Prompt: The woman gently tilts her head to the left while maintaining eye contact with the man, her expression softening into a subtle smile. The man stands still, holding her hands firmly as they face each other. The camera performs a slow, smooth dolly-in movement, gradually tightening the framing on the couple. They are positioned in a lush, sunlit outdoor setting with a stone wall behind them, remaining largely stationary as the camera pushes forward.

Explanation: The video maintains high fidelity to the first frame and captures the requested emotional tone well. While the camera movement is technically present, it is quite slow and subtle, and the head tilt could be more dynamic to fully satisfy the prompt's description. | overall_score=85 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":90,"motion_quality":80,"temporal_consistency":85,"visual_quality":90,"camera_composition":75}

Explanation: The video maintains high fidelity to the first frame and captures the requested subjects and setting well. However, the motion is quite static; the requested dolly-in is barely perceptible, and the head tilt is minimal, resulting in a somewhat stiff performance. | overall_score=82 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":85,"motion_quality":75,"temporal_consistency":80,"visual_quality":85,"camera_composition":70}

Explanation: The video maintains high fidelity to the conditioning frame and exhibits strong visual quality. However, it falls short on the specific motion requirements, as the requested dolly-in movement is barely perceptible and the head tilt is minimal. | overall_score=82 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":85,"motion_quality":75,"temporal_consistency":80,"visual_quality":85,"camera_composition":70}


Prompt: The white sea foam recedes rapidly toward the bottom of the frame as the ocean water pulls back from the shore. The turbulent, bubbly water flows in a consistent downward direction, revealing the darker, calmer water beneath the surface as the foam dissipates. The camera remains in a static, top-down aerial position, maintaining a fixed, high-angle framing of the shoreline throughout the entire sequence. This is a top-down view of ocean waves retreating across a sandy beach.

Explanation: The video demonstrates high-quality motion synthesis that perfectly matches the provided first frame and the prompt's requirements for receding sea foam. The temporal consistency is strong, with no noticeable flickering or geometry artifacts. | overall_score=92 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":98,"prompt_adherence":95,"motion_quality":90,"temporal_consistency":95,"visual_quality":92,"camera_composition":90}

Explanation: The video successfully captures the requested motion of receding sea foam with high visual fidelity and temporal stability. The movement is natural and aligns perfectly with the provided first frame. | overall_score=92 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":98,"prompt_adherence":95,"motion_quality":90,"temporal_consistency":92,"visual_quality":95,"camera_composition":90}

Explanation: The video successfully captures the requested motion of receding sea foam with high visual fidelity and temporal stability. The camera remains static as requested, and the transition from the initial frame to the animation is seamless. | overall_score=92 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":98,"prompt_adherence":95,"motion_quality":90,"temporal_consistency":92,"visual_quality":95,"camera_composition":90}


Prompt: A small white motorboat travels steadily from right to left across the dark water, leaving a long, V-shaped wake behind it that ripples toward the shore. The camera remains static in a high-angle aerial view, maintaining a fixed wide framing of the scene. The subject is a boat navigating a calm lake bordered by a lush green forest and a small cluster of traditional red wooden houses on the grassy bank.

Explanation: The video maintains high fidelity to the conditioning frame and effectively captures the requested scene elements. The motion is generally smooth, though there is a slight inconsistency in the wake's movement relative to the boat's speed. | overall_score=92 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":98,"prompt_adherence":95,"motion_quality":90,"temporal_consistency":92,"visual_quality":95,"camera_composition":90}

Explanation: The video maintains high fidelity to the conditioning frame and follows the prompt's instructions well. The motion is generally smooth, though there is a slight inconsistency in the boat's speed and minor jitter in the wake ripples. | overall_score=92 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":98,"prompt_adherence":95,"motion_quality":90,"temporal_consistency":92,"visual_quality":95,"camera_composition":90}

Explanation: The video maintains high fidelity to the conditioning frame and adheres well to the prompt's requirements. While the motion of the boat and the wake could be more fluid and physically accurate, the overall quality is very high. | overall_score=92 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":98,"prompt_adherence":95,"motion_quality":90,"temporal_consistency":92,"visual_quality":95,"camera_composition":90}


Prompt: Ocean waves roll steadily toward the shore, breaking into white foam as they travel from the bottom left toward the center of the frame. The water surface exhibits constant, rhythmic motion while the sandy beach and distant hills remain completely stationary. The camera maintains a static, high-angle aerial perspective, capturing the expansive coastal landscape. This scene depicts a tranquil, sunlit beach where the only movement is the continuous, gentle progression of incoming surf across the turquoise shallows.

Explanation: While the model successfully maintains the composition and fidelity of the first frame, it fails almost entirely to generate the requested motion of the ocean waves, resulting in a near-static image with only minor, unnatural artifacts. | overall_score=25 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":20,"motion_quality":10,"temporal_consistency":20,"visual_quality":30,"camera_composition":80}

Explanation: While the video perfectly matches the first frame and maintains the correct composition, it fails significantly on the primary requirement of generating motion. The ocean waves are static, and the video lacks the dynamic, rhythmic movement described in the prompt. | overall_score=25 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":20,"motion_quality":10,"temporal_consistency":10,"visual_quality":30,"camera_composition":90}

Explanation: While the model successfully maintains the initial composition and fidelity to the first frame, it fails completely to generate the requested motion. The video appears as a near-static image with only minor, distracting pixel-level artifacts rather than the fluid, rhythmic movement of ocean waves. | overall_score=25 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":20,"motion_quality":10,"temporal_consistency":10,"visual_quality":30,"camera_composition":90}


Prompt: The wheat field exhibits a gentle, rhythmic swaying motion as a breeze moves across the stalks from left to right throughout the clip. The camera remains completely static, maintaining a wide, fixed framing of the landscape. This scene features a vast, sunlit wheat field under a bright sky, with a few small red poppies visible in the foreground. The motion is defined solely by the consistent, fluid rippling of the grain heads as they bend in the wind.

Explanation: The video is highly faithful to the first frame and adheres well to the prompt's requirements for a static camera and a sunlit wheat field. While the motion is present and consistent, it could be more dynamic to better capture the 'rhythmic swaying' described in the prompt. | overall_score=85 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":90,"motion_quality":80,"temporal_consistency":85,"visual_quality":90,"camera_composition":95}

Explanation: The video adheres very well to the prompt and maintains high visual fidelity to the first frame. The motion is present and natural, though it could be more dynamic to better capture the 'rhythmic swaying' described. | overall_score=85 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":90,"motion_quality":80,"temporal_consistency":85,"visual_quality":90,"camera_composition":95}

Explanation: The video adheres very well to the prompt's requirements for a static camera and a sunlit wheat field. While the motion is present and fluid, it is a bit understated compared to the 'rhythmic swaying' requested, but the overall visual fidelity and temporal stability are high. | overall_score=85 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":90,"motion_quality":80,"temporal_consistency":85,"visual_quality":90,"camera_composition":95}


Prompt: The camera performs a slow, steady dolly forward along a dirt path through a dense, foggy forest. In the distance, a small group of people walks away from the camera, moving slowly deeper into the woods. Their figures remain small and centered in the frame throughout the entire duration. The surrounding trees and the path remain completely still, with no wind or other movement visible in the environment, emphasizing the quiet, steady progression of the subjects moving into the mist.

Explanation: The video maintains high visual fidelity to the first frame and captures the requested atmosphere well. However, the motion is too subtle to clearly represent the requested dolly movement and the walking action of the subjects. | overall_score=85 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":90,"motion_quality":80,"temporal_consistency":85,"visual_quality":85,"camera_composition":80}

Explanation: The video maintains high visual fidelity to the conditioning frame and adheres well to the prompt's atmospheric requirements. However, the requested 'slow, steady dolly forward' is barely perceptible, making the motion feel somewhat static rather than a deliberate camera move. | overall_score=85 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":90,"motion_quality":80,"temporal_consistency":85,"visual_quality":90,"camera_composition":80}

Explanation: The video maintains high visual quality and strong fidelity to the conditioning frame. While the camera movement is technically present, it is too slow to effectively convey the requested 'dolly forward' motion, and there is minor temporal instability in the subjects' movement. | overall_score=85 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":90,"motion_quality":80,"temporal_consistency":85,"visual_quality":90,"camera_composition":80}


Prompt: The water in the central fountain flows continuously, with a tall, steady vertical jet rising from the center while smaller surrounding jets spray water outward in a constant, rhythmic pattern. The camera remains completely static throughout the entire five-second duration, maintaining a wide, fixed framing of the scene. This shot captures a large, tiered stone fountain situated in the middle of a paved public park, surrounded by tall evergreen trees and scattered pedestrians walking in the background.

Explanation: The video maintains high fidelity to the first frame and adheres well to the prompt's requirements for a static camera and continuous water flow. The motion is generally smooth, though there are minor inconsistencies in the water's rhythmic pattern and some slight unnatural movement in the background figures. | overall_score=92 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":98,"prompt_adherence":95,"motion_quality":90,"temporal_consistency":95,"visual_quality":95,"camera_composition":90}

Explanation: The video maintains high fidelity to the first frame and adheres well to the prompt's requirements for a static camera and continuous water flow. While there is some minor jitter in the water animation and slight unnatural movement of background figures, the overall quality is very high. | overall_score=92 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":98,"prompt_adherence":95,"motion_quality":90,"temporal_consistency":95,"visual_quality":95,"camera_composition":90}

Explanation: The video maintains high fidelity to the first frame and successfully captures the requested fountain motion. While the water animation is slightly repetitive and exhibits minor flickering, the overall visual quality and adherence to the prompt are very strong. | overall_score=92 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":98,"prompt_adherence":95,"motion_quality":90,"temporal_consistency":95,"visual_quality":90,"camera_composition":95}


Prompt: A female boxer in a gym delivers a rapid, rhythmic series of straight punches toward a trainer holding focus mitts. She maintains a steady, forward-thrusting motion with her right arm, while the trainer actively adjusts the position of the red mitts to meet each strike. The camera remains static in a medium shot, capturing the repetitive, high-intensity exchange between the two athletes as they focus on their training drill.

