{ "metadata": { "version": "1.0", "created": "2025-12-16", "description": "Comprehensive dataset of world language families and evolution" }, "proto_world": { "note": "Hypothetical common ancestor - not scientifically established", "estimated_date": "50000-100000 BCE", "status": "hypothetical" }, "language_families": [ { "id": "japonic", "name": "Japonic", "alternative_names": [], "proto_language": { "name": "Proto-Japonic", "estimated_date_bce": 500, "date_range_bce": [ 700, 300 ], "date_uncertainty": "medium", "homeland": { "region": "Korean Peninsula", "coordinates": [ 37.0, 127.0 ], "alternative_theories": [ "Southern China" ] } }, "classification_status": "established", "speakers": 128000000, "number_of_languages": 12, "geographic_distribution": [ "Japan" ], "earliest_attestation": { "language": "Old Japanese", "date_bce": -700, "writing_system": "Man'y\u014dgana" }, "branches": [ { "id": "japanese", "name": "Japanese" }, { "id": "ryukyuan", "name": "Ryukyuan" } ], "controversies": [], "proposed_relationships": [ { "hypothesis_name": "Japonic-Koreanic", "related_families": [ "korean" ], "status": "controversial", "evidence_level": "moderate" } ] }, { "id": "mongolic", "name": "Mongolic", "alternative_names": [], "proto_language": { "name": "Proto-Mongolic", "estimated_date_bce": -750, "date_range_bce": [ -500, -1000 ], "date_uncertainty": "medium", "homeland": { "region": "Eastern Mongolia", "coordinates": [ 48.0, 115.0 ], "alternative_theories": [] } }, "classification_status": "established", "speakers": 6000000, "number_of_languages": 14, "geographic_distribution": [ "East Asia", "Central Asia" ], "earliest_attestation": { "language": "Middle Mongol", "date_bce": -1200, "writing_system": "Mongolian script" }, "branches": [ { "id": "eastern-mongolic", "name": "Eastern Mongolic" }, { "id": "western-mongolic", "name": "Western Mongolic" } ], "controversies": [], "proposed_relationships": [ { "hypothesis_name": "Altaic", "related_families": [ "turkic", "tungusic", "koreanic", "japonic" ], "status": "rejected", "evidence_level": "weak" } ] }, { "id": "tungusic", "name": "Tungusic", "alternative_names": [], "proto_language": { "name": "Proto-Tungusic", "estimated_date_bce": 0, "date_range_bce": [ 500, -500 ], "date_uncertainty": "high", "homeland": { "region": "Manchuria", "coordinates": [ 45.0, 125.0 ], "alternative_theories": [] } }, "classification_status": "established", "speakers": 100000, "number_of_languages": 12, "geographic_distribution": [ "Siberia", "Manchuria" ], "earliest_attestation": { "language": "Jurchen", "date_bce": -1119, "writing_system": "Jurchen script" }, "branches": [ { "id": "northern-tungusic", "name": "Northern Tungusic" }, { "id": "southern-tungusic", "name": "Southern Tungusic" } ], "controversies": [], "proposed_relationships": [ { "hypothesis_name": "Altaic", "related_families": [ "turkic", "mongolic", "koreanic", "japonic" ], "status": "rejected", "evidence_level": "weak" } ] }, { "id": "kartvelian", "name": "Kartvelian", "alternative_names": [], "proto_language": { "name": "Proto-Kartvelian", "estimated_date_bce": 2500, "date_range_bce": [ 3000, 2000 ], "date_uncertainty": "medium", "homeland": { "region": "South Caucasus", "coordinates": [ 42.0, 44.0 ], "alternative_theories": [] } }, "classification_status": "established", "speakers": 5000000, "number_of_languages": 4, "geographic_distribution": [ "Georgia" ], "earliest_attestation": { "language": "Old Georgian", "date_bce": -430, "writing_system": "Georgian script" }, "branches": [ { "id": "svan", "name": "Svan" }, { "id": "georgian-zan", "name": "Georgian-Zan" } ], "controversies": [], "proposed_relationships": [] }, { "id": "hmong-mien", "name": "Hmong-Mien", "alternative_names": [ "Miao-Yao" ], "proto_language": { "name": "Proto-Hmong-Mien", "estimated_date_bce": 2000, "date_range_bce": [ 2500, 1500 ], "date_uncertainty": "medium", "homeland": { "region": "Southern China", "coordinates": [ 28.0, 110.0 ], "alternative_theories": [] } }, "classification_status": "established", "speakers": 10000000, "number_of_languages": 35, "geographic_distribution": [ "Southern China", "Southeast Asia" ], "earliest_attestation": null, "branches": [ { "id": "hmongic", "name": "Hmongic" }, { "id": "mienic", "name": "Mienic" } ], "controversies": [], "proposed_relationships": [ { "hypothesis_name": "Austric", "related_families": [ "austronesian", "austroasiatic", "kra-dai" ], "status": "controversial", "evidence_level": "weak" } ] }, { "id": "pama-nyungan", "name": "Pama-Nyungan", "alternative_names": [], "proto_language": { "name": "Proto-Pama-Nyungan", "estimated_date_bce": 5500, "date_range_bce": [ 6000, 5000 ], "date_uncertainty": "high", "homeland": { "region": "Northeastern Australia", "coordinates": [ -15.0, 145.0 ], "alternative_theories": [] } }, "classification_status": "established", "speakers": 50000, "number_of_languages": 300, "geographic_distribution": [ "Australia" ], "earliest_attestation": null, "branches": [], "controversies": [], "proposed_relationships": [] }, { "id": "indo-european", "name": "Indo-European", "alternative_names": [], "proto_language": { "name": "Proto-Indo-European", "estimated_date_bce": 4500, "date_range_bce": [ 6400, 3500 ], "date_uncertainty": "high", "homeland": { "region": "Pontic-Caspian steppe", "coordinates": [ 48.0, 40.0 ], "alternative_theories": [ "Anatolian hypothesis" ] } }, "classification_status": "established", "speakers": 3400000000, "number_of_languages": 445, "geographic_distribution": [ "Europe", "South Asia", "Americas", "Oceania" ], "earliest_attestation": { "language": "Hittite", "date_bce": 1700, "writing_system": "Cuneiform" }, "branches": [ { "id": "anatolian", "name": "Anatolian", "estimated_divergence_bce": 3500 }, { "id": "indo-iranian", "name": "Indo-Iranian", "estimated_divergence_bce": 2200 }, { "id": "hellenic", "name": "Hellenic", "estimated_divergence_bce": 2500 }, { "id": "italic", "name": "Italic", "estimated_divergence_bce": 3000 }, { "id": "celtic", "name": "Celtic", "estimated_divergence_bce": 3000 }, { "id": "germanic", "name": "Germanic", "estimated_divergence_bce": 3300 }, { "id": "balto-slavic", "name": "Balto-Slavic", "estimated_divergence_bce": 2800 }, { "id": "armenian", "name": "Armenian", "estimated_divergence_bce": 2800 }, { "id": "albanian", "name": "Albanian", "estimated_divergence_bce": 1000 }, { "id": "tocharian", "name": "Tocharian", "estimated_divergence_bce": 3700 } ], "controversies": [ { "topic": "Indo-Hittite hypothesis", "positions": [ "Anatolian as first branch", "Anatolian as sister to PIE" ], "status": "ongoing" } ], "proposed_relationships": [ { "hypothesis_name": "Indo-Uralic", "related_families": [ "uralic" ], "status": "controversial", "evidence_level": "moderate" } ] }, { "id": "sino-tibetan", "name": "Sino-Tibetan", "alternative_names": [ "Trans-Himalayan" ], "proto_language": { "name": "Proto-Sino-Tibetan", "estimated_date_bce": 5000, "date_range_bce": [ 6000, 4000 ], "date_uncertainty": "high", "homeland": { "region": "Yellow River valley, North China", "coordinates": [ 34.9, 108.9 ], "alternative_theories": [ "Southwest