Ok naman yung Bini, nakikinig din ako ng songs nila. Pero wag naman munang global superstar. Wala pa sila don.

paano daw si global it girl, gabbi garcia? lol.

Juskooo true bang may paganon?? HAHAHAHAH nakakaloka talaga dito sa pinas. Lahat na lang, global, international, asias kineme.  i mean, no hate kay gabbi kasi magaling naman syang host. Yung may pa-title holder lang.


Sobrang shunga kasi talaga ng management nila. Dapat mas dinamihan pa yung filipino songs eh para mas ma establish sila lalo. Akala nila porket may dalawang hit songs (pantropiko, at salamin salamin) eh ready na sila mag transition sa international audience pero hindi eh. Yung recent english songs nila parang mga rejected scrap songs lang ng kpop groups.

rejects talaga ata ng twice mga yun kasi same producer daw

Ooh kaya pala Zero Pressure reminds me of I Can't Stop Me, or may Twice Jap release vibes hehe

Papasang magkapatid ang concepts nila actually

1.	Dance the Night Away (Twice) = Karera (BINI)

2.	Alcohol-Free (Twice) = Pantropiko (BINI)

3.	Scientist (Twice) = Blink Twice (BINI)

4.	I Cant Stop Me (Twice) = Zero Pressure (BINI)

5.	The Feels Album (Twice) = Talaarawan (BINI)

Karera is good thooo! Hindi siya tunog rejected song ng twice. Filipino songs are really their sounding talaga. Kung ipipilit talaga yung english songs pwede naman taglish. Yung "Pit a Pat" nila yun na pinaka magandang english song nila for me at it would have been better if yung chorus ay Filipino! I think it will be a hit

Maganda yung Karera and I don't think TWICE reject siya. Pero yung mv niya, yung pinaka-first part, parang same ng DTNA na they were all wearing white, nagising sila sa beach na para bang nashipwreck sila. Parang nung una ko nakita yung mv ng Karera, DTNA agad naalala ko although nag-iba din naman yung mv sa later parts.

Yeah and ang lamang naman ng BINI sa TWICE yung harmonies nila and pag utilize ng alto members nila. Hindi kagaya ng arrangements ni JYPapi na laging ang tataas key. Vocally, BINI reminds me more of SNSD+Mamamoo kaysa sa TWICE.

sang ayon ako sa pag gamit ng vocals nila... kung tutuusin vocal placements nalang nila ang kinakapitan ko kaya umaasa parin ako na babalik sila sa acapella roots nila. sa dami ng ppop groups na sumulpot sila palang parin ang nakakagawa nun ng tama at makinis.

they are at their best pag "real life pitch perfect girlies" ang peg nila. they are at their worst pag "twice copy-cats" sila

kung may gusto silang gayahin sa kpop, gayahin nila mamamoo nmixx fifty gfriend apink redvelvet

pero kung tutuusin hindi naman kailangan dahil pwede naman silang maging modern day smokey mountain or doremi o kung ano pa

lagpas kalahati ng members ng bini kayang bumaba panic ng malinis sa mga vocal placements nila.. si colet at gwen palang ang lawak na ng sakop e, pano pa yung pag kagaya ng sa wish bus perf nila ng cherry on top na literal na nagpapasahan at nagsasaluhan sila ng vocal placements. napakalaking sayang kung magiging twice copy cats lang sila


To be fair, K-Pop is just pre-loved Jpop 20 years ago. Nag evolve na lang sia into what it is now. Also, around 75% of Kpop releases are written by western composers na trinaslate sa korean, so the influenced are not really original.

Even if may mga lapses sa P-pop scene na ganto, ang importante is we retain listeners to local music scene. This is the strongest era of OPM since the early 2000s so lets just enjoy the ride.

Yes, KPop evolved from JPop. But now KPop has evolved so much, even the untrained ear can hear the difference between the songs of AKB48 and Blackpink.

Lahat ng bagay ngayon may foreign influence o "industrial grade copy-paste" ika nga ni OP. Bakit hindi sabihin na copycat lang ng McDo ang Jollibee? Na hindi original ang Chinese food ng Chowking at hindi Italian food ang Greenwich? Pati yung mga banda noong 90-2000's tulad ng Eraserheads bakit hindi sabihing "gaya-gaya" lang ng mga banda sa Amerika?

Natural at mabenta ngayon ang KPop kaya gagayahin natin. Pero yung kinokopya natin nagiging Pinoy. Tignan mo ang Jollibee spaghetti. Ang original spaghetti ay maasim, tulad ng sa McDo at Sbarro. Pero ginawang matamis ng Jollibee, nilagyan pa ng hotdog. Magalit at maweirdohan man ang mga foreigner, Pero ang Jollibee spaghetti ang spaghetti ng Pinoy. Isauli mo ang birth certificate mo Pag hindi. Haha.

Agreed about spaghetti. Flavor so distinct foreigners go there to get their fix. Proud to be shareholder

Saka Ewan ko din sa Yumburger. Beef naman siya pero hi di yung beefy ng Burger King. Basta iba. Pag may nagbukas ng Yumburger sa aircon na sasakyan tulad ng van o bus, nakakainis! Sa inggit! Haha


Well, P-pop and OPM are two different genres. P-pop is mainstream pop via manufactured groups or soloists. The OPM you are referring to are the bands of the 90s and early 2000s who had control over their sound.

We bought CDs and cassettes because we did not have streaming back then. Also, since there are no livestreams yet, if we want to see our favorite band, we have to hike it to wherever their gig is. I cant see that as us being more hardcore fans simply because we didnt actually have a lot of choices. If we want to see a band, we go to their gigs. Otherwise, well have to settle with FM radio.

Lastly, both cater to very different kinds of listeners. Bini may be churning out what some people may call musical garbage, but if the masses listen to it anyways, then we cant really argue with the results can we? Pretty sure the DJs who made money out of Budots music couldnt care less about what people think about it as long as they cash their checks.

Wait, isn't OPM the general lterm for any music that originated in the Philippines? And P-pop is a more specific genre under it? Then the bands are pinoy rock music? Or ngayon ba hindi na acceptable na tawagin din na OPM ang P-pop?

Sorry, nalito ako sa terms mo hehe

I'm late for the party pero na-observe ko na marami sa kanila ang tingin ay P-pop = boy/girl group. It's like the P-pop genre did not exist before maglabasan yung mga pop groups recently. Na parang sila ang dahilan kung bakit may p-pop ang OPM, ganun.

Yeah, mukha ngang ito yun. Dati nga may discourse pa if Sarah Geronimo should be included sa p-pop genre because she is making pop music kaso hindi daw kasi solo ata siiya? Idk haha I don't want to be too strict sa terms kaso parang may air or superiority kasi minsan kapag ayaw gamitin yung OPM as a description haha


Di lang naman Bini ang representative ng P-pop, dami pang ibang group dyan

True, may SB19 at ibang groups dyan pero BINI lang ata napapansin ng iba when it comes to negative comments. Parang lahat naman din ata ng P-pop groups na nandito sa atin may formula at nagsimula sa pagiging kpop copy paste. Problem lang siguro sa case ni BINI is that nagsimula kasi sila na tagalog talaga yung kanta, makabuluhan, at representation sa realities ng pagihing Filipino. Now na sumikat na sila parang kinalimutan nila paano sila nagsimula

Totoo namang kpop ang tinatahak na path ng bini e. Ang dami namang ppop group na hindi ganon, pero nadamay pa buong PPOP.


Pls exclude the other PPOP groups who are actually breaking out of the mold from this narrative

with that said, please stream alamat's music

ALAMAT


Shagidi yung may ulo na nasa kubeta diba?

Skibidi yun.

Shagidi Yung nag babasketball.

Shagid O'Neal?


Sorry but it is quite wrong to equate PPop as only BINI.

I grew up with 90's to 2000's era ng OPM. I can say kahit noon pa man ay mayroong influence ang Filo music sa Japanese, Korean and mostly Western music. Mayroon talagang tendency ng paggaya ng style. Kaya ka lang siguro naaalibadbaran sa nangyayari ngayon OP is dahil sa sobrang trending ng KPop to a point na everyone is getting influenced by it. Let's be honest here though, noong sumabog ang BTS and Black Pink worldwide, it opened doors to a lot of artists too. One day, I also wish to see foreigners na inaaral at kinakanta ang Tagalog songs ng artists natin and even big foreign artists na makicollab tapos tanggap ang Tagalog sa lyrics. (Sana marami pang katulad ng Head Honcho nina Eminem at Ezmil)

But I totally do get your point. There is nothing wrong with getting inspiration from it sana, kaso nagiging cringe lang talaga if you embody it to a point na nawawala na identity mo kaya lumalabas na gaya- gaya. The p...

Bano Ng alamat live at walang karisma. Good songs tho

I haven't seen them personally na magperform live so I can't comment. Pero yea, their songs are good, even incorporating true Filipino culture. Kaya hindi pwedeng sabihin na porke ganoon ang Bini is un na lahat ng Ppop.


HAHAHAHAHAHA if they just stuck to their bubblegum "pang-masa" sound that made them great in the first place, may career pa sila.

and talk less, especially on socmed.

kulang talaga sa pr training. ang squammy sumagot HAHAHAHAHAHA


Not even a fan of bini but ang oa nung "nakakahiya na talaga kasi" huhhh???

Kpop draws a LOT from Western artists din naman. Ilang taon na nilang nirereheat nachos ni Tinashe, among others, yet wala namang "nahihiya" for them. Maski Charli xcx din.

Tsaka hindi naman first time na ginamit ang kids game for a song sooo? Ever heard of Duck Duck Goose by Cupcakke? Don't want to say it kasi I don't like her, pero Taguan by Moira?

Just say you hate bini oh god.

Masyadong nilalagay sa pedestal yung kpop. Lol

Any any yung nagpost eh. Di naman nagrerespond sa mga nago-oppose sa kanya


APT. derived from a Korean hand clap game, with melody allegedly sampled from "Mickey" (oh Mickey you're so fine...)

Shagidi derived from a Pinoy hand clap game. Anong melody kaya kokopyahin neto?

Nag aaway once (twice fans) and blooms ngayon dahil sa beat. Turns out, isa sa mga producers ng Twice ang kinuha ulit ng starmagic kaya may similarity talaga sa beats hahahah

Interesting homie. Daming pera para sa prod, walang magawa sa PR problems ng mga to


Nasaan po yung chika dito

Naging celebrity bashing subreddit nalang to eh.

Yeah, pwede pa to sa r/PPOPcommunity. Pero baka need ni OP ng karma points, i-give na natin.


Tapos inaaway pa mg mga fans nila ang TWICE, haha

Kahit gusto ko yun Bini, isa toh sa reason ko na naiirita ako sa fandom nila. Meron nun OA mag react nung may bata na nagdala ng candybong z sa isang concert nila. May papost pa sa X na disrespectful daw hanggang sa binweltahan siya nung kapatid nung bata. Yung Mamamoo nga winelcome lang NAMAN yung ibang fans ma umattend ng concert nila na ibang lightstick yung gamit.

Pano kasi, marami na din sa fans nila na mga blinks din...

Hindi naman sya inaway dahil candybong yung dala nya. Inaway sya kasi harabas mag wagayway si fan. May full vid yun sa tiktok, dun ko yun unang napanood, and I think na-share din sa X, and na-settle yun with the siblings kasi misunderstood yung part na dahil sa candybong.


To be fair, diba Viva Hot Babes dati kumanta ng "Bulaklak" na isa sa nilalaro din natin nung bata pa. I know it's a different game pero, di rin naman kpop ang nauna na gumawa ng kanta based sa isang game.

Downvoted ka kahit may sense naman sinabi mo. Hahaha.

Ilang beses na rin akong nadownvote dito, lagi sinasabi ng mga nagrereply na pag may sense ang sasabihin mo about BINI, mas maraming downvotes talaga
Ok lang yun. Freedom of expression


I am not a BINI fan but this is a stretch. Songs inspired from games isn't exclusive to KPOP, heck KPOP is also inspired by JPOP and western music. Also, as some other commenter pointed out, KPOP also gets producers from the west so these songs aren't KPOP exclusive.

2003 Bulaklak by Viva Hot Babes with lyrics lifted from Filipino children's game/song

2018 Darren Espanto had a song titled Nanay Tatay which is also a children's game

2022 YGIG, a PPOP girl group, released SHABA SHABA with *Eeny, meeny, miny, moe* (game, not exclusive to filipinos)

Music evolves. You don't have to cage PPOP into distinct sound or genre.

Also POP music is popular music so it is broad.

OP is most likely pertaining to the TIMING.

Naglabas ng drinking game inspired song ang Kpop, few months later naglabas din sila ng similar concept.


