| |
| \begin{table}[h] |
| \caption{Per-field extraction metrics, summed across jurisdictions, for model \texttt{gemini/gemini-3.1-flash-lite}.} |
| \label{tab:per-field-gemini-gemini-3-1-flash-lite} |
| \centering\small |
| \begin{tabular}{@{}lrrrr@{}} |
| \toprule |
| Variable & Accuracy & Recall$_{\text{filled}}$ & Hallu. rate & $F_1$ \\ |
| \midrule |
| \texttt{court\_cost\_awarded\_nominal} & 85.5\% & 63.9\% & 4.1\% & 0.722 \\ |
| \texttt{defendant\_no1\_ISIC1\_industry\_category} & 50.7\% & 58.0\% & 65.9\% & 0.540 \\ |
| \texttt{defendants\_all\_count} & 75.1\% & 76.9\% & 90.5\% & 0.768 \\ |
| \texttt{dispute\_value\_nominal} & 56.2\% & 56.4\% & 44.0\% & 0.504 \\ |
| \texttt{legal\_subject\_judgement} & 3.6\% & 3.6\% & 83.3\% & 0.036 \\ |
| \texttt{party\_compensation\_awarded\_nominal} & 88.2\% & 71.4\% & 6.6\% & 0.727 \\ |
| \texttt{plaintiff\_loosing\_share} & 70.1\% & 71.3\% & 36.6\% & 0.727 \\ |
| \texttt{plaintiff\_no1\_ISIC1\_industry\_category} & 39.3\% & 54.1\% & 79.5\% & 0.429 \\ |
| \texttt{plaintiffs\_all\_count} & 87.9\% & 88.8\% & 100.0\% & 0.889 \\ |
| \texttt{trial\_end\_date} & 66.9\% & 67.6\% & 50.0\% & 0.680 \\ |
| \texttt{trial\_start\_date} & 52.4\% & 26.2\% & 9.7\% & 0.363 \\ |
| \bottomrule |
| \end{tabular} |
| \end{table} |
|
|
| |
| \begin{table}[h] |
| \caption{Per-field extraction metrics, summed across jurisdictions, for model \texttt{gpt-5.4-mini}.} |
| \label{tab:per-field-gpt-5-4-mini} |
| \centering\small |
| \begin{tabular}{@{}lrrrr@{}} |
| \toprule |
| Variable & Accuracy & Recall$_{\text{filled}}$ & Hallu. rate & $F_1$ \\ |
| \midrule |
| \texttt{court\_cost\_awarded\_nominal} & 83.2\% & 65.5\% & 8.3\% & 0.690 \\ |
| \texttt{defendant\_no1\_ISIC1\_industry\_category} & 52.7\% & 64.7\% & 74.7\% & 0.578 \\ |
| \texttt{defendants\_all\_count} & 73.0\% & 73.8\% & 56.1\% & 0.769 \\ |
| \texttt{dispute\_value\_nominal} & 51.2\% & 57.1\% & 53.8\% & 0.486 \\ |
| \texttt{legal\_subject\_judgement} & 4.9\% & 4.9\% & 100.0\% & 0.049 \\ |
| \texttt{party\_compensation\_awarded\_nominal} & 81.9\% & 67.3\% & 13.6\% & 0.611 \\ |
| \texttt{plaintiff\_loosing\_share} & 66.3\% & 69.9\% & 55.2\% & 0.692 \\ |
| \texttt{plaintiff\_no1\_ISIC1\_industry\_category} & 38.7\% & 53.9\% & 80.5\% & 0.426 \\ |
| \texttt{plaintiffs\_all\_count} & 84.9\% & 85.4\% & 71.4\% & 0.875 \\ |
| \texttt{trial\_end\_date} & 66.5\% & 66.9\% & 44.1\% & 0.690 \\ |
| \texttt{trial\_start\_date} & 40.4\% & 41.6\% & 61.3\% & 0.364 \\ |
| \bottomrule |
