"""Render the `Quantitative Results` LaTeX section. Reads `data/analysis/per_country_per_column.csv` (produced by `legex-analysis`), restricts it to the twelve evaluated jurisdictions and the fourteen evaluated fields, then prints the section preamble plus the headline table that compares the three systems on Acc / Recall / Hallucination / F1, both over all fields and over the four-field cost block. """ import argparse import csv import logging import sys from collections import defaultdict from pathlib import Path log = logging.getLogger(__name__) # Jurisdictions that survive the round-2 PDF audit (TW/BR/HK/IN excluded # because their source PDFs were incomplete; BE/NP/RS excluded because # inference was intentionally skipped for them). EVALUATED_COUNTRIES: tuple[str, ...] = ( "am", "au", "ch", "de", "es", "fr", "ge", "nz", "ph", "sg", "uk", "us", ) H2H_COUNTRIES = EVALUATED_COUNTRIES # backwards-compat alias EVAL_FIELDS: tuple[str, ...] = ( "legal_subject_judgement", "trial_start_date", "trial_end_date", "dispute_value_nominal", "plaintiff_loosing_share", "court_cost_awarded_nominal", "party_compensation_awarded_nominal", "plaintiffs_all_count", "defendants_all_count", "plaintiff_no1_ISIC1_industry_category", "defendant_no1_ISIC1_industry_category", ) COST_BLOCK: tuple[str, ...] = ( "dispute_value_nominal", "plaintiff_loosing_share", "court_cost_awarded_nominal", "party_compensation_awarded_nominal", ) # (system slug as written by legex-analysis, LaTeX label). Order = row order # in the headline table. SYSTEMS: tuple[tuple[str, str], ...] = ( ("gemini", r"\texttt{gemini-3.1-flash-lite}"), ("gpt", r"\texttt{gpt-5.4-mini} "), ("harvey", r"\textsc{Harvey} "), ) _BUCKETS = ("tp", "mismatch", "missed", "hallucinated", "tn") def _empty() -> dict[str, int]: return {k: 0 for k in _BUCKETS} def _metrics(c: dict[str, int]) -> dict[str, float]: tp, mism, miss, hallu, tn = c["tp"], c["mismatch"], c["missed"], c["hallucinated"], c["tn"] total = tp + mism + miss + hallu + tn filled_gold = tp + mism + miss empty_gold = hallu + tn p_denom = tp + mism + hallu p = tp / p_denom if p_denom else 0.0 r = tp / filled_gold if filled_gold else 0.0 f1 = 2 * p * r / (p + r) if (p + r) else 0.0 return { "accuracy": (tp + tn) / total if total else 0.0, "recall_when_filled": r, "hallucination_rate": hallu / empty_gold if empty_gold else 0.0, "f1": f1, } def _aggregate( csv_path: Path, ) -> dict[str, dict[str, dict[str, int]]]: """{ model -> { 'all' | 'cost' -> bucket counter } }.""" out: dict[str, dict[str, dict[str, int]]] = { m: {"all": _empty(), "cost": _empty()} for m, _ in SYSTEMS } h2h = set(H2H_COUNTRIES) eval_fields = set(EVAL_FIELDS) cost_fields = set(COST_BLOCK) models = {m for m, _ in SYSTEMS} with open(csv_path, encoding="utf-8", newline="") as f: for row in csv.DictReader(f): if row["country"] not in h2h or row["model"] not in models: continue col = row["column"] if col not in eval_fields: continue counts = {k: int(row[k]) for k in _BUCKETS} for k in _BUCKETS: out[row["model"]]["all"][k] += counts[k] if col in cost_fields: for k in _BUCKETS: out[row["model"]]["cost"][k] += counts[k] return out def _fmt_pct(v: float) -> str: return f"{v * 100:.1f}\\%" def _fmt_f1(v: float) -> str: return f"{v:.3f}" def _bold_best(values: list[float], formatter, higher_is_better: bool = True) -> list[str]: best = max(values) if higher_is_better else min(values) return [ rf"\textbf{{{formatter(v)}}}" if v == best else formatter(v) for v in values ] def render_section(agg: dict[str, dict[str, dict[str, int]]]) -> str: lines: list[str] = [] lines.append(r"% Auto-generated by legex-quant-results — do not edit by hand.") lines.append(r"\section{Quantitative Results}") lines.append("") lines.append( r"We score the three systems against the human coded dataset: a commercial" ) lines.append( r"review-table product by \textsc{Harvey} and two schema-constrained LLM" ) lines.append( r"pipelines (\texttt{gpt-5.4-mini} and \texttt{gemini-3.1-flash-lite})." ) lines.append( r"Since the dataset contains missing fields, e.g.\ where a court judgement" ) lines.append( r"does not issue costs we evaluate our systems against two metrics:" ) lines.append(r"\begin{itemize}") lines.append( r" \item \textbf{Accuracy when filled}: how often the system extracts the" r" correct value given that the human expert has classified it." ) lines.append( r" \item \textbf{Hallucination rate}: how often the system extracts a" r" value given that the human expert has left the field empty." ) lines.append(r"\end{itemize}") lines.append("") metrics_all = {m: _metrics(agg[m]["all"]) for m, _ in SYSTEMS} metrics_cost = {m: _metrics(agg[m]["cost"]) for m, _ in SYSTEMS} def _p(model: str, panel: str, key: str) -> str: src = metrics_all if panel == "all" else metrics_cost