China" ] } }, "classification_status": "established", "speakers": 1400000000, "number_of_languages": 460, "geographic_distribution": [ "East Asia", "Southeast Asia", "South Asia" ], "earliest_attestation": { "language": "Old Chinese", "date_bce": 1250, "writing_system": "Oracle bone script" }, "branches": [ { "id": "sinitic", "name": "Sinitic" }, { "id": "tibeto-burman", "name": "Tibeto-Burman" } ], "controversies": [ { "topic": "Unity of Sino-Tibetan", "positions": [ "Valid family", "Not a valid family" ], "status": "ongoing" } ], "proposed_relationships": [] }, { "id": "afro-asiatic", "name": "Afro-Asiatic", "alternative_names": [], "proto_language": { "name": "Proto-Afro-Asiatic", "estimated_date_bce": 12000, "date_range_bce": [ 15000, 10000 ], "date_uncertainty": "high", "homeland": { "region": "Horn of Africa", "coordinates": [ 10.0, 49.0 ], "alternative_theories": [ "North Africa" ] } }, "classification_status": "established", "speakers": 495000000, "number_of_languages": 375, "geographic_distribution": [ "North Africa", "Horn of Africa", "West Asia" ], "earliest_attestation": { "language": "Ancient Egyptian", "date_bce": 3300, "writing_system": "Hieroglyphics" }, "branches": [ { "id": "semitic", "name": "Semitic" }, { "id": "berber", "name": "Berber" }, { "id": "chadic", "name": "Chadic" }, { "id": "cushitic", "name": "Cushitic" }, { "id": "omotic", "name": "Omotic" }, { "id": "egyptian", "name": "Egyptian" } ], "controversies": [ { "topic": "Omotic branch membership", "positions": [ "Omotic is a branch of Afro-Asiatic", "Omotic is a separate family" ], "status": "ongoing" } ], "proposed_relationships": [] }, { "id": "niger-congo", "name": "Niger-Congo", "alternative_names": [], "proto_language": { "name": "Proto-Niger-Congo", "estimated_date_bce": 12000, "date_range_bce": [ 15000, 10000 ], "date_uncertainty": "high", "homeland": { "region": "West Africa", "coordinates": [ 10.0, 0.0 ], "alternative_theories": [] } }, "classification_status": "established", "speakers": 700000000, "number_of_languages": 1500, "geographic_distribution": [ "Sub-Saharan Africa" ], "earliest_attestation": null, "branches": [ { "id": "mande", "name": "Mande" }, { "id": "atlantic", "name": "Atlantic" }, { "id": "ijoid", "name": "Ijoid" }, { "id": "kru", "name": "Kru" }, { "id": "gur", "name": "Gur" }, { "id": "adamawa-ubangi", "name": "Adamawa-Ubangi" }, { "id": "kwa", "name": "Kwa" }, { "id": "benue-congo", "name": "Benue-Congo" }, { "id": "kordofanian", "name": "Kordofanian" } ], "controversies": [ { "topic": "Unity of Niger-Congo", "positions": [ "Valid family", "Not a valid family" ], "status": "ongoing" } ], "proposed_relationships": [] }, { "id": "austronesian", "name": "Austronesian", "alternative_names": [], "proto_language": { "name": "Proto-Austronesian", "estimated_date_bce": 3500, "date_range_bce": [ 4000, 3000 ], "date_uncertainty": "medium", "homeland": { "region": "Taiwan", "coordinates": [ 23.5, 121.0 ], "alternative_theories": [] } }, "classification_status": "established", "speakers": 386000000, "number_of_languages": 1200, "geographic_distribution": [ "Maritime Southeast Asia", "Madagascar", "Pacific Islands" ], "earliest_attestation": null, "branches": [ { "id": "formosan", "name": "Formosan" }, { "id": "malayo-polynesian", "name": "Malayo-Polynesian" } ], "controversies": [], "proposed_relationships": [ { "hypothesis_name": "Austro-Tai", "related_families": [ "kra-dai" ], "status": "controversial", "evidence_level": "moderate" } ] }, { "id": "dravidian", "name": "Dravidian", "alternative_names": [], "proto_language": { "name": "Proto-Dravidian", "estimated_date_bce": 