to support Binis recent issue", "Group ng fans yan sa FB di ba?"]}

{"dialog": ["Bago ba yan?", "Ang alam ko yung photos parang months ago pa yan eh. Pero siyempre the blooms aka grooms still gon eat it up", "Ahhh. That explains. Kasi I dont think Jollibee would want their kid friendly brand to be used as a mop para malinis yung grooming sexual abuse issue ng endorser nila. Mas ayaw ma-associate ng Jollibee sa ganyan\n\nMagiging problema yan sa contract nila with Jollibee, if this really came from ABS/ Bini PR Team. Yare sila big time sa sponsor nila bat ginawang sacrificial vessel . Mukhang fan initiative, kaso mukhang di pinag-isipan that this would be a potential problem sa sponsor contract deal ng idols nila"]}

{"dialog": ["parang poverty porn vlogger \n\nHAHAHAHAHHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHHAHAHAHAHAHAHHAA", "same thought, it kinda screams poverty porn"]}

{"dialog": ["\"ang isang mali ay natabunan kaagad ng mga mabubuti mong nagawa sa kapwa\"\n\nso ang katumbas lang pala ng SA and grooming jokes involving a minor (na 13 years old pa)... ay magbigay ng jollibee sa kalsada\n\nsponsored pa yan ng jollibee malamang HAHAHAHA poverty porn at its finest", "Right?? Ano ibig nilang sabihin na natabunan na agad yung isang pagkakamali dahil lang may mabuti kang nagawa sa iba? Hindi ko talaga gets yung ganitong mindset, lalo na sa mga taong bulok ang values (silang tatlo), o sa pinapalabas ng PR team nila. Mali na nga yung ginawa, tapos sila pa ang magdidikta kung ano yung sapat/katumbas para mapatawad. Sino ba sila para sabihing okay na ang lahat? Dapat yung taong nasaktan o nagawan ng mali ang may karapatang magsabi kung sapat na yung sorry. Kalokaaaaaaaa! Jollibee lang pala katumbas"]}

{"dialog": ["Might be an unpopular opinion: But both can be true at the same time.\n\nSure, they can be nice, and kindhearted people. I always believed that everyone has some *goodness* in them. But they could also be crass, and rude, who are capable of making tasteless \"statutory rape\" jokes/statements.\n\nEto yung hindi matangap ng mga stans eh. Which is disappointing. They downplay such issues, making it look like it's \"a normal thing\" to do. They deflect. Delikado yung approach na yan since 1.) We don't want it to be normalized. Nothing about casually saying doing a sexual act to a 13 year old kid is okay. And 2.) It only enforces the idea that their idols haven't done anything wrong. Na \"wala yan, maliit na bagay lang yan\".\n\nHow can they \"***reflect, and learn from our mistake***\" kung sa simpleng PR Team statement eh OKAY NA ang lahat? Kaya tuloy ang ending walang nagbabago. They will just take a month long break, cool off, then *everything* ...", "Well said"]}

{"dialog": ["Sabi na. Idadaan na naman sa charity ekek. ABS really has the best yet overworked spin doctors. Sana sulit sahod nila. Hahaha", "matagal na yan bago pa yung issue.  it doesnt correct their mistake pero at least icorrect natin ung context."]}

{"dialog": ["Star magic ba ung page??", "Fan page lang po yan ng Bini. Di naman yan managed by star magic"]}

{"dialog": ["Fan account naman yan to be fair lang. It was an old picture.", "Same as sa comment ko sa iba, recent yung post but they used old photos (galawang kengkoy). \n\nAnd yes, its a fan page thats not managed by Star Magic. Pero I meant to point out the fact that they still garnered this much support (peep the FB reactions and comments) in spite of the issue. Just goes to show that Star Magics PR handling is top notch, to the point na kahit gaano kasahol pa issue nila they will still be blindly supported by their followers"]}

{"dialog": ["That fb page po is hindi managed by star magic/abs. Fan page lang yan.\n\nCorny na they posted that kasi parang nagpapaawa effect tuloy sila... and it will not help lalo na sa mga bashers pero please fact check muna tayo guys.\n\nDoon kayo mag react if galing sa official acct ng bini or star magic mismo.", "Yes, its a fan page thats not managed by Star Magic. Pero I meant to point out the fact that they still garnered this much support (peep the FB reactions and comments) in spite of the issue. Just goes to show that Star Magics PR handling is top notch, to the point na kahit gaano kasahol pa issue nila they will still be blindly supported by their followers"]}

{"dialog": ["naniwala naman kayo?", "Kagat na kagat ang mga stans eh, kesyo tAo lAnG nAmAn nAgKaKamALi"]}

{"dialog": ["She's just posting viral Tiktoks that use her song Supernatural. Dami nyang fineature actually, so it's not as bukod-tangi as it appears to be.", "Slay"]}

{"dialog": ["Kaya pala siya trending on X hahaha pinagkakaisahan na siya  \n\nIn the end Paulo Avelino is Paulo Avelino. Not even PR teams and the management can stop him", "d ko gets. nilaro lang niya yung bini statement w a gta meme bat siya kinuyog sa x?", "Deflection. Its easier to attack Paulo whos making fun of the apology than to face the fact that their idols did something wrong.", "grabe naman kasi yung ginawa ng tatlo. kahit anong klase argumento gawin mo, talo ka talaga eh. grooming x sexual jokes ba naman", "Ang dami pang nagde-defend na kesyo inside joke lang daw yon at lahat naman daw ganon. Jusmiyo, kung ganyan kayo mag-inside joke, kailangan niyong mag-reflect.", "totoo. hindi pala ganun 'kabait' sina jhoanna, colet, stacy.\n\nkay aiah na lang ako, pag pati sya nagloko, aray talaga."]}

{"dialog": ["Gago ang tapang niya kasi under siya ng ABS. HAHAHAHAHA potek ano kaya iisipin ng bosses nito.", "mayaman na siya pwede na siyang magretire", "Pwede siyang mag stream tbh. I watched him before, I'll watch him again.", "anong games nilalaro niya sa stream?", "First person shooter games like tarkov"]}

{"dialog": ["Ano movie tinutukoy niya dito?", "Yes, MLWMYD due to change date ng palabas nila yan", "E July 26, 2019 pa yung tweet", "UNg Bea Fiasco ung 2019 na nakita mo...check mo s a taas may SS nung tweet nya after maresched ung movie...\nInunfollow pa nga nya ung Star Cinema kaya napilitang gawing March na ung release instead na April sana hahah", "Hahahaha nalito ako. sinusundan ko yung line sa gilid."]}

{"dialog": ["Listahan ng mga matatapang na filipino:\n\n1. Jose Rizal\n2. Paulo Avelino", "Mhie, nahiya naman si Andres Bonifacio", "pumangatlo lang siya kay paulo", "Mas okay sakin ilagay si jose rizal sa pangatlo tas si andres sa 1. Si paulo, okay stay put sa number 2 hahaha"]}

{"dialog": ["Paulo Avelino is a gamer and hes probably sharing it because its GTA VI  Wala siyang pake dun sa template pero yung fans triggered na triggered naman", "Yun nga eh.. Busy yun sa games niya. Ano pakialam niya sa issue ng BINI. Nagrepost lang ng meme napagsabihan na ng kung anu-anong salita. Pati anak dinamay.", "Wait what??! May anak na sya??!", "Yes. Binatilyo na. Ex niya, kasamahan dati sa GMA. Binisita nila yung bata sa New York after ASAP Cali. Umuwi din dito noong Holy Week."]}

{"dialog": ["Nakakatawa mga gr00ms na nagsasabi na hindi daw relevant si Paulo Avelino kung walang ka-loveteam hahaha sige nga ipag solo career nila yang bb gh0rls nila, tingnan natin if maging relevant pa din.  Ang tataas ng tingin masyado sa idolettes nilang bangketa version ng Twice, compared kay Paulo na ang dami na napatunayan sa industry.", "Grabe yung bangketa version ng twice .\nHard core tlga ng pinoy mang lait. \nDi papatalo sa Korea .", "Yung anak ko nga sabi ginaya lang daw sila ng twice. Sabi ko nga matagal na twice b3h, kaya hindi ko na pinagtiktok don niya nakukuha yon eh.", "Sabi ko sana nak wag kang delulu"]}

{"dialog": ["Dami ng galit sakanya sa X ahhahaaha wala raw utang na loob", "Sinusumbatan na nga siya ng blooms. Kung hindi daw dahil s concert ng Bini, wala daw promotion movie nila ni Kimmy.", "\\*GROOMS HGAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA", "Hahahahahahahhaahhaha benta mga correction"]}

{"dialog": ["Ang tapang", "Kaya pala trending sa X ngayon, pinagkakaguluhan ng fans", "Kinukuyog nga ng mga blooms. May superiority complex pa naman yung mga yun"]}

{"dialog": ["Ung tatahitahimik lang pero pag bumanat talaga solid. Nagpost din yan about hindi pagtapos ng movie diba.", "Context nun movie boss.. thanks", "Nagkaron ng changes dun sa showing date nu movie nila Kim tas nagpost sya na maranansan/matry daw kaya nya wag tumapos ng pelikula."]}

{"dialog": ["Ang daming time ni Paulo", "hahaha! may inside joke mga fans nia na out of boredom kasi 2 days nasa cebu si kim for an event, kahapon ng gabi lang ang uwi, pinapauwi na nila si kim baka ano ulit ma post ni paulo hahaha", "Wahahahahaha oo nga"]}

{"dialog": ["Di ko gets yung Meme. Pwede po pa-explain? Thanks.", "afaik gta 6 is widely anticipated ng mga gamers since gta 5 is released 2013 pa. So yun laging meme yung about gta 6 kasi laging nadedelay.", "Yung statement niyan, statement mismo ng developers ng game kasi this year ata release nyan tapos delay na naman HAHAHA"]}

{"dialog": ["Umuusok ilong ng fans kasi ginagawang katatawanan ung serious issue as if their idols did not do it first. That apology was so insincere and fake that it deserves to be mocked.", "He's only attacking the insincerity of their apology so di ko alam kung ano kinakagalitan nila lol"]}

{"dialog": ["He let his intrusive thoughts win. Okay lang yan malakas ka naman sa ABS haha", "But he has not signed any management contract yet. Self managed sya. He really just has a weird sense of humor at naisip lang nya Ishare. I doubt if he thought much about it. Hahaha"]}

{"dialog": ["Yung mga blooms na nanay nila ay kimpau, lagot kayo nde na kayo bbgyan pera pambili ng concert ticket. G na G na twitter mga kimpau mothers haha!", "Hahaha benta din mga sagutan nila sa X"]}

{"dialog": ["Ang lakas mang asar may CTTO pa", "Para sa creator ng GTA kasi yun hindi BINI"]}

{"dialog": ["sinasabi pa ng mga fans ng bini na trash daw si Paulo avelino for making fun of the issue. atecco sino ba yung ginagawang kakatawanan ang sexual assault sa minor? luh. apaka fanatic talaga umuurong na ang utak", "They need to watch Fangirl starring Paulo HAHAHAHAHHAHAHA"]}

{"dialog": ["nakita ko rin yun i was like??? WHEBHSHD AMATS NI KUYA", "Gamer's joke yung sa GTA na hindi malaunch launch. Parang hindi naman siya aware sa issue ng BINI. Pero ngayon na nagviral na ang  hanash ng bloom. Malalaman na rin niya yan"]}

{"dialog": ["Ekis sakin yan si Paulo. \n\nDi yan sumayaw ng salamin salamin sa Biniverse PH Arena. \n\nPanira ng crowd energy.", "Kahit ako di sasayaw sa jologs na kanta  na yon hahhaa"]}

{"dialog": ["Context nito?", "Dapat VDay movie yung sa kanila ni Kim Chiu pero minove sa March ang showing. Mas malaki kasi potential kumita Vday so baka mas may chance sana na may bonus sila"]}

{"dialog": ["but he's only gettin bashed from people who dont matter. he could post more shit like this and abs aint going to do anything lmao\n  \n\npaulo: \"okay so fire me then...\"", "Real"]}

{"dialog": ["Grabe, parang mas offended pa kayo sa meme kaysa sa joke about grooming a 13-year-old. The meme made fun of the apology format, hindi yung issue mismo. Kung yun ang mas pinoproblema niyo, maybe check your priorities. At hindi lahat ng hindi sumasayaw sa concert KJ.", "True! Dun sa sexual joke hindi offended kasi inside joke kuno. Tapos ito grabe magalit haha!"]}

{"dialog": ["Wala nang makakalapit na tagahanga?", "di kasi nag bebembangan sa harap niya mga fans niya kaya di na sila makalapit"]}

{"dialog": ["real motto niya\n\n\"ahhh 13 years old\"", "Sinasabunutan"]}

{"dialog": ["Enjoy na enjoy ung mga tao sa downfall ng bini. They waited for this moment. Gotcha moment for them. Lols", "Bat parang kasalanan ng mga tao? Walang gotcha moment, kasi yung mismong Bini member naman ang upload ng video nya, meaning wala siyang nakitang mali dun sa content ng video nya which is all the more disappointing. Wag nyo isisi sa mga tao yung nangyayari sa Bini, what you're witnessing is the **consequences** of their actions."]}

{"dialog": ["I'm trying to wrap my mind around what the user wants.\n\n1. Anong gusto nya ma-achieve? Gusto lang ba turuan ng leason ang BINI? Anong klaseng accountability at pag apologize ang gusto nya?\n\n2. If sobrang polar opposite talaga sa nakikita publicly ang BINI at di dapat hangaan, why not release it all na agad? \n\nI guess what I am asking is, anong end game nya?", "Who cares what their motive/s are? If its the truth, its the truth. Bakit mo palalaguin ang buhay ng closeted kupal?", "Yun nga punto ko - the truth is the truth. Kung kupal talaga ang BINI, bat di pa nya ilabas lahat? Bakit kailangan may threat pa? \n\nWhich implies na may motive sila - and not just the truth. Be it clout, attention, influence, money, etc. Kasi if gusto lang nya either (1) pabagsakin ang BINI and/or  (2) gusto nya ilabas ang totoo - bakit di na lang ilabas?", "Theyre probably trying to circumvent crisis PR of the first wave ng pasabog. Whoever this is, they know their stuff and Star Magic has to pray to all the saints that the coming ones flop like the polvoron video. Hindi ito basta fan or friend lang.", "That makes a ton of sense actually. Tipong they did not put all their eggs in one basket. Knowing the ABS/Star Magic PR machine, they probably dont want to show their hand from the start.", "Oo kasi pwede nila yan ihingi ng patawad lahat in one fell swoop then isahang move on nalang. But if staggered ang paglabas, nagmamarinate sa masa ang paninira. Lalo na kung juicy or controversial ang nature ng mga susunod na materials. Haha", "Tapos kung sinister talaga plano nila, and they have TONS of evidence, they can also plan to catch ABS/Star Magic/BINI in their own lie, if they do lie.\n\nKasi yung unang apology message is the typical \"not-saying-anything-at-all\" PR apology. Walang details.\n\nSo if mapilitan sila maglabas with more details, tas naghalo ng inaccurate details, they can then spin it around. Parang ginawa ni Professor sa Money Heist season 2.", "I hope we channel the same energy pagdissect ng political issues no."]}

{"dialog": ["Star Magic bosses and sponsors are seated in a meeting somewhere, collectively holding their breaths.", "Hahaha I doubt it sis. The Filipinos are forgiving. I doubt this will even make a dent on how the masa perceive them and their fans will still accept them readily", "Nah this will make a dent. Wala na yung perfect \"binibini\" facade nila. Brands will not like that.\n\nIf magrebrand man, Di pa sure if mattripan ng tao if they went the rebellious path.", "Youre underestimating how Filipinos can sweep things under the rug. Maris, anyone?", "Maris overcame her issue kasi talented siya, and may tv series pa rin siya after pumutok yun. Ppl forgot it dahil sa acting nya sa incognito. may movies pa.\n\nEh ang bini when was their last hit single?"]}

{"dialog": ["Sana naman walang issue si GWEN", "I checked BaliLeeg's posts sabi nya ang wala daw issue sa bini ay si Sheena at Aiah", "Di ba si Sheena yung naggagaya sa ngongo? Nagsasalita ng ngongo smth like that sa vid nila", "Yess siyaa. So kung wala siya na content for Sheena, meron na naman, which is yung ngongo. I guess si Aiah lang ang winner for today.", "Idk how they find it funny lol ang cringe. It's not even cutesy to act that way."]}

{"dialog": ["I'm sure pwedeng siyang kasuhan niyan.", "kung covered naman yung account niya baka walang taong mahanap. yung kay illiad kaya lang naman nahanap yon dahil may footprint siya ng identity.\n\n  \nyung source ng pics and vids? if kasuhan nila yon baka mag backfire lalo lol. parang 60% against sa bini tapos 40% mga fans nag dedefend.", "X can be compelled to comply to release the user data IF there is a court order", "Oo nga kaya wala padin takas delekado talaga siya pag ganun. Sana bumili nalang siya ng acc ng ibang tao hahaha."]}

{"dialog": ["So, yung source ay close din sa Bini? Tsktsk disturbing. Mahirap na magtiwala kahit kanino.", "Kung di ka pa naman gaga at anak ni satanas wala ka dapat ikatakot kahit may pasecret pa na magvideo sa yo hahah", "Sa true. Kung matino at disenteng tao ka, di ka mabobother.", "Embarrassing drunk pics like making out with random strangers at kahit nakahubad ka pa hindi yan magiging issue whatsoever."]}

{"dialog": ["villain era si ante ko, what's his/her villain story kaya? HAHA", "Si fonzi na bahalang gumawa ng video dito hahahaha fonz pasokk!! BABY ONE AND ONLYYY", "you're my one and only  caring ka kaseee"]}

{"dialog": ["Oh spicy!  This is going to be interesting! Ano pa kaya ang tinatago ng BINI? I wonder what other kinds of inappropriate jokes they might be telling? could there be more than just the grooming jokes? \n\nAlways remember making light of rape, abuse, depression, body shaming and grooming isn't just tasteless, It's morally reprehensible!  If you think that's acceptable humor, you're not just an idiot, you're MORALLY BANKRUPT!", "si Maloi nga diba tamang panggaya  lang sa mga may kapansanan . Feeling ko dark humor enjoyers yang mga yan eh. Tbh maraming ganyo Kaso public figure sila need nila maging sensible and responsible coz a lot of ppl are looking up to them :) thats the price of fame", "Not a bini fan tbh pero lahat naman ata ng tao ay may dark jokes like death etc. Ayun nga lang, sikat kasi sila and may image silang pinapangalagaan so lagot.\n\nTbh at this point, kahit yata drunk pics nila or vaping pics nila kukutyain sila ng mga tao. Kahit anong maliit na kapintasan ay big deal pag sikat ka lol"]}

{"dialog": ["Excited na talaga mga taga ChikaPH sa pagbagsak ng bini", "Hindi siya talaga chika sub, hate sub talaga. The number of hours or days people spend hating dito sa sub. Kung sinong celebrity man ang may pumutok na issue, may mga kating-kating mag-comment.\n\nI guess that's the \"power\" of anonymity. Lumalakas ang loob ng mga tao at nagkakaroon ng validity ang wrath.", "people throw rocks at things that shine.\nbut this timez its valid to hate on them."]}

{"dialog": ["Yan tama iyan para silbing lesson sa lahat\n\nWhat you leave your footprint on the internet stays forever and ever \n\nGoodbye bini hope you share the same fate as BGYO", "Anyare po sa BGYO?", "Not sure pero may member na cheater and abuser daw..."]}

{"dialog": ["wala bang ganto para sa mga politiko?", "meron ung sa Senate blue ribbon committee at office of the ombudsman kaya nga lang taon tatagal ung mga ganun...", "I mean, private anonymous accounts like BaLiLeeg can easily expose them"]}

{"dialog": ["Ano naman mapapala niya dito? Twisted yata utak nito. Tapos abang na abang naman mga taga chikaph. Mukhang sayang saya makita pagdapa ng iba. May pa seated seated pa. Ew", "For someone whos chronically online sa ChikaPH subreddit, part pa ng top 5% commenters, and has thrown around snarky and nasty takes on celeb issues featured sa sub, this comment is wild. The audacity is almost inspirational. Are you even reading your comments mo sa sub? Ew", "Yan gusto ko kalkal kung kalkal haha"]}

{"dialog": ["Garo Sero vs Kim Soo Hyun lang atake ni atecco", "Best thing about it is kapag nagbigay sila ng explanation about doon sa narelease na, may chance na may tinatago pang evidence na magcocontradict sa explanation na nabigay na. Maeexpose din if ever kasinungalingan lang yung explanation.", "Dig your grave deeper ang atake"]}

{"dialog": ["TBF I feel like sa mga ugali Ng girls at tabas Ng dila, nagiipon lng din tlga Sia at madami Lang din tlga lapses Yong girls na cinocondone at dinedefend Ng fans\n\nMatagal na sila cinacall out sa ibat ibang behaviour, madami nang pwede gamitin against sknila", "You call them lapses? Damn hahahah", "I was being nice hehehehe"]}

{"dialog": ["Kawawa naman si Alden, nadamay pa dito sa issue na to", "Yung anak ni Alden at Maine member pala ng Bini"]}

{"dialog": ["hmmmm dapat di niya innanounce plano niya, dapt nakascheduled post na yung meron siya, di pa pala tapos kaabang abang to. hehe", "Or ung biglang naguupload sa stories hehehe"]}

{"dialog": ["I don't think they have anything other than BINI members partying or having ugly and problematic boyfriends. This account thinks Mikha partying with Joao is problematic and incriminating. \n\nPero may nag-'expose' na dati kay Mikha (same accounts na nag-expose ng BGYO Nate vs. AC Bonifacio issue) na she calls Blooms \"dogs\" daw in private or something, na jowa/ex-jowa niya si BGYO Gelo and accused/implied na nag-ddrugs siya.", "Not surprising if some or all of them are exposed to drugs, even the girls. Lalo na lagari ang work nila at wala pahinga. Kalakaran yan sa entertainment industry"]}

{"dialog": ["I.am.seated. Bagal.  Bilis na para isang bagsakan na. Matatabunan pa yan ng eleksyon.", "ilabas na lang after election para di matabunan."]}

{"dialog": ["PR team would be working overtime", "PR team nila pagod na pagod na"]}

{"dialog": ["Kakaunti na nga ang Bini team may nang ttraydor pa. Not a good sign para sa inaasam na world domination, mukang may humaharang sa mismong circle nila.", "Kahit walang traydor sa kanila, walang mangyayaring world domination. Creative direction pa lang nila, fail na"]}

{"dialog": ["I thought BINI is different from BGYO. Hindi pala. Sa bagay they choose their friends eme sila.", "Show me your friends and I'll tell you who you are."]}

{"dialog": ["Feeling ko hindi downfall ehh. Mag lie low lang yan sila saglit tapos kapag di na maingay ang issue babalik na yan sila ulit. \n\nTignan niyo nalang yung cheating scandal kay Anthony-Maris. Hindi man pareho ng issue pero ang point ko ay di naman uso cancel or downfall dito sa pinas. Nakakapagod din kasi mang hate ng tao kaya ang ending papatawarin nalang natin as if walang nangyari.", "sa una lang naman magaling mag-cancel dito sa pinas pero eventually makakalimutan din yung issue", "Well si Toni G hanggang you tube na lang.", "Believe me after how many years makakabalik yan sa network either abs or gma. Makakalimutan din issues niyan. Kung mag aartista pa isa sa mga anak niya for sure kakagatin ng mga tao.", "I don't think so. Maliit lang industry nila and what she did was so unethical.", "Ang daming unethical sa industriya nila. Si bong revilla nga gumagawa pa ng series at pelikula tapos senador pa kahit nagnakaw ng malaking pera. Si toni pa kaya na sumuporta lang.", "Ibang usapan to. Pinutol talaga ni Toni yung connection nya with everyone in the industry. It left a bad taste in your mouth. I don't think anyone from management would risk getting her again.", "Sinong pinutol, recently lang nag meeting siya with charo santos para siguro mag movie sa film outfit nila. Mga nag guest sa tonitalks, si coco martin, piolo, jonathan manalo ng star music. Okay din siya sa gma at tv5. Hindi lng abs ang network. Ang lawak ng showbiz."]}

{"dialog": ["Mag coachella pa sila charot", "Walang pag asa mka pag coachella yan, hindi kakagat western audience sa discography nila, hindi din maganda pang festival setting songs nila.", "Bakit naman hindi maganda na pangcoachella? Hinfi ako bini fan ah. Tamang lurking lang ako dito. Nagustuhan ko din Pantropinko (kung mali spell bahala na)  Naappreciate ko naman sila kaya lang mas naging interesado ako sa ibang ppop group. Haha", "Leaning masyado sa  bubblegum pop and kulang talaga sila sa genre experimentation/depth tsaka lyrics nila is basic, shallow &  playing safe masyado ( which is understandable kasi mostly fans nila are kids and minors ) pero it will not resonate well sa western audience lalo nat super diverse pa naman audience ng coachella ( based on my experience since i attended 2019,22,24 ), it's good nga na may english songs sila but underwhelming and too generic naman, kulang talaga sa firepower/kick discography nila to get people engaged sa isang musicfest setting, tsaka limited lang din talaga Slots ng coachella  for asian acts, for years now 1 slot lang talaga nabibigay for Girlgroups and Mostly Kpop acts nakukuha since malakas hatak nila tlga, This year nga lang sila nag invite ng Girlgroup outside korea which is XG, well understandable din since complete package sila,i suggest na i watch mo performance ng XG sa coachella atleast same sila with Bini na may english songs yet malayo lang ...", "Wow. Thank you sa explanation. Akala ko walang magrereply eh. Now I was convinced.", "No worries hehehe, don't get me wrong ah i'm a bini fan pero underwhelming talaga comebacks nila, sadly wala talaga silang competition dito sa pinas so kahit titipirin ng starmagic yung comebacks nila eh open arms na i accept ng blooms yung mga kanta pero yun na nga hindi masyado nag hit outside sa fandom recent comebacks nila, sayang talaga hindi nila nasakyan yung momentum nung pantropiko/salamin2x.", "Hindi ba considered na competition nila ay ibang ppop group lalo na ang sb19? Or baka hindi mo iallow kc girl group ang bini while sb19 ay boy group?", "If PH lang mag focus yep ibang ppop groups yung considered competion nila which is dominated nila as a girlgroup, if against sb19 naman mga fans lang yung nag aaway sa 2,pero in reality malaki talaga difference ng boygroup vs girlgroup.\n\nBut if gusto ng Bini mag tap sa international scene eh ibang usapan na yun since madami competition sa international, Kpop,Jpop,Cpop may mga global groups din like Katseye/XG soo they need to step up if gusto nila magka ingay name nila internationally."]}

{"dialog": ["Hard lesson kay Colet ,if magtanda siya!! Di na niya pwede gamitin ang entitled personality or else babalik sakanya yan.", "Si colet na akala mo nakakatuwa pagiging anger nia lagi, sa totoo lang bastos siya sumagot sa socmed pero sa mga diehard fans nila cute na cute sila sa ganyang attitude nia.", "Kaya di ko magawang maging fan nila (although like ko ung ibang songs nila), kasi they're not good example sa youth and kids. Pabalang at sarcastic pa sumagot sa soc med, walang breeding. Feeling cool pag ganyan ung sagot. Ang natutuwa lamg jan eh ung mga wala ding breeding na fans ehh, sa true lang.", "lalo pa lumaki ang ulo nian ni Colet dahil sumikat sila kaya pabalbal magsalita eh", "Parang si Fyang  yung balbal eme magsalita akala mo kinacool. Parang squammy naman.", "True, iba ang generation ngayon they find it cool ung mga squammy na ugali", "Walang kaclass-class atecco"]}

{"dialog": ["Maybe its not a total downfall, but the stain is there for good. That digital footprint isnt going anywhere. The whole empowered women image, especially from those three, turns out to be nothing but hollow performance. Some of their fans whining about people criticizing the girls looks while happily tearing into the two guys in the clip. Wild.", "Agree. Diehard blooms will, of course, still be there supporting them. But casual listeners (like me and my sisters + mom) will surely have second thoughts na about them. I honestly found myself skipping their songs na on shuffle. Then nadiscover ko pa ibang kwento about some of their members and lets just say, colet is probably the shittiest among the girls hahahah", "Abangan ko yang Colet Issue sa X", "MAG WAIT KA TALAGA HA", "Yesssss bored pako sa buhay abang2 ng bagong chismax lng muna hobby ko"]}

{"dialog": ["Parang another day at the office lang yan sa executives and staff sa network nila.\n\nCoco groomer,  Mariz cheater so are  Andrea Brillantes, Daniel Padilla. etc  May mga career pa din naman. Si Gerald buong career niyan ganyan, Julia B.  \n\n  \nSpecialty nila yan ng PR spin doctors ng network\n\n  \nPero tingnan pa rin natin.  Yung boygroup nila parang di ko narin mahagilap kung may ganap pa ih,", "True. Ibang iba ang level of acceptance ng knetz vs. ph netz. Masyadong forgiving ang mga Pinoy. Not to mention mahina ang moral compass. Some of their fans, and even casuals, dont see anything wrong with what the three members did. So, I dont think this issue will cause BINIs downfall.", "Both are terrible tbh. Knetz's toxicity has driven people to commit suicide.", "Yeah, theyre two extremes imo."]}

{"dialog": ["I hope not. Nakakainis lang kasi ang ganda ng usad at trajectory ng career nila pero anak ng yawa. Ambobo lang. Nung naging sikat sila all the more dapat na naging mahigpit ang management gaya ng ginagawa sa Korea.\n\nKasi isang sablay lang may backlash for sure.\n\nTapos since mga bagets ang majority ng fan base nila dapat pinush ang relationship ban. Taeng tae sa mga lalake amp. Most ng issues na daw it sila may kasama ding lalake.\n\nSayang lang, rooting for them to succeed globally. Pero malaking dagok sa pagiging genuine nila sa women empowerment advocacy yung maikling video na pucha nag mukha silang plastic. Na damay pa lahat", "that's the reason why mahigpit ang idol culture sa korea at japan pagdating sa mga interactions nila sa mga male friends at co-idols nilang lalaki", "Wala namang magagawa kung ganun na talaga yung mindset or humor nila, may interaction man sa male idols o wala. They can still post and joke about these things even without them.\nNot saying not to condemn the other two, but yea.", "I guess in a way you're also on point on that.\nA case of nurture and nature perhaps.\n\nHopefully this becomes a wake up call for the management to do something. At the end of the day nadamay lahat, hopefully the weight of that can change them for the better.\n\nHard conversations from within them for sure will happen."]}

{"dialog": ["not really a downfall kasi (sa totoo lang) ang daming madaling mautong pinoy na walang moral compass. mukhang wala din brand na nag pull out sakanila ng endorsement and super protektado ng management kaya never icocover ng news outlets. lalo na at matatabunan yung issue nila ng ibang events like announcement ng pope and election. siguro nga di na nila need ng interview ala maris racal.\n\nyung tipong: socmed statement  tahimik sandali  release ng MAGANDANG song (should be a bop or else they are gonna catch another stray from people) lang na course of action then boogsh limot na yan ng mga tao lalo na at marami silang parasocial fans at iba rin talaga ang grip nila sa masang pinoy.\n\npero one thing for sure stained na yung image nila and di na mappreach yang \"women empowerment\" front kasi magmumukha nalang silang performative clowns if ginawa pa nila yun. \n\nand also the stan twt, kpop stans, and other rival ppop groups are gonna be ruthless to them. lalo na yung mga blooms noon a...", "socmed statement  tahimik sandali  release ng MAGANDANG song (should be a bop or else they are gonna catch another stray from people)\n\n  \nyeah about that, puro english kanta nirerelease and they haven't released a good follow up yet sa viral tracks nila", "oo continuous discourse yan ng mga tao since last year after ng salamin kung bakit puro english songs yung release eh sa tagalog pop songs sila nag boom. sabi ng fans nila international na daw kasi yung target at nag-eexperiment pa pero honestly pwede naman sila mag trending internationally kahit tagalog song."]}

{"dialog": ["Si Maris nga nagka teleserye at endorsement pa, sila pa kaya. ABS CBN  lilinis ng issue nilaz", "\"Nobody's perfect kala mo wala kayong nagawang kasalanan\" both issues ni Maris and nung kay AC sa PBB puro ganito naririnig ko.\n\nIt's either wag kayong humusga dahil lahat tayo may imperfection ang script nila or throw the boys under the bus ala Maris style.", "lol i really hate this \"nobody's perfect\" phrase when theyre defending these people kase hindi mo naman need maging perfect to know what is right from wrong???"]}
{"dialog": ["lol e sa bini sub pilit na pinapasa dun sa dalawang lalake yung blame", "Eh whos to blame pala?? Sila lang dapat?", "silang lahat"]}
{"dialog": ["I honestly dont think BINI will be gone bcos of this issue specially with the artist management they are-in. I believe isa sila sa most prized possession ng Star Magic nowadays. SM wont let their investment or money makers go down just like that. It took years of searching, training, and trial and error before they succeeded on producing a successful girl group like BINI. And honestly, it may never happen again.\n\n\nAlso, maraming Star Magic talents and nadawit sa ibat ibang issues in the past na mas malala and theyre still active in the industry.\n\n\nAlso note, the Filipinos have opened their arms and welcomed problematic artist(s) from other countries/Korea. So makikita mong hindi ganun katindi ang cancel culture sa Pinas.", "They need a better comeback than pantropiko for that to happen. I feel so bad sa other members. I know everyone makes mistakes, theres redemption surepero joking about 13yo about sexual stuff is another story :(", "Do we know who the 13-year old is? Hindi ba possible na that 13-year-old was 13 when the people in the vid were also around the same age? Naisip ko kasi baka in the past yung pinaguusapan nila and now natatawa na di sila makapaniwala sa pagkawild nila at that young age."]}
{"dialog": ["As a BLOOM (dati or ewan), di ko iba-buy ung apology. Ang off saken kasi baket damay pa yung lima kawawa naman sila. Nakakahiya na kay Mikha dahil nagrepost pa sya sa Twitter nya nung apology samantalang ung 3 walang paramdam or delikadesa. Pero, sige pagbigyan muna ng time baka naman magbago pa.", "Sa X marami din Maloi fans naiirita sa apology kasi si Maloi daw nung nagka-issue dun sa pwd's mag-isa lang naman daw niya hinarap at nag-apologize. Samantalang this time di naman siya involved pero bakit sinali along with the other four na di din involved.", "kaya nga eh sobrang unhinged talaga walang kwentang management ang cheap sobra ng mga networks dito sa pinas hahahah di marurunong magaddress ng issues"]}
{"dialog": ["Siguro. Parang di na sila  makakapag release ng malupit na tagalog songs kase may binuo ng ppop gg ang flipmusic. VVINK ata name ng grp.", "Taenang pangalan yan VVINK hahahahha", "HAHAHAHAHAHA"]}
{"dialog": ["Gonna say this, bakit kasi hinahayaan lang nila mga talents nila. Like wala man lang strictness, si mika kasama pa si owra sa bar. Si waloi kung sino-sino din. \n\nYeah may private life pero public figure sila.\n\nAyan na nagbite na. Mukhang failed ang pagkakagawa ng isang ppop group. Sana lesson learned to sa management.\n\nMaging strict sana kayo sa gagawing ppop. Hanggang maaari wag pababain ang value by letting them do things on their own. Pede naman na yan once magsosolo na (see blankpink)", "Si Aiah at Gwen lang talaga yung may good circle of friends sa kanila. Si Aiah puro churchmate at yung aso kasama, na lilink sa pba player na si Tiongson but he's a good person din naman. Si Gwen kay doc Z at sharlene san pedro kabonding. Si sheena sumasama din yan sa 3.", "Yern nga :3 if ever na may malice na nga if di nila kayang ikontrol yuung mga bad side, dapat di na sila naging member. Ito kawawa yung ibang madadamay. Still kahit sino pa friends nila, bad or good influence, dapat may strict rules sila as a ppop group. Di yung hindi private life namin to kaya kahit ano pede naming gawin. Eh paano kung umayaw ang fans, wala ngayon sila"]}
{"dialog": ["Bakit nika sinali c Aiah Sheena Gwen Mikha and Maloi. Hindi din nag iisip PR nila.", "Ito hula ko. May branding din kasi yang Bini na Walo Hanggang Dulo. Feeling ko pag iniwan nila yung lima sa apology, may mga fans na magpupush na maging lima na lang ang Bini or maghiatus na talaga yung tatlo. Ang dapat na ginawa na lang kasi, individually sila nagrelease."]}
{"dialog": ["Cant unsee. Sabi na eh, yung lack of media training ni Colet mag cause ng problems in the future. Pero okay na rin at naexpose na ganyan pala yung tatlo in private.", "Anong aasahan mo sa mga ugaling kalye na tao? Kahit suotan mo ng mamahaling damit, paliguan mo ng mamahaling pabango, at tapalan mo ng tiglilibong make up aalingasaw talaga kung san yan galing. Si Aiah at Mikha lang ata may maayos na pagpapalaki diyan. Buti pa yung Gwen kahit laki sa hirap pero lumaking mabuting tao."]}
{"dialog": ["wala ngang sorry sa person na involved in this issue. they're only sorry because their fans are disappointed.", "i know right people should check in on the girl\n\nhindi talaga sorry Bini sorry lang na nahuli sila :("]}
{"dialog": ["It will be interesting to see kung ano magiging outcome ng world tour nila", "Speaking of World Tour yung Temecula, CA stop nila SOLD OUT na sana pero ngayon ang daming bumalik na tickets sa ticketmaster website. Ang daming pink color meaning nag resell ng tickets kasi pag blue color available kasi yun.\n\nPS: Legal ang scalper and resell ng ticket sa US ibabalik lang sa website tapos papatungan ang prices."]}
{"dialog": ["they will definitely lose a good number of their fan base. considering younger kids ang market nila and parents tend to judge artists based sa controversy. and sobrang critical ng issue ha, PEDOPHILIA, idagdag mopang apakakalat nung video takit ipause mo pa and yung screenshot lang ilabas mo sa isang posts. i also dont think bini is in their primest. may mga lumalabas na na new groups, and madami dami din silang bashers even before (calling them jeje, panghe , and out of tune (asap performance)", "ceiling na nila yung 2024 hype. i don't think makaka gain pa sila ng massive support pagkatapos ng issue na to. awkward na sila mag stay sa bg pop. mas mainam mag rebrand nalang sila and gawing mas mature yung mga concept nila. saka bitawan na nila yung mga advocacy shit kase obvious naman na for show lang nila yun."]}
{"dialog": ["Ngayon mo pindutin yung anger mo, Colet! Hinayupak kang babaita ka.", "kalmahan mo lang te!!! HAHAHAH"]}
{"dialog": ["Theyll still be okay in the Philippines for sure but once this gets with the other U.S. Blooms, their brand and popularity will fall.", "Sabi marami daw nagbalik ng tickets na SOLD OUT na sana, mas unforgiving sila doon haha"]}
{"dialog": ["Do you really think BINI will be canceled or flop because of this issue? ABS-CBN is known for covering up their artists' controversies and even boosting their fame afterward. Remember Anne Curtis' 'I can buy you, your friends, and this club' outburst? Vhong Navarro's rape case? Coco Martin's alleged grooming of Julia? Coleen and Billy's cheating scandal with Nikki? Kim Chiu's 'bawal lumabas' moment? Maris and Anthony's cheating controversy? Did any of those ruin their careers? Hardly. If anything, BINI might come out of this scandal even more popular.", "\"Bawal lumabas\" is just a brain fart on the part of Kim Chiu. We all get brain farts every now and then. Nothing diabolical about it. They even made it into a song."]}
{"dialog": ["Like BGYO aun nalaos na di pa gaanong sumisikat. Lol. Imbes na mag focus sa issue nila sa mga fans pa nasisisi. As a leader Joanna should step up i call out fans nila, hindi eh nahuli pang nag comment ng tawa sa alt account na basher ng isang grp. Nakalimutang mag change account to her dummy acvount haha. Kung sa S. Korea yan matagal na silang cancelled. Deserve nila yan isa pa yang Star Magic na gatas na gatas sila di maayos ayos problematic na members ng groups nila. #deserve #downfall", "To be fair, never sumikat BGYO in the first place."]}
{"dialog": ["Idk about downfall. Si Maris nga, andyan pa", "Was about to comment this"]}
{"dialog": ["Not a downfall. Kailangan lang nila magtanda, bata pa sila madami pa silang pwedeng matutunan at iimprove.", "Wishing for their downfall isn't good too. But then they have to learn their lesson. Kawawa yung lima pang member na nadawit dito."]}
{"dialog": ["Hmmm kailangan lang nila ng another tagalog hit song ala pantropiko and salamin salamin, then all will be forgotten. Believe me.", "San naman sila kukuha nun? Eh yung Flipmusic may binuong gg na."]}
{"dialog": ["you can have all the money & fame in the world, but you can't class. #squammyshizbruh", "\\*buy"]}
{"dialog": ["Gwen-modelling\n\nAiah- pageant\n\nMaloi- singing\n\nSheena- dancing\n\nMikha-sports/vball", "Si Maloi mag-ingat din sana kasi last time muntik na rin siya macancel", "Lalo na nalilink pa siya dun kay Zild na problematic din.", "wait di ako updated. ano ginawa ni zild?", "Tinitira na nya si Maloi"]}
{"dialog": ["Maloi has both individual popularity and talent. And her solo fandom is the most loaded, kaya nilang mag-sponsor ng whole BINI event \n\n\nAiah and Mikha are individually popular too pero anong magiging career nila? They're not the most talented members.", "Theyre not, kung kukumpara sa mga most talented members nila, pero they are pretty talented kung ikukumpara sa ibang PPOP idols. Aiah and Mikha are two of the most versatile sa group especially Aiah. She can dance, rap, and sing, and also play instruments and beatbox too.\n\nAiah can thrive anywhere she chooses, while Mikha can go into acting or singing. Her voice is unique, and she can benefit from that.", "They're definitely not more talented compared to members of G22, KAIA, or even YGIG. I'm saying that as a Bini fan once. Aiah's skill level is suited for a group but not as a solo. Nakakasabay lang siya. Modeling career siya pwede or travel influencer.  \n\nMikha has below average singing skills, unique lang ang voice color niya. She was not very good in her short stint in He's Into Her and not very fluent in Tagalog so if she goes into acting, very limited magiging roles niya. She was a gamer, she can be a streamer, like Sharlene San Pedro.", "Hey agreed. Sobrang galing ng G22. Tbh, lamon na lamon talaga BINI. Iba lang din talaga star power netong BINI e haha\n\nYou know what, tama ka sa streamer! Haha sobrang bagay", "even the brand jingles mas maganda yung sa g22 geez"]}
{"dialog": ["She's their worst singer", "**Stacey is their worst singer haha", "Di naman, mababa kasi yung voice ni stacey... kaya niya mag low notes. Di lang siya for birit levels\n\nAyaw mo lang talaga kay stacey thats it.", "Okay kakagaling ko lang ng Youtube, yeah Stacey's better than Aiah\n\nBaka mas bet ko lang yung vocal color ni Aiah from their songs", "Di naman best singer si Stacey pero if live or record parang same pa rin voice niya at more stable. Yun lang kasi \"pinaka pangit na member\" yung tingin mostly ng iba kay stacey -- so matic chaka din sumayaw at kumanta\n\nSi Aiah, higher vocal range pero di pa masyado stable more on parang back up singer vibes or adlibs +++ pero bawi naman sa visuals si aiah at class\n\nDi  sila inborn singers katulad ni jho, colet at maloi"]}
{"dialog": ["wala bang google para mag chatgpt ka pa? ganon katamad?\n\n\nedit:\n\nGuys, wag na kayo mag away away lol. I just dont trust chatgpt enough, since di naman 100% correct yan. Simple lang naman kasi hanapin sa internet nung mga proof sa pageants ni Aiah, to make it more real proof. And personally, chatgpt makes me lazy & stoopid, thats why I dont rely on it.", "What's the problem in using Chat GPT as a search tool? It literally goes through the web to directly answer your question. \n\nAnd kahit google gamitin mo, lalabas rin ang AI suggestions sa AI counterpart ng GPT sa google. \n\nSo kapag gumagamit ng calculator, tamad na. Eh if that's a more efficient way of having answers to your questions. :)", "Pinagtagpi tagpi lang ni chatgpt.. di maasahan Lalo na sa mga ganito na topic..", "Isn't that the goal? Magkaroon ng tagpi-tagping information kung yun ang hinahanap nya? \n\n  \nKaysa halukayin mo pa isa-isa para lang mag-reply sa reddit or for other tasks. Of course, fact-check. Chat GPT and Gemini give links if may doubts.", "You know AI is bad for the environment right?"]}
{"dialog": ["si Aiah, marunong mag-isip e.", "Bakit hindi si aiah ang leader?", "Siguro minsan kasi nakikita mo yung vulnerability nya during visible panic attacks. As much as napaka-lighthearted ng persona nya, I am worried kung may trauma ba syang dinadala.", "Tried looking for a panic attack video then saw yung \"ang daming tao\" moment niya. Omg grabe yung itsura niya, felt so bad for her pero ang galing pa din nakapag perform ng maayos."]}
{"dialog": ["Kaya lang naman ayaw ko sa Bini dahil diyan kay Colet, lakas makahatak pababa.\n\nAs for me ito yung nakikita kong roles nila pag nabuwag na: \n\nMikha- teleserye and movies, bagay mga actions like Kylie Padilla\nGwen- yeah mowdel talaga si ateh mala Maymay Entrata! \nAiah- host vibes, ang refreshing ng face eh \nMaloi- same kay mikha pero mas bagay mga bff/comedy roles sakanya\nSheena- gurl?! sana maging next pop star or equivalent!\n\nYung tatlong engot na mukhang magiging vlogger nalang at doon magkakalat: \nColet- vlogger na paepal parang sila Yobab ganern, endorser ng scatter kasi laos\nJhoanna- vlogger din pero mukhang sa mga sossy vibes siya mapapasama, may class ang fez eh\nStacey- a day in my life ang atake! Hahahahaha", "Shes my pet peeve. Yung mga pabalang sumagot kahit maayos kausapin. They say it's a regional culture thing, kasi bisaya, pero I find it sooooo disrespectful lol", "HOY HINDE\n\nIt's a Colet thing. Dami-daming Bisaya celebrities na well-loved at maayos ugali ex. Melai, Maymay, Aiah", "I agree. Just said what I always see her fans use as a justification for her behavior."]}
{"dialog": ["Si Gwen yung parang mga artists na magugulat ka na lang na successful na pala. Sya yung tahimik lang pero nagbbuild up ng career. Hindi masyadong exposed pero significant.", "Mala maymay", "Exactly!"]}
{"dialog": ["I feel like Aiah would thrive anywhere she goes.", "Yah, it feels like BINI is just a stepping stone for her...", "Parang ganun nga naisip ko. Aiah is a model and may exp na siya sa showbiz kaya nga late addition siya sa Star Hunt para nabacker na ata."]}
{"dialog": ["sayang si Jhoanna pang newscaster or host na sana kaso di pala siya nagiisip", "Gagi, akala ko siya yung mga student council type of girly na ayaw magpakopya kasi sobrang uptight  Di mo talaga malalaman ugali ng artista unless you get to personally know them", "me too damn deep down parang queen bee regina george pala"]}
{"dialog": ["IM sorry but if hindi ma te train si Colet with how to do PR, wala ikakabagsak nya din talaga.", "Gandang ganda ako kay Colet nung una ko sila napanood. For me siya may pinakamagandang face sa Bini tie sila ni Aiah sa top1 ko kaso yung ugali jusko nakakaturn off  Parang Marian Rivera during her early years pero mas squammy", "I dont want to use squammy with a negative connotation. Pero sayang pinagpaguran nila if di talaga sila matututo to talk nicely to people and their fans lalo sa social media where everything is literally taken out of context"]}
{"dialog": ["Di ko makakalimutan yung pwedeng magwait ka? talking to a FAN. T$ng i$ang yan. Rihanna could never.", "Saan to? Haha may vid ka?", "Reply ni Colet dun sa tweet ng isang fan na concern lang naman sa kanila."]}
{"dialog": ["Maloi will strive as a singer lalo na if yung genre is mala-UDD, Barbie Almalbis, Kitchie Nadal. \n\nAiah and Mikha would do well as influencers. Pwedeng imilk ni Aiah yung pagtravel travel niya and yung fitness kineso nya. While Mikha can go the beauty route.", "Did you mean \"thrive\"\n\nGenre-wise, maybe dahil artsy artsy siya. Pero I think Maloi needs to have more vocal control training. Puro high notes siya sa BINI e. Parang di pa siya trained masyado sa vocal dynamics na need para sa ganyang klaseng genre.", "Ayun. Kanina pko nagiisip if strive or thrive hahahah thanks for correcting\n\nBut yes, she needs vocal control training. Although kaya naman sya ang high notes lagi kasi iilan lang sila na mataas at marunong talaga kumanta naturally. So baka kaya naman nya icontrol, di lang natin alam."]}
{"dialog": ["AIAH and MIKHA. Sila lng hindi amoy squammy sa kanila. And theyre the two most equipped to go global with ambassador deals and shit. \n  \n\nSilang dalawa lng naman parati nagsasalita pag english interviews eh HAHAHAHA yung iba na cicringe sa sarili pag nag eenglish. watch their english interviews. when a member not named aiah or mikha answers in english, they'll say an english word, repeat it loudly, and laugh. \n  \n\n\"we're so proud of our accomplishments. ACCOMPLISHMENTS?\"", "Pota I remember a video on Tiktok of Maloi na mag-aaral daw sya sa Thames(?) Uni or basta school. Nag introduce sya and said how she was very excited to go there tapos obvious naman na plain English lang and NO accent. Then may nag comment na Malois accent>>> ni reply-an ko ng Is the accent in the room with us? Tanginang yan na bash pa nga ako ng mga Blooms hahahaha fan din ako ng BINI and bias ko si Aiah at Maloi but judging from that video, wala naman talagang accent eh hahahaha", "Wahahahaha ikaw pa napasama"]}

{"dialog": ["Dapat bigyan ng chance i sali si Gwen sa Asias next top model, sobrang galing nya talaga sa ganyan eh kahit anong ayos magaling sya mag dala.", "Pucha survival show na naman??? Tama na ho  Haha", "Why not?! Pride naman natin sya if ever win or lose kilala na sya and for sure hindi naman ma di disappoint mostly ng fan talaga nya (me) maganda  sya i represent."]}

{"dialog": ["Aiah! Pwede pang model.", "Jusko naman yang pangalan mo huy", "Nananakit lang"]}

{"dialog": ["Maloi and Mikha may star quality imo. Jho rin sana sa acting industry but nvm.", "Si Maloi actually yung mukhang mahilig sa red flag na lalaki. Now pa nga lang nai-issue na dahil sa involvement niya kay Xild eh. Jejemon rin umasta. Hays.", "Star quality ata yung tanong, hindi personal issues? Performance-wise, she has a strong stage presence, malaking factor rin fashion sense niya and vocal abilities as to why I think she will do well as a soloist."]}

