Prompt: A white egret takes flight from a rocky, mossy tidal flat, flapping its wings rhythmically as it ascends and glides forward toward the horizon. The camera performs a smooth, continuous forward dolly movement, tracking the bird as it moves away from the foreground and into the distance. The scene is set on a low-tide coastal shelf with a sandy beach and distant treeline visible in the background under an overcast sky.

Explanation: The video does a great job of maintaining the scene's atmosphere and following the camera movement instructions. While the bird's wing motion suffers from some morphing artifacts, the overall quality is high and the prompt is well-represented. | overall_score=82 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":90,"motion_quality":85,"temporal_consistency":75,"visual_quality":85,"camera_composition":80}

Explanation: The video demonstrates high fidelity to the conditioning frame and successfully executes the complex camera movement and subject motion requested in the prompt. While there are minor artifacts in the bird's wing geometry and slight background jitter, the overall visual quality and temporal coherence are strong. | overall_score=88 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":90,"motion_quality":85,"temporal_consistency":85,"visual_quality":90,"camera_composition":85}

Explanation: The video successfully captures the requested scene with high fidelity to the first frame and good camera movement. However, the bird's wing motion suffers from significant morphing and anatomical instability as it flies, which detracts from the overall realism. | overall_score=82 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":90,"motion_quality":85,"temporal_consistency":75,"visual_quality":85,"camera_composition":80}


Prompt: The two sailboats in the center foreground glide steadily from left to right across the frame, maintaining their relative distance as they traverse the open water. The camera remains static, capturing the wide, expansive view of the lake under a partly cloudy sky. Small ripples move across the water surface in the foreground, while other distant sailboats remain largely stationary in the background, emphasizing the consistent, smooth motion of the primary subjects as they sail toward the right edge of the frame.

Explanation: The video maintains high visual fidelity and adheres well to the composition requirements, but the motion is too minimal to fully satisfy the prompt's description of the sailboats gliding across the frame. | overall_score=85 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":90,"motion_quality":80,"temporal_consistency":85,"visual_quality":90,"camera_composition":90}

Explanation: The video is visually high-quality and perfectly matches the first frame, but the motion is too minimal to fully satisfy the prompt's requirement for the sailboats to glide across the frame. | overall_score=85 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":90,"motion_quality":80,"temporal_consistency":85,"visual_quality":90,"camera_composition":95}

Explanation: The video maintains high visual fidelity and adheres well to the static camera composition, but the motion is too minimal to fully satisfy the prompt's description of the sailboats gliding across the frame. | overall_score=85 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":90,"motion_quality":80,"temporal_consistency":85,"visual_quality":90,"camera_composition":95}


Prompt: A small spider hangs suspended from a delicate web, swaying gently back and forth in a rhythmic, pendulum-like motion. The spider remains largely stationary in its orientation while the web threads vibrate slightly, causing the creature to drift slowly to the left and then back to the right. The camera remains static throughout the shot, maintaining a tight, macro-focused framing on the spider against a soft, out-of-focus green background.

Explanation: The video starts with high fidelity to the conditioning frame but suffers from significant identity drift and structural instability of the spider as it moves. While the camera composition and background are well-maintained, the motion lacks the requested rhythmic, pendulum-like fluidity. | overall_score=72 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":85,"motion_quality":65,"temporal_consistency":60,"visual_quality":75,"camera_composition":80}

Explanation: The video starts with high fidelity to the conditioning frame, but the spider's body shape and the web's geometry degrade as the animation progresses, leading to noticeable temporal instability. | overall_score=72 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":85,"motion_quality":65,"temporal_consistency":60,"visual_quality":75,"camera_composition":80}

Explanation: The video successfully maintains the macro-focused composition and visual style of the conditioning frame. While the spider's movement is generally consistent with the prompt, there is some minor geometric instability in the spider's body and the motion lacks the desired fluid, pendulum-like smoothness. | overall_score=78 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":85,"motion_quality":70,"temporal_consistency":75,"visual_quality":80,"camera_composition":85}


Prompt: A large, dark-colored fish with a yellow tail fin swims steadily from the upper center toward the lower right. Simultaneously, a bright yellow fish moves slowly from the lower center toward the right, passing behind a coral structure. Smaller fish drift in various directions throughout the background. The camera remains completely static, maintaining a fixed, wide-angle view of the coral reef environment. The scene captures the natural, fluid movement of multiple tropical fish swimming through a deep-water coral habitat.

Explanation: The video maintains high visual fidelity to the first frame and adheres well to the overall scene description. While the specific motion of the yellow fish is a bit understated and the dark fish's movement is slightly jittery, the overall temporal consistency and composition are very strong. | overall_score=85 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":85,"motion_quality":80,"temporal_consistency":90,"visual_quality":90,"camera_composition":95}

Explanation: The video maintains high visual fidelity and adheres well to the static camera requirement. While the motion of the primary fish is captured, the specific interaction of the yellow fish passing behind the coral is less pronounced than requested, though the overall scene is highly coherent. | overall_score=85 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":85,"motion_quality":80,"temporal_consistency":85,"visual_quality":90,"camera_composition":95}

Explanation: The video is visually impressive and maintains high fidelity to the first frame. While it captures the general movement of the fish, it fails to execute the specific spatial interaction requested in the prompt regarding the yellow fish passing behind the coral. | overall_score=85 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":85,"motion_quality":80,"temporal_consistency":90,"visual_quality":90,"camera_composition":95}


Prompt: The ocean water flows steadily through the narrow inlet, with white foam churning against the rocky shoreline and the concrete quay. The camera remains in a fixed, top-down aerial position, maintaining a static bird's-eye view of the entire scene throughout the duration of the clip. This perspective captures the constant movement of the sea as it pushes into the coastal channel beside the small harbor and stone buildings.

Explanation: While the model successfully maintained the static camera angle and the visual fidelity of the first frame, it failed to generate any of the requested motion. The ocean water, foam, and overall scene are completely static, failing the primary requirement of the prompt. | overall_score=25 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":20,"motion_quality":10,"temporal_consistency":10,"visual_quality":30,"camera_composition":90}

Explanation: While the video perfectly maintains the composition and fidelity of the first frame, it fails significantly on motion quality, as the water appears completely static, failing to depict the requested flow and churning foam. | overall_score=35 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":40,"motion_quality":10,"temporal_consistency":20,"visual_quality":40,"camera_composition":90}

Explanation: While the video perfectly matches the first frame and maintains the correct camera angle, it fails entirely to generate the requested motion of the ocean water, resulting in a static image rather than a video. | overall_score=25 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":20,"motion_quality":10,"temporal_consistency":20,"visual_quality":30,"camera_composition":80}


Prompt: The orange cosmos flower gently sways back and forth in a rhythmic, fluid motion, driven by a soft breeze. The surrounding green foliage and thin grass stalks also oscillate subtly in the same direction, creating a unified, gentle movement across the frame. The camera remains completely static throughout the entire five-second duration, maintaining a tight, centered framing on the flower head as it persists in its steady, natural rocking motion against the blurred background of a grassy field.

Explanation: The video maintains high fidelity to the first frame and adheres well to the prompt's requirements for a static camera and specific subject matter. While the motion is slightly mechanical, it is generally consistent and visually pleasing. | overall_score=85 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":90,"motion_quality":80,"temporal_consistency":85,"visual_quality":90,"camera_composition":90}

Explanation: The video maintains high fidelity to the conditioning frame and adheres well to the prompt's requirements for a static camera and specific subject matter. While the motion is slightly mechanical, it is generally consistent and visually pleasing. | overall_score=85 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":90,"motion_quality":80,"temporal_consistency":85,"visual_quality":90,"camera_composition":95}

Explanation: The video maintains the static camera composition and high visual fidelity to the first frame as requested. While the motion is slightly mechanical, it generally adheres to the prompt's description of a swaying flower. | overall_score=85 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":90,"motion_quality":80,"temporal_consistency":85,"visual_quality":90,"camera_composition":95}


Prompt: A white delivery van travels steadily from left to right along a residential street lined with parked cars. The camera maintains a high-angle, static top-down perspective, capturing the entire scene without any movement or adjustment. The subject is a white van moving horizontally across the frame, passing in front of a row of terraced houses with red brick facades and grey tiled roofs. The surrounding parked vehicles remain stationary throughout the duration of the clip.

Explanation: The video adheres very well to the prompt and maintains high visual fidelity to the conditioning frame. The motion is generally smooth, though there is a very slight, almost imperceptible jitter in the van's movement. | overall_score=92 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":98,"prompt_adherence":95,"motion_quality":90,"temporal_consistency":92,"visual_quality":95,"camera_composition":90}

Explanation: The video successfully maintains the requested static high-angle perspective and accurately depicts the van moving across the scene. While there is a very slight jitter in the van's motion, the overall temporal consistency and visual quality are high. | overall_score=92 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":98,"prompt_adherence":95,"motion_quality":90,"temporal_consistency":95,"visual_quality":92,"camera_composition":90}

Explanation: The video demonstrates high fidelity to the conditioning frame and follows the prompt's instructions regarding camera perspective and subject movement. The motion is generally smooth, though there is a slight, subtle jitter in the van's travel that prevents a perfect score. | overall_score=92 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":98,"prompt_adherence":95,"motion_quality":90,"temporal_consistency":95,"visual_quality":92,"camera_composition":90}


Prompt: A commercial passenger jet approaches from the distance, maintaining a steady flight path as it gradually grows in size within the frame. The aircraft maintains a consistent orientation, banking slightly to the left as it descends through the clear blue sky. The camera remains static, capturing the plane as it moves from the center toward the upper-left portion of the frame. The landing gear remains fully extended throughout the entire duration of the shot.