Explanation: The video maintains high fidelity to the first frame and effectively captures the requested boxing action with good motion quality. While there are minor temporal artifacts in the glove movement, the overall visual quality and adherence to the prompt are strong. | overall_score=85 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":90,"motion_quality":85,"temporal_consistency":80,"visual_quality":85,"camera_composition":95}

Explanation: The video maintains high fidelity to the first frame and effectively captures the requested action. However, it suffers from noticeable artifacts in the form of glove morphing and mitt instability during the high-speed motion, which detracts from the overall temporal consistency. | overall_score=82 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":90,"motion_quality":85,"temporal_consistency":75,"visual_quality":80,"camera_composition":90}

Explanation: The video maintains high fidelity to the conditioning frame and effectively captures the requested rhythmic boxing action. While there are minor temporal artifacts in the gloves during high-speed motion, the overall quality and adherence to the prompt are very high. | overall_score=85 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":90,"motion_quality":85,"temporal_consistency":80,"visual_quality":85,"camera_composition":90}


Prompt: The swimmer rests her hands on the edge of the pool, gently moving her arms and shoulders to maintain her position in the water. The camera remains static, maintaining a medium shot of the swimmer from the chest up. The water surface ripples subtly around her as she breathes steadily, her body bobbing slightly with the movement of the pool. A competitive swimmer in a swim cap and goggles waits at the edge of a lane in a dimly lit indoor pool.

Explanation: The video maintains high fidelity to the first frame and captures the requested atmosphere well. While the motion is generally good, there is some minor jitter in the hands and the water simulation is slightly artificial, but overall it is a high-quality generation. | overall_score=85 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":98,"prompt_adherence":95,"motion_quality":80,"temporal_consistency":85,"visual_quality":85,"camera_composition":95}

Explanation: The video maintains high fidelity to the conditioning frame and effectively captures the requested scene. While the hand motion is slightly mechanical, the overall visual quality and temporal stability are high. | overall_score=85 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":90,"motion_quality":80,"temporal_consistency":85,"visual_quality":90,"camera_composition":95}

Explanation: The video maintains high fidelity to the conditioning frame and effectively captures the requested atmosphere and composition. While the motion of the hands is slightly jittery and the water simulation is somewhat basic, the overall quality is high and consistent. | overall_score=88 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":98,"prompt_adherence":95,"motion_quality":85,"temporal_consistency":90,"visual_quality":92,"camera_composition":95}


Prompt: A person in a red jacket rappels slowly down the center of a steep, rocky waterfall, descending vertically while suspended by a rope. The water flows continuously downward over the dark, jagged rock face. The camera remains static throughout the entire shot, maintaining a wide, high-angle framing of the waterfall and the surrounding lush, green vegetation on the cliff sides. The subject maintains a steady, controlled downward movement against the constant, rushing motion of the cascading water.

Explanation: The video successfully maintains the static camera and the overall scene composition from the first frame. While the subject's motion is slightly unnatural, the prompt requirements are largely met with high visual fidelity. | overall_score=85 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":90,"motion_quality":80,"temporal_consistency":85,"visual_quality":85,"camera_composition":90}

Explanation: The video maintains high fidelity to the conditioning frame and successfully captures the requested scene. While the subject's motion is slightly unnatural and jittery, the overall composition and visual quality are strong. | overall_score=85 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":90,"motion_quality":80,"temporal_consistency":85,"visual_quality":85,"camera_composition":90}

Explanation: The video demonstrates high fidelity to the conditioning frame and successfully captures the requested scene elements. While the motion of the subject is slightly unnatural and exhibits minor temporal instability, the overall quality and adherence to the prompt are strong. | overall_score=85 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":90,"motion_quality":80,"temporal_consistency":85,"visual_quality":85,"camera_composition":90}


Prompt: The camera performs a slow, smooth dolly-in movement toward the central stone cross, gradually tightening the framing on the monument. As the camera advances, the green foliage in the background shifts slightly due to the changing perspective, while the foreground elements remain static. The scene depicts a quiet, sunlit cemetery setting with various headstones and a prominent central cross, maintaining a steady, deliberate pace throughout the entire five-second duration of the shot.

Explanation: The video is visually high-quality and perfectly matches the first frame, but the requested 'dolly-in' movement is too slow and subtle to be clearly perceived as a deliberate camera action, resulting in a slightly static feel. | overall_score=85 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":80,"motion_quality":85,"temporal_consistency":90,"visual_quality":90,"camera_composition":70}

Explanation: The video maintains high visual fidelity and temporal stability, but the requested dolly-in camera movement is too slow and subtle to be clearly perceived as a deliberate, smooth advancement toward the subject. | overall_score=85 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":80,"motion_quality":85,"temporal_consistency":90,"visual_quality":90,"camera_composition":70}

Explanation: The video maintains high visual fidelity and temporal stability, but the requested dolly-in camera movement is too subtle to clearly convey the intended cinematic effect. | overall_score=85 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":80,"motion_quality":85,"temporal_consistency":90,"visual_quality":90,"camera_composition":75}


Prompt: The camera performs a smooth, continuous forward dolly movement over the National Coal Mining Museum, maintaining a high-angle aerial perspective throughout the shot. A white car travels steadily along the road on the right side of the frame, moving from the bottom toward the top of the screen. No other objects or subjects exhibit motion during the sequence. The scene remains focused on the industrial complex and surrounding woodland as the camera advances steadily toward the horizon.

Explanation: The video maintains high fidelity to the first frame and successfully incorporates the requested car movement. While the camera movement is a bit subtle, the overall temporal consistency and visual quality are strong. | overall_score=85 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":90,"motion_quality":85,"temporal_consistency":85,"visual_quality":90,"camera_composition":80}

Explanation: The video successfully maintains the first frame's integrity and follows the prompt's instructions regarding the camera movement and the car's path. While the motion is slightly jittery, the overall visual quality and adherence to the scene description are high. | overall_score=85 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":90,"motion_quality":80,"temporal_consistency":85,"visual_quality":90,"camera_composition":80}

Explanation: The video effectively captures the requested scene and camera movement with high fidelity to the conditioning frame. While the motion of the car and the camera could be smoother, the overall execution is highly competent and adheres well to the prompt. | overall_score=85 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":90,"motion_quality":85,"temporal_consistency":85,"visual_quality":90,"camera_composition":80}


Prompt: The tall reeds sway rhythmically in a steady breeze, with the feathery tops bending and oscillating back and forth in a gentle, continuous motion. The camera remains completely static, maintaining a fixed, low-angle framing of the plants against the sky. This scene captures a dense patch of golden-brown reeds in an open field, where the stalks and plumes move in unison as the wind passes through them, creating a soft, fluid, and repetitive natural motion throughout the entire five-second duration.

Explanation: The video demonstrates high fidelity to the first frame and effectively captures the requested motion of reeds in a breeze. The temporal consistency is strong, though there is a slight repetitive quality to the motion cycle and minor background jitter. | overall_score=92 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":98,"prompt_adherence":95,"motion_quality":90,"temporal_consistency":92,"visual_quality":95,"camera_composition":90}

Explanation: The video demonstrates high fidelity to the first frame and effectively captures the requested rhythmic motion of the reeds in the wind. The camera remains static as requested, and the overall visual quality is high with no significant temporal artifacts. | overall_score=92 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":100,"prompt_adherence":95,"motion_quality":90,"temporal_consistency":95,"visual_quality":95,"camera_composition":90}

Explanation: The video demonstrates high fidelity to the first frame and effectively captures the requested rhythmic motion of the reeds in the wind. The temporal consistency is strong, and the overall visual quality is high, with only minor, negligible jitter in the background elements. | overall_score=92 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":98,"prompt_adherence":95,"motion_quality":90,"temporal_consistency":95,"visual_quality":95,"camera_composition":90}


Prompt: The camera performs a smooth, continuous pan to the right, revealing a bustling studio space. In the foreground, a man sits in a chair, looking down at his phone. In the background, multiple people move across the room, including a woman walking toward the left and others gathering around a dining table. The scene captures a dynamic, multi-layered environment where several individuals are engaged in various activities, transitioning from a focused foreground subject to a wider, active social setting.