{"dialog": ["Parang ewan naman kayo na biglang solo career na, taymperst lang. I think they should suffer the consequences too but I feel like grabe galit ng tao sa Bini vs the larger issue which is fcked up yung Pilipinas dahil sa govt lol.", "maling mali ung 3 and they need to apologize and be accountable. pero sa totoo lng ang daming tao dito na nag aantay na may magkamali sa Bini tapos sabay sakmal na.  People in this thread needs to understand na at a certain point of our lives sasablay tayo and i hope there are people that are willing to give us 2nd chance.  chance na mukhang ayaw na ibigay ng karamihan.", "This, heck di ako big fan ng Bini and if pipili ako, si Aiah din yung gusto ko, nadownvote pa nga ako, gigil din naman ako sa nangyari kasi abused ako as a child. But yung galit ng tao sa Bini feel ko stems on something deeper eh,  tipong matagal na nila gusto magfail Bini"]}

{"dialog": ["Yes, I acknowledge that AIs can make mistakes too if it's a more complicated task. \n\nBut it's merely list of pageants that Aiah won, the commenter did it in a more efficient way rathen than going through websites herself.  And as per her screenshot, there are references anyway if fact check is needed.", "Im answering the question you posed. You claimed that the use of ChatGPT as a search tool isnt a problem because it literally goes through the web to directly answer your question. Thats quite a confident, misguided assertion given the rate of hallucinations for GPT 4.5 was a whopping 37.1% for the SimpleQA test.\n\nAnd no, AI hallucinations dont just happen with more complicated tasks. I recommend reading more about the phenomenon (its very interesting!), or using more grounded AI models for research if you really need it for accuracy. For reference, even Sam Altman says the hallucinations are a feature and not a bug at this point.\n\nIm not trying to argue with you ha. And I dont really care about the Aiah thing enough to comment about it. Just wanted to temper expectations about AI models being the end-all of information-seeking.", "Don't waste your time explaining, bruh. I tried that too, and sarado talaga isip nya. Maybe natamaan sya or naoffend kasi she uses AI in her tasks kaya ganyan nalang din kasarado isip nya. It's not a bad thing naman to use AI, pero kasi yung convcition nya na AI can do no wrong is very alarming. Nasayang lang din time ko magcomment bit it seems like I'm just preaching to a blank wall. \n\nSiguro ganito na talaga mga pinoy ngayon. Basta may paniniwala ka, kahit mali or may magpoint out ng facts, ipaglalaban at ipaglalaban parin ang paniniwala."]}

{"dialog": ["Gwen could go the Maymay Entrata route and she will thrive. Aiah can do pageants and acting. Sheena does good acting too from her mmk ep.", "Kailangan lang mag practice pa ni Aiah sa Tagalog if gusto nya mag acting. If pageant, ok din sya don since magaling sumagot and may background na."]}

{"dialog": ["Bakit parang walang nagbanggit dito kay Sheena? That girl's solo career is gonna thrive for sure!", "She is such a talented dancer  pwedeng-pwede maging mainstay sa ASAP and she has a nice sense of humor."]}

{"dialog": ["Colet scatter endorser or motovlogger. Jhoanna on the Jen Barangan papansin influencer kuno trajectory. Stacey, backup dancer sa noontime show", "HAHAHAHAHHAHA napaka specific mo naman mhie"]}

{"dialog": ["Si Colet magiging barangay kagawad", "Hoy HAHAHA pero actually nakikita ko to sa kanya. Mukhang di rin naman sya extremely comfortable here sa Manila. And afaik, nagtayo siya business sa Bohol. So mukhang magwork sa kanya yung pamumuhay sa probinsya. Tapos kukunin sya ng lokal na pulitiko as part of their slate because of her clout :("]}

{"dialog": ["Yung nasa picture, pwede mag model. Same sila ng vibes ni maymay. Pang fashion week aura nila", "Yes ang ganda rin ng voice"]}

{"dialog": ["Not a fan of bini, di ko kilala lahat din pero nagagandahan ako kay Aiah. Pero napanuod ko sa youtube yung nag solo siya kumanta off key siya doon, e-heads ata yun kinanta niya, nakalimutan ko na.. pero Sa bini sino yung magaling kumanta?", "Yeah, not her area.\n\nUnfortunately, 2/3 nung mga tukmol ang main vocalists nila, then si Maloi"]}

{"dialog": ["Ok abscbn pr team\n\nHahaha jk", "Huy compliment yan for me HAHAHAHA Mali ata talaga trabaho ko hay\n\nPero hindi, tbh fan lang ako ni Gwen and Aiah"]}

{"dialog": ["Tingin ko wala. Parang Twice ok sila as a group pero so so lang pag solo career. Di naman sa di sila magiging successful pero more on so so nalang di kasing impactful pag group sila.", "thisss"]}

{"dialog": ["When they introduced Bini Gwen as patay gutom, I stanned her immediately. Hooray for all patay gutom", "Hype ka natawa ako HAHAHAHAHAHHAA AGWENGERS ka rin po?"]}

{"dialog": ["Agree ako kay Gwen, her face card sometimes gives off Lisa vibes.", "FINALLY, YES.\n\nDi sila magkamukha pero magka-vibe sila e. Must be the body.\n\n(And performance, really )"]}

{"dialog": ["Sayang si Colet tsaka Jho. Si Colet song writer. Pwede siya mag solo sa music. Bet ko actually yung ballad na narinig ko sa clip na gawa niya pero di nirelease. Si Jho naman news reporter\n\nSi Mikha nag acting role siya before so ewan ko if mag act ulit siya\n\nI can see Gwen as a model! Favorite siya ng camera", "Sayang nga. For me Colet is their best singer  Kaso best in squammy din hay"]}

{"dialog": ["Bagong host sa Wil to win", "Na mago-awkward smile sa background kapag nagtantrums si Koya Wel. Example, Anna Ramsey."]}

{"dialog": ["oo sya lang naman maganda sa kanila.", "Pakisampal nga yung nagsabi kanina dito sa chikaph na pangit raw si Aiah. Nayayamot na naman ako."]}

{"dialog": ["Sobrang angas makipag usap amputa bastos talaga", "Alam mo ung mahirap na saksakan ng jeje na akala mo sya lang tama sa mundo pero shunga naman. Ganyan vibes ni Colet sakin."]}

{"dialog": ["Siya ba yung origin nung napindot yung anger ko eme? IIRC, cheer na cheer pa yung mga fans nila na pabalang na sumagot lagi si acclang Colet \nAko na casual listener, parang I tweeted sa same thread, for a member of an upcoming group, girl this attitude is not cute \nSo ayon, nasugod ako ng mga baby bra warriors hahaahaha", "Vindicated tlga mga nagcall out sa kanila dati. Ndi Kasi nila ma gets Yong concept na may image silang dapat protektahan. Kala lahat papalampasin Lang.", "Ahhh kaya pala I was hit with Hindi mo kasi sya (Colet) gets, kasi hindi ka fan", "The good thing about it is there's so much digital footprint to throwback just like this one. Matinding I told you so hehehe"]}

{"dialog": ["Actually hndi naman talaga super galing unlike SB19  mediocre lang po", "Agree! Or ewan ko, baka magagaling sila pero lamya ng mga choreo nila, hindi nakaka idol. Parang kahit chuwariwaps on the side kaya yung mga choreo nila eh..", "Tapos hndi rin nagpapakita ng improvement sa vocals or nagpapakita na nag -eexplore sila overrated talaga hahahhahah", "Sobra  dapat nagstay nalang sila sa mga likes ng pantropiko kung ganon, wag na mag explore, di naman nag uupgrade eh"]}

{"dialog": ["Feeling nya kasi cool maging ganyan hahaha syempre yung iba sasabihin nagpapkatotoo daw. Hahahaa ew", "Ang squammy nung approach noh.", "Herlene budol vibes talaga. You cannot take the squatter out of the girl charot"]}

{"dialog": ["May reason kung bakit walang personal twitter accounts ang ibang kpop group members hahahahahaha.", "Zakly haha matindi ang control ng kpop management for these specific reasons talaga", "\"By the neck and By the throat\" lalo pag trabaho.\n\n sabi ng Korean counterparts namin sa work sa mga manager at project manager. Indeed ganun din ang method sa Japan"]}

{"dialog": ["Hanggang ngayon ba wala pa rin silang album? nakakaloka management nila if thats the case.", "di yata full album ung nirelease recently, ep lang ata yung considering kasi 6 tracks lang. \n\ni think warranted naman talaga ung concern nung fan noon regarding sa album kasi ito ung time na inaanounce ung biniverse encore sa phil arena after their araneta concert. ano nga naman ipperform nila, same same lang? hahaha they expect the fans to pay their expensive tickets para lang panoorin ang same na perf? \n\ntapos ayan ganyan ung sagot. also hindi nga siya directly called out/mentioned nung fan sa tweet e. sya mismo talaga nagreply.", "thanks OP for the context, ngayon ko lang nalalaman ito and makes sense naman na bakit same same kahit dami na nilang concerts and tours. di rin kina cute ni Colet yung pagiging anger hahahaha"]}

{"dialog": ["aura ni Colet parang schoolmate mong bully nung higschool.", "Yung vibes nya parang may amoy putok ang kili kili.", "Hooooooy akala ko ako lang nakakaisip nyan hahaahahahahhahahahahaah"]}

{"dialog": ["Yan na kasi personality na nagustuhan sa kanya noon at feeling ko yan na din binigay ng management sa kanya. For people who dont know, sa kpop industry kasi, yung management nag-aassign din ng personality per member para isipin talaga ng mga fans na di boring yung group. Na tipong makakaattract ng fans kasi ibat iba personality ng members. As far as I remember, nung di pa sikat Bini, nagViral yung mga live video ni Colet na kausap niya mga fans niya tapos pataray o ma-attitude siyang sumagot. Love na love siya ng mga tao nun kasi artist tapos parang barkada lang kausap mga fans. Kaso ito nga lang, sumobra na kaya good luck nalang sa kanila, lets see if makakaahon ang career nila sa bagong issue.", "This aint kpop, and theres no kpop management out there that promotes this type of core. Sure meron silang pa mysterious, ice king, ice queen bs pero skwating core? Wala lmao May nakita ka bang kpop idol na nakikipag bardagulan sa twitter? Wala.", "Read again my comment, sinabi ko na nagviral noon live videos niya at yan nagustuhan ng karamihan ng tao o fan sa kanya kaya most likely, yan yung personality na binigay ng management sa kanya. Malamang di uubra yan sa kpop industry since grabe ang bashing sa kanila, wala naman akong sinabi sa comment ko na may ganyan sa kpop, binigay ko lang yung backgroup na nag-aassign ng personality ang kpop management per member. I hope iniintindi natin ang comment bago mag-comment hahahaha. May part ba na sinabi kong may skwating cote sa kpop? Wala."]}

{"dialog": ["Tingnan natin if magka epek ang lahat ng ito on how they respond sa tweets nila. Tactless, now ano?", "Kaya nga eh, nasan ang tapang? I mean, take accountability! Be vocal, a quick tweet wont hurt to say you are sorry as a person not as a group. \n\n kasi nadadamay yung ibang members na nananahimik lang."]}

{"dialog": ["Tactless at squammy sya pero sa fans cute ang dating. And even during performances na may technical difficulties on her end, ang ate chona nya.", "I guess shes trying to or maybe thinks she comes off as badgal/savage girl with the replies"]}

{"dialog": ["Gustong gusto ng mga fans nila to, anger daw core memory ni colet - basag mga bashers nila kapag sinasagot ni colet. \n\n  \n\\>> Feeling cool pero squammy, atechona", "pero tuwing may issues, ang tahimik. throwing stones from a glass house."]}

{"dialog": ["eksena yan sha e, siya yung tipong nasobrahan ang pagiging straightforward bobita lang ang atake ng mga accla.\n\n\nmatatapang yan sila guys, naalala ko yung nasa pbb ang Jhocey, iniripan yata ni Dustin si Jhoanna tas nagsumbong si Stacey sabi ng isa \"Ay, iniirapan mo ko?\" sabay taas kilay angas e ahahahahahaa basta if you observe more mean girls ang atake nila, ganda yarn?", "wala tayong winner sa dustin at jhocey tho inirapan naman talaga"]}

{"dialog": ["Ending point ko talaga yung two-cents? keep the change  jusq ANG KANAL", "OMG I FORGOT TO ADD THAT!!!!!"]}

{"dialog": ["first bias ko si Colet kasi same kami taga bohol but after her interactions with the bashers sa twitter ekis na siya saken.", "Di naman basher yan, mga fans ng bini yan"]}

{"dialog": ["Ngayon lang naman ninonormalize pagiging squammy kesyo nagpapakatotoo lang daw. Wag ako. You are just mannerless.", "bawal ata icallout hehe"]}

{"dialog": ["si groomer napindot imbes na si anger", "Di nya na mapipindot si anger be, mababalikan sya haha"]}

{"dialog": ["Waiting for their down fall", "In my observation as someone who does Advertising and Marketing, that is not too far.\n\n I mean, let's recall the Lowbrow Restaurant group downfall after their fake PWD tirade. \n\n\"Call them Satan\" sabi nung Lowbrow Restaurant group"]}

{"dialog": ["Hindi siya cool, may anger issues sya.", "Deep rooted it seems. Sad and comical at the same time. But mostly sad na need i-address :("]}

{"dialog": ["Alam niyo ang nakakapagtaka lang hindi ba siya pinapagalitan ng management dahil diyan? Kasi diyan pa kang eh nasisira na image nila", "Yeah, yan din ang thoughts ko. I find it strange na Parang walang media training ang Bini Members. As an educator sa Advertising and Marketing, this does affect yung imagery nila. \n\nI dunno why, but perhaps this is where the fan appeal originated siguro?\n\nI am not saying na ok ako dito sa galawan nila na palaban, I am saying na maybe the fans \"fell in-love sa idea and imagery\" ng ganitong \"personality\" who knows"]}

{"dialog": ["Nagpa rhino lang, naging feelingera na masyado haha. Tapos itong recent issue, tanggal anger nya haha.", "Hindi naman sya nagpa rhino teh. Dun lang tayo sa anger bat dinamay pati ilong?"]}

{"dialog": ["Nadamay pa nga yung lima haha", "appreciate this statement. \n\nBut, there's no apology for the girl you mentioned and laughed at in the video? Not even a direct acknowledgment?\n\nAre you truly sorryor just sorry you got caught?\n\nAccountability means more than words. It means cutting ties with people who crossed the line. We trusted you. Many of us still do. Dont waste that.", "With the statement private moment, definitely only because they got caught. Ano pakialam nmin sa private moment, bastos ka pa rin", "parang ang dating dahil private moment pwede maging bastos grabe selective naman pala ang women empowerment nila", "Comment pa ng mga babybra warrior nila lahat naman daw ng magkakaibigan may mga ganyang joke (dark humor).\n\nJusko! Ginaya pa lahat sa mga tulad nila.", "True, their lines is BAKIT PERFECT KA BA?"]}

{"dialog": ["Parang kulang yung apology, wala silang plan na sinabi how to correct the behavior basta lang daw magreflect.", "THIS. Apologize and sweep under the rug lang ang vibes ng statement na yan.", "But Colet can never get away with her anger issues anymore. Maccall out sya. Hahahahaha", "Si Anger ba talaga si Colet?", "Sino sya pala? Haha", "Lolzzzz si anger yung sa inside out."]}

{"dialog": ["The video shows a private moment of us with friends. HUHHHH oh tapos????", "Like ganyan pala kayo mag usap privately. Bembangan, tapos pag usapan yung 13 year old na victim. Bwst.", "parang kasalanan pa natin na napanood natin paano sila mag \"biruan\" in private lol", "sa mga fans namn nila parang kasalanan rin ng nag post na nalaman ng mga tao ang baho na ugali ng idol nila", "hinahunting nga nila yung nagpakalat ng video eh hahahahaha kahit mahanap nila yon, nothing will ever change the fact na yun tunay na kulay ng mga idol nila"]}

{"dialog": ["Direk Dyogi could have simply typed this lol", "Also wow it took them almost 24 hours from video upload to construct this? Huwaw", "Minadali nga daw ksi nagbanta yung user ng nag leaked ng video na kapag wala pa rin statement may ilalabas pa sya na other issue na mas malala pa daw", "source?"]}

{"dialog": ["\"Nagkamali kami\" -- No shit, Sherlock. \n\nExcept it wasn't a simple mistake; it was a fucking choice.", "scary, kasi if ever na totoo nga na 13 yrs old yung ashley, parang ok lang sa kanila yun? walang nag call out? tumawa lang? thats vile.", "\"Private moment\" their asses. Sabihin nila, that's who they really are when they think walang ibang makakakita. Bunch of hypocrites.", "Agree. Parang ang siste, ay nakalabas lang kasi, sorry. Next time di kami magvvideo abd post."]}

{"dialog": ["Tao lang naman sila nagkakamali rin. Kayo ba perpekto at hindi nagkamali sa buhay niyo? comments in 3, 2, 1!", "Hahaha korek. Well jokes on them kasi di lang simpleng joke yan. Krimen yan be. Sit down.", "Theres a fine line in everything. Ang ironic lang rin kasi advocacy nila ay women empowerment and sa children. Ibang usapan rin kasi yang ginawa nila dahil tungkol sa minor and sexual position ang biruan nila. Rape, bomb/death threat, minor jokes are different and considered as crime na. Magjoke ka nga lang sa airport na may dala kang bomba, automatic kulong ka.", "Sa Tiktok yung mga Blooms nag live na sila, ok na raw kasi nagsorry na. Hahaha"]}

{"dialog": ["Sana di na sinama yung pangalan nung ibang members sa baba lol, dapat akuin ng mga nasa video", "tapang nung colet makipag-away sa fans nila tapos ngayon nagtatago sa group account", "humbled si anger ih"]}

{"dialog": ["This is hot trash and hot air. Non-issue kung private yan. Through that rogue friend, we were able to catch a glimpse of their truest selves. Yung tawa ni Jho? Thats ingrained. No hesitation, no second guessing. She enjoyed that shit. Yung pag video ni Colet? She wanted to keep that shit. Yung tono ng boses ni Stacey? Normal like reciting the fucking alphabet. \n\nKaya kung ako sakanila, mag music nalang sila uli pero wag na mag advocacy kuno kasi its all lost into the wind. Basag na ang pa-virgin era nila. Hindi din dapat sinama yung lima dyan kasi it indirectly means they were complicit to it all. Hindi dapat sila pumayag. Heads should roll.", "Kung ako sa kanila maghiatus silang tatlo pero wag na bumalik EME \n\nFor sure lagi na ma-bring up yang \"ahh 13 years old\" ni Jho, that would surely haunt her for god knows how long.", "Di ipaghahiatus yang 3 yan, kickoff na ng world tour nila this month tapos 2/3 ng vocal line nila kasali sa issue."]}

{"dialog": ["Doesn't change the fact na may mantsa na yung reputation nila. Hypocrite sila if they continue this women empowerment advocacy after what they did. The internet and the public never forgets.", "Mabbring up ulit yung issues nila pag may fanwars", "deserve. nang matikman din ng grooms yung ginagawa nila sa ibang fandom."]}

{"dialog": ["If they were in South Korea, wala na silang career after this. Or management will mandate 1 year or more career hiatus", "Alam mo naman dito sa Pinas, mas kinakampihan pa mga balahura. Yung iba nga nagiging senador pa eh haha", "True, mga tao sa pinas mabilis magpatawad at magbigay ng 2nd, 3rd to infinite chance sa mga tao demonyo"]}

{"dialog": ["Colet ang tapang mang-away ng fans  sa X pero di kaya mag release ng sarili niyang statement char", "Asa ka pa diyan kay anger pag siya may issue tahimik lang yan. Walang remorse whatsoever", "Baka nga napikon pa yon bakit kumalat yung video nila eh"]}

{"dialog": ["ahhahaha puro heart reax sa fb mga u2 u2", "Pero sa ibang page na nagshare like ABSCBN, Inquirer, etc HAHA reax ang marami HAHHAHAHAHA", "Typical kulto behavior"]}

{"dialog": ["So what kung private moment yun with friends? Ganon ba talaga kwentuhan, topic, at inside jokes nila? Di naman sa pagpapakasanto kasi kami naman din ng circle of friends ko, nag-uusap about ibang tao pero as far as my brain can remember never kami magtouch sa topic na yan kasi who would even do that?", "Private or not, no one should joke about doing s*xual stuff to a minor. You have to be sick in the head for you to be able to make or laugh at those kinds of \"jokes\"", "For a group na marami madalas naman ata online (sa dami ng issues na nagsisilabasan about dito tapos mas nararaise na ang awareness ng karamihan sa sensitive topics like this) alam naman nila mangyayari kapag nalaman ng madla na ganyan pala sila."]}

{"dialog": ["Si Jhoanna leader nila di ba? Perhaps hanap muna sila ng ibang leader while nagpapalamig si Jho", "Kapal ng mukha nung Jho kung magstay pa rin sya jan. isa syang malaking mantsa sa grupo!", "Sa true! Nakakahiya kasi Leader sya"]}

{"dialog": ["Grabe yung loyal supporters nila todo tanggol.Di ako magtataka kung panatiko mga yun sa politicians na problematic eh.", "true mga dds rin mga yan, yung utak nila wlang kalman laman, madali mauto!", "Ay for sure kasi kung talagang may prinsipyo at morals ka kahit pa idol mo basta mali call out dapat di yung blinded sa actions nila."]}

{"dialog": ["mukhang squammy. ugaling squammy. except for Mikha and Aiah", "tapos pag sila naman may lumabas na issue...\n\nnot hoping for it since silang dalawa rin pinakabet ko sa group pero if there's a lesson to this issue, it's that we don't truly know these ppl kaya better to not assume ano ba talaga ugali nila", "mfs don't learn lol"]}

{"dialog": ["Grabe yung pag dedefend ng fan base nila Hahahaha may nabasa pa ko \"bakit bawal magkamali\" Luh si ate mo Rape joke na po yun hindi pwede basta basta joke yun", "Isa pang line nila \"Ang hirap pag public figure dapat perfect\" mga baliw e no?", "Mga kulto talaga eh HAHAHAHA"]}

{"dialog": ["Most likely nerfed na yung tatlong Bini. Too bad yung isa leader pa. Juskopo. Tapos ngayon sa twitter yung nagupload ng video meron na daw pasabi or go signal sa source na may ipopost pa daw. Grabe whew.", "Gosh. Siguro inantay lang mag issue ng statement yung management.", "Kaya sayang na hindi na mauupload dahil naglabas na agad ng statements ang management, halata takot na may lalabas pa na baho sa bini"]}

{"dialog": ["Pure K-Pop inspired. From attire, songs, even their dance. Pati apology ChatGPT. \n\n13looms?", "May nabasa nga ako sa facebook comment, dahil maraming enabler na blooms. \"From blooms to groomer real quick\" daw", "Nagmukhang may class pa Sexbomb dancers haha"]}

{"dialog": ["Do you really think BINI will be canceled or flop because of this issue? ABS-CBN is known for covering up their artists' controversies and even boosting their fame afterward. Remember Anne Curtis' 'I can buy you, your friends, and this club' outburst? Vhong Navarro's rape case? Coco Martin's alleged grooming of Julia? Coleen and Billy's cheating scandal with Nikki? Kim Chiu's 'bawal lumabas' moment? Maris and Anthony's cheating controversy? Did any of those ruin their careers? Hardly. If anything, BINI might come out of this scandal even more popular", "Yung kay maris naging laughing stock na lang sya na possible ganyan na mangyayari sa bini, may makikita ka na comments na \"13 years old, ano ginawa kay ashley? sinabunutan?\". Tasyung next music nila possible magiging flop dahil hindi na tatangkilin ng masa at casual viewers. Yung Endorsements nila hindi na rin masyado matunog or papansinin ng masa gaya ng kay maris. Kilala na ang bini ng mga tao dahil sa nakakadire issue, hindi na yun maalis sa isipan nila", "At first lang naman siya naging laughing stock. If youll look at the recent comments sa kanya, nawawala or natatabunan na yung mga lewd comments ng papuri sa kanya dahil sa show niya incognito. Yung endorsement niya, nadagdagan pa nga eh. Kung si maris na hindi naman big star ng ABS eh nagawan nila ng paraan para ma save ang career, tingen nyo ba talaga pababayaan lang nila isa sa biggest money maker nila?"]}

{"dialog": ["Nadamay pa yung lima.", "Wala naman daw nagsasabi na nadamay yung lima sabi dun sa subreddit nila. Isa lang kasi silang entity.", "which is such bullshit lol. idol groups usually dont last long so si aiah and mikha na di squammy would want to have long-lasting solo careers. and being entangled with shit like this even if youre in the same group could damage them too if they dont voice out that \"hey, i dont support nor condone that behavior and i have talked to the three in private\""]}

{"dialog": ["Ano ba issue nila?", "search sub", "Ano po?"]}

{"dialog": ["If they are actually sorry, the three people need to leave this group.\n\nYou are actually sorry? No, sorry , face the consequences.\n\nLeave the Group!", "wla sila consequences ksi wala namn endorsements ang nag pupull out dahil sa mga issue nila, pano ba namn mga fans nila bulag bulagan sa kakagahan ginagawa nila kaya hindi sineseryoso ng bini members mga issue nila dahil after lumipas issue nila may another issue ulit", "Maaga pa\n\nMay magpupull out nyan."]}

{"dialog": ["I am not a fan of BINI or any local PPOP group but the thing about this issue is that I think the content is supposed to be a private moment shared with people those girls are really comfortable with\n\n\nI am not defending nor implicating that what that video contains is appropriate because it is not. Pero if you watched it in a wider perspective, marerealize mo na They didnt do it actually in public for others to see and impose (unlike most f*ckd up influencers who proudly flaunts mga kabastusan ng bunganga, ugali sa socmed and masked it as being real). \n\n\nIt is like how most people  especially young adults act and interact with their inner circles, people closest to them, people we are most comfortable to have that so- called KANAL HUMOR which I think is much worse and the term is just used to justify kabastusan lalo na sa mga influencers na ambabastos yung jokes sa socmed nowadays. \n\n\nAgain, let me reiterate that am not justifying their acts but just implicating facts because all of u...", "IMO:\n1. \"Kung kayo sa lugar nila...\" I would never make a joke like that about a minor.  Sinoman sa friends ko maging ganito, kokonyatan ko talaga!\n\n2. \"May nagpost bigla sa socmed kahit di dapat\" yes, mali naman yun. Pero baka nabwisit sa biro nila kaya inilaglag sila. For me, ang \"hindi dapat\" talaga eh yung ganyang biro. Sana nga biro lang, pano if totoo.  Hm?\n\nAdd: u/LucTargaryen_5999 magrereply ka sabay block. Kita pa rin reply mo pag nakalogout ako sa Reddit. \n\nNagpapadala ka sa bugso ng damdamin. Gamitin po ang kukote bago magreact ha o mamblock ha.\n\nDi talaga ako naggi-green jokes, lalo na kung ang tinutukoy ay bata. Di mo ba matanggap na may ganong tao? Ang defensive mo. Ikaw ata ang natamaan.\n\nAlso may sinabi ba ako na TINOTOLERATE MO? Tsk tsk", "1. kayo meaning NOT ONLY YOU. kung hindi ikaw natamaan, then dont act like youve been hit dahil hindi lahat ng tao sing linis mo. just a fact\n\n2. LOL basic human decency din lalo na sa friendship yung respecting privacy. pwede namang komprontahin ng direkta at i call out sila habang ginagawa nila yun diba? the one who took the video could have just called them out in the first place without taking it, but instead it WAS POSTED CONVENIENTLY at THE MOMENT ONE OF THE MEMBERS WAS ALSO GRADUATING..\n\n3. your reasoning clearly shows how narrow-sighted you are in the situation as what i have stated. I repeatedly say na I DONT TOLERATE WHAT THEY DID because it was never worth tolerating. what I am voicing out is how people who have shallow minds are eating up these girls like its not okay to be this shinning, shimmering image of perfection you guys are expecting them to be all the damn time, like how you drag them down just because a single exploitative video that should never have been uploade..."]}

{"dialog": ["Theyre only sorry kasi they got caught. Pero kung hindi lumabas yung video? Ganyan talaga sila in real life. What a shame:", "Tas alam din ng mga fans nila kaya galit na galit sila sa nagpakalat sa video dahil lumabas ang baho ng idol nila"]}

{"dialog": ["May mga buong araw palang nagco-comment at nagpo-post ng anti-Bini dito sa sub lol. That hate is quite something.", "Ansisipag ng mga taga chikaPH dapat irename na nila tong sub na to as BiniHaters haha \n\nIf OT ang pr team sa abscbn, mas malala ang OT dito sa pambabash hahaha", "You can really check out their timeline. Parang nag-antay ng ilang buwan o taon right at this moment. I mean nakakatawa na nakakaawa ang mga galawan.", "Yup parang mej matagal na yung ganap. Baka sa daleng dale na video pa nila yun or something ewan if may irereveal pa sila pero ilabas nalang nila yan para isang bagsakan nalang"]}

{"dialog": ["I think Starmagic is just waiting for election and new pope para mabaon sa limot issue ngayon ng Bini", "Mas matatabunan yan pag si Tagle pa naging Pope. Starmagic must be betting on that shit", "hahahahaha baka may mga \"issue\" din yang si tagle na mauungkat pag nagka ganon. hahahahaha"]}

{"dialog": ["Di na nila matatakasan yan. Sa comment pa lang sa fb puro \"13 years old\" eh. Tsaka magiging awkward na yan kapag may meet and greet sa mga menor de edad na fans. Kung ikaw nanay at tita ng bata, di ba nakakailang yun? Maalala mo yung mga tawa nila sa vid.", "Awkward. Parang ayaw ko iharap sa mga pamangkin kong bata yung 3. Tumatawa at enjoy sa mga minor jokes. Staku, ikaw pa naman bias ng mga bagets.", "Mag-aalangan lang ako pag lumapit ang anak ko sa BINI. Pero hahayaan ko pa rin. Pag dun sa dalawang maasim na boys, baka gumamit ako ng"]}

{"dialog": ["Graduate na rin ang career", "Nais kong i congratulate si Jhoanna na leader ng BINI dahil siya ay nakapagtapos (ng senior high)\n\nNgayon ang career mo din ay tapos HAHAHAHAHAH leader pa more\n\n\"women empowerment\" pa more\n\npwede siya mag journalist... sa SMNI kasi ka humor niya si quiboloy", "HAAHHAAHAH pwede na siya maging news caster doon"]}

{"dialog": ["kaya pala nung graduation parang uneasy si jhoanna (mukhang napagalitan ng magulang) kumpara kay gwen na parang chill lang", "makita ba naman ng parents mo na pumapayag ka na may nag rereenact ng doggy sa harap mo", "mawawalan ka ng \"proud parents\" moments pag ikaw yung parents ni jhoanna HAHAHAHAHHA kakakita nyo lang sa video ng anak ninyo na natutuwa siya sa mga nag dodoggy sa harapan niya sabay sabi ng \"ahhh 13 years old\" HAHAHAHAHAHHA kakahiya"]}

{"dialog": ["Omg goodbye Jollibee na ba ito??", "not yet. kakapost kang ng jollibee sa x ng birthday greetings kay bini sheena", "Naka-table pa rin yata sa meeting. Pwedeng drop ang three, or drop lahat. Si Anne nga takot na takot sa honest mistake nya with VG, eto pa kaya. Shocks!!"]}

{"dialog": ["Expert ang ABS-CBN dyan, pero mas expert sila sa demolition job. \n\nABS-CBN has been master of dark media arts. Malas lang talaga nila mali yung siniraan nilang tao. \n\nMay Mga baguhan na mga tao nila ngayon, tingnan natin if well trained or hindi.", "Yep. Kaya nga kinarma sila sa franchise nila, naback to you ika nga. Ginawang meatshield pa yung mga contractual people na nawalan ng trabaho.", "Nakakatawa na parating sinasabi/criticize ng abs-cbn yung nga contract workers sa gobyerno, tapos sila mag ganon din. \n\nHahaha."]}

{"dialog": ["**BINI members involved be like:**\n\nI misspoke.\n\nIt was just satire/dark humor.\n\nThat clip was totally taken out of context.\n\nI was just trying to spark a conversation with friends.\n\nI deeply regret my words\n\nThis doesnt reflect who I am.\n\nI was in a toxic environment and went along with it.\n\nI was triggered by my own trauma..\n\nI was just really stressed and overwhelmed.\n\nIve done a lot of healing and self-reflection.", "Bini just posted their statement and you almost hit it haha"]}

{"dialog": ["Baka ilabas na na jowa nung isa yung Zild", "Gagalingan nila mag edit sa PBB clips para yun ang umagaw ng spotlight"]}

{"dialog": ["may nag downvote kaagad wala pang 1 minute sa pag post ko HAHAHAHAHAHHAAHAH may lurkers na maasim na blooms dito malamang", "Lurkers na galing fb pero kulang sa karma para maka comment hahah"]}

{"dialog": ["Kung ang Ashley na tinutukoy nila ay si Ashtine Olviga nga ng AMNSE, maybe ang 13 years old noon ay si Ethan David, while Ashtine was 15 years old at that time. Recently may nakita akong post about sa rumored relationship nila since 2016 pero not sure if that's true. If totoo naman, kadiri si Ethan at nagawa pa ikwento sa girl friends yung private experience nya sa ganon.", "Narrative naman yan ng kapamilya trolls eh para mabaling sa iba lol."]}

{"dialog": ["video muna bago maniwala, bakit pa ba sila natatakot ipost yan", "cyberlibel is waving", "I'm confused, sa pagkakaalam ko ang libel is ikaw ang gumawa ng statement na ikakasira ng other party. Hindi yung siya nagsabi ng ikakasira niya. Correct me if I'm mistaken.", "not a lawyer pero i know grounds pa rin yan for cyberlibel even if the person said it themselves. it's about the intent and how it's published. if the poster's goal is to damage someone's reputation, esp in public and malicious way, counted pa rin yan as cyberlibel under ph law.", "yall are saying that it's the end of bini but far worst offenders still have a thriving career. Vhong is the one that I can think of and im sure there are others. Not saying that they should not be held accountable pero andami din napalagpas ang general public na problematic figure as long as they're talented. or pretty", "baks, i never said that. which part of what i said sounded like 'the end of BINI' to you?", "wrong reply. should've posted as a comment"]}

{"dialog": ["Tangina lang.    \n   \nBakit mo ivivideo in the first place at ipopost pa sa social media (kahit dump account) ang mga ganitong bagay kung usapang magkakaibigan? Shit na nga yung pinaguusapan ninyo, gagawa ka pa ng ebidensya. \n  \nGusto kong malaman ang thought process nila.", "Yun din yung di ko gets. Back in my youth (charot) marami kaming kalokohan ng barkada ko lalo na kapag nakainom. Pero hindi namin vinideohan at lalong hindi naka upload sa internet. Ganun na ba ka addict sa social media ang Gen Z? Middle millennial ako, born late 80s, btw.", "Hahaha millennial here and praning. Nagdedelete ako ng messages sa gc and dm minsan pag may nasasabi akong garapal.", "Nahihiya ako na magviral sa social media at makita ng mama ko! Hahaha", "Ngaun Kasi gusto Ng lahat magviral. Ayan napapala tuloy"]}

{"dialog": ["Waiting sa gimik pr ni star magic", "Magdodonate na sa charity ang bini in the next few days or weeks or may kakantahang orphanage/hospital", "Hindi malayo, tapos animals2x, matanda, bata, cancer kids mala mmk, tree planting, clean up drive for the image, or magkakabitan na naman ang usual pokpoks ng abs-cbn tapos ihighlight nila kunyari para mapagtakpan ang kanilang golden goose. Or iiyak lang yan, dyan naman sila magaling", "Tried and tested formula na ang charitable actions after scandals. Hopefully they don't go the weaponizing mental health route", "Pinakamabenta yang mental health kineme sa ngayon, tapos ang ending, sila pa ang biktima. Mayabang pa naman pr ng star magic, ang hilig2x sa mga toxic talents tapos pag nabutasan, magmamalinis at tapos gawing normal ang mga kahangalan nila. Tandaan, most ng causes at advocacies ng mga yan ay part of their marketing. Mas makatotohanan at nakakarami ang snoke & fock dyan kaysa tunay. Giling lang mas marami dyan, pero ambabaw sa tunay na buhay"]}

{"dialog": ["Maybe their managament was right for milking the fuck out of them when they were at their peak  After this issue, brands will surely back out one by one because the publics too enraged with this whole BINI issue.", "Oo nga noh? Come to think of it, baka napredict na nila na PR disaster ang ibang Bini members and it's only a matter of time before magkalat ng malala at di na nila malinis, kaya take advantage na. Win-win sa management at sa girls kasi magkakaipon sila.", "As a marketing girlie, heard from a friend in the industry din na adviced to stay away from social media na yang BINI members after their airport issue at mainit ang mata sa kanila on public. Hindi rin naman ata nakikinig at nakailang patol pa sila Colet on X. PR disaster talaga sila kaya baka tama rin na kinuha na lahat ng opportunities before kahit mukhang overworked sila.", "Tagal ko na nagmamakaawa na wag na magsocial media pero nay dump account pa talaga. Ang kalat. They brought this upon themselves, which makes it so fucking frustrating. Imagine losing everything youve worked for because you can't just FUCKING LOG OUT"]}

{"dialog": ["If these 3 will be the reason of their downfall, Id feel so sorry for Sheena. After hearing her story, BINI is her 2nd family and right now, yun ang lakas nya. Kung masisira ang BINI because of this issue, hope the management can save the other girls careers.", "not a Bini fan\n\nI think the management better cancel the contract of those 3 problematic Bini members\n\nok na ang 5 members \n\nmuch better than 8 \n\nmas makakatipid pa ang management sa talent fees etc", "Not a fan pero parang mas maganda tingnan pag 5 lang sila. Hindi masyadong problematic. Nasa lima naman ata yung malalakas na fan base e. Parang dun sa tatlo, si Jho lang yung maraming fan AT ISA AKO DOON. Sya lang pinakagusto ko sakanila kaya super disappointed ako.", "You'd be surprised ang daming fans ni grumpy anger button colet. Kaya dami ngdedefend sa basura na ugali"]}

{"dialog": ["kung sa South Korea to or kasing sensitive natin yung mga Koreans pagdating sa kahit anong issue ng mga celebs and idols, malamang bagsak na career ng mga to. madadamay pa iba nilang mga members dahil sa mga kawalangyaang ginagawa nila.\n\nnot a fan of Bini itself, but I could say na may ult bias are Colet and Sheena, natutuwa ako sakanilang dalawa pero Colet no more. I have to admit na problematic talaga siya. palaging galit, tuwang tuwa pa mga fans nila. kesho napindot na naman si anger kuno. masyado siyang pinipreach sa pagiging angry bird niya. tuwang tuwa pa mga blooms tuwing pinapatulan niyan yung mga bashers. \n\nJhoanna naman. girl, what happened? same with Stacey.", "ilang taon na ba ang colet na yan at ginagawang whole personality nya si anger?", "She's young, pero a lot of the younger generations are angry naman talaga", "meh, she's 23"]}

{"dialog": ["\"Squammy\" kanal humor slash relatable local girls ang brand ng Bini girls, or at least yung mga members na sikat. Never liked them for that actually kasi ang taklesa nila. Mga walang class. I believe na when you're a celebrity, specially an idol, need ng konting mystery and all. Kapag binunyag mo lahat, you have a certain demographic na ma-aattract. Kaya ayan look at how their fans act lmao.\n\nSomeone needs to make a PPOP group with the debut era Blackpink/MEOVV marketing style na \"exclusive\" and consists of classy anak-mayaman girls na may media training. For sure there's a market for that Bini can't tap in dahil \"pang-masa\" sila at hindi naman ganon ang image nila.", "BINI members were adviced to stay away from social media pero sila lang ang hindi nakikinig haha sakit na ng bumbunan ng PR team nila  Okay naman na pang-masa ang brand nila pero according to my friend, pinagsasabihan na yung girls na wag na masyadong sumagot sagot sa fans sa X at lalong umiinit ang mata sa kanila ng public. They should be doing the KB way na pang-masa pero still mystery pa rin ang totoong character.", "Yung pagsagot talaga nila sa fans sa Twitter ang na-off ako. At ang kunsintidor rin nung iba eh maypa-\"napindot na naman si anger xD\" pa.\n\nAnd yes, okay lang rin ang pang-masa brand. It works talaga. Ang SB19, from what I see, very kanal humor, relatable, local boys, rags to riches din ang branding. Pero never ko nakitang sumasagot 'yan sa masa kahit ang daming trolls or negative comments. They respond with music or humor instead. Kaya ang solid ng fandom nila eh. Eh etong Bini, may rift at divide na agad ang fandom dahil mismong fans inaaway", "Oo, si Pablo mismo eh hindi nagpapapatol and dinadaan na lang sa kanta yung mga sagot. Notice how the tracks they're producing consists of multiple diss tracks di ba?"]}

{"dialog": ["Ayoko ng ganyan. Mga pasabik. Kung irerelease niyo, irelease niyo  Hindi yung madami pang pa hanash na ganyan. Nakakabwisit. Hahaha", "Idrop na agad, parang kailangan muna ng maraming likes eh HAHAHHA UHAW DIN EH HAHAHHA", "Mga clout chaser ang mga putangina"]}

{"dialog": ["this is the kind of pr nightmare abscbn probably never expected from them", "If they didnt preparw for the worst negligence on their part. If cash cow pala ang peg dapat mas nag higpit sila", "PR teams here are nothing like US media PR teams. No where near as strict as they should be."]}

