That fb page po is hindi managed by star magic/abs. Fan page lang yan.

Corny na they posted that kasi parang nagpapaawa effect tuloy sila... and it will not help lalo na sa mga bashers pero please fact check muna tayo guys.

Doon kayo mag react if galing sa official acct ng bini or star magic mismo.

Yes, its a fan page thats not managed by Star Magic. Pero I meant to point out the fact that they still garnered this much support (peep the FB reactions and comments) in spite of the issue. Just goes to show that Star Magics PR handling is top notch, to the point na kahit gaano kasahol pa issue nila they will still be blindly supported by their followers


naniwala naman kayo?

Kagat na kagat ang mga stans eh, kesyo tAo lAnG nAmAn nAgKaKamALi


She's just posting viral Tiktoks that use her song Supernatural. Dami nyang fineature actually, so it's not as bukod-tangi as it appears to be.

Slay


Kaya pala siya trending on X hahaha pinagkakaisahan na siya

In the end Paulo Avelino is Paulo Avelino. Not even PR teams and the management can stop him

d ko gets. nilaro lang niya yung bini statement w a gta meme bat siya kinuyog sa x?

Deflection. Its easier to attack Paulo whos making fun of the apology than to face the fact that their idols did something wrong.

grabe naman kasi yung ginawa ng tatlo. kahit anong klase argumento gawin mo, talo ka talaga eh. grooming x sexual jokes ba naman

Ang dami pang nagde-defend na kesyo inside joke lang daw yon at lahat naman daw ganon. Jusmiyo, kung ganyan kayo mag-inside joke, kailangan niyong mag-reflect.

totoo. hindi pala ganun 'kabait' sina jhoanna, colet, stacy.

kay aiah na lang ako, pag pati sya nagloko, aray talaga.


Gago ang tapang niya kasi under siya ng ABS. HAHAHAHAHA potek ano kaya iisipin ng bosses nito.

mayaman na siya pwede na siyang magretire

Pwede siyang mag stream tbh. I watched him before, I'll watch him again.

anong games nilalaro niya sa stream?

First person shooter games like tarkov


Ano movie tinutukoy niya dito?

Yes, MLWMYD due to change date ng palabas nila yan

E July 26, 2019 pa yung tweet

UNg Bea Fiasco ung 2019 na nakita mo...check mo s a taas may SS nung tweet nya after maresched ung movie...
Inunfollow pa nga nya ung Star Cinema kaya napilitang gawing March na ung release instead na April sana hahah

Hahahaha nalito ako. sinusundan ko yung line sa gilid.


Listahan ng mga matatapang na filipino:

1. Jose Rizal
2. Paulo Avelino

Mhie, nahiya naman si Andres Bonifacio

pumangatlo lang siya kay paulo

Mas okay sakin ilagay si jose rizal sa pangatlo tas si andres sa 1. Si paulo, okay stay put sa number 2 hahaha


Paulo Avelino is a gamer and hes probably sharing it because its GTA VI  Wala siyang pake dun sa template pero yung fans triggered na triggered naman

Yun nga eh.. Busy yun sa games niya. Ano pakialam niya sa issue ng BINI. Nagrepost lang ng meme napagsabihan na ng kung anu-anong salita. Pati anak dinamay.

Wait what??! May anak na sya??!

Yes. Binatilyo na. Ex niya, kasamahan dati sa GMA. Binisita nila yung bata sa New York after ASAP Cali. Umuwi din dito noong Holy Week.


Nakakatawa mga gr00ms na nagsasabi na hindi daw relevant si Paulo Avelino kung walang ka-loveteam hahaha sige nga ipag solo career nila yang bb gh0rls nila, tingnan natin if maging relevant pa din.  Ang tataas ng tingin masyado sa idolettes nilang bangketa version ng Twice, compared kay Paulo na ang dami na napatunayan sa industry.

Grabe yung bangketa version ng twice .
Hard core tlga ng pinoy mang lait.
Di papatalo sa Korea .

Yung anak ko nga sabi ginaya lang daw sila ng twice. Sabi ko nga matagal na twice b3h, kaya hindi ko na pinagtiktok don niya nakukuha yon eh.

Sabi ko sana nak wag kang delulu


Dami ng galit sakanya sa X ahhahaaha wala raw utang na loob

Sinusumbatan na nga siya ng blooms. Kung hindi daw dahil s concert ng Bini, wala daw promotion movie nila ni Kimmy.

\*GROOMS HGAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA

Hahahahahahahhaahhaha benta mga correction


Ang tapang

Kaya pala trending sa X ngayon, pinagkakaguluhan ng fans

Kinukuyog nga ng mga blooms. May superiority complex pa naman yung mga yun


Ung tatahitahimik lang pero pag bumanat talaga solid. Nagpost din yan about hindi pagtapos ng movie diba.

Context nun movie boss.. thanks

Nagkaron ng changes dun sa showing date nu movie nila Kim tas nagpost sya na maranansan/matry daw kaya nya wag tumapos ng pelikula.


Ang daming time ni Paulo

hahaha! may inside joke mga fans nia na out of boredom kasi 2 days nasa cebu si kim for an event, kahapon ng gabi lang ang uwi, pinapauwi na nila si kim baka ano ulit ma post ni paulo hahaha

Wahahahahaha oo nga


Di ko gets yung Meme. Pwede po pa-explain? Thanks.

afaik gta 6 is widely anticipated ng mga gamers since gta 5 is released 2013 pa. So yun laging meme yung about gta 6 kasi laging nadedelay.

Yung statement niyan, statement mismo ng developers ng game kasi this year ata release nyan tapos delay na naman HAHAHA


Umuusok ilong ng fans kasi ginagawang katatawanan ung serious issue as if their idols did not do it first. That apology was so insincere and fake that it deserves to be mocked.

He's only attacking the insincerity of their apology so di ko alam kung ano kinakagalitan nila lol


He let his intrusive thoughts win. Okay lang yan malakas ka naman sa ABS haha

But he has not signed any management contract yet. Self managed sya. He really just has a weird sense of humor at naisip lang nya Ishare. I doubt if he thought much about it. Hahaha


Yung mga blooms na nanay nila ay kimpau, lagot kayo nde na kayo bbgyan pera pambili ng concert ticket. G na G na twitter mga kimpau mothers haha!

Hahaha benta din mga sagutan nila sa X


Ang lakas mang asar may CTTO pa

Para sa creator ng GTA kasi yun hindi BINI


sinasabi pa ng mga fans ng bini na trash daw si Paulo avelino for making fun of the issue. atecco sino ba yung ginagawang kakatawanan ang sexual assault sa minor? luh. apaka fanatic talaga umuurong na ang utak

They need to watch Fangirl starring Paulo HAHAHAHAHHAHAHA


nakita ko rin yun i was like??? WHEBHSHD AMATS NI KUYA

Gamer's joke yung sa GTA na hindi malaunch launch. Parang hindi naman siya aware sa issue ng BINI. Pero ngayon na nagviral na ang  hanash ng bloom. Malalaman na rin niya yan


Ekis sakin yan si Paulo.

Di yan sumayaw ng salamin salamin sa Biniverse PH Arena.

Panira ng crowd energy.

Kahit ako di sasayaw sa jologs na kanta  na yon hahhaa


Context nito?

Dapat VDay movie yung sa kanila ni Kim Chiu pero minove sa March ang showing. Mas malaki kasi potential kumita Vday so baka mas may chance sana na may bonus sila


but he's only gettin bashed from people who dont matter. he could post more shit like this and abs aint going to do anything lmao

paulo: "okay so fire me then..."

Real


Grabe, parang mas offended pa kayo sa meme kaysa sa joke about grooming a 13-year-old. The meme made fun of the apology format, hindi yung issue mismo. Kung yun ang mas pinoproblema niyo, maybe check your priorities. At hindi lahat ng hindi sumasayaw sa concert KJ.

True! Dun sa sexual joke hindi offended kasi inside joke kuno. Tapos ito grabe magalit haha!


Wala nang makakalapit na tagahanga?

di kasi nag bebembangan sa harap niya mga fans niya kaya di na sila makalapit


real motto niya

"ahhh 13 years old"

Sinasabunutan


Enjoy na enjoy ung mga tao sa downfall ng bini. They waited for this moment. Gotcha moment for them. Lols

Bat parang kasalanan ng mga tao? Walang gotcha moment, kasi yung mismong Bini member naman ang upload ng video nya, meaning wala siyang nakitang mali dun sa content ng video nya which is all the more disappointing. Wag nyo isisi sa mga tao yung nangyayari sa Bini, what you're witnessing is the **consequences** of their actions.


I'm trying to wrap my mind around what the user wants.

1. Anong gusto nya ma-achieve? Gusto lang ba turuan ng leason ang BINI? Anong klaseng accountability at pag apologize ang gusto nya?

2. If sobrang polar opposite talaga sa nakikita publicly ang BINI at di dapat hangaan, why not release it all na agad?

I guess what I am asking is, anong end game nya?

Who cares what their motive/s are? If its the truth, its the truth. Bakit mo palalaguin ang buhay ng closeted kupal?

Yun nga punto ko - the truth is the truth. Kung kupal talaga ang BINI, bat di pa nya ilabas lahat? Bakit kailangan may threat pa?

Which implies na may motive sila - and not just the truth. Be it clout, attention, influence, money, etc. Kasi if gusto lang nya either (1) pabagsakin ang BINI and/or  (2) gusto nya ilabas ang totoo - bakit di na lang ilabas?

Theyre probably trying to circumvent crisis PR of the first wave ng pasabog. Whoever this is, they know their stuff and Star Magic has to pray to all the saints that the coming ones flop like the polvoron video. Hindi ito basta fan or friend lang.

That makes a ton of sense actually. Tipong they did not put all their eggs in one basket. Knowing the ABS/Star Magic PR machine, they probably dont want to show their hand from the start.

Oo kasi pwede nila yan ihingi ng patawad lahat in one fell swoop then isahang move on nalang. But if staggered ang paglabas, nagmamarinate sa masa ang paninira. Lalo na kung juicy or controversial ang nature ng mga susunod na materials. Haha

Tapos kung sinister talaga plano nila, and they have TONS of evidence, they can also plan to catch ABS/Star Magic/BINI in their own lie, if they do lie.

Kasi yung unang apology message is the typical "not-saying-anything-at-all" PR apology. Walang details.

So if mapilitan sila maglabas with more details, tas naghalo ng inaccurate details, they can then spin it around. Parang ginawa ni Professor sa Money Heist season 2.

I hope we channel the same energy pagdissect ng political issues no.


Star Magic bosses and sponsors are seated in a meeting somewhere, collectively holding their breaths.

Hahaha I doubt it sis. The Filipinos are forgiving. I doubt this will even make a dent on how the masa perceive them and their fans will still accept them readily

Nah this will make a dent. Wala na yung perfect "binibini" facade nila. Brands will not like that.

If magrebrand man, Di pa sure if mattripan ng tao if they went the rebellious path.

Youre underestimating how Filipinos can sweep things under the rug. Maris, anyone?

Maris overcame her issue kasi talented siya, and may tv series pa rin siya after pumutok yun. Ppl forgot it dahil sa acting nya sa incognito. may movies pa.

Eh ang bini when was their last hit single?


Sana naman walang issue si GWEN

I checked BaliLeeg's posts sabi nya ang wala daw issue sa bini ay si Sheena at Aiah

Di ba si Sheena yung naggagaya sa ngongo? Nagsasalita ng ngongo smth like that sa vid nila

Yess siyaa. So kung wala siya na content for Sheena, meron na naman, which is yung ngongo. I guess si Aiah lang ang winner for today.

Idk how they find it funny lol ang cringe. It's not even cutesy to act that way.


I'm sure pwedeng siyang kasuhan niyan.

kung covered naman yung account niya baka walang taong mahanap. yung kay illiad kaya lang naman nahanap yon dahil may footprint siya ng identity.

yung source ng pics and vids? if kasuhan nila yon baka mag backfire lalo lol. parang 60% against sa bini tapos 40% mga fans nag dedefend.

X can be compelled to comply to release the user data IF there is a court order

Oo nga kaya wala padin takas delekado talaga siya pag ganun. Sana bumili nalang siya ng acc ng ibang tao hahaha.


So, yung source ay close din sa Bini? Tsktsk disturbing. Mahirap na magtiwala kahit kanino.

Kung di ka pa naman gaga at anak ni satanas wala ka dapat ikatakot kahit may pasecret pa na magvideo sa yo hahah

Sa true. Kung matino at disenteng tao ka, di ka mabobother.

Embarrassing drunk pics like making out with random strangers at kahit nakahubad ka pa hindi yan magiging issue whatsoever.


villain era si ante ko, what's his/her villain story kaya? HAHA

Si fonzi na bahalang gumawa ng video dito hahahaha fonz pasokk!! BABY ONE AND ONLYYY

you're my one and only  caring ka kaseee


Oh spicy!  This is going to be interesting! Ano pa kaya ang tinatago ng BINI? I wonder what other kinds of inappropriate jokes they might be telling? could there be more than just the grooming jokes?

