{ "status": "passed", "main_table_bodies_unchanged": 21, "figure_summary_files_matched": [ "adaptation_contrast_summary.csv", "horizon_agreement.csv", "horizon_observations.csv", "stage_case_contrasts.csv", "stage_excluded_slots.csv", "stage_paired_contrasts.csv", "timing_condition_summary.csv" ], "a100_table_fragments_reproduced": 4, "figure_sources": { "electronics_review_analysis.py": "0d795676299c5d37f98423a526eca8c64c8410d7f491a96e6cde83608395f662", "electronics_followup_figures.py": "850d1316f0a99e770f452706ecabc2eb78c34429f5f5b585b1c1de00d3e4bd87", "make_review_figures.py": "8c1b82ff74650b26993a62b0ad19ae4b4dd05929e213b8e811e62893d0ac3594" }, "stage": { "planned_slots": 144, "complete_blocks": 35, "excluded_slots": 4, "equal_case_actor_batch_mib": 3904.611111111111, "equal_case_whole_batch_mib": 7.458333333333333 }, "horizon": { "comparisons": 42, "agreements": 40, "paired_case_labels_agree": 4, "paired_case_denominator": 4, "caveat": "Historical and paired protocols are separate; no pooled accuracy estimate. Original 100-step panel: two extra excluded attempts; paired panel: three. Binary approval agreement does not resolve the type of an unsuitable outcome." }, "failure_counts": [ { "study": "Boundary", "eligible_invocations": 216, "completed": 156, "startup_budget_rejection": 48, "startup_allocation_oom": 3, "rollout_oom": 6, "weight_sync_oom": 3, "actor_update_oom": 0 }, { "study": "State release", "eligible_invocations": 36, "completed": 27, "startup_budget_rejection": 0, "startup_allocation_oom": 0, "rollout_oom": 0, "weight_sync_oom": 6, "actor_update_oom": 3 }, { "study": "Independent offload", "eligible_invocations": 144, "completed": 108, "startup_budget_rejection": 36, "startup_allocation_oom": 0, "rollout_oom": 0, "weight_sync_oom": 0, "actor_update_oom": 0 } ], "new_gpu_experiments": false, "reference_manuscript_commit": "e55d39258d334736243a2b09e2172eeec7d79013", "supplement_static_table_bodies_unchanged": 29, "supplement_generated_tables": { "stab:adaptation-true": { "rows_unchanged": 16, "constant_columns_moved_to_caption": {} }, "stab:adaptation-offload-true": { "rows_unchanged": 16, "constant_columns_moved_to_caption": {} }, "stab:adaptation-false": { "rows_unchanged": 2, "constant_columns_moved_to_caption": {} }, "stab:adaptation-offload-false": { "rows_unchanged": 2, "constant_columns_moved_to_caption": {} }, "stab:release-sensitivity": { "rows_unchanged": 6, "constant_columns_moved_to_caption": {} }, "stab:reservation-outcomes": { "rows_unchanged": 8, "constant_columns_moved_to_caption": {} }, "stab:reservation-predictions": { "rows_unchanged": 21, "constant_columns_moved_to_caption": {} }, "stab:timing-conditions": { "rows_unchanged": 8, "constant_columns_moved_to_caption": {} }, "stab:timing-work": { "rows_unchanged": 8, "constant_columns_moved_to_caption": {} }, "stab:timing-pairs": { "rows_unchanged": 6, "constant_columns_moved_to_caption": {} }, "stab:mi250x-slots": { "rows_unchanged": 5, "constant_columns_moved_to_caption": {} }, "stab:mi250x-transfer": { "rows_unchanged": 90, "constant_columns_moved_to_caption": {} }, "stab:mi250x-7b": { "rows_unchanged": 24, "constant_columns_moved_to_caption": {} }, "stab:mi250x-reservation-sweep": { "rows_unchanged": 16, "constant_columns_moved_to_caption": { "1": "c3", "2": "GRPO", "3": "lora", "5": "1" } }, "stab:mi250x-algorithm-adaptation": { "rows_unchanged": 12, "constant_columns_moved_to_caption": { "5": "1" } }, "stab:mi250x-horizon": { "rows_unchanged": 12, "constant_columns_moved_to_caption": { "2": "GRPO", "3": "lora" } } }, "all_main_figure_and_table_labels_cited": true, "reproduction_historical_pngs_match_manuscript": [ "standard_grpo_boundary.png", "review_instrumentation_batch.png" ], "mi250x_table_renderer_sha256": "fd18f9c6c4a9e205727a782b781f2115b0b5cc0f5b1763753eb8c1ba41f17b37", "figure1_clarification": { "label": "0/2/0 plus dash", "configuration": "reservation-m7-code_heavy_tail-off0-r60", "invalid_telemetry_seed": 453, "within_margin": 0, "above_margin": 2, "memory_failure": 0, "unresolved": 1, "measurements_and_classifications_unchanged": true } }