Explanation: While the first frame is highly accurate to the conditioning image, the video quickly devolves into severe temporal instability, with characters morphing, changing clothes, and appearing/disappearing. The requested camera pan is jerky and inconsistent, and the background activity fails to maintain any logical coherence. | overall_score=35 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":90,"prompt_adherence":30,"motion_quality":20,"temporal_consistency":20,"visual_quality":40,"camera_composition":30}

Explanation: While the video starts with high fidelity to the conditioning frame, it quickly degrades into a series of temporal inconsistencies and severe character morphing. The requested camera pan is jerky rather than smooth, and the background activity fails to follow the prompt's narrative, instead showing random character generation and disappearance. | overall_score=35 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":85,"prompt_adherence":40,"motion_quality":20,"temporal_consistency":20,"visual_quality":40,"camera_composition":30}

Explanation: While the first frame is highly accurate to the conditioning image, the video quickly degrades into severe temporal instability, with characters morphing and changing identities throughout the sequence. The requested camera pan is jerky and inconsistent, and the background activity becomes chaotic and incoherent. | overall_score=35 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":90,"prompt_adherence":30,"motion_quality":20,"temporal_consistency":20,"visual_quality":40,"camera_composition":30}


Prompt: The cluster of white daisy-like flowers sways gently and rhythmically from side to side, driven by a light breeze. The stems and petals oscillate in a continuous, fluid motion against a dark, blurred background. The camera remains completely static throughout the five-second duration, maintaining a fixed, medium-close framing of the wildflowers. This steady, natural movement of the plants is the only action occurring within the quiet, outdoor setting.

Explanation: The video successfully maintains the static camera and the subject matter from the first frame. While the motion is slightly repetitive and exhibits minor texture flickering, it effectively captures the requested gentle, rhythmic swaying of the wildflowers. | overall_score=85 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":90,"motion_quality":80,"temporal_consistency":85,"visual_quality":85,"camera_composition":90}

Explanation: The video successfully maintains the composition and subject of the first frame, but suffers from minor temporal artifacts and jittery motion that detract from the requested fluid, rhythmic swaying. | overall_score=82 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":90,"motion_quality":75,"temporal_consistency":70,"visual_quality":85,"camera_composition":95}

Explanation: The video successfully maintains the composition and subject of the first frame while adhering to the prompt's requirement for a static camera and swaying motion. The motion is generally good, though it exhibits some minor temporal instability and flickering in the flower petals. | overall_score=82 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":90,"motion_quality":75,"temporal_consistency":80,"visual_quality":85,"camera_composition":90}


Prompt: The young girl slowly rotates her body while holding the instructor's hand, performing a gentle, controlled spin on the ice. The instructor remains stationary, acting as a pivot point while guiding the girl through the rotation. The camera is static, maintaining a wide, eye-level shot of the pair centered on the ice rink. This scene features an ice skating instructor and a young student practicing a basic spin together in an indoor arena.

Explanation: The video maintains high visual fidelity and adheres well to the prompt's scene description, though the actual motion of the spin is a bit constrained and lacks the dynamic fluidity expected in a skating maneuver. | overall_score=82 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":85,"motion_quality":75,"temporal_consistency":80,"visual_quality":90,"camera_composition":85}

Explanation: The video successfully captures the requested action of a gentle spin on ice while maintaining high fidelity to the initial frame. While the motion is slightly mechanical, it remains consistent and adheres well to the prompt's requirements. | overall_score=85 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":90,"motion_quality":80,"temporal_consistency":85,"visual_quality":90,"camera_composition":90}

Explanation: The video maintains high fidelity to the conditioning frame and successfully captures the requested action of a spin on ice. While the motion is slightly mechanical, it is generally consistent and adheres well to the prompt's requirements. | overall_score=85 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":90,"motion_quality":80,"temporal_consistency":85,"visual_quality":90,"camera_composition":95}


Prompt: Multiple tropical fish swim steadily across a coral reef aquarium. A large, striped fish glides slowly from the left foreground toward the center, while a smaller, reddish-orange fish moves rightward across the sandy bottom. Other smaller fish hover near the rocks or drift in the background. The camera remains static, maintaining a fixed, wide-angle view of the underwater scene throughout the entire duration of the clip.

Explanation: The video maintains high fidelity to the first frame and follows the prompt's instructions regarding the movement of specific fish very well. The motion is generally fluid, though there are minor instances of unnatural swimming patterns and slight temporal jitter in the background elements. | overall_score=88 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":98,"prompt_adherence":95,"motion_quality":85,"temporal_consistency":85,"visual_quality":90,"camera_composition":95}

Explanation: The video maintains high fidelity to the first frame and successfully executes the requested movements for the specific fish described in the prompt. While there is some minor jitter and slightly unnatural motion in the fish, the overall visual quality and temporal consistency are very high. | overall_score=88 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":98,"prompt_adherence":95,"motion_quality":85,"temporal_consistency":85,"visual_quality":90,"camera_composition":95}

Explanation: The video maintains high fidelity to the conditioning frame and effectively captures the requested motion of the fish. While there is some minor jitter in the animation of the smaller fish, the overall temporal consistency and visual quality are high. | overall_score=88 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":98,"prompt_adherence":95,"motion_quality":85,"temporal_consistency":85,"visual_quality":90,"camera_composition":95}


Prompt: The palm tree fronds sway gently and continuously in the breeze throughout the entire duration of the clip. Simultaneously, the ocean waves roll steadily toward the shore, breaking into white foam along the beach. The camera remains in a fixed, static position, maintaining a wide, elevated framing of the coastal scene. This shot captures a tranquil beachfront setting with high-rise apartment buildings positioned behind a dense row of palm trees.

Explanation: The video successfully maintains the static camera composition and high-fidelity first frame. While the motion of the palm trees is a bit restrained, the overall scene is tranquil and adheres well to the prompt's requirements. | overall_score=85 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":90,"motion_quality":80,"temporal_consistency":85,"visual_quality":90,"camera_composition":95}

Explanation: The video is a high-quality generation that adheres well to the prompt's requirements for a static camera and specific environmental elements. While the motion of the palm trees is slightly understated, the overall temporal consistency and visual fidelity are very strong. | overall_score=85 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":90,"motion_quality":80,"temporal_consistency":85,"visual_quality":90,"camera_composition":95}


Prompt: A white car drives rapidly from left to right across the foreground, exiting the frame. Simultaneously, a red tram travels steadily from right to left along the tracks in the background, passing behind a stationary bus stop. A second white car follows the first, moving from left to right in the foreground. The camera remains static throughout the entire sequence, capturing the urban street scene with a fixed, wide-angle perspective as vehicles and the tram move in opposite directions.

Explanation: While the video maintains the static camera and initial scene composition well, it fails significantly on the specific motion requirements of the prompt. The vehicles do not follow the described paths, with the first car vanishing and the second car popping into existence, and the tram's motion is inconsistent. | overall_score=45 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":90,"prompt_adherence":40,"motion_quality":30,"temporal_consistency":35,"visual_quality":60,"camera_composition":80}

Explanation: While the video maintains the static camera and initial scene composition well, it fails significantly on the specific motion requirements. The first car vanishes mid-frame, and the second car pops into existence rather than entering from the left, violating the prompt's narrative flow. | overall_score=45 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":90,"prompt_adherence":40,"motion_quality":30,"temporal_consistency":35,"visual_quality":60,"camera_composition":80}

Explanation: While the video maintains the static camera and initial scene composition, it fails significantly on the motion requirements. The first car vanishes mid-frame, and the second car pops into existence rather than entering from the left, violating the prompt's narrative flow. | overall_score=45 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":90,"prompt_adherence":40,"motion_quality":30,"temporal_consistency":30,"visual_quality":60,"camera_composition":80}


Prompt: The camera performs a steady, slow forward dolly movement over a bridge spanning a frozen, snow-covered bay. Multiple cars travel consistently away from the camera along the road, moving toward the roundabout and the town center in the distance. The perspective remains high and centered, maintaining a stable aerial view of the bridge and the surrounding urban landscape throughout the entire duration of the clip.

Explanation: The video maintains high visual fidelity and successfully captures the requested scene, though the camera movement is too minimal to fully satisfy the 'forward dolly' requirement, and the vehicle motion lacks fluid, natural consistency. | overall_score=85 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":90,"motion_quality":80,"temporal_consistency":85,"visual_quality":90,"camera_composition":80}

Explanation: The video maintains high visual fidelity and adheres well to the scene description, but the requested camera movement is too minimal to be effective, and the vehicle motion lacks smooth, realistic flow. | overall_score=85 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":90,"motion_quality":80,"temporal_consistency":85,"visual_quality":90,"camera_composition":80}

Explanation: The video maintains high visual fidelity and successfully captures the scene, but the requested camera movement is too minimal to be effective, and there is minor jitter in the motion of the vehicles. | overall_score=85 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":90,"motion_quality":80,"temporal_consistency":85,"visual_quality":90,"camera_composition":80}


Prompt: A London Underground train departs the station, moving steadily from left to right across the frame. As the train exits, the camera performs a smooth, continuous pan to the left, tracking along the platform. A station worker in a high-visibility vest walks slowly in the opposite direction of the train, while a woman walks past the bench toward the left. The scene captures a busy subway platform at Hammersmith station with commuters moving through the space during the train departure.