Always remember making light of rape, abuse, depression, body shaming and grooming isn't just tasteless, It's morally reprehensible!  If you think that's acceptable humor, you're not just an idiot, you're MORALLY BANKRUPT!

si Maloi nga diba tamang panggaya  lang sa mga may kapansanan . Feeling ko dark humor enjoyers yang mga yan eh. Tbh maraming ganyo Kaso public figure sila need nila maging sensible and responsible coz a lot of ppl are looking up to them :) thats the price of fame

Not a bini fan tbh pero lahat naman ata ng tao ay may dark jokes like death etc. Ayun nga lang, sikat kasi sila and may image silang pinapangalagaan so lagot.

Tbh at this point, kahit yata drunk pics nila or vaping pics nila kukutyain sila ng mga tao. Kahit anong maliit na kapintasan ay big deal pag sikat ka lol


Excited na talaga mga taga ChikaPH sa pagbagsak ng bini

Hindi siya talaga chika sub, hate sub talaga. The number of hours or days people spend hating dito sa sub. Kung sinong celebrity man ang may pumutok na issue, may mga kating-kating mag-comment.

I guess that's the "power" of anonymity. Lumalakas ang loob ng mga tao at nagkakaroon ng validity ang wrath.

people throw rocks at things that shine.
but this timez its valid to hate on them.


Yan tama iyan para silbing lesson sa lahat

What you leave your footprint on the internet stays forever and ever

Goodbye bini hope you share the same fate as BGYO

Anyare po sa BGYO?

Not sure pero may member na cheater and abuser daw...


wala bang ganto para sa mga politiko?

meron ung sa Senate blue ribbon committee at office of the ombudsman kaya nga lang taon tatagal ung mga ganun...

I mean, private anonymous accounts like BaLiLeeg can easily expose them


Ano naman mapapala niya dito? Twisted yata utak nito. Tapos abang na abang naman mga taga chikaph. Mukhang sayang saya makita pagdapa ng iba. May pa seated seated pa. Ew

For someone whos chronically online sa ChikaPH subreddit, part pa ng top 5% commenters, and has thrown around snarky and nasty takes on celeb issues featured sa sub, this comment is wild. The audacity is almost inspirational. Are you even reading your comments mo sa sub? Ew

Yan gusto ko kalkal kung kalkal haha


Garo Sero vs Kim Soo Hyun lang atake ni atecco

Best thing about it is kapag nagbigay sila ng explanation about doon sa narelease na, may chance na may tinatago pang evidence na magcocontradict sa explanation na nabigay na. Maeexpose din if ever kasinungalingan lang yung explanation.

Dig your grave deeper ang atake


TBF I feel like sa mga ugali Ng girls at tabas Ng dila, nagiipon lng din tlga Sia at madami Lang din tlga lapses Yong girls na cinocondone at dinedefend Ng fans

Matagal na sila cinacall out sa ibat ibang behaviour, madami nang pwede gamitin against sknila

You call them lapses? Damn hahahah

I was being nice hehehehe


Kawawa naman si Alden, nadamay pa dito sa issue na to

Yung anak ni Alden at Maine member pala ng Bini


hmmmm dapat di niya innanounce plano niya, dapt nakascheduled post na yung meron siya, di pa pala tapos kaabang abang to. hehe

Or ung biglang naguupload sa stories hehehe


I don't think they have anything other than BINI members partying or having ugly and problematic boyfriends. This account thinks Mikha partying with Joao is problematic and incriminating.

Pero may nag-'expose' na dati kay Mikha (same accounts na nag-expose ng BGYO Nate vs. AC Bonifacio issue) na she calls Blooms "dogs" daw in private or something, na jowa/ex-jowa niya si BGYO Gelo and accused/implied na nag-ddrugs siya.

Not surprising if some or all of them are exposed to drugs, even the girls. Lalo na lagari ang work nila at wala pahinga. Kalakaran yan sa entertainment industry


I.am.seated. Bagal.  Bilis na para isang bagsakan na. Matatabunan pa yan ng eleksyon.

ilabas na lang after election para di matabunan.


PR team would be working overtime

PR team nila pagod na pagod na


Kakaunti na nga ang Bini team may nang ttraydor pa. Not a good sign para sa inaasam na world domination, mukang may humaharang sa mismong circle nila.

Kahit walang traydor sa kanila, walang mangyayaring world domination. Creative direction pa lang nila, fail na


I thought BINI is different from BGYO. Hindi pala. Sa bagay they choose their friends eme sila.

Show me your friends and I'll tell you who you are.


Feeling ko hindi downfall ehh. Mag lie low lang yan sila saglit tapos kapag di na maingay ang issue babalik na yan sila ulit.

Tignan niyo nalang yung cheating scandal kay Anthony-Maris. Hindi man pareho ng issue pero ang point ko ay di naman uso cancel or downfall dito sa pinas. Nakakapagod din kasi mang hate ng tao kaya ang ending papatawarin nalang natin as if walang nangyari.

sa una lang naman magaling mag-cancel dito sa pinas pero eventually makakalimutan din yung issue

Well si Toni G hanggang you tube na lang.

Believe me after how many years makakabalik yan sa network either abs or gma. Makakalimutan din issues niyan. Kung mag aartista pa isa sa mga anak niya for sure kakagatin ng mga tao.

I don't think so. Maliit lang industry nila and what she did was so unethical.

Ang daming unethical sa industriya nila. Si bong revilla nga gumagawa pa ng series at pelikula tapos senador pa kahit nagnakaw ng malaking pera. Si toni pa kaya na sumuporta lang.

Ibang usapan to. Pinutol talaga ni Toni yung connection nya with everyone in the industry. It left a bad taste in your mouth. I don't think anyone from management would risk getting her again.

Sinong pinutol, recently lang nag meeting siya with charo santos para siguro mag movie sa film outfit nila. Mga nag guest sa tonitalks, si coco martin, piolo, jonathan manalo ng star music. Okay din siya sa gma at tv5. Hindi lng abs ang network. Ang lawak ng showbiz.


Mag coachella pa sila charot

Walang pag asa mka pag coachella yan, hindi kakagat western audience sa discography nila, hindi din maganda pang festival setting songs nila.

Bakit naman hindi maganda na pangcoachella? Hinfi ako bini fan ah. Tamang lurking lang ako dito. Nagustuhan ko din Pantropinko (kung mali spell bahala na)  Naappreciate ko naman sila kaya lang mas naging interesado ako sa ibang ppop group. Haha

Leaning masyado sa  bubblegum pop and kulang talaga sila sa genre experimentation/depth tsaka lyrics nila is basic, shallow &  playing safe masyado ( which is understandable kasi mostly fans nila are kids and minors ) pero it will not resonate well sa western audience lalo nat super diverse pa naman audience ng coachella ( based on my experience since i attended 2019,22,24 ), it's good nga na may english songs sila but underwhelming and too generic naman, kulang talaga sa firepower/kick discography nila to get people engaged sa isang musicfest setting, tsaka limited lang din talaga Slots ng coachella  for asian acts, for years now 1 slot lang talaga nabibigay for Girlgroups and Mostly Kpop acts nakukuha since malakas hatak nila tlga, This year nga lang sila nag invite ng Girlgroup outside korea which is XG, well understandable din since complete package sila,i suggest na i watch mo performance ng XG sa coachella atleast same sila with Bini na may english songs yet malayo lang ...

Wow. Thank you sa explanation. Akala ko walang magrereply eh. Now I was convinced.

No worries hehehe, don't get me wrong ah i'm a bini fan pero underwhelming talaga comebacks nila, sadly wala talaga silang competition dito sa pinas so kahit titipirin ng starmagic yung comebacks nila eh open arms na i accept ng blooms yung mga kanta pero yun na nga hindi masyado nag hit outside sa fandom recent comebacks nila, sayang talaga hindi nila nasakyan yung momentum nung pantropiko/salamin2x.

Hindi ba considered na competition nila ay ibang ppop group lalo na ang sb19? Or baka hindi mo iallow kc girl group ang bini while sb19 ay boy group?

If PH lang mag focus yep ibang ppop groups yung considered competion nila which is dominated nila as a girlgroup, if against sb19 naman mga fans lang yung nag aaway sa 2,pero in reality malaki talaga difference ng boygroup vs girlgroup.

But if gusto ng Bini mag tap sa international scene eh ibang usapan na yun since madami competition sa international, Kpop,Jpop,Cpop may mga global groups din like Katseye/XG soo they need to step up if gusto nila magka ingay name nila internationally.


Hard lesson kay Colet ,if magtanda siya!! Di na niya pwede gamitin ang entitled personality or else babalik sakanya yan.

Si colet na akala mo nakakatuwa pagiging anger nia lagi, sa totoo lang bastos siya sumagot sa socmed pero sa mga diehard fans nila cute na cute sila sa ganyang attitude nia.

Kaya di ko magawang maging fan nila (although like ko ung ibang songs nila), kasi they're not good example sa youth and kids. Pabalang at sarcastic pa sumagot sa soc med, walang breeding. Feeling cool pag ganyan ung sagot. Ang natutuwa lamg jan eh ung mga wala ding breeding na fans ehh, sa true lang.

lalo pa lumaki ang ulo nian ni Colet dahil sumikat sila kaya pabalbal magsalita eh

Parang si Fyang  yung balbal eme magsalita akala mo kinacool. Parang squammy naman.

True, iba ang generation ngayon they find it cool ung mga squammy na ugali

Walang kaclass-class atecco


Maybe its not a total downfall, but the stain is there for good. That digital footprint isnt going anywhere. The whole empowered women image, especially from those three, turns out to be nothing but hollow performance. Some of their fans whining about people criticizing the girls looks while happily tearing into the two guys in the clip. Wild.

Agree. Diehard blooms will, of course, still be there supporting them. But casual listeners (like me and my sisters + mom) will surely have second thoughts na about them. I honestly found myself skipping their songs na on shuffle. Then nadiscover ko pa ibang kwento about some of their members and lets just say, colet is probably the shittiest among the girls hahahah

Abangan ko yang Colet Issue sa X

MAG WAIT KA TALAGA HA

Yesssss bored pako sa buhay abang2 ng bagong chismax lng muna hobby ko


Parang another day at the office lang yan sa executives and staff sa network nila.

Coco groomer,  Mariz cheater so are  Andrea Brillantes, Daniel Padilla. etc  May mga career pa din naman. Si Gerald buong career niyan ganyan, Julia B.

Specialty nila yan ng PR spin doctors ng network

Pero tingnan pa rin natin.  Yung boygroup nila parang di ko narin mahagilap kung may ganap pa ih,

True. Ibang iba ang level of acceptance ng knetz vs. ph netz. Masyadong forgiving ang mga Pinoy. Not to mention mahina ang moral compass. Some of their fans, and even casuals, dont see anything wrong with what the three members did. So, I dont think this issue will cause BINIs downfall.

Both are terrible tbh. Knetz's toxicity has driven people to commit suicide.

Yeah, theyre two extremes imo.


I hope not. Nakakainis lang kasi ang ganda ng usad at trajectory ng career nila pero anak ng yawa. Ambobo lang. Nung naging sikat sila all the more dapat na naging mahigpit ang management gaya ng ginagawa sa Korea.

Kasi isang sablay lang may backlash for sure.

Tapos since mga bagets ang majority ng fan base nila dapat pinush ang relationship ban. Taeng tae sa mga lalake amp. Most ng issues na daw it sila may kasama ding lalake.

Sayang lang, rooting for them to succeed globally. Pero malaking dagok sa pagiging genuine nila sa women empowerment advocacy yung maikling video na pucha nag mukha silang plastic. Na damay pa lahat

that's the reason why mahigpit ang idol culture sa korea at japan pagdating sa mga interactions nila sa mga male friends at co-idols nilang lalaki

Wala namang magagawa kung ganun na talaga yung mindset or humor nila, may interaction man sa male idols o wala. They can still post and joke about these things even without them.
Not saying not to condemn the other two, but yea.

I guess in a way you're also on point on that.
A case of nurture and nature perhaps.

Hopefully this becomes a wake up call for the management to do something. At the end of the day nadamay lahat, hopefully the weight of that can change them for the better.

