{ "aoa_controlled": { "paired_contrasts": { "aligned_minus_shared": { "confidence_interval_95": [ -0.013177898569545968, 0.003167468130149398 ], "mean": -0.00484777885414676, "positive_seeds": 3, "two_sided_exact_sign_flip_p": 0.4375, "values": [ -0.0048204052154185995, -0.016319953241986873, 0.005122660011440017, -0.02039125589610502, 0.006603677446776701, 0.0007186037704132175 ] }, "aligned_minus_shuffled": { "confidence_interval_95": [ -0.008018008983540307, -0.00022129977396769437 ], "mean": -0.003603797949011426, "positive_seeds": 2, "two_sided_exact_sign_flip_p": 0.1875, "values": [ 5.488145245768905e-05, -0.013336680319814498, 0.0003095083617046246, -0.00024297588491339894, -0.0018136023872173945, -0.006593918916285579 ] } }, "rows": [ { "controlled": { "baseline_cv_r2": 0.1062636258320967, "controlled_incremental_cv_r2": -0.019297647009817176, "controls": [ "corpus_frequency_decile", "evaluation_log_frequency", "character_length", "subword_length", "contextual_diversity", "prior_oov", "frozen Brown root lexical class" ], "folds": 10, "full_cv_r2": 0.08901661676357076, "n_words": 336, "raw_pearson": 0.0069041547224142595, "raw_pearson_p": 0.8996645415623049, "within_corpus_frequency_decile": { "-1": { "n": 19, "pearson": 0.2952204057830198 }, "2": { "n": 17, "pearson": -0.11602366401085926 }, "3": { "n": 12, "pearson": 0.3681529741261109 }, "4": { "n": 15, "pearson": 0.0692250180420915 }, "5": { "n": 25, "pearson": -0.06339872556906032 }, "6": { "n": 32, "pearson": -0.16905570922797208 }, "7": { "n": 64, "pearson": 0.1516147395064576 }, "8": { "n": 68, "pearson": -0.2501922871273643 }, "9": { "n": 77, "pearson": -0.027721857547420625 } } }, "variant": "dial_aligned_s1" }, { "controlled": { "baseline_cv_r2": 0.1066711951083874, "controlled_incremental_cv_r2": -0.003898120513015302, "controls": [ "corpus_frequency_decile", "evaluation_log_frequency", "character_length", "subword_length", "contextual_diversity", "prior_oov", "frozen Brown root lexical class" ], "folds": 10, "full_cv_r2": 0.1031888917691719, "n_words": 325, "raw_pearson": -0.025844087813755984, "raw_pearson_p": 0.6425092473445578, "within_corpus_frequency_decile": { "-1": { "n": 21, "pearson": -0.19236530892471895 }, "2": { "n": 13, "pearson": -0.14512549944738465 }, "3": { "n": 10, "pearson": 0.3619557854928773 }, "4": { "n": 16, "pearson": 0.019385586744148836 }, "5": { "n": 22, "pearson": -0.18459344076847817 }, "6": { "n": 33, "pearson": 0.09205730767497008 }, "7": { "n": 62, "pearson": -0.13298838190929 }, "8": { "n": 68, "pearson": 0.030310195759219036 }, "9": { "n": 77, "pearson": 0.27556827302114584 } } }, "variant": "dial_aligned_s2" }, { "controlled": { "baseline_cv_r2": 0.11101269302901418, "controlled_incremental_cv_r2": -0.0042270147536218605, "controls": [ "corpus_frequency_decile", "evaluation_log_frequency", "character_length", "subword_length", "contextual_diversity", "prior_oov", "frozen Brown root lexical class" ], "folds": 10, "full_cv_r2": 0.10725493056666513, "n_words": 338, "raw_pearson": 0.04815738064229656, "raw_pearson_p": 0.3774551304839715, "within_corpus_frequency_decile": { "-1": { "n": 21, "pearson": 0.26487931243061535 }, "1": { "n": 5, "pearson": -0.3030872889416838 }, "2": { "n": 13, "pearson": 0.13756830707276488 }, "3": { "n": 13, "pearson": 0.5248619664023931 }, "4": { "n": 15, "pearson": 0.31032104828977447 }, "5": { "n": 27, "pearson": 0.1521275275475448 }, "6": { "n": 34, "pearson": -0.27822030344535853 }, "7": { "n": 62, "pearson": 0.08100140343533958 }, "8": { "n": 68, "pearson": -0.12486815228029136 }, "9": { "n": 77, "pearson": -0.05756917506900467 } } }, "variant": "dial_aligned_s3" }, { "controlled": { "baseline_cv_r2": 0.12559121038664678, "controlled_incremental_cv_r2": -0.009020780524455319, "controls": [ "corpus_frequency_decile", "evaluation_log_frequency", "character_length", "subword_length", "contextual_diversity", "prior_oov", "frozen Brown root lexical class" ], "folds": 10, "full_cv_r2": 0.11770336060689024, "n_words": 320, "raw_pearson": -0.019127150963896992, "raw_pearson_p": 0.7332171813376864, "within_corpus_frequency_decile": { "-1": { "n": 18, "pearson": 0.20268736790085778 }, "2": { "n": 15, "pearson": 0.3474486677288158 }, "3": { "n": 9, "pearson": 0.31604046145861864 }, "4": { "n": 14, "pearson": 0.2803996926492452 }, "5": { "n": 21, "pearson": -0.5000108261095734 }, "6": { "n": 32, "pearson": 0.1535758241430079 }, "7": { "n": 62, "pearson": -0.03190558049040531 }, "8": { "n": 68, "pearson": -0.043842908749240635 }, "9": { "n": 77, "pearson": 0.07579144525462816 } } }, "variant": "dial_shared_s2" }, { "controlled": { "baseline_cv_r2": 0.103275608027252, "controlled_incremental_cv_r2": -0.0025559872485285684, "controls": [ "corpus_frequency_decile", "evaluation_log_frequency", "character_length", "subword_length", "contextual_diversity", "prior_oov", "frozen Brown root lexical class" ], "folds": 10, "full_cv_r2": 0.10098359191592521, "n_words": 333, "raw_pearson": 0.09075391254386236, "raw_pearson_p": 0.09827197244722222, "within_corpus_frequency_decile": { "-1": { "n": 