Explanation: The video successfully maintains the identity of the aircraft from the first frame and follows the prompt's instructions regarding the flight path and landing gear. While there is some minor geometric instability in the aircraft's body and landing gear during the approach, the overall visual quality and temporal consistency are high. | overall_score=85 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":90,"motion_quality":85,"temporal_consistency":80,"visual_quality":85,"camera_composition":80}

Explanation: While the video starts with high fidelity to the conditioning frame, the subsequent motion is highly unstable, causing the aircraft to warp and distort significantly. The prompt's requirement for a steady, gradual approach is not met due to the erratic and unnatural movement of the plane. | overall_score=45 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":40,"motion_quality":30,"temporal_consistency":30,"visual_quality":60,"camera_composition":40}

Explanation: The video starts with high fidelity to the conditioning frame, but the aircraft experiences noticeable identity drift and structural morphing as it approaches. While the motion and composition generally follow the prompt, the lack of temporal stability in the aircraft's appearance prevents a higher score. | overall_score=85 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":90,"motion_quality":85,"temporal_consistency":80,"visual_quality":90,"camera_composition":80}


Prompt: The camera performs a smooth, continuous forward dolly movement, gliding steadily over a vast, open grassy plain toward the distant horizon. The perspective shifts forward, gradually bringing more of the foreground terrain into view while the thin dirt road remains fixed in the mid-ground. The camera maintains a high, stable aerial vantage point throughout the entire duration, capturing the expansive landscape as it slowly recedes beneath the frame.

Explanation: The video successfully executes the requested forward dolly movement while maintaining high fidelity to the conditioning frame. The motion is smooth and the overall visual quality is high, though there is some minor jitter in the terrain textures during the camera movement. | overall_score=85 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":90,"motion_quality":85,"temporal_consistency":85,"visual_quality":85,"camera_composition":80}

Explanation: The video maintains high visual quality and adheres well to the initial frame, though the forward dolly movement is less pronounced than the prompt implies, resulting in a slightly static feel. | overall_score=85 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":90,"motion_quality":80,"temporal_consistency":85,"visual_quality":90,"camera_composition":80}

Explanation: The video successfully maintains the first frame and executes a steady forward dolly movement that aligns well with the prompt. While the motion is slightly jittery and the depth perception could be more pronounced, the overall quality is high and stable. | overall_score=85 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":90,"motion_quality":85,"temporal_consistency":90,"visual_quality":85,"camera_composition":80}


Prompt: The delicate pale flowers sway gently and rhythmically from side to side, driven by a soft, consistent breeze that causes the entire cluster to tilt and pivot in unison. The camera remains perfectly static, maintaining a tight, centered close-up framing of the blossoms against a soft-focus green background. This is a cluster of cuckoo flowers in a natural meadow setting, captured in a steady, tranquil motion sequence that persists throughout the entire duration of the clip.

Explanation: The video successfully captures the requested scene with high fidelity to the conditioning frame and good adherence to the prompt. While the motion is slightly mechanical, it is generally smooth and consistent, resulting in a high-quality, stable output. | overall_score=88 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":98,"prompt_adherence":95,"motion_quality":85,"temporal_consistency":90,"visual_quality":92,"camera_composition":95}

Explanation: The video maintains high fidelity to the conditioning frame and adheres well to the prompt's compositional requirements. While the motion is technically present, it is less fluid and rhythmic than the prompt implies, leaning more towards a slight, high-frequency jitter rather than a gentle, sweeping sway. | overall_score=88 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":98,"prompt_adherence":95,"motion_quality":85,"temporal_consistency":90,"visual_quality":92,"camera_composition":95}

Explanation: The video maintains high fidelity to the conditioning frame and exhibits strong visual quality. While the motion is present and consistent, it is less dynamic than the 'swaying' requested in the prompt, appearing more like a gentle vibration. | overall_score=92 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":98,"prompt_adherence":95,"motion_quality":88,"temporal_consistency":95,"visual_quality":95,"camera_composition":90}


Prompt: Ocean waves roll rhythmically toward the shore, breaking and receding across the sand. A dog trots across the frame from left to right. Several people walk along the beach, entering and exiting the scene at different intervals, while others stand still near the water. The camera remains static throughout the shot, maintaining a wide, fixed framing of the beach at sunrise. The scene captures the natural, continuous movement of the tide and the casual activity of people and animals on the coast.

Explanation: While the video successfully maintains the static camera and initial scene composition, the temporal consistency is very poor. The subjects exhibit severe morphing, limb distortion, and unnatural movement patterns, making the video visually jarring despite the high-quality initial frame. | overall_score=45 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":60,"motion_quality":30,"temporal_consistency":20,"visual_quality":40,"camera_composition":90}

Explanation: While the video maintains the static camera and initial frame composition, the motion quality is extremely poor, characterized by severe morphing, limb distortion, and chaotic temporal artifacts where people and the dog appear to warp or vanish. | overall_score=35 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":40,"motion_quality":20,"temporal_consistency":10,"visual_quality":30,"camera_composition":80}

Explanation: While the video starts with high fidelity to the conditioning frame, it suffers from catastrophic temporal consistency issues. The subjects (people and dog) undergo severe morphing, limbs disappear or distort, and the movement is highly unnatural and glitchy, making the video visually incoherent. | overall_score=35 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":40,"motion_quality":20,"temporal_consistency":10,"visual_quality":30,"camera_composition":80}


Prompt: The camera descends steadily on an escalator, maintaining a fixed, high-angle perspective behind two people. As the escalator moves downward, a woman in a dark jacket walks steadily toward the camera from the bottom landing, passing the escalator base and moving out of frame to the left. Simultaneously, a second person in the distance walks away from the camera toward the background. The two foreground subjects remain stationary on the escalator steps throughout the entire duration of the clip.

Explanation: The video maintains high fidelity to the first frame and correctly keeps the foreground subjects stationary. However, the motion of the walking woman is unstable, and the camera movement is not smooth, failing to fully capture the requested steady descent. | overall_score=78 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":85,"motion_quality":75,"temporal_consistency":70,"visual_quality":80,"camera_composition":75}

Explanation: The video successfully captures the primary subject's movement and maintains high visual fidelity to the first frame. However, it fails to implement the requested camera descent and the secondary subject's movement, resulting in a static scene rather than the dynamic one described in the prompt. | overall_score=78 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":85,"motion_quality":75,"temporal_consistency":70,"visual_quality":80,"camera_composition":75}

Explanation: The video maintains high fidelity to the conditioning frame and successfully keeps the foreground subjects stationary. However, the motion of the walking woman is unstable, and the background subject's movement is poorly executed, leading to a loss of realism. | overall_score=78 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":85,"motion_quality":75,"temporal_consistency":70,"visual_quality":80,"camera_composition":75}


Prompt: The camera performs a slow, steady forward dolly movement, gliding over the lush green mountain valley. As the perspective advances, the winding road and the small cluster of buildings in the distance gradually grow larger in the frame. The aerial view maintains a consistent altitude and orientation, focusing on the expansive landscape as it shifts beneath the lens, emphasizing the depth and scale of the mountain pass throughout the entire duration of the shot.

Explanation: The video maintains high fidelity to the conditioning frame and effectively captures the requested mountain valley scene. While the camera movement is a bit subtle, it successfully conveys the forward dolly motion with good temporal stability. | overall_score=88 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":98,"prompt_adherence":95,"motion_quality":85,"temporal_consistency":90,"visual_quality":92,"camera_composition":80}

Explanation: The video maintains high fidelity to the first frame and successfully executes a slow, steady forward dolly movement. While the motion is slightly subtle, it adheres well to the prompt's requirements for a mountain valley landscape. | overall_score=88 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":98,"prompt_adherence":95,"motion_quality":85,"temporal_consistency":90,"visual_quality":92,"camera_composition":80}

Explanation: The video maintains high fidelity to the conditioning frame and effectively captures the requested mountain valley scene. While the camera movement is a bit subtle and exhibits minor jitter, the overall visual quality and adherence to the prompt's atmospheric requirements are strong. | overall_score=88 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":98,"prompt_adherence":95,"motion_quality":85,"temporal_consistency":90,"visual_quality":92,"camera_composition":80}


Prompt: A woman stands before a window and rhythmically wipes the glass with a cloth in a circular motion, moving her arm from the upper left toward the center and back. She pauses briefly to dip the cloth into a bucket held in her other hand before resuming the cleaning motion. The camera remains static throughout the shot, maintaining a fixed, eye-level framing of the subject as she performs the repetitive task in the dimly lit room.