Recent BINI releases sounded a lot like Twice. Gusto ko isipin na theyre taking inspiration pero minsan parang blatant copy na masyado. Especially yung Blink Twice from Twices Scientist - pati yung MV parang lower budget version.

Ang gaganda ng Tagalog songs nila before. Masyadong blinded yata ang management sa biglang fame kaya sinasakyan talaga yung wave by releasing English songs para mas dumami ang reach. I really wish they take example from SB19.

Hindi lang management ang blinded pati bini members. Porket tanggap na ng mga fans nila twice vibe sila inabusado na nila, lahat na lang ng meron sa twice ginaya na nila. Kung nagbabalak sila mag international at wla sila original, puro copy paste na lang sa kpop style gagawin nila never nila mararating ang international na gusto nila.


At least APT has bruno mars to save that annoying song. Lol

Actually...


OP, any any na lang? Hindi pa nga narerelease yung kanta dami na agad sinasabi? Chika ba yan para ipost mo dito hahahaha

HAHA. diba? Maka post kala mo narinig niya na e. Hahaha. Bini brainrot na yan te


Agree. Pero lagot ka sa delulu blooms.

Grooms ain't gonna like this


The song hasn't been released though? Or has a snippet been released? /gen.
Didn't Bini receive a ton of flak because people are saying their latest songs are not a good representation of Filipino culture/music because the songs are entirely sung in English? Now that they seem like they are back with music that is Filipino since the title is shagidi, y'all are still saying something. Most people who has heard apt doesn't even know it's a Korean game, the song did not become popular because it's a Korean game. It became popular because the song has reached the general public since Bruno Mars sang it too and it used a sampling from Hey Mickey.

OP posting a PPop critique on an unreleased, not even a teaser, song of one PPop artist lol


How come OP is not replying to comments that talk about music evolution? Bakit nagrereply ka lang dun sa same yung opinion sayo?

Di ba? Says a lot about OP's purpose for posting his thinkpiece here. It's not even chika. Haha.


I feel that it's a management thing. I think That they have this constant pressure that they have to make their songs be a hit so they play safe with what already works - twice. Sobrang naalala ko twice sa mga color pallet Nila sa salamin. Tas puro English pa mga kanta, Atat mag global agad. Why not win over the locals before going overseas. Kita ko ung bts ng blink twice ba un? Puro mga kano mga song writer.

Now I can't help but compare it to sb19. They're their own song writers, it comes sa sarili nilang minds and their own creativity and it shows sa output Nila. Going to another behind the scene sa moonlight Nila na kanta, now albeit English, they were just having fun sa dance Nila na di need ng deep meaning or whatever.

But I digress, di pa Naka tulong na nagka issue Ibang ladies ng bini. Sobrang sayang kasi they do have the potential naman.

Agree with everything youve stated. I initially couldnt get into any kind of Filipino music. In high school/college, I had Sarah Geronimo, Nina, Parokya, Itchyworms, Hale, etc watched ASAP. Anything that ABS would try to produce and launch were copy and paste or artistas giving 45%. Cant blame them- theyre also hosting, doing shows, movies, road tours, etcand some of them didnt really have much talent (they were just pretty or mestiza).

SB19 proved me so wrong in the best way. They really have control of everything, they have creativity/originality and it shows. I dont even want to put them in the P-pop category because theyre doing their own thing and can cover so many genres. Im also a fan of one k-pop group  and have started veering more towards esbi. Filipino talents utilized and done right. K-pop singing is basic Filipino singing at best. Some k-pop choreography is advanced cheerleading 101 or high school hip hop talent show. Filipinos can really sing, harmonize, rap, dance, cho...


Wala pa nga yung song na judge na agad. Gustong-gusto natin sumikat ang p-pop worldwide pero mga Pinoy talaga hahanap at hahanap ng ikakabagsak ng mga rising p-pop groups. Also, you have to understand na wala tlgang appeal sa ibang lahi kung pure p-pop ang tunog nila, kaya kahit mga k-pop artists/group eh very westernized na ang music.

kung rejected song lang namn sa kpop song wag na lang kakahiya ang pinas


sorry pero parang twice wannabe na temu version ang BINI talaga :')

True, yung mga fans lang nila di pa rin matanggap na wala originality idol nila


No hate on Bini, but must say na yung bago nilang tracks are catchy. Yes, resembles ng KPop, pero I think halos ganon na talaga ang labanan. I believe they even collab on some composers "siguro" ng KPop, hence the similarity is there.

Kung Filipino type of song, baka di talaga masyado papatok.

Although Bini are doing English songs atm, maybe to attract more sa INTERNATIONAL audience. Like Blink Twice Dos Veces remix with a known Mexican singer Belinda. Saw on comments na baka they wanted to gain LatAm followers, kasi malakas din ang fandom dun sa KPop.

Some Koreans or KPop fans (based sa napapanuod ko reax vids) are satisfied naman with their voice quality, their dance, and MV, so feeling ko keri lang naman sa kanila.

If mga ocho-ocho or typical Pinoy novelty anh ipepeg ng Bini, baka wala na talaga makinig at manuod sa kanila. Hehe.

They gained stardom bc of their Tagalog songs. Their half baked Kpop reject songs are not making noise anywhere.


Ang eme nung sa livestream nila, halatang hindi naman nila alam pano laruin yung shagidi shapopo and nahihiya rin sila sa pinaggagawa nila

PLASTIC GIRLIES Talaga sila
Parang NAPIPILITAN na lang sila maging ganyan trabaho nila haha pagod na sila mag practice kaya mukha sila tanga at tamad tignan


Copy paste lang din talent nila. Idk why sobrang hyped pa din nila pero ang tatamad and lame mag perform. Walang umpf or something that would really make them shine and standout as a group

PLASTIC GIRLIES sila, Napipilitan na lang gawin ang trabaho na yan dahil marami sila pera makukuha, tamad na tamad na sila mag practice kaya ganyan na ka bulok ang performance nila. Bat pa ba sila mag effort kung alam nila marami sila BLIND FANS? Kahit ano gawin nila kagagahan at maging tamad pa sila tignan sa trabaho nila ay wala na sila pake, alam na alam nila marami na sila na scam at nagayuma na mga tao


tara sa kasi sa g22

Best Ppop GG. They have everything down except a huge network backing and mainstream success.


There used to be absolute metrics for popularity back then. Ngayon album sales, the streaming numbers, and video views can simply be pumped up by fans through bulk buying and mass streaming activities.

BINI and SB19 have sold out both Araneta and Philippine Arena FOR MULTIPLE DAYS. No other OPM acts have accomplished that before. Hindi pa ba sapat yun na metrics? Ngi.


Parang tanga lang yung walang big screen

Makinig nalang daw muna, for video, sa youtube nalang daw. Hha

Parang puro pera lang nasa isip, walang pakielam sa experience ng fans.

May nabasa ako sa r/bini na may say din daw mga girlies sa mga decisions ng management sa concerts, MV and etc. eto na yung patunay na wala talaga silang pake sa fans HAHAHAHAHAHAHAAHHA

mga apologist yan mga anjan


Worst concert ever. I've been attending concerts in Dubai, international or local artists man, the screens are there. Coca-Cola Arena is huge, last na nagconcert jan na Pinoy eh Rivermaya, walang problema sa audio and visuals. Bini's MGT really has to step up.

yass!! watched rivermaya.. galing ng prod.. hinde man super bongga.. but screens were there.. and hello compare ticket cost ng rivermaya sa BINI.. and kita mo talaga sofer happy ng mga titos and titas umuwi.. wala din akong narinig na any complaints after sa socmed.. lahat talaga happy.. unlike sa BINI, wala pako nakitang magandang feedback.. lelz!!

pop group pa naman sila, para necessary yung bonggang production vs. rivermaya

zakli!!


Ewan ko bakit may blooms na nagagalit eh consistent naman yung feedback na di nila naenjoy masyado nung mga umattend yung show dahil walang LED screens para sa mga nasa likod. Hindi nila makita yung Bini. May video evidence na nga, magcocomment pa na bitter at naninira lang.

Management should take note of this major issue para naman maayos yung next concert nila. Valid concern naman to.

Kaya hindi mag iimprove yan. Ok naman pala yung ganyan eh. Blind followers, wala man lang criticism para mag improve sana.

Mga baby bra warriors

Hahahaha kainis nagising ako


Lets be honest, di naman kase international level ang BINI at the moment. What made them think kaya na nila mag World Tour? Dahil lang nasama sila sa KCon? Ok sana kung bumwelo muna sila sa Pinas imbes na pinilit yung English releases, mas ok pa nga yung Salamin Salamin era nila compared sa ngayon.

Wala pa nga silang media training sinasabak na kaagad sa international.

Sabak agad sa international, hindi pa nga sila makasagot nang maayos sa English interviews

Maling basis na yata to for going international. Di naman basehan na dapat fluent mag-english. Kpop artists nga di mo maintindihan pag nag-english eh.

I said that in the context of the international interviews they've been booking lately. Wala silang kinukuhang translators so you'd expect mag-eeffort sila sa interviews na inaaccept nila, but no, so... Their interviews are always empty, no substance, not engaging


ahahaha..nanood brother ko sa dubai kasi pinilit sya ng gf nya!

Magaling daw bini in fairness sa kanila pero un venue daw talaga parang tinipid. Tapos di daw organized. Me usap usapan din daw na madami sa nanood ay either half price or free ticket and sa case ng bother ko, super discounted un ticket nila and was bought as a group plus airport nagtrabaho gf nya kaya nakuha nila at lowest price.

Typical na Pinoy production tubong lugaw. Malayo pa tlga tayo sa Hollywood and KPop.

feel ko sa second generation pa ng ppop magiging mas maayos.

yung mga ibang group kasi, managed by classic archaic companies dito sa pinas or failed korean companies.

i'm looking forward sa magiging group na managed by ppop artists and other song writers.

Upcoming ones will be yung group managed by sb19. Magkakaroon na rin ng group managed by FlipMusic (yung sumulat ng mga good songs ng bini)

Feel ko yung mga talagang naka experience ng grind sa ppop yung makaka setup ng proper industry.

Sacrificial lamb muna tong BINI. The moment na magrelease na ng ppop group tong SB19 dyan na mangangamote BINI at magcecater na yan sa mga fans HAHAHAHAHA


But it's not Bini's fault na ganun ang nangyare. But the promoters at management nila. They shouldn't take the hit sa ganitong eksena. Low class nakuhang promoter. Di inintindi ng management nila. Kakainis, nakaka awa mga bata!

Atcually, isa rin sa concern ng ibang attendees ay parang lack of energy.

Di ko napansin. Di ko kase sila napanood. I saw some clips lang online. Wala din ba back up dancers, para mag hype?

To be fair, extra gastos and logistics ang back up dancers. 8 naman sila so I think kaya nila ang prod amongst themselves.


Kung sino pa di nakapunta, sya pa nagpopost at nanggagatong. Crab mentality nga naman, pilipins.

Pinupuna natin at nagagalit tayo sa mga politiko't opisyal na bare minimum na nga lang hindi pa magawa.

Tapos sa mga celebrity, "crab mentality" kapag pinuna ang mga pagkukulang?

Sa totoo lang, walang Pilipinong gustong mag-fail ang BINI dahil dala nila ang reputasyon ng PH entertainment, kaya nga ine-expect natin na at least man lang sasabay ang production sa quality at level ng Kpop, Jpop...

Mag-demand ka naman ng quality sa lahat ng sinusuportahan mo.

Mukha nga nila di na quality, production pa kaya

Grabe ka naman kay Stacey hahaha


HAHAHAHAHA BARANGAY LEVEL PRODUCTION

Parang fiesta.

Buti pa nga sa fiesta, libre. Agahan mo lang para maganda view.


pag ang goal lang talaga ng management ay kumita, ganyan talaga mangyayari.  Kahit yung ph arena concert nila dito hindi worth it. masabi lang na nakapag ph arena.

ginawa kasing for promotion yung PH Arena concert ng BINI, imbes na sa BINI naka focus e ilalabas yung KimPau o ibang newbie starlet ng ignacia para makilala, sabayan pa ng mga pa endorsement ng BINI like sa Jollibee

Sinali mo pa KimPau dito as if may pakinabang ang concert na yun, Kim is a fan kaya nag agree sila sa Star Cinema to watch.

Wala namang pakinabang ang baby bra warriors. Nakaka 175M na by now ang movie because of KimPau fans na maraming mayayaman record breaking block screenings.


Jusmi! Ano ba nangyayari na sa kanila?imbis magpasikat kasi nasa ibang bansa eh ganyan Ang ginawa sa production?parang papuntang laos na ata Ang BINI

di naman kasi ata talaga sold out yung concert nila kaya tipid tipid sa prod, kakabig pa yung management

Fresh from GD concert and it was not sold out din po. But the production was INSANE. Visual feast kumbaga. All screens were opened in PH arena din. Yes, I know my disparity sa prices but fans deserve the best in every concert. Management should really step up.


