Prompt: The water flows continuously over the dam, creating a series of white, frothing circular patterns that move steadily downward toward the bottom of the frame. The water behind the bridge remains relatively calm, while the turbulent white water in the foreground maintains a constant, rhythmic motion. The camera remains static in a high-angle, top-down view, capturing the entire bridge and the dam structure as the water cascades over the spillway.

Explanation: While the model successfully maintained the visual fidelity of the first frame, it failed completely to animate the scene. The prompt's requirement for continuous water flow and rhythmic motion was ignored, resulting in a static image rather than a video. | overall_score=25 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":20,"motion_quality":5,"temporal_consistency":10,"visual_quality":40,"camera_composition":80}

Explanation: The generated video is essentially a static image; there is no discernible motion in the water, which directly contradicts the prompt's requirement for continuous, flowing water patterns. | overall_score=25 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":20,"motion_quality":5,"temporal_consistency":10,"visual_quality":40,"camera_composition":80}

Explanation: The generated video is essentially a static image; there is no discernible motion in the water, which directly contradicts the prompt's requirement for continuous, flowing water. | overall_score=25 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":20,"motion_quality":5,"temporal_consistency":10,"visual_quality":30,"camera_composition":90}


Prompt: A white car drives forward along a straight, paved road, maintaining a steady pace as it travels away from the camera toward the distant horizon. The camera remains static, providing a high-angle, wide shot of the rural landscape. The scene features a single vehicle moving through a quiet, hilly environment with sparse vegetation and a small roadside structure, capturing the continuous, linear motion of the car as it recedes into the background over the five-second duration.

Explanation: While the video maintains the visual style and composition of the first frame, it fails significantly on the core prompt requirement of the car driving away from the camera. The motion is highly unstable, characterized by jittery, non-fluid movement that makes the car appear to slide across the road surface. | overall_score=45 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":40,"motion_quality":20,"temporal_consistency":30,"visual_quality":60,"camera_composition":80}

Explanation: While the video maintains the initial scene layout well, it fails significantly on the core prompt requirement of the car driving away from the camera. The car instead moves toward the camera with very poor, jittery motion that lacks physical realism. | overall_score=25 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":90,"prompt_adherence":20,"motion_quality":10,"temporal_consistency":20,"visual_quality":60,"camera_composition":80}

Explanation: While the video maintains the initial scene composition well, it fails significantly on the core prompt requirement of the car driving away from the camera. The motion is highly unstable, characterized by jitter and unnatural sliding, which severely degrades the temporal quality. | overall_score=25 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":90,"prompt_adherence":20,"motion_quality":10,"temporal_consistency":20,"visual_quality":60,"camera_composition":80}


Prompt: The camera performs a slow, steady forward dolly movement over a suburban residential neighborhood. As the perspective shifts, a dark car travels from left to right along the main road situated behind the houses. Simultaneously, a white car moves in the same direction along the same road, maintaining a consistent pace. The scene remains focused on the aerial view of the housing development, with the motion of the vehicles providing the primary temporal activity throughout the five-second duration.

Explanation: The video maintains high visual fidelity and successfully incorporates the requested vehicle movements. However, the camera movement is so minimal that it barely fulfills the 'dolly' requirement, and there is minor jitter in the motion of the white car. | overall_score=88 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":98,"prompt_adherence":90,"motion_quality":85,"temporal_consistency":92,"visual_quality":95,"camera_composition":80}

Explanation: The video maintains high visual fidelity to the first frame and successfully incorporates the requested vehicle movement. However, the camera movement is too subtle to be clearly identified as a dolly shot, and the motion of the cars exhibits minor temporal jitter. | overall_score=82 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":98,"prompt_adherence":85,"motion_quality":75,"temporal_consistency":80,"visual_quality":90,"camera_composition":85}

Explanation: The video maintains high visual fidelity and successfully incorporates the requested elements (two cars moving in the same direction). However, the camera movement is very minimal, making the 'dolly' effect difficult to perceive, and there is minor jitter in the vehicle motion. | overall_score=82 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":98,"prompt_adherence":85,"motion_quality":75,"temporal_consistency":80,"visual_quality":90,"camera_composition":85}


Prompt: A large, flat-bodied fish swims slowly from the center toward the left side of the frame, maintaining a steady, horizontal trajectory. Its fins undulate gently as it glides through the water. Smaller fish swim in the background, moving independently in various directions. The camera remains static throughout the entire sequence, capturing the fish as it traverses the mid-ground of the aquarium tank against a backdrop of submerged rock formations.

Explanation: The video is visually impressive and maintains high fidelity to the first frame, but the motion of the main subject is quite subtle and lacks the dynamic undulation requested in the prompt. | overall_score=85 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":90,"motion_quality":80,"temporal_consistency":85,"visual_quality":90,"camera_composition":90}

Explanation: The video maintains high visual fidelity and adheres well to the composition requirements, though the motion of the main subject is quite subtle and could be more pronounced to better reflect the prompt's description of swimming. | overall_score=85 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":90,"motion_quality":80,"temporal_consistency":85,"visual_quality":90,"camera_composition":90}

Explanation: The video maintains high fidelity to the first frame and successfully executes the requested motion of the fish swimming toward the left. The overall visual quality is high, though the motion of the primary subject could be slightly more fluid. | overall_score=88 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":98,"prompt_adherence":95,"motion_quality":85,"temporal_consistency":90,"visual_quality":92,"camera_composition":95}


Prompt: Water cascades continuously downward from the top of the frame, creating a steady, turbulent flow that splashes into the pool at the base of the rocks. The white water churns and ripples outward from the impact point, maintaining a consistent, rhythmic motion throughout the entire duration. The camera remains completely static, maintaining a fixed, medium-shot framing of the waterfall as it falls against the dark, jagged rock face.

Explanation: While the model successfully maintained the visual fidelity of the first frame and the camera composition, it failed completely to generate the requested motion of the waterfall, resulting in a static image rather than a video. | overall_score=25 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":30,"motion_quality":10,"temporal_consistency":10,"visual_quality":20,"camera_composition":90}

Explanation: While the first frame is perfectly preserved and the composition is correct, the video fails entirely to generate any motion, resulting in a static image rather than a video of a waterfall. | overall_score=25 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":30,"motion_quality":10,"temporal_consistency":10,"visual_quality":20,"camera_composition":90}

Explanation: While the model successfully maintained the visual fidelity of the first frame and the static camera framing, it failed completely to generate any motion. The waterfall is frozen, violating the core requirement of the prompt to depict a continuous, turbulent flow. | overall_score=25 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":30,"motion_quality":10,"temporal_consistency":10,"visual_quality":20,"camera_composition":90}


Prompt: The blue cornflower on the right slowly unfurls its petals, expanding outward and upward to reach full bloom over the course of the clip. Meanwhile, the two smaller, tightly closed buds on the left remain completely stationary, showing no signs of opening. The camera remains perfectly static throughout the entire duration, maintaining a fixed, centered framing of the three flower stalks against a solid black background.

Explanation: The video successfully executes the complex motion prompt, with the right flower blooming while the left buds remain stationary. The visual quality is high, though there is a very slight, almost imperceptible camera shift at the beginning that prevents a perfect score. | overall_score=92 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":98,"prompt_adherence":95,"motion_quality":90,"temporal_consistency":95,"visual_quality":95,"camera_composition":90}

Explanation: The video perfectly follows the prompt instructions, with the right flower blooming while the left buds remain stationary. The visual quality is high, and the temporal consistency is excellent throughout the clip. | overall_score=95 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":100,"prompt_adherence":95,"motion_quality":95,"temporal_consistency":95,"visual_quality":95,"camera_composition":100}

Explanation: The video demonstrates high-quality, realistic motion for the blooming flower while keeping the other buds mostly stationary. There is a very slight, almost imperceptible camera shift or stabilization issue, but the overall visual quality and adherence to the prompt are very high. | overall_score=92 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":98,"prompt_adherence":95,"motion_quality":90,"temporal_consistency":95,"visual_quality":95,"camera_composition":90}


Prompt: The dense, dark clouds in the upper sky drift slowly toward the right side of the frame, while the smaller, scattered clouds below them move steadily in the same direction. The camera remains completely static, maintaining a wide, high-angle aerial view of the sprawling urban landscape. This scene captures a vast residential neighborhood and industrial district under a dynamic, overcast sky, emphasizing the continuous, horizontal flow of the cloud formations across the horizon.

Explanation: The generated video is essentially a static image; there is no movement in the clouds or any other part of the scene, failing the primary requirement of the prompt to depict drifting clouds. | overall_score=25 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":20,"motion_quality":10,"temporal_consistency":20,"visual_quality":30,"camera_composition":50}

Explanation: The generated video is essentially a static image; there is no perceptible movement of the clouds or any other elements, failing the primary requirement of the prompt to depict drifting clouds. | overall_score=25 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":20,"motion_quality":10,"temporal_consistency":10,"visual_quality":30,"camera_composition":60}

Explanation: The generated video is essentially a static image; there is no perceptible movement of the clouds or any other elements, failing the primary requirement of the prompt to animate the cloud drift. | overall_score=25 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":20,"motion_quality":10,"temporal_consistency":10,"visual_quality":30,"camera_composition":60}


Prompt: The camera performs a slow, steady dolly forward into the center of the room. As the perspective shifts, the sunlight beams casting shadows across the wall remain fixed in their position. The foliage visible through the doorway and in the foreground remains completely still, with no wind or movement affecting the leaves. The scene is an abandoned, dilapidated room with a fireplace and debris-covered floor, captured in a static, observational style that emphasizes the stillness of the environment.