| \end{tabular} |
| \end{table} |
|
|
| |
| \begin{table}[h] |
| \caption{Per-field extraction metrics, summed across jurisdictions, for model \texttt{harvey}.} |
| \label{tab:per-field-harvey} |
| \centering\small |
| \begin{tabular}{@{}lrrrr@{}} |
| \toprule |
| Variable & Accuracy & Recall$_{\text{filled}}$ & Hallu. rate & $F_1$ \\ |
| \midrule |
| \texttt{court\_cost\_awarded\_nominal} & 85.6\% & 57.8\% & 1.9\% & 0.689 \\ |
| \texttt{defendant\_no1\_ISIC1\_industry\_category} & 53.6\% & 49.3\% & 37.3\% & 0.523 \\ |
| \texttt{defendants\_all\_count} & 71.0\% & 71.6\% & 48.6\% & 0.777 \\ |
| \texttt{dispute\_value\_nominal} & 58.5\% & 47.0\% & 32.9\% & 0.463 \\ |
| \texttt{legal\_subject\_judgement} & 3.9\% & 3.9\% & 83.3\% & 0.043 \\ |
| \texttt{party\_compensation\_awarded\_nominal} & 89.5\% & 66.9\% & 4.7\% & 0.717 \\ |
| \texttt{plaintiff\_loosing\_share} & 70.8\% & 71.4\% & 33.3\% & 0.740 \\ |
| \texttt{plaintiff\_no1\_ISIC1\_industry\_category} & 56.7\% & 41.8\% & 25.4\% & 0.452 \\ |
| \texttt{plaintiffs\_all\_count} & 74.4\% & 74.9\% & 83.3\% & 0.812 \\ |
| \texttt{trial\_end\_date} & 66.0\% & 65.0\% & 12.3\% & 0.761 \\ |
| \texttt{trial\_start\_date} & 48.5\% & 13.3\% & 4.4\% & 0.216 \\ |
| \bottomrule |
| \end{tabular} |
| \end{table} |
|
|
| |
| \begin{table}[h] |
| \caption{Per-field extraction metrics, summed across jurisdictions, for model \texttt{harvey-2}.} |
| \label{tab:per-field-harvey-2} |
| \centering\small |
| \begin{tabular}{@{}lrrrr@{}} |
| \toprule |
| Variable & Accuracy & Recall$_{\text{filled}}$ & Hallu. rate & $F_1$ \\ |
| \midrule |
| \texttt{court\_cost\_awarded\_nominal} & 86.1\% & 57.0\% & 0.8\% & 0.679 \\ |
| \texttt{defendant\_no1\_ISIC1\_industry\_category} & 46.0\% & 33.6\% & 27.4\% & 0.406 \\ |
| \texttt{defendants\_all\_count} & 70.9\% & 71.8\% & 62.2\% & 0.777 \\ |
| \texttt{dispute\_value\_nominal} & 59.3\% & 33.1\% & 20.4\% & 0.387 \\ |
| \texttt{legal\_subject\_judgement} & 1.1\% & 0.7\% & 0.0\% & 0.009 \\ |
| \texttt{party\_compensation\_awarded\_nominal} & 88.4\% & 63.1\% & 4.9\% & 0.689 \\ |
| \texttt{plaintiff\_loosing\_share} & 71.8\% & 69.7\% & 15.9\% & 0.767 \\ |
| \texttt{plaintiff\_no1\_ISIC1\_industry\_category} & 54.2\% & 31.3\% & 18.8\% & 0.379 \\ |
| \texttt{plaintiffs\_all\_count} & 77.2\% & 77.6\% & 66.7\% & 0.832 \\ |
| \texttt{trial\_end\_date} & 65.8\% & 65.0\% & 14.0\% & 0.740 \\ |
| \texttt{trial\_start\_date} & 50.9\% & 15.1\% & 3.3\% & 0.247 \\ |
| \bottomrule |
| \end{tabular} |