return f"{src[model][key] * 100:.1f}" lines.append( r"\Cref{tab:overall} shows the same trade-off on both panels: the two" r" LLM pipelines are more eager extractors, while \textsc{Harvey} is" r" more conservative. Across all " + str(len(EVAL_FIELDS)) + r" evaluated" r" fields \texttt{gpt-5.4-mini} and \texttt{gemini-3.1-flash-lite}" r" reach accuracy when filled of " + _p("gpt", "all", "recall_when_filled") + r"\,\% and " + _p("gemini", "all", "recall_when_filled") + r"\,\%, alongside \textsc{Harvey} at " + _p("harvey", "all", "recall_when_filled") + r"\,\%, but the LLM" r" pipelines pay for that recall with hallucination rates of " + _p("gpt", "all", "hallucination_rate") + r"\,\% and " + _p("gemini", "all", "hallucination_rate") + r"\,\% against \textsc{Harvey}'s " + _p("harvey", "all", "hallucination_rate") + r"\,\%." r" Narrowing to the four cost-block variables, the three systems" r" converge on accuracy (" + _p("harvey", "cost", "recall_when_filled") + r"--" + _p("gemini", "cost", "recall_when_filled") + r"\,\%), and the" r" hallucination rates land at " + _p("gemini", "cost", "hallucination_rate") + r"\,\% (Gemini), " + _p("harvey", "cost", "hallucination_rate") + r"\,\% (Harvey), and " + _p("gpt", "cost", "hallucination_rate") + r"\,\% (GPT)." r" No single system dominates: the LLM pipelines are preferable when" r" the downstream task tolerates noisy extractions in exchange for" r" coverage, whereas \textsc{Harvey} is preferable when emitted values" r" must be trusted on the non-cost variables." ) lines.append("") acc_all = [metrics_all[m]["recall_when_filled"] for m, _ in SYSTEMS] hal_all = [metrics_all[m]["hallucination_rate"] for m, _ in SYSTEMS] acc_cost = [metrics_cost[m]["recall_when_filled"] for m, _ in SYSTEMS] hal_cost = [metrics_cost[m]["hallucination_rate"] for m, _ in SYSTEMS] acc_all_s = _bold_best(acc_all, _fmt_pct, True) hal_all_s = _bold_best(hal_all, _fmt_pct, False) acc_cost_s = _bold_best(acc_cost, _fmt_pct, True) hal_cost_s = _bold_best(hal_cost, _fmt_pct, False) lines.append(r"\begin{table}[h]") lines.append( r"\caption{Overall metrics on the " + str(len(EVALUATED_COUNTRIES)) + r" head-to-head jurisdictions, golden-set rows with no" r" expert-filled field excluded." r" \emph{Acc.\ when filled} is the share of expert-filled cells the" r" system extracts correctly; \emph{Hallu.\ rate} is the share of" r" expert-empty cells where the system invented a value." r" The right block restricts the same metrics to the four cost-block" r" variables. Best per column in \textbf{bold} (lower is better for" r" Hallu.\ rate)." r"}" ) lines.append(r"\label{tab:overall}") lines.append(r"\centering\small") lines.append(r"\begin{tabular}{@{}lrr@{\hskip 12pt}rr@{}}") lines.append(r"\toprule") lines.append( r" & \multicolumn{2}{c}{All " + str(len(EVAL_FIELDS)) + r" evaluated fields} & \multicolumn{2}{c}{Cost block (" + str(len(COST_BLOCK)) + r" fields)} \\" ) lines.append(r"\cmidrule(lr){2-3}\cmidrule(l){4-5}") lines.append( r"System & Acc.\ when filled & Hallu.\ rate" r" & Acc.\ when filled & Hallu.\ rate \\" ) lines.append(r"\midrule") for i, (_, label) in enumerate(SYSTEMS): lines.append( f"{label} & {acc_all_s[i]} & {hal_all_s[i]}" f" & {acc_cost_s[i]} & {hal_cost_s[i]} \\\\" ) lines.append(r"\bottomrule") lines.append(r"\end{tabular}") lines.append(r"\end{table}") lines.append("") return "\n".join(lines) def _print_console_summary(agg: dict[str, dict[str, dict[str, int]]]) -> None: """Quick human-readable echo so the user sees the numbers in the terminal too.""" print(f"{'system':<28} {'set':<5} {'Acc.filled':>11} {'Hallu':>6}") for model, _ in SYSTEMS: for tag in ("all", "cost"): m = _metrics(agg[model][tag]) print( f"{model:<28} {tag:<5} " f"{m['recall_when_filled']:>11.1%} {m['hallucination_rate']:>6.1%}" ) def main() -> None: logging.basicConfig( level=logging.INFO, format="%(asctime)s [%(levelname)s] %(message)s", handlers=[logging.StreamHandler(sys.stderr)], ) parser = argparse.ArgumentParser( prog="legex-quant-results", description="Render the Quantitative Results section + headline table.", ) parser.add_argument( "--input", type=Path, default=Path("data/analysis/per_country_per_column.csv"), help="per_country_per_column.csv produced by legex-analysis.", ) parser.add_argument( "--out", type=Path, default=Path("data/analysis/quant_results.tex"), help="Where to write the rendered LaTeX section.", ) args = parser.parse_args() if not args.input.exists(): raise SystemExit( f"{args.input} not found — run `legex-analysis` first to generate it." ) agg = _aggregate(args.input) tex = render_section(agg) args.out.parent.mkdir(parents=True, exist_ok=True) args.out.write_text(tex, encoding="utf-8") log.info(f"wrote {args.out}") _print_console_summary(agg) if __name__ == "__main__": main()