Explanation: The video successfully captures the requested scene with high fidelity to the first frame and good adherence to the prompt's specific actions. While the motion is slightly mechanical, the overall temporal consistency and visual quality are high. | overall_score=82 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":85,"motion_quality":75,"temporal_consistency":80,"visual_quality":90,"camera_composition":95}

Explanation: The video successfully captures the requested action with high fidelity to the initial frame and good overall visual quality. While the arm motion is slightly mechanical, it remains consistent and adheres well to the prompt's instructions. | overall_score=85 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":90,"motion_quality":80,"temporal_consistency":85,"visual_quality":90,"camera_composition":95}

Explanation: The video successfully captures the requested action and maintains the scene's composition and lighting perfectly. While the arm movement is slightly robotic and the interaction with the bucket could be more physically grounded, it is a high-quality generation that adheres well to the prompt. | overall_score=82 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":98,"prompt_adherence":85,"motion_quality":75,"temporal_consistency":80,"visual_quality":85,"camera_composition":90}


Prompt: The camera performs a smooth, continuous forward dolly movement, descending vertically over a rural village setting. As the camera advances, the perspective shifts to reveal more of the ground level while maintaining a top-down orientation. The lush green trees and terracotta-roofed houses remain static throughout the descent, serving as the primary subjects of this aerial view. The motion is steady and linear, creating a sense of gradual approach toward the cluster of buildings nestled among the dense foliage.

Explanation: The video successfully executes the requested smooth, continuous forward dolly movement while maintaining the top-down orientation. While there is some minor temporal instability in the textures, the overall visual quality and adherence to the prompt are high. | overall_score=85 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":90,"motion_quality":85,"temporal_consistency":80,"visual_quality":90,"camera_composition":85}

Explanation: The video maintains high visual fidelity to the first frame and successfully executes a top-down aerial view of a village. While the motion is generally good, it lacks the perfect fluidity of a professional dolly shot, and the sense of vertical descent is somewhat constrained by the limited perspective shift. | overall_score=88 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":98,"prompt_adherence":95,"motion_quality":85,"temporal_consistency":90,"visual_quality":92,"camera_composition":80}

Explanation: The video maintains high fidelity to the first frame and exhibits strong visual quality. While the camera movement is technically a zoom rather than a vertical dolly descent, it effectively captures the requested approach toward the village. | overall_score=85 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":90,"motion_quality":80,"temporal_consistency":85,"visual_quality":90,"camera_composition":80}


Prompt: A scuba diver holds a rope while floating underwater. She begins with her left hand raised, slowly lowering it toward her side as she transitions from an open palm wave to a peace sign gesture. Throughout the movement, a steady stream of air bubbles rises from her regulator. The camera remains static, maintaining a medium shot of the diver as several tropical fish swim past her from right to left across the frame.

Explanation: The video successfully executes the requested motion sequence while maintaining high visual fidelity to the conditioning frame. The hand gesture transition is clear and accurate, though there is minor geometric instability in the fingers during the movement. | overall_score=88 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":95,"motion_quality":85,"temporal_consistency":85,"visual_quality":90,"camera_composition":90}

Explanation: The video successfully executes the requested action of transitioning from a wave to a peace sign while maintaining the diver's identity and the scene's composition. The motion is fluid, though there is minor morphing in the fingers during the gesture change. | overall_score=88 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":90,"motion_quality":85,"temporal_consistency":90,"visual_quality":85,"camera_composition":90}

Explanation: The video successfully executes the requested hand gesture transition while maintaining high visual fidelity to the first frame. There are minor artifacts in the hand's movement and the bubble stream, but the overall temporal consistency and prompt adherence are very strong. | overall_score=88 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":95,"motion_quality":85,"temporal_consistency":85,"visual_quality":90,"camera_composition":90}


Prompt: The camera performs a smooth, continuous forward dolly movement, gradually closing the distance toward the structure. Throughout the five-second duration, the water in the foreground and the distant turquoise lagoon remain calm with no visible surface ripples or waves. The trees and foliage surrounding the wooden house remain completely still, indicating a lack of wind. This shot captures a tranquil, static coastal scene featuring a thatched-roof house built over the water, framed by dense, motionless tropical vegetation.

Explanation: The video adheres very well to the prompt's requirements for a static, tranquil scene and successfully executes a forward dolly movement. The primary limitation is that the camera movement is slightly stuttered rather than perfectly fluid, and the scale of the zoom is relatively conservative. | overall_score=92 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":98,"prompt_adherence":95,"motion_quality":90,"temporal_consistency":95,"visual_quality":95,"camera_composition":85}

Explanation: The video adheres very well to the prompt's requirements for a static, tranquil scene, successfully avoiding any unwanted motion in the environment. The camera movement is present and follows the dolly instruction, though it could be slightly smoother and more dynamic. | overall_score=92 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":98,"prompt_adherence":95,"motion_quality":90,"temporal_consistency":95,"visual_quality":95,"camera_composition":85}

Explanation: The video adheres very well to the prompt's requirements for a static, tranquil scene, successfully avoiding any unwanted motion in the environment. The camera movement is present and follows the dolly instruction, though it is somewhat subtle and exhibits minor jitter, which prevents a perfect score. | overall_score=92 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":98,"prompt_adherence":95,"motion_quality":90,"temporal_consistency":95,"visual_quality":95,"camera_composition":85}


Prompt: A person reaches into a sports bag filled with yellow padel balls and begins to stir them with their hand. The hand moves in a circular, rhythmic motion, shifting and displacing the balls within the confined space. The camera remains static, maintaining a close-up, top-down perspective of the bag interior. The scene focuses on the interaction between the hand and the collection of balls as they are agitated and rearranged inside the bag.

Explanation: The video starts with high fidelity to the conditioning frame and maintains a consistent, static camera angle. While the motion is fluid and realistic, the action shifts from 'stirring' to 'grabbing and removing' the balls, which is a slight deviation from the specific prompt instructions. | overall_score=85 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":90,"motion_quality":85,"temporal_consistency":80,"visual_quality":85,"camera_composition":95}

Explanation: The video maintains high visual quality and adheres well to the prompt's setting and composition. While the action shifts from stirring to removing balls, the overall motion is fluid and realistic, with only minor temporal artifacts. | overall_score=85 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":90,"motion_quality":85,"temporal_consistency":80,"visual_quality":85,"camera_composition":95}

Explanation: The video maintains high fidelity to the conditioning frame and effectively captures the requested scene. While the hand's motion is slightly more of a 'grasping' action than a 'stirring' motion, the overall quality is high and the temporal consistency is well-maintained throughout the sequence. | overall_score=85 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":90,"motion_quality":85,"temporal_consistency":80,"visual_quality":85,"camera_composition":95}


Prompt: The camera performs a slow, steady pan to the right across a vast, open field of wildflowers. The motion is smooth and continuous, maintaining a consistent horizontal trajectory while keeping the horizon line level throughout the five-second duration. The perspective remains fixed at a low angle, capturing the expansive landscape as it glides past the frame. This scene features a vibrant, colorful meadow of purple, white, and yellow flowers under a clear, bright blue sky.

Explanation: The video successfully executes the requested slow pan across the wildflower field while maintaining high fidelity to the conditioning frame. The motion is smooth, though there is some minor geometric distortion in the foreground as the camera moves. | overall_score=85 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":90,"motion_quality":80,"temporal_consistency":85,"visual_quality":85,"camera_composition":80}

Explanation: The video successfully executes the requested slow pan across the wildflower field while maintaining high visual fidelity to the conditioning frame. While there is some minor texture swimming and slight horizon instability, the overall motion quality and prompt adherence are strong. | overall_score=88 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":98,"prompt_adherence":95,"motion_quality":85,"temporal_consistency":85,"visual_quality":90,"camera_composition":80}

Explanation: The video successfully executes the requested slow pan across the wildflower field while maintaining high fidelity to the conditioning frame. While there is some minor texture swimming and slight horizon instability, the overall quality is high and adheres well to the prompt's requirements. | overall_score=85 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":90,"motion_quality":80,"temporal_consistency":85,"visual_quality":85,"camera_composition":80}


Prompt: The camera performs a slow, steady forward dolly movement, gradually approaching the rocky, tree-covered peninsula. As the camera advances, the water surface remains calm with subtle, gentle ripples. A small boat on the far left side of the frame moves steadily toward the left, leaving a faint wake behind it. The scene captures a high-angle, wide aerial view of a coastal landscape featuring a forested headland jutting into a deep blue bay.

Explanation: While the model maintains excellent fidelity to the first frame, it fails significantly on the motion requirements specified in the prompt. The camera does not perform the requested dolly movement, and the boat's motion is absent, resulting in a static video that does not fulfill the dynamic nature of the prompt. | overall_score=35 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":30,"motion_quality":20,"temporal_consistency":40,"visual_quality":60,"camera_composition":30}

Explanation: While the video maintains high visual fidelity to the first frame, it fails significantly on the motion requirements. The camera movement is nearly static instead of a dolly, and the boat's motion is jerky and lacks the requested steady progression. | overall_score=45 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":30,"motion_quality":20,"temporal_consistency":50,"visual_quality":70,"camera_composition":20}

Explanation: While the video maintains high fidelity to the first frame and has good visual quality, it fails significantly on motion requirements. The camera movement is nearly non-existent, and the requested dynamic elements (boat movement and water ripples) are absent, resulting in a static image rather than a dynamic video. | overall_score=35 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":30,"motion_quality":20,"temporal_consistency":40,"visual_quality":60,"camera_composition":30}


Prompt: The camera performs a slow, steady dolly forward through a dense coniferous forest, maintaining a consistent eye-level perspective. As the camera advances, the foreground tree trunks shift laterally across the frame, revealing more of the mossy, needle-covered forest floor and the repeating vertical lines of the trees in the background. The movement is smooth and continuous, creating a sense of walking deeper into the woods while the surrounding trees remain perfectly still in the quiet, overcast environment.

