Prompt: The person firmly grips their lower calf and ankle with both hands, applying steady pressure as they perform a static stretch. The hands remain locked in place, rhythmically squeezing and releasing the muscle while the leg stays held in a fixed, extended position. The camera is static and maintains a tight, close-up framing on the lower leg and hands, capturing the subtle, repetitive tension of the massage against the backdrop of an outdoor path.

Explanation: The video is highly consistent with the conditioning frame and effectively captures the requested action of a static stretch with a massage motion. The motion is natural, though the intensity of the squeezing could be slightly more dynamic to perfectly align with the prompt's description. | overall_score=88 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":98,"prompt_adherence":95,"motion_quality":85,"temporal_consistency":90,"visual_quality":92,"camera_composition":95}

Explanation: The video maintains high visual fidelity and adheres well to the prompt's framing and subject matter. While the motion is technically present, it is a bit understated and could better reflect the specific 'rhythmic squeezing' requested. | overall_score=85 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":100,"prompt_adherence":90,"motion_quality":80,"temporal_consistency":85,"visual_quality":90,"camera_composition":95}

Explanation: The video maintains high fidelity to the first frame and effectively captures the requested action. The motion is consistent and stable, though the hand movements could be more fluid to better simulate a realistic massage. | overall_score=88 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":98,"prompt_adherence":90,"motion_quality":85,"temporal_consistency":92,"visual_quality":90,"camera_composition":95}


Prompt: A group of people plays a soccer match on an artificial turf field. Players run across the pitch in various directions, passing and chasing the ball while others stand in position. The camera performs a slow, steady, and continuous drone-style forward dolly movement, gradually descending and gliding over the field toward the center of the action. The scene captures an active outdoor sports complex featuring multiple fenced-in soccer pitches and a nearby swimming pool area.

Explanation: The video maintains high fidelity to the conditioning frame and successfully executes the requested drone-style camera movement. While there is some minor temporal instability in the background, the overall quality and adherence to the prompt are very high. | overall_score=88 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":98,"prompt_adherence":95,"motion_quality":85,"temporal_consistency":85,"visual_quality":90,"camera_composition":80}

Explanation: The video maintains high fidelity to the conditioning frame and successfully executes the requested drone-style camera movement. While there is some minor temporal instability in the background and the camera motion could be smoother, it is a high-quality generation that adheres well to the prompt. | overall_score=85 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":98,"prompt_adherence":90,"motion_quality":85,"temporal_consistency":80,"visual_quality":85,"camera_composition":80}

Explanation: The video maintains high fidelity to the conditioning frame and effectively captures the requested scene and camera movement. While there are minor issues with motion smoothness and slight temporal jitter, the overall quality is high and adheres well to the prompt. | overall_score=85 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":98,"prompt_adherence":90,"motion_quality":80,"temporal_consistency":85,"visual_quality":85,"camera_composition":75}


Prompt: The camera performs a smooth, continuous upward tilt, starting from the lower base of the structure and rising to reveal the upper tiers of the ancient stone amphitheater. The framing remains centered on the massive, weathered exterior wall, maintaining a steady vertical trajectory throughout the five-second duration. The Colosseum stands as the sole subject, its iconic arched facade filling the frame as the perspective shifts from a low-angle view toward a more direct look at the upper levels.

Explanation: The generated video fails almost entirely to execute the requested camera motion, remaining static throughout the duration. While the visual quality and fidelity to the first frame are acceptable, the lack of adherence to the motion prompt makes it a failed generation. | overall_score=15 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":10,"motion_quality":5,"temporal_consistency":10,"visual_quality":20,"camera_composition":10}

Explanation: The generated video fails to execute the requested camera movement entirely, remaining static throughout the duration. While the first frame is accurate, the lack of motion makes it a complete failure regarding the prompt's primary instruction. | overall_score=15 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":10,"motion_quality":5,"temporal_consistency":10,"visual_quality":20,"camera_composition":10}

Explanation: The generated video fails almost entirely to adhere to the motion prompt, as it is a static image with no camera movement, despite the prompt explicitly requesting a smooth, continuous upward tilt. | overall_score=15 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":10,"motion_quality":5,"temporal_consistency":10,"visual_quality":20,"camera_composition":10}


Prompt: A person wearing a straw hat and purple shirt kneels beside a lotus pond, holding a camera to photograph the flowers. Throughout the five-second clip, the person remains largely still, while the large green lotus leaves and flower buds sway gently in the breeze. The camera is static, maintaining a fixed, medium-long shot that frames the subject from behind as they focus on the plants in the foreground. The scene is peaceful, with subtle, natural movement confined to the foliage.

Explanation: The video maintains high visual quality and perfect fidelity to the first frame, but the motion is extremely subtle and barely perceptible, failing to fully capture the 'swaying' requested in the prompt. | overall_score=85 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":98,"prompt_adherence":95,"motion_quality":70,"temporal_consistency":90,"visual_quality":90,"camera_composition":95}

Explanation: The video maintains high fidelity to the conditioning frame and adheres well to the prompt's composition requirements. However, the motion is extremely subtle, bordering on static, which fails to fully capture the 'swaying gently in the breeze' aspect of the prompt. | overall_score=85 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":98,"prompt_adherence":95,"motion_quality":75,"temporal_consistency":90,"visual_quality":90,"camera_composition":95}

Explanation: The video is visually high-quality and perfectly adheres to the first frame and composition requirements. However, the motion is barely perceptible, failing to capture the requested 'swaying' of the foliage in a dynamic way. | overall_score=85 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":100,"prompt_adherence":95,"motion_quality":70,"temporal_consistency":90,"visual_quality":90,"camera_composition":95}


Prompt: Water cascades continuously down the mossy rock face, creating a steady, rhythmic flow that pools among the dark boulders at the base. The stream continues to move forward through the center of the frame, while the surrounding forest foliage remains still. The camera is completely static throughout the entire duration, maintaining a fixed, wide-angle perspective of the waterfall and the adjacent wooden staircase leading up into the dense, shaded woods.

Explanation: The video maintains a very high level of fidelity to the first frame and successfully adheres to the static camera constraint. The motion of the waterfall is generally convincing, though it exhibits slight repetitive patterns, and the overall visual quality is high. | overall_score=85 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":90,"motion_quality":80,"temporal_consistency":85,"visual_quality":90,"camera_composition":95}

Explanation: The video maintains high fidelity to the first frame and adheres well to the prompt's requirements for a static camera and specific environmental elements. The motion of the waterfall is generally convincing, though it exhibits slight repetitive patterns and minor temporal artifacts in the surrounding foliage. | overall_score=88 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":98,"prompt_adherence":95,"motion_quality":85,"temporal_consistency":90,"visual_quality":92,"camera_composition":95}

Explanation: The video adheres very well to the prompt, maintaining a static camera and successfully animating the waterfall while keeping the surrounding forest still. The motion is generally convincing, though it lacks the perfect fluid dynamics of real water, and the overall visual quality is high. | overall_score=88 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":98,"prompt_adherence":95,"motion_quality":85,"temporal_consistency":90,"visual_quality":92,"camera_composition":95}


Prompt: A scuba diver swims steadily toward the camera, kicking their yellow fins in a rhythmic motion while maintaining a horizontal posture. As the diver approaches, they gradually tilt their body and rotate to the right, eventually passing out of the frame toward the upper right corner. The camera remains static, capturing the diver against a bright, sunlit blue water background as a steady stream of air bubbles rises from the diver toward the surface.

Explanation: The video maintains high visual fidelity to the conditioning frame and captures the requested scene well, though the motion of the diver could be more fluid and natural to fully match the prompt's description of swimming. | overall_score=85 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":85,"motion_quality":80,"temporal_consistency":85,"visual_quality":90,"camera_composition":80}

Explanation: The video maintains high visual fidelity and follows the prompt's narrative arc well, though the motion of the diver feels slightly artificial and lacks the fluidity expected of a swimming motion. | overall_score=85 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":85,"motion_quality":80,"temporal_consistency":85,"visual_quality":90,"camera_composition":80}

Explanation: While the video maintains high visual quality and fidelity to the first frame, it fails significantly on prompt adherence regarding the diver's movement and the camera's behavior. The motion is repetitive and does not follow the specific trajectory requested. | overall_score=45 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":40,"motion_quality":30,"temporal_consistency":40,"visual_quality":60,"camera_composition":50}


Prompt: A man holding a toddler stands on a spiral staircase next to a large window. The man extends his arm to point toward the greenery outside, holding the gesture for several seconds. He then slowly lowers his arm back to his side while continuing to hold the child. The camera remains static throughout the entire sequence, maintaining a high-angle, fixed framing of the pair as they look out the window together.