Hard conversations from within them for sure will happen.


not really a downfall kasi (sa totoo lang) ang daming madaling mautong pinoy na walang moral compass. mukhang wala din brand na nag pull out sakanila ng endorsement and super protektado ng management kaya never icocover ng news outlets. lalo na at matatabunan yung issue nila ng ibang events like announcement ng pope and election. siguro nga di na nila need ng interview ala maris racal.

yung tipong: socmed statement  tahimik sandali  release ng MAGANDANG song (should be a bop or else they are gonna catch another stray from people) lang na course of action then boogsh limot na yan ng mga tao lalo na at marami silang parasocial fans at iba rin talaga ang grip nila sa masang pinoy.

pero one thing for sure stained na yung image nila and di na mappreach yang "women empowerment" front kasi magmumukha nalang silang performative clowns if ginawa pa nila yun.

and also the stan twt, kpop stans, and other rival ppop groups are gonna be ruthless to them. lalo na yung mga blooms noon a...

socmed statement  tahimik sandali  release ng MAGANDANG song (should be a bop or else they are gonna catch another stray from people)

yeah about that, puro english kanta nirerelease and they haven't released a good follow up yet sa viral tracks nila

oo continuous discourse yan ng mga tao since last year after ng salamin kung bakit puro english songs yung release eh sa tagalog pop songs sila nag boom. sabi ng fans nila international na daw kasi yung target at nag-eexperiment pa pero honestly pwede naman sila mag trending internationally kahit tagalog song.


Si Maris nga nagka teleserye at endorsement pa, sila pa kaya. ABS CBN  lilinis ng issue nilaz

"Nobody's perfect kala mo wala kayong nagawang kasalanan" both issues ni Maris and nung kay AC sa PBB puro ganito naririnig ko.

It's either wag kayong humusga dahil lahat tayo may imperfection ang script nila or throw the boys under the bus ala Maris style.

lol i really hate this "nobody's perfect" phrase when theyre defending these people kase hindi mo naman need maging perfect to know what is right from wrong???


lol e sa bini sub pilit na pinapasa dun sa dalawang lalake yung blame

Eh whos to blame pala?? Sila lang dapat?

silang lahat


I honestly dont think BINI will be gone bcos of this issue specially with the artist management they are-in. I believe isa sila sa most prized possession ng Star Magic nowadays. SM wont let their investment or money makers go down just like that. It took years of searching, training, and trial and error before they succeeded on producing a successful girl group like BINI. And honestly, it may never happen again.

Also, maraming Star Magic talents and nadawit sa ibat ibang issues in the past na mas malala and theyre still active in the industry.

Also note, the Filipinos have opened their arms and welcomed problematic artist(s) from other countries/Korea. So makikita mong hindi ganun katindi ang cancel culture sa Pinas.

They need a better comeback than pantropiko for that to happen. I feel so bad sa other members. I know everyone makes mistakes, theres redemption surepero joking about 13yo about sexual stuff is another story :(

Do we know who the 13-year old is? Hindi ba possible na that 13-year-old was 13 when the people in the vid were also around the same age? Naisip ko kasi baka in the past yung pinaguusapan nila and now natatawa na di sila makapaniwala sa pagkawild nila at that young age.


As a BLOOM (dati or ewan), di ko iba-buy ung apology. Ang off saken kasi baket damay pa yung lima kawawa naman sila. Nakakahiya na kay Mikha dahil nagrepost pa sya sa Twitter nya nung apology samantalang ung 3 walang paramdam or delikadesa. Pero, sige pagbigyan muna ng time baka naman magbago pa.

Sa X marami din Maloi fans naiirita sa apology kasi si Maloi daw nung nagka-issue dun sa pwd's mag-isa lang naman daw niya hinarap at nag-apologize. Samantalang this time di naman siya involved pero bakit sinali along with the other four na di din involved.

kaya nga eh sobrang unhinged talaga walang kwentang management ang cheap sobra ng mga networks dito sa pinas hahahah di marurunong magaddress ng issues


Siguro. Parang di na sila  makakapag release ng malupit na tagalog songs kase may binuo ng ppop gg ang flipmusic. VVINK ata name ng grp.

Taenang pangalan yan VVINK hahahahha

HAHAHAHAHAHA


Gonna say this, bakit kasi hinahayaan lang nila mga talents nila. Like wala man lang strictness, si mika kasama pa si owra sa bar. Si waloi kung sino-sino din.

Yeah may private life pero public figure sila.

Ayan na nagbite na. Mukhang failed ang pagkakagawa ng isang ppop group. Sana lesson learned to sa management.

Maging strict sana kayo sa gagawing ppop. Hanggang maaari wag pababain ang value by letting them do things on their own. Pede naman na yan once magsosolo na (see blankpink)

Si Aiah at Gwen lang talaga yung may good circle of friends sa kanila. Si Aiah puro churchmate at yung aso kasama, na lilink sa pba player na si Tiongson but he's a good person din naman. Si Gwen kay doc Z at sharlene san pedro kabonding. Si sheena sumasama din yan sa 3.

Yern nga :3 if ever na may malice na nga if di nila kayang ikontrol yuung mga bad side, dapat di na sila naging member. Ito kawawa yung ibang madadamay. Still kahit sino pa friends nila, bad or good influence, dapat may strict rules sila as a ppop group. Di yung hindi private life namin to kaya kahit ano pede naming gawin. Eh paano kung umayaw ang fans, wala ngayon sila


Bakit nika sinali c Aiah Sheena Gwen Mikha and Maloi. Hindi din nag iisip PR nila.

Ito hula ko. May branding din kasi yang Bini na Walo Hanggang Dulo. Feeling ko pag iniwan nila yung lima sa apology, may mga fans na magpupush na maging lima na lang ang Bini or maghiatus na talaga yung tatlo. Ang dapat na ginawa na lang kasi, individually sila nagrelease.


Cant unsee. Sabi na eh, yung lack of media training ni Colet mag cause ng problems in the future. Pero okay na rin at naexpose na ganyan pala yung tatlo in private.

Anong aasahan mo sa mga ugaling kalye na tao? Kahit suotan mo ng mamahaling damit, paliguan mo ng mamahaling pabango, at tapalan mo ng tiglilibong make up aalingasaw talaga kung san yan galing. Si Aiah at Mikha lang ata may maayos na pagpapalaki diyan. Buti pa yung Gwen kahit laki sa hirap pero lumaking mabuting tao.


wala ngang sorry sa person na involved in this issue. they're only sorry because their fans are disappointed.

i know right people should check in on the girl

hindi talaga sorry Bini sorry lang na nahuli sila :(


It will be interesting to see kung ano magiging outcome ng world tour nila

Speaking of World Tour yung Temecula, CA stop nila SOLD OUT na sana pero ngayon ang daming bumalik na tickets sa ticketmaster website. Ang daming pink color meaning nag resell ng tickets kasi pag blue color available kasi yun.

PS: Legal ang scalper and resell ng ticket sa US ibabalik lang sa website tapos papatungan ang prices.


they will definitely lose a good number of their fan base. considering younger kids ang market nila and parents tend to judge artists based sa controversy. and sobrang critical ng issue ha, PEDOPHILIA, idagdag mopang apakakalat nung video takit ipause mo pa and yung screenshot lang ilabas mo sa isang posts. i also dont think bini is in their primest. may mga lumalabas na na new groups, and madami dami din silang bashers even before (calling them jeje, panghe , and out of tune (asap performance)

ceiling na nila yung 2024 hype. i don't think makaka gain pa sila ng massive support pagkatapos ng issue na to. awkward na sila mag stay sa bg pop. mas mainam mag rebrand nalang sila and gawing mas mature yung mga concept nila. saka bitawan na nila yung mga advocacy shit kase obvious naman na for show lang nila yun.


Ngayon mo pindutin yung anger mo, Colet! Hinayupak kang babaita ka.

kalmahan mo lang te!!! HAHAHAH


Theyll still be okay in the Philippines for sure but once this gets with the other U.S. Blooms, their brand and popularity will fall.

Sabi marami daw nagbalik ng tickets na SOLD OUT na sana, mas unforgiving sila doon haha


Do you really think BINI will be canceled or flop because of this issue? ABS-CBN is known for covering up their artists' controversies and even boosting their fame afterward. Remember Anne Curtis' 'I can buy you, your friends, and this club' outburst? Vhong Navarro's rape case? Coco Martin's alleged grooming of Julia? Coleen and Billy's cheating scandal with Nikki? Kim Chiu's 'bawal lumabas' moment? Maris and Anthony's cheating controversy? Did any of those ruin their careers? Hardly. If anything, BINI might come out of this scandal even more popular.

"Bawal lumabas" is just a brain fart on the part of Kim Chiu. We all get brain farts every now and then. Nothing diabolical about it. They even made it into a song.


Like BGYO aun nalaos na di pa gaanong sumisikat. Lol. Imbes na mag focus sa issue nila sa mga fans pa nasisisi. As a leader Joanna should step up i call out fans nila, hindi eh nahuli pang nag comment ng tawa sa alt account na basher ng isang grp. Nakalimutang mag change account to her dummy acvount haha. Kung sa S. Korea yan matagal na silang cancelled. Deserve nila yan isa pa yang Star Magic na gatas na gatas sila di maayos ayos problematic na members ng groups nila. #deserve #downfall

To be fair, never sumikat BGYO in the first place.


Idk about downfall. Si Maris nga, andyan pa

Was about to comment this


Not a downfall. Kailangan lang nila magtanda, bata pa sila madami pa silang pwedeng matutunan at iimprove.

Wishing for their downfall isn't good too. But then they have to learn their lesson. Kawawa yung lima pang member na nadawit dito.


Hmmm kailangan lang nila ng another tagalog hit song ala pantropiko and salamin salamin, then all will be forgotten. Believe me.

San naman sila kukuha nun? Eh yung Flipmusic may binuong gg na.


you can have all the money & fame in the world, but you can't class. #squammyshizbruh

\*buy


Gwen-modelling

Aiah- pageant

Maloi- singing

Sheena- dancing

Mikha-sports/vball

Si Maloi mag-ingat din sana kasi last time muntik na rin siya macancel

Lalo na nalilink pa siya dun kay Zild na problematic din.

wait di ako updated. ano ginawa ni zild?

Tinitira na nya si Maloi


Maloi has both individual popularity and talent. And her solo fandom is the most loaded, kaya nilang mag-sponsor ng whole BINI event

Aiah and Mikha are individually popular too pero anong magiging career nila? They're not the most talented members.

Theyre not, kung kukumpara sa mga most talented members nila, pero they are pretty talented kung ikukumpara sa ibang PPOP idols. Aiah and Mikha are two of the most versatile sa group especially Aiah. She can dance, rap, and sing, and also play instruments and beatbox too.

Aiah can thrive anywhere she chooses, while Mikha can go into acting or singing. Her voice is unique, and she can benefit from that.

They're definitely not more talented compared to members of G22, KAIA, or even YGIG. I'm saying that as a Bini fan once. Aiah's skill level is suited for a group but not as a solo. Nakakasabay lang siya. Modeling career siya pwede or travel influencer.

Mikha has below average singing skills, unique lang ang voice color niya. She was not very good in her short stint in He's Into Her and not very fluent in Tagalog so if she goes into acting, very limited magiging roles niya. She was a gamer, she can be a streamer, like Sharlene San Pedro.

Hey agreed. Sobrang galing ng G22. Tbh, lamon na lamon talaga BINI. Iba lang din talaga star power netong BINI e haha

You know what, tama ka sa streamer! Haha sobrang bagay

even the brand jingles mas maganda yung sa g22 geez


She's their worst singer

**Stacey is their worst singer haha

Di naman, mababa kasi yung voice ni stacey... kaya niya mag low notes. Di lang siya for birit levels

Ayaw mo lang talaga kay stacey thats it.

Okay kakagaling ko lang ng Youtube, yeah Stacey's better than Aiah

Baka mas bet ko lang yung vocal color ni Aiah from their songs

Di naman best singer si Stacey pero if live or record parang same pa rin voice niya at more stable. Yun lang kasi "pinaka pangit na member" yung tingin mostly ng iba kay stacey -- so matic chaka din sumayaw at kumanta

Si Aiah, higher vocal range pero di pa masyado stable more on parang back up singer vibes or adlibs +++ pero bawi naman sa visuals si aiah at class

Di  sila inborn singers katulad ni jho, colet at maloi


wala bang google para mag chatgpt ka pa? ganon katamad?

edit:

Guys, wag na kayo mag away away lol. I just dont trust chatgpt enough, since di naman 100% correct yan. Simple lang naman kasi hanapin sa internet nung mga proof sa pageants ni Aiah, to make it more real proof. And personally, chatgpt makes me lazy & stoopid, thats why I dont rely on it.

What's the problem in using Chat GPT as a search tool? It literally goes through the web to directly answer your question.

And kahit google gamitin mo, lalabas rin ang AI suggestions sa AI counterpart ng GPT sa google.

So kapag gumagamit ng calculator, tamad na. Eh if that's a more efficient way of having answers to your questions. :)

Pinagtagpi tagpi lang ni chatgpt.. di maasahan Lalo na sa mga ganito na topic..

Isn't that the goal? Magkaroon ng tagpi-tagping information kung yun ang hinahanap nya?

Kaysa halukayin mo pa isa-isa para lang mag-reply sa reddit or for other tasks. Of course, fact-check. Chat GPT and Gemini give links if may doubts.

