"""Refusal detection, value resolution, and the cleaning provenance format.""" import json import pytest from legex.evaluation.comparison import classify_cell, normalise, refusal_reason, resolve from legex.evaluation.cleaning import format_comment, format_original_input REFUSALS = [ ("The document does not state a specific date. N/A", "trial_start_date"), ("None (the judgment does not contain a party designation block)", "plaintiffs_all_count"), ("Based on my review, I cannot determine the amount in dispute.", "dispute_value_nominal"), ("N/A", "trial_end_date"), ("not specified", "trial_start_date"), ] KEEPERS = [ ("nonpecuniary", "dispute_value_nominal"), ("no_allocation_possible", "plaintiff_no1_ISIC1_industry_category"), ("Employment_Law/Discrimination", "legal_subject_judgement"), ("2024-01-21", "trial_end_date"), ("25400000", "dispute_value_nominal"), ("1", "plaintiffs_all_count"), ("1.0", "plaintiff_loosing_share"), # already a clean float → kept as-is ("0.86", "plaintiff_loosing_share"), ("l_financial_insurance", "defendant_no1_ISIC1_industry_category"), ] # (raw, column, expected canonical) — a single value recoverable after stripping # formatting noise / citations / backticks (never a digit scraped from prose). RECOVERABLE = [ ("20'000", "court_cost_awarded_nominal", "20000"), ("1 000 000", "dispute_value_nominal", "1000000"), ("2024/01/21", "trial_end_date", "2024-01-21"), ("1\n```", "plaintiffs_all_count", "1"), ("[1]\n\n2025-08-19", "trial_end_date", "2025-08-19"), ("1950\n[1] [2]", "court_cost_awarded_nominal", "1950"), # 2026-08 Harvey run: standalone English prose dates despite YYYY-MM-DD rule. ("March 19, 2026", "trial_end_date", "2026-03-19"), ("30 September 2020", "trial_end_date", "2020-09-30"), # 2026-08 Harvey run: ISIC codes with the sector letter capitalised. ("L_financial_insurance", "defendant_no1_ISIC1_industry_category", "l_financial_insurance"), ("No_allocation_possible", "plaintiff_no1_ISIC1_industry_category", "no_allocation_possible"), # Currency-decorated clean amounts. ("CHF 9'728'400.00", "dispute_value_nominal", "9728400"), ("30'000.--", "dispute_value_nominal", "30000"), ("6'500 fr.", "court_cost_awarded_nominal", "6500"), ("22.201,76 EUR", "dispute_value_nominal", "22201.76"), ] # Prose (has letters) → never auto-recovered, even with a number present → review. PROSE_TO_REVIEW = [ ("1.0\n\nThe complaint was declared inadmissible.", "plaintiff_loosing_share"), ("The operative part imposes court costs of 800 Swiss Francs.[1]\n\n800", "court_cost_awarded_nominal"), ("Greer (No. 19-8709): 1.0\n\nGary (No. 20-444): 1.0", "plaintiff_loosing_share"), # A number with a parenthetical qualifier is still prose — a human decides. ("1 (total plaintiffs/claimants/appellants)", "plaintiffs_all_count"), ] # Grouped integers without a decimal part: thousands- vs decimal-separator is # ambiguous ('5.000 €' = 5000 EU or 5.0 US) → review, never auto-recovered. AMBIGUOUS_AMOUNTS_TO_REVIEW = [ ("5.000 €", "dispute_value_nominal"), ("538,183 euro", "dispute_value_nominal"), ] @pytest.mark.parametrize("text,col", REFUSALS) def test_refusals_go_to_review(text, col): status, _, reason = resolve(text, col) assert status == "review" and reason @pytest.mark.parametrize("text,col", KEEPERS) def test_valid_values_kept(text, col): status, value, _ = resolve(text, col) assert status == "valid" and value == text @pytest.mark.parametrize("text,col,canon", RECOVERABLE) def test_recoverable_values_canonicalised(text, col, canon): status, value, _ = resolve(text, col) assert status == "recovered" and value == canon # Formatting-only recoveries the scorer already parses identically → must be score-neutral. # (Noise-stripped dates like "[1]\n\n2025-08-19" are intentional corrections, not neutral.) NEUTRAL_RECOVERABLE = [ ("20'000", "court_cost_awarded_nominal", "20000"), ("1 000 000", "dispute_value_nominal", "1000000"), ("2024/01/21", "trial_end_date", "2024-01-21"), ("1\n```", "plaintiffs_all_count", "1"), ("1950\n[1] [2]", "court_cost_awarded_nominal", "1950"), ] @pytest.mark.parametrize("text,col,canon", NEUTRAL_RECOVERABLE) def test_recovery_is_score_neutral(text, col, canon): for gold in ("", canon, "999", "2024-01-21"): assert classify_cell(gold, normalise(text), col) == classify_cell(gold, canon, col) @pytest.mark.parametrize("text,col", PROSE_TO_REVIEW) def test_prose_with_number_goes_to_review_not_garbage(text, col): # Never scrape a number out of prose into the data — a human decides. status, _, _ = resolve(text, col) assert status == "review" @pytest.mark.parametrize("text,col", AMBIGUOUS_AMOUNTS_TO_REVIEW) def test_ambiguous_grouped_amounts_go_to_review(text, col): status, _, _ = resolve(text, col) assert status == "review" def test_prose_without_value_or_marker_still_reviewed(): status, _, reason = resolve( "Based on the decision, the respondent substantially prevailed on the merits.", "plaintiff_loosing_share", ) assert status == "review" and reason == "no recoverable value" def test_normalise_is_pure(): assert normalise("The document does not state a date. N/A") != "" assert refusal_reason("nonpecuniary", "dispute_value_nominal") is None def test_provenance_format(): changes = { "trial_start_date": ("Not specified ", ""), "court_cost_awarded_nominal": ("20'000", "20000"), } assert format_comment(changes) == ( "The trial_start_date was sanitized from 'Not specified ' to 'empty (removed)'. " "The court_cost_awarded_nominal was sanitized from '20'000' to '20000'." ) assert json.loads(format_original_input(changes)) == { "trial_start_date": "Not specified ", "court_cost_awarded_nominal": "20'000", } assert format_comment({}) is None assert format_original_input({}) == "{}"