Explanation: While the video starts with high fidelity to the conditioning frame, it quickly degrades into severe temporal instability and identity drift. The motion is unnatural, and the specific actions requested in the prompt (the woman walking, the smooth camera pan) are either missing or executed with significant visual artifacts. | overall_score=35 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":85,"prompt_adherence":30,"motion_quality":20,"temporal_consistency":25,"visual_quality":40,"camera_composition":30}

Explanation: While the video starts with high fidelity to the conditioning frame, it fails significantly on prompt adherence regarding camera movement and character consistency. The motion is highly unstable, and the requested pan never occurs, resulting in a static and disjointed sequence. | overall_score=35 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":85,"prompt_adherence":30,"motion_quality":20,"temporal_consistency":25,"visual_quality":40,"camera_composition":30}

Explanation: While the video starts with high fidelity to the conditioning frame, it fails significantly on almost every other prompt requirement. The camera does not pan as requested, and the characters exhibit severe temporal instability and identity drift, making the scene incoherent. | overall_score=35 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":85,"prompt_adherence":30,"motion_quality":20,"temporal_consistency":25,"visual_quality":40,"camera_composition":30}


Prompt: A dark car drives from the right foreground across the intersection toward the left, while a large white coach travels from the right background toward the foreground, eventually exiting the frame. A white van follows the coach in the same lane. Pedestrians walk along the sidewalks on both sides of the street. The camera remains static, capturing a wide-angle view of a busy city street intersection with multiple vehicles and people moving through the urban scene.

Explanation: The video starts with high fidelity to the conditioning frame but fails to maintain the identity of the coach, which morphs into a bus. The lack of the requested white van and the poor temporal consistency of the moving vehicles significantly detract from the overall quality. | overall_score=65 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":70,"motion_quality":60,"temporal_consistency":55,"visual_quality":70,"camera_composition":80}

Explanation: While the video starts with high fidelity to the conditioning frame, it fails to maintain the identity of the vehicles (the coach turns into a bus) and misses key elements of the prompt like the white van and active pedestrians. The motion of the larger vehicle is plagued by morphing artifacts, reducing the overall temporal consistency. | overall_score=65 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":70,"motion_quality":60,"temporal_consistency":55,"visual_quality":70,"camera_composition":80}

Explanation: The video starts with high fidelity to the conditioning frame but suffers from significant object identity issues, specifically the transformation of the coach into a bus. While the camera and environment are stable, the failure to include the requested white van and the unnatural motion of the vehicles detract from the overall prompt adherence. | overall_score=68 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":75,"motion_quality":60,"temporal_consistency":65,"visual_quality":70,"camera_composition":80}


Prompt: A hand holding a champagne flute moves steadily from the left side of the frame toward the center, bringing the glass closer to the laptop screen to toast the people on the video call. The camera remains static throughout the shot, maintaining a fixed, close-up framing of the hand and the laptop. The scene features a person participating in a holiday video call, with the subjects on the screen smiling and holding their own glasses up to meet the toast.

Explanation: The video successfully executes the requested motion and maintains the composition well. However, the glass undergoes noticeable warping and the screen reflection lacks temporal stability, which detracts from the overall realism. | overall_score=82 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":85,"motion_quality":80,"temporal_consistency":75,"visual_quality":85,"camera_composition":90}

Explanation: The video successfully executes the requested motion while maintaining high fidelity to the initial frame. There is some minor temporal instability in the glass's appearance during the movement, but it does not significantly detract from the overall quality. | overall_score=85 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":90,"motion_quality":85,"temporal_consistency":80,"visual_quality":85,"camera_composition":90}

Explanation: The video successfully executes the requested motion of the hand and glass while maintaining the static camera composition. There is minor temporal instability in the glass's appearance as it moves, but the overall quality is high and adheres well to the prompt. | overall_score=85 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":90,"motion_quality":85,"temporal_consistency":80,"visual_quality":85,"camera_composition":90}


Prompt: Thick, low-hanging clouds drift steadily from left to right across the face of a jagged, rocky mountain peak. The movement of the mist is continuous and fluid, partially obscuring the craggy surface as it flows past the stationary rock formation. In the foreground, a small tree remains perfectly still, providing a sharp contrast to the constant, horizontal motion of the clouds. The camera is completely static throughout the entire duration of the clip, maintaining a fixed, wide-angle framing of the mountain.

Explanation: The video demonstrates high-quality motion synthesis, effectively capturing the requested cloud movement while keeping the foreground tree and camera perfectly static. The first frame is identical to the conditioning frame, and the temporal consistency is maintained throughout the duration of the clip. | overall_score=92 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":100,"prompt_adherence":95,"motion_quality":90,"temporal_consistency":95,"visual_quality":90,"camera_composition":90}

Explanation: The video demonstrates high fidelity to the conditioning frame and effectively captures the requested motion of clouds drifting across a mountain. The temporal consistency is strong, and the camera remains static as instructed, though there are minor compression artifacts. | overall_score=92 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":100,"prompt_adherence":95,"motion_quality":90,"temporal_consistency":95,"visual_quality":90,"camera_composition":90}

Explanation: The video demonstrates high fidelity to the conditioning frame and effectively captures the requested atmospheric motion. The cloud movement is fluid and consistent, and the static elements remain stable throughout the duration of the clip. | overall_score=92 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":100,"prompt_adherence":95,"motion_quality":90,"temporal_consistency":95,"visual_quality":90,"camera_composition":90}


Prompt: The chipmunk remains stationary on the wooden stump, rhythmically chewing with its mouth while its front paws hold and manipulate a piece of a peanut shell. The animal's jaw moves up and down consistently throughout the entire duration of the clip. The camera remains completely static, maintaining a fixed, eye-level side profile framing of the chipmunk as it eats. The background of lush green foliage stays still, emphasizing the focused, repetitive motion of the chipmunk's feeding.

Explanation: The video maintains high fidelity to the conditioning frame and adheres well to the prompt's requirements for a static camera and subject. The motion is natural, though the chewing action is somewhat minimal. | overall_score=92 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":100,"prompt_adherence":95,"motion_quality":85,"temporal_consistency":95,"visual_quality":95,"camera_composition":100}

Explanation: The video maintains high fidelity to the conditioning frame and adheres well to the prompt's requirements for a static camera and subject. While the chewing motion is present, it is slightly understated, but the overall temporal consistency and visual quality are very high. | overall_score=92 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":100,"prompt_adherence":95,"motion_quality":85,"temporal_consistency":95,"visual_quality":95,"camera_composition":100}

Explanation: The video demonstrates high-quality generation with excellent adherence to the prompt and the conditioning frame. The motion of the chipmunk is natural and consistent throughout the clip, with no significant artifacts or temporal instability. | overall_score=92 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":100,"prompt_adherence":95,"motion_quality":90,"temporal_consistency":95,"visual_quality":95,"camera_composition":100}


Prompt: A large ferry moves steadily forward through a narrow, muddy river channel, leaving a visible white wake behind its stern. The camera remains static, maintaining a high-angle, wide shot of the vessel as it travels from the left side of the frame toward the open water in the distance. The scene captures the ferry navigating the waterway, with the surrounding marshy banks and distant horizon remaining fixed throughout the entire duration of the clip.

Explanation: While the model successfully maintains the visual fidelity of the first frame, it fails significantly on motion quality, as the generated video is effectively static with no meaningful movement of the ferry or the water. | overall_score=25 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":30,"motion_quality":10,"temporal_consistency":20,"visual_quality":30,"camera_composition":60}

Explanation: While the model successfully maintains the visual integrity of the first frame, it fails significantly on motion quality, as the generated video is effectively a static image with no meaningful movement of the ferry or the water. | overall_score=25 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":40,"motion_quality":10,"temporal_consistency":10,"visual_quality":30,"camera_composition":60}


Prompt: The water flows rapidly from the left toward the right, churning and bubbling as it cascades over and around the dark, snow-dusted rocks in the foreground. A single brown leaf remains suspended in the center of the frame, bobbing slightly in the current. The camera remains completely static throughout the entire duration of the clip, maintaining a fixed, eye-level perspective of the river as it cuts through the snow-covered forest landscape.

Explanation: The video maintains high fidelity to the conditioning frame and adheres well to the prompt. While the water motion is generally good, there is some minor temporal instability in the texture of the flowing water, and the leaf's movement feels slightly artificial. | overall_score=88 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":98,"prompt_adherence":95,"motion_quality":85,"temporal_consistency":80,"visual_quality":90,"camera_composition":95}

Explanation: The video maintains high fidelity to the conditioning frame and adheres well to the prompt's requirements for a static camera and specific environmental elements. While there is some minor temporal instability in the water's surface, the overall visual quality and motion are quite convincing. | overall_score=88 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":98,"prompt_adherence":95,"motion_quality":85,"temporal_consistency":80,"visual_quality":90,"camera_composition":95}

Explanation: The video maintains high fidelity to the conditioning frame and adheres well to the prompt's requirements for a static camera and specific environmental details. While there is some minor temporal instability in the water's texture, the overall motion is convincing and the visual quality is high. | overall_score=88 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":98,"prompt_adherence":95,"motion_quality":85,"temporal_consistency":80,"visual_quality":90,"camera_composition":95}


Prompt: The camera remains completely static throughout the entire clip, maintaining a fixed wide shot of the scene. The six people sitting on the edge of the swimming pool remain perfectly still, with no movement from their bodies or heads. The only motion in the frame is the subtle, continuous rippling of the pool water, which flows gently across the surface of the blue water behind the group. The setting is a poolside area with a building in the background.

