RLVRAMBench / benchmark /replication_control /replication_control_design.json
kobzaond's picture
Publish complete Electronics submission: A100, MI250X, paper and raw evidence
1227045 verified
Raw History Blame Contribute Delete
19.3 kB
{
"analysis": {
"batch": "((actor_only-base)+(joint-reservation_only))/2",
"inference_limit": "descriptive replication; 3 seeds/case is not an equivalence or power guarantee; no confirmatory p-value fishing",
"interaction": "joint-actor_only-reservation_only+base",
"primary_pool": "complete four-condition same-device blocks with valid full phase evidence; all missing denominators reported",
"reservation": "((reservation_only-base)+(joint-actor_only))/2",
"summaries": "all block contrasts and per-case mean/min/max with n; equal-case mean over all 12 cases only when all cases contribute"
},
"cache_policy": "Fresh process, Ray namespace, scratch and compiler caches per period; same immutable cached model snapshot and data. NVML baseline and process sampling around/during each period. OS page cache, host contention and thermal carryover may remain.",
"device_capacity_mib": 40960,
"expectations": {
"labels": "historical_expected_label is a frozen descriptive source-copy expectation, never a required new outcome or retry criterion",
"primary": [
"positive mean actor_update batch effect",
"positive mean whole_run reservation effect"
],
"prior_visibility": "Original public outcomes informed the research question; this is a fresh-seed replication, not blind method development",
"secondary": [
"batch by reservation interaction, two-sided",
"all phase effects and completion/margin counts"
]
},
"expected_grid": {
"conditions": [
"base",
"actor_only",
"reservation_only",
"joint"
],
"models": [
"granite33_2b",
"phi4_mini",
"qwen25_3b"
],
"workloads": [
"code_heavy_tail",
"code_standard",
"gsm8k",
"math"
]
},
"failure_policy": "One permanent claim per block, no retries/requeues/replacement. Continue in frozen order after any outcome only if cleanup and two-device idle/identity gates pass and a full time slot remains. Never infer OOM from timeout or missing evidence. Retain all 144 slots.",
"frozen_at_utc": "2026-09-16T09:47:22.919813+00:00",
"hardware": "NVIDIA A100-SXM4-40GB",
"matrix_sha256": "50ed3836b8b8e9b84fb71e71e0d93e505a4202f2040f397ec542f2d0961ba160",
"memory_margin_limit_mib": 38912,
"order_seed": 2026091607,
"randomization": "Seeded Williams four-sequence schedule: distinct sequences within each 3-seed case; every condition/position and directed adjacency occurs nine times overall. Each sequence occurs three times/model. Exact within-case position balance is impossible with three repeats.",
"resource_cap": {
"allocations": 36,
"cleanup_reserve_seconds": 30,
"conditions": 144,
"gpus_per_allocation": 2,
"idle_timeout_seconds": 60,
"max_concurrent_allocations": 3,
"maximum_reserved_gpu_hours": 72,
"payload_timeout_seconds": 720,
"requeue": false,
"retries": 0,
"wall_seconds": 3600
},
"schema_version": "replication_control-1",