Management talaga ng bini ang dahilan ng magiging downfall nila.

noon oo, ngayon may extra effort din ibang members.

Dati nagpopost ako doon sa ppop sub na abs-cbn hihila pababa sa kanila pero recently combined effort silang dalawa haha

Naniniwala na talaga ako na mas gusto nila yung nugu phase nila dati at naaannoy na sila sa fact na sobrang sikat na sila whahahahahahaha


Inaway na ba siya nung isang member?

PWEDENG MAG-WAIT KA?

No album, no screens daw sabi ni madam!


Tinipid na naman ng ABS-CBN Management. Akala yata nila gagana dito yung tubong lugaw strategy of their other talents world tours na kahit basura experience, mahal pa din sila ng fans nila.

Maraming casual fans din na nanonood to see the actual performance and enjoy the experience. Hindi nagbabayad yang mga yan para sumigaw lang.

Step up, ABS-CBN. Ang daming kapalpakan lately, di na ko magugulat if humina ang suporta sa kanila

Humihina na nga eh HAHAHAHAH compared sa sudden rise of fame nila last year. Pagkatapos nitong World pag di pa sila nagrelease ng mala Salamin Salamin release malalaos na yang mga yan

"ah basta 8080 ka inggit ka lang sino ka ba crab mentality talaga pag sumisikat ang bini"

\- repeat x 10 according to some Tiktok comment from a 10 year old fan


Tapos kapag pinost mo sa r/biniph nang walang halong papuri sa performers sabihin basher ka. Sinasamba yung mga girls dun lalo na yung tatlong lokaret.

Sabi nga nila A'TIN daw yung organizer sa dubai kaya nagkaganun gahahahha grabe mga imagination ng kabataan ngayon

Kahit sino pa yun, sinong pipigil sa kanila magpalagay ng big screen diba?  Eh pag concert dapat matic na yun.


Usually problema siya ng mga OFW-based production sa ibang bansa. Medyo puchu-puchu talaga galawan.

PNE sa dubai maganda naman production. EHeads ok lang. depende naman kasi yan sa team

Yes tama. Sa bands, Id say mas low maintenance. Hindi ideal pero stage at gamit lang kailangan ng banda, makakatugtog yan. Kapag ganito kasi ibang level talaga ang production requirements.


A friend (not Pinoy) attended kasi curious siya and magaling daw based sa videos na pinanuod niya pero bad ang experience niya so napatanong siya na ito na daw ba ang standard quality ng Flipino artists and Filipino events

Pag sinabi mo yan sa sub nila dami iiyak dun HAHAHA basher and hater kana agad.


"Edi sana nagdala ka ng led"

-bini warrior

HAHAHAHAHHA COLET BIAS NYAN


World tour pero yung budget pang Mall tour. Hays, ABS-CBN management, galaw galaw naman!

Halatang ginagatasan niyo nalang ang girls tapos ang stage, props, and production ang nagssuffer.

Nakakahiya kasi world tour 'to eh.

Dibaa mabuti pa tuloy yung mga mall tour nalang!


may nabasa nga akong comment sa tiktok bakit daw sa eras tour kahit restricted view yung seats wala daw nagrereklamo like ateccoh thats THE eras tour kahit sa bubong pa yung seats papatusin talaga yan ng mga tao

ayy ngeee. taylor swift yun. di sila mgkalevel.


This happens when the people in charge is not an artist. Kapag mas nananaig ang business kesa sa art / music. Kawawa naman ang Bini, mukang may talent yung iba sakanila, kaso dahil sa management nila pati na yung mga fans nila na toxic, their name/s are being stained.

Business-minded lang din yung members kaya double whammy. I remember when they called out their own fans na bumibili ng fan merch. Hindi ka raw "real Blooms" kapag hindi yung overpriced Divi quality official merch binili mo. Members din ang nasa frontline to defend the management kapag may criticism sa mga ganap nila. They enable that shit


As usual walang say yung leader. Kunwari walang alam nalang hahaha lol. Kakasad na love ko panaman si jhoana dati ngayon? Pota ang bitch pala ng attitude.

Playoff dropper energy :( Akala ko pa naman may energy siya na pang-clutch player


IMO they should get John Prats as concert director. Iba talaga siya mag dala ng prod.

true!


Sana mag pa workshop ang management nila sa 1Z kung paano ang tamang pag manage. Talo pa sila ng small company.

Ang gagaling ng bini girls tapos ganito ang gagawin sa kanila. Mga di na nahiya.


Ilang days na lumipas di man nila to inaddress?

Di na yan maaddress kasi todo ngiti na BINI members sa London hahahahahhaah


yup sa germany kung saan nanood din si sara duterte

Legit ba??? Sa Munich din ako nanood eras tour last year.


Sorry. Not the big screen. The screens all around the stadiums werent lit unlike other concerts held there. Only the ones in front were used.

Yun na nga po. Yan po tinutukoy ko. Yung sa BINI meron po bang big screen sa likod? Diba wala po?


If may friends kayo sa ABS CBN, ask nyo sila. Last concert ng Bini dito sa Pinas, pinamimigay lang yung mahal na tickets para maubos. Namimigay last time yung friend ko

ganyan talaga sila, yung pinsan ko na dating employee ng ABS madalas my free tickets ng concert ng kapam artist

May mga bini fanatics dito na di matanggap katotohanan. Lol. Welcome to the real world  sayang wala silang kakilala sa ABS, eh di libre sana sila.

True naman talagang may mga namimigay ng ticket ng last minute. Yung eheads nga dito nag buy 1 take 1 eh

Yun pa kamong concert ni Toni Gonazaga years ago, sold out daw pero higit 50% eh pinamimigay lang  may navideohan pa na namimigay sa harapan mismo nung entrace ng venue haha

Hoy naalala ko yan. Haha

Ako yung nahiya para kay Toni nung panahon na yan haha. Tapos naka-announce nun sa tv eh sold out daw haha


Yung #5, OP, common paandar naman yan sa concerts.  Almost always, may encore.

Next time, huwag maniniwala sa artist kapag sinabing last song. Hehe!

Hahahaha I will take note.

Sa Kpop concerts, ang rule of thumb ay kapag hindi pa sila nagperform ng naka-merch wardrobe, hindi pa yon ang tunay na last set.

Yep. As an ARMY na ilang Bangtan con na ang na-attendan, verified eto haha.

Apobangpo!


Sabi ng friend ko na may friend sa ABS, laki daw ininvest na pera sa BINI ng ABS.

For sure. Kaya gagawin nila lahat mabalik yung money na ininvest. Add ko lang super mahal ng merch nila.

400 Aed for hoodie
250 aed for tshirt
500 aed for light stick

Grabe yung aed 500 light stick hahahahahahaahahahahha

Yan din yung sinabi ko. So yung isang set ng photocatd nalang binili ng husbans ko eh. 150 AED

Blackpink yarn HAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAH kaloka ang lake ng 500 satin! Dami ng mangyayari hahahahahha


ang di ko matanggap yung ka same nila ang ticket ng offlimits: to think more than 10 artists sa offlimits and One republic and Ed Sheeran ang headliners.. may kasama pang Ben and ben and a lot others.. and DJs every interval.. tas party til 3AM.. hahahaha!! all that kasama sa same ticket..

Agree, I think mas mura pa nga namin nakuha yung offlimits. So nagulat ako bakit ang mahal nang tickets ng bini. Then pagka kita ko nga sa Dubai groups, ang daming disappointed.

dibaaaaa?!??!?! ang lala lang!! imaginin mo yung artists sa offlimits.. like kumpara naman ghurl!! kaya shookt ako nung lumabas tix ng bini.. like what the F talaga.. hahahaha!! and the big screen sa offlimits ang lala din sa laki.. half nga ng performance ni Ed lumipat na kme sa likod.. kse may friend kme na nagsabi mas maganda daw sound system dun.. true enough mas na naenjoy namin.. less crowded pa dun.. tas no major diff dahil sa screen..

Haha same! Nasa harapan kami nung una, halos di na makahinga haha. Tapos lumipat kami sa likod luwal pa pala.

Gulat din ako sa price ng bini. Kasi nanood na din naman kami sa cocacola, mas mura din. Tapos malalaki din yung screens. So kala ko basic na yung ganung setup. Bakit kaya wala man lang screen?

nagwatch din ako rivermaya sa coca cola, okay naman.. may 2 screens sa gilid tas sa gitna minsan effects minsan yung live vids.. magkano lang ticket ng rivermaya.. tas sofer enjoy kmeng mga millennials.. hahahaha!! wala kong reklamong narinig lahat umuwi ng sofer saya..


Baka kulang sa sponsor? surf? pure gold? etc etc. lol Kuya wil?

HAHHAA WALANG ADS PERFORMANCE SA CONCERT KAYA NAGING LOW QUALITY TULOY YUNG CONCERT NILA

MUKHA PINALABAS RIN SOLD OUT ANG TICKET GAYA NG GINAWA NILA SA PH ARENA KAYA DUN NAPUNTA ANG BUDGET SA PAG SOLD OUT NG TICKET

NAKAKAPAGTAKA SAN NAPUNTA ANG PERA NG TICKETS KUNG SOLD OUT TAS GANYAN KINALABASAN NG CONCERT NILA? LOW QUALITY HANEPP YAN

Tanggapin na natin na yung world tour nila, hindi talaga target yung international audiences. Yung pakay talaga nila is yung mga OFWs at kapwa pinoy na nadiscover yung bini.

Baka walang LED screen kasi nga walang ads? Paano nga naman kikita yung surf, payless etc etc.

Nakakaloka din na minamaliit ng fans ng Bini yung SB19 na OFWs LANG naman ang nanonood sa SB19 pag nagconcert sila abroad. Pero ganito dinadanas ng OFW sa concert ng idol nila, puro palpak.


Honest question. Maikli ba talaga yung 2 hour-concert for an idol group?

Tsaka naka-ilan ba silang kanta?

Medyo... kasi ung usual con if idol group kaya 3 to 4 hrs plus ung setlist aabot naman 10 songs plus spiels pa may dance breaks pa...pangit pag may dead air kaya minsan may sub units para makapahinga din ung iba

Wait, what? 3 to 4 hours, tapos 10 songs lang?

I think they meant this concert umabot ng just over 10 songs. (14 ata ang total). Pero typically nga mga 20+ songs tapos 3+ hours kasi bukod sa whole albums worth, may old songs and may solo/subunit songs pa.


Baka problema sa Coca-Cola Arena. Nanood rin kami noon nung sila KZ pa ang nag-perform hindi rin gaano maayos; wala ring matinong visuals.

Siguro nakadagdag pa yung biglang pagka-injury ni Aiah sa pagkawala nila sa momentum. Maganda naman kasi yung simula nila.

Magaling naman talaga sila. Kaso naisip ko din pagdating nilasa Dubai sunod sunod agad promotions nila. Punta ng consulate, restaurants, lahat na. Kaya siguro medyo mid lang yunh performance nila.

OP yun sound issue is sa Coca-cola arena mismo kasi yan din napansin namin nun The corrs concert panget ng sounds sabog.

Siguro depende san ka naka-pwesto. Okay naman sounds samin nung The Corrs. :/


Kahit ano'ng fandom pa yan. Basta concert, kahit ano'ng network or producer pa yan madami talaga laging pa-free lalo na mga VIP seats. Concert ni Klarisse na nga lang nakakuha kami ng free noon. Haha. Hanap kasi sila ng friends sa management para may free rin sila.

Curious lng, you think ganito dn sb19? Pero nagka-Day 2 Kasi ung concert nila and 45k tix sold n for day 2..does that mean n tunay ung sold out Ng tix for the Day 1?

For sure ay tunay na sold out yung day 1 ng sb19. Halos 1 year and a half sila walang con after pagtatag tour so sabik mga fans. Pero kung mangyaring like bini may natirang 900 ticks a day before the concert, for sure sb19 would rather buy those out too via proxies. Tho ang naaalala ko, mga gen ad nlang mostly yung unsold nun sa bini con. So yung mga mahal na tickets pinamigay daw di ko lam sn nkuha. If may pinamigay tlga mga murang tickets yun.

> may natirang 900 ticks a day before the concert, for sure sb19 would rather buy those out too via proxies

based on their previous concerts (including world tour stops), hindi nila binibili. They just post few hrs before the actual con na tickets are still available and pwede mag walk-in.

and I hope they won't do this ever just for the optics na "sold out". magbabago talaga ang tingin ko sakanila


Wait what, no LED screen for closeups?? Di ba basic yun? So ano pag malayo ka sa stage nagbayad ka para makakita ng langgam at makarinig ng basag na tunog?