You know AI is bad for the environment right?


si Aiah, marunong mag-isip e.

Bakit hindi si aiah ang leader?

Siguro minsan kasi nakikita mo yung vulnerability nya during visible panic attacks. As much as napaka-lighthearted ng persona nya, I am worried kung may trauma ba syang dinadala.

Tried looking for a panic attack video then saw yung "ang daming tao" moment niya. Omg grabe yung itsura niya, felt so bad for her pero ang galing pa din nakapag perform ng maayos.


Kaya lang naman ayaw ko sa Bini dahil diyan kay Colet, lakas makahatak pababa.

As for me ito yung nakikita kong roles nila pag nabuwag na:

Mikha- teleserye and movies, bagay mga actions like Kylie Padilla
Gwen- yeah mowdel talaga si ateh mala Maymay Entrata!
Aiah- host vibes, ang refreshing ng face eh
Maloi- same kay mikha pero mas bagay mga bff/comedy roles sakanya
Sheena- gurl?! sana maging next pop star or equivalent!

Yung tatlong engot na mukhang magiging vlogger nalang at doon magkakalat:
Colet- vlogger na paepal parang sila Yobab ganern, endorser ng scatter kasi laos
Jhoanna- vlogger din pero mukhang sa mga sossy vibes siya mapapasama, may class ang fez eh
Stacey- a day in my life ang atake! Hahahahaha

Shes my pet peeve. Yung mga pabalang sumagot kahit maayos kausapin. They say it's a regional culture thing, kasi bisaya, pero I find it sooooo disrespectful lol

HOY HINDE

It's a Colet thing. Dami-daming Bisaya celebrities na well-loved at maayos ugali ex. Melai, Maymay, Aiah

I agree. Just said what I always see her fans use as a justification for her behavior.


Si Gwen yung parang mga artists na magugulat ka na lang na successful na pala. Sya yung tahimik lang pero nagbbuild up ng career. Hindi masyadong exposed pero significant.

Mala maymay

Exactly!


I feel like Aiah would thrive anywhere she goes.

Yah, it feels like BINI is just a stepping stone for her...

Parang ganun nga naisip ko. Aiah is a model and may exp na siya sa showbiz kaya nga late addition siya sa Star Hunt para nabacker na ata.


sayang si Jhoanna pang newscaster or host na sana kaso di pala siya nagiisip

Gagi, akala ko siya yung mga student council type of girly na ayaw magpakopya kasi sobrang uptight  Di mo talaga malalaman ugali ng artista unless you get to personally know them

me too damn deep down parang queen bee regina george pala


IM sorry but if hindi ma te train si Colet with how to do PR, wala ikakabagsak nya din talaga.

Gandang ganda ako kay Colet nung una ko sila napanood. For me siya may pinakamagandang face sa Bini tie sila ni Aiah sa top1 ko kaso yung ugali jusko nakakaturn off  Parang Marian Rivera during her early years pero mas squammy

I dont want to use squammy with a negative connotation. Pero sayang pinagpaguran nila if di talaga sila matututo to talk nicely to people and their fans lalo sa social media where everything is literally taken out of context


Di ko makakalimutan yung pwedeng magwait ka? talking to a FAN. T$ng i$ang yan. Rihanna could never.

Saan to? Haha may vid ka?

Reply ni Colet dun sa tweet ng isang fan na concern lang naman sa kanila.


Maloi will strive as a singer lalo na if yung genre is mala-UDD, Barbie Almalbis, Kitchie Nadal.

Aiah and Mikha would do well as influencers. Pwedeng imilk ni Aiah yung pagtravel travel niya and yung fitness kineso nya. While Mikha can go the beauty route.

Did you mean "thrive"

Genre-wise, maybe dahil artsy artsy siya. Pero I think Maloi needs to have more vocal control training. Puro high notes siya sa BINI e. Parang di pa siya trained masyado sa vocal dynamics na need para sa ganyang klaseng genre.

Ayun. Kanina pko nagiisip if strive or thrive hahahah thanks for correcting

But yes, she needs vocal control training. Although kaya naman sya ang high notes lagi kasi iilan lang sila na mataas at marunong talaga kumanta naturally. So baka kaya naman nya icontrol, di lang natin alam.


AIAH and MIKHA. Sila lng hindi amoy squammy sa kanila. And theyre the two most equipped to go global with ambassador deals and shit.

Silang dalawa lng naman parati nagsasalita pag english interviews eh HAHAHAHA yung iba na cicringe sa sarili pag nag eenglish. watch their english interviews. when a member not named aiah or mikha answers in english, they'll say an english word, repeat it loudly, and laugh.

"we're so proud of our accomplishments. ACCOMPLISHMENTS?"

Pota I remember a video on Tiktok of Maloi na mag-aaral daw sya sa Thames(?) Uni or basta school. Nag introduce sya and said how she was very excited to go there tapos obvious naman na plain English lang and NO accent. Then may nag comment na Malois accent>>> ni reply-an ko ng Is the accent in the room with us? Tanginang yan na bash pa nga ako ng mga Blooms hahahaha fan din ako ng BINI and bias ko si Aiah at Maloi but judging from that video, wala naman talagang accent eh hahahaha

Wahahahaha ikaw pa napasama


Dapat bigyan ng chance i sali si Gwen sa Asias next top model, sobrang galing nya talaga sa ganyan eh kahit anong ayos magaling sya mag dala.

Pucha survival show na naman??? Tama na ho  Haha

Why not?! Pride naman natin sya if ever win or lose kilala na sya and for sure hindi naman ma di disappoint mostly ng fan talaga nya (me) maganda  sya i represent.


Aiah! Pwede pang model.

Jusko naman yang pangalan mo huy

Nananakit lang


Maloi and Mikha may star quality imo. Jho rin sana sa acting industry but nvm.

Si Maloi actually yung mukhang mahilig sa red flag na lalaki. Now pa nga lang nai-issue na dahil sa involvement niya kay Xild eh. Jejemon rin umasta. Hays.

Star quality ata yung tanong, hindi personal issues? Performance-wise, she has a strong stage presence, malaking factor rin fashion sense niya and vocal abilities as to why I think she will do well as a soloist.


Parang ewan naman kayo na biglang solo career na, taymperst lang. I think they should suffer the consequences too but I feel like grabe galit ng tao sa Bini vs the larger issue which is fcked up yung Pilipinas dahil sa govt lol.

maling mali ung 3 and they need to apologize and be accountable. pero sa totoo lng ang daming tao dito na nag aantay na may magkamali sa Bini tapos sabay sakmal na.  People in this thread needs to understand na at a certain point of our lives sasablay tayo and i hope there are people that are willing to give us 2nd chance.  chance na mukhang ayaw na ibigay ng karamihan.

This, heck di ako big fan ng Bini and if pipili ako, si Aiah din yung gusto ko, nadownvote pa nga ako, gigil din naman ako sa nangyari kasi abused ako as a child. But yung galit ng tao sa Bini feel ko stems on something deeper eh,  tipong matagal na nila gusto magfail Bini


Yes, I acknowledge that AIs can make mistakes too if it's a more complicated task.

But it's merely list of pageants that Aiah won, the commenter did it in a more efficient way rathen than going through websites herself.  And as per her screenshot, there are references anyway if fact check is needed.

Im answering the question you posed. You claimed that the use of ChatGPT as a search tool isnt a problem because it literally goes through the web to directly answer your question. Thats quite a confident, misguided assertion given the rate of hallucinations for GPT 4.5 was a whopping 37.1% for the SimpleQA test.

And no, AI hallucinations dont just happen with more complicated tasks. I recommend reading more about the phenomenon (its very interesting!), or using more grounded AI models for research if you really need it for accuracy. For reference, even Sam Altman says the hallucinations are a feature and not a bug at this point.

Im not trying to argue with you ha. And I dont really care about the Aiah thing enough to comment about it. Just wanted to temper expectations about AI models being the end-all of information-seeking.

Don't waste your time explaining, bruh. I tried that too, and sarado talaga isip nya. Maybe natamaan sya or naoffend kasi she uses AI in her tasks kaya ganyan nalang din kasarado isip nya. It's not a bad thing naman to use AI, pero kasi yung convcition nya na AI can do no wrong is very alarming. Nasayang lang din time ko magcomment bit it seems like I'm just preaching to a blank wall.

Siguro ganito na talaga mga pinoy ngayon. Basta may paniniwala ka, kahit mali or may magpoint out ng facts, ipaglalaban at ipaglalaban parin ang paniniwala.


Gwen could go the Maymay Entrata route and she will thrive. Aiah can do pageants and acting. Sheena does good acting too from her mmk ep.

Kailangan lang mag practice pa ni Aiah sa Tagalog if gusto nya mag acting. If pageant, ok din sya don since magaling sumagot and may background na.


Bakit parang walang nagbanggit dito kay Sheena? That girl's solo career is gonna thrive for sure!

She is such a talented dancer  pwedeng-pwede maging mainstay sa ASAP and she has a nice sense of humor.


Colet scatter endorser or motovlogger. Jhoanna on the Jen Barangan papansin influencer kuno trajectory. Stacey, backup dancer sa noontime show

HAHAHAHAHHAHA napaka specific mo naman mhie


Si Colet magiging barangay kagawad

Hoy HAHAHA pero actually nakikita ko to sa kanya. Mukhang di rin naman sya extremely comfortable here sa Manila. And afaik, nagtayo siya business sa Bohol. So mukhang magwork sa kanya yung pamumuhay sa probinsya. Tapos kukunin sya ng lokal na pulitiko as part of their slate because of her clout :(


Yung nasa picture, pwede mag model. Same sila ng vibes ni maymay. Pang fashion week aura nila

Yes ang ganda rin ng voice


Not a fan of bini, di ko kilala lahat din pero nagagandahan ako kay Aiah. Pero napanuod ko sa youtube yung nag solo siya kumanta off key siya doon, e-heads ata yun kinanta niya, nakalimutan ko na.. pero Sa bini sino yung magaling kumanta?

Yeah, not her area.

Unfortunately, 2/3 nung mga tukmol ang main vocalists nila, then si Maloi


Ok abscbn pr team

Hahaha jk

Huy compliment yan for me HAHAHAHA Mali ata talaga trabaho ko hay

Pero hindi, tbh fan lang ako ni Gwen and Aiah


Tingin ko wala. Parang Twice ok sila as a group pero so so lang pag solo career. Di naman sa di sila magiging successful pero more on so so nalang di kasing impactful pag group sila.

thisss


When they introduced Bini Gwen as patay gutom, I stanned her immediately. Hooray for all patay gutom

Hype ka natawa ako HAHAHAHAHAHHAA AGWENGERS ka rin po?


Agree ako kay Gwen, her face card sometimes gives off Lisa vibes.

FINALLY, YES.

Di sila magkamukha pero magka-vibe sila e. Must be the body.

(And performance, really )


Sayang si Colet tsaka Jho. Si Colet song writer. Pwede siya mag solo sa music. Bet ko actually yung ballad na narinig ko sa clip na gawa niya pero di nirelease. Si Jho naman news reporter

Si Mikha nag acting role siya before so ewan ko if mag act ulit siya

I can see Gwen as a model! Favorite siya ng camera

Sayang nga. For me Colet is their best singer  Kaso best in squammy din hay


Bagong host sa Wil to win

Na mago-awkward smile sa background kapag nagtantrums si Koya Wel. Example, Anna Ramsey.


oo sya lang naman maganda sa kanila.

Pakisampal nga yung nagsabi kanina dito sa chikaph na pangit raw si Aiah. Nayayamot na naman ako.


Sobrang angas makipag usap amputa bastos talaga

Alam mo ung mahirap na saksakan ng jeje na akala mo sya lang tama sa mundo pero shunga naman. Ganyan vibes ni Colet sakin.


Siya ba yung origin nung napindot yung anger ko eme? IIRC, cheer na cheer pa yung mga fans nila na pabalang na sumagot lagi si acclang Colet
Ako na casual listener, parang I tweeted sa same thread, for a member of an upcoming group, girl this attitude is not cute
So ayon, nasugod ako ng mga baby bra warriors hahaahaha

Vindicated tlga mga nagcall out sa kanila dati. Ndi Kasi nila ma gets Yong concept na may image silang dapat protektahan. Kala lahat papalampasin Lang.

Ahhh kaya pala I was hit with Hindi mo kasi sya (Colet) gets, kasi hindi ka fan

The good thing about it is there's so much digital footprint to throwback just like this one. Matinding I told you so hehehe


Actually hndi naman talaga super galing unlike SB19  mediocre lang po

Agree! Or ewan ko, baka magagaling sila pero lamya ng mga choreo nila, hindi nakaka idol. Parang kahit chuwariwaps on the side kaya yung mga choreo nila eh..