{"dialog": ["casual fan tita here but not a bloom.\n\ni think dark and bastusan biruans really exist kasi maraame talaga sa atin ay taklesa at greenminded as a culture. plus we dont know ano context nung usapan so di ko masabi na SA and grooming ung video. so i really cannot crucify them for those heavy allegations cause it wasnt proven real, unless we see the full vid.\n\nang ayoko lang sa BINI ay yung pagrelease nila ng statement na\n\"ooops sorry we got caught pero kasalanan nyo pa din nainvade privacy namen\" kind of way. sama mo pa ung patuloy nilang pangaaway sa fans nila. tho calling out your fans if they are roo much is admirable, may healthy way to do that.\n\nwhile i agree we should respect the artists' privacy at tama naman talaga ung ibang pinaglalaban nila- the artists should also have this high level of awareness to accept the fact that they are a public figure\" and a part of their job is to be exposed in public's eye kaya dapat, alam nila mismo na parte ng trabaho nil...", "Same. Confused ako saan galing yung SA and grooming allegations. Out of context yung video and ang daming pwedeng context na hindi ganon kabigat. \n\nFor example, what if dinedemo nung two guys yung sexcapades nila when they were much younger? That's why emphasized yung \"13\" na age kasi nga naman unusual iyon for a 13 year old. But if she was doing it with someone around her age, that doesn't make it grooming, let alone SA.\n\nThat's just one possibility. Is it crass? Yes. Medyo off-putting if hindi ka type of person who makes 'dirty' jokes. But that doesn't automatically make it SA or grooming at all.", "i was thinking about that too. nung una kong panood, i thought the girl who said \"13 years old\" was pertaining dun sa isang lalaki, na he was 13 when he did that. hindi ko rin na-gets nung nabanggit yung name ng babae. sobrang kulang talaga sa context. not that I'm justifying that vid, i found it uncomfortable, and i barely know the people involved. sana lang maghinay-hinay sa mga salitang binibitawan yung iba kasi masyadong mabigat yung allegations na yun."]}
{"dialog": ["Alis nalang sila 3 para di madamay career nung 5", "True the fire. Delicadeza na lang if meron pa. Or yung 5 mag solo career if keri pa ma redempt. Tbh, they cannot cling with the \"BINI\" name anymore. Like in just a snap, naglaho bigla tingin ng mga tao sa kanila to the point na kahit anong damage control rn ng PR nila, laughing stock na sila because of what the 3 did."]}
{"dialog": ["Tagal na sinasabi na dapat i-train ng matindi tong mga to regarding responsible social media handling, di pa rin ginagawa. Ngayon, sana tutukan nila lalo na yung tatlo especially sa mga pag-uugali. Hindi na cute. Tumatanda na silang mga basura ang ugali.", "Feel ko sinabihan naman yan, si Maloi nakinig ehh, yung isa matigas talaga ulo"]}
{"dialog": ["Imagine after how many years of training, sweat and tears, ganito lang kadali sirain", "5 years of training sa 10-second video clip."]}
{"dialog": ["Oh my god. Masyadong naging comfortable sa soc med feeling untouchable. Hays", "pumasok na kasikatan sa ulo ng tatlo tsk tak tsk"]}
{"dialog": ["Is this the end of their Era? Ambilis naman", "As a Bini fan, sadly yeah, looks like it, hirap bumangon jan \n\nMag World Tour pa naman sila, goodluck sa cancel culture ng West, kaya sobrang frustrated din ako tangina, parang disappointed parent ganon HAHAHAHA"]}
{"dialog": ["Si Colet yung classmate mong campus crush at palaging sasayaw-kanta pag may program sa school pero 8080 at palamura.", "I never liked her to be honest. May something sa kanya na off vibes."]}
{"dialog": ["Puro pa cool kasi iniisip wala ng logic sus", "Yan pa itturo nila sa fanbase nila. Smh"]}
{"dialog": ["OT5 coming soon", "sila na lang itira tutal anjan naman yung ibang crowd favorite"]}
{"dialog": ["hahahaha.. ilang taon ba ang average ng mga users dito, bat naniniwala kayo sa mga ganyan.. juicecolored", "sa totoo lang haha"]}
{"dialog": ["An tanga bat ksi ni record pa... Sorry bobo. Ayan tuloy, face the consequence.", "Sorry di ako updated, anong video po? May link kayo?"]}
{"dialog": ["Pang-ilang anti-Bini post na ito? lol", "The hate did not come from nowhere bro. Deserve nila yung flak"]}
{"dialog": ["I think normal lang mag-green jokes within the circle, pero I dont think normal na isali ang minor don. Kahit yung mga madalas mag-green jokes, hindi ginagamit ang minor as example. Thinking about it, wala talaga akong maisip even in my circle ko na nag-jjoke ng ganyang klase. Either enabler ka or wala ka pang muwang sa mundo kaya tingin mo hindi big deal yan. Hopefully, its the latter.", "As someone na lagi may kabiruan ng green jokes, true yarn. Haha ang biruan namin lagi sa double meaning ng words tapos samin samin lang na may same wavelength pagdating sa green jokes"]}
{"dialog": ["Yung may guy na nagcomment na bakit daw sila nakamask sa airport eh di naman sila sikat daw. Tas nung the next time na nag airport yung bini nag jabawokeez costume sila full mask tas hoodie. I honestly think na that's funny hahahaha. Nagkaroon pa ng mini game sa twitter na kung sino raw ba yung bini member na ipopost nila while wearing the hoodie and mask\n\nBut I draw the line at that type of humor. SA humor will never be funny to me and SHOULD NOT be funny to anyone", "Their jabawokeez stunt was funny naman haha pero medyo ayaw ng PR team yung ganon na pakulo kasi mas nag gather pa ng attention sa public, lalo na on Facebook na consists of boomers."]}
{"dialog": ["Hindi naman taga-ABS iba jan, lalo na yang Lily Ganados. Binabash niyan sa account niya mga celebrities na inaaway ng fans ni Kathryn, majority are fellow ABS celebrities. Nakikipag-kampihan pa yan sa GMA alts para mang-bash ng ABS celebrities na hindi friends ni Kathryn. Kupal yan.", "wag ka ng mag taka fan din yan ni Deanna Wong na attitude sa fans", "Kaya lang naman naging \"fan\" ni Deanna Wong yan kasi kasagsagan noon ng love team nila ni Jema Galanza. Alam nyang nasa baby bra warriors ang clout kaya doon sya. LOL.", "pero ngayon si Jema binabash nya na"]}
{"dialog": ["lol hypocrites, pag ibang celebs yan OA sila mambash talaga, araw gabi pulutan nila. Selective", "Pag si Alden o Marian iyan abot hanggang impyerno galit nila. Nagsasaboy ng walang patawad na insulto at panlalait. Pero sa kapamilya, bigyan daw ng chance. Sabagay ano mapapala mo sa mga paid trolls?", "May dagdag fake news na blind item pa yan para gatungan pa."]}
{"dialog": ["Syempre galit sila kasi baka mawala sa payroll  di gumagana pagtatanggol nila kaya nanganganib matanggal sa PR team lmao", "Baka sila na next na ligwakin kapag nagbawas na naman ng empleyado ang ABS.", "Sana nga sila na ang next in line maligwak HAHAHAHA"]}
{"dialog": ["Kakapal ng mga mukha nyan. Ilang years na nilang sinasabi na mangga si Alden. Kung hindi mangga, bakla daw. Front lang daw yung sa love team kineme. Bakit hindi pa sila manigas?", "Uy careful baka sabihan kang Alden fan. Lahat daw ng redditors commenting against their fav fan ni Alden", "Hay naku go lang"]}
{"dialog": ["Funny tlga ng mga kapam alts. Pag GMA artists yan sila ang nauuna mag crucify at magpapakalat ng hate train. Mga kup*l tlga sila.", "This. Kaya Ang dami Kong tawa sa latest tweets nila. Hypocrites"]}
{"dialog": ["Same alt accounts na mahilig mang-drag down sa esbi. Especially, kay Stell.", "They are also the same people na grabe yung pambabash kay julie anne about the church mistake where she take accountability naman but super tanggol sa pag cheat ni maris racal na hindi naman nag sorry pero nagpa presscon."]}
{"dialog": ["Hahaha yan si Auntie Selina mukhang tambay lang din yan dito sa chikaph, & if you check her post dito lang din naman minsan galing yung content niya. Hindi naman lahat dito solid fan ng mga actor/actress, chikadora lang talaga & good observer.", "si Aunt Selina na hindi kayang ibash at sabihang groomer si Coco Martin, todo flex pa ng ratings ng batang quiapo at lait sa acting ni Ruru"]}
{"dialog": ["auntie Selina at lily,Dito kayu pumalag sa chikaph", "Nag try na yan mag karma farming si selina at pookie pie, dedmakels mga marites gaha"]}
{"dialog": ["Blooms = DDS = Loyalists = Extreme Leftists = Iglesia ni CoolTo =  Purist kakampinks\n\nPareparehas na panatiko, pareparehas na 8080.", "Also Blooms = Kathcakes\n\nBINI and Kathryn are the top female cashcows of ABS. Evident naman sa 2024 Christmas ID ng ABS"]}
{"dialog": ["bayad yan sila. PR accounts lang din yan disguised as makamasa alt accounts to create or alter the narratives about their talents/celebrities\n\nkumbaga pang-sway lang ng public opinions", "ganyan din sila nun kay maris. always on the move pag may issue/scandal na"]}
{"dialog": ["I fucking hate ABS CBN PR. LALO NA THAT THEY'RE TRYING TO INFILTRATE THIS SUB. Mga walang modo kayo, to spin your artists mess into a palatable gig to protect your business is unbelievable. Wag kayo pa epal hanggang dito, di niyo nababayaran mga gumagamit dito", "True. Nahahalata agad sila dito. Hirap na hirap sila. Unpredictable kasi dito."]}
{"dialog": ["what if GMA artists ang may issue, ano kaya magiging tweets nila? HAHAHAHHA", "Nauna pa nga sila dati isplook yung r*pe kay Sandro Muhlach kaya napagpyestahan. Nung nagsalita si Nio at Sandro na di nila nagustuhan yung mga naunang nagsplook ng walang consent, at nagiisip sila magsampa ng kaso, ayun bilis magdeactivate ni Altindaybadiday pati ng ibang alts."]}
{"dialog": ["Sana mapost din rin fez ni Naibara Lopez na isa din pulgas ni pusa", "May nag labas na ata dati sa x ng mukha nun ei terno din ugali nya sa itsura nya."]}
{"dialog": ["kung sa South Korea to or katulad tayo ng mga Koreans na sensitive when it comes sa kahit anong issue ng mga celebs/idols, bagsak na career ng mga to eh", "At dito Naka depende rin if sino nag hahandle kasi yung iba nkaka balik pero Yung Ibang artist halos di na mbalik ung dati nilang career status", "yes, pagalingan nalang din talaga ng PR. look at Kim Seon Ho, pabagsak na sana career niya nung kasagsagan ng issue niya pero magaling yung may hawak sakanya. kalkal kung kalkal sa past niya hanggang sa naisalba siya at namamayagpag parin ang career niya, kasi nga wala naman siyang fault. pero etong BINI, dili nalang ako mag-talk. ano yung advocacy nila? women empowerment? taena HAHAHA", "The thing din kasi with Seon Ho, may fans siya outside Korea na talagang susuportahan siya no matter what. Sayang naman din kasi yung caliber niya sa acting, hindi naman ganun karamihan ng actors sa kanila."]}
{"dialog": ["Nasan na kaya yung mga babae rito na nag popost na kesyo nag seselos sa jowa nila na baliw na baliw sa mga chimay na to? Eh chimay naman talaga. At di ko sinasabi to dahil lang may issue sila, putangina ang pangit naman talaga.", "HAHAHAHA nako tagal ko na sinasabi yan. Yung isa diyan muntik pa mautusan ng isang stylist friend ko dahil akala niya talaga julalay. Bini pala.", "kahit siguro sino kapag nakitang walang make up yang mga yan mapapagkamalang angels ni small laude", "lang talaga"]}
{"dialog": ["\"Bini save us through their music, tayo naman ang mag save sa kanila ngayun\"\n\n-taena mga superhero", "saved us through their music???? di ko nga bet mga kanta nila hahahahahahahahahahaha", "Imagine someone drowning and the lifeguard starts playing 'Cherry on Top'"]}
{"dialog": ["Ito ba yung mga gandang ganda sa sarili nila??? Sure na kayo dyan?", "Gulat nga ako eh. Yung nasa left tinatawag na Jennie Kim, kairita hahahahahaha", "Huh? Sino nagsabi? Blink ako ha pero te di ako ganyan ka bulag. Jusme wag naman si Jennie ko hahahahaah"]}
{"dialog": ["Possible scenario is ilalaglag ng star magic yung talents ng Viva para masave yung cashcow nila. Star Magic is notorious for throwing others under the bus.", "ito lang pinagtataka ko sa viva, bihira nila ipagtanggol mga talents nila. Like nung kasagsagan nung isyu sa kasal ni Claudia Barretto at binabash ng nanay ni cianne dominguez sila julia claudia at marjorie wala man lang pa-statement ang Viva Artists Agency to defend claudia & julia to think pareho nilang artists si claudia at julia ha at panay ang pagpapahiram nila ng artists nila sa Showtime."]}
{"dialog": ["Makakalimutan din daw yan ng fans nila", "in denial naman din fans nila todo tanggol pa"]}
{"dialog": ["Hindi namn talaga sila kagandahan or sobra visual kapag wala make up", "Hahahaha kaya nakakapagtaka pag may nagsasabi na ang ganda nila e, di ko talaga gets"]}
{"dialog": ["Maapektuhan kaya endorsements nila? Magkaka penalty kaya sila dahil sa issue?", "Yung Jollibee jusko poooooo", "For sure yan. Nung naglive in nga si James at Nadine, ekis na sila eh. Yan pa kayang SA ng minor.", "Confirmed ito?", "JoshLia break up, sinong natira?", "Right Joshua. \n\nThough did not know JaDine got dropped because of that live-in bit.", "But knowing Jollibee, they are conservative.\n\nI am so surprised Maris Racal came back for Mang Inasal."]}
{"dialog": ["Kung totoo man ito, mukhang indefinite hiatus muna ang mga main characters ng universe. Pero ang dali itype ng a very reliable source eh so hahahahha", "Nah they have an upcoming overseas tour. There is no way mag hiatus mga yan.", "Pwede maghiatus ung ibang members, tas ireason health prob.", "jusko pleaseee wag sana tayo gamitan ng mental health card", "Iiyak yan sa world tour nila at sasabihin Maraming salamat Blooms. Alam ko/namin na marami kaming pinagdadaanan ngayon, pero you chose to stay with teary eyes wink wink", "Wag mo bigyan ng idea hahaha. Hirap na hirap na pr team nila maglinis ng mga kalat nila. Dinagdagan pa nila. Bumango na nga ulit pangalan nila paglabas ng PBB tapos nabawi agad pagkatapos ng ilang araw palang."]}
{"dialog": ["Oh naur! Tuloy pa kaya ang world tour nila dito sa Dubai sa 18? sold out pa man din un nung una then nag-dagdag sila ng seat.", "Me and my friends also bought tickets. 6 kami in total but now I don't feel like going na. Let's see nalang talaga", "Puntahan nyo pa din. Kesa masayang yung pinambili nyo ng tickets. Kung ayaw nyo pumunta then sell nyo na lang. lam mo na, hirap buhay dito sa Dubai. Mistulang reward na lang natin sa sarili yung makapunta sa mga ganitong event.", "baka ibenta nalang. Di naman talaga ako fan nila, but I listen to some of their songs. Tsaka pag may nagcoconcert talaga dito na OPM artist, sinusupport namin. But this recent issue parang nakakawalang gana sumupport nang artist that don't live up to their advocacies .", "Ok lang mawalan ng gana. Isipin niyo na lang kumain kayo sa fine dining restaurant. Haha", "hahaha kaso di nakaka fine dining yung issue charot. Napag usapan namin, na manonood nalang kami since matagal na plano namin magkita kita on this same day. from iba-ibang emirates kasi kami manonood."]}
{"dialog": ["Ano kayang damage control gagawin ng abs d2. Actually kahit d2 sa reddit daming warfreak diehard bini fans. Dinelete ko na nga ibang comments ko kasi wala akong time makipag gera sa mga yon.", "Same damage control kay Maris and Anthony. Apologize once then lie low and keep quiet. Labas nalang ulit pag may bago nang issue at nasa ibang celebs na ang galit ng mga tao. Pretend like their own issue never happened.", "Ipagrerelease din ng kanta", "Lam na this. Tapos siguro sa kanta nilang isa about sa mental health niya eme", "Or Perpektong Tao version 2 haha"]}
{"dialog": ["If this is true then the World Tour is probably going to be cancelled...", "Yung concert sa LA, di pa din sold out.", "Ambitious naman kasi i Direk Dyogi. Hindi pa man sila international calibre na kaya mag world tour tbh. Gaatas na gatas ang mga akla.", "Ang pangit ng pag-handle sa kanila sa totoo lang. They're milking the group dry right now. Ilang beses na sila nag to-Tour with the same set list. Dapat they should be making more music to increase their music catalogue. The music is supposed to drive tours, not the other way around.", "Weird nga na nasa aurora pa sila. Ang dami nilang livs performances with so little to show for, hindi naman sila cover band!"]}
{"dialog": ["Kaya pa ba kahit 5 na lang?", "Sa tingin ko hindi, paano ang vocal performance ng group kung maalis ang 2 members na nagbubuhat sa live vocal ng group?", "Colet and sino yung isa?", "Jhoanna. Pero feeling ko kaya naman, nandiyan pa si Maloi. Magaling din kumanta si Gwen. Si Sheena at Aiah sakto lang."]}
{"dialog": ["Yung mga ganito yung dapat pinopost dito sa sub na to eh  Pa update EOD, OP! Hahaha", "tama di yung puro lait dapat chika talaga hahaha", "100%"]}
{"dialog": ["Ang take ko sa BINI issue ay dapat mas malala yung backlash sa mga lalaking gumawa nung joke. Accountable yung 3 as part ng video lalo ang laki ng platform at influence ng BINI, pero parang dapat mas turuan ng leksyon na rumespeto yung 2 lalaki.", "Both pareho ng level ng backlash. Mas pa nga dapat sa babae eh kc kabastos bastos na talaga yong may magrereenact ng sexual activities sa harap ng lider na yon at tatawa pa. Eww tlaga. nung teenager ako na wala pa ganun kaalam sa sex pero alam kong bastos ang ginagawa nila. Ekis tlaga", "Well palagi naman babae yung sinisisi sa ganyan kahit periphery sila sa joke. Pwede ba tayo mas mapanuri at kritikal sa lalaki? Nagbabago na mundo hindi na dapat may pass lang mga lalaki sa ganyan kesyo lalaki sila"]}
{"dialog": ["over sa \"we stanned the right member\". nilagay na naman sa pedestal hahahaha", "Typical redditor thingz"]}
{"dialog": ["this will gonna be their downfall ,nakakadiri ampt to think na mga babae pa", "Yun na nga eh halata mo sanay na sanay sila sa ganun disturbing joke, pakarat girlie yung tatlo sa loob binibini sa panlabas"]}
{"dialog": ["Sino ba yung mga lalake? Non showbiz friends? Livestream ba un or if hindi, sino nagpost ng vid and sino yung ashley? Sorry diko knows yung mga pahamak na lalake sa vid", "Di ko kilala yung isa pero, si Ethan, member ng GAT ppop boygroup."]}
{"dialog": ["According to my source, Aiah is headed to NXT daw? Akala ko diretso main roster na.", "Jade Cargill yarn?"]}
{"dialog": ["A very reliable source ito naman mga tao dito maniwala agad. \n\nNote: i do not tolerate Bini behavior specially S/A jokes.", "Maniniwala sila kasi pasok sa agenda nila hahahaha"]}
{"dialog": ["Feeling ko nga si Aiah unang magsosolo e.", "Good for her! Nasa kanya na ang lahat. Yung iba nakikisabay nalang sakanya pra matawag na may sense"]}
{"dialog": ["i think medyo malayo narin loob ni aiah sa ibang girls. mapapansin na tahimik lang sya pag magkakasama sila di tulad noon na labas lagi yung kulit. maybe nao-off na rin sya sa ugali ng ibang members. pinagtitiisan nalang since Bini yung nagdadala ng pera sa kanila", "Parang si Aiah lang kasi yung nagma-mature sa kanila. Yung mga joke at topic ng members paulit-ulit, hindi na nag-evolve from brainrot humor. Ang laging topic nila kay Aiah, her age, her ship with Mikha, her hobbies na sasabihin nila pang-tita."]}
{"dialog": ["May image palang pinoprotect bat pa vinid at inupload ni colet? Sad.", "Tbh si Colet para talagang walang utak na ginagamit sa socmed...", "Paano tinolerate ng fans nila yung ganyang ugali ng bobitang yan. Ilang beses na nangyari yung ganyan eh pinalampas lang haha. Yung nagtanong lng tapos nagalit si gaga na mababa comprehension", "Pinapalabas lang na 'totoong tao' daw kasi kaya ganon. Fyi kapag balahura ka sumagot sa totoong buhay makakahanap ka ng katapat mo na sasampalin ka na lang bigla...", "Kapag bastos, bastos na talaga. Sabi nga ni Anne Pinanganak kang bobo, lalaki kang bobo, mamatay kang bobo", "\"Utak nga ng tao nadidissect ko, doorknob pa kaya?\""]}
{"dialog": ["Maiiwasan sana ito kung umpisa pa lang may media or pr training na sila. Kahit mga simple pero paulit-ulit na paalala lang sa pag-iingat ng paggamit ng phone o awareness man lang sa sinasabi kaso wala eh. Hindi nila magets na need nila yun kasi bigla silang sumikat and sa totoo lang parang hindi nila alam ihandle yung fame. Sobrang taklesa pa rin nila. Naging sobrang hambog din ng fans nila bung sinasabi ng casuals na they should undergo media training. Nilait-lait pa ang mga kpop idols kesyo mahihina raw ang kpop fans and refusing authenticity daw. Nagba-backfire na tuloy ngayon kaya lalong nakakahiya.", "Sayang ang media training at laway ng PR team kung mahina kokote ng client or ayaw makinig.", "i know pero legit na wala silang media training at all", "Meron, I know the PR people who did the media training on them and lets just say.good luck sa BINI.", "oh.. then they are absolutely fucked", "Exactly. Bingo."]}
{"dialog": ["angtanga talaga ng mga celebrities na nilalagay katarantaduhan sa dump accounts nila. career sabotage", "real HAHAHA. i'm telling you guys, 'wag na 'wag niyo ilagay baho niyo sa social media kasi kahit naka-private 'yan, there will always be someone who can access it. proven and tested. that's the reason why i deleted all of the pictures showing my face in social media and doesn't upload them anymore. you'll never know the amount of people who can easily access your private dump accounts.", "eh kaso allegedly ay galing sa dump account mismo ni colet so kung totoo, wala siyang nakitang mali dun sa ginawa nila. hindi niya naisip na \"baho\" yun.", "Katawa mga public personalities na may dump accounts where they post their baho", "wake and bake"]}
{"dialog": ["Alisin na lang yung tatlo. Binis gonna thrive without them anyway.", "medyo sayang lang kasi magaling talaga na vocalist ng bini si jho and colet. si stacy okay lang kasi di naman ganon ka-talented compared to her members.", "true. sino nalang matitira na kayang maglive vocal", "Gwen and Maloi.", "hmmm si Gwen di masyado."]}
{"dialog": ["I actually like them as a group and wanted to see them. Part sa bias ko sana si Jhoanna pero jusko nakaka disappoint kahit di ako super fanatic hahay, wag nalang mag stan ng artists, kapagod na HAHAHAHAHAH parang dati bet ko si Maris pero ending ang lala ng issue", "Same. Fan ako ni Maris before.\n\nTapos ngayon lowkey BINI fan  Nagugustuhan ko pa mandin si Jhoanna recently. Hay, palibhasa may unnecessary h sa pangalan. Jejemon jok AHAHAHA", "Ang random pero huy may unnecessary H din ako sa pangalan", "NAUR GIRLIE IM SORRY", "WAGAHAHAGA OK LANG GIRLIE ANG FUNNY LANG"]}
{"dialog": ["The downfall of BINI", "Di mo sure. Ung kay maris nga, parang wala lang ung cheating issue. Mukhang ok na ulit ngayon", "Because Maris wasnt stupid enough to joke about sexual assault and video it pa", "turueeeeee. and andaming higad na kumakampi kay maris kasi cheaters din dila dati.\npero idoubt people would be so vocal about being #metoo when it comes sa joking about child abuse", "Wala nga comparison between Maris and BINI eh in terms of sins, it doesnt compare"]}
{"dialog": ["i wouldnt even pity them at this point if ever magpa presscon sila, ayaw ko na ng crocodile tears, alam pala nila na mali bat pa pinost??", "Nasa dump account eh. Akala nila walang snitch bobita lang talaga si ateng di nag-iisip", "Kahit sa dump acct pa yan, why did they think to post something so crass like this whlist begging for privacy kuno. kaloka mga bakla, sayang.. ang ganda na sana ng career. Talagang lumaki lang siguro ulo at they needed to be grounded na.", "baka ganyan talaga ugali kaya kahit anong pigil eh aalingasaw."]}
{"dialog": ["Ano yung career nung dalawang lalake????", "yung isa nasa Ang Mutya ng Section E and member ng GAT, bagong ppop group ng Viva na nag-remake nung Daleng-dale na song. Ayan, daleng-dale talaga sila. Taga-Star Magic pa ang kasama nila sa scandal.\n\nEdited to mention na isa lang sa dalawang yan ang member ng GAT.", "Hindi kasali sa group yung isa, rumored bf ni colet", "thanks! edited my comment. pero kay colet ba, hindi kay stacey?"]}
{"dialog": ["I wouldnt mind if si aiah, mikha and gwen nalang yung members ng bini. Yung iba, di macontrol pagkakalog eh.", "Mas maganda magkaroon na lang sila ng subunits para masalba pa ang group name kahit papano.", "Me reading that as soo-boo-nihts is a very  Diane Medina momint", "Su-bu-nit hahahahahaha di ka nagiisa te"]}
{"dialog": ["Si Stacey, siya na nga yung pinaka-panget siya pa yung pinaka bastos ang bunganga lol", "Di ko nga gets gandang ganda sila don may sarili daw ring light lol", "Bini Pokwang", "Don't disrespect Pokwang like that."]}
{"dialog": ["Iniisip ko pano nyang relationship ni Jho and Colet ksi may pnakamalinis na image non is Jho. Dont get me wrong mali ginawa nla pro ung dynamics nyan ng bini baka away2 na nman. Sa mga live nla before nun inaamin ksi nla na may times na di sla nagppansinan.", "Kung may talino si Jhoanna, di nya sisisihin si Colet kasi alam nya sa sarili nya na tinawanan nya yung ganong joke, meaning tinotolerate nya yun. Sama sama silang mag acknowledge ng mga mali nila at never nilang ulitin yung ganun.", "Eh un na nga halatang di nman tlga genuine na talino ksi tnawanan nya pa rin. So for sure lalu sa mga past lives nla, sgrdong may awayan na mangyayari nyan (pro of course dpat united prin ang front) and i agree na dpat magapologize nlang sla.", "Dapat sumama yan sa mga hindi nagtotolerate ng mali para matuto. E kung dyan sila sumasama, iisipin nyan mga yan normal yun at walang mali roon."]}
{"dialog": ["Ito na ang simula ng pagbagsak. Antanga rin kasi ni Colet for uploading that kind of video na parang normal na normal lang sakanila pag usapan yon. Kebabaeng tao. Kahit pa dump account mo yan te, mas magaling maghanap at imbestiga mga tao kahit gaano mo pa kagustong itago. HAHAHAHAHA. Face the consequences of your dumb actions. Kung titignan din sa video, parang this girl group is the kind of group na bully in real life. Smh", "What funny is nasa circle nila yung nag-leak nun so hundi na kailangan hanapin ng tao lol", "Hala totoo ba? Jusko", "Circle mo lang naman papayagan mo mag-follow sa dump account diba? Malamang sa malamang friend nila yun."]}
{"dialog": ["I've said it before: BINI members needs some serious Social media training.\n\nIdc kung anong tunay nilang personalities behind the scenes pero sana alalahanin nilang may mga bata at teenagers silang fans that look up to them.\n\nTsaka if Star Music really wants them to go Global, hindi tatalab yung ginagawa nila ngayon", "their fans were saying na pang kpop lang daw ang media training lol. nakakahiya tuloy sila lalo ngayon", "Antatanga din ng fans hahha. Need ng social media training kasi generation ngayon gusto lahat ishare at ipost. Lakas ng cancel culture sa SK pero sa totoo lang, cut from the same cloth ang fanatics duon at dito lalo na mga pop star fans and love team fans."]}
{"dialog": ["Nako pano ang mga endorsments hahaha", "idont know if jollibee would still want to be associated with these girls given na kids mostly ang market nila", "Sana nga ipull out na sila ng Jollibee, Puro mga A-List ang endorser ng Jollibee eh atsaka hindi maganda sa market ng Jollibee na yung endorser nila ay may issue about minor lalo nat dami mga bata mahilig sa Jollibee"]}
{"dialog": ["Kawawang 13 yo na bata kung sino man yun. Pinagtatawanan ng mga kapwa babae grabe. Mga BINIbini pa man din", "binibini sa pang labas, Pakarat girlie sa loob  Enjoyer ata sila kapag binabastos sila ng mga lalaki kaya wala sa utak nila na mali ang SA", "Di ko mawari eh ganito na ba biruan sa generation na to? Samen dati ganyang mga edad  mga biruan sa kalye pag usapang bastos walang damayan ng minor eh. Kase kotong ka nun or gulpi."]}
{"dialog": ["Empowering women pero ganoon biruan hahaha", "Pakarat girlie ksi sila in real life  Binibini lang sila panlabas", "Sabi nga nila, kahit anong ayos at ganda ng damit, di parin matatakpan ang masamang ugali"]}
{"dialog": ["Maapektuhan kaya endorsements nila?", "Sana nga para matauhan sila, palibhasa sanay sila na lumilipas lang mga issue nila kaya never sila natututo or nag iingat sa kilos nila kung may issue ba sila magagawa", "Yun lang. damay mga matitinong members"]}
{"dialog": ["Guys context please. Nakita ko video. Sino nasa silya and andun pa sa scene yung dalawang bini member habang nag uusap?", "casual pag-uusap, nagkukulitan yung 2 boys then, ni-dry hump ni Ethan from GAT si Shawn Castro sa harap ni Bini Jho. Tapos sabi ni Bini Stacey, ganun ginagawa ni E kay Ashly/Ashley na di natin alam kung sino, then may nagsabi (si Bini Colet ata) ng \"13 years old\" and \"sinasabunutan\" (not sure lang kung ano jan sa 2 sinabi nya).", "Omg! Naku nakakagalit at alarma ito. Parang natural na lang sa ibang kabataan. Tsk. Thanks!"]}
{"dialog": ["BINI needs Media Training in this case. On how this can be handled better", "Paano imemedia train eh sa ganyan sila nakilala sa pagiging kanal at scandalosa. Palapatol sa basher lahat nirereplyan hahaha kalat", "Oh damn... \n\n:( \n\nMy young cousins, my nephews and my nieces look up to them pa naman"]}
{"dialog": ["bat todo tanong pa?\nleast i want to happen is maexpose pa si girl. imagine maexpose na ginagawa mo yung when you were 13. whats with the obsession of finding the identity?", "focus na nga lang sana run sa issue. gusto pa idox ung girl", "kaloka. kung ako si girl if may magpost detailing bakit siya yan, kakasuhan ko. p"]}
{"dialog": ["Hindi namn busy mga yan, yung isa member panay travel abroad tas kapag may event video or live ang bini mukha pagod itsura, yun pala sa kaka travel nya hindi sa trabaho ginagawa ng bini  Yung isa member namn panay bar pati ibang member makikita mo panay rin gala with friends kaya nagiging sintunado boses nila kapag mag peperform sila, hindi na ata sila nag prapractice akala ata nila magaling na sila porket dami na nila fans", "Pwede ba pa-name drop if sino sa members ang ganito? Hahaha not much of a fanatic para i-follow ko sila but I want to know the tea.", "feel ko si Mika yung nagbabar"]}
{"dialog": ["Pake ni Emilio sa problema ng Jhocey eh hindi naman sila kasama hahahaha kung makacomment naman yung nasa ss hhahahahah", "Meron pa sa taas niyan ang sabi \"Ano pong masasabi niyo sa issue ng Jhocey?\" HAHAHAHAHAHA", "Hahahahahaha leave them alone guyssss\n\nPero I would understand kung uutusan ng each management ng MiLi na distansya muna sa Jhocey (well si Michael siguro, si Emilio baka gamitin for damage control) pero nakakasad lang kasi I was enjoying their interactions especially yung bowling night nila."]}
{"dialog": ["yes be she can sing \"in tune\" ordinary singing kumbaga na kayang kaya lang ng kapitbahay natin. and with good tuning okay naman. pero not to the point na as in live.\nmuch like yung mga dancer na pang asap and mgaling talaga versus yung mga kaya namang sumabay sa school intramurals mass demo", "Ahhh I get what you mean. I hope they do those  kind of perf more para mahasa.", "omg thought youre gonna lash out on me pero sa true more training pa talaga"]}
{"dialog": ["Dyogi have let them run off their mouth for far too long. Walang restraint, mindfulness, and tact. Okay na rin para lumabas ang totoong baho. Ang dami pang adbokasiya at social awareness kineme, puro performative naman. The audience are not blind. Now, we get to witness them with their real sh!t.", "trueeee the preaaaaaaching ni jhoanna sa pbb i kennat"]}
{"dialog": ["Ang gusto ko talagang malaman ay ano kaya reaction ng other Bini members don sa issue nung tatlo? As a medyo fan ng Bini interested talaga ako sa kalalabasan ng issue na to...", "Their bond and sisterhood will surely be tested. Worst case scenario magkaroon ng internal conflict between members. Especially dun sa 3. Magtuturuan kaya sila? Or will they face this issue together?"]}
{"dialog": ["hay na call out rin ang kanal humor nilang yan. lagi ako dina downvote sa mga tangang panatiko dito kapag may sinasabi ako patungkol sa ugali nilang yan lol", "Right? Their fans often disguise their trashy attitude as \"humor\"  or being palaban. Mga patola pa masyado, and yung sarcasm nila are sometimes too much and not funny at all."]}
{"dialog": ["Wala talagang naninira sa kanila no. Sila talaga sumisira sa mga sarili nila through their words and actions.  \nEx. Maloi mocking PWDs", "yung ngongo"]}
{"dialog": ["Ironic that their name is bini but their actions are opposite of binibini. Im not judging and we are all humans , they have a right to freedom and privacy, and luckily, the Philippines is NOT like South Korea (in that sense) but as my Titas would says, Myyy GODDDDDD. WHY ARE YOU SO BOBO?  I still cant believe Colet willfully uploaded that. Are you that tanga? Its one thing if its leaked. Its another thing if you record and keep it to yourselves (even if I disagree and what they said was disgusting) but the blooms will eventually find what you posted on your dump account! Talented pero walang utak, and I hate this phrase but Ill say it, walang breeding, talaga. And this is coming from a mid bloom. \n\nAs for the tweet - dapat lang", "From Bini to Bini ni andrew e real quick ung leaked joke time nila"]}
{"dialog": ["yung issue, parang hindi mo na nga dapat ginawa, pinagmalaki mo pa, colet, hindi mo na nga dapat vinideo, ipinost mo pa. Bala ka na, hirap niyo ipagtanggol", "is this from fliptoo battle? i feel so old"]}
{"dialog": ["How stupid are you to create a dump account and post nasty stuff on it. People will find out eventually. The best kept secrets do not have receipts.", "was it posted??"]}
{"dialog": ["planado na tlga nung origin nung nag post, either tinalo o may nagawa silang masama sa taong yun HAHAHHAHA, yan na downfall ng BINI. (sana naman this time wag sila maging PATOLERA sa X kasi ikakabaon pa nila lalo yun HAHAHHA)", "Na-call out na nga si Colet bilang sya naman ang mahilig mang call out HAHAHA", "Wala pang rebut si anger? Haha", "Wala, di pa daw alam kung sino ang pipindutin kung si Anger o si Embarrassment", "Turn-off masyado ako kay Colet dahil sa way nya sumagot sa comments online eh. Kahit di naman sya inaaway ng fan, treat nya yun as bashing/attack. \n\nTapos ngayon tahimik? Nag iisip pa ata anger vs embarassment + pr stunt + twisting facts", "Rude talaga pero natutuwa ang blooms sa mga sagutan nya", "Base lng sa observation ko karamihan ng pinoy gustong gusto ganyan ugali", "Hahaha korek, showbiz, politics. Name it."]}
{"dialog": ["Kahit naman kasi ordinaryong tao ka, kung ganun yung kakalat na issue sayo, mahihiya ka talaga. Imagine joking about SA/RP to a 13-yr old as if its a norm? A daily conversation? She deserves to be uneasy.", "mabuti nga pinaggraduate pa sa ibang school yan inexpel na dahil na dawit sa issue ng pedophilia at sexual perpetrator", "mukhang diploma mill ang school", "yung owner daw ng school na yan ay magulang nung isang member ng BGYO soooo", "Wait---so those two boys are BGYO members?", "No. Yung Ethan ay member ng GAT na boy group. Yung Shawn naman daw ay alleged boyfriend ni Stacey.", "She could do a lot better if that's the case. Parang ang excited nila pumasok sa realationship. May rumored relationship halos."]}
{"dialog": ["Sana mabash din yung Ethan David at yung isa pang lalaki. Dapat sa mga yan kinakapon.", "yan si ethan david din yung panimula kung bat nagkaissue sa BINI last year. di pa natuto alam nang bad influence sa kanila", ">yan si ethan david din yung panimula kung bat nagkaissue sa BINI last year. \n\nAnong gnwa nya last yr po?", "siya nagupload nung BINI appearance sa bday ni Gelo. im in no placecto give benefit of the doubt kasi fan lang naman ako, sino ba naman ako diba, pero i assume for the sake of camaraderie kaya sila pumunta don kahit na may issue na talaga yan sila.", "Feeling sikat talaga yang Ethan David. Sarap maglapag ng insider chika kung gaano kabobo yan. F na f!", "Please spill the tea hahahahaha"]}
{"dialog": ["Ang tanong sino nag video at nag post sakanila nun.", "Galing daw sa dump account ni Colet, so most likely siya may hawak nung phone", "So parang na hack si Colet?", "More like may nag-snitch kagaya nung kay Kitty D. sa dump/finsta account", "Grabeh noh. Parang ang stupid naman if pinost niya yun, kahit sa close friends niya. Di ba nila alam na ang pangit nun", "hot take but i prefer that this was leaked so now we know how they really think"]}
{"dialog": ["Ang tanong ko naman dito is yung guys ba, nabbash din? Gets ko naman why need i call out ang BINI, dapat lang. Pero i hope hindi lang sila yung sumalo lahat sa backlash. Sana same din ang energy towards the guys.", "Nope not siding with the guys pero yung pinaka root cause nung issue is yung gatong nung 2 tapos si Jho na dapat sumaway sa kanila e tumawa dun sa comment nung 2.", "The Ethan guy is a part of a group called GAT and teenagers are also probably watching that group so yes, deserve din nya yung bashing for acting that out. \nGets ko naman na mali talaga yung BINI and oo disappointing si Jho, and yes they deserve all the calling out and bashing. Pero since idol din yung isang guy, he's gonna get a free pass ba? Wala nga akong nakikita na nagcacall out. IMO, dapat lahat ng involved jan sa video e puros kino call out. If the guys are just horny, they could just said na \"ayaw ko sa minor\" knowing na Colet said 13yrs old.", "Hindi naman free pass. Its just that mas sikat yung Bini and madami na rin silang issues before na pinalagpas ng Blooms. I think this one is a dealbreaker. \n\nMay post na rin actually dun sa guys. But again, bukod sa pangit na manyak sila, wala rin naman kasi silang career to begin with.", "Ayun din. Haha pero ayun ayaw ko lang na walang hate energy dun sa guys kasi yung iba gagawin na namang excuse na kesyo \"mga lalaki\" yan.", "Actually, marami rin yung hate sa guys. Wala rin ngang nagtatanggol dahil bukod sa mali, wala rin namang fans. Haha \n\nMedyo nadisappoint kasi yung mga blooms talaga kasi akala nila genuine yung advocacies ng girls. Plus maraming minor na fans."]}
{"dialog": ["Halata nga. Yung ngiti ni Jhoanna halata mong uneasy siya eh. Parang paiyak na or smthng. Grabe siguro yung sakit na naf-feel ng parents niya nung nalaman na involved yung only child nila sa ganoon... Hayy", "may vid din sa grad song .di talaga siya kumanta or sumabay sa dance. iyak lang siya", "Link?", "dumaan lang sa facebook diko nacopy paste .", "I see. Well, mas ok na rin if shes shaken. May this make some sense to her."]}
{"dialog": ["Yung mga babae kayo pero ginagawang joke at joke lang para sa inyo ang SA at grooming", "Worst, they are promoting women empowerment. Ang lala.", "\"women of the year\" pa yan sila sa billboard at may paandar pa na miniverse  wow wow wow the irony", "Hypocracy at its best."]}
{"dialog": ["may anay sa group nila, hahaha", "ang nababasa kong theory sa X ay baka sa circle of friends daw nila. may spy/snitch sa mga private instagrams nila or dump accounts.\n\nfor me though, wala namang magiging issue kung wala silang ginagawang problematic. nakaka disappoint kasi hindi naman na sila mga bata. stop na sa making excuses for grown adults. hold them accountable for their actions tapos hope they learn and grow from it na lang.", "either talagang may hidden animosity yung nag snitch, or this is a normal occurrence sa dumps nila kaya napikon na at nilabas, or talagang kuha lang pikon nung snitch. either way, sila pa rin ang may mali.", "kaya nga, bakit nagagalit yung iba dun sa nagsnitch, siya ba nagsabi sa kanila na gawin yan? di ba hindi. at kahit \"jOkE\" yan amongst friends, any decent person won't find it funny. tsaka kung totoo na galing sa dump account ni colet yung video, ang lala kasi pinost pa niya talaga."]}
{"dialog": ["tama lang din yan, minsan talaga kailangan din ulit nilang tumapak sa lupa\n\nfeeling din kasi nila my immunity sila sa mga bashers since ang dami nag tatanggol sa kanila", "Sila rin yung mga OA sa grupo. I guess mababawasan na nang konti yung pagiging OA nila.", "At sobrang active sa X. Lahat pinapatulan na akala mo righteous. Oh ayan ngayon lumabas na biro lang sa kanila yang ganyang krimen.\n\nWomen empowerment pa more.", "The internet never forgets pa naman. Every time may sabihin sila that would relate to issues like abuse, women empowerment, children rights, for sure maqquestion credibility nila. \n\nThis will also affect endorsements because who would want their brand to be associated with artists with this behavior?"]}
{"dialog": ["The lack of media training is quickly coming to bite their asses. Ginatasan na agad kasi ng management, hindi man lang tinuruan magligpit or magtago ng kalat nila.", "Korek. Colet, ano na?", "Bastos ang Colet na yan. Lagi na lang nirarason na napindot si Anger. Lol.", "Kala nila nakakatawa. Haha. Feeling edgy sumagot, walang media training. Edi ayan. Dyan sya sumagot sa issue nya."]}
{"dialog": ["If may hidden animosity or inggit yung nag-expose, does it matter? Hindi naman gawa-gawa lang yung ni-leak eh, ts the truth!\n\nThey deserved to be cancelled and mawala sa spotlight forever.", "May mga nagsasabi pa na AI lng daw. Nakakatawa na nakakaawa mga fans ng grupong to.", "Lmao. AI? They dont even know the difference between AI and human. I feel sad for them.", "Mga bulag bulagan haha mga fake fans daw pag umalis sa fandom nila dahil LANG dun"]}
{"dialog": ["By friday, tapos na meeting ng PR team nila.", "Malalaman na natin pag nakaisip na sila ng strategy para sa issue na to pag may puting usok na na lumalabas sa ilong ni Dyogi whahahahahah", "Conclave pero pagbobotohan kung sino ang gagawing sacrificial lamb para iligtas career ng Bini.", "Sadya tlagang may sacerificial lamb? Sino ba ang naging ganun sa issue nina maris racal?"]}
{"dialog": ["nawala na yung video?", "Na copyright siguro", "meron kayo nung buong video?", "Yes nakasave sakin"]}
{"dialog": ["Di ko mawari sa account nya kung fan sya o hater ng Bini eh", "May pagka obsessed so both siguro lol", "Obsessed or not. Mali paren naman ang bini.", "Yung mga obsessed kase magaling mag halungkat o ayan paborito ninyo exposed na"]}
{"dialog": ["Even body language ng parents, especially yung tatay niya.", "Yes mukhang on the way pa nga lang daw baka napagalitan na yan", "for sure! only child pa naman din si jho tas strict din parents based sa mga kwento niya. mapapagalitan tlaga yan and rightly so."]}
{"dialog": ["sad, parang performative activism lang pala ginagawa nila", "Parang yung kay ashtine na dds. Nung nabuking biglang nag-follow sa angat buhay. Pare-pareho lang talaga sila", "double kill yun kasi di lang siya dds, bbm rin."]}
{"dialog": ["notice how this PR management has to clean their shit every now and then? hope they do some real action towards the girls if they still want to maintain their fame.", "Kaya pala mahal merch nila kase malaki gastos sa PR team", "lol. kaya pala kasi need din nang malaking pambayad sa PR team kasi malaking stunt ang need nilang gawin para macover up issue"]}
{"dialog": ["#Question: Tuloy kaya ang World Tour nila?", "Makancel sana Hindi nila deserve ang world tour na yan kulang na nga sa talent at di pa kagandahan exempt kay aiah at mika, di pa sila bumawi sa ugali, kahit sa ugali man lang nag all out sana sila.", "Naku, feeling ko super stress ni Laurenti Dyogi! Eh grabe ang pang gagatas niya sa Bini. Kaya dapat matulog and Binverse WT hehe"]}
{"dialog": ["FAFO moment niya and it hit hard.", "ano yung FAFO?", "Fuck around and find out. This gens saying of actions have consequences."]}
{"dialog": ["Nakakalungkot na napakainsensitive nila sa ganitong aspect. SA is really traumatic esp to us victims. BINI esp those three should be accountable for their actions. Theyll learn it the hard way.", "Nakakagulat na joke lang yung SA sa kanila samantala dati may nagsasabi sa fans nila nababastos daw ang bini at nagdedemand pa sa management nila na protektahan daw ang bini laban sa mga lalaki gumagawa ng kalaswaan sa picture ng bini. Tas itong mga bini after sila ipagtanggol ng mga fans nila sa mga kalaswaan, joke lang pala ang rape at Sexual abuse. Ma sexual abuse sana sila tignan natin kung magawa pa nila ijoke kapag sila mismo nakaranas nyan", "I agree. They really need to learn the hard way. Madali lang naman kc magsabi ng joke lalo na at di nila naranasan at hindi traumatic sa kanila. Pero pag naexperience nila ang sexual abuse (hindi ko hinahangad na may mangyari sa kanila pero parang sa galawan nila baka nga hindi na sila virgin, lol) dyan nila malalaman na ay mali pala naging reaction nila. Hindi pala dapat pagtawanan or gawing joke. Kahit pa sabihin na privately pa na usapan. Tsk tsk. Dyan sila iiyak at pavictim. Aigoo"]}
{"dialog": ["Sabi na nga ba. Kaya parang iba facial expression niya sa mga photographs and vids during their grad.", "Di ba parang nauna na ang graduation bago yong viral? Kc nung May 7 ko nalaman na may nagleak. Or busy lang kc ako sa kabilang fandom kaya hindi ko knows. Mga may 8 ko ns nalaman. Haha", "Nope, during grad mismo pinost. Nag-tweet mismo 'yung nag-leak ng video ng congratulatory message niya kay Jhoanna then stated na may gift day siya sa kanya (which is the leaked video). Can't find the screenshot lang."]}
{"dialog": ["May concert pa yang bini na yan dito sa Dubai, I checked the ticket prices out of curiosity and 5 times higher than normal. I went to Sarah G Bamboo, Leah Salongga and even international Artists concerts just last year dito sa coca cola arena Dubai but they have the same reasonable ticket prices. Ung bini di ako makapaniwala ung standing fanpit na pinaka mura is about 600 Dhs with is like 9k in php.", "So mas mura ang bini concert compared sa iba?", "Mas mahal"]}
{"dialog": ["Will this issue affect BINIs brand endorsements?? Kahit yung tatlo lang yung involve sa scandal na to??", "Yes, for sure may morality clause ang JOLLIBEE", "Patay"]}
{"dialog": ["Off topic pero nauna pa tong grumaduate ka injs kasi school namin", "What do you mean? Dapat ba di muna sya ggraduate. Curious here", "Hindi naman kakatuwa or proud nga samantala ako pa re schedule reschedule graduation tas wala namang kwenta dahil umasa lang sa bayadan palibhasa diploma mill pinag aralan ko"]}
{"dialog": ["si BaliLeeg yung original na nagpost kaya username rin niya yung nasa watermark ng video\n\ntime of upload: BaliLeeg - 11:27am ; mistffork - 1:04pm", "Sino kaya ang totoong BaliLeeg?", "Baka from circle lang din nila yan kasi allegedly ay galing sa dump acct ni c eh"]}
{"dialog": ["Ano nga yung sinabi ny dati sa fan, pwede wait lang? Something haha", "sabi nya hindi ka makapghintay? bastos talaga dating ng sinabi nya feel na feel pagiging anger kala nya ikakaganda ng ugali nya", "Asan na yang anger moment nya ngayon? Hehe. Kabustusan? Ahh, kaya pala. Alam naman natin na bastos mouth nya, pero di ko inexpect ganyan kalala."]}
{"dialog": ["Parang iiyak Si Jhoanna, yung tatay mukhang Galit.", "Mukhang namamalo talaga tong tatay nya no"]}
{"dialog": ["She looks like she's about to cry. Probably being hit by other members, manager, network and parents.\n\nThat's a hard lesson for them pero there should be more impact kesa sa public scrutiny.\n\nPag Kasi Public figure ka either don't do stupid shit na alam noong controversial or WAG IVIDEO and wag na wag iuupload. \n\nKahit pa sinabing dump acct Yan. You have ZERO idea who wants you down. \n\nWhether by animosity or dahil sa jealousy. \n\nThey should know better. They know their supposed qdvocacies, the public image they're painting for themselves and their audience.", "You can tell how one's mind works kung bakit need pa i-video yung ganung kalat. Double down pag in-upload. For what? Wala, kasi struggling yung gears sa ulo niya."]}
{"dialog": ["Bini, binira muna ata ng nanay at tatay  bago umattend eh. Halatang pinagalitan o ano", "Deserve kotongan! FAFO malala."]}
{"dialog": ["Galing daw yung vid sa dump acc ni c? Ang di ko maintindihan bat ipopost yung gantong kalat hangout videos in the first place??? Ang naiisip ko lang na rason ay it's for the eyes ng close circle of friends nila, who I can only assume won't react negatively to these kinds of jokes. Kumbaga normal lang to sa kanila. Yikes. (Syempre assumption ko lang naman yan but regardless of the context I would never laugh like that and joke about what sounds like SA involving a minor.)", "oo nga noh. comfortable talaga na ipost sa dump acc. marami pa namang friends to sila sa industry. okay lang pala ganito sa kanila. usual friends naman natin hindi masyado tayo nagga-ganito. meron man, hindi nagvi-video dahil pwede makalat baka mag magpost pa nga. hindi rin nag-iisip talaga na they are the nation's gg and di ba nila alam na marami pwede manira sa kanila even kahit friends pa nila? tapos post lang ng post ng kahit ano."]}
{"dialog": ["Bakit kaya madaming napopogian sknya??? Mas mukha pa syang housemate kesa sa mga totoong housemates hahaha ewan ko ba jan. Mas may dating pa ung KimPau visit e kahit ilang minutes lng", "Educated, tall and rich. Kung liligawan ka ni David, choosy ka pa ba? Taas ng standards ah.", "Oo, mggng choosy pdn ako. Haha di naman meaning na educated, tall, and rich sya eh automatic bet na sya kagad.", "Siguro kung ako din si David, magiging choosy din ako sa liligawan lalo na kung isa sa favorite na dish is palaka.", "Hoy ahahahahaha grabe naman ang pag background check kay atihhh hahaha", "Hahaha joke lang yan, serious nya kasi eh"]}
{"dialog": ["Walang kalatoy latoy si David sa totoo lang. Parang \"patay na bata\" ang peg.", "Kaya di ko talaga ma-gets hype sa kanya.", "Binuhat lang naman sya kasi ni Barbie. Barbie has such a colorful personality. Therefore, they matched her with this bland guy para mapasikat si guy.", "To be fair naman, they were not planning to. Unexpected lang ang perception sa tandem nila Barbie during MCAI kaya pinush na ng GMA.", "true. infair kinilig ako dun sa maria clara and ibarra"]}
{"dialog": ["bakit di na lang kasi si Dennis trillo pinasok or jillian ward. o di kaya since nag popromote sila ng encantadia isa sana sa mga sanggre or si imaw sana hahahahaha. nakakainis naman kasi tong si gma!", "Angel guardian sana.", "angel guardian na mukhang guardian angel.\nsana kasama padin sia sa running man 3 and sana soon na.", "nakito ko siya sa mall show nung running man sobrang natural ng ganda. Ang bait pa."]}
{"dialog": ["Meron ba syang dapat ipromote?", "yung movie niya na samahan ng mga makasalanan. siya bida dun pero 2weeks ago pa yung showing. actually lahat ng houseguest sa gma mga top favorites ng sparkle. mavy, gabbi, sanya, kim jisoo, michelle dee at david.", "omg for real? hahahahahhaha buong cast pala ginawang houseguests", "hindi naman. si david at sanya lang ang kasama sa movie."]}
{"dialog": ["True amboring niya. Naiinis ako sakaniya actually, parang ang yabang. Tyaka di naman pogi lol", "Diba friend daw yan nung Dustin? Parang ewan naman nagdagdag pa ng red flag sa bahay", "Parehas sila mukhang tanga hahaha"]}
{"dialog": ["Istg he is so dry i dont get bakit at paano sya naging artista.", "Oks lang daw ba dry,  malaway naman daw sya pagnagsasalita sabi ng nagcomment kanina sa taas.", "omg malaway talaga sya! Yung naiipon sa gilid ng mouth!"]}
{"dialog": ["Alam nyo ba nakita ko yan sa resto nya sa Molito, yung Sobra cafe? Andun yan nakatambay tapos nagpa pict ako grabe mga teh, hindi talaga sya pogi tapos ang suplado pa ng dating. Diko nga pinost ever picture namin kahit sa ig story ksi ang normal nya lang mas gwapo pa bf ko hahahah! Ang haba ng mukha nya pero ang tangkad nya tho.", "Pero nagpapic ka pa din? Curious tuloy ako ano itsura mo sa pic katabi nya. Tsaka bf reveal nga hahahahahhaha", "Oo!!! Hahaha for the clout nga sana. Kaso hahahah di talaga ko naganahan i story kasi tehhh ang suplado talaga ng aura nya. Saka yun nga ang haba ng mukha. Huhu sorry david."]}
{"dialog": ["bakit may pa house guest house guest pa", "First time mo ba manood ng pbb?", "definitely hindi haha what im trying to say is ang orginal na big brother wala nmang mga ganyan na guest hahaga kasi ang concept ng show is for the housemates to be isolated from the outside world. easy as that!"]}
{"dialog": ["Di naman pogi. Pogi ba yan?", "Yes above average looks nya", "Sarcasm ba to? Di sya pogi ha? Real talk"]}
{"dialog": ["Abnoy kasi yung GMA, porket nag-hype yung tandem nila sa Maria Clara At Ibarra, pinush bigla. Sa totoo lang, maganda talaga tambalan nila. Pero du'n lang sa mismong palabas na 'yon kasi maganda rin talaga yung kwento.\n\nPerlmo hanggang du'n lang. Takteng GMA 'to, ginatasan agad at sinunod-sunod yung project, tapos na-realize nila na hindi sila okay sa RomCom Movie at sa Mini-Series kaya muli silang pinagtambal sa isang Historical Drama kasi akala nila na mababalik yung spark since sa ganung genre nag-hype, ayon wala rin.\n\nBasically, one-hit wonder yung tandem nila, common sa mga KDrama Romance. Hindi na pwede ulitin.", "Yung MCAI, you know why it hit? It's because of the enemies-to-lovers trope  something GMA completely missed with Pulang Araw when they paired Barbie and David again. Ayun, hindi pumatok. One hit wonder tuloy naging labas. Mas may kilig pa  si Barbie and Jay Ortega sa Pulang Araw (again, because of that enemies-to-lovers tension lol)\n\nAs a certified bookworm girlie, I know there's a huge market for enemies to lovers, angst, and unrequited love (she fell first, he fell harder) tropes. GMA needs to start producing more stories like that", "Ako kasi sa Netflix ko siya pinanood, pero yung story arc din kasi maganda talaga. Like predicted siya kasi nga Noli at El Fili, pero nakaka-excite kung paano maisasabuhay with a twist of their characters na wala naman sa book."]}
{"dialog": ["will, brent and river are all introverts pero may character naman ang pagiging introvert nila kahit nga si vince na mas hirap mag halubilo pero infairness to him may character naman siya kahit introvert siya. si david kasi parang lagi talaga siya bored.", "Hindi din naman pinapansin sila Will, Brent at River nung mga fans nung simula nung PBB dahil nga introvert sila. Ngayon niyo lang sila napansin kasi tumagal na sila sa bahay at nakita niyo na yung ugali nila.", "sure ka ba? hindi sila tatagal kung hindi sila napapansin. naging nominated na sila tatlo pero nasave pa rin sila. ibig sabihin they offered something for people to be interested in saving them."]}
{"dialog": ["Mukha syang malaway. Lalo na pag nagsasalita.", "HAHAHAHAHAHAH ang specific"]}
{"dialog": ["Ayaw ba nila na si Vice na lang ipasok dyan para talagang mag-trend? Haha\n\nNapaka-low energy kasi ni david, kala mo laging napipilitan sa pinapagawa sa kanya eh. Kailangan niya na mas kalog yung kasama niya para ma-energize din siya kasi.", "Ilang beses na din kasi nag-guest si VG sa BNK, nag-stay pa nga yata ng ilang araw sa past seasons, they want to try something new siguro"]}
{"dialog": ["yung after Donny,sya ang sumunod lol walang na pa Wow at nagtatalon  na housemate", "Sana nilayo layo man lang ng araw noh hahahaha"]}
{"dialog": ["Not trying to be bias sa ABS, pero parang si MMD lang yung houseguest from GMA na may \"dating\". Hahahahah\n\nFrom ABS, we had Ivana, KimPau, BINI Jhocey, and Donny. Lahat may tatak and may appeal both sa masses and housemates. All of them were charismatic and had an instant appeal to the viewers pati na rin mga housemates, lalo na si Esnyr hahaha.\n\nFrom GMA, halos si MMD lang tumatak and Gabbi kahit papaano altho training ground din naman ng latter yun as a host.  We had Mavy, si Sanya, and 'tong si David, and tbh parang wala talagang \"oomph\" factor. 'Di umaapaw charisma nila (except MMD) imo.", "Okay naman nung si Jisoo naging houseguest. Dami ko tawa nung nag guest siya. Pero etong si David parang si Brent e."]}
{"dialog": ["Hanggang ngayon kaya sleep-deprived pa din siya? Diba yun yung sabi niya noon. Kaya siguro may energy gap. Pero seriously, David, please make sure you get some sleep! Kailangan natin yan.", "May sleep apnea pa rin siya. But I think his demeanor is just how he is."]}
{"dialog": ["Wala naman kasi siyang dating lol! Pasaway pa sa lapel ayaw ayusin at yung nametag halos nakavertical na", "Vertical Sulat pg Chinese."]}
{"dialog": ["Namamaga talaga mukha nya lagi. Anyway same lang yan sila ni Dustin. Feel na feel nya na binuhat nya si Dustin from nowhere", "May apnea kasi, laging hirap matulog ay puyat"]}
{"dialog": ["Para siyang Brent 2.0 waley na waley", "Lmfao got u Perlas"]}
{"dialog": ["The energy you show kasi the people reciprocate. Eh ang tamlay naman ng energy niya pagpasok, so the housemates kind of gave back the same lang.", "Hindi rin, yung dalawang bini nga hindi nagsasalita nung pumasok  eh,nag ala statwa pa,si Donny may buhat pang box.,"]}
{"dialog": ["Kanya kanyang taste siguro. Parang mas wala pang dating sakin si Donny lalo na nung sinabi nya na hindi raw naging madali buhay nya compared sa ibang tao. Like hello nepo baby ka kaya. Tapos hindi talaga ko napopogian sa kanya medyo look alike nya si Marina Summers. Nothing against but di ko lang bet masyado twinks.", "Hindi pogi si donny pero hindi rin naman pogi tong david. Maganda lang katawan niya tapos parang wala nang ibang laman yung personality. Kaya mas \"normal\" yung aura niya siguro. Si donny parang dito ko na lang na-appreciate sa bahay. Dati di ko rin magets bat sikat. Pero magkaibang magkaiba yung presence and aura nila pagpasok sa loob"]}
{"dialog": ["Sorry pero for me yung kay MMD walang dating  Pnuorin ko muna yung stay ni David for comparison", "infairness naman kay mmd yung pagpasok niya ang nagbigay ng reason para umamin si klang haha at siya nag comfort kay mika during the red flag task. funny din yung blondie trio nina esnyr, mmd at klang. game na game siya sakyan. though the remaining days of her stay medyo boring sa livestream. itong kay david ang boring ng buong 2days niya simula nung dumating siya nung sunday."]}
{"dialog": ["Napanood ko lang clip sa Youtube, na-miss ko si Angelica Panganiban!!! Walang kupas pa rin ang visuals ni Angge.  \n\nThis is what Im saying before na natutunan ko after n years of stanning k-ent, ang visuals kasi ng celebrities, may media platform na mas angat sila.\n\nmovie screen (Kathryn, Bea, Piolo)  \nTV screen (Coco, Kim, Marian)  \nstage (BINI, SB19)  \nprint ads and photoshoots (Janine)  \nvlogging (Ivana)  \nred carpet (Maymay, Kim, Nadine)  \npersonal (Karylle, Marian)\n\nMinsan, there are platforms that dont give justice to someones beauty. Like si ganito photogenic pero kapag umaacting na, lumalabas flaws ng mukha (Janine). Or mga idols na very charming sa stage kapag nag-peperform pero kapag umaacting na look very ordinary pala (BINI). Or si ganito na very charming on screen pero kapag nagpeperform on stage, walang appeal (Kathryn). Just find the platform that suits you best.", "Kapag hindi maganda visuals mo with any of the above, please study well in school and prepare for your 9-to-5 jobs, joke lang pero totoo.\n\nTho honestly, timing, opportunities and exposure matter too. Example PBB celebrity housemates, Ok naman visuals nila before pero walang pumapansin kasi starlet and hindi sila kilala ng mga tao. After PBB exposure lang nagka-interest mga tao sa kanila.", "Add to that the innate charisma, which I think is the common denominator among the people listed above, except for Janine (no offense, sorry sa fans; Im neither a fan nor a hater. Shes gorgeous, no question about it, but I dont think she has that charisma that appeals to general public). Talent, looks, and opportunities aside, charisma is also equally  important in showbiz because its what makes people gravitate toward a celebrity, both fans and haters.", "Ilang beses ko na nakita si Janine in person, pero super basic niya. Plane jane. Walang charisma. \n\nShes very photogenic though at parang goddess sa mga photoshoots.", "Same thought when I saw her in person last year kasama nya si Echo that time rin. Hindi nga rin siya tiningnan ng mga tao"]}
{"dialog": ["I never find her pretty, the nose isnt giving to me and overall face value. Only Aiah is legit beautiful for me. Most people kasi porket sikat as a group sila matik maganda na lahat. If i rank their face cards, Sheena is on the bottom last.", "Nakakatuwa nga kasi bihira na yung mga ganyang mukha. Lahat ng artista ngayon iisa hulma ng ilong, labi at ngipin. Puro paretoke.\n\n\nSana i-maintain ng Bini yung natural beauty nila at set ng teeth nila. Kasi yun yung dahilan bakit nagstood out ang bawat sa kanila. May kaniya kaniya silang special features.", "Bihira yung mukha pero parang kambal si Sheena at Sarah G\n\n/s", "May resemblance nga sila lalo kapag kumakanta at sumasayaw. May angas like Sarah G."]}
{"dialog": ["What a loser. She bravely acts for her MMK episode and re-live her traumatic past, but instead of commenting about her story, you judge her visual? Posting a bad angle to justify your hate. God forbid a person to have a bad angle. Sana perfect ka at wala kang bad angle", "why you cry??? kayo mga brooms dba pinagmamalaki nyo Visual kuno ng bini lalo na sa sb19 member tas ngayon na may nag post ng unflattering visuals ng bini nyo gagalit kayo at hindi nyo matanggap na hindi sa lahat ng pagkakataon maganda ang bini nyo. What a loser broom"]}