Explanation: The video successfully executes the requested dolly forward movement while maintaining high fidelity to the initial frame. The motion is generally smooth, though there are slight jitters and minor geometric warping on the trees that prevent a perfect score. | overall_score=88 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":98,"prompt_adherence":95,"motion_quality":85,"temporal_consistency":90,"visual_quality":92,"camera_composition":80}

Explanation: The video successfully executes the requested dolly forward movement while maintaining high visual fidelity to the conditioning frame. The motion is generally effective, though it lacks the perfect smoothness of a professional camera rig, and the depth perception could be slightly more pronounced. | overall_score=88 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":98,"prompt_adherence":95,"motion_quality":85,"temporal_consistency":90,"visual_quality":92,"camera_composition":80}

Explanation: The video successfully executes the requested dolly forward movement while maintaining high visual fidelity to the conditioning frame. The motion is generally smooth, though it exhibits slight micro-jitter, and the environmental atmosphere is well-preserved throughout the sequence. | overall_score=88 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":98,"prompt_adherence":95,"motion_quality":85,"temporal_consistency":90,"visual_quality":92,"camera_composition":80}


Prompt: The camera performs a slow, steady dolly-in movement toward the students in the classroom. A young boy in the foreground sits at his desk, rhythmically moving his hand as he writes in a notebook with a pencil. To his left, a girl also writes in her notebook, while a teacher sits at a desk in the background. The scene remains focused on the students as they continue their quiet, focused work throughout the duration of the shot.

Explanation: The video maintains high visual fidelity and strong temporal consistency, but the requested dolly-in camera movement is too minimal to be effective, and the character animation is slightly stiff. | overall_score=85 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":90,"motion_quality":80,"temporal_consistency":85,"visual_quality":90,"camera_composition":75}

Explanation: The video successfully executes the requested scene with high fidelity to the first frame and good prompt adherence. While the camera movement is present, it is quite subtle, and the writing motion could be more natural, but overall it is a high-quality generation. | overall_score=85 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":90,"motion_quality":80,"temporal_consistency":85,"visual_quality":90,"camera_composition":75}

Explanation: The video is highly faithful to the conditioning frame and maintains excellent visual quality. While the dolly-in movement is present, it is quite subtle, and the writing motion could be more natural, but overall it is a very high-quality generation. | overall_score=85 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":90,"motion_quality":80,"temporal_consistency":85,"visual_quality":90,"camera_composition":80}


Prompt: A person holding a glowing blue lantern walks slowly toward a wooden gate in the dark. As they approach, they reach out with their free hand to touch the gate, then begin to push it open, causing the lantern light to sweep across the structure. The camera remains static throughout the shot, maintaining a medium framing of the subject from behind as they navigate the dark, vine-covered entrance.

Explanation: The video demonstrates high fidelity to the conditioning frame and effectively captures the requested narrative sequence. The motion is generally smooth, though there is minor instability in the character's gait, and the lighting effects are well-integrated into the dark environment. | overall_score=88 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":90,"motion_quality":85,"temporal_consistency":85,"visual_quality":90,"camera_composition":90}

Explanation: The video demonstrates high-quality generation, successfully capturing the specific lighting and action requirements of the prompt while maintaining strong visual fidelity to the conditioning frame. | overall_score=88 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":90,"motion_quality":85,"temporal_consistency":85,"visual_quality":90,"camera_composition":90}

Explanation: The video successfully captures the requested narrative and atmosphere with high visual fidelity. While the physical interaction with the gate and the subject's walking motion could be more grounded, the overall execution is highly coherent and adheres well to the prompt. | overall_score=88 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":90,"motion_quality":85,"temporal_consistency":85,"visual_quality":90,"camera_composition":90}


Prompt: The camera performs a slow, steady forward dolly movement over a vast banana plantation. As the camera glides forward, the dense canopy of green banana leaves below shifts and recedes in the frame, creating a sense of depth and continuous motion. The perspective remains consistent, maintaining a high-angle aerial view of the expansive field. The scene captures a sprawling banana farm under a cloudy sky, with the camera steadily advancing across the landscape throughout the entire duration.

Explanation: The video is visually high-quality and perfectly matches the first frame, but the requested camera movement is too minimal to fully satisfy the prompt's requirement for a 'slow, steady forward dolly movement'. | overall_score=85 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":90,"motion_quality":80,"temporal_consistency":90,"visual_quality":85,"camera_composition":80}

Explanation: The video successfully maintains the scene from the first frame and executes the requested forward dolly movement. While the motion is slightly jittery and there are minor warping artifacts in the dense foliage, the overall visual quality and adherence to the prompt are high. | overall_score=85 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":90,"motion_quality":80,"temporal_consistency":85,"visual_quality":90,"camera_composition":80}

Explanation: The video maintains high fidelity to the conditioning frame and successfully executes a forward dolly movement. While the motion is a bit subtle, it adheres well to the prompt's requirements for a banana plantation scene. | overall_score=85 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":90,"motion_quality":80,"temporal_consistency":85,"visual_quality":90,"camera_composition":80}


Prompt: The man stands still, looking toward the right, as the subway train moves forward through a station. The camera remains static, capturing the man from the chest up while the station platform, including pillars and signage, glides steadily past the window behind him from right to left. The man maintains his gaze and posture throughout the entire duration of the shot, while the background environment continues its constant, smooth motion in the opposite direction of the train travel.

Explanation: The video adheres very well to the prompt, maintaining a static subject while the background moves at a consistent, realistic speed. The first frame is identical to the conditioning frame, and there are no significant temporal artifacts or identity shifts. | overall_score=92 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":100,"prompt_adherence":95,"motion_quality":90,"temporal_consistency":95,"visual_quality":95,"camera_composition":90}

Explanation: The video successfully maintains the subject's posture and the static camera composition as requested. While there is some minor flickering in the background lighting, the overall motion is smooth and the first-frame fidelity is very high. | overall_score=85 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":98,"prompt_adherence":90,"motion_quality":85,"temporal_consistency":80,"visual_quality":90,"camera_composition":95}

Explanation: The video successfully maintains the subject's posture and the static camera composition as requested. While there is some minor flickering in the background, the overall motion is smooth and the first-frame fidelity is very high. | overall_score=85 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":98,"prompt_adherence":90,"motion_quality":85,"temporal_consistency":80,"visual_quality":90,"camera_composition":95}


Prompt: The camera performs a smooth, continuous forward dolly movement, steadily approaching the large manor house and its surrounding formal gardens. As the camera advances, the perspective shifts to reveal more detail of the estate grounds and the structure of the building. The scene depicts an aerial view of a grand stone manor house situated within a sprawling landscape of green fields, trees, and manicured garden beds, maintaining a consistent, slow-paced forward motion throughout the entire five-second duration.

Explanation: The video successfully executes the requested forward dolly movement while maintaining high fidelity to the conditioning frame. The motion is smooth and the scene remains stable throughout the duration, with only minor, negligible artifacts in the background texture. | overall_score=88 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":98,"prompt_adherence":95,"motion_quality":85,"temporal_consistency":90,"visual_quality":85,"camera_composition":80}

Explanation: The video successfully executes the requested forward dolly movement while maintaining high visual fidelity to the conditioning frame. The motion is smooth and the scene remains temporally stable throughout the duration, though there is a very minor amount of jitter and slight warping in the background foliage. | overall_score=85 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":90,"motion_quality":85,"temporal_consistency":90,"visual_quality":85,"camera_composition":80}

Explanation: The video successfully executes the requested forward dolly movement while maintaining high fidelity to the conditioning frame. There are minor motion artifacts and slight jitter, but the overall temporal consistency and visual quality are strong. | overall_score=88 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":98,"prompt_adherence":95,"motion_quality":90,"temporal_consistency":95,"visual_quality":85,"camera_composition":80}


Prompt: A dark car drives rapidly from left to right across the foreground, exiting the frame. Simultaneously, a red bus travels slowly from right to left in the middle distance, while a few pedestrians walk across the street in the same direction as the bus. The camera remains static throughout the entire duration, maintaining a wide, eye-level shot of the ornate stone building and the busy urban street intersection in front of it.

Explanation: While the video maintains the static camera and the first frame perfectly, it fails almost entirely on the dynamic elements of the prompt. The car's movement is jerky and unrealistic, and the bus and pedestrians remain completely stationary, failing to fulfill the core motion requirements of the prompt. | overall_score=45 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":40,"motion_quality":30,"temporal_consistency":50,"visual_quality":60,"camera_composition":90}

Explanation: While the video maintains the static camera and the architectural details of the first frame perfectly, it fails significantly on the dynamic elements requested in the prompt. The car is a poorly rendered, sliding blur, and the bus and pedestrians are completely missing or static, resulting in a failure to animate the scene as instructed. | overall_score=45 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":30,"motion_quality":40,"temporal_consistency":50,"visual_quality":60,"camera_composition":90}

Explanation: While the video maintains the static camera and the architectural details of the first frame perfectly, it fails significantly on the dynamic elements of the prompt. The requested motion of the car, bus, and pedestrians is either missing or poorly executed as a low-quality visual artifact. | overall_score=45 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":30,"motion_quality":40,"temporal_consistency":50,"visual_quality":60,"camera_composition":90}


Prompt: Water continuously sprays outward from the Neptune fountain, creating a steady, rhythmic flow that cascades downward into the basin below. The water jets maintain a consistent, forceful trajectory throughout the entire duration of the clip. The camera remains completely static, holding a fixed, centered medium shot of the marble statue and the surrounding stone architecture. This scene captures the Neptune fountain in a public square at dusk, focusing on the fluid motion of the water against the stationary monument.