"scope": "All 12 original standard-GRPO model/workload cases; historical oracle-SPPO rows are validated as provenance, not replicated.",
"seed_audit": {
"files_sha256": {
"benchmark/decision/matrix.csv": "0c14400d24b03d89225b1f03bcdc68339f5080abb6168c1db1543db5a522bae6",
"benchmark/decision/results/attempts.csv": "2201d6bd23710a09468c9c04e1ab1247d0ba3e8444b08b623e9325b8e4bb93d7",
"benchmark/decision/results/validated_runs.csv": "388674ede4438b95272659318e30cb1cd87ee602a17e8e209825f6970ec9ea10",
"benchmark/estimation/matrix.csv": "1ff175e22c76bf1af3857b4ae57cd4f78bafe0d280a295d696e96815ef85e9c8",
"benchmark/estimation/results/pairs.csv": "040e9d135c0a132debc315d62dd6824b5bd826d42ec85056c722b058995d7cd1",
"benchmark/estimation/results/processes.csv": "9a4e03a34a51a287afb983b93244662f9ac7abf366ba97bd717ba9d371fefdc2",
"benchmark/host_capacity/matrix.csv": "1d2b2af601361a3cb46b65ff3be263685b3f725f2b0e4787a8ff9966084f5332",
"benchmark/host_capacity/results/pairs.csv": "f1c6ca2025a681b3f5185b7f133ec4f2028a79bfa1e0e3b6a8a0954f4478e5ce",
"benchmark/host_capacity/results/processes.csv": "87a1603625747e96f2aa21a338b9ea86b63ade888f249489546387f646ed8dae",
"benchmark/not_started_conditions.csv": "bde7386b464b21c769acc6c718b81a5c96c94318846869d9e814402db22fecb2",
"benchmark/runs.csv": "8e00ac4969709f71a6e780396085c9a259a71986dd45825cf52d42c061c53d5c",
"memory_tuner/rlvram_exact_transfer_online.csv": "559b074bfceeb0887250f3a5dbd5852c650fe37ad859a9d7bf2538c995030b2e",
"memory_tuner/rlvram_exact_transfer_vllm.csv": "e95d1a7a36aede547bd097c3c7a4cd180f39f8e4a8e07876b54e37eee5514846",
"memory_tuner/rlvram_exact_transfer_vllm_repeats.csv": "bd38cdf8467ef504ca819ebc906543ec5ba858d8d5e46c8308c5a1cb67905860",
"memory_tuner/rlvram_major_revision_cross_model_confirmatory.csv": "ed274c590ddbc8ebbe5d588970c8383860602fc693a6f91082cebf47a5d9f560",
"memory_tuner/rlvram_major_revision_cross_model_smoke.csv": "6c2546f30639b5fe198893f345098590bf82d17e1e97019ba90ed0028260cf1b",
"memory_tuner/rlvram_major_revision_residency_period1.csv": "2acb60aa820320fbf0697031177b3b4cdcc5ec5549011de44abcf899e539ec68",
"memory_tuner/rlvram_major_revision_residency_period2.csv": "f74d8a27078454fae482b7abd8401fc4686c157b7a3033b5e0e8e6f22d5ab365",
"memory_tuner/rlvram_major_revision_transfer_colocated.csv": "5f47da736e516ac70925046b9e0a0138a78fd5b61681ec54c98d9a19ca4a71d1",
"memory_tuner/rlvram_major_revision_transfer_offline.csv": "f9c4550bc2e3ce0c468a8cbc04ac859a299355aa817360024e2572a3d6749173",
"memory_tuner/rlvram_major_revision_transfer_online.csv": "d2f4866d660a3de0e9e5ab54f8322e81b05eb11f57039af17950cbbfb023e980",
"memory_tuner/rlvram_online_repeats.csv": "cd0019fe917150e6f802796572b74e0198d59c68ab7d4aadc6c6c6c93d19427d",
"memory_tuner/rlvram_online_screening.csv": "8cbec37db96395cb9257fe666ef03eb5a9ba4f64122fa4cc92440f69026a1a12",
"memory_tuner/rlvram_review_instrumentation_batch.csv": "21ab989275d4ecfd1279ee10545b70e9c00c172c7e13f00f426ab39d4e1ef7f6",
"memory_tuner/rlvram_revision_instrumentation.csv": "447f127357cc5fc1e2f077d0ee30994364f1bfdfc904e2d83d16db952e8b434d",