Explanation: The video maintains high fidelity to the first frame and successfully captures the requested static, observational style. However, the dolly forward movement is so minimal that it barely fulfills the prompt's requirement for a 'slow, steady dolly forward', and there is slight geometric instability in the foreground debris. | overall_score=85 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":90,"motion_quality":80,"temporal_consistency":85,"visual_quality":90,"camera_composition":80}

Explanation: The video maintains high visual fidelity to the first frame and adheres well to the prompt's requirements for stillness. However, the requested 'slow, steady dolly forward' is barely perceptible, making the motion quality feel somewhat underwhelming. | overall_score=85 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":90,"motion_quality":85,"temporal_consistency":80,"visual_quality":90,"camera_composition":80}

Explanation: The video adheres well to the prompt's requirements for stillness and environmental atmosphere, though the requested 'dolly forward' motion is very minimal and lacks the expected depth shift. The visual quality is high and the temporal consistency is maintained throughout the short sequence. | overall_score=85 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":90,"motion_quality":80,"temporal_consistency":85,"visual_quality":90,"camera_composition":80}


Prompt: The camera performs a slow, steady drone-style dolly-in movement, gradually approaching the stone building while maintaining a high-angle perspective. As the camera advances, the foreground olive trees shift slightly in the frame, revealing more of the structure's exterior stairs and base. The surrounding landscape of dense orchards and distant hills remains static throughout the shot. This sequence captures a rural stone house nestled within a vast, sprawling agricultural valley under a clear sky.

Explanation: The video successfully executes the requested dolly-in movement while maintaining high fidelity to the conditioning frame. While there is some minor motion jitter and slight texture warping in the foreground foliage, the overall quality is high and the scene remains consistent throughout the duration. | overall_score=85 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":90,"motion_quality":80,"temporal_consistency":90,"visual_quality":85,"camera_composition":80}

Explanation: The video successfully maintains the identity of the stone house and the surrounding landscape throughout the sequence. While the camera movement is a bit mechanical and lacks the fluid, cinematic quality of a professional drone shot, it adheres well to the prompt's requirements for a slow, steady approach. | overall_score=85 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":90,"motion_quality":85,"temporal_consistency":90,"visual_quality":85,"camera_composition":80}

Explanation: The video successfully executes the requested dolly-in movement while maintaining high fidelity to the conditioning frame. While the motion is slightly less smooth than ideal and the foreground reveal is limited, the overall quality is high and adheres well to the prompt's requirements. | overall_score=85 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":90,"motion_quality":85,"temporal_consistency":90,"visual_quality":85,"camera_composition":80}


Prompt: A flock of birds glides slowly across the sky, maintaining their relative positions while drifting gradually toward the right side of the frame. Their wings remain mostly still as they soar through the air. The camera is static, capturing a wide, fixed view of the overcast sky. This scene features a group of birds circling and drifting together against a backdrop of thick, grey clouds.

Explanation: The video maintains high fidelity to the first frame and effectively captures the requested motion of a flock of birds gliding across an overcast sky. While there is minor jitter in the bird movement, the overall temporal consistency and visual quality are strong. | overall_score=85 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":90,"motion_quality":80,"temporal_consistency":85,"visual_quality":85,"camera_composition":90}

Explanation: The video maintains high fidelity to the first frame and successfully captures the requested motion of the birds gliding across the sky. While there is minor jitter in the bird movement, the overall temporal consistency and visual quality are strong. | overall_score=85 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":90,"motion_quality":80,"temporal_consistency":85,"visual_quality":85,"camera_composition":90}

Explanation: The video successfully maintains the composition and atmosphere of the first frame while adhering well to the prompt's description of a gliding flock. The motion is generally smooth, though there is some minor jitter in the birds' silhouettes. | overall_score=85 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":90,"motion_quality":80,"temporal_consistency":85,"visual_quality":85,"camera_composition":90}


Prompt: A small, steady stream of water flows continuously from between mossy rocks into a calm, dark pool below. The water surface in the foreground exhibits gentle, rhythmic ripples that propagate outward from the center toward the edges of the frame. The camera remains completely static throughout the entire duration, maintaining a fixed, eye-level framing of the rocky stream bed and the small waterfall.

Explanation: The video maintains high fidelity to the first frame and exhibits very stable, static camera work. While the water motion is realistic, the specific request for ripples propagating outward from the center is only partially realized, resulting in a slight deduction in prompt adherence. | overall_score=88 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":100,"prompt_adherence":90,"motion_quality":85,"temporal_consistency":90,"visual_quality":90,"camera_composition":95}

Explanation: The video maintains high fidelity to the first frame and adheres well to the prompt's requirements for a static camera and specific scene elements. While the water motion is slightly repetitive, it is visually convincing and temporally stable. | overall_score=88 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":100,"prompt_adherence":95,"motion_quality":80,"temporal_consistency":90,"visual_quality":90,"camera_composition":100}

Explanation: The video is highly faithful to the conditioning frame and adheres well to the prompt's requirements for a static camera and specific subject matter. While the fluid motion is slightly limited in its dynamic range, the overall temporal consistency and visual fidelity are very strong. | overall_score=88 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":100,"prompt_adherence":95,"motion_quality":80,"temporal_consistency":90,"visual_quality":90,"camera_composition":100}


Prompt: The water flows continuously from the stone structure, cascading down the rocky stream bed toward the foreground. The white, turbulent water churns around the large, stationary boulders, creating constant ripples and splashes as it moves downstream. The camera remains completely static throughout the entire five-second duration, maintaining a fixed, wide-angle framing of the scene. This shot captures a rustic stone building nestled in a lush, green forest setting with a small, active waterfall flowing through the center.

Explanation: While the model successfully maintains the visual fidelity of the first frame and the static camera framing, it fails significantly on the motion requirements. The water, which is the primary subject of the prompt, shows almost no fluid motion, resulting in a static image rather than a video. | overall_score=35 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":40,"motion_quality":10,"temporal_consistency":20,"visual_quality":50,"camera_composition":90}

Explanation: The video is highly faithful to the conditioning frame and adheres well to the prompt's descriptive requirements. While the motion is technically present, it is somewhat limited in intensity, but the overall visual quality and stability are very high. | overall_score=88 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":98,"prompt_adherence":95,"motion_quality":80,"temporal_consistency":90,"visual_quality":95,"camera_composition":95}

Explanation: The video is highly faithful to the conditioning frame and adheres well to the prompt's requirements for a static camera and specific scene elements. While the motion of the water is functional, it lacks the high-fidelity turbulence and natural flow dynamics one would expect, but it remains a very strong generation overall. | overall_score=88 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":100,"prompt_adherence":95,"motion_quality":80,"temporal_consistency":90,"visual_quality":90,"camera_composition":95}


Prompt: A man holds a woman in his arms on a city street. The woman slowly extends her arms outward to the sides, reaching a full stretch before pulling them back in to wrap them around the man’s neck. Throughout the motion, the man remains stationary while holding her, and the woman keeps her head tilted back. The camera is static, maintaining a medium shot of the couple as pedestrians walk by in the background during the golden hour.

Explanation: The video adheres well to the prompt's core requirements, particularly the static camera and the man's stationary pose. While the woman's arm movement is not perfectly fluid or fully extended as described, the overall temporal consistency and visual quality are high. | overall_score=82 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":98,"prompt_adherence":85,"motion_quality":80,"temporal_consistency":85,"visual_quality":85,"camera_composition":80}

Explanation: The video is highly faithful to the first frame and captures the requested mood and character positioning well. However, the specific arm movements requested in the prompt are not fully realized, with the extension being somewhat limited and the final hand placement lacking clarity. | overall_score=82 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":85,"motion_quality":80,"temporal_consistency":85,"visual_quality":85,"camera_composition":80}

Explanation: The video is highly faithful to the conditioning frame and captures the requested mood and static camera composition well. While the arm movement is slightly less fluid and expansive than the prompt describes, the overall temporal consistency and visual quality are high. | overall_score=82 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":98,"prompt_adherence":85,"motion_quality":80,"temporal_consistency":85,"visual_quality":85,"camera_composition":80}


Prompt: The woman stands still on the wooden staircase, holding a book in her right hand while resting her left arm on the railing. She slowly turns her head from looking straight ahead to gazing toward the left, then gently closes her eyes for a brief moment before opening them again to look forward. The camera remains completely static throughout the entire duration, maintaining a fixed medium shot of the woman positioned on the stairs against a plain wall.

Explanation: The video maintains high visual quality and excellent fidelity to the first frame. However, it fails to fully adhere to the prompt's instruction to return to looking forward after the eye-closing sequence, as the subject remains looking to the left. | overall_score=85 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":80,"motion_quality":85,"temporal_consistency":90,"visual_quality":90,"camera_composition":95}

Explanation: The video maintains high visual quality and excellent fidelity to the first frame. However, it fails to execute the specific action of closing the eyes, and the head movement is less pronounced than requested. | overall_score=85 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":80,"motion_quality":85,"temporal_consistency":90,"visual_quality":90,"camera_composition":95}

Explanation: The video maintains high visual quality and excellent fidelity to the first frame. However, it fails to execute the specific action of closing the eyes, and the head movement is less pronounced than the prompt requested. | overall_score=85 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":80,"motion_quality":85,"temporal_consistency":90,"visual_quality":90,"camera_composition":95}


Prompt: Ocean waves flow continuously from the top left toward the bottom right, crashing against and swirling around three dark, stationary rock formations. The white sea foam churns and dissipates as it moves past the rocks, creating a rhythmic, turbulent current. The camera remains in a fixed, top-down aerial position throughout the entire sequence, maintaining a consistent, stable framing of the rocks and the surrounding water as the tide moves steadily across the frame.