Explanation: The video maintains high fidelity to the conditioning frame and successfully captures the requested scene with a static camera. The motion of the water is generally convincing, though it exhibits slight repetitive looping artifacts upon close inspection. | overall_score=92 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":98,"prompt_adherence":95,"motion_quality":90,"temporal_consistency":92,"visual_quality":95,"camera_composition":95}

Explanation: The video maintains high fidelity to the conditioning frame and successfully captures the requested static camera composition. The motion of the water is generally well-executed, though there are minor temporal inconsistencies in the spray patterns. | overall_score=92 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":98,"prompt_adherence":95,"motion_quality":90,"temporal_consistency":92,"visual_quality":95,"camera_composition":95}

Explanation: The video maintains high fidelity to the conditioning frame and adheres well to the prompt's requirements for a static camera and specific subject matter. The motion of the water is generally good, though it exhibits slight temporal instability in the spray patterns. | overall_score=92 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":98,"prompt_adherence":95,"motion_quality":88,"temporal_consistency":90,"visual_quality":95,"camera_composition":95}


Prompt: A gentle ocean wave rolls steadily toward the shore, its white foam cresting and washing over the wet sand before receding back into the sea. The water movement is rhythmic and continuous throughout the entire duration. The camera remains in a fixed, static position, maintaining a wide, eye-level framing of the beach. The scene captures the natural, repetitive motion of the tide against the sandy coastline, with the water line advancing and retreating across the foreground.

Explanation: The video adheres well to the prompt and maintains perfect fidelity to the conditioning frame. While the motion of the wave is generally good, it exhibits some minor temporal instability and unnatural jittering in the foam as it reaches the shore. | overall_score=85 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":100,"prompt_adherence":95,"motion_quality":80,"temporal_consistency":85,"visual_quality":85,"camera_composition":90}

Explanation: The video maintains high fidelity to the conditioning frame and adheres well to the prompt's requirements for a static camera and rhythmic tide motion. While there is some minor temporal instability in the foam's texture, the overall quality is high. | overall_score=85 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":100,"prompt_adherence":95,"motion_quality":80,"temporal_consistency":85,"visual_quality":85,"camera_composition":100}

Explanation: The video maintains high fidelity to the conditioning frame and adheres well to the prompt's requirements for a static camera and rhythmic tide. While the motion is generally good, it lacks a bit of organic fluidity in the final seconds, but overall it is a high-quality generation. | overall_score=85 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":90,"motion_quality":80,"temporal_consistency":85,"visual_quality":85,"camera_composition":95}


Prompt: The camera performs a smooth, continuous drone-style descent, moving downward and slightly forward while maintaining a high-angle, top-down perspective of the scene. As the camera lowers, the church spire and the surrounding urban landscape gradually expand in the frame, revealing more of the building's roof structure and the adjacent street layout. The motion is steady and controlled throughout the entire duration, providing a sweeping aerial view of the church and its quiet, tree-lined surroundings.

Explanation: The video maintains high fidelity to the first frame and demonstrates good temporal consistency. While the camera movement is smooth and follows the general direction of the prompt, it is less dynamic than requested, resulting in a slightly lower score for camera composition and motion quality. | overall_score=85 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":90,"motion_quality":85,"temporal_consistency":90,"visual_quality":85,"camera_composition":80}

Explanation: The video successfully maintains the first frame's integrity and executes a steady, controlled descent. While the motion is a bit more restrained than the 'sweeping' movement requested, it adheres well to the prompt's requirements for a drone-style perspective shift. | overall_score=85 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":90,"motion_quality":85,"temporal_consistency":90,"visual_quality":85,"camera_composition":80}

Explanation: The video successfully executes a smooth, controlled descent that aligns well with the prompt. While the motion is slightly conservative, it maintains high visual fidelity and temporal consistency throughout the sequence. | overall_score=85 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":90,"motion_quality":85,"temporal_consistency":90,"visual_quality":85,"camera_composition":80}


Prompt: The camera remains static throughout the shot, framed through overhanging palm fronds that gently sway in the breeze. The water surface is calm, showing subtle, rhythmic ripples that move slowly across the pond, distorting the reflections of the reeds and trees. The tall, dry reeds in the background remain largely still, with only minor, sporadic movement caused by the wind. This peaceful, natural scene captures a quiet moment in a pond surrounded by trees and vegetation.

Explanation: The generated video fails significantly on motion quality and prompt adherence, as it is essentially a static image with no discernible movement in the water or vegetation, contradicting the prompt's requirements for swaying fronds and ripples. | overall_score=25 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":20,"motion_quality":10,"temporal_consistency":10,"visual_quality":30,"camera_composition":90}

Explanation: The video is visually stunning and maintains perfect fidelity to the first frame, but the motion is too restrained, failing to fully capture the requested swaying of the palm fronds and the rhythmic nature of the water ripples. | overall_score=88 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":100,"prompt_adherence":90,"motion_quality":85,"temporal_consistency":90,"visual_quality":90,"camera_composition":95}

Explanation: The video is visually stunning and maintains perfect fidelity to the first frame, but it is overly conservative with motion, resulting in a scene that feels more like a static image than a dynamic video. | overall_score=88 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":100,"prompt_adherence":90,"motion_quality":85,"temporal_consistency":90,"visual_quality":90,"camera_composition":95}


Prompt: The camera performs a slow, steady forward dolly movement, tracking along the wooden boardwalk as it curves into the distance. Throughout the five-second duration, light snow falls continuously, with individual flakes drifting downward across the frame. The scene remains otherwise still, with no movement from the snow-covered trees, the frozen marshland, or the wooden path itself. The focus remains fixed on the path as the camera advances through the quiet, wintry forest landscape.

Explanation: The video successfully captures the requested scene and camera movement, maintaining high fidelity to the first frame. The motion is generally effective, though it lacks perfect smoothness, and there is some minor temporal instability in the falling snow. | overall_score=85 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":90,"motion_quality":85,"temporal_consistency":80,"visual_quality":85,"camera_composition":80}

Explanation: The video successfully captures the requested scene and camera movement, though the motion is slightly uneven. The first frame is highly accurate to the conditioning image, and the overall visual quality is high, despite minor temporal instability. | overall_score=85 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":90,"motion_quality":85,"temporal_consistency":80,"visual_quality":85,"camera_composition":80}

Explanation: The video successfully executes the requested slow dolly movement while maintaining high fidelity to the initial frame. The primary drawbacks are minor jitter in the camera motion and slight temporal inconsistencies in the snow animation. | overall_score=85 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":90,"motion_quality":85,"temporal_consistency":85,"visual_quality":85,"camera_composition":80}


Prompt: A red commuter train travels steadily from right to left along the tracks, passing through an outdoor station. As the train moves, a person wearing a light-colored hat and striped shirt walks slowly across the platform from the bottom right toward the center. The camera remains static throughout the entire duration, maintaining a high-angle, wide-shot perspective of the train station platform, tracks, and surrounding trees under a cloudy sky.

Explanation: The video maintains high fidelity to the conditioning frame and successfully executes the requested scene elements. While the motion of the train and the pedestrian is slightly jittery, the overall quality is strong and adheres well to the prompt's requirements. | overall_score=82 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":85,"motion_quality":75,"temporal_consistency":80,"visual_quality":85,"camera_composition":90}

Explanation: The video successfully captures all requested elements and maintains high visual quality throughout. The primary drawbacks are minor motion artifacts in the walking person and the train's movement, which could be smoother. | overall_score=85 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":90,"motion_quality":80,"temporal_consistency":85,"visual_quality":90,"camera_composition":95}

Explanation: The video maintains high visual fidelity to the conditioning frame and adheres well to the prompt's composition requirements. However, the motion of the person on the platform is unnatural and suffers from temporal instability, which detracts from the overall quality. | overall_score=82 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":98,"prompt_adherence":85,"motion_quality":75,"temporal_consistency":80,"visual_quality":90,"camera_composition":95}


Prompt: The camera performs a slow, steady forward dolly movement through a misty, frost-covered woodland. As the perspective advances, the foreground reeds and the icy surface of the swampy ground shift gradually downward and out of the frame. The background trees and the soft, diffused light remain constant in their relative positions, emphasizing the smooth, continuous forward motion of the lens toward the center of the forest clearing.

Explanation: The video maintains high visual quality and excellent fidelity to the conditioning frame. While the camera movement is technically present, it is quite slow and does not fully capture the dramatic perspective shift requested in the prompt. | overall_score=85 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":90,"motion_quality":80,"temporal_consistency":85,"visual_quality":90,"camera_composition":80}

Explanation: The video maintains high fidelity to the conditioning frame and captures the requested atmosphere well. While the forward dolly movement is present, it is quite slow and could be more pronounced to fully satisfy the prompt's description of the foreground shifting out of frame. | overall_score=85 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":98,"prompt_adherence":90,"motion_quality":80,"temporal_consistency":85,"visual_quality":90,"camera_composition":80}


Prompt: The clouds drift slowly from left to right across the night sky, partially obscuring the bright moon. As the clouds move, they create subtle, shifting patterns of light and shadow over the dark landscape. The camera remains completely static throughout the entire duration of the clip, maintaining a fixed wide shot of the moonlit clouds above a distant, glowing city nestled at the base of dark mountains.

