review_extension/aggregate/matched_null.json

{
  "analysis": "dial_terminal_overlap_matched_intervention_null",
  "claim_boundary": "Post-hoc model-output sensitivity under frame-Gram-matched random directions; no human causality or change to the frozen DIAL decision.",
  "complete": true,
  "frozen_at_utc": "2026-07-20T23:49:00Z",
  "implementation_commit": "60b03e385f970f6633257d72fd12260525a43982",
  "protocol_sha256": "ddb15f1810a6046ca250d29ec2b29035c8c73d07dd8a48437b632931dade06ab",
  "contrasts": {
    "A": {
      "aligned_minus_shared": {
        "confidence_interval_95": [
          -0.0008232593536376953,
          0.000754396120707194
        ],
        "mean": -0.00010355313618977864,
        "paired_effects": [
          -0.0014846324920654297,
          0.0017347335815429688,
          -0.0005629062652587891,
          -0.00028967857360839844,
          3.8623809814453125e-05,
          -5.745887756347656e-05
        ],
        "positive_seeds": 2,
        "two_sided_exact_sign_flip_p": 0.6875
      },
      "aligned_minus_shuffled": {
        "confidence_interval_95": [
          -0.0020748376846313477,
          -5.358258883158875e-05
        ],
        "mean": -0.001219630241394043,
        "paired_effects": [
          -0.0019192695617675781,
          0.0014464855194091797,
          -0.0020601749420166016,
          -0.002189159393310547,
          -0.002043008804321289,
          -0.0005526542663574219
        ],
        "positive_seeds": 1,
        "two_sided_exact_sign_flip_p": 0.09375
      },
      "condition_means": {
        "aligned": -0.0012061198552449544,
        "shared": -0.0011025667190551758,
        "shuffled": 1.3510386149088541e-05
      }
    },
    "H": {
      "aligned_minus_shared": {
        "confidence_interval_95": [
          -0.0001625219980875651,
          0.0009938875834147136
        ],
        "mean": 0.0003879865010579427,
        "paired_effects": [
          -9.775161743164062e-05,
          0.0015857219696044922,
          0.00013709068298339844,
          -0.0005269050598144531,
          0.00110626220703125,
          0.00012350082397460938
        ],
        "positive_seeds": 4,
        "two_sided_exact_sign_flip_p": 0.3125
      },
      "aligned_minus_shuffled": {
        "confidence_interval_95": [
          0.0008605718612670898,
          0.004465937614440918
        ],
        "mean": 0.0024562676747639975,
        "paired_effects": [
          0.0029489994049072266,
          0.002119302749633789,
          0.006892681121826172,
          -0.00039196014404296875,
          0.002110004425048828,
          0.0010585784912109375
        ],
        "positive_seeds": 5,
        "two_sided_exact_sign_flip_p": 0.0625
      },
      "condition_means": {
        "aligned": 0.0012772878011067708,
        "shared": 0.0008893013000488281,
        "shuffled": -0.0011789798736572266
      }
    },
    "O": {
      "aligned_minus_shared": {
        "confidence_interval_95": [
          -0.0012639363606770833,
          0.0014658371607462566
        ],
        "mean": 0.00015052159627278647,
        "paired_effects": [
          -0.0005741119384765625,
          0.0015382766723632812,
          -0.0026578903198242188,
          0.002652406692504883,
          -0.0007615089416503906,
          0.0007059574127197266
        ],
        "positive_seeds": 3,
        "two_sided_exact_sign_flip_p": 0.875
      },
      "aligned_minus_shuffled": {
        "confidence_interval_95": [
          -0.003228306770324707,
          -0.0017786423365275066
        ],
        "mean": -0.0024351278940836587,
        "paired_effects": [
          -0.004182338714599609,
          -0.0019512176513671875,
          -0.0028972625732421875,
          -0.0014863014221191406,
          -0.002439260482788086,
          -0.0016543865203857422
        ],
        "positive_seeds": 0,
        "two_sided_exact_sign_flip_p": 0.03125
      },
      "condition_means": {
        "aligned": -0.00047194957733154297,
        "shared": -0.0006224711736043295,
        "shuffled": 0.0019631783167521157
      }
    },
    "mean": {
      "aligned_minus_shared": {
        "confidence_interval_95": [
          -0.0005180570814344618,
          0.0008348623911539715
        ],
        "mean": 0.00014498498704698353,
        "paired_effects": [
          -0.0007188320159912109,
          0.001619577407836914,
          -0.0010279019673665364,
          0.0006119410196940105,
          0.0001277923583984375,
          0.00025733311971028644
        ],
        "positive_seeds": 4,
        "two_sided_exact_sign_flip_p": 0.71875
      },
      "aligned_minus_shuffled": {
        "confidence_interval_95": [
          -0.0009903510411580405,
          0.00021664301554361978
        ],
        "mean": -0.00039949682023790147,
        "paired_effects": [
          -0.001050869623819987,
          0.0005381902058919271,
          0.0006450812021891276,
          -0.0013558069864908853,
          -0.0007907549540201824,
          -0.00038282076517740887
        ],
        "positive_seeds": 2,
        "two_sided_exact_sign_flip_p": 0.3125
      },
      "condition_means": {
        "aligned": -0.0001335938771565755,
        "shared": -0.00027857886420355906,
        "shuffled": 0.00026590294308132597
      }
    }
  },
  "lineages": 18,
  "primary": {
    "confidence_interval_95": [
      -0.0005180570814344618,
      0.0008348623911539715
    ],
    "mean": 0.00014498498704698353,
    "paired_effects": [
      -0.0007188320159912109,
      0.001619577407836914,
      -0.0010279019673665364,
      0.0006119410196940105,
      0.0001277923583984375,
      0.00025733311971028644
    ],
    "positive_seeds": 4,
    "two_sided_exact_sign_flip_p": 0.71875
  },
  "random_controls_per_model": 32,
  "schema_version": 1
}