Tapos hndi rin nagpapakita ng improvement sa vocals or nagpapakita na nag -eexplore sila overrated talaga hahahhahah

Sobra  dapat nagstay nalang sila sa mga likes ng pantropiko kung ganon, wag na mag explore, di naman nag uupgrade eh


Feeling nya kasi cool maging ganyan hahaha syempre yung iba sasabihin nagpapkatotoo daw. Hahahaa ew

Ang squammy nung approach noh.

Herlene budol vibes talaga. You cannot take the squatter out of the girl charot


May reason kung bakit walang personal twitter accounts ang ibang kpop group members hahahahahaha.

Zakly haha matindi ang control ng kpop management for these specific reasons talaga

"By the neck and By the throat" lalo pag trabaho.

 sabi ng Korean counterparts namin sa work sa mga manager at project manager. Indeed ganun din ang method sa Japan


Hanggang ngayon ba wala pa rin silang album? nakakaloka management nila if thats the case.

di yata full album ung nirelease recently, ep lang ata yung considering kasi 6 tracks lang.

i think warranted naman talaga ung concern nung fan noon regarding sa album kasi ito ung time na inaanounce ung biniverse encore sa phil arena after their araneta concert. ano nga naman ipperform nila, same same lang? hahaha they expect the fans to pay their expensive tickets para lang panoorin ang same na perf?

tapos ayan ganyan ung sagot. also hindi nga siya directly called out/mentioned nung fan sa tweet e. sya mismo talaga nagreply.

thanks OP for the context, ngayon ko lang nalalaman ito and makes sense naman na bakit same same kahit dami na nilang concerts and tours. di rin kina cute ni Colet yung pagiging anger hahahaha


aura ni Colet parang schoolmate mong bully nung higschool.

Yung vibes nya parang may amoy putok ang kili kili.

Hooooooy akala ko ako lang nakakaisip nyan hahaahahahahhahahahahaah


Yan na kasi personality na nagustuhan sa kanya noon at feeling ko yan na din binigay ng management sa kanya. For people who dont know, sa kpop industry kasi, yung management nag-aassign din ng personality per member para isipin talaga ng mga fans na di boring yung group. Na tipong makakaattract ng fans kasi ibat iba personality ng members. As far as I remember, nung di pa sikat Bini, nagViral yung mga live video ni Colet na kausap niya mga fans niya tapos pataray o ma-attitude siyang sumagot. Love na love siya ng mga tao nun kasi artist tapos parang barkada lang kausap mga fans. Kaso ito nga lang, sumobra na kaya good luck nalang sa kanila, lets see if makakaahon ang career nila sa bagong issue.

This aint kpop, and theres no kpop management out there that promotes this type of core. Sure meron silang pa mysterious, ice king, ice queen bs pero skwating core? Wala lmao May nakita ka bang kpop idol na nakikipag bardagulan sa twitter? Wala.

Read again my comment, sinabi ko na nagviral noon live videos niya at yan nagustuhan ng karamihan ng tao o fan sa kanya kaya most likely, yan yung personality na binigay ng management sa kanya. Malamang di uubra yan sa kpop industry since grabe ang bashing sa kanila, wala naman akong sinabi sa comment ko na may ganyan sa kpop, binigay ko lang yung backgroup na nag-aassign ng personality ang kpop management per member. I hope iniintindi natin ang comment bago mag-comment hahahaha. May part ba na sinabi kong may skwating cote sa kpop? Wala.


Tingnan natin if magka epek ang lahat ng ito on how they respond sa tweets nila. Tactless, now ano?

Kaya nga eh, nasan ang tapang? I mean, take accountability! Be vocal, a quick tweet wont hurt to say you are sorry as a person not as a group.

 kasi nadadamay yung ibang members na nananahimik lang.


Tactless at squammy sya pero sa fans cute ang dating. And even during performances na may technical difficulties on her end, ang ate chona nya.

I guess shes trying to or maybe thinks she comes off as badgal/savage girl with the replies


Gustong gusto ng mga fans nila to, anger daw core memory ni colet - basag mga bashers nila kapag sinasagot ni colet.

\>> Feeling cool pero squammy, atechona

pero tuwing may issues, ang tahimik. throwing stones from a glass house.


eksena yan sha e, siya yung tipong nasobrahan ang pagiging straightforward bobita lang ang atake ng mga accla.

matatapang yan sila guys, naalala ko yung nasa pbb ang Jhocey, iniripan yata ni Dustin si Jhoanna tas nagsumbong si Stacey sabi ng isa "Ay, iniirapan mo ko?" sabay taas kilay angas e ahahahahahaa basta if you observe more mean girls ang atake nila, ganda yarn?

wala tayong winner sa dustin at jhocey tho inirapan naman talaga


Ending point ko talaga yung two-cents? keep the change  jusq ANG KANAL

OMG I FORGOT TO ADD THAT!!!!!


first bias ko si Colet kasi same kami taga bohol but after her interactions with the bashers sa twitter ekis na siya saken.

Di naman basher yan, mga fans ng bini yan


Ngayon lang naman ninonormalize pagiging squammy kesyo nagpapakatotoo lang daw. Wag ako. You are just mannerless.

bawal ata icallout hehe


si groomer napindot imbes na si anger

Di nya na mapipindot si anger be, mababalikan sya haha


Waiting for their down fall

In my observation as someone who does Advertising and Marketing, that is not too far.

 I mean, let's recall the Lowbrow Restaurant group downfall after their fake PWD tirade.

"Call them Satan" sabi nung Lowbrow Restaurant group


Hindi siya cool, may anger issues sya.

Deep rooted it seems. Sad and comical at the same time. But mostly sad na need i-address :(


Alam niyo ang nakakapagtaka lang hindi ba siya pinapagalitan ng management dahil diyan? Kasi diyan pa kang eh nasisira na image nila

Yeah, yan din ang thoughts ko. I find it strange na Parang walang media training ang Bini Members. As an educator sa Advertising and Marketing, this does affect yung imagery nila.

I dunno why, but perhaps this is where the fan appeal originated siguro?

I am not saying na ok ako dito sa galawan nila na palaban, I am saying na maybe the fans "fell in-love sa idea and imagery" ng ganitong "personality" who knows


Nagpa rhino lang, naging feelingera na masyado haha. Tapos itong recent issue, tanggal anger nya haha.

Hindi naman sya nagpa rhino teh. Dun lang tayo sa anger bat dinamay pati ilong?


Nadamay pa nga yung lima haha

appreciate this statement.

But, there's no apology for the girl you mentioned and laughed at in the video? Not even a direct acknowledgment?

Are you truly sorryor just sorry you got caught?

Accountability means more than words. It means cutting ties with people who crossed the line. We trusted you. Many of us still do. Dont waste that.

With the statement private moment, definitely only because they got caught. Ano pakialam nmin sa private moment, bastos ka pa rin

parang ang dating dahil private moment pwede maging bastos grabe selective naman pala ang women empowerment nila

Comment pa ng mga babybra warrior nila lahat naman daw ng magkakaibigan may mga ganyang joke (dark humor).

Jusko! Ginaya pa lahat sa mga tulad nila.

True, their lines is BAKIT PERFECT KA BA?


Parang kulang yung apology, wala silang plan na sinabi how to correct the behavior basta lang daw magreflect.

THIS. Apologize and sweep under the rug lang ang vibes ng statement na yan.

But Colet can never get away with her anger issues anymore. Maccall out sya. Hahahahaha

Si Anger ba talaga si Colet?

Sino sya pala? Haha

Lolzzzz si anger yung sa inside out.


The video shows a private moment of us with friends. HUHHHH oh tapos????

Like ganyan pala kayo mag usap privately. Bembangan, tapos pag usapan yung 13 year old na victim. Bwst.

parang kasalanan pa natin na napanood natin paano sila mag "biruan" in private lol

sa mga fans namn nila parang kasalanan rin ng nag post na nalaman ng mga tao ang baho na ugali ng idol nila

hinahunting nga nila yung nagpakalat ng video eh hahahahaha kahit mahanap nila yon, nothing will ever change the fact na yun tunay na kulay ng mga idol nila


Direk Dyogi could have simply typed this lol

Also wow it took them almost 24 hours from video upload to construct this? Huwaw

Minadali nga daw ksi nagbanta yung user ng nag leaked ng video na kapag wala pa rin statement may ilalabas pa sya na other issue na mas malala pa daw

source?


"Nagkamali kami" -- No shit, Sherlock.

Except it wasn't a simple mistake; it was a fucking choice.

scary, kasi if ever na totoo nga na 13 yrs old yung ashley, parang ok lang sa kanila yun? walang nag call out? tumawa lang? thats vile.

"Private moment" their asses. Sabihin nila, that's who they really are when they think walang ibang makakakita. Bunch of hypocrites.

Agree. Parang ang siste, ay nakalabas lang kasi, sorry. Next time di kami magvvideo abd post.


Tao lang naman sila nagkakamali rin. Kayo ba perpekto at hindi nagkamali sa buhay niyo? comments in 3, 2, 1!

Hahaha korek. Well jokes on them kasi di lang simpleng joke yan. Krimen yan be. Sit down.

Theres a fine line in everything. Ang ironic lang rin kasi advocacy nila ay women empowerment and sa children. Ibang usapan rin kasi yang ginawa nila dahil tungkol sa minor and sexual position ang biruan nila. Rape, bomb/death threat, minor jokes are different and considered as crime na. Magjoke ka nga lang sa airport na may dala kang bomba, automatic kulong ka.

Sa Tiktok yung mga Blooms nag live na sila, ok na raw kasi nagsorry na. Hahaha


Sana di na sinama yung pangalan nung ibang members sa baba lol, dapat akuin ng mga nasa video

tapang nung colet makipag-away sa fans nila tapos ngayon nagtatago sa group account

humbled si anger ih


This is hot trash and hot air. Non-issue kung private yan. Through that rogue friend, we were able to catch a glimpse of their truest selves. Yung tawa ni Jho? Thats ingrained. No hesitation, no second guessing. She enjoyed that shit. Yung pag video ni Colet? She wanted to keep that shit. Yung tono ng boses ni Stacey? Normal like reciting the fucking alphabet.

Kaya kung ako sakanila, mag music nalang sila uli pero wag na mag advocacy kuno kasi its all lost into the wind. Basag na ang pa-virgin era nila. Hindi din dapat sinama yung lima dyan kasi it indirectly means they were complicit to it all. Hindi dapat sila pumayag. Heads should roll.

Kung ako sa kanila maghiatus silang tatlo pero wag na bumalik EME

For sure lagi na ma-bring up yang "ahh 13 years old" ni Jho, that would surely haunt her for god knows how long.

Di ipaghahiatus yang 3 yan, kickoff na ng world tour nila this month tapos 2/3 ng vocal line nila kasali sa issue.


Doesn't change the fact na may mantsa na yung reputation nila. Hypocrite sila if they continue this women empowerment advocacy after what they did. The internet and the public never forgets.

Mabbring up ulit yung issues nila pag may fanwars

deserve. nang matikman din ng grooms yung ginagawa nila sa ibang fandom.


If they were in South Korea, wala na silang career after this. Or management will mandate 1 year or more career hiatus

Alam mo naman dito sa Pinas, mas kinakampihan pa mga balahura. Yung iba nga nagiging senador pa eh haha

True, mga tao sa pinas mabilis magpatawad at magbigay ng 2nd, 3rd to infinite chance sa mga tao demonyo


Colet ang tapang mang-away ng fans  sa X pero di kaya mag release ng sarili niyang statement char

Asa ka pa diyan kay anger pag siya may issue tahimik lang yan. Walang remorse whatsoever

Baka nga napikon pa yon bakit kumalat yung video nila eh


ahhahaha puro heart reax sa fb mga u2 u2

Pero sa ibang page na nagshare like ABSCBN, Inquirer, etc HAHA reax ang marami HAHHAHAHAHA

Typical kulto behavior


So what kung private moment yun with friends? Ganon ba talaga kwentuhan, topic, at inside jokes nila? Di naman sa pagpapakasanto kasi kami naman din ng circle of friends ko, nag-uusap about ibang tao pero as far as my brain can remember never kami magtouch sa topic na yan kasi who would even do that?

Private or not, no one should joke about doing s*xual stuff to a minor. You have to be sick in the head for you to be able to make or laugh at those kinds of "jokes"

For a group na marami madalas naman ata online (sa dami ng issues na nagsisilabasan about dito tapos mas nararaise na ang awareness ng karamihan sa sensitive topics like this) alam naman nila mangyayari kapag nalaman ng madla na ganyan pala sila.


Si Jhoanna leader nila di ba? Perhaps hanap muna sila ng ibang leader while nagpapalamig si Jho

Kapal ng mukha nung Jho kung magstay pa rin sya jan. isa syang malaking mantsa sa grupo!

Sa true! Nakakahiya kasi Leader sya


Grabe yung loyal supporters nila todo tanggol.Di ako magtataka kung panatiko mga yun sa politicians na problematic eh.

true mga dds rin mga yan, yung utak nila wlang kalman laman, madali mauto!