Explanation: The video successfully maintains a static camera and adheres well to the prompt's description of cloud movement over a night landscape. The motion is fluid and consistent, though the cloud animation feels slightly repetitive over the duration of the clip. | overall_score=88 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":98,"prompt_adherence":95,"motion_quality":85,"temporal_consistency":90,"visual_quality":85,"camera_composition":95}

Explanation: The video successfully maintains the static camera composition and adheres well to the prompt's description of cloud movement over a night landscape. The first frame is perfectly preserved, and the temporal consistency is high, though the cloud motion feels slightly repetitive. | overall_score=88 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":98,"prompt_adherence":95,"motion_quality":85,"temporal_consistency":90,"visual_quality":85,"camera_composition":95}

Explanation: The video successfully maintains the static composition and accurately depicts the requested cloud movement. While there is some minor flickering and compression noise, the overall quality is high and adheres strictly to the prompt. | overall_score=88 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":98,"prompt_adherence":95,"motion_quality":85,"temporal_consistency":90,"visual_quality":85,"camera_composition":95}


Prompt: A man wearing a dark jacket and cap walks slowly down the center aisle of a bus toward the back, carrying a dark plastic bag in his right hand. He maintains a steady pace, passing seated passengers before reaching his destination. The camera remains static, capturing the interior of the bus from a fixed, eye-level perspective behind the front rows of seats. The scene depicts a quiet, routine moment of a commuter moving through a public transit vehicle.

Explanation: The video maintains high fidelity to the conditioning frame and successfully captures the requested scene. While the motion of the man is slightly unnatural and the bag shows minor artifacts, the overall temporal consistency and visual quality are strong. | overall_score=82 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":85,"motion_quality":75,"temporal_consistency":80,"visual_quality":85,"camera_composition":90}

Explanation: The video is highly faithful to the conditioning frame and maintains a static camera perspective as requested. While the walking motion is slightly robotic and there is minor deformation in the plastic bag, the overall quality is high and the prompt is well-executed. | overall_score=85 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":90,"motion_quality":80,"temporal_consistency":85,"visual_quality":90,"camera_composition":95}

Explanation: The video successfully captures the requested scene with high fidelity to the first frame and good adherence to the prompt. While the motion of the subject is slightly mechanical and the bag shows minor artifacts, the overall temporal consistency and visual quality are very high. | overall_score=85 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":90,"motion_quality":80,"temporal_consistency":85,"visual_quality":90,"camera_composition":95}


Prompt: The camera performs a smooth, continuous forward dolly movement, steadily approaching the residential complex. As the perspective shifts, the relative positions of the apartment buildings expand outward, revealing more of the surrounding grounds and parking areas. The scene depicts a high-angle aerial view of a suburban neighborhood featuring several large, multi-story residential blocks situated near a low-rise commercial building and a grassy park area under a clear blue sky.

Explanation: The generated video fails almost entirely to execute the requested camera motion, resulting in a static image that does not adhere to the dynamic requirements of the prompt. | overall_score=25 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":10,"motion_quality":10,"temporal_consistency":20,"visual_quality":30,"camera_composition":10}

Explanation: The generated video fails significantly on motion requirements, as it is effectively a static image with no camera movement, completely ignoring the prompt's instruction for a smooth, continuous forward dolly. | overall_score=25 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":10,"motion_quality":10,"temporal_consistency":20,"visual_quality":40,"camera_composition":10}

Explanation: The generated video fails to execute the requested camera movement, remaining almost entirely static throughout the duration. While the initial frame fidelity is excellent, the lack of motion and failure to adhere to the prompt's specific camera instructions result in a very low score. | overall_score=25 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":10,"motion_quality":10,"temporal_consistency":20,"visual_quality":40,"camera_composition":10}


Prompt: The camera performs a slow, steady pan to the left across a dense, lush patch of vibrant green moss. Throughout the five-second duration, the camera maintains a consistent, close-up framing of the textured foliage, capturing the subtle, rhythmic swaying of the delicate moss fronds as they move gently in the breeze. The movement is fluid and continuous, providing a smooth, sweeping perspective of the organic, ground-level forest floor setting.

Explanation: The video maintains high fidelity to the conditioning frame and provides a visually pleasing, high-quality representation of moss. While the camera pan is present, it is slightly stuttered, and the requested subtle swaying motion of the moss is largely absent, resulting in a slightly static appearance. | overall_score=85 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":100,"prompt_adherence":90,"motion_quality":80,"temporal_consistency":90,"visual_quality":90,"camera_composition":75}

Explanation: The video successfully maintains the visual identity of the conditioning frame and executes the requested camera movement. While the motion of the moss itself is somewhat static and the pan has minor jitter, the overall visual quality and adherence to the prompt are strong. | overall_score=85 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":90,"motion_quality":80,"temporal_consistency":85,"visual_quality":90,"camera_composition":80}

Explanation: The video maintains high visual fidelity to the conditioning frame and successfully executes the requested leftward pan. While the motion of the moss itself is subtle and could be more dynamic to better reflect the 'swaying' prompt, the overall quality is high and the temporal consistency is well-maintained. | overall_score=85 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":90,"motion_quality":80,"temporal_consistency":85,"visual_quality":90,"camera_composition":80}


Prompt: The camera performs a slow, steady forward dolly movement, descending slightly toward the landscape. Below, the river flows continuously from the top right toward the bottom right of the frame, with visible white water rapids churning against the rocks. The surrounding forest remains still, while the water provides the only consistent motion in the scene. This aerial view captures a winding wooden walkway atop a rocky cliffside overlooking a river and a bridge.

Explanation: While the video maintains the visual integrity of the first frame, it completely fails to execute the requested camera movement and dynamic environmental motion, resulting in a static image sequence rather than a video. | overall_score=35 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":90,"prompt_adherence":20,"motion_quality":10,"temporal_consistency":30,"visual_quality":60,"camera_composition":0}

Explanation: While the model successfully maintained the visual fidelity of the first frame, it failed entirely to execute the requested camera movement and dynamic motion of the water, resulting in a static image rather than a video. | overall_score=25 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":20,"motion_quality":10,"temporal_consistency":20,"visual_quality":40,"camera_composition":30}

Explanation: While the model successfully maintains the visual integrity of the first frame, it fails completely to execute the requested motion. The video is a static image with no camera movement or water animation, rendering it a failure in terms of video generation capabilities. | overall_score=25 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":20,"motion_quality":10,"temporal_consistency":20,"visual_quality":40,"camera_composition":30}


Prompt: The dense, low-lying clouds in the valley floor drift slowly toward the right of the frame, while the higher cloud bank in the distance remains relatively stationary. The camera performs a subtle, smooth, and continuous pan to the right, revealing more of the forested mountain slope on the right edge. This wide, elevated shot captures a serene, sunlit mountain landscape blanketed by a thick, rolling sea of morning mist.

Explanation: The video is highly impressive, maintaining excellent fidelity to the first frame while executing the requested camera movement and atmospheric effects with high visual quality. The motion is smooth and consistent, though the pan speed is slightly faster than the 'subtle' movement requested in the prompt. | overall_score=92 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":98,"prompt_adherence":95,"motion_quality":90,"temporal_consistency":95,"visual_quality":95,"camera_composition":85}

Explanation: The video is of high quality and adheres well to the prompt's requirements for cloud movement and camera motion. While the pan is slightly faster than 'subtle', the overall execution is very strong with excellent temporal consistency and visual fidelity. | overall_score=92 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":98,"prompt_adherence":95,"motion_quality":90,"temporal_consistency":95,"visual_quality":95,"camera_composition":85}

Explanation: The video is highly impressive, maintaining excellent fidelity to the first frame and capturing the requested atmospheric conditions perfectly. The camera movement is smooth, though slightly faster than the 'subtle' description, which causes minor distortion at the frame edges. | overall_score=92 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":98,"prompt_adherence":95,"motion_quality":90,"temporal_consistency":95,"visual_quality":95,"camera_composition":85}


Prompt: A large ocean wave breaks diagonally across the frame, moving steadily from the upper left toward the lower right. The white foam of the crest churns and expands as it travels, while the turbulent water behind it flows in the same direction. The camera remains in a fixed, top-down aerial position, maintaining a consistent framing of the breaking wave as it advances across the turquoise sea.

Explanation: The video demonstrates high-quality fluid simulation that perfectly matches the initial frame and follows the prompt's motion requirements. The movement of the wave is natural and maintains temporal stability throughout the sequence. | overall_score=92 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":98,"prompt_adherence":95,"motion_quality":90,"temporal_consistency":92,"visual_quality":95,"camera_composition":90}

Explanation: The video maintains high fidelity to the first frame and effectively captures the requested diagonal wave motion. While there is some minor temporal instability in the foam texture, the overall visual quality and adherence to the prompt are very strong. | overall_score=88 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":98,"prompt_adherence":95,"motion_quality":85,"temporal_consistency":85,"visual_quality":90,"camera_composition":95}

Explanation: The video maintains high fidelity to the conditioning frame and successfully executes the requested motion and camera angle. While there is some minor temporal instability in the foam texture, the overall visual quality and prompt adherence are very strong. | overall_score=88 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":98,"prompt_adherence":95,"motion_quality":85,"temporal_consistency":85,"visual_quality":90,"camera_composition":95}


Prompt: Water cascades continuously down the entire length of the stone dam, creating a steady, rhythmic flow of white foam into the pool below. The camera performs a slow, smooth, and steady forward dolly movement, gradually pushing closer toward the center of the dam wall. This aerial perspective captures a massive stone dam structure spanning a wide, calm reservoir surrounded by dense, sunlit pine forests and rolling hills under a clear sky.