3500, "date_range_bce": [ 4500, 2500 ], "date_uncertainty": "medium", "homeland": { "region": "South India", "coordinates": [ 13.0, 77.0 ], "alternative_theories": [ "Indus Valley" ] } }, "classification_status": "established", "speakers": 250000000, "number_of_languages": 80, "geographic_distribution": [ "South India", "Sri Lanka", "Pakistan" ], "earliest_attestation": { "language": "Tamil", "date_bce": 300, "writing_system": "Tamil-Brahmi" }, "branches": [ { "id": "south-dravidian", "name": "South Dravidian" }, { "id": "south-central-dravidian", "name": "South-Central Dravidian" }, { "id": "central-dravidian", "name": "Central Dravidian" }, { "id": "north-dravidian", "name": "North Dravidian" } ], "controversies": [ { "topic": "Relationship to Indus Valley Civilization", "positions": [ "Dravidian languages were spoken by the Indus Valley Civilization", "No connection" ], "status": "ongoing" } ], "proposed_relationships": [] }, { "id": "uralic", "name": "Uralic", "alternative_names": [], "proto_language": { "name": "Proto-Uralic", "estimated_date_bce": 5000, "date_range_bce": [ 6000, 4000 ], "date_uncertainty": "high", "homeland": { "region": "Ural Mountains region", "coordinates": [ 60.0, 60.0 ], "alternative_theories": [ "Western Siberia", "Central Siberia" ] } }, "classification_status": "established", "speakers": 25000000, "number_of_languages": 38, "geographic_distribution": [ "Northern Eurasia" ], "earliest_attestation": null, "branches": [ { "id": "finnic", "name": "Finnic" }, { "id": "ugric", "name": "Ugric" }, { "id": "saamic", "name": "Saamic" }, { "id": "samoyedic", "name": "Samoyedic" }, { "id": "permic", "name": "Permic" }, { "id": "mari", "name": "Mari" }, { "id": "mordvinic", "name": "Mordvinic" } ], "controversies": [], "proposed_relationships": [ { "hypothesis_name": "Indo-Uralic", "related_families": [ "indo-european" ], "status": "controversial", "evidence_level": "moderate" } ] }, { "id": "austroasiatic", "name": "Austroasiatic", "alternative_names": [ "Mon-Khmer" ], "proto_language": { "name": "Proto-Austroasiatic", "estimated_date_bce": 4000, "date_range_bce": [ 5000, 3000 ], "date_uncertainty": "high", "homeland": { "region": "Mainland Southeast Asia", "coordinates": [ 16.0, 102.0 ], "alternative_theories": [ "South China" ] } }, "classification_status": "established", "speakers": 117000000, "number_of_languages": 168, "geographic_distribution": [ "Southeast Asia", "South Asia" ], "earliest_attestation": { "language": "Old Khmer", "date_bce": 611, "writing_system": "Pallava script" }, "branches": [ { "id": "mon-khmer", "name": "Mon-Khmer" }, { "id": "munda", "name": "Munda" } ], "controversies": [], "proposed_relationships": [] }, { "id": "kra-dai", "name": "Kra-Dai", "alternative_names": [ "Tai-Kadai" ], "proto_language": { "name": "Proto-Kra-Dai", "estimated_date_bce": 1500, "date_range_bce": [ 2000, 1000 ], "date_uncertainty": "medium", "homeland": { "region": "Southern China", "coordinates": [ 25.0, 110.0 ], "alternative_theories": [] } }, "classification_status": "established", "speakers": 93000000, "number_of_languages": 95, "geographic_distribution": [ "Southeast Asia", "Southern China" ], "earliest_attestation": null, "branches": [ { "id": "tai", "name": "Tai" }, { "id": "kadai", "name": "Kadai" }, { "id": "kra", "name": "Kra" } ], "controversies": [], "proposed_relationships": [] }, { "id": "turkic", "name": "Turkic", "alternative_names": [], "proto_language": { "name": "Proto-Turkic", "estimated_date_bce": 