Explanation: The video successfully executes the requested actions while maintaining the high-angle, static camera composition. The primary issues are minor artifacts in the hand's movement and slight temporal instability during the arm-lowering phase, but the overall quality is high. | overall_score=85 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":90,"motion_quality":80,"temporal_consistency":85,"visual_quality":90,"camera_composition":95}

Explanation: The video successfully executes the requested motion sequence while maintaining high visual fidelity and camera stability. The primary drawback is minor geometric instability in the hand during the arm-lowering motion. | overall_score=85 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":90,"motion_quality":80,"temporal_consistency":85,"visual_quality":90,"camera_composition":95}

Explanation: The video successfully follows the prompt's sequence of actions while maintaining high visual quality and camera stability. The primary drawback is some minor geometric instability in the hand during the motion phase. | overall_score=85 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":90,"motion_quality":80,"temporal_consistency":85,"visual_quality":90,"camera_composition":95}


Prompt: The camera performs a slow, steady drone-style forward dolly movement toward the river pier. Below, the water remains calm with minimal surface ripples. On the wooden pier, a dense crowd of people moves fluidly, walking in various directions as they board and disembark from the cluster of small wooden boats moored alongside. The larger cargo vessels in the background remain stationary throughout the shot, while the overall scene depicts a busy river transport hub during daylight hours.

Explanation: While the video maintains high visual fidelity to the first frame, it fails significantly on the motion requirements specified in the prompt. The crowd and water are essentially static, and the requested camera movement is barely perceptible, resulting in a very low-motion, unengaging video. | overall_score=35 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":20,"motion_quality":20,"temporal_consistency":30,"visual_quality":40,"camera_composition":30}

Explanation: While the video maintains high visual fidelity to the first frame, it fails significantly on the motion requirements of the prompt. The requested 'busy' activity of people and the 'drone-style' camera movement are barely present, resulting in a nearly static video. | overall_score=35 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":20,"motion_quality":20,"temporal_consistency":30,"visual_quality":40,"camera_composition":30}

Explanation: While the video maintains high visual fidelity to the first frame, it fails significantly on the motion requirements specified in the prompt. The crowd remains static, the water is frozen, and the requested camera movement is barely perceptible, resulting in a very low-energy, static output. | overall_score=35 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":20,"motion_quality":20,"temporal_consistency":30,"visual_quality":40,"camera_composition":30}


Prompt: A group of snowy egrets stands in a marsh, with one egret in the middle flapping its wings repeatedly to display them. Another egret enters from the top right, flying slowly across the frame toward the left before exiting the view. The camera remains static throughout the entire shot, maintaining a wide, fixed framing of the birds in the tall grass. The rest of the flock remains mostly stationary while the two active birds move.

Explanation: The video successfully captures the requested scene with high fidelity to the first frame and good adherence to the prompt's specific motion requirements. While there are minor artifacts in the flying bird's wing geometry, the overall temporal consistency and visual quality are high. | overall_score=85 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":90,"motion_quality":85,"temporal_consistency":80,"visual_quality":85,"camera_composition":95}

Explanation: The video successfully captures the complex scene described in the prompt with high fidelity to the first frame. While there are minor artifacts in the flying bird's wing geometry, the overall motion and composition are very strong. | overall_score=85 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":90,"motion_quality":85,"temporal_consistency":80,"visual_quality":85,"camera_composition":95}

Explanation: The video successfully captures the requested scene with high fidelity to the first frame and accurate camera positioning. While there is minor geometric distortion in the flying bird, the overall motion and temporal consistency are high quality. | overall_score=85 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":90,"motion_quality":85,"temporal_consistency":80,"visual_quality":85,"camera_composition":95}


Prompt: The camera performs a slow, steady forward dolly movement toward the rugged coastal cliffs. Throughout the five-second duration, white ocean waves continuously crash against the base of the dark, layered rock formations, creating a persistent spray and foam that flows outward into the deeper blue water. The scene remains focused on the dramatic interface between the jagged, stationary cliffside and the rhythmic, incoming tide, maintaining a consistent high-angle perspective of the rocky shoreline under a clear, bright sky.

Explanation: The video maintains high fidelity to the first frame and successfully executes the requested slow dolly movement. While there is some minor temporal instability in the wave animation, the overall visual quality and adherence to the prompt are very strong. | overall_score=88 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":98,"prompt_adherence":95,"motion_quality":85,"temporal_consistency":85,"visual_quality":90,"camera_composition":85}

Explanation: The video maintains high fidelity to the conditioning frame and successfully executes the requested camera movement. While there is some minor temporal instability in the water simulation, the overall quality is high and adheres well to the prompt. | overall_score=88 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":98,"prompt_adherence":95,"motion_quality":85,"temporal_consistency":85,"visual_quality":90,"camera_composition":85}

Explanation: The video maintains high fidelity to the first frame and effectively captures the requested scene. The primary drawback is a slight lack of smoothness in the camera movement and minor temporal artifacts in the water simulation. | overall_score=88 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":98,"prompt_adherence":95,"motion_quality":85,"temporal_consistency":85,"visual_quality":90,"camera_composition":80}


Prompt: The four rowers in a long, narrow shell rhythmically pull their oars through the water, creating a steady wake as they glide from left to right across the frame. The camera remains static, maintaining a wide, high-angle shot of the river. The rowing motion is continuous and synchronized, with the oars entering and exiting the water in a repeating cycle. The boat maintains a consistent speed and trajectory across the calm, open water, moving steadily toward the right edge of the frame.

Explanation: The video maintains high fidelity to the conditioning frame and effectively captures the requested rowing motion, though there are minor temporal artifacts in the oar movement and water wake. | overall_score=85 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":98,"prompt_adherence":95,"motion_quality":80,"temporal_consistency":85,"visual_quality":90,"camera_composition":95}

Explanation: While the video successfully maintains the static camera and initial composition, the motion of the rowers and oars is highly unstable, suffering from significant flickering and geometric distortion throughout the sequence. | overall_score=45 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":60,"motion_quality":30,"temporal_consistency":20,"visual_quality":50,"camera_composition":90}

Explanation: The video successfully maintains the scene from the first frame and follows the prompt's instructions well. However, the oars suffer from noticeable geometric artifacts and morphing during the rowing motion, which slightly detracts from the overall realism. | overall_score=85 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":98,"prompt_adherence":90,"motion_quality":80,"temporal_consistency":85,"visual_quality":90,"camera_composition":95}


Prompt: The camera performs a slow, steady forward dolly movement over a quiet urban intersection at night. A single vehicle travels away from the camera along the central road, while the surrounding city lights remain constant. The perspective maintains a high-angle, fixed-orientation view of the street grid and the illuminated building in the distance. This aerial shot captures the rhythmic, minimal flow of traffic through a sprawling, brightly lit cityscape under a dark, expansive night sky.

Explanation: The video successfully maintains the scene from the first frame and adheres well to the prompt's requirements for a night cityscape and camera movement. The primary drawbacks are minor jitters in the camera motion and slightly unnatural vehicle movement, but the overall visual quality remains high. | overall_score=85 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":90,"motion_quality":80,"temporal_consistency":85,"visual_quality":85,"camera_composition":80}

Explanation: The video maintains high fidelity to the conditioning frame and captures the requested scene elements well, though the camera movement is too minimal to clearly convey the 'dolly' effect requested in the prompt. | overall_score=85 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":90,"motion_quality":80,"temporal_consistency":85,"visual_quality":90,"camera_composition":80}

Explanation: The video maintains high visual quality and adheres well to the prompt's scene description, though the camera motion and vehicle movement exhibit minor jitter and lack the desired smoothness of a professional dolly shot. | overall_score=85 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":90,"motion_quality":80,"temporal_consistency":85,"visual_quality":90,"camera_composition":80}


Prompt: The aoudad stands in front of a rocky cliff face, initially facing the camera before slowly turning its head to the right. As it turns, the goat closes its eyes and extends its tongue out from its mouth, holding it there briefly before retracting it. The camera remains static throughout the entire sequence, maintaining a tight, eye-level framing on the animal's head and shoulders as it performs these subtle, rhythmic movements.

Explanation: The video successfully executes the requested sequence of actions while maintaining high visual fidelity to the conditioning frame. Minor issues with the fluidness of the tongue extension and eye closure prevent a perfect score, but the overall motion is coherent and follows the prompt instructions well. | overall_score=85 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":90,"motion_quality":80,"temporal_consistency":85,"visual_quality":90,"camera_composition":95}

Explanation: The video successfully executes the requested sequence of actions while maintaining high visual fidelity to the conditioning frame. While the tongue movement has minor morphing artifacts, the overall motion is coherent and follows the prompt's instructions precisely. | overall_score=85 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":90,"motion_quality":80,"temporal_consistency":85,"visual_quality":90,"camera_composition":95}

Explanation: The video successfully maintains the identity of the aoudad from the first frame and adheres well to the prompt's specific motion requirements. While the tongue extension has minor morphing artifacts, the overall temporal consistency and visual quality are high. | overall_score=85 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":90,"motion_quality":80,"temporal_consistency":85,"visual_quality":90,"camera_composition":95}


Prompt: The camera performs a slow, steady drone-style forward dolly movement, gliding over the industrial facility. As the camera advances, a single person walks at a measured pace across the flat roof of the main factory building, moving from the center toward the right edge of the frame. The surrounding road and landscape remain static throughout the shot. This high-angle aerial view captures the expansive industrial complex and the adjacent highway, maintaining a consistent, smooth forward trajectory for the entire duration.