{"dialog": ["Mommy role na si angge.  napaghahalataan ang edad ko", "Same here  nakakapanibago", "Nanay kaya siya ni JT s Pangako sa 'yo which is weird kc mas bagay clang mag-pinsan kesa s mag-ina.", "Kaya nga. Paano yun wala pang 10  years old nanganak na? Tapos si Jodi 13 years older lang kay KB tapos magnanay. Weird ng mga casting. \n\nTapos si Coco's yung role half ng actual age niya.", "Pangako Sa Yo 2015:\nDaniel 20 Kathryn 19\nJodi 33 Angge 29"]}
{"dialog": ["Huy nasa office ako!! Bawal maiyak!!", "omg same hahahahahaha juskolord"]}
{"dialog": ["pwede talaga silang sisters ni saraaahhhhh,", "kung sa Korea may monicker sila like kay Yoo Seung Ho (Little So Jisub) parang ganyan naalala ko kay Sheena na mejo hawig kay Sarah"]}
{"dialog": ["What time na ba mmk sa tv?", "sabado 830pm sa youtube."]}
{"dialog": ["Jusko ano internet mo, ISP Bonanza?\n\nEME!", "Uy, lumalabas edad ah. HAHAHAHAHA\n(And yes, nakarelate ako )", "True mami, HAHAHAHA Free internet from 12am onwards. Happy happy kapag summer break. Unli puyat HAHAHAHA"]}
{"dialog": ["Ito talaga problem ko sa acting niya sobrang western accent yung tagalog pero yung facial expressions and mata-mata acting is kuha na niya", "Mukha namang he's actively working on improving this naman kasi yung earlier shows niya - pinalabas kasi nung GMA ulit - ang tigas talaga ng dila pero ngayon mas matatas na siya sa tagalog. And that's just a couple of years na pagitan sa ngayon. Siguro 1-2 more projects, di na halata hehe", "Yes fast learner si Michael and sobrang laki rin ng improvement niya sa acting. Rooting for him"]}
{"dialog": ["Hes slowly but surely getting there. If you hear him in his old YT videos when he was 17-18 and put it side by side with how he speaks now, its night and day. Guessing that hes currently expanding his Tagalog/Filipino vocabulary and will work on the accent along the way.", "Yung video niya na kumakanta ng Bahay Kubo hahahaha pero his progress in learning the language is impressive sa totoo. He's only been here some years pero he already speaks better than the halfies who've been in the industry for more than a decade na pero baluktot na baluktot pa rin lol\n\nJust a little more, di na mahahalata. Bumibigat na din kasi roles na binibigay ng GMA sa kanya, hindi na teenybopper, so nahahalata pa yung kulang. Advantage din sa kanya na maging magaling sa tagalog para di ma-typecast as rich/fil-am roles lagi hehehe", "Fina-fast track talaga siya ng GMA tbh, I mean he was given the usual GV multi-lead teen romcom as one of the male leads, then a university romcom, tapos biglang heavy with Shining Inheritance tapos MIG is also borderline heavy. Feel ko, malaki pa igagaling at isisikat ni Michael, especially because he has this gift of developing natural-looking chemistry with all his on-screen partners (Jillian, Kate, even Kyline who was his sister, but probably the strongest one, my TOTGA love team, with Zephanie talaga). I actually dislike him going in and a bit before PBB because I root for Zephanie & Zephchael, and people painted him as a user after their tandem was separated, but thank PBB for letting me know him better and deeper."]}
{"dialog": ["ultrasound ba yan bat ang labo", "Ultrasound ampotek HAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA"]}
{"dialog": ["Bagay siya maging host ng Binibining Pilipinas. Pwede rin sumunod kay Dingdong para hindi laging si Dong ang host.", "i agree! ang eloquent nya no. galing mag build ng rapport with the audience!"]}
{"dialog": ["Pwede siyang kontrabida. Mukha rin siyang Thai actor na may lahi.", "May kahawig nga siyang Japanese actor hehe kapag naalala ko name...\n\nDun sa AKNP niya, medyo kontrabida siya kay Ken Chan hehe baka carry naman pero obvious kasi na he's being groomed as GMA's new leading man so baka di siya bigyan ng kontrabida roles pa."]}
{"dialog": ["I read sa pbb subreddit na inirapan daw ni Dustin si Jho. Di ko pa napanood yung clip if meron man pero nakita ko yung clip na tinutukso ni Jhoanna si Bianca about Dustin. Haha sabi yan daw yun.", "I watched it. Inaasar ni Jho at Stacey si Dustin dahil di nya gusto maingay na babae tapos unlike other housemates na ready makipag asaran at kulitan sa kanila, si Dustin inirapan sila.\n\nPero di to kita sa camera, nakatalikod si Dustin. Sinabi lang ni Bini Stacey kay Jho na uy inirapan ka oh tapos sabi ni jho inirapan mo ko??? \n\nSo ayun ayaw nya talaga sa maingay na girls gusto nya tahimik lang. pero ayun bisita naman sila di man lang sya nagpigil haha", "Hindi gusto maingay na babae??? Babae lang?? Omg baka true yung closeted comments ng iba", "kalat nga daw sa X na mahilig sya sa mga gays. may gay na nag expose sa kanya sa X kasi isa raw sya sa mga niloko. alam daw nila Vern Ong mga gawain nyan ni dustpan \n\ntake this w a grain of salt. hindi ko na mahanap orig post lol", "Nabasa ko din yan. Pero infer may nakita naman akong reel sa FB na may sponsor din na gay si River  so I guess kalakaran na to sa showbiz and even private people.", "Parang impossible ito. He comes from a rich family. As in rich. Recently ko lang nalaman nung nag-share ng post yung tita ko na pamangkin nila si River sa side ng husband niya."]}
{"dialog": ["Madadamay sya sa bashing if i-fofollow nya yung dalawa since controversial sila pareho. Yung pang-hangout nga ng group nila sa BGYO na friends nila, na-bash sila. Dyan pa kaya.", "She is still following BGYO, though. So i dont think takot sya sa bashing. She wont even call out dustin na inirapan si Jho kung iniisip nya yan", "Ay inirapan pala ni D si Jho? Seriously? Lakas ng loob ah.", "Whats inirapan?", "Roll eyes"]}
{"dialog": ["Why are y'all bashing OP? The post was actually good, r/chikaph worthy. Imagine, Stacey followed every housemate except those two? That speaks volume. The shade is silent but screaming!!!!", "Baka di lang nila gets kaya downvote agad. Its not just about whos followed who, may context. pero thank you!! :)", "+ new yan dito sa sub. Hahaha"]}
{"dialog": ["First of all, stop the slander na parang wala bang magawang maganda sa time / jobless yun mga nasa comment section where in fact pare-parehas tayong nasa subreddit na to  I dont get it  whats not clicking!?", "Like as if hindi tayo nandito para sa chismis, and being the chismax that we are, di ba dapat nalang sila magpasalamat at meron tayong issue, kahit petty pa yan, na pwedeng mapagusapan dito. Ano ba dapat nilang iexpect sa subreddit na pangalan ay \"ChikaPH\" HAHAHAHAHA", "Comment tayo next time ng wrong sub, downvoted sa gaong comments ng matigil na haha"]}
{"dialog": ["Yung mga nagcocomment ng jobless behavior na kala mo nakaangat angat sa buhay. Pero may time dito para tumambay at magcomment", "Mamsh its Sunday hahaha chill ka lang", "Hahahaaha bukas pa balik work. Sorry na po"]}
{"dialog": ["Deserve namang hindi i-follow. Tangina mo Dustin, you're dimming Bianca's shine.", "Dito talaga ako na-sad, sayang yung pag click ni bianca sa mga tao pagpasok nya"]}
{"dialog": ["Medjo off ung datingin ni Dustin kasi para bang pumasok lng ng PBB para lumande...  hahahahahaahh", "Para maghanap ng loveteam"]}
{"dialog": ["Wait am confused, nakalabas na ba ang 2 bini guests seeing as they can access their socmeds na or mga manager nila tong naghahandle ng account and nasa loob pa sila? (Not actively watching PBB but chismosa enough that I read chismis about them)", "Yes, nakalabas na kahapon."]}
{"dialog": ["Bakit wala si Esnyr", "baka di na sinama sa ss dahil naka-follow na siya before pa"]}
{"dialog": ["May time talaga para tingnan kung sino Yung finallow", "Yes, I have the luxury of time! ;)"]}
{"dialog": ["can yall not make this a big deal?? i also do not like dustin pero if you all corner her like this, she would probably be forced to follow them jna lang din para walang issue. jusko naman", "Beh wrong sub ka ata"]}
{"dialog": ["Kita ko bago pumasok c vince my mga classmates n nagpost abt him ala daw ambag si Vince s thesis. Lol", "Same same pala kay Mikee Q"]}
{"dialog": ["Agree with most here, people probably dont know her. Tbh, ordinary looking lang sya and doesnt stand out sa crowd.", "This!!! Sorry not to offend the fans pero nothing looks standout sa kanya. Mas marami pa ako nakita na normal / not in showbiz pero mapapatitig at 2nd look ka.", "Nakita mo n sya sa personal?", "No. No need to see her in person. The video speaks on itself   it's my remarks, i could be wrong or right. Compare it with Marian Rivera on cam and off cam vs. Aiah. Who do you think between the two yung mas mapapalingon ka?\n\nThat's what I am saying", "That's the sa beauty is preference. I'm not into mestiza beauties eh. Para sa akin lng ha typical pretty half pilipino si Marian.", "Okay you do you.  Discussing over preference is pointless."]}
{"dialog": ["Probably they didnt notice her kasi nagblend sya sa crowd. Or maybe they did see her but they respected her me-time as you said; pero ikaw, hindi mo naman nirespeto oras nya at pinost mo pa", "Or baka most of the people on that place di siya kilala. Haha", "Yeah , kht ako d ko siya ma recognize .", "To be frank, mas maganda pa sa kanya yong teen sa likod", "Yeah, mukhang Barretto yung face ni Ate."]}
{"dialog": ["Sa Sugbo Mercado kasi usually ang tinitignan lang if ano kakainin at kung saan sila kakain. Baka di sya nagregister sa mga tao dahil busy. Hindi pa sya dolled up.", "I agree. Main concern mo when going there is first, what to eat. Second, where to sit. Unless nasa harap mo na talaga, you wouldnt recognize people.", "Hirap magdesisyon kasi ng kakainin jan sa dami ng masarap.", "Madami masasarap pero meron din mga disappointments. Pero what I love about that place is discovering startups na pagkainan like yung Banana Pancake Trail."]}
{"dialog": ["Sorry ha, kung hindi ka super fan ng bini, di mo sila makikilala pag di sila mag kakasama na dumadating. Just like in this case, sa tingin ko di sya masyado kilala at mukang ordinary lang kaya di pinag kakaguluhan", "Most Bini members have non-intimidating faces and charm. I'd bet people would act much more differently if it's Georgina Wilson roaming around.", "There are a lot of ladies in Cebu who resemble Aiah and Georgina Wilson, especially sa IT Park-Banilad area -- madami half-pinoys here.  We recognize artistas, but usually Cebuanos just let you be -- unless mall show/concert yan, we fan girl din naman po. \n\nBut, if BINI fan ka talaga, you know Aiah has already asked before to respect their space and time away from the limelight. So, I'm sure a lot of people recognized her there, but a lot of people also love her enough to leave her alone to enjoy her time.", "Agree. Cebuanos are chill lang when it comes to artista sightings. We're generally not the type who hound celebs, ask for selfies, and stuff like that. May kdrama actors nga napadpad dito, parang wala lang. Lol."]}
{"dialog": ["People werent even glancing in her direction in that video so I suspect they didnt realize who she is.", "Tbh true. Like I know kung sino yung Bini but if i see one in public na walang ayos and acting casually I probably won't recognize them at all.", "Same, alam ko na nag eexist ang BINI and catchy ang songs nila, pero di ko kilala mga faces nila. Clueless lang ako haha"]}
{"dialog": ["Dapat sinaway niyo rin yung nag-video kay Sunshine at Atong Ang. Tong mga tao rito lol", "Huy omg totoo hahaha yung comments kay sunshine at atong g na g pa mga tao eh hahaahahahahaha sana raw vinideo", "Double standards. Pareho namang need nga privacy kahit gaano ka-sikat/lapitin ng tsismis so bakit game sila dun, pero kay Aiah hayaan daw dapat to enjoy her free time. Ay ambot"]}
{"dialog": ["Tapos ikaw taking a video without consent, tapos ipopost for clout. Ikaw yung walang respect. Typical bloom.\n\nThe people around in the area do not even recognize or know who she is. Baka they're leaving her alone, kasi \"Bini who?!\" yung crowd dyan. At hindi siya maganda para pansinin o lingunin ng kahit sino. Kitang kita sa video mo na very ordinary looking yang bini mo. Also, in Cebu? Ang daming napakagagandang Cebuana na ordinary citizens, at natural ang may magandang boses dyan.\n\nThe people there don't care or even bother to know who they are. Hindi lahat sa idols nyo umiikot ang mundo.", "Baka PR ito video na ito hahaha. Ngl parang walang star power parang mukhang ordinary lang", "Honestly though lol"]}
{"dialog": ["Or maybe they don't know her? Kasi people don't pay attention to her din.\n\nI know BINI pero hindi ko talaga sila kilala individually. I listen to them pero I don't watch them. \n\nPero before the fans bash me, hindi lang naman BINI, kahit BlackPink and SB19. Kahit nga sina Sabrina Carpenter, Gracie Abrams & Chappell Roan, di ko kilala mukha until recently kahit sila and constant playlist ko for more than a year na. Kasi I rarely watch them, madalas spotify lang ako. Being in group makes it extra hard to remember each individual.", "Oo madami sila sa group. Di ako matandain sa muka. Hindi din ako gano fan. But not saying na di sila magaling ah.  Di lang ako mahilig talaga sa gnyan.  Skl."]}
{"dialog": ["Kanang mga taga Cebu di mana sila hangol og celebrity. Sa kadanghang mas gwapa and gwapo nga taga Cebu compared to celebs. Naanad na na sila", "Tinuod!"]}
{"dialog": ["Cebuanos in general are nonchalant when celebrities are seen in public space having their me time. Dumudumog lang talaga pag official event or may activity involving the celeb.", "Yeah sila Baron naglalakad lng during sinulog. My friend saw Slater and his family at Rustans, kebs lng din daw yung other people. I guess people from Cebu aren't that confrontational or at least in the areas I frequent."]}
{"dialog": ["Is this real time????? Saka lowkey na nga siya, nagvideo ka pa tapos pinost pa. Mamaya madumog siya dahil dito?????", "I saw this same video yesterday sa TikTok so I don't think it's real time"]}
{"dialog": ["cebuanos generally dont care too much about celebrities when theyre out and about. theyll usually just take photos from afar or text their friends about it", "This is true."]}
{"dialog": ["So bakit ka nagvideo?", "Wala kasi siyang pang-karma mining at post dito unless may pic/video. hahaha."]}
{"dialog": ["bakit sa ibang stolen shot walang issue mga tao pero dito may consent pa nalalaman hahahaha. double standard yarn", "o-OA eh"]}
{"dialog": ["Or people don't care and is nonchalant nalang.", "If you look at all the people in that video, they aren't even looking at her. Siguro some may look and recognize her, but just don't care."]}
{"dialog": ["I dont think it is respecting her space. I think people just dont know her by herself so di sya kilala on her own.", "True lmao people might know the group BINI or its songs pero not necessarily each member even tho si Aiah ata pinakasikat sa grupo along with Maloi and Mika?"]}
{"dialog": ["relax everyone, hindi po ito realtime. i took this video yesterday", "Realtime or not, you still didnt respect her space and privacy, unlike of those other people that were included in your video ( and without their consent either)"]}
{"dialog": ["Yung mga nagsabing OA at staged si Esnyr dito, halatang never pa na-excite sa buhay hahahaha", "Naalala ko dati 1st time kong manonood ng concert (ELF ako, fan ng Super Junior) I was so sure of myself na kalmado lang ako during the concert, yung tipong sasabay ka lang sa kanta, ganun. Tapos nung nagstart na grabe rin yung energy ng crowd mahahawa ka talaga, ako yung maya't-maya \"uyy tingnan mo si ganito oh!\" Sabay hampas sa kasama ko", "Pandemic ELF ako. First time ko manood nung SS9. Pag intro nila, sabay tulo luha ko eh", "Anooonggg section ka???? Bwahahahaha ako din nakakaiyak ang lapet ko ke kyu.", "Upper box hahaha pero pag nag SS10, dun na ko sa mas malapit. Lol."]}
{"dialog": ["\"Jose Rizal na meet ang BINI\"", "Bini meets mabini nga raw eh", "HUHUHUH KAINIS"]}
{"dialog": ["HAHAHAHAHAHHAAHHA SAKTONG SAKTO SA TASK NILA  BAKA PAG WALA YUNG TASK SABOG EARDRUM MGA YAN", "Maybe yun talaga purpose nung task nila kasi alam ni kuya na sasabog ang bnk sa mga sigawan nila hahahaha", "True, ESNYR PALANG BAKA RINIG SIGAW NIYA SA LABAS"]}
{"dialog": ["Esnyrs reaction is valid HAHAHA naalala ko nanuod sila ni Bianca ng Grand Biniverse, tapos na-full storage sya HAHAHAHAHA", "Sya yung nalowbat yung phone habang concert diba? Or nawalan ng memory so binura nya lahat ng selfie nya? Hahaha", "nawalan ng memory HAHAHAHAAH"]}
{"dialog": ["What more kung si aiah yung andyan", "Shes his bias?", "Yeah, siya nga ang Bini Aiah ng Davao del sur"]}
{"dialog": ["Gusto ko yung naging palaka silang tatlo HAHAHAHAHAHA", "Diba! Nagsabaysabay talaga mga galaw nila kala mo nagrehearsal hahahahahaha"]}
{"dialog": ["gusto ko yung bigla silang sumayaw ang random", "Tapos hinawakan ni Esnyr ulo nila both tapos nag sign of the cross HAHAHAHA si accla jusko"]}
{"dialog": ["Our Filo ancestors after discovering fire.", "hahahahahahahahaha I can imagine"]}
{"dialog": ["Its giving ung mga sabrina carpenter sa valorant lol", "hindi po ba fortnite"]}
{"dialog": ["So may bayad ba ang livestream niyan? Chz.", "HAHAHAHAHA huy", "1,500/stream eme HAHAHAHA."]}
{"dialog": ["Madadagdagan na naman ang magagandang crushes ni Dustin.", "Bakit sobrang na-trigger si u/Apart_Cup_5206 sa comment na 'to, eh kahit saang post na may new female housemates o house guests na papasok, nababasa ko 'to. Spreading hate na agad 'yon? Babaw naman.", "Ewan ko din kay atecco. Its a running joke among viewers. Not to be taken seriously. As if naman I posted something libelous."]}
{"dialog": ["Staycation sa BNK", "Sana talaga maka stay sila till Holy Week is over. Ganda makita dynamic nila na hiwalay sa other girls."]}
{"dialog": ["TAWANG-TAWA KO NG KAY ESNYR NA. GRABE HALOS MAIHI AKO KAKATAWA", "Ako tumawa ng walang sound. Akala mo maririnig ni kuya hahaha kasama sa task yan???"]}
{"dialog": ["lahat kaya ng bini papasok? I can't wait to see my colet ahahahaha", "I dont think so pero if ever yes then maybe except gwen and sheena"]}
{"dialog": ["Any insight po sa mga personalities nilang dalawa? TIA", "Normal na sa kanila ang pisikalan kapag nag-aasaran. Parehas silang only child so that might explain their dynamics."]}
{"dialog": ["Uy pano manood nito from overseas?", "sa iwanttfc po"]}
{"dialog": ["Brace yourselves, tig dadalawa papasok weekly. lol", "Naku mukhang matutuwa si Dustin nyan"]}
{"dialog": ["Anyway, ang chararat nung Justin Soberano. Pati rin naman yung Yana, maputi lang. \n\nBagay nga sila at sana magsama na sila habangbuhay para di na makaperwisyo sa iba.", "Puro porma. wala namang work anak pa ng anak", "Omg so hindi lang isa yung anak niya?!", "2 with Chloie and afaik it was Liza nagsusupport sa kids not Justin. When he left Chloie and the kids, ang cringe ng posts ng lalakeng yan, buhay binata or maybe it was Yana who posts parang laging may pinapatunayan declaring love for her. Sana di na pakawalan ni Yana yan, para wala ng maperwisyong ibang buhay.", "Omg dalawa pala anak nila akala ko isa lang! Sana nga sila na magkatuluyan, parehas silang perwisyo sa mga tao pero nakakaawa lang talaga yung Chloie at 2 kids"]}
{"dialog": ["Di ko kilala yung Yana pero buti nga sa kanya di siya kasali sa BINI at di sumikat. Iritsng irita ako hahahaha pimapatakedown family picture ampota \n\nNakakaawa yung nanay at yung bata!!!!", "Yung beauty kasi nung yana hindi pasok sa standard muka syang matured nasa 30s ba yung face nya pero bata pa sya. Pero buti talaga wala sya Bini. At sana ma karma na agad sila", "Ilang taon na ba siya? True sa mukhang nasa 30s.", "Idk pero siguro ka age sya kila Aiah. Pero hindi talaga sya maganda may bangs pa sya dati kala nga cute sya doon."]}
{"dialog": ["Natawa ako dun sa wag daw mag pic magkasama yung parents at children hahahaha tanga ba siya", "her current ig story is that she should have been btcher lol", "She shouldve been smarter but clearly, that was too much for her"]}
{"dialog": ["Salamat sa anghel na bumulong kay Direk Loren na ipasok si Aiah at tanggalin tong si Yana and Angela. Sa docu kasi sobrang off nung dalawang yan, parang di nababagay sa personality ng BINI.", "Infer naman with Angela, friends friends pa rin sila until now. They're still hanging out from time to time. Etong si Yana, cinutoff na yata talaga nila kasi unfollowed na nila si gurl (well except aiah and colet)", "Angela gives off a Regina George mean girls vibe. Parang magagalit pag di sya lagi nasa gitna ng formation haha"]}
{"dialog": ["Pucha akala ko si dennis na naman", "Dumadami na silaaaaa hahaha"]}
{"dialog": ["I guess kaya di rin siya naka pasok ng bini because sinasala talaga nila from talent ng girls hanggang sa attitude and character. And i guess its a no talaga for this girliepop", "Long term ang plano nila sa BINI. Tanggal ka pag tingin nila hindi ka nakakabuti sa group dynamics. Importante sakanila na magkasundo ang members. Successful naman sila sa pagpili sa final lineup kasi mukang magkakaibigan talaga ang bini"]}
{"dialog": ["kapal naman ng Justin na to na dalawa na yung anak tapos nakadepende pa rin kay Liza. magtrabaho ka huy", "Aga nakabuntis ng loko tapos si Liza tumulong sa kanya. Nagawa pa talagang mag jowa ng bago di muna pinanindigan pagiging tatay yikes."]}
{"dialog": ["Huh? Kahit hiwalay na sila they are still a family. Parang may tulilig talaga itong mga soberano kung pinrio nya jowa nya over his kids", "If im not mistaken, Justin left his kids for Yana. Kabit na matapang"]}
{"dialog": ["Unang tanong? The who mga yan", "Justin -problematic na kapatid ni Liza . Yana -former trainee na road to BINI member na problematic. Chloe - Nanay ng mga anak ni Justin, private citizen"]}
{"dialog": ["Additional context sana OP hehe", "Nasa photos and caption na lol"]}
{"dialog": ["Lagi ako naiiyak sa story niya. Tapos the fact na siya yung choreographer ng pantropiko chorus part na naging catalyst sa pag sikat ng todo ng BINI was like a full circle.", "Pwede malaman short version? Not a fan eh, but Im curious kasi gagawan ng MMK", "She was raised by a single mom along with her grandparents. Supportive yung mom niya eversince lalo sa pagsasayaw niya. Hindi talaga siya nag audition sa PBB kundi yung kasamahan niya sa dance group tapos pinapunta lang yung grupo nila then hangang siya yung nakuha para maging housemate. After niya ma evict pinasok siya sa starhunt para maging trainee. During that time, 1 year naka coma yung mom niya tapos kalagitnaan ng training namatay mom niya. Since she was a minor, that time tapos maraming restrictions, hindi niya na naabutan yung lamay ng mom niya. Then bumalik siya sa training then doon nag umpisa yung closeness nila ng mga BINI members since she's also the youngest among of them. Namatay din yung lolo niya so ang natira nalamag sakanya lola niya and kuya niya. But despite all of that, she's one of the funniest BINI members. Siya yung pinaka malakas tumawa and happy pill at weakness ng lahat. When she was first assigned to do a choreography for the chorus of pantropiko...", "yung tatay niya, wala na silang koneksyon"]}
{"dialog": ["Tapos what if yung gaganap si Sarah G.", "Si sheena yung gaganap na teenage version niya tapos pag naging Bini si Sarah G."]}
{"dialog": ["Sya yung may tragic life story sa kanila. Single mom ata nagpalaki, tapos namatay mom nya habang nagtetraining and di na nya naabutan pati libing kasi pandemic pa nun, and Lola na lang ata natitirang kamag anak.", "May kapatid pa siya. Pero yeah, si amma na lang ata guiding figure niya. Last birthday niya with her mom ay nasa pbb pa siya then pandemic and starhunt came."]}
{"dialog": ["Alam ko si Eri Neeman (if im not mistaken) may clause siya sa contract niya na in the event na bigla siya mag cancel, siya maghahanap ng replacement who is AT PAR with his skills. Hindi yung kung sino sinong host lang ang ipapalit niya.\n\nWhether legally may habol si bride or not hindi na rin yan maghahabol mas stressful pa yun and time consuming. The point is maliit lang ang wedding industry. The MUA should have been professional enough sa paghandle ng concern kasi siya lang din masisira.", "curious lang dun sa clause ni Eri. If ever nga may kapalit, magrerefund din ba siya? Kasi alam naman natin jbang level ang rate ni Eri. Not hating on the price. Legit curious lang na kung ganito nangyare.", "I have a friend, di nakapunta si eri neeman. Si Sam yg pinadala ni eri which is mas mahal ang tf kay eri.", "Ohhhh good to know! Di ko din naisip kasi ung iba na kalevel ng tf niya kasi usually booked din ung mga mabenta sa weddings. Salamat sa rep!!"]}
{"dialog": ["yung ibang comment dito parang jinu-justify niyo pa pagiging unprofessional ng MUA, unang una kung hindi kayang mag commit sa mga bridal makeup clients wag na lang tumanggap. kahit pa sabihin na 2 months eh sobrang ikli para sa pagbobook na kesyo marami pa namang iba dyan, eh sa siya yung gusto ng bride to be, nagtanong naman si client at nagbigay ng assurance si MUA so yun yung pinanghawakan ni bride to be.", "Diba? Kahit walang signed contract, meron silang verbal agreement. Sinong professional ang magc-cancel nang 2 months before a wedding? Ang hirap kaya humanap ng back up hmua sa wedding.", "ang dali-dali kasi sabihin na humanap na lang eh, kaya naman siguro makahanap pero sana hindi 2 months before the wedding kasi ibang stress ang dulot nun sa bride. mahirap humanap ng MUA na kayang gumawa ng look na gusto nung bride kaya tigilan nila kaka-side sa MUA na yan kasi unprofessional talaga siya.", "Either hindi pa kinasal o puchu puchu lang yung kasal nila kaya di sila makarelate"]}
{"dialog": ["2 months is very short. At parang June bride pa, so very peak season siya. The least she can do is to help the bride find her a replacement. Kaso literal na iniwan siya sa ere nitong HMUA.", "May nirecommend nmn daw s knya kaso nung tiningnan ni bride to be ung profile nung recommended HMUA puro mga di daw kayang iachive ung gusto nyang look s wedding day nya", "She should have found a replacement na ka-level niya in terms of style. Pero instead, she just gave a recommendation and left it at that. Still unacceptable, lalo na considering how important the event is.", "Ganun n nga she just provided list of possible HMUA just so she can justify n tinulungan Niya ung b2b nag ask p nga ung b2b if pwdeng 50-50 sila s cost ng new HMUA since sya nag cancel hindi si b2b kaso Deadma n si ante"]}
{"dialog": ["ang bobo naman ng hmua.\n\n1. the bride double checked her availability and she confirmed na di problema ang tour ng bini girls.\n\n2. 2 months sounds long pero if you account the whole wedding planning, sobrang stressful neto. she should've given the bride 50% ng downpayment kase sakanya naman ang error.", "Hindi po mahaba ang 2 months. Yung mga in demand na hmua, maaga po mapuno yung sched nila kahit weekday yung wedding. Sobrang unfair sa client na wala man lang siyang compensation na nakuha.", "Agree. Tried to book my then-dream HMUA 22 MONTHS before our wedding. Took her 3 weeks to reply with follow-ups, only to find out na booked na siya. In-demand is an understatement."]}
{"dialog": ["Sana makita ng management to kasi pangit din to for bini. Kaloka yung unprofessionalism talaga :(( Wishing you the best and na makahanap ka OP!", "Stalked her ig idol na idol ni Theresa si Moira. No wonder bat ganyan ugali. Bini na nga lang malaki niyang gig ganyan pa siya sa iba. Hope Bini drops her.", "siya nag makeup kay AC Bonifacio last ABS-CBN Ball hahahaha"]}
{"dialog": ["Called her out on IG. Got blocked  Not even a bride or use HMUA services but detest unprofessionalism because of a bigger client.", "Bikis niya magblock ah. Hahahahaha hopes kumalat sa wedding industry yang ugali niya. Kawawa ibang future brides if siya ang makkadeal. Hoping na makalat ting incident na to for awareness, and sayo theresa sana makahanap ka ng katapat mo na kayang kasuhan ka"]}
{"dialog": ["As a b2b, this is so stressful!! In a span of 2 months, smooth na dapat lahat yan kasi confident ka ng everything will go smoothly cause you prepared way, way ahead of time. \n\nI can imagine the wasted time on research, the stress, the regrets. Napaka unprofessional!!", "the stress we had with the suppliers. we planned a year ahead, mga suppliers namin within 1.5months ng event time nag confirm, initial meeting and ung iba kakastart lang mag draft ng contract. the anxiety it gave us."]}
{"dialog": ["Malaki siguro package ni BINI para sa kanya ahahaha and also makakalis siya bansa. Alam ko nakapag USA na siya tapos si Moira client niya\n\nSo syempre ayun prio niya pero ang unprofessional niya. \n\nSana di niya nalang kinuha if hindi kaya.", "Aside sa malaking package, makaka kuha din sya ng ibang clients kasi tinatag sila sa mga photos. Viral din mga pics ng BINI at napapansin talaga ang make up nila.\n\nMas madaming artista, mas mahal na rate."]}
{"dialog": ["Nasa facebook na ba 'to? Para makarating sa iba.", "I think wala pa. Kasi sabi ni original OP ipopost na lamg niya after ng kasal niy. Kasi atm wala padin siya nahahanap na hmua  apakagag0 talaga ni theresa"]}
{"dialog": ["Unprofessional? Yes. Common Occurrence? Yes. \n\nSometimes opportunities just come and you grab it. I don't necessarily agree with the means but hey I respect the hustle. Although from what I see they reassured the client that there will be no problems so they should render the service. \n\nThere's no formal written contract but it constitutes as an oral one. Take note, \"meeting of the minds between 2 persons\" constitutes as a contract. Possible na kasuhan ng breach of contract yan.", "Hustle for the HMUA but hassle for the bride."]}
{"dialog": ["Is there even a contract that states the supplier will pay the bride / groom in the event of cancellation?", "Theres none but brides who intend to hire this particular MUA or any other MUA should learn a lesson from this and put a steep penalty in their contracts in the event of cancellation. Nakakaloka yung 2 months na lang before the wedding paghahanapin pa yung bride ng MUA."]}
{"dialog": ["Based sa original post mukhang walang signed contract both parties", "Doesnt matter. Well-settled na by the Supreme Court na verbal contracts are honored in the Philippines. Daming proof ni bride na meron ngang agreement. Enough na yun."]}
{"dialog": ["For me hindi naman sobrang unprofessional yung HMUA.\n\nNag-inform yung HMUA na more than a month, nagrefer pa kaya mali naman sabihin na NONE, para tulungan sia maghanap. \n\nMejo feeling entitled lang si bride para masabi na yung wedding make up artist nia ay BINI make up artist din.\n\nAng daming make up artist sa Pilipinas, bakit magpopost ng ganyan. \n\nBawal ang force labor kaya wag na ipilit. Wala din naman damages kasi there's enough time for her to find a replacement.", "hindi mo pa siguro nararanasan mag wedding planning at ikasal. anong mindset yan?? its either diehard fan to ng bini or the MUA itself. shame on you!"]}
{"dialog": ["Akala ko si belle mariano. Haha ganda nilang dalawa!", "na downvote ako nung nakaraan nung sinabi ko magkamukha sina Aiah at Belle", "Baka kulto ng Bini yung mga nagdownvote sayo.", "Bat naman idodownvote ng fan eh compliment nga yun. Obviously, haters ng bini ang nagdownvote. Ang dami nun dito sa sub.", "May sinabi ba akong fan? Ang sabi ko kulto... If genuinely fan ka alam mo ang tama at mali for your idol, yung kulto mga obsessed followers yun na sinasamba yung idol nila.."]}
{"dialog": ["Francis Libiran kay Belle. Michael Cinco naman sa BINI. Kanino yung kay Kath?", "Mark Alcala famous dress maker from Lucena", "Kakakita ko lang na si Anthony Ramirez sa kanya. Bigatin dn naman yung designer nya pero parang nakakapagtaka na di pa ata sya ginagawan ng gown nina FL at MC.", "Baka di kinotack ng stylist nya"]}
{"dialog": ["Mas maputi na si FL kesa kay Mekalem? wtf\n\nAnyway ganda ni Jhoanna", "Sino si FL? Pero agree. Jhoanna standout dito hahaha underrated din naman talaga sya sa bini kahit sya ang leader.", "Hindi ako fan ng Bini pero bet na bet ko talaga sa Jhoanna. Parang ang gaan gaan kasi ng aura nya.", "True. Sobrang underrated ni Jhoanna. #1 sa balota"]}
{"dialog": ["Jhoanna  \n\nPinakacomplete pckage sa bini. Hahaha", "true. ung isa mukhang alien. sorry", "Sino jan? Hewhew", "dyed short hair"]}
{"dialog": ["Girl's girl. IYKYK.", "Her latest role", "May camera footage pa! Just like that Alden one from a year go. Baka the next movie will be about women friendships"]}
{"dialog": ["Tanong ko lang, ano ba namgyayari sa loob ng abscbn ball? sa school lng ata ako nakattend ng ganyan. E wala naman sigurong principal na magsspeech ng 1 hr dyan. Or teacher na maingay at papapilahin kayo sa loob. May raffle ba? Kumakain ba sila sa loob or nagdinner na sila sa bahay nila? Hahaha", "Usually dinner, special guest singer/performance, and then dancing", "May mga awarding din sila like sa mga prom (couple of the night, best gown, best suit etc.) \n\nPero the main purpose ng abs-cbn ball ay for charity ata.", "Paano rin for charity? May bayad ba entrance dyan? Isa pa yun sa di ko magets hehehe", "Kikita sa bayad per plate, or pwede ka rin kumuha ng table under corporate ganun para sa kumpanya nyo, bale may patong yung actual costs ng food and event place etc. so parang mas mahal yung table malapit sa stage or something depende sa view. Then pwede rin may added donations like fund raising matching, or paramihan ng bid for table position aside from the default table/plate pricing with charity add-on. Stuff like gowns, jewelry, MUA can also be sponsored/loaned out as exposure, kaya may red carpet and pre-event shoot to display these. Basically lalabhan(?) yung pera to send people to the ball for charity, expenses are written off to the foundation, at kapag \"foundation\" kasi may tax exemption sya or something. I think may financial statement din dapat sa kinita ng foundation na ipapakita during the event kasi one of the things they do is celebrate ilan na mga natulungan ganon, magkano na na-raise eme tas encourage na tuloy-tuloy lang support, yun din yung laman ng speeche..."]}
{"dialog": ["Favorite nung stylist si Gwen? Kanyang outfit pinaka bumagay sa face and aura nya.", "Maging lang talaga siya magdala nang damit. Kahit last time ganon din. Di naman sa kanya pinakamagandang gown tbh"]}
{"dialog": ["Hindi talaga maganda si Maloi. Ang asim tignan. Ganda ni Colet, Aiah, Mikha, and Si GWEN talaga pinakamagaling magdala nang damit.", "#Sobrang expensive and pang-high fashion ng itsura ni gwen!!"]}
{"dialog": ["Pangit ng make up or camera. Ang putla tignan. Hindi compliment lipstick.", "Oo nga, bakit ang putla nila tignan. Pati hair nila hindi din bagay. Sayang naman."]}
{"dialog": ["\"Colet baket ka nagjowa!\"\n-Jhobert, 29, Unemployed", "More like:\n\nHindi pwede!! Colet at Maloi dapat - Jhemerlyn 21 F", "It's all the extra Hs", "jHoanna"]}
{"dialog": ["Mga fans ng bini mga baliw eh queer baiter daw yang Colet, aba putangina niyo kahit bading yang babaeng yan hindi kayo papatulan. Karamihan pa sainyo maasim o may anghit", "funny thing as well is the girls have been openly saying na wala talagang magjowa sa bini ever since, nakikiride lang sila sa ships bc its fun raw at fan service na rin sineseryoso naman ng ibang fans. trivia lang mikhaiah used to be a much bigger ship in the fandom pero naging oa to the point na nabibigyan kaagad ng malisya tuwing mag iinteract sila; so for a period of time naging distant sila sa isat isa, tho okay na sila now", "Eh trabaho naman kasi nila yon hahaha di naman kasi lahat ng lalabas sa bunganga nila eh paniniwalaan na. Jusko sinong maniniwala sa mga itsura niyan wala na naging jowa o hindi nagkaroon ng jowa. K-pop ganyan din eh", "dibaa?? Ang hirap naman paniwalaan na never nagkarelationship or even nagkaroon ng manliligaw mga yan. mas open nga actually yung girls about their dating life before kwinekwento nila yung mga naging past relationships nila ngayon hindi na nung lumake yung fandom. akala kasi ata ng mga to pagaari nila mga idols nila"]}
{"dialog": ["Wait, kala ko bawal si magkajowa?", "Philippines is loveteam-focused and wala naman sinabi ang star magic na may relationship ban sila. Also, Bini are not rookies anymore.", "No, during their guesting kasi sa AWKP sinabi mismo ng Bini na \"bawal po mag bf/gf pag PPOP\". Grabe sa downvote", "that was years ago na e plus baka sinasabi lang yun for the fans. If totoo man na love ban they recently signed a new contract that probably lifted the ban. hindi rin talaga mapipigilan yang mga yan. Jho also revealed recently na may mga nanliligaw sakanya"]}
{"dialog": ["theyre both grown. i hope all goes well for them!", "Aged like milk", "her having a bf is not the issue. her being stupid and dating someone stupid is the issue"]}
{"dialog": ["Dapat talaga normalized ang pagkakaroon ng jowa mg mga celebrity. Tigilan na yang mga loveteam na yan. Tsaka no to dating ban as long as di napapabayaan ang work. And shawarawt sa mga toxic fans jan, di niyo pag-aari ang mga idol niyo okay? Let them live and breathe. Kaloka kayo. \n\nP.S. not you OP ha, baka akalain mo ikaw HAHAHA", "I was just thinking of the same thing kanina lang while naghuhugas ng plato (nakita ko kase yung post dun sa Mika bago humarap sa lababo hahaha). Id be happy to know mga real life ganap ng mga to like a normal person na naiinlove etc., but they still do their job excellently kase alam nila na people ideally love their talent first more than anything else. \n\nBut it may be my age talking na I am over this toxic fandom shenanigans. Eme.", "Right? Like, if they genuinely like their idols, they would be happy kung happy ang idol nila, diba? \n\nBaka age yan mhie.  nung bagets pa ako medyo involved din ako sa mga fandom eme na yan. But as I grew older, I realized napaka-toxic at napaka-OA ng mga ganyan, lalo na yung mga fandom wars noon."]}
{"dialog": ["Taray sumasabay ang BINI sa issue ng KPop at ni Kim Soo Hyun ngayon. Leak kung leak.", "If totoo mang jowa nga yung guy,issue ba yan?\nSi Kim shyun target menor de edad-yan totoong issue. Para ka namang chismosang kapitbahay na porket may jowa na ang kapitbalur na taga kabilang kanto pa, ginagawa pang issue. misogynistic naman this person na ginagawan ng issue ang babaeng makakalove life", "Alam mo ba ang ibig sabihin ng sarcasm te????"]}
{"dialog": ["seaman daw si guy", "Seaman"]}
{"dialog": ["May nagpost nito sa FB. Nagalit ang mga blooms. Photoshopped daw yung pics.  Dapat daw yung mga Bini members ang makatuluyan ng bawat isa  Ganun talaga sila mag-isip?", "Kakadiri mga mag-isip. May kanya kanyang personal na buhay yang mga yan. Desisyon nila kung sino gusto nila at kanino sila masaya. Di porket fan sila, sila na palagi masusunod."]}
{"dialog": ["Magkamukha sila!", "Was about to say this."]}
{"dialog": ["Rumor pa ba yan? May pics, may pa happy monthsary at I love you pa.", "well, walang confirmation and anything, bigla nalang kumalat sa tiktok yang pictures nila, but I do get your point!"]}
{"dialog": ["Ganto sana Maloi at zild di ba, jusko kayo! Charot!", "Pass kay Zild groomer at malibog"]}
{"dialog": ["si chawot ba yan. charot", "Hahaha mas kamukha nung kapatid na babae"]}
{"dialog": ["Sobrang off talaga ako sa mga blooms (bini fandom). Afaik nung nagsstart na yung fame ng Bini they always defend the girls na wag nga daw itulad yung treatment sa mga kpop idol kasi iba sila. They need their own personal space kineme. Pero ngayong nagliparan mga dating rumors or rather dating proofs ng girls. Sila rin naman yung unang tumalikod sakanila. Di ko nilalahat though pero parang ito yung nakikita ko these days.", "Or sadyang madami lang talaga ang cloutchasers porket madali lang makarami ng clout dahil famous ang Bini kaya ginagamit nila ang BloomCard kuno. Sinabayan pa ng hindi magandang pagmamanage ng management ng girls. Low promotions+mahal na merch kahit hindi maganda ang quality kaya sa Girls ang backlash ng lahat At sunod sunod ang pagsalo ng mismong Bini ng mga force hate"]}
{"dialog": ["My Alamat Mo x Bini Colet ship has sunk. \n\nBut kung saan ang girls happy, dapat yun i-follow nila.", "I feel you. \n\nBut yeah, as long as they're happy, good for them."]}
{"dialog": ["2 of the worst fan bases here in the PH: Volleyball fans & music/love team stans \n\nBoth those fan bases (or stans), always overbearing & find ways na maging toxic", "simula nung na uso ang shipping na yan naging toxic na volleyball community, they support the player not the sport", "parang sa GaWong to nag start"]}
{"dialog": ["Bini are also terrible people, that mightve contributed to it as well", "How are they terrible people?? Because pinaglalaban nila sarili nila and sumasagot sa mga bastos na fans?", "You get what you deserve. Terrible people attracts terrible fans."]}
{"dialog": ["True ba yung kay Colet?", "Probably?"]}
{"dialog": ["anong band yung woty?", "Woman of the year", "for 2024 ba yan? sobrang aga naman kung 2025", "2025 po ang BINI kasi WOTY 2024 ay si Sarah G.", "bakit may 2025 na agad e di pa nakakaisang quarter yung taon hehe", "For achievements nang buong 2024 yung event. And also, March talaga cinecelebrate yan dahil Women's Month.\n\n\nAtsaka ganyan talaga. Parang Oscars 2025, mga films for the year 2024 ang inaawardan."]}
{"dialog": ["sino nag make up kay aiah ano ginawa nyo sa blush nya huhu", "tru yun din una kong napansin. parang ang inspo eh si sasa gurl sa blush huhuhu", "Yung hotdog na pinatong sa sinaing na kanin yung inspo ni sassa gurl"]}
{"dialog": ["Gusto ko yung look nung second girl sa left and yung last girl sa right. Very natural lang and pang actress yung aura.", "Funnily enough (in a good way), silang dalawa yung may acting credits sa mga teleserye before kaya lumalabas yung pang-actress na aura.", "I did not know that! Good for them! I hope to see them more as an actress."]}
{"dialog": ["Ang ganda ng outfit nila! It represents their identity and branding well as Bini as well as them being a Filipino group! They all look stunning but my faborjte outfits are Gwens, Jhoanna and Colet!", "Funfact: The Nation's GirlgroupBini wearing elegant sampaguita dress. The National flower(sampaguita) is BINI's Flower logo. If you look closely. Even the small details designs of Gwen, Aiah and Jhoanna are sampaguita flowers. And totoong ang Ganda ng suot ni Colet Kasi kitang kita Yung mismong sampaguita. Dahil rin sa kanya kaya narealize ko na lahat sila may sampaguita design sa dress nila", "Yun nga"]}
{"dialog": ["Ang gagandang  nilang lahat! Pinaka bet ko ung look ni Mikha, very demure,  and glowing nya lang", "Gurl nagutom ako akala ko sabi mo pinakbet"]}
{"dialog": ["Considering halos may facial resemblance si Sheena kay Sarah, it's as if kumpleto pa rin ang walo.", "Kaya nga eh, parang nagpatwin swap lang si Sheena kay Sarah"]}
{"dialog": ["Im sorry, how is 15-18 considered grooming?\nIt can only be considered grooming if he manipulated the girl especially if walang consent yung acitvities nila.", "Ang alam ko, if 2-3yrs difference, more like case of Romeo-Juliet shenanigans. But thats what I only know.", "Yeah. These age brackets are still considered under pedia. 1st year ka and nag jowa ng 4th year HS which very common", "Most ppl kasi use the term grooming kahit hindi naman talaga applicable sa situation. Ewan ko ba. I guess thats a new gen thing, using terms repeatedly kahit walang connect sa situation."]}
{"dialog": ["13-18 is already out of the Romeo and Juliet clause. Walang kinalaman circle of friends. Understand though that an 18 year old dating a 13 year old isn't grooming. Iba meaning nun.", "I see! Hehe barkada ko po sila and they are getting married next year they have been together na for 12 yrs shettt", "depende din kasi kung kelan sila nagsama. if they were already consenting adults then there's nothing to see there. If not, well nu gagawen kakasal na eh"]}
{"dialog": ["Mmm 15-18 isn't exactly bad , we in the PH still acknowledge the Romeo and Juliet clause (3-4 year age gap).", "Only up to 3 years."]}
{"dialog": ["Suyen is 21 mag 22 this year. Kung totoo na nilagawan sya ni Zild malamang 2023 shes around 20 that time. Si zild sabhin mo na 26 may genral rule na half your age plus 7 ang acceptable age to date. 26/2 plus 7 = 20  tska walang minor! 2022 last relationship ni zild. Op halata ka masyado! Kayo rin ung nasa tiktok tska x! Ngaun dingadagan mo pa ng grooming eme! In fairness tindi galit mo kay zild! Kung ako sayo ipako mo sya sa krus! Tska ang dami nyo time ha", "Well nung sila ni Shanne nag start sila na 14 si Shanne at 18 si Zild. Sure, both minors pero kunwari schoolmate mo sila parang may nakita kang sophomore na nag dedate ng senior.", "WAIT WHAT", "Yep, same church sila afaik. Nilapitan nya raw si Shanne and said **Courtship** **Day** **1**", "nag date din ako ng senior nung freshie ako nung hs pero 2 years lang age gap namin  naloka ako sa 4, parang wow beh cradle snatcher ata term for u"]}
{"dialog": ["Ano pa bang asahan mo diyan pati dating mga kabanda niyan lahat ng mga friends ko dinali kahit may mga jowa sila lalo na yang si Unique at Blaster. Tapos dumagdag pa jowa ni Blaster na groomer din tas aya ng aya ng threesome", "wtf, Crystal Jobli nag aaya ng threesome???", "Silang dalawa lol tandem sila maghanap eh\n\nWala namang masama if its their thing. Sobrang annoying lang nung panahon na yun kasi even yung friend kong virgin pa at the time kino-convince nila (salamat naman at hindi na-convince shes v precious)\n\nTapos si Crystal ang laki ng age gap sa mga friends ko", "lol yea no issue naman if yun yong thing nila, shookt lang ako. but yea, kita naman sa kanila na thing nila yon"]}
{"dialog": ["Ooh wala na sila pala ni Shanne Dandan", "matagal na. may gf na din si shanne ngayon", "totoo?!?! since when daw?", "since last year"]}
{"dialog": ["mag aalis na naman ba ng kanta sa playlist", "*I'm sure I'm gonna be downvoted to oblivion for this,* but sometimes I just tell myself to \"separate the art from the artist\" whenever I would listen, and vibe to Kanye West, Travis Scott, Michael Jackson, etc.", "Naiisip ko rin yan, pero habang nakikinig I would always be reminded na it's also a form of support to the artist. I'd be filled with guilt that there are people who suffered in the hands of those artists. \n\nBut you do you. We all have our own decisions at the end of the day.", "No, you're absolutely right. And it's nice to hear that your moral compass is still pointed in the right direction. And it's still a moral decision whether you'll continue listening to them or not, right?\n\nLook, I'm not saying YOU SHOULD continue to listen to them. But all I'm saying is that don't guilt trip yourself whenever you hear their music, and you end up enjoying or vibing to it again. Sometimes people take it too hard, and hold it against themselves.\n\nHindi naman kasalanan na na-enjoy niyo yung kanta, at hindi din naman ibig sabihin nun eh tinatapakan niyo na agad yung mga biktima nila. Hindi din kayo yung oppressor.\n\nIt's okay to feel guilt. And it's important to remind ourselves that some people behind these songs are shitty human beings."]}
{"dialog": ["Oof as a medyo bini fan sana hindi totoo na dating sila ni Maloi kung ganito pala kaproblematic si zild lols...", "dating ano sila?", "Dating daw as in nagde date haha"]}
{"dialog": ["Dun palang sa panot na gothic nakuha na nila boto ko HAHAHAHA", "WHAHGAHHAHHAAHAHAHHAAHHAHHAAHAHHAHABAHHAHHAHAHHAHAHAHAH TAWANG TAWA AKO"]}
{"dialog": ["Cum inside your heart pa nga", "HAHAHAAHAHHA PUTANGINA NAPA OHH WOOAH OH WOAAH OOOHB OOOOHH AHAHAHAHAH"]}
{"dialog": ["Taas nga ng hairline nya ano.", ",tu naman si alden. iba naman topic"]}
{"dialog": ["Isn't zild like a teenager? Like how is he being labeled a groomer rn.", "Lol Not anymore  Eat Bulaga's Music Hero happened in 2016, that's 9 years ago  We are getting old HAHAHAHAHAHA \n\nP.S. 1995 was 30 years ago  /RUNS"]}
{"dialog": ["Parang ang aasim nung member ng IV of Spades.", "sana may bot na mabilang kung ilang times nagamit yung word na \"maasim\" sa sub na to haha"]}
{"dialog": ["dami talaga weirdo sa music scene", "apaka poser pa niyan, nanggagaya lang yan ng style of clothing and even music"]}
{"dialog": ["separate the art from the artist, lol.\nDami talagang red flag na mga artists", "Its hard to do that though, especially if the artist's personal life is reflected on his/her songs."]}
{"dialog": ["suyen pala name nun kala ko lilypichu /jk", "Hahahaahah hoy hawig nga"]}
{"dialog": ["Pano naging groomer si zild e bata din sya? I mean di naman sya ganun katanda", "Yung suyen kakabente lang. Siya 27 na now. Possible na underage pa yung suyen nung jinowa niya"]}
{"dialog": ["Tumatanda na tayo. Nung kasagsagan ng mainstream breakthrough nilang apat as IV of Spades (2018), 20 years old pa lang si Zild.", "Trueeeeee"]}
{"dialog": ["All hail! Also Lover of Saturn  XD\n\nWhere is this gif from? I need to see the full thing  I'm a BB bloom", "I think this is from their araneta concert. They had a segment with lgbt queens. BINI has been a long time PRIDE supporter.\n\nAlso, yeah because of our princess I am now a lover of Saturn as well!", "Thanks for the info! I'll look for the video :) yas I love how inclusive our queens are \n\nWe need Sailor Saturn Staku cosplay"]}
{"dialog": ["Congrats  \nShout out sa bias ko STACEY!!!", "SHOUT OUT TO PRINCESS STAKU"]}
{"dialog": ["nako konti lang upvote neto kumpara sa iba, allergic kasi mga tao rito pag sumasakses ang bini hahahaha let them have it naman", "ayan nanaman sa mga pagcompare ng upvotes. di naman lahat inuupvote dito lol hindi naman to fan page"]}
{"dialog": ["Im surprised wala si sarah sa list", "Sarah is currently at 700M+ streams."]}
{"dialog": ["Sexbomb Girls pa din", "Kelangan na magcomeback ng sexbomb girls"]}
{"dialog": ["I think they are not putting Bini down. Temacula has a lot of Filipinos, thats why its expected na maraming bibili ng ticket. If they started in California muna, and booked smaller venues edi sana there is no drama that they are flop.", "the venue is sold out kasi pinamigay na ng casino mga tickets para sa high roller clients nila. complimentary tickets yan binili ng casino ang show mula sa producer! char ka dyan OP."]}
{"dialog": ["They dont like BINI here. Pag positive ang post about them, downvote ka talaga plus sasabihan ka pa na PR ka ng BINI. Pero pag nega ang post, ay talaga naman tuwang tuwa ang mga talangka.", "This is only one venue sweetheart, have u seen the other venues?"]}
{"dialog": ["This may hurt them in the long run, parang ginagawa silang cash cow na hanggang sa maexhaust :( tapos sana bagong album and balik nila yung filipino lyrics na may laman. Missing their salamin salamin & pantropiko era :(", "Same sentiments :< and I think nabawasan casual listeners nila dahil puro english na pinoproduce. Before kahit saang sulok ka ay puro Bini maririnig mo.", "Totoo to :( sorry pero naappreciate ko approach ng SB19 na laging filipino lyrics gamit nila sa songs. May english part lang. diba dapat ganon? Kasi nga theyre promoting PPop eh. KPOP, nagtarget sila western pero saka na sila nagintroduce ng english when they had a following na. Even BP, sikat nilang songs sa coachella hindi naman pure english song.", "Sa sb19 kasi sila ang writer at producer afaik.", "That makes more sense now kaya pala kaya maging solo artist or can pursue their own endeavors ng mga members  nila.\n\nI recently discovered Justin's discography at grabe din na director nadin pala siya for his and other artist's MVs", "Not their fan pero i think that is why my laman yung kanta nila at hindi commercialized yung tunog. Bini's sound ay maganda din at madaling pakinggan ang difference siguro parang mas connected ka sa lyrics ng kanta ng sb 19", "This is why Karera is one my fave Bini songs. May laman, tagos sa puso, and tagalog. I wish they can make more songs like that.", "I also love BINI's lagi.. ang ganda ng tagalog songs nila #ppoprise"]}
{"dialog": ["Real talk lang they don't have an established fanbase outside of PH otherwise, these small theaters would've already sold out. That's what their management refuses to acknowledge, to have a fanbase large enough to sell out a small venue quickly. Just look at how a lot of nugu Kpop groups can still sell these small venues in minutes because they have a reliable fanbase that was built before their debut. But it's in June pa naman, so there's still time.", "Dapat magpromote sila sa Japan and China(kung pwede). Loyal mga fans dun.", "si Ken ng SB19 nagpo-promote doon. not sure lang kung may solid fanbase na.", "Good. promote lang nang promote. sakupin ang Japan hahahaha. \n\nTeka lang siya yung may deep voice diba?", "Oo. tas ang dami nyang magagandang solo songs.", "Ahhh siya pala kumanta ng ache. Ang ganda nun \nAnyway, sana dumami japanese fans niya kase parang fit voice niya dun.", "Uu yung 7 Sins na album"]}
{"dialog": ["Why so many cities all at once kasi? They should've done just the cities with the biggest Filipino population in a couple of states lang. Ang laki din ng mga venues when they should've gone for auditoriums first. Rosemont in Illinois has 4,400 seats.\n\nKapag nag-sold out yung venue like sa San Francisco, tsaka pa lang sila dapat mag-hype ng PR about the big demand for BINI, then they can add more dates, venues, and other cities.\n\n\nAnd concerts on weekdays are always hard to sell dahil may work ang mga tao and mas mahirap kung need pa mag-travel and book ng hotel if sa malayo pa manggagaling. Most of their concert dates are on weekdays. And sa price ng concerts nowadays na sobrang mahal na because of Ticketmaster, nakaka-turn off na gumastos ng sobrang laki just for 1-2 tickets.", "Eto. Walang Florida, eh daming pinoy dun. At bakit may Boston?? Parang kinulang sa strategy yung locations.", "Ginaya yung mga kpop groups na may stop sa Boston hahahahaha", "i dont think maraming pinoy sa Boston...They should have done FLORida...anywhere kung san may Jollibee hahahahaah.", "Yeah.. Maraming asian bagets, due to Harvard and MIT, pero konti lang Pinoy dun.", "they should have just thought of san ba maraming pinoy..i mean i really dont think Boston ung unang maiisip ko.Florida,NYC,Texas and FL maraming Pinoy\naside sa Cali...i mean ABS should know,they did fiestang pinoy sa FL. . .i mean maybe they are trying to hit midwest so people doesnt have to travel? im trying to justify why Boston and walang FL..."]}
{"dialog": ["Pano ba ticket pricing nila abroad? Same pricing din ba dito na sky high magpresyo ng concert tickets?", "the one in houston..it ranges from $200- $70...depende kung san ka bibili na site.", "$400 ish with meet & greet + sound check", "saw that one..is it going to be worth it?eeehhh baka ung meet and greet dadaan lang. hahahaha.", "Oo feel ko yung tipong naka upo sila sa long table tas lalakad kayo sa harap nila. Tapos sound check 3 songs na walang energy na nakashades pa sila ganon  pagod mga yan of course", "for $400 nope....hayyy naku,gatas na gatas talaga.i cant believe na maraming bumili ng front row but sa ticketmaster may mga nag reresell na.. \n\ni want to watch them sa totoo lang...but ill wait till this weekend.inaaya ko p ung mga mas bagets sa akin.."]}
{"dialog": ["Uy ang sipag talaga! Blooms ako, tapos ni reqoute kolang ung performance nla sa showtime grabe mga ATIN naka 1k retweet at 1k hearts sla. Grabe sipag nla mag appreciate. Kasi ang ganda talaga ng DAM nla na song", "I meant the SB19 members' official and individual accounts (Stell, Pablo, Justin, Josh, wala pa ako nakita kay Ken) sa Tiktok, masipag sila mag-comment and repost nung mga dance covers and instrumental covers nung mga songs nila.", "Truth. Naka follow ako sa bini pero prang mas focus sla nag repost kapag mgq foreigner nagrereport ng dance covers nla LOL", "The instrumental and dance covers na nirerepost nila, wala naman pili. Even Pinoy dance groups or individual guitarists na nag-cover ng DAM, nirerepost o nag-cocomment naman yung mga SB19 members. I was just staying on point sa comment na nireplyan ko about SB19's presence in Japan because I know they have marketed there multiple times as a group or as a solo artist even before the comeback. \n\nAno ba ito, bagong script? Hahaha \"Bloom ako\" \"I follow Bini\" + comment + may slight parinig?", "Nooo. Namisunderstand mo ata comment nya. Minimean nya ata ay yung bini yung nagrerepost pag foreigner yung nagcover.", "YES. Hehe! Puro foreigner lang. or unless sikat ka na artist dto sa PH. Haha"]}
{"dialog": ["I know I don't have any say on this pero sana they focused on making good music muna. The flame died down when they had to do concerts on concerts. They're not just performers, they're really good musicians. Let them do their thing sana.", "This one.\n\nSa true lang nakikita ko yung TWICE sa kanila.\n\nNung biglang sikat nila parang ginamit na sila nang todo todo", "At least naman ang Twice may 2-3 comebacks/yr. Ang lawak ng discography nila kumpara sa Itimrosas", "Ofc OG ang Twice"]}
{"dialog": ["Solid yung sa california solong solo mo yung bini", "The Temecula stop only has 5 seats left.  Why solo? Lol\nThe colored circles are the remaining seats left.", "My bad.. I stand corrected... Thanks sa pag correct", "All good!"]}
{"dialog": ["Check natin sa sb19 world tour din after a few months", "pupuksain ata ako ng ibang blooms for joining the convo but since the group I'm supporting is mentioned...\n\n>Check natin sa sb19 world tour din after a few months\n\nIt's already their 3rd world tour. Tho, not all were sold out sa previous world tours, lahat naman full house.\n\nThis time tho, aside from going back sa usual stops, it seems like they're tapping a lot of countries/cities na never nila napuntahan and not the usual target of other Filipino artists.\n\nWorrying given that they're self-managed and they can't afford to bleed a lot of money, but if I'm gonna base it sa iTunes ranking ng DAM sa ibang mga bansa, hopefully they'll do well. Never naman sila papabayaan ng fanbases per country.\n\nSpeaking sa last two world tours ng group, paunti-unti ang pagkakabenta ng ticket pero umuusad. Tho, my biggest complain is wala silang promotion. Usually, it's the avid fans na updated sa ganap ng group during the 1st day, then by word of mouth na lamang...", "Natawa ako sa 'pupuksain ng ibang blooms' haha! But honestly, A'tin won't be here and won't see threads related to Bini if SB19 is not mentioned.", "nagreklamo na sila sa r/ppopcommunity"]}
{"dialog": ["Mukhang gustong mag speed run ng Star Music ang Bini sa global stage tulad ng established kpop girl groups.\n\nBut what they dont understand is that the top kpop groups today took time to reach where they are now. Established popularity domestically, then Asia, then global scale na.\n\nItong Star Music, ano ginawa? After mag viral ang Pantropiko, Cherry on Top(English song) agad. After ng ilang concert dito sa Pinas, World Tour agad.\n\nEdit: Sa mga blooms dito, don't come at me. I'm just stating my observation on how their management is handling them. \n\nI have nothing against the girls. Hardworking silang lahat, mababait at gusto ang ginagawa nila.", "Totoo!!! SM Ent nga before, may korean, Chinese, Japanese versions mga album nila para talaga makakuha sila ng following sa ibang bansa. Masyadong nagmamadali management, sobrang talented ng Bini, wag nila sayangin pls lang.", "concentrated kasi nung una ang hallyu sa countries na yan at first. yung 2nd gen yung mas sumikat sa ibang Asian countries, SEA in particular. tas sinubukan din nila mag North America pero walang concerts whatsoever pa masyado. yung BTS nga, unang mga concert pa nila sa US libre pa."]}
{"dialog": ["They're doing it all wrong:\n1) the management being ambitious and greedy, exhausting the girls\n2) the girls fighting with their fans who just happen to defend them from their management and ridiculing themselves online\n3) the prod for their lackluster english album, and the marketing for their poor promotion\n\nAgain, it's only a matter of time they lose their shine", "Atat na atat kasi ang management sa intl validation agad-agad.  Kulang na lang bansagan nila ng Asias Girl Group kasi di pwede kasi obvious naman na hindi. \n\nThey shouldve stuck sa old formula nila para mas ma-ingrain pa ang status nila sa Pinas.  I dont get baket kelangan nila mag English songs eh yung nagpasikat sa kanila is yung mga tagalog.  As I said before, let the intl fans adjust sa music nila, not the other way around.  Thats how they got noticed in the first place.\n\nTheir new EP is so dissapointing.  Zero Pressure lang ang maganda, the rest, tapon.  Atat rin ang management na maka-collab ng isang koreano.  Basta meron, go!  Kahit panget ng song, go!  Hay naku.  This is their worse EP imo.  Sayang.  \n\nTheyre going to lose ground sa Pinoy fanbase if they keep doing this.  They need to focus on catchy PPop songs.  They have the budget to afford hitmakers sa Pinas like Thyro, pero ewan ko kung ganun EP nila.  Imagine them having songs like Tala, Kilometro or Ikot-Ikot.  Imagine l...", "Management = Dyogi. Yes man lang karamihan like MQ and their coaches.\n\nIve called it before, na BINI is going downhill, and I dont like it. Sayang yung peak, di manlang nag plateau, bumagsak agad."]}