Explanation: The model failed to execute the requested motion entirely, producing a static image instead of the dynamic scene described in the prompt. While the first frame is accurate, the lack of any movement or water animation makes it a failure in video generation. | overall_score=35 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":20,"motion_quality":10,"temporal_consistency":40,"visual_quality":60,"camera_composition":20}

Explanation: While the video maintains high fidelity to the first frame and has good visual quality, it fails almost entirely on the motion requirements. The prompt explicitly asks for a continuous cascade of water and a forward dolly camera movement, neither of which occurs in the generated output. | overall_score=35 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":20,"motion_quality":10,"temporal_consistency":40,"visual_quality":60,"camera_composition":20}

Explanation: While the model maintains excellent fidelity to the first frame and high visual quality, it fails almost entirely on the motion requirements of the prompt. The camera does not move, and the water remains static, resulting in a failure to generate the requested video content. | overall_score=35 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":20,"motion_quality":10,"temporal_consistency":40,"visual_quality":60,"camera_composition":20}


Prompt: Two people work together to assemble a pizza on a wooden kitchen counter. The person on the left holds a plate of salami slices, slowly moving it toward the center of the frame while picking up individual pieces. Simultaneously, the person on the right carefully places salami slices onto the pizza base. The camera remains static throughout the shot, maintaining a medium-close framing of the hands and the pizza. The scene focuses on the collaborative process of topping the pizza.

Explanation: While the video successfully maintains the initial composition and framing, the motion quality is very poor, characterized by significant morphing and flickering of the salami slices and hands. The action of assembling the pizza lacks the necessary fluidity and realism to meet the prompt's requirements. | overall_score=45 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":60,"motion_quality":30,"temporal_consistency":30,"visual_quality":60,"camera_composition":90}

Explanation: While the video maintains the initial framing and visual style perfectly, the motion quality is very poor. The hands and the pizza toppings suffer from significant temporal instability, making the collaborative assembly process look unnatural and glitchy. | overall_score=45 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":60,"motion_quality":30,"temporal_consistency":30,"visual_quality":60,"camera_composition":90}

Explanation: While the video successfully maintains the initial composition and framing, the motion is highly unstable and lacks the fluidity required for a realistic assembly process. The salami slices exhibit significant temporal flickering and morphing, which severely degrades the overall quality. | overall_score=45 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":60,"motion_quality":30,"temporal_consistency":30,"visual_quality":50,"camera_composition":90}


Prompt: A single white car travels slowly along the winding coastal road, moving from the top of the frame toward the bottom left. The camera performs a steady, continuous forward dolly movement, gradually descending and closing in on the colorful buildings situated on the peninsula. The scene captures a tranquil lakeside complex nestled between a dense forest and a vast, calm body of water, maintaining a high-angle aerial perspective throughout the entire duration of the clip.

Explanation: The video maintains high visual fidelity to the first frame and exhibits good temporal stability. However, it fails to fully capture the dynamic camera movement and the specific trajectory of the car described in the prompt, resulting in a somewhat static-feeling output. | overall_score=85 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":80,"motion_quality":85,"temporal_consistency":90,"visual_quality":90,"camera_composition":75}

Explanation: The video maintains high visual fidelity to the first frame and exhibits strong temporal stability. However, it fails to fully capture the dynamic camera movement and the distinct motion of the car as described in the prompt, resulting in a somewhat static-feeling scene. | overall_score=85 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":80,"motion_quality":85,"temporal_consistency":90,"visual_quality":90,"camera_composition":75}

Explanation: The video maintains high visual fidelity and temporal stability, but the requested camera motion and the car's movement are too subtle to fully satisfy the prompt's dynamic requirements. | overall_score=85 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":80,"motion_quality":85,"temporal_consistency":90,"visual_quality":90,"camera_composition":75}


Prompt: The woman sits at a desk and speaks while gesturing with a pen held in her right hand, moving it slightly across the documents. The man stands beside her, leaning forward with his hands resting on the desk, his head tilted downward as he focuses intently on the papers. The camera remains completely static throughout the entire duration, maintaining a medium shot of the two professionals collaborating in an office setting.

Explanation: The video is visually high-quality and perfectly matches the conditioning frame, but the motion is too restrained to fully satisfy the prompt's requirement for active gesturing and speaking. | overall_score=88 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":98,"prompt_adherence":95,"motion_quality":80,"temporal_consistency":90,"visual_quality":92,"camera_composition":95}

Explanation: The video demonstrates high fidelity to the first frame and maintains a stable, static camera composition. However, the motion is somewhat limited and repetitive, particularly regarding the man's lack of movement and the slightly jittery motion of the woman's hand. | overall_score=82 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":98,"prompt_adherence":85,"motion_quality":75,"temporal_consistency":80,"visual_quality":85,"camera_composition":90}

Explanation: The video maintains high visual quality and adheres well to the prompt, though the motion of the subjects is slightly stiff and repetitive. | overall_score=88 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":98,"prompt_adherence":95,"motion_quality":80,"temporal_consistency":90,"visual_quality":90,"camera_composition":95}


Prompt: A regional train enters the frame from the right, traveling at high speed along the tracks toward the left side of the screen. The train remains in view as it passes the platform, eventually exiting the frame on the left. The camera is static, maintaining a fixed, wide-angle perspective of the station platform and the adjacent railway tracks. The scene features a modern passenger train moving through a quiet, suburban train station setting.

Explanation: The video maintains high fidelity to the conditioning frame and effectively captures the motion of the train passing through the station. While there is some minor motion blur and slight structural jitter, the overall temporal consistency and prompt adherence are very high. | overall_score=92 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":100,"prompt_adherence":95,"motion_quality":90,"temporal_consistency":95,"visual_quality":90,"camera_composition":90}

Explanation: The video demonstrates high fidelity to the conditioning frame and effectively captures the motion of the train passing through the station. While there is some minor motion blur and slight structural jitter, the overall temporal consistency and visual quality are very high. | overall_score=92 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":100,"prompt_adherence":95,"motion_quality":90,"temporal_consistency":95,"visual_quality":90,"camera_composition":90}

Explanation: The video maintains high fidelity to the first frame and successfully captures the requested motion of the train moving from right to left. While there is some minor temporal instability and motion blur, the overall quality is high and adheres well to the prompt. | overall_score=85 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":90,"motion_quality":85,"temporal_consistency":80,"visual_quality":85,"camera_composition":95}


Prompt: A white passenger ferry cruises steadily from left to right across the frame, leaving a visible wake behind it in the water. The camera remains static, maintaining a wide, fixed perspective of the boat moving through the harbor. A single bird flies slowly across the sky from left to right in the upper left quadrant. The scene features a ferry navigating calm water against a distant city skyline at sunset.

Explanation: The video maintains high visual quality and adheres well to the prompt, with the ferry moving steadily as requested. While the bird's flight path is a bit unnatural and the water wake lacks dynamic detail, the overall temporal consistency and fidelity to the conditioning frame are very high. | overall_score=85 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":90,"motion_quality":85,"temporal_consistency":80,"visual_quality":90,"camera_composition":95}

Explanation: The video is highly faithful to the conditioning frame and effectively captures the requested scene elements. While the bird's motion is slightly jittery and the water wake could be more dynamic, the overall temporal consistency and visual quality are strong. | overall_score=85 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":90,"motion_quality":85,"temporal_consistency":80,"visual_quality":90,"camera_composition":95}

Explanation: The video maintains high visual quality and adheres well to the prompt's composition requirements. While the ferry's movement is steady, the water wake and the bird's flight path exhibit minor temporal inconsistencies and lack fluid, realistic motion. | overall_score=85 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":90,"motion_quality":80,"temporal_consistency":85,"visual_quality":90,"camera_composition":95}


Prompt: A group of runners in athletic gear jogs steadily from left to right across the frame, maintaining a consistent pace along a paved road. The camera remains static throughout the five-second duration, capturing the side-profile motion of the participants as they pass by. In the foreground, several spectators stand still on the sidewalk, observing the event while the runners continue their movement across the background, passing behind the stationary onlookers and the bridge railing.

Explanation: The video maintains high fidelity to the first frame and accurately follows the prompt's scene description. However, the motion quality is hampered by noticeable temporal instability and unnatural, jittery movement of the runners, which detracts from the overall realism. | overall_score=82 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":98,"prompt_adherence":95,"motion_quality":75,"temporal_consistency":70,"visual_quality":85,"camera_composition":90}

Explanation: While the video successfully maintains the static camera and the initial scene composition, the motion quality is extremely poor. The runners suffer from significant morphing, flickering, and unnatural, stuttering movement that fails to convey a steady jogging pace. | overall_score=35 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":40,"motion_quality":20,"temporal_consistency":20,"visual_quality":30,"camera_composition":80}

Explanation: While the video successfully maintains the composition and initial frame of the conditioning image, the motion quality is poor. The runners suffer from significant temporal instability, with limbs morphing and flickering throughout the sequence, which detracts from the realism of the scene. | overall_score=45 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":60,"motion_quality":30,"temporal_consistency":30,"visual_quality":40,"camera_composition":80}


Prompt: A swarm of small black ants crawls rapidly and erratically over and around a larger, stationary reddish-brown insect carcass. The ants constantly shift positions, climbing over each other and the carcass while moving in multiple directions across the textured surface. The camera remains static throughout the entire duration, maintaining a close-up, top-down view of the ants and the carcass positioned between two rough, orange-colored brick surfaces.