Seats namin nasa bronze,. di mo sila kita. They looked like ants, di mo ma appreciate performances nila kasi di mo nman kita yung ginagawa nila, di mo makita mga mukha nila. Mostly ng mga tao yun ang reklamo, tapos nakakahilo pa yung lights and visuals na nagpaplay sa screen. Buti yung kasama ko malakas camera ng phone nya kaya sa phone nlang kami nanood haha

Hahahahaha para pala kayong team bahay na sa tiktok lang nanood


Dubai is their best-selling stop pero tinipid. Paano na lang sa stops na hirap na hirap silang ibenta? Naging fanmeet vibes na lang. Poor fans

DESERVE ng mga BLIND GROOMS makatanggap ng BARE MINIMUM GALING SA PROBLEMATIC GROUP NA SINUSUPPORT NILA

FOREVER NA BARE MINIMUM ENJOYER ANG MGA GROOMS

Lagi ksi nila tinatanggap ang bare minimum ng problematic bini kaya pati live performance ay hindi na nag eeffort masyado ang problematic bini members, bakit pa mag effort ang problematic bini members kung blind namn mga fans nila

Wag ka tuwang tuwa at proud na proud mga blooms sa subreddit nila at sa twitter. Sobrang abusado na management. Tinitipid fans tas ung mga tickets at merch overpriced. LED screen is bare minimum sa concerts. Grabe sa kapal muka ng management para di mag provide ng LED screen


Walo sila pero andaming dead air. It's good when artists are comfortable on stage pero ang Bini masyadong kumportable tamad na tamad sila magsalita yung iba kapag talk segment. Parang sila sila lang mag-uusap tapos di kasali audience.

Nafifeel ko na ang cringe sa US leg. Pagtatawanan lang nila accent ng bawat isa or something

At somepoint di ko naiintindihan yung banter nila sa isat-isa. Kaya naguguluhan ako sa mga sinasabi nila.

Sa cooking show lang ako nanood and it was bad. Imagine being there live tapos walang LED screens. I'd be frustrated too


I was there last night too, and same sentiment. Wasn't satisfied overall. Medjo pricey din nang ticket, kaya we expected more. Walang LED, yan talaga main criticism. Andaming tao, sold out and mahal nang ticket. Di man lang napalagyan ng ABS-CBN nang LED para makita nang nasa malayo ang performances? Ang basic din ng stage set-up, di rin nila nilagyan extension para atleast makaabot sila sa may unahan and makita nang mas marami ang girls. Concert also was 2 hrs, pero ang konti nang kinanta nila. There was a long pause nung c Aiah had to exit the stage dahil sa leg cramps nya kaya overall di talaga umabot nang 2 hrs yung performances. Pansin ko rin parang the girls were tired or di nakapag pahinga ng maayos? Their dances di ganun ka pulido compared sa ibang performance nila previously.

Ang haba din nung pause nila nung nagexit si Aiah kaya parang ang less nung performances nila. Tapos fans are expecting na sana may individual performances or subunit man lang. kaso wala din

I was expecting na may solo or duo kagaya nang sa Ph concert pero wala. During the long pause, yung katabi namin dalawang babae, umalis sila. Akala namin nag CR lang, pero di na bumalik. Di nila tinapos yung concert. Cguro mga casual fans lang yun, and nainip kaya di na tinapos.


Yung stage parang nag mall show lang. Mas may prod design pa ata yung mall shows.

I didnt watch the con. Wala b kahit pausok manlang?

Didnt watch it too. Im just basing it solely on the attached photo. Yung itsura kasi ng stage parang rehearsal lang :(


Nag world tour na pala ang BiNi? Akala ko start muna sila sa Asia.

First stop nila ang Dubai. Next ata yung London.

Yes dito sila by May 25


May space naman pala. Bat kaya di nalagyan LED lols

Di din namin alam haha kaya nagulat kami di namin makita unless i-zoom

Kala mo ikakahirap nila maglagay ng LED e no hahaha


ang expensive ng ticket para sa mukhang low budget stage ha. nahiya ticket nina taylor swift

Medyo expensive din talaga. Fan pit diamond is 545 aed and gold is 345.


Sold out ba talga? Parang ang daming vacant seats

Lagi namn pinapalabas sold out para di mapahiya ang problematic bini, sa kaka sold out nila naging low quality ang concert dahil napunta ang budget sa sinold out na ticket


Ang basic nung close up LED para hindi mailagay, especially sa prices nung tickets. Parang at this point niloloko na lang talaga ng management yung mga fans ng Bini. Tapos yung basag yung sound sys? When yung venue is well known venue naman for cons sa dubai? Nakaka bastos na sa fans yung issues nila sa mga concerts. Ang tingin talaga nila sa mga nagbabayad ay "basta bini, money ready". Tapos cash cows naman tingin nila sa bini members.

Honestly, they need to flop para magtanda yung management. NAKAKABASTOS!

I hope properly compensated ang mga girls dahil sa laki ng kinikita nila. Kasi napaka unfair naman na kasalanan ng production team tapos yung mga members ang nababash.


I posted yesterday here with photo around 8:00 at 8:30 simula ng performance nila not to bash BINI kasi hindi pa puno yung venue. I had to remove it kasi bumababa ang karma ko. Hahahaha! So actually, ang point ko is, may enough space pa ang mga standing mapa-fanpit at GA during the event mismo pero nag-open sila ng seated days before kasi sold out na nga daw at syempre, expensive na naman yung ticket na inopen nila. Then walang big screen. Had to use my phone throughout just to see their faces kasi nasa left suite kami na box.

Performance wise, aliw ako sa BINI.
Organizer, big NO.

Gatas na gatas talaga nila ang BINI.

True. Talagang gatas na gatas nila ang Bini. Maganda performances nila but yung organizers is a big no. Mukhang bago palang din yung organizers eh.


We need to know who the organizer are, para ma note down in the future

All things live middle east


Sa dami ng issues, ang generous mo pa sa 7/10.

Because yung performances naman nila is really okay. As a casual viewer, hindi ko ineexpect na ganun sila. Magagaling yung mga bata. Nagkamali lang talaga yung production and management nila.


Husband, Bini fan?

Teh magduda ka na

Mi naman! Hahaha hayaan mo na.


The hate theyre getting is absolutely overblown because of their recent issue. 7/10 is still pretty good. Nung nag con XG dito wala ding led di naman binash. Unfortunate yung nangyari kay Aiah kasi kumain ng 30mins. Pero most comments ive seen from non fans who attendee the con good naman daw performance nila.

Magaling naman talaga sila. Kumbaga if performances lang pag uusapan sulit bayad mo. Pero since ang tagal ng dead air dahil sa nangyari kay Aiah, then walang LED screen and another factors, ayun. Kaya nadisappoint yung mga tao.


ohmygod ang liit ng stage parang New Frontier Theater lang ano ba yan

Ganyan lang talaga ang stage sa Coca-cola arena. Hindi nila minomodify kahit sino pa ang mag-concert.


Ano po theme ng outfit kasi parang ang gulo nila sa mata

Modern Maria clara eme haha


Mas magaganda yung outfit nila nung di pa sila gaanong sikat, sa totoo lang. Hindi naman ako fashion expert pero mas eye candy yung pormahan nila dati.

Naguguluhan din ako sa mga suot nila jan sa poto.


How a year flies. Last year, bias ko si Jho sa Bini - like mahal ko siya

I cant say the same right now :(

Inaddress ni Irene yung gapjil niya before at nagsorry sa personal account. Why cant any of the 3 do the same?

100% as much as I hate to compare them to KPOP - pero gets ko kung bakit tlaga need hand written letter and in the person's personal account.

Because it gives a sense of accountability and sincerity, no matter how pretentious it may seem and even kahit hindi naman tlaga sincere yung idol behind close doors but still it's a great PR move. And a management apology post is just not it.

I'm a Luvie din and what Irene did was actually a smart PR move na ang bilis. Ang bilis ng personal apology to those involved  as soon as the issue came out, a handwritten apology letter to the fans and public with no excuses made, and stayed off social media.

Which is why Irene is still able to reclaim her fans trust. But the fact na ang tagal tlaga nila to even release a statement/apology about it, not until that account gave them a deadline, makes me think they really don't want to address the issue in the first place.

Around 10 months din siya nawala sa social media, tas nawalan din siya ng endorsements like Prada at Clinique

Pano na lang endorsements ng grupo? May portion na for sure di magrerenew dahil sa controversy nung tatlo

true malaki tlaga consequences sa korean industry, ganun sila ka bilis mag cancel. but look at Irene now, she's slowly still able to come back with an I&S comeback, even had a solo album, and have new endorsements.

For Bini's endorsements, I don't think it would be that much affected.

Hindi naman uso msyado dito yung dropping endorsements due to issues. First time siguro nangyari lang I think is Maris? but after time passed parang wala lang din naman and may bago na siyang endorsements

BINI will for sure survive financially. Ang may naging lamat lang talaga is yung reputation nila and probably their advocacies. It made a dent eh - now everytime the 3 will appear palagi nang may mag bring up ng issue na to even after many years have passed because hindi nakakalimot ang tao.

Lets see siguro later this year.

Hay Jhoanna :( parte ng pagiging leader ang accountability

Di talaga sapat yung group apology.

lider lang sya pag magpe-perform sila pero yung latest issue ang nag expose sa kanya. she has no leader aura and mentality

Sakit. Playoff dropper mentality :(

Kala ko pa naman mala-playoff riser siya


Naalala ko lang- 'di ba may socmed account na nagsabi na iisa- isahin nyang ilabas ung mga issue ng Bini? san na sya?

Wala for the clout lang yun. Sus

unless he was paid off? hmm

Yung inispill nya naman galing lang din kay colet. So outsider sya.


They're testing the water. Obv silence is their way to bury the issue. That's honestly sad for the women and children who are mostly their fans

Ganyan naman galawan ng abs, lahat ng may issue noon from anne curtis-mahal na mahal na sya ng tao ngayon...maris rascal-patuloy pa rin ang mga palabas and many others

Eh.. the Anne Curtis coke rant towards sila John Lloyd and Maria Racal cheating issue were messed up but not joking about the SA of a minor level of messed-up.


Ang disappointing na they can freely express themselves sa sariling accounts nila pero cant apologize? Kailangan sa BINI official account lang?

Kung mag apologize sila late na at hindi na mag mumukhang sincere

Di naman ata sila nagsisisi sa ginawa nila eh. Si Jhoanna mej pa kasi mapapansan mo talaga pagiging matamlay non. Pero sila Stakku at Colet? Wala nang pag-asa yan. Abot tenga pa nga ngiti ni Stacey dun sa recent airport pics nila eh


Tagal naman nilang pindutin si anger . Dati G na G sumagot sa mga bashers ngayon di man lang nila mapagtanggol sarili nila

Wala na silang tatlo. Nerfed down na sila kapag may hawak na mic. Di na nila mauulit yung dating paandar nila lalo na si staku at colet.

Neutered na rin yung pagiging politically aware ni Jhoanna at hindi na din seseryosohin ng mga tao yung mga sasabihin nya in the future. Si Aiah na lang gawin nilang spokesperson tutal sa kanya naman nagtatago yang BINI tuwing nagkaka-issue sila


Amg lakas ng backup, walang nag pullout ng endorsement  To think na ang daming bata na umiidolo sa mga 'yan.

Very disappointing lalo na sa Jollibee na yung target market mga bata.

Wala tayo magagawa hahaha bulag mga fans ng bini


Grabe sobrang fan ako ni Jho kasi i thought woman of substance siya pero damn this is beyond low yung ganitong behavior na parang wala lang??? Antayin niyo nalang downfall niyo bini dahil sa tatlong members niyo na walang accountability. Kung pwede OT5 nalang.

Ang bilis nasira ng credibility nya as a leader no? Hahahahahaah baka nga mag full blown T-ARA yang mga yan at ilipat nila kay Aiah yung leadership eh

True dat. Mas bagah kay Aiah maging leader. Ewan ko ba jan sa tatlong yan. Sa lahat ng members sila lang yung nakikipag barkada kanikanino lang like wtf? Lalo nayang si colet. Her anger personality was cute for me before kasi i thought sinasadya niya yun pero turns out squammy pala talaga siya ngayon asan n tapang niya? Pati si Stacey siya pinaka waterloo sa grupo nakipag jowa pa ng maacm. Kawawa yung limang nananahimik.


Did you watch the video or you just lack basic comprehension?

Also read my reply again. SLOWLY.

Already did both, it really has nothing to do with bini, Forbes 30 under 30 has destroyed its reputation many times already. Mga literal na criminal yang mga nilalagay nila.