Explanation: The video adheres well to the prompt's requirements, including the specific camera movement and the addition of the walking person. While the motion of the camera and the person could be smoother, the overall visual quality and fidelity to the conditioning frame are high. | overall_score=82 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":98,"prompt_adherence":90,"motion_quality":85,"temporal_consistency":80,"visual_quality":85,"camera_composition":75}

Explanation: The video adheres well to the prompt's requirements, including the specific camera movement and the addition of a walking person. While the motion is generally good, there are minor temporal inconsistencies in the person's gait and slight jitter in the camera movement. | overall_score=82 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":98,"prompt_adherence":90,"motion_quality":85,"temporal_consistency":80,"visual_quality":85,"camera_composition":75}

Explanation: The video does a great job of maintaining the visual integrity of the first frame while successfully executing the complex prompt requirements. The primary drawbacks are minor jitters in the camera motion and slight temporal instability in the person's walking animation. | overall_score=82 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":98,"prompt_adherence":90,"motion_quality":85,"temporal_consistency":80,"visual_quality":85,"camera_composition":75}


Prompt: A flock of birds flies in a loose formation from the left side of the frame toward the right, maintaining a steady altitude against the horizon. Below them, the ocean waves roll rhythmically toward the shore, creating a constant, gentle motion across the water surface. The camera remains completely static throughout the entire duration, capturing the wide, panoramic view of the birds migrating across the sunset sky above the dark, silhouetted beach.

Explanation: The video is highly faithful to the conditioning frame and adheres well to the prompt's requirements. While the motion of the waves and birds could be more organic, the overall visual quality and temporal stability are very high. | overall_score=88 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":90,"motion_quality":85,"temporal_consistency":90,"visual_quality":90,"camera_composition":85}

Explanation: The video is highly faithful to the conditioning frame and effectively captures the requested scene. While the motion of the birds and waves could be more fluid and dynamic, the overall execution is high-quality and consistent. | overall_score=88 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":90,"motion_quality":85,"temporal_consistency":90,"visual_quality":90,"camera_composition":85}

Explanation: The video maintains high fidelity to the conditioning frame and successfully executes the requested motion of the birds and the ocean. While there is some minor temporal flickering in the bird formation, the overall visual quality and adherence to the prompt are strong. | overall_score=88 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":90,"motion_quality":85,"temporal_consistency":85,"visual_quality":90,"camera_composition":90}


Prompt: A person stands facing away from the camera, holding a closed black umbrella at their side. As the clip progresses, they slowly raise the umbrella upward and outward to the left, unfolding it until it is fully open above their head. The camera remains static throughout the entire sequence, maintaining a fixed, eye-level framing of the subject positioned behind a decorative metal gate with a blurred building in the background.

Explanation: The video successfully executes the requested action with high fidelity to the first frame and consistent camera framing. While there are minor geometric artifacts during the umbrella's opening, the overall motion is fluid and adheres well to the prompt. | overall_score=85 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":90,"motion_quality":80,"temporal_consistency":85,"visual_quality":85,"camera_composition":95}

Explanation: The video successfully executes the requested action with high fidelity to the conditioning frame. While the umbrella's opening motion is slightly stiff, the overall temporal consistency and visual quality are high, making it a very strong generation. | overall_score=88 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":90,"motion_quality":85,"temporal_consistency":90,"visual_quality":90,"camera_composition":95}

Explanation: The video successfully executes the complex motion of opening an umbrella while maintaining the static framing and high visual fidelity of the conditioning frame. The minor issues with the umbrella's mechanical movement are subtle and do not significantly detract from the overall quality. | overall_score=88 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":90,"motion_quality":85,"temporal_consistency":90,"visual_quality":90,"camera_composition":95}


Prompt: The camera performs a smooth, continuous forward dolly movement, gliding steadily over the dense forest canopy toward the horizon. As the camera advances, the perspective shifts, revealing more of the open, grassy clearing in the lower left foreground while the trees below appear to drift backward beneath the frame. The wide-angle aerial shot maintains a consistent altitude and orientation, capturing the vast, sunlit woodland landscape as it recedes steadily into the distance throughout the entire five-second duration.

Explanation: The video is visually high-quality and maintains perfect fidelity to the first frame. However, the camera movement is quite static and does not fully capture the dynamic forward dolly motion or the significant perspective shift requested in the prompt. | overall_score=85 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":80,"motion_quality":85,"temporal_consistency":90,"visual_quality":90,"camera_composition":75}

Explanation: The video is visually high-quality and maintains perfect temporal consistency, but the camera movement is too subtle to fully capture the dynamic perspective shift requested in the prompt. | overall_score=88 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":98,"prompt_adherence":90,"motion_quality":85,"temporal_consistency":95,"visual_quality":90,"camera_composition":70}

Explanation: The video maintains high visual fidelity and temporal stability, but the camera movement is too static and lacks the pronounced forward dolly effect requested in the prompt. | overall_score=85 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":80,"motion_quality":85,"temporal_consistency":90,"visual_quality":90,"camera_composition":75}


Prompt: A school of small fish swims steadily from left to right across the open water visible through the cave entrance. The fish maintain a consistent horizontal path, passing in front of the submerged rock formation. The camera remains static throughout the entire duration, maintaining a fixed wide shot of the underwater scene. The perspective is framed from within a dark, rocky cave looking out toward the bright, blue-lit expanse of the ocean.

Explanation: The video successfully maintains the static camera composition and adheres well to the prompt's requirements. While there are minor artifacts in the fish movement and slight shape morphing, the overall temporal consistency and fidelity to the first frame are high. | overall_score=85 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":90,"motion_quality":80,"temporal_consistency":85,"visual_quality":90,"camera_composition":95}

Explanation: The video maintains high fidelity to the conditioning frame and successfully executes the requested motion of the fish school. While there are minor temporal artifacts in the fish shapes, the overall visual quality and adherence to the prompt are strong. | overall_score=85 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":90,"motion_quality":80,"temporal_consistency":85,"visual_quality":85,"camera_composition":90}

Explanation: The video successfully maintains the composition and scene established in the first frame, with the fish moving in a coherent, steady path across the frame as requested. The motion is generally smooth, though there are minor instances of unnatural swimming patterns and slight flickering in the background elements. | overall_score=85 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":90,"motion_quality":80,"temporal_consistency":85,"visual_quality":90,"camera_composition":95}


Prompt: A modern tram travels rapidly from left to right across the frame, crossing the street and exiting the view. Meanwhile, a person stands stationary on the sidewalk near a parked white delivery truck, remaining still throughout the duration of the clip. The camera remains in a fixed, high-angle, static position, capturing the urban street scene from an elevated perspective. The surrounding emergency vehicles and the environment remain completely motionless while the tram provides the only significant movement in the scene.

Explanation: The video successfully maintains the static camera and the stationary person as requested. However, the tram's movement is not smooth, and the background emergency vehicle exhibits distracting light flickering, which contradicts the prompt's requirement for a motionless environment. | overall_score=78 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":85,"motion_quality":70,"temporal_consistency":75,"visual_quality":80,"camera_composition":90}

Explanation: While the video maintains the initial scene composition well, it fails significantly on the motion requirements. The tram does not move across the frame as requested, instead suffering from severe temporal artifacts and jitter, and the person on the sidewalk fails to remain still. | overall_score=45 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":40,"motion_quality":30,"temporal_consistency":30,"visual_quality":60,"camera_composition":90}

Explanation: While the video maintains the initial composition and perspective of the conditioning frame, it fails significantly on the motion requirements. The tram does not move across the scene as requested, and the entire video suffers from severe temporal instability and flickering, particularly on the person and the emergency vehicle lights. | overall_score=45 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":40,"motion_quality":30,"temporal_consistency":30,"visual_quality":60,"camera_composition":90}


Prompt: The man walks slowly away from the camera through a field of tall green grass and wildflowers. As he moves forward, he turns his head slightly to the right to look toward the coastal landscape. The camera remains static, maintaining a fixed medium-long shot of the man and the surrounding meadow. The scene features a person walking through a grassy hillside with pine trees and a distant mountain backdrop.

Explanation: The video maintains high fidelity to the conditioning frame and successfully executes the requested actions, though the character's walking animation is slightly robotic and lacks realistic weight. | overall_score=82 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":85,"motion_quality":80,"temporal_consistency":85,"visual_quality":85,"camera_composition":80}

Explanation: The video maintains high fidelity to the conditioning frame and successfully executes the requested actions. While the walking motion is slightly mechanical, the overall visual quality and temporal stability are strong. | overall_score=82 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":85,"motion_quality":80,"temporal_consistency":85,"visual_quality":85,"camera_composition":80}

Explanation: The video maintains high fidelity to the conditioning frame and successfully executes the requested motion of walking and turning the head. While there is some minor temporal instability in the grass and the walking motion, the overall quality is high and adheres well to the prompt. | overall_score=82 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":90,"motion_quality":85,"temporal_consistency":80,"visual_quality":85,"camera_composition":80}


Prompt: The ocean waves roll steadily toward the shore, breaking into white foam as they wash over the dark pebble beach. A person stands motionless in the middle distance, holding a camera up to their face to capture the coastal view. The camera remains completely static throughout the entire duration of the clip, maintaining a fixed, wide shot of the person and the rows of colorful kayaks lined up along the coastline.