Explanation: The video maintains high fidelity to the conditioning frame and effectively captures the requested motion of waves around the rocks. While there is some minor temporal instability in the foam, the overall visual quality and adherence to the prompt are very strong. | overall_score=88 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":98,"prompt_adherence":95,"motion_quality":85,"temporal_consistency":82,"visual_quality":90,"camera_composition":95}

Explanation: The video maintains high fidelity to the first frame and effectively captures the requested motion of ocean waves around the rocks. The temporal consistency is strong, with only minor, expected artifacts in the fluid simulation. | overall_score=92 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":98,"prompt_adherence":95,"motion_quality":90,"temporal_consistency":92,"visual_quality":95,"camera_composition":90}

Explanation: The video maintains high visual fidelity to the first frame and effectively captures the requested motion of ocean waves around the rocks. The temporal consistency is strong, with only minor, negligible jitter in the foam patterns. | overall_score=92 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":100,"prompt_adherence":95,"motion_quality":90,"temporal_consistency":90,"visual_quality":95,"camera_composition":90}


Prompt: Clear water flows rapidly over rocky terrain, cascading forward toward the viewer in a continuous, turbulent stream. The water surface ripples and churns as it moves downstream, creating constant motion and white foam against the stones. The camera remains static in a low-angle, close-up framing, capturing the immediate foreground of the flowing creek. This scene depicts a small, sunlit forest stream nestled within a dense, green woodland setting, focusing entirely on the fluid, rhythmic movement of the water.

Explanation: The video maintains high visual fidelity to the conditioning frame and effectively captures the requested fluid motion of the stream. While there is some minor flickering in the foam, the overall temporal consistency and adherence to the prompt's atmospheric requirements are very high. | overall_score=92 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":100,"prompt_adherence":95,"motion_quality":90,"temporal_consistency":95,"visual_quality":90,"camera_composition":90}

Explanation: The video demonstrates high technical proficiency, maintaining perfect alignment with the conditioning frame while delivering realistic, continuous water motion that matches the prompt's description of a turbulent, sunlit forest stream. | overall_score=92 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":100,"prompt_adherence":95,"motion_quality":90,"temporal_consistency":95,"visual_quality":90,"camera_composition":90}

Explanation: The video maintains high fidelity to the conditioning frame and effectively captures the requested scene. While the water motion is generally good, there is some minor temporal instability in the foam textures, but it remains a high-quality generation. | overall_score=88 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":98,"prompt_adherence":95,"motion_quality":85,"temporal_consistency":80,"visual_quality":90,"camera_composition":95}


Prompt: Ocean waves roll consistently toward the shore, breaking into white foam that surges forward across the wet, pebble-strewn beach before receding back into the sea. The water movement is rhythmic and continuous throughout the entire duration. The camera remains static, maintaining a fixed, wide-angle perspective of the coastline. A distant lighthouse stands stationary on the horizon, overlooking the expansive, overcast beach scene as the tide interacts with the rocky shoreline.

Explanation: The video maintains high fidelity to the conditioning frame and effectively captures the requested scene. While there is minor temporal instability in the foam's movement, the overall visual quality and adherence to the prompt are very high. | overall_score=88 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":90,"motion_quality":85,"temporal_consistency":85,"visual_quality":90,"camera_composition":90}

Explanation: The video demonstrates high fidelity to the conditioning frame and effectively captures the requested motion of waves on a pebble beach. While there is some minor temporal instability in the foam's texture, the overall visual quality and adherence to the prompt are very strong. | overall_score=88 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":98,"prompt_adherence":95,"motion_quality":85,"temporal_consistency":85,"visual_quality":90,"camera_composition":95}


Prompt: The camera performs a slow, steady dolly forward through a snow-themed indoor park. A person in a dark hooded coat stands in the left foreground, holding a phone to record the scene. In the middle ground, several people walk slowly from left to right across the frame. The camera movement continues at a constant pace, maintaining a wide, eye-level perspective as it glides past the artificial cherry blossom tree and the illuminated Japanese-style pagoda structure.

Explanation: The generated video fails almost entirely to execute the requested camera movement and character animation, resulting in a static, flickering image that does not adhere to the prompt's motion requirements. | overall_score=25 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":90,"prompt_adherence":20,"motion_quality":10,"temporal_consistency":10,"visual_quality":30,"camera_composition":20}

Explanation: The generated video fails significantly on motion requirements, providing only a static, flickering image instead of the requested dolly forward camera movement. While the first frame is accurate, the lack of temporal progression and the distracting flicker make the output unusable as a video. | overall_score=25 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":90,"prompt_adherence":20,"motion_quality":10,"temporal_consistency":10,"visual_quality":30,"camera_composition":20}

Explanation: The video fails to execute the requested camera movement, remaining almost entirely static throughout the duration. Furthermore, there is significant temporal flickering and instability in the background elements and the people, which severely degrades the visual quality. | overall_score=35 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":90,"prompt_adherence":40,"motion_quality":20,"temporal_consistency":20,"visual_quality":40,"camera_composition":30}


Prompt: A motorcycle enters the frame from the left and drives across the foreground from left to right, passing behind the stationary metal chain. As the motorcycle exits the frame to the right, a couple walks slowly across the background from left to right, moving past the blurred city street and buildings. The camera remains completely static throughout the entire duration of the clip, maintaining a fixed, close-up framing of the heavy iron chain links in the foreground.

Explanation: While the model successfully maintained the static camera and the first frame, it failed to incorporate the secondary subject (the couple) and struggled with the spatial relationship between the motorcycle and the foreground chain. | overall_score=45 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":30,"motion_quality":40,"temporal_consistency":50,"visual_quality":60,"camera_composition":90}

Explanation: While the model successfully maintained the static camera and the first frame, it failed significantly on the prompt requirements, specifically omitting the couple and failing to correctly layer the motorcycle behind the chain. | overall_score=45 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":30,"motion_quality":40,"temporal_consistency":50,"visual_quality":60,"camera_composition":90}

Explanation: While the video successfully maintains the static camera and the first frame, it fails significantly on the prompt requirements, specifically the interaction between the motorcycle and the chain, and the complete omission of the couple walking in the background. | overall_score=45 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":30,"motion_quality":40,"temporal_consistency":50,"visual_quality":60,"camera_composition":90}


Prompt: The camera performs a slow, steady drone-like forward dolly movement over a public park at dusk. A few pedestrians walk along the paved path near the riverbank, while a vehicle moves slowly along the road toward the right side of the frame. The water remains calm, reflecting the twilight sky. This scene captures a wide, elevated perspective of a riverside promenade featuring a prominent tall tower and a small water park area in the foreground.

Explanation: The video maintains high visual fidelity to the first frame and captures the atmosphere well, but the requested camera motion is too subtle to be clearly perceived as a distinct dolly movement, and the dynamic elements (vehicle) are somewhat static. | overall_score=85 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":98,"prompt_adherence":90,"motion_quality":80,"temporal_consistency":85,"visual_quality":90,"camera_composition":80}

Explanation: The video maintains high visual quality and excellent fidelity to the first frame, but the requested camera motion is very minimal, making the 'dolly' effect difficult to perceive. The scene is otherwise well-rendered and consistent. | overall_score=85 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":90,"motion_quality":80,"temporal_consistency":85,"visual_quality":90,"camera_composition":80}

Explanation: The video successfully captures the requested scene with high fidelity to the first frame and good adherence to the prompt's specific elements. The motion is generally good, though it lacks the perfect smoothness of a professional drone shot, and there is some minor temporal instability in the water reflections. | overall_score=85 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":90,"motion_quality":85,"temporal_consistency":80,"visual_quality":90,"camera_composition":80}


Prompt: A person’s hand reaches into a green plastic basket filled with small, freshly caught fish and repeatedly tosses them upward, causing the fish to flip and scramble in mid-air before landing back in the pile. The hand continues this rhythmic, repetitive motion throughout the entire clip, occasionally adjusting its grip on the fish. The camera remains static in a high-angle, close-up shot, focusing on the person sorting the catch on a sandy beach.

Explanation: The video successfully captures the requested action and maintains high visual fidelity to the first frame. While the physics of the fish movement could be more realistic and fluid, the overall execution is highly competent and adheres well to the prompt. | overall_score=82 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":98,"prompt_adherence":85,"motion_quality":75,"temporal_consistency":80,"visual_quality":85,"camera_composition":90}

Explanation: The video maintains high visual fidelity to the first frame and captures the general scene well, but it fails to fully realize the specific dynamic action of tossing fish into the air, resulting in a more static sorting motion. | overall_score=78 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":85,"motion_quality":70,"temporal_consistency":75,"visual_quality":80,"camera_composition":90}

Explanation: The video maintains high fidelity to the first frame and captures the requested scene well, though the motion of the fish and the hand could be more physically convincing and less jittery. | overall_score=82 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":98,"prompt_adherence":85,"motion_quality":75,"temporal_consistency":80,"visual_quality":85,"camera_composition":90}


Prompt: Three young girls wearing party hats sit at a table with a birthday cake. The girl in the center blows into a party horn, causing the paper end to extend and retract repeatedly. The girl on the left holds a green party horn to her mouth, while the girl on the right holds a pink one. The camera remains static throughout the entire five-second shot, maintaining a medium framing of the children.

