Prompt: The camera performs a slow, steady forward dolly movement over a calm pond covered in lily pads. The water surface remains largely still, with no significant ripples or disturbances visible across the frame. The perspective gradually pushes deeper into the scene, emphasizing the expanse of the water and the distant treeline. The framing remains wide and static in its orientation, capturing the rural landscape under a cloudy sky as the camera glides forward at a constant, gentle pace.

Explanation: While the video maintains high visual fidelity to the first frame, it fails almost entirely to execute the requested camera movement, resulting in a static image rather than a video with a dolly effect. | overall_score=25 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":20,"motion_quality":10,"temporal_consistency":20,"visual_quality":30,"camera_composition":20}

Explanation: While the video maintains the visual integrity of the first frame, it fails almost entirely to execute the requested camera movement, resulting in a static image rather than a video. | overall_score=25 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":20,"motion_quality":10,"temporal_consistency":20,"visual_quality":30,"camera_composition":20}

Explanation: The generated video fails to execute the requested camera movement, remaining almost entirely static throughout the duration. While the first frame is accurate, the lack of motion and poor visual fidelity result in a very low score. | overall_score=25 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":20,"motion_quality":10,"temporal_consistency":20,"visual_quality":30,"camera_composition":20}


Prompt: The water surface ripples continuously with small, rhythmic waves moving toward the foreground. The camera remains completely static, maintaining a wide, fixed framing of the river and the distant mountain range. The scene depicts a calm, expansive river at dusk, where the only visible motion is the gentle, persistent flow and agitation of the water surface across the entire frame.

Explanation: The video successfully maintains the static camera and the overall composition of the conditioning frame. While the water motion is present and consistent, it is a bit understated compared to the prompt's description of 'rhythmic waves,' but it remains a high-quality, stable generation. | overall_score=85 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":90,"motion_quality":80,"temporal_consistency":85,"visual_quality":90,"camera_composition":95}

Explanation: The video successfully maintains the static camera and scene composition from the first frame. While the water motion is present and consistent, it is a bit understated compared to the prompt's description of 'rhythmic waves', but it remains a high-quality, stable generation. | overall_score=85 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":90,"motion_quality":80,"temporal_consistency":85,"visual_quality":85,"camera_composition":95}

Explanation: The video successfully maintains the static camera and the composition of the first frame. While the water motion is present, it is somewhat muted and lacks the distinct, rhythmic wave patterns requested in the prompt, though it remains temporally stable and visually coherent. | overall_score=85 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":90,"motion_quality":80,"temporal_consistency":85,"visual_quality":85,"camera_composition":95}


Prompt: A white passenger boat travels forward along a river, leaving a visible wake behind it as it moves toward the bottom of the frame. In the distance, a second boat moves in the same direction, while a third vessel remains further back. The camera remains static, maintaining a high-angle, wide shot of the river scene. The primary subject is a passenger boat navigating the calm water, with a lush, hilly landscape visible in the background.

Explanation: The video maintains high visual fidelity and adheres well to the prompt's composition requirements, but the motion is too minimal to convincingly depict the boats traveling forward, resulting in a somewhat static appearance. | overall_score=85 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":90,"motion_quality":80,"temporal_consistency":85,"visual_quality":90,"camera_composition":90}

Explanation: The video is visually stunning and maintains high fidelity to the first frame, but it suffers from very limited motion, making the boats appear nearly stationary despite the prompt's requirement for them to travel forward. | overall_score=85 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":90,"motion_quality":80,"temporal_consistency":85,"visual_quality":90,"camera_composition":90}

Explanation: The video demonstrates high fidelity to the conditioning frame and effectively captures the requested scene elements. While there is minor jitter in the water and some repetitive motion in the smoke, the overall temporal consistency and visual quality are very high. | overall_score=88 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":98,"prompt_adherence":95,"motion_quality":85,"temporal_consistency":90,"visual_quality":90,"camera_composition":95}


Prompt: The water cascades continuously over the central ledge, creating a turbulent, frothing pool at the base that churns and bubbles in place. The flow remains consistent, with white water rushing downward and splashing against the submerged rocks. The camera is completely static, maintaining a fixed, eye-level framing of the small waterfall. This scene captures a natural mountain stream flowing steadily between large, dark, moss-covered boulders, emphasizing the constant, rhythmic motion of the water as it crashes into the pool below.