{"dialog": ["I'm rooting for Blooms to succeed sa boycott katulad ng hindi pagbili ng official merch, hindi pag-renew ng membership, not falling for the damage control attempts ng management via the girls' socials, and so on. Hit Dyogi right where it hurts the most, the pockets, and it just so happens na collateral ang BINI (though may fault din sila to some extent by 'enabling' management to do this to their audience). *The Nation's Girl Group is not nationing, y'all.*\n\nIlang beses nang nasa short end ang Blooms and given yung core nila ay galing sa KPop, alam nila ang idol industry through their experiences in other fandoms. I'm sure many will agree na hindi capable mag-manage ng ganitong magnitude ang ABS kasi I said this before, **idols sila more than anything** and that means very different approach than what they normally do sa mga artista.\n\nThey just need to swallow their pride and accept the fact na kailangan talaga ng independent team that's solely f...", "Theyre binded by a contract, kaya they have no choice but to enable it. Pero sana, they couldve worked on their responses better. Nakasama din kasi na napatol sila sa ibang blooms that were calling out yung management. Kinda sad cos Blooms love them so much.\n\nAfter their peak, theyre releasing sh*t stuff for blooms no one asked. I dont remember Kpop groups selling divi looking tote bag as an official merch.\n\nDapat din maging aware sila na kpop fans found refuge in BINI, hence the decline of popularity of kpop not only here, but SEA. Sobrang laki ng influence ng pinoy fanbase, that foreign content creators are taking advantage of it. Trend yan dati pa, kung hindi Japan, China or Indonesia, mga pinoy talaga ang nagdi-dikta sa popularity ng mga grupo.", "I agree. Sana wag sila mang away pag may nag call out sa management nila. Hindi naman kasi sila yung problema. Hayaan nalang nila. Mas better wag na mag respond. Kaso minsan ang active active pa sa twitter na parang may kaaway palagi."]}
{"dialog": ["TOO MUCH HYPE. TOO MUCH PRESSURE.\ndi naman pang world tour agad, sino manonood sa US mga 30+ year old titas? ang tanong meron ba, with this too much girly girly cutie patootie?", "dugtong - bini is pang PH lang as of this moment ha, try to dominate asian pop culture first (pero mukhang di kaya) in the next 3-4-5 years", "another dugtong - if this sht goes through tapos puro dismaya nabuo sa loob ng isat isa? maghi hiwa hiwalay yan paisa isa"]}
{"dialog": ["Kelan concert nila? Matagal pa ba?", "Sa June..", "Jusko. Kawawa naman yung girls sunod-sunod concerts grabe na siguro pagod. Gatas na gatas ng management. This world tour is so rushed, sana manlang pinagpahinga kahit konti :(("]}
{"dialog": ["I wonder what their concert will be like, haha. Their last concert was full of ads, and I just want to forget the rest of the experience that made it sour. Anyway, I wish them the best, but I treat them as music artists. I do not like their current songs and new album it's not my taste, haha, just like how I dont like some new releases from artists I love", "Yun eh kung kaya sponsor ng local companies concerts nila abroad. Ang alam ko kasi, sa foreign artists, more or less sponsored din pero walang brand placement sa kahit saan sa loob. Not even banners.", "Meron naman, they can be sponsored by local businesses kung saan nagcconcert. Usually filipino owned businesses abroad din nagssponsor and may brand placement and promotion din syempre."]}
{"dialog": ["Agree, Asia muna sana. Too ambitious si Dyogi.", "Too greedy din, kawawa ang girls"]}
{"dialog": ["Ngl I found their songs really catchy pero parang nag die na yung hype? \n\nDi na ako masyado nakikinig ng songs nila. Di rin ganun kaganda yung new song nila. Dapat talaga nag focus nalang muna sila on creating new music. World tour agad agad tsk ano ba yan ABS\n\nBalik Sabrina Carpenter ako hahahaah", "They need to have at least 3-4 more HUGE hits like Pantropiko and Salamin level para cguro maka-consider sila ng world tour.  Binarat sila sa producers and composers.  They have the budget to afford the top hitmakers sa bansa, pero ganun lang EP nila."]}
{"dialog": ["Mali talaga mga decisions ng management ng Bini. Masyadong minamadali lahat. They probably thought na ang dali lang na-introduce ng kpop sa US which in reality, ay hindi. For big Kpop groups like Twice and Blackpink, it took them a couple of years bago sila nakilala sa US. Meanwhile, here comes Bini management that think they can duplicate what these Kpop groups did, only to realize na it was too soon and it would just make the group flopped.\n\nAnd please, ang TRYING HARD masyado ng management for releasing english songs just to cater to these global audience. Sana nag research muna kayo kung may fans dyan.\n\nAnd REAL TALK lang, if this global audience really likes Bini, they will listen to their songs kahit ba hindi nila maintindihan ang lyrics. No need to release english songs. Look at Twice, kahit korean pa yan, kung may established fans na sa US, they will listen. Hindi yung mag aadjust pa ang artist na gumawa ng english songs just to please the fans.", "Eto talaga yung kinagagalit ko sa management nila.  Super trying hard to appease to international fans na ang BINI pa talaga ang mag-aadjust.  Gurl, if Americans, for example, want English songs, theyll listen to their own.  Given the quality of their latest EP, I will definitely listen to my own.  Theyre not bringing anything unique to the table at this point.  That was part of their charm in the first place.\n\nMasyadong atat tong management nila. Instead of investing more sa girls like their MUSIC, quality of their merchandise, IMAGE, etc. mas inuna ang mga ka eng-engan na ganito.  Gusto niyo e market sa US tapos ganyan merch nyo for example???? Ano to, lokohan????\n\nTatak ABS - expecting maximum profit from minimal investment.  Wala sigurong nakakuha sa kanila ng memo kung paano nag-iinvest ang Korean companies sa mga idols nila before sila naka reach sa larger intl markets.  Tbh, kelangan nila mag-seminar and take notes sa Kpop companies, para alam nila ginagawa nila."]}
{"dialog": ["Pilit kasi , they are shoving it on the people", "+100"]}
{"dialog": ["Inasa lahat sa Filipino community sa US. Mga K-pop acts diverse ang fan base kaya mabilis nakakapuno ng malalaking venue.", "Saka mostly on the older side ang mga Pinoy abroad, dapat inuna talaga nila ang mga neighbours natin sa asia"]}
{"dialog": ["Release quality music and new album muna kasi. Grabe hype ng Dam ng SB19 lately, ilang beses ko na napanood performance nila sa AOS and Showtime.", "truedafire! bakit ba nagkaganto? andaming tukso... on repeat hahaha"]}
{"dialog": ["Its also because of lack of promotional material. Maraming citizens raw abroad ang di informed sa tour dates kasi never pa nag-promote ang StarMu ng general sale ticket selling dates. Member pre-sale and date lang ng mismong concert ang na-promote so far kaya akala ng marami, wala pa general sale.", "Nalaman ko lang na magcoconcert BINI sa ads ng IG"]}
{"dialog": ["I'm a fan but I agree na masyadong greedy management. They didn't even promote this concert properly. We just found out that the general sale for the world tour happened 2 days ago without announcement lol", "Yes not enough promotion na marereach ang casual listeners. Unless naka follow ka sa lahat ng social media nila you wouldnt know"]}
{"dialog": ["How big is the capacity of these venues? Parang Araneta Coliseum ba? Maybe they shouldve gotten smaller venues muna.", "the one is houston ay parang same nung unang biniverse nila...d ganun kalaki pero d rin maliit. keri lang.  \n\nthe tickets are good too."]}
{"dialog": ["actually i think targeted ito sa mga immigrant fans, secondary na lang siguro yung international/foreign market. they acknowledge na may market sila sa mga immigrant blooms and they want to exhaust that. kung magfocus sila sa japan/china/other asian countries, kailangan marunong sila magjapanese and chinese kahit basic kasi lol japanese fans pa lang are very particular kasi if u dont speakt their language, di ka rin magkakaroon ng sustainable fanbase.\n\nanyway kailangan nila mag Calgary show hmpft daming pinoy dito aka me char", "it includes both international-born and philippine-born pinoys so ang target market talaga nila sa english markets i believe ay yung di marunong magtagalog na pinoy iykwim hahahahhaa im not sure if they are truly trying to penetrate the international market using that album."]}
{"dialog": ["Ayokong idawit SB19 dito (cuz fanwars) pero para sa akin tamang way yung ginawa nila to reach stardom. Kailangan muna nila patatagin yung fandom nila sa Asia mainly China and Japan bago mag-promote sa US. And especially produce more Filipino songs rather than full English songs.", "I agree, kahit di English ung songs na nirerelease nila, sobrang hype parin ang mga international fans/reactors because of their signature sounds, vocals, music videos, choreo and lyrics."]}
{"dialog": ["Sino nga yung manager nito? Dyogi ba yun? Sorry hindi ako familiar sa name. Kung manager ba siya or siya nagbuo. Anyway, siya kasi ang pinaka nagbebenefit dito. Kaya kahit low quality songs na ang ilabas okay na sa kanya. Ang sad lang is the talent of Bini has been wasted with too much marketing and sponsporship. Sorry, pero wala talagang patience and enough grasp of reality and success ang mga management sa Pinas. They equate success with big cash flow. And sad to say, globally known stars like Lea Salonga and Charice Pempengco reach the heights of their success because they veered away from Philippine management.", "Naka jackpot lang naman talaga yang Dyogi na yan sa BINI. Tingnan mo yang BGYO nya, hanggang ngayon, waley pa rin. Di marunong mag-handle ng talents niya, especially from bad publicity.\n\nI mean sya rin ang nagpu-push kay Anji Salvacion.  So alam mo na.\n\nAgree ako sa daming sponsorships.  While it is money, it just cheapens their brand.  But maybe thats what they want, pang-masa naman talaga sila which is a goldmine sa Pinas."]}
{"dialog": ["Anyare sa blink twice? may nagpatugtog ba like pantropiko dati? parang nalimutan agad after release.", "Ako. Hahaha hindi ako fan ng BINI pero bet na bet ko tong Blink Twice nila. Yun lang pinapakinggan ko. Mas maganda sana yang Blink Twice nila if may halong Filipino language. More catchy. Lalo na sa mga gen alphas hahaha pansin ko lang sila yung mahilig sumayaw ng pantropiko sa Tiktok"]}
{"dialog": ["I mean it's too early to judge, may almost 3months pa nman before the concert. I'll reserve my judgement nlang if malapit na concert, if it is flop or not", "Alam mo naman trend ngayon. Kung talagang in demand yan, in matter of hours (or minutes pa nga), sold out yan. Usually, pag hindi tlga napupuno kahit ilang montha pa lang before the show, kina-cancel na. Also, imagine the cost they have to incur as to why need na now pa lang, dapat sold out na."]}
{"dialog": ["Dagdag pa dito yung andaming kung anong membership/subscription para lang makabili during presale.\nTo think nasa $30 ata yung membership para maka access sa first presale. Blackpink is $25 lang yata.\n\nIf Im a casual listener lang naman na hindi very updated like a fanatic na boomer rin, hindi nalang ako bibili.", "Ang daming presales for something na hindi naman magssoldout in a week."]}
{"dialog": ["Alin dyan yung sold? Yung may color?", "Grey yung sold."]}
{"dialog": ["Gusto rin naman ng Bini yan now, ang mag go international na sila. Happy sila na may world tour sila now. Watch niyo mga interviews. Ayun palagi nila na mina-manifest. :)", "This is what i want to say. Gusto to ng girls theyve been waiting their whole lives for this. The problem is is the management ready? Hell no. \n\nThis tour isnt about breaking into the global market naman talaga ( sa music nila, oo) but more on about reconnecting with Filo OFWs and international Blooms who have supported them from afar. Its a chance for BINI to see their fans in these countries. Even before andami kong nakikita sa bloom twitter na sana magpunta yung girls sa ganto sa ganyan para makita sila. Hindi rin naman ineexpect ng girls na masosoldout nila mga yan"]}
{"dialog": ["Not really a Bini fan but I dont hate them either. Actually, very bet ko si Aiah and shee the only Bini member I follow sa socials. I love her!\n\nPero everyday, pag na-open ako ng Reddit puro posts about sa kanya nalang nakikita ko and 3 consecutive days na yata. \n\nWla na bang bagong balita?", "Pati din yung sports one at pba gatas na gatas yung issue mahina ata ticket sales. Yung camera palagi nakatutok kay tiongson kitang kita tuloy yung foul.", "dito ako naiinis e yung mga \"sports media pages\" puro si Aiah na lang pinost e hindi naman sports related yung relationship nila kung ano man yun hahaahaha", "syempre sabay sa issue para mapagusapan din sila. hahaahahahaha"]}
{"dialog": ["Totoo naman mga sinabi ni Caelan and tama naman. He seems to be a nice guy. Simple and straightforward too. Ako tuloy yung nahihiya para kay Caelan sa attitude ng ibang fans. Other fans tend to be so overprotective sa idols nila to the point na they think they know better than Aiah and that they should be the one deciding for Aiah. Hindi naman dapat ganun.", "May nabasa pa akong comment na okay lang daw mag jowa si Aiah pero dapat si Mikha ang jowa. Ang hilig nila gawing lesbians idol nila. Mga delulu", "Eh karamihan naman kasi ng mga fans nila mga bading na galing bp at mga thai gl fans"]}
{"dialog": ["kaya kayo nababash kasi ang dami nyong pasikot-sikot sumagot. \n\nyung mga die hard fans ng bini lalo na kay aiah simple lang naman gusto nila marinig, **YES or NO** lang naman hinahanap nila na sagot!\n\nwag na pa issue at lalo kayong mababash", "They dont owe them [toxic bloom] kahit na ano. Hayaan nyo sila. Periodt", "they dont owe them?! kung wala yung mga fans nila saan pupulutin yung bini mo?\n\nkahit papano dapat maging totoo sila para sa ikatatahimik ng issue. \n\npinaikut-ikot nila yung mga fan tapos pag na bash nagpapakalinis.\n\nyou can't blame the fans (toxic man o hindi) kung ano ang mafefeel nila. die hard yan sila eh"]}
{"dialog": ["Tapos sasabihin ng mga delulung fans na akala mo pag aari si aiah na \"clout chaser\" daw yung guy ayaw na lang aminin sa mga sarili na ayaw nila pag jowain idol nila", "di mo sila masisisi kasi die hard fan sila. hahahah"]}
{"dialog": ["Ako nalang kasi piliin mo Caelan para ok na ang lahat", "tama! para masaya na mga bini fans hahahaha"]}
{"dialog": ["Half ba cya? He looks halfie ....", "Pinanuod mo ba yung video po?"]}
{"dialog": ["Why we normal human being can also have a star life? Its part of the life they chose. But I know sometimes it can be overwhelming. You have to be tough Bini", "The entitlement is unhealthy and insane"]}
{"dialog": ["Ako lang ba or bakit di magets ng iba?? Di naman to to confirm or deny yung relationship but more of to say na nasasaktan siya na nakakareceive ng hate yung mga nakapaligid sa kanya? I mean totoo naman, daming mga \"fans\" na ang toxic dun sa PBA player.", "you missed the memo. Everyone here in this sub hates bini. Lmao\n\nAnyway add ko lng dahil may context kaseng na miss out ng casuals dito kaya d cla on the loop:\n\n1st paragraph is addressing that shes aware na may issue with her and the b ball player and she still went to the game despite knowing these issues. Wala kase syang posts on socmed nung pumotok ang issue with the b ball player.\n\n2nd p is addressing that shes usually not affected by these issues kase halos lahat nlng ng lalaki na lilink sa kanya but this time, below the belt na yung blooms into dragging her friends at may death threats pa.\n\nThe rest is just hoping for everyone to be kind and just a playful joke sa dog nya. Bawal na pala yun according to chikaph.\n\nOh ayan sa mga bobong d mka gets dyan eto yung context sa essay nya.", "Madami palang nililink sakanya, haha. Etong Bball player lang nabalitaan e lol", "uhmmm. Afaik na balita din yung ky Jak Roberto. Also, you cant expect media coverage sa lahat ng nalilink sa kanya when Q2 last year they were relatively unknown. Kaya din cguro galit ang blooms dito kase eto yung may high chance na totoo eh. In denial lng.", "Ang nabalitaan ko kay Jak roberto e si Jackie ng showtime haha", "at least alam mo ngayon par. You're welcome kase ako na nag google para sayo hahahaha"]}
{"dialog": ["Haba ng sinulat and explains absolutely nothing", "I was like where is this going? Haha anywayssss, yaan na lang sana siya ng mga fans nila lol adult naman na yang mga yan", "Nahalata pa lalong may tinatago. Like asking a defensive kid na may kasalanan lol", "Tbf yung ibang fans kasi oa masyado. Bash agad. eh kung friends naman talaga sila lol"]}
{"dialog": ["So ano yung point ng post nya?", "Mag english lang ganern", "Im kind of afraid to say this cos Aiah is loved by many pero I noticed with her interviews (and this) she tries to sound articulate pero hindi naman talaga. I mean her english is okay but she tries to be fluent and deep.", "It maybe because of her pageant background. She has always been like this even before BINI, based on her ig captions. Hope she finds the balance between being articulate & being concise."]}
{"dialog": ["Mars pwede mo naman sabihin na wala kameng relasyon", "Main reason why celebrities dont want to confirm nor deny is that people will start to expect them to give a statement on every issue. Unless serious yung issue like alleged drug abuse, its better to avoid confirming/denying.", "Oo pati good/bad publicity pa din.", "Celebrities don't owe the public an explanation about their personal lives. So, I agree sa comment sayo, they don't need to confirm or deny. Siguro ikaw lang 'yung tipo ng taong masiyadong pakelamero. Mind your own business, ayan lang naman message niya."]}
{"dialog": ["That's how I write my essays kapag may hinahabol na word count", "Puro intro and konting body, walang conclusion hahahahah", "Di pala ako nag-iisa sa thought na to. Hahahaha"]}
{"dialog": ["tanong: Gutom ka na ba?\n\nSagot: Kaninang umaga nag breakfast ako tapos noong naglalakad ako palabas ng cafe biglang may naalala akong cravings for lunch kaso may pa food yung officemate kong may birthday kaya di ko nakain yung gusto kong kainin pero may merienda pa naman kaso feeling ko di ko na gusto kainin yun which is disappointing for me pero baka sana sa dinner makain ko na yung gusto ko. \n\nI really enjoy eating, but sometimes I cannot control myself and eat a lot but of course I can still make a room for dessert and coffee which is why I am disappointed.", "Parang si Prince Umpad hahaha", "BWAHAHHAHAAHAHAHAAHAHAHAHAHA"]}
{"dialog": ["Ang Gulo nak", "Pang sexy babe mamang", "Hoy mas okay pa din to! Hahaha"]}
{"dialog": ["Binasa ko and yes mahaba nga pero gets ko naman ung point nya na wag sya ilink sa kung sino sino. Maka bash na wala daw reading compre ibang pinoy pero ilang paragraphs lang nalito na agad? Eme", "Agree. Feeling intellectual agad mga tao dito. Klarong klaro naman gusto niyang iparating. May ma e hate lang. Hahaist buhay", "True gets nmn tlga..pero for them pointless p din"]}
{"dialog": ["Straight inglishera yarn", "Dere derecho", "Nosebleed"]}
{"dialog": ["Julius Randle ng Pinas", "Bakit Julius Randle?", "Frustration ng Knick fans sa kanya is yung body language niya pag di maganda performances niya, lalo na nung playoffs. Same thing kay aiah, visible pag not in the mood siya at nagdidi-disengage sa iba"]}
{"dialog": ["Her message could have been just one or two sentences. Haba ng intro.", "Kung one or two sentences, paano mo sasabihin?", "Tigilan niyo ko mga mosang. Nanuod lang ako."]}
{"dialog": ["Mga baliw fans netong BINI. Mga wala ba kayong buhay? dios mio. Ni isa sa BINI walang papatol sainyo mga panget", "Some of the delulu fans will eventually be the undoing of BINI."]}
{"dialog": ["essay ng hindi nagreview", "Pero nakasubmit on time cheret"]}
{"dialog": ["Thank God I thought I missed the monthly bini hate thread lol", "March 7 palang beshie, may entry nanaman ang ChikaPH sa How to be cool by hating BINI"]}
{"dialog": ["Parang hawig niya si Angeline Quinto sa pic", "Actually hawig naman talaga sila SI Angge talaga nakikita ko kay Aiah."]}
{"dialog": ["Should we give a fuck?", "Pero nagcomment ka pa rin?"]}
{"dialog": ["Parang mas may dapat pang iaddress yung si Colet haha I know I'm getting downvoted for this", "All i know about Colet? She doesn't give a fuck. Basta hindi daw siya ang tipong lumulutang sa dagat kapag itatapon."]}
{"dialog": ["these girls could definitely benefit from having no say about anything at all. since kpop nga naman blueprint nila.", "Hindi rin. Sa Ppop, hindi fang ang mga boss. Lalong hindi rin sunud-sunuran ang mga idols sa mga gustong ipagawa ng mga fans. Kumbaga idol image is zero fucks."]}
{"dialog": ["Yung mga bobo dito sa chikaph kahapon naiinis kayo kay colet kasi di professional sumagot sa twitter. Ngayon naman si Aiah naglabas ng statement may nakikita pa din kayong mali. \n\n\n\nCrab mentality talaga ng nga pinoy, sana masaya kayo sa mga libangan niyo sa buhay", "Mahirap bang respectful or even neutral na sumagot, (at hindi balahura tulad ni Colet) AT THE SAME TIME, may conclusion ang sinasabi? Ang point ng most commenters dito, ang haba haba ng statement niya, parang essay na nga sa haba, her statement still didnt reach a conclusion nor address the issue on hand. Simpleng Yes or no, we are / we are not dating. Periodt. Gets? Porket di pinupuri yang idol, crab mentality agad, fangirl/fanboys need to grow up"]}
{"dialog": ["Gets ko may pagka pick me girl sya. I know Aiah is genuinely kind pero I can see it in her. Ako naman si Jho gusto ko kasi mukang shes authentic naman. Stacey too.", "2025 na and yet you still call women pick me lmao"]}
{"dialog": ["Si Bini Jhoanna ba yung nag guest patroller sa TV patrol? Haha sorry nalilito kasi ako minsan who's who kasi may slight hawig sila sa isat isa sa group. Akala ko ung uniform ay costume lang nila for some skit, for school pala talaga...?", "yes siya yun! tbh nalito ako sakanila ni sheena noon. shes also a journalist noon nakalaban siya nung friend ko sa rspc before, kagaling daw talaga at active sa school orgs nila. kaya rin siguro ginawang leader.\n\nnagsschool pa rin sila may module na binibigay sakanila at yun inaaral nila tho minsan pumapasok parin sila ng face to face", "Samedt!!! Nalilito ako sknila ni sheena HAHA sila yung napagbabaliktad ko lagi sorry naman po\n\nAhh oki!! Nice to know na tuloy ang schooling nila bale yan ay college or shs sila...?", "yung tatlo (colet, aiah, maloi) college na si jho gwen stacey and sheena is shs palang. mikha naman ibang school siya most probably homeschooled yan", "Ohhhhh okay okay!! Salamat sa info, OP! HAHA clueless ako sakanila eh. Nice to know na tuloy ang schooling. Really good role models sila for the youth"]}
{"dialog": ["binidyo si bini jho", "# Bini Jho Crawford...", "ANUBAAAAAA AHHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAH"]}
{"dialog": ["ano ba to noon pia vs heart, ngayon puro bini laman ng sub nato hahah magsi-alisan nga dito yung mga kasali sa pr team ng mga artista", "may sariling chikaph na ang pia and heart fans feud", "Jusko puro naman team ni heart andun hahah"]}
{"dialog": ["Clout chasing vlogger feels nito but whatever.", "lagot ka hahaha", "Haha BINI fan ako nanood pa ko concert nila sa Edmonton halungkatin pa nila comments ko. BS lang yung mga ganitong PR stunt."]}
{"dialog": ["PR yan. Your mind is very small.", "idk ang ano lang for me that youre saying Binis charity works are for PR when they have been helping kahit na hindi pa sila sikat.", "Wag ka mag po-post ng good deeds ng Bini dito miss mam, ayaw ng Chika PH sa Bini."]}
{"dialog": ["grabe di na alam san lulugaw bini hahaha lahat na lang minasama niyo", "Occasionally may mga ganyang projects na din talaga sila like maloi, colet and aiah. Never sila nag vlog na tumutulong sila. Kahit check nyo pa socmed profiles ng mga yan. Talagang random people and friends lang talaga nag po posts. Ewan ko ba, yung ganyang mga acts ng girls minamasama pa ng mga tao dito. Anyway hindi din naman sila perfect pero i commend din nating yung mga ganitong good deeds. It's good vibes na din."]}
{"dialog": ["Poverty porn for a pr strat.", "di nga galing sakanya tong pic, pinicturan siya at pinost to ng casual on tiktok. she hasnt posted about this or kahit ig story"]}
{"dialog": ["Free ad. Congrats JFC!", "Actually sponsor nila si jabee, diba sumayaw pa nga nung concert nila sa phil arena, dami pang jabee ads sa big screen \n\nAnd also, Poverty porn"]}
{"dialog": ["di ko gets bakit nila inaaway si Caelen, ayos naman sagot nya sa mga interview about kay Bini Aiah, he never confirms nor deny naman kung my relationship sila, pero at least di pang clout chaser mga sagot nya linaw din naman ng sinabi nya na di sya mag sasalita about kay Aiah", "di kasi diretsu sumagot tingin ko yan dahilan kaya sila nababash yes or no lang naman yan para matapos na"]}
{"dialog": ["Mejo nakakahiya yung pati pamilya, friends and teammates sinasali!", "ginagatasan din sila ng mga \"friends\" nila para sumikat, kawawa sila\n\nkung sinagot na lang sana ng yes or no, e di tapos"]}
{"dialog": ["Di ko lang magets, bakit ang hilig makialam ng tao? Pabayaan na lang natin mamuhay yung ibang tao kung ano gusto nila gawin, labas na tayo dun.", "Toxic Filipino chismis culture"]}
{"dialog": ["puta sino umaaway? hahahaha", "Blooms hahaha"]}
{"dialog": ["Dating a basketball player is a canon event. Let her.", "may success stories naman.. Kevin Alas & Selena Dagdag nga ba? Court side reporter Barroca & his wife too.. pero yeah.. theres a *babaero* tag to hoops players haha", "Kianna Dy and Dwight Ramos sa gwapo ni Dwight nag tagal sila ni Kianna going to 6yrs na sila ewan na lang kung end game", "Kianna ba naman jowa! Win win pa rin kay Dwight ang hot kasi ni Kianna for me lang ha. Sya yung pag tinitigan mo lalong gumaganda. Ewan lang sa ugli pero ang ganda niya lang. super bagay sila ni dwight. Kainis haha", "makulit si Kianna as jowa opposite talaga sila ni Dwight, pero as in binibigay nya lahat sobrang genuine nya mag mahal, I remember noon yung ex ni Kianna grabe din effort ni Kianna doon, sana din talaga end game nya na si Dwight, kasi ang sakit ma broken ni Kianna", "Whoa! Sino ex niya?", "si Marck Espejo volleyball player, bf nya nung college 5yrs din sila", "Ay infer gwapo din"]}
{"dialog": ["Parang k-netz ang galawan ng ibang blooms", "Baka mostly naka sanayan sa kpop kaya nadala nila sa bini HAHAHAHAH. Di sila sanay na may relationship yung idols nila.", "Which is a bit off coming from pinoy blooms - culture nating ang loveteams, bakit parang shookedt sila", "For artista lang daw ata yan HAHAHAHA."]}
{"dialog": ["good luck sa mga blooms HAHAHHAHA", "Actually puro hates si cae ngayon sa ig! As a PBA Fan masyado nila nihype si aiah lalo na 50th anniv nila!!!", "Hayaan mo na yung PBA na ihype si Aiah wala nang gate attendance sa liga na yan maliban pag ginebra game", "Baka gusto nila ng sariling Taylor/Travis clout Hahahaha"]}
{"dialog": ["Fans should stop having a parasocial relationship with their idols  ang toxic din ng iba (di naman kelangan lahatin) sa tru lang wala naman tayong say sa personal life nila. Labas naman tayo dyan, at di naman kasama sa trabaho nilang 2 ang pagpyestahan ng rumors. Basketball at artist ang trabaho nila. may nagsabi \"normal\" yang ganyang pambabakod sa kpop, sana wag na nilang dalhin sa ppop.", "Aasim ng toxic blooms tbh. Mga iba diyan baby bra warriors", "Maraming white knight fanboy Blooms. Sila yung madalas kumakaway sa ibang fandoms lalo na kung boy group."]}
{"dialog": ["8 years age gap iba talaga nagagawa kapag sikat", "parehas legal age naman na, 8yrs isnt that big of a gap.", "Yes, wala ako sinasabing mali, but it does represent how our society in terms of dating trends"]}
{"dialog": ["Mag-iiyakan na yung mga possessive na fanboys. Hopefully the guy won't receive any d**th threats tulad nung sa friend ni Mikha.", "Ako nalang jowain nung guy para wala nang problema."]}
{"dialog": ["The amount of hate Caelan is getting is overwhelming. He is trying to be strong considering madami din siya pinagdaanan before relating sa mental health niya. Ano ba naman tong mga keyboard warriors. Knetz talaga galawan. Yung entire section sa may seat ni Aiah last night was comprised of Favor church members. Pastor James and wife Pastor Kate were there. Ed Barber was there. Andun din si RJ dela Fuente. Yung focus talaga nilagay kay Aiah. Yung PBA mismo post ng post din about Aiahs attendance para mapagusapan ulit league nila.", "Yuh! I think for the clout yung PBA kasi. Naghahakot ng views eh"]}
{"dialog": ["I say trew. I'll watch a guy friend's game once...but twice? (despite my very busy schedule) jowa moves na yan mga sis! haha", "She watch the game together with their church mates. Marami sila nanuod. Andyan din sila edward barbers and yung pastor nila."]}
{"dialog": ["Let me guess may mga nagwawala na sa twitter no?", "Syempre mga delulu eh. Di man lang naiisip na kaya andyan si Aiahkins dahil wala naman siyanh dapat na itago hahaha a lot of Blooms just don't realize the fact that she's already a full-grown woman at kaya na niyang magdesisyon para sa sarili niya"]}
{"dialog": ["Feel ko may deal ang ABS and PBA para mas maraming manood", "Yup! Knowing ABS hahaha"]}
{"dialog": ["I want to know what lippie she is using here", "Napansin ko nga rin na nice ng lipstick nya! Could be a Mac lipstick because they endorse it, but ang hirap hulaan ng shade! One of their matte lipsticks kaya? Hmm"]}
{"dialog": ["If I were Aiah, lalo kong aasarin yung mga toxic fans. Bahala kayong magkagulo dyan. Lol", "Chika naman ano issue", "She was spotted watching PBA Game and naglalaro dun yung nalilink sa kanya na si Caelan Tiongson.", "And some toxic Blooms didn't like the idea na their idols are dating someone."]}
{"dialog": ["Wala ng mas OG kay Lea Salonga and Menudo noong 80s. I think 13 yrs old lang nung time na to si Ricky Martin.", "Woooow OG nga!"]}
{"dialog": ["bat mo pinopost yan dito? ayaw ng mga tao dito sa bini. dapat yung negative lang.", "Tingnan mo 15 hours na pero wala gaano pumapansin HAHHAHAHA napaka selective mga tao dito eh", "Syempre di nila malalait accolades yan e HAHAHAHA dapat issues para galit na galit sila"]}
{"dialog": ["Ganyan! HAHAHAHA The girls deserve privacy naman kahit papano. Okay na they share their music and talent with us pero lets leave these na to them. Tangina netong mga chismosang press na to", "pero taena 32 na pala sya. HAHAHA", "yeah late na pumasok ng pba so 32 years old na rookie, pero madami na experience sa other leagues"]}
{"dialog": ["Wala naman masama. Theyre in their 20s tapos pipigilan lol Go AIAH", "32 na si Caelan", "Yep saw that comment but still, the point is, theyre free to date. Kahit di yang guy, but in general lang."]}
{"dialog": ["MIKHAIAH LUBOG", "Hahaha iyakan mga nag shiship Jan"]}
{"dialog": ["nawala yung freshness - biglang overexposed. tapos hindi ganon ka bongga ang latest songs nila. sana nag stick muna sila sa catchy, cutesy, tagalog lyrics. pinatibay pa sana ang foundation ng career nila, kumbaga.", "Atat kasi silang maging international stars eh hilaw pa talaga sila para doon. Gumawa ng English songs na di relatable sa mga Pinoy kaya flop tuloy yung latest song releases nila. Ang ganda na ng Pantropiko eh, sana gumawa pa sila ng ganung klaseng kanta.", "They will. Don't worry, may tagalog EP pa sila to be released this year. Tiniming lang nila itong english EP release for their world tour."]}
{"dialog": ["I wonder bakit hindi pasok sila Chapell Roan and Sabrina. \n\nBeen listening to them everyday since early last year. Kala ko sikat sila.", "Sikat naman sila but it's been a while since they released their last singles"]}
{"dialog": ["As far as know magka churchmate sila. Madami sila jan probably sinusuport nila yung ka churchmate nila. Tsaka na tayo mag assume kapag nakitang solo mga yan.", "Christian (born again) si Aiah?", "Yes. She volunteers in church kahit sobrang busy sched nila.", "I see. If I remember correctly kasi, yung kuya niya ay kinasal sa Catholic church so that confused me at first lol", "Parang ganon na rin siguro? Kuya ko sa simbahang katoliko kinasal dahil sa sister in law ko. Pero pagkatapos non, sa simbahan ng kuya ko na sila regularly nagsisimba.", "Ganyan din family namin. My dad was Catholic and never nagpa convert as born-again Christian when he was still alive. He sometimes attend Davor Church with us but most of the time he attends Catholic mass. Sabi nila sa amin ng Nanay ko, as long as we do good, and serve God - religion does not matter and i strongly agree with that. Tao lang naman talaga nagpapagulo lagi sa lahat."]}
{"dialog": ["Tapos si Joshua G creepily mass liking her pics (without following) sa gedli lol", "Di ko talaga magets hype kay JG. Ang creepy ng vibe nya tas ggss pa, cheater din.", "Okay naman siya as an actor, patunay na nananalo siya ng mga awards. Ang ayaw ko lang talaga sa kanya ay ang pagiging chickboy niya. Buti nabibigyan pa siya ng mga commercials sa pinaggagagawa niya eh.", "PBB days palang big deal sakanya virginity. Dba nabastos si Jane nun kasi tinanong niya if virgin pa. Magaling siya umarte, no doubt.\n\nKala ko nagbago na yan. Grabe gumanda kasi image niya from tamad, bastos at mayabang na hm sa PBB to the next JLC.\n\nTapos makikita mo yung mga ginagawang cheating na hndi pinapakita ng media. Pati sa FB walang balita sa kalokohan niya kaya deads na deads yung mga fans na walang kaalam alam.", "tinanong niya talaga yung jane ng ganon? ediba during darna days nila may jowa siya non?", "Oo. Galit na galit si jane non."]}
{"dialog": ["Kachurch mate kasi nila yan, and di lang sya yung nandyan pati yung ibang churchmate nanood din", "Serious question since RC ako, kaunti lang ba members ng church na yan? Ang close naman nila to even hangout.", "Madami kasi activities ang church na to aside from the usual sunday service. Yung mga small groups nila or whatever they call it, may mga outreach sa mga public schools, jails, etc. Alam ko si Caelan takes part in these activities sa mga public schools then si aiah nag volunteer din.", "Oh iba pa yun sa Aiadvocacy niya?", "Not familiar with her aiadvocacy basta this one is done with co-members sa church. May mga small group po kasi yun sa church, depending sa age bracket and each group may kanya silang ginagawa. Baka po yung aiadvocacy, sariling charity project niya talaga yun."]}
{"dialog": ["Diba may kasama sa contract nila yung bawal mag jowa? Or during trainee days lang nila yon?", "Kasama ba sa Bagong contract nila yun ngayon?", "Im not really sure. Pero sa busy ng sched nila, I am surprised kung may time pa magka jowa mga yan. But Aiah na yan eh. Galing mag time management"]}
{"dialog": ["Nanood lang ng basketball game.", "Jan din nagsimula si Kris-James, Andrea-Ricci"]}
{"dialog": ["Bakit parang nagseselos ako? HAHAHAHHAH", "Support kita dyan char"]}
{"dialog": ["Aba mahilig sa atleta", "Arceta mahilig sa atleta ? Pucha pang tabloid hahahahaha  wag nyo inaano Bebe ko"]}
{"dialog": ["Ang mahal nung mini album - unless may inclusions like photo book, cards, some other exclusive merch? I think ito talaga yung di makatarungan eh \n\nabout posters and enamel pins - they could go cheaper kasi mass produced and local naman... pero ganyan pricing ng anime/game merch kasi so di na ko nagugulat", "Kahit included pa pb, pc and other merch, sobrang mahal parin ng 2k for a mini album.", "Nakalagay sa pic sa baba may kasama na 100-page photo book + other stuff. Could still go lower no? Mga around 1 - 1.5k? Parang mahal ang photo books kung separate?", "Mahal parin. Sa mga kpop albums, may kasama din na photobook mga mini albums nila pero never umabot ng 1k. At hindi din separate ang price ng poster. Freebie sya kapag bumili ka ng album."]}
{"dialog": ["I just found out na 1k less lang pala album ng blackpink?", "Yup. Mini albums usually range from 599-899 while ful album naman usually nasa 650-1k (depends sa versions) with poster as freebies."]}
{"dialog": ["kung ang style ng BINI sa lightstick during concert is parang sa kpop, controlled po talaga yo. para mag sysync lahat sa kanta, ganern. saka doon na lalaman kung fake ba yung na biling LS (base sa kpop con experience namin HAHAHAHAHAHA)", "I mean yung wave po ng lightstick controlado yung wave.", "yung manufacturer ng bini lighstick, ay ayun din yung gumagawa ng light stick para sa KPOP, Normal naman yun sa mga KPOP concert, may main controller talaga para magsync lahat ng light stick. Para narin mabilis gawin yung wave, hirap nun kapag walang main controller.", "Pero sa Kpop fans ang gumagalaw dun sa wave sa Bini ay controlled.", "may wave effect kasi yung sa BINI and mahirap gawin yun kung mano-mano and malaki chance na hindi lhat magsi-sync. Kung napanood mo yung video, pawave namin ginalaw yung light stick."]}
{"dialog": ["Last major concert ng SB19 was October 2024? Since then, ginamit na mga songs nila as OST sa Breadwinner, Green Bones, Incognito. May pa naman concert, sana mag-release pa sila ng more quality songs. Naging fan ako lately ni Stell after niya mag-host sa Showtime and Pablo dahil musical genius siya.", "Sa Feb 28* sb19 will drop a single. On April 25 naman, EP yung iddrop nila :) These are all for their upcoming May con.", "Feb 28 po ang single and april 25 yung EP hehe", "Wow anyare sakin kanina HAHHAHAHA thank youuu"]}
{"dialog": ["re: inserted timescreen for love team, yan lang talaga siguro mahirap if they belong to a company na maraming need i-promote.  then again, i don't remember yg or any other companies na may actors/actresses doing that in their group's concerts. built different lang siguro ang abs-cbn. \n\ntapos yung problematic kpop artist..... wew, sana hindi maging reason para masira momentum nila. eaj is very controversial talaga. i wonder if their team did some background checking on him before approving that collab.", "Haven't looked him up since the jamie incident :/ may bago ba siyang issues?"]}
{"dialog": ["Lets give it to BINI. Not nepo babies, not tisay, not management favorites (when they were starting). Just pure hardwork, determination, luck.\n\nSabi nga nila, if you want something, you need to be **specific** kasi nakikinig lang ang higher-up sa manifestation mo", "Goosebumps kung mapapanood ng mga tao dito yung mga manifestations nila dati. Hindi talaga sila favorite ng ABS-CBN bosses pero look at them now.", "oo nga parang na-observe ko mas pinupush nila ang BGYO"]}
{"dialog": ["Goosebumps! Ito yung mga sumikat na pinaghirapan talaga. Some people think biglaan kasi 2024 nag boom sila talaga pero if they only see their old videos nag leafleting pa yung girls sa Baguio at humihiram ng damit sa wife ni Coach dati. Theyre reaping what they sowed!", "I suggest to watch Born to Win, their documentary,  because mapapamahal ka talaga sa kanila. I think it's in iWantTFC if you haven't seen it."]}
{"dialog": ["Kahit din yung global appeal ng kpop ay nasa paggamit ng Korean sa song nila. Kung tagalog ito will resonate more sa mga Pinoy listener sa Diaspora. Mas mabilis yung global connection nito sa ibang listener.", "Dito ka naman bibilib sa K-popthey take pride in speaking Korean, even if it's awkward. I've noticed that artists dont really care about not being fluent. Its only recently that they fully adapted to the international market and started pushing for English versions of their songs\n\nBut they all started by catering to their rootssomething BINI lacks. Why not invest in another album instead of just releasing this one song", "Ate have you listened to K-pop lately? Halos ganto na rin sila ngayon eh hahahaha", "nag full English ba? well pag full English target nila ang western pero mostly sa mga kanta nila ay naka stick parin sa Korean lyrics. kagaya ng TWICE pag may kanta silang full English means target nila ang western market pero bumabalik parin sila sa Korean lyrics.  ang k-pop naman kasi mas sumikat kahit na halos Korean lyrics yung mga kanta bago Sila nag penetrate sa western market.", "A majority of k-pop's 4th-5th gen halos 60-40 na ang Korean and English eh. I love NewJeans ha pero yung mga comebacks nila from OMG to Supernatural talagang 50-50 na ang english and korean eh.", "well in the first place never naman nila ni label na sila ay very k-pop or a international/global group just a Korean pop kumbaga. hindi nila sinusunod yung usual na k-popish sound. sa una pa lang ng nag debut sila korean-english na lyrics ng mga kanta nila. pero kita mo pumatok Sila. tsaka lang nag penetrate sa western market ang k-pop nong naging super popular na ang k-pop. yung mga bagohang k-pop na nag debut naging strategy na nila na mas damihan ang English lyrics. pero marami parin naman na halos Korean yung lyrics.", "I get what you're trying to say and in relation siya sa BINI, ang point ko lang naman is ang latest k-pop trends talaga medyo leaning na rin sila sa pagiging westernized. I agree naman na if BINI really wanted to penetrate yung western market they should at least focus sa local muna.", "yun na nga taglish yung mga lumang kanta nila na nag umpisa at pumatok. kung nagiging malawak na yung popularity tsaka Sila mag penetrate sa western market kaya masyado pang maaga. so far dalawang group lang yung mas Kilala bini at sb19 pero kung pag uusapan ang p-pop malayo pa talaga. ang k-pop kasi nakaalalay ang gobyerno nila sa pagtagayud ng industriya nila."]}
{"dialog": ["Dapat nagstick nalang sila sa title track tagalog/taglish songs tapos kahit bside nalang yung mga english songs. Magtetrending parin naman yan kung ipeperform nila and maganda talaga (ex. Kiss of Life bside songs). Sana ginaya nila formula ng sb19, na hanggang ngayon nagrerelease ng tagalog songs and love globally. Mas magaganda pa naman beat and lyrics ng tagalog songs nila", "correct. kaya lang yong management kc eh. tsk tsk", "Downfall talaga yan ng Bini. Saka ang attainable nila, lahat ng event nandon. Good for them kasi dami nilang projects pero downside, pagod na nga sila, nakakaumay pa. As a long time kpop fan, iba yung thrill kapag di mo madalas makita in person yung groups na bet mo eh. I know international sila pero sana may pamiss factor naman ang BINI. Kakaconcert lang eh, may aurora fest naman. Hahahaha. Oh baka ako lang to", "Which is buti na lang ganyan ginagawa ng SB19. Nagpeprepare sila sa SAW. Kaya lang sa March, kasama yata sila sa Bench. Haha", "Keri lang yung paminsan minsan may event, wag naman lahat ng event nandon. Hahahah. Pero yan gusto ng management, kung saan kikita."]}
{"dialog": ["I started as a casual listener and it was because of the catchy Tagalog songs that made me a fan. Maganda naman yung Cherry on Top kahit pure English but yung Pantropiko, Salamin Salamin talaga clearly defined their niche. \n\nSobrang overpopulated na ng Global music scene and Im not saying Bini is not capable but better to build muna talaga stronger base.\n\nAlso Dyogi, wag masyado i-over expose ang Bini please para kasing umay masyado sa casual listeners yung sunod2 na photocards by brands. Hehe just my two cents", "Cinompare ko songwriters and producers ng cherry on top/blink twice versus sa mga old songs nila that we really love (karera/lagi/pantropiko/salamin etc), and mas dekalidad talaga yung gawang pinoy. Hindi ko lang magets at nagpapaka try hard sila ngayon sa pag ingles ingles na ganyan eh booming ngayon ang PPOP artists sa industry (like maki, adie, dionela, cup of joe etc) na gumagamit naman ng filipino lyrics.", "Nagustuhan ko yung 4 songs na yun at relate sa karera. Sana mahanap nila yung sound and songs nila. Parang Sarah G na nagevolve mula sa cover songs hanggang nahanap na nya own style or sound niya. Ganun din SB19 na own songs na rin ar nahanap ang sound. Siguro exploring pa rin ang Bini. Pero ganda na nung 4 songs na yan. Sana masundan pa.", "Agree! If apple to apple comparison, SB19 established themselves muna sa PPOP and Tagalog songs before penetrating the Global scene. \n\nAng nangyayari kasi now na nag branch out agad Bini into english songs & international music scene, nacocompare sila agad sa ibanh groups example, yung Cherry on Top nacompare sa NewJeans since magkatunog."]}
{"dialog": ["masyadong Twice coded na ang bini. (feeling nayeon si maloi. sorry not sorry) nawawala na yung pagiging pang-masa nila. di ako hater, yun lang napapansin ko", "Lakas maka Talk That Talk nung MV haha", "or the scientist din!", "Teaser pa lang eto agad na-notice ko"]}
{"dialog": ["Actually really good. I like it!!", "Bakit ka downvoted?", "HAHAHAHA di ko rin alam", "ang funny"]}
{"dialog": ["As a casual listener ng bini sana nga nag stick muna sila sa taglish lyrics. Hindi yung rekta mala Twice kagad na full English lyrics yung nirerelease. \n\nSa akin lang naman to ha, sana walang magagalit pero the management is taking too much \"inspiration\" sa Twice, which sometimes makes me cringe. \n\nMay sarili tayong brand ng Ppop, why not stick there muna?", "this!\n\nmedyo same vibes yung concept neto tsaka scientist tapos yung salamin-salamin sa the feels. solid sana bini kung bibigyan sila ng mas local and relatable concept", "Same. Una kong naisip yung scientist ng twice nang makita ko itong blink twice"]}
{"dialog": ["ang ganda ng visuals kaso yung song hindi ganon ka catchy??? parang mas hanap ko padin sa kanila ang tagalog songs nila, I hope mag release sila ng ganon this summer", "As far as I can remember, they were also planning to release another Tagalog song. But sana maging maganda and catchy tulad ng Pantropiko at Salamin, Salamin. I'm a Bloom but I'm not very satisfied with Blink Twice. Maganda siya kaso mas bet ko pa ang Cherry On Top nila kung English songs lang nila ang pag-uusapan. Nakulangan rin ako eh, ang iksi kasi for me.", "I found my people. Agree ako sayo. Di masyadong catchy ang BT unlike sa COT. Unang ko palang napakinggan yung COT, nagustuhan ko na agad. Yung BT, wip pa para magustuhan ko playing it nang paulit ulit hahaha"]}
{"dialog": ["sorry pero i dont think this group will go far pag ABS (o big network) ang nasa likod nila. mga big management ang vision nyan ay mgkapera. sa tagal na nilang leader sa industry di man lang nila ginapang ang ppop. kasi pera lang gusto ng mga yan. nakikiride sa momentum. BINI will suffer from over commercialization, lack of creative control and burnout.", "at yan ang pagkakaiba ng SB19 sa kanila. Maliit man sila na company/self-managed pero nakafocus sila sa pagboom ng ppop sa Philippines. Talagang ini-introduce nila ang Ppop worldwide kahit alam nilang may mas sisikat or magiging kilala pa sa kanila. Big companies like ABS, they only focus to make money. Ang Alamat nga, ang ganda ng Maharani nila, by the way. haha", "SB19 is on a different league with their music/lyrics, live performances, work ethic. they are waaay up there. they started with very low budget but they never were sloppy."]}
{"dialog": ["as a casual listener.. if ang long-term goal nila ay longevity sa music industry.. sana nag-establish muna sila ng core fans at career nila dito bago sila magbranch out internationally.. build their discography.. release albums - be it an EP or full album - pero sa nangyayari ngayon.. parang hindi ata longevity goal ng management nila..", "ang goal ay pera tapos magtataka pag nag flop tapos ang solution ay gumawa ng bagong group", "sad lang talaga kung ganun ang mangyayari.. laki pa naman ng potential nila.. tsaka nagulat ako na may follow up concert na agad sila after nung last November.. akala ko kasi magstart na sila ng world tour nila.. hayyy"]}
{"dialog": ["panget panget haha sorry\n\ngaya ng cherry on top, parang cramming pagkagawa. balik sana sila sa FlipMusic kasi ang ganda ng tagalog songs nila.\n\nhuwag sana silang magmadali,bts nga andaming korean songs, tapos korean with mixed english bago maging full english songs. mahirap mag penetrate sa international na hilaw pa", "Nakita ko yung FlipMusic they produced Alas Dose by Calista!! Bagong kanta ng ppop girl group din. Ganung tunog sana yung gusto ko for BINI's songs  huhu kahit naman tagalog nakakakuha ng attention sa ibang bansa, sa dami ng Pinoy abroad narinig ko nanyung Pantropiko dito sa US. With this song, katunog lang din ng mga English songs dito, hindi masyadong stand out. Sana may makapansin pa rin sa kanila globally with all the international people behind this song.", "Actually rooting for Calista from this song alone. Ang ganda!"]}
{"dialog": ["THE LYRICS", "I heard you like confidence\nWell, Ive got a lot of it (fast forward to) \nHes not even thinkin bout me\nMaybe hes just lookin at me\n\nGirlie, wheres the confidence? \nAno ba talaga.", "Wahahaha true"]}
{"dialog": ["This is not my taste. I liked them because of Pantropiko, Salamin Salamin, and Karera. Those songs pushed me to listen to them. I dont know why they are moving away from their roots. Tagalog x English is their signature stylethey should stick to that, hayst. But who am I to tell them what to do, haha.  \n\nI listen to different artists and have been to various concerts, but with BINI I just want them to make English-Tagalog songs in that fun, pop-ish way for Filipinos. Not like thisanother song that sounds like any other pop song with no kaboom factor", "pero marami pa rin namang tumatangkilik sa kanila kasi napuno nga nila ng PH Arena. Baka iilan lang kayo or i sama ko na sarili ko (kahit nagbabasa lang naman ako ng comment) may concern sa kantang nirelease nila recently. Basta sa mga casuals, catchy ang song ay ok na. Lalo na pag idol mo pa ang Bini, ay talagang mapipilitan kang makinig sa mga kanta nila. Haha. Then eventually, masasabi mo na \"ay maganda pala.\" haha. Parang ganun lang ako sa SB19, whoah, I just love those guys.", "Yes, definitely, they can pull people, that is their charm. What pulled me in was their Taglish songs. I love them, and they made me feel alive and got me out of a rut last year. It was fun!  \n\nThis is why I went to their concert despite some people in my circle saying gatas na gatas sila and that their previous concert was just meh and might not be to my taste. They can definitely fill the Philippine Arena\n\nPersonally, I dont like their new songs because theyre fully in English. The fun Taglish songs I enjoyed are no longer there. Ganun lang talaga may mga artists na di ka magugustuhan ang mga release"]}
{"dialog": ["sobrang pagod na ko kakaexplain dito pero sige. if you guys dont know yet both separate tagalog at english ep ang ginagawa ng girls na irerelease ngayung year.\n\nAng rollout nila sa albums (ex, talaarawan) is at least three mvs and for the last mv ilalabas na yung ep. then after that next era na. theyll\ncome back to tagalog songs naman we just have to wait. personally mas gusto ko tong blink twice than some of their tagalog songs", "Thanks for the info! So, this is more of a B-side than a main track?", "most probably yes since ang main track ng talaarawan ay salamin which is the third andlast mv of the talaarawan album. ; di pa nila nirerelease yung song na ginawa ng bts producers"]}
{"dialog": ["Actually disappointed that Bini is becoming Westernized. Kaya nga sila nations girl group, sila ang nagrerepresenta saaten. Pero Ingles yung kanta. \n\nIt makes the group (the image) lowkey feel distant because then yung kanta ay hindi na para sa mga Pinoy, but for global marketing. Hayssss", "This. Pwd pa din naman sumikat kahit ndi English. Mga kpop nga kahit full Korean songs sumisikat pa din naman"]}
{"dialog": ["Super generic yung song. Dapat magstick na lang sila sa tagalog, dun ang appeal nila", "H&M shopping background music ang datingan"]}
{"dialog": ["Akala ko ba buhay ay di karera bakit parang madaling madali sila mag global at mag concert ulit?", "Baka raw kasi biglang malaos e. Kaso sa ginagawa nilang ganyan lalong magiging mabilis pagka-umay ng tao sa kanila."]}
{"dialog": ["Why does it sound like Motivation by Normani?\n\nBlink Twice is too western pandering and quite honestly, mediocre.", "Ako naman im hearing Baby its you by Jojo"]}
{"dialog": ["is BINI washed already? this song sucks", "Nah its my fav song from them"]}
{"dialog": ["Is it intentional Blink blackpink tpos twice?", "I guess that is the intent"]}
{"dialog": ["Pang B side lang to e", "Ahahaha sumakit likod ko sa comment na to hahahaha"]}
{"dialog": ["Wag mo sila i-criticize. Aawayin ka ng leader nila sa Twitter.  They have this habit na they attack fans for being concerned for them kahit na sa management yung rant ng blooms. Hahaha", "hahahhha"]}
{"dialog": ["mas bet ko tagalog songs nila tbh", "True, sana balik muna sila sa Tagalog songs, yun yung hits nila eh."]}
{"dialog": ["Just watched the MV bc of this thread. Sobrang meh.  Maganda sila, yes. Magaling sumayaw, yes. But the song please. Hay. Idk if appropriate comparison pero personally nakukumpara ko kasi talaga sila SB 19  as P-pop royalties. Yun lungs", "As an ATIN, iba po kasi sila ng genre at niche as a group kaya medyo off po na icompare sila. In KPOP terms, parang pinagcocompare yung concept at lore ng Stray Kids sa New Jeans. Not saying same ng level sa popularity or what, but like the difference ng concept is evident in that spectrum. Kanya kanyang target market lang po talaga."]}
{"dialog": ["Di ko maintindihan why they cant just go back to what made them famous: Salamin Salamin and Pantropiko vibes. Ride that hype out sana before trying to enter the global scene. Ang pangit nitong release na to, same sa Cherry on Top. Sobrang disappointing.", "Wala lang, para masabi ng mga fans na sila ang #1 Ppop group from Philippines kaya idominate na nila worldwide, masabi lang na globally known."]}
{"dialog": ["are you from ABS OP? galing din ng pr nyo no. Dito talaga sa chikaph nag post eh sa dinami dami ba nman ng haters ng bini dito eh pupunuin talaga ng engagement. Tignan mo yung thread andaming haters. On the flipside its getting so much views right now at 600k in only 3 hours sa tulong lng din ng mga haters", "wow, thats a compliment para ma-consider mo akong PR. Sana nga kunin ako ng ABS para naman may sweldo ako lol"]}
{"dialog": ["Sana mag stick muna sila doon  . \n\nSana stick na lang tayo sa tsismisan, no? Imbes magbigay ng unqualified opinions, di naman tayo ang nag hahawak ng karera nila at wala naman tayong track record sa pag handle ng talent", "E kung yung Chika Minute nga ng GMA nagbabalita ng entertainment news tapos dito sa Chika PH sub hindi pwede pag-usapan ang entertainment songs? Logic where?"]}
{"dialog": ["Teh, walang may issue sa BINI na gumagawa ng English songs. Ang point lang, mas okay sana kung hindi sunod-sunod na entirely English yung main tracks nila kung gusto nilang i-maintain yung peak nila with casual listeners. Walang nagba-bash sa girlsits a call-out sa management.\n\nAlso, si Dionela talaga ginawang example sa lyricism?  ROFL. Pangalawa, anong nagbago sa tunog ni Moira? Kaya nga di na siya nagkakaroon ng hit song kasi pare-pareho lang. Pangatlo, underrated naman talaga ang tawag sa artist na di sikat???? its literally a compliment, wishing they got better recognition. Lastly, kung feel mo na okay yung ginagawa ng management sa BINI, edi go, continue adoring them blindly.", "delete comment si tanga lol"]}
{"dialog": ["* Melody: 0.5/10\n* Lyrics: 1/10\n* Vocals: 6/10\n* Shock Value: 0.2/10\n* International Appeal: 0.5/10\n* Originality/Artistry/Difficulty: 0.2/10\n\nProduction Value: 350 pesos pang meryenda + studio rental 1.5k\n\nIntellectual Property Value: BEH KAW PA BA... K NA YUN SISSUMS \n\nRemarks: ok na rin kesa zero. \"dont be lazy\" daw sabi sa lyrics pero ika nga ni great fiipino poet/lyricist anabelle rama: \"KITANG KITA NIYO NAMAN.. DI KO NA KAILANGAN SABIHIN...\"", "Couldn't agree more. Nagsayang ng girl group tong si Dyogi. Ang cool ng lyrics and concepts sa Salamin Salamin tsaka Karera eh. Lyrics nila now walang sense mala \"boy i like u. do u like me?? im a cool girl yeah slayy yeah\"", "Ang bait ko na sa ratings ko. Gusto ko sana isagad honesty ko: north pole temperature levels talaga deserve nito pero... huhunting na ba ko ni dyogi kung ganun? \n\nYup karera is their best out of what they have", "True. Buti nga may 1 sa lyrics  hindi naman boy crazy yang walo, ginawan nila ng ganyang cringe lyrics.\n\nSi Dyogi nalang huntingin  Panget ng prinoduce nila this comeback. Para naman bigyan niya ng matinong kanta BINI.", "Bloom po ba kayo? Im a nomad music lover.. anything basta well done.. support ko .\n\nMy question is, has dyogi tried to consult/outsource music production for the girls, or in house lng forevs? I hve seen this coming kasi...  in my knowledge, min. 6mos or 1yr at least ang production ng single. If we wish to attain quality. \n\nThey did it with bgyo's  \"trash\" tama? Staffers were foreign.. reception was a flop pero i admire the effort. Maganda yun track. Sana may ganun din effort for girls. Foreign ba staffers ng cherry on top?\n\nIm well aware girls were busy in shows, endorsements and such since their boom.", "Composed by: Amanda Ratchford, Pacific-Joshua Zagabe, Pontus Kalm (Oneye), Marqueze Parker, Steven Franks (Mr. Franks), Darius Coleman Produced by: Oneye, Leather Jacket, Mr. Franks, Glitch Choreography by: Reden Blanquera, Matthew Almodovar & Mickey Perz, Directed by: Kerbs Balagtas  \n\nLooks like Western po ang composers and producers. Dance choreo and MV director are Filipino. If I recall correctly, Mr. Franks has collaborated with Ariana Grande, BlackpinkxSelena Gomez, Twice etc.", "I see thank you. Sounds like a good team. But to my ears, di ko din gusto cherry on top.. 4.5/10 overall \n\nWish they get an international big hit soon.. and albums pls, sana they make more music."]}
{"dialog": ["maganda pero hindi ito yung formula ng music na nagpasikat sa kanila.  \nkung gagawa sila ng single, dapat bop, pop, and catchy ang lyrics and music. for me bagay lang ito as side track sa album, just to give depth sa kanilang artistry.  \ndapat yung lyrics simple lang pero catchy, eto medyo di mo rinig ng maayos ang lyrics, tapos medyo wordy pa.\n\nSame vibes sya sa Moonlight (SB19) for me, I can feel na pinilit lang ng SB19 ang song to try to capture a global audience by singing in English. Pero at least mas catchy ang tune at lyrics ng Moonlight kesa sa Blink Twice at COT", "Tbf I wasnt a fan of Moonlight at first din, but it really grew on me. Its a well-made song.\n\nReady (by SB19), on the other hand", "We dont talk about Ready here  that song didnt sound like them at all", "HAHAHHAAHA the song that everyone I know just kind of forgot. About a month after it was released"]}
{"dialog": ["Sobrang flawless ng discography nila, cant believe na may one skip na ako songs nila. Di ko talaga bet, kahit ilang beses ko sya pinapakinggan today.", "Bat ka dinadownvote??? Downgrade naman talaga tong Blink Twice. Imagine galing sa meaningful songs like Karera tsaka yung concept ng Salamin Salamin about asking magic mirror, biglang mema tong new song.\n\nKaya nga nagbibigay ng criticism para ayus-ayusin ng management buhay nila.", "Even bini themselves attack every one, even fans, na may criticisms sa kanila and management, no matter how constructive it is. The fans are even worse.", "Not surprised  maya't maya sila may gulo. Either may ginigyera yung fandom or may pinapatulan yung Bini mismo kahit fan, basher, o clout-chasing content creator sa X.\n\nSa contract signing, obvious na affected na affected nung may nag breakdown. I hope they stop focusing on the hate. Ikakasakit talaga ng mental health at ikakasira ng peace nila talaga yan. Deadma lang. Sila naman \"sana\" yung successful."]}
{"dialog": ["Im getting TWICE vibes here. The Scientist?", "TWICE's Scientist was definitely in their moodboard.", "Sorry medyo naoff ako dun sa massage chair hahaha. I think ang peg nila yung part ni momo na nakaupo sa learning pod pero mas hightech ang dating nun eh"]}
{"dialog": ["Yung lyrics mas walang sense sorry. Gets ko na gusto ni Dyogi mag international sila pero bigyan naman sila ng hustisya sa content ng songs.\n\nEnglish yan. Mas marami makakaintindi. Hindi na umuubra yang \"Yeah boy I'm crazy for you. I slay. Do you like me boy?\" shit concept na yan.\n\nNow, with the recent English comebacks, nothing sets them apart from other pop acts sa ibang bansa also trying to make it global.\n\nHindi nila nakita yung value ng brand na nagpasikat sa kanila and yung Filipino charm ng girls. Mas may chance pa sila to go international if they carried on with their local songs.", "Agree. Ang mema. Sorry. Mema release, mema English song.  Walang sense, ang lamya.\n\nYung lyrics, walang substance. Gandang hangin lang eh.", "Yun pala yung term na hanap ko nung unang dinig ko sa lyrics: walang substance :((("]}