23, "pearson": 0.052308257594251915 }, "2": { "n": 14, "pearson": 0.3121823586404068 }, "3": { "n": 12, "pearson": 0.3070471944947507 }, "4": { "n": 14, "pearson": 0.45996147365529516 }, "5": { "n": 23, "pearson": -0.0691557222329647 }, "6": { "n": 32, "pearson": -0.16477401056167698 }, "7": { "n": 64, "pearson": 0.13639654401399404 }, "8": { "n": 68, "pearson": 0.2317606893340424 }, "9": { "n": 77, "pearson": 0.08191560043680109 } } }, "variant": "dial_shared_s4" }, { "controlled": { "baseline_cv_r2": 0.10546031736657091, "controlled_incremental_cv_r2": -0.003984038868708462, "controls": [ "corpus_frequency_decile", "evaluation_log_frequency", "character_length", "subword_length", "contextual_diversity", "prior_oov", "frozen Brown root lexical class" ], "folds": 10, "full_cv_r2": 0.10189643650135727, "n_words": 335, "raw_pearson": 0.04530499897469993, "raw_pearson_p": 0.4084963069039169, "within_corpus_frequency_decile": { "-1": { "n": 21, "pearson": -0.11883293958180113 }, "1": { "n": 5, "pearson": -0.13730779882514238 }, "2": { "n": 14, "pearson": 0.25263414256027544 }, "3": { "n": 12, "pearson": 0.3741558156565683 }, "4": { "n": 16, "pearson": 0.22608385342437598 }, "5": { "n": 26, "pearson": -0.06357287239605197 }, "6": { "n": 32, "pearson": -0.020167567425331816 }, "7": { "n": 62, "pearson": 0.14270453663117735 }, "8": { "n": 68, "pearson": -0.21160418093476804 }, "9": { "n": 77, "pearson": -0.014179535055932778 } } }, "variant": "dial_shuffled_s3" }, { "controlled": { "baseline_cv_r2": 0.11879175517246676, "controlled_incremental_cv_r2": 0.005861292585465527, "controls": [ "corpus_frequency_decile", "evaluation_log_frequency", "character_length", "subword_length", "contextual_diversity", "prior_oov", "frozen Brown root lexical class" ], "folds": 10, "full_cv_r2": 0.12395677452412546, "n_words": 315, "raw_pearson": 0.08367347922819593, "raw_pearson_p": 0.13840613549366163, "within_corpus_frequency_decile": { "-1": { "n": 18, "pearson": 0.18767663646421048 }, "2": { "n": 9, "pearson": 0.3327584737904702 }, "3": { "n": 11, "pearson": 0.5008750600835549 }, "4": { "n": 11, "pearson": 0.34051434507689665 }, "5": { "n": 22, "pearson": 0.01068376999293711 }, "6": { "n": 32, "pearson": -0.20022008096020877 }, "7": { "n": 62, "pearson": 0.010904980874368891 }, "8": { "n": 68, "pearson": 0.37706193761618256 }, "9": { "n": 77, "pearson": 0.05420919019572745 } } }, "variant": "dial_shuffled_s4" }, { "controlled": { "baseline_cv_r2": 0.08973555876694894, "controlled_incremental_cv_r2": -0.0001443952004176463, "controls": [ "corpus_frequency_decile", "evaluation_log_frequency", "character_length", "subword_length", "contextual_diversity", "prior_oov", "frozen Brown root lexical class" ], "folds": 10, "full_cv_r2": 0.08960412095052406, "n_words": 321, "raw_pearson": -0.015113191208931058, "raw_pearson_p": 0.7873647685871655, "within_corpus_frequency_decile": { "-1": { "n": 16, "pearson": 0.21255731628257052 }, "2": { "n": 10, "pearson": -0.5333543772654159 }, "3": { "n": 11, "pearson": -0.4184343987658333 }, "4": { "n": 17, "pearson": 0.6303812265767015 }, "5": { "n": 24, "pearson": 0.19742880546037006 }, "6": { "n": 33, "pearson": -0.018045979386345154 }, "7": { "n": 64, "pearson": -0.15967123866089172 }, "8": { "n": 68, "pearson": 0.011616783199553438 }, "9": { "n": 77, "pearson": 0.04315133686224797 } } }, "variant": "dial_shuffled_s5" }, { "controlled": { "baseline_cv_r2": 0.11679644369969755, "controlled_incremental_cv_r2": 0.004047690198248133, "controls": [ "corpus_frequency_decile", "evaluation_log_frequency", "character_length", "subword_length", "contextual_diversity", "prior_oov", "frozen Brown root lexical class" ], "folds": 10, "full_cv_r2": 0.12037137807759213, "n_words": 319, "raw_pearson": 0.11533571297165934, "raw_pearson_p": 0.03951816880236787, "within_corpus_frequency_decile": { "-1": { "n": 17, "pearson": 0.17930536845386127 }, "2": { "n": 10, "pearson": 0.6004149462602897 }, "3": { "n": 12, "pearson": 0.5211766631779873 }, "4": { "n": 10, "pearson": 0.2451745137691097 }, "5": { "n": 24, "pearson": 0.21790280600031084 }, "6": { "n": 32, "pearson": -0.08145778110218879 }, "7": { "n": 64, "pearson": 0.1563088068444909 }, "8": { "n": 68, "pearson": 0.28309758559748927 }, "9": { "n": 77, "pearson": 0.10031358896753534 } } }, "variant": "dial_aligned_s4" }, { "controlled": { "baseline_cv_r2": 0.08523289238786957, "controlled_incremental_cv_r2": -0.006738314116703226, "controls": [ "corpus_frequency_decile", "evaluation_log_frequency", "character_length", "subword_length", "contextual_diversity", "prior_oov", "frozen Brown root lexical class" ], "folds": 10, "full_cv_r2": 0.07906890427315105, "n_words": 314, "raw_pearson": 0.08853823959466353, "raw_pearson_p": 0.11741399522284811, "within_corpus_frequency_decile": { "-1": { "n": 16, "pearson": 0.25528141690486217 }, "2": { "n": 10, "pearson": -0.6698602912537526 }, "3": { "n": 9, "pearson": -0.3085924010417713 }, "4": { "n": 15, "pearson": 0.04369471126477336 }, "5": { "n": 23, "pearson": 0.265952030275386 }, "6": { "n": 