It has. I never said they're infallible. I said that there's a moneymaking operation behind the scenes but you can't explicitly buy your way onto the list. It has been explained on the first video you shared too.


they had interviews nga sa airport before flying for their concert and I thought they will address the issue and atleast apologize but sadly no.

Pansin ko theyre active again sa socmed tapos puro positive yung comments. Feel ko yung strategy ng PR team is to just drown out the negative feedback. May nga nagsulputan ding thinkpiece-style posts dito trying to spin the backlash into some kind of society just want to hate on women narrative. (Which I think is an oversimplification because the boys got some flak too, it just so happens na hindi lang talaga sikat.) May nagsasabi pa na the 13 year old daw they were referring to was the one of the guys in the video. Can someone confirm kung totoo to?

And as a former casual fan na bias si Stacey, disappointing sya. The 3 girls couldve offered a sincere apology from their own accounts,  pero their management just chose to release a PR statement na dinamay pa yung rest of the girls.


Paid awards naman yang sa Forbes hahaha magkano kaya binayad ng management

yung sa pbb 20k per seat paldo na yun


Siguro the best option na dapat gawin nila is apologize and be accountable sa actions nila.  Plus gusto ko din makita yung magsorry yung tatlo na nagstart ng issue  sa ibang member ng bini kasi nadamay sila.

not enough (for me).

i want those dumbasses, maski yung mga lalake, to sit in a room of survivors of SA and child abuse, and explain what was funny about the joke.

in return, each attendee can tell them a story of what happened to them, and tell them exactly why it was not funny.

it is telling of their character and cuts through everything they stand for.


Ang saya ng reaction ng public sa result ng election so nawawala na attention sa issue ng bini. Baka nakikisakay lang yung PR sa positivity

Saya na may halong bad trip
tanginang mangga at crimewater nakapasok amp


yaan mo na, exposed naman na kung anong ugali meron sila hahahaha lets just wait kung anong kaaciman na naman ilalabas nila (except aiah) in the coming months ngayon na unti-unti na silang nilalamon ng fame

True mga fans lang namn nila kawawa sa kakatanggol sa problematic idol nila. Hintayin lang ng bini members magsawa mga fans nila MAGTANGGOL sa kanila


As someone na may exposure sa mga SA children, inis na inis ako na downplayed yung ngyari. 13 years old na bata yung pnaguusapan nila. In unison pa sila lahat na kilala nila yung topic. Tapos sa apologies nila prang hndi sya nag eexist.

Please nman medyo luminaw na mga mata natin sa politicians, sana pati mga "IDOLS"

Who are these people downvoting you??


Ni hindi nga binalita ng ABS yung issue. Ang tanging balita lang about them ay nagpa-misa bago sila lumipad for their world tour, at yung pagpost ni Ariana Grande sa IG niya.

Hahaa about achievement lang pinopost ng abs kapag issue ng bini ikahihiya nila


Yaan niyo malalaos na din yan bini na yan.

True darating din ang PANAHON magsasawa mga fans nila MAGTANGGOL sa kaaciman ginagawa ng bini


Kaya dapat tigilan na ng blooms support mga yan hahahahaha kitang kita naman na walang pake sainyo tapos lagi pa kayo inaaway hahahahh

na scam ng malala ang mga blooms sa wholesome images ng bini kaya kahit na eexposed na ang tunay na ugali ng bini bulag bulagan lang sila


nasa kalagitnaan na talaga ng downfall nila ang bini. I think deserve?!

Same thoughts. I'm a fan ever before Pantropiko, and mas lalo ako naging fan after that. But now? Parang wala ng shine. Not sure if affected ba view ko ng recent issue nila, pero parang nawala yung star factor. Partly dahil din siguro puro English na yung kanta nila now. Iba talaga dating nung Tagalog songs nila.

Sana maayos na nila recent issue nila and hopefully maibalik nila yung dating sila.


Well thats what PR is for? May taga linis naman talaga ng kalat. Hindi naman pwede forever stuck sa issues.

May tamang approach kasi, kung may sensible at conscientious na PR sila hindi lang simpleng post at statement yan.

Mabigat ang responsibilidad ng BINI, kahit sabihing entertainer lang sila, obligado silang magtaguyod ng tamang values sa mga tagapakinig lalo sa mga batang fans nila dahil may inangkin silang advocacy, whether facade lang o totoo. Dapat isinama ng PR nila yan sa pag-iisip kung paano ia-address ang issue nila.

Sa ibang bansa yan, nagpa-presscon na agad ang agency kinabukasan, pinagbasa ng prepared na official statement, pinayuko bilang tanda ng pagpapakumbaba at yung manager ang sasagot para sa mga talent at sasabihin ang susunod na hakbang. May upcoming activity? Pwede namang ituloy, pero pagkatapos ay magre-reflect sila.

E wala, Hollywood approach ang sinusunod ng talent at management dito sa atin, yung papatahimikin lang yung talent in the hopes na mamamatay nang kusa ang issue. Nakalimutan nila na iba ang kultura nating mga Asian na hindi basta-basta nakakalimot pag...


Ill probably get downvoted for this, but I genuinely find it ironic that some of you are demanding an apology.

Yes, the situation is disappointing  but lets not forget, theyre human, not goddesses.

When Maris made a mistake, she publicly addressed it, yet people still criticized her and dismissed it as just a PR move. No matter how sincere or well-delivered an apology is  written or spoken  for some, its never going to be enough.

So please, cut the chase when it comes to asking for a personal apology from these girls. Lets be real  even if they did personally apologize, I 100% bet most of you would just mock it and say, The damage is done.

Syempre downvoted ka din ng mga closeminded at mga anak ni Lucifer  Even before di nila gusto ung BINI eh ngayon nakahanap ng way para mas ibash ung mga to. Kawawa puro hate sa puso.


So ano po ba ang dapat nilang gawin?

Mag apologize using their personal accounts at wag magtago sa likod ng official bini account na nadamay ang ibang members. And after that, isapuso yung mga advocacy nila kasi parang eme eme lang eh...


They spent too much money on them to let them burn. Especially may concert sila upcoming.

The Philippines isn't lacking in talent, so idk why they try to keep them. Like even people like Kathryn, Vice, Nadine, Coco, Piolo, etc. Yeah, they're good, but come on.... gatas na gatas na. Where are the fresh faces? Is this really the best they can do?

Daming talented sa pinas. Guaranteed they'll be better for PR too.

You already answered your own question for The PH isnt lacking talent so why try to keep them? with your very first sentence. ABS investment on these girls are deep.

I mean for sure Star Hunt is always active on searching the right talent; they never stopped at BINI. Pero when it comes to forming groups it takes more than just looks or talent. Lahat ng members need to weight a certain way, similar physique, height, age. Napakaraming factors that goes into account. Hindi lang basta basta marunong kumanta at sumaway eh pwede ng ilabas as girl group and will be guaranteed successful.

ABS tried to release multiple groups kita mo sa Showtime palang, but none of them peaked like BINI did. And tbh, Abs was pushing BGYO more than Bini when they debuted. It took years for BINI before having that one big break.

But yeah, my whole point is - it is very difficult to form a successful PPop group. It can take years and its never guaranteed na kakagatin ng masses.


Alam ko, hate na hate niyo ang BINI, pero sobrang bobo at braindead ng comment na to. Ang Forbes Asia Top 30 ay editorial pick, meaning may mga judges yan sa Forbes at pagbobotohan nila kung sino-sino ang pasok sa Top 30. May 4,500+ nominees at BINI lang girl group sa list while 2 BGs representing K-pop. Tapos sasabihin niyong bayad? Nasaan ba utak niyo?

Downvote niyo na ko dali  para patunayan niyong bobo kayo. Editorial pick yan. I-search niyo kung ano ibig sabihin nun para naman matuto ang mga bobong katulad niyo at hindi lang puro chismis.

Kaya mo yan, te


Forbes 30 under 30 is a scam. It's a paid advert. This has been exposed several times.

Lol........parang yung kumakalat dito palagi na "Asia's......most eme eme award" thingy, but on an international stage.

Yes the one where Whamos paid 100k for a couple award haha

Ang mura nman ng 100k

Hindi din naman kasi sobrang matunog yung awards night na yun. Parang networking something haha


Bini Josh Giddey era

pero imbis na under-18, 13 years old

Also, Ive seen a lot of Colet = Jeongyeon when hinahalintulad ang Bini sa Twice: which is offensive kay Jeongyeon kasi di siya magaspang at patolera

Sayang talaga si Jho - nagbago image niya overnight

True. Nakakaiinis kapag kimukumpara sila sa Twice.

Lol. May PR training pa Twice


We made it ate Maris! Char lungs.

Unfair. Hindi work ng Star Magic PR yung international festival tour and awards ng movie ni Maris dahil hindi under ABS yung movie. Kahit yung song na nilabas niya under an indie label. Kahit paglilinis ng kalat sariling sikap si Maris

Yung Maris sa tiktok tintutukoy ko Mhie


kaya sana yung tatlo na wag na masyadong palaban yung branding tapos sila pa yung magiging dahilan ng mga issue

especially Colet. problematic talaga siya ever since. tas mga fans nila tuwang tuwa pa sakanya kapag pinapatulan niya yung mga bashers at nagsusungit siya. lagi nilang sinasabi napindot na naman si anger si ante kinareer ang pagiging problematic  isa pa yan si Stacey at Jhoanna, parang mga nasa loob ang kulo. pasweet ang image pero ibang iba pala offcam. jeez


Galing naman ni Kempee De Leon

ANG GALING NI KEMPEE (4x)


Parang matagal na yan na expose na people pay to get featured on that. Not all naman pero it's not as credible

Ever since na-feature si Kylie sa cover nila nawala na credibility nila for me


Damage control  Magkano kaya binayad sa Forbes ?

Alam na this


Forbes Asia? Bakit wala si Asias Superstar with her billion movie

Buset Ka hahahahah


Great now they should get a PR team

They have a PR team tho. Yung lagi sila napopost sa Popbase at Popcrave, international magazine features like this and Billboard are all thanks to their PR team


Jhoannaaaa bakit kasi dyan ka pa sumama. Dapat si maloi na lang nasa video e. At least di masakit. Hahaha hayst

pinatitibok mo ang aking puso at aking manoy, oh maloi


Kapag si Aiah nagka-issue..Wala na talaga.

Si Gwen ba meron na?

Wala. Her only issue was the tinapay issue in pbb BAHAHHAHA

Anong tinapay issue?

Since tipid sa pbb so tig 2 slice lang ata dapat sila pero si gwen 3 or 4 slice kanya. LT lang yung time na yun pero kasi ang bata pa no Gwen nun hahaha

Buwisit yun lang pala haha

Mahalaga yung count ng tinapay kasi limited lang pwede kainin per tao. Kahit ako mag-aamok pag inubusan ng tinapay. Hahahahaha


Tahimik pa ba si Colet?

Hindi na nga umiimik sa X. Na pipe na ata dahil sa issue nila, walang accountability  weeew

Pag sya ung may issue tahimik. Pag tayo may issue sa kanila like how they answer sa mga fans - kala mo inapi eh. Colet asan accountability??

Wala e. Squammy talaga galawan. Tapang tapangan lang pala si atecco

Pati fanbase n'yan squammy!


Picture lang naman ito noh pero di ko bet yung aura talaga nung Colet. Nayayabangan ako sa kanya.

Napanood ko compilation ng Angry mode nyan sa Tiktok. Clips sa performance, SS ng mga reply nya sa fans sa X at mga live nya. Ang damiii! Totoo ngang inugali nya pagiging anger nya.

Beastmode yan pag yung audience naghahanap ng Mikhaiah layag. Ayaw masapawan ni Ateng.

ay wehh totoo? So possible totoo ang hula na may inggitan mangyayari sa members kaya hindi rin magtatagal ang group nila. Vibes palang ni colet ay bida bida ang aura at attention seeker sa pagiging beast mode

Halata diba? Yung tipong bida-bida at gusto niya sa kanya ang attention.


Aiah & Mikha - gaan ng aura sa always
Stacy - halos mabura na mukha sa make up
Maloi - hanggang sa simbahan nakalabas yung tiyan

> hanggang sa simbahan nakalabas yung tiyan

  gagii tumaas lang yata yung shirt Hahah naka akbay kasi kay sheena

Ay tumaas lang ba wahahaha lagi kasi naka crop top + low waist bottoms kahit saan eh

Haha I get youuu.  Tbf naman for her, shes only in her early 20s. I think its normal lang mag experiment ng kung ano mang style.

Yuh and it's okay naman regardless of any age to experiment. I just thought na naka ganun na outfit sya even inside the church hence I called it out.


Si Aiah and Mikha ang ganda ng aura.