"memory_tuner/rlvram_revision_temporal.csv": "648fa65cbebe522fa20db1c627214835881db78c61b49dcca0c11611695f52b9",
"memory_tuner/rlvram_revision_topology.csv": "f678434c19ed7de6787cb314165e8042de2c135783e1c8d0c905e2b07e1c8c30",
"memory_tuner/rlvram_screening_vllm.csv": "343e024b1c3fe41898d7daedf903a9c03efa6c3b5b3a24c05f7dff622c196aa6",
"memory_tuner/rlvram_strengthening_factorial.csv": "38a0645fe56b1a894bde2c9d183f7355c1ad358f7f14edc75fffa50775c9aebf",
"memory_tuner/rlvram_strengthening_granite_confirmatory.csv": "c664d23ec999cd64512d2617ad6fbbb330d76fd3d0621b58571bcef291e5d061",
"memory_tuner/rlvram_strengthening_granite_smoke.csv": "7a7d2e5883a48de74fd0c9f6b2767c9e65270294ab30f044e2674a2630ab51ce",
"memory_tuner/rlvram_strengthening_matched_colocated.csv": "d891dce5edeb086b6c4209e2004e1d7f295a7dd281e774ebe362aa02537bb12d",
"memory_tuner/rlvram_strengthening_matched_serving.csv": "94591fb4663d1e961d970758a6c9a78058e1941175c27f5a9652787c4dade88e",
"memory_tuner/rlvram_strengthening_same_node_period1.csv": "a5bf4cb2ced7c45ab9de05271be682979730263351b6682209634e6ced5211c5",
"memory_tuner/rlvram_strengthening_same_node_period2.csv": "5b0b95c4572c68899bc573e308248a8c25b77c488eb7a27ce4b77cd6ce5f228e",
"memory_tuner/rlvram_strengthening_temporal.csv": "74688e15ed17e7300ff6fcf6ca44e6ba4c6c84a94ba09e8b165c83e4bc269f55",
"memory_tuner/rlvram_v2_cross_family_confirmatory.csv": "0beb7ae7384490b1f15e0a7b5f933e644111bcede84999a508a34f1371771a45",
"memory_tuner/rlvram_v2_cross_family_development.csv": "d05807ff929184e06b8fe98580e01de1d11e6306b114f944631bf0caff1534b3",
"memory_tuner/rlvram_v2_cross_family_smoke.csv": "b3f375789490d84034f9bd6fb48fb0ff864570ce8dc38768c0aef10668185a76",
"memory_tuner/rlvram_v2_sleep_expansion.csv": "90277c284955dd0a2900403395fa77516d31955aa8477dff50508b9d5e81f649",
"memory_tuner/rlvram_v2_telemetry_calibration.csv": "19b07376ff33dad801404bcfcb44e6d042734f16e933e4a3e5ef066c122692f6",
"memory_tuner/rlvram_v2_temporal_confirmatory.csv": "4cf7a286b3c1f8ee62d0cf9a3dbe95ec68a4a848db47d00f2193c0aefa79c2f3",
"memory_tuner/rlvram_v2_temporal_pilot.csv": "56ff2c0241198f58eb9a4176214bf7a6021378734fc7d0ce135593bb73140f20",
"memory_tuner/vllm_matrix.csv": "2895a686c4ff18fc43e5e0640e2abdbf4cbd17440aaa03d54818ad626e06d6e9",
"memory_tuner/vllm_online_smoke.csv": "fb26a257e7ca9366468bd62ed7aa55bf02bac5fca22ff5eea922d2e229801963",
"memory_tuner/vllm_repeats_3b.csv": "c11595fc3e8ebfb6f49f1f0c696bd349b78ba7347380d5a754d7bcfb931e66d3"
},
"observed_seeds": [
0,
1,
2,
41,
42,
43,
47,
50,
51,
52,
53,
61,
62,
63,
71,
72,
73,
81,
82,
83,
90,
91,
92,
93,
94,
95,
96,
111,
112,
113,
121,
122,
123,
141,
142,
143,
144,
151,
152,
153,
161,
162,
163
],
"scope": "checked-in memory_tuner and benchmark CSV seed columns; does not assert a global scheduler/history census"
},
"seeds": [
211,
212,
213
],
"source_experiment_ids": [
"strong-factorial-granite33_2b-grpo-code_heavy_tail-actor_only-s94",
"strong-factorial-granite33_2b-grpo-code_heavy_tail-actor_only-s95",