Explanation: The video maintains high visual fidelity to the first frame and adheres well to the scene composition. However, it fails to fully execute the specific motion requirement of the party horn extending and retracting repeatedly, showing only a single, limited motion. | overall_score=82 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":98,"prompt_adherence":85,"motion_quality":75,"temporal_consistency":80,"visual_quality":90,"camera_composition":95}

Explanation: The video maintains high fidelity to the first frame and successfully captures the requested scene. While the motion of the party horn is slightly limited and doesn't fully retract as requested, the overall temporal consistency and visual quality are strong. | overall_score=85 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":98,"prompt_adherence":90,"motion_quality":80,"temporal_consistency":85,"visual_quality":90,"camera_composition":95}

Explanation: The video maintains high visual quality and adheres well to the prompt's composition and character requirements. The primary limitation is the motion of the party horn, which lacks the dynamic extension and retraction requested in the prompt. | overall_score=85 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":90,"motion_quality":80,"temporal_consistency":85,"visual_quality":90,"camera_composition":95}


Prompt: A mother duck and her two ducklings swim steadily from left to right across the frame. The mother maintains a consistent pace while the ducklings follow closely behind, bobbing slightly in the water. The camera remains static throughout the entire five-second duration, maintaining a medium shot of the birds as they traverse the calm, rippling surface of the pond. The scene captures the natural, synchronized movement of the waterfowl as they glide across the water.

Explanation: The generated video is effectively a static image that fails to animate the subjects. Despite maintaining the first frame's appearance, it completely ignores the prompt's requirement for the ducks to swim across the frame, resulting in a failure of motion and temporal progression. | overall_score=25 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":20,"motion_quality":10,"temporal_consistency":10,"visual_quality":30,"camera_composition":80}

Explanation: The generated video fails significantly on motion quality and prompt adherence, as it is effectively a static image with no discernible movement of the ducks or the water, despite the prompt explicitly requiring them to swim across the frame. | overall_score=25 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":20,"motion_quality":10,"temporal_consistency":10,"visual_quality":30,"camera_composition":80}

Explanation: While the video maintains high fidelity to the first frame, it fails significantly on motion quality and prompt adherence. The ducks do not swim or move forward as requested, and the water surface remains almost entirely static, resulting in a near-still image rather than a video. | overall_score=35 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":30,"motion_quality":20,"temporal_consistency":40,"visual_quality":50,"camera_composition":70}


Prompt: The elderly man remains perfectly still, gazing out through the window with a steady, fixed expression. His eyes do not blink or shift, and his facial features remain entirely motionless throughout the duration of the shot. The camera is static, maintaining a tight, unwavering profile framing of the man’s face against the window frame. The scene captures a quiet, contemplative moment of an older man looking out from indoors, with no movement occurring in the frame.

Explanation: The video maintains high fidelity to the first frame and adheres well to the prompt's requirement for a static, contemplative scene. However, there is a slight, noticeable shift in the man's gaze towards the end of the video, which slightly deviates from the instruction that he remains perfectly still. | overall_score=92 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":100,"prompt_adherence":95,"motion_quality":90,"temporal_consistency":95,"visual_quality":95,"camera_composition":95}

Explanation: The video adheres very well to the prompt's requirement for a static, contemplative scene, though there is a slight, unintended shift in the subject's eyes that contradicts the instruction for a perfectly fixed expression. | overall_score=85 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":100,"prompt_adherence":90,"motion_quality":80,"temporal_consistency":85,"visual_quality":90,"camera_composition":95}

Explanation: The video successfully maintains the static composition and overall visual quality requested, but fails to keep the subject's eyes perfectly still, which was a specific constraint in the prompt. | overall_score=85 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":100,"prompt_adherence":90,"motion_quality":80,"temporal_consistency":85,"visual_quality":90,"camera_composition":95}


Prompt: A small dark bird flies steadily from the left side of the frame toward the right, passing in front of the large white cumulus clouds. The camera remains completely static throughout the five-second duration, maintaining a fixed wide shot of the bright blue sky. The clouds themselves remain stationary, providing a stable backdrop for the bird as it traverses the open space from left to right.

Explanation: The video successfully maintains the static camera and the requested bird trajectory while preserving the integrity of the initial frame. The motion is smooth and consistent, though the bird's wing movement is somewhat simplistic. | overall_score=92 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":100,"prompt_adherence":95,"motion_quality":90,"temporal_consistency":95,"visual_quality":90,"camera_composition":90}

Explanation: The video adheres perfectly to the prompt, maintaining a static camera and a consistent, steady flight path for the bird against a stable background. The visual quality is high, and the motion is fluid without any noticeable artifacts or temporal instability. | overall_score=92 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":100,"prompt_adherence":95,"motion_quality":90,"temporal_consistency":95,"visual_quality":95,"camera_composition":90}

Explanation: The video adheres perfectly to the prompt, maintaining a static camera and a consistent background while the bird moves smoothly across the frame. The visual quality is high and the motion is natural. | overall_score=92 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":100,"prompt_adherence":95,"motion_quality":90,"temporal_consistency":95,"visual_quality":95,"camera_composition":95}


Prompt: A continuous stream of roasted coffee beans falls vertically from above, landing directly into a clear glass mug and overflowing onto the surrounding wooden surface. The beans bounce and scatter outward as they strike the pile already accumulated inside and around the base of the glass. The camera remains completely static throughout the entire duration, maintaining a fixed, eye-level medium shot of the glass mug centered against a blurred, light-colored brick wall background.

Explanation: While the video maintains the composition and initial state of the conditioning frame perfectly, it fails significantly to animate the requested action. The coffee beans do not fall or overflow; they remain suspended in a static, jittery loop that ignores the physics of the prompt. | overall_score=35 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":30,"motion_quality":20,"temporal_consistency":40,"visual_quality":40,"camera_composition":85}

Explanation: While the video maintains the initial composition and framing, it fails significantly on motion quality and prompt adherence. The coffee beans do not fall or interact with the mug; instead, they exhibit a repetitive, jittery animation that lacks any sense of physical movement or gravity. | overall_score=35 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":30,"motion_quality":20,"temporal_consistency":30,"visual_quality":40,"camera_composition":90}

Explanation: While the video maintains the composition and initial frame perfectly, it fails significantly on the motion requirements of the prompt. The coffee beans do not exhibit a realistic falling motion or physical interaction with the mug, resulting in a static, jittery appearance that contradicts the prompt's description of a continuous, dynamic stream. | overall_score=35 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":30,"motion_quality":20,"temporal_consistency":30,"visual_quality":40,"camera_composition":90}


Prompt: A person plays a MIDI keyboard, rhythmically pressing and releasing the keys with their right hand. The fingers move in a steady, repetitive sequence, depressing individual keys and lifting them back up in time with a musical beat. The camera remains in a static, close-up side profile shot, focusing on the interaction between the fingers and the illuminated keys. The scene captures a musician performing on a modern electronic keyboard in a dimly lit studio environment.

Explanation: The video successfully maintains the visual style and composition of the conditioning frame while executing the requested motion. While the finger movement is not perfectly realistic in its physics, it is highly coherent and adheres well to the prompt's requirements for a rhythmic performance. | overall_score=85 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":90,"motion_quality":80,"temporal_consistency":85,"visual_quality":90,"camera_composition":95}

Explanation: The video maintains high fidelity to the conditioning frame and effectively captures the requested atmosphere. While the finger motion is slightly fluid and lacks perfect mechanical precision, it is generally convincing and adheres well to the prompt's requirements. | overall_score=85 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":90,"motion_quality":80,"temporal_consistency":85,"visual_quality":90,"camera_composition":95}

Explanation: The video maintains high visual quality and excellent fidelity to the conditioning frame. While the finger movement is slightly fluid rather than perfectly rhythmic, it effectively captures the essence of the prompt with minimal temporal artifacts. | overall_score=85 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":90,"motion_quality":80,"temporal_consistency":85,"visual_quality":90,"camera_composition":95}


Prompt: The camera performs a smooth, continuous forward dolly movement, gliding over a bustling shipping terminal. As the perspective advances, the large container ship docked at the pier remains stationary while the foreground landscape shifts steadily toward the viewer. The wide-angle framing captures the expansive industrial yard, emphasizing the depth of the rows of stacked shipping containers and the towering cranes as the camera maintains a consistent, steady trajectory throughout the entire five-second duration.