Explanation: The video is highly faithful to the conditioning frame and the prompt, maintaining a static camera and capturing the scene accurately. The primary limitation is the slightly artificial, repetitive motion of the waves, which prevents a perfect score. | overall_score=88 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":98,"prompt_adherence":95,"motion_quality":85,"temporal_consistency":90,"visual_quality":92,"camera_composition":95}

Explanation: The video adheres very well to the prompt, maintaining a static camera and capturing the requested scene elements with high fidelity. The primary limitation is the somewhat mechanical and repetitive motion of the waves, which prevents a perfect score. | overall_score=88 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":98,"prompt_adherence":95,"motion_quality":80,"temporal_consistency":90,"visual_quality":92,"camera_composition":95}

Explanation: The video maintains high fidelity to the conditioning frame and adheres well to the prompt's requirements, particularly the static camera. The motion of the waves is acceptable but could be more natural, and there is slight instability in the background. | overall_score=88 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":98,"prompt_adherence":95,"motion_quality":85,"temporal_consistency":90,"visual_quality":92,"camera_composition":95}


Prompt: Two tennis players stand on opposite sides of a clay court, remaining stationary throughout the entire duration of the clip. The camera maintains a fixed, high-angle top-down perspective, capturing the full court and surrounding grounds without any movement or adjustment. The scene features two individuals positioned on a clay tennis court, with a net dividing the space and a small building visible at the top of the frame.

Explanation: The video perfectly adheres to the prompt's requirement for a static scene with no camera movement. The first frame is identical to the conditioning frame, and the visual quality remains consistent throughout the duration. | overall_score=95 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":100,"prompt_adherence":100,"motion_quality":90,"temporal_consistency":95,"visual_quality":95,"camera_composition":100}

Explanation: The generated video perfectly maintains the static nature of the scene as requested, with no camera movement or unwanted motion, and demonstrates high fidelity to the conditioning frame. | overall_score=95 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":100,"prompt_adherence":100,"motion_quality":90,"temporal_consistency":95,"visual_quality":95,"camera_composition":100}

Explanation: The video successfully maintains a static scene as requested, with no camera movement or unnecessary motion. The first frame is identical to the conditioning frame, and the overall visual quality is high. | overall_score=95 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":100,"prompt_adherence":100,"motion_quality":90,"temporal_consistency":95,"visual_quality":95,"camera_composition":100}


Prompt: The rider on a dirt bike accelerates forward, moving from the left side of the frame toward the right and eventually exiting the scene. As the bike travels, the camera performs a smooth, steady pan to the right, tracking the subject's movement across the snowy, wooded path. The rider remains seated and focused ahead throughout the short journey. A person in a white jacket and helmet rides a dirt bike through a snow-covered forest clearing.

Explanation: The video starts with high fidelity to the conditioning frame and captures the requested acceleration well. However, the subject's exit from the frame is somewhat abrupt, and there is a slight loss of temporal stability as the bike moves out of view. | overall_score=85 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":90,"motion_quality":85,"temporal_consistency":80,"visual_quality":85,"camera_composition":80}

Explanation: The video successfully captures the core action and setting described in the prompt with high visual fidelity to the first frame. While the camera movement lacks the requested smoothness and there is a slight lack of polish in the final exit, the overall execution is strong and coherent. | overall_score=82 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":85,"motion_quality":80,"temporal_consistency":75,"visual_quality":85,"camera_composition":70}

Explanation: The video maintains high visual fidelity to the first frame and captures the subject's movement well, but it fails to execute the requested camera pan, remaining static throughout the duration. | overall_score=82 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":85,"motion_quality":80,"temporal_consistency":85,"visual_quality":85,"camera_composition":65}


Prompt: Water droplets fall continuously from the upper leaves, creating a steady, rhythmic stream that splashes onto the lower foliage. The droplets descend vertically in a consistent, rapid motion, maintaining a constant flow throughout the entire duration. The camera remains in a fixed, static position, maintaining a tight, macro-focused framing on the lush green maidenhair fern leaves. The scene captures the natural, persistent dripping of water within a dense, shaded forest environment.

Explanation: The video demonstrates high fidelity to the conditioning frame and effectively captures the requested motion of falling water droplets. While there are minor temporal inconsistencies in the fluid dynamics of the water, the overall visual quality and adherence to the prompt are strong. | overall_score=88 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":98,"prompt_adherence":95,"motion_quality":85,"temporal_consistency":80,"visual_quality":90,"camera_composition":95}

Explanation: The video maintains high fidelity to the conditioning frame and effectively captures the requested macro-focused, static scene. While there is some minor temporal instability in the water droplets' motion, the overall quality is high and adheres well to the prompt. | overall_score=88 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":98,"prompt_adherence":95,"motion_quality":85,"temporal_consistency":80,"visual_quality":90,"camera_composition":95}


Prompt: A person wipes a large, flat banana leaf resting on a white table. The camera remains static in a close-up, high-angle shot. The person uses their left hand to move a folded, light-colored cloth in a rhythmic, circular scrubbing motion across the surface of the leaf, while their right hand remains pressed firmly against the right side of the leaf to hold it steady throughout the entire duration of the clip.

Explanation: The video demonstrates high fidelity to the conditioning frame and follows the prompt's instructions regarding camera angle and hand placement. While there is minor temporal instability in the cloth's movement, the overall visual quality and adherence to the requested action are strong. | overall_score=85 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":90,"motion_quality":80,"temporal_consistency":85,"visual_quality":90,"camera_composition":95}

Explanation: The video adheres well to the prompt, maintaining the requested camera angle and hand positioning throughout. While the motion of the cloth is slightly mechanical, the overall visual quality and temporal consistency are high. | overall_score=85 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":90,"motion_quality":80,"temporal_consistency":85,"visual_quality":90,"camera_composition":95}

Explanation: The video adheres very well to the prompt, maintaining the requested static camera and hand positions. While the cloth motion is slightly artificial and exhibits minor morphing, the overall temporal consistency and visual quality are high. | overall_score=85 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":90,"motion_quality":80,"temporal_consistency":85,"visual_quality":90,"camera_composition":95}


Prompt: A person types on a laptop keyboard, with fingers rhythmically striking the keys in a continuous, rapid motion. The hands remain positioned over the center of the keyboard, with individual fingers pressing down and lifting in a fluid, repetitive sequence throughout the entire duration. The camera remains completely static, maintaining a tight, high-angle close-up shot focused on the interaction between the fingers and the keys. The scene captures a person typing on a laptop placed on a white surface.

Explanation: While the video maintains the visual style and composition of the first frame, the motion is highly unrealistic and fails to depict the fluid, rhythmic typing requested in the prompt, resulting in a static, jittery appearance. | overall_score=35 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":40,"motion_quality":20,"temporal_consistency":30,"visual_quality":60,"camera_composition":90}

Explanation: While the video successfully maintains the static camera composition and matches the first frame perfectly, the motion quality is very poor. The fingers do not realistically strike the keys, instead appearing to vibrate or morph in place, which fails to meet the prompt's requirement for a fluid, rhythmic typing motion. | overall_score=35 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":40,"motion_quality":20,"temporal_consistency":30,"visual_quality":60,"camera_composition":90}

Explanation: While the video successfully maintains the static camera and high-quality visual style of the first frame, the motion generation is poor. The fingers do not realistically interact with the keyboard, instead exhibiting jittery, morphing, and unnatural movements that fail to convey the act of typing. | overall_score=35 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":40,"motion_quality":20,"temporal_consistency":30,"visual_quality":60,"camera_composition":90}


Prompt: A bright, narrow beam of light sweeps slowly across the dark night sky from right to left, originating from a distant point on the horizon. The beam remains visible as a faint, glowing trail against the black expanse before gradually fading. The camera remains completely static, maintaining a wide, fixed framing of the sprawling city lights below. This is a high-angle, long-distance view of a nocturnal urban landscape under a vast, dark sky.

Explanation: The video successfully maintains the static camera and city background from the first frame, but the generated light beam suffers from significant temporal instability, including flickering and disjointed movement that deviates from a smooth sweep. | overall_score=78 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":85,"motion_quality":70,"temporal_consistency":75,"visual_quality":80,"camera_composition":90}

Explanation: The video successfully maintains the static camera and urban landscape from the first frame, but the motion of the light beam is jittery and suffers from temporal discontinuities, failing to achieve the requested smooth, slow sweep. | overall_score=78 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":85,"motion_quality":70,"temporal_consistency":75,"visual_quality":80,"camera_composition":90}

Explanation: The video successfully maintains the static camera and the urban landscape from the first frame, but the motion of the light beam is jittery and lacks the smooth, sweeping quality described in the prompt. | overall_score=78 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":85,"motion_quality":70,"temporal_consistency":75,"visual_quality":80,"camera_composition":90}


Prompt: Two clownfish swim within and around a large sea anemone on a coral reef. The anemone tentacles sway gently in the current throughout the clip. One clownfish moves from the center of the anemone toward the right side, while the other remains near the lower right edge, occasionally darting slightly. The camera remains static, maintaining a fixed, medium-wide shot of the anemone and the surrounding rocky reef environment.