0, "date_range_bce": [ 500, -500 ], "date_uncertainty": "high", "homeland": { "region": "Central Asia/Mongolia", "coordinates": [ 47.0, 97.0 ], "alternative_theories": [] } }, "classification_status": "established", "speakers": 170000000, "number_of_languages": 35, "geographic_distribution": [ "Eurasia" ], "earliest_attestation": { "language": "Old Turkic", "date_bce": -700, "writing_system": "Orkhon script" }, "branches": [ { "id": "common-turkic", "name": "Common Turkic" }, { "id": "oghur", "name": "Oghur" }, { "id": "yakut-dolgan", "name": "Yakut-Dolgan" } ], "controversies": [], "proposed_relationships": [] }, { "id": "eskimo-aleut", "name": "Eskimo-Aleut", "alternative_names": [], "proto_language": { "name": "Proto-Eskimo-Aleut", "estimated_date_bce": 2000, "date_range_bce": [ 3000, 1000 ], "date_uncertainty": "high", "homeland": { "region": "Bering Strait", "coordinates": [ 65.0, -169.0 ], "alternative_theories": [] } }, "classification_status": "established", "speakers": 100000, "number_of_languages": 11, "geographic_distribution": [ "Arctic regions of North America and Siberia" ], "earliest_attestation": null, "branches": [ { "id": "eskimo", "name": "Eskimo" }, { "id": "aleut", "name": "Aleut" } ], "controversies": [], "proposed_relationships": [] }, { "id": "na-dene", "name": "Na-Dene", "alternative_names": [], "proto_language": { "name": "Proto-Na-Dene", "estimated_date_bce": 7000, "date_range_bce": [ 8000, 6000 ], "date_uncertainty": "high", "homeland": { "region": "Alaska/Yukon", "coordinates": [ 65.0, -140.0 ], "alternative_theories": [] } }, "classification_status": "established", "speakers": 200000, "number_of_languages": 40, "geographic_distribution": [ "North America" ], "earliest_attestation": null, "branches": [ { "id": "athabaskan", "name": "Athabaskan" }, { "id": "eyak", "name": "Eyak" }, { "id": "tlingit", "name": "Tlingit" } ], "controversies": [ { "topic": "Haida membership", "positions": [ "Haida is a member of Na-Dene", "Haida is a language isolate" ], "status": "ongoing" } ], "proposed_relationships": [ { "hypothesis_name": "Dene-Yeniseian", "related_families": [ "yeniseian" ], "status": "proposed", "evidence_level": "moderate" } ] }, { "id": "algic", "name": "Algic", "alternative_names": [], "proto_language": { "name": "Proto-Algic", "estimated_date_bce": 1000, "date_range_bce": [ 2000, 0 ], "date_uncertainty": "high", "homeland": { "region": "Pacific Northwest", "coordinates": [ 45.0, -120.0 ], "alternative_theories": [] } }, "classification_status": "established", "speakers": 200000, "number_of_languages": 30, "geographic_distribution": [ "North America" ], "earliest_attestation": null, "branches": [ { "id": "algonquian", "name": "Algonquian" }, { "id": "yurok", "name": "Yurok" }, { "id": "wiyot", "name": "Wiyot" } ], "controversies": [], "proposed_relationships": [] }, { "id": "uto-aztecan", "name": "Uto-Aztecan", "alternative_names": [], "proto_language": { "name": "Proto-Uto-Aztecan", "estimated_date_bce": 3000, "date_range_bce": [ 4000, 2000 ], "date_uncertainty": "high", "homeland": { "region": "Southwestern United States / Northwestern Mexico", "coordinates": [ 35.0, -115.0 ], "alternative_theories": [] } }, "classification_status": "established", "speakers": 2000000, "number_of_languages": 60, "geographic_distribution": [ "Western United States", "Mexico" ], "earliest_attestation": null, "branches": [ { "id": "northern-uto-aztecan", "name": "Northern Uto-Aztecan" }, { "id": "southern-uto-aztecan", "name": "Southern