Explanation: The video adheres perfectly to the prompt, maintaining a static camera and still subjects while successfully animating the water ripples. The temporal consistency is high, and the visual quality is excellent. | overall_score=95 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":100,"prompt_adherence":95,"motion_quality":90,"temporal_consistency":100,"visual_quality":95,"camera_composition":100}

Explanation: The video adheres perfectly to the prompt, maintaining a static camera and still subjects while successfully animating the water ripples. The visual quality is high and the temporal consistency is flawless. | overall_score=95 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":100,"prompt_adherence":95,"motion_quality":90,"temporal_consistency":100,"visual_quality":95,"camera_composition":100}

Explanation: While the model successfully maintained the first frame and camera composition, it failed to generate any motion, resulting in a static image rather than a video clip. | overall_score=25 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":20,"motion_quality":10,"temporal_consistency":20,"visual_quality":30,"camera_composition":90}


Prompt: Multiple white butterflies flutter erratically in various directions throughout the frame, constantly entering and exiting the scene while occasionally landing on or taking flight from the green foliage. Some butterflies drift horizontally across the foreground, while others move deeper into the background or hover near the purple flower spikes. The camera remains completely static, maintaining a fixed, medium-shot framing of the dense, sunlit garden plants and the active insects swarming around them.

Explanation: While the model successfully maintains the static camera and initial frame composition, the motion of the butterflies is highly unstable, characterized by intense flickering and unnatural, glitchy movement that fails to simulate realistic flight. | overall_score=35 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":40,"motion_quality":20,"temporal_consistency":20,"visual_quality":30,"camera_composition":90}

Explanation: While the video successfully maintains the static camera and initial scene composition, the motion of the butterflies is highly unrealistic, characterized by significant flickering, morphing, and disjointed movement that fails to simulate actual flight. | overall_score=35 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":40,"motion_quality":20,"temporal_consistency":20,"visual_quality":30,"camera_composition":90}

Explanation: The video maintains the static camera and scene composition perfectly, with high fidelity to the first frame. While the butterflies are present and active, the motion quality suffers from noticeable flickering and temporal instability, which detracts from the overall realism. | overall_score=82 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":90,"motion_quality":75,"temporal_consistency":70,"visual_quality":85,"camera_composition":95}


Prompt: The zebra stands in a grassy field and grazes, keeping its head lowered toward the ground throughout the clip. Its tail flicks repeatedly from side to side in a rhythmic, swishing motion to ward off insects. The camera remains completely static, maintaining a fixed, wide-angle framing of the zebra in profile against the distant lake and hills. The subject's body remains largely still, with only the tail and the subtle, rhythmic movement of the head while feeding.

Explanation: The video maintains high fidelity to the conditioning frame and follows the prompt's instructions well. The primary drawback is the slightly unnatural, jittery motion of the tail, which detracts from the overall temporal smoothness. | overall_score=88 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":98,"prompt_adherence":95,"motion_quality":85,"temporal_consistency":80,"visual_quality":90,"camera_composition":95}

Explanation: The video maintains high fidelity to the conditioning frame and adheres well to the prompt's requirements for camera stability and subject behavior. While the tail motion is slightly mechanical, the overall temporal consistency and visual quality are high. | overall_score=85 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":90,"motion_quality":80,"temporal_consistency":85,"visual_quality":90,"camera_composition":95}

Explanation: The video successfully maintains the composition and subject from the first frame. The motion of the tail is present and generally follows the prompt, although it feels slightly mechanical. The overall visual quality is high, with only minor temporal artifacts in the background grass. | overall_score=85 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":90,"motion_quality":80,"temporal_consistency":85,"visual_quality":90,"camera_composition":95}


Prompt: Multiple cars drive steadily toward the camera along a multi-lane highway at night, their headlights and taillights creating continuous streams of motion. The vehicles maintain a consistent forward pace, moving from the distance toward the foreground. The camera remains completely static, providing a fixed, elevated wide shot of the busy urban road. This scene captures a steady flow of nighttime traffic on a highway, with vehicles traveling in both directions under bright overhead streetlights.

Explanation: The video maintains high fidelity to the conditioning frame and effectively captures the requested nighttime traffic scene. While there is some minor temporal instability in the vehicle movement and light trails, the overall visual quality and adherence to the prompt are very high. | overall_score=88 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":98,"prompt_adherence":95,"motion_quality":85,"temporal_consistency":82,"visual_quality":90,"camera_composition":95}

Explanation: The video maintains high fidelity to the conditioning frame and effectively captures the requested nighttime highway scene. While there is some minor temporal instability in the vehicle motion, the overall quality is high and the camera remains appropriately static. | overall_score=88 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":98,"prompt_adherence":95,"motion_quality":85,"temporal_consistency":82,"visual_quality":90,"camera_composition":95}

Explanation: The video maintains high fidelity to the conditioning frame and effectively captures the requested nighttime highway scene. While there is some minor temporal instability in the vehicle movement and light trails, the overall quality is high and the camera remains static as requested. | overall_score=88 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":98,"prompt_adherence":95,"motion_quality":85,"temporal_consistency":80,"visual_quality":90,"camera_composition":95}


Prompt: A person walks steadily forward across the sand, moving from the upper-middle frame toward the bottom center. The camera performs a slow, continuous drone-like dolly-in, gradually tightening the framing on the subject as they traverse the dune. The person maintains a consistent pace, leaving a trail of footprints behind them in the sand. The surrounding landscape remains static, emphasizing the subject's movement through the vast, open desert environment.

Explanation: While the video maintains the visual style of the first frame, the motion is highly unnatural, with the subject appearing to slide across the sand rather than walk. The requested camera movement is largely absent, and the subject's movement is plagued by significant temporal instability and artifacts around the feet. | overall_score=45 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":90,"prompt_adherence":40,"motion_quality":30,"temporal_consistency":30,"visual_quality":60,"camera_composition":50}

Explanation: While the video starts with high fidelity to the conditioning frame, it fails significantly on the requested motion. The subject appears to slide across the sand rather than walk, and the camera remains static instead of performing the required dolly-in, resulting in poor prompt adherence and motion quality. | overall_score=45 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":50,"motion_quality":30,"temporal_consistency":30,"visual_quality":40,"camera_composition":30}

Explanation: While the video starts with high fidelity to the first frame, the motion of the subject is highly unnatural, characterized by sliding and significant morphing artifacts around the feet. The requested camera movement is poorly executed, appearing jittery rather than a smooth, continuous dolly-in. | overall_score=45 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":40,"motion_quality":30,"temporal_consistency":35,"visual_quality":50,"camera_composition":20}


Prompt: A lone surfer paddles slowly forward on a surfboard across the calm, clear ocean surface. The camera maintains a high-angle, static top-down perspective, capturing the rhythmic, gentle ripples of the water as they move steadily toward the left side of the frame. The surfer remains positioned in the center of the shot, consistently gliding through the shallow, turquoise water while the surrounding sea surface exhibits a subtle, constant motion flowing from right to left.


Prompt: The peacock butterfly remains perched on a yellow dandelion, rhythmically opening and closing its wings in a slow, steady motion. The wings lift slightly upward and then fold back down against the flower, repeating this cycle throughout the entire duration. The camera remains completely static, maintaining a tight, centered close-up framing of the butterfly. The subject is a vibrant butterfly resting on a bright yellow flower amidst lush green foliage, captured in a steady, macro-style shot.

Explanation: The video successfully maintains the static camera and the subject's position from the first frame. While the wing motion is generally good, it exhibits some minor unnatural, jerky movements and slight texture warping, which prevents a perfect score. | overall_score=85 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":90,"motion_quality":80,"temporal_consistency":85,"visual_quality":90,"camera_composition":95}

Explanation: While the video successfully maintains the initial framing and subject, the motion of the butterfly is highly unrealistic, characterized by severe morphing and temporal instability that degrades the visual quality significantly. | overall_score=45 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":60,"motion_quality":30,"temporal_consistency":20,"visual_quality":50,"camera_composition":80}

Explanation: While the video successfully maintains the initial framing and subject, the motion of the butterfly is highly unrealistic, characterized by severe morphing and temporal instability that breaks the visual immersion. | overall_score=45 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":60,"motion_quality":30,"temporal_consistency":20,"visual_quality":50,"camera_composition":80}


Prompt: Several ants crawl along the thorny stem of a rose bush, moving steadily from left to right across the frame. The camera remains static, maintaining a close-up, fixed framing of the branch and the insects as they navigate the thorns and the thin green string tied to the plant. The background remains a soft, out-of-focus green landscape throughout the entire five-second sequence.

Explanation: While the video maintains the static composition and initial frame perfectly, the motion of the ants is highly incoherent and suffers from significant temporal artifacts, making the movement look like flickering noise rather than biological locomotion. | overall_score=35 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":90,"prompt_adherence":30,"motion_quality":20,"temporal_consistency":20,"visual_quality":40,"camera_composition":80}

Explanation: While the video successfully maintains the static camera and the initial scene composition, the motion of the ants is highly unrealistic and suffers from significant temporal artifacts, making the movement look like a series of disjointed, glitchy frames rather than fluid crawling. | overall_score=35 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":90,"prompt_adherence":30,"motion_quality":20,"temporal_consistency":20,"visual_quality":40,"camera_composition":80}

Explanation: The video maintains high fidelity to the first frame and successfully captures the requested scene of ants on a rose bush. While the motion of the ants is slightly jittery and exhibits minor morphing, the overall visual quality and adherence to the prompt are strong. | overall_score=82 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":85,"motion_quality":75,"temporal_consistency":80,"visual_quality":85,"camera_composition":90}


Prompt: The camera performs a slow, steady drone-style pan to the right, gradually revealing more of the baseball stadium field and the surrounding urban landscape. As the camera pivots, the perspective shifts from focusing on the foreground industrial warehouse to capturing the full expanse of the green baseball diamond and the highway beyond. The scene remains otherwise static, with no movement from vehicles or people, maintaining a calm, observational perspective of the construction site and stadium grounds throughout the entire clip.