Silang dalawa namn talaga Legit na maganda since debut nila, kahit di kagandahan make up nila nung debut days nila maganda talaga

Enhanced na rin ilong ni mikha

Enhanced pala yun? Kaya pala


Pa-religious na sila forda goody image

??

 Lagi pong merong send-off mass ang BINI, regardless kung saan sila pupunta.

Ang galing mag downvote ng mga tao dito kahit totoo naman sinasabi. Eh talaga naman laging may mass pag may big ganap ang bini. Gets naman na hindi nyo sila gusto. Pero pag tama naman ang sagot, wag nyo idownvote. Feeling high and mighty mga tao dito. Ayaw na itatama sila. Kala ko ba uso mag fact check dito sa reddit?

Last time may nagcomment sa isang bini post na ang bastos daw ni sheena kase sinabi nya na amoy epep daw si colet hahahh. Napakadaming upvotes. Tapos may nag correct na epep ay pangalan ng inaanak ni colet na nakatira sa condo nya. Ayun sandamakmak ang downvotes hahaha.

Ano pang aasahan mo mga tao dito sa sub na ito, makapanglait na ng itsura wagas eh kahit other celebrities na hindi naman problematic. Matatapang lang naman yan kasi anonymous dito baka pagnakita mo pa personally sila pa itong mga mukhang dugyot.


Pinaka nabago tlga image for me is Jhoanna

agree since leader siya ng group tapos siya payung kitang kitang tumatawa sa nagkakandyutan sa harap niya bwak bwak bwak

hahaha yung nagkakadyutang mga V@kL@ sa viral video???? hahahha


Di tlga magandang tignan yung mapagpatol na image ni colet. Dalawang (Kollete & colet + fyang) ang ganun sa abs.

Edit: Minsan, okay lang yung pagpatol/call out nya sa mga fans dhil may mga fans din nman na sumosubra na pero minsan nakakainis na palagi na lang syang pumapatol sa mga fans. Nagfefeeling si P.A ba sya? Di pa sya/sila umaabot sa star status ni P.A para maggaganyan.

Ok lang naman I guess to call out fans when they step out of line. Like I saw a reply from one member of SB19 (I forgot who!) saying he does not tolerate their behavior and to stop what they're doing. Parang scolding father lang ang dating, inaayos mga anak na umasta nang tama. Yung problema kay Colet eh mayabang, rude at palengkera ang dating. Sarcastic at arrogante sa sariling fans. Sino ba naman di matu-turn off sa gano'n. Yung management naman nila, di man lang kino-correct yung gano'ng behavior. Kapwa at fault.

Si SB19 Pablo ba 'to nung time na na-bash ang A'TIN and SB19 ng mga taga-volleyball community?


for me lang ah, if it wasn't for Maloi's distinct powerful voice, ang waley nila as a ppop group. sa beauty naman, Mikha at Aiah talaga periodt

Powerful? Pwede. Distinct? I dont think so. Halos magkakasame vocal color nga sila e.

Dahil sa singing style niya siguro, like siya yung in-charge sa runs. Kung power, si Colet. Kung vocal agility si Maloi


Could it be na purposely pinagtabi tabi silang tatlo + Aiah para matakpan yung issue na nag leave sa gc si Aiah

Lagi ginagawa damage control si aiah  Si aiah dati na nag post ng pic nung bata pa sya para ma segway ang issue ng ibang members nya at mapunta ang attention sa kanya lol

Deserve nya yung mga solo travels nya kasi buhat na buhat nya yung PR ng BINI whahahahaha


nagtabi pa talaga ang tatlo

Buti hindi sila dumulo, maka-crop sila


Aiah and Mikha yun ganda nla pang leading lady. Si Gwen maganda din sya lalo na sa editorial na photos pang model ganern

Agree, I think na if hindi BINI or hindi nag work out, Gwen can have a successful run as a model.


Nagtabi tabi pa nga. Char!

Sinama pa si aiah para matakpan baho ng awra nila


they look so different without their stage make-up

They look so normal no? Parang lalagpasan mo lang sa daan pag nakasalubong mo.


Can someone ID them from left to right please thanks

Aiah Stacey Colet Jhoanna Mikha Gwen Maloi Sheena


Idk pero bat parang pilit ngiti nila

Ganyan talaga kapag FAKE SA HARAP NG CAMERA  Pilit na plit mga FEMINIST yun pala balahura ang ugali sa kapwa babae kapag wala fans na nasa paligid


Hindi dasal ang need nila tbh hahaha

Divine intervention yata ang need hahaha


Si aiah nalang talaga fina-follow ko sa bini. Pati yung group acc unfollowed ko na

Good job ses


Dapat sinama na nila dyan pedo friends ng tatlo.

Yung pedo friends ang kailangang mabuhusan ng holy water


So ako lang talaga nagagandahan kay maloi?? Ewan bat I find her pretty huhuhu

Ganda nga nya dyan!


I may be wrong, pero yung mata ni Colet parang galing sa iyak.

same kay jhoanna mukha nasermunan ng pari sa kalaswaan nila


Pati pagsimba need pa ipost  para matakpan ung issue na bago? Lol

Dati na sila ganyan kapag mag coconcert sila lagi may simba post para ipakita sa mga fans na mga angel kuno sila. Pilit na pilit ksi pa wholesome image nila tas di pala kayang panindigan ng ibang members


Can someone make a list ng issue per member? Hahaha

From the top of my head lang after becoming a Bloom last year.

Aiah - no problematic issue. Madalas lang malink sa guy friends niya.

Stacey, Colet, Jhoanna - yung recent issue nila.

Mikha - no problematic issue. Pinupuna ng iba na mahilig mag-bar. (I don't see it as an issue though.)

Gwen - no problematic issue. Yung tinapay issue niya lang sa PBB.

Maloi - tumawa (react) sa isang tiktok video na sumasayaw na parang ginagaya sumayaw ang isang PWD. She immediately apologized. Apologized on her own account though not from the Bini PH account. 2nd is in a relationship daw kay Zild na isang cheater/red flag. Never proven though. They say they're always seen together, but to be fair they're always seen together with their other friends not just them.

Sheena - Naglike ng isang troll post nung 2020 or 2021 about an SB19 member's retoke. (not sure if retoke or yung face) This one I think has been patched up though. Sheena probably apologized in person kasi they seem ok...


Whos who? Hindi ko kasi talaga kilala Bini. Tapos iba pa face nila kapag walang makeup.

will try my best. Left to right: Ayah, stacy, kolet, Joana, si father, mika, gwen, maloi, sheena


HOY HAHAH dapat sa dulo sila hahah or foreshadowing ba na aalis din si aiah with them charot

Wag


They aren't on that level yet to be performing in this type of capacity nor selling such price. Lbr they are only locally known, they haven't amassed any international fandom outside of YT baiters that will spend money to see them.

Even Kpop acts are stuggling to sell out venues.

You can't solely rely on the Filipino community abroad who are mostly millennials and working class.

Manman is way too ambitious.

Tho nothing wrong with setting ambitions but as per Nina "iStep by istep bago ka sumakses" like they need to realize there is no shortcuts.

nahihiwagaan din talaga ako kung bakit push na push yung management nila na mapenetrate yung international scene when in fact hindi pa naman sila ganun ka-stable (idk if this is the right term) locally.

yung ibang kpop acts na kakadebut lang, paulit ulit na nagrerelease ng kpop songs, tapos small scale fan meetings, hanggang sa mga small tours. pag pumupunta dito sa pinas, nft muna, tapos next na balik, araneta naman, tapos next balik, moa naman.

hindi rin naka-help sa girls yung pagrelease nila ng english songs kasi imagine, nag peak yung salamin, salamin. then after that, hindi na nasundan. tapos ganun pa umasta sa soc meds. eh sa kpop idols, bibihira lang talaga yung nakikipag away sa fans, kapag mga napika na lang sa sasaeng.

sana ginawang stable muna yung popularity & pinalaki muna yung fandom organically before penetrating the international scene. achievement yung nakapag kcon la sila pero what happens after that? parang nawawala yung momentum. :(

parang recent songs nila jennie at lisa. lost their hook sa actual fans and audience nila.

Damay na naman yung dalawa when both their albums are doing great in their own ways. All their songs actually suit their personality, and the genre isnt even surprising. Who are these fans? The blinks who are always critical with whatever the members release? Fans who always rally about letting the members be given artistic freedom, and yet the moment the girls do something theyve been talking about wanting to try, nauuna fans in criticizing them? The publics reception sa songs nila is fine. Stop taking haters opinion as facts.

stop taking opinion as hate.
or better, give us a script so we can copy paste it and comment it to every post na involved ang music nila.

Kaya mo nga sila i-bring up sa topic na hindi sila involved, specially on a post that literally has nothing to do with them or their music in general, hihingi ka pa script.

I didnt even take your comment as hate, and was generally just talking about the actual fans and audience you mentioned. Actual fans seem to be taking their music well. So who are these youre talking about and why do you speak about their opinion as facts? Majority of those who talks about their songs not being taken nicely are mostly haters who poses as fans and gen public. So ano ka dyan, since you seem to be familiar enough about their opinion to talk? Kaya nga sinabi ko stop taking haters opinions as facts

haaayy kaya di ako sumasali sa mga fandom na yan eh. hirap


Masyado sila nagmadali for a world tour. Bini is super sikat here sa pinas pero world wide they are not as known.

this is true! ginatasan talaga. to think, nag-die down na din talaga hype with bini since hindi nasundan yung pantropiko fever

True. Flop yung recent EP nila hindi nagcchart locally. Hindi din relatable sa Pinoy unlike nung Pantropiko at Salamin. Sadly, nawala na din masyado hype nila. Walang kakaibang promotion, walang eye catching na content, walang viral na anything bukod sa mga negative issues ng ilang members recently.

Puro kase pera ang management ehh, look at their live streams, dati naman libre lang sa Kumu, ngayon may membership na

Their merch is low qual even though sobrang mahal, okay lang sana kung abot kaya ng masa kaso hindi ehh

They also abandoned Tagalog songs in pursuit of international fame pero sa totoo lang yung recent releases nila sound weak, parang AI generated yung lyrics, I think may issue din yung producer ng recent English songs nila, nagka issue ata don sa SB19 na parang panget din kinalabasan not sure

\>nagka issue ata don sa SB19 na parang panget din kinalabasan not sure

Can you expound this? afaik, sb19 is not in any way related sa producers ng gg (idk who their producers are). recently lang naman kumuha ng ibang producer ang group for Simula at Wakas EP. Si August Rigo and Simon Servida lang ang previous nila na nakawork.

Yeah, I checked the Biniverse track list and there is not a single producer there that SB19 has worked with.  Which makes sense since their sounds are so vastly different, its doubtful there would be much crossover.


How old are they as a group? Meron ba talaga silang solid fanbase abroad who will be willing to watch their concerts? Parang sumikat sila after a couple of songs and then nag-overestimate yung management na because they sold out Philippine Arena, they can sold out venues in other countries, too

Sobrang mahal ng concert tickets ngayon. If even Beyonce can't sell out full stadiums anymore, you know there's something wrong talaga.

Correct me if Im wrong, hindi naman nila na sold out talaga ang PH Arena. Naka black curtains yong mga unsold sections/seats.

kahit nung sa Aurora music fest ang tamlay din ng crowd sa kanila (tho last performer sila at umuulan na) buti pa nung si TJ nag perform e, at yung cup of joe nung 2nd day kahit umuulan hype yung crowd

Heto rin sabi ng friend ko. Andami raw dead air sa Bini. Kulang rin stage presence lalo na in between songs. Di marunong makipagusap sa crowd.

I'm not an expert pero di ba 8 members sila sa group, bakit may isang backup singer pa sila on the side? Twice ko na napansin to.

A lot of the girls just double the other girls (when they have to dance) kasi lbr ilan lang talaga sa kanila ang strong vocally. They dont have complex harmonies by themselves. So the backup singer covers some other harmonies/adlibs to fill out the sound. If theyre doing sit down perfs or acapellas, theyre fine, though.


Black curtains are waving

Ano ibig sabihin nyan

last concert nila sa Philippine arena maraming black curtains kahit ang sabi ay sold out daw

kaya nag taka ako nung inannounce na sold out hahahaha. gusto kasi sila first as a ph act sa phil arena

Goal yata nila is angkinin nga ang title na first Filipino performers na nag-PH Arena.

Kaya may rumors na natunugan na mag-PH Arena ang SB19, kaya inunahan nila kahit katatapos lang ng major concert nila. Bali, nag-major concert ulit na halos walang bagong release kaya nag-reklamo ang fans na pinatulan nila sa Twitter lol.

Haha true. Sunod sunod concert last year tas wala namang bago. Sayang lang pera. Ung sa New Frontier Theater lang talaga yung maayos na concert para sakin kasi 1st time. The rest is meh, puro recycled acts nalang.