Explanation: The video maintains high visual fidelity and adheres well to the core requirements of the prompt, though the forward dolly motion is less pronounced than expected. The scene remains stable and consistent throughout the duration. | overall_score=85 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":90,"motion_quality":80,"temporal_consistency":85,"visual_quality":90,"camera_composition":80}

Explanation: The video successfully executes the requested forward dolly movement while maintaining high fidelity to the initial frame. While there is some minor geometric instability in the complex crane structures, the overall temporal consistency and adherence to the prompt are strong. | overall_score=85 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":98,"prompt_adherence":90,"motion_quality":85,"temporal_consistency":80,"visual_quality":85,"camera_composition":80}

Explanation: The video successfully executes the requested forward dolly movement while maintaining high fidelity to the conditioning frame. While there is some minor geometric instability in the complex crane structures, the overall temporal consistency and adherence to the prompt are strong. | overall_score=85 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":98,"prompt_adherence":90,"motion_quality":85,"temporal_consistency":80,"visual_quality":85,"camera_composition":80}


Prompt: The cellist rhythmically pulls the bow across the strings in a steady, repetitive down-and-up motion, while her left hand remains positioned on the fingerboard to hold the notes. Her head and torso sway slightly in time with the music as she focuses on the sheet music. The camera remains static throughout the shot, maintaining a medium side-profile framing of the young girl playing the cello in a bright, sunlit room.

Explanation: The video maintains high fidelity to the conditioning frame and adheres well to the prompt's composition requirements. While the motion of the bow is slightly mechanical and lacks perfect realism, the overall temporal consistency and visual quality are very high. | overall_score=85 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":90,"motion_quality":80,"temporal_consistency":85,"visual_quality":90,"camera_composition":95}

Explanation: The video is highly faithful to the conditioning frame and maintains excellent visual quality and composition. However, the motion of the cello playing is somewhat robotic and lacks the necessary nuance in the left hand and bow arm to fully satisfy the prompt's description of rhythmic, active playing. | overall_score=82 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":98,"prompt_adherence":90,"motion_quality":75,"temporal_consistency":85,"visual_quality":85,"camera_composition":95}

Explanation: While the video perfectly preserves the first frame and camera framing, it fails significantly on the motion requirements. The bow movement is physically incorrect and jittery, and the subject lacks the requested subtle body movements, resulting in a static and unrealistic performance. | overall_score=45 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":60,"motion_quality":20,"temporal_consistency":30,"visual_quality":60,"camera_composition":90}


Prompt: The water surface ripples with consistent, rhythmic waves moving steadily toward the lower left corner of the frame. The camera performs a slow, smooth, and continuous upward tilt, gradually revealing more of the dense, green mangrove forest that borders the dark, reflective water. This aerial perspective maintains a steady, elevated framing throughout the entire sequence, focusing on the interplay between the textured, moving water and the expansive, static canopy of the surrounding coastal vegetation.

Explanation: The video maintains high visual fidelity to the first frame and exhibits good temporal stability. However, it fails to fully execute the requested camera tilt and the specific directional wave motion described in the prompt. | overall_score=85 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":100,"prompt_adherence":80,"motion_quality":85,"temporal_consistency":90,"visual_quality":90,"camera_composition":65}

Explanation: The video maintains high visual fidelity and temporal stability, but the camera movement is too minimal to fully satisfy the prompt's requirement for a 'slow, smooth, and continuous upward tilt'. | overall_score=85 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":100,"prompt_adherence":90,"motion_quality":85,"temporal_consistency":90,"visual_quality":90,"camera_composition":60}

Explanation: The video is visually impressive and maintains perfect fidelity to the first frame, but it fails to execute the requested camera movement effectively, resulting in a nearly static shot rather than a clear upward tilt. | overall_score=88 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":98,"prompt_adherence":90,"motion_quality":85,"temporal_consistency":95,"visual_quality":92,"camera_composition":70}


Prompt: Three elands graze on a grassy field in front of a large rock. The eland on the left moves its head rhythmically downward to feed on the grass, while the central eland shifts its weight and turns its head slightly to the right. The eland on the right remains mostly still, keeping its head lowered to graze. The camera is static, maintaining a wide, high-angle framing of the animals throughout the entire five-second duration.

Explanation: While the video starts with high fidelity to the conditioning frame, it fails significantly on the motion requirements specified in the prompt. The central eland suffers from severe, unnatural morphing artifacts rather than the requested movement, and the other animals remain static, failing to fulfill the dynamic requirements of the prompt. | overall_score=35 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":30,"motion_quality":20,"temporal_consistency":30,"visual_quality":40,"camera_composition":60}

Explanation: While the video maintains the initial composition and framing perfectly, it fails significantly on the motion requirements. The central eland suffers from a major visual artifact where its head morphs into a distorted, unrecognizable shape, and the expected grazing motions are largely static or non-existent. | overall_score=35 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":20,"motion_quality":20,"temporal_consistency":30,"visual_quality":40,"camera_composition":90}

Explanation: While the video starts with high fidelity to the conditioning frame, it suffers from a catastrophic failure in the central subject's geometry, which morphs into a nonsensical shape. The motion is minimal and fails to capture the specific actions requested in the prompt. | overall_score=35 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":20,"motion_quality":20,"temporal_consistency":30,"visual_quality":40,"camera_composition":90}


Prompt: The turbulent river water flows rapidly downstream, churning and bubbling as it surges through the narrow, rocky canyon gap. The white-capped current maintains a consistent, forceful forward motion toward the viewer. The camera remains completely static throughout the entire five-second duration, maintaining a fixed, high-angle framing of the river nestled between the steep, craggy canyon walls and the surrounding pine trees.

Explanation: While the model successfully maintained the static camera and high-fidelity composition of the first frame, it completely failed to generate the requested motion of the river, resulting in a static image rather than a video. | overall_score=25 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":30,"motion_quality":10,"temporal_consistency":10,"visual_quality":30,"camera_composition":80}

Explanation: While the model successfully maintained the composition and fidelity of the first frame, it failed completely to generate the requested motion. The river appears entirely static, failing the core requirement of the prompt to depict turbulent, rapidly flowing water. | overall_score=25 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":30,"motion_quality":10,"temporal_consistency":20,"visual_quality":30,"camera_composition":60}

Explanation: While the model successfully maintains the composition and visual fidelity of the first frame, it fails completely to generate the requested motion. The river remains frozen, which contradicts the prompt's requirement for rapid, turbulent flow. | overall_score=25 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":30,"motion_quality":10,"temporal_consistency":20,"visual_quality":30,"camera_composition":60}


Prompt: A red double-decker bus travels slowly down the center of a deserted city street, moving away from the camera toward the background. The bus maintains a steady pace, eventually passing through an intersection. The camera remains completely static throughout the entire duration of the clip, maintaining a fixed, eye-level framing of the urban thoroughfare. The scene features a quiet, empty road at night, illuminated by traffic lights and building lights, with the bus as the only moving element.

Explanation: The video successfully maintains the static camera and the first frame's composition. While the bus's movement is slightly unnatural (sliding effect), it adheres well to the prompt's requirements for a night scene with a moving bus. | overall_score=85 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":90,"motion_quality":80,"temporal_consistency":85,"visual_quality":90,"camera_composition":95}

Explanation: While the model successfully maintains the initial frame and camera composition, it fails significantly on the core motion requirement. The bus does not travel down the street as requested; instead, it remains stationary while the background exhibits unnatural, jittery movement, failing to depict the requested action. | overall_score=35 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":90,"prompt_adherence":40,"motion_quality":20,"temporal_consistency":30,"visual_quality":50,"camera_composition":80}

Explanation: While the video maintains the initial frame and camera composition well, it fails significantly on the core motion requirement. The bus does not travel down the street; instead, it remains frozen in place while the background exhibits unnatural, jittery movement, failing to depict the requested action. | overall_score=35 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":90,"prompt_adherence":40,"motion_quality":20,"temporal_consistency":30,"visual_quality":50,"camera_composition":80}


Prompt: The camera performs a steady, continuous vertical descent directly over a dense forest of snow-covered pine trees. As the drone moves downward, the trees appear to expand outward from the center of the frame, creating a sense of increasing proximity to the canopy. The perspective remains fixed in a top-down, bird's-eye view throughout the entire duration, maintaining a consistent downward trajectory toward the winter landscape below.

Explanation: While the first frame is accurate, the model failed to generate any motion, resulting in a static image rather than the requested drone descent video. | overall_score=25 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":10,"motion_quality":10,"temporal_consistency":20,"visual_quality":40,"camera_composition":20}

Explanation: The video successfully executes the requested vertical descent with high fidelity to the initial frame. The motion is smooth and maintains the required perspective throughout, with only minor issues regarding texture stability during the zoom. | overall_score=92 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":100,"prompt_adherence":95,"motion_quality":90,"temporal_consistency":95,"visual_quality":90,"camera_composition":90}

Explanation: The video successfully executes the requested vertical descent with high fidelity to the initial frame. The motion is smooth and maintains the required top-down perspective throughout the sequence. | overall_score=92 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":100,"prompt_adherence":95,"motion_quality":90,"temporal_consistency":95,"visual_quality":90,"camera_composition":90}


Prompt: A herd of blackbuck antelopes stands in a dirt enclosure, with one individual resting on the ground in the foreground. Throughout the clip, the antelope on the far right lowers its head to graze on the ground, while the others remain standing and shift their weight slightly. The camera is static, maintaining a wide, fixed framing of the scene. The movement is subtle, characterized primarily by the grazing motion of the single standing buck and minor postural adjustments among the herd.