Explanation: The video successfully executes the requested camera pan and maintains high visual quality and fidelity to the first frame. However, it fails to adhere strictly to the 'no movement' constraint regarding the highway traffic, and the motion could be slightly smoother. | overall_score=88 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":90,"motion_quality":85,"temporal_consistency":90,"visual_quality":90,"camera_composition":80}

Explanation: The video successfully executes the requested drone-style pan, maintaining high visual quality and strong adherence to the first frame. While the motion is slightly uneven in its pacing, the overall execution is highly effective and visually coherent. | overall_score=88 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":90,"motion_quality":85,"temporal_consistency":90,"visual_quality":90,"camera_composition":80}

Explanation: The video successfully follows the prompt's instructions for a drone-style pan, effectively revealing the stadium while maintaining the static nature of the scene. While the motion is slightly jittery, the overall quality and adherence to the conditioning frame are very high. | overall_score=88 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":90,"motion_quality":85,"temporal_consistency":90,"visual_quality":90,"camera_composition":80}


Prompt: The camera performs a slow, smooth zoom in on the scene, gradually tightening the framing around the central figure. The Santa Claus figurine remains perfectly still throughout the duration of the clip. The flickering light from the candles in the background creates a subtle, rhythmic pulsing effect on the surrounding surfaces. This festive display features a small Santa Claus ornament positioned on a white table next to a red stocking filled with wrapped candies and decorative glass candle holders.

Explanation: While the video maintains the visual fidelity of the first frame perfectly, it completely fails to execute the requested camera motion (zoom-in) and the requested lighting effects (flickering candles). It is effectively a static image, failing the primary motion requirements of the prompt. | overall_score=25 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":10,"motion_quality":10,"temporal_consistency":20,"visual_quality":40,"camera_composition":10}

Explanation: While the video maintains the visual integrity of the first frame perfectly, it completely fails to execute the requested camera movement (zoom-in) and the requested lighting effects, resulting in a static image rather than a video. | overall_score=25 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":10,"motion_quality":10,"temporal_consistency":20,"visual_quality":40,"camera_composition":10}

Explanation: While the initial frame is perfectly preserved, the video fails to execute the requested camera movement (zoom-in) and lacks the specified lighting effects, resulting in a static image rather than a dynamic video. | overall_score=25 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":10,"motion_quality":10,"temporal_consistency":20,"visual_quality":40,"camera_composition":10}


Prompt: The clouds drift slowly and steadily from left to right across the sky, maintaining their general shape while undergoing subtle, natural shifts in density. The camera remains completely static, providing a wide, fixed landscape view of the open field. This scene captures a vast, clear blue sky filled with scattered white cumulus clouds hovering above a dark, grassy horizon line, emphasizing the calm, continuous movement of the atmosphere over the quiet, stationary ground.


Prompt: Two scuba divers hover near a coral reef, holding onto a horizontal rope. The diver on the left points his right index finger forward, then slowly lowers his hand. The diver on the right keeps her hand extended, palm up, as various small fish swim erratically around them. A steady stream of air bubbles rises from the divers toward the surface. The camera remains static throughout the shot, maintaining a medium framing of the two subjects against the reef.

Explanation: While the video starts with high fidelity to the conditioning frame, it fails significantly on prompt adherence regarding the specific hand movements of the divers. The motion is unnatural, and the temporal consistency of the background elements (fish and bubbles) is poor, leading to a disjointed viewing experience. | overall_score=35 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":90,"prompt_adherence":20,"motion_quality":30,"temporal_consistency":25,"visual_quality":40,"camera_composition":80}

Explanation: While the video starts with high fidelity to the conditioning frame, it fails significantly on the specific motion requirements of the prompt, particularly the diver on the right who waves instead of holding a static pose. The motion of the fish and the bubbles is jittery and lacks fluid, realistic underwater physics. | overall_score=45 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":90,"prompt_adherence":30,"motion_quality":20,"temporal_consistency":40,"visual_quality":60,"camera_composition":80}

Explanation: While the video starts with high fidelity to the first frame, it fails significantly on the specific motion requirements of the prompt, particularly the diver on the right who waves instead of holding a static pose. The motion of the fish and bubbles is jittery and lacks fluid, realistic underwater physics. | overall_score=45 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":90,"prompt_adherence":30,"motion_quality":20,"temporal_consistency":40,"visual_quality":60,"camera_composition":80}


Prompt: Ocean waves roll continuously toward the shore, breaking into white foam against the jagged black rocks scattered across the beach. The water moves steadily from left to right, with smaller ripples and whitecaps visible across the surface of the sea. The camera remains completely static throughout the entire duration of the clip, maintaining a fixed, wide-angle framing of the coastal landscape. A rocky shoreline meets the ocean under a clear sky with distant mountains in the background.

Explanation: The video maintains high fidelity to the conditioning frame and adheres well to the prompt. The motion is generally fluid and realistic, though there is a slight repetitive quality to the wave animation that prevents a perfect score. | overall_score=92 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":98,"prompt_adherence":95,"motion_quality":90,"temporal_consistency":92,"visual_quality":95,"camera_composition":95}

Explanation: The video maintains high fidelity to the conditioning frame and successfully captures the requested motion of waves rolling toward the shore. While there is a slight repetitive quality to the water animation, the overall temporal consistency and visual quality are very high. | overall_score=92 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":98,"prompt_adherence":95,"motion_quality":90,"temporal_consistency":92,"visual_quality":95,"camera_composition":95}

Explanation: The video demonstrates high-quality generation with strong adherence to the conditioning frame and prompt. While there are minor temporal artifacts in the wave motion, the overall visual quality and stability are impressive. | overall_score=92 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":98,"prompt_adherence":95,"motion_quality":90,"temporal_consistency":92,"visual_quality":95,"camera_composition":90}


Prompt: The camera performs a smooth, continuous forward dolly movement, gradually closing the distance toward the stone church tower. As the camera advances, the perspective shifts slightly, revealing more of the surrounding landscape and the village buildings nestled in the background. The motion is steady and linear, maintaining a consistent altitude while tracking toward the church. This aerial perspective captures a stone church set against a backdrop of rolling green hills and dense forest.

Explanation: The video successfully executes the requested forward dolly movement while maintaining high fidelity to the conditioning frame. There are minor temporal inconsistencies in the background, but the overall motion and visual quality are strong. | overall_score=85 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":98,"prompt_adherence":90,"motion_quality":85,"temporal_consistency":80,"visual_quality":85,"camera_composition":85}

Explanation: The video successfully executes the requested forward dolly movement while maintaining high visual fidelity to the conditioning frame. The motion is generally smooth, though there is some minor jitter and slight geometric distortion of the tower structure as the camera advances. | overall_score=88 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":98,"prompt_adherence":95,"motion_quality":85,"temporal_consistency":90,"visual_quality":92,"camera_composition":80}

Explanation: The video successfully executes the requested forward dolly movement while maintaining high fidelity to the conditioning frame. There is some minor temporal instability in the background, but the overall motion and composition are well-aligned with the prompt. | overall_score=85 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":98,"prompt_adherence":90,"motion_quality":85,"temporal_consistency":80,"visual_quality":85,"camera_composition":85}


Prompt: The camera performs a slow, steady dolly-in movement toward the center of the frame, gradually tightening the focus on the succulent leaves. The subject remains entirely static throughout the five-second duration, with no movement from the plant itself or any external elements. The shot maintains a consistent, fixed perspective as it pushes forward, keeping the foreground and background foliage in a soft, blurred state while the central succulent remains the primary point of visual interest.

Explanation: While the video maintains the visual quality and fidelity of the first frame perfectly, it completely fails to execute the requested camera movement, resulting in a static image rather than the dynamic dolly-in shot described in the prompt. | overall_score=25 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":10,"motion_quality":5,"temporal_consistency":80,"visual_quality":60,"camera_composition":10}

Explanation: The model failed to execute the primary instruction of the prompt, which was to perform a dolly-in camera movement. The video is essentially a static image for the entire duration, resulting in a failure of motion quality and prompt adherence. | overall_score=25 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":10,"motion_quality":5,"temporal_consistency":50,"visual_quality":40,"camera_composition":10}

Explanation: While the model successfully maintained the visual fidelity of the first frame, it failed entirely to execute the requested camera movement, resulting in a static video that does not adhere to the motion requirements of the prompt. | overall_score=25 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":10,"motion_quality":5,"temporal_consistency":50,"visual_quality":60,"camera_composition":10}


Prompt: The camera performs a slow, steady dolly forward, gradually closing the distance toward the harbor and the cluster of red buildings. Throughout the five-second duration, the water in the bay remains calm with minimal surface movement, while the clouds above drift slowly across the sky from left to right. This aerial perspective captures a snowy coastal village nestled against a backdrop of jagged, snow-covered mountains, maintaining a consistent, smooth forward motion toward the center of the frame.