32, "pearson": 0.2645379150415795 }, "7": { "n": 63, "pearson": 0.05937317046960968 }, "8": { "n": 68, "pearson": 0.11984830686238554 }, "9": { "n": 77, "pearson": 0.14036190283040692 } } }, "variant": "dial_aligned_s5" }, { "controlled": { "baseline_cv_r2": 0.08458293272406481, "controlled_incremental_cv_r2": -0.0036566365670853695, "controls": [ "corpus_frequency_decile", "evaluation_log_frequency", "character_length", "subword_length", "contextual_diversity", "prior_oov", "frozen Brown root lexical class" ], "folds": 10, "full_cv_r2": 0.08123558520172958, "n_words": 326, "raw_pearson": -0.005672943308350539, "raw_pearson_p": 0.9187288620526413, "within_corpus_frequency_decile": { "-1": { "n": 20, "pearson": 0.052455919078396675 }, "2": { "n": 11, "pearson": -0.1773399655000026 }, "3": { "n": 10, "pearson": -0.21244279839595331 }, "4": { "n": 13, "pearson": -0.008587804985965017 }, "5": { "n": 24, "pearson": 0.3805575415181999 }, "6": { "n": 34, "pearson": 0.044252333022928185 }, "7": { "n": 63, "pearson": 0.06039408726220603 }, "8": { "n": 68, "pearson": -0.031658523060049584 }, "9": { "n": 77, "pearson": -0.05483579870933875 } } }, "variant": "dial_shared_s0" }, { "controlled": { "baseline_cv_r2": 0.10119218133996843, "controlled_incremental_cv_r2": 0.01616424114248316, "controls": [ "corpus_frequency_decile", "evaluation_log_frequency", "character_length", "subword_length", "contextual_diversity", "prior_oov", "frozen Brown root lexical class" ], "folds": 10, "full_cv_r2": 0.11572072766153851, "n_words": 336, "raw_pearson": 0.09492368844499594, "raw_pearson_p": 0.08231292689907711, "within_corpus_frequency_decile": { "-1": { "n": 22, "pearson": 0.04225080557013135 }, "1": { "n": 5, "pearson": 0.8267039288206355 }, "2": { "n": 16, "pearson": -0.0011313530033814079 }, "3": { "n": 12, "pearson": 0.2835581936459424 }, "4": { "n": 17, "pearson": 0.4199164718780525 }, "5": { "n": 26, "pearson": 0.23296559161881836 }, "6": { "n": 31, "pearson": -0.05823691854444074 }, "7": { "n": 61, "pearson": 0.18675544416418577 }, "8": { "n": 68, "pearson": -0.0691722881688406 }, "9": { "n": 77, "pearson": 0.033373631990235686 } } }, "variant": "dial_shared_s3" }, { "controlled": { "baseline_cv_r2": 0.1188661598635734, "controlled_incremental_cv_r2": -0.007456917887116443, "controls": [ "corpus_frequency_decile", "evaluation_log_frequency", "character_length", "subword_length", "contextual_diversity", "prior_oov", "frozen Brown root lexical class" ], "folds": 10, "full_cv_r2": 0.1122956171701166, "n_words": 322, "raw_pearson": -0.016906853789652152, "raw_pearson_p": 0.7624809960762067, "within_corpus_frequency_decile": { "-1": { "n": 16, "pearson": -0.02062790804857112 }, "2": { "n": 12, "pearson": -0.3544258863761243 }, "3": { "n": 13, "pearson": 0.13000650398237146 }, "4": { "n": 13, "pearson": 0.15731615114916825 }, "5": { "n": 25, "pearson": -0.05845484572969551 }, "6": { "n": 31, "pearson": -0.08958812679666868 }, "7": { "n": 64, "pearson": -0.03591393380389195 }, "8": { "n": 68, "pearson": -0.01411178208383809 }, "9": { "n": 77, "pearson": 0.0346808003436893 } } }, "variant": "dial_shared_s5" }, { "controlled": { "baseline_cv_r2": 0.09955135079550448, "controlled_incremental_cv_r2": -0.008531923234961658, "controls": [ "corpus_frequency_decile", "evaluation_log_frequency", "character_length", "subword_length", "contextual_diversity", "prior_oov", "frozen Brown root lexical class" ], "folds": 10, "full_cv_r2": 0.09186879204346676, "n_words": 325, "raw_pearson": 0.008037454500952505, "raw_pearson_p": 0.8852309535759784, "within_corpus_frequency_decile": { "-1": { "n": 22, "pearson": 0.3402233126709645 }, "2": { "n": 11, "pearson": 0.12018635096342799 }, "3": { "n": 10, "pearson": -0.037138256764643274 }, "4": { "n": 11, "pearson": 0.27114788267247597 }, "5": { "n": 25, "pearson": 0.019402010938018438 }, "6": { "n": 33, "pearson": -0.06345200093216313 }, "7": { "n": 62, "pearson": -0.1089805326930325 }, "8": { "n": 68, "pearson": -0.01083981909344339 }, "9": { "n": 77, "pearson": 0.153260798195682 } } }, "variant": "dial_shuffled_s0" }, { "controlled": { "baseline_cv_r2": 0.10179235569832568, "controlled_incremental_cv_r2": -0.005960966690002678, "controls": [ "corpus_frequency_decile", "evaluation_log_frequency", "character_length", "subword_length", "contextual_diversity", "prior_oov", "frozen Brown root lexical class" ], "folds": 10, "full_cv_r2": 0.0964381698499377, "n_words": 335, "raw_pearson": 0.0004985314039085975, "raw_pearson_p": 0.9927469161483732, "within_corpus_frequency_decile": { "-1": { "n": 20, "pearson": 0.01760770181969827 }, "2": { "n": 19, "pearson": 0.4541489148154313 }, "3": { "n": 10, "pearson": -0.3573200493617909 }, "4": { "n": 15, "pearson": -0.09515297080555758 }, "5": { "n": 25, "pearson": 0.02975810560667762 }, "6": { "n": 30, "pearson": 0.1299366233501794 }, "7": { "n": 64, "pearson": 0.04990039650919027 }, "8": { "n": 68, "pearson": -0.15160125961601162 }, "9": { "n": 77, "pearson": -0.001914761196672215 } } }, "variant": "dial_shuffled_s1" }, { "controlled": { "baseline_cv_r2": 