{"dialog": ["blink twice is kinda meh. they need to reheat their pantropiko and salamin salamin nachos.", "Karera and Lagi is also good. I was hoping na Tagalog song yung bago since magaganda yung mga Tagalog songs nila. This one is kinda bland. Parang twice yung datingan ng mv."]}

{"dialog": ["Im a fan of Bini pero damn sana tagalog nalang ulit ilabas nilang bagong kanta.\n\nOk sana kahit english basta maganda yung sounds at lyrics pero this one is kinda meh.\n\nEdit: add ko lang, mas maganda pa yung kanta nila sa coke na Blooming.", "True! I love blooming hehehee and i miss their taglish songs\n\nnagmamadali sila na sumabak ang mga gurlies globally  parang tuloy yung outputs nila parang minadali\n\nEdit: parang half-baked, mema post lamang sila"]}

{"dialog": ["It's okay. Cherry On Top is better imo. I really hope mag-release ulit sila soon ng Filipino song kasi dun talaga sila minahal ng mga tao.", "Cherry on Top(I don't like it as much as their other songs) feels alive at least. Blink Twice is cute but kinda sounds so empty and dull. Parang may kulang. It would be a good filler track but not as a single lol\n\nI'm rooting for them but this was disappointing"]}

{"dialog": ["Music video looks eerily similar to Twice's Scientist", "Oo nga eto din yung nasa isip ko kanina pinanuod ko tuloy ulit yung scientist"]}

{"dialog": ["In a normal pop group timeline, this wouldve been their comeback. Comebacks are usually more impactful, more upbeat and strategic in converting new people into the fandom. I wouldve preferred this song to be the follow-up to a more pasabog na comeback single.", "In terms of comeback, Im waiting for SB19 comeback EP next 2 weeks to see if they will deliver justice to hiatus."]}

{"dialog": ["Pinoy fans pa din ang naghahype ng songs nila, kaya napapansin ng ibang lahi, kaya sana mag release na ulit sila ng Tagalog songs, kahit may part na lang na english, gandang ganda kaya mga International audience sa tunog ng tagalog na dialect.", "Ang pagkakatanda ko they are planning to release another Tagalog song as well. But I'm hoping na maganda and very catchy tulad ng Pantropiko and Salamin, Salamin cause even if I'm a Bloom, I'm not very satisfied with Blink Twice. Maganda naman siya kaso mas bet ko pa rin yung Cherry On Top kung mga English songs lang nila ang pag-uusapan."]}

{"dialog": ["Parang medyo similar steps sa ibang kanta. Ung pataas taas kamay. Haha", "HUHUHUHU PANSIN KO DIN NGA. Cringe talaga ako noong nakita ko yung steps. Nakakadismaya. Una ko inisip, palitan na sana nila yung style ng choreo nila. Sobrang recycled huhuh"]}

{"dialog": ["The concept reminds me of Girls Generation 2010 era songs like Hoot.", "Totoo."]}

{"dialog": ["Maling sub ka OP. Sa PPop ka dapat mag-post, wala namang chika dyan kung discussion sa mv ang hanap mo. Lowkey hardselling ka ng new release ng fave mo.", "Ay sorry po, pero parang pressed na pressed ka naman sa BINI haha."]}

{"dialog": ["Sino sa kanila ang may potential na mag grow to top artist? Or kahit tumagal na lang sa showbiz", "Si aiah pwd mag artista. Ang ganda tingnan."]}

{"dialog": ["Bakit parang sunud sunod concert nila?", "BINIVERSE THE REPEAT  \nBINIVERSE THE REPEAT REPEAT \n\nBINIVERSE BACK TO SCHOOL REPEAT\n\nBINIVERSE HALLOWEEN REPEAT\n\nBINIVERSE CHRISTMAS REPEAT\n\n  \nhays nakakailang na tuloy maging Blooms balik nama tuloy kpop fan", "Natawa ako  (sorry baka awayin ako ng co-fans) pero main concern ko rin ito nung in-announce yung sa bulacan. Gusto man mag watch pero kasi if repeat lang same sa NFT & Araneta, next time nalang siguro. Ibang artists naman this year.", "went to their araneta concert and nakakabigla somehow kasi in 3 months, another concert\n\nfor me, parang mas okay if mid-year or q2 ang next concert sana nila (like during summer) para naman may more months pagitan pa from recent concert nila. di nga nag-sold out concert nila now sa ph arena eh, kung di rush yunh date and maka-recover (financially) ang mga blooms, for sure soldout din yang ph arena \n\nkasi from 3 nights sold out sa nft, fans were craving like syempre ayon nga sold out siya kaya grabe the urge to save up (like me) sa next concert nila, andon yung rush, yung eagerness, kaya pre-selling palang na-sold out na yung sa araneta. kaso yung ph arena talaga ay", "Agreed! Ako man nadisappoint na may Repeat pa. Like pinromote nila yung yung Araneta as Finale, Grand Biniverse. Tas nung narealize nilang na sold out, parang tinanggalan nila ng value yung sa Araneta. Turns out dipa pala yun yung Grand Finale.  nakaka turn off di consistent yung promotion nila, pinapalitan everytime may opportunity pumera. Tapos yung sa PH arena was supposed to be only Valentines Repeat, pero ginawa nang world tour kineme. Like???? Make up your mind manman. Ano ba talaga. Kaya I skipped kahit na super lapit ko lang sa Bulacan. Better to save money sa other artists this year na may ioffer something new.", "i like their idea rin na valentine's special ang want nila, pero sana 'wag on bigger venue agad, buti sana mura lang tickets eh vip lang maganda sa ph arena huhuhuz, gusto ko rin manood kasi ulit kaso ihhh dami need i-prioritize sa expenses :(( ta's share ko na rin pero 'di ako carat ha, pero yung seventeen na kpop group kahit halos yearly concert, ang laki ng months ng agwat kaya kahit papaano yung mga fans nila nagkakaroon talaga ng sufficient time to save up", "Honestly yun talaga yung nakaka-off eh, yung agwat nung dates. Parang super shameless ng management perahan mga fans, any opportunity na lang. Agree ako sa ibang fans na mas may sense pa last stop ang PH arena for their world tour, not the start. You wont see any asian act/western act na ganito yung roadmap\n\nNormal formula would be: album/ep release > promotion of album > tour dates announcement > months and months of promoting, tv guestings etc tas add dates and cities nalang along the way (pero same tour/content pa rin)\n\nAng nangyayare kasi sa biniverse, same concert, same songs, but sobrang daming variations. As someone who went to the NFT version, they made it sound like Grand Biniverse sa Araneta will be the finale, like theyre gonna end it with a bang. And super ganda naman talaga. Kaso na sold out 3 days, so gumawa ng another variation para ma push yung Bulacan. Apparently kulang yata yung rehearsal time nila since mahaba vacation nila (not updated as I detached myself ...", "parang sa normal na tao lang, may times na kapag everytime mo nakikita yung tao parang sanay ko na or worse nakakasawa, nawawala yung essence kasi na ay magse-save up ako big time just to see them. lalo na yung sunod-sunod din sa photocards jusko, wala manlang 1 month pagitan yung sa puregold, enervon, super crunch, tapos angel ata. actually parang na-fatigue ako sa bini. i love them. pero kalma muna hahahahaha. di manlang magpa-miss din sa fans para pasabog and inaabangan talaga ang comeback to release new songs.\n\nadditional: mindset ng bebe ko na why hindi kami nag-vip sa araneta kasi local artists lang sila (not degrading in any way) and possible na makita naman sila kahit saan. mas okay pang mag-vip or high tiers sa mga international artists para sulit talaga kasi yun masasabi mong either once in a lifetime. tapos ayon nga, may concert ulit sila.\n\ntapos yung lightstick na kesyo nung una ayaw magpa-ship ganito ganyan then ilalagay lang din online tas kung may vouchers and coins ka e..."]}

{"dialog": ["In fairness, this the same shit you'll see in KPop fandoms.\n\nThe difference is, the group's members never intervened.", "Eto pansin ko sa bini. Lagi sila ang nagrerespond sa criticisms sa kanila. Its not good PR for them kasi mukha silang mga patola. Management should montior their social media accts. Or at least PR train them para hindi nagkakalat.", "I agree tbh, actually prang fko na mas strict ang PR training ng mga filo celebs dati compared ngayon", "Iba kasi ang pag handle ni Dyogi sa Star Magic. Ibang iba sa panahon ni Mr M. Ang problema kasi kay Mr M outdated na ways nya pero aminin natin prime era ng  and 2000s and 2010s.!", "No lies detected!"]}

{"dialog": ["Need nila ng comeback hit or else..", "They need another Tagalog/Taglish song like Pantropiko, Salamin 2x, and Karera o kaya like their 2022 songs I Feel Good or Lagi.", "True. Masyado sila nag madali hitting the international stage with them releasing full english songs. Cherry on top caused a steep decline on their market after them releasing sure-hits like pantropiko and salamin salamin. Im not sure how blink twice will perform and if its not as good as pantropiko/salamin, consider Bini is on their way to their flop era  ayaw kasi makinig.", "This is very true. Heck, even a bisaya song from Colet or Aiah could be better. Matagal nang sinasabi ng fans na magstick nalang sa tagalog songs, ayaw makinig ng management. Feeling YG or Hybe si Dyogi.", "BANG PD AMPEG"]}

{"dialog": ["Naloka ako kasi may casual fan ng BINI na nag-voice out lang ng opinion niya about the issue tapos binarda na. May pa-check pa sila kung Bloom daw ever since tapos nung pinakitaan na top artist niya sa Spotify ang BINI, hindi daw yun counted. HAHAAHAHAHA", "True  Patola kasi ang mga pota. Pwede namang pabayaan na lang yung tweet ng common citizen. Eh rushed naman talaga yang concert nila ni wala pang bagong hit. Panay Bini Run pa sila. Ilang beses na sila nakikita.", "ABSCBN din ba yung fun run nila?", "Unsure if sino ang main organizer pero for sure signed off ni ABS yun."]}

{"dialog": ["ngl i agree with op that the ph arena con is a mistake (na offend siguro si jho sa word na mistake pero totoo naman) - business wise, mistake tlga ang step ng abs cbn to go have a con in ph arena for a repeat concert 3 months after the 3 day sold out con for almost the same show using a very inconvenient venue pa.\n\ndid they really expect that 45k people who attended the last con will want to see the same show? eh napaka layo ng venue and napaka pangit ng ph arena tlga due to their lack of facilities for waiting area and stuff. sure a lot of people would like to see bini live, they're popular with the locals and the masses. there are a lot of people din who didn't get the chance to watch them during the 3 day con but not to the point that it will fill up the 55k seats and to lengths of willing to spend so much for their con ticks and handle the hanash of ph arena. kaya mostly tlga die hard fans lang ang napunta sa ph arena for an artist con dahil sobrang stressful tlga ng venu...", "well, they sold out that 55k capacity arena + 210k online viewers on iwant so i guess it's not so much of a mistake on a business standpoint \n\nedit: it's not 210k but 261k :)", "yes and it took a while. sa mismong day of the con na na-sold out and if blooms didn't made the effort to promote, have fan events and giveaways - it wouldn't been possible.\n\nso i stand by my statement, its still a huge mistake for abs to plan the ph arena so early in the year. if it wasn't so rushed, the concert would have been better executed. mas better prod, set list, flow and it would've sold out faster.", "it's just a pet peeve of mine to read statements that sound overly conclusive and certain, like 'damn, can you reserve judgement and let it play out?' lol. some of your assumptions from your first comment were literally proven wrong by the event itself, so let's just agree to disagree. i do agree that they should've amplified the promotion for blink twice. i think it's okay for the philippines to be the last stop of the tour but i don't think it's also necessarily wrong to start it here. i think it's a good decision to kickstart the concert here in ph in a soldout arena as it will generate hype not just here but also abroad because of the bragging rights of being the first group to sold out the blah blah. \n\n\nwhy the downvote tho?  sorry if i come off as snarky"]}

{"dialog": ["Ako talaga i am for the movement na tanggalan ng internet ang Bini. Ang kalat", "YES. It's also for their own good. Kahit sa contract signing, Aiah broke down. While it's good to be real with their emotions, they need to protect their brand.", "Ang qualms ko lang ki aiah why bawasin din pagpost sa insta kung gusto nya magcooldown\n\nAnd wag naman mag vacation sa lugar na malapit sa warzone like egypt pls lang", "Haha I agree dito sa second part. Nakikita ko mga posts nya. Hindi lang sa war zones kundi sa lahat. I understand na gusto nya mag-enjoy at siguro napaka-humble nyang tao. Hindi nya ata na-realize na baka may makakilala sa kanya at dumugin sya abroad. Wala naman ata syang security detail na kasama. Mostly solo trips pa sya."]}

{"dialog": ["Arogante so much. Ikaw na yung dinedefend ng fan from your management, ina-antagonize pa. It's only a matter of time they fade out.", "Wala na silang traction internationally. Sayang, organic pa naman yung nakuha nilang response. Kaso itong management halata na hindi rin equipped enough to handle that level of growing fame. Unang-una Filipino songs nila yung nag viral ng malala pero English song ang ginawang follow-up. Tapos hindi pa na promote ng husto yun kasi push sa tubong lugaw approach yung management. Maganda na yung momentum nung 3-day sold out concert nila, prime chance to release an EP or work on a full-album na talagang map promote nila. The PH Arena concert couldve been pushed two years later or something para by then malaki-laki na rin yung body of work nila.\n\nSaka the first thing they should have done to these girls the moment they blew up eh mag hire ng competent social manager to handle their social media accounts. This is not PBB na laging pumapatol for the sake of relatability at pagpapakatotoo lol. May branding na inaalagaan na and besides, sobrang busy nila na tapos gumaganyan pa. \n\nPwede pa naman ...", "Opportunity na for them na after nung 3-day concert to release an album as a follow through kasi mas magagatasan nila yun for this year, but no, they chose to hold a series of fun runs and another concert 3 months after. Aanhin yon?!? Di man lang nag-isip. Short term strike-while-the-iron-is-hot <<<< longevity", "Bibitawan yan sila pag nakabalik na franchise ng ABS. Balik sila sa long-term artists nila.\n\nMukhang marunongh naman management magpatakam ng tao dati eh. Tamo yung career planning nila sa Kathniel na hindi panay panay ang labas at may sense of exclusivity. They're bleedingg money lang talaga and BINI ang isa (if not main) cash cows nila.\n\nHow sad."]}

{"dialog": ["Concert ng concert eh wala naman bagong song ni release? Enough na ba yong Blink Twice na irerelease a day before their concert? Dont think so. Im a bloom pero I think sobrang pang gagatas talaga yung sunod2 na concert eh. Baka magsasawa lng fans nila kalaunan.", "Mukang di SOLDOUT kahit sa dami ng pagppromote. Dami nga giveaway tickets eh.", "Para mabawasan naman yang anagas nila. Tsaka irethink ng ABS yang panggagatas nila."]}

{"dialog": ["True parang sa mga maling bagay kasi sila naginvest to maintain their momentum (i.e. sunod sunod na concert) Parang naging hayok mgmt (or label?) at pinush ang Bini to gain more fame.", "Personally, hindi ko gusto yung roadmap ng ABS para sa BINI in the sense na kakagaling lang nila sa successful 3-day concert sa Araneta almost 3 months ago. There's no reason for them to do another big concert this soon unless yun ang gagamitin for the world tour expenses.\n\nWhat they needed to sustain momentum is new music, and I don't just mean Blink Twice. On the other hand, you see their endorsements every day, whether sa TV or social media, and I think that would've sufficed kung hindi pa sila ready to drop ng EP/album.\n\nOther OPM/PPop acts are doing the same to keep themselves in public consciousness habang wala pa silang bagong music, getting endorsements as well (e.g. KFC with Juan Karlos, Zack Tabudlo, Adie and KAIA, Greenwich with Maki). Don't forget SB19's endorsements with McDo and Dunkin that kickstarted it. Safe to say, the Philippine music industry has never been this mainstream after some time.", "Yun nga eh parang di maganda na nag naging way nila to stay in the center of the attention of the public is to keep the girls performing kahit na paulit ulit naman na nakita yan ng madla. Like sana nagstick na lang muna sila sa endorsements while cooking smth up as the next big thing for Bini. Eh wala parang natakot sila na kapag hindi sila nagperform, malalaos agad sila."]}

{"dialog": ["To be fair, I saw PULP page (organizer of the event) and the comments of the issues raised was clearly unfair to the fans as well. \nAs much as some of people here defend Bini, super mali ang management.  Halatang rushed and hindi worth it ang money.", "I bought the ticket. I used to listen to them last summer. Im just a casual listener, and those concerns are legit. But assuming it wont be worth the money before the concert? Thats just not how it works. You can say that after the concert if youre not satisfied\n\nMadami talagang issues sa concerts. Ive been to several, not just Pulp, and there are always problems, even with Ovation or Livenation. Napakaraming issues\n\nAng concern ko naman ay kung paano sila mina-manage ng ABS. Napakakalat. Masyadong opinionated sa wala sa lugar, to the point na bumababa na sa level ng fans na gusto lang mag-vent out. This is where K-pop artists hugely differ. The separation is so distinct that fans' clamor and anger are just noises. Pero sa BINI, pumapatol talaga, which can be a double-edged sword"]}

{"dialog": ["\"THOSE\"  girl, the people complaining are also your fans na concerned lang sainyo!\n\nhirap naman maging bini fan. kapag cinallout mo poor decisions at panggagatas ng management sa idols mo ikaw pa masama", "Ang iimature nakakairita. I like them but gosh wala talagang pr training kakaloka"]}

{"dialog": ["di niya na gets yung point.. naoffend agad", "Potala af eh. Ang shunga pa ng pagpatol. Obviously bothered na bothered sila sa hate. Wala namang nagsasabi na hindi nila pinaghirapan o pinagpaguran sa practice yang concert. Sabi lang nung fan ang aga masyado maulit. Offended agad ampota."]}

{"dialog": ["lagi nilang bukambibig yan, na grabe yung pagod at effort nila sa training, rehearsals, events sunod sunod\n\nparang nakakabingi na rin kasi naaappreciate naman ng blooms yun pero hindi naman kailangan laging i bring up parang utang na loob pa ng blooms na working hard kayo\n\njust let your performance speak for itself", "Kala nila sila lang ang napapagod kumayod ng pera, ung Blooms iba sa kanila nag wowork at pinaghihirapan ng husto yung concert nila."]}

{"dialog": ["masyadong parasocial. nag-s-send ng feedback yung fans tapos pine-personal ng members at ibang fans. gurl kung may quality and safety concerns sana ni-redirect nyo sa management nyo, bakit ikaw yung sumasagot dyan??", "This is what i noticed din sa die hard blooms (and now, also sa bini members) na pag merong nag criticize about how they are MANAGED, they take it personally na as if the critiques are attacking the girls themselves  kelan ba papasok sa utak nila na the girl themselves actually, at the very least, are sellable and likeable naman kahit papano and the issues that rational blooms are raising are directed towards the management!!! Kasi common sense naman, lahat ng galaw ng Bini, management ang utak sa lahat ng yan so malamang dapat management ang matamaan sa criticism and mag address niyan"]}

{"dialog": ["Will always stand by my statement na papuntang Swiftie level toxic na yung majority ng Bini fans. Di ka pwedeng mag call out kahit na yung kina call out is yung management or yung merch nila\n\nIve seen other comments naman na polite yung nagtatanong or genuine curiosity lang tapos hostile na agad yung mga fans or even one of the members.", "Understandable na na-insult siguro yung Jhoana, but she took the criticism personally. Mukha ngang hindi naman towards them yung comment, more like sa producers/management.\n\nAlso yung Those, teh fan mo parin naman yan, sinabi lang na hindi naging maganda yung experience niya sa concert. She couldve said that they will make sure na yung susunod na concerts will be better, or ignore nalang. Need nga yata talaga nila ng PR training, not a fan or a hater, pero recurring issue kasi sakanila yung pag clap back sa netizens."]}

{"dialog": ["Pede bang bawasan nila mga featured artist nagmumukhang ASAP na eh", "ASAP BINI version hahahaha. Tapos isang buong segment na puro yung sponsors lang nila. Cute naman kaso parang nanood talaga ako ng ASAP."]}

{"dialog": ["Di ako fan, pero sa nakikita ko, ayaw nila ng critics. Hilig pa pumatol. Dyan kayo babagsak mima", "Totoo. Bothered na bothered sila eh no. Di nila maenjoy yung success. Tingin sila nang tingin sa criticisims sa kanila."]}

{"dialog": ["Their agency should learn from Korean agencies. Let the management handle each members socmed accounts. The more na they have free rein sa mga words nila sa socmed the more they tarnish whatever reputation they have built. Masyado silang patola.", "Real. Hindi ko gets para patulan yung ganyang call out?? I mean gets naman na you should address pero di ba dapat sa group since grupo silang sinasabihan hindi lang naman si bini j?"]}

{"dialog": ["Just a casual listener to bini and ppop in general here, pwede paexplain bakit issue ang PH arena concert nila?", "sunod sunod ba naman concert, kttpos lang 3 day sold out con netong november tapos ng PH arena.\n\ntapus dhl ata yan sa duo performance ng bini members na uulitin lang. kaya nadisaappoint ibang fans"]}

{"dialog": ["Anu ung blooms? Sorry di ako updated. Nakatira ako sa ilalim ng bato . Also, ang toxic naman nyan.", "Fandom name ng BINI"]}

{"dialog": ["Bakit nag eexpect ang blooms na bini will throw star music under the bus? employers nila yun \n\nthey cant just jump ship or be independent. syempre they will defend their employer to their best interest.", "di nila ineexpect yun. pero gusto lang nila ivent out yang mga problems ng management nila kasi pwede namang bini can shut up na lang and let their fans do the ranting or pwede din sila magtweet/react about sa complaints ng fans like assuring them na nabasa nila ung tweets and they will just suggest sa management na lang yung mga sinasabi ng fans."]}