Looks like the seating capacity here is 3x the one for SB19's concert (Pickering Arena). Too bad for me, SB19's sold out, resale tickets remaining.

SB19, I guess, tinetest pa din nila yung fanbase nila outside PH and they are also thinking yung magiging price ng ticket. As much as possible they want the price to be as affordable as possible

They had their Pagtatag concert in the same venue in 2023. I was thinking they'd be a bigger act now, but I guess they're taking the more conservative route.

Yes. Ayaw pa din nila mag risk. Hopefully next world tour mas malaki na yung venue. They deserve it din naman.

Yeah, would've loved to see them live!


to think na One Ok Rock is doing a concert on a smaller venue, THE One Ok Rock. Masyado talagang ambitious yung management. The bigger the venue pa naman, the higher the price of the rent for the stadium, tsk. Management talaga magpapabagsak sa girls e.

si Dyogi kasi parang my gusto patunayan, yung mga pinapasikat nya kasi ngayon flop sa casual viewers, yung BINI lang talaga nagustuhan ng fans kaya masyadong ginatasan kaya parang my umay na

Sino ba pinasikat nyan? Eh si Kim chiu lang din naman kaya nung may award si bawal lumabas andun din sya to take credit

si Kim Chiu na pag walang loveteam irrelevant, magaling naman si Kim kaya lang di maiangat ni Dyogi ng solo artist

Hirap na hirap si Vice tulongan yan sa Showtime ano ano nalang sinasabi eh


I really believe masyadong malaki at sobrang dami nilang kinuhang venues sa NA tour nila. Outside Filipinos kasi and mangilan ngilang foreign listeners, sobrang niche ng Ppop sa NA. I'm a Bini fan pero they should've gone with smaller venues like what SB19 opted for. Like test the waters lang muna.

Though hindi naman kailangan sold out para mag generate ng profit ang isang concert especially if may sponsors. Typically madaming bumibili lang ng tickets very near the concert date, pero for sure may effect dito yung recent issue nila.

Speaking of sb, mukhang di rin nila maso-sold out SG! Siguro iniisip ng producers na ito lang yung SEA stop, pupuntahan ng ibang SEA countries/jp/china. Sayang! Sana mag small venues din sila sa jp and Indo.

kelan nga ang SG ng esbi? More than 50% sold na last time I checked sa X. Possibly bibilis ang ticket sales after kickoff kapag may vid na ng performances.

May Japan (no announcement yet of date and tix selling) and Taiwan (sold out) stops sila tho. They'll even be performing sa Hito Awards Taiwan prior to that.

Problem ko with Singapore is the lack of promotion. Fanbases ang kayod magpromote together with the producer sa small gatherings. I hope may bigger platform sila like radio/channel/big socmed accounts and group na ma utilize to promote the con.

edit: even the announcement of global fan package was posted by the fanbase's admin. I wonder if may official account ang producer and may own following like Pulp/LNPH/Applewood here sa PH.

Natumbok mo. Also just checked, and august 24 ang SG. May time pa.


nauumay nako sa bini totoo lang.
theyre not songwriters.
only a few of them could REALLY sing.

problematic pa morales.
saw a live performance of SB19-- yun talaga yung TALENT.

1st sentence, tell that also to kpop groups.

i only know blackpink. sorry. yung recent magkakamukha lang din kasi

Natawa ako dito hahaha


I wonder kung mayuwi sa kasuhan yan with the sponsors.  Its not just because walang gustong manood, but because may nangyari kasi that could have led to low sales.

Pero matagal nang open yung ticket selling. This week lang naman nagkaissue.

I wonder kung pababa na yung hype ng Bini.

Naging laughing stock na nga yung tatlo eh ahhaha kaya bababa talaga hype sa kanila, yung mga casual viewers hindi na sila seseryosohin katulad kay maris na issue pa rin ang binibring up sa kanya sa sochmed. Basta may nakakadiri issue hindi na yun maalis sa pangalan ng tatlo bini


No idea why they thought they were on this level. XG which is alot better than them are gradually growing their fan base.

They just did Coachella. Theyre working the circuit in Korea and are swinging to Latin America.

This looks to be greed.

It's also easy to love XG because their members have this Japanese politeness in front of the camera. I can't say the same for some of the BINI girls.

For sure. If you saw the documentary, Simon instilled this in them.

There was a clip where Simpn told them to close their social media accounts. Something to the effect of do you want to post something that youll regret later?

Very much relevant at this moment.

The girls are sweethearts. Theyve been unproblematic as talented as they are.

So far anwyay. I hope it stays that way.


Mas gugustohin iba na mag work kesa manood ng concert. Ang mahal ng ticket nila!

truee, saka baka ibenta na lang din ng iba yung tickets nila dahil sa issue

No problem dyan kasi pasok na sa producer yung pera.


to be fair ang laki din kasi ng capacity ng venue nila, eh first time palang naman nila mag concert diyan.

Ang bilis din kasi ma sold out nung last North America concert nila, akala sguro nila pag nag concert ulit sila mabilis ulit ma sold out.

Chineck ko din yung sa Vancouver and sobrang dami pang available na tickets. Luging lugi sila kung lahat ng north america nila ay hindi mag sold out. Sana inuna muna nila ang Pilipinas

That may be one of the issues. Hindi kase talaga sila engaging sa live performances. Wala silang vocal stability talaga when singing live kaya madalas para silang pumipiyok. Not to mention obvious na hinhingal sila pag nagpe-perform. They rely mainly sa backing track. Sa Pinas they can get away with this especially since may back-up singers din silang sumasalo. So yung ibang mga nakapanood sa kanila before sa North America probably realized they won't get their money's worth kaya di na uulit.


They should have just gotten a smaller venue then if there's a demand for more tickets then they could either upgrade the venue to a bigger one or book a second night on the same venue, this is what small rock bands do when they perform for the first time in a new market to see if the demand is there.

Overestimation siguro to. Canada din ata yung inupgrade nila na venue last time. Nilakihan venue kasi sold out na pero may demand pa. Ito ata masyado naman malaki.

Yeah, mas maganda sana imarket na pag maliit yung venue ilalagay nila pag na sold out ang isang venue na either **sold out**, **upgraded venue** or **added date**, para mamarket nila na may demand sila sa ibang bansa.


I fear baka di na sila makapag world tour after this. Baka sasabay na lang sa ASAP para makapagshow outside PH.

Balik BGYO level

I wish them well, though. Di lang talaga ako bilib sa venue picks. Mas malaking venue kasi mas mahal ang production cost. And kapag di nakapagROI, most likely di na makaulit. Iniisip ko na lang na magiging good outcome eh magiging inclined ang management na ifocus ang promotions nila sa PH since andito naman yung solid fanbase nila. And makakapag nationwide tour na sila sa mga provinces na di nila napuntahan last year.


i went to their concert last year dito sa toronto (which is actually sa oshawa lol) and madami talagang seats na hindi occupied pero pinapalabas nila sa socmed na sold out daw. this was around august ata last year, tapos babalik sila with just 1 new song so wrong move talaga.

yung blackpink nga na years ago pa last nag concert dito hindi pa nasosold out yung tickets eh, sila pa kaya?

They have more than one new song. They have a whole new EP and (allegedly) a second one waiting for release.  But the fact that you (and many others) dont know about the new EP is part of the problem. I cant tell if its just lack of interest or wrong promotional tactics by their management.

oh righttt i totally forgot about that, yun yung puro english songs. medyo forgettable kasi yung EP na yun for me huhu sorry


There is a cost of living crisis where everyone is living paycheck to paycheck. Di afford ng tao and di enough ang disposable income.

Prices have gone up since pandemic pero nung nag-concert ang Eheads in 2023 sa Hamilton, Ontario marami pa rin ang nanuod. Parang di naman ramdam ang paycheck to paycheck living condition. I just dont think ganon kasikat ang BINI internationally.

Yup, madami silang casual listeners especially Pantropiko and salamin salamin era, and maybe they keep coming back to those songs, but not everyone are fan enough to spend $50 (yan yata pinakamura ticket price) or give a few hours of their time just to watch them. Hindi priority kumbaga.


Oooh di kaya sinadya ilabas yung pdf video para may reason to cancel or postpone the concert? Para hindi masyado mapahiya dahil ang totoo, hindi talaga bumenta ang tickets? Oh my Hahahaha mas masakit sa pride yun kaysa sabihing may questionable attitude ang 3 members

hala possible totoo theory mo na yan, or kung hindi man sadya ilabas yung video, i think may maganda dulot din sa kanila ang video na yun, may magagamit sila rason kung bakit hindi sila naka sold out. Nakakahiya ksi kapag nalamn na hindi nila nagawa mag sold out outside Philippines, sa Philippine arena nga binili na lng ng management ang ticket para masabi sold out, kaya pala grabe ang ads ng concert nila na yun pati sa led screen naka display ang ads yun pala para makabawi sa mga ticket na hindi nabenta

Tama. Also, parang mas malaki ang impact if malaman ng mga tao na hindi sold out ang tickets or halos walang bumibili dahil *palaos na or wala ng hype*. Kasi mas magtuloy-tuloy yan and ma condition ang mind ng mga tao na wala na talaga silang appeal. Hanggang dun lang sila sa Pantropiko days. Yes nakakahiya yun dahil pride nila yan. Sana di muna nila tinarget ang international music scene. Nagfocus muna sila dito. Mga catchy na tagalog songs muna.


Hold on, mga mhie. If you were to ask yung mga CASUAL LISTENERS ng BINI parang apat lang yata yung kanya nilang sobrang sumikat  Gatas na gatas naman

Tbh salamin at pantropiko lang alam ko

true  those saka yung Cherry then Karera


Akala cguro ka level sila ng BTS

Jhope and Suga nga maliit lang na arena ang venue tpos nag theater pa ata si Suga na venue to think na sila superstar talaga.


Mahirap na daw kasi ang buhay sa Toronto, Canada. Pinoys would rather work na lang daw.

Lol or di lang sila kilala. My white washed pinoy cousins dont even know them


More! More! Para magtanda yang mga BINI members na hindi sila nakakaangat porket sikat. Dito lang naman sila sikat. Lumaki na mga ulo lalo na yang Colet, anger anger pa nalalaman gusto magpaka edgy. Bumalik sana sila sa kangkungan ng malaman nila ang responsableng paghandle ng fame. Andiyan na ang SB19, hindi pa humingi ng tips.

true maging starlet sana sila ulit para hindi na sila magrereklamo sa privacy nila, Tutal gigil na gigil sila sa mga tao dinudumog sila, after nila magpapansin sa tiktok bigla ayaw pala nila pansinin sila kapag nakita sila sa public


Bro they don't have the discography or the pull for things like this. I remember someone said "Full album Muna Bago concert" tapos parang nagalet hahaha

PWEDENG MAG WAIT KA???

HAHAHAHA


OA naman niyan. Ayaw ba nila mag start sa small venues?

Ambisyoso masyado ang management nila eh.


Tapos pang asap performance lang yung ipapakita.  kaloka! Taas ng pangarap.

Dagdag mo may mga ADS PERFORMANCE pa  kakahiya sila kapag dinala pa nila ang mga ads na yan dyan sa world tour nila


Gatas na gatas kasi sila. Umay din yung sunod sunod concert nila.

I think ABS-CBN is a terrible management agency when it comes to this.

They only know how to cover up issues but not maintain popularity.


Tbf naman with Bini, di pa sila talaga makakapuno ng world tour levels talaga. They're not that big yet internationally.

Ambitious lang talaga yung manman. Sana tinest lang muna nila how big their fanbase for next World tour. Siguro sold out yung con nila since matagal na din nag ticket selling.


Kahit last Canada concert nila ay ilang beses na-move ang sched ang venue. Tsaka madalas nagpapa 70% off discount ang abs near the event kapag hindi pa rin puno ang venue. Afaik, ganun ginawa last time kaya naging sold out

Lol kahit yung recently concluded na SMtown concert sa Mexico ganun din ginawa para ma-sold out lang tickets.


Yung mga Filipino sa East Coast have not heard of Bini, unlike sa West Coast na medyo kilala sila. Ok naman yung sales ng Pechanga Resort and sa San Francisco. Pero daming bakante sa Chicago and NY venues.

Ang daming factors ang dapat i-consider if you are going to watch a Filipino act like Bini. People who live far would have to travel, and they have to spend money on hotels and in- city transpo. Hindi na biro yung gastos, so it would have been better is nag-concentrate sila sa Asian region then grow from there.

This is true. I know them because theyre one of the Pop groups that first popped up with MNL48. But majority no one really listens and knows them. Should have started small before going big.


Parang hindi pang long term goal ng management nila which could lead to their downfall nga.