Ay for sure kasi kung talagang may prinsipyo at morals ka kahit pa idol mo basta mali call out dapat di yung blinded sa actions nila.


mukhang squammy. ugaling squammy. except for Mikha and Aiah

tapos pag sila naman may lumabas na issue...

not hoping for it since silang dalawa rin pinakabet ko sa group pero if there's a lesson to this issue, it's that we don't truly know these ppl kaya better to not assume ano ba talaga ugali nila

mfs don't learn lol


Grabe yung pag dedefend ng fan base nila Hahahaha may nabasa pa ko "bakit bawal magkamali" Luh si ate mo Rape joke na po yun hindi pwede basta basta joke yun

Isa pang line nila "Ang hirap pag public figure dapat perfect" mga baliw e no?

Mga kulto talaga eh HAHAHAHA


Most likely nerfed na yung tatlong Bini. Too bad yung isa leader pa. Juskopo. Tapos ngayon sa twitter yung nagupload ng video meron na daw pasabi or go signal sa source na may ipopost pa daw. Grabe whew.

Gosh. Siguro inantay lang mag issue ng statement yung management.

Kaya sayang na hindi na mauupload dahil naglabas na agad ng statements ang management, halata takot na may lalabas pa na baho sa bini


Pure K-Pop inspired. From attire, songs, even their dance. Pati apology ChatGPT.

13looms?

May nabasa nga ako sa facebook comment, dahil maraming enabler na blooms. "From blooms to groomer real quick" daw

Nagmukhang may class pa Sexbomb dancers haha


Do you really think BINI will be canceled or flop because of this issue? ABS-CBN is known for covering up their artists' controversies and even boosting their fame afterward. Remember Anne Curtis' 'I can buy you, your friends, and this club' outburst? Vhong Navarro's rape case? Coco Martin's alleged grooming of Julia? Coleen and Billy's cheating scandal with Nikki? Kim Chiu's 'bawal lumabas' moment? Maris and Anthony's cheating controversy? Did any of those ruin their careers? Hardly. If anything, BINI might come out of this scandal even more popular

Yung kay maris naging laughing stock na lang sya na possible ganyan na mangyayari sa bini, may makikita ka na comments na "13 years old, ano ginawa kay ashley? sinabunutan?". Tasyung next music nila possible magiging flop dahil hindi na tatangkilin ng masa at casual viewers. Yung Endorsements nila hindi na rin masyado matunog or papansinin ng masa gaya ng kay maris. Kilala na ang bini ng mga tao dahil sa nakakadire issue, hindi na yun maalis sa isipan nila

At first lang naman siya naging laughing stock. If youll look at the recent comments sa kanya, nawawala or natatabunan na yung mga lewd comments ng papuri sa kanya dahil sa show niya incognito. Yung endorsement niya, nadagdagan pa nga eh. Kung si maris na hindi naman big star ng ABS eh nagawan nila ng paraan para ma save ang career, tingen nyo ba talaga pababayaan lang nila isa sa biggest money maker nila?


Nadamay pa yung lima.

Wala naman daw nagsasabi na nadamay yung lima sabi dun sa subreddit nila. Isa lang kasi silang entity.

which is such bullshit lol. idol groups usually dont last long so si aiah and mikha na di squammy would want to have long-lasting solo careers. and being entangled with shit like this even if youre in the same group could damage them too if they dont voice out that "hey, i dont support nor condone that behavior and i have talked to the three in private"


Ano ba issue nila?

search sub

Ano po?


If they are actually sorry, the three people need to leave this group.

You are actually sorry? No, sorry , face the consequences.

Leave the Group!

wla sila consequences ksi wala namn endorsements ang nag pupull out dahil sa mga issue nila, pano ba namn mga fans nila bulag bulagan sa kakagahan ginagawa nila kaya hindi sineseryoso ng bini members mga issue nila dahil after lumipas issue nila may another issue ulit

Maaga pa

May magpupull out nyan.


I am not a fan of BINI or any local PPOP group but the thing about this issue is that I think the content is supposed to be a private moment shared with people those girls are really comfortable with

I am not defending nor implicating that what that video contains is appropriate because it is not. Pero if you watched it in a wider perspective, marerealize mo na They didnt do it actually in public for others to see and impose (unlike most f*ckd up influencers who proudly flaunts mga kabastusan ng bunganga, ugali sa socmed and masked it as being real).

It is like how most people  especially young adults act and interact with their inner circles, people closest to them, people we are most comfortable to have that so- called KANAL HUMOR which I think is much worse and the term is just used to justify kabastusan lalo na sa mga influencers na ambabastos yung jokes sa socmed nowadays.

Again, let me reiterate that am not justifying their acts but just implicating facts because all of u...

IMO:
1. "Kung kayo sa lugar nila..." I would never make a joke like that about a minor.  Sinoman sa friends ko maging ganito, kokonyatan ko talaga!

2. "May nagpost bigla sa socmed kahit di dapat" yes, mali naman yun. Pero baka nabwisit sa biro nila kaya inilaglag sila. For me, ang "hindi dapat" talaga eh yung ganyang biro. Sana nga biro lang, pano if totoo.  Hm?

Add: u/LucTargaryen_5999 magrereply ka sabay block. Kita pa rin reply mo pag nakalogout ako sa Reddit.

Nagpapadala ka sa bugso ng damdamin. Gamitin po ang kukote bago magreact ha o mamblock ha.

Di talaga ako naggi-green jokes, lalo na kung ang tinutukoy ay bata. Di mo ba matanggap na may ganong tao? Ang defensive mo. Ikaw ata ang natamaan.

Also may sinabi ba ako na TINOTOLERATE MO? Tsk tsk

1. kayo meaning NOT ONLY YOU. kung hindi ikaw natamaan, then dont act like youve been hit dahil hindi lahat ng tao sing linis mo. just a fact

2. LOL basic human decency din lalo na sa friendship yung respecting privacy. pwede namang komprontahin ng direkta at i call out sila habang ginagawa nila yun diba? the one who took the video could have just called them out in the first place without taking it, but instead it WAS POSTED CONVENIENTLY at THE MOMENT ONE OF THE MEMBERS WAS ALSO GRADUATING..

3. your reasoning clearly shows how narrow-sighted you are in the situation as what i have stated. I repeatedly say na I DONT TOLERATE WHAT THEY DID because it was never worth tolerating. what I am voicing out is how people who have shallow minds are eating up these girls like its not okay to be this shinning, shimmering image of perfection you guys are expecting them to be all the damn time, like how you drag them down just because a single exploitative video that should never have been uploade...


Theyre only sorry kasi they got caught. Pero kung hindi lumabas yung video? Ganyan talaga sila in real life. What a shame:

Tas alam din ng mga fans nila kaya galit na galit sila sa nagpakalat sa video dahil lumabas ang baho ng idol nila


May mga buong araw palang nagco-comment at nagpo-post ng anti-Bini dito sa sub lol. That hate is quite something.

Ansisipag ng mga taga chikaPH dapat irename na nila tong sub na to as BiniHaters haha

If OT ang pr team sa abscbn, mas malala ang OT dito sa pambabash hahaha

You can really check out their timeline. Parang nag-antay ng ilang buwan o taon right at this moment. I mean nakakatawa na nakakaawa ang mga galawan.

Yup parang mej matagal na yung ganap. Baka sa daleng dale na video pa nila yun or something ewan if may irereveal pa sila pero ilabas nalang nila yan para isang bagsakan nalang


I think Starmagic is just waiting for election and new pope para mabaon sa limot issue ngayon ng Bini

Mas matatabunan yan pag si Tagle pa naging Pope. Starmagic must be betting on that shit

hahahahaha baka may mga "issue" din yang si tagle na mauungkat pag nagka ganon. hahahahaha


Di na nila matatakasan yan. Sa comment pa lang sa fb puro "13 years old" eh. Tsaka magiging awkward na yan kapag may meet and greet sa mga menor de edad na fans. Kung ikaw nanay at tita ng bata, di ba nakakailang yun? Maalala mo yung mga tawa nila sa vid.

Awkward. Parang ayaw ko iharap sa mga pamangkin kong bata yung 3. Tumatawa at enjoy sa mga minor jokes. Staku, ikaw pa naman bias ng mga bagets.

Mag-aalangan lang ako pag lumapit ang anak ko sa BINI. Pero hahayaan ko pa rin. Pag dun sa dalawang maasim na boys, baka gumamit ako ng


Graduate na rin ang career

Nais kong i congratulate si Jhoanna na leader ng BINI dahil siya ay nakapagtapos (ng senior high)

Ngayon ang career mo din ay tapos HAHAHAHAHAH leader pa more

"women empowerment" pa more

pwede siya mag journalist... sa SMNI kasi ka humor niya si quiboloy

HAAHHAAHAH pwede na siya maging news caster doon


kaya pala nung graduation parang uneasy si jhoanna (mukhang napagalitan ng magulang) kumpara kay gwen na parang chill lang

makita ba naman ng parents mo na pumapayag ka na may nag rereenact ng doggy sa harap mo

mawawalan ka ng "proud parents" moments pag ikaw yung parents ni jhoanna HAHAHAHAHHA kakakita nyo lang sa video ng anak ninyo na natutuwa siya sa mga nag dodoggy sa harapan niya sabay sabi ng "ahhh 13 years old" HAHAHAHAHAHHA kakahiya


Omg goodbye Jollibee na ba ito??

not yet. kakapost kang ng jollibee sa x ng birthday greetings kay bini sheena

Naka-table pa rin yata sa meeting. Pwedeng drop ang three, or drop lahat. Si Anne nga takot na takot sa honest mistake nya with VG, eto pa kaya. Shocks!!


Expert ang ABS-CBN dyan, pero mas expert sila sa demolition job.

ABS-CBN has been master of dark media arts. Malas lang talaga nila mali yung siniraan nilang tao.

May Mga baguhan na mga tao nila ngayon, tingnan natin if well trained or hindi.

Yep. Kaya nga kinarma sila sa franchise nila, naback to you ika nga. Ginawang meatshield pa yung mga contractual people na nawalan ng trabaho.

Nakakatawa na parating sinasabi/criticize ng abs-cbn yung nga contract workers sa gobyerno, tapos sila mag ganon din.

Hahaha.


**BINI members involved be like:**

I misspoke.

It was just satire/dark humor.

That clip was totally taken out of context.

I was just trying to spark a conversation with friends.

I deeply regret my words

This doesnt reflect who I am.

I was in a toxic environment and went along with it.

I was triggered by my own trauma..

I was just really stressed and overwhelmed.

Ive done a lot of healing and self-reflection.

Bini just posted their statement and you almost hit it haha


Baka ilabas na na jowa nung isa yung Zild

Gagalingan nila mag edit sa PBB clips para yun ang umagaw ng spotlight


may nag downvote kaagad wala pang 1 minute sa pag post ko HAHAHAHAHAHHAAHAH may lurkers na maasim na blooms dito malamang

Lurkers na galing fb pero kulang sa karma para maka comment hahah


Kung ang Ashley na tinutukoy nila ay si Ashtine Olviga nga ng AMNSE, maybe ang 13 years old noon ay si Ethan David, while Ashtine was 15 years old at that time. Recently may nakita akong post about sa rumored relationship nila since 2016 pero not sure if that's true. If totoo naman, kadiri si Ethan at nagawa pa ikwento sa girl friends yung private experience nya sa ganon.

Narrative naman yan ng kapamilya trolls eh para mabaling sa iba lol.


video muna bago maniwala, bakit pa ba sila natatakot ipost yan

cyberlibel is waving

I'm confused, sa pagkakaalam ko ang libel is ikaw ang gumawa ng statement na ikakasira ng other party. Hindi yung siya nagsabi ng ikakasira niya. Correct me if I'm mistaken.

not a lawyer pero i know grounds pa rin yan for cyberlibel even if the person said it themselves. it's about the intent and how it's published. if the poster's goal is to damage someone's reputation, esp in public and malicious way, counted pa rin yan as cyberlibel under ph law.

yall are saying that it's the end of bini but far worst offenders still have a thriving career. Vhong is the one that I can think of and im sure there are others. Not saying that they should not be held accountable pero andami din napalagpas ang general public na problematic figure as long as they're talented. or pretty

baks, i never said that. which part of what i said sounded like 'the end of BINI' to you?

wrong reply. should've posted as a comment


Tangina lang.

Bakit mo ivivideo in the first place at ipopost pa sa social media (kahit dump account) ang mga ganitong bagay kung usapang magkakaibigan? Shit na nga yung pinaguusapan ninyo, gagawa ka pa ng ebidensya.

Gusto kong malaman ang thought process nila.

Yun din yung di ko gets. Back in my youth (charot) marami kaming kalokohan ng barkada ko lalo na kapag nakainom. Pero hindi namin vinideohan at lalong hindi naka upload sa internet. Ganun na ba ka addict sa social media ang Gen Z? Middle millennial ako, born late 80s, btw.