0.10877054221131977, "controlled_incremental_cv_r2": -0.004207628874719926, "controls": [ "corpus_frequency_decile", "evaluation_log_frequency", "character_length", "subword_length", "contextual_diversity", "prior_oov", "frozen Brown root lexical class" ], "folds": 10, "full_cv_r2": 0.10502057941072718, "n_words": 322, "raw_pearson": 0.03235308525388521, "raw_pearson_p": 0.562960974889625, "within_corpus_frequency_decile": { "-1": { "n": 20, "pearson": 0.0461223074374737 }, "2": { "n": 11, "pearson": 0.29097638051717 }, "3": { "n": 8, "pearson": 0.36729889602128407 }, "4": { "n": 16, "pearson": 0.36908361425662406 }, "5": { "n": 22, "pearson": -0.19158542600417272 }, "6": { "n": 33, "pearson": 0.2337115312059241 }, "7": { "n": 62, "pearson": -0.08802900341200297 }, "8": { "n": 68, "pearson": -0.031161125758105986 }, "9": { "n": 77, "pearson": 0.1331295194015465 } } }, "variant": "dial_shuffled_s2" }, { "controlled": { "baseline_cv_r2": 0.09785786610788128, "controlled_incremental_cv_r2": -0.008477041782503969, "controls": [ "corpus_frequency_decile", "evaluation_log_frequency", "character_length", "subword_length", "contextual_diversity", "prior_oov", "frozen Brown root lexical class" ], "folds": 10, "full_cv_r2": 0.09021036954512052, "n_words": 316, "raw_pearson": 0.020433913060344186, "raw_pearson_p": 0.7174719914672328, "within_corpus_frequency_decile": { "-1": { "n": 16, "pearson": -0.2627935852380965 }, "2": { "n": 11, "pearson": -0.23595869885587847 }, "3": { "n": 7, "pearson": 0.46522197364131357 }, "4": { "n": 12, "pearson": 0.09549246961080513 }, "5": { "n": 25, "pearson": 0.0047088205762544355 }, "6": { "n": 32, "pearson": 0.24708575219307055 }, "7": { "n": 62, "pearson": -0.021394379021274564 }, "8": { "n": 68, "pearson": 0.2709577338310833 }, "9": { "n": 77, "pearson": 0.036272126209464184 } } }, "variant": "dial_aligned_s0" }, { "controlled": { "baseline_cv_r2": 0.10689757800773625, "controlled_incremental_cv_r2": -0.002977693767830303, "controls": [ "corpus_frequency_decile", "evaluation_log_frequency", "character_length", "subword_length", "contextual_diversity", "prior_oov", "frozen Brown root lexical class" ], "folds": 10, "full_cv_r2": 0.10423819249173571, "n_words": 333, "raw_pearson": -0.08796022780273972, "raw_pearson_p": 0.1091125595198792, "within_corpus_frequency_decile": { "-1": { "n": 22, "pearson": -0.008475276917248253 }, "0": { "n": 6, "pearson": -0.5244759710740176 }, "2": { "n": 14, "pearson": 0.009233683815494678 }, "3": { "n": 10, "pearson": -0.22723839113224326 }, "4": { "n": 14, "pearson": -0.14721524359629973 }, "5": { "n": 24, "pearson": -0.2952604477531095 }, "6": { "n": 30, "pearson": -0.1468272863697285 }, "7": { "n": 65, "pearson": 0.17378233060174583 }, "8": { "n": 68, "pearson": -0.27411456064970585 }, "9": { "n": 77, "pearson": -0.07458201184034946 } } }, "variant": "dial_shared_s1" } ] }, "claim_boundary": "Temporary lexical differentiation and acquisition only; no persistent modules, human causality, universal optimality, or leaderboard claim.", "complete": true, "gradient_conflict": { "aligned": { "associative_hierarchical_cosine": 0.0, "associative_order_cosine": 0.0, "language_associative_conflict": 0.5052083333333334, "language_associative_cosine": -8.62512933963444e-06, "language_hierarchical_conflict": 0.020833333333333332, "language_hierarchical_cosine": 0.01089979361101238, "language_order_conflict": 0.4401041666666667, "language_order_cosine": 0.00024217656414293742, "order_hierarchical_cosine": 0.0 }, "shared": { "associative_hierarchical_cosine": 0.001654688640466399, "associative_order_cosine": -0.0001762238990371164, "language_associative_conflict": 0.5442708333333334, "language_associative_cosine": -0.00015648017364355837, "language_hierarchical_conflict": 0.010416666666666666, "language_hierarchical_cosine": 0.008531188859781954, "language_order_conflict": 0.4348958333333333, "language_order_cosine": 0.0002621650745027182, "order_hierarchical_cosine": 0.0006649294829799146 }, "shuffled": { "associative_hierarchical_cosine": 0.0, "associative_order_cosine": 0.0, "language_associative_conflict": 0.5442708333333334, "language_associative_cosine": -0.00013039418767372504, "language_hierarchical_conflict": 0.049479166666666664, "language_hierarchical_cosine": 0.0065805416283334734, "language_order_conflict": 0.4140625, "language_order_cosine": 0.00037410032632578805, "order_hierarchical_cosine": 0.0 } }, "mechanism": { "grouped": [ { "checkpoint_words": 1000000, "condition": "aligned", "factor": "hierarchical", "learned_minus_random_median": { "confidence_interval_95": [ -0.0009120305379231771, 0.0019238789876302083 ], "mean": 0.0005433559417724609, "positive_seeds": 4, "two_sided_exact_sign_flip_p": 0.5625, "values": [ -0.0013747215270996094, -0.0020995140075683594, 0.003490447998046875, 0.0009627342224121094, 0.0012383460998535156, 0.0010428428649902344 ] }, "mean_exact_matching_fraction": 0.9104817708333334 }, { "checkpoint_words": 1000000, "condition": "aligned", "factor": "order", "learned_minus_random_median": { "confidence_interval_95": [ -0.0024385452270507812, -0.0011522769927978516 ], "mean": -0.0017847220102945964, "positive_seeds": 0, "two_sided_exact_sign_flip_p": 0.03125, "values": [ -0.00041961669921875, -0.003017902374267578, -0.0016160011291503906, -0.0016932487487792969, -0.0024499893188476562, -0.0015115737915039062 ] }, "mean_exact_matching_fraction": 0.9104817708333334 }, { "checkpoint_words": 1000000, "condition": "aligned", "factor": "associative", "learned_minus_random_median": { "confidence_interval_95": [ -0.001816113789876302, 0.00019049644470214844 ], "mean": -0.0007248719533284506, "positive_seeds": 3, "two_sided_exact_sign_flip_p": 0.25, "values": [ 0.0006780624389648438, -0.0031270980834960938, -0.0010089874267578125, 0.0001163482666015625, -0.0011844635009765625, 0.00017690658569335938 ] }, "mean_exact_matching_fraction": 0.9104817708333334 }, { "checkpoint_words": 10000000, "condition": "aligned", "factor": "hierarchical", "learned_minus_random_median": { "confidence_interval_95": [ -0.0011748472849527996, 0.0009415149688720703 ], "mean": -0.00012691815694173178, "positive_seeds": 3, "two_sided_exact_sign_flip_p": 0.84375, "values": [ 0.0016922950744628906, 0.0008044242858886719, -0.0015168190002441406, -0.001033782958984375, -0.0017862319946289062, 0.0010786056518554688 ] }, "mean_exact_matching_fraction": 0.9078776041666666 }, { "checkpoint_words": 10000000, "condition": "aligned", "factor": "order", "learned_minus_random_median": { "confidence_interval_95": [ -0.0012673536936442058, 0.0018986860911051433 ], "mean": 0.00031797091166178387, "positive_seeds": 3, "two_sided_exact_sign_flip_p": 0.75, "values": [ 0.003040313720703125, -0.0023179054260253906, 0.0022945404052734375, -0.0001068115234375, -0.0018591880798339844, 0.0008568763732910156 ] }, "mean_exact_matching_fraction": 0.9078776041666666 }, { "checkpoint_words": 10000000, "condition": "aligned", "factor": "associative", "learned_minus_random_median": { "confidence_interval_95": [ -0.0009289582570393881, 0.00027553240458170575 ], "mean": -0.00027982393900553387, "positive_seeds": 3, "two_sided_exact_sign_flip_p": 0.5, "values": [ 0.00027179718017578125, -0.0009632110595703125, -0.0016155242919921875, 0.00039196014404296875, -0.00012540817260742188, 0.00036144256591796875 ] }, "mean_exact_matching_fraction": 0.9078776041666666 }, { "checkpoint_words": 30000000, "condition": "aligned", "factor": "hierarchical", "learned_minus_random_median": { "confidence_interval_95": [ 1.6570091247558594e-05, 0.0028676986694335938 ], "mean": 0.0013266801834106445, "positive_seeds": 5, "two_sided_exact_sign_flip_p": 0.15625, "values": [ 0.0017676353454589844, 0.0048677921295166016, -0.0010945796966552734, 0.0015840530395507812, 0.0006003379821777344, 0.00023484230041503906 ] }, "mean_exact_matching_fraction": 0.9138997395833334 }, { "checkpoint_words": 30000000, "condition": "aligned", "factor": "order", "learned_minus_random_median": { "confidence_interval_95": [ -0.0015042622884114583, 0.0009551843007405599 ], "mean": -0.00033593177795410156, "positive_seeds": 2, "two_sided_exact_sign_flip_p": 0.65625, "values": [ 0.00044918060302734375, -0.0023255348205566406, 0.002424955368041992, -0.0007388591766357422, -6.604194641113281e-05, -0.0017592906951904297 ] }, "mean_exact_matching_fraction": 0.9138997395833334 }, { "checkpoint_words": 30000000, "condition": "aligned", "factor": "associative", "learned_minus_random_median": { "confidence_interval_95": [ -0.0019003947575887044, -0.00046376387278238934 ], "mean": -0.0012109676996866863, "positive_seeds": 1, "two_sided_exact_sign_flip_p": 0.0625, "values": [ 8.630752563476562e-05, -0.00223541259765625, -0.0022003650665283203, -0.002008199691772461, -0.00042057037353515625, -0.0004875659942626953 ] }, "mean_exact_matching_fraction": 0.9138997395833334 }, { "checkpoint_words": 1000000, "condition": "shared", "factor": "hierarchical", "learned_minus_random_median": { "confidence_interval_95": [ -0.0011202494303385417, 0.00038250287373860675 ], "mean": -0.00031828880310058594, "positive_seeds": 1, "two_sided_exact_sign_flip_p": 0.53125, "values": [ -0.002109050750732422, -0.00014257431030273438, -0.00042438507080078125, -9.822845458984375e-05, -0.000125885009765625, 0.0009903907775878906 ] }, "mean_exact_matching_fraction": 0.90771484375 }, { "checkpoint_words": 1000000, "condition": "shared", "factor": "order", "learned_minus_random_median": { "confidence_interval_95": [ -1.0887781778971354e-05, 0.001979668935139974 ], "mean": 0.0009791851043701172, "positive_seeds": 4, "two_sided_exact_sign_flip_p": 0.15625, "values": [ -0.00047206878662109375, -0.0005345344543457031, 0.0008134841918945312, 0.0022144317626953125, 0.0027818679809570312, 0.001071929931640625 ] }, "mean_exact_matching_fraction": 0.90771484375 }, { "checkpoint_words": 1000000, "condition": "shared", "factor": "associative", "learned_minus_random_median": { "confidence_interval_95": [ -0.0005044142405192057, 0.0021265347798665366 ], "mean": 0.0008064111073811849, "positive_seeds": 3, "two_sided_exact_sign_flip_p": 0.34375, "values": [ 