"strong-factorial-granite33_2b-grpo-code_heavy_tail-actor_only-s96",
"strong-factorial-granite33_2b-grpo-code_heavy_tail-base-s94",
"strong-factorial-granite33_2b-grpo-code_heavy_tail-base-s95",
"strong-factorial-granite33_2b-grpo-code_heavy_tail-base-s96",
"strong-factorial-granite33_2b-grpo-code_heavy_tail-joint-s94",
"strong-factorial-granite33_2b-grpo-code_heavy_tail-joint-s95",
"strong-factorial-granite33_2b-grpo-code_heavy_tail-joint-s96",
"strong-factorial-granite33_2b-grpo-code_heavy_tail-reservation_only-s94",
"strong-factorial-granite33_2b-grpo-code_heavy_tail-reservation_only-s95",
"strong-factorial-granite33_2b-grpo-code_heavy_tail-reservation_only-s96",
"strong-factorial-granite33_2b-grpo-code_standard-actor_only-s94",
"strong-factorial-granite33_2b-grpo-code_standard-actor_only-s95",
"strong-factorial-granite33_2b-grpo-code_standard-actor_only-s96",
"strong-factorial-granite33_2b-grpo-code_standard-base-s94",
"strong-factorial-granite33_2b-grpo-code_standard-base-s95",
"strong-factorial-granite33_2b-grpo-code_standard-base-s96",
"strong-factorial-granite33_2b-grpo-code_standard-joint-s94",
"strong-factorial-granite33_2b-grpo-code_standard-joint-s95",
"strong-factorial-granite33_2b-grpo-code_standard-joint-s96",
"strong-factorial-granite33_2b-grpo-code_standard-reservation_only-s94",
"strong-factorial-granite33_2b-grpo-code_standard-reservation_only-s95",
"strong-factorial-granite33_2b-grpo-code_standard-reservation_only-s96",
"strong-factorial-granite33_2b-grpo-gsm8k_long-actor_only-s94",
"strong-factorial-granite33_2b-grpo-gsm8k_long-actor_only-s95",
"strong-factorial-granite33_2b-grpo-gsm8k_long-actor_only-s96",
"strong-factorial-granite33_2b-grpo-gsm8k_long-base-s94",
"strong-factorial-granite33_2b-grpo-gsm8k_long-base-s95",
"strong-factorial-granite33_2b-grpo-gsm8k_long-base-s96",
"strong-factorial-granite33_2b-grpo-gsm8k_long-joint-s94",
"strong-factorial-granite33_2b-grpo-gsm8k_long-joint-s95",
"strong-factorial-granite33_2b-grpo-gsm8k_long-joint-s96",
"strong-factorial-granite33_2b-grpo-gsm8k_long-reservation_only-s94",
"strong-factorial-granite33_2b-grpo-gsm8k_long-reservation_only-s95",
"strong-factorial-granite33_2b-grpo-gsm8k_long-reservation_only-s96",
"strong-factorial-granite33_2b-grpo-math_short-actor_only-s94",
"strong-factorial-granite33_2b-grpo-math_short-actor_only-s95",
"strong-factorial-granite33_2b-grpo-math_short-actor_only-s96",
"strong-factorial-granite33_2b-grpo-math_short-base-s94",
"strong-factorial-granite33_2b-grpo-math_short-base-s95",
"strong-factorial-granite33_2b-grpo-math_short-base-s96",
"strong-factorial-granite33_2b-grpo-math_short-joint-s94",
"strong-factorial-granite33_2b-grpo-math_short-joint-s95",
"strong-factorial-granite33_2b-grpo-math_short-joint-s96",
"strong-factorial-granite33_2b-grpo-math_short-reservation_only-s94",
"strong-factorial-granite33_2b-grpo-math_short-reservation_only-s95",
"strong-factorial-granite33_2b-grpo-math_short-reservation_only-s96",