Explanation: The video maintains high visual fidelity and excellent temporal consistency, perfectly matching the conditioning frame. However, the motion is quite static; while it technically performs a slow dolly, the movement is so minimal that it barely meets the prompt's requirement for a 'slow, steady' forward motion. | overall_score=88 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":98,"prompt_adherence":90,"motion_quality":85,"temporal_consistency":92,"visual_quality":90,"camera_composition":80}

Explanation: The video maintains high visual fidelity and excellent temporal consistency, perfectly preserving the first frame. However, the motion is too minimal to fully satisfy the prompt's requirement for a clear dolly forward and active cloud movement. | overall_score=88 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":98,"prompt_adherence":90,"motion_quality":85,"temporal_consistency":92,"visual_quality":90,"camera_composition":80}

Explanation: The video maintains high visual fidelity and temporal consistency, perfectly matching the conditioning frame. However, the motion is too minimal to fully satisfy the prompt's requirement for a clear dolly forward and active cloud movement. | overall_score=88 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":98,"prompt_adherence":90,"motion_quality":85,"temporal_consistency":92,"visual_quality":90,"camera_composition":80}


Prompt: Ocean waves continuously surge toward the left, crashing against the jagged rock face. The water churns and foams as it flows over the uneven, submerged stones, creating a rhythmic, turbulent cycle of incoming swells and receding white foam. The camera remains in a fixed, static, high-angle position, capturing the relentless movement of the sea against the shoreline. This scene depicts the natural, repetitive motion of coastal waves hitting a rocky cliffside.

Explanation: The video maintains high fidelity to the conditioning frame and effectively captures the requested motion of waves against the rocks. While there is some minor temporal instability in the foam, the overall visual quality and adherence to the prompt are very strong. | overall_score=88 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":98,"prompt_adherence":95,"motion_quality":85,"temporal_consistency":82,"visual_quality":90,"camera_composition":95}

Explanation: The video maintains high fidelity to the first frame and effectively captures the requested motion of waves against the rocks. While there is some minor temporal instability in the foam, the overall visual quality and adherence to the prompt are very strong. | overall_score=88 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":98,"prompt_adherence":95,"motion_quality":85,"temporal_consistency":80,"visual_quality":90,"camera_composition":95}

Explanation: The video maintains high fidelity to the conditioning frame and effectively captures the requested wave motion against the rocks. While there is some minor temporal instability in the foam, the overall visual quality and adherence to the prompt are very strong. | overall_score=88 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":98,"prompt_adherence":95,"motion_quality":85,"temporal_consistency":80,"visual_quality":90,"camera_composition":95}


Prompt: The sun descends steadily behind the distant mountain ridges, moving downward and slightly to the right until it disappears behind the peaks. The sky transitions through subtle shifts in light as the sun sets. The camera remains completely static throughout the entire duration, maintaining a wide, fixed framing of the mountain landscape and the foreground of dead trees. This is a high-altitude mountain vista at sunset, capturing the gradual sinking of the sun below the horizon line.

Explanation: The video demonstrates high fidelity to the conditioning frame and effectively executes the requested sunset motion. The camera remains static as instructed, and the temporal progression of the lighting is visually coherent and high-quality. | overall_score=92 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":98,"prompt_adherence":95,"motion_quality":90,"temporal_consistency":95,"visual_quality":95,"camera_composition":90}

Explanation: The video demonstrates high-quality generation, maintaining excellent fidelity to the first frame while successfully executing the requested sunset motion. The lighting transition is natural and the camera remains static as instructed, with only very minor temporal jitter in the background. | overall_score=92 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":98,"prompt_adherence":95,"motion_quality":90,"temporal_consistency":95,"visual_quality":95,"camera_composition":90}

Explanation: The video demonstrates high-quality temporal consistency and adheres strictly to the prompt's requirements for a static camera and a descending sun. The first frame is perfectly preserved, and the lighting transition is natural and visually appealing. | overall_score=92 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":98,"prompt_adherence":95,"motion_quality":90,"temporal_consistency":95,"visual_quality":95,"camera_composition":90}


Prompt: The blades of the four prominent wind turbines rotate steadily in a clockwise direction throughout the entire clip. The camera remains completely static, maintaining a wide, fixed framing of the wind farm set against a hazy, flat landscape. The motion is consistent and rhythmic, with no changes in speed or direction, as the blades continue their circular path against the backdrop of the distant, fog-obscured horizon.

Explanation: The video successfully maintains a static camera and consistent scene composition throughout. While the rotation of the blades is generally good, there is some minor jitter and slight speed variation that prevents a perfect score. | overall_score=85 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":90,"motion_quality":80,"temporal_consistency":85,"visual_quality":90,"camera_composition":95}

Explanation: The video maintains the static camera and atmospheric conditions well, with the wind turbines rotating in the correct direction. There is some minor geometric instability in the blades as they rotate, but the overall quality is high. | overall_score=85 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":90,"motion_quality":80,"temporal_consistency":85,"visual_quality":90,"camera_composition":95}

Explanation: The video successfully maintains the static camera and atmospheric setting of the first frame. The wind turbines rotate in the correct direction, although there is some minor jitter and slight geometric instability in the blades as they move. | overall_score=85 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":90,"motion_quality":80,"temporal_consistency":85,"visual_quality":90,"camera_composition":95}


Prompt: Several birds fly steadily across the clear blue sky, moving from the center toward the upper right corner of the frame. Their flight paths are consistent and direct. The camera remains completely static, maintaining a fixed, wide-angle perspective of the vast, cloud-streaked atmosphere. The scene captures a group of birds in flight against a bright, expansive sky, emphasizing their graceful, continuous movement across the stationary frame over the five-second duration.

Explanation: The video adheres well to the prompt and maintains high visual fidelity to the first frame. While the motion of the birds is slightly unnatural and jittery, the overall composition and temporal stability are strong. | overall_score=85 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":90,"motion_quality":80,"temporal_consistency":85,"visual_quality":90,"camera_composition":95}

Explanation: The video successfully maintains the static camera and the initial scene composition. While the birds' flight path is not perfectly linear and exhibits minor morphing artifacts, the overall visual quality and adherence to the prompt are high. | overall_score=85 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":90,"motion_quality":80,"temporal_consistency":85,"visual_quality":90,"camera_composition":90}

Explanation: The video successfully maintains the static camera and background composition from the first frame. While the birds' flight paths are generally consistent with the prompt, there is minor jitter and slight morphing in the birds' shapes during their movement. | overall_score=85 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":90,"motion_quality":80,"temporal_consistency":85,"visual_quality":90,"camera_composition":95}


Prompt: The camera performs a slow, steady downward tilt, gradually revealing more of the street level and the park area below. Throughout the five seconds, multiple vehicles, including cars and a green bus, move steadily along the road from the bottom right toward the center left. The urban scene features a large shopping complex adjacent to a green park, with a dense skyline of high-rise buildings in the background remaining static as the perspective shifts downward.

Explanation: The video demonstrates high fidelity to the conditioning frame and effectively captures the requested motion of multiple vehicles. While the camera tilt is slightly jittery, the overall temporal consistency and visual quality are strong. | overall_score=88 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":98,"prompt_adherence":90,"motion_quality":85,"temporal_consistency":92,"visual_quality":95,"camera_composition":80}

Explanation: The video successfully executes the requested camera movement and scene composition while maintaining high fidelity to the first frame. Minor issues with motion smoothness and vehicle animation prevent a perfect score. | overall_score=88 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":98,"prompt_adherence":90,"motion_quality":85,"temporal_consistency":92,"visual_quality":90,"camera_composition":80}

Explanation: The video is visually impressive and adheres well to the prompt's content requirements, but the camera movement is too minimal to fully satisfy the 'slow, steady downward tilt' instruction. The motion of the vehicles is generally good but exhibits minor temporal jitter. | overall_score=85 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":98,"prompt_adherence":90,"motion_quality":85,"temporal_consistency":85,"visual_quality":90,"camera_composition":80}


Prompt: A rock climber reaches her right hand upward to grip a higher hold on a textured stone face. She then pulls her body weight slightly upward and shifts her gaze downward toward her hand placement. The camera remains static in a tight, side-profile framing, focusing on the climber as she navigates the vertical rock wall. The climber is positioned against a rugged, light-colored cliffside with a yellow safety rope hanging vertically in the background.


Prompt: The camera performs a smooth, continuous forward dolly movement, gradually descending and pushing toward the historic brick monastery complex nestled in the green landscape. As the camera advances, the perspective shifts to reveal more detail of the courtyard and surrounding fields. The motion is steady and deliberate, maintaining a consistent forward trajectory throughout the five-second duration. This aerial shot captures the sprawling rural estate and its surrounding meadows under a soft, late afternoon sky.

Explanation: The video maintains high fidelity to the first frame and successfully executes a forward dolly movement. While the descent could be more pronounced to fully match the prompt's description, the overall visual quality and temporal stability are very strong. | overall_score=85 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":90,"motion_quality":85,"temporal_consistency":90,"visual_quality":90,"camera_composition":80}

Explanation: The video demonstrates high-quality generation with excellent fidelity to the first frame and consistent visual style. While the camera movement is a bit subtle and lacks a perfectly smooth, continuous feel, it successfully captures the essence of the requested dolly shot. | overall_score=85 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":90,"motion_quality":85,"temporal_consistency":90,"visual_quality":90,"camera_composition":80}

Explanation: The video maintains high fidelity to the first frame and successfully executes a forward dolly movement. While the descent is less pronounced than requested, the overall visual quality and temporal stability are strong. | overall_score=85 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":90,"motion_quality":85,"temporal_consistency":90,"visual_quality":90,"camera_composition":80}


Prompt: The camera remains static, framing a vibrant red peony bud nestled among dark, glossy foliage. Throughout the five-second clip, the flower and surrounding leaves sway gently and rhythmically from left to right, driven by a soft, consistent breeze. The movement is subtle and fluid, causing the entire cluster of vegetation to shift in unison against the blurred, out-of-focus garden background. There are no other changes in the scene, maintaining a calm, natural atmosphere throughout the duration.