Explanation: While the video successfully maintains the composition and appearance of the first frame, it fails significantly on the motion requirements of the prompt. The scene is almost entirely static, lacking the requested grazing behavior and natural animal movement, and suffers from persistent flickering artifacts. | overall_score=35 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":30,"motion_quality":20,"temporal_consistency":20,"visual_quality":40,"camera_composition":70}

Explanation: While the model successfully maintained the visual fidelity of the first frame and the static camera composition, it failed to generate any of the requested motion. The video is effectively a static image, failing the prompt's requirement for grazing and postural adjustments. | overall_score=35 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":30,"motion_quality":10,"temporal_consistency":20,"visual_quality":40,"camera_composition":80}

Explanation: While the model perfectly preserved the first frame, it failed to generate any of the requested motion, resulting in a static image rather than a video clip. The lack of movement makes it fail the prompt adherence and motion quality criteria significantly. | overall_score=35 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":30,"motion_quality":10,"temporal_consistency":20,"visual_quality":40,"camera_composition":80}


Prompt: The camera performs a slow, steady, and continuous forward dolly movement, descending slightly while maintaining a top-down perspective over the landscape. As the camera glides forward, the entire scene shifts upward in the frame, revealing more of the lower garden paths and surrounding greenery. The perspective remains fixed on the estate grounds, capturing a smooth, linear approach toward the center of the manicured gardens and the adjacent historic manor house.

Explanation: The generated video fails to execute the requested camera movement entirely, remaining almost completely static throughout the duration. While the visual quality and fidelity to the first frame are high, the lack of adherence to the motion prompt makes it a failure in terms of video generation. | overall_score=25 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":10,"motion_quality":10,"temporal_consistency":20,"visual_quality":40,"camera_composition":20}

Explanation: The generated video fails to execute the requested camera movement entirely. While the first frame is perfectly preserved, the video remains static throughout, failing to meet the prompt's requirement for a slow, steady, and continuous forward dolly movement. | overall_score=25 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":10,"motion_quality":10,"temporal_consistency":20,"visual_quality":60,"camera_composition":20}

Explanation: The generated video fails to execute the requested camera movement entirely, resulting in a near-static image that ignores the prompt's specific instructions for a forward dolly and descent. | overall_score=25 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":10,"motion_quality":10,"temporal_consistency":20,"visual_quality":60,"camera_composition":20}


Prompt: A single bird flies steadily from the right side of the frame toward the left, crossing the horizon line against the backdrop of the sea and cliffs. The water surface ripples gently with small, rhythmic waves moving toward the shore. The camera remains completely static throughout the entire duration, maintaining a wide, fixed framing of the coastal landscape and the sunset sky.

Explanation: The video adheres well to the prompt and maintains high visual quality and camera stability. The primary shortcomings are the lack of dynamic water movement and slightly robotic wing animation for the bird. | overall_score=85 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":90,"motion_quality":80,"temporal_consistency":85,"visual_quality":90,"camera_composition":95}

Explanation: The video adheres well to the prompt's structural requirements, particularly the static camera and the bird's movement path. However, the motion of the bird and the water is somewhat limited and lacks the dynamic realism expected for a high-quality generation. | overall_score=85 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":90,"motion_quality":80,"temporal_consistency":85,"visual_quality":90,"camera_composition":95}

Explanation: The video adheres well to the prompt and maintains high visual quality and camera stability. The primary shortcomings are the lack of dynamic water movement and slightly robotic wing flapping of the bird. | overall_score=85 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":90,"motion_quality":80,"temporal_consistency":85,"visual_quality":90,"camera_composition":95}


Prompt: A man rides a bicycle directly toward the camera along a narrow, cobblestone urban alleyway. He maintains a steady pace, pedaling continuously while holding a phone to his ear with his left hand. The camera remains static, capturing the cyclist as he approaches from the background and moves into a close-up framing. In the background, a person in white clothing stands near a wall, holding a broom and remaining stationary throughout the entire five-second duration.

Explanation: The video demonstrates strong adherence to the prompt and maintains high fidelity to the conditioning frame. While there are minor issues with the fluidity of the pedaling motion and slight temporal instability in the background, the overall visual quality and composition are highly effective. | overall_score=82 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":90,"motion_quality":85,"temporal_consistency":80,"visual_quality":85,"camera_composition":80}

Explanation: The video effectively captures the requested motion of the cyclist approaching the camera while maintaining high fidelity to the initial frame. Minor temporal artifacts in the background character's movement and slight unnaturalness in the pedaling motion prevent a perfect score. | overall_score=82 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":85,"motion_quality":80,"temporal_consistency":85,"visual_quality":85,"camera_composition":80}

Explanation: The video demonstrates high fidelity to the conditioning frame and effectively captures the requested motion of the cyclist approaching the camera. While there is minor temporal instability in the background figure, the overall visual quality and adherence to the prompt are strong. | overall_score=82 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":90,"motion_quality":85,"temporal_consistency":80,"visual_quality":85,"camera_composition":80}


Prompt: The camera performs a smooth, continuous drone pull-back, moving steadily away from the subject while simultaneously tilting upward to reveal more of the vast desert landscape. The person remains stationary, standing still on the narrow ridge of the sand dune throughout the entire duration. The framing shifts from a medium shot of the individual to a wide, expansive aerial view of the surrounding dunes and the distant town, maintaining a consistent, slow-paced backward motion until the end.

Explanation: The video successfully executes the requested drone pull-back and upward tilt while maintaining the subject's position on the ridge. The visual quality is high, and the transition from a medium shot to an expansive aerial view is fluid and natural. | overall_score=92 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":98,"prompt_adherence":95,"motion_quality":90,"temporal_consistency":95,"visual_quality":92,"camera_composition":90}

Explanation: The video successfully executes the requested drone pull-back and tilt motion while maintaining the subject's position on the dune. The visual quality is high, and the transition from the medium shot to the wide aerial view is fluid and natural. | overall_score=92 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":98,"prompt_adherence":95,"motion_quality":90,"temporal_consistency":95,"visual_quality":92,"camera_composition":90}

Explanation: The video successfully executes the requested drone pull-back with high fidelity to the first frame. The subject remains stationary as requested, and the overall motion is smooth, though the upward tilt could be more dynamic to fully capture the expansive landscape. | overall_score=92 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":98,"prompt_adherence":95,"motion_quality":90,"temporal_consistency":95,"visual_quality":92,"camera_composition":85}


Prompt: A dragonfly flies steadily from the right side of the frame toward the center, hovering briefly over the water before continuing its flight path toward the left. The camera remains completely static, maintaining a fixed, wide-angle perspective of the calm lake and surrounding reeds. The scene captures a peaceful, natural wetland environment where the only movement is the small insect navigating across the still, reflective surface of the water under a bright, cloudy sky.

Explanation: The video successfully maintains the static camera and background environment of the conditioning frame. While the dragonfly's movement is slightly artificial and lacks perfect fluidity, it adheres well to the prompt's requirements for flight path and behavior. | overall_score=85 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":98,"prompt_adherence":90,"motion_quality":80,"temporal_consistency":85,"visual_quality":90,"camera_composition":95}

Explanation: The video adheres well to the prompt, maintaining a static camera and a consistent environment. While the dragonfly's entry is slightly abrupt, the overall motion and visual quality are high. | overall_score=85 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":98,"prompt_adherence":90,"motion_quality":80,"temporal_consistency":85,"visual_quality":90,"camera_composition":95}

Explanation: The video successfully adheres to the prompt's requirements for a static camera and a dragonfly flying across the scene. While the entry of the dragonfly is slightly abrupt, the overall visual quality and fidelity to the conditioning frame are very high. | overall_score=85 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":90,"motion_quality":80,"temporal_consistency":85,"visual_quality":90,"camera_composition":95}


Prompt: The water surface ripples continuously with small, rhythmic waves moving steadily toward the left shoreline. The dense forest on the hillside remains completely still, showing no movement from wind or other external forces. The camera is locked in a static, wide-angle shot, maintaining a fixed framing of the lake and the forested mountain range in the background. This is a tranquil, stationary landscape scene where only the water exhibits subtle, consistent motion across the entire duration of the clip.

Explanation: The video successfully maintains the static composition of the conditioning frame while introducing the requested subtle, rhythmic water motion. The forest remains appropriately still, and the overall temporal consistency is high. | overall_score=92 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":100,"prompt_adherence":95,"motion_quality":90,"temporal_consistency":95,"visual_quality":90,"camera_composition":100}

Explanation: The video is highly faithful to the conditioning frame and maintains perfect temporal stability. However, the motion of the water is too subtle to fully satisfy the prompt's requirement for rhythmic, steady waves. | overall_score=85 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":98,"prompt_adherence":90,"motion_quality":80,"temporal_consistency":95,"visual_quality":90,"camera_composition":95}

Explanation: The video successfully maintains the static nature of the landscape while introducing subtle, consistent motion to the water. It adheres well to the prompt, although the wave motion is quite minimal. | overall_score=88 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":100,"prompt_adherence":95,"motion_quality":85,"temporal_consistency":90,"visual_quality":90,"camera_composition":95}


Prompt: A fisherman stands in shallow water holding a large bamboo fishing net structure. He pulls the bamboo pole downward, causing the submerged net to rise slowly toward the surface of the water. The camera remains static throughout the shot, maintaining a wide framing of the fisherman and the surrounding river landscape. The water surface ripples gently as the net emerges, while the fisherman maintains his grip on the bamboo frame to control the upward motion of the net.