Hahaha millennial here and praning. Nagdedelete ako ng messages sa gc and dm minsan pag may nasasabi akong garapal.

Nahihiya ako na magviral sa social media at makita ng mama ko! Hahaha

Ngaun Kasi gusto Ng lahat magviral. Ayan napapala tuloy


Waiting sa gimik pr ni star magic

Magdodonate na sa charity ang bini in the next few days or weeks or may kakantahang orphanage/hospital

Hindi malayo, tapos animals2x, matanda, bata, cancer kids mala mmk, tree planting, clean up drive for the image, or magkakabitan na naman ang usual pokpoks ng abs-cbn tapos ihighlight nila kunyari para mapagtakpan ang kanilang golden goose. Or iiyak lang yan, dyan naman sila magaling

Tried and tested formula na ang charitable actions after scandals. Hopefully they don't go the weaponizing mental health route

Pinakamabenta yang mental health kineme sa ngayon, tapos ang ending, sila pa ang biktima. Mayabang pa naman pr ng star magic, ang hilig2x sa mga toxic talents tapos pag nabutasan, magmamalinis at tapos gawing normal ang mga kahangalan nila. Tandaan, most ng causes at advocacies ng mga yan ay part of their marketing. Mas makatotohanan at nakakarami ang snoke & fock dyan kaysa tunay. Giling lang mas marami dyan, pero ambabaw sa tunay na buhay


Maybe their managament was right for milking the fuck out of them when they were at their peak  After this issue, brands will surely back out one by one because the publics too enraged with this whole BINI issue.

Oo nga noh? Come to think of it, baka napredict na nila na PR disaster ang ibang Bini members and it's only a matter of time before magkalat ng malala at di na nila malinis, kaya take advantage na. Win-win sa management at sa girls kasi magkakaipon sila.

As a marketing girlie, heard from a friend in the industry din na adviced to stay away from social media na yang BINI members after their airport issue at mainit ang mata sa kanila on public. Hindi rin naman ata nakikinig at nakailang patol pa sila Colet on X. PR disaster talaga sila kaya baka tama rin na kinuha na lahat ng opportunities before kahit mukhang overworked sila.

Tagal ko na nagmamakaawa na wag na magsocial media pero nay dump account pa talaga. Ang kalat. They brought this upon themselves, which makes it so fucking frustrating. Imagine losing everything youve worked for because you can't just FUCKING LOG OUT


If these 3 will be the reason of their downfall, Id feel so sorry for Sheena. After hearing her story, BINI is her 2nd family and right now, yun ang lakas nya. Kung masisira ang BINI because of this issue, hope the management can save the other girls careers.

not a Bini fan

I think the management better cancel the contract of those 3 problematic Bini members

ok na ang 5 members

much better than 8

mas makakatipid pa ang management sa talent fees etc

Not a fan pero parang mas maganda tingnan pag 5 lang sila. Hindi masyadong problematic. Nasa lima naman ata yung malalakas na fan base e. Parang dun sa tatlo, si Jho lang yung maraming fan AT ISA AKO DOON. Sya lang pinakagusto ko sakanila kaya super disappointed ako.

You'd be surprised ang daming fans ni grumpy anger button colet. Kaya dami ngdedefend sa basura na ugali


kung sa South Korea to or kasing sensitive natin yung mga Koreans pagdating sa kahit anong issue ng mga celebs and idols, malamang bagsak na career ng mga to. madadamay pa iba nilang mga members dahil sa mga kawalangyaang ginagawa nila.

not a fan of Bini itself, but I could say na may ult bias are Colet and Sheena, natutuwa ako sakanilang dalawa pero Colet no more. I have to admit na problematic talaga siya. palaging galit, tuwang tuwa pa mga fans nila. kesho napindot na naman si anger kuno. masyado siyang pinipreach sa pagiging angry bird niya. tuwang tuwa pa mga blooms tuwing pinapatulan niyan yung mga bashers.

Jhoanna naman. girl, what happened? same with Stacey.

ilang taon na ba ang colet na yan at ginagawang whole personality nya si anger?

She's young, pero a lot of the younger generations are angry naman talaga

meh, she's 23


"Squammy" kanal humor slash relatable local girls ang brand ng Bini girls, or at least yung mga members na sikat. Never liked them for that actually kasi ang taklesa nila. Mga walang class. I believe na when you're a celebrity, specially an idol, need ng konting mystery and all. Kapag binunyag mo lahat, you have a certain demographic na ma-aattract. Kaya ayan look at how their fans act lmao.

Someone needs to make a PPOP group with the debut era Blackpink/MEOVV marketing style na "exclusive" and consists of classy anak-mayaman girls na may media training. For sure there's a market for that Bini can't tap in dahil "pang-masa" sila at hindi naman ganon ang image nila.

BINI members were adviced to stay away from social media pero sila lang ang hindi nakikinig haha sakit na ng bumbunan ng PR team nila  Okay naman na pang-masa ang brand nila pero according to my friend, pinagsasabihan na yung girls na wag na masyadong sumagot sagot sa fans sa X at lalong umiinit ang mata sa kanila ng public. They should be doing the KB way na pang-masa pero still mystery pa rin ang totoong character.

Yung pagsagot talaga nila sa fans sa Twitter ang na-off ako. At ang kunsintidor rin nung iba eh maypa-"napindot na naman si anger xD" pa.

And yes, okay lang rin ang pang-masa brand. It works talaga. Ang SB19, from what I see, very kanal humor, relatable, local boys, rags to riches din ang branding. Pero never ko nakitang sumasagot 'yan sa masa kahit ang daming trolls or negative comments. They respond with music or humor instead. Kaya ang solid ng fandom nila eh. Eh etong Bini, may rift at divide na agad ang fandom dahil mismong fans inaaway

Oo, si Pablo mismo eh hindi nagpapapatol and dinadaan na lang sa kanta yung mga sagot. Notice how the tracks they're producing consists of multiple diss tracks di ba?


Ayoko ng ganyan. Mga pasabik. Kung irerelease niyo, irelease niyo  Hindi yung madami pang pa hanash na ganyan. Nakakabwisit. Hahaha

Idrop na agad, parang kailangan muna ng maraming likes eh HAHAHHA UHAW DIN EH HAHAHHA

Mga clout chaser ang mga putangina


this is the kind of pr nightmare abscbn probably never expected from them

If they didnt preparw for the worst negligence on their part. If cash cow pala ang peg dapat mas nag higpit sila

PR teams here are nothing like US media PR teams. No where near as strict as they should be.


casual fan tita here but not a bloom.

i think dark and bastusan biruans really exist kasi maraame talaga sa atin ay taklesa at greenminded as a culture. plus we dont know ano context nung usapan so di ko masabi na SA and grooming ung video. so i really cannot crucify them for those heavy allegations cause it wasnt proven real, unless we see the full vid.

ang ayoko lang sa BINI ay yung pagrelease nila ng statement na
"ooops sorry we got caught pero kasalanan nyo pa din nainvade privacy namen" kind of way. sama mo pa ung patuloy nilang pangaaway sa fans nila. tho calling out your fans if they are roo much is admirable, may healthy way to do that.

while i agree we should respect the artists' privacy at tama naman talaga ung ibang pinaglalaban nila- the artists should also have this high level of awareness to accept the fact that they are a public figure" and a part of their job is to be exposed in public's eye kaya dapat, alam nila mismo na parte ng trabaho nil...

Same. Confused ako saan galing yung SA and grooming allegations. Out of context yung video and ang daming pwedeng context na hindi ganon kabigat.

For example, what if dinedemo nung two guys yung sexcapades nila when they were much younger? That's why emphasized yung "13" na age kasi nga naman unusual iyon for a 13 year old. But if she was doing it with someone around her age, that doesn't make it grooming, let alone SA.

That's just one possibility. Is it crass? Yes. Medyo off-putting if hindi ka type of person who makes 'dirty' jokes. But that doesn't automatically make it SA or grooming at all.

i was thinking about that too. nung una kong panood, i thought the girl who said "13 years old" was pertaining dun sa isang lalaki, na he was 13 when he did that. hindi ko rin na-gets nung nabanggit yung name ng babae. sobrang kulang talaga sa context. not that I'm justifying that vid, i found it uncomfortable, and i barely know the people involved. sana lang maghinay-hinay sa mga salitang binibitawan yung iba kasi masyadong mabigat yung allegations na yun.


Alis nalang sila 3 para di madamay career nung 5

True the fire. Delicadeza na lang if meron pa. Or yung 5 mag solo career if keri pa ma redempt. Tbh, they cannot cling with the "BINI" name anymore. Like in just a snap, naglaho bigla tingin ng mga tao sa kanila to the point na kahit anong damage control rn ng PR nila, laughing stock na sila because of what the 3 did.


Tagal na sinasabi na dapat i-train ng matindi tong mga to regarding responsible social media handling, di pa rin ginagawa. Ngayon, sana tutukan nila lalo na yung tatlo especially sa mga pag-uugali. Hindi na cute. Tumatanda na silang mga basura ang ugali.

Feel ko sinabihan naman yan, si Maloi nakinig ehh, yung isa matigas talaga ulo


Imagine after how many years of training, sweat and tears, ganito lang kadali sirain

5 years of training sa 10-second video clip.


Oh my god. Masyadong naging comfortable sa soc med feeling untouchable. Hays

pumasok na kasikatan sa ulo ng tatlo tsk tak tsk


Is this the end of their Era? Ambilis naman

As a Bini fan, sadly yeah, looks like it, hirap bumangon jan

Mag World Tour pa naman sila, goodluck sa cancel culture ng West, kaya sobrang frustrated din ako tangina, parang disappointed parent ganon HAHAHAHA


Si Colet yung classmate mong campus crush at palaging sasayaw-kanta pag may program sa school pero 8080 at palamura.

I never liked her to be honest. May something sa kanya na off vibes.


Puro pa cool kasi iniisip wala ng logic sus

Yan pa itturo nila sa fanbase nila. Smh


OT5 coming soon

sila na lang itira tutal anjan naman yung ibang crowd favorite


hahahaha.. ilang taon ba ang average ng mga users dito, bat naniniwala kayo sa mga ganyan.. juicecolored

sa totoo lang haha


An tanga bat ksi ni record pa... Sorry bobo. Ayan tuloy, face the consequence.

Sorry di ako updated, anong video po? May link kayo?


Pang-ilang anti-Bini post na ito? lol

The hate did not come from nowhere bro. Deserve nila yung flak


I think normal lang mag-green jokes within the circle, pero I dont think normal na isali ang minor don. Kahit yung mga madalas mag-green jokes, hindi ginagamit ang minor as example. Thinking about it, wala talaga akong maisip even in my circle ko na nag-jjoke ng ganyang klase. Either enabler ka or wala ka pang muwang sa mundo kaya tingin mo hindi big deal yan. Hopefully, its the latter.

As someone na lagi may kabiruan ng green jokes, true yarn. Haha ang biruan namin lagi sa double meaning ng words tapos samin samin lang na may same wavelength pagdating sa green jokes


Yung may guy na nagcomment na bakit daw sila nakamask sa airport eh di naman sila sikat daw. Tas nung the next time na nag airport yung bini nag jabawokeez costume sila full mask tas hoodie. I honestly think na that's funny hahahaha. Nagkaroon pa ng mini game sa twitter na kung sino raw ba yung bini member na ipopost nila while wearing the hoodie and mask

But I draw the line at that type of humor. SA humor will never be funny to me and SHOULD NOT be funny to anyone

Their jabawokeez stunt was funny naman haha pero medyo ayaw ng PR team yung ganon na pakulo kasi mas nag gather pa ng attention sa public, lalo na on Facebook na consists of boomers.


Hindi naman taga-ABS iba jan, lalo na yang Lily Ganados. Binabash niyan sa account niya mga celebrities na inaaway ng fans ni Kathryn, majority are fellow ABS celebrities. Nakikipag-kampihan pa yan sa GMA alts para mang-bash ng ABS celebrities na hindi friends ni Kathryn. Kupal yan.

wag ka ng mag taka fan din yan ni Deanna Wong na attitude sa fans

Kaya lang naman naging "fan" ni Deanna Wong yan kasi kasagsagan noon ng love team nila ni Jema Galanza. Alam nyang nasa baby bra warriors ang clout kaya doon sya. LOL.

pero ngayon si Jema binabash nya na


lol hypocrites, pag ibang celebs yan OA sila mambash talaga, araw gabi pulutan nila. Selective

Pag si Alden o Marian iyan abot hanggang impyerno galit nila. Nagsasaboy ng walang patawad na insulto at panlalait. Pero sa kapamilya, bigyan daw ng chance. Sabagay ano mapapala mo sa mga paid trolls?

May dagdag fake news na blind item pa yan para gatungan pa.