0.0019817352294921875, -0.0003924369812011719, 0.0017142295837402344, 0.0032410621643066406, -0.0002512931823730469, -0.0014548301696777344 ] }, "mean_exact_matching_fraction": 0.90771484375 }, { "checkpoint_words": 10000000, "condition": "shared", "factor": "hierarchical", "learned_minus_random_median": { "confidence_interval_95": [ -0.0013591448465983074, 9.5367431640625e-06 ], "mean": -0.0006719430287679037, "positive_seeds": 1, "two_sided_exact_sign_flip_p": 0.15625, "values": [ -0.0012731552124023438, -8.0108642578125e-05, -0.001926422119140625, -0.000133514404296875, 0.0005292892456054688, -0.0011477470397949219 ] }, "mean_exact_matching_fraction": 0.9073893229166666 }, { "checkpoint_words": 10000000, "condition": "shared", "factor": "order", "learned_minus_random_median": { "confidence_interval_95": [ -4.553794860839844e-05, 0.0014082590738932292 ], "mean": 0.0007286866505940756, "positive_seeds": 4, "two_sided_exact_sign_flip_p": 0.125, "values": [ -0.0009050369262695312, 0.0016579627990722656, 0.0015301704406738281, 0.0011773109436035156, 0.0010237693786621094, -0.00011205673217773438 ] }, "mean_exact_matching_fraction": 0.9073893229166666 }, { "checkpoint_words": 10000000, "condition": "shared", "factor": "associative", "learned_minus_random_median": { "confidence_interval_95": [ 0.0004723866780598958, 0.0012322266896565754 ], "mean": 0.0008609294891357422, "positive_seeds": 6, "two_sided_exact_sign_flip_p": 0.03125, "values": [ 0.0015268325805664062, 0.0010619163513183594, 0.00038051605224609375, 0.0008573532104492188, 0.0012102127075195312, 0.00012874603271484375 ] }, "mean_exact_matching_fraction": 0.9073893229166666 }, { "checkpoint_words": 30000000, "condition": "shared", "factor": "hierarchical", "learned_minus_random_median": { "confidence_interval_95": [ 0.0002956787745157878, 0.002894878387451172 ], "mean": 0.0013451178868611653, "positive_seeds": 5, "two_sided_exact_sign_flip_p": 0.0625, "values": [ 0.0051441192626953125, 0.0004639625549316406, 0.0014569759368896484, -0.0001595020294189453, 0.0006394386291503906, 0.0005257129669189453 ] }, "mean_exact_matching_fraction": 0.9119466145833334 }, { "checkpoint_words": 30000000, "condition": "shared", "factor": "order", "learned_minus_random_median": { "confidence_interval_95": [ -0.0006709496180216471, 0.00039347012837727863 ], "mean": -0.00013132890065511069, "positive_seeds": 3, "two_sided_exact_sign_flip_p": 0.625, "values": [ 0.0006253719329833984, 0.0002338886260986328, -0.0009217262268066406, 0.0006139278411865234, -0.0003402233123779297, -0.0009992122650146484 ] }, "mean_exact_matching_fraction": 0.9119466145833334 }, { "checkpoint_words": 30000000, "condition": "shared", "factor": "associative", "learned_minus_random_median": { "confidence_interval_95": [ -0.0013728141784667969, 0.0002696514129638672 ], "mean": -0.0006571610768636068, "positive_seeds": 1, "two_sided_exact_sign_flip_p": 0.21875, "values": [ -0.001180887222290039, -0.0014655590057373047, 0.00145721435546875, -0.0015606880187988281, -9.441375732421875e-05, -0.0010986328125 ] }, "mean_exact_matching_fraction": 0.9119466145833334 }, { "checkpoint_words": 1000000, "condition": "shuffled", "factor": "hierarchical", "learned_minus_random_median": { "confidence_interval_95": [ -0.00015894571940104166, 0.001440127690633138 ], "mean": 0.000671227773030599, "positive_seeds": 5, "two_sided_exact_sign_flip_p": 0.21875, "values": [ 0.0006160736083984375, 0.0018181800842285156, -0.001220703125, 0.0002741813659667969, 0.0018486976623535156, 0.0006909370422363281 ] }, "mean_exact_matching_fraction": 0.9112955729166666 }, { "checkpoint_words": 1000000, "condition": "shuffled", "factor": "order", "learned_minus_random_median": { "confidence_interval_95": [ -0.0014845530192057292, 0.00047961870829264325 ], "mean": -0.00047095616658528644, "positive_seeds": 2, "two_sided_exact_sign_flip_p": 0.5, "values": [ -0.0002498626708984375, 0.0008559226989746094, -0.0026025772094726562, -0.0008482933044433594, -0.0011072158813476562, 0.0011262893676757812 ] }, "mean_exact_matching_fraction": 0.9112955729166666 }, { "checkpoint_words": 1000000, "condition": "shuffled", "factor": "associative", "learned_minus_random_median": { "confidence_interval_95": [ -0.0014875729878743489, 0.0007094542185465494 ], "mean": -0.0004707177480061849, "positive_seeds": 2, "two_sided_exact_sign_flip_p": 0.53125, "values": [ 0.0004019737243652344, -0.0020322799682617188, -0.001705169677734375, 0.0019617080688476562, -0.00017786026000976562, -0.0012726783752441406 ] }, "mean_exact_matching_fraction": 0.9112955729166666 }, { "checkpoint_words": 10000000, "condition": "shuffled", "factor": "hierarchical", "learned_minus_random_median": { "confidence_interval_95": [ -0.001795053482055664, -2.7815500895182293e-05 ], "mean": -0.0008765061696370443, "positive_seeds": 3, "two_sided_exact_sign_flip_p": 0.25, "values": [ -0.002044677734375, 7.200241088867188e-05, -0.002463817596435547, -0.0014061927795410156, 0.0003294944763183594, 0.0002541542053222656 ] }, "mean_exact_matching_fraction": 0.9117838541666666 }, { "checkpoint_words": 