Explanation: While the video perfectly maintains the first frame and camera composition, it fails entirely to execute the requested motion of the fishing net, resulting in a static image rather than a video. | overall_score=25 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":20,"motion_quality":10,"temporal_consistency":10,"visual_quality":30,"camera_composition":80}

Explanation: While the video maintains the visual style and composition of the first frame perfectly, it fails to execute the primary motion requested in the prompt. The video is effectively a static image with minor, low-quality artifacts, lacking the dynamic movement of the fisherman and the fishing net. | overall_score=35 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":30,"motion_quality":20,"temporal_consistency":20,"visual_quality":40,"camera_composition":80}

Explanation: While the video maintains the visual style and composition of the first frame perfectly, it fails to execute the primary motion requested in the prompt. The video is effectively a static image with minor, low-quality artifacts, lacking the dynamic action of the fisherman and the net. | overall_score=35 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":30,"motion_quality":20,"temporal_consistency":20,"visual_quality":40,"camera_composition":80}


Prompt: The camera moves forward at a steady pace along a multi-lane highway at night, maintaining a consistent following distance behind a silver sports car. The sports car accelerates slightly, pulling away from the camera while weaving subtly between lanes. Other vehicles in the surrounding lanes maintain a steady flow, their headlights and taillights creating streaks of light. The camera remains fixed in a stable, forward-facing position, capturing the continuous motion of traffic moving toward the distant, illuminated overpass.

Explanation: The video maintains high fidelity to the first frame and captures the requested night highway scene effectively. While the motion is generally good, the sports car's weaving is quite subtle, and there is minor temporal jitter in the background lights. | overall_score=88 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":98,"prompt_adherence":90,"motion_quality":85,"temporal_consistency":85,"visual_quality":90,"camera_composition":85}

Explanation: While the video starts with high fidelity to the conditioning frame, it fails almost entirely to execute the requested motion prompt. The scene remains largely static with only minor, distracting flickering artifacts instead of the fluid, forward-moving traffic sequence described. | overall_score=35 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":40,"motion_quality":20,"temporal_consistency":30,"visual_quality":40,"camera_composition":50}

Explanation: While the model successfully maintains the visual style and content of the first frame, it fails almost entirely to execute the requested motion. The video lacks the dynamic camera movement and vehicle behavior described in the prompt, resulting in a static, jittery sequence that does not fulfill the core requirements of the generation. | overall_score=35 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":40,"motion_quality":20,"temporal_consistency":30,"visual_quality":40,"camera_composition":50}


Prompt: A cluster of yellow caterpillars with black spots clings to a thin, vertical thread. Throughout the clip, the caterpillars exhibit constant, subtle writhing and shifting motions, with individual bodies undulating and crawling over one another while the entire mass remains suspended in place. The camera is static and maintains a tight, macro-level framing on the central group of insects against a soft, out-of-focus green background. The motion is characterized by continuous, small-scale, rhythmic twitching and crawling.

Explanation: The video demonstrates high fidelity to the first frame and successfully captures the complex, subtle, and rhythmic motion of the caterpillars as requested. While there is a slight sense of a repeating motion loop and minor jitter in the lower cluster, the overall visual quality and adherence to the prompt are very strong. | overall_score=92 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":98,"prompt_adherence":95,"motion_quality":90,"temporal_consistency":92,"visual_quality":95,"camera_composition":90}

Explanation: The video demonstrates high-quality generation with excellent fidelity to the conditioning frame and effective capture of the requested subtle, writhing motion. The temporal consistency is strong, and the overall visual quality is high, though the motion pattern becomes slightly repetitive over the duration of the clip. | overall_score=92 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":98,"prompt_adherence":95,"motion_quality":90,"temporal_consistency":92,"visual_quality":95,"camera_composition":95}

Explanation: The video demonstrates high-quality generation with excellent adherence to the conditioning frame and the prompt's requirements for motion. The movement is fluid and consistent, though it exhibits a slight repetitive quality typical of short-duration video generation. | overall_score=92 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":98,"prompt_adherence":95,"motion_quality":90,"temporal_consistency":92,"visual_quality":95,"camera_composition":95}


Prompt: A long freight train moves steadily from left to right across a massive steel vertical-lift bridge spanning a calm river. The train cars pass continuously over the tracks, maintaining a constant speed throughout the entire duration. The camera remains completely static, providing a wide, elevated side view of the bridge structure and the passing rail traffic. The scene captures the rhythmic, mechanical motion of the train against the backdrop of a lush, tree-lined riverbank under a partly cloudy sky.

Explanation: The video maintains high fidelity to the conditioning frame and successfully executes the requested motion of the train. While there is some minor temporal jitter in the train's movement, the overall visual quality and adherence to the prompt are very high. | overall_score=88 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":98,"prompt_adherence":95,"motion_quality":85,"temporal_consistency":80,"visual_quality":90,"camera_composition":95}

Explanation: The video maintains high fidelity to the conditioning frame and successfully executes the requested camera motion and subject movement. While there is some minor temporal jitter in the train's motion, the overall visual quality and adherence to the prompt are very strong. | overall_score=85 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":90,"motion_quality":85,"temporal_consistency":80,"visual_quality":90,"camera_composition":95}

Explanation: The video maintains high fidelity to the first frame and effectively captures the requested scene. While there is some minor temporal jitter in the train's motion, the overall visual quality and adherence to the prompt are very high. | overall_score=88 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":98,"prompt_adherence":95,"motion_quality":85,"temporal_consistency":80,"visual_quality":90,"camera_composition":95}


Prompt: A group of friends gathers in a bright living room to celebrate. The central man in a grey shirt breaks his embrace with a man in a white sweater, then turns to shake hands with a man in a red shirt. Simultaneously, the man in the white sweater turns to embrace a woman with dreadlocks. The camera remains static throughout the scene, maintaining a medium shot that captures the social interaction of the four individuals as they exchange greetings and gestures.

Explanation: The video successfully executes the complex multi-character interaction requested in the prompt while maintaining the static camera composition. However, there is noticeable identity drift in the central character, and the motion of the handshake is somewhat unnatural and jittery. | overall_score=82 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":85,"motion_quality":80,"temporal_consistency":75,"visual_quality":85,"camera_composition":90}

Explanation: The video maintains excellent visual quality and fidelity to the first frame, but fails to accurately execute the specific complex social interactions described in the prompt, particularly regarding the character movements and identities. | overall_score=68 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":60,"motion_quality":65,"temporal_consistency":70,"visual_quality":80,"camera_composition":90}

Explanation: The video maintains excellent fidelity to the first frame and keeps the camera static as requested. However, it fails to accurately execute the specific social interactions described in the prompt, and there is noticeable identity drift in the central character during the movement. | overall_score=65 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":60,"motion_quality":65,"temporal_consistency":60,"visual_quality":70,"camera_composition":80}


Prompt: A small wooden boat with a lone rower moves steadily from left to right across the frame, cutting through the calm water. The rower rhythmically paddles, propelling the vessel forward toward the right edge of the scene until it exits the frame. The camera remains static throughout the shot, maintaining a wide, level perspective of the river. A person sits in a traditional boat on a wide, rippling river under a cloudy, sunset-lit sky.

Explanation: The video successfully maintains the integrity of the first frame and follows the prompt's instructions well. While the rower's motion is slightly mechanical, the overall visual quality and temporal stability are high. | overall_score=85 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":90,"motion_quality":80,"temporal_consistency":85,"visual_quality":90,"camera_composition":90}

Explanation: The video maintains high fidelity to the conditioning frame and successfully executes the requested motion of the boat moving across the river. While the rower's motion is slightly mechanical, the overall visual quality and temporal stability are very high. | overall_score=85 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":90,"motion_quality":80,"temporal_consistency":85,"visual_quality":90,"camera_composition":90}

Explanation: The video successfully maintains the integrity of the first frame while executing the requested motion. The motion of the boat is generally consistent, though the rower's animation could be more refined for higher realism. | overall_score=85 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":98,"prompt_adherence":90,"motion_quality":80,"temporal_consistency":85,"visual_quality":90,"camera_composition":95}


Prompt: A woman jogs steadily from left to right across the frame, maintaining a consistent pace with rhythmic arm swings and a focused forward gaze. The camera tracks her movement with a smooth, continuous pan to the right, keeping her centered in the frame until she exits the view. Once she passes, the camera continues its rightward pan, transitioning to focus on the surrounding park trees and foliage, which remain still against the background.

Explanation: The video adheres well to the prompt's complex camera instructions and maintains high visual quality. However, the subject's arm suffers from noticeable morphing artifacts during the jogging motion, which slightly detracts from the overall motion quality. | overall_score=82 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":85,"motion_quality":80,"temporal_consistency":85,"visual_quality":85,"camera_composition":80}

Explanation: The video successfully executes the complex prompt, maintaining the subject's identity and the requested camera movement. While there are minor artifacts in the subject's arm movement and slight background jitter, the overall quality is high and adheres well to the conditioning frame. | overall_score=85 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":90,"motion_quality":85,"temporal_consistency":80,"visual_quality":85,"camera_composition":80}

Explanation: The video successfully follows the prompt, maintaining the subject's identity and the requested camera movement. While there is a slight degradation in the subject's arm geometry as she leaves the frame and minor background jitter, the overall quality is high and adheres well to the conditioning. | overall_score=85 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":90,"motion_quality":85,"temporal_consistency":80,"visual_quality":85,"camera_composition":80}


Prompt: A group of five friends stands on a cliff edge overlooking the ocean. The person on the far left slowly raises their right arm, extending it upward and outward toward the horizon, while the others remain still, observing the water. The camera is static, maintaining a wide, fixed framing of the group from behind as they look out over the sea. The scene captures a quiet, contemplative moment of a group of hikers pausing at a coastal viewpoint.