Prompt: A young girl in a red bucket hat and denim overalls runs across a grassy park from left to right. She maintains a steady, rhythmic jogging pace, swinging her arms naturally at her sides. The camera follows her movement with a smooth, continuous pan to the right, keeping her centered in the frame. The background features lush green trees and a gentle slope, remaining consistent as the camera tracks the girl throughout the entire five-second duration.

Explanation: The video maintains high fidelity to the conditioning frame and effectively captures the requested action and setting. While the motion is generally good, there are minor issues with the smoothness of the camera pan and slight artifacts in the character's leg movement. | overall_score=85 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":90,"motion_quality":80,"temporal_consistency":85,"visual_quality":90,"camera_composition":80}

Explanation: The video maintains high fidelity to the conditioning frame and effectively captures the requested action. While there are minor motion artifacts and the camera pan lacks perfect smoothness, the overall visual quality and temporal stability are strong. | overall_score=85 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":90,"motion_quality":80,"temporal_consistency":85,"visual_quality":90,"camera_composition":80}

Explanation: The video maintains high fidelity to the conditioning frame and follows the prompt's action well. While there is slight jitter in the motion and minor camera tracking instability, the overall quality is high. | overall_score=88 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":98,"prompt_adherence":95,"motion_quality":85,"temporal_consistency":85,"visual_quality":90,"camera_composition":80}


Prompt: The camera performs a smooth, continuous forward dolly movement, gradually approaching the stone church tower. As the camera advances, the perspective shifts to reveal more of the roof structure and the surrounding dense green trees. The framing remains centered on the church spire throughout the entire five-second duration. The scene depicts a stone church with a prominent clock face set against a backdrop of mature trees and a cloudy sky, with no other movement occurring within the frame.

Explanation: The video is of high quality and maintains perfect fidelity to the first frame. While it adheres to the prompt's core requirements, the camera movement is quite conservative and lacks the dynamic perspective shift described in the prompt. | overall_score=92 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":100,"prompt_adherence":95,"motion_quality":90,"temporal_consistency":95,"visual_quality":95,"camera_composition":80}

Explanation: The video successfully executes the requested forward dolly movement while maintaining high visual fidelity and temporal stability. The motion is generally smooth, though there is minor jitter, and the composition remains well-centered on the spire throughout the duration. | overall_score=92 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":98,"prompt_adherence":95,"motion_quality":90,"temporal_consistency":95,"visual_quality":95,"camera_composition":85}

Explanation: The video is visually impressive and maintains perfect fidelity to the first frame. However, the camera movement is quite conservative and does not fully capture the extent of the perspective shift described in the prompt. | overall_score=92 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":100,"prompt_adherence":95,"motion_quality":90,"temporal_consistency":95,"visual_quality":95,"camera_composition":80}


Prompt: The camera performs a slow, steady forward dolly movement through the center of a snow-covered cemetery. As the perspective advances along the path, the light source on the left remains fixed in the frame while the surrounding headstones and trees pass by at a consistent pace. The motion is smooth and linear, maintaining a constant height and centered framing throughout the entire five-second duration, capturing a quiet, atmospheric journey through the silent, winter landscape.

Explanation: The video maintains high fidelity to the conditioning frame and effectively captures the requested slow, steady dolly movement. While there is some minor geometric instability in the background elements during the movement, the overall quality is high and the atmosphere is well-preserved. | overall_score=88 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":90,"motion_quality":85,"temporal_consistency":90,"visual_quality":90,"camera_composition":85}

Explanation: The video successfully executes the requested forward dolly movement while maintaining high fidelity to the initial frame. The primary detractions are minor flickering of the light source and slight jitter in the camera motion, but the overall quality is high. | overall_score=88 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":90,"motion_quality":85,"temporal_consistency":90,"visual_quality":90,"camera_composition":80}


Prompt: The camera performs a smooth, slow rack focus, transitioning from the foreground wildflowers to the cluster of discarded electronic monitors and televisions sitting in the field. As the focus shifts, the background objects become sharp and clearly defined. The camera remains static throughout the entire sequence, maintaining a fixed framing of the electronics set against a grassy, outdoor slope. The primary action is the gradual, deliberate adjustment of the focal plane from the near plants to the distant junk.

Explanation: The video successfully executes the requested rack focus, transitioning smoothly from the foreground wildflowers to the background electronics while maintaining high visual quality and temporal stability. | overall_score=92 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":98,"prompt_adherence":95,"motion_quality":90,"temporal_consistency":95,"visual_quality":92,"camera_composition":90}

Explanation: The video perfectly executes the requested rack focus, transitioning smoothly from the foreground wildflowers to the background electronics. The visual quality is high, and the composition remains stable throughout the duration. | overall_score=92 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":98,"prompt_adherence":95,"motion_quality":90,"temporal_consistency":95,"visual_quality":92,"camera_composition":90}

Explanation: The video successfully executes the requested rack focus from the foreground wildflowers to the background electronics while maintaining high visual fidelity and temporal stability. | overall_score=92 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":98,"prompt_adherence":95,"motion_quality":90,"temporal_consistency":95,"visual_quality":95,"camera_composition":90}


Prompt: The clouds drift slowly and steadily from right to left across the frame, with the dense, shadowed cloud mass in the center moving toward the left edge while the smaller, scattered white clouds in the upper left corner shift in the same direction. The camera remains completely static throughout the entire duration, maintaining a fixed, wide-angle view of the open sky. This scene captures a calm, expansive blue sky filled with diverse cloud formations moving across the horizon.

Explanation: The video successfully maintains a static camera and follows the prompt's motion instructions well. While there is some minor temporal instability in the cloud textures, the overall visual quality and fidelity to the first frame are high. | overall_score=85 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":90,"motion_quality":85,"temporal_consistency":85,"visual_quality":90,"camera_composition":95}

Explanation: The video maintains high fidelity to the first frame and successfully captures the requested cloud movement and static camera composition. While the motion is generally good, there is minor jitter and slight morphing of the cloud structures that prevents a perfect score. | overall_score=85 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":90,"motion_quality":80,"temporal_consistency":85,"visual_quality":90,"camera_composition":95}

Explanation: The video successfully maintains the static camera composition and respects the first frame perfectly. The cloud movement is consistent with the prompt, although the motion quality is slightly artificial in its fluidity. | overall_score=85 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":90,"motion_quality":80,"temporal_consistency":85,"visual_quality":90,"camera_composition":95}


Prompt: The Egyptian goose stands still on a stone ledge by the water, rhythmically preening its chest feathers with its beak. The bird tilts its head downward and moves its bill back and forth across its plumage in a continuous, repetitive grooming motion. The camera remains completely static throughout the entire duration, maintaining a fixed, medium-shot framing of the bird as it focuses entirely on its self-cleaning activity against the calm, rippling water in the background.

Explanation: The video demonstrates high fidelity to the conditioning frame and effectively captures the requested grooming behavior with natural, rhythmic motion. The overall visual quality is high, with only minor motion artifacts during the bird's bill movement. | overall_score=92 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":100,"prompt_adherence":95,"motion_quality":90,"temporal_consistency":95,"visual_quality":90,"camera_composition":90}

Explanation: The video demonstrates high fidelity to the conditioning frame and effectively captures the requested grooming behavior with natural, rhythmic motion. The overall visual quality is high, with only minor artifacts during the bird's movement. | overall_score=92 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":100,"prompt_adherence":95,"motion_quality":90,"temporal_consistency":95,"visual_quality":90,"camera_composition":90}

Explanation: The video demonstrates high fidelity to the conditioning frame and successfully captures the requested preening behavior with natural, rhythmic motion. The overall visual quality is high, with only minor artifacts during the bird's movement. | overall_score=92 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":100,"prompt_adherence":95,"motion_quality":90,"temporal_consistency":95,"visual_quality":90,"camera_composition":90}


Prompt: A construction worker wearing a hard hat and gloves stands in a dark, hazy environment illuminated by a single overhead spotlight. He slowly raises his right hand toward the light, keeping his gaze fixed upward as he reaches into the beam. The camera remains static in a medium shot, capturing the subject from the side as he performs this deliberate, upward-reaching motion. The scene focuses on the man's slow, steady movement as he interacts with the light source.

Explanation: The video demonstrates high fidelity to the conditioning frame and successfully executes the requested motion. The lighting and atmosphere are well-rendered, though there is a slight degradation in hand geometry during the reach. | overall_score=88 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":98,"prompt_adherence":95,"motion_quality":85,"temporal_consistency":90,"visual_quality":85,"camera_composition":95}

Explanation: The video demonstrates high fidelity to the conditioning frame and successfully executes the requested motion with good temporal consistency. While there are minor artifacts in the hand's geometry during the reach, the overall visual quality and prompt alignment are very strong. | overall_score=92 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":100,"prompt_adherence":95,"motion_quality":90,"temporal_consistency":95,"visual_quality":90,"camera_composition":90}

Explanation: The video demonstrates high fidelity to the conditioning frame and successfully executes the requested motion with good temporal stability. While there are minor artifacts in the hand's geometry during the reach, the overall visual quality and prompt alignment are very strong. | overall_score=92 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":100,"prompt_adherence":95,"motion_quality":90,"temporal_consistency":95,"visual_quality":90,"camera_composition":90}