Explanation: The video maintains high fidelity to the conditioning frame and follows the prompt's instructions well. While the motion of the fish is slightly robotic and the anemone exhibits minor temporal artifacts, the overall visual quality and adherence to the scene composition are strong. | overall_score=85 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":90,"motion_quality":80,"temporal_consistency":85,"visual_quality":90,"camera_composition":95}

Explanation: The video successfully maintains the scene from the first frame and follows the prompt's instructions well. While the fish movement is slightly robotic and the anemone motion is not perfectly fluid, the overall visual quality and adherence to the requested composition are strong. | overall_score=85 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":90,"motion_quality":80,"temporal_consistency":85,"visual_quality":90,"camera_composition":95}

Explanation: The video maintains high fidelity to the conditioning frame and follows the prompt's instructions regarding the movement of the two clownfish well. The motion is generally smooth, though there are minor instances of unnatural fish movement and slight texture morphing in the anemone. | overall_score=85 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":90,"motion_quality":80,"temporal_consistency":85,"visual_quality":90,"camera_composition":90}


Prompt: The camera performs a slow, steady drone-style forward dolly movement, gradually descending and pushing toward the center of the urban landscape. Below, traffic flows continuously along the multi-lane highway on the left, while the parking lot remains static. The perspective maintains a high-angle aerial view of a sprawling commercial complex and surrounding city streets, capturing the constant, fluid motion of vehicles moving along the road while the buildings and parking infrastructure stay fixed in place throughout the five-second duration.

Explanation: The video fails to execute the requested camera movement and the dynamic traffic motion specified in the prompt, resulting in a nearly static image that does not meet the motion requirements. | overall_score=35 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":20,"motion_quality":20,"temporal_consistency":40,"visual_quality":60,"camera_composition":35}

Explanation: The generated video fails significantly on the motion requirements specified in the prompt. While the first frame is perfectly preserved, the video lacks the requested camera movement and the dynamic traffic flow, resulting in a static image sequence rather than a video. | overall_score=35 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":20,"motion_quality":20,"temporal_consistency":30,"visual_quality":40,"camera_composition":30}

Explanation: The generated video fails significantly on the primary motion requirements. Despite the prompt explicitly asking for a slow, steady drone-style forward dolly movement, the video remains almost entirely static, failing to capture the requested fluid motion of traffic or the camera's descent. | overall_score=25 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":20,"motion_quality":10,"temporal_consistency":20,"visual_quality":30,"camera_composition":20}


Prompt: A gold SUV drives from the right side of the frame toward the left, crossing the street and exiting the view. Following it, a dark sedan travels along the same path, moving from the right edge toward the left side of the frame. The camera remains static throughout the entire clip, maintaining a fixed wide shot of the urban street scene. The setting is a city street lined with parked cars, brick buildings, and green trees.

Explanation: While the first frame is perfectly preserved and the camera remains static, the model failed to generate the second vehicle requested in the prompt. Furthermore, the motion of the single generated vehicle is highly unnatural, suffering from severe temporal flickering and geometric distortion. | overall_score=45 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":40,"motion_quality":30,"temporal_consistency":30,"visual_quality":60,"camera_composition":90}

Explanation: While the initial frame is perfectly preserved, the model failed to generate the second vehicle requested in the prompt and the motion of the single generated vehicle is highly unnatural and geometrically unstable. | overall_score=45 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":40,"motion_quality":30,"temporal_consistency":30,"visual_quality":60,"camera_composition":90}

Explanation: While the first frame is perfectly preserved, the model fails significantly on the prompt requirements. Only one of the two requested vehicles appears, and it manifests via a jarring pop-in effect rather than entering the frame naturally, followed by significant visual degradation and morphing during its movement. | overall_score=35 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":30,"motion_quality":20,"temporal_consistency":20,"visual_quality":40,"camera_composition":70}


Prompt: The camera performs a smooth, continuous forward dolly movement, traveling steadily toward the coastline. As the perspective shifts, the houses and surrounding vegetation gradually expand in the frame, revealing more detail of the rocky shoreline and the water below. This aerial view captures a quiet coastal neighborhood, maintaining a consistent downward-tilted angle throughout the entire five-second sequence as the drone advances over the landscape toward the sea.

Explanation: The video demonstrates high fidelity to the conditioning frame and successfully executes the requested forward dolly motion. While there is some minor geometric instability in the terrain as the camera moves, the overall temporal consistency and adherence to the prompt's narrative are very strong. | overall_score=88 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":98,"prompt_adherence":95,"motion_quality":85,"temporal_consistency":90,"visual_quality":85,"camera_composition":80}

Explanation: The video successfully executes the requested forward dolly movement while maintaining high fidelity to the starting frame. There is some minor texture instability in the rocks and vegetation, but the overall temporal consistency and prompt adherence are very strong. | overall_score=88 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":98,"prompt_adherence":95,"motion_quality":85,"temporal_consistency":90,"visual_quality":85,"camera_composition":80}

Explanation: The video demonstrates high fidelity to the conditioning frame and successfully executes the requested forward dolly motion. While there is some minor texture instability and slight geometric warping near the end of the sequence, the overall visual quality and adherence to the prompt are strong. | overall_score=88 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":98,"prompt_adherence":95,"motion_quality":85,"temporal_consistency":90,"visual_quality":85,"camera_composition":80}


Prompt: A worker in a high-visibility vest stands behind a metal railing, continuously spraying a high-pressure water jet downward to clean the pavement. The water stream moves in a rhythmic, side-to-side sweeping motion across the ground, pushing soapy foam forward. A second person in a blue vest stands in the foreground, holding a long wooden pole and slowly dragging it across the wet surface. The camera remains static throughout the shot, maintaining a medium-long framing of the street-level cleaning scene.

Explanation: The video is highly faithful to the first frame and maintains excellent visual quality throughout. While the water spray animation is convincing, the second person in the foreground is static, failing to execute the requested dragging motion, which slightly impacts the overall prompt adherence. | overall_score=88 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":98,"prompt_adherence":90,"motion_quality":85,"temporal_consistency":85,"visual_quality":90,"camera_composition":95}

Explanation: The video is highly faithful to the first frame and maintains excellent visual quality throughout. While it captures the primary action of the water jet, the secondary action of the person with the pole is missing, and the water motion is slightly mechanical. | overall_score=88 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":98,"prompt_adherence":90,"motion_quality":85,"temporal_consistency":88,"visual_quality":92,"camera_composition":95}

Explanation: The video maintains high fidelity to the first frame and excellent visual quality. However, it fails to animate the second person as requested in the prompt, and the water motion is slightly limited in its dynamic range. | overall_score=88 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":98,"prompt_adherence":90,"motion_quality":85,"temporal_consistency":85,"visual_quality":90,"camera_composition":95}


Prompt: The camera performs a slow, steady dolly-in movement, gradually closing the distance toward the central plant. As the camera advances, the leaves of the small plant sway gently and rhythmically from side to side, reacting to a light breeze. The surrounding forest floor and the tall, dense pine trees in the background remain static throughout the shot. This sequence captures a quiet, focused perspective of a young plant growing within a lush, shaded woodland environment.


Prompt: The person lying in the hammock gently rocks back and forth, their body swaying rhythmically with the movement of the fabric. Their right arm lifts slightly and moves in a small, relaxed gesture before resting back down. The camera remains static throughout the shot, maintaining a fixed, wide-angle framing of the person resting in the hammock suspended between two pine trees in a grassy forest clearing.

Explanation: The video successfully captures the requested motion of the person in the hammock with good fidelity to the initial frame. While there is some minor temporal instability in the hammock's movement and slight anatomical artifacts during the arm gesture, the overall quality is high and adheres well to the prompt. | overall_score=82 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":90,"motion_quality":85,"temporal_consistency":80,"visual_quality":85,"camera_composition":90}

Explanation: The video successfully captures the requested motion of the person in the hammock with high fidelity to the first frame. While there is some minor temporal instability and slight morphing during the arm gesture, the overall quality is high and adheres well to the prompt. | overall_score=82 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":90,"motion_quality":85,"temporal_consistency":75,"visual_quality":80,"camera_composition":90}

Explanation: The video maintains high fidelity to the conditioning frame and successfully executes the requested motion. While there is some minor temporal instability in the person's arm and the hammock fabric, the overall quality is high and the prompt is well-represented. | overall_score=82 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":90,"motion_quality":85,"temporal_consistency":80,"visual_quality":85,"camera_composition":90}


Prompt: Dense, dark gray clouds in the foreground drift steadily toward the right side of the frame, while the bright white cumulus clouds behind them remain relatively stationary. The camera is static, maintaining a fixed, wide-angle view of the sky. This scene captures the layered movement of atmospheric cloud formations against a clear blue backdrop, emphasizing the contrast between the shifting dark masses and the stable, sunlit cloud structures.

Explanation: While the video maintains the initial frame perfectly, it fails to execute the requested motion. The clouds appear largely static with minor, jittery artifacts rather than the steady, directional drift described in the prompt. | overall_score=35 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":40,"motion_quality":20,"temporal_consistency":30,"visual_quality":40,"camera_composition":50}

Explanation: While the video maintains the visual structure of the first frame, it fails to execute the requested motion. The clouds exhibit almost no realistic drift, instead suffering from significant temporal instability and flickering that degrades the overall visual quality. | overall_score=35 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":40,"motion_quality":20,"temporal_consistency":30,"visual_quality":40,"camera_composition":50}

Explanation: The video successfully maintains the visual integrity of the first frame while effectively animating the clouds. While the motion is a bit subtle, it aligns well with the prompt's requirements for layered movement and a static camera. | overall_score=85 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":90,"motion_quality":80,"temporal_consistency":85,"visual_quality":90,"camera_composition":95}


Prompt: The camera performs a steady, continuous forward dolly movement, traveling over the surface of the river toward the distant mountains. The water flows gently toward the camera, creating subtle ripples and reflections on the surface throughout the duration of the shot. The framing remains centered on the river as it winds between the forested banks. This scene depicts a tranquil river flowing through a lush, tree-lined valley with a wooden boardwalk visible along the left bank.