Explanation: The video maintains high fidelity to the first frame and captures the requested waterfall motion effectively. The temporal consistency is strong, with only minor, expected artifacts in the fluid simulation. | overall_score=92 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":100,"prompt_adherence":95,"motion_quality":90,"temporal_consistency":95,"visual_quality":90,"camera_composition":90}

Explanation: The video maintains high fidelity to the first frame and captures the requested waterfall scene with great realism. The motion is fluid and consistent, though there is a slight repetitive quality to the water's movement over the duration of the clip. | overall_score=92 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":100,"prompt_adherence":95,"motion_quality":90,"temporal_consistency":90,"visual_quality":95,"camera_composition":100}

Explanation: The video maintains high fidelity to the first frame and adheres well to the prompt's description of a static camera and a cascading waterfall. The motion is fluid and consistent, with only minor repetitive artifacts in the water's texture. | overall_score=92 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":98,"prompt_adherence":95,"motion_quality":90,"temporal_consistency":92,"visual_quality":95,"camera_composition":100}


Prompt: A young girl kneels on a rug and draws on paper with a pencil, her hand moving rhythmically across the page. Beside her, a man sits cross-legged on the floor, shifting his hands as he sorts through small cards. Behind them, another man sits on a sofa, slowly turning the pages of a book. The camera remains static throughout the scene, maintaining a wide, eye-level framing of the three people engaged in their quiet, focused activities in a bright room.

Explanation: The video maintains high fidelity to the conditioning frame and accurately depicts the requested scene. While the motion is somewhat subtle and repetitive, the overall temporal consistency and visual quality are high, making for a convincing and stable generation. | overall_score=82 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":98,"prompt_adherence":90,"motion_quality":75,"temporal_consistency":85,"visual_quality":85,"camera_composition":95}

Explanation: The video maintains high fidelity to the conditioning frame and successfully captures all three subjects performing their respective tasks. While the motion is somewhat subtle and repetitive, the overall temporal consistency and visual quality are strong. | overall_score=85 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":98,"prompt_adherence":95,"motion_quality":75,"temporal_consistency":85,"visual_quality":90,"camera_composition":95}

Explanation: The video maintains high fidelity to the first frame and accurately depicts the requested scene. While the motion is somewhat subtle and could be more dynamic, the temporal consistency is strong and the overall visual quality is high. | overall_score=85 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":98,"prompt_adherence":95,"motion_quality":75,"temporal_consistency":85,"visual_quality":90,"camera_composition":95}


Prompt: The camera performs a smooth, continuous forward dolly movement, traveling down the center of the road toward the Multi Gardens gate. As the camera advances, the perspective shifts to reveal more of the surrounding buildings and the road surface. A single white car moves slowly forward along the road, passing under the gate structure. The scene captures an urban landscape with a central road leading toward a distant city skyline under a clear, bright sky.

Explanation: While the video successfully initiates the requested camera movement, the structural integrity of the scene collapses rapidly. The gate structure and surrounding buildings suffer from extreme temporal instability and morphing artifacts, making the video visually incoherent after the first second. | overall_score=45 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":85,"prompt_adherence":60,"motion_quality":30,"temporal_consistency":20,"visual_quality":40,"camera_composition":50}

Explanation: While the video starts with excellent fidelity to the conditioning frame, it suffers from catastrophic geometric instability and temporal incoherence as the camera advances. The gate structure and surrounding buildings melt and morph, failing to maintain consistent spatial geometry throughout the dolly movement. | overall_score=45 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":85,"prompt_adherence":60,"motion_quality":30,"temporal_consistency":20,"visual_quality":40,"camera_composition":50}

Explanation: While the video starts with high fidelity to the conditioning frame, it suffers from catastrophic geometric instability and temporal incoherence as the camera advances. The gate structure and surrounding buildings melt and morph, failing to maintain structural integrity throughout the dolly movement. | overall_score=45 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":85,"prompt_adherence":60,"motion_quality":30,"temporal_consistency":20,"visual_quality":40,"camera_composition":40}