{"dialog": ["Question lang, nag start naba sila mag sell ng tickets sa world tour? Baka kasi di patok yung sales nila.", "Wlaa pa ata. No dates pa rin ata yung world tour"]}

{"dialog": ["ACTIVE NANAMAN MGA OTIN AH??", "Eto nanaman yung baliw. Eto ha if di mo alam.. Click mo yung name ni OP tas may search bar dun.. Type mo SB19. Tignan mo if may lalabas. Lahat ng against sa idols mo pinagbibintangan mo agad na A'TIN. Ganun ka ba katanga?"]}

{"dialog": ["lol damage control", "Thats exactly it. Hindi raw pag-invalidate pero anong tawag sa pag-all caps nung those?"]}

{"dialog": ["Nakasabay ko na once si Alden sa car-free, ang bango niya talaga tignan kahit pawis huhu", "Hindi lang tignan. Kahit amuyin eh  amoy bagong ligo"]}

{"dialog": ["Uyyy... gusto ko yan Alden & Barbie!! Halatang close friends sila kasi ang relax & may pagka wacky pose din siya", "What if yung biggest plot twist pala ay si Alden at Barbie ang nagka gustuhan."]}

{"dialog": ["Confirmed chicken legs ni Paulo Avelino, hindi lang because of camera angle like last time.", "Hindi katangkaran si Paulo and hindi rin mahaba legs niya. If bulky legs niya, he will look short. I assume better tingnan visually especially if hes wearing pants. Huwag lang magpalaki sobra ng upper body, baka maging Johnny Bravo."]}

{"dialog": ["And to all fake news peddler na nagpakalat na may aalis sa BINI.", "It's great that Aiah was the one who delivered this message. Siya rin puntirya niyang fake news na yan eh.", "Oo nga kasi very eloquent siya. Napansin ko isa si Aiah sa may mga pinaka konti yung basher.\n\n\nImagine kung si Colet, Maloi or Gwen yung nag shout out sa mga bashers. This whole sub are surely gonna label them as \"palengkera\" at \"kanal\" just because they aren't the best on expressing their thoughts. Tapos sasabihan pa niyan mag media training akala mo naman talaga hindi ginagawang hobby yung mag basa ng celebrity gossip lol.", "Not Gwen, si Sheena ang natatawag na kanal."]}

{"dialog": ["Not a Bini fan because fan ako ng Kpop medyo matagal na (I'm a guy btw) but nung napanood ko interview nila kay Boy Abunda recently lang, I can say na alam mong edukado yung mga members.\n\nThey can balance the atmosphere of being a public figure and makamasa at the same time.\n\nI love how each one of them mostly said na nakakatulong na sila sa parents nila after becoming a Bini. Nakaka-inspire.\n\nSpecial Mention: ang ganda nga ni Aiah lalo pag tinitigan mo ng matagal tsaka si Mikha.\n\nNakabisado ko agad mga names nila. Magkamukha si Sheena at Jhoanna konti. I find Gwen's beauty parang pang Kdrama lalo kasi short hair sya now.", "Welcome to the portal.", "Wdym? Hahaha"]}

{"dialog": ["Call out your cult too", "mka tawag ng cult pero posting history mo nangangamoy DDS. The irony. Mahiya ka sa buto mo.", "Hahaha DDS pa rin kahit 2025 na. Wala talagang software update para sa mga tanga."]}

{"dialog": ["Taray yung chika na may aalis na sabi ni Ogie \"may source\" daw siyang nag sabi pero yung source niya chika lang sa C at dito sa ChikaPH hahaha ayan tuloy ano kaya ang say ni mama O sa next vlog niya haha\n\nGo Bini!!", "Ilang beses na yang na-call out ng different fandom by spreading fake news. Sa lahat ng sinabi niyang chika ay come from here lang naman.Baka galit siya sa Bini kase hindi nagpa-interview sakanya. Kay Karen Davila kase sila nagpa-interview. Sayang daw clout and views."]}

{"dialog": ["Putan6ina kasi netong mga 'to. 'Wag kayo mang-bash ng mga PPOP idols(except kung homophobic, pedo, bully, drug user etc.) tao lang din mga 'yan at ini-entertain lang tayo. Ang i-bash niyo ay mga DDS, hindi tao mga 'yun at cancer sa Pilipinas.", "Tama! Bash niyo yung kalbo sa senado! Lahat ng panget at masasama sa senado gow!"]}

{"dialog": ["Karamihan sa mga bashers mukhang pusit", "Kaya nga sila nasa Reddit kasi anonymous"]}

{"dialog": ["Taray nashoutout pati bashers. \n\n\n\nDi naman titigil yung mga trolls at bashers pero sana maremind sila na tao rin yung mga pinagsasalitaan nila ng kung anu ano. Gets ko madali mang bash kasi di naman nila maaabot yung level nung binabash. Tapos ganyan pa response sa kanila. Binagsakan na ng umaapaw na negativity, pagmamahal pa rin ang sagot.", "Special mention, na-inggit ako"]}

{"dialog": ["Standout talaga ganda niya compare sa ibang members ng group. Not saying na panget yung iba, magaganda rin sila pero parang average pretty girls lang ganun. Yung tipong pinakamaganda sa section or street niyo, while Aiah is maganda pa rin kahit kanino itabi.", "Sana naman kung magbibigay ng criticism yung constructive. Yung ikakaimprove ng pinagsasabihan.  Yung mga opinion kasi na ganito pwede naman sarilinin na lang.\n\nPwede naman tayong pumuri ng ibang tao na hindi sila ikinocompare sa iba."]}

{"dialog": ["To be fair basura naman talaga music nila  Tapos paulit ulit pa", "To be fair, basura talaga ugali mo"]}

{"dialog": ["Late response pero nag join na ko. Hahahahaha thanks!", "Welcome poooo"]}

{"dialog": ["yan ba yung current gf ng kapatid ni liza na may anak?", "Unrelated sa post ni OP pero parang dinelete ni Liza at brother yung posts tungkol sa baby.", "Wait lang, etong Yana ba yung nanay ng pamangkin ni Liza? Or ibang girl pa yun? Please enlighten this Mosang hahaha", "No, eto yung pinalit sa mother ng 2 kids.", "korek! im one of his exes  serial cheater and addict yan si justin", "OMG ang init ng tea ah haha I wonder what was the reason kung bakit naghiwalay sa recent ex eh dalawa na kids. And the timeline is kinda"]}

{"dialog": ["Iha i think aware ka sa tanggalan...andun na nga ung c Jelay from Pbb...d rin nakapasok. naku for the clout.", "Si angela din from pbb otso batch 3 ligwak", "alam mo magegets ko ung sentiments ng batang to kung di sila aware sa tanggalan..kaso alam nila eh..i mean girl d nasayang unless wala kang nakuha sa isang taon na un. kahit isang technique etc."]}

{"dialog": ["I'm not sure if trauma is the right term to use sa experience mo. Pero prior to that, lahat naman kayo alam nung pumasok kayo ng starHunt sa possibilities na tanggalan. Wala pang BINI that time. You guys are Starhunt trainees. The mere fact na you keep comments ng mga Bashing and hatred against BINI and puro heart reacts sa lahat ng papuri sayo only reflects na hindi mo din talaga deserve maging final 8 ng starhunt that eventually became BINI. Kinikeep mo talaga yung mga Bashing sa BINI tungkol sa looks nila at papuri sayo na mas Maganda ka sa 8. It only shows hindi lang puro LOOKS hinahanap ni Direk Dyogi and other coaches. Maganda ka lang siguro pero wala kang charisma? Walang x factor? Mediocre talent na tingin nila mahihirapan sila ma polished? We don't know. Hehe maybe that's your case? Kapal din ng mukha mo ngayon mag inarte. Nasaan ka nung di pa sila sikat?", "True! Yung mga recent comments against Bini inaapprove nya. Two faced btch.", "Kunwari proud sya pero gusto nya talaga mag create ng buzz and hate para mapansin and kahit papaano umangat sya."]}

{"dialog": ["Okay I'm not a fan  but just to be fair si ate ay nagdedelete ng comments defending BINI pero nagkkeep ng mga comments na nagiinstigate ng hate towards the women. Anong paguugali yan?", "Papansin kasi sya LOL"]}

{"dialog": ["1 year as a trainee is maikli pa compared to kpop standards. In kpop, girls/boys as early as 10 years old or less, kinukuha na as trainee, then inaabot ng 5 to 10 years before maka-debut sa girl or boy group. And hindi pa sure kung magiging successful ba yung group. TWICE Jihyo was a JYP trainee as early as 8 years old and only got to debut when she was 18, so 10 years siyang trainee.\n\nNot because trainee ka, it will guarantee your success. Its a gamble. Sa halip na nasa school ka, taking courses to gear yourself for a stable 9-to-5 job in the future, youre gambling for a chance na maging part ng isang successful girl group like BINI. Sana sinabi sa kanila ng ABS yun to manage their expectation.", "TRUTH.I remember Lea Salonga was studying BS Biology, planning to become a doctor. But when Miss Saigon came along, she had to make a choice, and she decided to go for the musical instead of finishing her degree. Life has a way of throwing us choices, and sometimes, they take us down unexpected paths.\n\nYou just have to choose, and choose wisely. Whatever the outcome is, it's a part of your journey, and it teaches you something along the way. Life doesnt always go as planned, but the choices we make shape who we become."]}

{"dialog": ["BINI na talaga ang nations girl group natin may sarili na silang debut lore like SNSD lol", "solid s0ne akis. sobrang close ng resemblance for me. lahat ng mga girl groups na may 8+ members will always be compared to the legendary soshi."]}

{"dialog": ["gatas na gatas ng abs, halos walang pahinga, show after show. nakita ko recent showtime guesting nila ang tamlay at lungkot ng aura nila.\n\nkita niyo naman halos lahat sila nagkakasakit na, every now and then may member na nagkakasakit, dahil yun sa walang pahinga. drained na sila masyado at halatang halata na na nahihirapan na sila", "The price of being famous ika nga nila. So sad for Bini Members. I just hope na mag hiatus sila kahit 1 or 2 months lang.", "kung drained ka i think hindi sapat ang 1-2 months lang. ilang taon na silang super busy since trainee days palang nila walang pahinga talaga. di yan kaya ng katawan ng tao kahit gano ka pa kalakas."]}

{"dialog": ["Maybe hindi ganun kalakas ang EQ nya. No hate, I like them. Pansin ko compared to other girls mas mabilis syang maapektuhan. Mental health is really important, how I wish she can get the support she needed.", "Yep. Aiah has anxiety. Yung first concert nila, inatake siya ng anxiety before going on stage."]}

{"dialog": ["it screams \"gimik\" for me para mapag usapan upcoming concert. i'm a bini fan pero really? 3 shows wala ka sa mood? how unprofessional can you get? Anne Curtis nga di mo mapapansin magkaaway sila ni VG sa show to think everyday mo sila napapanood", "I agree. Unprofessional yung ganyan"]}

{"dialog": ["Not a fan of BINI, pero grabe double standards just because theyre popular and well-liked? If ibang celebrities ito, binash nio na with ate chona and attitude issues. But because its BINI, mental health issue and kailangan intindihin?", "Example: Denise Julia"]}

{"dialog": ["OP maraming bitter sa Bini dito sa sub nato. Yung iba dito, they think hating on Bini makes them cool lol", "bakitt??"]}

{"dialog": ["More importantly, asan si Fyang???\n\n/s", "dami nag downvote di ata nagets? HAHAHAHAHA", "Hahaha baka nga di na gets yung /s", "most likely. altho di ko rin nagets sa ibang comments ung \"/s\" pero dahil dito sa fyang comment nalaman ko na, napa upvote tuloy ako hahahahaha", "Understandable!! Nung bago din ako sa Reddit, di ko din gets yung /s. Pero meron akong nakitang thread non ng mga ginagamit na mga ganyan here sa Reddit kaya naka sunod ako. So guys, mga nag downvote  /s means sarcastic po. Hahaha napa upvote din ako eh. Hahaha", "right right! pag nakahanap ka ng comment na gets mo context tas with \"/s\" maiintindihan mo na. pero ang funny lang talaga nung amount of people na nag downvote hahahaha"]}

{"dialog": ["Siguro feeling under the weather.\n\nThey really shouldve squeezed in a new song before the concert. Cherry on Top was already too long ago.", "Agree. Better siguro if narelease yung Blink Twice before the concert no?", "They are dropping it before the concert naman, 2 nights before nga lang.\n\nIt's a matter of win some, lose some sa promo kasi they either have a Showtime guesting without Blink Twice (which is what happened) or wala silang LIVE promo for the PH Arena show at ngayon lang sila puwede kasi they'll be ramping up concert prep over the next few days.", "True. Mas pinili nila I debut ang live performance ng blink twice sa concert nla. Ang weird nmn ksi kng nirelease nla ngyn tpos di nmn ni maperform live dhl nirereserve nla yyng performance sa concert."]}

{"dialog": ["Ang weird ng schedule nila, nag guest sa showtime pero COT parin ang performance instead na Blink twice na sana. Tapos imbes na magpromote na sila next week, magpprepare pa sila for concert. Parang hindi na mamaximize yung opportunity.", "i agree. Medjo all over the place. i think theyre promoting the concert para mapush yung pagkasold out. pero 4k nalang naman natitirang tickets so why bother diba? its so much better if post concert tong promo nila. \n\nmy guess is that these guestings were scheduled last year pa; in time for blink twice siguro but nabasa ko rin na namove ang release ng blink twice dapat ata jan ang release. pero ginawang feb. kaya sunod sunod and knowing na mahirap mag move ng schedule for shows, tinuloy nila.", "Make sense kung january nga. Perfect comeback sana. Dapat minove nalang nila yung release date kahit last week of jan para may purpose naman appearances nila sa shows. I wonder kung paano nila ippromote yang blink twice since magiging busy na sila.", "diba super sayanggg! they do have schedules pa ata after blink twice. so baka dun yung proper promotions. well see meron kasi talaga pre at post promo eh"]}

{"dialog": ["Parang hindi na sila ganun karelevant.", "The hype died down a bit? antagal na nung last song release nila kasi", "yeah nagdie-down for casuals ata. pero massive pa din yung fans nila. 1m-2m likes parin tiktok likes ng members. 4k nalanh natitira sa tickets nila out of 50k sa ph arena. parang enough na fans nila to sustain them. Like kpop; parang echo chamber of fans nalang meron per group", "Tbh socmed likes and shares aren't really an accurate indication ng laki ng fanbase. Fans can have multiple accounts and hindi naman secret ang existence ng bots to inflate these stats. Just one dedicated fan can increase these numbers din if may tyaga to stream their content for long hours daily. \n\nThey should still strive to keep the casuals interested hehe goods naman na popularity and recall nila so far, pero ppop (or opm as a whole) is booming right now - much better if they have new songs every time may concert tour so people have something new to look forward to. Casuals are fickle - kapag may bagong mas catchy at maganda sa pandinig, lipat agad sila dun."]}

{"dialog": ["no offense pero sawa na ako sa \"Nation Girl Group\" they should focus on making new albums, na hiya ako sa ibang group  (local or international group) lagi nag labas ng album pero seldom mag concert kahit malaki fan base ito sila opposite. hahaha repeated and recycle lang mga song every concert .\n\nparang influencer sila over girl group kasi pero labas endorsement palagi, and hindi ko na gets bakit nag pa fun run sila palagi? the management really suck.", "Nakakasawa din nga. At wala din kasing competition.", "Yes walang competition talaga sila. They went different direction after blooming. . The management is clearly milking them at weird way. They become influencers rather than music girls.  But oh well. I wish them success.", "Sayang nga. Ang attention sa sb19 parang napunta lahat sa kanila."]}

{"dialog": ["Matumal bentahan kase walang new songs.\nPag nag release ng new album yan unaunahan ulit", "not really matumal; 4k nalang natitira sa tickets for ph arena out of 50k so thats impressive. their merch also has sold out sa site (last i checked). \n\npero tbh kaya yan masold out if later this year ginanap.\n\ngusto ata kssi ng management tuluyang masold out kaya pinapagguesting sila. promo na rin sa feb 13 new single nila.", "Oh I see, konti na lang din pala. Akala ko madami pa since yung dati nilang concert na 2-day mabilis nasold out compared ngayon then nagkaroon pa ng pang 3rd day.\nKaya na yan masoldout"]}

{"dialog": ["In relation with this, sa world tour nila, gaano kaya karami pupunta? Not really a hater pero di ko lang maimagine na a relatively new and a relatively not-so-big (emphasis sa relative sa mga mattrigger diyan) girl group would actually take on a world tour, eh yung songs nga nila medyo kaumay na idk hahahah", "the girls do have an international audience rin pero onti lang rin naman sama mo na mga reactors sa yt. but i think itll be a relatively small venue lang sa sg noon marami ring nagpunta sa gig nila last 2024 e so idk we cant tell pa", "hmmm the sg event was free and maraming up and coming artist na pinuntahan ng ibang fans din. Plus it was a very open venue so really hard to say?"]}

{"dialog": ["Nun previous concert nila last year\nnagkasakit naman si Aiah. Hectic din ang schedule.\nGet well soon Gwen!", "Onga po eh. Uso rin kasi sakit ulit :("]}

{"dialog": ["sabi sa x 4.5k tickets nalng daw ang tira?", "So naka 50k na rin sila? Parang not bad naman na lol. I would argue that it's already impressive"]}

{"dialog": ["Sold out na ba ang tickets?", "50k/55k na ang soldout. May 4k+ pa. It's pretty impressive in 3 months without new song. Pero sana nag release sila before concert for hype."]}

{"dialog": ["Si Angel Locsin talaga nakikita ko kay Colet. Noong teenager pa si AL. Same sila ng smile at eyes.", "Dba. Mas nakikita ko si angel kocsin sa knya kesa kayy nadine n lagi snsbi kamukha nya"]}

{"dialog": ["Papalitan na raw siya ni Queen Fyangieee", "stoppp"]}

{"dialog": ["Wrong move for me to google image calcified tartar", "Marami sa tiktok yung videos na binabasag siga using water hahaha", "isa sa guilty pleasure ko tsaka ung dr pimple haha", "Mas makapal na tartar mas satisfying panoorin. Pati sa Dr. Pimple, meron pa yung Toebro."]}

{"dialog": ["I wish he would go to the dentist and take anti anxiety meds nalang lol. I have a phobia din of dentists, as in after every dentist appointment nangangatog ang katawan ko like I just experienced something traumatic. I found a dentist who prescribed me with Valium, and I take two everytime I go to the dentist, it works naman.  I just need a designated driver after.", "May specialized dentist that can give you sedatives during the procedure. Usually for children with mental disabilities clients nila.", "I dont think I need that bad of an intervention, Valium lang okay na ko, but yeah thats good to know."]}

{"dialog": ["Yung ilang months pa nga lang after ng cleaning mo, medyo annoying na kapag may build-up na uli ng tartar kaya nga advise is 4-6months ang cleaning. May napanuod ako sa youtube is parang bloke na ng yelo yung namuong tartar dun sa patient kasi wala capacity to access dental care.", "Mahal din talaga kasi yung dental care, almost only accessible talaga sa may kaya lang.", "2k ang pa deep clean ng ganyan, dito sa amin."]}

{"dialog": ["Dun ko mismo napanood yung sinabi nya na may phobia sya sa dentist because of his mother.", "Anong context nung sa mother niya?", "Ginagamit daw ng nanay nya na panakot sa kanya na dadalhin sya sa dentista"]}

{"dialog": ["Kamusta naman kaya ang breath ni Tito Boy Parang naawa tuloy ako sa guests niya lol.", "Tapos tatawanan pa niya nung long drawn out na \"ahhhhhhhuaaaaahuaaaaaaahuaaaaaa~\" niya."]}

{"dialog": ["Mababasa ito ng staff ni tito boy, active pa naman dito hahahah", "Totoo!!! Paging u/fasttalkboyabunda"]}

{"dialog": ["Talas ng mata mo OP hehe maybe you are a dentist or working in a similar field? Hehe", "That's what I thought too. Nakita nya talaga yun"]}

{"dialog": ["Sure na kayo na tartar? Or baka sungki yon? Dba marami cases na  may isa pang ngipin sa likod ng ngipin.  If bad breath sya, for sure matagal ng na chismis yan.  Especially nung Boy and Kris pa , kris mismo ookrayin yan.  I really doubt it is tartar.", "No, di sya ngipin sa likod e. As in nagthicken yung teeth nya sa baba. Possible na wala pa or di pa ganun kakapal nung The Buzz time pa kaya di pansin since it takes time naman para magbuild up yung ganun kakapal na tartar."]}

{"dialog": ["King of Talk \nKing of Tartar", "Shutaaaa. Hahahaha"]}

{"dialog": ["Ano ba talaga cause ng tartar? May kakilala ako never nagpalinis ng ipin, pero never nagkaroon ng build up", "Baka masipag mag toothbrush at floss"]}

{"dialog": ["so, implants ba yung teeth nya?", "May implants ata sya yung ata ang sponsor GAOC"]}

{"dialog": ["Maybe a case of Peter Pan syndrome. Refuses to feel old so he dates younger women.\n\nEdit: Go mga sis, downvote lang but one thing your downvotes cant deny: His patterns of dating young women that can almost be his daughters lols", "Lol Marc Nelson has said the same thing about himself in the past. Peter Pan daw siya. Pedophiles", "Lol, right? Rico Blancos a creep"]}

{"dialog": ["Though may history talaga si Rico B na much younger women ang exes niya, yung kay Maloi naman eh fans rin lang nagpakalat nun diba? Singled out sila sa video at malicious caption though andami palang kasamang artists sa group and event iirc", "Phil Star ang nagpa big deal ng issue.  Malicious headlines all for clicks.", "tapos never nag apologize yung writer sa damage na nagawa niya, tuwang-tuwa pa sa clout."]}

{"dialog": ["Tirador din ng bagets eh. Started with Kc Concepcion.", "I did the math. She wasnt his first kid."]}

{"dialog": ["Sino kaya ang next na M.R.?", "Maris Racal to Maloi Ricalde to ?"]}

{"dialog": ["i digress pero is it just me or parang di na ganon ka hype ang bini? like d ko na sila ramdam", "Yep and that's normal. Masaya na kaming fans sa mga na-achieve ng BINI last year."]}

{"dialog": ["May bago bang album yung Bini or mga songs? Parang kakaconcert lang nila ah\nBaka factor din yon since wala masyado aabangan mga fans.\n\nDinaman masyado pinapahalata ng management yung paggatas nila e noh, \nFor me dapat nag release muna sila kahit EP manlang.", "Bakit kasi nangyayari na yung walang album release puro EP pero malakas loob mag tour? Di ba kaya mag output ng 12 songs at once na cohesive since album? Ang weird. Patak patak. Songs pa ba yan or content na lang.", "Nakakamiss yung panahon na bago muna irelease yung full album or e.p., maglalabas muna ng isa or dalawa singles . Ngayon puro singles nalang. Pag nagrelease naman ng album , lahat ng kanta ay puro nirelease na as singles.\n\nSponge cola for example", "Ayun nga. Compilation na lang ng previous releases. And mostly di cohesive, kasi pinatak patak na tong mga songs eh. \n\nAnd singles naman dapat talaga parang patikim ng album. Ngayon wala nang attention span ang tao na makinig ng album, I guess. Which sucks.", "They're missing out alot for not listening to albums\n Eheads Fill Her for example. Eheads listeners knows this song. But majority of the people only knows this during their time at their 2022 concert. After that (probably two days later) ,the song became a chart topping hit single"]}

{"dialog": ["ABS-CBN is milking them like a cash cow. This is damaging sa long term growth and longevity ng careers nila.\n\nThis is not a hate comment sa BINI girls ah. Pero tinatanggalan kasi sila ng sense of elusiveness sa ganyang ginagawa ng ABS. Kumbaga hindi man lang pinapacrave or pinapatakam for more yung general public.\n\nIn short, MABILIS NILANG NILALAOS yung BINI pag tinuloy-tuloy na ganito.\n\nTreat them as ARTists.", "Hehe what can we expect? Andiyan pa kasi hype. \n\nPero sana naglabas muna ng new album. Kahit EP lang. Para may bagong kanta.\n\nHindi puro Salamin at Pantropiko n nmn. Maryosep", "Kaya nga eh. Ang aga pala Feb 2025 agad? Tapos ilang beses nang um-appear BINI  may fun run pa nga.\n\nI hope ABS-CBN manages them better. Their \"Cherry On Top\" didn't do so well or at least sa expectations na meron sa kanila after the hype from the songs you mentioned.", "I sincerely feel like CoT being an English song didn't help the song. Parang hayok ang management na gawing global sila kaagad. May rumor akong narinig na English din daw ang next release nila. Weird lang kasi 'yung hits nila ay Filipino pop songs, bakit sila nagpipilit sa English. Hindi muna alagaan ang local fanbase bago magshoot for the stars. Kaloka.", "Yikes. Bilis nila i-let go yung OPM concept that made BINI a hit."]}

{"dialog": ["To be honest I don't think there is an OPM act na keri i-sold out yung venue na yan. Nonetheless, happy for BINI pa rin. Majority naman na yata ng tickets ay sold na. Not bad for the first opm act to perform there.", "Aldub lang ata na filipino celebrity ang nakapuno niyan last 2016 during their aldub anniversary. Si Olivia Rodrigo rin kaso di naman pure pinay.", "Legit ba yung soldout ng Aldub?", "Yes. Legit. Umattend pa nga lahat ng teacher ko sa highschool nun tas may free bus ang EB. Mura lang din kasi ticket nasa range PHP300-1000 lang ata (correct me if I'm wrong) at nasa hype talaga nun yung Aldub.", "150 ata pinakamura sa aldub non hahahaha"]}

{"dialog": ["Huge factor din na very competitive ang February 2025 concert lineup. Halos araw araw yata na may concert sa lahat ng venues all over NCR during February, starring both local and international acts. On Feb 15 show date alone, magkakasabay ang The Corrs, A1, Bini, Erik/Yeng/Christian and Regine Velasquez.", "Plus may waterbomb festival pa sa Quirino Grandstand.", "Yung waterbomb is Feb 22 pa but still.\n\nHindi ko na nga sinama dyan yung concerts from Feb 1 to 15, which includes yung 3 night concert ni TJ Monterde and 2 night concert ng Cup Of Joe sa Araneta, then Martin and Pops sa MOA Arena, then yung mga small shows ng Sessionistas, Mr. C, etc etc madami pa. Yung kay Regine is also a 4 night concert series. Sa foreign acts naman, may shows ang Hoobastank, The Script (2 nights in Araneta), NIKI (2 nights sa MOA Arenna), Taeyang, Ronan Keating etc etc.", "Jam-packed pala ang concerts this Feb. Ang daming artists na gusto kong panoorin."]}

{"dialog": ["One thing P-Pop needs to learn from neighbor countries like Japan and Korea when it comes to, well, Pop, is that high-ticket events like concerts need corresponding content. New music, new collabs, more build-up promotion. Currently it seems like BINI has been doing ads and concert to concert lang. Idk. Di alam nila Dyogi how to sustain their stardom in so many ways.", "Pano pinapabayaan sa twitter yung mga girls tapos sasabihin ok lang patola totoo naman sa sarili ganun. Yeah its 2025 and you can say what you want pero may image sila na pinoprotektahan look at kpop konteng backlash kita mo na effect sa person involved", "To be fair, animal din talaga yung mga haters and casual bashers nila lalo on Facebook. There's this weird trend that men are actively smearing the girls. But media training is media training especially if you're still establishing yourself towards the general public. With their twitter behavior, only fans will really let it go and understand.", "Its a small price you've got to pay lalo na pasikat palang ganun. If they want to be the next thing, may template nmn just like kpop. But yeah easier said than done."]}

{"dialog": ["Idk if hot take or ano: Cherry on Top ruined their momentum. Sobrang thriving sila sa filipino songs tapos biglang nagfull english at change concept agad", "True. Even kpop groups nasa almost 10yr mark na bago nagttry ng full English songs unless established na agad sa una palang na palong-palo sila internationally. Pansin ko though na if ganun, maiksi lifespan kasi mahina roots sa home country, hindi naman pwedeng intl/world tour palagi.", "Huh? Diba Filipinos have been making English songs since forever. You're looking at it from a kpop POV na they make English songs to lure the intl audiences. Pero Pinoy tayo, nakalimutan niyo na ba na maraming OG English songs ang Pinoy? I'm not even a Bloom. Napakamot ulo ko.", "What we mean is malakas 'yung impact nila sa Tagalog and kahit na Tagalog 'yung songs naka-reach sila ng numbers overseas. It's a way to ride on the hype and for people to differentiate them from other groups. Nag-switch sila to English songs agad making them just another girl group. Ang dami-daming girl group na nage-English, what makes them unique now? Hindi lang fellow Asians ang competition nila with English songs. Hindi rin naman ako Bloom, just stating an obvious pattern among successful groups out there. \n\nMaraming OG English songs na OPM oo, pero let's be truthful here, medyo bago sa paningin at pandinig 'yung girl group na Tagalog pop at naging ganito ka-successful. Unless isama mo sa bilang ang Sexbomb Girls. Kidding aside, may momentum 'yung Tagalog language: a way to gather new listeners whether nakakaintindi or not."]}

{"dialog": ["Sana nagrelease muna sila ng bagong EP man lang between their 3day concert last November and this world tour para may bagong ilook forward yung aattend ng concert. Why would people spend money again if most likely the same set man lang sa recent concert nila. They barely released anything in the past two months. Yes for sure different or new production/special performances but still the same Bini songs from their concert 3months ago.\n\n\nSuper fresh pa siguro sa memories ng mga nagattend yung last concert nila kaya I understand why this didnt sell out as fast compared from their last concert + bigger venue.", "NGL, I was expecting a new song/ep after that announcement. Pero mukhang napuno na ng bookings for the holidays at naubusan na ng time maghanda ng bagong kanta.\n\nThen come 2025, mukhang nag break sila then prepare na sa concert. Mukhang ang new ep announcement eh after pa nitong concert na ito\n\nEdit: added more words", "I feel like too soon talaga pagschedule ng world tour. Masyado nagmamadali management nila. Takot ata bigla mawala yung hype kaya strike while the iron is hot i guess"]}

{"dialog": ["Mauubos yung ibang slots diyan eventually. Yung company ng ate ko (na ineendorse ng bini) bibili ng marami eh tas ipapa raffle ganon and bibigyan employees. Madaming endorsments bini im sure isusupport din sila ng mga yun. \n\n\nAlso, medyo di ko inexpect to kasi lagi silang sold out dati. Ang bilis talaga mag-die down ng hype.", "Super laki din naman ng difference ng Philippine Arena compared sa New Frontier Theater in terms of seats. Madali talaga masosoldout ang smaller venues compared sa Phil Arena na 55k seats.", "I think she/he referring to NFT / Araneta 360 ng BINI. Almost 80-90% sold out na sa PH Arena almost a month pa naman yung concert may chance na ma sold out pa after releasing their guestlist and pakulo."]}

{"dialog": ["That's a production issue though, not a venue one. Been to many concerts sa PH Arena and may production talaga na sablay ang sound system and meron din naman na top-notch. \n\nAnd PH Arena, as a venue, never really stopped hardcore fans from coming despite being a hassle to go to (*coughs in K-pop concerts*).", "But the difference is K-pop acts dont hold different concerts na magkakalapit ang dates. yung Enhypen, at least one year ang pagitan ng concert shows nila dito sa Pinas: Manifesto (Feb. 35, 2023), Fate (Feb. 3, 2024), Walk the Line (March 1, 2025). Ito kasing sa BINI, November 2024 ang last concert nila sa Araneta, tapos minadali ng Star Music na magkaroon ng another concert (without any comeback) in just less than three months. But it seems like theyre doing fine naman since marami na rin namang nabentang tickets (around 50k na raw).", "I was only disputing sound quality claim. I totally agree na masyadong minamadali ng Star Magic ang BINI."]}

{"dialog": ["Factor din siguro po na after valentines day and sweldo day so either nagddate mga tao, may event, or di nalang lalabas para makipagsiksikan sa traffic. Already watched a concert there sa PhilArena (Blackpink), and I can confidently say na ayoko na sa venue na yun HAHAHA :((", "So true hassle pa ang pagpunta. Araneta at moa pa rin. wala naman kailangan patunayan kung hindi ka mag philippine arena haha."]}

{"dialog": ["Ang weird kasi. Kaka concert lang nila for 3 days tapos mag coconcert ulit sa mas malaking venue lang then wala naman new release na kanta.", "They even called it at first as Biniverse the repeat concert. Pero ni-rebrand as World Tour concert kase nga di na-sold out as they were expecting. Di ba daming Blooms nagsabi kaya nila yan i-sold out in 24 hours?"]}

{"dialog": ["Bakit world tour? may other venue paba bukod sa pinas?", "Meron po. common countries with huge Filipino crowd."]}

{"dialog": ["Sana kahit xmas song remake meron. Tagal na ng Cherry on top.", "Meron sila"]}

{"dialog": ["Anong nangyari ba dun sa MNL48?", "Flopped."]}

{"dialog": ["Hi po, curious lng pano u nalaman na hnd pa sya sold out?", "Kaka-post lang ng Star Music"]}

{"dialog": ["Yung nagsulat ng article, kapatid ni Juan Miguel Severo", "Anong nangyari kay Juan Miguel Severo??", "Ang alam ko lang so far ay ever since lumabas yung issue, wala na siya sa AWKP. Pero in the last few months, parang nagpaparamdam daw uli siya sa socmed", "Anong issue po yun? Tsaka ano po yung AWKP?  Sorry wala akong gaanong balita sa kanya. Ang naaalala ko lang is sya yung may spoken words content?", "Ang Walang Kwentang Podcast with Direk Jadaone. Sila partner before Direk JP. Tinanggal siya nung pumutok yung issue na he harassed Paolo Pangilinan\n\nEdited typo", "Became a listener ng AWKP last year and now ko lang nalaman na siya pala ang partner before direk jp! Buti na lang hindi na siya, every time kasi maririnig ko boses niyan akala ko nag-sspoken word poetry", "buti nalang talaga kasi puro siya lang nagsasalita noon, halos di na makapag salita si direk Tonet kasi bida bida yung isa. ang saya lang nung pumalit na si direk JP", "Ang benta sa akin ng dynamics nina direk tonet at direk jp"]}

{"dialog": ["This is not giving news platform its giving chika platform", "Yes because its an entertainment column. Kaya nga patanong ung headline at Hindi exclamation point. Hindi Dahil philstar news yan wala na silang entertainment column and entertainment news covers gossip as well.", "Ano nmn kng entertainment column sya . Dpt b malicious ytng header?", "Alam mo kung deboto ka ng bini mag sabi ka lang. kasi parte ng entertainment column Ang gossips. Specially si Rico blanco kasama nya na puro bata ung ex. Kung big deal yang header para Kay maloi Kasuhan nya.", "Ayun gumagawa ng gossip n wla basehan. Ibig sbhn naninira.", "Paki explain pano paging paninira Ang pakikipag date? May asawa ba silang dalawa? Or Baka meron silang gf/bf na di ko alam? Pano nagging paninira Ang mag tanong kung romantically involved Ang dalawa ng single na tao?", "Paninira kpg nagkakalat ng di totoo.", "Pag sinabihang kang mabait Tapus Hindi naman pala totoo paninira un? Ako tigiltigil lan mo ko sa mga lohikang palpak mo."]}

{"dialog": ["deserve. anlaki ng platform ng philstar tas ganyan  \n\nlike is it THAT hard ba to get your facts straight and to not post a poorly cropped picture", "Philstar used to be broadsheet material media pero nowadays mas malala pa sila sa tabloid.", "may pika ata kay maloi yung gumawa ng article. yun din daw yung gumawa ng issue about maloi mocking pwds last time.", "I saw pero prior to this they've been headlining shitty stories and una sila sa mga chismis based \"news\". How the mighty have fallen"]}

{"dialog": ["Nakakadiri. Respetadong news publication naging fake news na ngayon for clicks and views.", "Parang 2 seconds nga lang yung appearance ni rico sa video nung tumatawid sila crop kaagad tapos gawa ng article. Halos hindi nga naguusap yan si maloi at rico, mas nakakabonding pa ni maloi si blaster at zild tapos kay rico yung link? Mema lang yung writer na yan for clout.", "Malicious din yung pagkakascreenshot. Iisipin mo holding hands sila while pumapara ng taxi.", "Kaya nga sinadya yung crop para kunwari holding hands sila."]}

{"dialog": ["Buti nag iistand up Bini members sa ganito yung ibang artista di kaya", "Something na di kaya ng management nila lol", "Hello. Since when naglalabas ng statement ang starmagic sa mga ganito issue? Never nmn sla naglabas hinahayyaan nla ang artist nla ang mag salita dhl that's personal.  Ginagaya mo nmn sla sa entertainment agency sa korea n bawat issue ng artist naglalabas ng statement ang mngt nla. Wla k sa korea ha"]}

{"dialog": ["Mas malala call out ni Colet. Mejo galit. Hehe.", "Patingin po ng screenshot"]}

{"dialog": ["kala mo dispatch tong si Philstar eh, nasaan po yung integrity niyo", "More like Pannchoa"]}

{"dialog": ["baka collab yan ng MV or baka related sa music siguro. kasi diba pag member ka ng isang group lalo na ppop ngayon, bawal muna in a relationship. knowing Abs mngnt, gagawa ng scene para maaga palang pag usapan na para mag spark na agad ng curiosity ang tao once na may nabuo na silang MV or music or kung ano man niluluto nila.", "Yan yung pinagiisipan ko dyan sa isyu na yan"]}

{"dialog": ["Rico bat ganun? Bakit si Maloi? Bakit hindi na lang si Mikha?", "Baliw"]}

{"dialog": ["Parang pinaghalong Harry Roque at Darryl Yap", "this might be the worst possible hybrid of all"]}

{"dialog": ["Most people only read the headlinesmay study yanand it's actually happening to her. Most of the people sa blue app akala totoo yung headline. Sana gamitin ang utak kung may class ka.", "Yung nagdebunk na ang taong mismong involved sa fake news/clickbait/speculations, natawag pang classless. Kaloka."]}

{"dialog": ["Kaano-ano ni juan miguel severo si writer hahahaha", "Magkapatid sila - personally know them", "Ay pucha. Magkapatid parehong basura hahahaha", "> parehong basura\n\nSpill", "Juan Miguel harassed Paolo Pangilinan during set yata nung series nila, yung Gaya sa Pelikula. Si Paolo mismo nagsabi nun. Dami na din yata ibang issues ni Juan Miguel buhat nung lumabas yung issue ni Paolo. Kaya ayun biglang lie low. Unfriended na sya ng mga celeb friends niya, even Kathryn yata"]}

{"dialog": ["Typical clickbait headline, oo. Pero kung babasahin yung article, maingat yung writer sa paggamit ng \"allegedly\" at interrogative sentences kaya technically, walang mali sa nireport nya. Malas nya lang pinagmumura na sya ng mga fans ng bini", "Ang problema ksi binibigyan ng romantic angle. Kht wla nmn basehan. Dba pwede ng outing lng ng mga magkakaibigan", "New year, new love? was the original headline. it was definitely malicious", "Kahit naman sa mga Hollywood celebrities pag mag kasama rumored agad na dating. Dahil ba si maloi ung naiintriga ? Kaya napaka big deal? As if walang history ung kasama nya ng pagiging tirador ng bata."]}

{"dialog": ["I dont get it. Philstar is a tabloid", "**The Philippine Star** is their flagship newspaper.\n\nTheir tabloid is **Pilipino Star Ngayon**.", "Since bata pa ko di ko nakitang kalavel ng The Philippine Star ang Manila Bulletin pero maybe its just me na di nagbabasa ng newspaper", "Same. 20 years ago nung bumibili pa magulang ko ng diyaryo it's either Bulletin or Inquirer.\n\nBulletin because of Joey de Leon's columns.\n\nInquirer because of Pugad Baboy.\n\nPero sayang din yung dating promo ng Jollibee na may libreng Philippine Star kapag umorder ka ng breakfast meal pero tingin ko sa isang particlar branch lang merong ganun..."]}

{"dialog": ["May clip sa twitter na sinabihan niya bini members na \"bawat galaw niyo sinusulat ko\"", "creepy dude, parang photographer sa isang cosplay event vibes", "Isa siyang Papa...\n\n#PAPARAZZI."]}

{"dialog": ["I think wala naman beef with Maloi, sensationalized lang ang headline kasi alam naman nila hindi na babasahin ang whole article", "Yeah, it's for clickbait purposes."]}

{"dialog": ["Eto ah, feel ko hindi yan sya macacall out nang ganyan kung hindi BINI ang subject ng articles. Kase sa totoo lang, marami sa mga balita ngayon na kung hindi click bait, eh rage bait ang title. Kahit sa mga malalaking news outlets, kapag hindi ka nagbasa lagpas ng headlines, talagang gagawa ng interaction yung posted article.", "i believe he was also called out when he wrote the Chelsea Manalo, natalo article\n\nthat pageant article was rage-bait. this article of him from today is obviously clickbait, almost fake news even\n\nbut yea, if its from an unknown artist, i doubt hell write that kind of headline din"]}

{"dialog": ["Beef with Maloi, at the very least. Look at the byline of those headlines and see the name of the author. Kapatid ni JMS from the looks of it (pareho pa nga sila ng initials eh).", "Same thoughts."]}

{"dialog": ["Wait wait. Pero hindi si Maloi ang kasama nya or si Maloi?", "Kasama si Maloi. The issue is hindi lang naman sila ang magkasama sa circumstance na yan. The romantic involvement/allegation is uncalled for."]}

{"dialog": ["Yeah pero this could all be avoided kung resposible din sya sa choice of words, right? Fan man siya or hindi, nakuha niya atensyon ng binabalita niya, at hindi yun nagustuhan ni Maloi.", "Yan dapat ang unang point mo pero nde, unang battle point mo is to point out the writer as n SB19 fan. Nawala tuloy ssnse ng \"reduce biases argument\"."]}

{"dialog": ["I hope its not true. Men his age should not be dating girls of Malois age. Ang icky.", "Gathering sya ng mga singer-songwriters. Nasa LU din kasama nila si Zild pati yung newlyweds ng Ben & Ben si Agnes & Pat", "Yep, pretty much tabloid level news. Philstar has garnered some goodwill lately from being \"hip\" with the news but this is what you get once these publishers get too comfortable"]}

{"dialog": ["Hoooooy. 22 palang yung Maloi.", "Parang 22 din daw si Maris nung naging sila ni Rico", "Wow leonardo di caprio pinoy version"]}

{"dialog": ["i saw a tiktok comment about nung gumala sila rico, maloi, and other young artists saying \"wala bang kaibigan si rico na ka edad nya?\" HAHSHSHAHUHU", "Pero may point yung comment haha I know colleagues nya sila sa music industry pero like dude youre 51. \nIts just like sa office, you can work together but outside your work, you cant be hanging out with them kids. Predator behavior na pinapakita ni Rico Blanco."]}

{"dialog": ["I dont particularly like BINI but if this is true, someone save her jusko. What business does he have with girls half his age?", "It's not true. Maloi herself called out Philstar news for this misleading and fake article"]}

{"dialog": ["Nagtayo sya ng hotel bar sa la union, invited mga young artists. Un lang un. Pero anyway, basta naging sila ng 18+ yo female, fair game. LOL", "No pls lang pwede ba. Fair game for who. An 18 year old female is still a teenager and has no business being with a man in his 50s. If shes around 25 and has had some life experience, then thats a different story."]}

{"dialog": ["**Legal age** naman pareho ah? 22 and 40 something? **Wala din grooming**.. coz it would imply close na si Rico & Maloi dapat before 18 then magiging sila which i dont think was the case din\n\nDownvote agad. Walang paliwanag?", "52 na si rico"]}

{"dialog": ["Whatt? Naging sila nung isang member ng BGYO?  tanong ko nga sa biniph", "sila pa rin ata ngayon di q sure kung naghiwalay"]}

{"dialog": ["Parang ang dumi nilang tignan", "yung camera ata yon, pati filter parang kuha ng myphone datingan"]}

{"dialog": ["Naku OP good luck maraming hater ng BINI dito lalo at mga babae sila", "Halatang pangit at amoy putok sa totoong buhay yung iba dito", "True! Halatang may galit sa sarili"]}

{"dialog": ["Nako op mali ka ng group na pinostan, aatakihin nila yan dito", "Hayaan mo na. Mas marami tayong mga matitino rito.", "COUNT ME IN"]}

{"dialog": ["As nice as it is, celebrities doing charity works seem like one big PR move", "Nah. You just don't see the good in everyone. How pathetic.", "Sad talaga actually. Cancer ng lipunan"]}

{"dialog": ["ok sige", "It is easy to be kind", "\"it is easy to be kind\" pero depende sa mood niya"]}

{"dialog": ["Ang ganda niya. Na-happy yung mga bagets. Pasko na. Me problema ba? Kayo telege.", "Yung isang DDShit lang yung may problema dds"]}

{"dialog": ["Brace yourself dami haters ang bini dto.\nMeron din mga haters si sofia andres dto. Di ko maintindihan saan galing ang hate nila", "They love to hate successful women in general"]}

{"dialog": ["dinogshow niya yung \"trashbag tote bag\" huhu T\\_T", "Kaya in love na in love ako kay Yves"]}

{"dialog": ["nugagawen macacanonized naba sila as saint eme", "/r/pinoypasttensed"]}

{"dialog": ["Yung thicc daw sila pero yun pala isang guhit nalang obese na", "Tapos Greek god physique ung hanap?"]}

{"dialog": ["Bakit downvoted 'to eh part naman ng Earth ang Africa?", "Natawa ako sa comment thread na to in fairness"]}

{"dialog": ["Pinagttripan sya. Alot of people dont like her bc of her fans kaya some ppl are mocking them and her by doing that, yung hahanapin si fyang or imemention sya on something na di naman related sakanya", "Sino ba si Fyang? Not trying to be mean here and just legit curious. Bigla ko nalang nakikita name niya sa comments eh. Tiktoker ba siya, artista or what?", "Tiktoker and pbb Big Winner", "Ah okay, thank you!", "just to add, may nababasa ako na nag \"Yes to ABS CBN shutdown\" daw sya dati, pero ngayon nasa ABS CBN."]}

{"dialog": ["Di naman stunning, maputi lng!", "This. Wala pang katawan Hahahahhaa Ayoko nalang magtell", "Pwede naman mag surgery, but I think she should improve on her acting first.", "Magiinarte daw sya sa set hahahahahah"]}

{"dialog": ["Common din ang beauty ni girl, nung tinabi sha sa mga kasama nya sa top 5 parang di ko sha nakilala, ibang babae ung lutang ang ganda tlaga pero di sha.", "yung KAI yung maganda", "Big night lang kasi napanood ko pero mother ko un laging nanonood if sya ung ampon daw haha. Shes beauty queen material at sya bet ng mama ko nun manalo hahahaha. Narrative kasi na deserve ng mahirap at may madramang BG kaya stan ni mother.", "di rin ako palanood ng tv kaya nakikita ko sa epbi. yung kai ang maganda yung tipong pansinin at classic yung ganda, ganurn, kaya kahit di siya ang nagtetrend naalala ko name niya. hahaha"]}

{"dialog": ["Walang class yan si Ante hahahaha. Ewan ko ba't ang hilig ng mga pinoy sa squammy. Sabi nila \"maganda\" daw pero san don?", "I mean, we cant deny shes pretty. (Bakit pag ayaw natin sa tao ang common sabihin na hindi naman sya maganda). Hahahaha. Pero thats about it. She doesnt have it. Kahit yung love team nilang pinipilit na walang dating haha. Plus, si kuya laging matamlay. Hahaha.", "Plus ung pangungurot nya lagi ng utong na nkakabwisit..", "Dapat yan ang title KUROT-UTONG KWEEN. Since akala nya cool gawin un, normal squammy gurly."]}

{"dialog": ["yung nakikita mong everywhere is mockery na hahahhah", "Ginawang katawa-tawa nalang sya.", "true. kasalanan din yan ng mga fans nya tapos hindi nya pa pinagsasabihan. hinahayaan nya lang din lol isama mo pa yung ka tandem nya ngayon na si jm. parehas mapanghe. they're literally a laughingstock now"]}

{"dialog": ["She can't host, she can't act, she can't think straight enough to not support Marcos-Duterte...", "And she supported ABS shutdown, whatta", "Right. And even now that she's fading into the background people won't let up lol\n\nShe's actually getting more famous for not getting famous"]}

{"dialog": ["Maybe it's your social media algorithm? Skip those posts that don't please you and one day you won't even notice they won't appear on your feed anymore.", "The post, I like. The comments I see not so much. Hahaha. Pero thats what I normally do. I block contents from people I dislike pati narin profile nila. \n\nMedyo overwhelming lang talaga yung comments haha. Out of proportion. Thanks btw.", "Yeah. Yung magiging problem mo jan is right now ABS is painting Fyang to be the next \"teen queen\" so expect those paid trolls to post a lot about her. So basically, if you want to opt out of anything associated with Fyang, you would need to avoid all the showbiz chika as well. Ang mangyayari, pick your poison haha"]}

{"dialog": ["It means nagmamature na po ang inyong generation, welcome to the club! Come to mama! ~90s product~", "Hoy hoy hoy hoy. Explain. Hahahahhaha. I need more than that comment.", "Super duper late reaction. Pero I will give you an acceptable reason: BUMABATA po tayo HAHAHAAHA (kay dustin naman tayo mairita eyyy)"]}

{"dialog": ["Trip lang yung iba dyan hahahahaha", "Bakit wala ang Fyangie namin"]}

{"dialog": ["Legit, dapat nga nasa Moana 2 sya eh. Di bale, icampaign namin si Queen Fyangie for Human Centipede 3", "AHAHAHAHAHHAHAHAHAHHAAHAHHAHAHAHA"]}

{"dialog": ["Kahit sa volleyball community hinahanap si fyang sa individual awardees so i think trip trip lang yun.", "trip trip lang talaga kahit di related kay Fyang yung post nasa comsec name nya, minsan nga about sa namatay yung post pangalan ni Fyang nasa comsec para ba tuloy syang \"what country is this\" na comment"]}

{"dialog": ["Not a fan, di ko nasubaybayan PBB nila but too early to tell, too early to judge. With how Star Magic monetized BINI, I came to this conclusion na anything is possible jan sa new PBB batch kahit wala franchise ABS. Hindi man tayo maka-relate but grabe fandom ng PBB batch na yan sa socmed lalo na sa Tiktok and FB.\n\nI guess yun ang difference ng Mr. M vs Dyogi babies. Real talk, Mr. M in ABS kept on giving opportunities sa favorites niya (Bea, JLC, Gerald, etc) kahit hindi malaki fanbase and hindi always successful projects. Unlike Dyogi who prioritize those with huge fanbase and mainstream as of the moment.", "Nah, Dyogi also play favorites. BGYO was so favored by Dyogi (before Bini blew up) by a mile. You can definitely tell it through their promos. Also, Dyogi has a habit of pushing artist, even if they are not that popular. Did everyone forget about Anji Salvacion? Dyogi pushed her a lot."]}