Explanation: The video maintains high fidelity to the first frame and captures the requested scene elements well, but the motion is too subtle to fully satisfy the 'continuous forward dolly' requirement, and the water lacks the expected fluid animation. | overall_score=85 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":98,"prompt_adherence":90,"motion_quality":85,"temporal_consistency":85,"visual_quality":85,"camera_composition":80}

Explanation: The video maintains high visual fidelity to the first frame and captures the requested scene elements well. However, the motion is too subtle to effectively represent a 'continuous forward dolly movement,' and the water lacks the requested gentle flow, making the scene feel somewhat static. | overall_score=85 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":90,"motion_quality":80,"temporal_consistency":85,"visual_quality":85,"camera_composition":80}

Explanation: The video is visually stunning and maintains perfect fidelity to the conditioning frame, but it fails to deliver the requested dynamic motion. The camera movement is barely perceptible, and the water lacks the active, flowing ripples described in the prompt. | overall_score=88 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":98,"prompt_adherence":95,"motion_quality":85,"temporal_consistency":90,"visual_quality":92,"camera_composition":80}


Prompt: The camera performs a smooth, continuous forward dolly movement, gliding over a rugged, tree-dotted mountain slope toward a distant, expansive mountain range. As the camera advances, the foreground terrain shifts downward and out of the frame while the central valley and peaks remain fixed in the distance. The perspective maintains a steady, high-altitude aerial framing throughout the entire five-second duration, capturing a slow, immersive approach over the arid, sunlit landscape.

Explanation: The video is visually stunning and maintains perfect fidelity to the first frame, but it fails to execute the requested camera motion effectively, resulting in a nearly static shot rather than the dynamic dolly movement described. | overall_score=85 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":90,"motion_quality":80,"temporal_consistency":85,"visual_quality":90,"camera_composition":80}

Explanation: The video fails to execute the requested camera movement, remaining almost entirely static throughout the duration. While the visual quality and fidelity to the first frame are high, the lack of motion makes it a poor adherence to the prompt's specific instructions for a dolly movement. | overall_score=35 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":20,"motion_quality":20,"temporal_consistency":40,"visual_quality":60,"camera_composition":20}

Explanation: While the visual quality and fidelity to the first frame are high, the video fails almost entirely on the motion requirements specified in the prompt. The camera does not perform the requested forward dolly movement, resulting in a nearly static image that does not capture the immersive aerial approach. | overall_score=25 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":20,"motion_quality":10,"temporal_consistency":20,"visual_quality":40,"camera_composition":10}


Prompt: The camera performs a smooth, continuous vertical ascent, pulling back from a top-down view of the garden to reveal more of the surrounding paved courtyard and building structures. The framing remains centered on the geometric garden layout throughout the entire five-second duration. This aerial perspective captures a quiet, static scene where the camera movement is the only source of motion, steadily increasing the field of view as it rises above the landscaped grounds and surrounding architecture.

Explanation: The video successfully executes the requested vertical ascent while maintaining high visual fidelity to the first frame. The motion is generally good, though it exhibits minor jitter, and the composition remains well-centered throughout the duration. | overall_score=92 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":98,"prompt_adherence":95,"motion_quality":90,"temporal_consistency":95,"visual_quality":95,"camera_composition":85}

Explanation: The video successfully executes the requested vertical ascent while maintaining the integrity of the scene and the geometric garden layout. The motion is smooth and consistent, with only minor artifacts that do not detract from the overall quality. | overall_score=92 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":98,"prompt_adherence":95,"motion_quality":90,"temporal_consistency":95,"visual_quality":92,"camera_composition":90}

Explanation: The video successfully executes the requested vertical ascent while maintaining the integrity of the original scene. The motion is smooth and the composition remains centered as requested, with only minor artifacts during the camera transition. | overall_score=92 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":98,"prompt_adherence":95,"motion_quality":90,"temporal_consistency":95,"visual_quality":92,"camera_composition":90}


Prompt: Low-hanging wisps of mist drift slowly from left to right across the middle distance, weaving through the dark silhouettes of the forest canopy. Above, the cloud layer remains largely stationary, showing minimal shifting. The camera is completely static, maintaining a wide, fixed landscape framing throughout the entire duration. This scene captures a quiet, expansive view of a forested valley under a vast, overcast sky, emphasizing the subtle, horizontal movement of the ground-level fog.

Explanation: The video adheres very well to the prompt, maintaining a static camera and capturing the requested atmospheric conditions. While the motion of the mist is quite slow, it is present and consistent with the scene's requirements. | overall_score=92 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":100,"prompt_adherence":95,"motion_quality":85,"temporal_consistency":95,"visual_quality":90,"camera_composition":95}

Explanation: The video maintains high fidelity to the first frame and successfully captures the requested atmospheric motion. The camera remains perfectly static as requested, and the temporal consistency is high, though the movement of the mist is somewhat subtle. | overall_score=92 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":100,"prompt_adherence":95,"motion_quality":90,"temporal_consistency":95,"visual_quality":90,"camera_composition":90}

Explanation: The video maintains high fidelity to the first frame and successfully captures the requested atmospheric motion. The camera remains perfectly static as instructed, and the overall visual quality is high, with only minor compression artifacts in the shadows. | overall_score=92 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":100,"prompt_adherence":95,"motion_quality":90,"temporal_consistency":95,"visual_quality":90,"camera_composition":90}


Prompt: Two hikers with backpacks ascend a steep, snow-covered mountain slope. The person in the foreground rhythmically moves a trekking pole forward and plants it into the ground while walking upward. The second hiker, positioned slightly ahead and to the right, continues walking steadily uphill away from the camera. The camera follows them from behind in a handheld, slightly shaky motion, maintaining a consistent medium framing as they progress through the misty, rocky terrain.

Explanation: While the video captures the requested atmosphere and camera style, it fails significantly on subject consistency. The hiker in the foreground undergoes a drastic change in appearance from the first frame, and the second hiker is not properly tracked or maintained throughout the sequence. | overall_score=45 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":30,"prompt_adherence":50,"motion_quality":40,"temporal_consistency":40,"visual_quality":60,"camera_composition":50}

Explanation: The video fails significantly on identity fidelity, as the foreground hiker's appearance changes drastically from the conditioning frame. While the environment is well-rendered, the lack of temporal stability regarding the second hiker and the jittery, unrealistic motion of the trekking pole undermine the prompt's requirements. | overall_score=45 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":30,"prompt_adherence":50,"motion_quality":40,"temporal_consistency":40,"visual_quality":60,"camera_composition":50}

Explanation: While the video captures the requested atmosphere and camera style, it fails significantly on identity fidelity, as the primary subject's appearance changes drastically from the conditioning frame. The second hiker is also poorly tracked, leading to a loss of the requested scene composition. | overall_score=45 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":30,"prompt_adherence":50,"motion_quality":40,"temporal_consistency":40,"visual_quality":60,"camera_composition":50}


Prompt: The excavator arm in the center of the frame repeatedly lowers and raises its bucket to dig into the dirt, while a worker in a high-visibility vest walks slowly from the left side of the construction site toward the right. The camera remains in a static, high-angle, tilt-shift perspective throughout the entire duration. This scene captures a busy construction site with heavy machinery and personnel operating within a cordoned-off area.

Explanation: While the video successfully maintains the visual style and composition of the first frame, it fails almost entirely to animate the requested actions, resulting in a static image rather than a video. | overall_score=25 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":10,"motion_quality":10,"temporal_consistency":20,"visual_quality":40,"camera_composition":80}

Explanation: The generated video fails to animate the scene as requested in the prompt, resulting in a static image rather than a video. While the first frame fidelity is high, the lack of any motion or adherence to the action-based prompt makes it a failure as a video generation. | overall_score=15 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":90,"prompt_adherence":10,"motion_quality":5,"temporal_consistency":5,"visual_quality":20,"camera_composition":60}

Explanation: The generated video fails to animate the scene as requested in the prompt, resulting in a static image rather than a video. While the first frame fidelity is high, the lack of any motion makes it a failure in terms of prompt adherence and motion quality. | overall_score=15 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":90,"prompt_adherence":10,"motion_quality":5,"temporal_consistency":5,"visual_quality":20,"camera_composition":60}


Prompt: A person tightens the quick-release lever on a bicycle front wheel hub. The right hand repeatedly rotates the lever clockwise in short, incremental arcs, pausing briefly between each turn to reset the grip. The left hand remains steady, holding the fork and wheel assembly in place. The camera is static, maintaining a tight, eye-level close-up on the hub and the hands performing the mechanical adjustment. The scene focuses on the hands securing the wheel to the bicycle frame.