Explanation: The video successfully maintains the composition and identity of the first frame while executing the requested action. The motion is generally consistent, though the arm movement could be more natural, and the overall visual quality is high. | overall_score=82 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":90,"motion_quality":75,"temporal_consistency":85,"visual_quality":85,"camera_composition":90}

Explanation: The video successfully follows the prompt's instructions, with the person on the left raising their arm while the others remain still. The motion is generally stable, though the arm movement could be more fluid, and the overall visual quality is high. | overall_score=82 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":90,"motion_quality":75,"temporal_consistency":85,"visual_quality":85,"camera_composition":90}

Explanation: The video successfully maintains the requested composition and camera angle, and the first frame is highly faithful to the conditioning image. However, the motion of the arm is jittery, and the person in the center suffers from noticeable temporal instability and flickering, which detracts from the overall quality. | overall_score=72 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":85,"motion_quality":65,"temporal_consistency":60,"visual_quality":75,"camera_composition":90}


Prompt: The camera performs a smooth, continuous dolly-in movement, steadily closing the distance toward the stationary black sedan. As the camera advances, the perspective shifts slightly to reveal more of the car's side profile while the background trees and house remain fixed in place. The framing transitions from a wider view to a tighter shot of the vehicle, maintaining a consistent, level height throughout the entire five-second duration as the car sits parked on a stone driveway.

Explanation: The video successfully executes the requested dolly-in movement while maintaining high visual fidelity to the conditioning frame. There are minor artifacts related to geometric stability during the zoom, but the overall quality is high and adheres well to the prompt. | overall_score=85 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":90,"motion_quality":85,"temporal_consistency":80,"visual_quality":85,"camera_composition":80}

Explanation: The video successfully executes the requested dolly-in movement while maintaining high visual fidelity to the conditioning frame. There is some minor geometric instability in the car's reflection and slight background jitter, but the overall motion and composition are very strong. | overall_score=85 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":90,"motion_quality":85,"temporal_consistency":80,"visual_quality":85,"camera_composition":80}

Explanation: The video successfully executes the requested dolly-in movement while maintaining high visual fidelity to the conditioning frame. There are minor temporal inconsistencies in the background and slight geometric warping of the car, but the overall quality is high. | overall_score=85 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":90,"motion_quality":85,"temporal_consistency":80,"visual_quality":85,"camera_composition":80}


Prompt: A white car travels steadily along the road from the bottom left toward the top right of the frame, passing the corner of the building. Simultaneously, a second white car moves along the parallel road on the right side, heading toward the top of the frame. The camera remains in a fixed, high-angle aerial position, providing a static top-down view of the parking lot and surrounding roads at dusk.

Explanation: While the model successfully maintains the visual fidelity of the first frame and the camera composition, it fails entirely to execute the requested motion. The cars are static, resulting in a failure to adhere to the core prompt instructions. | overall_score=25 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":20,"motion_quality":10,"temporal_consistency":20,"visual_quality":40,"camera_composition":90}

Explanation: While the video maintains the visual style and composition of the first frame perfectly, it fails completely to animate the scene according to the prompt. The cars remain stationary, resulting in a lack of motion quality and poor prompt adherence. | overall_score=25 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":20,"motion_quality":10,"temporal_consistency":20,"visual_quality":40,"camera_composition":90}

Explanation: While the model successfully maintains the visual fidelity of the first frame, it completely fails to animate the scene according to the prompt, resulting in a static image sequence rather than a video. | overall_score=25 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":20,"motion_quality":10,"temporal_consistency":20,"visual_quality":30,"camera_composition":50}


Prompt: The camera performs a slow, steady forward dolly movement, gliding over the marshland while maintaining a high-angle perspective. As the camera advances, the perspective shifts slightly to reveal more of the water channels and the surrounding dead trees. The scene remains tranquil with no visible movement from the vegetation or the water itself. This aerial shot captures a vast, desolate swamp filled with leafless trees and patches of dry, golden grass scattered throughout the dark, reflective water.

Explanation: The video is visually stunning and perfectly matches the first frame, but the requested camera movement is too subtle to be clearly perceived as a 'slow, steady forward dolly', resulting in a slightly lower score for motion and composition. | overall_score=92 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":98,"prompt_adherence":95,"motion_quality":90,"temporal_consistency":95,"visual_quality":95,"camera_composition":85}

Explanation: The video is visually stunning and perfectly matches the first frame, but the requested camera movement is too subtle to be clearly perceived as a deliberate dolly shot, resulting in a slightly static feel. | overall_score=92 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":98,"prompt_adherence":95,"motion_quality":90,"temporal_consistency":95,"visual_quality":92,"camera_composition":85}

Explanation: The video demonstrates high fidelity to the conditioning frame and effectively executes the requested slow, steady forward dolly movement. The visual quality is high, and the scene remains tranquil as requested, with only minor, negligible jitter in the background. | overall_score=92 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":98,"prompt_adherence":95,"motion_quality":90,"temporal_consistency":95,"visual_quality":92,"camera_composition":90}


Prompt: A water buffalo stands in a shallow, muddy wetland and begins to walk forward toward the camera, lifting its legs through the water and creating small splashes with each step. The camera remains static throughout the entire duration, maintaining a wide, eye-level framing of the scene. In the background, other water buffalo graze slowly in the distance across a grassy field under a bright, partly cloudy sky.

Explanation: While the video starts with high fidelity to the conditioning frame and maintains the requested camera angle, the motion quality is very poor. The buffalo exhibits severe anatomical morphing and unnatural sliding motion, and the temporal consistency is compromised by significant flickering throughout the scene. | overall_score=35 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":90,"prompt_adherence":40,"motion_quality":20,"temporal_consistency":20,"visual_quality":30,"camera_composition":80}

Explanation: While the video starts with high fidelity to the conditioning frame and maintains the requested static camera, the motion of the water buffalo is highly unrealistic, characterized by severe morphing and a lack of coherent walking mechanics. The temporal consistency is poor, as the animal's anatomy distorts significantly throughout the sequence. | overall_score=35 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":40,"motion_quality":20,"temporal_consistency":20,"visual_quality":40,"camera_composition":60}

Explanation: While the video starts with high fidelity to the conditioning frame, the motion generation is poor. The water buffalo's legs morph and distort in a non-biological way, and the expected walking motion and water splashes are not realistically rendered, resulting in a highly unstable and unnatural animation. | overall_score=35 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":40,"motion_quality":20,"temporal_consistency":20,"visual_quality":40,"camera_composition":60}


Prompt: The camera performs a slow, steady forward dolly movement over a vast, lush green rice field. Gentle, rhythmic waves of motion ripple across the grass blades, moving from the foreground toward the background as if pushed by a soft breeze. The framing remains wide and consistent, maintaining a low-angle perspective that emphasizes the expansive landscape and the distant, cloud-covered mountain range under an overcast sky.

Explanation: The video maintains high visual fidelity to the conditioning frame and adheres well to the scene description. However, the requested camera movement and the specific motion of the grass are quite muted, resulting in a less dynamic output than the prompt implies. | overall_score=85 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":100,"prompt_adherence":90,"motion_quality":80,"temporal_consistency":85,"visual_quality":90,"camera_composition":80}

Explanation: The video maintains high visual fidelity to the conditioning frame and adheres well to the environmental description. However, the requested camera movement is very minimal, and the motion of the grass is less dynamic than the prompt implies. | overall_score=85 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":90,"motion_quality":80,"temporal_consistency":85,"visual_quality":90,"camera_composition":80}

Explanation: The video is visually high-quality and perfectly matches the conditioning frame, but it fails to fully realize the dynamic motion requested in the prompt. The camera movement is almost imperceptible, and the grass motion is too static to convey the 'soft breeze' effect described. | overall_score=82 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":98,"prompt_adherence":85,"motion_quality":75,"temporal_consistency":80,"visual_quality":85,"camera_composition":70}


Prompt: The person picks up a light green pepper from the wooden kitchen counter with their right hand, lifting it into the air before catching it again. Simultaneously, their left hand reaches down to grasp an orange pepper, lifting it slightly off the surface. The camera remains static throughout the shot, maintaining a medium close-up framing of the person and the assortment of fresh vegetables on the table. The subject is a person in a white t-shirt preparing produce in a kitchen.

Explanation: While the video maintains the initial scene composition and subject appearance perfectly, it fails significantly on the core action requirements. The hands do not interact with the vegetables in a physically plausible way, resulting in morphing artifacts rather than the requested picking up and catching motions. | overall_score=45 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":40,"motion_quality":30,"temporal_consistency":40,"visual_quality":60,"camera_composition":80}

Explanation: While the video maintains the visual style and composition of the first frame, it fails significantly on the core action prompt. The hands do not realistically interact with the vegetables, and the requested motion of lifting and catching the peppers is entirely absent. | overall_score=45 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":40,"motion_quality":30,"temporal_consistency":40,"visual_quality":60,"camera_composition":80}

Explanation: While the video maintains the visual style and composition of the first frame perfectly, it fails significantly on the core action requirements of the prompt. The hands do not actually interact with the peppers, resulting in a lack of realistic motion and a failure to execute the requested tasks. | overall_score=42 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":30,"motion_quality":35,"temporal_consistency":40,"visual_quality":60,"camera_composition":90}