{"dialog": ["Im positive her mgmt pays for that too, the more shes talked about, her career will gain traction, her launch will attract endorsers and more money for the mgmnt. Madali lang yan.", "wala man lang nga yan ni-isa na endorsement eh naunahan pa siya nung kai"]}

{"dialog": ["Can she just use her real name, ang baduy ng fyang, seriously.", "Feeling ko mas relatable kasi pag nickname gamit. Like someone na kilala mo lang. Gaya ni Maine Mendoza/Meng"]}

{"dialog": ["Who the ef is Fyang?", "Dont bother looking her up. The algorithm will ruin you hahahahah. Just get away from here and continue with your precious life"]}

{"dialog": ["HAHHA trip trip lang yan. Mga faney kasi niya wala sa lugar makapag comment kaya ayan for all na ang eabab na si fyangie..\n\n\nIsa pa tong maries cabral as a pet peeve na sya kairita haha", "Anji > fyang\n\nMercedes and hasna >>>>  maries"]}

{"dialog": ["Pano ba ipronounce pangalan niya? Ef-yang o Fiyang? Haha sorry di ko siya kilala pero lagi ko nakikita pangalan niya sa tiktok", "Fiyang"]}

{"dialog": ["Not a fan but honestly shes not just maputi admit it or not miss girl got that face card. Maybe just not enough for showbiz but shes not average. Although yes, shes not good at interviews like kai but she can host. She goes well with AC bonifacio. Maybe lets not force the hate train and let the girl live lol", "No I dont hate her. Di ko lang talaga ma-gets bakit sya kailangan hanapin everywhere. Hosting no. Saw her several times sa asap pero wala talaga. Medyo cringe. But the face card yes. So aside sa dance dance sa tiktok shell do well sa prints."]}

{"dialog": ["wala tlg common sense ibang matatanda dito, obvious naman na humor lng nila na hanapin si fyang kung saan saan. patola din e", "Ay matalino to sya. Anong gulay kaya to?"]}

{"dialog": ["Alexa Ilacad and Belle Mariano", "Si alexa talaga sayang", "nanghihinayang ako Kay Alexa,,malaki potential,magaling Naman umarte,kumakanta pa,,sana magkaron din sya Ng big break at wag na itambal Kay KD"]}

{"dialog": ["Kim Molina. \n\nDi ako updated pero parang puro acting projects nakikita ko sa kanya madalas eh. Pero of course, she was known as a singer naman dati na rin, kaya dko sure if valid tong sagot ko hahaha.", "She is known for portraying Aileen in the long-running Filipino stage musical Rak Of Aegis."]}

{"dialog": ["Ysabel Ortega, sng hina ng GMA sa marketing", "hindi rin kasi nya ata focus ang pag aartista since gusto nya ata maging lawyer"]}

{"dialog": ["Maris Racal. Multi-talented talaga. May phase sa career nya na active sya parehas as a singer/songwriter and as an actress. Namention ko na to before na deserve nya maging next Toni G, I mean, ang magkaron ng sold out concert (basta mabigyan lang sya ng hit song) at maging blockbuster queen (hoping na eto ang maging next achievement nya). \n\n\nSue Ramirez. Na highlight na before pagiging singer nya sayang hindi nagtuloy tuloy. Galing din magrap. Love her version of Love the way you Lie.", "Hmmmm. Uno problemo mi amiga"]}

{"dialog": ["Vivoree, Maris Racal, and May May Entrata", "May album na si Maymay diba amakabogera pa song nya then Vivoree nasa musical play naman Tabing Ilog."]}

{"dialog": ["Enrique Gil. Hes a good dancer and charismatic on stage. Idk if he can sing tho but he has a stage presence. \n\nSa korea, ginagawan nila to ng paraan ehh kaya nagkaroon ng position dati. Yung iba nga visual ang position ehh pero nawala rin after 3rd gen afaik? \n\nDara is not good at singing, she can hold a tune but she was charismatic and can command a fanclub like cult leader hence she was put in a girl group and named as the visual.", ">Idk if he can sing tho but he has a stage presence. \n\nIdk if he can sing too, pero iirc, he released a song before. Mobe ang title"]}

{"dialog": ["si Belle Mariano di naman marketed as a singer si Belle nung nag uumpisa sya", "belle mariano, surprisingly. with the right songs, she could me. i like her more as a popstar than an actress kasi she looks comfortable and in her element than acting. magaling din naman siya but she has a bright future in singing."]}

{"dialog": ["Kanina saw the Wish Bus ni Julie Anne, wala man lang taong nanonood", "eh???? why Naman?:("]}

{"dialog": ["Nag heal din sya ng inner child nya", "Why?", "nag celebrate ng birthday sa jollibee since before mayayaman lang nakaka afford", "Oh Akala ko mayaman sila kasi naka abroad trip, like sa Paris bago pa man maging Bini. \n\n Saw this sa interview with Karen Davila on YT."]}

{"dialog": ["Ang konti talaga ng comments pag positive ang post about BINI", "Gusto nila ikakasisira, yung parang overrated ang bini ganun, mga hampas lupa naman in real life", "I agree. Sa totoo lang, mas squammy pa ang ibang member ng chikaph kaysa sa tinutukoy nila. Sorry not sorry."]}

{"dialog": ["Comment section:\n\nMadaming mag hahate sa positive thing about BINI.\n\nActual comment section as of 7:16 PM (checked hanggang baba)  \nWala pa namang nag hahate \n\nHahahahahah", ">ang tahimik talaga kapag positive yung post about BINI.\n\n\n\n>Deadma lang tong ganitong post dito\n\n\n\n>Ang konti talaga ng comments pag positive ang post about BINI \n\nIba yan sa sinasabi mong \"madaming maghahate sa positive thing about BINI.\" Kung di mo alam pagkakaiba, ewan ko na lang sa'yo.  \nTotoo naman yung sinabi nila, kita mo 800+ upvotes ng post pero wala pa sa 50 yung comments. At least may hiya yung mga BINI haters para hindi magkalat dito."]}

{"dialog": ["this is something not everyone could see, Blooms lang. mas kita padin ng non-fans and haters ang bad side ng BINI kahit mas lamang yung good sides nila. Blooms na nandito sa ChikaPH, don't expect too much positivity about BINI kasi majority sa kanila dito e ayaw sa BINI.", "ginawa kasing hate train ang sub na to na konting actions lg ng bini ay big deal na"]}

{"dialog": ["Bawal positive dito dapat hate lang saka hilaan pababa ng kapwa babae at babae at heart", "Inggit tawag dyan hahahhahaa"]}

{"dialog": ["ang tahimik talaga kapag positive yung post about BINI.", "Nag down vote yung mga puro chismis at hate lang ang gusto"]}

{"dialog": ["May jowa yan si Joshua diba", "Oo non showbiz gusto ni Joshua n low profile. May gf tpos naglilike ng pic. Di na nagbago .", "Masama ba maglike ng pics ng co-celebrity?\n\nPutangina nyo ang totoxic nyo", "Masama kng may gf ka at may history yung guy nag ddm sa ibang girl while still in a relationship. Umpisa like like lng harmless daw pero aunod dm na", "nag-dm din sya kay shuvee (gmas new artist)", "When ito? Dba . Ugali n nya yan kya ito paglilike nya sa pics ni aiah ay di harmless lalo n pic lng ni aiah ang ni lilike nya among bini members.  May nakita pa ako vid nun asap l.a nun finale song nla n lht ng artist nasa stage nasa likod sya ni aiah tpos hinawakan nya balikat ni aiah di ko lng binigyan ng meaning pero now may kasama paglike ng pics. Feeling ko dumadamoves ang mokong. \nDba kng matino ka lalaki at may gf ikaw mismo ang medyo lalayo sa ibang girls lalo na non showbiz ang gf mo.", "Nov 2023 lumabas yung article. Nagdm sya sa bikini photo ni shuvee \"This Is my mine\" sabi daw sa dm ni joshua", "Ano di ko gets this is my mine ? Yan tlga ang dmed nya? Grammatical  incorrect pa. Kaya di ko tlga gets kng bkt sya pinatulan ni Julia. \n\nNaalala ko tuloy yng isang convo nla ni Jane sa pbb ls. Nakalimutan ko n kng paano n pnta yng convo nla sa ID basta di nya alam kng ano ibig sbhn abbreviation(ID)n yan. Di ko alam kng nagtatanga tangahan sya ondi nya lng tlga alam.\n\nKaya tuwing may nababasa ako rumors n he is dating or gf nya this highly educated girl. Lagi may question mark kasi sabaw tlga sya. may sentiment nga sa main thread  ng pbb sa pex. N mahaba ang patience ni Jane ksi napapagtiisan nya kausap si Joshua."]}

{"dialog": ["Joshua is the type of guy na hindi mo gugustuhin maging friend or barkada ng boyfriend mo", "True. And feel ko enabler yan kasi friend yan ni DJ, sila silang tatlo ni Zanjoe palagi magkakasama so may alam yan sa mga ginagawang kalokohan ni DJ.", "Hetong topic nato was brought up before nung peak ng KathNiel break-up"]}

{"dialog": ["Ay nako ipagdasal nyo hanggang ganyan lng at wla n sya gawin. Babaero yan si Joshua. Kng napanood nyo season nya napaka red flag nya . Ginamit nya si jane para pagselosin si loisa then vice versa na pansin ni Jane ang galawan nya kya pinagsbihan. After nya mag I love kay Jane Jane sa loob ng bahay paglabas nla di n pinansin Jane tpos naging sla ni loisa nagbreak sla dhl may nilalabdi yta ibang babae. Same with julia baretto may ka dm uta ibang girl ang mokong.  And may interview sya with boy abunda yta yun tinanong sya kng ano ang turn off nya ang sagot nya kpg n wla n yng mystery dun sa girl. Walking red flag", "Malandi na sya ever since. Sobrang pa boy next door na came from humble beginnings yung paimage sa kanya ng ABS. Like nung guesting nya sa Magandang Buhay with Julia at mga hosts, pumunta pa sila sa public school nung elem pa si Joshua. Pa next big star na yung trato kay JG that time. Namention din sa interview kasama yung adviser ni JG na nagkagf na sya nung elem. Cringe lang yung part na yon kasi parang pinapaselos si Julia that time. \n\nI'm not a fan pero hinanap ko sa YT yung episode na yon kasi late ko lang nalaman na schoolmate ko pala sya nung elem. Pero sure akong yung datingan ni Joshua, ay aware sya na kaya nyang magpafall at feeling ko pumapasok lang din sya sa school para lumandi just like kung anong ginawa nya sa PBB.", "Di n sya teenager nun naging sla ni Julia. Galawan prin nya pagselosin ang mga babae. So ugali n tlga nya yan. Napaka ewan pinag aaway ang mga babae.\n\n Isa sa mga dhilan kya may silent war si jane at loisa nun pbb dhl sa kakagawan nya. Alam mo yun tipo isang araw yng atensyon nya n sa iyo tpos bigla n lng mag iiba iihip ang hangin di k n masado papansinin mappnta sa ibang babae . Ang hirap ng ganyan sa loob ng bahay ni kuya na kyo kayo lng magkakasama magnify yng feelings mo tpos mga teenager b that time.\n\nSadboi din yan eh. Kpg di nakuha ang gusto paawa effect. Manipulative at gaslighter ang ganyan eh. Di ko alam kng bkt pinatulan julia. Ksi gosh base sa pbb nya wla kwenta kausap."]}

{"dialog": ["Who even has time to check this lmao. Some people can't get a life", "+ yung mga nakaka notice na nag unfollow-an out of nowhere, without even an issue surrounding the involved parties like, naka-on ba notif sa inyo", "same thoughts  parang 24/7 nakabantay sa soc med activity haha, di ko alam kung mabibilib ako or macri-creep out hahaha"]}

{"dialog": ["Anong height ni Aiah?", "5'6", "I am 5'6 nakita ko sya personal and she's just 5'4. Usually female artists exaggerate their height by an inche or two"]}

{"dialog": ["Remember when Joshua was still in a relationship with Julia and nag DM siya sa isang girl? Malas niya lang si girl nilantad ang kalandian niya. Ending umiyak si Joshua sa show ni Boy Abunda  what a clown.", "oh god yeah hahahahaha. thanks for reminding me. boy has a green flag & soft boi branding going on but he's actually a very ???????? guy. pbb days pa man, kakaiba na talaga ugali niya"]}

{"dialog": ["This could be harmless likes but may history na kasi ng ganito si Joshua during Joshlia days pa", "not just Joshlia days, pero PBB days palang."]}

{"dialog": ["Pag si Joshua next pinartner kay Kathryn di ako kikiligin hahahaha ekis na sa kinikilig ang tumbong sa iba habang may jowa pa", "Wag na wag talaga ipapartner or bigyan ng series yung dalawa jusko napanood ko lang sa news kanina gusto daw ni JG na maka work si KB. Walang dating"]}

{"dialog": ["Hay nako yan ka na naman Juswa. naalala ko nung sila pa ni Julia nag comment siya sa photo ng random bikini pic ng girl sa ig. (but comment in a way na ni dm nya yung comment nya sa pic parang ganun). ang dahilan pa kasi nagandahan daw sa shadows ng halaman ahahhaha OK", "Magpapalusot pa ang kuya eh, huling huli na cheating yung ginagawa. Pinapalabas na compliment lang daw hahaha"]}

{"dialog": ["Hindi ko gets how Joshua gets all these girls. Parang kaklase mo lang sa high school nung jeje days.", "Kaya nga eh. Yung kahit bihisan mo ng maayos pero ganun pa rin yung nakikita mong behavior nya. Jejemon talaga"]}

{"dialog": ["Its just a like tho wag niyo lagyan meaning parang di naman big deal", "Ay nako may history yan noh."]}

{"dialog": ["Dream daw nya makawork si kathryn. E ang totoo, di siya makapalag kay daniel. Gusto nya pormahan before si kathryn, suntukin siya ni tumbs", "Both naman mukhang lampa. Buti pa si Kath & Julia, ang sisipag mag work out kaya toned yung katawan."]}

{"dialog": ["Yung ginagawang punching bag si tumbong dito ang favorite ko  DASURV NA DASURV HAHAHAHHAHAHAHA", "Yes!! Nasusuka ako pag me nababasa akong anything good about him sa fb. \n\nLike, wtf. Delusional pa din mga fans neto?!", "You wont believe how deranged his supporters are sa x. \n\nShade ng shade kay Kath (calling her names dahil sa certain scenes from hla), sinasabing magiging flop na daw ang hla kasi wala nang support from them (this is coming mostly from kns na naging d fans nalang) pero lol karma nga naman, super blockbuster ang hla. \nEwan ko ba kung anong nakita nila kay tumbz para suportahan pa rin siya hanggang ngayon.", "There were circulating photos na chat between kathniel fans (na mukhang hindi na ngayon) na nagsabi na si Kathryn ang reason of the breakup. Like some sort of hindi pa ready si Kathryn to commit to marriage and nag-NO sa live in setup proposal ni Daniel. May part pa run na na-depress daw si Daniel at nagkulong sa condo dahil dinecline hahaha. Chika is galing sa camp ni Daniel yun to tarnish Kathryn. Paniwalang-paniwala kasi sila dun hahahaha", "Sila sila na lang din talaga ang nag uutuan noh lol"]}

{"dialog": ["Kaartehan ni Bea A", "Kaartehan saan? Parang di ako aware jan sorry! Mas aware ako sa mga flop projects nya huhu", "Nung kumalat unang pics ni dom at sue, nag story si bea w/ her gay looking \"friend\" na sweet sila. Lol pakapapansin", "Owww hahaha. Ayaw palamang ni ate gorl hahahahaha", "True hahaha fe"]}

{"dialog": ["Yung kay Gretchen at Remulla pero wala na follow up charot", "Context pls.", "Wala na ata yung post pero may redditor na nagshare dito na nakita silang magkasama sa airport iirc"]}

{"dialog": ["Mag-iisang taon ng puyat sa KathDen!", "Ako 4 days pa lang pero hirap na hirap na ko", "Hahahah naku mukhang maeextend pa ang pagpupuyat natin since sobrang successful ng HLA for sure may next project ang KathDen next year!"]}

{"dialog": ["Eksena ng isang politiko lalo na ito recent meltdown niya.", "bakit downvoted ka? haha. upvote ko nga haha", "Hahah di ko alam. Thanks sa upvote :)"]}

{"dialog": ["Si Hope at jowa niyang scammer. Nung una di talaga ako makapaniwala na papatulan niya yung ganun?", "Da who is the jowang scammer?", "Jeff Oh"]}

{"dialog": ["Sino si Tumbs?", "Daniel Padilla (in relation sa old audio recording nya na kinikilig daw yung tumbong nya kay Jasmine Curtis)", "Ohhhhh I see, hahahaha thank you sa info, hindi ako updated dito"]}

{"dialog": ["Pamilya ni Carlos Yulo. Lumabas lalo kung gano ka toxic ang mga boomer.", "This! I really feel sorry for Carlos but at the same time i dont mind na lumaki to para lang maging aware na yung mga susunod na generation. Blood is not always thicker than water at giving back to parents should be done out of love at hindi utang na loob."]}

{"dialog": ["Daniel Padilla as a red flat : proven\n\nFinally lumabas na yung baho nya. Nung tumbong scandal nya palang, dapat nacancel na yan e.", "Truths. KathNiel fans dreamboy is the scariest and ugliest guy"]}

{"dialog": ["Alice Guos Senate Hearing. Si Cassy Ong na puro pa cute. Anything about senate hearing. Nakakastress, pero I want to be socially aware.", "Same AR dela cerna harry roque. \nDan fernandez Ivana Alawi \nPhilip Salvador sa senado\nLuis sa pulitika\n\nSobrang dugyot ng pulitika"]}

{"dialog": ["Carlos-Angelica-Chloe.\n\nIt was the perfect issue. It uprooted decades of toxic family issues sa lahat ng pamilya. Bawat tao nakakarelate sa kanila kahit gaano ka successful. Everyone has had money issues with their family. Dumagdag pa yung gf angle.", "Parang pwedeng gawan ng thesis to ng Psychology students. HAHAHA!"]}

{"dialog": ["Kath and her ex and the girlies involved\n\n\nOrange and Lemon versus the girlie on sheeps clothing", "After Orange&Lemons issue, tapos sinundan pa nung kasama dapat sya sa BBM concert, biglang nawala sa sirkulasyon si ate girl. Daming nawalan ng gana eh."]}

{"dialog": ["The news about Liam pained me.", "Hey. Same."]}

{"dialog": ["Hiwalayang Tumbz at Kath lol\nAt ang tambalang #KathDen akalain mo nga nman na magtatambal pla sila", "Eto din yun e, parang bugbog na bugbog na image ni Jag pero si Kath parang nagka make over, not just physically pero mentally, emotionally pati financially na din sa dami ng naging endorsements at projects nya nung nakalaya na sya sa mabahong leather jacket."]}

{"dialog": ["1. Heart Evangelista vs Pia Wurtzbach supremacy (r/chikaphpiavsheart)\n\n2. Naglabasan baho ni Pia. Lahat may kinalaman sa pagnanakaw, pagsisinungaling at pang aagaw\n\n* Contacts ni Heart\n* Seat ni Heart sa fashion shows\n* Brand deals ni Heart\n* Fashion outfits ni Heart\n* Instagram captions ni Heart\n* Carolina Herrera video ni @stylenotcom\n* Candy sa tindahan hahahahahaha\n* Credit grabber na siya daw ang nag pave ng way, at siya daw ang first ever Filipina sa kung ano anong bagay\n* Nikipag sex sa tent with her best friend's boyfriend, Gerald Anderson, sa shoot ng My Perfect You\n\n3.Carlos Yulo vs Angelica Yulo \n\n4. Ivanna Alawi nabukong kabit ni Mayor Benitez sa airport \n\n5. 4th Impact 200 Shitzus\n\n6. Burning Sun Scandal \n\n7. Alice Guo case\n\n8. Quiboloy case\n\n9. Marcoses and Dutertes falling out\n\n10. Liam Payne's death", "May sub na? Hahaha"]}

{"dialog": ["Grabe si momsh. Her fans claim that shes palaban. Pero palengekera levels na itey. Haha I distinctly remember this. She really had a warfreak era. Kalurky. I wonder if nag mellow down na now that shes a mother", "Nakalimutan niyo ata na tao din yan. Kung pulit ulit sayo ginagawa yang mga ganyan, kahit ako malamang murahin ko din sila mayat maya pag napuno nako. Hahaha", "Ako during campaign period ni Leni lumabas yung pagka warfreak ko eh! hahhaahahahah!  Kasi hindi sa lahat ng pagkakataon mapipigilan mo yung sarili.  Sometimes mapupuno ka din lalo mga kung bobo kausap mo tapos fake news peddler pa!"]}

{"dialog": ["Fave bini! And id say isa siya sa pinaka-sophisticated na members, and sensible tooo", "True!!!! Siya fave ko sa bini kasi sophisticated at may substance", "true aside from that siya yung may own life outside work and hindi personality ang pagiging gg member", "Yes, she's kalog, but not rude hehe! Happy to see her during early days nila kasi a friend of my boyfriend works at ABS/ Star Magic (basta either diyan), I got a free VIP Pass. And wow, Aiah, I'd say, is the most genuine, beautiful, natural, elegant, and mukhang hindi maingay! (Bilang naiirita agad sa ingay)\n\nBUt i love the girls nonetheless!! They all have their \"quality\" qualities. If hindi Jhoanna ang leader, I'd say qualified si Aiah. :))", "Why nga pala si jho ang naging leader sorry i'm not into bini and idk about their lore that much. Also, I think kaya tahimik si aiah is bc she came from a diff city ganyan kami I'm from cebu and moved to manila so my life kinda changed rin.", "I have no idea rin actually!!! I consider myself a casual listener lang na medyo observant haha", "oh okie pero mas maboka ata si jho among the girls that's why siya yung naging leader feel ko lang naman I mean siya yung alam agad what to say sa acceptance speech and such."]}

{"dialog": ["Err this is in a positive side and wont gain traction  unless by some miracle.", "Nadali mo! Hahahaha mga tao sa sub na to pag BINI (or anyone in general) napopost allergic pag positive eh. Nanginginig pa mga yan kasi dapat panay bashing lang ang magtrend bwhahaha", "Pag Daniel Padilla at Bini matic baha ang comments hahahahahha", "Baha ng negative comments pa talaga!\n\nAyan na sila nag dodownvote LOL"]}

{"dialog": ["Ay beh dedma ang mga mosang d2 pag ganyang positive news about Bini, same nung may nagpost na nagdonate sila sa mga nasalanta ng bagyo", "Yeah, right. Kahit nung may positive post tungkol sa kanila last time about sa GBV dedmakels ang mga hinayupak. I just know they're same with others who are waiting for their downfall. Pinoy tings.", "Why do you need their comments tho? You cannot please everybody. Thats the truth. \n\nSo what if dedma sila sa any positive post? That does not make BINI or any person any less. Who are those mosangs anyway? They dont matter. :)", "Yup these non-doers dont matter. They are just miserable fcks projecting their misery. May nakita akong profile, mental health advocate sa ibang subs pero grabe maka bash dito. May pa show compassion pa daw na comment puro lip service lang pala."]}

{"dialog": ["Meron din ganitong ganap kay Justin ng SB19 recently.", "Ito yung chinito cutie?", "Yep sya nga."]}

{"dialog": ["Demanding your idol get praised is so off-putting. Just read the comments here. Magiging less ba yung tinulong niya if people don't recognize her good deed? Diba hindi? Kung mabuti ka talagang tao, which I think she is, wala kang pakielam if you get praised for your good deeds or not. The good deed is the reward itself. Doing good and expecting something in return is not doing good. Stop making her look bad by complaining about how her good deeds aren't being recognized enough. Instead of letting her celebrate her good deed in peace kayo na mismo nagpapasok ng negative energy by demanding recognition.", "bakit daming downvotes nito? eto pinaka may sense na comment.", "Braindead cultists don't understand it kasi. They just proved the comment's point."]}

{"dialog": ["Dedma yung mga maaasim dito na haters ng bini at ni daniel ah? Hahaha", "Tbf, there's nothing to like about Daniel.", "True valid yung kay daniel. Yung hate kay colet halatang mga bagito lang sa Twitter palibhasa mga palamunin pa sa bahay."]}

{"dialog": ["Shes my ultimate bias  I stan a bisaya queen!", "My favorite too!"]}

{"dialog": ["Her and Jhoanna", "My two biases"]}

{"dialog": ["See di nag tretrending, why? because Filipinos like to see wrong from good individuals, then try their hardest to look for the good in the most evil individuals. This is Philippines, we need to get nuked cleanse the cesspool we call the pearl of the east.", "Filipinos are good at pointing wrong jusko .wala ng pag asa."]}

{"dialog": ["Di ako fan ng Bini pero uupvote ko kasi sobrang haters ng mga tao dito sa sub eh. Para lalo lang silang mainis.", "Mukhang matagal pa magsusuffer mga haters. Tagal ko na nang hinihintay yung downfall na sinasabi nila."]}

{"dialog": ["W move Aiah. If only Elyu is near to help them out :)", "Afaik, her team doesn't allow volunteers pa who aren't originally part of her team. Also, di pa rin daw tumatanggap ng donations. Maloi and Colet were also able to join before."]}

{"dialog": ["to be fair, it's not entirely hating on bini but rather pointing out the questionable things that other members do. as far as i know, isa si aiah sa bini member na walang issue around her. ang issue lang na narinig ko involving her was yung sa fan na nagbigay ng puppy sa kaniya which is not even an issue sa kaniya but rather sa fan. while i understand your concern na puro hate ang nare-receive ng bini dito kasi people tend to generalize bini as a whole kapag may issue ang isa sa kanila, you also have to understand na yung action ng isa sa kanila ay nagrereflect sa kanila as a group simply because they function as a group. kaya nga sa kpop industry kapag may issue ang isang member ng group, confirmed na or not, tinatanggal agad kasi nga naaapektuhan yung buong group dahil sa action ng isa. buti nga hindi kasing lala ng sa sokor ang cancel culture dito sa pilipinas kaya hindi uso yung magkick out sa group at ginoglorify pa ng iba yung actions nila. madalas kong nakikita dito pag hin...", "Agree!"]}

{"dialog": ["They'd post something good about their idols, tapos \"labas haters\" ang hamon. Why not just use the platform to show good vibes? Ang toxic na nga ng ibang members ng bini, ung ganitong matino, yung fans ang nakakabasura.\n\nWhy do the fans need the validation na \"perfect\" ung idols nila?\n\nPag walang positive comments sa nega side ng bini na posts, they imagine na \"walang masabi\" yung haters. \n\nPag walang negative comments sa nice posts about bini, they same the same thing. \n\nSame with other delulu fandoms, cult-like.\n\nTheir mental gymnastics deserve a gold medal.", "Its the irony of it. \n\nThis sub wants a perfect prim & proper idol so they NITPICK every action but go silent when good deeds are done."]}

{"dialog": ["Yeah kaya nga SALN gusto ko makita kasi public doc yun di ba?  Gano ba sila kapera para afford nila mag-maintain ng legal at super expensive na side chick? Saka enough ba yung income from  business nila to sustain that? \n\nSama mo na yan si Daniel Fernando, oo binata nga so technically walang kabit pero kung totoo yung allowance at car nung starlet, bwisit sya! For sure wala naman naipong malaki yan from Scorpio Nights alone para ma-afford ang allowance. Kaya pala ako gigil kasi Gov namin yan!  Yung Bulacan kungdi binabaha wala man lang matinong hospital yung ibang towns.", "Digiplus palang tiba tiba na si benitez. Kaya niya talaga magkaside chick, pero ang problema nagagamit yung digiplus plus other businesses para sabihing di sya magnanakaw na pulitiko... lol nakakapagtaka din na 200k lang allowance niya eh MIL ko nga yan ang allowance pero wala pa yun sa kuko ng mga benitez. Sinungaling din si legal wife. Pinababa niya yan para di sila masilip. \n\nAng wish ko is magdrama pa sila para kung sino man kalaban nila hits them when vulnerable at makita mga anomalya nila"]}

{"dialog": ["ABS-CBN is the king of PR kaya not surprising na ganito atake nila sa issue ni Ivana (downplaying the issue, posting a photo of her in white to portray innocence and purity). They really are good at boosting the image of their artists. Why do you think mas sikat at kilala ang mga big stars ng ABS kesa GMA? It's because of their promotional prowess. \n\nMagaling din sila magsweep ng issues ng artists nila under the rug. Remember the maris controversy? Yeah, it already slipped the minds of most people. Maris still has a thriving career. Business as usual for maris. It might go the same way for Ivana in the future.", "Maris is talented and beautiful. Hindi puro pasexy. This has neither talent nor beauty. Grabe thirst trap nya IG. Pero not really that beautiful sa ibang angles. Angle angle lang char. Also with Maris, check comment section, dami pa rin panghuhusga sa kanya. Maris thrives because of talent. Kaya mas madali downfall nitong si IA. Hindi rin ganun kawalan si IA kasi at the time of Maris scandal talaga back to back ung projects nya. IA, ano ba meron? Tapos na mga tv stint nya. So not so much kawalan to invest on her as they did Maris. Ung jowa nya ang sasalba sa kanya."]}

{"dialog": ["So, how can these AI replace journalists? (Actually, I'm really curious about this since I think AI has unlimited potential in the future) \n\nCause the way you say it, even if it's data driven, it still needs human intervention to collect and input the data.\n\nLet's say there is hostage-taking in, let's say, Sulu. How can AI go to that location, interview relevant people, and deliver the news straight from the source? We still need journalists to do that, right? No amount of AI right now can do that on-field data gathering.\n\nAnd if we need human intervention (journalists) to collect and input the data, then how can we be sure that the data is factual and not biased, since it came from a journalist? How can AI verify, for example, that the events that happened were factually true if it relies on the data given to it, since it's all about the data? Does it eventually go back to the principle of Garbage In, Garbage Out kasi there is still human intervention required...", "Actually, people in the industry nowadays and people who knows dont give a fuck a about journalist. They know they can be easily be paid. \n\nAI have more invasive and factual findings. And non biased reports\n\nNowadays only thepeople who dont know listens to the journalists. \n\nFact finding/research is more data driven rather biased infused findings of people/humans.\n\nYou have no idea how AI/data mining have becomr so invasive nowadays.\n\nThey get actual facts without even getting interviews. Even interviews doesnt mean they speaking the truth.\nInterviews are like PR release. I rather rely on the actual data than lip service. \n\nYou have no idea talaga on how advance is technology nowadays. Everyone listens.\n\nBasta in my industry which is data. Data collected by humans are unrealiable. Thats a given fact. Ill rather believe in data thats not being given. Ill rather believe in data that has been collected unknowingly, without the bias."]}

{"dialog": ["Di ko gets issue ng mga tao, di talaga ako fan ni ivana pero at this issue parang gets ko sya. If hindi nya pinasuyo/inutos sa driver nya instead yung order ibalik, machacharge sa staff yun, 17k yun, ok lang senyo macharge sa staff yun? Also, tama yung iba, work naman ng driver magdrive at magantay, naawa kayo sa driver dahil naghintay pero di kayo naaawa sa staff sakaling icancel at sakanila icharge yung bill na 17k lang naman diba. Same thing with people saying icancel nalang, what would you think happen if icancel nila e out na yung ibang food tapos fault ng store sya, sinong magsasuffer ng loss? Hindi ba staff padin? Di ko talaga kayo gets, at this moment mas gets ko si ivana.", "The way she expressed her thoughts is kind of hard to dissect already. But imo once you send your order back, even if thats your personal driver or not theres already a possibility of being charged tothe person who made the mistake or will be just on the businesss wastage. But is it possible for one restaurant to make an order within 9hrs wait period? Will you let an order take that long? Or just demand a money back if the situation is radical enough. Its well within your paragraph na nga eh other food are already out. So pwede naman mag demand ng refund for the orders that were not released. Diba? But then her other story here says eto na yung 17k? So seems like shes just having a mood swing or something coz honestly her dilemma can be easily resolved through proper communication with the restaurant."]}

{"dialog": ["Ivana created that story to explain where her money was coming from. Pero in reality mukhang galing sa mga sugar daddy nya na politician.  Well if she is selling her body to supoort her family,  eh hustle nya yon.   Sana nga lang eh nagimbento sya ng backstory na medyo credible.  Kasi if you check her vlog, yong rental na apartment nila sa Sta. Mesa pang-low income talaga.  No sign of luxury.  Maliit at magulo.  Pangmahirap. Tapos nong namatay yong tatay biglang pinamanahan sya ng yaman a5 mansyon sa Morocco at sya lang ang binigyan  when she has 3 other siblings, two of which are older than her.  Isa don yon kuya nya.  Makes you wonder for a patriarchal society like Morocco, bakit sa babae ipapamana yong pera ng tatay nya.  Doesn't make sense.", "ang sabi raw kasi niya siya nagpaiwan sa dad niya before he died. nauna other siblings, tas siya na. binuhay sila ni mona as a child actress and nung nagkasakit na si mona, siya naman ang kunayod (this was when their dad died and nagkapera na sila). idk im not a fan of her so idk how credible she is but i always thought na when i first saw her in sino ang may sala, she didnt really have a luxurious air around her but parang starlet/sexy star. even until now. she still has the same vibes. turns out, kabit pala talaga ng mga politicians."]}

{"dialog": ["Tapos hindi naman sya yung eldest in the first place. Ang panganay nila si Almira, second si Hash, third sya and bunso si Mona. Sabi rin nya, sa kanya pinamana ang lahat like why? Hindi nga sya panganay, hindi rin sya nagiisang lalaking anak, hindi rin nya nakasama ng matagal ang papa nya kasi umuwi sya ng Pinas, paano sya magiging favorite?\n\nHeiress kunwari, eh yung bahay nila sa Bahrain renovated na sa vlog nya para magmukhang mamahalin. Tapos hindi naman kalakihan, standard house lang dun.", "Parang nag usap nlng sila ng pamilya nya na ganyan ng \"kwento\" kuno nila. Wala na sila choice kasi, si ivana tlga nag papasok ng malaking pera sa pamilya nila. Kaya pinangatawanan nalang nila yang narrative na yan.\nImposible na balcksheep ka, suwail ka pero at, the same time responsible kang anak. Make it make sense ika nga.\nKung totoo ung sinasabi nya, at kung ako tatay nya, di ko iiwan kay ivana ung buo kong kayamanan lalo Nat sakit sya sa ulo nung teens pa sya. Knowing na business man kuno ako.\nDiba...\nKunwari nalang, sinasakyan natin sya haha. Time will reveal kung ano tlga sya. Mae expose at maeexpose yan."]}

{"dialog": ["And one thing na pinagtataka ko is even if you're born rich, hindi ka naman for sure hahayaan ng billionaire dad mo to join showbiz or start a vlog since that can compromise the family's privacy. Lalo na mga rich Arabs, kulang na lang sa ilalim ng lupa na sila dumaan just to keep themselves private.Kadalasan pa e nagiging cause of kapraningan ng rich dads yung mga anak nilang babae.\n\n\nKaya hindi rin ako bilib sa Morrocan billionaire narrative nila.", ">even if youre born rich, hindi ka naman for sure hahayaan ng billionaire dad mo to join showbiz or start a vlog since that can compromise the familys privacy\n\nYou raise a very good point that I can confirm myself because its literally applicable to me hahaha. My parents are both businesspeople, with my dad even being a former network executive (wont specify where to protect my privacy, but suffice to say he was pretty high up and knows the whos who of the entertainment industry), who have explicitly forbidden me from entering that industry or even dating/marrying a celebrity/vlogger. We value our privacy very much and the same is true for most well off families."]}

{"dialog": ["Basically, Ivana like2 months ago? posted a video recalling how out of nowhere, her abdomen had fluid build up that was also leaking to other parts of her body. She said she felt like her organs were drowning. Her stomach grew over 5 inches wider. Doctors had to poke a hole near her stomach to empty it out. Hospitalized for 7 days & she literally almost died. \n\nDont know if it should be attributed to kulam but i think thats what OP was referring to lol", "I don't believe in kulam until  I've been in a province na kilala sa ganyan pero actually maski yung mga tagaroon sa probinsyang yun takot din sila magpunta sa diumanoy specific lugar ng mga mangkukulam. They have something they call na 'respect' dun sa lugar, tapos alam nila na nakakapangkulam talaga yung mga tao sa parang village na yun. Pero contrary to what we know, iba pala presyo nun haha 5 digits minimum tapos thru networks, yung kahit may pambayad ka pag wala ka koneksyon sa mga tagaroon mismo wala kang access sa lehitimong mangkukulam. And para silang 'vigilante' ba tawag dun, kasi gusto nila is valid daw ang reason mo before they can perform that, hindi pwedeng dahil naiinggit ka lang."]}

{"dialog": [">Eto ung nahihiwagaan ako eh like bakit pumayag yan na ganyan ang setup na wala pang script eh dating CEO yan ng ABS.\n\nIn case you're not aware, ABSCBN is full-on grooming Coco as FPJ's successor in every aspect of Filipino society that the latter has penetrated when he was still alive. \n\nAnd one of the things they are pushing Coco to emulate from FPJ is the sense of developing his own creative license, like FPJ used to do in his movies. Kaya may basbas ni Charo lahat ng napapanood natin sa BQ. \n\n (TRIVIA: Ronwaldo Martin, Coco's real-life younger brother who plays Santino in BQ, got his screen name from FPJ's alt name that he uses as director of his own movies, \"Ronwaldo Reyes\")", "Kaso, kelangan pa rin talaga ng actual creative support. FPJ had the likes of Carlo Caparas and Pablo Gomez to help flesh out his stories. \n\nCoco needs that similar team with good creative freedom. Case in point, BQ's three main storylines (Tanggol's gang, Rigouuur/Marites/Lena, Ramon's syndicate) are so disjointed that it can sometimes feel like watching three different shows in one episode. A good creative team can better tie that up.\n\nAs a comparison, while we may make fun of it, Probinsyano actually had a more coherent story. Kasi all the side stories ultimately tie back to Cardo's main story.", ">As a comparison, while we may make fun of it, Probinsyano actually had a more coherent story. Kasi all the side stories ultimately tie back to Cardo's main story.\n\nAgree. And yung Probinsyano, every guest star, may iba ibang issues about society ang natatackle. Human trafficking, drugs, gambling, politics, lgbt, etc. Lalo na the first seasons. Natandaan ko pa mentally challenged si Paulo Avelino dun nung sya ang guest tapos si Juday, may multiple personality disorder.\n\nDi yung basta makikisali lang sa barilan."]}

{"dialog": ["si rk bagatsing yung anak nyang namatay kasi sumugod sya sa quiapo at nakasagupa mga tropa ni tanggol. di ko lang maalala kung si tanggol yung nagbababaril sa kanya. pero naalala ko talaga yung usapan nila ng nanay nya na parating na galing abroad yung sister nya. inuutusan sya non ni Olga na maghanda ng mabuti para di nya malaman yung family business nila (ang cliche putek). hindi ko yan makakalimutan kasi sabi ng lolo ko baka raw si mokang yun hahahaha sabi ko naman di pwede kasi nasa abroad nga. so kung may isa pa syang anak na babae baka maging kalabtim uli ni coco melon in the future, baka mamamatay din. hay naku po.", "Wag naman sana! Jusko lahat na lang gusto ata tikman ni Coco CHAREEENG HAHAHA! Sana kontrabida din siya if ever, makakatulong ni Olga! Para maiba naman, parang maganda kung ang final boss ay babae naman, naiiba sa mga cliche action movies/series. Tsaka Olgas character is good on paper, perfect fit for the main antagonist role. She have all the right reasons para maging kontrabida. Yung character na Ramon (Christopher) medyo weak sa totoo lang, tsaka wala syang rason to hate Tanggol.\nMatagal-tagal na rin tayong walang kinaiinisan na kontrabida sa mga series lately hahaha."]}

{"dialog": ["I wouldnt call Lloyds charity work poverty porn. Lumaki si Lloyd na alam ang pakiramdam ng wala. Lumaki si Lloyd kasama ng mga pamilya na wala rin. They feel for each other. Ang di nyo nababanggit kay Lloyd is HOW MUCH RELATABLE HE IS SA KARAMIHAN. Lloyd always share, kahit yung segment nyang Luto Baninat magluluto sya ng isang recipe na pwede naman kanila lang pero idadamay nya yung buong kahabaan sa labas ng bahay nila. Lloyd loves to share. Ang alam ko (correct me na lang if mali) even in his death may hiling parin siyang bahagian na charity.", ">I wouldnt call Lloyds charity work poverty porn.\n\nBut it is exactly what it is, poverty porn. HOWEVER, hindi kasi sya yung pera-pera na lang, bigay-bigay tapos gamit na gamit yung mga tao. 'di sya ganun. Like you said, kabilang din kasi sya na wala din. So ramdam mong concern talaga sya at masaya yung ginagawa nila not pure \"poverty porn\". Again, like you said, talagang nagsi-share at hindi talaga nagbago. Alam mong kaya nang i-upgrade yung lifestyle, and yes medyo nag-upgrade din naman talaga, yet he remained simple and true to his core 'til the end."]}

{"dialog": ["That british wannabe accent? Its one of the worst imitations Ive ever heard, and Ive been to the UK. The closest you can get to an accent like that is growing up in the UK, and even then youd be mocked for because it sounds like someone trying hard to fit in, but its not similar to any of the many different british accents Ive heard. People actually believe someone can have an accent like that growing up in the middle east or wherever she grew up?", "Ang hater mo naman. You're coming across as if you visited UK briefly and you already made it your whole personality. I'm not a fan of Ivana and I looked up the vlog after seeing your comment. It was indeed bad. Malamang she didn't grow up there. And it's not like the people featured in the video were particular with what a good or bad English accent is. They are the general public. They do not care much where the accent is from. \n\n>The closest you can get to an accent like that is growing up in the UK\n\nNot entirely true as there are American actors like Rene Zellweger and Meryll Streep that did an impeccable job emulating the English accent.", "If youre going to make a claim like you know something, expect to be proven wrong. Ang claim nya was like they knew accents and knew that was Ivanas real accent. It obviously isnt.\n\nAnd yes I know people can impersonate, these are professionals. But what I was saying is you think someone can develop a natural british accent like thay growing up anywhere outside the UK? Kasi that comment wasnt saying impersonation, but that was her real persona. So I dont know what people who can imitate the accent have to do with this if you think I was saying you cannot have a british accent unless you grew up there."]}

{"dialog": ["Physically abused ung nanay sa Bahrain kaya bumalik sa Pinas. Yung mga anak sumunod rin pabalik ng Pinas, si Ivana yung last holdout kaya rin siguro paborito siya nung tatay (Samier Al-Alawi).\n\nKaya totoo rin namang dumaan sila sa hirap. Pero a hole in the story is yung rift between Ivana and her mom: naglayas si Ivana, si mona had to work as a child actress to sustain the family. Si Ivana nag Starstruck pero hindi siya umabot sa level of success ni Mona sa that time, so si Ivana nagpaka escort to sustain herself. Si Amira nagwork as a DJ.\n\nEh recently lang naman namatay yung si Samir Al-Alawi (2018 ata) so recently lang din naka inherit ng malaking pera si Ivana. So besides showbiz, nag escort escortan na siya way before that.\n\nAs much as malaki kinikita ni Ivana sa vlogs and endorsements, lets be honest, para kang may sure na 1 million sa Solaire pag nag eescort ka. Its easy money. Kung ako maganda baka thrice a week ako mag eescort para may tuition ako. Kaso bilang bading mas compet...", "> Physically abused ung nanay sa Bahrain kaya bumalik sa Pinas.\n\nMakes sense kung hindi nakapagtrabaho agad or kumikita ng sapat yung nanay niya (during Monas acting days) if she had been dealing with trauma from abuse/domestic violence on top of raising kids on her own. I was wondering whether yung case niya is more like Andrea Brillantes mom or if it was more like Julia Montes mom kaya the children took on the role of being their familys provider.\n\nNakakaloka lang though kung paano naatim nung nanay ngayon na magpatuloy sa kaliwat kanang pagbili ng lupa at sa maluhong lifestyle nila ngayon knowing kung anong ginagawa ng anak niya to fund that. Ang hirap hindi isipin na hindi aware yung nanay sa pagiging escort nung anak niya at sa pangangabit nito considering dumadalaw sa kanila at kasama pa sa trips nila yung mga lalaki. I guess, she lost whatever parental control she had when her children became the providers of her family.\n\nI kinda understand in a way why Ivana resorted to bein...", "I dont think Mona will escort. Wala siya nung tigas ng mukha ni Ivana plus well-supported siya ni Ivana financially. Kahit papaano naman kumikita si Ivana sa mga endorsements and sa Youtube niya. Di hamak lang na sobrang luho nila; jawdrop talaga ako dun sa bagong 3BR condo nila sa Makati na never nilang tinour or pinag-usapan pero obvious namang Two Roxas Triangle yun. Para ka nang bumili ng bahay sa nearby Bel-Air Makati (which is where Marian Rivera lives kaya andaling gawan ng script na bakit na-late pa si Ivana sa collab eh taga Roxas Triangle lang naman siya)"]}

{"dialog": ["True. A lot of redditors here in ChikaPH hate BINI. Why can't we be happy that a girl group from the Philippines is striving to make it internationally. Whether they make it or break it, ang mahalaga, they took the chance.\n\nMukang baliktad mindset ng ibang pinoy. Kapag foreigner na may 1/8th Filipino blood ang sumikat sa ibang bansa, kahit di nakatungtong ng pinas, di marunong mag-Tagalog or anumang dialect ng PH, at di familiar sa culture ng pinas, automatic Filipino pride. Pero pag pinoy na nagsusumikap na makilala sa ibang bansa (Kai Sotto, Liza Soberano, BINI, etc) daming masamang sinasabi at nagwiwish na bumagsak sila.", "Nowadays, celebrities arent just looked at for their talent. In a social media driven world, people with a massive platform are held in a higher standard as part of keeping them accountable for the influence they have. Theres also an over saturation of talent in a global scale and now people are learning how to thin the herd by exposing their extra-curricular activities.\n\nBasically just put it this way, madali nang sumikat ngayon pero naging madali din ang malaos. As a celebrity, they should learn this by now and try to bullet proof their image through better public engagements and marketing."]}

{"dialog": ["I watch CBML every episode and I do not see the growth na supposedly eh bolder sila this year according to their magazine shoot last year. \n\nWhat's the deal with them \"not kissing\" on the screen? Naka-ilang projects na sila, nasa tweetums atake pa din tayo. They were portrayed as adults that can do everything in life nung umpisa, then slowly naging teen romance yung mga eksenang pampakilig sana nila. The almost kiss in La Sinfonia did not do anything in their favor kasi after nung muntik na, they hugged and their faces looked overwhelmed? \n\nAnyways, may mga episodes pa naman so baka nga makita na yung level up na sinasabi nila, yet I don't know how they're going to do that in less than 50 episodes.", "Akala nila kaya nilang i-pull off yung ginawa ng KN na puro pabitin yung kissing scene at ilang projects yung dumaan bago yung first rela on-screen kiss\n\n\nFirst of all, matatanda na sila para magpa-tweetums jusko pushing 30 na si Donny. Nag work yung sa KN kasi alam ko 17/18 lang sila nung ginawa yung SDTG at G2B, kumbaga age appropriate yung pagpapabebe.\n\n\nSecond of all, to pull-off that kind of thing kailangan nang MALALANG CHEMISTRY, which is by the way they don't have. Nakakasuka man aminin ngayon pero grabe yung talaga yung magic at chemistry ng KN nung hay-day nila. Hindi nila kailangan gumawa ng grand gesture like pasakbit ng kamay sa braso para kiligin yung mga tao.\n\n\nDyogi kung lurker ka man dito advice ko lang sa'yo bawasan mo na kaka hard sell sa loveteam nila. Donbelle being the successor of Kathniel will never happen. Magaganda silang mga nilalang, talented si Belle, ma-appeal si Donny, yung acting skills naman kayang hilutin sa workshops, kusang kakagatin ng mga...", "Nasayangan ako kasi ang ganda na nung umpisa nung CBML. Wow, ibang story, medyo nakatutok dun sa crime and mystery, and Belle is out for blood. Tapos biglang ngek, balik sa tweetums kilig, like ano ba yun? Dapat yung atake is mature/age appropriate flirting na. Stolen kisses here and there, parinig flirting na double meaning na hindi binabawi sa palusot. I really don't get the holier than thou vibe na walang masyadong intimacy ang mga eksena nila. \n\n The kuliglig rain scene was beautifully shot, pero ilang beses na ba natin nakita yun. Mas appropriate pa yung rain shot nila sa Love is Color Blind kasi kahit papaano, they were portrayed as people na a few years out of college pa lang."]}

{"dialog": ["Lol saying na fact yang opinion mo is nonsense. Again, not bagay for you doesnt mean na hindi din bagay sa iba. There's a reason why marami silang fans. Gets ko sana if puro talak na wala sila chemistry pero hindi talaga sikat ang donbelle kaso halata namang sikat sila kaya nga lagi silang topic dito kasi nga pag sila topic, mas paguusapan. Ang dami loveteams na may project ngayon at wala chemistry pero bat never na topic dito? Kasi walang engagement pag sila kasi hindi kilala. \n\nIf fan ka talaga ni donny, you would know how he is. Hindi yan nakikipag skinship kahit sa previous loveteam niya at hindi fan service si donny. Bat need mag FS ni donny e magulang nyan ang handler niya at mayaman na siya. He doesnt need that fan service BS. Wala ako pake if gusto niya belle or not pero donny has always been straigtforward pag ayaw niya sa tao. Kahit promotion, honest siya if wala talaga. I've known this kasi fan nako ni donny myx era palang at ilang babae na naka loveteam niya.", "Delulu pa more  obvious naman na di nya bet si belle bu lt ofcourse as a fan of the LT youll deny it. Pero sige kung san kayo masaya. And i saw him din w/ his previous LT & he treats her ex-LT same way hes treating belle rn. So in conclusion, reel lang talaga LT nila. \n\nIsa pa ang sabi ko lang naman bukod sa wala silang chemistry eh halatang workmate lang tingen ni donny kay belle. Kung ano-ano na pinagsasabi mo! Don mo i-comment yan sa kung sino man nag sabi na di sila sikat. Kasi kahit si OP wala sinasabi na di sila sikat.\n\nAt lastly sabi mo nga doesnt mean na di bagay for me eh di na rin bagay sa iba. Eh bat galet na galet ka sa opinion ko? Wag kang nangingialam ng opinion ng iba. Its a FACT that majority of us here in the tread eh di nababagayan sa kanila.", "Mema. Ge nga send ka nga compilation dito if same lang talaga para may comparison. \n\nGirl ang haba din kasi ng pinagsasabi mo. Isa nga lang reply ko eh. Tas ikaw naka ilang paragraph ka ng mga observation mong selective. Wala ako pake if mag jowa db or not. Pero yung tingin mo na si B lang lapit ng lapit eh di mo nga man lang nakita yung vids na lagi niya tinatakbuhan palayo si donny ay kulang na. \n\nOh ayan mas clear. Agree naman sa fact na majority sa sub na to ay hindi bet ang donbelle pero yung \"hindi sila bagay at fact yun\" ayan ang mali. Know the difference"]}