Uto-Aztecan" } ], "controversies": [], "proposed_relationships": [] }, { "id": "nilo-saharan", "name": "Nilo-Saharan", "alternative_names": [], "proto_language": { "name": "Proto-Nilo-Saharan", "estimated_date_bce": 11000, "date_range_bce": [ 12000, 10000 ], "date_uncertainty": "high", "homeland": { "region": "Central/Eastern Africa", "coordinates": [ 10.0, 30.0 ], "alternative_theories": [] } }, "classification_status": "controversial", "speakers": 37500000, "number_of_languages": 200, "geographic_distribution": [ "North Africa", "East Africa", "Central Africa" ], "earliest_attestation": null, "branches": [ { "id": "eastern-sudanic", "name": "Eastern Sudanic" }, { "id": "central-sudanic", "name": "Central Sudanic" }, { "id": "saharan", "name": "Saharan" }, { "id": "maban", "name": "Maban" }, { "id": "fur", "name": "Fur" }, { "id": "koman", "name": "Koman" }, { "id": "gumuz", "name": "Gumuz" }, { "id": "kunama", "name": "Kunama" }, { "id": "berta", "name": "Berta" }, { "id": "songhay", "name": "Songhay" } ], "controversies": [ { "topic": "Unity of Nilo-Saharan", "positions": [ "Valid family", "Geographic grouping (Sprachbund)" ], "status": "ongoing" } ], "proposed_relationships": [] }, { "id": "trans-new-guinea", "name": "Trans-New Guinea", "alternative_names": [], "proto_language": { "name": "Proto-Trans-New Guinea", "estimated_date_bce": 8000, "date_range_bce": [ 10000, 6000 ], "date_uncertainty": "high", "homeland": { "region": "New Guinea highlands", "coordinates": [ -6.0, 147.0 ], "alternative_theories": [] } }, "classification_status": "proposed", "speakers": 3500000, "number_of_languages": 400, "geographic_distribution": [ "New Guinea" ], "earliest_attestation": null, "branches": [], "controversies": [ { "topic": "Internal classification", "positions": [ "Highly uncertain" ], "status": "ongoing" } ], "proposed_relationships": [] } ], "language_isolates": [ { "id": "basque", "name": "Basque", "iso_639_3": "eus", "status": "living", "speakers": 750000, "location": { "region": "Iberian Peninsula", "coordinates": [ 43.0, -2.0 ] }, "first_attested_bce": -1000, "proposed_relationships": [] }, { "id": "burushaski", "name": "Burushaski", "iso_639_3": "bsk", "status": "living", "speakers": 100000, "location": { "region": "Northern Pakistan", "coordinates": [ 36.5, 74.5 ] }, "first_attested_bce": null, "proposed_relationships": [] }, { "id": "sumerian", "name": "Sumerian", "iso_639_3": "sux", "status": "extinct", "speakers": 0, "location": { "region": "Mesopotamia", "coordinates": [ 33.0, 44.0 ] }, "first_attested_bce": 3500, "proposed_relationships": [] }, { "id": "ainu", "name": "Ainu", "iso_639_3": "ain", "status": "critically_endangered", "speakers": 10, "location": { "region": "Northern Japan", "coordinates": [ 43.0, 143.0 ] }, "first_attested_bce": null, "proposed_relationships": [ { "hypothesis": "Altaic", "status": "rejected", "notes": "Proposed connection to Altaic languages is widely rejected." } ] }, { "id": "korean", "name": "Korean", "iso_639_3": "kor", "status": "living", "speakers": 80000000, "location": { "region": "Korean Peninsula", "coordinates": [ 37.0, 127.0 ] }, "first_attested_bce": -600, "proposed_relationships": [ { "hypothesis": "Altaic", "status": "rejected", "notes": "Proposed connection to Altaic languages is widely rejected." }, { "hypothesis": "Japonic", "status": "controversial", "notes": "Proposed connection to Japonic languages is debated." } ] }, { "id": "nihali", "name": "Nihali", "iso_639_3": "nll", "status": "living", "speakers": 2000, "location": { "region": "Central India", "coordinates": [ 21.5, 76.5 ] }, "first_attested_bce": null, "proposed_relationships": [] }, { "id": "kusunda", "name": "Kusunda", "iso_639_3": "kgg", "status": "critically_endangered", "speakers": 2, "location": { "region": "Nepal", "coordinates": [ 28.0, 84.0 ] }, "first_attested_bce": null, "proposed_relationships": [] }, { "id": "haida", "name": "Haida", "iso_639_3": "hai", "status": "critically_endangered", "speakers": 20, "location": { "region": "Pacific Northwest", "coordinates": [ 53.0, -132.0 ] }, "first_attested_bce": null, "proposed_relationships": [ { "hypothesis": "Na-Dene", "status": "disputed", "notes": "Sometimes included in Na-Dene, but this is disputed." } ] }, { "id": "zuni", "name": "Zuni", "iso_639_3": "zun", "status": "living", "speakers": 10000, "location": { "region": "New Mexico", "coordinates": [ 35.0, -108.0 ] }, "first_attested_bce": null, "proposed_relationships": [] }, { "id": "purepecha", "name": "Pur\u00e9pecha", "iso_639_3": "tsz", "status": "living", "speakers": 140000, "location": { "region": "Mexico", "coordinates": [ 19.5, -101.5 ] }, "first_attested_bce": null, "proposed_relationships": [] } ], "macro_families": [ { "name": "Nostratic", "status": "rejected", "proposed_date_bce": 15000, "included_families": [ "indo-european", "uralic", "altaic", "kartvelian", "dravidian", "afro-asiatic" ], "proponents": [ "Holger Pedersen", "Vladislav Illich-Svitych", "Aharon Dolgopolsky" ], "evidence": "Lexical and morphological similarities", "mainstream_acceptance": "low", "controversies": "Methodological flaws, reliance on reconstructed forms, and the time depth involved make it highly speculative." }, { "name": "Eurasiatic", "status": "rejected", "proposed_date_bce": 15000, "included_families": [ "indo-european", "uralic", "altaic", "koreanic", "japonic", "eskimo-aleut" ], "proponents": [ "Joseph Greenberg" ], "evidence": "Lexical and morphological similarities", "mainstream_acceptance": "low", "controversies": "Similar to Nostratic, methodological flaws and reliance on reconstructed forms make it highly speculative." }, { "name": "Altaic", "status": "rejected", "proposed_date_bce": 2000, "included_families": [ "turkic", "mongolic", "tungusic", "koreanic", "japonic" ], "proponents": [ "Gustaf John Ramstedt", "Nicholas Poppe" ], "evidence": "Lexical and morphological similarities", "mainstream_acceptance": "low", "controversies": "Now considered a Sprachbund (linguistic area) rather than a genetic family by most linguists." }, { "name": "Austric", "status": "controversial", "proposed_date_bce": 8000, "included_families": [ "austronesian", "austroasiatic", "kra-dai", "hmong-mien" ], "proponents": [ "Wilhelm Schmidt" ], "evidence": "Lexical similarities", "mainstream_acceptance": "low", "controversies": "Not widely accepted due to lack of systematic sound correspondences." } ], "terminology_notes": { "deprecated_terms": [ { "old_term": "Ural-Altaic", "current_term": "Uralic and Altaic (as separate entities)", "reason": "The proposed Ural-Altaic family is now rejected by mainstream linguistics." }, { "old_term": "Sino-Tibetan", "current_term": "Trans-Himalayan", "reason": "Some scholars prefer 'Trans-Himalayan' to avoid implying a close relationship between Sinitic and Tibeto-Burman." } ], "controversial_terms": [ { "term": "Altaic", "controversy": "The validity of Altaic as a genetic family is highly disputed. Many linguists now consider it a Sprachbund.", "alternatives": [ "Transeurasian" ] }, { "term": "Nilo-Saharan", "controversy": "The unity of Nilo-Saharan is highly disputed. Some linguists reject it entirely.", "alternatives": [] } ] } }