Syempre galit sila kasi baka mawala sa payroll  di gumagana pagtatanggol nila kaya nanganganib matanggal sa PR team lmao

Baka sila na next na ligwakin kapag nagbawas na naman ng empleyado ang ABS.

Sana nga sila na ang next in line maligwak HAHAHAHA


Kakapal ng mga mukha nyan. Ilang years na nilang sinasabi na mangga si Alden. Kung hindi mangga, bakla daw. Front lang daw yung sa love team kineme. Bakit hindi pa sila manigas?

Uy careful baka sabihan kang Alden fan. Lahat daw ng redditors commenting against their fav fan ni Alden

Hay naku go lang


Funny tlga ng mga kapam alts. Pag GMA artists yan sila ang nauuna mag crucify at magpapakalat ng hate train. Mga kup*l tlga sila.

This. Kaya Ang dami Kong tawa sa latest tweets nila. Hypocrites


Same alt accounts na mahilig mang-drag down sa esbi. Especially, kay Stell.

They are also the same people na grabe yung pambabash kay julie anne about the church mistake where she take accountability naman but super tanggol sa pag cheat ni maris racal na hindi naman nag sorry pero nagpa presscon.


Hahaha yan si Auntie Selina mukhang tambay lang din yan dito sa chikaph, & if you check her post dito lang din naman minsan galing yung content niya. Hindi naman lahat dito solid fan ng mga actor/actress, chikadora lang talaga & good observer.

si Aunt Selina na hindi kayang ibash at sabihang groomer si Coco Martin, todo flex pa ng ratings ng batang quiapo at lait sa acting ni Ruru


auntie Selina at lily,Dito kayu pumalag sa chikaph

Nag try na yan mag karma farming si selina at pookie pie, dedmakels mga marites gaha


Blooms = DDS = Loyalists = Extreme Leftists = Iglesia ni CoolTo =  Purist kakampinks

Pareparehas na panatiko, pareparehas na 8080.

Also Blooms = Kathcakes

BINI and Kathryn are the top female cashcows of ABS. Evident naman sa 2024 Christmas ID ng ABS


bayad yan sila. PR accounts lang din yan disguised as makamasa alt accounts to create or alter the narratives about their talents/celebrities

kumbaga pang-sway lang ng public opinions

ganyan din sila nun kay maris. always on the move pag may issue/scandal na


I fucking hate ABS CBN PR. LALO NA THAT THEY'RE TRYING TO INFILTRATE THIS SUB. Mga walang modo kayo, to spin your artists mess into a palatable gig to protect your business is unbelievable. Wag kayo pa epal hanggang dito, di niyo nababayaran mga gumagamit dito

True. Nahahalata agad sila dito. Hirap na hirap sila. Unpredictable kasi dito.


what if GMA artists ang may issue, ano kaya magiging tweets nila? HAHAHAHHA

Nauna pa nga sila dati isplook yung r*pe kay Sandro Muhlach kaya napagpyestahan. Nung nagsalita si Nio at Sandro na di nila nagustuhan yung mga naunang nagsplook ng walang consent, at nagiisip sila magsampa ng kaso, ayun bilis magdeactivate ni Altindaybadiday pati ng ibang alts.


Sana mapost din rin fez ni Naibara Lopez na isa din pulgas ni pusa

May nag labas na ata dati sa x ng mukha nun ei terno din ugali nya sa itsura nya.


kung sa South Korea to or katulad tayo ng mga Koreans na sensitive when it comes sa kahit anong issue ng mga celebs/idols, bagsak na career ng mga to eh

At dito Naka depende rin if sino nag hahandle kasi yung iba nkaka balik pero Yung Ibang artist halos di na mbalik ung dati nilang career status

yes, pagalingan nalang din talaga ng PR. look at Kim Seon Ho, pabagsak na sana career niya nung kasagsagan ng issue niya pero magaling yung may hawak sakanya. kalkal kung kalkal sa past niya hanggang sa naisalba siya at namamayagpag parin ang career niya, kasi nga wala naman siyang fault. pero etong BINI, dili nalang ako mag-talk. ano yung advocacy nila? women empowerment? taena HAHAHA

The thing din kasi with Seon Ho, may fans siya outside Korea na talagang susuportahan siya no matter what. Sayang naman din kasi yung caliber niya sa acting, hindi naman ganun karamihan ng actors sa kanila.


Nasan na kaya yung mga babae rito na nag popost na kesyo nag seselos sa jowa nila na baliw na baliw sa mga chimay na to? Eh chimay naman talaga. At di ko sinasabi to dahil lang may issue sila, putangina ang pangit naman talaga.

HAHAHAHA nako tagal ko na sinasabi yan. Yung isa diyan muntik pa mautusan ng isang stylist friend ko dahil akala niya talaga julalay. Bini pala.

kahit siguro sino kapag nakitang walang make up yang mga yan mapapagkamalang angels ni small laude

lang talaga


"Bini save us through their music, tayo naman ang mag save sa kanila ngayun"

-taena mga superhero

saved us through their music???? di ko nga bet mga kanta nila hahahahahahahahahahaha

Imagine someone drowning and the lifeguard starts playing 'Cherry on Top'


Ito ba yung mga gandang ganda sa sarili nila??? Sure na kayo dyan?

Gulat nga ako eh. Yung nasa left tinatawag na Jennie Kim, kairita hahahahahaha

Huh? Sino nagsabi? Blink ako ha pero te di ako ganyan ka bulag. Jusme wag naman si Jennie ko hahahahaah


Possible scenario is ilalaglag ng star magic yung talents ng Viva para masave yung cashcow nila. Star Magic is notorious for throwing others under the bus.

ito lang pinagtataka ko sa viva, bihira nila ipagtanggol mga talents nila. Like nung kasagsagan nung isyu sa kasal ni Claudia Barretto at binabash ng nanay ni cianne dominguez sila julia claudia at marjorie wala man lang pa-statement ang Viva Artists Agency to defend claudia & julia to think pareho nilang artists si claudia at julia ha at panay ang pagpapahiram nila ng artists nila sa Showtime.


Makakalimutan din daw yan ng fans nila

in denial naman din fans nila todo tanggol pa


Hindi namn talaga sila kagandahan or sobra visual kapag wala make up

Hahahaha kaya nakakapagtaka pag may nagsasabi na ang ganda nila e, di ko talaga gets


Maapektuhan kaya endorsements nila? Magkaka penalty kaya sila dahil sa issue?

Yung Jollibee jusko poooooo

For sure yan. Nung naglive in nga si James at Nadine, ekis na sila eh. Yan pa kayang SA ng minor.

Confirmed ito?

JoshLia break up, sinong natira?

Right Joshua.

Though did not know JaDine got dropped because of that live-in bit.

But knowing Jollibee, they are conservative.

I am so surprised Maris Racal came back for Mang Inasal.


Kung totoo man ito, mukhang indefinite hiatus muna ang mga main characters ng universe. Pero ang dali itype ng a very reliable source eh so hahahahha

Nah they have an upcoming overseas tour. There is no way mag hiatus mga yan.

Pwede maghiatus ung ibang members, tas ireason health prob.

jusko pleaseee wag sana tayo gamitan ng mental health card

Iiyak yan sa world tour nila at sasabihin Maraming salamat Blooms. Alam ko/namin na marami kaming pinagdadaanan ngayon, pero you chose to stay with teary eyes wink wink

Wag mo bigyan ng idea hahaha. Hirap na hirap na pr team nila maglinis ng mga kalat nila. Dinagdagan pa nila. Bumango na nga ulit pangalan nila paglabas ng PBB tapos nabawi agad pagkatapos ng ilang araw palang.


Oh naur! Tuloy pa kaya ang world tour nila dito sa Dubai sa 18? sold out pa man din un nung una then nag-dagdag sila ng seat.

Me and my friends also bought tickets. 6 kami in total but now I don't feel like going na. Let's see nalang talaga

Puntahan nyo pa din. Kesa masayang yung pinambili nyo ng tickets. Kung ayaw nyo pumunta then sell nyo na lang. lam mo na, hirap buhay dito sa Dubai. Mistulang reward na lang natin sa sarili yung makapunta sa mga ganitong event.

baka ibenta nalang. Di naman talaga ako fan nila, but I listen to some of their songs. Tsaka pag may nagcoconcert talaga dito na OPM artist, sinusupport namin. But this recent issue parang nakakawalang gana sumupport nang artist that don't live up to their advocacies .

Ok lang mawalan ng gana. Isipin niyo na lang kumain kayo sa fine dining restaurant. Haha

hahaha kaso di nakaka fine dining yung issue charot. Napag usapan namin, na manonood nalang kami since matagal na plano namin magkita kita on this same day. from iba-ibang emirates kasi kami manonood.


Ano kayang damage control gagawin ng abs d2. Actually kahit d2 sa reddit daming warfreak diehard bini fans. Dinelete ko na nga ibang comments ko kasi wala akong time makipag gera sa mga yon.

Same damage control kay Maris and Anthony. Apologize once then lie low and keep quiet. Labas nalang ulit pag may bago nang issue at nasa ibang celebs na ang galit ng mga tao. Pretend like their own issue never happened.

Ipagrerelease din ng kanta

Lam na this. Tapos siguro sa kanta nilang isa about sa mental health niya eme

Or Perpektong Tao version 2 haha


If this is true then the World Tour is probably going to be cancelled...

Yung concert sa LA, di pa din sold out.

Ambitious naman kasi i Direk Dyogi. Hindi pa man sila international calibre na kaya mag world tour tbh. Gaatas na gatas ang mga akla.

Ang pangit ng pag-handle sa kanila sa totoo lang. They're milking the group dry right now. Ilang beses na sila nag to-Tour with the same set list. Dapat they should be making more music to increase their music catalogue. The music is supposed to drive tours, not the other way around.

Weird nga na nasa aurora pa sila. Ang dami nilang livs performances with so little to show for, hindi naman sila cover band!


Kaya pa ba kahit 5 na lang?

Sa tingin ko hindi, paano ang vocal performance ng group kung maalis ang 2 members na nagbubuhat sa live vocal ng group?

Colet and sino yung isa?

Jhoanna. Pero feeling ko kaya naman, nandiyan pa si Maloi. Magaling din kumanta si Gwen. Si Sheena at Aiah sakto lang.


Yung mga ganito yung dapat pinopost dito sa sub na to eh  Pa update EOD, OP! Hahaha

tama di yung puro lait dapat chika talaga hahaha


Ang take ko sa BINI issue ay dapat mas malala yung backlash sa mga lalaking gumawa nung joke. Accountable yung 3 as part ng video lalo ang laki ng platform at influence ng BINI, pero parang dapat mas turuan ng leksyon na rumespeto yung 2 lalaki.

Both pareho ng level ng backlash. Mas pa nga dapat sa babae eh kc kabastos bastos na talaga yong may magrereenact ng sexual activities sa harap ng lider na yon at tatawa pa. Eww tlaga. nung teenager ako na wala pa ganun kaalam sa sex pero alam kong bastos ang ginagawa nila. Ekis tlaga

Well palagi naman babae yung sinisisi sa ganyan kahit periphery sila sa joke. Pwede ba tayo mas mapanuri at kritikal sa lalaki? Nagbabago na mundo hindi na dapat may pass lang mga lalaki sa ganyan kesyo lalaki sila


over sa "we stanned the right member". nilagay na naman sa pedestal hahahaha

Typical redditor thingz


this will gonna be their downfall ,nakakadiri ampt to think na mga babae pa

Yun na nga eh halata mo sanay na sanay sila sa ganun disturbing joke, pakarat girlie yung tatlo sa loob binibini sa panlabas


Sino ba yung mga lalake? Non showbiz friends? Livestream ba un or if hindi, sino nagpost ng vid and sino yung ashley? Sorry diko knows yung mga pahamak na lalake sa vid

Di ko kilala yung isa pero, si Ethan, member ng GAT ppop boygroup.


According to my source, Aiah is headed to NXT daw? Akala ko diretso main roster na.

Jade Cargill yarn?


A very reliable source ito naman mga tao dito maniwala agad.

Note: i do not tolerate Bini behavior specially S/A jokes.

Maniniwala sila kasi pasok sa agenda nila hahahaha


Feeling ko nga si Aiah unang magsosolo e.

Good for her! Nasa kanya na ang lahat. Yung iba nakikisabay nalang sakanya pra matawag na may sense


i think medyo malayo narin loob ni aiah sa ibang girls. mapapansin na tahimik lang sya pag magkakasama sila di tulad noon na labas lagi yung kulit. maybe nao-off na rin sya sa ugali ng ibang members. pinagtitiisan nalang since Bini yung nagdadala ng pera sa kanila

Parang si Aiah lang kasi yung nagma-mature sa kanila. Yung mga joke at topic ng members paulit-ulit, hindi na nag-evolve from brainrot humor. Ang laging topic nila kay Aiah, her age, her ship with Mikha, her hobbies na sasabihin nila pang-tita.