"strong-factorial-phi4_mini-grpo-code_heavy_tail-actor_only-s94",
"strong-factorial-phi4_mini-grpo-code_heavy_tail-actor_only-s95",
"strong-factorial-phi4_mini-grpo-code_heavy_tail-actor_only-s96",
"strong-factorial-phi4_mini-grpo-code_heavy_tail-base-s94",
"strong-factorial-phi4_mini-grpo-code_heavy_tail-base-s95",
"strong-factorial-phi4_mini-grpo-code_heavy_tail-base-s96",
"strong-factorial-phi4_mini-grpo-code_heavy_tail-joint-s94",
"strong-factorial-phi4_mini-grpo-code_heavy_tail-joint-s95",
"strong-factorial-phi4_mini-grpo-code_heavy_tail-joint-s96",
"strong-factorial-phi4_mini-grpo-code_heavy_tail-reservation_only-s94",
"strong-factorial-phi4_mini-grpo-code_heavy_tail-reservation_only-s95",
"strong-factorial-phi4_mini-grpo-code_heavy_tail-reservation_only-s96",
"strong-factorial-phi4_mini-grpo-code_standard-actor_only-s94",
"strong-factorial-phi4_mini-grpo-code_standard-actor_only-s95",
"strong-factorial-phi4_mini-grpo-code_standard-actor_only-s96",
"strong-factorial-phi4_mini-grpo-code_standard-base-s94",
"strong-factorial-phi4_mini-grpo-code_standard-base-s95",
"strong-factorial-phi4_mini-grpo-code_standard-base-s96",
"strong-factorial-phi4_mini-grpo-code_standard-joint-s94",
"strong-factorial-phi4_mini-grpo-code_standard-joint-s95",
"strong-factorial-phi4_mini-grpo-code_standard-joint-s96",
"strong-factorial-phi4_mini-grpo-code_standard-reservation_only-s94",
"strong-factorial-phi4_mini-grpo-code_standard-reservation_only-s95",
"strong-factorial-phi4_mini-grpo-code_standard-reservation_only-s96",
"strong-factorial-phi4_mini-grpo-gsm8k-actor_only-s94",
"strong-factorial-phi4_mini-grpo-gsm8k-actor_only-s95",
"strong-factorial-phi4_mini-grpo-gsm8k-actor_only-s96",
"strong-factorial-phi4_mini-grpo-gsm8k-base-s94",
"strong-factorial-phi4_mini-grpo-gsm8k-base-s95",
"strong-factorial-phi4_mini-grpo-gsm8k-base-s96",
"strong-factorial-phi4_mini-grpo-gsm8k-joint-s94",
"strong-factorial-phi4_mini-grpo-gsm8k-joint-s95",
"strong-factorial-phi4_mini-grpo-gsm8k-joint-s96",
"strong-factorial-phi4_mini-grpo-gsm8k-reservation_only-s94",
"strong-factorial-phi4_mini-grpo-gsm8k-reservation_only-s95",
"strong-factorial-phi4_mini-grpo-gsm8k-reservation_only-s96",
"strong-factorial-phi4_mini-grpo-math-actor_only-s94",
"strong-factorial-phi4_mini-grpo-math-actor_only-s95",
"strong-factorial-phi4_mini-grpo-math-actor_only-s96",
"strong-factorial-phi4_mini-grpo-math-base-s94",
"strong-factorial-phi4_mini-grpo-math-base-s95",
"strong-factorial-phi4_mini-grpo-math-base-s96",
"strong-factorial-phi4_mini-grpo-math-joint-s94",
"strong-factorial-phi4_mini-grpo-math-joint-s95",
"strong-factorial-phi4_mini-grpo-math-joint-s96",
"strong-factorial-phi4_mini-grpo-math-reservation_only-s94",
"strong-factorial-phi4_mini-grpo-math-reservation_only-s95",
"strong-factorial-phi4_mini-grpo-math-reservation_only-s96",
"strong-factorial-qwen25_3b-grpo-code_heavy_tail-actor_only-s94",
"strong-factorial-qwen25_3b-grpo-code_heavy_tail-actor_only-s95",
"strong-factorial-qwen25_3b-grpo-code_heavy_tail-actor_only-s96",