10000000, "condition": "shuffled", "factor": "order", "learned_minus_random_median": { "confidence_interval_95": [ -0.0011550585428873699, 0.0008141994476318359 ], "mean": -0.00027497609456380207, "positive_seeds": 2, "two_sided_exact_sign_flip_p": 0.65625, "values": [ -0.0010628700256347656, 0.0003032684326171875, -0.001678466796875, 0.002235889434814453, -0.0006837844848632812, -0.0007638931274414062 ] }, "mean_exact_matching_fraction": 0.9117838541666666 }, { "checkpoint_words": 10000000, "condition": "shuffled", "factor": "associative", "learned_minus_random_median": { "confidence_interval_95": [ -0.0006430943806966146, 0.0013820330301920574 ], "mean": 0.00034387906392415363, "positive_seeds": 4, "two_sided_exact_sign_flip_p": 0.59375, "values": [ 0.002410888671875, -0.0015516281127929688, 3.1948089599609375e-05, 0.00139617919921875, 0.0003390312194824219, -0.0005631446838378906 ] }, "mean_exact_matching_fraction": 0.9117838541666666 }, { "checkpoint_words": 30000000, "condition": "shuffled", "factor": "hierarchical", "learned_minus_random_median": { "confidence_interval_95": [ -0.002013603846232096, -0.0005588928858439127 ], "mean": -0.0011972983678181965, "positive_seeds": 0, "two_sided_exact_sign_flip_p": 0.03125, "values": [ -0.0007183551788330078, -0.0008411407470703125, -0.0006892681121826172, -0.002973318099975586, -0.00020766258239746094, -0.0017540454864501953 ] }, "mean_exact_matching_fraction": 0.9169921875 }, { "checkpoint_words": 30000000, "condition": "shuffled", "factor": "order", "learned_minus_random_median": { "confidence_interval_95": [ 0.0011266469955444336, 0.0027426481246948242 ], "mean": 0.001931309700012207, "positive_seeds": 6, "two_sided_exact_sign_flip_p": 0.03125, "values": [ 0.0035736560821533203, 0.0013041496276855469, 0.0016703605651855469, 0.0023038387298583984, 0.0023941993713378906, 0.00034165382385253906 ] }, "mean_exact_matching_fraction": 0.9169921875 }, { "checkpoint_words": 30000000, "condition": "shuffled", "factor": "associative", "learned_minus_random_median": { "confidence_interval_95": [ -0.0007306734720865885, 0.0005986690521240234 ], "mean": -2.9285748799641926e-05, "positive_seeds": 2, "two_sided_exact_sign_flip_p": 0.90625, "values": [ -7.486343383789062e-05, -0.00013709068298339844, 0.00038504600524902344, 0.0012857913970947266, -0.0014998912811279297, -0.0001347064971923828 ] }, "mean_exact_matching_fraction": 0.9169921875 } ], "raw_cells": 162 }, "primary_acquisition": { "claim_boundary": "Acquisition-trajectory evidence only; no human causality, persistent modularity, or leaderboard claim.", "complete": true, "lm_loss_noninferiority": { "margin_nats_per_token": 0.02, "paired_differences": [ 0.0015838082104311368, -0.00653062194730758, -0.005162638409691667, -0.062482217812380725, -0.01949286430529984, -0.043344135151058616 ], "passed": true }, "paired_seeds": [ { "aligned_auc": 41.9647378735038, "aligned_minus_shared": -0.10913044270033367, "aligned_minus_shuffled": -0.1480378142969343, "seed": 0, "shared_auc": 42.073868316204134, "shuffled_auc": 42.112775687800735 }, { "aligned_auc": 41.78627886112664, "aligned_minus_shared": -0.9209893531270836, "aligned_minus_shuffled": -0.5968538361991094, "seed": 1, "shared_auc": 42.70726821425372, "shuffled_auc": 42.38313269732575 }, { "aligned_auc": 42.30020013449295, "aligned_minus_shared": 0.40718146987685344, "aligned_minus_shuffled": -0.09908535062600521, "seed": 2, "shared_auc": 41.89301866461609, "shuffled_auc": 42.39928548511895 }, { "aligned_auc": 42.8088087045882, "aligned_minus_shared": 0.5532633582636066, "aligned_minus_shuffled": 0.4906796632259258, "seed": 3, "shared_auc": 42.255545346324595, "shuffled_auc": 42.318129041362276 }, { "aligned_auc": 42.238673271782595, "aligned_minus_shared": -0.05878804069950405, "aligned_minus_shuffled": 0.029909167629668332, "seed": 4, "shared_auc": 42.2974613124821, "shuffled_auc": 42.20876410415293 }, { "aligned_auc": 42.52377659635637, "aligned_minus_shared": -0.06301234027512237, "aligned_minus_shuffled": -0.2949629856468121, "seed": 5, "shared_auc": 42.58678893663149, "shuffled_auc": 42.81873958200318 } ], "primary": { "confidence_interval_95": [ -0.42061751215070586, 0.31580479361536956 ], "contrast": "aligned_minus_shared_log_exposure_auc", "mean": -0.031912558110263944, "positive_seeds": 2, "two_sided_exact_sign_flip_p": 0.8125 }, "schema_version": 1, "seed_unit": true, "shuffle_gate": { "confidence_interval_95": [ -0.35911677954007953, 0.17649122622728322 ], "contrast": "aligned_minus_shuffled_log_exposure_auc", "mean": -0.10305852598554448, "passed": false, "positive_seeds": 2, "two_sided_exact_sign_flip_p": 0.5 }, "terminal_exposure_words": 30000000, "trajectory_rows": 216 }, "reading_time": { "analysis": { "baseline": "frequency, length, position, previous length, and current/previous shared-condition surprisal", "candidate": "condition-specific current-word surprisal", "claim_boundary": "Held-out human prediction only; no intervention or human causality claim.", "endpoint": "log1p self-paced reading time", "grouping": "sentence