| \end{table} |
|
|
| |
| \begin{table}[h] |
| \caption{Per-field extraction metrics, summed across jurisdictions, for model \texttt{legora-1}.} |
| \label{tab:per-field-legora-1} |
| \centering\small |
| \begin{tabular}{@{}lrrrr@{}} |
| \toprule |
| Variable & Accuracy & Recall$_{\text{filled}}$ & Hallu. rate & $F_1$ \\ |
| \midrule |
| \texttt{court\_cost\_awarded\_nominal} & 92.0\% & 70.1\% & 0.9\% & 0.806 \\ |
| \texttt{defendant\_no1\_ISIC1\_industry\_category} & 62.2\% & 55.5\% & 22.5\% & 0.621 \\ |
| \texttt{defendants\_all\_count} & 66.5\% & 66.6\% & 37.1\% & 0.750 \\ |
| \texttt{dispute\_value\_nominal} & 65.0\% & 34.7\% & 12.3\% & 0.447 \\ |
| \texttt{legal\_subject\_judgement} & 2.2\% & 1.8\% & 16.7\% & 0.023 \\ |
| \texttt{party\_compensation\_awarded\_nominal} & 92.7\% & 79.1\% & 4.2\% & 0.797 \\ |
| \texttt{plaintiff\_loosing\_share} & 71.8\% & 69.3\% & 11.4\% & 0.784 \\ |
| \texttt{plaintiff\_no1\_ISIC1\_industry\_category} & 58.0\% & 36.8\% & 16.9\% & 0.438 \\ |
| \texttt{plaintiffs\_all\_count} & 70.5\% & 70.5\% & 28.6\% & 0.807 \\ |
| \texttt{trial\_end\_date} & 78.1\% & 77.8\% & 13.5\% & 0.825 \\ |
| \texttt{trial\_start\_date} & 56.0\% & 27.2\% & 3.6\% & 0.405 \\ |
| \bottomrule |
| \end{tabular} |
| \end{table} |
|
|
| |
| \begin{table}[h] |
| \caption{Per-field extraction metrics, summed across jurisdictions, for model \texttt{legora-2}.} |
| \label{tab:per-field-legora-2} |
| \centering\small |
| \begin{tabular}{@{}lrrrr@{}} |
| \toprule |
| Variable & Accuracy & Recall$_{\text{filled}}$ & Hallu. rate & $F_1$ \\ |
| \midrule |
| \texttt{court\_cost\_awarded\_nominal} & 92.1\% & 70.4\% & 0.7\% & 0.808 \\ |
| \texttt{defendant\_no1\_ISIC1\_industry\_category} & 57.1\% & 50.7\% & 28.5\% & 0.570 \\ |
| \texttt{defendants\_all\_count} & 66.2\% & 65.8\% & 18.4\% & 0.755 \\ |
| \texttt{dispute\_value\_nominal} & 66.6\% & 39.7\% & 12.9\% & 0.488 \\ |
| \texttt{legal\_subject\_judgement} & 2.6\% & 2.2\% & 16.7\% & 0.028 \\ |
| \texttt{party\_compensation\_awarded\_nominal} & 92.5\% & 79.7\% & 4.5\% & 0.797 \\ |
| \texttt{plaintiff\_loosing\_share} & 72.5\% & 70.8\% & 16.3\% & 0.775 \\ |
| \texttt{plaintiff\_no1\_ISIC1\_industry\_category} & 59.2\% & 36.9\% & 14.8\% & 0.444 \\ |
| \texttt{plaintiffs\_all\_count} & 72.3\% & 72.4\% & 35.7\% & 0.816 \\ |
| \texttt{trial\_end\_date} & 77.4\% & 77.0\% & 13.2\% & 0.822 \\ |
| \texttt{trial\_start\_date} & 56.1\% & 27.2\% & 3.6\% & 0.406 \\ |
| \bottomrule |
| \end{tabular} |
| \end{table} |
|
|