As a huge fan of Itzy, sad to say baka yung hirap ng pagretain ng hype nila ay mangyari rin sa BINI, to think management din ang may kagagawan kung bakit. Kaibahan nga lang nila may social media training ang KPOP group.

Cherry on Top = Sneakers


what if mapuno yan may masabi pa din ang pinoy  pinoy nga naman hilaan pababa crab mentality

Philippine arena nga hindi na sold out, impossible na kaya pa bilhin ng management ang mga ticket hindi na benta para lang masabi sold out katulad ng ginawa nila sa Philippine arena


Daming nagmamagaling dito. Have you guys ever thought that maybe the agenda is not to sell out? Maybe its building credibility or Filipino fanbase around the world - a build-up move. Maybe its as simple as wanting to perform for the Filipino fans outside of PH. You guys assume that their target even extend beyond pinoys when obviously that is not the case, so what is even the significance of telling they are not ready for the global stage, when they are not even trying to perform in a global stage. Do you see them marketing Bini outside of the filipino fanbase? I dont think so!!

haha seriously I get the issue and everything but people here are nagmamagaling and honestly just assuming shit because they are playing abroad. there are some happy-go-lucky filipinos out there who would spend for this to get out of their busy lives and maybe get a taste of ph culture. so go place your analysis somewhere else!! not ready for the global stage my ass, they arent even marketing for the global s...

Do you really think they would rent out more expensive venues (mas malaki, mas higher cost) kung wala silang expectation? You all always reason out na "business is business" kapag may questionable decisions ang management nila, but suddenly it's not and they just wanna treat their fans? Bobo haha


Pwede ba makita yung sa OOR? Kami dito hintay lang sa pinas muna kung kailan.

Huy sama if ever bumalik sila


Ilan daliri mo te? Naka 3 album/ep na sila. Tig 3 songs each lang ba laman per album?

So bakit halos ad jingles laman ng setlist nila?


**Sa Pinas, kahit may scandal ang celeb, parang walang nangyari. Basta marunong umiyak sa TV at magpost ng hugot apology, back to regular programming na ulit. Mabilis makalimot ang tao, lalo na pag may bagong issue. And lets be honest, as long as youre still benta sa masa, kebs na si brand, pera pa rin ang habol.Redemption arc is life, at minsan pa nga, mas sumisikat pa after the chismis. Maris, Coco, Tumbong, and others are saying hi**

Never na cancel si Coco Martin at late na rin na realize ng tao na groomer pala yun pero too late na. Si Daniel Padilla mga 1 year walang project yun habang si Kathryn patuloy pa rin. Si Maris nakabawi pero yung "Happy Skin" na endorsement niya nagisa kaya di talaga nalimutan ng tuluyan

Sa Bini kasi fresh talaga saka yung sila Coco Martin, etc. ay di naman mga "women empowerment" advocates na malaki ang fanbase sa mga bata kaya yari ang BINI dito kahit pa makabawi sila

Si tumbz nawala sa kfc, pepsi, at bpi. Not sure kung emperador pa rin sya pero wala na rin alam ko. Buti na lang medyo ok ang incognito nila.

Yung Emperador Coffee lang naman ang profuct endorsement ni Tumbong with Emperador.


Ang may malaking fanbase sa Bini na casuals ay si Mikha and Aiah. Makikita mo yan sa sigawan sa mga events nila.

Ang may pinaka dedicated na active fanbase ay si Maloi. Her fanbase group actively sponsors Bini events. Ang yaman ng fanbase nya.

The three? Asa gitna si Jho at Colet. Least popular si Stacey.

I remember nung lumabas yung photocards nila sa jabee nagiiyakan yung mga bata when they didnt get Stacey. All the little kids wanted her! Anyare? Sa mga bata lang yata siya popular. I get it tho, personally she ranks the least among the members for me

Kasi Stacey ang yung girly and princess ata hahaha


Let's be honest, yung tatlong involved is nasa mid/low popularity. Their endorsements and projects will start getting affected kapag yung top members ang nagka-issue na malala. I think Aiah and Mikha are the most popular, maybe Maloi din pero ilang buwan na siya di nilulubayan ng issue with zild pero wala naman effect sa popularity nila.

Kaya nga buti nagrelease sila ng statement dahil kundi may bagong video daw na irerelease na involve naman yung top members ng Bini

Naaah. Feeling ko bluff na lang yang video na yan. Kung totoong feeling nya ay Garosero sya ng Pinas, maglalapag at maglalapag yan ng videos and receipts ng baho ng bini. Lalo na ngayon na nagrelease ng statement and not everyone sides with the group, eto talaga chance nya magexpose. Pero asan na? Naghanap lang yan ng clout sa true lang.


Baka magpull out jollibee. Or nagpull out na. They do it so quietly

Sadly oo. Malamang hindi na sila irerenew knowing na pambata ang theme ng Jolibee. Imagine may new ads ang bini tapos makikita mo sa com sec yung mga issues na binabato sa kanila. Kung ako jolibee iiwas ako sa ganto.

Jollibee is notorious with dropping endorsers agad basta may scandal. Kasama sa contract nila yun tapos need bayaran yung contract/nagastos ng buo. Yung kay maris and anthony, para hindi magbayad ng buo, pinalitan nila for fyang. Buti nga pumayag jollibee corp eh.


at this point feeling ko talaga di naman kayo galit sa bini dahil sa issue nung tatlo, hate niyo lang talaga ang bini. asal hater lang eh

It was the perfect opportunity to pin them down.

Yung isa ngang madalas mag-post dito, avid fan ng ibang group. He was literally bashing BINI in older comments for their talents, which has nothing to do with the gravity of the offense in the leaked video.

Hindi ko sinasabi na hindi valid ang uproar, pero meron at merong nakikisakay na hater lang talaga.

mga nagtatago yan dati na mga haters. naghihintay lang ng timing para maging valid ang hate nila sa bini kahit nadamay lang namn ang 5 dahil sa tatlo and at least callout the men too. very obvious talaga sila


Sobrang tagal na po kasi nangyari yan at nag-apologize na rin sila. Hindi pa rin ba maka-move on? Endorsers know better.

maasim na blooms spotted HAHAHHAHAHAHA

*grooms


Parang wala na sila sa Samsung. Lately open na sila sa pagflex ng iphone nila

nagka commercial ba ang bini for Samsung? parang product placement lang namn ang nangyayari nuon haha


From someone who used to work for Marketing, their issue is too small to pull out. Nagpupull pa rin naman sila ng sales. Also, mejo nagdie down na yung issue. Sadyang dito na lang ata sa reddit at x maingay. Plus, theyre currently out of the country na. Wala na sila masyadong ganap in the next 1-2 mos dito. So wala. Makakalimutan na ng karamihan yang issue na yan.

Which is sad


Im still disappointed kay Jhoanna, Colet, Stacey. Hindi na nakaka-good vibes whenever I think of BINI. And to think my underage niece is fangirling over them. Nakaka-disappoint.

Ilayo mo sa BINI ang underage niece mo. Pagbebembang sa isang 13 years old ginawa lang katatawanan kahit sa inuman or private conversations with green jokes hindi normal yan.


All these endorsements pero never naisip ng Kopiko sumali...

Sa isla nag kopiko.
nag kopiko nag kopiko

Nescafe endorsers sla e


NGL this is the reason why Star Magic Artists has better showbiz careers than any of its competitors. I mean grabeng scandal to and for them to control this. Imagine if Campaign Strategist mo ang Star Magic gurl baka maipanalo ka nila sa pagkapangulo.

Kaya rin siguro naging Star Magic artist na si Ivana? Mahusay kasi PR control wahaha

Uyyy. Kaya siguro ang tahimik ng pangalan nya ngayon

Lakas makapabango ng image yung short stint niya as pbb houseguest.


Totoong walo hanggang dulo kasi kahit yung mga hindi naman kasali sa issue eh nadamay

Ang off talaga non. Kung ako yun, alis na ako hahahahaha. Biruin mo di mo naman kasalanan tapos nasama pa name mo sa apology statement LOL nakakabastos fr

After ng apology na yan, nagsilabasan yung mga solo stans kasi nagrereklamo kung bakit nadamay yung bias nila na di kasali. Tapos meron din ot5..

Ganyan talaga kapag grupo. Di maiiwasan na may solo stans. Baka mas naging comfortable lang sila maging vocal after niyan kasi nga naman, nakakainis yung nangyaring damay damay.


never tlga ako naniniwala sa mga ganitong gawain yay, lalo ang gumagawa ay my issue

wala pang issue nung nag viral yang pag tulong niya na yan pero hanep ng mga fans ginamit at pinagmukha na ngayon niya ginawa yan HAHAHA

So meaning noon palang performative na, noted hahahhaa grabi grooms Ngayon ah


Even before the issue, medyo na-ooff na ko pag nag gaganyan sila eh, para kasing di sincere sa pakiramdam ganon or maybe its just me idk

Careful. Genuine daw yang charity work ng Bini according to fans. Masama ka daw na tao if di ka naniwala na genuinely good people sila.

I mean mababait naman sila siguro (still doesn't excuse the jokes) pero baket kase kailangan pang videohan  ang pagtulong. That shit screams performative


Months ago na po yang pagbigay po niya ng food. Not after the issue po.

Yes pero yung post is recently lang. Bale they used old photos to support Binis recent issue

Group ng fans yan sa FB di ba?


Bago ba yan?

Ang alam ko yung photos parang months ago pa yan eh. Pero siyempre the blooms aka grooms still gon eat it up

Ahhh. That explains. Kasi I dont think Jollibee would want their kid friendly brand to be used as a mop para malinis yung grooming sexual abuse issue ng endorser nila. Mas ayaw ma-associate ng Jollibee sa ganyan

Magiging problema yan sa contract nila with Jollibee, if this really came from ABS/ Bini PR Team. Yare sila big time sa sponsor nila bat ginawang sacrificial vessel . Mukhang fan initiative, kaso mukhang di pinag-isipan that this would be a potential problem sa sponsor contract deal ng idols nila


parang poverty porn vlogger

HAHAHAHAHHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHHAHAHAHAHAHAHHAA

same thought, it kinda screams poverty porn


"ang isang mali ay natabunan kaagad ng mga mabubuti mong nagawa sa kapwa"

so ang katumbas lang pala ng SA and grooming jokes involving a minor (na 13 years old pa)... ay magbigay ng jollibee sa kalsada

sponsored pa yan ng jollibee malamang HAHAHAHA poverty porn at its finest

Right?? Ano ibig nilang sabihin na natabunan na agad yung isang pagkakamali dahil lang may mabuti kang nagawa sa iba? Hindi ko talaga gets yung ganitong mindset, lalo na sa mga taong bulok ang values (silang tatlo), o sa pinapalabas ng PR team nila. Mali na nga yung ginawa, tapos sila pa ang magdidikta kung ano yung sapat/katumbas para mapatawad. Sino ba sila para sabihing okay na ang lahat? Dapat yung taong nasaktan o nagawan ng mali ang may karapatang magsabi kung sapat na yung sorry. Kalokaaaaaaaa! Jollibee lang pala katumbas


Might be an unpopular opinion: But both can be true at the same time.

Sure, they can be nice, and kindhearted people. I always believed that everyone has some *goodness* in them. But they could also be crass, and rude, who are capable of making tasteless "statutory rape" jokes/statements.

Eto yung hindi matangap ng mga stans eh. Which is disappointing. They downplay such issues, making it look like it's "a normal thing" to do. They deflect. Delikado yung approach na yan since 1.) We don't want it to be normalized. Nothing about casually saying doing a sexual act to a 13 year old kid is okay. And 2.) It only enforces the idea that their idols haven't done anything wrong. Na "wala yan, maliit na bagay lang yan".

How can they "***reflect, and learn from our mistake***" kung sa simpleng PR Team statement eh OKAY NA ang lahat? Kaya tuloy ang ending walang nagbabago. They will just take a month long break, cool off, then *everything* ...

Well said


Sabi na. Idadaan na naman sa charity ekek. ABS really has the best yet overworked spin doctors. Sana sulit sahod nila. Hahaha

matagal na yan bago pa yung issue.  it doesnt correct their mistake pero at least icorrect natin ung context.


Star magic ba ung page??

Fan page lang po yan ng Bini. Di naman yan managed by star magic


Fan account naman yan to be fair lang. It was an old picture.

Same as sa comment ko sa iba, recent yung post but they used old photos (galawang kengkoy).

And yes, its a fan page thats not managed by Star Magic. Pero I meant to point out the fact that they still garnered this much support (peep the FB reactions and comments) in spite of the issue. Just goes to show that Star Magics PR handling is top notch, to the point na kahit gaano kasahol pa issue nila they will still be blindly supported by their followers