Explanation: While the video maintains the initial framing and visual style perfectly, the motion is fundamentally broken. The lever does not interact with the hub in a realistic way, and the hand movement is a repetitive, jittery animation that fails to simulate the mechanical action of tightening a quick-release lever. | overall_score=35 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":40,"motion_quality":20,"temporal_consistency":30,"visual_quality":60,"camera_composition":80}

Explanation: The video maintains high visual fidelity and adheres well to the composition requirements. However, the motion of the quick-release lever is physically incorrect for the object depicted, and the hand motion lacks the specific 'resetting' behavior requested in the prompt. | overall_score=82 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":98,"prompt_adherence":85,"motion_quality":75,"temporal_consistency":70,"visual_quality":90,"camera_composition":95}

Explanation: While the video starts with high fidelity to the conditioning frame, it fails significantly in motion quality. The quick-release lever is animated as a continuously rotating crank, which is mechanically incorrect and fails to adhere to the specific, incremental motion requested in the prompt. | overall_score=35 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":40,"motion_quality":20,"temporal_consistency":20,"visual_quality":60,"camera_composition":80}


Prompt: A white rabbit sits motionless behind a dense thicket of dark, thin branches. The rabbit remains entirely still, its ears upright and alert, while its nose twitches rhythmically throughout the entire duration of the clip. The camera is static, maintaining a tight, eye-level framing on the rabbit through the foreground foliage. The scene is quiet and focused, capturing only the subtle, repetitive movement of the rabbit's nose against the backdrop of the dark, stationary brush.

Explanation: The video maintains high visual fidelity and adheres well to the composition and subject requirements. However, the requested rhythmic nose twitching is extremely faint and lacks the distinct, repetitive motion specified in the prompt. | overall_score=85 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":90,"motion_quality":80,"temporal_consistency":85,"visual_quality":90,"camera_composition":95}

Explanation: The video adheres well to the prompt's composition and subject requirements, maintaining high visual fidelity throughout. However, the requested rhythmic nose twitching is extremely faint and lacks the expected dynamic motion, which slightly detracts from the overall motion quality. | overall_score=85 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":90,"motion_quality":80,"temporal_consistency":85,"visual_quality":90,"camera_composition":95}

Explanation: The video is highly faithful to the conditioning frame and effectively captures the static, focused nature of the scene. While the nose twitching is present, it is less rhythmic and pronounced than the prompt implies, and there is slight instability in the foreground foliage. | overall_score=85 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":90,"motion_quality":80,"temporal_consistency":85,"visual_quality":90,"camera_composition":95}


Prompt: The camera performs a slow, steady forward dolly movement, gliding over the water toward the dense, tree-covered peninsula. As the camera advances, the perspective shifts to reveal more of the residential structures nestled among the trees on the right side of the landmass. The framing remains wide, maintaining a high-angle aerial view of the island and the surrounding lake, while the water surface remains calm and still throughout the entire duration of the shot.

Explanation: The video maintains high visual fidelity and adheres well to the prompt's scene description. The primary area for improvement is the smoothness of the camera movement, which exhibits minor jitter, and the degree of perspective shift, which is somewhat limited. | overall_score=85 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":90,"motion_quality":85,"temporal_consistency":90,"visual_quality":90,"camera_composition":80}

Explanation: The video maintains high visual fidelity to the conditioning frame and successfully captures the essence of the prompt. The camera movement is generally effective, though it lacks the perfect smoothness of a professional dolly shot, and the reveal of the residential structures is somewhat limited by the speed and nature of the motion. | overall_score=85 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":90,"motion_quality":85,"temporal_consistency":90,"visual_quality":90,"camera_composition":80}

Explanation: The video successfully executes the requested forward dolly movement while maintaining high visual fidelity to the conditioning frame. The motion is generally smooth, though there is minor jitter, and the perspective shift is present but could be more dynamic. | overall_score=85 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":90,"motion_quality":85,"temporal_consistency":90,"visual_quality":90,"camera_composition":80}


Prompt: The camera performs a slow, steady forward dolly movement, gliding over the rugged terrain toward the distant horizon. As the perspective shifts, the layers of mountain silhouettes appear to recede and deepen against the glowing sunset. The framing remains wide and stable, maintaining a consistent aerial view of the vast, misty mountain range. This is a sweeping drone shot capturing the serene, atmospheric transition of light over a sprawling, layered landscape of peaks and valleys at dusk.

Explanation: The video is visually stunning and maintains perfect fidelity to the conditioning frame. While the motion is technically present, it is so subtle that it barely registers as the requested 'forward dolly movement', which is the only significant deviation from the prompt. | overall_score=92 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":98,"prompt_adherence":95,"motion_quality":90,"temporal_consistency":95,"visual_quality":92,"camera_composition":85}

Explanation: The video is visually stunning and maintains perfect fidelity to the first frame. However, the requested camera motion is very minimal, making the 'dolly movement' feel more like a static shot with slight digital zoom or stabilization, failing to fully capture the dynamic sweeping drone shot described in the prompt. | overall_score=92 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":98,"prompt_adherence":95,"motion_quality":90,"temporal_consistency":95,"visual_quality":92,"camera_composition":85}

Explanation: The video is visually stunning and maintains perfect fidelity to the first frame. While the atmospheric transition is well-executed, the requested forward dolly movement is barely perceptible, making the motion feel more like a static shot than a dynamic drone movement. | overall_score=92 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":98,"prompt_adherence":95,"motion_quality":90,"temporal_consistency":95,"visual_quality":92,"camera_composition":85}


Prompt: The man in the center holds a white paper and gestures with his left arm toward the right, while the other three people look in the direction he is pointing. The camera performs a slow, steady dolly-in movement, gradually tightening the framing on the group. The four individuals stand together in a wooded area, wearing athletic shirts with race bibs, as they engage in a collaborative discussion about their route or race strategy.

Explanation: While the video maintains high visual fidelity to the first frame, it completely fails to execute the requested camera movement and character motion, resulting in a static, lifeless clip that ignores the core dynamic requirements of the prompt. | overall_score=45 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":40,"motion_quality":30,"temporal_consistency":50,"visual_quality":60,"camera_composition":20}

Explanation: While the first frame is perfectly preserved, the video fails to execute the requested camera movement and exhibits significant temporal instability and lack of character motion, making the scene feel static and unnatural. | overall_score=35 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":40,"motion_quality":20,"temporal_consistency":30,"visual_quality":40,"camera_composition":25}

Explanation: The video maintains high visual fidelity and adheres well to the prompt's content, but the requested camera movement is barely perceptible, and the characters lack the dynamic motion expected in a 'collaborative discussion'. | overall_score=82 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":98,"prompt_adherence":85,"motion_quality":75,"temporal_consistency":80,"visual_quality":90,"camera_composition":65}


Prompt: Two scientists in a laboratory setting work together, with the standing male researcher writing on a clipboard while the seated female researcher simultaneously writes on a document below him. The camera remains static throughout the shot, maintaining a medium framing of the pair. The male researcher moves his pen across the paper in a steady, rhythmic motion, while the female researcher keeps her hand moving consistently across her own document, both focused on their respective tasks.

Explanation: The video maintains high fidelity to the conditioning frame and follows the prompt's structural requirements well. While the motion of the writing is slightly stiff and lacks natural fluidity, the overall temporal consistency and visual quality are strong. | overall_score=88 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":98,"prompt_adherence":95,"motion_quality":80,"temporal_consistency":90,"visual_quality":95,"camera_composition":95}

Explanation: The video is visually high-quality and perfectly matches the conditioning frame, but the motion is too minimal to fully satisfy the prompt's requirement for active, rhythmic writing. | overall_score=85 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":98,"prompt_adherence":90,"motion_quality":75,"temporal_consistency":85,"visual_quality":90,"camera_composition":95}

Explanation: The video is highly faithful to the conditioning frame and accurately depicts the requested scene. While the motion is somewhat minimal and lacks dynamic energy, the overall visual quality and temporal stability are very high. | overall_score=88 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":98,"prompt_adherence":95,"motion_quality":80,"temporal_consistency":90,"visual_quality":95,"camera_composition":95}


Prompt: The ocean waves roll steadily toward the shore, breaking against the dark rocks and washing over the sand. A small group of people walks slowly from the right side of the beach toward the center, while others remain scattered, standing or crouching near the water. The camera remains static throughout the entire duration, maintaining a wide, fixed framing of the coastal landscape. A white house sits quietly on the grassy hill overlooking the beach scene.

Explanation: The video maintains high fidelity to the first frame and adheres well to the prompt's scene description. While the motion of the waves and the people is somewhat subtle and occasionally jittery, the overall visual quality and composition are strong. | overall_score=82 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":98,"prompt_adherence":85,"motion_quality":75,"temporal_consistency":80,"visual_quality":85,"camera_composition":90}

Explanation: The video maintains high fidelity to the first frame and adheres well to the static camera requirement. However, the motion quality is quite low, as the waves and the people in the scene show very little dynamic movement, making the video feel more like a near-static image than a fluid animation. | overall_score=78 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":98,"prompt_adherence":85,"motion_quality":70,"temporal_consistency":75,"visual_quality":80,"camera_composition":85}

Explanation: The video maintains high fidelity to the first frame and adheres well to the prompt's scene description. However, the motion of the waves and the people is somewhat stiff and lacks fluid, natural animation, with some minor temporal instability in the textures. | overall_score=78 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":85,"motion_quality":70,"temporal_consistency":75,"visual_quality":80,"camera_composition":90}


Prompt: The water in the circular fountain continuously sprays upward in a steady, rhythmic pattern, creating a constant flow of white foam. A person wearing a white shirt and backpack walks steadily from the left side of the frame toward the right, passing behind the fountain. The camera remains completely static throughout the entire five-second duration, maintaining a fixed, eye-level wide shot of the abstract bronze sculpture situated in front of the Exchange Square building entrance.