"strong-factorial-qwen25_3b-grpo-code_heavy_tail-base-s94",
"strong-factorial-qwen25_3b-grpo-code_heavy_tail-base-s95",
"strong-factorial-qwen25_3b-grpo-code_heavy_tail-base-s96",
"strong-factorial-qwen25_3b-grpo-code_heavy_tail-joint-s94",
"strong-factorial-qwen25_3b-grpo-code_heavy_tail-joint-s95",
"strong-factorial-qwen25_3b-grpo-code_heavy_tail-joint-s96",
"strong-factorial-qwen25_3b-grpo-code_heavy_tail-reservation_only-s94",
"strong-factorial-qwen25_3b-grpo-code_heavy_tail-reservation_only-s95",
"strong-factorial-qwen25_3b-grpo-code_heavy_tail-reservation_only-s96",
"strong-factorial-qwen25_3b-grpo-code_standard-actor_only-s94",
"strong-factorial-qwen25_3b-grpo-code_standard-actor_only-s95",
"strong-factorial-qwen25_3b-grpo-code_standard-actor_only-s96",
"strong-factorial-qwen25_3b-grpo-code_standard-base-s94",
"strong-factorial-qwen25_3b-grpo-code_standard-base-s95",
"strong-factorial-qwen25_3b-grpo-code_standard-base-s96",
"strong-factorial-qwen25_3b-grpo-code_standard-joint-s94",
"strong-factorial-qwen25_3b-grpo-code_standard-joint-s95",
"strong-factorial-qwen25_3b-grpo-code_standard-joint-s96",
"strong-factorial-qwen25_3b-grpo-code_standard-reservation_only-s94",
"strong-factorial-qwen25_3b-grpo-code_standard-reservation_only-s95",
"strong-factorial-qwen25_3b-grpo-code_standard-reservation_only-s96",
"strong-factorial-qwen25_3b-grpo-gsm8k-actor_only-s94",
"strong-factorial-qwen25_3b-grpo-gsm8k-actor_only-s95",
"strong-factorial-qwen25_3b-grpo-gsm8k-actor_only-s96",
"strong-factorial-qwen25_3b-grpo-gsm8k-base-s94",
"strong-factorial-qwen25_3b-grpo-gsm8k-base-s95",
"strong-factorial-qwen25_3b-grpo-gsm8k-base-s96",
"strong-factorial-qwen25_3b-grpo-gsm8k-joint-s94",
"strong-factorial-qwen25_3b-grpo-gsm8k-joint-s95",
"strong-factorial-qwen25_3b-grpo-gsm8k-joint-s96",
"strong-factorial-qwen25_3b-grpo-gsm8k-reservation_only-s94",
"strong-factorial-qwen25_3b-grpo-gsm8k-reservation_only-s95",
"strong-factorial-qwen25_3b-grpo-gsm8k-reservation_only-s96",
"strong-factorial-qwen25_3b-grpo-math-actor_only-s94",
"strong-factorial-qwen25_3b-grpo-math-actor_only-s95",
"strong-factorial-qwen25_3b-grpo-math-actor_only-s96",
"strong-factorial-qwen25_3b-grpo-math-base-s94",
"strong-factorial-qwen25_3b-grpo-math-base-s95",
"strong-factorial-qwen25_3b-grpo-math-base-s96",
"strong-factorial-qwen25_3b-grpo-math-joint-s94",
"strong-factorial-qwen25_3b-grpo-math-joint-s95",
"strong-factorial-qwen25_3b-grpo-math-joint-s96",
"strong-factorial-qwen25_3b-grpo-math-reservation_only-s94",
"strong-factorial-qwen25_3b-grpo-math-reservation_only-s95",
"strong-factorial-qwen25_3b-grpo-math-reservation_only-s96"
],
"source_git_head": "45ec93878d9f44d95cb30f2c0a6530d3a243e9ad",
"source_sha256": {
"memory_tuner/rlvram_strengthening_factorial.csv": "38a0645fe56b1a894bde2c9d183f7355c1ad358f7f14edc75fffa50775c9aebf",
"profiles/standard_grpo/factorial-cells.csv": "8b6bf295d6fed3c98ce1ff23abcce9239a6281704d3e781b4dfecda36d8c8a37"
},
"status": "design_frozen_before_new_target_runs_execution_seal_required"
}