sent_id", "rows": [ { "baseline_cv_r2": 0.1355724273453276, "condition": "aligned", "folds": 10, "full_cv_r2": 0.1344626563639283, "incremental_cv_r2": -0.001283821822100295, "observations": 1496, "seed": 0, "sentences": 205, "variant": "dial_aligned_s0" }, { "baseline_cv_r2": 0.1355724273453276, "condition": "shared", "folds": 10, "full_cv_r2": 0.1355724273453276, "incremental_cv_r2": 0.0, "observations": 1496, "seed": 0, "sentences": 205, "variant": "dial_shared_s0" }, { "baseline_cv_r2": 0.1355724273453276, "condition": "shuffled", "folds": 10, "full_cv_r2": 0.1343974526256645, "incremental_cv_r2": -0.0013592517832983209, "observations": 1496, "seed": 0, "sentences": 205, "variant": "dial_shuffled_s0" }, { "baseline_cv_r2": 0.12924652502596023, "condition": "aligned", "folds": 10, "full_cv_r2": 0.12909796143562668, "incremental_cv_r2": -0.00017061498415271714, "observations": 1496, "seed": 1, "sentences": 205, "variant": "dial_aligned_s1" }, { "baseline_cv_r2": 0.12924652502596023, "condition": "shared", "folds": 10, "full_cv_r2": 0.12924652502596023, "incremental_cv_r2": 0.0, "observations": 1496, "seed": 1, "sentences": 205, "variant": "dial_shared_s1" }, { "baseline_cv_r2": 0.12924652502596023, "condition": "shuffled", "folds": 10, "full_cv_r2": 0.12861127571574238, "incremental_cv_r2": -0.0007295397933804182, "observations": 1496, "seed": 1, "sentences": 205, "variant": "dial_shuffled_s1" }, { "baseline_cv_r2": 0.13786696731715353, "condition": "aligned", "folds": 10, "full_cv_r2": 0.13728632200380275, "incremental_cv_r2": -0.0006734985104837055, "observations": 1496, "seed": 2, "sentences": 205, "variant": "dial_aligned_s2" }, { "baseline_cv_r2": 0.13786696731715353, "condition": "shared", "folds": 10, "full_cv_r2": 0.13786696731715353, "incremental_cv_r2": 0.0, "observations": 1496, "seed": 2, "sentences": 205, "variant": "dial_shared_s2" }, { "baseline_cv_r2": 0.13786696731715353, "condition": "shuffled", "folds": 10, "full_cv_r2": 0.13708803977163153, "incremental_cv_r2": -0.0009034888074037628, "observations": 1496, "seed": 2, "sentences": 205, "variant": "dial_shuffled_s2" }, { "baseline_cv_r2": 0.13311039206812103, "condition": "aligned", "folds": 10, "full_cv_r2": 0.1338050586917391, "incremental_cv_r2": 0.0008013322772150167, "observations": 1496, "seed": 3, "sentences": 205, "variant": "dial_aligned_s3" }, { "baseline_cv_r2": 0.13311039206812103, "condition": "shared", "folds": 10, "full_cv_r2": 0.13311039206812103, "incremental_cv_r2": 0.0, "observations": 1496, "seed": 3, "sentences": 205, "variant": "dial_shared_s3" }, { "baseline_cv_r2": 0.13311039206812103, "condition": "shuffled", "folds": 10, "full_cv_r2": 0.13497043318955637, "incremental_cv_r2": 0.0021456493472944427, "observations": 1496, "seed": 3, "sentences": 205, "variant": "dial_shuffled_s3" }, { "baseline_cv_r2": 0.13375672902450286, "condition": "aligned", "folds": 10, "full_cv_r2": 0.13407572237766618, "incremental_cv_r2": 0.00036824915569522165, "observations": 1496, "seed": 4, "sentences": 205, "variant": "dial_aligned_s4" }, { "baseline_cv_r2": 0.13375672902450286, "condition": "shared", "folds": 10, "full_cv_r2": 0.13375672902450286, "incremental_cv_r2": 0.0, "observations": 1496, "seed": 4, "sentences": 205, "variant": "dial_shared_s4" }, { "baseline_cv_r2": 0.13375672902450286, "condition": "shuffled", "folds": 10, "full_cv_r2": 0.13371642878782064, "incremental_cv_r2": -4.652300113883179e-05, "observations": 1496, "seed": 4, "sentences": 205, "variant": "dial_shuffled_s4" }, { "baseline_cv_r2": 0.12890098964085217, "condition": "aligned", "folds": 10, "full_cv_r2": 0.1260213287398817, "incremental_cv_r2": -0.0033057790982717883, "observations": 1496, "seed": 5, "sentences": 205, "variant": "dial_aligned_s5" }, { "baseline_cv_r2": 0.12890098964085217, "condition": "shared", "folds": 10, "full_cv_r2": 0.12890098964085217, "incremental_cv_r2": 0.0, "observations": 1496, "seed": 5, "sentences": 205, "variant": "dial_shared_s5" }, { "baseline_cv_r2": 0.12890098964085217, "condition": "shuffled", "folds": 10, "full_cv_r2": 0.12709860998855138, "incremental_cv_r2": -0.0020690870163628805, "observations": 1496, "seed": 5, "sentences": 205, "variant": "dial_shuffled_s5" } ], "schema_version": 1, "terminal_exposure_words": 30000000 }, "paired_contrasts": { "aligned_minus_shared": { "confidence_interval_95": [ -0.0018560870288880278, 0.0002431781262778506 ], "mean": -0.0007106888303497113, "positive_seeds": 2, "two_sided_exact_sign_flip_p": 0.3125, "values": [ -0.001283821822100295, -0.00017061498415271714, -0.0006734985104837055, 0.0008013322772150167, 0.00036824915569522165, -0.0033057790982717883 ] }, "aligned_minus_shuffled": { "confidence_interval_95": [ -0.0008195479477462649, 0.0003686974971202073 ], "mean": -0.00021698198796808268, "positive_seeds": 4, "two_sided_exact_sign_flip_p": 0.53125, "values": [ 7.542996119802581e-05, 0.000558924809227701, 0.00022999029692005735, -0.001344317070079426, 0.00041477215683405344, -0.0012366920819089078 ] } } }, "schema_version": 1, "terminal_exposure_words": 30000000 }