Explanation: The video maintains high fidelity to the first frame and adheres well to the prompt's requirements. The primary weaknesses are minor motion artifacts in the walking person and a slightly synthetic look to the water animation. | overall_score=85 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":90,"motion_quality":80,"temporal_consistency":85,"visual_quality":90,"camera_composition":95}

Explanation: The video maintains high fidelity to the conditioning frame and adheres well to the composition requirements. However, the motion of the person is slightly unnatural, and the fountain's water animation is less dynamic than the prompt implies. | overall_score=82 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":85,"motion_quality":75,"temporal_consistency":80,"visual_quality":90,"camera_composition":95}

Explanation: The video maintains high fidelity to the first frame and adheres well to the prompt's composition and action requirements. The primary minor issues are slight motion artifacts in the walking person and the somewhat artificial, looping appearance of the fountain water. | overall_score=82 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":85,"motion_quality":80,"temporal_consistency":85,"visual_quality":90,"camera_composition":95}


Prompt: The gloved hands of a medical professional hold a syringe and a test tube. The person slowly pushes the syringe plunger downward, injecting a clear liquid into the tube. The needle remains steady inside the tube opening throughout the process. The camera remains static in a close-up shot, focusing on the hands and the medical equipment. The subject is a healthcare worker in scrubs, performing a precise, controlled laboratory procedure.

Explanation: While the model successfully maintained the visual fidelity of the first frame, it failed entirely to animate the requested action, resulting in a static image that does not fulfill the prompt's requirement for motion. | overall_score=25 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":20,"motion_quality":10,"temporal_consistency":10,"visual_quality":30,"camera_composition":60}

Explanation: While the first frame is perfectly preserved, the video fails entirely to animate the requested action of pushing the syringe plunger, resulting in a static image that does not meet the requirements of a video generation task. | overall_score=25 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":20,"motion_quality":10,"temporal_consistency":10,"visual_quality":30,"camera_composition":60}

Explanation: While the model successfully maintained the visual fidelity of the first frame, it failed entirely to execute the requested motion. The video is essentially a static image, violating the core requirement of the prompt to show the syringe plunger moving and liquid being injected. | overall_score=25 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":20,"motion_quality":10,"temporal_consistency":10,"visual_quality":30,"camera_composition":60}


Prompt: The orange crown imperial flowers sway gently and rhythmically from side to side as if caught in a light, steady breeze. The stems remain anchored in place while the heavy, bell-shaped blossoms and their leafy crowns oscillate in unison. The camera remains completely static throughout the entire duration, maintaining a fixed, eye-level medium shot of the cluster of flowers against a blurred, dark green coniferous background.

Explanation: While the video perfectly matches the first frame and maintains the requested camera angle, it fails entirely to generate the requested motion. The flowers are static, and the only 'motion' present is a minor, low-quality artifacting/shimmering that does not resemble the requested swaying. | overall_score=25 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":20,"motion_quality":10,"temporal_consistency":10,"visual_quality":40,"camera_composition":80}

Explanation: While the model successfully maintained the visual fidelity of the first frame and the static camera composition, it completely failed to generate the requested motion. The flowers do not sway or oscillate as described, resulting in a video that is effectively a static image. | overall_score=25 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":20,"motion_quality":10,"temporal_consistency":10,"visual_quality":40,"camera_composition":80}

Explanation: While the video maintains the visual integrity of the first frame perfectly, it fails entirely to execute the requested motion. The flowers remain completely frozen, ignoring the prompt's requirement for rhythmic swaying and breeze-induced movement. | overall_score=25 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":20,"motion_quality":5,"temporal_consistency":10,"visual_quality":60,"camera_composition":60}


Prompt: Two people on a moving open-top bus wave pride flags rhythmically. The person on the left holds a large flag, moving it back and forth in a steady, sweeping motion. The person on the right continuously waves a smaller rainbow fan, creating a blurred, oscillating effect in the foreground. The camera remains static, maintaining a medium close-up shot of the subjects as they celebrate during a parade. The motion is consistent and repetitive throughout the entire five-second duration.

Explanation: The video adheres well to the prompt and maintains high fidelity to the first frame, but suffers from temporal instability regarding the smaller flag/fan object, which flickers and changes shape throughout the sequence. | overall_score=82 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":98,"prompt_adherence":85,"motion_quality":75,"temporal_consistency":70,"visual_quality":90,"camera_composition":95}

Explanation: The video maintains high fidelity to the first frame and captures the requested actions well, though there is some minor flickering and temporal inconsistency regarding the smaller flag/fan object. | overall_score=85 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":98,"prompt_adherence":90,"motion_quality":85,"temporal_consistency":80,"visual_quality":85,"camera_composition":95}

Explanation: The video demonstrates high fidelity to the first frame and maintains a stable camera composition. While the motion is generally good, there is a slight deviation from the prompt regarding the object held by the person on the right, and the flag physics exhibit minor temporal instability. | overall_score=82 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":98,"prompt_adherence":85,"motion_quality":75,"temporal_consistency":78,"visual_quality":85,"camera_composition":90}


Prompt: The pink rose bush and surrounding green vines sway gently and rhythmically from left to right, driven by a consistent breeze. The movement is fluid and continuous, affecting the leaves and flower heads throughout the entire frame. The camera remains completely static, maintaining a fixed, eye-level medium shot of the rose-covered pergola. The scene captures the natural, subtle motion of garden foliage in a quiet, outdoor setting.

Explanation: While the model successfully maintained the visual integrity of the first frame and kept the camera static, it failed completely to generate the requested motion. The video is effectively a still image, violating the core requirement of the prompt regarding rhythmic, gentle swaying. | overall_score=25 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":20,"motion_quality":10,"temporal_consistency":20,"visual_quality":60,"camera_composition":90}

Explanation: The generated video fails significantly on the motion requirements specified in the prompt, appearing almost entirely static throughout the duration. While the visual quality and first-frame fidelity are high, the lack of the requested rhythmic, fluid motion makes it a poor adherence to the prompt. | overall_score=25 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":20,"motion_quality":10,"temporal_consistency":20,"visual_quality":60,"camera_composition":90}

Explanation: While the video maintains the visual composition and fidelity of the first frame perfectly, it fails completely to generate the requested motion. The scene is static, lacking the gentle, rhythmic swaying of the rose bush and vines described in the prompt. | overall_score=25 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":20,"motion_quality":10,"temporal_consistency":20,"visual_quality":60,"camera_composition":90}


Prompt: The camera performs a slow, steady, and continuous forward dolly movement, gliding over a dense forest landscape toward a distant river. The perspective shifts gradually, revealing more of the terrain below as the frame advances. This aerial shot captures a vast, hilly woodland area bordering a wide river under a heavy, overcast sky, emphasizing the smooth, forward-tracking motion of the camera as it traverses the natural environment.

Explanation: The video successfully maintains the first frame and follows the prompt's camera movement instructions well. While there is some minor jitter in the motion, the overall visual quality and adherence to the scene description are high. | overall_score=85 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":90,"motion_quality":85,"temporal_consistency":85,"visual_quality":85,"camera_composition":80}

Explanation: The video successfully executes the requested forward-tracking camera movement while maintaining high fidelity to the conditioning frame. The temporal consistency is strong, and the overall visual quality is high, though the sense of 'gliding' could be slightly more dynamic. | overall_score=85 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":90,"motion_quality":85,"temporal_consistency":90,"visual_quality":85,"camera_composition":80}

Explanation: The video successfully maintains the first frame's integrity while executing a smooth, steady forward dolly movement that aligns well with the prompt. The overall quality is high, with only minor limitations in the intensity of the camera motion. | overall_score=85 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":90,"motion_quality":85,"temporal_consistency":90,"visual_quality":85,"camera_composition":80}


Prompt: A person stands on a paddleboard in the center of a calm, reflective waterway, moving steadily forward away from the camera. The individual rhythmically dips their paddle into the water on the left side, creating a small wake that trails behind the board. The camera maintains a consistent, low-altitude tracking shot, following the subject from behind as they glide through the center of the frame toward the distant treeline.

Explanation: The video maintains high fidelity to the first frame and follows the prompt's camera instructions well. While the paddle motion is slightly robotic and there is minor flickering in the water wake, the overall visual quality and temporal stability are strong. | overall_score=85 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":90,"motion_quality":80,"temporal_consistency":85,"visual_quality":90,"camera_composition":90}

Explanation: The video is highly faithful to the first frame and follows the prompt's camera and subject movement instructions well. While the paddle motion and water wake could be more physically accurate, the overall temporal consistency and visual quality are high. | overall_score=85 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":90,"motion_quality":80,"temporal_consistency":85,"visual_quality":90,"camera_composition":90}

Explanation: The video demonstrates high fidelity to the conditioning frame and follows the prompt's camera movement and subject action well. While there are minor artifacts in the paddle's motion and the water wake, the overall temporal consistency and visual quality are very high. | overall_score=85 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":90,"motion_quality":80,"temporal_consistency":85,"visual_quality":90,"camera_composition":90}