Explanation: The video maintains high fidelity to the conditioning frame and effectively captures the requested swarm behavior. While there is some minor temporal jitter and slight morphing of the ants, the overall visual quality and prompt adherence are very strong. | overall_score=88 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":98,"prompt_adherence":95,"motion_quality":85,"temporal_consistency":80,"visual_quality":90,"camera_composition":95}

Explanation: The video maintains high fidelity to the first frame and effectively captures the requested scene. While there is some minor jitter and slight temporal instability in the movement of the ants, the overall visual quality and adherence to the prompt are very strong. | overall_score=88 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":100,"prompt_adherence":95,"motion_quality":85,"temporal_consistency":85,"visual_quality":90,"camera_composition":95}

Explanation: The video maintains high fidelity to the first frame and effectively captures the requested scene. While there is some minor jitter and slight temporal instability in the movement of the ants, the overall quality is high and adheres well to the prompt. | overall_score=88 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":100,"prompt_adherence":95,"motion_quality":85,"temporal_consistency":85,"visual_quality":90,"camera_composition":95}


Prompt: The camera performs a slow, steady forward dolly movement, gliding over the undulating landscape of terraced tea plantations. As the perspective advances, the rolling green hills shift slightly in the frame, revealing more of the valley floor and the intricate patterns of the tea rows. The aerial view remains stable and smooth throughout the five-second duration, maintaining a consistent altitude while gradually pushing deeper into the expansive, mountainous tea-growing region.

Explanation: The video is visually stunning and maintains perfect fidelity to the first frame. However, the requested forward dolly movement is barely perceptible, making the motion feel more like a static shot than a dynamic camera move. | overall_score=85 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":90,"motion_quality":80,"temporal_consistency":85,"visual_quality":90,"camera_composition":80}

Explanation: The video is visually stunning and perfectly matches the conditioning frame, but it fails to execute the requested camera movement effectively, resulting in a nearly static shot rather than a dynamic dolly. | overall_score=85 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":90,"motion_quality":80,"temporal_consistency":85,"visual_quality":90,"camera_composition":80}

Explanation: The video maintains high visual fidelity and adheres well to the prompt's descriptive elements, though the requested camera movement is quite minimal and lacks the sense of progression described in the prompt. | overall_score=88 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":98,"prompt_adherence":95,"motion_quality":85,"temporal_consistency":90,"visual_quality":92,"camera_composition":80}


Prompt: The driver's hand firmly grips the steering wheel, which rotates steadily to the left as the vehicle navigates a turn. The hand maintains its position on the wheel throughout the movement, following the arc of the steering column. The camera remains in a static, close-up, first-person perspective from inside the car, capturing the driver's hand against the blurred, passing landscape outside the windshield. This sequence shows a driver steering a car along a winding road.

Explanation: While the video maintains excellent fidelity to the first frame and has high visual quality, it fails significantly on the core requirement of the prompt: the motion of the steering wheel. The video is essentially static, with no discernible rotation or navigation of a turn, resulting in a failure to adhere to the motion-based prompt. | overall_score=35 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":20,"motion_quality":20,"temporal_consistency":30,"visual_quality":40,"camera_composition":60}

Explanation: The video maintains high fidelity to the conditioning frame and adheres well to the prompt's requirements for a static, first-person perspective. While the motion is technically present, it is quite subtle, but the overall visual quality and stability are very high. | overall_score=88 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":98,"prompt_adherence":95,"motion_quality":85,"temporal_consistency":90,"visual_quality":92,"camera_composition":95}

Explanation: The video is highly faithful to the conditioning frame and maintains excellent visual quality throughout. However, the motion of the steering wheel is too minimal to fully satisfy the prompt's requirement for a steady rotation, and the background lacks the expected sense of movement for a driving scene. | overall_score=88 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":98,"prompt_adherence":95,"motion_quality":85,"temporal_consistency":90,"visual_quality":92,"camera_composition":95}


Prompt: A woman in a yellow blazer stands in the foreground and raises her right arm, gesturing with her hand as she speaks. Simultaneously, a woman to her left slowly lowers her hand from her chin to her side. The camera remains static throughout the shot, maintaining a medium framing of the group. A man with a child on his shoulders and another young girl in the lower center remain still, observing the scene in a bright, modern interior.

Explanation: While the video maintains the initial composition and framing well, it fails significantly on the requested motion. The primary subject's arm movement is highly distorted and unnatural, and the secondary actions requested in the prompt (the woman lowering her hand) do not occur. | overall_score=45 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":40,"motion_quality":30,"temporal_consistency":50,"visual_quality":60,"camera_composition":90}

Explanation: While the video maintains high visual fidelity to the first frame, it fails significantly on prompt adherence regarding the requested character actions. The motion is almost non-existent, failing to capture the specific gestures described. | overall_score=45 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":40,"motion_quality":30,"temporal_consistency":40,"visual_quality":60,"camera_composition":80}

Explanation: While the video maintains the visual style and composition of the first frame perfectly, it fails almost entirely to execute the requested motion prompts for the characters involved. | overall_score=45 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":40,"motion_quality":30,"temporal_consistency":40,"visual_quality":60,"camera_composition":80}


Prompt: The iridescent surface of the soap bubble exhibits a continuous, fluid motion as swirling, colorful patterns of liquid film migrate slowly downward and across the sphere. These intricate, vein-like structures shift and merge in a rhythmic, organic flow while the bubble itself remains perfectly stationary. The camera framing is static and tight, maintaining a fixed, centered view of the upper portion of the soap bubble against a dark, featureless background throughout the entire duration of the clip.

Explanation: The video demonstrates high-quality generation, maintaining perfect fidelity to the conditioning frame and effectively capturing the requested fluid, iridescent motion of the soap bubble. The temporal consistency is strong, and the visual quality remains high throughout the clip. | overall_score=92 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":100,"prompt_adherence":95,"motion_quality":90,"temporal_consistency":95,"visual_quality":95,"camera_composition":90}

Explanation: The video demonstrates high-quality generation that adheres strictly to the prompt and the conditioning frame. The motion of the soap film is fluid and organic, and the overall visual quality is very high, with only minor, negligible jitter in the pattern movement. | overall_score=92 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":100,"prompt_adherence":95,"motion_quality":90,"temporal_consistency":95,"visual_quality":95,"camera_composition":90}

Explanation: The video is a high-quality generation that perfectly matches the conditioning frame and follows the prompt's requirements for motion and composition. The fluid dynamics of the soap bubble are rendered with great realism and temporal stability. | overall_score=95 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":100,"prompt_adherence":95,"motion_quality":95,"temporal_consistency":95,"visual_quality":95,"camera_composition":100}


Prompt: The liquid surface remains entirely static throughout the five-second duration, with no movement or shifting of the colorful paint droplets or the surrounding fluid. The camera is fixed in a stationary, top-down position, maintaining a constant, unchanging frame of the vibrant, multi-colored paint mixture. This is a completely still, high-angle shot of a viscous, abstract liquid composition, showing no temporal progression or dynamic activity across the entire clip.

Explanation: While the first frame is highly accurate to the conditioning image, the model failed entirely to adhere to the negative constraint of the prompt, introducing significant motion and an intrusive object that was not present in the original scene. | overall_score=15 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":90,"prompt_adherence":0,"motion_quality":0,"temporal_consistency":10,"visual_quality":60,"camera_composition":20}

Explanation: While the video starts with high fidelity to the first frame, it fails the primary prompt requirement of being a static, still shot by introducing a moving spatula that disrupts the entire scene. | overall_score=15 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":90,"prompt_adherence":0,"motion_quality":0,"temporal_consistency":0,"visual_quality":60,"camera_composition":40}

Explanation: While the initial frame is perfectly preserved, the model failed to follow the negative constraint regarding motion. The introduction of a moving object into the scene is a direct violation of the prompt's requirement for a completely still, static composition. | overall_score=15 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":0,"motion_quality":0,"temporal_consistency":0,"visual_quality":60,"camera_composition":20}


Prompt: The camera remains static in a high-angle, top-down aerial view of the ocean. A large, white-capped wave moves steadily from the left side of the frame toward the right, dissipating into foam as it travels. Several surfers on boards are scattered across the water, bobbing gently with the natural rhythm of the ocean swells. The scene captures a group of surfers waiting for waves in a vast, deep blue sea.

Explanation: The video maintains high fidelity to the first frame and effectively captures the requested motion of the wave and the surfers. While there is some minor temporal instability in the foam, the overall visual quality and adherence to the prompt are very strong. | overall_score=88 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":95,"prompt_adherence":90,"motion_quality":85,"temporal_consistency":85,"visual_quality":90,"camera_composition":95}

Explanation: The video maintains high fidelity to the conditioning frame and effectively captures the requested scene. While there is some minor temporal instability in the foam, the overall motion and composition are highly accurate to the prompt. | overall_score=88 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":98,"prompt_adherence":95,"motion_quality":85,"temporal_consistency":85,"visual_quality":90,"camera_composition":95}

Explanation: The video maintains high fidelity to the conditioning frame and effectively captures the requested scene. While there is some minor temporal instability in the foam, the overall motion and composition are highly consistent with the prompt. | overall_score=88 | aspect_scores={"first_frame_fidelity":98,"prompt_adherence":95,"motion_quality":85,"temporal_consistency":85,"visual_quality":90,"camera_composition":95}